1. Introduction The decoupling of lexis and syntax leads to the creation of a rubbish dump that is called ‘idiom’, ‘phraseology’, ‘collocation’, and the like. (Sinclair 1991:104) The following study will select some items of the linguistic ‘rubbish dump’ evoked by Sinclair in the above quotation, namely multi-word verbs, and assign them a somewhat more suitable place, perhaps the corridor connecting lexis and syntax. Multi-word verbs have in general received less than adequate treatment so far. Linguists dealing with purely lexical matters, for instance word-formation, have usually excluded them, ostensibly on the grounds that, seen from a formal perspective, they do not constitute ‘words’. But that exclusion seems arbitrary insofar as they constitute le xemes and are formed on the basis of regular patterns. Furthermore, it may lead to embarrassing contradictions, for instance the inclusion of phrasal nouns as opposed to the omission of phrasal verbs in works like Marchand’s (1969). Grammarians, for their part, have also mostly felt ill at ease with multi -word units; while these do have an internal syntactic structure, it is burdened with exceptions in many cases brought about by their lexeme status, so that a special treatment of them is made necessary. Most of all, multi-word verbs have hardly ever been treated as a group as such; rather, individual types are inserted here and there in grammars in many different sections (with the notable exception of Quirk et al. 1985), which makes them very hard to find . In general descriptions of the language they exist on the fringes — as rubbish dumps are of course wont to do. However, they have found a more comfortable shelter in their very own specialized dictionaries (such as Cowie & Mackin 1975), a kind of haven for ‘exotic’ verbs. And yet multi-word verbs are neither exotic nor at the fringes of the English language; rather, they are a part of the mainstream development. To quote Sinclair (1991:68) once more: "the whole drift of the historical devel opment of English has been towards the replacement of words with phrases (...)". I will therefore treat multi -word verbs in the present study as a group in their own right, with an emphasis on their common features, examining their development and behaviour in their authentic textual environments. The time and the basis I have chosen for this consideration is the non-literary prose of the late Early Modern English (EModE) era — that is, precisely the time, the place and the language important for the emergence of modern Standard English.
2
Introduction
Inevitably, the problem indicated in the first Sinclair quotation above will play an important role in this study. Both lexical, or rather semantic, and syntactic matters are intertwined in the case of multi -word verbs, and both will require more or less equal attention. The connection is so intricate, I find, that it would be unwise, if not impossible, to attempt a unified theoretical treatment with one of the two areas as the dominant basis. Accordingly, this will not be a theoretical piece of work, but one that will take an empirical and eclectic approach; my foremost aim is the description of what is there in late EModE. I will try to take a ccount of the fact that syntax and semantics merge to some extent in multi -word verbs. However, I take semantics to be the primary, and thus in some respect the more important level. After all, people who know how they are going to say something, before they know what it is they are going to say, must be considered a rare species. Multi-word verbs certainly originate mainly for semantic reasons — but these can be found just as well in the semantic properties of syntactic structures as purely in those of the individual words making up the complex verbal unit. In sum, my aims in this work are to throw some light on how syntax and semantics combine and also interact with more ‘peripheral’ linguistic areas, such as considerations of style or register, to produce a greater variety of expression in the English language. Moreover, this is foremost an historical study, and thus questions of the characteristics of multi -word verbs in EModE, their status within the language, and their development co mpared to the situation found in Present-day English (PDE) will of course be major concerns. The frequencies found and their rise or decline over time will be further important points, especially as two studies (Konishi 1958; Spasov 19661) have pointed to a decline of phrasal verbs within the period to be studied here. A new assessment of their results will be possible in the light of the more extensive data to be presented here (9,467 multi-word verbs, of which 4,266 are phrasal verbs). In general, it will also be interesting to see whether the frequencies of different kinds of multi -word verbs develop in similar ways. Furthermore, I will pay attention to EModE speakers’ awareness of and attitudes towards multi -word verbs, which might have a (positive or negative) influence on the development of these forms within the context of emerging prescriptivism and the standardization process. These matters will form the core of this work, comprising chapters 6 to 9. The chapters preceding these four will set the historical scene and provide the material required to put the empirical findings into their proper perspective. Three aspects play a role here. The first concerns the data base, 1
For information on Spasov 1966, a book that proved impossible to obtain, cf. Bolinger 1971 and Hückel 1968/69.
Introduction
3
the Lampeter Corpus of Early Modern English Tracts (1640-1740), and its historical context, as the nature of every corpus necessarily affects the resultant data (chapter 2). The second and third aspects relate to linguistic theories about multi-word verbs and my interpretation or application of them (chapters 3 and 4), and the whole history of multi-word verbs (chapter 5).
2. The Lampeter Corpus of Early Modern English Tracts Empirical research in historical linguistics is no simple matter. On the one hand, historical linguistics has actually always been corpus-based, in being orientated towards authentic language data preserved in old texts brought down to us — i.e. it is firmly based on empirical evidence. Of course, for most of the time there was no ‘corpus’ in the present strict sense of the word; real historical corpus linguistics only started with the publication of the Helsinki Corpus in 1991. Since then, there have been more attempts to supply historical linguistics with a firm basis of principled corpora, and the Lampeter Corpus is a contribution to this ongoing process, filling one slot with a collection of prose writings from 1640 to 1740. On the other hand, it is faced with difficulties not experienced by researchers into the present-day language. There is the inapplicability of modern linguistic intuition to old data; this, together with the absence of native speakers of, e.g., EModE, complicates judgements about the acceptability, the appropriateness or, in general, the exact nature and status of any instance found of a linguistic phenomenon. This fact either impedes or rules out completely the employment of some common methods in synchronic linguistics; this point will also have to be kept in mind for the chapters 3 and 4. Then, there is the finiteness of the data, both in an absolute, overall sense — there are only so many texts that have come down to us — and with respect to instances for individual features. From this it follows that there will necessarily be gaps in the existing data, with not all historically possible linguistic manifestations actually being documented. With regard to individual features this naturally means that one should be careful not to build major arguments on the basis of apparent nonoccurrence. Any historical study will inevitably touch on the question of linguistic change, and this also shows up some particular limitations of the available data. Samuels (1972:6) listed the following assumptions about linguistic change, namely: (a) the majority of linguistic changes originate in the spoken language, and may or may not ultimately spread to the written form, (b) fewer changes, usually of a different nature, arise in the written language, and may or may not be incorporated into the spoken language, and (c) the written language exerts a conservative influence, by preventing or slowing down the acceptance of many changes that come about in the spoken language. The problems are obvious: we do not have any first-hand record of the spoken language for older periods of the language, but can only work with approximations, such as court room transcripts, private letters and
The Lampeter Corpus
5
dramatic dialogue in stage plays. We cannot assume that all features found in the spoken medium are reflected in the written texts, and of those actually found we do not know how long they have already been in existence before eventually turning up in writing. It is also not easy for us to assess which of the phenomena we find in our data would have been regarded as particularly, or even exclusively typical of the written form. All these limitations on the data base for the historical study of the English language, needless to say, apply to the present corpus as well. Moreover, as Atkins, Clear & Ostler (1992:5) have so rightly remarked in general, any "corpus is inevitably biased in some respects", regardless of whether it is diachronic or synchronic. What might be of particular relevance in the present case is the absence of the spoken dimension, in the light of the fact that the phenomenon under discussion, multi-word verbs, has often been labelled as colloquial in modern English. The more one knows about a corpus, the easier it is to put data derived from it into the proper perspective. Also, the characteristics of a written language can only be adequately put into their proper perspective against the background of the interaction of the people using it and the uses of literacy in a given society (Traugott/Romaine 1985:14). Therefore the following two sections will be devoted to a description of the Lampeter Corpus and its historical setting. 2.1 General Characteristics of the Lampeter Corpus In brief, the Lampeter Corpus is a collection of non-literary prose covering the 100-year period from 1640 to 1740. Its basic structure is determined by its sub-division into ten decades with twelve complete texts each, bringing the whole corpus up to 120 texts and 1,172,102 words.1 Every decade in turn has an internal structure, containing two texts for each of the six domains of 2 RELIGION , POLITICS, ECONOMY , SCIENCE, LAW and MISCELLANEOUS . But let me now go through the corpus characteristics in more detail. As to the time chosen, it of course represents an important period in the standardization process of the English language, a time when the
1
The research for this study was carried out with a pre-publication form of the corpus - therefore all the word counts given here may vary somewhat from the final word counts of the published corpus. 2 The codes for the individual texts chosen in the corpus and used throughout this study to identify examples taken from the corpus derive from this basic structure. The codes consist of one of the abbreviations Rel, Pol, Ec, Sci, Law, and Msc for the domains, plus the letter A or B (two texts for each domain) and the date of publication, thereby identifying the decade, e.g. PolA1646, SciB1684.
6
The Lampeter Corpus
relatively inconspicuous selection and codification process was going on (Stein 1994:10), i.e. before codification became institutionalized in the grammars and dictionaries of the 18th century. The Lampeter Corpus period either follows or coincides with important linguistic processes, in particular the massive expansion of the lexicon leading to the Inkhorn Controversy (e.g. Nevalainen 1999; Baugh/Cable 1978) and the gradual regularisation of syntactic structure towards its modern standard (e.g. Rissanen 1999, Rydén 1979). Furthermore, the span of one hundred years, while not very long in itself, was considered sufficient for the purpose of studying linguistic change, covering, as it does, three generations. The limitation in period length was also thought sensible in order to provide somewhat greater depth (1,172,102 words for 100 years as opposed to, e.g., 551,0003 words in the Helsinki Corpus for the whole EModE period, 1500-1710) while still staying within manageable overall proportions. It is thus possible to treat the corpus either as a synchronic snap-shot of late EModE or as the basis for studying diachronic development within those 100 years. Both approaches will be applied in this study. Figure 2.1 shows the spread of data (word size) over the ten decades in the Lampeter Corpus. The exact extent of the chosen 100 years was also influenced by the basic material that had been chosen. The material basis was the Tract Collection stored in the Founders’ Library of the University of Wales, Lampeter (hence the name of the corpus) 4, which up to relatively recently allowed instant access to the original prints in its possession. Using these prints instead of later editions ensured the absolute authenticity of the material — a fact not to be underestimated 5 — and also brought to light texts that had not been edited or re-published since their first publication. The available material from which to choose in the collection was especially rich during in the period from 1640 to 1740, with the Civil War in the 1640s causing a first peak of publication figures (and changing the nature of public discourse for good (Feather 1988:50f)), followed by even higher outputs in the 1680s, 1700s and 1710s.6
3
The figure is taken from Kytö’s manual to the Helsinki Corpus (1991:2). For further information on the Tract Collection, cf. Harris & James (1974). 5 Editions, which are usually prepared by people from other fields of research, e.g. historians, are not necessarily very reliable with respect to purely linguistic matters. 6 After 1640, the printing industry expanded considerably with the publication of c. 1,000 titles a year in normal times, and up to c. 2,000 titles in moments of crisis or public hysteria, and also with increasing edition sizes (c.1,500 copies, but up to 3,000 copies in some cases) (Cressy 1980:47). 4
The Lampeter Corpus
1730 108,454 1720 words 123,048 9% words 10%
1640 126,099 words 11%
1710 102,740 words 9% 1700 101,714 words 9%
7
1650 96,456 words 8% 1660 102,233 words 9%
1690 126,148 words 11%
1680 150,457 words 13%
1670 134,753 words 11%
Figure 2.1 The decade structure of the Lampeter Corpus The decision as to which kind of texts to include in the corpus was also guided by the material found in Lampeter. As the name Tract Collection already suggests it consists of tracts, though primarily actually of pamphlets. The main OED definition of the latter runs as follows: A small treatise occupying fewer pages or sheets than would make a book, composed and ... (since c 1500) printed, and issued as a separate work; always (at least in later use) unbound, with or without paper covers. In a general sense used irrespective of subject (...), and in 17th c. including issues of single plays, romances, poems, novelettes, newspapers, news-letters, and other periodicals; still sometimes applied to chap-books, and the like; ... As the OED shows, the meaning of tract (s.v. tract n. 1) is in fact rather similar to this: 2. a. A book or written work treating of some particular topic; a treatise; a written or printed discourse or dissertation
8
The Lampeter Corpus 3. a. In later use: A short pamphlet on some religious, political, or other topic, suitable for distribution or for purposes of propaganda. [first quote for 3.a.: 1762]
This means that those two particular publication formats provide for a great variety of topics and text types or genres. 7 The subject matter of the pamphlets are often questions of intense and also controversial current interest, such as the assessment and call for assassination of Cromwell, a discussion or rather refutation of witchcraft, or the economic rivalry with the Dutch. On the other hand, there are also very ‘sober’, less contentious publications, such as Hooke’s scientific treatise on the motion of the earth, a rather dry treatment of the legal administration of land-ownership, or a lengthy exegetical tract on the biblical term ‘scandal’ — things one would not expect to appear in that format from the modern perspective. 8 As regards text types, there are such things as the inevitable sermons, political and legal speeches, court room transcripts, essays, lectures, ‘text-books’, satires etc. — as well as texts that elude any hard and fast classification. The corpus is intended to reflect this varied situation as far as possible, though with two exceptions. Any kind of literary output to be found among those pamphlets (cf. the OED definition above) was excluded from the collection; this also goes for the — perhaps not always quite so literary — output of the well-known literary figures of that period, such as Dryden, Defoe or Swift.9 The reasons behind this are that (a) the literary production of that time is relatively easily accessible at any rate, and it is also already represented in corpora (e.g. the Century of Prose Corpus), and (b) the Lampeter Corpus is instead supposed to represent the back-drop to this, the wide mainstream of written language production, so to speak. Literature and great writers, after all, can only be correctly assessed if seen in their own proper environment. 10 Newspaper material was also excluded, as this will be available in the ZEN (Zürich 7
Grabes (1990:viii) used a more restricted definition than the one adopted here in his study of the English pamphlet from 1521 to 1640, e.g. with restrictions as to the length (up to 50 pages), the domain (only religion and politics) and the necessity of being related to current affairs. In general, most people seem to think mainly of politics in connection with pamphlets, cf. also for instance Ahrens (1991). 8 For a list of all the texts contained in the corpus, see the corpus manual (forthc.). Cf. also for general interest the online catalogue of the Founders’ Library. 9 This decision reflects a distinctly modern perspective, however, for, as Sharpe & Zwicker (1987:1-20) point out in their introduction, the 17th century distinguished the literary and the fictitious much less clearly from other types of writing than we do today. Literature then could still be all things, and all things could be literature. 10 Also, as Warner (1961:80) remarked with respect to the historical study of style, a minor writer can perhaps reveal the characteristics of his age better than a major author.
The Lampeter Corpus
9
English Newspaper) and the Rostock Historical Newspaper corpora. To sum up this point, the variety assembled in the corpus should also ensure a diversity of linguistic structures, for instance in lexical range through the many different topics and areas treated, but also with regard to syntactic structures dominant or under-represented in one or the other genre or register. All the texts included in the corpus are complete texts, not samples of arbitrarily cut-out smaller text chunks found in most other corpora. They contain everything from the titlepage to the Finis, that is, in addition to the main text, also dedications, addresses (usually to the reader), introductions by publishers, and appendices with lists or other additional matter. It should not be ignored that this approach has its disadvantages: the varying length of individual texts (from 3,436 words to 24,042 words) can make compilation and the final corpus seem rather erratic, it can introduce strong biases if not enough care is taken, and it certainly complicates linguistic statistics. However, the great advantage of this method is that it makes text-linguistic and stylistic studies possible on a sensible level. In this way the corpus can far better reflect the uneven spread of linguistic features across the different manifestations of the language. The inclusion of complete texts was considered especially necessary, as prose style – and this is taken to include overall textual characteristics – seems to have undergone an extensive shift in the period in question here (cf. Jones 1951; Adolph 1668, 1981). It is also easier to identify the individual stylistic preferences of some authors and to make allowances for them if one is working within the context of whole texts. The inclusion of such material as dedications and addresses can also create interesting sociolinguistic perspectives. The decade structure of the corpus, which looked like a very simple thing in the beginning, proved to have its own particular problems as well. The frequency of later editions of texts that were found in the Tract Collection made it necessary to decide on the fact that it was not primarily the date of publication, but rather that of writing which was to count. This means texts suitable for inclusion needed to have been written in the same decade in which they were published, i.e. first editions as a rule. Later editions were included in some cases, but only if the text expressly stated that corrections, enlargements or the like had been carried out by the author. Only if the time line is kept ‘intact’ in that way is the study of linguistic change over the one hundred corpus years at all feasible. The question of authorship has already been touched on above when discussing the exclusion of literary writers. A special feature of the period in question is the high instance of anonymous publications, which are to be understood against the background of censorship laws (e.g. Feather 1988:85;
10
The Lampeter Corpus
Siebert 1965:passim), or rather of eluding them, and the harsh punishment of authors found guilty of libel throughout most of the period.11 Being such a typical characteristic of the press situation then, anonymous publications, as well as those only identified by the putative initials of the author, were not completely excluded from the corpus; however, given the fact that knowledge about the author can be (socio)-linguistically important, they were kept to a minimum. Thus, most authors are known by name, and background information could be found about most of them, though unfortunately not all. Each author is represented only once in the whole corpus. Texts originating with a corporate body (stated on the titlepage or the Lampeter library catalogue), such as the Commissioners of the Navy, the East India Company or the House of Lords, were also included; in contrast to truly anonymous publications their authorship is definitely restricted to a certain socio-economic circle of people. Given the text-linguistic and to a lesser extent sociolinguistic concerns connected with the compilation of the corpus, this was also to be reflected in the finished product with the help of SGML markup based on the TEI scheme, i.e. markup of individual features of the texts and a header with (background) information about the text and its author added to every text. I will not go into detail here about these matters 12, but the general aim of the markup was to make the original layout of the texts as retrievable as possible — in so far as linguistically relevant — from the electronic version. 13 2.2 The Lampeter Corpus as a Mirror of 17th- and 18th-century England It is in three respects especially that the Lampeter Corpus can be called a mirror of the political, cultural and social conditions of England in the 17th and 18th centuries. The first is found in the areas of life and topics covered by the texts, i.e. in general by the domain structure. The second is represented by the authors of the texts, their social spread, their education, their professions and their place in public life. The last has to do with the nature of public discourse at that time, that is on the one hand the situation
11
Cf. for instance the fate of the author of text LawB1649, who lost both his ears and was branded on the cheeks (cf. the header information) as punishment for publishing libellous texts. 12 For a detailed explanation of the markup, cf. the corpus manual (forthc.). For some further remarks about the header information, see below in 2.2. 13 Quotations from the corpus in this study will not contain any overt mark-up, and will reproduce the original typographical appearance of the textual instance only if necessary to the discussion.
The Lampeter Corpus
11
of ‘the press’ as such and on the other hand the characteristics of the reception process and of the audience. The domains RELIGION , POLITICS , ECONOMY , SCIENCE , LAW and MISCELLANEOUS are supposed to reflect as widely as possible the scope of life as found between 1640 and 1740.14 And in English and British history, this was a period of enormous importance and far-reaching consequences for the future of Great Britain. To deal adequately with that point would mean turning this study into a full-blown historical treatise which, needless to say, is completely out of place here. Thus I will restrict myself to those kind of remarks of immediate relevance to the corpus material. Religion and politics are intimately intertwined in the era in question, and this is reflected in the texts; many of them deal with both issues at once or with one of them under the guise of the other. In contrast to the modern perspective this would not then have been perceived as problematic, contradictory or even remarkable at all. Of course this was bound to cause problems for classification in the corpus; usually the predominant theme in a ‘mixed’ text would determine under which heading it went (this applies also to texts in the other domains), or, in some cases, text type would help determine the question: however political the content, a sermon will always be found under RELIGION in the corpus (e.g. RelA1696). Mixed texts in general seem to have been not uncommon then, as thinking was obviously less compartmentalized than it was to become later. Therefore, there has intentionally not been an attempt to generally avoid ‘mixed’ texts and opt only for ‘pure’ ones, as this would have distorted the historical situation. Any linguistic approach taking domains/registers or text types as its basic parameter will have to take account of this fact. The four issues that are important with respect to RELIGION are Anglicanism, Protestant Dissent, Catholicism (with all three always including their relationship to the political state) and the question of (passive) atheism. The last may seem surprising at first, but while this was a religious age, it must not be forgotten that it also was the Age of Reason. In fact, after the Toleration Act of 1689 a significant number of people attended no form of worship whatsoever, which was either a sign of outright atheism or simply of
14
A comparison of this classification, which was ‘imposed’ by the corpus compilers on the Founders’ Library’s Tract Collection rather than statistically derived from it, with Feather’s (1986) subject analysis of British 18th-century publishing shows that it is not wide off the mark. Although an exact comparison is somewhat hampered by his very wide category ‘social sciences’, the only ones of his types which the Lampeter Corpus does not cover are literature (and this intentionally so), philosophy and languages (both of which of are numerically minor categories). Thus the Lampeter Corpus can also be seen to reflect the publishing situation rather accurately.
12
The Lampeter Corpus
religious apathy (Spurr 1991:378) — perhaps rather the latter, as atheism could still be the cause of sharp attacks against persons suspected of it, e.g. Hobbes (Hunter 1981). Nevertheless, there was, after the Glorious Revolution, a new atmosphere of liberalism, which fostered the growth of ‘heresies’ such as Socianism or Deism — whose members were seen as suspect not only by the Established Church but also by the state, for there was a certain connection with political radicalism (Kenyon 1977:83) as in the case of John Toland, the author of PolA1720. The question of atheism/religious apathy, while of interest in itself, is also important for estimating the possible impact of sermons on the population: not everybody might have been exposed to them as often as Samuel Pepys (cf. his diary). In general it was assumed, however, that sermons reached many people and had a great influence, so that in each decade one of the RELIGION texts (RelA) is always a sermon. After more than one hundred years of intense Protestant indoctrination and of reading the Bible in English a very far-reaching religious influence – even if maybe more on the subconscious level – on the morals, the thinking and also the mode of expression of the people can be assumed (cf. Humphreys 1954:168). And of course the sheer amount of publications on religious themes can be taken as proof of considerable public interest in the matter. 15 The real problem of the Anglican Church and the state at the time was probably not fear of atheism but the danger perceived to come from the Dissenting and Catholic camps. The English apprehension of Catholicism reached psychopathic dimensions (Mullet 1987:148), the best corpus example of which is text RelA1679, the "sermon of the Antichrist", by whom none other than the Pope is meant. Anti-Catholic sentiment also had the clearest and longest lasting political influence, in bringing about the Glorious Revolution and the Bill of Rights (1688/89) as well as the Act of Settlement (1701), the latter forbidding a Catholic monarch or consort. The events leading to the first of these are defended and justified in PolB1690, one of whose authors happened to be a future bishop of Gloucester. While antiCatholicism could rely on widespread support within the population, the Dissenters were, so to speak, the ‘enemies from within’. The execution of Charles I and the Puritan Commonwealth that followed had left England traumatized about the effects of radical Protestantism, a feeling that lasted well into the 18th century (e.g. RelB1718; cf. Kenyon 1977:83). The ongoing sermons before Parliament every January 30, on which RelB1730 is a comment, testify to this. Therefore, the first approach was to suppress and 15
Spufford (1981:130; 138) found a proportion of up to 31% of religious publications among the chapbooks, dominating especially the cheap market - thus pointing to their accessibility also for the lower levels of society. Cf. also Hunter (1981:163).
The Lampeter Corpus
13
attack Dissent (cf. for instance RelB1667 with a discussion of this), which, naturally, was resisted by the Dissenters (cf. an ‘answer’ written by William Penn, RelB1674) and which was also not ultimately successful: the Toleration Act of 1689 relieved the Dissenters of most restrictions. While there seemed to be a numerical decline of Dissenters towards the end of our period (Spurr 1991:387), their culture, e.g. in the shape of the progressive Dissenting academies, was an important contribution to English culture. In spite of all external and also church-internal problems the Anglican Church of England was the dominant religious influence in most people’s life. It survived most conflicts relatively intact, such as that between jurors and non-jurors (e.g. the author of RelB1701) or the Bangorian Controversy (RelB1718, RelB1721), and managed to stabilize itself in the 18th century, producing more calm and social balance within its ranks. The Anglican clergy on the whole was rather open to new developments, even progressive ones, which meant, for instance, that bishops also busied themselves with other than religious (or political) matters, as for instance George Berkeley, Bishop of Cloyne, and mathematics (SciB1735). With regard to POLITICS one can think principally of two possible types of texts, i.e. (i) texts on political theory, or (ii) treatments of and comments on current political affairs. It is especially the latter kind that is found in the Lampeter Corpus; theoretical considerations enter into some texts, such as PolB1659 (the definition of tyranny) or PolA1684 (the discussion of monarchy as such), but they are always firmly anchored in some current state or event — in those two cases Cromwell’s rule and the Exclusion Crisis respectively. It seems as if the publication format of a pamphlet does not readily offer itself to the exposition of political theory. Thus the Lampeter POLITICS texts are closely mirroring the well-known course of English history, e.g. the English Civil War and the Scottish involvement in it (PolA1646), government during the Commonwealth (PolA1659), the success of General Monck in preparing the ground for the Restoration (PolB1660), the Exclusion Crisis (PolA1684) leading up to the Glorious Revolution (PolB1690), the ongoing Jacobite threat to England after this (PolA1702), the rise of party politics following their beginnings in the 1680s (PolA1711), or — connected with the emergence of party democracy — the intricacies of elections (PolB1724). It was the existence of elections, and thus of an electorate, which made political information in print so especially important; one modern estimate puts the number of voters at c. 340,000, that is one in every four men (Speck 1987:45f). But those who were not entitled to vote also seem to have shared in a keen interest in politics, naturally particularly so in times of crisis (Mullet 1987:130). While the great majority of corpus texts deal with English affairs, there is also some interest
14
The Lampeter Corpus
in Ireland (PolA1720) and more notably for Scotland (PolB1689, PolA1699, PolB1706), reflecting both the greater importance of Scotland for England and also more self-confidence on the part of the Scots. Most texts are very ‘insular’ in outlook, but foreign (PolA1672) and colonial (PolA1699) matters occur as well. However, those are much more common in the domain ECONOMY — a telling sign of where English priorities lay in that age. The POLITICS texts as a whole usually exhibit a highly argumentative style of writing, and while this is also true of individual texts from other domains they do in that respect represent a more unified group. The domain ECONOMY is not to be understood as ‘economics’, whose beginning as an (academic) discipline can be traced to Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations (1776), but it represents the great mass of writing on that topic existing before, which is best characterized as ‘economic nationalism’. There was indeed a strong interconnection between politics and economic matters, with the latter being both a means and an aim in the political struggle with other nations. Most notably there was the economic rivalry with the Dutch (cf. EcA1652, EcB1700), which even resulted in three wars during that period. As economic competition and activity in general was beginning to take place on a world-wide stage (a first ‘globalization’, so to speak), foreign trade (e.g. EcA1720, EcB1731) and colonial economies (EcA1714, EcA1731) gained in importance — and the whole enterprise also became more risky (cf. for instance the case of lost ships in LawA1673). Risks, and also greater costs, were more easily shared by groups of businessmen such as the East India Company (EcB1641, EcB1676, EcB1681, EcA1697), founded in 1600. Joint-stock companies like this one were a new development of the 17th century and an important step towards the modern form of capitalism. But also for the individual merchant/entrepreneur and for the state as such the question of finance became ever more pressing, as trade became more expansive, and thus more expensive, and at the same time more competitive. State financing was of course as sensitive a topic then as it is nowadays and the search was constantly on for relatively ‘harmless’ methods of raising revenue (EcB1660, EcB1696, EcB1717). The longest-lasting outcome of that period’s successful struggle to come to terms with finances was the Bank of England, founded in 1694 (EcA1705).16 Of course, both foreign economic involvement and sober financing require a good foundation in the domestic economy (cf. EcA1681). Many people saw this very clearly, and while, probably as a result of public interest, the press reflected outside affairs to a 16
Cf. for instance Graves & Silcock (1984:169-193) on the English financial system. According to them, by 1700 it was very well-developed and definitely superior to those of Continental Europe, so that texts from that period reflecting the evolution might be especially interesting.
