NICOLAS SLONIMSKY Writings on Music VOLUME ONE
Nicolas Slonimsky, Boston, 1927
NICOLAS SLONIMSKY Writings on Music ...
137 downloads
3346 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
NICOLAS SLONIMSKY Writings on Music VOLUME ONE
Nicolas Slonimsky, Boston, 1927
NICOLAS SLONIMSKY Writings on Music VOLUME ONE Early Articles for the Boston Evening Transcript
Edited by Electra Slonimsky Yourke
ROUTLEDGE New York and London
Published in 2004 by Routledge 29 West 35th Street New York, NY 10001 http://www.routledge-ny.com/ Published in Great Britain by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane London EC4P 4EE http://www.routledge.co.uk/ Copyright © 2004 by Electra Slonimsky Yourke Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group. This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to http://www.ebookstore.tandf.co.uk/.” All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or uti lized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any informa tion storage or retrieval system without permission in writing from the author. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Slonimsky, Nicolas, 1894–1995 [Selections. 2003] Nicolas Slonimsky: writings on music. p. cm. Edited by Electra Slonimsky Yourke. Includes bibligraphical references (p.) and index. ISBN 0415-96865-8 (v. 1: alk. paper) 1. Music—History and criticism. I. Yourke, Electra. II. Title. ML60.S646 2003 780–dc21 2003011569 ISBN 0-203-97028-4 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN 0-415-96865-8 (Print Edition)
published in The Boston Herald, May 5, 1926
CONTENTS Preface A Note from the Editor
x xiii
Tansman’s Traits: Prodigious Youth, Prolific Composer, New Guest at the Symphony Concerts 12/28/27 Stravinskiana 2/25/28
1
The Avierinos’ Concert 3/22/28
7
4
By Way of Introduction [Honegger] 3/30/28
10
A Welcoming Hail [Casella] 4/28/28
13
Young Modernists Hoe Their Own Row [Copland & Sessions] 5/11/28
15
By His Faith, By His Work, To The End [Gilbert] 5/26/28
18
The Hand That Evokes Music From the Ether [Theremin] 10/2/28
22
From the Ether A “New” Music In New Manner [Theremin] 10/8/28
25
New Stirrings in Ether-Wave Music [Theremin] 10/19/28
29
In Arthur Honegger the Symphony Concerts Receive a Notable Guest 1/10/29
31
The Patient, The Doctors, The Verdicts [American music] 1/29/29
35
Composer, Conductor, Cosmopolite [Goossens] 2/23/29
39
By Innovation Shall Hearers Recognize Him [Cowell] 3/9/29
43
Bouncing Into Fortune’s Lap And Out Again [Dukelsky] 3/14/29
46
Our Jazzing, Their Jazzing, Reasons Why 4/20/29
49
Modernist Sprung From the Ancients [Casella] 5/28/29
56
The Pit They Have Hollowed for Toscanini 11/2/29
59
Unalloyed, Undecorated, Undiminished [Musorgsky] 11/30/29
64
This America Deep in His Fervent Soul [Bloch] 12/27/29
67
A Single Line Is Glazunov’s Musical Life 1/15/30
71
Side-Glances at Prokofiev Now Returned 1/30/30
74
In Epitome The Career Of Roussel 10/23/30
77
Who Is Mossolov? And What Is He? 12/1/30
81
The Psalms and Pieties of Igor Stravinsky 12/13/30
83
The Strange Case of Arthur Vincent Lourié 1/3/31
86
Fortunate Years for Unfortunate Composer [Musorgsky] 4/11/31
89
With the New Concerto for Mirror [Stravinsky] 12/26/31
93
Florent Schmitt 11/26/32
98
Enter Lastly The Youngest Of the Angels [Markevitch] 4/20/33
101
Scientific Mind Turned on Music [Saminsky] 5/20/33
105
Welcome for The Incoming Modern Master [Schoenberg] 10/28/33
107
From the West Composer New To Bostonians [Harris] 1/24/34
112
Composer Who Has Clung To His Own Way [Ives] 2/3/34
116
Ranging Round the World of Music 11/3/34
120
Ranging Round the Music-World 11/17/34
124
Ranging Round the World of Music 1/5/35
128
Ranging Round the World of Music 2/9/35
132
Marginal Notes on The Russian Film 2/23/35
136
Memorandum About Unfamiliar Music 3/20/35
139
Ranging Round the World of Music 4/6/35
141
Music of Ives on New England Scene 5/4/35
145
Ranging Round the World of Music 6/8/35
147
Shostakovich, The Soviets’ Wonder Boy 11/2/35
150
Ranging Round the Music-World 12/35
153
Visitor from Mexico to Symphony Concerts [Chavez] 4/9/36
157
Vladimir Dukelsky, Alias Vernon Duke [date unknown]
160
New Placing of Rakhmaninov [date unknown]
164
Index
167
PREFACE Fleeing revolution-torn St. Petersburg in 1918, my father, Nicolas Slonimsky, first went to Kiev, then to Yalta in the Crimea in 1920, thence to Constantinople; finally, via Bulgaria, he arrived at his intended destination, Paris, late in 1921. He was twenty-seven and, despite the revolutionary turmoil of his life to date, had made his way as a working musician. He had taught piano, accompanied singers, coached, worked as a rehearsal pianist; he wrote on musical subjects for newspapers and journals along his itinerary of flight, and he had pounded the piano in silent movie houses. In Paris, he became musical secretary to the conductor Serge Koussevitzky, joining the many émigré Russians who sparked the lively musical life of Paris. In 1923, the Russian tenor and opera director Vladimir Rosing, having received funding from George Eastman to start an opera company in Rochester, New York, invited my father to join the staff as accompanist and coach. My father accepted eagerly and boarded a transatlantic liner with his few possessions and a British book of basic language instruction. He did not speak a word of English. Undeterred, he applied his analytical skills, his knowledge of other languages, including Greek and Latin, and his musical ear to the task of mastering American English. His approach was to avoid using a dictionary and to treat the language as an “extinct dialect.” His boisterous fellow artists at the Eastman School, including the novelist Paul Horgan and the director Rouben Mamoulian, were no help—they enthusiastically adopted his mislocutions as much more fun than the correct ones. At the movies he studied the subtitles, and he treated print advertisements, which he had never seen before, as tutorials in the lingua franca. Hence, by the time Koussevitzky, now conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, invited him to leave Rochester and become the BSO’s rehearsal coach; he could also act as official bilingual secretary. His credentials, his job, and his additional independent activities as accompanist, teacher, and lecturer quickly earned him a place in the Boston “intelligentsia.” His English was fluent by then, though still accented. The Boston Evening Transcript, a daily newspaper, conceived of itself as modest, conservative, partisan, and in good taste, specializing in literature and theater. It had come into being in 1830, founded by Lynde M. Walter, a well-born graduate of Harvard University. From 1842, the Transcript was edited by the founders sister, Miss Cornelia W. Walter, called “the brilliant lady editor” by some but not by Edgar Allan Poe, who, after she criticized him, described her as “the pretty little witch.” In the 1880s, its editor was Edward Clement, known as “the Beau Brummel of Boston journalism.” With a circulation of about 17,000, it continued to emphasize the arts, especially music and drama. There is no record of how my father came to write for the Transcript, starting in 1927. His position as Koussevitzky’s secretary and musical assistant had just come to a calamitous end upon the publication of an article in the Boston Herald headlined “My Secretary Knows More Than I Do—The Boss,” for which he, among many others, had
been interviewed. But his photo was featured. He tried to explain to the maestro that the quote referred to the secretary to the President of the United Fruit Company, but to no avail. As he tells it in his autobiography, Perfect Pitch, he was summoned to the Koussevitzky home: Koussevitzky motioned me to repair to the living room, with Mrs. Koussevitzky leading the way. He proceeded to speak in measured tones as if addressing a defendant in a court of law: “I have nothing against your making extra money by playing the piano in clubs and at social functions,” he began. “But we have a right to demand that you leave my name out of your publicity.” … Then Mrs. Koussevitzky broke her silence. “Like a dirty Odessa Jew,” she remarked icily, “you are trying to pull your sordid little tricks behind Mr. Koussevitzky’s back.” Considering that Koussevitzky was himself a Jew, born nearer to Odessa than I, her remark was fantastic in its rudeness. He never saw Koussevitzky again. That was in January 1927. Thereafter he pursued musical activities of his own and, within a few short years, conducted historic concerts introducing American music to European audiences. His championing of modern American composers, Ives in particular, brought attention to them and to him. In 1933, he conducted a series of landmark concerts of modern music at the Hollywood Bowl. Although the audiences did not welcome them, he succeeded in establishing himself professionally as an important spokesman, analyst, and interpreter. The only available source in collecting the articles in this volume is his own files, now in his collection at the Library of Congress. There may have been more articles that he did not retain or that were lost over the years. Unfortunately, the Transcript microfilms are not indexed, so a search would require scrolling through hundreds of reels containing every page of the daily paper for many years. Even the undated articles included here cannot, as a practical matter, be located and properly sequenced. Most of these forty-eight Transcript articles, appearing at uneven intervals over nine years, were evidently timed for the visit of a composer to Boston or the performance of a work by the Boston Symphony. Hence they are especially interesting as contemporary analyses of composers of emerging significance. Many of the subjects proved not to be of pantheon status, making these analyses all the more rare and valuable. As firsthand records of the world of new music in Boston in the twenties and early thirties, their depth of content is surprising for what were, after all, columns for a daily newspaper. There is no record of why my father’s Transcript articles stopped in 1936. On April 23, 1941, an editorial headlined “Hail and Farewell” appeared on the front page of the Transcript. “For 111 years the Transcript has been closely interwoven with the history and traditions of Boston and America,” it read, but its circulation “has always been curtailed by the necessity of selling at a price [5 cents] higher than its immediate competitors,” rendering it less successful in attracting advertising. Accordingly, it would cease publication in seven days. In the same issue, news headlines announced that German columns had smashed through the pass at Thermopylae and surrounded the Greek army; the king and government had fled to Crete. The arts pages reported that Lillian Hellman had won the Drama Critics’ Circle award for Watch on the Rhine.
The following days’ editions were filled with mournful cries and calls for establishment of a fund to keep the Transcript in business. On April 28, the Transcript gratefully reported the enviable experience of seeing “the flowers for our own funeral,” an avalanche of suggestions for keeping the paper alive. Although contributions were received and the employees agreed to donate a portion of their wages, there was no hope of success in a reasonable time. Readers were urged to offer jobs to 225 “loyal workers.” The paper lives in the lines of T.S.Eliot:
When the evening quickens faintly in the street Wakening the appetites of life in some And to others bringing the Boston Evening Transcript… Electra Slonimsky Yourke October 2002
A NOTE FROM THE EDITOR Every article in these volumes is presented in full without any editing whatever. I have also preserved the orthography and other stylistic elements as they appeared in the original publications or manuscripts. Changes were made only in the rare instances of errors or misprints obvious to me. Accordingly, readers will encounter a wide variety of spellings, especially of Russian names, and the disparate punctuation policies of dozens of different publications. I believe that fidelity to the originals helps highlight the historic nature of these documents, and preservation of the record, warts and all, was of great importance to my father, a lover of language in all its flowerings. —E.S.Y.
TANSMAN’S TRAITS PRODIGIOUS YOUTH, PROLIFIC COMPOSER NEW GUEST AT THE SYMPHONY CONCERTS December 28, 1927 The Times and the Musician—From Poland to Paris— Abundance and Individuality—Years of Preparation and Years of Maturity—Ease and the Man
Composers have their fates, as do books. Music, the most abstract of all the arts, a substance taken from nowhere, or—as the recent experiments of a Russian professor purport to show—from anywhere, by means of a radio antenna and a human hand, that elusive substance seems to live a tense life of its own on the music sheet and in the concert-hall. What a riot of conflicting tendencies! What ingenuities of the creative hand! What intricacies of development, rivaling the trickiest problems in mathematics! As in science, new things are discovered, discussed, rejected, or finally accepted and put into practice. From simplicity, if not simpleness, it has evolved logically to sky-scraping edifices of sound. With the “ceiling” thus attained (to use an aviator term) the composers turned back. Simplicity, by all means, and tumbling went the stacks of musical scores. C major, if you please, and more of it. Skriabin made use of it, naively, as things now seem, in the fifty-three final measures of his “Poem of Ecstasy.” Prokofiev, too, is fond of this simplest key; and, even, the recent Martinu cannot resist the temptation and drenches his “Tumult” in its waters. The huge assemblages of sonorous instruments (and percussion!) have given way to smaller bodies (Frank Martin’s “Chamber Fox-Trot” dispensing with percussion altogether) until there are such things as Schönberg’s “Quintet,” that lymphatic piece of music which would supply an excellent musical accompaniment for H.G.Wells’s sombre vision of the earth’s declining days, with the sun half burnt and a few crustacea scattered on a forlorn beach…. Will the composers meet the inglorious end of Cratylus for whom there was but one unquestionable truth, the motion of his forefinger to and fro before his nose? Bold deeds and recantations succeed one another: only few discerning musicians can hurry slowly. Among them, one Alexander Tansman deserves attention. He is unafraid. He is old-fashioned. He writes music in consecrated forms. He puts to use his native Polish folk tunes. What is more, he expresses himself, and not merely a current idea…. Tansman was born in Lodz, a prosperous town of the erstwhile Russian Poland. He disclosed a sensitive ear for music at an age when babes make their first attempt to imitate the spoken word. Able teachers (Russia never lacked them) gave him first
Nicolas slonimsky
2
instruction in the piano and initiated him into the elementary notions of musical science. At nine he was already engaged in serious composition. He rapidly traversed the paths of his early gods. Grieg gave him purity of design and bequeathed to him heed for folktunes as the most genuine material for musical work. Chopin taught him how to use the form of sublimated dance and demonstrated that embellishments, turns and figurations are not merely a musical accessory. Strauss and Skriabin brought him up to date (that is up to that date, before the cataclysm). A full-fledged musician, he produced a “Symphonic Serenade” for strings, the first of his compositions to be played in public. He was fifteen then and was working joyously, passing, one after another, through all the necessary stages of musical development. Tansman’s first notable success was the winning of all the three prizes at the Polish National Contest in 1919. The news reached him through the daily papers; in the spirit of joyous celebration he tossed his hat on his walkingstick and dashed madly through the streets of Warsaw. Before long he was on his way to Paris, at the time the capital of the musical world, by virtue of some uncodified treaty of Versailles. Ravel and Stravinsky were working there; he submitted himself to their influences, but later emerged from their crucibles invigorated and not effaced. Not unlike Chopin a century before him, he brought to Paris a wealth of his native melodies and soon became a musical plenipotentiary of Poland in the Western World. It was almost without effort that Tansman acquired full mastery over musical forms and orchestration. Then he found his voice and proceeded to speak with an accent quite his own. Accumulating organ-points, descending sevenths, ostensible fifths, and all-butsyncopated rhythms (often on a single note) are unmistakable shibboleths of Tansman. His three-sectioned forms, his songful flutes and sharply detached trumpets (he delights in referring to them in diminutive terms) make up the well-defined cast of his musical countenance. He once wrote to entertain some friends; it was a series of pieces “a la manière de—.” But “la manière” turned out to be Tansman himself, invariably. The joke was on the composer. Tansman does not shun polytonality, plain and outspoken; he is particularly fond of the combination of two opposing keys, say C major and F-sharp major. His “Etude Scherzo” is written frankly in this two-keyed tonality. By the way, why is it that the opposite keys (in the circle of scales) blend so well? Liszt all but united them; Stravinsky mated them in the magnificent pageantry of “Petrushka.” No composer has since been able to resist the enchantment of this firstling of polytonality. Tansman writes with amazing ease and speed. It is no extraordinary feat for him to toss together five Preludes in two hours and a half for an “occasion.” His manuscripts are the delight of the printers; hardly any considerable change marks the transition from the first draft to the second and final copy. If the results do not come up to his expectation he does not hesitate to throw the whole thing overboard or put the jetsam to other use. Thus an ill-born first movement of his Symphony in A minor becomes an Overture Symphonique and is played with this title at a Concert Straram in Paris, while the revision speeds on its way to catch up with the three ulterior movements that repose in the composers portfolio. Tansman has to his credit a symphony, an opera, a ballet, two piano-concertos, three quartets, three violin-sonatas, numerous orchestral and piano-pieces, and also songs. He plays the piano, lectures, writes. His fluent knowledge of five languages and a smattering
Tansman's Traits
3
of a few others give him a requisite background for a man of culture. He had his thirtieth birthday last June…. Somehow or other it is characteristic of our time to produce men that work and live with ease and elegance. Knowledge is no longer a product of hard labor. The romantic heaviness and tragedy of a composer’s life has gone into fiction along with the bright-hued coats and unkempt locks.
STRAVINSKIANA February 25, 1928 A Note Here, a Note There About the Composer of “Oedipus”
An ancient theory teaches us that human life moves in spirals; each constituent circle comprises a period of seven years during which man undergoes a metamorphosis so complete that not even the tiniest tissue of the body remains unchanged. Infancy, adolescence, maturity mark transitions, until the apogee is reached. Then, the decline begins in narrowing curves. An equally ancient theory perceives a thread of continuity through these changing aspects. The conflict of an ever-present essence and everchanging attributes has led to many a philosophical dispute and disclosed many a valuable truth. It is particularly revealing to study the evolution of a great mind; the general tendency, magnified a hundredfold in its concave mirror, affords a better scrutiny of the concomitant processes filled with brusque turns, sudden retreats, and striking apostasies. It is not paradoxical to proclaim an ultimate self-denial as the logical outcome of a great career. The law of change holds its own. With these preliminaries, we approach a work that causes us to wonder, an operaoratorio by the illustrious Stravinsky, freshly submitted to critical opinion. This is Stravinsky of 1927, sharply divergent from the Stravinsky of 1920, which latter is diametrically opposed to the Stravinsky of 1913. We shall not seek for dates previous, lest we grope and fumble in vain, finding but a name. “Œdipus Rex” is written to the text by Jean Cocteau—Jean Cocteau of 1927, Catholic and mythologist. He has run the gamut of human infatuations, embracing a faith which, to the over-cynical may appear as his latest perversity. Jean Cocteau is anxious to narrate to the world a story well known; of things dead, he would speak in a dead language. Latin is the Esperanto of the true Catholic—but Cocteau’s proselytism is of recent date and his schooldays remote. Therefore Monsieur Danielou is intrusted with the task of translation, mindful of the audiences that may be shy of classical learning. Cocteau retranslates Danielou’s ecclesiastical Latin into telegraphic French and assigns the part of the Interpreter to a “speaker.” The Latin diction is carefully supervised; the performers are advised against minor mouse-traps and admonished to harden the consonants, replace the dental “c” by the gutteral “k,” sound a broad “u.” Precursory notes and half-authenticated comments point out Stravinsky’s return to the classicism of Handel. But the score reveals landscapes much more distant in time. We are suddenly carried as if with Andersen’s magical snowshoes, into the midst of churchly musicians that struggle in the confinement of their cells for the fresh air of plain harmony. This coarse, warpy matter, these crude clumsy “tone-clusters,” these rapidly converging motets and stiff-sewn canons, these immovable turgid basses and repetitious discords, this incredible rigidity of style, harks back to the polymelodic era when music
Stravinskiana 2/25/28
5
was in a nascent state, when Palestrina was being born. An innocence of all accumulated wisdom is so ingeniously recreated in “Œdipus” that we are inclined to wonder whether the composer, on seeing the blind alley into which contemporary music has apparently strayed, had not determined to start all over again. … We can readily visualize the score, beautifully copied, in gothically shaped neumes, on that indestructible parchment which by some freak of fashion has lately found its way into music-loving American homes wherein it provides an atmospheric screening for lamp-shades. A masterpiece may yet be discovered in these translucent antiques…. Stravinsky is an individual force that by virtue of many circumstances and coincidences has become a great power in art. His seditious ardor has won an easy victory over the decadent patricians at Debussyan sea. The war came close on top of “Le Sacre du Printemps”—some say because of the Sacre. Peace followed directly after “Ragtime.” Stravinsky “divined” the war as well as the subsequent ragtime, according to the illuminati. A Belgian soldier-musician actually had a vision of the earth dancing to Stravinsky’s music during the last German offensive. It was symbolical of the times after the war that Stravinsky should abandon larger forms of composition. In 1922, he disclosed his “Mavra,” a curious bouillabaisse of oldfashioned arias, slovenly harmonized with superimposed tonic and dominant chords in profusion. One of the critics, an intelligent and independent brain, expressed the belief that “Mavra” was Stravinsky’s first failure. Promptly, he received a rebuke from the composer, for Stravinsky was never diplomatic enough to “rise above” adverse, or unjust, criticisms. Then, two years later, the Octet appeared. At first, the front row of musical busybodies was perplexed but it quickly deciphered the handwriting on the wall. “Le Maître dit,” declared a bellwether, “and we have naught but to listen.” The ill-starred Cassandra of Stravinsky’s “first failure” dipped his quill into the ink of penitence and swore allegiance. Dictatorship was thus established. A few extant contrapuntal pundits protested, but their dissenting voices were drowned in the general clamor. The noisiest of them all was that turbulent tribe of impressionable young men that go hitchhiking on the chariot of each current deity. They supplied the necessary crowd-effect. Stravinsky’s laboratory, whether it happens to be Biarritz, Monte Carlo or some other sunny spot, is well guarded against intruders. Few, if any, know what goes on there; what will next issue from his test-tubes. Rumors are plentiful, however. A cunning spy would report seeing Stravinsky with the score of Bizet’s “Carmen” under his arm, which may mean the lifting of the ban from the conventional operatic forms. Five years ago the intelligence forces were poorly organized and Stravinsky stirred up considerable commotion when he suddenly took up the defense of the well-buried Chaikovsky. The latter’s mediocre ballet, “The Sleeping Beauty,” was produced by Diaghilev, and properly condemned by the umpires of artistic elegances, reflecting, incidentally, upon Stravinsky. There was a great excitement when he publicly approved the revival, adding that he himself derives heritage from that bard of the melancholy rather than from the constructive Russian Nationalists. Stravinsky once dubbed Ravel a Swiss watchmaker, for the excessive nicety of his musical machinery. If the gentle Frenchman were as sharp-tongued, he would retaliate by likening Stravinsky to a Levantine alchemist, canny searcher for the Philosopher’s Stone that would enable him to turn base metals into gold; for that purpose one might have
Nicolas slonimsky
6
Latinized him, Stravinius. Strange vapors rise from the experimenter’s muffle-furnace, assuming wondrous forms. Homunculuses emerge from the doors and mingle with unsuspecting humanity. Unseemly, as some of the resulting composts may be, yet time and again crystals of piercing beauty are shaped therefrom. The prime matter may be inert, but it is quickened by the wizard’s touch. In the words of the thinker: “Genius is the activity which repairs the decays of things.” And behold, through lifeless forms, there shines the fluorescent light of resurrection.
