orth by 2020
orth by 2020
Perspectives on Alaska’s Changing Social-Ecological Systems
Edited by
Amy Lauren Lovecra...
46 downloads
2129 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
orth by 2020
orth by 2020
Perspectives on Alaska’s Changing Social-Ecological Systems
Edited by
Amy Lauren Lovecraft and Hajo Eicken
© Copyright 2011 University of Alaska Press. All rights reserved P.O. Box 756240 Fairbanks, AK 99775-6240
ISBN 978-1-60223-142-9 (paperback) 978-1-60223-143-6 (electronic) Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data North by 2020 : perspectives on Alaska’s changing social-ecological systems / edited by Amy Lauren Lovecraft and Hajo Eicken. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-1-60223-142-9 (pbk. : alk. paper)—ISBN 978-1-60223-143-6 (electronic book) 1. International Polar Year, 2007-2008—Congresses. 2. Polar regions—Research—Congresses. 3. Research—Polar regions—Congresses. 4. Arctic regions—Research—Congresses. 5. Antarctica—Research—Congresses. 6. Polar regions—Environmental conditions— Congresses. 7. Climatic changes—Detection—Polar regions—Congresses. I. Lovecraft, Amy Lauren. II. Eicken, Hajo. G587.N65 2011 304.209798—dc22 2011005676 Cover and text design by Paula Elmes, ImageCraft Publications & Design Cover art: Ooyahtoanah, ©1996 by Ken Lisbourne This publication was printed on acid-free paper that meets the minimum requirements for ANSI / NISO Z39.48–1992 (R2002) (Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials). Printed in Korea
Contents Foreword xi Preface xv
1 A Holistic Approach for a Changing North
Section Editors: Amy Lauren Lovecraft and Hajo Eicken
2
1
1.1 Introduction—Amy Lauren Lovecraft
3
1.2 Transdisciplinary Collaboration in the Fourth International Polar Year: Connecting Studies of Arctic Change across the Sciences and the Arts—Amy Lauren Lovecraft and Hajo Eicken
5
1.3 Scenarios as a Tool to Understand and Respond to Change —John E. Walsh, Marc Mueller-Stoffels, and Peter H. Larsen
19
1.4 Contextualizing Alaska’s Climate Change from Global to Local Scales: The Boreal Forest, People, and Wildfire—F. Stuart Chapin III and Amy Lauren Lovecraft
41
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainability Section Editors: Ray Barnhardt and Pia M. Kohler
55
2.1 Introduction—Ray Barnhardt
57
2.2 The Anchorage Declaration—Submitted by Patricia Cochran
69
v
3
2.3 My Place, My Identity—Angayuqaq Oscar Kawagley. Editors’ Note by Ray Barnhardt and Pia M. Kohler
75
2.4 A Changing Sense of Place: Climate and Native Well-Being—Steven R. Becker
79
2.5 Values of Nushagak Bay: Past, Present, and Future —Todd Radenbaugh and Sarah Wingert Pederson
95
2.6 Food Systems, Environmental Change, and Community Needs in Rural Alaska—S. Craig Gerlach, Philip A. Loring, Amy Turner, and David E. Atkinson
111
2.7 Indigenous Knowledge and Global Environmental Politics: Biodiversity, POPs, and Climate—Pia M. Kohler
135
2.8 Indigenous Contributions to Sustainability—Ray Barnhardt
151
2.9 Climate Change and Creative Expression—Mary Beth Leigh, Krista Katalenich, Cynthia Hardy, and Pia M. Kohler
163
Alaska’s Freshwater Resources
Section Editors: Amy Tidwell and Dan White
vi
169
3.1 Introduction—Amy Tidwell and Dan White
171
3.2 Alaska Freshwater Policy Development since Statehood —Jedediah Smith
183
3.3 The State of Water Science—Jonathan Pundsack, Dan White, Jessie Cherry, and Amy Tidwell
195
3.4 The Role of Fresh Water in Alaska’s Communities—Andrew Kliskey and Lilian Alessa
205
3.5 Planning for Change—Amy Tidwell, Dan White, and Andrew Kliskey
209
4 The Arctic Coastal Margin
Section Editors: David E. Atkinson and Peter Schweitzer
217
4.1 Introduction—David E. Atkinson, Peter Schweitzer, and Orson Smith
219
4.2 The Physical Environment of Alaska’s Coasts —David E. Atkinson
229
4.3 Humans in the Coastal Zone of the Circumpolar North —Peter Schweitzer
253
4.4 Case 1: Newtok, the First Village in Alaska to Relocate Due to Climate Change—Robin Bronen
257
4.5 Case 2: Flood Waters, Politics, and Relocating Home: One Story of Shishmaref, Alaska—Elizabeth Marino
261
4.6 Case 3: Finding Ways to Move: The Challenges of Relocation in Kivalina, Northwest Alaska—Patrick Durrer and Enoch Adams Jr.
265
4.7 Case 4: Current Situations and Future Possibilities: Issues of Coastal Erosion in Kaktovik, Alaska—Elizabeth Mikow
269
4.8 Case Studies: Summary, Conclusions, and Prospects —Peter Schweitzer
273
4.9 The Arctic Coastal System: An Interplay of Components Human, Industrial, and Natural—David E. Atkinson, Peter Schweitzer, Orson Smith, and Lisbet Norris
277
vii
5 Management of Living Marine Resources Section Editor: Keith R. Criddle
6
5.1 Introduction—Keith R. Criddle
301
5.2 Marine Fisheries off Alaska—Keith R. Criddle, Diana Evans, and Diana Stram
305
5.3 Climate Change Brings Uncertain Future for Subarctic Marine Ecosystems and Fisheries—Franz J. Mueter, Elizabeth C. Siddon, and George L. Hunt Jr.
329
5.4 Conservation of Marine Mammals in Alaska: The Value of Policy Histories for Understanding Contemporary Change—Chanda Meek
359
5.5 Addressing Rural Livelihood and Community Well-Being in Alaska’s Fisheries—Courtney Carothers
377
5.6 Tracking Changes in Coastal-Community Subsistence to Improve Understanding of Arctic Climate Change —Martin D. Robards, Hajo Eicken, and F. Stuart Chapin III 389
Marine Infrastructure and Transportation Section Editor: Andrew Metzger
viii
299
407
6.1 Introduction—Andrew Metzger
409
6.2 A Historical Perspective on the United States Coast Guard Presence in the Arctic—Lisa Ragone
411
6.3 The Arctic: A Growing Search-and-Rescue Challenge —Rick Button and Amber S. Ward
421
6.4 Traffic Management in the Bering Strait—Maureen Johnson
429
7
6.5 The Effect of Unregulated Ship Emissions on Aerosol and Sulfur Dioxide Concentrations in Southwestern Alaska —Nicole Mölders, Stacy E. Porter, Trang T. Tran, Catherine F. Cahill, Jeremy Mathis, and Gregory B. Newby
435
6.6 Strengthening Institutions for Stakeholder Involvement and Ecosystem-Based Management in the US Arctic Offshore —Sharman Haley, Laura Chartier, Glenn Gray, Chanda Meek, Jim Powell, Andrew A. Rosenberg, and Jonathan Rosenberg
457
6.7 Futures of Arctic Marine Transport 2030: An Explorative Scenario Approach—Marc Mueller-Stoffels and Hajo Eicken
477
Coastal and Offshore Oil and Gas Development: Balancing Interests and Reducing Risks Through Collaboration and Information Exchange Section Editors: Sharman Haley and Hajo Eicken
493
7.1 Introduction—Sharman Haley and Hajo Eicken
495
7.2 Analysis of the Arctic Council Oil and Gas Assessment, Oil and Gas Guidelines, and the Prospective Role of the Arctic Council—Dennis K. Thurston
503
7.3 The Need for International Cooperation in Offshore Oil and Gas—Anatoly Zolotukhin
527
7.4 Technological Frontiers for Offshore Oil and Gas —Walter Spring, Victoria A. Broje, Jeremy R. Dean, Michael L. Eckstein, Elio J. Gonzalez Domingo, Mark C. Hansen, Jerod M. Kendrick, Jochen Marwede, John H. Pelletier, Robert E. Raye, Allan M. Reece, Robert L. Rosenbladt, David G. Taylor, Cody C. Teff, Melanie M. Totten, and John M. Ward. Corresponding Author—Mitchell M. Winkler 537 7.5 The Role of Local and Indigenous Knowledge in Arctic Offshore Oil and Gas Development, Environmental Hazard Mitigation, and Emergency Response—Hajo Eicken, Liesel A. Ritchie, and Ashly Barlau
577
ix
8
7.6 Local Perspectives on the Future of Offshore Oil and Gas in Northern Alaska—Richard Glenn, Edward Itta, and Thomas Napageak Jr. Edited by Matthew Klick 605
Expressions of Climate Change in the Arts Section Editor: Maya Salganek
9
617
8.1 Introduction—Maya Salganek
619
8.2 Global Warming and Art—John Luther Adams
623
8.3 Dry Ice: Artists and the Landscape—Julie Decker
627
8.4 Social Climate Change of Alutiiq Dance Forms —Lena Snow Amason-Berns
637
8.5 Seeing Change: A Filmmaker’s Approach to Climate Change—Maya Salganek
641
8.6 The Syntax of Snow: Musical Ecoacoustics of a Changing Arctic—Matthew Burtner
651
8.7 Climate Change as Telematic Art—Scott Deal
665
8.8 A Long-View Perspective on Collaborative Filmmaking —Leonard Kamerling
673
Planning for Northern Futures
Planning for Northern Futures: Lessons from Social-Ecological Change in the Alaska Region —Hajo Eicken and Amy Lauren Lovecraft
679 681
Acknowledgments 701 Index of Authors and Coauthors
705
Index 711 x
Foreword
J
ust short of experiencing the first International Polar Year, Karl Weyprecht died in 1881 from tuberculosis. After a life-threatening, two-year Austro-Hungarian expedition from 1872 to 1873 to chart the Northeast Passage, Weyprecht returned to Austria and campaigned tirelessly for interested countries to work together to establish stations at the poles where scientific measurements could be standardized and taken simultaneously. His effort paid off; the International Polar Commission was formed in 1879 and the first International Polar Year (IPY) was planned for the two-year period spanning 1882–18831. Eleven countries participated in establishing twelve stations in the Arctic and one in the Antarctic. Now, a century and a quarter after completion of IPY-1, IPY-4 (2007–2008) has come and gone. Was it a success? Absolutely, although it did not measure up to the intense burst of scientific activity that occurred during IPY-3, the International Geophysical Year (IGY; 1957–1958). Conditions leading up to and surrounding IPY-4 were dramatically different. The Cold War had thawed and attention had shifted away from demonstrations of technological prowess and technocratic solutions. Unlike the suite of intriguing ideas earlier facing IGY, including plate tectonics, space exploration, and electronic communications, the paradigm-shifting idea of IPY-4 centered on global climate change and the societal changes that might be required to mitigate and cope with a warming planet. Recognizing the critical role that the Arctic and Antarctic regions play in climate, IPY-4’s sponsors returned to a more limited focus—coordinated research within or about the polar regions, much as Weyprecht originally proposed—but with an additional directive that this IPY specifically include the people of the North and the social sciences as a component of its research agenda.
xi
xiiâ•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
IPY-4 involved sixty-three nations and the total support for coordinated international research has been estimated at $1.5 billion. In the United States, the National Science Foundation alone awarded 389 new or continuing IPY research grants for a total of nearly $160 million. Of those, 122 projects involved activities in Alaska. University of Alaska Fairbanks’ (UAF) faculty received thirty-five NSF awards totaling $23.3 million, demonstrating clearly both the capabilities and the interests of our researchers. Our scientists were on the ground—in the field, in rural Alaska communities, around the globe, and in science centers across the country. They reached out to help educate the public and spent tireless hours documenting, collecting, and investigating at both ends of the Earth. Their efforts helped fuel the international momentum of IPY and brought incredible recognition to our state and university. Thanks to the commitment of the University of Alaska President Mark Hamilton, Vice President Craig Dorman, and UAF Chancellor Stephen Jones, significant resources were made available to extend the benefits of IPY throughout Alaska. As UAF’s vice chancellor for research at the time, I was tasked with developing a strategy for investing these funds in a sustainable and productive way. I, in turn, convened a steering group comprised of members representing the arctic research, teaching, and outreach expertise that our university is renowned for.2 Early on, Hajo Eicken and Amy Lauren Lovecraft lobbied for modest support to initiate a multidisciplinary research outreach activity they called North by 2020. Their idea was to create a forum that would bring scholars, elders, students, and experts from the public and private sectors to address several social-ecological issues facing the people of the Far North. I admit to being somewhat dubious at the time: I couldn’t see how they could accomplish even a large portion of what they were proposing for so little investment. Besides, the social-ecological issues they proposed to tackle were complex, culturally sensitive, and potentially divisive. But I had enough confidence in the leaders to believe that even if they had to scale down their ambitions, the concept and potential gains were well worth supporting. The over seven hundred pages encompassing North by 2020: Perspectives on Alaska’s Changing Social-Ecological Systems are clear documentation that my doubts were misplaced. The contributions in this volume reveal how much common ground can be gained when scientific rigor and cultural perspectives are skillfully and equitably intertwined. Anyone who examines this book—even in part—will be enriched in some way by its contents. By incorporating informative tutorials and rigorous research papers with moving personal experiences and essays spanning social sciences and the arts, Eicken and Lovecraft cast a multicultural light on
Forewordâ•…xiii
the challenges and opportunities facing residents of a rapidly changing Arctic. The editors and contributors to this volume are to be commended for a job well done. Karl Weyprecht would be proud. Virgil L. (Buck) Sharpton Chair, US Arctic Research Commission President’s Professor, UAF November 16, 2010
Endnotes 1
2
Why two years? The widely held explanation is that two years were required to ensure both summer and winter data collection at both poles. The more likely reason, however, is that polar expeditions—especially before air transport was common—took a long time to stage and mount. The custom has carried through subsequent IPYs. One of the unique aspects of the program born of this process was the energetic participation of so many young researchers. Through our Young Researchers’ Network, our IPY postdoctoral program, and North by 2020, we encouraged interactions between many of our senior scientists—those inspired by the last IPY—and a new cohort of polar researchers. Today our young scientists have a fresh look toward their research and how it can be communicated to the world. The enthusiasm, perspectives, and expertise of this generation of UAF’s “Young Turks” will carry us to the next IPY.
Preface
F
ocused on various aspects of change in Alaska and the circumpolar North, this book summarizes and reflects on a range of different activities and findings emerging from the Fourth International Polar Year (IPY). Most of the contributions gathered in this volume emerged from the University of Alaska’s (UA) North by 2020: A Forum for Local and Global Perspectives on the North, which brought together researchers, teachers, students, and a broad range of experts and contributors from within Alaska and abroad to explore the topic of a changing North. We are grateful to all contributors and participants in this bottom-up process for sharing so generously their time and expertise; the diversity of people and perspectives represented in North by 2020 has made this an exciting and rewarding effort. We were fortunate to have the backing and financial support of the University of Alaska, which provided the ideal vessel for the diversity of work reported on in later chapters of this volume. In particular, we acknowledge the critical support provided by then Vice Chancellor for Research Virgil “Buck” Sharpton at the University of Alaska Fairbanks (UAF). Without Buck’s guidance in the early stages and his continued encouragement and backing throughout the project this work would not have been possible. Anita Hartmann, associate dean of the College of Liberal Arts at UAF, also played an important role in fostering and guiding the work summarized in this volume, both as associate director of the North by 2020 forum and as co-chair of the UA IPY Subcommittee on Research. We are also grateful for the support and input provided by the other subcommittee members, who developed a strategy and implementation plan that informed much of the initial stages of North by 2020. While the North by 2020 forum theme leaders and section editors for this volume are highlighted throughout this text, we would like to acknowledge their critical engagement and leadership, which helped bring this effort together in an innovative way. We thank you! xv
xviâ•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
None of the activities that this volume builds on would have been possible without various forms of support, including crucial financial contributions, by a range of institutions. While these are explicitly referred to in the various chapters and the acknowledgments section of this book, we would like to highlight the important role played by a few key supporters. These include the US Department of State, which provided important funding to get core aspects of North by 2020 under way. The engagement by Julie Gourley, US senior arctic official, during a visit to Fairbanks was also helpful. At a critical stage in North by 2020 activities, we were fortunate to win as a partner the Inland Northwest Research Alliance (INRA), in particular Executive Director Steve Billingsley and Director of Business and Research Development Fred Sica, who, along with Executive Assistant Michelle Rutledge, provided financial and strategic support for an IPY synthesis symposium hosted by the University of Alaska Fairbanks in March 2009. The support from the International Arctic Research Center (IARC) and Director Larry Hinzman, as well as UAF Chancellor Brian Rogers, has been important in allowing for the production of this volume and for the North by 2020 forum to grow into its next phase. Much of the work reported in this volume builds on the significant commitment that the National Science Foundation, and in particular the Arctic Division of the Office of Polar Programs, made in supporting IPY activities in the North. These funds enabled some of the research that a range of other activities were then able to build on. Numerous individuals were instrumental in bringing this volume to fruition. We are particularly grateful for the editing skills of Tom Alton and the crucial help of Mette Kaufman in pulling together the documents and images that make up this volume. Berill Blair and Nathan Coutsoubos helped organize meetings and prepare documents at key stages of the North by 2020 process. Elisabeth Dabney and Sue Mitchell with the UA Press were extremely helpful in getting this book off the ground. Thanks also to a number of colleagues who provided feedback on earlier drafts of this volume or sections thereof. Maya Salganek and Julie Decker curated the artwork plates introducing each section of this book, and we are grateful for their thoughtfulness and perseverance. With an effort as broad and diverse as this, the circle of those who made it happen is much wider than can be acknowledged here; to all those who helped along the way we are grateful and appreciate your engagement. Amy Lauren Lovecraft (Oslo, Norway) and Hajo Eicken (Fairbanks, Alaska) January 2011
1
A Holistic Approach for a Changing North
Section editors: Amy Lauren Lovecraft and Hajo Eicken
PLATE 001 Tipping Point 2 Jessie Worth Hedden Mixed media on panel 28" x 24" 2008 Photo by James Barker
1.1
Introduction by amy lauren lovecraft
I
n one generation the foundations for life in the Arctic are being transformed. Our volume is an effort to create an integrated inquiry into the social-ecological systems of the Alaska region experiencing rapid changes. The different sections of our volume analyze, illustrate, and discuss aspects of human-environmental systems whose resilience is threatened, in particular through erosion of the services derived from ecosystems supporting life in the North. As a whole, it assembles scholarship across different disciplines and fields of knowledge directed at the question: How can Alaska and the circumpolar North best understand the pitfalls and opportunities of rapid change? Until recently, the answers to this question have tended to come in disciplinary modes. “In most areas of knowledge, science possesses piecemeal (disciplinary) knowledge produced by reductionism, but lacks the overall synthetic understanding of the interactions produced through the application of the holistic approach” (Østreng 2010:14). This volume provides a richer understanding of the effects of environmental change across the Alaska region by assembling scientific data, elder expertise, artistic expression, private-sector experts, and case-study depth in a holistic depiction of the rapidly changing North. Rather than dividing the research by discipline, we have thematically organized our efforts to address social and environmental systems experiencing some of the greatest stressors. The sections are thematically organized by scholarship subject area: (1) social-ecological approach and methods, (2) the knowledge of indigenous peoples, (3) northern freshwater systems, (4) Arctic coastal systems, (5) living marine resources, (6) marine infrastructure and transport, (7) oil and gas development, and (8) artistic expression of climate change. Each explains the social and environmental transformations occurring in the Alaska region from a different set of perspectives. We close with a synthesizing chapter (9) to bring together the major lessons and consider how decision-makers might plan for the 3
4â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
future of the Arctic. Sections are linked by a brief segue to help the reader see the interconnectedness of the different themes. In a book of this breadth we want our readers to have bridges on their journey from which they can see how separate sets of investigations are fundamentally related. Each section has been compiled by one or more editors who are experts in the subject area. They have collected chapters tied to the section subject and written introductions explaining the importance of the research area and how each chapter in it contributes to a clearer, more holistic understanding of the Alaska region. Each section benchmarks the state of their subjects and considers what their futures hold. For example, the section on indigenous knowledge explains the concept of indigenous knowledge, how it relates to the social-ecological systems of the Alaska region, and why it is imperative to maintain it as both a source of vital information and a necessary feature of cultural resilience; the section on the arts focuses on the expressive nature of the social-ecological system, demonstrating how people are grappling to depict the meanings of environmental changes. We conclude with some scenarios for the future of the Alaska region and recommendations we hope can help decision-makers plan for those most affected by these changes. This organization, importantly, more accurately demonstrates dynamics of northern systems because it fosters the synthesis of lessons revealed across specializations rather than narrowly focusing on physical, biological, or social sciences. The first section of this book is designed to contextualize the scope, rationale, and underlying methods of our project. Chapter 1.2 outlines the mandate of the International Polar Year and explains the theoretical and practical underpinnings of our project’s transdisciplinarity in relation to trends in Arctic research. In Chapter 1.3, Walsh et al. explore, in straightforward language, how scenarios of Arctic change are developed. They present an introduction to how scientists measure changes, formulate predictions, and think about uncertainty in the future. Their chapter also primes the reader to consider key attributes that pervade the research of complex systems such as surprise, uncertainty, and feedbacks. Chapter 1.4 then provides a brief case study of wildland fire to illustrate social-ecological system (SES) analysis across scales from global to local.
Reference Østreng, W. 2010. Science without boundaries: Interdisciplinarity in research, society, and politics. New York: University Press of America.
1.2
Transdisciplinary Collaboration in the Fourth International Polar Year: Connecting Studies of Arctic Change across the Sciences and the Arts by amy lauren lovecraft and hajo eicken
T
his edited volume is a response to the vision of the Fourth International Polar Year (IPY-4). It stems from an innovative transdisciplinary project—North by 2020: A Forum for Local and Global Perspectives on the North. The aims of the forum have been twofold: (1) to benchmark what we know about the social-ecological systems of the Alaska region that are most vulnerable to the key drivers of change in the Arctic and (2) to bring this information into substantive discussions about the future of the Far North. We use the phrase “Alaska region” to denote the geographic area that is the focus of our study (see Figure 1.4.4 for a map) but without drawing artificial boundaries at state borderlines because the subjects of our volume themselves (e.g., waterways, peoples, animals, and pollutants) are a part of a vast interconnected circumpolar system. Our latter aim is an ongoing process of enhancing the participation of relevant stakeholders in defining and evaluating research projects alongside the dissemination of knowledge through documents, workshops, and other products and activities. This volume itself has been created through the collaboration of a diverse group of people involved with the North by 2020 forum over the past several years. It showcases and translates the perspectives from scholars, elders, students, and experts from the public and private sectors to provide an overview of several social-ecological systems of major concern in the Alaska region.
5
6â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
The Fourth International Polar Year While global initiatives come and go, IPY-4 has been a powerful force to foster internationally coordinated research, raise awareness, stimulate funding, and showcase both the Arctic and Antarctic as important regions of the globe. It was planned as “an intensive burst of internationally coordinated, interdisciplinary, scientific research and observations” to “exploit the intellectual resources and science assets of nations worldwide to make major advances in polar knowledge and understanding while leaving a legacy of new or enhanced observational systems, facilities and infrastructure” (ICSU 2004:7). The International Polar Year was designated as 2007–2008, but the “official observing period” was March 1, 2007, to March 1, 2009, to capture two full annual cycles of research work at the poles. IPY-4 was significantly different from the three prior in that it not only coordinated research on the physical environment of the polar regions but also included work on the “human dimension.” As one of the six IPY research themes, this one charged researchers “to investigate the cultural, historical, and social processes that shape the sustainability of circumpolar human societies, and to identify their unique contributions to global cultural diversity and citizenship” (ICSU 2004:9). Even as this volume goes to press, the IPY legacy has brought together researchers from across the globe to share data at major international conferences, with another large meeting planned for 2012 in Montreal. It appears that this “burst” has created new research directions, partnerships, debates, and products. From the perspective of Alaska, and the Arctic as a whole, what did the IPY actually charge us to do? Table 1.2.1 demonstrates how the US National Academy of Sciences conceptualized the IPY, and it generally reflects the national plans of other participants as well.
Trends in Arctic Sciences While IPY-4 was planned among nations and international scientific bodies, its execution was largely driven by national and international scientific and professional organizations, universities, and strong contributions from key senior polar researchers and activists. During the last two decades, the conduct of polar research and more generally northern circumpolar research has evolved substantially. These changes have been driven by a shift in the perceived importance of the Arctic by both public and private sectors across the globe. The political relationships present during the International Geophysical Year 1957–1958 have changed radically and a “global environmental problematique” has supplanted the Cold War as the major polar concern (Shadian and Tennberg 2009:2). Concurrent to this geopolitical
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…7 Table 1.2.1. US National Committee’s vision for the Fourth International Polar Year. The U.S. National Committee for IPY, established by the Polar Research Board of the National Academy of Sciences, formulated the vision for U.S. participation in IPY. That vision was articulated in a report called A Vision for the International Polar Year 2007–2008. In the report, the committee identified seven recommendations for the U.S. science community and agencies to address during IPY. The U.S. IPY effort, it said, should: •
Excite and engage the public, with the goals of increasing understanding of the importance of the polar regions in the global system and advancing the nation’s general science literacy.
•
Use IPY to begin a sustained effort to assess large-scale environmental change and variability in the polar regions.
•
Pioneer new polar studies of coupled human–natural systems that are critical to U.S. societal, economic, and strategic interests.
•
Explore new scientific frontiers from the molecular to the planetary scale.
•
Use IPY as an opportunity to design and implement multidisciplinary polar observing networks that will provide a long-term perspective on climate change and other phenomena.
•
Invest in critical physical and human infrastructure and technology to guarantee that IPY leaves a legacy of enduring benefits for the nation and for the residents of northern regions.
•
Encourage researchers to act as leaders in IPY efforts.
