Michel Sima net
Spring r
Universitext EdIoWao.rJ (Ni:dr Amiiiui):
S . .... F.W. Gelving P.R. Halmos
_ ... ..... ....... ......."".a-
Springer lHiolo" i &o r ' 5
9dV
It
If- b •
T..,.
Si, ; ' ,
j I
~ ~
,
!
1
j!
•I !
1!llI
1.
~~
I
~i:
lSI
1; 1
J j
I
lllj jllj]}i 111111 .I'll _/ i r I Hl'
1
!
1
<
;
1-
11 J!l!!. ' ., <
IiIlJI!!A!!Jlll!llliillilllllJii jl!!l!!)!lllI}j
1
Michel Simon net
Measures and Probabilities Foreword by Charles-Michel Marle
Springer
•
Mi
S ' PS'"
""""- .
"""". s......
U"
s-.a-..CA~
F, W ,
Lanmc. ~!1 48SU
""
AWS" ) , C'
.,
....
C ' .,~
--
-.-
P,R.
.......... "--0-.. , .
~
H~
AI..........101
M .. h.otJoa.\i
MIdt..., Stale U.r-.ity
Eaot
Cehr""
CIar. Un;-';,y
""
..... -,«IV..
.... ,....... """
. w..... _ ... _ _ """" _ ("'" , '.,f",. ' 1 I W_ "'::_:_: , , . ',,'I:
'I
,',=,.'
... , .
ISlIP< ... "'.,........ ,..",..... ' .... _ 1
'. " ,
'0'- ', .....,
,,-'.1.",:1
Qu" .........
:11'.>0-_ f'i'
too-..,tO
. ....... _ _
.A U' _.... , , ' a d ........ _ ......" ...... , n;" _ _ _ '" . . .. _ _ , '
.. V I .... lISAl. _ _ _
..
.... _ ...... -
..... ,
"........ __ .. "
. . . . ' " ' .. 11 ' .. - - '
, ...... _ _ _
,
"
.
_.
"
'
,
P _ _ 6"' .. """ .....
oaIooo=._' __ ..
' ' ' ' _,
, ' ilJo _ _ . .. _ .... 'P
......
• _ _ .. 11..00"
...
_ _ Yon •
, ... _ " . k , ... _
''
t
.... _
............ _
.
P." ..... s ' .. - . . _, ." .. ... " ...... ", --'."""',. Po '
", .. __ ... _
\'Ofi , ''' . I~",,", '''
bolo.Uoo
... __ ............... , ... , "M.... " • _
......
...... n-- .......... " ,.
ioo .. _
,,' . .,.,.. . . . _
.. . ... , ' - I ,(1i ' i , _ _
,01 ''''M _ _ "A '
. ..... '
.. , ...
.......
k,_~.,
n . .. _
.
,
'0:1'...." " , 'S ...... _ I f
_~
...
.
.. q
'""IooQo>.,.!-
,
.. , 'A,
"",,,,, 0\ .... _ , ,ea. , . "," ' ... _
""- y .... _ . II. , 'bsSl'1N '001 " II
••
Foreword
Inl ..... U<>" tbeory hoIdo .. prin .. ~u".. , wbetber In f'W'" matbem&ticl or in vvIouI nelda of applied .....,hema,;.:". It pIt.y1 .. oomral ... in ~ It io the t.Ho of probability tl>oory and ~ an indiopmNble tool In matbo> molkoJ pbysIcI.. III pwUcula. in qua", wn mecbank:o ...d " ..i ......1 mechania. Therdo.." • ........,. tu\hoo1::, ~ to inl.f:&l".tlorJ theory a1rMdy .vaIlabk. The ~m book 1:1,' Michel SimonllH dilfus f""" the previouII1.eXU In ma.ny ~fI'I!'C'ta, and, lor Ih&t fHiOIl , It ill to be particulatly """"""",,1de<1. wn." do,o.!inI with i~t;o" lbeo
e authono ........ , .... ~artl.nf: point. the notion of .. _lire <>II .. r..."Uy of ",heeu 01 .. od; thi8 ."",-.1> II: IjiWly _ U IUIIft1 to applications in probebility ,,,,,,,,,,. Ott",. au\b0r8 ~I..- to.art -..:llh t ho notion of R..doa ","""un! (a cot\tlnllO\M 11 ........ f'ww> \1oc>&I (la the ~ of Q)Dlin"""" fuo<:tioDl _ilh """poo<:loupport "" .. ~ ...... pooct ~) boca...., it plays an important role In &n&Iywio and - " ' " ftt the studs of diotribulloD tbflOr J . Swtln,g cI.f -..lIb the _1000 of ~l mzz,,>re, Mr. Simonnot prO'Vide& .. uni~ ~.t,.....,1 of \hoee two &"",·ri e", Jk><~ iooqratlooo U......1eo (11)0 ""'" .-Il h ""'I'<'Cl 10 .. """·Iy"" - " ' " or 1M oc.bcr with , .I;X\ 10 .. Rfdoo ~) are dtdllCOld ... particular c-.. of In~ioI, lrith reopeu to .. o.nlcU _u.re. Inciden~ly. lloeo.. " .. on ""ten$io IOO(M lmpon.~ ....ulu of <:ODII&llt _ , INCh ..
-=
vi
r
On ~be odlft band. tbe framework <:t..-, here;s fairly mon:: ~ral thM tho;.,... ,. . . lI y ""'P'"' 0< ~ complex: from the OUUltt, tho: i~;s defintd for func...."" than tbe t....,,_ found in lIlO6t other t<:XU of tbe....". Ievcl. The lmpolt&lll. aspaoU of intecr&tioOD tbtory (V SpiIoQiI! , different tYJ)ef o f oem ......• gm«. "",""urc dolcompoIition. !UoOOn·Nikodym de'-;_h..., imoce aDd product I"? "'.IMP) &n! all I.rce.Il 7W excdlent Introdudioo to prot,.bimy tbtory, OO'\oering tbe"'r<:>nf; Ia... of ~
_u""
numbe.., tbe ""nt,..llImll tl_"m , .tid oooditk>nal pr-ob&l);litio!ol. II &Il10 pro. v'deo _ .pplicatlons 0( inlqntion in ano.l)-.it, !ueb .. II>Ioo aDd .nal)'';''. Clarity of tbe • 0 ~tion zwd nume-tOUi ",. .".::I at tbe endi of 1M chapUro 101..". it 10 be .-i .... t.exlbook. It will aIf;o ~ very _rul to .., ·10.... aDd "ill proyide • cood tource ofleklc",," for ""'IIJ' matl>ematicians. CII" II~.;s"~!oCIIE~ M"II~~
Onivcroi«i Pan. VI Pinrc t'I. M..... Curie Matbo!ma'k1_
Preface
n il book 10 lnt.oo.ded to "'" an introduclOboo.bi ..... On. "'-Y 1.....1 tboo .....,.0:1 and third J*rU (Chap\en 9 to 14 o.od 15 to 18) .. an ;ntrodlJC1.ion 10 Ihe theory of probo.bility, or . . thee foorth put OIl an illlrod"",lo)n to an..oI)lI.ie. 1 """, ally pooc :cd from fim principim and my lroolll...,' io, for t b e _ p&I1. oeIf-<:QtU.aio.ed. ~het than r&lniliarill' "';111 ~a1IO\>01ocJ, _ fu",," 'Ional --'1*. and • oertllin degree of 1Dll1bem&11cal lIOpllllil.icalioa, Uule it requiml for proftt.blo ra4i"ll oI.llIis teet. The 10p0I0gIeal b.cqn>und n __ :lo:d II oo.uai. for oxamvIo, In Moduro GCtOC wi.II provi\1 At t he<:nd of-=" chap'",", ~( !! I, .. hleb ~ desl&ned to pt'e!Ienl eome additional mat.etial and enm~ .... pr-cMded. The treatmen' 01 inteen-lion I' !.be elemen\.r.:y level ..suatIy _ orilh eicba" poI:itive or Ii.".:d "....""'" on ".aIp:bnI or ..ith «Hnpie:< Radon n-. au<" on LoeoIly (OmpIW:t H • ....&,dI' $ ....... In Ihit book , _ Ii.- <>;>ooide. <*np!ex Daniell mefl/iu"" 00 • lpoooe ?t{n,C) 01. elementary functlonl. To deli"" tboo upper inU:(r&l, J.tV~, oJ. .lily p / with ~ to ,"" ""riM " ., VJI 01 a....,opIex Daniell 1I"' nn! 1', a daM J of pellili"" fUDCtIooo, Ihal eontalns tho upper en"lopooo 01 \lIO: " 'in« _ of))(llll.
Ii"'"
r
viii t1"" elemental)' fu nctions, iI inlroctua.d, C ivco • Banach opeoe F, • fu!lC1Wn 1 from fl into F iI ,,_l"~ i f aOO only If, for -=:II ( > 0, lhere e>3; t heir In .. n..-trir.o.bl!l spo.t:oe This procedure works, in particuJar, .. hen H (fl, C ) iI the ""' of simple funo. LioooI on .. wmlt in,g 5, It alto works when 0 iI .. locally compact ' pA<:e-1>Ot _ " uily .,,-compa<:t- aOO when H(O, C ) ie tbe IiItt of oontlnU6t>l! fuoeti0n8 DO 0 wit h compact support, T wo fairly gor>e!1ll and .,..y to handle intesruion t hoot ' , ..., t b... obtai".,.;, Tho: first ono\ (Chapter19 II) 14) iI ~p(cioIly ruiWl to the DeI!do of probe),;lj. . " tbe -..od one (Chapc ~ 19 II) 24) II) tbo8o 01 anaJ)"SU. I~tally, _ thai many """jor resulu on Radon moaol\IIe f0llow lmmedluely from thel. counterpMt """II.. on abolIract II_mao ddlnm on tbe __ miri", of dilf.. e"" .. of compact !IOU, Thil Pi ' ,1$ votume iI strondY Inlluenad by, and owe. mud> to, Po(loboil, itr....t ""_" ... by P, Billil>3;lley (W iley, 19M), l nUgn>I;",. by N, Boo, boki (Hermann, I~), n..tUe "" A.wy,u (>"OIu_ '2) by J, !)Ieu.!or",o! (A,. demit ~ 1976), loI_re n..-, by P, lIaimos (Spri"3"',Verlat!:, 1974), MutJ.1'U d pro/>oIJ>iJUh by C, M, Marie ( 11etmMn, 197(j, aOO R,e.oI aM Com,coo7, ~ U>al Ih. Ust. by DO " I w10h to \rt~, Marie from Paris Uni~, W , R udin olTbe Unl,~tyofWi1<::onsin, &ud to K. \ 'c>K bac from Or~ Un~lty fur their kind remarb and encou' ''¢i'O(tlt, I am MJ.edaily iDdebt'" to Prof-.. J, ~ lor biI Iongti ..... M1ppoH and cood <:<JuI>OeI and to p,a )f C, M, M ...1e tot hill ;"vaIuabLe """ 'om t-inally I would like to u...nk P TOpp<) and 0, Vinel for belplng wllb lhe ~, R. EaitaWI,)'.(;IM and M , C a ....... for ty~tlilfl tbe onanlllCript In OOFX, and Spri"3"'-V_lac lor .oorpcinc tho: IIlanU$ttipt, n.. d>apter ic>.roo:!uct __ are d uo to C , Vit>el
r
,11.1_
..mo."".;"",
c.M.
'I'
ate
Contents
• p ".,.. ....
1 I
Integration Relative to Daniell Measures R.Ien S!>IlCl!I' 1.I
,
vI!
Onkfftl
Cmupo
,
,
.,
I
,
"
"
to
In!.Huble and M.. , eorftn8
" ""
"
M 36
Int<'«f'l,~
Seta
.. ,M-..no.bIe S,*"", . , MpM\!J$bie Mapping , , , , , F.-nUaJly Int'1:rabloo MOOnp
, , ,
, ,
, ,
,
"" ro
"
,
,
,, , , ,, ,
.
62
,
'
,
, ,, ,
" "Leb"'gue M,.""unI o n R
""
38
• ,
4.1 4.2
..." " ". "
Ru' ~ Ex~ ": " "' .. RoeJ NumbH _ TM C&ntor S!nculu FI '..... ;.,.,
V Sp' ~ U Pefinil ion of V S...,.,..
,., M
eo.,'bK ! ill! TheOttmll !Mi II! M"'IItt
Coo"",,
• •
"
Unilonn!y Intosrabll\ Soots
• •
•
.
.
•
1!H
• •
• •
• •
•
108
•
•
,
,
•
II \I
OperatiollS on Meuun!5 Defined on Semirings
173
I wllI" "'" !\I••• " .... wI Produ c t M .. . ' ''...... Q! MM'''''' 1..... ,.".1 an . M ...",*,* Se.
1111 I V;
92
118
"
,,.,
104 Combi.w.ion 01. Opm.\iom on Meas""" . lO.S
O".l'
10.& no., y.-.u.-Ueotill D«oonposiUon TI.eoICill
12
'"
C hanu o r Vniab .... 17 I Djffc,op". hoo In u '
13.2 St!of.lll!:l ~' _lolm 13.3 Une 1m."
14
, 21 0
h
lA?
,,
,, ,
, ,,,
.
13.4
no., ~'" D.composiUon 01. a Funt:t lon
13.~
Upper and I.oM!r Dtri,·ati"""
The Fonder lvmsrorm 10 14 Me... '.... in R' H2 Oi!ltribill ....... E1,"'1w-u.. 14.1 c....,ri · nrr Mor rix 144 Tbr Fourier Tr.pstOrm 145 Noxm ol I ..... in R"
,
,
·
R'
'" ", m '" 288
287
29S , , ,
, , , ,
,
"" '" 30.'
III
Co Dvllrgcnce of Random V.... wbles j C onditional Expectatio n 309
" 18
The Stronl La.... o r LuI<' Number. IS. I in Probability . . . . . .. lS2 IndopInd..,e" 01. R·nd<>
Con"""""""
The r;r.nl ra] 1.l m lt Tb,....,..m
III
· · · ·
'"
31 2 31 3 316 3 18
• .'\20
CwLz •• 17
Onler S'"')S'ia 17 I Dell";,;"" o f .be
344
C'trrJer Srar ;"
17.2 Con.u",,""" 01 lbe Empirkal
IV 19
"
344
~IMI""
Operations on Radon Measures
3T7
... Adequa" Faro' ly or M"""URS 19 I Indu..ffl Bodoo Mea'urr 1?2 u,DmIe Familln! 01 C<>ml!OlCt SetS
3-"0
193
"
jcs
SliD 01 Bodoo M....... ltftl . .
IIJI.II&S of Radon t.l euW'ft and P rodtIC' Measures 21, ) 21 ,1 21 3
Im.og .. olIU.donM.... u~ . .. o...:om!>O!ition of a M~ In Slic8 PreMln"« Bodoo
21.3 21-4
Produtl 01 Rfsuw 1.1"""""", Cilium: of Variable Fonnula.
Me·.,,_
H u r Me. ." ....
23 I
IDu na"! M ..asures
'"
..... ." 4]]
. 421
. .n
425 426
xlii
24
C-nnvnli"iop of !!.lea. " .....
24
i
0"",01 ...'* M-w,,,.,.
24.1 248
466
." ,
,
De6njl \op aCGdfA,.., I>I jr
.., '" .e!
AOA Symbol Index
..,
Copyrighted material
Part I
Integration Relative to Daniell Measures
,.
Copyrighted material
1 Riesz SpaDes
I..e< X be
I,
fur>
11."._ ol_i~ ......
x , 1_ 1(1) _ f. "')
6 _. M..... 'a. if I . _><' S tulib."q ... , on [-.bI ...... r.1.(,)o'I d, ... 6,.. h,... to doll"" tho! _ of pooit, ..
1.
_w_"
..,.1" .........
:nt o i n a _ .. , .. ,-~
1. 1 TIoio fi ... ooc<"", ; ~tl'Od .... tho "",ion of <><der-od &J"'UJII and 1at.1o!oo. It "'-"", to. -.., to ~ br. millod ....... ..II ~n ~ . ....:I> .. Z 0< R or tho """"" Clio, III of .......1""" .-~ ... fur>«"- O D [0.61 with .heir ........... O<dor!nca1.2 It io do/W'" to. obort .. Oldy of Rlooo. opoceo, thai .. ot ... p111;_ fu " " - "". ' . d bownJ 101. equll'JM>'l -.itb ita "",,,,,01 <>rdo:ri~ • POll"'''' ~ Iorm on E Io_'n"",,". U W. &nalb dof· D=- 'el' a ,.._ A Dan;,!, _ u .. io • ~_ Io<m [, on • _ _ cl "'... _ ff. _ hu • "SDk • ...u..ion' (DeIinltion I.U) aad oudo
pOOi.,...
.... IM_. to.
M
,10K L{t.) - 0 .hot •• , ... I. debt .., 0 0U>CIerw>0d .... ."...i..w,y oondi' ..... A _
In
11* . no. ~ ,be eumploo
""""';0;"" . . . . ld
,ho, ,hot " .
~.
boo ma,r
...... IOIooop '" mind.,., tho !tit ann ~ ........ , od . . . ",*, ;.e U_ Jona "" tho"'" 01 ..... tin ...... fIt"",1ono "" (0.111 aDd aloo II,. p(IOiIi~ ~_ Iormf t . : X ) I _ l {e).boA. E
".111.
l.l
Ordered Groups
Defin it ion 1.1.1 Lot G be. oommut6,i~ IfOUP wri't.enlddld""ly. An ordot-r ",ruc\U", on G, ~ h,- :!O, Is.-id to boo cornpo.'ible with tho group $I."",,"" ' ...... ol G .. ~ It ..,,,,,,,," lhe 1oIIowi", axiom: Irz:S:~, lhen z+: < ~+I lor &II : E G.
n.. group G. ~ ...;tb • O>
Taltfnl • -
- z, • _ -II • .00 : _ - (z ~ ~l !\><:( ' . 'i ~ly In Definit ion 1.1.1, _ _ 11Ide 1Iw, in G, lho i""'luallliN % II, 0 < II - %, Z - " :!O 0, and
:s:
....
- II SO - z "'" equi.. l.nt FOIl" uamplt, R. w\t;h III \IIIl.l&lloddillon and lUI usual om." , "' 6Il oodt |
P ropolition 1. 1. 1 S"¥P<>« IMI (z;)'!o'S. I z, :s: /I, /".. all I :s: i :s: ... z, + ". +:I:. :S: II, + .. . +11.0 . FIo""""",-, %j + ... +z. < ", + ... + 11.0 ....-..ewr molt." 1 :!O i S n I'" ""'Idt. ". < ".
..u.
n.-
u..n.
""""ions
The z, + Z) :!O %, + lOt and "" +" S "+,, [mply %, +:0:, :s: ", +lI':t. On II.. 01",,", hand. if z, +z~ - VI +11:1 . • hen z, +"'2 - z, +11:1 -Ill +/1>. hencoo. :r, _" and z, -Ill. n...gro...-.! P Jl()Ot";
Pint. •• .. ox ."" .. _
t6IIe k>[1owo
2.
t.,. 1lld\lC\Im en ...
0
For CY"'Y' EG,'ho t ~lon" - z+ ..... ::, ,'tlI thoOlrderofG. ,""", if . ,.....,.mpty fa.mlly {z,ku 01 dc"'''''tI of C has. oupromum V .... , z,. tben tho r.m.uy (. + z,)"" aloo It.u •• upntDum. and V,.;/(. + z , J ~ I + VrE' r" A similar stal<:"kot boOdis fOO" the Infimum N.. !be mappl", z _ - z reo .. _ the (Itder of G 010 ,hbt • nootmpty family {~)'
11..,:0,.
(- z;}.., It.u t.u lDfi.=, and thell A...,( - :r,) _ - V,..,z,. Dell nitlon 1.1.2 In 6lI oodw\d Jf"O'Jl) G, ,, e C ill -' 0 ("",p«ti"'lJ',:t < 0). If Gil.." ood",ed """". tho eel. 01 1'- pOOIiti>1l eIocIllC!",- ,..;\1 ..u&!1y "" dmoted by So n (- G'"J .. CO) and C+ :J C+ +
cr.
cr
cr_
1.1 O"I""d G"",p" Pro~ltioD
5
1. 1.2 UI. comml>1Gt.." group G lie gtven, "lUIld P lie • fUbuj
"JO ...:10 tMl p n(- p ) .. (OJ alUl P+ P C P_ The ..."'1;"" %::;
~
if 01Ul mlr
if, - '" E P "/ina on <mJ~ .1"",",", compal,bIe ""th the grnp .lnIdM... "I Moretl~" G ;, t<>UoIl, M"rhrtd if ,,>III <>nI, iJ G _ P U (- P).
G.
o
PROOF: Thill is obriouo.
An ","",ed oe\ E io oaid 10 be din!CU!d up"'ard (..... pecti""'y. down ..vd) .1>0.......... to. all % E G. V E G. t~ ""OIlS z E G .w.\sfyin& :t ., z and ~ ::; ~ (..... pectively. % ~ ~ and ~ ~ ~). EvelY onieT
P .... ~ltlon 1.1.3 An M"IkrN gro~p G " d'r"&':led ",,>III .".J, if it ;, gen. a 'ed br G~ , cr, if """"'- ./mI... j oj G .. 1M: diJJ'~ oj I_ pomi ... ,*",...t..
.q,,,""/.e,,u,.
"""""let
PROOP: If G iI di"",Ied, lor ~""ry ~ E G. tl>o.re """"' .. % E G· lhan Z; _ : t .. ~-(~- :t). Coo' .. ody, if % .. ,, -v and~ .. ... - 1 ......... M. v, .... I _ all j)OIili"", then % S" + to and, S" +.... 0
P .... poo.ltlon 1. 1.4 UI (~,) ... , lie" ......empt, fimte Jamil, ift a di....,u./ gmup O. TIIo. ....... v; _
""".1."". tab! . ..
~"
0
An ""I",ed oe1; E is called .. lallia! whenevIII 1:. , E G lIe~. A. ,,_.Mry "M ~ OI>fId,t",,, u...t z " , .,...1 .. Il101 % V , tzUl. :nw:" z+~ " % " ,+z V, _
PROOF: Su,...,.... that 1: " , ""iota. lbm
:r +, - :r '" _ z + , + (- z) V (-,1 _ z V,. Tbe proof IX 11>0.
<:Onvtnle
group. :nw:" G " 0 /aUt« if "lUI oj tile loilftliftg c.c>ndIlU'''' IIfIUU:
Pr-<>pWltlon 1.1 .6 S..",.".., 0 .. ""
..... if 0 .. O· -
cr- ,,>III <me
onlemj
(.) E....,. pa;~ oJ.1ernctU ,,10+ IIu 0 (6)
o
io j im ... ....,..
E....,.,..... oj ~ ,,10·
...,....". ..... .
IIu on irVim ..... '"
0·.
I'
ale
PIIOOF : n- cond.iliooo aM otMowdy !>Hpl",,),. Con,~y, undo.-r hypoth. ",is (Il) (" "I_li""ly. (b)), eo.cb pili, of ~Iommts % E G"'" , V E C + h.M a IUrw-um ( rwpectl""ly, an Infi mum) in G equeJ to il& 'UpEeit/urn a (_p"o" Ii"",>", it.l infimurn ~) in G"'" . Th" .. abvio:>o..os lOr 0; 1Or~, lei. ~ E G boe alcN-."" bound for % and ,. Thoen l!>ere c:xiwl .. E G"'" such lbat : +" E C + (boa. ..... G .. G"'" - C· ). Nooo 11>f.,..(z+u, V+ uj" greater than ~+" and ea." be writtal ~+ c+ II (c 2: 0). Si .... b +c < % and b +c < V, c _ O. lIenc:e b+ "" Info. (z + "., + u) 2: Z +'" &Dd z :5:~. Nat, lei. " E G. V E G boe arbitrary and U E G+ boe ow:lt IMI z + U 2: 0 &Dd W+" 2: 0; UOOtt hypot'-"_ {al (...... ~i""ly, (b)), z +" and , + u have a ",,,,_mu.m (l"
a
T~m 1.1.1 ~1DP<>"1~1o'.' Le.mnlll) Ld (". hs<s., (II;),;YS. . . 111'(1 fi7li.t~ ~ IP\ (;+ HJUfIIi"f L,s.s. "; " L '!i1S.II, rn G , Wn, IMre ......11 • ~ ~ (z,.; ),,,,;,,,• . '!.IS. #Uth I1Iat z, .. LI!i1 "'....; ~.II j mwI'I" L' S'S'''J lor.,J1 j. PROOf':
I. Ftrsl, consider 1Il00 ~ P '"' q ., 2. Put ',., ., .... p(O . %, - 1')) and .,., .. "1.1 - (Zl - n)· Sinc-e %, - I/"> .. 1/1 - ,.., io .maller than '" &Dd 1/.. '1.2 .. '" - ".' &Dd >7.1 - 1/1 - " .' ftre s-jli ..... M",,_. + z., = ... , + :',ll, and '" .. + :•." II> - "'> + "1.2-
",., Z,., ",.3.
".1
2. Next, _ .. ,~ that 1Il00 theorem holds lor p < m o.Dd q .. n (_ilb '" :> 2, 0 2: 2) and prove lbal It balds for p .. m and q .. n. By
( L ,,) ••• - L .,' 1'S"-'
19S~
Since.he......:lt boIds lOr p .. 2 and q .. n, _"..." find t ..... """'Iue....... (~j,:r;J"'~, (:f) , ,,,, s o In (;+ ... tlsfyillg
r;
&Dd II, ,. oj + lor all 1 :s; j :s; n, Now. since the t~m 10 ' rue fur p _ m _ 1 &Dd q .. ". d ..re "' • dou~ -....... "" (1<; ... j,~.~ .. _ I .I $j~~ ;" c+ ....:II tbat %, _ LI$ih "<'; for oJl ! !: ; :s; '" - 1 ond <j ..
L,<j< __, IIfJ fur all 1 :s; j S n. Pu~ "'; - ....; for oJl 1 :s; ; :s; '" - 1 -.rod';"; .. r; (I :s; j S oj. Then the double -..""n"" (.,.;),""" .... '",IS _ hu the desired propertlell.
, 'I'
ate
3. Int....dw!&l"lllhe roIeo of the %. and the
~, . "'e
find similarly thal if lbe cheoiem holds lor p .. m and q < .. (m ::!: 2... > 2). lben it holds for p .. '" and q ..... The tt.eowu now 101101111 by double lnductioo.
c Corollary ~
Lei
, .%,.... , %~
........ find~;
/Ie .kment.r olC- "",..","9 ~ 'S E,s;s.%'. EO C+ ( I S ; S .. ) Iud> Ihdt ~ 'S %, lor all; ~nd
, .. E, s.s~~ · P ROOF: Apply """""m 1.1.1 to the ~""""" (%, ),S'S" and the ~ ra ..>ad from lhe I...:. elemems /I and • '" ~ ,~. %,) - ,. 0
(E,
~lI nlt lon
1.1.3 For % E C. tM e~t r v O (_Pft'\ively (- r ) VO,"'" "pea;vely (- :r) V:r) ill called tho pooiti"" part of % (h P"'1i>-dy the nqalive part, ,etpec:tively tM abololute value. or variation, of %) and ill .. rittel! :r+
(,...-th"ely %- , )%Il. NOle that . accordi"ll to t t - definit ....... tM nepl.ive part of:r ilia poIitive element. CJearty, :r- .. (- %). and ) - %1 -14 NOle abo tM Iormulu :r V ~ " :t + U - %). and ~ ~ (/I - %) • . "The liM fol1oon ;mnwlia' rly from 1M Cat:\. that lhe ooduins of G .. preoerved under tranol.t;"n ; the ecoond if a ooneeq_ofPIt)jI,,";tlon I.I,S.
%" .. -
Tbeoo e m 1.1.2 (. ) ., .. " . -.,-
"j
~II
"+ ,, r - .. 0, lor e...ery rEG.
(/I.)
01 % E G '" A diiJ.moct. 01 boo ,....;titte elemenI.r, " .. ". + '" ,,11<1 V " ,, - + IU. ~ ... . . .. " .. . ., 'S) if ~ '" ..,- S , . "n./.,- ::!: ~-". 1" 1 .. ,,++ ,,-.
M
I" + , 1 :S 1" 1 + Iwl
(c)
For
An)
~
" .. .. -
U
for all "./1 EO G; ""'.. 9<'''.....11, I E' s's ~ ", 1 S E, ~ . s . I:r, l /or An, jiniU ItqWnOIi ("' )'s. s ~ G.
(J) )%I - Iwl
:s I" -
r l for all:t.
;"
/I
E G.
PROOF ' We ..ill prove (.1 and (b) lirnu)' ......... "'iy. If z .. .. - W. .. lot", " , ~ are politi.", then .. ::!: %. , anti ...... - %+ ill positive. FurtIw:[I,ooot. z + - :r .. %v o - " _ (%- z )V(-:r) _ r-, bmce:r .. ". - :r- and ... .. w- %-. """ ; e G be amaJltr than ,, - .. ~. - " . Then,, :S "ooot>O.tr, if z S " ... then:r· - % ill poIitive. II) " . :S " . - '. and z ill nqalive. n""eb'(, "'" fmd that:r+ " %- .. 0 and . by ,r...wation. t~"'" " .. .. ",.
,,+ -;;
•
{( j ' Let z , WEG beP""'" If,, :!> ~ . tbm snd :z - ~ , - . ConV
",. s: ....
,,+ S w" Md :. - ,.. , - .
r :5~· and
,,+-:r s:
-t :5(-%)+ _ :r- .IIO
~+
- , - .. , ... bene>~r
s:
(d ) : z" v ;r > 1z1, btca. - :r :5 ,,- ""d - :E :z- . NIt. If .. ill an upper bound lor % and - :r , Ibm .. ~ 2: z".
,,+
Slnot ,, - iI poeilive and linee Int(,, · .r )., O. the La6/. '100 inequ.l!itioet imply .1;0.< ,,- .. 0 and .. .. ,,+ ; tbe /i.a t"", ioequa!it;'" .hCD live a 2: z+ V " - .
Honee z + V,, - .. Izj. Now
+"
,,+V ,,- .. :z+ + ",.
by Propoeilion I. U ' .
s: 161 + " I/)(a._ s: 1"1and " s: IPI· Similarly, - z - , s: Irl + 11'1 · 1I_ 1z s: Izi + l.t, (f): ~II& z and ,In (e) IJ1 ~ and ~ ve Izl - 1, 1 s: 1%- l'I; (e), :z -+ ,
llimilariy,
...
1, 1- 1"1 S Iv -
:t
% -
r l ..
Iz -
,.
....
III.
C
Noce lhal:r .. z · - r"" .. 0 if 1z1- z ·
+,,- .. 0; t hUl I:r] > 0 lor all" E G,
""""rnpe,
Pl"Opoooit ion 1.1. T Ld {", I'E1 /It. Q j"",il'J .n C .../11 "" ;,vtmM'" " .,." lei • E C lot ...-ti1N". n.. .. 1M ,amllv (: V :t;j'EI 1141 "" mfi'""'" "M ..... '{, v ¥.) .. : V(/\"ol " ,j.
p Rfl()r: We ...-y _ _ that , .. O. Noor 1/+ s: z; £or . U i . If a ~ ,. Iooftr boo .." k>r (r j).( /. 111m a :s :r, + :r, for al l i Ii' 1. Now z, fo"',. ( I, i E J ; tb"" a s: :to + ~- lor I E I • • "d a s: II T ,,- .. ~ • . " "' .... lIo
.. -os I<>
s: ,-
e_,. be l booom.
0
I~,.: "
and v. _ obta.in • limilar poOp04h lo)n. In p&rbeular. if {1<.).c, it. nonemply family with • 1lUpr=wn " in G. tben ,,- .. I\;,[ /:r;- . be<:auM (-%). _ (""" - :J,) . _ "",/ ( - ,, ;) . , Dcllni llon 1.1 .4 T-.o elemenu :toII in G are oald 10 be disjoilll. or mutually $ "1'\1 ..... .. hene .e. ~I "t.! _ O. In Ibill ...... _ shall.loo>M)' lhal: % iII diajoim from , . If A ill . "'~ ck;;>ent
_tmplr !in;/.t, /-u.·u
PIIO()J> By induction on 111 and IJ I, it suffi<:el to Iihow Iht.t :J "
(~ +.)
s:
",,'+%,,; for ~I:r . r . : E G"'" _"OW put I " :r " U. + . )_By n-em I Ll. s:
I <:M be.......n~ I , +~, .. be..e O I , and ~ S %" :, and l be ""uk &:>I~
s: II and 0 s:
I, S '. Then I,
s: % ,, ~ 0
'I'
ate
Corollary I If", E G U diIjoin.! I>
Jrr!m
I"" All/I + 1"'1AI' I .. O.
0
Corollary ~ If (;r, l IS'S'" (l/;lISlS" ft~ II." fi.w.e lel z; ;, diIjoim Jrr!m ..w. 1/,. th .... z, + ... + "'.. Gild 1/, + ... + lIa a~ ~t.
PROOf: T his fol~ from Corollary L by indu.etion tIn m and n .
Corollary 3 ··· + 1"'.1·
lIz" .. .. "'. ""' "'hl....!1y diljc>in.t.
PROOf: If "', , are disjoint. tben 10 are ... (:r + ,l+ and ", - +,- .. ('" + 1/)-.
0
th .... lz, + ... + "'.1 ..
I"', I+
+1/" and ",- + 1/ -. Thus "'~ +,~ .. 0
Propoo.ltlon 1.1.9 U I (z ;l'EI bo ft ...,_plr fGmjJ~ in G /unoi"fl G nII'ft" m...., z. 1Jom allllll E G IMI;, diljt!illl fram..w. z; ;, oW dVjotnl fram
•• P ROOf: 1, 1" z; '"' 0 for eoocb i E 1, 10 (P,oc-ition 1.1.7). MOl ..."",
1, 1A z·
.. v .u (lwl A :tn .. 0
1111Az- .. 1111 A(/41:0",) .. A••A IIII A",,) .. 0, .. 1/" disjoint from both
1.2
",+
and "' -. and
""DOl! from 1z1..
", +
+ "'-.
C
Riesz Spaces
DefInition 1.2.1 Su..."...., ,hal. E: II a .-...I _ :S oa E .. Mid to be compatible wilh lho: _
IJW'l' An order relation IJW'l' H""'un: of E i f lhe
IOllowil\l two conditions hold: (al '" :5, impl;'" '"
+, :S 1/ +,
for all
,E E.
(b) '" 2: 0 l",pI;'" AI" >0 lor all mil numbo:n J. > O.
_.par:e.
A real_'J)ke ";Ih .. O)mpatible order II""Ued "" OIo:\t. M By definItion. a ru.... IJW'l' II." OIo:\t ,ed _ rpooce which II. lattice.
,
10
I. RiMa ......
Let a ru.u spw-e E ba
P""1l.
For IUIy f'Ola! nwnbcr A > O. ti>c Ofder of E mnailll invt.rit.DI under the bomothdy ~ - .\.:; thUfl ....p(.u,.\.') _ .1.1tIp(:r,,) for .U :r, , € E _!n particuW, (,I.... ). _.\.·:c and (b)- .. .\. . :. b CYt't)':r € E and br ~ .\. I1 «i""" intt&'"" .. 2: ~I ,:r and n1' ar(l dil>jc>int and Inlll a-I A~. It I'oIIowI lhat, If A It a I>(W"oen'p"y .... boet 01 E. lhe diljoint complement of A 011 . _ IUhIo,*",
of E.
Oeflnitlon 1.2.2 E It MId to be Oedekind oom~ ... heo~ _h DOlltmpQ- WM 01 E 11>0.1 .. bouode<:l al>oo'e bM a suj:ftmwn. &tuMoI~nUy. E .. Dtdttind oom~ w~ t..:h -.empty ..,beet of E that 101 bo:>w>dood
t t'JOoo I>ao an infimJm Pl'<>po<ion 1.2.1
E;, DtdU:iM """"'I~ if 4M 0fIIJ 1/""" 0/ u.e I~
""" .......i"".., /otIiJ,: (. J E.....,
~pl,
01:.( ......
(6)
.
Mid A 0/ £+ Uuol if dirtcktI _,... and 100_""""
~ .. m.
ew..,. ........1,01' .......'
A 0/ ~
thGl if d,,~UtI.w--..d Iwu on inji .
