L O N D O N M AT H E M AT I C A L S O C I E T Y M O N O G R A P H S
Series Editors Dr Peter Neumann Professor E B Davi...
31 downloads
970 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
L O N D O N M AT H E M AT I C A L S O C I E T Y M O N O G R A P H S
Series Editors Dr Peter Neumann Professor E B Davies
L O N D O N M AT H E M AT I C A L S O C I E T Y M O N O G R A P H S NEW SERIES
Previous volumes of the LMS Monographs were published by Academic Press, to whom all enquiries should be addressed. Volumes in the New Series will be published by Oxford University Press throughout the world. NEW SERIES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
Diophantine inequalities R. C. Baker The Schur multiplier Gregory Karpilovsky Existentially closed groups Graham Higman and Elizabeth Scott The asymptotic solution of linear differential systems M. S. P. Eastham The restricted Burnside problem Michael Vaughan-Lee Pluripotential theory Maciej Klimek Free Lie algebras Christophe Reutenauer The restructed Burnside problem (2nd edition) Michael Vaughan-Lee The geometry of topological stability Andrew du Plessis and Terry Wall Spectral decompositions and analytic sheaves J. Eschmeier and M. Putinar An atlas of Brauer characters C. Jansen, K. Lux, R. Parker, and R. Wilson Fundamentals of semigroup theory John M. Howie Area, lattice points, and exponential sums M. N. Huxley Super-real fields H. G. Dales and W. H. Woodin Integrability, self-duality, and twistor theory L. J. Mason and N. M. J. Woodhouse Categories of symmetries and infinite-dimensional groups Yu. A. Neretin Interpolation, identification, and sampling Jonathan R. Partington Metric number theory Glyn Harman Profinite groups John S. Wilson An introduction to local spectral theory K. B. Laursen and M. M. Neumann Characters of finite Coxeter groups and Iwahori-Hecke Algebras M. Geck and G. Pfeiffer Classical harmonic analysis and locally compact groups Hans Reiter and Jan D Stegeman Operator spaces E. G. Effros and Z.-J. Ruan Banach algebras and automatic continuity H. G. Dales The mysteries of the real prime M. J. Shai Haran Analytic theory of polynomials Q. I. Rahman and G. Schmeisser The structure of groups of prime power order C. R. Leedham-Green and S. McKay Maximal orders I. Reiner (reissue) Harmonic morphisms between Riemannian manifolds P. Baird and J. C. Wood Operator algebras and their modules: an operator space approach David P. Blecher and Christian Le Merdy
Operator algebras and their modules—an operator space approach David P. Blecher Department of Mathematics, University of Houston
Christian Le Merdy Laboratoire de Mathématiques, Université de Besançon
CLARENDON PRESS
•
OXFORD 2004
3
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Bangkok Buenos Aires Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kolkata Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi São Paulo Shanghai Taipei Tokyo Toronto Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Oxford University Press, 2004 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2004 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer British Library cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Data available ISBN 0-19-852659-8 1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2 Typeset by the authors using LaTex Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd., King’s Lynn, Norfolk
To Kindra and Marie-Laure, who surpass all...
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
A major trend in modern mathematics, inspired largely by physics, is toward ‘noncommutative’ or ‘quantized’ phenomena. This thrust has influenced most branches of the science. In the vast area of functional analysis, this trend has appeared notably under the name of operator spaces. This young field lies at the border between linear analysis, operator theory, operator algebras, and quantum physics. It has useful applications in all of these directions, and in turn derives its inspiration and power from these sources. Perhaps the importance of operator space theory may be best stated as follows: it is a variant of Banach spaces, which is particularly appropriate for solving problems concerning spaces or algebras of operators on Hilbert space arising in ‘noncommutative mathematics’. An operator space, loosely speaking, is a linear space of bounded operators between two Hilbert spaces. Thus the category of operator spaces includes operator algebras, selfadjoint (that is, C ∗ -algebras) or otherwise. Since any normed linear space E may be regarded as a subspace of a commutative C ∗ -algebra (for example, the continuous scalar functions on the unit ball of E ∗ ), operator spaces also include all Banach spaces. In addition, most of the important modules over operator algebras are operator spaces. With this in mind, it is natural to seek to treat the subjects of C ∗ -algebras, nonselfadjoint operator algebras, and modules over such algebras (such as Hilbert C ∗ -modules), together under the umbrella of operator space theory. This is the topic of our book. In the last decade or two, it has become very apparent that it can be a useful perspective. Indeed, operator space theory, as opposed to Banach space theory, is a sensitive enough medium to reflect accurately important noncommutative phenomena such as the spatial tensor product. The underlying operator space structure also captures, very precisely, many of the profound relations between the algebraic and the functional analytic structures involved. Our main goal is to illustrate how a general theory of operator algebras, and their modules, naturally develops out of the operator space methodology. We emphasize both the uniform (or ‘norm’), and the dual (or ‘weak∗ ’), aspects of the theory. A second goal, or prevailing theme, is the systematic study of algebraic structure in spaces of Hilbert space operators. For example, we are interested in the structural features characterizing the objects which operator algebraists are interested in, how rigid such structures are, how they behave with respect to duality, and so on. A third goal, and this is one of the most inspiring aspects of the subject at large, is to highlight the rich interplay between spectral theory, operator theory, C ∗ -algebra and von Neumann algebra techniques, and the influx
viii
Preface
of important ideas from related disciplines, such as pure algebra, Banach space theory, Banach algebras, and abstract function theory. Finally, our fourth goal is pedagogical: to assemble the basic concepts, theory, and methodologies, needed to equip a beginning researcher in this area. Our book falls roughly into three parts. Each chapter begins with some words of introduction, and so we will only very briefly describe their contents here. Part 1—Chapters 1–3—presents the basic theory of operator spaces, operator algebras, and operator modules. We also introduce much of our notation here. Part 2—Chapters 4–7—presents more advanced topics associated with these subjects, and describes more technical results. Chapter 4 discusses, for example, the noncommutative Shilov boundary, injective envelopes, operator space multipliers, and M -ideals, and applications of these topics to ‘operator algebraic structure’. Chapter 5 is devoted to the ‘isomorphic’ (as opposed to ‘isometric’) aspects of the theory. This includes completely isomorphic characterizations of various classes (operator algebras, operator modules, Q-algebras), as well as examples of ‘operator algebra structures’. In Chapter 6, we discuss various tensor products involving operator algebras, such as the maximal tensor product, or Pisier’s δ tensor norm. We give various applications, for example to dilation theory, or to finite rank approximation (nuclearity, semidiscreteness, etc.). In Chapter 7 we collect some criteria which ensure that an operator algebra is selfadjoint. Part 3—Chapter 8—develops the theory of Hilbert C ∗ -modules and the related notion of triple systems, largely from an operator space perspective. In this chapter we also describe some of the beautiful two-way interplay between C ∗ -modules and the theory in the earlier chapters. Finally, a short appendix contains some frequently needed facts from operator theory, Banach space theory, and Banach and C ∗ -algebras. We include proofs of many of these facts. Each chapter ends with a lengthy ‘Notes and historical remarks’ section, consisting of attributions, discussion of the literature, observations, additional proofs, complementary results, and so on. We apologize for inaccuracies or omissions here, of which there are sure to be many. In all cases, the reader should consult the original papers for further details, and other perspectives. This book was begun in 1999, during a year-long visit of the second author to Houston. We wish to thank the Universities of Besan¸con and Houston, the CNRS, and the National Science Foundation, for their support. We are also indebted to several colleagues for very many kindnesses, and for teaching us much of this material, in particular William Arveson (who started it all), Edward Effros, Paul Muhly, Vern Paulsen, Gilles Pisier, Zhong-Jin Ruan, Allan Sinclair, and Roger Smith. We thank Matthias Neufang, Bojan Magajna, and Damon Hay for many very helpful suggestions, and Oxford University Press and the LMS Series editors for an excellent job of processing our book. Houston Besan¸con June, 2004
D. P. B. C. L-M.
Contents
1
Operator spaces 1.1 Notation and conventions 1.2 Basic facts, constructions, and examples 1.3 Completely positive maps 1.4 Operator space duality 1.5 Operator space tensor products 1.6 Duality and tensor products 1.7 Notes and historical remarks
1 1 4 16 22 27 38 45
2
Basic theory of operator algebras 2.1 Introducing operator algebras and unitizations 2.2 A few basic constructions 2.3 The abstract characterization of operator algebras 2.4 Universal constructions of operator algebras 2.5 The second dual algebra 2.6 Multiplier algebras and corners 2.7 Dual operator algebras 2.8 Notes and historical remarks
49 49 57 62 68 78 82 88 96
3
Basic theory of operator modules 3.1 Introduction to operator modules 3.2 Hilbert modules 3.3 Operator modules over operator algebras 3.4 Two module tensor products 3.5 Module maps 3.6 Module map extension theorems 3.7 Function modules 3.8 Dual operator modules 3.9 Notes and historical remarks
102 102 109 115 119 123 128 131 136 142
4
Some ‘extremal theory’ 4.1 The Choquet boundary and boundary representations 4.2 The injective envelope 4.3 The C ∗ -envelope 4.4 The injective envelope, the triple envelope, and TROs 4.5 The multiplier algebra of an operator space 4.6 Multipliers and the ‘characterization theorems’ 4.7 Multipliers and duality
147 147 152 156 161 167 175 180
x
Contents 4.8 4.9
Noncommutative M -ideals Notes and historical remarks
183 188
5
Completely isomorphic theory of operator algebras 5.1 Homomorphisms of operator algebras 5.2 Completely bounded characterizations 5.3 Examples of operator algebra structures 5.4 Q-algebras 5.5 Applications to the isomorphic theory 5.6 Notes and historical remarks
195 195 200 209 215 224 228
6
Tensor products of operator algebras 6.1 The maximal and normal tensor products 6.2 Joint dilations and the disc algebra 6.3 Tensor products with triangular algebras 6.4 Pisier’s delta norm 6.5 Factorization through matrix spaces 6.6 Nuclearity and semidiscreteness for linear operators 6.7 Notes and historical remarks
232 232 239 241 248 254 259 265
7
Selfadjointness criteria 7.1 OS-nuclear maps and the weak expectation property 7.2 Hilbert module characterizations 7.3 Tensor product characterizations 7.4 Amenability and virtual diagonals 7.5 Notes and historical remarks
269 269 274 279 282 292
8
C ∗ -modules and operator spaces 8.1 Hilbert C ∗ -modules—the basic theory 8.2 C ∗ -modules as operator spaces. 8.3 Triples, and the noncommutative Shilov boundary 8.4 C ∗ -module maps and operator space multipliers 8.5 W ∗ -modules 8.6 A sample application to operator spaces 8.7 Notes and historical remarks
296 297 308 322 328 331 348 350
Appendix A.1 Operators on Hilbert space A.2 Duality of Banach spaces A.3 Tensor products of Banach spaces A.4 Banach algebras A.5 C ∗ -algebras A.6 Modules and Cohen’s factorization theorem
359 359 360 361 363 364 367
References
369
Index
385
1 Operator spaces
In this chapter, we present quickly the background results about operator spaces which we shall need, and also establish some notation which will be used throughout this book. The reader with a little mathematical maturity could use this chapter as a minicourse on the basics of operator space theory. Fortunately the lengthy proofs here usually belong to the very well-known results (such as Ruan’s theorem, or the extension/characterization theorems for completely positive or completely bounded maps). Thus with the exception of a few such well-known proofs (which may be found in [149, 314, 337, 385, 102]), we can be quite selfcontained. Warning: our proofs in this chapter are often only a good sketch, and some things are left as exercises. The reader should also feel free to skim through this chapter, returning later for a specific definition or fact (we try to be conscientious in later chapters about referencing these by number). Those mainly interested in the general theory of operator spaces, should consult the fine aforementioned texts for a more comprehensive and leisurely development. And of course usually the original papers contain much additional material. We will take for granted facts found in any basic graduate level functional analysis text. For example, we assume that the reader is comfortable with basic spectral theory, the very basics of the theory of C ∗ -algebras and Banach algebras, and standard facts about the various topologies in Banach spaces or dual spaces. Much of this may be found in the Appendix, together with a few of the unexplained terms below. 1.1 NOTATION AND CONVENTIONS 1.1.1 Our set notation and function notation is standard. We use Ac for the complement of a set A. The term ‘scalar’ denotes a number in the complex field C. We use n, m, i, j, k for integers, and I, J or α, β, γ for cardinal numbers. Vector spaces are almost always over the field C unless stated to the contrary. The usual basis of Cn or 2 is written as (ei )i , and we use this notation too in the other p sequence spaces. We write IE , or sometimes I when there is no confusion, for the ‘identity map’ on a vector space E. An isomorphism, at the very least, is always assumed to be linear, one-to-one, and surjective. If T : E → F , and if W ⊂ E is a linear subspace, then we write T|W for the map from W to F obtained by restricting T to W . We often use the symbol q or qW for the canonical surjection
2
Notation and conventions
˙ , or sometimes x, from E onto E/W . We write x+W ˙ for the class of x in E/W , ˙ thus x+W = qW (x). If E is a normed space, we write Ball(E) for the set {x ∈ E : x ≤ 1}. Expressions such as ‘norm closed’, ‘norm closure’, or ‘xn → x in norm’ (or simply ‘closed’, ‘closure’, or ‘xn → x’), mean of course ‘with respect to the norm topology’. All topological spaces are assumed to be Hausdorff. We use standard notation for the standard examples, for example, C(Ω) is the Banach space of scalar valued continuous functions on a compact space Ω. In the literature these are often called ‘C(K)-spaces’, and of course are exactly the commutative unital C ∗ -algebras (see A.5.4). We use the letters H, K, L for Hilbert spaces. Thus if these letters appear in the text without explanation, they will always be Hilbert spaces. We write B(E, F ) for the space of bounded linear operators from E to F , and B(E) = B(E, E). Indeed whenever C(X, Y ) is a class of operators then we use C(X) for C(X, X). We write E ∗ for the dual space of E, namely E ∗ = B(E, C), and we often write E∗ for a predual of E (if such exists). We write iE : E → E ∗∗ for the canonical embedding, but will often simply think of E as a subspace of E ∗∗ . We abbreviate ‘weak*’ to ‘w ∗ ’ usually. Thus we write w∗ w∗ -continuous, w∗ -topology, w∗ -closure, etc. Thus S denotes the w∗ -closure of a set S. We say that a net of maps Tt : E → F converges strongly (or point-norm) if Tt (x) → T (x) in the norm topology of F for all x ∈ E. If F is a dual space then Tt → T point-w∗ if Tt (x) → T (x) in the w∗ -topology of F for all x ∈ E. A multilinear map between dual spaces is said to be separately w ∗ -continuous if whenever one fixes all but one of the variables, then the map is w ∗ -continuous in the remaining variable. We recommend that the reader review the facts about the w∗ -topology presented in the first sections of the Appendix. An operator T between normed spaces, with T ≤ 1, is called a contraction. A quotient map T : E → F is a linear map which maps the ‘open unit ball of E’ onto the ‘open unit ball of F ’. A projection or idempotent on a space E is a map P : E → E satisfying P ◦ P = P . However if E is a Hilbert space then we will mean more, indeed for an operator on a Hilbert space, or more generally for an element of an operator algebra, we always use the term projection to mean an orthogonal (i.e. selfadjoint) idempotent. If K is a closed linear subspace of a Hilbert space H then PK is the canonical projection from H onto K. 1.1.2 For emphasis, we list separately here some of our major conventions. First, we usually suppose that all of our normed spaces are complete. This is not a serious restriction, since the completion of an operator space is again an operator space; and the ‘incomplete’ versions of most results ‘pass to the completion’ without difficulty. We make the ‘completeness’ assumption mostly to avoid having to be constantly making annoying and repetitious remarks about results ‘passing to the completion’. Another convention is our use of the notation XY for sets X, Y . Assume that we have a pairing X × Y → E where E is a Banach space. Write this pairing as the map (x, y) → xy. Then XY usually denotes the closure in the norm topology in E of the linear span of the xy, for x ∈ X and y ∈ Y . We write Span(XY ) if we are not taking the closure here.
Operator spaces
3
See also A.6.4 for some important related facts. There is an exception to this notation; if K is a subset of a Hilbert space H and if D ⊂ B(H, L) is a set of operators then we use [DK] for the norm closure in L of the span of terms xζ for x ∈ D, ζ ∈ K. If X is a subspace of B(K, H) or of a C ∗ -algebra, then we often use the symbol X (also written as X ∗ when there is no possible confusion with the dual space) for the set of ‘adjoints’ or ‘involutions’ {x∗ : x ∈ X}. 1.1.3 (Matrix notation) Fix m, n ∈ N. If X is a vector space, then so is Mm,n (X), the set of m × n matrices with entries in X. This may also be thought of as the algebraic tensor product Mm,n ⊗ X, where Mm,n = Mm,n (C). We write In for the identity matrix of Mn = Mn,n . We write Mn (X) = Mn,n (X), Cn (X) = Mn,1 (X) and Rn (X) = M1,n (X). If x is a matrix, then xij or xi,j denotes the i-j entry of x, and we write x as [xij ] or [xi,j ]i,j . We write (Eij )ij for the usual (matrix unit) basis of Mm,n (we allow m, n infinite here too). We write A → At for the transpose on Mm,n , or more generally on Mm,n (X). We will frequently meet large matrices with row and column indexing that is sometimes cumbersome. For example, a matrix [a(i,k,p),(j,l,q) ] is indexed on rows by (i, k, p) and on columns by (j, l, q), and may also be written as [a(i,k,p),(j,l,q) ](i,k,p),(j,l,q) if additional clarity is needed. 1.1.4 The Hilbert space direct sum will be written as ⊕2 , or simply ⊕ (but we use the latter for some other kinds of direct sums too). We also write H (α) or 2α (H) for the Hilbert space direct sum of α copies of H. Here α is a cardinal. This is called a multiple of H. The Hilbert space tensor product is denoted H ⊗2 K. If S, T are operators on H and K respectively, then we write S ⊗ T for the usual operator on H ⊗2 K taking a rank one tensor ζ ⊗ η in H ⊗ K to S(ζ) ⊗ T (η). In particular, S ⊗ IK is often called a multiple of S. Indeed, if K is identified with 2α for some cardinal α, then we may unitarily identify H ⊗2 K with 2α (H), and S ⊗ IK with S α . Here S α ((ζi )) = (Sζi ), for (ζi ) ∈ 2α (H). The commutant of a subset S ⊂ B(H) is written as S or [S] . The C ∗ -identity is the statement T ∗T = T 2, valid for any bounded operator T between Hilbert spaces, or any element of a C ∗ -algebra. We write S p (K, H) for the Schatten p class (see also A.1.2 and A.1.3). If H = K is n-dimensional then we write this as Snp , thus Sn1 is the dual space of Mn . We use WOT for the weak operator topology (see A.1.4), although we usually prefer to use the (finer) w ∗ -topology (= σ-weak topology, see A.1.2). Which of these two topologies one uses is often a matter of taste, in the situations we consider. Very frequently, we will need the polarization identity. We state one form of it: Suppose that E and F are vector spaces, and that Ψ : E × E → F is linear in the second variable and conjugate linear in the first variable. Then 1 k i Ψ(x + ik y, x + ik y), 4 3
Ψ(y, x) =
k=0
x, y ∈ E.
(1.1)
4
Basic facts, constructions, and examples
This is frequently applied when E = F is a ∗-algebra, and Ψ(x, y) = x∗ y. 1.1.5 We also use some basic notions from algebra, such as the definitions of modules, algebras, ideals, direct sum, tensor product, etc. These may be found in any graduate algebra text. Our spaces, of course, usually have extra functional analytic structure, and in particular possess a (complete) norm. If A is an algebra, then Mn (A) is also an algebra, if one uses the usual formula for multiplying matrices. We usually refer to a closed two-sided ideal of a normed algebra simply as an ‘ideal’. One unusual usage: we use the term unital-subalgebra for a subalgebra of a unital algebra A containing the unit (identity) of A. Similarly, a unital-subspace is a subspace containing the ‘unit’ of the superspace. A unital map is one that takes the unit to the unit. We use the very basics of the language of categories, such as the notion of object, morphism, and functor. The main categories we are interested in here are those of Banach spaces and bounded linear maps, operator spaces and completely bounded linear maps, operator algebras and completely contractive homomorphisms, C ∗ -algebras and ∗-homomorphisms, and operator modules and completely bounded module maps. These notions will be introduced in detail later. However it is worth saying that each of these categories (and any others we shall meet) has its own notion of ‘isomorphism’ (i.e. when we consider two objects as being essentially the same), subobject, embedding, quotient, quotient map, direct sum, etc. When we use one of these words in later chapters, it is usually understood to be with reference to the category that we are working in. For example, in Chapter 2 we may simply write ‘A ∼ = B’, or ‘A ∼ = B as operator algebras’, and say that ‘A is isomorphic to B’, when we really mean that there is a surjective algebra homomorphism between them which is completely isometric (defined below). Or we may write A → B to indicate that A is ‘embedded’ in B in the suitable sense of that chapter. For example, in Chapter 2 it means that there is a completely isometric algebra homomorphism from A to B. 1.2 BASIC FACTS, CONSTRUCTIONS, AND EXAMPLES 1.2.1 (Completely bounded maps) Suppose that X and Y are vector spaces and that u : X → Y is a linear map. For a positive integer n, we write un for the associated map [xij ] → [u(xij )] from Mn (X) to Mn (Y ). This is often called the (nth) amplification of u, and may also be thought of as the map IMn ⊗ u on Mn ⊗ X. Similarly one may define um,n : Mm,n (X) → Mm,n (Y ). If each matrix space Mn (X) and Mn (Y ) has a given norm · n , and if un is an isometry for all n ∈ N, then we say that u is completely isometric, or is a complete isometry. Similarly, u is completely contractive (resp. is a complete quotient map) if each un is a contraction (resp. takes the open ball of Mn (X) onto the open ball of Mn (Y )). A map u is completely bounded if def ucb = sup [u(xij )]n : [xij ]n ≤ 1, all n ∈ N < ∞.
Operator spaces
5
Compositions of completely bounded maps are completely bounded, and one has the expected relation u ◦ vcb ≤ ucbvcb. If u : X → Y is a completely bounded linear bijection, and if its inverse is completely bounded too, then we say that u is a complete isomorphism. In this case, we say that X and Y are completely isomorphic and we write X ≈ Y . 1.2.2 (Operator spaces) If m, n ∈ N, and K, H are Hilbert spaces, then we always assign Mm,n (B(K, H)) the norm (written · m,n ) ensuring that Mm,n (B(K, H)) ∼ = B(K (n) , H (m) )
isometrically
(1.2)
via the natural algebraic isomorphism. Recall from 1.1.4 that H (m) = 2m (H) is the Hilbert space direct sum of m copies of H, for example. A concrete operator space is a (usually closed) linear subspace X of B(K, H), for Hilbert spaces H, K (indeed the case H = K usually suffices, via the canonical inclusion B(K, H) ⊂ B(H ⊕ K)). However we will want to keep track too of the norm · m,n that Mm,n (X) inherits from Mm,n (B(K, H)), for all m, n ∈ N. We write · n for · n,n ; indeed when there is no danger of confusion, we simply write [xij ] for [xij ]n . An abstract operator space is a pair (X, { · n }n≥1 ), consisting of a vector space X, and a norm on Mn (X) for all n ∈ N, such that there exists a linear complete isometry u : X → B(K, H). In this case we call the sequence { · n }n an operator space structure on the vector space X. An operator space structure on a normed space (X, ·) will usually mean a sequence of matrix norms as above, but with · = · 1 . Clearly subspaces of operator spaces are again operator spaces. We often identify two operator spaces X and Y if they are completely isometrically isomorphic. In this case we often write ‘X ∼ = Y completely isometrically’, or say ‘X ∼ = Y as operator spaces’. Sometimes we simply write X = Y . 1.2.3 (C ∗ -algebras) If A is a C ∗ -algebra then the ∗-algebra Mn (A) has a unique norm with respect to which it is a C ∗ -algebra, by A.5.8. With respect to these matrix norms, A is an operator space. This may be seen by noting that M n (A) corresponds to a closed ∗-subalgebra of B(H (n) ), when A is a closed ∗-subalgebra of B(H). We call this the canonical operator space structure on a C ∗ -algebra. If the C ∗ -algebra A is commutative, then A = C0 (Ω) for a locally compact space Ω, and then these matrix norms are determined via the canonical isomorphism Mn (C0 (Ω)) = C0 (Ω; Mn ). Explicitly, if [fij ] ∈ Mn (C0 (Ω)), then: (1.3) [fij ]n = sup [fij (t)]. t∈Ω
To see this, note that by the above one only needs to verify that (1.3) does indeed define a C ∗ -norm on Mn (C0 (Ω)). Proposition 1.2.4 For a homomorphism π : A → B between C ∗ -algebras, the following are equivalent: (i) π is contractive, (ii) π is completely contractive, and (iii) π is a ∗-homomorphism. If these hold, then π(A) is closed, and π is a
6
Basic facts, constructions, and examples
complete quotient map onto π(A); moreover π is one-to-one if and only if it is completely isometric. 2
Proof Apply A.5.8 to the ‘amplifications’ πn . ∗
1.2.5 (Norm of a row or column) Suppose that A is a C -algebra, or a space of the form B(K, H), for Hilbert spaces H, K. If X is a subspace of A, and if x1 , . . . , xn ∈ X, then we have x1 n n 1 12 2 .. ∗ ∗ [x1 · · · xn ] = x x and = x x k k k k , (1.4) Rn (X) . k=1 k=1 xn C (X) n
where the product and involution mean the obvious thing (in the ambient superspace). Indeed this follows from the C ∗ -identity (see 1.1.4). 1.2.6 (Maps into a commutative C ∗ -algebra) If [aij ] ∈ Mn then
[aij ] = sup aij zj wi : z = [zj ], w = [wi ] ∈ Ball(2n ) . ij
It is easy to see that this also holds, but with ‘=’ replaced by ‘≥’, and | · | replaced by · , if aij ∈ B(H). Using these formulae, it is a simple exercise to see that any continuous functional ϕ : X → C on an operator space X is completely bounded, with ϕ = ϕcb. From this and equation (1.3), it follows that u = ucb for any bounded linear map u from an operator space into a commutative C ∗ -algebra. 1.2.7 The following trivial principle is used very often: If we are given complete contractions v : X → Y and u : Y → Z, and if uv is a complete isometry (resp. complete quotient map) then v is a complete isometry (resp. u is a complete quotient map). If, further, Z = X and uv and vu are both equal to the identity map, then both u and v are surjective complete isometries, and u = v −1 . Theorem 1.2.8 (Haagerup, Paulsen, Wittstock) Suppose that X is a subspace of a C ∗ -algebra B, that H and K are Hilbert spaces, and that u : X → B(K, H) is a completely bounded map. Then there exists a Hilbert space L, a ∗-representation π : B → B(L) (which may be taken to be unital if B is unital), and bounded operators S : L → H and T : K → L, such that u(x) = Sπ(x)T for all x ∈ X. Moreover this can be done with ST = ucb. In particular, if ϕ ∈ Ball(X ∗ ), and if B is as above, then there exist L, π as above, and unit vectors ζ, η ∈ L, with ϕ = π(·)ζ, η on X. The very last line clearly follows from the lines above it, and 1.2.6. Also note that conversely, any linear map u of the form u = Sπ(·)T as above, is completely bounded with ucb ≤ ST . This is an easy exercise using Proposition 1.2.4. We omit the well-known proof of Theorem 1.2.8 (see the cited texts above).
Operator spaces
7
1.2.9 (Injective spaces) An operator space Z is said to be injective if for any completely bounded linear map u : X → Z and for any operator space Y containing X as a closed subspace, there exists a completely bounded extension ucb = ucb. A similar definition exists for u ˆ : Y → Z such that uˆ|X = u and ˆ Banach spaces. Thus an operator space (resp. Banach space) is injective if and only if it is an ‘injective object’ in the category of operator (resp. Banach) spaces and completely contractive (resp. contractive) linear maps. The following is ‘contained’ in Theorem 1.2.8 (and the remark after it). Theorem 1.2.10 If H and K are Hilbert spaces then B(K, H) is an injective operator space. Recall that one version of the Hahn–Banach theorem may be formulated as the statement that C is injective (as a Banach space). Thus 1.2.10 is a ‘generalized Hahn–Banach theorem’. Corollary 1.2.11 An operator space is injective if and only if it is linearly completely isometric to the range of a completely contractive idempotent map on B(H), for some Hilbert space H. Proof (⇒) Supposing X ⊂ B(H), extend IX to a map from B(H) to X. (⇐) Follows from 1.2.10 and an obvious diagram chase.
2
1.2.12 (Properties of matrix norms) If K, H are Hilbert spaces, and if X is a subspace of B(K, H), then there are certain well-known properties satisfied by the matrix norms ·m,n described in 1.2.2. For example, adding (or dropping) a row of zeros or column of zeros does not change the norm of a matrix of operators. By this principle we really only need to specify the norms for square matrices, that is, the case m = n above. Also, switching two rows (or two columns) of a matrix of operators does not change its norm. From this we derive another useful property. Namely, the canonical algebraic isomorphisms Mn (Mm (X)) ∼ = Mm (Mn (X)) ∼ = Mmn (X)
(1.5)
are isometric, and hence, by iteration, completely isometric. Thus if X is an operator space then so is Mn (X) (or Mm,n (X)). As an exercise in operator theory, one may verify that for such X we have: (R1) αxβn ≤ αxn β, for all n ∈ N and all α, β ∈ Mn , and x ∈ Mn (X) (where multiplication of an element of Mn (X) by an element of Mn is defined in the obvious way). (R2) For all x ∈ Mm (X) and y ∈ Mn (X), we have x 0 = max{xm , yn}. 0 y m+n Conditions (R1) and (R2) above are often called Ruan’s axioms. Ruan’s theorem asserts that (R1) and (R2) characterize operator space structures on a
8
Basic facts, constructions, and examples
vector space. This result is fundamental to our subject in many ways. At the most pedestrian level, it is used frequently to check that certain abstract constructions with operator spaces remain operator spaces. At a more sophisticated level, it is the foundational and unifying principle of operator space theory. Theorem 1.2.13 (Ruan) Suppose that X is a vector space, and that for each n ∈ N we are given a norm · n on Mn (X). Then X is linearly completely isometrically isomorphic to a linear subspace of B(H), for some Hilbert space H, if and only if conditions (R1) and (R2) above hold. 1.2.14 (Quotient operator spaces) If Y ⊂ X is a closed linear subspace of an operator space, then using Ruan’s theorem one can easily check that X/Y is an operator space with matrix norms coming from the identification Mn (X/Y ) ∼ = Mn (X)/Mn (Y ). Explicitly, these matrix norms are given by the ˙ ]n = inf{[xij + yij ]n : yij ∈ Y }. Here xij ∈ X. formula [xij +Y 1.2.15 (Factor theorem) If u : X → Z is completely bounded, and if Y is a closed subspace of X contained in Ker(u), then the canonical map u ˜ : X/Y → Z induced by u is also completely bounded, with ˜ ucb = ucb. If Y = Ker(u), then u is a complete quotient map if and only if u ˜ is a completely isometric isomorphism. Indeed this follows exactly the usual Banach space case. 1.2.16 (Operator seminorms) An operator seminorm structure on a vector space X is a sequence ρ = {ρn }∞ n=1 , where ρn is a seminorm on Mn (X), satisfying axioms (R1) and (R2) discussed in 1.2.12. In this case, and if N is defined to be {x ∈ X : ρ1 (x) = 0}, by (R1) we have that the kernel of ρn is Mn (N ), and ρ induces matrix norms on X/N in the obvious fashion. By Ruan’s theorem, (the completion of) X/N is then an operator space. Let X be a vector space, and let F = {Ti : i ∈ I} be a set of linear maps, where Ti maps X into an operator space Zi , for each i ∈ I. We suppose that supi Ti (x) < ∞, for all x ∈ X. Let N = ∩i Ker(Ti ). For each n ∈ N, we define a seminorm on Mn (X) by [xpq ] −→ sup [Ti (xpq )]. i
This is fairly clearly an operator seminorm structure for X. Using the facts in the last paragraph, these seminorms become matrix norms on X/N , and with these norms (the completion of) X/N is an operator space. Similarly, if I is a directed set then the expressions lim supi [Ti (xpq )] define an operator seminorm structure on X. This yields an operator space as before. 1.2.17 (The ∞-direct sum) This is the simplest direct sum of a family of operator spaces {Xλ : λ ∈ I}, and we will write this operator space as ⊕λ Xλ (or ⊕∞ λ Xλ if more clarity is needed). If I = {1, . . . , n} then we usually write this sum as X1 ⊕∞ · · · ⊕∞ Xn . If Xλ ⊂ B(Hλ ) then ⊕λ Xλ may be regarded as the obvious subspace of B(⊕2λ Hλ ). A tuple (xλ ) is in ⊕∞ λ Xλ if and only if xλ ∈ Xλ
Operator spaces
9
for all λ, and supλ xλ < ∞. We may identify Mn (⊕λ Xλ ) with ⊕λ Mn (Xλ ) isometrically (and by iteration, completely isometrically). Thus if x ∈ Mn (⊕λ Xλ ), then we have xn = supλ xλ Mn (Xλ ) . Clearly the canonical inclusion and projection maps between ⊕λ Xλ and its ‘λth summand’ are complete isometries and complete quotient maps respectively. If Xλ are C ∗ -algebras then this direct sum is the usual C ∗ -algebra direct sum. If the Xλ are W ∗ -algebras then this direct sum is a W ∗ -algebra too, and is easy to work with in terms of the canonical central projections corresponding to the summands. The ∞-direct sum has the following universal property. If Z is an operator space and uλ : Z → Xλ are completely contractive linear maps, then there is a canonical complete contraction Z → ⊕λ Xλ taking z ∈ Z to the tuple (uλ (z)). If Xλ = X for all λ ∈ I, then we usually write ∞ I (X) for ⊕λ Xλ . If I = N we may simply write ∞ (X). Note that we have ∼ ∞ Mn (∞ I (X)) = I (Mn (X)). If I = N then one may define a c0 -direct sum operator space of operator spaces X1 , X2 , . . . . This is simply the subspace of ⊕∞ n Xn consisting of tuples (xn ) with limn xn = 0. We write c0 (X) for this space if Xn = X for all n. 1.2.18 (Operator valued continuous functions) Let Ω be a compact space, let X be an operator space, and consider the space C(Ω; X) of continuous X-valued functions on Ω (see A.3.2). This is an operator space with matrix norms coming from the identification Mn (C(Ω; X)) = C(Ω; Mn (X)). Clearly this ‘canonical’ operator space structure is given by the same formula as (1.3), and the natural ∗ embedding C(Ω; X) ⊂ ∞ Ω (X) is a complete isometry. Note that if A is a C ∗ algebra, then C(Ω; A) is a C -algebra, with product as pointwise multiplication and with f ∗ (t) = (f (t))∗ for any f ∈ C(Ω; A) and t ∈ Ω. Similarly if Ω is merely a locally compact space, then C0 (Ω; X) is an operator space as well, with Mn (C0 (Ω; X)) = C0 (Ω; Mn (X)) for all n. 1.2.19 (Mapping spaces) If X, Y are operator spaces, then the space CB(X, Y ) of completely bounded linear maps from X to Y , is also an operator space, with matrix norms determined via the canonical isomorphism between Mn (CB(X, Y )) and CB(X, Mn (Y )). Equivalently, if [uij ] ∈ Mn (CB(X, Y )), then (1.6) [uij ]n = sup [uij (xkl )]nm : [xkl ] ∈ Ball(Mm (X)), m ∈ N . Here the matrix [uij (xkl )] is indexed on rows by i and k and on columns by j and l. Applying the above with n replaced by nN , to the space of matrices MN (Mn (CB(X, Y ))) = MnN (CB(X, Y )), yields Mn (CB(X, Y )) ∼ = CB(X, Mn (Y ))
completely isometrically.
(1.7)
One may see that (1.6) defines an operator space structure on CB(X, Y ) by appealing to Ruan’s theorem 1.2.13 (directly or in the form of 1.2.16). Alternatively, one may see it as follows. Consider the set I = ∪n Ball(Mn (X)), and for
10
Basic facts, constructions, and examples
x ∈ Ball(Mm (X)) ⊂ I set nx = m. Consider the operator space direct sum (see 1.2.17) ⊕∞ x∈I Mnx (Y ). Then the map from CB(X, Y ) to ⊕x∈I Mnx (Y ) taking u to the tuple ((Inx ⊗ u)(x))x ∈ ⊕x Mnx (Y ) is (almost tautologically) a complete isometry. Thus CB(X, Y ) is an operator space. 1.2.20 (The dual of an operator space) The special case when Y = C in 1.2.19 is particularly important. In this case, for any operator space X, we obtain by 1.2.19 an operator space structure on X ∗ = CB(X, C). The latter space equals B(X, C) isometrically by 1.2.6. We call X ∗ , viewed as an operator space in this way, the operator space dual of X. This duality will be studied further in Sections 1.4–1.6. By (1.7) we have Mn (X ∗ ) ∼ = CB(X, Mn )
completely isometrically.
(1.8)
Note that the map implementing this isomorphism is exactly the canonical map (described in A.3.1) from Mn ⊗ X ∗ to B(X, Mn ). 1.2.21 (Minimal operator spaces) Let E be a Banach space, and consider the canonical isometric inclusion of E in the commutative C ∗ -algebra C(Ball(E ∗ )). Here E ∗ is equipped with the w∗ -topology. This inclusion induces, via 1.2.3, an operator space structure on E, which is denoted by Min(E). By (1.3), the resulting matrix norms on E are given by (1.9) [xij ]n = sup [ϕ(xij )] : ϕ ∈ Ball(E ∗ ) for [xij ] ∈ Mn (E). Thus every Banach space may be canonically considered to be an operator space. Since Min(E) ⊂ C(Ball(E ∗ )), we see from 1.2.6 that for any bounded linear u from an operator space Y into E, we have u : Y −→ Min(E)cb = u : Y −→ E.