THE AVIERINOS’ CONCERT March 22, 1928 Debut in Boston, Where He Now Lives and Works, of a Russian with a Past as Well as a Present—Memories and Experiences—A Chamber-Program, Well Made and Well Played
There is a strange discrepancy between the living picture of history in the making and the smooth record in the classified accounts. We see a big parade of “heroes,” but their companions who have inadvertently missed the opportunity to deliver a historic phrase or fire the first shot are refused admittance. There’s nothing to be said about them. Yet even the stern British lawmakers speak of the “incorporeal hereditaments” and place them alongside the marketable heirlooms. Modern biographers—our recent visitors Emil Ludwig for one, André Maurois for another—boldly inquired into the living soul of the past in order to restore the balance. On their pages the Valhalla of the great was enriched by a picturesque legion of “the unknown.” The obsolescent magic lantern gave way to the cinematographic camera, the still picture began to move. The nineteenth century—how remote it seems to us now!—still yields first-hand information. Among us—right here in Boston—there lives a man who is a personified Thesaurus of facts and events of the last forty years of music. He is Nicolas Avierino, a name well known among the Russian musical intelligentsia, less known outside his country. A “companion of the great,” his claim to note lies in the qualities that cannot always be turned to gold. He has composed no voluminous scores: proffered no novel theories; startled foreign capitals with no daring interpretations (that confounded word!). Yet he is by no means a “might have been.” His life is as abundant in accomplishments as it is rich in color. Born in Taganrog, the home-town of Anton Chekhov, in southern Russia, he disclosed inherent musical abilities at a very early age. The violin was the instrument that he, or rather his parents, chose for him. He was sixteen when Chaikovsky came to town to conduct a concert of his own music. Chaikovsky’s brother, who was engaged there as the managing director of a prosaic steamship company, had long been friendly with Avierino’s family. He arranged what now would be called an “audition” (the times were simpler then); Chaikovsky was impressed with the young Avierino’s talent and offered him a scholarship at the Moscow Conservatory. There, under Chaikovsky’s wing, Avierino completed his musical education. Later he married Chaikovsky’s god-daughter, whose father was the eminent writer and critic, Laroche. The musical strain in Avierino’s family is continued in his own daughter, Olga Avierino, rare example of a singermusician. Avierino recalls an instance of the innate kind-heartedness of Chaikovsky. The janitor’s boy, aged seven, was in the habit of making Chaikovsky’s working table his
Nicolas slonimsky
8
playground. One day when Avierino called on him. Chaikovsky announced his decision to go to Klin—his summer house—where he could work undisturbed. (He was then completing the orchestration of the Sixth Symphony.) “But who dares to disturb you here?” questioned Avierino in righteous indignation. “Why, Egorka,” (which was the name of the obstructive boy) replied the composer of “The Pathetic.” He was visibly perplexed at Avierino’s suggestion that a good kick would suffice to solve the problem. At the Conservatory Avierino met a bashful lad in the uniform of a marine-cadet. The boy was studying composition, also the piano. One day, Avierino’s teacher, the famous and redoubtable Grzimali, could not find anyone to accompany at the lesson. Avierino called in his friend, but the lad pitiably failed to read the simple chords at sight. “What? Is he sick or crazy? The poor wretch has no notion about music!” The boys name was Alexander Skriabin. In the gallery of Nicolas Avierino’s memory are arrayed in a splendid line Chaikovsky, Rimsky-Korsakov, Arensky, Cui, Glazunov, Medtner, Skriabin, Taneiev, Rakhmaninov. Avierino heard Anton Rubinstein improvise and play for the gratification of his friends. He epitomizes Rubinstein’s power in these few words: “When he played well, it was sublime; when he played badly, it was abominable.” He also asserts that he heard Rubinstein make a crescendo on a single note! Avierino holds the distinction of being the first professional viola-player in Russia. Yes, viola-players used to be recruited from the ranks of retired violinists. In 1905, Avierino, who was then teaching at the Moscow Philharmonic, wished to form a quartet. Two violinists and a ’cello-player of first magnitude joined him; Avierino took up the viola, which later brought him well-deserved laurels. As a viola-player he made an extensive tour through Russia with Shalyapin. Two years before the war Avierino was appointed Director of the Conservatory at Rostov. He disclosed uncommon executive ability, and the Conservatory was well on the road to prosperity when the war and revolution put an end to peaceful activities. Avierino followed the itinerary of Russian exiles and ultimately established two homes with an ocean between them: Paris and Boston. At Symphony Hall, those who would see, if not hear Mr. Avierino, may descry him in the viola-section of the orchestra’s farthest point east. Last night, at Steinert Hall, Mr. Avierino made his first public appearance hereabouts. The program was arranged in two contrasting halves: Bach and the Russians. The sixth Brandenburg Concerto for two violas, two violas da gamba, ’cello and bass, was probably a “first time in Boston.” Mr. Avierino’s colleagues from the Symphony, Messrs. Bernard Zighera, Droeghmans, Marjollet and Lemaire, assisted him. How powerfully did Bach write for instruments of deeper voices! How miraculously did he dispose of the difficulties of writing within a close range! The Concerto was given a faithful performance—each composing voice was brought out with dignity and discretion; each player was alive to the meaning of the music as a whole. There was more of Bach: Mr. Avierino played the famous caiconna, transposed a fifth lower to suit the instrument. Mr. Avierino knows the secret of the true viola sound; he never “goes fiddle”; accordingly, his playing was full-bodied, rich in undertones, wellpoised. A man of impeccable taste, he gave style as well as tone. For Bach “con cembalo” the brothers Zighera played a sonata questionably named for “piano” and viola da gamba. The seven strings of that hot-house instrument are as familiar to Alfred Zighera as is the fingerboard of his ’cello. Bernard Zighera is as expert
The avierinos' concert 3/22/28
9
in striking the piano-keys as he is in plucking the harp-strings. Alfred on the viola da gamba evokes all the excellence of ’cello tones; Bernard’s piano-playing has something of the style glorified by Wanda Landowska: it is both delicate and rhythmically impelling. The precision in team-work of the two brothers brought obvious delight. An intermission came, and then Madame Olga Avierino sang. Her appearance was nothing short of a revelation. What a glorious voice! In the songs of her own land, sung in her native language, she unfolded a magnificent panorama of warm, bright, rich colors. Wistfulness and joy, fear and abandon, song and recital—all found expression in her singing, while her voice flowed forth in an evermoving stream…. With the excep-tion of Nina Koshetz, there are few Russian voices equaling that of Olga Avierino. Mr. Avierino finished the concert with a group of viola-pieces, some of them borrowed from the violin-repertoire, one arranged by Mr. Avierino himself; others original. A piece like Arends’ concertino may appear obsolescent if not entirely out of date. Yet, the metallic sound of Mr. Avierino’s viola made it endurable for the ear. Mr. Avierino was recalled, as was Madame Olga Avierino before him. There was as much enthusiasm as a half-filled hall of small dimensions could muster. The concert served a noble purpose—the profits are to go to Home and School Visitors Association. Those who missed the concert can see, if not hear, Mr. Avierino at the Symphony: viola section, farthest point east.
BY WAY OF INTRODUCTION March 30, 1928 Parisian Anecdotes and Other Amiable Personalia About Arthur Honegger, Composer of “King David,” at Symphony Hall Next Sunday—From “Bad Boy” of “The Six” to Present Place as Highly Reputed Musician
Many an engaging biography has been spoiled by a premature regeneration of the hero. Nearly all famous persons start on their careers as “enfants terribles.” With the tumultuous twenties behind them, a tangible menace of respectability begins to loom. And it was well said that, contrasted to that horrid state, even the dastardly profession of the Pirates of Penzance would appear “comparatively honest.” Only when senility comes along, flaunting a beard à la G.B.S. or Trader Horn, does the whilom bad boy resume his earlier practices—this time as a “viellard terrible.” Thus, Arthur Honegger was once severely chastised for disobedience to the musical legislators, to be later brought into the limelight of admiration. In January, 1920, Comœdia, a Parisian daily paper that combines the news of the arts with naively undisguised commercialism, printed a story about six young people in search of new ways in music. This article gave vogue to Milhaud, Honegger, Poulenc, Auric, Durey and Germaine Tailleferre. It was a chance combination. If at the gathering in Milhaud’s rooms, to which Cocteau brought the critics of Comœdia, there had been one more young musician, history would have known “The Seven.” As it was those present became “The Six” and had to hang together thereafter for fear to be hanged separately. For, a fullbasement feuilleton in a Parisian art-paper was not a matter to be scoffed at. Anyhow, the six had been—and have remained till this day—excellent friends. They did not have to proclaim their flagrant differences, and at least one of them, Durey, was saved from obscurity by his presence at the party. Arthur Honegger soon unsheathed his claws. The bad boy of 1920 became “the popular idol” in 1924. “King David,” produced in Paris under the leadership of Robert Siohan, obviously appealed to the clean and the unclean musically; while en masse both applauded. The consuls gave Honegger a suspectful “once over.” The legend of “The Six” had already been “debunked;” but Honegger stood firmly on his feet, with his “Pacific” starting on a world-tour, his oratorios shouting joy in brazen fanfares. Honegger is no Stravinsky. In his choral music any collation with Stravinsky’s “Œdipus Rex” must be rejected without reservations. Stravinsky has formed his present idiom through a series of highly interesting and, at times, mysterious transformations; whereas Honegger has carried on the traditions. He does not cross the Pyrenees with Debussy and Ravel in quest of exotic flavors. His Muse is healthy, red-cheeked, fullbodied. He outpours joy as naturally as a whale spouts a geyser of salty water. Honegger
By way of introduction [Honegger] 3/30/28
11
is a poet of victory—and the list of his works gives little food to the anatomists of melancholy. The horoscope of a composer may be easily cast by this simple query: “How do you like your trumpets?” Ravel prefers them muted, unobtrusive and velvetcovered. Stravinsky (before “Œdipus”) scorns them—a phrase crying for valves and pistons he would give—in “The Nightingale”—to the piano obbligato! But Honegger prefers trumpets in their delicious impudence and lets them loose. A “Horace Victorieux” cannot be victorious without fanfares, a “Chant de Joie” is not joyful without the towering upper register of half a dozen cornets! In Hebrew times instrumental speech was confined to trumpets and harps, and the power of the brass was crushing. Did not the walls of Jericho fall in sunder when a full brass-band was blown against them? Honegger’s “return” to the classical themes has never been an act of devotion or premeditation. His “King David,” as well as the subsequent “Judith,” was written to order. Mezières, a little village in Switzerland, contained a theater, or rather a stage, built of pine planks, sheltered from the elements by a sort of canopy. There was a pit for the musicians. The performances passed in rustic informality, spectators spreading all about the natural scenery, the directors announcing the beginning of the next act by loud buglecalls. Hence, by necessity, the fanfares of “Judith.” Food was also served, and Honegger who came occasionally to conduct was once seen directing with a sandwich clutched in the palm of his left hand. He also took delight in catapulting prune-pits at The Narrator. For Honegger is given to hilarity tempered by a sense of humor. After the success of “Pacific” he has never missed an opportunity to shake hands with the engineer of the trains on the Paris-Lyons-Mediterannée line. One of the brothers Morax, who owned the Mezières Theater, was—back in 1920—in need of orchestral accompaniment to a “dramatic psalm” in five parts. He consulted Ansermet, the musician and conductor. Ansermet suggested Honegger, and Stravinsky endorsed the idea. But Honegger’s whereabouts were unknown. A letter containing the offer was sent in care of Darius Milhaud and, after several postal peregrinations, reached the addressee. Honegger was then in financial straits and willingly agreed to undertake the job for a sum of five hundred Swiss francs (less than a hundred American dollars). There was not much of an orchestra to write for; a sole double-bass represented the string section. But wind instruments were sufficient in number. Honegger did wonders of adaptability; the choruses went down on paper first; the scant orchestration followed between Feb. 25 and April 28 of the year 1921 (without benefit of the leap-year day!) the score was written, the commission fulfilled. In 1923, Honegger reorchestrated the whole thing for the Paris performance. But the trail of the woodland orchestra of Mezières was not entirely effaced from the new score, and the soloing double-bass still stood in evidence recalling the times of its splendid isolation. Honegger has now become a recognized master of music. His progress is that of natural evolution. He is, perhaps, the only composer (elders aside) that withstands the pressure of Stravinsky. The time may be not distant when Honegger will become the torch-bearer of the modernist tradition and with it receive all the blessings—and all the curses that such high light and leading inevitably entail.
Nicolas slonimsky
12
An article as clipped and preserved by Slonimsky. His collected papers are now housed at the Library of Congress, Washington, DC.
A WELCOMING HAIL April 28, 1928 Alfredo Casella Comes a Second Time to Lead The Pops
The spirit of the age is not easily caught and embottled. Contemporary observers have not developed that sixth sense which enables us to subscribe a common denominator to the confusing variety of events. The right to judge is therefore handed to posterity and in its name the warring factions assert their respective truths. The conflicting tendencies of today will be properly pigeonholed by scholarly lexicographers of 2000 and the “Twentieth Century Style” will rise in the splendor of learned definitions. The dead ballast—the poor unsuspecting living corpses!—will be pitched ingloriously out of the window. Only few lucky ones will inherit the earth of future cinephonographic encyclopedias. Who will dare to question the inscrutability of the generations to come? In our own right, being posterior to the romanticists of the past century, we take the bench. Berlioz, assembling the opinion of his time, had once uttered—in a single breath—the names of Chopin, Schumann and Kalkbrenner. We all know by now that Kalkbrenner got into the company by an optical error. It would take courage to resuscitate Kalkbrenner’s music. It takes as much courage to denounce the unfathomable boredom of Berlioz’s own major works. The greatest virtue of the twentieth century style in music appears—to the coeval eye—to reside in its changeful spirit. All styles, from bare primitivity, through grotesque inflation, down to affected simplicity are present. The very idea of the necessity of being consistent begins to lose ground. Younger elements feel the ozonizing breeze of the times and drift gently along its course—the pilot’s stick well in hand, the engine pulsating in strong beats. Boston now greets a man in whom the searching spirit of our times seems to have found its expression. Alfredo Casella comes to us as conductor of the Popular Concerts of the Symphony Orchestra. These concerts under his direction, have assumed a dignity undiminished by “refreshments served between the numbers.” Nay they have almost become educational. All ages, all styles, all tastes are presented, the personality of the conductor permeating the whole. Casella began to study music at the age of four. At eight he knew all of Bach’s Suites, Preludes and Fugues. This early acquaintance left an ineffaceable trace in his mind. When the cry “Back to Bach” became the fashion of the moment, Casella had nothing to remodel in his musical make-up. Music was not the only lore that tempted Casella. From “childhood’s happy days” he was interested in chemistry and electrical engineering. His scientific bent was later disclosed in his book, “Evolution of Music”—a unique and absorbing work unfolding the progress of musical thought from the famous “Messe des
Nicolas slonimsky
14
fous” of the thirteenth century up to the last compositions of the modern school, Casella himself included. Casella’s evolutionary course has traversed—within the twenty-odd years of his activities—at least four different methods of music-making. His own country justly claims him as national composer. His “Italia,” his songs to the texts in dialect, his early symphonies, reverberate native tunes and rhythms. But not in vain has Casella received Parisian education. As citizen of the musical world at large, he left not a corner unexplored. He knew the lure of blatant polytonality; in his “Pages of War” (with the subtitle “Five Films”) he piled Pelion upon Olympus and Ossia upon Pelion to describe the march of German armies through Belgium. Atonality, as free play of tones, was also the object of Casella’s researches—to be abandoned after it proved barren. Long before Stravinsky Casella turned back to the companions of his youth—the great Johann-Sebastian and his Italian contemporaries. The “Partita” was the product of this renewed interest in the good old wine of the past. Sprinkled with a scoopful of modernity, it presents a classic example of synthetic style. The unflagging logic of the development deserves a special study. The combinational of each musical atom is strictly observed; the symmetry of composing elements is crystal-like, Boston is as yet waiting to hear “Scarlattiana,” in which the composer has enlarged and glorified the essentials of the Italian master. Casella’s manifold activities have brought him fame as pianist of the very first rank, as conductor, as composer. Fewer know him as eloquent writer. Yet, his little book on Stravinsky (written in a delightful Florentine style), his truly remarkable notes in the “Evolution of Music,” his frequent contributions to the publications of both continents make him a person of high standing in the literary world. In his versatile mastery of various arts and sciences, Casella appears real forerunner of a second Renaissance. Specialization in our times has reached the peak of absurdity. We are hav-ing experts in finishing touches with no knowledge of fundamentals; wine-testers ignorant of laws of chemistry. Soon we will have great masters of “pianissimo” or builders of stupendous climaxes or geniuses of slow movements to whom any other form of expression is a closed book. Leonardo da Vinci was versatile, because versatility then was the companionate trait of genius. An artist then was not only a producer but also a maker. To play a ready-made fiddle is commendable and pleasurable. To invent a fiddle belongs to the truly great. Alfredo Casella is a maker of music as well as a producer. As such he stirs and differentiates the musical progress of our times. All those who seek broader outlook will join in the welcoming chorus “Ave, Casella, Bostoniensi Te Salutant!”
YOUNG MODERNISTS HOE THEIR OWN ROW May 11, 1928 Mr. Copland and Mr. Sessions Arrange Novel Series of Concerts in New York
Modern music has availed itself of a “Salon des Independents.” An obscure theater— Edyth Totten’s in New York—is its site, “The Copland-Sessions Concerts of Contemporary Music,” its official title. It is fitting that these two energetic and gifted makers of new music should head such an enterprise. Holding apart from somewhat spectacular exhibitions of the League of Composers and similar organizations, yet complementing and enhancing these occasions, the Copland-Sessions concerts have been set afoot “in the interests of the younger generation of American composers.” But—the editorial note of the program cautiously warns—“Youth will be interpreted in the most elastic sense.” Likewise, one ought not be too particular about American exclusivity, for, as the same note avers, “an occasional European work of corresponding interest may be included.” Finally, dismissing the bothersome notions of “young” and “American,” the two authors of the series—both unmistakably young and American—declare that “the only criteria in the choice of material will be excellence of promise”—the most latitudinarian statement ever made in any chart of liberties. They were seven—the composers arrayed at the Second Concert of Contemporary Music on May 6. Unlike the demons of Prokofiev’s weird incantation they were genial, well meaning, and, in the case of one or two, naive in their earnestness. To be sure, Mr. Copland and Mr. Sessions towered so conspicuously over the heads of the rest of the group that it must have brought painful discomfort to their modest selves. Mr. Copland contributed “Two Pieces for String Quartet,” a confusing heading for two movements of which one, Rondino, is dated 1923 and the other, Lento Molto, was finished just in time for the first rehearsal of this concert. The Rondino was delightful to hear—sneer as the composer may at the distant date. Free interplay of rhythms, yet in conformity with the austere requirements of the form, melodic invention of poesy and humor, imparted that balance of musical pulsations that is too rarely achieved by creative musicians. On the other hand, the last-minute Lento harked back to the composers “Music for the Theater,” with hardly a touch of well-calculated innovation. Here Mr. Copland was again a poet. He takes a simple figure of four notes—a descending second, a skip, an ascending second—and works wonders passing it from the ’cello to the viola, from the viola to the violins in turn, while the triad of a purity that seems to be fresh-found accompanies each entrance of the theme. Mr. Sessions handed in a Sonata for Piano in four cemented movements played without pause by Mr. John Duke, two slow Andantes enfolding an Allegro a Vivo as
Nicolas slonimsky
16
Coda. The Vivo was not heard—because the composer had not finished it in time for the concert. Instead an ending was affixed to the second Andante to fit the piece for public hearing. Once more Mr. Sessions shows himself a persistent and scholarly searcher for a new style that is to supplant the combustion and ruin of the shattered system of polytonality. The chastest melody imaginable opens the Andante, the laciest accompanying figure gives it flesh; only an acid inflection now and then reveals the hand that pulls the string. Equally transparent is the Allegro; the second Andante is a recapitulation. Thus a new synthetic style is being built. Roger Sessions is more than qualified to be one of the chief masons. Robert Delaney a young Californian and a pupil of Nadia Boulanger, proffered a Sonata for Violin and Piano in which Mr. Copland played the piano-part. In the witty words of a discerning musician who had seen the manuscript in advance the worth of the music lies in its negative qualities: that is, the composer does not do things that are not good; does not fall into banality; guards himself from obvious imitations. But there the music remains a sketchy, bristling succession of notes leading nowhere. As a display of skill it is interesting. Richard Buhlig, who first memorizes any pianistic nonsense and then gives it off powerfully, played a group of piano pieces by Ruth Crawford, Adolph Weiss and D. Rudhyar. Miss Crawford, a composer from Chicago, was anything but feminine in the rough-and-tumble of the “Lento, tempo rubato” and “Leggiero.” Did she know the East, she would have realized that her musical manners are slightly out of date. Otherwise, she seems to be not without perspicacity and there may be a chance for her in the future. Mr. Weiss is a well-equipped and thoroughly educated musician. He knows what he is talking about. There is also a scheme to his rather bewildering inventions. Perhaps, that is why his Four Preludes would appear more interesting to the eye than to the ear. Beyond any doubt, the music has constructive elements that will eventually serve some lofty purpose. As yet it is still preparatory. One is at a loss when confronted with the Three Paeans by Mr. Rudhyar, the one elder composer in the list. The titles: “With Joyous Exaltation,” “Epic and Resonant,” “With Rhythmic Fullness” are aggressive, and the high artillery of theosophy (on the printed copy of the music) blinds a surprised spectator and puts him to flight. At a safe distance, one cannot help being rude. This kind of music is a Naught raised to the Nth power. It does not even burst like the fabled frog; brings no relief to the strain. Last on the program stood a Quintet for Piano and Strings (in one movement) by Master W.Quincy Porter, a pupil of Ernest Bloch. To many it bore promise and disclosed more excellence than any other piece of the evening, Mr. Copland’s and Mr. Sessions’s excepted. The slow introduction had distinction, valor, dignity of the leading line. The faster middle-part went in lively, sharp-edged rhythms: the return to the slower movement (a fast section wedged between two quiet parts, according to modern habit in vogue since Honegger’s first Violin Sonata) was worked out without slackening or lowering the pitch. The handling of the instruments was excellent. To be sure, over the entire stretch of the music Ernest Bloch’s spiritual ectoplasm was clearly observable. At first he infuses his pupils with his own personality; then gently releases them as soon as they show the signs of growth encouraging them in their independent steps. Thus Roger Sessions had written “Masques” as Bloch’s pupil, and a few years later asserted himself in the Symphony. Similarly, by all logic supported by precedents, W.Quincy Porter must
Young modernists hoe their own row [Copland & Sessions] 5/11/28
17
find his own Parnassus, George Antheil was the only pupil that cheated his teacher, and went astray into the noisy realm of front-page publicity. Bloch publicly disowned him. The Copland-Sessions Concerts have a significance far beyond the value of the music played last Sunday. The house was nearly sold out, which means that there are several hundred persons actively interested in modern music. They also mark the beginning of a consistent propaganda led by composers themselves. With the public beginning to take notice in new music the day is not distant—know all men by these presents!—when modern music will reach the longed-for stage of self-support.