~
PItOOr. Clewly. dIll conditionll uel\b ''Y. Con_I!, _ _ t hai Qi')Ddillcill (a) holds. and lee. 8 he • l>Oiiotwpempt7 Mite P6N 01 8 o:.ooKitute a ed C ~ 101 dir««d upwW_ Let .. he <)Of! olitll tlo!:roetltlI, and deIU>e C. _ (:r EC: z > 01_ Tbta C. - G. \.bat It direcud 0JpQrd and bounded abo;oo.e, hao .. ""~ •. Now " + 6 It lhe 1OlPf'!""lIn of C., and ao 01 B .. ...,Il. In floC!, condition (b) imp/a condition (_) indeed. If 8 101 .. noaempty .ut.et.ol E· , di~ upward and bounded abo.M!. and If c ..... uppoer bow>d. 10< S, then c - B .. dlrec:led downw.....!_ Dtt>o\In« b)' m .he inRnwm of c- B, we _ thalC-- m It l be IIlIpremwD of B. 0 E""'Y _ _ w bsl*'" of
otdooorfld _ If*"
,..1 ..
lUI
n
:s 1rIOI'e(Ml'.
Dcflnl'lon 1.2.3 Let E he an ",d",«1
,"«:to, ~ &nd V, IV
he two .uppIo",...t,a:y _ ",t*P"'dI 01. e . We...,. that E .Ihe oode. «! direct ...... of V and W ~ thecaoonlcal map (z , ,)- z + r f..... the o<de,ed _ _
,
1.2 RIMa " -
II
dc,w_to<
lpooOo V " IV O
Deflnltlon 1.:.1 .4 Let E tIt; . RioI> 0fJI"0e. A _ ~ Fol E ill c.lll: F for ..u :r E F .00 , E F . F ill <»lied an ideal wbene...,.,. E F. , E E , and ItII S 1:r1 Imply 11 E F . F • call<:'tID"m In E of. n<)nO':mp(y ""beo:t
"",""",pie. gI-. B top<.>ioci<:aIOp&<:1': n. let F (n . R ) be lhe _ _ . ..... of..u ~.alu<:"alued functiom on n. Then 8{O.R ) .00 C{fI, R ) _ RIea ~ of T(O. R ). B{n. R ) io an Ideal of F (O. R ). but C{O. R ) 10 lOX. f inally. B(n. R ) il lIOl a band in .1'(0. R ). e...... t"",,«b it ill ~ eomplete. Fl:Io- ttlt; "....·1........ <J! thie e<'!<."ti
--
N OIflIMl ~ bat>d B in E 10 Do:dcld. N(IOI' let A be a ... beo:t
Propooltlon 1.:.1.2 Lot D "'" 4
...,....mpl~
• ..u.1 01 E'" .1OCh /JI4I
(. ) D+D c DGnd ~)
:r E D."" 0 So , So:r impj, 11 E D .
Lot M "'" 1M od 01 "'preIIIG ollllo~ ........ mpl~ ~" in D IMt G.. "'-dtd E E· om "'" --;U.... ~+ •. 00\(.£, E Mu u.., "'preIII"'" ...... E E"'" .. diljoi1lt frcrn M .
. . . . . ~ <WF)I:r
.1(. E D: v So "I
P IlOOr. By P1opoo1llon 1.1.9. it ....1Iico.I toloo,.,. that ... l: - ~ ie~ from DOt. tqUi...Jmtly. that Ii .. ; 1.1 .. 0 for all t E D. Now. for all ~ E D Ntil(yinJ .. S " , _ have v So ,. aD
as "
11.
Theorem 1.:.1. 1 (F . RIea Dec:om""';tlon Theorem) Ld A k G """,,I ./ E. n.c... tlw: iio;coi1lt ......pkme.u A' 0/.4 ;, • Ioond. TIo~ ~I """'J'Iemml.4~ 0/ .4' it tmcllr 1M knd ~toI .. A . • ...t E ;, 1M ~ &fId ",m.JA'.A~.
f llO()r. By P "'P'JI'it loo. 1.1.9. A' and A" &llI l)onda. E""'J :;t: E ~ ..... be written , + " wb.re r E .4' I.Dd • E A" _ ~llive (P"'P'JI'ilion 1.2.2). Th. 11.,'" that E _ A' + A~. F'Iut)"'''IlOI"e, A' n .4" .. (OJ , II) tMI A' , A " are
I.
12
ru-s-
oupplem«ll.ary """"'" ~ti,,.
of a
A'.
(ku",ul
of E. F ,ually, fir>ee the OOlnponente in A', A~ positi~ . .....,..., .h •• 15: ioI.he 0«1"'00 direct sum of
sut.~ ~
A~ .
I~
remaiDl '0 be shown that A~ ;" ex&d its diQoinl oompl ,,,,,,,,t 8'. Now it C B , 10 8' C A'. On the ocher Iw>d. B C A~ lU>d E 1'1 the din!<:t JUm of A' . A"; thlJ6 8 .. it" and 8' .. A'. 0
E.
Note, ,ncldto>Ut.Lly. that -S E di!ljoint from it if.nd only if It is disjoint from B (bol
P l"OpI)eT bo1IJod oj tile J_ !41 1-s,1Jtn" ofoo;k JamiPJ ('1;),0 ;n A. Ltl M, be ~ clGM ol 8lq>l"t:fnO oJu..os.. """"""'PIt ."bod, oj M , !hal ""' 6oundtd . . . . in E . 1'1II:n At. _ B;' . PROOf': Indeed, M. C B . Now. ~ti,,« l.l"' be ,be d illjoint comp&.,rnent of A (... , "'Iui>-alettlb". of B ). and taki,,« D .. At, in Pro~tion 1.2.2. we lee that ......,- (1",,_ of I!:"" ill tho. IIUIII of an cle""'nt of M. and an ~ of l.l"'. Beta..... E ill ilic dlrttt Ill'" of B and l.l"', tbe proposition MUon.. 0
knd gcnenLl<'lli" &r .."".. JiKd a E E emf leI bo! 1M .1;0;'" COI I+leill~' oj B •. 1'111:", lor eK>'}t r E e'" , ~ "",",pone'" oJ", ill B• .. ..,....: 10 oup"" z' inf{ .. lol, z).
Th«>renI 1.2.2 Ul B. /10
e:.
~
PftC><)P: "-un\
,.netUed
If nEE, ~ E E .... diojoinl: . ,Ilea ,"" b6Ild.! A . B by ". b, ",,»«:livoely, "'" dOUoinL Inc\eo!d, • ~ to the d.joinl oompk" ..", it' of
(n} ... B C A'.
1.3 Order Dual of a Riesz Space DclInl.J.on 1.3. 1 A 1i!>eV Iorm Lon.., oro.oed _ ~ti"" If L(r ) 2: 0 (in R ) for all % E E+ .
If L ill JXI'Iili~, the n:btlon P~itlon
% -:: ~
implieo! L(-s)
"pace E Is Mid 10 be
':S L(').
1.3.1 Ld E ... ""...-dtml _,tn" 'J'I'<'I' and L .... ~jlmc tionjrom E in.to R ~ng L(;,:) 2: 0 Jor
1.3 Order 1>-1 of.
ru... Spoa
13
P I'IOOF: Additivity of L implies thai L( - : ) ,. - L(: ) for II!'m')' : E E, and ., ... .......:I ooly treat thoe cuo in ... bich ), 2: O. N""" L(n.) .. n · Lj. ) for.U "ENand,.]I.EE, ~
LG ') " ~'L(')' Theedoot. L(r:) .. r · L(. ) for"]l ralioccal numben r :<: 0 and ,,]1 • E E. Now , If r , r' ~ tatioccal num~ satWyin,g r ~ ), ~ r', ~ ha,,,
r ' L(z ) ~ L(.u) ~ r' · L(. ). But r · L(z) and r' . L(%) "...y be IUen .. clooie to), L(:r) .. dtIIi"'f E #tIdI tJwu C + C c C .red JC c C I.". ~/), > 0) """ ""'icb E .. C - C. Lei M '"'" A ""'""" frr>m C into R MlU/)cfiIJ M (", + ~) .. AI(", ) + AI(p) "'" all"" ~ E C AM AI (.u) .. WI"')
f.".""" % E C ami Ctoer)"), > O. Then
t/c.erc: aU,", A ",,_lin...- ~
LoIMI<>E. P ROOf': EIocb • E E can be .. ritt..., % - ~, .. h: If % _ ~ - "I II aoot.ber decompOlitkla of. (~, " e C ). then % + " .. >:' + 1/ • ., M (", ) + M ("I )" AI (>:' ) + M (,I). The mappi"ll E:t. _ L( . ) io obriowoIY. linear form on E . 0 1.3.3 Ld E '"'" A lli..",W "",/.or 'P<JCO, "mlltl M .. a....."..." fr=o E· into R + ,1IGh tJwu M (%+~) .. M (. ) + M {II) /.". 011 • . II E £+. Then M ""'" ....iqw PQ4iI;'" I;""'r~ I<> !hI,,..\f E . P.~ltlo"
P lU)(lf: The acne &fIUIl>I'UI OIl lhat of P 'OJIO"ilkla 1.3.2 pro_ tW AI b.u .. unlquoe addili"" nullIIion L 10 E. Ptopoaitinn 1.3.1 then Jboon that L io llnear. 0 For thoe mnIlDdcr oflbio..ction. Ie!. .. ru-",*", E be p,....,. The _ Q 01 pOIill.-e U....... formo on E io ... ut.et 0I1.he ~ dual £' 01 E ("'*'" 01 all tiMar fonno on E). ClearlY. Q + Q c Q and ), . Q c Q for oJl cui Qben ), > 0; mocWIU, Q n (-Q) .. (Ol beeaWlt, if L and - L both beIooI to Q. then Lj",) 2: 0 and L(.) 0 for oJl • 2: 0, ., L .. 0 (Propooilkla I. t .3). Thio " n . lhal Q ddil>ee &II ordtt ...u.tkla OIl £' : L S AI if and only if /If _ L .. .. pOIIili.-e Untar fonu, or L S!If if and only If L(. ) < !oft"' ) for "U % E EO. £' io tb"" &CI ",deeed """""" "I*"', and lUI ~Itl"" t lc""",UI an. the pOliti"" "near fuo rna: thlf fact toCO)UUUI for thoe ~ooIoey p~y IDtnxloced.
s
DefInition 1.3.~ A liDt&t form L On E is6&id I<) benrder·bounded whene-teI" L It. bowxIed on bE E : Iwl $ z) for every ,. E E-. The :IpAQe of .oJ1 orderbounded l i _ f("". 00 E Is c&J1ed the nrOcr dual nf E. Tl>eore m 1.3. 1
fa) A. Imt4T form L "" E
01 ~ poniI.... (l)
u <>nI"u_Ioo ..n.Ud if ..nd <>nI, if il;, ~
mota>" I~·
diJJ~"'fUY;
n.. C>f"der i....t n QI E u" DtIIiebn4 ocmpkk~ .. 'I"'«.
P!tOOP: If L .. U - \I , w~ U. \I ..,.., !;orO po&itj~ linear 10,,,,,, on E , tbeD, lor all ,. E E+. the ~ion - ,. S II S ,. lrnplio.'e -U(,.J S U(r) U(..) and -V( .. ) $ \I (W) \1(.. ). lIeno: ILII,)I S Ulol ) + \I (ol), and"" L is oro. ....
....
""'Conveu.el.r, ....
s.
s
that L Ie ordeo--bounded. Wt need onI)' find .. pOIIiti~ ti~a:r bm N tud1 thu Nlz) ~ L(,.) 10, eed> ,. E e+ b ill lbe diKe .."". of t..-o pOIIiti~ Ii.,.,.... bmo. Put M(.,) .. ""Po;s.rS-' L.(u) fur all ,. E £ +. Then M (,. ) + M (:r') .. IUPoS~ • .o:s:"S" L{r + Y') $ AI(.. +:r') for &l1" , :r! E r . Nert, for ..U < ~ 0 S : S z + r , ..., find 1/, Y' E e+ ,ueh tlu.! 0 S. , S z . o S V S :r! , and : .. (mn;illary I<) Tbo,o~ 1.1.1 ); then 1,«) .. L(u) + L{y) S M (,.) + M (r). wlotoce M (,. +:r') S M (,.) + M (:r'). Since MI"+:r') .. M (%)+M(:r')1or 0.I1:t.:r' E f:+ .• be m&P~"'z - ""I'oso$. 1-(1/) frnm £+ into R hAIl .. pOIIitl~ linta:r ~ M \.(> £ . n .. p«M'!I tbe fir3t pArt of tlot Ibtotem and ~ O>Or.~r. that M is the ouP"'mum 01"0 and L In n. [t «'oWIIS to be ))«M"Il that n 1$ OedekiOO <:omplele Qt, eQuivalently, that ~ry """"mN oet of pOIIi.;~ linear forms.hat is dl"",1Cd upward and bounded abo<><: (in E' ) h.u .. su"",mum. Ail thil ill. in flirt, .. = ?'luetlce of tbe 1oUowi."l! lemma. 0 \Ul'lOl
,+ "
"*"
LemmA 1.3. 1 Ld H .... '''''~ply ..,.-rd.iireold ,..bn! f>1 £". II ""I>..oN " lol) .. fi>ta" Ir>r 0./1" e E+. Ill"" JI IWo .....,..,..,.. .. '" u in £'" . on.o:l .-(:a-) .. ,ul>..oN .. (,,) lor all " E
r.
P1tOOl' : For ~ry" E .F;+ , put v(,,),. SU""(HU("'), Tlotn vI""' )" .l.u(z:) lor 0.11 " e £+ and all .I. 2: O. Font... """,,, vI,. + ~) = u(,.) + "(W) lor o.Il "', ~ to e+, tM:<:t._ H 10 di-=lCd u~, The lemma n...... foILoon from ~too \.3.2. 0 fUo:tJI that L +(:1') .. '''PosrSo L(w) fo< all LEn and toll ., E ~
"""<:too,, II••,
(L V M )(,, ) _ (L II M ){s) ,.,
...,_.
IUp .~o..~
.~
.. ....-. inf
~~
r. From this
L(II) + M (:) L(,)
+ At(: )
(n
,
1.30rdt
for all L, M E 11 and for ~ r E £'". In particular, tbe IiroI. of tt... bmuIM, we _ ILI(r) ..
~1lI
15
M by - L In
that
'"'....
. ~,. ~ ,
L(II-
~).
~.
Obeen'e that I~ - % 1S r in thil IMt formul&: &100, tbe ",w.ion 1.. 1S :r impl;" L(.. ) _ L(... ) - L(M - ) S ILI(" · ) + ILI(" - ) .. ILI( I.. I) < ILI(:r), wbellC! ILI (r ) _ 'UP!-I!Oo L( ..). In particular , IL (:r)1 S I LI(~I) for all % E E . ProJ><-ltion 1.3.4 T_ ".,litillt: lillftlT /omu L, !oJ "" E an: dj;jo;'il if Irwi ~ i/, for """l':r E E· .nd ~! > O. tMr< """1 II , z E £+ #...:100 /Nil :r _ w+ z .nd L(W) + M (z ) S ~.
Paooy: In view 01 tbe """""" formula in Eq. ( I ), tbill conditioo L II M _ O.
m
F7 no that [J
P~ltlon
1.3.5 Let L . . . ".,IEtlut: Ii..... r lorm ... E. A "...;m.. linmr form !oJ .... E Iodoftg. t.> the !Iond ~ 6,1 L .n 11 i/ and MElr i/, lor '"""'Yr E £'" """ ewry t > 0, tMr< .noll a raU nzunkr~ > 0...d>1ItGl the ...",..., O:s , S r arwl L(, ) :s ~ M (r) :S !.
,,,,pl,
PRoof': First , we obow that tbe condition ill ,.. "y: if At 2: 0 beloap 10 tbe '-d snzeraud by L, tben M _ V8~ «(nL) II M) by Tbeonm 1.2.2. Now U• .. At - (ilL ) h M ill IX"iti~ !or all n E Z·, and since 118 U. .. 0, Lemma \.3. 1 poo_tbat U.(:r) co.,," .... to 0 .. n _ +00; thlll tr.:.; Il oudI that U. (r) :s t/2. n havilll Men c:n.:..n , ...., _ that the f1'latioo :s , :s " [",pl;"
""m-
o
M (W) S t/2 + «(nL) II M )(W) S t /2
+ IIL(,).
L(II) S t /( Zn ), .. ..-as w be . hoom. W~ """" pro,," that tbe conditioo II I Ul!icimt. For """f)' 1X"i11~ lioear form M on E...., can wri~ M _ U + V , where U I:>eloocI to the band ~ted by L , V II diljoint from L, and U , V "'" poo;iti~ (TI>eon'm 1.2. 1). NOlI', If M Mtiolieo tbe condi.ioo of .be I>f"OP<*tioo, then 10 0, 'boo_ 0 < 6 :s , Iudi. that \.be f1'iatlonl 0 S .. :s :r and L( .. ) S ~ imply V( .. ) S t; for ....... ~ , z e £+, ...., ha.., :r _ ~ +. and L(,) + V(.) :s 6 (J>ropo:.itioo I.H). Thus V (r ) .. V eil) + V(. ) S t + 6 S 2t-. Since t ill ... bill"lry, V(:r) .. 0 for all r E £+ . Hence V .. o. 0
Thus M (, ) S !
w~r
For example, let T{O, R ) be tbe ordenld """""" 3paoo of all ....:I·valued
function, on .. tel. fl. "' ... t . : / _ 1(0)
Gi~
distinct " . ~ in fl, ...., _ t hat the pos;tl~ U_ I _ 1(6) on T (fl, R ) "'" diljoiill.
"""!. :
••
1.4
Daniell Measures
()efu~
.1"(0 . C) (""'pecl:iV'Oly. F (O. Rl ) to be the spo.co: of complex· (respoc. ti""ly. reel· ) valued fu...:\kms on 'giw.n nonempty 0Ie1 O. UId. For I e F {O. C ). denote by ~ I UId 1m I the re.ol and in"'tinalY part.5 of I. ILl '/itO, C) be a _tor .ubopo.ce of F (O.C). euch that Tk/. 1m I . and II I belong 10 11:(0 . R ) _ '/i(O.C) n .F(O. R ) for any I e 11:(0. C ). Since
···J "">'V' ,. I , ) _I, + h+2 I" - h l
and
. ' (I I )
""
"
-=
I ,+ h -ilo - h i l
I" I,
€ '/i(0, R ), .., 900 t llal 11:(0. R ) is a lI.ies> subopo.ce of .F(o, R). MOii,OOt r. "'" _urne t41, for all I" I, in 11: + _ 'Ii(O, R )+ and tll 9 in H (o.C) IIUCh thal 191 < I , + h tb
for all
19.1 S 1,. I9'>IS h . Bod"~ + 9'> - g. n..-n. fix"" & Cli".,.,!Qnn" on 1I:(0 , C) &mo\ml, to fixirq! &1'1. R,..llMar mappirq! r from 'Ii(O. R ) Into C . " and ... """tOO by ,,(I) . ?(~ fJ+iT(I",f) lor tll I e 'Ii(O, C ). For IhlI lEI "". "",..-l not disti"l!uish C li""", on 1I:{O. C) from R,.. Unear "",p~,,&, of 1-1(0 , R ) inlO C . J:le6ne a CI"-r for m " OIl H(O .C) ... reel if ,,( f) ill reoJ ror eva)' I in H (O, R), and pojilive if ,,(I) ill pooiti ... ror f:6Cb I in '11 +. 'The"", of R.li"""", forllll on 'Ii(O. R ) will be 0""'..00 br tbe rel.lIon 1', S 1" ... ~ " , (I) 5 1'.(1) ioo' &II I € H+.
f"",.
Ooflnition 1••• 1 A Cli,...,. form I' On 'Ii{O. C ) .. 6It.id to be of finitfl vario;.. tion wi......:"" L(fl • ""Pri'''''III.C).'''I~ 1 11'(9)1 is finlte roo- every I E '11 +. TMorem 1.4.1 ~II' ''''' C ·/......... '''"'' on 'Ii(rl, C) . 01 finik wNlioft. :n..:n u..: ""'pp11Ig I _ L{/) o~ H+ h4I a ~niqw C ·Ii........ ulennon 11'1 ((If' V,, ) to 1M """"" 0/'l1{0 . C l · M"..,.,... •. 11'1 ~ 1M .... 4Ilut olllll ""';Ii. II ....., lornu " on '/i{0 , C) ... t~fri", 11'(g)1 5 "II, )) lor 411 , e '11 (0 . C). 11'1 it m/kd u..: obol..u oo.Nt, or u..: -"olion, 01 1'. PROOF'. Lt< T be tlot unit~i,.de in the (:<)ntpltx pl&ne. ILl 10, h e 1(+ . If g" ,. E '/i{0, C l an:M>Ch that 1911 S I, and 19'>! < h . tben Itt + ( ,.1 5 1, + h for all (E T ; but ...., ~ Midc • • function 9 e '/i (O. C ) , lTd> thal Igi S h· By hypothesi', l boa exlol ",,. e 'I1 (rl.Cl 08tisfyi"l! 1901 5 ', . 19>1S h . and, - " ... ,.; I hUll 11'(1)1 S 1I'(g')1+ 1,,(9,)1 S Ll / ,) + L(h)· SiT"'" 11'1g)! is .... bitrarily do6e 10 h ), we _ thAt L(!, + h) 5 L(!,j + L{/. ), and
,,+
L{!,'"
.. L(f, + It) - LIft) + LIIl). By Propo6ition 1.3.3, L Ms " H (O.C) . oo 11<1 ill
pOIiU~.
Iu-r ,",,10M Ii')'! 11'1 to the .,boIe of ~....sl of the proof _ follow$ easily. 0 UD~
1.4 o.m.!l Mo.umI
17
n-"em 1.4.2 ut " lit ~ C ·b'"""" form .,." ?f(fl . C ), and _me tAal,,;, ....w. ut ... "" the H·Ii........ fr>rm .,." ?f(fl . H ) c:om!Ipondi"f t<> " . i71rm ; 1nMftII"' . ~(f) .. lU~rE "(n.A).t.Is/ ll'(J)1 (10 IkIIt 11'1 ~ t<> II'!). P IIOO'" The 6m lUlemenl iI obvious. ,,"ow . for fixed
a ..
. up
• f ..m....I.I.I:Sf
f"
11. +. pUl
1,,(, )1 .
I'or e¥ery 9 e 1( fl.CJ salillfyi", 1, 1 S J. IM~ v:iol.l a cnmplex nurnt.o.r ( witb moduli.. I .""" that ~ (,)I .. ,,«(g). Then 11'(, )1 .. ,, (Re(C,» a. So !l<1(/) Now the .... , .... i""'lualily is ~k!arly lrue. and lhe reoull
s
s ...
rouo.-.. c
The.~
QM (fl. C ). of I""'" eli ....... forms 00 1((fl. C ) dial ha"" fini'" .......Iion • • a _ _ IU"~ 01 1M al3<:braic dual 11.(fl. C )" and """Will lhe lei. of Il<*ti"" U-.- for"", on 1( fl. C ). MOito ~'.lpl_ p!or any Il<*ti"" li-.- form (by Tbeortm 1.4.2). II' , + 1'.1 s 11', 1+ 11'.1. and lol'l .. In l'II'1for alII',. 1',. I' In QM (fl. C) and all " E C . I'o r any linear form I' on 11.{Il. C l. lhe linea. form Jl : J _ ,,0) • called 1M canjuple of 1'; Re I' .. {II + Jl)/2 and 1m I' .. (p - p)/('li ) an. calk!
DefI nition 1.• •2 A I' in Q.\.i (fl. C ) is said to be a Daniell - FZ".m! if 1'(/. ) <:OII·. u ... to 0 for ~ dec , 56", sequence (/. ).~ , in 1(+ admitll", 0 as 11.1 Jow.er en""'ope. Equivalently. p e QM (fl . C ) is a lAnieli metllNl'II if 1'(/.) taIdo to I'U) for evo-ry iDC.--i", ""'I""""" in 11.+ o.dmilti", I E n + as il.l upper ~o,-.Iop< . Call M (fl . C ) the -=tor rubol*'" of QM{fl. C ) <:<)08isti", of the Daniell " ., ,.,..,. and QM (fl. R ) (, !l pectivdy. M (fl, R » the H-woctor ~ 01 1""'" I' in QM{fl. C ) (""pediveiy. in M (fl . C » IILaI an.......t .
P ropo.lt ion 1.4 . 1 M {fl. H)
u ..
baM
In
QM {fl. R ).
P IIOOF: Let p E M {fl, R ), and IeC. (I. ). Z' be an iDCreuilll!: ""'I"""'" La 1(+ upper ~o,~ I heloo># to 1(+. Tbe ""'I""nce (p+U. »o?: ' inc> F ,., and II ...... ,Nkd. 10 .. .. ruP.Z' I'+U. ) • finite. For ~ > 0, lhere in "H.", , :5 I , ouch tlw. p+(f) :5 pIg) H / 2. Now the ""'I""""" (tofU., , l) . z , iOCiCT E and hzoz LafU, jI) .. fJ as it, upper en,-.Iope. Thill ,,( infU~ , fJl) ~ to I'(gl, and ,hel'll ill an n for _hid> ,,(g) :5 1'(lnfU • •,l) +t/2 1'. (I..) +~/2 + ~/2. FlntJly. " . (I) +~, ",Ilich ,," 0_ t lw. ,,+(1) .. a ;
_"'*
ex.",
:s ..
s
:s ..
,
.. be""", we _ lhat 1" II. Daniril mea8U~ &nd .M(O. R) is. 1Ueoz .... ~ 01 OM eO, R). tiat. Id A be. nor",,"p1y ou'-t or M + ., M (O. R )+. di~oo upward , bootInde O.lbere uillU ~ E A -n that (p - vHt.) < Then (I' - ..)(f. ) ~ ttl ro. all " > ! N<>-. for " larK" eDOU«h. V(J.I ~ ,/2. 110 ,,(f.) ~ t. lIe"c~" Os" Daniel! ,.-ure. 0
Ln·
Ob.enoe thai 1/11 belouc> to .M{O, R ) for ~i)'" E M {O, C ), b«&1.IIIe !PI < I&1'1+ IIt''l'l· In ]n>pO we IIhalI ex"",i"", !alt<. If I' € OM (O.C) and ,, € QM+ ....,...m thal!P{~lI < v(h) lor all h E 1i'*' , t'- I,.{gJl S v(lIi) lot 0.11 g E )t(O , C). For" E OM (O, C ), lOOt 11'1" SUPGET Rt(QI' J.
I
Leo E .... " JAddr '-.j -.~ R-. oJ*)t. A 610."" ...... :F .,.. E .. oaId '" bo _ .......... bo,.e'd thtn ttiouo X E T o.tw 00 bourriod.".,... uoI below. Tlw:ro _may _ .... ho _ IiIDiI (n ' S _Im.ty........ Iimil) <Jl F . wri._Iim_F C. LLro<' Mly. li",kIf F) • ..,. , "" "",,,,,II In/",, (... p X ) I. S"' .iwlr. _" (Ia{ X)) 01 E, ,.,hen X " " . - ....... ' M ~ B 01 000· .......... _ X E :1': ."""
w....., .ho,
;;""1aC1' S "",,,,,,,F. F "- ........ ~ ...;. ill O. "" II (",Jo •. ) . ( _fOat. If lim kif F • 11m "'p:l'. "Ib.o " " " _ ...: ... 01 ~ .~~.Io:mtntI! .. thorn d : ' Old ..,. ~m 1'. and .... _ .ha< F """'.€Fi <0
I,
",,""'IF""
...
T 1I~'It.et_F_£ . _u..,
101 (oup X - Inl X ) _ U" ....p F - lim iIIl F ,
,.
Let / be ... "' .... "" ~ I...... E ""'" on i1MI of. D...lddDd
...... pIook 1UtM""""" F . If" fi""," balOo F "" E """',,,, ..., _ o.tw tho ~" ... _ /IT) "" F .... "cox.. _ .ha< liID/(F) - / (ti1llF), 3. I.e< A be. 'II "P'} ",<1.. «1 ott, d!rocted "po<&«j. _ S.be filter bMif (p E .... : 8 i! ,,) (a .. E .... ). Tho 610 .. "" S .. <we. 4. I.e< CE; )", . be.·n , •• ply family of DfIdeklDd """pIook Riotm ud lot E be tho " ' _ """"'" opooo E" s_ .1Ia< " I:n«ndtd fiJter ....... F .... E .. - ........ ax •• ot 11_ only If. 10, -.,. i .• be AIW ...... JI"", (.Fl II ",
.... . ....... A...... ...,01""'_ 0<1..,. *"
A,
boo·...w
n,••
'''''.0
"*"',
r
2
"*"
Lo< 0 be. D<dotiod ...."P'o<e Rioa ...:I lot (6' ..... bo. 1&miI:J 1m E. Ordot< 1>1 lod,...,.. ."" <:t.oo F{t) of 6nit ....- . 011 . _ put 0" - E ,,~. ball H E F (I) (.. .. 0 ). Tho IomilJ {6 ,) .. , 00 oald.., be ( _ ) ... ",.. ·h. if
E",,"c·
Jor Ch'P""" I
IV
I ON , H E' T{I)) io boIoa.cled aDd il ,be """Wi"3 H _. " bu • limit ...,... ,ho ~pwanl-
wri,"'"
I.
"""'" .1Lot a family (r, ),~, if .ummablo if _
ODIy if ,ho
IoIIo-ins toad ..
lioot Idd: (a ) Fa-......,. H E' T(I ). ,be .upremum r" in E . (b) Iul"" . ...m ... _ 0. (U .. part 1 of Exercioe I .)
~
11..:1 : K
E T I l), K ..... H ..
I,
hat a
1.
"""'" IILot IWIJ' oublamily of a oummabIe family io .....,_Ne .
s.
Lot (r, ),., be •• ummabIe family iD E _ (I.) ... be a partition of I . Fa-=!> ). E L , put .... r, . Show ,bat the family {" )' H if ."mm,b!o
E,.,. aDd ,bat Eu-., ... E ... , z •.
4. Lot (z,),., be a family ia E _ (I . ), ... be & &1Oi", partit .... of I . S u _ ,hal.be family (r .).. , • • O\Lm ..... bIo Jor an ). E L. Sb<>o-.hal {r, ),.., 110 . "m_Ne I . Lot (z,J.. , _ {.. I .. , be , _ ...... mabIe famitx. in E ';Ib lho _ Iade.~, 1. p..,... 1....1 (r,+1' )"" lIoownmableaDd tIW ,{r, +.. ) ..
E.•
E.. ,,,, + L,tI"· 6.
Show u.a. a family (r ,).. , of ~Iiw ok ,..,.......",m'b!o if aDd oalr if" tho ~ I.., : H E T (/)) • boIondod _ _ _ .......... lb. __ . E,., z , _ ... p"....m .... Lot (.. I... , be. r.... iJJo ... E .ucl> IILot 0 S .. :5 '"
Jor oJl ; E I . Show that .be io iD E ............ , (Iz,I)" , 110 .......
_ aDd ..... , iD.hiII .... IE .. , z,1 S E,. , lr,l· .. Lot (z. )... be. family ia E a/ mn• ....u,. diojoil1!. .Iot .... _ "'wet.b.ot liz,) : i E' I ) • bounded . - . Show ,bat (Iz,I) ........ m ..... bIr, prow, in fact, ,bat (L,u"')* .. E ... , z: aDd (E .. , r,)~ -
L.., ,,;,
... 111M S
IE,.. %,1_ E ... I",).
Lot E be • o..dNiDd OOIIDpiote I.
rur.. "-",.
Sbow that , ............. lamll,o (u. j ..., in E a/ .. rictly ';,b , ... 1ollo.i"3 "" \ ,;..,: (. j (b l
~ . ;.."
.Ioroe,,"
.." ... ..-e dio;om. .. be ...." .. J;' t . Fbo-......,. ,, :> O. t bore ...... i E , ...... Ilia< lul(" .... ):> O.
(V" Z f E I , aDd",,_ tllM ' Iz. ): i E I I .. .....' k.! _ _ ia E. Show , ...., lot: ......,. ; E I, r • • ,ho
E..,
••
"
loo:< A b
,haI." "
I . Pro>" (PI V ,.) _ (z " " ) V{z " " ) Io<..n z, " . " E A if and oa.ly If z V{ .. " " ) '"' (ez V .. )" (z V 1'» for ..n cz, " , .. E ..t (in .h...... A io Mid to 110 " ",nbuti ..).
2.
Stow- 'hoolollowi,..; O>O>diliono {., (b ) (e)
or<: O&Iioliod:
A io " iitribooU ... A 1&00 ... "' ~ _m. D. U>d .... pr=um, I. A-"",,, E A 11M • «01 z' ito A, ' 11M io, """"Y z f' A , _ "";"to ... r € A _ ,bat %/l z ' _ 0 &ad z v r _ I . I
, , , ....
(Tbt io, A io . &c It " • ....1..... ) Provt ,bat ~ z € A ..... ...,;qu., .1 -r and ,ha< (:00: V _ :00:'" r/, _ fez /I ~ )' '"' z· v r/ ro. oil z. ,E A.
,r
«wor!o5
I•• " . ' +00;1001 _ •• c~ _ io ........bat io boob <: ~ . I U>d opeD. AH."..!__ II' _ 5 io <&Ilod ...-odi.... . _oaI if ,1>0 .""",,, tot. Iotm • _ lot ,1>0 "'1>'1 C '" So 5 io II.... toOdorl!" io ...-odi ......... "
"'*'"
I.
Let 5 110 ..... ·Ily d _ _ ..... . """"_ H· .....c,If .............. 6{S) be 'ho c!.M of .." ED I to of 5. o.nd -10(5) to, Incl...,.,. p",.... ,t.u. b(S) • • _ _ .1. b....
2.
.... 5, i be Mo 10(5) """" "(T) . P ....... bo, ,be«: ""'.... I..... " .... pIo .... ., '" 5..., T _ ,bat ! W ) _ (o>(cz) ," f' UJ for ..n U E 1>(5) (if. E 5. po.I\ 8 _ (U E 10(5) , • e UI. &ad obow 1M< (""\"u ! (U) io • .. "II ....... ).
3. Lot A be. 11.0 b , . . , _ A- -..II, d jeooq_. T io ' .
_
S"- _
'" A"
....,.. .... s..-, I 0 of< I. " ""boo:< J '" A 10
6{T) &r
....... , .....'" A I\u •
"''''' ~''m. by ~
to .1.
if A _
2).
sw.. _
w• .....,. _ .....
Ia'u.:.. w..
(uniquo II!> ",,<WI_ to tho ""'"
~he«I
{.,
calk
IEJ.
(b) 011'1, and (e)
lor
..n", ,E A,>: "
,E J if &ad
""'J' ifzE J and, E J .
.... 5 bo ,110 elMo '" """"imal ~11erS and, 100- - , . z f' A. put S. _ (J f' 5 : z E JI. p,...., ,bat (5.)' - 5 . , &ad .ha< s. ~. So " So U>d 5.v. '"' s. u So lor 011 :00:. J In A. S __ lha< tho _ So korm 'ho _ '" • H '. h lf~""
-
s.
4.
.... Ai C Abo - " ,Ioat 5 ;. U"Ai 5, lor all ~nl"' • . . - . A. of Ai . DoaooI. by 1 tllo of 1 _ • E A b- .,hldl .bent .,,;0,0 • fig ... tot A. C Ai ...... lhal • aI. I • • all ... and _hldo that 5 .. """'pOd by _ " , , .... 5 f- U ' EA, 5. (~Zcr~·. Ienuna).
""*
Ex,,", ': I 10< CMplft I
21
5. $""",.""".110 map ~ _ S. io alai.;.", ioo<'.....iom frooo, A 0ftl0~S) (_ ,.., ""","poet_ of $) . IS
A Boo!
A io
~ ~
~~ .
I.
A H'''wIQrfl" _
X 10 oaid to'" """d'''!) dio<:nn""""'" if ,hoi ,h• .,... hold:
, _) E""l" open"", """ _ (h) I~)
~
(lo..
clo>oi>o",.
E~ """" .... U wdI ''''''' U _ i"'{O) io clos>tn. If U. V "'" diojooint _!OJ' to of X •• _ ti n P ....
."".a..
