PROGRESS
IN
Nucleic Acid Research and Molecular Biology Volume 47
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PROGRESS IN
...
28 downloads
1164 Views
14MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
PROGRESS
IN
Nucleic Acid Research and Molecular Biology Volume 47
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PROGRESS IN
Nucleic Acid Research and Molecular Biology edited by
WALDO E. COHN Biology Division
KlVlE MOLDAVE Department of Biology
Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge, Tennessee
University of California Santa Crrrz, California
Volume 47
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. Harcourt Brace ]manmich, Publishers Son Diego New York Boston London Sydney Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper. @ Copyright 0 1991 BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means. electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Academic Press, Inc. San Diego, California 92101 United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24-28 Oval Road, London NWl 7DX
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number:
ISBN 0-12-540041-1 (alk. paper)
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 91
92 93 94
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 I
63- 15847
Contents
ABBREVIATIONS AND SYMBOLS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix
SOME ARTICLES PLANNED FOR FUTUREVOLUMES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xi
Molecular Structure and Transcriptional Regulation of the Salivary Gland Proline-Rich Protein Multigene Families. . . . . 1 D o n M. Carlson, Jie Zhou and Paul S. Wright
I. 11. 111.
IV. V. VI.
Background .......................... PRP mRNAs 11-free Translation Analysis . . PRP cDNAs and Amino-acid Sequences . . . . . . . . . Sequence and Structural Analyses of PRP Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Regulation of Expression of PRP Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Functional Aspects of PRPs ................
...............................
3 6 9 10 16
18 20 21
Recognition of tRNAs by Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases . . . . .23 LaDonne H. Schulman I. Recognition versus Identity . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Assays of the Amino-acid-acceptor Specificity of 111. Role of the Anticodon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Role of the Acceptor Stem and the “Discriminat at Position 73 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............... V. Other Recognition Profiles VI . Role of Modified Bases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . The Complex of E. coli Glutamine tRNA and Glut VIII. tRNA Binding Domains of Other Synthetases . . . ...................... IX . Concluding Remarks References ...........................
Ribosome Biogenesis in Yeast.
24 25 29
44 58 64 66 72 81 82
. . . . 89
H. A. Rau6 and R. J. Planta I. Transcription of Ribosomal-RNA Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Expression of Ribosomal-protein Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V
91 103
CONTENTS
vi
111.
Processing and Assembly of Ribosomal Constituents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Structural Elements in RNA
111 124
. . . . . 131
Michael Chastain and Ignacio Tinoco. Jr. I . Secondary Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
132
111. Tertiary Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Predicting Tertiary Interactions . . . . V. Three-dimensional Structure . . . . . . VI . Determining RNA Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Protein-RNA Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............... VIII . RNA-RNA Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . RNA-DNA Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
150
I1 . Predicting Secondary Structure . .
161 167 169 170 171
Nuclear RNA-binding Proteins . . . . . 179 Jack D . Keene and Charles C . Query
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 180
.
RRM Family of Proteins
.......
. . . . . . . 202
Amplification of DNA Sequences in Mammalian Cells . . . . . 203 Joyce L . Hamlin. Tzeng-Horng Leu. James P. Vaughn. Chi Ma and Pieter A . Dijkwel I . Historical Development of the Amplification Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Occurrence of Amplified DNA Sequences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Properties of Amplified DNA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Possible Mechanisms and Ways to Discriminate among Them . . . . . . V. Usefulness of Cell Lines Bearing Amplified Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Conclusions and Future Directions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
205 206 207 218 228 232 232
CONTENTS
vii
Molecular-Biology Approaches to Genetic Defects of the Mammalian Nervous System . . . . . 241 J. Gregor Sutcliffe and Gabriel H. Travis I.
Neural Mutants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. The rds Gene . . . . . . . . . . 111. Secretogranin 111 . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IV. V. VI.
Making Mutants . . . . . . . . Getting All of the Genes Reprise . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Lens Proteins and Their Genes.
257
. . . .259
Hans Bloemendal and Wilfried W. de Jong I. The Lens and Its Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. The Lens and Its DNA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
References
..................................................
INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
259 269 277 277
283
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Abbreviations and Symbols All contributors to this Series are asked to use the terminology (abbreviations and symbols) recommended by the IUPAC-IUB Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature (CBN) and approved by IUPAC and IUB, and the Editors endeavor to assure conformity. These Recommendations have been published in many journals (I. 2) and compendia (3)and are available in reprint form from the Office of Biochemical Nomenclature (OBN); they are therefore considered to be generally known. Those used in nucleic acid work, originally set out in section 5 of the first Recommendations (I)and subsequently revised and expanded (2.3),are given in condensed form in the frontmatter of Volumes 9-33 of this series. A recent expansion of the one-letter system ( 5 ) follows. SINGLE-LETTER CODE Symbol
RECOMMENDATIONS.
Meaning
(5)
Origin of symbol Guanosine Adenosine (ribo)Thymidine (Uridine) Cytidine
R
G or A
Y
T(U) or C A or C G or T(U) G or C A or T(U)
M
K S W‘ H B
puRine pyrimidine aMino Keto Strong interaction (3 H-bonds) Weak interaction (2 H-bonds)
or C or T(U)
not not not not
G; H follows G in the alphabet A; B follows A T (not U); V follows U C; D follows C
D
A G G G
N
G or A or T(U) or C
aNy nucleoside (i.e., unspecified)
Q
Q
Queuosine (nucleoside of queuine)
V
or T(U) or C or C or A or A or T(U)
‘Modified from Proc. Natl. Acad. Ski. US.A. 83, 4 (1986). *W has been used for wyosine, the nucleoside of “base Y” (wye). ‘D has been used for dihydrouridine (hU or H, Urd). Enzymes
In naming enzymes, the 1984 recommendations of the IUB Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature ( 4 ) are followed as far as possible. At first mention, each enzyme is described either by its systematic name or by the equation for the reaction catalyzed or by the recommended trivial name, followed by its EC number in parentheses. Thereafter, a trivial name may be used. Enzyme names are not to be abbreviated except when the substrate has an approved abbreviation (e.g.. ATPase, but not LDH, is acceptable).
ix
ABBREVIATIONS AND SYMBOLS
X
REFERENCES 1. JBC241,527 (1966); &hem 5,1445 (1966); MlO1, I (1966); ABB 115. I (I%), 129,l (1%9); and e1smhere.t General. 2. EJB I S , 203 (1970); JBC 245, 5171 (1970);JMB 55, 299 (1971); and e1sewhere.t 3. “Handbook of Biochemistry” (G. Fasman, ed.), 3rd ed. Chemical Rubber Co., Cleveland. Ohio, 1970, 1975, Nucleic Acids, Vols. I and 11, pp. 3-59. Nucleic acids. 4. “Enzyme Nomenclature” [Recommendations (1984) of the Nomenclature Committee of the IUB]. Academic Press, New York, 1984. 5. /LIB 150, I (1985). Nucleic Acids (One-letter system).t Abbreviations of Journal Titles
Journals
Abbreviations used
Annu. Rev. Biochem. Annu. Rev. Genet. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. Biochemistry Biochem. J. Biochim. Biophys. Acta Cold Spring Harbor Cold Spring Harbor Lab Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. Eur. J. Biochem. Fed. Proc. Hoppe-Scyler’s Z. Physiol. Chem. J. Amer. Chem. Soc J. Bactcriol. J. Biol. Chem. J. Chem. Soc. J. Mol. Biol. J. Nat. Cancer Inst. Mol. Cell. Biol. Mol. Cell. Biochem. Mol. Gen. Genet. Nature, New Biology Nucleic Acid Research Proc Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. Proc SOc Exp. Biol. Mcd. Progr. Nucl. Acid. Res. Mol. Bid.