The Lampeter Corpus
15
much greater extent, developments at home were not to be neglected. In both agriculture and manufacture increasing specialisation and sophistication were noticeable, often helped along by new inventions or techniques. The progressive farmer or entrepreneur would be expected to encourage ‘improvement’ (e.g. EcB1653, cf. also SciA1653), and while all this did not amount to an Industrial Revolution yet, it clearly pointed in that direction. The great mass and variety of economic publications reveal clear popular interest in the matter, and it seems that most people saw business as something positive and worthwhile (Humphreys 1954:52ff). And they obviously regarded it as something down-to-earth: all the texts are connected to one or the other current event or problem, there is nothing abstract or theoretical about them. SCIENCE is perhaps the most exciting of all the domains, and that is because science in our modern sense of the word is only really emerging during this period.17 What one finds in the 17th and 18th centuries, especially the former, is an overlapping of two scientific traditions, that of the old academic, tradition-bound approach and that of the new rational and empirical approach going under the name of ‘real (or natural, experimental) philosophy’. Corresponding to this, there was a clash and transformation of world-views, with somewhat confused views of metaphysical and nonmechanical causes gradually giving way to a clearly fact-based, rational understanding of the visible world. However, even the new ‘real philosophy’ did not right from the beginning conform to our narrow modern definition of science, it was rather "centring on natural and mechanical problems but extending through the life sciences towards medicine and through chemistry and applied mathematics towards technology" (Hunter 1981:32). As the terms ‘applied’ and ‘technology’ already hint at, there was a strong utilitarian bend present in the new approach, with the question of the usefulness of scientific studies for the amelioration of human circumstances being given due consideration. However, the most defining element of ‘real philosophy’ was the methods used, which are all based on Baconian empiricism and which are still in use in science today. These are the collection of data, the careful observation of real-world processes and events, the formulation of hypotheses and the conducting of experiments. Probably the best embodiment of this new science is the Royal Society founded in 1662. The domain SCIENCE is supposed to reflect this historical picture, and thus the variety of texts it includes is only to be understood if one disregards the narrow modern definition of the term. Astrology (SciA1644), for example, definitely represents the older approach, but nevertheless is still within the 17
Cf. Hunter (1981) for a good introduction into early modern science.
16
The Lampeter Corpus
confines of science in the 1640s (e.g. Clay 1984:185) — after all, even Newton still dabbled in alchemy! Furthermore, the traditional kind of science is also represented by such textbook-like treatments of ‘secure’ knowledge as are found in SciB1652, SciB1666, or SciA1698. Among the representatives of the ‘real philosophy’ one finds texts that even today would be regarded as prototypical science (SciA1666, SciA1674, SciB1676, SciA1683, SciB1684, SciA1720, and SciB1722), with some well-known authors such as Hooke or Boyle. Authors of some other texts must have been well established within the circle of the virtuosi (as the new scientists were then called), even though their output might seem too applied or dubious to us (e.g. SciA1653, SciB1696, SciA1709, SciB1714, SciA1730). Two texts (SciB1701, SciA1712) are special in so far as they are not ‘scientific’ as such, but rather deal with the status of scientific professions, something that is important from the perspective of the increasing consolidation and closing-up of these professions during the early modern era. What makes this domain of additional interest is the fact that scientific texts (together with sermons) have been suspected to be at the forefront of the stylistic changes taking place at the time (Jones 1951; Adolph 1968). Two principal kinds of texts combine to make up the domain LAW . On the one hand, some texts belong there because of their text type, i.e. they represent genres that only occur in the legal sphere such as statutes (LawA1643), petitions (LawB1661) or pleas (LawB1715). On the other hand, there are those texts that deal with topics or describe events in the sphere of law; they are rather about law or legal questions than within law. Some of them give an insight into the administration of law as such (LawA1680) or, on the basis of this, put the case for certain improvements, as for instance LawA1653 and LawA1694 do. Others discuss specific legal cases which either had caused public dispute, such as LawB1688, LawB1697 and LawB1704 (all of them concerned in some way with royal prerogative), or which were deemed to be of general public interest, e.g. LawA1703 or LawB1738, the latter one being concerned with the case of a printer and involving the question of freedom of the press. Law texts, as some of the above already show, can also have a close affinity to politics, be it because they touch on the question of civil rights (LawB1649, LawA1732), or because they deal with treason cases (LawA1716, LawA1723, LawB1723). Trial or court-room transcripts, such as LawA1668 and LawB1678, but also LawA1716, form a class of their own between those two types and provide a most vivid picture not only of the workings of the legal system but also of everyday life in that period. In so far as there is some actual ‘speech’, however filtered through writing, found in them, they are especially interesting for register or stylistic studies. What is also intriguing about the
The Lampeter Corpus
17
domain LAW in general is the fact that on the one hand it reflects something so typically English as the Common law system and on the other hand it was one of the last spheres of public life to officially give up the use of a foreign language with the abolition of ‘Law French’ in 1732. While MISCELLANEOUS might not sound like a very useful name for a domain, it was thought necessary in order to enable the inclusion of a wide variety of texts evidently typical of the time and the contemporary press which fit none of the other categories and are also too varied as a group to be given a more descriptive name. Quite a few of these texts are what one would find in the popular press nowadays. Among those there are topics such as natural catastrophes (MscA1669), the supernatural (MscB1666, MscA1696, MscA1712), frauds and swindlers (MscB1692), ‘adventure story’ (MscA1685), as well as biographies of people of interest (MscB1676, MscB1729, MscB1739). Other texts would fall rather under the headings of manuals or practical advice, be it more in the social sphere (MscA1676, MscB1700) or in garden and household (MscB1718, MscA1722, MscA1730), the latter combining its advice with a sales advert. Some texts view matters with political implications from a different, sometimes private, angle, for example the Civil War from the point of view of a militia man (MscA1643), ship-building and its effects on the strength of the English navy (MscB1646), or an important contractor on the rebuilding of London (MscB1685). Satire, which is so typical of the era, is also found (MscA1650, perhaps also MscB1700), as well as a self-reflective treatise on the freedom of the press (MscA1704). While the corpus thus allows illuminating insights into many aspects of life in early modern England, the domain structure and the variety of text types 18 present also make it possible to create sub-corpora in order to study different registers 19, styles, or formality levels, for instance. The following pie chart shows the absolute (number of words) and relative sizes (percentage of corpus) of these domain sub-corpora:
18
The text headers will contain information on what the text calls itself, e.g. essay, treatise, speech etc. But of course not every text contains a self-description of that kind, in which case the slot will remain empty. An additional text classification (cf. Schmied/Claridge 1997 for an early attempt) on our, the compilers’, part was considered too subjective in nature and thus dispensed with. 19 As the Lampeter Corpus period is a time of changing social conditions and emerging institutions, registers should not be seen as monolithic blocks, however. Fairclough’s (1988) concept of multi-registerial texts might be interesting here.
18
The Lampeter Corpus
Science 222,395 words 20%
Economy 173,077 words 15% Law 204,645 words 17%
Religion 202,802 words 17%
Politics 204,839 words 17%
Miscellaneous 164,344 words 14%
Figure 2.2: The domains of the Lampeter Corpus The second view into early modern England mentioned above is provided by the authors of the corpus texts and the information about them contained in the text headers. Of course, this is not always the case, definitely not for anonymous texts (16 in all) and those with ‘corporate’ authors (4), but there are also some authors, though known by name, about whom nothing could be found out (11). However, in all other cases it was attempted to give as much of the following information as possible: the date and place of birth, sex, age, places of residence up to the time of writing the text, educational history, occupation(s), as well as the socio-economic status of the writer and of his/her father or mother, occasionally supplemented by a further biographical note (such as “Royalist affiliations” for James Howell [PolA1648]). The following is an example taken from the header of text SciA1674:
Robert Hooke 1635 Freshwater (Isle of Wight) Freshwater; Oxford; London; Oxford; London
The Lampeter Corpus
19
<EDUCATION>Westminster-School; Christ Church, Oxford: MA (1663) secretary; Gresham Professor of geometry; surveyor of London; inventor; professor of Mechanics to the Royal Society; perpetual curator of experiments to the Royal Society <SOCECSTATUS>professions (academic) <SOCECSTATUSPAT>professions (clergy) From a sociolinguistic perspective it is the classification according to socio-economic status that is probably of most relevance. Of course, it is difficult to re-create a sociological profile of a past society and the results of such attempts always have to be treated with some caution. Nevertheless, the following model, which is based on the research of such historians as Holderness (1976), Wrightson (1982, 1986), Clay (1984), Houston (1992), and Coward (1994), seems to present a fair picture of society at the time of the Lampeter Corpus. I. Nobility · Aristocracy / Peerage (dukes, earls, marquises, viscounts, barons) · Gentry (baronets, knights, esquires, gentlemen) · Archbishops & Bishops II. Landed and Professional Classes · Officers · Government Officials · Clergy · Lawyers · Medical Profession · Merchants and Manufacturers · Yeomanry (rural) III. The "middling sort" · Freemen (masters, craftsmen, tradesmen) · Husbandmen / Craftsmen / Tradesmen (rural) IV. Lower ranks · Wage-earners (journeymen, apprentices, servants etc.) · Cottagers / Craftsmen / Tradesmen / Labourers (rural) V. The Poor
20
The Lampeter Corpus
Factors that play a role in determining social status include birth, title, wealth and the nature of that wealth, life-style, occupation, form of land tenure, tenure of positions of authority and legal status, not all of which are of equal weight, however (Wrightson 1982:22). The model should not be seen as static; there were of course shifts, even if only small, in the relationship between social groups during the 100 years covered here, and there was also the not negligible fact of individual social mobility (Wrightson 1986:180; 187). Naturally, not all members of society as found in this model are relevant with regard to authorship because of the uneven spread of literacy (especially the ability to write) through society (Spufford 1981:21ff) and also because access to the printing presses would have been uneven for the different social classes. 20 Thus the two lowest levels in the above model can usually be disregarded in the question of (direct) authorship and the middling sort, so to speak, will also be under-represented in that respect. Most authors will invariably come from the two top levels, which from a sociolinguistic point of view is rather deplorable. However, at least the second level and the existence of ‘social risers’ (i.e. higher social level than the father) allow for some possibly interesting variation. Another point which is somewhat disappointing is the rarity of female authors, only two in the whole Lampeter Corpus (both in the domain RELIGION ); probably it was difficult for women to get access to the printing presses. 21 It is noteworthy that one of the corpus’s female authors had inherited a print shop from her husband, which enabled her to print her material herself. The corpus thus represents the different possibilities of social and cultural participation for different members of society. Looking through the corpus authors one thus finds the following social spread: in the first and highest class there are 22 authors in all, the majority (11) of them belonging to the aristocracy, while six are members of the gentry and five are found in the ranks of the higher clergy. Most authors, however, are found in the second social class, representing among them all the possible professions but not the yeomanry (which is only found in the father generation of some authors). Of the 59 people in this group, the 20
However, Smith (1994:6; 23) remarks that authorship could reach rather far down the social scale (especially during the Commonwealth), that the capacity to put something into print grew from the 1640s onwards and that in general new kinds of authors emerged in England in the 17th century. 21 I.e. those that could write at all. In fact, nearly 90% of all women in 17th-century England could not even write their names (Cressy 1980:41). However, among London women illiteracy declined rather dramatically down to 44% by 1720 (ibid. 147).
The Lampeter Corpus
21
majority of 24 belong to the clergy. The urban part of the third, ‘middling’ group is present in the corpus with 15 authors. About 14 authors could be characterized as ‘social risers’, as they are somewhat higher up in the social ranking than their fathers were. The opposite process is also found, usually as a drop from the first into the second class, which is not surprising as younger sons of the gentry, and to a lesser extent also of the aristocracy, who did not inherit had to find another source of income. An example, though probably less out of need than out of inclination, is Boyle (SciB1684), who was born into the aristocracy, but then became a scientist. Together with the variety regarding occupations and the various educational courses taken by the authors, the existing social spread also makes it possible to approach the Lampeter Corpus from a sociolinguistic point of view. What distinguishes the Lampeter Corpus authors from most of their colleagues in PDE corpora is the nature and status of their writing. In the 17th and, to a lesser extent, the early 18th centuries "writing was not yet regarded as a profession, but rather as a form of civilised communication" (Bonham-Carter 1978:12). Although there were authors who wrote on commission for the booksellers and for money (Feather 1988:103f), for the majority of early modern authors writing was neither their sole occupation nor even the most prominent part of their life or profession. Eisenstein (1983:100) calls these authors (until the 18th century) "quasi-amateurs". It is probably not saying too much if one expects this to have an influence on their use of the language, e.g. the possible absence of professional group styles. The third thing the Lampeter Corpus mirrors is the nature of public discourse at that time and thus, indirectly, the audience of the texts found in the corpus. That public discourse and public opinion were taken seriously then and its machinations and outcome consciously exploited by, e.g., politicians is expressly stated by one of the highly contentious texts of the Lampeter Corpus (PolB1730, my italics): However the whole Stream of their Malice, for some Time, flowed only in this Channel, to vilify this Minister’s Name, to arraign his Conduct, depreciate his Services, blacken his Character, and weaken his Credit, both with his Prince and his Fellow-Subjects; all Hands were imployed, and all Engines set at Work; Manuscripts were circulated, the Press loaded, Coffee-House Talkers, Table-Wits, and Bottle-Companions had their Instructions given them; and the grossest Falshoods were inculcated in the grossest Terms; ... (p.11) The Transition was easy from Ministers to Princes; and the same Methods that had served to defame the one, were now imployed to
22
The Lampeter Corpus depreciate the other. The whole Artillery of Pamphleteers, Balladmongers, and Libellers was drawn out; ... (p.17)
All the means then possible were used, and while the author of that text mentions them accusingly, he himself is also using the most effective of those means, the pamphlet, to react to them. Pamphlet publications could be more effective than, for instance, the newspapers (one of which, The Craftsman, PolB1730 is directed against), because (a) they could treat of their topics more exhaustively if they wanted, and more importantly (b) because they could be less easily traced and suppressed as they did not emanate regularly from one rather constant source. As "the pamphlet was (...) the principle [sic] means of reaching a mass audience" (Feather 1986:38), it can be assumed that most of the authors, especially those writing about matters of great interest and/or contention, wrote with the widest possible audience in mind. Pamphlets usually want to influence and sway public opinion, and this they can only do if they make themselves clearly understood. Gordon (1966:9) states that even when print became the normal means of dissemination, much prose remained oral in conception. The drama, the sermon, and the pamphlet (...) perpetuate in print what was first conceived in terms of the spoken word. It can therefore further be assumed that most pamphlets are not written in any kind of complicated or intricate style, but rather at a neutral level. To assume a more ‘colloquial’ level, in spite of Gordon’s comment, would be to expect too much, as the stylistic awareness of the age was too well developed for that; one of the Lampeter authors even felt it necessary to apologize for the — in his opinion — inadequately humble style of his work.22 How aware authors were of their readers is also shown by the frequency of addresses to the reader being attached to their main work.23 The natural place of pamphlets was the streets and especially London’s coffee-house scene (Sommerville 1996:163), as also mentioned in the corpus quotes above. While pamphlets, as well as everything else, were 22
"... and tho’ possibly my Stile may appear rough and unpolish’d, which the courteous Reader I hope will a little excuse, ..." (MscA1685, p. 26). But a rather desperate statement by Richard Baxter (Reliquiae Baxterianae, 1696), one of the authors of MscB1658, contains an implicit admission that the style of most writers is probably still too complicated: "Indeed, the more I have to do with the ignorant sort of people the more I find that we cannot possibly speak too plainly to them. If we do not speak to them in their own vulgar dialect, they understand us not." (quoted in Gordon 1966:125f). 23 Twenty texts contain addresses to the reader; additionally, there are fourteen addresses to specific persons or groups of people.
The Lampeter Corpus
23
in their great majority printed in London (e.g. Feather 1988: 67), they also reached the rest of the country, partly through pedlars but also through a network of booksellers (Spufford 1981; Alston 1981; Feather 1988:41). Nevertheless, the London readership was the most important one (Smith 1994:26); London was not only by far the biggest city in the country (with 575,000 inhabitants (c. 10-12%) from a whole population (England/Wales) of c. 5-5.5 million in about 1700)24, but also the place where all important decisions were taken and thus where these could be influenced by pressure from below (cf. for instance the Saccheverell affair and the riots connected with it, beginning in 1709). The c. 500 coffee-houses in London were the places where people congregated not only to drink coffee, but to read literature, pamphlets or newspapers and to discuss their content (Humphreys 1954:18; Feather 1988:54). Or they did not even have to read them: early Modern England was still to a considerable extent an oral-based culture or at least one with a considerable oral residue (cf. Ong 1982). People would still read things aloud for others to share in the information (cf. Cressy 1980:14; Feather 1988:94 and Aries/Chartier 1991:150ff, also the illustration p. 130). Sommerville (1996:125) quotes Charles Leslie as saying that even the illiterate will Gather together about one that can Read, and Listen to an Observator or Review (as I have seen them in the Streets) where all the Principles of Rebellion are Instilled into them, and they are Taught ... to Banter Religion.25 Authors were aware of these practices, and therefore it is not completely inappropriate to assume that they not only wrote for readers, but also for listeners. Through the practice of reading aloud, illiterate and semi-literate people also gained access to the world of pamphlets, thereby increasing the audience. Though the extent of literacy in societies of the past is extremely hard to measure (Schofield 1981), and estimates in the extant literature differ (e.g. Cressy 1980, Spufford 1981), there is reason to believe that literacy, in par24
Figures from Wrightson (1982:128), Borsay (1987:197) and Clay (1984:2; 170). Urbanization, i.e. the proportion of the nation living in towns, was expanding; by 1700 probably a quarter of the population of England and Wales was urban (cf. also the map in Clay 1984:168). London was even a real metropolis, definitely the biggest city in Western Europe and one of the three to four largest in the world (Borsay 1987:200). An increasing urban population also meant more (active) participants in the public discourse of the time, among other things because literacy was probably more widespread in towns than in rural areas (Cressy 1980:72). 25 Source given by Sommerville: Rehearsal, Preface to the first collected volume published in 1708.
24
The Lampeter Corpus
ticular the ability to read (both the easier task and the one taught first in schools (e.g. Schofield 1981:460), was more common than often thought and that it even trickled down to the lower reaches of society (e.g. Spufford 1981) — although there was of course a clear social stratification in literacy levels. Furthermore, illiteracy certainly declined during the early modern period, as can be seen in the following graph taken from Cressy (1980:177):
Figure 2.3: The decline of illiteracy in early modern England (reproduced from Cressy 1980:177) One important aspect for the amount or increase of literacy is certainly religion: more people in Protestant cultures, such as the British one, have been shown to possess books at all (an indication of literacy) and also in greater numbers than their contemporaries in Catholic environments (Aries/Chartier 1991:134ff). In addition, however, print as such was probably not the least factor in bringing about an increase in literacy by encouraging people in daily or at least weekly contact with printed matter (an amount of exposure not possible in manuscript cultures!) to learn to read and write (Eisenstein 1985:21). While the wide audience thus must have had some checking influence on ‘high-flying’ style in pamphlets, there will also have been a reverse influ ence on the audience by the language actually used in the pamphlets. Seen psychologically, written, more specifically printed language has an inherent authority never attained by the spoken word — and in an age that (a) exhibits a rather high awareness of linguistic matters, especially of the status of the English language, and (b) gradually sets out on the course of standardizing the language, the role played by the language of public discourse is by no means negligible. Stein (1994:14) has pointed out that "it could well be argued that inherent in the written printed language of the time there was a
The Lampeter Corpus
25
codifying effect per se" and that it was already the case "long before (with e.g. Johnson and Lowth) a prescriptivism based on codification proper set in", which thus gives crucial importance to the 17th century in this respect. Printed matter not only disseminated specific linguistic features among its wide audience, but also influenced the future perception of language as such (cf. Bex 1996:32). It is thus especially the ‘mainstream’ features of English, those that are part of the drift (cf. chap.3) and those that are associated with neutral to moderately conversational styles — like the analytic verb forms examined here — which will be illuminated by a closer look at these kinds of writing.
3. Multi-word Verbs as a Group 3.1 An Attempt at a Definition The focus here will be on the question of what can count as a verb in the context of a sentence. Or, how are expressions such as the underlined ones in the following sentences, taken at random from the BNC, to be treated in this respect? (1) (2) (3a) (3b) (4) (5)
A small party may get a substantial number of votes, but if they fall short of the quota it will not normally win a seat. (BNC EW4 700) You work with your dog so you have to look after him very carefully. (BNC A17 1502) She has made a choice not only of person, but of class. (BNC AN4 2928) What you may have to take into consideration is the well-being of companies or individuals you are dependent on for your future. (BNC CBC 4727) Above all, though, glasnost and greater contact with the West have brought about a fait accompli. (BNC A2X 432) We all fell in with what you wanted, we all bent over backwards to do what you wanted. (BNC FAB 3392)
What they all have in common is that (a) they consist of more than one word1, i.e. are analytic constructions, and (b) nevertheless represent a semantic unity that is characteris tic of a single word or lexical unit. While some elements (especially prepositions and particles) are ‘easier’ to integrate into the verb phrase, others, such as a choice (3a) have not found as ready an acceptance — after all they are susceptible to a traditional in terpretation as a direct object. Here, all the elements in the above examples will be seen as being part of the verb. In all other respects, however, they clearly differ from each other, most notably in their internal make -up, but also — as a consequence — in their syntactic behaviour. Moreover, their frequencies and thus their impact on the structure of English v ary greatly, with the type found in (4) certainly being the most prominent one. Nevertheless, their common characteristics justify combining them into one larger group for the purpose of investigation (cf. 3.4). In the history of 1
The notion of ‘word’ will throughout the study be used in an everyday, quasi pretheoretical way (cf. Bauer’s discussion (1983:7-10)), as a more theoretical definition is not necessary for the problem in hand.
