Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy Lessons from Brazil
William R. Nylen
Participatory Democracy versus ...
66 downloads
1829 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy Lessons from Brazil
William R. Nylen
Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy
This page intentionally left blank
Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy: Lessons from Brazil By
William R. Nylen
PARTICIPATORY DEMOCRACY VERSUS ELITIST DEMOCRACY
© William R. Nylen, 2003. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews. First published 2003 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN™ 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 and Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, England RG21 6XS. Companies and representatives throughout the world. PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN 1–4039–6306–1 hardback Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Nylen, William R. Participatory democracy versus elitist democracy: lessons from Brazil/by William R. Nylen. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references (p.) and index. ISBN 1–4039–6306–1 (alk. paper) 1. Democracy—Brazil. 2. Political participation—Brazil. 3. Elite (Social sciences)—Brazil. I. Title: Participatory democracy versus elitist democracy. II. Title. JL2481.N94 2003 320.981—dc21
2003048605
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Design by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India. First edition: October, 2003 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
For Nize
This page intentionally left blank
Table of Contents
Preface and Acknowledgments Foreword Chapter 1
ix xiii
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics in the United States
1
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics in Brazil
13
Chapter 3
Participatory Democracy in Theory
27
Chapter 4
Participatory Democracy in Practice—Brazil’s Workers’ Party and the Participatory Budget
35
The Orçamento Participativo in Betim, Minas Gerais
51
Examining the Claims of Proponents of the Participatory Budget
61
Examining the Claims of Critics of the Participatory Budget
91
Chapter 2
Chapter 5 Chapter 6 Chapter 7 Chapter 8 Conclusion
Administering the Participatory Budget— Ideology and Dedication
131
Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy—Lessons from Brazil
145
Notes
157
Annex 1: Questionnaire for Delegates and Councilors of the Participatory Budget, 1998
209
viii
●
Table of Contents
Annex 2: Characteristics of 1998 OP Delegates (Respondents) in Betim and Belo Horizonte
213
Bibliography
217
Index
239
Preface and Acknowledgments
T
his is a book about problems and promises of democracy at the beginning of a new millennium. It started out as a book more specifically about Brazilian democracy, reflecting one North American’s ongoing discovery of, and fascination with, Brazilian politics. During the actual writing of the book, however, in the United States of the late 1990s and early 2000s, I found myself discovering numerous and suggestive parallels between my research in Brazil and my daily attention to politics at home. The book quickly evolved, then, into a more explicitly comparative analysis of what I saw to be the problems of turn-of-the-millennium democracy in both Brazil and the United States. In fact, the more I researched and read about these problems, the more I discovered that they were shared to a greater or lesser degree by a great many other contemporary democracies throughout the world. But I’m getting ahead of myself. From my first visit to Brazil in 1986 and through subsequent visits, I sometimes fancied myself to be in the position of the great French social philosopher, Alexis de Tocqueville, who in visiting the early nineteenth century United States and in writing his famous Democracy in America, could not help but compare what he saw in North America with what he knew and felt most intensely back home in France. Tocqueville felt that many of the social and political processes he observed in North America—as well as the normative and prescriptive conclusions he drew from those observations— were comparable in important respects with similar processes in France. I have to admit that I first began to think this way while living in Brazil for two years during the Reagan–Bush era of American politics (late 1987 to mid-1989). Brazil’s staggering social and economic inequalities appeared to offer a glimpse into the future of neoconservativism in the United States that began with the Reagan administration in the early 1980s.1 While that argument may have been stretching the rules of comparability a bit thin, my propensity to think comparatively continues to provide me with new questions and insights regarding both countries.2
x
●
Preface and Acknowledgments
One such insight led me on an eight-year (so far) research journey from the megacity of São Paulo to the tiny fishing village of Icapuí and the drought-parched interior town of Quixadá in the Northeastern state of Ceará, then to the industrial towns of João Monlevade, Timoteo, Ipatinga, and Betim, and the capital city of Belo Horizonte in the Centraleastern state of Minas Gerais. In each of these visits, I went in search of information about localized efforts undertaken by Brazil’s Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores: PT) to democratize the country’s infamously elitist politics by opening up local politics to so-called popular political participation—that is, to individuals and groups historically ignored by or excluded from political decision-making processes. The more I researched and wrote about these cases of “popular democratic governance” (or Participatory Democracy) and the social and political ills they were attempting to address, the more I thought about possible lessons they could offer to North Americans increasingly disillusioned with and alienated from their own political system. Could it be that Brazil—notorious for its social inequality and weak democracy—could offer valuable political lessons to North Americans about how to address our own political problems?3 In attempting to answer that question in this book, I have in mind at least two interested audiences. One is made up of fellow Brazilianists and Latin Americanists and others interested in democratization and political development in Latin America and the so-called Developing World. This first audience is, perhaps, the traditional one for a social science book based on a case study from Latin America. A second audience, however, is made up of those not necessarily or primarily interested in Brazil or Latin America, per se, but interested in experiments in participatory democracy designed to make democratic government, in general, more accessible and more responsive to average citizens. Like Tocqueville, I find myself in both camps. As I delved into the Brazilian cases of popular participation, I became increasingly aware that their implications went beyond even the Brazilian and American cases. Practical experiments in Participatory Democracy kept revealing themselves to me, sometimes in unlikely places: Japan, Jamaica, Canada, Uruguay, Bolivia, and South Africa, to name but a few. I discovered that major development organizations, like the United Nations Development Program, the Interamerican Foundation, and the World Bank, were keenly interested in popular participation and its impact on improving the long-term success and sustainability of their development projects. Similarly, important public policy institutes, like the Unión Iberoamericana de Municipalistas, were closely monitoring and studying participatory mechanisms of public administration for their citizenship-enhancing outcomes. And, of course, I discovered a growing literature on participatory democratic
Preface and Acknowledgments
●
xi
theory coming from my academic colleagues primarily in the fields of political science and sociology. I offer this book as a humble contribution to the work of that community of practitioners and researchers; and I offer it as an introduction to that community’s concerns and hopes for fellow North Americans who believe that democracy-in-practice can and must be something more than a virtually exclusive game of moneyed elites and “special interests,” empty media sound bites, and increasingly dissatisfying choreographed campaigns. No man is an island, and I have been assisted in myriad ways by innumerable people in the long process leading up to completion of this book. Inevitably, no short “acknowledgment” can faithfully perform the task of including everyone who has contributed in one way or another. Nonetheless, one must make the worthwhile effort. So, first, I wish to thank all of the many Brazilians whose formal interviews, private conversations, published and unpublished works, and friendships over the years have formed the building blocks for my own thoughts and analyses. I can only hope that my interpretations and presentations live up to the faith you so graciously invested in me. In particular, for their assistance well above and beyond the call of duty, I wish to thank Eriberto Barbosa Gama, Flávia de Paula Duque Brasil, Luiz Henrique de Oliveira Cunha, Osvaldo Fiori, Maria Auxiliadora Gomes, Maria Beatriz Gonçalvez, Jésus Lima, Gilberto Lisboa, Otilie Macedo Pinhero, Geraldo Margela, Elke Reagan de Oliveira, Laercio José Ribeiro, João and Teresa Rodrigues, José and Celi Rodrigues Leão, Eugenio Salvio Lobo, Mônica Maria Castro de Sousa, and Nara Lúcia de Bragança Teixeira. These are the people without whom I could not have carried out my field work in Brazil. I also wish to thank my loving and patient wife, Nize Rita Nylen, and my sons, John João Nylen and Russell Wright Nylen. Not that they were dragged kicking and screaming to Brazil all those summers. But they did have to put up with my rather odd definition of being on vacation: field research two-tothree hundred miles away from the family for weeks at a time, and constant reading and writing . . . always writing. And I want to thank my mother, Vivien Wright Torrey, and my stepfather, Donald Robert Torrey, for their unwavering support over the years. It was 1976 when you brought home that announcement about a summer foreign exchange opportunity in Mexico. Thanks, mom. It’s made all the difference. Finally, thanks to my mentors over the years for kindling the spark: Carla Robbins, Bruce Bagley, Riordan Roett, Henrique Rattner, Doug Chalmers, and Al Stepan. Thanks, as well, to supportive colleagues along the way, including Paul Haber, Anne Hallum, Kathryn Hochstetler, Mimi Keck, Peter Kingstone, Scott Martin, Tony Pereira, Tim Power, John Schorr, and Bill Smith.
This page intentionally left blank
Foreword
W
illiam Nylen has written a wonderful little book about the creation of vibrant democratic participation in a society struggling with elitist politics and citizen alienation. No, this book is not about the United States—nor about Britain, France, or Germany—though one might well wish that it were. It is about Brazil, one of those “Third World” nations that we so often dismiss as “developing” democracies, which have yet to enter the family of established democratic systems and thus have much left to learn from America or its European counterparts. In truth, as Nylen makes clear, students and scholars of established politics in the United States and elsewhere have much to learn from Third World nations such as Brazil. In Brazil, political activists struggle with severe problems of poverty and crime far greater than our own, while also confronting the sort of elitist politics and mass disengagement that predominates within contemporary established democracies. If proponents of democracy have reason to despair about the future of democracy in United States and Western Europe, they would seem to have even more reason for concern in Brazil. Yet in the face of such obstacles, activists committed to the long-term empowerment of Brazil’s impoverished mass citizenry have embraced reformist strategies that hold out real hope for the involvement of nonelite citizens in democratic politics. Nylen tells the story of one such reform effort. The reform effort Nylen examines is the implementation of “Participatory Budgets” in the policy decision-making of the towns and cities governed by Brazil’s Workers’ Party. As in other democracies, Brazil has local as well as state and national governments that are elected by voters, with these governments including not only mayors, governors, and presidents but city councils and legislatures. And as in other contemporary democracies, such elections are dominated by money and by highly organized interest groups, so that social and economic elites tend to have considerable influence on politics, thereby generating elitist politics, mass disengagement, and
xiv
●
Foreword
limited attention to the concerns of the poor. To offset such developments, the Workers’ Party has created participatory budgets as a process to insure that any and all citizens can have leverage on government decision-making. In communities with participatory budgets, the local administration must call neighborhood meetings throughout the city to discuss the next fiscal year’s budget, particularly the spending priorities for public works projects. All citizens can attend these meetings and nominate a list of public works priorities for their neighborhood, as well as for the city. Participants then vote on which projects to give priority and on who among them will serve as delegates to attend the city-wide assembly that will vote on a final list of budget priorities. Those results are then presented to the city council, and the delegates are allowed to discuss and defend the various proposals before the council. The overall process provides a way in which common citizens can influence the budget proposals that city councils debate, instead of leaving such influence to well-heeled citizens or well-organized interests. It can also create considerable pressure on city council members to attend or participate in the local meetings whereby citizens shape the participatory budget and to heed citizens budget requests. Lest the reader forget, Nylen is describing a process of citizen participation in the creation of city budgets in a nation in which common citizens are extremely poor—far more so than average citizens in established “North Atlantic” democracies. While most citizens do not actually attend such meetings, preoccupied as they are by issues of daily survival and subsistence living, thousands of them do, and in the process appear to have some considerable influence on local officials and budget debates. But the important question to Nylen, concerned as he is with the health of modern democracies and the lessons of the Brazilian experience for other nations, is whether the existence of participatory budgets appears to have positive consequences for participatory democracy in Brazil. As a social scientist interested not simply in identifying innovative democratic reforms but assessing their empirical consequence, Nylen seeks to answer this question through systematic empirical research. Nylen’s research strategy is two-fold. First, he engages in in-depth personal interviews with a large number of local officials and citizen activists, seeking to understand from them the nature of their personal experiences with the participatory budgets. These “qualitative” interviews form much of the empirical basis for the book’s core narrative while also providing great insight into the operation of the participatory budget process. His extensive quotes from these interviews bring to life common citizens who may be engaging in political action for the first time, helping us to visualize and
Foreword
●
xv
understand them. Moreover, his interviews with Workers’ Party activists make clear that elites in democratic politics are not always just single-minded seekers of reelection, or machine bosses using patronage to consolidate community power; they can be public servants deeply committed to social betterment. Yet, as a balanced and objective analyst, Nylen also gives elected elites and government officials their due, reporting their comments on participatory budgets in an evenhanded manner that serves to document the limits and pitfalls of participatory budgets, as seen from the standpoint of city council members and mainstream officials. In addition, Nylen has surveyed a subset of delegates to the participatory assemblies, and subjects these interviews to systematic quantitative analysis in order to determine whether the participatory budget reforms are aiding mass participatory engagement. Are the existence of participatory budgets actually empowering common citizens, broadening the range of citizens who are represented in policy deliberations, and sustaining the engagement of common citizens in mass participatory politics? Or, despite the hoopla, are participatory budgets ultimately a bust when it comes to engaging mass citizens in democratic policy-making—yet one more example of the difficulty or impossibility of creating institutional arrangements that nurture participatory democracy, and thereby one more testament to the inherent preimminence of elitist politics? I will let Bill Nylen present the findings from his mass surveys, walking you through them step by step. As a genuine social scientist, committed to systematic inquiry and objective empirical analysis, Bill pulls no punches. Concerned as he is about the strengthening of democracy through mass participation, he might like to tell you that a participatory budget is the magic bullet that empowers the common citizen and slays the elitist dragon. But that is not what he finds, and that is not what he reports. Instead, Nylen paints a complex, discerning, and true portrait of the effect of participatory budgets on the common citizens of Brazil. Part of his story is disturbing. Thus he reminds us that in a nation characterized by great poverty, the poorest of the poor may be so impoverished that they simply lack the time, strength, or energy to participate in politics. Similarly, he determines that the empowerment of common citizens is a difficult and tenacious problem, so that relatively few citizens engage in participatory budgets who have not previously participated in some form of politics. The existence of participatory budgets does not draw the disengaged into the political battle except in special and limited cases. One the other hand, much of his story is hopeful. Thus, for example, women participate far more equally as a result of participatory budgets than they would through membership on city councils. The moderately poor do
xvi
●
Foreword
have greater input into policy-making than they otherwise would. City councils feel subjected to much greater oversight, and are thereby less likely to cave into clientelist politics or patronage influence than they might were participatory budgets absent. And those common citizens drawn to politics by mass participatory movements are more likely to sustain their long-term involvement in politics if additional outlets for effective participation exist, such as participatory budgets. While a participatory budget may not empower the disengaged or slay the dragon, it does help sustain the participation of engaged activists and keep the dragon at bay. Most critically, Nylen’s story reminds us that the struggle for meaningful democracy is a continuing one, with many paths yet to be trod and many strategies for democratic enhancement yet to be pursued. Moreover, even if participatory innovations have their limits, as does a participatory budget, they also can add in important and measurable ways to the quality of mass political involvement. Thus the budgetary processes in the Brazilian cities Nylen examines appear much more vibrant and responsive to mass citizen input, particularly the input of the poor, than is my sense with respect to American cities. Reading about participatory budgets in Brazil, against the backdrop of the stunted and elitist politics of contemporary American democracy, one wonders why “we” didn’t think of such a participatory reform, and why we have failed to join the list of nations he presents who are now utilizing it. Despite being about Brazil, and in many ways precisely because it is about such a developing democracy, Nylen’s book has much to say to students of American politics and of established democracies in general. In truth, after reading “Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy,” I was left to wonder whether the phrase “established democracy” may in fact be an oxymoron. Perhaps any nation with an “established” democratic order is a nation that will inherently generate elitist dominance and mass disengagement, ceasing thereby to be a truly vibrant and true democracy. In contrast, a nation continually in the process of developing and transforming its democracy, particularly through the broadening and deepening of mass participation in its central policy decisions, may well be the more authentic and innovative democracy, no matter how poor its citizenry or poorly established and routinized its rules and procedures. Perhaps we in established democracies have failed to embrace participatory reforms such as the one examined here by Bill Nylen precisely because our procedures are so established and rigid, our elites have come to so totally dominate them, and our citizens are so fully disillusioned that new and truly innovative participatory processes are impossible to envision, much less to
Foreword
●
xvii
implement. To imagine thousands of American citizens joining together in local meetings in their neighborhoods, and then in collective assemblies, and then at city council meetings, pushing for the budget priorities they have embraced through local deliberation and mass votes—that is a vision worthy of de Tocqueville. Reading about Brazil, I am left to wonder when it is that we will join the ranks of “developing” democracies and push beyond elitism to truer forms of mass democratic participation. It is in this spirit that I recommend Bill Nylen’s masterful little book to you. It is a rare find—walking the line carefully and effectively between research monograph and classroom text, between normative advocacy and objective scholarship, between democratic theory and empirical reality, between an in-depth grasp of local politics in Brazil and insightful awareness of the implications of his story for First World nations such as the United States. I found myself thinking about the possibilities for mass democratic participation in new ways after reading “Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy.” I also found myself wanting to share it with friends, colleagues, and students. I suspect that you will as well. Lawrence C. Dodd University of Florida May 9, 2003
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 1
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics in the United States
N
orth Americans at the beginning of the twenty-first century have what can only be called a schizophrenic love–hate relationship with their democratic political system. On the one hand, we hate politics, most of all, we hate politicians and bureaucrats. On the other hand, we’re convinced that we have the best political system in the world. How is it possible to feel so proud of something you hate so intensely?1 Some would argue that a good part of the puzzle lies in today’s particular crop of politicians. Election year 2000, for example, gave us Al Gore and George W. Bush. Each was criticized for talking a lot but actually saying very little—minimal substance, minimal convictions—all for the sake, paradoxically, of not alienating potential supporters. Surely, there are better, more inspiring politicians out there . . . somewhere. Others might point to the way our two major parties have evolved. In this day and age, the democratic and republican parties are essentially fund-raising machines. While attacking each other for pandering to “special interests,” it is undeniably clear to most Americans that both parties have become increasingly beholden to big money contributors—extremely wealthy individuals, corporations and corporate lobbying organizations—many of which have been proven to be, shall we say, “ethically challenged.”2 The vast majority of Americans can’t pony up with the Big Money, and it’s only logical that growing numbers would be upset over their “unconstitutional” insignificance.
2
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
As if that’s not bad enough, political parties have the maddening capacity to turn anything and everything into seemingly irresolvable conflict. Most Americans seem to believe that all problems have solutions. Thus the popularity of the word “bipartisan.” But American politics, since the 1980s, has been anything but bipartisan. Indeed, the word “politics” is synonymous in most people’s eyes with “gridlock” and the incapacity of politicians to reach a reasonable and just compromise.3 Surely, parties could do a better job in promoting negotiations and compromise for the good of the country. But whether they hate today’s politicians or political parties or both, many Americans continue to believe that our political system itself—constitutional representative democracy—is essentially sound and good. To them, the problem lies with those who have somehow abused democracy.4 Most believe that if we could just “throw the bums out” (maybe even force them out with a gimmick like term limits), or start up a viable third party, or maybe even institute restrictions on campaign financing, we could reclaim our democracy and be proud of it once again. Reform, in other words, is desirable and even possible. But where and how to begin? What Democracy Is, and What It Is Not Rather than answer that last question right away, let me pose a much more provocative one in its stead: What if the problem is not just with today’s politicians or parties? What if bad politicians and ugly parties were the result of the two very pillars of American society: representative democracy and free enterprise capitalism? Most Americans cannot even read those words without feeling angry or defensive. That’s how strongly we have come to identify, not only with the ideals of representative democracy and capitalism, but with a sense that these ideals are fully realized in the original design of our democratic system and in the legal and social structures that underpin our economy. Since this is a book primarily on democracy, let’s focus on the ideal versus the reality of representative democracy in America.5 It’s certainly true that Americans’ dual commitment to an ideal of democracy (“liberty and justice for all”) and to an institutional design of representative democratic politics (constitutional government, checks and balances, bill of rights, etc.) is the envy of many throughout the world. It goes a long way toward explaining our political stability in the face of many challenges over the years, from civil wars to great depressions to political scandals. Stability, however, has a nasty habit of transforming itself into stagnation and even decay. And that’s where I believe we are today in terms of our country’s political development: stagnant and beginning to decay.
