Performance Interventions Series Editors: Elaine Aston, University of Lancaster, and Bryan Reynolds, University of Cali...
153 downloads
1356 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Performance Interventions Series Editors: Elaine Aston, University of Lancaster, and Bryan Reynolds, University of California, Irvine Performance Interventions is a series of monographs and essay collections on theatre, performance, and visual culture that share an underlying commitment to the radical and political potential of the arts in our contemporary moment, or give consideration to performance and to visual culture from the past deemed crucial to a social and political present. Performance Interventions moves transversally across artistic and ideological boundaries to publish work that promotes dialogue between practitioners and academics, and interactions between performance communities, educational institutions, and academic disciplines. Titles include: Alan Ackerman and Martin Puchner (editors) AGAINST THEATRE Creative Destructions on the Modernist Stage Elaine Aston and Geraldine Harris (editors) FEMINIST FUTURES? Theatre, Performance, Theory Maaike Bleeker VISUALITY IN THE THEATRE The Locus of Looking James Frieze NAMING THEATRE Demonstrative Diagnosis in Performance Lynette Goddard STAGING BLACK FEMINISMS Identity, Politics, Performance Alison Forsyth and Chris Megson (editors) GET REAL: DOCUMENTARY THEATRE PAST AND PRESENT Leslie Hill and Helen Paris (editors) PERFORMANCE AND PLACE D. J. Hopkins, Shelley Orr and Kim Solga PEFORMANCE AND THE CITY Amelia Howe Kritzer POLITICAL THEATRE IN POST-THATCHER BRITAIN New Writing: 1995–2005 Marcela Kostihová SHAKESPEARE IN TRANSITION Political Appropriations in the Post-Communist Czech Republic
Jon McKenzie, Heike Roms and C. J. W.-L. Wee (editors) CONTESTING PERFORMANCE Emerging Sites of Research Ramón H. Rivera-Servera and Harvey Young PERFORMANCE IN THE BORDERLANDS Mike Sell (editor) AVANT-GARDE PERFORMANCE AND MATERIAL EXCHANGE Vectors of the Radical Melissa Sihra (editor) WOMEN IN IRISH DRAMA A Century of Authorship and Representation Brian Singleton MASCULINITIES AND THE CONTEMPORARY IRISH THEATRE
Performance Interventions Series Standing Order ISBN 978–1–4039–4443–6 Hardback 978–1–4039–4444–3 Paperback (outside North America only) You can receive future titles in this series as they are published by placing a standing order. Please contact your bookseller or, in case of difficulty, write to us at the address below with your name and address, the title of the series and the ISBN quoted above. Customer Services Department, Macmillan Distribution Ltd, Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS, England
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre Brian Singleton
© Brian Singleton 2011 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6–10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2011 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN 978–0–230–22280–9
hardback
This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
Contents List of Illustrations
vi
Acknowledgements
viii
1
Introduction
2
Contesting Canons
22
1
3
Performing Patriarchy
44
4
Monologies and Masculinities
70
5
Quare Fellas
96
6
Male Races
127
7
Protestant Boys
156
8
After Words
191
Notes
201
Select Bibliography
213
Index
223
v
List of Illustrations Figure 1
Brendan Gleeson as Fluther Good in Sean O’Casey’s The Plough and the Stars, Abbey Theatre, 1991, directed by Garry Hynes. Photograph by kind permission of Abbey Theatre Archive.
30
Giles Terera as Christopher Malomo in Bisi Adigun and Roddy Doyle’s version of J. M. Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World, Abbey Theatre, 2007. Photograph: ROS KAVANAGH PHOTOGRAPHER.
40
Figure 3
Denis Conway as Dinnie (seated) and Garrett Lombard as Blake in Enda Walsh’s The Walworth Farce, 2006. Photograph by Keith Pattison, courtesy of Druid Theatre Company.
59
Figure 4
Karl Shiels as the Howie Lee and Aidan Kelly as the Rookie Lee, Peacock Theatre, 2006. Photograph: ROS KAVANAGH PHOTOGRAPHER.
79
Figure 2
Figure 5
Figure 6
Michael Roberts and Des Keogh in Druid Theatre Company’s production of The Stanley Parkers by Geraldine Aron. Photograph by kind permission of Amelia Stein, courtesy of the James Hardiman Library Special Collections, NUIG.
110
Michael Colgan as Justin (seated left in Irish Army uniform), Dolly West’s Kitchen by Frank McGuinness, Abbey Theatre, 1999. Photograph by kind permission of Abbey Theatre Archive.
119
Figure 7
David Fishley as Joseph Omara being interrogated by David Herlihy playing Leo Gaughran in Donal O’Kelly’s Asylum! Asylum!, Peacock Theatre, 1994. Photograph by kind permission of Abbey Theatre Archive. 142
Figure 8
Publicity image of the cast of Charlie O’Neill’s Hurl, Barabbas the Company, 2003. Photograph: ROS KAVANAGH PHOTOGRAPHER.
144
Cast of Jimmy Murphy’s The Kings of the Kilburn High Road, Arambe Productions, 2006. Photograph: John Nelson.
149
Figure 9
vi
List of Illustrations vii
Figure 10
George Seremba in rehearsal for Come Good Rain at the Samuel Beckett Theatre Dublin, 2005. Photograph: Paul Farren.
Figure 11
Gordon (Sean Kearns) confronts Ray (Stuart Graham) while young brother Richard (Marc O’Shea) covers his ears, in Gary Mitchell’s In a Little World of Our Own, Peacock Theatre, 1997. Photograph courtesy of Abbey Theatre Archive. 183
Figure 12
Freddie (Patrick O’Kane) undergoing interrogation in Gary Mitchell’s As the Beast Sleeps, Peacock Theatre, 1998. Photograph courtesy of Abbey Theatre Archive. 184
Figure 13
Paul Hickey in Protestants by Robert Welch. Ransom Productions, Old Museum Arts Centre, Belfast, 2004. Image courtesy of Ransom Productions.
188
Schoolboys learning to dance in Thomas Kilroy’s Christ Deliver Us! Abbey Theatre, 2010. Photograph: ROS KAVANAGH PHOTOGRAPHER.
199
Figure 14
152
Acknowledgements I would like to thank the Series Editors, Elaine Aston and Bryan Reynolds, for commissioning this book, and for guiding it (and me) through the editing and production process. I am indebted first and foremost to Melissa Sihra for inspiring me to write the book. All of the productions that feature in this book I witnessed first hand and many of them I reviewed for Irish Theatre Magazine. Thus, I would like to thank the successive Editors of ITM, Karen Fricker and Helen Meany for helping me bring my ideas to print. Further, the producers of the various Arts shows (Art Zone, The Eleventh Hour, The Arts Show) on RTE Radio One enabled me to articulate my views on these productions to a wide public, for which I am extremely grateful. Though first-hand witnessing is invaluable, I also benefited substantially from archives; I would like to thank Mairéad Delaney of the Abbey Theatre Archive, Vera Orschel of the Special Collections Department of the James Hardiman Library of NUI Galway, Sinéad McPhilips of Druid, and all the librarians who went out of their way to help me in the Department of Manuscripts of the National Library of Ireland. Further, many of the practitioners featured in the book donated either time, memorabilia, collections, or recollections; in particular, I would like to thank Bisi Adigun, David Grant, Raymond Keane, George Seremba, and Neil Watkins. I am forever grateful to my colleagues at Trinity College Dublin who covered my teaching during a leave of absence to help me write this book. Finally I am indebted to the many theatre artists in Ireland who have not only entertained me vastly but also have sought to contest normativity and give voice to those on the margins.
viii
1 Introduction
The origin of this book lies in the publication of Melissa Sihra’s edited collection Women in Irish Drama: A Century of Authorship and Representation.1 At the launch in 2007 in the bar of the Abbey Theatre Dublin a copy of the book was presented to actress Phyllis Ryan whose image appears on the front cover in a photograph taken from a 1937 Abbey Theatre production of Sean O’Casey’s play The Shadow of a Gunman. Responding to the gift, Ryan noted how important this book was in its ‘recovery’ of women’s contribution to the Irish theatre in a century dominated in historical reconstructions of the ‘canon’ by male playwrights. Jokingly, she surmised how interesting it would be to read a book on ‘men and the Irish theatre’. Most people laughed at this in the knowledge that twentieth-century Irish theatre practice is remembered almost exclusively for its contributions and interventions by men. For me, though, it was not another book about Irish men that was needed, but one that asked new questions. What kind of men and their representations precisely have been canonized? And what have been the challenges to those hegemonic representations at the latter end of the twentieth century, and in the twenty-first? And so, the premise of this book is to deconstruct both the representations and interventions of masculinities on the Irish stage, and to expose how particular masculinities also succumb to the oppressive drives of hegemonic forms of masculinity performed as patriarchy. Irish theatre has always been gendered since it was first imagined at the end of the nineteenth century when the heroes of a mythical past were used as icons for both an emerging nation and a national culture. As Anthony Bradley and Maryann Gialanella Valiulis point out in their book Gender and Sexuality in Modern Ireland, Ireland has been gendered ‘by the political nationalist metanarrative and the cultural nationalism 1
2
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
of traditional culture and literature – as a woman victimized by the colonizing English male’.2 In some respects this could be read as a reappropriation of the gender binary between colonizer and colonized as in colonial discourse (and popular cultural representation) the subjects of the British Empire were usually caricatured as being either infantilized or feminized. Subsequently the nation’s Constitution (in both versions of 1922 and 1937) defined the parameters for the operation of gender and its specific contributions to Irish society; in particular the role of woman was given an unequivocal definition as mother. This project of the nation imagined through theatre and through gender, however, is only recently receiving critical attention, prompted in large part by the radical social, cultural and political shifts in Ireland in the past twenty years. Bradley and Valiulis point out that these challenges in many spheres of public life in Ireland are the direct result of ‘challenges to the status quo by women’s groups, gay and lesbian groups and dissenters from the Catholic ethos of the state, as well as a self-awareness prompted in part by affiliation with other European countries, and a crisis of identity of what it means to be Irish at the end of the twentieth century’.3 But that crisis of identity was caused in large part by Ireland’s positioning of itself, not against the colonizer, but between the diasporic hinterland of the USA and the economic fraternity of the European Union. None of the changes of legislation that have taken place would have been achieved so quite so easily had it not been for the rulings of the European Court of Human Rights in respect of the decriminalization of homosexuality on both sides of the Irish border, and the pressure it brought to bear on the Irish government on its constitutional ban on women travelling to seek, or even to seek information on abortion. For the most part, this book will focus on social, cultural and performative interventions on gender construction in the Republic of Ireland, but necessarily it will wander back and forth across the border to critique the representation of masculinities in Northern Ireland by way of comparison, contrast, and also by uniqueness of example. The impact of the recent social and political sea-change in the Republic has been to permit a space for the interrogation of the use of gender in not only metanarratives of the national but also in the almost exclusively male-authored and centred historiographical construction of Irish theatre. It is only in the past few years that Irish theatre historians and literary critics have begun to question their obsession with Ireland’s post-colonial status and its marginalization (if not annihilation) of discourses that challenge the assumptions of the historical metanarrative. Theorizing gender
Introduction 3
of course has been hugely problematic for that post-colonial analysis as the colonizer/colonized and male/female binaries are taken to task and problematized. Theorizing gender as a cultural construction also brings into question other identities, such as sexuality, as well as nationality, and thus the historiographical project of the post-colonial analyst is also destabilized. Ireland’s most significant ‘other’ need not necessarily be England in this new formation. Any analysis of gender in a national context will inevitably permit the articulation of alternative voices to male discourses of nation. Women’s political and cultural interventions in the creation and formation of the Irish state have only recently been recovered and restored to the central narrative. The focus of this book, however, is to tear apart the notion that masculinity is a pre-ordained fixed identity and to pluralize the construction of that identity, exposing the numerous masculinities at play in contemporary Irish society, and not all of them dominant, hegemonic, or upholders of the national and nationalist metanarrative. Further, the book seeks to disentangle gender and sexuality, and read sexualities alongside masculinities. Thus there is a double project at play here in the uncovering of voices and lives that have not heretofore been represented by literary and theatre critics, or historians of Irish theatre, despite the fact that throughout the period under scrutiny multiple and alternative masculinities have permeated the Irish stage. The intended span of stage representation under scrutiny will be from the early 1990s to the present, situating them within their social, political and cultural contexts, and organizing them according to sociologist R. W. Connell’s useful categorizations in his book Masculinities, that begin with the hegemonic but focus on the protest, toxic, queer and the strategic masculinities that contest hegemonic representation. The aim is to analyse texts, performances and cultural moments that mark key shifts in Irish social formation, including legislation, that interrogate the nation through gender but in respect of class, race and sexuality. The primary aim is to demonstrate how, in the latter part of the nation’s first century, Irish theatre’s representation of masculinities contests the legislative hegemonies and national imaginaries of the state. The early 1990s is used as a rough historical marker as it was the period in which Ireland transformed its economic performance, overhauled some key components in its colonial legislation, and fuelled an unprecedented growth in theatrical activity. The first woman and first socialist President, Mary Robinson, was elected in 1990 and although her office holds no state power, Robinson refashioned the role that in the past had been reserved for retiring and benign politicians. The Irish media were enamoured with her style and performance on the world
4
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
stage and her policy of inclusiveness of the most marginal sections of the population and the nation’s diaspora was thrust to media prominence. She (and her successor Mary McAleese) welcomed representatives of heretofore peripheral peoples in the imaginary of the nation state: lesbian and gay activists, women’s groups, Orangemen from the North, Travellers, and refugees and asylum-seekers. Indeed, for many Mary Robinson was the champion of the very people who had been marginalized by the state’s draconian social policies. At the time of her election, divorce was illegal, homosexuality criminalized, contraception strictly controlled, and abortion outlawed except when the life of the mother was under threat. Travellers were subject to successive sedentarist policies of the state by which halting sites were encased and imprisoned by walls of concrete with little or no access to sanitation in some cases. The first asylum-seekers had arrived on Irish shores and no clear policy on their treatment and admission meant that they were more often than not imprisoned. Homophobia in all aspects of Irish life was endemic and sanctioned by the repressive Victorian legislation that underpinned it; gay bashing was frequent and the courts’ lenient response to the perpetrators only fuelled the practice. The Protestant population had dwindled in the Republic since Partition (1922) and the Orangemen in the North who pledged allegiance to the Queen of England were excluded from narrative possibilities for the future of the island. Mary Robinson, of course, as President, did not alter the oppression in any direct way, although she was involved in the processes and legal challenges that led to the decriminalization of homosexuality. Instead, she used her iconic position to lead, by example, a march towards social inclusiveness and the disaggregation of a singular and hegemonic vision of the Irish state as white, Catholic, patriarchal, and compulsorily heterosexual. Writing in 1998 about the last years of the twentieth century Paul Sweeney observed that Ireland had ‘the fastest growing economy in the world’.4 Economist Kevin Gardiner christened it in 1994 the Celtic Tiger, a name to reflect the tiger economies of Asia that had preceded it. It is clear in Sweeney’s assessment that the ‘miracle’ was state-engineered as huge tax concessions attracted largely US multinationals to locate factories in Ireland where a young and educated workforce could sustain the information technology sector. By the end of the decade Ireland was the second largest producer of software in the world, after the USA. Later, though, it would be revealed that the main driver of the economy was in property development that meant existing home owners were sitting on potential fortunes. The new prosperity had been unprecedented and unimaginable since the nation was created. And the new wealth eventually
Introduction 5
translated into a younger workforce and a more localized entertainment sector. It also meant that the tide of emigration for the nation’s youth could be stemmed and eventually reversed. For theatre, this meant that a new avant-garde emerged, connected to the world through the Internet primarily rather than through family connections in the diaspora. World travel for the young rapidly became a choice rather than a necessity given their new economically empowered status. Ireland’s early economic success ran concomitantly with successes on the international stages of popular culture. Only reaching the quarterfinals of the soccer World Cup might be disastrous for many countries, but for Ireland the performance was hailed as a triumph. Post-colonial prejudices were set aside for the ‘triumph’ as the team that scored so well in Italia 90 was composed of many second- and third-generation players born in England, and the manager was the legendary English soccer hero, Jack Charlton. A succession of Irish victories in the early stages of the competition saw the Irish flag raised with pride all over the country during the most popular television programme in the world. Similarly, in the television competition with the second highest viewing public in the world (of over 300 million), Ireland did not only do well, it scored an unprecedented hat trick of wins in the Eurovision Song Contest (ESC). To this day Ireland still maintains the record for the most wins (seven) in the competition. Though lampooned nowadays by Irish critics for being kitsch, the ESC holds a particular place in the construction of Irish national pride in the 1990s. Winning the competition offers the national broadcaster the opportunity to stage the event the following year and doing this three years in a row, Irish broadcaster Radio Telefís Eireann was able to showcase Ireland as a tourist destination being both a crucible of European culture and a still unspoilt pre-modern idyll. The 1994 staging of the Contest’s interval act also brought about one of the most significant phenomena in contemporary Irish culture. The interval act of the Contest is designed to cover the period when the whole of Europe votes for their favourite song. In 1994 a fourteenminute sequence of music and dancing featured the new-wave Celtic sounds of Anúna while Irish-American traditional dancers Jean Butler and Michael Flatley led a troupe of twenty-four dancers. Now known by the name Riverdance the act quickly grew into an internationally touring show. Like the tourist board postcards between each of the contestant’s songs, Riverdance updated the traditional, permitting the dancers to use their arms for the first time while retaining the traditional steps. Added to this was a click-track (a tape) that augmented the sounds of the feet. The music built to a resounding climax as the troupe performed
6
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
in a line representing a tumultuous and extensive corporate body of Ireland: proud, defiant, and culturally competent. ‘Culture Ireland plc’ then invaded the world. With all that success on the biggest and most popular of international stages, and with an unrivalled economy at home, as Diarmaid Ferriter points out, ‘the middle classes had earned the right to be absolved’5 from decades of high taxation, political corruption, sexual abuse scandals, rampant alcoholism, shameful public services, and some of the worst forms of draconian legislation against the most vulnerable citizens of any state in the European Union. Theatrical activity of the period was also part of that success story and public funding of theatre through the Arts Council rose by 300 per cent during the decade. Matching this, the number of funded companies rose from eleven in 1991 to over forty in 2001. The two major producing houses, the Abbey and Gate theatres of Dublin, targeted largely middleclass and middle-aged audiences in their productions of national and international classics with a text-based approach to new writing at the Abbey in its drive for the discovery of new material to enter the canon of theatrical literature. Two companies that had been founded in previous decades, Galway’s Druid and Dublin’s Rough Magic, flourished during the decade and in many respects emulated and, some might argue, overtook the role and function of a national theatre. But the real story of theatrical innovation was to be found in the plethora of new companies that emerged in the early 1990s, formed by practitioners (many of whom had trained abroad) and in forms that were non-realistic, and often highly physical, and approached texts with a corporeal irreverence. For instance, Barabbas the Company was launched in 1993 with a production of Irish life in red nose clowning (Come Down from the Mountain, John Clown, John Clown), Blue Raincoat set up shop in Sligo with their Etienne Decroux-styled performance, and visits from practitioners such as Anne Bogart and Romeo Castellucci inspired the nation’s young practitioners in a very direct way. The Project Arts Centre had been the crucible of innovation since it was established in 1967 and it continued to give shelter to new forms and new practices. Graduates of the first University Drama Department at Trinity College Dublin burst onto the scene with their new theatre companies (Pigsback/Fishamble, Pan Pan, Randolf SD) and an appetite for innovation. Perhaps the most significant contestation to the dominant realism of Irish theatre was the corporeal challenge to storytelling that these companies innovated. Political performance, though, was a rare commodity and theatre tended to shy away from national political debates for the most part, preferring instead allegory, or the revival of the politics of the struggle for the nation that
Introduction 7
accompanied the Irish Revival in theatre and culture. Irish theatre, and particularly the Abbey Theatre, had an ignominious history of attempting to eliminate from its stages challenges to the hegemonic vision of the state. It was the arrival of Brian Friel’s voice in 1964 with his Dublin Theatre Festival production of Philadelphia, Here I Come! that represented the failure of De Valera’s Ireland to contain the aspirations of the country’s youth and highlighted the blight of emigration. The staged split subjectivity of the central character was also a revolutionary act in Irish theatre. By the 1990s Friel’s work had been canonized given the extent of the social realities of modern Ireland that he was critiquing. But a largely realistic form and rural subjects did not reflect the experience of the young people coming of age in the 1990s. And just as the economy was fuelled by tax concessions to foreign investors in contrast to decades of isolationist policies that crippled the country, Irish theatre began to look outwards and to experiment with new forms. Of course, experimentation was the central dominant concern of practitioners in the 1990s and the products of the period certainly professed few political credentials in performance practice. Productions representing exclusively issues of class, race, ethnicity, or sexuality were rare. A new dominant form of monologue drama emerged, largely from young male playwrights, who had been influenced less by Irish theatrical heritage and more by Hollywood cinema. But those dramas, featuring mostly men, and exposing the unsavoury underbelly of Irish society, gave voice to a new masculinity on the Irish stage, protesting, through self-abjection, against its exclusion from the central success narrative propagated by the state. Representing issues of class as an identity marker in Irish society after Partition was a clear challenge to the narrative of nationalism that blocked out identity politics. Marina Carr was the one ‘woman’ playwright (and I use that marker with caution) who emerged from the decade with plays that proffered searing attacks on prejudice, featuring marginalized central characters, strong defiant women, and often either abject male partners or repugnant patriarchs tied hegemonically to land or politics. Gay men emerged too from their pre-1990s depiction as victims of homophobia or sufferers of HIV/AIDS, reaching their apotheosis after the decriminalization of homosexuality in 1993. Frank McGuinness’s work embraced some truly queer characters and contested the right to represent or defend the nation in compulsorily heterosexual terms. But, as you will read later in the book, Irish theatre criticism at the time failed to seriously address sexuality as a central issue of his work focusing instead on nationalism and theatre, and thus neutralizing his contestation of national narratives. Race and nation achieved much greater prominence at the end of the millennium
8
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
both in political debates and media representation, although race was still largely configured as a problem to the nation and the primary focus was on the legality of the so-called ‘non-national’. Báirbre Ní Caoimh, director of Calypso theatre company led the way in a challenge to this representation accompanied by political theatre activist and actor/playwright Donal O’Kelly whose work tackled issues of racism and prejudice endemic in Irish society that the national trope of Irish theatre would prefer to ignore. It is through these subjectivities that this book aims to chart an assessment of how masculinities are conceived, not simply in terms of symbolic identity but also as socially relational. A gender politics within a spectrum of masculinities will be revealed pulling against and often contesting the centrifugal force of a desired and fostered hegemonic masculinity. These subordinated masculinities will constitute the main focus of the book as will their challenge to the forces of patriarchy, at play in the performance of the hegemonic on the Irish stage.