BY HIS FAITH, BY HIS WORK, TO THE END May 26, 1928 From the Pen of a Friend, The Mind, Habits, Life, of Henry Gilbert
When death comes there also comes a new realization. Small events, random remarks, chance meetings assume a new and illuminating significance. The character of the man appears clear and complete: Ecce Homo! Henry Gilbert died on May 19 in his native Cambridge where he was born sixty years ago. The Germans called him Uramerikaner, the primeval American composer. Many, on this side, call him the Walt Whitman of American music, a courageous and uncompromising pioneer. His life was a series of picturesque adventures, ennobled by constant striving towards the aim which he had set out to attain: to compose some American music. He was a national composer from conviction, not out of false patriotism. For this he fought valiantly, armed with an unflinching sense of self-assertion and equally strong capacity of reflective criticism. An exquisite sense of humor saved him from both the immoderate elation at a success and mortifying despondency at a failure. He was whittling his tunes out of the products of this American earth; he set up his structure with the hand of a man stubbornly devoted to his cause. He lived to see the victory; American music, steadily growing, gaining universal recognition. His perception was never dimmed by partiality. He was of old stock; modern deviltries were out of his ken. Yet he welcomed Copland, who came from an entirely different America; he thought that Cowell was “mathematics,” but willingly admitted certain virtues even in this bewildering innovator. In his judgments he was naturally discerning, unprejudiced and openminded. He publicly declared that he was out of sympathy with the moderns. But he would refer to his own compositions as to “A. B. C. music”—and there was a derisive admission that the “devilishly clever” moderns had something on him. There were many among those assembled at the funeral who knew Henry Gilbert intimately and jostled with him cheek by jowl from boyhood on. At the request of Mrs. Gilbert they spoke and also read his favorite poet, Walt Whitman. Henry Gilbert’s life unfolded itself in these reminiscences. He grew up in Massachusetts, his family escutcheon dates as far back as 1640, where a Humprey Gilbert was registered at Ipswich. He was also descended from Lieutenant Ezekiel Belknap of Revolutionary fame. Both of his parents were musicians; his father—Benjamin F.Gilbert—was a composer and organist; his mother—Therese A.Gilson-Gilbert—a singer. She still lives in the same house where Gilbert, his wife and their two daughters have lived. Hoary with
By his faith, by his work, to the end [Gilbert] 5/26/28
19
age, she was spared the ordeal of knowledge of her son’s death; nor does she possess sufficient mental strength to hear, to see and to understand. As a boy, Gilbert was keenly interested in natural history. He would by hours chase butterflies or pry into the mysteries of plant life. The infinite variety of life fascinated him. He was an early thinker—at the age of ten he attended one of the performances by the celebrated Ole Bull, that same Ole Bull who long before Prokofiev’s “Quintet,” for thirteen instruments successfully executed quartets and trios with but one assistant “presiding at the Piano Forte.” The young Gilbert determined then to play the violin; his grandfather obligingly contrived for him a home-made Stradivarius, with an old cigarbox for the body and a piece of light wood for fingerboard. Gilbert taught himself to play and when the heavy hand of necessity forced him into the open, he became a professional violinist. He played at hotels and in small theaters—on one occasion even at an insane asylum. In one of these places he met a Wagnerian soprano who overheard him play something from Lohengrin. She suggested that he should study with Edward MacDowell, the American composer, who was then in Europe receiving inspiration from Grieg and Liszt. Going to Europe was entirely out of question; but by a fortunate freak of chance, MacDowell felt oppressed by nostalgia, and decided to return to America, where he joined the staff of the New England Conservatory at Boston. Promptly Gilbert applied for instruction and constituted himself MacDowell’s first American pupil. A composer’s life in the gay nineties was not the frivolous dalliance of Parisian smart boys of 1928. Under the pressure of circumstances, Gilbert was compelled to seek employment. For ten subsequent years he had worked in the printing establishment of his uncle and in the office of the C.C.Birchard Company. During these years he never grew sullen or lost courage, but, perforce, relegated music into the realm of luxury. In 1901 he was stirred by the reports of a novel opera where mob-scenes were enacted: it was “Louise” by Charpentier. Gilbert would not have been Gilbert if he had not acted as he did. Obeying a desire long suppressed, he embarked on a cattleboat that took him over, went to Paris, heard the opera, and at the top gallery of the Opera Comique gave a solemn vow to become a composer. He came back and set up his lodgings in a barn at Quincy, Mass. The barn was occupied, beside himself, by a horse and a cow. But after a while the cow departed (she probably was sold) and the horse went crazy and had to be shot. “No wonder,” Gilbert would add facetiously, “the sounds emitted by the piano I had installed there were anything but soothing.” It is indeed a rare occurrence that a mere determination to become a composer should be realized. Gilbert could not help falling short of his ultimate aims: too many obstacles were blocking his way; continuous, nagging penury was not the least of them. He had to plow a virgin field, was ushered into his profession by no solicitous teachers. Yet seen from a different angle, his achievement seems to have reached far beyond the mark set by himself. He has succeeded in saying his vigorous say; he has blazed a new path, disclosed the virtues of a music that is American. Against MacDowell’s Grieg-like gentleness he “sounded his barbaric yawp.” The genuineness of his powerful shout was unmistakable; his sincerity and originality made up for what he might have lacked in technique. He never tired of reiterating his ideals—by word of mouth, by letter of print. He spoke of buoyancy, exuberance and nervous vitality of America, of its jolly up-and-coming
Nicolas slonimsky
20
spirit—energetic, optimistic, impatient of restraint—with plenty of jingoism, vulgarity and “hurrah boys.” Like most pioneers he had a great gift of expressing his thoughts in a direct and vivid manner. He wrote well; he spoke as engagingly. In a talk given in 1920 before the Men’s Club of Redding Ridge, Conn., he told his life with frankness and expressiveness, commanding admiration. Under the cover of splendid irony and mockery he recounted amazing stories. “The Dance in Place Congo” is now a well-known composition. Last year it received its European sanction at the Frankfurt Festival. The power of the music reflecting the “shout” of the New Orleans negroes is uncommonly impressive. Yet, some twelve years ago, the then conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra to whom the score was submitted did not deign to examine it; nor could Gilbert obtain any reply to the notes of inquiry which he wrote concerning it. Seeing no chances for a performance in his home city, he went to seek fortune in New York. The director of the Metropolitan Opera House accepted the “Dance” for a ballet production. A story was written, and the rehearsals began. The ballet-master was a Bohemian and knew nothing about negroes. Yet he was possessed by realistic ideas. To impart a “couleur locale” he contrived large wooden flamingoes, “which flew in quite a natural manner” about the treetops. Surprised, Gilbert asked him what his invention was: “Why they don’t have flamingoes in Louisiana.” The ballet-master was a kind soul and seeing the composer in obvious distress promptly ordered: “Cut out the birds.” As the rehearsals progressed, Gilbert saw his ideas fading away; but at least there was good will and the five performances went through without serious injury to the music. The composer pocketed his $250—a sum hardly sufficient to cover the expenses of the trip— and returned home. Gilbert’s manners were by no means conducive to worldly success. He did not know the gentle art of handling conductors. He never wrote adulatory notes to any of the Zeuses of orchestral firmament. He would submit the score, patiently wait for results, make all allowances for the conductors busy timetable, but he would not give up a lot of his music for the sake of a performance. On one occasion, when a conductor exhibited, in Gilbert’s own words, “conceit and ignorance” to the extent intolerable even in the highest-stationed representatives of this sacred profession, Gilbert calmly withdrew his score at the last rehearsal. It is only truth to tell that the papers reported the performance just the same. It was the unforgettable good fortune of this writer to have been associated with Henry Gilbert in a professional way, when Gilbert’s last composition “Suite for Chamber Orchestra,” was played by the Chamber Orchestra of Boston on April 28. The suite was destined for the spring festival at Washington, under the auspices of the Elizabeth Sprague Coolidge Foundation, at whose commission the work was written. It developed, however, that the program could not include the entire list of compositions on hand. The composer thereupon secured a permission to have it performed in Boston first. The piece contained three movements: a Prelude, “somewhat in the nature of an exercise for the violins,” the Spiritual and the Fantasy. Gilbert wrote in his characteristic style: “The Spiritual is an attempt to create a native American piece—something that shall sound, unmistakably, as if it had its origins in America, and nowhere else”; and of the Fantasy: “It has no program—just music—with plenty of melody which I believe in. The main theme is somewhat ‘ragged’ in character, and there are one or two episodes in ‘sure enough’ rag-time rhythm, but then it wouldn’t be me if they weren’t there.”
By his faith, by his work, to the end [Gilbert] 5/26/28
21
Henry Gilbert was present at all the rehearsals; as well as at the performance. When he appeared on the stage to acknowledge the applause nothing in his nobly cut features, offset by a stream of silver hair, would evoke the foreboding of an imminent end. His copper-brown complexion—which incidentally led many to belief that he was of Indian blood—alone betokened a faulty circulation and weak heart-action which was to cause the final stroke. It is not the intention of this article to give an evaluation of Gilbert’s musical heritage. Nor would a mere enumeration of his works add to his character as composer and man. His music is of America and for America; written by an American who loved his country and contributed greatly to its perpetuation in art. He was a gentle, understanding soul. He feared not death as he feared not life. In the words of his fellow-poet he might have said:
Give me your tone, O death that I may accord with it.
THE HAND THAT EVOKES MUSIC FROM THE ETHER October 2, 1928 To Introduce Prof. Theremin, Russian Savant of Sound, Prophet of New Tones
Science invades music! This most unruly of all Pierian pastimes becomes an object for experiments. Professors of acoustics and investigators of aerial vibrations tell amazing tales of exploration and discovery, and urge professional musicians to co-operate. The latter being hard of hearing, cer-tain scientists see fit to use the cave-man method and hit the unwilling ones with the club over the head. Professor John Redfield writes an astonishing book on Music “as a science and an art,” bristling with invectives and full of righteous indignation. At times, the author is magnificently unjust or delightfully autocratic. He would forcibly remove pianos, uprights or grands, from the conductors or the composers room; he would “shoot at sunrise” all individuals who call themselves teachers of harmony; he would relegate into Morondom all vocal instructors and would leave no instrument untuned in the orchestra. No soothing book, but what will you? Musical Babbitts cannot be sufficiently thrashed, and revolutions are not made in white gloves. Mr. Redfield’s book is a revolutionary book in this—that it relentlessly preaches the necessity of rejuvenation of an art that shows all symptoms of decrepitude. The Philistines already feel the surging tide; here and there proffer an impotent defense. Musicians, so they say, do not need knowledge, music being guided solely by instinct. Science can manufacture no Stradivarius, can find no recipes for Beethoven’s Symphonies. Moreover, brains are actually at odds with musical brawn. A perfect blonde somehow loses her perfection the moment she—by misadventure—begins to think. A perfect tenor must of necessity be innocent of gray matter, and we read a list of artists who lost their box-office attraction through giving intelligent performances. To explode all this balderdash would require little effort. But of much more consequence it is to welcome—not sparing the words—those who are bringing about the peaceful revolution. Here is Professor Theremin whose name should be pronounced in French fashion: Termin. He is a Russian of remote French parentage. Unlike Professor Redfield, he is a gentle spirit. He comes to us—at Symphony Hall next Sunday afternoon—with the fruits of his labor, and does not urge or imprecate. No one can fail to be impressed by the new and wonderful music invoked from the magic box “by the movement of the hand.” We imagine—and our imagination is helped by the appropriate posters—a human hand playing on the waves of ether, and little we care whether this ether exists at all, and what actual change the moving hand effects. It is a pity that lack of curiosity, so typical of the musical crowd, prevents us from inquiring into the source and origin of these audible wonders.
The hand that evokes music from the ether [Theremin] 10/2/28
23
Professor Theremin began his exploration of sound at the University of Petrograd (renamed Leningrad in 1924) some nine years ago. He was chiefly interested in instrumental timbres and the overtones on which the former depend. To be master of overtones is to become a demiurge of sound-colors, inasmuch as the relative strength of these secondary vibrations determines the timbre. Electric current, duly transformed and brought within the range of audibility, affords an excellent and controllable medium for accurate measurement. Hertz’s ether waves, the radio waves of our everyday life, make the technical part still less dependent on material conductors. For the first time, an instrument sounds, unfinished with valves, pistons or strings, freed from the incidental noise of scratching, clapping and plucking—a sound generated by the varying tension of the electro-magnetic field. A metal rod, similar to the radio-antenna, and an intensifier form the two chief parts of the apparatus. The human hand, or any moving material body “plays” on the instrument. Professor Theremin warily warns his pupils (for he has a “class”) against playing with their unbuttoned coats or, for that matter, with their noses. The “technic” is altogether different from any known musical instrument, and there are fifty-seven varieties of howls and screams in store for every apprentice who would evoke the spirit of electrical music, untrained by The Sorcerer. Professor Theremin—who is not a professional musician—has learned to “play” a few representative pieces by Rakhmaninov, Skriabin and Saint-Saens. He has no keyboard or any scale to follow, and has to rely exclusively on ear. Someone, inconsiderately passing through the laboratory, may add an extra sharp or flat by projecting his body on the electromagnetic field. Absolutely correct pitch in the tone-production of the Thereminovox is still to be desired. But the sonority startles anyone who has ears to hear. Forty thousand ’cellos playing in an incredible unison are pouring out a stream of vibrating air. Suddenly, the timbre changes; and something resembling the Vox Humana of the organ is heard, emanating, it seems from all sides. The present Theremino-vox is at its best in the tenor register. It does not have to take a breath and that continuity of sustained tone, of which Wagner dreamed all his life, is at last achieved in a manner glorious beyond description. Less ambitious contrivances stand alongside the Ether-Wave-Player in the Theremin Laboratory, housed in the annex of the Plaza Hotel in New York. One of them is of incalculable importance to musical science. It looks like a toy upright piano or a celesta without the “insides.” Instead, there are a number of radio-dials each labeled do, re, me, etc., including the chromatic tones. By a turn of these dials, each one of which is divided into 180 degrees, the corresponding sound is altered. Each note can thus be given any value of pitch within certain limits. Intervals, beyond the dreams of musicians in purity, can be produced with any degree of accuracy, for any duration of time. The audible test of this accuracy is given by the Tartini tones, the tones that represent the difference between the frequencies of the two components. When this difference is only a few vibrations per second (our “symphonic” unison) we hear periodically pulsating beats that remind one of H.G.Wells’s fantastic story in which an inventor, having tasted of his “accelerator,” found himself in a sort of slow-motion world—with sounds disintegrated into mere succession of heavy, monotonous raps. As the two constituents of the former unison diverge, the beats grow more and more frequent; the eardrum fails to register them separately; the resulting depression exteriorizes itself in an incredibly low sound, climbing up as the operation continues. We traverse the entire scale of all possible Tartini
Nicolas slonimsky
24
tones; then again we are confronted with the incredible when Theremin produces the seventh overtone which lies outside of the tempered scale, but forms a perfect consonance with the tonic—a consonance which we have never heard in our lives. This instrument allows production of a perfect pitch for any note of the scale, tempered or other. By its nature, it cannot be affected by temperature, humidity or any other nuisance of the concert-hall. It can revolutionize our so-called “symphony” orchestras and constitute an unalterable standard of pitch. An orchestral conductor who, upon being informed, does not immediately avail himself of it, will be deliberately standing in the way of better performances. Theremin is fascinated by the possibility of plural musical systems. Ours is based upon the partial tones 2, 3, 5. What new music could be built if we chose the tones 7, 11, 13, as foundation? Or any other combination of pure sounds? Skriabin made an attempt at creating a new musical system. But in his “Prometheus” he tempered his imaginary high overtones. He could not catch the unreal seventh tone. Theremin can. A new Skriabin will work on a responsive medium, will have his orchestra tuned up or dispense with it altogether. An ensemble of Theremino-Voxes will well suit the task. Theremin, the inventor, and Redfield, the prophet, with many others seeking to cure music, as art and science, of the threatening anemia, are performing the valuable office of a cultured missionary. Musical obscu-rantists clinging to their reactionary creed, will resent any radical change, and will sneer at knowledge, as opposed to instinct. The poor souls know their history none too well. The “machine methods” of Gutenberg did not kill poetry. The scientific spirit of sound explorers will not kill music.
FROM THE ETHER A “NEW” MUSIC IN NEW MANNER October 8, 1928 As Virtuoso and Lecturer, Demonstrates His Invention
Professor
Theremin
Seldom did an occasion so outgrow itself as the appearance of Professor Theremin at Symphony Hall yesterday afternoon. The inventor presented a few aspects of his discovery, made for all ages and all times, to a limited audience recruited from widely different ranks: Musicians (in a striking minority), professors of various sciences, men and women of literature and art, technicians, radio-specialists, dealers in electrical appliances and a considerable crop of ladies and gentlemen engaged in earnest exploration of the Great Beyond and other unknown mysteries. All these were not sufficient numerically to fill up the spaces of the long-enduring Symphony Hall. Each one had brought, however, his specific ardor. General interest to the proceedings was unremitted; curiosity flung high; and the mental processes peculiar to believers in cosmic vibrations imparted a beatific look to some of the listeners. Boston is a seat of scientific religions; before he knows it, Professor Theremin may be proclaimed Krishnamurti and sanctified as a new Deity. Indiscriminate idolatry (on wrong assumptions) is just as serious a menace to Professor Theremin’s research work as blunt indifference which— again, numerically speaking—confronted him in this city. Berlin delegated enough Germans for four capacity houses at Theremin’s appearances. Pleasure-loving Paris has seen a crowd turned away from Theremin’s exhibition at the Grand Opera. America, and its Hub, strangely demur, in spite of the front-page publicity and alluring aspects of the thing, as conceived in the popular mind. The stage of Symphony Hall proffered to the heterogeneous attendance an uncommon spectacle. Three radio sets, all of different makes, with no attempt at beauty or elegance, stood there. Each one was furnished with a vertical metal rod—the antenna. Three loud speakers of futuristic size and shape ranged behind—a huge triangle for Professor Theremin, a rectangular prism for one of his assistants and a near-cube for the other. Music desks as part of the radio sets. Wires and batteries. And a grand Steinway in the middle of all that irrelevancy…. The bell rings, scaring off the curious amateurs that gather near the parapet. A moment of psychological anticipation, and Mr. Theremin appears, swiftly pacing across the stage, his bearing erect, carriage dignified. He is just about thirty. He affects a small moustache. He wears a blue business suit which possibly tends to dispel a magician complex. No bag of tricks to be emptied upon the breathholding mob. Merely a scientific business to be related, with all allowances for public ignorance and public imagination. Mr. Theremin has little English, which fact he communicated to those assembled in a few words. Mr. Gerard thereupon read the
Nicolas slonimsky
26
translation of Professor Theremin’s explanatory paper, using the correct pronunciation of Theremin’s name: Termen, with the accent on the second syllable. The paper, in diction and substance, was aimed at the general public and carried the message clearly, without undue tax on untrained minds, but with sufficient elementary background of everyday science. Professor Theremin, according to his declaration, is not to eliminate the personal element in art; his aim is to lessen, or abolish altogether, the mechanical difficulties of a “technique” and natural deficiencies of home made instruments. The resistance of the material is the chief enemy of good tone-production. Consequently, the material must be made elastic to the greatest extent. There is no subtler medium in existence than the electro-magnetic field in which we theoretically and unwittingly live. The scientist summons an electric current to his aid and does all preliminary work with it before putting it “on the air.” The logical chain of conclusions in Theremin’s popular paper captures the laziest brain. Politely assuming that the public knows something about overtones, he points out, that his apparatus enables him to create timbres at will. He then proceeds to demonstrate. Medium pitch, impressive, smoothly flowing. Bass tone, huge-massed and monstrously voluminous. High tone, an excursion into the birds’ domain. Whistles, tiniest squeaks, insect-like humming; shrill, piercing, almost head-splitting high frequencies, swiftly disappearing into the inaudible in the fortieth-thousands of vibrations. The audience reacts variously. Amusement, pleasure and the under-lying spirit of “How on earth…,” particularly among the youngsters that came with the youthful determination to “find out.” And when the echo effect was shown and a sound reflected to the other end of the hall, several upturned faces bore unmistakable testimony to the fact that nothing was to be taken for granted. The squeaks and the low grumbling of the futuristic triangle aroused applause. Professor Theremin, gentle and condoning, acknowledged it with a civil bow. He let Mr. Gerard read on; we learned that the human hand is nothing but a prosaic electric conductor that alters the electric capacity of the condenser, or the antenna in Mr. Theremin’s case, and thus affects the musical pitch. But, as Mr. Theremin puts it poetically, “From time immemorial the commanding wave of the hand has been the sign of supreme power.” And supreme artistry. Professor Theremin showed us how lifeless a tone is, unquickened by Vibrato. Science, in its highest achievements, does reverence to human art. Has art fully repaid its debt to science? The program, in its “pops” consistency, stirred one’s mind to philosophizing. First cinematograph pictures recorded a sneeze of Edison’s assistant. First phonograph plates reproduced a trivial tune; first television demonstrations transferred the image of a lady smoking a cigarette. Professor Theremin’s electrical instrument plays for us “selections” that greet us from every radio-speaker and every Victrola. Schubert’s Ave Maria was the opening “number.” In it Mr. Theremin disclosed his new technique. A decided advance of the hand is requisite to change the pitch beyond the interval of a third. A quick jerk of a finger is all that is necessary to raise the pitch chromatically. A quirk of the little finger will add a flat or deduce a sharp. The right hand takes care of the pitch. The left hand puts on expression marks. It lowers upon the intensifier and dampens it into nothingness. It shoos away the tone to secure a glissandoless transition spaced out by the right hand. It affords a staccato or pizzicato effect by discontinuing the sonorous tremor. Ring-shaped
From the ether a "new" music in new manner [Theremin] 10/8/28
27
in Mr. Theremin’s apparatus, a rectangle of wires in that of his assistant, the intensifier is a foot-controlled device in the third machine. Professor Theremin can send his electric menials in any direction, multiply them by any number, kill them in a fraction of a second, scatter them in any given order; can produce any timbre, plaintive and meditative, grotesque and abusive. It is difficult not to fall into prophesying when this new power is first disclosed to us. Let us hope that it will become commonplace before long, much to the benefit of a musical humanity. As yet, raving, and the more immoderate the better, is the legitimate expression. Skriabine’s early Etude and particularly, the never dying Swan of Saint-Saens made one realize suddenly that Theremin is a musically endowed person. He had been cultivating ’cello playing quite seriously, taking courses at a musical institution in Petrograd and appearing at the usual semi-professional concerts. He conceived his first general ideas—which have come to realization in such a glorious way—while struggling with doublestops in one of the ungodly Goltermann Concertos. Technical difficulties—all of which are, strictly speaking, unnecessary and removable—are as little part and parcel of art, as slow locomotion is property of human kind. Riddance from physical impediments in musical instruments has been the lofty aim of all great manufacturers. Theremin cuts at the root of the problem, and solves it. In a duet from Glinka, Mr. J.Goldberg joined Theremin “at the Theremino-Vox.” It was a foretaste of the future large ensemble of electrical instruments. Mr. Goldberg himself performed, very musically and with excellent feeling for nuances, the eternal “Night” of Rubinstein. Then, a female adept of the new craft, made a graceful appearance on the stage, in the person of Miss Stepanova. The audience, delighted and warmed, greeted her cheerfully. For a moment, one thought of Theremin, as a Thurston about to saw the young woman in two cohesible parts or effect her exit through the loud-speaking triangle…. Gently, and pupil-like she played her part in the Quartet from Rigoletto transformed for the nonce into a Duet with dubious aid from the piano. The characters of the Opera were swapped round, Miss Stepanova often taking up the Duke’s songful measures, and Mr. Theremin turning coloratura. Handel’s Largo was then presented in the form of a trio with the piano again somewhat in the way. Miss Stepanova, the eyes of the audience upon her, stationed herself, quite unexpectedly, at the bass-apparatus. Professor Theremin cautiously tested the thing, on the stage, occasionally arousing some hundred—or so it seemed—sleepy and grouchy double-basses and eliciting selfcontented squeaks, not from the ether, this time, but from the audience itself. The Volga Boatmen song for three instruments—the excellent arrangement is said to be made by Alexander Siloti—brought an end to the program. The marvelous, hitherto unattainable qualities of Professor Theremin’s invention—the continuous tone, astonishing volume, new and beautiful timbre, combined with the flexibility of soundcontrol affording the faintest pianissimo as well as crushing forte—these powers stood out in this last song as a convincingly written last paragraph of an epoch-making book. The public—an excited, picturesque crowd, drew nearer to the stage and was tasting the last drops of now unmitigated pleasure. Professor Theremin and his assistants urbanely went through the ritual of acknowledgment; then made for the artists’ room where autograph seekers, conjecturers and swarthy gentlemen-believers in cosmic vibrations
Nicolas slonimsky
28
waited for a chance to talk to the man whose hand makes ether-waves change their course. The event may have been majestic in its way. Still, the impression prevailed that its relation to the greatness of the cause was anything but adequate. Probably, first exhibitions of every great invention were incongruous. The attention of the people is often misdirected; the showy or the entertaining part of the business unproportionately emphasized. The core of a great discovery is seldom touched. Exhibitions have their agelong traditions; the financial side has also to be considered. Professor Theremin was born under a lucky star. He is news. He has frequently held attention of large masses. Musicians of note endorse his invention. Big industry does not try to starve him out of business, but—according to modern methods—directs his spreading influence into safe channels. But those of his discoveries that are not so spectacular as the Theremino-Vox still lie in abeyance. Professor Theremin has a method whereby a piano may be automatically tuned with a margin of accuracy of one hundredth of a tone. It is amazing in its simplicity and conclusive in its self-evidence. Where is that piano-manufacturer who will dare to overturn the present order of things and purchase the patent? Theremin himself would be reluctant to throw an army of hardworking tuners out of business. Theremin has an instrument that provides an unalterable pitch. Who is the first musician to use it? Theremin is offering, for the asking, a magazine of timbres, colors, and mathematically correct frequencies. Where is the composer to make proper use of this wealth of musical material? It remains with the ever-growing group of propagandists to preach the new doctrine— that of the rejuvenation of music by science. Splendid victories have been won already. But the mental attitude that generates a passive resistance on the part of the old-school musicians has still to be combated. This resistance will disappear when Professor Theremin’s generic ideas will be accepted as the only corollary of the long evolution of music—as a science and an art.