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
3
Let me begin to explain by pointing out that political stagnation and decay are the absolute antithesis of democracy. In the words of Italian political scientist, Norberto Bobbio, “For a democratic system, the process of ‘becoming,’ of transformation, is its natural state. Democracy is dynamic, despotism is static and always essentially the same.”6 Democracy is dynamic because, first and foremost, it is a conflictual process of inclusionary adaptation both reflecting and spurring on changes in the overall balance of social and political power. While originally a means of adapting to the competing demands of a relatively small number of rich and powerful groups and individuals by sharing power, public revenues, and responsibilities among them (rather than fighting it out until one individual held complete and unchallenged power), the history of democracy in the West has seen such inclusionary adaptation extend itself outward from the well-to-do and the well-connected, deeper and deeper into the ranks of average citizens: working men, women, people of color, etc.. Throughout the twentieth century, democratic adaptation came to include the extension of governmentprovided social goods and services in favor of citizens suffering the effects of various types of market failure, from economic downturns, to entrenched poverty rooted in ethnic and gender discrimination, to urban decay, to environmental degradation.7 Such adaptation has always followed upon a groundswell of actual or potential public unrest. Each generation has seen its social movements of the excluded and/or ignored arguing and struggling for equality and justice—for inclusion as citizens—against the exclusionary practices of the powerful, the well connected, and/or the simply intolerant. Such struggles, and their periodic victories, constitute the very definition of democracy.8 This can be seen repeatedly in the development of democracy in the United States. Let’s look at three different examples. The very fact that the U.S. Constitution of 1788 was drawn up and ratified in the shadow of Shays’ Rebellion (1786–1787)—an armed uprising “from below” of indebted Western Massachusetts farmers against the state government’s high taxes and threats of imminent foreclosure on their farms—calls attention to the nature of the nation’s foundational legal document as part inclusionary concession, part exclusionary retrenchment. Most of the Founding Fathers were landowners; many were slaveholders. They were an educated and moneyed elite among a virtual sea of slaves and uneducated small farmers and shopkeepers. While progressive for the time, most remained as true to their class and status interests as they could while, at the same time, touting the inclusive “democratic” nature of the new Constitution. And for the day, thanks in no small part to the threat of Shays’ Rebellion, it was inclusive and democratic. By the same token, activism from labor and small farmers’ groups in
4
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
the latter part of the nineteenth century and the concerted efforts of Progressive reformers in the first decade of the twentieth century ultimately changed the Constitutionally mandated, but corruption-filled, indirect election of U.S. Senators via state legislatures into direct elections (the 17th Amendment of 1913). Similarly, the Civil Rights legislation, of the late 1950s and early 1960s, followed upon at least a decade of grassroots civil rights activism by such groups as the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee and the Southern Council of Baptist Churches, and such previously unknown individuals as Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King Jr. Only when such protests threatened to turn violent in 1963, however, did Presidents John Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson and the Democratic Party introduce the landmark Civil Rights legislation of 1964 and 1965, inviting moderate leaders to share in claiming victory for their cause while, at the same time, pointedly excluding more radical claims and claimants. Once we understand this fundamental point about what democracy actually means (i.e. a conflictual process of inclusionary adaptation), we can also see the problem with the way most people define democracy: the so-called procedural definition of democracy—universal suffrage, regular and free elections, freedom of association and political organization. Rather than being defining end-points of democracy, these important procedures and institutions should be seen as hard-won democratic victories emerging from an ongoing historical process of democratic struggle for inclusion. They exemplify the outcomes of democratic adaptive mechanisms so far, at the same time that they constitute important building blocks for future democratic gains.9 So when I say that democracy today in the United States is stagnant and beginning to decay, I mean that the process of inclusionary adaptation has essentially stopped, even as the democratic institutions and procedures of the past continue to function, albeit without much enthusiasm or participation. Elitist Democracy We find ourselves today in an unhealthy situation where the powerful, well connected, and intolerant have become extremely well adept at using those institutions and procedures to further concentrate wealth and power among themselves.10 In the process, what were originally constituted as inclusionary mechanisms are transformed into mechanisms of exclusion. This is what I call “Elitist Democracy.” In the United States, socio-economic influence and political-institutional control/exclusion come together primarily in the realm of campaign financing
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
5
and in the political propaganda that emerges from the now-constant campaign process.11 Politicians from both major parties are dependent on wealthy individuals and corporations to finance their increasingly expensive runs for office. Political fund-raising becomes a full-time activity, oftentimes requiring more time from incumbents than legislating or administering the public good. At the same time, the present and future interests of large donors have become increasingly dependent upon decisions (and, perhaps even more important, on non decisions) made in the halls of Congress and in the Executive branch, as well as in the interpretive “spin” that both parties put on events and political agenda items.12 Both parties, in fact, have done their utmost to make us dislike—and, therefore, turn our attention away from—democratic politics and government. Since the early 1980s, the Republican Party has been phenomenally successful in waging war against the State, routinely identified with an inherently out-of-touch “Big Government” full of lazy bureaucrats distributing tax-guzzling government handouts to the undeserving poor-because-theywant-to-be-poor. Republicans have waged this war even as they have diverted attention from the reality and political implications of growing socioeconomic inequality and the “capture” or “colonization” of the State by corporate interests and their well-financed interest groups. Republican-induced nervousness about an overactive national government readily taps into a deeply ingrained and still-popular strain of North American political culture of “rugged individualism” and distrust of authority (remember the words on our first flag: “Don’t Tread On Me”). Meanwhile, the Democratic Party has largely failed in mounting a progressive attack on the antidemocratic effects of economic and social privilege and “corporate welfare” (“crony capitalism”) largely because they, themselves, are dependent upon Big Money contributions just like the Republicans, and because they have adopted a strategy of fighting the Republicans at the polls by moving to the Right to attract more “moderates.” It turns out that the institutions and procedures of representative democracy form a perfect framework for the creation and solidification of a mutual interdependency between political and economic elites.13 Meanwhile, the rest of us find our “official” political relevance reduced to the periodic casting of votes for one or another already bought-and-sold candidate. Typically, no party or candidate acknowledges the extent to which they have sold themselves to the highest bidders. Yet the buying and selling is obvious to the rest of us. So the parties and candidates end up looking like liars or, at best, panderers. Elections end up looking like saturation marketing campaigns for competing “products” that are, in fundamental respects, the same, and that so many of us don’t really like or want anyway.14
6
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
But partisanship and ideology aside, the growth of the modern regulatory, welfare and military-industrial-corporate State really does bring with it a host of antidemocratic tendencies well captured in Edward Rubin’s description of the contemporary “administrative state” which, he argues, “exponentially increases the difficulties that political representation creates for the theory of self-government”: An administrative state is not governed by elected representatives, but by a vast number of appointed, specially trained, hierarchically organized officials. Elections provide the means of choosing a small number of representatives who are authorized to issue commands to these officials and to supervise their actions. Administrators make the vast majority of government decisions, including many of the most important ones, on their own. In short, elected representatives are only partially responsive to the voters because the inherent limitations of the representative and administrative processes limit voter control over the government. Any control that the people themselves exercise over governmental operations is thus doubly attenuated by the intervening representatives and administrators, and far removed from anything that could plausibly be described as self-government.15 Rubin’s administrative state challenges democratic representation in much the same way that the German Sociologist, Max Weber, foresaw modern “bureaucratic rationalization” increasingly diminishing the scope of democratically elected political leadership and, indeed, of the individual liberty of all citizens.16 Both Rubin and Weber, however, clearly understood that only a large and powerful State could carry out the necessary tasks of administering, regulating, and policing an increasingly complex society while, at the same time, compensating for the social inequalities inevitably produced by capitalism’s “creative destruction.” Both authors, then, present us with the same political challenge: how to find a way to democratically oversee and monitor or, at the very least, to politically check and balance such a powerful State? Unfortunately, contemporary representative democracy has not evolved in such a way as to meet that challenge. Instead, we seem to be following the arguments and prescriptions of a distant and frankly irrelevant past: the eigteenth-century neoclassical liberal critique of the Mercantilist and Absolutist State (e.g. Adam Smith) and/or the early twentieth-century neoliberal critique of the pre-Fascist and Socialist States (e.g. Friedrich Hayek). Contemporary republicans, however, use these same basic arguments
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
7
to attack and delegitimate a capitalist (not Mercantilist) and democratic (not Absolutist, or Fascist, or Socialist) State. Yet, when and where they gain elected office, they have cynically used that same “over-active” State to actively promote the interests primarily of wealthy campaign contributors, powerful corporations, and other established socio-economic elites. Democrats have responded with a strategy perhaps best characterized as “If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em.” So welfare programs for single mothers and poor children are cut to the bone, while subsidies to wealthy agribusinesses and tax cuts to the richest 1 percent reach record levels.17 Because public life is essentially closed to the majority and because public policy is increasingly focused on the wealthy minority, growing numbers of citizens retreat into their private lives. In the words of the American professor of politics and sociology, David Held: “If democratic life involves no more than a periodic vote, the locus of people’s activities will be the ‘private’ realm of civil society and the scope of their actions will depend largely on the resources they can command. Few opportunities will exist for citizens to act as citizens, as participants in public life.”18 For the great majority of nonelite Americans, politics, very simply, is what they—the wealthy and well connected—do. It’s not what we do. In the telling words of Richard M. Valelly, “It’s not that Americans are tuning out. They’re being left out.”19 Civic Disengagement Is there any wonder why so many people are cynical or simply dismissive of contemporary democratic politics? This cynicism and disillusionment has not gone unnoticed by social scientists. The North American political scientist, Robert Putnam, for example, made a name for himself in the 1990s by carefully chronicling North Americans’ “civic disengagement” in terms of low and declining voter turnouts (e.g. voter turnout for presidential elections declined more-or-less steadily from 1964 to 1996), increasing distrust in democratic politicians and processes (e.g. levels of distrust in government rose from 30 percent in 1966 to 75 percent in 1992), and declining levels of participation in organized civil society.20 So why don’t more people complain? First, I would argue that the growing majority of Americans who don’t vote are, in fact, complaining by “exiting” from democratic politics altogether. All Americans know they “should” vote. When they don’t vote, it’s because they feel that it’s not worth their time. Again, given the bought-andsold nature of contemporary democratic politics, where the voices of those
8
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
with hefty campaign contributions and/or the voices of faceless government bureaucrats are so much louder than the voices of common citizens, this is by no means irrational behavior.21 By the same token, the growth of “independent” voters and the flirtation with third-party politics in the 1990s, are further indications of rational dissatisfaction with the traditional political parties and politicians. Similarly, the jump in popular initiatives and referenda—effectively bypassing traditional representative institutions just as their creators in the Progressive Movement of the early twentieth century intended them to do—can be interpreted as a sign of dissatisfaction with status quo political institutions and processes.22 Second, many Americans don’t express their complaints about politics— vocally or by joining political groups—because they are engaged more-or-less full-time and more-or-less contentedly in the engaging world of consumer capitalism. Up to the year 2001, the economy had been booming for decades. And while economic inequality had been growing, and salaries for many Americans had been stagnant or actually declining in relative terms, the prices of most consumer goods were dropping, and credit cards had become universally available to all. Americans were swimming in toys and electronic distractions (many of which were now produced abroad by workers earning pennies to the dollars once earned by American workers). Americans were also swimming in mountains of consumer debt, hundreds of billions of dollars of it. At the same time, prior to the events of September 11, 2001, alienation and cynicism had themselves become hot commodities, especially in the entertainment and fashion industries, as the growing number of uninformed and disengaged noncitizens were invited to feel proud of their rejection of any notion of civic duty or responsibility, at the same time attracting younger and younger consumers into the lucrative fold of detached coolness. Of course, “detached coolness” is the perfect complement to bought-andsold politics. Each one reinforces and reconfirms the other. The more the citizens “just don’t care,” the more they “hate politics,” the more the politicians and the wealthy turn politics into their own exclusive game. The more that happens (and as long as the toys and distractions are readily available), the less the citizens care to dirty their hands messing with politics.23 Citizen Politics Finally—and somewhat counter to the forgoing discussion of civic disengagement—it turns out that some Americans do, in fact, complain about the policies and processes of elitist democracy. North American
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
9
political scientists, Russell Dalton and Pippa Norris, have each contributed to a growing body of literature suggesting that, while dissatisfied with the reality of contemporary democracy, a substantial number of American (and European) citizens have gone beyond either rejecting politics outright, or simply “playing the game.” Instead, they are actively reengaging in nonpartisan forms of political participation such as issue-specific social movements, local-level community activism, and civic and philanthropic voluntarism: what Dalton calls “citizen politics” and Norris calls “critical citizens.”24 And while each one sees these as potentially hopeful signs for the future, the continuing disconnect between these new forms of politics, on the one hand, and the well-entrenched official politics of political parties, politicians and their socioeconomic elite supporters, on the other, seems unlikely to stall the ongoing slide from today’s stable and stagnant democracy to tomorrow’s democratic decay. What we need, I would argue, is some sort of bridge to connect these two increasingly distinct realms of political activism. The alternative would either be a drift into more intense and possibly antidemocratic confrontation, or a withering of citizen politics into even more pronounced civic disengagement. What Me Worry? Some, however, might argue that so-called stagnant democracy is really not all that bad. If people freely choose to become disengaged from politics, can’t they freely choose to reengage whenever they wish? And isn’t it a good thing—an indication of governmental success in nurturing the market economy—that so many Americans are “swimming in toys”? In partial answer to the first question, we need to recognize that some public policies made outside of the light of public oversight cannot ever be reversed, not even by a widespread rebirth of civic activism. We cannot reclaim, for example, a pristine wilderness or a vital watershed destroyed by collusion between lawmakers and polluters. We cannot bring back to life consumers of dangerous or faulty products brought to market through collusion between lawmakers and unscrupulous or careless manufacturers. We cannot simply erase the debt incurred and charged to subsequent generations by collusion between lawmakers and well-heeled recipients of “corporate welfare,” pork barrel spending and nonsensical tax cuts for the rich.25 Neither can we easily restore the hopes and opportunities of generations of poor children lost to crime, drugs, and disease due to cutbacks in public education and the welfare state ordered by lawmakers in open collusion with corporate and wealthy interests touting fiscal discipline and a “fair” tax code.
10
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
Not only policies, but also democratic processes themselves can become difficult if not impossible to reclaim via a potential burgeoning of citizen politics. The two-party system is, perhaps, the biggest and longest lasting example: it has become so entrenched that no amount of periodic third-party activism has been capable of transforming its fairly rigid logic of competition toward the ideological center—which is to say, toward the ideologically imprecise and programmatically vague. One of the veritable laws of social science is that once born, institutionalized and peopled with a bureaucracy, organizations and procedures develop an active adversity to subsequent efforts at reform. Fortunately (or unfortunately, as the case may be), most Americans still have their families, jobs, communities . . . and their toys and distractions to fall back on. These afford them the opportunity to disengage from politics— to disengage from their anger and disappointment—and to “retreat into the personal” or into apolitical micro-communities of family and friends where they can still find a measure of happiness and a sense of purpose and belonging not available to them in the traditional arenas of democratic citizenship. Such happiness as they can find in such activities, however, does not cause political disengagement. Rather, it compensates for whatever psychological or ethical issues may emerge in the minds of individuals who know very well that they “should” care about politics, at least to the extent of voting, but who also know that politics in the United States is no longer “of the people, for the people, and by the people.” The national community of democratic citizenship is thereby exchanged for much smaller issue-specific, non-political, or even anti-political communities and/or isolated but materially comfortable individuals. Society as a whole becomes fragmented. In the meantime, those in charge of the formal institutions and processes of democracy have only to promote political “stability” and economic growth in order to maintain a de facto divide and rule strategy over the great majority of ex-citizens and the brave few voices in the wilderness, as it were, who continue to press the democratic ideal. Solutions? And now we come to the crux of the matter: a philosophical, or normative, question. Should we trust these “democratic” rulers? Are their material and political interests consistent with those of the “great majority of ex-citizens”? My answers to these questions are obvious from the way I have framed the discussion up to now. I am morally offended at the galloping inequality in our nation (now being politically institutionalized by efforts to abolish the
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
11
reforms of the Progressive Era, the New Deal and even the lukewarm reforms of the Clinton era). I am outraged at the ability of so many elected officials to let environmental degradation run rampant in return for a few campaign dollars and a process of “development” that disproportionately benefits a relative handful of the well placed. And I am alarmed at the potential for today’s civic disengagement to turn into tomorrow’s “uncivil movements” (as the line between angry “exit” and angry “voice” has historically been so easily breached by the democratically fatal combination of personal charisma, us-versus-them rhetoric and weak public commitment to democracy-asusual).26 Therefore, I conclude that we cannot trust those who would support the “divide and rule” status quo. Their interests are their interests, and no one else’s. An oligarchy, no matter how benevolent it would appear on the surface, is still an oligarchy. So what is the alternative? Let me recall one of the points I made earlier: that today’s bought-andsold politicians and parties, our increasingly disengaged citizenry, and the relative few and relatively isolated “critical citizens” are the natural and inevitable result of the institutions and procedures of representative democracy and the free market economy as each has evolved (or co-evolved) so far. That being so, we cannot simply “kick the bums out” or try to introduce a third party into the game. The game itself is flawed. It has become fundamentally elitist and exclusionary. For real democracy to reemerge, there must occur an inclusionary adaptation or a series of inclusionary adaptations on behalf of the excluded and ignored—that is, on behalf of so many Americans alienated, disengaged or otherwise isolated from contemporary official democratic politics. Representative democracy needs to be democratized. But where is the groundswell of political activism from below that has historically heralded in such inclusionary reforms? How can exclusionary elitism be countered if so many of the excluded and ignored prefer to “exit” from politics rather than raise their voices and join together against the injustice of political exclusion and social inequality? For those of us who see the problem of democratic stagnation and decay, who understand its implications, is there no other option than the self-defeating one of renouncing politics altogether or the exhausting one of “raging against the machine”? Those questions are the reasons for my writing this book. Hopefully, I’ve already been able to pass on something of their sense of urgency, at least from the point of view of someone who shares that sense. In the following chapters, I will look beyond the boundaries of the United States, first, in order to emphasize and illustrate that elitist democracy and
12
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
civic disengagement are by no means exclusively North American problems. The same will hold true for the existence of critical citizens and citizen politics. Then I will introduce a set of ideas and practices that purport to offer answers to the questions just posed by means of an alternative to the antidemocratic options of politics-as-usual, on the one hand, and the renunciation of politics (“exit”), on the other. That alternative is called “Participatory Democracy.” After introducing the idea and intellectual history behind the Participatory Democratic model, I will enter into the realm of Brazilian politics to explore a concrete example of Participatory Democracy in action: the Participatory Budget (Orçamento Participativo—OP) as practiced in the cities and states in Brazil that are administered by the Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores—PT), Latin America’s largest Left-wing party and the party of Brazil’s president as of 2003, Luís Ignacio Lula da Silva. Following an analysis of the OP—as representative of a series of efforts on the part of the PT to “democratize democracy” by way of Participatory Democratic innovations, I will argue that Participatory Democracy should be seen not so much as an alternative to representative democracy than as a complementary set of inclusionary institutional reforms that could help to harness the “social capital” inherent in citizen politics everywhere and, thereby, revive some of contemporary democracy’s lost luster. I will further argue that the model of Participatory Democracy, as a model, has the emotional appeal—and the mobilizing potential—of an ideology. It resonates with the well-known principles that have led so many people to revere democracy and, at the same time, to reject what democracy has become in today’s real world. It explicitly makes that distinction between what is and what should be; and it just as explicitly makes the claim that what should be could be. It is by no means a panacea, nor is it a Utopia. It may be, however, a blueprint for a necessary democratic revival in the twenty-first century.
CHAPTER 2
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics in Brazil
A
s argued in the last chapter, a growing number of North Americans have become cynical about or disillusioned with their country’s version of democracy—defined as the politicians, political parties, and special interests of the day. It turns out that the United States is merely one among many democratic countries with similarly low and/or declining rates of voter turnout, trust in politicians and belief in government efficacy. Among other long-term democracies, voter turnout records alone show Switzerland, New Zealand, the Netherlands, and France to be in a comparable situation.1 If we look more broadly at indices of public confidence in democratic leaders and in the performance of representative institutions, Japan and virtually all of Europe turn out to be, in the words of Susan Pharr and Robert Putnam, “disaffected democracies.”2 At the same time, many socalled emerging democracies in the former Soviet Union, Eastern Europe, and Latin America—especially Venezuela (since 1973), Colombia, Ecuador, Guatemala, Chile, Peru, Argentina (since the late 1990s), and Brazil—have been equally plagued by citizens’ disengagement and, in some cases, their engagement in “Antipolitics:” antidemocratic uncivil movements and Neopopulist demagoguery.3 As one should expect, political analysts have not been blind to this phenomenon. In the words of the American political scientist, Ken Roberts: “The proliferation of concepts such as ‘low-intensity democracy,’ and ‘schizophrenic democracy,’ ‘protected democracy,’ ‘exclusionary democracy,’ and ‘delegative democracy’ suggests that the initial
14
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
euphoria surrounding the demise of military dictatorships has yielded to a growing malaise regarding the ambiguous character and quality of new civilian regimes”.4 The long-time analyst of Latin American politics, Abraham Lowenthal, similarly notes “In country after country, polls show that most people although they still say they favor ‘democracy,’ are increasingly critical of the performance of democratic governments and deeply skeptical of all democratic political institutions.”5 Symptoms of Civic Disengagement in Brazil Brazil is a perfect representative case of civic disengagement and disaffected democracy.6 Its “index of voter alienation” (the sum of abstentions, blank and invalid votes during national elections) rose from 17.6 percent of eligible voters in 1989 to 33.39 percent in 1994, rising to a high of 40.19 percent in 1998 before dropping down to 28.13 percent in 2002.7 While voting is mandatory in Brazil, 49 percent of respondents in a 1998 poll said they would not vote if they had the choice. In that same year, 75 percent of respondents couldn’t remember whom they had voted for in the previous Congressional elections less than four years earlier.8 In another poll from 1998, respondents were asked which institutions contributed most, and which least, to the good of the country; Congressmen and Senators scored last, far behind bankers, businessmen, and even the armed forces.9 In a 1999 poll of voting-age residents of the state of São Paulo, 60 percent of respondents said they did not trust the national Congress; another 36 percent said they trusted it only a little. Forty-three percent said they couldn’t trust the President; another 49 percent said they trusted him only a little.10 Meanwhile, much of the literature of the 1980s and 1990s documents the decline of union membership and of participation in the grassroots organizations and social movements that had played a significant part in democratization processes in the mid-to-late 1970s and early 1980s.11 Implications and Explanations of Civic Disengagement in Brazil As alluded to in chapter one, one of the most predominant implications of civic disengagement is its tendency to spiral into a cycle of ever-increasing disillusionment with, and further disengagement from democratic politics. Individuals feel increasingly distant from democratic politics and begin to distance themselves even further by retreating into their private lives and into micro-communities of family, friends, and others more obviously “like themselves.”
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
15
In order to understand why that might be a problem, it’s worth emphasizing that when one is talking about democratic participation (or the lack thereof ), one is necessarily talking about individuals acting upon a feeling of citizenship (or the lack thereof ); that is, a sense of belonging (or not) to a political community that both defines and protects individual rights and responsibilities of membership in the broader society. According to Canadian political theorist, Ronald Beiner, these are issues “having to do with membership, national identity, civic allegiance, and all the commonalities of sentiment and obligation that prompt one to feel that one belongs to this political community rather than that political community . . .”12 The point here is that democracy depends upon the construction or reconstruction of a broadly diffused sense of belonging—or having the right to belong—to a (generally) national political community of protected individual rights and well-defined responsibilities. Without such a collective identity, the functioning of democracy is difficult if not impossible. In the history of Brazil, as in much of the so-called developing world, such a collective identity has been repeatedly thwarted by long-standing traditions of patron clientelism or patrimonialism where the game of politics is centered around individual politician’s distribution of patronage and “favors” (e.g. legislative votes, public funds, public sector jobs, etc.) and candidates’ promises of such, in exchange for political/financial support and votes.13 Describing patronage as one of the “guiding principles of Brazilian social organization” in the nineteenth century (and beyond), the American historian Richard Graham defines it as an “exchange of protection for loyalty, benefits for obedience” with obvious implications for social domination: . . . failure to obey or be loyal subjected one to punishment by the patron and left one openly vulnerable to exploitation by others. No dichotomy existed between force and benevolence: each drew its meaning from the other. [. . .] In a culture of genuine paternalism, the recipient [of a “favor”: a job, a contract, a public service, etc.] must see himself as a child, with cloying gratitude for a father’s benevolence that cloaks enormous relief at escaping punishment.14 The Brazilian anthropologist, Roberto DaMatta, explains that in rigidly hierarchical societies such as Brazil’s, in which personal connections (e.g. “who you know, not what you know”) are the dominant currency in all social transactions, there is nothing worse than to be reduced to being an anonymous individual “subjected to the impersonal codes of traffic, of supply and demand, and of all levels of government.”15 Brazilians attempt to
16
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
avoid this by “knowing one’s place” and staying there (e.g. staying close to one’s family, cultivating personal bonds of mutual support, and commitment to social “superiors” and “inferiors,” respecting politics and even economics as distant social realms controlled by and for “superiors”), although this is not usually a conscious decision.16 In such societies, the political game is highly personalistic. Political parties, for example, serve primarily as local-based electoral machines for elite political personalities who control and sometimes literally own them. Nationally, they exist in the sense of loosely organizing and uniting a number of these local-level machines and their leaders into a type of mutualaid society. These parties are neither ideologically coherent or issue-oriented, nor are they bureaucratically organized “catch-all” parties pursuing goals of interest articulation and intermediation. In fact, representation is not really on their agenda at all. In the words of the Argentine political scientist, Guillermo O’Donnell: Instead, there is the rule of those individuals who, by virtue of their traditionally dominant position, in exchange for “favors” expect continued loyalty from their subordinates. [ . . . ] To the extent that this type of relationship prevails, both a requisite and a result of it is the fragmentation of the popular sector, as well as a fierce resistance to any effort on the part of the subordinated classes to organize as collective subjects and to be represented as such.17 Brazil’s modernization (urbanization, industrialization, advances in public education and health, etc.) throughout the twentieth century transformed these traditions of locally rooted patron-clientelism and personalism but did not eliminate their basic operating logic.18 Corporatism,19 Populism,20 Nationalist-Developmentalism21 and political centralization—all initiated under authoritarian auspices by Getúlio Vargas in the 1930s and reinforced to a greater or lesser extent by subsequent political regimes well into the 1990s— merely turned the national State into something of a Super Patrón. Various elite groups competed for the prize of “taking over” the State or portions of it, offering clientelistic bargains—patronage in return for support—to other networks of political and economic elites and to organized nonelites (e.g. urban labor), while strictly forbidding autonomous social movements or political representation outside of elite-dominated party machines and State-run organizations. In the words of the American political scientist, Rebecca Abers: Today, many local politicians continue to mobilize electoral support both for themselves and for their allies at the state and federal levels through
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
17
complex systems of patronage, distributing state resources on a particularistic, personal basis. Not only does this system tend to concentrate power in the hands of incumbents who have access to state resources, but the highly discretionary nature of public resource allocation under clientelism also inhibits systematic planning and the implementation of generalized, egalitarian social policies.22 The contemporary result is what I have been calling “elitist democracy,” led and dominated by what the American political scientist, Francis Hagopian, identifies as a series of “closed circles of power holders that dominate a range of state institutions and political processes, and that concentrate political as well as economic power within a limited number of families.”23 Brazil’s historical context of patrimonial elitism allows us to better understand contemporary political disengagement, especially on the part of nonelites, as the rule rather than the exception. The Brazilian political scientist, Evelina Dagnino, aptly labels the resulting social system one of “social authoritarianism”: . . . in which economic inequality, misery, and hunger are the most visible aspect of a social order presided over by the hierarchical and unequal organization of all social relations: what we could call social authoritarianism. Profoundly rooted in Brazilian culture and based predominantly in criteria of class, race and gender, social authoritarianism reveals itself as a system of classifications that establish different categories of persons, laid out in their respective places in society. [ . . . ] This social authoritarianism engenders forms of sociability and an authoritarian culture of exclusion that infuse the whole of social practices and reproduce the inequality of social relations at all levels.24 Today the situation is further complicated by an additional barrier to nonelite activism and mobilization: the growth and proliferation of organizationally sophisticated, well-armed and ruthlessly violent crime syndicates in virtually all of Brazil’s urban poor and working-class neighborhoods, especially in the notorious favelas (shantytowns) interlaced throughout Brazil’s cities and towns.25 In large part due to a seemingly never-ending three-way civil war among and between rival crime organizations, and/or between one or more of them and the corrupt and equally ruthless local police forces, residents of these neighborhoods find themselves quite literally caught in the crossfire.26 Loyalty to one or another side is either rewarded or
18
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
punished depending on which side is currently winning. For most Brazilians, looking the other way, remaining uncommitted and keeping quiet are the best ways to stay alive. To make matters worse, when politicians either informally ally themselves to one of the crime organizations (usually offering impunity in exchange for financial support) or, conversely, when they decide to “get tough on crime” and side with the police (usually grandstanding in hopes of gaining middle-class support), democracy and society itself becomes infected with the ensuing violence. The logical outcome of this combination of elitist patrimonial social structures and political traditions with new forms of organized social violence is the reinforcement of Brazil’s tradition of nonelite social engagement in apolitical micro-communities. As Emile Durkheim pointed out more than a century ago, and as Communitarians continue to argue today, humans are inherently social beings. By nature, it seems, we need to feel and experience community and solidarity with other human beings. Brazil’s popular culture provides numerous opportunities for experiencing such solidarity in day-today life. Almost all Brazilians play an active role in one or more small-scale apolitical micro-communities (e.g. family, church congregation, neighborhood, gang, turma, camarada, torcida, etc.) where they feel the solidarity of being with others “like themselves.” This is made all the more satisfying when it is regularly combined, as it so often is in Brazil, with socializing and festivities (e.g. preparing for and performing in carnival and Saint’s day activities, dancing, singing, drinking, conversing, playing or watching soccer, etc.). Sometimes, membership in these micro-communities is as simple as wearing a certain T-shirt or being a resident of a particular part of town. Being “in” is easily recognized by those both within and without. At the same time, membership is usually fairly fluid; that is, members can join and drop out with relative ease and acceptance. What seems most important of all is that these apolitical social spaces seem to provide individual Brazilians with a personally satisfying feeling of solidarity with others. For nonelites, they seem to compensate for the lack of broader-scale horizontal solidarities (i.e. nation, class, race, gender, etc.) and upward social mobility. Impoverished, hierarchically segregated, politically ignored or excluded, and threatened by violence from multiple fronts, nonelite Brazilians are nonetheless socially satisfied.27 For the poor and other nonelites, conforming to these cultural pathways certainly constitutes one more barrier to the possibility of self-reliant upward mobility as well as to the development of a “modern” and democratic sensibility that one can/should be an agent in the unfolding of one’s own and one’s society’s fate.28 Indeed, as argued in chapter one, such a sensibility lies
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
19
at the very foundation of the social movements and reformist politics that define democracy as a process of “inclusionary adaptation.” But conformity to such cultural pathways, no matter how “irrational” in terms of social and political mobility and reform, is also a source of very real individual comfort and happiness and is, therefore, entirely rational as well as functional from an individual point of view.29 So, while it’s certainly true that with Brazil’s widespread poverty, social violence, and political exclusion, most Brazilians cannot possibly be “citizens” in the classic sense of the word, neither are they living in a Hobbesian world of all-against-all. Neither citizens, nor isolated individuals, most Brazilians are socially integrated in numerous and assorted but essentially disconnected micro-communities. They are divided and they are subdivided, and they are ruled over accordingly.30 Brazil’s history, however, does show us repeated instances of nonelite political activism. A series of autonomous nonelite movements emerged in the late 1950s and early 1960s, for example, allied to an increasingly radicalized Left that gave little if any allegiance to the frankly elitist democratic system then in place.31 These were violently squelched by the repressive military reaction of 1964, which in turn lasted until the mid-1980s. Eventual liberalization and democratization took the form, primarily, of elite negotiations; although, once again, a significant degree of autonomous nonelite activism and mobilization accompanied those negotiations and, arguably, pushed them in a more “popular” direction than might otherwise have been the case.32 This “resurrection of civil society” was much commented upon at the time.33 Many expressed the hope that with the reemergence of autonomous nonelite activism (e.g. “new social movements,” “new unionism,” the progressive Catholic Church, the “New Left,” etc.), Brazilian democracy might move beyond its historically elitist and highly fragile forms. Virtually all observers of contemporary Brazilian politics now believe that these hopes were overly optimistic.34 The return of clientelism and personalism, and growing socioeconomic inequality (which will be discussed later), has brought with it their seemingly inevitable fruits, so familiar in Brazilian history: elitism, corruption, nepotism, and the aforementioned “fragmentation of the popular sector.” Nonetheless, as American political scientist, Kathryn Hochstetler, among others, has pointed out, “[a]lthough the mid-1980s did see significant changes in social movements organizing in Brazil, popular and middle-class actors did not retreat from active mobilization then.”35 Instead, she argues, many transformed their former antiauthoritarian activism into participation in democratic political parties and Nongovernmental Organizations (NGOs).