Irish men and masculinities What exactly constitutes masculinities in an Irish context at the turn of the millennium? It would be too easy to construct an identity for the Irish male in psychoanalytic terms and across the binaries of men/ women and sex/gender. The Irish male, let alone his masculinity, is very difficult to determine in a post-colonial context given his feminization in the colonial period, subordinated to the hegemonic forces of British law, custom, and practice. Post-colonially the subordination has been used as a contrapuntal narrative in the construction of masculine identity. Whereas women have been used iconically in popular verse and song, and subsequently to embody Ireland either as Róisín Dubh (Dark Rosaleen) or the Aisling figure in the Irish theatre, men and their masculinities have had no such role. History presents masculine identity in Ireland with a succession of martyrs, heroic, defiant, subversive, but ultimately vanquished by colonial forces. Martyrdom to some extent has fostered a spirit of abjection in the representation of Irish masculinity and the ongoing failure to achieve the ultimate nationalist game plan of a united Ireland has continued to foster such abjection in cultural representation. In counterpoint to the revolutionary narrative stand the heroes of mythology, with Cúchullain at the helm, pointing to an idealized past though with an impossible present for the Irish male. In the post-colonial context the Irish male has been a paradox: agricultural rather than industrial, militarily defensive and neutral rather than imperial and proactive, the martyr rather than the victor. All of these
Introduction 9
markers were by necessity a post-colonial construction to delineate the difference between England’s representations of the Irish as being resistant to an imposed modernity. The cultural confidence that accompanied the economic boom of the 1990s then stood to test that particular paradox as the present realities in the economic, social, and cultural realms clearly configured the Irish male as heroic and hegemonic. The patrilinear succession of presidents ended in 1990 and successes in sporting and cultural spheres were achieved as much by women as men: Sonia O’Sullivan in athletics, (the now discredited) Michelle Smith in swimming, and a triumvirate of Eurovision Song Contest winners (Linda Martin, Niamh Kavanagh, and Eimear Quinn). Legislative changes to the Constitution in the late 1980s and early 1990s were very much driven by politicians such as Máire Geoghegan-Quinn and Mary Robinson. Clearly, the national imaginary was not a uniquely masculine construction. In terms of gender and identity, Ireland proved the point made by many theorists of gender that a simple analysis of gender in terms of symbolical relationships from a psychoanalytic perspective is insufficient. A specific and particular approach to the examination of Irish masculinities is called for in socially relational terms. R. W. Connell in his groundbreaking book Masculinities makes the point that even within masculinities there operates a gender politics that subordinates and heralds certain practices and achievements as well as validates the status of specific forms of masculinity.6 Connell begins his categories with the hegemonic but is clear to outline the slipperiness of categorizations. The hegemonic, he opines, ‘is not automatic, and may be disrupted’.7 This is a crucial point to grasp at the outset since part of the project of every historical version of hegemonic masculinity has been a determination to present itself as a process of some natural order. As Michael Mangan points out, hegemonic masculinity relies for its maintenance and continuance on the assumption that there has always been ‘one unitary and (probably) transhistorical gender state called masculinity’, and ‘that certain social activities inherently reinforced the achievement and maintenance of masculinity, while others challenged, hindered or problematized it’,8 and by extension these latter were ignored, silenced, or ultimately outlawed by the hegemonic form of the gender order. Judith Butler’s seminal book Gender Trouble in 1990 placed the focus of gender not on some pre-existing reality but on the notion that gender is actually a performance itself: ‘Gender ought not to be constructed as a stable identity or locus of agency from which various acts follow; rather gender is an identity tenuously constituted in time, instituted in an exterior space through a stylized repetition of acts.’9 So if gender is already a performance and not an innate reality, where
10
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
does this leave notions of state-sanctioned dominant forms of masculinity propagated by the authorities such as the Constitution, divorce and property laws, Old Testament teachings, laws on sexuality and the age of consent, and the constitutional definition of an Irish citizen? All of the legal and constitutional constructions of gender until the early 1990s supported the myth of a gender order based on the notion of the hegemonic dominance of a particular form of masculinity. And that masculinity not only lorded itself over women, but also subjected subordinated groups of men to its authority and control. Hegemonic masculinity, then, operated through a performance of patriarchy. But how do we determine the hegemonic in a contemporary Irish context, given the history of the subordinated subject of the Irish male in colonial history? Most contemporary historians agree that certain specific practices of the colonizers were retained after independence in an effort to prove native worth in the game of control and subordination. Many of the private, fee-paying schools in Ireland run by religious orders replicate the British public-school system in their valorization of competitive sport as a model of hegemonic masculinity. Paradoxically the sport they valorize in the boys’ schools is not the national game of hurling or any other form of Gaelic Games, as one might expect in a Catholic nationalist new Ireland. On the contrary, rugby is the sport of choice and to this day infers economic status and confers social position on the player. Rugby in particular played an important role in the formation of the subject in and of the British Empire. As Michael A. Messner points out in Power at Play: Sports and the Problem of Masculinity, ‘the British consciously developed sport in their public schools as a means of preparing boys to one day administer the Empire. Team sports, based as they were on the twin values of dominance over others and deference to the authority of leaders, were valued as a means to inculcate “initiative and self-reliance”, along with “loyalty and obedience”.’10 The purpose of school sport was a socialization of boys into accepting an innate superiority and destiny to dominate while maintaining a rigid class structure that contained hierarchies of dominance of males over other males, such as in the class system that permeated the military. Thus the hegemonic masculinity espoused by such schooling in an Irish context is a replica of the English class system that in nationalist terms may be a sell-out but in social terms is a triumph. Soccer, as in England, is seen as an urban and working-class pursuit, and in Ireland as a ‘foreign’ game, and thus not at all hegemonic in a national context given the low and semi-professional status of the game. Gaelic Games (football and hurling), on the other hand, fostered as part of the
Introduction 11
revivalist and nationalist agenda at the end of the nineteenth century is constructed around parish/county tribal affiliations and has huge economic clout given its endemic popularity at all levels of competition. In its successive media campaigns in the past two decades (most notably by its sponsors, Guinness and the Allied Irish Bank) the Gaelic Athletic Association (GAA) marketed male Gaelic Games (football and hurling) as being pre-colonial and mythological warrior sports closely linked to the Cúchullain myth. Gaelic Games stand in counterpoint to rugby in their island-insularity. In many respects the emergence of the practice and popularity of Gaelic Games is concomitant with a wider political struggle for independence and of resistance to colonial rule. As Messner articulates: ‘Subordinated groups of men often used sport to resist racist, colonial, and class domination, and their resistance often took the form of a claim to “manhood”.’11 Thus the male warrior on the sports field in GAA terms was, and to some extent still is, symbolic of an armed struggle. The national permeation of the GAA in each of the thirty-two counties in Ireland gives a locus for an anti-colonial battle in rural culture beyond urban colonial control, latterly conceived as modernity. And it is between these two sporting traditions and cultures that the new modern Ireland stands, configured in terms of its masculinities, and divided along class lines. Thus Irish hegemonic masculinity in sporting terms is one that fluctuates and is not necessarily fixed by a singular centrifugal force. Only a small section of the population is privileged enough to attend a feepaying school and thus be exposed to rugby as a sport, while Gaelic Games are free to all in school, in the parish, or for the most proficient, at county level. Gaelic football though is an amateur sport, unlike rugby nowadays. However, some county players are often considered economic assets by their employers and are given special privileges (such as time off work) to permit them to train at the highest professional level. These two team sports then, desired and fostered by society along class lines, enact a performance of dominance both on and off the sports field. Women’s rugby is virtually non-existent while Gaelic Games for women are significantly more organized along the same club and county lines as the men’s games. Notably the GAA still retains its nineteenth-century terminology from the women’s game (Ladies Football) and the intercounty national final attracts only a tiny fraction of that for the men’s game. In effect, the cultural and financial capital of the men’s games in Ireland (GAA, soccer, rugby) permits a socialized form of male bonding that ensures a hegemonic dominance in the gender order, irrespective of the foreign or national origins of the games themselves.
12
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
By the turn of the millennium the social roles played by a very small fraction of men in Ireland had specifically economic determinants, configured in sport across a spectrum of team games. And therein lies the first paradox of the hegemonic power of the national imaginary, since the national game at all levels observes no class lines. While one set of hegemonic society figures court rugby (accountants, bankers, lawyers, CEOs), another set risen from the ranks supports Gaelic Games (construction industry bosses and politicians). The two sports thus converge in the performance of a hegemonic masculinity that erases colonial histories on the one hand and celebrates the ur-warrior of the Celt within the contemporary Irish male. Of course, this division along class lines converging in a performance of hegemony is not unique to an Irish context. However, in few other nations is there a uniquely national sport with nationalist pretensions on the wrong side of a class/economic hegemony. The two games, though, are similar in their construction of a hard-body image for the Irish male as a marker of hegemony. And their supporters also converge to conspire in this construction. On the one hand we see the working-class Dublin male (and often manual worker) thronging the terraces of Hill 16 at the GAA’s national stadium, Croke Park in Dublin, while across the city in Lansdowne Road (now the Aviva stadium) the often gym-enhanced bodies of the office bosses roar on provincial or national teams in rugby. Both conspire to construct the myth of masculinity residing in aggression, speed, and the infallible hard-body of the male. And both enable hegemonic masculinity to defend its position of power within society through ideological (GAA) and economic (rugby) dominance. Through sport, the state subsidizes literally and figuratively a performance of ‘competitive and dominance-oriented masculinity’.12 But what of those masculinities that do not form part of, or are excluded from, or simply refuse to participate in this dominance orientation of hegemonic masculinity, and what cultural forms enable those voices to emerge? Historiographically, it would appear that Irish theatre is not necessarily the place where this might happen. Histories of theatre until the early 1990s have conspired with the project of nationbuilding to construct a similar form of dominance orientation selecting the great male producers of theatre configured as literature. Of course there are many great male Irish authors of the twentieth century, from W. B. Yeats, J. M. Synge, Sean O’Casey, and Samuel Beckett, through to Brian Friel, Tom Murphy, and Frank McGuinness. But constructing histories centring almost exclusively on the literary production of these authors is an exclusionary tactic to construct a male canon. The process of leaving out the processes whereby those authors were canonized,
Introduction 13
the actresses that starred in their plays, and the many works by authors whose literary merits have been put to the sword of modernity has led to a hegemonically masculine history of Irish theatre. The process whereby the Irish canon has been formed historiographically and through literary criticism emulates what Jill Dolan terms a patriarchal/ canonical authority that ‘has determined the canon’s selection and then mystified its terms, so that this reified body of work seems always to have been in place’.13 Perhaps ‘mystified’ needs further reflection in the Irish context as the motivation for the construction of a canonical authority as patriarchal has consistently been justified as a post-colonial project of resistance to colonial representation. Nevertheless the mystification occurs because of a century’s common-sense criticism that has permitted the canon formation to go unchallenged. Just as Article 41.2 of the 1937 Constitution essentializes the definition of woman in Ireland as that of mother, so too does the patriarchal authority of the cultural construction of Irishness render dominant a singular hegemonic masculinity. Often the justification for canon formation is determined by the literary quality of the playtext all the while ignoring completely the extent and significance of the cultural and sometimes political intervention an actual performance might have generated in a particular historical moment. Popular and community theatres are barely afforded a mention in most histories, and paratheatrical performances are completely excluded. Subjectivities such as race, ethnicity, sexuality, and class have also been subject to erasure or silence. Of course those histories have been products of social and political imperatives of their time, but the relative lateness of a challenge to them (in the 1990s) is testament to the dominance of the organizing structure of Church values and state laws, as well as to the policies of isolationism (that led to the social dominance of a singular patriarchal class, economic stagnation, and large-scale emigration) through most of the century. To give voice to alternative subjectivities would have incited the wrath of conservative forces that viewed those challenges as anti-patriotic. Thus, it was not until the 1990s that truly positive representations of what it means to be Irish could be permitted in terms other than male, white, Catholic, settled, and heterosexual. From the late 1980s onwards revisions of Irish cultural and theatrical history have begun to emerge. David Cairns and Shaun Richards’s book Writing Ireland: Colonialism, Nationalism and Culture subjected the hegemonic mythology of Irishness to deconstruction, followed by Adrian Frazier’s Behind the Scenes: Yeats, Horniman, and the Struggle for the Abbey Theatre and Lionel Pilkington’s Theatre and State in Twentieth-Century
14
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
Ireland that challenged the construction of the Irish Revival. Cairns and Richards were the first to point out how Irish playwrights of the modern era were seeking to assert their ‘manliness’ in direct opposition to their colonial construction, but in doing so of course they were replicating already replicated versions of the drives of patriarchy.14 Other challenges to hegemonic and dominance-oriented histories of theatre in Ireland include Mary Trotter’s re-situation of Yeats’s national project within the context of competing amateur groups for national status in Ireland’s National Theaters: Political Performance and the Origins of the Irish Dramatic Movement. Paul Murphy’s Hegemony and Fantasy in Irish Drama, 1899–1949 further challenges the myth-making that occurred, laying down a challenge to both the authenticity and the class-ridden project of the national imaginary conceived through culture. Patrick Lonergan’s Theatre and Globalization: Irish Drama in the Celtic Tiger Era explores how the national imaginary is contested by its performance in a globalized world. Further, Anna McMullan, Cathy Leeney, and Melissa Sihra have all forged new ground in their recovery and analysis of the many women who have contributed so much to the success of Irish theatre. All these authors and their works force us to re-examine precisely what we have valorized in the past. For this project, then, it is important to recover and reconfigure all those masculinities that have been subordinated by the dominance orientation of the national project. The hegemonic clearly takes its own cue from its social and economic power in Irish society, but blue-collar physical strength (as has been exposed in Gaelic Games) emulates and often replaces that hegemonic position in Irish society since it constructs for itself its own version of the hunter-hero of national culture that has nothing to do literally with the pen-pushing bosses emulating the practices of their former colonial masters. And yet within that bluecollar construction there is excluded a raft of experiences that could in no way be described as hegemonic. Novelist and playwright Colm Toibín writing in 1987 did much to recover the almost lost work of playwright Tom Murphy whose 1961 play of emigration Whistle in the Dark had been rejected by the Abbey Theatre because it was deemed not to be a ‘true’ depiction of Irish experience, but was instead a depiction of those who were ‘unfree in a free Ireland, full of resentment, bewilderment and pain, not sharing any of the beliefs in nationalism, religion or social progress with the rest of the country, nor themselves attaining any class solidarity’.15 The evacuation of huge swathes of the working classes from Ireland because of a poor economic situation fuelled the myth that in the post-colonial Ireland, unlike in the past, there was
Introduction 15
no class system in operation. But the policy of self-determination configured as economic isolation was not just a nationalist project; it was also in large part a cartel of the new ruling middle class to control the wealth of the country. The ‘G’ symbol on Irish products as markers of ‘Guaranteed Irish goods’ fostered national pride in the early 1970s when it was first promoted by government but in reality it helped to line the pockets of Ireland’s small and powerful elite. Protectionism in all areas under state control was further boosted by strict laws on foreign investment that helped to further the cause of private Irish profiteers at the expense of ordinary people who were forced by these anti-competitive practices to pay a premium for even the most essential of services. But all that changed in the late 1980s and early 1990s with the invitation to foreign investors to set up shop in Ireland. The result was a new economic miracle that did not divide the wealth more fairly but simply increased the number of the privileged who had access to the increased influx of capital. The percentages and margins of the ownership of wealth remained fairly stable despite the change. The state-subsidized theatres up until the 1990s largely conspired in that myth-making by exclusion, silence, and enforced absence of authors and themes that did not endorse the nationalist ideology of a free state. In 1990s Ireland and beyond 10 per cent of the population owned half the wealth of the country, and as the economic boom exploded and new overnight dot.com millionaires were created, it only served to expose that for the vast majority of the population the Celtic Tiger economy was a complete myth. Forced out into sprawling suburban housing schemes with few or no amenities and not possessing the skills for this new so-called knowledge economy, a growing population of disconnected and disaffected youth was spawned and fuelled by a violent drink and drugs culture. Growing up in the 1990s for this section of the population the national imaginary did not exist and the myth-making of the economists for them was not reality. The Irish male particularly was the subject of scrutiny by the emerging playwrights of the 1990s who configured abject males surfing on the social margins but in a personal and spiritual wasteland, protesting against hegemonic ideals to which they could never hope to aspire. In popular culture, such as sport, masculinities participated in a form of buddy culture with a county, province, or national imaginary. But in the theatre the subordinated masculinities through economic isolation were situated in the form of a monologue or monodrama, standing alone, in a spotlight on the stage, isolated, adrift of a team or another buddy, recounting their mock-heroic tales of their own self-destruction. Unaware of their own
16
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
abjection and subjection by hegemonic forces they enact before us, they tell of their often pitiful encounters with violent others, rejection by women, and their inevitable refuge and solace in vast quantities of alcohol. In the post-colonial context these are the new subalterns, feminized and emasculated not by a colonial other but by the centrifugal drives of a hegemonic masculinity at the very heart of the Celtic Tiger Irish economy and social order. In the North of Ireland (or Northern Ireland – depending on your political affiliation), the economic boom in the Republic took many Unionists by surprise, especially given that it was predicated on the end of isolationist nationalism. Brought up in true Empire fashion to believe in their own innate supremacy and trapped in the partition myth that independence from the Union had brought about the economic degradation that the new Republic deserved, Unionists had to radically rethink their position in relation to both countries. Trapped in a mire of political stagnation and ruled colonially from London, Northern Ireland as a state was for the first time being left behind economically. The ‘peace process’ from 1994 and beyond was engineered partly by means of a revised strategy of the nationalist Sinn Féin party and the IRA, and by a barefaced and exasperated strategy by both the UK and US governments of dangling carrots of large-scale economic investment to secure political progress. Unionists, though, being increasingly disaffected and internally polarized, were forced to the negotiating table to bargain for their survival. Throughout the history of the euphemistic ‘Troubles’ (effectively a civil war) since the late 1960s theatre in Northern Ireland had not shied away from representing present realities despite the fact that most of the real drama was taking place in the streets of Armagh, Belfast, and Derry in the form of riots, explosions, murders, and protests. The work of communitybased theatre groups such as Charabanc exposed the lives of women battling to hold families together while a civil war raged around them. Authors Christina Reid and Ann Devlin writing from their separate traditions also exposed the exclusionary practices of both Unionism and Nationalism as regards the struggle for supremacy constructed in masculinist terms. But the theatre also charted the shift in the balance of power and political influence over the last four decades from Unionists to Nationalists, helped by demographic shifts, rising and falling birth rates within communities, and emigration. Playwright Gary Mitchell who was living and writing at the time in a sprawling Unionist workingclass housing estate outside Belfast, exposed the working-class Unionist male mired in criminality with paramilitary gangs, involved in feuds,
Introduction 17
racketeering, and drug dealing. This representation was a far cry from the mythological land-owning Protestant settler who fought for Queen and country. This was a picture of the result of colonialism in which the working classes were divided and the one group (Unionists) were led to believe that they were the privileged that had first call on jobs and housing. Jobless, and with little or no economic power, and now in relative peace-time without any social agency or a clearly defined paramilitary enemy, the new working-class Protestant male could only exist by creating the conditions of furthering the patriarchal project by the subordination of women and other males. In 1996 a new Women’s Coalition emerged as a fledgling political party intent on fighting for equality rights regardless of unionist or nationalist divisions. The political impetus for change culminated to some degree in what was known as the Good Friday Agreement that was endorsed overwhelmingly by the electorate on both sides of the political divide and both sides of the border in 1998. What became clear throughout the decade was an awareness that, as Diarmaid Ferriter points out, ‘it was often poverty rather than violence or sectarianism which made change in Northern Ireland difficult’.16 And it was also fear not only of the ‘other’ side or political affiliation, but fear of the other within one’s own community, a fear that there might be more than one singular narrative, and in this context, more than one masculinity. The struggle for the decriminalization of homosexuality in the Republic will be charted in a subsequent chapter but for the moment suffice it to say that the centrifugal force of a dominant masculinity also meant that there was a dominant sexuality that ruled by the criminalization and thus complete rejection of any possible alternative. In Northern Ireland there was a clear project of sexuality cleansing as the leader of the ultra-right Democratic Unionist Party began his campaign in the 1970s not only against Catholics for their so-called heretical beliefs but also against those he considered a danger to the compulsory and ‘native’ heterosexuality of the settler society of Unionists. His ‘Save Ulster from Sodomy’ campaign held rallies across Ulster and sought signatures to contest the threat of the possible decriminalization of homosexuality, as at the time Northern Ireland had successfully argued itself out of changes to British laws on sexuality. Like many Unionists trapped in the Victorian mentality of their predecessors that had engineered an economic boom for the Northern region, and trapped in the marriage of religion and politics, Ian Paisley’s party led the vanguard against any change to repressive Victorian laws, change which he believed ironically was a nationalist conspiracy to bring down the edifice of the
18
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
Northern state. His alignment of homosexuality with Catholic nationalism was simply an up-take of British colonial effeminization of Ireland and the irony is that the nationalist struggle in the North at that time was derided by women’s groups because of their exclusion. Gay liberation was not on the agenda of nationalists at the time since the primary equality issue was one of religion and national allegiance. Subsequently in the new political configuration since the Good Friday Agreement and since the establishment of a self-governing power-sharing assembly the politics of the social emerged in political narratives with Sinn Féin leading the way in the promotion of equality issues, while the DUP continued to propagate inflammatory nineteenth-century medicalized constructions of alternative sexualities. In the Republic, following on from the North’s legal change in 1982, the celebratory apotheosis of the decriminalization of homosexuality in 1993 had little sustainable impact on theatrical representation. Revivals of Frank McGuinness’s play Observe the Sons of Ulster Marching Toward the Somme hinted that the homosocial bonding in the play might actually be homosexual. Interestingly, a Lyric Theatre Belfast production of the same play in 2003 also played up this reading much to the dismay and anger of some Unionist ex-servicemen. The Abbey Theatre presented the first part of Tony Kushner’s Angels in America in 1995 but to near empty houses. Lesbian representation almost reached the point of erasure, from admittedly a virtually non-existent position in the first place with the emigration of the lone voice of Emma Donoghue, though the late ’noughties saw the emergence of new lesbian voices and representations. And the gay male was returned, after a few significant and positive representations, such as in Gerry Stembridge’s The Gay Detective (1993) and Frank McGuinness’s Dolly West’s Kitchen (1999), to being emasculated by an obsession with gay theatrical figures of the past, most particularly with Oscar Wilde, his works, and re-imaginings. Thus despite decriminalization theatrical representation returned to a practice of compulsory heterosexuality by default. Irish television was a little less reticent after decriminalization, using a popular drag queen from the gay club circuit Shirley Temple Bar to call its regular bingo game.17 Soap operas such as the Irish language Ros Na Rún and the Dublin urban soap Fair City used the new status of the gay man in society to write fairly positive characters not blighted by hatred or illness. But same-sex intimacy in these programmes could be contextualized within globalized popular culture since similar narratives on British television had already occurred and been transmitted into Irish homes at least a decade earlier. Ten years later, though, the annual Dublin Gay
Introduction 19
Theatre Festival expanded with increased visibility in the wider public sphere.18 One of the new subjectivities to emerge in the period in question was the non-Irish. As an isolationist country with a poor economy since its establishment and also because of the political upheaval in the North, Ireland was not the place of desire for migrants. In fact the opposite was the case as the narrative of emigration has always dominated Irish history. But the new economic boom reversed the trend and threw up another section of society for the dominant to marginalize. As Diarmaid Ferriter points out, ‘between 1995 and 2000, about 10,000 people sought asylum in Ireland, a development unprecedented in the twentieth century’.19 European laws permitted free travel within the Union to seek employment and the new member states of the EU in the former Eastern Europe fled their depressed economies in search of the rich pickings of the Celtic Tiger. The whole of Ireland altered demographically and very swiftly. The entry of Ireland economically onto the world stage meant the country was subjected to the forces of globalization. The myth-making that surrounded the Celtic Tiger economic miracle centred on Ireland’s exports (in terms of both trade and culture). The other side of the story is that Ireland became a place of desire for many people seeking to escape either economic stagnation in a post-communist context or those caught up in the maelstrom of conflict migration. While both stories dominated media representation the two were not necessarily connected as consequences of globalization. The exportation of culture, for instance, was seen as a success story, but immigration was depicted journalistically as a problem Ireland had not actually sought out for itself. While the economic migrants were white Caucasian, many of the asylum-seekers and conflict migrants came from the African continent. On top of that Ireland was suffering from a severe shortage in key service industries and the government actively sought out target employment groups in specific countries such as India and the Philippines for nursing, while at the same time permitting thousands of Chinese students to enter Ireland to study English in full knowledge that their visas entitled them to take up service jobs in shops, pubs, and restaurants that had fallen out of favour with the highly expectant Irish youth. Intolerance of the marginalized that had been suppressed by changes to legislation and by the media demolition of the Catholic Church through a succession of abuse scandals found a new outlet in the arriving migrants who had no political and little economic capital. Politicians hungry for votes in marginal seats too frequently condoned racism, and this was abetted by a lack of a clear
20
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
strategy to deal with integration of the new arrivals. Media obsession with the new immigrants simply fuelled the anger of the ‘underclass’ in a so-called classless society who had been left behind by the new economic miracle. The white European economic migrants also did not escape the racist taunts as their willingness to work for minimum wages meant that employers could reduce wages legitimately and still recruit staff. While Calypso and Donal O’Kelly were at the forefront of exposing the racist underbelly of Irish society, there have been few representations of other races in mainstream theatre. The white Catholic nation with its twentieth-century repertoire was not constructed for the new races and the notion of colour-blind casting remains an alien practice. Jason King points out that hardly any space in contemporary criticism has been devoted to the impact of the new arrivals on social and cultural life in Ireland, and particularly in theatre. He picks up on Patrick Lonergan’s contention that there has been little or no ‘sense of responsibility to represent the adverse effects of globalizing social processes on those who have felt them most directly, such as asylum seekers and refugees. And yet, their arrival in Ireland represents a more obvious face of globalization than the peregrinations of the Irish theatre diaspora, and should occupy a more prominent place in the emergent critique of globalization and Irish theatre that is too often preoccupied with the reception of Irish plays abroad.’20 Up until the 1990s non-white immigrants to Ireland were from the professional classes who had come on scholarships to study mostly sciences and medicine, and their integration into the Irish middle classes was assured as a result of their economic and social status. Many of the new arrivals, however, who had come from middle-class backgrounds in their home countries, were hurtled to the bottom of the class pile upon arrival and doubly marginalized because of their race. An African theatre group emerged in 2003, Arambe Productions, which began to foster the talents of young Africans in Ireland. But social activists working on race relations are swift to point out that their integration into society would take a generation or more to achieve and it is by no means certain that the theatre will be an attractive medium for the cultural expression of the new immigrants and their children. Meanwhile, on a more positive note, there has been one TD (member of parliament) of Indian origin and one African mayor of a provincial Irish town, while the Abbey Theatre presented an Arambe-commissioned idea for a reimagining of the Irish classic revival play The Playboy of the Western World by J. M. Synge in 2007, updated to contemporary Dublin with a Nigerian immigrant in the title role. This production, which
Introduction 21
will be analysed in Chapter 2, is an example of how the Irish canon can be contested in a spirit of social change and where Ireland’s own colonial missionary legacy in Africa might begin to take responsibility for the geopolitical changes in the world out of which Ireland emerged as ‘refuge’. Nevertheless, that particular production will be problematized in its inherent fetishization of its hero for his ‘manly’ qualities of strength and courage on the sports field and the battlefield. The hegemonic masculinity that is at the very heart of the Revivalist canon of the early twentieth century still gives cause for concern when contemporary productions attempt to deconstruct it by means of alternative subjectivities. The possibility of the embodiment of an Irish masculinity in anything other than white terms, set against a contemporary urban Irish white underclass shrouded in criminality, is an intervention in the genealogical construction of a national and normative masculinity. The aim of this book, then, is to recover those practices that have been left out of previous narratives, and to look beyond the middle-class preserve of the theatre for examples of positive practice and representation of masculinities that have been subordinated by hegemonic drives of dominance and by centrifugal forces within masculinities. It will, by necessity, valorize performances (both inside and outside conventional theatre) as well as performative acts in the political and wider social spheres that will inevitably have had an impact on the representation of canonical works. The historiographical time marker must also be kept porous, as processes of change socially, culturally, politically and theatrically of course are not subject to units of time. A large part of this book covers the so-called ‘Celtic Tiger era’ from 1994 to 2007 but the challenges to masculinities and their representation before, during, and after that economic marker are complex. In many ways this book is a challenge to canon formation in Ireland and it attempts to give voice and render apparent practices that have already been written out of contemporary histories. The focus on masculinities is not exclusively a study of the one gender and the pluralizing of identity is a deliberate attempt to expose how theatrical representation can challenge and contest the widely held belief of a unitary power player in the gender order. This examination of masculinities in the Irish theatre will seek to analyse the subjection of both men and women to hegemonic social, cultural, and political forces, but it will also attempt to uncover how one might resist performatively the power of patriarchy.