NEW STIRRINGS IN ETHER-WAVE MUSIC October 19, 1928 Henry Prunières, editor of “La Revue Musicale” and Parisian arbiter of good taste in music, has contributed to the New York Times an article about various achievements of French champions of “electrical music,” commonly called “ether-wave” music and universally associated with the name of Professor Leon Theremin. It is most gratifying to learn that the idea of using the electro-magnetic field as a medium for production of sounds is spreading; that the natural resistance on the part of the musically conservative is weakening; that musical physicists in all countries begin to take vital interest in the movement that is to remedy most of our musical ills. It is less agreeable to watch the growth of a subtle controversy which tends to detract somewhat from the priority of the originator of a great idea. Monsieur Prunières pictures Professor Theremin as a dreamer unmindful of practical ends, infatuated with the beautiful vision of a hand causing “sounds to burst from an antenna,” caring little for correctness of pitch or virtuosity of technic. This attitude, Monsieur Prunières philosophically remarks, is “perfectly in accord with the Slavic type of genius.” These compliments paid, Monsieur Prunières proceeds to his business, which is to prove that the Frenchman Hugonion antedated Theremin in his invention. “The principle utilized by him is in substance that of Professor Theremin, though it was patented in 1922 before the Russian savant began his labors,” Monsieur Prunières baldly asserts. But it was fully three years before that Theremin began laboratory experiments in the ice-ridden, famine-stricken Petrograd of 1919. Long before the war, as a youth dividing his time between science and music, Theremin brooded on the problem of eliminating the resistance of the wood, brass or catgut of our instruments and finding a new medium for sound-production. It was this generic idea that brought about his discovery. The “movement of the hand in the air” is an incidental and quite unimportant detail. Monsieur Prunières must have been taking too literally the posters representing Theremin as modern magician who evokes music—crotchets and all—from the indisputably “empty space.” But the learned editor of “La Revue Musicale” is apparently not at home with acoustics. He tells us that M.René Bertrand, the inventor of the “dynaphone,” discovered “by chance” a principle different from that of his predecessors, but does not give a hint as to the content of this new principle. On the other hand he says that M.Bertrand succeeded in eliminating all interference, which sounds strange, inasmuch as interference has never been much of a problem and can be easily subdued on any electrical device, including that of Professor Theremin, by generating a negative frequency. He immediately makes a bad slip in referring to “audible” waves with a frequency “varying from one vibration a minute to 10,000 vibrations a second.” Monsieur Prunières should have “heard” the
Nicolas slonimsky
30
“low” tone of two vibrations per second which Professor Theremin produces at the peril of his own person, his guests and even the furniture, floor and window panes. Such a “sound” causes various sinking sensations about one’s diaphragm and alters blood pressure. It displaces air particles by three centimeters. In handling these mammoth sounds (and Professor Theremin is busy on the problem of introducing them into the orchestra for better sustenance of the bass tones) the experimenter must think of the safety of musicians in the orchestra and patrons of the front-row. Needless to say that one vibration a minute is as audible as the sound produced by the revolution of the moon. Monsieur Prunières’s faux pas is, however, a satisfying event. It testifies to the importance of Professor Theremin’s invention. No great discovery ever remained uncontested by honest searchers in a similar direction. The telephone, the phonograph, the incandescent lamp, were twice and thrice invented, apparently at synchronized moments. Even the two satellites of the planet Mars were caught by two pairs of eyes in the same night, not to mention the Laputans’ prophetic findings. But gratitude and recognition go to the genius who first formulated his object with unobscured clarity, set to work with unflinching determination and achieved the aim in full consciousness of the problems involved and efforts to be made.
IN ARTHUR HONEGGER THE SYMPHONY CONCERTS RECEIVE A NOTABLE GUEST January 10, 1929 The Composer and The Man in Brief Survey, with “Pacific” for His Image—The World Into Which He Entered and Prevailed De la musique avant toute chose.
Stirred by a gust of wind, an Æolian harp sounds a tone—a syllable of musical language. The air is full of music; and now and then happily winged Ariels unchain it for us on their magic trumpets. Then the tempest roars in chromatics; then earth and fire, water and air, shape themselves into four-part harmony. Music and nature run in parallels, never to cross, ever to counterpart. Respighi’s caged nightingale is less winged than Beethoven’s pastoral birds; Strauss’s alpine wind-machine less chilling than Rossini’s breezy scales. Portraiture in music defeats its purpose by exposing the inaptitude of an art to measure up to life, greater as the former may be than the latter, if kept within its own uncurved course. Few musicians are as true to these chaste ideals as Arthur Honegger, not long ago a formidable modernist, now an unopposed messenger of the new musical truth which is as inevitable to come upon us as the year 1930. At the Dantesque age, on the summit of his powers, he already gathers the rewards of his mettle. Last year Russia greeted him, and he found orchestras there that had his music well in their routine. Now America welcomes him with an uncompromising salute. Soyez le bienvenu! Curiosity whips the sentiment, and the figure of the French-Swiss composer wearing a healthy smile under a basque cap becomes the picture of the hour. He is as much excited over things American, as the curious are excited over him, and, true to his first infatuation, he never fails to inspect the locomotives that drive him hither and thither. His type is Pacific 2–3–1, according to the number of the wheels, in front, on the side, and behind. Indiscriminate newspapermen, using indiscriminate cuts to illustrate his most famous musical score, err frequently and annoyingly in these details. Arthur Honegger took the Pacific for his inspiration as Schubert had taken the postillion. Nor is he the first to marvel in tones at the puffing monster. In his modest way, Glinka wrote a song of the railroad train; and Berlioz was tempted by the early engine. In Honegger’s Symphonic Movement there are actual musical sounds in the rails vibrating under the speeding wheels, there is an obvious acceleration of beats and puffs. There is even the familiar effect of the Doppler principle—the change of pitch of the whistle of a
Nicolas slonimsky
32
locomotive travelling at a high rate of speed. But Honegger does not set a pair of rails, or blow the steam whistle, as a musical photographer would. All this serves him as material as the minor third of the cuckoo served our musical ancestors. The harmonics used by Honegger in the introductory bars of “Pacific” are uncannily near the actual scratchings and scrapings when an engine is first set in motion. A gramophone record made under the wheels of a 2–3–1 would have been more correct, but its application to a musical piece would have killed it outright; for all that follows is designed on a musical scale, demanding musical setting. “Pacific” evolves in a quasi-sonata form, which, in ideal purity, is motion progressing from a slow and short introduction to a rapid rhythmic movement, either ending in a crash or symmetrically receding into the original stillness. “Pacific” comes to a stop— and the double and triple rhythms serving as speed-regulators produce an irresistible impression on the senses. Here is almost an illusion. No wonder Jaques-Dalcroze considers “Pacific” an embodiment of a true rhythm, a masterpiece of music as sound in motion. The melody flows abundant in “Pacific” as soon as the brakes are released; its course is smooth; scarce drum-beats mark the junctions. In “Rugby”—Honegger’s glorification of football—he goes a step further, eliminating percussion altogether. A game without a crash! Plenty of commotion, but commotion by a breathless melody marked, and by riding rhythms sharpened. Music flowing full tide, full of sudden alarms and trepidations, music that excites without stunning. To some, such elimination of the most logical accessory to any music of motion and vigor, would seem an unnecessary stunt. But Frank Martin, Honegger’s less illustrious countryman, wrote a fox-trot for chamber orchestra without drums and lost not a whit of pulsating power. The classically inclined Hindemith does not luxuriate in percussion. Even taken as a stunt, this general trend toward economy of means has not a little significance. Stunt and mastery are next-door neighbors. Palestrina and Bach were great stunt-performers. There is not a vestige of human sense in writing a perfect canon, at the expense of tremendous effort and possibly crippled inspiration. We possess no multiple power of sensation to follow several independent lines of complicated counterpoint. Yet Bach’s achievement in Fugue changed the face of musical history and paved the way for the great symphonists of the following centuries. A successful stunt presupposes a superior technic. Physical culture teaches us to stand on our heads that we may stand firmly on our feet. Musical culture must pursue a similar course. Modern youth achieve things that would baffle ancient wise men. There is no need to worry about scarcity of geniuses; the musical world is still in the making, and out of the present turmoil remarkable men are arising more numerous than ever. Arthur Honegger appeared on the musical horizon during the war. Music was in a crisis, as was the entire world. Musicians, great or small, were languishing under the strain of mortifying decadence. Mallarmé was ever worrying that his sonnets were not “sufficiently obscure.” They were; and to his texts sensitive musicians were setting an equally obscure, languorous, though strangely attractive music. They reveled in visions of ancient Greece, vanished gods and voluptuous nymphs. Satie had a cult of his own, perfecting the art of miniature. Exquisite raptures in nebulous tones, half-suggestions of an impossible felicity, the entire wealth of the impressionistic palette, seemed to reign
In arthur honegger the symphony Concerts receive a notable guest 1/10/29
33
over the souls and minds of both musicians and poets. Away from this coarse life with its internecine wars and annihilating machinery! More flowers, perfumes and pretty things! Into this world of wan decadence came Arthur Honegger. The difference between Zurich, whence he came, and Paris, where he established himself, was great. Of different make and spirit, he was not tempted by the impressionistic vapors. He was all for healthy, boisterous rhythms. His first Sonata for Violin and Piano, written between 1916 and 1918, does not betray the signs of French sensualism. He writes a “Homage to Ravel,” but thereafter pays but little musical homage to the acknowledged master of French music. In Paris during the war, he meets Mademoiselle Andrée Vaurabourg, now Madame Honegger. She plays his early Toccata at a meeting of the improvised Cercle Musical et dramatique Indépendant. Ever since, her style of playing, full of feminine charm, finds reflection in Honegger’s piano-writing, up to the subtle and brilliant Concertino. For sentimental reasons, Honegger may recall in this January of 1929 that exactly nine years ago, at a gathering at Darius Milhaud’s, a music-reviewer, eager to help along a group of struggling young musicians, listened favorably to their efforts. On Jan, 23, 1920, an article appeared in Comœdia, that caused confusion for a number of years: “Les Six Francais; Darius Milhaud, Louis Durey, Georges Auric, Arthur Honegger, Francis Poulenc et Germaine Tailleferre.” The Six had just as little in common, in their musical make-up, as any six Frenchmen picked on the street would have in their physical appearance. But it was a “boost”; “The Six” were friendly; they did not consider the arbitrary grouping as being in any way harmful. The story of “The Six” proved, however, more vital than any one imagined. Some explanations on the part of Honegger and Milhaud were quickly forgotten, and the easier way of following the erroneous conception was universally adopted. At least, one of the group was thus saved from oblivion. Honegger’s first popular success came with “Pacific” in 1923. In the same year he reorchestrated “King David,” the oratorio that had originally been written for a rustic theater at Mezieres, scored for a wood-wind ensemble plus a solitary double-bass. Rimsky-Korsakov once said that all orchestral music could be divided into three categories: music that sounds well even with an inexperienced orchestra; music that only a good conductor and an expert body of players can bring out to advantage; music that no conductor and no orchestra can salvage. Honegger’s music sounds always well and yields itself admirably to instruments. His instrumentation is as simple as it is logical. He has a strange aversion to “fancy” instruments. True, he has written a Hymn for ten string instruments, all different, ranging from ultra-violin to infra-bass, at the instigation of Monsieur Léo Sir, the inventor. But never once has he used such a common nuisance as the E-flat clarinet. Stravinsky sends it cackling in the most inappropriate passage of “Œdipus!” Honegger is also universal in his tastes and abilities. Oratorio has never been held in favor among young composers, and Florent Schmitt suffered much loss of popularity on account of his addiction to large and solemn forms. Honegger, the modern, tackles huge choral masses with the sure hand of a Berlioz. Without much ado, without pomp and proclamation, he writes the masterpiece of oratorio that is “King David.” With equal mastery, he indicated the modern style for opera in “Judith.” Biblical subjects, used and abused to the limit, do not disconcert him. Subject matter does not count. Modern art can
Nicolas slonimsky
34
handle old articles in a modern fashion. “Horace Victorieux” with the most conventional story out of the most respectable part of Roman history is made to proclaim modern ideas. His Concertino admittedly an antiquated form, sparkles with the most unashamed jazz. “Pastorale d’Ete” proffers an undisguised melody under the simplest dress of a chamber orchestra. Complete freedom from any premeditation, no adherence to schools, no fear of taboos, a fine disdain of the repressions that hamper the development of young talent! This simplicity of purpose and mastery of performance place Arthur Honegger above even the most talented of his contemporaries. In this period of ultimate formation of a modern idiom, he is likely to become a central figure. When others hesitate or experiment he moves forward. In the musical Rugby he is an easy winner.
THE PATIENT, THE DOCTORS, THE VERDICTS January 29, 1929 The Case of American Music Back and Forth Between Two Consultants
American music is not jazz. Jazz is not music…. With these words opens a provoking book by a provoking writer: “An Hour with American Music” by Paul Rosenfeld. Since it is virtually impossible to spend a full hour with American music without jazz obtruding on the auditory nerve, Mr. Rosenfeld’s statement assumes at once a paradoxical guise. His book is a torrent of words and unverbal vocables, which, by its very force of impetus, washes away all prejudice of established beliefs, and floods over the head in its irresistible onrush. After the promised hour is over, the reader finds himself in the condition of the Niagara tourist traversing the Hurricane Bridge and getting out at the Rock of Ages: utterly benumbed, soaked to the bone, lashed by the winds, yet singularly refreshed by an experience, very jungle-like, but safely within immediate reach of modern civilization. Mr. Rosenfeld’s paradoxes are deadly poison for smug generalities. Jazz has changed nothing in the human environment, he asserts, and reveals to us new and unsuspected agencies at work. “How many revelatory experiences do we not owe to the work of Varese, of Chavez, and Copland?” he asks rhetorically. How much of the intensity of American life does not come from the burgeoning of the talents of Harris and Sessions and Ruggles?” The hilarity of a statistical mind must not be aroused at this. Mr. Rosenfeld’s book is a wishful revelation of a world-that-ought-to-be, and we cannot help joining him in a jazz-less chorus; yes, we want our musical tastes to be governed by the young sophisticates rather than by Mrs. Carrie Jacobs Bond. And if the “End of a ‘Perfect’ Day” still outsells Aaron Copland’s “Vocalise,” it is merely an error of perspective. Only once in the history of mankind have things been adjusted properly. It was in Russia in 1917, when the then Bolshevik commissary of musical affairs, Comrade Arthur Lourié (now a Parisian refugee) tried to advance musical development of the masses by publishing, in his capacity of a dictator, his fanciful and modernistic compositions, to the exclusion of all others. From such methods our splendid modernists would undoubtedly demur, even if the House of Ricordi would resign its power in their favor. But it is none the less gratifying to dream of a better world where people would flock to hear and see burgeoning talents—very polytonal—and where a solid line of ushers would have to be established to hold back the crowds at the League of Composers’ concerts…. Mr. Rosenfeld’s book of fiction is such a dream, published, distributed, and—enjoyed.
Nicolas slonimsky
36
Mr. Rosenfeld makes short work of the Spirituals and Mountain songs, as American folk-lore. He questions the very genuineness of the negro chants. He hardly mentions Indian music at all. According to Mr. Rosenfeld, MacDowell is the first American composer deserving the name; and to him he is none too lenient. “His music amounts more to an assimilation of European motives, figures and idea than to an original expression.” He finds MacDowell’s real personality in the “quaint little melodic idea” of the Woodland Sketches, and gives a fine, sensitized appreciation of MacDowell at his best in the following lines: There is a MacDowellesque accent, facileness and sentimentality notwithstanding; some glamour or tone added by him to the world’s horizon. Perhaps it is merely a faint note of sweetness, a helpless sweetness, childlike and impotent in the world, and unbalanced by robust qualities other than voluptuousness. But in all Wagner and Grieg and Chopin there is nothing quite like it, with its queer romance. It is not by the territory of actual birth that a composers national allegiance should be established, but, above all, by the spirit of his creative imagination. Mr. Rosenfeld places Charles Martin Loeffler next to MacDowell as composer of America, and discourses upon merits and demerits of this unquestionably remarkable man. But Charles Martin Loeffler is the Anatole France of music not only by the outward traits of countenance. His music is not so easily accountable as Mr. Rosenfeld may make us believe. Its elusiveness, an eclectic style with a strong observant mind in constant attendance, its half-said words and half-sung melodies, all this is tantalizing and deceptive of simplicity. Loeffler remains aloof, and detached from the body of American music, because America is not yet made ready for his beatifical poise. Mr. Rosenfeld has little interest for the workers of the soil. Yet, it is among those pioneers that the source of American music will be found. To him the late Henry F.Gilbert is a musical folklorist, and not the creator of an American idiom, savored with Indian and Negro rhythms, but as intensely national, as Whitman’s verses. Mr. Rosenfeld mentions Kelley’s “New England Symphony,” but has very little to say about Arthur Foote, Chadwick, or Frederick Converse. Such an enlightened composer as Edward Burlingame Hill should have had a more prominent place in Mr. Rosenfeld’s window display. The entire New England group, possibly the nucleus of American national music is strangely overlooked by the author. Yet Horatio Parker gets a few pages, but what is there of America in Horatio Parker? Surely, Mr. Rosenfeld is not pragmatic in his survey of American music, yet his judgment never fails him when he comes across a falsified product. The success of Deems Taylor’s opera “The Kings Henchman” did not blind him against the obvious insignificance of the whole affair. Certainly, this is not an “American” opera, and Mr. Rosenfeld is a thousand times right in accusing the composer of “a thorough uninventiveness.” But one expects a mention of Cadman’s “Shanewis,” Converses “Sacrifice,” and, above all, the only American grand opera, “The Last of the Mohicans” by Paul Allen, one of the few American composers thoroughly equipped with a European technique. In Paul Allen’s “Pilgrim Symphony,” awarded the Paderewski prize in 1910, the student of American music will find the fundamental traits of that synthetic American
The patient, the doctors, the verdicts [American music] 1/29/29
37
style—neither Indian, nor Negro—which is forming itself at the hands of Americans whose strong feeling of national kinship is accompanied by perfect craftsmanship. But Mr. Rosenfeld’s pet is modern music, and to the moderns of this nation he lustfully turns, skipping over decades of less spectacular development. Whether Edgar Varese should be rightly considered an American composer is a moot question. Or, rather, it is not a question at all; a few years of interrupted residence do not constitute a claim to nativity. On the other hand, it would be unfair to annex a ready product, such as Varese’s brilliant works, to the body of American music. Ernest Bloch has written an American epic; it is of special interest as the reaction of a genius to his novel surroundings. But America cannot claim Ernest Bloch any more than it can claim Lafayette. Edgar Varese’s “Ameriques,” whatever worth it may possess musically, is an onlooker’s impression, or, rather the musical expression of the state of bewilderment generated by the immensity of America. George Gershwin, or Aaron Copland, wouldn’t bother to do the like; they were born in the midst of the alleged noise of America and to them it is no news. True, John Alden Carpenter has succumbed to the architectural charm of skyscrapers; but his ballet is not a photograph of noises, but a series of rhythmical dances, characteristic of modern America. George Antheil is obstreperous and arrogant; but his noise is not of this country either—rather it goes back to the pre-war experiments of Marinetti and his group of short-sighted futurists. (How cruelly has the Future deceived them!) The only deserving investigator of noises and sounds in America (if Varese is to be disqualified as non-American) is Henry Cowell of “tone-clusters” fame. Someone has remarked that Cowell’s compositions ought to be patented rather than copyrighted. But innovation in music is as honorable as research in other branches of arts and sciences, and Cowell in his “laboratory” in Menlo Park, as Varese in Paris, is doing useful work. Mr. Rosenfeld has no use for Gershwin; he pushes him away to “where he belongs”; that is in the lighter class of music. “The Rhapsody in Blue,” the “American in Paris,” the Concerto in F all seem to him utterances of an unaccomplished musician. It is getting more and more difficult to deny Gershwin’s significance, jazz or not. Mr. Rosenfeld will soon find himself a lone objector. Aaron Copland is one of the most interesting figures in American music. He has all the sophistication that Nadia Boulanger and the Conservatory of Fontainebleau may impart. At the same time he is of the soil, or of the street if you will. At any rate, he is that American composer with European technique who, according to the Prophets, must bring solution to the problem of American music. The reason why Mr. Rosenfeld finds Aaron Copland immature in his style is extremely difficult to compass. Of all things, immaturity is certainly not to be detected in Copland’s compositions, even of the earliest date. On the contrary he seems to have been born with a mature mind. Not even the usual influences—Scriabin, Ernest Bloch—are easily traced in his beginnings. If Stravinsky has come at all across his path, then it has happened after the Music for the Theater and the Jazz Concerto revealed to us his unmistakable self. But Rosenfeld writes entertainingly and brilliantly on Copland, and, with the exception of his dissenting opinion as to Copland’s immaturity, he makes an interesting study of the man. In contrast with Copland, Roger Sessions, his closest associate, has gone through all the preliminary stages: Ernest Bloch, whose pupil he was, and Stravinsky, under whose sway he fell in due time. Mr. Rosenfeld gives an excellent description of Sessions’s
Nicolas slonimsky
38
Symphony. “It is rounder, more inevitable and texturally more continuous than any other symphony written by an American. In giving Sessions his place in the advance of American music, it suggests the course a development of his powers might take. Sufficiently fortunate it could scarcely fail of producing an American Brahms.” The other names listed in Mr. Rosenfeld’s survey are Leo Ornstein, the Russian-born musician of grandiose flights of fancy; Dane Rudhyar, the peripatetic mystic with more philosophy than music at his disposal; Adolph Weiss, the faithful disciple of Schoenberg; Carl Ruggles, the sturdy builder; Ruth Crawford, a Chicago lass; Charles Ives, a musicengineer; Virgil Thomson, an impressive phenomenon; Roy Harris, an Oklahoma find; and Carlos Chavez, the Mexican of strangely logical design, whose import Mr. Rosenfeld sees through a magnifying glass, devoting to him an entire chapter. This list of names curiously coincides with that of composers whose works have been published in the eight issues of Henry Cowell’s modernistic quarterly New Music. Even the order of their appearance is nearly identical in Mr. Rosenfeld’s book and in Mr. Cowell’s publications. Otherwise, how shall we account for Mr. Rosenfeld’s giving so much consideration to Dane Rudhyar, who certainly cannot be very well bracketed with Charles Martin Loeffler, as Mr. Rosenfeld does. True, both of them are of Mid-European extraction, but a sense of proportion (which is obviously not Mr. Rosenfeld’s greatest virtue) should preclude such a juxtaposition. But after all, Mr. Rosenfeld does not aim at historical impartiality. He is a militant individual mind, a very interesting mind, and certainly possesses more discernment and more imagination than dozens of people entertaining traditional views. Any art is good but dull. Rosenfeld’s is stirring.