(1.10)
From this last fact one easily sees that Min(E) is the smallest operator space structure on E. Also, if Ω is any compact space and if i : E → C(Ω) is an isometry, then the matrix norms inherited by E from the operator space structure of C(Ω), coincide again with those in (1.9). This may be seen by applying 1.2.6 to i and i−1 . Summarizing: ‘minimal operator spaces’ are exactly the operator spaces completely isometrically isomorphic to a subspace of a C(K)-space. According to A.3.1, another way of stating (1.9) is to say that ˇ Mn Min(E) = Mn ⊗E (1.11) isometrically via the canonical isomorphism. 1.2.22 (Maximal operator spaces) If E is a Banach space then Max(E) is the largest operator space structure we can put on E. We define the matrix norms on Max(E) by the following formula [xij ]n = sup [u(xij )] : u ∈ Ball(B(E, Y )), all operator spaces Y . This may be seen to be an operator space structure on X by using 1.2.16 say; and from this formula it is also clear that it is the largest such. Since every Banach
Operator spaces
11
space is isometric to an operator space (see 1.2.21), · 1 is evidently the usual norm on E. It is clear from this formula that Max(E) has the property that for any operator space Y , and for any bounded linear u : E → Y , we have u : Max(E) −→ Y cb = u : E −→ Y .
(1.12)
1.2.23 (Hilbert column and row spaces) If H is a Hilbert space then there are two canonical operator space structures on H most commonly considered. The first is the Hilbert column space H c . Informally one should think of H c as a ‘column in B(H)’. Thus if H = 2n then H c = Mn,1 , thought of as the matrices in Mn which are ‘zero except on the first column’. We write this operator space also as Cn , and the ‘row’ version as Rn . For a general Hilbert space H there are several simple ways of describing H c more precisely. For example, one may identify H c with the concrete operator space B(C, H). Another equivalent description is as follows (we leave the equivalence as an exercise). If η is a fixed unit vector in H, then the set H ⊗η of rank one operators ζ ⊗η is a closed subspace of B(H) which is isometric to H via the map ζ → ζ ⊗ η. (By convention, ζ ⊗ η maps ξ ∈ H to ξ, ηζ.) Thus we may transfer the operator space structure on H ⊗ η inherited from B(H) over to H. The resulting operator space structure is independent of η and coincides with H c . Indeed from the C ∗ -identity in Mn (B(H)) applied to [ζij ⊗ η], one immediately obtains n 21 [ζij ]Mn (H c ) = ζkj , ζki ,
[ζij ] ∈ Mn (H).
(1.13)
k=1
If T ∈ B(H, K) then T = T cb, where the latter is the norm taken in CB(H c , K c ). Indeed let [ζij ] ∈ Mn (H c ), and let α ∈ B(2n , 2n (H)) correspond to this matrix via the identity Mn (H c ) = Mn (B(C, H)) = B(2n , 2n (H)). Likewise let β ∈ B(2n , 2n (K)) corresponding to [T ζij ]. Then β = (I2n ⊗ T ) ◦ α, and hence β ≤ T α. This shows that T cb ≤ T . More generally, we have B(H, K) = CB(H c , K c )
completely isometrically
(1.14)
We give a quick proof of this identity in the Notes for this section. A subspace K of a Hilbert column space H c is again a Hilbert column space, as may be seen by considering (1.13). Similarly the quotient H c /K c is a Hilbert column space completely isometric to (H K)c , as may be seen by applying 1.2.15 to the canonical (completely contractive by (1.14)) projection P from H c onto (H K)c . ¯ is a Hilbert We define Hilbert row space similarly. Recalling that H ∗ ∼ = H r ¯ space too, we identify H with the concrete operator space B(H, C). Analogues of the above results for H c hold, except that there is a slight twist in the corresponding version of (1.14). Namely, although B(H, K) = CB(H r , K r ) isometrically, this is not true completely isometrically. Instead there is a canonical ¯ r ). We have ¯ r, H completely isometric isomorphism B(H, K) ∼ = CB(K
12
Basic facts, constructions, and examples ¯r (H c )∗ ∼ = H
and
¯c (H r )∗ ∼ = H
(1.15)
completely isometrically using the operator space dual structure in 1.2.20. The first relation is obtained by setting K = C in (1.14). Similarly, the second relation follows e.g. from the line above (1.15). We write C and R for 2 with its column and row operator space structures respectively. 1.2.24 (The operator space R ∩ C) We let R ∩ C be 2 with the operator space structure defined by the embedding 2 → R ⊕∞ C which takes any x ∈ 2 to the pair (x, x). Let (ek )k≥1 denote the canonical basis of 2 . Then it follows from (1.4) that for any N ≥ 1 and any x1 , . . . , xn in MN , we have 1 1 (1.16) xk ⊗ ek MN (R∩C) = max x∗k xk 2 , xk x∗k 2 . k
k
k
We also note that if X is an operator space and u : X → 2 is a bounded linear map, then u is completely bounded from X into R ∩ C if and only if it is both completely bounded from X into R and from X into C. Moreover we have (1.17) u : X → R ∩ Ccb = max u : X → Rcb , u : X → Ccb . 1.2.25 (Opposite and adjoint) If X is an operator space, in B(K, H) say, then we define the adjoint operator space to be the space X = {x∗ : x ∈ X} (see 1.1.2). As an abstract operator space X is independent of the particular representation of X on H and K. Indeed we can alternatively define X as the ¯ ∗ , and with set of formal symbols x∗ for x ∈ X, with scalar product λx∗ = (λx) ∗ matrix norms [xij ]n = [xji ]n , where the latter norm is taken in Mn (X). The adjoint operator space is sometimes denoted by X by some authors. However we warn the reader that X is not the same as the conjugate operator space considered in [337]. If X is an operator space then we define the opposite operator space X op to be the Banach space X with the ‘transposed matrix norms’ [xij ]op n = [xji ]n . Note that if A is a C ∗ -algebra, then these matrix norms on Aop coincide with the canonical matrix norms on the C ∗ -algebra which is A with its reversed multiplication. If X is a subspace of a C ∗ -algebra A, then X op may be identified completely isometrically with the associated subspace of the C ∗ -algebra Aop . If u : X → Y , then we write uop for u considered as a map from X op to Y op , and u for the map from X to Y defined by u (x∗ ) = u(x)∗ . These maps are completely bounded, completely contractive, completely isometric, etc., if u has these properties. There is a ‘conjugate linear complete isometry’ from X op to X , namely the map x → x∗ . 1.2.26 (Matrix spaces) If X is an operator space, and I, J are cardinal numbers or sets, then we write MI,J (X) for the set of I × J matrices whose finite submatrices have uniformly bounded norm. Such a matrix is normed by the supremum
Operator spaces
13
of the norms of its finite submatrices. Similarly there is an obvious way to define a norm on Mn (MI,J (X)) by equating this space with MI,J (Mn (X)), and one has Mn (MI (X)) ∼ = Mn.I (X), for n ∈ N. We are being deliberately careless here, and indeed in the rest of the book we often abusively blur the distinction between cardinals and sets. Technically if I, J are cardinals, we should fix sets I0 and J0 of cardinality I and J respectively, consider matrices [xij ] indexed by i ∈ I0 and j ∈ J0 , and write MI0 ,J0 (X) instead of MI,J (X). However if one chooses different sets I1 and J1 of these cardinalities, then there is an obvious completely isometric isomorphism MI0 ,J0 (X) ∼ = MI1 ,J1 (X), so that with a little care our convention should not lead us into trouble. Or we may protect ourselves by fixing one well-ordered set associated with each cardinal. We write MI (X) = MI,I (X), CIw (X) = MI,1 (X), and RIw (X) = M1,I (X). If I = ℵ0 we simply denote these spaces by M(X), C w (X) and Rw (X) respectively. Also, Mfin I,J (X) will denote the vector subspace of MI,J (X) consisting of ‘finitely supported matrices’, that is, those matrices with only a finite number of nonzero entries. We write KI,J (X) for the norm closure in MI,J (X) of Mfin I,J (X). We set KI (X) = KI,I (X), CI (X) = KI,1 (X), and RI (X) = K1,I (X). Again we merely write K(X), R(X) and C(X) for these spaces if I = ℵ0 . If X = C then CIw (C) = CI (C) = (2I )c (see 1.2.23 for this notation), and we usually write this column Hilbert space as CI . Similarly, RI = RI (C) = (2I )r . We write KI,J for KI,J (C), and MI,J for MI,J (C). It is fairly obvious that if u : X → Y is completely bounded, then so is the obvious amplification uI,J : MI,J (X) → MI,J (Y ), and uI,J cb = ucb. Clearly uI,J also restricts to a completely bounded map from KI,J (X) to KI,J (Y ). If u is a complete isometry, then so is uI,J . Thus the MI,J (·) and KI,J (·) constructions are ‘injective’ in some sense. For cardinals I, J, we leave it as an exercise that MI,J ∼ = B(2J , 2I ). Via this ∞ 2 2 identification, KI,J = S (J , I ). Thus for any Hilbert spaces K, H we have that B(K, H) ∼ = MI0 ,J0 for some cardinals I0 , J0 . We leave it as another exercise that MI,J (MI0 ,J0 ) ∼ = MI×I0 ,J×J0
(1.18)
completely isometrically. Putting these two exercises together, we have established that for any cardinals I, J, we have MI,J (B(K, H)) ∼ = B(K (J) , H (I) )
completely isometrically.
(1.19)
If X is an operator space then so is MI,J (X). This may be seen by choosing a completely isometric embedding X ⊂ B(H), and noting that by the ‘injectivity’ mentioned a few paragraphs back, and formula (1.19), we have MI,J (X) ⊂ MI,J (B(H)) ∼ = B(H (J) , H (I) ) completely isometrically. If X is complete then so is MI,J (X), since it is clearly norm closed in MI,J (B(K, H)). For any operator space X, we have MI,J (X) = CIw (RJw (X)) = RJw (CIw (X)).
(1.20)
14
Basic facts, constructions, and examples
One way to see this is to first check (1.20) in the case X = B(H) using (1.19), and then use this fact to do the general case. By a similar argument, MI,J (MI0 ,J0 (X)) ∼ = MI×I0 ,J×J0 (X) for any operator space X, generalizing (1.18). 1.2.27 (Infinite sums) Suppose that X, Y are subspaces of a (complete) operw ator algebra or C ∗ -algebra A ⊂ B(H). Let I be an infinite set. If x ∈ RI (X) and y ∈ CI (Y ), then the ‘product’ xy (defined to be i xi yi if x and y have ith entries xi and yi respectively) actually converges in norm to an element of A. To see this, we use the following notation. If z is an element of RIw (X) or CI (Y ), and if ∆ ⊂ I, write z∆ for z but with all entries outside ∆ ‘switched to zero’. Since y ∈ CI (Y ), given > 0 there is a finite set ∆ ⊂ I, such that y − y∆ = y∆c < . If ∆ is a finite subset of I not intersecting ∆ then xi yi = x∆ y∆ ≤ x∆ y∆ ≤ xy∆ < x. i∈∆
Hence the sum converges in norm as claimed. Thus we have RIw (X) CI (Y ) ⊂ XY
and
RI (X) CIw (Y ) ⊂ XY,
(1.21)
where XY is as defined in 1.1.2, a closed subset of A. Also xy ≤ xy for x, y as above, as may be seen from a computation identical to the first part of the second last centered equation. Proposition 1.2.28 For any operator space X and cardinal I, we have that CB(CI , X) ∼ = RIw (X) and CB(RI , X) ∼ = CIw (X) completely isometrically. Proof We prove just the first relation. Define L : RIw (X) → CB(CI , X) by w L(x)(z) = i xi zi , for x ∈ RI (X), z ∈ CI . This map is well defined, by the argument for (1.21) for example. It is also easy to check, by looking at the partial sums of this series as in (1.21), that L is contractive. Conversely, for u in CB(CI , X), let x ∈ RIw (X) have ith entry u(ei ), where (ei ) is the canonical basis. It is not hard to see that xRw ≤ ucb, and L(x) = u. Thus L is a I (X) surjective isometry. This together with (1.7) yields Mm (CB(CI , X)) ∼ = CB(CI , Mm (X)) ∼ = RIw (Mm (X)) ∼ = Mm (RIw (X)) isometrically. From this one sees that L is a complete isometry.
2
Proposition 1.2.29 If X and Y are operator spaces then there are canonical complete isometries KI,J (CB(X, Y )) → CB(X, KI,J (Y )) → CB(X, MI,J (Y )) ∼ = MI,J (CB(X, Y )). In particular, if Y = C, we have CB(X, MI,J ) ∼ = MI,J (X ∗ ). Proof Since KI,J (Y ) ⊂ MI,J (Y ), the middle inclusion is evident. There is a canonical map Θ : MI,J (CB(X, Y )) → CB(X, MI,J (Y )), which takes an element
Operator spaces
15
[uij ] from MI,J (CB(X, Y )), to the map x → [uij (x)]. Also there is a canonical map CB(X, MI,J (Y )) → MI,J (CB(X, Y )), which takes u to the matrix [πij ◦ u], where πij is the projection of MI,J (Y ) onto its i-j entry. It is rather easy to check that these maps are mutual inverses, and are both completely contractive. Hence they are complete isometries. Thus MI,J (CB(X, Y )) ∼ = CB(X, MI,J (Y )). Finally, the isometry above taking MI,J (CB(X, Y )) into CB(X, MI,J (Y )), clearly takes Mfin I,J (CB(X, Y )) into CB(X, KI,J (Y )). By density, KI,J (CB(X, Y )) em2 beds completely isometrically in CB(X, KI,J (Y )). 1.2.30 (Interpolation) We recall the complex interpolation method for Banach spaces (e.g. see [33, Chapter 4]). Suppose that (X0 , X1 ) is a compatible couple of Banach spaces. This means that we are given a topological vector space Z, and one-to-one continuous linear mappings from X0 to Z and X1 to Z. Regard X0 and X1 as subspaces of Z. Their ‘sum’ X0 + X1 ⊂ Z is, by definition, the space of all x0 + x1 , with x0 ∈ X0 and x1 ∈ X1 . This is a Banach space with norm x = inf{x0 X0 + x1 X1 : x0 ∈ X0 , x1 ∈ X1 , x = x0 + x1 }. We let S denote the strip of all complex numbers z with 0 ≤ Re(z) ≤ 1 and we let F = F(X0 , X1 ) be the space of all bounded and continuous functions f : S → X0 + X1 such that the restriction of f to the interior of S is analytic, and such that the maps t → f (it) and t → f (1 + it) belong to C0 (R; X0 ) and C0 (R; X1 ) respectively. Then F is a Banach space for the norm f F = max sup f (it)X0 , sup f (1 + it)X1 . t
(1.22)
t
For any 0 ≤ θ ≤ 1, the interpolation space Xθ = [X0 , X1 ]θ is the subspace of X0 + X1 formed by all x such that x = f (θ) for some f ∈ F. This turns out to be a Banach space for the norm xXθ = inf f F : f ∈ F, f (θ) = x . If we let F θ = F θ (X0 , X1 ) be the subspace of all f ∈ F for which f (θ) = 0, we see that the mapping f → f (θ) induces an isometric isomorphism Xθ = F(X0 , X1 )/F θ (X0 , X1 ).
(1.23)
Assume now that X0 and X1 are operator spaces. Then each interpolation space Xθ has a ‘natural’ operator space structure. Indeed note from (1.22) that the mapping which takes any f ∈ F(X0 , X1 ) to the pair of its restrictions to the lines {Re(z) = 0} and {Re(z) = 1}, induces an isometric embedding F(X0 , X1 ) ⊂ C0 (R; X0 ) ⊕∞ C0 (R; X1 ). By 1.2.17 and 1.2.18, we may consider F(X0 , X1 ) as an operator space, the norm on Mn (F(X0 , X1 )) being inherited from C0 (R; Mn (X0 )) ⊕∞ C0 (R; Mn (X1 )).
16
Completely positive maps
Then taking the resulting quotient operator space structure on F/F θ and applying (1.23), makes Xθ an operator space. More explicitly, the matrix norms on the operator space Xθ are given for any [xjk ] ∈ Mn (Xθ ) by [xjk ]n = inf max sup [fjk (it)]Mn (X0 ) , sup [fjk (1 + it)]Mn (X1 ) , t
t
the infimum taken over all fjk ∈ F(X0 , X1 ) such that fjk (θ) = xjk , for all j, k. Observe that for each n ≥ 1, we have natural one-to-one continuous linear maps Mn (X0 ) → Mn (Z) and Mn (X1 ) → Mn (Z) . Hence (Mn (X0 ), Mn (X1 )) is a compatible couple of Banach spaces. It follows easily from the above discussion that Mn (F (X0 , X1 )) = F(Mn (X0 ), Mn (X1 )) isometrically, and hence (1.24) Mn (Xθ ) = Mn (X0 ), Mn (X1 ) θ . This formula readily implies that a key interpolation theorem (see [33, Theorem 4.1.2]) extends to completely bounded maps. Namely, let (Y0 , Y1 ) be another compatible couple of operator spaces, and let u : X0 + X1 → Y0 + Y1 be a linear map. If u is completely bounded as a map from X0 into Y0 , and from X1 into Y1 , then u is completely bounded from Xθ into Yθ , for any θ ∈ (0, 1), with θ u : Xθ −→ Yθ cb ≤ u : X0 −→ Y0 1−θ cb u : X1 −→ Y1 cb .
1.2.31 (Ultraproducts) Let U be an ultrafilter on a set I and let (Xi )i∈I be a family of operator spaces. We let N U ⊂ ⊕∞ i Xi be the space of all (xi )i such that limU xi Xi = 0. By definition, the ultraproduct of the family (Xi )i∈I along U is the quotient operator space Xi /U = ⊕∞ NU i Xi i∈I
from 1.2.17 and 1.2.14. It is easy to check that for any x = (xi )i in ⊕i Mn (Xi ), the norm of its class x˙ modulo Mn (N U ) is equal to x ˙ = lim xi Mn (Xi ) . U This implies the ‘injectivity’ of ultraproducts. Namely if (Yi )i∈I is another family of operator spaces such that Xi ⊂ Yi completely isometrically for each i ∈ I, then i∈I Xi /U ⊂ i∈I Yi /U completely isometrically. Finally, we observe that if (Ai )i∈I is a family of C ∗ -algebras, then N U is an ∗ ideal of ⊕∞ i Xi and hence their ultraproduct is fairly clearly a C -algebra. Note ∞ ˙ that if (ai )i and (bi )i belong to ⊕i Ai , the product a˙ b of their classes modulo N U is the class of (ai bi )i . 1.3 COMPLETELY POSITIVE MAPS 1.3.1 (Unital operator spaces) Recall that a C ∗ -algebra A is called unital if it contains an identity element 1. We say that an operator space X is unital if it
Operator spaces
17
has a distinguished element usually written as e or 1, called the identity of X, such that there exists a complete isometry u : X → A into a unital C ∗ -algebra with u(e) = 1. A unital-subspace of such X is a subspace containing e. 1.3.2 (Operator systems) An operator system is a unital-subspace S of a unital C ∗ -algebra A which is selfadjoint, that is, x∗ ∈ S if and only if x ∈ S. A subsystem of an operator system S is a selfadjoint linear subspace of S containing the ‘identity’ 1 of S. If S is an operator system, a subsystem of a C ∗ -algebra A, then S has a distinguished ‘positive cone’ S+ = {x ∈ S : x ≥ 0 in A}. We also write Ssa for the real vector space of selfadjoint elements x (i.e. those satisfying x = x∗ ) in S. Then S has an associated ordering ≤, namely we say that x ≤ y if x, y are selfadjoint and y −x ∈ S+ . By the usual trick, any element of an operator system S is of the form h + ik for h, k ∈ Ssa . Also, if h ∈ Ssa then h1 + h and h1 − h are positive. Thus Ssa = S+ − S+ . A linear map u : S → S between operator systems is called ∗-linear if u(x∗ ) = u(x)∗ for all x ∈ S. Some authors say that such a map is selfadjoint. We say that u is positive if u(S+ ) ⊂ S+ . By facts at the end of the last paragraph it is easy to see that a positive map is ∗-linear. The operator system M n (S), which is a subsystem of Mn (A), has a ‘positive cone’ too, and thus it makes sense to talk about completely positive maps between operator systems. These are the maps u such that un = IMn ⊗ u : Mn (S) → Mn (S ) is positive for all n ∈ N. Indeed the morphisms in the category of operator systems are often taken to be the unital completely positive maps. Suppose that S is a subsystem of a unital C ∗ -algebra. By the Hahn–Banach theorem and A.4.2 (resp. (A.11)), it follows that Ssa (resp. S+ ) is exactly the set of elements x ∈ S such that ϕ(x) ∈ R (resp. ϕ(x) ≥ 0) for all ϕ ∈ (Span{1, x})∗ with ϕ(1) = ϕ = 1. From this it is clear that if u : S1 → S2 is a contractive unital linear map between operator systems, then u is a positive and ∗-linear map. Applying this principle to un , we see that a completely contractive unital linear map between operator systems is completely positive. Clearly an isomorphism between operator systems which is unital and completely positive, and has completely positive inverse, preserves all the ‘order’. Such a map is called a complete order isomorphism. The range of a completely positive unital map between operator systems is clearly also an operator system; we say that such a map is a complete order injection if it is a complete order isomorphism onto its range. The following simple fact relates the norm to the matrix order, and is an elementary exercise using the definition of a positive operator. Namely, if x is an element of a unital C ∗ -algebra or operator system A, or if x ∈ B(K, H), then
1 x x∗ 1
≥ 0
⇐⇒
x ≤ 1.
Here ‘≥ 0’ means ‘positive in M2 (A)’ (or ‘positive in B(H ⊕ K)’).
(1.25)
18
Completely positive maps
1.3.3 It is easy to see from (1.25) that a completely positive unital map u between operator systems is completely contractive. (For example, to see that u is contractive, take x ≤ 1, and apply u2 to the associated positive matrix in (1.25). This is positive, so that using (1.25) again we see that u(x) ≤ 1.) Putting this together with some facts from 1.3.2 we see that a unital map between operator systems is completely positive if and only if it is completely contractive; and in this case the map is ∗-linear. If, further, u is one-to-one, then by applying the above to u and u−1 one sees immediately that a unital map between operator systems is a complete order injection if and only if it is a complete isometry. We omit the well-known proofs of the following two results. Theorem 1.3.4 (Stinespring) Let A be a unital C ∗ -algebra. A linear map u : A → B(H) is completely positive if and only if there is a Hilbert space K, a unital ∗-homomorphism π : A → B(K), and a bounded linear V : H → K such that u(a) = V ∗ π(a)V for all a ∈ A. This can be accomplished with u cb = V 2 . Also, this equals u. If u is unital then we may take V to be an isometry; in this case we may view H ⊂ K, and we have u(·) = PH π(·)|H . Theorem 1.3.5 (Arveson’s extension theorem) If S is a subsystem of a unital C ∗ -algebra A, and if u : S → B(H) is completely positive, then there exists a completely positive map u ˆ : A → B(H) extending u. Indeed, if u is unital, then 1.3.5 may be easily seen from 1.2.10 and 1.3.3 (although usually one proves 1.2.10 using the completely positive variant). Lemma 1.3.6 (Arveson) Suppose that X is a unital-subspace of an operator system, and suppose that u : X → B(K) is a unital contraction (resp. complete contraction, complete isometry) with range Y . Then there exists a positive map (resp. completely positive map, complete order isomorphism) u ˜ between the operator systems X + X and Y + Y , which extends u, namely the map x1 + x∗2 → u(x1 ) + u(x2 )∗ , for x1 , x2 ∈ X. Proof Note that the ‘contraction’ result here applied to the amplifications u n will imply the ‘complete contraction’ result; and the complete isometry case will then follow by considering u−1 . Suppose that u is a contraction, and consider u restricted to the operator subsystem X ∩ X . This is a unital contraction and therefore is positive and ∗-linear by a fact in 1.3.2. From this it is easy to check directly that the formula above for u ˜ is well defined. Suppose that x1 + x∗2 ∈ X + X is positive, and that ζ is a unit vector in K, so that ϕ = ·ζ, ζ is a state on B(K). Then ϕ ◦ u extends by the Hahn–Banach theorem to a contractive unital functional ψ on X + X . By the aforementioned fact from 1.3.2, ψ is therefore positive and ∗-linear. Thus (u(x1 ) + u(x2 )∗ )ζ, ζ = ψ(x1 ) + ψ(x2 ) = ψ(x1 + x∗2 ) ≥ 0. Hence u(x1 ) + u(x2 )∗ ≥ 0.
2
Operator spaces
19
1.3.7 (The diagonal) Because of this last result, if X is a unital operator space (see 1.3.1) then there is an essentially unique operator system, written as X +X , which is spanned by X and its adjoint space X . Indeed, if u : X → B(H) is any unital complete isometry into B(H) (or into an operator system), then by 1.3.6 the operator system u(X) + u(X) is (up to unital complete order isomorphism) independent of the particular u. We usually identify two unital operator spaces up to unital completely isometric isomorphism. By the same principle, any such X contains a canonical operator system, namely ∆(X) = {x ∈ X : u(x)∗ ∈ u(X)}, where u is any unital complete isometry as in the last paragraph. This is well defined independently of u. We call ∆(X) the diagonal of X. The following follows immediately from a fact in 1.3.2 and the last definition: Corollary 1.3.8 If S is an operator system, if Y is a unital operator space, and if u : S → Y is a unital contraction, then Ran(u) ⊂ ∆(Y ), and u is positive. Proposition 1.3.9 (A Kadison–Schwarz inequality) If u : A → B is a unital completely positive (or equivalently unital completely contractive) linear map between unital C ∗ -algebras, then u(a)∗ u(a) ≤ u(a∗ a), for all a ∈ A. Proof By 1.3.4 we have u = V ∗ π(·)V , with V ≤ 1 and π a ∗-homomorphism. 2 Thus u(a)∗ u(a) = V ∗ π(a)∗ V V ∗ π(a)V ≤ V ∗ π(a)∗ π(a)V = u(a∗ a). Corollary 1.3.10 Let u : A → B be a completely isometric unital surjection between unital C ∗ -algebras. Then u is a ∗-isomorphism. Proof By 1.3.9 applied to both u and u−1 we have u(x)∗ u(x) = x∗ x for all x ∈ A. Now use the polarization identity (see (1.1)). 2 Proposition 1.3.11 Let u : A → B be as in 1.3.9. Suppose that c ∈ A, and that c satisfies u(c)∗ u(c) = u(c∗ c). Then u(ac) = u(a)u(c) for all a ∈ A. Proof Suppose that B ⊂ B(H). We write u = V ∗ π(·)V as in Stinespring’s theorem, with V ∗ V = IH . Let P = V V ∗ be the projection onto V (H). By hypothesis V ∗ π(c)∗ P π(c)V = V ∗ π(c)∗ π(c)V . For ζ ∈ H, set η = π(c)V ζ. Then P η2 = V ∗ π(c)∗ P π(c)V ζ, ζ = η2 . Thus P η = η, and V V ∗ π(c)V = π(c)V . 2 Therefore u(a)u(c) = V ∗ π(a)V V ∗ π(c)V = V ∗ π(a)π(c)V = u(ac). 1.3.12 (Completely positive bimodule maps) An immediate consequence of 1.3.11: Suppose that u : A → B is as in 1.3.9, and that there is a C ∗ -subalgebra C of A with 1A ∈ C, such that π = u|C is a ∗-homomorphism. Then u(ac) = u(a)π(c)
and
u(ca) = π(c)u(a)
(a ∈ A, c ∈ C).
Theorem 1.3.13 (Choi and Effros) Suppose that A is a unital C ∗ -algebra, and that Φ : A → A is a unital, completely positive (or equivalently by 1.3.3, completely contractive), idempotent map. Then we may conclude: (1) R = Ran(Φ) is a C ∗ -algebra with respect to the original norm, involution, and vector space structure, but new product r1 ◦Φ r2 = Φ(r1 r2 ).
20
Completely positive maps
(2) Φ(ar) = Φ(Φ(a)r) and Φ(ra) = Φ(rΦ(a)), for r ∈ R and a ∈ A. (3) If B is the C ∗ -subalgebra of A generated by the set R, and if R is given the product ◦Φ , then Φ|B is a ∗-homomorphism from B onto R. Proof (2) By linearity and the fact that a positive map is ∗-linear (see 1.3.2), we may assume that a, r are selfadjoint. Set 0 r ∗ d = d = . r∗ a Then Φ2 (d2 ) ≥ (Φ2 (d))2 by the Kadison–Schwarz inequality 1.3.9, so that 2 r rΦ(a) Φ(r2 ) Φ(ra) ≥ . Φ(ar) ∗ Φ(a)r ∗ Here ∗ is used for a term we do not care about. Applying Φ2 gives Φ(r2 ) Φ(ra) Φ(r2 ) Φ(rΦ(a)) ≥ . Φ(ar) ∗ Φ(Φ(a)r) ∗
Thus
0 Φ(ra) − Φ(rΦ(a)) Φ(ar) − Φ(Φ(a)r) ∗
≥ 0,
which implies that Φ(ra) − Φ(rΦ(a)) = 0 and Φ(ar) − Φ(Φ(a)r) = 0. (1) By (2) we have for r1 , r2 , r3 ∈ R that (r1 ◦Φ r2 ) ◦Φ r3 = Φ(Φ(r1 r2 )r3 ) = Φ(r1 r2 r3 ). Similarly, r1 ◦Φ (r2 ◦Φ r3 ) = Φ(r1 r2 r3 ), which shows that the multiplication is associative. It is easy to check that R (with original norm, involution, and vector space structure, but new multiplication) satisfies the conditions necessary to be a C ∗ -algebra. For example: (r1 ◦Φ r2 )∗ = Φ(r1 r2 )∗ = Φ(r2∗ r1∗ ) = r2∗ ◦Φ r1∗ . We check the C ∗ -identity using the Kadison–Schwarz inequality 1.3.9: r∗ ◦Φ r = Φ(r∗ r) ≥ Φ(r)∗ Φ(r) = r∗ r = r2 , and conversely, r2 = r∗ r ≥ Φ(r∗ r) = r∗ ◦Φ r. (3) This will follow if we can prove that Φ(r1 r2 · · · rn ) = r1 ◦Φ r2 · · · ◦Φ rn , for ri ∈ R. This follows in turn by induction on n. Supposing that it is true for n = k, we see that r1 ◦Φ r2 · · · ◦Φ rk+1 equals Φ((r1 ◦Φ r2 · · · ◦Φ rk )rk+1 ) = Φ(Φ(r1 r2 · · · rk )rk+1 ) = Φ(r1 r2 · · · rk rk+1 ), using (2) in the last equality.
2
Operator spaces
21
It is important to note, and easy to check, that the canonical matrix norms from 1.2.3 for the C ∗ -algebra Φ(A) in the result above, coincide with its canonical matrix norms as a subspace of A. This may be seen by the uniqueness of a complete C ∗ -norm on a ∗-algebra (which in turn is immediate from A.5.8), and an application of Theorem 1.3.13 to the canonically associated projection Φn on Mn (A), for each n ∈ N. 1.3.14 (The Paulsen system) If X is a subspace of B(H), we define the Paulsen system to be the operator system CIH X λ x S(X) = : x, y ∈ X, λ, µ ∈ C = X CIH y∗ µ in M2 (B(H)), where the entries λ and µ in the last matrix stand for λIH and µIH respectively. The following important lemma shows that as an operator system (i.e. up to complete order isomorphism) S(X) only depends on the operator space structure of X, and not on its representation on H. Lemma 1.3.15 (Paulsen) Suppose that for i = 1, 2, we are given Hilbert spaces Hi , Ki , and linear subspaces Xi ⊂ B(Ki , Hi ). Suppose that u : X1 → X2 is a linear map. Let S i be the following operator system inside B(Hi ⊕ Ki ): CIHi Xi . Si = Xi CIKi If u is contractive (resp. completely contractive, completely isometric), then λ u(x) λ x → Θ: ∗ u(y)∗ µ y µ is positive (resp. completely positive and completely contractive, a complete order injection) as a map from S 1 to S 2 . Proof Suppose that z is a positive element of S1 . Thus a x z = x∗ b where a and b are positive. Since z ≥ 0 if and only if z + 1 ≥ 0 for all > 0, we may assume that a and b are invertible. Then −1 −1 1 1 a 2 0 a 2 0 a x 1 a− 2 xb− 2 = ≥ 0. 1 1 1 1 x∗ b 0 b− 2 0 b− 2 b− 2 x∗ a− 2 1 1
1
Hence by (1.25), we have that a− 2 xb− 2 ≤ 1. Applying u we obtain that 1 1 a− 2 u(x)b− 2 ≤ 1. Reversing the argument above now shows that Θ(z) ≥ 0. So Θ is positive, and a similar argument shows that it is completely positive if u is completely contractive. By 1.3.3 we have that Θ is completely contractive in that case. If in addition u is a complete isometry, then applying the above to u 2 and u−1 we obtain the final assertion.
22
Operator space duality
1.4 OPERATOR SPACE DUALITY An operator space Y is said to be a dual operator space if Y is completely isometrically isomorphic to the operator space dual (see 1.2.20) X ∗ of an operator space X. We also say that X is an operator space predual of Y , and sometimes we write X as Y∗ . If X, Y are dual operator spaces then we write w ∗ CB(X, Y ) for the space of w∗ -continuous completely bounded maps from X to Y . Unless otherwise indicated, in what follows the symbol X ∗ denotes the dual space together with its dual operator space structure as defined in 1.2.20. Of course X ∗∗ is considered as the dual operator space of X ∗ . Proposition 1.4.1 If X is an operator space then X ⊂ X ∗∗ completely isometrically via the canonical map iX . Proof Let X ⊂ B(H). By the definitions, iX is completely contractive. To see that iX is completely isometric, it suffices to find for a given n ∈ N, > 0, and [xkl ] ∈ Mn (X), an integer m and a completely contractive u : B(H) → Mm such that [u(xkl )] ≥ [xkl ] −. For such[xkl ] and , by (1.2) we may choose ζ1 , . . . , ζn , η1 , . . . , ηn ∈ H with l ζl 2 = k ηk 2 = 1 and xkl ζl , ηk ≥ [xkl ] − . k,l
Let K = Span {ζ1 , . . . , ζn , η1 , . . . , ηn }, and let u : B(H) → B(K) be the map u(x) = PK x|K . If m = dim(K), then we may view u as mapping into Mm . It is completely contractive, by the remark after 1.2.8 for example. Finally, [u(xkl )] ≥ u(xkl )ζl , ηk = xkl ζl , ηk ≥ [xkl ] − , k,l
k,l
2
which is the desired inequality. 1.4.2 (Remarks) From 1.4.1 we have for any [xij ] ∈ Mn (X) that [xij ]n = sup{[ϕkl (xij )] : m ∈ N, [ϕkl ] ∈ Ball(Mm (X ∗ ))}
(1.26)
In other words, the following canonical isomorphism is a complete isometry: Mn (X) ∼ = w∗ CB(X ∗ , Mn ) ⊂ CB(X ∗ , Mn ).
(1.27)
Another consequence of 1.4.1, is that if X is an operator space which as a Banach space is reflexive, then X ∼ = X ∗∗ completely isometrically. 1.4.3 (The adjoint map) The ‘adjoint’ or ‘dual’ u∗ of a completely bounded map u : X → Y between operator spaces is completely bounded from Y ∗ to X ∗ , with u∗ cb ≤ ucb, as may be seen from the obvious computation. Indeed using (1.26) during this computation or applying 1.4.1, one sees that u cb = u∗ cb . Direct computations from the definitions also show that if u is a complete quotient map then u∗ is a complete isometry. It is slightly harder to see that
Operator spaces
23
u is completely isometric if and only if u∗ is a complete quotient map. Indeed, if u is a complete isometry, then we may regard X ⊂ Y , and then an element in the open ball of Mn (X ∗ ) ∼ = CB(X, Mn ) may be ‘extended’ by 1.2.10 to an element in the open ball of CB(Y, Mn ) = Mn (Y ∗ ). This shows that u∗ is a complete quotient map. Conversely, if u∗ is a complete quotient map then u∗∗ is a complete isometry, so that u is a complete isometry (using 1.4.1). Finally, one may see as in the Banach space case, that for complete operator spaces, if u ∗ is a complete isometry then u is a complete quotient map (e.g. see A.2.3 in [149]). Thus u is a complete isometry if and only if u∗∗ is a complete isometry. 1.4.4 (Duality of subspaces and quotients) The operator space versions of the usual Banach duality of subspaces and quotients follow easily from 1.4.3. If X is a subspace of Y , then applying 1.4.3 to the inclusion map X → Y yields the fact that X ∗ ∼ = Y ∗ /X ⊥ completely isometrically via the canonical map. Similarly, the dual of the canonical quotient map Y → Y /X is the canonical complete isometry (Y /X)∗ ∼ = X ⊥ . The predual versions go through too with the same proofs as in the Banach space case: if X is a w ∗ -closed subspace of a dual operator space Y , then (Y∗ /X⊥ )∗ ∼ = (X⊥ )⊥ = X as dual operator spaces. Also, ∗ ∼ ⊥ (X⊥ ) = Y /(X⊥ ) = Y /X completely isometrically. 1.4.5 (The trace class operator space) If H is a Hilbert space then B(H) is a dual operator space. More precisely, let us equip its predual Banach space S 1 (H) (e.g. see A.1.2) with the operator space structure it inherits from B(H)∗ via the canonical isometric inclusion S 1 (H) → B(H)∗ . Then B(H) = S 1 (H)∗ completely isometrically. Indeed the canonical map from B(H) to S 1 (H)∗ is completely contractive by definition. That this map is completely isometric follows from the fact, included in the proof of 1.4.1, that for any n ∈ N, > 0, and [xkl ] ∈ Mn (B(H)), we can find an integer m and a w ∗ -continuous completely contractive u : B(H) → Mm such that [u(xkl )] ≥ [xkl ] − . Similarly, B(K, H) is the dual operator space of the space S 1 (H, K) of trace class operators, the latter regarded as a subspace of B(K, H)∗ . Henceforth, when we write S 1 (H, K) we will mean the operator space predual of B(K, H) described above. Similarly, we will henceforth also view Sn1 = Mn∗ as an operator space. Lemma 1.4.6 Any w∗ -closed subspace X of B(H) is a dual operator space. Indeed, if Y = S 1 (H)/X⊥ is equipped with its quotient operator space structure inherited from S 1 (H), then X ∼ = Y ∗ completely isometrically. Proof This follows from 1.4.4 and 1.4.5.