Pt-ow. .""" ;r X 10 1y d~ • •Iw:n X 10 ..,.&11,. dio<>on"",,,<.l. 2. Lott X ..... t.ota.ll,. d _ _ ""'. ~ H........... . ~ »~ ' 10M /( X ) 10 Dede):!nd -..pIece if ond Gilly if X io ""~ dioooo~. f
IAt X be .. ~., _ _ An LSCfwo<."ti<>oo. on X ("'pood i.-.!y. .. USC fu",," tion 01> Xl io an .t.t. .. iati<>oo. f<>r. _ ( _.~. a wn) .. jrnp;i......,. "'....100 on X. If A io .. _ ... _
A" jrot ""Y " E X .
01 X o<MI I • fiu>cti<>oo. _ ~i1i .....
n.... M' r _
X o.IW,i"!l ...;~) 2:
/ (' ) ·
......... A
..
'0"
inl ,
":or)"
A into 1t .b.a put ..p I I, ) , ... ...,""
01._
U.........1eot USC fu...:t.io ... I" .... I I,) f<>r 0.11 ~ E A. ...:I , io o:aIled l ho USC ~oriuIloo
" J. II< I.
""',I<. -...... ''''''' X 10 """'"poet...:l
0l
kt I ... an lSC fu""'"" on X ond , ill USC recu~i<>oo.· For ~ a E R ... poi ... " E X ..... h ~""" A") :> a doeo '"'" I>olon« to ~M_'" of A _ (r E X : .,(p) < " j : to, 10 l.5C 11<..... , .. <1>n\i....,... For """'"l' pair of ..... i<>nal N,rnhen <. ' < < •. """"" .""" the <~ I .... I" E X : I I,,) :S <. 91") 2: . / .. ..... bdte tJo.a'I _ , OIl toido .. ". . ,,, , ""'.
Mdt."""
2.
~. Ie< ~ bto a ful>Cl.ion"';'h "01_ ia
Ii. dofined and """,i. """" "" the 'X _ Mof ._he<. _ ... IoI. Lot/ ....... lSCf....... m..n X ;nIb R .bat _ "';'h ~ on X - M and ito equal to - 00 "'" "'. Show.hat.ho USC ,.....~ioc, of, _ with ~ "" X - .ft. u.d to "" X _ lot , 'M' ... ohow ..... A h.oo .. tutiq ... ""~ to Denote to,. c-' (X, of . _ <:O<&tla ....... IUII«_ I I""" X ;nlJ> It fo&- ..-~idt r '(+«o) and r '(-00) "'" _booo: .... .,...,."';~ .hlo.,.., ... put A .. I + , Slmll&rb-.... deli.,. ~I lot all ~ E R ond all I E c-'(X . C""{ X,ltj . "*"",,ittally .... &.0..:1. io. R.;e,;o _ ~ .""". if H ..........."pI,. .._ of C"'( X, 1£). .....,nd-! 000 ... and if I io 1.. _ _ ."' zI ..... (I(z ) ..... ~ .. ~z ) 100 oil z E X ). ,ben ,be USC 'OS ,)...I _ito&> <~.I
,
m........
n-
""".in...,...
x.
m.
g c( / io Ib.I '''P'''O'Urn of 11 I~ C"" (X ,Ii)_ Cot>tludo iU ideal C(X , R ) ..., Oo.IokiDd """pieI.t.
•.
,h.o., C-( X ,II:) Md
~ .4
boo ... """" ... t.d c( X , and let H e<moiot of tho Indicator funo:tiono Iv c( ,bo urn ofHlmC(X, R ).
8
~
1.
E be •
[lor'
If " E E ;,; . lhal ( ~ , " E Z +) ;,; bow>d''' ,bo. " ..
""PI i " 2..
liD<.
_
,
lbol 1..t""N
((I/ n)..) .. II rot...,.,.
~ E
£',
I~ ... E: 10 Ac
d.....
9
~
E be.IJood.kjDd alID~ R_ Opooo oDd B" fh 1_ boondo in E: Mliafyin& B, C ih . lei z be ... . k"..,,, c( E: ond :t,,:t> III< oom_1I< in B,. ih_ S ' that . " 10 lho ...... 1· ht.l~ c( z, 1m l bo _ B, «I B, .
10 Let" > lI_li_ln.OredrI
,
;,; • norm
:s • :s
1. A < E C ... ho comp'"''.''' of Min . booDd of C. if and only illl u and i..t( .. " _ oj _ 0. S"",," ,Iw. lbo _ A ot ,''''''' eIetoet1.. c 10 • l><dokiDd oom~ Px J · · ~ ~ and io o ~ i in ,be nonD
a.
C. .
For ~
~
let .. bo lbe oomponect <>fC. _ _ by (~" -z)-. SIoow .hat .. be,"",", ~ IIw. C>. .. II ro, A -U" H, ....:I ,ha< .. .. w lor A > n% l. For.11 ~ E R, P"""' t bbt t ho _ 8. In C•• by •• ,;,; _ lJ- .he band in C. ",,,,,,,,ted by ( A.. - %)-. Fix
%
im
OUI>.~ i..t(~~" _
_.ted
in R,
%) +, ..) ot .. In ,bo _
:s "" ..
:s ".
:s
• . Wi,b ~ _ -"1\00";0 ~ J" " , - .haI ,!>t .., "'~ of z in B. 10 k . - (.I, .. - z )· . ....:I 00 ;. .rn.ller ,han ~ . !I c bolonp to A. ;f < S <., and If B 10 lhe t.nd in C. _ ~ by .. pr
r..
Let a , B E R ",ilb a < 0, and I.. Po , '"~ be l ho projcoctlono of C. <...to . be boondo _ ..... by <:0 and '" mlpectivdy. p.",.. Ibbt (p$- Po )(" ) ~ (P. - Po ) · (".(,,)) ;,; ..-...JI..- IbM tI(.. -e.) Now _ by a;. lho """'PI<ment c( ( "" ) in c., and p... B .. 0:. "" 8 . 5i""" the "",,_nl (a .. - .,)- of ., - "" im 0:. 10 pooilive, t be """,_I
""p'"
&.
Let , > 0 ...... let >... ~ ,._ , .•.I.., be t-..l nurobo:n.ud> .hat .... _ 0, c .... ~,.. and 0 < A. - A._, :S. Sot.tJI I::: j::: n . For.,.....y II :S j::: n. d _ by '"
F .. i"b~1
Jt,.. - ,,_. )(z ) -
~ (CA.
-
CA • ••
11 'f 1'(":0..
-
c>., •• )
boll l S i S n . and 10 O~ - r: ,~,S' ~(eA. - <••• ,)1 'f f. Oed""" that , .... _ 00 1"1_ V of C •• ~. i
Ld S "" II.. Stoooo 0p000 of A. 6< I"" indiuto>r fu...::tion of II.. r c-.wy c E A (D O. Fu' ....
r.-.: ....
.... nu..v..r. .I.o . l, . . . . . ....... """ that .1.0 'f I~f, .. f{fl . ..... > ,up,U ,t.). ond 0 < ~ - ..... 1 'f ~ b~ I 'f j 'f n, PIlt A, '" I' E S:f{t) <~) b 011 1 'f is'' ond B, _ A" B.... A,n CA.., b 0112 SIS n . " that If - r: ,~.~. ;1.,1 • .1 'f •. no... W io _ In C(S. R ).
&.
p",.... thai. &
1I_ QI)OnI,j"", ....
E", l ,c, of .IE"..,... . ,
Ifond
.. _ wile, : i E Hl v (.. -
L
c,_
ZH
-
e, : i
I " ",
E A io
pOOili~
..... d •• by
I HI) ;
L
I ••
HVUJ ... H
H
lor j E r}. Thuo tbo:rt io • uniquo ioom<>rp/Uom ' from 1M .. due
Ld (z. ).. ~ , be. Co.ucby ..... _ la C... &nd let I" •• I. ~, ........boteq" n.....::ll t ..... I~ • • , -z •• 1 'f 2"""' boll. 2: I. Put \II'" z ... , _z •• boll . ;?: I. Pro... . hat the fami ly ("' )'l' i ......... mm ..... la I> ODd _ thot. i f , ... (z " )' 2' __ z . ~ ;-z .. , la ..... 2, C. (10 C. io . 8Mod1 0p000). COlldudcl that 9 _ to an _ .. try &om C. i...., C(S. It).
,,,,,,o>o
E.
\1>. '_
""pi '"
LeI z E C•. Pf...-..haI.,. ... 9 io pOOil ;'" if and
II
Lee £, ,,> O. C. be .. in Exeftilo 10. aI>d M!I: B. be lbe band ito E
~
. , o.
I.
B:.
Foo- 0Wfl' z E pu. ~ . ... laf(....,.,) b all I~"" " ~ O. aI>d .... i~ .... 1.... USC fOC\Ilarisat .... of lboo uppor ... . <1",. of I.... h .. "" IbM iz ill """,I~ ___ It, boIt:oIco ... aI>d " h ._ lbat 9, Iml (z, ODd tbtrfti;n lbao, S z . O""h"", .hal ijz ~ ... C-(S.R:\ &nd • • boo in C-(5. Ii) of lboo h • . 1.1", ,", . . .. h ... ,up.,.c•. O$.o'S' h' .
c:
"'pr
:s
:s .(
,».
1.
~ IhM Ih.er. io • uniq ... 1;""'" ""'I> j from C. into C""(S. Ii) .1lCb Ih&t I (z ) _ fr Iot.a % E B: • ..-d _ 1h4.t ~ ;,.., ..... .,.phism from B. """" all <>r.!enId _ oubipta of C""' (S. 'ft) (oboenoe IMt if z. ~ E B: _1Ji s: Iz. ~ z).
1_ s:
J.
4.
s: s:
Let rEB: _ g E c'"'(s. R) be V-O. oud>.hat 0 9 9>:. """ ....y i
p,..,.. lbe
....
btatino t"""""'n: th..-.: ",,>ott • Rita ""'" tt....! ,
ioomorpbiom ~ from B.. on!<> &D idoooJ 0( C""(5. 'ft). lot all • in A _ I mapo C. on\o C(S. R ).
l>.
Ib C. (eurnln<.N:""" ....... do ""... .,n 60l Ex.ercioo 10). s;..,. z '"' oup'ZO ibf( n~.z) 100- ~ 1: E 8 :. j .. uniq ... *"-1>""" from lbo...-de"'" _tor .pooo B . OI>to .... ideilI '" C'" (S, I£) S_.IIM V io ...de< _
oudt. .....
i2
t'"
1(.1- I .. fOr oil. E.A..
""""maI._
Let E be .. Dodddnd <»mplo<e Riees'!*'eo C.... )a. A II In E oJ Olrittly pooiU .... diojoiDt -' ", aDd, fOr - . " E A • ........ e by bMd _ated by ..... E io _ I hlc 10 I'" ide&! of n... AIl.. """ ' 10\\"11: of 11_ (2.)..; A oud>.haI (lz. ) : 0 E A) io bou_ olw:rvo ( _ bettioo J) . fO< ~ o E A. let K . be tbe St<-"-'" of (:0: E 8 : 0 % o . 1:o1(z .0 - 1:) - OJ ond I. ,boi" .phiom~ted ~ from B.. ""'" .... i
a.. ....
s: s:
E>orn:iooe
llJ.
I"'"
"*'" '"
Let X be .... !<>pOI onm .,rl'" K .. C""(X. 'ft) lbe II.,.. ......... ,..,... fu .... _ I from X imo 'ft: b ,"'h>ch r ' (-hx» and r ' (-",,) do_ in X . and "H( R ) .... """""
x.
....,_bore
"'u....
i.
If B;' .. ""-,,poty .u.... of E, boun<\cd above. and if I io , ... upper ........ lope of ..... (:tl. b z E B.' - tha, * (oup B ) io .be USC """larizati<>c Of
2.
by F (A } .hoI .... of finite IlL....... of II . If r e ". _ 1: _ o z. is.hoI of:t t.loo.!! tbe 11,...... a. fiDr all" E A, ..., boo.,., Za _ O"l'.~ inl(" ..... %a ) . .. _ Inl(" .... ,z.) bolonjp to ~ - . ("If·). _ % _ ouP••lA :o:. io tbe OUl'f1'lllu,", of tho u~.di_ted .... B ,, - ' iotlAt! oI t"" '~P""J 'nf(" ..... r a ) (J e F (A )• .. po>oi. i"" i " " -). 0.,. d"...bat ."" &1\.0< (; of -,10.. ol B...-do:< coa ... , to r ond.,.......;... ~
E..
_.p<JOit.i<m
• -'("H' ). 13
t.et E bu RiooI>. 'POO!!. and (U,).." • """""'P'Y family '" po>oili .... Ii ....... _ " " E. Aoo""", .......... 'opoloc T . dofi""" bf "'" ......i _ U,()zl), io a H· ,...,.....,
-.
i . S"",", ,hat "'" """"""" r _ )z) is un.ilormly <XKLtin ...... I""" 8 ...10 E ond ~ in "'" ~ T .
,ha, r
... ..
'I'
ate
E
LC:<'
.".
Ch.apt
l . S u _ that E io DodtkiZ>d oompi
g
3.
s_ 4.
"'*'"
H• ...,.loct b, we .._ Ihr.. the ~ _ _ E ;. (Dmplc< .. N"", Itt A be. & _ 1><1 upward-how 1hr.1 "'P..,A I (z ) _/( .... pA ). o-I...... hat E _ DodtIdZ>d oomplot.e.
or
<»<>I"""'" .....
".p
Le\ F be. "" order ........ Sit ...... f: wi.b Iimi, % . Let A be u.. ... 01 u.. .... p X - iDf X. ~"""' X • . . - _ 'M ~_ of l:>owodod .... ;;, F . Not.e Wot A io dir«t ....... , _ E.
'I'
ate
2 Measures on Semirings
",. l boor)r
lot
~
or ~,~ _u_
whd> .. 1... r<>(t
in , ......... p'.. . 1o_i.a1,
......,
m ,1>0 Iheoty or ptOboohili,y_
n.
U C;-, .. _ _ P'J"'" 0, c.ho _ oeI ol """ipptd .. ith .ymmoOf'eIy .. -urinl! (Orinit.,., 1.\ .2). The " .ri.. of HUm.:;. _ ODd ,be .. "rboa '" ~l .... (W.iU.,.. 2. 1.6). ,,, a ~ .paD!! n , ..... on-. .be _ impor<&D< eompIM of ,...~ _ . _ and ..ill be widely . - I
,_'ion ... ..
'~" tl.. book. 2.2 In . hio ...,.;0.. .... finot dJi_ quMl-_ ...... 'bon _ .... .,.. _~ It. lullC\io>n " on .. -Uri.,. S .. .. _~ if and only if, lor &"f . ' '1'' .. "r
r:
UA.
s. •
L"eA,) """........
bot_ ~nct ' c ' 5 m.... deli""" on a oomiri", S ar>d D&nidJ - r. ...... <106_ 011. S4bnplo fun«1ono ( ~fI""".",.,. ).
W. ;0..""1\",,, J ct " " .. _ .... _ ' ,.. dellJIfId ..." . . oj I.. ~ "'.~ iI>d..dod iD _ interYal/. 2,3
2.1
Semirings, Rings, and
0<1
the
....u.UIf; of a.II
o- Ri n~
Let 1'(0) be .he peA" oct of .. D(II>tmpty tel. n. For all ;t, B E 1'(0 ), tbe dilfe' , ' '''''' of A and 8 , A - B , is defined ... A f) 8"; lhe 5ymmdrie ditfert"llCl!
A t:. 8 _ (A n a<) u ( ACn 8 ) tonaists of the elemoontl that lie in A Of B but not In both. for eKh A E "P(O), denote by 'PA the mappilll from 0 into the rilll Z/ ZZ C ~ua1 tAl I on A , tAl 0 on A • 'Ibm 'P"-,,s _ 'PA + '1'8 and 'PNl8 - 'PA' 'P8 lor aU A, B E "P(O). So the operations t:. and n !lYe "P(O) the st"""ure 01 . uniUty rilll· Dellnlt lon :U.l A elMs R. c "P(O) ill called .. rilll ohubeets 0111 (or eirnply • "'" In fl) if it •• rnbrilll 01. "P(fl) in the .... ua1 _ . Equivalenlly, "R •• ""I .. hen it. IIOOmlpty and when A t:. 8 . A n B lie in R. for aU A, B E "R.
PcopOIIIltlo" 2 .1.1 A n
~nd
if
PIIOOf": The conditioo. D<' " ')" boa""" A U B .. ( A t:. 8) 6 (A n 8 ) and A n a< _ A t:. (A n 8 ); It iIIrnllicient btet.""" A 6 8 _ {A n a<)U (ACn 8 ) andA n 8 _(A u B)6(A 6 B). a DefInition 2.1.2 A no)I"Iempty cw.. S C "P(I1) • caIlcd .. aecnirin& If, lor aU A. 8 E S. then: • • finite colleaioo ol mutually d.joim S _ wJK.e union t. A n 8. &lid if the...". pr
I.
Now the in\<;nooctloa 01 • coIleaion 01 rillp ... ri",. So _ m.y ddine the rinr; ~ by C to he the ...... 11..• "'" mnUlnin« .. Ii"'" C 01 P (fl).
..,1><:_
Propoaltion 2.1.2 LeI S W .. nmiriJog in fl. 'nIcn E E P (O) IOu in 1M ";!If "R ~ ~ 5 if and <>nlr if;1 ..... finiU ""...... 1>1 S,~t.. oJIic.\ .... ~ W ~
dUJoi>tl.
PROOr: lei. R.' be tbe claM oll"'- IUbeets 01 0 ... hicb can he finitely par. tIIO:w:d by s.-u. We fusI. Jbow It...! e¥ery IInloa 01. linl\<; I-.mlly 01 s-ts (no!. '. ' rily diojoim) Iieo in "Ri. The proof ill by induction on tbe number 01 elecnenll 01 the f.a.nlily; IUppoet it illme if lhil number iI n - I (n > 2), and let ( X, ),,.;.,.; _ be .. l...mly in 5 with n el<menll. We an write
z_
U I ";;";.
X, -U
U
X,)n x:Ju x •.
1";''';. - '
N.".., by the Inductloa hypotbtolls, U,,.;.:>.._, X. _ U, ~<. Yj, ... hen: YJ E 5 and YJ n Y. - , if i ;. .t. MOIW"",, I"J n X: .. U' '';G'';., Z.... where Zj ... E S &Dd ZJ ... n Zi'/! _ , if (t " fl. Theldote, Z _ lU,~~U':5"";., Zj.... ) u X. , &Dd _ _ 11w ZJ .... n Z• .Il " 8 if i" .I: or Q;' fl, and that Z; ... n X • .. . b oJl j, Q. n.;" _ lbat Z 1... In R. i , &Dd t be proof is comp\Hc.
,
N.... A U B and A. n B I~"" ~' for aU .4., B E 'R'. It rern.ai ... ro be ~ tbAt A n IJ< beIonct to 'R ' _By the ... tu<:!illll N'gUII'Itnt , i t IUfIlceoI to conoM" .. tile CMe in .. tuo:t> A !MiIt 10 S. 'The> let A be an $-eM and B,., U's.'S~ B; be .. ~nJ«o union of S·~ A n lJ' _ n, Sis . (A n 8:'), wheno An n: lw in 1\.' ; bcoot A fl lJ' ill an 'R'-... a
_"'pi,
P ropn 2.1.3 Ld Site m......iring in n . F"., ~nr {int S·.a. B. (k E K , K /iniU) ,lid! tIw .... .4., " •• ~ 0/ ........ o/Ih. ,.11 B. _
en.,.
C n.,
PIlDOP: E~ _ A. ) n Al'l lim in 'R for any DOI'""pty IlUbtet J of I , ... -=II £1 can be linMl y pUtitlono:(O) ad "'<>It &p ... lilt . /00 .. 01 .11 nobtll .In dtid .." .. mUm (\u A., ~ f it fin;~ and".,.,...,..pfJ .... eI n~ A. ... A~ Iiu in C '"' .... i e I . ..mil al /trill, _ A. me. i'htll ... it a _',;"g, ."'" 1M "'If ~k4 !of ... it eucll, ~ ring ~uJ '"
C.
PRO(IPC For.u £ • niSI"., A,.,- aad F - ('''!.IS" d ,,"nJ' lie In 4r . On tbe;,u.,;... hand,
U
U
A~ .. _
IAt,n(
A.,.,- In 'i' , the let E n F
n
A, .. )I.
where tbe A!j .. n tn, soSl - ' .4., .. ) ~ diojoim ; ...
U
E n J'C .
Ie
n
A,,,)nA; ... n(
ISiS., ISiS_,
.. the
fini~
n
A. ,. lI
'S. :5j- I
a
union of disjoint ..-au..
Let C and • be .. In P r<>po)Oition 1. 1-4. Denot
V the cl.a88 nl finite
of C - ~ (A,)",I be a li nite _ p t y ,..."ily oIlUboIeU of 11, IPUCh u..t at Ieo.ot _ A; lod"'gII to C, and "",h tlw "'tbH A, « .4~ liM I"C for all IE I. PlOt J ..,(1 E 1:.4, ECI . n..n ia«!~
- (il iA.). Il .0
L
K C/_J
(1- 1,0: )
",' _ J
(-I )I KI . l i n.
, )",,, ..
\I ~. ~
A:)
io a line.r oomhil\t.tion of tbe I" (B E V ). If F Ie An R-_lO< $pace and I a rnappi", from Q UIt(I F 01 tho. !arm I:;EI c, , 1,0. (I finite, ... E F. A; € >t). thea, by tbe ... rnmark. J is . . . 01 tho! form L jH II;· 1,,_ (J finite.
-u'"
"'E F. B, E V ),
Dellnltlon 2.1.3 A Mlbclaloo R of P IO) iI oald 10 be. coun, ·hIe unio<1 of ~ iI an R.-ed.
• ri""..oo.
a·ri"l!"~
it iI
H"""". R C 1>(0 ) iI • a -ri", if it .. , ......."'pey. if A n B" 11M in R lOr aU A, 8 E 'R, ..00 if , count&ble union of ~ Is an 'R-1It't. In this eue. , counu.bIe ime, _tio<1 of ~ iI aIoo IJI 'R-_, "'""" 51'
.. here A _ U. ~ A" 'or IJIJ' - . _ (..t.)' N of 'R-eeU. M befor.!, then! Is. omrJio:st a·ri", containi",. civm MlbclM:! C of P IO). c· 11ed the " _ri,,, ~5", .. ted by C..00 oftw written ,,(e) 0< C. P ........ ltlon 2.1.5 LdC 600 a ... /PCI", "f P(O). If E iI an, let in ,,(C), r.V:n ~ uti" a ,»..."dle .ft'600'"11 V ofC Ada u...t E E ,,(V ). PItOQV: Tloe union of tl:oo:o a .. u~ of a(C) tlw. _
by tome a ,untable ruM •• of C iI. a-ri", a>ntr.ini", C ..00 contained in a(C); il iI 11.. i
,em
a
With not&l.looro .. in Pr........,;tion 2. I.S, the elM:! of tl:oo:o 55eU in n «>o(r«l by • CUU/lUlbie union of C_ iI . a-ri",. So every elePPlent in a(C) is contained in • munt&ble union of C-u. DefInition 2 .1.4 A lP'-ayatcm in n ilulul P of oubseuoCO sucb thaI An 8 iI.finite or muntablo union of dilj<>int P_. for all p·oeu A, 8 . Deftn ltlon 2.1.5 A
,.,.~
in 0 iI • clut C of subseu of 0 with t be
roilaorillll poopullM:
(. ) F _ E 11M in C, for all C-eeu E, F sucb that E c F. (b) A countable union of disj<>inl C-eeu itlJl
Obeerve IIw. if . it ...
"·ri,,,.
~Iem
c...t.
Ie ck H :l1rith rESptCI to finite imcr_ tionl. then
Tbeo..,m :l.l.1 (lP' _ A Theorem) LeI P 600 a lP'-.,.1eno """ C !he A·.,.teno ~ 6r P (~ Df all A•.,slmu
.,..riI!f ~U
aU 8 E P . N"", CA coutairro P , 'or eeeb A E C; thus CA _ C, ..hlcb that C Ie clo cd ";th _pect to finite Imcr_tiano.
,
ptOVES
0
Glvm,. !IOm;,I", S In O. l he ~lemenu of ...(5 ) ..·m htncd"orth be o:alIo!d the 5-BoreIlieU, or ~mply tb.. Borel ~ when the", is DO poIifIibility o f amfllllioa. A oemirin« (l'5pfId.ivoe\y, " "11& " ... _ring) R in 0 is Sllid to be. !IOmlt.~lxa (h!IIIpoocti...ty. fln ~ .... _. btaj ..!.me''e' 0 I>oeIon&! to R . The OrDB!Ieot ~t". (~i~y, .... ~) ODfltainiDg" p ven .ubcw.s C ,,£ 'P(O) iii called the ' IVi... (mlpectively, ... -~bta) ~ ...ted by C; its eIemenu "'" the X £ Rand lbe X ' . for X E R, wIleR; 'R is lbe lin« (..... pooctively . ... ·rin«) generated
", C Defl nillon 2.1.6 In alOp<:llop;ial opeoe 0 , the ...·ring 8 (""l*1ively. BII ), gmenuod by ,be eta. '" ali open _ (. ppoleI.ively. <:If all CQmI*I aeu), 10 called lbe Borel ",~" of 0 (no6pCCt;vely. ,be HILl""" ". ri", of 0 ). and iu elorno:nt& fln!l the Bon:I oeu (..... ped;vel,y, t be HaI..- lieU) in 0 . Prop
",,·.bn.and LJ...,
P?tOOP: t:. - I A c o : A n x E 8 K for all X E B", I"' 00QI.n. the cx-lsut-u of fI, PICI t:. :l B. If A belonp to B lUId it OOQIained in lho! countable union of o::>mp8
bece._""""
2.2
tn..e
Measures on Semirings
o.,Onitlon 2.2. 1 A maWing I' from 5 into C is Mid to 1M: ...Jdit;..., .. homeve. II ( A,) II (Ao) for """'Y fini te bmily (~).." of mutually d isjoint 5.-. _bo8rl union I... In 5. We define 11 (') to 1M: O.
14E,
L4'
Tho!o~m
2.2.1 Gi_ 1M. &dditMjI...dll'" II'S _ C . lAo... auto. 1I.. iqw. "dditi... ,.rocli<m II, from 1i """ C ...AD.. ",otrictWft UI 5 it II.
Eaeb Z E R it of the kmn Z ,., U'S 's~ X , . ..Ith X, E S and X, n X. _ I ... ho .... u i '" k. Hmoe _ may put II , (Z ) - E,s's' I'(X, j. To pr<MI that II, io _1kIeII!M!d, _ .......1 sbow that, if Z"'?toloo of lhot Jonn Z _ U,Sjs, Vj , with Y; E 5 and Y,ny, _ . wbtDO)"" j '" I. thot> E ,< ,s~ II( X,)l;:,.s;s, j« Vj ) . N<M. k>r """IY 1 :5 i :5 .. and ."..,.,. I :5 j :5 P. of, n YJ It l he d~1>1 un"" of 5-. Z;J.~ ( "';th I :5 " :5 m(i,j» ). PICI PIIOOI'".
'I'
ate
whl'".,.
we _
,hal LL S ':S:~ " eX, ) .. L;.:[,:s:. plY;).
We prove IlOO< that II, is additive OQ 'R: Ld (X ,),,,;;,,; , be .. linite f.omily of mut....:Jly dilljoint 7i.-8eu, .00 pul Z .. U'S ';'> " X i. We have Z .. U' Si S, Yj. with Y; E S and )oj n y, .. 8 .. hene>~ i 'I- I. &.cb Xi n lj iii the disjoint union of S-1ItU Z'J..,( I :5 (> ~ ,,1{;, j)), 110 Yj .. U, s .,.;. U' :S~ :S o.('J) Z,,;,.. lor
.u1 :S i S p. and
Finally.
.. L L p,(x ,n YJ) ' s.s _ ':Si S. .. L p ,( X; ), 1:5' :5 _
-P~IUon
2.2.1
S~PPO"
th<J.I S;, ~ ring ~nd Itt ,, : S - C W 4" aJditive
J.,....or finite "''''''' (....l,u 0/ S · ..,.,. """"" F ( / ) ;, lilt: po"" ....<»lkd m.:Julon·erd"';on
'orm").
It!
0/ I
(IN.
PROOF: T he..,.wl ill obvioull ror 1/ 1_ I. Let n 2: 1, .00 ""me tbe formula io...:lid ror IJI:S '" N........, ....:.. , hat 1/1_ n+ I. and d _ &rI ele",.,," ~ 01
,. """ _(UA')-_'Aol+_ ( U ,,)-_( U'A.nA,'). ""
,El- I_'
iEI - I _)
t«a'1H I'(A U 8 ) .. II(A) + ,,(B ) - p( A n 8 J for iii A. B In S. Nel
Oeflnit;"n 2.2 .2 A n the ~n,;tl ng S is IUl addit;"" function from S II'Il<> C $UCh that II< I(A) .. oup L""II« A
V" if tMdilive / .... ~nr qt
A E S MId ( A. )oE' be a finile po.nition of II into S ..... Clearly. LIE, VI' (A,) :S VI'{A). Con........ty, ~ (Bj)jEJ be an arbitrary ftnllol pal' !ilion of A ;nlo S....u. For cw.'l' (i.i) E I "J. II, n Bj III the ...,;On .. finite l&mily Z'J" (where t E K'J) of d;.uoint S __ . Henoe III{Bj)( < LIE' L.E .... ~ (1'( ZiJ.• )( ro. all i E J , and PROO~ Let
or
E (II( Bs)1 JEJ ....benQO _ _
s: L ... ,
(:L L
that V;<{A) 5
IEJ
Ip(Z,J .•
. (lr,.,
11) :S L VI'( A.), ""
4, V p(A,)
o
VI' 1I1hf: sm&IlfIII. Uitole Idditi~ functions" from 5 Into R + "'Ii$(yi~ I,.(A)I S..(A) fo,- all A e 5 . Jr 11 10 al VI'( II;) :S Vp( A ) Ior e....-ry - . _ (A')."2; ' of diojolnt S _ whnoe unloo>" contal...,d in an S....,. A. l~ , ioo" ......:b Inl<#f n ;00 I, A n (U'!j'~~ 11;)< "M be partitioned into finitely m4llY S _ 11.(,1, E K ), foe 4IIY lirul~ po.nllion of A. (I :S ; :S n) inlo 5~ A;" (j E J,). thol .... J (lSi S n . j E J.) and t be Ai. Ct E K) form. pBrtlt Lon of A, ~
." DeAnltion 2.2.3 A functioo I' from 5 illto C ill .. ,,-"lire ...h....·...".
C.l
II II. ".....;._""
(b) II is ,,·odd!t'''' (i.e., ;<{A} .. L.2:L I'(A.) 10< """'l' d;,,;o;.lIt S«u ",hoet union A ill 411 5_).
""'I"'''''''' (A.I.2:' of
from 5 mto Cis .. m........., if (..lid onl, if). 0/ dirjotml 5 · ..." _u.imd m Gil A E: 5, 1M. ,~
ThM .... m 2.2.3 A jtoMNm I'
f<w
Oil, "",WAa! (II;).~I
E '2:1I'(A, ) """"".... . .."d if ,,( A) ~ E. ~ I lil A.) .....,~ A - u. ~, A•. PROO", For M Y eeq.......,. ( A. );>I 0( disjoint S·$tU (OnIaint<\ in M A E 5, tbe _leo L;2:' p(A.) ill comolui"... ;""ly c:onverg<mC . "" E. z I II<{A,1I1!l\1!11 be Snlte.
'I'
ate
S«t A, put VIl l A) _ IUp E;E,I,,(Adl, .. here tbe l upremum io I'm over tbe d_ 0I.6nite pwtitioos ( .... ).H of A by S-. We b"" to . . . t~t VIl l A) io 6nite. r im, 01 >e thaI., If thll JIFOIl«1y is II'\Ie for all .IooG""" Ao 01. ODe finite partition 01._ A by S«u, then it boklo For A,.nd V,,( A) s E.." V,,(.... ) (br tbe ~ 01 'lbeormI 2.2.2). Now .......,.. that tho prapmy io w.. lOr ODe A E S. Then there aillto .. finite »II"ition ..tJ (I El,) 01 A InlO S«u sud! lhat E"" . r,,(~ )1 ~ 2 + I,,(..t)), r.nd, by tbe poe.io\Is obeetvatloo, tho ",ope.ty is f.aIae for at!eM1 one AI, (i. E Id. M~.
ror
eoft')'
L ,U,-/'"
"'(~) I
-, •••L
1"(~ lI-I,, ( A:,)1
2 + I,,(A)I-I,,(A)-
,2
L
,,( ~)I
L
/I.(.t!)I,
"',-;'') + 1,,(Ali-I,,(A)I-
""-I" ) Ai. (:foil be
~/' _I", I,,(AJ)I ~ I. Fo< tbe _ _ I"UIOII., S«u A~ (i E I .) 10 tW tho pi operty io faloe lOr _
10
pwtltlooeod by ..t:, Mtiofyina; ,(P(A?>I ;>: I. ~l", thi:8 poor • lOA) lind d~t S«u A!' (t ;>: I, i E I. - {i.}) .uch thallho .. tieI E. z • E"". _ I;. IIIi1A~)1 di""l"J'III . .. bleb II .. coiltrr.dktion. 0
L:...,._I..
T t-..em 2.2.4 V" .. " ...........e lur P IIOOI': Let (A. ).Z'
be ..
et>efJ'...........,,, "" S.
of disjoint S«u ... bote unloo A 11M ID S. We ..-I only """"" IIw VIll A) < r:. ~. V,,(A;). BUI. if (BlhEJ io ... ",bilrfory finlte pr.rtlti.orl of A IDto S«u, Mod> A, n BI (I;>: I, j E J ) 10 tho diQoint unlool of S-«u Z'.i" (J: E K,.j. K'J 6nite) . 10 ~....e-ntt
~ I,,( BI)I
-
~ ~ . ] ;.. "{Z.J..)t
s LL L
1,, (Z'J .. lI
o Propooltlon 2.2.2 UI" k" ...................., (_,;«If, " ..........e) "" S "",, '" tJ\.e ""~ Gdditi .... ~ 01 " to"R.. 17Kn '" ... qIOUi·,..e . " (-rupt>etiwl), " ..........e) "",, akft4I
V",
V".
,.
.
:s
P ROoF' Denote b,- '" u.. addll j,,, exlmsioo of V I' to R. Tt.en I",(AII .... ( A) for all A E ~ . !It) 1' , ;s • qU8OJi._ure U>d VI" S ..... Mut..,nr, ViiI (A ) 2: VII(A) .. l'l{A) for all A E S, 80 VI' ,(A ) .. " ,{ A) for &II A E S. llen<:o: V" , and "I. which agree on S. are id.ntical. Nat, _ _ume that" is. m FE w re &nd ~ that PI ill Also. 9'Jre. LeI. (A;)QI boo. fIe loogI to R. and IK (8i),~J boo..., ",bltrary fini"" p8dil io<> of Z into S-toe1.& ~ A. n ,B i ,(i ~ L; E J) is the union of . fa,nily ( Z'j" )'~ K.~ (K'J finite) of d l!lJoiot Thm B, .. U,2:1 U'E K'~ Z;J'" ..hence ~8j) ... L; ~,L.EIO:.~ I'(Z,J.. ) .. E,q, ,,,(A, n 8 S), 1'0. """ry j E J. ~fore. ",(Z) - E .i€J :L;i!!' p,(A, n BS)' $i...,. -=It family u.,(A;n 8j));<: . ill bummable, "" is (1<. (.4, n B;») '
Ii'"
s-.
"""1'
ba.~reon S and (A.)~al • OOq~of S..- <1«. ' i"" to A in S. Tben ,,(A.) - I'(A) .. n _ +00; Iud d , p, (,4 I _ A") .. E, <,<._, p,( A; ..t... , ) to I' ,{A, - A) .. E.<:I I',(Al - A,.,) "" .. - +00. Similarly, If (A,.),,<:I ill..., 1...... ""'I' ........ of S..-. wb.oee union A be'ongo to S, lbea ,, (A~) _ ,,(A) .. n _ +«>. Corm!r.eQ-,,,,,,,,,,, t hat S .... and Io!$ I' be .. q ua/;i-measure 011 S . If ,,(A~) _ 0 for e>Uy 8equenoo\ (A. )02;' of S-u which doc, unto e. tbet! "
Q)rl'"''''
5
""It
"n&".