Source: Reprinted from http://www.ipy.gov/Default.aspx?tabid=53.
shift is the growth in participation of subnational governments, non-state actors, transnational organizations, and private business in shaping Arctic decision making. Notably, the settlements of land claims and other new agreements with governments by many Arctic indigenous peoples have altered the political-economic geography of the north (Zellen 2009). The production of Arctic knowledge no longer rests solely with governments and the management of Arctic living and nonliving resources has become an international concern. In short, IPY-4 has mirrored “changes in international society and the relationship between science and society” (Nilsson 2009:28). This has affected how scientists choose methodological approaches, consider their research subjects, engage with communities and individuals, and perceive the “problems” of the Arctic. It has also promoted the following general trends in arctic science endeavors:
8â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Multidisciplinarity in methods and research team building. The movement at the US National Science Foundation in the late 1990s to fund interdisciplinary programs stemmed from a realization that students seeking graduate training in the sciences and engineering often did not graduate with a suite of skills diverse enough to prepare them for the “contemporary stresses” of the job market or to engage the complex questions societies face in the future (COSEPUP 1995:75). This dovetailed with universities in the United States that had been adding interdisciplinary programs to their education as part of a growing trend to study environmental policy problems from both social and natural science perspectives. The proliferation of undergraduate environmental studies majors offered at colleges and universities has been one example of this cross-disciplinary movement. Consequently, most American funding agencies have encouraged interdisciplinary teams and approaches to research. In roughly the same time period this trend also developed in Sweden, Norway, and Germany as interdisciplinary programs and centers of research were encouraged and funded (Østreng 2010). While polar research has long enjoyed a tradition of interdisciplinary collaboration, these broader developments have greatly enhanced capacities for collaborative research that spans several disciplines and nations. The need to save on costs in an era of shrinking budgets. The Arctic is a costly location to perform research either on the ground or remotely. Even prior to the economic recessions of the 2000s, the end of the Cold War and the rise of public focus on national spending signaled that the funding for military, research, and other US arctic endeavors might shrink. The Alaska region is one of limited infrastructure and extreme climate. Its land and seascapes challenge people and equipment, creating a need to combine resources and collaborate nationally (e.g., across research centers or agencies) or internationally (e.g., through the shared use of icebreakers and other large-scale research platforms). Formerly marginalized points of view are now being recognized and validated. The Native land claims settlements in Alaska during the 1970s represented a shift in the US executive branch on policies related to indigenous peoples. It meant that rather than being perceived as wards of the state, indigenous people were empowered as stakeholders and citizens. Intertwined with this development has been the growing credibility among scientists of indigenous or local knowledge. In particular, in Alaska, indigenous ways of understanding snow, ice, weather, and ecosystems have started to inform many research projects. Across circumpolar nations rural communities and individuals have become partners in designing projects, researching the changes witnessed, and participating in governance. On the international stage, transnational organizations of indigenous peoples have
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…9
become active in Arctic making. For example, the Inuit Circumpolar Council and the Saami Council both hold the status of Permanent Participant on the Arctic Council. Increasing political and public attention is being given to the Arctic. While the International Polar Year has been enveloped in this trend toward public attention, it has also stemmed from, on the one hand, the centuries-old fascination with the Alaska frontier and, on the other, the new opportunities for hydrocarbon exploitation and shipping across the top of the world. Both are strongly affected by technological advances and a diminished sea ice cover. They also bring in to sharp focus the arctic nations’ concerns related to national boundaries. Recent continental shelf exploration and bilateral agreements indicate that Russia, Canada, and the United States are particularly keen on determining borders. This greater scrutiny popularizes arctic issues, such as the adoption by southern populations in the United States and Canada of the polar bear as a hallmark of climate change. Greater scrutiny may also place undue stresses on local arctic populations already grappling with the multiple dimensions of change on the ground. Climate change is faster at the poles, and, as the Arctic changes, surprises will arise. As the Arctic Climate Impact Assessment (ACIA 2004) and other scientific findings have demonstrated, changes will be comparatively rapid in the North. As ecosystem functions shift, there is a great deal of uncertainty related to what will happen to freshwater systems, forests, marine ecosystems, and other key aspects of the natural world. Complexity science indicates that unexpected or surprising developments are key features of complex systems. Thus researchers and stakeholders have to predict, creatively imagine, and plan for new future states of the circumpolar North that may have seemed improbable, if not impossible, a few decades ago. New technologies and advanced knowledge have expanded the scope of research to include complexity and extend across all relevant scales. Innovative instrumentation and satellite remote sensing technologies have provided scientists with unprecedented breadth and depth of data coverage, often in real time. But there has also been the recognition, in part due to the new capabilities of measurement and new scientific theories of ecosystems, that the Far North is not a “wasteland” but a highly productive and vital feature of global ecological and climate processes. These twin forces improve understanding of the Arctic as a whole while also allowing those affected by change to respond in more effective ways to adapt to or benefit from such change.
10â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
These interrelated trends, when considered together, have pushed arctic researchers, at their best, into a new frontier where cross-disciplinary teamwork is the norm; where indigenous peoples are partners in helping to define and execute research projects; and where the results have an impact on a global audience. In such an era, highlighted by the worldwide participation in the International Polar Year, it is vital to foster legacies from collaboration that engage multiple viewpoints and generate useful, holistic sets of information that can help society and individuals cope with change.
A Response from Alaska: The North by 2020 Forum as a “Bottom-up” Approach to Advance Transdisciplinary Arctic Research Considering the growing momentum of the Fourth International Polar Year, the North by 2020 forum was formed by educators and researchers across all of the University of Alaska campuses in 2006 to explore, discuss, plan, and prepare opportunities for sustainable development in a North experiencing rapid transformation. While many definitions exist for collaborative work across disciplines, the concept of “transdisciplinarity” has come to define “transcending the boundary between the academe and stakeholder expertise” where the “nature and characteristics of scientific knowledge as we know it” can be produced by attention to “real world problems”; in partnership “with a wide range of stakeholder expertise representing a raft of conflicting needs, interests, and values”; and through a research process “based on deliberative strategic planning” (Østreng 2010:29–31). As such, North by 2020 was designed to facilitate research and learning across academic disciplinary boundaries to address the stakeholder concerns surrounding northern futures while at the same time engaging public, private, and government experts. In this context, it greatly helped that many scientists at the University of Alaska were successful in obtaining substantial research support from the National Science Foundation to help build the US Arctic Observing Network (AON). The AON represented a major US contribution to the IPY and was conceived as a broad interagency effort directed at both answering key scientific questions and serving the needs of society and key stakeholders (IARPC 2007). Out of an initial thirty-four funded projects, University of Alaska researchers were leading five and were involved in a total of eleven projects, spanning the entire breadth of disciplines. The foundation upon which the North by 2020 forum was built drew in part from these projects. While hosted by the University of Alaska and led primarily by research scholars, the forum has been open to a variety of participants due to its structure. To
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…11
facilitate the exploration of critical areas of change in the Alaska region, it sought to engage researchers and their stakeholders thematically. Rather than in a top-down process where rigid research agendas were determined and participants solicited, the forum built itself around existing networks of researchers and their projects to develop a common set of lessons about rapid change in vulnerable systems and the capacity of these systems to adapt to such change. One could consider the forum’s mission as tied both to the development of research deliverables and to transdisciplinary modes of inquiry and communication. Our driving question also speaks to the IPY as an opportunity to reflect on how science works: How do researchers collect data in meaningful ways to analyze and communicate the interconnected transformations being experienced in the Alaska region and the Far North more generally? The recognition that transformations of human and environmental systems are inherently interrelated has been the broad starting point for the North by 2020 researchers. The key drivers of change across the circumpolar North can be generally explained across four dimensions. First, there are regime shifts in climate and the environment that are about to exceed the range of past variability and change. This means that new ways of understanding will have to arise to meet the challenges of unpredicted qualities in our natural world. Second, there is an increasing interdependence between the Arctic region and global processes. This is a social characteristic due to technology that permits products of the Far North to reach global markets, and it brings distant ideas and practices to a region until recently isolated from much of the rest of the world. It is also an environmental phenomenon as science demonstrates the vital role the northern oceans, ice bodies, and atmosphere play in climate, weather, and biophysical patterns across the globe. Third, the combination of rapid technological development, the end of the Cold War, changing structures of governance related to indigenous peoples, and rapid changes in ecosystem functioning has sweeping impacts on northern populations and cultures. This can be seen in both rural and urban areas of the circumpolar North, where patterns of subsistence and travel tied to snow and ice are no longer reliable and infrastructure maintenance grows more costly. Fourth, and often popularized in the media, there is an expansion of global geopolitical and economic interests into the North. This is largely due to the potential for hydrocarbon exploitation, but it also relates to the development of marine shipping, tourism opportunities, and national views about boundary security, species protection, and citizen identity. With such a broad set of transformations, an equally broad approach was needed to capture, at a minimum, key responses to these drivers. This edited volume explores the vulnerability, resilience, and adaptation of people and their environments in the Alaska region. Our work demonstrates the importance of the Far North in the broader efforts of scientists to assess large-scale environmental change and variability at the poles. A changing climate is altering fundamental
12â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
geophysical and biological features of life in the Arctic. Simultaneously, socialeconomic pressures are shifting the way in which societies perceive and use their natural surroundings. In and around Alaska’s coastal regions, this set of dual pressures is particularly intense. Diminishing sea ice, increased economic interests in developing renewable and nonrenewable resources, debate over the role of protected animals and habitats, and increasing threats to indigenous peoples’ ways of living have all resulted in intense pressure on an area of the earth that is highly vulnerable to change. The capacity for the Arctic and its peoples to be resilient in the face of adversity is evident from the centuries in which this social-ecological system has provided conditions from which humans have derived benefits. But in the twenty-first century, the environment of the circumpolar North has begun to transform to the extent that even some adaptive capacity may be threatened. Now, our work contributes to a strategic human interest: further understanding of the current functioning and human uses of ecosystems and landscapes in the Alaska region and sketching out scenarios that describe plausible changes anticipated over the next decade or two to foster creative adaptation in a changing North.
Methodological Approach In March 2009, the University of Alaska Fairbanks was host to a multidisciplinary symposium, “Lessons from Continuity and Change in the Fourth International Polar Year.” The purpose of the symposium was to present initial results from IPY research and provide an integrative forum for cross-disciplinary communication (http://institute.inra.org/ipy/). The keynote speaker was Nobel Prize winner Dr. Murray Gell-Mann. His public lecture focused on how the tendency to compartmentalize research can produce skewed results because in complex systems an additive approach to individual features of a system will not explain the transformative behavior of the whole. He suggests that such specialized studies be complemented with a “Crude Look at the Whole.” In a recent book considering sustainability he writes, A great deal of research and teaching in the sciences and the humanities, especially at universities, is confined to individual departments representing particular fields of knowledge. While specialization and sub-specialization are inevitable and necessary, they need to be supplemented by research and teaching that transcend somewhat narrow disciplinary boundaries. .╯.╯. In considering a very complex system, we tend to break it up into more manageable parts or aspects and to study these more
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…13
or less separately.╯.╯. . The difficulty is that any attempt to understand a nonlinear system, especially a complex one, by assembling various parts or aspects will only work if those parts or aspects interact weakly, so that the whole system is decomposable. But that is not true of the world problematique. In that sense there is truth in the old adage that the whole is more than the sum of its parts. .╯.╯. What we need, then, is not just detailed work on separate issues, but also the efforts of teams of brilliant thinkers, many of them specialists, devoted to considering the “whole ball of wax.” It can, of course, be argued that this is too big a job for any single group of people, no matter how talented or erudite. This is true. Of course such an ambitious aim can be accomplished only crudely, and that is why I refer to it as taking a “Crude Look at the Whole” (CLAW). (Gell-Mann 2010:2–3) This is the approach our book takes. We cannot present every system in its entirety nor touch comprehensively on all the aspects of the Alaska region facing rapid change. Rather, we provide insight, evidence, art, and firsthand accounts related to these changes so that the reader can gain a more holistic understanding of the challenges and opportunities facing Alaska and the circumpolar North more generally. We have, however, hoped to reduce the crudeness of our presentation by taking a research approach grounded in the growing field of social-ecological systems study.
Studying Social-Ecological Systems: Definitions and Methods The phrase “social-ecological system” (SES) has evolved primarily from ecology and policy literatures. It draws on the concept of human–environment coupled systems where a researcher seeks to examine both the support of a society by its environment and how the society concurrently acts to affect its environment (Anderies et al. 2004; Berkes and Folke 1998; Chapin et al. 2009; Lovecraft 2008). This realm of linkage between the two spheres is dynamic and complex, and it may display emergent properties. By dynamic, it is understood that any SES contains ongoing feedback loops between people and the natural world and a change in one sphere can affect others even across scales of action (Scheffer 2009). The characteristic of complexity means that social-ecological systems tend to behave as systems, assemblages of parts that interact and thereby form a unitary whole. One cannot
14â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
understand them by taking apart the pieces and analyzing them in an additive fashion. Instead, the organizational qualities and equilibria are dependent on suites of factors whose behavior is inherently affected by other factors in the system (Kay et al. 1999). Lastly, the concept of emergence relates to the capacity of a system to produce novel and coherent structures, patterns, and properties during the process of self-organization within a system (Corning 2002). For SESs, this feature has two fundamental implications. First, these systems cannot be reduced to a set of composite properties that can deterministically foretell all possible outcomes— thus surprises, or unintended consequences, can and do arise (Gunderson 2003). Second, since any SES also contains people who have agency and hold values, the structures, patterns, and properties of any given SES are products of creative coconstructive forces imbued with deep cultural meanings whose expression (e.g., artistic, managerial, spiritual) is itself a vital variable in the functioning of the system and which some notable scientists even regard as an indication of the sacred (Kauffman 2008). While these qualities may make research of SESs appear daunting, one can take a location, for example, Alaska, and begin to understand it through examining subsets of a social-ecological system. In other words, we know that the climate is changing, and we have evidence of the different ways these changes are borne out across the ecology of land and seascapes, in weather patterns, in geophysical features, and the perceptions of those who live there. Given these changes, how might different coupled human–environmental systems respond? What might these responses mean to future human actions (e.g., policy planning, cultural adaptations) and environmental qualities (e.g., seal populations, forestation)? To answer such questions, North by 2020 was designed as a transdisciplinary forum so that many different properties of SESs could be examined and shared across methodological boundaries. Through the support of the University of Alaska and other sponsors, we were able to use some seed money and heavy advertising among a wide group of colleagues to bring together natural, physical, and social scientists working on similar problems but from different points of view. What emerged was a subset of systems that, while not comprehensive of the entire Alaska SES (something beyond the scope of perhaps any book), are facing rapid changes now and whose changes will affect the lives of people both residing in them and dependent on them from a distance. The final presentation of SESs for this volume has been deliberative. The major thread tying the thematic sections together is the cryosphere. The word has its root in the ancient Greek word “kryos,” referring to cold or frost. In modern parlance, it refers to all the locations on the planet where water is in its solid form either above ground as freshwater ice or sea ice, glaciers, and snow or below ground as permafrost. As Sections 3 and 4 demonstrate, it is exactly this feature of the Earth that
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…15
is most rapidly changing. Questions related to the timing and amount of snowfall, how long rivers stay frozen, at what depth and over what regions one finds permafrost, and to what extent the sea ice cover is thinning and shrinking are bound up together, and the answers to each figure prominently in the lives of Alaskans and the future of their state. The cryosphere is central to Alaska’s fresh water in the Interior, the coastal regions, and the marine areas surrounding the state. It is a physical phenomenon that has social impacts far beyond simply providing locations and services of value to people. The changing cryosphere affects economic, political, and spiritual dimensions of people’s lives. These changes have social implications because of the tight interrelationship between people and their environments in the North. This is true not only of the Native Alaska peoples but also of those whose livelihoods are tied to natural resource exploitation. It is true of municipalities and homeowners who face new challenges to building and living across a state with permafrost. The changes in these systems affect the ways people communicate, not only in the language they use to describe their environment and relationship to it but also in visual communication of art and dance. As society wrestles with how to understand changing cultural patterns, the arts reflect this challenge. We view the humanities perspectives in the final section of our volume that highlight expressions in the arts as a key component of explaining northern change. The research of social-ecological systems is a complex task. It has required most of the North by 2020 participants to consider methods and approaches outside of their own disciplinary training, to look beyond a single location or geographic boundary, and to take a long-term perspective on what the changes and responses discovered mean for Alaska and its inhabitants. Tied to the concept of presenting our readers with both social and ecological research has been the desire to present multiple standpoints. We wished to present “less partial and distorted accounts of the entire social order” and to provide “a causal, critical account of regularities of the natural and social worlds and their underlying causal tendencies” (Harding 1992:583). In other words, diversity of methods and standpoints presents a more genuine depiction of reality in the Alaska regions tied to cryospheric changes than any single perspective could. Based on this belief, we have analyzed the systems in this volume, divided for readability into thematic sections, through diverse methods. We have intentionally brought together a broad range of expertise to explain what is happening in the Arctic and what it means for the people who live, work, and play in and simply hold dear the Alaska region. Our goal in this text is to present a picture of the Alaska region that is rich—rooted in empirical evidence, depicted through multiple perspectives, and not devoid of values. This text focuses on a slice of the most vulnerable aspects of Alaska, and it contextualizes them in terms of the entire circumpolar North. We hope our readers understand that the text does not simply
16â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
set up current characteristics of Arctic change; it also poses potential futures for the region and proposes how individuals, governments, and private industry might set priorities for the near- and long-term future that can enhance arctic resilience. There are naturally a couple of caveats. First, while North by 2020 as a forum covered subjects beyond those represented in this book, for the sake of manageability we have narrowed our presentation to the key sets of findings of each research group, as defined by their themes (e.g., living marine resources, freshwater systems). Second, our goal is not to present any particular political or policy strategy but to highlight the major opportunities and problems that need to be addressed by the year 2020. We sincerely hope to promote communication and facilitate strategizing across public and private sectors so that stakeholders tied to these systems can become aware and active in planning their own futures—futures that can sustain the valuable properties of arctic ecosystems and cultures. We would like our work to serve as a call to active engagement, debate, discussion, and participation. Another hope is that this book will demonstrate an effort at transdiciplinary research in a changing Arctic, not only in its contents but also in its research approach to the subject. As a final, perhaps more personal, comment, it is the view of the editors that meaningful research cannot sit in bins on shelves or speak only to narrow audiences. As such, researchers must be willing to invest time in translating their data into a meaningful discourse that can accurately represent the complexity of socialecological systems as dynamic bounded units, themselves changing, and nested within a global system that also changes. We believe that the public university has an important role to play, both in helping society bring into focus plausible scenarios of future developments and by making findings from research, such as that of IPY-4, accessible to stakeholders and the public at large. It is our desire that this volume can serve to help facilitate participatory engagement across and outside of the university system. It is possible that disciplined yet imaginative speculation about the longer-term future can be of some help seizing opportunities and in avoiding some of the worst catastrophes. But in thinking about the future let us take seriously the idea of a “Crude Look at the Whole.” (Gell-Mann 2010:7)
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…17
References Anderies, J. M., M. A. Janssen, and E. Ostrom. 2004. A framework to analyze the robustness of social-ecological systems from an institutional perspective. Ecology and Society 9(1), 18. Arctic Climate Impact Assessment (ACIA). 2004. Impacts of a warming Arctic: Arctic climate impact assessment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Berkes, F., and C. Folke (eds.). 1998. Linking social and ecological systems: Management practices and social mechanisms for building resilience. New York: Cambridge University Press. Chapin, S. F., C. Folke, and G. P. Kofinas. 2009. A framework for understanding change. In Principles of ecosystem stewardship: Resilience–based natural resource management in a changing world. Edited by S. F. Chapin, G. P. Kofinas, and C. Folke. New York: Springer. Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy (COSEPUP). 1995. Reshaping the graduate education of scientists and engineers. Washington DC: The National Academies Press. Corning, P. A. 2002. The re-emergence of “emergence”: A venerable concept in search of a theory. Complexity 7(6), 18–30. Gell-Mann, M. 2010. Transformations of the twenty-first century: Transitions to greater sustainability. In Global sustainability: A Nobel cause. Edited by H. J. Schellnhuber, M. Molina, N. Stern, V. Huber, and S. Kadner. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gunderson, L. H. 2003. Adaptive dancing: Interactions between social resilience and ecological crises. In Navigating social-ecological systems: Building resilience for complexity and change. Edited by F. Berkes, J. Colding, and C. Folke. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Harding, S. 1992. After the neutrality ideal: Science, politics, and strong objectivity. Social Research 59(3), 567–587. ICSU IPY 2007–2008 Planning Group. 2004. A framework for the International Polar Year 2007–2008. International Council for Science. Interagency Arctic Policy Research Committee (IARPC). 2007. Arctic Observing Network (AON): Toward a US contribution to pan-arctic observing. Arctic Research of the U.S., 21, 1–94. Kauffman, S. A. 2008. Reinventing the sacred: A new view of science, reason, and religion. New York: Basic Books. Kay, J. J., H. Reigier, M. Boyle, and G. R. Francis. 1999. An ecosystem approach for sustainability: Addressing the challenge of complexity. Futures 31(7), 721–742. Lovecraft, A. L. 2008. Climate change and arctic cases: A normative exploration of socialecological system analysis. In Political theory and global climate change. Edited by Steve Vanderheiden. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
18â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Nilsson, A. E. 2009. A changing Arctic climate: More than just weather. In Legacies and change in polar sciences: Historical, legal, and political reflections on the international polar year. Edited by J. M. Shadian and M. Tennberg. Burlington, VT: Ashgate. Østreng, W. 2010. Science without boundaries: Interdisciplinarity in research, society, and politics. New York: University Press of America. Scheffer, M. 2009. Critical transitions in nature and society. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Shadian, J., and M. Tennberg. 2009. Introduction. In Legacies and change in polar sciences: Historical, legal, and political reflections on the international polar year. Edited by J. M. Shadian and M. Tennberg. Burlington, VT: Ashgate. Zellen, B. 2009. Arctic doom, Arctic boom: The geopolitics of climate change in the Arctic. Denver, CO: Praeger.
1.3
Scenarios as a Tool to Understand and Respond to Change by john e. walsh, marc mueller-stoffels, and peter h. larsen
A
book addressing anticipated changes over the next few decades faces a fundamental conundrum. On one hand, communities, planners, and decision-makers demand more detailed and robust information about the future of social-ecological systems of Alaska and the North. On the other hand, various uncertainties are inherent in predictions about the future. There is an emerging need to address these uncertainties in a rigorous manner, while enabling planners and other decision-makers to continue to make decisions about the future despite these uncertainties. Subsequent sections will provide examples of how this is being done in particular cases. In the first part of this chapter, we will set the stage by introducing the concepts of scenarios, projections, and uncertainties, with an emphasis on the roles of linked uncertainty when attempting to model entire systems. Because this volume addresses a suite of interactive changes across high latitudes, it is appropriate to illustrate these concepts with examples from the realms of climate modeling and integrated assessment modeling. These two realms of application are the subjects of the second and third parts of this chapter. An overall thrust is the cascade of uncertainty through a predictive system that encompasses economic and ecological components as well as physical drivers. While the key concepts are described in detail in the following sections, we preface this discussion with the essential distinctions between the major tools that pertain to information about the future. Scenarios are essentially a collective set of assumptions about possible futures, intended to give the decision-maker a strategy-planning framework. A projection is a prediction, usually limited to part of an overall system, that is based on—and hence contingent on—a particular scenario or suite of scenarios that includes the factors expected to influence that part of
19
20â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
the system for which future information is desired. A prediction is a forecast of the future without regard to contingencies. We now provide background and examples for each of these concepts, and we show how uncertainty is an essential consideration in their use as tools that can connect researchers to planners and to others who must make decisions based on anticipated trajectories of social-ecological changes in the North. As noted in the synopsis and in the case studies of the following chapters, the uncertainties are generally of sufficient magnitude that projections (or predictions) are, in some respects, reduced to speculation on the near and especially the long-term future. Nevertheless, the available information is often the best guidance to provide continuity amid change and to foster creative adaptation.