20
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
As in the United States and Western Europe, then, a healthy presence of “critical citizens” remained active in Brazil in confronting an otherwise dreary postauthoritarian political history of elitist politics and civic disengagement. As we will see in subsequent chapters (and quite unlike what we see in the United States), the articulation of many of these democratic and nonelite political activists into a progressive political party with a clear commitment to further democratization—the Workers’ Party—has served to bridge the gap between official political institutions and processes and the “citizen politics” of nonelite political activism. As a consequence, as “unconsolidated” and “incomplete” as Brazilian democracy may be, it is by no means as stagnant as its North American counterpart. Nonetheless, many obstacles and dangers remain. Neoliberalism—Disguised as a Solution, but Making Matters Worse While democratic processes of inclusionary adaptation are clearly threatened by patrimonial traditions and practices, and by increasing levels of violence, democracy is also threatened from a very different direction: from technocratic neoliberals and their academic apologists. Neoliberals routinely call attention to the penetration, capture, and subsequent fragmentation of democratic States by narrow self-interested groups and individuals (e.g. organized labor on the Left and clientelistic politicians on the Right). Latin American States are frequently cited as all the more susceptible to such capture and fragmentation due to the region’s long history of State interventionism in the economy and the organization of State–civil society relations along elitedominated corporatist and clientelistic lines.36 Neoliberals therefore talk of the need to build up the State’s administrative capacity by fostering or insuring policy makers’ autonomy and insulation from civil and political society.37 In practice, though rarely stated explicitly, neoliberalism rejects both patronage politics and democratic representation; indeed, the two are seen to go hand in hand. Accordingly, neoliberals’ proposed solutions lie with cadres of highly trained experts (usually like themselves and, evidently, perceived to be above politics) united behind a single banner: to restructure the rules and institutions of the State so as to allow the “magic of the marketplace” (competition, innovation, efficiency, etc.) the greatest possible latitude in redefining the organization and predominant logic of social relations in favor of the Liberal ideal of competitive individualism. All groups and individuals need to feel and act personally responsible for their own behavior—including their own economic success and failure. The only legitimate job of the State
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
21
is to create the proverbial “level playing field” by setting up strictly delineated rules and regulations that apply to all citizens at all times. At most, democratic politics (exclusively identified with elections and civil rights) serves the purpose of drumming out clientelistic politicians and corrupt bureaucrats as “unacceptable sources of inefficiency”; at the same time, in the words of the American political scientist, Kurt Weyland, neoliberals hope that “an increase in state capacity could motivate more citizens to advance their interests and ideas through politics . . . to hold public officials and politicians accountable.”38 In terms of the claim that their proposed economic reforms will ultimately benefit democracy, however, neoliberals are their own worst enemies. In the short-to-medium term, neoliberal economic reforms generate recession, unemployment (and the “informalization” of employment), reductions in welfare and social programs that hit the poor the hardest, and increased crime and violence. In the medium-to-long term, they concentrate income and resources, and lead to a growing gap between a minority of “haves” and a majority of “have nots.” In the words of Argentine political scientist, Atilio Borón, “The class selectivity of the neoliberal state is blatant: strong to promote the market forces and to advance the interests of big capital, weak to defend the public interest or to be responsive to the needs of the poor.”39 A large and growing number of desperately poor or downwardly mobile citizens will not actively support democracy (e.g. civic disengagement), and may even side with those intent on destroying it. In the words of the American political scientist, Henry Dietz: If individual citizens perceive or undergo decreasing welfare, their preference for democracy may weaken. Thus the presence of democratic mechanisms (the vote, the right to protest or to demand attention to grievances) can paradoxically threaten not only a regime but ultimately the system itself. [ . . . ] Authoritarian regimes can, if they must, force compliance, at least over the short run, but democracies must convince the citizens that they have some specific minimum probability of benefitting from democracy itself.40 Similarly, the American political scientist, Tim Power and sociologist, Timmons Roberts, argue that “If, after repeated use, the vote has no apparent effect on the problems of poverty and inequality, the result is apathy, cynicism, and the delegitimation of parties and politicians.”41 Technocratic and antidemocratic at its core, neoliberalism increases the likelihood of an antidemocratic “neopopulist” reaction to the painful implications of its policies (discussed in greater detail in the following section). To this date, events in Venezuela surrounding the neopopulist presidency of
22
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
Hugo Chavez, and those leading to the military coup in Ecuador in January of 2000 (to forestall a neopopulist outcome) provide the best illustrations of Dietz’s analysis being borne out in reality. Finally, some social scientists argue that neoliberalism’s elevation of individualism and consumerism above all other social values creates an ethic of self-centeredness that is ultimately detrimental to social cohesion and, therefore, to democracy.42 The Brazilian psychologist, Iziná Helena Traváglia, for example, describes a “New Ethic” emerging from Brazil’s embracing of neoliberalism in the 1990s in the following terms: Every individual chooses their own rules and lifestyle, without sacrificing anything for collective principles, traditions or models that restrict individual freedom. There is a return to “every man for himself.” Due to a total disenchantment with traditional values, heroes or higher ideals don’t exist anymore, only individual enjoyments. This leads to the fragmentation of affective and social bonds. . . . [T]he great teacher is the market, which always offers new and attractive objects for consumption.43 This New Ethic undermines not only the elusive national collective identity of citizenship (discussed earlier), but the “social sufficiency” rooted in Brazilians’ participation in multiple micro-communities as well. Social fragmentation is thereby exacerbated, first, as the growing number of “have nots” increasingly recognize themselves as such and are made to feel personally responsible for their “failure” (even though it is much more likely to be the result of the very “magic of the marketplace” they are encouraged to embrace); second, as fellow “have nots” are seen to be failures and, therefore, unworthy of sympathy or solidaristic collective political action, and; third, as the democratic State—Big Government or politics in general—is seen to be the problem rather than the solution to inevitable market-created inequalities (the preferred solution being, naturally, more “magic of the marketplace”).44 To be fair, many neoliberals have more recently come to recognize the negative social and political implications of their economic proposals. Some have attempted to compensate by providing what the American political scientist, John Fox, calls targeted “semi-clientelist” side payments: financial resources, public policies, technical and logistical support, etc. distributed to adversely affected groups (especially those most vocal and organized), thereby effectively co-opting them and hindering the possibility of more widespread opposition.45 The former president of Mexico, Carlos Salinas de Gortari (1988–1994), for example, established his now famous National Solidarity
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
23
Program, or PRONASOL, to function precisely in this manner.46 Others have obtained similar results by running side payments through traditional patron–client networks and political machines, allowing well-placed regional and local-level political elites to distribute patronage as they see fit. Brazil’s president, Fernando Henrique Cardoso (1995–2002), for example, utilized this strategy in his efforts to gradually implement neoliberal restructuring of Brazil’s economy.47 Regardless of the specific tactics utilized, the political point is clear: in order to effectively implement neoliberal reforms, the State must somehow demobilize the popular sectors who are most adversely affected. But if the problem is with Elitist Democracy itself, as I have argued, then demobilizing nonelites will only make matters worse, not better. The Threat of Antipolitics: Targeting Democracy as the Problem At some point, even stable, long-term democracies have to be concerned about the potential transformation of chronic civic disengagement and frustrated citizen politics into “Antipolitics,”48 also referred to as “Neopopulism”49 and “uncivil movements.”50 Contemporary examples include the rise of neo-Nazism and antiimmigrant sentiment in Europe. In the United States, it is visible as antigovernment and pro-gun paranoia (e.g. the militia movement of the 1980s), organized antiabortion violence and the oft-noted general decline in “civic discourse.” The situation is much more worrisome in Latin America and other parts of the developing world where, as we have seen for the case of Brazil, political and economic elites have historically held only the most precarious instrumental commitment to democratic politics, and where nonelites have normally been severely punished when they’ve tried to mobilize or even protest. Brazil also illustrates how dangerously heightened levels of economic inequality (what some aptly call “social apartheid”), violent crime, and generalized insecurity have more recently resulted from the developing world’s vulnerability to volatile international economic ups and downs and from neoliberal economic policies that exacerbate inequality and insecurity. Not surprisingly, then, Latin America has seen the rise of virulent and sometimes violent Neopopulist politicians and parties (e.g. Alberto Fujimori in Peru and Hugo Chávez in Venezuela) and various “uncivil movements” (e.g. Colombia’s violent guerilla and paramilitary organizations).51 Neopopulists oftentimes invoke a benevolent-dictatorial Savior of the People as the only means to clean up “dirty” democratic politics (along the lines of arguments historically associated with most military interventions and fascist
24
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
experiments throughout the world). Some Neopopulists may even ally themselves with uncivil movements that set out to demonize, isolate, exclude, or even eradicate “impure” scapegoats—foreigners, ethnic or regional minorities, “class enemies,” and the like. Commenting on Brazil’s situation in early 1999, for example, following a steady stream of evidence of insider trading deals and favoritism between top-level government officials and private sector groups (all in the midst of the collapse of the country’s currency and the all-too-familiar inequality-enhancing recessionary policies that the recently reelected president had promised during the campaign that he would not impose), political columnist of the influential newspaper, Folha de São Paulo, Clóvis Rossi, warned of the threat of a future turn toward Law and Order, Clean-up-the-Corruption types of antipolitics: “Let nobody complain of the voter who, in the next election, bends his ear towards some adventurer appearing as a ‘vigilante for justice’ or a ‘hunter of the corrupt’ or some worse thing. The country has already seen that film before. If it be condemned to repeat it, it is because the omission of the authorities more and more is taken as connivance.”52 The crucial point for our discussion here is to emphasize that many disaffected and disengaged citizens, in their desire to simply avoid politics altogether, end up providing space for these antipolitical groups and individuals to gain a foothold in the political arena. Others may be induced to actually join the antipolitical crusade, turning their former civic disengagement into a puppet’s dance of choreographed mobilization against specified enemies and against democracy itself. While these antipolitical groups and individuals and their crusades may be dismissed as extremist expressions of discontent on the part of a relatively small number of people, their existence and their staying power over the years reveals that many citizens share their rabid discontent with and mistrust of democratic institutions and values.53 Bringing the issue back to the doorstep of North Americans, Robert Putnam argues forcefully that “the greatest threat to American liberty comes from the disengaged, not the engaged. The most intolerant individuals and communities in America today are the least connected . . .”54 We have seen that traditional patrimonial conservativism, “modern” neoliberalism and neopopulism are, in part, the cause and, in part, the consequence of contemporary Elitist Democracy and civic disengagement in Brazil (and, I would argue, in many other disaffected democracies as well). All three share the common denominator of seeing the task of governance as one of preserving or constructing new mechanisms of exclusionary politics; that is, continuing or accentuating the demobilization of nonelites. The “task of governance,” in other words, is to squelch democracy itself. This is the
Elitist Democracy, Civic Disengagement, and Citizen Politics
●
25
same “democratic stability” discussed in the chapter one. It is a stability, however, that suggests troubling weaknesses, not reassuring strengths. Borrowing from John Stuart Mill’s version of utilitarian Liberalism, I would argue that when any group or individuals in society, let alone a majority group, are either politically excluded, marginalized, or otherwise ignored, society itself is deprived of the vibrant pluralism necessary to keep itself from stagnating and decaying.55 Similarly, Putnam and others have more recently warned us of the need to recognize and conserve precious supplies of “social capital” (i.e. currently engaged and responsible citizens or, at the very least, the inculcated notion that engagement is the proper thing to do) or risk losing democracy to new forms of authoritarian practice or, on the opposite extreme, social and political breakdown.56 In the words of Ken Roberts: “Over the long term, democracy . . . thrives on deep social roots, a broad base of support, and a capacity to adapt to changing circumstances and newly emerging social pressures, all of which require a participatory civil society. Democratic regimes that short-circuit such participation may be deceptively calm on the surface, but they often contain deep seismic rifts that periodically shake their foundations and threaten their institutional edifice.” 57 In sum, a combination of civic disengagement and a disconnect between “citizen politics” and the well-entrenched official politics of political parties, politicians and their socio-economic elite supporters is a clear and present danger (at least it is for those of us who take democracy seriously). If traditional methods and practices of Elitist Democracy, neoliberalism, and neopopulism do nothing but exacerbate that problem, what is to be done? The Problem of the (Perceived) Lack of Alternatives I have argued that public cynicism and disillusionment with existing democratic politics does not necessarily mean that people dislike democracy per se.58 On the contrary, it seems that most would prefer better democracy to no democracy at all. But how to obtain better democracy when the existing rules of the game favor and are guarded by those who most benefit from the status quo? That is the big question that plagues so many democratic citizens throughout the world and has engaged so many democratic theorists as the so-called third wave of democratization around the world enters its fourth decade.59 An even more fundamental question, however, is how to implement a better democracy in the absence of anything even approaching consensus on a practical alternative to the status quo. Winston Churchill’s well-known adage, that “democracy is the worst political system . . . except
26
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
for all the others,” may continue to make us smile. But it rings increasingly hollow in the face of the reality of disengaged citizens and disaffected democracies around the world. To many of us here at the outset of the twenty-first century, especially in the United States, democracy simply is and will be. To talk of an alternative, or even to talk of the threat of democratic breakdown, is to be seen as a speaker of nonsense. To talk seriously of fundamentally reforming democracy is to be seen as something of a pie-in-the-sky dreamer. Since fundamental change is inconceivable, fewer and fewer people seem to bother trying, or even caring. Many intellectuals—fortunately, not all—engage themselves in dry academic debates complete with an invented vocabulary that says absolutely nothing to those outside their own rarified circles.60 The politically active focus ever more closely on working within the existing rules of the game and/or on “getting mine while the getting is good.” “Getting real” and thinking purely in “practical” terms becomes a stand-in for motivational goals and transformative ideals. At the same time, average citizens either continue to retreat into their own private lives and micro-communities or, in the aftermath of September 11, 2001 eagerly and sincerely take part in the initially spontaneous, but increasingly scripted and choreographed cheerleading and flag-waving sessions of wartime patriotism. Meanwhile, national security concerns chip away at civil liberties, government business is increasingly cloaked in secrecy, economic bailouts target the wealthiest of the wealthy while government cutbacks target the poor, criticism of the government is roundly criticized as “unpatriotic” . . . and democracy increasingly trickles up and away. What is to be done? The following chapter will introduce one alternative model of democracy—Participatory Democracy—that in one form or another emerged from the late twentieth century as the most promising progressive alternative to traditional Elitist Democracy, neoliberal technocracy, and neopopulist anti-democracy. That it is no mere theoretical construct will become very clear in subsequent chapters when we turn to an analysis of a fascinating real-world example of Participatory Democracy in Brazil: the Participatory Budget.