"a m " . "<e.
s..,,.,oc
PI"Op<>IIltloo <1.<1.3 I/>d! 5 it .. .,.· n"!!. ..... t..o.ndtd rh.. ruPAE.I V ,,( A) < +«>/_
TII~n
all
m.....",... " 011 5
P!tOOf'; SUppeoIIure" on
S which is not bounded_ T Mn. for """" 1nt""'" n ~ 1. there is .. B.. In 5 ouch t hat V,,(B~) ~ n; __ • putting 8 .. U,2;' B •• _""" V,,{ B) ~ n for e>Uy n. 1!.Dd"" V ,,{ B ) .. +«>. 0
S io .. "" , .. ,," if ..nd only if it io.,._ additive. For any 8eq""""" (A')'2;' of S--. (00\ ,w 'rily disjoint) """ for A positi"" function" on .. ..,...;n .,,;
s.-
u,
:s
B Indudcd in A.. In Ihla cue, ,,(B ) E.2;I I'(A,). Iv', : j , any Io!c " , be the unique _reo e>::tet>ding " to R.. and. for every intqer n ~ I. pul B... .. B n Ao n (U,<,< ~ _ , A.t TIw':n . &l!>Ce B ill l be di!Jjoint union of the 8.., _ haw ,,( B ) .. E~, ", (8~ ) ::: E o 2;' " , (A. ).
Definition <1.<1.4 LH F be .. real """"" "1*'0. A mapping / from {l inlO F ill S-.impie If it is or the form / .. E.JO~i' I"" ",here J io finite, Ai Jieo in S lor ~'(1 1 J e J, and c, bdoop t o F. The 0Iet of oJl S .... mpie """Wines from n in'" F will be
wriItt"" '" LO€ K (l;.l, ·1-,. lar .....14IoIe memlle.. £I, .. 01 F .
••
LJ_O.
P ROoF: E...:h / , Qlb be .,ritltn"" C;.j ' 1... ~ . 8 y i'TOposilion 2.\.3, there uisl d>.joint 5«u B~ (* E K, K 6nltt) tuch thaI e.d> A;J (i;n /, i in J I) is .. union of fOe of lhe B" : A;J _ UItf:I<,~ 8._ Then
f. -
L
,0.
Itf:K. ~
- «.K L ( UEI•.LItf:K' J I <,), •. a Now Iel.
5 _ C bt; addilh~, "",d Ic\ F be a BanadI "IW"" (real 01" c:omp6ex, .. It tabs OIl mol o. com plex vaI_). II f ., ColA, " ..., Saimplo rnapp;ng from n into F. lW define the wintognJ oil 10 be d le _ JI(f) .. f f dp .. E ,vC;jt(A, ), This definition m°w." ..""" beo:a_ the _ r:.." e;I'lA,) III il>depen
E"",
L.uC; lA, " LIEJSl,,;, !here exiM disjoillC ~p'r 5..-. B. (t E K . K finite) rud! llult ...:II Ai and each is .. unino of oome of the 8 •. T betl If
J ..
Ai
L ., 4 1'(A, )
- L., < L
1'(8. )
B. C A,
- ~ L~. e;) - &C~. s) - L~ ' L -
",,(B. )
"I'(B. )
I« B. )
jO
B, C A;
:L S· ,.CAj).
~,
The functioon ji: I ..... [/Ct~ from 5 inU) C ...... 0Ul identlfy E and thl: ~ dual SI(S, C)" of SI(S, C ). !ltacd.. t b .... 0>n!Iid0:r only SI (S,C) [...Iead ol tho: moor.. ~0.1 )f(ll, C ) of Smion 1.4.
"'*'"
lomdiDn " ""'" S inU! C .. Q "",",,"""""lin: m...,.,..j if """ onitI if ji h~ fin;~ ",,"';clUm (,...p"di ... I~, ..
Theorem 2.2.5 An IOdJili«e (~,
Q
c Daniell m _). MO' II!:>LC' , (foj _
ii;.
PItQQ,; 1'\nI.. IlUI'P'*l that ji hall finik variIIt;c.,. Let (A,)~, be a fini te po,rtltioon of A € S inU) $ ....u.. For e"o'ef)' i € I , t~ .... a oomplex number Co .. ill> modul ... 1 .. tisl"yinc I,,{A,)I ., '" ."(,,, ). Then I _ I ... ta1w;". III $ I.. , "" E.."I1<{"'ll" ii{/) " IM!)I < !PI(I .. ). Thus" is II quas>rneasurt and V,,( A):S (foj( l .. ) br 0.11 A E S. Ox..., oely.llUpp\* that" if B quas>-_"', CIe&rly.l [ 1'4<1 $ [ !tIdV" lor all. E SI(S. C). and [ IrlV" lilion 2.'2.4). The .. !Pu!) ., !lUP~$f(S.G"l.lflS / I [ 1'1,,1 $ [lrlV" br ~ry IE SI+ (S). So ji halllinlte variation, and Ijil(I ..) - v,,{A) for 0.11 A € S. This jJ<'MI that liil - ii;. N~, ~_ that ;:. It a Daniell """",ure, and let (A;)02:' be.~_ ol diojoint 5-oeto .. ~ utUoa A lioelln S . For ~ry integer " (I. ). !, doc, .. 5 • to 0, ii(l.. ) - I'( A) - E,:s's....( A. ) taIdfI U) 0 .. " _ +00. and bffla! " Is II _u~. F'lnaUy, _un", lhat I' III • 1I>eIIOiill O. Then
i"''
E"" '"
s.. .. (~ € £I : I.(~) > e} u..ln"llloo: alln ~ I . and the ao:querIClI! (8' )" 2;. dec_ to lhe empcy """ ... VI'. ( B.) _ 0 ..... _ +<:.>. N<M
J
l ..dV,,:s M · V".(B.,) + e· VI' ,(A) .
.. t.c ... M
- SUIl,... It ("') and A., (~ E fI : I, (z )
.-.-lim
> OJ , thUil
¥P(I.. ):5 e . V" ,(A )•
tim
ii;(f. ) -
o.
o
"'*'"
Call QM (S. C ) ( . I"" th-ely. M (S.C)) I .... o:>mpIex vector of qu&lll-" , ",.-ell (reoptcUvdy. _ ) 011 S. By Theorem 1.3.1 and P"-'I'O-
tition 1.4. 1. th$ cruer..I ¥fICIQr 'poo<:O:' QM (S . R ) ol.....! quui.meuureI 011 S ;.,. Do!do!kind cornpIote It>-"p6Ce, and M {S, R ) _ QM(S. R ) n M {S , C ) ;., a b&nd In QM{S. R). MO' Ilc"cr. for e¥eT)" I' E QM(S. R ) and for o:YeT)'
A
E 5. I' +(A) ..
H I'{ A)+ VI'( A))
~IU.P
..
L
PI" ) 8 ~PC A)
(1'18)+11'(8)1)
L
fUp ,,(H)+, PC") "£p(,,)
..
.. hen: PIA ) at.endII.,...... lhe clUi 01 aU finite panillorio 01 A In\O 5«ta; li m.. 1.dJUon 01 s..:tlon 1.4.... ""til!!i.od ... hen ..., ~ 51 (5. C ) (l"'lwd oI1i{fl. C )). 1looo.,.,..., ol ~ti>O!" ' '''... 011 5 io "";tlen M +($}. For the rf:IDaInder ol this I<:t " boo: • pOSilive meMu,"" 011 S. Denote by 07+ lhe lei. 01 upper et\~1opeI 01 inu : , dl\l ..... ue, ..... In 1i+ .. SI+ ($}, and put 1" (f) '"' ... p,o; ... . •,S.I ,, (g) for all I e 07 +.
"""'ion.
P~itioll 2.2.:; l - fJ ""''''' le:r 'er Ali I eo7+ and 9 E H· ... (~ fJ S I· 111f{f, gl, g), I +~, ond M Io>t.lot.og to 07+ , /M" aliI , 9, II e
:r'
"'1'
w'"" .
oiWI/cr <011 " > 0; ...... I"{f +g) .. ,, ' (Il +"' (~l ond ,,' (M ) _ ,,·,,' (11). Finall). ."..., i...".."..;,.g ."""en.. {f.)~/: , ino7· lou ill """"r "" ..... 1 in 07" , ond ,,' {Il- "'P.~. ,, ' {f.l·
POWOF-. E •..,.,. I e 07+ is the upper ~Iope of an in<;. : 1;"11 ~_ (/. ). /:1 in"K"'". For ev.ry g E ){" 8/Iot;,{ying 9 ~ I. the ..... _ {f. - inf{f•. ')). /:1 loci 5 5" Ie I - g, 10 f - , bdotlglr \0 ;r; !leX1 t he 1Oq""""" (Inf{f•. g)),,/:, i'..... ~\O9.80
.--
I' (g) .. 11m ,,( inf{f.,g») S
.up ,,(gj ......·.ri.f
.--
.. lim
11 m ,,(f.);
I'{f~ ) .
.--
:1+ and I ;!jj UP!""" e", elope. For ~ n ~ I, ~ (g. ... ).. /:, be. ao::oqueoce;n H+ ;nc""";,,« \0 I. , and put Noot,. Itt (/.).", be an lont ' "1111 !equen« i n
h., .. 8Up{g, .... 92 ... . .... g..... ) for till in~ m ~ l. Then g; .... ~ II .. ~ / .. for aU l S i S m, 10 Ii - .uP"!' iii... S "" P.. /:, h .. k>r .-.y i ~ I , and , S
10 ... T ills ~ lhatlbe!lKi\leDCe (h.. ).. ~ , i""~ 10 J. Mou:.".... , IlUP_2:1 ,,"(j... )
o
2.3
Lebesgue Measure on an Interval
Let 1 be ... ...,....."ply l.D~rvaI of R. PUt 0 _ inf(/ ) It.Ild ~ _ $up(/), 110 lhat 1 .. (4.~). Consider the """,iri"l 5 in 1 a)"'; ...i"l of &II inlervalo 1 0,/31 ouch that 0 S in J , &z>d, ... boo .. bel.oop 10 I , of ai! inlervlt.la (0, jJJ such that fJ ~ to I. 5 is oalled the lIIIluraillemiri,,« in I . The ,,·ring ~ by S ill _IT "..., 10 be lhol Borel ".o.!&ebr'" In I.
fJ
Defin!tlon 2.3.1 LH p. be ... complex m" . 8' .... on S. A function F from I inlO C is oalled It.Il indeliwle in!"I!ra1 of I' ... F {Pl - F (o ) - 1'(Ia-, M) &II 0 , {J E I oatWring
bene..,.
roo-
f!~: :_:;:~~..": ~'fJ: ~!
J:
dp+
[~+
I:
~
1'(1<>,0])
01"
dp_O
f:'
br all deIinlt.e i~ of 1'. Now F (z ) _ F (:ro) + til' &II" E 1 &z>d ro.- &:\)' other indefinlt.e !otewa! of 1'; 110 we Bee that ind:tnile intqrab of " .,.., equoJ. up 10 ... <:OnI\Nl1.
r
roo-
Pro~it lon
2 .3. 1 Ltl F : 1 -. R iIo! m."..,...;ng, eM rig/lt-..,."tin ....... on (.., 10{. TIl ... 110......... "".................. I' on 5 cdmilting F ... gn ind~fini~ m/qrnJ eM ",tUfyi,., p.({o» .. 0 ..... ~ g /!dong. to ,. T he uwqumees of Bud> ... _ure" otJl'io ...; 10 prove lu exio8~, ~ defir.e ... fuD
L 1'1 (<>.. ,fJ,,)) < p.(o,PI) • ,
.
~
1>0.:.,..., I' is a
LeI , > 0 be «I""". A. F is rlgh\.-a)ntinoous at + 6.tJI· Additiooally, roo-~. n 0 ouch that "P. l S p.«o.,Jl..I) + , /2- ', If .... put Jft - (Oft ,Po + 6,,1n /. N.,... tbe quao,;..~.
exi",
interior J: of J~ rtlMi...:: \(I f COOlainol (n •. A.). Md, since the cburt of J io! indinu..~, J:.lhen:~:cisl H, ~ I , .. "n, that J C J., U· . ·uJ., . From p(J) 5 p(J.,) + ... + p(J~. ) 1oI1m.'l! IIQW p({Q,81) :s:: ~, I'«n • . P-.ll +t . .... . io! arbitralY. tJl) .. L~.:!; , lI{(n • •.o..)). and $I> jOlt. mU9'",. 0
1'«0.
°
Dellnl t lon 2.3.2 The unique meMure I' 00 5 ~uch thn p()o,Pl) _ fJ _ JOoall .. , fJ E I aato.t:yiD« 0 :s:: (J, . nd ouch that p({a)) .. 0 ..""... ·,..,r 4 ""~ to f , is called Le~ ,IIOU"", 011 I . To IlOO that I' ""isla, tal.. F{z) _ z in Proposition 2.3.1.
Eu,clse.f for Chapter f I
I .. R ' , ",O(U0p, n '~' ~''''''''J (G,,,,, lor I :!i ; S t ) io ""lied" 1Iq...... Go io iodtj>£'ode,iO of •. Let S "" .be c_ " ~ ioIinc of """ ompIy Od ot'Id 01.l000000 1 I q _ .. htJooo ...... _ h&ve .... '.,..·1 Show ,Iw. S 10 " oo:n>lri .... """'" 'Ioouch A n 8 """Y """ Ile in S lot ubitr..,. A E S. 8 E S.
"""""'i_
.. be ..... , .. _
l
c.Jl S """"" _iril\ll if it """I ...... ,hot""'Ptr.tOt ....:I io' ~ j ui>
S·..u At. . ... A. ouch u..t A .. At. c A, C ... C A... Band A. -A, _, E S lor 0.11 1 :s:: t s: ... Let ~ : S _ C I>< " fwooet.,.. ...... that jO(A U 8 ) .. ,.fA) + ~(B) .. be ...... A. BE S, A U 8 E S, and A n B .. t, A ~ ni'" ~ioco ( Eo ) ... , of E E S IntO S·..u io called • ",-,i''''' if ,,(;In 6) .. )~. ,,(A n 5o) .,. &II A E S. If {Eo) .. , and { F,),~ , .... bil. ~_ 01 E E-S-';'IO 5 _ lben (E.),~, io called • ""ht-tit.,.. '" {F,)!" ............. _ oeI; E. 10 .,... .... t>ed no """ '" tl>< """ F, .
~""t
\, S - lbal. if" oubpwtiliOli of" - 'ilion {E, ),., 10 a
", ~it .... >
u....
( 50 ).. ... "",p&rtic.ioo>, II (Eo)... """ (Fi),.., _ ,_ ",p&rti' ior>o of E. . - ,10&0 {Eo n F,)(•.r')<'.' 10 • S. If E. Co C C, C ... C F. whtR C. E S lor &II 0 S. i S. n, """ if C. -C, _• • D. Iiooo u. S lor all I :!i i:!i n. _ lhat (E .Do .. . " D.) 10 • ... ~it .... ", F . 7.
".putit""'. c.. •
4,
s- ,ba,......,. hita p&rtitiooa '" aDd «*:Iudoo lhat " io addil ;'"
<)
Wi
S-oet E
I". S ..... 10 •
",~i';o".
S.
:J Let R bo ..... fine _ ' i . , . m'bo fiQi •• ...,J ooIini~""" in ... uno:owrtablo n. Doli"" II' "" R- b:r Wine II'{A) 10 bo d." n~onbef '" po;w In A if A 10 finite, aDd - " ....... " io , be Q ~ _ cl pOinU in A' ;r A ill ooIini\e. S...... ,bal II' io ,.·oddith" "" R, "'" 10 '"'" a_un.
t.;
'V'
ate
3 Integrable and Measurable Functions
rod_.""
fund. !" ,aaJ _io:)nool nocIlcit.lt, ''''<pabIo,.oo-.. ' .....-' to " Ji-- ___ nr.. <1_ of Hi", D o g Intqrablo _ _ ........ koeIy ........ (d. Seot ..... 7.6) .. wu d' -...... In U.. nl _ _ h _ury th......p 1M otudy 01 Fourier _ _ fur in'" ... In ......,MI. the <'- ol fu...h :........ let "~ io qu~ Iarp. !ndety_ J. could be O&id thAt lIIit .. 1M ' - ' oJ. .1>0 _""" ud I. it ,,1Ia! to nndof'OW>
ThIo ch~ i... .......bIo fuDCtioao
""~
_,,,0l>I0
"Cl"''''
am. ...
,--
1 1 Cr.... " 0... .... " r F'",I'. \he Uppof ;~ 01. pOOl. ;.., r...n<:lIoo. with roopot', I<> V" ill defh.ed A p...l1 ... fur>« ...... Mid 10 be ,...nqliciblt If itl uppot in..,01 io ....n. n.io 0I1owo .. to oX6... 5PI' ltIIbIo_ aDd tho _10<> o f _ 'y ,,,..--..• .,..' y",!wn" . We Ibm I"'I"N • low imp>nu.' .-.1.. 0U(:h . . Bt:ppo !.-i', , hz .. _ It' ",W 3.1 .1). F'Mou'. he (p..,,,... "ion 3.1.2), .00 tho ru--Fiocbor h iD (Theot . 3. 1.3) "" ~_ of £'11<). 3.2 One of 1M ....... limn.at_ of rue.-"".I~teVtJ In ,he """ \h&I i. _ yiold ....ibnt nsulto ... _ it ....,_ to the ;""",01 01_"", .. Of ...... cl f"""'-' F.,..,.....,pM. if " .....Iormly _nd
t'"
m
,!
o
3
....,.. .."bout _ _
cn.-
... "." mI.Oclt • ••ono1a1.o '1i.1t.ooo'" .....,
l ... '-';"";'1 ond
m.
1_
di l!_i&.bi~ 1.Y
of an
in~&l
~.
n., _ • •_
wilb 1 : ...... to.
pu-..-
(P, - ".... U.3 and Ttoooo ... , 3.2.3). ue of """"'......... in ... olyoio..
•
3.3 In ,hlo obon""",ion ... Iocuo our ."... , ion to .... "',.,.,. , ....... fw>cI.ioonI; &Dd dolno 1'.... ter;rabIo _ and ~ u_ leU. U Tltioo -.ct;'" ioo to ,he deIi.l..,., of "·....,..ur-,,",, ioo. ..c. <. ~ "cd Ifritb ••,..i., &Dd 'ho _ion of _"",t;,k ~ botWl!Ctl ''0'(> oudo _ I, it iIuportan. to _ioo ,bat. ,1UoI _ion 01 _....toIllly _ _ depend
de..-,'"
.•'e
"** ,ha,
OD._~
en.
.1>.
3.$ ~ maiu ","ultof -'ion io .1oo ioIlowi .. iDrm of ~'• •l.oo..= ......" 3_5.1) , . OOQ_ 04 ,.._u,-"",, mowO .... f....... n iO>to" . hid> """,u ... IotaIIJ _ ewry ... here to I """-r" uniforml, to I on .100 """,. ~) on' of ..... bitnoiilJ ....all ~obIo .... Fin.all, .... Pl'O"O .10.& •• I'· _urablo ",_Ion from n iDto a Bu d _ ioo U>tq:rabie If and only if ito _ imqr&1 .ith , _a to VI' . finite (Thoo<.m a . ~_ l). n. I .1"1 it>tqr&1 flO",,"io ... ioo~, ......11 .. boundod m< "ra 3..7 FirS..... deIi .... ho _ and ..,.,.. i"'qr&1 of . poOll"" f...... _ I ioo in.. P"bIo If aDd 01017 if ito _ and Iooow i .............. IWte and ... iUiI. Notioo ,hal il l !o IUlqroblo"" ioo VI: m .b. ''-Y. •here it DO "imp ......... i ...... aI". We tbon _ J........ '. 1-..!11y (Tbooo . ", 3.7.3) .,hid> Ia.., impOrt ..... _ ~h in.1oo of ptObobility and in &aa.l"';O.
a.'
,....,;...bIoo "*'"
or
t-,.
po_
""'_04_ . . . .'-"").
" .... I' Ia . I'. in~ ... whk:tl """ .....m&II... (omaJlo.-and _ _ botb in A _"no wI. _ _ ioo Mid to too dIlr••<; ~ _ " ' " ioo &I:t _1>10 of_ & " · 'UI'O. 0.. .ho otbor _ . & '1'",. Mid to too _Ie: if -=to IiOI1nrs1~bIo a....:r&blo
38
intu it i..oiy. 0lI alOIn lew. _ . ,, ~
n.. ......., 1l1li a
•• 000.ho oemiria,s of MU ouboot.o '" N 10 ... ex&DIJlIe (t! s..ctloao 6.3). If I' 10 and I Ia . l\lllCtion from n i _ • .-rizabIo _ , I ioo ....... ...-.bk If &Dd <>DIy if It ioo .,.,n' .n, . ... 010 _k atom ... <Mit&i ... an
&tom.
.">mir
( 110"", .... 3.111). A Daniooll • ' ''''' I' ~ ...... _ ..... it on ,ho ,1l1li ~ of inlqr-""""'" alkd 'bo maia pr<>IonpIioo of 1'. Siaoll.&rlJ. I' drIi............... ,.. caJl&d .ho_i&I ",·ok I ...... of 1'. "" II>< rlati ~ '" _i&IIr mtqr&blo -.to. W•• hea $ttod;t .....,... ..I& ......... ic>o bot ......... boooo 3..9
3.1
_u_
Upper Integral of a Positive Function
Let 0 be • 0>0DefI\p(y ~. F (O. C ) I"" ......,. of complu. vaIl>Od funct __ on O. and C ) a ....::tor wbo~ of F {O, C ) web thal rk/, 1m I, and !I! bdoq to H (O,C) for &11 1 E H (n. C). A.wnune ,It&t, for.U I ., I. E H + and Eo< all, E H (fl, C ) OlUi"fyi", 1, 1 :s " + hI"" .... etist , •• 9'l E H (fl. C ) ~ud! tlt&t lg,l S I ., 111>1 S I. , and, _,. + 11>. MQo "" .~r. "'!'P'* IIt&t iufU . I) liM in 1f+ br aliI e 11+ (Stone', Q)Ddition). Now If:< ,:r- be. lei. of functlQ"'I from fl into (0, + ooJ ...·ilh t be foIlowl",
nco,
pt OJ>ttt~:
(a ) 07+ :J 11+ """ 1 - 9 boelongtl to 07+ f(>t &11 I E 07+ and 9 E H + IIU:I:h
.hat, :5 f(b) inf{/.,), ..,P{/, , ). and I + 9
bdor!«
to.1+
br &111, 9 E
r .
(e) 1<1
€.r for """y ~ > 0 and e""'Y l e:r.
(d ) E""'l' 111<1" 'ing ~""noe in ,;,.. haoI i'" upper tnw:lQpe in
(e) For ~ Daniell" . , ''''''
<)D.
1(0, C ), if we put
V,,"U ) .. lor all
I E
r.
IIIp V,,(,) ,.,>(·.#$.I
,r,tbm
(i) V,, ' U + I l
.. V,,· (/) + V,,' (f)
(ii) V,,"(IUP.i!: ,I.) .. in :7+.
for all I . I e
IUP..1:1 V,,·U.)
lor
,r;
e'oel) l""~og ~ueo<>':
We encountered aucI: a cl&8l:7+ in Section 2.2. No. Ie\" be a DanIell "....U'" <)D. 1(0. C). Detlnltion 3.1.1 Fot """y fW>C\ion I from 0 into [0, +wI, t),. number inf",p ... U V ,,' (1:0 )( +<><> llIhen: i8 DO 1:0 E :7+. 1:0 ~ !l io called 1M upper integral 011 with .... poet to V" &Del .io ...
r
r
.,.., lwo IUDMion:: frotU {} IDto (0, +wI aucI: lbat I S P. Ibm V,,' U ) s V,,· (fl · If I ,. h. I .,.., II,,~ functioo:: from {} into [0. +<><>Jand ~ > 0 is a real 1PU1Tlb«. then V,,' tIP + J.) S V ,,·U, )+ V,,"(h ) and V ,,' (1
T heorem 3.1.1 (Beppo Lev!'. Theorem) F{)r U~ )~:t ,
~
me • . :;'5g
~""
QI fo-ticru frr>m {} inUo (0, +001. V,,' (IUp I . ) .. sup V,,' U~ ).
P P\OOf: It eul!ia:o; to Jhow
thaI
ily clurf)< bold:: if sup V,,· (f.)
n..
V,," (.up/~ ) S IUp V,, "U. ). l.t>oqual. .. +00. n.en.r.::ft, _ ""'y ' '!I5!''nIOl tbat
sup V,, · (f. ) < +00. We tI>ao- 11:.t.1, lor _ h t > 0, tl:.oerec eris'" an In<:~ iog 55Ilq_ (g,,)~> 5 In :7 + ruo:b that I. S ", &Del V" "(,,, ) S V,,"(/.) + t. If I is tile up. per t melop<: of 1M ~_ (g"),. ~ , , _ I:.t.,.., V,, "(g) .. tupV" ' (,,, ), flO V,,' (g) S Wp V,,·U.) + t. S;""" 1Up I. :5 II and t Is arbilnory. I),. thwl(m wlllloUow. lbr IhlI, oo.e..... that lhere exi$U It.. E :7+ 8Ud! that I. S It.. and V,,· (h..) S V,,·U. I '" r/'l". Tho fun.;.-tiono ", ..... p(Io ,. I., •. , . •h~llie in J+ . f
I_ I.
and
A...
1UpU._I,h.) _
,.-" .. inf(g,._I. h~) ~. _ . + II. , it k>I~ .hat ~
~ I~_ I ; lina:
infu.. _I,h. ) +
V,,"(g,, _,) + V" "(h.) - V,," ( ioflg,. _1.11.,.)
V,, ' lg,. ) _
:s
V,,· (g. _I) + V,," (h.) - V,."(f. _,l
< V,,·U. )
+;. +€(I - 2"'-, )
V,,·(I.)+t( I - ~)_
:S
11.00. V,,· c,. l :S V,, · (f. ) + { for IlIl n
P ropooltloo :1.1.1 For ' '''"'11
~
l. ILl ~red.
0
~
(1,). 2:1 ollMI>Ctlono 10, ....1. _ ........ V,."O:::'l l !oJ:S E' ~ I V,,"(f. ).
PROOf', If woe puL '" •
E, S":5"- I.
/rom n
ill/
for ~ "
V,."{g.):S
L
V,,"U. ),
IS· S· V,,'
(L!o ) - . up V,.· (g. ) :S L '~ I
·ll
V,.· (b )·
.~,
o
"'ftC-
P ropo.Jtlon :U ,2 (fiotou'. Lemma) LeI (I. I.l I Ito a _ 0/ tionI /rom n into (0. - 1. ~ .. V,,"(limlof. _ __ I. ) :S IiminlV,,· U.)·
.:j,"''''''''
PIIOO" FQlIlII intet;~n n ~ I . Put 90 - inl.1::'>I•••. The (t.,).l l in<" " . and euP.~ 1 '" _ lim in! I • . For each " oo,.. :S I .... for , .2: G, '"'" ha"" V ,,'lg..) :S Inf.lC' v,,·(1. ... )_Th ...
V,.· (limin! I. ) _ fliP v,.· (g,.) oS liminf V,."(I. ).
o n..tI.nltloo ':1.1.2 A flmctlot> I from n into (0.+001 III oald 10 be ,.-Df'dlclble .."",... e, V,,' U) _ G. A..,bitt. E 01 n is MId 10 be ""lIf3litible, or 01 V ..... rr F7"'.1/"" 0, if '" to ,,-nqilclblo:.
E. l,l •. and .. ..,p/. , III ,...""&Ilclble for ~ """l""""" (I.)oll of,... DO&Iiaiblo! fulldiont from n into {G. _I. Evef)' s,,1Mt, of a .....phle !Itt is ,..."..tlpble , and • union of
"""o..lIIy many ,.·nqlillbk acto III ,..",,11&11>1&
o..6.n ltlon 3. 1.3 II pn>peI'ty .. oald 10 be true alll108t ""'"')'w l=e fOf " (abl:rrev\ated 1.. 4 ". or ~.) if &rid only if It illrut outaide .. ".negligible 10)1.. P ropoo.lUon 3.1 .3 A. nn 'I h, ~n
'''PI'''''"
P "OOI': Tbe oondition .. ,,,, "y. lrl ,d, l luo. I ill Degligibloo. and let Ii: be the oct of pOima % E 0 such tluo!; 1 (%) ~ 0-. then ! ~ 'f Sup~ ("n . 110, I . . . Degligiblt. The <:OI>P""" IIuol. the IO!I E of point.ii % whe~ I does DI)I. , .... ish .. o>e&Iigl,-*, then I 'f sup.~ I nl " . 10 I is ox>gIigibloo. a
P ropoo.lt lon 3.1.4 l..., I ....., g bo ttoo /t".,,~ I", 'U., 1M" V,,"(f ) .. V$O" (g) .
from
n
mto [0, +ooJ. II
P ROOF: I..et E .. 1%EO , 1(%) ~ g(l:j). S;""" in(U .,) '"' 1lUp(j,g) 00 £<, It ",,/6COII to prove 1M pt"OpOIIillon .. 11m I 'f g. n..o let II he the r"nction cqual to +00 on £ and to 0 on E"; W1l Iuo", I 'f 9 'f I + II , and"" (V,,· )(f)
s: IV 1'. XI) s: (V 1'. )(1 + II ) s: (VI' " )( f) + (V $0. )(11) '"' IVI' · )(I )·
a Proposit ion 3.1.5 [I I : n -
if finiu.
......
iO,+<»] u.udI tA
~
I
s:
PROOF : Put E .. 1-'(+00). r OO" every I"~" 2: 1. _ h...", nls I . .. nV,,"(l.) VI'·(f ) Sinu t his".rut lor ..,.bilrarily Wg
s:
a
lIuoxk>rth, F .. ~ A mapping I from 0 illtO F is Mid he i C&n be wriHen I" L.u/.... , """ .. fl· nite iItI I, , and elements ... of F . Such .. rep"""","" wioo .. ailed .. dec:6mpo8ition f. ~ H (O. R ) 1<1> F be ,he .....:tor 'I*'"' of deeoiilP"'! "bIt maWings from 0 lnt(> F. N .....· IUPpoooe Ihac. F is • real ()T complex l!anecl> 9pf1Oe .. I' .. real '" (OtIlplex, and let F' be itll dual (the ...... of ODtlt ioOOlll li-. lor.... on Fl. If L'EI 1;4, is .. dec:6mp<>6it1on of I E }t(O. R )I F. Ibtu L .. I ,,(1,)<>..: 00... not ~ on the penicul..- deoompooillou of I , b .;'( ,,(f,)<>..:) ., ,,(.' 0 f) for &II .' € F' (W . Rudin. f\onclOo...t Anat,N, C"h&pter 3. Corollary to Tboo«'ln 3.4). HeDOI! W1l ....y
Lei
,
3.1 Upper In' pol of a 1'I:Ieit1¥e Funcl.ioD
dMote tbe _tor
_~. I f
0&5
E... ,,(I<}4; by f 1dJ., clllled tbe jl-intevaJ of I. FUrther--
1<411- SUP.-t"r ,''-IS ' Il'U 1<4111 (ibO:!., Corollary 1.(1 ~ U ),
beDtt
~, II(l' I1''''1- .-tr.''''IS'
0
1)
""pi 1%' IldY" S I"I/ ldV". 0
.'
r
wbHe 1/ 1.tV,, :s ~/ I ...I · Vp(lf;1) ill finite. I n what foIlf:>,.... , "" fOOl> 116 we o::onsIder \.be t!><pre!I8ion I <41 (or lbe similar ",,~ic)n lId" of s..ctic)n 306), It shall be ~"'~ lhal F "" & -.l or alrDpIo:x &n.ch "P""", as" Is -.l Of complex. mappOn&'! I from n 1.111.(1 F """" that I/ ldV" < +00 form.-.,.. ~ T}II'I. and the function I I/ leW" '" & ...,,;norm Of>
f
n.e
r
r
Fj.II').
I",(n •
DefInition 3. 1.4 Do:no::M by C~II') the cklllu", of 1f(n. R ) iii F in the ""m;" .... ,ot ,' !"","Il>"" the ,,-I"~ "'ppi~ lrom 0 ;1110 F. N_ 0>0Slde0- C~v.) as • ....::1.0< ",bel*"" of 'M iJemlnonno:d SpooO! .1JII'). Tboa ,be "imq..J
"I· Obeco .c ~hat I f Id,,1S N,(I) fOl" 0.11 I E C~v.). A &It.. \hat cnn....1"!"1 in F}{I') Is MId to amvcrge in lbe "",&n. P r<>pmltloo 3. 1.6
II U ;, ......lin .......
lilim, map /n>m
F
imo II Bomadi
qo«G 1mIIi/ I E C ~v.), ~"Uol liu m 4(P) and f (Uol}dp - U(f Id,,). Propwitloo 3.1.1 Ld ({~)~> , /It II ~ ... F}(p.)...d< eMt
L N,(I.)
."
1Jw
<:;
+00 .
""rit-. E .2:' 1.lz) ....-,.,..• ...uon.ulW"'e. II "'" JOIil I {z ) -
E.~, 1.lz)
at IIlrno.l
H, frt<" .,// n
~
(I -,~. I.) S .:;', N,({.l
O. TIKro/"",.
~ Krit-. E .2: 0 I~ """''''"'JU
UI I in !h. """,n.
E.2:1 1/.(z li of n into ill,+«>1· Since N,ul S I:..." N,V. ) <:; +00, 9 "' finite • .e., &lid the series I:.. ~, f.{:r) """,ugw at.olulely •. e. Si".,. F 10 """,plete. this...n.. ..,."ugw a.e., and PIt()OF : Conoider ,be function 9 : z -
g(:rI ..
lI("'JI:s e.lk""", N,(I):S N,{g) < +oo.1U>d J!ioei in J'~(P). On thl: ""her h$nd , 1(%) - LL:s.oS~ J,{:t)1 s: L:,~ " ., 1/.(o: Ualmost "''eI')' ... ''''re, for '"""Y intq;cr n 2: O. ThllO N,(t - L ls t s .lo) S L'~""L N,U. ). 0
,..)
E~~,
M
Th~ ~ (1;.(%)). 2; '
N,t!;•• , - / 4) ;, /ir!ik .
"''''''''lJ<'.' 0./"",,/ ~"",,
(c) 1/ "'" ,.., /(.,) _ !1 _ _ _ h .. (:r) acI aImo" .,II pointo % .mc.: 1/>" limi.l aioto, =d t...t. I{:r) arl>iI .... riI~ o~n 0, _ (1;,,) .. ,.,
u.-
I'%Ut.o Z C 0 .UdI tJuu V,,-(Z) ""if<>mll~ to f "" (1 - Z
"""""'JU
:S
!
and tJoe
(e) The ... ..mu a "".." ..... 9 from (1 into 10. +001 oudIlIMI 11',(9) < .nJ If;. (;Eli'S: 9("') /(}r ail '" Iii fl.
+00
""",Iy
PROOF : By indt;cl.ioo on n , dc~ne a ;""..,...1"11: ""'Iu"""," {i,, )"~, of ID~ 2: I, sueh that N,(I<-1... ):S 1- '" for..-chn 2: I and foTeochi 2: i"
By I'roposilioa 3.1,7, IM """"'- .. ilh general term h .• L -I;. ronvesges almost """.,. ... be .... I&I>d in ,he _ . 1(1 ... IlIII.ppi~ h E F H l' j. ThUll the gee etQDeT>Oe (J;),,. . i!$elf WIl'UI'*, Th .. P"J""l$ (al. ( b). (el · rf_. tor """". n in N . pul y~'; I" € n : Ih •• , - /;. 1(" ) 2: 1 /2~ 1. From ( 1/2~)· I y. 1/; •• , - h. l. il IoIIooN Ihat (1/ 2")· V,,· (Y~) N,(/••• , - / •.1. wheooo V,, ' (Y~) 2-~. P~I Z~ _ u...,,~ Y..: By cooostruo;boo.. '~P.en _z. 1/;.. , - /;.1 < IJ2" roo: ..u k 2: n. II:) lhe _ .... t h &""Crallerm f ;•• • - f .. (t 2: I) co"'"'gti6 ~Dlformly Oft Z~ Si nce V ,,' (Z~ ) :5 1 /2~- 1. roo: "'''''- > 0 "'" """ cboooe n !ItICh Ib.u V ,,' (Z~ ) :S c. Then. If N .... """",,IWble >Itt sud> IMt {f;, )>>, o:on'UXCOl lo Ion 0 - N. "'" mo.y ub Z .. Z~ U N I'lId 9 .. If.,1+ L,~ , I/; •., - f .. l. which PO""'" (d). a
:s
:s
n-
T~m
:s
e
3.1.3
( Hie
Theorem )
",mp/d<.
