Thi, public.li"n i, J<> igned lu provide accUf.Ie and 3ulhOlil.ti,.., i"f"rl11.I;o" in regard '0 ,100 ,u bject ",'Uor
Via P",.ide'" "",I
P~blish" .'
).jau"",n .\I<Maho"
f.Jiror,,,/l.lirc
Acquisition, EditDr: Sh, nnon Ik ming D<"dop"I<'" /iditpr: M""",,, p, lugo Prp,lI/c,iP" Editor: Fred Urf
I'rod"",;o" Dcs;g"",, l'amda 1I•• "liou CO",", V"igNC" R"d H,m,nd..
G 2007 Ell." K, enrry
Publ i, hed by Kdpl.n Pubh.h ing. a divi.ion of Kapl.n, Inc. ! Liberty 1'1"", 24 th 1'1 00' New York. NY 10006 All righ" r.",,,·,' J . 'Ihe I<~t "f'hi. l'ubli<;,jon, or ,ny part thereof. may no' bo reproduc
Pr in t.d in th. vnil..J Stat., "f Am .. i<,
j,,,,,, .. y 2008 !098765~J2!
Koplon I'ublishing book> or< availabl. at 'p<<:;;.1 qu. ntity discou nts to u.. fo • .,1.. p"'mo ti on.,~ mpl <>y« pr<mium., 0' oJ u,"Iio»a) purpo .... PI.,.., ,,~'iI our Sp",i,) S.l .. Department to prdcr or for m
Table of Contents yii
Introduction PART [. l aw 101
OJ
Ciassjfica!joos of the I aw
03
2. Civilliligalion ... . ...... . ... . " . ... . ... .. ..... ..... . . ... ... .... . 13 3.
Alternati~
4
FEhin an d the I aw
3S
5
HowDpBusjnessesFjtjn'
4S
Dispute Resolution . .......... .. .... . ........ . . .. . .. . 25
S5
PARI II ' Civil law j[) Oetajl
6. TheRecipeforaTort ........................................ . ... 57 7. TheRecipeforaContract
....... . . . . . . .............. 7 1
8. Contracts, Do You Always Have 10 Do What You Promised!
9. Wh at Contracts Mus! Be io Writing? 10. Wbat About Mel Third-Party Rights in Contracts . PART III - Contrac ts in Business II
Sa les Contracts and Remedies for BrN ch
.. 87
... 101 .1 11 123
125
12. Warranty Contracts and Products liability ...................... 137 13
Se(ll redTransactjoDs
lSI
VI
T" BLE OF CONTENTS
PARI IV' Trends jn Bu siness 14
E.Commerre
15. Intellectual Property 16
Global a,lS;n .. ss and International I aw
Ackn owledgements ...
165 167
.... 177 193 . . . . "' .. 205
Test You[}elf Answers
207
Glossary • .. • . , .
,233
Index
251
Abolill he Author
263
,.
Introduction s an asp iring MBA student, an cxccuth'c or professional in the work loree, o r as an even everyd ay conSUlller, yuu WIlW across 1''guJ issues aU the time. You hear abou t lawsuits all the time in the night!), news. You
A
rcaJ legal notices on product la bels. Maybe you ljIlO!" materials from scvcrdl bw)ks ill a paper pm an: wriling a paper for class, making sure not to viola\(' anyo ne's co pyright. Or you agree to cBay's teTms of agreement in orde r to become a member. You pul your old baseball ca rds up for sale, and subseque ntly ent er into an agreement with a guy in Seattle who wants to buy them. All of these situations h,lVe legal implica tions. "lhc purpose of th is hook is no! 10 make a lawyer out o f you. Whether you rea d it straight th rough or consult the sections you need for I'I'fcrence, this bo ok will instead give you the basic tools you need to help you to think clearly and logically abou t how business and lcgdl mulle rs illlcrtwine. It is also meant to aid to people who want to beco me mo re familia r with «legalese" or co mm on leg"J.1 situation s, or they simply may want a "refresher course" o n certain aspec ts of law. In fact, this book can eve n hell' YOll to beco me a hetter consumer and to keep you IIp-to.{late with the glohal and technological realities of today's marketplace . As rou read through the day -to -day, true-to -life situations I have u_~cd as examplrs, rou will rcaliT.e tha t you know a Jot mOTe 'Ihout this sulljeCl than you tho ught. Together, we will refine yo ur critical thin king abou t events and we will organize concepts to ma ke them easier to relate to and remember. I usc a lot of c"okillg analOgies to remind stu dents th at eve ryone starts wi th the basics and build, o n them . In no time, with a little prdetice, you can be applying co mmon recipes to interpret many business dealings.
,
"
Urheberre<;htlich ge5chlitltes Material
... LAW 101
Welcome to MBA Fundamentals Business Law. In Part I, we will start with the basics. When you begin cooking, you first learn your way
around the kitchen. In "Law 101 ; we' lllearn the basic divis ions of the law and the steps that a lawsuit follows. We'll also explofe some vari-
at ions on the typical litigation process by reviewing methods of alternative dispute resolu tion. We will keep our legal analysis healthy by adding ethical considerations to our ingredients. Finally, we will
see how a[1 these elements mix with the business world.
Jrhch~"
11 h
I"
Urheberre<;htlich ge5chlitltes Material
Classifications of the Law
T
he law
Involve~
the
mo~t
ancie nt of arts - storytelling. Actually. all of
life's activities invo lve storytelling-some fi cti on, some nonnction. My
car sta rts to make 11 grinding sound when I sta rt the ignition. I g o to the mechanic and he translates my story into "bad spark plugs and corrosion on
the cables: I get a terrible sore throat "nd my ('ii'S hurt.' go to the doctor and she translates my story inl0 ·strep throat, 11 septic bacterial infection 10 be treated wi th antibiotics." Practitioners of the law do the silme thing. They label th ings in their own way, but they a re just eKpressing you< story in anot her way. Don't be too intimidated by the silly terms and ancient
phrases. It Is Just storytelling. and you too can understand tho:. language and translate the ideas wit h a linle
Criminal Law Mi~demeanor
Felony Standard of Proof
pra ~t ice, patien~e,
and
~ommon
Civil Law Contracts Torts Intentional Reckless Negligen t Standard of Proof
sense.
PA~T I: LAW 101
4
IN THE REAL WORLD In June 1994, Orenthal Jam es Si mp son, a.k.a O. I. Simpson, H foo thall running h,ICk kgend, was arrested and charged with the murder of his eK"wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and a Los Angeles wailer, Rnnald Goldman, Ms. Simpson and Goldman were found brutally murd"fl'(l oulsi,\c her homl' in Brentwood, CaHrornia. 11le SWte of Ca lifornia chargl-d Simpson with two counts of fint desrce murder. Oneofthe mol"(' bizarfl' aspects of the case was that before beingarrested, Sim pso n was on the run in a famouslytcbised car chase through the .Itreets of LA , t\ jury trial ensued. High-powcfl'd lawyers were present. And, despite the endles> p re~~analysi5, the televised m urt scssio n5, th e dozens of witnesses, ,md the incriminating eM cha.>;e, Sim pso n w~. /i,und not gui lty. 11u'reafter, the families of Nico le Brown Simp son aud Ronald Goldman Simp_,,,n civilly f"r wrongfu l death. They cbime d th,11 he was T,'spon-
_~ucd
sihle (or the loss of their love d ones. A jury trial en,ued. H igh.powe red bwycfS WeT" present. An d dl'sp ile thl' fact that Simpson was found not guilty of the crime, he was found liable to the Gol d man family and ordered to pay $8.5 million in damages. lie was also found guilty of committ ing battcry on his ex,wife, although no d"m~ges were sought by th e Brown fa mily. llow ea n this b~? You ca n't be tried twice fo r the same crime_ can )'ou? If a crim in al jury fin ds you not guilty-beyond a rcasonabll' dou bt-h ow ca n a civ il jury punish yo u? And why wasn't the jig up when Simpson tried to dude the poli ce in his Ford Bronco with a wad of cash , his passport, a nd a falo;c heard?
KEY CONCEPTS 111e law is a set of ru les "hout acc"ptab le conduct. Lega l types categorize the rul es that talk ahout conduct. lhc first main categories arc crimin,\! law and civil law.
Criminal Law Criminal law regulates pub lic standards of c<mduct. Each o f m lives in a community, or more accumtcly, in layers of comm unitk.~-a city, a c" unty, a st~tc, a nation. Th ere ,He principles of co ndu ct that your comm unity h
CHAprr~ I • Cl .... SSlflCATIONS Of THE lAW
agn'lod upon,
~nd
5
oy heing a mellloer of your community, you arc heM to
those stan dards_I n my(ommunity. you must drive tlO more th an 25 miles pe r hou r in a schoo l wn .... you catillOt Icg
ycar~
old. and it is against the law to break into you r neighbor's
bouS<.' and take h is p roperty. we all agree to t hese rul es. If you violate a public st~ndard of conduct. you arc not always in big Irouhk. Sometime", a minor rule is broken, This crime is called
iL
misde-
meanor- and your in fraction c~n bc remcd ied by paying a fine or losing
a pril·il
c;J. n
goof up quite a
few l imcs and ~tilJ keep you r rights an d pri\,ikgl's, although your pockel. book may be a little lisbter. If you violate a public standa rd in a serious way- on e thJ t Cluses da m· age to property o r injury to person .• - you may have a 101 to lo~e. When you commit a seril>u~ crime. called ,1 fdony. the conSC'iu ~nces ti,r viobting the puh li c .~tambrd of "'nduct could include large fines, hig los, of privileges, and even the loss uf your freedom to be in that sodety, (ommonly rderred to as priso n ti me. Because a felony co nvictio n cu ul d polI.'n tia lly deprive a citi7.en of const itutionally guaranteed
ri Sh\.~- lire.
liberty. and
propcrty~
the Slakes arc "c ry hiSh and the law goes out of its way to get it righ t. With felony charges comes a list of protections for thc accused citizen. includ ing the r ight to co u nse l. the right to trial by jury, t he right to confro nt accuscr.~. and the r ight against >e/f-incrh.jil1a lion. Breaches of public standards of con duct arc pmse
rcprescn tat iv~- t he
U. S.
allo rncy, state's attorney, or cnunty att orneY - Jlld the public pays, via th rir taxes, for these o ffi ci al. to uphold the standards th at their commun ity has set. [f any fines or monetary damages arc due because u f vioia tio ns of con duct. they He paid in to tbe public coifers. not to individua ls who may have
been hurt . You can almost ahv"Jys ide ntify a crimina l ClS<.' by the way it is n amed. or 'Iylcd. as thcy say in thl-Ieg-d l world . The case will bc one brought by thc public against the accused. such as U.S. Peopl~
1'. Timothy MrVdgh. Slate 1'. Simpjon. v. l,a rry Fly/II, ur COmm0ll1vellltl1 v. Uzzj~ [lorden. 11le sllIndard of
6
PA~T I: LAW 101
prooj, or the d~:gree with which the ch,n-ge nee ds 10 he prove n aga inst the accused in a criminal (".lSI.', is heyDlld rl rerlsonahlc doubl, which is the high<:st sta ndard in Ih<: law. It mea ns that the accused is presumed innocent unlil the decider oj jact (t he judge or the jury) hclic ves beyond any douht that there is no other possihle explanation for what happened and who caused it. 'Ihey have to be [00 percent and IInanimou~ly convinced that the p("TSon accused did what he was accus("d of to find criminalliabi[i t)". This isa nOlhcr way in whkh the individu al is protected against unfair governnl en t act ion.
Civil Law The [aw aL~o irnpu.~e.~ pcrs"'lal n"pu"sihility on ci t ize"'~ in the com munit y. '[his is (iI·illaw. lhc area of civil law is further di vided into co ntract cases and tort ca~es. A COn/rarr has to do with a private promise between ind ividuals to do so m("th ing, such as provide a product, hui[d a ho u.~c, or (" Ilter into a marriagc. A lOr/ is a wrong you do to another person or his property. Torts arc so metim es called pen onal injuries. It is human nalure to so metimes hreak a pmmise ()T fail tu be a.~ careful as you sho uld in your deali ngs wit h others. Ex~ mpl e~ of torts could he the followi ng: l.
Joe gets druo k at a bar 00 Saturday night and inlentionally hreah his best friend's jaw oycr a comment nhout a pool shot. An intcntional injury to a citize n is quite serious. Our civil bws slrh'c to protect citizens from this type of behavior.
2. Vice President Dick Cheney accide ntally 5hoots his hUllting partner, [larry Whittington, in the face . 'this is not an intentional act, hut when so meo ne is ca reless or rccklc~' and had things happen, civil law allows the injured pUl}' tn recover. 3.
Your neighhor ta kes yo ur daughter 10 the swi mming 1'001one hot aftern""n with her children. She f;\iL~ tn keep her eye 0 11 y"ur child every moment. Yo ur child slips on the wet pool d<:ck, hits her chill, and n"luires three st itches. This is a ncgligl'n t act, bu t luckily, nul a serio us fault of your neighb or or a serious injury to rour child.
'Ihcre is no pub lic pro se~ U1or for these cases. Many of these cases arc settled wi th out recmlf.
•
CHAprr~ I • Cl .... SSlflCATIONS Of THE l AW
7
parties, ca ll ed phlinliffs, have to hire their ow n lawyers a nd file their ow n laws uit s. -Ille person s accused of violating these priva te standards arc call1'd defenda nl s an d also hir~ re p rese ntative s to help them tell their side of the .~tory. If the plaintiff win s, he cannot put a defe ndant in jail o r take away his privileges. Civil claims arc all about da mages. or mone tary amounts, to compell s,lt e the pla in tiffs for the broken promises or injuries. 'Ihc euo;c, arc bro ught in the parties' names, ware styled, for example, as Smilh v. /tmes or Doc 1'. \1' ,I1· :\1arl, o r HOlll eow"" r \'.
Bili/d~r
ur Crdil
Cllrd CO. I'. CU lloma. The slamla rd of prouf, ur degree wilh which Ihe cl aim needs to b e proven against a civil defenclan l, is a lesse r st,mdard th an tbe cr iminal
~tandard
of proof. In a civil case, the plaintiff has to prove bis
claim by a prepollderan(c oj Ihe
~vidcnu,
which mean s that more likely
Ihan nOI, Ihe defendanl causcd Ihe damages that arc claimed. It is not a unanimous standard, and a plaintiff c-an recover some damages e'-c n if th,"re arc othcr p];msible or likely cont ributing f~ctors to the ~itll ,l tion that may have c-a used sume harm . Su metim es the prcponJemnce of tbe evi de n" " standard is (a iled the 51 pe rce nt rule hl"Cau_~e all the decider of fact (j udge o r jury) needs to find is that the defenda nt is more Ihan halfway
~I
fault in Ihe situatio n. You cannot he charged Iwice for Ihe samc c rime. The U.S. ConstitUlion says so in the Fifth Ame ndment , which forbids double jeop~rd)'. But th at doesn't mean that an ,let on yo ur part ca nn ot result in a number of charges. It ~11 depends on what standards. pu hlic u r prin k, that yll u violate. If you
run a sto p 5ign, y"u co uld he ch arged with multip le public viohltio ns: fail ing to stop, ca u_,ing an accident, exceedi ng th e speed limit, perhaps even failure to wear your scat belt or driving without ,1 valid licen!'e. Aud all yu u we re doing was ge Uing a '-luact of milk from the co rn er Shire. In ad dilion, yo ur actions could have violated a private standard. to nol run into others' cars, causing perso na l an d property damage. You co uld then be sued civilly for damages by Ih e owner of Ihe car and any hurt parties. So. one action could remit in a criminal and a tort chargc- or severa l charges. Also, it cou ld result in c hJfges again,t roo fro m many levels of gove rnme nt. If you rob the local bank before going fo r the milk, you have committed both a federal and a .• tatc ainU".
J,
*
~I
h
8
PA~T I: LAW 101
THE LAW IN ACTION 0. J. Simpson was aCC\1S1:d of two hdnous crime.~-hreaches of puhlic standard" of condoct- that if>, t,lking the life of two human beings, Thc State of California, which is where the incident occu rred, brought the charges against him. The ease was styled Slare 1'. Simpson . This was a felony charge. a serious crime. with penalties upon conviction up to and indud ing the death penalty. The defe ndant was presumed innocent until pro\'en guilty. '!"he dcfendant's actions bcfo re being taken into custody were not pa rt of the record and (ould not he construed as admissions of guilt. lhe defendant was atforded all the rights reservcd to him hy the law and the U.S. Constituti on. induding the righ t \<) a sp~"Cdy trial, the right to confront his aCCllsers. and the right tn be free ofinaiminating himself. A tria l was held w!l<'o.: a jury of 12 citi1.cns heMd all the nidence. The evidence presented focused un the defendant's motives and oppu rtunitie s to commit the crime. It included forens ic and crime scene evidcnce and testimony about where the defendant was during the commission of the crime. The defendant ha d e\"Cry right to que stion the evidence presented and present alternate theories of what happcned. One alternative theory presented was that this was a mcially based case and that a det~clive in the e-.lse wished to fl"Jnte the defendant hy planting a bloody glove at thc crime scene. 'lhe ddendant di d not take the stand in his own defense, and thi s fact could not be constru~d against him bee-J use of his Fifth Anwmlment right "gainst self-incrimination. TIle matter of the pre-arrest Uigh! was never brought up to the jury. It was not relevant to the homicides. After a 133-day trial and Icss than (our hours of jury dc1iber.ltion, the defendant was found not guilty on both cou nts of murder and Simpson was free to go. Fo rever after, he would be legaUy not guilty of thesc felonious claims in the eyes of th(, law, although many bystanders (media, citi7.ens) quest ioned the vrrdicl.111CTe was no appeal. The state had iLl chance to try the "ISC and th"t was it. Fo r better or worse. Sim p'lm's crim in al case wasov~r.
But one act can be a crime (breach of J public standard of co nduct) and also a tort (breach of a personal standard of conduct). TIIC families of the victims sued Simpson in state court, in a case styled Rufo v. Simpson
CHAprr~ I • Cl .... SSlflCATION S Of THE lAW
9
(Ronald Go ldman'5 rlIolher'~ name is ShMOU Rufo). The cl;lirll here was lhat Simpson had some Involvement- SI perce nt or more- in the deaths of the vi,li ms and Ihose dealhs lefl lh e surviving loved ones wilhoullhe support, com forI, and company of Iheir fam il y members. This is ca lled a case for wrOrlgful dcarh . Here, the ev idence ce nt ered on how mu ch the victims supported and aided their familie}, how their deat h~ would result in llIore costs- to nlisc children. be wilhout (he "ssistilllce of Ihe l(wed one, etc. Economic matters were at i ~su e, not forensic fi ndings. In this trial, Ihe defendaut's failure tn testify in his ow n defense cnuld he CUllstrued aga inst him and Simpson did take tIl<.' stand to deny his invnh-elllcnt. The fac t ()flh e rleqllilhl t in Ihe crim inal trial was nol relevan l in thi.~ lrial. A jury of 12 citizens heard all the evide nce in a trial lastin g
Simpson was nnt charged twice for the same crime. He had multiple criminal charges against him, th e result of one acl of violence. He had multiple civil charge~ agai nst him, the result of the same act. The criminal trial and the ch'i! trial focused on entirely diiferent evidence, an d had enti rely dilferent judges presiding an d juries dcdding. l he poten tial co nSC' luences - Jcath or luts of mo ney- wac on «) 01 plctcly di ffe rent levels. '[he burden of proof in each case was co mpletely d itre~nt ; they d" not atfec t each ot her and une does not determine the o ut conll' of the o ther.
TEST YO URSELF In 2002, Tri-State Crematory, Inc. in Noble, Geo rgia, was in th e news. It was discovered th,1\ the business had not cremated bodies sent to them from area funeral homes. In fact. over 330 bodies were found on the 16-acre site of the business. some dating back to th e early 19905.
10
PART I: LAW 101
The ~ta te of Georg ia
ha~ law~
prohibiting the
abu~ing
of a
corp~e.law~
prohibiting individuals from making false statements on death certifl" cares. and laws prohibiting theft by deception. All l he~e criminal viola" tions aTe classified as felonies. The crema tori um had cont racts with many area funeral homes to provide the cremation services for their customers. In milny instances. the crematory de livered concrete mixing powder to gr ievin g families instead of remains, Tri-S tate was paid for their services by the famil ies of the deceased through the various funeral homes. 1.
Cou ld Tri-State be charged with a crime? Could they be charged wlth more than one crime?
2.
Who wou ld prosec ute this cri me?
3.
What could the comequences of committing such a crime be?
4.
Cou ld anyone sue Tri-Stale on a civ il cha rge? If so, who could sue and wha t would it be based on-a contract or a tort?
S.
Whilt could the comequences of civil liability be for Tri-State?
Brain Teaser 6.
Is it easier to prove the criminal case than it is to prove Ihe civil case?
Questions Future Chapters Wi ll Answer 7. 8.
Cou ld thiS be a federal case? How ca n Tr i-Sta te Crematory, Inc., which is a corporation. be put injail?
9.
Cou ld the families sue anyone other than Tr i-Sta le (or their damages?
Answers can be found on pages 207- 208.