COMPOSER, CONDUCTOR, COSMOPOLITE February 23, 1929 Eugène Goossens, His Accomplishments, Ideals and Musical Background
The British Isles, until very recently, lay musically barren. The once brilliant epoch of Purcell and the madrigalists left no successors. In the eighteenth century Great Britain was importing illustrious Germans to make music at their befogged home. In Queen Victoria’s glorious days Sir Arthur Sullivan went to Germany in quest of musical inspiration. He failed conspicuously; the by-product of his labors—the comic opera— only survived. And then, not urged and unexpected, sprung the youngest generation of English composers—and without much ado, often in the spirit of jollification, registered their names in the history of musical art. Among the Englishmen who make the music of the present day, Eugène Goossens is an inspiring figure. He is an interpreter as well as creator; as orchestral conductor he breaks the exclusiveness that surrounds a composer. He finds himself a member of the living musical world; he faces audiences, and audiences respond to him. He carries music to them—music of all times, with his contribution as a self-portrait. When, in Hollywood, he conducts a performance in the open air and makes the ten thousand of the arena listen with understanding to Stravinsky’s Rite of Spring, he enjoys the privilege that few, if any, composers ever have had; and, when to the public that admires him as an inspiring dispenser of symphonic delights he offers his own music, he lastingly establishes himself in the musical brains as well as in the musical hearts—for if success on the concert platform may be disputed, creative achievement, palpably demonstrated, seals tight the doubting lips. By a curious coincidence, Eugène Goossens is not of English blood. His family is of Flemish-Belgian extraction. Goossens spells his first name with an “accent grave” and speaks French with the fluency of a bilingual person. His father, Eugène Goossens, Sr., was named after the grandfather; all three Eugènes of three generations devoted their lives to music, but only Eugène, Jr., disclosed creative gifts. Eugène, the grandfather, was responsible for the first English performance of “Tannhauser.” He also was one of the first conductors of the Carl Rosa Company. His grandson, in due time, came to conduct several performances in the same opera house! The musical streak in the Goossens family was strong enough to bestow a unique blessing on a brother of Eugène, the astounding oboeplayer, Léon Goossens. Eugène Goossens was not a typical child-prodigy. There was little in him that unconsciously moved him towards music as an intangible toy. Rather, understanding came with the early realization of his strange powers. He played violin proficiently and
Nicolas slonimsky
40
piano as a matter of course, thereby strengthening George Bernard Shaw’s belief that the day will come when children will congenitally acquire the ability of playing on a musical instrument. He reduced his apprentice years in compositions to faint reflections of Debussy and still fainter—of Skriabin. Then, not yet twenty, he began to write in a style which cannot be described but as peculiarly his own. Simultaneously, he turned conductor, having had previous orchestral experiences in Sir Henry Wood’s orchestra. At first his conductorial appearances were casual and depended exclusively on the magnificent defections of Sir Thomas Beecham with whom he then was associated. Thus he did some of the strangest barnstorming in the life of any musician. In 1921, he founded his own orchestra, which received an instantaneous recognition. Opera for all sorts of instrumental combinations, piano pieces, songs, orchestral short works and even folk-song arrangements were meanwhile dashed off with a facility that was viewed with alarm by many a sympathetic observer, oblivious perhaps of the similar facility of Mendelssohn’s and Mozart’s youthful days. At twenty-six he had already established himself as a versatile musician, conductor and composer. Edwin Evans, his friendly critic and author of the texts (in blank verse) that served for some of Goossens’s finest inspirations (characteristically, for both Evans and Goossens, French verse among them), in his series of monographs in the Musical Times had already—in 1919—a complicated subject before him in the person of the twenty-six-year-old composer. His review, in many points, is not obsolete in 1929. For the path of imaginative evolution chosen by Goossens does not bring startling reversions and apostasies, typical for such turbulent geniuses as Stravinsky. Goossens’s style can be traced by an analyst determined to connect him with the musical past of his country—to the early English composers of madrigals and voluntaries. There is in Goossens the static energy and harmonic tension characteristic of the dispassionate “cold fire” of his remote predecessors. Again, his apparent leaning towards the quaint verse of three centuries ago, the playful and sad ritornelles of which he is making delightful use in his songs, may establish a heredity. But more interesting it is to uncover the elements of his musical structure, to spot, perhaps, some of his favorite devices. The task is not easy. We may safely declare Goossens a “chromatic” composer: his voices ascend and descend languidly in semitones, or skyrocket violently in a bouquet of kaleidoscopic symmetries. But he will delude us with the plainest C major chords of his Quintet. We may point out the ingenious use of contrary motion in full chords running into each other but we will be immediately thwarted by the sight of the military rows of parallel intervals—fifths, fourths, sevenths—or clusters of chords, similarly arrayed; it is true that in the latter case an organ point usually establishes some fundamental unity. A liking for the diminished octave with its flavor of an unresolved suspension can be noted. But rhythmic formulas, so patent in some modern Parisians, defy codification in Goossens’s works. Moreover, slow movements are almost fifty-fifty in relation to the swift—a strange way for a modern composer. Negatively, it can be asserted that Goosens employs no polytonality as the thing is used by Milhaud, for instance. That is there is no stentorian obviousness of it, and all the passages that are suspected of polytonality can be, if tackled without malice aforethought, explained away as the result of the same elusive contrary-parallel motion of intervals or chords. Sometimes, a melody is shadowed by a fifth or by a string of parallel chords
Composer, conductor, cosmopolite [goossens] 2/23/29
41
(particularly six-four chords), but their very parallelism unites them beyond possible disintegration. Atonality is not a good guess either—the parentage with Schoenberg must be obviously fictitious. Edwin Evans experimented with the twelve-tone notation—when he transcribed into that musical mode some of Goossens’s pages, the intricacy of the music, due largely to the abundance of accidentals, disappeared—the thing became astonishingly clear. But then what of the tonal Goossens? In the works of a composer, like the Russian Obouhov, the twelve-degree notation (which he invented for his own and his fellowatonalists’ use) is eminently fitting. It seems quite idiotic to waste time and ink in marking accidentals in a score of a determined atonalist (and Obouhov is one of the most consistent, for he never allows himself a doubling, thus outlawing the very octave and unison), but when the tonal tissue, no matter how opalescent, appears now and then with a decided clearness, then legitimate doubts arise as to the fairness of the relegation of a composer to an otherwise perfectly respectable company but with which he professes no cordial entente. However, something positive can be said in regard to Goossens’s harmonies. They are advisedly the result of the meeting of several voices—in parallel or contrary motion. This is achieved by counterpoint—that is, each composing part conserves its individual meaning, receding and advancing according to the general plan and for better layout. But—and this is important—the individual voices always get somewhere, proceed in some direction, or await a turn to sustain balance. This rules out unrestrained impressionism—the tinkling variety, pursuing purely acoustic effects. It also draws Goossens nearer to the classical camp. His form is always clear, and exposition free of formalistic ballast. He often does away with the entire business of elaborate working out, and after having stated—but not restated—his subject with sufficient cogency, puts an end to it. His Sinfonietta in one movement is such a statement, emphasized by the resplendent orchestral coloring with the brass let loose in clashing chords. It is interesting to note, for contrast, that Milhaud’s “the worlds shortest” symphonies for small orchestra, contain each two or three movements. Goossens’s Rhythmic Dance written for the mechanic piano and later scored for orchestra is an example of an equally concise statement in rhythms. Goossens believes that music cannot be servant of another art, and shuns vast programmatic designs, but is highly sensible of humor in music. Occasionally, he would admit portraiture or imitation. In his “Teatime” there are five repeated octaves indicating the time of the afternoon. In the same song the street-organ intruding upon the amorous couple inside is suggestive and humorous. His Hurdy-Gurdy Man enjoys fame far beyond the boundaries of the modern musical world. The dissonances are blamed on the familiar defects of the organs pipes and are greatly relished as such. But for the “dissonances de la vie” of Edwin Evans’s verses Goossens underscribes a titillating discord not without the diminished octave. When, however, there is a menace of drowning the musical idea in a sea of local color, Goossens is adamant. He was commissioned to write some incidental music for a theater. In his score, “East of Suez,” he chooses to remain a musician rather than decorator, and adds a note: “No Chinese instruments are used in the orchestra, and the harmonic idiom of the incidental music is Western throughout.” Is Goossens as revolutionary as some would have him, or a neo-classicist as others would prefer to say? A variety of moods is reflected in his music. Like the modern that he is he would jollify in swelling rhythms and melodies, or convert an epigram into tones.
Nicolas slonimsky
42
But then, in the Phantasy Quartet he would write a poignant and lyric interlude, or sing “the dolefull’st ditty” with his bereaved Philomel. The romantic strain in Goossens is one of the happiest, musically speaking. His song of Melancholy, “the sweetest melancholy,” is one of the most penetrating ever written to express the mood of contemplative sadness. But has not every composer, worthy of the name, expressed in some degree, all human emotions that stir the soul? Humor, serenity and gayety have always been chief motives for musical inspiration. The moderns who do not exchange sincerity for artifice, will always draw upon this only source. But—and this certain people would not forgive—they will express these emotions in the idiom of their own times—and not in the beautiful but dead speech of the past.
BY INNOVATION SHALL HEARERS RECOGNIZE HIM March 9, 1929 Henry Cowell, Explorer Among Pianistic Possibilities Alights in Boston
When you go to a concert you anticipate a certain amount of pleasure to be administered in the usual fashion, through familiar mediums. You will register surprise and possibly discontent if the performer applies himself to a strange instrument or uses a queer method of attack. You are quite likely to retain such an artist in your visual memory when all aural recollections have faded into a blur. The same short circuit in association of ideas that suggests the nickname “Darwin” for a pet monkey is responsible for many an aberration in judgment of musical or literary personages. That is why notorious persons spend most of their leisure in repudiating all sorts of sticky legends or reiterating forgotten reasons for remembered actions. Among others Henry Cowell is a notorious victim. He is known, if at all, as the fellow who plays on the piano with his elbows and fists. This oddity is enough to strike one’s imagination and is too self-evident to need any further elucidation. The somewhat mannered expression “tone-clusters,” designating several keys sounded together, has remained, however. Charles Ives, who combines successful managing of an insurance company with composition of modern music, recommends a ruler for production of “tone-clusters”; Henry Cowell who has developed remarkable precision in placing the cluster within set limits prefers “natural” methods, but does not object to any other. Surprisingly enough, he lays stress not on the startling appearance but on the effect. As innovator, Henry Cowell directs his attention chiefly to the piano. Not only does he introduce novel technical devices on the keyboard, but he gets inside the instrument, under the open lid, on the sound board. There lie potential tones worth seeking. The naked strings can be swept in glissando, plucked with a plectrum, divided in halves with resulting overtones, tapped and struck variously. Also the lid itself can be used for percussion effects. Of course, such a piano ceases to be the instrument of immortals, and becomes something else, which Cowell chooses to call String and Percussion Piano. It is essentially a new instrument capable of producing new and peculiar timbres. It can be reverberant or subdued; the use of sympathetic vibrations lends tenuous sustained pianissimo. Mr. Salzedo has done something similar to the harp—he uses it both as a percussion and string instrument; he mutes it with a piece of paper and commits many other atrocities upon it. According to some, he violates the very spirit of that celestial instrument, and if anybody deserves Hell and Damnation for that, Salzedo does. But unfortunately for the deprecators, a musical instrument is not the one-sided appliance it seems. The violin in Debussy’s sonata travesties as mandolin, piccolo flute, trumpet and
Nicolas slonimsky
44
drum—and a player of genius must be able to find all these timbres within its case. The first musician who plucked the string of a violin or tapped it “collegno” must be held responsible for the appearance of Salzedo and Cowell. Henry Cowell was born in Menlo Park, California, and there he continues to make his home, between times visiting eastern States and Europe. He was “exceptional” and “precocious”, and as such was observed by Dr. Terman of Stanford University, who wrote an interesting account on Cowell’s early investigation into the causes and origins of things that children are supposed to take for granted. Thus, as a child, he had his doubts about the sacredness of consonant music, and began to write dissonances, unaware of a similar reaction among adults in Europe. In 1917, barely twenty, he outlined his book on “New Musical Resources”, which reveals an uncommon scientific spirit and stubborn logic. The desire for novelty has never been Cowell’s stimulus. He has been producing his unmarketable goods disinterestedly, for vindication of his ideas. Twenty of his piano pieces, a quartet with thundersticks and a few songs are available in print; some five hundred songs and piano-pieces remain in manuscript, with a symphony, piano concerto, choruses and other compositions of varying bulk. They usually bear impressionistic names, often borrowed from Irish mythology. Banshee, Leprechaun, wailing ghosts and groaning apparitions appeal to Henry Cowell. The String and Percussion Piano can emit a howl to make one’s flesh creep; moans and groans have never been reproduced more realistically. Again, the fairy cobbler’s shoes are beautifully mended on the lid of an open baby grand (with a darning egg as the requisite implement). Fairy Bells are all a-tinkling, played pizzicato, with the accompaniment of a chamber orchestra. Cowell’s Amiable Conversation looks appalling on paper, while “Antinomy” appears philosophical. Toneclusters are rampant, and produce a most powerful impression on a blindfolded person. A listener who is in the habit of watching the performers doings will be distracted by the sight of flying fists and applied forearms. Henry Cowell can also compose for the ten fingers. His six “ings” (which is the gerundive ending of floating, frisking, fleeting, scooting, wafting and seething) are quite playable and even effective in the most ordinary sense. In his “scherzo” he is almost Mendelssohn-like. By nature an eclectic, he rejects nothing and accepts anything provided that there can be found consistent exposition of an idea. The strength of Henry Cowell lies in his codification of musical means and aims. He is concerned with obvious deficiencies of the pres-ent system of notation, particularly insofar as rhythm and meter are concerned. For instance, why do we have half-notes and quarter-notes, but no third-notes, for which defection we must pay the penalty of an awkward tripleting. With the age of polyrhythm dawning upon us, we are getting into trouble with contrapuntally woven rhythmical designs. Henry Cowell has a stately system that would solve nearly all these difficulties; he creates divisions of all simple numbers, up to eleven, in diamond-shaped, triangular, or rectangular notes, according to the value of each. This system will be accepted when the polyrhythmists gain control of the musical world, for which eventuality it is too early to hope, or to fear. Of far more consequence is Cowell’s attempt to connect fundamental rhythms with ratios of vibration between two notes of an interval, consonant or dissonant. Here Cowell bases his theory on a physical fact and the implication of existence of dissonant rhythms is fascinating.
By innovation shall hearers recognize him [Cowell] 3/9/29 45
Henry Cowell has been exuberantly praised and senselessly rejected by various factions. We quote, “a titre documentaire,” an impression of a professor of a western university: His creations bring one at the strike of a tone-cluster into the very texture of our contemporary world whence one directly experiences the swift and immense dynamism of primal world-destroying and world-creating forces. From the softest murmurings of the piano we ascend with Henry Cowell, by virtue of his original means of tone-production, to planes of being where we recognize a strongly rhythmic cosmos sublimely shaping itself out of weltering chaos by a clash of energies that augments in tonal volume, pyramids its effects into overarching claps of thunder, till in this titanic struggle we behold a world-structure in motion, and quake within to live through the cosmic ordeal. A world structure in motion. Dynamic architectonics! The architecture of the universe breathed upon, stirred by creative impulse into life! What an achievement! The speculation of Democritus, Kant, Einstein, has fused with imagination of Lucretius, Goethe, Robinson Jeffers. Resting on purely musical grounds and leaving philosophy alone, we see in Henry Cowell an independent and intelligent force that is working for the purpose of enlarging and generalizing the chief postulates of musical science. And it is not our concern, with the aid of what unusual devices he produces his effects, as long as these effects are plausible. The oldest and anti-moderns may remember a remarkable gravure, now an unobtainable rarity, entitled “Music of the Future.” In addition to an orchestra of bedraggled and dazed musicians, with the calves of their legs all aquiver and eyes askew, there is seen in the background a set of cats with their tails pressed between two boards screwed together. The conductor is detached from the platform, as both his feet participate in time-beating. Dangling from his desk there are two scores bearing largelettered names of—not Henry Cowell, but—alas!—Richard Wagner and Franz Liszt.
BOUNCING INTO FORTUNE’S LAP AND OUT AGAIN March 14, 1929 The Years and The Courses Of Vladimir Dukelsky, Composer at Hand
Composers of modern music are a wandering race. Often they live and work outside their own country. Ernest Bloch embraced American faith; Varese found congenial surroundings in New York City; while George Antheil went to France “pour epater les bourgeois.” Stravinsky has not seen Russia since the days of “Petrushka.” Prokoffiev revisited the U.S.S.R. after his fame was firmly established in foreign lands. The youngest side of Russia is Vladimir Dukelsky, Russian who writes Russian music outrightful heir to Stravinsky and Prokoffiev in spirit and manner but as independent of either as any college boy blossoming forth into a grand career along the lines in which his parents, now growing respectable, had been prominent and successful. This week his Symphony in F will be heard at the Symphony Concerts. Dukelsky—writes Nicolas Slonimsky to The Transcript—belongs entirely to the twentieth century. He was born in 1903 with the movies and aviation, and grew at a quick pace. At eight he was already engaged in composition of a ballet in fourteen acts, having picked up elementary information about music anywhere he could. He also felt the disturbing flow of poetic feelings within him and indulged in poetry until the realization of his musical powers displaced the weaker gift. Both symbolism and classicism attracted him; he chose Maeterlinck for an “opera in three acts” and an arcadian story about Milovsor for an opera-pastorale. At the Conservatory in Kiev he received regular instruction; his examination-piece—a string sextet—was a surprising revelation of maturity at sixteen; with Dukelsky, in the class of Gliere, was Skriabin’s son, Julian, a boy of genius, who was drowned at the age of eleven. A few piano pieces and an unfinished orchestral score was his legacy and for years after the quality of the music stirred speculation. The civil war in Russia divided the country into separated fragments, with no definite boundaries. The overflow of population moved in general direction southwards, converging on Constantinople, where the various streams met. Dukelsky was caught in the tide, and emerged as Boy-Scout and member of the Y.M.C.A. in the Turkish capital, which at that time was in an occupation by the Allied forces. Dukelsky’s family spoke English, and he himself was a polyglot. American affiliations saved him from the bitterest ordeals of Russian émigrés. He did some piano-playing here and there; composed songs which passed unappreciated at the Y.M.C.A.’s Musicales; wrote a ballet for a Russian group of dancers appearing at one of the theaters. Constantinople in 1920 was a melting pot of all nationalities, fit only for temporary refuge. Steamers and
Bouncing into fortune's lap and out again [Dukelsky] 3/14/29
47
railroads were busy carrying Russians to France and Germany. Dukelsky waited for a bigger chance and one fine day, an American ship took him and his family to New York. He struggled valiantly for a place in the unorganized musical colony. An Overture from his pen was played at Carnegie Hall and dismissed as a piece of risible pretence. In 1923 Dukelsky completed his Piano Concerto in C Major. It marks his beginnings as composer of power and imagination. There could be no mistake: it sufficed to hear the first two measures—a simple excursion from C major to G-sharp minor and back—to invest in the composers future. As it stands now, it is one of the best modern Concertos— for the piano, not for a dissembling harpsichord or illusory percussion instrument. The quality of the music is such as may be expected from a composer of genius unaware of his abilities and his inspiration, free of influences, repressions or inhibitions. Not a false stroke or affected emphasis from one end to the other, and a display of brilliance in the coda that would dazzle even those brought up on Lisztian sonorities. The secret lies in the simplicity of design and resulting concentration and condensation of effect. The Concerto, willingly proffered by the composer at private parties in arrangement for two pianos, aroused a few inchoate societies of modern music but the tempo of events was obviously slow, with no prospect of a vigorous accelerando. After many discussions, doubts and fears, Dukelsky sailed for Paris, there to start it all over again as others had started. He was well furnished with introductory letters to Parisian magnificoes of the baton and the press. But, almost Lindbergh-like, he did not have to use these testimonials to his worth. He met Diaghilev, played the Concerto for him, was instantly “discovered,” and commissioned to write a ballet. The theme was Zephyr and other winds improbably falling in love with Flora, with intermezzi, interludes and various episodes. Dukelsky wrote it in Monte Carlo, in the basement of the Casino, and Diaghilev’s troupe gave it to the world. From the beginning, the reception was favorable. Dukelsky was “bruited about”; Diaghilev hailed him as his third find—after Stravinsky and Prokoffiev; the papers buzzed; Poulenc and Auric wrote articles about Dukelsky’s opinions on jazz, and his picture was reproduced in musical journals. At the first night in Paris the orchestra played atrociously, but the composer was cordially greeted and, clad in immaculate black and white, bowed from the stage. Then came London and, with changing fortunes, other cities with a few depressing lulls between. Dukelsky was flying back and forth, from Paris to Venice, from Monte Carlo to London, overcoming the barriers that are set for Russian citizens traveling in Europe. He was a picturesque and engaging figure in those days, almost mid-Victorian in the magnificence of his deportment and the resplendence of his attire. Fortunately, his versatility spared him pecuniary embarrassments. He contributed, as Mr. Duke, a few jazz-numbers to a London review, and the royalties therefrom kept him going comfortably for a length of time. He wrote, in 1925, three songs to eighteenth-century Russian texts, charming and simple musical treatment of the subject. Stravinsky was fond of the songs; and seekers for sensation may discover in “Apollo,” which was written two years later, a passage well-nigh identical with the introductory measures of one of Dukelsky’s melodies…. But—has not Stravinsky written a ballet entirely based upon Chaikovsky’s tunes? The Concerto was meanwhile forgotten. It had been published in version for two pianos; the composer had spoken to several pianists of eminence about a possible performance; all were interested, but the necessary orchestration was not forthcoming.