CHAPTER 3
Participatory Democracy in Theory
P
articipatory Democracy has been embraced by a growing number of intellectuals, and by leaders and activists of the political Left and Center-Left throughout the world, as a means to directly address the problems of Elitist Democracy.1 It has also been adopted by many within the international development community, and even by a large number of ostensibly nonideological municipal leaders and administrators in the United States.2 Proponents of Participatory Democracy are characterized, first, by their unwillingness to accept the antidemocratic and citizen-demobilizing conclusions of either “do-nothing” status quo conservativism, antiState neoliberalism or demogogic neopopulism. Second, they claim that such indicators of civic disengagement as low and declining voter turnouts, increasing distrust in democratic politicians and processes, and declining levels of participation in organized political society can be countered by actively promoting citizens’ involvement in important decision-making processes— fostering what Avritzer calls “participatory publics”—especially at the local or grass-roots level where politics can more easily be seen to be relevant to peoples’ day-to-day lives.3 Empowerment The operative hypothesis here is that citizen participation produces “empowerment,” defined by Dagnino as “the construction of active social subjects, defining for themselves what they consider to be their rights and fighting for recognition of those rights.”4 More specifically, empowerment refers to the transformation of an individual’s prior mentality of fatalism and dependency on “higher ups” and/or an active disgust regarding all things political,
28
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
to a new sense of personal responsibility to struggle against systemic exclusion and domination, and a belief in one’s efficacy to be successful in doing so. In the illustrative words of political theorists, Jane Mansbridge and Arnold Kaufman, “democratic participation—by which meant exercising real power over the decisions that affect one—would improve, generally, ‘one’s powers of thought, feeling and action.’ ” 5 In terms more familiar, perhaps, to North American political scientists, empowerment means moving from “parochial” and “subject” mentalities toward a “participant” mentality.6 Proponents of Participatory Democracy see political participation, therefore, not only as a collective action strategy necessary for furthering the interests of repressed, excluded and ignored individuals and groups (i.e. power and persuasion through numbers), but as the vehicle for an individual’s psychological emancipation from the idea of natural sociopolitical hierarchies (e.g. class, gender, race, etc.) and the sense of personal impotence in breaking out of such hierarchies (e.g. perceptions of “natural” social hierarchy and/or of politics as inherently elitist generating nonelite passivity, stoicism, etc.).7 The imputed importance of empowerment for the broader health and progress of democracy cannot be overstated. In the words of the American political scientist, Larry Diamond, “prominent theories of democracy, both classical and modern, have asserted that democracy requires a distinctive set of political values and orientation from its citizens: moderation, tolerance, civility, efficacy, [and] participation.”8 Theorists of political culture in the 1960s often theorized—and many observers continue to believe to this day—that, in the absence of such democratic values (an oft-cited problem of the “Third World”), democracy just won’t “fit.”9 Contemporary proponents of Participatory Democracy reject such culturally deterministic logic, arguing in its stead that properly designed and promoted opportunities for meaningful and efficacious political participation can generate empowered citizens, and that empowerment can generate something of a snowball effect of deepening citizen participation.10 To the extent that empowerment takes place among previously excluded, ignored, and/or underserved sectors of the population, proponents of Participatory Democracy argue that politics becomes more pluralistic and democratic.11 Existing representative democracies become even more representative as they become more participatory. Another important, and related, claim is that an empowered and active civil society provides an oversight function, and therefore a democratic check, to the sort of corruption, backroom politics, and clientelistic log-rolling common to elitist politics anywhere.12
Participatory Democracy in Theory
●
29
Empowerment is said to occur as an initial instance of political participation generates an understanding that one’s individual interests are inextricably intertwined with, and arrayed against, the interests of others (“political consciousness”) and that seeking to further those interests necessarily involves further political participation and conflict (“civic engagement”). Scholars frequently cite various arenas of organized civil society (e.g. interest group politics, social movements, organized social activism, and/or philanthropy, etc.) as the most empowering “schools of democracy.”13 Becoming active in political society (e.g. joining a political party, campaigning on behalf of a candidate and/or a party, etc.) is another oft-cited means of taking the first step into political awareness and activism. Once engaged in one arena of democracy, empowered citizens purportedly expand their participation to other arenas.14 This notion of empowerment spilling over from an initial instance of participation is widely held by scholars like Robert Dahl, who writes “Joining organizations and participating in politics reinforces [sic] one another.”15 Similarly, Jana Everett writes “as in grass-roots movements generally, activism frequently induces broader participation in the political system.”16 The big question, of course, is “Does empowerment really happen and, if so, how?” We already know that in contemporary contexts of civic disengagement, most people have become completely turned off by virtually all aspects of political society while many have distanced themselves from organized civil society as well. So, how do the disengaged become empowered?17 In looking for an answer to this question, contemporary proponents of Participatory Democracy make the inevitable bow to the previously cited works of Robert Putnam and his concept of “social capital.” I will too. But we are obliged to begin with the classic work in the field of social capital: the arguments of the early nineteenth-century French political writer, Alexis de Tocqueville, whom Putnam himself has called the “patron saint of contemporary social capitalists.”18 Alexis de Tocqueville and Contemporary “Neo-Tocquevillians” Tocqueville argued that centralized State “tyranny” (a paradoxical tendency of democratic regimes) could/should be countered through administrative decentralization and through local-level citizen participation in political organizations and civic duties.19 “[T]he strength of free peoples,” he argued, “resides in the local community. Local institutions are to liberty what primary schools are to science; they put it within the people’s reach; they teach
30
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
people to appreciate its peaceful enjoyment.”20 Tocqueville praised both the political and administrative decentralization he found in the pre-industrial Northeast of the United States (as compared to his native France). He reserved special praise for New England’s unusually democratic political culture apparently sustained if not actually created by participation in local-level politics and civic duties. Tocqueville’s arguments in favor of political decentralization have always found an audience among liberal and neoliberal thinkers unhappy with the effects of “Big Government” on individual liberty.21 But while liberals and neoliberals praise decentralization for its ability to check the seemingly inexorable “tyrannical” encroachments of Big Government on local and private spheres of activity, New Left and Communitarian thinkers prefer to focus on Tocqueville’s insights that are more appropriate to the contemporary problem of civic disengagement (a phenomenon Tocqueville might have called “the diminishing of civic spirit” and “the degradation of public life”).22 Accordingly, today’s Neo-Tocquevillians focus their criticism of Big Government on the psychological and behavioral effects on individual citizens who observe their democratic government becoming ever more remote and ever more scripted by groups and individuals—lawyers, bureaucrats, professional politicians, lobbyists, pollsters—who are nothing like “the rest of us.” The practical implication of such a perception is that local issues and offices are essentially powerless, so why bother? Indeed, “Why bother with Washington (or Brasília) since who am I to make any kind of difference?” Tocqueville and Neo-Tocquevillians alike argue that citizens need to feel that their community matters before they can come to feel that their participation is worthwhile. In such communities as those he saw in New England, Tocqueville noted that the individual citizen “sees the township as a free, strong corporation of which he is part and which is worth the trouble of trying to direct.”23 Similarly, Neo-Tocquevillians argue that political and administrative decentralization, by enhancing local decision-making authority, can make citizens see their own political engagement as useful both to themselves and to their community. In the words of the American political scientist, Robert Dilger: . . . advocates of decentralization argue that active state and local governments promote a sense of state and community responsibility and selfreliance, that state and local governments are closer to the people and better able to adapt public programs to state and local needs and conditions, that they encourage participation and civic responsibility by
Participatory Democracy in Theory
●
31
allowing more people to become involved in public questions, and that they encourage experimentation and innovation in public policy.24 Unlike their liberal and neoliberal counterparts, however, most NeoTocquevillians recognize that political and administrative decentralization in and of itself is not enough to effectively counter citizen disengagement.25 In some contexts, such as those most prominent in rural areas and small towns throughout the world, decentralization can merely open the door to repressive and demobilizing forms of elitist local tyranny. As argued in the last chapter, in Latin America and much of the developing world, such local tyranny has historically taken the form of patrimonial clientelism practiced by local elites (caudillos and coroneis) and their political machines, as well as by the corporatist/developmentalist State.26 Decentralization can also generate an insidious form of “modern” local tyranny, especially in urban areas: a supposedly benevolent technocracy of bureaucrats and neoliberal politicians justifying their antidemocratic exclusionary rule under such banners as “Total Quality” and “Best Practices.”27 To counter such local tyrannies, New Leftists and Communitarians strongly emphasize Tocqueville’s arguments that local-level participation in “secondary institutions” and civic duties fosters a sense of connectedness— social solidarity, civic consciousness, social capital—among otherwise selfseeking and/or envious individuals.28 Working together in various and assundry localized civic duties such as jury duty, town council meetings, community barn raisings, and the like, individuals become empowered as citizens. They “wake up” in that they come to understand that, in a great many instances, both attaining and maintaining their own self-interest is inextricably intertwined with attaining and maintaining the interests of their neighbors, and vice versa—a phenomenon he labeled “self interest properly understood.”29 In the words of American political scientist, Benjamin Barber, “civic activity educates individuals how to think publicly as citizens even as citizenship informs civic activity with the required sense of publicness and justice.”30 The American historian, Derek Phillips, seems right in arguing that Tocqueville and many contemporary Communitarians romanticize the extent of local-level solidarity in early nineteenth-century New England towns and, indeed, in most real-world communities.31 I would argue, however, that most Neo-Tocquevillians—particularly those from the New Left—understand that where local-level participation doesn’t create an allembracing solidarity among all members of a given community, it can create more limited group solidarities among some members. These are usually built
32
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
up around a new-found consciousness of existing lines of social cleavage (e.g. class, ethnicity, etc.) or of the individuals and groups involved in more issue-specific localized conflicts. Far from being a bad thing, however, this “new found consciousness” and “more limited group solidarity” are the fundamentals of “empowerment” as discussed earlier (i.e. beginning with “the construction of active social subjects” out of individuals in a given society so that they may act collectively against various forms of tyranny, both centralized and decentralized). Ignored, actively excluded, or disengaged citizens do not wake up (when and if they ever do) to a world of civic harmony and love. Rather, they discover the real world of politics that Max Weber so adequately labeled “organized domination” and that I identified in chapter one as a never-ending struggle among competing interests (with democracy being the process whereby nonelite interests gradually gain access to such public goods and privileges as human rights, civil liberties, and State-provided social services).32 Seen this way, political consciousness means, first and foremost, the ability to distinguish political allies from enemies, while civic engagement means identifying with one’s allies even to the point of actively joining them in organized efforts to pursue and/or defend shared interests. Empowerment is, therefore, the first step—taken at the level of the individual—in actually creating the pluralistic society so often simply (and simplistically) assumed by observers and even some theorists of contemporary democracy. Perhaps the most important point out of all of this is Neo-Tocquevillians’ recognition that empowerment—especially of nonelites—needs to be actively promoted and maintained; thus the central concern with the problem of civic disengagement, which can now be seen as the opposite of empowerment, or disempowerment. The Debate over Origins and Strategies of Empowerment But Neo-Tocquevillian thinkers are of two minds on pinpointing both the origins of empowerment and the political strategies necessary to maintain and/or expand it. On the one hand, civil society-centered theorists and practitioners argue that empowerment occurs spontaneously in response to historical events or processes—for example, in opposition to an unpopular authoritarian regime,33 in response to a new consciousness of formerly unseen or “forbidden” collective identities,34 in response to a new consciousness of new or formerly unseen interests or concerns,35 or during what the American political scientist Sam Huntington has called moments of “creedal passion” when deeply held cultural myths and ideals about society and politics are suddenly shattered by revelations of a starkly opposing reality.36
Participatory Democracy in Theory
●
33
Evidence of such spontaneous empowerment can be seen in “resurrections of civil society” during such special periods in numerous countries throughout history: street demonstrations, letter writing campaigns, civil disobedience, ostensibly apolitical Nongovernmental organizations providing services and training to the poor and otherwise excluded, etc.37 but also in the more gradual emergence of “citizen politics” in the latter portion of the twentieth century. The practical implications of this civil society centered view are that dedicated New Leftists and Communitarians need to work within civil society itself to make sure that these spontaneous eruptions of activism from below become organized and self-sustaining, and that they maintain their fundamentally grass roots (i.e. localized and personal) character as well as their equally fundamental autonomy from political society and the State.38 Only thus, it is argued, can they maintain pressure on the status quo while avoiding the co-optation and demobilization that is said to inevitably occur when one works for change within the system. Others argue that the politics of empowerment should be more focused on political society.39 This political society-centered view argues, first, that leadership from political party and even sympathetic government leaders is essential to overcome the issue-specific and highly fragmented nature of grassroots-based consciousness raising and activism.40 Equally important, they argue that a logical conclusion of the civil society-centered view is that once any given moment or wave of spontaneous empowerment passes, especially (albeit paradoxically) if by victory over the offending historical situation, so too does much of the activism that it spawned.41 The social capital thus created can, at best, only be maintained and rarely if ever actually expanded upon. Proponents of the political society-centered view argue, however, that empowerment politics needn’t merely respond to the tides of history, or play a rearguard action to try to preserve existing stocks of social capital “in the trenches” of civil society, as it were. Instead, legislation and administrative practices can be specifically designed to enhance and encourage popular participation and empowerment—to “deepen democracy.” In the words of Richard Valelly, “people don’t just come to politics; politics also comes to people.”42 Participatory institutional reforms, understood to emerge (if at all) from the machinations of political society, hold the promise of bringing even more citizens into the game of democratic politics, including the politically alienated and otherwise disengaged. Thus, as flawed as political parties and elections may be in practice, political society-centered New Leftists and Communitarians argue that it is only through parties and elections that an initially small number of empowered and committed people can popularize and begin to implement an actively empowering
34
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
participatory model of democracy from above and possibly even institutionalize it so as to avoid the more ephemeral moments of social movement empowerment from below. We will return to this debate about the proper “creative political agency” in subsequent chapters; but an important point to emphasize here about both versions of the New Left and Communitarian arguments is their willingness to work within the rules of the game of formal-institutional representative democracy while, at the same time, professing a transformative vision of reforming democracy in a more participatory direction.43 Both speak, in other words, in gradualistic terms of democratizing democracy, not replacing it or ignoring its failings.44 Popular participation via a radical authoritarian imposition, in addition to being a contradiction in terms, harkens back to a Leninist/Stalinist past that New Leftists would rather forget than recreate, and one that Communitarians never embraced.45 But simply working within the rules of the game without pursuing any transformative vision would be to abandon the dreams of social justice that have defined the very meaning of progressivism—both socialist and democratic— for over two centuries.46 At about the same time that the post–Cold War Left was revamping its ideology, bringing it closer to Communitarian ideas, the mainstream international development community was also adopting what I have been calling Neo-Tocquevillian strategies of decentralization and popular participation and adding them to its more traditional emphasis on poverty reduction.47 The dovetailing of these two processes occurred within the ongoing Third Wave of democratization. This provided impetus and support for the political society-centered approach to empowerment as many NeoTocquevillians originally based in civil society found themselves elected or appointed into political society as party leaders, legislators, and administrators of public policy. In the process, a great many once-active social movements and grassroots groups disappeared or became less active as their ranks of leadership thinned.48 The end result, for our purposes here, was reduced support for the civil society-centered approach to empowerment politics. In chapter five, I will flesh out one increasingly well-known effort on the part of what I have been calling “political society-centered” NeoTocquevillians to bring the Participatory Democratic model down from the realm of political theory into the real world: the Participatory Budget (or Orçamento Participativo—OP) as practiced in local and state governments administered by the Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores—PT) in Brazil. The next chapter, however, contains a necessarily brief sketch of the history of the PT in the context of the broader historical evolution of the Brazilian Left in general.
CHAPTER 4
Participatory Democracy in Practice—Brazil’s Workers’ Party and the Participatory Budget
O
n November 15, 1988, former City Council member, Luiza Erundina, of the Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores—PT) was elected mayor of Brazil’s largest city, São Paulo. Erundina’s election was truly a historical event in Brazil’s political history. Much of the São Paulo PT leadership and active militancy were the same leaders and activists of the metalworkers strikes ten years earlier that had brazenly and successfully challenged both the government and the powerful oligopoly of foreign-owned automobile companies for the first time since the military took power in 1964. Then there was Erundina herself: a middle-aged unmarried woman, an immigrant from the Northeast of Brazil (generally considered the country’s economic and cultural backwater by São Paulo natives), and an activist in one of the more radical wings of the openly Socialist PT. Finally, the contrast with Erundina’s predecessor could not have been more pronounced: the quixotic octogenarian, Jânio Quadros—a former president (until resigning suddenly in 1961 in his first year of office), and a master at Brazil’s traditional intra-elite game of stitching together electoral and governing coalitions by trading public funds and privileged access to public services and jobs in return for political and financial support among boss-style city council members and powerful economic elites. Erundina’s victory was a complete surprise to most observers. No polls had predicted it. The state and national leadership of the party had previously abandoned the campaign as a lost cause. The second-place candidate,
36
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
businessman and former mayor under the military, Paulo Maluf, with an enormous political machine and seemingly limitless financial resources, had been the clear frontrunner throughout most of the campaign. But when the votes were fully counted, Erundina had won with a plurality of 29.84 percent of the vote in a field of fourteen candidates.1 Late in the afternoon of election day, with returns coming in showing Erundina’s surprise victory, word went out that there would be a big victory celebration up on Avenida Paulista, São Paulo’s “Wall Street” and the site of numerous marches and manifestations in which the PT had participated in previous years. Living only a few blocks away, I grabbed my camera and ran to take a look. In the last minutes of daylight, I was able to capture on film the euphoria of the first several hundred people arriving, many with party flags in hand, campaign stickers stuck to their clothes and faces, and wearing PT and Erundina campaign T-shirts. Several hours later, the street was packed with thousands of people dancing, waving flags, exchanging embraces, and, of course, holding up traffic. Over the next few months, the euphoria of unexpected victory gave way to the harsh reality of governance. Quadros had left the city with a staggering debt, a bloated payroll, and a chaotically disorganized bureaucratic machine: another common feature of Brazil’s patrimonial political tradition. Erundina was forced to stop work on several highly visible highway and tunnel construction projects in the central zones of the city so that she could rein in the city’s deficits and target her limited spending capabilities on the impoverished zones in the sprawling slums ringing the city. Opposition politicians and the ever-critical media were relentless in their criticisms of her Administration’s “incapacity” to govern. Surprisingly, perhaps, leaders and city council members from her own party were, at times, some of her harshest critics. I mention the São Paulo experience (without entering into a more detailed analysis) because it is widely recognized within the PT as having been an eye-opening example of the multiple challenges of moving from the realm of ideologically oriented opposition into the “real world” of democratic governance.2 For our purposes here, two challenges were particularly important. The first involved recognizing the need to negotiate with opponents and to abide by preexisting administrative rules even when doing so seemed repugnant to party and individual principles. Like it or not, this was and is the give-and-take of democracy in practice. Meeting the challenge well means relaxing certain ideological principles (without abandoning them) and adopting new principles of pragmatic public administration (without elevating pragmatism to the central guiding principle).3 Successfully confronting this challenge constitutes, in the words of the Mexican political scientist, Jorge Castañeda, “the apprenticeship of democratic rule.”4
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
37
The São Paulo experience also clearly illustrated the second albeit related challenge of real-world democracy that has been going on within the PT since its inception in 1980: surviving the inherently conflict-laden processes of party building and institutional learning as different party factions battled it out for ideological and political dominance, or “hegemony,” within the party.5 While the party has sometimes seemed to teeter on the edge of fratricidal dissolution (an impression heightened more by the deliberate openness of party debates and the hostility of media coverage than by any real threat of dissolution), the history of the PT shows how the processes of party building and institutional learning have resulted in the internal hegemony of an interpretation of Socialism that can only be labeled Neo-Tocquevillian in its adoption of Participatory Democracy as the backbone of the modo petista de governar (the PT’s mode of governance).6 A Brief History of the Workers’ Party
7
The history of the PT reflects a fundamental transformation of the Brazilian Left in the final thirty years of the twentieth century: it has largely emancipated itself from both State corporatism and Marxist-Leninism, and it has fully embraced political democracy (albeit a vision of democracy much different from the Brazilian status quo and the North American “mainstream” procedural definition of democracy discussed in chapter one). Since Getúlio Vargas’ authoritarian and populist Estado Novo (1937–1945), the organized Left in Brazil had been repressed and the urban working classes integrated into politics from the top-down by State-controlled corporatist unions.8 The unorganized poor remained politically inert due to the stranglehold of traditional clientelism in the countryside, machine-style party clientelism in the cities, literacy requirements for voting, and numbing poverty. During the postwar period (1945–1964), nationalist-populist “parties of the State”9— especially Vargas’ Brazilian Workers’ Party (PTB)—continued this legacy of State incorporation and control, albeit in an institutional context of Elitist Democracy. In the charged atmosphere of the Cold War, however, political debate became increasingly polarized, and the PTB split between its moderate deal-brokering Vargista leaders and its more radical grassroots. The Cuban revolution in 1958 and 1959 seemed to present a viable alternative to the radicals’ frustration with “bourgeois democracy”: only violent revolution spearheaded by a small but dedicated vanguard party or guerilla movement could bring forth social justice by eliminating capitalism and its democratic facade. Subsequent events, however, took their toll on the revolutionary Left. Communism and Marxist-Leninist vanguardism were relegated to the fringes
38
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
by thirty years of failed armed struggle, brutal military repression of real and imagined opponents, an enormous growth of the urban working class and an intensive modernization of vast rural areas (both accompanied by rising wages and expanded access to social benefits), the collapse of the Soviet Union and Eastern European socialism in the late-1980s, and the subsequent decay of Cuban socialism. New “Post Cold War Left” goals and strategies emphasized “democratizing democracy” (empowering citizens to participate more directly and independently in institutions of contestation and governance) and, at least in the short-to-medium term, “humanizing capitalism” (redirecting a significant portion of the economic surplus toward improving the quality of life and future prospects of nonelites) until a new vision of an anticapitalist socialist “Utopia” could be adequately theorized.10 Meanwhile, in Brazil, many who had never considered themselves Leftists or even political joined in opposition to the country’s authoritarian and highly unequal style of capitalism and demanded a return to democratic government. Founding the PT In 1978 and 1979, massive strikes in the industrial outskirts of the city of São Paulo brought participating union leaders and sympathizers to the conclusion that union representation of members’ demands for better working conditions, wages, etc. was not enough to ensure a better life for Brazil’s working classes.11 Workers were also citizens, with needs and interests outside of the workplace; and they needed to be represented as such in the national political arena. Even for workplace issues, unions were seen as highly vulnerable to State repression, whereas a party might operate in multiple locations within and outside the State. In supporting the idea of a workers’ party, the recognized leader of the strikes, Luís Inácio Lula da Silva, called attention to Brazil’s history of oligarchical and populist parties of elites cutting deals among themselves while making grand promises to an inert mass of client-supporters. Lula argued that a true workers’ party could only construct itself from the bottom up ( pelas bases), acting as an umbrella organization for the political participation of urban workers and all others who felt unrepresented by traditional politics.12 Lula’s “New Unionist” leaders formed the initial core of the PT, alongside a small but significant number of longtime Leftist activists and intellectuals. They found support in the “progressive wing” of the Catholic Church, and from numerous community-focused and identity-based social movements throughout Brazil.13 In the words of Brazilian social scientists, Lúcio
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
39
Kowarick and André Singer, “We are dealing with a party with a large number of militants that during the 1980s simultaneously assisted in the construction of union and grassroots movements while being forged by these movements.”14 The PT was founded on February 10, 1980 and legally constituted two years later. Party leaders agreed that the formal rules and procedures of democratic politics, flawed as they were, could be used as a means to publicize the struggles of the party’s constituent social movements, to expand and unify their followings, and possibly even to “occupy spaces” of institutional power in order, eventually, to transform Brazil’s unequal social structures (albeit in an, as-yet, ill-defined direction).15 The PT in Electoral and Institutional Politics The PT first garnered truly national attention in late 1984 with its insistent demand that direct popular elections (Dirétas Já) replace the military’s plan for indirect presidential elections. Massive street rallies and demonstrations resulted. Brazilian economist, Paulo Baia, notes this “irony of history” by which “a Left that gave little strategic value to democracy and that even frequently discussed its merely tactical utility ended up being the principal voice in defense of its full installation . . . .”16 When the Direct Elections campaign was adopted and then abandoned by moderate PMDB leaders as a means to get their candidate, Tancredo Neves, indirectly elected, the PT risked public censure by requiring its Congressional delegation to abstain from voting for the popular Neves.17 Neves’ death and the subsequent collapse of José Sarney’s presidency into economic turmoil and corruption, led “many Brazilians [ . . . ] to see the PT as the only political force that had had the courage to stick to its principles.”18 The party’s subsequent “outsider” image fueled its electoral growth, in the late 1980s, and continued to do so well into the early 2000s. The party entered Brazil’s electoral fray in 1982. Table 4.1 outlines the PT’s performance in all arenas of electoral politics from 1982 to 2002.19 Table 4.1 shows that 1982’s first multiparty elections produced eight PT federal deputies. That number doubled to sixteen in 1986, more than doubled to thirty-five in 1990, increased by 43 percent to fifty in 1994, increased again by 18 percent to fifty-nine in 1998, and increased yet again in 2002 by 54 percent to become the largest party delegation in the Chamber with ninety-one federal deputies.20 While it took ten years (1990) before the party elected a senator, it elected five in 1995, added two more in 1998 and became the second largest party in the Senate when its delegation increased
Table 4.1 Outline of PT’s Performance in all Arenas of Electoral Politics from 1982 to 2002.
President Federal Senate Federal House Governor State House Mayor City Council Member
19821
19852
19863
19884
19893
19903
19924
19943
19964
19983
20004
20023
n.a. 0 8 0 12 2 118
n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 2 n.a.
n.a. 0 16 0 40 n.a. n.a.
n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 36 900
0 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
n.a. 1 35 0 81 n.a. n.a.
n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 54 1100
0 5 50 2 92 n.a. n.a.
n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 115 1985
0 7 59 3 90 n.a. n.a.
n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 108 1808
1 10 91 3 147 n.a. n.a.
n.a.: not applicable. 1 Innaugural elections: Federal Legislators (Senate and House), Governors, State Legislators (House), Mayors, and City Council Members (1982). 2 Innaugural mayoral elections for state capitals (1985). 3 Regular federal and state elections: President (beginning in 1989, aligning with the rest in 1994), Federal Legislators, Governors, Vice-Governors (elected separately, but not listed here), and State Legislators. 4 Regular municipal elections: Mayor and City Council Members (1988).