"' "
•
CIi .... PTE~ 1 • CL.... SSIFICATIONS OF TIi E LAW
K'E tJ P,OINTS TOl REMEMB.ER . The law love~ to label thlng~.legal termi no logy categorizes ideas, just like a grocery store categorizes produce and canned goods; with a road map, legal terms make sense. The law is all about regulating conduct among peop le in a community. It does not dem(lnd the best of us, but it sets minimum st(lnd(lrds of conduct. Two big c(l tegories of th e law Me cr imi n(lilaw (lnd civill
,
"
\ \
Urheberre<;htlich ge5chlitltes Material
Civil Litigation have a n olde r b rother who, when asked to do chores as a teenager, would
I
always seem to have a comment on them for my mother. This caused
my mother to develop a feisty comeback of her own; "Mike, you could make a federa l case out of anyth ing," It wasn't until I got to law school that
I realized my mother was wrong. You (ilnnot make a federal Cilse out of anything, and in this chapter you'll learn why.
History of Civil Dispute
Sources of the Law
Resolution
Steps in a Lawsuit
Federa l COUft Cases
State Cou rt Cases of Law and Equity
IN THE REAL WORLD [n 2005. Acme Constructio n Company. located in D~\'cnport. Scntt Coun ty, Iowa, signed a contmct to do a commercial build-ou t just across Ihc Mississippi River. 'lhcy were constructi ng a new BijpII Jewciry for Jim ,HId Jerry Ballard, who were eXI)and ing from (heir sI11311 family store in C3mbridgc.
14
PARr I: LAW 101
Henry County, lIlin o'-', tn the new King Mall in Moline, Rock Island Cnunty, Illinois, which is about 20 miles away. '[he Ballards wa nted a glitzy store worthy of the big city and the new mall, complete with custom-b uilt display (;\SC~ and flashy lighting. Acme had hecn recommended by business co ntacts a nd gave an alfordable estimate and workable timetabl e. Work proceeded, an d. as is com mon, chan ge5 were mad e. 'Ihe Ball;!rds asked for morc d isp];IY areas Ihan first hid an d for s.(l me upgr;u.lcs in fi nish
materi~ls.,
like th e gt.lnite on the w~lls and Hoo r. So me of the~ change orders wac reduced to wr itin g, some were IIOt. The add itions to the co nt T'dCI look mon."t im e to comple!e, so when May I Cdme, the .~tore was not ready for the gT'dnd openi ng that was plann ed and highl)' anticipated. Aeme put ill overti me and Bijou had a sparkly, albei t span;cly ;Itlendcd. opening on Mar 8. Acme sent the final bill to the Ballards for $22.000 on May 10, having al ready received $60,000 in progress payme nts. On May 11, the Ballards told Acm e tha t dlle to the latc opening. the absence of an agreement In P;IYovertime, a nd the co~t overruns, they were not paying one more dim e. Bdtlre eithe r p;lrty run~ to th e cuurthollsc, Acme and the Ballards try tl) resolve their dispute. Acme is reluctao t to sue be<:ause this job was recomm~nded by other Acme cllstomers and word wOlild gct back to them. Plus, there is a lot "f interest in Acmc's talents br other mall stores, induding one of the hig anchor stores. [Iowever, the $22,000 balance already rellcels some concessions 10 Bijou for the job tim ing. In addition, the Ballards made the cha nges, nnt Acme. 'fhe lIallards arc nervo ll.s hec~Il'>C Ihey ha"e already e"pended th eir budget for the m'lll location and thc gTa nd open ing was lightl y auended.lhey lIl ay have I" go to the hank for s.(lmeextTd wo rking capil al all d don't wan l to look 1i101i,h ahollt their cx p,msion or tardy in thei r hill paying. Afh.'r MJ U1C initial discus_~ion , ndth'" party i~ happy. Doesl"ilherparty have a cause of act ion they could take to co urt? Where should th e laWSUit be filed?
KEY CONCEPTS GcneT'.Illy, when a person comm its a misdemCdno r, _~hc pays the tine a ll d it is over. Often, even mo re se rious crimes, like failing to stop at a light, arc resolved wilh a tine, lo ss of drh'j ng privileges, Of a course at driving schooL There i~ an ;l(ci(knt in the slo re pa rking lot. MOTe than li kely, the patt ies
CH .... PTER 2 ' CIVIL LITIGATION
\
5
willl'xchange informatioll, insur,\IlCc c"mp'lIlies will be c"lI t~ctcd, and the matter will be rcsulved through business channels. We even hea r about public prosecutors accepting nl'goti;lt cd );.Culements in serious criminal maUers.ln fact, it is estimated that 1>5 to 90 percem of criminal mutters never result in a trial and approximatcly95 perce nt of civil matte rs lieule by agn'elnent. However, wme cases arc nut settled, and if the panks feci that a pub lic or priv~te standard bus been viol~ted and the aclor must be pu nished, the reCOIlTS(' in th is country is to lake your ca use of action (case) to c"urt.
History of Civil Dispute Resolution The handling of disputes wasn't always that war- In ancient times, it was often the officials of society, frequently religious leaders, who resolved dis pu tes, many times wit h a trial by torture to test if the wrongdoer was evil or untruthful. If the acc used recovered after the tortu re. he was exoncrawd.111c American law syste m isb a..... d on the Engl ish sptem. [n medieval times, dispotcs were settled with a trial by orJelll. l he ~cc used would unde rgo some awfu l aerci.o;e involving a hot pohr o r boiling water o r po isonous poti"n_~, and ifh (, came out alive, it was determined that God was on his side and he was truthful. "Jhen often, the accuser was pun ished. Among the aristocrats, there was a more civilized way of dispute resolution, calkd trial',y combat or judicial duel. This was also an accus ato ry procedure. and the accused was duty bou nd to defend his honor by fighting to prove truthfulness. Again, God WM th,' judge. So me nobles ,,"~rc hetter fighters Ihan Hth ers, and over lime. it was ugr~cd that YOll could hire an ",/meatus (advo C'J te- usually a knight) to defend for you. This hclp ~d the survival r"te among peers, but stll! w~s not the best way to solve disputes. In the laler Midd le l\ges., tri'll by omh beC'"mc popular. In this system, the parties would need to prove their claims by collecting oaths or sworn statements supporting them from lords., p,'crs, or ot hers of high estate. The party wit h the best backup won. Ag-ain, advocates were us~d to help litiga tors through the system. bUI in this ca.... their weapons we re or~tory .• kills and knnwkdge of the law. 'Ihe accu.o;er ~n d accused could not kstify themsclws allom their own maliN, as it was assumed they woul d lie. A jury from the communit)' (of their pl"ers) IIMlally det('rmin('d the o ut C<Jme.
16
PARr I: LAW 101
The ,~ysteJl1 has continued tu evoh'e, but the basics art' recognizahle back to the Middle Ag~s, Today, if you have a dispute to settle ~nd must g" to court, you first need to decide what court to go to. There are 51 major court sy.~tems in the United States- the federal court system and 50 statc court systems. Each has its own rules about what it docs. But you cannot make a (,-dcI'd l case out of everything. You cannot take a matter about divorce 10 ,m;L11 claims courl oor (a o you take a Intlfic cit~tion to probate (ou rl. [)epending on the nature of the case, the parties involved, ,1IId the amount of money at issue, there is a rigbt CO\lrt for every dispute.
Federal Court Cases '10 get int o (cdcrdl court, yuu mu st he charged with il fedcrJ I aim" or have
an eligible civil case. In add ition, fedent l courts will hear any dispute involving the Constituti on of the United St'ltes. Interstate kidnapping and hank robbery arc crimes Ihal viola te fedentl law and go to federa l court. Cases involving civil rights or a frl~dom g uaranteed in the Bill of Rights go to fl-derJI co urt. Your fender bender usually docs not. The reason isjwlicilll economy. 'Ihe feder.!.l co urts want to take the most important C.lses they CJn and cases that ma), not be fJirly heard in other jurisdictions. To get yuur ell'il dispule in fcdeml courl, you n~cd to have a fedeml issue, a federal crime, a matter between stJtes nr between a state of the United Stute" il nd d foreign country. or a matter that qualifics for divusily jl'riWictioil. Diversity jurisdiction is how must prh'ate claimants get \u fcd~rJI ",urI. It means thaI the ph1intiffs (thuse suing) need to live in a stale dilfe ren t from the defendants (t hose being sued). Fedi'ral cou rt s figure, if yo u both li ve in 10"'a, you can go to Iowa to re so lve your dispute. But if a party lives in Cali fornia, and was hit by my car while on vacation in Iowa. it may not he fair for me to go to San Lui s Obispo o r for them to come to Davenport Iowa, and be judged by a jury of Jocals with loca l sym pathies and eth ics. In addition, ju~t so the workloud doe .• n·t set too pNty, to qualify for fedent! diva~i ty jurisdictio n the ll<1 rties mu,t hal'c alle,lst $75,000 in dispute. Once il is llccidcd that you will seck a public solution to rour dispute, you have to dec ide when: to go, 'nlat is a questi on "fjurisdiai"'I. Thl'rc ,1re 51 ma in jurisdictions aud many subjurisdictio ns wit hin the United States. If you have a fedeml matter, yo u check a map and see which federal district
•
CH .... PTER 2 ' CIVIL LITIGATION
\
7
you arc in, 'flu, country is divided into II sectimu, Of fl'der..1court d i5/rictJ, and you file your f~der~l case in the closest courthouse to wh~re you r~siJe, whe re the Jef~ndants reside, or where the accident happe ned, Often, [oct! feder~lcourt districts have oHices in your nearest fedcr~1 building, StatcsalMl ha'-e divided their court system s into districts, sometimes called circuits, to give a litigmll as local a pl,ICc as possible to conduct his trial. County scats arc olkn where state district courthou.'I(:.~or circuit courthouses arc l"cated. It is also common fo r courts to be dh'ided further by the mattcrs they hear. Your local courthouse may have a small daims division (for ddims that involve low dollar amounts ami when: litigants can argue their own cas<:s without lawyers), tralfic ,jivisions, juveoile c"urts, family courts, probate courts (for wills and estar.: matters), and district courts for everything elsc. You have to eva lu ate what you arc asking for to know which (Ourt to go to.
State Court Cases of Law and Equity Sometimes state COUfts are divided into law an d equity divisions. This is also a th rowback to medieval English legal tmditioll. The realm used to belong to the sovereign- the king. He panled estates and honors to fellow nobles.. but he could take them away. When disputes between lords and peers arose. the king was the arbiter of dispote,,," since it was all ahout him anyway. Q,-cr time, the king didn't want tn ~ I way~ hold court listenin g \0 complaints. I Ie had heller thing~ to do, So he dclegilted the dl'(:isionmaking in cuur t to his lords. The y could dedJe disputes based o n the king's direct ions- the statements he had made before_ Sometimes claim ants Cdme to cou rt an d asked for somethi ng Ihal didn't fit th e mold. They didn't want an injury paid for or a hill re~()lvcd, they wanted the coort 10 decide an issue of fairness, called cqu ;/y_They asked the court to orJer so meone to mar ry someone else o r to turn over a ~hipmcnt of "min. Thh left the lords a li ttle confused. There were no clear directions aho ut fairness anJ it wa.~n'I even certain the)' were qualified to rule on the~e que.,tions. The king set up ,1 separate court system; now the people could .'\I:ek recours<: in the law C"Url "r in eq ui ty courl, and in ~'
18
PART I: LAW 101
cou rthouse or your fl..teral cou rthou~e to lile a CJse, yo u CJn comhiue requests for legal and equitable dedsions in one fillng. An example might be in a divorce case. where there is not only a lega l ruling ending the mar· ital status, but also an c<./uitablc ruling kceping the parties from hafJssing each other at their rcspcctil"c homes. So, how do you know which court 10 go lo! You considcryour matter. Is it a federal case? If not, what state court could )'I/U go to? Thb depends on where the plaintiff !"Csides, where the defendant resides, and where the incid~nt that is th~ suhje
Sources of the l aw Since there arc 51 court systems in this country, there arc 51 different sets of laws that could he applied to YOllr case. Wherc do the courts look to decide your matter? I'irst, they look to the U.S. Constitution, which is the supreme law "fl he land. No olher bw th,11 the fcdcrJI gnvl'rnmcnl uf any stale govcrnm entp Jsse s can conllic t with the U.S. Constitution. Next, each cou rt sys tl'm looks to the laws passed by the legislature of that jurisdiction. Federal courts look at laws passed by COII!)rcss. State co urts look at state laws, often compiled into codes. such as the Iowa Code, or statute books., such as Illino is Compiled Statntes. Finally, if neither the U.S. Constitution nor fedeml or slate laws give guidance on the issue before th e COllrt, the court could loo k to the former case law, called commol1 /<111'. to decide a situation. III our country, ",<,like predictability in the law, 50 if YOll ca n find a previo ll .• ca."", with similar fa cts as ynllrs that w{'nt to co urt ,md ri.xdvcd a rutin!) frum ~ judge or a jory, Y()II c~n rdy "n th~t "utcome to predict what
•
CH .... PTER 2 • CIVIL LITIGATION
\
9
wi ll happen in your case. This is calkd a precedent . Cou rt s must oh_.erve wha t wenl before and be in conformance with it. "Ihis is also calleJ the doctrine of 5r~r~ deci5i5, which mea ns " lcllh~ previo us ruling ~t.md ." Some ,tales allow .~amc·scx unions, some stales gf"~nl libcf"~1 child support. and somc states have low lax f"Jtcs for corporations. Dcpc nJing on whal you want a court to comidcr for you, you may be able to predict a beller outcome in o ne jurisdiction over '1I10ther. If you bring your fender hclldcr case ill Kam.as, that state's lort law will apply. If you bring yo ur case in California, you may be abl~ to predict a higser award fi)r pain an d Ml lfering than in Kansas, Thest' laws th"t have to do wil h the subject m~lIerofthe ca,c arc C
Steps in a Lawsuit Whether yo u bring you r claim in federal or state court, there is a predictable step-by-step proc~ss of pursuing a lawsui t. first. you til e a complain/. someti mes called a pleading. Th is st"t:ms apprnpri'1tc since yo u arc bringing up something you are c(»np laini ng abuut and you are plea ding for help 10
20
PARr I: LAW 101
rc.~olve it. TI1C filer of a complaint is called the plainti!f or thc "eli/;oneT, since you are being pbintiv~ with the court and asking for (pelitioning for) relief. The papers you file aw served on the person you arc ')Tguing with, called the defendant (defending himself again.lt ynur charges). Snmetimes the defendant is called the respondent (because he is responding 10 your complaint and it sound~ more neut!";)l tha n to call him the defendant, which implies guilt), lhc defendant "
ecunom)'. If the defense argues that Ihe)' arc nOlliablc to the plaintiff becau~ someone clse was to bla me for the incident. that someo nc clsc may as well he there to get thi~ all worked o ut. The .• e pleading~ sent hack and forth can tak~ mon t h~ to exchange. All the claims have to he .~Iat~d and re.~p ondcd to hetween all the parties inn,lved. (f there are multip le plaintiffs and/or multiple defendants, the pleading process can be qui te co mplex. Next, there is a process of dis.:overy that takes place ],dwccn the partics. Dis(())"ery i~ the process of gathering Ihe relevant evidence to prove your case. It could include taking writte n o r oral statements and gathering witness~s, diagl"Jms, tests, expert testimony, or scil'ntilic research on the issue. Ihh 'tel' is cnstl), and time consuming, bUI it helps the parties cbrify where they (;leh stand and the veracity of the claims being made. Ma ny cases settle at snme pu inl dur ing the discuvery procc,' s hecause the parlies mo re clearly view thei r respective positions amI cut their los~.'. Interr<>s,' /oric$ (wri ll,'n 4ue~lion s ami an ....vcr~ hetwe,'n partie~) ,1I'Id dep"siti"ns (sworn statements by parties and Witnesses) arc used widely in discovery. When discovery is nearing wmplction, a trial date is usually sd, which OIn easily he t\\'o years or more from the dale the case was filed depending on the jurisdiction. At trial, the parties each gcl a chance to do their storytelling-with te~limony, exhibits, and crllM·cxami nat inn-to attempt to convince the trier of fi, et, who is a judge or a jury, of what happened. Whoever t ell~ the most bdievah!c story wins. In a civil C-dM:, if th,' plaintiff wins, she
CH .... PTER 2 • CIVIL LITIGATION
21
gets ~ judgmenl for d,unages ill an amou nt Ihal Ihe ~ou rt d('[ermi nes. If the p[a i ntifflos~s. Ih~ def~ndant just has to pay his attorney for d~fcnding him. If on.: side is unhappy wi th the res ull of the trial. it is possible. bu t not a guar,\ntccd right, to appea/the judgment to a higher court. which is a U.S. court of appeals or a state appel/ale co urt. 'Ihe appell ate court does not retry the case. '1hey do not hear Ihe witnesses ag~ i n; they do not view the exhibits. In oor syskm, the trial co urt determines the facts of a (;I.\C because the tTi,,1court sce.~ it "ll- Ihe wit nrss.cs. the rcdct ions. the cx hih i t~. 'Ihey make a fi luling offacl that stick. with the cast: f"rever. Wh .. t is appealed is a poin t of law o r a pruceduml po illl aboUl the triaL If the trial court misapp lied the law in ,[ul'slion, the appellate court may re"en;c the ruli ng. If a piece of evidence that the appelbte co urt fdt was proced ura lly necessary was not allowed in at th e Irial, the trial court ru ling co uld be changed. The facts arc never changed on appeaL So you have one shot to get it right. If ),o u can not prove O. J. Simpson guilty hcyond a reasona hlc doubl tn the jury of hi s peeTll at trial, you (annot have another chance to prow your c.. ~e_ Simpson is fi)rcVfr no t ,t murderer of Nic o[e Brown Simpson or Rooald Gold man.
THE LAW IN ACTION Despitc the fJct that fili ng a [aw5uit could ruin business relations hips, ge nerate bad pub licity, a nd cost tholl.~ands of doilars in Iq;;d rces, S22,000 h tno mu ch for Acme to los<: an d too much fo r th~ B allard.~ to pay. Either partYC<>llld!ile a law.,u it. H doesn't matt er in a civil action who is the plaintilf. It does not mean you a rc the good guy. Being til(> defendant docs nnt mean you arc the bad guy. If Acme sues the Ball ards to collect mo ney due under the construction co ntract. th e Ballards will certa inl y cnu ntenlle Acme fo r ovcn;harging without change orders an d failing to mcet the opening date. If the Bal la rds sue on the theory of breach of contract, so the contract amou nt is reduced and the cOnlrac! is considered paid in full, Acme will (atain[y countcnue for a1lthc pricey marble ,lnd the [,lhor to install it. 'Ihe lawsuit could be fil ed in SCOll County, Iowa, where Acme ",-,e.~ Illlsiness amI where the co ntrac t was entered into, or it could he filed in Henry County. Illi nois, where the Ball ards live and still operate their fi rs t
22
PART I: LAW 101
store. The bwsuit COlild also he fi led in Ro ck " land County, illinois, where the work wasdonc. Although the case could have been filcd in federal court if no mo ney was paid along the way, it cannot he filed thcre now. Th,' reljuirements for federal diversity jurisdiction arc plaintiffs having di/ferent citizensh ip from defendants (which is true here) an d more than 575.000 at issue (which is not trlle due to the progress payments). When more than one ",urt has jurisdiction ovcr a di spute, it is " Ilied CO llcurrell t juri5lhcT. When considering the choice in this case. the parties would weigh the costs of filing in each location, the timing for gelling a mailer to trial , the location of the witnesses and interested panics needing to be present at trbl, the average award amounts made on contract dispute cases in each jurisdiction, and the substanti ve klw to be applied. If Iowa h;ld rules that were more lenient on contract change order:;, Ac me would lVan t to be there. If Illino is had more contra ct ca~cs that interpreted timing in co ntract, as critical, the llullards would want to be thnc.
TEST YOURSELF Tho:. winto:.r of 2006 wa~ quite cold in Ga l e~burg, tllinoi~. The Lynch family lI~ed a portilble kerosene heater in their ba~ement to help keep warm. One Sunday
"' "
•
CH .... PTER 2 • CI VIL LITIGATION
1.
Does Mr. Lynch or Sam have a cause of acti on to pursue'
2.
Is this case based 00 a contract or a tort?
3.
Who would be the defeodaot(s) in this case ?
4.
In what state(s) could a lawsuit be soughtl
23
S. Can this case be fi led in federal court? In state court? In more than one state court?
Brain Teaser 6.
If yo u had the choke to go to federal court or state court with this case and you knew that federal juries were very cooservative 10 awarding damages in death cases but state juries in Chicago we re very libe ral, which court would you choose to file in?
Questions Future Chapters Will Answer 7.
When does the locat ion of a corporation's headquarters come into pl ay?
8.
When a case is as serious and comple:< as this one, is it mandatory to have a trial?
An swers can be found on pages 208-2 1O.
"' "
•
24
PARr I: LAW 101
the injured party is to try to work to a conclusion by agreement or negotia tion, If a matter cannot be resolved through private agreement, the injured p(lrty m(lY seek recourse in (I court of I(lw; in other words. you have a cause of action. Depending on the type of m
iIt
the law, which com{'s from
the U.S. Constitution. statutes, and past case decisions. cal led common law, When litigating. the court applies substantive laws (about what type of case you have)and procedural laws (about how to go about the court proceeding). The steps in a lawsuit take time and re sou rces-but each step makes sense and keeps the process as orderly as possible. If yO" do"', lik' yO""';,' '0"" """, yO" m,y b, ,bI, "'PP'" your case, but an appeal is not 11 new trial.