Nicolas slonimsky
48
True to the care-free spirit of one who feels the gods at his call, Dukelsky on several occasions missed appointments for which struggling musicians would strive for months. Next, the realization that music inferior to his is performed and enjoyed would throw him into fits of activity, interrupted by a sudden and urgent departure for another point of destination with futile telegrams following in the wake…. Does Dukelsky imitate Stravinsky? This question is the first in the modern catechism. According to Dukelsky himself, he follows Glinka and Dargomijsky, his musical grandfathers, so to say. Inasmuch as Stravinsky harked back in “Maura” to Glinka’s methods (with displacement of harmonies by one-half wave-length, which often pitches the tonic against the dominant) Dukelsky would be imitating Stravinsky imitating Glinka. But there is no trace of Stravinsky’s syllogistic frigidity in Dukelsky’s bright and pastoral style. If Stravinsky is Torquemada, then Dukelsky is a dealer in indulgences, of which he makes ample use himself. His Concerto is a delectable sin, with unashamed cantilena alternating with darts of rhythmic virulence. Question number two: Does Dukelsky revert to Bach or to Handel in some other non-Stravinskian way? Still easier is it to answer in the negative. The next question would touch a composers attitude towards folk-tunes or quasi-folk-tunes. Yes, Dukelsky cultivates them in his songs, and, less obviously, in his ballet. Sophisticated songfulness—the Concerto always excepted—tempts him, and he resorts to it in moderation. It is as difficult for a composer nowadays not to roll down into a numbered hole, as it is to walk on a narrow plank without leaning on the rails. But those unaware of the narrowness of the path are said to walk unperturbed, like Charlie Chaplin, in the “The Circus,” rope-walking and gamboling in the air, not realizing that his support has gone. Dukelsky started gorgeously, and betrays so far no sign of weakness. Why not grant him that high order of distinction—originality? So much, biographically, from Mr. Slonimsky.
OUR JAZZING, THEIR JAZZING, REASONS WHY April 20, 1929 Merits of the European Kind At Last Acknowledged And Recited
When a European composer adopts the idiom of jazz, he deserves pity. Eumenides, as well as less mythological hounds in the form of music critics are sure to be on his trail. He is also an easy prey, for in his admiration for the exotic delight he is bound to lose his sense of balance and overdo things. Americans who hold the secret of jazz-making are even less tolerant of their European followers than the Europeans themselves in judging American art and American tastes. Few fair-minded Americans would consciously recall that jazz-rhythms were first born among negroes, and that the jazz band, fascinating because of its incongruity, was scattered all over the terrestrial globe before having been assembled at some preVolstead bar on the Pacific Coast…. The banjo came from Central Africa (origin disputed), the ukulele came from the Sandwich Islands, or, according to Joan Lowell, was introduced there by a Harvard student. The saxophone was invented in 1842 in Europe; the sliding trombone is by no means a new device; in the realm of percussion only the drum, electrically illuminated from inside constitutes an unquestioned innovation, with the derby hats for mutes imparting an air of informal joviality, essential to the new art. However, the fact remains that jazz has become thoroughly and almost exclusively an American product; all attempts to grasp its spirit by outsiders have heretofore failed notoriously and irretrievably. The curse of the creative jazz-worshipers lies precisely in their religious attitude toward it. Just as a St. John Ervine is “no good” at the American slang or even colloquial American, in spite, or because, of his close adherence to the best rules of the vernacular, in the same way a European composer is laughable because he takes the thing so seriously. American jazz has inundated European music-halls; it is curious to note that a colored player is paid twice or thrice the amount of a white American who may be as good or even better: so strong is the desire to present a guaranteed genuine article. But European masses—the famous man in the street—remain utterly unaffected by the universal syncopation. The song of the year 1924 in Paris was “Titine,” with the melody as contemptible as any of the tunes current fifty years ago, and with the “lyrics” that meant precisely nothing. However, it was such a rage that even General Nobile on the way to Polar regions did not escape it, and, caught by the ear, bestowed the name on his pet terrier, subsequently saved by Captain Lundborg at latitudes inaccessible to popular hits…. About at the same time, with the jazz invasion at its peak, Paris produced a melancholy ditty about “mon village” which was a quieter place years ago than the
Nicolas slonimsky
50
present day “Paname,” as Paris has come to be surnamed. The song deplored modern traffic and modern bustle. Jazz was not as much as mentioned in the complaint. Musical comedies of Paris and Berlin are as impervious to American influences. To look over the files of annual successes in Paris: “Ta Bouche,” “Sur la Bouche”—the entire gamut of osculatory exercises, one should think nothing has intervened in European light music since the days of Offenbach. Jean Cocteau, upon hearing the first jazz band play, delivered a winged aphorism: “It is a catastrophe subdued and put to work.” Here we come to the very root of the European jazz problem. Jazz in Europe remains an imported fad, delightful, teasing and irresistible, but hopelessly foreign, a wild orange cultivated con amore in a hot-house. In the process of domestication, Jazz adapts itself to European tastes—and instantly ceases to be jazz. In a new incarnation it may prosper, however. Historically, the Spanish language is a corruption of the Latin; but as surely it is beautiful in its corruption. European jazz is a miss by miles; but—given time—why should it not evolve into an art? The objection is soon to arise that it is hardly credible for a stark imitation article to ever become a genuine product. But the question is not one of genuineness but that of survival under different skies. At any rate, Americans holding the first mortgage on jazz from negro slaves should be more indulgent to second borrowers. Chop Suey is an American dish, not to be found in China (so the Chinese assert), and Charlotte Russe has nothing Russian in it; by virtue of the same paradox, European jazz is, or will be, a concoction recognizably but not identically equal to the American brand. But where are to be found those samples of European jazz that justify the belief that it will ever emancipate itself? As it has been said above, the populace in Europe is unconcerned. It is serious composers, great and small, that are intensely interested in jazz. To understand it psychologically, one must look back at the Europe of the war and armistice days. The old artistic world was crumbling before the onrush of elemental forces armed with modern means of destruction. Somehow it became impossible or even blasphemous to indulge any longer in ethereal longings after an unutterable ideal, to clothe these ideals in intangible veils, to unfold these veils with languid fingers. Opiates cease to function when a hard blow is dealt on the nervous centers. An impulse to activity, if even wasteful activity, led to mass production of dancing music. Past were the days when Maeterlinck and Debussy yearned to tell “something to somebody.” The postwar generation began using plain language enjoying the shock they thus administered to their elders. But then the elders themselves set to thinking and to revising, and one after another, embraced the new spirit of the faster rotating world. Of the dancing, the strongest “kick” was supplied by negro jazz-players who descended upon Paris in the very first days after the armistice. They belonged to the Music-Hall and never claimed a higher station. In the emasculated City of Light they found more. The success of the exotic and animal race among white women in Paris is a historical fact, recorded as such in Krenek’s “Jonny spielt auf.” The Metropolitan production of that opera shied at something that is not even considered secret or reprehensible. In our time of relative enlightenment, the administration of the Metropolitan would have run no risk in presenting Jonny in full splendor of his racial color without recurring to the black-face travesty. Twenty years ago Debussy wrote Golliwog’s cake-walk in the rag-time form. Eric Satie had included a “rag-time” in his “Parade.” Stravinsky, listening to the last cannon-
Our jazzing, their jazzing, reasons why 4/20/29
51
shots of the war in his retreat in a Swiss border village, was moved to compose a “rag.” This was not jazz—not yet. The “blue” note of the third that was to destroy the partition between major and minor had not yet sounded to European ears. Nor had the seventh been flatted. According to the science and theory of jazz, as variously promulgated by Paul Whiteman, Aaron Copland and Dr. Isaac Goldberg, jazz is harmony, rhythm, counterpoint and color. Paul Whiteman gives a psychological explanation of the “sad gayety” of jazz, Copland is interested in its “polyrhythms,” Dr. Goldberg proceeds (in his excellent “blue” book) analytically. These men are all Americans, regardless of race and color, and judge the product of their country, from their domestic point of view, with competence and sagacity. A more generalized theory might be offered, regarding jazz as a product of a certain “displacement” of all musical elements as enumerated in Dr. Goldberg’s essay. If the word “lyrics” is taken into consideration, the picture of total “displacement” becomes all the more clear. Along these lines, jazz must be observed in the making, not as rigidly recorded on the music sheet. Most composers of jazz-music know little about written music anyway, and it is essential to an outsider to understand that. Gramophone records are in this respect an invaluable asset. Listen to Helen Kane in her song hits, “I Want to Be Bad,” for example. Jazz is in her blood, closely connected with the American language and accent, and the printed sheet serves her only for an outline. Dance or dancing motion, “shaking shoulders and twisting hips” is as inseparable from the whole. In other words we find ourselves confronted with a primitive coalescence of all arts. “Breaks” have lately been written out in Whiteman’s orchestra, but improvisation still remains an essential element of good jazz. The situation is very similar to the time of figured bass and improvised cadenzas, which were meant to be filled in. The nineteenth century respect for details has obliterated this practice. It is worthy of consideration that the twentieth century has come to revive it. In its chase after the elusive Blue Bird of jazz—European composers have underestimated this part of the game—improvisation. The blue bird has lost her gorgeous hues in the daylight of their examination, and no vivisection could reveal the secret of examination, secret of her vicious vitality. A “displacement” of harmonic contours may easily produce an effect of polytonality or atonality. The abundance of grace notes, in jazzed accompaniments is the first inning of this harmonic instability. Any jazz tune can actually be accompanied in an off key without causing the least difficulty to a native singer. Here a European ear trained to polytonal and atonal effects finds something familiar. The tendency to transfer the beat to an unaccented note produces the effect, known to a European as syncopation. It is quite understandable, but as unattainable to an outsider as the quality of the vowel “a” in the word “bad”, uttered by Helen Kane…. European jazz, the jazz of the printed sheet, is perforce stationary. At the best, a foreigner can learn argot, but he will never be able to enrich it with new words, having no living source to draw upon. But the new material thus absorbed may influence the further development of European music, eventually emerging in a shape conditioned by the peculiar European environment. We can note certain peculiarities of European jazz upon a brief survey. European jazz is humorous, it is often an intended caricature, it is always mischievous. As it should be, we may add, for, having no roots in the soil, it must be mannered. European jazz is lavishly incrustated with counterpoint, usually atonal, rarely polytonal. And so it should
Nicolas slonimsky
52
be, for atonality is European for “blues.” European jazz is mildly insinuating, but always polite. Small wonder, for insinuation rather than plain talk is the European way. European jazz is expertly orchestrated. It was to be expected, for Europeans excel in musical salads and macedoines. The blend is always perfect whatever the ingredients may be. European jazz conceals a unifying rhythmical figure behind it, deviations are expressly pointed out, to be complemented by a counter design. Well it may be, for the sense of balance in European music governs the intangible itself. Every European composer in adapting Afro-American rhythms is following a course conditioned by his former practice. Debussy had a genius of sophisticated simplicity; no one, not even Musorgsky himself could talk to children more understandingly. In “Golliwog’s Cakewalk” he opens the door ajar to the music hall. Cakewalk in those days was just as naughty as “twisting hips” is today, and rag rhythms were just as destructive for the spirit of Doctor Gradus ad Parnassum as “I’m Always Chasing Rainbows” is destructive for Chopin’s Fantaisie-Impromptu therein mutilated. Debussy serves this cake-walk with a twinkle in his eye, as a half-forbidden fruit, but sugars it with familiar and exquisite harmonies. Children are flattered or supposed to be flattered at the glimpse of adult life, and then forward the piece to the humorously inclined grown-ups. Not so Satie who wrote designedly for Dorian Grays with baby faces and a log of sins (musically speaking) in a secret chamber. For Satie simplicity is an affectation and an escape. In Cocteau’s “Parade” everything is listless dalliance; taking the cue, Satie indulges in a delicious “rag-time of a packet boat,” with a sustained diatonic line of melody laid against a simple rhythmical design in the manner of early fox-trots. Stravinsky had nothing to learn about syncopation. As early as 1912, in Petrouchka, he used syncopated chords, dangling in the air so to speak, without the slightest support on the accented beat. In a ballet such procedure was uncommon; more of it came in the “Sacre du Printemps”; in “Les Noces” there are characteristic passages with some rough syncopated pile-driving; the one, for instance, where a guest at the wedding speculates in a bass voice about the potential market value of the bride. But this is all pure Stravinsky, and there is not a vestige of jazz. Only in the “rag-time” Stravinsky pretended to embrace the new idiom—and failed gloriously. One finds in this piece a clearly stated rag theme, but the subsequent development takes away all that there was of the “rag,” leaving unmistakably Stravinskian leads and heavy basses, visible to the naked eye and audible to the ear, unadorned with the familiar trumpet. It is all the more puzzling that condemnatory criticism should find clever imitation in this piece which precisely failed in this respect, if imitation was at all intended by the composer. Stravinsky has remained insensible to jazz, and with him that group of young musicians who in spite of their gifts are unable to struggle out of his influence. Prokofiev is even less concerned with jazz; and the youngest of the expatriated Russian composers, Vladimir Dukelsky indulges in it only when he has to eke out his budget by writing for music-halls. Jean Wiéner approached the jazz problem from yet another angle. He took it business like, and at his concerts introduced the black stepchildren of music. He himself wrote several compositions giving a European version of jazz. His “Concerto FrancoAmericain” is particularly interesting. Its important feature consists in the introduction of typically European compound measures of five or seven beats. These rhythms too often appear to be a cerebral product rather than that of inventive imagination. Stravinsky
Our jazzing, their jazzing, reasons why 4/20/29
53
inaugurated the fashion, but even he amended the rhythmical intricacies of the “Sacre” with a simplified version for practical performances. Wiéner’s Concerto is obviously an exercise in a novel manner. Yet, naive as it may be, the use of compound measures may yet prove to be a distinctive feature of European jazz. Why not a fox-trot in five-four time? With all its rhythmic versatility American jazz holds on firmly to simple meters. As Aaron Copland has indicated, jazz is rich in polyrhythms; in fact, the very syncopation is the result of counterrhythms, three against four. Jazz is, then, so far as rhythm is concerned, an interplay of simple measures of different length. No compound rhythm is present in either of the two parallel lines, and here is something for European jazz to excel in, for these rhythms have long been incorporated into European music. Ravel became interested in that element of jazz which is characteristic of “blues”—the instability of major and minor, the sliding effects. To this he dedicated the second movement of his Violin Sonata, and adduced the name “blues” to it. Ravel’s reaction to jazz is highly instructive to study. He is sparing of effects, but almost never misses fire when he concentrates his efforts on a certain point. In the Violin Sonata he maintains a pedal on the tonic, dominant and the third, and lets the violin perform rhythmical fragments and slides in an unrelated key. The piano gives short rhythmical cadenzas that serve also as a transition from one period to another. Ravel never writes obeying an impulse or following a popular fad. His entry in the field of jazz is significant. Darius Milhaud heard real jazz in America during his first visit here in 1924 and was greatly impressed. In his articles on jazz he particularly notes the band of the Hotel Brunswick, Boston. These bands, playing at hotels not for expectant snobs, but for enjoyment of guests absorb Milhaud’s interest. He proceeds forthwith to transplant this nonchalant jazz into Europe, and puts it even into “Creation du Monde,” challenging Fundamentalists and Darwinists alike. Arthur Honegger is concerned more with American locomotives than American jazz, but as early as 1924, five years before his visit hereabouts, he wrote a few splendid pages of jazz in his Concertino. Alexandre Tansman paid a charming compliment to this country when he regaled American audiences with a portion of jazz in his latest piano Concerto. Again, his pretence was not to beat Americans in their own game (which certain short-sighted persons may have resented) but to say “hello” in the language of the people. It would be interesting to catch his or other composers’ accent, for since “hello” has become a coin of universal currency, it also has undergone changes characteristic of the persons using it, and may eventually transform itself into a new entity, as related to the original edition, as Roman languages are related to the classical Latin. Another interesting example of European jazz is furnished by the fox trot composed in 1924 by a Swiss, Frank Martin, for Julia Sazonova’s Marionette Theater in Paris. Here is a piece written in the idiom without quotation marks. But it is not any more American for that, and fortunately so. Frank Martin uses the devices of an American jazz band— syncopation, free counterpoint, chromatic meandering around harmonic mainstays, and creates a piece which is original and musically interesting. Scored, it contains no saxophone and no percussion thus silencing all charges of imitation. It is almost austere in its minimization and at the same time valuable as an example of early jazz in Europe. Hindemith included a rag-time in his “Suite 1922” for piano. He admonishes the player to forget all about conservatory methods and get as much sound and fury out of the piece as it is conveniently possible. His piece is a perpetuum mobile with stumbling
Nicolas slonimsky
54
blocks placed at the end of each run. No jazz to speak of. Rather more interesting rhythmically is the famous duet of the piccolo and the double bass in his Concerto for Orchestra. It is a genuine piece of unintentional jazz. Shostakovich, the new composer from Russia, has thought up a novel scheme. He utilizes jazz-themes (in the case of his recent Symphony it is Youmans’s “Tea for Two”) as folk-lore and submits it to symphonic treatment. Why not? Has not Stravinsky in Petrouchka used Italian airs and other itinerant melodies that swept Russia in the beginning of the century for a purely Russian epic? Curious are the ways of musical traffic. The jazz-makers aspiring for a better world, pick up classical repertory (from the lowest shelf) and smear Dvorak’s Humoresque or Rimsky-Korsakov’s song with their unctuous m-ta, m-ta rhythms, whereas Europeans look at the meanest examples of Irving Berlin’s composite tunes with an air of studious curiosity. Alfredo Casella has orchestrated Berlin’s “Russian Lullaby” and almost made music out of it. But is the original worth Casella’s while? The lilt of this “Russian Lullaby” is that of an American waltz, “Autumn’s Dream” by Joyce. It was ground on all street organs in Russia from 1900 until 1915. As a boy, Irving Berlin must have heard it in his native village, and remembered it in the new country. American jazz has completed a full circle. European jazz held its first victory—disputed as it may be—when Ernst Krenek brought out his jazz opera. “Jonny spielt auf” was written in the summer 1926, and produced in sixty different cities of Europe during the following year. New York had to humiliate itself and go to a Bohemian composer in quest of a real modern opera. An opera with engines, railroad stations, taxi-cabs, radio and telephones! American jazz via Europe! You might as well import spaghetti to Italy. It came back considerably whisked up, but clearly recognizable. Even the polyrhythms were present, giving an excellent rapid waltz time within regular four-four measures. Little consolation, for in Krenek’s score jazz has become “yachtset,” as Germans pronounce it. Poor Jonny was condemned on the ground of gross exaggeration and false pretence. No plea of ignorance or foreign influence was taken into consideration. It will take a considerable cooling down until the moment arrives when the American public will take “Jonny” as he is—an expatriate speaking with an accent, but still of the good old stock of American syncopators. He is also naive, as the manager of the heroine is when he raves about the great fortune that awaits him in America and the imminent success of his artist. Europeans will always think that an “American contract” is the golden road to glory. Only a trans-Atlantic journey with the subsequent revelation that America is not an easy nut to crack, will cure Europeans of this mirage of idle and yielding American wealth. And what hundred-percenter, what jingo can pay a more touching tribute to God’s country than the concluding hymn of Krenek’s opera? Here it is in extenso: The hour has struck for Old Time to go. The new Time is dawning. Do not miss the moment! The journey to the unknown land of liberty has begun! Thus, Jonny strikes up the band for our dancing! The New World comes across the sea in radiance and inherits ancient Europe by means of the dance!
Our jazzing, their jazzing, reasons why 4/20/29
55
(From a lecture, with music, on European jazz and Krenek’s “Jonny” delivered at the Boston Public Library on Sunday, April 14.)
MODERNIST SPRUNG FROM THE ANCIENTS May 28, 1929 Casella as The Concert of His Chamber Pieces Will Reveal Him E pur si muove!
Modern music it is asserted by some, is the music of modern noise. If it lapses into serenity or—horribile dictu!—romanticism, it ceases to be modern. Shortsighted friends and vaticinating enemies of modern music, both make the tacit admission that the path of music leads towards an inextricable thicket, which by some miracle is bound to appear simple to modern minds accustomed to the rebuses of modern life. Not long ago one of the solicitous sympathizers complained about the situation in a magazine devoted to modern music. In his view, the very raison d’être of modern music seemed to be lost at the pitiful sight of the modern Samson getting a hair cut. Even the redoubtable Varèse, who used to get his inspiration from the din of buildings in construction, is now preparing a “simplified edition” of his “Amériques,” to the extent of sacrificing the “crow-call” and the steamship-whistle, so tantalizingly featured in the first edition of the score. If this “retreat” is a resignation, then the superannuated gentlemen of the enemy camp are right to sound a recessional. If modern music is the music of noise, then it will pass away unregretted. Fortunately for true modernists, the assumption is wrong. Confusion exists only in the minds of detractors, while modern builders remain quite unperturbed— even Stravinsky, the mystery man of modern music. Alfredo Casella is one of the few moderns not in the least distracted by the seeming dissolution of the materia musica. His musical pedigree is so sound that his art appears a resultant of the entire evolution of music. Indeed, in his remarkable treatise on musical cadences, he traces a direct line from the crude chorales of the thirteenth century to the elaborate conclusions of his own period. Only Schönberg and his disciples remain outside—perhaps for the sin of destroying the musical mode. Casella himself has never been attracted by atonality; in all his numerous works he remains true to the ideal of definite modality. Within these limits he may be aggressively polytonal, as in “Pages of War,” or descriptive and national as in the well-known “Italia.” But the fundamental plan is always clear, and the intellect behind is at all times present in his scores. That is why they make excellent “augen musik” (by no means a disparaging term) for study. At the same time, Casella’s mastery in handling instruments achieves the maximum of effect with the minimum of means. Goethe’s saying that law is liberty and limitation is enrichment is fully applicable to Casella compositions.