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
41
to ten in 2002.21 In state politics, the PT elected its first governors in 1994, in Espirito Santo and the Federal District of Brasília.22 While losing the Brasília seat in an upset in the 1998 elections, the party elected governors in the states of Acre, Rio Grande do Sul, and Mato Grosso do Sul. Another upset loss in Rio Grande do Sul in 2002 was offset by reelections in Acre, Mato Grosso do Sul, and a new governorship in Piauí. In the legislatures of Brazil’s 27 states, the party’s initial 12 state deputies in 1982 more than trebled to 40 in 1986, then doubled to 81 in 1990, increased by 14 percent to 92 in the 1994 elections and dropped only slightly to 90 in the 1998 elections. In 2002, the number of PT state deputies spiked by 63 percent to 147. It was in municipal politics that the PT surprised many observers. Beginning with only two elected mayors in 1982 (and its first state capital mayorship— Fortaleza, Ceará—in 1985), the number of PT mayors jumped to 36 in 1988, increased by 50 percent to 55 in 1992, more than doubled to 115 in 1996, and increased by 63 percent to 187 in 2000. By 2001, the party had governed or was governing in a wide variety of cities ranging in size and character from the tiny rural town of Lavandeira in the Centralnorthern state of Tocantins, with its 1,119 inhabitants, to the highly urbanized and industrialized city of São Paulo, with its nine-and-a-half million inhabitants.23 Finally, in presidential elections, table 4.1 does not do justice to just how well the PT fared in each of Brazil’s post-authoritarian elections for national leader. Candidate Lula placed a close second in 1989 behind Fernando Collor, winning 16 percent in the first round of multi-candidate voting, and 46.9 percent against Collor’s 53 percent in the second round. Although there was no second round in the 1994 and 1998 elections due to Fernando Henrique Cardoso’s first-round victories (54.5 and 53.1 percent, respectively), Lula’s second-place results (27 and 31.7 percent) were almost double his first round showing in 1989. Finally, in the 2002 presidential elections, Lula was overwhelmingly victorious, winning 46.4 percent of the vote in the first round and 61.3 percent in the second round against Cardoso’s candidate, José Serra. In spite of losing the presidential elections of 1989, 1994, and 1998, the PT’s strong showings in these and in Congressional and subnational elections further raised the party’s visibility and credibility. In addition, as Fernando Collor’s presidency (1990–1992) collapsed in a wash of economic stagnation and corruption, the party’s opposition remained loud and consistent. Relations with Itamar Franco’s interim presidency (1992–1994) started off with hints of a tacit alliance, but the PT declined any formal participation in Franco’s administration and moved squarely into opposition as he adopted a growing number of neoliberal reforms. It remained steadfast in
42
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
opposing the government of president Fernando Henrique Cardoso (1995–2002), in spite of Cardoso’s initial popularity and that of his flagship neoliberal economic program, the Real Plan. As the economy stumbled in 1999 with a massive devaluation of the artificially overvalued Real, then entered into a slow but steady process of decay, especially in terms of rising unemployment, the PT’s message of anti-neoliberalism (in favor of reviving the role of the State in order to resuscitate the national economy and institute social welfare programs) and anticorruption (in favor of greater citizen participation and oversight of State operations) seemed to find increasing public acceptance.24 By 2002, the party was far from being the isolated voice of radical São Paulo trade unionism that some of its critics had predicted in 1980. It had grown into a national organization with some 750,000 registered members nationwide, an impressive electoral record, a growing number of experienced politicians and administrators, a solid nationwide party preference of 17–19 percent throughout the 1990s (the highest among Brazil’s dizzying array of political parties)25 and, of course, a victorious candidate in the 2002 presidential elections. In many areas of the country, and in all presidential elections up to and including 2002, it was even possible to argue that Brazil effectively had a two-party (or two-coalition) system: PT versus anti-PT. The PT’s Programmatic Evolution as a Function of “Institutional Learning” The PT has always considered elections (and formal democracy in general) as a means to achieving more “substantive” ends. In Lula’s words, the party has been dedicated from the beginning to “showing to the population that institutional democracy is not enough” in a country of such glaring inequalities as Brazil: “It’s necessary, for example, to democratize the economy. To the Brazilian elite, democracy means that the worker can shout out that he’s hungry. For us, democracy means that the worker has the right to eat.”26 This substantive conception of democracy has always included greater citizen participation. In the words of PT President, José Dirceu: The idea that guides the PT’s ideological evolution is the idea of citizenship, and the idea of the public—public space, not Statized space. In Brazil, private space exists, and the State’s space exists, but the public space must come into existence increasingly, to become a reference point. Because while voting is fundamental in electing a legislative representative or the executive chief in each of the three levels of government, we want
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
43
citizens to be increasingly organized to directly participate in public administration, not just in decisions but in deliberation processes. This idea has gone from being an ideology to being an instrument of participation and citizenship . . . of putting one more power in the traditional arrangement of executive, legislature and judiciary.27 The PT’s embracing of what Evalina Dagnino calls “new citizenship” clearly represents a break with traditional Left thinking about the “secondary” nature of politics and political culture relative to “primary” economic and class structures.28 At the same time, however, it represents an equally clear continuation of the Left’s traditional moral crusade to “save” the downtrodden from the ravages of capitalism;29 and to do so in spite of the masses themselves—that is, in spite of the poor majority’s “false consciousness” (or, in Gramscian terms, their self-repression by way of internalizing the values, culture, and ideology of the dominant elite classes as if those values, etc. were actually their own), and/or their conservative fear of the unknown or untested.30 While an organizational strategy of popular organization and mobilization is still paramount, it has been significantly transformed from the orthodox Leninist idea of a revolutionary elite acting within a secretive vanguard party structure, to the embracing of the PT as a relatively loose umbrella-style organization of constituent social movements, ideological factions, and individual party members and “sympathizers” acting within a political context of representative democracy.31 The social struggle—no longer restricted to class struggle—has increasingly come to be seen as taking place in the realm of ideas: the Gramscian struggle for ideological hegemony in the context of an antidemocratic political culture and a set of antidemocratic social institutions.32 In the words of Tarso Genro, former mayor of Porto Alegre, this struggle involves . . . the formation of a free and independent public opinion, one that is not subjected to the large means of communication [i.e. the corporate media], and that, as such, may form a solid foundation capable of constructing a permanent opposition to the process of domination; a process that flows through large media and the huge monopolies of information . . . . Another question is that which refers to the establishment of a new pattern of social organization and interaction . . . This refers to the construction of a political culture open to the idea of socialism.33 But while ideology has certainly been a guiding light throughout the PT’s history, equally if not more noteworthy has been the impact of its
44
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
“real world” experiences in local governance on the party’s ideological evolution (what I earlier called “institutional learning”). Victories in local elections, and Constitutional provisions for substantial fiscal autonomy for local governments (Title VI), provided the PT with opportunities to practice what it preached.34 And practice ultimately had a moderating influence on the party as a growing number of party activists found themselves weighing the ideals and strategies forged in years of union organization, academic theorizing, or social movement activism against the give-and-take negotiations and compromises inherent in democratic governance.35 How far one should compromise became a divisive issue among party members, particularly between those actually in local government, and those in local party organizations, constituent unions, and social movement organizations.36 In some cases, disputes around this issue became so divisive that local parties withdrew their support of the administration and/or the administration withdrew itself from the party.37 In spite of these debates, however, and in part because of their selfdestructive potential, a programmatic consensus within the party emerged in the mid-to-late 1980s around two basic goals of “popular democratic” administration: inverting priorities (inversão de prioridades) and popular participation ( participação popular). These were presented as the party’s version of “State reform” in direct opposition to the then predominant Neoliberal model of diminishing the size and role of the State in the name of expanding opportunities for private initiative. All petistas could agree that Neoliberal State reforms merely concentrated greater power and resources in the hands of economic and social elites. And while the Brazilian State had so far been a less-than-perfect instrument in offsetting the inequalities of capitalist development, the solution was not to dismantle the State, but to democratize it and put it to work in helping to solve the problems and serve the interests of the nonelite majority of Brazilians. Inverting Priorities Inversão de prioridades means targeting public policy to favor the poor and otherwise excluded (e.g. improving public education, public health, public transportation, low-cost housing, etc.), while taxing those most capable of paying.38 In São Paulo, for example, under the administration of Luiza Erundina (1989–1992): . . . social spending reached 48.1 percent of total city spending, up from 33.8 percent during Jânio[Quadros]’s administration [1985–1988] and
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
45
nearly 10 percentage points higher than it had ever been in the past fifteen years. [ . . . ] The only funding source that was readily available to the mayor’s office was a direct tax on property [Imposto Predial e Territorial Urbano, or IPTU . . .]. Erundina increased the share of the IPTU as part of the total municipal income from 9.7 percent in 1989 to an estimated 20.8 percent in 1992. The PT administration was partly successful in adjusting real estate resale assessments to realistic levels and in making tax collection more progressive.39 An objective analysis of the results of inverting priorities in PTadministered cities would require comparative analysis of local government performance before, during, and after the PT (a task beyond the scope of this chapter or book).40 A number of studies exist, however, suggesting an overall positive assessment. Brazilian political scientist, Silvio Caccia Bava, for example, argues that “From an across-the-board reading of the results of the recent democratic administrations [i.e. PT-administered cities from 1989–1996], one can affirm that public services under the responsibility of these municipal governments have improved.”41 From an intensive study of five PT-run cities, Rebecca Abers writes that “Many PT administrations have successfully eliminated traditional forms of clientelism and corruption, such as the widespread practice of farming-out public works projects to select businesses at exorbitant prices.”42 My own work on small-town PT administrations in the states of Ceará and Minas Gerais suggests similar conclusions.43 It’s worthwhile noting, as well, that when Brazil’s federal government in 1995 sought out the country’s most successful experiences in “innovative local government” for inclusion in an exposition at the United Nations’ 1996 Habitat II Conference in Istanbul, Turkey, 8 of 18 selected projects came from PT-administered cities. One poster in the party’s national office bragged, “The party administers less than 1% of our cities, but it contributes 44% of the projects that officially represent Brazil.”44 Similarly, when UNICEF sponsored publication in the early-to-mid 1990s of a 15-volume series of exemplary educational programs in Brazil, 5 of the 15 cases came from PT-administered cities.45 Such evidence points to the seriousness of PT activists and administrators in translating the party’s platform into actual practice. But they cannot gauge citizens’ subjective evaluations of PT performance, nor their subsequent evaluations of the legitimacy and efficacy of becoming more engaged in Brazilian democracy. PT leaders and activists make the following argument in that regard: 1. “inverting priorities” means that PT administrations are more responsive to the needs of ordinarily ignored and excluded citizens;
46
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
2. because of this, a greater number among this majority of Brazilians have felt represented by the PT; 3. therefore, many more nonelite citizens are willing to see the democratic system in a more positive light than would otherwise be the case. PT leaders, however, would be the first to admit that such arguments are difficult to prove.46 First, it seems doubtful that a large number of nonelites feel represented by the PT. The electoral record is certainly inconclusive. Many PT administrations have been voted out of office after just one term (e.g. Fortaleza, São Paulo, and the Federal District of Brasília, to name several highly visible cases). Yet a good many others have continued in office for two or three terms (e.g. Porto Alegre, Santos, Diadema, Betim, Ipatinga). While it is true that many voters have seen the PT as the most ideologically consistent party in Brazil with the fewest number of corrupt politicians, they have also tended to feel it is too “radical” for their tastes—at least preceding the presidential elections of 2002.47 Many PT victories have been the result of time-specific “protest voting” and/or split voting among Center and Right candidates, neither of which indicate long-term partisan or programmatic support.48 The PT also suffers from the fact—discussed in chapter two—that many Brazilians in the late-1980s and 1990s, and the poor most of all, showed little knowledge of, or interest in politics.49 Alongside the poverty and inadequate education that usually accompany and help account for such views, voter indifference allows for practices of elitism, clientelism, and corruption to bias election results. Brazilian television, for example, where the vast majority of Brazilians receive their information about politics, routinely portrays PT administrations in a negative light.50 Absent large expenditures of public funds for self promotion (a practice long rejected by most within the party, but embraced by the vast majority of Brazilian politicians), and absent large campaign war chests, the party is particularly susceptible to media bias. As for the effects of clientelism and corruption, the literature is replete with studies indicating how machine politics and vote-buying sway elections, especially among the poorest segments of the population—precisely those who receive the benefits of the PT’s “inversion of priorities” and should be most grateful or interested.51 Popular Participation Fully aware of these problems, and believing that social/political activism begets political consciousness or empowerment (which, in turn, constructs
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
47
authentic democracy by diminishing the formerly oligopolistic power of political and economic elites), the PT’s agenda for local governance long emphasized the importance of encouraging empowerment and citizen activism by opening up new channels of political participation.52 The reasons for doing so should, by now, be simple to understand. PT leaders and activists were convinced that democratic governments in Brazil would still be capitalist and clientelistic; meaning that a PT government’s autonomy to carry out egalitarian reforms would be limited by the State’s ultimate financial dependence upon revenues generated by capitalist enterprises and employment, by the social and political power of wellentrenched economic and political groups (including those within the State bureaucracy itself ), and by the ability of such groups to construct and finance a conservative political opposition.53 Electoral mandates would never be enough. A PT administration would have to construct new forms of ongoing organized and mobilized popular support if it hoped to be able to implement any of its proposed reforms. Given the power of an elitedominated opposition, that popular support would have to be widespread, not restricted to the PT’s core constituency of organized labor, progressive Catholics, and Leftist intellectuals. Clearly, empowering Brazil’s numerically superior, but organizationally challenged nonelites would have to be a necessary and integral component of any successful progressive reform. The ultimate goal of popular participation was therefore clear. But how to carry it out? Early PT administrations set up Municipal Councils and Popular Councils (Conselhos Municipais and Conselhos Populares) focused on specific themes—education, public health, public housing, etc.—in hopes that by meeting together in familiar settings (e.g. neighborhood meeting halls or local school buildings) and expressing opinions on issues they themselves deemed important, participants could channel those opinions directly into the formal decision-making processes of the Administration and the City Council.54 Some of the more radical factions within the party saw these councils as ideal locations for popular consciousness-raising and for the coordination and mobilization of disparate antisystem (i.e. anticapitalist and antidemocratic) political currents. A growing majority within the party, however, saw them as suited to the new “heterodox” party project of citizen empowerment via popular participation—a project proposal, so to speak, that would eventually become the hegemonic ideological and strategic position within the party.55 While popular councils held a privileged position on both sides of the PT’s ideological debates, arguments in their favor also included a strong pragmatic component. By incorporating such forums into formal decision-making
48
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
processes, PT administrators of all stripes hoped that average citizens would become more involved in local politics, thereby helping the administrations to challenge the traditional dominance of paternalistic elites, clientelistic political machines, and other elite-dominated practices and institutions. Other strategic goals included the following: ●
●
●
●
providing governmental access to the PT’s core constituency of union and social movement activists; creating alternative channels of communication (so as not to rely on the predictably anti-PT local media or expensive government propaganda campaigns);56 creating ostensibly nonpartisan networks of popular support and mobilization (so as not to rely on the typically small number of supporters active in party politics and organized civil society); directly exposing apolitical or non-PT Brazilians to the PT’s “mode of governance” in the hopes of winning them over for electoral and mobilizational purposes.
It is impossible to say which of these logics—ideological or strategic— predominated in the adoption of popular participation programs by the leadership of early PT administrations. For some, strategy paved the way to ideology.57 Former Secretary of Extraordinary Affairs in the 1989–1992 PT administration of São Paulo, Ladislau Dowbor, exemplifies this trajectory in the following statement: What we saw initially as basically a springboard to “real” power higher up proved to be an essential environment for rebuilding citizenship . . . . Suddenly, people realize that the public space belongs to them and not necessarily to professional politicians. This certainly does not resolve national and global issues, but in the long run it certainly will change the way politics is perceived at any level. Through local administrations, I have no doubt that we are contributing very seriously to a more general change in political culture.58 For others, in a process I earlier called “institutional learning,” initial orthodox justifications were softened as mobilization and party-building took a back seat to the need to build citizen support for administration policies in the give-and-take bargaining inherent in democratic governance and public administration.59 Committed early on to the construction of participatory Councils, the immediate challenge was to make them truly popular and not just a place for
Participatory Democracy in Practice
●
49
State administrators to dictate to a silent group of passive listeners, or for fellow petistas and their organized allies to argue among themselves. An even bigger challenge, however, was to insure that the Councils not be seen as mere instruments of party recruitment and propaganda (something that some within the party openly desired). Thus, there was a basic contradiction built into the PT’s very idea of participatory councils. On the one hand, citizens’ empowerment was assumed by many in the party to mean PT-style political and ideological consciousness and even party identification. On the other hand, openly partisan messages and indoctrination would quickly delegitimate the whole process before a population tired and disillusioned with party politics, and an opposition just waiting to expose the “underlying agenda” of the PT’s “Trojan Horse” commitment to Participatory Democracy. The Participatory Budget One effort to resolve this apparent contradiction emerged in 1989 in the city of Porto Alegre in the state of Rio Grande do Sul, then governed by the PT under the leadership of Olívio Oliveira Dutra (1989–1992): the Participatory Budget (Orçamento Participativo: OP). Porto Alegre’s PT argued that their OP democratized local democracy by disempowering traditional entrenched political elites and empowering nonelites. The means: giving ordinary citizens access to the most important decision-making process at the municipal level—spending the city’s money. The Brazilian political scientist Ricardo Tavares describes the way Porto Alegre’s OP functioned in its early years: Popular assemblies in 16 city zones bring together 10,000 people and 600 grassroots organizations to debate and vote on municipal expenditure priorities. From a general budget of approximately $465 million, about 31% is divided up in an open, public process involving large numbers of people and interests. As a result of this process, the city’s residents decided the city should concentrate its resources on legalizing land titles, providing water and sewage to poor communities (almost 100% of households now have clean drinking water), transportation, and environmental clean-up.60 The success of Porto Alegre’s OP in terms of growing levels of citizen participation and a clearly popular redistributive outcome of the entire process (capped by the PT’s reelection in 1992 and 1996, and by Dutra’s election to the governorship of Rio Grande do Sul in 1998), generated great interest
50
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
within the party in studying and duplicating the strategy.61 Porto Alegre’s PT seemed to have discovered a means of balancing pragmatic demands that voters perceive government programs to be in their own vital interests, with ideological concerns for promoting citizens’ empowerment and building the foundations of a new post–Cold War socialist hegemony.62 The OP quickly became a cornerstone of PT administration in virtually every PT-run city in the late-1980s and 1990s (although party leaders are quick to point out that it is only one of many “new public spaces” that the party constructs for the purposes of promoting greater popular participation).63 And while fundamentally reformist in nature, the OP could easily fit into the Left’s traditional discourse of radical, even revolutionary, change. The following words from a speech by Patrus Ananias, former PT mayor of Belo Horizonte, the capital of Minas Gerais, are a case in point: The OP constitutes a political, administrative and cultural revolution. It’s a political revolution because it constructs popular democracy leading to greater solidarity, concern for the common good and a redistributive outcome. It’s an administrative revolution because it directly confronts corruption by bringing in the people to oversee the State—they move from being mere spectators to being actors. And it’s a cultural revolution because by increasing the spaces of active citizenship, it changes the mentality of people, giving them greater political and social consciousness. It starts with you being concerned about the street in front of your house. Then you’re talking about your neighborhood, your region, your city, your state, and finally your entire country.64 Rather than immerse ourselves in the quite large and growing literature on Porto Alegre’s OP, chapter five allows me to return to my own discoveries of the PT’s practices of popular participation in the state of Minas Gerais in the mid-to-late 1990s. Let me make clear, however, that what I observed in Minas Gerais should be seen as an illustrative example—a case study—of what was taking place at that same time in PT-administered municipalities throughout Brazil. Indeed, similar experiments have been implemented in such distinct places throughout the world as Japan, Jamaica, Canada, Uruguay, Bolivia, and South Africa, to name but a few.65 The following chapter, then, is a detailed description of how the OP functioned in the medium-sized industrial town of Betim in the state of Minas Gerais.
CHAPTER 5
The Orçamento Participativo in Betim, Minas Gerais
T
he medium-sized city of Betim (roughly 300,000 inhabitants in 1998) is, in many ways, a microcosm of Brazil as a whole.1 Similar to most of the country’s experience of urbanization since the 1950s, Betim literally mushroomed from its rural small town origins when industry began to locate there in the early-1970s.2 By the 1990s, the city had continued to grow by some 15,000 to 20,000 inhabitants per year. Located about 25 miles from the city of Belo Horizonte, capital of the state of Minas Gerais, and Brazil’s third largest city, Betim has shared in the fortunes and the misfortunes of Belo Horizonte’s (BH) larger metropolitan area.3 Both Betim and BH were notable in the 1980s and 1990s for their relatively vibrant economies,but also for their alarming social problems rooted, since the 1950s, in a sustained rapid influx of poor rural immigrants and a series of income-concentrating economic development models initiated by the federal government. The results mirrored those of the nation: high but unstable levels of economic growth and wealth creation, and an extremely unequal distribution of that wealth. Also similar to the rest of Brazil, patron–client relations had long dominated politics and social relations in Minas Gerais.4 Accordingly, public and social services in Betim were scarce where they were not entirely absent. Writing in the first year of the new PT administration (1993), Otílie Macedo Pinheiro, Technical Advisor to Betim’s Secretariat of Planning and Coordination, wrote the following description of Betim at that time: Betim is a municipality situated in the metropolitan area of Belo Horizonte. It is marked by strong contrasts.
52
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
One the one hand, it collects the second highest amount of tax revenue in the state of Minas Gerais, it has a modern and consolidated industrial park, and has strong potential for growth and adaptation to new economic and technological conditions. On the other hand, it is the municipality with the highest statewide indexes of favelização [shanty town living conditions], it has a high rate of unemployment, and the greater portion of its 200,000 inhabitants lack the training to occupy the jobs created within the city. The current administration entered office finding only 30% of households with access to sewers, only 40% of the roads were paved, there was not a single hospital bed in the public sector, and seven entire neighborhoods had neither running water nor electricity. In other words, Betim is a municipality rich in revenues, but with a population that is poor and totally lacking in public services.5 And while Brazil’s Constitution of 1988 provided an unprecedented decentralization of resources to states and municipalities, the first Cardoso administration (1995–1998) and the allied state government of Eduardo Azeredo instituted a series of recentralizing fiscal reforms beginning in 1996 that hit municipalities the hardest (especially those run by opposition parties, which were deliberately shut out of compensatory “side payments” in the form of various and assorted federal and state government initiatives).6 In this context of poorly distributed wealth, longstanding clientelism, inadequate infrastructure and (later) diminishing resources from the federal and state governments, the citizens of Betim elected Maria do Carmo Lara Perpétuo (1993–1996) and Jésus Lima (1997–2000), both of the Partido dos Trabalhadores (PT), to govern their town.7 While the story of how Maria do Carmo and Jésus literally changed the face of Betim is both interesting and inspiring,8 in what follows, I will focus primarily on their efforts to design and implement Betim’s Orçamento Participativo (OP). In subsequent chapters, I will select out and expand upon several of the most important claims and criticisms of those in favor and against the OP. These claims and criticisms will form the foundation for a subsequent critical analysis of the PT’s version of the Participatory Democratic model based on case studies of both Betim and BH. Betim’s OP in Action On July 22, 1995, I observed 129 residents of the working-class neighborhood of Bairro Betim Industrial meeting together to discuss, in effect, what the city government could and should do for them and for the city as a
The OP in Betim, Minas Gerais
●
53
whole. For weeks preceding this particular meeting, the residents of Bairro Betim Industrial had been informed of the meeting by way of handbills distributed by city workers, carros de som (cars with loudspeakers mounted on top) circulating through the streets of the neighborhood, and by word of mouth among the residents themselves. Throughout June and July of 1995, 99 such meetings were held all over Betim in an effort to include all of the city’s 128 neighborhoods.9 1995 was, in fact, the third year in which the citizens of Betim were meeting in neighborhoods throughout the city to vote for the upcoming year’s spending priorities. Opening the meeting in Bairro Betim Industrial, the head of the local Regional Administration and chief organizer of these meetings throughout his region, Airton Augusto, explained the concept behind the city’s OP.10 The basic idea was simple: the administration wanted neighborhood residents to meet together with members of the OP’s organizing team in order to openly discuss and democratically select a list of priorities for public works and social spending in their own neighborhood, in the region of the city in which their neighborhood was a part, and in the city as a whole. Residents were encouraged to “nominate” specific spending priorities at all three levels and to participate in the subsequent debates about which should constitute the top three priorities for each level. Following the debates, they would vote by a show of hands—each person could vote for three priorities at the neighborhood level, three at the regional level, and three at the citywide level. The final tally would determine their collective sense of the government’s top three spending priorities for each level. Their final task would be to elect neighborhood representatives from among themselves—one delegate for each ten residents present at the meeting—to attend the next month’s Regional Budgetary Assembly where regional spending priorities would be discussed and voted upon. These representatives would then elect 500 delegates from among themselves to form a Municipal Budgetary Congress for discussion and a final vote on citywide priorities. Airton then explained the OP’s origins. Maria do Carmo had been elected mayor as a candidate of the PT in 1992. Throughout the campaign, she had promised that the OP would be a centerpiece of her administration: an “ethical proposal” rooted in the PT’s ideology and “mode of governance” which explicitly elevated popular participation to a guiding principle.11 Airton ended his talk with a rundown of past OP results and the extent to which “popular demands” had been met by the administration since coming to power: a municipal hospital, three emergency health care centers, eight elementary schools, fourteen daycare centers, eight public dental care centers, and a center of popular culture.
54
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
Following Airton’s introduction, Gilberto Lisboa, president and founding member of the local neighborhood association, described the history of the neighborhood’s struggle to acquire such basic public services as bus service and paved thoroughfares. He praised the OP for making that struggle that much easier. Gilberto, also a member of the PT, finished by stressing the power of neighborhood unity, and the need for continued solidarity (defined by him as the responsibility on the part of “those who have” to understand that others “who don’t have” deserve help in order to catch up). During the two-hour meeting, all who wanted to speak and offer suggestions were allowed to do so. Nevertheless, this was clearly a case of “guided” popular participation, as Gilberto essentially ran the show. Votes were taken, but not without Gilberto’s frequent interjections of, “I think . . . is most important for us,” or “That concern is best taken up in a different manner.” While this sort of intervention has formed grounds for criticizing the process as window-dressing for PT manipulation (a critique I will discuss in greater detail in chapter seven), confusion on the part of a great many participants was a constant throughout this meeting as well as others I observed in Betim and elsewhere. This confusion often took the form of individuals stubbornly pushing personal interests and demands, or repeatedly returning to a point from which the discussion had already moved on until other participants would get disgusted, tune out, or actually leave the meeting. Confronted with this, Gilberto’s “guiding” of the process is understandable albeit, perhaps, lamentable in terms of the underlying didactic purpose of such meetings (i.e. “empowerment” via participation). At the end of the meeting, the voting results were as follows: ●
●
●
neighborhood priorities: (1) pave selected streets (2) build a neighborhood health post (3) augment the sewer system; regional priorities: (1) augment the sewer system (2) build a cultural center (3) pave selected thoroughfares; citywide priorities: (1) outfit the newly constructed hospital (2) build a bus terminal (3) finish construction of a major traffic artery through town.
At the end of the meeting, thirteen residents of Bairro Betim Industrial were elected as delegates for the upcoming Regional Budgetary Assembly. The previous year in Bairro Betim Industrial, only thirty people had shown up to the neighborhood meeting. As a result, the neighborhood sent only three delegates to the Regional Budgetary Assembly.12 While all of this was going on, administration officials used a somewhat complicated formula to determine the amount of budgetary resources each
The OP in Betim, Minas Gerais
●
55
Administrative Region would receive. From the 1995 estimated municipal revenues for 1996 of R$130 million (roughly US$144 million at the time), they deducted such fixed costs as public servants’ wages, interest payments on past debt, and ongoing administrative operations. The administration determined that the remaining R$21 million available for new investments (16.15 percent of total revenues) was the effective budget of the OP for 1996.13 Based on regional population figures (higher population meant more “points”) and an assessment of infrastructure needs (lack of public services meant more “points”), the administration assigned a percentage of this total “new investments” budget to each region and a percentage to the city as a whole. In the subsequent Regional Assemblies and Municipal Congress, delegates could only approve about half of the priorities handed up from the neighborhood meetings. In the weeks leading up to the Assemblies, elected OP delegates were offered a training course focusing on instruction in the basics of public administration and budgeting. Just prior to the Assemblies, delegates traveled together in a string of city buses to each of the priority sites to hear local residents and delegates speak out on behalf of their specific project (an event called the “Caravana do OP” or The OP Caravan). Negotiations among delegates of mutual support were often intense (“We will vote for your neighborhood’s priorities, if you vote for ours”). Following debates and show-of-hands voting in each of the Regional Budgetary Assemblies and in the Municipal Budgetary Congress, the final results were presented as part of the administration’s 1996 budget to Betim’s city council for debate and a final vote. With only three of the council’s twenty-one members, the PT had struggled bitterly with the chamber from day one of Maria do Carmo’s administration.14 Most council members had shown themselves to represent precisely the sort of clientelistic and paternalistic practices that the PT wished to eradicate: extravagant salaries (e.g. the salary of the council president was almost twice that of the mayor), nepotism, vote buying, and clientelistic distribution of public goods and services to supporters, rather than to all eligible citizens.15 While they could not openly admit it, these council members resented the fact that their names were no longer tied to significant public works projects “offered up” by the administration. They could no longer claim these projects as their “gifts” to the citizens in return for the latter’s continued or future support at the polls. The administration was deliberately changing the long-standing rules of the game—deliberately usurping a significant source of council members’ power and prestige. Most members of the council were not happy about the change.