Introduction to Scenarios If we think of the world around us as a system with many driving factors, interactions, and feedbacks, then it should not come as a surprise that a comprehensive and precise forecasting of the future state of this entire system is not feasible. Furthermore, even if we were able to understand and model all driving factors, interactions, and feedbacks correctly, such a model would exhibit a host of nonlinearities, which can cause strong divergence of model runs with similar parameters. This makes the model outcome sensitive to initial conditions, such as measurements (e.g., data collected in the field) and extrapolation (e.g., data supplied by other models). For example, state-of-the-art weather forecast models require a certain number of field stations and remote sensors gathering current weather data to give accurate regional and local long-term forecasts. Even the smallest error in the current state will grow as the forecast evolves, and some such errors are unavoidable. Thus, there is always a source of error, which will lead to uncertainty, even if the model producing the forecast were perfect. And since we are far from being able to create perfect models, the sources for uncertainties in model outcome are numerous. However, this chapter is not meant to discount such modeling approaches as they are the current state of the art in forecasting, and are constantly being improved. Nonetheless, the levels of uncertainty and inter-model divergences with increasing time-spans and levels of complexity should be troubling for any decision-maker who has to plan for the future based on such data. This is where scenarios are a useful and powerful tool; they can give us images of possible futures and, thus, a strategic planning framework. Scenarios are used in a variety of contexts in our daily lives. The simplest scenario is an “if-then” type exploration of possible futures (e.g., “if the blizzard ceases, then we can get on the ice for some measurements”). At a higher level of sophistication, we use scenarios to prepare for (usually) worst-case incidents. For example,
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…21
each fire drill is a worst-case scenario played out to prepare for the actual event. The above examples display a single-event planning strategy, which is just fine for a small disaster drill or for daydreaming. However, scenarios, properly developed and used, can be a much more powerful tool in situations where the decision-making process is marred by numerous uncertainties. Here scenarios are images of plausible futures, intended to give the decision-maker a strategy-planning framework. Unlike forecasts, scenarios are never intended to draw an accurate picture of the future, but to allow for nonlinear developments and diversity where a forecast’s uncertainty prohibits sound strategy planning. Thus scenario planning provides a framework for what if-ing that stresses the importance of multiple views of the future in exchanging information about uncertainty among parties to a decision (Lempert et al. 2003). This process of what if-ing should be oriented on plausible developments. However, “outside the box thinking” is necessary to prepare decision-makers for the possibility of nonlinear and otherwise surprising developments. Only by doing so will decision-makers be able to develop flexible strategies. Scenarios can be developed at any level of resolution. That is, one can develop coarse-grained global scenarios all the way to fine-grained specific scenarios. Coarsegrained scenarios encompass large systems, such as the key elements of the global economy, or scenarios reaching far (more than twenty years) into the future. Finegrained scenarios can be detailed but hence will be limited to small systems (e.g., spatial) scales or short-term scenarios (e.g., three to five years in the future). The general approach in scenario management is to provide three to five scenarios tailored to the field in question. Usually some global keystones of development, such as economic growth, are included in such a study. However, one can build multileveled scenarios, that is, develop a global scenario framework and incorporate more specific scenarios into it. This approach is especially useful if one plans to develop specific scenarios for different fields as these will still all exist in the same global setting. This works, as long as a specific field is not likely to strongly influence global development. For example, if one were to develop specific scenarios for a regionally confined ecosystem, then this ecosystem’s development will strongly depend on the development of the global climate, but not vice versa. On the other hand, if one were to develop scenarios for the Arctic, including a militarization of the region, then there could be strong interaction and feedback with a seemingly coarser factor such as global economic growth. Time frames for scenarios vary. However, in a futures studies setting, scenarios for fewer than five years into the future are rare. There are several reasons for this: (1) for shorter time spans, uncertainties in forecasts are often manageable; (2) in a corporate setting, short-term (i.e., up to three years) planning is usually dictated by the financial plan. On the other end of the spectrum, scenario time frames are
22â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
theoretically open ended. However, it is questionable how useful a set of scenarios with a long time frame is, as the amount of disruptive and unanticipated events in the actual development will increase with the length of the time span considered. Aforementioned disruptive and unanticipated events are a common problem both in forecasting and scenario building. However, they are intrinsic to the way the future unfolds. One possible way to sharpen the eye of decision-makers to such events is to include Wild Cards (Steinmüller and Steinmüller 2004) into scenarios. Wild Cards are low probability, high impact events that can radically change the future development. In a global setting a Wild Card could be, for example, a war over resources in the Arctic. At the corporate level this could be the discovery of a different use for a specific product, catapulting it from niche to mass-market. Clearly, while one can try to incorporate plausible Wild Cards into a set of scenarios, it is the implausible and “unforeseeable” events that make this practice necessary in the first place. Thus, it is important to point out to the scenario user to only take given Wild Cards as examples of a broader problem requiring flexibility in strategy development. While one scenario itself will describe a possible future, a set of scenarios spans a space of possible futures. The actual future might be a hybrid between two or more scenarios. Thus it is important that the scenario writer, as well as the scenario user, think of and search for early indicators that will help identify which of the scenarios the actual development is headed toward. Only by doing so can strategies be revised and, if necessary, changed as an early indicator suggests a change in direction of the current development toward a different scenario. An example of an early indicator in Scenarios for Arctic Maritime Transportation by 2030 (MuellerStoffels and Eicken 2009) is the announcement by the Russian government to deploy an “Arctic Force.” This could indicate a further tensioning in relations of the Arctic’s littoral states, favoring the worst-case scenario. Scenarios as a strategy-planning framework can be further classified into normative and explorative scenarios. This distinction is related to the method employed in arriving at a set of scenarios. Normative scenarios are written by an informed author, for example, a person who is likely to be able to anticipate possible future developments in the field in question from experience, sometimes in conjunction with a futurist and after a brainstorming workshop with colleagues. Explorative scenarios are based on extensive research into the field in question, an analysis of interactions between the main drivers of development in this field and a model, usually software aided, of how to weigh such interactions. The aim here is to reduce the bias that individuals, especially experts in a field, bring to the process. This can be achieved by studying interactions one by one, while setting the view of the greater picture aside. The amount of different explorative methods is vast, and describing them all is well beyond the scope of this short overview. The interested reader may
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…23
consult J. C. Glenn and T. J. Gordon’s book Futures Research Methodology Version 3.0 (Glenn and Gordon 2009), which gives the most comprehensive overview about futures studies methods publicly available. In the following, we will only discuss explorative scenario methods. In the section on projections and uncertainties, the global climate model projections will be based on greenhouse gas scenarios developed by exploratory scenario methods (IPCC 2001a). The key to a successful explorative scenario process is a well-defined research question, which will include a time frame (how far into the future), the level of resolution, the specific field in question, and the intended use of the scenarios. The clear definition of this research question is crucial as the next step is extensive research into the key factors driving and defining the field under investigation.1 If a research question is vague or changed at a later point, much time can be wasted on researching irrelevant key factors or going too far into detail on less significant factors. Often the key factors are determined in a workshop of experts of the various aspects of the field in question and significant stakeholders, guided by a futurist. Here the goal of the futurist is to stimulate the group of experts and stakeholders to discuss what, in their opinion, are the important key factors, and to articulate their reasoning. The product of such a workshop should be a list of key factors ranked by the group by their perceived importance. Depending on the intended project size, and the desired resolution, the top ten to thirty-five key factors (more are possible but result in large amounts of data) are then intensively researched. The two questions here are (1) How does the key factor relate to the field? and (2) What are its possible future projections, that is, in which direction could it evolve? For example, in scenarios for the Arctic the “Extent of summer sea ice” is likely to be a key factor, with future projections “higher extent,” “constant extent,” “low extent,” and “no sea ice,” or many others depending on scope, region, and time frame. The point is to arrive at well-defined key factors and future projections. While the overarching goal for all explorative scenario methods is to generate scenarios that are self-consistent and more or less plausible, a multitude of methods exists. Each has strengths and weaknesses (Glenn and Gordon 2009). One such method is the Consistency and Robustness analysis (Gausemeier et al. 1996; Mueller-Stoffels et al. 2009). In this analysis, key factors driving the development of the field under consideration are identified. Each key factor is assigned several future projections (i.e., ways in which it could develop in the future). Each future projection is assigned a plausibility value. In general, any combination of future projections of the different key factors represents a possible future. However, some of these possible futures contain future projections that are inconsistent with each other. To rule out such inconsistencies, each future projection of a key factor has to be compared with all future projections of the other key factors and their pair-wise
24â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
consistency determined. From the resulting matrix, consistent future projection bundles (raw scenarios) can be calculated. Furthermore, the respective plausibilities of the future projections contained in a raw scenario are combined into a cumulative plausibility. And a raw scenario is said to be robust if it has both a high consistency value and a high plausibility. Raw scenarios with inconsistencies are rejected. For example, “Creation of wealth with low interference” in the Arctic’s Native peoples’ lifestyles is completely inconsistent with an “Armed conflict” in the region. Thus a scenario containing both these key factors is inconsistent and implausible and would thus be discarded. From the usually large set of raw scenarios, the futurist selects three to five for the final scenario writing. These raw scenarios should be as diverse as possible to give a broad range of final scenarios. A well-written scenario will be a concise description of a possible future. It is not useful to give drawn-out descriptions of the state of affairs in this future because scenarios are meant to stimulate the reader to think about the possible future himself or herself. Thus it is best to leave space for the reader to fill in the blanks. If Wild Cards are included in the scenario process, some consideration should be given to the robustness of the scenario under the occurrence of a Wild Card. For example, a scenario stating that the arctic region is managed under a unilateral treaty system would break down under the occurrence of the Wild Card “War over resources in the arctic region.”
Why Use Scenarios to Plan for the Future and Not the Best Possible and Available Forecast? While reliable forecasting is more desirable than scenarios, it usually is unavailable on a holistic scale. Furthermore, divergence between different models is a problem, and it often cannot be determined objectively which of two diverging models is better. In the following section, we address this issue with climate models. These problems can be overcome by using a scenario process that incorporates forecasting results for subsystems. This means model divergence can actually become a useful tool because the results from two or more diverging models just mean different future projections to a key factor. For example, predictions of sea ice extent in the arctic basin for this century range from “no more summer sea ice in twenty years” to “unchanged ice extent.” Thus the different forecasts, all results of scientific modeling, can be used as future projections of the key factor “Summer sea ice extent” and one can apply plausibility values related to the confidence/uncertainty given by the respective modelers or reviews by the community. Such a practice will ensure that scenarios are built on reliable, scientifically sound knowledge of subsystems (fine graining), while possible developments of the big picture are made available (coarse graining). Decision-makers will thus be given a useful planning tool, which
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…25
can be refined as more reliable forecasts become available. Explorative scenarios and forecasting do not contradict each other but are supplemental parts integral to supplying decision-makers with a reliable basis for strategic planning. Explorative scenarios are a relatively inexpensive way to incorporate forecasts for subsystems into a holistic overview of the complete system. They are meant to stimulate thinking about the future and enhance strategic planning capabilities. Furthermore, an open scenario process that includes many stakeholders can be useful in sparking discussions about shaping a future that is desirable to all, thus allowing the implementation of joint efforts of stakeholders to arrive at such a future. Our knowledge of the “real world” is incomplete, and thus any forecast carries uncertainties. Such uncertainties are intrinsic in the way our description of the world works. However, uncertainties are problematic to the process of strategic planning. Supplying decision-makers with a set of scenarios based on divergent, but plausible, forecasts enhances the ability for sound strategic planning under uncertain circumstances. Such scenarios can and should be refined and strategies adjusted as better forecasts become available. In the following sections, we address the uncertainties inherent in two components of the strategic planning enterprise. First, we highlight uncertainties in the global climate model projections. Second, we examine uncertainties in integrated assessment models that are driven by climate and other factors.
Projections and Uncertainties: The Climate Model Example Global climate models are the most widely used tools for projections of climate change over the time scale of a century. These models are mathematical representations of the physical and dynamical principles that govern the behavior of the atmosphere, ocean, sea ice, and land surface (Washington and Parkinson 2005). These models are essentially the same formulations used in numerical weather predictions, although the starting point of the forecast is less critical for simulations of climate than for weather forecasts. While these models are the best tools available for predictions of climate over time scales of decades to centuries, their predictions are far from perfect, so their predictions are highly uncertain. The reason for the uncertainty is the subject of this chapter; examples of the consequences of the uncertainties are presented in the next chapter and throughout the book. There are three main sources of uncertainty in the use of global climate models (GCMs) for climate projections: natural variability (the chaotic component of climate), the range of possible future greenhouse gas emissions scenarios, and differences among the models’ formulations. First, it is known that if climate models are run several times with slightly different starting conditions, the different
26â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
predictions will have different timing of events, even though the underlying statistical character (mean, variance, etc.) of the “model climate” tends to be similar for each run. Figure 1.3.1 illustrates this behavior in terms of the Arctic’s area-averaged temperature simulated by a set of climate models over the twentieth century; the figure also shows the corresponding curve for the actual climate of the twentieth century. While many models capture the statistics of temporal variability with reasonable fidelity, the timing of the warm and cool periods clearly differs among models. This variability is a feature of the climate system, and users of climate projections must recognize its importance. As noted in the first section, it arises from the tendency for small differences in initial conditions to grow over time through various scales of atmospheric instabilities, and it is closely related to the limits (two to three weeks) on deterministic predictability of day-to-day weather. Such behavior has received considerable attention under the umbrella of “chaos” in the atmospheric circulation. This type of uncertainty can affect yearly, decadal, or even longer means, so it is highly relevant to the use of model-derived climate projections. To reduce this uncertainty, one may average the projections over decades or, preferably, form averages from a set (ensemble) of at least several model runs. Such a procedure can help separate the anthropogenic contribution to climate change
Figure 1.3.1. Arctic surface air temperatures averaged over 60–90°N as simulated by different climate models (thin colored lines). Model output is from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project, CMIP3. The solid black line shows observed values. All time series are five-year running means. From Wang et al. (2007).
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…27
from the natural variability. However, averaging of model simulations tends to reduce the extremes that are present in any individual simulation. Loss of the extremes is undesirable if one is interested in the possible changes in the exceedence of thresholds or the occurrence of extreme states, which can result from a trend due to external (e.g., anthropogenic) effects combined with an episodic event due to natural climate variability. While a single model simulation has a chance to capture the statistics of extreme events, a drawback from considering only a single model run rather than an average of several model runs is that the natural variability component obscures the influence of anthropogenically caused changes such as greenhouse warming. In short, it is important to recognize the lack of predictability in the timing of variations, ranging from extreme weather events to decadal anomalies, in climate model simulations, while at the same time realizing that these variations may be superimposed on a slower long-term trend.
Figure 1.3.2. Arctic (60–90°N) surface air temperatures simulated by IPCC AR4 climate models for the twentieth century with historical greenhouse gas and aerosol concentrations (black symbols) and the twentyfirst century based three greenhouse scenarios: A2 (red), A1B (green), and B1 (blue). Different models are distinguished by letters (from Walsh and Chapman 2007).
28â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
A second source of uncertainty arises from the range in plausible emissions scenarios. Greenhouse gas emission and concentration scenarios are developed based on assumptions for future greenhouse technologies, economic activity, and societal responses (IPCC 2001a). These scenarios were obtained through the exploratory scenario method. They are used to drive the Atmosphere-Ocean General Circulation Models by specifying future greenhouse gas and aerosol concentrations in the models. An example is the use of several scenarios of anthropogenic forcing (greenhouse gases, aerosols) in the most recent Climate Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP3) and summarized in the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC 2007). Most of the CMIP3 models have made projections under the emissions scenarios denoted as A2 (rapid increases in greenhouse gases), A1B (moderate increases), and B1 (slower increases). Because greenhouse gas concentrations in the emission scenarios differ by only small amounts through 2050, climate projections are relatively insensitive to the precise details of which future emissions scenarios are used over the next few decades. For the second half of the twenty-first century, however, and especially by 2100, the choice of the emission scenario becomes a major source of uncertainty of climate projections (IPCC 2007), as shown in Figure 1.3.2. When 2010–2050 is the time frame of interest, future climate assessments often use a single middle range anthropogenic emission increase scenario, the SRES A1B or A1B, and A2 together to increase the number of potential future states. Their CO2 trajectories are similar before 2050 and nearly identical through 2020, which is the focus of this book. The third source of uncertainty in climate model simulations arises from differences in model formulations, referred to here as “across-model” differences. Complex processes, especially those occurring at scales smaller than a model’s spatial resolution, are generally represented using a few simple parameters that are adjusted or “tuned” to fit observational data. This approach is called “parameterization.” For example, fractional cloud coverage over a 200 x 200 kilometer area can be made a function of the average relative humidity over the 200 x 200 kilometer area; sea ice drift can be made proportional to the wind speed. The proportionality factors can be considered the tunable parameters in these cases. The selection of processes to be parameterized and the tuning of the parameters are at least somewhat subjective, and the various modeling centers have made different choices. Composites (arithmetic means) of simulations by different models average out many of the across-model differences, and they also average out much of the natural variability that manifests itself in different regions and time periods of individual model simulations. Figure 1.3.3 illustrates the dilemma faced by users of climate models. The top three panels show the simulated winter temperature changes for 1951–2000 from
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…29
three different models, all of the same vintage (early–mid-2000s). All models were run with the same historical values of greenhouse gas and aerosol concentrations for 1951–2000. The differences in simulated temperature changes are large, especially on a regional basis. Over Alaska, for example, two models show cooling while one model shows strong warming during the fifty-year period. The large differences arise from a combination of natural variability and the across-model differences, which are responsible for the first and third types of uncertainties discussed above. However, when the IPCC model simulations of this period are composited (averaged), the pattern of change is a more coherent pattern of modest warming, as shown in the lower right panel of Figure 1.3.3. In fact, the composite (all-model mean) change of the annual mean temperature simulated by the models shows good agreement with the corresponding observed pattern, as shown in Figure 1.3.4. Both patterns exhibit the polar increase of warming that is known to be a characteristic of greenhouse-driven climate change (Serreze and Francis 2006). The compositing has effectively removed much of the uncertainty due to natural variability and the across-model differences.
Figure 1.3.3. Patterns of winter temperature changes (°C) simulated by three individual models (upper), and the corresponding mean pattern of fifteen different models (lower right). All models are from the suite used in the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report.
30â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
When expected values of future changes are based on averages of model simulations, how many models should be included in the average? On the one hand, it is apparent that the number of models should exceed one because of natural variability. On the other hand, some models perform sufficiently poorly that they may be regarded as outliers. To the extent that outliers degrade an average, they should be excluded. Preliminary experiments with varying numbers of the models used in composites indicate that an optimal fraction of models for inclusion is about half of the available models (Walsh 2008). This finding is based on the recent set of IPCC model simulations, but it seems to be relatively insensitive to the choice of variable (temperature, precipitation, pressure) and to the choice of the region or its size (Alaska, Greenland, or the broader Northern Hemisphere). Given that (1) individual models show some success at capturing the magnitude but not the timing of natural variations (Fig. 1.3.1) and (2) averages of model simulations capture the broad spatial patterns of change over multi-decadal periods (Fig. 1.3.4), how should one make use of climate models in optimizing scenarios for the future? It is apparent that single simulations by individual models offer the best hope for capturing the statistics of the variability that characterizes the real atmosphere. Natural variability of future climates may be estimated from simulations by models that best capture historical variability, but the projections from
Figure 1.3.4. Changes in annual mean temperature over the fifty-year period 1957–2006, as (a) observed and (b) simulated. (b) is a composite of IPCC model simulations.
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…31
these models must be cast in terms of probabilities obtained from the natural variations. For instance, one may use time series of model output to answer the question: What is the likelihood that a particular N-year period in the future will be warmer than the N-year period immediately preceding it? For N=1, the probability will be close to 50%, while for large N (~fifty), the probability will be high—mostly greater than 90%. On the other hand, best estimates of future changes, expressed as expected values of changes from the present, should be based on averages over at least several models (e.g., the top half of the models based on past-performance metrics suitable to the application or need). The latter approach minimizes the effects of uncertainties due to natural variability and across-model differences, while the use of probabilities of N-year changes offers a way to include in future projections the uncertainties due to natural variability. For projections spanning the next half century or less, the choice of a greenhouse forcing scenario is not a major consideration, as noted above. Projections for this range can be based on a single scenario and presented in terms of the ranges spanned by natural variability and across-model differences, after eliminating the models that perform more poorly for the desired application. However, beyond the next fifty years, the projections should be presented in terms of ranges encompassing these same two sources of uncertainty as well as uncertainties arising from scenarios of future greenhouse concentrations.
Integrated Assessment Models and Their Uncertainties We now move into the realm of integrated assessments, for which greenhouse scenarios and climate model projections are augmented by many other considerations that will shape the course and effects of future environmental change. This section discusses (1) the definition of an integrated assessment model, (2) how uncertainty about future system conditions influences these linked models, (3) how scientists are communicating a wide range of predictions to stakeholders who need to make decisions now, and (4) research frontiers in integrated assessment modeling given compounded uncertainty.
Defining Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) The IPCC defines integrated assessment modeling as “an interdisciplinary process of combining, interpreting, and communicating knowledge from diverse scientific disciplines in such a way that the whole set of cause-effect interactions of a problem can be evaluated” (IPCC 2001b). This basic definition suggests that there are a number of reasons why IAM modeling is important, especially when attempting to
32â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
model the likelihood of future outcomes. First, combining knowledge from diverse disciplines can help researchers, funding agencies, and stakeholders perform sensitivity analyses of an entire system to determine which components of the model have the greatest influence over the outcomes being evaluated. Second, IAMs force individual researchers (and their respective institutions) to think carefully about how their models may be used by other researchers or stakeholders trained in other natural or social science fields. Finally, IAMs give interdisciplinary scientists the ability to rank the factors that may be contributing the most to the statistical uncertainty of the entire system being evaluated. However, Schneider (1997) notes that if communication of IAM assumptions and results is poor, then IAMs can do more harm than good when attempting to implement “rational” policies. Modeling chaotic systems—including arctic change and the societal responses to it—compounds each individual model’s known and unknown errors and biases, producing predictions inherent with structural and other forms of statistical uncertainty.
Compounded Uncertainty and IAMs All integrated assessment models that make projections about future conditions exhibit some level of compounded statistical uncertainty. Schneider (1983) refers to this phenomenon as the “cascading pyramid of uncertainties.” Compounding statistical uncertainty occurs when multiple modules of an IAM each have their own biases and errors with the total uncertainty of the system being modeled represented by the aggregation of all measurement errors, modeling biases, range of scenarios, etc. For example, consider an attempt to assess the economic impacts of climate change on infrastructure in areas of permafrost. As shown in the preceding section, global climate models typically produce mean (or average) projections for a number of important variables, including temperature. These models are run over and over with different assumptions about the future (i.e., scenarios, etc.) and, in addition to average values, a range of possible values is produced by the modeling groups. Next, natural scientists interested in the impact of temperature on permafrost use global (or regional) climate model results and then make their own models—with their own formulations, simplifications, and parameters, along with biases and unknown errors—to predict permafrost response to future temperature. Finally, economists and engineers build their own assumption-laden models using results from the permafrost scientists. The result is a linked system of models displaying a wide range of results. The range of results (or statistical uncertainty of the entire system) is not normally distributed around the projected average value (i.e., the probability distributions have “fat tails”). Fat-tailed statistical distributions can be used to estimate a plausible range of impacts, assuming that the likelihood of extreme events is increasing at a given location. In summary, there is coupled,
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…33
structural statistical uncertainty about the impacts of the concentration of greenhouse gases on the global climate (i.e., results of Atmosphere-Ocean GCMs), the Arctic’s climate in particular (downscaled results), as well as assumptions made about future engineering or economic conditions (e.g., how to discount future impacts back to the present).
Discounting Future Risk to the Present: The Role of Uncertainty Socioeconomic researchers often make assumptions about how to discount future economic impacts back to the present so that policymakers can make rational decisions now about how to allocate resources. The appropriate choice of a discount rate, which is often a subjective decision made by the researcher (or a group of stakeholders), has important implications in the impacts calculation. The discount rate is the difference between a benefit (cost) received (expended) at a future time rather than today. A small change in the assumed discount rate can change the results by millions or even billions of dollars depending on the context of the problem being studied. Although the discount rate is one important assumption made by socio-economists, it may not be the most important issue to focus on. Weitzman (2008) notes that the statistical influence of structural uncertainty coupled with a lack of information about high-temperature impacts (e.g., damage to infrastructure) from climate change can potentially outweigh the statistical influence of the discount rate used when conducting an analysis of future economic risk. Weitzman’s research suggests that reducing uncertainty about impacts may be more important than the discount rate scenario used to discount future risk back to the present. This assumes that interdisciplinary scientists are transparently communicating their results, assumptions, and uncertainties to policymakers and other stakeholders.
Communicating Integrated Assessment Model Uncertainty to Inform Policy Schneider (1997), Schneider and Lane (2005), and many others continue to stress the importance of integrated assessment modelers working with stakeholders to transparently communicate their scenarios, methods, and results. Schneider and Lane (2005:66) eloquently note: When speaking to policy makers and citizens, scientists must make it evident that any quantitative answers generated by IAMs are not to be taken literally, but should be used more as tools to generate insights into the decision-making process; they are not “truth machines,” but general guideposts. Scientists must open
34â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
and conclude their presentations to policy makers and laypeople on IAM results with clear, concise statements about assumptions and uncertainties, and should avoid overloading a presentation with numerical data, keeping in mind that communicating with decision makers and the public requires very different skills and language than communicating with scientific colleagues. It will be necessary for scientists to find the appropriate balance between transparency and completeness. Furthermore, Mastrandrea and Schneider (2004:571) note that using probability distributions to communicate statistical uncertainty is a valuable tool when communicating scenarios to policymakers and other stakeholders: Without explicit efforts to quantify the likelihood of future events, users of scientific results (including policymakers) will undoubtedly make their own assumptions about the probability of different outcomes, possibly in ways that the original authors did not intend.╯.╯.╯.╯We believe that such probabilistic methods are more valuable for communicating an accurate view of current scientific knowledge to those seeking information for decision making than assessments that do not attempt to present results in probabilistic frameworks. Larsen et al. (2008) attempted to strike this balance between transparency and completeness when they reported risk to Alaska’s infrastructure from projected climate change. The authors described a scenario they created for their integrated assessment model (see Table 1.3.1) and then produced results showing two forms of uncertainty. Figure 1.3.5 shows the projected range of additional public infrastructure costs for Alaska due to climate change from Larsen et al. (2008). Two different types of uncertainty are displayed in this figure. First, three different climate models are shown (i.e., “warm,” “warmer,” and “warmest”). Second, each climate model has a distribution of economic impacts based on the historical record of year-to-year natural climate variability around the climate model’s mean projection. Note that this depiction incorporates two of the three sources of uncertainty addressed in the previous section (natural variability and across-model variance) but not across-scenario variance because of the near-term time horizon.