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
27
linguistics, these structures were mostly treated neither as a group nor in a systematic way. Therefore statements concerning them in older general descriptions of English — which I will briefly look at now — are usually scattered all over the works in question. Kruisinga’s (1925:II/3,72) definition of a compound, which according to him is "a combination of two or more words forming a semantic unit which is not identical with the combined meanings of its elements", is of interest here, as one of the examples he gives for such compo unds, pay attention, fits in with (3). In other places he explicitly mentions "compound verbs" (used for a combination of (2) and (4), (ibid. II/1, 113 ff) and "separable compounds" (reminiscent of German ‘separable verbs’), illustrated among others by cases like (4) (ibid. II/1, 65). Behind these separable compounds may lie his distinction between "distance compounds", which he exemplifies by for my brother’s sake, and "contact-compounds" such as schoolmaster (II/3,73). "Semi-compounds" is another of his terms, used for combinations like laugh at, think fit, take care of that are on the one hand "closely connected in meaning", but on the other are "not completely isolated" (II/3, 76). Kruisinga’s usage of the word ‘compound’ clearly shows that he is prepared to give word status to such combinations as in (1)-(5) above and that his main reason for doing so is their semantic cohesion. Poutsma (1926:25,118) employs the term "group-verb" for cases in which there is a close link between a verb and its complemen t and in which "the component parts form no real separate subjects of thought", i.e. just like Kruisinga his motivation for recognising a class of compound verbs is semantic. Jespersen (1928:III,294) carefully states that some phrases, his examples being taken from the classes of (2) and (3) above, "are now felt as wholes". In another place (V,6) he explicitly calls them "composite verbal expressions" and analyses them as a whole as W in his SWO-structures. Thus he draws syntactic consequences from his observation. Two different descriptions are employed by Curme (1931:572f), "transitive compound verbs" for such types as (2) and (3), and "group words" for combinations like (4). This latter term is used to distinguish some groups of words from other syntactically similar ones on the grounds that they exhibit the "oneness of meaning" otherwise only found in a word. It is clear from the statements and opinions just quoted that the prob lem posed by the structures in (1) to (5) and similar ones has received so me treatment, albeit mostly rather haphazardly and unsystematically in early studies. Recently, linguistic treatments of this point have been more systematic and intensive, as chapters 3 and 4 will show. Nevertheless, with the exception of Quirk et al. (1985), they have hardly been comprehensive with respect to multi-word verbs as a group. Thus, the attempt to deal with
28
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
all kinds of multi-word verbs in a more comprehensive, theoretical and empirical manner seems both necessary and appropriate. This is what the present work tries to do. I will take Quirk et al.’s (1985:1150) definition of a multi-word verb as a "unit which behaves to some extent either lexically or syntactically as a single verb" as a starting point. "To some extent" is symptomatic of everything having to do with multi-word verbs, as there are no clear -cut boundaries, only a cline — and the cut-off points will always have to remain based more or less on the subjective feeling of the linguist dealing with the problem. I do not, therefore, propose to offer a hard and fast theory of the problem, but simply an account of the matter which seems plausible to me. Another boundary that multi-word verbs touch or rather straddle is the one between syntax and semantics, cf. "either lexically or syntactically" in the quotation above. Some of the complexes one intuitively classifies as multi word verbs will fulfil lexical/semantic criteria, others syntactic criteria, while a third group will satisfy criteria in both spheres (cf. also Burgschmidt/Perkins 1985). Fulfilment of all possible criteria in each case cannot reasonably be expected in this context, in my opinion. I intend to use surface structure (cf. also Denison 1985b:189) and semantics (similar to many of the linguists cited above) most of all in my approach to the topic. "As language is used, meaning is both the beginning and the end point" (Dixon 1992:5), and syntax is ‘only’ the means of realizing the intended meaning. The following then is an attempt at a definition. First of all, a multi word verb is a group consisting of two or more words, regardless of whether they form an uninterrupted sequence or are spread discontinuously across the clause. Secondly, this group is made up of whatever in the context of a clause or sentence transports the concept of, or information about, the ‘process’ itself (cf. Halliday 1985:102), the ‘verbal’ meaning. The group should thus exhibit what Cruse (1986:77) terms "the union of a lexical form and a single sense". Here I am interested in how verbal semantic s may be enriched, changed or even taken over by additional elements. Notice, however, that not all its elements have to make a semantic contribution to the overall meaning; there can be empty or operator elements. Thirdly, the items making up such a multi-word verb do not necessarily all belong to the traditional word class verb; possible candidates are nouns, adjectives, adverbs, and prepositions. It is clear, however, that at least one real verb must be present to fulfil the necessary grammatical functions associated with a verb in a clause. Lastly, the internal structure of multi -word verb combinations is usually such that an alter native syntactic analysis (perhaps also connected with an alternative meaning) of them and their connection
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
29
with the rest of the clause is perfectly possible (cf. Dixon 1982:39), e.g. the analysis as a verb-direct object sequence (make a choice in (3a) above) or as verb + prepositional phrase instead of as a lexical multi -word verb (cf. Quirk et al.’s (1985:1150) two analyses of dispose of N). While the first, third and fourth points refer to (surface) form, the second one is about meaning, i.e. function, which is the most important element of the definition. An additional point is stability over time, the habitual nature of t he combination (Gläser 1986:16;19; Burgschmidt/Perkins 1985:27). This is cer tainly important, but it can only be verified empirically with other wise pre-defined multi-word verbs. Cruse’s notion of semantic constituents (1986:23 -32), which are formplus-meaning complexes (cf. the elements of the above definition), is, I think, of interest here. He himself uses the concept to award the status of minimal lexical units to idioms and — with some hesitation — to dead metaphors, but not to collocations (ibid. 37-45). According to this notion, multi-word verbs could only be considered lexical units if they represent one minimal semantic constituent. To illustrate this with Cruse’s examples, on the mat in The cat sat on the mat is a semantic constituent of the whole sentence which, however, consists of the further minimal semantic constituents on, the, and mat. Cook —’s goose, on the other hand, in This will cook Arthur’s goose cannot be divided into the constituents cook, ’s, goose, but is itself already a minimal semantic constituent. Analysing the relevant part of (6) into its semantic constituents, we get she - ... - looked - into her big, brown eyes - ..., which can be tested by putting the constituent (here the last of the three) into another sentential context, to which it should make an identical semantic contribution, cf. The doctor put the eyedrops into her big, brown eyes. (6)
She held Lizzie’s paw, looked into her big, brown eyes, wishing Lizzie could live forever. (BNC A17 1097)
The constituent in question here separates further into the minimal semantic constituents into — her- big — brown — eyes, which could be individually contrasted with at — his — bright — blue — eyes, for example; according to this theory the exchanging of blue for brown should yield parallel changes of meaning in different sentences. The substitutions made change the meaning of the whole sentence, but do not alter the basic meanings of the other individual constituents, e.g. whether there is the preposition at or into does not have any effect on she, look, eyes etc. as such. An analysis of (7), however, yields a different picture: ... — a House of Commons committee — had looked into — the possibility — ....., all of them further divisible (within limits, cf. House of Commons).
30
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
(7)
Even as early as 1840 a House of Commons committee had looked into the possibility of connecting Dover with Calais. (BNC A19 1780)
But looked into here is not further divisible. If one substitutes, e.g., stare for look, or at for into in sentences (6) and (7), they will not undergo parallel changes of meaning (recurrent semantic contrast), which would be necessary to prove that look is a minimal semantic constituent in both. Besides, a substitution with at would also change the meaning of look — which is an indication of multi-word verb status as the substitution of one part of a multi word unit changes the overall meaning of the unit (cf. Zgusta 1967:579). The surface sequence looked into makes a different semantic contribution to each of the sentences. The semantic contribution of the form to (7) is repli cated in The engineers looked into the problem, where a substitution with, say, ignore or discuss also produces an identical semantic contrast. The fact that ignore could also substitute for look into in (6), and that it is very hard to describe what identical semantic contrasts or contributions are, points to the limitations of this procedure. It is neither as straightforward, nor as precise and non-circular, i.e. non-intuitive, as Cruse makes it out to be. Nevertheless, it is a more varied and flexible test than the traditional one of substitution with a simplex synonym — especially as such a substitution is often impossible, as for example in (8) and (9)2. (8) (9)
No, a childminder cannot normally take care of a sick child .... (BNC A0J 307) I sacrifice everything for cricket, never stop out late and always take the greatest care of myself. (BNC A6Y 183)
Intuitively, take care of in both sentences is a lexical unit with the same or almost identical meaning of "restoring/maintaining health". But the substitu tion test will only work indirectly, i.e. for all the other elements of the sen tence, because the discontinuous, modified group in (9) makes it impossible to substitute another unit and still leave the syntactical structure intact. This seems to be the way Cruse (1986:37) himself proceeds in the case of cook — ’s goose (cf. above). Another problem is that one could, e.g., substitute notice for care (but cf. Zgusta 1967 referred to above), pointing towards the divisibility of take care of into the minimal semantic constituents take, care, and of. The substitution results can thus be contradictory in the case of individual combinations. In my opinion, given the varied syntactical nature of multi-word verbs, the ‘outwards-in’ procedure — substitution-testing 2
Discarding both look after and care for, as they are themselves multi-word complexes.
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
31
everything in the sentence until only the suspected complex lexical unit remains left — is a valid testing method. The approach outlined above admittedly makes multi-word verbs a rather open, and therefore somewhat unwieldy, class. However, the more one subdivides this general class and defines those subsections (cf. chap.4), the less open the approach becomes, although quite a few fuzzy edges will always remain. Before continuing with describing several possibilities of subdivision and proposing the scheme to be employed here, a few more words about the term used here are in order. As mentioned above, "multi-word verb" has been taken over from Quirk et al. (1985), basically because it is a very noncommittal cover term that can serve for a whole variety of combinations. Ultimately, however, these forms are very much context -, i.e. sentence- or clause-bound. In many respects, therefore, the label multi -word predicate might be more appropriate, but this would miss the fact that not a few of the structures in question are lexicalized. Thus, the term multi -word verb, which I will continue using, should be taken with the caveat pointed out here. 3.2 Classification Schemes for Multi-word Verbs All individual types of multi-word verbs have received some sort of treatment in the literature, and while most of this has been done in isolation, there have nevertheless been some attempts to draw up (more or less) complete lists of possible types and to classify them. 3 Mitchell (1958) A classic in this area is the classification given by Mitchell (1958:106), even though it deals only with a part of all the possible combinations. It has the advantage of great clarity and simplicity. His whole system is based on binary contrasts, as is visible in the following scheme: non-prepositional (to take) (1) non-phrasal prepositional (to take to) (2) non-prepositional (to put up) (3) phrasal prepositional (to put up with) (4)
3
The examples used in section 3.2. are those used by the quoted authors themselves.
32
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
With (1) representing the simplex verb, the classification deals with three types of multi-word verbs, namely prepositional verbs (2), phrasal verbs (3) and phrasal-prepositional verbs (4), where phrasal means the inclusion of an adverbial component. While the term phrasal verb had been introduced long before that time (Smith 1925:172), Mitchell’s scheme certainly contributed a lot to the establishment of the now common terms for the three major and most common types of multi-word verbs at least. Quirk et al. (1985) The most accessible attempt at classification is probably to be found in Quirk et al. (1985:1150-1168). A major division is made into principal types and "other multi-word verb constructions", which are obviously regarded as of minor importance. Inside the principal types a further division selects only idiomatic types as multi-word verbs proper, whereas the non-idiomatic, i.e. literal, types (e.g. come in, run away with) are treated as "free combinations" and thus placed outside the class concerned. The principal types, which are based on the formula "verb ± direct object ± adverb ± preposition", consist of the six combinations Phrasal Verb (verb + adverb) Types I ( crop up) and II (turn N down), Prepositional Verb (verb + preposition) Types I (come across N, e.g., a problem) and II (take N for N, e.g., a fool) and Phrasalprepositional Verb (verb + adverb + preposition) Types I (come up with N) and II (put N up for N, e.g., an election), where Type II is in each case the one containing a direct object. A further three types are listed under "others", namely verb-adjective combinations (e.g. lie low, cut N short), verb-verb combinations (e.g. make do with, put paid to) and verbs governing two prepositions (e.g. develop from ... into). Several problems may be mentioned in connection with this classification. Firstly, the principal types are allocated to the class of multi word verbs on semantic grounds (idiomaticity), whereas this does not seem to apply to the last three minor types. Secondly, the idiomatic approach can lead to interesting exclusions. Combinations such as come in, and send N away, which syntactically behave identically to crop up, turn N down, are thus not treated as multi-word verbs. Cases such as depend on, consist of with an obligatory preposition also seem to find no place here. Moreover, idiomaticity is not a clear-cut affair, but is best seen as a cline yielding a not very happy basis for classificatory purposes. For instance, their excluded example run away with was found in the present corpus in a sense that could be glossed by the simplex "steal", while of course the literal meaning would also still be present in the mind of the speaker/hearer. Fourthly, prepositional verb types IIb and IIc (subdivisions not mentioned above) contain a further fixed, unchangeable element besides the preposition, namely a noun as in
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
33
take care of, give way to, and lose touch with. The question is whether the presence of the noun, which is collocationally and semantically more salient than the preposition, should not take precedence over the latter in classifying these types. They are definitely on a different level than Type IIa which contains structures such as thank N for N, where the N slot can be filled by many different nouns. Talking of nominal elements in multi-word verbs, it is also somewhat unclear where combinations such as take into consideration would fit in with the present classification. They are mentioned only in passing as "yet another sub-type" of Type IIa prepositional verbs, if examples given there (lull N to sleep, put N to rights) can be interpreted as being of the "take into consideration" -type. Another minor point is why verbs governing two prepositions should be separated so completely from the other prepositional types in the classification. A last point concerns the verb -adjective combinations, namely the question why instances such as make sure/certain and see fit (mentioned only in a footnote) are not counted among them. Hückel (1968/69) An attempt to classify the major types of multi-word verbs according to strictly formal criteria, excluding semantic considerations as far as possible, is found in Hückel’s (1968/9:257-260) article dealing with the "Wortverband" (» lexical unit). The formal criteria applied comprise transitivity and word order, as well as the possibilities of passivization and nominalization. Thus, Hückel’s first general division is into transitive and intransitive combinations. The transitive category contains the following five major types: 1. verb + particle + direct object, 2. verb + direct object + particle, 3. verb + particle + preposition + direct object, 4. verb + reflexive pronoun + particle, 5. verb + fixed direct object. Type 1 is further split up into ’A’ with moveable particle posit ion, either before or after the direct object (lay (down) the burden (down)), and ’B’ where the particle is fixed in pre-object position, e.g. take out insurance, strike up a friendship. Type 2 is in a way the mirror image of Type 1B by requiring the particle to occur in fixed post-object position as in see N off, do N in. Type 4 is illustrated by give oneself away and brace oneself up. His Type 3 consists of ’A’ which permits movement of the particle and ’B’ with immutable word order, cf. The judge put down the crime to him/put the crime down to him (A) vs. The banker put the £5 down to my account only (B). Three sub-classes make up Type 5, two of which (’A’ and ’C’) are called
34
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
"blockiertes Syntagma" (= blocked syntagmatic group), and are illustrated by the building forms part of a larger estate/the police at once gave chase (A — gerund possible) and the next stories saw print in the following years (C — gerund impossible). Sub-class 5B involves a fixed preposition after the direct object, such as in EFTA steal a march on EEC. Four major types are contained in the intransitive category: 1. verb + particle, 2. verb + particle + preposition + noun/pronoun, 3. verb + preposition + noun, 4. verb + adjective. Type 1 contains combinations like sign on, talk back, and strike home. Structures such as look forward to, bear down upon, and break even with are included in Type 2. Type 3 is subdivided according to possibilities of passivization, namely ’A’ (possible), e.g. the government embarked upon a new policy, see through a trick, vs. ’B’ (impossible), e.g. the price lags behind the costprice. Finally, Type 4 is illustrated by loom large. The emphasis put on purely formal criteria in this classification is a nice attempt at keeping things as objective as possible, but the consequence is an explosion of sometimes confusing types plus the inclusion of dubious structures, as well as the omission of others. The transitive Types 1, 2, 4 and the intransitive Type 1, for example, could, in other classifications, all be subsumed under the heading phrasal verb (verb + adverb). Whether the position of the particle should be taken as a defining feature, as in Trans. 1A, 1B and 2, is doubtful because this is on the one hand rather idiosyncratic depending on the particular combination involved and on the other it has to do with degrees of idiomaticity inhibiting certain transformations (cf. Fraser’s (1976) degrees of frozenness). Also, in 1B the nouns insurance and friendship seem to have already become part of the idiom. Why those verbs with a reflexive pronoun cannot be part of Type 1A is not clear; Hückel’s ex ample give away, for instance, also occurs with other objects (cf. Cowie & Mackin 1975) and the position of itself is sufficiently explained by the rule that pronominal objects always precede the object (Cowie & Mackin 1975: xlix, and 5.2. below). Transitive Type 3 and Intransitive Type 2 represent what elsewhere are called phrasal-prepositional verbs, and again the word order dividing 3A and B is probably too idiosyncratic to be a basis for classification. Intransitive Type 3, dealing with prepositional verbs, seems to be somewhat over-inclusive; using passivization and gerund as criteria (3A) would even allow such structures as sleep in a bed, where the cohesion between sleep and in is in all other respects practically nil. Furthermore, 3B opens the door for virtually all kinds of constructions of the type verb + prepositional phrase. The inclusion of nominal and adjectival combinations
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
35
as separate types (Transitive Type 5 and Intransitive Type 4) is useful, but unfortunately incomplete. Like Quirk et al., Hückel omits the nominal take into consideration-type; moreover, the adjectival type has no transitive counterpart (e.g. cut N short) and makes no provision for the addition of a preposition, unless break even with, even being considered a particle by Hückel, under Intransitive Type 2A is taken to belong here. Cowie & Mackin, ODCIE, Vol. 1 (1975) and Cowie, Mackin & McCaig, ODCIE, Vol. 2 (1983) This is a classification from a lexicological angle, as is to be expected in the case of dictionaries, but it nevertheless does not neglect syntactical considerations. Cowie & Mackin’s classification in their first volume is based on six basic patterns, which are represented by them in the following schematic table (1975:xxix): Table 3.1: Cowie & Mackin’s classification (1975) particle preposition particle + preposition
Intransitive [A1] [A2] [A3]
Transitive [B1] [B2] [B3]
It takes up Mitchell’s basic contrasts of phrasal verb (1; go off, tip N off), prepositional verb (2; bank on N, foist N on N), and phrasal-prepositional verb (3; fall back on N, put N down to N) and splits these up further into intransitive and transitive types (A + B). While the classification o f these major types as illustrated by the examples in brackets is abso lutely logical, the authors also subsume under these headings other combinations which exceed the specifications above. Thus, bring to grips with and fall in love (with) are classified as B2 and A2 respectively, on the grounds that they "would exactly match those patterns if it were not for an additional preposition" (ibid.:xxx), i.e. with in the cases concerned. Other examples for this somewhat over-inclusive procedure are make an example of, take exception to, bear in mind (all B2) and fall into disrepute (A2). In all these cases the whole phrase as quoted here is taken as the headword in the dictionary, i.e. is seen quite rightly as a single idiom. At least one preposition is present in all of them, justifying their presence in the dictionary (1975) in the first place — and in a way also their classificatory treatment, as it makes life easier for the dictionary user. In all other respects and contexts, however, they deserve a more sophisticated treatment, especially as important differences exhibited for example by all those under B2 are thus entirely
36
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
neglected. The contrast between e.g. bear in mind and make an example of is obvious, but this latter and take exception to are not identical constructions either. At least, the verb + prepositional phrase constructions are noticed here, unlike in Quirk et al. (1985) above. Nevertheless, what has been said in the section on Quirk et al. about their Prepositional Verb Types IIb and IIc applies here as well. The second volume (1983), dealing with phrase, clause and sentence idioms, contains further types, which could be interpreted as multi -word verbs, under the heading of clause patterns (xxix -xxxiv). The patterns treated there have a much wider basis than the approach taken here necessitates. In the introduction, Cowie (1983:xiv) poses the question "[i]f it is true that highly idiomatic expressions tend in some ways to resemble single words, should this unity be reflected in the way they are grammatically described in dictionary entries?" and decides against it. Therefore, it is not possible to state which of the entries the authors would regard as more ‘unitary’, word like in nature than others. While items such as go berserk, come clean, get even with, drive N mad, make N plain, make answer/reply, run a risk (of N), take place, and give N a thought (randomly selected here) are found in the dictionary (1983), they are not classified in the manner of volume I as lexical units. Denison (1981 / 1984) The classification proposed by Denison (1981:23-34; 1984) is actually not meant to include anything else apart from verb-particle combinations (1984:276,n.3). Thus, he uses the pattern verb + one particle (adverb or preposition) as a starting point and elaborates on this in the following table (1981:23; 1984:273). Table 3.2: Denison’s classification class 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
second particle + + + +
direct object + + + +
prepositional object + + + + -
name intransitive phrasal verb transitive phrasal verb prepositional verb phrasal-prep. verb -
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
37
The first four are the well-known types, which Denison illustrates with the examples cool off (class 1), use N up (2), deal with N (3), and home in on N, look forward to N (4). Verbs with two prepositions are not included here, for he points out (1984:276,n.3) that they behave syntactically like class 3 — in this case they may be taken as being in fact indirectly included. Class 5, represented by let N in on N and single N out for N, could in my opinion also be called phrasal-prepositional verbs, in this case transitive ones (cf. Cowie & Mackin 1975), whereas class 4 comprises the intransitive ones. In this way they would be analogous to phrasal verbs. Class 6, also nameless here, might just as well be called transitive prepositional verbs (cf. Cowie & Mackin), as it consists of such combinations as foist N on N, take N for N. Come out ahead, get back in (Class 7) and put N back together, read N back out (Class 8) are unusual insofar as they contain two adverbial particles, but Denison is probably right in saying that they can be regarded as an extension of Class 1 and 2 respectively. As an extension, Denison (1981:36f) remarks that group-verbs with other components can be accommodated into the above classification, for example take place, go bad (class 1), make clear, get right (class 2), get to grips with, put paid to, stop short of, take care of (class 4), and lay N low with (class 5). This approach disregards the differences in the internal make-up of the combinations, however, something which also can have consequences for their behaviour as a unit. Palmer (1965 / 1974) In his two books on the English verb, Palmer (chap.10) deals with verbal combinations, using the following rather traditional classification, which does not offer anything new: 1. phrasal verbs, which can be either transitive or intransitive; 2. prepositional verbs — in 1965 only the intransitive type (e.g. look for N), then in 1974 also the transitive ones such as take N for N. This latter type moreover includes combinations involving a noun, cf. make a mess of, set fire to, give way to. In 1965, these latter examples were treated under "other verbal combinations" and described as verb-noun-preposition units. 3. phrasal-prepositional verbs, of which the 1965 book recognises only intransitive combinations such as put up with N, while the 1974 approach also includes transitives like put N down to N. Furthermore, he mentions get rid of, with rid classified as an adjective in 1965, and put paid to, have done with etc., i.e. verb-verb combinations in the sense of Quirk et al. (1985). None of these latter units are given the status of a separate category.
38
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
Vestergaard (1977) In a brief but very lucid classification, Vestergaard (1977:3) manages to do more than many larger and more complicated attempts. He recognises four main groups of multi-word verbs, namely 1. prepositional verbs (verb + preposition), to which type the book in question is devoted, 2. phrasal verbs (verb + adverbial particle), 3. verb + object (e.g. give offence), and 4. verb + prepositional phrase (e.g. fall in love). All four can and do function as lexical, in this case, verbal units, or as he expresses it, as V in a V(erb)P(reposition)-N(oun) cluster. He does not therefore see any necessity for an additional class labelled ‘phrasal-prepositional verbs’. Fraser (1976) Fraser does not offer an explicit classification, but in defining and exactly delimiting his verb-particle combination, he lists and also discusses other similar ’compound verbals’ in English. While this therefore cannot be a com plete listing, the following discrete types can be extracted from his chapters one and two: 1. verb-particle combinations, 2. verb-adverbial combinations, 3. verb-preposition combinations, 4. verb-adjective combinations (e.g. cut short, blow open, make good), 5.1. verb-noun-preposition combinations (five types, exemplified respectively by make reference to, catch sight of, bring word to, make a fool of, catch hell from), 5.2. verb-prepositional phrase combinations (e.g. bring to light, call into question, put into effect ), 5.3. verb-noun combinations (e.g. cast anchor, keep peace, take courage). Both 1 and 2 could be and are often called phrasal verbs in other contexts, with 2 seemingly representing those combinations in which the particle is used in the literal, quasi-spatial sense. Other types looking deceptively like phrasal verbs are left out of 1 in his chapter 2; these have not been incl uded in the list above, either, as their independent status is rather doubtful. Fraser’s verb-preposition combination seems to include any verb-preposition sequence; however, he is not concerned with defining prepositional verbs in the strict sense, but only with keeping particles and prepositions apart. The types 5.1 to 5.3. are all treated under one major heading by him, indicating that he sees them as sub-types of one basic category; nevertheless I have decided to list them separately. It should have become obvious in all these classificatory schemes that there is a kind of hard core of multi-word verbs on which most people can
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
39
agree. This core comprises phrasal verbs, prepositional verbs and phrasalprepositional verbs which are always mentioned and moreover form stable categories with a rather well-defined membership. Others, such as verbadjective or verb-verb combinations, come up only occasionally and not often with separate status. Another problematic point seems to be those units involving a nominal element, which are treated either under prepositional verb, meaning that those without a preposition are disregarded, or the whole type is ignored altogether; only Hückel, Vestergaard and perhaps Fraser recognise them as separate categories. 3.3 Proposed Classification The classification proposed here is similar to those discussed above, but shifts the weightings somewhat. Here, only the classification with the absolute minimum of information about the several types will be given; the precise definition of the individual categories follows in chapter 4. (I) Phrasal verbs Verbs followed by a particle of an adverbial nature in a non-prepositional use.4 They can be intransitive (fly away) or transitive (take up, e.g. a hobby). (II) Prepositional verbs Verbs followed by a preposition in its clear prepositional use. There is only one type, a transitive one, because if one interprets verb and preposition as a unit then the following noun (phrase) functions as its direct object. The type with the sequence verb-free object-preposition (turn N into N) is regarded as a special sub-type of prepositional verb, but one that will not be treated here 4
I am aware of the problems in allocating unambiguous word class tags to the nonverbal parts of multi-word verbs. On the one hand, one could argue that the question does not arise, i.e. that they have no word-class of their own if they are part of the multi-word verb as a whole. Carstensen (1964:326f), e.g., mentions as alternative descriptors of these elements "postposition", "postverbium", and "postpositives Präfix", the latter terms being taken from Shlutenko (1955, quoted there). Cf. also Marchand’s (1951:74) term of "postpositional verbs" for what are here called prepositional verbs. On the other hand, the different elements in the various types do influence the syntactic behaviour of the combination and make different semantic contributions to the whole unit. The distinction between prepositions, adverbs and intermediary categories has proven especially problematic (cf. for example Dietrich 1960, Sroka 1962 + 1972, Kaluza 1990, Mitchell 1978, and most recently O’Dowd 1998). Denison (1981:16) speaks of a principle of gradience between preposition and adverb. I will decide on a pragmatic surface-structure approach: prepositions, however closely connected to the verb, need a nominal element to refer to, and whenever this nominal element is missing, the adverbial interpretation is enforced.
40
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
for practical reasons. Verbs with two prepositions are included under (II) by virtue of their first preposition, while the second one is ignored.