Modernist sprung from the ancients [Casella] 5/28/29]
57
In this respect the new Serenato for Clarinet, Bassoon, Trumpet, Violin and Violoncello—to be played at his concert in Brown Hall tomorrow—is particularly interesting. The number of instruments was not to exceed six, according to the terms of the competition for which it was written and in which Casella shared the first prize with Bartók. Casella takes five, in unusual combination; in the Gavotte renounces the two string instruments and gives a demonstration of technical skill in writing an exquisite trio for wind-instruments. In the Cavatina he employs only the violin and the ’cello, in fourpart writing, in double-stops. The concluding chord of the Cavatina is ingeniously written for the ’cello soaring high in double harmonics, with the low C string plucked pizzicato by the only unoccupied finger; while the violin furnishes the middle harmony in the lowest register of the instrument. This inversion of registers is used by Casella in various works, and is the secret of their uncanny vitality. The Concerto Romano, heard last Sunday at Symphony Hall under the composer’s direction, exploits the possibilities offered by unusual blendings of the great organ and brass against the background of strings. Here we find the same renunciation of tinsel and shine in favor of frugal and sober sonorities. The Sonata for Piano and Violoncello, also to be heard on Wednesday, is written along the same lines, with the inversion of registers again at play with felicitous results. Three thirteenthcentury Songs for Soprano are varied in mood, the first in “strict style,” the second a “recitative,” the third a miniature opera buff a, in the typical march-like movement. In this latter type of composition Casella delights: he returns to it in the “March” from the Serenata as well as in the Concerto Romano. Be it said also that Casella is a composer of definite and symmetric designs; that he abhors suggestion instead of statement and diffusion instead of compactness. He is never formless; rather he is uniform, and the ternary construction—a songful part separating the two sections of a rondo—lies at the foundation of nearly all of his works. Hence, the rule of contrasts and variations in the largest sense, the familiar in the new according to William James’s phraseology. Thus one may discover the upper tetrachord fulfilling an important office in Casella’s musical diction. Certain rhythms and figures, virile and direct, may be traced here and there as a sort of individual stamp. While four styles have been discerned in Casella’s works by commentators, the last, or the latest, style seems to be his true idiom, connecting the composer with his predecessors in Italy and establishing him as a member of a natural evolutionary line. In this latest period, it is true, he adheres perceptibly to the style known as Gregorian, or modal. Chromaticism has little or no charm for Casella; while his scores certainly do not look modern, if the word is to be misinterpreted as connoting something involved and eccentric. H.L.Mencken once concocted a delicious parody on a program-book discoursing learnedly and endlessly upon a tone-poem written by a German with an unpronounceable name. The composer, it seems, was engaged in platitudes coated in a thick layer of double-sharps and triple-flats which would make a Chinese riddle out of simple C major. If Mencken’s German was a modernist, then Casella is none of that, for his pages look astonishingly blank, with hardly an accidental. As in some of Prokofiev’s straightforward music, C major is often featured. The British gentleman who, according to a newspaper anecdote, wearily sank into his sofa pillows and requested somebody to play a C major chord as the necessary antidote to a whole evening of modern music which he had had to endure, would not have needed this musical balm after a concert
Nicolas slonimsky
58
from Casella or Prokofiev. Some statistician ought to make a comparative study of moderns and ancients in this respect. He would find the classics the more chromatic. Moderns of Casella’s type have thus restored the simplicity lost by late romanticists. But Casella’s simplicity is the simplicity of strict counterpoint which is not so simple after all. Whoever cares to investigate will find feats of contrapuntal skill in such scores as the “Partita” or the “Scarlattiana.” The direct appeal of these works has been tested; the scholarship in this case is applied to enhance the value (even the box office value) of the composition. For the restless spirits that are not contented with “ear-sports,” as music used to be termed by pre-Elizabethans, remains the pleasure of “eye-sports”—a study of a modern composer who is modern not because he emulates the elevated trains, but because he expresses the eternal musical truth in the pliant sentences of contemporary speech.
THE PIT THEY HAVE HOLLOWED FOR TOSCANINI November 2, 1929 The Illustrious Conductor in Peril from Excess of Admiration
When an interpreter of arts has reached a universally acknowledged eminence, a need grows to incorporate his deeds and fancies in book form. Floral tributes fade, and applause dies away, but a book of reverent biography will endure. Arturo Toscanini is incontestably a world figure. The wide interest aroused by his appearances in this country has caused one of our most discriminating publishers, Alfred Knopf of New York, to publish a volume of 222 pages dedicated to the life and works of the famous conductor. The book is written by one Tobla Nicotra, and translated from the Italian by Irma Brandeis and H.D.Kahn. It appeared last spring when Toscanini sailed for Italy; now that he is again “with us,” it is fitting to return to the only publication available in the English language which deals with Toscanini not only as a conductor of genius but also as a mortal among mortals. That the book is “authoritative” and based on first-hand information, no reasonable doubt can persist. A single example will suffice. The biographer gives an instance of Toscanini’s generosity in financial matters, when he contributed one hundred thousand Italian lire to the “Pro Scala” fund, at the Scala Theater of Milan. The Association of Trustees of that organization had presented Toscanini with a check for that sum to mark their appreciation of Toscanini’s services. Toscanini refused to accept the gift, protesting that he had only done his duty. His rejection startled the trustees. They wrote him begging to accept their spontaneous offering. They “marked time in trepidation” awaiting his reply. This time Toscanini accepted, only to turn the check to the fund of the Pro Scala, with an admonition that the donor should remain anonymous. Hence, the item on the memorial tablet at La Scala: “Signor N.N.—100,000 lire.” Munificence like evil deeds “will out.” Undoubtedly, it was difficult to keep the secret, but it is equally obvious that the disclosure could have been made only with the express permission of the association, and under the condoning eyes of the donor himself. Which bears no reflection on the honor of either; the story of this gift, twice offered, once rejected, once accepted and finally turned over to charitable purposes, was bound to become public, or a beautiful occasion would have been missed to show that noble souls still exist in our materialistic age. This and similar information leads us to believe that we are dealing with an official biography, issued, most probably, with Toscanini’s knowledge of the text, or, at least, representing the point of view of Toscanini’s closest friends and admirers.
Nicolas slonimsky
60
If it were not for this “human interest” the book should have been wearily passed over by the board, for as a literary product it is utterly inconsequential, dabbling in laughable theorizing, and infused with that peculiar logic that is best illustrated in the famous lines of the hardy captain of the Pinafore:
Though I’m anything but clever, I can talk like that for ever; Once a cat was killed by care; Only brave deserve the fair. As irrelevantly, Signor Nicotra quotes in profusion from Schiller, Schopenhauer, Tolstoy, Nietzsche, Victor Hugo, Berlioz, Taine, and others, and then “jumps to conclusions” utterly unwarranted by the quotations. His language is turgid and, at times, unbelievably clumsy. For this the translators must accept their share of the blame. It seems that even cursory editing would cleanse the text of such redundancies as “mounting crescendo,” such misuses as “hectic” for “exciting,” such inexcusable journalisms as “snags” (in a score!) and of numberless “metaphors gone insane”—as Mark Twain used to term mixed figures of speech. Chapter One tells us of Toscanini’s first steps in music. It is scant in actual information, but rich in instances of topsy-turvy logic. Thus we learn that “the large majority of young persons with any degree of exceptional (?) musical talent make up their minds at the first opportunity that they must become composers.” “Not so Toscanini…. His diploma had not infected him with the common itch to produce a steady flow of musical compositions.” But on the very next page we find that Toscanini “did, none the less, make a few early attempts at compositions.” Moreover: he “entered into negotiations with the editors Giudici and Strada” and had published some songs the titles of which (Desolazione, Nevrosi, Autunno and such like) the biographer officiously offers to the reader. He does not venture to discuss the merit of the compositions themselves, but gracefully turns about to proffer a theory which is worth mentioning in view of its recent revival in the columns of the New York press: It must be noted that in their matchless comprehension Toscanini’s readings of music themselves border on creation and provide him an aesthetic satisfaction almost identical with the composers. And further on: when one is really stirred by the beauties of a composition, he is almost sure to be pricked by the desire to write one of the kind himself—less for the sake of rising to the composer’s rank than in order to experience emotions which, since more personal, will presumably also be deeper. This inarticulate muttering echoes what more literate writers try to establish as dogma: the interpreters supremacy over the composer. The idea springs from the most natural
The pit they have hollowed for toscanini 11/2/29
61
sources: the desire of the mediator to become master. When actual “creation” is beyond the powers of an artist, the “common itch,” of which Toscanini’s biographer speaks, will lead him to an act of folly: the usurpation of the “creators” rights. There are patrons of arts who put their signature over a work of some poor fellow of a composer, and learn to convert their vicarious indulgence into actual belief in their authorship. They are not unlike the interpreters who declare themselves above the composers. It is a pity: for, admirable in their proper place, they become ridiculous when headstrong admirers drag them into a wrong category. Toscanini’s first appearance as conductor was with an Italian opera traveling in South America. Signor Nicotra’s account of the incident is so confusing that it is impossible to understand why the public, incensed by the orchestras treatment of a native conductor who had resigned in protest, hissed off the two Italians who in turn took up the baton, but accepted Toscanini, then a mere boy of nineteen, summoned from his ’cellist’s desk to conduct. But to quote Signor Nicotra’s own inimitable lines: There stands young Toscanini on the conductor’s dais wearing somebody else’s dress coat—which they have got him inside of without his being aware of it—holding a baton someone has managed to thrust between his fingers. He closes the score (for he is never during his whole career to conduct except by memory), lifts his baton, sends the familiar (sic!) electric glance to left and right, and gives the signal for attack. The feat of getting into somebody’s coat without being aware of it can only be matched by the ingenuity of the language in which it is expressed. Signore Nicotra fails to explain how Toscanini’s electric glance could have been familiar if it was his first appearance at the desk. But this is the delightful feature of all Nicotras, Italian, American, universal— that the limitations of space and time, common sense and elementary grammar disappear when confronted with a genius. Toscanini is a happy possessor of an excellent musical memory. He conducts all his performances without notes. It is a most valuable gift, which enables the conductor to eliminate the often annoying physical barrier between him and his players. Toscanini may be a “memory phenomenon,” but he is not the only one. Sir Thomas Beecham conducts not only at the performance, but at all rehearsals without a score. Albert Coates does as well. And then there are Stokowski, Mengelberg, Gabrilowitch—all “score-less” conductors. With that, the range of their repertory is considerably wider than Toscanini’s. Signor Nicotra’s anecdotes which he relates to substantiate the legend of Toscanini’s uniqueness in this respect are suspiciously unconvincing. Here is number one: When his teacher Giusto Dacci heard the current rumors about his pupil’s memory, he was frankly skeptical and asked Toscanini whether the report was true. In reply Toscanini at once sat down and wrote out the entire overture to the first act of Lohengrin! Does Signor Nicotra realize that to “at once sit down and write out” an overture requires hours of time? Did the challenger wait for him to finish? And who selected the item to be
Nicolas slonimsky
62
“at once written out”? It is not at all clear even in Signor Nicotra’s own sympathetic description. Anecdote number two: The first violinist of Toscanini’s quartet wrote an Adagio in tribute to a count. It was performed once, but when the friends assembled at the count’s home a year later, the composer was not there. The count bemoaned his absence all the more bitterly because there was no copy at hand to revive the Adagio, of which the count grew fond. Toscanini took the other two aside. “Shall we surprise the count?” he asked. “Give me a pencil—here’s a piece of paper.” And he proceeded to rewrite the Adagio from memory. It has not been recorded whether the counts delight matched his surprise when he heard the first notes (sic!) of his quartet come back to life. Sly Signor Nicotra! Were only the first notes rewritten by Toscanini, or the entire quartet? Only in the latter case would Nicotra’s claims be justified. Relating the story when Toscanini “stepped in” to conduct “Cristoforo Colombo,” Signor Nicotra is again non-committal, almost cleverly so. Did Toscanini conduct this opera from memory? His biographer does not say “yes” or “no,” and proceeds to tell some mild nonsense about Toscanini’s school days when “he had only to hear a motif to be able to write it down.” This method of procedure is apt to produce an effect opposite to the biographers intentions, even arouse some suspicion. Once upon a time Toscanini indulged in some talks on music. Signor Nicotra quotes Toscanini’s digests of Mozart’s and Beethoven’s lives, and comments on them: Toscanini’s “Conversazione” are full of absorbing data as well as illuminating sidelights on his own viewpoint. It becomes clearer than ever, reading them, that this man never forgets anything: dates, names, sto-ries, as well as the literature of his special province, remain in his mind like some super-child’s learning in an unerased copy book. Why this strange conclusion? Was Toscanini barred from the use of the Encyclopedia while he compiled these Conversazione? In his haste to claim the earth for Toscanini, Signor Nicotra gets into most embarrassing situations, contradicting himself on every page, in every paragraph. Toscanini is a great conductor; his symphonic concerts ought to be studied for their technical excellence, the root of which may be found in his operatic routine. But Toscanini is notoriously limited in his repertory. His “first performances” are gathered chiefly from Italian works of a “mild” variety, from such genial composers as Respighi and Sabata. Alfredo Casella, the more individualized Italian, is significantly absent from Toscanini’s programs. Toscanini takes in Strauss and some Debussy, and ventures an abridged version of Stravinsky’s Petrouchka. He plays strictly honorable music, and indulges in no experiments. A noble attitude, respectable in every way. But his official biographer would not keep at rest; he has to prove that even in the realm of orchestral music Toscanini is “uber alles.” The results are lamentable. The sample programs of Toscanini’s concerts in Italy, with Mendelssohn’s Overture to Midsummer Night’s Dream on nearly every one of them, look childish when compared with those of modern conductors. And when Signor Nicotra tells us that Toscanini’s second program in Milan
The pit they have hollowed for toscanini 11/2/29
63
was distinguished by “a richly varied program—the Manfredini Concerto Grosso, Respighi’s ‘Ballata delle Gnomidi’ and the Beethoven and Wagner selections of the previous concerts” he plainly tries his readers’ patience. Signor Nicotra carefully avoids all that is obscure in Toscanini’s biography, for instance the trouble that precipitated his departure from America after his break with the Metropolitan. But he does recount—in a chapter euphemistically entitled The Dionysiac—the untoward happening when Toscanini broke a bow on a violinist’s head, with the subsequent court proceedings. He offsets the story by a few touching fairy tales where Toscanini figures as a forgiving teacher and his musicians as reverent pupils. In one instance, Toscanini shouted at a musician and called him an ass. The offender—that is the musician—was heart-broken, not because of the insult, but because Toscanini addressed him formally, in the Italian equivalent of Mr.! Signor Nicotra does not like to recall the condemnatory attitude that the entire country and the press took against Toscanini after he had struck the musician. But Toscanini was the pride of the nation and a senator. He was acquitted, after a most ingenious defense offered by the celebrated psychologist Annibale Pastore: The musical “sacro furore,” he said is frequently capable of causing such intense excitation as fully to eliminate the normal personality. In this case it would be a grave mistake to call the normal Toscanini to account for what happened. Everyone, psychologist or not, can see what exaggerated proportions the musical pathos takes in him. The Dionysiac mood— essential to musical life—might be described as orgiastic transfiguration, during which every inhibitive force is suppressed and impulsive power exaggerated to the point of paroxysm…. The faculty of distinguishing good and bad and acting in accordance with the distinction is replaced by the faculty (acting and reacting with extreme violence) of response to beauty and ugliness…. In his almost indescribably emotional state at that rehearsal Toscanini’s act was typical of the unconsciousness of genius, breaking with all the surface conventions of normal life. To condemn him for it would be as bad as condemnation of musical genius. This raises a tremendous issue. If for a superb performance of a symphony it would be necessary to injure one of several musicians, what should be sacrificed—art or skull? Optimists still think that both the integrity of art and that of the human body can be preserved without undue strain on the temperamental director. After his interlude in court Toscanini never broke a violinist’s bow, and his performances have not suffered therefrom. Even from his own point of view, self-constraint must be beneficial, for violent actions are necessarily distracting to the artist and, therefore, detrimental to the work of art at hand. Peace will come when artists—great and small—will civilize themselves, and when their admirers will acquire enough sense to keep their heads cool, even in the very process of self-immolation at the shrine of a current deity.
UNALLOYED, UNDECORATED, UNDIMINISHED November 30, 1929 Musorgsky’s “Boris Godunov” In Original Version for American Hearing
The restoration of the authentic version of Musorgsky’s opera “Boris Godunov” is not only a great artistic event but also a sign of the times. The “people” that according to Pushkin’s stage directions, remain “silent,” when told of the election of the usurper Boris, and later, of the impostor Grishka, that people have suddenly revolted against their artistic guardians, and have demanded to be shown into the laboratory of the genius without benefit of editors. Musorgsky’s original version is by no means a recent discovery; during the composers lifetime, and under his supervision, a vocal score was published by Bessel. But in this edition, the composer robbed himself of some ten pages of exquisite music from the final scene between the Overseer and the people. In the words of Victor Belaiev, the scholarly author of an illuminating pamphlet on the genuine “Boris,” “the exclusion of this exquisite close of the whole tableaux, exquisite in both a musical and a scenic respect, is difficult to understand.” As incomprehensible is the elimination of the eighty-four bars of “magnificent music which must be ranked amongst Musorgsky’s greatest achievements,” as Belaiev appraises it—the music of Pimen’s account of the Tsarevitch’s murder, essential to the dramatic completeness of the opera. These two scenes and some other significant additions have been for the first time brought out, thanks to the labor of love performed by Paul Lamm in his edition of Musorgsky’s “Boris,” Oxford University Press. This edition also gives some most interesting variants, among them the original version of the scene in the Tsar’s apartment in the Moscow Kremlin. Needless to say, Rimsky-Korsakov is entirely blameless for Musorgsky’s voluntary self-abridgement as evidenced in the composer’s vocal score. Rimsky-Korsakov’s “guilt” may be established only by comparison between his revised text and the composer’s. Musorgsky’s vocal score has been recently reprinted by several publishing houses and thus has rekindled the controversy. But the controversy itself is old. Only the point of view has changed. The harmonies that appeared coarse and uncouth fifty years ago, are now stimulating and revealing. The orchestration that seemed drab and ineffective to professional orchestrators, appeals to the modern ear by its very restraint. The epoch of show and display has terminated with the war, was killed by it. Composers themselves set to revise their early works and tear off the tinsel that once was spark. Thus Stravinsky has plucked orchestral feathers a-plenty from his immodestly luxuriant “Fire-bird.” RimskyKorsakov, who lived in a different century, has done the reverse; and, as we compare the noble economy of Musorgsky’s orchestra with the gaudy brilliance of Rimsky’s we
Unalloyed, undecorated, undiminished [Musorgsky] 11/30/29
65
wonder how he, a sincere admirer of Musorgsky’s genius could err so egregiously. In the apt phrase of Lawrence Gilman, Rimsky might as well have introduced harps and celesta into Brahms’s C minor Symphony. From the point of view of harmony, Rimsky’s alterations have been under suspicion long before the restoration of the genuine “Boris.” In some instances the correcting hand of a professor is too obviously present. Consistently, Rimsky has eliminated all “mixing” of the harmonic and melodic minor scales (in Xenia’s lament); has resolved superimposed suspensions (in Marina’s phrases in the scene at the fountain); has sewed up disparate keys by appropriate modulations; has done much more distorting work. He was sincerely convinced that Musorgsky aimed high, but fell short; he sincerely wanted to help a friend and a genius who unfortunately was lacking in technique. He lodged with Musorgsky in the autumn of 1871, and knew him intimately. Yet a note of anger sounds in these lines from his memoirs: It looked as though Musorgsky suspected me of being the conservative professor who might convict him of parallel fifths, and this was unbearable to him. And then, more explicitly: His style lacked finish and gracefulness of form. This he lacked because he had no knowledge of harmony and counterpoint. At first, Balakireff’s circle ridiculed these needless sciences, and then declared them beyond Musorgsky. And so he went through life without them and consoled himself by regarding his ignorance as a virtue and the technique of others as routine and conservatism. The first version of “Boris Godunov” was rejected by the committee of the Imperial Theater of St. Petersburg, on account, among other rea-sons, of the discontent of Giovanni Ferrero, a double-bass player and a member of the committee. He was shocked by the composers employment of the double-basses divisi playing chromatic thirds in the accompaniment to Varlaam’s song. Rimsky-Korsakov finds this ridiculous. He tells us of the fury and indignation of the composer at the unofficial suggestion that he should introduce “love- interest” into his opera (the first version did not contain the Polish scene, nor the scene of Revolt). Upon second thought, Musorgsky submitted, and set to the composition of these scenes. (It was while he was lodging with Rimsky.) The part of Marina was created, in accordance with Pushkin’s text, and, at the energetic insistence of the prima donna, Madame Platonova, who wanted the opera for her benefit performance, “Boris” was presented in its entirety, in January, 1874. Shortly before, the composers vocal score was published. The performance was a great event according to the account of V. V.Stasov, Musorgsky’s thunderous champion. Other accounts do not record an outstanding success, however. Cesar Cui published an article nothing short of slanderous. He termed the work immature and hasty. Musorgsky’s correspondence shows how deeply this unexpected attack wounded him. Can the surmise be substantiated that the more conventional form and development of the Polish scene was partly due to the fact that the two composers lodged together at the
Nicolas slonimsky
66
time, and that Musorgsky had undergone a certain disciplining influence, albeit, the two friends worked separately? Rimsky-Korsakov tells us in his memoirs, that their time was strictly divided; Musorgsky was regularly employed in the Department of Woods and Forests, and was on duty part of the day. Rimsky-Korsakov had his professorship at the Conservatory, which left some time—and the right to use the piano—to Musorgsky. But they “constantly exchanged plans and ideas.” But even if Musorgsky himself would have succumbed to Rimsky-Korsakov’s better learning, there would have been room left for the selective mind of new musical generations to choose. It often happens that the composer, on second thought, tones down some of his effects. Chopin’s works are most interesting for study in this respect. Liszt took the liberty of retaining the “discordant” E flat in the final chord of the introduction of the first Ballade, even if Chopin changed it in the proofs. For a final version, a choice has to be administered, when there are several authentic variants. The discriminating hand of Leopold Stokowski has undoubt-edly fixed some details in the score for the first presentation of the genuine “Boris” in this country. The eminent Russian critic, Igor Glebov, advances an interesting theory that the hero of Musorgsky’s national opera was not Boris, but the people itself. He substantiates his theory by showing how, in the original version, Musorgsky, preferred less poignant tones in Boris’s declamation. Also, the placing of the scene of revolt after that of the Tsar’s death seems to have a significance of its own. There was more importance given in the original version to the roles of courtiers and other minor characters. The deleted parts were mostly those related to the people, or the people’s contact with the officials. Musorgsky’s original plan might have been checked by such considerations as the impossibility of staging an opera without a hero, or with a collective hero; perhaps, the thought of possible censoring diverted him from his idea. Whatever it was, Musorgsky’s figure appears before us on a far higher plane than that of his immediate friends and coworkers. The very elusiveness of his main line, the variety of interpretations that his scores afford, testify to his greatness, seen from all angles of space and time. A purely national product, his musical genius knows no frontiers. A musician of his time, he nevertheless moves parallel with the new generations—like a star too distant to be affected by the relative changes within our limited circle.