2
In particular this shows that any W ∗ -algebra equipped with its ‘natural’ operator space structure (see 1.2.3) is a dual operator space. The converse of 1.4.6 is true too, as we see next, so that ‘dual operator spaces’, and the w∗ -closed subspaces of some B(H), are essentially the same thing. Lemma 1.4.7 Any dual operator space is completely isometrically isomorphic, via a homeomorphism for the w ∗ -topologies, to a w∗ -closed subspace of B(H), for some Hilbert space H.
24
Operator space duality
Proof Suppose that W is a dual operator space, with predual X. Let Y = C, and recall from 1.2.19 the construction of a complete isometry W = CB(X, Y ) −→ ⊕∞ x∈I Mnx (Y ) = ⊕x∈I Mnx , namely the map J taking w ∈ W to the tuple ([w, xij ])x in ⊕x Mnx . Since ∗ the maps w → w, xij are w∗ -continuous, and since ⊕fin x Mnx is dense in the 1 ∗ Banach space predual ⊕x Mnx of ⊕x Mnx , it is easy to see that J is w∗ -continuous too. Thus by A.2.5, W is completely isometrically and w ∗ -homeomorphically isomorphic to a w∗ -closed subspace of ⊕x Mnx . If the latter is regarded as a von Neumann subalgebra of B(H) say, then W is completely isometrically and 2 w∗ -homeomorphically isomorphic to a w ∗ -closed subspace of B(H). 1.4.8 (W ∗ -continuous extensions) If X and Y are two operator spaces and if u : X → Y ∗ is completely bounded, then its (unique) w ∗ -continuous extension ucb = ucb. u ˜ : X ∗∗ → Y ∗ provided by A.2.2 is completely bounded, with ˜ Indeed recall from A.2.2 that u ˜ = i∗Y ◦ u∗∗ ; and this extension clearly satisfies the asserted norm equality (using the first paragraph in 1.4.3). Note that since w∗ u ˜ is w∗ -continuous, we have u˜(X ∗∗ ) ⊂ u(X) . The above also shows that CB(X, Y ∗ ) = w∗ CB(X ∗∗ , Y ∗ )
(1.28)
isometrically via the mapping u → u ˜. In fact (1.28) can easily be made a complete isometry with the help of the later item 1.6.2. By 1.4.5, the last paragraph applies in particular to B(K, H) valued maps. 1.4.9 (The second dual) Let X be an operator space, and fix n ∈ N. We wish to compare the spaces Mn (X ∗∗ ) (equipped with its ‘operator space dual’ matrix norms as in 1.2.20), and Mn (X)∗∗ . First note that they can be canonically identified as topological vector spaces, as may Mn (X ∗ ) and Mn (X)∗ (this is just the simple fact that if E = F ⊕ · · ·⊕ F is a finite direct sum of copies of a Banach space F , which has been assigned a norm compatible with the norm on F , then E ∗ is canonically algebraically and topologically isomorphic to F ∗ ⊕ · · · ⊕ F ∗ , the latter with any norm compatible with the norm on F ∗ ). We will prove in 1.4.11 below that this identification is an isometry. As a first easy step, let us check that the identity mapping from Mn (X)∗∗ to Mn (X ∗∗ ) implementing this identification, is a contraction. For this purpose, let η = [ηij ] ∈ Mn ⊗ X ∗∗ , and assume that its norm in Mn (X)∗∗ is less than or equal to 1. By Goldstine’s lemma A.2.1, there is a net (xs )s in Ball(Mn (X)) such that xs → η in the w∗ -topology of Mn (X)∗∗ . Let ϕ = [ϕpq ] be an element of Ball(Mm (X ∗ )) for some m ≥ 1. The fact that xs → η in the w∗ -topology of Mn (X)∗∗ , is equivalent to the fact that xsij → ηij in the w∗ -topology of X ∗∗ for all 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n. Hence we deduce that [ηij , ϕpq ] = lim [ϕpq , xsij ]. s
By (1.6) or (1.26), the norm of the latter matrix is dominated by 1. Thus [ηij , ϕpq ] ≤ 1. By (1.6) again, we deduce that [ηij ]Mn (X ∗∗ ) ≤ 1, which proves the result.
Operator spaces
25
1.4.10 (The second dual of a C ∗ -algebra) If A is a C ∗ -algebra, then the second dual A∗∗ has two canonical operator space structures. The first is its ‘operator space dual’ matrix norms (see 1.2.20); when we write Mn (A∗∗ ) in the lines below, we will be using these norms. The second are those from 1.2.3, arising from the fact that A∗∗ is a C ∗ -algebra (see A.5.6). We claim that these two operator space structures are the same. To see this we will need to use notation and facts from A.5.6. In particular we let πu : A → B(Hu ) denote the universal representation u (A∗∗ ) (see the proof of A.5.6). The of A, and we write A†† for the W ∗ -algebra π claim will follow if we can prove for any fixed n ≥ 1 that Mn (A)∗∗ ∼ = Mn (A†† ) = Mn (A∗∗ ) ∼
isometrically
(1.29)
via the canonical maps. The first of these maps is the contraction from M n (A)∗∗ to Mn (A∗∗ ) discussed in 1.4.9. The second map in (1.29) is IMn ⊗ π u , which is a contraction since according to 1.4.8, the mapping π u is a complete contraction. To establish (1.29), we need only prove that the resulting contraction ρ : Mn (A)∗∗ −→ Mn (A†† ) is isometric. It is clearly one-to-one. We regard Mn (A)∗∗ as a C ∗ -algebra by applying A.5.6 to Mn (A). It therefore suffices to (n) check that ρ is a ∗-homomorphism. Regarding ρ as valued in B(Hu ), we have (n) ρ(η) ζ, ξ = i,j πu (ηij )ζj , ξi , for ζ = [ζi ], ξ = [ξi ] ∈ Hu , and η = [ηij ] as in ∗ 1.4.9. Since π u , and the maps η → ηij , are w -continuous, it follows that ρ is w∗ -continuous too. By the w∗ -continuity properties of the involution and product in a W ∗ -algebra (see A.5.1), it suffices to prove that the restriction of ρ to Mn (A) is a ∗-homomorphism. Since the latter equals IMn ⊗ πu , we are done. The last result has many consequences. For example, we can use it to see that S ∞ (H)∗ = S 1 (H) completely isometrically, complementing the observation in 1.4.5. Also we obtain: Theorem 1.4.11 If X is an operator space then Mm,n (X)∗∗ ∼ = Mm,n (X ∗∗ ) completely isometrically for all m, n ∈ N (via an isomorphism extending the identity map on Mm,n (X)). Proof First suppose that m = n, and choose a C ∗ -algebra A with X ⊂ A completely isometrically. Then X ∗∗ ⊂ A∗∗ completely isometrically by 1.4.3, hence we have both Mn (X)∗∗ ⊂ Mn (A)∗∗ , and Mn (X ∗∗ ) ⊂ Mn (A∗∗ ), isometrically. Under the identifications between Mn (A)∗∗ and Mn (A∗∗ ) and between Mn (X)∗∗ and Mn (X ∗∗ ) discussed above, these two embeddings are easily seen to be the same. Hence the isometry Mn (A∗∗ ) = Mn (A)∗∗ provided by 1.4.10, implies that we also have Mn (X ∗∗ ) = Mn (X)∗∗ isometrically. The complete isometry follows by iterating the isometric case. The case n = m may be derived from the above, viewing Mm,n (X) as a 2 subspace of Mk (X) where k = max{m, n}. We leave this as an exercise. 1.4.12 (Duality of Min and Max) For any Banach space E, we have Min(E)∗ = Max(E ∗ )
and
Max(E)∗ = Min(E ∗ ).
(1.30)
26
Operator space duality
To see this, note that by using (1.8), (1.11) and (1.12), and the basic properties ˇ seen in A.3.1, we have of ⊗ ˇ ∗∼ Mn (Max(E)∗ ) ∼ = CB(Max(E), Mn ) = B(E, Mn ) ∼ = Mn ⊗E = Mn (Min(E ∗ )). That is, Max(E)∗ = Min(E ∗ ). Therefore Max(E ∗ )∗ = Min(E ∗∗ ). However we claim that Min(E ∗∗ ) = Min(E)∗∗ . This claim may be seen using the fact that ‘minimal operator spaces’ are completely isometric to subspaces of unital commutative C ∗ -algebras (i.e. of C(K)-spaces), the fact that the second dual of a complete isometry is a complete isometry (see 1.4.4), and 1.4.10. Hence Max(E ∗ ) and Min(E)∗ are two operator space structures on E ∗ with the same operator space dual, and therefore they are completely isometric, by 1.4.1. 1.4.13 (The 1-direct sum) For a family {Xλ : λ ∈ I} of operator spaces, let ⊕fin λ Xλ be the set of ‘finitely supported’ elements of the algebraic direct sum ∞ ∗ ∗ of the Xλ . There is a canonical one-to-one map µ : ⊕fin λ Xλ → (⊕λ Xλ ) , 1 and we may define the 1-direct sum ⊕λ Xλ by identifying it with the closure of ∞ ∗ ∗ 1 µ(⊕fin λ Xλ ) in the dual operator space (⊕λ Xλ ) . Evidently, the 1norm on ⊕λ Xλ 1 is exactly the usual ‘ -norm’ λ xλ ; and a tuple (xλ ) is in ⊕λ Xλ if and only if xλ ∈ X for all λ, and λ xλ < ∞. If Xλ = X for all λ ∈ I then we write 1I (X) for ⊕1λ X. It is easy to argue that the canonical inclusion and projection maps λ and πλ between ⊕1λ Xλ and its ‘λth summand’ are complete isometries and complete quotient maps respectively. Also, ∗ (⊕1λ Xλ )∗ ∼ = ⊕∞ λ Xλ
as dual operator spaces.
(1.31)
Similarly, the dual of an ∞-direct sum of finitely many operator spaces (or the dual of a c0 -direct sum of infinitely many) is completely isometric to the 1-direct sum of the duals. We leave these assertions to the reader to check. In particular, ∗ 1I (X)∗ = ∞ I (X )
and
c0 (X)∗ = 1 (X ∗ ).
The 1-direct sum has the following useful universal property. Namely, if Z is another operator space and uλ : Xλ → Z are completely contractive linear maps, then there is a canonical complete contraction u : ⊕1λ Xλ → Z such that u ◦ λ = uλ . One may see this with a diagram chase: u∗λ maps Z ∗ to Xλ∗ , so that by the universal property of the ∞-direct sum we obtain a map v : Z ∗ → ⊕λ Xλ∗ . Then v ∗ : (⊕λ Xλ∗ )∗ → Z ∗∗ . Composing v with the canonical map ⊕1λ Xλ → (⊕λ Xλ∗ )∗ gives a map u : ⊕1λ Xλ → Z ∗∗ . One easily checks that u ◦ λ = uλ , whence u actually maps into Z, and we obtain the desired result. This universal property may be rephrased as an isometric isomorphism CB(⊕1i Xi , Z) ∼ = ⊕∞ i CB(Xi , Z). Replacing Z by Mn (Z) and using (1.7) shows that this relation also holds completely isometrically.
Operator spaces
27
∗ The canonical inclusion and projection maps λ and πλ between ⊕∞ λ Xλ and ∗ its ‘λth summand’ are w -continuous. This may be seen by dualizing the inclusion and projection maps between ⊕1λ Xλ and its summands. Any operator space is a complete quotient of a 1-sum of spaces of the form Sn1 = Mn∗ . This may be seen, for example, by applying the second last fact in 1.4.3 to the map J in the proof of 1.4.7. Another frequently used property of these direct sums is as follows. Suppose that uλ : Xλ → Yλ is a complete contraction for each λ ∈ I. Then this family of maps clearly induces a single contraction u = (uλ ) : ⊕1λ Xλ → ⊕1λ Yλ . It ∞ also clearly induces a complete contraction (uλ ) : ⊕∞ λ Xλ → ⊕λ Yλ ; which is completely isometric if every uλ is. Applying the first fact in the last sentence to ∗ ∞ ∗ the family of maps u∗λ , gives a complete contraction from ⊕∞ λ Yλ to ⊕λ Xλ , and it is easy to see from the norm density of the ‘finitely supported’ tuples in a 1-direct sum, that this map is the dual of the map u above, and hence is w ∗ -continuous. From this and 1.4.3 we deduce that u is a complete contraction. We have also shown that families (vλ ) of w∗ -continuous complete contractions between dual spaces canonically induce a single w ∗ -continuous complete contraction between the ∞-direct sums of the spaces.
1.5 OPERATOR SPACE TENSOR PRODUCTS As we said in the introduction, the reader should feel free to skim through these results, returning later when necessary for a definition or fact. In this section and the next we tend to leave more details than in previous sections as exercises for the interested reader. 1.5.1 (Minimal tensor product) Let X and Y be operator spaces, and let X ⊗Y denote their algebraic tensor product. Any finite rank bounded map between operator spaces is ‘composed’ of scalar functionals, and hence is automatically completely bounded by 1.2.6. Thus the correspondences between tensor products and finite rank mappings discussed in A.3.1 yield embeddings X ⊗ Y → CB(Y ∗ , X) and X ⊗ Y ∗ → CB(Y, X). The minimal tensor product X ⊗min Y may then be defined to be (the completion of) X ⊗ Y in the matrix norms inherited from the operator space structure on CB(Y ∗ , X) described in 1.2.19. That is, X ⊗min Y → CB(Y ∗ , X) completely isometrically. (1.32) n That is, if u = k=1 xk ⊗ yk ∈ X ⊗ Y , then the norm of u in X ⊗min Y equals sup xk ψij (yk ) , (1.33) k
Mn (X)
the supremum taken over all finite matrices [ψij ] of norm 1, where ψij ∈ Y ∗ . A similar formula holds for u ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ). From this similar form of (1.33) and (1.26), we see that the matrix norms on X ⊗min Y are also given by the formula [wrs ]n = sup [(ϕkl ⊗ ψij )(wrs )] (1.34)
28
Operator space tensor products
for [wrs ] ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ), where the supremum is taken over all finite matrices [ϕkl ] and [ψij ] of norm 1, where ϕkl ∈ X ∗ and ψij ∈ Y ∗ , and where ϕkl ⊗ ψij denotes the obvious functional on X ⊗ Y formed from ϕkl and ψij . We see from (1.34) that ⊗min is commutative, that is X ⊗min Y = Y ⊗min X as operator spaces. It is also easy to see from (1.34) that ⊗ min is functorial. That is, if Xi and Yi are operator spaces for i = 1, 2, and if ui : Xi → Yi are completely bounded, then the map x ⊗ y → u1 (x) ⊗ u2 (y) on X1 ⊗ X2 has a unique continuous extension to a map u1 ⊗ u2 : X1 ⊗min X2 → Y1 ⊗min Y2 , with u1 ⊗ u2 cb ≤ u1 cb u2 cb . As an exercise, the reader could check that this is actually an equality, but we shall not need this. If, further, the ui are completely isometric, then so is u1 ⊗ u2 . This latter fact is called the injectivity of the tensor product. To prove it, since u1 ⊗ u2 = (u1 ⊗ I) ◦ (I ⊗ u2 ), we may by symmetry reduce the argument to the case that Y2 = X2 , u2 = IX2 , X1 ⊂ Y1 and that u1 is this inclusion map. Then the result we want follows from (1.32) and the obvious fact that CB(X2∗ , X1 ) ⊂ CB(X2∗ , Y1 ) completely isometrically. For any operator spaces X, Y , we have X ⊗min Y ∗ → CB(Y, X)
completely isometrically.
(1.35)
To prove this, note by the injectivity discussed above that we may assume that X = B(H). However, CB(Y, B(H)) = w ∗ CB(Y ∗∗ , B(H)) ⊂ CB(Y ∗∗ , B(H)) isometrically by (1.28). Since the norm on B(H) ⊗min Y ∗ is induced by the embedding of B(H) ⊗ Y ∗ in the latter space, B(H) ⊗min Y ∗ ⊂ CB(Y, B(H)) isometrically. The complete isometry follows by changing H into H (n) , and using (1.2), (1.7), and the fact that Mn (X ⊗min Y ) = Mn (X)⊗min Y for operator spaces X, Y (which in turn follows from (1.32) and (1.7)). 1.5.2 (Further properties of ⊗min ) Suppose that H1 , H2 are Hilbert spaces, and consider the canonical map π : B(H1 ) ⊗ B(H2 ) → B(H1 ⊗2 H2 ). This is the map taking a rank one tensor S⊗T in B(H1 )⊗B(H2 ) to the map on H1 ⊗2 H2 denoted also by S ⊗ T in 1.1.4. We claim that π actually is a complete isometry when B(H1 )⊗B(H2 ) is given its norm as a subspace of B(H1 )⊗min B(H2 ). To see this, we choose a cardinal I such that H2 = 2I , so that we both have MI ∼ = B(H2 ) and H1 ⊗ 2 H 2 ∼ = 2I (H1 ). By (1.35) and 1.4.5, B(H1 )⊗min B(H2 ) → CB(S 1 (H1 ), MI ). However, by 1.2.29, and (1.19), we have CB(S 1 (H1 ), MI ) ∼ = MI (B(H1 )) ∼ = B(H1 ⊗2 H2 ). This proves the claim. Thus if X and Y are subspaces of B(H1 ) and B(H2 ) respectively, then by the injectivity of this tensor product, we have that X ⊗min Y is completely isometrically isomorphic to the closure in B(H1 ⊗2 H2 ) of the span of the operators x ⊗ y on H1 ⊗2 H2 , for x ∈ X, y ∈ Y . We remark, in passing, that the above says that
Operator spaces
29
the minimal tensor product coincides with the tensor product of the same name used in C ∗ -algebra theory, or with the so-called spatial tensor product. Indeed note that if A and B are C ∗ -subalgebras of B(H1 ) and B(H2 ) respectively, then A ⊗min B may be identified with the closure of a ∗-subalgebra of B(H1 ⊗2 H2 ). Thus A ⊗min B is a C ∗ -algebra. If A and B are also commutative, then so is A ⊗min B, since it is the closure of a commutative ∗-subalgebra. From the last paragraph and 1.2.2 it is clear that for any operator space X, ∼ Mn (X) (1.36) Mn ⊗min X = completely isometrically. By similar reasoning, using also (1.19), we have KI,J ⊗min X ∼ (1.37) = KI,J (X). Indeed, in the case I = J, both sides of (1.37) correspond to the closure of (I) ), if X ⊂ B(H). Mfin I (X) in B(H Similarly, it follows from the second last paragraph, and from the fact that B((H1 ⊗2 H2 ) ⊗2 H3 ) ∼ = B(H1 ⊗2 (H2 ⊗2 H3 )), that ⊗min is associative. That is, (X1 ⊗min X2 ) ⊗min X3 = X1 ⊗min (X2 ⊗min X3 ).
(1.38)
Accordingly, this space will be merely denoted by X1 ⊗min X2 ⊗min X3 . Similarly, one may consider the N -fold minimal tensor product X1 ⊗min · · · ⊗min XN of any N -tuple of operator spaces. Proposition 1.5.3 Let E, F be Banach spaces and let X be an operator space. ˇ as Banach spaces. (1) Min(E) ⊗min X = E ⊗X ˇ ) as operator spaces. (2) Min(E) ⊗min Min(F ) = Min(E ⊗F (3) For any compact space Ω we have (with notation as in 1.2.18), C(Ω) ⊗min X = C(Ω; X)
completely isometrically.
(1.39)
∗
Proof We have isometric embeddings Min(E) ⊗min X ⊂ CB(X , Min(E)) and ˇ ⊂ B(X ∗ , E) by (1.32) and (A.1). However CB(X ∗ , Min(E)) = B(X ∗ , E) E ⊗X by (1.10), which proves (1). The isometry in (2) follows from (1). Thus the complete isometry in (2) will follow if Min(E)⊗min Min(F ) is a minimal operator space. But this is clear if we use the ‘injectivity’ of ⊗min , the fact that ‘minimal operator spaces’ are the subspaces of C(K)-spaces, and the observation in 1.5.2 that the minimal tensor product of commutative C ∗ -algebras is a commutative C ∗ -algebra, and hence is a C(K)-space. We now prove (3). Since C(Ω) is a minimal operator space, the relation C(Ω) ⊗min X = C(Ω; X) holds isometrically by (1) and (A.2). By definition (see 1.2.18), Mn (C(Ω; X)) = C(Ω; Mn (X)). Replacing X by Mn (X) in the previous relation, we deduce that C(Ω) ⊗min Mn (X) = Mn (C(Ω; X)) isometrically for all n ∈ N. However by (1.36), and also by the associativity and commutativity of ⊗min , we have ∼ C(Ω) ⊗min Mn ⊗min X = ∼ Mn C(Ω) ⊗min X . C(Ω) ⊗min Mn (X) = This shows that Mn (C(Ω) ⊗min X) = Mn (C(Ω; X)) isometrically.
2
30
Operator space tensor products
1.5.4 (Haagerup tensor product) Before we define this tensor product, we introduce an intimately related class of bilinear maps. Suppose that X, Y , and W are operator spaces, and that u : X × Y → W is a bilinear map. For n, p ∈ N, define a bilinear map Mn,p (X) × Mp,n (Y ) → Mn (W ) by (x, y) −→
p
u(xik , ykj ) ,
k=1
i,j
where x = [xij ] ∈ Mn,p (X) and y = [yij ] ∈ Mp,n (Y ). If p = n we write this map as un . If the norms of these bilinear maps (as defined in A.3.3) are uniformly bounded over p, n ∈ N, then we say that u is completely bounded, and write the supremum of these norms as ucb. It is easy to see (by adding rows and columns of zeroes to make p = n) that ucb = supn un . We say that u is completely maps of three varicontractive if ucb ≤ 1. Completely bounded multilinear ables have a similar definition (involving the expression [ k,l u(xik , ykl , zlj )]), and similarly for four or more variables. We remark that if v : X → B(H) and w : Y → B(H) are completely bounded linear maps, then it is easy to see that the bilinear map (x, y) → v(x)w(y) is completely bounded in the sense above, and has completely bounded norm dominated by vcbwcb . Indeed this boils down to the fact that B(H (n) ) is a Banach algebra. Let X, Y be operator spaces. For n ∈ N and z ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ) we define zh = inf{xy},
(1.40)
where the infimum is taken over all p ∈ N, and all ways to write z = x y, where x ∈ Mn,p (X), y ∈ Mp,n (Y ). Here x y denotes the formal matrix p product of x and y using the ⊗ sign as multiplication: namely x y = [ k=1 xik ⊗ ykj ]. We leave it as an exercise (see 9.2.1 in [149] for more details if needed) that the expressions in (1.40) for all n ∈ N, define an operator seminorm structure on X ⊗ Y in the sense of 1.2.16. Now let u : X × Y → W be a bilinear map which is completely contractive in the sense above. Let u˜ : X ⊗ Y → W be the canonically associated linear map. For z ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ), we have by the definitions above that ˜ un (z) ≤ zh ,
(1.41)
where the latter quantity is as defined in (1.40). If ϕ and ψ are contractive functionals on X and Y respectively, then using 1.2.6 and the fact at the end of the second last paragraph, we see that the bilinear map (x, y) → ϕ(x)ψ(y) is completely contractive. Thus from (1.41) and the definition of the Banach space injective tensor norm of z (see A.3.1), we deduce that the latter norm of an element z ∈ X ⊗ Y is dominated by zh. Hence indeed · h is a norm. By the fact at the end of the last paragraph, together with Ruan’s theorem, we see that the completion X ⊗h Y of X ⊗ Y with respect to · h is an operator space. This operator space is called the Haagerup tensor product. Note that the canonical bilinear map ⊗ : X × Y → X ⊗h Y is completely contractive in the sense above.
Operator spaces
31
Using (1.41) we see that if u : X × Y → W is a bilinear map with associated linear map u ˜ : X ⊗Y → W , then u is completely bounded if and only if u ˜ extends to a completely bounded linear map on X ⊗h Y . Moreover we have ˜ : X ⊗h Y −→ W cb ucb = u in that case. The above property means that the Haagerup tensor product linearizes completely bounded bilinear maps. A moments thought shows that this is a universal property. That is, suppose that (W, µ) is a pair consisting of an operator space W , and a completely contractive bilinear map µ : X × Y → W , such that the span of the range of µ is dense in W , and which possesses the following property: Given any operator space Z and given any completely bounded bilinear map u : X × Y → Z, then there exists a linear completely bounded u˜ : W → Z such that u ˜(µ(x, y)) = u(x, y) for all x ∈ X, y ∈ Y , and such that ˜ ucb ≤ ucb. W via a complete isometry v satisfying v ◦ ⊗ = µ. Then X ⊗h Y ∼ = 1.5.5 (Further properties of the Haagerup tensor product) By the definition of the Haagerup tensor product, or by its universal property, it is easy to see that this tensor product is functorial. That is, if ui : Xi → Yi are completely bounded maps between operator spaces, then u1 ⊗ u2 : X1 ⊗h X2 → Y1 ⊗h Y2 is completely bounded, and u1 ⊗ u2 cb ≤ u1 cb u2 cb . It is also easy to show that the Haagerup tensor product is associative (e.g. see [318]). That is, (X1 ⊗h X2 )⊗h X3 ∼ = X1 ⊗h (X2 ⊗h X3 ) completely isometrically. Accordingly, this space will be merely denoted by X1 ⊗h X2 ⊗h X3 . The induced norms on Mn (X1 ⊗ X2 ⊗ X3 ) may be described by the ‘3-variable’ version of (1.40). From this one may see that X1 ⊗h X2 ⊗h X3 has the universal property of ‘linearizing’ completely bounded trilinear maps (see discussion at the end of 1.5.4). Similar assertions clearly hold for the N -fold Haagerup tensor product X1 ⊗h · · · ⊗h XN of any N -tuple of operator spaces. Also, the Haagerup tensor product is injective. That is, if u1 and u2 in the last paragraph are completely isometric, then so is u1 ⊗u2 . See the Notes for directions to a selection of proofs of this fact. It is much easier to see that the Haagerup tensor product is projective, that is, if u1 and u2 in the last paragraph are complete quotient maps, then so is u1 ⊗ u2 . To see this, note that by the functoriality, the map u1 ⊗ u2 is a complete contraction. Let z ∈ Mn (Y1 ⊗ Y2 ), with zh < 1. By definition, we may write z = y1 y2 , where y1 ∈ Mn,p (Y1 ), y2 ∈ Mp,n (Y2 ) both have norm < 1. Then y1 = (u1 )n,p (x1 ) and y2 = (u2 )p,n (x2 ) for x1 ∈ Mn,p (X1 ), x2 ∈ Mp,n (X2 ), both of norm < 1. Let w = x1 x2 ∈ Mn (X1 ⊗h X2 ), this matrix has norm < 1, and (u1 ⊗ u2 )n (w) = z. By an obvious density argument, this shows that u1 ⊗ u2 above is a complete quotient map. The Haagerup tensor product is not commutative. That is, in general X ⊗ h Y and Y ⊗h X are not isometric. We shall see some examples of this later. One final property of the Haagerup tensor product: there are convenient norm expressions for ·h . Suppose that A and B are C ∗ -algebras, or spaces of the form
32
Operator space tensor products
B(K, H). If X and Y are subspaces of A and B respectively, and if z ∈ X ⊗ Y , then by the definition in 1.5.4 and (1.4) we may write p p 12 12 zh = inf ak a∗k b∗k bk k=1
(1.42)
k=1
p where the infimum is taken over all ways to write z = k=1 ak ⊗ bk in X ⊗ Y (or equivalently, by the injectivity of this tensor product, in A ⊗ B). Proposition 1.5.6 may write z as a norm sum (1) If we ∞ convergent z∞∈ X ⊗h Y with zh < 1 then ∞ ∗ ∗ a ⊗ b in X ⊗ Y , with a a < 1 and b b < 1, and k k h k k k k=1 k=1 k=1 k where the last two sums converge in norm. That is, [a1 a2 · · · ] ∈ R(X) and [b1 b2 · · · ]t ∈ C(Y ). (2) If x = [a1 a2 · · · ] ∈ R(X) and y = [b1 b2 · · · ]t ∈ C w (Y ), that is if ∞ ∞ ∗ ∗ a a converges in norm and if the partial sums of k=1 k k k=1 bk bk are uni∞ formly bounded in norm, then k=1 ak ⊗ bk converges in norm in X ⊗h Y . Similarly if x ∈ Rw (X) and y ∈ C(Y ). X ⊗ Y with z − w Proof (1) If z is as stated, choose w1 ∈ 1 h < 2 and n1 ∗ w1 h < 1. By (1.42) we may write w1 = k=1 xk ⊗ yk with k xk xk ≤ 1 and k yk∗ yk ≤ 1. Repeating this argument, we may choose w ∈ X ⊗ Y with 2 n2 − w < , and w < . By (1.42) we write w = z − w 1 2 h 2 k=n1 +1 xk ⊗ yk 22 2∗ h 2 with k xk x∗k ≤ 2 and k yk yk ≤ 2 . Continuing so, we obtain for every m ∈ N nm a finite rank tensor wm = k=n xk ⊗ yk with z − w1 − . . . − wm < 2m , m−1 +1 nm n m ∗ yk∗ yk ≤ 2m−1 . Now it is clear that k=nm−1 +1 xk xk ≤ k=n 2m−1 , and m−1 +1 ∞ ∞ ∗ ∗ the partial sums of k=1 xk xk and k=1 yk yk converge in norm to elements ∞ with norm close to 1, and that z = k=1 xk ⊗ yk as desired. a ⊗ b are Cauchy, note that from (2) To see that the partial sums of ∞ mk=1 k ∗ 1 k m ∗ m 1 2 2 (1.42) we have k=n ak ⊗ b k h ≤ k=n ak ak k=n bk bk . Now use the ∞ 2 fact that the partial sums of k=1 ak a∗k are Cauchy.
The following important result is due to Christensen and Sinclair, and Paulsen and Smith. We will refer to it as the ‘CSPS theorem’. See the Notes section for references, and directions to a sample of the available proofs. Note that the second part of this result follows from the first part and 1.2.8. Theorem 1.5.7 (CSPS theorem) Suppose that X and Y are operator spaces, and that u : X × Y → B(K, H) is a bilinear map. (1) u is completely contractive (as a bilinear map) if and only if there is a Hilbert space L, and there are completely contractive linear maps v : X → B(L, H) and w : Y → B(K, L), with u(x, y) = v(x)w(y) for all x ∈ X and y ∈ Y . (2) If X and Y are subspaces of unital C ∗ -algebras A and B respectively, and if the conditions in (1) hold, then there exist Hilbert spaces K 1 and K2 , unital
Operator spaces
33
∗-representations π : A → B(K1 ) and ρ : B → B(K2 ), and contractions T ∈ B(K, K2 ), S ∈ B(K2 , K1 ) and R ∈ B(K1 , H), such that u(x, y) = Rπ(x)Sρ(y)T,
x ∈ X, y ∈ Y.
1.5.8 (Remarks on the CSPS theorem) An analoguous result to (1) holds for multilinear completely bounded maps of three or more variables, and can be proved using 1.5.7 and the discussion on associativity in 1.5.5. Thus if X1 , . . . , XN are operator spaces and if vj : Xj → B(Hj , Hj−1 ) are completely contractive linear maps then the N -linear mapping taking (x1 , . . . , xN ) ∈ X1 × · · · × XN to v1 (x1 ) · · · vN (xN ) ∈ B(HN , H0 ) is completely contractive. Conversely, any completely contractive N -linear map has this form. Likewise, (2) has analoguous formulations for multilinear maps. For example, let u : X × Y × Z → B(K, H) be any completely contractive trilinear map, and assume that X and Z are subspaces of unital C ∗ -algebras A and B respectively. Then u has a factorization of the form u(x, y, z) = Rπ(x)Ψ(y)ρ(z)T , where π : A → B(K1 ) and ρ : B → B(K2 ) are unital ∗-representations, Ψ is a complete contraction from Y to B(K2 , K1 ), and R, T are contractions. If u : X × Y → B(K, H) is a completely contractive bilinear map, then the Hilbert space L in (1) may be replaced by the possibly smaller space which is densely spanned by v(X)∗ (H) and w(Y )(K). In particular L may be chosen to be finite-dimensional if X, Y, K, H are all finite-dimensional. As a final remark, we stress the case of completely bounded bilinear forms. If we have a completely contractive u : X × Y → C, the CSPS theorem ensures that u may be written as u(x, y) = w(y), v(x)H , where H is a Hilbert space and v : X → H r and w : Y → H c are completely contractive maps. 1.5.9 (Self-duality of ⊗h ) Let X and Y be operator spaces. Then X ∗ ⊗h Y ∗ → (X ⊗h Y )∗
completely isometrically
(1.43)
via the canonical map. Indeed, first assume that X and Y are finite-dimensional. We let J be the canonical map from X ∗ ⊗h Y ∗ into (X ⊗h Y )∗ , which is a surjection in our finite-dimensional case. By (1.8), it suffices to show that Jn is an isometric isomorphism from Mn (X ∗ ⊗h Y ∗ ) to CB(X ⊗h Y, Mn ), for any n ≥ 1. We consider z ∈ Mn (X ∗ ⊗h Y ∗ ) and we let u = Jn (z). By 1.5.7 (1) and the third paragraph in 1.5.8, there exist an integer p ≥ 1 and two linear maps v : X → Mn,p and w : Y → Mp,n such that vcbwcb ≤ ucb and u(x ⊗ y) = v(x)w(y) for any x ∈ X and y ∈ Y . We let ϕ = [ϕij ] ∈ Mn,p (X ∗ ) and ψ = [ψij ] ∈ Mp,n (Y ∗ ) be the two matrices corresponding to v and w respectively. Then ϕik (x)ψkj (y) , x ∈ X, y ∈ Y. u(x ⊗ y) = v(x)w(y) = [ϕij (x)][ψij (y)] = k
Thus z = ϕ ψ, and hence zh ≤ ϕψ = vcb wcb ≤ ucb. The converse inequality ucb ≤ zh may be obtained by reversing the arguments.
34
Operator space tensor products
In the general case, fix [uij ] ∈ Mn (X ∗ ⊗ Y ∗ ). Write each uij ∈ X ∗ ⊗ Y ∗ in m the form k=1 ϕk ⊗ ψk , for functionals ϕk ∈ X ∗ , ψk ∈ Y ∗ . Let W (resp. Z) be the span of all these (finite number of) functionals in X ∗ (resp. Y ∗ ), over all i and j too. We may view [uij ] in Mn (W ⊗h Z), and by the injectivity of ⊗h (see 1.5.5), its norm in the latter space equals its norm in Mn (X ∗ ⊗h Y ∗ ). By the last paragraph, and by 1.4.4, its norm also equals the norm of the associated element in Mn (((X/W⊥ ) ⊗h (Y /Z⊥ ))∗ ). However, by the projectivity of ⊗h (see 1.5.5), and 1.4.3, we may view ((X/W⊥ ) ⊗h (Y /Z⊥ ))∗ ⊂ (X ⊗h Y )∗ completely isometrically. The composition of these identifications is easily seen to take [u ij ] to the desired matrix in Mn ((X ⊗h Y )∗ ), and so we are done. 1.5.10 (Some relations to Banach space tensor products) The Haagerup tensor product of minimal and maximal operator spaces corresponds to well-known Banach space tensor products (see A.3.5 for a review). Let E, F be Banach ˇ spaces. Then for any m ≥ 1, we have isometric identities Rm (Min(E)) = 2m ⊗E 2 ˇ and Cm (Min(F )) = m ⊗F , as may be seen from (1.11). Then it is immediate from (1.40) and (A.5) that Min(E) ⊗h Min(F ) = E ⊗γ2 F
isometrically.
(1.44)
If G is an arbitrary Banach space and H is a Hilbert space then CB(Min(G), H r ) = Π2 (G, H)
isometrically,
(1.45)
where the latter denotes the Banach space of 2-summing maps from G into H (see A.3.4). To prove this consider u : G → H and assume that u is 2-summing. ˇ → 2n (H) has norm less than or According to A.3.4, the mapping I2n ⊗ u : 2n ⊗G equal to π2 (u) for any n ≥ 1. Hence I2 ⊗ I2 ⊗ u : 2n ⊗ ˇ 2n ⊗G ˇ −→ 2n ⊗ ˇ 2n (H) ≤ π2 (u). n
n
Using (1.2) and (A.1), we have isometric identities ¯ C)) ∼ ¯ 2n ) ∼ ˇ 2n (H). Mn (H r ) ∼ = Mn (B(H, = B(2n (H), = 2n ⊗ ∼ Mn by (A.1) again, so 2 ⊗ ˇ 2n = ˇ 2n ⊗G ˇ = Mn (Min(G)) On the other hand, 2n ⊗ n by (1.11). Thus the second last centered equation exactly means that the map un from Mn (Min(G)) to Mn (H r ) has norm ≤ π2 (u). Thus ucb ≤ π2 (u). The converse inequality is easily obtained by reversing the arguments. Suppose that x in Rm (Max(E)), viewed as an element of Rm (Max(E)∗∗ ) ∼ = CB(Max(E)∗ , Rm ) = CB(Min(E ∗ ), Rm ), the last isomorphisms using 1.2.29 and (1.30). Applying (1.45) with G = E ∗ we see that if w : E ∗ → 2m is the linear mapping corresponding to x, then x is equal to π2 (w). Therefore the argument before (1.44), and (A.6), show that Max(E) ⊗h Min(F ) = E ⊗g2 F
isometrically.
(1.46)
isometrically.