56
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
Council members proposed exactly 345 amendments to the Administration’s first OP-generated budget, the great majority of which represented efforts to channel OP funds toward their own pet projects. Throughout the council’s deliberations, some 200 delegates from the Regional OP Assemblies and the Municipal OP Congress lobbied alongside administration officials to keep the OP exactly as it had been presented. They repeatedly argued to the council that the OP expressed the direct wishes of the population; to act against those wishes was to risk public condemnation and difficulties in reelection. In the end, only thirty-one amendments were sustained, and the OP for 1994, thus amended, received unanimous approval from the council. In order to better institutionalize this necessary popular pressure on behalf of the mayor’s OP-assisted budget proposal before the city council, mayor Maria do Carmo created the Conselho Municipal do Orçamento Participativo (CMOP) consisting of representatives elected from the Municipal Budgetary Congress. The CMOP subsequently met once a month throughout the year, not only to support the administration’s budget proposal before the city council, but also to monitor the administration’s implementation of OP-generated budget priorities. Relations between Mayor Maria do Carmo and the city council remained conflictual throughout her tenure.16 They reached a particularly low point in late 1994 when the council launched an official inquiry into charges of financial malfeasance against her administration, charges that eventually included an attempt to impeach the mayor herself (all charges were later dropped as groundless). Widely perceived as a retaliation against her efforts to restrict pay increases for council members and to limit budget outlays for the council as a whole, the situation was resolved when negotiations resulted in more modest increases than those originally proposed by the council. In a context of rising municipal revenues (a significant side benefit of diminishing levels of inflation in the mid-1990s and the health of Betim’s industrial park), the substantial perks of council membership were both affordable and formidable, including council members’ monthly salaries of R$4,500 (over US$4,000), R$750 bonus for each of up to two “extraordinary” council meetings per month, the right of each member to hire up to seventeen fulltime “assistants” (forty for the council president) and retention of 5 percent of the city budget to spend as they please.17 Rising revenues and a public approval rating that reached 98 percent in the last year of her mandate also enabled mayor Maria do Carmo to hold onto her discretionary control of over 40 percent of the city’s budget. Although most of this had to be spent on operational costs of the municipality, this did not shield the mayor from council members’ criticisms that she, herself, was using the money for clientelistic and self-promoting purposes.18
The OP in Betim, Minas Gerais
●
57
Relations between the city council and the administration reached their most explosive proportions in 1997, however, following the election of Maria do Carmo’s vice mayor, Jésus Lima. In the middle of his first year in office, on August 29, 1997, Lima was shot five times at close range in a public meeting. Miraculously, he survived. The police quickly caught the gunman, and identified the former president of Betim’s city council, José do Nascimento Elias, as the “intellectual author” of the assassination attempt.19 Lima had barely recovered from his wounds when he found himself locked in an intense, albeit familiar, political struggle with the opposition block of city council members over his OP-inspired 1998 budget proposal. In a context of fiscal retrenchment due to federal and state policies that the administration claimed reduced the city’s revenues in 1997 by R$36 to 40 million (equivalent to 24–27 percent of the 1998 budget), Lima mandated that that year’s OP could not consider new expenditures but only prioritize the completion of those already under construction or left undone from previous OPs. Unhappy with Lima’s decision, CMOP delegates entered into the fray by demanding a 42 percent reduction of resources to the city council, from R$13 million in 1997 to 7.5 million in 1998.20 The council responded by rejecting the entire budget proposal and drafting an alternative, increasing its own resources to R$14 million, paid for with draconian cuts to social spending programs and to the city’s basic operating expenses, and with the reduction of the mayor’s discretionary spending from 40 percent down to zero. Both sides sent the issue to court, during which time the city actually had two competing budgets of questionable legality. The struggle was so vitriolic that even the national media reported the story, focusing primarily on council members’ salaries, open nepotism, extravagant self-promotion, and other expensive perks. Meanwhile, several federal Senators publically cited the example of Betim’s city council as they proposed a Constitutional amendment limiting the amount of resources that could be passed on to municipal legislators.21 Negotiations between Lima and the city council, including the active participation of CMOP councilors, eventually arrived at a solution of R$10.9 million to the council and discretionary freedom for the mayor over 15 percent of the total budget. Over Lima’s veto, the council also voted in a new perk: each member would receive R$15,000 annually to distribute to philanthropic organizations (broadly defined) of their choice, including those over which they themselves presided.22 When I next visited Betim in September of 1998, the 1999 OP was in full swing; but participation was markedly down.23 Once again, the idea of building new public works projects had to be abandoned due, in part, to the continued fiscal crunch, in part to the unforeseen costs of maintaining previously constructed OP projects (e.g. the municipal hospital, a 24-hour
58
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
first aid center, much expanded sewer, and running water systems, etc.), but also due to Mayor Lima’s decision to invest heavily in a particularly largescale item prioritized in previous OP budgets but never constructed: a part major traffic artery, part flood control, part beautification project that entailed dredging the polluted river that flowed through town, channeling it in concrete, laying down two lanes of asfalt on each side, and constructing a “green zone” park around the entire project. Administration officials knew that participation in the OP would suffer and that delegates would use a lot of their time criticizing the administration. Mayor Lima, however, had become increasingly disappointed in the OP because he felt that the previous year’s delegates had used the OP primarily as a forum to criticize the administration while discounting the overwhelming fiscal problems confronting the city. After months of discussions with CMOP councilors, the administration decided to go ahead that year with an “educational” OP, one that would discuss the origins of the city’s financial problems (federal and state policies), highlight the nature of the city’s spending over the last several years, and introduce OP delegates to the idea of expanding and diversifying the OP in the future. By holding neighborhood meetings for several contiguous neighborhoods at once, the number of that year’s meetings was reduced from 1995’s ninetynine to just sixty-six meetings. Only 2,614 citizens participated in those meetings, electing 495 delegates for the regional OP forums and the Municipal OP Congress.24 Because of declining participation, each delegate now represented five participants at neighborhood meetings, and regional delegates were now automatically municipal delegates as well. Since no new public works projects were being voted on at that year’s Municipal OP Forum, Mayor Lima’s and Betim’s OP coordinators were surprised that over 500 delegates and citizens showed up for the event on a pleasant Sunday afternoon. The following year, in an effort to reinvigorate participation in Betim’s OP 2000, the administration diversified the range and scope of coverage of the OP, organizing six public Plenary Sessions for interested OP delegates and other citizens: Culture and Sports, Urban Development, Social and Economic Development, Health, Public Administration, and Education.25 Diversification meant that interested citizens and elected delegates could move beyond discussing and deciding upon that part of the budget exclusively dedicated to public works. They would now be able to discuss and decide upon spending priorities for the entire city budget. In the words of one member of the administration’s organizing body for the OP: “It’s a question of raising social and political consciousness. Up to now, people only see the hole in the street and work to get it fixed through the OP. Now they
The OP in Betim, Minas Gerais
●
59
see things on a much larger scale. . . . People can discuss all public policies and the trade-offs involved in choosing them, not just public works projects.”26 Each subject-specific Plenary Session would begin with a general discussion of municipal finances (revenues and expenses, broken down by department and type of income or operating expense). Relevant departmental heads would then present their department’s specific financial report, followed by a presentation of ongoing programs and projects and their proposal for the next fiscal year. Participants would then break down into groups to discuss the quality of existing services, and to indicate suggested reforms. These discussions and suggestions would be recorded and included in the general discussion of the budget in the Municipal OP Congress, thereby helping OP delegates to decide on where budgetary resources for the entire city administration would best be used. Betim’s OP experience is broadly representative of the universe of cases of PT-administered OP programs. The administration calls a series of neighborhood meetings throughout the city to discuss the next fiscal year’s budget, particularly the spending priorities for public works projects. Each meeting begins with officials presenting a rundown of the city’s fiscal situation followed by a description of what the OP is (part of the administration’s more general commitment to “popular participation” and “transparent” decisionmaking), the “official line” of why the OP exists (citizens’ empowerment and democratic accountability), and what is expected of participants in the OP. Participating residents at these meetings nominate a list of hoped-for public works projects for their neighborhood, for the region of the city that encompasses their neighborhood, and for the city as a whole. During the presentation of these project proposals, residents are allowed to publically voice their preferences for one or more projects. A final vote establishes a list of projects, prioritized by the number of votes each receives. Finally, residents nominate and vote on a group of OP delegates (usually one for each ten residents attending the neighborhood meeting) who will participate in the final prioritization, again by way of majority voting, at subsequent regional and/or municipal OP Assemblies. Before that final vote, administration officials prepare detailed feasibility studies and cost estimates for each project emerging as a priority from the neighborhood meetings. Armed with this information, and with the experience of having personally visited each project site in an “OP Caravan,” OP delegates are free to negotiate and network among themselves in the days leading up to the final vote. Results are then incorporated into the administration’s budget proposal presented to the city council. OP delegates, or an elected subset of them, accompany the process of negotiations with the city council, defending the administration’s proposal from
60
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
amendments that might redirect resources toward the priorities of individual council members. Naturally, this entire process creates great pressure on city council members (on the whole, entirely unused to so much public involvement in such matters) to either go along with or even to participate in the OP process, or to develop legitimate arguments as to why such collaboration is not possible or desirable. Most of Betim’s city council members chose the second option. The resulting arguments made in favor of and against the OP are representative of those I have encountered, either personally or in the literature, regarding OP experiences in other PT-administered cities in Brazil.27 The following is a list of the most important polemical claims and criticisms in terms of our discussion of Participatory Democracy. Here, I will present them only as arguments. In the next two chapters, however, I will expand and elaborate on each of them in an effort to shine some light upon the relevant debates and, hopefully, to draw some conclusions about the version of the Participatory Democratic model that the PT has put into practice.
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Principal pro-OP Claims Pro-OP Claim #1: The OP is fundamentally popular participation (participants are primarily nonelites). Pro-OP Claim #2: The OP is an instrument of empowerment (through participation, the previously excluded become socially conscious and politically active). Pro-OP Claim #3: The OP constitutes another layer of political representation (participants represent the broader interests of their neighborhoods, their organizations, and of people “like them”). Principal anti-OP Criticisms: Anti-OP Criticism #1: The OP is unnecessarily antagonistic to the legislative body (e.g. city council) and to existing representative organizations in civil society. Anti-OP Criticism #2: The great majority of citizens never participate in the OP, and among those few that do, the subsequent drop-off in their participation is evidence that so-called popular participation is actually not popular at all.28 Anti-OP Criticism #3: The OP is merely a disguised form of party activism and recruitment for the PT (“partisanization”). Anti-OP Criticism #4: Most “common” people don’t know how, and can’t know how, to participate in such complicated and important political processes as budget-making (nonelites are incapable of serious political decision-making).
CHAPTER 6
Examining the Claims of Proponents of the Participatory Budget
O
ver the years, I have been impressed at the number of Partido dos Trabalhadores (PT) leaders and activists who describe popular participation (more often than not, exemplified with a reference to the Orçamento Participativo (OP) in terms of the well-known Christian parable: “You can give a poor man a fish today and he will be hungry tomorrow, or you can teach him to fish and he will never be hungry again.” As discussed in chapters three and four, popular participation is said to engender empowerment: as the poor and otherwise excluded/disengaged majority take part in processes of decision-making and policy implementation that improve their lives and that of their communities, they are able to see themselves as agents in their own self-improvement and not mere supplicants of generally inadequate and ultimately demobilizing “gifts from on high.”1 They are able to see themselves, in other words, as bearers of human and political rights. For an individual’s empowerment to be effective, however, PT leaders are quick to point out that empowerment has both an individual and a collective dimension. The transformation of the individual as summarized earlier cannot bear fruit without the necessary collective dimension of political engagement. Empowerment therefore explicitly assumes an acceptance of the responsibility of active democratic citizenship: since one has acquired the consciousness to act, one is obligated to use that consciousness in the continuing struggle against economic inequality, political authoritarianism, paternalism, and other forms of oppression. This is all the more necessary in a political context of electoral democracy where a “popular democratic” party (e.g. the PT) may occupy positions of executive and
62
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
legislative power only to be turned out at the next election by those determined to return to the demobilizing and disempowering traditions and practices that have characterized Brazilian politics for most of its history. Empowered citizens, in this latter scenario, are something of an insurance policy against a total rollback of progressive reforms instituted under PT leadership.2 But to what extent is this responsibility to become, in effect, a political activist actually embraced by those exposed to these new participatory public spaces? That’s a question that kept coming back to me as I delved into the histories of Brazil’s PT and the OP in Minas Gerais and elsewhere.3 Was it possible to verify these claims of OP-induced popular participation and empowerment? If so, we could potentially go a long way toward embracing the Participatory Democratic model as a practical alternative to neoliberalism, neopopulism, and do-nothing conservativism. If not, well, we need to know if we’re barking up the wrong tree. I visited Minas Gerais for the third time in late 1998 for a period of seven months, determined to empirically test the claims of OP supporters (as well as the anti-OP criticisms discussed in chapter seven). I chose to study two OP processes that were in full swing that year: the aforementioned case of Betim, and that of the nearby state capital, Belo Horizonte (BH).4 Some of my questions about popular participation and empowerment were amenable to statistical analysis, so I designed and distributed questionnaires to Betim’s 495 OP delegates at their 1998 Municipal OP Congress, and to BH 1,950 OP delegates in each of their nine Regional OP Forums (see annex one).5 In Betim, 222 delegates (44.85 percent) filled out and returned the questionnaires. In BH, 1,068 (54.77 percent) did the same. To complement the quantitative analysis, I interviewed numerous OP administrators, elected officials, leaders, and members of neighborhood associations, as well as individual OP delegates. Using these data as the basis of analysis, let us now take a much closer look at the three principal claims made by OP proponents introduced in the conclusion of chapter five. ●
Pro-OP Claim #1: The OP is fundamentally popular participation (participants are primarily nonelites).
As in all PT-administered cities and states, Betim’s and BH’s administrators and political leaders claim that the OP is an instance of “popular participation.” In other words, it is primarily intended as a means for previously excluded, ignored, and/or underserved nonelites to have access to, and to become more active participants in, democratic politics. While all citizens are welcome to participate, OP administrators expect the more wealthy and
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
63
comfortable to have less interest—which is not a problem, because these latter groups are assumed to already have ready access to the political system and to other means of economic and social advancement. In the words of Pitagoras dos Santos, Advisor to the Northern Regional Administration in BH: The more wealthy and middle class . . . often ignore instruments of popular participation and go directly to the “formal institutions” and elected officials. . . . Those in the poorer neighborhoods are more active in the OP and in social movements in general. Their problems are more starkly present in their neighborhoods and are more associated with public goods like running water, sewers, and the like.6 That’s more or less the “official line.” But do OP delegates really come primarily from the nonelite ranks of society? In addition to testing the claims of OP proponents, this question is all the more important because a number of participatory programs implemented elsewhere—in the United States, for example—have been noted for their tendency to attract a disproportionate number of relatively well-to-do and more-educated participants.7 The claims of predominantly popular or nonelite participation in the OP are clearly borne out in the cases of Betim and BH. Figures 6.1, 6.2, and 6.3 present the basic characteristics of the respondents to my questionnaire in both cities: sex, level of education and employment.8 Figure 6.1 shows that women constituted 44.2 percent of BH’s delegates, and 39.6 percent of Betim’s. While men constituted the majority in both cases, the proportions are by no means wildly skewed. In addition, it’s important to note that women are far more underrepresented in Brazil’s formal political institutions. Of Betim’s 21 City Council members in 1997, for example, two (9.5 percent) were women; of BH’s 37 Council members in 1998, 6 (16.2 percent) were women; of the 77 state deputies in the Legislative Assembly of Minas Gerais elected in 1998, 5 (6.5 percent) were women.9 The popular or nonelite character of OP participants in both BH and Betim are also visible in terms of OP delegates’ levels of education. Figure 6.2 shows that 69 percent of BH’s delegates, and 81.1 percent of Betim’s, had less than a high school education. This popular or nonelite profile is even further reinforced by data regarding delegates’ employment status. Figure 6.3 shows that salaried workers, housewives, the retired, and the unemployed constituted 59.9 percent of BH’s delegates, and 64 percent of Betim’s.
64
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
70.00
% of All Respondents
60.00 50.00 40.00 30.00 20.00 10.00 0.00 Male
Female
n/a Betim (222 Resps)
BH (1,068 Resps)
Figure 6.1 Sex of Delegates: BH and Betim, 1998.
60.00
% of Respondents
50.00 40.00 30.00 20.00 10.00
BH (1,068 Resps)
a. n.
C Pri om m pl ary et H e ig In h S co c m ho pl o H ete l ig h C S om ch pl oo et l e U In ni co ve m rs pl ity et e U C niv om er pl sity et e
e co Prim m a pl ry et e In
Se
m
i-l
Ill
ite
ite
ra t
ra te
0.00
Betim (222 Resps)
Figure 6.2 Education of Delegates: BH and Betim, 1998.
The data contained in figures 6.1, 6.2, and 6.3 clearly support the claim of the OP’s popular or nonelite composition in the cities of BH and Betim. Given Brazil’s elitist political regime (itself a reflection of the country’s elitist political culture and social structures), these characteristics of active OP delegates in Betim and BH are quite remarkable. One thing they show us is that a significant number of nonelite Brazilians are willing to involve themselves
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
65
18.00 16.00 % of Respondents
14.00 12.00 10.00 8.00 6.00 4.00 2.00
BH (1,068 Resps)
n. a.
O th er &
pl oy ed
ife U
ne m
ed
H
ou se w
et ir R
ne ss Bu si
Se P rv ubl an ic ts La bo r :C &S La bo r :I nd .
Li bl .
Pr of l.
0.00
Betim (222 Resps)
Figure 6.3 Employment of Delegates: BH and Betim, 1998.
in participatory processes of local-level governance. While many nonelites are disengaged from the political world, some at least are willing to buck that trend if given the opportunity to do so. As its proponents claim, the OP appears to provide such an opportunity. Rebecca Abers reaches the same basic conclusion of predominantly nonelite participation in her case study of Porto Alegre’s OP, but her data point out an important detail: that “the ‘very poor’ living in squatter settlements and shanty towns were less well represented than the ‘not-so-poor’ poor living in impoverished, but somewhat better-off, working-class neighborhoods.”10 My own data on BH and Betim don’t allow me to comment comparatively on this observation. However, Abers’ conclusion that the poorest-of-the-poor participate less is consistent with some of my qualitative data obtained from interviews with OP administrators and activists in BH and Betim. The following comment from BH OP delegate, neighborhood activist and long-time PT activist, Rogério Pereira de Araujo, is exemplary in this regard: Maybe Brazilians—I would not say 100%, but the great majority—live their lives prisoners to their stomachs. They may need a lot more. But only after their stomachs are full can you talk to them of other things. Until that’s done, they’re worried about their day-to-day survival: rent to pay, children to feed with milk, a nagging wife—even worse when the
66
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
woman has to do all of these things herself. It’s hard to call such people to participate.11 Therefore, for lamentable albeit entirely understandable reasons, not all nonelites appear to be equally represented in OP-style participatory democratic institutions. When survival itself is in question, participation is either an unaffordable luxury or a minor distraction. ●
Pro-OP Claim #2: The OP is an instrument of empowerment (through participation, the previously excluded become socially conscious and politically active).
The following story, from an interview with Olira de Souza Viera (housewife, OP delegate, and founding member of a neighborhood-level Nongovernment Organization (NGO), the Commission of Social Welfare of Jardim Alterosa in Betim), is a perfect illustration of the claim made by proponents of the OP and Participatory Democracy that providing opportunities for political participation empowers previously apolitical nonelites, turning them into active participants in the broader political process: When I came here, I was a person practically asleep because I didn’t participate in anything. I only came to live here in this neighborhood. I don’t know why this place was so needy. But it was and still is. Then, suddenly, I woke up and started to get involved in the movements. I started in the OP on my own accord. I moved here from Belo Horizonte with my children, and there was nothing here: no place to go shopping, nothing. My kids wanted to go back to Belo Horizonte, and it was a constant struggle to keep them here. So I said, “I’m going to participate because a new mayor is coming into office now—and I hadn’t even voted for her, I was still voting in Belo Horizonte at the time—she seems very good, and I’m going to participate to make this place better.” So I did, and I’m still active today. I participate with all my heart in all the OP meetings. I fight, I cry— you know, it really hurts when it comes to the time where all the city council members vote against our budgets. It’s sad because you fight long and hard and it hurts. Days and nights away from your home fighting for a budget, wanting something for your region and, all of a sudden, twentytwo or twenty-one Council members go there and vote against it. It’s everything that the community—the region—wants, and all of a sudden, a few lazy asses with pockets full of money go there and vote against our work. I’ve cried many times because of this. And after I started to get involved in the OP, I started to have the courage to participate in other
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
67
activities. I started to participate in the Pastoral de Criança of the Catholic Church. And I learned a lot in these things. You learn and you pass along your learning to other people you meet along the way. . . . I also work with people with high blood pressure, with diabetics. . . . I never stop participating in the Church itself. So now, thanks to God, I’m awake, working for the community, and I intend to keep on working. And fighting too! I fight. I provoke. I go to the city council chambers and provoke and fight. Even though it may not be the time to do it, I do it anyway because what they do hurts me, you understand?12 Dona Olira’s story contains all the elements of a case study of OP-inspired empowerment: a previous history of no involvement in politics or collective action, an initial experience of participation in the OP turning into continued participation, and subsequent “spillover” participation into other arenas of collective action. More anecdotal evidence from Betim and BH supports this story of OP-inspired empowerment: three of Betim’s city council members in 1998 had begun their political careers as OP delegates, OP administrators spent a good deal of their time educating and training delegates to “see the bigger picture” (e.g. to know the city budget in its entirety and not just focus on individual public works projects in their own neighborhoods),13 and other delegates spoke to me about the OP in such terms as “The OP gave me the opportunity to do something more than just live my own life”14 and “Delegates are learning democracy by doing democracy.”15 But are these stories of OP-inspired empowerment truly typical ones? Are they representative of the majority, or a significant minority, of other OP delegates’ personal political histories? Or are they exceptions to a more general rule—for example, of delegates participating only once in the OP then, “untouched” by the experience, withdrawing back into their apolitical private lives and micro-communities (i.e. no empowerment); or, on the opposite extreme, of delegates with past histories of active participation in party politics and/or in organized civil society merely continuing their activism in the OP (i.e. previous empowerment being “carried over” into the OP)?16 These may be the most important questions that this book asks, for nonelite empowerment lies at the root of the Participatory Democratic model as it is normally understood and of the process definition of democracy. Referring to his own studies as well as those of political theorists Carole Pateman and Robert Dahl, David Held speaks directly to the importance of
68
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
the question of empowerment via participatory institutional design: Evidence from studies of innovations in democratic control of the workplace, while by no means unambiguous in all respects, highlights, according to Pateman, that “a positive correlation between apathy and low feelings of political efficacy and low socio-economic status,” typically found in most liberal democracies, can be broken by making democracy count in people’s everyday life, i.e. by extending the sphere of democratic control to those key institutions in which most people live out their lives. If people know opportunities exist for effective participation in decision-making, they are likely to believe participation is worthwhile, likely to participate actively and likely, in addition, to hold that collective decisions should be binding. On the other hand, if people are systematically marginalized and/or poorly represented, they are likely to believe that only rarely will their views and preferences be taken seriously, weighted equally with those of others or assessed in a process that is fair or just. Thus, they are likely to find few good reasons for participating in, and regarding as authoritative, the decision-making processes which affect their lives. On a continuum from effective to limited participation, modern liberal democracies lie, for many working-class, female and non-white citizens, strictly at the latter end.17 In my efforts to operationalize and measure the concept of empowerment as stimulated by participation in the OP process, I asked OP delegates in Betim and BH to indicate their participation in “civil society” and “political society” both at the time of the survey (September 1998) and prior to their election as OP delegates. While causation cannot be proven, a significant increase in participation would indicate a correlation between participants’ experience as OP delegates, and a subsequent or concomitant spillover participation into other social and political organizations (i.e. empowerment). Such a correlation would at least suggest a causal relationship between OP involvement and empowerment. Similarly, a significant decline in the number of delegates indicating no participation in organized civil society, and/or a decline in those declaring “no interest” in party politics, would suggest a movement from political passivity to activism.18 Table 6.1 illustrates the participation of BH’s and Betim’s OP delegates in civil society.19 Many BH delegates participated, both prior to their OP experience and at the time of the survey, in neighborhood organizations (52.2 and 64.5 percent), in religious groups (40 and 40.1 percent) and, to a more limited degree, in philanthropic and charity organizations (12.4 and
Table 6.1 Civil Society Participation. Neighborhood Organizations
Labor Unions
504 (52.17%) 623 (64.49%) 23.60%
98 (10.14%) 84 (8.70%) 14.30%
Betim Pre-OP 90 (48.39%) Time of Survey 113 (60.75%) % Change 25.60% n 186 (% of total)
28 (15.05%) 15 (8.06%) 46.40%
BH Pre-OP Time of Survey % Change
Religious Organizations
Cultural Entities
386 (39.96%) 97 (10.04%) 387 (40.06%) 103 (10.66%) 0.30% 6.20%
Philanthropic & Charity
Municipal Councils
Other
None
120 (12.42%) 95 (9.83%) 101 (10.46%) 190 (19.67%) 133 (13.77%) 119 (12.32%) 108 (6.93%) 118 (12.22%) 25.30% 37.90% 6.90% 10.80%
n 966 (% of total) 75 (40.32%) 72 (38.71%) 4.00%
20 (10.75%) 23 (12.37%) 15.00%
19 (10.22%) 21 (11.29%) 10.50%
14 (7.53%) 19 (10.22%) 35 (18.82%) 32 (17.20%) 19 (10.22%) 17 (9.14%) 51.40% 128.60% 0.00%
70
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
13.8 percent). Indices of “none” (i.e. no participation in organized civil society) among BH delegates stood at 19.7 percent prior to their OP involvement and 12.2 percent at the time of the survey. The direction of change in BH delegates’ levels of participation in civil society fits the hypothesis in almost all categories, the exception being labor union activities. Significant increases of 25.3 percent in other participatory Municipal Councils (in the areas of health, education, culture, etc.) and 23.6 percent in neighborhood associations; and a decrease of 37.9 percent in the “none” category represent changes that are all hypothesis-confirming.20 The data for Betim also show that a large percentage of delegates participated, both prior to their OP experience and at the time of the survey, in neighborhood organizations (48.4 and 60.8 percent) and in religious groups (40.3 and 38.7 percent). Smaller but still significant rates of participation are shown in philanthropic/charity organizations (10.2 and 11.3 percent) and in Municipal Councils (7.5 and 17.2 percent). Indices of “none” among Betim’s delegates (18.8 and 9.1 percent) are slightly lower compared with BH. As in BH, Betim’s data for the direction of change in levels of participation fit the hypothesis in most, but not all, categories. Most notable are significant increases of 25.6 percent in neighborhood associations, and 128.6 percent in Municipal Councils. Similarly, delegates claiming no participation in civil society organizations fell 51.4 percent. A significant drop (46.4 percent) in union participation among Betim’s delegates and among those in BH likely reflect a nationwide decline in union membership in the 1980s and 1990s resulting from economic crises and adjustment problems that plagued Brazil from the late 1970s.21 The basic thrust of the data from table 6.1, however, supports the hypothesized spillover relationship of the empowerment thesis between OP participation and greater participation in organized civil society. Most of this spillover occurred in neighborhood organizations and other local government-sponsored participatory processes. The astute reader will have recognized, however, that the majority of delegates in both cases were already active in civil society before becoming OP delegates (80.3 percent in BH and 81.2 percent in Betim). In other words, relatively few delegates (roughly 20 percent in both cases) were disengaged from civil society prior to their involvement in the OP. These data challenge claims made by proponents of the OP and the empowerment thesis that participatory processes like the OP address the problems of civic disengagement. Indeed, it would appear that the OP amounts to a great deal of “preaching to the choir,” that is to the already empowered, and comparatively very little actual empowerment.