ARB ARGen ABB BBRC Bchem BJ BBA CSH CSHLab CSHSQB EJB FP ZpChem JACS J. Bact. JBC JCS JMB JNCl MCBiol MCBchem MGG
Nature NB NARes PNAS PSEBM This Series
tbprints available from the Office of Biochemical Nomenclature (W. E. Cohn, Director).
Some Articles Planned for Future Volumes
Phosphotransfer Reactions of Plant Virus Satellite RNAs
GEORGEBRUENING Positive and Negative Regulation of Gene Expression by Steroid Agonists and Antagonists ANDREW B. CATO, H. PONTA AND P. HERRLICH
c.
Regulation of Gene Expression in Trypanosomes
CHRISTINE CLAYTON Oligonucleotides as Antisense Inhibitors of Gene Expression JACK
s. COHEN AND M.
GHOSH
The DNA Binding Domain of the Zn(ll)-containing Transcription Factors JOSEPH
E. COLMAN AND T.
PAN
Specific Hormonal and Neoplastic Transcriptional Control of the Alpha 2u Globulin Gene Family
PHILIPFEIGELSON Cellular Transcriptional Factors Involved in the Regulation of HIV Gene Expression
RICHARDGAYNORAND C. MUCHARDT Correlation between tRNA Structure and Efficient Aminoocylation
RICHARD GIEGE, C. FLORENTZ AND J. PUGLISI snRNA Genes: Tronscription by RNA Polymerase II and RNA Polymerase 111
NOURIAHERNANDEZ AND S. LOBO Regulation of mRNA Stability in Yeast ALLAN JACOBSON Recombination Enzymes from E. coli and S. cerevisiae
RICHARD KOLODNER Cell Delivery and Mechanisms of Action of Antisense Oligonucleotides
BERNARDLEBLEU,J. P. LEONETTIAND G . DEGLSO Signal-tronsducing G Proteins: Basic and Clinical Implications
MICHAEL A. LEVINE xi
SOME ARTICLES PLANNED FOR FUTURE VOLUMES
xii Synthesis of Ribosomes
LASE LINDAHL AND J. M . ZENCEL Enzymes of DNA Repair
STUARTLINN RNA Replication of Plant Viruses Comprising an RNA Genome
ANNE-LISEHAENNI, R. GARCOURI-BOUZIDAND C. DAVID Nitrogen Regulation in Bacteria and Yeast
BORIS MACASANIK Alkylation Damage Repair Genes: Molecular Cloning and Regulation of Expression SANKAR MITRA An Analysis of lntron Splicing in Monocot Plants RALPH SINIBALDIAND I. METTLER trp Repressor, A Ligand-activated Regulatory Protein
RONALDL. SOMMERVILLE lmmunochemical Analyses of Nucleic Acids
DAVIDSTOLLAR The Structure and Expressions of the Insulin-like Growth-factor Gene LYDIAVILLA-KOMAROFF AND K. M. ROSEN
Molecular Structure and Transcriptional Regulation of the Salivary Gland Proline-Rich Protein M uItigene FamiIies DON M. CARL SON,^ ZHOU~ AND PAUL S. WRIGHT~ JIE
Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics University of California-Davis Davis, California 95616
I. Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. PRP mRNAs and Cell-free Translation Analysis ........ 111. PRP cDNAs and Amino-acid Sequences ............................ IV. Sequence and Structural Analyses of PRP Genes V. Regulation of Expression of PRP Genes ............................ VI. Functional Aspects of PRPs .........
16 18
...........
21
3 6 9
The proline-rich proteins (PRPs) in mammalian salivary glands are encoded by tissue-specific multigene families whose members have diverged with respect to structure and regulation of expression. A common evolutionary origin of the P R P genes is evident from the extensive conservation of 5’untranslated regions, coding sequences, and intronlexon organizations. The 42-nucleotide repeat unit CCA CCA CCA CCA GGA GGC CCA CAG CCG AGA CCC CCT CAA GGC has been proposed (1) as the ancestral unit, multiples of three bases probably being recruited into, or deleted from, this ancestral sequence during gene duplication. Gene conversion possibly was the mechanism of homogenization of the divergence of the internal repeats. Two nonallelic mouse P R P genes ( M P 2 and M 1 4 ) have essentially identical sequences, with two major differences (2). M P 2 has 13tandemly arranged 42-nucleotide repeats, whereas M 1 4 has 17 repeats. M 1 4 has an insertion by transposition of a two-kilobase member of the long, interspersed elements of repeated mouse DNA (LINE family) into intron I. The 5’-untranslated se-
* To whom correspondence may be addressed. Present address: Neurological Sciences Institute, Good Samaritan Hospital and Medical Center, Portland, Oregon 97209. Present address: Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals. Inc., Cincinnati, Ohio 45215. 2
1 Progress i i i Nucleic Acid Hrearch and Moleciilar Biology, Vnl. 41
Copyright 8 1991 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
2
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
quences and regions encoding the signal peptides of all PRP mRNAs, regardless of source, are nearly identical. In another multigene family from rat submandibular glands that encodes contiguous repeat proteins (CRPs) or glutamic acid/glutamine-rich proteins (Glx-rich proteins), the 5'-untranslated sequences and the regions encoding the signal peptides of the mRNAs are 91% identical (nucleotides) and 92% identical (amino acids) to the PRP mRNAs (3, 4). Two mRNA size-classes, each containing multiple PRP mRNAs, are transcripts from PRP gene families of mice (5), hamsters (6),rats (i'),and humans (8).The CRP or Glx-rich multigene family also encodes two size-classes of mRNAs, and this multigene family has the same introdexon organization as the mouse and rat PRP genes. Cell-free translations show some unusual differences in PRPs encoded by mRNAs from parotid glands of four mouse strains (BALB/cJ, DBA/2J, CD-1, and C57BL/6J) after isoproterenol treatment (5).Reasons for the variations of translation products in these mouse strains after induction of the PRP gene families are unknown. Repeated administration of the P-agonist isoproterenol causes hypertrophy and hyperplasia of rat and mouse parotid and submandibular glands (9, 10).The morphological changes are accompanied by a dramatic increase, or induction, in the synthesis of PRPs. Typically, these proteins contain 25-45% proline, 18-22% glycine, and 18-22% glutamine and glutamic acid. Aromatic and sulfur-containing amino acids are either very low in amount or absent. Generally, PRPs can be divided into acidic and basic groups, and both groups may be glycosylated and phosphorylated. PRPs may compose more than 70% of the protein in salivary gland extracts after treatment with isoproterenol. All