(1.47)
Likewise by (A.7) we have Max(E) ⊗h Max(F ) = E ⊗γ2∗ F
Operator spaces
35
1.5.11 (Operator space projective tensor product) As with the Haagerup tensor product, it is convenient to first define an intimately related class of bilinear maps. Suppose that X, Y , and W are operator spaces and that u : X × Y → W is a bilinear map. We say that u is jointly completely bounded if there exists a constant K ≥ 0 such that [u(xij , ykl )](i,k),(j,l) ≤ K[xij ][ykl ] for all m, n and [xij ] ∈ Mn (X), and [ykl ] ∈ Mm (Y ). The least such K is written as ujcb. We say that u is jointly completely contractive if ujcb ≤ 1. Jointly completely bounded multilinear maps of three or more variables are defined similarly. We also observe that any completely contractive (in the sense of 1.5.4) bilinear map u is jointly completely contractive. This is immediate from the simple relation [u(xij , ykl )] = unm ([xij ] ⊗ Im , In ⊗ [ykl ]). Let X, Y be operator spaces, and let n ∈ N. For z ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ) define z = inf{αxyβ},
(1.48)
the infimum taken over p, q ∈ N, and all ways to write z = α(x ⊗ y)β, where α ∈ Mn,pq , x ∈ Mp (X), y ∈ Mq (Y ), and β ∈ Mpq,n . Here we wrote x ⊗ y for the ‘tensor product of matrices’, namely x ⊗ y = [xij ⊗ ykl ](i,k),(j,l) . We omit the easy proof (see [149] if necessary) that this defines an operator seminorm structure on X ⊗ Y . For z ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ), and for any jointly completely contractive bilinear map u : X × Y → W , it is easy to see from the definitions that ˜ un (z) ≤ z ,
(1.49)
where u ˜ : X ⊗ Y → W is the associated linear map. From the observation at the end of the last paragraph, it follows that this is also true if u is completely contractive. Taking u = ⊗ : X × Y → X ⊗h Y , we deduce that · h ≤ · . Thus the quantities in (1.48) are norms. By Ruan’s theorem the completion of X ⊗ Y with respect to these matrix norms is an operator space, which we call the operator space projective tensor product, and write as X ⊗ Y . By (1.48) and (1.49) we see that if u : X × Y → W is a bilinear map with associated linear map u˜ : X ⊗ Y → W , then u is jointly completely bounded if and only if u˜ extends to a completely bounded linear map on X ⊗ Y . Moreover, ˜ : X ⊗ Y −→ W cb ujcb = u in that case. The above property means that the operator space projective tensor product linearizes jointly completely bounded bilinear maps. As for the Haagerup tensor product this is a universal property, and characterizes X ⊗ Y uniquely up to complete isometry. From this it is easy to argue that
CB(X ⊗ Y, Z) ∼ = CB(X, CB(Y, Z)) ∼ = CB(Y, CB(X, Z))
(1.50)
36
Operator space tensor products
isometrically, and indeed (by replacing Z by Mn (Z)) completely isometrically. In particular,
(X ⊗ Y )∗ ∼ = CB(X, Y ∗ ) ∼ = CB(Y, X ∗ )
completely isometrically.
(1.51)
We now list a sequence of properties of the operator space projective tensor product. Again it is very easy to see, copying the idea of the analoguous proofs in 1.5.5, that ⊗ is functorial, and projective. It is also an easy exercise to see that ⊗ is associative, and (1.51) shows that ⊗ is commutative. We use these words in the sense that we have used them for the other two tensor products. From the universal properties of ⊗ and ⊕1i (see above and 1.4.13), it is easy to check that
Y ⊗ (⊕1i Xi ) ∼ = ⊕1i (Y ⊗ Xi ),
(1.52)
for operator spaces Y and {Xi }. Proposition 1.5.12 Let E, F be Banach spaces and let Y be an operator space.
ˆ as Banach spaces. (1) Max(E) ⊗ Y = E ⊗Y ˆ ) = Max(E) ⊗ Max(F ) as operator spaces. (2) Max(E ⊗F Proof The first item follows by computing the duals of these two tensor products, using (1.51), (1.12), and (A.4). Then (2) follows from (1) if we can show that Max(E) ⊗ Max(F ) is a maximal operator space. To do this, observe that
ˆ W ) = B(E, B(F, W )), B(Max(E) ⊗ Max(F ), W ) = B(E ⊗F, for any operator space W , by (1) and (A.3). The latter space equals
CB(Max(E), CB(Max(F ), W )) = CB(Max(E) ⊗ Max(F ), W )
by (1.12) and (1.50). Thus Max(E) ⊗ Max(F ) is ‘maximal’.
2
Proposition 1.5.13 (Comparison of tensor norms) If X and Y are operator spaces then the various tensor norms on X ⊗ Y are ordered as follows: · ∨ ≤ · min ≤ · h ≤ · ≤ · ∧ .
Indeed the ‘identity’ is a complete contraction X ⊗ Y → X ⊗h Y → X ⊗min Y . ˇ (see Proof The first inequality follows from (1.34) and the definition of ⊗ ˆ A.3.1). The fact that · ≤ · ∧ follows from the universal property of ⊗ (see A.3.3), since the bilinear map ⊗ : X × Y → X ⊗ Y is jointly completely contractive, and hence contractive. We saw in 1.5.11 the complete contraction X ⊗ Y → X ⊗h Y . For the remaining relation we may assume by the injectivity of these tensor norms that X and Y are unital C ∗ -algebras, and then X ⊗min Y
Operator spaces
37
is a C ∗ -algebra as observed in 1.5.2. We may write x ⊗ y = (x ⊗ 1)(1 ⊗ y), which may be viewed as the product π(x)ρ(y) of two (completely contractive) ∗-homomorphisms. Thus the bilinear map ⊗ : X × Y → X ⊗min Y is completely contractive, which by (1.41) proves the desired relation. 2 Proposition 1.5.14 If X, Y are operator spaces, if H, K are Hilbert spaces, and if m, n ∈ N, then we have the following complete isometries:
(1) H r ⊗h X = H r ⊗ X, and X ⊗h H c = X ⊗ H c . (2) H c ⊗h X = H c ⊗min X, and X ⊗h H r = X ⊗min H r . (3) Cn (X) ∼ = Cn ⊗h X = Cn ⊗min X, and Rn (X) ∼ = X ⊗h Rn = X ⊗min Rn . ¯ r ⊗h X ⊗h K c )∗ ∼ ¯ r ⊗ X ⊗ K c )∗ = (H (4) (H = CB(X, B(K, H)). ∞ c ∼ ¯ r and S ∞ (K, H) ⊗min X ∼ ¯ r. (5) S (K, H) = H ⊗min K = H c ⊗h X ⊗h K ∼ Cm ⊗h X ⊗h Rn . (6) Mm,n (X) = (7) Mm,n (X ⊗h Y ) ∼ = Cm (X) ⊗h Rn (Y ).
(8) H c ⊗ K c = H c ⊗h K c = H c ⊗min K c = (H ⊗2 K)c , and similarly for row Hilbert spaces. ¯ r ⊗ H c. (9) S 1 (K, H) ∼ =K (10) CB(S 1 (2I , 2J ), X) ∼ = MI,J (X), if I, J are cardinals.
Proof To prove that X ⊗h H c = X ⊗ H c completely isometrically, it suffices by Proposition 1.5.13 to show that I : X ⊗h H c → X ⊗ H c is completely contractive. This will follow if we can show that any jointly completely contractive map u : X × H c → B(L) is completely contractive (in the sense of 1.5.4). Assume that H = 2J for some cardinal J. Let v : X → RJw (B(L)) = B(L(J) , L) be the linear map defined by v(x) = (u(x, ei ))i∈J for any x ∈ X. Then v corresponds to u via the identifications
CB(X ⊗ CJ , B(L)) = CB(X, CB(CJ , B(L))) = CB(X, RJw (B(L))) provided by (1.50) and Proposition 1.2.28. Thus vcb = ujcb. Then we define a map w : CJ → CJ (B(L)) ⊂ B(L, L(J) ) by w(ζ) = (ζj IL ) for ζ = (ζj ) ∈ 2J . It is clear that wcb = 1 and moreover we have a factorization u(x, ζ) = v(x)w(ζ) for any x ∈ X, ζ ∈ H = 2J . By the easy part of the CSPS theorem 1.5.7, we deduce the desired inequality ucb ≤ ujcb. The first part of (1) is similar. To prove (2), we may assume by injectivity of ⊗min and ⊗h that H and X are finite-dimensional. In that case the result follows from (1) by duality, using (1.15), 1.5.9, (1.51), and (1.32). Item (3) follows from (2) and (1.37). The first equality in (4) is clear from (1), and the rest is clear from the string
¯ r ⊗ X ⊗ K c )∗ ∼ (H = CB(X, CB(K c , H c )), = CB(X ⊗ K c , H c ) ∼ which equals CB(X, B(K, H)). Here we have used (1.51), (1.50), (1.15), and (1.14). The first equality in (5) is clear from (1.32), (1.15), and (1.14). Then
38
Duality and tensor products
¯ r by commutativity of ⊗min , and so S ∞ (K, H) ⊗min X = H c ⊗min X ⊗min K the second part of (5) follows from (2). Item (6) is a special case of (5), and (7) follows from (6) by (3) and the associativity of the Haagerup tensor product. The middle equality in (8) follows from (2), and the first equality from (1). Writing ¯ r = RI for cardinals I, J, the last equality in (8) may be seen H c = CJ and K from (1.37) and (1.18). Clearly (9) follows from (4) with X = C. Lastly, for (10), CB(S 1 (2I , 2J ), X) is completely isometric to
CB(RI ⊗ CJ , X) ∼ = CB(CJ , CB(RI , X)) ∼ = RJw (CIw (X)) ∼ = MI,J (X), 2
using (9), (1.50), 1.2.28, and (1.20). 1.6 DUALITY AND TENSOR PRODUCTS This material is usually only used in the final section of later chapters.
1.6.1 (Mapping spaces as duals) If Y is a dual operator space then so is CB(X, Y ), for any operator space X. Indeed by (1.51) an explicit predual for CB(X, Y ) is X ⊗ Y∗ . From this, together with the density of the finite rank tensors in X ⊗ Y∗ , it follows that a bounded net (ut )t in CB(X, Y ) converges in the w∗ -topology to a u ∈ CB(X, Y ) if and only if ut (x) converges in the w∗ -topology to u(x) in Y for all x ∈ X. In particular, setting Y = B(K, H) for Hilbert spaces H, K, and using the same principle again, we see that the above equivalent conditions are also equivalent to ut (x)ζ, η → u(x)ζ, η
for all x ∈ X, ζ ∈ K, η ∈ H.
(1.53)
1.6.2 (Dual matrix spaces) If X is a dual operator space then so is Mn (X). Indeed by (1.51) and (1.8) we have
(Sn1 ⊗ X∗ )∗ ∼ = Mn (X). = CB(X∗ , Mn ) ∼ More generally the same proof, but substituting 1.2.29 for (1.8), shows that for cardinals I, J, MI,J (X) is a dual operator space with operator space predual S 1 (2I , 2J ) ⊗ X∗ , and also MI,J (X) ∼ = CB(X∗ , MI,J ). If I, J are sets, and if I0 and J0 are finite subsets of I and J respectively, write ∆ = I0 × J0 . The set Λ of such ∆ is a directed set under the usual ordering. For such ∆, and for x ∈ MI,J (X), we write x∆ for the matrix x, but with entries xij switched to zero if (i, j) ∈ / ∆. Then (x∆ )∆ is a net indexed by ∆ ∈ Λ, which we call the net of finite submatrices of x. Corollary 1.6.3 (Effros and Ruan) Let X be a dual operator space, and let I, J be cardinals. (1) If (xt )t is a bounded net in MI,J (X), then xt → x ∈ MI,J (X) in the w∗ topology in MI,J (X), if and only if each entry in xt converges in the w∗ topology in X to the corresponding entry in x.
Operator spaces
39
(2) If Y is a dual operator space, and if u : X → Y is a w ∗ -continuous completely bounded map, then the amplification uI,J : MI,J (X) → MI,J (Y ) is w∗ -continuous. If, further, u is completely isometric, then uI,J is a w∗ homeomorphic complete isometry onto a w ∗ -closed subspace. ∗ (3) Mfin I,J (X) is w -dense in MI,J (X). Indeed if I, J are sets, and x ∈ MI,J (X), then the net of finite submatrices of x converges to x in the w ∗ -topology. Proof Using the fact that MI,J (X) = CB(X∗ , MI,J ) = CB(X∗ , B(2J , 2I )) (see 1.6.2), (1) follows from (1.53), and the density of Span{ei } in 2I and 2J . Items (2) and (3) follow immediately from (1) and A.2.5. 2 Note from 1.6.3 that for a w ∗ -closed subspace X ⊂ B(K, H), one may define (J) MI,J (X) to be the w∗ -closure of Mfin , H (I) ). I,J (X) in MI,J (B(K, H)) = B(K 1.6.4 (A characterization of dual operator spaces) An operator space X which is a dual Banach space, is a dual operator space if and only if Mn (X) is a dual Banach space, and the n2 canonical inclusion maps from X into Mn (X) are w∗ continuous, for all n ≥ 2. This follows immediately from the following criterion (which is the one which will be used in the sequel). If X is the dual Banach space of W , and if W is equipped with its natural matrix norms as a subspace of X ∗ via the natural inclusion, then X is the dual operator space of W if and only if the unit ball of Mn (X) is σ(X, W )-closed for every positive integer n. That is, if and only if whenever (xt )t is a net in Ball(Mn (X)), x ∈ Mn (X), and the i-j entry of xt converges in the σ(X, W ) topology to the i-j entry of x for all i, j = 1, . . . , n, then x ∈ Ball(Mn (X)). The ‘only if’ in the last criterion follows from 1.6.2 and 1.6.3 (1). For the other direction, assume that the unit ball of Mn (X) is σ(X, W )-closed for every n ≥ 1. By 1.5.14 (6) and the selfduality of the Haagerup tensor product (see 1.5.9), we have Mn (X)∗ = Rn ⊗h X ∗ ⊗h Cn . Since ⊗h is injective we deduce that Rn ⊗h W ⊗h Cn ⊂ Mn (X)∗ isometrically. Hence it is easy to argue that the image of Ball(Mn (X)) inside (Rn ⊗h W ⊗h Cn )∗ has polar set in Rn ⊗h W ⊗h Cn equal to the unit ball of Rn ⊗h W ⊗h Cn . Also, this image is w∗ -closed by hypothesis. Therefore by the bipolar theorem, Ball(Mn (X)) is equal to the unit ball of (Rn ⊗h W ⊗h Cn )∗ . By 1.5.14 (4) and (1.8), the latter space is isometrically equal to CB(W, Mn ) = Mn (W ∗ ). Hence Ball(Mn (X)) = Ball(Mn (W ∗ )). Since this holds for any n ≥ 1, this shows that X ∗ = W completely isometrically. 1.6.5 (Normal spatial tensor product) If X and Y are dual operator spaces, with operator space preduals X∗ and Y∗ , then CB(Y∗ , X) is the dual operator space of X∗ ⊗ Y∗ by 1.6.1. As in (1.35), we regard X ⊗min Y → CB(Y∗ , X), and we define the normal minimal tensor product X ⊗ Y to be the w ∗ -closure of X ⊗Y (or of X ⊗min Y ) in CB(Y∗ , X). Equivalently, if X and Y are w∗ -closed subspaces of B(H) and B(K) respectively, then we may define X ⊗ Y to be the w ∗ -closure in B(H ⊗2 K) of the copy of X ⊗ Y . This is sometimes referred to as the normal spatial tensor product. If M and N are W ∗ -algebras, then M ⊗ N as described above is the usual von Neumann algebra tensor product (e.g. see [407, IV; 5])
40
Duality and tensor products
and in particular, B(H) ⊗ B(K) = B(H ⊗2 K). To see that these two definitions of X ⊗ Y are the same (up to w∗ -homeomorphic complete isometry), we use the following argument. Since X and Y are w ∗ -closed subspaces of B(H) and B(K) respectively, we know by 1.4.6 that X∗ and Y∗ are quotients of S 1 (H) and S 1 (K) respectively. By the ‘projectivity’ property of ⊗, we obtain a complete quotient map Q : S 1 (H) ⊗ S 1 (K) → X∗ ⊗ Y∗ . Using the identification (1.51) we see that Q∗ may be viewed as a w∗ -continuous completely isometric embedding CB(Y∗ , X) → CB(S 1 (K), B(H)) ∼ = B(H ⊗2 K), the last relation from the first paragraph of 1.5.2. Via the canonical identification of X ⊗ Y with a subset of CB(Y∗ , X), we see that the w∗ -closure of X ⊗ Y in B(H ⊗2 K) may be identified with the w∗ -closure of X ⊗ Y in CB(Y∗ , X). In general, CB(Y∗ , X) (or equivalently, (X∗ ⊗ Y∗ )∗ ) is not equal to X ⊗ Y . However they are equal when X and Y are W ∗ -algebras, as was shown by Effros and Ruan (see the Notes section for a few more details). This is also the case when X = B(H). Indeed, for any dual operator space Y and cardinals I, J, MI,J ⊗ Y ∼ = MI,J (Y )
(1.54)
as dual operator spaces. This follows by the remark after 1.6.3, and an argument similar to the one used for (1.37). Also, MI,J (Y ) ∼ = CB(Y∗ , MI,J ) by 1.2.29. Setting H = 2I gives B(H) ⊗ Y ∼ = CB(Y∗ , B(H)). We leave it as an exercise that the normal spatial tensor product is ‘associative’, and ‘functorial’ for w∗ -continuous completely bounded maps. 1.6.6 (Operator valued measurable functions) Let (Ω, µ) be a measure space (σ-finite for specificity), and let Y be a dual operator space. Since L∞ (Ω) is a commutative W ∗ -algebra, ucb = u for any L∞ (Ω)-valued bounded map (see 1.2.6). Using natural conditional expectations, there is a net vλ of finite rank contractive maps on L∞ (Ω) such that vλ converges to IL∞ point-w∗ . If u ∈ B(Y∗ , L∞ (Ω)) then (vλ u)λ is a net of finite rank operators Y∗ → L∞ (Ω) converging point-w∗ to u. Since this net is bounded, this implies that vλ u → u in the w∗ -topology of CB(Y∗ , L∞ (Ω)) by 1.6.1. Each vλ u is finite rank and so ‘belongs’ to Y ⊗ L∞ (Ω). This together with the first few lines of 1.6.5 shows that B(Y∗ , L∞ (Ω)) = CB(Y∗ , L∞ (Ω)) ∼ = L∞ (Ω) ⊗ Y.
(1.55)
Assume that Y∗ is separable. Then the latter operator space has an interesting description in terms of Y -valued functions defined on Ω. We say that a function f : Ω → Y is w∗ -measurable if f (· ), ϕ : Ω → C is measurable for any ϕ ∈ Y∗ . Using the separability assumption it is easy to see that for such an f , the scalarvalued function f (· )Y is measurable. We set f ∞ = f (· )Y L∞ (Ω) and we say that f is essentially bounded if f ∞ < ∞. Then f ∞ is a seminorm on the space of such functions and we let L∞ (Ω; Y ) be the normed space obtained after
Operator spaces
41
taking the quotient by N0 = {f : f ∞ = 0}. As in the scalar-valued case, we identify any w∗ -measurable essentially bounded function f with its class modulo N0 . Using again the separability of Y∗ , we see that for any f ∈ L∞ (Ω; Y ), f ∞ = sup f (· ), ϕL∞ : ϕ ∈ Ball(Y∗ ) . Thus we may define a bounded map Jf : Y∗ → L∞ (Ω), by Jf (ϕ) = f (· ), ϕ, and we have Jf = f ∞ . It turns out that the resulting isometric embedding ˆ ∗ )∗ is onto. This is proved e.g. in [380, L∞ (Ω; Y ) → B(Y∗ , L∞ (Ω)) ∼ = (L1 (Ω)⊗Y Theorem 1.22.13] when Y is a von Neumann algebra and the proof given there extends to the general case. (See also Proposition IV.7.16 and its proof in [407].) The resulting identity B(Y∗ , L∞ (Ω)) ∼ = L∞ (Ω; Y ) shows that the latter space is complete and by (1.55), we obtain an isometric identification L∞ (Ω) ⊗ Y = L∞ (Ω; Y ). By the reasoning in 1.5.3 (3), this identity is a complete isometry if L ∞ (Ω; Y ) has matrix norms obtained by equating Mn (L∞ (Ω; Y )) and L∞ (Ω; Mn (Y )). Thus L∞ (Ω; Y ) is a dual operator space. If jY : L∞ (Ω) ⊗ Y → L∞ (Ω; Y ) is the w∗ continuous mapping providing this identification, and if we consider finite families (fk )k in L∞ (Ω) and (yk )k in Y , then jY maps k fk ⊗ yk to k fk (·)yk . 1.6.7 (W ∗ -continuous extensions: the bilinear case) Let X, Y be operator spaces, let W be a dual operator space, and let u : X × Y → W be a completely bounded bilinear map. Then u admits a (necessarily unique) separately w ∗ continuous extension u˜ : X ∗∗ × Y ∗∗ → W , this extension is completely bounded, and ˜ ucb = ucb. To prove this, we may assume by Lemma 1.4.7 that W is a w∗ -closed subspace of some B(H). By the CSPS theorem (1.5.7), we find a Hilbert space L and two completely bounded maps v : X → B(L, H) and w : Y → B(H, L) such that u(x, y) = v(x)w(y) for all x ∈ X, y ∈ Y . According to 1.4.8, v and w admit w ∗ -continuous extensions v˜ : X ∗∗ → B(L, H) and w ˜ : Y ∗∗ → B(H, L) with ˜ v cb = vcb and w ˜ cb = wcb . Define a ˜(η, ν) = v˜(η)w(ν) ˜ for any bilinear map u ˜ : X ∗∗ × Y ∗∗ → B(H) by letting u η ∈ X ∗∗ , ν ∈ Y ∗∗ . Then the easy part of the CSPS theorem ensures that u˜ is completely bounded with ˜ ucb ≤ ˜ v cb w ˜ cb = vcb wcb ≤ ucb. Since u is ˜ is valued in W as well. valued in W , and W is w∗ -closed, its extension u 1.6.8 (Normal Haagerup tensor product) If X and Y are two dual operator spaces, we let (X ⊗h Y )∗σ denote the subspace of (X ⊗h Y )∗ corresponding to the completely bounded bilinear forms X × Y → C which are separately w ∗ continuous. Then we define the normal Haagerup tensor product X ⊗ σh Y to be the operator space dual of (X ⊗h Y )∗σ . From 1.6.7 one may deduce the following two consequences. First, if X, Y are two (not necessarily dual) operator spaces then (X ⊗h Y )∗ ∼ = (X ∗∗ ⊗h Y ∗∗ )∗σ . To see this, consider the map u → u ˜ in 1.6.7, in the case that W = Mn . Note that
42
Duality and tensor products
a map u into Mn is separately w∗ -continuous if and only if each ‘entry’ uij is separately w∗ -continuous. It follows that (X ⊗h Y )∗∗ = X ∗∗ ⊗σh Y ∗∗
as dual operator spaces.
(1.56)
Second, if X, Y are two dual operator spaces, then the natural action of X ⊗ Y on (X ⊗h Y )∗σ yields a completely isometric embedding X ⊗h Y ⊂ X ⊗σh Y.
(1.57)
To see (1.57), let j : X ⊗ Y → X ⊗σh Y be the canonical mapping, and fix z in X ⊗ Y . It is clear from the definitions that j(z) ≤ zh. The converse inequality relies on the selfduality of the Haagerup tensor product. We let > 0. By (1.43), we have X ⊗h Y ⊂ (X∗ ⊗h Y∗ )∗ isometrically. Hence there exists a map Φ ∈ X∗ ⊗ Y∗ such that Φh = 1 and zh ≤ |z, Φ| + . Writing Φ as ∈ X∗ and ψk ∈ Y∗ , then the bilinear form u : X ×Y → C k ϕk ⊗ψk for some ϕk ∗ defined by u(x, y) = k ϕk (x)ψk (y) is clearly separately w -continuous and we have z, Φ = j(z), u. Hence |z, Φ| ≤ j(z)ucb. By (1.43) again, and the injectivity of ⊗h , we have X∗ ⊗h Y∗ ⊂ X ∗ ⊗h Y ∗ ⊂ (X ⊗h Y )∗ , so that ucb = Φh = 1. Since was arbitrary, this shows that zh ≤ j(z). Hence j is an isometry, and a similar argument shows that it is a complete isometry. Indeed, X ⊗ Y is w∗ -dense in X ⊗σh Y . Let q : (X ⊗h Y )∗∗ → X ⊗σh Y be the adjoint mapping of the embedding (X ⊗h Y )∗σ ⊂ (X ⊗h Y )∗ , and let i : X ⊗h Y → (X ⊗h Y )∗∗ be the canonical embedding into the second dual. Then the embedding in (1.57) is qi. That its range is w ∗ -dense follows from Goldstine’s lemma A.2.1, and the fact that q is a quotient map, and is w ∗ -continuous. 1.6.9 (Weak* Haagerup tensor product) This is another ‘dual version’ of the Haagerup tensor product. Since will not use this tensor product very much, we content ourselves with an abridged development of it. See [70, 150] for much more information, for example, there are several other ways to describe this tensor product. If X and Y are operator spaces then we define X ∗ ⊗w∗ h Y ∗ = (X ⊗h Y )∗ .
(1.58)
We now discuss why this is a ‘tensor product’. By the last paragraph of 1.5.8, and writing the space H there as 2I , we have that w ∈ (X ⊗h Y )∗ if and only if w may be written in the form w(x ⊗ y) = ϕ(x), ψ(y), for a cardinal I, ϕ ∈ CB(X, RI ) and ψ ∈ CB(Y, CI ). Now CB(Y, CI ) ∼ = CIw (Y ∗ ) and CB(X, RI ) = RIw (X ∗ ), using 1.2.29. Writing ϕ = [ϕi ] and ψ = [ψi ], we have shown the following asw ∗ sertion. Namely, w ∈ (X ⊗h Y )∗ if and only if there exist [ϕ i ] ∈ RI (X ) and w ∗ [ψi ] ∈ CI (Y ) such that w may be written as w(x ⊗ y) = i ϕi (x)ψi (y) for x ∈ X, y ∈ Y . The last sum converges absolutely in C, as may be seen by the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality. We may therefore think of elements w ∈ X ∗ ⊗w∗ h Y ∗
Operator spaces
43
as tensors, and write w = i ϕi ⊗ ψi , or w = ϕ ψ. We call this a weak representation for w, and equate two weak representations if they agree ‘as functionals on X ⊗h Y ’. By the above, ∗ [ψi ]C w (Y ∗ ) }, w = min{[ϕi ]Rw I (X ) I
where the minimum is over all weak representations for w. Note that X ⊗h Y ⊂ X ⊗w∗ h Y completely isometrically. This is just a restatement of (1.43). Thus if X is finite-dimensional then X ⊗w∗ h Y = X ⊗h Y . It follows readily from the ‘associativity’ of the Haagerup tensor product (see 1.5.4), and (1.58), that the weak* Haagerup tensor product is associative too. It is ‘functorial’ too in an appropriate sense. That is, w ∗ -continuous completely bounded maps will tensor. In fact more is true: Given dual operator spaces Xk and Yk , for k = 1, 2, and completely bounded maps uk : Xk → Yk , there ∗ ∗ is a canonical completely bounded map u1 ⊗ u2 : X1 ⊗w h X2 → Y1 ⊗w h Y2 with (u ⊗ u )( x ⊗ w ) = u (x ) ⊗ u (w ), for any weak representation 1 2 i i 1 i 2 i i i i xi ⊗ wi . Moreover, u1 ⊗ u2 cb ≤ u1 cb u2 cb . We omit the proof of this perhaps surprising assertion, which may be found in the original paper [70] (or see [150] for a different proof). Many of the identities in 1.5.14 have versions appropriate to ⊗w∗ h . For example, for a dual operator space X and a cardinal I we have ¯ ∼ CI ⊗w∗ h X = CI ⊗X = CIw (X)
(1.59)
and a similar relation holds for RIw (X). Indeed, the ‘∼ =’ here follows from (1.54).
The predual of CIw (X) is RI ⊗ X∗ , by 1.2.28 and (1.51). However by 1.5.14 (1), the latter space equals RI ⊗h X∗ , which is the predual of CI ⊗w∗h X. Another useful relation is
RI ⊗w∗ h X = RI ⊗h X = RI ⊗ X ∼ = CI (X∗ )∗
(1.60)
(and there is a matching formula for RI (X∗ )∗ ). To see (1.60), note that if w is in RI ⊗w∗h X, then w has a weak representation i ri ⊗ xi , with [ri ] ∈ RJw (RI ) and [xi ] ∈ CJw (X), for a cardinal J. However RJw (RI ) = RJ (RI ), so that by the proof of 1.5.6 (2) we have that w ∈ RI ⊗h X. This gives the first equality in (1.60). The second equality is 1.5.14 (1), whereas the third follows from (1.58), since CI (X∗ ) = CI ⊗h X∗ by 1.5.14 (2). By analogy with 1.5.14 (7), for cardinals I, J we have MI,J (X ⊗w∗ h Y ) ∼ = CIw (X) ⊗w∗ h RJw (Y ).
(1.61)
To see this, notice that the first space here equals CI ⊗w∗ h (X ⊗w∗ h Y ) ⊗w∗h RJ ∼ = (CI ⊗w∗ h X) ⊗w∗ h (Y ⊗w∗ h RJ ), using (1.20), (1.59) and its matching ‘row version’, and the associativity of ⊗ w∗ h . By (1.59) again, this equals the right-hand side of (1.61).
44
Duality and tensor products As an application, we show that for any operator space X we have KI,J (X)∗∗ ∼ = MI,J (X ∗∗ )
as dual operator spaces.
(1.62)
By 1.5.14 (5), (1.37), (1.58), and (1.60) and its matching ‘column’ formulation, KI (X)∗ ∼ = (CI ⊗h X ⊗h RI )∗ ∼ = (CI ⊗h X)∗ ⊗h CI ∼ = RI ⊗h X ∗ ⊗h CI . By 1.5.14 (4) and 1.2.29 we have (RI ⊗h X ∗ ⊗h CI )∗ ∼ = MI (X ∗∗ ). = CB(X ∗ , MI ) ∼ ∗ This proves (1.62). Another proof may be given using C -algebraic principles. 1.6.10 (A principle for separately w ∗ -continuous maps) Suppose, for example, that we have a completely bounded trilinear map Φ : X × Y × Z → B(K, H), where X, Y, Z are dual operator spaces. Suppose that Φ is separately w ∗ -continuous. From the CSPS theorem 1.5.7 we have Φ(x, y, z) = u(x)v(y)w(z)
(1.63)
for completely contractive maps u : X → B(K1 , H), v : Y → B(K2 , K1 ), and w : Z → B(K, K2 ). Here of course H, K, K1 , K2 are Hilbert spaces. Then we claim that K1 , K2 , and the maps u, v, w may be slightly adjusted, to each be w∗ -continuous and still satisfy (1.63). To see this, we first state an obvious principle, which we leave as an exercise. Namely, if u : X → B(K, H) is a completely contractive w ∗ -continuous map, if L is a subspace of H with associated projection PL , and if G is a subspace of K, then the map PL u(·)|G is w∗ -continuous and completely contractive too. Because of this principle, the following procedure applied to the maps one at a time, from right to left, will make them w ∗ -continuous, without destroying w∗ -continuity of any of the previously adjusted maps. We begin on the right, with w. We note that for ζ ∈ K, η ∈ H, Φ(x, y, z)ζ, η = w(z)ζ, v(y)∗ u(x)∗ η = PL w(z)ζ, v(y)∗ u(x)∗ η,
(1.64)
where L = [v(Y )∗ u(X)∗ H], and PL is the projection onto L. Replacing w by PL w, and v by its restriction to L, we may assume that K2 = L. If (zt )t is a bounded net in Z converging in the w∗ -topology to z, and if x ∈ X and y ∈ Y are fixed, then Φ(x, y, zt ) → Φ(x, y, z) in the w∗ -topology. Thus from (1.64), w(zt )ζ, v(y)∗ u(x)∗ η → w(z)ζ, v(y)∗ u(x)∗ η. From this, and norm density considerations in L, it is clear that w(zt ) → w(z) in the WOT. Since this is a bounded net, it converges in the w ∗ -topology (see A.1.4). Thus by A.2.5, w is w∗ -continuous. Finally, we replace K2 by its subspace [w(Z)H], and replace v by its restriction to this subspace. This ends the procedure. We now begin the same procedure again, to make the next map v w∗ -continuous. Thus we replace K1 by its subspace [u(X)∗ H], and use an argument similar to the above. Once v is w ∗ -continuous, we replace K1 again by [v(Y )w(Z)H], and then continue, to make u w ∗ -continuous.
Operator spaces
45
1.7 NOTES AND HISTORICAL REMARKS One might say that operator space theory grew out of Stinespring’s theorem [398], via Arveson’s landmark papers [21, 22] and the fundamental work in the seventies (continuing into the early 1980s) of Choi and Effros, Haagerup, Kirchberg, Wittstock, and others. The eighties saw much activity in the area of completely bounded maps; the vision of Effros (e.g. see [133]) and Paulsen’s text [307] were particularly influential in this development. See also [94], and the much overlooked work of Hamana (referenced in our bibliography). However operator spaces did not become a field in its own right until Ruan’s theorem 1.2.13. This result was proved by Ruan in his thesis [369] (see also [370]) under the direction of Effros, and was inspired by [90,318]. Ruan used this theorem to define operator space quotients, operator seminorm structures, and so on. See also the inspiring papers [142, 143], for example. A couple of years after that, operator space duality, and the basic operator space tensor theory, were developed independently by Blecher and Paulsen, and Effros and Ruan (e.g. see [42, 66, 145, 146]). (The Haagerup tensor product of operator spaces had been developed earlier (e.g. in the important paper [318]).) In the early 1990s Pisier lent his considerable strength and expertise to the subject, as is fabulously testified to in [332, 337]. After this the field grew quite considerably, with many brilliant mathematicians making remarkable contributions. For a more complete account of basic operator space theory, and for more references to the literature to complement the list in these Notes and historical remarks sections, the reader should also consult the texts [149, 314, 337, 385]. See also [433], which is currently being rewritten in an expanded printed form. There are other good surveys of part of the subject, such as [338, 366]. 1.2: Parts of 1.2.4 are folklore, no doubt known from the beginning. A generalization is proved in the later result 8.3.2. Observation 1.2.6 is due to Loebl. A related useful fact is that for a bounded linear map into Mn , we have T cb = Tn (see [389]). The canonical example of a map which is not completely bounded is the ‘transpose map’ on K. Injectivity of operator systems was studied deeply by Choi and Effros (e.g. see [90]), partly inspired by Arveson’s extension theorem (see 1.3.5 and [21]). Later, Theorems 1.2.8 and 1.2.10 were proved by Wittstock [432, 431], Haagerup [177], and Paulsen [305]. See those papers, and [149, 314, 337, 385], for additional historical details. Paulsen’s proofs of these two results is now the standard route. See also [325, 335] for a different approach extending Theorem 1.2.8 to a Banach space setting. The first isomorphism in (1.5) has been dubbed the ‘canonical shuffle’ by Paulsen. It is not true that a one-to-one and surjective completely bounded linear map T : X → Y between complete operator spaces has a completely bounded inverse. Indeed, there is no ‘open mapping theorem’ in this sense. Of course if the countably infinite amplification of T maps K(X) onto K(Y ), then there is no obstacle. That CB(X, Y ) is an operator space was observed first in [143]. The operator space dual was called the standard dual by Blecher and Paulsen, and the asso-
46
Notes and historical remarks
ciated duality theory was developed independently by those authors and Effros and Ruan. Minimal and maximal operator spaces were first considered in [142] and [66] respectively. Formally, Hilbert row and column spaces may first appear in [432]. They played a role in [135,66] and were further developed in [147]. Some of the results in the latter paper had also been noticed by Blecher, and [43] gives alternative routes to these and to other results from [147]. There are other interesting operator space structures on a Hilbert space, most notably the (selfdual) operator Hilbert space OH of Pisier [328, 337] which will be mentioned again in Chapter 5 (see 5.3.4). Nearly all of the definitions/results on infinite matrix spaces here may be found in a series of papers by Hamana, and Effros and Ruan (e.g. see [186,143,146]). Interpolation and ultraproducts of operator spaces were first considered by Pisier [328, 331, 327]. See also [436] for related work. We sketch a simple proof of (1.14). We may write H c = CJ , K c = CI , for cardinals I, J. Setting X = CI in 1.2.28 yields CB(CJ , CI ) ∼ = RJw (CI ) ∼ = MI,J completely isometrically, where the last equality follows from any of the centered equations in 1.2.26. 1.3: Many of the results in this section are from Arveson’s original papers [21, 22]. These papers established, for example, the role of completely positive maps in the unitary equivalence theory of irreducible sets of compact operators, a generalization of the Shilov boundary to arbitrary operator algebras, and generalizations of the Sz. Nagy–Foias dilation theorem to representations of arbitrary function algebras. Arveson’s result 1.3.6 is the decisive relation between unital operator spaces and operator systems. Paulsen’s lemma 1.3.15 (originally from [305]) yields the decisive relation between general operator spaces and operator systems. Note that we did not use the fact that the map was unital in 1.3.9, indeed many of the results in this section are true without this assumption (e.g. see [36]). There are also direct proofs of 1.3.9 not using Stinespring’s theorem. The result 1.3.10 is an easy variant of the Banach–Stone–Kadison theorem [212]. Item 1.3.11 seems to appear first in [301], but is related to Choi’s multiplicative domain [87]. Other sources for results in this section are [88,90,211,213,307,399]. 1.4: The facts in this section are due to Blecher (see [42], which was written close to the date of [66,145], although it appeared much later), with the following main exceptions. The fact that X ⊂ X ∗∗ completely isometrically was independently noticed in [66, 145]. Effros and Ruan had noticed 1.4.7 via a different route [146]. 1.5: The minimal tensor product may have been first considered for operator spaces in [307]. An account of this tensor product from the perspective of C ∗ -algebra theory can be found in [407], for example. Relations such as the complete isometry X ⊗min Y → CB(Y ∗ , X) were first noticed in [66]. The approach presented here to the minimal tensor product is taken from the latter paper, with some simplifications influenced by the exposition in Chapter 8 of [149]. The functoriality property of the minimal (or spatial) tensor product is one of the most important properties of completely bounded maps: they may be tensored. This may have been first observed in [117], which dates to 1982 or earlier. This
Operator spaces
47
property is not shared by general bounded maps with respect to the natural tensor products found in C ∗ -algebra theory. Haagerup defined the tensor product that bears his name in [176], at least for C ∗ -algebras. It was studied in the 1980s in papers of Effros, some with coauthors (see [149] for detailed references). In [318] Paulsen and Smith showed that the Haagerup tensor product in the generality presented here, is an operator space (this is usually seen now using Ruan’s theorem, as was first noted in [369]), and proved many of the other facts presented here. The class of bilinear or multilinear maps described here as ‘completely bounded’ are given a different name in [149]; instead Effros and Ruan use this term for the class which we call ‘jointly completely bounded’. The injectivity of the Haagerup tensor product is also from [318]. Other proofs were found later by Effros, Paulsen, and others (e.g. see [385, 149, 314, 337] or 2.10 in [43], for a selection). The projectivity of ⊗h and ⊗ was observed in [147]. Part (2) of 1.5.6 is also true for uncountable sums with the same proof. The original references for Theorem 1.5.7 are [93] (for C ∗ -algebras) and [318] (for general operator spaces). Other proofs may be found in [149, 307, 337]. The selfduality relation (1.43) was conjectured by Blecher and proved in full in [147]. Different proofs appear in [43,70]. The latter paper sketches a route based on Smith’s important notion of strong independence [391], through many of the basic results in this section. Observation (1.44) was perhaps first in [40]. The relation (1.45) is from [147], see also [325] and [310] for related results and developments. For further information on g2 , we refer the reader to [118] (e.g. see 12.7 there). Relations (1.44), (1.46), and (1.47) are just three examples of relationships between the Haagerup tensor product and Pisier’s ‘gamma-norms’ introduced in [326]. See [328] and [243] for related developments. The operator space projective tensor product and its basic properties were developed in [66,145]. Formula (1.48) is from the latter paper. There is a similar formula valid for all z ∈ Mn (X ⊗ Y ), writing z = α(x ⊗ y)β, where the latter matrices are now countably infinite (see [149]). In [66] it is shown without using formula (1.48), that there is an operator space X ⊗ Y having all the other properties mentioned in 1.5.11 and the paragraphs after it. Various forms of the relations in 1.5.14 may be found in [135,66,147,139,43], but [147] is the primary reference. Note that 1.2.10 follows from 1.5.14 (4), and the injectivity of ⊗ h . 1.6: Nearly all the facts about infinite matrices in 1.6.2 and 1.6.3 are explicitly in [186, 143, 146]. Neufang has generalized 1.6.3 in [292]. The result 1.6.4 is due to Le Merdy [244], who also showed in that paper that if X is an operator space which is a dual Banach space with predual Y , then there may not exist an operator space structure on Y such that Y ∗ ≈ X completely isomorphically (see also 2.7.15). The equivalence between the two descriptions of ⊗ in 1.6.5 is related to the fact that (X∗ ⊗ Y∗ )∗ = CB(Y∗ , X) equals the normal Fubini product of X and Y , which was proved independently by Blecher and Ruan (see [43, Theorem 2.5], [372]), inspired by the von Neumann algebra case [146]. The Fubini product for operator spaces was first studied in [186] though. Since the normal Fubini
48
Notes and historical remarks
product is defined in terms of slice maps, such maps are key to understanding when X ⊗ Y = CB(Y∗ , X) holds for dual operator spaces X and Y . For example, the fact that this holds for two von Neumann algebras, which was proved in [146], follows from the slice map theorem of Tomiyama [410]. This fact is of great importance in many recent papers on Fourier analysis (e.g. see [378]), since, for example, one may deduce from it that A(G1 × G2 ) ∼ = A(G1 ) ⊗ A(G2 ) for locally compact groups G1 , G2 (see [146]). A dual operator space X is said to have the dual slice mapping property if X ⊗ Y = CB(Y∗ , X) holds for all dual operator spaces Y . This is equivalent to X∗ possessing the ‘operator space approximation property’ (see [146,139,233]). The argument at the beginning of 1.6.6 is only part of this result in the case when X is a commutative W ∗ -algebra. It extends to all semidiscrete (=injective) von Neumann algebras. The description of L ∞ (Ω; Y ) as a space of Y -valued w∗ -measurable functions is essentially taken from [380, Section 1.22]. The definitions and results in 1.6.8 are due to Effros and Ruan (see [138, 150], and references therein). The weak* Haagerup tensor product was developed by Blecher and Smith in [70] for dual operator spaces. Later this tensor product, and its basic properties, were generalized to all operator spaces (e.g. see [150], and to a lesser extent [5]), under the name extended Haagerup tensor product. Spronk has shown in [397] that the original arguments of [70] immediately yield many of these generalizations from [150]. Result 1.6.10 is from [150].