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
71
This hypothesis-challenging conclusion is bolstered by the fact that the majority of delegates who were inactive in civil society prior to their involvement in the OP were first-time participants in the OP: 82.3 percent in BH and 73.3 percent in Betim. Only 17.7 percent in BH and 26.7 percent in Betim had become “veterans” (i.e. stayed on to participate for two or more years). Assuming that longer participation in the OP means more exposure to democratic learning-by-doing (and assuming that the 1998 group of delegates is representative of those from other years), this association indicates that disproportionately fewer pre-OP nonactivist delegates actually exposed themselves to such longer term political learning.22 Those most in need of empowerment, in other words, were the least likely to pursue it. Despite the relatively small number of delegates who were inactive in civil society prior to their involvement in the OP, and in spite of their tendency not to remain active in the OP beyond the first year, might not their involvement in the OP still generate higher levels of participation in at least some arenas of organized civil society (as seen in the general population)? In other words, can we still observe empowerment, defined as a spillover from the OP into civil society activism—in this case, first-time activism? Table 6.2 reformulates the data from table 6.1 by controlling for previous civil society activism. The results give only weak support to the empowerment thesis.23 First, slightly more than half (53.7 percent) of BH delegates who were inactive in civil society before they participated in the OP remained inactive. For Betim, however, only 40 percent remained inactive while 60 percent became active. In both cases, there were two significant increases in participation: 62 BH delegates (32.6 percent of those previously inactive in civil society) and 15 Betim delegates (42.9 percent) became active in neighborhood organizations upon joining the OP, while 14 BH delegates (7.4 percent) and 3 Betim delegates (8.6 percent) became active in religious organizations. In sum, the data show that the lion’s share of the spillover effect from OP participation to participation in organized civil society took place among individuals previously active in civil society. This is the same group that was also the most likely to remain participating in the OP beyond the first year. And while roughly half of the BH delegates who were inactive in civil society prior to their involvement in the OP remained inactive in civil society despite their OP activism, it is important to recognize that almost half did become active. At the same time, a majority (three-out-of-five) of previously inactive Betim delegates also became civil society activists. So while the data show that the OP generally did not attract a great many previously
Table 6.2 Civil Society Participation x Pre-OP Civil Society Activism. BH
Neighborhood Organizations Active
Pre-OP Time of Survey
504 (64.9%) 561 (72.3%)
Inactive 0 62 (32.6%)
Philanthropic & Charity Active Pre-OP Time of survey Betim
Neighborhood Organizations Active
Pre-OP Time of Survey
Inactive
120 (15.5%) 0 131 (16.9%) 2 (1.1%) n 966 (% is of Active or Inactive)
90 (59.6%) 98 (64.9%)
Inactive 0 15 (42.9%)
Philanthropic & Charity Active Pre-OP Time of Survey
Inactive
19 (12.6%) 0 19 (12.6%) 2 (5.7%) n 186 (% is of Active or Inactive)
Labor Unions Active 98 (12.6%) 83 (10.7%)
Inactive 0 1 (0.5%)
Religious Organizations Active
Inactive
386 (49.7%) 373 (48.1%)
Municipal Councils
0 14 (7.4%)
Cultural Entities Active
Inactive
97 (12.5%) 101 (13.0%)
Other
0 2 (1.1%)
None
Active
Inactive
Active
Inactive
Active
Inactive
95 (12.2%) 118 (15.2%)
0 1 (0.5%)
101 (13.0%) 100 (12.9%)
0 8 (4.2%)
0 16 (2.1%)
190 (100%) 102 (53.7%)
Labor Unions
Religious Organizations
Active
Inactive
28 (18.5%) 14 (9.3%)
0 1 (2.9%)
Active 75 (49.7%) 69 (45.7%)
Municipal Councils
Cultural Entities
Inactive
Active
0 3 (8.6%)
20 (13.2%) 23 (15.2%)
Other
Active
Inactive
Active
14 (9.3%) 30 (19.9%)
0 2 (5.7%)
19 (12.6%) 17 (11.3%)
Inactive 0 0
None Inactive
Active
0 2 (5.7%)
0 3 (2.0%)
Inactive 35 (100%) 14 (40.0%)
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
73
disengaged citizens, this conclusion is qualified in both cases (more so in Betim) by significant increases in participation, primarily in neighborhood associations, among the previously disengaged. What about party politics? Is participation in the OP associated with an increase in delegates’ participation in political society?24 Table 6.3 presents the data for both BH and Betim. BH delegates show relatively low pre-OP and time-of-survey indices in party membership (18.9 and 23.5 percent, respectively), party militancy (9.2 and 10.2 percent percent) and candidate militancy (5.9 and 8.6 percent), and only moderate indices of party sympathy (25.8 and 27.9 percent). These are combined with relatively high indices of disinterested voting (38.8 and 34.5 percent) and even a few isolated cases of disinterested nonvoting (3.8 and 2.9 percent).25 Despite these data, the direction of change in all categories indicates support for the empowerment thesis. A 24 percent increase in party membership, 11 percent in party militancy, 44.7 percent in candidate militancy, 8.3 percent in party sympathy and a 15.1 percent increase in interested non-partisanship all indicate increases in political participation or, in the case of the latter two, increased political consciousness in the arena of political society. These results are reflected in the 11.1 percent decrease in Disinterested Voting and the 23.3 percent decrease in disinterested nonvoting among BH delegates. Compared with BH, Betim’s data indicate a higher degree of activism and greater increases in participation/consciousness in political society 39.3 percent of its delegates were members of political parties at the time of the survey, up 36.2 percent from a pre-OP rate of 28.8 percent. Party militancy increased 52 percent, from 15.3 to 23.3 percent. Candidate militancy showed a 26.7 percent increase, from 9.2 to 11.7 percent. Sympathy for one or another political party and interested nonpartisanship remained steady at their pre-OP rates of 47.9 and 11 percent, respectively. These results are reflected in the decline of 36.1 percent in disinterested voters (22.1 to 14.1 percent), and in the fact that none of Betim’s delegates claimed to be disinterested in party politics to the point of never voting. Clearly, the data supports the hypothesized relationship of the empowerment thesis between OP participation and greater participation in political society.26 Once again, however, we need to ask whether our observations so far are the result, not of OP-induced political learning and empowerment, but rather of increased political activism on the part of those already active, in this case, in the arena of party politics. Slightly more than half of the delegates in BH (57.4 percent) and an overwhelming 77.9 percent of Betim’s
Table 6.3 Political Society Participation. Member
Party Militant
Candidate Militant
Party Sympathizer
BH Pre-OP 150 (18.9%) Time of Survey 186 (23.5%) % Change 24.0% n 792 (% of total)
73 (9.2%) 81 (10.2%) 11.0%
47 (5.9%) 68 (8.6%) 44.7%
204 (25.8%) 221 (27.9%) 8.3%
119 (15%) 137 (17.3%) 15.1%
307 (38.8%) 273 (34.5%) 11.1%
Betim Pre-OP Time of Survey % Change n 163 (% of total)
25 (15.3%) 38 (23.3%) 52.0%
15 (9.2%) 19 (11.7%) 26.7%
78 (47.9%) 78 (47.9%) 0.0%
18 (11%) 18 (11%) 0.0%
36 (22.1%) 23 (14.1%) 36.1%
47 (28.8%) 64 (39.3%) 36.2%
Interested Nonpartisan
Disinterested Voter
Disinterested Nonvoter 30 (3.8%) 23 (2.9%) 23.3%
0 0 0.0%
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
75
delegates were active in political society prior to their OP experience.27 As with the data on civil society, the prevalence of previously active participants challenges the claim of the empowerment thesis that participatory processes like the OP address the problems of civic disengagement. In the case of Betim, few delegates were disengaged from political society prior to becoming involved in the OP. BH, however, with its 337 delegates previously inactive in political society, does provide a more suitable test for the empowerment thesis: did they become empowered with their OP participation? Before we disaggregate these data based on previous activism in party politics, we should ask whether the same association between veteran delegates and previous activism that we saw with respect to civil society activism also attains in the arena of political society. It does. The majority of delegates who were inactive in political society prior to their involvement in the OP (71.9 percent in BH and 79.4 percent in Betim) were first-time participants in the OP. Only 28.1 percent in BH and 20.6 percent in Betim were “veteran” participants. So pre-OP political society activists are not only more likely than nonactivists to take advantage of the opportunity to participate in the OP, but they are also more likely to stay participating beyond the first year. In recognizing the same pattern we saw for civil society participation, we reach the same conclusion: those most in need of empowerment— the politically disengaged—are the least likely to pursue it in governmentsponsored participatory processes like the OP. Now, in spite of their relatively smaller numbers, and despite their tendency not to remain active in the OP beyond the first year, might not the OP involvement of delegates previously inactive in political society still generate higher levels of political consciousness and participation in political society (as observed for the general population)? In other words, can we still observe empowerment for this group? Table 6.4 reformulates the data from table 6.3 by controlling for previous political society activism. In BH, 72.4 percent of the 337 delegates previously inactive in political society still considered themselves disinterested voters at the time of the survey, while 5.9 percent placed themselves in the disinterested nonvoter category (total: 78.3 percent). In Betim, 58.3 percent of the 36 previously inactive delegates continued to call themselves disinterested voters (there were no disinterested nonvoting OP delegates in Betim). More promising numbers in both cases can be seen in the “mild” activism category of party sympathy (11.3 percent in BH, up 217 percent from only 3.6 percent; and 38.9 percent in Betim, up 180 percent from 13.9 percent) and in the 9.2 percent of BH’s delegates who came to identify themselves as interested nonpartisans. This means that
Table 6.4 Political Society Participation x Pre-OP Political Society Activism. BH
Member Active
Pre-OP Time of Survey
Party Militant
Inactive
150 (33%) 175 (38.5%)
0 11 (3.3%)
Interested Nonpartisan Active Pre-OP Time of Survey
Inactive
Member Active 47 (37%) 63 (49.6%)
Active
Inactive 0 2 (0.6%)
Disinterested Voter Active
Inactive 307 (91.1%) 244 (72.4%)
Party Militant
Inactive 0 1 (2.8%)
Interested Nonpartisan
Pre-OP Time of Survey
73 (16%) 79 (17.4%)
119 (26.2%) 0 0 106 (23.3%) 31 (9.2%) 29 (6.4%) n 792 (% of Active or Inactive delegates)
Betim
Pre-OP Time of Survey
Active
Inactive
Active 25 (19.7%) 37 (29.1%)
Inactive 0 1 (2.8%)
Disinterested Voter Active
Inactive
18 (14.2%) 0 0 36 (100%) 16 (12.6%) 2 (5.6%) 2 (1.6%) 21 (58.3%) n 163 (% of Active or Inactive delegates)
Candidate Militant Active 47 (10.3%) 56 (12.3%)
Inactive 0 12 (3.6%)
Party Sympathizer Active 192 (42.2%) 183 (40.2%)
Inactive 12 (3.6%) 38 (11.3%)
Disinterested Nonvoter Active 0 3 (0.7%)
Inactive 30 (8.9%) 20 (5.9%)
Candidate Militant Active 15 (11.8%) 17 (13.4%)
Party Sympathizer
Inactive
Active
0 2 (5.6%)
73 (57.5%) 64 (50.4%)
Disinterested Nonvoter Active
Inactive
0 0
0 0
Inactive 5 (13.9%) 14 (38.9%)
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
77
roughly one in five previously inactive BH delegates became more active in party politics, while the corresponding number in Betim was roughly double that at two out of five. In general, however, table 6.4 supports the results seen for civil society: the lion’s share of the hypothesized spillover effect from participation in the OP to participation in organized political society seems to have come primarily from individuals previously active in political society. This is the same group that is also the most likely to remain participating in the OP beyond the first year. At the same time, between 60 and 80 percent of the delegates who were inactive in political society prior to their involvement in the OP remained inactive in political society despite their OP activism. They are also the most likely not to participate in the OP beyond a single year. Once again, the data show only weak support for the argument of OP-inspired empowerment of previously disengaged citizens. The empowerment thesis implies that new arenas of popular participation such as the OP can engage historically excluded, ignored, and/or underserved nonelite sectors of the population thereby encouraging greater participation and pluralism in other arenas of democratic politics. That the OP in BH and Betim did not tend to attract or engage many previously disengaged citizens is clearly a challenge to this thesis.28 Instead, most OP delegates were already engaged civil and/or political society activists. These same pre-OP activists also accounted for a disproportionate share of the spillover effects of new participation in civil and political society, and they tended to participate longer in the OP, thereby gaining disproportionately from the democratic learning assumed to accrue to veteran participants. While these results challenge the empowerment thesis, they should not be interpreted as delegitimating the Participatory Democratic model. Popular participation is not exclusively about empowerment—it’s also about citizens’ oversight of government and the political class (accountability), and the pluralization of democratic participation and representation (i.e. active participants in a democracy should not all be wealthy men from similar socioeconomic and ethnic backgrounds). Finally, the fact that previously active delegates tended to become even more active during their OP experience should not be dismissed just because it does not conform precisely to the claims (and hopes) of the empowerment thesis. Even a passing knowledge of the literature on democratization and social movements suggests that sustaining popular political activism (e.g. citizen politics) is an important challenge to countries moving from a period of democratic transition to one of consolidation.29 The following citation refers to the Brazilian women’s
78
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
movement, but it could apply to other social movements as well: . . . the restoration of Brazilian democracy removed some of the motivation for unity among disparate wings of the women’s movement and presented them with new challenges. As middle-class women activists became more involved with political parties in the new democratic order, they tended to loose their contacts with community groups representing the urban poor. Indeed, in many Latin American nations the restoration of democracy had the ironic effect of demobilizing women.30 Brazilian political scientists, Sergio Azeredo and Leonardo Avritzer, make the general case that “neither those social movements built upon demands for public services and rights, nor the civic associations constructed during the last phase of the authoritarian period, were to be included in the specific organizational structures of the State that emerged from the process of [Brazil’s] redemocratization. On the contrary, what one saw was an expansion of the influence of clientelistic structures . . . and a growth of all of the vices proper to that form of relationship between State and society.”31 In this context of diminishing space for grassroots political activism in new democracies, the OP provides an important space for sustaining existing nonelite grassroots activism (or “social capital,” recalling the discussion of Putnam’s work from chapters two and three). Participation in the OP, in other words, could keep community-level activists from either trickling up (or being co-opted) into more “distant” and/or clientelistic arenas of party politics and public administration, or of “exiting” into political disillusionment, apathy, purely personal spaces and/or apolitical micro-communities. Constituting a meeting ground for territorially and thematically isolated popular sector activists, the OP could also be seen as providing them an opportunity to build and maintain horizontal solidarities and networks—to provide the heretofore missing bridge between citizens politics and the official world of party politics. Finally, and no less importantly, the OP offers existing activists an opportunity to learn how to compete and negotiate democratically for scarce public resources (who says existing political activists don’t need democratic schooling?).32 In the words of one OP and former Comforças delegate and longtime neighborhood activist from the neighborhood of Vila Santa Maria in BH: “The OP . . . allows us to identify the activists of other communities and to make contact with them. And the same for them, to make contact with us . . . All of this is done through the OP.”33 Regarding the democratic schooling of OP delegates, my own
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
79
conclusions are supported by Azeredo and Avritzer’s analysis of the 1994 OPs of both BH and Betim: . . . it seems clear that the Participatory Budget is innovative not only in its incorporation of broader segments of the population in the process of elaborating the budget. It is also, and principally, innovative in bringing part of the political culture of social interaction and of negotiation to forums where such practices were entirely absent up to that point.34 Neither does the OP constitute a case of some form of “participatory elitism” where the previously active are unfairly privileged vis-à-vis the disengaged.35 First, context is key. We are talking about previously active nonelites acting within a demonstrably elitist political system showing clear signs of even further elitization (i.e. the “democratic stagnation and decay” discussed in chapters one and two). We are not talking here about relatively wealthy and educated civic boosters and socialites crowding out the voices of the truly needy. Second, as I will argue in the next section of this chapter (along with proponents of the OP), promoting spaces for continued nonelite activism—and a modicum of empowerment of the previously inactive— contributes to a healthy “pluralization” or diversification of democratic representation. Even if participatory mechanisms of public administration and decision-making like the OP are not able to put an end to civic disengagement, establishing new arenas and instruments of nonelite activism can make it harder for antidemocratic elites to continue to undermine and debase existing traditional or official democratic institutions and processes. And in conjunction with an electorally viable political party dedicated to promoting and furthering nonelite interests (e.g. the PT, with its platform of “inverting priorities” and promoting popular participation), such participatory mechanisms can promote new democratic advances both in terms of enhanced representation and in terms of substantive gains in material well-being and political rights for nonelites, in general. Over the long run, this may even begin to have an impact on the problem of civic disengagement, as those who have “exited” from politics because of alienation and disillusionment with contemporary elitist democracy and/or for reasons of extreme poverty or discrimination, decide that it may be worth their while to reengage in a democracy more clearly “of the people, for the people, and by the people.” In short, Participatory Democracy needs to be seen not as an end in itself (i.e. as an alternative to representative democracy), but as a means for reforming and advancing systems of representative democracy that find themselves in a state of stagnation and decay.
80
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
To sum up this section of the chapter, the cases of BH and Betim suggest that, contrary to its proponents’ claims, the OP is a less-than-effective tool for engaging and empowering the disengaged. While no doubt a troubling finding for proponents of participatory democracy, it is by no means a damning one. In both cases, the OP appears to have been instrumental in maintaining and, in some cases, actually increasing existing supplies of social capital by keeping previously engaged nonelite activists participating in democratic politics—in civil society and in political society—at the municipal and grassroots levels. Democratic institutions are, therefore, peopled by a more diverse or demographically representative, as well as a better informed, socially conscious, and “democratically schooled” set of political activists than might otherwise be the case. ●
Pro-OP Claim #3: The OP constitutes another layer of political representation (participants represent the broader interests of their neighborhoods and regions, their organizations, and of people “like them”).