, Ii
I
Alternative Dispute Resolution
M
y husband 1elis a great story a bou t compromise. When his mOlher 11.'1 him and his younger brother have a candy bar, one son would
get to cut the candy bar into two pieces and the other son would gel 10 choose which piece he wanted. This at least appeilred to promote fairness with minimal squabbling. Everyone got a li tt le of what they wanted.
This chapter is about alternillivl.'s 10 liligation as methods of dispute resolution, or a kinder, gentler way to resolve disputes so that everyone can get a little of what they want.
Negotiation
Arbi tration
Medi
IN THE REAL WORLD 'Ihc dispute discussed in chapter 2 between Acme Construction Co, and lim and lerry Ballard is a good example of a C"JSC that may benefit from S()m~ lIlleri'l l/l ive dispute resolutio" (ADR). lhe parties arc disputing th e remaining conlmcl balance of $22.000 thH t Acml' demanded. but Ihe
26
PART I: LAW 101
B'llIards rcfuwd to pay hec4u,;c of e~till1ate overruns and delays with the store projeci in King Mall, lhe parties all' at an impasse: neither wants to throw out a figure, bulth~ difference is too great 10 walk away. In chaplI.'r 2, some complications we re di.\.Cusscd about where a lawsuit could be flied, how long it may take, and what resources it may COSI before there is any solulio n for either side. In thb ca.s.c, the parties may benefit by trying to negotiate, mediate, or arbi(l"
KEY CONCEPTS Alternative dispute resolution has been around for a lung time. It was popubr in Illcdkval EngJand hccau~e it allowed for part i e,~ to he appeas~:d lI'ilhout resorting to lhe humiliating and sometimes deadly outcomes of Irials by combat described in chapter 2. There were many inform'll pressures to compromisl', especiaUy among merchants who needed to con tinue doing busine~s with each other in small towns. Th~r~ were family pll'ssures put upon arguing p.lrties, and the pos"ihility of being shunned in your own co mmunity was a slrong deterrent 10 a susta ined argumen t. In fact, resolutions of di,put es made outside of the courtroom were so fre'lUent th~lthe p"pulace had th~ir owo word for a mediated settle ment. It was a /owdtly. I doubt that YouTube and the record industry are going to have a loveday soon, bUI there is good reason for disputing parties to Iry to avoid a prolonged court fight. Most disputes today arc set tled without trials. So me matters get settled before there ever is the need to con~ider filing a lawsuit. Some get s.:ttlcd afler a law,llI it is filed, but before the parlic,~ go so far in lo it as to havc totally prepared for trial .lIld set a (I~tc. There arc many factors that determine if a dispute will be senled OUI.• ide of (ourl or with a trial. Usually sm'lll matters thai can he ignnr,'d or disagreements invo lving small amounts of moncy jusl fade away. When a matter is too serious 10 be ignored, Ihe parties still musl weigh the time involved in po~uing a legal rem"dr, the costs, Ih,' energy that goes into a legal resolution, and the pUblicity a cou rt matter will generate. In addi ti on, when a matter goes to court, there is usually a declared winner and a declared loser. No "ne wants to 01.' a losef.
,
"
ClM PTER 3 • ALHRNATIVE OISPUH RESOLUTION
27
Negotiation The simplest and most common altunativc to J court Glse is for the parties \0 negotiate. Negoliar ion can take m.my forms, from a very informal meding over ,,,tree 10 a roundlable dis<:us.~ion wil h attorney.1 present on e.Kb .• iln
'0
Mediation Mcdill/jorl is a billllore complex than negotiation because it involves a third
pa rty- the mediator. Mediation still has to be voluntary. so both sides of the dispute must agree to try mediation, but this time, they do it in front of a maSler of ceremonies. The media/or is a neutral party prescnt tn help the sides .li.<;cuss their is.sue.." but also 10 take an active role hy sugscsting
28
PART I: LAW 101
solutio ns, compromi.~es, or hargains that may facilitate ,I se ttleme nt. The parties ca n have their attorneys wi th them at mediation, but the mediator is in charge. Often mediation will startll'i[h each side tell ing thcirMo ry to the other side and the mediator. After this, the mediator may split up the shies to the dispute and talk to one party about the ~trengths and weaknes~es of their argoment an d press them fnr their scU lemellt nlllge. lhen, that side will be escorted to Ill{' wdiling room while the mediator ~bedl5 up~ o n the other side. 111i5 h a chance fur each party ltl get a n elltr~l reac tion to their CaSe. This is different from the plaintiff's managc mem telling them what a good position they arc in or their atlorney.~ tellin g them that the case is strong; rJthcr, this may be the first "ou t sjde~ voice they have gotten, and soml"limes it is a surprise. Not ewryone sees matters as th .., IitiS-Jnts do. Not everyone gets as emotional an d incensed as the parties to a lawsuit. It is a great ICl'eler. Se.• sions may go hack .llld forth for a while, joint mectinp may be had ;lg" in; the proce.IS will go along as long as Ihe medialUr feds it is helpful. As with negntialion, lhcTl' is no requirement to reach a sctlleml'nl. But Sl'U [C· ment o r no, the process and the feedback gain~>d from the session ca n be "ery helpful to the realistic .1SM'ssment of the case at hand. Meoiators arc chnsen by the pa rties and .~hnulo be neutr,\l or inde· pendent. They may be chose n for lheir legal expertise. Many mediato rs are anorneys or retired judges. Some mediators He chosen for their knowl· "dgc in tbe field. For example, in a medical m" lpradicc cas.:, pcrbap.s a physician would serve as a mediator. In a construction casc, an engincer or architect may he tbe he~t judge of wbat is going on. There are many sources to [ocak mediators. among ttwm har associations and arbitration and mediation groups. The partic.~ to the di~pute u.~ually agree ou how to pay the mediator, whosc fees are not bas.:.-d on the outcome of the C"JSC (natumUy), but Me gcncrJ.l[y an hourly or daily mtc. "-'Iany employment contracts call for disputes 10 be mediated. as do many supplier contrJct!, conslmction mattcrs. consumer purchases, and even billing disputes. Like negotiation, mcdi;ltion (an be accomplished f,lste r than a trial. Depending on the jurisdiction inl'o[l'ed, getting a ca..... to trial could take hch"l"C1l two and five years. You cou ld agree \0 negotiate next week Of lind d
ClM PrER 3 • ALHRNATIVE OISPUH RESOLUTION
29
mediator for 10 days from now. Both negotiat ion and mcdiation ,Irc cheaper than a trial because th.-y arc less [o rmaL You do not have to develop your evidence as ~t rictly as with a courl trial. You nwy choose 10 have fewer witncs,e~ and experts 10 present to a mediator than yuu would to a judge or jury. It is a lc~s Ihreatening and forbidding setting than a court house, so parlies often arc more at case an d bettcr al telling their stories Ih an in fron t of a judge. jury, court reporter. and gallery. And like negotiation, medi
Arbitration Arbilr(1!ion is the most formal of the alternative dispule resolution formats. This process uses a neu tral third party o r. on occasion, ncutrJI third parties or panels. Arbitration is volun tary. so hoth partics must agree to resort to this technique. ArbitrJtors arc found thmugh har as.~nciations or arbitra lion and mediation groups and rellcet thc expertise needed to conside r the subject at is.\ue.lhe part i~s tu th.- dhp ut e Cdn agree 10 make the arbitrdtklll hinding. wh ich mea ns whatever result the arbitrator or arhitrators come up with will end the maUer. Binding arbilmlion means agreeing tu let the arhilrator he the judge in your ca.' e. The part ies Cd n ,I[SO agree 10 nonl>iniling arbilml j"n. But why go through the who le process and get a ~dccisio nn from the arbitrJtur if no one is bound by it? B~cau sc evcn th ough nonbinding arbitration may nu t end a case, it still gives the parties a dry run of their trial. They get feedback and a more realistic idea of the strength of their Cdse by having arbi trate d. If the parties want to hedge their bets. they can agree tn nonhinding arbi· tration and if they both like the decision, they CHn agree tu make it hinding. Because arhilrJli nn is more formal and com p[ex than mediati'lll
30
PARr I: LAW 101
nq;otiation, it can be costly. In SOll1ecase~, it is a,cos tly as going tn trial, bu t still prt'fcrred becaUSf' it is more private than a public trial and the mit's of evid~nce are more relax<.'d than in court. Today, there is wide usc of ADR
cl au~es
in con tr..lCIS. Employe rs may
require employees to mediate a work dispute, union membel":'i may have to arbitrate Ihcirwork condition. su ppliers may contractually have to mediate dispUk S with clients. and custom~r.\ may have to mediate with aU lo com panies to get Ih<,ir ~ I clllon» cars repaired. When part ies agree 10 usc ADR, they give up a constitutionally
goar~ nte<-..I
right tn seck redress of the ir
grievances in court. Th is is an important right for citizens and busim·s.o;~s. The issue has been r..lised whether contr..lcts that require ADR arc constitutional. In other words, do you have to sCitle your muller as the contract s;J.ys, or could yo u go dinxtlyto co urt and su<' o\-cr yourdbagre<'ment? The law has upheld ADR contract terms so long as the parties to the contmct arc clearly aware of these terms al the signing of the agreement. and
Alternative dispute resolution is here to stay. Its usc grows every YC;lr. n~w form .~ of negotiating sdtl~ll1ents are hdng <.leI-doped inlhe bw and
in private indu~try. One reason rorit~ l'opul;lTity is that the parties rcally have nothing to lose. lhe fact tlwt ADR has taken place, and any olfers of se ttlement that we rc made in an ADR ll,,&o tiation. are not admissible if the mailer eventually goes 10 trial. It is a way for panks to a dispute to get on with what they do best- running their busi nesses mther than being mired in a lawsuit with aU its expenditures of money, time, and ~nergy. It is also a way for the panics 10 he pan oftbe ",olulion to the proh lem. [f lhe coun dderrninc., Ihe facts of the case, those arc the facL' forever aftcr: the re isa win neran<.l a loser. A DR is a way to resolve d isputes",J every\>Ile gcts a little of what they want.
THE LAW IN ACTION Could Acme Constnt<::tion resolw the $22,000 issue with the Ballards without go ing to trial ? Sure they could, bUI they may need some hdp. Before this case would even be filed, the panics wou ld probably try to ncgoti atc a sett l~m~nt through their attorneys. r.,·rayhc they arc so emotional and scarcd right nol\" that this will go nuw here. Ndtherparty milyhe willing to star t the hidding.
,
"
ClM PTER 3 • ALHRNATIVE OISPUH RESOLUTION
31
Perhap, agreeing "" a neutrallhird parly c"uld be su((es,ful. A mediator in the construction indostry might be able \0 evaluate th~ reasonableness of the ov~rtime and materi;II costs as well as the degree uf difficulty the change orders added to the job. An outside commercial attorney or retired judge may evaluate the strength of the kgal arguments to persuade Ihe parties \0 come to a &culemen\. Mediation could occu r relatively quickly, or after some of the discovery has taken place. Witnesses including the BalJards and Ihe construction ~upervisor and crew could appear in a cdsual setting and give their information informally. The mediator could :15k them direct questions tu gd aU the details that arc important. The mediator could «lean unn each side 10 make so me compromises in amounts, but also on equitable or fairness questions. Perhaps the Ballards could have 90 days to pay the balance due giving them a period of time \0 see how popular the new store becomes; perhaps they could have the remaining marble not used on th e job. A me diator familiar with the complicatinlls of change orders co uld explain to the Bal1"rds that Ihdr c~tr~ cabinets and upgrades could not re~sunabl)' have been done "n thl" _'ame timetahle. Maybe th,l\ mediator c"uld impress upon Acme that they were in a superior position \0 know there would be a timing probll'm and should ha"e explained this better 10 the cuslomcr. By chance, there could be _"ome punch list items left to complete and the Ballards might be worried that Acme won't complete them unless the entire bi ll is paid. With mediation, each party could express what is really important to them, establish what their settlement rJnge is.. and gct a little something they want. 'Ihere wnuld be no winner or loser. But mayhe each party is en trenched in their posi tion. The matter may he at a stakmate- $22,OOO on une side and not a dime on t hrother. Binding arbi trJtion could Sl'UIe the mailer more quickly and cheaply than a trial. Each side would have input imo the sekction of the arbitrJtor or arbitT'dtors, unlike in a trial, where you take the judge you gct or work with \he jury pool you have. Arbi tration would he less public. Thc Ballards don't want the main chapter in their expansion history to be about a bill disp ute. ,\cme wants to do more business in the mall. They both want to get on wi th what they do best- construction and sales. Mnch like a judge, all arbitrator could weigh the matter and present a workou t. which is what in circe!
32
PARr I: LAW 101
the ,ourt wou ld do at trial. The arilitrJtor lIlight t'lke ~"Iuli()n suggestions from bOlh sides so the parties could [ive with the OU lcome, Again, there wouiJ be no winner or loser.
TEST YOURSELF Dog'~ Be~t
Friend Co, i~ a manufacturer of dog food that i5 ~old to three
leading dog food companies fo r distribut io n under the ir own labels. Las t month, a shipment o f ingredients from the Far East conta ined a contam inant Ihat wa~ mixed in to canned dog food distributed in 10 states, Before the contamination was discovered, 22 dogs in eight states fe ll serio usly ill with kidney fai lure. Fifteen dogs died. The manu facturer immediately issued a reca ll of all cans distributed, but more ca~es
of ailing dogs are being reported eac h day.
Review Questions 1.
Do the pel owners have a cause of action (case) against Ih e manufac turer of the dog foodlls it based on a contract or a torll
2.
Dog's Besl Friend Co. is located in California, but all the co ntamin a led food was delivered to Midwest a nd southern states. Since no contaminated food got to consumers in Ca lifornia, the company feels it is safe from any lawsu its. Do you ag ree ?
3.
In the worst case scenario. Dog's Best Friend pres iden t, Mr. Hound, fee ls the company might have to reimburse customers for the cos t of the bad dog food. Is Mr. Hound correct?
Test Yourself on Th is Chapter 4.
list three reasons why Dog's Best Friend should consider using ADR to resolve daims about contaminated dog food.
S.
What kind of experience should a mediator in this
ca~e
h'lYel Whyl
"' "
•
ClMP TER 3 • ALH RNATIVE OI SPUH RESOLUTIO N
33
Brain Teaser 6.
What could be some creative and equitilb le points to indude in a negotia ted settlement that wou ld make the manufilcturer look better and the victims feel better?
Question Future Chapters Wi ll Answer 7.
Is n't there a law that products shou ld be fit for their purpose? Where WilS the FDA?
Answers can be found on p
Alternative dispute resolution (ADR ), which is growing in popu· larity, is used to resolve business and perlOnal litigation matters quickly, cheaply, informally, and more privately than litigation. Alternative dispute resolution options indude negotiiltion, mediil ' tion, and ilrbitration. In business, there is a big advantage to resolving disputes at the cheapest, quickest level a nd getting on with what you do bestmore business. ADR allows the parties, rather than a judge or jury, to dedd e what is most impOrtant to them , and it allows for more equitab le and ethical considerations in outcomes. Negotiation allows the pa rt ies to get together, either personally Or with iln advocilte, to discuss the issues involved and \0 work out the dispute. Mediation uses a third p
,
"
34
PAR T I: LAW 101
Arbitration
i~
the
u~e
of a third party or parties that co nsider pre~·
entations from each side and make a determina tion on how the issues should be resolved. Arbitr ation can be binding or nonbinding on the part ies to the dispute. Even if ADR fails to conclude a dispute, the process g l ~es the parties a more realistic idea of their argumen ts and poss ible outcomes. The fact that ADR has taken place, and any offers of senlement milde d uring ilny ADR, ilre no t ildm issible pieces of informiltion at trial if the pilrties fail to reach 11 neg ot iated reso lution of the case.
,
"
Ethics and the Law rhies is the study of right behavior or how people should act. In
E
Victorian times, it was unheard of for a si ngle lady to be in a man's
presence unchaperoned. If she found he rse lf in that situation, her re putation was ruined. In Victorian t imes, many a gentleman engaged in buying and selling human beings as slaves. If he found himself In that business, his
rep ut"tion was made. Tim es change and ethics change. Even in the same time frame, in the same cultu re, eth ics collide. In this chapter, we will d iscuss the relationship
between what is legal and w hat is eth ical. As we discussed earlier, th e law
does not require perfect behavior. In 'e"lily, it sets minimal standa rds of conduct. Ethics, o n the other hand, is about goodness and ideals. A legal act. such as choosing not to recycle. could well be wrong conduct acco rding to your conscience. But an ethica l act for you, such as compmti ng all your garbage in your backyard, which is in city limits, could be illegal. In th is chapter, we will diSCUSS some of the Influences on legal and ethical decision-making. We wi ll also d iscuss how your business decis ions involvin g ethics can ruin or make your reputation.
Jrhch~"
tl h
I"
36
PARr I: LAW 101
v.[jlj AT'S I A ~E A D Businesses
Stakeholders to Consid er
Theo ries of Ethical
If it's legal, is it eth ica l? If it's
Behavior
ethical, is it legal?
Businesses and Ethics
IN TH E REA L WO RLD In 195 1, a D.wcnport, Iowa, art ist started a small .sculpture !lusines.<. lsa hel Bluum had .\ tudied art wi lh Grant Wo od at the Siolle Ci ty Art Colony
in th e 1930s. I ler style WaS thoroughly America n, realistic, and ti ed to tire heartland. Her .~( ulptures ,,'ere made from Mi~sis~ipl'i River day and (UIl· cre te, lovi n81y Irand -fin isllt.'d in tire sh ape of nl bb its, owls, hedSe!I011s, a nd roly.poly childr,'n, then finished wi th a greenish hand.rubbing and signed by the artist. The sillall business was a local fixtuI"C fo r rears and a source of auth entic prairie gifts for travelers and natives. 'lire .scnll'tures were modemtely priced and therefore popular birthday, grd dnat io n, wedding, and anniversary presents. As Isabel ,'nkred Iwr rightics, shl' .<01.1 th.., bnsincs.", Isabel Bloo m, 1.1.1., to three local hosinesslll~n. TIle y co ntino ed to r un th~ " peration from ils Vill age of East Davenl' ort location (wcr loukins the river; but they also expanded produ ction and sta rted distributing the sculptrrl"l's to Midwestern gift Slores, induding stores in Chicago snb urbs. Sales grew. l he handma de techniques continued until early 2006, when the owners an · nounced that the production of Isabel llioom statues would be mOI'ed to Chi na. The move would mean lower p rod uction costs and !letter distribution
pos~ibilitics
in the United States. l he move wo uld a lso mean the luss
of 50 johs in Davenport and no mor.: hand-finishing ur Mississippi River cl~y. lhe items wou ld st ill be signed ISAIIU BlOOM on the bottom. It w~s purely a busi ness decision.
,
"
CHAPTER 4 , HHICS AND THE LAW
37
KEY CONCEPTS 'Jhe discipline of ethics concerns the study of what is considered good and had hehavior. The d iscipline of running a busine's conccrns mak inga profit. Ethical principles an d business principles arc both alfccteJ by the times in which they operate Jnd by the traditions t1wy han' known , yt't in the end, a business is gnnd when it h prufitahle and bad when it is not.
Businesses and Lega lit y To he pmfitahle. Ill" ,t bosinesses nbserve the law. "lhere is a defi nite and usoally swift consequence for violating a public or private standard of co nduct. With a climinal vinlat ion, a company mal' he charged a mnnetary fine, which ce rt ainly impacL~the hOllom linc. /I criminal penalt)'could also indudca loss ofJicensc orplivi1cgc, which would affect future prufits.lf a busin,'55 b reaches a contract. a civil violation has occorred, which could resu lt in the company having to compensate the damagL>d part)' with money. If a business commits a tort - injuring SOnl~'One "r damaging his property- the law will requirt· the business to pot the injored party hack in the position he was in bdim: th~ tort occ nrred , which 'lgain coold mean Significant cOllll'cnMtion going to the vic, li lll. TIlcrefnre, bUsine.I.les tr), to refrdin fmm cnmmitting illt"g".I1 acts. Businesses arc not only ~xp~ctcd to opemtc l~gaHy, the)' arc also expected to operate ethicaU)'. Howel'er, what is right bchal'ior for som~: is not right behal' ior for others. Indl\"iduaJ.~' ethical sensib il ities diffa wild ly, and so do those of businesses. In thc long run, a fail urr to be aware of and sensitive to ethical concer n.1 can alrecl a Ou.~iness\ profit as much as an il lega l acl can. TIle puhlic responds to clhiC"JI cnncerns, and eV('t1 though a may he opc r~tlng wilhin the law, if it m,lkcs poo r ethical choices
busines.~
fo r its times and audience, it will lose pmfits a nd thereby be olf purpose.
Theories of Ethical Be havior Ethics 3rc nebulous- often as dou dy as Ihe Milky Wa),. Ph ilosophers have hthelc d some hasic theories ahou t l·thical beh'IViu r. I'o r example, onc widely recognized et hical theor)' is the principle ojulilily. A utilltarian makes
"' "
38
PART I: LAW 101
o.Iec i5io ns of ri~ht and ",mng f()",u,~i n~ on the outcome that provides the ~rcat· est good forthe g reat~ st number of p<-'Opk. Anolhercthica.! th~'()ry is Ihepril'!· (ipk of egoism. An ethical egoist would not care a bit how a decision alfected another; he valucs whatever is in his own bcst in terest, an ll by definition, thai must be thc best cboice, ~omeone who believes in the pr inciple of the (d upon him. In other words, a hc1icver in the CJlcgorical imperative would consider il elhicallo lic 10 anolher if he agrees that anyone else edn li e h> him. These are jost three ethical the"ric~ nut of many, People in all places and:1I all times have disag~ed "bOUI what is right hehavioT. One ethiedl tllL~)ry is not superior 1<> an ot her. just di lferent frnm it.