(III) Phrasal-prepositional verbs Verbs followed by an adverbial particle (as in phrasal verbs) and a pure preposition. There are monotransitive (put up with, cf. the explanation given under prepositional verbs) and ditransitive (put N down to N) types. (IV) Verb-adjective combinations Verbs followed by an adjective or a past participle, the latter being taken in its adjectival quality. They are intransitive (hold good) or transitive (break open), and, in the case of the latter, can include a final preposition (fall short of). (V) Verbo-nominal combinations They comprise all combinations which contain a nominal element as a fixed part and can be subdivided into three types, namely (Group I) simple verb noun unit (take a walk), (Group II) verb-noun-preposition unit (catch sight of), and (Group III) verb-prepositional phrase unit (put in execution). (VI) Verb-verb combinations Verbs followed by another verb in a form other than the past participle (cf. (IV)), i.e. either an infinitive (let go) or a present participle (send N packing). Both types can be either intransitive or transitive. Verb-verb combinations will be left out of consideration in the following analyses. They are certainly a minor category — probably slightly more uncommon than verb-adjective combinations, and as a group more fragmented than the latter. Furthermore, cursory searches of the Lampeter Corpus yielded not a single example of this type. Whether this is due to sheer accidence or to a later, post-18th century development of this category, cannot be determined at the moment. I would like to draw attention to a general problem concerning all the categories above, which is nicely summed up by a quotation taken from Denison (1981:23): Trying to draw a clear distinction between group-verbs and notgroup-verbs is unrewarding, however. It must be recognised that group-verbs vary along many different axis, and that far enough along any axis of variation there will be collocations which are not groupverbs. No one test can delimit the area clearly and in full accord with one’s intuitive notions, ... (my italics, CC)
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
41
It is actually a (vicious?) circle we are moving in: we all know in some way what, e.g., a phrasal verb is, but a full and theoretically adequate pr oof of this intuitive knowledge seems impossible. If in doubt, I will therefore trust my intuitions more than I will trust any kind of test. Chapter 4 and the data se lected should be considered with this in mind. 3.4 Common Concerns This is the place to address the important question of why all these different types should be treated together. It is especially for four reasons, or four bundles of reasons, that I have decided to examine them as a group. First, they are exponents of an important trend in the history of the English language, that from a more synthetic to a more analytic linguistic system. Multi-word verbs can be seen as both a result of and a reaction to developments connected with the analytic "drift" (cf. Sapir 1921:chap.VII). Their most obvious analytic characteristic is of course the fact that one meaning is expressed by a combination of separate individual words (free morphemes). The alternatives to this procedure are, or would have been, compounding and affixation, and in this respect the decline in the productivity of prefix verbs (e.g. overtake, outrun) is noteworthy when seen against the rise of phrasal verbs (cf. chap.5). While the analytic approach is characterized by "semantic spreading", namely the "packing thinner [semantic] bundles into two or more words" (Bolinger 1971:45; also Brinton/Akimoto 1999), the synthetic method could be called ‘semantic concentration’, where all the semantic features are crammed into one word. The first of these two approaches is more flexible and often produces a semantically more transparent result. Furthermore, multi-word verbs make use of features that have come about or have grown in importance as part of the analytic trend, namely prepositions and zero-derivations. With the loss of inflectional endings, more prepositions were regularly used, especially following verbs, and this is of course an important prerequisite for them to merge syntactically and/or se mantically with the verb phrases. Zero-derivation facilitates shifts from one word class to another, and thus the use of original nouns in e.g. phrasal verbs or the use of original verbs in verbo-nominal combinations. On the other hand, multi-word verbs also in some way counteract one consequence of analyticity, namely the rather rigid word order of English. Within this order, the verb, or rather the simplex verb, has a definite fixed place leaving little leeway for thematic re-ordering (except with the help of relatively complicated syntactic topicalization structures); verbs consistin g of more than one word, however, especially phrasal verbs, verb-adjective and verbo-
42
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
nominal combinations, can more easily shift (parts of the) verbal predication to more prominent sentence positions. One could call this ‘syntactic spreading’ in analogy to the ‘semantic spreading’ mentioned above. Liefrink (1973:47f) neatly captured this connection between typological features and the use of simplexes or multi-word structures by distinguishing synthetic sentences ("synthetic verb" = a simplex, e.g. to clean), analytic sentences (verb + sentence constituent, e.g. make N clean), and periphrastic sentences (verb + deverbal noun, e.g. give N a clean). While there is a difference between analytic and periphrastic sentences, on a higher general level they are both analytic. Secondly, looking at individual examples of the categories to be treated and their behaviour, one might receive the impression of a rather unsystematic assortment of idiosyncracies. Therefore, as stated in the introduction, they have often ended up in the idiom section of linguistic description. But the first impression is not correct and the idiom sec tion is not where multi-word verbs necessarily belong. Rather, they should be treated as a separate class in their own right. There is a difference between idioms proper and multi-word verbs, although non-compositionality of meaning (which I take to be the prime defining feature of idioms here) is also found among the latter. Prototypical examples of real idioms are kick the bucket "die", beat about the bush "avoid getting to the real topic", or have blue blood "be a member of the aristocracy".5 The most important distinctions between cases like these and multi word verbs as understood in this study are in my opinion the following: (i) The several types of multi-word verbs are each based on a clear syntactic pattern, with the help of which one can relatively freely go on creating such forms fitting the pattern. There is no such regularity with real idioms, and no syntactic constraints on the creation of new idioms — they can take any syntactic form. Multi-word verbs are basically colligations, because their underlying pattern requires the "mutual accompaniment of grammatical categories", not just of individual forms (Mitchell 1958:103, fn. 3). Katz/Postal’s (1963:275f) "lexical idiom", dominated by one word class, e.g. a verb, and forming a complex item within that word class, can also serve as a label for multi-word verbs. Their opposite, phrase idioms, are not thus dominated by any of their syntactic constituents.
5
I will leave syntactically not well-formed idioms, such as trip the light fantastic, go bananas, and those containing unique (not otherwise occurring) elements, e.g. kith and kin, out of consideration, as they are irrelevant for my concerns.
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
43
(ii) Real idioms always have an opaque, i.e. non-compositional, semantic make-up. Multi-word verbs, on the other hand, fill the whole range from completely literal to totally opaque. (iii) An opaque multi-word verb is different from an opaque idiom, in so far as the figurative meaning is inferable from the single constituents of the combination. Even in highly idiomatic units this is possible, provided some common sense and creativity is used. Analysis of real idioms usually requires at least some extralinguistic, socio-historical knowledge. Take for example the euphemistic phrasal verb pass away "die" versus the idiom with the same meaning, kick the bucket. Not even linguists agree on the exact origin of the latter, whereas "pass" = "go, proceed, move onward", i.e. onward to heaven or hell (as the case may be), and "away", i.e. away from the speaker/from this world, yields up the process of figuration quite easily. 6 The second reason why multi-word verbs are treated as a group thus lies in their stable syntactic patterns and the fact that their constituents always retain at least a tiny bit of individuality. What might also be useful in the context of sorting out the problems posed by idiomaticity is Mel’cuk’s proposal (1960) to distinguish between (i) idiomaticity and (ii) stability of collocation (cf. Mitchell’s "colligation", being a special type of collocation, used above). Among the four types Mel’cuk lists, namely (i) stable and idiomatic, (ii) stable and non-idiomatic, (iii) non-stable and idiomatic, (iv) non-stable and non-idiomatic (quoted from Lipka 1972:78), the first and the second can apply to different types of multi-word verbs. The third and fourth are inapplicable as stability is guaranteed by the underlying grammatical patterns. Thirdly, some or all of the multi-word types also share other features. A large proportion of them are lexicalized. And all of them, except for those prepositional verbs where the preposition is a purely syntactic requirement, use their composite nature to produce some shifting, changing or enrichment of meaning. This is achieved not only through the mere presence of the indi6
The argument produced here with regard to multi-word verbs is similar to the approach taken by Gibbs (1990) to what I call ‘real’ idioms here. He argues that "[i]dioms such as pop the question, spill the beans, and lay down the law are "decomposable" because each of their components obviously contributes to their overall figurative interpretations" (422-3), in contrast to idioms such as kick the bucket, shoot the breeze, where this is not the case. Metaphorical mapping motivates idioms of the former kind for the speaker. While I agree that there is just such an internal semantic variability within the sphere of idioms, I also think that Gibbs’ decomposable idioms are still on a different level from (idiomatic) multi-word verbs. In the latter, the metaphorical processes involved are usually less complicated and intricate.
44
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
vidual parts, but also through their different positions in the sentence and through possible modifications of the individual elements. One special semantic trait is the development of aspectual or aktionsart meanings in some of the combinations (especially phrasal verbs and verbo -nominal combinations). While the overall meaning is enhanced, that of the verbal part is often greatly reduced (even in some phrasal verbs, cf. Lipka 1972:152), turning the verb into a functional element. In this respect it is interesting that the same basic, very frequent verbs are used in all the types (cf. also Liefrink 1973), with certain exceptions for (non-idiomatic) prepositional verbs again. Thus, there are obviously the same or very similar systematic processes at work in all these multi-word combinations. This might further mean that the ‘history’ of individual combinations is very similar. They go through an evolutionary process leading to fixedness: from ad hoc expression to fixed expression and finally to single word (cf. Hudson 1998:168). Akimoto (1989, quoted in Brinton/Akimoto 1999:16) describes the development of a verbo-nominal combination as a four-stage process. As this can apply to other multi -word categories as well, I will describe it here in more general terms: stage 1: all the constituents are unrestricted; stage 2: the relation between the constituents becomes sta bilized, the presence of the single elements becomes fixed, and some component parts lose certain features of their original word -class, i.e. become decategorialized; stage 3: re-analysis of the constituent structure occurs (from, e.g. [ lose] [sight of X] to [lose sight of] [X]); stage 4: all of the constituents are idiomatized into a single lexical item. Traugott (in Brinton/Akimoto 1999:248) doubts whether the first of these stages really exists; in my opinion, it does for some combinations (e.g. the take a walk type), but not for others (e.g. rely on). While Traugott (ibid.) merges stages 3 and 4, I would prefer to keep them separate, reserving stage 4 for really opaque combinations. At any point in time, one will find specimens at all four stages; while those at stage 3 and 4 represent the more prototypical cases, sampling in historical contexts should cast its net wider than just those two cases. The last point to be mentioned here concerns the simplex (quasi-) synonyms that exist for most multi -word verbs. This leads to the question of choice on the part of the speaker/writer and to the various effects produced by one or the other choice. Consider, for example, choose vs. make a choice with the alternatives shorter/longer, verbal (dynamic?)/nominal (s tative?), transitive/intransitive use, possibilities of verbal/nominal modification etc. Or consider the set find out / discover with its opposition native versus
Multi-word Verbs as a Group
45
Romance vocabulary, and all that this is supposed to entail (e.g. in/formality, emotional value, hard words). Also consider the relationship between do over and redo, the latter standing for synthetic derivational word -formation processes; with cut short and shorten, however, the difference is less morphological than semantic. These few example s shall suffice here to show that multi-word verbs raise interesting questions in the fields of semantics and stylistics.
4. Categories of Multi-word Verbs This chapter will be devoted to a clarification of how the five multi -word verb categories are to be understood in this investigation. For this purpose, it will be necessary to review to a considerable extent the linguist ic opinion found in the literature so far. The basis of the definitions is the situation found in PDE; therefore, I will use modern examples, taken from the British National Corpus (BNC), as illustrations. 4.1 Phrasal Verbs The term ‘phrasal verb’ is problematic for two reasons: on the one hand, the category in question has not always been called that but, e.g., verb -particle combination (Fraser 1976) or discontinuous verb (Live 1965), and on the other hand, ‘phrasal verb’ has sometimes served as a cover term including also prepositional verbs (e.g. Sroka 1972) and maybe even other categories (e.g. Dixon 1982). Here, the most common approach will be followed, namely that phrasal verbs are relatively unitary combinations of a verb and a particle, which is best of all described as an adverb, but not as a preposition. 1 While any kind of lexical verb could theoretically be a part of a phrasal verb (which, however, is not the case, as will be seen later), the word following the verb belongs to a relatively closed class of invariable items. The following list of possible particles in phrasal verbs is based on those given in Quirk et al. (1985:1151), Cowie & Mackin (1975:lxxx), and Fraser (1976:5), as well as my own data (cf. also Bolinger 1971:17f): aback, aboard, about, above, across, after, ahead, along, apart, around, ashore, aside, astray, asunder, away, back, behind, by, counter, down, forth, forward(s), home, in, off, on, out, over, past, round, through, to, together, under, up This is not a complete list (which might be hard to achieve anyway, according to Bolinger); some of the particles given in Cowie & Mackin (or also in Kennedy 1920) have been left out as irrelevant for the present 1
In the following discussion of phrasal verbs I will ignore all those approaches that do not regard them as multi-word verbs. Most of them are found in the generative camp and involve a small clause interpretation, cf. for example Bas Aarts (1989), den Dikken (1995), or Kayne (1985). While trying to solve some theoretical syntactical problems, they completely side-step important semantic and communicative/ functional implications. I do not think that a purely syntactical approach to phrasal verbs (or multi-word verbs in general) can really be fruitful.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
47
analysis. The italicized items in the list can be used as prepositions as well, which is the reason why so much trouble is taken in the lit erature to distinguish phrasal and prepositional verbs. Which sequences of verb and adverb are then to be accepted as phrasal verbs here? To start with, I will regard both completely literal types (verb, or both verb and particle used in their literal or adverbial sense, e.g. pull away, yield up) and figurative, idiomatic combinations (e.g. fall out "happen", put off "postpone") as phrasal verbs (similar to Denison 1981; and cf. Bolinger 1971:16, who mentions Fairclough 1965 as doing the same), in contrast to, e.g., Quirk et al. (1985; cf. above) or Dixon (1982). Idio maticity, after all, does not emerge out of nowhere, but is based in some way or other on the regular patterns of the language. Literal phrasal verbs are the core from which figurative types are ultimately derived, and to which they are still connected by an identical, or in idiosyncratically frozen idioms at least similar, syntactical behaviour. Thus, idiomatic phrasal verbs cannot be understood without their literal background, and in the less idiomatic cases the connection, the underlying thought process of semantic idiomaticization, is still graphically clear. Besides, there is also a very pragmatic reason for including all kinds of phrasal verbs: there is a gradience or cline, reaching from completely literal to totally opaque cases, with both shading into the other (cf. also Bolinger 1971:36,n.12). It would be very hard to draw a clear dividing line somewhere — nor would it be very helpful for the matter in hand (also Kroch 1979:222f). Fraser (1976:3), on the other hand, does draw this line, and while he ostensibly does it on syntactic grounds (position in action nominalizations, constituents in gapped sentences, modification, contrastive stress), the result is a con trast between more literal types — his verb-adverbial combinations — and more idiomatic units — his verb-particle combination. 2 As stated above (chap.3), there is an intransitive and a transitive typ e3 — and the most usual indicators or tests for phrasal verbs unfortunately work with the transitive combinations alone. In order to include both types I will start the discussion about what phrasal verbs are with the particles and their function. The particles belong to the class of primary, invariable, oneword adverbs, such as those exemplified by the list above. By ‘primary’ I understand that they should not be derived by any regular processes from 2
A good discussion of Fraser’s approach in this respect is found in Declerck (1978:314f). Lindner (1981:26-31) also voices her criticism, pointing out e.g. that Fraser does not actually succeed in separating neatly the things he wants to separate. 3 Fraser (1976:4) claims that intransitive combinations are relatively rare, and Live (1965:438) seems to share his opinion. However, I am not aware of any empirical study that has tested this claim.
48
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
adjectives or nouns (e.g. sad — sadly, sky — skyward — i.e. what Bolinger calls "pure adverbs"). Also, the particles must not be pure prepositions, i.e. they must either not be followed by a noun phrase at all (ability to stand alone): (1)
The next day a high-tech caption machine broke down. (BNC A4N 10) And the one night, one bright and starlit night, a true free dragon came by to pay a call. (BNC A6J 839) Would you like Jenny to go along as well? (BNC A0F 3176)
Or they must not be the head of the following noun phrase, i.e. form a prepo sitional phrase constituent with it: (2)
These pieces, on view in London, also went along the smugglers’ network. (BNC A1Y 492) ... and so every airhead ... rushed out to buy one and take it up a mountain. (BNC AS3 1314)
vs. (3)
From 1624 to 1640 Dutton bought up the land round Sherborne Park ... (BNC Ab4 367)
Also, they must not refer or relate to any noun phrase in another sentence position as in (4) (stranded preposition, cf. 4.2): (4)
So, this is the situation you must practise and be able to cope with. (BNC A0H 1658)
Thus, (1) and (3) are instances of phrasal verbs, whereas (2), and (4) are not. In many cases, a prepositional phrase can be supplied by the imagination or socio-cultural knowledge of the reader/hearer (Dixon 1982:9), and the particle could actually be called a reduced prepositional phrase, as in for into the room in (5) (cf. Bolinger 1971:23). 4 (5)
I had orders not to take in tea until half past ten. (BNC A0D 2238) i.e. take into the room
Here, it is important that the reduction is not a case of conte xt-determined ellipsis (cf. Fairclough, as quoted by Bolinger 1971:21), by which I mean that the ‘missing’ element should not be mentioned in the same or the 4
There are also other theoretical views of this matter. Declerck (1977) sees it as a presupposition, and Legum (1968) postulates a rule of "particle incorporation" into a PP. While the latter is quite nice, because it starts out with the phrasal verb particle, the exact linguistic way these structures come about does not really matter. The important point is that a reader/listener can and probably does supply the "missing" information in his mind.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
49
immediately surrounding sentences. The simple fact that the particle can also stand on its own changes its status from preposition to adverbial (Lipka 1972:175); these cases are therefore included in the class of phrasal verbs. While Fraser (1976:46-49) admits to the similar behaviour of the reduced prepositional phrase and particles, he nevertheless excludes them from his verb-particle combination, because they are in his view semantically independent of the verb. I agree here with König (1973:84) that it would in any case be difficult to sort out prepositional reduction cases from others. 5 Another point of difference between adverbs and pure prepositions is noticeable in speech (and therefore not that helpful with a written historical corpus), namely the fact that adverbs can be or are accented, whereas prepo sitions are not (e.g. Fraser 1976:2; but denied by Sroka 1972:146). Lipka (1972) and Pelli (1976) use this as their main criterion. Furthermore, the pos sibility of contrastive accent can separate phrasal verb particles from other adverbs (Bolinger 1971:13f).6 Bolinger (1971:chap.2) discusses three types of particles, namely adverbs, prepositional adverbs and adpreps. While adverbs are the clear cases, i.e. those in the list above that can only function as adverbs (e.g. away, aside), prepositional adverbs "oscillate between preposition and adverb", which he exemplifies by "She knocked down the argument. She knocked the argument down." (ibid. 26). Both these types help to make up phrasal verbs, and will be accepted in this study as well. Bolinger’s adprep, which exhibits a dual constituency, being drawn both to the verb and to the following noun phrase, is found in sentence c. (his examples): (6)
He ran down the road. a. He ran it down. (disparaged it) - adverb b. He ran down it. (did his running somewhere down the road) - preposition c. He ran down it. (descended it) - adprep
Again I agree with Bolinger, so that in the present study adprep cases will be definitely excluded from the phrasal verb class. Another interesting question connected with the particles is their se mantic characteristics. Here I am not concerned with semantic features of 5
A special problem in this general context concerns verbs followed by the sequence "out of". These can be either a verb followed by the complex preposition "out of", or a phrasal verb with the particle "out" followed by a prepositional phrase headed by "of" (some out-phrasal verbs may be reduction cases from "out of"). As this is a very hard and basically extremely subjective decision to make, I will follow Pelli (1976) and Denison (1981) in excluding those cases altogether. 6 For papers devoted to the question of stress in phrasal verbs, cf., e.g., Eitrem (1903), and Taha (1960).