PlWOf: .1J(P) Is (t>mp~ to,- Theorem 3. U . Md .'0) i$ £} (p) ...·hich Is clooooxl in F~()I.) .
0
J.I Vppe< lr>tq>oI 01. _
FIaKtioa
47
Prop / , til"" / € t~CJ.) and (f. ),~, (:On""'!U I<> / in 1M .........
.""piIe'"
''''-1_
P!t()OF: By Tbeorfln 3.1.2, I""~ exist • • (f,. ).~, of. (f;~i!: ' ...hkti ,"",wga a.... to a "..pping 9 € t~CJ.) , ouch that (f.l'i!: ' con ....... to 9 in tho:: mean. Hence / _ 9 '.e_ Q
Prop
(. , (h).~1 ........,u '" 1 in tile "'......
o
PROOF: This folloon from ~'" 3.1.2.
Lemma 3.1 .1 ~I EO.. """"",,...01 _Iqr """'" ol/inite ...-....-..... F.... ('""l" e > 0, tht;,.. eriu lin.... I....,., " " .. . , '" "'" E n.di t1W ( I - oj ' 1% 1::; "'i>ts ls , I~ (~) I .s 1'1 101" ISII % E E . P ROOF: Put B .. {r E E :
1. 1 < 11 and S .. {.
E E :
1.1_ 1}. B ..
<>pw
liN. in B Ior...m • € B and tech ), € R .. Uafyi", I)'IS \. By lbe Hahn- Banach tI...,,",,~ b evoery II E S , there exisu a linear fonn ". on E NCb that 1".(.)1< \ lor ali. E B aDd ~.") .. 1 (W. Rudin, FImcli<m.al Anal..... CbapU!' 3. Theorem 3.4). Then 1 - ( .s t~.(I )I < 1 for all. E S ;n """'" ,uitably d!(sen open ~boe(su........ry pOint of. S liN. in one of the \Ii = 11"" 0 COOYI!X,..oo),.
.s
l'bcre.".;slll • eeq"""",, (f.. l.~ I in 1f(O, III tbat '"""([ilCIi to 1 in lhe mean. Roopiacin« f .. lor I: , if ,+ "y, ""'''''y .,,_ that"""" f. I;"
!'!tOOt':
In 1f ~_n....
o Propooitioa 3.1.10
f lll-dV" .
F.... 1
€ t~CJ.),
1/ 10."'-
'" Cj.CJ.)••n
PROOF, To bogin, lUPI"*' tlutt I Ii... in n {l1. R) 0 F. and iO has tbe form E '5JS_ h ' oJ . ... hen! /; E 1tII1, Rl and aj E F. ld t :.. I), By ~"'''''''' J, 1.1, there ~illt !;nee,: forms M" . .• , u, on the >«C.or t;ubsp.a<:e E of F genmt.1ft! br ab '" , .... , Iud> that ( I ~ t) '1:1-0::: .up,«<. I",(.1I :s; 1' 1for.U , E E. Th"" - -
(I - c) ·1/ 1:s; sup I..,o / l :s; II I
,
s;~ ,
Sut ,be ~,ol ~ to 1t{I1, Rl, iO~. _ eup.<;<, I"."..r_. 111is 1'inu,uable. It J"ftJ>ol'" to trt*! tbe (:8« .. here 1 if not I,," ' mily deo:om_hIe. For Ihls. ore let (f. ). ;!: . be. family in 11:(11. Rl0 F oon,~", to I in tl~ "~",,. For...-y" :!: I . "'" MWl II1I -ll.11 :s; 1/- 1.1. !IO Iil l-I/. II · dl'" :s; 11 - 1.1' .tV,.. Hence the .....""""" 111. 1)..;:, oon"'gf)i! '0 111in tlot """"" , and LlI_ ".in~ tw-a_ eltu.) ill c~ in F:"{jO) FInally, If J$ I :s; N,(jl lor """ry 1 E e~u.l, ""d N,(n., f 1JIdY" ... tboorn In 1.....""'" 3, 1.2. 0
r
r
We aw defi,.. on e ~{jO) the .,..uivalcDO! relation "I _ 9 if 1" /I ahnoet ev SpIW:1:. rill ..Upracti<:al 1"1'P'*"', _ -=d not distl"&Uiosh C~( "l and L ~{jO). A fuDdion 1 frem n IntQ JE II called jO-lntegrable if It is equ.a! a.t. to a ". I"tegrabie func\ioo 9 from n \"to R- Clearly, if 9 and are t""l lueb funetlontl, I~ Jr4< - J ttl", ... it m O' . _ to define Ihe oon>pIe.. number J gdj< .. the In!.e&raI of J. written 1 """'''''''''' 10 1 E e '(j<, ft) in the mean If. for 9 .. . 1>00."', III - , 1·.tV" Ie.... to 0 .. h exl mdll.,...,.. the fil\.e"r F : ,**,1)', t hie dt/inltlQn doeo depend on ,be d>oi
t
J
r
'*
Theo..,m 3.1 .• 1
€:r
r
io Wint.",
,* if a nd onJp ;1 r I · dV" <
+00.
P lIOOr': SUppolee I· dV I' io 6nite. Si~ V,, ' Cl) .. fliP...... . 4~1 V,.(f), for .,.,.,.,. ~:> Olhereexist.lgE 11:+. 9 5 1, sud> l hat v ,,"(!) S V,,{g)+ ~ , Then V,,' (!) '" v,,"Cl - 9) + V ,,(g), .o V,," (f - g) S ~. 0
P ro. -It lo" 3.1.11 lUi'l l ,. h) AM infCl,. h ) Ii
h , 9. , 9:1
..., rml-vaIuod func:ciono on 11 , then
h
E Q. Inde«l, thill inequality evldentb' Idds il thoeroc .... ;.," ; in (1.2) such thaI f«~) _ IUP{/, . h )(z ) and 9;(ZJ _ ,Up(g,. g,)(z). n..ref
for
eYery :.:
..... 1-."" g, (z ) 5 g,(z) 5 1,lz). '" II; - 1;I(z) 5 II< " I(z); 011 the oI.her hand. If 1,(1') < 1,(:.:). toe ha"" 1,(1') 5 1;(:.:) 5 Ijlz ). and II; - Ij l(~) 5 Iii - 9)1(:.:) ..... t.eooe tbe d.sin>
j ; If
1,lz ) 2:
~,Iz) .
;.., two " .int O. thoeroc al8t II In 1((0. R ) and lJ'l In 1/:(0, R ) such tb.at I" - III . .tV" < ~/ 2 ..00
f
f lh - ,..1· dV" 5~/2· n..n
I
Isup(l!. hI - ,upU, .,.)I· dV" $
r
(I" - ,,1 + 110 - 9>1)· dV" 5 (.
3.2 Convergence Theorems Theorem 3.2. 1 (Monotone Convergence Theorem) Ld(/~ )~2:'" ... ir.... . (_p&:tiO(Ir. a ,u"..,."mg) ""VUt""" in .c'CII: It). no.... I - "'P. 2:' I. (_fiO(!~. I - inl.2: ' I. ) u inlt9n -oo). In lIIu _ . (/.,.", """""'l'U to> , in 1M: """,n.
i."
.w"
P ROOF : \V.. "XI"8i(\er the <:a6O'! of fill lr.;rMSi"3 ~_ (/. ). ", In .c'(p.; R ), and SlIpp<.>1e lha • • up.",I l.dII,.. ill Soile. The oequenal U I~' dII,..)~" , 1D<.i :: I . '" It <:OI>Ve~ In It. ~, I II . - 1.I4V,.. - IV. - 1,}dV,.. (OO·.up It> 0 .. p , q _ +0<>. SiD
* """It
.w,.. _
I
,...llMITabie.
0
P ropoeltlon 3.2.1 ( F'lotou '. Tboor<>m' UI (f. ). ", .. a _""'" ill J:'(p. ;R) .Iid! Ih - DIO), , , _ III~ ....... 9 in J: '(p.; R) ........ III..: 1:5 I. A.e. (_,iwJr. 9 2: ,. ",.e.) Ir>r
,.w"
f 1·1fV,, $. f l'dV" $. ~,!:!'J;!.f I. ·dV" (f"eJP'lCti""lJ. 19: dV" 2: I I . .w"
~
Iim,up_ ..... II• . dV,,).
",ill prwe ""Iy the fiN; otaU!fl""'~ For ea.ch ru:..J. II, ,be _ q\lotnC'e (", ... ).~"' when: " .' .. inf. 5.iS'!" deo;,..,astoI. and""e ha~ f 11-.... ciVil > g . .wl' f« all k :!: n. By the rDOn<>tone (;Dn,el~I>O% theorem, I/o .. lnf.~~ "' .. is i"m~ LlkeYioe, the ""'I""""" (9")" ~ L lDtm , aDd ..., ha~ J gn'dV" :!O Inf'2:. f J. -dV I' 'S c:, wben! c .. ~m 10£"_.,,,/,. -dV". ThUll ,uP.;!: . iI... lim Inl,, _ _ In is ".i.o~, a"d f , -dV" ~ / .,w" 'S
PROO':
W~
J
•
a
Domi .... ted Converxen<:e Theorem) 1/ G (J.),.~, ;~ C~{Pl """otI"f<" ~.e. /.Q 4 maPJl'ing / fram 11 inti> F (......'e F to • 8a.JWIdo IJ'G<%), .n.m fI ",I<> 10. +001 ItI, then I ;, " .;Ilt..,Wc ani (/.),.2;1 """,.."u 10 f in 1M ......" .. /:O~UJo. f 1. dJ;.
Theorem 3.2.2
"'I"''''''
( Let..:.~ '.
r
""""".,... II>
J /dj..
f
PlIOOf': It IW!io<:eI to prt>'I'e lhal If, - 1.1. dV" con~p 10 0 .. p .00 q lend 10 +0:>. Fb:: n ~ I. ADd 0>D0ider the 8equen<:tl (g., ..).':!:. where p,. ..... luP"s..d. l/. - 1.1· No. {p.")' 2:" is an illc" "ing 8equmot of ~inln(>toM 1.110..,..,"', {g,. .. )v. converg.. a111X111 ev
<:OIl..,,.,.,.,..,.
°
J ", ..
r
r...-
Q:)." .......
C orolla.y Ld r /Ie • fiIt~r 1<'ith • """,,14b/e ba.>u "" G od <>/ indiou A, (f~ )"'A /Ie • "'milt; "" C).{p), .IUII : 0 _ F /Ie • ",.ppin9. A_",~ th4I, lor I (z) ~ To N_ ,.,.~ III=. U • ,",,,,,I;"" II frr;m 0 mu. [0, +001 •...,. IMt g.dV I' < +00 G"'" 1/.1 :S: 9 ru:gligiWt: od (4eptJld,ng "" oj lor dI Q E A. Tkn I E C).(I') " nd (f,,)~ .........,.,. "" / "" 1M ma ...
.,,,,';:Ie.
r
r
UId, lor eve' )" n :!: I. let o. be an .. bit •.." d.meDt of.4,.. By T """""'" 3.2.2. I ill ,..il>leptble aDd (/• • ).I!' OO.... CZ'"* 10 I la the..-n. By ooptra
P"'"I'WIUon 3.2.2 I" ""'.... tIW I : 0 _ F lot. I'"in.!.,..,bk, il io >IC
r
coodi,ioos ,.,.., oatWied Let (f.)~I! ' "" • !equtllCe in "h:{O. R) €I F . ..e. OOIlVerJiLllIo I, aDd let II that 1/ 1:s II everywhcn: ('I'I.-.", 3. 1.4). P ROOP: SUJ>POI!" tIM!
3.2 Coo,uS""" 11«
NOOI' e.r:b
I. can be ... riUftI I • ..
M
~, ,s. < .. ." •.• . ~ ... , wben! ....... E 1/. and
""" E F. PutU", 10,...... .. lof ("', .• , m(2; - Inf(2g, II .Il)), for each inc.eget m 2: I , tbe "... ... .,.., I"*tive. ".iutesrable. • "d bounded _Iv .. by 1"; ••. The ""'I""""" (h; ...... }.. ~, (u.. indica; and n ~ fi""d) eo.," tl p' to tIM! fund.ion -(J; ... " ...... by
• I ••
I) _ >:
{
it 1/ .{z )! < 2g{z } if 1/.{z H 2: 2g{z }.
By tIM! domi.....ted mnvergmce tl>eor<m, I!>. .... ".integ. able. . . Po> .. ~, ,s.,st. ~, .•. »< •• lies In C}{P} (Proposit ion 3. \.6). Further,
g,. I) z ..
{
I. (>:} if l/ .(>:}1< 2g{>:} if 11.(z )l 2: 2g{z ).
0
NQt, tIM! ""'I""""" (Po>J.~, <:O>I_geo .. ~. to I. and 190 1 !i 2g for ~ .. 2: I . The dominated con~ theorem then.bows ,ha' I • inlqrabk []
3 .2.3 (Contlnui'), wll h Respect 10 a Para mel ... ) wI A ..,,, topoIofior/.,..,.., ...... " potnt i" A, ond tl
t,
(. ) For..w. " E A, 1M ""'wing >: _ 1(>: , 0 ) ;, ~)
willi..,., W•.
Far oabo!.ul ail >: E n . 1M ""'Pl"ng 0 - I {z , 0 ) ;,
O>IIIi" ........ ,
00 .
(e) :n,.,." .not. ~U 0/ .... "nd ./o=tiofI ~,..".. n inIo 10,+0<0) ftdIlMl ~ < +0<0 "ndlh4t, lar ~ 0 E U, 11(>:.0 )!!i g(>:}
r ..w"
""tIUk. "<'!iiigi/>le,.1 (kpending "" 0 ).
~
1M
""'wing " -
J1(>: , 0 )",,(>:) ""'" A
i nto F ;, O>IIIin ....... aI 00.
P ROO', Th. follow. im....,.;l;"I,ly from t he corollary to n.wo.", 3.2.2.
[]
At llUI point ..... in'rod""" """" IIOUtlon and make _ dorfinillona. If E , F .,.., .....t (or cornpIn) nornv:d 'P"""", for e:very i~ n 2: I , .... eaIl L" (E , F ) the ...........:I opaa! of n linear conlinlIOUI mappillP from E" in\.o F , _ .... put LO(E , F ) .. F. On the other hand , .... ioolJ(:l.lvely define ..... ....,.;1 "I*"! L{" )(E ,Fj u IoIJo-n: LIO)(E , F) .. F , and L{. )\E.F) .. L(E , Lt" - ' )( E , F)) for n 2: I . Then tben! iI an iIIOmoetry i. of L - )( E , F) onIO L"(E , F). defined by
(.;.h))(11,.···, .. ) .. n..)· "
_I ..... 11, .. (h(.. )· .. - ,) ...J.
"0 '
N_ let X be .... optn JUboJet of E, I " mappi"l: from X Into F, .... )lOin!. of X , _ n > I .... intefl"r. 1 iI Mid to be n limos dilJrrmtiable.t" _ to have V " )1(" ) u deri""'-ive of on:Ier nat", i f aDd ooJy If
,
(a)
I
II ( n - I ) ,i..- dilfM'mtiabLo! at mcb point of an open V 01 .. (,,1th V e X );
o~hood
(b) lhe tn&Ppillll :.: - D(~- '1/("') f
D" 1(.. ) '" 1. (0(· )I (a)) is alio called the
I is aid to be of claaI C"
",h derlvati~ of I
8t a.
it is n ,imN difJenon&iabLi! al ~aclt point of X and if the mappi,,«! rr I (0 S k S n ), '" _ f? 1 (:.:). are conlinuoua on X . When E _ K ("'ilh K _ R (Ie C j, I is n timel dilferentitJk at a if and ooly if it 11M a dcriva,i...,. p")la), of orokr " a, a (in the usUIII """""j. and then p"l( .. ) _ lY' / (.. )(1, ... , I). W6 _
Tbuoro! an opm AbMt 01 .. ""'"""" 1I'>lI (or compla) E, and let I I>o! c .....pping from (O-N) >< A inlo F, .,""" N .. "I'.~ l\Ib.oel 0/0. For 09"'''' iO\tqlu" 2: I, '~PPO" lMIlM lolk>"';fUJ """"it..,... a~ ...tUfted:
,,,,,,/.or .paa
(oj For """'lI
% "
n - N, 1M m<:Ipping 1(%,,) ; • - 1("". ) ;., 01 clcu C"
~A.
PJ For
md1 z " A, ilIe ""'P"''''' " ... O·(j(", ,'j)(z) fmm n - N ink> l,.· ( E . F)
r.)
For...u.
10, +«>1.-ell tJW. /M'
m.u an
inI."..,Wc ",,,,,Ii,,,, 90 ,...... n - N .nto = .,.jJiei<:ntl~ cl<>n I.... ,
~ D"(J(% ,·))(.)II:::: 9"(%) ~~i"O - N ,
n.o.n ill. ""'Pl"fUJ Il,. _ f I (% .• )dl'(%) /rom A into F .. 0/ duo C". and rrh (z ) _ f rr(j(",.·)) (. jdl'(%) Jor 0110 < k :::: n aM. e A.
P ROO", Let a" A and 90 be ... &bow, .... d let r > 0 be .. real nwnber such that A 0001 ...". the,,~ b&lI B with e<mt<=... and radius T, and such 'Mt, for all : e S, ID "(/(",. ')) (: )1 :::: 90 (:1:) •. e. in 0 - N_ Let 0:.::: k < n - I be find for t~ _ o t , and let g. be t be fw>ctioo 1:'"
L OS~" - · - ,
from
Ilrr" ·(J(",. -ll(a)~ . ; + !Io("' )'
(:::)!
0-
T~Ior'~
N into 10,+«>1. Evideotly, 9. is ilMgrabJe. For any given : e B, IomtuLo. ano... that
,.
for &II
,
~
E {} - N. But
(I - 1)---- ' , . D"(!(%"))(H 8(r- Cl))' ,JIJ • (n - , - I. )
f.
and Ibm!: eDol3" I 'glipble ... btet N. 010 C>(lOU.lni", N oudIlhal, for evuy .. ~ I and for e¥CI)' 1 :!>":!> II, I D-(/(r "))(4 + (~/" )(% gA(.z) for all:r 01 fl _ N.> Thus
anns:
n /.' (H)·-~ ' U
•
0 (n _ J: -I)! , D
(If." ·lj(a + 8(. -
II .:s (n _' k)I90(%)
u
for all :r of (J - N •. In shott, for evuy • E B , ..., ha~ 10> (If>:, ,))(z)1 :S go (.,) Le. In [} - N. Now, ror eodI O:S 1t :S n, dtnou by I)(')/, lbo: m&ppina:' /1)1.")(1(." .J)(.). <4«",) from A lnlG L(O)(E , F ). By ,ho pta;ed,,,« ~t and Proposition 3 .2.3, 0(' )/1 io oonIlnOOUl at ... Next, lei. 1St S n aDd • E B ho: 6n(I , and I '" 0 be ..... I.. IIICh that 1'1:S I. Then
1)1'-1) (If" .,»(4 + It. - "J) - U"-I) (It." .J}(a)
,
-(I.' and tho: _
WO){!(:r"J)(CI + It(. -
&tJUmen1 .. '"'-" .00... tlw
an ·dO) .(. - aI,
i
I~ ot·- I'(J(:r,' ))(4 + I{. -I4») - l)f' - " (!(:r, -Ill")
5"(")'1·- "1
11 - N. The domill&ted """""I'K"BCe tlltoo«!m tben ,,"0_ tlw 0- ') 11 (0 + 1(, -
Le. in
(01
We ~ that otber.......,... ollhis It..... a .. aisc , bo.n "'" shall requi~onl,.
n.....eIU 3.2.3. We conoider lhe foIlawi,. a&mpW, whkb are lntw.dM to lU""ln.te the IdMo "'" Moe Just po: :"L«!. If " .. .. _~on .. "",,,in,. S in n , aDd if,. ill the U~ form I - J Idv on SI(S,C), then "'" put IdV,. _ IrlVII for every I : n - (0, +001, and .. on (.1+ W;m I t in CbapIer 2). G iven .. rwwnpty interval t • ("' ~) 01. R witb IHl wdpoinl. .. and ~ wdpal.nt 6 (... 6La Ji), 1cI.)' he ~ _un! on t , aDd lei. F be .. ruJ
r
r
yr
ate
3.
50(
I~ aDd M~
Fun<. ;"..
.It&.
If 0 and fJ are.wo poinlll of Ii IIUCh a. ~ one of t he in~rvabI ",itb endpoinlll 0, {J I:a lnduded in I and nontmp ty. and if I : f _ F is .uch tlt&t IIH ill ~.inlegrable for one (...0.1 10 e-my) i"~'8111 C J ..lth endpolnt~ o .
p, ~
put
-
".0<8oro>8. -
I ; 1 _ F is..ud to be . ICq> lunctiOll il then! ~xlsu. pwti.ion of J into finlt~ly naQy In~'8Ie J. such lhat I i6 C'OIISIM' on eed> J. ThUll the it~ funaione. I,..,." 1 Into F for m a mal I : 1 _ F .. SIIId to bc ~la.ted .. bent""" On _ h c<>mp.)<:t $ubintcrvtol of I. It i6 tbc uniform limi~ of 8Iql IUn<:Iions. It 18 euily _n t hat I : f _ F is ~lall:d if and only if it ...... righc.-hand limit &I eed> point of (... 6( ""0.1 ,,
_ .pace.
Jef\-hand limit at ~ poin. of 1a, 6}. In po.r1icubr. any MtItinUOOU!l funetiOll f,..,." 1 into F .. regulated. [f I ; 1 _ F .. .-qula\<:< ""'WtiIl.!!; outside 10. fJI. and l>o:t>c.t io k-ln~. L:t I : 1 _ F bc reguJalOi on 1 """ the coroilary to lhe domi .... 'oo c<>n'-ergen'" .~n" " nd il hM. right, lt&nd deri .... tl..., I _ '[""ly," left-hand deriva\i .....) equal to I {r + ) '" lim.,.., . _./IJ) IIe>ll'«tivdy. to 1(<<- ) _ limy ... . .--. / b'll at .-I> point r of (G. ~ (Ulilpoeellvdy, of Ia. 6» . [n po.:1i<:ubr. it is OIXIIinUO\.llt and It hoe a deri...,iw: equal to 1(%) &I. all points % ~&I. do DOt bclon« to """"" munI.&bIo ... ~ of I. n ... ~IOt . , z ..... J:. III)dt is" primitive of I . and_
I!
I:
1{1}dt .. C(P)- G{lated fUn<:Iion I : 1 _ F is integrable if and only il 1/(t)idt .. r il l . 1 1<>"",4~ bas a fioi~ limit ...
a>nclude that
t
I!
l
Id), ..
lim
HI."",
iff
I (t )
0--0 ."_1 "
(br lbe.......tbry "'tbedom.h"'teda>n~nee thec>r-em). Talrl"i I -(0. +<»]. tbe.d:. c, I : z. .... flioz. / z io not ~·intqr&ble ....."" 'bou«.h .In l / ld, """. limit .. z. _ +00. N_ ~ ~-e." eumplc .. ~ lbe dominal.6d OOIl""rgC..... t~ dofto nOl. appIJ. L:t ~ be Le~ _ ....'" on)O. I). Given (> > O. pul I~ _ D O. 1!o," ~1 for teeh n E N . Then I : 10, 11 ~ z _ [1/ z.)O is the I/Ilpremum of the I~ (".~ 11Iz-J desi"",t8 tbe Lnl-ep"al J'IO'Irt of l Iz). If <1 2: I. lben: is tIO ~.in~
I:
3.2eo..... , ....
Tboot._
M
funcUon "'hid> domin"eo a1l l be I •. If (I ., I , fl. dA doeo not con~ to 0 .. n -+oo. NUl . lei A be d .. act of aU fini u. subsets Dr 10. I]. Order A by inclusion. and let :F he the Slter Dr -:tions <>f A. FDf each 6nite IUbeet J of jO, II, deo<>te by I J t he iDdW"M' func!.ioo of J on
1I.Ioa.c:F, but
f
/0, I]. n..n
IJd). .. 0 doeo not tend 10
f
IJ COIl>at>eo pDinlwWe to I IdA ... I. Compare tbill ....ull
with the eoroIla.y 10 lbe (\omin&ted corn~ nce \~
In our IMl example, "'" apply Theotem 3.2.3. Let P, (1wputivdy, ~) b! !be funcUon on R. periodic _il h period I , defined by P,(z ) ... :r; - 1/ 2 (l E!pectl~ly, ~ ( • ) ... "'~ - .. +1 / 6 ) for r E 10, II. Ilt nce p, los I'f&Ulated and ~ ill ClLIa\ioLJOUa. Now lei flo .. (: E C : Re : > 0 ) and fl, '"' ( : E C : Re z > I) . G;...e" • E 0 " .........;.ier the fu nction I ; .. _ (.. + 1)- ' on Writ.e lOr the llItO&faI put 01 z . n..n. for """y n E N,
10. +001.
1..1
,
.. L (t -D·/(.n+ l) - L 1tS .. <·
{
f( rn+f)dt
1tS_ <,, ·
0
- ltS_Lo (~/(m + I ) + ~/(m)) - [ ' I (:r;}d« Q
.. bela
L
I (m ) ..
ItS_ So
~/(O} + I ( I} + ... + I (n -
1"
1) +
I (z }d« + ~[J(O) + I (n») +
"
~/(n) -
1"
I (:r;,,".
[
P,(.. )· f (.. }d«·
0
Leu ;,. n u.Dd 10 +00.
«.).. L (m + W' .. ....!...+ _,1 _ • . r- P,(I)· r ·-' d.I . • - I 1, -~
((.) - ....!...... .!.'1 - •. •- I
1.,
P,(t )· r
·-' d.I .
1,-
P, (I) . 1- ' - 'd.I ill .w6"...t and bolo::>ow"phic in 110. Tbe. dote , theo:e ill • hoIoo:no
....
,
••
3.
I~
ODd
~1eNu.oble
f\".<. ion.
b- all • E i"I(, - ( I) . GIY""- • EjO. II. let , be tbe function t ~ , - . - 1(. from iO, +oo/Into R. Si""" b;t 3· .. - ' bail I E I.., n+ Ii.
Po.
-!oct -
I)
ill pooitiY1l (where 0, .. 1/ 6) and 9'(1)
s
,, /.." . ,/.." "2.
-
(10, - 1\)'(1) ' , (I}dI
-_ .
-
(10, - 1\ )(1) , V(I}dI
1,-
ill . . than ,,-'/ 4 b- ~ n E N . lienee P,(I)g(t)dt" Ieos.han "'/24 . .00 (,(.) • INti thaD - I + ,,"/ 24, ThiI 81,.,.... that , • sttio:lly deoc~n& 01>
10,11·
3.3 Integrable Sets ~,.
he .. Danio!ll _1= ""
DeRnltion 3.3.1 A
a,~
,,,beet E of n
("""'ion I " 10 p-intesr-bioo,
'f1>en
q
1{(n .c ).
,,1IaI
to
be jl-integr&bLt if iUt indicatOr
J I ....." . A . B E i.
put ,,(E) ..
Ca!l i. .be eta. of in~ab'e __ For all
I""" _ oul'< I A . h ).
'" A. n IJ< and A U B b60ng to i. Rcnot i ill .. rilll MoretDOO (A.).~I '" A. be\otlp to X, beo:.tt._
x,n..;:"
.
'n.
A '" . In! ,. ;:" I A,n."""" • ....... ueoce '" -R ,uclt that E.>. V,, (A.) <
(Tbeorcm 3.:2.1 ), If (.4,, ). ;:, . +<00, .be~ u..~. A.. I~ In i.. by ,he
..
tnQDOIont
(;O
, , .,, . jl~.'dV"S L V"(A.)
j1U, • • A. dV" S L
for all "'~ n ;<: 1. Flrany .... uen<:<: (A.). »
. ~\
ofinl~ subett
latqrabloe IO!\. A .. u,,:!:. A. iI " .intqn.bIr;-.........,...... ,,(A) - E.:!:l ,,(A.) If .he A • ...... diejolat.. P ropootido" 3.3. 1 Stt>er 1M dew 0/ Gll;~..w..u oj E . F\,,~, .0( ""'r ~ 1:- , e+ ~ tiIGI e- nE+ '"'. p".! E .. E· U E- .
3.3t~S
51
PIlOOf': u... (F .. ).. ~ , be a fIe(j~ of in\.eXTabie I Ubeeu of E , ,ut:b thai. ,,(F.. ) COIl'U&,* I<> ""PoC II:I'(G) ,.. m - +CO. and pu~ F .. u..~~~ for ead:! fixed illlOSO' m '2: t , the!1C\9 Fi (I C I .. .. IL.l..... m», w
...
"' - Fn(nF.)n ( n ,,) . •u
,U~- l
form, finite: partition P..(F ) of F inl<> int~bIe!IeU. Ot:.w:, ~ t hat Fi' '" (Fi' n f!.. , ) u( Fi' n F.... ,) .. U tf' 80 that each tel In P.. (F) can be partilioned into ~ in P... ,(F ). Dmotc: by £.. the union (Ill",*, Fj' (/ C I .. ) l ut:b that 1'(Fi' ) '2: O. Then ,
r,'" F;;:;i...
for~I S;",m.
Maw..,.,
,,(E... ) '" ,,( £.. U E.... ,) S .. · < ,,(
U E1),
,,-
beca'. -=II £.. U £..~, u ... u E..+> io partitioned by E.. u ... U £"+>_1 and by I"'*' I7' •• of poetdve _ure di:Uoint from E.., U .. . U E.. ... _I. Th .. implioellhal
for
C¥tfy j
::!: I. Put E"'
--- n UE,. _
lim sup Ej
"~J J~_
BlIp ,,(G) .. lim ,,(F, ) S ,,(E"').
CCII:
' - +00
.nd"nee E+ C E \.hiIo 10 ... oq.wily. Finally. InfcCB ,, (G ) '"' infcCB ,,(E - G) .. ,,(E ) - p( £+ ) .. p(E - E"' ) . .nd80 .........ytakeE- .. E - F*" . 0
ObMorve thai. ,,(G) 2: 0 lOr G e E· and peG) s 0 for G c &-. hel!! j , if G c ~ for example, u.e..
Note that Stone'. condition hu oot ye\ I>oeen .-I.
iO.+
I lie
intqrnble fundWn from n inlo R + .. inf(f, I );,~, and r' (]r,+ooj)" an irUtg, hI""1
Propo<lon 3.3.2 Lei
1m
,,,,mkr r :> O.
PIlOOf": ~ ill .. """"'...,. (J').~I in 'H. + cntl""rging \() I in tbe ",..n. Tht.doot, li,,{(t•. I) - inf(J, 1)1 . 0 be .. rerJ number and pmli", A - 1- '0".+001). ,"" func\ions
r
r
II. _ im (I,,,.[/ - r -in! (?,l)j) ~ int.ograble.
domilW«! by fir, aDd """verge point .."", to I" . Thus I" is
a
I~~
Lot / : n -10, +<»1 l>o "
Propooltion 3.3.3
ftin(;.ti(m.
FM' .....,
in's"' n ~ 0, P-' I• .. L,,S,,s.:r-. , Ilk - IllT')' 1.0.,.' ~ A.... .. 1-' {l(k - Iltr. "lrO JQr 1 S k < " .:r and A•.:I'- . , ,_ - I - I ((n. +001). Tht:n tIw:..........,. (I.Jolt. """"""'" I<> ,.
PAllOr: Otw......
a
Theorem :t.3.1 LeI C~v<).
p~
First. let
F""
I : 11
ro»I &.....:h.,..or. Tht:n SI(R..F'l if ~ '"
_ R + be integrable. In ,he notation of p' ......... p*
11M :U.3, lilt f~koo I . 1.. In S r"{R ). 5i,..,. Ibco
""'I"'''''" (1. ). ;;'1 I"", ,· ?, ,
it <XI
L;o.,
N_ let F be .. -.l SanICh iII*"!, / E .c~v. ), and let A be, win~abIe !Iet_ Fo.. ~ t ,. 0, !.hen: ""ISU 9 E Stj'R , F) euc:h lha~ I II - , ldV I' S ~. Tbeo I/ I~ - gl" lclVI' Stand gl" life io StjR. F). W~ mil)" conclu
r
I l ~ ilWI~
Propoooition :u ... "
H ,
I l ..dV I' '" .up.., l1(n.C).I. IS I II gl" dl' l frtr ftI«1J
we_
1(1 A .
r
tn.
PROOf": Glvm ~ ,. 0, Ie!; I E H + be ouch that II .. - I I . dVl' S RepIo.ciD« I by Int{!, I ), if ' 0' - "y, we may IUppOIIe t .... , I S '- Then Ie!; ,E 11:{n ,C) be ouch lil&l.1g1 S I _ II gd..1 2: Il
If", "1
> >
,,+ / ""-' " (J ,clVp-i) -J /
I ln_.. .wI'
~
J
II .. dVl'
-~
·" c Prvposl\ion 3.3.5 oel A .
f
I AdV,. _ . up""s<{R,C).1 f hl"ds
If
P ROOF: Given ~ > 0, let, E 11(O, Cj be ouch thal t91 ::;: 1 and gl .. dpl ~ I".w,. -~/2 (Propo.;tion 3.U ). Since SI(R.C) II den .. In 4{p.). there e:r;iN II E SI(i . C) RICh lb., f (g - hi . II, if '-';> "y, ... hen! P .. doe projection from C (IIlto tbe cLc:.ed. OOD~ IIeI. 1)(0, I) _ {. E C : 1_1:5 1), ..., .....y auppOee Ihl::; I. Then
J
1/ ill"d,.) 2: I
f
gl"dpl-
f
f
(f - 1I)I Ad,, ) ?:
f
1.. . dVp. - f ;
c
.. hence the result.
T'->rem 3.:1.2 Far net) i~ ..1 A . Vp(A) _ SUI>(A.). ~ , I "( A;}I, IOI\erc (A. ).. , t:>tendr _ !lie cJo.u 0/ all fi";~ ".,rtitioru pI A 'IUD mIL" abt. H • •
P ROOP: G;""n t > 0, Iel " E S I(R , C ) be suoh that 1111:5 1 and I JlIt1 .. dpj2: J IAdV p - t . No... h can be .rnt~ I: ,«<~ 18, . ", when: tbe B; _ d;.joint ilJU!Cl'ble octs and lhe" ~ 10 b (o. i). Tben
H..,.,. 5tIP(A.).
obrioos.
E..., ", (A.)I
2:
f
I" . dV,.., and the ""....... lnlquality iI
[]
DeflnlUon 3.3.2 A IUboK A of 11 .. called #-Mod",.te if it iI ....... ;rwlID • muntable union 01 ~inteptble __ A maPlJ'lnl from n Into R Of .. vector .pace II ..-moderate If it .."W- ouwide. ,..moderate "", ,
"
P roposition :1.3.6
II I: n - j(I,+ocI iI,tid! doal
/ iI ",,,,,,,",,,,.
r I· dV" < +00,
do~n
<"
+001'''''''
PROOF': Let" be aD i~abIe functiou from 0 imo (0 . lhat I (Tl>e<:nm !I.l t ). Thm +col) ~ inl.tFd:>ie for~., n ~ I . &nd /
"-'01/1>.
"",,;Shes
""UJi<\e. u..;?;l II-I Ol/n. +001).
0
3.4 ,,·Measurable Spaces The po.i. (RA of . nonemp
" .. .",.-abio "P""" ~Hn ltion
:1.-&. 1 Let (O, F) &nd (O'.F) be 1_ ".~ . pe ...... A m' wi"" / : n _ rr if.ui to be ~Ie F IF ...~r r '(A') E F for -=I> A' E F .
(rr.r). and
I[ (O.F). ~ FIF
, aDd I a
''*''''
(fl". r ) "'" <1· mta/lunble I • mapping """",urabIe F / r , then, ciee..ly, go I ..
ma~
moMUrabk :FIr.
...