proteins derived from the nucleotide sequences of PRP cDNAs and PRP genes are characterized by four general regions: a signal peptide region, a transition region, a repeat region, and a carboxyl-terminal region (11). The apparent tissue-specific synthesis and the appearance of PRPs in saliva in such large quantities, either constitutive (as in humans) or induced by isoproterenol, suggest biological functions in the oral cavity and the gastrointestinal tract. Several functions, such as calcium binding, inhibition of hydroxylapatite formation, and formation of the dental-acquired pellicle, have been attributed to the human salivary PRPs (12). PRPs have an unusually high &nity for such multihydroxylated phenols as tannins; feeding tannins to rats and mice mimics the effects of isoproterenol on the parotid glands (13). The induction of PRP synthesis by dietary tannins clearly results in a protective response against the detrimental effects of the tannins (13). Unlike mice and rats, hamsters do not respond to tannins in the diet by the induction of PRPs. Pronounced detrimental effects are observed in weanling hamsters specifically. When these animals are maintained on a 2%
t
tannin diet for 6 months, they fail to grow (6).Tannins are unusually toxic to weanling hamsters; an increase of tannin in the diet to 4% causes death to most animals within 3 days. The association of tannins with pathological problems, including carcinogenesis and hepatotoxicity, and the influences on growth and toxicity in hamsters, have led to the proposal that PRPs may act as a first line of defense against these multihydroxylated phenols (13). This review focuses on the biochemistry and molecular biology of the salivary PRPs; it is not intended to be an overall or complete review of PRPs. To those who have contributed to the PRP literature and whose work is not mentioned, we apologize. Previous reviews are used for many references and studies.
1. Background4 Salivary glands of various animals synthesize, or can be induced to synthesize, a group of proteins unusually high in proline, the so-called prolinerich proteins (PRPs) (12, 14-20). These proteins collectively constitute the largest group of proteins in human salivary secretions, making up more than 70%of the secreted proteins (12).PRPs may be divided into acidic and basic groups, and members of each group may be phosphorylated or glycosylated, or both. These unusual proteins are constitutive in human saliva, but families of similar proteins are dramatically increased or induced in parotid and submandibular glands of rats, mice, and hamsters by isoproterenol treatment (6, 18, 19,21).Profound morphological effects on rat parotid glands by isoproterenol treatment were first observed in 1961 (9, 10). Repeated pharmacological doses cause dramatic glandular hypertrophy (Fig. 1). The increase in DNA synthesis with isoproterenol treatment (25, 26) probably results mainly from polyploidy; by 4-5 days, more polyploid than diploid nuclei are seen (Fig. 2) (see 27 for a review on the regulation of salivary gland size and the effects of isoproterenol). The dramatic accumulation of PRPs in the parotid glands of rats treated with isoproterenol was first described in 1974 (16, 18,28).After 7-10 days of treatment (5 mg of isoproterenol per day), PRPs composed about 70%of the total soluble proteins in parotid gland extracts. Initially, an acidic PRP (PI =
4 Reviews describing mainly the human PRP families are available (12, 22, 23). These unusual proteins were first observed in human saliva by Mandel, Thompson, and Ellison (24) and were first purified and characterized by Bennick and Connell(14) and by Oppenheim, Hay, and Franzblau (15).The genetics of this human multigene family were described in a review by Bennick (23). Other than for comparisons of the human cDNAs and multigene families, this review focuses primarily on the tissue-specific inducible multigene PRP families of mouse, rat, and hamster.
4
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
FIG.1. Hypertrophic effects of isoproterenol treatment on rat salivary glands. Rats (150200 g of body weight) were injected intraperitoneally with 5 mg of isoproterenol daily for 7 days. The parotid glands (p), submandibular glands (sm), and sublingual glands (sl) were removed from control (bottom) and isoproterenol-treated animals (top). No changes were noted for the sublingual glands, which secrete principally mucous glycoproteins. Parotid glands, which are serous secretors, showed a dramatic increase in weight of about 6- to l0-fold. Submandibular glands are of a mixed cell population and showed an intermediate response to isoproterenol.
4.5) was identified (Ipr-lA2), and this protein was phosphorylated and glycosylated (16, 18, 19). Subsequently, six basic PRPs unusually high in proline (40-44%), glutamine plus glutamate (22-25%), and glycine (18-20%), containing varying amounts of lysine plus arginine (7-9%), were isolated and characterized (18, 19). Aromatic and sulfur-containing amino acids were either absent or present in very low amounts. Therefore, PRPs have little or no absorbance at 280 nm. Neither hydroxylysine nor hydroxyproline is present and the treatment of these PRPs with purified prolyl hydroxylase failed to convert proline into hydroxyproline. The molecular weights of the basic proteins, from sedimentation equilibrium, ranged from 15,000 to 18,OOO, and that of PRP Ipr-1A2 was 25,000. A high MW,,, (71,000) was observed following chromatography on Sephadex G-100, but the unusually high axial ratio (>25) of these proteins undoubtedly caused this value to be substantially overestimated. S values ranged from 1.1 to 1.4. Circular dichroism spectra showed no a-helical or polyproline conformations.
FIG. 2. Karyotypes of (a) a mouse bone marrow cell and (b) a monse parotid gland cell. The chromosomal display of the mouse hone marrow cell showed the normal 2n (= 40) chromosomes after 2 days of isoproterenol treatment. The mouse parotid gland cells (>50% of the cells) showed 471 chromosomes after 2 days of isoproterenol treatment. (Courtesy of Christopher Bidwell.)