2 Basic theory of operator algebras
2.1 INTRODUCING OPERATOR ALGEBRAS AND UNITIZATIONS By definition, a concrete operator algebra is a closed subalgebra of B(H), for some Hilbert space H. When the context is clear, we often simply write A ⊂ B(H) or A → B(H) to denote this. As for operator spaces, we will have to consider operator algebras from an abstract point of view. We will start from the obvious observation that any operator algebra A is both an operator space and a Banach algebra. Conversely, if A is both an operator space and a Banach algebra, then we call A an (abstract) operator algebra if there exist a Hilbert space H and a completely isometric homomorphism π : A → B(H). In that situation, we often identify A and the concrete operator algebra π(A) and say that A is represented as a subalgebra of B(H), or that A is an operator algebra on H. We often identify any two operator algebras A and B which are completely isometrically isomorphic, that is, there exists a complete isometric algebra homomorphism from A onto B. In this case, we write ‘A ∼ = B completely isometrically isomorphically’, or ‘as operator algebras’; or simply ‘A = B’. Some more notation that will be used throughout: We say that an operator algebra A is unital if it has an identity (i.e. a unit) of norm 1. In this case, the unit is often written as e or 1 (or sometimes eA or 1A if necessary). However in this book we will usually focus on the larger class of operator algebras which are approximately unital; that is, which possess a contractive approximate identity (cai). The main reason for this choice of focus is because this class includes all C ∗ -algebras. We repeat from 1.1.5 the convention that a unital-subalgebra is a subalgebra A of a unital algebra B with 1B ∈ A. Of course operator algebras may be thought of as the (closed) subalgebras of C ∗ -algebras. The closure of a subalgebra of an operator algebra is obviously an operator algebra. By a representation of an operator algebra A on a Hilbert space H, we mean a homomorphism π : A → B(H). Of course we are almost always interested in the completely contractive representations. It should be noticed that unlike ∗-representations between C ∗ -algebras, bounded and completely bounded homomorphisms between operator algebras have no automatic rigidity property in general. For instance, a completely contractive homomorphism need not have a closed range. If A and B are operator algebras, then we will often write A → B when there exists a completely isometric homomorphism j : A → B. Again, a unital map is one that takes the identity to the identity.
50
Introducing operator algebras and unitizations
∗ 2.1.1 (C ∗ -covers) If S is a subset of a C ∗ -algebra B, then CB (S) denotes the ∗ ∗ C -subalgebra of B generated by S (that is, the smallest C -subalgebra of B containing S). A C ∗ -cover of an operator algebra A is a pair (B, j) consisting of a C ∗ -algebra B, and a completely isometric homomorphism j : A → B, such ∗ (j(A)) = B. that j(A) generates B as a C ∗ -algebra. That is, such that CB
2.1.2 (The diagonal) We defined this for unital operator spaces in 1.3.7. If A is an operator algebra (possibly nonunital), represented as a subalgebra of B(H) say, then we define the diagonal of A to be the C ∗ -algebra ∆(A) = {a ∈ A : a∗ ∈ A}. Note that if A is a w∗ -closed subalgebra of B(H) then so is ∆(A) (by the w ∗ continuity properties mentioned in A.1.2), and hence ∆(A) is a W ∗ -algebra. To see that the definition of ∆(A) is (up to ∗-isomorphism) independent of the particular representation of A, consider any isometric homomorphism π : A → B(K). Then it follows from A.5.8 that π(a)∗ = π(a∗ ) for any a ∈ ∆(A). Thus π maps ∆(A) ∗-isomorphically (and therefore also completely isometrically, by 1.2.4) onto the corresponding space {b ∈ π(A) : b∗ ∈ π(A)}. From this, one deduces that a contractive homomorphism from a C ∗ -algebra into an operator algebra B, actually maps into ∆(B), and is a ∗-homomorphism. Also, from this we see that a closed subalgebra of a C ∗ -algebra B may have at most one involution with respect to which it is a C ∗ -algebra. If there exists such an involution, then the subalgebra is a ∗-subalgebra of B. 2.1.3 (Recognizing selfadjoint elements, etc.) Certain important elements in an operator algebra may be characterized intrinsically, and such results are very often useful. For the discussion that follows, we fix a closed subalgebra A of B(H). Then the projections in B(H) which happen to be also in A, are exactly the idempotent elements in A of norm 1 (see A.1.1). The selfadjoint operators in B(H) which happen to be also in A, are exactly the selfadjoint elements in the diagonal ∆(A). If A is a unital operator algebra, then these selfadjoint elements are exactly the Hermitian elements of A in the sense of A.4.2. The diagonal ∆(A) is the span of these selfadjoint elements of course. If a, b are elements in the unit ball of A, and if ab = 1A , then a = b∗ by A.1.1, and a, b ∈ ∆(A). If in fact ab = IH , then b is an isometry on H, and a is a coisometry. If in addition ba = 1A , then b is a unitary in ∆(A), and is a unitary operator on H if 1A = IH . 2.1.4 Let A ⊂ B(H) be a unital operator algebra, with unit denoted by e. Then e2 = e and e = 1, consequently e : H → H is a projection, as noted in 2.1.3. Let K ⊂ H denote the range of e. If a ∈ A, then since eae = a, we have a(K) ⊂ K and a(K ⊥ ) = {0}. We may therefore regard A ⊂ B(K) as an operator algebra on K, and in that representation, the unit e coincides with the identity operator IK . Also [aij ] = [eaij e] = [(aij )|K ]Mn (B(K)) ,
Basic theory of operator algebras
51
for aij ∈ A. This shows that any unital operator algebra may be represented (completely isometrically) as a unital-subalgebra of some B(H). In 2.1.10 below, we will prove a similar result for approximately unital operator algebras. In fact the next several results establish various useful properties of contractive approximate identities in operator algebras. 2.1.5 (Nondegeneracy) Let A be a Banach algebra, let H be a Hilbert space, and let π : A → B(H) be a contractive homomorphism. We say that π is nondegenerate if [π(A)H] = H. This terminology is consistent with that in A.6.1. Indeed if we consider H as a left Banach A-module by letting aζ = π(a)ζ, for any a ∈ A and any ζ ∈ H, then π is obviously nondegenerate if and only if H is a nondegenerate A-module. This is also equivalent, as we mentioned in A.6.1, to saying that π(et ) → IH strongly, if (et )t is a cai for A. If A ⊂ B(H) is a concrete operator algebra, then we say that A is a nondegenerate subalgebra of B(H), or that ‘A ⊂ B(H) nondegenerately’, if the embedding from A into B(H) is nondegenerate. Lemma 2.1.6 Suppose that a is an element of a subspace of B(K, H), and that (et )t is a net of contractions in B(K) such that aet → a. Then aet e∗t → a, ae∗t et → a, and ae∗t → a. Proof If aet → a then aet e∗t a∗ → aa∗ , so that 0 ≤ a(I − et e∗t )a∗ →0, where ∗ I = IK . Thus by the C -identity, a I − et e∗t → 0. Multiplying by I − et e∗t we see that a(I − et e∗t ) → 0 as required for the first assertion. Also, ae∗t − a ≤ ae∗t − aet e∗t + aet e∗t − a → 0 since ae∗t − aet e∗t ≤ a − aet → 0. Finally, ae∗t et − a ≤ ae∗t et − aet + aet − a ≤ ae∗t − a + aet − a → 0 by what we just proved.
2
Lemma 2.1.7 Let A be an operator algebra and suppose that B is a C ∗ -cover of A. If A is approximately unital, then B is a nondegenerate A-bimodule in the sense of A.6.1. In this case (viewing A ⊂ B): (1) If b ∈ B then there exists an element b0 ∈ B and elements a1 , a2 ∈ A with b = a1 b0 a2 . Moreover if b < 1 then b0 , a1 , a2 may be chosen of norm < 1. (2) Every cai for A is a cai for B. Proof Notice that once (2) is established, then B is a nondegenerate Banach A-bimodule, and then (1) follows from Cohen’s factorization theorem (see A.6.2). Let (et )t be a cai for A, and let a ∈ A. Then et a → a, and using 2.1.6 we have a∗ et → a∗ . Thus if b is in the dense ∗-subalgebra of B generated by A, then 2 bet → b. By density, bet → b for every b ∈ B. Similarly, et b → b. 2.1.8 It follows from the last result that any C ∗ -cover (B, j) of an approximately unital operator algebra A is a unital C ∗ -algebra if and only if A is unital. Indeed
52
Introducing operator algebras and unitizations
if A is unital with unit 1A , then j(1A ) is a unit for B by 2.1.7 (2). Conversely, if B is unital with unit 1B , then by 2.1.7 (2) we see that any cai (et ) for A satisfies j(et ) = j(et ) 1B −→ 1B . Since j(A) is closed, we have 1B ∈ j(A). As another application of Lemma 2.1.7, we may see using 2.1.5 that if B is a C ∗ -cover of an approximately unital operator algebra A, and if π : B → B(H) is a ∗-representation, then π is nondegenerate if and only if its restriction π|A is nondegenerate. Lemma 2.1.9 Let A be a Banach algebra with cai (et )t , and let π : A → B(H) be a contractive homomorphism. We let p be the projection onto [π(A)H]. Then π(et ) → p in the w∗ -topology of B(H). Moreover, for a ∈ A we have π(a) = pπ(a)p,
a ∈ A.
(2.1)
Proof Let K = [π(A)H]. If a ∈ A then π(et )π(a) → π(a), and so π(et )∗ π(a) converges to π(a) by 2.1.6. Hence π(et )∗ → IK strongly on K. If ζ, η ∈ H, then π(et )ζ, η = pπ(et )ζ, η = ζ, π(et )∗ pη −→ ζ, pη = pζ, η. Thus the bounded net (π(et ))t converges to p in the WOT. Hence it also converges in w∗ -topology to p, by A.1.4. Using the last fact and the separate w ∗ continuity of the product in B(H) (see A.1.2), we obtain for a ∈ A that π(a)p = w∗ - lim π(a)π(et ) = lim π(aet ) = π(a). t
t
Since pπ(a) = π(a) by the definition of p, the claim (2.1) follows at once.
2
2.1.10 (Reducing to the nondegenerate case) The relation (2.1) should be interpreted as follows. Let H, K, π be as above. If we regard B(K) as a subalgebra of B(H) in the natural way (by identifying any T in B(K) with the map T ⊕ 0 in B(K ⊕ K ⊥ ) = B(H)), then the homomorphism π is valued in B(K). Since π is nondegenerate when regarded as valued in B(K), this yields a principle whereby to reduce a possibly degenerate homomorphism to a nondegenerate one. Applying this to completely isometric homomorphisms, we obtain that for any approximately unital operator algebra A, there exist a Hilbert space H and a nondegenerate completely isometric homomorphism π : A → B(H). 2.1.11 (The unitization) Often problems concerning an operator algebra A are solved by first tackling the case where A is unital; and then in the general case considering the unitization A1 of A. It is this process of unitization which we now discuss. If A is a nonunital operator algebra, then a unitization of A which is also an operator algebra may be obtained by regarding A as a subalgebra of B(H) for some H, and then taking A1 = Span{A, IH }. We will prove in Corollary 2.1.15 that up to completely isometric isomorphism, this unitization does not depend
Basic theory of operator algebras
53
on the embedding A ⊂ B(H). Consequently, A1 will be called the unitization of A, and we usually use it without any reference to a concrete embedding of A in B(H). We will first establish the more general Theorem 2.1.13, which is an extremely useful extension principle. The following simple lemma is a special case: / A. Lemma 2.1.12 Let A ⊂ B(H) be an operator algebra, and assume that IH ∈ Then for any n ≥ 1 and any matrices a ∈ Mn (A) and λ ∈ Mn , we have λMn ≤ a + λ ⊗ IH Mn (B(H)) . Proof Consider the algebra A1 = Span{A, IH } ⊂ B(H). Since IH ∈ / A, we may define a functional φ on A1 by letting φ(a + λIH ) = λ for any a ∈ A and any λ ∈ C. It is clear that φ is a homomorphism. From the basic theory of characters from any text on Banach algebras, we have that φ is contractive. Hence by 1.2.6, φ is completely contractive. This proves the result. 2 Theorem 2.1.13 (Meyer) Let A ⊂ B(H) be an operator algebra, and assume / A. Let π : A → B(K) be a contractive (resp. completely contractive) that IH ∈ homomorphism, K being a Hilbert space. We let A1 = Span{A, IH } ⊂ B(H), and we extend π to π 0 : A1 → B(K) by letting π 0 (a + λIH ) = π(a) + λIK ,
a ∈ A, λ ∈ C.
Then π 0 is a contractive (resp. completely contractive) homomorphism. 2.1.14 Before launching into the proof of Theorem 2.1.13, we recall a few facts concerning the so-called Cayley transform of operators on a Hilbert space H. To those familiar with the basic theory of operator semigroups, the following facts will be transparent (e.g. see [405] sections III.8 and IV.4). In order to be self-contained, we will prove these facts using some basic results about the Riesz or analytic functional calculus (e.g. see [106] section 2.4). We let D and P denote respectively the open unit disk and right-hand open half plane in C. We let z−1 d : D → P be the conformal map z → 1+z 1−z , and let c(z) = z+1 be its inverse. If −1 is not in the spectrum σ(S) of an operator S on H (resp. 1 ∈ / σ(T )), then we define the Cayley transform (resp. inverse Cayley transform) by c(S) = (S −I)(S +I) −1 (resp. d(T ) = (I + T )(I − T )−1 ). It follows from the spectral mapping theorem (e.g. see [106, 2.4.4 (iv)]) that 1 ∈ / σ(c(S)) (resp. −1 ∈ / σ(d(T ))). Thus we see from the functional calculus that these transforms are indeed inverses of each other. For example, c(d(T )) = T providing that 1 ∈ / σ(T ). An operator T ∈ B(H) will be called a strict contraction if T < 1. In that case, the usual Neumann series trick shows that the operator I − T is invertible and (I −T )−1 = k≥0 T k belongs to the operator algebra generated by I and T . Next, an operator S ∈ B(H) will be called strictly accretive if Re(S) = 21 (S + S ∗ ) is positive and invertible. That is, there is a scalar > 0 with Re(S) ≥ I. 1 After pre- and post-multiplying by Re(S)− 2 , it is easy to see that such an S is
54
Introducing operator algebras and unitizations
invertible. Similarly, for any z ∈ C with Re(z) ≤ 0, it is clear that S − zI is also strictly accretive, and therefore invertible in B(H). Thus the spectrum of S is contained in P. We claim that (S + I)−1 belongs to the operator algebra B generated by I and S. To see this, by the basic theory of Banach algebras it is enough to show that χ(S + I) = 0 for every character of B. However by the Hahn–Banach theorem any such χ extends to a state ϕ on B(H) (see A.4.2), and ϕ(S + I) = ϕ(S) + 1 = 0 (indeed Re(ϕ(S)) = ϕ(Re(S)) ≥ 0, by (A.11) say). Using the formula 4Re(S)ζ, ζ = (S + I)ζ2 − (S − I)ζ2 ,
ζ ∈ H,
(2.2)
a simple computation shows that: (1) S ∈ B(H) is strictly accretive if and only if −1 ∈ / σ(S) and the Cayley transform c(S) = (S − I)(S + I)−1 is a strict contraction. (2) T ∈ B(H) is a strict contraction if and only if 1 ∈ / σ(T ) and the inverse Cayley transform d(T ) = (I + T )(I − T )−1 is strictly accretive. Indeed (2) may be derived from (1) and the fact above that T = c(d(T )). Proof (Of Theorem 2.1.13) It is clear that π 0 is a homomorphism. We will show that if the nth amplification πn is contractive, then so is πn0 . Fix T in Mn (A1 ) ⊂ B(2n (H)), with T < 1. We will show that πn0 (T ) < 1. We may write T uniquely as T = a + λ ⊗ IH , with a ∈ Mn (A) and λ ∈ Mn . By Lemma 2.1.12, we have λ < 1. To simplify the notation, we shall identify λ and λ ⊗ IH in the sequel. Let us apply the assertion (2) of 2.1.14 to λ. We find two selfadjoint matrices α, β ∈ Mn such that (I + λ)(I − λ)−1 = α + iβ, and such that α is positive and invertible. We may write the preceding identity as α−1/2 (I + λ)(I − λ)−1 α−1/2 − iα−1/2 βα−1/2 = I.
(2.3)
Let us now apply 2.1.14 (2) to T . We find that (I + T )(I − T )−1 is strictly accretive, from which we deduce that θ = α−1/2 (I + T )(I − T )−1 α−1/2 − iα−1/2 βα−1/2
(2.4)
is strictly accretive. According to (2.3) we can write this operator as θ = I + α−1/2 (I + T )(I − T )−1 − (I + λ)(I − λ)−1 α−1/2 . Now observe that (I + T )(I − T )−1 − (I + λ)(I − λ)−1 may be rewritten as (I − T )−1 (I + T )(I − λ) − (I − T )(I + λ) (I − λ)−1 , which is simply 2(I − T )−1 a(I − λ)−1 . Since (I − T )−1 belongs to the operator algebra generated by I and T (see 2.1.14), hence to Mn (A1 ), and since Mn (A) is an ideal of Mn (A1 ), we obtain that (I + T )(I − T )−1 − (I + λ)(I − λ)−1 ∈ Mn (A). Therefore θ − I belongs to Mn (A). Moreover by a fact in 2.1.14 again, (θ + I)−1 belongs to the operator algebra generated by I and θ, and hence also to M n (A1 ). Hence the Cayley transform (θ − I)(θ + I)−1 belongs to Mn (A).
Basic theory of operator algebras
55
Since πn0 is a unital homomorphism and θ + I is invertible, πn0 (θ) + I is −1 = πn0 (θ + I)−1 , and hence invertible as well. Also πn0 (θ) + I −1 . πn0 (θ − I)(θ + I)−1 = πn0 (θ) − I πn0 (θ) + I By the assertion (1) of 2.1.14, the operator (θ −I)(θ +I)−1 is a strict contraction. Since it belongs to Mn (A), and since πn is contractive, we deduce that 0 πn (θ) − I πn0 (θ) + I −1 = πn (θ − I)(θ + I)−1 < 1. By 2.1.14 (2) we deduce that πn0 (θ), which is the inverse Cayley transform of the −1 operator πn0 (θ) − I πn0 (θ) + I , is strictly accretive. By (2.4), πn0 (I + T )(I − T )−1 = πn0 α1/2 θα1/2 + iβ = α1/2 πn0 (θ)α1/2 + iβ is strictly accretive. Since πn0 is a homomorphism, we have as above that −1 πn0 (I + T )(I − T )−1 = I + πn0 (T ) I − πn0 (T ) . By 2.1.14 (1) again, we have πn0 (T ) < 1, which concludes the proof.
2
Corollary 2.1.15 (Meyer) Let A ⊂ B(H) be a nonunital operator algebra and let π : A → B(K) be an isometric (resp. completely isometric) homomorphism. Then the unital homomorphism from Span{A, IH } into B(K) extending π is an isometry (resp. complete isometry). Proof By assumption, IH ∈ / A. Let B = π(A) and regard π as valued in B. Since A is isomorphic to B as algebras, B is nonunital. Hence IK ∈ / B. Using the notation from Theorem 2.1.13, we deduce that π 0 : Span{A, IH } → Span{B, IK } is a bijection, with (π 0 )−1 = (π −1 )0 . That theorem shows that π 0 and (π −1 )0 are both (completely) contractive. Thus π 0 is a (complete) isometry. 2 2.1.16 (Unitization of a subalgebra) It is clear from 2.1.15 that if C is a unital operator algebra with unit denoted by 1C and if A ⊂ C is a nonunital subalgebra, then A1 may be taken to be Span{A, 1C } ⊂ C. In particular if A, B are nonunital operator algebras with A ⊂ B, then the units of A1 and B 1 may be identified and A1 may be viewed as a unital-subalgebra of B 1 . 2.1.17 (Unitization of an approximately unital algebra) Although the unitization A1 is now defined unambiguously, it is in general very difficult to describe its norm (or its matrix norms) intrinsically. However if A is an approximately unital operator algebra, and if A ⊂ B(H) nondegenerately (see 2.1.10), then for any a ∈ A and any λ ∈ C, we claim that a + λIH = sup ac + λc : c ∈ A, c ≤ 1 . (We note in passing, although we do not need this here, that the right-hand side above is the ‘unitization norm’ from A.4.3, and that another equivalent
56
Introducing operator algebras and unitizations
description of it is given there.) To prove the claim, let (et )t be a cai for A. Since et → IH strongly by 2.1.5, a + λIH is the strong limit of aet + λet . Hence a + λIH ≤ sup aet + λet . t
The other direction is easier, since for any c ∈ A with c ≤ 1, ac + λc = (a + λIH )c ≤ a + λIH . This proves the result. With the same proof we see that more generally, for any integer n ≥ 1 and for any matrices [aij ] ∈ Mn (A) and [λij ] ∈ Mn , we have [aij + λij IH ] = sup [aij c + λij c] : c ∈ A, c ≤ 1 . (2.5) If A is an already unital operator algebra then Meyer’s result shows that there is an essentially unique unital operator algebra containing A completely isometrically as a codimension 1 ideal. Again we write this strictly larger algebra as A1 . In fact this ‘unitization’ is just the ‘∞-direct sum’ A ⊕∞ C (see 1.2.17). Proposition 2.1.18 Let A be an approximately unital operator algebra with a cai (et )t and denote the identity of A1 by 1. (1) If ψ : A1 → C is a functional on A1 , then limt ψ(et ) = ψ(1) if and only if ψ = ψ|A . (2) Let ϕ : A → C be any functional on A. Then ϕ uniquely extends to a functional of the same norm on A1 . Proof We first prove (1). Suppose that ψ : A1 → C satisfies limt ψ(et ) = ψ(1). For a ∈ A and λ ∈ C, we obtain limt ψ(aet + λet ) = ψ(a + λ1), and so ψ(a + λ1) ≤ supψ(aet + λet ). t
Consequently, ψ(a + λ1) ≤ ψ|A sup aet + λet ≤ ψ|A a + λ1, t
which proves that ψ = ψ|A . Assume conversely that ψ = ψ|A . We may assume that this norm is equal to 1. By 1.2.8 there exist a Hilbert space H, a contractive unital homomorphism π : A1 → B(H) and two unit vectors ζ, η ∈ H such that ψ(x) = π(x)ζ, η for any x ∈ A1 . Let K = [π(A)ζ] ⊂ H and let p be the projection onto K. For any a ∈ A, we have π(a)ζ, η = pπ(a)ζ, η, and so π(a)ζ, η = π(a)ζ, pη ≤ π(a)ζpη ≤ apη. This shows that ψ|A ≤ pη. Hence, by hypothesis, pη = η = 1. Thus pη = η, that is, η ∈ K. Now recall from Lemma 2.1.9 that π(et ) → p in the w∗ -topology, and thus
Basic theory of operator algebras
57
ψ(et ) = π(et )ζ, η −→ pζ, η = ζ, η = ψ(1). We now deduce (2) from (1). Let ϕ ∈ A∗ . Again we may write ϕ = π(·)ζ, η; and Lemma 2.1.9 and the ‘first half’ of the last centered equation shows that (ϕ(et ))t converges. Extend ϕ to a map ψ : A1 → C by defining ψ(1) = limt ϕ(et ). The ‘only if’ part of (1) ensures that ψ = ϕ. On the other hand, the ‘if’ part of (1) shows that this norm preserving extension is unique. 2 2.1.19 (States) If A is unital then a state on A is a functional ϕ on A of norm 1 which satisfies ϕ(1) = 1 (see A.4.2). If A is not unital but has a cai (e t ), then we define a state on A to be a functional ϕ on A of norm 1 which satisfies limt ϕ(et ) = 1. By the last result, such ϕ extends uniquely to a state on A1 . 2.2 A FEW BASIC CONSTRUCTIONS The class of operator algebras is stable under many of the categorical constructions introduced in Chapter 1. We shall now review the simplest of these in this short section. 2.2.1 (Direct sums) Let I be a set and let (Ai )i∈I be a family of operator algebras. Let A = ⊕i∈I Ai be the ∞-direct sum of this family, as studied in 1.2.17. Besides being an operator space, A is a Banach algebra for the pointwise product defined by setting the product of (ai )i and (bi )i equal to (ai bi )i . Here (ai )i and (bi )i are in A. If we represent each Ai ⊂ B(Hi ) as an operator algebra acting on some Hilbert space Hi , the resulting embedding A ⊂ ⊕i∈I B(Hi ) ⊂ B ⊕2i∈I Hi is a homomorphism. Hence A is an operator algebra. It is clear that A is unital if each Ai is unital. 2.2.2 (The minimal tensor product) To define this we use facts from 1.5.1 and 1.5.2. Let A ⊂ B(H) and B ⊂ B(K) be two operator algebras. Equip the algebraic tensor product A ⊗ B with the joint multiplication defined by letting ai ⊗ b i cj ⊗ dj = ai cj ⊗ bi dj , (2.6) i
j
i,j
for any finite families (ai )i , (cj )j in A and (bi )i , (dj )j in B. It is clear that the natural embedding A ⊗ B ⊂ B(H ⊗2 K) is an algebra homomorphism. Passing to the completion, we see that A ⊗min B is an operator algebra. If A and B are unital with identities denoted by 1A and 1B , then A ⊗min B is unital as well, with identity equal to 1A ⊗ 1B . It is also worthwhile to observe that if A and B are approximately unital, then the same holds for A ⊗min B. Indeed if (et )t and (fs )s are cai’s for A and B respectively, then by a simple density argument, any y ∈ A ⊗min B satisfies lim lim (et ⊗ fs )y = lim lim y(et ⊗ fs ) = y. s
t
s
t
58
A few basic constructions
It follows from the ‘functoriality’ property in 1.5.1 that if π : A → B(H) and ρ : B → B(K) are completely contractive homomorphisms, then there is a unique completely contractive linear map π ⊗ ρ : A ⊗min B −→ B(H) ⊗min B(K) ⊂ B(H ⊗2 K) with (π ⊗ ρ)(a ⊗ b) = π(a) ⊗ ρ(b) for a ∈ A, b ∈ B. By an obvious density argument one sees that since π ⊗ ρ is a homomorphism on A ⊗ B, it is also a homomorphism on A ⊗min B. 2.2.3 (Matrix algebras) A special case of the minimal tensor product of particular interest, is the case when B = B(K), or equivalently when B = MI for a cardinal I. If n is a finite integer then Mn (A) ⊂ Mn (B(H)) = B(2n (H)) is an operator algebra on 2n (H), the product of two elements [aij ] and [bij ] of Mn (A) being given by n [aij ][bij ] = (2.7) aik bkj . k=1
We recall from (1.36) that Mn ⊗min A = Mn (A) as operator spaces, and this isomorphism is easily seen to be a homomorphism too. Thus they are ‘equal as operator algebras’. This result extends with a similar proof to the case when I is an infinite cardinal or set. Indeed recall from 1.2.26 that KI (A) is defined to be the closure of the subalgebra Mfin I (A) of the algebra MI (B(H)) = B(2I (H)). Thus KI (A) is an operator algebra on 2I (H) and KI ⊗min A = KI (A)
as operator algebras.
(2.8)
Note that if [aij ] and [bij ] are two (infinite) matrices belonging to KI (A), then their product is equal to the matrix [cij ] whose entries are defined by the expression cij = k∈I aik bkj ∈ A, the latter sum being norm convergent. The last fact follows from the discussion preceding (1.21). On the other hand, MI (A) need not be an algebra at all. However there are several operator algebras inside MI (A) which occasionally play a role. For example, the subsets of MI (A) corresponding to CIw (RI (A)), RIw (CI (A)), CI (RIw (A)) and RI (CIw (A)) are all operator algebras. We write RIw (CI (A)) as Mwr I (A); and we write CIw (RI (A)) as Mwc (A). These two operator algebras contain the other I two algebras in the last list as subalgebras. These facts will not play much of a wr role for us, and we leave the details as an exercise. Note that M wc I (A) ∩ MI (A) is also an operator algebra, and it contains the operator algebra A ⊗ min MI as may be seen by inspecting rank 1 tensors in the latter space. 2.2.4 (Operator algebra valued continuous functions) Let Ω be a compact space, and A an operator algebra. The operator space C(Ω; A) discussed in 1.2.18 is an operator algebra for the product defined by (f g)(t) = f (t)g(t). Namely,
Basic theory of operator algebras
59
if A is a subalgebra of B(H) then C(Ω; A) is a subalgebra of the C ∗ -algebra C(Ω; B(H)). If A is unital, then C(Ω; A) is unital as well, the identity being the constant function equal to the identity of A. According to (1.39), we have a completely isometric identification C(Ω) ⊗min A = C(Ω; A). We notice here that this identification holds as well ‘as operator algebras’. This is equivalent to saying that the linear mapping taking a finitesum k gk ⊗ ak ∈ C(Ω) ⊗ A to the function f ∈ C(Ω; A) defined by f (t) = k gk (t)ak is a homomorphism if C(Ω) ⊗min A and C(Ω; A) are equipped with the multiplications defined in 2.2.2 and above respectively. Similarly if Ω is merely a locally compact space, then the operator space C0 (Ω; A) is an operator algebra for the pointwise product. As operator algebras, we have that C0 (Ω) ⊗min A = C0 (Ω; A). 2.2.5 (Uniform algebras) By definition, a (concrete) uniform algebra is a unitalsubalgebra of C(Ω), for some compact space Ω. In this book, we will consider any uniform algebra as endowed with its minimal operator space structure (described by the formula (1.3)). Then an (abstract) uniform algebra is a unital operator algebra which is completely isometrically isomorphic to a concrete uniform algebra. In this way we regard uniform algebras as a subclass of the operator algebras. A characterization of the algebras in this subclass will be given in 3.7.9 (see also the Notes to Section 4.6). More generally, we will use the term function algebra for an operator algebra A for which there exists a compact space Ω and a completely isometric homomorphism π : A → C(Ω). Any function algebra is a minimal operator space. 2.2.6 (Disc algebra) This fundamental example of a uniform algebra has two equivalent definitions. Let us denote by D and T the open unit disc of C and the unitary complex group T = {z ∈ C : |z| = 1} respectively. Then the disc algebra A(D) is the subalgebra of C(D) consisting of all continuous functions F : D → C, whose restriction to D is analytic. By the maximal modulus theorem, the restriction of functions in A(D) to the boundary T is an isometry. Hence we may alternatively regard A(D) ⊂ C(T) as a uniform algebra acting on T. In that representation, A(D) consists of all elements of C(T) whose harmonic extension to D given by the Poisson integral is analytic. Equivalently, given any f ∈ C(T), we associate Fourier coefficients ! k ∈ Z. (2.9) f(k) = f (z)z −k dm(z), T Then A(D) ⊂ C(T) is the closed subalgebra of all f ∈ C(T) such that f (k) = 0 for every k < 0. The (analytic) polynomials form a dense subalgebra of A(D). 2.2.7 (Operator algebra valued analytic functions) Let X be an operator space. For any f ∈ C(T; X), we may define Fourier coefficients f (k) ∈ X by means of (2.9). According to 2.2.6, we let A(D; X) ⊂ C(T; X) denote the subspace of all f such that f(k) = 0 for every k < 0. Equivalently, as in the scalar case, A(D; X)
60
A few basic constructions
may be defined to be the subspace of C(D; X) consisting of all functions F whose restriction to D is analytic. We have A(D) ⊗min X = A(D; X) completely isometrically. Indeed both spaces may be regarded as the closure of A(D)⊗X in C(T; X). (The density of A(D)⊗X in A(D; X) follows from a routine argument using Fejer kernels.) If X = B is an operator algebra, it follows from either of these definitions that A(D; B) is an operator algebra which is both a subalgebra of C(T; B) and C(D; B). In that case the above identification holds ‘as operator algebras’. 2.2.8 (Opposite and adjoint algebras) We will use notations from 1.2.25. If A is an operator algebra, then the operator space Aop from 1.2.25, is also an operator algebra for the reversed product ◦ defined on A by a ◦ b = ba. Indeed, if A is a subalgebra of a C ∗ -algebra B, then Aop may be identified with the matching subalgebra of the C ∗ -algebra B op discussed in 1.2.25. We remark in passing that if A = Aop , and if A is approximately unital, then A is commutative. This follows quickly from one of our later ‘Banach-Stone theorems’ (e.g. see 4.5.13) applied to the identity map from A to Aop . Similarly, the adjoint operator space A (written also as A∗ when there is no possible confusion with the dual space) from 1.2.25, is an operator algebra, with product a∗ b∗ = (ba)∗ , for a, b ∈ A. Indeed if A is a subalgebra of a C ∗ -algebra B, then A may be identified with the subalgebra {a∗ : a ∈ A} of B. Note that if A has a cai (et )t , then (e∗t )t is a cai for A∗ . If π : A → B is a completely contractive homomorphism between operator algebras, then the canonical completely contractive mappings π op : Aop → B op and π : A → B from 1.2.25 also are homomorphisms. In particular, given a completely contractive representation π : A → B(H), we obtain a canonical completely contractive representation π : A → B(H). It easily follows from Lemma 2.1.9 that if A is approximately unital and π is nondegenerate, then π ∗ is nondegenerate as well. 2.2.9 Let X ⊂ B(H) be an operator space acting on some Hilbert space H. Then the operator space defined inside B(H ⊕ H) = M2 (B(H)) as 0 x : x∈X 0 0 is completely isometric to X. It is also a subalgebra of B(H (2) ), with trivial (i.e. zero) product. Thus any operator space may be regarded as an operator algebra. 2.2.10 The last construction has a unital version which turns out to be much more useful. Again we consider an operator space X ⊂ B(H) acting on some Hilbert space H. We define λ1 x (2.10) : x ∈ X, λ1 , λ2 ∈ C ⊂ B(H ⊕ H), U(X) = 0 λ2
Basic theory of operator algebras
61
where λ1 and λ2 stand for the operators λ1 IH and λ2 IH respectively. By definition, U (X) may be regarded as a subspace of the Paulsen system S(X) defined in 1.3.14. It therefore follows from 1.3.15 that as an operator space, U(X) only depends on X and not on the Hilbert space H on which it acts. For any x, y ∈ X and any λ1 , λ2 , µ1 , µ2 ∈ C, we have λ1 x µ1 y λ1 µ1 λ1 y + µ2 x = . 0 λ2 0 µ2 0 λ2 µ2 Hence U(X) is a subalgebra of B(H (2) ), and the multiplication on U(X) does not depend on H. Thus U(X) is a unital operator algebra whose definition only depends on X. The norm on U(X) also only depends on the norm on X (and not on the full operator space structure of X), as we shall see below. Proposition 2.2.11 Let X and Y be operator spaces, and let u : X → Y be a linear contraction (resp. complete contraction). Then the mapping θ u from U(X) to U(Y ) defined by " # λ1 x λ1 u(x) θu = , x ∈ X, λ1 , λ2 ∈ C, 0 λ2 0 λ2 is a contractive (resp. completely contractive) homomorphism. Proof It is clear that θu is a homomorphism. The ‘complete contraction case’ follows immediately from 1.3.15. To see the ‘contraction case’, we explicitly compute the norm of a matrix in U(X). We have λ1 x 2 2 2 2 2 2 0 λ2 = sup λ1 ζ + xη + |λ2 | η : ζ + η ≤ 1 . Here ζ, η ∈ H, where H is a Hilbert space on which X is represented completely isometrically. It is easily seen that this last quantity equals 2
sup |λ1 | 1 − η2 + xη + |λ2 |2 η2 : η ≤ 1 , (the being obvious, and the other is obtainable by letting ζ equal one inequality xη eiθ 1 − η2 xη
, for real θ). In turn the last centered quantity equals 2
sup |λ1 | 1 − t2 + xη + |λ2 |2 t2 : t ∈ [0, 1], η = t 2
= sup |λ1 | 1 − t2 + xt +|λ2 |2 t2 : t ∈ [0, 1] . This last expression, for fixed λ1 , λ2 , may be regarded as a function f (x). Since f is an increasing function, the desired result follows easily. 2 Corollary 2.2.12 If X and Y are two isometric (resp. completely isometric) operator spaces, then U(X) and U(Y ) are isometric (resp. completely isometric) operator algebras.