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…35 Table 1.3.1. Example of an Integrated Assessment Modeling Scenario (Larsen et al. 2008). Model Component
Assumption
Functional Form:
Probabilistic Lifecycle Analysis
Discount Rate:
2.85%/year (real)
Base Year:
2006
Projected Years:
2030, 2080
Public Infrastructure Count:
15,665 Pieces
Public Infrastructure Value:
$39.4 Billion ($2006)
Infrastructure Base Costs (per unit):
See Larsen et al. (2008)
Infrastructure Useful Life by Type:
See Larsen et al. (2008)
Depreciation Matrix Version:
January 31, 2007
Climate Projection Regions:
5.6ºx5.6º Grid Box Centered at Anchorage, Barrow, Bethel, Juneau, Fairbanks, and Nome
IPCC SRES Scenario:
A1B
Preferred Climate Models:
CSIRO-Mk3.0 (Australia), MIROC3.2.(HIRES) (Japan), and NOAA.GFDL-CM2.0 (US)
Climate Model Base Years:
1980–1999
Observed Climate Variability Data Source:
University of Alaska Fairbanks Geophysical Institute
Distribution Shape for Observed Regional Climate:
Gaussian
Extreme Climate Events Probability:
Less than 1st Percentile, Greater than 99th Percentile (for observed range of climate)
Extreme Climate Events Scalar:
+10% Increase in Impact to Useful Life
Natural Variability Forward in Time:
Static at Observed Regional Annual Variances
Trans-Alaska Pipeline Included in Results:
No
Event-based Adaptation:
Yes
Infrastructure Growth Forward in Time:
Static at 2006 Count (i.e., 15,653)
Permafrost State Forward in Time:
Static at 1965 Location (USGS)
Impacts from Changes in Relative Sea Level:
Implicit, but not locally projected
Software System:
SAS 9.1 TS Level 1M3, XP_PRO Platform
Hardware System:
Dell Dimension 8300 (Intel Pentium 3.06 GHz; 500 GB Hard Drive)
36â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Figure 1.3.5. Example of Communicating Multiple Forms of Uncertainty with an IAM.
Figure 1.3.6. Example of projection of high-resolution temperature changes with greenhouse scenario explicitly noted.
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…37
The aforementioned example is just one method that has been recently employed in the context of the Arctic. It is clear that new research frontiers are being explored in an effort to transparently communicate uncertainty as well as assumptions about future scenarios.2
Frontiers in Uncertainty Research The Scenarios Network for Alaska Planning (SNAP) project at the University of Alaska (http://www.snap.uaf.edu/) has produced high-resolution maps depicting projected temperature changes in Alaska by mid-century with user-friendly symbols communicating the underlying scenarios and resolution produced during the climate model downscaling (see Fig. 1.3.6). 3
Figure 1.3.7. Example of the communication of high-resolution across-model statistical uncertainty.
38â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Conclusion The preceding sections point to the emerging trend toward the conveyance of information on scenarios and projections in a probabilistic framework. While some uncertainties, such as those associated with model parameters and with sensitivities of impacts to environmental variables, are likely to be reduced in the foreseeable future, other uncertainties are unlikely to be reduced. Among the latter are natural variations of future climate over multiyear to decadal time scales. Optimizing the use of information on scenarios and projections in the face of these uncertainties is a fundamental challenge for planners and decision-makers. The following chapters provide examples of the diverse strategies and needs of various sectors as they confront a future of change.
Acknowledgments The authors thank Marcus Geist of the Nature Conservatory–Alaska and William Chapman of the University of Illinois for the maps and other figures illustrating the projections. This work was supported in part by the National Science Foundation’s Office of Polar Programs through Grant ARC-0652838.
References Gausemeier, J., A. Fink, and O. Schlake. 1996. Szenario-Management: Planen und Führen mit Szenarien (English: Scenario management: planning and leading with scenarios), 2nd Ed., Munich, Germany: Hanser Verlag. Glenn, J. C., and T. J. Gordon. 2009. Futures research methodology version 3.0. Washington DC: The Millennium Project. IPCC. 2001a. Special report on emission scenarios. Working group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. IPCC. 2001b. Mitigation—Contribution of working group III to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Edited by B. Metz, O. Davidson, R. Swart, and J. Pan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. IPCC. 2007. The physical basis of climate change. Working group I, fourth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Larsen, P. H., S. Goldsmith, O. Smith, M. L. Wilson, K. Strzepek, P. Chinowsky, and B. Saylor. 2008. Estimating future costs for Alaska public infrastructure at risk from climate change. Global Environmental Change 18, 442–457.
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…39
Lempert, R. J., S. W. Popper, and S. C. Bankes. 2003. Shaping the next one hundred years: New methods for quantitative, long-term policy analysis. Santa Monica, CA: RAND. Mastrandrea, M. D., and S. H. Schneider. 2004. Probabilistic integrated assessment of “dangerous” climate change. Science 304, 571–575. Mueller-Stoffels, M., and H. Eicken. 2009. Futures of arctic marine transportation 2030. Paper presented at the State of the Arctic Conference, Miami, 2010. Mueller-Stoffels, M., E. Gauger, and K. Steinmüller. 2009. Explorative scenarios using consistency and robustness analysis and Wild Cards. To be published in Conference proceedings for Lessons from Continuity and Change in the Fourth International Polar Year, March 4–9, 2009, University of Alaska Fairbanks, Fairbanks. Schneider, S. H. 1983. CO2 , climate and society: A brief overview. In Social science research and climatic change: An interdisciplinary appraisal. Edited by R. Chen, E. Boulding, and S. H. Schneider. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: D. Reidel Publishing. Schneider, S. H. 1997. Integrated assessment modeling of global climate change: Transparent rational tool for policy making or opaque screen hiding value-laden assumptions? Environmental Modeling and Assessment 2(4), 229–248. Schneider, S. H., and J. Lane. 2005. Integrated assessment modeling of global climate change: Much has been learned—still a long and bumpy road ahead. The Integrated Assessment Journal 5(1), 41–75. Schneider, S. H., and M. D. Mastrandrea. 2005. Probabilistic assessment of “dangerous” climate change and emissions pathways. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102, 15728–15735. Retrieved from http://www.pnas.org/cgi/reprint/ 0506356102v1. Serreze, M., and J. Francis. 2006. The Arctic amplification debate. Climate Change 76, 241–264. Steinmüller, A., and K. Steinmüller. 2004. Wild Cards. Wenn das Unwahrscheinliche eintritt (English: Wild Cards. When the improbable happens), 2nd Ed. Hamburg, Germany: Murmann Verlag. USARC. 2010. Scaling studies in arctic system science and policy support. Edited by C. Vorosmarty, D. McGuire, and J. Hobbie. Arlington, VA: United States Arctic Research Commission. Walsh, J. E. 2008. Simulations of present Arctic climate and future regional projections. Proceedings, Ninth International Conference on Permafrost, International Permafrost Association, 146–150. Walsh, J. E., and W. L. Chapman. 2007. Simulations of Arctic temperature and pressure by global coupled models. Journal of Climate 20, 609–632. Wang, M., J. E. Overland, V. M. Kattsov, J. E. Walsh, X. Zhang, and T. Pavlova. 2007. Intrinsic versus forced variations in coupled climate model simulations over the Arctic during the 20th century. Journal of Climate 20, 1093–1107. Washington, W. M., and C. L. Parkinson. 2005. An introduction to three-dimensional climate modeling, 2nd Ed. University Science Books.
40â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Weitzman, M. 2008. On modeling and interpreting the economics of catastrophic climate change. Department Working Paper, Harvard University Economics, February.
Endnotes 1 2
3
The nomenclature in futures studies is unfortunately quite muddled. We will stick to the terms used in describing the Robustness/Consistency analysis (Gausemeier et al. 1996; Mueller-Stoffels et al. 2009), as this is the example method later used. For example, the United States Arctic Research Commission—in their 2010 call for research—first reported that an unpublished analysis by researchers involved in the Larsen et al. (2008) study found that a number of unknown factors may have contributed to a systematic underestimate of both the dollar amount of infrastructure at risk and the statistical uncertainty of their original results (USARC 2010). These maps were intentionally produced using degrees Fahrenheit because policymakers/stakeholders in the United States typically understand this temperature metric better than Celsius. This simple conversion issue is an excellent example of a communication disconnect between natural science and applied policymaking.
1.4
Contextualizing Alaska’s Climate Change from Global to Local Scales: The Boreal Forest, People, and Wildfire by f. stuart chapin iii and amy lauren lovecraft
T
he previous chapter’s discussion of the tools science uses to determine patterns and how scientists account for uncertainties as they provide data for decision making dovetails nicely with our chapter’s focus on observed changes in the boreal social-ecological systems of Alaska. As Walsh and co-authors wrestle with how to optimize scenarios for future decision making (Chapter 1.3), changes in the northern wildfire fire regime present evidence of current shifts in a suite of coupled human–environmental interactive relationships. This chapter presents a snapshot demonstrating how dynamic and complex these relationships among people, forests, weather patterns, and fire can be. It also explains how unintended consequences and human innovation can arise in light of feedbacks across scales of activity. Alaska’s boreal forests are part of a discontinuous ring of boreal forest locations around the circumpolar North. They are only one of many landscapes on earth that are wildfire-dependent; their ecosystems have become fire-adaptive, and they depend on fires for their productivity (Chapin et al. 2006). Our brief review of the impact of fire on the landscape in relation to people is meant to place Alaska’s changing climate in a global context, demonstrate the cross-scale effects that climate change is producing in social-ecological systems, and give insight into how social-ecological thinking can highlight linkages between problem and solution sets.
Global Processes in a State of Flux
Human actions are having large and accelerating effects on Earth’s climate, environment, and ecosystems. During the last fifty years, for example, human activities 41
42â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
have changed ecosystems more rapidly and extensively than during any comparable period of human history (Steffen et al. 2004) (Fig. 1.4.1). The Earth’s climate is now warmer than at any time in the last 500 (and probably the last 1,300) years (IPCC 2007), in large part because of atmospheric accumulation of carbon dioxide released by the burning of fossil fuels. Agricultural development accounts for much of the remaining forcing of climatic change (IPCC 2007). If all fossil fuel emissions ceased instantly today, the excess fossil-fuel CO2 in the atmosphere (about 35% higher than the “natural” background) would decline by 50% within thirty years and another 20% within a few centuries, but the remaining excess CO2 would stay in the atmosphere for thousands of years. This will create, from the perspective of human lifetimes, a permanently warmer world. Fossil fuel emissions have increased more rapidly over the last thirty years than most scientists had projected (IPCC 2007), and the land and oceans have become weaker sinks for the CO2 that has accumulated in the atmosphere. The question of how much warmer the world will become depends on the rate at which fossil fuel and other trace gas emissions are curtailed. Climate change involves more than temperature. Warmer temperatures increase the rate of evaporation of water, which accelerates the global hydrologic cycle. Patterns of hydrologic change are more complex than those of temperature, but, in general, wet areas are expected to become wetter, dry areas will become drier, and extreme events—both droughts and floods—will increase in intensity (IPCC 2007). In addition, increased human mobility is spreading plants, animals, diseases, industrial products, and cultural perspectives across the globe more rapidly than ever before. This increase in global mobility, coupled with increased connectivity through global markets and new forms of communication, links the world’s economies and cultures, so decisions in one place often have international consequences. At the same time, new technologies and improved communication also open new opportunities for adaptation strategies to be shared (NRC 2010).
The Regional Scale of Alaska’s Climatic and Ecological Changes The warming that has occurred globally is amplified at high latitudes (IPCC 2007), so Alaska, and the Arctic generally, is warming twice as rapidly as the global average (IPCC 2007) (Figs. 1.4.2, 1.4.3). Mean annual air temperature in Interior Alaska increased by 1.3°C during the past fifty years (Shulski and Wendler 2007) and is projected by downscaled climate models to increase by an additional 3–7°C by the end of the twenty-first century (Walsh et al. 2008) (http://www.snap.uaf.edu).
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…43
100 0
600
Globalized (foreign) investment
400 200
00
50
20
00
19
19
50 18
00
0 50
00
50
20
19
00
0
Paper consumption
18
Tons (million yr –1) 1998 dollars (billion)
1
200
17
2
19
00 20
50 19
00 19
50 18
00 18
17
50
0
Fertilizer use
50
2
3
18
Water use
50
6 4
0
Nutrients (108 tons –1)
(1000 km)3 yr –1
0
15
00
2
Real GDP
30
18
Global population
4
45
1990 Dollars (1012)
6
17
People (billion)
Human Actions
Earth-System Responses –1 3
60
# (10 )
Fisheries exploited
80 40
Species extinctions
20 10
20 00
0 20 0
0 19 5
19 00
0 18 5
0
19 50
0
18 0
20 00
19 50
19 00
18 50
0.01
20 0
18 00
0.02
19 00
0
0.03
17 50
25
Great floods
0.04
30
100
Land conversion
% of fisheries
% of land area
0
-0.5
50
17 50
0.5
18 50
280
0.05
18 00
300
Northern hemisphere temperature
Floods decade
320
1.0
0
340
Atmospheric CO2
17 5
CO2 (ppmv)
360
Temp. anomaly ( oC )
380
Year
Figure 1.4.1. Increasing rates of change in human actions and earth-system responses since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. Significant increases in rates of change occur around the 1950s in each case and illustrate how the past fifty years have been a period of dramatic and unprecedented change in human history. Adapted from Steffen et al. (2004).
44â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Temperature is increasing most rapidly in winter, which shortens the snow-covered season by about 1.5 days per decade and increases the frequency of thaws and rainstorms during winter (Chapin et al. 2005). Annual precipitation has increased by only 7 mm in the last fifty years (Hinzman et al. 2006). Its projected continued increase will likely be insufficient to offset summer evapotranspiration (http://www.snap.uaf.edu), leading to potentially drier soils, drying of wetlands, and lower lake and river levels. Fairbanks, for example, is projected to warm by about 4°C by 2050, even with an optimistic scenario of substantially reduced global fossil fuel consumption. This would produce a climate similar to the current climate of Saskatoon, Canada. The prairies that used to characterize this part of Saskatchewan now support monocultures of oilseed rape. Such a transition on the landscape and of society’s use of the landscape is dramatic. Given our ability, through scientific modeling and empirical evidence, to understand the changes across Alaska’s terrestrial and marine ecosystems, how will Alaskans respond to climatic changes of this ecologically important magnitude? Furthermore, because the circumpolar north plays a major global role, for example, in regulating climate patterns and species migrations, how will those distant from the Arctic consider these changes and their relationships to them? Because one cannot measure the responses of ecosystems to change without considering the interrelated feedbacks of society, any answer to these questions involves careful consideration of the ecological and human impacts of the changes. If viable farmland becomes possible, communities must consider the management of water, the building of roads, the security of food systems, and the potential for an influx of people and other animal and plant species to a region. This long-term planning often falls by the wayside as people face the problems in the near-term. However, by observing changes and working to predict future states, some of the worst tradeoffs of a changing landscape may be avoided. For example, in Alaska, and across the western United States more generally, it appears that long periods of fire suppression in many fire-adaptive forests have had the unintended consequences of more intense, larger, and more frequent fires burning closer to human habitation (Dennis 2003). A warming climate and the movement of people into wildland fire interfaces without considering the potential risks are contributing factors in the increased loss of life and property; this has been especially notable in locations of high population density such as southern California. The generally accepted management strategy of suppressing all fire did not anticipate these consequences. We cannot always know what our best intentions may produce, and surprises can be devastating. The rapid rate and directional nature of Alaska’s warming climate have important ecological and societal consequences. The permafrost layers in the soils are
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…45
Global surface temperature ( oC deviation from the mean)
a.
0.6
Annual mean 5-year mean
0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4 1880
1900
1920
1940
1960
1980
2000
Year b.
Figure 1.4.2. Time course (a) of the average surface temperature of Earth from 1850 to 2005 (IPCC 2007) and (b) latitudinal pattern of warming from 1961 to 2004 (Chapin et al. 2005).
46â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Temperature anomaly (oC)
3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
Figure 1.4.3. Change in surface air temperature of Alaska from 1930 to 2004 (Chapin et al. 2005).
warming. Where soil ice content is high, this causes the ground surface to subside, threatening roads and other infrastructure and altering drainage patterns in natural ecosystems—in some places converting forests to wetlands, in other places causing lakes to drain, and in still other places causing land slippage and erosion. In the Kenai Peninsula of south central Alaska, warming enabled spruce bark beetles to shorten their life cycle from two years to one and increase their overwinter survival. This radically altered the balance between the insect and its host, causing widespread insect outbreaks and forest dieback (Allen et al. 2006). Fires occur more extensively (Kasischke and Turetsky 2006) and trees are expanding into tundra at both altitudinal and latitudinal treelines (Lloyd et al. 2007). Within tundra, shrubs appear to be expanding (Sturm et al. 2005). Shrubs trap the snow that serves to insulate the ground in winter and reduce heat loss, thus sustaining microbial activity and providing more nitrogen to support yet more shrub growth. Shrubs also shade out lichens, reducing the abundance of winter food for caribou, whose diet consists primarily of lichen. The increased frequency of winter rains, which is already observed in northern Scandinavia, encases lichens in ice and reduces their availability to reindeer and caribou. This presents a poignant example of seemingly small environmental shifts, such as more shrubs and rain, having direct impact on the northern
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…47
cultures whose livelihoods are tied to reindeer husbandry or caribou hunting. For these peoples, the loss of herd vitality can result in less food, lower incomes, and hardship. In Alaska, the magnitude and spatial extent of recent changes in shrub cover and icing events are less well known, but it is clear that many dimensions of arctic and boreal ecology are changing rapidly (Chapin et al. 2006). People have inhabited Alaska for 6,000–12,000 years (Aigner 1986). In subsequent millennia, different cultural groups have settled in regions with different ecologies, Eskimos on the coast and Indians in interior and southeastern Alaska. The map of Alaskan ecosystems is virtually identical to the map of indigenous languages and associated cultures (Fig. 1.4.4) because of the close adaptation of culture to environment (Nelson 1983) and the effects of cultural practices on the land (Natcher 2004). This demonstrates the connections between human societies and their natural surroundings that form a social-ecological system and raises critical questions regarding the changing properties of Alaska’s ecosystems. If the ecology of Alaska is changing so radically with climate warming, what are the implications for the cultures that occupy these landscapes and seascapes? What are the challenges and opportunities for human adaptation and change?
Ecoregions
Indigenous Languages and Peoples Eyak-Tlingit
Arctic tundra
Tlingit Eyak
Boreal forest Subarctic tundra
Haida Tsimshian
Coastal rain
s re
fo
t Eskimo-Aleut
Athabascan
Iñupiaq
Gwich'in
Holikachuk
Central Yup'ik
Hän
Upper Kuskokwim
Unanga{ (Aleut)
Deg Xinag
Upper Tanana
Sugpiaq (Alutiiq)
Dena'ina
Tanacross
St. Lawrence Island Yupik
Ahtna
Lower Tanana
Denaakk'e (Koyukon)
Map by C. West, M. Wilson and J. Kerr - ISER
Figure 1.4.4. Maps of ecosystems (left) and cultural (linguistic) groups (right) in Alaska. The close correspondence between these maps demonstrates the tight linkage between ecosystem and society. Redrawn from Gallant et al. (1996) and Krauss (1982). Reprinted from Chapin (2009).
48â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
At the Local Level: The Changing Relationship of People and Fire One example of the tight interrelatedness between social and ecological systems in Alaska is between people and wildfire. Across all scales, from local to global, changing wildfire regimes in the world’s northern boreal forests have an effect on village lives and governments, and on the landscapes in which people live. The fine-scale relationship of indigenous people with wildfire has changed radically since prehistoric times. Before extensive contact with Europeans, Athabascans, who inhabit mainly interior Alaska, lived primarily in small family bands that moved seasonally to access different resources when they were most available (Natcher 2004; Nelson 1983). When fires or post-fire succession reduced the suitability of habitat in one place, bands adjusted their seasonal migration accordingly. This enabled people to continue to access a wide range of successional habitats, although the specific locations changed over time. During the twentieth century, people were settled in permanent villages that provided compulsory education and access to many of the so-called necessities and some benefits of western life. But this radically restricted mobility on the land and therefore challenged the earlier resilience achieved through spatial adjustment to disturbance events (Chapin et al. 2008). Fires that burn close to a village change accessible habitat, and the plants and animals it provides, for decades. Without the ability to move across the landscape different settlements would experience abundance or impoverishment unexpectedly, unequally, and with little recourse to hunt or gather outside of village boundaries. Both local hunters and wildlife biologists report similar successional patterns of post-fire recovery of subsistence resources (Fig. 1.4.5), but their conclusions, in part due to settlement patterns, about implications for wildfire management are quite different (Chapin et al. 2008). Wildlife biologists recognize the importance of maintaining fire on the landscape to regenerate early successional habitat that supports animals such as moose, given the long (80–200 years) fire intervals reported for black spruce (Kasischke and Turetsky 2006). Looking at the same patterns, local hunters are concerned that opportunities to hunt for moose will not return for at least a generation or caribou for several generations (Chapin et al. 2008). These long time intervals are problematic because of the tight dependence of local economies on subsistence resources and the fundamental importance of hunting as a cultural practice that is threatened by assimilation into Euro-American culture. If a hunter cannot teach his or her children how to hunt, or if he or she cannot transmit the cultural values that are inherent in those activities, how can this subsistence-based culture survive? This intergenerational transmission of knowledge is further complicated by social, economic, and educational changes; technological changes in ways
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…49
to access the land; and loss of seasonal mobility as people settled into permanent villages in the mid-twentieth century (Chapin et al. 2008; Nelson 1983). Nonetheless, people living on the land are proud of their capacity to adapt to change, especially if they know what changes are likely to occur. Harvest of flammable fuels near communities, for example, can reduce wildfire risk, reduce the amount of diesel fuel purchased to heat public buildings, provide wage income to local villagers, and create secondary successional moose habitat close to town (Chapin et al. 2008). This strategy has been implemented in the village of Tanana and is being considered by other communities. Given that fire extent will likely continue to increase in interior Alaska, it is important to consider opportunities as well as problems. Fires bring wages to village fire crews that are important to the mixed cash–subsistence economy of rural Alaska. Firefighting can provide the money needed to purchase snowmachines, ammunition, and gas for hunting (Trainor et al. 2009). This example demonstrates how climate change is a dynamic force in the lives of northern peoples as it creates vulnerabilities, but if people have the capacity to develop adaptive strategies it need not be a monolithic threat without recourse.
Caribou
Animal density
Moose
0
25
50
75
100
Time (years) Figure 1.4.5. Temporal changes in moose and caribou abundance after wildland fires in Alaska’s boreal forest based on observations of local hunters and corroborated by scientific studies. Modified from Chapin et al. (2008).
50â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Climate change and wildfires in Alaska have social-ecological impacts that extend far beyond Alaska. There is now evidence that there are also feedbacks from the local system to global processes. A shortened snow-covered season, for example, substantially increases regional absorption of solar radiation in spring and fall by changing broad areas from white reflective to dark absorptive surfaces (Chapin et al. 2005). In addition, the carbon dioxide and methane released by wildfires add to the heat-trapping capacity of the atmosphere (IPCC 2007). Both processes act as feedbacks that amplify rates of warming throughout the planet, affecting societies everywhere (Chapin et al. 2005).
Conclusions Social-ecological systems, by their nature, are complex. Just as fire behavior can be unpredictable, so too are human behaviors. As the example of Tanana demonstrates, social capacity to adapt can prevent catastrophe and initiate innovation. For there to be adaptive planning and responses, however, society has to be able to observe, measure, and predict changes not only in its environment but also within society itself. This is part of the reason the Fourth International Polar Year’s inclusion of the study of social processes has been important to research. Prediction forewarns us and hopefully forearms us. It enables us to present to our communities the potential trade-offs of current activities on future outcomes, in many cases through scenario building. However, science does not occur in a vacuum. It is translated by teachers, scientists, politicians, community members, journalists, and others. It is inherently a human process through which we understand the world around us. Consequently, the cross-pollination of knowledge about a system, for example, between pan-Arctic science data and indigenous knowledge, will be vital in communicating information to design scenarios, deliberate alternative outcomes, and plan how to reach sustainable futures.
A Holistic Approach for a Changing Northâ•…51
References Aigner, J. S. 1986. Footprints on the land: The origins of Interior Alaska’s people. In Interior Alaska: A journey through time. Edited by J. S. Aigner, R. D. Guthrie, M. L. Guthrie, F. Nelson, W. S. Schneider, and R. M. Thorson. Anchorage: Alaska Geographic Society. Allen, J. L., S. Wesser, C. J. Markon, and K. C. Winterberger. 2006. Stand and landscape level effects of a major outbreak of spruce beetles on forest vegetation in the Copper River Basin, Alaska. Forest Ecology and Management 227, 257–266. Chapin, F. S., III. 2009. Managing ecosystems sustainably: The key role of resilience. In Principles of ecosystem stewardship: Resilience-based natural resource management in a changing world. Edited by F. S. Chapin III, G. P. Kofinas, and C. Folke. New York: Springer. Chapin, F. S., III, M. W. Oswood, K. Van Cleve, L. A. Viereck, and D. L. Verbyla (eds.). 2006. Alaska’s changing boreal forest. New York: Oxford University Press. Chapin, F. S., III, M. Sturm, M. C. Serreze, J. P. McFadden, J. R. Key, A. H. Lloyd, A. D. McGuire, T. S. Rupp, A. H. Lynch, J. P. Schimel, J. Beringer, W. L. Chapman, H. E. Epstein, E. S. Euskirchen, L. D. Hinzman, G. Jia, C.-L. Ping, K. D. Tape, C. D. C. Thompson, D. A. Walker, and J. M. Welker. 2005. Role of land-surface changes in arctic summer warming. Science 310, 657–660. Chapin, F. S., III, S. F. Trainor, O. Huntington, A. L. Lovecraft, E. Zavaleta, D. C. Natcher, A. D. McGuire, J. L. Nelson, L. Ray, M. Calef, N. L. Fresco, H. Huntington, T. S. Rupp, L. DeWilde, and R. L. Naylor. 2008. Increasing wildfire in Alaska’s boreal forest: Pathways to potential solutions of a wicked problem. Bioscience 58, 531–540. Dennis, C. 2003. Burning issues. Nature 16 January, Vol. 421, 204–206. Gallant, A. L., E. F. Binnian, J. M. Omernik, and M. B. Shasby. 1996. Ecoregions of Alaska. Washington: US Govt. Printing Office. Hinzman, L. D., L. A. Viereck, P. C. Adams, V. E. Romanovsky, and K. Yoshikawa. 2006. Climate and permafrost dynamics of the Alaskan boreal forest. In Alaska’s changing boreal forest. Edited by F. S. Chapin, III, M. W. Oswood, K. Van Cleve, L. A. Viereck, and D. L. Verbyla. New York: Oxford University Press. 39–61. Intergovernment Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2007. Climate change 2007: The physical science basis. Working group I contribution to the fourth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press. Kasischke, E. S., and M. R. Turetsky. 2006. Recent changes in the fire regime across the North American boreal region: Spatial and temporal patterns of burning across Canada and Alaska. Geophysical Research Letters 33, doi:10.1029/2006GL025677. Krauss, M. E. 1982. Native peoples and languages of Alaska (map). Alaska Native Language Center, University of Alaska Fairbanks.