2 Contesting Canons
Long before the creation of the nation state of Ireland, there has been a symbolic use of masculinity both in the military contestation of colonialism as well as in the construction of a nativist cultural capital, no more so than in the theatre. The theatrical canon that emerged later at the beginning of the twentieth century has a very contested history, however. The Yeats–Gregory project of a national theatre in revisionist terms was an attempt by an Anglo-cultural elite to carve out a position for itself in an emerging national and nationalist culture. Their legacy perhaps is summed up specifically in the work of two of their popular playwrights, J. M. Synge and Sean O’Casey, both of them Protestant, though from contrasting positions on the economic and social scales. Synge offered slices of peasant cultural life in an imagined rural idyll marred by immorality, gender conflict, attempted parricide, and greed. And yet those themes that incurred the wrath of those competing for the mantel of national cultural iconicity were influenced heavily by both naturalist and symbolist concerns that carved a modernist agenda onto an emerging national theatre. Similarly O’Casey’s Dublin trilogy bowed to the influences of naturalist/symbolist Henrik Ibsen and expressionist Ernst Toller. From Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World to O’Casey’s The Plough and the Stars these now canonical plays both worked against a nationalist agenda for an unqualified and rose-tinted republican cause for blameless nativist traditions and cultures, and yet conversely, because of their modernist credentials, came to be extolled as canonical literary masterpieces. And despite the riots and protests that marred their initial reception they have enjoyed an uninterrupted theatrical shelf-life. For what characterized their performance until the early 1990s were representations that supressed their national implications in favour of their more than protean gender politics. 22
Contesting Canons 23
The Plough and the Stars’ domestic inner-city Dublin tenement and pub settings configure gender politics into binaries of hunter-hero revolutionary male fighter versus an apparently selfish female desire for self-preservation. The very public revolution is the backdrop for a very personal struggle of one woman, Nora Clitheroe, to keep her relationship and her sense of family together. Meanwhile the public sphere is littered with the pompous rhetoric of political leaders and the swaggering bravado of bar-stool revolutionaries, while around them circulates a prostitute plying her trade. And throughout the century there emerged a tradition of representation that reinforced this binary of jolly (male) drunks and happy (female) whores. The violence of the former was tempered by an innate good humour played to the gallery for a laugh, and the profession of the latter anodynely was configured as healthy and hearty, rather than the result of poverty and destitution. Playing the ‘comedy’ of male violence and female prostitution rendered the Plough harmless politically and as the century wore on it became a theatrical sign of why the country needed a revolution in the first place. Further, such performance could infer that alcoholism and prostitution were the direct result of colonial rule. Never was Fluther Good really taken to be a violent alcoholic, and the consumptive Mollser was often regarded as the weakling of a litter rather than the victim of some of the most appalling social housing conditions in Europe. It also had become common practice to completely eliminate a short scene of the play in which an unnamed Lady from Rathmines (from the then fashionable southside of the city) becomes caught up in a scene of selfish looting (hardly role-model behaviour for the otherwise ardent supporters of Irish revolutionaries). And so as the play became enshrined in the Irish theatrical canon, a parallel canonization of the representation of gender in the play became enshrined as standard practice. Looking back now with a post-sructuralist view of gender, it is hard to determine what precisely was hegemonic about the masculinities represented in the Irish theatrical canon. Synge’s stages were littered with wandering tramps while O’Casey’s urban communities were full of often ne’er-do-well and workshy men at the bottom of the social heap. Part of the make-up of the hegemonic is the social position that confers a status within competing masculinities. In Synge’s In the Shadow of the Glen, for instance, Patrick Burke is an ageing small-holder who attempts to trick his young wife into betraying her philandering and wayward desires. But while her ultimate door-slamming rejection of her husband might echo an earlier Ibsenite heroine, the final image is one of masculine solidarity as two men of differing generations ‘celebrate’ the expulsion of their fear
24
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
of infidelity, while we are left to imagine what precisely will be the lot of Nora condemned to wandering the roads as a tramp. The premise for The Playboy of the Western World, similarly, is ineffectual parricide that fails ultimately to win out as the celebrity of the violent ‘hero’ is based on a myth; when reality returns to destroy the myth, father and son are reunited in soldarity against the fickleness of a woman’s world that attempts to tame the hero. In many senses, then, these canonical plays that feature far from hegemonic masculinities in the social sense actually strive to reassert a hegemonic position for masculinity in which the gender order is continuously asserted through land and financial captital by means often of violent enforcement. Both plays begin with apparently irrational acts that are unseen and unstaged, such as Patrick Burke pretending to be dead in order to trap his wife whom he suspects of having a young lover, and by young Christy Mahon who flees his home for striking his father and leaving him for dead in a ditch. But as the plays progress the hegemonic drives of masculinity reassert themselves through rational action and violence. For instance, Nora leaves to join a tramp who is landless, penniless, and thus the very antithesis of hegemonic. Young Christy is roped and tied by a gang of men more affronted by his bravura and lies than by him having attempted to commit murder. The reassertion of patriarchy here is presented as inevitably violent yet potentially benevolent as Christy is spared and restored to his position as son and thus to a subordinated masculinity.
Hynes’s Plough Contesting canons, as Jill Dolan reminds us, not only opens up spaces for new voices to emerge, but in theatre it permits new audiences and their voices to be heard as well: ‘A useful byproduct of the dismembering of traditional canons will be the dismembering of the generic spectator whom the dramatic canons once addressed.’1 But what happened in Irish theatre was a dismembering of the anodyne effect of ‘jog-trot naturalism’2 on audiences in the late nineteenth century by an anniversary staging of an iconic moment in Irish nationalism. The insurrection of Easter 1916 by the principal revolutionary figures, though a failure ultimately, is remembered as the moment when the nation of Ireland was proclaimed, and thus enshrined in Republican mythology. The year 1991 marked the seventy-fifth anniversary of the event and the newly appointed director of the Abbey Theatre Garry Hynes used the occasion to stamp her directorial mark on the national stage with her version of a sublime nationalist moment. The play most closely associated with the
Contesting Canons 25
actual revolutionary moment, Sean O’Casey’s The Plough and the Stars (1926), was also celebrating an anniversary of its own: its sixty-fifth year. Garry Hynes’s elevation to lead the Abbey Theatre was itself also a momentous occasion, since she was the first woman to lead the theatre since its co-founder Lady Augusta Gregory. Hynes had an admirable track record before her having founded the by-now internationally renowned Druid theatre company in Galway in 1975. Her characteristic directing style was an uncompromising and unsentimental depiction of Irish life, customs, and values that found its home in the revival of plays by J. M. Synge and the new writing of Tom Murphy. Garry Hynes’s place as director of the national theatre came swiftly on the heels of a famous political victory by an Irish woman, Mary Robinson, who was swept to the presidency of Ireland on a tidal wave of hope from the political left, women collectively, and a host of marginalized social groups. Although the position of President offered no political power, Robinson’s election was seen by many in the establishment as a direct challenge to a patrilinear succession of retiring male politicians. Despite attempts to thwart her high-visibility approach to the presidency by the incumbent government, she carved out for herself a role as champion of the marginalized, welcoming them to her official residence, and celebrating the very heterogeneity of a nation that had all but wiped out huge swathes of the non-hegemonic from the national narrative. Garry Hynes similarly met with huge resistance from a patriarchal elite both within the Abbey Theatre establishment as well as in the wider cultural sphere of critics and commentators. Her choice of debut production (The Plough and the Stars) was a marketing dream, given the anniversary politics of both the play and its featured content. But in that wider cultural sphere, revisionist critical voices were beginning to emerge that contested Sean O’Casey’s place in the contribution to the national cultural effort. Both Seamus Deane and Declan Kiberd read O’Casey’s 1916 play as a contribution to the stage Irish buffoonery that the Irish national theatre project was supposed to be contesting. Although stoutly defended by Nicholas Grene, a new generation of scholars, led by Lionel Pilkington3 and Paul Murphy,4 continue the revisionist narrative of the early canon as being an attempt to secure a prominent cultural significance for an already ruling social elite (the Ascendancy class of Yeats and Gregory). O’Casey, though, was from an altogether different social milieu than the idealist founders of the Abbey, from an impoverished lower middle class in the north Dublin inner city. But he did not live in a tenement, was not destitute, and was a self-fashioned manual worker in an attempt to authenticate working-class credentials.
26
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
While critics and historians, whether revisionist or not, obsess on O’Casey’s questionable contribution to the nationalist agenda, Hynes’s first Abbey production of The Plough and the Stars presented an excoriating attack on social and gender politics. Rather than focusing on purely nationalist issues, she stripped the play of its sixty-five years of stereotypically comic representation that had largely saved it from the revisionists, and instead of exposing the play to further attacks from those revisionists, actually released a new and potent significance for the play in terms of the politics of gender. While Hynes’s feminist approach held up to scrutiny the motivations of the men involved in armed struggle, the vacuous rhetoric of the stage politician rang hollow in a society wracked by the social injustices of poverty and its terrible consequences, particularly on women’s health. Irish Times critic and political commentator Fintan O’Toole joined Hynes at the Abbey as her literary adviser and thus began an era of production at the national theatre of socialist and feminist revision of the Irish theatrical canon. Together with her designer Frank Conway, Hynes removed from the Abbey stage and the production history of the Plough all the comfortable familiarity that naturalism offers. Revisionists had exposed O’Casey as scopically portraying Dublin’s tenement working classes, and the Hynes/Conway matrix did not even attempt to perpetuate the myth. Instead the production opened to reveal a completely white box on top of whose proscenium was inscribed the motto of the Free State Army: ‘WE SERVE NEITHER KING NOR COUNTRY BUT IRELAND’. In addition the entire floor area of the stage was covered in a large and extremely washed-out Union Jack. The impression of the initial iconography of the first moments of the production clearly lulled nationalist opinion into a false sense of security. For, as the Union Jack receded the audience was then exposed to a representation of a far from heroic nationalist struggle. The surviving rose-tinted mythology of the historical event was here challenged by a brutal and scathing portrayal of a fractured society in which men are drunk on alcohol, violence, or their own warped sense of heroism, and Irish women are subjected to that violence as well as to the violence of the poverty (in the form of terminal illness and prostitution) that a patriarchal society has imposed upon them and for which the male revolutionaries offer no hope of change. And thus the inscription on the proscenium sat as an ironic counterpoint throughout the whole production. Much has been made by revisionist critics of O’Casey’s displacement of the central political figures in the historical event (such as Pearse and Connolly), no more so than in the second act pub scene in which the
Contesting Canons 27
locals assuage their thirst for revolution in alcohol and in the company of a prostitute. The heady mixture of alcohol and prostitution form the context within which revolutionary political rhetoric is expounded by the one iconic and unnamed figure of The Speaker. Of course, O’Casey’s context disrupts the spectacle of heroism but his Speaker is normally portrayed in shadow against the pub window thus firmly separating him from the on-stage ne’er-do-wells. Hynes, though, decided to have The Speaker embodied and placed in the middle of the audience in a contemporary suit like a modern-day Fianna Fáil politician whose image was reflected large on a drop-down on-stage mirror, overshadowing the pub scene and uncomfortably reminding us that seventy-five years on from this revolutionary moment, both the political rhetoric and the appalling social conditions of Ireland’s under-classes have barely changed. By contemporizing and embodying The Speaker, Hynes did not permit the audience to bask in the comfortable familiarity of a distanced revolution to which rose-tinted nationalist sentiment paid perennial lip-service. Instead she forced them to watch one man who looked like the rest of them narrate a political rhetoric that was ill-fitting and totally vacuous for a contemporary context. This contemporary male politician calling the men of Ireland to arms had resonances of the then Taoiseach Charles Haughey who had been implicated in gun-running activities for the IRA in defence of Northern Catholics in the late 1960s. This one directorial choice, which was uncomfortable for some in the audience, was far from being a simple comment on the vacuity of the revolutionary politics of nationalism in a contemporary context; it was a strong indictment of the failure of post-revolutionary politics to fundamendally alter the living conditions of Ireland’s most vulnerable. Hynes, thus, did not only follow O’Casey’s line and displace the central male figures of the historical event, onto which so much nationalist mythology has been hung, she also refocused audience attention on the politics of gender within armed struggle. Costume designer Consolata Boyle dressed O’Casey’s women in russet-coloured rags and shaved their heads, in an act that both marked and unmarked their gender. The semiotic reading of a shaved head in 1991 was as a marker of a violent gang culture together with resonances of the Holocaust. Caught between these signifiers Hynes’s women were anything but domestic slaves to a surrounding male-dominated revolution. One of the central relationships in the play is between Nora and Jack Clitheroe, a lower middle-class couple fallen on hard times. Jack is part of the armed struggle while Nora does everything in her power to prevent him from leaving her and risking his life. Some critics have described Nora’s pleadings
28
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
to her husband not to fight as a ‘hysterical’5 reaction to a man’s heroic choice. Hynes, however, directed the relationship as intensely physical with both husband and wife being an equal match for the other, and directing Nora’s plea for her husband to stay as a rational argument to the point that Jack’s determination to leave for the mean streets of revolutionary Dublin appeared totally unreasonable. Similarly, Jack’s return in Act Three, wounded and shocked at the sight of his own blood, was presented as the less than heroic ideal reaction to blood sacrifice, a stark counterpoint to the rhetoric of The Speaker in the previous act. Nora’s reaction to his return similarly has been interpreted according to the on-stage male reading of it by her husband. Her pseudo-biblical reaction was played by Ingrid Craigie without any irony: ‘My Jack, my own Jack, that I thought was lost is found, that I thought was dead is alive again.’6 Set against the non-hysterical delivery by Nora, Jack’s reaction, ‘for God’s sake, Nora, don’t make a scene’, could only come across as particularly heartless, since she clearly was not making a scene. And this is one of many examples in the production where Hynes directed the politics of gender against received type, challenging sixty-five years of performance and critical tradition. Another notable example of Hynes’s challenge to received notions of gender order were to be found first and foremost in the casting of prostitute Rosie Redmond and the consumptive Mollser. The former had a performance tradition of being cast as a buxom, healthy and extremely jolly participant in her occupation. The latter has often been played by a healthy actress in no danger of imminent death. Hynes reversed all that: Rosie, played by Lorraine Pilkington, clearly was not happy with her life as a prostitute and she delivered her lines to undercut any comic reading of them. It was clear that she actually was in desperate need of the money and would have done anything other than her enforced profession, if she had had a choice. Similarly Mollser, played by Ruth O’Briain, could hardly speak her lines, given the extent of her illness and Hynes did not allow for the expediency of eliminating dead time on stage by glossing over the actual effect of her tuberculosis. The audience had to sit through the very painful attempts by Mollser to speak and be confronted very directly with the reality of poverty in a material and embodied sense. Although I am focusing on Hynes’s direction of two female characters in a book on masculinities and the Irish theatre, these two representations need to be highlighted in order to show how canonical representation of a canonical play about a revolution constructed historically in terms of the male figures of heroic action, are contested by Hynes’s representation of women. The actresses’ refusal to
Contesting Canons 29
deliver their lines as comic foil to male wit, particularly in the case of Rosie Redmond, also stands as a challenge to patriarchal stereotyping. Of all the men in the play posturing to fashion a nation through paramilitary action, Jack Clitheroe stands at the helm. He is the only one configured both in the public sphere of revolutionary action as well as in the private domestic sphere as husband to Nora. But he is also a real live man of action as opposed to the political figure (The Speaker) who calls the men of Ireland to a blood sacrifice. In Jack is compounded all the conflicting impulses of the revolutionary male caught not simply between private and public duty but also in what turns out to be a class war. As a member of the paramilitary workers’ militia, Jack has ostensibly one aim in his rifle sights: the British army occupying Ireland. But the Revolution also throws up new enemies for the militia in the form of their own people. Many of the inner city poor use the opportunity of the chaos provided by the cover of military action to go on a looting spree, setting aside the national objective for the sake of their own personal imperative: survival. This is a far cry from the heroic ideal of blood sacrifice mythologized in the words of The Speaker, and borrowed from the real-life revolutionary Proclamation of the Republic. It is also a far cry from the call to arms of the young men of Ireland by the Old Woman in Yeats’s 1902 play Kathleen Ní Houlihan. Jack Clitheroe, far from being the hard-body hero of the Revolution, refuses to kill his looting compatriots but opts to fire warning shots over their heads: ‘… bad as they are they’re Irish men an’ women’. His superior, Captain Bill Brennan retorts: ‘Irish be damned! Attackin’ and mobbin’ th’ men that are riskin’ their lives for them. If these slum lice gather at our heels again, plug one o’them, or I’ll soon shock them with a shot or two meself.’7 Here we find an example of how the self-fashioned new hegemonic masculinity of the revolutionary heroes begins to fragment before our eyes, as the patriarchal drives of hegemony seek out new subordinates not only in the form of the underclass described here as ‘slum lice’ but also in terms of Jack’s sparing of their lives. Jack is reminded by his superior of the hegemonic masculinity that is conferred on him by his status within the Citizen Army. But it is a hegemonic status with which he is not at all comfortable, especially since it demands that he subordinate other inferior masculinities to his own ‘pure’ revolutionary action. When he returns to his domestic setting this conflicted masculinity is all too patent and it is translated into the violence of inarticulacy as he struggles to make sense of a revolutionary patriarchy that demands the subordination of other masculinities including his own as husband and lover. Played by a young Patrick O’Kane in Hynes’s production, Jack was the physical epitome of
30
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
his hegemonic fighting status but Hynes brought that fighting zeal back into the domestic setting to ensure that the relationship between him and Nora was an intensely physical one and one in which Nora, too, physically asserted her humanist values on the need to protect life, and particularly that of her husband first and foremost. Thus her violent and intensely physical treatment of Jack, ‘a hair-pulling fingernail clawing fight’,8 was one motivated by her desire to drag her husband back from the clutches of imminent death, rather than one based on a simple selfish and pathetic need, a manner in which she is so often portrayed. One of the most loved and remembered characters in the play, the drunkard Fluther Good, is worthy of mention. The character is one of the ‘slum lice’ to whom Captain Brennan might have been referring in
Figure 1 Brendan Gleeson as Fluther Good in Sean O’Casey’s The Plough and the Stars, Abbey Theatre, 1991, directed by Garry Hynes. Photograph by kind permission of Abbey Theatre Archive.