P roposition 3.4 .1 l.d O. 0'
«""" ""n~lp "'"
a...t
I: n _ 0'
~
map-
J. UI F Ioc a " . ,..;", in n . 'l"M d4.u F f 0/ nkriA, Lr ,~) i" rr ~1>C1l1iIaI1 ;,
"....,....,We F I P . t . U tPboa<1· nnginfl'. 'J1o,,<:/lluI-l (p ) _(r' (A' ): A'E F'1 LrQ """';"';" n. CIIIItd 1M ",. ,."., go ...",,'" ~ I . I -'(P ) u the 1maI1..1 "' . ...., F in n otId! Ilto.tl;' m64!J'U'fGWcFI P . PJIOOY: ObYlou8.
0
'poI_,
P roposition 3.•. 2 Ld (O,T) , (O'.P ) b( 1_ ",·m_nWlt OM leI C' lit< • 0011«& .. 0/ M"" oJ fI' .1Id! IiIoI F ;. tIw: ",."", goenm>t.:d 6r C' Tlleal it _ruhIo: F I F' u\(.....e1" I -'(A') Ii.., in F l()t 011 A' E C'. PItOO, : In tbe nQtatiou of P r<)p(lIIit;"o 3.4. 1.
Ff
"'>RIal ...
C' ""d , , ..... , F .
c
DeHnit iou 3 •• •2 La n be • """""'pi)' ""' . ( n,. FI»)'~1 be. nonemply funlly 01 <1·-=abk ~~. and, for eadt ; E I , ~ I. be a -wlns from n inu> 0,. The ",.rill(!: F ID 0 ~eratal 1»' {,,'(A,I : ; E I . A, E F;} is ca.l1«I the " . ring g.n,,,.ted by tbe famlly (J. ).~/'
3 .••3 I.. I/o.( ...,/ali"" OIl JHfiniliqn '.-l.t. F ;, 1M orn.dlerl OIl IMM: in fI nidi th4J ...m I, ;, .........,u1e"F;. Lt:I (O' ,.:P) /.Io! .. " ._~rcbl~ ~ h /.Io! .. mapping from 0' """ fl. Then h ;, ~ .:PI F Ii ""J <>nl, if I, o h iI ........nsbI< .:PIF, lor....:/l l . P~ltJ.on
".ring.'
......
PItOOF: By p~tloo> 3.4.2 , h iI meaourable .:P IF if &nd only if U, 01 11)- '( .... ) lioe In F for """'l' i € 1 and eWlr)' A, € F;. 0
If F , ill the .... rin« .....10& generated by
by a cl-. C. of osuboeu of (A, ) : i € 1. A; € C,).
~t.,d
{I,'
0" then T
ill the
'""'''''''P'Y
Deftnltlon 3.•. 3 t..el. (O.}) be a ,,·_ur.bIe lpoo<:e and E a SIt*, of O. T'hi! .... rin« F I E gmer_1ed by lhe canoni
boo a _""upey {&milJ' '" ...· _..ur .... IP'"'* C"""kIH lbe product oet fI ,. n'EI ft, and lbe canook·1 projectlor> Pi hem fl 0010 tbe fador f1; . The ...·rill,(!: F in fI smented by t he family (J>,)I<;' oImawill&l iI called lbe product .... riq of the F, and is writteD ®,uF,. Theorem 3 .• . 1 Ld (n. l,u k a I."'ilr QI 1<». ' sjeW; .e. F.,.. -.It. i, Id 8, .. Ihe &>reI " . •~ 0111.· ALN, 101 0 100 u.~ pr<>d Ie; I bg;,' q<>(II n ;,t I G"d B il6 B«r:1 " .a/gUnl. :nw:.. 0 ' EI S. C B. I" ,..,tic1Jar, if 1 ;, (tJI. ..."II) .......taW. aM ...m I<>po'-'Sim! """'" Iuu .. """"tab/./: 1o.tU, Ih<m B _ 0 "" B,.
n.
n.
P ItC)OI': 5i""" Pi is meuurabIo 8/S. for eo.ri> i. lbe idm!.ily of fI ;, it u.. 11>10 IUI>!oet.s of fI of lbe form p~ ' (V.,) n ... n p;:'(V... ) {i ...... i. € I. V.. e U" for """'Y I :5 .t :5 '" """",iluL.e. beeIs fur the product topoIocy, thlt (countable) built ;, ront "ined in 0 .." 8;. N..,. ewry Open eub&el. of 0 lit _ union ('» I rily oount.&bIe) of di$t1Dct .1.u",u" of thil buII.., il liN in 0 iEi 0
s..
-
"Ibe pal. of a ......"'p'y ~ n and .,,•• is' bra F In n
DefInItion 3. 4.& Let (n ,.F) and I! ite Iloor-.I " .lllgd>ra.. f mo 'J •• bleFI 8'· FT
called._MUtabIe
a " "urable~, 0' a t~!Ipe<:1O , fI - ll' ~ aaid to ~ _urab!e F if It is
~
:
~
Theot'<)m 3.4.2 Ld (0 . F) It.! a mfCIwnb/e
'PIlO<. 0' 4 "",'riusbIe 'PG". an
(t. ).2:1 4 ~ pI ",,"Wing.! frvm n in./(> 0' ttJhid> o?~ "..inl~ /;> a ""'wing J. S~ IA4t ""d I. ;, mmJ1
PROOf': ConsXler <m 0' .. d;"t~ " that, for e"")' open 1>1'-'. V or 0'.
r '(V) C limi .. f I;'(V)
c r'(V).
(1)
",here limiDf 1;'IV) - U~~ , n,~ . f ;'(V). Indeed, if z E I-'(V), Ii""", f Ir) _ lim,,-_/p{:t) and V ill open , I,(:t) beIorl.p 100 V 6:>r" large eoougb , and the firn inclusion obuins_ Similarly, if z E lim inf I;;' (V), there ~ta "" inleger n II>Cb that I,(z ) belongs 10 V for all " ~ n .!K> I(z) " 1; ...... _ _ 1.(0:) lM$ in V. Thio gl_ the second inclwd let B. be 11", union of thooc Open boJlo of ..,.diU$ I / ~ (",~ ~ E N ) _oed 0.1 poiots of F. B. ill open , IWd F _ B• .. n. 2:,J~. For. if z E /1., lhen
rr.
n.<:,
rt.2:'
n r' (B.).. r '( n S.) .. r'( F) .. r'( n b.) .. n r'(lJ.). . ~,
.~ ,
Applying ..,1&lioo ( 1)
1<)
. ~,
. ~,
B. , Ml oIrtain the incl".ioll
r '(B. ) C !!minf I;;'(B. ) c r'(lr.l. So
r'(F)-
n r ' (B. ) en
( Iimlnf I ;'(B. )) c
'2:'
which sayt
3.5
1- '(F) _ rl.2:' ( lim lof I;' (B. »,
n r'(lr.),., r
""d tlris lieI! In F .
' (F ), 0
Measurable Mappings
Definition 3.5. 1 A subloet. A 01 n is said to he p·met.lIunbie if A n B is p.in~ for aU jrin1ql'able """" B-
The d ... M of
,,-II'
? · "'.rable. IICt8
io obviously ..... ·~bra.
Dellnltion 3.5.2 A ..... boe\ Nol.O io Mid 1<) he loo:tt.Uy ".negligible If N n E is oegligible for every Ull
••
DefInition 3.5.3 La F be .. metriut.ble s~. A .... ppb\& I from () Into F 10 aid to be /t" mNI8u ... bIe if (a)
I iI ......u ... bIe M :
(b) W ewry i~ ~ E , then: exists .. rq;ligible atl N e E IUd> tlw the t.opoIop:aI I ( E - H ) • "p&ra~.
"'*'"'
~ IIw. ewry
mapping froo> n into F which '"4Ireee Wilh
I
l.aA. II
/J.meuurable.
A rw . " ry and 1Uf!iciem cooditioo that .. fUDCtion I from fl into R: be " . meuu ... bIe II I l>I.t 1-'{l T, +001) lie in M f.,.. aU rW numben r , 100-1, tbe Bo.-el O'·tJrebra of R: ill'" ,, -rilll! ttne ...ted by lbe c1_ mnoi81illl! of R: and tbe!lets
/1", _
I·
Propoeltlon 3.5.1 Each I
E.r ;, ".~.
PlIOOf': Let r > 0 be a fHl numbe-r and \e\ E E i. T het-e uiou 9 E .r" Iud! tlwg 2: 1.11" and < +00. lfn > r . . . . inl'l"'". inf(f, ng) bdonp to.1 · and iI intqn.bIe (The:Htm 3.1.4). Tb... Iot~. r' OT._1) n E ..
!"g ..rv"
E n lDf(f, ng)- ' (lr. +oo1) iI/,,"in~.
[]
DefInition 3.5." Let E be .. oonempty _ and 5 .. "mial&ebn in E (i.e. , .. Itmlring ronuinilll! E). A .... pping I from E into .. eel rr II Aid to be S" o>p!e .....ne-.-er tbe", II a finite putitioo ( E, ).EI of E lnto S·oet.I Iud! tlw I II oonot..,11 on ~ E•.
Propoeillon 3. 5.2 A .....pping I from n ...... a ....lrUoWc ",..... F ;, p m" ,*,c!lle if an.cl """ jf, /.". mdr. imfJ' die nib .., E 0/0, I ;, 1M limit a.t. ift E 01 a ~ ol 1l.I E.ft",pk mapping>. P ROOf": Let d be .. distance on F (compatible . ill! tbe IOp<:IIov of Fl. If / iii /J'" .. 'J , ..... bleand E .... intqn.bIe""" tben! ....... .. rq;Ii&ible_ N C EIUd> ,,,-, I (E- H ) II oeparable. Then. letti", (~ : i ~ I) be .. <:OUIltabie denoe oub_of / (E- N ). _1>1...... , lot......,. l~n?: I. I (E - H ) c U i!: ' 8 (IIo . I/ n), or E - N c U i!:' (B(~. I/ n»), whftoe B(II;, l I n) d' 'iptee lbe open tJ.l1 with.,..,~ iii and radio. I/ n . Hence there exisu ... in~ "- IUd> thai. tbe V It" IL¥ F'un! of Y• .. E - UI '5' 'S •• I - I (B(~,. I / n») is Ietoo ,Itan I j r. N_ )LUt
r'
Z. _ U"i!:. Y.. , and deli"" an i l E..unple mapping 01,,: oI,,(:t:) ..
I
~ E
.,
F
if :t: E Ao .. Z. .
if:t: E Aj .. E n
",here IiO iii fUed but arbitrary (l...Io:s.SI- ' ..... )· n I - ' {B(", I/ n »)
IorI S i S k" .
"Then tbe eeq_ (o/>.,)~2: ' o:xr.t' g& to I at """" point or E V,IIni!:' Z.) .. o.
n.
lt ,
Z•• and
Con.......ty. JUppCI6e t hat the condition .. satisfied, and let E be an intepbic~ . We <:an find B ""'Iuen<:f: ("';).>1 of k / E-,;mple mll.ppi"3ll from E into F, which ~ to fi E outside B ''''I(ligihle ~ NeE. Fll< , E F and, for...::ll i <: 1, let I"! bo: the mawing from E into F wbich ogreeII witb 'P, on E - Nand ... hK:b 10 , ",,(E - N). Fin.olly, lor ~ -EIoml1 8el. 8 ib F, I-' (B ) n E is integrable fo.. oJl E E k ; I!O I-'( B ) I.... in M . a
"·,,,_urobk
P ropoo,it ioD 3.o!>.3 l.,d I. be ~ "",pping /r<1m n mt
from 1(0)
into" "",triuhle """'" G, tkfl u
0
I ;, " . ..,.." oJUbk
PlIOOf' : Is E be "" inlf«rabie oe\, and let N be. negligible JUMet of E ouch that I.(£:- N )" 8epe.::abie for every- n <: L Fort$Ch .. ~ I. let 8" he tht: Bom
181.>1 (E-
R_
...,...,.,a:
Theorem 3.5.1 (£ SOI"O"V'. Theo.... m) ul (I.l.lI bc G "I ,, _m~ "'appingJ from fl ;nto a "",tri.t.o:~ "nil""" 'JIG<" F, ....... ~ l ~ .e '" G mappinf I . n..... I if " .~ M_ _, lor ~'""lI i~ ..,1 E an4 ....." t > 0, then: aitto an intqrnbi• ..,1 B e E .ucA tJw. V,,(Bl:S t an4 nocIo.lh.ai u.. . t\'U<"Me (I") .~I a>n«ryu "n;j~ to I .... E - B . PROOF: Let N be .. I0<:0.I1)" nqii&ibh: 8et lIueh IhIIl {I. )..~I ">nod&,,! to I ou~ N, a:>d let d be • dis ....... on F. For every PBir of illlq
:s
It mtqrabit, &lid V,, (B) :S I:.>, V,, (8~h') :S ~ . By oonsln.lCt;o", (I.. ).. oomt. gtS "niiormly 1.0 I on E - B-'" D _ +00. Finally, /IE-Ii", ~ble fil E - N. hen<:(: I Is _"",bit; M. ~ow ...., can chooIe Ii 110 d.at eo.ch ME - .... ) "'~' &lid be.><;e ICE - .v) is toepIll1Iobie. a
>.
Propoo.llioll 3.~." U I (1_ ).. bot a I t ~ rrwoppOng I · Ft>r end> m 2: L. It:! (I....~ ).~ I bot 0 ...,....._ 01 " •............obl<: """,pi..,. /mm !l illl<> F, OI>Q"",,.,..., I.o.~ k> 1_. TMn, It>r eodI mOOtt""" (Q(P))'~1 cl ;~ ... 2: I .•1ICh tMl (J,.~(.) ).~,
.....""'JU 10
I
p.t. .... A .
P ROO~:
Fi,..., OUPP<8 .h.t.t A 10 In~. WI :> 0 ~ &i~. F.,.-"""'Y '" ~ I, there «isu &n 1~1e Z_ of A such that V$I(Z_):;: tlr' and ...m thllll"" ""'I.\IeIICI!! {J..... )~~ , co", er"", uniformly 1.0 1_ (Xl A - Z ... : t hen, puttlD« Z • U...;: ' ha~ V /-IfZ) :;: t , and t&d> 1It
,,,beet
z.. , ""
_"('X" unikinnlJ" 1.0 I,. on A - Z_
No.. "" _ 10 the 0_ ... bOe (.4.;).> , of loltpable - . which wt may lake disjoint . By .. ha. woe h.t.~ jlN ";"'n, lhere «k" A do, of inlesrMle fUbetu of A;. Iud>
that
Cil
-
n.2:' Vi ..... oqI~ble:
(b) for - . y m:> \ , , "" ""'I.""""" {I_.~).~I ~ uniformly to eedI A, - Y, ... (with J> ~ 1)_
I ...
(Xl
Put Y• ., U,~ , Y,.... for all J> 2: I. "" that n.~, Y, k nogl\ilbie. By indootioon on p , ...., <»nSI.n.><:t .. Strictly i,.......;"11 &equroce ("(J» )~I of integc,.. tbo.t .1(/,..(.), 1,) :;: II p on U 'S'li'.( A, - Yo ... )- Nftn, ~ Ii he a oqI~bIa ...'-t of A sud> that {I.. )... » comE' .... 10 I (Xl 04 _ N_ 0 ;""" :r; In A U Y.) :r; bf:Lonp A, for A ouil&ble ; 2: I. and then: «itt3 PO ~; """" iliB,:r; d_ not lie in Y... ThEn, for all p 2: po , "" ha", d(J~)(z). 1,(:.:)) < lIt>. lIentt I (z ) is lbe limil oi lhe !,.• (p){:,:). p - +00, and the proof ill complete. 0
2: 1 Iud>
IN (n.>,
J.
w
ul F bot .. rwJ &ruu:A $J>OO<- A mapping / /m",!l into) F .. I'"~ ..n
PItOOt": By PlOpel;"'" 3.5.2. ,boo CODdilion is ~ul6.:ie"t. Com~y, IUI~"" tbo.t I ;" ~ and mo<\err.l.t. and let (o4, );~, bt; A!Isiliooa 3.$.2). FOI ewry n ~ I , ~ g.. to he the ""'Willi from n inl.O F
tlw ogne with I". on eMf! A, for .'hiel> i '5 n , ..00 thal vanisbeo ouWde UL!; '!;~ A,. Then (g.)~~L coo""'!1'6 \Q I a.e. [J
T heorem 3.5.2 ul V Ie a ~ _1M rub..,.,.", til C}v. ), whene Fila rml Ban4dL IPO'OO- A mflppmg I from n iroto> F iI "'rouGI~",bk .. nd " ............k if and on/JI if it illIw: limit ae. 01 a "'I"'enot: on V . P JU)()S": By Propoai\i.on 3.5.5, Thoon::m :U. I . and P ropositioJ\ 3.1.9, e&cl> I in .c}v.) ifll'""~bIe; Ihllll ihe coJ>ditlon ill aufficienl. COh'.'sely, ~ I : n _ F he ""","urahle and TOOde-re.~. B)' P,op:ai lion 3oS.!>, I io the limi~ -.e. or a _""""" (J.. ).. ~L in St(R. F). BUI ...at I.. ill l he !imi~ a.e. 01 . _ueru:::e in V ( P n;>pO)!Iitioon 3.1.11), 010 I is the limit Le. 01 . _""""" in V (Pmpo:wilion 35.4). [J
Theorem 3. 5.3 A ....... "''11 and nfficiert! o>ro0 and I ifl l he limit . .... nf. ~ in 1i{fI , R ) (3) F, So Thaw.", 3oS.3 folJooors hom Theorem 3.5,2. [J
_n<>I fJI - I:.,;>:, r
T I__ e m 3.5.4 wi {f.).>, he a into (O. +<>oj. ~ ra:.~, I~ ) '.w"
" .m~fo<mtWnl
I~ ' dV" ,
/rom n
PJtOOf': F\Lc all p-rrEL"u.abIa fw,c!io, .. I , 9 from fI into !O,+<>ol, ..... Ita... rU+,jdV" - I·0 or 9·.w" - +<>0. and aI80 if I and , ..,.., I'""inlegrablt. Then 3.5.4 Wh.. from Beppo LeY;'" lbeo<em. [J
r
r
r
r n.eo"""
3.6 E",.entially IntegrabJe Mappings By OOCl.Ultlon, ..... "'" 0
~
(+<>0) _ 0 )( ( - <>0) _ O.
DefinI t ion 3.6.1 For all funccioDs
j ' l.w" .
I from fl jnto (0, +00(,
...
oul!.j' 11~.w"
is called ,he upper ' , ."tia! inttgnJ nf I (wil h...,.p«t \l) V,, ). c.:...a.:qt>den.te ~
r
r
r
r
If E iI B I U","", 01 0, 1 o!dV" _ 0 m _ ,hAl E is loo:eJly ~~l.iciblo. If / and , aft two func:\ions from r:l into [0. +<:>o[ ...hd> qree I.... e. , tben
rand/·,\.dV" - r g·dVl'- lf I,g. aOO II a~ t h_ functiona from ,. 0 ;". n:al numbe"
r{f
tben
+ g)· dV" <
r
I ·dV" +
r
r:l into [0,+0::11
g_.w"
j "Mo.dV,, _>.. j · h·.rv,,_ If U.).,~, is an i.uc,.... -ing oeque",," 01 functions from r:l into 10,+00] u.d if 1 - oup"2:' I~, , hen
P ......... lt ion 3.1. 1 Ld I , g. dM h ... u..... fImdio'" fnmo 0 into 10.+00), ..wt ~ dM h wmeo;,v ... hl. Tht" 1(g+h)-dV" .. 1,-dV,,+ Ih -dV".
r
r
!'ROOt': It !lUffictoI.., p ,h(, .hllt
1/.J +h) -dV" ..
t
r
19 dV,,+
t
r
Ih· dV",
51 ..... /19 + hl _ I g + Ih..... ha,..,
t
J{g+h)· dV" s: /
and I. r<:mai", to bo:
~
Ig·dVl' + /
lhal
/ f9 ·dV" +
r
Jh · dV"
s:
r
Ih· dV".
1(g +h)· dV",
We need oaly 0)1: S' v., IhI; ~ in .. hid> J" 1(, +11) -dV" < +00. "Then tbere '""~. E ,,.. th.al " ::: 11.1 + h). P ut ~ _ . '1.1+ 11) .. I...."'.' , + 11 ,. 0 and" < +"." and put ~ _ +oo .. bcre
....:n
r o{g+h) -dVI' r .. -dV",
,+h _0 or .... +00; tho:n It ~ u{g+hl, to> < M.... w 0 and u(..,) < +001 is WmoMUrabIoo and tbe fuDCtion Id, ~) - a/ 6 from [0. +oo[ " ]0, +001 in.., I't "' COIIdn __ . and
benco "IE 10 n..-; 'Urabioo M IE, .. hid> ......... thal " 10 I'-n-..rabIo:. A...., and ,,/,. a:e I'-~. Siooe ~;:: J, ..... ha...,
j "I,· dV" + j "Ih· dV,. s: jO trg . .w" + j "0-11 · dV"
.r
..(,+II)-dV"
OJ,
st . .w". a
•
Theorem 3.6. 1 l.Q.
r-J III;, II
r 1
""I ",cd ' ut~
M Il l ;' ...odtn\te. (c)
into [0, +001
I lot: " fomdion frrmt 11
r l.w" .. J' IdV" .
r l.wl/- < +<:<;!, ....:.t.o ...m u...t / """w.... III..,..,
II
i>I~ leU ,
leI
A. u...t "
G
""""~
L .. ~. ""ojdc A .
.........
1>,
r
PROO' : (. ) ....d (t.) 1I.t.~ been I"",ted preylo tll.t.t /1iVI' - .... P~;: I /I A., dV1'. P ut A .. U~l: ' A~. Then
r
J'
~~r / 1A.,dV" ~
r
/IA
r
I I AdVjJ.
j ' /
r I IA' dV" ..
r I
I e:r. then the IIi!t , -'(10, +<:<;!D " A Ie moderat whence _ _ tIw J' IdV,, !S IdVp. c
Prop05itioll 3.6.2
1'lt(M)l": If , e " .. and f gdVjJ !S
Now Itl F be • Bo n"'h from 11 ioto F cueh that
c
O.
1IpA(Ie. and
1T.U) ..
e""'ll
let ~&o) he tbe
r
IIi!t Ql
r l/I· dV" < +<:<;!. Endow
tbe ""rninorm N; ' I - r il l'
I
~~
T heore m 3 .6.2 / Ioe/ongt I<> ~&o) (ru"",~,. ~(jl») if .."" q..Jy if il ;,
""'", lId" ..
ep4Ilo.e. 10 G f e P,.&o) (",",,,,,,11,,01,, g e .cj.(j.); '" 111;' f pdoo)- I : 11 - F ;, UK>ItWit, ,, ·iPII"9f"Gble il ""d omI~ if il;, ".~~ IfIJV" < + 00. I ;, " . inl .•• =We i/ .."" <mI, if it ;, " •.....km14: UJ'tn,Iiallp jJ.in~_
a"" r
e"" c
I d" .. f I dl'
for all I € Cj.(I" . tbe _ntW ;IItfll'a1 ] I dp. of ...,. I € ~(I') ill \Wall,. .. rillm f Idp.· For e\W)' ~~~.eI: A, fIlA d;< .. then ",ritWO fA I d".
Sinco! ]
•
Obee....e tW. If .. 1tt A iI _nl;.,)lr in~bIe (I.e.. if 1.. iI). TI.eot.", 3.6.1 oboon th.t.t Ail .. union of.., integrable Itt and .. locaJlr ""&li&lble Itt. Noor. put 1111 - sup",>I(n.CI.IfI";' 111(, )1 ,., ~uPIE>I'J";' VI'U ). 10 that 11'1- UVI'I· Dellt, llIo n :S.6.2 ". is saki to be bounded "hEtIC.e. Propoo
11'1 _
u.KJtliAll, "..;"'1';1 : bk.
!
1... dV".
• •up
1".1 is Snite.
r 1 . dVl' . So I' .. """nda/ ;j~,..I ""'~ if fl ..
I!QI .. d".I'5 SUP ! I, IdVI' :S •
~(n.CJ
WI!> '
sup 10" lSI
V".U)-I".I
r
for .....,. intqrable Itt A • ., I . dV". < 1".1 (Propooitioa 3.3.4). ConvttlElr. VIIU) :S 1" 1 . dV" lor ..u I E 1(+ ...tWyi~ 1 :S 1. Hence
1I' I'5 rl .dV"..
[]
Propoo opa(e F.1Mn J lvdl' IJ vdl' hu;" D lor....., ""'JIIrirIf I from fI imo 0,..1....., UIeIIliall, mt~ /ram fI imo (O,+oo! #UdI Iht.t J g 0,..1 19 ;, tue1lt1aIl~ j", ;; .. Wo!. If Id". - I, IMn J I~ Iiu i7I tAe elo«.d CIim_ "'. . . . ofl{fI ). lor ....., tue1lt1aIl, irtlq'uWo! ""'PJ>i1lf 1 /ram fI into. r-...I B
D
I.",,,t>om, 1"
°
PI\OOF: We ~ ooJr J)rO'o'e the fi~ cloirn. Oeow: by F' the dual lpoooe 01 F . Lee ( o. a') '" "'(z) :5 0 (a' E F'. 0 E R ), • relation defini", in F • clMM h.t.lf~ E "hlch """w... D . TMn U{.z),(.z),.') '5 o,(.z) for aJl.z E n, ., (/ 1gd", a') '" /(1" ..') . d" '5 <> J "t"., ..>d J I gdl'1J gp to E. By the Hahn- g·n ..... theorem. D illhe intu_lion 011"," clMM h.t.lf...... "bid! oonw.. it, t.Dd the proof ill mmjWte. []
Propc.-ition 3.B.5 S~PJlOH " II j:IL>Ati .... a,..l kl I : n - (O, +00) .. " . mtIfl.nL",w.,. PI£/. 9(1) '" 1'"(I - '()I, +001») lor ....., raJ nwmlo!r f > 0, and covider~ , I.e ...,... "'........., en)O. +00(. Thcto jd" '" ~f)dA(I).
1"
PIIOOr. FiM,""ppo8fl th.t.t
or {O,I" ... , I.) (with 0 <
I
f,
r
bu. finite, positi"" ......., """",Ir. {I" ... ,f.} < f, < ... < to). Thoen
r
On tbe Oloo hll.ud,
L
g(1)d.\(I) .. I, . ,,' (1 2: I,) +
(I, _ 1, _ , ). ,,' (1 2: t, ).
·';'S·
boca.... g \a ...... he val ... 1"(1 2: I, ) on 10, I, I, the value ,,' (1 2: I.) on (I" 1.1. _. _. If all the; 1"(1 _ I. ) an: fiDi"", t he ",,18 (1 '" I, ) ftre -.:ItiaDy iDI<>grftbIe,
...L
I, ' ,, (1 '" I, ) '"
L
I, (P(J 2: I, ) - ,,(1 2: 1;+1)1 + I • . ,,(1 2: to)
'" 1, -,,(12:1 ,) +
r
L
(1, - 4 _,) 1'(12: 1;);
~ ' S·
r
he"", Idp g(1 ) - ,1.\(1). Evlokndy.• hio "'Iu.olity remains InIO! if 0lIl': of the 1'"(1 '" II) Ie inftnllt_ We ""'" puoo to ,"" ~ra1 cue: ""PI>'*' I n. -=-.bIo:. and D(K>I!~r the ....... function / . . . In P'Q908iIIorl 3.3.3. For ~ t ;> O. the 8eq..en<:e of XU
(U.
;> I)).,!:, ;' ''''
.. n _
+CO.
1 to (1 ;> I), SO ,," «(1. ;> I») converges 10
Thl:n:ron,.
j "l ·d" '"
,,' (U ;> I))
... j ' I.-iJ<
r '" r '"
Urn
.- ~
Hm
,,'(U~ ;> I)) . d.\(I)
P(I ) -
a
3.7
Upper and Lower Integrals
Let Ji(n,C) and:r be '" in Section 3.1 Denote h1 J the sec of t"functionilio from n Into I{ "';th !.he proper\)' thll.t lhen. exists 9 e 11{n , R) oodI thlll h - 9 bo:Ion&» to :r. Let h he .. poeitive ' ''ment of J , and lei , E Ji(n, R) be ouch thaI " - 9 bi' o'ga to.r ; lhen , ' :s 10, and , . - g :s h - g; Ihuo 10 - gO .. (h - g) - (go- _ g) ,"", In J+ , and &l8o" '" (10 _ g+)+ , '. T hitl mealOI that J+ io the IIr:I of pOOIiIive ~lemcnu of J N_ , for~very h E J. if 9 E 11(n , R ) io ouch tbat g:s h. then Io-g ];e. In J , and """"'" I;" In J~ . AIIoo, '" +ho beIonp to J for .on " " ": E J. and M E J b- allh E J and.\ E R ' . Furthe'II"" ' . if h , and 10. belong to J and 9 In Ji(n , R ) 10 dotnilW.M t.,. Inf(h " h.) , then $Up(Io, ,/0: ) -, '" sup(h, - g, It., - p) and ;"r(Io" 10, ) _ 9 lie In Thill J)r'<W<:O that J is ft lattice_ Ileno:
.r.
3.7 Upp« and!.oooer I....... .
71
Definition :1.7.1 For ~ h E.1. p " (h} .. suP"; I'I(Il.R).. s ~pll} iI ailed the upper int~ 01 h.. O~ t hat . .. t..n h I... in .1 • . p" (h.) is iust the Quant ity
r hdp ..hid>
..... _mum in Scdion 3. 1. I! h. E .1 and g E ?t (O. R ) are .udt that /I < h.. then p"(" ) ..
p" (" - g) + $0(/1 ). Hmoo p" (h , + h. ) .. $O " (h,J + $O " (h. } for all h, and h. In .1, and p OeM ) .. ).. p' (h) for e-.·e'l')" ). E R · and e-.'ft)" h E .1. Simlt.rly, p' (ouph,, ) .. IUP.~ , $O' (h A ) for every inc:noui"ll ""'I"""" ("" )A ~ I in .1.
P ropoooltion 3.1.1 A n, ( ..a~ and ~ """",/>on !hal. h E intqnlWl: U !hal. p ' (h ) < +00 . In !IIu .....,. p " (h) .. I h · 4p.
.1 hoe
p-
Suppoee thai; p" (h) < +00. For ~ ~ > 0, t here exisu /I in ?t{fI, R ). 9 S h , such that p(g);:: p" (h) -t. T h<-n p" (h - 9)" p" (h) - p(f) S t, which P IlOOF:
that h is p. i~. Mo.-..er, I lul.p S p(g) + r S p' (h) hdp S p" (h) and. In fact , I hdp .. p" (h).
prO>'OII
I
Put - .1 ... ( _ h , h e .1). Any vaI.- and iI p·lntqrab!oe.
~ti~
+ t , eo
a
(u"",ion 01 - .1 takco only finite
P ropatltlon 3.1.2 A "'MohM1 I Jmm fl ;nl<> It ,. " . inltgrubIe if and <>nIr ii, 10<' everv r > O. then: m.I ,, · inl.,.-obk "'Moho". 9 e - .1 and h e .1 IIOdI tiUII,I S , S hand I (h - 9) ' d" S c . We ""'~ /4U 9 pouiti ... VIm I u pcuitiK. P ROOF: ObriooAly. the modition iII~ . No.- .... ppoee that , ill ,,·inl~ and ot-m: that..., may""'''''' I ill ~ti"". Given r > 0, tllMe uist U E ?t ... . ,..,h t hat II - " I, d" S c/4, and v E .1. such tha\ II - ul S " and dp. S ~/2. 1'0.,.. - v :!> 1 - u :!> ", .. he""" u -":!> I S u + " and (u - v) · :!> I :!> u + v. Th<-n it .ul6c:e. to take 9" (" - tt)· and h .. " + v ( t..cause .. + v - (n - v)· :!> "lv). 0
f' ".
r
Propatltion 3. 7.3 For ettCf}' t~ ",... ti/m I Jmm fl into Ii: (rup«:tiud" inl.. lO, +00)), then: o:rirl .n i~.<9VtIIOI' (g.). >, 01 inlqnJbk ",otdiov 0' - .1 (_tivd~, 0/ ",.iIi..., /10""6",,, 01 - .1} ,,";,J 0 duo , hog ~ (h,, )A~' .., ~e ",... IIOM af.1 ndllhat g. :!> f :!> h" lor oJl n ;:: 1 "nd / .. suP.g" .. lnf. h. """"', ~. PlIOOf' : riM . • u~ thai. / .. p<8it;'.,. For every I n~ n 2' I, """" exiIt an imqnoble v. e .1 and • pooitive .... oJ -.1 ouch thai. .... S / S .... and 1(.... - .... ). 4j. S 1/ ... If ..... put 90. .. IlUp(U' , ... , .... ) and h" .. in( v, .. , . ,VA)' ..., .,., , hat the ""'I .... """'" (9A ). 1; ' and (hA )A~ ' have the dollil'fld pmpert.... l~, iii""" 9 .. IlUPA>I Jl,. :!> / . g is ".lntqrab!oe (by the lhoomm); and ' A)' d" :!> ,,~) . d,. S
""""""'" '""', .. "eo....
1Ii..o. I(J -
1(.... -
I/ n . ...., hIt.... lldo/J - 1gd.jJ - lim,,_+oo l(l- ",,)d'1' _ O. ",hie!> pnPI"eI that ! and 9 are "'IuaI &I...... """'Y"'bere- The argument;' tbe..",., for (II.M ,. In "",."a! . ..., may app/)' tho ... ta>.lilli argument to ""d 1-: B().ben: are two in<:rflOIilli ~n<:oOI (1.).2; " CJ:). ~, ofln",«.abie luno:tioDs of -.1 and tWO decrn5ll1i ltquen<:oOl { ~~ ). ~l' {II:).:>, of In<
r
-
.ox:h that
(a) 0 ~ (., (b)
~
r
~
h:, and t: S - / -
r _SUI','. _ in!
~
peLt g" -
,:,
("") .~, hIt.... the
+ g! r.nd II. S"'ed
~
Jo:;
~O;
alrnool e>'f:rywben::
(d - / - SUI't.; - inf II; Theo>
-
alrnoot e>'f:rywbere. _
II!. + II:. Clearly. tbe IIeCIUI:IlOIOI {g.). 2;'
pL"Oper1\a1.
and []
n_
o..llniUo D 3.7.2 for """ry func tion J : J[, /J'(I) - Inf""J' .... ~J/J· (h) and /J"(f) ,. - /J"( - f) .... caIJcd tbo ul'P'" ioto:gtai and tbe lower ioi"eg.l of
I ~
that /J "(f) Ie the same q\l&l>tlty '"' that in Definition 3.1 .1, _1>w J ill positi""
P ropoo l[
J 1101" far
~"",.,.
"'ndiim I
PROOr'. By ddl.nitio<>. /J ' (f) - Inl (J II 01" : II 2 J. II E .1. II in"'l. able). 10 Inf~J . ..... 'o. lIolp. S ,,' (f ). Thill ..., In&f <:Online out all_ion 10 the c:.w: ",hIwe inf.u..~Jhtlp is not +00. and let. r E R be li&tktly &Jftlcr tlwl this number. 'lbertexisu II 2 I. II iOlqrable.!N<:h that htlp < r . and. by PIO(>Ofitk>t> 3.7.3. there &leo fXIWI II' E,7, II' i~, II' 2 II . NCh lhat h' do" ~ r . Therri:ore. p"(I ) < r . and It.. propooIition bI~ []
J
J
1
Similarly. P.U) - "'I' (J gd/J : 9 S f . 9 integ. ahle
I: """"" /J, (f) S /J'U )·
P ropgo,ltlon 3, 7.5 1/ /, ..... " ""' I.., ",,,,,,-,, frtmo 11 i/oto Ii .....:It t/I<11 " + II if tk/iMt1 <11......1 ~~"' And if /J"(ftl t /J"(II) mllku oenH, ~ ,,"U, + II) ~ /J "(J,) + p"(h)· JI {t. ). ;." if An i""""""IIf "...,,«
0/"''''''''''' from 11 "'-to 'Ii nw:o\ /hal p" U. ) ,. -00 far n ~ tft01OSJO'I , u.~ /J' (OUP~,
f.) -
w~, /J'(I. ).