50
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
individual adverbs, but with generalisations valid for all adverbs occurring in phrasal verbs. From an etymological perspective, the items in question all originally served to denote location and/or direction in space. For literal or nearly literal uses, Bolinger (1971:chap.7) proposes two necessary features of phrasal verb particles, namely (i) motion-through-location, and (ii) terminus or result, thereby excluding all manner, time, place, simple direction and stance adverbials. Dixon (1982:40) also regards motion as important, whereas Lipka (1972:177) states that when the particle functions as a locative adverb (i.e. literal use) it denotes direction and adds the feature +dynamic to the whole combination. I assume this comes about by different definitions of the term ‘direction’, not through a fundamental difference as regards the particles. Bolinger wants to exclude, among others, up/down in the sense of upward(s)/downward(s) with the help of criterion (i) above — and those are items that Lipka excludes as well (similar: Fraser 1976:49 f).7 For some (literally used) particles, however, Bolinger’s description ’motionthrough-location’ seems problematic; there is hardly any motion whatsoever in, e.g., together, home, by, counter, apart, behind, asunder, whereas about seems to convey ‘pure’ instead of directed (i.e. through location) motion. Some of these have a clear result and are thus saved by his second criterion (which he sees as the more important one), but this still leaves about (e.g. blow/carry about) and by (pass/come by — literal senses), which are hard to attach any resultative features to. As I see it, the particle should either have the feature ‘motion’ in general (not location and not direc tion in the sense of -ward(s) adverbials) or the feature ‘result’ or both — with the last perhaps being the prototypical cases. Both Bolinger (1971:92-95) and Fraser (1976:22-25) also remarked on the fact that the real verbal force in some cases seems to lie in the adverb while the verb fulfils the role of a manner de scription, as in (one of) Bolinger’s examples: (7)
Comb down your hair. (to down by combing)
The feature ‘result’ inherent in some particles has given rise to a somewhat transferred aspectual or aktionsart use of particles in some phrasal verbs, for example adding a continuative/iterative (Live 1965), perfective (Kennedy 1920; Lipka 1972), intensity/totality (Live 1965) telic (Brinton 1988), or completive/terminative sense (Fraser 1976; Live 1965) — an example of this would be buy up (3) above. A causative interpretation added by the particle 7
Fraser (1976:51-59) excludes more than most others from his verb-particle combination class, on the grounds of the basically adverbial nature of their second constituents. While I tend to agree with the exclusion of his "kiss-back" cases, I would rather include all his other exclusions ("turn off", "drive back", "babble on" cases) in the class of phrasal verbs.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
51
is also possible (Live 1965:436). There is, however, no fixed system and also no one-to-one correspondence between a certain particle and a certain aspectual meaning (Live 1965:437; Bolinger 1971:chap.8). Particles in idiomatic phrasal verbs (e.g. blow up "explode") are not affected by any of the above interpretations. As regards the (non-semantic) function of the particles, general state ments are harder to make. Sometimes, the addition of a particle changes the transitivity of a verb, making it either transitive ( stare vs. stare down) or intransitive (e.g. take vs. take off) (Kennedy 1920:26; Fraser 1976:8; Dixon 1982:30). In other cases, it is only the added particle that creates a verb from words otherwise not used as verbs on their own (Fraser 1966:47 f), for instance ante up, zip up. Another point with regard to phrasal verbs seems to be active combinations with a passive signification (Kennedy 1920:27). These occurrences, however, are not part of a systematic whole, and also not very numerous (Dixon ibid.). As to the syntactic tests which have been proposed to determine the class of phrasal verbs, there is one test that works for both transiti ve and intransitive combinations. It concerns the insertion of an adverb be tween the verb and the particle, which should not be possible for real phrasal verbs (with certain exceptions, such as right, all, the hell) (Bolinger 1971:11ff; also 117ff; Fraser 1976:3;25ff). Fraser sorts out the ‘interruptable’ cases into his verb-adverbial combination class as opposed to verb-particle combinations (= phrasal verbs proper), whereas Bolinger points out that varying degrees of bondage between verb and adverb, as well as the position on the scale of idiomaticity, play a role. The only thing this test will do is clearly divide the really idiomatic cases (no insertion possible) from the completely literal ones (such as (8)), and probably leave an uncertain area of more or less transferred uses in the middle. (8) (9) (10)
Cadfael picked up the psaltery with due respect, and laid it safely aside on the little prayer desk. (BNC G0M 1620) On the day of the wedding, just for a short while, all strife was laid aside. (BNC G2E 1669) His mocking manner seemed laid quite aside. (from Declerck 1978:315)
Insertion of e.g. completely in (9) might be acceptable for some speakers, in some contexts or it might not be. Insertion might be more restricted with intransitive combinations in general, however (cf. Quirk et al. 1985:1152). As I will not apply a literal-idiomatic division in the definition of phrasal verbs, the simple insertion criterion will also not be used here. However, another insertion test, namely that of whole adver bial phrases, may profitably
52
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
distinguish between phrasal verbs and other verb-adverb combinations, as Vestergaard (1974:305f) points out. The remaining four tests then apply only to transitive phrasal verbs. 8 The first of these is the transformation of the phrasal verb into an action nominal (Fraser 1976:3), such as (11): (11)
... the most learned and certain Rule for the finding out of the Longitudes of Places (SciB1649)
Verb-preposition sequences cannot be transformed in the same way, i.e. *the seeking after of the gifts is not possible. (12)
... the very seeking after the gifts of Gods Spirit (RelA1653)
However, Bolinger (1971:8ff) points out that this test does not work with all phrasal verbs, whereas it does work with some verb -adprep-combinations, and that, in general, the nature of the action involved seems to play a role. This goes to make it more of a semantic than a syntactic test. The last three tests are very similar and have to do with the relative positions of particle and object (Bolinger 1971:10f; 15f, chap.5; Fraser 1976:16ff). First, the particle can stand on either side of the noun object (cf. (13a-b)), which is not true of pure prepositions which can only precede the noun, nor of pure adverbs which must usually follow it. The weight and length of the noun phrase might influence this test, however; in (14a) the placement of about after the object phrase would be highly unlikely. But it is hard to make general statements about what length of the object phrase enforces post-verbal position of the particle; clausal and gerundival objects, however, always do (Wood 1956:19; Van Dongen 1919:329). Secondly, if the object in question is a pronoun, it will precede the particle (cf. (14b)), whereas it will follow a preposition. (13a) There’s no need to nail the shelves down, ... (BNC A16 1079) (13b) Nail down the central panel — ... (BNC AM5 1582) (14a) ... and bring about an irreversible shift of power and wealth to the working class (BNC A3T 5) (14b) Eleanor of Aquitaine, the princess whose marriage to an English king brought this about, is one of the femmes fatales of the Cantos; ... (BNC A1B 81)
8
A possible fifth test is passivization of the phrasal verb, which was used for example by Live (1965) and Lipka (1972). I will not deal with this test here, because I am not at all convinced of its usefulness. It cannot distinguish phrasal verb particles from other adverbs in ways which the other tests could not do as well or even better, nor can it separate phrasal from prepositional verbs.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
53
(14c) And it was that lack of hits which probably helped bring about the suicides. (BNC A6E 1273) This is a test that always works except when the pronoun receives contrastive stress for some reason, as then it can follow the particle. Finally, Bolinger’s favourite test says that "the particle can precede a simple definite noun phrase (a proper name or the plus a common noun) without taking it as its object" (1971:15) (cf. (14c)). Again this sorts out both pure adverbs and pure prepositions, and it emphasizes the unitary nature of verb + parti cle. Bolinger (ibid. 112) calls combinations passing this test "compounds of a sort". The restrictions on the characteristics of the object are the important point here, as heavy noun phrases could change the results for pure adverbs dramatically. Also, Fraser (1976:18) states that with very short noun phrases the particle prefers the position immediately following the verb. Wood (1956:23;24) thinks that generally the post-verbal position is the more usual one, but especially so with more abstract and metaphorical expressions; the latter opinion is shared by Bolinger (1971:96). It is also important, when applying these tests, to keep in mind that some phrasal verb combinations have been fossilized with either post-verbal or post-nominal positions of the particle, with no change being possible any longer (cf. e.g. the listing in Fraser 1976:19f; Wood 1956:25). Such cases are included by Bolinger (1971:113) under his second-level stereotyping and exemplified by take in washing (post-verbal) and bring the victims to (postnominal). A possible test for levels of stereotyping is fronting of the particle, which works only with completely or fairly literal particles, e.g.: (15)
Down went the Bluecher [= ship]. (BNC AA9 912)
There is of course the question about the motivation for these different syntactic positions and transformations. Erades (1961), and Bolinger (1971), basing himself on the former, find the reason in the information structure of the sentence and the amount of news value or newsworthiness inherent in the object. Objects introducing something new will normally have end-position (following the particle), and these will usually be nouns or noun phrases. On the other hand, objects that denote something already known or inferable from the context come between verb and particle; this applies to nouns which have been mentioned shortly before in the context, pronouns, and "semi-pronominal nouns" (Erades 1961:58) such as thing(s), matter. The unitary or compound nature of phrasal verbs mentioned above seems to me to be confirmed by their use in non-verbal contexts and in wordformation processes (Live 1965:429). Thus, there is conversion to nouns
54
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
(e.g. take-off n.)9, which Lipka (1972:138) calls an "extremely productive process", nominalization with the help of suffixes, or as adjectives (cf. Vestergaard 1974:307), like (16) and (17), just to mention some example s. (16) (17)
the total fed-upness with the Tories (Peter Crampton, MEP, June 1997) badly thought out international marketing programmes (BNC A60 26)
Pre- and suffixation is especially interesting, as it emphasizes word status. Nevertheless, this fact is hardly ever commented on; the only one who sees it as important for multi-word verbs in general is apparently Leisi (1985:119). As hinted at above, something still remains to be said about the verbal element of phrasal verbs. In theory, any kind of verb would be possible, but it does not turn out to be that way in reality. Statistically, there are clear preferences to be found. Monosyllabic or disyllabic verbs with the accent on the first syllable are the dominant group, and those are usually Germanic (Anglo-Saxon or Norse) elements (Bolinger 1971:175; Fraser 1976:13f; Live 1965:430). Kennedy (1920:29) even gives tentative figures: of the monosyllabic verbs only 18% were non-Germanic, whereas with the disyllabic ones the percentage rises to about 55%. Verbs with more than two syllables are rare: Fraser (1976:14) lists exactly 13. Furthermore, it is the very common and multi-functional verbs (cf. e.g. Kirchner 1952) which also seem to be the most common ones in phrasal verbs. On the other hand, there are also many monosyllabic verbs which never occur together with a particle; while this is thus an important prerequisite, it is not a guarantee. Fraser (1976:9) lists the following as the most productive verbs with many different meanings each: take, put, go, get, turn, lay, set, run, make, and fall. Potter (1965:287) has a list of the 24 most frequent verbs, which include the ones from Fraser plus back, blow, break, bring, call, come, give, hold, keep, let, look, send, stand, and work (but notice that he includes prepositional verbs under the term phrasal verb!). As regards semantic features of verbs in these combinations, it seems that in general stative verbs such as know, want, see, hope etc. are not used to create phrasal verbs (Fraser 1976:11). Furthermore, Fraser thinks that it is possible to find whole groups of systematic combinations (i.e. those with consistent meaning alternation brought about by the particle (ibid. 5)) in which the verbs have identical or similar semantic traits. An interesting case is also the existence of a group of verbs which seldom or never occur without a particle (Kennedy 1920:29), e.g. point out. The result of the union between a verb and an adverbial particle is a unitary phrasal verb, but the observed differences between exis ting phrasal 9
Sørensen 1986, Preuss 1962, Neubert 1973, and Lindelöf 1937 are studies dealing specifically with this point.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
55
verbs have brought about attempts to look for some ordering principle. Bolinger’s semantic-idiomatic system (1971: chap.9), which would have profited from a clearer description and explanation on the part of the author, distinguishes between First- and Second-Level Stereotyping as well as Firstand Second-Level Metaphor. While in first-level stereotyping verb and particle, although forming a unit, retain their individual meanings (e.g. toss up), the second level is a completely opaque, non-compositional combination (e.g. throw up "vomit"). The metaphor levels come in between the two stereotyping levels on the semantic cline, first-level metaphor implying the non-literal, transferred use of the particle (e.g. buy up), and second-level metaphor the transferred, figurative use of the whole combination (e.g. make up a face). Fraser (1966:51f; 1976) differentiates into systematic and unsystematic combinations: systematic combinations are all those that share identical co-occurrence restrictions with the simple verb, while the unsystematic ones are all the rest. Systematic combina tions are further subdivided into a literal type (adverbial sense of particle, e.g. hand out), a completive type (i.e. an aktionsart type, e.g. hang up), and a third type with neither a literal nor a completive particle (e.g. fight off, cross out, note down). Declerck (1977) bases his classification on semantic features (especially the underlying CAUSE), producing three types: (i) locomotion phrasal verb (walk in/out), (ii) instrumental phrasal verb (comb out), and (iii) manner phrasal verb (cut out). König (1973:90) also has three semantic groups, according to whether the meaning of the whole unit is the result of (i) meaning of verb + original adverbial meaning of particle, (ii) meaning of verb + aktionsart meaning of particle, or (iii) non-compositionality, i.e. fully idiomatic combinations. In my opinion, Bolinger’s system is the most helpful one, even if the terms are not very happily chosen. The only thing this classification seems to miss is those cases where the particle is apparently re dundant, i.e. the verb could actually stand on its own without a (major?) change of meaning, for example meet up vs. meet. But probably depleted particle use could be accommodated as ‘transferred’ under first -level metaphor, if one stretched the definition somewhat. To sum up, in the present study, the following approach to phrasal verbs will be taken as the basis for collecting data from the Lampeter Corpus. Phrasal verbs are combinations of a verb and a primary, invariable adverb, the latter including the heads of re duced prepositional phrases but excluding adpreps. The semantic make-up of these adverbs should contain the features ‘motion’ and/or ‘result’. Two tests ar e seen as important, namely (i) if the object is a pronoun, the particle must follow it, and (ii) the particle can precede a simple noun phrase without taking it as its object. Of course, it is hard to apply any kind of test of whatever nature in an histo rical context
56
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
— after all, there is no native speaker of EModE available to give his or her judgement. Thus, apart from naturally occurring transformations, the only way is to use PDE grammaticality statements, and hope that they will not be completely inadequate for the older period. And finally one more point: everything in the cline from the completely literal to the totally opaque units will be accepted. 4.2 Prepositional Verbs "Since none of the criteria for prepositional or phrasal -prepositional verbs are compelling, it is best to think of the boundary of these categories as a scale" is how Quirk et al. (1985:1165f) sum up their treatment of this category. Certainly, prepositional verbs are the most difficult to define and the ones nearest the borderline of all possible multi-word verbs. This stems from the fact that (most, if not all) sentences containing a verb -preposition sequence allow two different syntactic analyses, depending on the various possibilities of bracketing of constituents. The first and more straightforward solution is SVA (cf. (18a)), which involves a simplex verb followed by an adverbial phrase, i.e. in this case there is no prepositional verb. Certain peculiarities of English, however, point towards the likelihood of an SVO analysis as in (18b). (18a) [All four books] [speak] [of a "someone other".] (18b) [All four books] [speak of] [a "someone other".] (BNC A05 493) The facts favouring (18b) are both structural/syntactic and semantic. The first involve among others the curious prepositional passive (cf. (19)) and the various preposition stranding possibilities (cf. (20)), e.g. in relative clauses and topicalized sentences, while the latter is represented by clearly idiomatic (mostly semantically opaque) verb-preposition combinations (cf. (21) vs. literal (22)). (19) (20)
Her Birmingham background is hinted at ... (BNC A06 913) ... and never try to lift more than you can easily cope with. (BNC A0G 2204)
(21)
"... and thus we come by those ideas we have of yellow, white, [etc.]" (BNC ABM 816) Soldiers from Stirling would have come by Crieff and Amulree, ... (BNC A0N2171)
(22)
All of these point to a greater cohesion between verb and preposition than between preposition and following noun phrase, but they nevertheles s —
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
57
except for the idiomatic cases — do not completely invalidate the SVA analysis.10 While the SVO solution neatly explains a few things, it also poses a new problem of its own, namely the necessity of structural re -analysis, from the bracketing of (18a) — which is assumed to be the primary one — to that of (18b) above, creating a complex verb (Denison 1993:124). I will simply take re-analysis for granted here without discussing it any further. The following paragraphs will deal with the delimitation of the category prepositional verb to be used in this study, taking up the points men tioned above and a few others of importance as I go along. Looking at common verb-preposition sequences such as depend on, look after, wait for, or belong to, it is apparent that certain collocational restrictions (cf. Palmer 1965:180 + 1974:215) or even a collocational fixity is at work here. According to Davison (1980:48) and Vestergaard (1977:58), the preposition involved should not be freely substitutable by another, the latter stating the same condition for the verb. It is for the preposition that this condition is really important, as one can assume that it is the verb that selects the accompanying preposition, and not vice versa. Of course, in some cases the preposition is substitutable, e.g. besides look after there is also look for, look into, but the exchange in these cases is not ‘free’ but governed by different meanings which also affect look itself. Furthermore, this criterion should not be taken to mean that the verb should never occur without the preposition, as, e.g., rely on, if it is to be a ‘real’ prepositional verb. Depend, look, wait, belong can all stand on their own, but either that involves different (shades of) meaning(s) or different syntactic environments, e.g. That depends. That depends what you mean. The important thing is that in a certain kind of usage the preposition is a fixed member of the sequence. If collocational fixity is taken one step further, so to speak, one reaches the stage of lexicalization (e.g. Vestergaard 1977:58), and Bolinger 10
There are indeed approaches which deny the existence of prepositional verbs or at least think them superfluous. Götz/Herbst (1989:226) in their review of Quirk et al. (1985) criticize the view taken there on the grounds that it leads to an increase of both the syntactical rules and the lexicon. Huddleston (1984:200-202) does not see verbpreposition sequences as a single syntactic constituent, based on two things especially: (i) the position of an adverbial, cf. Ed relied steadfastly on the minister vs. *Ed relied on steadfastly the minister, and (ii) the possibility of coordination, or rather repetition of the preposition, cf. Ed relied on the minister and on his solicitor. The first point is of course problematic, but one also cannot say, e.g., *Ed trusted completely the minister — adverbs simply do not often intervene between verb, whether simplex or complex, and a simple direct object. The fact that the adverb can intrude between the verb and its preposition is due to the janus-faced character of the preposition and the unresolved, wavering status of the noun phrase. This also applies to the coordination problem.
58
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
(1977:59) thinks it possible that "the great majority of prepositional verbs are lexicalized". He does not specify his definition of lexicalization there, but if one applies Bauer’s (1983:48f) terminology, for example, many prepositional verbs can certainly be called institutionalized and a certain amount even semantically lexicalized. This latter leads us to the criterion of meaning. It has been observed that a verb-preposition sequence is more likely to be a prepositional verb if it has a unitary (i.e. usually idiomatic) meaning (Palmer 1974:216; Bolinger 1977:58). The question of what constitutes a ‘unitary meaning’ is of course a difficult one, but the substitution with a simplex synonym (despite the problems of synonymity) can be and often has been used as a valid aid. However, this criterion should not be overempha sized, but only used in addition to others. 11 Also, it is sometimes over-inclusive (e.g. go into — enter), but on the other hand excludes good candidates, such as look after, which have no simplex synonym. These considerations are perhaps of more importance for the internal description of the group of prepositional verbs and of the gradience or cline observable within it. In this context, Goyvaerts’ (1973:560f) identification of several subgroups of prepositional verbs falling into two broad categories is of particular interest. These categories are (i) purely prepositional verbs (e.g. look after, believe in) and (ii) verbs which need a preposition to introduce their object (e.g. consist of, rely on). I take both kinds to be prepositional verbs, although they exhibit some differing characteristics. Instead of concentrating on the verb and the preposition, as done so far, another approach is to examine the status of the noun phrase following them. If an SVO analysis is to be upheld, the noun must be independent of the preposition preceding it. To my knowledge, Vestergaard (1977) contains the most comprehensive treatment of that problem so far. A few of the — more important — points made by him shall suffice here. The noun must be a role-playing participant in the clause, and it must be interpretable as a "true participant" rather than as a circumstantial element. He illustrates thi s with the following example: (23)
I get up and talk about it in the House of Commons...
where "(about) it" is a true participant, whereas "in the House of Commons" is not (Vestergaard 1977:46). This is similar to Bolinger’s (1977:67) ap 11
De Haan (1988:124) doubts even in the case of idiomatic combinations that their status as prepositional verbs is absolutely clear. This is in clear opposition to Quirk et al.’s stance of including only idiomatic units among their prepositional verb class (already criticized above). It is also notable here that Palmer changed his mind between 1965 and 1974, excluding non-idiomatic cases in the later edition without stating his reasons for so doing.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
59
proach, who uses the "true-patient" status of the noun as an argument for the possibility of passivization, and as an extension, it seems, also for preposi tional verbs as such. Vestergaard’s circumstantial elements are in Bolinger’s (ibid. + 75) terminology purely spatial, temporal or existential relationships. Two of Vestergaard’s (1977:49f) further tests underline the point made above: the noun alone (i.e. not the preposition-noun sequence) must be replaceable by a relative pronoun or another pronominal form, and again t he noun alone can be topicalized in a pseudo-cleft sentence, something which would not be possible for "the House of Commons" in (23), for example. The question transformation test is also concerned with the status of the noun, insofar as it serves to exclude prepositional phrases that are simply predication adjuncts (i.e. Vestergaard’s circumstantial elements). These latter can be questioned adverbially by means of "where, when, how, why" (cf. (24)), while a noun that is more like a direct object of the verb-preposition combination would require a non-adverbial question form with "who, what" (cf. (25)) (Quirk et al. 1985:1165; Diensberg 1988:90). (24) (25)
... the one [ladder] that hangs on the side of the potting shed. (BNC A0D 2329) Where does it hang? By now they too knew they could call on me. (BNC A0R 469) Who could they call on?
While this test is very convenient, it does lead to contradictory results, e.g. in cases where both questions forms are possible as in (26) (cf. e.g. de Haan 1988:122). (26)
It was in those far-off days as they strolled through the parks ... (BNC A08 1356) What did they stroll through? Where did they stroll?
Furthermore, the results from this test sometimes collide with those of another test, namely the possibility of passivization. It is a characteristic of objects that they can become the subject of a passive clause, whereas this is not possible for complements (which the question test above would admit) or adjuncts. If therefore the noun of the prepositional phrase can become the passive subject, this means that it performs the same function to the verb preposition combination as it would to a simplex transitive verb (Vestergaard 1977:56; similar Bolinger 1977:58; also Kilby 1984). Van der Gaaf (1930:1) called it direct object in these cases, while the term "prepositional object" (e.g. Quirk et al. 1985:1156) is probably a better choice in order to highlight the differences that nevertheless exist between the two types. (27a-b) are regular prepositional passives, so to speak; for example, "this" stands in the same relation to "look into" as it would to "examine" in This needs to be examined.
60
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
(27a) ... I should just hate to see my name on anything that could not be relied on, ... (BNC AHA 441) (27b) This needs to be looked into. (BNC A0D 2439) (28) (29)
Despite the spread of private pensions, 75 per cent of pensioners lived on less than £3,500 a year. (BNC A50 516) *Less than £3,500 a year was lived on by 75% of pensioners. His bed had been slept in, but there was no sign of Travis. (BNC JY1 427)
In both cases in (27) the question test from above would yield a what-form as well. While the last is also true of (28) (cf. what did they live on?), the passive is impossible because of the nature of "a small salary"; it is probably not "affected" enough by the action to serve as a true patient. (29), on the other hand, would certainly not pass the question test (taking where?), but "this bed" can be interpreted as especially "affected", because of the vi sible result of Travis having slept in it (probably messy sheets); no longer visible effects, but instead a famous former occupant (e.g. Napoleon) of the bed, indicated by a by-phrase, would make the sentence acceptable as well (cf. Diensberg 1988:96; Couper-Kuhlen 1979:9). As Couper-Kuhlen has shown, the semantic make-up of the noun in question plays an important role for the possibility of passivization, quite apart from such intracta ble factors as frequencies and highly fluctuating acceptability ratings of prepositional passives among speakers. Thus, the passivization test probably does not say as much about the cohesion between verb and preposition as one might wish it did. Live on might be suspected to belong to the class of prepositional verbs (Diensberg 1988:89 puts it into a sort of middle class of verbs with a "prepositional complement"), whereas sleep in one would definitely want to exclude — and in neither case do the tests help very much. Preposition stranding in general, i.e. in non-passive contexts, which at first sight is a good pointer towards the cohesion of verb and preposition, is called inconclusive by de Haan (1988:123), whereas Denison (1985b:192; also Dekeyser 1990) goes even further and attributes it simply to the fact that the (preferred) uninflected relative cannot be preceded by a preposition — and, one should add, that is of course completely impossible in the case of the zero relative. A point to be mentioned in favour of a multi-word verb interpretation is the possibility of coordination of the verb-preposition sequence with a simplex verb, both sharing a common object, which Denison (1985:191; cf. also Bennett 1980:106f, and Jespersen 1928:III,272, with examples) referred to as a proof for "structural re-analysis". Later, Denison (1993:124) did not seem so sure about it, calling it a less secure test than passivi zation. I would sug-
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
61
gest that it also depends on the way the coordination is syntactically realised, cf. the following sentences. (30) (31) (32)
they tend to choose subjects they like and approve of. (BNC A35 32) Many people with AIDS have to spend long periods of time in hospital unless there is someone at home who can help and look after them. (BNC A00 81) The 10 per cent or so of the population which votes for Sinn Fein appears to approve of, or at least to tolerate readily , the IRA’s attempts to kill soldiers and policemen. (BNC A2P 476)
(32) seems to me to make the most convincing case, as the verb -preposition sequence is separated from its remaining prepositional phrase or object by the simplex verb, and there is nothing that motivates this particular sequence other than the choice of the writer. In (31), the V -P-N sequence is still intact, leaving both interpretations open; moreover, "help" could be seen as bein g used in an intransitive way — although I find that unlikely here. (30) exhibits the well-established preposition stranding pattern and the addition of another verb is no major step here. While there is this gradience in importance, I would nevertheless accept all the kinds of coordination of transitives preceding the object as proof. Another point, which is not often mentioned, but which Poutsma (1926:II,34) claims as a proof for a complete union between verb and prepo sition, is the fact that the past participle and the preposition can be used as an attributive adjunct/as an adjective, e.g. longed-for peace (Live 1965:429). Some of the most common of these transformations contain the negative suffix un-, e.g. unheard-of, unthought-of. After the foregoing discussion of the situation as found in the litera ture, it is now time to determine what will actually be used as criteria for identifying prepositional verbs in this study. Collocational fixity is, I think, an important point, that is the co-occurrence of one verb with one preposition, either always or consistently in a certain meaning or usage. Both idiomatic and non-idiomatic combinations will be accepted, on the same grounds as in the case of phrasal verbs (cf. 5.1. above). The following tests will be the ones to be applied: the question test, the passivization test, as well as the test whether the noun is a role-playing participant instead of a circumstantial element. Of course, not all of them have to work; I am also inclined to see the first and the last as the more important ones. The combinations belong to and believe in, for example, will be treated as prepositional verbs here, as it is only the passivization test that does not work in their case. The last mentioned test implies certain cha racteristics — or rather absent features — of the preposition: it definitely excludes purely spatial, temporal or other distinctive uses of prepo sitions, such as cause,
62
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
manner, instrument, purpose (cf. Poutsma 1926:II, 32). In general, the preposition as part of a prepositional verb should have very little or no mean ing of its own independent of the verb and stand in no opposition to other prepositions (König 1973:67-69). This type of preposition has been described as elements with affix character or function (cf. Leisi 1985:122; Rauh 1990:486ff + 1992:363), "pure markers" with the function of making the verb transitive (Allerton 1982: 16f; 59), or as "inherent preposi tions" (Dixon 1992:271), in each case in contrast to truly lexical elements. Consider the difference between the following a. (‘meaningful’, i.e. lexical preposition) and b. examples: (33a) It should work with a hammer. (instr.) He will wait at the station. (spatial) We will meet again on Monday. (temp.) (33b) It does not consist with the theory. They finally arrived at a conclusion. They insisted on another meeting. Thus (fight) for/against N (34a), for example, will be excluded here, as well as e.g. talk/deal (in the sense of "trade") etc. with N (34b), but not deal with in the sense "to act in regard to, administer, handle, dispose in any way of (a thing)" (OED s.v. deal v., 16+17; cf. (35)). In these excluded cases, it seems that the preposition has a more explicit, closer connection with whatever fol lows than with the preceding verb. (34a) I prest my deere Christ not to drown us, for said I, we fight for thy Kingly office, ... (RelB1650) (34b) In most places in India, we are in effect our own Law-makers, and can arrest and imprison any Natives that deal with us, or owe us money; ... (EcA1681) vs. (35) ... reviews within the periphery did begin to deal with the relationship between form and content in far more radical ways ... ( BNC ARD 598) In contrast to most approaches to prepositional verbs, I will, like de Haan (1988:134, n.1), accept only those among that class which he describes as "strict sequences of a verb and a preposition". Only an adverbial element is allowed to interrupt that sequence (as in (36)), whereas an intervening object is a disqualifying feature, i.e. Quirk et al.’s Type II prepositional verb (e.g. take N for N) will not be treated here. As I see it, in the latter case the cohesion between verb and preposition is often considerably weakened or even non-existent.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
63
(36a) Even so, one in five pensioners rely entirely on state benefits for their income. (BNC A5S 19) (36b) How you discuss AIDS will depend a great deal on the way you operate in your family. (BNC A0J 779) It might be assumed that this could lead to doubtful exclusions, but it did so in only one case: (37)
... but Justice would be turn’d into Gall and Wormwood. (PolA1684)
(37) was excluded because of its verb-object-preposition structure (in the active voice), whereas (38) has been accepted. (38a) ... the Metallick Sand of the Bathe, unless corroded with an acid Menstruum, doth not turn to Vitriol. (SciB1676) (38b) Soviet Russia was turning into a "purely bourgeois republic". (BNC A64 311) A last type I would like to include here is one which probably most falls out of common definitions of prepositional verbs. Verbs that exhibit a changing usage, for example with accompanying preposition then but not today (e.g. admit of), or verbs occurring sometimes with, sometimes without a preposition (cf. Dixon 1992:278ff), can be enlightening and will therefore be examined as well.12 Their inclusion stems from my interest in the modifications, however slight, in meaning brought about by these combinations. (39) is an example of the latter case; "at" here clearly modifies "play" and does not belong to the following "politics". (39)
He wants to play at politics. (BNC A8X 1017)
Perhaps Jespersen (1928:III, 252) was thinking of similar cases when he stated that often the preposition makes the whole expression "more graphic". This concludes my treatment of prepositional verbs, but before we go on to the other categories, a few words about the differentiation of preposi tional from phrasal verbs are in order, at least as far as it also applies to writ ten historical data. The most important difference is the position of the object, especially the pronominal one, in both cases. With prepositional verbs the preposition cannot be shifted after the following noun phrase, whereas with phrasal verbs this is possible, and even obligatory in the case of a pronominal object (with certain idiosyncratic idiomatic exceptions). Fraser (1976:2) regards this as the main distinguishing criterion. Further, in contrast 12
In EModE many verbs occur both with a prepositional object and with a nonprepositional, i.e. direct, object, e.g. command, favour, forget etc., without obvious change of meaning. Usually it is the non-prepositional use that survives into PDE (cf. Rissanen 1999).