6
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
II, PRP mRNAs and Cell-free Translation Analysis Studies by cell-free translation analysis using the reticulocyte lysate system and labeling with [3H]proline or 135Slmethionine showed dramatic and definitive changes in the patterns of protein synthesis in parotid glands of isoproterenol-treated rats, and PRP mRNAs were highly elevated in the treated animals (29).There was very little synthesis of PRPs from poIy(A)+ RNAs from glands of control rats: poly(A) RNAs from the glands of treated animals synthesized mainly PRPs; translation patterns with [3H]proline and [35S]methionine gave identical labeling patterns; and PRPs from cell-free translations were all precipitated by antibodies to PRPs. [35S]Methionine was incorporated only into the initiation site, as determined by sequence analysis and by the fact that PRPs synthesized by tissue slices of parotid glands of isoproterenol-treated rats in the presence of [35S]methionine contained no 35S label. Because most PRPs are acid-soluble, a property first used in the purification procedures of rat submandibular gland PRPs (30),it is imperative that cell-free translation products be precipitated with a solution containing both trichloroacetic and phosphotungstic acids (29). The induction of PRP mRNAs in the parotid and submandibular glands of both rats and mice by isoproterenol treatment has been demonstrated by Northern and dot-blot hybridizations (21). PRP mRNAs either are very low or are not detectable in the glands of untreated rats and mice. After 4-5 days of isoproterenol treatment, mRNAs encoding these unusual proteins compose over 50% of the total glandular mRNAs (5). For example, plasmid pRP25 does not hybridize with RNAs from control rats (Fig. 3A), but does hybridize with PRP mRNAs of two size-classes, ranging from 600 to 1100 bases, from isoproterenol-treated animals. These size ranges of mRNAs are consistent with all rat RNA preparations tested. The multiplicity of PRPs encoded by the PRP mRNAs from treated rats is evident from Fig. 3B, since about 12 PRPs were identified by cell-free translation analysis and immunoprecipitation. The PRP cDNA insert of pUMP40 (11), prepared from mRNAs from BALB/cJ mice, has been tentatively identified as the transcript of the mouse PRP gene MP2 (1).However, the nucleotide sequences of MP2 and the PRP insert of pUMP40 showed only 98% homology (1).MP2 was cloned from a genomic library prepared from chromosomal DNA from the CD-1 mouse strain. In an attempt to reconcile the heterologous regions and base differences between the CD-1 mouse gene MP2 and the BALB/cJ mouse mRNA, we isolated mRNAs from four mouse strains. Northern blots of total RNA from the parotid glands of mouse strains CD-1 and BALB/cJ and from strains DBA/2J and C57BL/6J, from both control and isoproterenol-treated mice, were probed with 32P-labeled exon +
7
PROLINE-RICH PROTEIN MULTICENE FAMILIES
A
B
1078 1353
872 -
603 -
FIG.3. Northern blot of parotid gland RNA from normal and isoproterenol-treated rats and cell-free translations of “sized” PRP mRNAs. (A) Parotid gland RNAs (10 pg) from normal and isoproterenol-treated rats were electrophoresed on a 1.5% agarose gel containing 5 mM methyl mercury hydroxide and transferred to nitrocellulose. The blot was probed with 32Plabeled pRP25 (11).(B) RNA was isolated from a methyl mercury denaturing low-melting-point agarose gel and translated in oitro with [SSImethionine. The translation products were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Lanes l and 8 show S S label incorporated in the absence of RNA and with total RNA from the parotid glands of isoproterenol-treated rats, respectively. Lanes 2-7 are the translation products obtained from RNA indicated in (A). Molecular-weight standards ( X l O - 3 ) are indicated at the right, and nucleotide standards are indicated at the left. [Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Biological Chemistry (S).]
IIb (see Fig. 10) of PRP gene MP2 (5). Two major classes of PRP mRNAs were detected in the treated animals. RNA species of about 1050 and 1300 bases for BALB/cJ and DBA/2J mice and about 1100 and 1200 bases for CD-1 and C57BL/6J mice were observed. Cell-free translations of total RNA from these four mouse strains showed interesting and unusual differences in the PRPs synthesized (Fig. 4). Similar labeling patterns were observed with both [3H]proline and [35S]methionine. The amounts or levels of incorporation varied considerably between controls and treated animals, and cx-
8
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
35S-Met
I
3
M.W. Std.
I PR
NORMAL a
-3
x c 0 m
<m -J
U
\ -I
m
I
lc
n m
m V
V
3 H -Pro ’
cv
*
a
m
-
-I
I
m U 0 n m V
m lc In
o
3
(0
(D
\ -I
I PR
NORMAL 7
7
3
\
1
cv
\ -I
U
lc
U
In 0
D
3
\
m
0
m
3
cv
\
m
(D
7
<m
‘
-
3
-IN
m \
I + a a n o m -I
m o
o n
45.0
31 .O
21.5
FIG.4. Translation products of RNAs prepared from four different mouse strains. Ten micrograms of total RNA from parotid glands of the mouse strains indicated, both before and after isoproterenol treatment, was translated with either [35S]methionine or [3H]proline; 200,000cpm of 35s and 50,000 cpm of 3H were applied to gel electrophoresis. a-Amylase and parotid-specific protein are indicated by the upper and lower arrows, respectively. Molecularweight standards (XlOW3) (M.W. Std.) are indicated at the left. [Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Biological Chemistry (5).]
amylase (upper arrow, Fig. 4)and parotid-specific protein (lower arrow, Fig. 4) were dramatically reduced. a-Amylase and parotid-specific protein expressions appear to be regulated in concert (31).Earlier cell-free translation experiments (21, 29) and RNA/DNA hybridization results (5) show that a-amylase mRNA is dramat-
PROLINE-RICH PROTEIN MULTIGENE FAMILIES
9
ically decreased by isoproterenol treatment. In a related study, a polymorphism in an androgen-regulated single-copy mouse gene (RE?)produced three major mRNAs (32).These RP2 mRNAs differed in the lengths of their untranslated 3’ regions as a result of using different polyadenylation sites, and additional variability resulted from the insertion of a member of the mouse B1 family. However, these RP2 polymorphisms had no effect on the translation product. Whether the PRP polymorphisms are the result of different PRP genes or are caused by differential RNA splicing remains to be determined.
111. PRP cDNAs and Amino-acid Sequences Plasmids containing cDNAs for PRPs were first isolated from a cDNA library prepared from RNA isolated from the parotid glands of isoproterenoltreated rats (7). Four recombinant plasmids (pRP8, pRP18, pRP25, and pRP33) were selected. Several mRNAs hybridized to each PRP cDNA, which emphasized the similarities in nucleotide sequences of the PRP mRNAs. This could have resulted from the expression of a family of closely related genes or from the production of multiple mRNAs from the same or similar genes by different splicing patterns. Whether one or both possibilities are responsible for the multiple PRP mRNAs has not been unequivocally demonstrated. Subsequently, several more PRP cDNAs were cloned from mouse and rat parotid gland mRNAs after isoproterenol treatment (11) and from the human parotid gland (33).5 The nucleotide sequence of the PRP cDNA insert of pRP33 (7) encodes the acidic PRP, Ipr-1A2 (Fig. 5). The 13 amino-terminal amino acids are highly hydrophobic and are probably part of a signal peptide (the signal peptide region) (see Fig. 8). The next 60 amino acids (the “transition” region) contain numerous acidic residues, with 10 aspartic acids in the 16-aminoacid sequence of Asp-58 to Asp-73. The “proline-rich” region (residues 80-189) is high in proline, glycine, and glutamine, and includes six repeats of 18 or 19 amino acids (the “repeat” region). The 17 carboxyl-terminal amino acids (the carboxyl-terminal region) contain single residues of tyrosine (-2O1), tryptophan (-203), and phenylalanine (-204) clustered close to the carboxylterminal serine (-206). These data, derived from the nucleotide sequence of pRP33, gave the first complete amino-acid sequence of a PRP. This sequence has been compared (7) with the partial amino-acid sequences reported for the human acidic (34) and basic (12)PRPs. Subsequent data derived from several PRP cDNA and PRP gene sequences show that the first 100 nucleotides in the 5’ regions of PRP mRNAs, which contain the 5’5 Differential splicing is considered to contribute to the multiple PRP mRNAs in the human salivary gland (33).