Busi nesses and Ethics When an elhical question arises, how can a bus iness. whose ma in goal is to make a profit. get it right? 'Ihe simple answer is that a busi ness Glnnot get it righl all the time. There will always be an alldienc~ Ihat di sagrees wilh its decisions. However, a business's ethical dwices can alfect profits just as ,<;cri· <)II51y as illegal choiccs. For example. \V'II·Mart. Ihe \\'orlo.l'~ lal);est rctailer, continually gets feedback on its choices. Locking employees in at the work· placc is a b~d choke. OlTering personal weUness programs is a good choice. Nike uses celebrities 10 promote their sports shoes. This is good choice. Nike uses Indonesian manufacturing facilities with poorworking conditions. That is a bad choice. Alcoa is Ih e leading manufacturer of aluminum. Manufac· turing aluminum creMes some ~rious environmelltal hy.products. Alcoa choo,," to sponsor m,lOY envirnnmental Cduses ami education program'. This is probably a ddibcrak cho ice 10 enhance the Ctl mpan y's reputation as a good neighbor and an environmentally responsible organization. To gUide them in making ethical cho ices. many businesses :ldopt dhi· cal codes, mission SliUal1cnts. or sbtcments of purpose. These pronounce· ments give somc insight into the values of a wmpany. Also, a company can be cvaluated for its good or bad behavior by lookin g at its choices of wage Icvels and thc fringe benefits it offcrs employees, its hours of operJtion. or ils co mpany morale and CIlm munity involvement If the react ion 10 a business decision is extremely Ilq;at ive. the co mpany may cha nge its choice, If a business's choices are considered
•
CHAPTER4. HHICS AND THE LAW
39
sc riOlIS violation" of ethical ~t'lflJ ard5, th(· i s~ue may hc addressed by lhe public ur legislature, resulting in steps tu make the act ivity illega L I:or ex.lmple, in 200 1, th~ en.'rgy company En ro n wllapsed 'lfter diKlosures that the fi nancial statements they were is~u i ng, which were ce rtified hy their accou ntants, Arthur Andersen, LLI'. were fa lse and mislead ing. 'Ihou~ands of sharcholdas. incl uding many Enron emploYl·es. suffered <;"
Stakeho lders to Consider Ho w can a business generate maximum profi ts wi th minimum viobtiuns oflaw s and values? The besl advice is for a business to evaluate the effects of its actions o n all its COlIStilUcnts. ThL\ is a tedious procc\s, as the inkrested parties. or stakt>holdcrs. include the following: L
'Ihe slwreholilers or owners of Ihe lJUsincss . The main d ut y to th is group is for the bu s i n~ss tu make a profit and k~ p a sterling reputation to encourage new illl'csto rs.
2.
1he e",plo)',,~s of the bllsjn~ss. A co mpany has a d ut y to deal f~i rly with those who wo rk to ma ke ils profit. 'lhis includes a dury of loyalty to employees, a duty to provide a safc working environment, and a duty to keep th .. empl oyees inform ed of decisions affecting thei r welfare.
3.
'1/1C bminc55 partners of th e company. This constituency in d ud~s the suppliers. manu fJ cturcrs, and di stributors Ihat the company docs business with on a regubr basis. Wilh out ethical treatm ent 10 those who the hu,\ine.ls depends upon to pmdnce ~nd distribute its product, serious problems co ul d result, an d prohlcms ,lamage pro fi ts.
4. '[he (uMomers of lh~ business, TIlis gmup huys the proJuct or service th e husiness prov id es. Custome r di sapproval is rdlcctcd clearly ami imnK.Jiatcly in salcs numoers, whic h ~frcc l pro fits.
40 5.
PART I: LAW 101
111" pullU, alliITge or /lI e w mnlUnily /lIe bu
Thi.~
co n-
stituency cuuld be very large and only minimally iovolved in Ihe subject of the ["Iusiness, but a company is a residen t or where it does business and has a dut)' to be a good neighbor.
6.
'1he e'"Il'irol1rnent. In today's ewnomy, the neighborhood is the planet. Many business decisions affect the environm,'nt now and for years to come. Resources arc finite: the urge to consume is unlimited. No bU5ines~ can alford to ignore the environmcntal consequences of its actions in today's world.
If it's legal, is it ethica l? If it's ethical, is it lega l? To rccap. an ethical decision could bc eithn kgal or iUegal. l'or example, Tim may belie'"c it is ethirully correCI to pay his employees more than minimum wage. "lhat belief was fo nn ed from his cultuml, religious, and wcial inte ractions. Wage and hour laws T<'quirc only that he pay minimum wage. but he docs morc. lllat i~ a gn.)d ethical choice for Tim, and a kgal choice. Maybe Sam bclkve\ th at all
cmploy,·c.~
should earn theirw,lgcsovera period
of time an d no employee should start ou t making more tha n $1.50 au hour. This could be a strong cthical bdid for Sam based on his family tmditions and ethnidty. But it would be against the bw fur Sam to exercise that ethiml belief with his employces. Wage and hour laws require emplorc.·rs to pay minimum wage. That isan agT<'ed upon standard in our socieljr, regardles.~of Sam's personal se nse of right and ..... rong. So all individual's personal ethics could mean that he i.. mOfe generous or less gencrous than the law requires. Could a k1\al d ecision be an unclhical one? Yes. il could he unethical for you. For examp le, many people beli,,"e it is unethical to IISC birth control. 11leir euhure, religion. and/or lraditious teach thai children sh ould be openly .....{'Icomro into families. Il owevrr, the la ..... does not forbid the usc of hirth control. Every state, ..... hich regulates Ihe health and ..... elfare of its citizens, has sct forth the conditions under which birth control can bc avaibblc to it residents. In this instance, somc pcople's pcrsonal cthical hdiefs n13ke th em label
tbi.~
law unethiG'!.
Businesses do not have to do 1110re than the law requires. but because they arc livingorgallizati()l1S, Ihey hal'e an ethical.~tancc " r uutlook. lflheir
•
CHAPTER 4 ' ETHICS AND THE LAW
41
ethic~ C~USl'
them to ran short of the legal stano.laro.l.~, they will face .ome unpleasant conse'l\l~nces. To al'oid violating specific laws, they may find another jurisdiction in which Ihey can do the desired ,1(lion; for example, the y may move Ihe company 10 (heape r bhor cenlers or tn lo(alions with fewer environ mental restrictions. However, Iher<: arc good reasons why husiocs~cs may cxcrd~c generous et hi cal standards. ·Ihese rea50ns indude meding the ir .\Iatell purpo.sc and heing nn track with their goab and outlook, hut they may ,1150 include some Jcs.s nohlc o r mixed motives, ~ uch as the des ire ror good employee rdalimls, community approval. and heller sales.
THE LAW IN ACTION The dedsion to move Isabel Dloom, ltd., to China was not popular. I lead· lines screamed, "S he would he spinning in her grave." nhe artist died in 2001.) Endl ess mau- on-t hc-strcet interviews <Juotcd ",lIectors Silying. "rll nl'Va buy another M:ul pture. Co mpany officials relcased stalemcnts confirming Ihal il was a wry dilficult dl·cisinn and emphasized Ihat wnrkl'f!; woul d be given lengthy notice befo re the close. Is the Ikdsion a kgal one? Ab5O lutel y. A husinesscan opeulc anywherc it wishes. ·[his is a company that ultimately is responsible to its shareholdH
ers, and opera ting more efficiently mcans bigger profits. Positioning itself to promote nationwide sales also mcans higger profiL~, Is thi s decisi on all cthiat l one? It depcllds on what your standanls an'. If the bu.,illes' applies the principle of utility, its goal is to enSUTe the grea test gooJ for the great~st numher. A utilitarian focus "'ould iuvt)lv~ emplo ying 1110re people, making more pro fits for shareholdns, and selling more products. If the business applles the principle of (1:\0isl11, its goal is to do anything for more take -hom e dollars for the top people. If the business applies the principle of the· categorical imp.'rali"e, ils goal would be to do to the employees and shareholders only those actions that it was willing to lluivcrsalize. In the en d. why was this de cision made? Acco rding to the company's statement, management decided to mak~ this move hecause do ing so allowed for production ...... vings and better positioning for the co mpany to
42
PART I: LAW 101
distrihute its pmdllCI nationwide. Prof,t C"'lel'rns .Hld hu.~illess i~sues appe~r to have trulllp~d histurical and community concerns. When the announcement 10 move to China was made february 9, 2006, however, the uproar ove r the dl"
TEST YOURSELF Since th is chllpt er emphasized that ethical decisions are reilitive, it would not be appropriate to ask questions with definite answers. Rather, I wou ld like to illustrate some choices companies have made about their ethical decisions and ask you to weigh in on the ir propriety and the principles at wOIk. 1.
In 1978, Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield stilned
iI
small ke Cleam
company in Vermont. Ben & Jerry's was commi tted to doing business in a social ly responsib le way. One choice the owners milde was to cap executive compensation at seven times that of the lowest paid worker in the company. This measure not only estab li shed a sense offair play with in the organiUltion, bot also helped the company make fair payments to the local dairy farmers they used as suppliers and kept the morale levels of the company high. There was nothin g illega l aboot this compensation
~ca le,
althoogh th e market woold
bear a much higher wage for a CEO of a company this size. The compensation ra te did not hurt the profits of the bus iness. WhIch of the three ethical principles mentioned in this chapter is operating in this choice-the principle of utility. the principle of egoism. or the principle of the categorical imperative ? Why? 2.
In December of 2000, Robert Nardelli became CEO of Home Depot. He ran the company for five years, increasing the revenue ilnd profits
•
CHAPTER4. HHICS AND THE LAW
43
of the bu~iness. The ~hare price however, lost ground. Shareholder return over the period was down 13 percent. Since Mr. Nardelli's compensation package was made public in each yearly repo rt, by 2006, it was wide ly known that he had earned over $200 million in salary and bonuses and was set to keep earning bonuses regard less of the company', performance. Mr. Nardelli resigned in January of 2007. There was nothing illegal about th is compensation scale, a nd in the market. Nardelli cou ld get a similar package elsewhere. The compe nsat ion rate did not hu rt the profiu 01 the business. Which of the three ethica l principles mentioned in this chapter is operating in th is cholcel Whyl 3.
In Ma rch of 2005, the American College of Phy~icia n Executives re leased results of a survey of physician leaders. When as ke d about their concerns, 78 pe rcent of those responding indicated they were "very concerned" or "moderately co ncerned" about physicians over treating patients to boost income, a nd 76 percent were "very concerned" or "moderately concerned" about the influence on physicians by phillmaceuticill companies. Which of the thlee ethical principle~ ment ioned in thiS chapter is operilting in these responseslWhyl
4.
In early 2007, Ihe Attorney Generil l of New York begiln investigating the relationship between student loan companies a nd un iversities. Initial evide nce suggested some finilnciil l aid ildministrators at the universities had investments in the ~tudent loan compan ies that they were putting on "preferred lende r" lists and recommending to students seeking finilncia l ilid. ln some Cilses, the finilncial ilid staff me mbers had sold shares for larg e
profit~.
One of th e universities
involved has specific ru les in their employment handbook specify ing that employees ~hould not directly or indirectly have an interest in a business that is in co nni ct with the employee's du ties with the school. Which of the three ethical principles mentioned in this chapter is operating in th is situa tion with the financial aid employees! Why? Answers can be found o n pages 212-213.
"' "
•
44
PART I: LAW 101
Ethic~ i~
the
~tudy
of how people ~hould act. People are innuenced
in their ethical deci~ion~ by their culture, religion, and Ethic~ do('~
tradition~.
not label any culture, religion, Or tradition
another; it e valuates how people make the as they do.
choice~
~uperior
they do
10
to
act
Businesses a re engaged in commerce to make a profit. Their ethical choices ca n affect profit. An ethica l decision cou ld be an illegal decision; a legal decision (ould be an uneth ica l decision. Ethical decisions are not a lways based on a belief about right action; they can be motiva ted by a desire for good publicity, social approval, and increased profit.
,
"
How Do Businesses Fit In? van or tru ck owned by a business is involved in a traffic accident
A
res ulting in properly damage a nd injuries. It happens every day. Can
the business be charged with a crime, such as exceeding the speed limit
or failing to stop at a red light? Can a business be sued civilly? Whilt if the vehicle owned by the business was not at fault? Could the business then
sue another? In what court "nd for what recovery? Does the dispute h.we
to go to cou. t, Or can a business take advan tag e of alternative dispute resolution? And finally, is a business governed by the U.S. Constitution. statutes, and case law precedent? Is a bus iness entitled to a speedy trial, the tight to free speech, and the protection against self-in criminat ion?
In this chapter, we will review the introductory chapters as they apply specifically to business rights and responsibilities,
Businesses, Civil Litigiltion,
Businesses and Constit ... tional Gua rantees
and ADR
Businesses, Sta tutory Law,
Businesses in Court
and Common Law
Businesses and Self-Inctim inat ion
Businesses and Crimes
46
PARr I: LAW 101
IN THE REAL WORLD l\cfor~ Novcmnerof2005. Gregg I'notogT'Jphy, In c., WM ope rating a small hu siness in Des ''''Iuines, Iowa. The owners were parents Tom ,md C indy Gregg and thelr son, Bob. 'n I l' business specialized in photogT'J phy for grad oatio ns, anniversaries, ncw babies, and othn e"cnts, but its bread and huller was its wed
tnct to photograph the ('vent, provide proofs. Jnd finish photogT'Jphs. It ofte n received a down paymen t or upfront money on the scrvices. In Novem be r of 2005, num erous complaints were made to the Polk Co unty att orney's ollice abo ut Gregg Photogra phy, Inc. Ten custome rs we re i,knti fic d as having problems with Gregg's servi(cs; eight of those ha,1 filed criminal compl ainl.~ with the po li c~ departmen t. Appa rently Gregg was lwldin g over $9,000 of costu me r deposi ts fur se rvices the custo mers never received. Has Gregg Photography. Inc., committed a crime? Can the business be put in jail? Do the dissatisfied customers have any recourse against the co mpa ny? I low c,m they pursue this? What do th,' y ,,",t nt fro m Gregg PhntngT'Jphy?
KEY CONCEPTS The co un applies the u.s. Consti tu tion, statutes, and common law to busi ness.;s jusl as it docs 10 peopk Busine.lses arc therefore liable if they violat" puhlic standa rJs of co ndu ct, just like indiviuual citiu ns- but there are some dilr~rences in Ih e WJ), this plays out.
Businesses and Constitutional Guarantees Language in the commerce chinsc of the Constitution (article I, section 8) gives the national government the risht to regulate co mmerce in the Uni te d States. lhat means the federal govern ment can pass rules binding a bminess's dealings with other businesses, customers, and the puhli c. Examples of these regllhltions include laws regul atin g interslate transpo rta tion, equ al employ ment opportu nity, and t,[xes. In addition,
CH~PTE~ 5 · HOW DO BU SINESSES FIT IN?
47
states posse'" po/icc powers and arc allowed under the Constitution to pass laws regarding the health, safety, morals, and genentl w clfar~ of its citizens, That means the statc government can pass Tules binding a busi· neH. Examples of state regulation 01 hosiness include restaur..l nt health standards, licensing of medical professio nals, and workers' co mpensa' tion laws. l he Con,ti tution also gUaranll"t:S 10
J,
*
~I
h
48
PART I: LAW 101
BlIsinesus, Slatu/or), l .al\; ulld COIIJIIW" Law, A husiness i~ ',11.", bound
by Ih e fcd~ral and state statules that regulate it. Not every statute a legisla. ture passes pertains to a business, so not every rule applies, hut a business has 10 bc al,'a re of the rules and regulations rC<.juired in its industry to keep ils opemtion lcl,'1l1. A bu~iness is also bound b)' the decisions that havc been rendered in p.lst fcderJl ~nd state court cases, Precedent applies to a com pany just .IS it doe~ 10 iLn indivi JU '11 ~nd helps a business predict holl' its claim o r dispute rna)' turn o ul.
Businesses and Crimes We can all think of ways in which a business can commit a crime, A local financia l !irm may commingle its money with that of its clients, 'That is a crime. A brg{' corporation ma), misle ad inv{'stors and ('mp lo)'ees about its financial h{'ulth with exaggerated profit and loss reports. Tha t is a crimc. A sandwic h shop could serve tainted food to custo mers. Tha t is a crime. Or a craft husiness could hav{' unsafe wiring that causes a cus tnmn to susta in a st·,'cre electrical shock. That is a crimI'. fiusinesscs can commit misdemeanors or felonies. Ihey can pay fines aodlose Iicl'Mes and privileges, but a business can nut bl' put in jail. If a business commits a felony, for which the consequence could be a prison sentence. the responsible representatives of the business are charged and suhjecl to this pcnalty. lhe p{'r:son charged is Ihc pcrson most direct l)' responsible to r the felonious activity- usually an officer or director of the cumpan)' if the crime rdatc' to ~ bl1sines..~ decision, or the employee invoked ifthe crjm~ relates to an accident ur inju ry. A business charged with a crim e ca nno t he subject to double jeopardy and enjoys the risht to a sp~... dy criminal trial the righl to have assiSlance of counsel, and the right tu confront the witnesses against them. A business could also he tbe victim of a crime. such as robbery, employ{'c cm bez;;l mlClIl, or purchase of supplies that He never Tl'ceivoo. The puhlic proS('cu tor represents business victims as well as individual victims of cr im e. Again, a compa ll )' rep",.lentative would he making the complaint on h1.'ha l( o( the businc.'5. If the accu.«! is !(luml gui lt y o( till.' cri m{', any fine is paid into the public cotfer.l . The purpu.le of a business's pursuing a
•
CH~PTE~ 5 · HOW DO BUSINESSES FIT IN?
49
criminal complai nt is 10 uphold Ihe standards Sci hy S"eil'ty and ke<'p the public safe from a recurrence oflhis Iyp<: uf event.
Businesses, Civil Litigatio n, and ADR A llusines .• may 11<: 1i,lhle to another for a ch'il mallcr- hased eithn 0 11 a hreach of co nlraCI or a lorl. If ace usct! of violating ,I personal .• tand'lrd of co ndUCllo another, a business has to hire legal represenlation and defend itself.lf lhe business is found liab le, it may beordcred to pay damages to the injured parly. A side ctfect ofhcing inl'oll'ed in a legal claim co uld be had publicity and lost &ood",iU. Because the publicity could be as detrimental as the cl,li m it~clf, hu~inesses favor the usc nf alternative dispute reso lotion. ~uch as n~"8otiati o n. med iation, and arbitra tkln_ ADR is cheaper, faskr, and much less puhlic than a civil trial. A husine~s may s\l e others f(l f civil da m· ages. To do so, it must hire legal representation and pursue th e mailer. The business goes through the same processes as an individual claimant to try to recover damage.~.
Businesses in Court Businesses may f('solve disputes in fedeml court if they qualify- that is, if the Ill,llter involved is Jbout a fede rJI questio n o r if there is diversity jurisdiction. To qualify for fcderJI div~rsity jurisdiction, the plaintiff and the defendant in the lawsuit have to be from different states. liut in what state docs 3 hu~in es.' reside? Fede ral rules state th~t J business reside s in every state where it docs business. Businesses may also 3vailthemsdves of state cOllrls to resolve any dispu tes. They h,l\"c acee...' to C(l urt in any state in which they do busin ess. Li ke every other crim inal defendant, a husi IWSS is presu illed illnoccut until prove n guilty of a cri minal charge beyond a reasonable doubt. Like every o th er civil defendant, a business needs to prove its case by a preponderance of the evidence. /Jusin cssf!S and Self-Incrimination. Ihne is one significant limitation on a bosiness in a criminal situation. TIle Fifth Amendment to the Co nstitu· tion provides that no pe rso n in a crimilwl case ~s hall be co mpelled .. to he a witness ag~inst himself.' This right guam nt~cs thaI a perso n charged
50
PART I: LAW 101
with a crimc has no obliga tion to provide person;11 incriminating recurd ... to prosecutors, although prosl'cutors may try to obtain rdevant wriuen rl'-
curds by discuvery. TIlis right ,I lso guarantees that an accused can refuse to te.~tify on his ow n behalf io a criminal malter and that this failure to testify cannot be construed against the acc used. 'I his is notthl' case for a business. A business cannot refnse to provide business record s, even if they contai n incriminating information against the husine.'s or an employee. olfieer, or contact of the business. 'Ihc Fifth Amend mcnt protection is for pers<ms, not for husinesses. Uhwisc, a husiness Cd unot tl'stify in a criminal maner. It ..... ould be unwieldy to put Ford Motor Company on the willH:sS stand. A busines ... appear., in co urt throu gh il.~ reprl'scnt,llives, mainly individu als who arc o/ficl'rs or directors ofthl' company. Thosl' indiv id ua ls canno t claim the Fifth Amendment and refuse to testify because what they say rna)' be incriminating to the business entit),. Those individuals could asscrt the Fifth }\ mendment for themsclves; however. ifa[JY of the questions wou ld elicit information, that may incriminate the lI"it ncsse~ pcr.,oll
THE LAW IN ACTION According to the Iowa Code, dl'priving anothcrofhis pro pl'rty is thdt. The crime of theft is classified acco rding to degrees.. depending on the s<:riousness of the theft. The am,)unt of money Gregg Photography. Inc., held for it, complaining customers fell into thc category of second-degrcc theft, which is punishahle hy ~ fine of between $5,000 and S7,000 and a prison sentence of up to five yea rs. Taking ano ther's moncy at this levd is a fclony. Thl' Polk Count y alloflll'y charged Gn'gg Pho tography. Inc., , .. ith o nl' count (charge) oft heft. The Greggs voluntarily talked to the police and the pros..'cutor, explaining that Tom and Cindy were really not part o fth~ businl'ss; the)' had only agreed to give Bob soml' money to start up his business and in return got so me shares of stock in the corpor.:Jtion. Bob was the one who ran the husiness day to day and did alllhe photography. Appar~ntly thillgs had gotten tight, with (he rent on the IOClt i!)n. the unexpected expCIll'C of some nCll" e'luipmen t, and ,I slow fall ."a'on. Bob was doing
CH~PTE~ 5· HOW DO BU SINESSES FIT IN?