64
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
to prepositional verbs, phrasal verbs do not quite as freely allow their sequence to be interrupted by manner adverbs (with certain monosyllabic exceptions and those only with literal phrasal verbs). 4.3 Phrasal-prepositional Verbs This third category of multi-word verbs is in some way an offspring of the two preceding categories, in so far as it could be described as basic ally a phrasal verb with a preposition added on to it — but in fact it is generally more than just that. In contrast to both the above, which are very common, occurrences of this category seem to be much rarer. The under lined structures in the following sentences can serve as prototypical examples of this category. (40) (41) (42) (43)
The doctor’s voice broke in on her thoughts. (BNC JY0 289) There was no telling what a girl like that might come up with; they might beat Mavis Bramley yet. (BNC A1C 1444) The last years of his life seem to have been largely given over to this task. (BNC A6S 598) If I stretch my imagination, I can admit to feeling a little tired lately, but put that down to the ageing process. (BNC CA9 488)
The first particle in each case is an adverbial (in, up, over, down), the second a preposition (on, with, to). Just as with prepositional verbs, stranding is possible, cf. (41), the same goes for passivization; in (42) this is even the obligatory syntactic form, as this particular combinat ion only ever occurs in the passive. As with phrasal verbs, there is a semantic cline, with (40) and (42) being transferred uses, in which the metaphor is still retrievable, whereas (41) and (43) are completely opaque. In contrast to phrasal verbs, however, phrasal-prepositional verbs do not extend to the completely literal end of the cline — at least not in the definition of this category to be used here. My approach to phrasal-prepositional verbs is much more semantically, or rather idiomatically, determined than in the case of the preceding two categories. With three words co-occurring, two of which are high-frequency functional items one has to make especially sure that they really form a lexical unit, and do not just happen to be used side by side. After all, almost any phrasal verb can happen to be followed by a prepositional phrase (cf. Carstensen 1964:318 f; Palmer 1974:238). Unitary meaning seems to be the right way of establishing lexical -unit status in this case; thus, in the above sentences the respective paraphrases could be (40) "interrupted", (41) "think of, invent", (42) "devoted", and (43) "attribute to". If one downplayed semantic considerations here, given the frequency of
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
65
phrasal verbs and the ubiquity of prepositions, one might end up with a large class of phrasal-prepositional verbs, most of them having very little internal cohesion. As regards cohesion, Denison (1981:29f) points out that some sequences of verb + particle + preposition display an internal constituent struc ture, whereas others do not. His examples of the two kinds are keep on + at and put up with, respectively. As regards the first instance, Cowie & Mackin (1975) have two entries, one "keep (on) at" and the other "keep on (at/in)", i.e. in both cases one element of the three-part sequence is deletable leaving either a simple prepositional verb (keep at) or a simple phrasal verb (keep on) — with the same or only slightly changed meaning. With put up with, on the other hand, no element is deletable and there are no separ ate constituents; trying to separate with from the rest would enforce a completely different interpretation on put up. Keep (on) at is explained by Cowie & Mackin as "worry, pester, harass (continuously) with suggestions, requests, complaints", i.e. as having a non-inferable, idiomatic meaning, keep on (at/in) is much closer to the literal end of the spectrum with "not remove (from), continue to employ (at/in)". In this latter case the prepositional phrase could be questioned by "where" — something which excluded such cases from the class of prepositional verbs (cf. 5.2.). The same criterion will also be used here to eliminate some apparent phrasal-prepositional verbs. Thus keep on (at) is out, whereas keep (on) at and put up with are in, on account of their idiosyncratic, idiomatic meaning and their use of ‘empty’ prepositions (cf. the explanation under 5.2. above). Denison (1981:29f) mentions another point in favour of their unitary status, namely the fact that these sequences are rarely interrupted by anything else or inverted in any way. Pied-piping of the preposition would be highly unusual (Palmer 1974:238). Regarding interruptability, in cases like (43) above, the object can of course intervene, and — according to Cowie & Mackin (1975:xlii) — so can (in principle at least) adverbs and adverbial phrases between particle and preposition, even if the preposition is non-deletable and the combination idiomatic. However, interruption does not seem to be very common. The above then are the reasons for regarding them as a class of their own, a class of transitive lexical units, and not as intransitive verb -particle combinations followed by a preposition, as Fraser (1976:4) does. As regards transitivity, Cowie & Mackin (1975:xlif; lvf) separate the class into an intransitive pattern A3 (e.g. do away with, come in on) and a transitive pattern B3 (e.g. fob N off with N, take N out on N). Their approach is understandable insofar as they include completely literal combinations such go aground on (e.g. a sandbank) — question "where" possible! — or scrape along on (e.g. a low salary), comparable to the prepositional com-
66
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
plement cases (cf. 5.2. above), which could hardly be called transitive in any sense. As these cases are excluded here, I think it better to think o f all phrasal-prepositional verbs as being transitive, the pattern A3 (or Quirk et al’s Type I) being monotransitive and the pattern B3 (Quirk et al’s Type II) being complex transitive. On semantic grounds, Potter (1965:289) sub-divides the phrasalprepositional class further into three groups, which are (i) transparent combi nations (e.g. come up with N, fall in with, go on with, look forward to ), (ii) opaque combinations (e.g. do away with, go in for, make up to), and (iii) combinations with redundant elements (e.g. face up to, meet up with). Group (i) should, in my opinion, not include really literal ones, but only those cases where the metaphorical extension is still readily retrievable. I fully agree with group (ii), as this is the one that will include all the prototypical combinations. Group (iii) is an interesting case because of the question of how redundant the particles are, or even if they are at all redundant. The point here is that one can also face N (instead of facing up to N) or meet N (vs. meet up with N) — and whether it would make a difference. It is true that the combinations share the same or at least similar co -occurrence restrictions with the simplexes, and are thus remi niscent of Fraser’s (1976) systematic phrasal verbs. However, there are differences in meaning, certainly more noticeably in face up to than in meet up with, but nevertheless they are there and will have to be examined in each case. To briefly summarize, all the relevant criteria for phrasal verbs and prepositional verbs apply here as well. The only additional feature that is important is the exclusion of completely literal combinations and thus an emphasis on idiomaticity. 4.4 Verb-adjective Combinations Although the existence of these combinations was noticed an d remarked on long ago (e.g. Kruisinga 1925; Poutsma 1926; Jespersen 1928), they have nevertheless not received any extensive treatment so far. This might be related to the fact that members of this class are not very numerous and that they do not pattern internally as neatly as the other categories discussed already. Adjectives after all are a more unwieldy class than primary adverbs or prepositions. After such vague and intuitive descriptions as that the predicative forms "one sense-unit with the verb" (Jespersen 1928:V,31), or the adjective forms a sort of compound with the verb (Poutsma 1926:25), Quirk et al. (1985:734,n.2; 1167f) have definitely accorded these combinations multiword verb status. They point out their similarity to phrasal verbs, esp ecially
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
67
regarding the different positions of the object (cf. 4.1 above and examples (44a-c) below), which would turn the adjective into a kind of particle (cf. also Fraser 1976:36). (44a) Stomach and bowel problems have also laid him low but he shows no sign of stopping. (BNC K4V 2922) (44b) A virus has laid some of my horses low. (BNC HAE 365) (44c) There had been nothing achieved by the expedition save the coachman’s cold which now threatened to lay low the rest of her staff. (BNC H82 2406) However, Quirk et al. (ibid.) also declare comparative modification to be possible in some cases, as in their example reproduced here as (45). This modification emphasizes the adjectival character of the second element. (45)
John didn’t put the cloth as straight as Meg.
In principle, however, I think it is possible for a word to simultaneously function as a particle syntactically and semantically as an adjective. Taking a non-multi-word verb stance, the adjective can be seen as either an object complement or a subject complement. Poutsma (1926) spoke of a result-relationship, and Fraser (1976:36f) called it a be-relationship 13 between direct object or subject and the adjective, analyses which remind one of the small-clause interpretations of phrasal verbs (cf. footnot e 1 above). A paraphrase of the above as he is low, the horses are low (44a-b) is of course only possible if one interprets low in the metaphorical sense that also applies when taking lay low as a unit. I am clear ... (46) works somewhat better, especially if one retains the rest of the sentence, but the result relationship is best of all illustrated by com pletely literal cases such as (47): the drawer is open. (46) (47)
I want to get clear of this mess before anything else happens. (BNC G3G 2601) I suspected something, and one day I decided to break open her drawer. (BNC GWH 1486)
Seen diachronically, the complement analysis is probably valid in most cases, but where in the course of time the adjective became more and more attached to the verb and the meaning grew increasingly opaque, this original relationship is rather obscured nowadays.
13
Sequences which exhibit a be-relationship in surface structure by actually including the verb to be will not be regarded as verb-adjective combinations here. Often phrases such as be indicative of are treated under nominal tendencies/combinations and included in the set, cf. e.g. Renský (1964) and Hoffmann (1972).
68
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
The attachment of the adjective to the verb, and thus the unitary char acter of the whole combination, can be tested by a variant of the simple noun phrase test, i.e. the test whether the adjective can stay next to the verb pre ceding a very short object (Bolinger 1971 14; König 1973:88). The two following examples pass this test: (48a) This is a good way to make known the University ... (BNC EE6 313) (48b) you break, break open the window and get it (BNC KCE 5210) I am not quite sure whether this test works with all combinations one would like it to work with; I have not managed to find an authentic example in which lay low was followed by a simple noun phrase object, for instance. Naturally, it also does not work with intransitive combinations, which Quirk et al. (1985:1168) call copular, although it can cover those which occur both in transitive and intransitive uses, e.g. break open. Nor is it a usable test with those combinations followed — obligatorily or optionally — by a preposition, e.g. get clear of (cf. (46) above), fall short of. Some, but not all, of the latter can actually be called transitive. Lastly, there are those cases which have become intransitive by object deletion, e.g. the "it" in see/think fit, which is not only dropped when an infinitive follows (as Jespersen 1928:V,32 says), but in practically all occurrences. Thus, there is no real test for quite a number of verb-adjective combinations. I propose to employ the modification possibilities as an additional test, which would work for all kinds of verb-adverb combinations. In combinations to be regarded as real multi-word units, modification should be restricted to the minimum, i.e. to short ad verbials indicating manner (cf. (49a)) or intensification (e.g. so, very, completely), as in (49b). (49a) What I want to grieve is the old Maurice before he was laid so humiliatingly low by whatever it was ... (BNC H9Y 2969) (49b) If possible, get someone else to fly it before you to make quite sure that the ASI is working correctly. (BNC A0H 1768) I would not accept put straight in (45) above as a verb-adjective combination in the sense of this study. Because of the comparative modification, straight retains too much of its syntactic adjectival character to become really attached to the verb and form a unit with it. Comparative modification including as ... as, or than should thus not be possible, whereas more and most, if on their own, are allowed, as they can be seen as simple manner adverbs. Reduced modification possibilities make a statement about the closeness of the bond between verb and adjective; the more habitualized (or 14
Bolinger (1971:chap. 6) treats verbs-adjective combinations as a sub-category of phrasal verbs. Thus everything he says about the latter (cf. 4.1) applies here as well.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
69
even fossilized) a combination becomes, the less likely modification will be; for example it will hardly be possible to find a modified occurrence (in any way) of see fit in PDE. At the beginning of this section, I said that this category does not pat tern nicely. But Bolinger (1971:72-76) and König (1973:88f) advocate a possible subdivision into three groups. The first is made up of a combination of a causative verb (e.g. make, keep, leave) and an unknown number of adjectives, with such results as make known, make possible. In the second group any kind of verb can combine with an adjective of a closed set, namely open, loose, free, and clear, producing e.g. let loose. The third and last group is one that is lexically open, but semantically closed, in so far as any kind of verb or adjective is possible as long as the resultant combination expresses a cause-result relationship, as items like bleach white, cut short do. While this classification works with many, perhaps even the majority of verb -adjective combinations, there are cases which are not covered by it, in particular, it seems, not those with a final preposition. To end this section, these are the features the verb -adjective combinations to be considered here should possess. They are the combination of a verb with an adjective, and an optional or obligatory preposition at t he end, in which the adjective carries a prominent, sometimes even the major part of the meaning of the whole verb phrase. In some instances, the adjective embodies the verbal process as such, whereas the verb in a way modifies it by indicating the manner; this is often visible by one adjective occurring with a number of different verbs. As to the adjectives in question, most belong to the traditional word class adjective (e.g. good, sure), some are both adjectives and verbs, regardless of the direction of derivation (e.g. open, free), and some are past participles of verbs used in an adjectival function (e.g. known, rid). The criterial tests are simple noun phrase test, the nonadmission of comparative modification, and generally as little modification as possible. Additionally, in contrast to the situation with phrasal verbs, the possibilities of passivization might also be of relevance here. 4.5 Verbo-nominal Combinations One cannot really say that this category has not been given attention, but it has not been very comprehensive or systematic; in fact, most works so far have dealt with one specific semantic and syntactic sub-type among the possible combinations. This is also reflected by the fact that there is no common, established name for the category in question here. The same can be said for the verb-adjective combinations just treated, but those at least are much less common than the units involving a nominal element. Terms used
70
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
so far for this category include "complex verbal structures" (Nic kel 1978), "complex predicate" (Cattell 1984), "expanded predicate" (Algeo 1995), "Funktionsverbgefüge" (Müller 1978), "take-have-phrasal" (Live 1973), "verb-object combination" (Firbas 1969), "V-N construction" (Stein 1991), and "verbo-nominal phrase" (Renský 1964). The first three are too general and could also stand for all the other categories treated here, the fourth ignores the important nominal part, the fifth is confusing because it is reminiscent of phrasal verbs, and the sixth might be mislead ing because of its use of the term object (cf. below). The remaining two are really the best of all, and therefore I have partly taken over the last term, as ‘verbo -nominal’ has the advantage of at least clearly describing the cate gory and setting it off from all the others; phrase/construction has been replaced by ‘combination’, because it seems important to me to lay somewhat more stress on the pos sible unitary character of the sequence. As already stated above (cf. chap.3), this category is further divided into three sub-groups, namely (Group I) simple verb-noun units such as talk a walk, take place, give way, (Group II) verb-noun-preposition units, e.g. set fire to, catch sight of, put an end to, take care of and (Group III) verb-prepositional phrase units, like come to an end, bring to light, put in execution , cf. the following example sentences: (I)
(50) So training must take place with this time period in mind. (BNC A0M 348) (51) Table 4.6 takes all those who were able to give an answer at both first and second assessments ... (BNC B0W 737)
(II)
(52) Teachers ran the risk of looking like idiots or liars. (BNC AA8 496) (53) Then John made use of his position as director of the Comedy Theatre and arranged the children’s dances in the pantomime. ( BNC B34 67)
(III)
(54) What factors would you take into consideration when assessing a patient’s nutritional status? ( BNC EV5 937) (55) ... the helpings put me in mind of "Nouvelle Cuisine meets Yorkshire portions". (BNC BPJ 400)
From the examples given it should be obvious that there is quite an amount of internal variation within the three groups (regarding, e.g., type of noun, articles), which is probably unavoidable whatever kinds of classification criteria are used, given the variety of verbo -nominal combinations. 15 I haven 15
Live (1973), for example, chose to take the character of the noun as her criterial element to produce her Types I, II, and III. But she did not fit verb-prepositional phrase sequences (of which she mentions only those with be) into this classification, so
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
71
chosen to take as the basic classification criterion the absence or presence of a preposition, and, in the case of the latter, its syntactic position. This also has the advantage that the resultant types fit roughly in with those di scussed in the extant literature. Before proceeding to the discussion of these three categories, a few more general observations valid for all of them are in order. In all these com binations it is the nominal part that carries the major or even all the c omponents of meaning, i.e. the noun itself embodies the verbal process instead of being affected by it (as an object would be). This fact is especially important for the first two groups, where the noun is found in the direct ob ject position. Quirk et al. (1985:750ff) make the same semantic observations, but neverthe less retain the term ‘object’ in calling the noun an "eventive object". While the noun certainly does not represent an object semantically and functionally, the syntactic surface structure m akes it look like one. Therefore, Quirk et al.’s term, in capturing this double-sided nature of the noun, seems appropriate. From the above it follows that the verb is of minor or even of no importance, from the semantic perspective, but of course it is syntactically necessary as a verbal operator. Therefore, the verbal part is usually taken from the rather small class of very common, multi -functional verbs, such as make, take, give, put etc. Somehow verb and noun, plus perhaps a preposition, coalesce with each other to form a unit. And this is actually all that can safely be generalised about verbo-nominal combinations; thus their basic definition is necessarily semantic. A conclusive syntactical definition, in the form of tests, although some will be discussed below, is hardly possible; mainly, I think, because the individual behaviour of the nouns determines very much what syntactical possibilities the whole combination will have. Let me start with Group I then, the simple combination of a verb and a noun, without any preposition being involved. Most people have used a rather restrictive definition for this category, which is understandable in a way, because it is only in this way that one gets a set about which neat generalisations are possible. According to this approach a type of verbonominal combination is formed by the sequence: (operator) verb + determiner + deverbal noun, as in the prototypical example take a walk. Among those who have worked with this or a very similar definition are that it remains incomplete, in my opinion. She also totally ignores the prepositions, although some of the examples she gives would habitually require the presence of one. Hiltunen (in Brinton/Akimoto 1999) chose the presence or absence of an article, and the kind of article present, as a classificatory criterion. But articles in the combinations seem to behave rather idiosyncratically at any rate, and are especially problematic within an historical perspective.
72
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
Nickel (1978), Live (1973), Algeo (1995), Wierzbicka (1982) 16, Stein (1991), Stein & Quirk (1991), Müller (1978) 17, Prince (1972), Dixon (1992), and Cattell (1984). The verb in this category is purely functional, fulfilling the syntactic requirements of a verb in the sentence, and belongs to a small group, of which the most common are give, have, make, and take, i.e. verbs of Germanic stock (Nickel 1978:67). Algeo (1995:208) even restricts what he calls the "core expanded predicate" to those four verbs just mentio ned; Stein (1991:2) further excludes make, leaving a group of three verbs for her V-N construction. With the loss of most of its meaning, the verb also loses its potential for receiving any more than weak stress, the main accent fal ling on the noun (Müller 1978:13) — it is a "light verb" in every sense (Live 1973:33). This assumption is challenged by Stein (1991), however, who attempts to prove that the verbs make very spe cific contributions to the meaning of the whole combination; Müller (1978:114) also sees some independent meaning in them (cf. also Poutsma 1926:II,394; Dixon 1992:351ff). The determiner is usually simply the indefinite article (Nickel 1978:66); Algeo, Stein and also Dixon are again more restrictive by strictly excluding anything but the indefinite article. However, Live (1973:36) points out that some article-less combinations have to be seen as a sub-pattern of this category, e.g. take command, make love, give battle; additionally she mentions the much less common case of the definite ar ticle, e.g. have the lead (cf. also Müller 1978:140f). As to the nouns, in a narrow sense, they are zero-derivation nouns which are formally identical with a verb (Live’s Type I and Algeo’s core expanded predicate; also Stein 1991:2 and Dixon 1992:339), or, in a wider sense, they are either derived from or related to a verb stem (Nickel 1978:68; Hoffmann 1972:169). They are generally abstract in nature, in contrast to nouns in typical verb -object constructions, which are much more often of the concrete type , cf. He gave her a smile vs. He gave her a book (Nickel 1978:68; Müller 1978:105). 16
Wierzbicka deals only with a very specialized type of the pattern "have (take, give) + indefinite article + verbal (infinitival) stem", i.e. the last part of the sequence is not seen by her as a noun at all (also Dixon 1992), even though it is combined with an article and can be modified. She claims that these cases "can be distinguished from deverbal nouns with a zero suffix, e.g. smile, cough, or quarrel..." (755), but does not convincingly show how. In my view, this approach cannot be upheld, as it is impossible to brush away all the formal nominal features exhibited by the final parts of these combinations. An additional criterion of Wierzbicka’s seems to be the existence of a simple-verb counterpart. 17 Müller makes a difference between preposition-less Funktionsverbgefüge with the nominal part taking the place of a direct object — i.e. the category under discussion at the moment — and those containing a preposition in the middle, e.g. bring to an end (cf. below). Thus he takes a broader view than the other linguists enumerated here.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
73
Apart from this basic type just described, there are variants (usually kept very distinct from the ‘core’ type) regarding the nominal part of the combination. Müller (1978:128), Live (1973:36f) and Algeo (1995:205f) all mention nominal elements which, though clearly related to a verb, are formally noun-marked, e.g. through a suffix, such as apology, comparison, choice, loss (Live’s Type II). Live’s Type III, which she calls peripheral, is made up of combinations where there is no underlying noun-verb correspondence, but which are nevertheless replaceable by other simplexes, e.g. make an effort, take an oath, have an opinion (similar Müller 1978:120 and Algeo 1995). Live draws attention to the fact that the contribution of words of Romance stock to her types II and III is very pronounced, even more so in combinations lacking the article, whereas this is not the case in her Type I. What has been said so far accounts almost completely for the members of the first group posited above, simple verb -noun units, but it leaves some isolated items unexplained — which I would like to include, though. These are in particular take effect, take place, take pains , and make way, which neither have cognate simplex verbs 18 nor are they really replaceable by single-word equivalents — nevertheless they exhibit a very unitary verbal character. It seems to me that they are more lexicalized than most other members of this group, and this might ex plain their deviance in this respect. I now come to Group II, the setting up of which is necessary to ac count for the clear (even if at first only intuitively felt) contrast between, e.g., take a walk and catch sight of, as well as for the fact that some combinations fossilize with a fixed preposition. Members of this group are always transitive (whereas Group I units can be both transitive or intransitive); semantically they require the presence of an object and the only way to attach an object to the nominal part is of course with the help of a preposition — which therefore becomes obligatory. The problem is to decide in which cases the preposition (and thus the object) is really obligatory, as any simple verb-noun sequence can theoretically be followed by a preposition. I take the preposition to be obligatory if the combination can never occur without it 19, and if the nominal element following the preposition 18
There are, admittedly, the verbs to effect, to place and to pain, but none of those has the relevant meaning for the nominal part in the combination. A kind of exception is pain, as, at least in the Lampeter period, there was still a relationship between the simplex and the periphrastic construction, cf. these OED examples (s.v. pain n.): Eumenes pained himselfe (= took pains, CC) to carrie succour to his left wing. (1614, Raleigh, Hist. World iv. iii. 9) While he pain’d himself to raise his note. (1700, Dryden, Cock & Fox 669) 19 The condition here is that the following element is a noun and not a clause; even prepositional verbs ‘lose’ their preposition when preceding a clause.
74
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
can be seen to be affected in the way the direct object of a simplex verb would be. (56a) Make love to me, Jay. (BNC A0L 1001) (56b) You can’t make love at pistol point ... (BNC A0L 2392) While in (56a) the object me is definitely affected (cf. the simplex construction love me, and the possibility of passivization), (56b) shows that make love can occur without a further object, and thus without to, especially, but not exclusively, because it often takes a plural subject. Therefore, make love will be put into the first group above. The same goes for take part, which is an even clearer case: it can occur without the preposition (cf. (57b)) and the following nominal cannot be called affected. (57a) The Conference would wish all who may take part in the referendum to recognize that Protestant Churches are pro-Life ... (BNC A07 1036) (57b) We’re looking for ten volunteers to take part, each of whom will be sent five plants (...) to grow. (BNC A0G 390) Take part with, however, meaning "side with somebody" would lose this meaning if without the preposition, and therefore belongs into Group II. Put an end to is also definitely a fixed verb-noun-preposition sequence and as such part of the second group. The whole combination needs an object, hence the unacceptability of (58b). (58a) He would also be expected to pay a premium to put an end to the chaos. (BNC A3L 629) (58b) *He would also be expected to pay a premium to put an end. Sometimes apparent unacceptability in the preposition -less use can be remedied by increasing or changing the context, especially by modification of the nominal part. But this does not seem to be the case in the present example. Also, the delimitation of the groups will be clearer if the non -modified combinations can stand alone. Besides the two points mentioned above, the nature of the verb and the noun involved might also play a role in the delimitation of the two groups. An important question is whether the noun is independent enough to stand on its own or whether it requires some kind of complementation. Take for example the word charge, which enters into verbo-nominal combinations (in the Lampeter Corpus) in the meanings (a) "military attack", (b) "accusation", and (c) "responsibility, care" (cf. its OED entry). In the case of (a), e.g. give charge, it is self-sufficient requiring no complementation (i.e. Group I membership), with (c), e.g. take charge (of), constructions with or without complement are possible (i.e. Group I as well), but with regard to (b), e.g. lay a charge to/on N, the presence of an object of the accusation is
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
75
necessary 20 (i.e. Group II membership), lay a charge alone carrying no complete independent meaning. The verb being lay, and not make, for instance, may also play a role in this case. With the Lampeter Corpus examples have defeat (Group I) and give defeat to (Group II) it is definitely the verbs that make the difference — basically by embodying a passive versus an active sense. On the other hand, both give alarm and take alarm can stand on their own; whether the (in)transitivity of the underlying or related verb has a principled influence — the verb alarm could be used intransitively (cf. OED, s.v. alarm 1.a.) — is not quite clear to me, and would need to be looked into further. In general, it has to admitted that the borderline between Groups I and II is rather fuzzy and also permeable. There is quite definitely a gradient. What makes things even more complicated is that some combinations such as take care (of) and give (an) account (of) belong to both groups, something which goes together with different meanings: (59a) Take great care turning right. (BNC A0J 36) "be careful" (59b) This will take care of any (...) calcium deficiency too. (BNC A0G 2321) "deal with" (59c) Had she simply had Maggie so that someone, somewhere, would have to love her and take care of her? (BNC A6J 161) "care for, look after" 21 (60a) I could give you a blow-by-blow account of how England lost to Portugal the other night. (BNC A0U 1061) "tell" 20
The (obligatory) presence of an object does not necessarily always entail a fixed preposition, cf. the Lampeter Corpus instance give alteration, where the object can intervene between the two elements (a case of dative shift), thus putting this example into Group I. 21 Nunberg, Sag & Wasow (1994) propose a "double entry analysis" (523) for such verb-nominal sequences in order to account for differing syntactic behaviour exhibited by one and the same combination. The idiom take care of can be analyzed as an idiomatic phrase ("an idiosyncratic type of phrasal construction that is assigned its own idiomatic meaning" (507)) or as an idiomatic combination (which "consist[s] of a fundamentally semantically (typically figurative) dependency among distinct lexemes, however restricted in distribution these lexemes might be" (ibid.)). This may (as here) or may not go together with some semantic differentiation. (59b) contains the idiomatic phrase, which is supposed by them to disfavour the passive with care in subject position (inner passive), whereas (59c) as an idiomatic combination is said to permit both types of passive equally well. However, the native speakers I asked found the inner passive dubious/unsatisfactory in both cases. Besides, the authors go to great lengths to explain something rather simple: all the elements in these combinations are janus-faced, looking inward on the combination and kind of merging, as well as looking outward as individual words. Their individual meaning is retained or retrievable to varying degrees, which may also determine their syntactic behaviour. These degrees form a cline, not two separate camps.