52â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Lloyd, A. H., C. L. Fastie, and H. Eisen. 2007. Fire and substrate interact to control the northern range limit of black spruce (Picea mariana) in Alaska. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 37, 2480–2493. Natcher, D. C. 2004. Implications of fire policy on Native land use in the Yukon Flats, Alaska. Human Ecology 32, 421–441. Nelson, R. K. 1983. Make prayers to the raven: A Koyukan view of the northern forest. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. National Research Council (NRC). 2010. America’s climate choices. Washington DC: National Academies Press. Shulski, M., and G. Wendler. 2007. The climate of Alaska. Fairbanks: University of Alaska Press. Steffen, W. L., A. Sanderson, P. D. Tyson, J. Jäger, P. A. Matson, B. Moore III, F. Oldfield, K. Richardson, H.-J. Schellnhuber, B. L. Turner II, and R. J. Wasson. 2004. Global change and the earth system: A planet under pressure. New York: Springer-Verlag. Sturm, M., J. Schimel, G. Michaelson, J. M. Welker, S. F. Oberbauer, G. E. Liston, J. Fahnestock, and V. E. Romanosky. 2005. Winter biological processes could help convert arctic tundra to shrubland. Bioscience 55, 17–26. Trainor, S. F., F. S. Chapin III, A. D. McGuire, M. Calef, N. Fresco, D. Natcher, P. Duffy, T. S. Rupp, L. DeWilde, O. Huntington, M. Kwart, and A. L. Lovecraft. 2009. Vulnerability and adaptation to climate-related fire impacts in rural and urban interior Alaska. Polar Research 29(1), 100–118. Walsh, J. E., W. L. Chapman, V. Romanovsky, J. H. Christensen, and M. Stendel. 2008. Global climate model performance over Alaska and Greenland. Journal of Climate 21, 6156–6174.
In section 1 walsh, mueller-stoffels, and larsen defined and explained the scientific methods used by researchers to evaluate data and make the types of predictions that generally inform discussions on adaptation to and mitigation of climate change and its impacts. Chapin and Lovecraft present an example of these impacts and human responses.
This type of scholarship, replicated across nations, has made policymakers, politicians, activists, and the general public aware of the shifts in the earth’s climate and weather systems. It represents a small portion of a much larger undertaking by societies to better understand what changes are occurring from the local to global scales and across the planet—from desertification on the African continent to coral reef bleaching in the South Pacific and to shrinking ice caps at the poles. However, the approaches outlined in the previous section operate primarily with one type of knowledge. Punctuated by Thomas Kuhn’s seminal work on “paradigm shifts” (1972), there has been a growing recognition by scholars that science itself is bound by historical forces and a human tendency to reinforce accepted assumptions, for example, in methodological approaches. The certainty of the western scientific endeavor as the only means by which people can know things, and its claims to universality and neutrality, come into question as we learn more about the complex nature of human lives and our impacts on the world (Blair 2010; Figueroa and Harding 2003). In fact, formalized western science is one of several ways to examine reality accurately and anticipate future events. Another way in which humans have gathered and disseminated vital knowledge across millennia has been through direct, lived observations that are passed down and refined through generations in an oral tradition. Such a process is not in opposition to the scientific method, but it differs, for example, in its focus on the contextual qualities of information. This form of knowledge can have different labels. The in-depth place-based information that people acquire when living in a location that helps them to navigate physical and social obstacles is generally called local knowledge. One need not live in the wilderness to acquire and test data on a daily basis that can be passed on to others. For example, information related to the fastest subway routes, the least expensive coffee shops, the nearest pharmacy, and the safest places to bicycle is valued immensely by outsiders; just consider the tourism book industry. The case in Chapter 1.4 of seasonal fire cycles presents another example. Annually, scores of firefighters from Alaska are flown to other states to assist in fire suppression, move equipment, travel distances in forests, and facilitate evacuations. They need local knowledge to supplement maps or GPS. They must obtain detailed information such as side street shortcuts, the number of people and animals at a residence, and trails through forests that can only be gained from community members whose daily lives are information storehouses. When local knowledge is directly associated with indigenous peoples, it is generally called indigenous knowledge. More narrowly, when such knowledge is tied to enduring cultural traditions related to ecological processes it is often called traditional ecological knowledge (Berkes
1999). Section 2 focuses primarily on Alaska Native knowledge, and Barnhardt explains its socialecological implications in detail. Each of these modes of knowledge production represents a valuable contribution to the human endeavor to learn about reality. In concert they can help us as we try to understand the effects of a changing climate, foster human adaptive capacity in the face of change, and design strategies for the future.
References Berkes, F. 1999. Sacred ecology: Traditional ecological knowledge and resource management. Philadelphia, PA: Taylor and Francis. Blair, B. 2010. Risk society on the last frontier: Indigenous knowledge and the politics of risk in oil resource management at Alaska’s North Slope. M.A. thesis, University of Alaska Fairbanks. Figueroa, R., and S. Harding. 2003. Science and other cultures. New York: Routledge. Kuhn, T. 1972. The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
2
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainability
Section editors: Ray Barnhardt and Pia M. Kohler
PLATE 002 Spirit Mask Susie Bevins Wood and mixed media 30" x 30" 2009
2.1
Introduction by ray barnhardt
I
ndigenous peoples of the circumpolar north have been caretakers of the land for millennia. They have acquired extensive deep knowledge regarding the environment in which they live, and they have been at the forefront of debates about the impacts of and responses to accelerating ecological changes. The Fourth International Polar Year provided an opportunity to forge more meaningful institutional and collaborative research links with indigenous communities and to entrain and support emerging indigenous scholars. It was clear that implementing a successful IPY program required working closely with indigenous stakeholders in all phases of developing and implementing an IPY research agenda. The UAF North by 2020 Working Group on Indigenous Knowledge and Western Science identified four near- and long-term goals: 1. Develop a strategy and support activities to increase the number of Alaska Native graduate and undergraduate students in underrepresented fields of scientific research. 2. Include Alaska Native perspectives in UAF planning and research activities that have implications for Native people and communities. Seek funding to engage Native graduate students in affiliation with such research initiatives. 3. Work with researchers to ensure compliance with protocols for cultural and intellectual property rights, including the Principles for the Conduct of Research in the Arctic and the Research Guidelines of the Alaska Federation of Natives (http://www.ankn.uaf.edu/rights.html). 4. Help implement a program of graduate fellowships and residencies to enhance the exchange between arctic indigenous peoples and between Native and western perspectives on topics of relevance to the circumpolar north. 57
58â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
The Convergence of Western Science and Indigenous Knowledge Indigenous societies, as a matter of survival, have long sought to understand the irregularities in the world around them, recognizing many underlying patterns of order in nature. For example, Alaska Native people have long been able to predict weather based on observations of subtle signs that presage what conditions are likely to be. With the vagaries introduced into the environment by accelerated climate change in recent years, there is a growing interest in exploring the potential for a complementary relationship between what were previously considered to be two disparate and irreconcilable systems of thought: western science and indigenous knowledge. Given the holistic and comprehensive nature of indigenous knowledge systems, the theme of “Indigenous Knowledge Systems and Western Science” provided fertile ground for pursuing a broad international and interdisciplinary agenda addressing research areas associated with IPY-4. In 2007, the International Council for Science–World Meteorological Association Joint Committee for the International Polar Year and the IPY International Program Office identified six themes around which IPY activities were to be organized: atmosphere, ice, land, oceans, people, and space. In the introduction to the activities associated with “people,” the IPY offered the following statement of intent: IPY promotes constructive and respectful engagement with northern people through community monitoring, through acknowledgement and protection of traditional knowledge, and through inclusion of northern people as valued partners in planning and conducting IPY and in evaluating and assessing IPY results and legacies. IPY researchers will focus on northern human health, particularly on impacts of pollution, contaminants and parasites in traditional foods, existing and emerging infectious diseases, chronic diseases, and unhealthy behaviors. Researchers will explore many facets of arctic social systems, to determine resiliency to internal and external change and to develop adaptation and mitigation strategies. IPY investigations will include studies of unique uses of language, such as for intergenerational understanding of sea ice, studies of how legal systems protect the value and integrity of traditional knowledge, and economic and social assessments of the impacts and opportunities related to natural resource management and energy and transportation developments. (http://www. ipy.org/)
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…59
This statement captures many of the recommendations that have been put forth over the past twenty years regarding the emerging role of indigenous peoples in multiple facets of arctic research. It is to the “inclusion of northern people as valued partners” in IPY-sponsored activities that the North by 2020 Working Group directed its attention. The intent is to provide a means for indigenous people to influence the IPY research agenda at all levels and to prepare a cohort of indigenous scholars to carry forward that research agenda to future generations of indigenous and nonindigenous researchers. The aspirations of indigenous peoples in relation to IPY extend beyond serving in a passive or advisory role in response to someone else’s research agenda. Indigenous peoples wish to shape the terms of that agenda and actively participate in its implementation. One of the most persistent constraints in fulfilling those aspirations has been a lack of recognition of indigenous peoples as having the qualifications and expertise to be “valued partners” in the research process. To overcome those constraints, indigenous scholars who have a high level of research expertise and an in-depth understanding of the dynamics at the interface between indigenous knowledge systems and western science must increase their preparation. These are issues of concern across the circumpolar region, and therefore this strategy for IPY-related research and graduate education is reflected in many recent reports on arctic research involving indigenous peoples. For example, the 2005 International Conference on Arctic Research Planning (ICARP II) held in Copenhagen included a working group on “Indigenous Peoples and Change in the Arctic: Adaptation, Adjustment and Empowerment,” which identified the distinguishing characteristics of indigenous peoples as follows: • • • • • • •
They are the aboriginal inhabitants of the region in which they live. They speak or spoke a language that is different from that of the dominant group. They are or were discriminated against within the legal and political systems. Their cultures diverge from that of the remaining society. Their languages, cultures, and values are endangered. Their cultures are based on herding, hunting, and fishing. They consider themselves and are considered by others to be different from the rest of the population. (ICARP II 2005)
Taken together, those characteristics clearly set indigenous peoples apart as inhabitants of the circumpolar region and call for distinct strategies in addressing their social, economic, political, and cultural needs. IPY-4 provided an opportunity to begin to address the concerns of indigenous peoples and the growing
60â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
recognition by multiple international actors that indigenous peoples in the Arctic have significance not only in the usual role as passive research subjects or “wards of the state” but also as agents of their own future. In 2004, the Arctic Council issued the Arctic Human Development Report, which highlighted three significant factors influencing the lives of indigenous peoples of the Arctic: controlling one’s own destiny, maintaining cultural identity, and living close to nature (Arctic Council 2004). Key to alleviating the negative effects and strengthening the positive contributions of these factors in people’s lives is the need for education and research efforts initiated in the Arctic by indigenous peoples themselves and by local institutions. As the Arctic Human Development Report indicated, Economic models and policies in modern arctic societies are traditionally designed and legitimated in administrative and political institutional contexts outside the Arctic. A key concern of future research should be to have a critical look at these contexts aiming at gaining new grounds for decision-making.╯.╯. . Indigenous Peoples of the Arctic have managed to carve out political regions in which they make up the majority, or at least a significant part of the population. Based upon this reality, Indigenous Peoples and communities are now actively involved in setting research agendas. This opens a completely new dynamic between researchers and arctic peoples. No longer seen as “objects” of research, Indigenous Peoples are active participants in new research initiatives increasingly based on partnerships, out of which new knowledge can be gained, general theory developed, and policy relevant recommendations for pressing contemporary issues can emerge. It is thus obvious that research agendas set by Indigenous Peoples themselves or reflecting indigenous cultures will be a key factor in setting research priorities for the next decade. (Arctic Council 2004) While these issues are of critical concern for indigenous peoples and communities in the circumpolar region, their significance is by no means limited to the Arctic. These are issues of broad international importance, as reflected in the 2005 United Nations report on the Status and Trends Regarding the Knowledge, Innovations and Practices of Indigenous and Local Communities, which concluded as follows: Indigenous Peoples are establishing new solutions in order to meet the challenges of modernity and overall change. These solutions,
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…61
for instance regarding the use of local knowledge in the context of resource management, can differ from each other quite radically. However, the cultural and traditional knowledge-related base is still there. The cases from different parts of the Arctic show that it is important to explore and document traditional knowledge for the benefit of the modern society and its needs and challenges. It is also important that holders of different knowledge and traditions, indigenous and non-indigenous, come together and listen carefully to each other’s concepts and perspectives. (HelanderRenvall 2005) Recognizing the need to address these issues in a systematic way, the National Science Foundation Office of Polar Programs convened a “Bridging the Poles” workshop in Washington DC in June 2004. The workshop brought together scientists, educators, and media specialists to outline an education and research agenda for IPY. Among their recommendations were the following: Communication with arctic Indigenous Peoples must include developing a new generation of researchers from the Arctic who actively investigate and communicate northern issues to global populations and decision makers. This theme of building capacity within communities, together with providing opportunities for personal contact and field experiences, making polar issues relevant at the community level, and developing mentoring and support systems, was articulated for each target group. Networking diverse communities together through common interests can have a long-lasting impact. (NSF 2004) Workshop participants then outlined the following objectives for IPY regarding the engagement of diverse communities: •
•
Arctic residents, including indigenous populations, are meaningfully engaged in developing and implementing polar research, education, and outreach, including community concerns and traditional knowledge, with an increase in the number of arctic residents—especially indigenous Alaskans—with PhDs. Focus on building capacity within indigenous communities for conducting research (including local collection of data) and education/outreach in both traditional and nontraditional venues. Community-based educational components should be developed for existing and planned long-term
62â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
•
observation networks, structured like GLOBE (Global Learning and Observations to Benefit the Environment) projects and tailored by community members to address community-relevant issues, and to involve both Native elders and scientists. Arctic research projects by Native people, for Native people, will involve finding funding sources and connecting them with Native communities. There can be varied tracks for community-based science education ranging from informal to certificate track to graduate degree track. Develop opportunities for all types of students. Recognizing that Native peoples have knowledge and traditions to share with other populations is an important first step toward their involvement. Their presence in the field of education, both traditional and nontraditional, will assist in encouraging more Natives and in providing a bridge to other cultures. Science information existing in their people through their elders and collective knowledge and practices has a place in current and future research. Respect for preserving their traditions must be considered in any program. (NSF 2004)
These objectives from the “Bridging the Poles” workshop have been at the core of the North by 2020 Working Groups initiative to engage a cohort of emerging indigenous scholars with the IPY research agenda. These scholars are prepared to address the complex issues at the interface between indigenous knowledge systems and western science. The American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), following a series of symposia on “Native Science” begun at the 2003 Annual Meeting, published the Handbook on Traditional Knowledge and Intellectual Property to guide “traditional knowledge holders in protecting their intellectual property and maintaining biological diversity.” In the handbook, AAAS published the following definition: Traditional knowledge is the information that people in a given community, based on experience and adaptation to a local culture and environment, have developed over time and continue to develop. This knowledge is used to sustain the community and its culture and to maintain the genetic resources necessary for the continued survival of the community. (Hansen and VanFleet 2003) Western scientific perspectives influence decisions that affect every aspect of indigenous people’s lives, from education to fish and wildlife management. As a consequence, indigenous people themselves are taking an active role in reasserting
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…63
their own traditions of science in various research and policymaking arenas. There is a growing awareness of the depth and breadth of knowledge that is extant in many indigenous societies and its potential value in addressing issues of contemporary concern, including the adaptive processes associated with a rapidly changing environment. The following observations in the Arctic Environmental Protection Strategy (Inuit Circumpolar Conference 1993) illustrate the point: Resolving the various concerns that Indigenous Peoples have about the development of scientific based information must be addressed through both policy and programs. This begins with reformulating the principles and guidelines within which research will be carried out and involves the process of consultation and the development of appropriate techniques for identifying problems that Indigenous Peoples wish to see resolved. But the most important step that must be taken is to assure that indigenous environmental and ecological knowledge becomes an information system that carries its own validity and recognition. A large effort is now underway in certain areas within the circumpolar region, as well as in other parts of the world, to establish these information systems and to set standards for their use. Actions taken by indigenous peoples over the past twenty years have begun to explain indigenous knowledge systems in ways that demonstrate their inherent validity and adaptability as complex entities with a logic and coherence of their own. As this shift evolves, it is not only indigenous people who are the beneficiaries; the issues that are being addressed are of significance in nonindigenous contexts as well. Problems of apathy, alienation, and anomie, which are evident under conditions of marginalization and disenfranchisement, have gravitated from the periphery to the center of postindustrial societies, so new insights that are emerging from indigenous societies are of equal benefit to the broader community. In an effort to begin to address the imbalance of emic and etic perspectives in indigenous contexts, the University of Alaska Fairbanks has obtained National Science Foundation funding under the Integrated Graduate Education, Research and Training program to implement a pilot program around the themes of resilience and adaptation in social–ecological systems. As an interdisciplinary graduate-level training and education program, Resilience and Adaptation (RAP) has focused on sustainability in times of rapid change and aimed at preparing scholars, policymakers, community leaders, and managers to address issues of sustainability in an integrated fashion. Through coursework, an internship experience, thesis research, and other training activities, students enrolled in PhD and master’s programs address a
64â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
major challenge facing humanity: sustaining the desirable features of Earth’s socialecological systems at a time of rapid change. The concepts of resilience, adaptation, vulnerability, and transformation serve as unifying themes in research examining global-to-local interactions. The program prepares students for positions of leadership in academia, government, nongovernment organizations, education, Native organizations, and agency management. A particular emphasis is placed on recruitment and participation of Alaska Natives and members of other indigenous groups (cf. http://www.uaf.edu/rap/). Most past research initiatives aimed at engaging indigenous people were designed from a nonindigenous, etic perspective and were focused on ways to make indigenous people understand the western/scientific view of the world (Langdon 2009; Sefa Dei et al. 2008; Smith 1999). Until recently, little attention was given to how western scientists and educators might better understand indigenous worldviews. Even less attention was given to what it means for participants when such divergent systems coexist in the same person, organization, or community. It is imperative, therefore, that we approach these issues on a two-way street rather than viewing the problem as a one-way challenge to get indigenous people to buy into the western system. Indigenous people may need to understand western society, but not at the expense of what they already know and the way they have come to know it. Nonindigenous people, too, need to recognize the coexistence of multiple worldviews and knowledge systems. They need to find ways to understand and relate to the world in its multiple dimensions of diversity and complexity. The incongruities between western institutional structures and practices and indigenous cultural forms have not been easy to reconcile. However, many of the indigenous initiatives associated with the International Polar Year have provided compelling evidence of the benefits that can be derived from pursuing collaborative research endeavors, as indicated by the chapters in the current collection.
Section Overview This section on “Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainability” begins with the “Anchorage Declaration,” a position statement drawn from the Indigenous Peoples’ Global Summit on Climate Change, which met in Anchorage, Alaska, April 20–24, 2009. The summit focused on the role of indigenous peoples in addressing the effects of climate change on their communities and cultures, referencing the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples as well as the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. At the heart of the Anchorage Declaration is a call for international action to “take the necessary measures to ensure the full and effective participation of indigenous
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…65
and local communities in formulating, implementing, and monitoring activities, mitigation, and adaptation relating to impacts of climate change.” In exchange for their participation in these efforts, indigenous peoples offered the following pledge: We offer to share with humanity our traditional knowledge, innovations, and practices relevant to climate change, provided our fundamental rights as intergenerational guardians of this knowledge are fully recognized and respected. We reiterate the urgent need for collective action. The subsequent chapters in this section provide examples of such collaborative and reciprocal actions as drawn from initiatives carried out during the Fourth International Polar Year. A reflective and perceptive contribution is found in observations on “My Place, My Identity,” by Angayuqaq Oscar Kawagley. As a Yupiaq scholar, Dr. Kawagley has been at the forefront in articulating the long-term consequences of climate change on the lives and livelihood of indigenous peoples, including the impact on worldviews and educational practices. His expansive perspective is followed by Steven R. Becker’s concrete examples of indigenous people’s responses to climate change and its implications for a sense of place and Native well-being. Of particular concern in Becker’s chapter, “A Changing Sense of Place: Climate and Native Well-Being,” are the threats to identity and livelihood as villages face relocation and even dissolution as a result of climate-induced thawing of permafrost and massive coastal and riverine erosion. The next chapter, “Values of Nushagak Bay: Past, Present, and Future,” by Todd Radenbaugh and Sarah Wingert Pederson, expands on the theme of changing patterns in climate, habitats, and economies. It explores the ways in which these changes are altering the foundations of traditional value systems derived from a deep association with the surrounding ecosystem over millennia. With these changes comes a competing value system with a more exploitative orientation to the environment, creating the challenge of finding ways to achieve a sustainable balance. Nowhere is the need for this balance more evident than in the imperative for sustainable food systems that can adapt to the accelerating changes in climate and environment. The next chapter in this section, “Food Systems, Environmental Change, and Community Needs in Rural Alaska,” by S. Craig Gerlach, Philip A. Loring, Amy Turner, and David E. Atkinson, highlights the importance of food security and the threats to local food systems. In an international system relying on the notion of state sovereignty, the rights of indigenous peoples have long been contested. Yet since the declaration of 1993 as the International Year for the World’s Indigenous Peoples, there has been a marked increase in the integration of indigenous knowledge in global assessments, agenda
66â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
setting, and policymaking. This trend is paralleled by a clearer recognition of the rights of indigenous peoples, including through the adoption by the UN General Assembly in 2007 of the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. In her chapter, Pia M. Kohler provides an overview of the evolution of participation by indigenous peoples in global environmental politics in particular, including the essential role of indigenous knowledge in shaping global policies and institutions. In the chapter “Indigenous Contributions to Sustainability,” Ray Barnhardt examines the interface between indigenous communities and the institutional environments in which their lives are situated. He identifies the structures and relationships that are needed to produce a life and livelihood that are sustainable in both the local and global contexts. A central construct in this and the preceding chapters is the rights of indigenous people and the need for them to bring their own worldviews and knowledge systems to the decision-making arenas that affect their lives. Self-determination and self-government are no longer hollow aspirations; they serve as the foundation of a sustainable future for indigenous peoples around the world. In the last chapter of the indigenous knowledge section, Mary Beth Leigh, Krista Katalenich, Cynthia Hardy, and Pia M. Kohler report on “Climate Change and Creative Expression,” an interdisciplinary art/science course developed for middle-school children at Effie Kokrine Charter School in Fairbanks, Alaska. With a 90% enrollment of Alaska Native children, the Effie Kokrine School emphasizes Native culture and values. The course, which integrated creative writing and dance with climate change science, culminated in a book of poetry and a public performance. The students created readings, theater, dance, and music that communicated their knowledge, thoughts, and feelings about climate change in Alaska.
Sustainability of Social-Ecological Systems Indigenous peoples throughout the world have sustained their unique worldviews and associated knowledge systems for millennia, even while undergoing major social upheavals as a result of forces beyond their control. Many of the core values, beliefs, and practices associated with those worldviews are recognized as having an adaptive integrity that is as relevant today as it was for generations past. The deep indigenous knowledge rooted in the long inhabitation of a particular place offers insights that can benefit everyone, including educators and scientists, as we search for a more satisfying and sustainable way to live on this planet. The task of achieving sustainability within a context of rapid change hinges on our ability to demonstrate that we can forge a reciprocal relationship that has relevance to local indigenous societies as well as in the broader social, political,
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…67
and educational arenas. Using research strategies that link the ways of knowing already established in local communities and cultures with western science will enable indigenous people to find value in what emerges and put new insights into practice toward achieving their own ends. The knowledge gained from these efforts will further our understanding of basic human processes associated with the transmission of knowledge in all forms. Bringing the research expertise and educational capabilities associated with the IPY into direct involvement with indigenous scholars and communities has served a capacity-building function. It has provided a potential “multiplier effect” in underdeveloped areas on a range of socioeconomic indices, including health, education, and economic well-being. IPY has focused on an interdisciplinary, crossinstitutional, and cross-cultural research endeavor. It is well positioned to ensure that community and institutional participants and the infrastructure supporting them will move forward on a pathway to becoming self-sufficient and sustainable beyond the life of the Fourth International Polar Year.
References Arctic Council. 2004. Arctic human development report. Copenhagen: Arctic Council. Hansen, S. A., and J. W. VanFleet. 2003. Traditional knowledge and intellectual property. Washington DC: American Association for the Advancement of Science. Helander-Renvall, E. 2005. Composite report on status and trends regarding the knowledge, innovations and practices of indigenous and local communities: Arctic region. Geneva, Switzerland: United Nations Environment Programme. ICARP II. 2005. Working group on indigenous peoples and change in the Arctic: Adaptation, adjustment and empowerment. Copenhagen: International Conference on Arctic Research Planning II. Inuit Circumpolar Conference. 1993. Arctic environmental protection strategy: A research program on indigenous knowledge. Nuuk, Greenland. Langdon, J. (ed.). 2009. Indigenous knowledges, development and education. Rotterdam: Sense Publisher. National Science Foundation (NSF). 2004. Bridging the Poles. Washington DC: Office of Polar Programs. Sefa Dei, G. J., B. L. Hall, and D. G. Rosenberg (eds.). 2008. Indigenous knowledges in global contexts. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Smith, L. T. 1999. Decolonizing methodologies: Research and indigenous peoples. New York: Zed Books.