10
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
'
M
L
V
V
L
L
T
A
A
L
L
V
L
S
S
A
H
G
S
m
D
E
E
V
T
Y
E
D
S
S
S
Q
L
L
D
V
E
Q
Q
a
N
Q
K
H
G
Q
H
H
Q
K
P
P
P
A
S
D
E
N
G
s
D
G
D
D
S
D
D
G
D
D
D
G
S
G
D
D
G
N
R
E
R
8oP P
P
H
G
G
N
H
Q
R
P
P
P
G
H
H
H
G
9BP P
P
S
G
G
P
Q
T
S
S
Q
P
G
N
P
Q
G
P
P
Q
P
G
N
P
Q
G
P
P
nP
' " P P P Q G G P Q G "
P
P
P
Q
G
G
P
Q
Q
P
P
Q
G
G
P
Q
G
P
P
Q
G
G
H
Q
Q
I w P A Q D A T H
E
Q
"'P
R
Q
P
G
K
P
Q
G
P
P
Q
P
G
N
P
Q
G
R
P
P
Q
P
R
Q
D
P
S
Y
L
W
F
K P 206 S S
FIG. 5. The amino-acid sequence derived from primer-extended pRP33, arranged to align similar sequences. [Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Biological Chemistry (7.1
flanking sequence and encode exon I (or the putative signal peptide), have unusually strong homologies (>95% identity) (11)(Fig. 6). Sequence data obtained from a multigene family encoding CRPs from rat submandibular glands (3), are unusually high in glutamine and glutamate (4) and are very similar in this region, 91% of the nucleotides and 92% of the amino acids being identical to the sequences of the PRPs (3).
IV. Sequence and Structural Analyses of PRP Genes One of the family of mouse PRP genes was isolated on a cloned 3600-bp EcoRilBgZII-generated DNA fragment from a partial Sau3A bacteriophage library of CD-1 mouse chromosomal DNA (1).The transcriptional unit included three exonic sequences separated by 1434 bp (intron I) and by 450 bp (intron 11). The upstream sequence (Fig. 7) had putative induction sites for CAMP(box I11 and box I) and an activator or enhancer sequence (box II), ZDNA sequences that flanked an 86-bp sequence, a TATA box, and a CAAT box (1).The derived amino-acid sequence of this PRP gene ( M P 2 ) revealed a protein that contained 13 tandemly arranged repeats of 14 amino acids with the prototype sequence P P P P G G P Q P R P P Q G (Fig. 8). Each amino
-30
-20
I
I
up2 A
M(terenrs:
C
I
A
C
-10 I T
T
C
.
~
0
10
20
30
40
50
I
I
I
I
I
I
~
G
M
A
M
C
T
C
C
T
T
C
C
~
~
60 I ~
T
~
T
~
~
02030000000330220001003011213010000000230130300130330003301030010123311010010230111123333333300010
FIG.6. Comparisons of the S’-flanking regions and sequences e n d i n g exon 1 of PRP cDNAs and PRP genes from mouse ( M P 2 , pUMP40, pUMPl2, and pUMPl), rat (pRP25, pRP33, and pRP18), human (CPTI, CPT3, and CP6), hamster (H29), and rat CRPB. The legend indicating differences of 0, 1, 2, and 2 3 denotes the relative conservation of bases at each position. In 65% of the positions, there is only 0-1 base change.
~
T
C
C
T
H29
HE2 C T A A C C T T A A G C A T C T T T A A T A G A A C A A ~ T ~ G ~ G C ~ T C T-650 AT
I l l
I I
I
I Ill
I
-494 TCCCTACTGGGTGAGCTAACTCCCTACACAAT"AAACAAATCAATCAACT
I
D
I
GGTCCTTCAIAAATGTAACAGTCAAA-CAIACTCAC-CAGGAATTACGGATT-602
II
IIIIIIII Ill
-
1 1 1 1 I II II
I
-444 AAGTGTTAT GCATGTAACA-TCATGCCA A-TAACACUTGAA
+
I
I
-
d
CAAGATATTGACTCATGTATACCTCATATGTGTTGTGACTCCACTTTTAC -552
0
TGGGACTTTATAGATGAAATAGGTCTCATGCTTTACTA GCCAAT GTTGTA -502 GTTATTGTGTTAGGTCAGGAGAATAGTGGGCACTCTTACTGAGGCTTAGC -452 ATGTTAGGGATTCCAAGGGTCTTGGTGTAATTGATAlTTGlTTATGAATA
-402
GCCTCAACACCATCACTCTTAACTAATTATAGAATATATAAGAACATATA
-352
TAAGTGACAGTGGTTAAGCTATCCTACTGATCATAAA?iATTGACCACATT
-302
CAATTTGGACAGAAATCATTACTGTCAA TATAAACAAAT
-263
I I I I I I l l II CATAATTTTGCACCTTTAGTCTCAGTGA CAGGAA
-404
-370
I l l IIIIII IIII I Ill I I II II IIIII GAATATGGACA AAATTA TACAGGTATGTAGAAGCACCTCCCACAA
-322 TCATACCTAATAGGTCAGAGTCAGAGTTATGTCAATAACAGTGTCTTACA -274 CAATGATAGGCCTTAAAGGACAATAGACTTATTG -238 ATAGAACTATATATCTAATGTCTAGACTTTGCCTGTATCACTTAAACTAT GTGTATGCACACTAGTTTTA -244
I
I I
-1aa TGTTGTCAAAATTTCACATTGTACCATAGAGAACTGAAACATTGACTGCA CCCCAATGCACATTGATACACAAA AAATGTCAGCAAATGCA ATGAGATAT -193
I
II I
I I II
I
-138 TCCTGCTGGGCTAGAGTCCCAAAG AAAAGTCAGT GATGCA AAG
TTATATATTGTTAGTCATTACTGCAATAACTGGGTTATATGATTACATAG -143 GAGTTTTTTCTAGTAGGGACACTAGCAGCTAGC
TCTTCCTTACCTCATCCTGATGGGCAAAAGTCCCAGTGTCACACAAAGGA
-60
GAAAGGTGACATTCTTCTGCTCCTCCTTATAAAGGCAGTGTCTTACT
-12
II II I I l l II I I II I l l I I IIII TA TCCTGCTG TG TC AGGT CAGATCAATAGTGAGGA
-95 C
-60
I IIIIIIII IIII IIIIII I IIIIIIIIIII II I I CATGAAAGGTGCCATTGTTCTGC CTTCCTTATAAAGATTTTGGCCTTGC TCTTCCAGCACAGACTTGG
I
IIIIIIIIIIIIIII
-11 TGGCCCAGCACAGACTTGG FIG.7. Comparisons of upstream sequences of mouse PRP gene M P 2 and hamster PRP gene H 2 9 . The upstream sequences of M P 2 and H 2 9 are aligned to maximize sequence similarities. Putative regulatory regions are indicated. Boxes 111 and I, M P 2 , -640 to -623 and -218 to 203. respectively; arrows, AP-1 binding sites; GCCAAT, -513 to 508. CCAAT box.