76
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
(60b) Some four or five-year olds are perfectly able to give a coherent account of themselves, while some 16-year olds cannot. (BNC A2P 695) "explain, account for" The "of" in (60a) is not an integral part of the combination 22, although it is always present when the object is specified (cf. Cattell 1984:5). The important thing is that it need not always be specified. Combinations with a completely integrated preposition seem to be not all that common; thus Group II is smaller than Group I. What has been said about the characteristics of the verbal and nominal parts above is also valid here. Two further tendencies are nowadays visible in this present group, namely a certain preference for the zero-article in the base (infinitive) form of the combination and a higher percentage of Romance nouns. The third and last group of verbo-nominal combinations comprising verb-prepositional group sequences contains both transitive and intransitive units. Examples for intransitive combinations are come to an end, come to light, be in doubt; in this group it is the verbal part that determines intransitivity. With the transitive combinations there are some that require an additional preposition at the end, either to link to the object of the whole unit, as in stand in need of N, or to add another object or complement, e.g. put N in mind of N. As with prepositional verbs above, separation of the preposition from the rest is not seen as a problem (61a,b); on the other hand, the phenomenon of the stranded preposition exists here as well (61c). (61a) This meant that the new "natural philosophy" stood in need, not merely of practical development, but also of intellectual justification and explanation. (BNC ABM 666) (61b) A general system of gardening founded on experience is a work of which the public has long stood in need. (BNC ALU 923) (61c) ... both shopping expedition and holiday were what she stood in need of. (BNC AD1 3234) The direct object of the combination usually, but not always, intervenes be tween the verb and the prepositional part, i.e. take N into consideration, instead of take into consideration N; the latter becomes necessary, however , if the object noun phrase is very long or heavy (cf. (62c)). Thus, the elements of the combinations are usually separated in real language; this is balanced out by less common nominal modification in this group. (62a) The judges may even take the owner’s appearance into consideration when making their minds up. (BNC A17 1035) 22
Cf. also Nunberg, Sag & Wasow’s (1994:520, esp. fn. 34) discussion of take advantage (of), which at first sight looks like a typical preposition case, but empirically is obviously not.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
77
(62b) More ominously its size and capacity also took into consideration future military needs. (BNC AR0 521) (62c) The judge further invalidated a statute that requires the agency to "take into consideration general standards of decency and respect for the diverse beliefs and values of the American public ." (BNC EBV 51) Apart from the conditions as to the internal make -up of these combinations, other, mainly syntactic criteria have also been applied to them. Most of them deal primarily with Groups I and II, however. Nickel (1978:68ff; also cf. Hoffmann 1972) mentions four criteria, which might be useful: the action denoted by the deverbal noun has the subject of the sentence as its agent (subject-predicate relationship as with a simplex verb); if a possessive pronoun accompanies the noun it is dominated by the subject of the sentence (cf. (63)); it is not the verbal but the nominal part of the combination that determines which kind of object it can take (cf. also Müller (1978:106), who says that the combination shares the selectional restrictions of the simplex equivalent, but he also admits some restricted selectional role to the verb (115)); and the verb cannot be freely replaced by others (similarly Müller 1978:114 and Hoffmann 1972:170), whereas substitution by members of the same semantic class is possible in normal verb-object constructions. (63)
And when you’ve made your choice, we’ll deliver your new machine ... (BNC AYX 217)
Müller (1978:9; 106), besides stating generally that the combinations are se mantically identical to simplexes, and can as a rule be replaced by the latter in context, also suggests some syntactic criteria to be used, namely gapping, pronominalization and certain forms of topicalization (ibid. 107-110). Gapping should only be possible if the two verbs are either both used in a verbo-nominal combination or are both used in their literal sense, but not if usage differs, cf. *John took a cigarette and then a swim in the pond. Pronominalization of the nominal part of the combination is said to be highly restricted or completely impossible, i.e. the noun cannot usually be replaced by it23 (whereas the whole combination can), or be questioned with the help of "what?".
23
Against this assumption cf. Nunberg, Sag & Wasow (1994:501f, incl. fn. 16), who quote the following nice example: The children made a mess of their bedrooms, but then cleaned it up. According to Krenn (1977:108), the noun must be present in the semantic structure to be pronominalized, and I would argue that many of the nouns in verbo-nominal combinations are at least partially, if not completely present semantically. Thus, the restriction on pronominalization should not be overrated.
78
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
(64)
The government gave way in 1988, then went back on [the] deal ... (BNC A9N 231) *What did the government give?
As to topicalization, cleft and pseudo-cleft sentences are claimed to be either unusual or again wholly impossible with verbo-nominal combinations. Fraser (1976:44) adds a criterion specifically for Group III types, namely the fact that the prepositional-phrase part of the combination cannot be preceded by an adverbial, whereas ‘free’ prepositional phrases permit this. The replaceability by a simplex of the same meaning mentioned above is a criterion that is often employed. Dixon (1992:340) operates on the sentence level by requiring that two sentences, one with the simplex, the other with the verbo-nominal combination, should have essentially the same meaning. Renský (1964:290) makes substitution by a non-derived verb his basic condition or criterion. This is intended to exclude on the one hand such cases as take place, take heart, which he calls intuitively different from, e.g., take aim, take hold, from the set of verbo-nominal combinations, and, on the other hand, to omit cases where the simplex verb is actually derived from the verb in the periphrastic form, e.g. to be head of > to head. But this criterion should not be overrated, in my opinion. Although it is deceptively simple in use in most cases, it usually goes hand in hand with a loss, substitution or shifting of semantic features, so that the simplex and the com bination are by no means identical, or a simple "stylistic variant" (Renský 1964:290); cf. also Cattell (1984:77), who uses the careful formulation "near paraphrases with related simple verbs" when describing his basic criterion. Further, the actual lack of a single-word ‘equivalent’ might have come about by a historical development in the course of which the combination simply won out on the simplex (cf. fn. 18). Also, if a language makes do with just the combination, and does not bother to create or borrow a simplex, this might be an important point as well. Non-substitutability does not, therefore, disprove multi -word verb status. The question of the status of the nouns in these combinations has been touched on above; it is of somewhat greater importance for Groups I and II than for Group III. In principle, the nouns possess all formal characteristics of nominals on their own, i.e. they can take all sorts of determiners, or also none, they can be premodified (e.g. adjectives, (65a)) or postmodified (e.g. relative clauses, (65b)), and they can be pluralized (66) — but of course every combination behaves idiosyncratically in this respect, allowing some things and barring others. Degrees of lexicalization are obviously important here. The plural, for example, is relatively rare in these combinations; some combinations allow it freely, whereas others do not permit it at all (Stein 1991:13; Müller 1978:114).
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
79
(65a) ... this may lead to generalisations about the group which take little account of the individual qualities of the artists. (BNC A04 1289) (65b) it is perhaps the way in which these terms are used by professionals and others to which the greater attention should be paid if we are to make progress which is enduring. (BNC GWJ 570) (66) Over the next days, the girls swam, took long walks, talked, and ate Cook’s meals ... (BNC FNT 1501) Sheintuch (1981:esp. 333-337), whose concern is with non-idiomatic verbal units (partly parallel to Groups I and II as understood here), states that, in order to function as part of such a unit, nouns cannot have unique reference to something in the real world. Basically, this is certainly correct, but her added restriction, that this condition is not of equal importance in different syntactic constructions, is also relevant. For it could be ar gued that the addition of a personal pronoun or a relative clause produce unique reference for the noun in question. Another point that is important for the status of the noun (in both Group I and II) is the question of transitivity, and thus also the question of (direct) object-hood of the noun. The first group can be used both intransitively and transitively, as I regard He gave an answer to be intransitive (cf. also Traugott in Brinton/Akimoto 1999:240), whereas He gave him an answer/He gave an answer to him are seen as transitive uses of the same item. I think semantically this statement needs no clarification, but in formal, syntactic terms the situation is of course not that simple: the noun phrase an answer occupies the direct object position. Normally, it should be possible to distinguish it from a ‘real’ object (such as [give N] a book) by a combination of some of the semantic requirements and syntactical tests enumerated in the discussion of Group I; the "what"-question test in particular can produce rather amusing results in the case of verbo-nominal combinations. There are also the possibilities of passivization, i.e. whether the nominal element of the combination can become the subject of a passive sentence, but unfortunately this leads to very contradictory results within t he group of verbo-nominal combinations. Müller (1978:138) deals with the question by calling the noun in the combination not a "Wertigkeitsargument", but a "Prädikationskomple ment". Chomsky (1981:37;101), encountering the same problem in take advantage of Bill, treats it by calling advantage a quasi-argument, that is either a non-argument that has been assigned no actual Q-role, or an argument with the special role "#"; the same treatment is given to take care of, make much of. However, in this way one ends up with having quasi-arguments in subject-position, as both advantage and care, even much, can become the subjects of passive sentences. Additionally, all this seems to apply only to idioms. It is probably disputable whether the above examples are idio ms or
80
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
not, but give an answer certainly is not — thus this solution would have to be extended to regular patterns as well. Cattell (1984:52;111) basically agrees with Chomsky, although his complex predicates are not idioms; but he also admits that there is no independent way of telling whether a noun phrase is an argument or part of a complex predicate, i.e. a verbo -nominal combination. The problem of passivization has been mentioned before, and now a few more words about it are in order. The third group of verbo-nominal combinations is perhaps the least problematic in this respect: it has direct objects which are not part of the combination and can therefore freely passivize (cf. (67)). Moreover, the noun in the prepositional phrase is not like a preposi tional object, but has more of a complement nature, and thus does not allow passivization. (67)
Allegations of such activity were brought to light by Cathy Massiter, ... (BNC ASB 871)
With the other two types of combinations, inner passive, based on the nominal part of the combination itself, and/or outer passive, based on the object of the whole combination are possible. The outer passive is in principle always possible, although Müller (1978:170) calls it rare (68b). Bolinger (1977:62) points out that the high or low frequency of a combination may play a role here. The inner passive, however, is more idiosyncratic (68a). (68a) Mention should be made of some other urban projects that are designed to improve agency co-ordination. (BNC B1U 974) (68b) ... therefore the planning considerations that have been mentioned need to be paid attention to. (BNC J41 27) Live (1965:37f) explains the differences partly via the characteristics of the verb (have-/make-combinations) and partly with the features of the dev erbal nouns (take-/give-combinations), whereas Müller (1978:169) attempts a semantic classification of the nouns (only for give-combinations). However, all this has to do with the fact that in all kinds of verbo -nominal combinations, but probably most of all in the second group, there is an internal cline to be noticed, from very close units to looser combinations. Denison (1981:37), for example, remarks that set fire to is to be placed at the more unitary end of the spectrum, whereas take care of tends towards the more open end. Fire in the former is not an independent noun any longer, as it cannot accept modifications or be made subject of a passive sentence. Care, on the other hand, can do both of these. Nevertheless, both are in my opinion to be seen as lexical units in their own right, so that lexical/semantic facts do not necessarily closely correlate with syntactic facts in this area.
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
81
I will close this section, like the others, with a brief summary of which combinations are to be accepted in this study. The following is to be understood for all three groups. Generally the combination should present a unitary meaning — and there is no denying that semantic intuition will be at work here, aided by paraphrasability with a simplex yielding a similar overall meaning. Moreover, the meaning should be centred in the noun, not in the verb. This does not mean that I assume the verbs to be completely empty; I think they can make independent semantic contributions to the combinations, including for example those of an aspectual/aktionsart kind. Therefore I will not a priori restrict the number of verbs to be included, but accept any kind of verb as long as it does not completely override the noun in importance. The only verb that I mostly exclude is to be. Some linguists (e.g. Poutsma 1926, Renský 1964; Hoffmann 1972) dealing with nominal tendencies have included structures such as to be an early riser, to be indicative of N as combinations. I ignored those completely in the case of verb -adjective combinations above, and will do the same for verbo-nominal combinations — with certain exceptions, however. When be (i.e. the primary notion of existence) clearly is not present in the semantic structure, as in be of opinion "think" or be at a loss "not know what to do", I have accepted the unit in question. As to the nouns, they certainly need to be of the abstract kind, and this depends on their use in the context in question. "Eyes" in set eyes on N does not represent the biological entity, but is metonymic for t he faculty of seeing — and therefore abstract. Give evidence, on the other hand, can in certain circumstances be excluded, namely in those cases (in court, e.g.) where "evidence" refers to a written statement, i.e. a concrete object. While I think that most nouns in the combinations are of the deverbal kind (conversions, suffixal derivations, or otherwise clearly related, e.g. die — death), there are also those with no formal relation to a verb, e.g. way, liberty. All these kinds will be accepted. There are also no conditions set on the presence or absence of a (certain kind of) determiner within the combination. As it is hard even today to find a sufficient number of native speakers who will agree on the (non-)acceptability of transformations of verbo-nominal combinations, I will completely refrain from employing syntactic tests on historical verbo-nominal data — except for observing which syntactic ‘transformations’ appear in the data as such. To end this whole section with, I will try to present the basic internal make-up and the transitivity features of the multi -word categories discussed above in a somewhat more convenient form:
82
Categories of Multi-word Verbs
Table 4.1: A synopsis of multi-word verbs verb category phrasal verb prepositional verb phrasal-prepositional verb verb-adjective combination verbo-nominal combination: Group I verbo-nominal combination: Group II verbo-nominal combination:Group III
noun adverb prep. adjective noun prep. noun (y) x (y) x y (x) (y) (y) x x y (y)
x
(y)
x
(x)
(y)
x
(y)
(y)
x
x
y
x
(x)
(y)
Note: "x" means the element is part of the multi-word verb, (the second "x" for prepositional verbs, given for the sake of comprehensiveness, does not constitute a new subtype, cf. 4.2); "y" (="yes") makes a statement about transitivity; and bracketed letters () indicate optionality (depending, e.g, on transitive vs. intransitive combination).
5. The History of Multi-word Verbs Complex forms with relatively clear syntactic patterning such as those dis cussed in the preceding chapter of course do not appear out of nowhere, but take time to evolve and also to consolidate. Thus, it is not surprising that either the types in question themselves or at least te ndencies in their direction are to be found in earlier stages of the En glish language. Therefore this chapter is intended to give a brief overview of the development of multiword verb types as far as can be found in the literature, and as far as is relevant to the present study. It appears that scholarly attention has been very unevenly spread, with the Old and Middle English stages clearly being overrepresented in the treatment of phenomena related to multi-word verbs. There is not much information to be found on the later periods. Also, the different types have not met with an equal amount of interest. It is es pecially remarkable that such types as phrasal or prepositional verbs have not be en the object of corpus studies as regards their place in Present -day English. At least I am not aware of any work done in that area. The following account will of course reflect these biases in the literature. 5.1 Old and Middle English The attention accorded these two periods is justified by their (especially the latter’s) importance for the phenomena in question. Denison (1981:3) states that while OE presents a completely different situation from PDE, by the time of late ME the basic structure of the present position of multi-word verbs had been established, i.e. most of the syntactic pat terns had come into existence and there were even some fully idiomatic cases to be found. This means that in the time span stretching approximately from late OE to ea rly ME some important developments were taking place, cf. for instance Hiltunen’s (1983a:220) statement on phrasal verbs: "The crucial period in the syntactic and semantic development of the phrasal verb falls within lOE and eME." While it is true that OE did not actually possess any of the types of multi-word verbs discussed in chapter 4, certain facts and tende ncies can be made out that represent the precursors or roots of the types later to emerge. Both phrasal and prepositional verbs have their ultimate origins in a highly complex OE situation exhibiting quite some variation and flexible boundaries between whatever ‘types’ there may have been. OE verbs could and did occur in conjunction with words to be variously termed prepositions, adverbs, prepositional adverbs, postpositions, separable prefixes, and
84
The History of Multi-word Verbs
inseparable prefixes (cf. Mitchell 1978), which can all look very similar, even identical on the manuscript page. The following few examples and the comments on them are taken from Mitchell (1978:255 -56) and are to give a glimpse of the situation: (1) (2a) (2b) (3)
Þa sticode him mon Þa eagan ut 7 siÞÞan him mon slog Þa handa of (Or 168.4) Þæt he for godes lufon eode to reordum mid Þam tocumendum mannum (Mart 168.25) cume to and drince (ÆHom 5.143) Gyrstanæfen me gelamp, Þæt ic ungewealdes ætsporn æt anum fotscamele. (900, Wærferth tr. Gregory’s Dial. 22,10; OED s.v. yesterneven)
Ut in (1) is probably an adverb, and of in the same sentence is either also one or it is a preposition (in post-position) belonging with him. Alternatively of is seen by some as a separable prefix, just like to in tocuman in (2a-b). Æt- in (3) is a clear case, undoubtedly to be interpreted as an inseparable prefix. But whatever their status in OE, it is amazing how reminiscent some of them are of PDE phrasal verbs, e.g. in (1) of take out and cut off, or come together for (2a-b). Phrasal verbs Hiltunen’s account (1983a) is the most thorough treatment of the genesis of the phrasal verb, and the following account leans hea vily on it. As far as one can speak of OE phrasal verbs, they are collocations of a verb and either a phrasal or a prepositional adverb (ibid. 20), as ut in (1) above. In contrast to PDE, syntactic possibilities are still more open, with four positional patterns of adverbial element and verb, two preverbal (1. a V, 2. a (...) V) and two postverbal ones (3. V a, 4. V (...) a) (ibid. 21; similar Roberts 1936:479, but denying the existence of a (...) V), cf. (4) and (5) respectively. While the preverbal patterns are still dominant in early OE, there is a quite noticeable shift towards the postverbal patterns in late OE, a development which is strengthened in early ME (first in main, then also in dependent clauses), leading to the final establishment of the postve rbal pattern by 1200 (ibid. 106-11). (4a) (4b) (5a)
He het his heafod of aslean. (Ælfric, Saints’ Lives 26, 162, Visser §668) þæt eac Eðna þæt sweflene fyr tacnade, þa hit up of helle geate asprong on Sicilia þæm londe (Or 88.30; Hiltunen 1983a:105)) Ateon ut þa horhestan wætan. (Leechdoms II, 222; Visser §668)
The History of Multi-word Verbs 85 (5b)
Ge drehnigeað ðone gnæt aweg. (OE Gosp., Mt. XXIII, 24; Visser §668)
Von Schon (1977), who is also concerned with the relative position of phrasal verb elements, recognizes two separate particle shifts in her data. The first particle shift, namely the movement to postverbal pos ition with a finite verb, is said by her to have begun in the 7th century, whereas the second particle shift, i.e. the same with non-finite verb forms, occurred only some centuries later. 1 Both Denison (1981) and Hiltunen (1983a) basically, even if with some reservation, agree with her findings, the latter pointing to a mere 35 non-finite postverbal examples in OE2, only 10 of which date from before the 10th century (ibid. 127-133). It can therefore be assumed that the change for non-finite form took place in late OE. At any rate, the postverbal position of the particle becomes the norm in ME, cf. for example Denison’s (1981:174) figures for the Orrmulum, where only 6% of all particles are in preverbal position. By 1250, the phrasal verb construction had definitely reached its modern shape (Hiltunen 1983a:6) 3. During the ME period the phrasal verb expands further and in time becomes quite a normal linguistic pattern (Brinton 1988:225). According to Kennedy (1920:13) it was a common part of everyday language in the 15th century, cf. the down-to-earth example in (6). (6)
He took of hys clothes. (1485, Caxton Chas. Gt. 212; OED s.v. take)
A good sign for its established status is also the appearance of the first nouns derived from phrasal verbs in the 14th and 15th centuries, for instance the now obsolete sit-up "surprise" (Sørensen 1986:274, also Denison 1981:13133). Burnley (1992:445), for example, cites the agentive phrasal nouns holder up of Troye (Chaucer) and fynder up of false religions (Lydgate). While most of these nouns are derived from or related to phrasal verbs, some also go back to verb-preposition sequences, such as the 15th century lean-to "a shed", or go-between found in Shakespeare. As to the reasons for the above development, Hiltunen (1983a:114; 125; 144) sees the changing of the element order of the clause as the single 1
Two problems should be mentioned here. First, Von Schon’s data base is rather small. Secondly, and more importantly, the ms. containing her 7th century material actually dates from much later. It is conceivable that things like the position of particles may be altered in the process of copying older material. 2 Compare the situation with German particle verbs (or so-called separable prefix verbs), where the particle remains preverbally attached to the verb in non-finite forms, but is found in separate post-verbal position in the case of finite forms. 3 Visser (§§670-671) cites preverbal uses after this time, especially in poetry, which are partly nonce formations for the sake of rhyme and partly ‘translations’ of Latin verbs.
86
The History of Multi-word Verbs
most important factor in the establishment of the phrasal verb patterning: the close relationship between the SV order and the postverbal pattern profits the latter as the SOV order goes into decline towards the end of the OE period. Marchand (1951:73) also regards phrasal verbs as one of the results of a fixed word order. But the rise of the phrasal verb is also connected with the fall of an other construction, OE prefix verbs. The latter’s very sudden decline to almost zero productivity and use by early ME left a slot to be filled by the newer analytic constructions (Hiltunen 1983a:92; 52). Most of the reasons adduced for the ultimate demise of the prefixal system are at the same time, if turned round, arguments for the phrasal verb. The push - and drag-chain process producing the new situation in ME received its briefest and also clearest account in Samuels (1972:163-65), which I will not repeat here, instead going through the individual reasons that have been mentioned in the literature. (i) Through the prefixes’ lack of stress their phonological structure became successively weaker, leading to loss of independent phonetic content (Hiltunen 1983a:52; Samuels 1972:163; Lutz 1997:263). De la Cruz (1975:78) calls the same fact "morphological weakening". Phrasal adverbs, on the other hand, as independent elements, can and often do carry full stress, which also means that they are not likely to be subject to phonetic weakening, and that they can transport intonational information, e.g. emphasis (Denison 1985a:47f). (ii) Another kind of weakening was going on in the semantic sphere with the fading away of the prefixes’ concrete locative, aspectual and intensifying meanings (Hiltunen 1983a:94f; de la Cruz 1975:49). Again, phrasal adverbs would carry a more explicit meaning. (iii) Preverbal elements are rather obscure and/or a potential s ource of ambiguity in an SOV syntactic order as existed in OE (Hiltunen 1983a:188; Konishi 1958:118). That means that the prefixal system must already have been drastically weakened in OE, before SV became the predominant element order in early ME. This argument of course also applies to the preverbal patterns of OE phrasal verbs mentioned above and explains their ultimate loss. An additional suggestion in this context is the one made by Marchand (1969:131) to the effect that the postverbal pattern might be connected with the normalising of the position of spatial adverbs in general. (iv) The prefixal system was burdened with too heavy a functional load, in which no single function was strong or prominent enough to secure its usefulness and thus its survival (Hiltunen 1983a:97). One could probably say the same about the thriving phrasal verb ‘system’ today; thus this is not a decisive factor as long as all other conditions are favour able.