2.2
The Anchorage Declaration submitted by patricia cochran
Indigenous Peoples’ Global Summit on Climate Change
F
rom April 20 to 24, 2009, indigenous representatives from the Arctic, North America, Asia, the Pacific, Latin America, Africa, the Caribbean, and Russia met in Anchorage, Alaska, for the Indigenous Peoples’ Global Summit on Climate Change. We thank the Ahtna and the Dena’ina Athabascan Peoples in whose lands we gathered. We express our solidarity as Indigenous Peoples living in areas that are the most vulnerable to the impacts and root causes of climate change. We reaffirm the unbreakable and sacred connection between land, air, water, oceans, forests, sea ice, plants, animals, and our human communities as the material and spiritual basis for our existence. We are deeply alarmed by the accelerating climate devastation brought about by unsustainable development. We are experiencing profound and disproportionate adverse impacts on our cultures, human and environmental health, human rights, well-being, traditional livelihoods, food systems and food sovereignty, local infrastructure, economic viability, and our very survival as Indigenous Peoples. Mother Earth is no longer in a period of climate change, but in climate crisis. We therefore insist on an immediate end to the destruction and desecration of the elements of life. Through our knowledge, spirituality, sciences, practices, experiences, and relationships with our traditional lands, territories, waters, air, forests, oceans, sea ice, other natural resources, and all life, Indigenous Peoples have a vital role in
69
70â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
defending and healing Mother Earth. The future of Indigenous Peoples lies in the wisdom of our elders, the restoration of the sacred position of women, the youth of today, and in the generations of tomorrow. We uphold that the inherent and fundamental human rights and status of Indigenous Peoples, affirmed in the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), must be fully recognized and respected in all decision-making processes and activities related to climate change. This includes our rights to our lands, territories, environment, and natural resources as contained in Articles 25–30 of the UNDRIP. When specific programs and projects affect our lands, territories, environment, and natural resources, the right of selfdetermination of Indigenous Peoples must be recognized and respected, emphasizing our right to free, prior, and informed consent, including the right to say “no.” The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) agreements and principles must reflect the spirit and the minimum standards contained in UNDRIP.
Calls for Action 1.
In order to achieve the fundamental objective of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), we call upon the fifteenth meeting of the Conference of the Parties to the UNFCCC to support a binding emissions reduction target for developed countries of at least 45% below 1990 levels by 2020 and at least 95% by 2050. In recognizing the root causes of climate change, participants call upon states to work toward decreasing dependency on fossil fuels. We further call for a just transition to decentralized renewable energy economies, sources, and systems owned and controlled by our local communities to achieve energy security and sovereignty. In addition, the summit participants agreed to present two options for action, each of which was supported by one or more of the participating regional caucuses. These were as follows: a. We call for the phase out of fossil fuel development and a moratorium on new fossil fuel development on or near indigenous lands and territories. b. We call for a process that works toward the eventual phase out of fossil fuels, without infringing on the right to development of indigenous nations. 2. We call upon the parties to the UNFCCC to recognize the importance of our traditional knowledge and practices shared by Indigenous Peoples
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…71
3.
4.
5.
6.
in developing strategies to address climate change. To address climate change, we also call on the UNFCCC to recognize the historical and ecological debt of the Annex 1 countries in contributing to greenhouse gas emissions. We call on these countries to pay this historical debt. We call upon the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, and other relevant institutions to support Indigenous Peoples in carrying out Indigenous Peoples’ climate change assessments. We call upon the UNFCCC’s decision-making bodies to establish formal structures and mechanisms for and with the full and effective participation of Indigenous Peoples. Specifically we recommend that the UNFCCC: a. Organize regular technical briefings by Indigenous Peoples on traditional knowledge and climate change; b. Recognize and engage the International Indigenous Peoples’ Forum on Climate Change and its regional focal points in an advisory role; c. Immediately establish an indigenous focal point in the secretariat of the UNFCCC; d. Appoint Indigenous Peoples’ representatives in UNFCCC funding mechanisms in consultation with Indigenous Peoples; e. Take the necessary measures to ensure the full and effective participation of indigenous and local communities in formulating, implementing, and monitoring activities, mitigation, and adaptation relating to the impacts of climate change. All initiatives under Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation (REDD) must secure the recognition and implementation of the human rights of Indigenous Peoples, including security of land tenure, ownership, recognition of land title according to traditional ways, uses and customary laws, and the multiple benefits of forests for climate, ecosystems, and peoples, before taking any action. We challenge states to abandon false solutions to climate change that negatively impact Indigenous Peoples’ rights, lands, air, oceans, forests, territories, and waters. These include nuclear energy, large-scale dams, geo-engineering techniques, “clean coal,” agro-fuels, plantations, and market-based mechanisms such as carbon trading, the Clean Development Mechanism, and forest offsets. The human rights of Indigenous Peoples to protect our forests and forest livelihoods must be recognized, respected, and ensured.
72â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
7.
8. 9.
10.
11.
12.
We call for adequate and direct funding in developed and developing states and for a fund to be created to enable Indigenous Peoples’ full and effective participation in all climate processes, including adaptation, mitigation, monitoring, and transfer of appropriate technologies in order to foster our empowerment, capacity building, and education. We strongly urge relevant United Nations bodies to facilitate and fund the participation, education, and capacity building of indigenous youth and women to ensure engagement in all international and national processes related to climate change. We call upon financial institutions to provide risk insurance for Indigenous Peoples to allow them to recover from extreme weather events. We call upon all United Nations agencies to address climate change impacts in their strategies and action plans, in particular their impacts on Indigenous Peoples, including the World Health Organization (WHO), United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), and United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues (UNPFII). In particular, we call upon the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and all other relevant United Nations bodies to establish an Indigenous Peoples’ working group to address the impacts of climate change on food security and food sovereignty for Indigenous Peoples. We call upon the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) to conduct a fast-track assessment of short-term drivers of climate change, specifically black carbon, with a view to initiating negotiation of an international agreement to reduce emissions of black carbon. We call upon states to recognize, respect, and implement the fundamental human rights of Indigenous Peoples, including the collective rights to traditional ownership, use, access, occupancy, and title to traditional lands, air, forests, waters, oceans, sea ice, and sacred sites, as well as to ensure that the rights affirmed in treaties are upheld and recognized in land use planning and climate change mitigation strategies. In particular, states must ensure that Indigenous Peoples have the right to mobility and are not forcibly removed or settled away from their traditional lands and territories, and that the rights of peoples in voluntary isolation are upheld. In the case of climate change migrants, appropriate programs and measures must address their rights, status, conditions, and vulnerabilities. We call upon states to return and restore lands, territories, waters, forests, oceans, sea ice, and sacred sites that have been taken from Indigenous
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…73
Peoples, limiting our access to our traditional ways of living, thereby causing us to misuse and expose our lands to activities and conditions that contribute to climate change. 13. In order to provide the resources necessary for our collective survival in response to the climate crisis, we declare our communities, waters, air, forests, oceans, sea ice, traditional lands, and territories to be “Food Sovereignty Areas,” defined and directed by Indigenous Peoples according to customary laws, free from extractive industries, deforestation, and chemical-based industrial food production systems (i.e., contaminants, agro-fuels, genetically modified organisms). 14. We encourage our communities to exchange information while ensuring the protection and recognition of and respect for the intellectual property rights of Indigenous Peoples at the local, national, and international levels pertaining to our traditional knowledge, innovations, and practices. These include knowledge and use of land, water, and sea ice, traditional agriculture, forest management, ancestral seeds, pastoralism, food plants, animals, and medicines and are essential in developing climate change adaptation and mitigation strategies, restoring our food sovereignty and food independence, and strengthening our indigenous families and nations. We offer to share with humanity our traditional knowledge, innovations, and practices relevant to climate change, provided our fundamental rights as intergenerational guardians of this knowledge are fully recognized and respected. We reiterate the urgent need for collective action. Agreed by consensus of the participants in the Indigenous Peoples’ Global Summit on Climate Change, Anchorage, Alaska, April 24, 2009.
2.3
My Place, My Identity by angayuqaq oscar kawagley editors’ note by ray barnhardt and pia m. kohler
Editors’ Note
T
he following essay was prepared by Angayuqaq Oscar Kawagley in response to an invitation from the editors of this section. Oscar is a Yupiaq Eskimo who was raised by his grandmother in a traditional fish camp setting in southwestern Alaska. Oscar’s upbringing meant that he was immersed in many of the ways of the old people. His grandmother spoke no English, and Yupiaq was his first language. It was his generation that experienced a time of great change as Native people throughout Alaska emerged from a traditional lifestyle to encounter the western world. In particular, Oscar learned the strong connections between language and culture, and he learned to respect the environment and live in harmony with it. This grounding in the Yupiaq language, culture, and environment gave Oscar the unique qualities and perspectives that enabled him to work between two very different worlds later in life. He went on to break ground as the first Yupiaq to become a teacher, to complete a master’s degree, to earn a PhD, and to become a faculty member at the University of Alaska Fairbanks. He completed his PhD in 1992 at the University of British Columbia, with his scholarly pursuits culminating in the publication of his book, A Yupiaq Worldview: A Pathway to Ecology and Spirit, now available in its second edition. Oscar has published numerous additional articles that are widely read and cited for their contribution to our understanding of the intersection of indigenous knowledge systems and western science. (Oscar’s essays are available on the Alaska Native Knowledge Network website at www.ankn.uaf.edu.) Few people are as skilled as Angayuqaq Oscar Kawagley in bridging the western academic/scientific world and that of indigenous peoples. The past four 75
76â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
decades have seen Alaska Native people struggle to have their voices, issues, and concerns heard by the western world and to have meaningful roles in institutional and governmental decision making that affects their lives. Oscar has been a highly influential and effective voice for Alaska Natives in dealing with policy and program development in a wide variety of fields. He has worked to develop culturally sensitive curriculum materials, conduct collaborative scientific research, foster cross-cultural understanding and communications, and assert basic human rights. Among many other positions, he has served as a commissioner on the Alaska Native Science Commission since its inception. Oscar’s leadership has been recognized at the highest level, as reflected in the numerous invitations he has received to contribute to national and international forums on a wide range of issues. He participated in a United Nations Commission on Human Rights project to develop guidelines for UN-sponsored indigenous human rights education initiatives. In 2004 he received the Alaska Governor’s Award for the Arts and Humanities, citing his forty years of service to the state of Alaska, and in 2009 he was granted emeritus status at the University of Alaska Fairbanks. Dr. Kawagley brings unique qualities and perspectives to bear on contemporary social and ecological issues, and he has demonstrated his ability to make original scholarly and public service contributions to his field in ways that are having a significant impact locally, nationally, and internationally. We are honored to include Oscar’s voice in this collection.
My Place, My Identity
by angayuqaq oscar kawagley I recently watched a television program titled “You Own Alaska.” My first reaction was that this was an expression motivated by political and economic interests. But the more I thought about it, the more it grated on my worldview. How could anyone “own” Alaska? According to my ancestral traditions, the land owns me! Thus began my reflections on how my Yupiaq worldview differs from that of the dominant society. The cold defines my place. Mamterilleq (now known as Bethel, Alaska) made me who I am. The cold made my language, my worldview, my culture and technology. Now, the cold is waning at a very fast rate and, as a result, it is changing the landscape. The changing landscape, in turn, is confusing the mindscape of the Yupiat and other indigenous people. Some of the natural sense makers of Mother Nature are out of synchronization with the flora and fauna. We, the Yupiat of the Kuskokwim River, used the leafing of the alder tree to tell us when the smelts would journey up the river and we could begin dip netting
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…77
for them. When the alder leaves emerge from the bud, the king salmon will be arriving, and so on. But these indicators are no longer reliable when spring arrives two to four weeks earlier than usual. This is just one example of the changes that are taking place in the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta. In times past, the landscape formed our mindscape, which in turn formed our identity. I grew up as an inseparable part of Nature. It was not my place to “own” land or to domesticate plants or animals, which often have more power than I as a human being. We know that Mother Nature has a culture, and it is a Native culture. This is why we as a Native people have to emulate Her. We know that the Ellam Yua, the Person or Spirit of the Universe, lives in Her. That is why she serves as our guide, teacher, and mentor. We need to spend much time in Nature to commune with the Great Consciousness. This gives balance to the Native person. Mother Nature encourages us to become altruistic, showing the utmost respect for everything around us, including the flora and fauna, the winds, the rivers, the lakes, the mountains, the clouds, the stars, the Milky Way, the sun, the moon, and the ocean currents. Mother Earth gives me everything I need to know and be able to do to problemsolve. But times have changed, making living a life in concert with Mother Earth more difficult. Missionaries and the educational system had the first impact. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, schools were introduced to the Yupiat people by the Christian churches under contract with the US government. Boarding schools were established for Alaska Native youngsters. The education provided was organized to assimilate the Native people into the techno-mechanistic and consumerist worldview. The education was oppressive and suppressive of the Native language and culture. By this time, the United States had become adept at organizing and administering boarding schools for American Indians. Native children were taken away from their parents and villages for long periods of time. They would return to their home villages, but they no longer fit in. Their wants and desires were averse to the village life. The assimilative education was so effective, it caused most Native youngsters to suppress their own Nativeness. From the late 1960s and up to the present, Native people have been working diligently to change education so that it accommodates their languages, worldviews, culture, and technology. This is a slow healing process for the villages. Our educational mission is to produce human beings at home in their place, their environment, their world. This is slowly being brought to fruition through the efforts of the Native people themselves, with support from others of like thinking. The Yupiat have been proactive in reorienting the education system for their children and are now proving to be equally proactive in dealing with the effects of
78â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
climate change. They are looking at how our ancestors dealt with climate change in the past and applying what they learn to the present. Once they have an idea of what might be done, they devise a plan and ask for technical assistance from engineers, hydrologists, geographers, and other scientists whose knowledge and skills will give them the best guidance. For example, the village of Newtok, which has suffered from extensive erosion, has taken a leadership role in planning the move of their village, including seeking finances, looking at a possible new site for the village, and asking elders and geologists to provide an assessment of whether their choices are right. This is a villageled design and organization for moving everything, including the homes, airfield, water well, and other community facilities. The Yupiat are also proactive in cleaning spawning areas for salmon. They meet periodically with state fisheries experts to let them know their concerns and to address issues in which they need technical help. Native people realize that the traditional ways of knowing and doing can benefit from technical assistance provided by the various disciplinary sciences to strengthen their plans and work. Working together, the two ways of knowing are much more powerful and, we hope, more conducive to doing the right thing. It is through such collaborations that the historic clash of worldviews as reflected in the phrase “You Own Alaska” can become a force for new understandings and solutions to the many challenges we face together.
2.4
A Changing Sense of Place: Climate and Native Well-Being by steven r. becker
T
he United Nations identifies indigenous peoples by a variety of factors, one of which is their special relationship with traditional lands—a relationship that “has a fundamental importance for their collective physical and cultural survival as peoples” (Chakrabarti 2007). Indigenous peoples actively draw on the power of their place physically and spiritually (Deloria and Wildcat 2001), forming a tie to traditional lands that can transcend generations living in an urban setting far removed from those lands (NUIFC 2008). “It is this .╯.╯. place-based existence .╯.╯. that fundamentally distinguishes Indigenous Peoples from other peoples of the world” (Alfred and Corntassel 2005). But what happens to indigenous peoples when changes in global climate drastically alter the land itself ? Global climate is naturally variable, and indigenous peoples have successfully weathered those changes through a number of adaptation strategies (Houser et al. 2001). However, the current warming trend is happening at an alarming and unprecedented rate, with the arctic region changing even faster than the global average (ACIA 2004). Noticeable and substantial shifts in weather patterns, ice formation, flora, and fauna are being observed, often within a single generation (Krupnik and Jolly 2002). These changes are profoundly affecting arctic peoples. Alaska Native elder Angayuqaq Oscar Kawagley has stated on numerous occasions that “the Yupiaq are defined by the cold” (Kawagley 2008). But now the cold is going away, and the land and its patterns are changing. What happens to your sense of place as the plant and animal people to whom your parents and grandparents introduced you travel on, and new neighbors take their place? What effect might that have on your sense of well-being, your sense of self ? This chapter will discuss the role that sense
79
80â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
of place has in Native well-being, review some of the potential impacts that climate change may have on the environment, and explore the resulting impacts on sense of place and Native well-being. Finally, this chapter presents some recommendations compiled from interviews with Native elders and scholars about how to maintain individual and cultural identity in the face of climate change.
Sense of Place in Native Well-Being “Sense of place” can be defined as belonging, attachment, and individual or collective ownership of a particular location, especially a community (Tapley 2003). For indigenous peoples, this concept of community comprises not only human beings but also the landscape and its nonhuman inhabitants (Ferguson 2005). Indigenous peoples have an inherent spiritual relationship with the land (Tofa 2006). Their traditional land is “the cradle of their being, its spirituality engulfs and dominates their belief system” (Tapley 2003). Because of these factors, sense of place for indigenous peoples is an “intertwining of the boundaries of land, tribe, and self ” ( Jones and Hunter 2003). Elizabeth Ferguson states this relationship eloquently: For example, if I say: “I am part of the land,” it is not due to an ecological affinity with the land, rather, it is because the bones of my ancestors become the land, and the land includes all our stories, ceremony and history. This makes the land a part of me; the land is my relative. I am in direct relationship with that land. It is my blood. (Ferguson 2005:26–27) The land (including the plants, animals, and other spirits it is shared with) is an extension of one’s being. The mountains and rivers are an intrinsic part of indigenous identity ( Jones and Hunter 2003), and place and identity are one and the same (Ferguson 2005). Because of this close relationship between place and self, physical isolation from the land can be traumatic for an indigenous individual or for an entire people. In describing the Maori experience, Jones and Hunter (2003) describe the loss of traditional lands as “equivalent to the psychological alienation from identity, much like amnesia due to trauma.” Although for many indigenous peoples, colonization and assimilation pressures and physical isolation from traditional lands have blurred the strong tie between place and identity (Redman 2008), even indigenous peoples living for generations in urban settings will often seek out Native organizations in part to connect with others who are physically removed from their homelands
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…81
(NUIFC 2008). It is because of this close relationship to the land that global climate change has the potential for devastating effects on Native well-being.
Global Climate Change Over the last one hundred fifty years, an exponential increase in the combustion of fossil fuels and various industrial activities have led to an increase in atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide (~30% increase) and methane (~150% increase), which are two of the more abundant greenhouse gases (GHGs). These changes, exacerbated by an associated increase in atmospheric water vapor, have intensified the natural greenhouse effect, resulting in long-term changes in the global climate (MacCracken et al. 2001). The Arctic is now experiencing some of the most rapid and severe climate change on earth (ACIA 2004). According to Edward Parson, Lynne Carter, and others who were part of the 2001 study Climate Change Impacts on the United States, significant changes have been seen in the past century: • • • • •
Alaska’s climate has warmed about 2.2° Celsius (4° Fahrenheit) since the 1950s and 3.9° Celsius (7° Fahrenheit) in the Interior in winter. Most of the state has grown wetter, with a 30% average precipitation increase between 1968 and 1990. The growing season has lengthened by about fourteen days. Dramatic reductions in sea ice and permafrost have accompanied the recent warming. Alaska’s warming is part of a larger arctic trend corroborated by many independent measurements of sea ice, glaciers, permafrost, vegetation, and snow cover.
The rate of change is also increasing. Air temperatures in Alaska, Siberia, and Canada have risen 1.0° Celsius (2° Fahrenheit) in the past decade, compared to the global average of 0.6° Celsius (1.2° Fahrenheit) in the past century (Rosen 2004). Severe impacts related to climate change are already being experienced in Alaska. The warming trend described above has been accompanied by several decades of thawing in discontinuous permafrost, causing increased ground subsidence, erosion, landslides, and disruption and damage to forests, buildings, and infrastructure. Sea ice off the Alaskan coast is retreating (14% since 1978) and thinning (40% since the 1960s), with widespread effects on marine ecosystems, coastal climate, human settlements, and subsistence activities (Parson et al. 2001). George Canellos of the US Denali Commission gave the following testimony before the Alaska Climate Impact Assessment Commission in 2007:
82â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
When I studied regional planning at the University of Pennsylvania, we learned from the great hydrologist Luna Leopold that lakes are the most ephemeral of surface water features. Few lakes are older than a few thousand years, and they often follow a process of shrinkage, encroachment by meadows and eventual disappearance. Like a total solar eclipse, however, I never thought I would see a lake vanish in my lifetime. When I lived in Bethel in the early 80s, our subdivision was platted around two tundra lakes. When I returned last summer (2006), one had disappeared, changing magically into a green swath of tundra. Locals say it happened quickly in a matter of weeks last summer, the water simply disappearing into the ground. Did a warming trend melt enough permafrost to allow the water to drain away? I’ll leave that conjecture to others. (Canellos 2007:1) If a western scientist such as Canellos can observe such changes, how much more apparent are they to Native elders whose lives are tied to the land? The following are some observations from Iñupiaq elders participating in the US Department of Energy’s Atmospheric Radiation Measurement Program (ARM 2007): Sadie Neakok: Climate change has affected the river ice. In the past, the ice was frozen and secure enough to set nets for gill net fishing in September. Now the ice doesn’t freeze until October. Percy Nusunginya: Climate change has affected the shore-fast sea ice and where a lead occurs in the ice. This affects where the animals are available and consequently affects food availability for people. Arnold Brower Sr.: Drier weather in Barrow affects plants. Berries, a traditional subsistence food, do not grow well in the drier weather. I believe that climate change has also affected wildlife in the area. There are many small birds and migratory wildlife that used to be abundant but are no longer around. George Leavitt: Climate change on the North Slope has increased erosion greatly. My house used to be forty feet away from the bluff, but in the last twenty to twenty-five years, there has been so much erosion, the house is now directly next to the bluff.
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…83
Harry Brower Jr.: The sea ice is thinner now than ever before. Whale hunters need to be even more cautious because of thawing and cracks in the ice. Eugene Brower: In the fall and spring is when I see the greatest changes. It is warmer in the spring than usual and it freezes later in the fall. Also, we aren’t getting the multi-year ice to the degree we used to have in the fall time. These quotes demonstrate the detailed level of observation of local conditions by indigenous peoples through their close ties to the land that helps define them. The ARM program is not the only project incorporating indigenous observations into western scientific research. Indigenous observations of arctic environmental change is the theme of the book The Earth Is Faster Now (Krupnik and Jolly 2002), which includes extensive and detailed observations related to weather patterns and variability, snow and ice conditions, water levels in rivers and lakes, and wildlife populations. These observations are evidence of the profound impacts of climate change on the indigenous peoples of the Arctic and their way of life.
Impacts of Climate Change on Indigenous Peoples Global climate change is already having immediate physical impacts on indigenous communities in the Arctic (Parson et al. 2001). According to a 2003 report by the US General Accounting Office (GAO 2003), 184 Native villages in Alaska (~80%) are subject to increasing erosion, flooding, or both due at least in part to climate change. These impacts are exacerbated by the fact that indigenous communities often lack the economic and technical resources available to nonindigenous communities to respond to social and environmental challenges. Indigenous peoples within a colonizing society tend to have higher rates of significant health problems, more insecure and inadequate housing, comparatively lower standards of education and training, and lower economic standards of living than their nonindigenous counterparts. These factors render indigenous peoples in general more vulnerable to the physical impacts of climate change (CANA 2006). The heavy reliance on subsistence resources in Arctic communities adds another physical vulnerability to climate change. Indigenous communities depend on their environment for many types of resources. A changing climate puts such resources at risk and will affect both sustenance and cultural dependence on those resources (Houser et al. 2001). Present climate change already poses drastic threats
84â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
to subsistence livelihoods of Alaska Natives, as many populations of marine mammals, fish, and seabirds have been reduced or displaced due to retreat and thinning of sea ice and other changes. In a press briefing held on October 23, 2007, Elijah Lane, a member of the Native Village of Point Hope and director of its Parks and Wildlife Department, said, As a member of the next generation of subsistence whalers and hunters, I’m seeing the effects of climate change in all I do. I have seen the erosion and the disappearing ice in the Chukchi Sea. I have seen the changes in the migrations of animals on the land and in the water as a result of climate change in Alaska. (Dickson et al. 2007:2) Projected climate changes are likely to intensify these impacts. In the longer term, projected ecosystem shifts are likely to further displace or alter the resources available for subsistence, requiring communities to change their practices or move (Parson et al. 2001). Because of individual, cultural, and spiritual ties to the land, relocation is not easy for a Native community. Residents of Shishmaref, a village of six hundred people located on a barrier island in the Chukchi Sea, are planning to relocate their village to the mainland due to severe erosion problems. The US government proposed relocating the people of Shishmaref to other villages in the area but, according to Luci Eningowuk, chair of the Shishmaref Erosion and Relocation Coalition, abandoning their ancestral homeland with its traditional food supply “would have a devastating impact on how we exist and who we are” (quoted in Rosen 2004). Perhaps more devastating than the immediate physical impacts on indigenous peoples are the social and cultural impacts triggered by these changes. The climate and landscape provide an important sense of place for Native peoples, who are integral to the natural environment. As vegetation and wildlife species and patterns shift, indigenous peoples’ relationship with their environment, which has been sustained through many generations, is likely to change (Houser et al. 2001). Native peoples will lose the indicators they use to predict natural conditions and coordinate the timing of events (Kawagley 2008). As Shari Fox observes, this will lead to substantial distress for individuals and the community: For example, consider how extremely skilled elders and hunters can no longer predict the weather as they have in the past. No longer able to be confident in their predictions, some elders and hunters are genuinely distressed, not only because they can no lon-
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…85
ger advise travel parties with assurance, but because their personal relationship with the weather itself has changed. (Fox 2002:43) The cultural context of Native peoples is being disrupted (Houser et al. 2001), and that disruption is likely to continue for the foreseeable future. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC 2007), even if greenhouse gas emissions ceased today, global average surface air temperatures would continue to rise an additional 1° Celsius (~2° Fahrenheit). All of the models show similar temperature increases for the next several decades, leading the IPCC to conclude that “adaptation will be necessary to address impacts resulting from the warming which is already unavoidable due to past emissions” (IPCC 2007). The Climate Change Impacts on the United States study had the following predictions for Alaska during the coming century (Parson et al. 2001): •
• •
Continued strong warming, reaching 0.8–2.8° Celsius (1.5–5° Fahrenheit) by 2030, and 2.8–10° Celsius (5–18° Fahrenheit) by 2100, strongest in the Interior and north and during winter
Continued precipitation increases, reaching 20–25% in the north and northwest, with areas of decrease along the south coast Increased evaporation from warming will more than offset increased precipitation, making soils drier in most of the state
When changes of this magnitude are taking place, it is easy to fall into despair. Kawagley (2008) speaks of the emotional reaction associated with the loss of natural indicators and the cultural context associated with a changing landscape: I think that it will be kind of horrific, psychologically.╯.╯. . It would be just like losing a family member. There would be a lot of grief attached to it, because they have known it for so long, then all of a sudden it is gone. This type of grief may be difficult to recover from, and for indigenous peoples, who are already facing pressures from the loss of language and traditions, the changing landscape could be the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back. As Justine Rose Webb of Murdoch University wrote regarding the changes to the traditional landscape associated with the colonization of the Pilbara region of Australia, “When the very essence of your life is taken away, like a line of dominos, the momentum pushing you down can be the easiest way to fall” (Webb 2003).