Contesting Canons 31
that, despite his rhetoric, his action is far removed from any nationalist Republican ideal. Theo Dorgan, writing in the Irish Times in defence of the production clearly spelled out how Hynes offered a radical interpretation of the role within a panoply of staged masculinites that undercut the hegemonic ideal: ‘The conventional manner of presenting this play has hinged on a soft-centered sentimentality, one which depends for its force on showing Fluther, say, as a benign, shambling decent skin, with a penchant for the oul’ jar. […] By contrast Brendan Gleeson’s Fluther is frankly an alcoholic, with the alcoholic’s frightening capacity to shift mood with sudden and brutal force.’9 Dressed in Doc Marten boots and with a shaved head Brendan Gleeson played him ‘as a raging, inarticulate brute’.10 But this interpretation clearly was seen by first critics as a problem when his ‘bull-necked crew-cut Fluther […] needs to seem more tender than boorish’.11 The latter statement by the then lead Irish Times critic David Nowlan betrays a desire for convention in interpretation and for a sentimental approach to O’Casey’s less than sentimental version of a revolutionary moment. Gleeson’s interpretation of the role was unconventional as he did not invite the audience to soften towards him. He was a frightening alcoholic and an embodiment of another of Ireland’s social ills. Conventionally he has been received by audiences sympathetically as he provides some superb claptraps in his lines that appeal to naked nationalism. One such claptrap comes at the end of the play in the presence of two British soldiers in the tenement: ‘I’d beat the two o’yous without sweatin’.’ This was no lovable drunk in stout defence of his country but a man throughout the production who terrorized all by his fearful alcoholic mood-swings. The inference was that he might well have beaten the British soldiers but that his uncontrollable rage would be misplaced in a post-revolutionary society. By not permitting a sentimental reading of the character Hynes and Gleeson exposed how a masculinity as toxic as Fluther’s should not be inappropriately tolerated by armchair nationalists prepared to forgo basic decency in their desire for a heroically masculine nation in whatever form. The portrayal of Fluther (like that of Rosie Redmond) was a rejection of a comic reading and was a political contestation of the acceptability of poverty and all its concomitant ills as a consequence of post-revolutionary independence in which a new set of Republican elites had replaced the colonial administration allowing forces of patriarchy to trample over social justice and acceptable forms of male behaviour. The controversy that raged in the press and in the letters pages of the Irish Times throughout the production’s run was fuelled by the critical establishment’s attempt to reassert itself using gender and its
32
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
representation as the principal yardstick by which to measure the production. Hynes had not set herself an easy task since preceding her production there was a much loved and highly popular production of the same play directed by former Abbey artistic director Joe Dowling that ran in the Gaiety Theatre and on tour and was reputed to have attracted over 100,000 spectators. Dowling’s production was realistic, conventional, and occasionally sentimental that appealed to a wide catholic taste and sported all the attributes of rose-tinted representations of gender in its most benign form that had allowed O’Casey’s troublesome and less than heroic version of the 1916 Rising to endure for the rest of the century. Pre-publicity for Hynes’s national theatre debut production included a puff-piece in the Irish Times constructed around an interview with the director. Hynes clearly used this to signal how revisionist she was intending this production to be and to signal that the revisionism was to come in the form of the representation of gender: ‘Rosie has usually been portrayed as an ageing whore with a heart of gold. This is inappropriate, as O’Casey clearly wanted her to be seen as a young woman who is desperate to get a customer so that she can eat and drink.’12 This emphasis was one that was picked up by first critics, none more so than David Nowlan who fell far short of criticizing the production as a whole, erroneously labelling it expressionist and resorting instead to picking out individual performances that contrasted with a conventional interpretation. Bessie Burgess, Nowlan opined, ‘comes across strongly as the harridan, but less effectively as the heroine’. He continued with a description of Rosie Redmond as ‘more pathetic than feisty’, and Mollser as ‘purely a cipher for sickness’.13 Clearly Nowlan’s wish was for all the characters to be more sentimentally portrayed, more stereotypically anodyne in performance, which belied Hynes’s intentions as clearly laid out in the programme note by Literary Adviser Fintan O’Toole that the marginalized characters of Dublin’s inner city tenement slums might not have been as contented with their lot as bourgeois critical opinion had led us to believe. Later in the Irish Times letters debate it was suggested by playwright Hugh Leonard, who loathed the production, that Nowlan was too afraid to criticize the production proper and resorted instead to criticizing individual performances. This is interesting because much had been made by journalists of the symbolism of the first woman director of the Abbey being appointed swiftly after the election of the first woman President. Although he never criticized Hynes directly Nowlan (perhaps unwittingly) used gender and its representation as a first line of attack. The idea that somehow there was in Nowlan’s belief system an acceptable form of realism in representing
Contesting Canons 33
O’Casey’s less than heroic revolutionaries is doubly ironic when one realizes how much under attack O’Casey’s vision was in its own time by survivors and relatives of the historical event, and by subsequent revisionist critics and historians. Nowlan began his critique by lamenting the production’s supposed humourlessness: ‘There is not so much as usual to like or enjoy. Laughter seems to be encouraged by a deliberately slow pace.’ At the end of the week the Arts Editor of the same newspaper Fergus Linehan picked up on Nowlan’s viewpoint and launched an attack on the production in a more direct fashion: ‘Stripped of all its humour and warmth, it becomes not some powerful parable of poverty but a bad tempered snarl which leaves us unenlightened and unstirred.’14 The occasion for Linehan’s intervention was a production of the play by Sam Mendes at the Young Vic in London that conformed more to the establishment’s expectations. The comparison served to provide examples of traditional representation so lacking for the critics in Hynes’s production. But the opening sentence of Linehan’s article is highly revealing in the extent of the effect of Hynes’s production on the performance of the establishment that had acted as guardian of the repertoire and its traditional representation in a postindependence Republic: ‘It was a brave decision to challenge the Irish theatre establishment on its home ground (you could chip ice cubes out of the atmosphere on Tuesday’s first night).’ This demonstrates clearly that Hynes was at the vanguard of a centrifugal force in Irish theatre, emerging as she did from the independent sector and from the regional cultural powerhouse that Galway was becoming, and attacking the urban middle-class obsession with peasant plays and cutesy tenement slums and wrapping them up in a bucolic sentimentality. By stripping her stage bare and shaving her actors’ heads, Hynes tore through tradition and even went as far as offering an alternative reading to revisionist critics of O’Casey to show how his socialist politics might have challenged myths but were not necessarily anti-nationalist. The combination of Hynes’s and O’Toole’s reading of O’Casey’s play firmly highlights the pursuit of social justice, configured in a performance of injustice that is highly gendered. And while we saw how injustice is meted out in the form of appalling social conditions and their effect on women’s health, we also saw how the monolithic narrative of nationalism is a patriarchal force for the oppression of men as well as women. R. W. Connell offers some useful definitions of the pursuit of social justice that help us read through Hynes’s direction: ‘Pursuing social justice does mean pursuing uniformity […] Pursuing social justice in power relations means contesting men’s dominance
34
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
in the state, professions and management, and ending men’s violence against women. It also means changing the institutional structures that make elite power and body-to-body violence possible in the first place.’15 In terms of Hynes’s direction, the unsexing of characters by shaving their heads, and playing against the many famous lines that have been fondly remembered as claptraps, leads to a critique of the mythologizing of a historical moment and its theatrical embodiment. Hynes’s men were no folksy urban types; she presented them as masculinities that were conflicted by multiple imperatives, such as in Jack Clitheroe, the hunter-hero resisting colonial oppression and the refusnik in a classconscious Citizen Army unprepared to sacrifice his own people for the sake of a national ideal. Another conflicted masculinity was to be found in the representation of Fluther Good, willing to defend his territory from British soldiers in rhetoric only, while ominously capable of lashing out against his own people in an alcoholic rage. The production also exposed the national ideal as a class-ridden myth used to assert control by a new elite through the rhetoric of blood sacrifice. And all the while the seemingly benign Speaker located in the midst of the audience dressed in a lounge suit spouted the mythological rhetoric of 1916 confronting the audience with the fact that contemporary society in the new Republic was founded on inequality and patriarchal oppression of both men and women.
Urban Playboy The Playboy of the Western World by J. M. Synge has been a source of division amongst the theatrical establishment and competing audiences since its first performance at the Abbey Theatre in January 1907. The now infamous ‘Playboy riots’ that accompanied the first performances centred on what was condemned by some factions as a revivalist and neo-colonialist representation of the true native and rural peasant Irish. The linkage between theatrical representation and the realities of an emerging nation was hotly contested. Who was represented was not in doubt (namely the uncorrupted ur-peasant untainted and beyond the reach of colonial rule), but how that figure was represented was a sore point. Synge’s now mythic parable of the construction and constructedness of heroism might indeed be read as a revisionist attack on the overthrow of patriarchal colonialism configured theatrically as an act of parricide. But it has also been condemned by nativist nationalists for such an exposure in its form of an ungrateful son of Ireland, Christy Mahon, whose lies and deceit lead to the deception of countryfolk
Contesting Canons 35
whose own complicity in the deceit is just as shocking and whose violence and naked desire for vengeance is galling. It is a play that falls far short of a nationalist ideal and yet it has survived despite that for the entire twentieth century and beyond. The reason for its success lies in its comic portrayal of very strong women pitted against some very hapless and feckless men. Christy’s sudden appearance in the one-set shebeen provides the country women with an idealized action hero they so painfully lack in the surrounding male company and Christy is seduced by their desires so thoroughly that he temporarily performs the role of hero for them. Read solely through the lens of gender this play is an exposure of the fantasies and realities of competing masculinities. And it is only through fantasy and desire that the baseline subordinated masculinity of the peasant farmer can be transformed into the hegemonic masculinity of action. Further, the Playboy has survived in the canon for reasons beyond its dramaturgical structure and its literary qualities because of its provision as a vehicle for the comic turns so beloved of popular audiences. Its very clear division of gender roles and its inversion of them are also the source of much of its appeal. For instance, the two leading female characters are very much women of action. Pegeen Mike may indeed be subject to her father’s ultimate control but in stage time she is very much in control of the shebeen and of the fate of her less than glorious fiancé. On the other hand, the Widow Quinn is a woman of inherited wealth and status. She owns a small-holding and although desirous of a man for sexual gratification largely appears content with her role as widow and the financial and social independence that that title and status confer. And so when Christy, the wannabe hero, appears on the scene he is torn between the two women’s affections; while Pegeen desires Christy as a potential husband and thus the conferral on her of social status, the Widow Quinn as an independent woman of means has a very clear and simple use-value for him, and that is very much subordinate to her. Indeed the Widow Quinn could easily be mistaken for the one true hegemonic masculinity present on the stage in the play. Such a reading in terms of masculinity could be seen in the 2004 Abbey Theatre production,16 in which actress Olwen Fouéré who played the role was dressed in men’s clothes (those of her character’s deceased husband) and occasionally took on the vestiges of the male body in motion. A trawl through the production history of the play at the Abbey Theatre reveals an invariable approach in design as the country cottage trope for the nation has been maintained throughout the century. This single-set representation of the heart of the nation lying at the hearth
36
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
of peasant culture is troubled somewhat by the pub setting of Playboy although the set itself is a transformable space doubling as Pegeen’s living room as well as a public space. The collapse of the public into the private also helps transform this woman’s place in peasant society, blurring her private domestic identity with an important and socially cohesive role that confers status on her in a masculine public sphere. When Christy appears at her doorstep he first enters her public sphere but as she settles him down by the fire and makes a bed for him she domestically transforms the role through the conversion of her space. The space thus becomes a metaphor for the dialectic throughout the play of woman’s private desires versus her public performance. Christy’s appeal is rooted in his ability to operate within that dialectic, successfully negotiating a space between the two performances. Ultimately, though, this is a rough and dark pastoral depiction of an imagined urIreland for a nation that had not yet come into being. A century on, its relevance lies not in its potential metaphor for nation or its role in the construction of a native theatrical canon, but in its representation of women’s construction of masculinities. In the early twenty-first century its performance has never been as popular. The above-mentioned Abbey centenary production had a direct rival in the form of a production by the Druid Theatre company from Galway, directed by Garry Hynes, who had returned to the company she had founded after her three-year Abbey directorship. Over the course of the following two years Druid were to stage the entire body of work by Synge including the unfinished Deirdre of the Sorrows in a marketing triumph entitled DruidSynge that was to tour internationally and be recorded on DVD. It many ways Druid had earned almost ownership rights of Synge’s work having made their name and reputation with a celebrated 1975 production of the Playboy. All of their re-stagings were tough, uncompromising, and often brutal retellings of the gender fable while the 2004 re-staging clearly dispelled the myth that the play ever was a representation of nation. However, all of their productions retained a rural setting. The 2007 Abbey Theatre production, in contrast, was a radical and controversial rethinking of the play, used as a textual premise for a relocation and rewriting of it by popular novelist and Booker prize-winner Roddy Doyle, and Nigerian performer and director Bisi Adigun. But the genesis of the play was not at all with the Abbey. Bisi Adigun by the Abbey centenary year had become a national figure and the anchor for a ‘multicultural’ magazine programme on national television RTE. During 2003 he set up Arambe Productions, an African theatre company based in
Contesting Canons 37
Dublin whose remit was not only to provide performance opportunities for Africans living in Ireland but also to produce African plays for audiences in an Irish context. Their official mission statement is to ‘afford members of Ireland’s African communities the unique opportunity to express themselves through the art of theatre’.17 The name is derived from the Yoruba saying ‘ara m be to mo fe da’ (there are wonders that I want to perform) and the Swahili word ‘harambee’ (work together). The following year Adigun incorporated the company and invited celebrated Dublin author Roddy Doyle to launch it. By far its biggest success has been in reimagining plays by Irish authors but using African actors. In a repertoire of nine productions to date, arguably their most famous production was a reworking of Jimmy Murphy’s 2000 play The Kings of the Kilburn High Road (to be discussed in Chapter 6) that features a collection of men who have left a poverty-stricken Ireland to work as labourers in London. The play centres on the wake of one of their number whose body is being returned home for burial. Essentially it explores the nostalgic yearning of Irish immigrants for a lost past, and for a country and society that no longer exists. Arambe’s recasting of the Irish roles with African actors exposed how the contemporary experience of migrants in the new Ireland has resonances with their Irish counterparts abroad and the principal aim of the production was to spark and foster cross-cultural understanding in a country riven by economic disparity and racism.18 Right from the beginning of Arambe productions Adigun expressed a desire to rethink The Playboy of the Western World in the context of a globalized world, immigration, and inter-cultural understanding and he approached Doyle to co-author it with him. The original contractual relationship was between Arambe and the two authors and it was only in early 2007 that the director of the Abbey Theatre, Fiach Mac Conghail offered to produce the play as an Abbey production. Although suppressed from the media for over a year, behind the scenes the contractual relationship between Arambe, the Abbey, and the authors had fallen apart and had become the subject of much legal wrangling that at the time of writing has still not been resolved. Sadly the project’s main drive to foster inter-cultural understanding was upstaged literally by an ownership disagreement that threatened to derail the whole project. Nevertheless the Abbey production was scheduled as its Dublin Theatre Festival contribution for 2007 with both authors playing a large part in the publicity drive for the production. But the production itself caused a huge flurry of both critical and academic enquiry given the use of Synge’s title for what was essentially a new play written with the original only as a premise. Adigun and Doyle had relocated
38
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
the play from its original County Mayo rural shebeen to a pub owned by a criminal gang master in one of West Dublin’s sprawling housing estates that had become infamous for its gangland turf wars. Whereas The Plough and Stars used inner city Dublin as its social backdrop, this new version of Synge’s classic was situated in the very place to where the inner city population had been relocated in successive policies of social engineering since independence, swapping urban deprivation for suburban isolation. The new location effectively transformed the play into a sub/urban pastoral, and the principal dramaturgical premise of the folklore inherent in tales of violent criminality supported by a local community in defiance of any kind of law was to find a new home in the suburban sprawl and in a deprived community where evasion of the law is similarly condoned by the surrounding community. The fascination with the storytelling of folkore similarly slotted well into the contemporary fascination with tabloid journalism and the present-day aspiration for celebrity even through criminal activity. Synge’s original play thus held a fascination for Dublin middle-class audiences throughout the century because it was set in a rural community of others. They were not ostensibly the ur-Irish of a new nation, but exotic others in a land beyond the Pale but with recognizably dramatic traits in the play’s presentation of the hero’s Oedipal situation (attacking his father to escape an arranged marriage with one older woman only to be tempted by another who offers to protect him from his father), and a community’s love and need for celebrity heroes, however constructed. The play has the comfortable familiarity of its stock comic tropes along gender lines, as well as dramatic action that turns on the trials of a father–son relationship. And yet it also exudes a foreignness for the middle classes in its presentation of a shockingly naïve community that was taken in by an impostor, as well as its distasteful penchant for violence in the form of lynch-mob rule. The new version by Adigun and Doyle also offered to a contemporary middle-class audience a similar dialectic of the familiar and foreign; the West Dublin pub was a recognizable location and yet for most was still a world apart from their actual lived experience. The characterizations were versions of pub drunks, violent men of action, and an over-sexed woman familiar from some of the Abbey’s celebrated repertoire, none more so than the stock presentations of The Plough and the Stars before Garry Hynes wrested it from its anodyne comic tradition. There were actual place names mentioned (such as the Blanchardstown Shopping Centre) and an iconic picture of Irish football legend Roy Keane. Thus the new version traded on a familiarity that was quasi-folkloric. The new characters
Contesting Canons 39
all retained aspects of their original rural roots; Pegeen is still running the pub and running rings around her fiancé Sean with whom she is to enter an arranged marriage (for Sean is the hapless son of a Dublin criminal matriarch). Pegeen’s father (in this version Michael James) is a gangland criminal who uses the pub as a front for less salubrious activities. He refers to his two henchmen by the colloquial diminutive versions of their names, Philly and Jimmy, to confer a subordinated status on them which they live up to happily as they are men who prefer aclohol to fighting (and the one clearly prevents the other). Meanwhile the Widow Quinn is a glamorous older woman whom the press has reported as being a suspect in the murder of her husband (in an obvious reference to a real-life husband killer known in the popular press as the Black Widow). In sum, the new version uses contemporary folklore of a glamorized criminal type in much the same way that Synge had created an amalgam of actual parricides and the folkloric retelling of them. But for some critics ‘the production’s emphasis on the alien other and celebrity culture’19 was a familiarity too far since it had ostensibly eradicated the literariness or lyricism of the Synge original. In fact the new version had replaced an imagined Hiberno-English with a recognizable Dublin working-class slang, and thus the by now famous lines were reduced often to expletives although they provided another layer of humour. By far the most radical and challenging aspect of the new version was the rethinking of the outsider who appears in this urban folkloric setting. Christy Mahon in the original may not be part of the community he enters at the beginning of the play but he is of the same class and race as the community that embraces him. In the Adigun/Doyle version Christy Mahon has been renamed Christopher Malomo who has escaped his native Nigeria via England and Northern Ireland and has ended up by mistake in a West Dublin pub. The same premise as in the original play spurs him on, namely that he has killed his father who wanted to execute an arranged marriage for him to a woman who was far from his ideal. Yet in this version he is a double outsider marked by his race from the outset: he ‘is not a desperate member of the social underclass, but an affluent, educated young Nigerian’.20 And so, unlike in the rural original, when Christy walked onto the stage as a black man he was doubly othered and there were audible intakes of breath in the audience. The audience, though, were not necessarily reacting to the surprise of a black actor appearing on stage but were revealing an anxiety for him in the particular environment that had been set up on stage, an environment and social class not renowned for its inter-cultural understanding. And when Christy’s father appeared later in the play in traditional dress, the
40
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
shock was even greater as both his clothing and his skin colour were markers of the outsider. However familiar the gangland stereotypes may have been for the middle-class audience the innate fear of that society was translated into a fear for the safety of the African migrants. The biggest surprise for most critics was the level of tolerance the gangland criminals expressed towards the outsiders, and there were few lines that referred to his skin colour. This tolerance for some was a mark of the failure of the version to confront the reality of racism, but the production’s glide over the issue of racism actually revealed a good deal about the presentation of race instead in a post-colonial society. The race rather than racism drive of the production also challenged and troubled the construction of masculinity in a post-colonial context. The fascination of Christy, particularly for the women in the play, takes on an added signficance in the Adigun/Doyle version because of the new character’s race. This fascination, when confronted by a black body, has the hue of colonial fetishization. The first remarks about Christy’s body
Figure 2 Giles Terera as Christopher Malomo in Bisi Adigun and Roddy Doyle’s version of J. M. Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World, Abbey Theatre, 2007. Photograph: ROS KAVANAGH PHOTOGRAPHER.
Contesting Canons 41
refer momentarily to his skin colour but the women in turn (as in the original) desire to touch the body of an imagined hero. Particular emphasis is placed on what marks his body as different from the white male body, and thus his hair becomes the focus of attention. Of course Christy himself feeds into the myth of his body in both versions as he preens himself in front of a mirror, but here again he marks out his difference by referring specifically to how he maintains his hair and how he cleans his teeth. As the narrative reveals, the black male body has reached a point of crisis according to Christy as he laments the generalized perception of the ideal male body in Nigeria. Like in many traditional societies the economic and social status of the individual male uses the body as a marker so that the ideal becomes manifest in a corporeal corpulence. Christy adamantly rejects this ideal body, much preferring the slim Western model as epitomized by many highly successful African soccer stars. And here we see a clash of ideals being played out over the male body that constructs hegemonic masculinity in two contrasting forms. Of course the corpulent body need not be sexualized in a society where arranged marriages are the norm given that the attraction is economic and social, but in a Westernized society where sexuality is competitive in physical terms it is here that hard-body masculinity is prized. Christy Malomo’s body in the form of actor Giles Terera was supremely fit and slim and this provided the credibility factor for a story of parricide. It is as if only a hard-body masculinity could commit an act of murder. And in the new version he continues to fuel the hard-body myth, not in the sporting race of the original but in the beating up of a hard-man and gangland criminal who is a rival to his host’s dynasty. Thus in the original a criminal act may be the spur to the creation of a hero but that heroism is perpetuated by sporting and thus socially sanctioned prowess. In other words, the masculinity that Christy exemplifies as a runaway is a protest masculinity against the hegemonic patriarchy of economic status. But as he is lionized by his new-found community protest masculinity itself is refashioned as hegemonic not in economic but in social terms. Not so, however, in the Adigun/Doyle version, as this dialectic of masculinities is reversed. Christy starts out as hegemonic economically from the outset. Not only is his father a wealthy businessman but Christy himself has a Masters degree and is set to inherit his father’s wealth. The act of parricide that launches him into the criminal underworld is a defiant act that sets him spiralling into a form of protest masculinity. Although on-stage and in front of his new audience he is proud of his African culture, he is highly critical of the masculinity that his native culture valorizes both economically and socially. His act of protest then
42
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
becomes the signifier of status in a Western underworld community that prizes protest masculinity configured in acts of violence.21 An alternative hegemony is established outside of the law which is premised on physical strength, the inculcation of fear in other rival masculinities, and in a series of performances by women who themselves have social status for similarly performing patriarchy. The emphasis on violence as a performance of hegemonic status is a language that Christy learns very quickly in his new-found Irish context. And this leads us back to the emplacement of this play in the canon which some read as a performance of anti-colonial resistance.22 Such a reading though, as Nicholas Grene highlights, can be over-stretched to imagine that audiences are taken through an experience of ‘heroised enthusiasm equivalent to romantic nationalism, towards the true liberation of independent self-making’.23 The represention of agrarian violence that was claimed as ‘symptomatic and generalised into a characterisation of the people as a whole’24 by the colonial administration and that was used as a charge against Synge’s representation by competing factions within nationalism is troubled by this new Nigerian Christy and by the urban professionalization of violence not for reasons of an aspirant nationalism but for personal greed and gain. The new play’s context of urban criminality that fuels the celebrity pop culture of Ireland stands opposed to claims of a nationalist narrative for the play. And the new men of a post-colonial society are exactly like the hard-body ur-Celt warriors of romantic nationalism, but with nothing to drive them but wealth and greed outside of lawful structures. These extra-legal acts of violence stand in protest against the narrative of nationalism while the nationalist Irish male retains the same hard-body signifier with a now new and anti-nationalist signified. The supremely fit body and its ability to fearlessly commit acts of violence become Christopher Malomo’s prime economic asset regardless of his race in the exclusively white society of the play. And while critics pointed out that the issue of his outsider race in this society was not addressed, the play continuously pointed out how a globalized culture of hard-body masculinity is an economic asset and prime signifier of social status in both legal contexts (such as is evidenced in the reverence shown to Roy Keane’s image as a sporting hero in institutionally sanctioned hard-body masculinity) as well as in the extra-legal context of this West Dublin criminal underworld. And so in many senses this new play does not fetishize the African body as other necessarily, but glorifies its similarity to Ireland’s own ideal image of the male body. The hard-body of the African is seamlessly embraced into this underworld’s performance of extra-legal hegemonic masculinity to the point, after some initial caution,
Contesting Canons 43
where he is allowed to entertain the notion of being suitor to Pegeen and thus an imminent relation. While this of course is highly fanciful in realistic terms, it does permit an examination of masculinity in an Irish context that is not exclusively marked by subjectivities and where we can see how competing masculinities (as embodied by Christy’s race, wealth, and physical status) are renegotiated in a new Irish context. But of course the original drive of the narrative is to expel the would-be interloper when it is discovered that his initial hard-body act is a lie. In the Adigun/Doyle version Christy’s attempt to escape his friends-turned-enemies relies on the original play in dressing him up as a woman. But in this new contemporary context the women’s clothes he puts on are highly significant: a pink velour pjyama-suit with the word ‘BITCH’ stencilled in silver on the backside. The image of the black man in pink with his new subordinated status emblazoned on his backside is a total feminization and subordination of this once hegemonic male. But in an Irish context where nationalism has configured itself within a colonial matrix, the representation of a black man feminized as well as roped and tied subsequently is a troubling representation of the Irish: no longer the feminized other, the white Irish are now configured as the patriarchal colonizers, all through the representation of the male body. At the end of the play when Christy’s father returns in traditional African dress, order is restored. As the two finally bond together in the face of being feminized and othered, they exit in a performance of their rejection of the white Western fetishization of the black male body which turns out to be a front for an innate desire to colonize it. The Irish as colonized turned colonizer is summed up in the rewriting of Pegeen’s celebrated last line from ‘Oh my grief, I’ve lost him surely. I’ve lost the only playboy of the western world’25 to a simple expletive: ‘Fuck!’ This rewriting can be read as a realization of what the new Irish have become, and at the same time a realization of how the performance of an idealized masculinity could lead them astray. In many senses this production was not such a radical departure from the traditional use of symbolic masculinity within the cultural representation of nationalism. Where this rewriting and its production differ is that it challenges the nativism inherent in nationalist discourse, presenting vestiges of hegemonic masculinity in a social class whose economic claim to it has been achieved in an illegal and thus antinational fashion. It also exposes how a globalized Ireland differs little in its construction of an idealized masculinity from its originary nativist impulse, and that invites us to suspend a rejection of racial difference and focus on a performance of sameness between black and white hardbodies and colonized/colonizer.26
3 Performing Patriarchy
As articulated previously, Ireland as a nation, like other post-colonial nations, was conceived through the metaphoric use of gender. In Ireland’s case it was conceived specifically through a series of female tropes, such as the Róisín Dubh (the Black Rose as metaphor for a nation for whom one would die), or the Aisling (a vision in the form of a woman). Both of these women-tropes were performed in popular and political song with romantic nationalist sentiment. Meanwhile in the theatre the concept of the Aisling figure indelibly linked the form to the nationalist project in Yeats’s and Lady Gregory’s 1902 play Kathleen Ní Houlihan. In the play she is embodied by a rootless Poor Old Woman who has been dispossessed of her four green fields (as an overt symbol of a colonized and specifically Irish nation with its four provinces). She appears onstage and asks the young male patriots of Ireland to forsake their families and to fight on her behalf. So if Ireland as nation was conceived as a woman metaphorically it was so in opposition to the patriarchal colonizer of Britain. The appeal to Mná na hÉireann (women of Ireland) by Mary Robinson as candidate for the presidency in 1990 was in part a call to an important constituency of voters in a historically male-dominated constitutional role and election but it was also a recognition of the role women played both metaphorically but more importantly actively in the birth and subsequent creation of the nation state. Nevertheless it was a deliberate call to replace the metaphorical in nationalist sentiment with an actual woman, and one who stood politically in support of the subjectivities that had been marginalized not by the colonizing British legislation, but by successive waves of post-colonial political administrations that had imagined a nation through policies of exclusion. Woman, for instance, as Melissa Sihra points out, was configured as indissociable from her use-value in the production of a male-dominated capitalist 44
Performing Patriarchy 45
economy (in other words as a mother of a future workforce): ‘From the 1930s on, women’s perceived primary social function as wife and mother, and the implementation of the draconian 1932 public service “marriage bar”, which prevented married women from being employed as civil servants and national school teachers, was used to limit their role and potential in public life.’1 What transpired then in effect was a new form of colonization in which, according to Anthony Bradley and Maryann Gialanella Valiulis, ‘the lives of actual Irish women were colonized by Irish men’.2 The project of constructing a nation in gendered terms meant that Ireland was already female in the cultural imaginary, in opposition to Britain as a colonizing male. But this role of woman was not an actual one, but rather a dream-vision (Aisling) of metaphor only. The reality was that the construction of the nation was in fact an overt performance of patriarchy that recolonized the people again in terms of gender and as a lived reality, not as metaphor. The principal architect of the nation who himself contributed to the armed struggle for liberation in the early part of the century, Eamon de Valera, ultimately of course performed the epitome of patriarchal roles in the political sphere. When he became Taoiseach in 1937, despite earlier assertions that everyone would be treated as equal in the new nation, he conspired with the Catholic Church hierarchy to replicate legislatively a Church-based division of social and economic roles along gendered lines that served to secure patriarchy as the ‘national’ ideology. Effectively this ideology constructed woman’s role in the state as one exclusively confined to motherhood, and made sure she was confined by legislating against divorce. His reign continued (with two interruptions) until 1959 during which time women were trapped in marriage and expected to contribute to the economy by giving birth with absolutely no right to work in the public sector or to escape when the marriage turned sour. Subsequently he was returned in two elections as Uachtaráin (President) until his retirement in 1973 but his spectre as austere patriarch haunted the country right up until the beginning of the economic boom in the 1990s. His successive economic isolationist policies based on a largely agrarian economy could not sustain its population and led to several generations being lost to emigration. When the economic boom emerged in the early to mid-1990s Ireland’s Constitution and legislation had already undergone a sea-change that was supported in the main by popular opinion. The altered demographic of Ireland as a result of the reversal of the tide of emigration among Ireland’s youth, coupled with pressure from the European Economic Community (and from 1993 the European Union) meant that the constitutional gender
46
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
entrapment along with its premise of compulsory heterosexuality could be questioned and overturned. In 1993 after a long-running battle in the European Court of Human Rights and subsequent long-fingering of the ruling at home, the criminalization of homosexuality was repealed, and in 1996 the Family Law (Divorce) Act was passed permitting couples to divorce and remarry. In the political and social sphere of the new nation, despite a liberalization of legislation, successive generations of political leaders in the contemporary period have performed less than ideal models of patriarchy as was evidenced in the plethora of trials and tribunals exposing corruption at the highest level. This was particularly significant in the economic boom years of the 1990s when the general upbeat mood of a thriving society was able to condone tacitly much of the political scandal of personal gain. And this is one of the ironies of modern Ireland that personal profiteering by some politicians is not deemed to be anti-national despite its criminality and social immorality. This continues to be one aspect of the performance of patriarchy in its construction of the Irish male as eternally colonized so that his ability to buck legislation and get off scot-free is read as a righteous refusal to be colonized by authority. Ironic as it may be, this is a patriarchal practice that disguises itself as a colonized female other for its self-centred, goal-oriented phallocentric gain.