51
the best he could, hut he fell hehind in johs and mi.,sed some o ther job, completely, He was ignoring the calls from angry custom<,fS but never mean t for anyone to be hanned. Despite all the causes of the diflicuhy, GuS!; PhotogT'Jphy, In c., had commilled theft. It had deprived others of their property. "lhe bu~i n ess could be tried on the cha rge and could be liable to pay a significant fine. Because this olfens<, was a felony, iLlld the IlOssibil ity of jail time was also an issue, the Polk COlillty attorney had to make a decisio n a.• to whilt hu,ines.~ owncrs or olficers should be charged with the crime. Oh"iou~ l y, tlw business itsdf C"dllilot 1)0 to prisoll. III this C"d5e, tlw county attorn~y determined that Boh was the managing owner and the one who shnuld h~ve prevented the situation. Since they were all ow ners of a small business. Tom and Cindy could also be charged with brl'aking this law, but the county attorney used his discretion and did not charse them. [fBob and Gregg PhotogT'dphy, [nc., were found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of committing theft, the company would he liable for a big fine ,llld probably also lose it\ license [0 ()pemt~ within the cHy of l)~s Moill<'5. I:nr a small business already in financial difficulty, a guilty verdict would meao the end- of money, of au thority to opeT'Jtc, of customers, of goodwill. For Bob, ,1 gui lty verdict would nh.'an a big monetMy debt and prison time. 111 prcpaT'Jtion for the criminal trial of SlIIrc 1'. Gregg Photograph}", IrlC., the defendants would be ab le to confront the complaining customers and havl' counsel re present them (although not a public defendl'r, beC"Juse they arc not ind igent). The state would have the right to ,~ubpocna business record, ,howing the con tracts and depos its n.'ceived. Bob Gfl'gS could not ohject tn providing these hu,iness records because they are the busine.'s', property, not his I'ersnnally, an d a business has no fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. The defe nd,lIlIs wou ld also be entitled tn a speedy trial and the presumption of inn ocence until provcn gllilty berond a reasonable doubt. To pro"c the caS<', the county attorney would call the customers as witncsses, show the business Rxords of the deposits received, and (('fur to the Iowa statute that defines the otfense. In thi, case, the Po lk County
52
PARr I: LAW 101
forward and agreed to P,IY any deficient 'Imoun ts. nob agH'ed to plead guilty to a less serious degree of Iheft and pay a fine. '[he business \OSI its liccn~c to opemtc in Des Moines. [(Bob evcr tried to gcl a business license in Iowa in the future, the theft conviction would preyent him from doing so. lustice was served. '[he resolution recognized the crime, the defendants paid a liM, and the public was protected from Ihis happening again. The Greggs were not c() mplctdr otT the hook. th()ugh. '!bere were still angry customers. Allhough thc parents had resources to rcturn all down payments, smne customer. still felt they had a came of action against the busi ness for produ cts that were never re.::eil-ed. Sonw custo m<'rs demanded the services they already contTJding album, since precious memories 10Sl arc hard to value. Sinc~ tbis incident caused bad pubHcitr gencl"Jl1y for photogl"Jphers in the area, a number of colleagues ofG regs I'hutogmphy, Inc., stepped Ill' und offered 10 finish developing photos or rctak.' photos for injllr"d custome rs at no cnst. "lhis helped a rclIow ph<JtoSI'~p b er meet his obligations and softcned the bad pres~ all photographers WCTC suffering.
TEST YO URSELF 1.
DaviS Couoty wanted to irlCrease the local sales tax by 1 percent to provide more reVenUe for county roads and Infrastructu re repairs. The IOC
"' "
•
CH~PTE~ 5 · HOW DO BU SINESSES FIT IN?
2.
53
In the year 2000. it wa~ disdosed that the federal government had been investigating the Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines for environmental violations. Evidence showed th~1 the comp~ny had use d tactics ~uch as hidden piping and night dumping to discharge thousands of gallons of waste products, induding oily bilge, photo· developing chemiCills, and dry ·cleaner fl u ids. Affected waterways incl uded the New YOl k harbor, the Port of Miami. and the Alaskan Inside Pas5
3.
Mr. Paul Max has run Max Tax Service, Inc .• for six years. Although the business is incorporated, he is the only owner of shares and makes "II the manag",ment d",cisions. Max Tax Service, Inc., is being audit",d by th'" Intern,,1 R",venue Service regarding its corpor"te tax li"bility for the year 200S. The IRS has subpo",na",d som", corporat", tax J",cords, but Mr. M"x does not wish to provid", them. He is pleading rhe Fif/h, which means he is invoking his right not to incriminate himself accorded to him by the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution. Will he be successful?
Brai n Teaser 4.
In a 2002 advertising campaign, Nike,lnc., claimed that it protected rights of laborers in overseas factories that made its footwear. A labor activist. Marc Kasky, did not believe this was a va lid claim and sue d the corporat ion in the state of California for false advertising. Nike defended the suit saying that it was protected by the First Amendment right to freedom of speech. Who s hould win this dispute and why?
Answers Clin be found on pages 213-2 14.
"' "
•
54
PART I: LAW 101
A business entity can commit a crime or have a crime committed agaimt it. A busin('Ss "ntity can commit a civil violation or hav(' a civil violation committed against it. The Constitution of the Un ited St" te, grants some rights to businesses just as it doe, to individu"ls. but 11 business does not enjoy all the protections granted to individual citizens. A business can sue and be sued in federa l and state courts depending on wh('r(' it does busin('ss. A business can use alternative dispute resolutkm to resolve claims.
,
"
· .. CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
Now thaI we have some background information about the law, the p rocess of litigation, and alternative dispute resolution, w e are ready to examine civil law in mo re detail. Part II outl ines how to dete rmine liabil ity for a tort or for a breach of contract. In addition, this section provides defenses to such claims so that a business faced wi th these actions might know how to establish rightful cla ims and respond to
wron gful ones.
Jrhch~"
11 h
I"
Urheberre<;htlich ge5chlitltes Material
The Recipe for a Tort
W
hen I got mar ried, J was a 25-year-old law school graduate with w hat I thought was a 'ertain level of sop histication. I don't know
why it hit me with such shock when I realized that my st udent specialties of
ham sandwiches and cheap sp
I was offering my mate Chicken Supreme and Boeuf Bou/guignon.1 swear if I had lea rn ed to make the Eminen<::(' Brune-a bittersweet, d ense choco-
late cake-earlier. he woul d have proposed two years before. This chapter is not about tortes. the dessert, but it is about recipes. The law is a 10\ like cooking. If you have all th e necessary ingredients, you
can (fea te th e des ir ed prodUC1. Cooking up a civillor t claim is a matter of having all the right elements fall into place, and in this chapter we'll put together an easy-to-follow. foolproof recipe.
Jrhch~"
11 h
1"
58
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
v.[jlj AT'S I A ~E A D Types ofTorts In t entional
Defenses to Claims of Negligence Coment
Reckless
Assumption of Risk
Negligent Ingredients for 11 Tort of
Contributory Or
Negligence
Comparative Negligence
Damages in Tort Cases
Strict Liability
IN TH E REA L WOR LD In 1999, a t rdgic acc iden t occurred nca r J~nes,'ille,
Wi~onsin,
involving a
van !ilkd with h igh school and college stud(· nts working to sell magatine sub scriptions o n their Eastn break. Youth Employment
S~Tvices,
LLC,
and its related company, Subscriptions Plus. inc., operated out or Iowa and Oklahoma, respec tivel y. The y hired 20-yea r-o ld Jeremy Holmes to work as a d river and handler for groups traveling to v,lrious communities to sell
,ub.~cription,
door-tu-doo r. On thl' evening of ~'I~rch 25. a Mihon
Township police officer d ocked a van on 1-90 going ahout 80 miles per hour. I Ie pulled ,mto the interstate to follow ,lnd .' aw the vehicle veer off the roa d,
h~'Sjn
to roll, and th row about 12 people ontu the highway.
F' mrk'en peopll' were in the van; seve n were killed an.l fke were seriously injured. [s what happened a tragic accident? An act ufGod? II crime? II tort?
KEY CONCEPTS A tort is a personal injury. The law allows a person who is injured by the actions of another to recover from that person if all the right elements arc in place. Tort law is d b ranch of civil law, which concerns the rights of individuals to rcco"er against one another. '[he usual method of recovery is to Sill' for damages. One action Oln result in both a crime and a tort
CHAPTEII6 • THE RECIPE FO R A TORT
59
claim becausc one action can violate a public and a private stan<.lar<.l of conduct.
Types of Torts If my neighbor misses a stoplight an<.l runs his caf into my lovely 1998 I lunda Ikcord, this could oe a crime ,md it could abo be was probably reckless. Reck· le.'s is the description used in the law for behavior about ..... hich you should have known better. My neighbor should have known b('tte rthJn to drive his car considering that he knew the bT"Jkes were getting funny. Or. he should have known better than to talk on the phone while driving. Being reckl('ss is troubl ing hehavior; the law usually doesn't ignore this type of actio n, hilt it doesn't co nsider it as diab olical as intentio nalmi.o;.co nduc t. Maybe he was jllst negligcnt. N~gligelll is the de!'Cription uscd in the law for oehavior thai i.~ can'less. H(' didn't mean to cause an accident. He had no w,lrning th,lt something might h~pl'en, but he wasn't being as careful as he should have been. Negligellcc describes a truc accid,'n1, uninh.'llded dnd unforesl'cn, but damaging nevertheless. Negligence is v('ry common and llsuaUy not ~s serio ous in its consequences as recklessness or intentional acts. To determine how to cIas.~ify the S<.'riousness of a tort. you U.\.C the terms intentional, reckless. and negligent. which arc the SJmc words used to clas· sify crime•. TIll: more .'
•
60
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
Ingred ients for a Tort of Negligence To establish negligence, the law requires certain ingredients to be present. These includl' duty, oTeach, damage, and cJu'ation. Since ch'illaw gives a place (or people to recowr (or p~rson" l brcachc~ o( conduct, negligence in· vokes ,I hre'leh of a rule or comluct, or ,I duty. To weigh the duty involved, the law creates tbe reI/,0/1IIM" p,'rs(!n by asking, ~What would a reasonab le person do in these cirClllnstancl's?H Would a reaso nabll' pawn bdil've there was a duty? Would a reaso nable person think she should bc able to drive to the corner store for a quart of milk without getting plowed in to at a :;toplight? Of w urse she would. Laws and regulations imply th at members of society have duties to one anot her. We bav" trallic laws and regulations on who can drive. Drivers have a duty to otha drivers. Employers have a duty to their employees to provide a .'
CHAPTEII6 • THE RECIPE FOR A TORT
61
law~uils a., k for pain ,HId mffering or emotional d istrcS5 damage_,. arc gen..,rally hard for the la w to value and arc likely 10 r..,sult in mone}, damage; only if they go along with real physical injuries or d'imaged property. Finally. tort law requires Ihe liable party to he a c-dUSC of the hurt. My neighbor's actions have to diredly contrib ute to th e injury that result~. 'Jhis is where many tort claims fuil in part or in tot 'll. As " society, we arc quick 10 hlaillc olhers when thing~ go wrong. l'or exa mple. he did run th'lt stol' light, but the city hung the light in un awkward spot nn that corner, and he (ouldn't sec it dearl y. Or, h.., did run that stoplight, but h.., just had his car serviced and the mechanic must have dam"s(oJ the br"kcs. Or, he did run that stoplight , but he was late for work and would lose his job if he didn't get there on time. so il was his bOM'~ fault. Cml$ation i~ aiM) hard tu
injury
'lhc~
prove on occasion because injuries result from more than one cause. for example, my neighbor did run that stoplight, but [ was not watching the intersecti on as dusely ,IS r shou ld have oeen hcforc proceeding. So ther~ you have iI, th e recipe ti'T a toli. To hold th~ peno n committing a tort - called a torlf"~ $"r- liablc for his action, you havl' to prove duty, breach, damage, and causation. If you don't have all four, you don't have a torI. Wh,lt do you have ? Well, you could have an accident, such as knocking a person's booh out of her hands in a crowded hallway. [n a crowded hallway, it is I"<'asonable thaI this may happen, and if there
62
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
wedding, some fnod disasler, or a sp"'lIal1eou.~ foul·up. Often anim,11 anl ics arc invulved. lh~se fall short of torts,
b~C"~usc
they generJlly don·t highlight
injuri~s
olher Ihan damaged pride, and the properly damage is minimal Ihough cssenl iallo the slapslick qualilY.
Damages in Tort Cases If you do havl' ~ winning recipe and all the ingredients of a tort claim ~re presenl, you recover damages. TIlal is, you ,11"1;· compcn.~alcd f(,ryourlos.'. On uccasion, dama ges include mo re Ihan jusl the immediate lusses thai occur. I may llel>tl a Tl'nlal car for lwo days while the Ho nda is heing fixed, and the only Tt'ason I need it is because my neighbo r damaged my ca r, so he sho uld also pay for the renlal car. This type of add itional damage is called incidentlll (because it goes along wilh the original tort) or cclHcqucntial (be cause it is a result of the original to rt), so the tortfcasor is liah!e. If I am hurt in the accident wilh my ncighh or, my damages may include payme nl of cosls fur medi ca l tTt'aIllH'nt and recovery, includ ing hospital bills, physicaltherap)' cnsl.', and lost wages while I am o ff work. GcneTJ.lly these am()un t.~ aTe supposed to PUI me back in the position [ would have i:> l"Cn in if the acciden l had no t occurr<>ccause of third-,legrce hurns she
~ uffered
when a Styrofoam
~ up
of co ffee purch a",.,J through a
drive-uJ' winrluw spilled in her lap. A jury awa rded her S200,000 in damages and $2 .7 mill ion in punitive damages. McDonald·s was punished for this accident beC"auS<' it was brought to lhe jury's attention tha i the restaurJnt had had more than 700 burn claims over 10 years beC"ausc o f ils sc al ding-hot co tfee. McDonald·s kept its coffee at a temperature sign ificantly hottcr than any othe r rcstaumnt"s to protect Ihc flavor, it cla imed, but also to sa"c th e prod uct longer before having to throw it away. This knowledge of the danger of the p ro duct, coupled with the profit mot ive in,'Olvcd, pml>al>ly persuaded t h ~ jury th'Hlhi s was not a case "f negligence but rather a C"J.se of reckless, willflll beha vior un the
•
CHAPTEII6 • THE RECIPE FO R A TORT
63
part of the tortfeasnr to va lue profit ove r safety. The awanl of 52.7 million is a stagg~ril1sly la!);e amount; it is also the profit /vlcDonald's J\13UC on two days' worth of coffee sales. Sometimes, civil courts allow for punitive damases to motivate a tortfcaSoT to 1113ke so me siSnificant chanses in the way he doe~ busilll'SS. Immed iately after this caS(', the temper-Ilure of l\kDona ld's wifeI' dropped from 190 degrees to 155 desrees. After similar puuitive damasc.~ awards, tnha cco comp'lllies gol serio us aboul their warning progra ms and changed their marketing tcchn i que~ and Ford and Piresl"'le re~
Defenses to Claims of Negligence It is haru to defend yourself if you commit an intentio nal tort. In sum,' instances, you Gin argue self-defense or defense of others if your actious harm a person. Recklessness, by its very definition. means you should have known better th an to do yuur acli,)fi, ' 0 it is ditficult 10 defend yourself in thiscasc, because it pres umes a certain cal1ousllessor willfu lness in the face "fbetter judgment. However, there arc some defenses that a perwn accused of co mmitting a negligent tort may use to shield hersdffrom liability. Th~y inclu.!e the following:
I.
Gm;<enl. In some Glses, the injured party knows that a possibility of harm may result from th e actio ll taken. Bungec jumping otf a bridge or clitf i., frd ught with danger. TIlat is part of it~ appeal. Things ca n go wrong, and jfthcy do, the result is usually se rious. 'Ihcreforc, Ihe service pro"ider may rcquir~ Ihe customer to sign a COnSl'llt form or a waiverofliahilit y, recognizing the fact thaI the custo mer agrees In hold the service provider lurm less from any damage that may occur. Businesses usc conse nt s and waivers alilhe time. Every time you park in a parking garJge, there is a wah'er form Oil your ticket stub. 'Ihe owner of the gJrage is not liable for any da mage that may occur 10 your car while il is p'lrhd there. Every car wash i",nter-al'your
64
PARr II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
2.
ConrriJJII/ory IJ r wmjmrariw lIegligena. This i., the cbSl;ic dcf~nse to a tOr( claim. When a tonfeasor 3rgU~S contributory negligence, she i~ saying that even if she co mm itted a ton, she should not be liable hecaose soml"(lne else cnntrihuted to the harm caused. The usual cn n· tr ibutor is the victim himself. My neighbor should bave stopped at the red light hut since I was not driving as ,,<,fely as I shuuld have been, my neighho r is otf Ihe hoo k. I Ie could not be the causc of the h'lrm becausc ! w~ s in the wmng, 100. Conr rilJll tory negligence is a harsh ruk If verified, it usually b" rs the victim from recovery. Few victim, arc blamc!ess. Few accidenu have o ne ca use 11Il 1y; the y often arc a collahnT"Jtivc efforl. $0 tod"y, most states have abandoned Ihe contributory negligence doctrinl' for th,' rul e of OJm paT"Jlive negligence. With comparatit"C negligencc. a judge o r jury co n weigh the cJusation of an accident and apportion the bb me amo ng the parties, ordering each to pay his fair ~harc of the damages. In my car accid ent, perh,lps Illy nl' ighbor i~ I\() perc~nt 10 blame and I am 20 percent ",spon.•ihle. If my loss<,s w<,re $100, he would have to p,ty S80 and I would have to ah>l<Jrh the rest of my loss. Compamti,'" negliger"e is r~ally abou t determin ing the ca usation ingredie nt of a lort hy co nsidering all thc parties thai may cause a lort. There is a time limit to C"Jus'ltio n. In a pnso nal injury case, it is usuaUya year and a day. If th., victim doesn't die within that time, the lortfeasor is pmhahly not Iiahle for c~ u sing the victim's death. whenever it does occur. !nkrvening and supersedi ng causes can diminish a t()rtfca'or'~ Iiahi li ty also. 1:"r example, if the ambu lance la king me tu the hospital fnr stitches after Illy cnllision with my neighbor is in volved in a serious accidcnt, my neighhor is probahly not held rc.~po ns ib l e for m)' hroken neck.
3.
Assu mption of lh e risk . This is relaled to consent and to co ntrihutory nq;ligcnce. With Il~SI.4l11pliol1 of th e risk, the tortfC"Jsor argues that the vict im assumed some responsibility for whal happe ned. If you enga ge in extreme fighting, you could set hurt; if you go hunt ins, you could he the vict im of an accident; if yo u choose to exit if burning building via the elevuto r, yo u co uld SCI inj ured severely.
*
~I h
CHAPTEII6 • THE RECIPE FO R A TORT
65
Strict liability There ure u few instances in which the law recognizes liability for a tort even if all the clements arc not present. This liability without neglig(·n ce i.~ cal1~d strict liability. The law take.~ this ullllSlial ,tep he(;\usc certain situation, are impossible to make safe and when they cause hHm, the injury is usually quite sewre. ThcTl'fore the law impoSt's an absolnte duty thallhe victim be co mpensated by the person causing the harm. Strict liahility generally applies to thn sc who deal in an ultrahazardous business nr with defective product s. Examples of ultrahazardous bU5incsses arc chemical companies, rock (Iuarric.~. and manufacturers that produce to"ic waste. E~am p lcs of defective products can he found in chapter 1 t.