86â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Maintaining Identity through Climate Change In light of the bleak outlook painted above, how do indigenous peoples maintain their identity, their sense of individual and communal self, throughout these changing times? Unfortunately there is no single easy answer to that question, but some ideas that have been put forth may assist a community in preparing for change. The ideas presented below have been shared by indigenous elders, leaders, and scholars from multiple cultures, including Dr. Angayuqaq Oscar Kawagley and Stanley Tom (Yupiaq), Howard Luke and Randy Mayo (Athabascan), Tony Weyiouanna Jr. (Iñupiaq), Mervyn Tano (Native Hawaiian), Margaret LaPray (Niimi’ipuu), and others with whom I have had the honor of working over the years. This chapter draws heavily on the work of Dr. Kawagley. However, like all things in nature, there are no broad lines or sharp demarcations here between these elders and their specific ideas. Rather, their teachings are woven together and cycle back to one another as the seasons of the year, and the lessons need to be used the same way.
Have Confidence in Yourself First, indigenous peoples need to have faith in their innate adaptability. This and the experiences and lessons that have been learned about coping with climate fluctuations have sustained Native cultures through many generations (Houser et al. 2001). In addition, the environmental balances that sustained Native peoples in North America for many millennia began shifting rapidly about five hundred years ago. While there is clear evidence that indigenous peoples manipulated the environment to meet their needs, it was on the whole done with an awareness of their relationship with the land and a level of respect and reciprocation that improved the robustness and sustainability of the ecosystem (Barsh 2004). This respect and reciprocation changed on a massive scale with the beginning of European colonization. Forests were cut for farming. Exotic grasses and crops were imported to replace native grasslands. Rivers and streams were dammed and channeled. Uplands were flooded and ponds and swamps drained away. Key wildlife species were harvested to near extinction, and domesticated and imported animals displaced other traditional species (Houser et al. 2001). Since the advent of European colonization, indigenous peoples have also faced substantial social challenges. Treaties have been broken, tribes scattered or “consolidated,” and entire nations have been forced to leave their homelands (Houser et al. 2001). Diseases have eradicated whole villages (Napoleon 1996), missionary schools have tried to educate and convert Alaska Natives out of their Native ways (Kawagley 2006), and government policies have tried both genocide and
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…87
assimilation (Deloria 1988). As Nancy Maynard stated in the Final Report: Native Peoples—Native Homelands Climate Change Workshop in 1998, The fact that North American indigenous societies have survived into the 21st century, with cultures, traditions, languages, and portions of their Native homelands relatively intact, speaks of a respectful and enduring reliance upon traditional ecological knowledge, spiritual strength, and cultural adaptations. (Maynard 1998:ii) Her words are echoed by Kawagley, who maintains that to keep their adaptability, indigenous peoples must be well grounded in their culture and traditional knowledge (Kawagley 2008).
Be Grounded in Your Culture In his paper Oral Traditions in the First Steps toward Decolonization, Leo Killsback (2006) states that “Indian people need to look to their oral traditions to understand, find guidance, and seek solutions to the problems they face.” This is true particularly for problems related to climate change. The oral histories not only tell them what past climate was like, they also frequently contain lessons on what the community did to adjust and survive. Thus, the retelling of these stories by elders can help teach younger generations how to adapt to adversity (Houser et al. 2001). However, indigenous peoples must not fall into the western trap of looking only backward and viewing traditional knowledge as a static body of knowledge. Traditional knowledge is the information that people in a given community, based on experience and adaptation to a local culture and environment, have developed, and continue to develop, over time (Tano 2006). It will be critical to continue to build on and develop traditional knowledge during these times of change. As Kawagley (2008) states, In my area we used to use the alder leaves coming out to tell us when the smelts are going to be coming and just when they are beginning to break out the [King] salmon will be here, then the chum salmon, and then the silver salmon when it is completely leafed out. Hey, but that’s not applicable anymore because summer comes a month early, and spring comes a month early, and so that affects us. And so something, a sense-maker, that we have depended on for a long, a very long time, all of a sudden is no
88â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
longer; useless. So we’ve got to find out the process for generating new knowledge, something that is more applicable.╯.╯. . We’ve got to generate new ways of coming up with natural sense-makers. Kawagley’s emphasis here is on the process inherent in traditional knowledge. In many indigenous communities, the traditional knowledge that is currently being passed down is more often the substance (knowledge and skills handed down over generations) rather than knowledge of the process (forming knowledge through practical engagement with the environment) of generating or modifying traditional knowledge. Both of these traditions are required to construct a body of knowledge that will help best deal with the changing environment (Fox 2002). Oral traditions are about more than just skills and signs, however. They are also about learning the appropriate rules of behavior for the culture (Oleksa 2005). The world of indigenous peoples is a changing and changeable one, influenced by the ceremonies that honor the cycles of the world: sunrises and sunsets, the phases of the moon, the cycle of the seasons, and the spirits of plant, animal, earth, and river. Rites of renewal are performed to honor the spirit of life, to provide reciprocity in the form of ceremony, storytelling, dance, or song. Renewal revives, respects, resurrects, and reveres relationships with the world. Many indigenous peoples believe that if they break their compacts with the animate world, they will surely suffer the consequences (Ferguson 2005). In the Yupiaq pre-contact tradition, these rites and rules of behavior were generally kept by the shaman, or spiritual leader, of the community. However, the absence of practicing shamans in Yupiaq country today poses a quandary in this time of change: And most assuredly, I really believe that we are at a disadvantage right now because we don’t have practicing shamans that can go into the natural world, go into the spiritual world, to find some answers. It makes it more important that we teach youngsters their own language and their own cultural ways, as well as encourage and nurture those youngsters that want to go into the sciences. (Kawagley 2008) Using a complementary blend of Native and western sciences, Kawagley hopes that the younger generations of Natives can glean the appropriate behaviors for working with the new plant and animal spirits coming into the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta. “Yeah, we are in for some tough times. We are going to have to come up with a lot of new rituals and ceremonies to fit the times” (Kawagley 2008). But before they can develop the rituals and ceremonies needed to establish respectful,
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…89
reciprocal relationships, there will have to be a healing of the self that brings the human, natural, and spiritual realms into balance (Kawagley 2002).
Promote Healing Many indigenous peoples, especially in Alaska, are still dealing with extensive grief from Yuut Tuqurpallratni, the Great Death, which resulted from the influenza pandemic of the early 1900s (Napoleon 1996). This pandemic destroyed families and even entire villages throughout Alaska. The widespread shock and grief has affected multiple generations with what has been described as a form of cultural post-traumatic stress disorder (Becker 2008). Kawagley (2008) feels that this disruption may be even worse for the Yupiaq because they have not recovered as a people from the trauma of the Great Death: Most of us are not healed. We haven’t repaired ourselves, because we haven’t brought closure to our griefs, especially griefs of my ancestors, my grandparents, of the terrific loss of life. And here it is, there is going to be more grief as a result of the climate change. Because the cold made everything about me, and once that is gone, boy, that is going to wreak havoc among my own mind, my own self. In his book Yuuyaraq: The Way of the Human Being, Napoleon (1996) promotes the use of the traditional talking circle as a way of dealing with the grief that is lingering from the Great Death. Kawagley (2008) believes that something similar should be established within communities for dealing with the losses associated with climate change: The same thing with seals, which we’ve depended on for so long. We have to hunt so long for them, for meat, for clothing, for seal oil—oh boy, seal oil! And what about some of the elders and elders-to-be in the near future, when all of a sudden they only see the seals on TV and they get hungry for .╯.╯. “oh boy, I remember when I used to have dried seal meat with seal oil, and my lady would be scraping to tan the sealskin to make hats and boots and things like that.” There [are] going to be a few, I would think, that will feel a loneliness, a depression, because of that. And so we may have to maybe set up a place where they can meet and talk about these changes and losses of the seal and all that means, as
90â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
an example. I can somehow foresee some grief meetings to address those and help people to get over that and find a replacement, find a replacement for whatever they find all of a sudden gone. Talking circles, or other traditional methods of emotional and spiritual healing, are critical to provide individuals and communities with leaders who are able to guide us through the changes ahead.
Be Agile and Adaptive Leaders Indigenous peoples are living in an era that is both complex and uncertain. They need to develop and nurture leaders who can meet the physical, economic, and sociocultural challenges resulting from climate change. These leaders are needed in all walks of life. According to Mervyn Tano of the International Institute for Indigenous Resource Management (IIIRM), indigenous peoples need agile leaders “to help unravel complex problems, to introduce a degree of certainty, and to facilitate the kind of decision-making required to not only survive, but to thrive” (Tano 2006). He describes agile leaders as those who • • • •
Realize that they exist in an era of permanent change Are creative thinkers with a deep sense of purpose Have a broad repertoire of behaviors and experience to bring to bear Are adaptive and resilient to changing situations
These leaders need to be well versed in western science and management, but they must also be thoroughly grounded in their Native language, culture, and traditions (Kawagley 2008). They must see the value in both Native and western science, see the complementary uses of the two, and use both methods appropriately as the basis of true adaptive management (Tano 2006). Agile leaders must work from a strong foundation in their culture and accept only those values and beliefs from the outside world that they deem to be good and necessary. They must adopt those things that will strengthen indigenous values, beliefs, and traditions (Kawagley 2008). These agile leaders must build bridges between the western and indigenous worldviews (Tano 2006), but they must build those bridges on indigenous terms and from an indigenous place of power (Kawagley 2008). Only then can they safely weather the coming storm. While such leaders are few and far between, examples of such leadership do exist in Alaska. Alaska Native community leaders such as Tony Weyiouanna of Shishmaref and Stanley Tom of Newtok serve as examples of agile leadership in
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…91
their efforts to relocate their villages due to climate change impacts. They are working to ensure that the relocation process and new village layouts are consistent with the values and traditions of their specific cultures.
Conclusion Global climate is changing. Even if global societies were to completely stop the emissions of all greenhouse gases today, the cycle has started and we have no choice but to see it through. Indigenous peoples will be adrift on a sea of change, and those changes will be painful; there is no getting around that. Their lands will change, as will the neighbors that they share the land with, and those changes will affect their very selves. They will at times feel lost, betrayed, and perhaps resentful at the colonizing societies who have caused the changes that they must now deal with. But indigenous peoples have faced changes in their environment, as well as social and cultural upheaval, before and have survived. Indigenous peoples can have confidence in their ability to adapt because they have done so since the Distant Time. They have survived because they passed down their stories, recognized the value in those lessons, helped and healed each other through the changes, and have had leaders who could adapt to the chaos of changing situations. Through such actions and traditions, indigenous peoples will continue to adapt and survive the current changing sense of place.
References Alfred, T., and J. Corntassel. 2005. Being indigenous: Resurgences against contemporary colonialism. Government and Opposition 40(4), 597–614. Arctic Climate Impact Assessment (ACIA). 2004. Impacts of a warming Arctic: Arctic climate impact assessment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ARM. 2007. Kiosks—Barrow, Alaska. Atmospheric Radiation Measurement Program, US Department of Energy, March 23, 2007 (cited October 30, 2008). Available from http://education.arm.gov/outreach/kiosksbarrow.stm. Barsh, R. L. 2004. The importance of human intervention in the evolution of Puget Sound ecosystems. In T. W. Droscher and D. A. Fraser (eds.), Proceedings of the 2003 Georgia Basin/Puget Sound Research Conference. Retrieved from http://www.psat .wa.gov/ Publications/03_proceedings/start.htm. Becker, S. R. 2008. Yuut Tuqurpallratni and Native cultural well being. Fairbanks: University of Alaska Fairbanks. Unpublished manuscript in possession of author.
92â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
CANA. 2006. Indigenous communities. Climate Action Network Australia 2006 (cited October 30, 2008). Available from http://www.cana.net.au/socialimpacts/australia/ indigenous.html Canellos, G. 2007. Climate change: The Denali Commission Perspective. Juneau. Alaska Climate Impact Assessment Commission. Chakrabarti, O. 2007. Indigenous peoples, indigenous voices. New York: United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples. Deloria, V., Jr. 1988. Custer died for your sins: An Indian manifesto. Oklahoma City: University of Oklahoma Press. Deloria, V., Jr., and D. R. Wildcat. 2001. Power and place: Indian education in America. Golden, CO: Fulcrum Publishing. Dickson, D., B. Beardsley, and R. James. 2007. Alaska Native press briefing calls on Congress to protect Native cultures from impacts of oil and gas development in northern Alaska. Washington DC: Pacific Environment. Ferguson, E. 2005. Einstein, sacred science, and quantum leaps: A comparative analysis of western science, Native science, and quantum physics paradigm. Native American Studies, University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada. Fox, S. 2002. These are things that are really happening: Inuit perspectives on the evidence and impacts of climate change in Nunavut. In The Earth is faster now: Indigenous observations of Arctic environmental change. Edited by I. Krupnik and D. Jolly. Fairbanks, AK: Arctic Research Consortium of the United States. General Accounting Office (GAO). 2003. Alaska Native villages: Most are affected by flooding and erosion, but few qualify for federal assistance. Washington DC: US General Accounting Office. Houser, S., V. Teller, M. MacCracken, R. Gough, and P. Spears. 2001. Potential consequences of climate variability and change for Native peoples and homelands. In Climate change impacts on the United States: The potential consequences of climate variability and change. Edited by N.A.S. Team. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. IPCC. 2007. Climate change 2007: Synthesis report. Geneva, Switzerland: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, United Nations Environment Programme. Jones, M. E., and J. Hunter. 2003. Enshrining indigenous knowledge in the national science curriculum: Issues arising from the Maori case. Paper read at RSCD Conference— Politics of the Commons: Articulating Development and Strengthening Local Practice, July 11–14, 2003, at Chiang Mai University. Kawagley, A. O. 2002. Alaska Native education research: Reaching into the profound silence of self. Paper read at International Arctic Social Sciences Association, May 1995, at Rovaniemi, Finland. Kawagley, A. O. 2006. A Yupiaq worldview: A pathway to ecology and spirit. Second Edition. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press.
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…93
Kawagley, A. O. 2008. Interview: The effects of climate change on the Yupiaq. Fairbanks, AK, November 22, 2008. Killsback, L. 2006. Evahvete Hoheta “hanestse”: Oral traditions in the first steps toward decolonization. Paper read at 48th Annual Conference of the Western Social Science Association, April 19–22, 2006, at Phoenix, AZ. Krupnik, I., and D. Jolly (eds.). 2002. The Earth is faster now: Indigenous observations of Arctic environmental change. Fairbanks, AK: Arctic Research Consortium of the United States. MacCracken, M., E. Barron, D. Easterling, B. Felzer, and T. Karl. 2001. Scenarios for climate variability and change. In Climate change impacts on the United States: The potential consequences of climate variability and change. Edited by N.A.S. Team. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Maynard, N. G. (ed.). 1998. Final report: Native peoples–Native homelands climate change workshop. Albuquerque, NM: US Global Climate Change Program. Napoleon, H. 1996. Yuuyaraq: The way of the human being. Edited by E. Madsen. Fairbanks: Alaska Native Knowledge Network. NUIFC. 2008. Urban Indian America: The status of American Indian and Alaska Native children and families today. Seattle, WA: National Urban Indian Family Coalition. Oleksa, M. J. 2005. Another culture/another world. Juneau: Alaska Association of School Boards. Parson, E. A., L. Carter, P. Anderson, B. Wang, and G. Weller. 2001. Potential consequences of climate variability and change for Alaska. In Climate change impacts on the United States: The potential consequences of climate variability and change. Edited by N.A.S. Team. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Redman, S. 2008. Shaping identity and “Place” in Australian indigenous housing. In Berkley prize series. Berkeley: University of California, Berkeley. Rosen, Y. 2004. Alaska Natives say warming trend imperils villages. Anchorage, AK: Thomson Reuters. Tano, M. 2006. Developing agile tribal leaders and agile tribal institutions to adaptively manage and mitigate the impacts of global climate change in Indian country. Denver, CO: International Institute for Indigenous Resource Management. Tapley, B. 2003. Sense of place in the Pilbara. Perth, Australia: Institute for Sustainability and Technology Policy, Murdoch University. Tofa, M. 2006. Indigenous place and development. Denver, CO: International Institute for Indigenous Resource Management. Webb, J. R. 2003. Indigenous history of the Pilbara. Perth, Australia: Institute for Sustainability and Technology Policy, Murdoch University.
2.5
Values of Nushagak Bay: Past, Present, and Future by todd radenbaugh and sarah wingert pederson
M
ost of the research on ecosystem valuation has focused on broad regional to global scales, with emphasis on the influence of local culture (Colt 2001; Costanza 2006; Daly and Farley 2004; King and Mazzotta 2009; MEA 2003). The value of an ecosystem has a foundation in local culture, so to fully understand a local system one must explore how the inhabitants have come to view nature. This chapter focuses on the people and ecosystem of Nushagak Bay in southwest Alaska, a large, relatively unspoiled estuary covering about 1,409 square kilometers. Nushagak Bay hosts one of the world’s largest sustainable sockeye salmon fisheries. An estimated 10 million sockeye return each season; the 2008 return was 10,158,000 fish (ADF&G 2008). The harvest of salmon is important to the area commercially, but by many measures it is more important culturally. In this chapter, the concept of ecosystem valuation will be applied to the Nushagak Bay area. The significant role of local values such as respect for nature and hunter success (ANKN 2006) will be discussed. How past, present, and future values placed on the local ecosystem have changed, and the factors influencing those changes, will also be explored.
Hierarchies Since natural systems are hierarchical (e.g., Radenbaugh 1998; Salthe 1985), scales become important when investigating system attributes. When discussing values of nature, change may occur at the smallest unit or individual level up to the broader unit of culture. At the scale of culture, perceptions are collective and broader,
95
96â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
encompassing the processes and services of ecosystems (Gobster et al. 2007). Generally, any broad changes in culture and ecosystems take place within time frames greater than a generation. Therefore, adaptation (by biota and individuals) goes unnoticed by individuals in the near term. Further, the interplay between ecosystems and culture often creates interdependent and coevolving networks within the broad ecosystem (Gobster et al. 2007; Nassauer 1995; Radenbaugh 2005). This is a dynamic notion that carries beyond the concept that when ecosystems change, culture adapts.
Nushagak Bay Unlike many regions in North America, the land, rivers, and estuaries of Nushagak Bay are still unspoiled and naturally productive (Fig. 2.5.1). The estuary’s present health is a consequence of two major social-ecological factors: historically low human population densities (0.06 per square kilometer) and a culture dependent and linked with the biota. This dependence has led the local culture to adopt patterns of stewardship that have kept the ecosystem healthy, even at times of extrinsic threats. In this region, the majority of human history has been dominated by a Yup’ik culture in which environmental stewardship was believed necessary for the continued healthy coexistence of humans and nature (Kawagley 1995). Since the mid-1800s, globalization, consumerism, and climate change have been altering the socioeconomic and ecological systems, yet the healthy quality of nature remains. Humans have always influenced ecosystems, but increasing evidence has shown that humans can dominate and indeed negatively overwhelm the way ecosystems function (MEA 2003; Vitousek et al. 1997). This has not yet happened in Nushagak Bay to any extreme, as its inhabitants are still dependent on the ecosystem’s services such as the provision of fish and pure water. However, not all of the ecosystem’s services are fully valued equally. Understanding how a culture has valued and currently values the local ecosystem will help in predicting how people might value it in the future and whether these values are causing damage to the ecosystem.
Physical Geography and Ecology of Nushagak Bay From a physical geographic perspective, the Nushagak estuary is new. It was formed fewer than five thousand years ago as a result of melting Pleistocene ice and rising sea level, which drowned and eroded the mouths of the Nushagak, Wood, Snake, and Igushik Rivers (Kaufman et al. 1996). By far, the largest inputs of water and sediment come from the Nushagak River followed by the Wood, Igushik, and
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…97
Figure 2.5.1. Nushagak Bay, Alaska.
Snake Rivers. Within the bay, tides play a dominant role in shaping the geomorphology of the shorelines, channels, and deltaic plains (Fig. 2.5.2). The shallow waters of eastern Bristol Bay also help to define Nushagak Bay by protecting the region from large waves that can be generated in the Bering Sea. Five species of Pacific salmon pass through the estuary to their spawning grounds up the river systems. Chinook (king) enter first in late May and early June, followed by sockeye (red), chum (dog), coho (silver), and pink (humpy) with variation in run times. The two most locally valued species are Chinook and sockeye.
98â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Chinook are the largest salmon and are valued for subsistence use and by sport anglers. Sockeye is the most abundant species in the estuary, highly valued by the commercial fishing industry and for subsistence use. Each spring, as the air and water temperatures warm and river discharge increases with runoff, biological productivity also increases in Nushagak Bay. Early June sees the first Chinook salmon returning from the Pacific Ocean via Bristol Bay. As the summer progresses, water temperature warms further, more nutrients flow in from rivers, and the estuary responds. An increase of phytoplankton is followed by large numbers of amphipods and crangon shrimp (which end the summer in large swarms). By mid-June, the keystone species, sockeye salmon, starts returning in the millions, bringing with them marine protein and nutrients. By mid-summer, the bay supports large numbers of invertebrates (i.e., shrimp and amphipods) and finfish (i.e., starry flounder and smelt). These local populations, along with the returning salmon, feed large pods of beluga whales that in turn are fed on by orca farther out in the estuary. In summer, Nushagak Bay also serves as a nursery to millions of salmon smolts before they head back out to the Pacific Ocean as adults. During the summers of 2007–2009, the Bristol Bay Environmental Science Lab conducted trawling studies of Nushagak Bay. These studies suggest that the bay can be subdivided into at least three habitat zones based on fauna, sediment, salinity, and tidal current velocity (Fig. 2.5.2). In the upper estuary, the average surface salinity is 5 ppt. Even at depth (10 meters), salinity is rarely found to be above 15 ppt. Due to the strong influence of the rivers as well as water from the Kvichak River to the east, the bay is dominated by freshwater inputs and freshwater-tolerant species. It is not until a few kilometers south of the Etolin Point and Cape Constantine that more marine species assemblages are encountered (Ormseth, NMFS, personal communication). Another factor that defines Nushagak Bay is the high turbidity, especially in the upper estuary zone (Fig. 2.5.2), with summer average turbidity measured at 200 NTU. Thus, the bay is characterized by low salinity with a high silt and fine sand sediment load. The benthic species diversity in Nushagak Bay has a Shannon Diversity (H′) value of 1.54, ranking it below similar subarctic estuaries such as Ungava Bay, near Labrador, and Lower Herring Bay in Prince William Sound where the Shannon Diversity values are H′=2.11 and H′=2.5, respectively ( Jewett et al. 2001; Stewart et al. 1985). The lower diversity is most likely due to the low salinity and high turbidity of Nushagak Bay. The greatest sampling effort has been within the upper and middle reaches of the bay, well within the riverine and upper estuarine habitat zones. Common species include rainbow trout, smelt, starry flounder, bay shrimp, and two species of amphipod. Less commonly we encounter lamprey eels, juvenile salmon, eelpouts, and sticklebacks.
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…99
Figure 2.5.2. Nushagak Bay geography with 2007–2008 trawling tracks and areas of major estuary zones based on sediments and fauna.
100â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
The biotic interplay occurs at several spatial and temporal scales and determines the estuary’s health and resilience. When one component is changed or another is added, primary or secondary effects often occur. Such ecosystem-level change can occur at a large scale (e.g., the Exxon Valdez oil spill) or through cumulative effects of small-scale impacts (e.g., introduction of single family homes in the Matanuska-Susitna Valley). In both cases, the end result is an ecosystem-level change. Such ecosystem-level change is becoming common worldwide, as witnessed in the Chesapeake Bay, Great Lakes, and the Aral Sea (MEA 2003; Vitousek et al. 1997). Further, because estuaries receive inputs from both marine and freshwater systems, they serve as indicators of ecological health for a region (Cederholm et al. 1999; Costanza et al. 1993; Kelly and Levin 1986). However, cultural history has significant influences on the ecological health of estuaries because the ways in which estuaries are used and abused often reflect their perceived value. Therefore, to maintain ecosystem health at the broad scale it is important to understand the cultural history and the ecological role of species.
Cultural Values in the Nushagak Bay Region Nushagak Bay has been a place of resource use since the first travelers came to the region about four thousand years ago. The rich ecosystem has sustained humans from the early Yup’ik settlements to the towns of today. Since the late 1890s, the Nushagak watershed has witnessed the growing influences of globalization, consumerism, and climate change, each of which has rapidly altered the socio-economic and ecological systems of the region. The potential introduction of multibilliondollar industries, such as industrial fishing, oil and gas exploration, and mining, along with the current industries of commercial fishing and nature/game outfitting, bring environmental challenges. To maintain the health of Nushagak Bay, many residents see value in merging traditional knowledge with western scientific practice. To do this requires maintaining access to subsistence resources (Table 2.5.1) while exploring the best uses (or nonuse) of nonrenewable resources. Table 2.5.1 lists the most important renewable subsistence resources used by residents of the Nushagak Bay area (Radenbaugh and Fox 2007). The food items listed have been important for communities throughout every historical period, illustrating the major role of subsistence foods. In spite of all the cultural changes occurring since the early Yup’ik occupancy of the area, these foods are still valued and help define the bay’s culture. Elaborate traditional annual calendars are used to illustrate the yearly timing of seasonal subsistence activities. The use of traditional knowledge has helped residents maintain access to subsistence resources at the local scale while preserving the integrity of the broader ecosystem.