Offstage As far as the theatre was concerned, the problem of performing patriarchy was not without conflict as in a colonial society the arch-patriarch is a colonizer and must be demonized, whereas in a post-colonial society the patriarchal hue of the nation cannot be criticized explicitly. And this despite the aforementioned irony of performance in the political sphere that still persists in dressing itself up as a persecuted ‘female’. So the presentation of masculinity in the theatrical sphere eschewed for the most part the presentation of patriarchal masculinity as a metaphor for the nation. One of the reasons for this was the symbiosis of Catholic Church and state which created a patriarchally theocratic political system that enabled the Archbishop of Dublin, the most notorious patriarchal example being that of Archbishop John Charles McQuaid (who remained in post from 1940 to 1972), to command deference from political leaders and approval for social and constitutional issues that theatened that theocracy. And so the performance of patriarchy on a political level was played out in a competition between competing masculinities by the leaders of Church and state determining the path of a nation that had for the most part been forged through the blood sacrifice of many of the nation’s subordinated masculinities, that is
Performing Patriarchy 47
the working-class revolutionaries, despite the fact their middle-class leaders had usurped the iconic status of martyrs. The theatre never attempted to embody any of the political leaders of the new nation in any real or realistic sense. The Speaker in The Plough and the Stars is given a generic title to obviate a reading of him or a direct association of him with Pádraic Pearse. It is not surprising that that would be the case given the Abbey Theatre’s state funding and the draconian measures that were being taken by official censors of literature and the cinema. No such official censorship ever operated in Ireland, even before independence, because Ireland’s theatre never fell under the purview of the Lord Chamberlain, and in modern Ireland an official state censor of theatre was never created. However, censorship operated regardless, and usually through the Department of Justice reacting to objections from various conservative moral interest groups and embassy representatives who might object to stage interpretations of their subjects considered critical of their national (and usually foreign) policy. Censorship thus operated in a clandestine form with the film censor usually being consulted for advice. But the advice was generally taken and enormous pressure was brought to bear on theatre managements, including the leading theatres in Dublin such as the Gate and the Abbey. That pressure nearly always triumphed as the theatres did not want to run the risk of being accused of inciting a public order offence, since the Department of Justice was involved, and there is little doubt that the fear of an official and overt form of censorship might be introduced if theatre managements did not acquiesce on the occasions when pressure was brought to bear in private. The film censor during the Emergency (neutral Ireland’s term for the Second World War), Dr Richard Hayes, famously commented that there was no need for a theatre censor to operate officially as there was for cinema for reasons of age: ‘The Abbey audiences are 100 per cent adult and the cinema audiences may conceivably be as much as 80 per cent children.’ But as Donal O’Drisceoil points out, ‘class rather than age may have been the determining factor in Hayes’s differentiation’.3 Perhaps the lack of a perceived need for an official censor was based on the premise that live theatre by its very nature is home-produced and appeals to the more prosperous sections of society. With those givens, it would be perfectly reasonable to assume that the theatre producers would self-censor and that audiences would be educated enough and embraced enough in dominant ideologies that representations contesting the dominant would never be sanctioned let alone be acceptable to the theatregoing public. Not so the cinema with its imported and thus suspect ideologies that offered alternative images unfettered from the ideologies of Catholic conservatism. While theatre was seen to nurture dominant ideology, cinema was seen as a threat to it,
48
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
in much the same way as De Valera’s economic policies had blockaded its commercial market from the corruption of global competition. A similar competitive situation was played out in the cultural sphere, notably in the theatre with Yeats struggling to assert his authority in the first decades of his national theatre project at the Abbey as witnessed in the organized disturbances in the theatre by factions of national opinion and self-interested others intent on claiming the title of national. His famous put-downs in which he declared that the Irish people had disgraced themselves again4 constituted a performance of a hegemonic masculinity that straddled Ascendancy authority in a still colonial situation and a nationalist authority in the emergent nation. Later when Yeats was courting public subsidy, political appointees to the Abbey board effectively acted as unofficial censors who could alert state authorities to upcoming productions likely to cause offence or scandal. But it was not just the Abbey that was under threat of unofficial censorship from conservative moral guardians. Those foreign influences that were being successfully suppressed in the cinema were threatening to corrupt the stages of Ireland in the 1950s. Ironically this came about as a direct result of a Tourist Board (Bord Fáilte) initiative to both celebrate Irish cultural life and to attract outside investment in the form of tourism. The project was called An Tóstal; it began in 1953 and as a national event with every conurbation from large city to tiny village expected to form An Tóstal councils to initiate a post-Easter celebratory pageant of parades, sporting, and arts events. In 1957 Brendan Smyth, an impresario who ran at the time an acting academy as well as owned the largest of Dublin’s theatres, the Olympia, proposed to Bord Fáilte a theatre festival for Dublin as part of the An Tóstal event. The very first festival featured an impressive lineup of international artists that belied any notion of an insular cultural life in Dublin at the time. Visiting companies ranged from Jean Vilar’s celebrated Théâtre National Populaire to the Royal Ballet, starring Margot Fonteyn. The Gate (with Denis Johnston’s The Old Lady Says No!) and the Abbey with Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World and O’Casey’s Juno and the Paycock, reliably produced the canon between them. But it was in a small private theatre club in Dublin’s fashionable southside and not far from the political establishment where a controversy erupted that was to have serious repercussions on theatrical life for years to come. The Pike Theatre had been established by Carolyn Swift and Alan Simpson as a cultural expression of a new modern elite, opposed to the national ideology that enshrined patriarchy as its modus vivendi. The repertoire of its tiny fifty-seat venue was a mixture of high modernism (premiering plays by Beckett and Ionesco) and a series of reviews making fun of the
Performing Patriarchy 49
shibboleths of the Irish state including the GAA, the Irish language policy of the Abbey Theatre under Ernest Blythe, as well as the more ludicrous pronouncements concerning decency by the Catholic Church elite. As Lionel Pilkington describes, ‘the Pike marked out the theatre as possessing transgressive power vital to Ireland’s modernization. Not only was the Pike unconcerned with representing national consensus, it was also opposed to it. This was an anti-national theatre with a mission.’5 With its deliberate anti-nationalist stance and liberal cultural agenda the theatre operated as a private club to secure its freedom from state intervention. However, its first contribution to the theatre festival in 1957, Tennessee Williams’s The Rose Tattoo, attracted the opprobrium of the state that effectively was to close down the theatre given the legal expenses incurred in defending the theatre’s director, Simpson. As Pilkington records from available evidence from the files of the Office of the Attorney-General, the production was targeted even before its opening by elements within the Department of Justice and advice was sought on the viability of bringing charges of indecency against the theatre. The Gardaí (police) arrived at the theatre well into the production’s run after warnings had been issued to the theatre to drop certain unspecified objectionable passages and when Simpson refused to do so he was arrested and charged with having ‘produced for gain an indecent and profane performance’.6 Many believed at the time that the profanity was the dropping of a condom (that was actually mimed in the production) since condoms were illegal. But Williams’s play that persists in its ‘comparisons between sexual orgasm and religious ecstasy’7 was wholly in the dock and not just because of the reputed appearance of a fictional condom. The case dragged on in the courts for over a year and even ended up in the Supreme Court because the Gardaí remained silent on the matter of whose instructions they were acting on when they arrested Simpson. For many this was a watershed moment in the cultural life of the new state as the patriarchal combination of Church and state were prepared to abuse their collective powers to limit legitimate cultural expression. When the case was finally dropped, Simpson’s theatre was close to collapse. His audience subscriptions dwindled tenfold and he had to resort to a fundraising appeal to pay off his debts as he had not been awarded legal costs. The Catholic hierarchy and their political puppets in government were triumphant as the closure of a theatre was a pallocentric marker of their own supremacy, but conversely the failure of the case and the embarrassment caused by the exposure of backroom machinations in the corridors of power and the political abuse of the role of the police meant that the Gardaí were reluctant to become embroiled in theatre censorship again.
50
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
While the court case was still dragging on the Catholic authorities continued to perform their dominance and control over culture. Such was the alignment of Church and state at the time that cultural events such as An Tóstal were sanctioned by the Church in the form of an official blessing performed as a Mass. Emboldened by the closure of the Pike production the previous year, Archbishop John Charles McQuaid objected to the line-up of the 1958 Festival and refused permission for a special Votive Mass to mark the opening of the festival. The programme featured a play entitled Bloomsday which was an adaptation by Allan McClelland of James Joyce’s novel Ulysses, Sean O’Casey’s play The Drums of Father Ned, together with three of Beckett’s short plays and a reading of his radio drama All that Fall. McQuaid objected to both the Joyce and O’Casey plays (on the grounds of the blasphemous nature of their writing) and he stirred up public controversy that put enormous pressure on the An Tóstal authorities still reeling from the Pike Theatre débâcle. O’Casey would not consent to changes being made to his play and withdrew permission for it to be performed in Dublin. Three days later the An Tóstal council dropped the Ulysses adaptation and then Beckett withrew permission for his plays to be performed in protest. With all three cornerstones of the Festival now dropped the whole event had to be cancelled. The exercise of power and control by the Church was endemic in society but what was problematic for the liberal elite was that the state was so closely aligned to Church orthodoxy that cultural expression was determined by it. But in many ways the whole An Tóstal scandals of 1957 and 1958 served as a lesson to Irish theatre producers to set up shop outside of state-sanctioned structures. Brendan Smyth reinvented the festival the following year with a new name (Dublin International Theatre Festival), ditched its association with An Tóstal, moved it to the autumn, and invited Simpson and the Pike to participate. This whole experience served as a benchmark for successive generations of theatre practitioners that the role of theatre in the fabric of Irish society could well be a contestation of dominant ideologies through performance intervention, tackling patriarchal authorities of Church and state by performing outside their structures. What happened subsequently in Irish theatre can only be described as a slow sea-change, but one which led to a second revival. While the Church seemed to have held sway in Dublin, Brendan Behan was being lauded in London for his plays, The Quare Fellow and The Hostage, directed by Joan Littlewood for Theatre Workshop. The latter play was an irreverent farce on contemporary revolutionary politics and included a whole host of ‘whores and queers’ far removed from the nationalist
Performing Patriarchy 51
imaginary. Back home a new generation of playwrights emerged led by Brian Friel whose humanity and acute social conscience tackled modern Ireland’s endemic injustice on various fronts: the failure of governments to sustain a viable economy resulting in mass emigration (Philadelphia, Here I Come!, 1964), political corruption at the highest level of government (The Mundy Scheme, 1969), and the hypocrisy of society on matters of sexuality and sexual politics (The Gentle Island, 1971). While the first was a popular success in the form of social critique embedded in the internal struggle of a young man on the eve of his departure for America, the other two are much more forceful excoriating attacks on the political and moral quagmire the new Ireland had become. Friel was accompanied on this new path in writing for the stage by Tom Murphy who took much longer to be accepted as part of an emerging canon. His first play, premiered in London by Joan Littlewood in 1961, Whistle in the Dark, was a powerful examination of the self-destruction of subordinated Irish masculinities in the form of the Carney family, immigrant labourers in Coventry. It shows a violent tribal sub-culture relating to the world and to the family within by subordinating women and any masculinity conceived of as being weak. But it also clearly demonstrated how the fluidity of masculinities is socially relational and dependent on economic circumstances and social position. The historical sweep outlined in the preceding paragraphs was a performance of patriarchy that by and large kept at bay outside influences and representations that did not conform to the dominant and theocratic ideology of the state off the stage. And while the new generation of playwrights such as Friel and Murphy heralded the beginning of a new role for theatre in exposing the failure of Ireland post-colonially in a social sense, those same writers also suffered critical opprobrium for their plays that featured recognizable attacks on the state. The discourse of the critical opprobrium was realism that was used as a yardstick to measure ‘true’ representations of Ireland and the Irish people – truth, of course, being the preserve of the ideologically dominant. The extraordinary survival of the peasant myth of an idyllic ur-Ireland before colonization or resistant to colonization was one such realism that was the preserve of the first revival led by Yeats. In the latter half of the twentieth century those ‘plays peasant’ that had come under attack in their own time for being travesties of the real, were latterly being held up as examples of the real. The very fact that they belied reality made them even more convenient vessels in which to invest an imagined realism in the very beginnings of indigenous theatre. This imagined and desired ‘realism’ was nothing other than an attempt to
52
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
assert authority over cultural representation. Given that the origins of the Revival were located firmly within representations of peasantry, it was a logical step for the successors of that representation to use it as a yardstick for a cultural ideal. And this is where and how a hegemony was established, namely in the confluence of the wide dissemination of a cultural ideal with the practices of the theatrical establishment. That there was not one single woman either writing for or directing on the stage to achieve any kind of status within the theatre in the post-1958 period (until effectively the 1970s and the emergence of the Druid Theatre Company) is testament to the patriarchal practices of a whole cultural establishment. What emerged in the 1960s was a new form of masculinity that challenged and eventually gained a hegemonic position but it was just as patriarchal as what came before. But let us not forget that the position of women in society as a whole and not just in the theatre was subject to legislative censure in a series of Acts in the 1930s that kept women out of the workplace and in the home subservient to her husband: ‘any attempt by Irish women to assert their right to equality and a life outside the home was regarded as a threat to the status quo by the dominant male political élite and something which needed to be legislated against’.8 It was only in 1973 that the public service marriage bar was repealed but it would take another generation and an economic boom that effected a labour shortage before women could achieve any kind of equality both as an economic reality and in the social imaginary. It is important to keep in mind, when reviewing some of the offstage controversies, how the theatrical establishment and inheritors of a canon and a dominant ideology performed their hegemonic status as patriarchal intervention. And thus it is worth at this point reviewing the controversy surrounding the first production by Garry Hynes at the Abbey in 1991. The early 1990s really did produce a political watershed in Ireland with the election of not only a woman as President for the first time but also a committed activist for social justice, women’s rights, and indeed human rights in general. She had also been involved closely in the campaign for the decriminalization of homosexuality that won its case at the European Court of Human Rights in 1988. The extent and significance of Mary Robinson’s victory must not be underestimated since it was a humiliating defeat for the party that had dominated Irish politics since 1932, Fianna Fáil. Media reporting of her early years as President divided very much along political lines. Some were hugely critical of her dismissal of office staff inherited from previous presidents, while others vilified the then Taoiseach Charles Haughey
Performing Patriarchy 53
for attempting to limit her public appearances and international travel. But the international media interest in her held sway at home as she was quickly seen as a national asset in the creation of an international image of Ireland. And thus when Garry Hynes was appointed artistic director of the Abbey the politics of gender came to the fore as in no other moment in twentieth-century Irish theatre. It is rumoured that Hynes was embattled from the start in an institution run along state lines with inherited work practices that had no legitimacy in the modern theatre. It is even reported that at an early production meeting for her first show, The Plough and the Stars, a stage manager was reputed to have unearthed and supplied a bassinet from the original 1926 production. Hynes’s rejection of the bassinet of course could also be read as a rejection of a century’s tradition of performance in which the rose-tinted and anodyne representation of Irishness had become the dominant representational practice on the stage in response in part to the creation of a cultural ideal that could be endorsed by the political establishment. But Hynes’s response could also be read in gendered terms: rejecting a historical artefact as well as hegemonic representational practice was in turn a rejection of patriarchy. There is no doubt that the controversy was split along gender, age, and political lines, as is evidenced in the previous chapter. The critics of the production who voiced their opprobrium in the Irish Times were middle-aged men who were establishment icons of the arts world. For instance, Fergus Linehan in retrospect could be interpreted as having abused his position as Arts Editor to vilify Hynes’s first production. He held up an English production’s realism as a stick with which to beat Hynes, inferring that she had betrayed her nation. His reference to her taking on the ‘establishment’ on opening night at her peril was a clear shot across the bows that the rational realism of the dominant representational practice had to be preserved if she was to survive at the helm of the national theatre. Famously thereafter playwright Hugh Leonard weighed in with two letters that again used ‘rational realism’ as the yardstick with which to measure Hynes’s supposed failure. Looking back at the controversy that raged in the press it becomes abundantly clear that the attacks started with her representational practice, and widened to be an attack on her right to represent the nation culturally. In fact the rejection of both bassinet (tradition) and rational realism (hegemony) was constructed as an anti-patriotic rejection of nation. Linehan’s praise for Sam Mendes’s production in London clearly called into question Hynes’s national credentials. At no time did Linehan or Leonard refer to Hynes’s gender in their attacks but Linehan in particular clearly set her apart
54
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
from the establishment, and this is despite the fact that she had been running an extremely successful independent theatre company since 1975 and had garnered an international reputation, as well as being the Artistic Director of the national theatre. We can clearly get a sense from these press articles that they were inferring hers was a representational practice that no man would have put on the stage. Hynes’s production was a challenge to normative traditions of representation as well as an assault on the patriarchal performance of the theatrical establishment. Throughout its history the Abbey Theatre has rarely been out of the news and in more recent times it has been the subject of another controversy concerning financial irregularites (and an enormous deficit) that was exposed during its centenary celebrations in 2004. Subsequently another controversy is worthy of note in terms of the performance of patriarchy. It occurred in 2008 during a successful artistic period for the theatre under the directorship of Fiach Mac Conghail and involved Garry Hynes again. Hynes launched an attack on the Abbey through an interview in the Irish Times for securing the rights to several of Sean O’Casey’s Dublin plays despite the fact that Hynes and her Druid theatre company had publicly declared that they were planning to mount a major retrospective of O’Casey’s work (four Dublin plays for the 1916 centenary), and in fact had approached Mac Conghail in 2006 about the possibility of presenting the four Dublin plays as a co-production. The story emerged in an interview in the Irish Times with cultural critic Fintan O’Toole who had been her literary adviser during her own tenure as Artistic Director of the Abbey. In the interview she made an attack on the privileging of the Abbey in terms of Arts Council funding despite the growth of the internationally renowned independent sector led by herself and Lynne Parker (of Rough Magic): ‘As in any other industry, anything that encourages monopoly practices is bad for the industry as a whole.’9 Despite rebuffs from Mac Conghail of the charges of gazumping Hynes, O’Toole’s follow-up article two days later more clearly charged the Abbey with patriarchal practice: ‘The Abbey has to see itself as part of a symbiotic network of relationships in which it gains from the ideas and energies of other companies and they gain from it muscle, prestige and national standing.’10 O’Toole clearly depicted the Abbey as representing a hegemonic masculinity that performs patriarchy through its refusal to engage with a much smaller independent theatre company from the country. Of course the whole purpose and raison d’être of hegemonic masculinity is not to recognize alternative masculinites as equals but to subordinate them. In the media representation of the incident, whatever the rights and wrongs of the Abbey’s position, the wider
Performing Patriarchy 55
context of state funding of theatre provided a larger framework for the critique of the disproportionate funding of theatres run by men (Abbey and Gate) and by women (Druid and Rough Magic).