PROOP: 10 PfD'I"! !be Srst, rtion, it ""16",,, 14> ronsi~ tbe """" ...be .... /J "U,) < +00 and /J "(h ) < +00. If h,. h• ..,.., two in~ fun<:t,;,;,.,.s@ thlt.t h, ~ I" h. ;:: fI , Irt ,;" " it, boe t~ I8l-vaIucd funo:tiono OD 11 w it, + h. 2 " + h .oJ ......t e....ry ... here, ITO /J "(/ ' + h) S /J{h, +h,) - /J{h,) +/J(h, ). and p" (f, T hl :; /J"(/, ) +/J "{/,).
" gUllion, ~ ~ as in e.7 io intqrable &lid that II~ 2: I~ .
For the
I>"
~
T~rn
3. 1.1 . IUI'I""'inc that
a
Theorem 3 .1.1 M\eIIp' {I} " /i'u/e, !htTo: eNtI a .. iftltgrab/e ",,,,,lion /1 ,lid th4l " 2: / and /l{l,) .. /l" (I) ; 1/ h .. ~ " " ",nd .nttgrabk ",,,,,lion nell tho/. h 2: /"ttd /l(h )" /l" (1). !hen / . ~ h olrrw.t ~ A "_'N'''Y ~ttd ~ o:ond>'ticrn rh.o.t/1Io! ;nt es1dle .. tho/. /l , {I ) on4 /l' (I ) N /iniU
""....,.
P ROOF: Suppooc ,,' (I) io finite. ror ev"tf)'" 2: 1. the ... u:iltII lUI inusrable fuDCtIon I>" sud> that II.. 2: / and /l' (f} ~ ,, (I>,, ) ~ /l"{I) + I / n. o-Iy. II _ infn2:' 1>" - infn2:' inf(h , •. ... 1>,,) is intqrable &nd /l' {I) .. ,, (II ). /'0_ Let / " h be"" in tbe II..... • .1tioort. We 1"0,," that /1 _ h .01",,* """")'W1>o. ...: theft iI no ratooion in .... uminc that /, ~ h- for ev"tf)' i E (I , 2). let be • -'-,-..)ued funet~ on.o, equal to /, at poI~!,1w!re /, and h _ IInM, and . up ..... that /, :s J.. We ha"" ,,(h), or /lli. - ft) .. o . ..
i;
i, .. i. u., and /, -
h
,,(i.> ..
u. F\naIly. Let / be. function from n into R: Iud> tbat /l, (I) , /l ' (I} _finite and equal . "rIIo= u:ioI intqrable functions , . " such that 9 ~ / ~ II and " U) .. ,,(h). Then 9 " h .. / al..-t ......-.ywlw!re, 1>0.""" / io inusrable- 0
",to n:
/0""
P~IUon 3. 7.6 f/" ~nd h ~'" ",,,,,tio ... from n .-..ell 11\.01 " + h ;, th/inm .... .. nd i/ p, (It ) + p" (h ) maku -..e, tA.!n /l, (It + h) :S /l,{I,) + ,,' (h ) ~ ,, ' {I, + h )· 1//, ; n "ttd h : n arfttnJ..,.. then 1" (It + h ) - ,,(/ ,) + ,,' (h ) GtId /l, (It + h) .. 141t) + ", (h )·
n: ;,.nltyro.hk
n: ;,
P ROOF: Tto prove that " , {li + h) :S " , {I, )+"" (h ), ...., .....y IUppo:oee ,," (h ) < +0>. Gi""" lUI integrable fu"",1ou II. 2: h. let h. 1>0. • ...aI·valued fuDCtion equal to ~ Le . If 9 io an lntegrloble f""",ion ouch that , < I , + h , _ ha"" , ~ /, + e., or 9 - it, ~ / , u . II foltoor. that /l(' ) - " (,,,) ~ " . (ft). "Jbenof....... p,(f, + h ) - 1'(11.) :5 p, (f,). or " , (f, + h) :s I',{I, ) + 1'(11,). and finally p . (I, + h ) :5 " , (It ) + ,,' Ch )· Tto ",...blilb the lnequalJt)· I' "(/d + ,,' (h ) ~ ,,"Cit + h), ((jllSidel - It and - h . The Iaot .nation now follows easily. a
h. •.
_ R: IIo! neIIlhatl',U) (rupecti~J,. ,,"U») ,:, foniU. 1/, ("""",'i~IW, II) ;, .... i ..';;,£6I. ",,,,,tiM> from n iIUQ ,11(1\ th4l 9 :5 / .nd pU) .. 1',(1) (""f/«filtd). II 2: / and 1'(11 ) _ ,,' U»). theJo 1"(/ - , ) .. 0 atld I"U - 9) .. 1"(/) - 1', U ) ( rupecfuoti•• 1',111 - I) .. 0 "tid 1" (11 - I) .. I"(f) - ,,"(f»).
Prop
ut/ : n
n:
PROOF : By Pt-opo.ilion 3.1.6. 1"(1 - 9) .. I'"U ) - /lU) and /l,(I - , ) 1"(/) - " tI) .. o. Similarly, ,,' (h - f) .. ,, (II) - ,, "(I) and 1', (11 - I) p(h) - ,,- (I) - o. a
,
Proposition 3.1.8 wI / 10: "" ~
Jrmn rt
""",tiq" from fl intQ R. 4nd Id 9
1'[ • ..dI IAGj ,,' (9) .. finit.o:. Then " """".....I")' .. nII' ~ Qm4ilion IMI, "" inl...,....W. .. th4l "U) .. ,,' (g) + ,, ' (J - , ).
/Ie • ",,,.(;tWQ
int(J
PlIOOf': Suppooe that 1'(1) -p'W) + P' U - gl· Si""" / II i~rat>le. ,,' (f - gl ..
-
__ 'c gl .. ,,(II -
But ,.' (f -
,......
ji(fl + ,,' (-g) '" I' U) -
,.' (g) by hypod",sit. 10
1'. (, ).
,,'U) ..
,.. (g), and 9 Is
a
Oeflnit lon 3. 7.3 F(If aU su~ A of fl, ,,"(A) .. ,, ' (I,,) and " . (1,0) are called ,hoe outer m: " u"" and tbe inDO!T ltWUun! of A. Natt that ~ h.o...,
aln;o.d)'
dull ";tb the quantity ,,' (A ) ..
" .CA) ..
r lAd" in
!"'=yiQua 'O'Or'k.
Propooitlon 3. 7.9 F<>r A C n. " . (A ) .. eup(I'(B ): B e A. B ;"1'9' /,/" ..n4 $0' (04 ) .. in! (,,( 8) : B ::> A. 8 ;"4. 101.) P IlOO', Let r < /O. ( A) be. r...J num"" •. T heM t'Ii!l1.S an in~ funetioon f PJdI that 0 S f S I .. and r < f fdJ<- For all in~ra " ~ I. BR .. C" E 0 ./(:0) ~ I f nI ~ In~_ BT d~ domi .... """ con~n"", t'-"tm. f /I". djl (:OD>e'ga11 \.0 J 111." iii n _ +O:::>.!10 tbe"" exiWI n <= I ,uch til&! /1 IJ.djl <= r . For lb. n, B~ .. B- Since f S I,. ..... hay<> ,,(8 ) ..
p""
J
_"ion. that ",' ( A) ill finite &nd let , > ",' (A)
f 18<11' > J /184- :! r, wbicb 1"00<:6 I t.. fir$!
Tb proI'e tho IOIXIOd ......\1"", ",ppooo:; be. -.l numbt<-o ~ exbu I th.at I 2: lA and Id", ~ , The" B _ Iz € f} : I (z ) 2: 1) ;,. !~, <:O
E:r ...m
f
""*
Pro.,.,.ition 3.1. 10 F..-.-ry ,lIMa A % Ih4t II, ( A) <: +00 (rupa:ImeIy, ", -I A) <: +00), til ..... eriot, 0'1 ~w. HI A, C A , re'1'«liIId,. A. :l A) ....,.. tIIaI ,,(A,) _ I'- (A ) (,.,'p«li!1dr, ,,(A. ) _ ", ' (A )). Fqr ~ A, (re.,...:Iiw/f. A.) o/lilu ~ II, (A - A,) .. 0 ond ", ' (A - A,) '"' ",' (A) - II, (A) (req«l~", ,,_(Ao - A ) _ 0 .IId ",' {A. - A) _ ",' ( A) - ",,( A)). P ROOF, Tht! e>:i6tenoe of A" A. follooon from P mpooitioo 3.7.9, &nd the otl,er ~""'(Qi ~ opp .. ",ofP,OjXISition3.7. 7. 0
,...,
P roposition 3.7.11 Lot A, B 6e I"",
d~t .~~
o/f} 4n4C!heir 1Ini<m.
p_(A) + ", , {B)::; ",, (C):5 ",,(A ) + ,,-(B ) S ",' (C):5 ,,'(A) + ,,'(B ).
,
3.1 U_
ODd I-..- I ·'
C..
~
PItQ()F; The mlddIe inequalities folkN from P~tion 3.7.6; the tiM and lui. from Proposition 3. U. 0
S.7.12 LeI A, 8 ". _ diJjoim ,~u oJO ,110\ lllal ,,'CA) < +00, J" ( 8 ) < +00, IIn.d Id C ". Ihti. union. Thtl'l PI"O~ilion
" , (C) - 1', ( 11.) - " , (8 ) :!: ,,' (A) + 1" (8) - J"(C) . PII:OQF: Fin
/1'"' - /1'0,", +/
-
/ J I A,d;<
JI",d" - / JI AtflB,d"
..
/ JIA",,,,dp. S ,,( A.
n 80 ).
". (e) :!: ,,(A. n 80) .. ,,(A, ) + ,,( 8, ) - ,,(A, U 8,, ) :5 ,,' (11.) + ,,' {B ) - ,,' (C).
,,,,,,,raj
We """ ~ to lhe cue, &ad ~ A" 8 , be t .... intqrablo ouboeu 01. A , 8 tf!IIp
" . t(A - A,)U(B - B, II:5 I" { A - 11. ,)+,,' (8 - 8, ) - ,,' 1(11. - A,) U( 8 - B, )).
So, " . (A u B ) .. ". [(11. - A,) U (8 - 8 ,)) +,,(A,) + ,,(8 ,) "" Propooillo.. 3.7.6. and
,,' [{A - A, ) u (8 - 8 ,)) + ,,(A,) + ,,(8 ,) .. ,,' (A U 8 ). Tbudu,~,
.II. (C) - .11 ,(11. ) - 1', (8 ) :!: !.II'CA) - .II,CA))
+ !..II' (8 ) -
.11, (8 )1 + " . ( 04. ) + " . (8 ) - .II' (C).
" , (e ) - 1', ( 04. ) - " , {B) :5 ,,'(A ) + ,,'(8 ) - ". (C).
o
76
3.
In~
aDd M_llfabie Func. io""
Theo..,m 3.1.2 A ~""·,,rv 4nd ~t O>IIdltitm 1h4l4 ,!dI",t A 1>/0 lI< ",.~e to rJ\4I it opIU "," ( i.e. , ,,' C B) _ ,,"CA nB) + ,,' (..1' n B ) for all I1ibKtl B 1>/ 0 ). PROOP, 5uppooe A is I""meatluro.ble. and let B bol an a.tbitrary fUb6eI of {}. We &Irsdy know ,hal ,,-(B) ~ ,,- (An B ) + ",- ( A'n B ). If ,,-(8 ) is finite, .... lei. B, bol an intepable ... oonWninj!: B IIUCh tlul.! ,,-(B) = ,,(8,). Then ,,-( B ) .. ,,(8,) .. ",(A n B, ) + ,,( ..Ie n 8, )
2: ,,- (A n B ) + ,,' (..Ie n 8),
,,-(8 ) "'" ,,-( A n 8 ) + ,,-( A' n B }. eon," ..... ly. IUPII"'" that ","(8) '" ,," (A n 8 ) + ,,"l A' n 8 ) £Or $II integrable 90ts B. Put I = Is and 9 ~ I Ans. 5i""" "U) = ,,-(g) + ,,'U - gl, .... """ that 9 Ie Inte&;rablo! (P ropooilioo 3. 7.8). Henoe A is "·""",,,urM>Io,. 0 go
Dell,,[tion 3.1.4 A fW>C\ion I from {} inu. R is qu"';.integmble Cwith reapect t<> "I if and only If It is ",·"""",,,,,,ble and ,,"U ) .. ",(f). In thiol <:aile, .... put
"U) - ,,'U) .. ,,_(fl ·
This implies lha, is Snite.
I
ioI inte&Jehle if and only if it is ql>11$i-integrable and ,.(1)
ProjXlBltion 3.7. t 3 J.d.1. g lI< t_ 'l"blc '~n(;~ /rom fI.nto R , ~"" '"PP:>''' lloa/ ... (fl ... ,,(g) ma.tu KfU<. Tht:n 1 +9 ,. d.{irwrl <>.I"""" e...... Dkrc, .. quUt.""ttgrUk, lind I'(f + g) -1I(1l + 11(9) ·
P ROOF: Fi$, . ..""'" that "CIl is finite. T ho)n 'upp(IOifc that I t.akroI on tini.., v&I.-. Furth""
I
,,_U+g) '" ,up{ ,,(t l: t s l+g, _ IUp{JI(f + h) : h S g.
is inte«mble , and ...., """1
kinteg' able) h ~,able)
.. I'U) + ",(g),
-
and o.Imllady ,,' (f
+ gl
=
"'U) + " ' ($I), "" I + 9 if quasi-int
in thie
N.,xt, _moe that ,,_ (f) .. +00 _ " . (g). The", e:o:ist inle&n'bIt funel iorl$ /o ,!Jt I""h lhal I, S /, !Jt S g, and lhal ,,(/0) and ,,(g,) ....., atbitmrily I-. We haw. I ~ - 0<) Le. and 9 ~ - 0<) a.e. Henl:k /tmct;(m I , s l Im.!t <>~ "Ilk nllrnbtn ",'(/") 4"" I'-U-) .. {itUt~. "M 1I (f) = ,..- (/" ) - 11-(1-) _l~, kl I lI< G ftuw:ti<m Jrnm {} 'nll> R. ,...ma."....w. aM I"""""'"'u, mch /hat I.ouI """ <>1 the .. umber. ,,-(r) ",..I ,.."(1 -) it {iniu; 11= I ..
P ro»Ollltlon 3.7. 14
0'
qooui.;II~.
F()r"
c",,·
P ROOf: Fif«, SUJ)pOle thai. I ill quui-io~. If pCIl II finite, then I iII~ , p' (r ) ....J "'.(1- ) ..... finlte, ....J ", (I) .. ",(1+) _ p(l - ). [f p, (1l - +00, there erist.s an inuvabk function , < I : iii..... :s , -. ...., uoe ",' (1- ) < +00, whet, p. (r ) 2: 1'.(1) _ +00. If ",' (Il- -00, then ",' (r) Is finite, but 1' , (1-) 2: p,(-Il- - ",' (Il - +00. N_h" I be .. in tbe --.d ' w :,tion. We Pf<'V'I! that I Is quui-in~ First. suppa.: that I Is pooitioe....J bounded. If ( A.. ).~, II an 1.... 0: 11 Inc.tf
r
ru"""""
1',(1). We _ pMI to l be ~ <:Me. We .....y """"""" thaI p'(r) illinlte. 10 that / - Is intqrable. By tbe ab<we arwwnmt, II quul.~, and P".p";lion 7.13 ~ that /_ Is qllMi--in\qrablo and lbat p(ll '"'
r - /-
r
p' (r ) - 1"(1-).
[]
Corollary LeI" C II k p.~ ~nd 1J·",o,1:e Ie. 171m ,..(A. ) _ p' {A ), ~nd p' ( A.) _ ,.' (B) + ,.. (A - 8 1 br 011 ....mil 8 0/ A .
PROOf": ,.. (Al .. ",' ( A ) by PtopoeitKlo> 3.7.14. Then ,. ' (Al .. p' (8)
+ ,. , (A _ 8 J
o U A il .. p-......unbIo lei. ... hlcb .. DOl p-IlIod", .te. II iI p , (A ) -;. ,.' (A) (tee ChapW" 7, Exe"iot: 'j.
-'bIe lhat
Loom .... 3. 7.1 LeI D k a """""'" ...1 in ~ .....J toc:aIlr am"",,, 'po« F. ~nd leI op III! • """""'" II""'~ "" D (.wo. u..t OP('u+ (I - ' ), ) :S "·OP(r)+ (I - ')·op(l ) J.... r , • E D ~mI 0 :5: , :5: I) . LeI L III! 1M. cl.au 0/ r:tmti" .... u afJinr; foptcfio'ru "41 "" F AId! IMt "41/ D :S ",. II D ... d40tJ .mI op t.".,..,. otmiamIinllOu, /.VII op ,,1M. ~ en~ {"4I/ D : ... E L} . 17w: ... me......u Joo/h if D .nd op CIIntin.......
'I,
,,<tpen
P JIOOf : Lot rburbitr&1)' In D, and lei a be. real numbe,..ucb tIw.. < op(rl. Put A _ ((I , I) E D" R : I 2: op(.» if D ill &72 1 and ",!own ~jnuoue, and put A _ H",I) E DJ< R : I > op(l)-op(,)+ a) if D iIIopenandop COOItInuoue. In tM 11m. cue .4 ill .. c...cl ..,.,vex lei. in F J< R , and in tbe teCO<>d cue il Is an open """""'" au'-!. of F J< R. B, the Hahn- Ban.ocb IIdritlu, then! F J< R .c~ byperpIane ~ (r, " ) ",hlcb doeI not mM,t, DameIy H .. {(I,I): ..(1)+.1.1 _ oJ, .. t...-e .. ill. tonIi""""" Ii_form 011 F and.\, 0 ..... t..o real numben. In fan, H .. ((I,!): u(1 - II) +),(t_ Il) _ 0) ,
""".In
beca""" it coot.lns ( ~, a)_ Now .I.
t- 0, becalJlie u.,
~ OO!
he ih H . Therefore, rq>Iacing ~ by .. /(- .1.), .." ""'Y 8Upp IhM H ~ {(.,I) € F x R ; ..(z - ,) ~ 1 - 01_ Si nce u (~) - "'(,) < ..(V) - .... "''I: ha"" .. (~) - \PI%) < ..(V) - 0 foo- e>"I:ry • E D, or " (1 -~) + a < .,:>( z ), ..·bich P"""" the lernml>. 0 T~m
3.7.3 (Jel'l$en', Inequality) A ..""", lMt ,,"(r!) '"' i. Lei F l>< II4dIIJICO', D " COnlinKOU, r.\.~ f Idp I>u it> D, 1''' I is qtoIl.I" ".~, and
""n..,.,
" .....z
f
PIlO(>P: In the Iir$t (till, "'" koo>w that I"" ~ .. ih D (Propooilion 3.6.4) . In the fIOODI)nd C88C, "" P E l7'. The", eo:isU ... <:<>nUnuous linear fonn u Q " r", lOll \I € D. T hen u(/ Idl' ) - n 0 1- n )dl' > 0, $0 /d" t-- p. Thio; p"-""'l6 lhat / I"" I.,.
f
/e..
\0 D.
!.em,,,,,
N<., in On<'! ~ or lhe other, witb l he ..."", oot&I;ion as ill 3.7. I, ~(J IdI'l " f (of>o / }dp S /.1",0 I}. 0
3.8 Atoms LeI. p be ... Daruelll'J>eMIIIe 011 ... 8fMOOI' n (O, C).
Definitio n 3.8.1 A ".ln~ ... bk oet A isa".atomlrV ,,( A) > O."d j f V ,,(B ) is "'lUIII either to V 1'(,1) or to 0 foT """'Y ".in~bIe ,ubeet n of A.
Vp(A ) -11'(,1)1 for
A, by Tboorem 3.3.2. Defj"" all equivalence relalion on lhe class C of atoms as foIlcJws: A , _ A, jf and 001)' if I .. , ~ I .. , a i _ -.ywbere. Oboe,,,,, that, if A" A, lie in C, tben ";I!>er A , n A, is oql.WbIt 0' A, _ .-4.,. LeI. " bt lbe canorucal ,nappillg from C ooto the qllOtient 11*00 C/ _ _ eve<)' uom
Pro""",itioD 3.8.1 11 E ;, an inl~.d and CIi: tho cI4.u 01 1h-oJ. "tor>u u'liGh "'" c:ontoined;" E, th .... ~C-'!' ) it 01 m.»1 c:ourUabk. PROOF; For 1'\"'1')' n 2: 1, let C. be the -""" of tho8e A € C" ouch tbat V,,(A) > (1/( n + I)). VI'!£). Assume that ~c..) hall n+ I ru.tinct ~ ~Al) •. . . , ~A"I) for,."". i~ n 2: I . Thet> A, n A, is nqligihk too diMil>CI i. j , $0 V"IA, U ___ u A• ., ) _ L,<.<e+' V,, (A.;) by the indusior>exclusion formula., w~ V,, (A , U ... U A~ ~-,) > V ,,(£ ), B ront raliictioD.
3.8 'n"","
Itenoe p(c,.) has at _
.. elements, £Or
~
n
o
PT-opOaltlon 3.8.1 S~PPO'" I' i6""'. ul E ~ An inl~ ..,1 _inillf no o>I<>m. n.... {p(F ): F i~ .ndIul oJ E) U A"""'''''''' ilLkrNl in R.
e-
PltOOv: Let f:+, be ... in Propooition 3.3.1. O~ that Vp(F) .. p(F ) ( ..... poUi¥tly, Vp(F ) .. - p(F ») for all intqrable oubooeu F of 6+ ('&J*'" tively. of e-). by ~ 3.3.2. It we can J>Rl'I'" that the Proposition boIdri for £+ and £:- , tben ..... conclude that (p(F ): F imqn.bIe, F C £} .. [p(£:- ), p(6+ )J. be. it sum10 consider tbe <:Me in whlr.b peE ) > 0 and p(F ) O. .... can Sod an integrable I nbed A of E llIdt that 0 < pI A) S r. Let ,. be the suP"'munt of the peA), ... here A e> Inttsrable ,ubeets of E ,...eh that p(A ,) S ,. and p(A. ) S T, tben ,,(A , U A.) < (J, and"" ,,( A, U A,) S T. Coo ,. 4uoently, there Ie an 'iq ill:lquen<:e ( A.. ).;:, of in~ IUt-u aI E ouch that pI A,,) a>D'''rgeo to T ..... _ +00. If _ put A .. U" ,A• • then pIA) ., T. N"", tbere e> T. which a>nI..-.dicu the dmllition 01 T. He""" T > fJ/2. Now. if io an illlqrable 5Ut-t of e ouch that p(C) S (J. then p(e) S T. So pC£ - C) > {J - T. and (by tbe p •.,.;.ed!ng argument) tbHe " an in~able subed 0 aI E - e for whid> «(J - T)f2 S 1'(0) S (J - T. from the fact that _ h&voe p(e U OJ S 1. and ,,(C) + fP - 1)/2 S 1. Hence 1, which proves Ih&t 1 .. (J.
n.e..
,,>(:..
e
ot:!
of
P~ltlon
n. -
;::;'~~:':i;':"'~ 1/2"_'~::r~~, ", ~ . ,"'1""'* ;~ that
construct an
3.8.3 Ld / hi! 0
n.... f ;, ......t4n1
- 1/ 2"+' ), _
mopping frt>m otom A .
p ,~
A.e. in
~
{}
irIlQ A ~ttU-
80
3.
I~
&r>d M ....... o.ble F\inctioDo
P ItOOF; I .. 1M limll, a.e. in A. of a o;e<jUffiOl! (/. ). ~, of 'iiIA.simple mappinp. Since It is lUI alom, eo.ch , . is OOnMant a.e. in It. and there cxistt .. rqli&ibll: lUb8et N. of A sud! t .... t I . t.e.ke!l the oonsta,u ,ruue~. on It _ N. _ ~ N be a ntFigibit ~bo!et of It OOO1a;niog ali 1M N., sud> lhat (f").~ , con'''rplIlo I on A-N. For all z € A- N, t he 8eqUffiOl! (f.(:t)).l!:' ., (""),,<:' COD>(' &a 10 I (z ), and 10 I ie tOOSUnl on It - N 0
DeHn llio n :1.8.2 p. ;.. Ii&ld 10 boo dilf_ if il has no 1IWmII. ,. atomic if <:ech inl~ fit! .hid! ie not negligible oontail'lR an
.. oaid
10 M
atnm-
T """""m :1.8.1 S~pp<)It. p. ;, "'''''''''" / .. """"r Ih4t Q ",apping from n In.to a IIldri.tMtc qeoo lie ,..-.IOrCIbk. il;, """"......, aM ~ tJI~1 i.I _ _ ~ OCI ..... nl ~ ,,"f. in fad> G~. I ·.w,. - EJ("I" I I"dV,. Ivr "" ",..a>.:>... I /rom n hit" (0.+001 • ..nere P(A) emndo ~ tJ.t H I F 01 dmu ,,/0./......· f Idp. - EI'I"Jf II,,~ lor ~ tlHnti..Jl, p.-'nl<"gnlWe m4""'ng
r
from n in.lo
•
PROO .... Ltt
I he
r
&.....:.11 "....,..
a mappi,,& from fI int(l a metri ... ble a).'llOe . ond ,uPJ>(IIIe IhM I .. _lUll a.e. !n <:ech alllm. Fix an intqrtt.b&e .... C • ."d Id (.t.)l<;/ be a fatnil)' of atoms _iDOd in E, sud> Illal each alOm contained In £ ie equioalcnt to oat ond only (lDIl Ai . n,., $et £ - U o A.. OOlllai ... "" &lOt """'1 j E I, thmo ;"" nestillible ou!.e\ N. of A. sud! Illal I II oo:JSWot oro At - N,. Now Jet; N boo a ,Itglisible suboolt. of E, oonWning E A" No, a Dd U'';)Eh/ .,,.J A, n A,. elcwly, I 19 the
U.E/
lhE,
limit 01> E - N of • ""'1_ of iiI £ -almp\c mappillf\l, which
II
~"-n.bio.
Now 18
I
be a fUDdion from fI inlll
r
l·dV,.S
"",,-eo
lhat. I
iO. +001· Then
L I'I"I~'
r
11,, ·dVp.
e""Y ..hen: lor <:ech illl~ oct £ (F " ie IM,a of ~I "'E" of u.:.. &t.om8 t hBl an: coma;nod in E ). S<:.PP'*' tllal I ill ~_un.ble and ... niobftl outAde a ~....,..urable aDd ~moden.IU,,1; E. Then I ·.w,. - EI'I"IV". II"eN" by Beppo l..,.,.i',
t-:.. . I I. S [;1'1""". I I" a1,OOIiC
f'
r
r I · dV,. - EI'I"w, r I I" . dV,.. _u"'" r I· dV,. < +00. n..:n. kor > O. then: eo:;sU , E:r """" that 9
HI!fII:e
I~
~ f
aDd
~
which P"""'" Illat
r I ' dV,.
".measurable.
r I· dVp +00. Thm! E.1ICIt I . II.
No. "U~ tlLat p.~rau,
[
tel
lP.XiIu a I'.meuurable and loo:aUy dmoet ~here.. So
<:
thac.
L
1·dVI' . j' fl. · dVI'i?
oIA}ET
We ILave thel tfole pio.eo:! that
I : rl_ 10, +001·
r I . dV
j'11"" •. .w"
..r
• L,.,. j'IIA 'dV" . I' • EoIA)€!"
I1A . dV" for e>e.,
Fin.tJly. lot I he .... _tiaUy "'[D~ n1&PP;"II; from rllnu. & ~ ope<-, and let E be a p·meaourable and p·rnodcrate ~ ouch ,hac. I " II. loo:aUy oJmoK e->E'1where. Idp .. ! II.dp .. LoIA)ET.! IIAdp .. EoIA)ET! I IAdp by the domi ...,ed con'dlE"'" 'beorem. C
Then!
3.9
Prolongations of IJ.
on a ouniri", Sinn. and " iI the ~.-c funn I ..... ! IdA Oti SI(S,C). tben we put I . C io. q ....... meaoure. and be"", If A is a
n..
10 a
I'
r
"PiS"'"
pa " " " , , , by
r
r
r
TlW!ooC'D 3.3.2. M"''''' ..... , VjJ.(A ) .. f lAdVp For all A e ii.
DfIflnltlon 3.9.1 jJ. It called tbe maln prOlooptiott of p.
r
r
Theorem 309.1 I · ping '""" rl iiilo .. mc/1"iz4hle Ipoot to p.~ if ani, if il to jJ. .........1It"CIbk.
0""
P I\OOP : [f (§,.).l!1 Ie an i...... . I'i"ll; Ieq........ In sl+{ii) and g . ruP.l!'f".
r g · dVjJ. . "Up..! f" · dVl<" ouP.!,. · dV" • r g. dV/,- ThiI.oo... ,bat. r f· 10,+00]. For tbe """'... inequality. ot.erve that every , e :J. r ,. dV < +00 IIertce is , ,,, uwoer of an I";", In t'-
ltld:llhac.
io
I'-I~~,
and
r
~Iope
ilw;>
r, ·
I'
Ieq''''''''
sl+ (ii) {P'oprow
,,,,-, r r
r r
cru.) of .1'~u.). C~u.) Is tM d06U .... of 51(ft. F) in .1'}(P); thOlS C}u.) -
C,(P). The li_!%1.t.p(linp f - f f "" and f - f f dj. from C~(,, ) inlO F. "'hid> are (OntinUOUil and "'~ OIl St(R . F), are ,n f..,t ilkntical_ a
Now, £or A E 'R:, V,,(A) "" fUP( A,) 4J I,,( A; )I, (A.loe l rMging 0W;r the elM! of finile .... rtitionl o f A inlO ~ [ndfled. ""'ry E e 'if io _ un;"n of an inl~.et and _locally ~;gIbIe.et . n.. ... ro.-.,. p : A - f IA<4< io" m '75 'reOll~. and Vj.(A ) _ flAdV" for "II A e'll Definition 3.D. 2 P lo! c· 11ed lbe -..11&1 ptOionptN>n of ".
r
Tbeorem 3.9.2 I· dV,. ... 1'1' dVl' lor ~ /undW>" I {rom n .nto jO,+CCl). C~(Ii) - 4(1') {k._ is r. ........ ~robok if aowl <'fIIr if i l "I'·-"rsbk.
- lid"
r
be a fwx:&ion from n llllo 10. +00). By tbe definition of I ·d\" il and 1'1 .
I
r
r r
r
l'
l'
r
r
l'
r
r
l·dVr. - J ' / IA·d\"Ii - J ' f'A ·dV,.. .. J ' flA -dV"
~ rl'
r
11Iio """""" that f . dV p .. f . dV". If F io a Banacb "*",, t!>en '~(ii) -l}u.) by the _ 01 Tbeorern J.9.1. n.. ",malnl", . " alono are oIw~
Pro~ltlon 3.9 .1 (. - ,., to - r., !'ROOt",
~
~ment .. that
a
;: - li. an4{o - r..
facti are immedio.le from Tl>tor-emIIl.9.1 &nd 3.9.2.
a
Of particular I n _ is the foliowin,s problem. Oi"", a rneas=e 1'4 on a ... in n , ",!>en ill it true thal,. _ fl. (resp«t;""ly. r. = r.. )1 A panial ill Ii- in P,OpOeitioool 3_9_2 and 3.9_3_
~ &I ........
Pl'OpOOIltlon 3.11.2 u! 41 III! a .oemir'ing of uunl;"U~ ".irlt.,..,blo ..u. and
•
3_9 P.. J. • •pt.... 01 p
ttl
«I A c {} Utou tr.oe A n E On E E . .. llull /oQ:Jl~ p.n~•.
,,~.
E ..
/oQ:Jlr p-~ lor
83
ewr)'
ne..lbCJ'+ ) c lbtJi); ~, f I ,dVjJ• .. f l ·dVjJ ~nd f I~ .. f l · rIp lor..u I E 4:u..). Ftn4l1" p" .. ji. II (and onl. if) mdll«allr p.~ «I
it I«allr JJ+ -~
PROOf": Since SIt •. C ) it dme. In ChljJ ). the
aJ!Umtflt .. I"'-t of P~l ion 3.3,5 and Theo ... ,n 3.3.2 &i- VJJ+ ( E) .. f 1,,·dVjJ lor all E E • . Tbm "' ·dV jJ .. lI ·dV JJ+ ror all upper "' I"eiops It of ."" rine ""'I'''''''''"' ito 51'· (. ), and eo I · dVjJ ~ I · dVjJ. lor all fuoc\iooI I from {} Uno (0, +<><>]. W" COIIdude ,,,,-, 4 (JJ+ ) c li::tJi). and ,1141. f I ·dV /J+ .. fl ' dVjJ and f IrIp . .. Idj.I for all I E 4u..)· If .. _ A io IoeaIly jJ+'''''IIi«i ble, itl If""" A n E an ~ E E . io locally ~necli&ihle, eo A it locally jJ'~i&ible by IIypOlhee.is (b). lienee lhu..) c
r
rr
Arne
r
f
lbtJi).
To linilb l be proof, "'wo- tlw NCb locally jJ' ~i«ible"",- io locally /J+' ""IIiClbIe. If I t ' ....p to 4:v.), it "locally ~a1_ e .... ,.hen the Ulnil of .. Caudty ""'I";""'" (/.)-2;' in 51(. , C ) (which may be "'Pfded eilher .... . ubil*" of 4:CJ'+ ) or of lbv.)). T heo , rir>ee I " IDeally jJ+-aIn>O!it en'1wbm! lhe limil Dr (/. ). 2:" il belc>ngs to !h(/J+ ). 0
Propoeillon 3.11.3 U I • /or ~ oem;,;"g 01 p ·ink., W. Kto "nd k l jJ+ /or tJw. -.we E I,, · dIJ "" • . 5, , _ IIi4l SI (• . C ) it..:e.... in v.). n- £bCJ'+ ) c 4:v.); ~, f IdVJJ+ " fl ' dVjJ "nd f I~ " IdIJ /t)f' 0Il1 I E £hCJJ. )· Firn>JI" [J. .. ,.. if and oml. if eocA J' . ~ K' ..
f
£)"
JJ+-Mgl;gibk. PROOF: A""", III ill
P~tion
o
3.9.2.
The next. rerult . ttIOti ....t«l by Propo;::oait;on 3_9.3, deaIoo ... ith "",,,iI'inp 4o fur .,hicb St(. , C) io de_ in £h(jJ).
u,
_t.
,W.
PropGIIltlon 3.11.4 5 , • W 1000 ,tlJI' D/ jJ · ;nlL!§1 Kto, and lei • W W " . 1"ifIg ~ .,. ... 5_K III
PROOF: lei. V be tbe cloture of 51(. , C) ito £i,CJJ). Given A E • • defuIe T A 10 be tbe cia. at the 8 c A ... t.<.e indicator function I;"" in V . For _ry 8 ETA and for..-y € > 0, then eristI I E St +{. ) ouch 11141. !l" - I I· dVjJ 'S', and tht .. be ouch that 11.. _8 -( I .. - J) )· dV,. :5 t; l hilo ~ tlw 04 - 8
r
r
lies in TA _Similarly. if B" lJ., tore elw>ents o f T... lben: ""isl J.. h e Sf~ (.) $t>dI tlw li D, - /.1. dV" ~ t !'liQr \M!ry 1 :.::: i .,: 1, and then
r
r
11OIP( 18, . I.., ) - OUP(/L ./.11· dV p
:s: t .
wbich ~ 1M! B, U B, licoI in T... Finally. Jet ( B. ). ~I be an ;,..:>cni'l\! 1ItqUC>QII in T A, and. put B .. U.~18"; the...eq..eno:e (I";').~ I ron'~rpll.O Is in 4,{p), "" Is beionglI to V . N"", TA job. ".aIg<:bra in A.. ThiIo ........ thal. t hl! c'" of tboeo:.oo:U E c for which 16nA Ii ... in V for ~ A. E '" iI .. ".fine """'·'nil\! • . Now let £ e S and B E i .. in .be III.&l.eII>mt or t he proposition . Tbo:no io a ~ (04.1. 1: ' of d"'joint ~ "",h thlu 8 c u.~ , A. • . The funttioor>s :c ,~.:s" IA. " B I~ in V and. they Wi""", poinurige to 18 .. n _ +00. 1'1>0 _ _ _ ,g........ I~ then stto..'& IIw I s. &I>d benc:e I • • lies In V. FiDa.lty, t hat SI{S, C) c V and. V - 4 {P). D
n
obw;,..,
EurciIu for Chapter 9 I
<:00.""
If /I.<¥ 1M ........
2
""'I''''''''.