62
The abstract characterization of operator algebras
Proof We need only prove the isometric case. Given an isometric isomorphism J : X → Y , apply Lemma 2.2.11 to J and J −1 to obtain that uJ : U (X) → U(Y ) is an invertible isometric homomorphism. 2 2.2.13 (Ultraproducts) Let U be an ultrafilter on a set I, and consider a family of operator algebras (Ai )i∈I . We let A be their ultraproduct along U, as defined in 1.2.31. Assume that each Ai is a subalgebra of some B(Hi ). Then it follows from the last few results in 1.2.31 that A is an operator algebra, a subalgebra of the C ∗ -algebra i∈I B(Hi )/U. Clearly A is unital if each Ai is unital. 2.3 THE ABSTRACT CHARACTERIZATION OF OPERATOR ALGEBRAS The main result of this section is Theorem 2.3.2, usually referred to as the BRS theorem. This fundamental result gives a criterion for a unital (or more generally an approximately unital) Banach algebra with an operator space structure, to be an operator algebra. Among other things, the BRS theorem allows one to check that abstract constructions with operator algebras remain operator algebras. We discuss some of the most important such constructions later in this section. 2.3.1 Recall from 2.2.3 that if A is an operator algebra, and if n ≥ 1 is an integer, then Mn (A) is an operator algebra with product given by (2.7). In particular it is a Banach algebra, so that the product on A is a completely contractive bilinear map in the sense described in 1.5.4. This is equivalent (since the Haagerup tensor product linearizes completely bounded bilinear maps—see 1.5.4) to saying that the multiplication mapping m : A ⊗ A → A on A extends to a completely contractive mapping on the Haagerup tensor product A ⊗h A. That is, m : A ⊗h A −→ A ≤ 1. (2.11) cb The BRS theorem asserts that this property characterizes operator algebras, at least for unital or approximately unital algebras. We will see in 5.3.6 that this characterization may fail without the approximately unital assumption. Theorem 2.3.2 (BRS theorem) Let A be an operator space which is also an approximately unital Banach algebra. Let m : A ⊗ A → A denote the multiplication on A. The following are equivalent: (i) The mapping m : A ⊗h A −→ A is completely contractive. (ii) For any n ≥ 1, Mn (A) is a Banach algebra. That is, n aik bkj k=1
Mn (A)
≤ [aij ]M
n (A)
[bij ] M
n (A)
for any [aij ] and [bij ] in Mn (A). (iii) A is an operator algebra, that is, there exist a Hilbert space H and a completely isometric homomorphism π : A → B(H).
Basic theory of operator algebras
63
Proof The equivalence between (i) and (ii), and that (iii) implies these, was mentioned in 2.3.1. To see that (i) and/or (ii) implies (iii), we let A be as in (i), and we will first assume that A is unital, with identity e of norm 1. Fix a complete isometry u0 : A → B(H0 ), for some Hilbert space H0 , and apply Theorem 1.5.7 (1) to the mapping u0 m : A ⊗h A → B(H0 ). We obtain a Hilbert space H1 , and two completely contractive mappings u1 : A → B(H0 , H1 ) and v1 : A → B(H1 , H0 ), such that u0 m(b, a) = v1 (b)u1 (a) for any a, b ∈ A. Since mcb ≤ 1 and u1 cb ≤ 1, the mapping u1 m : A ⊗h A → B(H0 , H1 ) is completely contractive. By Theorem 1.5.7 (1) again, we may factor u 1 m as well as a product of two mappings defined on A. Proceeding by induction, we obtain that for any k ≥ 1, there exist a Hilbert space Hk , and two completely contractive mappings uk : A → B(H0 , Hk ) and vk : A → B(Hk , Hk−1 ), such that uk m(b, a) = vk+1 (b) uk+1 (a)
k ≥ 0, a, b ∈ A.
(2.12)
For k ∈ N define a seminorm | · |k on the algebraic tensor product A ⊗ H0 by ai ⊗ ξi = uk (ai )ξi k
i
Hk
i
for any finite families (ai )i in A and (ξi )i in H0 . These seminorms satisfy the following key inequalities. For any integers k ≥ 0, n ≥ 1, m ≥ 1, and for any [bpq ] ∈ Mn (A), [aij ] ∈ Mn,m (A), [ξij ] ∈ Mn,m (H0 ), we have 2 2 2 m(bpq , aqi ) ⊗ ξqi ≤ [bpq ]Mn (A) aqi ⊗ ξqi p
k
q,i
q
.
(2.13)
k+1
i
Indeed according to the definition of | · |k , we have 2 2 m(bpq , aqi ) ⊗ ξqi = uk m(bpq , aqi )ξqi p
k
q,i
p
q,i
p
q,i
2 = vk+1 (bpq )uk+1 (aqi )ξqi
by (2.12)
2 2 ≤ [vk+1 (bpq )] uk+1 (aqi )ξqi q
i
2 2 = [vk+1 (bpq )] aqi ⊗ ξqi q
i
.
k+1
Since vk+1 is completely contractive, this yields (2.13). Applying (2.13) with n = 1 and b11 = e, we see that ai ⊗ ξi ≤ ai ⊗ ξi i
k
i
k+1
64
The abstract characterization of operator algebras
for any finite families (ai )i in A and (ξi )i in H0 . This monotonicity allows us to define a new seminorm | · |∞ on A ⊗ H0 by letting ai ⊗ ξi = lim ai ⊗ ξi = sup ai ⊗ ξi . ∞
i
k→∞
k
i
k
i
k
Passing to the limit in (2.13), we clearly obtain that 2 2 2 m(bpq , aqi ) ⊗ ξqi ≤ [bpq ]Mn (A) aqi ⊗ ξqi p
∞
q,i
q
i
∞
(2.14)
for any [bpq ] ∈ Mn (A), [aqi ] ∈ Mn,m (A), and [ξqi ] ∈ Mn,m (H0 ). Now observe that | · |∞ is a prehilbertian seminorm. Indeed each Hk is a Hilbert space, hence |·|k is prehilbertian for any k ≥ 0. Thus each |·|k satisfies the parallelogram identity. Passing to the limit, we obtain that |·|∞ also satisfies this identity, which proves the observation. We may therefore define a Hilbert space H by first taking the quotient of A⊗ H0 by the kernel N = {z ∈ A⊗ H0 : |z|∞ = 0} and then completing the resulting normed space (A ⊗ H0 )/N . Using (2.14) with n = 1, we see that for any b ∈ A, one may define a bounded linear mapping π(b) : H → H with π(b) ≤ b by letting ˙ ˙ ai ⊗ ξi +N m(b, ai ) ⊗ ξi +N, π(b) = ai ∈ A, ξi ∈ H0 . i
i
Then applying (2.14) with arbitrary n ≥ 1, we find that the resulting linear mapping π : A → B(H) is actually a complete contraction. Since m is a multiplication our mapping π is clearly a homomorphism. That π is a complete isometry now reduces to showing that [bpq ] ≤ [π(bpq )] (2.15) for n ≥ 1 and [bpq ] ∈ Mn (A). Assume that [bpq ] > 1. Since u0 : A → B(H0 ) is a complete isometry, there exist ξ1 , . . . , ξn ∈ H0 such that 2 ξi 2 = 1 and u0 (bpq )ξq > 1. p
i
q
Since the sequence of seminorms | · |k is nondecreasing, for any p we have bpq ⊗ ξq ≥ bpq ⊗ ξq = u0 (bpq )ξq . ∞
q
q
0
q
˙ ) = b ⊗ ξ +N ˙ for b ∈ A and ξ ∈ H0 , we have Using the identity π(b)(e ⊗ ξ +N 2 ˙ π(bpq ) e ⊗ ξq +N > 1. p
q
Basic theory of operator algebras
65
On the other hand, since e = 1 and each uk is a contraction, we have e ⊗ ξq +N ˙ 2 = lim uk (e)ξq 2 ≤ ξq 2 = 1. k
q
q
q
This shows that [π(bpq )] > 1 and hence the inequality (2.15), which concludes our proof in the unital case. Finally, we consider the case that A is nonunital, but has a cai (et )t . Let A1 = A ⊕ C be the Banach algebraic unitization of A considered in A.4.3, with unit denoted by e. More generally, we define matrix norms on A1 by letting
[aij + λij e] [aij c + λij c] = sup : c ∈ A, c ≤ 1 (2.16) 1 M (A ) M (A) n
n
for any integer n ≥ 1 and for any matrices [aij ] ∈ Mn (A) and [λij ] ∈ Mn . By 1.2.16 these matrix norms satisfy Ruan’s axioms 1.2.12, and hence define an operator space structure on A1 . Moreover for any [aij ] ∈ Mn (A) we have [aij ] = lim [aij et ] ≤ sup [aij c] ≤ [aij ]. t
c ≤1
Thus we may regard A as a subalgebra of A1 completely isometrically. Given [aij ], [bij ] ∈ Mn (A) and [λij ], [µij ] ∈ Mn , note that by (2.16), [aij + λij e][bij + µij e] = sup [aij + λij e][bij c + µij c] : c ∈ Ball(A) , M (A) n
Moreover, given any c ∈ A we have [aij + λij e][bij c + µij c] = lim [aij et + λij et ][bij c + µij c]Mn (A) . Mn (A) t
If Mn (A) is a Banach algebra, we deduce that [aij et + λij et ][bij c + µij c] [aij + λij e][bij c + µij c] ≤ sup Mn (A) t ≤ [aij + λij e][bij c + µij c] by (2.16). Taking the supremum over all c ∈ A with c ≤ 1, shows that M n (A1 ) is a Banach algebra. By the first part of the proof (the unital case), we see that 2 A1 is an operator algebra, and hence so too is its subalgebra A. 2.3.3 (Applications) We now apply the BRS theorem to show that various natural constructions produce operator algebras. As a first example, we note that in analogy to 1.2.16, we may define an operator algebra seminorm structure on a unital algebra A. Namely, this is an operator seminorm structure in the sense of 1.2.16, such that 11 = 1, and such that the nth seminorm is submultiplicative for every n ∈ N. We let N be the nullspace of ·1 as usual. An argument similar to the one in 1.2.16, but using the BRS theorem instead of Ruan’s theorem, shows that (the completion of) A/N is a unital operator algebra.
66
The abstract characterization of operator algebras
We apply this principle to suprema and limsup’s of operator algebra structures, just as we did in 1.2.16. Suppose that A is a unital algebra, that Λ is a set, and that for each k ∈ Λ we have a unital operator algebra Bk and a unital homomorphism πk : A → Bk . We suppose that for all a ∈ A, the quantity sup{πk (a) : k ∈ Λ} is finite. We may then define an operator algebra seminorm structure on A by an = sup (πk )n (a)n k
for a ∈ Mn (A). By the last paragraph, (the completion of) a quotient of A is an operator algebra with these matrix norms. If Λ is a directed set, then replacing the sup by lim sup in the last equation yields another operator algebra. Throughout this book, a closed two-sided ideal of an operator algebra will simply be called an ideal. Long before the field of operator spaces arose, it was known that if J is an ideal of an operator algebra A, then the quotient algebra A/J is isometrically isomorphic to an operator algebra (see the Notes section for references). This fact follows as an immediate corollary of the BRS theorem: Proposition 2.3.4 Let J be an ideal in an operator algebra A. Equip the quotient Banach algebra A/J with its quotient operator space structure (see 1.2.14). Then A/J is an operator algebra. That is, there exist a Hilbert space H and a completely isometric homomorphism π : A/J → B(H). Proof Assume that A is a subalgebra of B(K). Then J is also an ideal of the unital operator algebra A1 = Span{A, IK }; and the canonical embedding A/J ⊂ A1 /J is both a complete isometry and a homomorphism. Replacing A with A1 if necessary, we may therefore assume that A is unital. Then A/J is unital, and hence it suffices to show that A/J satisfies the assertion (ii) of Theorem 2.3.2. This is readily seen from the fact that A satisfies (ii), and from the definition of the quotient operator space structure. 2 2.3.5 (Factor theorem) As in 1.2.15, it follows that if π : A → B is a completely bounded homomorphism, and if J is an ideal in A contained in Ker(π), then π descends to a homomorphism A/J → B with a ‘cb-norm’ which is no larger than that of π. 2.3.6 (Interpolation) We shall apply Proposition 2.3.4 to the complex interpolation of operator algebras. We first need a few facts concerning interpolation of Banach algebras. Consider a compatible couple of Banach spaces (A0 , A1 ) and recall from 1.2.30 the definition of the ‘interpolation space’ Aθ = [A0 , A1 ]θ for θ ∈ (0, 1). If A0 and A1 are Banach algebras, if A0 + A1 is a C-Banach algebra for some C ≥ 1, and if the embeddings A0 → A0 + A1 and A1 → A0 + A1 are both homomorphisms, then we say that (A0 , A1 ) is a compatible couple of Banach algebras. These conditions roughly mean that our two Banach algebras A0 and A1 have a ‘common multiplication’. In this case, this multiplication is both a contractive bilinear map from A0 × A0 into A0 and from A1 × A1 into A1 ; hence by interpolation, the multiplication extends to a contractive bilinear
Basic theory of operator algebras
67
map Aθ × Aθ → Aθ for any θ ∈ (0, 1). Each Aθ is therefore a Banach algebra for this common multiplication. The Banach algebra structure of Aθ has a useful alternative description in terms of quotients. Indeed, consider the Banach space F = F(A0 , A1 ) defined in 1.2.30 (for A0 = X0 and A1 = X1 ), and observe that F is an algebra for the pointwise multiplication. Then the space F θ = {f ∈ F : f (θ) = 0} ⊂ F is an ideal of F and we may therefore consider the quotient algebra F/F θ . Then it is clear that the isometric identification Aθ = F/F θ
(2.17)
provided by (1.23) holds at the algebraic level. Indeed if x = f (θ) and y = g(θ) are two arbitrary elements of Aθ , with f, g ∈ F, then xy = f (θ)g(θ) = (f g)(θ). If (A0 , A1 ) is a compatible couple of Banach algebras and if A0 and A1 are operator algebras, then we will say that (A0 , A1 ) is a compatible couple of operator algebras. In that case, Aθ = [A0 , A1 ]θ is both a Banach algebra (by the above discussion), and an operator space (by 1.2.30). Proposition 2.3.7 Let (A0 , A1 ) be a compatible couple of operator algebras. Then Aθ = [A0 , A1 ]θ is an operator algebra for any θ ∈ (0, 1). Proof We fix some θ ∈ (0, 1) and apply 1.2.30 and 2.3.6. The embedding F ⊂ C0 (R; A0 ) ⊕∞ C0 (R; A1 ) is obviously a homomorphism; hence F is an operator algebra by 2.2.4. Thus Aθ is an operator algebra by (2.17) and 2.3.4. 2 2.3.8 (Direct limits) A similar construction to 2.3.3 yields the direct (or inverse) limit of operator algebras. There are several variants on this, for simplicity we sketch only the case of unital operator algebras and unital maps. Let Λ be a directed set, suppose that we have operator algebras An for each n ∈ Λ, and suppose that for each m ≥ n we have completely contractive unital homomorphisms πmn : An → Am with the property that πmn πnk = πmk . We suppose that πnn is the identity map, for all n. We consider the disjoint union of the An ’s, and take equivalence classes under the relation x ≡ y if and only if x ∈ An , y ∈ Am , and there exists a k ∈ Λ with πkn (x) = πkm (y). Of course addition and multiplication is well-defined on equivalence classes. Define a matrix seminorm structure on the set of equivalence classes by [xij ] = lim supm {[πmn (xij )]}, where n is such that xij ∈ An for all i, j. We quotient by the nullspace of this seminorm, and denote the resulting space by lim An . Appealing to the BRS theorem in a similar → way to 2.3.3, we find that this space is again an operator algebra. We write i n for the canonical completely contractive unital homomorphism An → lim An . We → leave as an exercise the fact that the algebra lim An has the appropriate ‘direct →
limit universal property’ (analoguous to that in [368] or Appendix L in [423]).
68
Universal constructions of operator algebras
2.3.9 (Matrix normed algebras) Let A be a Banach algebra which is also an operator space. We say that A is a matrix normed algebra if [bkl ] [aij bkl ] ≤ [aij ] Mmp (A)
Mn (A)
Mp (A)
for [aij ] ∈ Mn (A) and [bkl ] ∈ Mp (A). In this definition, the rows of [aij bkl ] are indexed by (i, k), whereas its columns are indexed by (j, l). From 1.5.11 the latter condition is equivalent to saying that the multiplication mapping m : A ⊗ A → A extends to a completely contractive mapping on A ⊗ A. That is, m : A ⊗ A −→ A ≤ 1. cb Since the operator space projective tensor norm dominates the Haagerup tensor norm (1.5.13), any operator algebra is a matrix normed algebra. The converse however is far from being true. Indeed note that if A is a Banach algebra, then Max(A) is a matrix normed algebra, as is clear from the identity 1.5.12 (1). Thus any Banach algebra may be regarded as a matrix normed algebra. However of course most Banach algebras are not isomorphic to an operator algebra (e.g. see 5.1.5 for more on this issue). A good example of a matrix normed algebra is CB(X) for an operator space X. With its canonical matrix norms (1.6) it is fairly obvious that CB(X) is a matrix normed algebra. However we shall see in 5.1.9 that if CB(X) is an operator algebra then X must be a Hilbert space. 2.4 UNIVERSAL CONSTRUCTIONS OF OPERATOR ALGEBRAS Various classical universal constructions in the C ∗ -theory have natural extensions to the nonselfadjoint framework. In this section we will present some of these, and show as an application of the BRS theorem that they may be characterized ‘internally’ in terms of certain ‘factorization formulae’. For example, following [67], we will consider the universal operator algebra of a semigroup, and the free product of operator algebras. Some other universal constructions will appear later on in the book (for example, the maximal tensor product of operator algebras will be discussed in Chapter 6). 2.4.1 (Ordering and isomorphism of C ∗ -covers) Let A be an operator algebra. If (B, j) and (B , j ) are C ∗ -covers of A (see 2.1.1), we then declare (B, j) ≤ (B , j ) if and only if there is a ∗-homomorphism π : B → B such that π ◦ j = j. By A.5.8, such a ∗-homomorphism π is automatically surjective and unique (this is because the ∗-algebra generated by A is dense in both B and B , and π is uniquely determined there, and is surjective). We say that (B, j) is A-isomorphic to (B , j ) if a π exists as above which is also one-to-one (and therefore a ∗-isomorphism by A.5.8). This is an equivalence relation, and we define C(A) to be the set of equivalence classes of C ∗ -covers of A, with the ordering above. In this ordering, we will see next that there is a largest element of C(A). This C ∗ -cover we think
Basic theory of operator algebras
69
of as the noncommutative maximal ideal space of A. It is much more difficult (see Section 4.3) to see that there is a smallest element of C(A) in this ordering, known as the C ∗ -envelope of A. Proposition 2.4.2 Let A be an operator algebra. Then there exists a C ∗ -cover ∗ (A), j) of A with the following universal property: if π : A → D is any (Cmax completely contractive homomorphism into a C ∗ -algebra D, then there exists a ∗ (A) → D such that π ˜ ◦ j = π. (necessarily unique) ∗-homomorphism π ˜ : Cmax Proof It suffices to assume that D = B(H), for a Hilbert space H. Suppose that the cardinality of A is less than or equal to a cardinal β that we choose such that β ℵ0 = β. Define F to be the set of completely contractive representations π : A → B(2J ) where J varies over the cardinals which are less than or equal to β. We write Hπ = 2J . Define j = ⊕ {π : π ∈ F}, that is, j(a) = ⊕π∈F π(a) for all a ∈ A. This is a completely contractive representation of A on a Hilbert space Hmax = ⊕π∈F Hπ . In fact j is also completely isometric, as may be seen by standard arguments. The projection of Hmax onto its ‘πth coordinate’ will be ∗ (A), or C ∗ (A) for brevity, to be the C ∗ -algebra written as Pπ . We define Cmax inside B(Hmax ) generated by j(A). Note that if θ : A → B(H) is any completely contractive representation of A, with dim(H) ≤ β, then there is a unitary U on H such that ρ = U ∗ θ(·)U ∈ F. Define ρ˜ : C ∗ (A) → B(Hρ ) to be ρ˜(T ) = Pρ T|Hρ . Then ρ˜ is a ∗-homomorphism defined on C ∗ (A), and ρ˜ ◦ j = ρ. Then θ˜ = U ρ˜(·)U ∗ is a ∗-homomorphism C ∗ (A) → B(H), and θ˜ ◦ j = θ. Clearly θ˜ is the unique such ∗-homomorphism. Thus we have shown that C ∗ (A) has the desired universal property, but for extending completely contractive representations of A on Hilbert spaces of dimension ≤ β. From this fact it is not hard to show that C ∗ (A) has this universal property when H has arbitrary dimension. We briefly sketch the argument. For π : A → B(H) as above, we let J0 be a set whose cardinality is equal to dim(H). Then we consider the set G of pairs (J, {Kj }j∈J ), where J is a subset of J0 , the Kj ’s are mutually orthogonal nonzero subspaces of H with dim(Kj ) ≤ β for any j ∈ J, and each Kj is reducing for π(A). Recall that this means that Kj is invariant for both π(A) and π(A)∗ . The set G has a natural order, namely (J, {Kj }j∈J ) ≤ (J , {Kj }j∈J ) if J ⊂ J and Kj = Kj for any j ∈ J. Applying a routine Zorn’s lemma argument, we see that G has a maximal element (J, {Kj }j∈J ). Since we supposed that Card(A) ≤ β and β ℵ0 = β, it is not hard to check that ⊕j Kj = H. Indeed if x ∈ H is orthogonal to each Kj , and if C ⊂ B(H) is the C ∗ -algebra generated by π(A), then [Cx] is reducing for π(A) and has dimension less than or equal to β. This is a contradiction. We leave the details to the reader, Thus π may be written as a direct sum of a family of completely contractive representations on Hilbert spaces of dimension ≤ β. Now it is clear that π has the desired extension π ˜. 2 ∗ (A) in 2.4.2 is called the 2.4.3 (The maximal C ∗ -algebra) The algebra Cmax ∗ maximal or universal C -algebra of A. Algebraically, the universal property in
70
Universal constructions of operator algebras
∗ 2.4.2 is saying that the functor A → Cmax (A) is the left adjoint to the forgetful ∗ functor from the category of C -algebras to the category of operator algebras. ∗ (A), j) is unital and it is easy to check that it is If A is unital, then (Cmax also characterized by the following universal property: if π : A → D is any unital completely contractive homomorphism into a unital C ∗ -algebra D, then there ∗ exists a (necessarily unique and unital) ∗-representation π ˆ : Cmax (A) → D such that π ˆ ◦ j = π. ∗ (A1 ) is the maximal It is also worth noticing that if A is not unital and if Cmax ∗ ∗ C -algebra of its unitization, then Cmax (A) coincides with the C ∗ -subalgebra of ∗ Cmax (A1 ) generated by A. Indeed let C be the latter C ∗ -algebra and let j be ∗ (A1 ). We consider a completely contractive the canonical embedding A1 → Cmax representation π : A → B(H). By Meyer’s theorem 2.1.13 there is a completely contractive unital homomorphism π 0 : A1 → B(H) extending π. By the universal ∗ ∗ (A1 ), there is a ∗-homomorphism ρ : Cmax (A1 ) → B(H) such property of Cmax 0 that ρ ◦ j = π . The restriction of ρ to C is the desired extension of π.
2.4.4 (The universal representation) We define the universal representation πu of a possibly nonselfadjoint operator algebra A to be the restriction of the ∗ (A) to A. universal representation (see A.5.5) of Cmax 2.4.5 (An example) Consider A = T2 , the upper triangular 2 × 2 matrices. According to Corollary 2.2.12, A = U(C) is completely isometrically isomorphic to the subalgebra of M2 (C([0, 1])) defined as % $ √ λ1 µ · : λ1 , λ2 , µ ∈ C ⊂ M2 (C[0, 1]), 0 λ2 √ where · is the square root function on [0, 1]. We henceforth identify A with this ∗ (A) = {f ∈ M2 (C([0, 1])) : f (0) is a diagonal matrix}. subalgebra. Claim: Cmax We will prove this claim by showing that the last C ∗ -algebra has the property of Proposition 2.4.2. First we observe that the ∗-algebra E generated by A is dense in the space of matrices of the form √ b√ 1 b2 · b3 · b4 with bi ∈ C([0, 1]), and the latter space is dense in the algebra of functions f ∈ M2 (C([0, 1])) such that f (0) is a diagonal matrix. Then we consider a nondegenerate (completely) contractive representation π : A → B(L) on some Hilbert space L. This immediately gives a decomposition of L as a Hilbert space sum H ⊕ K say, and operator T : K → H, namely T = π(E12 ), so a contractive √ λ1 µ · λ1 IH µT that π maps any in A to . It is easily checked that 0 λ2 0 λ2 IK √ b1 (T T ∗ ) b2 (T T ∗ )T b√ 1 b2 · , bi ∈ C([0, 1]), −→ θ : b3 · b4 T ∗ b3 (T T ∗ ) b4 (T ∗ T )
Basic theory of operator algebras
71
is a ∗-homomorphism from E into B(H ⊕ K) = B(L). Also, θ is bounded; for √ 1 example, b2 (T T ∗ )T = b2 (T T ∗ )(T T ∗ ) 2 ≤ b2 ·C([0,1]) by spectral theory. Hence θ extends to a ∗-homomorphism on the containing C ∗ -algebra. 2.4.6 (The enveloping operator algebra of a Banach algebra) This is an analogue of the well-known enveloping C ∗ -algebra of an involutive Banach algebra. We shall only consider unital algebras for the sake of simplicity. Let B be a unital Banach algebra which is also an operator space. We let I be the collection of all unital completely contractive homomorphisms π : B → B(H), H = Hπ being a Hilbert space. For any integer n ≥ 1 and any matrix b ∈ Mn (B), we define
|||b|||n = sup πn (b)Mn (B(H)) : π ∈ I . It is easy to see that each ||| · |||n is a seminorm on Mn (B), and that they define an ‘operator algebra seminorm structure’ on B in the sense of 2.3.3. We let O(B) denote the resulting operator algebra obtained by the procedure of 2.3.3 (namely, the completion of the quotient of B by the nullspace of |||·|||1 ). We will call O(B) the enveloping operator algebra of B. 2.4.7 (Universal property of O(B)) For B as above, there is a canonical completely contractive and unital homomorphism i : B → O(B), whose range is dense, and (O(B), i) has the following property: for any unital operator algebra A and for any unital completely contractive homomorphism π : B → A, there exists a (necessarily unique) unital completely contractive homomorphism π ˜ : O(B) → A such that π ˜ ◦i = π. It is easy to see that this property characterizes O(B) uniquely, up to appropriate isomorphism. Next we use the BRS theorem to give an alternative description of the enveloping operator algebra O(B) in terms of factorization matrix norms. We will then see some surprising applications of this. Proposition 2.4.8 Let B be a unital Banach algebra which is also an operator space. For n ∈ N and b ∈ Mn (B), we have (with the notation from 2.4.6) (2.18) |||b|||n = inf b1 b2 · · · bN , the infimum over all integers N ≥ 1 and all possible factorizations of b in the form b = b1 b2 · · · bN , with b1 ∈ Mn,k1 (B), b2 ∈ Mk1 ,k2 (B), . . . , bN ∈ MkN −1 ,n (B) for some positive integers k1 , k2 , . . . , kN −1 . Proof For any N ≥ 1, let ZN = B ⊗ · · · ⊗ B be the N -fold tensor product of N copies of B. Let mN : ZN → B be the N -fold multiplication defined by letting mN (b1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ bN ) = b1 · · · bN for any b1 , . . . , bN ∈ B, and then extending by linearity. We write m1 for the identity map on B. Then it follows from (1.40) that the right-hand side of (2.18) is equal to
|b|n = inf inf zh : z ∈ Mn (ZN ), IMn ⊗ mN (z) = b . N ≥1
72
Universal constructions of operator algebras
Fix b, b ∈ Mn (B), for some n ≥ 1, and let ε > 0 be an arbitrary positive number. For some integers N, N ≥ 1, there exist elements z in Mn (ZN ) and z in Mn (ZN ) such that IMn ⊗ mN (z) = b, IMn ⊗ mN (z ) = b , zh < ε+ |b|n , z z as an element of Mn (ZN +N ), we have and z h < ε + |b |n . Regarding IMn ⊗ mN +N (z z ) = bb . Thus |bb |n ≤ z z h ≤ zhz h ≤ ε + |b|n ε + |b |n . Since ε > 0 was arbitrary, we have proved that |bb |n ≤ |b|n |b |n ,
b, b ∈ Mn (B), n ≥ 1.
(2.19)
By adding on identity matrices decomposition of z (or z ), we can in the tensor assume that N = N . Then IMn ⊗ mN (z + z ) = b + b , and so |b + b |n ≤ z + z h ≤ zh + z h ≤ 2ε + |b|n + |b |n . Since ε is arbitrary, | · |n is subadditive. Similar arguments show that the quantities | · |n define an operator algebra seminorm structure in the sense of 2.3.3, simply because the Haagerup matrix norms on each ZN satisfy Ruan’s axioms (see 1.2.12), and because of (2.19). Thus, by 2.3.3, the completion of the quotient of B by the nullspace of the seminorm, is an operator algebra A. We shall now prove (2.18). First note that the canonical map i : B → A is a unital completely contractive homomorphism. Thus the universal property of O(B) ensures that ||| · |||n dominates | · |n , for each n ≥ 1. On the other hand, suppose that b ∈ Mn (B), and let π : B → B(H) be a unital completely contractive homomorphism. If b = IMn ⊗ mN (z) for some z ∈ Mn (ZN ), then b ∈ Mn (B) and πn (b) = IMn ⊗πmN (z). Since πmN : B ⊗· · ·⊗B → B(H) is the linear mapping which takes b1 ⊗· · ·⊗bN to π(b1 ) · · · π(bN ) for any b1 , . . . , bN ∈ B, by the first paragraph in 1.5.8, we have that πmN is completely contractive on B ⊗h · · · ⊗h B. Hence πn (b) ≤ zh. It therefore follows from the definitions 2 of ||| · |||n and | · |n , that we have |||b|||n ≤ |b|n . 2.4.9 (The semigroup operator algebra) Let G be a discrete semigroup. The space 1G of summable families indexed by G, is a unital Banach algebra with the convolution product (e.g. see [106]). We define the semigroup operator algebra O(G) of G to be the enveloping operator algebra O(Max( 1G )). There is an obvious bijective correspondence between the contractive representations σ : G → B(H), the unital contractive homomorphisms π : 1G → B(H), and the unital completely contractive homomorphisms π : Max(1G ) → B(H). According to these correspondences, the matrix norms on O(G) may be described as follows. Let (eg )g∈G denote the canonical basis of 1G , and let C[G] = Span{eg : g ∈ G} be the semigroup algebra of G. Then for b = g λg ⊗ eg ∈ Mn ⊗ C[G], with λg ∈ Mn , we have
Basic theory of operator algebras |||b|||n = sup λg ⊗ σ(g) g
73
Mn (B(H))
where the supremum runs over all contractive representations σ : G → B(H). According to 2.4.7, the operator algebra O(G) is characterized by the following universal property. There exists a contractive representation i : G → O(G) whose range generates O(G) as an operator algebra, such that: for any contractive representation σ : G → A into a unital operator algebra A, there exists a (necessarily unique) unital completely contractive homomorphism σ ˜ : O(B) → A such that σ ˜ ◦ i = σ. 2.4.10 If G is a group, then 1G has a natural involution b → b∗ . Regarding G ⊂ 1G via the map g → eg above, then this involution on 1G is simply the unique ∗-linear extension to 1G of the map g → g −1 on G. Suppose that π is a contractive group homomorphism G → B(H). Since π(g)π(g −1 ) = π(g −1 )π(g) = IH for any g ∈ G, it follows from the last assertion in 2.1.3 that π(g) is unitary, with π(g −1 ) = π(g)∗ . By the basic theory of representations, π extends to a contractive ∗-homomorphism 1G → B(H), and extends further to a ∗-homomorphism from the full group C ∗ -algebra of G, into B(H). By 1.2.4 this homomorphism is completely contractive. By the universal property in 2.4.9, it follows that O(G) coincides with the full group C ∗ -algebra of G. The next proposition is a strengthening of Proposition 2.4.8, in the case that B = Max(1G ) for a semigroup G. Since its proof is similar to that of Proposition 2.4.8, we omit it. Proposition 2.4.11 Let G be a discrete semigroup and let b ∈ Mn ⊗ C[G] for some n ≥ 1. Then |||b|||n = inf α0 α1 · · · αN , where the infimum runs over all possible product factorizations of b of the form b = α0 b1 α1 b2 · · · bN αN , where α0 ∈ Mn,k1 , α1 ∈ Mk1 ,k2 , . . . , αN ∈ MkN ,n are scalar matrices for some k1 , . . . , kN ∈ N, and b1 ∈ Mk1 (B), . . . , bN ∈ MkN (B) are diagonal matrices with entries in the set {eg : g ∈ G}. The latter factorization result is especially interesting in the case when G is either N0 (the additive semigroup of nonnegative integers), or N20 . Before coming to this, we need to review two important results from operator theory. 2.4.12 (Nagy’s dilation theorem) Let A(D) be the disc algebra from 2.2.6, and let P ⊂ A(D) denote the dense subalgebra of polynomials. Assume that T is a contraction on some Hilbert space H. Nagy’s dilation theorem [404, 405] asserts that there exists a Hilbert space K, an isometry J : H → K, and a unitary operator U ∈ B(K), such that T k = J ∗ U k J for any k ∈ N. Let π : C(T) → B(K) be the ∗-representation obtained by applying the spectral mapping theorem to U . That is, π(f ) = f (U ) for any f ∈ C(T). Then f (T ) = J ∗ π(f )J for any polynomial f . This shows that the mapping f ∈ P → f (T ) extends to a unital completely contractive homomorphism uT : A(D) → B(H).
74
Universal constructions of operator algebras
Any matrix [fij ] ∈ Mn (P) can be viewed as a matrix valued function, namely as the function f taking z to [fij (z)]. Moreover it follows from 2.2.5 that its norm as an element of Mn (A(D)) is equal to sup f (z)Mn : z ∈ D . Any such function f will be called a ‘matrix valued polynomial’ (in one variable). If f = k≥0 f (k) z k is the (finite) expansion of f , then uT (f ) = k≥0 f (k) ⊗ T k . Thus we have
≤ f Mn (A(D)) = sup : z∈D . f (k) ⊗ T k f (k) z k k≥0
Mn (B(H))
Mn
k≥0
This is a matricial version of von Neumann’s inequality (which is the case n = 1). 2.4.13 (Ando’s dilation theorem) Let A(D2 ) be the bidisc algebra, which may be defined to be the closure of the set P 2 = P ⊗P of polynomials in two variables, in C(T2 ). Equivalently (see 2.2.7), we have A(D2 ) = A(D) ⊗min A(D) = A(D; A(D)). Ando’s dilation theorem (see [9, 405]) extends Nagy’s theorem as follows. If T, S are two commuting contractions on a Hilbert space H, then there exist a Hilbert space K, an isometry J : H → K, and two commuting unitary operators U, V on K, such that T k S l = J ∗ U k V l J for any pair of nonnegative integers k and l. By a similar argument to that of 2.4.12, we deduce that the mapping f ∈ P 2 → f (T, S) extends to a unital completely contractive homomorphism uT,S : A(D2 ) → B(H). In particular, this yields a version of von Neumann’s inequality for pairs of commuting contractions. 2.4.14 (The semigroup operator algebras of N0 and N20 ) If σ : N0 → B(H) is a contractive representation of G = N0 on a Hilbert space H, then T = σ(1) is a contraction. Conversely, any contraction T ∈ B(H) gives rise to a contractive representation σ : N0 → B(H), defined by letting σ(k) = T k for any k ≥ 0. If we identify the algebra C[N0 ] with P in the usual way (ek = z k for any k ≥ 0), we deduce from this correspondence, 2.4.12, and the the last centered formula in 2.4.9 that O(N0 ) coincides with A(D) completely isometrically. Similarly, since contractive representations of N20 correspond to pairs of commuting contractions, it follows from 2.4.13 that O(N 20 ) = A(D2 ). In the following result, matrices are assumed to have (finite) sizes for which the matrix products make sense. Theorem 2.4.15 (1) For n ∈ N let f ∈ Mn (P) be a matrix valued polynomial. Then f (z)Mn < 1 for all z ∈ D if and only if there exists a factorization f (z) = α0 b1 (z)α1 b2 (z) · · · bN (z)αN ,
z ∈ C,
where α0 , α1 , . . . , αN are scalar matrices of norm < 1 and b1 , . . . , bN are diagonal matrices whose entries are of the form z k for (varying) k ∈ N.