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…101 Table 2.5.1. Examples of subsistence activities and foods with high values in the Nushagak watershed. Activity
Yup’ik species names
English species names
Fishing
neqet anerrluat naternarpiit iqalluat iqalluarpiit cuukviit
any fish trout halibut smelt herring pike
Hunting
tuntut issurit yaqulget
caribou seal birds
Picking Berries
atsalugpiat tan’gerpiit suraviit tumaglit
salmonberries blackberries blueberries cranberries
Greens
quagcit tarrnat mecuqerrlliq ceturqaaraat
sourdock wild celery wild celery fiddlehead ferns
In this time of rapid global change, nature’s role in supporting individuals and their culture is becoming more apparent. Traditional knowledge holds an important function and is being valued more than in the recent past as a record for local natural history and resource use (Sparrow et al. 2006). Scientists are gleaning data from oral histories that span hundreds of years (Kawagley 1995; Oozeva et al. 2004); Native people are using their western education to help their communities adjust to an uncertain future; and scientists and Natives alike are coming to see their two worlds merge to promote local resilience. Communities surrounding Nushagak Bay are in need of a comprehensive valuation and ecosystem adaptation plan. This need is seen in public meetings such as the one that developed the Dillingham Comprehensive Plan, where planners and Nushagak elders called for preserving important traditional knowledge in regard to subsistence. (In 2009 and 2010, organizations that have discussed this type of planning include the Dillingham City Council and the Qayassiq Walrus Commission.) Across the Bristol Bay region there are concerns that subsistence values are being replaced with values that are dependent on nonrenewable resources (Radenbaugh and Fox 2007). One way to promote good stewardship and healthy ecosystems in rural Alaska is to teach traditional knowledge alongside modern scientific methods (Barnhardt 2005; Kawagley 1995).
102â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Changing Values Table 2.5.2 illustrates how the value of nature has shifted in Nushagak Bay as cultural changes continue to affect various traditions. From past to present, the value of nature has changed from being primarily a provider of natural subsistence resources to being a grab bag of resources that serve to produce commodities. The future view of nature seems to focus on the broader ecosystem and the goods and services it provides. However, management strategies to date focus generally on individual species and their use in subsistence or the local economy and not on the ecosystem. A brief description of the historical geography that formed the values is outlined below. The early Yup’ik period and the influence of Russian and European contact are discussed to contextualize the ways in which values have changed from one period to the next. Table 2.5.2. Changing values of the Nushagak Bay region, Alaska. Nature Valued as
Ecosystem Use
Scale of Management
Value Drivers
Past
provider
need-based subsistence
local: species
traditional knowledge
Present
commodity producer
commoditybased
regional: species
western science and consumerism
Future
provider and commodity producer
sustainable management
associations broad: whole ecosystems
western science and traditional knowledge
Past: Nature as Provider Early Yup’ik Period Human settlement of the Nushagak region took more than a thousand years as small bands of people moved across the Bering Land Bridge (along the coast and interior) by tracking a preferred climate, resource availability, and their curiosity. The earliest Nushagak inhabitants were most likely nomadic bands that moved into the region shortly after the land was deglaciated 4,000 to 5,000 years ago and used the region’s coastal areas, rivers, and lakes (TNWR 1986). Athabascan, Aleut, and Yup’ik hunters and fishers may have set up summer camp in the region, but eventually the Yup’ik bands settled and built villages. By 2,000 years ago, three
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…103
different groups lived in eastern Bristol Bay, but it was the Aglegmiut Yup’ik who lived in the Nushagak area (VanStone 1967, 1972). Subsistence activities most likely dominated daily life through the harvesting of the abundant fish (e.g., salmon and trout) in summer and hunting of mammals (e.g., caribou, fur bearers, and marine mammals) in winter (VanStone 1967). These early peoples had an intimate relationship with the land and extensive knowledge of northern ecosystems. Nature and ingenuity provided all the necessary resources for survival (Table 2.5.2). As successful hunters and gatherers, the inhabitants saw nature as a provider and had an intimate knowledge of its workings at the finer scales. However, it is not known how much they understood about the complexities of broader scale ecosystem goods and services.
Russian Influence The Bristol Bay region first came to European attention in 1778 when Captain James Cook sailed into the bay on board the Resolution and gave it its present name. In the early 1800s, the Yup’ik living in the Nushagak region did not have prolonged contact with Europeans until a party of Russian-American Company employees from Kodiak Island were sent to explore the territory of Bristol Bay (VanStone 1972). As part of these explorations and to establish a fur trade, the Aleksandrovski Redoubt was established in 1818 on an eastern bluff in Nushagak Bay. It allowed the Russians to trade with interior regions from the Kuskokwim to Kvichak Rivers (VanStone 1967). Although the redoubt did not attract a large fur trade, it served as an important base for expeditions into the interior of southwest Alaska. Moreover, the redoubt gave the Bristol Bay region contact with Russian fur traders throughout the 1800s. This contact had profound influences on culture because it introduced the gradual cultural change from total reliance on subsistence resources (i.e., nature as provider) to international trade of raw or manufactured goods (i.e., commodity-based).
Present: Nature as a Commodity Rise of an Industrial Fishery In 1867 the United States purchased Alaska from Russia and took possession of Aleksandrovski Redoubt, renamed Nushagak, where the US Signal Corps built a weather station. After the Russian assets were sold, influence and contact with western ideas expanded. The US influence expanded the commercial fisheries in Nushagak Bay, rapidly replacing fur as the most important economic commodity. In 1882, the first documented fishing fleet and salting station operated at
104â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Kanulik, 2 miles north of Nushagak village (Unrau 1994). The next year the Arctic Packing Company of San Francisco set up the first salmon cannery and made its first pack of 400 cases of about 4,200 salmon (Moser 1898, 1902). This industry generally operated only a few months a year during the salmon runs. Power came from wind (for boats) and steam (for canneries), and there was a rapid influx of new ideas and technology in the region. The canneries often competed with each other during the short summer fishing season. This changed with the arrival of the Alaska Packers Association (APA) in 1892. APA amalgamated canneries across southwestern Alaska and Bristol Bay to exert economic and political control of the fishery (Unrau 1994). In the late 1880s, there were four operating canneries in Nushagak Bay, and by the end of the 1890s, there were canneries on the Naknek and Kvichak Rivers, all of which traded with the local populations. Throughout the early 1900s the APA dominated the Nushagak fishery. The bay seemed healthy and had high fish returns until the end of World War I in 1918, when only a few fish returned to the estuary as a result of overfishing likely due to the high prices and demand for canned salmon (Unrau 1994). This indicated the need for better resource management, exclusion of fish weirs, and establishment of escapement goals. However, the White Act passed by Congress in 1924 became a vain effort at fishery conservation (US Cong. 1924). In reality the act favored the big companies and worked against the development of small operators. The powerful salmon industry then pushed to enact regulations mandating that only sailboats could be used in Bristol Bay. This gave control of the fishery to the industry, as the sailboats were then moved in the strong tides through the use of cannery tugs (or monkey boats) and by anchoring scows for fish delivery. It was not until 1950 that individually owned power boats were allowed in Bristol Bay, and within three years, nearly all sailboats had been replaced by power boats. The rapid development of the bay’s commercial fisheries during the close of the nineteenth century had a significant influence on the culture and on how people valued nature. For many Native Alaskans, the fishing industry was their first exposure to the wage economy and working by the clock. With thousands of Scandinavians, other Europeans, and Asians, the fishery further helped in developing a commodity-based economy. The interaction of these populations made the region even more ethnically diverse. Most of these residents embraced the seasonal subsistence culture and simultaneously imparted aspects of their culture to the cultural mixing pot. With the growth of the commercial salmon fishery, some settlements grew while others declined. The village of Nushagak lost its title as bay’s capital to villages on the west side of the estuary, including a small cannery village at Snag Point, which later became Dillingham. Then in 1918 the influenza epidemic struck the region, killing many. The Kanakanak Hospital and its orphanage played an
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…105
important role for the survivors and solidified a population center in Dillingham (Fig. 2.5.1). Although some influences of the early Yup’ik culture are still evident, the Russian period and the later cannery economy profoundly transformed values in Nushagak Bay. The economy and culture of Nushagak Bay have evolved to embrace capitalistic activities. Western science and technology were also viewed as the keys to extracting nature’s wealth (Table 2.5.2). The evolving culture blended traditional and western ideas and linked the economy with the global market. Although this period reduced the importance of traditional knowledge when valuing nature, replacing it with commodity-based knowledge, subsistence values remained strong.
Rise of Sustainable Management Nushagak Bay today is still diverse and the culture remains vibrant and dynamic. Dillingham, the economic hub, has a population of 2,466 (US Census 2000) and has all of the economic activities of a modern society. Although the poverty rate is higher than the national average, the use of nature’s wealth through subsistence activities is not included in these calculations. Much has changed in the region, but one thing that has not changed is the way communities value nature economically and culturally as it sustains a way of life. Since the 1940s, federal and state agencies, universities, industry groups, nongovernment organizations, and local fishermen and fisherwomen have come to play important roles in fisheries management by using partnerships and scientific methods to improve fisheries management techniques. By establishing strict salmon escapement goals and creating more diverse markets for fish products, science and technology have given fishers more control over the fishery. Nature as a commodity took an important turn in the 1990s with the establishment of the field of environmental economics. Costanza et al. (1997a) estimated the value of the world’s ecosystem services at over $3 trillion per year. They found that coastal environments, including estuaries such as Nushagak Bay, have disproportionately higher values of services (43% of the world’s ecosystem value) even though they cover only 6.3% of the planet. Thus, estuaries were shown to be among the most valuable geographic features on the planet, having a 1998 value of $10,378 per acre. Most of this value is due to important ecosystem services, such as nutrient cycling, as wetlands and estuaries help turn nitrogen and phosphorus into the carbohydrate food on which all life is dependent. Using numbers from Costanza et al. (1997b), the 1,409 square kilometers of Nushagak Bay and the tidal portions of its major tributaries may perform services worth approximately $2.76 billion annually. Grass beds and wetlands associated with the region push that number even higher.
106â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Potential Future: Nature as Provider and Commodity Nushagak Bay is valued by non-subsistence users primarily as a commercial fishing ground, but it is also a nature and sport tourism destination. To date, the Nushagak ecosystem has proved to be able to provide all these activities with no apparent loss in ecosystem function. The robustness of the region has been attributed to the health of the watershed, which is a result of the variability of spawning habitats and the biocomplexity of the life history strategies of salmon populations (Hilborn et al. 2003). These factors have allowed the system as a whole to adjust to biophysical changes such as climatic and oceanic conditions, in addition to the described changes in culture. Thus, the diversity of the Nushagak region has been the primary mechanism for ecosystem sustainability and health (Hilborn et al. 2003). Any loss of habitat, species, genetic, or cultural diversity could result in less complexity and diversity, lowering the integrity of the broader ecosystems and making the region less resilient to ecological predicted global-level changes (Schindler et al. 2005). A growing number of local efforts, such as the Nushagak-Mulchatna WoodTikchik Land Trust, Nunamta Aulukestai (Caretakers of the Land), Nushagak Watershed Council, Dillingham Comprehensive Plan, and UAF Bristol Bay Campus Ecosystem Health Initiative, place values on ecosystem services, especially in the fisheries and energy sectors. Talk of building sockeye hatcheries and diesel power plants no longer dominates discussions of economic growth; rather, efforts are now starting to include more sustainable management practices. Furthermore, discussions of values often blend information from both western science and traditional knowledge. Both types of knowledge contribute complementary data from different perspectives. Western science tends toward a reductionist model and subdivides nature into disciplines. Yup’ik knowledge examines generalities so as to concentrate on the broader scales. One example of this is the Yup’ik annual subsistence calendar. The combined use of western science and traditional knowledge has shown to have management benefits (Huntington 2000). Together they attempt to improve resource management by using information that transcends scales and cultures, leading to better decisions. Environmental issues exist in Nushagak Bay at and above the local level. For example, local threats, such as unplanned growth due to an increasing population, can become cumulative. Furthermore, the sustainability of the salmon fishery could be easily reversed if the complex heterogeneity of the ecosystem is altered by catastrophic human influences such as an oil spill. Lastly, large nonrenewable resource industries with significant ecological footprints could jeopardize the region’s health if all negative impacts to ecosystem health are not mitigated. The twenty-first century brings to Nushagak Bay many possibilities, including introduction of multibillion-dollar nonrenewable resource industries (e.g., oil and gas development and
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…107
mining) along with climate and ocean chemistry changes (IPCC 2007). These changes will present challenges to the ecosystem. To maintain the health and sustainability of Nushagak Bay, many residents see merit in merging their traditional knowledge with western scientific practice. This requires maintaining close connections to subsistence resources by scientifically exploring the best use (or nonuse) of renewable and nonrenewable resources. Monitoring the ways in which resources are used may allow residents, resource managers, and stakeholders to adapt to the shifting patterns in the climate, habitats, and economy while maintaining a sustainable culture and healthy ecosystem. The future health of Nushagak Bay is threatened by a host of activities and influences that span several ecological levels. The small-scale systems have proved to be resilient enough to coexist with the level of current growth. However, future cultural and ecological change to Nushagak Bay may come not from local change but from alterations in the larger system. These may include processes such as globalization (in the form of unsustainable development, catastrophic toxic dumping, and mass tourism) or climate change (in the form of temperature rises, nitrogen loss, and ocean acidification). Therefore, sustaining culture and nature at the local level will require monitoring systems at a global scale.
Final Thoughts The ways in which a culture responds to nature depends on experiences on both the individual and the community level. A local culture can be influenced by shared experiences that develop into a collective consciousness. The range of experiences can include subsistence hunting in a wilderness, witnessing the Milky Way, tending to gardens, and walking city streets. So the local culture’s connectedness within ecosystems is a result of long-term decisions. Because of this, the decisions made by one generation often influence the next generation’s understanding and perception of nature. If individuals have fewer experiences in nature, the opportunity to know their connection within nature may be diminished. The decline of ecosystem health begins when a culture starts to perceive itself as separate from nature and the vital functions it provides. This has been occurring for thousands of years and is characteristic of many places today. However, the regions that are the healthiest generally have residents who understand their direct connection to ecosystem function. While other regions are trying to renew their relationship with nature, that relationship has never left the Nushagak region. Now to complete the picture, it is time for residents of Nushagak Bay to fully embrace the concept of sustainability and better understand their connection to the rest of the world.
108â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
References Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADF&G). 2008. Commercial Fisheries Division, news release: Bristol Bay salmon season summary. Available at http://www.cf.adfg .state.ak.us/region2/finfish/salmon/bbayhome.php. Alaska Native Knowledge Network (ANKN). 2006. Yup’ik cultural values. Alaska Native Knowledge Network, University of Alaska Fairbanks. Available at http://www.ankn .uaf.edu/ANCR/values/yupik.html. Barnhardt, R. 2005. Creating a place for indigenous knowledge in education: The Alaska Native Knowledge Network. In Local diversity: Place-based education in the global age. Edited by G. Smith and D. Gruenewald. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Cederholm, C., M. Kunze, T. Murota, and A. Sibatani. 1999. Pacific salmon carcasses: Essential contributions of nutrients and energy for aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems. Fisheries 24(10), 6–15. Colt, S. 2001. The economic importance of healthy Alaska ecosystems. Prepared for Alaska Conservation Foundation. Institute of Social and Economic Research, University of Alaska Anchorage. Available at http://www.commerce.state.ak.us/oed/toubus/pub/ healthycosystems.pdf. Costanza, R. 2006. Thinking broadly about costs and benefits in ecological management. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management 2, 166–173. Costanza, R., J. Cumberland, H. Daly, R. Goodland, and R. Norgaard. 1997a. An introduction to ecological economics. Boca Raton, FL: St. Lucie Press. Costanza, R., R. d’Arge, R. de Groot, S. Farberparallel, M. Grasso, B. Hannon, K. Limburg, S. Naeem, R. V. O’Neill, Jose Paruelo, R. G. Raskin, P. Sutton, and M. van den Belt. 1997b. The value of the world’s ecosystem services and natural capital. Nature 387, 253–260. Costanza, R., W. Kemp, and W. Boynton. 1993. Predictability, scale, and biodiversity in coastal and estuarine ecosystems: implications for management. Ambio 22(2/3), 88–96. Daly, H. E., and J. Farley. 2004. Ecological economics: Principles and applications. Washington DC: Island Press. Gobster, P. H., J. I. Nassauer, T. C. Daniel, and G. Fry. 2007. The shared landscape: What does aesthetics have to do with ecology? Landscape Ecology 22, 959–972. Hilborn, R., T. Quinn, D. Schindler, and D. Rogers. 2003. Biocomplexity and fisheries sustainability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 100 (11), 6564–6568. Huntington, H. P. 2000. Using traditional ecological knowledge in science: Methods and applications. Ecological Applications 10, 1270–1274.
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…109
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2007. The physical basis of climate change. Working group I, fourth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Jewett, S. C., T. A. Dean, R. O. Smith, and A. Blanchard. 2001. Exxon Valdez oil spill: Impacts and recovery in the soft bottom benthic community in and adjacent to eelgrass beds. Marine Ecology Progress Series 185, 59–83. Kaufman, D., S. Forman, P. Lea, and C. Wobus. 1996. Age of pre-late-Wisconsin glacialestuarine sedimentation, Bristol Bay, Alaska. Quaternary Research 45, 59–72. Kawagley, A. O. 1995. A Yupiaq worldview: A pathway to ecology and spirit. Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland Press. Kelly, J. R., and S. A. Levin. 1986. A comparison of aquatic and terrestrial nutrient cycling and production processes in natural ecosystems, with reference to ecological concepts of relevance to some waste disposal issues. In The role of the oceans as a waste disposal option, edited by G. Kullenberg. Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Reidel, 165–203. King, D. M., and M. J. Mazzotta. 2009. Ecosystem valuation. US Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service and National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration. Available at http://www.ecosystemvaluation.org/. MEA. 2003. Millennium ecosystem assessment, ecosystems and human well-being: A framework for assessment. Washington DC: Island Press. Moser, J. F. 1898. The salmon and salmon fisheries of Alaska: Report of the operations of the United States Fish Commission Steamer Albatross for the year ending June 30, 1898. Bulletin of the US Fish Commission. Vol. XVIII. Washington DC: US Government Printing Office. Moser, J. F. 1902. The salmon and salmon fisheries of Alaska: Report of the Alaskan Salmon Investigations of the United States Fish Commission Streamer Albatross in 1900 and 1901. Bulletin of the US Fish Commission. Vol. XXI. Washington DC: US Government Printing Office. Nassauer, J. I. 1995. Culture and changing landscape structure. Landscape Ecology 10, 229–237. Oozeva, C., G. Noongwook, G. Noongwook, C. Alowa, and I. Krupnik. 2004. Watching ice and weather our way/Sikumengllu Eslamengllu Esghapalleghput. Washington DC: Arctic Studies Center, Smithsonian Institution. Radenbaugh, T. A. 1998. Saskatchewan’s prairie plant assemblages: A hierarchical approach. Prairie Forum 23, 31–47. Radenbaugh, T. A. 2005. Managing changing landscapes on the northern prairies: Using functional groups and biotic guilds. In Managing changing prairie landscapes, edited by T. A. Radenbaugh and G. C. Sutter. Regina, SK: Canadian Plains Research Center, 147–159.
110â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
Radenbaugh, T. A., and M. Fox. 2007. Bridging Native culture and environmental science: Changing higher education methods in the Bristol Bay region of southwestern Alaska. Canadian Aboriginal Science and Technology Society, Calgary, Alberta. Salthe, S. N. 1985. Evolving hierarchical systems: Their structure and representation. New York: Columbia University Press. Schindler, D., D. Rogers, M. Scheuerell, and C. Abrey. 2005. Effect of changing climate on zooplankton and juvenile sockeye salmon growth in southwestern Alaska. Ecology 86(1), 198–209. Sparrow, E. B., J. C. Dawe, and F. S. Chapin III. 2006. Communication of Alaskan boreal science with broader communities. In Alaska’s changing boreal forest. Edited by F. S. Chapin, M. W. Oswood, K. Van Cleve, L. A. Viereck, and D. L. Verbyla. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Stewart, P. L., P. Pocklington, and R. A. Cunjak. 1985. Distribution, abundance and diversity of benthic macroinvertebrates on the Canadian continental shelf and slope of Southern Davis Strait and Ungava Bay. Arctic 38, 281–291. Togiak National Wildlife Refuge (TNWR). 1986. US Fish and Wildlife Service Togiak National Wildlife Refuge, Final Comprehensive Conservation Plan, Wilderness Review and Environmental Impact Statement. US Fish and Wildlife Service, Region 7, Anchorage, AK. Unrau, H. D. 1994. Lake Clark National Park and Preserve, Alaska: Historic resource study. US Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Anchorage, AK. US Census. 2000. US Census Bureau, http://factfinder.census.gov/. US Congress. 1924. An Act for the Protection of Fisheries in Alaska. 68th Cong. 1st sess., H.R. 8143. Congressional Record no. 204, June 6, chs. 270–272. VanStone, J. W. 1967. Eskimos of the Nushagak River: An ethnographic history. Seattle: University of Washington Press. VanStone, J. W. 1972. Nushagak: An historic trading center in southwestern Alaska. Fieldiana Anthropology, Anthropological Series Volume 62. Chicago: Field Museum of Natural History. Vitousek, P. M., H. A. Mooney, J. Lubchenco, and J. M. Melillo. 1997. Human domination of Earth’s ecosystems. Science 277(5325), 494–499.
2.6
Food Systems, Environmental Change, and Community Needs in Rural Alaska by s. craig gerlach, philip a. loring, amy turner, and david e. atkinson
F
ood systems provide a useful window through which to examine the direct, indirect, and cumulative impacts of a changing climate and environment on individual and community health and viability (Ericksen et al. 2010; Loring and Gerlach 2009). Rural livelihoods in the high-latitude North are tightly connected to climate, weather, and ecosystems. Northern people have relied for millennia on the landscape for their food through hunting, herding, gathering, fishing, and small-scale gardening. Rural residents regularly observe and reflect on changes to the landscapes and seascapes that provide their livelihoods; each trip across the river or sea ice is an experiment—a test of several hypotheses regarding hydrology, weather, seasonality (the timing of seasons), and the distribution and abundance of fish and game. Unexpected changes and unprecedented environmental conditions are easily noticed, including changes to the distribution and abundance of wild fish and game or to the frequency and magnitude of forest fires, landslides, river and coastal erosion, lake and landscape drying, and permafrost degradation. When combined with social and economic change, climate, weather, and changes in the biophysical system interact in a complex web of feedbacks and interactions to make rural life challenging. This is especially true where communities strive to rely on country foods for subsistence, cultural identity, and individual and community health and self-reliance. However, climate change is not the first or even most important challenge facing people and communities of the North (Keskitalo 2008; Lynch and Brunner 2007). High and rising costs of food and fuel, dramatic and rapid changes to the landscape and weather, fisheries closures and other management actions that keep
111
112â•… north by 2020: perspectives on alaska’s changing social-ecological systems
freezers and smokehouses empty, social and political debates and conflicts regarding the development of land, and troubling health trends such as increases in diabetes and heart disease, depression, and alcoholism are examples of the many difficult issues that rural Alaskans grapple with every day. Each of these challenges may indeed be linked to climate change in various ways, and local people understand this perfectly well. Nevertheless, people need to act in response to these challenges now, and it is highly unlikely that the most effective, place-based solutions to problems such as food insecurity, diabetes, cancer, and a lack of job opportunities will have anything to do with the primary or even secondary drivers of global climatic change. In this chapter we take an ecological approach to exploring the pathways by which ecosystem, political, social, and economic change can interact. We use the Alaska food system as a lens to show how rapid change in any one or all of these dimensions can undermine community health and stability. We focus on rural Alaska, situating the politically charged and value-laden concepts of “rural” and “subsistence” within the political ecology of the entire Alaska food system. The emphasis is on linking local, regional, and globally scaled influences on the food security of rural households. The operating premise is that Alaska’s rural and urban communities are tightly connected and possibly over-connected. The dependence created by this connection can (1) render rural communities vulnerable to disruptions and fluctuations in food, fuel, commodity, and transportation costs and (2) create an influx of impacts for urban communities as rural residents cope with food and economic insecurity. A part of our discussion rests on the idea that the legal definition of subsistence has never captured the reality or importance of the role played by country foods in the livelihoods of Alaska Natives, nor has it effectively addressed the realities of changing Alaska Native foodways and food traditions. While the current institutional and regulatory framework has at times protected access to country foods to be sure, it has constrained and undermined it as well. Political rhetoric about rural, urban, and subsistence priorities notwithstanding, we suggest that the current subsistence paradigm falls short of providing any real institutional support for rural Alaskans who are trying to maintain or enhance food security and health through the promotion of self-reliant economies based on country foods. We end with some thoughts about possible responses to change that might allow communities to regain control over access to land and country food resources, community health, and self-reliance. These thoughts are not ours alone but have emerged through long collaboration with people in rural Alaska communities, especially along the Yukon River and in some Bering Sea coastal and near-coastal communities where much of our recent work has been done.
Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change, and Sustainabilityâ•…113
The Political Ecology of Food Systems Food links household and regional economies to larger economic and ecological landscapes through an array of functional connections and dependencies. Borrowing from Goodman and colleagues (2000), we define the food system as the total range of activities