This claim can be broken down into three separate parts. First, the institutional design of the OP forces delegates to think and act in the collective interests of their neighborhood, region, and city. Delegates are elected to represent their communities, and they must negotiate with other elected delegates to pass a limited number of OP priority projects. Second, the OP gives its delegates a means to revitalize and renovate existing, oftentimes less-than-democratic, neighborhood organizations. Third, the “transparency” of the budget-making process under the OP injects greater accountability (therefore, representation) into the entire public administration. When I interviewed Gilberto Lisboa, president of the neighborhood association of Bairro Betim Industrial, a year after the neighborhood OP meeting in Betim described in chapter five, he talked about how elections to become OP delegates had, in some cases, created the need among aspirants to campaign and negotiate among themselves: There have been active disputes over the elections for OP delegates in a majority of Betim’s neighborhoods and regions. For example, in the Northern region there were three distinct slates of candidates. There were several slates in the Icaivari region too. Here, on the other hand, we had only a single slate in the last two elections. Prior to the elections, we called all the groups together to negotiate so we wouldn’t divide our neighborhood. The negotiations weren’t easy. Some said “If your candidate wins, we’ll launch our own slate.” But we still ended up with a single slate.36
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
81
Lisboa and others explain how these OP negotiations and campaigns teach participants that talking about “my” candidacy or project gets them nowhere; that victory can only come when speaking in collective terms of “our” slate or project and then acting accordingly. Delegates, in other words, are said to necessarily become representatives of collective interests (i.e. they learn to tie their individual interests to those of the larger community in which they live: Tocqueville’s “self interest properly understood”). If they won’t or can’t do so, they will fail for lack of the necessary support. The following illustration of the same idea comes from Rogério Pereira de Araújo, a then-unemployed third-time OP delegate from Bairro Nossa Señora dos Passos, BH: The first time we participated in the OP, through the efforts of a very capable companheiro, Leonel, along with Carlinhos and Ginesio, we were able to bring 200 people to the OP meeting. This was in 1996. Due to a lack of experience and because we didn’t know how the thing worked . . . we had a right to twenty delegates, but we only elected two along with two back-ups: me, Dona Luzia, Carlinhos, and Dona Elza— all were community representatives and are active today in the Health Council and in the new neighborhood association. So we participated and were, let’s say, destroyed, because the OP is a dispute among groups (uma disputa de grupos): there’s a certain amount of money for projects, and you have to organize your delegates and then go to the [regional] forum where those groups with the most people voting in a bloc have more political weight. We arrived with our two delegates, and came back with nothing. Due to my contacts in the labor union movement, I had more capacity to deal with people. Dona Elza, for lack of experience, didn’t even know how to negotiate. She and the other two ended up in the hands of our friends from the neighboring favela, Padre Lopes. They won’t say that, but that’s exactly what happened. They formed a group and managed to pass a project for Padre Lopes, a Health Post if I’m not mistaken. Padre Lopez had had a previous experience in organizing; every OP, they end up getting at least one thing passed. They’re a lot more organized than we are.37 Learning to become better organized can generate positive results, in the short term, in the form of passing priority projects for one’s neighborhood and, in the long term, in the form of building a core of unified representatives in the neighborhood for any number of social and political purposes. That’s certainly what happened in Rogério’s neighborhood of Nossa Senhora dos Passos in BH where OP delegates eventually joined together to form
82
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
a new neighborhood association (more on that experience below). Brazilian Sociologists, Mercês Somarriba and Otavio Dulci, examining the results of the BH third OP, concluded that this was not unusual amongst OP delegates with whom they spoke: “The experience constituted for them a lesson in political leadership, one that they evaluated very positively. They believe that the OP, in those three years, has been a learning experience, teaching to them and the population a new way of dealing with the problems of each community, changing as well their way of thinking about possible ways of solving such problems.”38 My field research in the neighborhood of Bairro Santa Maria, also in BH, gives us yet another example of OP-inspired education and training in neighborhood-level leadership and representation: Now in terms of the organization of the OP at the neighborhood level, this depends on each community’s interest, and on each group’s understanding of the OP idea. Here in Santa Maria we have a large number of groups involved in community affairs—in the local health center, the church, the daycare center—and each one ends up being an agent for passing on information about the OP to the rest of the people who live here. What are we going to approve? What’s the priority of the community? How are we going to build on this idea to pass our OP obra, being that the other neighborhoods within the micro region also have priorities and want obras from the same OP budget? What is a budget?’ And from there, the community that organizes itself and elects its delegates, they’re the ones that have the power of voice, the power to make decisions. That’s the logic. You can take a community that is weak and indicate one obra as their priority, but unfortunately there’s not money for everybody. So this is what we have to learn; we have to go through this learning process. We are constructing a strength of unity, a unified strength of various groups, to try to get the strength of votes inside the OP. . . . How do we do that? We do it with a lot of struggle, a lot of discussion; for example, this year, our high school here was a fundamental factor in spreading the word. And we who are activists, have to be alert to that: even if people don’t participate in groups, they could still be interested in certain topics that we activists are working for. Because we are asking for obras that are important for the whole community, and we can see that in the OP meetings. So we get close to such people and tell them that you’re going to be our delegate for our campaign [for the specific obra]. So this is how it works. Sr. João has responsibility for his sector, Dona. Antoninha and I have responsibility for health care, which we know about. And in the
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
83
case of Sandra, we came to her street and had a meeting there as part of a campaign to raise consciousness about why it’s important for people to participate in the meetings, and why participation is important to obtain the obra, and all of that. So we really follow up with these people, and they’re invited many times to the meetings. . . . Nothing better than to have someone from their own street tell them how we’re dealing about their community’s needs and problems.39 OP delegates’ organization of neighborhoods for the purposes of supporting neighborhood projects in the OP voting process was not unusual. According to Monica Maria de Jesús Carvalho, a five-year veteran OP administrator for the Northeastern region of BH, her Regional Administration office used to organize all OP-related neighborhood meetings. By the sixth year, however, “neighborhood OP delegates meet on their own, to mobilize voting blocs around specific proposed obras. This is a positive development. It means they are becoming self-sufficient. They only call us when they need technical information or something of the sort.”40 The following citation from field notes taken during a regional OP assembly in the Barreira region of BH illustrates how the design of the OP together with admonitions of OP administrators encourage OP delegates to think beyond their own needs and those of their own neighborhood to include those of the region as a whole: “A big part of [OP administrator] Luís Henrique’s job is convincing delegates that they’re more than representatives of their neighborhood. They’re representatives of their entire region. As such, they need to think about and vote on more than just ‘their’ obra. They get fourteen votes to choose among twenty-two to twenty-five possibilities. They need to choose with a sense of solidarity and responsibility.”41 When OP delegates travel as a group to visit the projects in their region that they will soon be voting on, many are visiting neighborhoods they’ve never seen before. They know that roughly half of those projects will not receive funding. They have the choice of casting their votes according to their conscience (which projects deserve their support based on their own perception of need) or according to the logic of tit-for-tat negotiations constantly put forth by proponents of any number of the projects (“I’ll vote for your’s if you vote for mine”). These are the same difficult choices that face any democratic representative. And while neighborhood priorities are likely to remain prominent in the minds of most OP delegates, they can’t help but be affected in some way by these processes of learning about the larger region in which their neighborhood is situated and by the numerous face-to-face meetings and negotiations with other OP delegates. Such meetings and negotiations can
84
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
help forge horizontal bonds of solidarity across otherwise isolated neighborhoods with similar needs and interests. Constructing and articulating collective interests and representing those interests in OP forums as neighborhood-level and even regional-level political leaders, OP delegates often find themselves treading on the turf of already existing supposedly representative neighborhood associations. I say “supposedly representative” because Brazil’s neighborhood associations are notorious for being the neighborhood-level extensions of clientelist political machines, directed and controlled from above by political bosses and from within by a neighborhood boss or a small group of loyalists, and usually active only in periods preceding elections.42 Once again, Geraldo Lisboa of Bairro Betim Industrial in Betim offers us an illustrative example: “We’ve had a neighborhood association in Bairro Betim Industrial since 1982. It basically functioned to distribute tickets for free milk, free food baskets, that sort of thing. It was openly tied to a particular city council member who was clearly the ‘owner of the association.’ During the first four years, there was never a public meeting and its officers were never elected.”43 That neighborhood-level collective action and clientelism do not necessarily go together, however, is emphasized, for example, in the work of Robert Gay on Rio de Janeiro favela organizations, and of Rebecca Abers on the OP-induced renovation of neighborhood organizations in Porto Alegre.44 By introducing real means of neighborhood-level representation (i.e. with annual elections for delegates and open, democratically run meetings) and producing real results in the form of needed public works projects, the OP is said to directly challenge the false representation of traditional clientelistic associations. Adonis Pereira, Regional Administrator for the Northern Region of BH, described how the OP had stimulated democratic changes in many of his region’s neighborhood associations: “The OP has changed the way neighborhood associations perceive their role. . . . People participate in the OP to benefit the entire community and they work to get the neighborhood association to do the same. Many exist that are still of the traditional type. But many more have been renovated, with new active members and a new leadership.”45 In repeated visits to neighborhoods in BH and Betim that had actively participated in the OP, I observed such processes of renovation and contestation between mobilized OP delegates and long-time leaders of the more traditional neighborhood associations. We need to remember that although previously inactive OP delegates in BH and Betim tended to remain inactive outside of their all-too-brief foray into participatory decision-making, that was much less the case when it came to participating in neighborhood associations. The implication here—echoing a similar conclusion by Abers from
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
85
her analysis of the Porto Alegre case—is that well-designed institutional innovations providing meaningful opportunities for politically active nonelites to participate at the level of the neighborhoods in which they live can be effective in transforming former instruments of neighborhood-level clientelism and citizen demobilization into instruments of grassroots participation and representation.46 The following are several examples from my field research in BH: Adelia Mendes—Bairro Nossa Senhora dos Passos, Belo Horizonte: Water and sidewalks were brought into the neighborhood under the Administration of Mauricio Campos [during the 1964–1985 dictatorship], but only in our street [the central “artery” of the neighborhood]. Another mayor, Sérgio Ferrara, finished the sidewalks, but purely in exchange for votes. . . . The neighborhood association existed and still exists, with official documentation and everything. However, their leadership is not interested in the OP. It doesn’t participate in anything. That association only exists in one part of the Vila, and we’re excluded because we don’t live there. Once they even got a lot of money to do things in their part of the Vila. What did they do? They did things for their own use and benefit. A lot of their people built new houses, bought houses in other neighborhoods, that sort of thing. They used the money for themselves. We had no part of that. Our intention is to fight for the interests of the entire Vila, not for ourselves. So what do we do? Everyone knows about the other association, including the city, which now goes directly to Rogério [“veteran” OP delegate quoted earlier]. Why? Because the others don’t show up for anything. Why would they work with a bankrupt association? Many, many years ago, that association had a school, an office building, land, and everything. All of that is gone. And they don’t care anymore because they know that the money won’t be coming through them. Because in the OP, the money doesn’t go through individuals. This is what I found to be very interesting about the OP. We delegates hear about and go visit the various proposed projects, then we vote and the city constructs the prioritized projects while we watch to make sure it’s done correctly. No one person distributes the money because if they did, it would disappear, like it did it the case of the old association. Our plan now is to take over the old association by calling for an election for a new leadership, which is allowed under the association’s statutes. . . . There are only eight of us. I know that we’ll need more, but this group is very unified and works well together. All of us are active OP
●
86
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
delegates. We meet and discuss things, but not in any regularized fashion outside of the OP. Currently, however, several of us are enrolled in a class at the Regional Administration learning to be “Gestores Comunitários” [Community Activists]. We’re learning a lot, like how to deal with the community, how to speak in front of large groups, how to understand the city budget and how public works projects move through their implementation phases. . . . We’re new at this, but we are learning. 47 ● Djalma and José Estacio da Silva—Bairro Tupi Alto Mirante, Belo Horizonte: We don’t have a neighborhood association of our own, not yet anyway. There’s a guy here with an association in another part of the neighborhood. He’s been the president forever. He does nothing. In fact, he’s worthless.48 I became active in the OP in order to try to better this neighborhood. A neighboring bairro had been improved through the OP: a sewer system, asphalt, a new bus line. I saw this. Djalma and Geraldo were already active in the OP. They had a neighborhood meeting three or four years ago and said that the neighboring bairro had been improved through the OP, and that we needed to get together and make it work for us too. Eventually, the bus came here too due to an OP project that paved the main streets of the neighborhood. At that point, I decided to participate. Djalma and Geraldo . . . called me in the beginning of 1998. . . . Several of us decided to go as a group and check the thing out. Could we believe in it, or was it just politics? Many said it was more politics than results. . . . We looked for the most interested, but many decided not to go. . . . The mobilization was due primarily to Djalma and Geraldo and, before that, to José Antonio. Djalma went house to house, Geraldo got a bus to take people to the meeting—which is very important because for every ten people that show up, you get to elect a delegate to the Regional Assembly. We got 100 people to come to that meeting. . . . These 100 people remain in contact with us. They tell us what they want for the neighborhood, that sort of thing. We’re the ones who actually participate the most. But they always ask us: “Did our priorities get approved?”, “When does construction begin?” . . . They’re always asking, “When is the next meeting?”49 ● Maria José Pereira Ramos and Adeja Anira dos Santos Rodrigues— Vila São Francisco, Belo Horizonte: The old neighborhood association is dead. But a network of contacts still exists. Once the association participated, but not anymore. They won
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
87
an obra in the first OP, then sat back and complained that the Regional Administration wasn’t implementing the obra. No one followed up.50 I think the Association doesn’t work anymore because it doesn’t have the participation of the residents. No one helps. . . . For example, there’s supposed to be an election every four years. [The president] invited everyone to participate, but nobody believes he has any power. But he elected himself again. Not necessarily because he wanted to, but because nobody showed up to vote. . . . He’s illiterate, but he’s a good person with good sense. But he’s also got a bad side. He talks like this: “I’m the president of the neighborhood association, and if it’s not me making the decision, then nothing has been decided.” Pretty nasty, huh? Now, people show him letters and things, and he doesn’t know what they mean. He keeps the letters, says he’ll do something about them, then does nothing because he doesn’t know what they say. He knows how to talk, how to play a good host, and that’s about it. But everybody runs to him with complaints and demands. Even if a toilet stops up, they run to him. But what good is that? He may try to help out, but he’s only one person. And he has a full-time job. A neighborhood association has to be a group of residents participating. It’s not the president’s role to solve everything personally. He, himself, agrees with that. He says he doesn’t have time to solve all the problems of the favela; he’s got to solve his own problems first. Our concern is to prepare residents so that they can assume that group role.51 The association is already devalued in the eyes of residents. To bring it back up would require a lot of work. People know Alderico is president, but not much else. And the association is very divided among the group that supposedly supports Alderico. They fight amongst themselves all the time over little things. . . . I’m participating in the OP because I saw that things weren’t going forward. Someone stopped in the middle of the road. So I’m going to keep going until the end. No one’s going to trip me up. . . . Somebody’s got to do something. I believe that if I, and if she, and others want to do something, and we have enough free time to follow up, I think we can get the obras that we want. There’s a 100% chance that we can get them. What that means for our Vila is that either we remove those people living in dangerous areas, or we fix the place up. And as long as I don’t see that happening, I’m going to keep working to make it happen.52 At the last OP meeting, I was convinced that our obra wouldn’t pass. There weren’t very many people from the Vila there. But we negotiated and it did pass. And when we came back home, people looked at us differently: with a certain amount of respect. Some that participated earlier
88
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
without getting what they wanted—including the president of the old neighborhood association—say that it’s all a waste of time, a stupidity (“babaquice”). They simply stopped going to the meetings. But we OP delegates also had support from the local newsletter and from the local priest. That generated more respect for us too. But now we have to show them that the obra will actually be completed. That’s what people are waiting to see. The president of the neighborhood association seems to be ambiguous about our success. On the one hand, he’s happy to see that the obra passed. But he’s also worried about losing influence.53 In addition to OP delegates themselves, on-the-ground administrators of the OP were the most likely to voice the argument that the OP enhances democratic representation by challenging the traditional clientelistic structures normally present at the neighborhood level. These were the administrators who regularly attended the neighborhood and regional meetings, and who saw the struggles actually taking place. In both BH and Betim, many of them voiced a complaint that top administration officials and party leaders seemed not to recognize the importance of this outcome of the OP and, therefore, did not sufficiently support OP delegates in their neighborhoodlevel struggles against clientelism. As mentioned in chapter five, for example, according to one of his closest aides, Betim’s Mayor Lima did not recognize the impact that OP delegates were having in transforming or, at least, challenging many of Betim’s older neighborhood associations (many openly created and supported by individual city council members to solidify their redutos eleitorais) until I presented the results of my survey to his cabinet at the close of Betim’s sixth OP process. In Belo Horizonte, OP administrator, Luís Henrique, made a comparable observation: “The Administration has not carried out its role in following up OP meetings and processes with a concentrated effort to turn delegates into representatives of neighborhood associations and organizations. The Comforças representatives should be the targets of such action, but it’s not done. It’s our biggest challenge. But the [OP] team is just too small.”54 Thus, we may have a paradox: while many OP delegates and administrators close to the day-to-day operations of the OP process recognize a new OP-induced vibrancy in neighborhood-level politics (a “pluralization” of political activism), top administration and party officials seem strangely unaware that this new vibrancy represents precisely the sort of civic engagement the OP is supposed to generate. Taking place at the neighborhood level, one might hypothesize that such activism operates below the proverbial radar screens of political leaders more concerned with “important” political dynamics at the municipal, state, and national levels.
Proponents of the Participatory Budget
●
89
In the end, however, even where ignored by top administration and party officials, the evidence seems strong that the OP enhances political representation by opening up neighborhood-level spaces to pluralistic contestation and participation. The third and final way in which the OP is said to enhance political representation comes about through the “transparency” of the OP process itself. Putting information about city finances and operations directly in the hands of citizens makes the formal institutions of public administration and political representation more accountable, responsible, and therefore, more representative.55 Edinaldo Daniel, coordinator of the Association of Residents of Nova Bade, Vila Inconfidência, and Almarante in Betim, tells the following illustrative story: In the past, our neighborhood was ignored by the mayor’s office. When they did come here, they would always say the same thing: “There’s no money”. And there was no way to know if there was money or not. Now things are much more transparent and people can know. Like we now know about the amount of money that city council members control, and it’s shameful. They can’t play that game with us anymore and have it go unnoticed. Information is power.56 Indeed, the active role played by Betim’s and BH CMOPs—and the Comforças groups in each of BH’s nine regional administrations—and by regular OP delegates in the fierce struggles between the administration and the city council (as described in chapter four) constitutes the strongest illustration of the OP functioning as a means of injecting greater accountability into local government. According to Otílie Macedo Pinheiro, Technical Advisor to Betim’s Secretariat of Planning and Coordination, the accountability-inducing and corruption-reducing transparency of the OP was the main reason why the UN’s Habitat II Conference in 1996 chose the OPs of Porto Alegre and Betim as among the world’s most exemplary models of public administration.57 Conclusion We can now sum up the findings of this investigation into the major claims of the OP’s proponents as illustrated by our two case studies. First, the OPs in Betim and BH are clear examples of “popular participation,” just as their proponents claim. Women are much better represented among active OP delegates, for example, compared to more formal representative political
90
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
institutions. Similarly, the clear majority of OP delegates in both cities had less than a high school education; and they were either salaried workers, housewives, retired, or unemployed. These characteristics of active OP delegates in Betim and BH are quite remarkable in light of Brazil’s elitist political regime, political culture, and social structures. They show us that, while many nonelite Brazilians are disengaged from the political world, a significant number are willing to involve themselves in participatory processes of local-level governance if given the opportunity to do so. Second, the OPs in Betim and BH do not provide much support for proponents’ claims that such participatory processes engage and empower large numbers of previously disengaged or alienated citizens (the “empowerment thesis”). It turns out that most OP delegates were already engaged in civil and/or political society activists. These same pre-OP activists also accounted for a disproportionate share of the spillover effects of new participation in civil and political society; and they tended to participate longer in the OP, thereby gaining disproportionately from the democratic learning assumed to accrue to veteran participants. While it may not have been a great tool for empowering the disengaged (at least not in these two cases), the OP was arguably quite useful in maintaining and, in some cases, actually increasing existing supplies of social capital by keeping previously engaged activists participating in democratic politics—in civil society and in political society—at the municipal and grassroots levels. Finally, in assessing the general claim that the OP enhances local-level democratic representation, we find three specific arguments to substantiate that claim. First, the open election of OP delegates and their subsequent need to negotiate among themselves for collective benefits constitute an entirely new layer of democratic representation and activity. Second, OP delegates directly challenge the antidemocratic clientelistic distribution of public services and goods traditionally associated with neighborhood associations and other local-level organizations. Third, the OP’s open distribution of information about the finances and operations of municipal government promotes greater accountability, responsibility, and ultimately, better representation within the executive and legislative branches of local government. In sum, OP-induced political participation does substantially appeal to and include nonelite citizens. And while OP processes do not appear to empower many of the politically disengaged and alienated, they do appear to offer substantive opportunities to existing nonelite activists to continue their political participation beyond the heady days of democratic transition into the more mundane and otherwise increasingly elitist and distant game of democratic consolidation. The overall result: the “pluralization of democratic activism” and, therefore, the “democratization of democracy.”
CHAPTER 7
Examining the Claims of Critics of the Participatory Budget
C
hapter five introduced us to some of the OP’s most fervent critics: opposition members of Betim’s city council. It would be easy to dismiss much of what they had to say on the subject as mere partisan diatribes on the part of traditional clientelistic politicians out to discredit an innovative democratic process that challenges their here-to-fore unquestioned capacity to administer public goods as if they were their own private property (i.e. the very definition of patrimonialism). However, since we took the claims of Orçamento Participativo (OP) proponents seriously in chapter six and subjected them to critical analysis, it behooves us to do the same with the arguments of the OP’s critics. In this chapter, then, I will present four major critiques of the OP that emerged again and again in conversations with opponents of the process in both Belo Horizonte (BH) and Betim. I will then present the counter arguments of OP proponents, generally administrators and officials affiliated with the Workers’ Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores). Finally, for each debate, I will make use of my own observations, the data from my quantitative and qualitative analyses of the OPs of BH and Betim, and relevant data from comparable cases (e.g. Porto Alegre) to hazard some conclusions about the conflicting claims. ●
Anti-OP Criticism #1: The OP is unnecessarily antagonistic to the legislative body (e.g. city council) and to existing representative organizations in civil society.
City council members in Betim describe their function primarily as one of representing the citizenry and monitoring the activities of the administration.1
92
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
Those who oppose the OP oftentimes see it as reproducing, and therefore unnecessarily impinging upon, these very functions. Similarly, they argue, popular participation already exists in the many neighborhood associations dotted throughout the city. At a minimum, they ask, why put in place something that already exists and functions well? Betim city council member, Paulo Mundim, exemplifies this argument: . . . yes, we must have popular participation. But it should be done with the existing established representatives of communities—the neighborhood associations—with city council members present at all stages. The majority of council members have regions in the city where their electoral support is very strong (redutos eleitorais). They should be recognized as the proper representative of these areas. . . . As a council member, I am in constant contact with neighborhood leaders, businessmen, liberal professionals and even with common citizens who aren’t interested in politics but who sometimes want to express their opinions.2 Anti-OP council members argue that even worse than this unnecessary duplication of functions is the fact that the council members themselves and their constitutionally founded offices are constantly denigrated and discredited by OP administrators before the population. Obviously, they do not see themselves as the enemy. On the contrary, they are the constitutionally endowed, democratically elected legislative representatives of the municipality and its citizens. Having attended a large number of OP meetings in Betim, BH, and elsewhere, I can attest to the fact that city council members are regularly singled out by OP administrators and other administration officials, less by name than by office, as some of the worst abusers of the formal instruments of democracy for personal political and economic gain. My experience, especially in Betim (see chapter five), as well as volumes of case studies of clientelism in Brazil and Latin America, demonstrate that city council members (members of legislative bodies in general) deserve to be singled out, because they have regularly used their offices in ways that abuse the public trust.3 The same is true, as we discussed in chapter six, of many of the neighborhood associations preexisting the OP: most represent the political interests of their “sponsors” (patrões) on the city council or, at best, of the leaders of the associations themselves, far more than the residents of the neighborhoods in which they are located. In other words, most of the existing institutions do not “function well,” at least not with respect to representing the citizenry (neither, for that matter, do they do a very good job in efficiently and effectively administering the public good).
Critics of the Participatory Budget
●
93
Proponents of the OP make no apologies for the fact that the OP directly challenges the ability of city council members and traditional neighborhood associations to be the exclusive “representatives” of specific neighborhoods and regions. They argue that city council members and their hand-picked or self-selected neighborhood “leaders” have traditionally constructed clientelistic political machines through the targeted distribution of rewards (e.g. public works projects, jobs in the public administration, etc.) in return for electoral support, and punishments (e.g. no public works projects, loss of jobs, etc.) in retaliation for electoral opposition or weak electoral support. These machines have served to disempower and to demobilize the popular sectors over the years as the latter find their avenues of legitimate representation always subordinate to the interests of one or another temporarily dominant elitist political machine and subject to the punishments of the losing machine.4 At best, clientelistic intra-elite competition provides limited access to what should be universally accessible public goods and services as “rewards” for extending support to one machine against another. At worst, the rewards are only promised at election time but are never actually delivered. At any rate, when residents of a neighborhood feel beholden to a given politician for the rewards he or she bestows upon them, collectively or individually, they are less likely to hold that politician accountable for such things as ethical behavior in office (“She may be a thief, but at least she shares some of the spoils with me”), and they are less likely to collectively mobilize on behalf of anything, including an opposition candidate, that the politician doesn’t approve of. (“We really need paved streets in our neighborhood, but council member X says I better not push for it or I may lose the other things he says he’s going to give me.”) Thus, as argued in chapter six, the OP is explicitly constructed to be an extra instrument to impose accountability on both the city council and traditional neighborhood associations, and even on the administration itself. In effect, the OP acts as an extra check and balance on these more established institutions.5 In a context of rampant clientelism, to call such an extra check and balance “unnecessary” is to stand in favor of the essentially inegalitarian and antidemocratic status quo described throughout this book. Whatever political conflict that may ensue with established institutions should be seen as the result of enhanced opportunities for nonelite organization and representation. Collectivities of nonelite citizens organizing outside of, and against, long-existing elitist institutions should be seen as healthy for the process of democracy (and only hurtful for those who stand to lose their traditional clientelistic privileges, or for the “ungovernability” theories of their academic apologists).
94
●
Participatory versus Elitist Democracy: Brazil
But is this extra check and balance constitutional? Does it, as some of its detractors argue, illegally usurp the political-administrative function constitutionally reserved for the formal legislative body, in this case, the city council.6 First and foremost, the use of citizens’ councils to both participate in and to monitor the administration of government programs was firmly established in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution.7 We have also seen that OP processes take place within the deliberative and implementation phases of the Executive’s budgetary process (i.e. during preparation of the Executive’s draft of the annual budget submitted to the Legislature, and in overseeing the actual implementation of approved projects). This puts it fully within the powers of the Executive to organize and administer. It is, in other words, a choice of the Executive whether to construct and implement his/her administration’s budget proposal using instruments of popular participation such as the OP, or whether to construct and implement it haphazardly, behind “closed doors” in “smoke-filled rooms” and/or from the formulas of technically trained experts.8 City council members are free to object to specifics or to the entirety of the Administration’s OP-induced budget proposals and subsequent implementation processes; this right has not been, and cannot be, taken away from them by the OP. They do so, however, at the risk of alienating and angering constituents who have been active in the construction of the Administration’s budget proposal or, if not active participants, may still see substantial benefits for themselves and their communities in the proposal. Ultimately, council members’ decisions to contest the administration OP-induced budget is a political decision, not a legal or constitutional one. Such a decision must always involve a political cost/benefit calculus that takes into consideration such factors as the number of PT or PT-allied council members in the Council itself, the degree and intensity of organization and mobilization of OP delegates during the process of the Council’s deliberation of the budget, and the relative capacities of the Administration and the Council to present their side of the story to the larger electorate (the latter having a great deal to do with the attitudes of local media vis-à-vis the Administration). Again, none of this contradicts the logic or the rules of democracy. ●
Anti-OP Criticism #2: The great majority of citizens never participate in the OP, and among those few that do, the subsequent drop-off in their participation is evidence that so-called popular participation is actually not all that popular at all
The first component of this critique—that few people really participate in the OP—is represented by the following complaint from Romulo Veneroso,
Critics of the Participatory Budget
●
95
another of Betim’s opposition city council members: “In my neighborhood, we have about 4,000 residents. Yet we were ‘represented’ by only twenty delegates in this year’s OP [1996].”9 Assuming that Veneroso’s figures are correct, the 20 delegates in his neighborhood represented 200 participants at the neighborhood meeting, or 5 percent of the neighborhood’s total population. When officially registered rates of citywide OP participation are set alongside the size of their respective cities’ total population, Veneroso’s observation for his neighborhood is broadly true for both Betim and BH. Even the relatively high number of 20,000 participants in Betim’s third OP (1995) amounted to only 7–8 percent of the city’s total population at that time. The 38,508 participants in the fourth year of BH’s OP (1997) amounted to only 1.8 percent of the city’s total population of 2,100,000. And the 10,735 participants in the fifth year of OP discussions (1993) in the much celebrated case of Porto Alegre represented less than 1 percent (0.77) of the city’s 1,400,000 residents.10 These percentages represent far less, some detractors have pointed out, than the percentage of citizens