Basic theory of operator algebras
75
(2) Let n ∈ N and f ∈ Mn (P 2 ) a matrix valued polynomial in two variables z and w. Then f (z, w)Mn < 1 for every (z, w) ∈ D2 , if and only if there exist matrix valued polynomials of one variable f1 , . . . , fN , g1 , . . . ∈ gN , with f (z, w) = f1 (z)g1 (w)f2 (z) · · · gN −1 (w)fN (z)gN (w),
(z, w) ∈ C2 ,
with fi (z) < 1 and gi (w) < 1 for any 1 ≤ i ≤ N , and any w, z ∈ D. Proof Taking 2.4.14 into account, the first assertion is a straightforward application of Proposition 2.4.11. For the second assertion, we only need to prove the ‘only if’ part. We let f ∈ Mn (P 2 ) be a matrix valued polynomial such that f (z, w)Mn < 1 for any (z, w) ∈ D2 . Applying Proposition 2.4.11 again, and the second paragraph of 2.4.14, we obtain a factorization of f of the form f (z, w) = α0 b1 (z, w)α1 b2 (z, w) · · · bN (z, w)αN ,
z, w ∈ C,
where α0 , α1 , . . . , αN are scalar matrices of norm < 1 and each bi is a diagonal matrix of the form bi (z, w) = Diag z n1 wm1 , z n2 wm2 , . . . , z nk wmk for some nonnegative integers n1 , m1 , n2 , . . . , mk . We write bi (z, w) = bi (z)bi (w), with bi (z) = Diag z n1 , z n2 , . . . , z nk and bi (w) = Diag wm1 , wm2 , . . . , wmk . Then f has the desired decomposition, with f1 = α0 b1 , fi = bi for any 2 ≤ i ≤ N , and gi = bi αi for any 1 ≤ i ≤ N . 2 2.4.16 (Free product of operator algebras) We now turn to another universal construction, the unital free product. We refer, for example, to [26, 368, 418] for some background on free products, in particular free products of unital algebras and free products of unital C ∗ -algebras. Let A and B be unital operator algebras, and let F(A, B) denote their unital algebra free product. This unital algebra is characterized by the following universal property. There exist unital one-to-one homomorphisms jA : A → F(A, B) and jB : B → F(A, B) such that jA (A) and jB (B) generate F(A, B) as an algebra, and such that: for any pair (π, ρ) of unital homomorphisms π : A → C and ρ : B → C into a unital algebra C, there exists a (necessarily unique) homomorphism π ∗ ρ : F(A, B) → C such that (π ∗ ρ) ◦ jA = π and (π ∗ ρ) ◦ jB = ρ. Let I be the collection of all pairs i = (π, ρ) of unital completely contractive homomorphisms π : A → B(H) and ρ : B → B(H), H = Hi being a Hilbert space. Then for any integer n ≥ 1 and any matrix y ∈ Mn (F(A, B)), we define
|||y|||n = sup IMn ⊗ (π ∗ ρ) (y)Mn (B(Hi )) : i = (π, ρ) ∈ I . It is easy to see that each ||| · |||n is a seminorm on Mn (F(A, B)). It turns out that ||| · |||n is actually a norm. This follows from [26] in the case when A and B are C ∗ -algebras. In the general case, let C and D be unital C ∗ -algebras such that A ⊂ C and B ⊂ D are unital-subalgebras and observe that by [26, Proposition
76
Universal constructions of operator algebras
2.1], the canonical embedding F(A, B) ⊂ F(C, D) is one-to-one. For any pair of ∗-representations π: C → and ρ : D → B(H) and any y ∈ Mn (F(A, B)), B(H) we have IMn ⊗ (π ∗ ρ) (y)Mn (B(H)) ≤ |||y|||n . Taking the supremum over all such possible pairs (π, ρ), we deduce from the above mentioned result in the C ∗ -algebra case, that y = 0 if |||y|||n = 0. We let A ∗ B be the completion of F(A, B) in the norm ||| · |||1 . Arguing as in 2.4.6, we see that A ∗ B is a unital operator algebra for the matrix norms (induced by) ||| · |||n . We call A ∗ B the unital free product of A and B. If A and B are unital C ∗ -algebras then A ∗ B coincides with the usual full amalgamated free product C ∗ -algebra, as may be seen using the above and A.5.8. 2.4.17 If A and B are two unital operator algebras, then there exists a pair of unital completely isometric homomorphisms π : A → B(H) and ρ : B → B(H), for a common Hilbert space H. Indeed if A and B are represented as unitalsubalgebras of B(H1 ) and B(H2 ) respectively, then take H = H1 ⊗2 H2 , and define π and ρ by letting π(a) = a⊗IH2 , and ρ(b) = IH1 ⊗b, for any a ∈ A, b ∈ B. It now follows from the centered equation in 2.4.16, that the embeddings jA and jB considered in 2.4.16 are unital completely isometric homomorphisms jA : A → A ∗ B
and
jB : B → A ∗ B.
From now on (except in the next item), we will suppress mention of jA and jB , and simply regard A and B as unital-subalgebras of A ∗ B. 2.4.18 (Universal property of the free product) It is clear that the unital free product operator algebra A ∗ B of A and B is characterized by the following property. There exist unital completely isometric homomorphisms jA : A → A∗B and jB : B → A∗B, whose ranges together generate A∗B as an operator algebra, such that: for any Hilbert space H and any pair (π, ρ) of unital completely contractive homomorphisms π : A → B(H) and ρ : B → B(H), there exists a (necessarily unique) unital completely contractive homomorphism π ∗ ρ from A ∗ B to B(H) such that (π ∗ ρ) ◦ jA = π and (π ∗ ρ) ◦ jB = ρ. One may use the BRS theorem to give the following description of the matrix norms on unital free products. The proof is similar to that of Proposition 2.4.8 (and Proposition 2.4.11), and is therefore omitted. Proposition 2.4.19 Let A and B be unital operator algebras, let F(A, B) be their unital algebra free product, and let y ∈ Mn (F (A, B)) for some n ≥ 1. Then zMn (A∗B) = inf a1 b1 a2 · · · aN bN , where the infimum runs over all N ∈ N and all possible factorizations of y of the form z = a1 b1 a2 · · · aN bN , with a1 ∈ Mn,k1 (A), b1 ∈ Mk1 ,l1 (B), a2 ∈ Ml1 ,k2 (A), . . . , aN ∈ MlN −1 ,kN (A), bN ∈ MkN ,n (B) , where k1 , l1 , k2 , . . . , lN −1 , kN ∈ N. Our next objective is Theorem 2.4.21, for which we will need the following: Proposition 2.4.20 Let A be a unital operator algebra.
Basic theory of operator algebras
77
(1) If u : A → B(H) is completely contractive then there exist a Hilbert space K, contractions V : H → K, W : K → H, and a unital completely contractive homomorphism π : A → B(K), such that u(a) = W π(a)V for a ∈ A. (2) Let B be a second unital operator algebra, and let u : A ⊗ h B → B(H) be a completely contractive map. Then there exist a Hilbert space K, two linear contractions V : H → K, W : K → H, and two unital completely contractive homomorphisms π : A → B(K) and ρ : B → B(K), such that we have u(a ⊗ b) = W π(a)ρ(b)V for any a ∈ A and b ∈ B. Proof Part (1) is an obvious consequence of 1.2.8, so that we only need to prove (2). If u : A ⊗h B → B(H) is completely contractive, then Theorem 1.5.7 (2) ensures that we can find Hilbert spaces K1 , K2 , and contractive linear operators V : H → K2 , R : K2 → K1 and W : K1 → H, as well as unital completely contractive homomorphism π : A → B(K1 ) and ρ : B → B(K2 ), such that u(a ⊗ b) = W π(a)Rρ(b)V,
a ∈ A, b ∈ B.
(2.20)
We shall now modify this factorization into the desired form. Note that in (2.20), without loss of generality we may replace K 1 and K2 with 2I (K1 ) and 2I (K2 ), for any set I. Indeed it suffices to replace W ∈ B(K1 , H) with the row matrix [W 0 0 · · · ] ∈ B(2I (K1 ), H), replace V ∈ B(H, K2 ) with the column [V 0 0 · · · ]t ∈ B(H, 2I (K2 )), and to replace π(a), R, and ρ(b), with their corresponding multiple ρ(a) ⊗ I2I , etc. Choosing a sufficiently large I, we may assume that K1 and K2 have the same dimension. Thus there exists a unitary U : K2 → K1 . Using this unitary we can write u(a⊗b) = W U U ∗ π(a)U U ∗ Rρ(b)V for a ∈ A and b ∈ B. Replacing W by W U , R by U ∗ R, and π by U ∗ π( )U , we therefore obtain that (2.20) holds true with K = K1 = K2 . Since R ∈ B(K) is a contraction, the operators I − RR ∗ and I − R∗ R are nonnegative. We may define a unitary Γ ∈ B(K ⊕ K) by the formula R (I − RR∗ )1/2 Γ= . −(I − R∗ R)1/2 R∗ Moreover for a ∈ A and b ∈ B, we can write π(a) 0 ρ(b) 0 V u(a ⊗ b) = W 0 Γ 0 π(a) 0 ρ(b) 0 π(a) 0 ρ(b) 0 V Γ . = W 0 Γ Γ∗ 0 π(a) 0 ρ(b) 0 V Replacing K by K ⊕ K, V by , ρ by ρ ⊕ ρ, π by Γ∗ π ⊕ π Γ, and W by 0 [ W 0 ]Γ, we see that (2.20) may be achieved with R = IK . 2 Besides A and B, the simplest subspace of A ∗ B is the linear span of all the products ab, for a ∈ A and b ∈ B. More specifically, note that the map (a, b) → ab from A × B to A ∗ B is bilinear, and therefore yields a canonical linearization E : A ⊗ B → A ∗ B. The range of this map has an attractive description:
78
The second dual algebra
Theorem 2.4.21 Let A and B be two unital operator algebras. Then the canonical map E : A⊗B → A∗B above extends to a complete isometry A⊗ h B → A∗B. Proof Fix y = k ak ⊗ bk ∈ A ⊗ B, with ak ∈ A and bk ∈ B. Then a b ∈ A ∗ B. Let θ : A ∗ B → B(H) be a completely isometric E(y) = k k k homomorphism for some suitable H, and let π = θ|A and ρ = θ|B be the corresponding (completely isometric) homomorphisms on A and B. Then E(y)A∗B = θ(E(y)) = π(ak )ρ(bk ) ≤ yA⊗h B k
by the fact at the end of the first paragraph in 1.5.4. Conversely, let u : A ⊗h B → B(H) be a completely isometric mapping for some suitable H. According to the second part of Proposition 2.4.20, we have a factorization of the form u(a ⊗ b) = W π(a)ρ(b)V for some contractions V ∈ B(H, K) and W ∈ B(K, H), and for some unital completely contractive homomorphisms π : A → B(K) and ρ : B → B(K). Then W π(ak )ρ(bk )V yA⊗h B = u(z) = k ≤ π(ak )ρ(bk ) ≤ E(y)A∗B k
by the universal property 2.4.18. This shows that A ⊗h B ⊂ A ∗ B isometrically. 2 A similar argument shows that A ⊗h B ⊂ A ∗ B completely isometrically. 2.5 THE SECOND DUAL ALGEBRA Passing to the second dual is a commonly used trick in C ∗ -algebra theory, as it allows one to work with von Neumann algebras and their various weak topologies. For similar purposes, it is important to understand the properties of the second dual A∗∗ of a nonselfadjoint operator algebra A, and thus we devote a section to this topic. We will not take for granted any facts about the second dual of a C ∗ -algebra not proved in this book, and will prove such facts as we go along. We begin with some background and notation on second duals of Banach algebras. 2.5.1 (Arens product) Let A be a Banach algebra. Then we may equip its second dual A∗∗ with two natural products as follows. Consider a ∈ A, ϕ ∈ A∗ , and η ∈ A∗∗ . We let aϕ and ϕa be the elements of A∗ defined by aϕ, b = ϕ, ba
and
ϕa, b = ϕ, ab
for any b ∈ A. Then we let ηϕ and ϕη be the elements of A∗ defined by ηϕ, b = η, ϕb
and
ϕη, b = η, bϕ
for any b ∈ A. By definition, the left and right Arens products ·λ and ·µ on A∗∗ are given by the following formulae, for η, ν ∈ A∗∗ and ϕ ∈ A∗ :
Basic theory of operator algebras η·λ ν, ϕ = η, νϕ
79 η·µ ν, ϕ = ν, ϕη.
and
These two products are called the Arens products. They have useful equivalent formulations in terms of double limits. Namely, let η, ν ∈ A∗∗ , and according to Goldstine’s lemma (see A.2.1), let (aα )α and (bβ )β be two nets in A converging to η and ν in the w∗ -topology of A∗∗ . From the last centered formula we have η·λ ν, ϕ = η, νϕ = limνϕ, aα = limν, ϕaα = lim lim ϕ, aα bβ . α
α
α
β
A similar calculation works for the other product, and thus: η·λ ν, ϕ = lim lim ϕ, aα bβ α
∗
β
and
η·µ ν, ϕ = lim lim ϕ, aα bβ (2.21) β
α
∗∗
for any ϕ ∈ A . It is easy to check that A is a Banach algebra with either product ·λ or ·µ , and that these products both extend the product of A. 2.5.2 (Arens regularity) A Banach algebra A is called Arens regular if the left and right Arens products coincide on A∗∗ . In that case, we will speak of the product ην of two elements of A∗∗ without any ambiguity, and we drop the notation ·λ or ·µ . It is easy to see using (2.21) say, that a subalgebra A of an Arens regular Banach algebra C, is again Arens regular, and that in this case A∗∗ becomes a subalgebra of C ∗∗ . 2.5.3 (A characterization of the Arens product) If a Banach algebra A is Arens regular, then the Arens product on A∗∗ is separately w∗ -continuous. To see this, fix ϕ ∈ A∗ and η ∈ A∗∗ , and consider the functional ν → ην, ϕ on A∗∗ . By the formulae above, this functional coincides with ϕη ∈ A∗ . Hence it is w∗ -continuous. Similarly for any ν ∈ A∗∗ and any ϕ ∈ A∗ , the functional η → ην, ϕ coincides with νϕ ∈ A∗ , and hence is w∗ -continuous. Conversely, if A∗∗ is equipped with a product which extends that of A and is separately w∗ -continuous, then A is Arens regular and the product on A∗∗ is indeed the Arens product. This clearly follows from (2.21). From this last fact and A.5.7, it is clear that any C ∗ -algebra A is Arens regular and that the product on the W ∗ -algebra A∗∗ is the Arens product. Corollary 2.5.4 Any operator algebra is Arens regular. Proof We just saw that any C ∗ -algebra is Arens regular. The result then follows by the remarks at the end of 2.5.2. 2 2.5.5 (W ∗ -continuous extension of homomorphisms) Let A be an operator algebra (or more generally an Arens regular matrix normed algebra), and let π : A → B(H) be a completely contractive homomorphism. According to 1.4.8, we let π ˜ : A∗∗ → B(H) be the unique w∗ -continuous mapping extending π, and we recall that π ˜ also is completely contractive. We observe that moreover, π & is a homomorphism when A∗∗ is equipped with its Arens product. Indeed, this follows immediately from the separate w ∗ -continuity of the products on B(H) and A∗∗ (see A.1.2 and 2.5.3). If π above maps into a w ∗ -closed subalgebra M of B(H) then it is evident that π ˜ maps into M too (by w ∗ -continuity).
80
The second dual algebra
Corollary 2.5.6 If A is an operator algebra, then A∗∗ is also an operator algebra. Indeed, there exist a Hilbert space H, and a completely isometric homomor˜ : A∗∗ → B(H) phism π : A → B(H) whose (unique) w ∗ -continuous extension π w∗ is a completely isometric homomorphism. In this case, A∗∗ ∼ &(A∗∗ ) = π(A) . =π Proof Let C be a C ∗ -algebra containing A as a subalgebra. Dualizing the embedding map A → C twice, we obtain by 1.4.3 a completely isometric embedding A∗∗ → C ∗∗ . By the remark at the end of 2.5.2, A∗∗ is a subalgebra of C ∗∗ . Since the second dual operator space structure on C ∗∗ coincides with the one inherited from its C ∗ -structure (see 1.4.10), we see that A∗∗ is an operator algebra. Consider the following commutative diagram of operator algebra embeddings: A ⊂ C ∩ ∩ A∗∗ ⊂ C ∗∗ Let πu : C → B(H) be the universal representation of C. According to 1.4.10, u : C ∗∗ → B(H) is a πu satisfies the conclusion of our proposition. That is, π ˜ is completely isometric homomorphism. If π is the restriction of πu to A, then π ˜ is a complete isometry. Then it follows by the restriction of π u to A∗∗ , and so π the Krein–Smulian theorem, as in the last few lines of the proof of A.5.6, that π(A)
w∗
= π &(A∗∗ ).
2
2.5.7 It is clear from the above proof and 1.4.10 that for an operator algebra A, the completely isometric identification Mn (A)∗∗ ∼ = Mn (A∗∗ ) from Theorem 1.4.11, is also an isomorphism of algebras, for any n ≥ 1. We now turn to approximately unital algebras and mention a well-known result concerning Arens regular Banach algebras. Proposition 2.5.8 Let A be a Banach algebra and assume that A is Arens regular. Then A has a cai (et )t if and only if A∗∗ has an identity e of norm 1. Similarly, A has a right cai (et )t if and only if A∗∗ has a right identity e of norm 1. If A is an operator algebra, and (et )t is a cai or right cai for A, and if e is as above, then et → e in the w∗ -topology of A∗∗ . If A has both a left and a right cai, then A has a (two-sided) cai. Proof Assume that A admits a cai (et )t , and let e ∈ A∗∗ be a cluster point of this net for the w∗ -topology. Then for any a ∈ A, ae is a cluster point of aet for the w∗ -topology. We are using the separate w ∗ -continuity of the product on A∗∗ (see 2.5.3). Thus ae = a. Thus, by A.2.1 and separate w ∗ -continuity again, ηe = η for any η ∈ A∗∗ . Similarly eη = η, and so e is an identity (of norm 1). Analoguous arguments give the ‘only if’ direction in the ‘right cai case’. Next we note that a right identity of norm 1 for an operator algebra is unique if it exists. To see this simply note that such a right identity is by A.1.1
Basic theory of operator algebras
81
a (selfadjoint) projection. If p, q are projections with pq = p and qp = q, then by taking adjoints we see that p = q. If e is an identity or right identity of norm one for A∗∗ and if (et )t is as above, then the previous argument shows that e is the unique w ∗ -cluster point of (et )t . Thus et → e in the w∗ -topology. The last assertion of the proposition follows from the other assertions, and the analoguous results for left identities. Next suppose that A∗∗ has a right identity e of norm 1. By Goldstine’s lemma (A.2.1) we may choose a net (et )t in Ball(A) converging to e in the w ∗ -topology of A∗∗ . Then for each a ∈ A it is clear that aet −→ a weakly in A.
(2.22)
Let F be the set of finite subsets of A. For any F = {a1 , a2 , . . . , an } ∈ F, define PF = {(a1 u − a1 , a2 u − a2 , . . . , an u − an ) : u ∈ Ball(A)}, a subset of A⊕∞ A⊕∞ · · ·⊕∞ A. By (2.22), 0 lies in the weak closure of PF . Since PF is convex, 0 also lies in its norm closure, by Mazur’s theorem from basic functional analysis. Let Λ = F × N, which we consider as a directed set with respect to the product ordering. Given λ = (F, m) for some F = {a1 , a2 , . . . , an } ∈ F and m ∈ N, there exists a uλ ∈ Ball(A) such that ak uλ − ak < 1/m for all 2 1 ≤ k ≤ n. Then (uλ ) is evidently a right approximate identity for A. Corollary 2.5.9 Suppose that A is an approximately unital operator algebra (or Arens regular matrix normed algebra), and that π : A → B(H) is a completely contractive homomorphism. If π ˜ : A∗∗ → B(H) is its w∗ -continuous extension (see 2.5.5), then π is nondegenerate if and only if π(et ) → IH in the w∗ -topology, ˜ being unital. for any cai (et )t of A. This is also equivalent to π Proof The first ‘if and only if’ follows from Lemma 2.1.9. For the other, note ˜ (eA∗∗ ) (in the w∗ -topology). 2 that et → eA∗∗ by 2.5.8, so that π(et ) → π As another application of the ‘second dual’ we give the following principle, which is surprisingly useful for nonselfadjoint algebras. Theorem 2.5.10 Suppose that A and B are (norm closed) subalgebras of an operator algebra C. Suppose further that each of A and B are approximately unital; and that AB = B and BA = A. Then A = B as subsets of C. Proof We may assume that C is selfadjoint. By symmetry it is enough to show B ⊂ A. We shall consider second duals and apply Proposition 2.5.8. Since A ⊂ C and B ⊂ C are subalgebras, we may regard A∗∗ ⊂ C ∗∗ and B ∗∗ ⊂ C ∗∗ as w∗ -closed subalgebras. Recall from basic functional analysis (see A.2.3 (4)) that A = A∗∗ ∩ C. Thus we only need to show that B ⊂ A∗∗ . Let (et )t be a cai for A and let eA be the unit of A∗∗ , so that et → eA in the ∗ w -topology of C ∗∗ . Also et b → b for any b ∈ B by the equality AB = B. Since the product on C ∗∗ is separately w∗ -continuous, we obtain that eA b = b for any b ∈ B. Hence, again by separate w ∗ -continuity, we have eA η = η for any η ∈ B ∗∗ .
82
Multiplier algebras and corners
In particular, if eB denotes the unit of B ∗∗ , then eA eB = eB . By symmetry, we also have eB eA = eA . Since eA and eB are projections in C ∗∗ , we deduce that eA = eB by taking adjoints. We can now conclude as follows: for any b ∈ B, we have b = beB = beA = w∗ -limt bet . Since BA ⊂ A we see that b belongs to the 2 w∗ -closure of A, and hence to A∗∗ . There is an analoguous version of the last result when AB = A and BA = B. It is interesting that these results are not true for general Banach algebras. 2.6 MULTIPLIER ALGEBRAS AND CORNERS 2.6.1 (Left multipliers) If A is simply an algebra then, according to the algebraists, a left multiplier of A is a right A-module map u : A → A. The left multiplier algebra LM (A) is the unital algebra of left multipliers of A. Let λ be the left regular representation of A on itself. Namely, λ(a)(b) = ab for a, b ∈ A; this is a homomorphism from A into the left multiplier algebra of A. If A is a Banach algebra which has a cai, then it follows from A.6.3 that any left multiplier is bounded. Thus Banach algebraists usually define the left multiplier algebra LM (A) of an approximately unital Banach algebra A to be BA (A), the unital Banach algebra of bounded right A-module maps on A. If, further, A is an operator algebra or a matrix normed algebra in the sense of 2.3.9, with cai (e t )t , then it follows immediately from the relation u(a) = limt u(et )a, which clearly holds for all u ∈ BA (A) and a ∈ A, that BA (A) = CBA (A) isometrically. Here CBA (A) is the set of completely bounded right A-module maps. Thus we define the left multiplier algebra LM (A) of such A to be the pair (CBA (A), λ), where λ : A → CBA (A) is the left regular representation of A mentioned above. Since LM (A) is a subalgebra of CB(A) (completely isometrically), it is clearly a matrix normed algebra. Note that the usual matrix norms on LM (A) = CBA (A) as defined by (1.6), have a simple description in this case. Namely, due to the relation u(a) = limt u(et )a above, it is fairly evident that (2.23) [uij ]Mn (CBA (A)) = sup [uij (a)]Mn (A) : a ∈ Ball(A) . Equivalently, if we regard Mn (A) as a right A-module in the obvious way, we have Mn (LM (A)) = CBA (A, Mn (A)) = BA (A, Mn (A)) isometrically. Henceforth in this section A is an approximately unital operator algebra. One would wish the left multiplier algebra of A to be a unital operator algebra, and fortunately it turns out that CBA (A) with its usual matrix norms discussed in the last paragraph, is an abstract operator algebra. This may be seen by the BRS theorem, or by the Theorem 2.6.2 below. Theorem 2.6.2 Let A be an approximately unital operator algebra. Then the following algebras are all completely isometrically isomorphic: (1) {η ∈ A∗∗ : ηA ⊂ A}, (2) {T ∈ B(H) : T π(A) ⊂ π(A)}, for any nondegenerate completely isometric representation π of A on a Hilbert space H,
Basic theory of operator algebras
83
(3) CBA (A). In particular, CBA (A) is a unital operator algebra. Proof Let LM be the algebra defined in (1). According to 2.5.6, LM is an operator algebra. Any η ∈ A∗∗ with the property that ηA ⊂ A may be clearly regarded as an element of CBA (A) hence there is a canonical homomorphism θ : LM → CBA (A), which may easily be seen to be completely contractive using (2.23). Let (et )t be a cai for A. If θ(η) = 0 then ηet = 0. Using the separate w∗ -continuity of the product in A∗∗ (see 2.5.3), and Proposition 2.5.8, it follows that η = 0. Thus θ is one-to-one. Given v ∈ CBA (A), let η be a w∗ -cluster point of v(et ) in A∗∗ . Clearly η ≤ v. For a ∈ A, we have v(a) = lim v(et a) = lim v(et )a = ηa, t
t
where again we have used the w ∗ -continuity of the product. Hence θ(η) = v. Thus θ is an isometric surjection, and a similar proof shows that it is a complete isometry. This proves the completely isometric isomorphism between (1) and (3), and also shows that CBA (A) is a unital operator algebra. If we write LM (π) for the algebra in (2), then there is a canonical homomorphism ρ : LM (π) → CBA (A), namely ρ(T )(a) = π −1 (T π(a)) for a ∈ A. If [Tij ] ∈ Mn (LM (π)), then by (2.23) we have (2.24) [ρ(Tij )]n = sup [ρ(Tij )a]n = sup [Tij π(a)]n ≤ [Tij ]n , where the supremum is taken over a ∈ Ball(A). Thus ρ is completely contractive. To see that ρ is completely isometric, we take ε > 0, and choose a vector ζ in Ball(2n (H)) such that [Tij ]n ≤ [Tij ]ζ + ε. Then [Tij ]n ≤ lim [Tij π(et )]ζ + ε ≤ sup [Tij π(et )] + ε ≤ [ρ(Tij )]n + ε, t
t
the last inequality by (2.24). Thus ρ is completely isometric. To see that ρ is onto, suppose that v ∈ BA (A). Let η = θ−1 (v) ∈ LM, and let π ˜ : A∗∗ → B(H) be the w∗ -continuous homomorphism extending π as discussed in 2.5.5 say. Then for any a ∈ A, π ˜ (η)π(a) = π ˜ (ηa) = π(ηa). This shows that π ˜ (η) ∈ LM (π) and ρ(˜ π (η)) = θ(η) = v. Thus ρ is onto.
2
2.6.3 (Left multiplier operator algebras) More generally, for A as above, we consider pairs (D, µ) consisting of a unital operator algebra D and a completely isometric homomorphism µ : A → D, such that Dµ(A) ⊂ µ(A). Sometimes we write µ as µA to indicate the dependence on A. We say that two such pairs (D, µ) and (D , µ ) are completely isometrically A-isomorphic if there exists a completely isometric surjective homomorphism θ : D → D such that θ ◦ µ = µ . This is an equivalence relation.
84
Multiplier algebras and corners
One should think of each of the three equivalent algebras in Theorem 2.6.2 as a pair (D, µA ) as in the previous paragraph. We spell out what the map µA is in each case. In (1), it is the usual inclusion iA : A → A∗∗ . In (2), it is π, and in (3) it is the map λ mentioned above the theorem. We define a left multiplier operator algebra of A, to be any pair (D, µ) as above which is completely isometrically A-isomorphic to (CBA (A), λ). We also write any such pair as LM (A). The following is clear from the last proof. Corollary 2.6.4 Each of the operator algebras in 2.6.2, together with its associated map µA discussed above, is a left multiplier operator algebra of A. That is, they are each completely isometrically A-isomorphic to (CB A (A), λ). 2.6.5 If A is unital, then it is easy to see that LM (A) = A. We also remark that if π : A → B(H) is as in 2.6.2 (2), then we may view LM (A) as a subset of the second commutant π(A) . Indeed if T ∈ B(H) with T π(A) ⊂ π(A), and if S ∈ π(A) and a ∈ A, then ST π(a) = T π(a)S = T Sπ(a). Since π is nondegenerate we have ST = T S. Thus T ∈ π(A) . Corollary 2.6.6 Let A be an approximately unital operator algebra, and fix u in Mn (CBA (A)). Write Lu (resp Lu ) for the operator on Cn (A) (resp. on Mn (A)) given by the usual formula for multiplication of matrices. Then (1) uMn (CBA (A)) = Lu cb = Lu cb . (2) Mn (CBA (A)) ∼ = CBMn (A) (Mn (A)) ∼ = CBMn (A) (Cn (A)) ∼ = BA (A, Mn (A)) isometrically. (3) LM (Mn (A)) ∼ = Mn (LM (A)) completely isometrically. Proof We observed after (2.23) that BA (A, Mn (A)) ∼ = Mn (CBA (A)). We let LM(A) denote the algebra in (1) of Theorem 2.6.2. Clearly Mn (LM(A)) is isomorphic to LM(Mn (A)) as operator algebras, using the fact from 2.5.7 that Mn (A)∗∗ = Mn (A∗∗ ). This yields (3), by the way. Thus by 2.6.2 we have Mn (CBA (A)) ∼ = CBMn (A) (Mn (A)) isometrically. It is clear by inspection that Lu cb = Lu cb for u as above, so that CBMn (A) (Mn (A)) ∼ = CBA (Cn (A)) isometrically. This proves (1) and (2). 2 2.6.7 (Right and two-sided multiplier algebras) We may define the right (resp. two-sided) multiplier operator algebra RM (A) (resp. M (A)) in a similar way, and one obtains similar results. For example, these algebras may be taken to be RM (A) = {η ∈ A∗∗ : Aη ⊂ A} (resp. M (A) = {η ∈ A∗∗ : ηA ⊂ A, Aη ⊂ A}). However there are one or two pitfalls to be wary of. First, the canonical map RM (A) → A CB(A) into the algebra of completely bounded left A-module maps is a completely isometric anti-homomorphism. Thus RM (A) should be identified with A CB(A) with the reverse of the usual multiplication on the latter. This ‘twist’ is related to the reason why algebraists often write operators on the right of the variable. Second, the canonical embedding LM (A) → CBA (A) does not restrict, as one might first guess, to an embedding of M (A) into the A-bimodule maps on A. The traditional way for Banach algebraists to circumvent this last
Basic theory of operator algebras
85
difficulty is to consider two-sided multipliers as a pair of maps in the double centralizer algebra (see the Notes on Section 2.6). Instead, we take the following approach. We consider pairs (D, µ) consisting of a unital operator algebra D and a completely isometric homomorphism µ : A → D such that Dµ(A) ⊂ µ(A) and µ(A)D ⊂ µ(A). We define two such pairs to be completely isometrically A-isomorphic just as we did in 2.6.3. We use the term ‘(two-sided) multiplier operator algebra of A’, and write M (A), for any pair (D, µ) as above which is completely isometrically A-isomorphic to {x ∈ A∗∗ : xA ⊂ A and Ax ⊂ A}. In fact these may be characterized quite nicely as subalgebras of LM (A). We leave the following as a (simple algebraic) exercise: Proposition 2.6.8 Suppose that A is an approximately unital operator algebra. If (D, µ) is a left multiplier operator algebra of A, then the closed subalgebra {d ∈ D : µ(A)d ⊂ µ(A)} of D, together with the map µ, is a (two-sided) multiplier operator algebra of A. Corollary 2.6.9 If A is a C ∗ -algebra then M (A) is the diagonal ∆(LM (A)). In particular, M (A) is a C ∗ -algebra. Proof If η ∈ LM (A) ⊂ A∗∗ then Aη ⊂ A
⇔
η∗ A ⊂ A
⇔
hence η ∈ M (A) if and only if η ∈ ∆(LM (A)).
η ∗ ∈ LM (A), 2
∗
2.6.10 (Essential ideals) If C is a C -algebra then an essential (two-sided) ideal of C is an ideal I of C for which the canonical homomorphism from C to B(I) associated to the product map C × I → I, is one-to-one. It is a pleasant ∗-algebraic exercise to show that this is equivalent to saying that K ∩ I = (0) for every nontrivial (two-sided closed) ideal K of C. Any C ∗ -algebra A is an essential ideal of M (A). Clearly, if C is a C ∗ -algebra containing A as an essential ideal, then the canonical homomorphism C → BA (A) = CBA (A) = LM (A) is completely contractive. Hence by the last paragraph in 2.1.2, for example, it yields a one-to-one ∗-homomorphism into ∆(LM (A)) = M (A) (see 2.6.9). Thus M (A) is the largest C ∗ -algebra with A as an essential ideal. If A is a w∗ -dense ideal in a W ∗ -algebra M , then M = LM (A) = M (A). Indeed, the complete contraction above from M to CBA (A), is one-to-one by the w∗ -density of A. That it is completely isometric and surjective is easily seen by considering, for any T ∈ CBA (A), a w∗ -limit point of (T (et )) in M , where (et ) is the approximate identity for A. The other assertions are now easy. In fact, this argument works more generally if M is a matrix normed algebra which is a dual space with separately w∗ -continuous product, and if A has a cai. 2.6.11 (Multiplier-nondegenerate morphisms) Let A, B be approximately unital algebras. A completely contractive homomorphism π : A → LM (B) will be called a left multiplier-nondegenerate morphism, if B is a nondegenerate left
86
Multiplier algebras and corners
module with respect to the natural left module action of A on B via π. This is equivalent, by Cohen’s factorization theorem A.6.2, to saying that for any left cai (et )t of A, we have π(et )b → b for all b ∈ B; or to saying that any b ∈ B may be written b = π(a)b for some a ∈ A, b ∈ B. Similarly for right multiplier-nondegenerate morphism; and a (two-sided) multiplier-nondegenerate morphism is a map π : A → M (B) that has both of these properties. Thus if π actually maps into B, then π is multiplier-nondegenerate if and only if (π(et ))t is a cai for B, for any cai (et )t for A. Note that the canonical map A → M (A) is multiplier-nondegenerate. Proposition 2.6.12 If A, B are approximately unital operator algebras, and if π : A → M (B) is a multiplier-nondegenerate morphism then π extends uniquely to a unital completely contractive homomorphism π ˆ : M (A) → M (B). Moreover π ˆ is completely isometric if and only if π is completely isometric. Proof By 2.6.7 we may regard M (A) and M (B) as subalgebras of A∗∗ and B ∗∗ respectively. Let π ˜ : A∗∗ → B ∗∗ be the (unique) w∗ -continuous homomorphism extending π (see 2.5.5). We will prove that π ˜ maps M (A) into M (B) and that π ˜ (·)|M(A) is the unique bounded homomorphism on M (A) extending π. As usual we let (et )t be a cai for A. Let η ∈ M (A) and let b ∈ B. Then ˜ (η)π(et )b → π ˜ (η)b. Since π ˜ is a homomorphism π(et )b → b by 2.6.11, hence π ˜ (η)b = limt π(ηet )b is the limit of a net of B, hence and ηet ∈ A, we find that π belongs to B. Similarly, b˜ π (η) ∈ B for any b ∈ B, which shows that π ˜ (η) ∈ M (B). Assume now that π ˆ : M (A) → M (B) is a bounded homomorphism extending π, and let η ∈ M (A) and b ∈ B. Each ηet belongs to A, and this net converges to η in the w∗ -topology by Proposition 2.5.8. Hence π ˜ (η) = w∗ - lim π(ηet ). t
On the other hand, π(et )b → b, and hence π ˆ (η)b = lim π ˆ (η)π(et )b = lim π ˆ (ηet )b = lim π(ηet )b. t
t
t
This shows that π ˆ=π ˜|M(A) . It remains to prove the last assertion, so suppose that π is completely isometric. Using (2.23) we have for η ∈ M (A) that π (η)(π(a)b) = π(ηa)b ˆ π (η)cb ≥ ˆ if a ∈ Ball(A), b ∈ Ball(B). Taking the supremum over all b ∈ Ball(B) gives ˆ π (η)cb ≥ π(ηa) = ηa. Taking the supremum over all such a ∈ Ball(A), gives that ˆ π(η) cb ≥ ηcb. So π ˆ is isometric, and similarly it is completely isometric. 2 2.6.13 The analoguous result for ‘left multiplier-nondegenerate morphisms’, in which we replace M (·) by LM (·) in 2.6.12, holds with the same proof.