",r<: ""
1Al" boo .. pooi'ti ... 0an0ell .,. ' P 11(0 , C ). I.-:t ".1. ;,> he .. of i~tq:ro.bIo f~I>(t""" from rt In\o 10. +eeJ. ond lot I be .... iDlql'abIo fuooction m;- I'l _10. +j O
f /rI.,. .. n -
+DO, ___ that (/' ).~ I .....~ to
J iIt
~"he
.. pooi.i ... o..r.l.1I _""'.,.. 11(0 , C ). F .. reo! Bana.:h opoce. and .. ""'t_!~ Cj.y.) '--sine .1"...• ......,.,.her-o to / II In .c~ u.). S~_ .... ~ N,un )""'_ ~ N,(f) .. n _ +<:cI. Then _ ...... (In)"'" ....."" .. ~ I ,........ - . tot " ",.hM 11/.1-1/. - I II Sil l). (f.)..~,
3
Lot .. boo .. poei.i", [)o.o.~
I 5Fl' ''' on HC!}. C). Lot ( ... ).~,. (~).~l' (I. ).~, boo.Juoeo _ iD £'IJ.;ft). 5 ......... . ......'-'t "" fwlctioM ... b, _1"'pu:U~. _ """" t hM G. S I. S , aI_« .. o.l>at " . & ..." intogr&blo &ad tIW 4 . , "" to ...w &ad _p
.. n -+oo.
I.
i"
<10<1>"',' f ... J
r
.... ~ f . ldp. '"' 1$ C_ F...... '. Iomm.o). 0.,,11..,. .hM I .. In. ... ~ &ad ..... f 1.4" ...... to J Idp. .. n - +<><>. ~
l . P ....... IIIa.t. it lo. },.z, .... "'.. ,..,. to a \a tbel ~
4
J
,_bon>, s.._ f w".
I
ill . ... _
1_ E- c"'l).
_n o
tho .. (f.). ~ • ..,., ... ,..,.
Lot" ..... poeiU,. ""_jell m ' w .... _ H (n . C). Let (""). ~ I boo .. ,,",,""""'" or MI' I .. of n. Su_ thoro 10 .. _""""" ( B.. ).~, of diojoi .... """" tbot A. C B.. lor ~ n?:}. Prtwoo .hat ". ( U.~ l A. ) '"' L.~, ,,· (A. )
,.·_IlBbIo ....
&ad .1oM ". (Un!,
.t,.) '"' E.~, ".C..... ,·
F
.1("'. lor Ch'p''' 3
M
a,
5 I.-" 1>0; . . . . . fl... · ~ "' ''l oa "H(fl, C) ""'" lot 1; bo, ... lntqr.blo"",," SIoow lMI (P( 8 ) : B ....... &bIo. B e E ) io """'poo:t. ( _ ~"'" U .2).
t.;
'V'
ate
4 Lebesgue Measure on R
A. ,bIo pOi ... iI
--
uampkot.
o.:.a. ....
b,o,,, <1000 in ' "
..tuI to IDol! .. what..., will .., ",,,, ' ,,, ... .-it b ......,.
n. • • • obott,.,lo. ol'
4, 1
_.n!
5 1",,1>" ooioo. of. r<JoJ
tiatr<
' ""pIoo b
in
n....-.n-...
.....t \bf'O\lS ........110 I
of_ d.. ""'"
p'
,"
~ """"
.. III
4_'
bul III ~ .. 0 .,...... . "eo, .bon! (b
~,
. be ..... ' .... of "PMbcioslul" ...... I. 1*rtkW..-. ";"6
4.3 We _
p" fun<.'tioon _ _ \100 ..;.".... 01 • .-.. 8
, "H p'in&.
.. u",).
c.mo.. ......
Base-b Expansions of a Real Number
Ltt 6 ;> 1 bill." '''~~. and:z. . 1'1\&1 Dumber. For --*' In~ n 2: O. ~ p.. be !be pw.UWIllnlqrn" lUot !Ip,.. 1 . 6' · oS %. and "" T~_, r~. for '"'~ n ~ I, tbf: ""I"""" (T.},,~ lnaeas e' l(I z . FOr ...a, inl~ n ~ 1, put " . .. p., - bp". , . Sil>Qe !Ip.. , - 6- ' :!S :t .: 6(p" • • + 1)' 6, n, ..., ha,,, 0 "a 6 - 1. N_ T • .. PI> + '5' S_ ... hence Z .. l1li + L' ;!.I ... /b".
s:
.s
E
'V.
.s
.s
DdInitlon " , 1.1 With III)tatioOD. all -'vM. (po. (10. )'~ 1 1 "' called lbe propo:. ",po."';';" of % (wltb l&\ptd to the bMo 6).
•
( .1 HI ,: bE.""","""" 01 .. Real N"",,*
87
to, I, 2, ... ,~ -
I}. By ..,hat ~" h..,,, just shown, the function ..,: (9o.{ .... )~<:I) .... 90 + E.. , .... /IT. oends Z )( AN onto R. We wiU pM" that, if z e R is not of the ~ "/11' (with k E Z. " :> 0). It lllhe ima&e lII>doer .., of iUl .ole ptOpO:'t uPfol'Sioa. On the other hand. if .z 11M t he form k/ II' , we will tbow lhar. it ill lbe ima&e under.., of 1M) (kme~ ~y, ita plover ""p"noinn.oo aDOtMr exp" .... ion which we call improper. So let (90, ("~)"i!: ,) be such lhal z - 90 + L"i!:' ,-.. /11' .00. lor evuy iolCler Ir\ 2: 0, pul , _ .. till + L I<":5," " .. /1>". CleAtly, ,_ ~ .z ~ ,_ + 1/ ""' , .00 .z + I /~- un_ .... .. 1- I for any" > m. We ooociude lhat r ... '" ' .. 0< r ........ + 1/ 6- . lbe ,""uer equality holding ooly w!oeo " .. .. 6 - I for all i~ " > m. If the oumMr of in~1S n ::!: I .ud> IhaI. tI.. < b - I ill fmite, e.nd if Ir\ io t!oe .mallesl pOsiti ... integer such that ...... b - I for rI > m . t hen :r .. 911 + L ':5 " :5" .... /11' + I /b'" h.oo the form Itl b- (k E Z ). ThUl, if:r ill DOl. 01 1M form k/ ..... (till. ( .... ) .. i!: ,) is .... orily 1M 1"""'" ex.,.nsioo of :r. N_ IUppOot thal z h.oo the form k/II'. TIw: ... an: lwo P<*ibilila: P ut A ""
<._
I. " .. < b - I for infinitely """'lJ' indM::ei n. Then (911. [ .... ).. i!: ,) It tbe proper ""panoion of z .
2. " .. < 6 - I for only finitely many ioojcn rI. Tben ld m be ,he omall..11 ~iti ... intq<:r such WI tI.. .. b - I for rI > m, "" IhaI. " h.oo 1M form Itl b- (with k e Z). When m ::!: I. k io not divisibk by b. ThUll m It 1M omalleot of liIoR inlfFB m' ::!: 0 .ud> that :r has tM form t' / 6... • (t' E Z ). I..:t (p.o. (.... )..i!: ,) he the proper ""p" ...... of :r. If m _ 0, then Po ... 'III + I and ... ... 0 lot rI 2: I. On the <>CMr b&Dd, If m 2: I, tlw:a Po - till . .... _ .... lor l :in <m ..... _ tI.. + I. e.nd .... _ O lor n>m. In abort • ..,hen" hail the form It/ b" , it ill lhe I",. under.., of at most 1M) .",.",,",.00 In fOCI of eunly 1M) and OUt claim ill true. A real number.z h.oo a ~rminating ""panoion" (ruch that .... _ 0 lor rI Jarp CDOU&b) If and ooIy if II has lhe form It/ .... (n 2: O. It E Z ), and in that <:Me iUl t6minating e:xpansioo. ill lu plopo:'l upt.nlioa. Nen . «I", AN the lcrimgl"aphic ordering <:' < (",,) ,,<: , if ..", < "_ !or the omaIleot . m. 01 tiloR in~ .. n.ud> that .... i> tI.. ). T ben tM functioa G ; (.... ).. ~ , _ L~ i!: ' ",,/1>" from AN onto (0, I I iou . . f'urtba ......... for " . W IE ,,"" _Wylng" < " , lhe equalily G(,,) .. G (u) boIds if uod 0IlIy if II. " J«, ".pl>Cti~ly. the ",Opel tot.,.".;oo u>d the iJDptOpO:'t e:x.,.".;on of ........ .z eJO, Ifn B , where B .. {It/ II' ,n::!: I. "E Z}.
.let".",,".
«.... )..
Deflnlt ion 4. 1.2 When ~ ... 2 (,... pecti~y. b _ 3. ~ ... 10). the proper ~ 6 e:xpanSion of" iI called iu proper dyadic (I EE Ji
"'w
88
4.
~
M.aour. _ R
4.2 The Cantor Singular FUnction For aztr nooemp(y .ubintenall of R.
~ shall
denoc.e by .:0 (/ ) its left endpoint
aM by !l(1) i l 5 . endpOi."r,.. De/l1Ie, by inducl.... "" Il, • fam.ily {J...)... of mutually disjoim, ope" Lntel d •. as btlows. The ln~ " u.keo all poeitive ,...tuce; foe o:ach " 2: O. P taJu:. thf: .-at_ 1, 2, 3, ... All Int~ 1 are <:OQWned 10 10, II, and ..., laloe 10.0 _ JI / 3. 2/ 3]. Nat, . t.ppoiIC Ihf: r +' - 1 i~ I...... have been ~ forO S m S n, Ib 8UCh .....y thal. if J~ Ie tbeir uni<m. then 1<1, IlnJ: is thf: ......... ofr'" d J I,,~ K .... (';tb 1 :;; p $ r+ '), mutua.tlyd"'}olnt , all of lengtb 1/3'+'. and suet. lhal a (K •. ,) <: a(K• .• l <: .. . <: a (K. )"",o'). If K . .. _ la,bJ, then "" tab for 1.+, ... tIM: <>pen Interval. J.. + (1) - .. )/3, ~ - (1) -
,r ,
ft ...
.. )/31· OdInitlon "",2. 1 The complemenl K in I _10, IJ of 11M: unioa w tlle 1"-1 io c.lled the Oontor 110\. T hf: 1. ............ 11ed lbe iD«1"Yal!l Ulntilluoos to K .
Ltot ~ be ~ _un, "" I . S;""" ~I I - J.) _ (2/3)''' ' for eve7)" n 2: I , tbe Cantor set K ,. n..~{l l . ) III poneg!.igll*, bec.r:f: tottlty di'loxl~. If n. P ..... 1_ lntq<: ... JUc:b that n 2: 0 and I $ p $ '2"~'. II",,, '2"+' - P caro be "';11"" )',2' + ... + ....... ,2", ... be", A" ... , ....... , ..... uoiquely detennluM elemettU of {O,I). By Induct ion oa n , It is <:tI&ily shown lha,
-
(a) a(K"-I1 '" E ,s;. s .... Z( l - .l.t )/3· , (bl IfUl ~ Pi _ 21+1 - (A," + . . . +.IJ+'2") for ..U 0 S j $ n - I, lhea K .... c K • • ,. "
.1
C ·,· C K~.
Oo:note by • ,be function (z.).~, .... L .
ei..... In'
if 5 n 2: 0 atId 1 $ P $ '2""'. let ("" )'2: ' "" tbe proper lriadic: e>-...... inn ollt(K ...I. N"" let ("")' ~' he a pOint of B atId :r ito image under ~. In o.-der that", IN: In K .... II Io"i« pry and JU/Iiclf:n' lhat """ "r lho: IolIowiu& IIImo DDOd.iIIooo bold:
(al :r. _""
1or~ 1
$ /0 $ ,,+1 .
(b) Q( K~ ... ) '" 0 and ("" )..?I is i;s improper lriadic~.
(e) i1(K ",,) '" I aDd (:r. )o ~, is
il$ proper tri&dio: ""p&It$<m.
In the pArtiot:ula:r calle ,.~ (: to C is strictly it..., " Iill(l aDd ~C) is a>nlaiuM in K. C..,,,"( ,acly, let z E K . For ~ n 2: 0, ",rite.:o A lor t he ori&;in or the K .... (:()Otal~ill(l:l'. TWo .:oA'" - a"
.s
has tbe form t: •• 2/30+ 2 for alUiuble l:~~2 in {O. l }. whma! ... deduce that z liM in ~(C). Therefor., K '" V(C) has t he ~&rdin.oJity of t be cooUnllum. Now dmnte t.,o k \be tel. of \be P( KA . . ). If t: lies in k , thero iU impr~ tn.dic expanelon be' 00p 10 C. On tbe d if there eoiltllan intqer n ?: 0.1lCb that l: . '" 2 for all I: > n + 2, thero ¢( l:. ). ) '" P( K... ) fur a.uitable 1 S p S 2·+1; th..., it:. ila pnint of
K - k , thero
ill proper t n.dic ~~po.osion bekmp \ 0 C. F in.oJly, a nee
' '1
and IUfficlenl. condition that Z E K be tbe i""'«f' ~ ~ of two diotit><:t ~t..m.ntI of B iI that It be an ~Ddpoint of !lOme inl.erval COOti&uouo to K .
I "" 1M ,""",ion /rom K in.l .. [0. 1] nch !hoI I( t>((z. ). ») '" E.~, z, /2' +' I'" t>4dI (z, ), 01 c. ~ I ',LI" f!mt.tion
Propoo
leI
Jr- I
.n.te> I llllaico\ meMo I ond II n 2: 0, I ::; p::;2" ). g
"""'t,,"' ......... mch ,,.If:rwIf... (1IIWt
I
ilour.iec'ive and ;oc, ·i"3. The unlq ... poi .. (z . w) in K x K I ud> that z < 1/ and I (l: ) '" 1(, ) ate t be poin (o(l ..... ),P{I....J), wi. "i(( . . . deduee the e:ristence of g. CI
PlIOOf': ClearlY.
Definition 4.2.2 gil ca!1o:I the Cantor singular function.
om...
NOlI' Id (:r, ). be ... tle"",nl of 8 and :r '" "'((z. ). ). m .. tbe luprallum of u...e integen k 2: 0 such that l: , ..... z, ..", all even (m may be "'IuallO +00). It z lieo in 1 - K . and if ... put q '" E ,s:>s .. (", . / 2). 2"'- > + I , thero z belonp 10 I.... and g(l:) - / (11( /", .. whma! ... _ that
».
ThillMt equality il t tut even ... ben z; liel in K . He""" ... ha,'e obcained , be eoplicit ex pc . on of g(l:) for alll: E 1. Ob8crvo! that 9 iI equal to (2p-I)/2"'" 011 NCb f ..... Pro_Ilion 4.2.2 F", ~ n 2: O. plOl K. '" U,s.s,. *' K . .... .. nd IIIriU I K. "" tJw: indio>,.,.. 0/ K • .... ,. Atoo •• o' io. '" (3/2)'+ ' . I K.. tiM let '" be 1M "'n<:lion l: h,, (t )dt .. h,,1 1O..jds.< on /. ~ 1M "'nepq,.., g• .....P<1l'" ,mifannlr tI> II>~ C~nlM.o"f'l/
/t",,,"""
f:
I
PROOF: If", II; a pOint oIoome I..., (m > 0, 1 ::; p S 2"' ), thero g", ... (%) _ (2p - 1)/2.. .. ' lor all iOIelen I: ?: o.... {g..... - ", )("'l '" 0 for NCb int""", n ?: m. On tbe other haneI. if % iI a pOint 01 ....... K .... (n 2: O. 1 S P S 2"* '), thtrt "'(o(K.... S "'("') S ",(II( K .... whm<e ... dod..... IIw. ", (l:) &z>d, simiLarly. ", .. ,(z ) lie in rIP - 1)/2""". p/2"*'I. So I",.. , - ",1S 1/ 2"+' for all ;DIqe.. n ?: O.
ll
»,
"
.
CleArly, tbe limit of tbe ,.. ill ~ on ead> conootWrl component of
/ - K. N<>w let In ). be an e\o:menl. of C ~nd Z '" \!t( z. ). ). For any ill~ II
o
"'' 'l1lOIit
In slK:rt, , is com.io ....... Inc...... nl':, and has cieri_I", zero elIerywbere, &11<\ ytt ioi tbe. unibrm limit or lbe .b6oIuldy awlnUOUll ful>Cliono g._ By P"""",ition 12. U , 9 h-. deri .... li'" +00 &I. UOOClUlltably """'Y points
on
4.3
Example of a Nonmeasurable Set
For &oy ... boott E ol R and any mol numl:>er ... .." define E + .. as t be IOtt £ EI . Man "'......Ily, lor AI»'''''-I& E, For R , "'" let E + F be tbe....c ( z + __ ; Z £ E, r £ Fl. Fi....uy, we " 'riU, .I. to.: U:bo1Iiguo _ure on
('" + .. ,"
"P rovo-Ilion 4.S.1 lJ E ;., .. '\'·in~ . 0, IMn D(E ) . (z - ~: z ,1'£ E) u .. ~ ¢fO . P RODP"; For AI»' mol numl:>e< 0 <: .. <: 1, lbere iIIllIl ~ a.t U COI1I~ni~ E , suclt thGt .. - .I. ' (V) !: .I.(E} Ieee Theorem 6,1.1) . Then .I.(E n J) 2: .. ' .I.(J ) for &I. ~ _ cuonooo:tcd Q)a.p<>t>
1-
.l.( J)/2 , ),(J )/2(.
[J
PropoIIltlon 4.3 ,2 ~re to • ( """",_"",...) ..-..6Kl M of R ,tfch tII.1 .\,. (M n E) _ 0
./ "P ROOP: LeI. 9 he an i ...tioM! ~r, aOO let. 8 (rtllpo:octl""ly. C) be tbe...c of numbers ollM form II + 1118. wbett m € Z &lid n iIIllIl """" {.... pectiYl!l)i, odd} iIIt.,-, For eod> inl~; "ffI inlqff II; E Z such I,," 0 +;e <: 2; pul z; .. II; + ;e. N<>w, If Jill .. bo:>unded OpeD interval, lei. t € N he such that ),(J) 2: 2/ " : ~ lhe nultll;>en :r. , . .. ,Zt, theN: are &I. \e&et &11<\ :t) . Iud> Ihat "', - z,1is strictly Ieso IhaD 2/ t , and
:s ...
t,...,...,:t,
tben there exisu r E Z for ...·bicb r(I, - I, ) helon&o to J . Thil provts that B ill dtnoe in R. CleM!y, C .. B + I 11 also
-I.n<'gi~
I(t ..Aid. .. ""I a BImIII(/.
PJU)()F: LeI. ; be tbe func:tion lhat agreeo with the Cantor IiD&ular fUDCtion gon t .. (0.1) and that ilequal toOon ]- oo,O) and to I on !I,+oo[. The (Ooott function Il : :r .... (:r + j(:r})/2 ;. III.rictly i...... -inc on R; beDOe it ii_ ""'->"",philm, ... ith in....... Il-'. Sinoo -I(II{/" .. )) .. ~(I" .. )/2 lor all itLI."Fft" > 0 and I :S p:S 2". ~ _ that -1 (11(/- K)) .. 1/ 2. TI.e. dOLt, -I(II(K J) " 1/ 2, e-.~" thou&h the C..,tor eet K i1-1.nql~bIe. WIth notation loS in Propoeition 4.3.2. E .. h -' (AI n h{ K ») ;. -I."""i«\bIe, ,-""" it iI included In K , but ill ima«e M n h(K ) uno:Ier Ills not ~ measurable. Finally, E ;. not. ~I oet, '-"\lie h{E) ill not _ BlIreIIOt. C
Propoe.lt lon 4.3.4 Ld AI Ioe '" in I'topolili<>n , .j.t an
p( (M n Ed U (M< n Eo») ~ ~~"(E,) + ~ ~"(Eo) ~U,
ufinu a " ....u.m.e ,...d ..... p "" T ""'" Ih4I P(E) .. -I "(£) Ivr
tdlEe M . P ROOP : Si""" -I ' (M n E, ) .. -I' (Ed and -I' (.W n E,) .. Eo In M. the pr-,tion iI oIwiouf. Thull
.i. ;. not •
~'
(E,J lor all E" C
maximal extellllioo of ~.
1 Lot II be lhe functioD:r .... :r - ~ + 1/21 .... R, wbo<e (:r + 1/210 fu<>aion % .... ,(..,,) .... . d_ltuuly at -t. (2k + I )/(Zn) (witb k E Z ).
'VI
ale
4.
Lobftl!!"" M._"-", ...
R
SM..bat f : "6 _ E~, g(u)/n' .. ~1aI«l &10<1 that it .. n' .. ~icl>" _ 01 tho lot", (U + II/( ).» · 2. r.... ~ boo • p<>nI. oI.ho form (ll' + I )/(~' I. ADd 21 • in ........ 'e<mo: o ~ (Zk + I )/(~) (";th n
I.
0:..,
:::'!!:::l-.!}';1 ;}E;;;·}/(~..:!:.:~~n' ~ ~·/(8n·)· c...cl..da
l
lhat
1
i""""".
Le\ ~ > I b<."
I. !.ott % b<. """'" lope! t , ' b."pt.nOioo>. Show ,tat " .. . a!\oDaI if _ IH1iy if t lltte uiI. ;·"V" ...
~
bMW
p<,;..die.
3 p,..,.., , bu tho: C· ..... oi .....1aI "'''''''''' 9 iDd"""" • bijoction f""" K n (R - Q ) onI
(Q. l]n(R - Q )
(_~ ...
s_ ~ D(X") .. (,, -
I.
2).
• • ~ E K • • ~ K)
cooot.oJ .. 10. 11, _
' - ,tat
D(K)_ 1_1 . 1!. Oom-",.ho «>11<, ......
2.
5
II> """ 1 ""-th P , opoohloft 4 .3. 1.
01 Propooi.1ooo c.3.2. if G" .•. . G. are poi .... 01 A • • _ .... (U, ~ .""(L +0,) .. 0. 1 _ . An D(U' ~I ,,"(L .,. ... » 0>1>1 ..... 110 ",hoe< t.. ... - 0, (I :S i. j :S 1'). In
~ ~ioII
pol,,,. ....... . I.
Lot { ... ).~ , be an ~""""ion of.ho poiDto in A. I'U - " i ...... p ~ D. I"'t F. " U.~.(L+o. l. Silo-(F')'~ l <10<_ to .humpty_ bu.
,ha.
1I,a! l' (E n F.) .. ...·( E) 10< ""'fY .... _u,abIo _
""u1. in
E _ _'l' P ~ I.
.boo,"""
:I..
C-~
I.
Lot n be • _ _ and " • _ _ .... oemin"" in O. Ale». "" £ be • ".int.vo-blo "'" fuoct""" f...... n iOl<> R ........ hot fl.
,100
put
I wi,h Beppo Levi ',
_!.
10 ,..m.~ Fot '"""Y • > D. """'" tto "',..".,. 01 6 > 0 .""" 'h.aI., 10< o.lI _ohio """itlono (J' )' H of H. iaIt6 s-u oIltn&th ... than 6• I I~ c•. ,,(E n So ' . itIdoep< ..d"". ol It..
.... ...... I{
. ..... ol CO ill
)1
Jo.
w_" LobeoJ.... 01 Ihill .....11. 10
E •••
_u~ ...
r '{ JoJ)1
." in •.....,.J.
Ii ...... ,""",","
5 V Spaces
III .. '........ (J lf r.I!<)"·
A ~ f ....... 1 .. _ 10 be 1m (;'(,0) if tI>o p'" POL " 0( ab60. U hao IIw! .. ruct~ of • _ .poooe....d 1 _ N, (J) _ io . oemi-.., ..... " ~ I . V , whld> io I~ """'..... oJ. £' ..uh , _, 10 tho ...... ioo f _ ~
io. 8 8""", _ U> ~ I ). In , hIo ~ .....m ulef>d ...... of t be .....110 01 Soctio<> '-2 ( ..... ,L . . _ ) to.bceo _ T'be FiodIoe<- Rlon d .... ea I_ r "te_ of ~ I ) mq ""'(""-Io,ed. olio< ,ho .....Inated ........ ," • •Iow< I . . . .boo ..... oj ~Ir>d.""" n . . ' . hoof . ... 01 55: P'II'" ,"""'" In that 1\ oJ.,." _ I<> _ ..n tbr. tooIo of Be" 5 :~ _ _ tlw:<><J. jr&.& ,
,.t... ".
V.,.,
U
!D''''' _10m ~ """"" .....oJ ~,nd·""",tall"""l...JI\"" Fb< "''''mpioo. if,., *'"
I! , _ , / . t ,'",. to (0,+00» . ..... if I . 9 1_ funo\ ..... " " f} _ lhal N.{f ) aDd N,CtI) &aito., .bon N,{fg) :5 N.{I)N.(f) (P, ........... t.Ioo> &. 1.2). 'l"bo<>rom 1.1 ... ......· oli ..... ioo 01. Minlo:Nol<,', I--.litr. if I and ..... e- fuDc:t.iom oo tho duoJMy 01 U aod L' wbeA ,..., 9 .... ~ lhal it, .. ben 1/1' + I/ f _ I. If F io . &naeIo _ . azod" _ , .... <:<>fI,jupte, . ' - . 10< .......,. , EO L:"'v.). 1- {lrJl' io • <»nt;""""" ~noar ,o...""'·! on L~(I') ...nb ""'"" N.!, ) {1looonm ~l..5 . n.. .......... w will t.. doNIt .-itlt ill ' " ' - ' " IO• with 1/ ,
fT _
+-
*'"
ot ."" .....,.....
s..:uo.
U
n.. I>(Ilioa of " " " - " _ iD M "
~
s..
.boot..,..
9 "" io IDll"OdlOChl. Thio Ml
01 UDib"m . _
Tltio Ml,...y t..
_i,,,",, deo.Io ..n it ~DlfonaIy ''''"FabIo_.
,
5.1 Definition of V Spaces Lemma 5.1.1 I.el 0 , {J E)O, I( !(Ita/I. TIooo a~~ =:: 0<1 mol",.,...;.,... a , ~, "'7""Iilr hD/4ill9 if Gild omI~ if"" 6.
+ fib for
all PO""""
PllOOl': The inequality is oI:wiouo for G = 0 or 6 = O. "fherefore ,!RIppo101! thal. tbe funcliGn r _ ~ (rom /0, +«>( inl<) R. Then:ai$ta 0 <: G <: 6, and e E ,,",10( su
""""ide.
{JG"-'.
In ~hat foIlo.nos. lei. fl hoe • ""no:mpty 6d. and f-l _pace "H (fl, C ), which ",m initially be positi ....
~
Oaniell _ un: on B
PropoeJtlon 5. 1.1 I.et - 0 and 6 >- 0 noel> tN.J. af .. bg WoUmo ol _rv=.
'0 r
r
(r
r
r
r
A .. fdp. >- 0 ... d B '" gd" >- O. From the 1""'IUNlly (f I A)" . ul B'I =:: (of)/ A + (h)1 B , It folkrn that P ROOP: We m&y JUJ)p(l!Ie lhat
'f· r l' d" =:: ~ f· ' f·
AO .B'
fdp.+B
yd;J._o+ fJ _l ,
wben<:o: the de!ired Inequality. When, ..odition&lly. / and g an: ,,-me&IIurablc, 1M «iua!It:y boIds if and only If
that is. if and only if
(!),, ·(:f - <>} + ~ oJ_~ry"lm. 01",
if and only if
/ 104 .. 1/ B .IO'!(JSI <mlrywbere
o
functlo ... I from fl into [0, + ooJ, .... put N, (I ) '" (1" I'd,, )" ' . For """'Y function / from fl into R, we ~ br Moo(fj lbe $mal\ollt of thoeol e E" J( such that I (r ) =:: c locally WoJIDOIIl; ~ben!, &ad .... put ",-(f ) .. - Moo (- I). F inaJly. '"" write N...(f ) for the smailf"ll. of tl>oole e E (0. + ooJ such that 1/ (" )1 =:: c loct.lly " ....Jrnoot eve.,...hcn:. 111"" """,(f ) =:: M.. (f ) and N,..(f ) _ M .. (l f l) when"" O.
For &II n:&I numl>en! p >-
(I and oJI
P ropoo!ltlon 5.1.2 If p , q, r ""' ill 10. +coJ, ...m IIuu 11r ~ III' + l/ q, a"d il / , I ""' 1_ ",..me", fr=o fl into jO,+oo( . 1IdI !hat N,( fl end N.(g) e,,"
finite, Ihtll N, (f,l) s: N~(f)N, (j). A n«:tua~ An 0, ~ > 0 -..dI IhiIt .. · f P " 60· t' p-"Imoot , " ~
... .
P ROOP: Fim , 5IIppooe that P &nd q are finitE. T hen
/r '
'11' ill<
s: (/' Pr4<)'" . (/' ,.dl<)'" s:
by Proposition 5. 1.1. Thuo N, (f9) N~(f)N, (9). Clw-ty. tho: latler inequalIty runa;". trut .. hen p" +00 CO" q _ +00. 0
s:
In particular . ;':,(f,l) N,(f)N, (g) ..hen P. q E 11.+001 ~ oonjupte (I.e. , INCh that IJp + IJq _ I ). Thio ill HOlder, i""'lua!ity.
n_
P .... paotJt lon 5. 1.3 1.<:111 ' (0. +001100 I<-~' " n
.....,(1) .
J s: J godl<
Igdv.
< M",, (f)'
f ' 11 _ R
J
grip
m .. (f)g{z ) s: I (z )g{z ) s: M.. (f)9(Z) . t...... e>'eT)'wl>e.., (when
Pl-opoooition ~
5. 1.~
Tho
$d f
1< '" 0), the ""ull is obviouI .
o
I be .. ,",,,d;,,,,, from 11 irlta (0. +oo( ""'io\ ;, ..... p _ 01 tilo,," p € jO,+oo] lor ""'kA N~(f) if /i"iu. u either
1.<:1
_jOt, or".. ~ o/li., anJ. ""'til J .. U'lR ;, ~pf), I I p '''' qN~(f)
;, "".\lOU "'" ( I / p : p € J). N_ """"" IIw I u p. ~; th<-n !he fufLf;ti0"4 p "" N,(I ) u .-Im....... on lAc dwuro 1 011 ....tlllUpOCl tD ]0, +001. aNI it ;, i ...... eo li .. ~ in Ihc inleTior r 01 J ,.Jw. r ;, ..........pf)_
"'u.'" di/!.,
P ROOP, Lee. ~, , be \_ diMi",,! d ement! or J &nd IPt. 0 <: 1 < I be .. ~ nllIllber. Put I / p .. 1/ . + (1 - 1)/" "J"ben '" _ Ip/ r &nd tJ .. (1 - 1),/. wto.I I. By Propo:.ilion 5.1.1, f'~dp /'CI<)" . /' dl< )II, l hat ....
rr .
s: (r
(r
N,(I) < (N,(I ))" (N,(Il) '_', &nd k>g N~(f) S t· k>g N. (f)+ (l-I)-k>g N, (fl· Tbe. eloce. J is eitber empty or an !nr.......J of R. &nd the functioo I/p ....
los: (N.{t))
is con,""x on (I/ p : p € JI . Nut , 'U(>p(lllt that J ", oonempty and fix . € J. From / , _ I'/~ ' ill_ ....... N,.(1l (N.(m"' · N",,(flr..-· I/. for &11 -.I nwnbas p > '. &lid
s:
Ilmsup_ _ ,V, !!) S N""It). Henof!. If +00 1:>1:1<>"9
I.(>
1, J oont.i"" ",bi·
Ifarily ~ nwolle .... which prow!II tl.a.t I is an inte.voJ of 1'(. N(>W .U~ that J is not" pOint , and Let ~ be ill orI&In and , ito endpoint (r <: .:S; +00). At 1/1' - lor N~(J) is ~ on (I/,. , p E J). p .... N~(J) is ronlinUOUll on Ir .•!. Put A _ (% En: l Iz ) ;:: I). Wbm P E J tends I.(> r, f'I A dee" : to r i ll and " I " . iDe.: 5! I to r 1" 0, ""/ l'IAdl' decreuee to /,I"dl' by lbe II>OIICItOnoI! t",""mn.oo / 'l". d" inc ..._ I.(> r IA' dp. Finally, tends \0 f I"dl' + 1... 4" /'dj.. which PfO\'f'II that lbe function ]l "" N,UI is c<>ntinUOUll at r (whenever r > 0). The 54ffiOI ~t...,..\uI for., if . < +<:C . Now _U"'"' +00 and leta be .. r +00, _ ha~ lim inr..... _ N,(J) 2: thal. N.. (I) 2: Um8Up,.-...., N,(I). .." c:onclud/: that 3
J
""" "'g'DOe J /'''''' r·
r r'
r
r
'hill, _
S"
p ....
N,tf);,;
con~nUOUtl.'
•
Finally, oul>P08" lbad' is DOlle"'",),. We I'f'O"" t hat P - f !'dp is inlinlUOly dilf....u iable 10 .r and 111&1 III n'~ den ..... is P - J /". kig" / - dp. P ul A _ (z En: 0 < J{TC) < I) and B _ lz E rI : I(z ) ~ 1) _ For a fixed I> e \c\ r. t be e\e ...""u of J.ucb that r < I> < t, and cIIooo;o. real number 6 > 0 eo t hat r < p _ 6 < p + 6 < •. Thf: fuoctionl! I _ It -Iog~ II from IO. I[ Into R and 1 .... 1- ·· w,g" 1 from [I.+oo[ into R an: bounded by """,,"e>O.Then
'i,"
r,
II .. ·
r ·1og"/1.. 11.. · r-··r .log" I I :5 c · r-··1.. :5 ,,/, 1..
1,, ·
r .log~ 1- I,,· r" -r' -log" 1 :5 c- r+' -1,,:5 " /' la.
eo Ir· k< I I :5 ,,/"1 .. +"I'la for all q satisfying r :5 q - 6 < q + 6 :5 doeIraI a>ndU!lion foI~ bjI tbe ll\andard ...... Ita 01> dilf. ",ntiation i~ sign (Theonlm 3.2.3).
•.
The tbe 0
"00.,
r;. I. ~ 5,,1'_ tMl r ind" ,. I. UII : rI - [0. +<:<>[ II< ,,~ tuu1 "<>I ~_ 11 J _ (I' E[O. +oo[: N~(f) < +-00) .. no .... CIIl>tr, ito infimum .. O. M"""",,,"r, Ihe ", ..dum p _ N,(f ) .. ir>t:muing en J,
P ropooition
Iog(f) .. ~inl S.d'., """ N,(1l ~"'"
IQ
up(
10.•[.
r In8(!)dp) ... " "I
O.
P ROOF: Let • E J aDd p E T1>en .,,, ""d . /(. ~ an: <:OI\juple upot>(llta, "" N,(f'I:5 N. /,(f'I N./C. _,)(1) and N,(!) :5 "'. (f). Thus. if J 10 not.. mpty, Ito infimum 10 0 and tbe function I> _ Np(f) illnc""";ng on J. Put A ,., ('" E n : 0 :5 / (>') < 1) and B,. ('" E rI : I (",)?: I). Foc every u of 10, +00[, (u' - 1)/1> deer : 7' ,," 10 log u as I> goeo to 0 in 10. +00[_11ldeed, fur r , • E +-oo[ oru
10,
u' - I
•
_
,/..•.
-
••
c'
ro ...•
~dll _ ( .. ' - 1)/ • . Now let • be in J . By tbe II>()Il(ltODe comco p'"ce LM<mm, I) / pdp con~rgea to fll Iot!;(f}d" M I' - 0 In 10,.)· On tbeodotr '-d. f AW -I)lpd" con~ to foIA .\otI(f)cf" (Pros»lillcn 3. 7.5). ThIM fW - I )/pd" <:OIl"'",,, 10 f\otl+(f)cf" Loc- (f)d;.1o((/)d;. (PulpO.;t;"D :).7.1 4). SiLlC'e log .... f,"/l / r)(, ncr Fio (1/ , ) .
llf(r -
r
r
IocN,(f) -
~ .\otI(! rd;J ) :!O ~(f rd" -
for all" €jO ••,...hlch Ieods 10 \otI(Lim N,(f»
-
~ \otI( N,(f)) s.
1) -
f /';
!
r
Iot!;(f)
aOO L; m, oN,!/) < ap{f 0log(f):p(p· flo& I· ....... ~ thu ~ ( rlolf/}d,,) _ lim_N,(f).
r
s.