THE LAW IN ACTION TIle accidellt outside of/allesl'ilIc, Wisconsin, was a tragedy. It aho resulted in criminal charges against the driver, the colllpany that employed him. and the owners oflhe company. In addition. child labor law viobtions were filed against the companies in Oklahoma and Wisconsin. but we wun t 10 analyze the fach to ~ce if any tort liability is present. 'Ihal el'ening 14 yoongsters. aged 15 to 25 years. were riding in th e van driwn hy Jeremy 1I0lmes. The v;m h~d adeq ua te scat belts. hut none "f th e passengers were wearing one. After Jeremy sped past the police e
66
PARr II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
The first ingred ient nece,~sary to prove a tnrt hased o n negligence i.~ duty. lhe employer, Yuuth Employment Services, LLC, had:.l dut y to provide a safe working environment fur its employees. One issue in this case was that the co mpany argued that the youth were not employCt:s of the co mp any, hut rather independe nt contnlCtors selling on commission. '[his point h irrelevant in the analysi s of duty, a~ even an independent contractor forced to rioJc in the principal's vehi cle should expect safc trall~port . 'lhe driver. jeremy Ilolmes, had a duty to Gl re for his crew safely. lIe breached that oJuty hy driv ing 110 milcs per hour ill an unregi'tered. unlkenxeoJ \·.,hic1e without valid authorit y to drive. The owner of the company, Choan Abn Lane, had a duty to act re.lp,utsih ly as a company owner and otficer. He did not do so in that he falsified reco rd s abo ut the \"an's usc. knew the vehicle was unlicell5ed and unregistered, and knew Jere my Holmes was unfit to drive and lead a crew. All three potential defendant s had a duty to each victim. Did th e defendant.' actions es\"blish the "econ tl clement of a to rt claim-that is. " breach of dut)·1 Ye.~, in each CdSC. because each defendant was carcles~, if nnt rcckk.s. to allow this ch"in of cve n\.~ tn gn forward. lhe third clemen t in a tort claim is damages. Did the breach of duty cause damages? Tragically, seven youth WHC killed and five WHe serio usly injured. In the CaS," of a deceased victim, hi~ or her representative usually sues the tortfeasor for wrongful death. A judgme nt findin g the to rtfeasor liable- for wrongful death would order him to pay damages. The tcrm guilty i, no t used in civil cascs; the defendant is found to he eithe r liahle or not liable. Damages for a lost lit.... would depend 0 11 the age of th e vktim. his eco nomic prospects had he sur.·ived, and the co n"equcn tial amI incidental ex penses due tn the death. such ~s expenses t.) depeudants and loved ones who no lo nger ha n' the services and ,tffccti ou of the victim. One of tbe cra~h vktims suffered seve re brJin damage. His damages include future medica l expenses and treatment costs. lost income potential, and special livi ng armngements necessary for the rest of his life. O ne IS-year-old girl wa~ paralyzed from the waist down and has minimal use of her arms and fingers. I Ju pamlpis h'l s led to many co mplications
J,
*
~I
h
CHAPTEII6 ' THE RECIPE FOR A TORT
67
including lung problems and bladdcr infcction~. In one yeH her bills ,II one hospital exceeded $200,000. -nle gi rl's mother worked as a lab technician, but sbe had to give up the job to provide round-the-clock c,lre for her daughter. Clearly, these two vktims have substantial and ongoing damages from this in cident. 'lhe timll clement in a tort claim is causation. Did the defendants' acti onscuu.lC Ih e dam'lge.\ thaI o"urr~>d1 Are there any defenses thill would prolect th e defen dants from liability? It is true that all the victims signed up to work for this tr:.wcling maga~ine sales cump'lny. They k new travel ing in it va n was part of the job, but Ihis knuwledge is not conse nt to b.. involvcd in ,I highway accident. They also did nOI u.~e the seat belt.s available in the vehicle. Failure to usc sca t bellS is II contributing factor to the vklims' injuries. but by fur the biggest GlUS,' o(this tragedy was th,' ncgligence orthe driver and the company employing him. Could Ihe lortfeasors claim Ih at the rcal cause of th e accid ent was the policc officer by the side of the road who clocked the vall .•cared the unlicensed drivcr, ,1110.1 precipitated the ""ident? No, Ihe police omcer had tl'ery right I" be thcre, and a rtason~ble person would knnw that. A rCdsnnab le person wou ld not h,lYe drivcn with Ihe n'Cord Ihat }~remy Holmes had. A reasonable employer woul d nOI have aUow,>(\ such an employee to superv ise a salcs crc'~ aud drive a vall. A reasonable company owoer would nol have PUI into commercial usc a van thJt was unlicensed, unregistered, and improperly insured. l his ewnt satisfies aU Ihe requirements of a tort of groM negligence wi th grd"c damages. Gross negligencc is m()st serious because it is a conscious. ,>o luntary act that 'I mounts to a reckless disr"Sanl of a legal duty. Y'JU ca nnot ~y that any nflhe tnrtfeasofS intended 10 harm the victims, hut hy their ulla indifrtrcncc tn the welfare of otha.~, they came vcry close to intentional behavior. TIle vic tims d id receive some co mpensation fur Iheir damages from insurance that was available, bUI not cnough \0 mcet their future ne~ds or compensate for the losse5. Exact figurcsonlhc dantages vic lims recovered aTe un availab le because of settled claims and scaled court records. The fOrtfe3sors were wiped out financially, and they h,we also faced fclony criminal charges stemming from this incident.
J,
*
~I
h
68
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
TEST YOURSELF As a tribute to television past and present, I'd like to take th e exerdse examples from classical moments on the sma ll screen _ 1.
In the opening credits to The Dick Van Dyke Show, a jolly Rob Petrie comes home to New Rochelle, New York, after a busy day writing comedy. He kisses his wife, Laura. He wa lks into the living room and takes a dass;c pratfall over the ottoman, arms and legs fla il ing. He bounces one las t time onto h is feet, smiling and happy. Tort o r no tort?
2.
In a 1991 episode of LA. Law, the senior partner, Le land McKenzie, is speaking with a fellow attorney and former paramou r, Rosa lind Shays, as they leave the office. They are getting heated in their remarks. The eleva tor door opens, Rosalind wal ks into the e levator with one last zinger to Lela nd, and-Ahhhh!- the audience hea rs a fad in g scream and a splat. The elevator was no t funct ion ing properly. The episode was tit led "Good to the Last Drop." Tort or no tort?
3. In a 200S ep isode of Las Vegas, new casin o owner Monica Mancuso is on the roof arguing with Danny McCoy. She is dressed in a wild, kimono -sleeved gow n. A hug e gust of wind comes along and flies her off the roof while Styx's 'Come Sail Away· is playing for the fade· out. We leam in th e next episode that she lands in the front window of a high-end shoe store. Tort or no tort? 4.
CBS had nex t year's rating s in the bag when they ended the 1979- 60 season of Dallas with the mother of all cliff-hangers, Who shot.JR! Tort or no tort?
Answe rs can be found on pages 214-215.
"' "
•
CHAPTEII6 • THE RECIPE FO R A TORT
K'E tJ P,OINTS TOl REMEMB.ER . A tort is a personal injury for which the law gives a remedy, usually damages, to put the injured party back in the position he was in before the incid ent happened. Torts, like crimes, can be caused by intentional, reckless, or negligent conduct. The more serious the intention to cause harm, the more serious the consequences; the more se riou s the harm caused, the more serious the consequences. To recove r for a to rt, you need to have al l th e se ing redients: duty, breach, dama ges, and causation. If the recipe falls short of an ingredi en t, you do not have a to rt. You may have an emballanment, or a blund e r, or a leally good entry for America's Funniest Home Videos. If you have a winning recipe, you can recover fo r your losses and some related expenses. In ra re instances, tori cla ims can result in punitive damages. To prolecl yourself against a tort claim, YOll may be able to use defenses to offset liability. Defenses indude consent, assumption of the risk, and contributory and comparative negligence, On occasion, the law doesn't care if you have the recipe exactly rig ht to establish a tort. It imposes strict liability on ind ividuals who engage in unusually dangerous activity.
,
"
69
Urheberre<;htlich ge5chlitltes Material
The Recipe for a Contract
T
oday
I~
a typlcaIThur~day. It
entered in to or
e~erdsed
I~
10:45 in the morning. and I have already
my rights in a11ea5110 contracts.
I we nt out to my"" at about 7:10 A.M. to drive my husband to his job. I was confident doing so because I know I have adequa te ca r insurance in
force to protect me. my car, ilnd my sleepy hus bilnd. Westopped at the bagel shop. I contracted for a plain bagel and a coffee.
On the way out. I purchased a newspilperfrom the stand on the corner. I dfOpped my husband off at work, because he has 11 contract to b", there by 8:00 A.M .. and I hea ded hom e. Befo re I cou ld beg in work. I needed 10
check {hI" news, and thanks to an ag reement with the local ca ble provider, I
am able 10 do t hat by switch ing on the television.
Fi nally, it is time to get to wo rk , so I fire up t he new I"ptop, stili under w"rmnty, "nd do some online research thanks to my contract with the Internet provi der. At about 10:00, I go to the refrigerator for some or"nge juice that I purchilsed ilt the locill groceryesterd"y. I getil cali from the w"ter compilny about com ing to ,ead the inside meter at a tim e when I am home. We have a contr"c! that provides for periodic, inside checks. With ali t his contracting going on, it Is a wond er t here is any time to write, and this chapter Is d ue, by con trac t, before th e en d of th is month!
Jrhch~"
II h
la
72
PART II; CIVI L LAW IN DETAIL
Th ere i, noth ing to be int imida ted about when you consider .tudying contracts. You have been using them every day, all day, toryears. This chapter will put that knowledge into fow •.
v.t.tl.AT' 5 , A l;I.E A D Contract Types
Capacity
Agreements That Are Not Contracts
Legality Vo lun tariness
Offer
Quasi Contrac t and
Acce ptance
Promi.sory Es toppel
Consideration
IN TH E REA L WORLD Mr. a nd Mrs. Buyer we re Ihrilled 10 be [nuking fo r their first ho u,,:. TIley had .1list of ewryth ing they \\"antt·d: an older home, ,I yard fN the kids, and hardwood !lOOTS. They had Ihis im3ge ofthdr family lounging in the living room - fire in the firepl3ce, Christmas tm: in the comer. and gleaming oak beneath their feet. When they saw Mr. and Mrs. Selle r's 1920s brick home at 123 Cherry Lane. th ey were interesk'11 anxious and excited that they called the Sellers til .~e,' if
CHAPrElI 7 ' THE REC IPE FOR A CONTRACT
73
Ihey could come over 10 m,'asure for drapes. No convenient time could hi' found. About ]0 da)'s before the closing, the Buyers tried to arrange a tim e to review the ups tairs layout, but ag ai n, the Sellers were just too busy. It was hard to wait, but the Buyers di d, until the night hefore the closing. 'Ihe Sellers had moved o ut that da y and the Buyers did not sec the harm in driving over to look around. 'lhey wal ked up the front sleps, ~ Iq)ped onto the hig front porch, and lovi ngl y looked through the pict ure window,s into the living roo m. What? Could it he? lhey pee red in again, and confirmed that Ihe middle of the IS' x 20' li\"ing room was not glea min g hanlwood, but mw plywood. Onl y about two feet uf the room's edges wen;, oak HOOTing. The Sellers had had a large arca rug in this room. The Realtor's descriptioo of th e tloors throughout th e house read SOME IIARO WO O D FLOORS .
Did the BuyeVl and Sellers have a good contract? Did it con tain all the necessary ingredients to be enfo rceable? What ifthe Buyers did not go through with their ;lgreemcnt? Could thc Sellen .'ue them for damages? What WOUhllho.,c damage., be? Do the Buyers have any reC" Ufl;e undl'r the circurll .• tancu to defl'nd themselves against a claim tha t they breachc.,] their promise 10 buy the house?
KEY CONCEPTS Co ntract actions, along with torts, mak" up the two main categories of civil law. In the last chapter, we reviewe.,] torts, or perso nal injuries, thnt often arise from an unexp"cted and unanticipated event. Co ntracts, on the other hand, itTe u.,ually wmful agreements that people enter inlo, but they co me in many shapes and sizes. It i., ea$y to get illlimi.,]at~d with JlI the sp~cia l ized contrdClte rm s that legal and husincss texts throw amund, but many uf these term s make perfect sense if yo u thin k JboUI them with examp les.
Co ntract Types ContrJctscan he wri tt en. like it leasc "grccmcnl lilT yo ur apartment. " rthe y ..tn he oml, like going into a paint store ilnd getting it ):\ullon ofCOnktnplation GreelL. Some peuple g<'l all excik'<.l about Ihis point and think a valid
74
PART II; (IVIL LAW IN DETAIL
c"ntrad must he written d"wn, hut that is n"t lrue in mosl (ases, Ay far, the majority of contmcts peo ple elller into arc or~l. Contracts may be express o r im pli~d. If they arc expressL'tI. they have been e~prcsscd ora lly or in writing. If they arc implied, no words of cnn· trJCling hal'e been spoken. For example, the paperb oy delivers the Vlli/y Times to my fro nt door at about 5:00 A.M. He docs not knock on the do or 0'1'0'1)' d"y and wake me to ask if! w~nt the paper; he just throws it vcr)' hard against the front door. r go to a grocery checko ut counter, hold up my candy har, depmi l 50 cen ts o n the cou nt er, and walk o ut. I don't want a witnessed, wrilten record of that tr:lllsaction; I don't CWll have to utt er a II'0rd bec;\u.le my act inns say it all. Co nt rJcts can he e~ecll ted or execlltory. These terms refer to the time it ta kes to complete the agreC Illl'nt. My candy bar purchase is an cncuted contract. The deal is done, fu lly performed when I give money and get the chocolate bar. My apa rtment lease is an execulory contract. lt is going 10 be performed over ,I period of tim e. It is $til l ongoing, alth ough the terms hav~ hee n sct and ",on't change Juring the length oflhe l ~ase. r am huyin g my ca r with an executory cont ract. r did not pay l'lT it all at once, out r will be p~ying over the nex t 36 months. Finally, cont r~cts can be vali d, "oid, voidable, or invalid, These tefms just descrihe how bi nding the agreement is. A ,'alid cont ract is another name for an enforceable co nl rac\. A I'oid contrJct might look like it fils the recipe, hut it is not enforceable because of a term Of condition. A l'Oida/.JIc co ntr~ct docs fit the recipe, hut the law may stiH rcfuS\: tl) enforce it for some rca~on. A nd an inyalid contract is the same as an unenforceah le contract; it does not have all the ingredients nece'~ry to he enforceable.
Agreements That Are Not Contracts We make a lot of agree ments thaI the law will nol enforce, and those should be distinguished from contracts. For example, I tell my son Ihat r will take him to the zoo if he dean s hi s room. He canno t sue me in acourl ofb w if I fa il to get him to the zoo thaI day. I was just giving hi m some motivation. I may leUmy sister that I will gow ith herto visit Aunt Peggy. If I have to work that Jay and do not ma ke the Irip, my sister ca nn ot slie 111('. I jnsl thonght it would he a nice gesture to acco mp any her. If my neighbor drops a hag " f
CHAPrElI 7 • THE RECIPE FOR A CONTRACT
~mce ries unloadin~
75
her car and I we she has $p illed a quart of milk, I may
run o\'~r and give her the cxtrJ quart I have in my refrigerator, I C'.tn't sue hcr if she doesn't reimburse me; I was offcring a gift. O ther types of agreement~
that the law will not enforce include ethical obligatiom ("Our policy
is no refonds withoot a receipt, but yo u arc a rcgular customcr~) and sales pitches (~' Ihi~ will be the last du~t mop you eyer have to buy~).
The Recipe for a Co ntract Co ntmd s arc all abollt hargains . .~a le s, deals. and agr~'<'ments, 111e law will enforce the ones that follow th e redpe by haVing an olfer, an acce pt ance, co nsidcT"Jtio n, C'Jpaci t)'. legJli ty. and yol un tar incss. Offer, The first dement or ingredient is an offer. Somdimes people arc just talking oot a possible sccnario: "[ migbt scn m)' car~; "I'm thinking about a ne w high defillition tdevision"; or "Call't you just S('c you rself in this sports car? ~
'!he'e preli mirHlry di$cussion$ and ,\alc$ pitches arc Ilot offers. Dlfers
most be definite and they must come from a person who has an intentio n to he bound. Newspaper advertisements ~re not oifers; the)' He too gener~1 and nut made to specific individuals. That is why th" store can get away with not llJ vill g the adverlised ~deal" when you get there. So someonc has to start the ball rolling, and this is thc offeror. The offeror makes a promise to do so mething, buy something, exchange some thing, etc. An example of a specific olfer would be ~ rll give you S20 for )'OUf algebm book." It could also he a nonverbal olfer. such as unloadi ng your groce ry cart conlents on the checkout lane al the supermarket ami nodd ing your head that )'011 found every thin g you neede<1. Whether you put it into words or not. your behav ior indicates you arc olfering to purchase those items. An offer has to be received to be elfective, so the offeror must be specific and communicate it to the offeree. I cannot step into anotber person',; negotiation and expect the S
76
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
for a
rea.~onahle
lime. A reaso nable lime I" respond 10 huying a load of Cln be a much shurle r lime than a reasonable lime 10 respund to an offer 10 pur,halOl.' a house. Whal is reasunable dep(.'I1ds un Ihe subject of Ihe conlrJct. If timing is very important, the otfem r cao .~pecify ~Estimate good for 30 days" or whatever other timing he re<.jui res. ban~nas
Acceplrmce. Once ,\11 "tfer has been cum municated hy the otfcror 10 the
offeree , there ,m' some choices. 'lhc otferec may agree to the terms. 'Ihis
i.~
an Maplar"", TIle acceptdnce must be in the same f"rm as the "ffer. You cannut mak .. any cha nges, su iflhe offer is "I will sdl yuu Illy car for $],000," the acceptance rnu~t he something like ~okay" or ~dear or · SI,OOO it is." The acceptanc ... CJnn o{ be HO kay, $] ,000 for your car and an extra sct of ti res." This requirement that the offeree
CHAPrElI 7 • THE RECIPE FOR A CONTRACT
77
accep t.UICe for it to be dfedive. TIlis is calkd the m"iibox rule. TIle law likes to Interpret that an agreemcnt bctween the parties has taken place as soon as poss ible. so once there is an offer
1ll01l~y).