13
PROLINE-RICH PROTEIN MULTICENE FAMILIES
I M L V V L F T V A L L A L S S 1 6 A Q G P R E E L Q N Q I Q I P N Q R
SIGNAL PEPTIDE TRANS I T I O N REG ION
3 4 P P P S G F Q P R P P V N G S Q Q G 52P P P P G G P Q P R P P
Q
G
REPEAT REGION
66P P P P G G P Q P R P P Q G 8oP P P P G G P Q P R P P
Q G
g4P P P P G G P Q P R P P Q G 108P P P P G G P Q Q R P P Q G 122P P P P G G P Q P R P P Q G 136P P P P G G P Q L R P P Q G 15oP P P P A G P Q P R P P Q G 16‘4P P P P A G P Q P R P P Q G 178P P T T - G P Q P R P T Q G 191P P P T G G P
Q Q R P P Q G
205P P P P G G P Q P R P P Q G 219P P P P G G P Q P S P T Q G 2 3 3 P P P T G G P Q Q T P P L A G N T 61 G
CARBOXYL TERMINUS
2 5 2 P P Q G R P Q G P R STOP 26 1 FIG. 8. Amino-acid sequence of PRP GPMsm derived from the nucleotide sequence of mouse PRP gene MP2.
acid within the repeat had its “favored” codon ( 1 ) (Table I), and six amino acids had a total conservation of codons for all 13 repeats. Subsequent studies (2) showed that two nonallelic PRP genes ( M P 2 and M 1 4 ) are tandemly arrayed and separated by about 30 kbp. Analysis of DNA sequences suggested that M P 2 and M 1 4 arose via gene duplication of a common ancestor. A homology matrix, or “dot-plot,” showed virtually no spurious background, and, aside from three differences, the sequences of the two genes, including the introns, were nearly identical. The differences observed were two additional sequences in intron I of M 1 4 of 223 and 2005 bp, four additional repeats (17 repeats total) in M 1 4 , and fractional sequence differences of the simple repetitive sequences (CA, TA, and TAGA) of intron
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
14 TABLE I COMPARISON OF CODON USAGE’ Codon
MP2
Other mouse genes
CCU Pro (47)b CCA CCG
16 16 60 8
31 25 38 6
GGU Gly (19)b GGC GGA GGG
0 62 31 7
21 26 32 21
CAA Gln (17)b CAG
53 47
35
CCU Arg (7)b CGC CGA CGG AGA AGG
6 0 6 6 64 18
7 13 13 12 31 24
ACU Thr (4)b ACC ACA ACG
23 0 77 0
25 36 32 7
UAA term UAG UGA
100 0 0
0 0 100
ccc
65
“Reprinted with permission from theloumul of Biological Chemistry ( 1 ) . b Amino-acid composition in mol%.
I. The additional 2005-bp sequence was the 3‘ portion of the mouse LINE element, and it apparently had been transposed into intron I, but in the opposite orientation of M 1 4 (Fig. 9). This mouse LINE sequence (LIMdPRP), like most mouse LINE elements, is truncated at the 5‘ end (35). LIMd-PRP contains the typical polyadenylation signal (AATAAA) and an adenine-rich sequence, and it is flanked by a pair of 10-bp imperfect repeats (TGTCTTTTTT and TGTCTTTCTT). This IO-bp sequence is present only once in MF2. These and other data are strong evidence that LIMd-PRP entered this PRP locus via transposition. Both M P 2 and M 1 4 are transcriptionally active in the parotid gland when the mouse is treated with isoproterenol (11). PRP cDNAs pUMP4 and pUMP40 are encoded by M 1 4 and MF2, respectively. The number of tan-
15
PROLINE-RICH PROTEIN MULTIGENE FAMILIES 0
10
5
15
20
30 35
25
40
45
50
60
55
65
70 75
80 kb
GENES
Hindm Sol1 BamHI EcoRI
CLONES
I
9
I,
1
0
I
,
b
,
,,
I
f
,,,
, I
c
,d,
e
,
I
,
MC I6 MC22 M I4
FIG. 9. Linkage of mouse PRP genes MP2 and M14.The organization of MP2 and M I 4 are shown by the expanded scales and the relative lengths are indicated by the kilobase bar. Solid bars show the three exonic regions, and the open arrow ( M 1 4 ) represents the LINE insert. Arrows show the direction of transcription. [Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Biological Chemistry @).I
dem repeats within each gene varies, as we indicated (I, 36), and is similar to those reported (37) using variable number of tandem repeats (VNTRs) as markers for mapping human genes. However, PRP tandem repeats are the major body of the active gene, and no sequence similarity exists between this repeat and the invariant core sequence of VNTRs (37, 38). Sequence analysis of a hamster PRP gene (H29) showed that the hamster, rat, mouse, and human PRP genes are all closely related. Mouse and rat PRP genes have two exons encoding PRPs (I and IIb) (Fig. lo), while hamster and human genes have three exons (I, IIa, and IIb). Exon IIa of hamster and human PRP genes are both comprised of 36 bp, seemingly coming from the 5’ sequences of exon IIb of the mouse and rat. Whether this difference in PRP gene organization resulted from a separation or combination of exonic regions is unknown. Upstream regulatory regions of mouse, hamster, and human PRP genes are discussed in Section V. Unlike PRPs from mice and rats, which are all blocked on the amino terminus, hamster PRPs Hp43a and Hp43b were partially sequenced from the amino terminus (39). The open reading frame of exon I (H29) encodes hydrophobic residues, the putative signal peptide. Exon IIa contains only 36 bp, and the derived amino-acid sequence is A T I Y E D S I S Q L S, which is exactly the sequence of the amino terminus of Hp43a, except in position 8, which is D instead of I. Exon IIb contains 514 bp and encodes the mature protein, except for the first 12 amino acids. Exon IIb has 10 Hue111 sites and six Sau96I restriction enzyme sites, which is one of the unusual characteristics of PRP genes (I).One open reading frame of exon IIb encodes a 20-
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
16 EI
E Ilo
\ ,I
Hamster
'\\
H29
M
ll
0
Human PRHl
,'
N
\
I,
I,
,
,
,
,/
,
\I
'\
'
;
:: I t
I
U
I
3'
5' 1 kb
FIG. 10. Comparison of PRP gene organizations in mice, hamsters, and humans. Related exonic regions (bars)are connected by dashed lines. The gene organizations of hamster H29 (36) and human PRHl (8)show the additional 36-bp exonic sequence. [Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Biological Chemistry (2).]