Basic theory of operator algebras
87
As a corollary of the last result, and 2.1.7 (2), we note that if B is any C ∗ cover of an approximately unital operator algebra A, then LM (A) ⊂ LM (B), RM (A) ⊂ RM (B), and M (A) ⊂ M (B), as unital-subalgebras. As another corollary, suppose that J is a left ideal of an operator algebra A, that J has a cai, and that π : J → B(H) is a completely contractive nondegenerate representation. We claim that π extends uniquely to a completely contractive representation π ˜ of A on H. Indeed the uniqueness follows from the relation π ˜ (a)π(x)ζ = π ˜ (a)˜ π (x)ζ = π(ax)ζ, for a ∈ A, x ∈ J, ζ ∈ H. Viewing B(H) as the multiplier algebra of S ∞ (H), it is easy to see that π is a multipliernondegenerate morphism in the sense above. By 2.6.12, π extends to a completely contractive representation of LM (J) on H. Since LM (J) = CBJ (J), it is clear that there is a canonical completely contractive homomorphism from A into LM (J). Composing the last two homomorphisms gives the desired result. We end this section with some relations between multipliers and ‘corners’. 2.6.14 (Corners) If p is a projection in M (A) then we say that pAp is the 1-1-corner of A (with respect to p). In this case pAp is an operator algebra (indeed it is a C ∗ -algebra if A is one), as is the 2-2-corner (1 − p)A(1 − p). We say that pA(1 − p) is the 1-2-corner of A (with respect to p). Consider the subset B of M2 (A) consisting of all 2 × 2 matrices whose i-j entry belongs to the i-j-corner of A with respect to p. This set B is a norm closed subalgebra of M2 (A), which we claim is canonically completely isometrically isomorphic to A. To see this, first suppose that A = B(H). Then A ∼ = B(K ⊕ K ⊥), and it is fairly clear that this is ∗-isomorphic to B in this case, via a ∗-isomorphism π say. By 1.2.4, π is completely isometric. For a general subalgebra A ⊂ B(H), the claim is established by considering the restriction of π to A. In fact, it is usually helpful to regard the 2 × 2 matrix operator algebra B as a subalgebra of the 2 × 2 matrix ∗-algebra corresponding to B(K ⊕ K ⊥ ). 2.6.15 (Corner-preserving maps) Suppose that A and B are approximately unital operator algebras, and that p and q are projections in M (A) and M (B) respectively. As in 2.6.14, this allows us to decompose A and B as 2 × 2 matrix operator algebras. We say that a map π : A → B is corner-preserving, or decoupled, if π maps each of the four corners of A into the corresponding corner of B. In this case we let πij be the restriction of π to the i-j-corner of A, viewed as a map from the i-j-corner of A into the i-j-corner of B. We call πij the i-j-corner of π, and sometimes write π = [πij ] to indicate this situation. Suppose that π : A → M (B) is a contractive multiplier-nondegenerate morphism (see 2.6.11) and that p is a projection in M (A). If we define q = π ˆ (p), where π ˆ is as in 2.6.12, then q is a contractive idempotent, and is consequently, by 2.1.3, a projection in M (B). Also, π is corner-preserving as a map into M (B) (with respect to the corners defined via p and q = π ˆ (p)). To see this, note for example that π(pa(1 − p)) = π ˆ (pa(1 − p)) = qπ(a)(1 − q) for any a ∈ A. 2.6.16 (Corner-preserving completely positive maps) Suppose that Φ : A → B is a unital completely positive map between unital C ∗ -algebras. Suppose that
88
Dual operator algebras
p is a projection in A and that q = Φ(p) is a projection in B. Then a similar principle to 2.6.15 holds. Obviously Φ restricted to the linear span of p and 1 − p (which is a two-dimensional C ∗ -algebra) is a unital ∗-homomorphism. It follows by 1.3.12 that Φ(pa) = qΦ(a) and Φ(ap) = Φ(a)q for all a ∈ A. Hence Φ is again corner-preserving, and we may write Φ = [ϕij ] just as in 2.6.15. Since Φ is completely positive and hence ∗-linear it follows that first, ϕ11 and ϕ22 are completely positive, and second, that ϕ12 (x∗ ) = ϕ21 (x)∗ for any x ∈ pA(1 − p). In other words, ϕ21 = ϕ12 in the sense of 1.2.25. In passing we observe that using 1.2.10 and 1.3.3, we may extend (the first part of) these results to the case when Φ : A → B is a unital completely contractive homomorphism between unital operator algebras. 2.6.17 We may rephrase 2.6.16 in the language of bimodules. Note that the existence of projections p ∈ A and q ∈ B, is equivalent to saying that A and B each contain D2 = C ⊕ C as a unital C ∗ -subalgebra. That Φ may be written as a matrix of maps [ϕij ] with respect to these projections p, q, is equivalent to saying that Φ is a D2 -bimodule map. We can therefore extend the observation 2.6.16 to ∗ the case when A and B contain a copy of Dn = ∞ n as a unital C -subalgebra, and Φ : A → B is a unital completely contractive map. In this case, A and B decompose as n× n matrix algebras, with respect to the n canonical idempotents in Dn . Also, Φ is a Dn -bimodule map if and only if we may write Φ = [ϕij ]. In this case we say again that Φ is corner-preserving. Again 1.3.12 implies that if Φ is ‘the identity map’ on the copies of Dn , then Φ is corner-preserving. 2.7 DUAL OPERATOR ALGEBRAS We shall now consider dual objects in the category of operator algebras, both from the concrete and from the abstract point of view. By definition, a concrete dual operator algebra is a w ∗ -closed subalgebra of B(H), for some Hilbert space H. As a consequence of 1.4.7, any concrete dual operator algebra is a dual operator space. In the converse direction, let M be an operator algebra together with a given additional topology τ on M , and we suppose that τ is the w ∗ -topology given by some predual for M . We call such an algebra M , together with the topology τ , an (abstract) dual operator algebra, if there exist a Hilbert space H and a w∗ -continuous completely isometric homomorphism π : M → B(H). In this case, the range π(M ) is w∗ -closed by the Krein–Smulian theorem A.2.5, and π is a w∗ -homeomorphism onto its range. Hence π(M ) is a concrete dual operator algebra acting on H, which we may identify with M . If M is a dual operator algebra, then we say that the topology τ mentioned above, is a dual operator algebra topology on M . In the selfadjoint situation, we use the term ‘von Neumann algebra’ for a concrete selfadjoint dual operator algebra, and the term ‘W ∗ -algebra’ for an abstract selfadjoint dual operator algebra (see A.5.1 and A.5.3). By the famous theorem of Sakai, a W ∗ -algebra is exactly the same as a C ∗ -algebra with a Banach space predual; and in this case the Banach space predual is unique (see
Basic theory of operator algebras
89
[380, Sections 1.13 and 1.16]). We will see that in the nonselfadjoint context, some new complications may occur. For example, in general the predual of an operator algebra need not be unique. That is, an operator algebra may possess more than one dual operator algebra topology (see Corollary 2.7.8 and Proposition 2.7.16). However we will establish an abstract characterization of dual operator algebras (see Theorem 2.7.9) which is close to Sakai’s result. We often identify any two dual operator algebras M and N which are w ∗ homeomorphically and completely isometrically isomorphic. In this case we sometimes say that M ∼ = N as dual operator algebras. 2.7.1 If M is a dual operator algebra, then we will reserve the notation M ∗ for any operator space predual of M which induces the given dual operator algebra topology on M . If M ⊂ B(H) is represented as a w ∗ -closed subalgebra (by a map π as above), then by 1.4.6 we may take M∗ = S 1 (H)/M⊥ . 2.7.2 Unital dual operator algebras play a particularly prominent role in the sequel. A slight modification of the argument in 2.1.4 shows that any unital dual operator algebra may be represented as a w ∗ -closed subalgebra of some B(H) containing IH . (Note that the map a → a|K in 2.1.4 is a w∗ -continuous complete isometry into B(K), and is thus a w∗ -homeomorphism by A.2.5.) 2.7.3 As a consequence of Corollary 2.5.6, the second dual of any operator algebra is a dual operator algebra, as one might hope. The next result collects together several superficial facts about dual algebras: Proposition 2.7.4 Let M be a (possibly nonunital) dual operator algebra. (1) The product on M is separately w ∗ -continuous. (2) For any a ∈ M and any ϕ ∈ M∗ , the functionals ϕa and aϕ (using notation from 2.5.1) both belong to M∗ . (3) If M is approximately unital, then M is actually unital. (4) The w∗ -closure of a subalgebra of M is a dual operator algebra. (5) The unitization (see Section 2.1 above) of M is also a dual operator algebra. (6) If M is nonunital, and if π : M → B(H) is a w ∗ -continuous contractive homomorphism, then the canonical unital extension of π to the unitization of M (see 2.1.13) is w∗ -continuous. Proof Item (1) is clear from the separate w ∗ -continuity of the product on B(H) (see A.1.2). Item (2) is a restatement of (1). For (3), assume that (e t )t is a cai for M , and let e ∈ M be a w∗ -cluster point of this net. For any a ∈ M and any ϕ ∈ M∗ , and passing to a subnet, we have ϕ, et a = aϕ, et −→ aϕ, e = ϕ, ea by (2). Since et a → a, we deduce that ϕ, ea = ϕ, a. Similarly, ϕ, ae = ϕ, a. Since ϕ ∈ M∗ was arbitrary, this shows that e is a unit (of norm 1) for M . For (4), let x, y belong to the w∗ -closure of the subalgebra A in M , and let (aα )α and (bβ )β be two nets of A converging to x and y respectively in
90
Dual operator algebras
the w∗ -topology. By (1), xbβ = w∗ -limα aα bβ . Hence xbβ belongs to A ∗
w∗
w∗
. Then
xy = w -limβ xbβ , and so xy ∈ A . Finally, suppose that M is a w∗ -closed nonunital subalgebra of B(K), and write I for IK . Suppose that (xt )t and (λt )t are nets in M and C respectively, with (xt + λt I) converging in the w∗ -topology. By the Hahn–Banach theorem, it is easy to see that (λt )t converges in C. It follows that (xt )t converges in M , in 2 the w∗ -topology. From this, (5) and (6) follow easily. 2.7.5 (Examples) The following completes the list considered in Section 2.2. We refer the reader to the extensive literature on dual algebras for deeper and more interesting examples (see the first paragraph of the Notes section for this chapter for a few references). (1) As in 2.2.1, the ∞-direct sum of dual operator algebras is again a dual operator algebra. We leave this fact as an exercise using the last facts in 1.4.13. In particular, if M is a dual operator algebra and I is a set, then ∞ I (M ) is a dual operator algebra. (2) Let M and N be two dual operator algebras. Then it follows from 2.2.2 and 2.7.4 (4), that their normal spatial tensor product M ⊗ N (defined in 1.6.5) is a dual operator algebra. We leave it as an exercise that if π, θ are w ∗ -continuous completely bounded representations of M and N , then the extension of π ⊗ θ to M ⊗ N is again a w∗ -continuous completely bounded homomorphism. (3) The result in 2.2.4 extends as follows. Let (Ω, µ) be a σ-finite measure space, let M be a dual operator algebra with separable predual, and recall from 1.6.6 the w∗ -continuous completely isometric isomorphism jM from L∞ (Ω) ⊗ M onto the dual operator space L∞ (Ω; M ) of w∗ -measurable essentially bounded functions f : Ω → M . If f, g ∈ L∞ (Ω; M ) then the pointwise product function (f g)(t) = f (t)g(t) is w ∗ -measurable and hence belongs to L∞ (Ω; M ). Moreover the resulting multiplication on L∞ (Ω; M ) is separately w∗ -continuous. Indeed these results are established in [380, Theorem 1.22.13] in the case when M is a W ∗ -algebra and the proofs given there extend almost verbatim to the nonselfadjoint case. Now consider L∞ (Ω; M ) as equipped with this pointwise product. Then the last lines of 1.6.6 show that the restriction of jM to L∞ (Ω) ⊗ M is a homomorphism. Since the products on L∞ (Ω) ⊗ M and L∞ (Ω; M ) are both separately w ∗ -continuous, we deduce that jM is a homomorphism. Thus L∞ (Ω; M ) is a dual operator algebra for the pointwise multiplication and L∞ (Ω) ⊗ M = L∞ (Ω; M ) ‘as dual operator algebras’. These results extend the well-known fact (e.g. see [380, Theorem 1.22.13]) that L ∞ (Ω; M ) is a W ∗ -algebra if M is a W ∗ -algebra. (4) The discussion in 2.2.6 and 2.2.7 can be continued as follows. Let H ∞ (D) ⊂ L∞ (T) be the Hardy space of all f ∈ L∞ (T) whose negative Fourier coefficients vanish. Then H ∞ (D) is a w∗ -closed subalgebra of L∞ (T), and hence it is a unital dual operator algebra. Using Poisson integrals, H ∞ (D) can also be described as the algebra of all bounded analytic functions from D into C. More generally, if M is a dual operator algebra with separable predual, then the space
Basic theory of operator algebras
91
H ∞ (D; M ) of all functions f ∈ L∞ (T; M ) whose negative Fourier coefficients vanish is a dual operator algebra. Moreover H ∞ (D; M ) can also be described as the algebra of all bounded analytic functions from D into M and we have an identification H ∞ (D; M ) = H ∞ (D) ⊗ M ‘as dual operator algebras’. We omit the proofs of these assertions, as they diverge from our main concerns. (5) When M = MI , for a cardinal I, then (2) yields a dual operator algebra structure on MI ⊗ N . On the other hand, if N ⊂ B(H) is represented as a dual 2 operator algebra on H, then MI (N ) is the w∗ -closure of Mfin I (N ) in B(I (H)) by Corollary 1.6.3 (3), hence is a dual operator algebra by 2.7.4 (4). From this it is not hard to see that the identification MI ⊗ N = MI (N ) given by (1.54) holds ‘as dual operator algebras’. This is analoguous to (2.8) and is related to the latter by the following proposition. Proposition 2.7.6 Let A be an operator algebra, and I any cardinal. Then KI (A)∗∗ ∼ = MI (A∗∗ ) as dual operator algebras. Proof The canonical embedding A ⊂ A∗∗ induces a completely isometric homomorphism π : KI (A) → KI (A∗∗ ) ⊂ MI (A∗∗ ). By (1.62) the unique w∗ -continuous extension π ˜ of π to KI (A)∗∗ is a completely isometric isomorphism. However by 2.5.5, it is a homomorphism too. 2 We now return to the algebra U(X) constructed in 2.2.10. Lemma 2.7.7 Let X be an operator space. (1) If U(X) is a dual operator algebra, then X ⊂ U(X) is w ∗ -closed. Hence X is a dual operator space. (2) If X is a dual operator space, then U(X) is a dual operator algebra. Indeed U(X) has an operator space predual for which the canonical embedding from X into U(X) is w∗ -continuous. Proof Assume that U(X) is a dual operator algebra. Let p be the projection 10 in U (X) defined by p = . Then p U(X)(1 − p) is the subspace of U(X) 00 corresponding to X. It is a fairly obvious general principle that a corner pM (1−p) of a dual algebra M is w∗ -closed. Indeed by 2.7.4 (1) and the fact that p is a projection, it follows that if (yt ) is a net in pM (1 − p) converging to b ∈ M say, then yt = pyt (1 − p) converges to pb(1 − p). Thus b = pb(1 − p) ∈ pU(X)(1 − p). Assume conversely that X is a dual operator space. By 1.4.7 we may assume that X ⊂ B(H) is a w∗ -closed subspace of B(H) for some Hilbert space H. Then U (X), as defined by (2.10), is easily seen to be a w ∗ -closed subalgebra of B(H (2) ) and the result follows at once. 2 Corollary 2.7.8 There exist a unital operator algebra A with two distinct dual operator algebra topologies. Equivalently, there exist two completely isometric homomorphisms π1 : A → B(H1 ) and π2 : A → B(H2 ) such that M1 = π1 (A) and M2 = π2 (A) are w∗ -closed but π1∗ (M1 ∗ ) = π2∗ (M2 ∗ ).
92
Dual operator algebras
Proof Let E be a Banach space with two distinct preduals Z1 and Z2 . More precisely, we think of these preduals as two distinct subspaces Z1 ⊂ E ∗ and Z2 ⊂ E ∗ . We consider the operator space X = Min(E), and the unital operator algebra A = U (X) of 2.2.10. Let J : X → U (X) be the canonical embedding. Since X = Max(Z1 )∗ = Max(Z2 )∗ , the second part of Lemma 2.7.7 ensures that there exist two completely isometric homomorphisms π1 : A → B(H1 ) and π2 : A → B(H2 ) respectively, such that M1 = π1 (A) and M2 = π2 (A) are w∗ closed, and such that π1 ◦ J : X → M1 and π2 ◦ J : X → M2 are w∗ -continuous. In the last statement X is regarded as the dual of Z1 and of Z2 respectively; that is, (π1 ◦ J)∗ (M1∗ ) = Z1 and (π2 ◦ J)∗ (M2∗ ) = Z2 . Thus if π1∗ (M1∗ ) and π2∗ (M2∗ ) 2 were equal, we would have the contradiction that Z1 = Z2 . We have noticed that a dual operator algebra is a dual operator space. The main result of this section is the following converse, which may be regarded as a dual version of the BRS theorem, and also as a nonselfadjoint version of Sakai’s theorem mentioned at the start of this section. Theorem 2.7.9 Let M be an operator algebra which is a dual operator space. Then the product on M is separately w ∗ -continuous, and M is a dual operator algebra. That is, there exists a Hilbert space H and a w ∗ -continuous completely isometric homomorphism π : M → B(H). The first assertion saying that the product on M is separately w ∗ -continuous will only be proved in Chapter 4, in 4.7.2. The rest of the proof will require several intermediate steps of independent interest, and will be completed in 2.7.13 below. We start with a version of Proposition 2.4.20 (1), for unital dual operator algebras. Theorem 2.7.10 Let M be a unital operator algebra which is also a dual operator space. Let u : M → B(H) be a w ∗ -continuous completely contractive map, H being a Hilbert space. Then there exist a Hilbert space K, two linear contractions V : H → K, W : K → H, and a unital w∗ -continuous completely contractive homomorphism π : M → B(K), such that u(a) = W π(a)V for any a ∈ M . Proof We first apply Proposition 2.4.20 (1) to u. We obtain a Hilbert space G, two linear contractions T : H → G and S : G → H, and a unital completely contractive homomorphism θ : M → B(G) such that u(a) = Sθ(a)T,
a ∈ M.
(2.25)
Moreover we may assume that G = [θ(M )T (H)]. Let K = [θ(M )∗ S ∗ (H)] ⊂ G, and let p = PK be the projection onto K. If a, b, c ∈ M and ζ, η ∈ H then u(acb)ζ, η = pθ(b)T ζ, θ(c)∗ θ(a)∗ S ∗ η = pθ(c)pθ(b)T ζ, θ(a)∗ S ∗ η. Thus u(acb) = Sθ(a)θ(c)pθ(b)T = Sθ(a)pθ(c)pθ(b)T.
(2.26)
Setting a = b = 1 in (2.26) yields u = W π(·)V , where W = S|K , V = pT and π = pθ(·)|K . A well-known general principle states that if θ : A → B(H)
Basic theory of operator algebras
93
is a homomorphism and if K is a subspace of H such that θ(A)∗ K ⊂ K (or equivalently, such that θ(A)K ⊥ ⊂ K ⊥ , then π = PK θ(·)|K is a homomorphism. To see this, note that for any a, b ∈ A and any ζ, η ∈ K, we have π(ab)ζ, η = θ(ab)ζ, η = θ(a)θ(b)ζ, η = θ(b)ζ, θ(a)∗ η = π(b)ζ, θ(a)∗ η. On the other hand, π(a)π(b)ζ, η = θ(a)π(b)ζ, η = π(b)ζ, θ(a)∗ η. Thus π is a unital completely contractive homomorphism. To show that π is w∗ -continuous, we fix a, b ∈ M and ζ, η ∈ H. We noticed before Theorem 2.7.10 that the product on M is separately w ∗ -continuous (by 4.7.2). Since u is w∗ continuous, the mapping c → u(acb) is therefore w ∗ -continuous from M into B(H). Also observe that for any c ∈ M , we have using (2.26) that u(acb)ζ, η = pθ(c)pθ(b)T ζ, θ(a)∗ S ∗ η = π(c)pθ(b)T ζ, θ(a)∗ S ∗ η. If (ct )t is a bounded net in M converging in the w ∗ -topology to c ∈ M , then π(ct )k1 , k2 → π(c)k1 , k2
(2.27)
for k1 = pθ(b)T ζ, k2 = θ(a)∗ S ∗ η. The span of the set of such k1 is dense in K, and similarly for the span of the set of such k2 . Therefore, by a simple norm density argument, (2.27) holds for all k1 , k2 ∈ K. That is, π(ct ) → π(c) in the WOT. Since this is a bounded net, it converges by A.1.4 in the w ∗ -topology. Thus π is w∗ -continuous by A.2.5 (2). 2 We next give a dual version of Proposition 2.3.4. Recall from 1.4.4, that if X = Z ∗ is a dual operator space and if Y ⊂ X is w ∗ -closed, then the quotient space X/Y is the dual operator space of Y⊥ ⊂ Z. Proposition 2.7.11 Let M be a dual operator algebra and let J ⊂ M be a w∗ -closed (two-sided) ideal. Then M/J is a dual operator algebra. Proof We may assume that M ⊂ B(H) is a w ∗ -closed subalgebra of some B(H). Then by 2.7.4 (5) its unitization M 1 = Span{M, IH } is also a w∗ -closed subalgebra, any ideal of M is still an ideal of M 1 , and the canonical embedding M/J ⊂ M 1 /J is w∗ -continuous. Replacing M by M 1 if necessary, we may therefore assume that M is unital. If M is unital, then N = M/J is unital, hence N is both a dual operator space and a unital operator algebra (by 2.3.4). By 1.4.7, there exists a w ∗ -continuous linear complete isometry u : N → B(H), for some Hilbert space H. Choose K, π, V and W as in Theorem 2.7.10, with u = W π(·)V . For any n ≥ 1 and any matrix [aij ] ∈ Mn (N ), we have [aij ] = [u(aij )] ≤ W [π(aij )] V ≤ [π(aij )] ≤ [aij ] . n n n n n Hence π is a complete isometry, so that N is a dual operator algebra.
2
94
Dual operator algebras
Lemma 2.7.12 Let M be an Arens regular Banach algebra. Assume moreover that M = X ∗ is a dual Banach space, and that the product on M is separately w∗ -continuous. Let iX : X → X ∗∗ be the canonical embedding. Then the adjoint mapping Q = i∗X : M ∗∗ → M is a homomorphism. Proof Take η and ν in M ∗∗ and consider two nets (at )t and (bs )s in M converging respectively to η and ν in the w ∗ -topology. Then it follows immediately from the separate w∗ -continuity that Q(ην) = w∗ - lim lim Q(at bs ) = w∗ - lim lim at bs = w∗ - lim at Q(ν) = Q(η)Q(ν). t
s
t
s
t
2
Thus Q is a homomorphism.
2.7.13 (Proof of Theorem 2.7.9) Assume that M is an operator algebra which is also a dual operator space. We already emphasized that the product on M is separately w∗ -continuous (by 4.7.2). Let Q : M ∗∗ → M be defined as in the above lemma. Combining the latter with 2.5.4, we obtain that Q is a homomorphism. Since iX is a complete isometry, Q also is a w ∗ -continuous complete quotient map, by 1.4.3. Thus Ker(Q) is a w∗ -closed ideal of M ∗∗ . Factoring through its kernel, Q induces a w∗ -continuous (by A.2.4) and completely isometric homomorphism from M ∗∗ /Ker(Q) onto M . In fact this map is a w ∗ -homeomorphism, by A.2.5. Since M ∗∗ is a dual operator algebra, as we remarked in 2.7.3, Proposition 2.7.11 shows that M ∗∗ /Ker(Q) is a dual operator algebra. Thus M is a dual operator algebra. Corollary 2.7.14 Suppose that A is an operator algebra, and that m is any product on A∗∗ extending the product on A, for which A∗∗ is (completely isometrically) an operator algebra. Then m must be the Arens product. Proof By Theorem 2.7.9, m is automatically w ∗ -continuous. By 2.5.3, m is the Arens product. 2 In the light of Sakai’s theorem (which we described at the start of this section), one might imagine that Theorem 2.7.9 remains valid if we replace the assumption that M is a dual operator space by the weaker assumption that M is merely a dual Banach space. In fact this is not true, and our next goal is to show this. We will use the following subtle result which clarifies some differences between Banach space and operator space duality. Lemma 2.7.15 There exists an operator space X with a unique Banach space predual Z, such that X possesses no operator space predual. Moreover, whenever Z is equipped with an operator space structure, the canonical mapping between the dual operator space Z ∗ and X is not a complete isomorphism. Proof Let B be an operator space that will be specified later on. From 1.4.13, 1 (B ∗ )∗ = ∞ (B ∗∗ )
and
c0 (B)∗ = 1 (B ∗ )
(2.28)
Basic theory of operator algebras
95
completely isometrically. Thus c0 (B)∗∗ = ∞ (B ∗∗ ). If η ∈ ∞ (B ∗∗ ), let η˙ denote its class in the quotient space ∞ ((B ∗∗ )op )/c0 ((B ∗∗ )op ) (see 1.2.25 for this notation), and write η¯ for the pair (η, η). ˙ Consider the operator space ∞ ∗∗ ∞ ∗∗ X = η¯ : η ∈ (B ) ⊂ (B ) ⊕∞ ∞ ((B ∗∗ )op )/c0 ((B ∗∗ )op ) . (2.29) The map κ : X → ∞ (B ∗∗ ) taking η¯ to η is a complete contraction, that is, ηMn (X) ηMn (∞ (B ∗∗ )) ≤ ¯ ∞
(2.30)
∗∗
for any n ≥ 1 and any η ∈ Mn ⊗ (B ). Moreover since η → η˙ is a contraction, κ is an isometric isomorphism. The main point to be kept in mind is the operator space structure on X induced by the right-hand side of (2.29). Obviously, η˙ = 0 for any η ∈ c0 (B). Thus if η ∈ Mn ⊗ c0 (B) then η Mn (X) . ηMn (c0 (B)) = ¯ That is, the canonical map ι : c0 (B) → X is a complete isometry. Fix z ∈ Mn ⊗ 1 (B ∗ ) for some arbitrary integer n ≥ 1, and let u be the associated linear mapping from ∞ (B ∗∗ ) to Mn (as in (1.27), and using (2.28)). Note that u is w∗ -continuous, and therefore it is the unique w ∗ -continuous extension to ∞ (B ∗∗ ) of the map u|c0 (B) : c0 (B) → Mn . Hence according to 1.4.8, and also using (1.27) and (2.28), we have u : ∞ (B ∗∗ ) −→ Mn = u|c (B) : c0 (B) −→ Mn = zM (1 (B ∗ )) . 0 n cb cb It follows from the last equations, and the fact that κ and ι are completely contractive, and that u ◦ κ ◦ ι = u|c0 (B) , that we also have (2.31) zMn (1 (B ∗ )) = u ◦ κ : X −→ Mn cb . Being isometric to ∞ (B ∗∗ ), X is a dual Banach space by (2.28). We shall now assume that B is a C ∗ -algebra. Then ∞ (B ∗∗ ) is a W ∗ -algebra, and so 1 (B ∗ ) is the unique Banach space predual of X. Equation (2.31) may be rephrased as the fact that if we view 1 (B ∗ ) ⊂ X ∗ in the natural way, then the operator space structure induced on 1 (B ∗ ) from X ∗ , coincides with its usual one from 1.4.13. Let Z denote 1 (B ∗ ) equipped with another operator space structure for which X = Z ∗ completely isomorphically via the canonical map. Then Z = 1 (B ∗ ) completely isomorphically by our rephrased version of (2.31). Passing to operator space duals, we find that X = ∞ (B ∗∗ ) completely isomorphically as well. This means that there is a constant c > 0 such that η ˙ Mn (∞ ((B ∗∗ )op )/c0 ((B ∗∗ )op )) ≤ cηMn (∞ (B ∗∗ )) for any n ≥ 1 and any η ∈ Mn (∞ (B ∗∗ )). Restricting to matrices η whose entries are constant sequences valued in B, we deduce that ηMn (B op ) ≤ cηMn (B) ,
n ≥ 1, η ∈ Mn (B).
Hence we obtain a contradiction by choosing our B so that the last inequality is 2 false (take for example B to be B(H) or S ∞ (H), with dim(H) = ∞).
96
Notes and historical remarks
An example which also satisfies the last lemma, but which looks much simpler, is obtained by defining X to be the subspace of B(H) ⊕∞ (B(H)/S ∞ (H))op consisting of pairs (T, T˙ ) for T ∈ B(H). The arguments of the lemma go through verbatim almost to the end. However the last three lines of the proof (in the case that c > 1) then require nontrivial facts about the Calkin algebra B(H)/S ∞ (H). Corollary 2.7.16 There exists a unital operator algebra A with a Banach space predual for which the product is separately w ∗ -continuous but for which there is no complete isometry J : A → B(H) which is w ∗ -continuous, or whose range is w∗ -closed. Such an algebra A has no operator space predual. Proof Let X be an operator space satisfying Lemma 2.7.15, and let Z denote its Banach space predual. Consider the unital operator algebra A = U(X) defined by 2.2.10, and we will prove that it satisfies the requirements above. First note that Min(X) = Max(Z)∗ is a dual operator space (see 1.4.12). Thus U(Min(X)) is a dual operator algebra by Lemma 2.7.7 (2). Moreover A is isometrically isomorphic to U (Min(X)) by Proposition 2.2.12. This proves that A has a Banach space predual for which the product is separately w ∗ -continuous. Second, note that if A were a dual operator space, then it would be a dual operator algebra by Theorem 2.7.9. By Lemma 2.7.7 (1), this would imply the contradiction that X ⊂ A is a dual operator space. If there existed a w ∗ -continuous complete isometry J : A → B(H) then the range of J is w ∗ -closed by A.2.5, so that A would be a dual operator space (using 1.4.6). 2 2.8 NOTES AND HISTORICAL REMARKS Nonselfadjoint operator algebras were first studied by Kadison and Singer [215], and a little later by Ringrose (see references in [364]). Shortly after this study commenced, many major and foundational papers on the subject were written by Arveson—for example, see [20–23, 25]. It was Arveson who defined complete contractions, and complete isometries, and recognized their importance to operator algebras and operator spaces. Around that time, motivated in large part by operator theory and the invariant subspace problem, dual operator algebras began to be studied extensively using Banach space techniques. We will not attempt the long list of names that might be mentioned here, we would be sure to omit some. For some citations see [23, 32, 84, 108, 240, 337, 354], and references therein. Operator algebras occur quite naturally in mathematics, for example as the ‘classifying object’ for many problems. In the 1970s also, Varopoulos initiated another direction in the study of operator algebras as Banach algebras. For example, see [417,116,124,123,411,82]; amongst other things, these authors gave some characterizations, and produced many surprising examples of Banach algebras which are/are not bicontinuously isomorphic to operator algebras. We say a little more on this work (which greatly influenced the subject of our book) in Chapter 5. We have included some results on Banach algebras in the Appendix; others may be found in the standard texts, for example [74, 106, 297, 298].
Basic theory of operator algebras
97
Again, we will not attempt to describe the huge literature on nonselfadjoint operator algebras from the 1980s and later. The deepest examples and special classes of operator algebras are out of the range of our book. We hope that at some future point we might see a text entitled ‘Operator algebras by example’ to follow [108,110]! General results, which apply to all operator algebras, seem to be rather scarce in the literature. Our book of course only treats topics connected with operator spaces, and even then is incomplete due to limitations of space. We have omitted to address a few major topics which are extensively covered in other books [108, 314, 335, 337], such as dilation theory. 2.1: The result 2.1.7 is from [46]. The unitization of approximately unital (matrix normed) operator algebras may first appear in [344]. Meyer’s results [277] suggest that perhaps other questions about the ball can be transformed into questions involving positivity. The diagonal ∆(A) has played a role since the beginning of the subject. Arazy and Solel show in [14] that a surjective linear isometry T : A → B between unital operator algebras takes the diagonal onto the diagonal. It then follows from a result of Kadison [212] that T (1) is a unitary v in ∆(B), so that v ∗ T (·) is a unital isometry of A onto B. They also show that for unital surjective isometries, T (xy + yx) = T (x)T (y) + T (y)T (x) for all x, y ∈ A. See also [196]. If A is a unital C ∗ -algebra, then a = sup |ϕ(a)| for a ∈ A+ , the supremum over states ϕ of A. There is a result resembling this which is true if A is an operator algebra. Namely, define a matrix state of A to be a completely contractive unital ϕ : A → Mn . Then a = sup ϕ(a) for any a ∈ A, where the supremum is taken over matrix states of A. A similar formula holds for a ∈ M n (A). Indeed, suppose that A ⊂ B(H), that a ∈ Mn (A), and consider a finite subset of vectors in H on which a ‘achieves its norm’ within . Let K be the span of these vectors, let PK be the projection onto K, and let ϕ(x) = PK x|K . Since B(K) ∼ = Mm for some m, we may view ϕ as a matrix state on A. The result is now easy (see [69] and [394]). If A is an operator algebra which is not approximately unital, we say that a homomorphism π : A → B(H) is ∗-nondegenerate if the span of terms of the form c1 c2 · · · cn ζ, for ζ ∈ H and ci ∈ π(A) ∪ π(A)∗ , is dense in H. The universal representation defined in 2.4.4 is a good example of a ∗-nondegenerate representation. For operator algebras with cai, one can show that ∗-nondegeneracy coincides with our earlier notion of nondegeneracy. Indeed, it is not hard to see using A.1.5 that an operator algebra A possesses a cai if and only if whenever π : A → B(H) is a ∗-nondegenerate completely contractive homomorphism, and whenever x ∈ H, then x ∈ [π(A)x] (see also [72]). Our book focuses on approximately unital operator algebras for the most part, however some analoguous theory of operator algebras with a one-sided cai may be found in [55] and [60]. 2.2: The constructions in this section are well-known, with the exception of a few of the facts mentioned in 2.2.3. An early study of the spatial tensor product of nonselfadjoint algebras may be found in [316]. The constructions in 2.2.9 and
98
Notes and historical remarks
2.2.10 we have heard attributed to Arveson. The norm relation in 2.2.11 is wellknown (e.g. see Chapter IV Section 2 in [159] for a generalization); its usage in 2.2.11 is taken from [279]. A frequently used variant of the algebra in 2.2.10, is its subalgebra with repeated diagonal entries. Simple modifications to 2.2.1 show that the ‘c0 -sum’ (see 1.2.17) of operator algebras is an operator algebra. Many other general operator algebra constructions have been considered by others. As just one example, we mention the work of Gilfeather and Smith (see [170, 385], and references therein; in the former paper the automorphisms of certain operator algebras are parametrized and studied using the weak* Haagerup tensor product of 1.6.9). 2.3: The BRS theorem is due to Blecher, Ruan, and Sinclair [69]. The nonunital case appeared first in [373]. The proof given here is due to Le Merdy [246]; we have presented this proof in part because of its capacity to generalize. In fact one need not assume associativity of the product in the BRS theorem, this is automatic as proved in the original paper [69]. That the quotient Banach algebra of an operator algebra A by an ideal is isometrically isomorphic to an operator algebra, was proved by Cole when A is a function algebra [424], and then extended to general operator algebras by Bernard [34] and Lumer [259] in the early 1970s. A direct proof of this may also be found in [337], and it is used there to give an alternative proof of the BRS theorem. It is an interesting open question as to whether every unital Banach algebra for which von Neumann’s inequality holds, is an operator algebra (e.g. see [125]). Interpolation of operator algebras considered as Banach algebras was briefly studied in [415]. See [44, 62] for interpolation in the sense considered here. Nonselfadjoint direct limit operator algebras have been well studied; Power used the BRS theorem to construct such algebras in [350]. In [241] there is an explicit identification of the ‘C ∗ -envelope’ (see Section 4.3) of an interesting class of direct limit algebras. See also [111, 112, 351] for example. Matrix normed algebras were first mentioned in [42]; it was observed there that the Fourier algebras of a locally compact group were examples of these. They were used extensively in the middle 1990s by Effros, Ruan, and Kraus, under the name completely contractive Banach algebra, in order to study Banach algebras which have an operator space structure of specific interest. For example, see [377] or Chapter 16 of [149], and references therein. 2.4: The name ‘C ∗ -cover’ is due to Muhly we believe, however the concept ∗ itself was developed by Arveson. The maximal universal C ∗ -algebra Cmax (A) of an operator algebra A was mentioned in [67, 64], and it (and the associated ‘universal representation of A’) played a crucial role in [50, 52, 72]. The latter ∗ (A), and paper treated the nonunital case first. Another construction of Cmax Example 2.4.5, may be found in [50]. Duncan has established some functorial ∗ (·), and computed it for certain interesting classes of algebras properties of Cmax (e.g. see [129]). Note that saying that one C ∗ -cover (B, j) is dominated by another (B , j ) in the ordering defined in 2.4.1, is the same as saying that if one forms any poly-
Basic theory of operator algebras
99
nomial p in variables coming from A and the set {a∗ : a ∈ A} of formal adjoints, then pB ≤ pB . In this case, the kernel I of the canonical ∗-homomorphism from B to B is called a boundary ideal of B for A. Note that then B /I ∼ = B as C ∗ -algebras, and indeed also as C ∗ -covers of A. We show in Theorem 4.3.1 that a minimal C ∗ -cover exists in this ordering. We will take this fact for granted in the following discussion. Let A be an operator algebra, and consider the family of all C ∗ -covers of A. This has two extremal elements, namely the maximal one ∗ (A) from 2.4.3, and a minimal one whose existence we are taking on faith, Cmax and which we denote by Ce∗ (A). For any C ∗ -cover (B, i) of A, we define KB to ∗ be the kernel of the ∗-homomorphism Cmax (A) → B provided by 2.4.2. It is easy to see from the universal property in 2.4.2 that (B, i) ≤ (B , i ) if and only if KB ⊂ KB . In particular (B, i) and (B , i ) are equivalent with respect to the canonical equivalence relation on C ∗ -covers, if and only if KB = KB . Next consider the ideal J defined to be KB in the particular case when B = Ce∗ (A). Then by the above universal property of these covers, it is easy to see that K B ⊂ J for any C ∗ -cover B of A. Hence such KB is an ideal of J. Conversely, for any ∗ closed ideal K of J, it is easy to see that Cmax (A)/K is a C ∗ -cover of A. Putting all the above together, we have that the correspondence B → K B is a bijective order-reversing correspondence between the partially ordered set C(A) of equivalence classes of C ∗ -covers of A, and the set of closed ideals of J. The last set is a lattice. Indeed by [122] 3.2.2, this lattice is lattice isomorphic to the set of open sets in a topological space, namely the open sets in the spectrum Jˆ of the C ∗ -algebra J. We recall that the spectrum Jˆ is the set of the equivalence classes of irreducible representations of J. Thus we have shown that if A is an operator algebra, then C(A) is a complete lattice, which is lattice anti-isomorphic to a certain topology. More precisely, C(A) is lattice anti-isomorphic to the set of open sets in the generally ˆ In this canonical way, one can associate a non-Hausdorff topological space J. topological space with any operator algebra A. It is an interesting exercise to compute this topological space explicitly in the case that A = T 2 , using 2.4.5. The matrix factorization idea and several of the key examples in this section are from [67]. Some remarks on [67], and a list of other examples that may be treated in this framework, including the enveloping operator algebra discussed here, may be found in [45]. In connection with 2.4.14, it should be noticed that since von Neumann’s inequality does not extend to the case of three commuting contractions [416], the unital operator algebra O(N30 ) cannot be isometrically identified with the tridisc algebra A(D3 ) ⊂ C(T3 ). Pisier put the