Onstage The political realities of hegemonic masculinity for the most part have been eschewed by contemporary Irish theatre in favour of performance of patriarchy configured in father–son relationships. Such has been the extent of these representations on stage that it led to critic and journalist Helen Meany famously opining: ‘I’ve seen so many father–son relationships in the Irish theatre that I think I might have had one myself.’11 The father–son relationship as metaphor for the colonial struggle in the first Revival of course was not without its problems. J. M. Synge’s representation of the phenomenon in The Playboy of the Western World (1907) features an attempted parricide while in Yeats’s Purgatory (1938) a father kills his son to prevent him succumbing to the filthy modern state that the nation had become and which fell far short of a previously constructed ideal. Yeats’s ideal Ireland was one in which a class structure of ascendancy and peasantry happily cohabit, but as Susan Shaw Sailer points out, ‘Yeats emblematized an Ireland become literally degenerate (in bloodline as well as in culture) because of the “pollution” of the state by the breakdown of class structure and the subsequent domination of the country by the Catholic peasantry and middle class.’12 Yeats was not only railing against a petit-bourgeois takeover of the country but also against a Catholic-configured modernity and thus killing the son of the play can be read as an attempt to arrest the march of the modern national. Father–son relationships permeate the stage from the second Revival onwards and form the premise of the plotlines of both Friel’s Philadelphia, Here I Come! and Murphy’s Whistle in the Dark but both embody characters who are justified dramatically and have a rationality all of their own. Further, both plays connect with the theme of emigration. Friel’s play was very much a marker for a new generation of Irish theatre in the 1960s that was hugely critical of the failure of post-colonial patriarchal society for the economic mess of the country and the failure to hold on to its youth. Murphy’s play showed the consequences of emigration on masculinity struggling to find a hegemonic status within a wider economic context that subordinated them. But later in the contemporary period something more interesting happened to the fathers as they began to dematerialize although they still haunted the stage. In Friel’s
56
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
Chekhovian play Aristocrats, first produced at the Abbey Theatre in 1979, the patriarch is District Justice O’Donnell whose life is in decline but who never appears on stage. Set in his metaphorically decaying home (in a sense continuing Yeats’s decaying Big House in Purgatory), four of O’Donnell’s five children first congregate for the wedding of the youngest but end up staying for a funeral. First though, O’Donnell materializes as patriarch in the form of his voice that is relayed through an intercom. In many senses he has been reinfantilized as the family go about their business with the help of what is ostensibly a baby alarm to keep an ear on the father. But whenever his voice booms through the tannoy, his overly sensitive son disintegrates at the sound of his voice. In the 2004 Abbey Theatre revival (directed by Ben Barnes) Peter Hanly played O’Donnell’s son Casimir as a neurotic who performed a psychological breakdown on stage and was comforted in pietà-like pose by his sisters. Casimir is prone to false memory syndrome but largely in relation to the supposed literary luminaries who were reputed to have stayed in the house now abandoned socially and materially. But his false memory was clearly a symptom of the decay of the Catholic landed gentry and also a metaphor of the lifetime of psychological abuse he suffered at the hands of his father. It is clear through the reminiscences that Casimir O’Donnell’s psychological collapse is the end result of a family line of O’Donnells whose work and social status down the generations was in terminal decline. O’Donnell’s grandfather had been Lord Chief Justice, his father a Circuit Court judge, O’Donnell himself a District Court Judge, while Casimir is a failed solicitor now reportedly working in a sausage factory in Hamburg. If it were not for the staged trauma of the abuser and abused in this performance of patriarchy one could view it as a spectacular and comic collapse of patrilinear power. Casimir represents the end of the patriarchal line completely and Friel presents the collapse as both logical and necessary conclusion to dynastic and hereditary patriarchy. One contemporary male playwright more than any other has featured patriarchy as a major dramatic component in his plays. Stuart Carolan’s first play Defenders of the Faith, first performed in the Peacock Theatre (directed by Wilson Milam) in 2004,13 is set in a farmhouse on the South Armagh border and in IRA ‘bandit country’ in 1986, and crucially before the ‘peace process’. Carolan returns to the country cottage trope of the birth of the nation to explore patriotism in an exclusively masculine environment. The house is dominated by the loud, overbearing Father who abuses his sons with countless repeated expletives and performs a Republicanism that continues the nationalist trope of feminizing the
Performing Patriarchy 57
British. For instance, in the opening scene the youngest son Danny is playing under the table with a pitchfork head and pretending he is the Second World War comic-stip British airforceman Biggles. The Father is incandescent that his son’s hero is British: ‘He’s a pilot in a book. In the name of Jaysus? A fucking Brit pilot. (Sighs.) And you’re the mother’s son right enough.’14 The mother of the family is no longer in the house as she has had a nervous breakdown and now stays in a psychiatric hospital. The removal of the mother from the family home causes chaos in the all-male environment with a pitchfork in the kitchen and a spoon being found out in the yard. The work and domestic implements are all mixed up as the generically titled Father (although his name is Joe) tries to keep the domestic order for which his wife was once responsible. The entire dialogue is peppered with Joe’s foul-mouthed assaults on his sons but the plot twists reveal that his Republicanism was nothing but a performance and that he was secretly a tout and responsible both for the death of one of his sons and ultimately for the nervous breakdown of his wife. Thomas, another son, on discovering his father’s secrets, kills his father and longs for the return of his mother while talking to his dead brother Shamey: ‘The mother will be back. Back where she belongs. And we’ll all be together again.’15 The colloquial use of the definite article is not accidental as it encapsulates a woman’s life, place, and role in relation to these unreconstructed men. The trauma of both the husband and sons is blamed on the collapse of the mother but in fact it is the collapse of patriarchy, as exemplified by the act of parricide and the eldest son Thomas’s mental collapse into monologue at the end of the play, that really is being critiqued. But without the presence of the mother on stage the spectacle is one of masculinities in performance, struggling for supremacy in the constant subordination of one by another. And while woman’s absence is lamented it is patriarchal masculinity alone that is visible, that is in crisis, and that is visibly suffering. Carolan continued his theme of the collapse of patriarchy with an even greater phallocentric spectacle of it in his next play The Empress of India, first performed by the Druid Theatre Company, directed by Garry Hynes in Galway 2006. The play’s premise is the failure of Hollywood actor Seamus Lamb who has returned to his sickbed, and possibly deathbed, a ‘depressive Irish actor with a tendency toward over-poetic rants’.16 His wife’s death nine years previously is blamed as the cause of the failure of his career and meanwhile his daughter Kate commits suicide on the London Underground in stage time. This also causes one of the sons, journalist Martin, to rail against Woman in upper case. In one climactic scene he transfers his sense of betrayal by his mother for dying
58
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
to a rage against the ur-Mother of Catholicism, the Virgin Mary, while straddling an oversized statue of the Virgin. But the play focuses largely on the Freudian collapse of the actor Seamus who is being tended by Nursey (a diminutive term he uses in order to reinfantilize himself). Seamus’s treatment of his second son Matty is a typical example of toxic masculinity performed as patriarchy. Matty has returned from a selfimposed exile in New York presumably after the death of his mother but also most likely to escape the abuse of his father. He is an albino with a suspect sexuality (played effeminately and thus quite obviously gay in the first production at Druid by Tadhg Murphy). Both of these physical signs are used as excuses for Seamus to launch a verbal attack on his son that is reminiscent in some respects of the treatment meted out to Casimir in Friel’s Aristocrats. One of the greatest ironies of the premiere production was that Seán McGinley who played Seamus sported a large mane of white hair and thus was a de facto albino himself. McGinley’s dominance of the stage (as his bedridden state is clearly arbitrary and selfishly self-imposed) was a spectacle of patriarchal power whose profane dialogue at times was a comic assault on that power, and yet simultaneously served to support it even more. The absence of women in both of these plays naturally led to spectacles of phallic masculinity that, in their worship of Woman, disavow their patriarchal status. One of the most successful plays in the contemporary period depicting a relationship between father and sons is Enda Walsh’s The Walworth Farce, directed by Mikel Murfi, that was first performed by the Druid Theatre Company in Galway in 2006 and subsequently in a re-staging the following year for the Edinburgh Festival that toured to London and New York over the course of eighteen months. Interestingly Walsh relocates his three men from their native Cork city to the Walworth Road in inner city south London. These are not the economic migrants of old, forced out of Ireland to find a job; they are fleeing from a violent past and a guilty secret of the father. The entire action takes place in a three-room flat in which their days are taken up almost exclusively by performing memories of their lives in Cork. These performances have a competitive edge as the father, Dinny (played by Denis Conway) will award a trophy to the best actor (either of his two sons Blake and Sean or himself) in their ‘performances’. The father not only performs, he controls the action from his chair as he has rewired the flat’s lighting system to a control board beside him. But at several intervals during the course of the action before each cycle of the re-enactment takes place he performs a limbering-up exercise that demonstrates his association of physical prowess with the performance
Performing Patriarchy 59
Figure 3 Denis Conway as Dinnie (seated) and Garrett Lombard as Blake in Enda Walsh’s The Walworth Farce, 2006. Photograph by Keith Pattison, courtesy of Druid Theatre Company.
of power. But that power is suspect and self-consciously performative; at several other intervals during the course of the play he stops and rubs cream onto his head, neck, and face in manic and compulsive-obsessive gestures. These gestures reveal a body in decline, a scaling of the skin, an unhealthiness that no amount of physical exercise can help. His skin condition is an outward sign of an internal psychological problem. But the cream rejuvenates him each time as he comes out of these manic moments fighting fit. These momentary signs of weakness of course could be interpreted as gaps in the spectacle of his phallocentricity that permit him after a lapse to re-emerge resplendent and his power even greater. The lapses constitute relief that permit his powerful self to be even more awe-inspiring. Mastering the moments of weakness constitutes an even greater performance of phallic prowess. The re-enactments of father and sons involve scenes from the boy’s childhood and force the sons to dress up as other family members including uncles and aunts. Some of the tales told are of the boys’ cruelty to other children and to animals, but crucially the father Dinny only plays himself. The purpose of the retelling which takes up most of their waking hours is to preserve the memory of their lives in Cork, but also crucially to misremember and to use performance as a tool to
60
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
rewrite history and to airbrush out of it the father’s violent relationship with his wife. And thus the absent wife and mother becomes enshrined in a bucolic memory of non-enactment and non-embodiment while the extraordinary feats by her male children in the multiple roles they have to play at top speed and the extraordinary skill they have to possess in order to do so, inevitably ends up as a spectacle of phallocentric power. Thus the heroine-worship of the mother turns out to be an excuse for the perpetuation of patriarchy. One of the sons, though, is permitted to go once a day to the outside world in order to buy provisions that are in fact props for the performances to be re-enacted when he returns. The day we encounter them the youngest Sean has returned from Tesco with someone else’s shopping bag and so has the wrong props for the performance. Thus much of the humour derives from Sean’s fear of the father finding out his ineptitude and also the use of the wrong props in the ensuing enactment. Crucially though, Sean’s mistake permits the appearance of another character, that of black check-out operator Hayley who restores the shopping bag to its proper owner but also reveals her daily infatuation with the strange Irish boy. Unwittingly she enters the flat and is imprisoned by the father who then forces her at first to watch and then to participate in the bizarre performance. The incongruity of the black character playing characters in an all-white Cork family drama is sinister in the extreme because of the abusive power the father Dinny has over her as well as her sons. What started out as a farce very suddenly becomes a threatening horror story. The only way out of this entrapment is to kill the father and break the cycle of the performance of entrapment. Before Dinny falls on his elder son Blake’s knife he is able to reveal precisely who these characters think they are and why they are trapped in this infernal cycle of re-enactment in an imaginary conversation with his absent wife, Maureen: ‘A day of twists and turns and ducks and dives and terrible shocks. A story to be told, no doubt, and cast in lore. For what are we, Maureen, if we’re not our stories?’17 The truth is that the sons do not have any meaningful life outside the father’s stories, and the more terrible truth is that his wife has no story to tell except the one told by her husband, and thus no real story at all. And it is perhaps her absence that tells the biggest story of them all as the performance of Dinny’s patriarchy subordinates his sons until the end and there is an inference that his wife may only be a memory in the sense that he might have killed her before fleeing from Cork. Though this is never stated, the more significant fact is the performance of patriarchal power that not only controls the present (and Dinny’s entrapment of his sons
Performing Patriarchy 61
in a flat) but also controls memories of the past: ‘the farce structure itself is Dinny’s construct, a virtual universe that he has created for his sons in order to indoctrinate them and force their submission’.18 The arrival of a woman from outside their closed world, let alone her race that does not fit the Cork story, is the catalyst for the cycle to end and the tragedy to ensue. Blake kills his father and in turn Sean kills Blake, in order to save Hayley. Sean then allows Hayley to leave the flat and there is a very long and poignant moment when Sean stares at the gap in the door. His hesitation raises expectations of his salvation but Walsh does not allow him to leave: Sean swiftly closes the door and bolts it. Such is his indoctrination by patriarchal authority that he is unable to break out of it and the closing moments of the play in dumb show is a retelling of the same story with the character of Hayley incorporated into it (he blackens his face with shoe polish) and the strains of ‘An Irish Lullaby’ relocate him in the bucolic Ireland of his childhood. This reinfantilization of masculinity is wrapped up in a musical index to the patriarchal parent who never lets his sons grow up. The arrested development of the son is also a major feature of Sebastian Barry’s 2002 play Hinterland, first performed as a co-production by Out of Joint, the Abbey Theatre, and the Royal National Theatre (London).19 In the contemporary period, this play evoked an inordinate amount of media interest given the striking similarities of some of the main characters in the play (and especially the leading male Johnny Silvester) to the figures of real-life politics. Much of the hype was generated by the theatre’s publicity machine focused on the Abbey Theatre’s production of a play so close to current affairs. That media interest also fuelled speculation that the real-life people whom the play was supposedly representing would take out an injunction against the production. The play’s central character, Johnny Silvester, is a now disgraced politician and former Taoiseach, at home outside Dublin struggling to cope with an ongoing state tribunal on his involvement in political corruption in the form of bribes and misuse of public money. At the same time he is facing the prospect of a personal battle with cancer. Out of his cupboard where he keeps state papers comes the ghost of Cornelius, his former right-hand man whom he betrayed, and into the cupboard he hurriedly has to place his former mistress who had heard over the radio he was gravely ill. In many ways this is the material of a contemporary political farce were it not for the uncanny resemblance of Silvester to the real-life disgraced former Taoiseach Charles Haughey, and nowhere is the link more tangible than in his use of Haughey’s most famous phrases: ‘I did the state some service.’ Audiences flocked to the theatre
62
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
to see what other media would not show, namely the private life of the man who had led and so vaingloriously misled the nation. What they witnessed though was no tragic hero, however much the character of Silvester attempted to portray himself as a statesman. His hubris knows no bounds: ‘We were the judges of ourselves, and anyone who wasn’t in the thick of battle, with a twopenny-halfpenny country to turn into a modern state, has no right to go back through all that and say this or that was wrong. […] I made this country, whether they like it or not. They all voted for me when they thought it was to their advantage.’20 And now the country has turned its back on him and left him to suffer. He paints for himself a picture of the tragic hero left to be disembowelled by the self-righteous new generation that he spawned, and this sense of betrayal he feels is constructed as an inter-generational conflict between a father and his sons. Meanwhile, his own flesh and blood son, Jack, appears to embody metaphorically the emasculation of the inheritors of Silvester’s patriarchy. Thirty-year-old Jack has given up his life and his place in the world of work (he was a vet), to return under the family roof and patriarchal control. He wanders about the house with a Walkman permanently attached to his ears. There are numerous references to his precarious mental state and in fact his botched suicide attempt bridges Acts One and Two. He has spent time in a psychiatric hospital and is on medication. His mother diagnoses his problem as having taken on the ills and travails of his father. Interestingly the arch-progenitor in the play (in the domestic and public sphere of political life) passes on his psychosis and not his political acumen and success narrative. For the nation that Silvester has helped to build is not one of mythic nationalist trope, but one of an Ireland globalized, as Lisa Fitzpatrick remarks: ‘In both nationalist and postcolonialist mythologizing, the masculine role has to be engaged in defence of the Motherland/bride. […] Stripped of a nation, or a coherent national identity, there is nothing to defend. Silvester leads the country into a prosperity of globalization that ironically creates his son’s crisis of identity and self-destruction.’21 The reallife Charles Haughey, of course, is celebrated as chief architect of the economic conditions that engineered the twelve-year economic boom from the mid-1990s, and so is Silvester in the play. But the entry of Ireland into modernity also comes at a price: it is the loss of nationalism and sense of self. In the play it is represented by the passing on from the father to the son of nothing but mental torture and a death-wish. The tragedy presented is that Silvester constructs himself as a hero in his political life but fails to see that his inability to manage the end of his life is uncharacteristic of the hero, and that the action of a hero is
Performing Patriarchy 63
meaningless if that hero does not have a legacy to pass on. Patriarchy, thus, is performed within the canonized national trope but here interestingly it is portrayed as a performance of failure. The spectacle of patriarch as progenitor thus ultimately collapses into toxicity as his reproduction in the form of his son is nothing but a self-subordinated masculinity on a path to self-destruction, and further, his prostate cancer takes a grip on his reproductive organs, marking the ultimate physical collapse of phallic power. In the same year that Hinterland was produced by the Abbey another play featured a patriarchal politician who murders his own offspring as a sacrifice to ‘God’ in order that his own deeds in the political sphere might retain a sanctity all of their own. Marina Carr’s play Ariel, unlike Barry’s play, did not make any attempt at approaching the verisimilitude of a well-known and real-life politician. Hers was an invention of pure fiction though set very much in the everyday realities of contemporary Ireland with huge resonances and implications for the culture of greed and selfishness that had emerged as a by-product of the economic boom. Set in her favoured Midlands topography and dialect, wealthy businessman and politician Fermoy Fitzgerald is on the brink of achieveing his ultimate goal, namely his elevation to Taoiseach (Prime Minister) after the next election. The play begins with a birthday party for his daughter Ariel who has just turned sixteen, but centre stage in the domestic scene is her father, Fermoy, who performs his patriarchy without irony and with unselfconscious hubris. Early on in the play he reveals his self-fashioned status as an alpha male on the stage of world leaders through history: ‘Dreamt last nigh I was dinin wud Alexander the Greah, Napoleon and Caesar, and we all had tiger’s feeh under the whihe linen tablecloth. Ud was brillint. And ya know thah famous portrait a Napoleon, up on hees whihe horse, the fah legs of him diggin inta the flanks, off to distriy the world? Well, I can’t stop dramin about thah picture, ony I’m the wan on the whihe horse insteada Napoleon.’22 Napoleon’s desire to conquer is read by Fermoy as a wish to destroy the world and this ‘conquer and destroy’ philosophy drives him on to sacrifice his children for the greater good of his quasi-religious project as he believes that the sacrifice of his child is the price he has to pay to justify his worldly success, and this sacrifice must be made before the ultimate worldly goal can be achieved. The play has both resonances of Old Testament thought as well as references to Greek mythology, and has been compared most closely with Euripides’s Iphigenia at Aulis. At the end of Act One Fermoy murders Ariel. He is in turn murdered by his wife, Frances, at the end of the second act which takes place ten years after Ariel’s supposedly ‘accidental’ death. The
64
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
third act is composed around the final dénouement when the youngest daughter takes revenge on her mother for the death of her father. In the context of Carr’s oeuvre this is a familiar depiction of how women struggle to ‘engage in a traumatic and vociferous resistance to stifling codes of patriarchal authority and confinement’, but with devasting costs. Melissa Sihra goes on to elucidate: ‘Carr’s tenacious refusal to romanticise the realities of patriarchal confinement in this country is powerful and opens up a dialogue that contests the systematic abjection of women of all economic backgrounds in Irish culture and history.’23 Carr’s play elevates contemporary characters to the level of Ancient Greek and biblical myth, transporting them beyond their social roles and into territories where the construction of the divine is portrayed as a patriarchal touchstone to justify its performance on a humanity that is gendered in its subjection. Fermoy’s plan for when he becomes Taoiseach is to destroy any notion of a social conscience: ‘I swear to God I’m goin to brin in a new religion, no more guilt, no more sorrow, no more good girls and good biys, just the unstoppable blood pah a the soul.’24 In many respects he is calling for a purification of politics, ridding the country of the hypocrisy of political leaders who ruthlessly pursue political pathways for their personal gain, as Barry exposed in Hinterland, while on the other professing to possess a social conscience. What Fermoy is offering Ireland is a break from patrilinearity, a natural order of the political world, espoused by his arch-opponent for the top job Hannafin: ‘You were forged in a bloodbah, Fitzgerald, and the son allas carries the father somewhere inside of him.’25 The political lineage forged in revolution is clearly exposed by Fermoy as corrupt and corrupting while he offers the survival of the fittest that is not dependent on the actions and authority of political forefathers: ‘Laineage manes natin anymore. You’re the auld generation thah’d like to kape us in our place forever. We new wans comin up judge a man for whah he is in heeself, noh where he came from.’26 And so, while performing patriarchal authority in his domestic sphere, Fermoy ultimately sacrifices that authority: by killing his child his role as pater familias is called into question. The father of the nation is the new patriarchy to which he aspires. But Carr does not leave us with the death of Fermoy at the hands of his wife as a positive outcome or an act of resistance, for like in The Oresteia, murder breeds murder and the cycle of revenge killings continues apace. One might be tempted to read revenge as the discourse of new authorities competing for control through rational killings rather than hysterical acts of rage. But Carr invites us to witness how the performance of patriarchy through acts of revenge entrap any possibilities of contestation. Younger daughter Elaine in the final act of revenge by killing her murdering
Performing Patriarchy 65
mother proclaims her new identity in her embodiment of her long dead brother James and her father Fermoy. Speaking to her mother before she kills her, Elaine screams: ‘Ya say ya prayed for a son to make up for James. Well, I am James. I’m James returned. And I’m me father that ya butchered to hees eyeballs. And I’m Ariel.’27 The act of revenge here is one which is performed beyond gender to expose how patriarchy is not the preserve of patrilinearity per se, but is a performance of dominance that transgresses binaries of gender, constructed in cycles of revenge. The cycle of representing the nation as Mother Ireland turned full circle at the turn of the millennium with the Druid and Royal Court Theatre co-production of Marina Carr’s play On Raftery’s Hill in 2000. At first glance we have an exact replica of Lady Gregory and Yeats’s Kathleen Ní Houlihan in setting and sets of characters (a rural farm, an imminent marriage, and a restless old woman). But as Melissa Sihra points out, Carr’s play almost one hundred years later overturned the myth of Yeats’s matrilinear myth of Mother Ireland: ‘The kitchen hearth, presented in Gregory’s and Yeats’s play as the feminized core, the womb of Ireland, is now irrevocably violated.’28 The hearth is the interior of Red Raftery’s farmhouse kitchen somewhere in the Midlands and thus at the very centre of the nation. The mother of the family is long dead while the grandmother wanders around the house in a delusional and reinfantilized state searching for a way out and a way back to her childhood. Red’s daughter Dinah has assumed the matriarchal position in the family while Red dominates and destroys all around him. The only other male in the family, Red’s son Ded, has retreated in selfimposed exile into the cowshed where he lives like an animal covered in manure and where his serious mental health problems can be contained in private. The youngest daughter, Sorrel, is the only bright hope in the play as she is betrothed to local boy Dara Mood and thus on the brink of escape from Red’s controlling influence. But while Red may dominate his family around the hearth, outside he has lost control. Where the farm should be a place of growth, new life, and nurture, Red’s farm is where dead animal carcasses lie rotting. Meanwhile Red ironically has an obsession with hunting wild hares that he believes are destroying his land. Grandmother Shalome describes how Red has been responsible for the destruction of the farm: ‘Far be it from me to say anything good about Old Raftery, but I will say this much. He kept his farm clean. You could eat your dinner off the yard if you were that way inclined. Now it’s just a river of slurry and rotten animals. The smell from these fields.’29 Red, though, has a completely different take on the situation on his farm and that concerns the patrilinear succession of the property as his son
66
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
Ded is incapable of inheriting the farm given his psychiatric problems, as he tells his neighbour and hunting buddy Isaac: ‘Any other father’d have him in an asylum. Not me though. Whah am I to do with the farm, Isaac? Three hundred acre a the finest land this side a the Shannon and west a the Pale. And me only son and heir can’t tell nigh from day, oak from ash. He’d milk a bull and drink it in his tay and never know the differ. And I swear I seen him talkin to the corn, kissin ud and caressin ud as if ud were a golden wench swayin in the sun.’30 But it appears no different elsewhere as Dara Mood reports of a local girl digging up the corpse of her dead child who had been fathered through incest. And things are no different in the Raftery household as the play reveals. One of the most disturbing aspects of the play that made it uncomfortable to watch in its first production was the theme of incest running throughout, and enacted at one point on the stage. The youngest daughter Sorrel is the product of an incestuous relationship between Red and his eldest daughter Dinah. Red forced his son Ded to assist at the birth in the cowshed and this was the beginning of his mental decline. Dinah, though, it appears, has come to terms with the abuse which has been going on sporadically for the past eighteen years, and she has been able to adjust and accommodate. But when Red’s attentions turn to his youngest daughter at the end of Act One, the only light at the end of this cycle of incest goes out. Angered by a conversation he eavesdropped between Sorrel and her husband-to-be Dara, and fuelled by whiskey, Red rapes his daughter on the kitchen table in full view of the audience using the metaphor of skinning a hare, sadistically using a death-threat as a warning to comply with the rape. In the first production the director, Garry Hynes, stopped the action just short of the rape itself, as is indicated in the text: ‘Now Red has her down to her slip. He pauses, looks in satisfaction at his work […] He pushes her across the table, cuts the straps of her slip. Now this is how ya gut a hare. (Stabs knife in table.) Blackout.’31 Hynes, though, stretched out the blackout for what appeared to be an inordinate length of time, but it was time forced upon the audience to reflect on what they had just watched and it was time in which she did not permit the audience to ignore the horror of the dramatic action and escape to the bar. Though no rape was staged, it was one of the most chilling moments in contemporary Irish theatre that confronted its audience with the realities of a social taboo that was being played out in abuse scandals in popular media, many of them connected with the arch-patriarch of the nation, namely the Church. The second act brought even further destruction for the family. No longer a virgin, Sorrel breaks off her engagement to Dara in a very
Performing Patriarchy 67
cruel fashion and begins to assert herself now in the house as a rival to Dinah whom we have learned is not her big sister but actually her mother. And the two rivals have now to vie for the incestuous affections of their father. Meanwhile grandmother Shalome appears in one of her night-time wanderings in Sorrel’s now stained wedding dress in a poignant metaphor of the destruction of innocence and the play ends with Red tearing off a strip of the dress to clean his gun, a final physical assertion of his patriarchal authority, configured as an abuse and act of destruction of the virgin’s dress. Far from the rape of the Old Woman’s four green fields in Gregory’s and Yeats’s Kathleen Ní Houlihan, this play does not present a metaphorical call for the young men of Ireland to overthrow and evict the oppressors. Carr presents an Irish topographical examination of the hearth and home as being violated from within, inter-generationally, that has existed for a very long time. Together with Hynes in the premiere production, audiences were forced to watch this reversal of nationalist myth-making, using the power of darkness in the blackouts to confront and disturb them, and to contest a century’s representation of the self-effeminization of Irish patriarchy, exposing its real mission of dominance and control over women and the subordination of other men. Carr’s work moved away from its Midlands setting and representations of Irishness with her play The Cordelia Dream, first performed in 2008 by the Royal Shakespeare Company at Wilton’s Music Hall in London. Nevertheless her focus on the performance of patriarchy inter-generationally within the family remained constant. Responding to the brief of writing a contemporary piece related to or inspired by the Shakespeare canon, Carr chose the relationship between Lear and his youngest daughter Cordelia as her inspiration, although her ‘daughter’ generically named Woman encapsulated also aspects of Lear’s other daughters Goneril and Regan. The play takes place in a oneroom flat inhabited by an ageing composer whose genius has deserted him, although in his mind he is conducting imaginary orchestras and completing a never-to-be-finished magnum opus. In the premiere production directed by Selina Cartmell and designed by Giles Cadle, the room appeared to be the back of a film set, the reverse of what we should be seeing with a glimpse of a more finished set off-stage. A CCTV monitor in that production was able to track the comings and goings of the outside world and help protect the generic Man from it. Only one woman ever appears and in Act One it is revealed that she is his daughter, another composer who has usurped his musical powers and genius and, according to him, has left him emasculated and
68
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
artistically impotent. Rather than a battle of the sexes, the relationship between the two unmasks the sacrifices each had made for the sake of their respective careers and how the muse has deserted both of them. Each blames the other for the desertion of their muse, as it is only possible for one of them to be in the ascendant at any one time. The success of one talent is dependent on the destruction of the other. But while the Woman (or daughter) blames her loss of potency on the overwhelming power of patriarchy (and the Man – her father’s jealousy of her talent succeeding him), the Man rails against womankind generally. When prompted by her daughter to describe men, he replies: ‘We don’t exist. We have pianos and stools. We part with semen to procreate. We are remorseful in the afternoon. At night we disappear into women. If we’re lucky. That’s men for you. Sometimes we read a book or two and have really strong opinions. We make grand statements on art, music, poetry, the state of the country, you name it, we can pronounce on anything. And what never ceases to amaze me is, people believe us – worse, take us seriously. And somehow that’s enough, that sustains us for eighty years.’32 His self-awareness late in life reveals a knowledge of how men fool the world because the world is patriarchal and has constructed the world to let itself be fooled. Like her Shakespearian forebear, Woman is aware that her fate is inextricably enmeshed with that of her father. In the second act Carr takes the relationship into new territory, allowing the Man to be released from his one-note vision of his daughter as a dog-hearted ingrate. Here we see him in a near naked state, in pyjamas, bordering on dementia, and wearing his deceased wife’s flowery straw bonnet. The realization of who the woman is who has called to see him (his daughter again) prompts a moment of incontinence. And in the first five minutes of Act Two, Carr both feminizes and infantilizes him. Meanwhile in the premiere production, director Selina Cartmell took up the notion of the masculinizing of the woman. In Carr’s text she smokes her father’s cigar, and towards the end of the play she removes his white tie and tails for his imaginary last concert, and puts them on herself. The symbiotic inter-generational enmeshing of father and daughter (and two contrasting artistic talents) visually on the stage is a very definite swapping of gender roles. But it is also revealed that the woman and the man are no longer equal as she has taken her own life by hanging nine days previously and has returned to life to ease her father’s passing into death. One could argue that the woman’s self-sacrifice is an end-result of perpetual patriarchy, but other than the woman’s words, there is nothing visually to suggest she is a revenant. Her continuing embodiment and her deliberate masculinization of it points to possibilities of talent and genius
Performing Patriarchy 69
untrammelled and defined by the boundaries of gender. The Man’s febrile descent into dementia and an infantilized state stands as counterpoint to a final image of Woman as righteous and natural heir. While Carr’s patriarchs remain on the stage they have been reduced to supporting roles grovelling at the feet of Woman begging for forgiveness for infidelity (in Woman and Scarecrow, 2007), or here in terminal decline, effeminized and infantilized, a host of other women writing for the Irish stage likewise have blazed a trail in their repositioning of patriarchy in performance: ‘Men do not delight, as we see them either at the point of collapse, or at the moment of their dematerialization.’33 In Stella Feehily’s Duck, lead female character Cat rejects her family in which her mother has masculinized herself and emasculated her husband and his role in the family, and goes on to reject the young patriarchs emerging in society, in favour of an uncharted journey with her best friend into the unknown in sisterhood.34 In Hilary Fannin’s Doldrum Bay (2003), the abusive and philandering patriarch is on his deathbed, represented only by the sound of a heart monitor, and then his ashes dispersed at sea.35 And in Ioanna Anderson’s Words of Advice for Young People,36 only the recorded voice of a dead patriarch (and celebrated children’s author) remains as an ironic counterpoint to his failure as a father to his daughter in real life. What all these performances of patriarchy set out to achieve is the disruption of mimesis, moving their action outside the country cottage and family home, setting their action often in the open spaces of beach (Doldrum Bay) and garden (Words of Advice) and permitting the performance of possibility beyond the bounds of lived reality. And what better way to contest patriarchy than to deconstruct and eventually eradicate its very materiality? The Mná na hÉireann are no longer mythical creatures conducive to the phallic erection of the hard-body male warrior of nationalist sentiment. While the women set out on uncertain journeys, again rootless but no longer embodying nation or nationalist mythology, the patriarchs in contemporary Irish theatre are performed as evanescent and ultimately immaterial.