aminoacid peptide that is repeated five times and has a prototype sequence of P P Q Q E G Q Q Q N R P P K P Q N Q E G. The first 43aminoacids and the last 12 amino acids derived from the nucleotide sequences of exons IIa and IIb diverge from this prototype repeat pattern and give rise to the transition region and the carboxyl-terminal region, respectively. While the 5'-noncoding regions and the sequences encoding the putative signal peptides (about 100-110 bp) are highly conserved in all PRP mRNAs (Fig. 6), there is a discrepancy in the apparent cleavage site by the signal peptidase in hamster PRPs, as suggested by the amino-acid sequence of Hp43a. From the amino-acid sequence derived from PRP gene H 2 9 , the nascent polypeptide chain has the sequence M L V V L L T A A L L A & E H f A T I Y E----, with Glu (E) and His (H) preceding the apparent site of cleavage ( t ) (see the amino-terminal sequence encoded by exon IIa, above, A T I Y E D-----). Histidine has not been observed in position -1 (counting from the cleavage site) (40). We have proposed that the signal peptidase cleaves between Ala and Glu ( J. ) and that Glu and His are removed by further processing (36). However, this proposal predicts an unusually short signal peptide of only 12 amino acids.
V. Regulation of Expression of PRP Genes The upstream sequences of mouse PRP genes M P 2 and M14 and hamster PRP gene H 2 9 contain potential regulatory elements (Figs. 7 and 11). In each of these genes, three highly conserved regions were identified (boxes I111) (1).These regions include two putative CAMPresponse elements (boxes
17
PROLINE-RICII PROTEIN MULTIGENE FAMILIES
Source
Sequence
E. coli CRP Binding Site
Bovine a-gonadotropin Human VIP
A A N T G T G A N N -122 -81
Reference (411
- T N N N - N C A
T T A T G T G A A G - T A C -
- .C A
-108
(55)
T A C T G T G A C G
- T C A
-65
(56)
- T C T T
PRP Genes, Box 111 Mouse MP2 Mouse M14 Hamster H29
-640 -640 -435
A A A T G T A A C A G T C A A - A C A C A A T G T A A C A G T C A A - A C A G C A T G T A A C A - T C A T G C C A
-623 -623 -418
(1) (2) (36)
PRP Genes, Box I Mouse MP2 Mouse M14 Hamster H29
-218 -217 -114
A A A T G T C A G C - A A A T - G C A A A T T G T C A G C - T A A T - G C A A A A T G T C A G T - - G A T - G C A
-203 -202 -99
(1) (2) (36)
Human PRP Genes PRHl PRH2
-484 -484
A A A T G T G A A A A T A C C A A A T A T A C A A A T A T C
-467 -467
(8) (8)
Relative Base Frequencies: A T G C
0 1 0 411 12 11 12 0 0
0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 3 1
1
11 0 0
- T C A - C A T 1lJ 0 1 0 11 0
FIG. 11. Sequence comparisons of the E . coli CRP binding site with putative cAMP regulatory sites (boxes I and 111) of PRP gene M P 2 . Similar sequences in the E . coli CRP binding site are reported in bovine a-gonadotropin, human vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), and human PRHl (PRP) genes. The relative frequencies of A, T, G , and C at each position are indicated. Positions 4, 5, 6, and 8 (TGT-A) are totally conserved. Positions 12, 18, and 19 each show only one substitution: A for T ( 1 2 ) in M P 2 , and A for C (18)and C for A (19),both found in human PRHI.
I and 111) with sequences similar to the CRP binding site required for transcriptional activation of CAMP-regulated genes in Escherichia coli (1,41) (Fig. 11). Also, box I11 of the mouse PRP genes contains a sequence (-637 TAACAGTCA - 629) which resembles the 8-bp palindromic sequence TGACGTCA, a cAMP response element (CRE) in eukaryotes (42).The palindrome is imperfect by one base (A for G), and it is interrupted by an A. This sequence in box I11 of the hamster gene is similar, but it lacks a G (TAAC-TGA). Such overlapping sequences of CRP and CRE have been shown to be functionally related (43). Mammalian activation-translation factors (ATF)can bind specifically to some E. coli CRP sites, and, conversely, E. coli CRP-binding protein specifically binds to some mammalian ATF sites (43). Of considerable interest is the observation that multiple AP-1 binding sites (44) are present immediately 3' to box I11 in PRP genes MP2 and M14 (Fig. 11).These sequences are not present in the hamster gene. A perfect
18
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
copy of the AP-1 heptamer, TGACTCA, is located at positions -594 to -588. A totally conserved CCAAT box (GCCAAT) is located at positions -516 to -509 in MP2 and M14. Proteins known to bind to the CCAAT box (CTF/NF-1 proteins) activate both transcription and replication (45). The proline-rich transcriptional activator of CTF/NF-1 is distinct from the replication and DNA binding domain in that it requires an additional carboxylterminal domain (46). Preliminary studies using gel-mobility-shift assays (47) have shown that nuclear extracts from the parotid glands of isoproterenoltreated mice have about a 6-fold increase in protein(s) binding to the upstream sequence (-702 to -574 bp) of MP2. “Footprint” assays indicate that the nuclear protein(s) binds to the AP-1 repeats. Adding Bt,cAMP or forskolin to hamster parotid gland primary-cell cultures resulted in a large increase (i.e., 15-to 30-fold) in PRP mRNA levels (48). The increase was most dramatic between 10 and 18 hr of treatment. Treatment of the cells with cycloheximide blocked this induction of PRP mRNAs, which is added evidence that the synthesis of a trans-acting factor is necessary for the dramatic increase in transcriptional activation of the PRP genes. &-AmylasemRNA was not significantly ailected by the cycloheximide treatment. Transfections have been performed using the plasmid pUMP2BE, which contains the complete MP2 gene, and with various constructs containing deletions of the upstream sequence of MP2. Constructs containing the sequence -702 to -574 bp of MP2 in tandem with the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) promoter and the chloramphenicol transferase (CAT) gene showed induction of PRP mRNAs of 2- to 4-fold. Various cell types have been used for the transfection experiments, including PC-12, AtT20, and L M cells. Presently, we are attempting transfection experiments with a parotidhepatoma cell line prepared by fusion of FTO-2B cells and parotid gland primary cells (49). This may be the only “immortalized cell line of parotid gland cells available, and these cells may respond more dramatically to transfections with the PRP gene regulatory sequence.