THIS AMERICA DEEP IN HIS FERVENT SOUL December 27, 1929 Ernest Bloch, Rhapsodist, Prize-Man, Composer None the Less
A composer is about to be glorified in an unprecedented way. Ernest Bloch’s epic composition “America” is to be performed—almost simultaneously, day for day, hour for hour—by major orchestras of the United States. The composer himself will hear the San Francisco Symphony—for in the Far West he is making his home now. An anthem concludes “America”; the composer hopes that it will become an inspiring call to the people, that the audience will rise to it and join the voices of the score. Then, a miracle will have been performed, and this country’s national hymn—which at present is also that of the imperial Austria and England—will be spontaneously born. Ernest Bloch, the creator of a new American musical epic! Ernest Bloch, the prophet of racial music, the Parisian modernist of yore! What a complex of personalities, what a storm of passions! And what devastating sincerity in this violent, changing soul, ever blazing with the fire of imperishable faith. Faith, in spite of sufferings that pervaded his stormy life, in spite of grinning despair, in spite of his own disbelief. Ernest Bloch is, beyond doubt, the most individual composer of our age. His works are inseparable from his own destinies and the tides and ebbs of his moods are the flow of his music. Nor does music exhaust his energies, to the elimination of all that cannot be expressed in sounds. Ernest Bloch is ever tortured by problems involving mankind as a whole, inter-relation among people, truthfulness of life. A tempestuous mind that would not have the peace offered him on the golden dish of self-contentment. He seeks storms as men seek repose, and in the conquest of them he finds his supreme happiness—to be compared in depth of emotion only with his utter wretchedness when the stream of baser life intrudes upon his inner self. The fairy that bestowed the musical genius upon Bloch, also cursed him with the spirit of piercing understanding and a craving for reform. Wit—destructive and without mercy—making strange bedfellows with faith, adds to the mental unrest of Ernest Bloch, who finds no place on earth to rest his weary head. The refuge of creed is constantly bombarded by doubt; skepticism is made impossible by the desire to live on—and to make life truer to the ideal. Sincerity shuts off self-complacence and soothing hypocrisy. Ernest Bloch will live. He was born in Geneva—the home of the League of Nations—on the border of the serenest of lakes, in a country of peaceful and beautiful living. A Swiss Jew—what can be nearer to the ideal of true internationalism? Yet, he loves every nation as a bearer of an ideal. His Americanization is a true one—for it is conversion to an ideal, insomuch as
Nicolas slonimsky
68
America embodies it. “I have charged myself, needed or unheeded, to compose a march for these States.” Thus Walt Whitman. “It is the hope of the composer that this anthem will become known and beloved, that the audience will rise to sing it, becoming thus an active and enthusiastic part of the work and its message of faith and hope.” Thus Ernest Bloch. In his search for an everlasting ideal, Ernest Bloch keeps close to life, rejoicing at every spark of goodness and worthiness, that can be found in a human soul. His utterances seldom know the middle way; he fluctuates, like Dostoievsky, between the abysses of whole-hearted acceptance and scornful rejection. He writes as if driven by an inner force of unquenchable intensity. He reads, he corresponds. He opens wide his arms to anybody who is willing to understand him. But he speaks as openly to the face of dull complacency. He is a man of enemies and friends divided by the sharp line of two irreconcilable psychologies: shall life be made more beautiful and more truthful? Shall life be made more comfortable and more durable? Many an element of beauty or truthfulness must be sacrificed to secure comfort and care-free existence. When Bloch “failed to be re-engaged” at Cleveland, was not this the core of the trouble, rather than his intransigence and the committee-ladies’ tender feelings? A parallel was often drawn between Bloch and Beethoven. Analogies are odious, but it cannot be said that Beethoven was always inspired in his actions by the purest of designs. It must be conceded, even by Bloch’s enemies, that he, however erratically from their smug point of view, was actuated by the spirit of human truth. Ernest Bloch started early on his way. He was barely twenty-one when his Symphony was performed at Geneva. Romain-Rolland wrote him an enthusiastic letter. He admonished the youth not to listen to praises or condemnations. Indeed, Bloch never cared for outward signs of recognition. The peculiar process in his mind consisted in projecting an ideal upon the world; the recognition was necessary for him as a sign, as a wave of hand from a friend. But there it ends—no vainglory, no ticklish sensation of fame. Above all, no pose, but an outspoken attitude, which, by virtue of its very incredibility, in the eyes of some people amounts to a pose. The Opera “Macbeth” which was produced at the Opera Comique in Paris some twenty-five years ago was met by usual derision and some harshness—its music, so natural and easy to modern ears, was declared barbarian. The composer was dismissed with a shrug and a warning. “The Jewish Poems” were first rejected by Dr. Muck during his term of office at the Boston Symphony, because of the title, but were accepted later, when the composer exhibited a rather uncommon tenacity to the notes as well as to the words above them written. Dr. Muck is said to have been pleased with Bloch’s uncompromising attitude. The composer con-ducted—it was his first visit to America— the performance was a success. “The Jewish Poems” impressed by their impetus and racial self-assertion. His Shelomo for ’Cello and Orchestra and the “Israel” Symphony definitely established his reputation as a Jewish composer, given to revealing the chosen race in music. He revolted against this confinement in an open letter. “Why should I be bottled, labelled, compelled to eat Kosher all my life? I have more personalities than one, I have not said my last word.” More personalities than one! Rarely does a man see himself in a truer light! His Jewish personality is but one of many aspects of his soul.
This america deep in his fervent soul [Bloch] 12/27/29
69
It is the Jewish soul that interests me, the complex, glowing agitated soul, that I feel vibrating throughout the Bible; the freshness and naivete of the Patriarchs; the violence that is evident in the prophetic books; the Jew’s savage love of justice, the despair of the Preacher Jerusalem; the sorrow and the immensity of the Book of Job; the sensuality of the Song of Songs. All this is in us; all this is in me, and it is the better part of me. It is all this that I endeavor to hear in myself and to transcribe in my music the venerable emotion of the race that slumbers way down in our soul. In his Jewish pieces Bloch is best known and understood. There is very little in orchestral literature that surpasses the Jewish Poems in sheer power. Bloch’s secret consists in relentless accumulation of sound; his music climbs in diatonic degrees, receding only to gather strength. It is something like the ascension of an interminable stairway leading into the clouds. The piercing shrieks of his trumpets produce almost a physiological effect, stupefying, dulling the perceptive powers, releasing them only when all is said and done. But then, Bloch writes a Concerto Grosso, a care-free work written as a “relaxation.” Can Bloch blame the critics for hunting “motifs of the Synagogue” in it? In a remarkable letter written to the editor of a daily paper he tells the “simple truth” (always the truth!): Once upon a time (Cleveland, 1923, I think) coming home in my Ford car, rush hours, bad traffic, unbearable Irish policemen, I had an obstinate rhythm in my head. I stopped, noted it, the Prelude was born. It had a clear-cut, classic form. I got the idea to use it for a little work for strings that our Students’ orchestra could play, and to add three or four numbers in good, clear, classic form, to serve as antidote for my “advanced” pupils, who were writing Jewish music, cosmic phantasmagorias in ultra-modern idiom, though very tame, repressed, New England natures, with old regular, repressed families, many of them ministers. In the same letter he describes his sojourn in New Mexico: When I came back people asked me whether I had written an Indian Symphony or an Indian Opera (as Americans do, to perpetuate the “tradition of the race”). No, I did not. I wrote a Fugue, a classic Fugue. 1—The music of the Indians is too beautiful as it is, to retouch it. 2—I have enough of my own ideas and need not steal them. 3—I have not yet been impregnated enough by the soul of this extraordinary country (New Mexico) for my chemistry, my musical chemistry to be ready. It may come some time. But it must come in spite of myself. One does not create life that way. Music cannot be made. It makes itself, in ourselves.
Nicolas slonimsky
70
This letter was written early in January, 1926. The prize competition for which Bloch wrote “America” was not yet announced. “It may come some time.” It did. In spite of Bloch himself, and in spite of the competition. For not always do competitions evoke only the most elementary inspirations. Bloch has been an easy winner of prizes; his suite for Viola and Orchestra in 1919, his Suite for Chamber Orchestra in 1927, his Epic Rhapsody “America” in 1928 were prize-winning compositions. Prizes, competitions may be the actuating spur, but once at work, Ernest Bloch is unable to contain himself. He puts into every work all the passion and violence of his rousing spirit…. His pupils, he feels are also children of his brain. But in his teaching he is most liberal. He never tired of extolling Roger Sessions who went far from Bloch’s musical path. His newest hope—Quincy Porter—never flatters has master by unmitigated imitation. But George Antheil—who, strangely enough, is also Bloch-bred—committed the only unforgivable crime. He deliberately went into sensationalism. He was never interested in accomplishment for its own sake. His music became as twisted as he himself. Bloch openly disowned him. Manifold are Ernest Bloch’s interests and activities. “To rest, work” as Orlando di Lasso said, is his favorite motto. In this world of business-like musicians he presents a strange sight. His very appearance is arresting—large features, deep-seated eyes, penetrating look, under a Beethovenian brow. His conversation is illuminating. The freshness of his perception amazes all who do not know how to be wise as a child. The world is constantly being born to him. It changes constantly, and he changes in it, standing, hatless, admiring the panorama that unveils before his eyes. He tries to understand—and he penetrates deeper than the aborigines themselves. He is making discoveries in what is considered commonplace; he purifies everyday experience and extracts its vital elements. He looks to the world—and, admiringly, creates.
A SINGLE LINE IS GLAZUNOV’S MUSICAL LIFE January 15, 1930 The Man and The Composer, From Past to Present His Firm-Set Self
Half a century ago a shy youth of sixteen brought an orchestral score to his famous teacher, and, diffidently moving unyielding fingers across the keyboard, presented a pianistic equivalent of the Symphony of his imagination. This episode was lovingly noted by Rimsky-Korsakov—the teacher—in his “Musical Life.” Alexander Constantinovich Glazunov—the pupil—was instantly accepted as the legitimate heir to the rare treasure of the Russian National School created by five non-professionals: a naval officer, RimskyKorsakov; an ensign of the guards; Musorgsky, a professor of chemistry, Borodin; an expert in fortification, Cui; and a broad-minded amphitryon, Balakirev. The New World—in the geographical as well as in the chronological sense—is now welcoming Alexander Constantinovich Glazunov with a measure of sincere admiration and awesome respect that no other composer of universal fame has heretofore received. Popular emotions are often symbols; and Glazunov is a personification of ideals long dormant but none the less active beneath the surface. Tradition and faith may be these ideals. An irreproachable past may be the endearing feature. Glazunov, in all his years, has never looked over his shoulder to see the possible ruins of his civilization. Even Liadov, his closest associate, in his late years was moved by Skriabin’s elusive harmonies, and sounded a foreign note in his final works. It is a futile occupation to look for similar contemporary influences in Glazunov’s music. Since the day when his first Symphony in E aroused Rimsky-Korsakov, his progress was sound and undisturbed. He has known no “periods.” Even the youthful storm and stress, when a daring mind sets out to conquer the world, eluded him. Ravel and Strauss are now classical composers; but both of them have had their incendiary moments, and are still at work devising new and startling schemes, sometimes in defiance of the former faiths. There is no need to mention Stravinsky, the prodigy of avatars. If these reformed bad boys are accepted—or pardoned—the respect that they are enjoying in the popular mind or among musicians of the old school, will never match the white purity of Glazunov’s record. Those who come in contact with Glazunov, the man, never fail to be impressed by the same high qualities that distinguish his music. Glazunov, the director of the Conservatory of St. Petersburg, the thoughtful and self-denying father of an institution that literally supplied the world with the major part of its virtuosi and composers of all descriptions— conservative, modern, modernistic—this Glazunov presiding over the directorial table and liberally dealing out aid, advice and financial help, still awaits his historian. The
Nicolas slonimsky
72
medieval law which functioned up to the Revolution of 1917, and which barred the members of Jewish faith from residence in the capitals, was the greatest burden on Glazunov’s mind. A Russian of pure stock, he somehow managed to raise the “normal” percentage to the 53 per cent of the actual registration of Hebrew students in 1915, without breaking the law. Glazunov’s solicitous regard for impecunious students led him to considerable expenditures from his private purse. How he could reconcile the mildness of his personal rule with the highest standards of discipline and learning at his Conservatory is a subject of wonderment. Thus Glazunov outgrows the mere maker of music. He embodies principles that outlive the passion for the new. The world may grow independent and youngsters may sneer at eminence, but the halo of recognition will remain with the glorious past. Not too seldom revolutionaries themselves turn about and discover fantastic lights in abandoned valleys. Has not Chaikovsky been recently installed by Stravinsky in this fashion? In his steady progress, Glazunov has never been over-confident. His correspondence with Chaikovsky shows that at one time, after the con-spicuous failure of one of his secondary works he was seriously doubting his powers. Moreover, Chaikovsky, in a reply, while declaring himself an admirer, admitted that there was a lack of something in Glazunov’s music. What was that something? Chaikovsky promised to tell at the next personal meeting. But did the meeting take place, or did Chaikovsky speak his mind? Glazunov’s music is an open book. It does not present riddles, and conceals no key behind its pages or between its lines. Its methods may be traced to Liszt, its subjectmatter to the Russians, its mood and form to Chopin. But the combination of these elements forms an unmistakably individual style. This music may seem unearthly, or impress us with stationary aloofness, but its peculiar beauty, the ice-cold flame burning at the edges, kindles the imagination in spite of the absence of obvious ardors. Glazunov’s themes make absorbing material for study. He likes to state the subject in the deep register of the alto, the G-string of the violin, the middle octave of the piano, the viola of the string-quartet. The melody ascends, accompanied by the bass in stately procession at a diverging angle. The design is noble, clear, yet inherently capable of manifold transformations yielding itself to intricate embellishments. It is often built on a succession of thirds, ascending or descending, receding then by a second, to resolve the suspension. These thirds in further development may proceed without recession and compass two full octaves, passing through all seven notes of the scale. Taken together they form a chord, dissonant yet easily solvent, which is the “Glazunov chord.” Thematic material seems inexhaustible at Glazunov’s hands; the thousand and one ways to fertilize a melody and to marshal its multiple variations through the spaces of musical structure have no secrets for him. He is deliberate in his methods; there is sobering poise in the exposition; exquisite balance in the tightening augmentations. Glazunov is past master of counterpoint and orchestration; so was the great Taneiev. But Taneiev’s works have been relegated to the archives; not even his astonishing Symphony is ever heard. Glazunov, on the contrary, is in the repertory everywhere. There must be a hidden force in Glazunov’s monumental creations that compels the public to listen to his music. Ability, not necessarily desire, may father the thought. The genius for devising flexible melodies may have led Glazunov to the form of variation as the best medium. His greatest musical triumphs—the Intermezzo of the Sixth Symphony, the Variations for
A single line is glazunov's musical life 1/15/30
73
Pianoforte, to mention but a few— are embodied in such compositions. To touch a melody, without distorting its recognizable features is an art in itself and it is Glazunov’s art par excellence. This accounts for the logic of his development where musical leaves seem to grow out of the stem before our very ears. The leaves furl into buds, buds blossom into flowers…. To some they are a product of the hothouse; but incubated, or by nature born, they are as fragrant…. In style, Glazunov is less overtly national than his illustrious predecessors. He abandons some formulas, among them pseudo-orientalism, with its famous lowered sixth. But he retains the “grand” manner, the richness of Russian modes. When he makes use of a folk-tune, such as the Song of Volga Boatmen in his early symphonic poem, “Stenka Razin,” he leaves nothing undone; by change of rhythm or pace, he adapts it to a variety of moods; or by a crafty feat of instrumentation breaks it asunder, and then opposes the halved parts to each other. “Stenka Razin” was written in 1889, not for contrapuntal artifice, but for the crowds at the Paris Exposition to enjoy. Glazunov’s counterpoint, as Bach’s counterpoint, is his natural idiom. The scholarly Glazunov stands in delightful contrast with the Glazunov of ballet music. Here his sense of measure finds its most legitimate application. But it is not the sensuous ballet of the French: the music is light and nimble; there is little dramatization, and the intrinsic logic of the music never ceases to control the form or movement. Glazunov may also be programmatic, as in the suite “Moyen Age,” where there is a Death dancing and enticing, playing the open fifths on the fiddle: the traditional formula for Devils and such. Glazunov is majestic in depicting forests, seas, or widespread wastes of land. There he employs huge orchestral masses suggesting the immensity of the subject. But he is never elephantine as Strauss in the “Alpine Symphony”; and certainly he resorts to no onomatopœia of thunder machines. But Glazunov is primarily a composer of absolute music. Quartets, Symphonies, Concertos. Since 1915, when he wrote incidental music to the play, “The King of Judœa,” by Constantin Romanov, the Tsar’s cousin, his production has ceased. H.G.Wells, in his fantastic account of a journey to the post-revolutionary Petrograd, tells the story of Glazunov being unable to compose because of the shortage of music-paper. This may or may not have been the true cause of Glazunov’s abstinence from creative work. Those who remember Glazunov and Russia in the dark days following “The End of St. Petersburg,” recall with amazement the incredibly lean figure of the director of the Conservatory. They say he could wrap his coat around him twice over, which represented the loss of some sixty pounds of weight. Composing may not have been in order in those days…. Through wars and revolutions, Glazunov has never been untrue to his artistic self. The fact that there are people who compose music based on unresolved dissonances concerns him as little as the existence of interesting but incomprehensible guttural sounds in African dialects. Political changes, changes of surroundings, want, physical privations, are contingencies to be met and to be endured. But integrity of character cannot and must not be influenced by such changes. Glazunov has given us an inspiring example. His has been a noble life in art. That is why his welcome has grown to the significance of a stirring event.
SIDE-GLANCES AT PROKOFIEV NOW RETURNED January 30, 1930 A Trait Here, A Page There, Of The Manifold and Puissant Composer
Some years ago an intelligent far-seeing Russian critic made a startling prediction: that the time would come when Serge Prokofiev, in the halo of European fame, would be welcomed as master in his native country. He was mistaken only in that he allowed fifteen years for the event to happen. In the year 1927, not a decade after Prokofiev went a-wandering around the globe, he visited Russia as a recognized and even loved mastermusician. Who could think of such good fortune for the poor, ugly duckling, Prokofiev might have said, recalling his music and text to Andersen’s fairy-tale. Prokofiev is now an accepted composer. Amateur pianists everywhere struggle with the Gavotte from his Classical Symphony with the same fervor that they formerly applied to Rakhmaninov’s C-sharp minor Prelude. According to Mr. Casella, boys in the streets of Moscow whistle the tune of Prokofiev’s March from “Love for Three Oranges.” Prokofiev is on the operatic stage from Leningrad to Chicago; Diaghilev’s ballet has been miming and dancing to his music for half a generation. His scores are on the library shelves of every respectable orchestra—conductorless or leader-bound. Out of the air, the radio-audience hears him. He is a celebrated figure, on his way to eminence. At first Prokofiev’s career was centered on his pianistic powers. In his student years— at the Leningrad Conservatory, under Glazunov ‘s directorship—he was known chiefly as a pianist of stupendous ability. He did not even graduate in composition. Thus, his First Concerto which he played at the final exercises, and which must have annoyed some of his professors, was only an auxiliary for a display of his technical brilliance on the chosen instrument. He received the first prize as pianist. His compositions were merely tolerated, or ranked with such pastimes as playing chess, in which game Prokofiev was more than proficient. He won against every competitor in the all-Russian chess tournament for amateurs. Alekhine, the chess world-champion, thinks highly of Prokofiev’s talents in this direction. But not the chessboard, nor even the keyboard of the piano has elevated Prokofiev to his present position. His fame is the composers fame—to the virtual exclusion of all his achievements in other fields. Prokofiev’s evolution was singularly sane. He showed signs of musical genius at a very early age. At eight or nine he contrived an “opera” with all the paraphernalia of dramatic happenings essential to the form. His libretto abounded in conspiracies, duels, narrow escapes from death. The first and the last performance took place at his uncles mansion. The metaphorical curtain dropped prematurely when the composer was ordered to bed. Children’s compositions ought to be studied with at least as much interest as
Side-glances at prokofiev now returned 1/30/30
75
infantile drawings. There may be more spontaneity in the mind of a musical child than in compositions of a worldly gentleman making music his means to success. Prokofiev’s Opus One is a Piano-Sonata, discoverable not only in such treasuries of published and manuscript music as the Library of Congress. It is a pleasing perambulation over the keyboard, strangely Brahmsian in design, but musically unpromising. Prokofiev’s genius is disclosed for the first time in his Piano-Concerto—the graduation piece. There is magnificent daring in that music. The opening passages for the solo-instrument recall the finger-exercises of the celebrated Hanon, but Prokofiev struck fire. It was a new departure in the toccata style—a continuous flow of percussive tones dispensed with magnificent dash and effectiveness. There is suggestion of phenomenally long-winded breath; the usual abrupt cutting-off only enhances the impression. Prokofiev’s music is angular, or, more specifically, quadrangular. He sees no need of capricious digressions which only diminish the effect. He is not searching for new rhythms. He prefers not to break the old. One, two; left, right; up, down—Prokofiev’s music marches along, leaps upwards and snaps like an exhilarating muscular exercise. The secret of increasing tension by the hammering-out of a persistent rhythm was discovered by Prokofiev long before Ravel invented his “Bolero.” Prokofiev faces the charges of crudeness and even monotony with a stone-face. He is champion of direct action in music. And direct action demands fearless determination and perseverance—at all costs. Primitive music and primitive rhythms hold fascination for every one who abhors decadent moods. Fairy tales are product of a primitive mind. Prokofiev is attracted to such sources. His first opera, “The Gambler,” is based on a story of fantastic realism. Such texts are peculiarly suitable to Prokofiev’s genius. He may introduce a few measures of photographic verity like the swiveling figure for the roulette-ball. One nearly feels it as it winds up in the fatal zero. “The Flaming Angel” and “Love for Three Oranges” are other texts that fed Prokofiev’s inspiration. There is no need to recall the magnificent nonsense of the ballet, “Chout.” But how strikingly sensible the music! Prokofiev wrote “The Scythian Suite” when he was twenty. The score reflects the men and the gods of the half-legendary tribe of Scythians which roved over the plains of Russia before the Slavs came to inhabit the land. They were nomads and were last heard from some two thousand years ago. Their mysterious disappearance enhanced the fascination of their name. As the languid mid-Victorians yearned to be “early English ’ere it is too late,” so the Russians, suffering from a fashionable ennui, recalled their possible ancestors. Prokofiev’s music was revolutionary. When the first performance of the work was announced in Moscow, a not uncommon incident occurred; the orchestral parts were not ready in time, and another piece was substituted at the last moment. This did not prevent the headlong critic, Sabaneiev, from showering on Prokofiev all sorts of invective for his music. Prokofiev gave out the facts of cancellation in an open letter; the critic was forthwith asked to resign. At that time such dishonesty could not be tolerated. We all know that nowadays critics get away with worse things. From the Scythian Suite a straight line leads to “They Are Seven” on a cryptic text of age-old antiquity, for tenor solo, chorus and full orchestra. It is a sort of lingering explosion, releasing all the energies that matter may contain. Prokofiev breaks up the musical tone as scientists would split the atom. The score is a stunning revelation of power.
Nicolas slonimsky
76
The lyrical Prokofiev is in striking contrast to the Prokofiev of savage force. His lyricism is often reflective. It may take on a sardonic aspect when the composer looks soberly at his subjective indulgence. But the stirring quality of his lyrical pages is undeniable. Again, his uncanny efficiency works miracles: With a few notes stripped of all elaboration he produces an irresistible effect. His songs to the gentle words of Russia’s poignant poetess, Akhmatova, are such revelations of a moving emotion translated into the simplest musical signs. There is often sadness or self-pity; but a cheerful tone somehow breaks through. Prokofiev is pre-eminently an optimistic composer. Like all fairy tales, his music promises a happy ending. Even when he touches stark realism, the measures still flow free. His grotesque stage-figures, like The-Sailorwith-A-Bracelet or The Bread-Smugglers in the ballet, “Pas d’Acier,” do not repel. Beside Stravinsky, Prokofiev stands out as healthy and virile composer. There is a heartening tendency nowadays towards sanity in music, and in this movement Prokofiev is one of the chief figures. Not in vain does he mention Vladimir Dukelsky as his favorite composer among the young; for Dukelsky’s music is straight as an arrow, and it hits as unfailingly. The more meandering Auric and Poulenc lack the stamina that Dukelsky possesses, as a birth-right. After all, the business of music is to produce a tonic effect. Prokofiev’s rhythms and energies are eminently musical.
IN E