If you in1crprct "J will pay YOIl $2,000 if YOIl paint my house" unilateral contract. you have tn paint my whole ho u~ hcl<}fe [owe you
a penny, bec.tuse 1 promised and )'OU must act. 1 could walk ou t of my aircondition.od living roo m into th ... 1 lO-d~grce heat you aft.' working in and SO the prefe rence is 10 interpret Jil contracts 3" bilaleral co ntracts, o r two -p romi.o;c deal-. If yo II interpret "I will pay y\'U $2,000 i f yo u paint my house" as a bilateral co ntract, J am prom isingt" payyoll if you
promi~
to paint my hOIL.'c. Once tht.'l'l"Omises
Jre exchanged. there is a deal (assuming all the other ingH'dients arc preselu ) and the action is co mp lete. TIlerefore, 1 CJnnUI renege un my half of the deal bdore the ofTcre,' is finished with the action. Bibteral contracts arc considered fairer and more cificient in recognizing the bargain immediate lyupon the "meeting of the minds" to con lm et. Of course, there is still good usc for unilalera l contracts, and some times the offeror who is in conlrol of the terms wants to specify that he reqlLires completed action on the pJrt of the olfe ree befoTe he acts. For example, if I contracted fOT a cu"t(Jlll-made
78
PARr II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
gown to wcar to my sou\ wedding, I would want to specify that I wil! not pay in full unlll I am satisfied with the workmanship and fit. CoII$;tirrIlIiIJII, ·[he third ingredient in a binding contnlct is cOI1.itimlliol1. Co nsideration is not politeness, although polite hu.'ines.~ dea lings arc always cncour~g~-J. Coosidt')""ation has a special meaoing in the law and rden; to the fact that the parti~s ~nter into a bargained-for exchangc. This exchange of something onegal value distinguishes a bindin g contract from a gift.llw something oflegal valuc is otien mone y, atlcast on onc side of the deal, but money is not the only consid e)""ation gi"en in contracl5. The cxchange could he an item foran item, or an ih' m for some type of conduct. Co nsidenlti on is doing so methillg that you are not legally o blib'Olted to do. I am not obligated to go to work every day. [ could sit home 'Illd cat honbOllil, but [ choo>c to exchange Illy daytime huu rs for payment from mr h05.l. Cott~idcmtion is also refrJining from doing something you have evcry kgal right to do. Fo r example, my nephe w is over IS anJ has every right to smoke. r Jo not like smoking. I promis~ him $500 if he quits smoking for six months. He quits, and the only reason he docs is because I madl' an agreement with him . He is giving up something he has every right to do specifirully in exchange for my promise to pay him $500. lfhe quits for six months, 1owc him $500.1 Ie has ncry kg al right to colkd th at frolll tnt'. I OUlIIot s;lyto hilll, ~Ah , you should l];Ivl' 'lu it anyway, and I did YO Il a big favor." I havl' to pay. Capacity. ·Ihe next ingredient in a bi nding co ntract is capac ily. ·lhe law rcstricts so mc individuals from making binding contrach. ~'linors c~n not entcr int o hinding contracts unless th ey dre for nec~.'iS ities, like food aml ., helter.ll1is law prcVl'1l1s disreputah lc indi vidna ls and busin esscs from taking advantage of minors who may not be mature cnough to ~nter into contrdC\s knowl~d geahly. In most states, minori ty termina tes at 18 years of age. "Ihe law also protec ts those opemtins under a mental imp airme nt from enter ing into binding contmcts.l'1'lcntal impairment docs not relate to a ce rtain IQ or ase; it relates to whether an individual has an appreciation of the consequences of his act io ns. Ofte n elderly or infi rm individuals bave questio nahle conl mct cJ pacity, but 50 can healthy 30-year-olds after majo r surgery Of duri ng a significant illness,
"' "
•
CHAPrElI 7 • THE REC IPE FOR A CONTRACT
79
Legulity. TIle fifth ingreJ ient in a h indingconlrdct is!eg,IIity.TIle law will no! enforce a contrdcl for an illegal purposc.lhcreforc, cu nlracts regarding prostilution, il1~'Sal gambling, ;11'1.1 agwcm~nts \0 co mmit torts arc not enforceahle. Anothertype nfcnntract thaI is lad::ing in legalilY ho ne Ihal is contr.lry 10 public pnlicy. -Ihese contracls wnuld includc agrccmcnt scontaining cxculpalory clauses. An e.nulpatory dame i~ a provision tha t atlemph 10 relieve o ne ]Xlrty from liah ility. A surg~on wou ld be using an e~cu lpatory clau se if he asked his pa tient.~ 10 ~ ign an agreement promising never to sue him under any circomstances. This is d iJfercnl frum signing an infi.,rmcd c<",sent Ihat a surgical procedure ma), be dangerous. An exculpatory clause \\"ould attem pt tn exculpate. or free, the _~u rgeon from li ah ility even ifth~ surg~"On was negli gcnt in his care. Annlher examp le nf a contr.lCI cn nlrJry 10 puhlic pnlicy is a conlrJcll hal is so one -si,jcd asto be un conscionable. An unwn,cionablc con-
tra ct is one Ihal is OUlrJg~"OUS or unscrupulous, usually oeCiusc the parties have such unequal barg
"' "
•
80
PART II; (IVI L LAW IN DETAIL
A cu nt rJct is misrepresented if one party gi ve.~ falo;c in ti.rmaliun abuu t a fact that may alfect the ag rcem en1. I'or cKamplc, maybe myculVorkcr and i were not thinkin g about ditferent cars. We both intended our transaction to refer to the Miata, but befor~ he olfers me $17,000, he asks me if [ have had any trouble with the convertible leaking. I say [have not, although Ihat is the prime reason I am gelling rid of it. ·Ihis misreprnentatioll could affect the vo lulltarilless of thi s hiLrgain. 1\'l y coworker wuul d not have otfered $17,001) fo r a leaky ca r. de.~pitc its sleek eKterior. A contnlCt is fraudulenl if one parly deliberately ur int en tion ally misrepresents a fact ailtlut the suhject of the agreemen t. When you make a fmud ulcnt statement in a COlllnlcl negotiation, you inlend to deceive the other party. [t could he fraud if [ went on the say tn my coworker, "The /l.tiata has never leaked; you have not hing 10 worry aboutlhere:' This d early affects th e voluntarincss of the agreement, and if fm ud is presenl, the contrJct can be v(>ided lOr ca ncell ed. [f all si." clements of a contract arc present and one party docs not perform ;IS promi.,cd, the injured party c"uld sue in cou rt for d amage~. CQlltr,/c/ dam ages HTe calculated 10 give the i nju~d pany the heneflls of the bargai n and;tTe discussed in detail in chapter 10. [fyou wantvcry dctd as a unilateul con tract , put it in your agTl't'llicnl. Contl'"ct~ arc between ind ividuals in society, anrJ freedom of cont ract is a basic, funrJamenlal right rcs('rv('d 10 the people by the Fifth and Fourteenth Amen rJ mcnls 10 Ihe u.s. Constitution. Indivi duals and busin~.'sses arc very free to ente r into c"ntl'acts ahout any legal subject.lhe law docs not care if your cont ra ct is a good dcal. ·Ihe Jaw will e uforce a cont ract in which o ne p"ny overpays for an item. The I
Quasi Co ntract and Pro missory Estoppe l Somelimesau in gre dient is missing. You lo ok so me sleps. did some work, paid some money. but technically you don·1 have a good contract. In thi s case. Ihe law may give )'ou some relief cven though you goofed lIl). One thiog the ,0"11 may do is liste n ttl an argnment in quas i c(ln/r.W , or
CHAPrElI 7 ' THE REC IPE FOR A CONTRACT
81
~almost w ntr.td." [n thi' case, yuu thruw yourself on the mercy o r the court, admit that yo u w<, re a little lacking in the r<'cip~ , but ask for some relief to u\'oid a tnriblc injustice. Sornctim<,s you r<'ally miss 'l ui te;1 few ingredient.~ to a goo d co ntract. In that case you may argue promissory estoppel, hegging the court to estop, or prevent, Ihe other party from de ny ing the deal because you. the injured party, have significantly relied on this faulty harg'lin, and allowi ng the " Iher parly 10 gel "ut ufth e agree ment would unjustly enrich him . Quasi coni tJct and promissory cstoppel arguments are l"1 uitahle remedic.. (see chapter 2) and the court is allo wed to acl, no l b~cause it is interp reting a legally ~nforccablc agreemenl, hut heca u.<;c it is preventing an unfairness. TIll.' classic pnuni~s"ry estoppel eKample is the roofing company that comes 10 your house and h,'gins to put on a new roof, which yo u go oul and watch them imtaJl,
el'e n Ihough you know they mean t to do the neighhor's roof. Significant value was given to YOIl in a new roof. YOIl could have spoken up and prevcnted th e .itu 'ltion that ha_, unju~ t ly (Onrichcd you. Technically, there is no co ntra ct helwecn yo u and the roofmg co mpan )', hut it w"uld he an injustice 1101 tn provide the cnm pany with some relief- that is, money for the job, 'Ihese noncontracl argumellts are bro ughllo court morc often than you may Ihink, mainly hecause a 101 of people try 10 do their ow n contracl~ without legal advice, goo fup in the particulars, and then need help enforcing th eir rights.
TH E LAW IN ACTION Do the Buyer.> and Sellers have a legally enforceJh1c agreemene Let's check the ingr~x1ienb: 1.
lhe Buyers mad e a wr!ItI.'n oITer to Ihe Sellers. [I was dear and dcfinile-123 Cherry Lane fo r $91 ,000. It was com municJted to the Sellers through the Realtor. This was a bilatcrJl agreement, completed when Ihe olfer to purchase was signed. 'Ihe Buyers promised 10 buy and the Sellers promised to sell. The deJI would be completed within one mo nth, at the actual dosing of the sale. but the pfl)mises binding the parties to Ih<, conlract were mad~ when each party signed Ihe olrer t<) purchaw.
82 2.
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
The Sellers accept<'d the olfer. TI,ey thought aoout it fi,r a hit, out they signed it and dispatched their 3cceptance by returning the signed offer to purchase. TIle}' did not chJnge the terms and counterofrer a price of $95,(}()0, 3Jt hoogh that is wh3 t the y hoped to get in it ially. They accepted the offer that was made to them with no changes.
3. There was considerJtion. Considerdtion is a barg3incd-for exchange. lhe Sellers are selling their house, which they arc not lcg;illy obligated 10 do. The Buyers arc gh'ing S9l ,000 of their moncy to the Sellers. whi ch they al1' not obligated to do. Both a 11' gelling somethi ng of value. 4.
Both the Buyers and th e Sellers have' capacity 10 en ter into binding con tracts. TIley arc of legal age and there al1' no disaOilitics oper.lling in this ca.",.
5.
The con tmct meets thc rcqu irement of legalit y. Buying and se ll ing real ~state is leg;d everyw here in this country.
o.
[t appears that Ihis (onl mel was voluntarilycnlered into. No one forced the Scllel"$ to take this otfer or to mo\"C in the first pb'e. 'Ihc Buyrr.• certainly took thd r time and looked at th is house on three oCCJsio ns b"forc deciding to m;lkc all ol rer.
Th.· parties' respective positio ns vary. As fa r as the SeUns arc concerned, there is a binding contmct th~t the law sho uld enforce. "l he Buyers shou ld be made, by a court, to complete the transaction no matter what issues they haw wit h the living room 1I00r. After nil, they arc gelling a gre~t house. '[hey can pul down a rug or even install hardwood !loo rboards if they wish. The Seller., belil'\'e a wurt ,h(}uld award thelll d;lmage.• in the amoun t of $95.000 if the Buyers don' t follow through on the deaL As for the Buyers, they arc in shock. How cou ld this have happened? Did n't they ~ sk specifically about the 1100rs? We re there ulterior motives at play when the Sellers would never be av-.lilable to let th em measure for curtains? If the SelleTh lied about the Iloor, what other haurds lurk? Sure, there was an offer, acceptance, considerat ion, capacity, a nd legality, but not so fast on th e vo lun ta ri ness. 'lh e Buyers bal"'6'l in ed for a house with hardwood fl oors in the living roo m. not plywood. At a minimum there was a mistake. The dealings prohably point mo re to a mi.
CHAPrElI 7 _ THE REC IPE FOR A CONTRACT
83
,,,urt should n"t enfurcc this , ,,ntr,let due to the lack of vo luntary agreement. However, the lluyers adm it that hardwood Jloorb oards could be installed in the li ving room for abo ut 52,200, which is about 2 percent of the purchase price, Hove you decided whom you arc moting for! Keep
re~ding
to discover
the conclusion to this case in chapter 8.
TEST YOURSELF 1,
David Doright h
"r~en
t~ l ev ision
in his living room and tunes in to his favorite 'how, Anriques Roadshow. Ton ight's program idrom St. l ouis, his hometown. Although it is stric tly a hobby for him, David fancies h imse lf pretty savvy about aotiq ues. Ha lfway through the show, a ,mall chest of drawers is featured. The owner, a young man, tells that he bought it about six months ago a t a garage sale to furnish his first apartment. The chest looks familiar to DaVid. As he leans in to get a better view, David realizes that this is the old chest from his basement, which he sold at his I
Judy sta rts her day with a piping hot cup of coffee from the vending mac hine in the lunchroom. Today, she puts in her dollar and out comes the aromatic vanil la cappuccino- right onto the floor and her new suede shoes. The cup failed to fall int o p lace. Is this a breach of con tract Or a tort?
3.
Sally's son, Rex, is an active boy_ He is also q uite big for a seven-yearold. Last Saturday, Sally was picking up a wedding present in the china shop. and while checking out, she let go of Rex', hand for jUH a minute. (ra.lh! A lovely Waterford vase was sma.lhed to bits. The owner has a clear sign at the entrance, You BREA K IT, YOU BUY fT. What happens next?
"
84
PAR r II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAI L
Brain Teasers 4.
Arthur Roberts is a famous architect. He is in demand to design unique houses for the rich and famous. Mr. Roberts just finished an eight·month·long project-a Malibu estate for Mr. and Mrs. Rock Star, At the dosing today, the Stars refused to pay the balance due to Roberts of $560,000 because they just learned that Mr. Roberts let his architect's license lapse by failing to send in his renewal fee of $25 on time. The Sta rs afe claiming that this is an illegal contract since
Mr. Robem was not legally licensed throughout the contract. Is the con tr~ct
5.
illegal. and thus unenfo rceilble!
Dan contracted with Eric to do the sno w removal on his property this last winter. They agreed that (or all snow removal needed from November though March, Dan would pay $200. Dan paid Eric in (ull o n November 8. Throug h Match 31, it only snowed two times. Can Dan ask for a refund? What if it had snowed 30 times last winter? Cou ld Eric alk for more compensation? Could promissory estoppel a pply here?
Question Future Chapters Wi ll Answer 6.
What will happen to the Buyers and Sellers of 123 Chl!rry lane? I( thl! Buyers brea ch a legal a greement, what w ill the consequences be? Are there any defenses the Buye rs (Quid raise so they don't have to go through with this deal? In tort situations, there ale some defenses that ciln be raised such as contributory or comparative negligence . Would this approach help here ?
An swers can be found on pages 215 - 218.
"' "
85
CHAPrElI 7 • THE REC IPE FOR A CONTRACT
K'E tJ P,OINTS TOl REMEMB.ER . Contract law is a category of civil law concerning private rights between parties who make an agreement. Contracts come in many forms: writt('n and oral. implied and
('~.
press, executed and ex ecutory, and unilateral and bilateral. These are ~II terms that descr ibe an aspect of th e agreement. A contract is an agreement the law will enforce. The recipe for a binding contract is offer, acceptance, consideration. capacity. lega lity, and voluntarineH. If you don't have all the ingredients to form a binding contract, you may have a gift. ethical obligation. sales pitch. or motivationa l promise, but not a lega lly e nforceable ag reement. If you have al l the ingredients to fo rm a bind ing con tract, the law will protect you so that you get what you bargained for. To be sure you have a winning recipe for
be sure to
yourcontr~ct,
ask for al l the extra ingredienl! that a re important to you. If your recipe almost works, but falls short of an ingredient, the law may enforce your promises using an equitable remedy ca ll ed promissory estoppe l.
,
"
Urheberre<;htlich ge5chlitltes Material
Contracts: Do You Always Have to Do What You Promised? recent ly had to replace the printer I use at home. I shopped around,
I
looked
advice. After considerable deliberation,l bought a name-brand model with
a wireless feature from a big box electronic Sio re. That wasan easy contract. By the t ime I had done a ll the research , I just went in, pointed to the one I
wanted, and chec ked out. Contract co mpleted. Then th e trouble began. The printer was very hard to hook up and didn't function wi relessly. I hired a computer wiza rd to help with the set up.
When he could get the printerto work, it was very slow - much slower than advertised-and it made a loud grinding noise in the proces s of printing.
After two attemph at wirele~~ hookup, I attempted to
u~e
the printer with
a cable, a nd that wa~ no more reliable. I thought I knew what I wanted and needed in a home printer, but thl~ is not it. I am not happy with my co ntract. The big box store claims in adver· ti~emen t~
that they want
sati~fied
ctlstomers, ~o they shou ld not be happy
either. Can I get out of my ba rgain? Can I get reimbu rsed for the bills I paid to the computer wiza rdl
Jrhch~"
II h
I"
88
PART II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
v.[jlj AT'S I A ~E A D Discharge by Imposs ibility
Material Breach
Discharge by Operation
Defenses to Contract
of liIw
Per/ormance
Discharge by Rescission
Mistake
Conlract Breach
Misrepresentat ion
Spedfic Performance
Fraud
Substantial Perfo rman ce
IN THE REAL WORLD In chap ter 7. we met the Sellers and the Buyers. 'lhey entcred into a legally contr.r.ct to excha nge owne rsh ip of a house (or S9 1,000. The promises were mad,'; the deal w~s don,·. All that was left "'as the ,,/fi cidl
enforceab l ~
dosin g. The nir,ht before tbe sched uled dosing. the Buyers learned that the hou se "'as not as they expcCk"d. The beautiful hardwood living room floor was mostly plywoo d that h~d been cove red by a rug. 'Ihe Buycrs arc now questio ning every assurance the Sellers made about the home. They want to hack o ut of the deal hut don't exactly know wh~t that mean s. Can they he forced to huy the house? Cr the Sellers) knew nothing aOOnt thl' 110M "prob l.'m: TIl{' Sell.,TS had told the ir Reallor lh atlhe house had "some hardwood tloo rs," which w~s lrue, as one bedroo m was carpeted and the kitchen was tiled. No one had pulled back the rug in the living room to look nnderne,rth. The Sellers did not olfer the plf\" ood information at any time, although thcy admit they were asked some general questions ab out the floors before the olfer was made. The Sell ers have moved out. TIley lMVe taken significa lll and .~Ub.~talllial steps in rdiance Oil this deal. from their poi nt of vi~w> the Hoor "p rohl~ m" is minHr cu mpared to the gr~at piece of rea l estale the Buyers are getti ng. Even
(flAPTE~ 8
• DO YOU I
89
Ihe Buyers adlllillhallhey wanled an older home and wi lh il. Ihey e~pcclcd sollie surpriS<'s. Well. here is snrpriS<' nUlllberonc: [n Ihe 1920s. sOllie honse, were built wilh hardwood tloor$ only allhe cdges of Ihe room$. Area rugs and Ihi~ building fealure were commonly u!;cd 10 save COSIS. II wou ld lake about $2.2UO 10 put hardwood flooring in the midd le of the room if the Buyers 50 chose. ·Ihe Sellen know for a fact that thc Buyer~ werc going to ~pend Ihis much o n new dr~pcs for the living mom. Can Ihe Sellers force Ihe Buyers 10 buy the house? Can the Sellers keep Ihe home and al50 get damages frum the Buyers for breach of contract? I [ow much can they get? Whatever happened to ~uyer br w~re? ISlillhere SOme kind oflaw?
KEY CONCEPTS Chapler 7 outlined the ingredients n~"
Co ntract Breach When a party fai ls to perform what he promised. he brl'ilches, or breaks. the cuntf.lct. Thi~ failure hascon_,cqucnce. not on ly fur the party breaching the deJI but also for the injured part)!. [f my neighbor, Philip. hreaks his agreement to drive mc to work today.ll<.' isthe one who failed to pnforrn . bu t as a consequence, I have to pay $3 to take the bus to work. ~'ly agreement with Philip is that [ pay him $2 per day. so his failure has cost me $1. As a genel'J I rule, the person breaking the conlract should compensate the injured party by giving hi m the benefit of Ihe bargain. In that case, I should not have to pay Philip for the Iran5portalion that I did not receive an d I shou ld gct S t from him to cover the e~ tm costs I paid 10 lake the bus. Bul, [ also arril'ed latc at work and that was a pwblcrn. I often am slow gctting started in the morning and alll usually latc getting back from
90
PARr II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
lu nch. Today, whcn I was running in, the bo., infor med me that I wou ld be gett in g a negative review this mo nth due to tardiness, so no bonus for me. Can I sul' my neigh bo r for the los t bon us that his missed ridl' caused? No, [ ('.Innot. Co nt l"",\C! damages arc limited to compemating the injured porty for the benefit of the bargain. not for items that are nOI foreseeable or reuwnably related to thc deal. The hIW i\ very liberal in the ru les that allow pa rties to enter in to contrJcts, w, in cases of breach of co nt ract, th e law docs not award punitive damages, a. it does in some tort ca'ICs. Adults and bus ines'ICs arc free to enler in to an)' barllains they desire tha t are leSal. If yo u make a bad (o llt mct, 11w law is not gOillS to pun ish the oth er side with excessive damagcs.ln my ca.~e, I should have a reasonable backup plan, which I do, with m)' SJ bus ride. If Philip proves himself unrcliabk' repeatedly, I am free 10 contrJcl elsewhere.
Discharge by Impossibility. So mN imes things happen that mokc 0 eo ntm et im possible to perform. Ex amples of impossib il ities include tbe death of a party to a CO nim ct, the J~stru ctio n of an item that is the ~u bject of the co nlmet. or an aet of God. Whcn a conlract is legally impossible to pe rfor m, Ihe CO ni!"".l Ct is vo ided and therefore it is uv~r. [(K itt y Carlislc had Jgreed to sing the nmn·s he irs could stiU sell me the hous~. if th ey wislll'd, but the agr,'cmcnt bdween me and the de ceased cou ld be \'o id ed if the hdrs wished to void il. [fthe man's house burned dow n before the dosins. I cOlil d void the contract duc to destruc tion of the subject matter of the deal. I need a house to live in. not a ve ry emply lot eve n if it is otfered with a brge check from Ihe insuranCl' company for the homc·s valu e. Similarly, a contract ca n be voided by an /l ei o[God, which refers to a natuml occurre ncc. such as a lIood o r tornado, th"t coul d not have been prevented or foreseen . When an act of God strikes, the subjec t matter of Ihe contract L\ usually dcstruyed.
"
•
CflAPTE~ 8
• DO YOU I
91
Disdw rge b,· Opendio'l of Law. There arc al.1n a few specific laws th at forgil'e performance of a co nt ract. '[he fint one is the statute of limitations. The ,Iature ofJimilariom is a procedural law that says a legal claim must be brought within a certain period of time. Most contract claims havc a sta tute oflimitation s of 10 years. You mu st sue to enforce a cont ract within 10 years of the breach, or the cause of action is too stale. 'Ihislaw protects against ancien t claims bein g brought to co urt where ev idence is old and memories arc poor. 'I he ot her law that mar (orgive per(ormance i.~ the hankruptcy act. Ce rtain deb tors are discharged fro m performing their C'lllt r~ct obligation., ifthe y arc de cb red legall y bankrupt. Discllarge by Resdssio fl. Occasionally, both parties to a contr~ct may
change theiT minds. This is callcd a contract rcninion. In effect, a rcscis· sion voids the deal. Rescission mllSl be a mutual decision by the parties, not a one·sidcd backing oul of the de al. Techni caUy, when parties ab'Trc to rescind a co ntra ct. they enter int o a ne w offe r and acceptance. ag~ei n g not to perfo rm on their previo us pro rni'ICs. The consideration for the rescis sion is their mutual nonenforcement of th e origi n~l term s. In th .. case o( a reM: issio n, eJch party should be put back in the place th ey were befure the contact wa,~ entered into, as if th e deal had ne"u h'lppencd. An example ()f a co ntrJct rescissi on could in"ol"e your choice of gnl(Juat e school. If yo u werl' accepted at a school you likl'd and indie-dled yo u would altl'nd, but then your number one choice accepted yo u, you an d !he first school may mutually agree that you will accept the new otfer. 'lhe first school docs not reaUy mind since it has a wait ing Ii,_t of othercan didatc~ anxio us to get in. So, to rec;!]), o nce you emer imo a co n!r.ld, you could perform it to its com pletion. That is a disd large hy perfo rm ance. You coul d be excused fro m performa nce becd use of a death , destru ction, ur act ofGoJ. Th is is J di scharge by imp ossib ility. You cOlild be excused from perfo rm ance be· Ca USe oflh e statute oflimitations ordue to a bankruptcy. 'lhis is a discharge by operJtion oflaw. Or you could mutually decide to cancel the deal. This is a discharge by rescissi on.