The History of Multi-word Verbs 87 (v) The sheer presence and availability of phrasal types as al ternative, but more explicit, expressions of the same meanings and fulfilling the same or similar functions hastened the decline of prefix verbs (Hiltunen 1983a:98ff; 145; de la Cruz 1975:49; Denison 1985a:46ff). (vi) Lastly, the general trend towards analytic constructions disfavoured the synthetic prefixal constructions (Hiltunen 1983a:98; van der Gaaf 1930:12,19; Konishi 1958:118f), and profited the analytic phrasal verbs. While this statement may be true, it contains a certain amount of circularity, which disqualifies it as a ‘reason’. Whatever the reasons (it is not the purpose of this study to decide the ques tion), it is clear that the OE prefixal system did become extinct and that the modern phrasal verbs did take over in its place. De la Cruz (1975:77f) nicely illustrates this fact by citing examples of pre fix verbs in the Ancrene Riwle together with their modern phrasal rendering, e.g. the prefixal verbs with geare translated as phrasal verbs formed with up or out, and similarly for- = up/away/off, be- = up/away/off, to- = up/out/away/off, a- = up/out/away. However, some prefixes survived with modest productivity, especially over-, under-, out-, fore-, mis-, be-, and un-, and Lutz (1997:279; 281) takes care to point out that they are those which have a phonologically stable and distinct form, most of them also possessing a distinct meaning — and thus they are exempt from some of the reasons for decline stated above. Some of those surviving prefixes are identical with phrasal verb particles, sometimes leading to contrasting formations with different meanings, e.g. overtake — take over, outlive — live out. In ME, prefixal and phrasal variants existed side by side even with the same meaning, cf. fall by — bifallen "happen", flee out — outflee "expel, banish", or look over — overlook "survey from on high" (Burnley 1992:445). While the reasons against prefixal verbs and in favour of phrasal verbs dealt with above were purely language-internal, there is also the question of outside, particularly Scandinavian influence on the latter (and also on prepositional verbs) (e.g. Burnley 1992:422f, 444f; Roberts 1936:477). Old Norse had advanced phrasal constructions, but direct influence on OE/early ME has not been or cannot be proven, not least because the relevant ON texts are only extant in later manuscripts. Hiltunen (1983a:43) thinks it merely likely that the ON phrasal construction acted as a kind of catalyst, stimulating the further development of the postverbal construction type already present in OE. According to Lutz (1997:262, n.8) the Scandinavian influence worked much more indirectly by accelerating the reduction of unaccented syllables, including inflectional endings, in the Northern English dialects, thereby speeding up the fixing of word order in those dialects — which in turn favoured phrasal verbs. Denison (1981:54f,
88
The History of Multi-word Verbs
157, 285-89; 1985a:49-53), while admitting that a purely internal development is perfectly possible, still goes somewhat further by thinking an ON influence on the aktionsart usage at least likely and by assuming the direct borrowing from ON of phrasal verbs of surrendering very likely, cf. the early instances of give up, (7) being one of them, in the Final Continuation of the Peterborough Chronicle. (7)
& sæde heom ð he uuolde iiuen heom up Wincestre (ChrE 266.35, 1140; Hiltunen 1983a:125)
Once present the borrowings would then have served as a catalyst for the formation of similar combinations. Denison (1981:156) also mentions another possible foreign influence of an indirect nature: in translations from Latin into English the many Latin compound verbs could have induced the translators to render them as native verb -adverb collocations (quasi calques). Interestingly, Hiltunen (1983a:98) has examples (among them the following (8)) where exactly this happens, but on top of a prefix verb, showing how moribund the prefixal system must have appeared to some translators. (8)
L61.22 quem viri Domini Fortunatus expulissit GD (CO) 77.11 þe se drihtnes wer Furtunatus ær onweg adraf (H) 77.8 þe ... ær ut adraf
Another assumed foreign influence is of rather a negative kind in so far as the development of phrasal verbs might actually have been slowed down by the great influx of loan words, French ones during ME, Latin ones later (Kennedy 1920; Rot 1988:185). Konishi (1958:120) thinks that to be more likely of written and formal varieties of the language than of colloquial English, however. In fact, I think it likely that wholesale borrowing might even have stimulated the formation of phrasal verbs as a counter-reaction. The internal development of phrasal verbs in OE and ME also showed considerable progress. If one follows Brinton (1988:217, 220) some particles exhibit an earlier development in OE to fully-fledged verbal particles than others; this goes especially for of and forth, but also for up, út, onweg/aweg, ofdune/adune (without prefixal counterparts). Regarding the semantics of phrasal verbs in OE, there are two levels. On the first level straightforward literal meanings are found, with both members retaining their basic meanings. This means that the phrasal adverbs mostly occurred with their original locational or — more commonly — directional meanings (Hiltunen 1983a:147f; Denison 1981:147), cf. (9). The second level contains combinations with transferred meanings, i.e. meanings which are metonymically or metaphorically removed from the literal plane but in which the literal meaning is still transparent enough, as in (10).
The History of Multi-word Verbs 89 (9) (10)
hie siþþan aweg flugon (Or 160.22; Hiltunen 1983a:120) Do awei þe þohtes, þat prokien þin heorte þurh licomliche lustes (HMaid 11.108; Hiltunen 1983a:148)
Fully idiomatic combinations with opaque meaning are not found in OE (Hiltunen 1983a:148). In ME figurative combinations become more common, and de la Cruz (1972:116ff) identifies ‘close units’ on semantic grounds in that period, such as the transferred combinations lay up "save", bring down "kill" or the more fully idiomatic figurative units fall out "disagree", stir up "rebel", and bring forth "produce". As regards aktionsart meanings of phrasal particles, Hiltunen (1983a:147) finds the resultative use to be rare in OE, but gradually expanding with the rise of the postverbal pattern. Brinton (1988:220, 225), on the other hand, says that especially those particles not corresponding to prefixes (cf. above) "often" exhibit telic meaning; in ME she sees telic usages to be increasing. According to Denison (1981:147), particles used with a directional meaning are often ass ociated with an "effective value", but he cannot find any clear OE example with completive up (which is so typical of PDE). The first definite examples of this use are the give up cases (cf. (7)) in the Peterborough Chronicle mentioned above (Denison 1985a:43f). Prepositional Verbs The history of prepositional verbs is similar to that of phrasal verbs in so far as the roots of the development are found in the OE situation (van der Gaaf 1930:14), but the breakthrough of the construction happened in early ME (Hiltunen 1983a:179). One of the precursors of or trends leading to prepositional verbs is the post-position of the prepositional adverb as in him (...) com (...) to (11), called Type (C) order by Hiltunen (1983a:186). (11)
Him com þa mycel folc to. (ChrE 224.34 [1087]; Hiltunen 1983a:177)
But on the whole the appearance of the prepositional verbs on the linguistic stage seems to have been rather sudden. Denison (1981:208) remarks on the amazing number of new collocations appearing in late OE and ME, which at once gave a rather unified/unitary impression. To bring about something like the prepositional verb it was first necessary to have conditions which would cause closer as well as more frequent contact of verbs and prepositions, and secondly conditions which would favour the re-analysis as one verbal unit of two previously separate words. A decisive role with regard to the first condition was certainly played by the decay of the OE case system (Denison 1981:209ff; de la Cruz
90
The History of Multi-word Verbs
1973:163, 165f). On the one hand, this led to an increased use of prepositions, especially after verbs, to some degree taking over the function of the former inflectional endings (de la Cruz, ibid.), and on the other hand it is connected to the fixing of the SVO element order, which in turn may have had a positive effect on the increase of the prepositional verb pattern (Denison 1985b:201). Foreign borrowing or calquing, i.e. of French, Latin or ON verbs followed by a preposition (e.g. OF tenir a — hold in/of, MedL dispensare cum — dispense with, ON fara með/við — fare with), might also have contributed to the increased incidence of verb-preposition sequences (Denison 1981:209ff and 1985b:193); the same goes for the increased use of prepositional object groups under the influence of French (de la Cruz 1973:168f). Furthermore, the eclipse of the prefix system did not only favour the rise of phrasal verbs; verb-preposition sequences could also take over some of the prefixal functions (Denison 1981:209ff). The functions in question were those of making an intransitive verb transitive and of making possible a different kind of object from that taken by the uncompounded or simplex form of the verb (de la Cruz 1973:173). All these factors led to a much greater variety and frequency of prepositional use in ME than in OE (Denison 1985b:193). The second point concerning re-analysis is more complicated and definitely also more disputed. Without further discussion, I will here take for granted that re-analysis does in fact occur, but this opinion is not shared by all linguists.4 The problem of explaining re-analysis is similar to the old chicken-and-egg paradox: it is hard, if not impossible, to say whether a construction is a contributory factor to or only a symptom of re -analysis. An environment favourable to re-analysis is certainly created by the ellipsis of the noun phrase following the preposition as in (12) (Denison 1981:208; de la Cruz 1973:169). In the absence of its normal point of reference, the preposition can be interpreted as having a closer connection to the verb or even of belonging to it. (12)
ich ga lihtliche ouer, ne do bute nempni ham (Ancr. (Corp-C.) 53b.3; Denison 1985b:198)
Of greater importance in this respect, however, are the coordination cases, i.e. those constructions where a verb-preposition sequence shares a common object with another verb, cf. (13). Really valid evidence is provided only by constructions where the common object follows both verbs, which is found for the first time in early ME; OE coordination cases all have fr onted objects (Denison 1985b:198f). 4
Cf. e.g. Inada (1981), as quoted in Denison (1993:152); also Huddleston (1984:201205).
The History of Multi-word Verbs 91 (13)
þe ueond hateþ and hunteð after hire (a1225, Ancr. R. 128, Visser §395)
Lexicalization and/or semantic idiomaticity of verb -preposition sequences definitely also has something to do with unitary perception as prepo sitional verbs (Denison 1985b:194) — either as a reason or as a consequence. In this context, it is interesting that Denison (1981:245) found prepositional verbs with idiomatic meanings in the Orrmulum, which is very early indeed. The following are lexicalized and idiomatic ME examples, the latter describing an adulterous act in a tree: (14) (15)
and ye send for me, I shall .. bryng hem with me. (Paston Letters, No. 631; Van der Gaaf 1930:15) I wende han seyn / How that this Damyan hadde by thee leyn. (c.1395, Chaucer, MerchT IV.2393; Denison 1985b:193)
There are two other phenomena which can support re-analysis, namely preposition stranding in general and the typically English prepositional passive.5 With those two it has to be kept in mind that they reac h far beyond the range of prepositional verbs proper, that is, not everything concerning them is also relevant to prepositional verbs. De la Cruz (1973; also de la Cruz/Saameco 1996) sees the possibility of passivization as the most crucial event in the development of prepositional verbs, as it is only this transformation that makes them really suitable to take over the function and the slot of the former prefix verbs. He dates this seminal change to the late 13th century, citing as supporting factors most of the facts favouring prepositional verbs related above, and additionally the decline of the impersonal pronoun man. His most important point, though, is the effect of analogy, in the guise of the systemic pressure exerted by the phrasal verb system towards the filling by prepositional verbs of an empty functional and formal slot. As de la Cruz/Saameco (1996:175) put it "it is in the visible signs of verb and particle cohesion, shown by adverbial particles and prepositions alike, that we should see the primary ground for the analogy that de la Cruz (1973) proposed ...". This view is criticized by Denison (1985b:197; also 1993), who claims that the necessary homogeneity and coherence is lacking in the proposed system and that the "identification" of phrasal verb particles with prepositions in prepositional verbs is a rather dubious assumption. His first point is certainly right, as the 13th century is somewhat early for a fully-fledged phrasal system, but the fact that linguists would not ‘identify’ adverbial particles with prepositions does not mean that
5
Denison (1993) gives the best and most accessible general overview of research done in this area up to 1993.
92
The History of Multi-word Verbs
the ‘naive’ native speaker would not either. In fact, I think it rather likely that the superficial similarity of both constructions is striking for most speakers, and thus would not completely exclude the possibility that both constructions can influence each other at times. What de la Cruz’s view seems to overlook, however, is the linguistic extension of the prepositional passive, which also occurs in environments not even remotely prepositional -verb-like, cf. the ubiquitous example This bed was slept in by Napoleon. Systemic pressure by phrasal verbs could not explain those cases, in my opinion. Moreover, it should also not be forgotten that not all prepositional verbs actually passivize. Nevertheless, the possibility of prepositional passives and an increasing amount of them in the course of history must have had an influence on the re-analysis of verb-preposition sequences. In OE the prepositional passive did not exist at all, and the first safe ME examples date from the 14th century (cf. (16)), according to Denison (1985b:190), who disputes Visser’s (§1950) putative 13th-century example. While the construction is not overly common in the 14th century, it seems to have soon become established, being used extensively in the 15th century, among other places in the Paston Letters, e.g. (17), which proves its presence in everyday language (Denison 1985b:190; van der Gaaf 1930:19-21). (16) (17)
tribulacion ne shuld not fro his course with grutching be þoght on. (c. 1370, Yorksh. Writers II, 48; Visser §1951) he shuld ... be kept in prison til he were put to answere of swich crymes as he were so detect of. (Paston Letters, No. 151; Van der Gaaf 1930:11)
The emergence of the prepositional passive might also have been supported by the cases of preposition stranding in prior exi stence. Stranding is already found in OE, especially in WH-less relative clauses and infinitive clauses (Allen 1977:76-116), but usually the stranded preposition preceded the verb (van der Gaaf 1930:2-5; Denison 1985b:197), cf. (18, 19). Sometimes, as in the case of fronting in (20), it followed the verb. (18) (19) (20)
ac ælc hæfð be þam andefnum þe he ær æfter ærnað (Ælfred, Solil. 201,3; Visser §403) Seo burg ... wæs swiðe fæger an to locianne. (Or. 74,13; Visser §404) Freond ic gemete wið. (MCharm 11.37; Denison 1985b:192).
The ultimate reason for stranding is to be found in the fact that the uninflected relative, i.e. the non-WH relative (as in (18) above), cannot be accompanied by a preposition (Dekeyser 1990; Denison 1985b:192). But a certain feeling on the part of the speakers that the preposition had a close connection to the verb, or belonged to it, might have played a role as well;
The History of Multi-word Verbs 93 after all, WH-less relatives might have been avoided if stranding had been thought inappropriate, and cases in which the preposition occurred twice (once with the WH-relativizer and once with the verb), as in (21) below, would not exist (cf. Denison 1993:133). (21) (22) (23)
she coniured hym by feythe that he ought vnto hym in whose seruyse thow arte entryd in. (1470-80, Malory, M. d’A. 676, 35; Visser §416) Judas ... al redi for to fight On him he suld ha foghten for. (13.. Curs. M. (Cott.) 15735; Visser §412a) alle þet ich chulle speken of (c. 1225, Ancr. R. 2; Visser §410)
However, stranding even spread to new environments in ME, such as WHrelatives themselves, contact clauses and topicalization (Dekeyser 1990; Denison 1993:132; cf. (22)). The position of the stranded preposition also shifted to the modern postverbal position as in (22-23), the first examples of which being found around 1200 (Dekeyser 1990:165) and soon, i.e. from the middle of the 13th century on, this became the norm, at least in prose (van der Gaaf 1930:7; Denison 1985b:197). Phrasal-prepositional Verbs In contrast to the phrasal and prepositional verbs just treated, there is hardly any information on phrasal-prepositional verbs. Visser (§417) notes the existence of verb+adverb+preposition+complement in OE and ME, but doubts whether their complement can be regarded as a prepositional object and thus whether they are really instances of phrasal-prepositional verbs. At least two of his ME examples are convincing to me, namely But lat us falle awey fro this matere (Chaucer, Troil. 3, 1306; c. 1385), and ... til þey sawe theyre tyme to breke out on hem (Brut. 1436 (Hrl. 53) 580, 10; c. 1437). In contrast to Visser, Denison (1985b:202f) sees enough evidence even for idiomatic or lexicalized combinations in ME, quoting for example cry out on from around Chaucer’s time, and come off with, fall in with found in the Paston Letters. Verb-adjective Combinations Information concerning verb-adjective combinations is even rarer. Some, but not all examples listed by Visser (§237) under the heading "quasicopulas" fit the definition employed here. None of them belong to the OE period, and the only clear ME example for me is from 1423, [Thay] breken louse, and walken at thaire large (Jas. I, Kingis Q. CXV). According to Jespersen (1928: III, 369) cases like make merry, make bold etc. go back to an old usage with a reflexive pronoun, which was then omitted later. He does not say when this happened, though. The OED records no examples with
94
The History of Multi-word Verbs
(reflexive) pronouns for make bold, but has both full and elliptical usage for make merry (s.v. merry): (24) (25)
BoÞe seize he WiÞ too houndes mirie made. (1320, Sir Tristr 3085) Make we vs merie for mete haue we at wille. (1350, Will Palerne 1880)
Verbo-nominal Combinations Verbo-nominal combinations have received somewhat more attention than the preceding two types. Nominal tendencies in general are of course connected with this type, and in this context Klaeber’s (1943:73 f) findings that OE translations often render a verbally expressed Latin or Greek original with a combination of verb and noun, in which the noun is usually dominant, are of interest here. He also claims to have found the same nominal leaning in indigenous OE prose. Among the types of nominalized expression he lists (ibid. 77), only the first — and, according to him, the most common one — is the combination of a verb with a nominal object, which is usually abstract and agentive. Two of his examples are gewin drugon "they fought" (Beow 79) and fyl geniman "take a fall, be killed" (Mald 71). Visser (§148-149; §151) dates the origin of the usage of verb + etymol ogically related noun (roughly my Group I), usually without article, with approximately the same meaning as the simplex, to OE, but mentions only examples with the verbs habban and niman, for example (26), paraphrased by him as "deliberate". (26)
He hæfde geþeaht mid his witum and freondum. (Bede 292,12; Visser §149)
He also finds some OE forerunners of the type including a final preposition (my Group II), for instance (27), but does not remark on its frequency (§703704). It is not clear whether they were phrasal units in the sense the modern types are. (27) hwæþer heora sceolde on oþrum sige habban. (Or. 156,1; Visser §704) Brinton and Akimoto (in Brinton/Akimoto 1999), looking for OE collocations with (ge)don/(ge)macian, sellan/giefan, (ge)niman/tacan , and habban + deverbal noun, found quite a variety of don-items, fewer items with sellan, niman and habban, and very few only with macian and giefan. The combinations they found are described by them as less grammaticalized, less idiomaticized, and less lexicalized than their PDE counterparts. According to Hiltunen (1983a:28), verbo-nominal combinations (Groups I and II) are numerically a rather limited group in OE, but the type expanded considerably in ME, partly through French influence. The latter influence
The History of Multi-word Verbs 95 was mainly lexical, i.e. via direct borrowing of phrases (cf. faire paix — make peace), which was supported by the fact that the pattern was already grammatically established in the language. Both Hiltunen (1983a: 215f) and Denison (1985b:203) remark on the not uncommon appearance of lexicalized and/or idiomatic combinations, also those including a final preposition, in ME (28-30), although the degree of idiomaticization was not very high according to Matsumoto (in Brinton/Akimoto 1999). (28) (29) (30)
lasse boste it maketh, A beggeres bagge, þan an yren-bounde coffre. (1377, Langl., P.Pl. B. xiv, 247, Visser §150) ther as men take moore reward to the nombre than to the sapience of persones (c. 1386, Chaucer C.T.; Visser §704) The chyuetayns haue at the moost nede of socour yeuen weye to their enemyes and made the peple proye to them. (1413, Pilgr. Sowle (Caxton 1483) iv.xxx. 78; OED s.v. give)
The first passives of this type are found around 1400 (Marchand 1951:76) or later in the 15th century (Denison 1985b:202), cf. (31a-b). Matsumoto and Tanabe (in Brinton/Akimoto 1999) call passivization infrequent, and the former notices a preponderance of the inner -passive type. (31a) Rule vs by rightwisnes ... , þat no fawte with vs founden be. (c. 1400, Destr., Troy 4850; Visser §1986) (31b) I trowe it shall apeyr, but if it be take hed hate. (c. 1422-1509, Paston Letters 143; Visser §1986) The last verbo-nominal type based on verb + prepositional phrase (Group III) is harder to trace in history. Some examples of this type are found in Visser (§293) under an otherwise both much narrower (only be) and much wider group. There are no OE examples of that kind, which is not very surprising given the lower frequency of prepositional groups in that period. Some few fitting ME examples can be extracted from Visser’s listing, e.g. Youthe and elde is often at debaat (c. 1386, Chaucer Troil. A320) and he ... fireth all the world aboute, whereof they weren all in doubte (c. 1390, Gower, Conf. Am. IV, p.187). The foregoing account of the early development of multi -word verbs shows that while all necessary single elements, precursor forms, important tendencies and even embryonic multi-word types were present in OE, it was the ME period during which all the crucial steps in their evolution were taken. At the end of ME, the system of multi -word verb forms as dealt with here was basically in place, forming the basis for further syntactic an d semantic refinement and especially for numerical expansion. Regarding the latter, and setting the whole thing into a wider context, the following statement by Denison (1985b:201f) is interesting:
96
The History of Multi-word Verbs I would argue that the spread of (a) idiomatic prepositio nal verbs, phrasal verbs, the HAVE A LOOK type, and so on, and (b) the fixing of S-V-O order followed by the rise of auxiliary verbs, and the regulation of DO, would have been mutually supportive. The growth of verb-complement idioms would encourage syntactic regulation, and vice-versa, since a complete lexical item could then appear in all sentence patterns in a fixed sequence without interruption. The real period of growth of the prepositional verb, for instance, was between 1300 and 1700, which coincides with the rise and regulation of DO.
This leads us on to the next period, Early Modern English. 5.2 Early Modern English From this period on the phrasal verb seems to have increased steadily both in frequency and in productivity (Brinton 1988:187). The 16th and 17th centuries especially have been picked out as a first high point in their history, producing a great variety of usages (Kennedy 1920:16; Diensberg 1983:253f). The development of idiomaticity, and thus the greater internal cohesion of many phrasal verbs, also makes considerable progress, e.g. (33) (Diensberg ibid.), although the majority still seem to be semantically concrete like (32) (Hiltunen 1994:132). (32) (33)
Put thy sacchell over thy arme, that it fall not of. (1583 Hollyband Campo di Fior 51; OED s.v. fall) All things are now in Readiness, and must not Be put off. (1664 Dryden Rival Ladies i.ii; OED s.v. put)
The aspectual or aktionsart use of phrasal verb particles is also continued, and perhaps furthered; cf., for instance, Charle ston (1941:100, 110ff), who found examples of durative/progressive (e.g. go/work/drive etc. on) and effective/egressive (e.g. give over, sit out, leave off) aspect in her 18th century material. Phrasal nouns also continue to be formed: Lindelöf (1937:31) lists 25, 27, 34 for the 16th, 17th and 18th century respectively, for instance run-away, sneak-up (16th c.), turn-over, draw-back (17th c.), and cut-off, let-down (18th c.). There are also two studies which point to a less linear, rather an inter rupted picture of the development of phrasal verbs in EModE. Both lead to the conclusion that there was a temporary decline in phrasal verbs between roughly 1650/1660 and 1750 or 1800. The first of these studies is found in Konishi (1958:125), who chose ten common verbs to investigate the first quotations (in the OED, I presume, although he does not state that explicitly) of their combinations with phrasal particles and of their new meanings. That is, he was looking at productivity and not at actual usage — but of course it
The History of Multi-word Verbs 97 can be assumed that there is a connection between the two. His findings are to be seen in Figure 5.1 below. The other study is by Spasov (1966), who examined 46 plays spread from late ME to modern times (post 1945) to determine the occurrences of phrasal verbs in them (cf. Figure 5.2 below). 6 His study thus aims at actual usage, and that moreover in a medium which must be seen as the closest we get to ‘colloquial’ la nguage in historical linguistics (with the exception of private letters, of co urse). Therefore it is remarkable that it corresponds so relatively closely to Konishi’s results.
Figure 5. 1: Productivity of selected phrasal verbs (reproduced from Konishi 1958:125)
6
Unfortunately, Spasov’s book proved to be very elusive, and so my discussion of his findings must necessarily be second hand, based mostly on what Bolinger (1971) says. I hope that this did not lead to a distortion of the facts here. One tentative point I would like to make concerns Spasov’s textual basis: it seems to me to have been rather small with only 46 plays over such a long time span. And I have not seen the list of plays he used, which might also have been enlightening.
98
The History of Multi-word Verbs
Figure 5.2: The frequency of phrasal verbs in 46 plays (Spasov 1966, reproduced from Bolinger 1971). In both cases the lowest point lies somewhere in the second half of the 18th century, i.e. in the great prescriptive period in the history of English. But the period of decline spans the century preceding that time, and thus roughly the time covered by the Lampeter Corpus. Therefore it will be important to keep this putative development in mind when looking at the corpus data later on. Potter (1965:285), for instance, seems to offer contradicting evidence when stating that phrasal verbs are used "fairly frequently" by Sterne and Dryden. Dryden, of all people, was very conscious of his language use, and it is not that conceivable that he would have gone against the prevailing linguistic trends of his time. Two other studies have been devoted to phrasal verbs in EModE, Hiltunen’s (1994) investigation of the relevant part of the Helsinki Corpus, and Castillo’s (1994) of Shakespeare’s plays. Both came to the conclusion that their syntactic behaviour then was basically the same as today. A curious development occurred in the area of prepositional verbs. Marchand (1951:76) cites attempts to turn some prepositional objects into — also formally — direct objects, as in arrive a place, despair thy charm, look a person (no sources given). In these cases it did not work, but some former prepositional verbs are nowadays used without a preposition, e.g. congratulate (cf. (34)), join, miss, fail (Visser §399-400). This shows that some internal variation within the groups across their historical development always has to be reckoned with. (34)
I congratulate with you, for losing your great acquaintance. (1732, Swift, Let. to Gay; Visser §400)
The History of Multi-word Verbs 99 But while some items become lost, new ones also develop. The prepositional passive continued to spread in an amazing way and speed until about 1700, though losing impetus somewhat in the 18th century, perhaps through the influence of prescriptivism (Visser §1953-1955). Phrasal-prepositional verbs consolidated their status in this period, which is syntactically visible in the first passives occurring with items of this category, cf. the items (35a-b), which seem to be the two very first ones (Denison 1985b:202; Visser §1958). If one goes by the list of examples in Visser (§417), they also become significantly more numerous, e.g. (36, 37) below from among them. (35a) There was a servant of yours, and a kynsman of myne was myschevously made away with. (1502, Townly, Plumpton Correspondence 164; Visser §1958) (35b) if their Neighbors will not follow their example, ... they shall be cryed out on for disaffected. (1662, Simon Patrick, Account of the Sect of Latitude-Men, 12; Visser §1958) (36) whereby he became ... better able to go thorowe with this enterprise. (1568, Grafton, Chron. II, 32; Visser §417) (37) All those who do not live up to the Principles of Reason and Virtue. (1709, Steele, Tatler No. 125, §1, Visser §417) There is no information about the fate of verb -adjective combinations and very little about verbo-nominal combinations in this period to be found in the literature. Visser, for example, yields examples such as the following (38-41) for the latter type in various places, but next to nothing by way of explanation. (38) (39) (40) (41)
I have a great mind to be a lecherous man. (c. 1550, Bale, K. Johan (Camden) 12; Visser §151)) A Pick-Pocket; who made a Dive into my Pocket. (1700, T. Brown, Amus. Ser. & Com. 126; Visser §151) They will still gripe fast, what they haue once caught hold of. (1602, Carew, Cornwall 2a, Visser §704) Her husband ... has been in Love with her ever since he knew her. (1711, Addison, Spect. I no. 15; Visser §293)
Kytö and Hiltunen (both in Brinton/Akimoto 1999) provide some information on the — so far — missing EModE link in the history of verbonominal combinations. Working with the EModE part of the Helsinki Corpus, Kytö finds an increase in the use of these forms over the period 1500-1710. The most common verbs in her data are have and make, the latter of which must therefore have become more multi-functional and important since the OE period, when it was rather rare (see above). As in OE, however,
100
The History of Multi-word Verbs
the items found are still generally semantically transparent and not very idiomatic. Hiltunen concentrated his search on one particular text type, namely plays, with only some additional pieces of poetry and prose. 1,404 tokens representing 418 types make up his data, in which make, have (cf. Kytö), and