4 Monologies and Masculinities
At the turn of the millennium a new breed of young male authors invested heavily in the monologue and monodrama forms to such an extent that it became a dominant theatrical trend. The fact that the vast majority of the characters in these plays were men calls into question how the dramatic form and the theatrical spectacle conjoin to offer a representation of masculinity that is at once abject and yet simultaneously spectacular. The need to speak alone (solus loquor) in contemporary society is the preserve of certain performing professions (law, education, politics, etc.) that have inherited their performative form from their social positioning as arbiters of society, and that possess a socially invested authority, based on knowledge. But the methodologies of medical authority in the nineteenth century, from Freud onwards, that pioneered empirical research in the analysis of speaking alone (psychoanalysis), provide a more private performance of self that is deconstructed as ‘sick’. Thus the private articulation of self becomes the prescriptive methodology for the healing and the re-entry into the public domain of the performance of self, that may or may not have the authority to speak alone. In both cases the ‘speaking alone’ is a privilege of the dominant, of authority, of the knowledgeable that subjects its subordinates to the passive role of listeners, who are not permitted to challenge the authority of the monologue, to interrupt it, or to subvert its authority. Speaking alone therefore is a professional performance of hegemonic authority. Nevertheless, in the theatre, since the 1970s onwards, feminism in its various forms has contested the authorial right of the monologist to perform a hegemonic and often patriarchal authority in the public sphere, by employing the monologue for the voiceless, the muted groups who traditionally have been at the margins of society, and who 70
Monologies and Masculinities 71
often have no social agency. Giving voice, and particularly a solo voice to the voiceless is not simply an auditory contestation; in the theatre the single image of the solo performer whose gender in so-called realist theatre from the latter half of the nineteenth century onwards is physically located around and about a masculine spectacle of embodiment, is a challenge and a confrontation. If we can only see a woman on the stage, men are visually erased, and only called up in the spectators’ imagination by the reconstruction of men’s position in relation to how the woman constructs them in her solo narrative. What, then, do we make of the extensive use of the monologue form by male writers in the contemporary Irish theatre? At first sight, of course, it would appear that this is a reassertion of authority over the use of the form and the performance of male authority on the Irish stage. To some extent this is a valid interpretation, since the economic circumstances of the period did not lend themselves to a necessary downsizing of publicly funded theatre companies to just the one actor. In another sense, however, these monologues do not feature hegemonic males performing authority. If anything, they are replete with socially subordinated male individuals who are performing their own abjection in a society in which they have lost their place. Further, the men represented form very much a muted group in themselves, confined to a nondiscursive and inverted self-loathing, whose alcohol-dependence both permits them to cope with their subordinated position, but ultimately causes their social self-destruction. And yet we have the quandary that spotlit on the stage they erase the embodiment of women on the stage, and reconstruct them according to their own narrative authority. In the dramatic world of the narrative construction of their own abjection they perform in a past tense, confessionally. But how does this confessed abjection of the drama relate to the theatrical display of the male body, speaking alone, visually and narratively unchallenged? If psychoanalysis teaches us that gender, and in this case, masculinity, is not an empirical (Freud) or archetypal ( Jung) given, but is representative of man’s emplacement in social relations (Lacan), the sociology of gender as articulated by R. W. Connell pushes us to think of gender ‘not fixed in advance of social interaction, but … constructed in interaction’.1 In his monograph Masculinities, Connell uses throughout an ethnomethodological approach to his empirical research on an array of men and their masculinities. Though prompted in conversation, Connell’s subjects invariably use the monologue form to tell their stories, most of whom are telling them for the very first time. Analysing these narratives, we see how men construct their masculinities in an interaction with
72
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
others from their past ‘characters in their narratives’ as well as with the listening researcher. This ethnomethodological approach perhaps can be used as a template for the analysis of the contemporary Irish theatrical monologue, while being mindful simultaneously of the speaker’s invariable self-awareness of his performing role and thus his own conscious construction of his place in social relations in psychoanalytic terms. And that is why preference is given to the term ‘monology’ as a direct reference to the discursive method of ethnomethodological research. Monologic discourse occurs regardless of the theatrical form, whether it be in the form of a monologue drama from a single actor speaking alone, to two or more actors speaking alone in dramas where no onstage embodiment of social relations exists, or in monodramas where actors play multiple roles in a singular narrative voice. Monologies, therefore, call into question not only the sole interlocutor, but also the narcissistic impulse of monopoly and control over the construction of narrative, as well as a more medicalized interpretation of the monologist talking to himself. The issue of contemporaneity arises in the discourses of monologies as on-stage action never happens, and it is narrativized action in the past tense by a co-present and embodied monologist whose sole narrative and singular image provide for a spectacular construction of the monologist. Throughout the following analyses of plays and performances one of the most fundamental questions that will be asked is to whom is the monologist speaking? The privilege of monology assumes an agreed passivity in the listener/spectator, provided of course that the monologist is not talking to himself. And as we shall see, by the constructed evasion of the question of the listener to the monologist, the contemporary Irish plays and performances under examination here are able to further protect the masculine voice from a real-world reaction that ought to intervene in their solo pursuits. It is no accident, therefore, that one of the principal exponents of the form, Conor McPherson, stipulated that the action of his celebrated 2003 play Port Authority is ‘set in the theatre’. Setting the play deliberately in the theatre against abstract designs removes social contexts that might situate and therefore damage the spectacle of masculine narratival authority. Real-life men in a situational limbo is very much a visual statement on power, visual authority, and the male actor’s virtuosic potential. Unhinged from reality the monologists offer a display of spectacular memory, endurance, and physical control. Spotlit, they provide the only source of ocular pleasure. And regardless of their narratives of (often) hapless characters in dysfunctional social relations, spectators have nothing else to look at but the male body. So while the male characters wallow in their self-preoccupation, their inability
Monologies and Masculinities 73
to empathize with others, and barely conscious of their low self-esteem (in fact, all the attributes of the narcissistic personality), they conversely in the theatrical world present their own to-be-looked-at-ness. This, I would conjecture, stems from an erotic impulse to be desired physically in embodiment. It also marks a need for a listener to sympathize with their narratives of their actual place in the world that denies them the authority that their embodiment before us clearly demands. The focus of this chapter will primarily rest on the monologue dramas that provide a purely masculine stage although I am mindful of the use of the form by other contemporary authors, and I will refer to them as I go along. I do so in order not simply to analyse the narratival construction of the world by male characters as symptomatic of man’s place in social relations, but also to focus on the spectacle of phallic authority by analysing the all-male stage. Although some of the monologues feature just the one male on stage, the majority offer simultaneous images of two or more men, sometimes of different ages, sometimes simply of different sizes and physical characteristics. This interplay of visually competing masculinities is important in the construction of a theatrical spectrum. However, the characters never speak to each other. Isolated from each other physically, they speak out front, to us, although it is not clear what relation they have with us other than a theatrical one. Thus the main drive of the chapter will attempt to map the relationship between the narratival construction of a masculine abjection with a performance of theatrical dominance, a relationship between the socially subordinate and mute and the spectacle of embodiment and empowerment. Although the majority of this chapter will examine what happened on the stage, towards the end I will examine a narrative performance of a key player in Irish theatre throughout the contemporary period whose memoirs replicate a theatrical symbiosis of dominance and abjection. The successful American male actors-turned-monologists such as Spalding Gray and Eric Bogosian whose solo performances ranged from confessional direct address to monodramas with multiple characters have no match in Irish theatre. The new wave comedians that emerged in the 1990s are perhaps their Irish successors, such as Tommy Tiernan, Ed Byrne, and Dara O’Briain, all of whom speak as themselves and develop a cult of the personality, while excoriating the distorted values of Irish society both amusingly and shockingly. In the theatre no such performer has played as himself. The father of modern Irish monology is Brian Friel. The first part of his 1967 play Lovers frames the central hillside conversation of two young lovers, with two narrative reports positioning the action as a flashback of memory while the on-stage
74
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
memory is just that, a memory of action. But it was in his celebrated 1979 play Faith Healer that he set the template for the wave of new writing in a similar form that was to come over a decade later. In it, Friel presents four stand-alone monologues, the first and last of which are by faith healer Francis Hardy in which he ponders over his gift, while the middle two are told by his wife Grace and manager Teddy. None of the actors appears on stage at the same time but each in turn refers to the same events, each version differing from the last, and offering audiences the theatrical game of piecing together a throughline of narrative truth. In his 1994 play, Molly Sweeney, however, three actors remain on stage throughout, all visible in a play about sight. The three characters are Molly, her husband Frank and her surgeon Mr Rice and the monologues detail from three different perspectives Molly’s journey from blindness to partial sight. Controlled by exegetic illumination in most productions, these monologues hold our interest in the points of divergence between them, in a world where meaning is unstable. Both of these forms of the monologue play, the separate display of the singular actor in succession, and the on-stage visual complementarity of all, act as templates for the more contemporary work by the new male writers. In the first form there is still a personal theatrical relationship between solo performer and an audience who has no other embodied competition in stage time to disrupt the relationship between actor and spectator/listener. In the latter form the co-presence of other actor/ characters and the divergent monologues, though dimly illuminated when not speaking in some productions, are visual reminders of how social relations determine the self. As much as Friel’s templates are useful comparisons from the point of view of form, they are not concerned with the relationship between form and the construction or manifestation of masculinities per se. Nevertheless, what emerged in the theatre in the 1990s reconfigured formally the use of monology on the stage to the point where, as Patrick Lonergan has remarked, ‘to speak of the Irish monologue as a distinctive style is problematic’.2 What did emerge was a mixture of narratival realism set against non-real and purely theatrical backdrops, as well as a highly self-conscious and unrealistic set of discourses that shifted the emphasis away from theatrical communication to dramatic invention, and shifted the centre of power away from a director’s vision of the world to a direct link between playwrightstoryteller and his actor-interpreter. The fact that all the practitioners involved were men necessarily pushes the focus of any analysis onto issues such as discourse, form, and the emplacement of self within social relations.
Monologies and Masculinities 75
The storyteller tradition in Irish culture is legendary. The seanchaí in traditional culture was an itinerant storyteller whose one-man performance would entertain privately in homes to which perhaps neighbours would be invited. It was the principal form of dissemination of myth and legend in which fact and fiction were meaningless terms and in which both the real and the magical would coalesce. In essence these performers were the purveyors of information in pre-literate culture who would wrap up their tales into the form of a fable. A seanchaí then was a ‘homo fabulator’, a creator of fables whose art was not simply the story but an art of the telling of the story. The inheritor and champion of this tradition in the contemporary theatre is Conor McPherson whose early plays were all written as monologues and whose later plays use monologue within a dialogic dramatic structure in order to create suspense, and it is a suspense which Peter Lenz describes as being created ‘not through action but through a traditional power of narrative’.3 All of McPherson’s characters have gone through some past horrific experience that they relate in stage time. That has the effect, in some instances, of atonement, and in others, a shamanic reordering of the chaos of their lives. As Scott T. Cummings relates, the narration of a fable by McPherson’s characters has multiple intentions: ‘It can be a plea for sympathy, an act of expiation, an affirmation of sanity, an effort to conquer or seduce, or a confession. In each case, a past personal ordeal is converted into a kind of present public ordeal. That is, a previous test of character, one which often reflects unfavourably on the speaker, becomes the basis for a story which, however fantastic, through the symbiosis of telling and listening redeems the speaker.’4 The theatrical storytelling then becomes a device for the therapeutic healing of his characters and their social status is crucial to an understanding of their need to speak. Many of his characters come from working-class or lower middle-class North Dublin and some have the aspirational tendencies of their partners or peers to rise to the upper middle classes thrust upon them. Some go through life unaware of their own position within it, inheriting as they go an incommunicability of their own fears, a difficulty in forming relationships, and an obvious recourse to alcohol. Indeed from what we know about their lives it is difficult to imagine them in real life ever finding a voice, or if they were to find that voice it would only be as the result of alcoholic lubrication in some pub tale of perhaps invented exploits. And therein lies the crux of the problem of masculine identity for McPherson’s working-class males in Irish society whose economic boom barely impacted on their lives. While they may all have had no fear of unemployment, the enforced drudgery of their
76
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
social status has left them searching for a meaning. And yet at the same time they long to talk, to explain, to narrate, and at the same time to show their prowess in the articulation of their tale. These are no monosyllabic men on the psychiatrist’s chair, but men who have inverted their roles in the private and public sphere, remaining silent and undemonstrative with their loved ones, and performing their stories in the very public space of a theatre. Their tales constitute their existence and it is in those tales that their social relations are called into question. Therefore narrative is a powerful form with which to contest the emasculation they have experienced socially, regardless of how fanciful they dress up their life stories into fables. The first three plays by Conor McPherson were all monologues rather than monodramas, and were all directed by himself. In his Author’s Note to the collected edition of these three plays, McPherson demonstrates a mistrust of theatricality, and a determination that theatre should empower his narrative and not reinvent it: ‘These plays are set “in a theatre”. Why mess about? The character is on stage, perfectly aware that he is talking to a group of people. […] The temptation may be to launch into a one man “performance”, to “act things out”. But such a performance will never be as interesting as one where the actor trusts the story to do the work.’5 Here he betrays his desire for control; the actor must ‘trust’ his text and not ‘act out’. The play is not set anywhere but in a theatre and thus there is no embodied fictional world than the one narrated in the plays. One could also argue that the rejection of an embodied fictionality is a rejection of realism as a form. His characters talk directly to spectators/listeners without a medium; spectators are not asked to suspend disbelief, but simply to piece together information provided by the text that is all powerful as it conveys action, setting, and psychology. And what the audience watches is the bravura skill of the actor in being able to narrate the story and speak to them as individuals in a personal experience with the actor. Patrick Lonergan makes an important and interesting suggestion as to the use of the monologue form: ‘such characters often perform in monologue because they cannot credibly be represented in naturalistic encounters with others’.6 Nevertheless McPherson’s much later play The Seafarer (2007) finds a contextual naturalism for the socially marginalized that is also able to contain monologue not as a form but as a theatrical device. However, Lonergan’s reading of the early work points out that the dramatic functioning of these texts is the disjuncture between the tale told and the telling of it. Embodying or acting out negates the fable as to act it out is to make it real. Keeping action within a fable is to allow
Monologies and Masculinities 77
the fable greater potential for myth-making and questioning of reality. However, at the end of all the plays the socially relational masculinity is represented by one or more males trapped in spotlights as symbolic of their social relations; as Lonergan points out, ‘they are “talking to themselves” because no one else is listening to them’.7 R. W. Connell’s structuralist approach to the analysis of masculinities needs considerable attention while analysing these monologue dramas as there are competing sets of masculinities, both narrated and embodied, at play here. Connell’s useful tripartite categorizations deconstruct a singular masculinity into the hegemonic, the subordinated, and the oppositional. Through his ‘life history’ approach to the analysis of his masculine subjects he allows them to articulate masculinities for themselves. In all of the plays under scrutiny in this chapter is it extremely easy to identify those categorizations at play, although the characters in the dramas are not always aware of which category they fall into and indeed some use their narratives to chart a transition from one type of masculinity to another. Similarly the male characters often contradict themselves in terms of their masculinities and occasionally, when they come close to revealing emotion, the application of a structuralist approach to them makes no sense. Structuralist analysis, while useful for understanding life histories that articulate a man’s sense of his own masculinity, invariably focuses on action, on the male as agent in social interaction. Social relations of masculinities are thus constructed through the competing impulses of masculine agencies. But what of feeling, of emotion? In other words, what about the disjuncture between what men do and what men feel about what they are doing? Although as agents men might conform to a specific type of masculinity, their emotional response to their performance in that particular identity in a structuralist analysis has little or no room to be explored.
Non-negotiable masculinities It is impossible to use Connell’s structurated approach to masculinities while analysing contemporary Irish monologue drama, and tracing a line from the hegemonic, to the subordinated through to the oppositional or protest. In fact there are very few representations of the truly hegemonic in the first place, no more so than in the work of Mark O’Rowe. His one and only all-male monologue drama, Howie the Rookie, offers a useful starting point for analysis as it is set in a masculine environment of ardently fixed identities that are not up for negotiation. First performed at the Bush Theatre London (directed by Mike Bradwell) in 1999, it subsequently
78
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
toured for several years and was revived in 2006 with the same cast, directed by Jimmy Fay at the Peacock Theatre Dublin. The play is set in the North Dublin criminal underworld and owes much to an Irishman’s reading of Hollywood crime fiction. It features two characters, the Howie Lee, and the Rookie Lee, who in two distinctly separate monologues tell of one incident in their lives from their own perspective and how it ended in various degrees of tragedy for both. The eponymous Lees are not related and apart from a shared name their characters are totally different. The Rookie is known by all, and crucially by himself, to be good looking and attractive to women and women appear to like him, while his namesake the Howie Lee has little success with women and in fact has constructed sex as a purely biological impulse. Further he makes some extremely derogatory remarks about the women in his life, such as his mother’s bad breath and worse dress sense, and about Avalanche, his hard-man friend Peaches’ sister, who is extremely overweight but is the only woman interested in him. Meanwhile the Rookie uses his hard-man masculinity less as a biological need and more instrumentally as a means to other ends that involve social relations with other men. They both have a gay friend called Ollie but they distance themselves from him and his sexuality. They may know that he is gay but they do not know what that is, simply that it is something subordinated and ‘not them’. For the Howie, Ollie’s ease with women is something of wonder but more crucially he uses Ollie to engage with the women he fancies because of his own low self-esteem with women. The Howie has a plethora of ne’er-do-well friends, although he narrates his social relations as being controlled by a series of acts of revenge for wrongs committed on them. Meanwhile, the Rookie has no friends at all and he is well aware of it,8 and this is one of the reasons why, despite his good looks and charm with women, he falls victim continually to acts of revenge from other men. Although the two men use the same stage space, they do not share it, but the Howie’s narrative depicts a set of relations between men that are constructed around assaultive violence. The Rookie Lee takes up his own version of the story but refracts the assaultive violence with the occasional moment of intimacy. In a spot of bother with the hoodlum the Ladyboy, and the brother of a woman he had sex with simply to wheedle money out of her, the Howie offers him assistance that the Rookie narratively constructs as tenderness. He is first able to help him with a cream for his scabies itch but there is something more at play: ‘Then he reaches out an’ touches me bruised eye. Gently. Gently. Not gay, like, just … And then he puts his hand once through me hair, like, that, starin’ at me
Monologies and Masculinities 79
like he’s thinkin’ ’bout somethin’ else.’9 The two Lees inhabit a world in which any sign of tenderness between men is interpreted as effeminate and therefore unmasculine. The total elimination of tenderness between men is used as an instrumental bonding device that shores up a form of masculinity that the characters in their own social milieu view as dominant, though in the social underclass, it is far from being hegemonic. And it is in this subordinated class that these young men go about their lives in opposition to society’s hegemonic drives, constantly conscious of their need to engage in acts of instrumental violence as a visible performance of their masculinity. Though powerless socially they perform their masculinity in a way that achieves for them social status. Ultimately in their narratives that performance has disastrous consequences: the Howie’s selfishness leads inadvertently to the death of his younger brother, while his selflessness in defence of his friend the Rookie leads to his own death. While O’Rowe’s two men may lack social power which leads them to a life of crime motivated to a large extent by the drives of their
Figure 4 Karl Shiels as the Howie Lee and Aidan Kelly as the Rookie Lee, Peacock Theatre, 2006. Photograph: ROS KAVANAGH PHOTOGRAPHER.