Specific Performunce. In the mre instance where compensatio n for the henefit of the hargain is not satisfactory, th e law will co nsid er o rder· in g the hreaching party t" specifically perfor m the contract. Specific
92
PARr II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
paforma>1Cf is unusual hl'causl' it is rMe Ih,lt monelary damages can n" t lake c..tre oflhe breach. For the cou rt to a ..... ard specific performa nce, the casl.' has 10 in\,ol,,1.' unique or rare items. If I had J contr..tct to bu y a KUTt Vonncb'llt drJwing (ye.l, he was an artist as well
a.~
an author) for $2,500
and the ..leakr selling it changed his mind. I would not want to accept my $2,500 hack. I want that particular dmwing. 'Iherc is not anothcr onc likc
it and I madc a deal. 1he filet that the dealer got scntimental is too bad. 'Ihc fact that Kurt Vonncgul died beforc Ihe drawing was delivered 10 me, so that now its "alu~ is much
high~r,
is also too had fm the J~aler. Money
ca nn ot gh'e me the be nefit of the bargain. Only the item itsc!f wiH do, and in rare, uniquc cases like this, the court may on.l cr the parties to co Ulp1c\c the contrJ.cI as made.
SlibSlalltiul Performance. AsdiSQl&Scd in chapter I, the law docs not require a perso ll or husines.1 to be perfect. Sometimes things do 1I0t go as planned. 'Ihcre arc co nlra ct rules thai cover !C:;S than perfect performance. If you do all of what you promised. you get the benefit of rOUT barga in. If ),ou ,10 most of what YOli pwmislxl, shouldn't YOli Sd mnst of what you bargained fiJT? The law thinks that you should and exhibits this b~l i efin the doctrine of sub!r(H1 -
tial performance. If a person subslantiallyperformson a co ntrdct, he does not do a perfect job, but he makes an honest and eameSI atlc'mpi to perform com pletely. Fo r example, my brother-in· law builds bouses. He is a great builder and rarely hasa complaint from clients. I Ie has a solid reputation in the com munity for nlfering a fine product and excelle nt workmanship. If on the closing date for a houS<' ht· has built. one thing rema ins incomplete- the ki tchen doOT handles (18 of them) are not in duc 10 a hack order-hds hc ., ubst'lnlially comple ted th~ hOllse? Of course he has. The con tmct should becomplekJ. he should he paid in full, and the cont ra ct sholdd be disch arged. He is going to prol"iddhe door h andles when they arrive and install them in a workm anlike manner. No one should want to hold up a moving \'..tn, a loan commitment for the bU >'ers, a comt ructionloan to pay olf for the builder, and the kids getti ng enrolled in their new school fur 18 door hand les. On occasion. a who le order docs not come in as planned, but 80 pe rcentofit can bc{lclil"crcd to the custom~r today and the nest in two days. Co ntl"m:ting parti es who have rclitxl on the agreement si nce the time the promiscs where exchanged Jo not wam to Slart ol"er IlOW. They want \(} make
•
CflAPTE~ 8
• DO YOU I
93
do, as well as they Cd n, and get complete perlimnallce as .1(1)11 as Ilossible. .Even if complete perfo rmance is nut possible, in many cont racti ng situations SO percent p~rrormance is prcr~rJbII.' to:wro pe rcent perfonnancc. In cases whe re perfect perform ance can never be achk ved, the parties might agree to amend their contract to cover what Cd n be supplied. For example, the selle r would provide 80 percen t of the urderand the buyer wuuld pay 80 percent or the purcha..... pri ce. 'nlis is c~lIed an accord and mtis/action. Ihe partksco me to an accord, or agreement. and conside r the contrJct Mlisfied.
Ma/crilll En'll' /! . On uccasiun. th cr~ is less tha n substantia lpcdurmance. This is called a material breach, meaning signific ant breach of co nlrac \. Under the se circumstances, one party gets Sig nifica ntly less than he expectNl in performance from th e other party, such that, for all intents and purposes, the con trJct is breached and some damages ,Ire owed. for exampl e, I am movi ng my IJW office from one IDcation to Jllother Jnd need some huild'out servicc.~ in my new locatio n. I hire A & S, In impmv~ment company. tD wa ll off a larg~ area into two otfices. hang new doors through out the slMce, install a check-in window in the recep tion area. and apply a fresh coa t <)f paint to Ih e space. All the work needs 10 be done in 60 dJYs. We a gr~ o n a contract price of $3,800 and I pay an $800 dl'pusit toward th e cost of supplies. After 60 days, I have terminated my rental agreement al my former location, packed up all my Dffice equipment and supplies, rented a moving ".In, and arranged fo r a hookup of all new ut ilit ies in the new location. A & S has removed JII the Did doors. put in a crooked wind ow in the recepti on Jr<'u that looks like it is fro m Ma and I'a Kcttk's hou"c, and pullip half the drywall. It i.1 moving day and Ihe space luoks worse than it ""a has. A & S has not done a complde job, or even J substanti al perrormance o r the (o utmCl . Its actions co nstilote a malrrial breach of comruct. Because of the deficiencies, I do nUl have to pay the remaining $3,000 contract price since I have not receh·ed the work this represe nt s, und I may have additional tort damages to claim again.<;t A & S because of the harm they caused tD my business by breaching our Jgreement. A & S co uld argue that they arc en titled to so me consideration, meaning mDn~y. fo r the work that they did .1 1,1; hDwever. th~ wDrk dDne fall~ so f~lr sho rt of th e work promised tha t a <':oll rl w
94
PARr II; CIVIL LAW IN DETAIL
Defenses to Contract Performance In considering defenses to co ntract performance, it is important to revisit the discu.,.ion of mi~takc, mi~rt'prcscntat ion, and frdud, begun in chapter 7. When any of these even ts occur, Ill<' vo luillarincss of a co nt mct can be questinned, hut, oil occasioll, these even ts arc also ll.<ed 10 defend ag'lin .• t the Cllfnrcemcnl of a con trac\' It is nol always easy to fi gure out if a mistake $hould negaW the demenl or vuluntar incss o r nol. Since contract htw does not protect against had bargains, the parties to a deal have the ohlig.. tion to be proxise and dearahou! the terms tbey desire. A daim that "I di dl}t know that old book was a " .. Iua ble first edition» will not defeat a valid contTdCt. However. lfthe mistake is made be,"rcprescl1lal ion usually notes a fa lse or misleading statemen t made with Ih,' intent to deceive. Usually
•
CflAPTE~ 8
• DO YOU I
95
the P,lrty m,lking the ,'tatement knows th,ll it docs not '~(Iuare with the facts. Misr~presentat ioos cao be ol'l' rly zealous guarantees like '''Ihis product will strip olf Sl.'yen layers of paint in flY(.' minult's.H They can he care· less stakmen\.~ like laheling a product "low fa( whe n it docs not meet the Food aod Drug Administrat ion staodards for a low-fat food. Misrcprcscotat ions can also he rcddc &5 or nq;ligent statemcnh like "Safe for childrcn undcr J" on a prol!uct with many .Imall jliLrts that children may choke 011. So, Sillc.• pitche1O, or Pfccontr,l(ting persuasion, arc not part of t hc contract, but false, misleading, nr reckless ,;.ales pitches could he so influential to the bargaining as tu be cunsidered a mi5r"prescnt~tioo, which intuTll, could n~b,lte ~ contract. TIle key to co nsidering whether a misreprcscntatioo can bl' used to n"gall" a contract is whether a party relied on it in making the deal. If a statemen t is material- that is, an imponant part of the deal - and it turns out to be false. perhaps the agreement should not be uphdd. II n example of a material misrrprc,'-Cntali on i, ,10 em ployer ldling an inlerviewee that thc husines,~ will always have a , trong presenc~ in th~ IOC'd l community even though he knnws the bllsines$ is set to mOye to Mexico in three months. Fnlilil is a dcllbcm\l' disregard of the truth. A person making a fraudul"nl statement in a con tract negotiation is telling a lie for the purpose of inducing the olher party to enter into Ihe bargain. TIlis He could be the telling of an unt ruth, which is frJu d by commission, or the concealing of a fact that should bc disdos~-J, which is frJud b)' omission . Such intentional misinformation docs ca,~t doubl on lh" y"luntarine.~s of the ilgrcement, and thus, whelher there was a JcgJlly enfo rceable agree ment in the fint place. 1luwever, in the imtance of concealing a fact lhat should he revea led, the frdll
96
PARr II; CIVI L LAW IN DETAIL
an invl'.ltor to inve.~t in a .~tllck that immediatciy lo,t ~ign i fi~ant va lue. Th e investo r wo\~d no t have boughl the slOck if the stockbroker had disclosed the risk facto rs present thai he knew bUI withheld from his customer.
THE LAW IN ACTION In the mailer of the Boyers all() lhe !-idlers of 123 Cherry La ll I'. there is a contracl that has not yet bl'en fully performed hecause thc d osing ha,' not taken pbce. With the discovay of the plywood living wom lIooT, the Buyers don'l want Ihe dos ing to lake place ~s planned. The house is slill intact, so it is not impossible to perform th is contc-dC\. No one has died and there has heen 110 acl of God; however, Ihe Buyers would like to change thcir minds. They don'l want the house as il i" Perhaps iflhl' Sellas would reduce Ihe price by an amount equal 10 the cost of installing hardwood IIooring, the n they could come to an acco rd and sa tisfaction. BUI. the Sellen; arc not willing to do this. The ScilcTll feci th,1I ,I deal i., a deal and IhallhL. is a uni<jue house. They are nol willing 10 rescind Ihe contract. In fact, they fecl .~" strongly ahoulthc deal thai they ,Ire threat· cniog 10 sue the Buyers for specific perform~nce of the contrJcl. In uther wurds, Ihey wanl the court lu force Ihe Buyers 10 dose un the huuse. The Sellen' fall hac k position is to ask for damages. Damages should give them Ihe benefil of the hargain. which is, according to their figures. u S20,OOO nel profit from the sale ofthl' house. Ifthc' house has to bc put back on the market an d res<)l d. it may sell for k,,~ thall the $91,O()OIhe Buyers were willing to pay. In fact, it proba hly will scll for less now that it i" sitting empty incur Ihe e"pense nfkeeping with ~ll its Haw' exp'Jsed. 1 he Sellers wi ll the house until it resells. TIlest "'''pen,ses indmJ.: Ihe mortgage payments, t,lxes, utilities, insurance, and yard maintenan ce. In other words, the Sellers coold suffer thousands of dullars in damages if thc Buyers arc allowed to \"oid this contract.
,ii,,,
The Buyers could argue Ihat Ihey should nOI be forced to pcrfonn on Ihe contract due to a material breach. To win on this argument they would have to convince the (ourt Ihat ,I hardwood living room floor wa.' a vcr)' impo rtanlle rm for Ihem. 'Ihis was an item on their ~must have" list. but so was a y;ml for Ihe kids and an ulder home. Everyo ne admi ls Ihal Ihe
(flAPTE~ 8
• DO YOU I
97
Jlour C;Hl he made tu fit the Buyers' expectations with a $2,200 expenditure. Obviously, the Sellers wlll argue that this is a smallltcm that is not material to the deal and a very minute portion of the purchase pli,e. The Sellers woul d urge the coun to rule that they had subSlantially performed on the contract, even if their performa nce was not perfect. 'Ihe Buyers can also argue a defense of mist,lke, misrepresentation, or fraud. As di\.Cuss.:d in chapter 7. these p~) int' nlise questions ahuut Ihe voluntarincss of the contr-a", hut it is possible for the Buyers to admit that there is a legally enforceahle agreement here and that their cunsent to the dc~1 was "uluntary, but stHl raise Ihes<: poin ts as a ddellse tu p<'Trorman(c. To I"in this argument, the Buyers ne~xl to concentrate on the facts and circ umstances thaI show imentionaI misreprescnt:!lion or even actke concealment by the Sdlcrs. Key points to their argnment aT,' the spccifi' qucs lions they asked the Sellers when viewing Ihe ho me and the inability 10 vicw the home after making the offer to purchase. Let'.t.",y th at the lIuyers refuse to dose on thc hllu.'e. Thc Sellers cou ld Sll~ the llu)'~ rs for specific performanc~, a.tking Ihe court 10 order them 10 buy the hOllse. Th is i.1 a uoi' llie ,md extraordin,lry remedy th,lt the court may be lillwilling to enforce again5\ the Buyers. In the alternative, the Sellers could also ask the court to award them damages for the Buyers' failure to dose on the deal. If the house is resold for $79,000 heforc the (;j,te gd~ 10 trial, the claim for spccifk perfonnan,c would have to be dismissed bec.msc the house is no longer available lor the Buyer:; to purch,ls,', but the damages d aim wo uld .tlill be before the ,ourt. With these f~ct.", if the Buyers losc, they face damages in eX"M of S12,OOO due to the difference between the purch'lse prices. If the Buyers win and prove misrepresen tation or fr-~ud that rCM: inds the contra ct, ther would gct hack till' $ 1,(I()(J earncst m')l1ey that they had p:!id the Sellers. The Slakes arc high for each si de. After:! Iwo-d~y trial, the judge rules in fal'or or the Buyers. The judge didn't go so far as to fmd fraud on the part of the Sellers, but she did fllld misreprescntation that was deliber-Jte on thc part uf the Sellers and male· rial to the Buyers. As is usual in contract cases, each side has to p:!y their own attorney fees, which amounted to ab out $3,50n CJ,h. Con tr-a'ting is not for the faint of h<'Jrt. Careless ness in hu siness agreements can cos t dearly, eve n if YOIl will your , asc.
J,
*
~I
h
98
PART II; CIVI L LAW IN DETAIL
TEST YOURSELF 1.
Cal~in
soaped the left rear panel of his car backing out of the
gilTage. Thi~ made him m"d, not be<:
Lou and Linda were scheduled to be married on May 20 in longview Park. When arrang ing the detilil~ with city hall, they discovered that Judge Judy was to perform the
~ervices
on thil t dilY. Judge Judy fe ll
ili on May 18 and arranged for Judge Joe 8rown to su bstitute. He d id, but th en the newlyweds sued Judge Judy for specific performance. Will they win? 3.
The Browns always have a golden retriever. The ir first dog, Maggie, was iI r<'
"' "
•
(flAPTE~ 8
• DO YOU I
99
Brain Teaser 4.
Roz has a contract to submit 10 cartoom a month to The New Yorker magazine. In return , she receive~ $2,500. The re is no guarantee that any ca rtoon will be used in th e magazine, but for each cartoon published. ~he re<eives an additiorlill 52.500. Her contr"ct states th~t the 10 cartoons are due by the 151h of the month and that failure to deliver all the cartoons for the month by that date is a material breach of the contract for which Roz wi ll pay The New Yorker $3.000. April has been a very unfunny month, and by the 15th Roz only has nine cartoon~ to deliver. On April 17 she delivers the 10th. Has Roz sub~tantially
performed? Has she committed a material breach of her
contract? What damages does she owe The New Yorker. if any? What if none of the ca rtoons from the April s ubmission~ were printed? Wh" t if the one submitted April17 we re printed? Answer~
can be found on p
Mmt con tracts a re discharged by being performed according to their terms . If a party substantially performs his promises. he has met his conlract obligations. Sometimes the parties to a contract mutually decide to change a term and agree o n another term. This is called an accord and sat· isfaction. which voids the origina l agreement and replaces it wi th anot her bargain. If a party to a contract fails to perform, she has breached the con· tract and could be liable to the other party for damages. Contract damages are calculated to give the p
ba rgain.
Contract damages do no t include pllnitive damage awards.
,
"
100
PA.RT II; CIVlllA.W IN DETA.ll
A co ntract can be voided due to destruction of the subject matter of the contrac t, death, or an act of God. This is ca lled dis charge by impossibil ity. A contract can be legally unenforceable because of a statute of limit ations or the bankruptcy of a party. This
~
called discharge by
operation of law. If th e parties to a contract mutually decide to call off the deal, the contract is rescinded. This is called discharge by rescission. If a party contracts for rare or unique item s, the court may award him the item itself rather than damages for breach of the d eal. This is a rare remedy called specific performance. If a party does not substantially perform, this is ca lled a material breach, and the party breaching the contract may be liable for damages. Sometimes mistake, misrepresentation, and fraud can be used as defenses to performing a contract.
,
"
What Contracts Must Be in Writing?
W
e learned in chapter 7 that co ntracts can be oral or written. We also
learned that there is no secret handshake that must be made to
seal 11 deal, that thefe are no magic words that make a contract valid, and
no dollar bi ll s that have to be exchanged to make it stick. We reviewed examples of ex tre m ely informal agreements that make up co ntracts in our everyday lives, such as making a purchase from a vend ing milchine or using an ATM. However, some bargains th at you make 1Ire 100 important 10 handle informally. They involve great reliance or great expense. There are
some Ciltegories of contracts that the law req uires be put in writ ing for t he parties' safety and for ease of resolving disputes, shou ld th ey arise. There aren't many, but they are important to know.
The Statu te of Frauds: MY LEGS The Elements of a Written Contract
The Paro l Evidence Rul e
102
PA.RT II; CIVlllA.W IN DETA.ll
IN THE REAL WORLD jod is w mad. l ie just c"mpleted his second ),ear "r law sch ool an d looking liJrw ard to his slimm er dl'r kin g job in a law firm in
W'I.\
h i~ h o me~
town. He worked at Stevens and Sissel last summer. W hen he was hired last May 10, old Mr. Strvcns said he cou ld wo rk with th e linn every until he wa s oul uf law sch oo\. Jo cl coun,,'d on
thi~
job to gaio
~umml'T
e~pcricncl'
in research and some d ecent pocket money. J lowcwr, old Mr. Stevens died last C hristma s an d thl' new managing partner, Mr. Sissel, jmt told Joel that he docs not have a job Ihere Ihis summer. Can loci enforce th is ora l contTJct that
W,IS
supposed to last th ree summers? JocI now wishes he wa.' a
hetter stud ent lotsl year in Mr. Berman's cu nlr,te l cI ass.
KEY CONCEPTS The idea o f requiring writing for some cont r,"IS is very old and dates back to a 1677 English law. The UnileJ Stat es adopted this rule and r~'qoirc.~ co n tT,lds that ha\'c to do wit h MY LEGS to be in writing. Of CO UTSt', It.·IY LEGS is an acro nym, one tha i I lea rned alm o.\t )0 years ago from
my co ntra cts
professor in law schoo!.
The Statute of Frauds I he stat ut e of fumh sounds like it shou ld he about fmud. It is, in a way, r.ut the 'Ialute of fraud .1 refers tn laws ar. oot wh ich types of co ntr;lcts must r. e in writing to avoi d frau,\. Fir,_t, it is impor tant to understand how 3n orJI (o ntract ca n be su bj ect to frauJ. If l.ord Neuman and I, !'CrfEll en, had an oral agre cme nt ah out splittins t he rn'cnuc from the (:fOpS J Srow eve ry year, it could work out just fine if we werc getting alo ng and buth had gre at mcmuries. However, ycar to year. our recollection of the exact t,'rms could fade. I co uld get greedy. Lord Ne um an (ould want to get me out of his fiel ds and get sc rfWilliam in bec-.l llSl' he is stronger and younger and willing to take a smaller percen tage. Lord Ncmn;m could d ie and lcavc me to dca l with his evil If we havc a disput~ over term s, and the 'lgrcemcnt is merely way we can prove ou r case in ,I court of law is
~on,
EJgar.
oT~ I , t h~
on ly
r.youruwn testimo ny. Tha t
CHAPTER 9 ' WHAT CONTRACTS MUST BE IN WmTINGl
103
is no pmhlem for I.ord Neuman. He is very well spoken. I, on thl' other hand, am a serf, and going to (ourt is a bit da ullting for me. 1 (o uld he perfectly exact in my mem ory of details hut less Ihan convincing in my orJI testimony. I.ord Neuman could have a personal relationship with the judge. It just could be unfa ir. A written docu ment would he better evidence of our terms and it co uld be interpreted o n its flce-that is, hy reading its Cl/ ntcn[.\, r~ l hcr Ih,ln hy lislening to o ur spin on Ihc deal. Such sitoations developcd as co mmerce grew in Engla lld in the late 16005., and the formal iting of COJltrdCls with the poteJltial for frdud became important. Tuday, the slatut~ offmuds rC4uir~s six kinds of contmcls 10 be in writing to be enforccahle. !fthr.w COnlracts arc nul in wriling, they still can be agr~'ed to and enforced by Ihe parties to the co ntr..lC1 as long as th ings go wcll; but in thl' cvcnt of disputc, unless your contract is in writing, thl' court will nOI enforce your deal based un orJllcslimony. You wi!! be limited to your writing, and if YOIl have none, the court will not help you enforce you r rights. lh~ M in "IY 1.EGS stands ti,f lIl(!rrj(lge. Contrdcts made in comidemti()n of marriage mu.~t be in wr iting. In hygone timc.~, this rdcrred to (onlmcts 10 cxchange money- given by the wifc's family- to the husbandto-he f,x his taking the
104
PA.RT II; CIVll lA.W IN DETA.l l
an important agreeme nt and one that
~h"ulo.l
b(, a5 complcte and detailed
as possib1c. lfY01l3rc rcm ing an apartmcm rn ont!Ho-llIomh, you Illay