80
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
masculinity, nevertheless, if one analyses these monologues as life histories then a more complex reading of these two male characters can be achieved. The narratives do not speak about the other more successful world. Their world is exclusively insular, and thus any action that takes place within it is not at all motivated by opposition or protest against social status, as a middle-class audience might interpret it. Instead, driven by their construction of themselves in the masculine order, they perform acts of subordination continually, either of gay men, women, or of other men who have wronged them. Linguistically O’Rowe further shores up their masculine sense of self by often omitting pronouns. The disavowal of action by not using ‘I’ constructs the men’s action not as a story, but as a performance, in a past tense that is alive and in the present setting of the theatre. And writing in short snatches of description he creates a fast-action whirlwind of a set of actions that move from one to the other without intervention of a narrative sense of feeling. But once the Rookie in the second monologue begins to join forces with the Howie the narrative begins to explore sense and feeling without disparagement. Although the moment of tenderness cited above is brief and swiftly moves on to another action, it is to an action that the Rookie performs that he would not have done without the Howie, namely rubbing his body all over with cream to stop the scabies itch. The Howie’s connection with the Rookie is thus physicalized and can be read as one which is instrumentally ameliorative. The stylized and lyrical snatches of action stop for this prose-like recounting of a moment of one man’s life history in which an emotional life flickers. When the play was first performed in 1999 the two actors Karl Shiels and Aidan Kelly were close in age to the characters they were performing and their interpretation clearly followed along the lines of the machismo espoused in the text. When the two actors reprised their performances seven years later, they had grown away from what they had originally embodied and thus interestingly there opened up a disjuncture between the now much older spectacle of the male body and the narrativized action of young men engaged in assaultive violence. And while the narratives swing between past and present tenses, the past tense was pushed further back in memory by the embodiment of the now older actors thus distancing the present theatrical spectacle of masculinity from actions they were supposed to have performed in a past life. In the same way as the characters achieve a certain hegemonic status, though socially subordinated, through oppositional action, similarly the remounted production negotiated a sense of masculinity between a hard-body masculinity in the narrative, and a more distanced
Monologies and Masculinities 81
and introspective telling of the story that permitted the life history to be of men who were no longer in the same physical and emotional place of the story they were recounting. Instead the production offered a negotiated nostalgia for a remembered past that was at odds at times with the hard-body narrativized action and much closer to the emotional rather than the social relations between men.
Negotiated masculinities All of the men in the monologue plays of Conor McPherson are from the lower middle or upper working classes of North Dublin, for whom the aspiration of self-betterment is a given. A young man’s trajectory in McPherson’s world is mapped out for him from birth, namely work, marriage, and parenthood, and throughout there is an expectation of compulsory heterosexuality. In his first play, Rum and Vodka,10 the protagonist fulfils every element of the trajectory when he reveals how it all went wrong for him. In a series of confessions he reveals the slippage between an understanding of a rigidly defined masculine order in terms of his place in the domestic sphere and the workplace and his seemingly innate inability to find his place satisfactorily within that order. He begins first with his status as a married man with two young daughters, a mortgage, and a secure job. But his entry into that defined masculine order was more accidental than desired. His marriage is the result of the unexpected pregnancy of a woman with whom he was having an affair while still dating his girlfriend whom his family adored. He does not present himself as a sexual predator at all; in fact he constructs a world in which he lets things happen to him rather than him deliberately and actively pursuing goals and conquests. This self-conscious state of abjection becomes for him a modus vivendi, and even his subsequent two-year period in which he entered the masculine order of the adult world (as worker, husband, and father) he found within it a freedom. His sense of freedom though is one in which he discovers a hegemonic status of his own which allows him to contest the construction of his life by others as ‘one big sordid detail’.11 This new-found hegemonic status of the protagonist is not a mirage by any means but a negotiated masculinity. He talks proudly of his two children, and of his wife’s insatiable sexuality (to which he is more than a match). However, in the workplace he is a simple clerk, who is positioned at the bottom of the pecking order, and since the office work does not inspire him he has no desire to move up the office ranks. Ironically he is working for Dublin Corporation’s Voting Registration office which collects
82
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
data on the enfranchisement and potential empowerment of Dublin’s citizens. As an adult citizen himself he feels far from empowered. The reason for this is a growing sense of his own arrested development. Though he is proud of his achievements, further development is a mirage for him and he responds through a desire to be sixteen again.12 This desire to return to being a teenager is a desire for irresponsibility, to be allowed not to participate in the performance of masculinity in which his own position he knows will only ever be subordinated. By longing to be sixteen again he is silently wishing to contest his compulsory entry into adult masculinity. This impulse to regress drives him to alcoholism, which both restores his confidence to perform a less subordinated form of masculinity, but in reality leads him into a series of performances of protest masculinity. The ultimate act of protest comes in the workplace. In an irrational moment fuelled by post-alcohol dehydration he contests his surbordinated position, made doubly ironic because he is subordinate to an office superior he perceives as physically inferior with no fashion sense. He throws his computer out of the office window and it lands on his superior’s car. And thus he sets off on his adventure through the streets of Dublin guided by the pubs as landmarks. The journey he describes falls between further haplessness and an increasingly subordinated position within masculinity (such as when he is attacked physically in a supermarket by his wife when she discovers he has spent all his money), to an emboldened belief that the cure for his malaise is to be found in other women. Throughout this picaresque narrative journey, McPherson’s anti-hero blames others: ‘I think I’d have to say that my drinking or habitual drinking is due to the two men I work with’,13 and of a woman he meets at a late-night concert he says, ‘On the way out she squeezed my hand and smiled at me. She was curing my life.’14 At that same concert he is told of a cure for the depression into which he is sinking because of the kind of alcohol he was drinking. The combination of rum and vodka is presented to him as another ‘cure’, and it is in pursuit of this cure that he becomes emboldened in his sense of his own masculinity to construct himself as hegemonic and to subordinate others: ‘I got a rum and vodka at the bar after pushing about for ten minutes with housewifes and queers.’15 What has happened to him is a shift from negotiating a space for himself within the public sphere to becoming engaged in acts of protest against the masculine order that subordinates him and helps him construct a new masculine identity by subordinating others. He drinks away the family wage that is a prized attribute of a negotiated hegemony with lower-earning socioeconomic groups and since this family wage forms very much the structure on which gender relations exist in his domestic world, his subordination
Monologies and Masculinities 83
of women as housewives comes as no surprise. And similarly all around him are the ‘queers’, or men who do not construct women as objects of sexual desire, who are similarly subordinated in his drive to fully conflate hegemony with heterosexuality. For what we come to understand as we experience his life history is that his protest against his life stems from an awareness that to be hegemonic in any sense, negotiated or not, is to perform a masculinity that is complicit with it, regardless of whether one’s status confers any great degree of the hegemonic. And so with this perhaps subconscious awareness of his masculinity being complicit rather than hegemonic he embarks on a journey that rejects domestic patriarchy in favour of sexual adventuring, his home for the pub, and a low-expertise workplace for an alcohol-fuelled environment where his drinking prowess, social skills, and general pontifications on all subjects are revered. In the second part of the play, having met the ‘cure of his life’, Myfanwy, he is introduced to a whole new social class on Dublin’s southside. The new ‘couple’ drop by Myfanwy’s brother’s house in Ranelagh to find new clothes for him only to discover that her brother’s wealth is seemingly limitless and that he is in Pakistan writing a history textbook. Meanwhile, one of Myfanwy’s friends, Rupert, is at acting school and writing a film script. All of the people he encounters have aspirations, are in positions or aspiring to positions of both wealth, but more importantly, creativity and self-fulfilment. But McPherson’s anti-hero reads this only as a context within which he is further subordinated: ‘I knew I was as intelligent as these fuckers. But I just didn’t seem to have any opinions. I was embarrassed sitting there.’16 Having sponged off Myfanwy in an impecunious state for several days, he finally stoops to robbing her after a fight with another man and upon discovering that she has betrayed him for Rupert. And so the journey ends up back in Raheny in North Dublin where he realizes that his own story is one of many similar stories throughout the estate on which he lives. In a chip-shop he overhears another man fear the return to his wife after a night’s drinking all the while clutching his young daughter’s hand who had presumably been dragged around the pubs with him. He finally ends up silently on the floor of his daughters’ bedroom listening to them breathing in their white cotton pyjamas which brings him to his final and current state of despair: ‘I couldn’t bear it.’17 Throughout his narrative he tries to justify his actions, with his very self-conscious tales of humorous action which further reveal his emasculation in the social sphere (such as when he dresses in Myfanwy’s pink clothes to go to the pub and assuage his thirst as his own clothes are in the washing machine). Here we listen to a moment in which he
84
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
was prepared to feminize and ultimately emasculate himself to satisfy a compulsion. Notably though we only have the image of the emasculated male; not one word of mockery of the image from those who must have witnessed it makes its way into the narrative. But these are moments that construct him as hopelessly and haplessly socially subordinate, but in the telling of them and in the theatre they come across as moments of narratival triumph. Setting himself up in the narrative in a series of performances of his own abjection has a similar motivation to the tales of his sexual exploits that are far from conventional. What is interesting here is that he confronts the self-justification of his own sometimes irrational behaviour with garrulous comic tales of his own abjection that make it appear that his irrational acts are part of an overarching rational project. Thus the rationalization of the irrational through comic narration forms a process of desire for expiation. The narrative bravura could be read as an act of contrition, but it could also be seen as a further refashioning of a hegemonic masculinity in the present ‘performance’ of an abject past. The anonymous speaker in Rum and Vodka preserves his anonymity throughout and is unable to be objectified or further subjected to scrutiny. His narrative journey, though, through to self-destruction is worthy of further analysis. If we read his narrative as a ‘life history’ in the sociological sense, the construction of that history reveals a journey through masculinities that is socially relational and indeed interrelational. Following on from R. W. Connell’s concept of the hegemonic within masculinity and its practice of subordinating other masculinities through patriarchy, which sometimes leads to the subordinated ‘protesting’ against the system that produces the rules and the hierarchization, James W. Messerschmidt offers a tripartite structure of socially practised masculinity. Messerschmidt’s categories of masculinities also include the hegemonic, the subordinated, and the oppositional. Crucially the latter term differs from Connell’s idea of the ‘protesting’ masculinity as he reveals that oppositionality does not necessarily imply a call for the end to the hegemonic but embraces the hegemonic and refashions it within a different set of social relations. McPherson’s narrator thus embarks on a narrative that winds its way through all three categories. At the outset of the narrative he reveals that he comes from a stable lower middle-class family environment, that he is employed in a secure job, he is heterosexual and sexually potent. Read as the context for a life history there is nothing to suggest that his subsequent action is motivated by his environment. Crucially though he reads his own situation and relates to it in terms other than the hegemonic. His self-expressed
Monologies and Masculinities 85
hegemonic status as a potent heterosexual male leads him to multiple infidelities; his hegemonic sense of self as sexually powerful and attractive fails to relate itself socially. Further, though he is employed, his white-collar job does not permit him to physically demonstrate his hegemony and he is very much aware of and affected by his junior position within the office in which he is perpetually subordinated by his immediate superior who is described physically as far from the hegemonic (‘Farah slacks’, ‘Clarke’s shoes’, ‘completely bald’18). Throwing his computer out of the office window was the first demonstrative act of his oppositional masculinity which in fact he reads as a protest against his subordination and a display of his belief that he is hegemonic. Thus the oppositional and hegemonic masculinities within which he negotiates his social relations cohere in this one act to reject a subordinated status within the workplace. It is the turning point in his life story, for though he displayed oppositionally masculine behaviour before which he read as hegemonic (his repeated infidelity) he has committed to the girl he accidentally made pregnant and embraced the role of fatherhood. Yet his masculine status within the workplace did not match up to his role within the domestic sphere. Messerschmidt presents a rationale for McPherson’s narrator thus: ‘At times and under certain social conditions men construct “oppositional masculinities” that are in one way or another extrinsic to and represent significant breaks from hegemonic masculinity, and may actually threaten its dominance.’19 Throwing a computer out of the office window then becomes an authentic transgression that is both an expression of opposition as well as a reassertion of hegemony. Going on a drinking binge around Dublin, which takes up the remainder of his narrative, also presents further examples of his conflation of the hegemonic and the oppositional. Despite the threat of failure caused by an excessive consumption of alcohol, he narrates a continued ability to be attractive to women and to be sexually potent. He also attacks a bunch of country lads for having stolen a bottle of vodka that he himself had stolen earlier, further asserting his physical hegemony and his territory (he is from the city and they are not). But the new South Dublin and upper middle-class environment he finds himself in towards the end of his narrative, through an experience of a new set of social relations that are economically and educationally superior, also makes him aware that despite his sense of self at the start of his narrative as being hegemonic, his actual position is subordinated socially. Thus his act of violence at the party was another example of an oppositional masculine practice as an attempt to assert a rightful
86
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
hegemony in a social situation in which he finds himself a subordinate. This monologue play thus displays the complexities of masculinities and the relativity of their practice within given social situations. Oppositional protest, though violent, needs also to be read as a contestation of subordination. McPherson’s second monologue play, The Good Thief (1994),20 displays a different narrative trajectory. Again an anonymous narrator starts the monologue with a confirmation of his status as a professional oppositional masculinity, namely an enforcer for a Dublin criminal. And this oppositionality provides him with hegemonic status within the criminal underworld. It differs from Mark O’Rowe’s depictions of oppositional masculinity in Howie the Rookie as he uses a performative strategy, namely his own comic collapse into emasculation, as a counterpoint to his oppositional and would-be hard-man image. His masculine status is conflicted by having lost his girlfriend Greta to the crime boss. In order to reposition himself as hegemonic he narrates how his girlfriend is not faithful to the crime boss and that the latter has deviant sexual practices. Setting out on a paid job as enforcer he self-presents as possessing phallic power (with his guns and references to his sexual prowess with women) but his narrative abjectly presents a series of incidents that contribute to his comic collapse (despite physical damage he survives various attempts on his life and betrayals by his criminal associates). The narrative journey ends with him having left Ireland after a long stretch in prison looking back at a once oppositionally hegemonic status. One brief reference towards the end of the play interestingly reconfigures the narrator within power relations. Explaining how his prison sentence was a lot lighter than it could have been, he reveals a former life: ‘My army record was good, I’d never been arrested before.’21 Here is a man whose journey through masculinities begins with sublime status as a soldier, and whose necessarily physically embodied hegemonic status was also conferred on him by his employment status. McPherson only reveals that information near the end of the narrative, and as a distant and almost inconsequential memory. For us in this project of uncovering the practices of masculinities the placing of this information in the narrative is crucial. He had a good army record and so clearly he was not kicked out of his hegemonic status. But in civilian life he replaces the army with a job that also involves weapons and imbues him with a certain hegemonic status in the social underworld, though in wider social terms it is oppositional. Thus while we would read the narrator’s life history as a descent from the hegemonic to the oppositional, he himself sees it as a continuation of the
Monologies and Masculinities 87
one hegemonic project. Armies, though, like criminal gangs, have strict codes of hierarchy, but within the army he does not reveal any moment when he contested that hierarchy. In the criminal gang, too, he does not contest but embarks on a series of actions that help to negotiate his subordinated status (he does not challenge his crime boss for having stolen his girlfriend, and he is a paid employee without pretensions of usurping authority). And when he does embark on a series of oppositional acts of bravura against his boss, he does so accidentally and in an act of self-preservation, rather than as a rational and concerted plan to seize power. Ultimately, of course, when the crime boss catches up with him he is further subordinated, surrendered to the police and the judiciary, imprisoned, and ultimately on the run from Ireland. His narrative is in the past tense and he looks back nostalgically at a past which he constructs as hegemonic though which we read as oppositional and ultimately subordinated. The comic bravura of the present performance of the story, like that of the narrator in Rum and Vodka, acts as counterpoint to a subordinated past. McPherson’s breakthrough play, This Lime Tree Bower,22 further experimented with the monologue form, this time with three men on-stage throughout delivering their versions of the same events and characters from their own unique perspectives. All three display separate masculinities though they are conjoined by a shared gender, a shared stage, and a shared display of their storytelling powers. The action is set in a seaside town and features two brothers of a chip-shop owner, one of whom (Frank) works for his father while the other ( Joe) is eight years younger and still at school. The third member of the trio is Ray, boyfriend to the brothers’ sister Carmel. The action takes place in winter when the seaside town is bereft of day-trippers and the narration paints a picture of a town without a purpose, a metaphor perhaps for the men’s performed abjection. The chip-shop owner never appears on stage but he is depicted as a morally upright single parent struggling to cope with a family and business debt to a local councillor and bookie. Crucially the mother has died some years previously while Carmel makes rare appearances in the narrative and almost exclusively in relation to her boyfriend Ray. Joe demonstrates an emerging masculinity; he is admiring of his older brother with whom he shares a bedroom, and heroworships a good-looking boy new to the school, Demian. Carefully he positions his worship of Demian as admiration rather than attraction, and makes careful references to an emerging, though not yet realized, sexuality. Frank is extremely conscious that far from being the successful small business owner, his father is economically subordinate, and
88
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
in a literal sense is positioned as permanently indebted to the bookie who has given him a loan. The principal action of the narrative centres around him staging a robbery of the bookie, using a weapon and instrumental violence to assert his belief in a rightful hegemony. Caught up in the narrative by accident rather than design is Carmel’s boyfriend and university philosophy lecturer Ray, of a superior social class but whose life is a total abuse of his hegemonic position to the point of it actually being a contestation. He is a serial abuser of his female students, takes pride in his ability to hold down alcohol, and throws tantrums in department meetings. The nadir of his oppositional masculinity comes during the question-and-answer session after a lecture by the famous (fictional) philosopher Konigsberg. Struggling to cope with his binge drinking Ray’s long-anticipated question to attack the philosopher comes out of his mouth as projectile vomit. Comically he stages a collapse of his hegemony through oppositional display in which he revels. It is at this moment when audiences laugh at the comic tale of one hegemonic male’s comic treatment of his intellectual superior that provides us with an insight into how McPherson’s plays work on the audience through the structured action of his performing masculinities. In response to Ray’s narration of this comic effect, Frank breaks the dramaturgical vow of silence and breaks into Ray’s narrative with: ‘I never heard that.’ Ray responds: ‘I’ve been saving it.’23 Cleverly, McPherson positions their narratives, not as first-time confessions, but in a long series of performances of oppositional masculinity. Caught between the two men, one a man of oppositional action in his robbing of the bookie, and the other a performer of oppositional abjection who prides himself on his anti-hegemonic position on the inside, is Joe whose incipient masculinity ends narratively in his entry to adulthood by agreeing to spend a weekend away with these two older men and his first actual performance of heterosexuality. In effect, the three are united in their successful oppositionality to more hegemonic masculinities that oppress them: Frank robs the man who is keeping his father economically subordinate and gets away with the crime; Ray’s anti-heroic vomiting at the lecture of a famous philosopher contests hierarchization in the academy and performs publicly a refusal to accept the hierarchy; and when Joe discovers that his hero Demian is prepared to sacrifice Joe for his own protection, he constructs a masculinity all of his own. McPherson, on the surface, offers audiences the life histories of subordinated masculinities in the form of monologues whose first-person narration presents ‘the meaning of social life for those that enact it,
Monologies and Masculinities 89
revealing their experiences, practices, and social world’.24 All his characters are aware of the tensions that exist within the structuration of masculinities, and their social performances (and the dramatic thrust of their narratives) are driven by those tensions in moments of contestation of the subordinated against the hegemonic. Where the comedy arises, though, and this is particularly evident in the character of Ray in This Lime Tree Bower, is when the hegemonic male rejects his status through often accidental oppositional acts caused by a persistent abjection. Following on from Gramsci’s notion of hegemony, Victor J. Seidler, in his book Young Men and Masculinities, points out that ‘hegemony is not simply a matter of power. It is crucially a matter of the legitimation of consent.’25 McPherson’s comic anti-heroes do not enact consenting masculinities in the structural sense. They are very much aware of the various masculinities they perform in the various aspects of their lives and of how their masculine world provides them with a complex and often competing set of demands that do not necessarily conform to their imagined position within masculinity. While the narrator in Rum and Vodka could not cope with the realization of his position in the masculine order and turns to alcohol, in This Lime Tree Bower, Frank and Ray contest their position within a set of masculinities: Frank rationally turns into a man-of-action while Ray’s abject act of contestation is performed through a failure of bodily control. Crucially we need Joe in this matrix as his masculinity is constructed before our very ears and positioned between the performances of the two older men. And before our very eyes we see an on-stage spectacle of masculinities that reveal a complex set of competing demands on and desires of men whose social performance achieves expiation and celebration through theatrical embodiment.
Abjection and renegotiation Abjection as narrated though not embodied by McPherson’s monologists is a key critical strategy with which to renegotiate a masculinity by the narration of personal trauma that lives on which conflicting masculinities clash have experienced. One further play by McPherson and an autobiography by one of Ireland’s foremost theatre directors use critical solo voices for the performance of their masculine abjection. McPherson’s last staged monologue drama, Port Authority (2001),26 which I have elsewhere described as a ‘requiem for masculinity’,27 eschews the oppositional as a preferred male strategy and permits three masculinities subordinated by circumstance to seek solace, atonement,
90
Masculinities and the Contemporary Irish Theatre
and a return to an infantile state, all the while offering them their moment of embodiment and hearing. In the first production, directed by the author while he was going through his own personal crisis that landed him in hospital before the production opened, the three men of this tripartite drama were isolated in an abstract space with a tolling bell to push them into speaking, with only the play title to suggest metaphorically that these male ‘ships in the night’ were seeking the security of some port after a storm. Unlike in This Lime Tree Bower the three men do not share the same story but they do share the same North Dublin spaces (from the tough housing estate of Donnycarney to the more affluent suburb of Sutton). They also share some of the same characters and locations and have similar experiences, and at times while listening to the complementary narratives it sounds as if these are three generations of the one family. But McPherson does not permit us fully to connect them. The youngest, Kevin, has a tale of a brief interlude in his teenage life when he left home to live in the squalor of a rented flat in Donnycarney, to be exposed to a hedonistic life of drink, drugs, rock bands, and women. While his incipient sexuality lusts after and eventually finds a woman, the whole experience for him is a disaster and his experiment with his own agency leaves him unfulfilled. He returns to the bosom of his family and a girlfriend whom he does not acquire, but who acquires him. In his late-thirties, the middle-aged Dermot recounts one incident in his recent life when he was mistaken for someone else and offered an accountancy position with a firm that manages celebrities. Aware of his failings socially, academically, and bodily, his is the funniest tale of all as it relates the complete collapse of the male body. His brief moment of empowerment provides him with a desire for other women as he complains of his wife’s size embarrassing him. But once his mistaken identity is discovered he returns to his wife with an awareness of the impossibility of his ever attaining a hegemonic masculinity. And finally there is Joe, who is in a nursing home run by a religious order. His tale is of how a picture came to be in his possession. Much earlier in his life, while his wife was in hospital, his neighbour looked after him and he felt a short but intense desire for her, although he never did anything about it. On her deathbed the neighbour bequeathed him the photo of her that he had refused to take all those years ago. His tale is again of the acceptance of his lot in life, now safely in the care of Sister Pat, for whom sexuality is not an issu