VI. Functional Aspects of PRPs The high conservation of the sequences and structures of PRP genes and PRPs argues for specific biological functions for these unusual proteins. Some of the proposed functions, such as calcium binding, hydroxylapatite binding, formation of the dental-acquired pellicle, and agglutination of oral bacteria, have been reviewed, especially for human PRPs (12, 22, 23). In 1983, we showed that PRPs, which were dramatically induced in rat parotid glands by feeding tannins, are beneficial to the rat (SO).Condensed tannins (proanthocyanidins, oligomers G f fiaan-3-01s) and hydrolyzable tannins
PROLINE-RICH PROTEIN MULTICENE FAMILIES
19
(oligomers of gallic acid) are present in many foods. Antinutritional effects and other toxic and pathological properties, such as carcinogenicity and hepatotoxicity, have been associated with the ingestion of tannins and with the medicinal use of tannins. The general properties of tannins, their effects on biological systems, and specifically their roles in the induction of PRPs have recently been reviewed (13). Seeds of bird-resistant cultivars of sorghum, a major cereal crop of the semi-arid tropics, contain high levels of tannin (high-tannin sorghum), which diminishes the nutritional value of the grain. Studies designed to define the interactions of tannins and proteins show that tannins have an extremely high affinity for proteins rich in proline (51), and that the salivary PRPs have the highest affinity (50). Because the gastrointestinal tract, specifically the oral cavity, is the source of PRPs, it was suggested that salivary PRPs might interact with tannins and serve as a defense against the detrimental effects of dietary tannins. While the dramatic induction of PRPs in the rat following isoproterenol treatment clearly offsets the usual detrimental effects of dietary tannins (50),parotid glands from rats fed high-tannin sorghum (i.e., 2% of their diet) without isoproterenol treatment were also enlarged about 4fold, and there was a dramatic increase in PRPs within 3 days. Thus, tannins in the diet mimic the effects of the P-agonist isoproterenol on the parotid glands. There was an initial weight loss on the 2% tannin diet, reversed at 3 days, or at the time of maximal stimulation of PRP synthesis. After this time, the animals grew at close to the normal rate. Amino-acid analysis, electrophoretic patterns of proteins, and cell-free translations of mRNAs all confirmed that the PRPs induced in parotid glands by feeding tannin are identical to those induced by isoproterenol. Subsequent studies show that the P-agonist propranolol (a mixed PI, P,-agonist) and atenolol (a PI-agonist), when included in the diet, block the induction of PRPs by dietary tannin. Butoxamine, a P,-specific blocker, had no effect and therefore the P-adrenergic receptor affected by tannin feeding is the PI-receptor. The addition of either propranolol or atenolol to the diet of rats also causes substantial increases in four proteins in the submandibular glands, of MW 145,000 (GP145), 42,000 (P42), 40,000 (P40), and 39,000 (P39) (52). GP145 is glycosylated. These proteins are tissue-specific, as they were not detected in the parotid or sublingual gland, lung, liver, pancreas, kidney, heart, or small intestine either before or after propranolol treatment. We believe that this is the first report on the induction or regulation of protein synthesis by a P-adrenergic blocker. The hamster was used as another animal model to study the regulation and expression of PRPs. The hamster responded to isoproterenol by the induction of a series of proteins (39). However, the protein encoded by “PRP” gene H29 was unusually high (34%) in Gln and was only 15% Pro.
20
DON M. CARLSON ET AL.
Also, there was no evidence of a hypertrophic response in the hamster salivary glands. Subsequent studies of feeding tannins to hamsters also showed essentially no hypertrophic response, and PRPs were not induced. Weanling hamsters fed a diet of 2% tannin lose weight for about 3 days, as do rats and mice, but then an unusual growth inhibition occurs (39). Hamsters maintained on a 2% tannin diet failed to grow, and even at 60 days were essentially the same body weight as at 3 days after starting the feeding trial. When diets were switched, the experimental animals gained weight at close to the normal rate for young hamsters, while the control animals, then on a 2% tannin diet, lost about 20% of their weight. Clearly, the detrimental effects of tannins are reversed or inhibited by the induction of PRPs in rats and mice, but hamsters are unusually susceptible to tannins. In fact, increasing the tannin content of the diet to 4% was fatal to most hamsters within 3 days.
VII. Discussion Specialized cells in eukaryotes variably express different genes during differentiation and development. Exocrine glands, such as the pancreas and the salivary glands, have served as models of secretory tissues. Under ordinary conditions, the salivary glands of adult animals are relative stable and do not change appreciably in cell size or number (27). However, administration of the catecholamine isoproterenol causes dramatic morphological, cytological, and biochemical changes. Morphologically, the parotid glands can increase up to 10-fold in size. Cytologically, about 50% of the acinar cells are polyploid within 2 days of treatment. Biochemically, a dramatic induction of the multigene family encoding the PRPs is observed. The expression of PRPs for the parotid and submandibular glands is tissue-specific or, possibly more correctly, cell-specific. PRPs have been identified immunochemically in the trachea (53) and the pancreas but there is no evidence that PRP genes in these tissues respond as in the salivary glands to isoproterenol treatment. Small amounts of PRP mRNAs are observed in the mouse pancreas after isoproterenol treatment (C. A. Bidwell and D. M. Carlson, unpublished), but these results were variable. Current data suggest that transcriptional controls, tissuespecific factors, and post-translational modification share the role of principal modulators of the expression of the PRP gene families.
(a),
ACKNOWLEDGMENT These studies were supported in part by NIH grant DK 36812. P.S.W. was supported by
NIH training grant T32 HL 7013-13.
PROLINE-RICII PROTEIN MULTIGENE FAMILIES
21
REFERENCES D. K. Ann and D. M. Carlson, JBC 260, 15863 (1985). D. K. Ann, M. K. Smith and D. M. Carlson, JBC 263, 10887 (1988). G. Heinrich and J. F. Habener, JBC 262, 5262 (1987). L. Mirels, G. S. Bedi, D. P. Dickison, K. W. Grossand L. A. Tabak,JBC262,7289(1987). D. K. Ann, S. Clements, E. M. Johnstone and D. M. Carlson, JBC 262, 899 (1987). H. Mehansho, D. K. Ann, L. G. Butler, J. Rogler and D. M. Carlson, JBC 262, 12344 (1987). 7 . M. A. Ziemer, W. F. Swain, W. J. Rutter, S. Clements, D. K. Ann and D. M. Carlson,JBC 259, 10475 (1984). 8. H. S. Kim and N. Maeda, JBC 261, 6712 (1986). 9. H. Selye, M. Cantin and R. Veilleux, Growth 25, 243 (1961). 10. K. Brown-Grant, Nature 191, 1076 (1961). 11. S. Clements, H. Mehansho and D. M. Carlson, JBC 260, 13471 (1985). 12. A. Bennick, MCBchem 45, 83 (1982). 13. H. Mehansho, L. G. Butler and D. M. Carlson, Annu. Reu. Nutr. 7, 423 (1987). 14. A. Bennick and G. E. Connell, BJ 123, 455 (1971). 15. F. G. Oppenheim, D. I. Hay and P. Franzblau, Bchem 10, 4233 (1971). 16. A. Fernandez-Sorenson and D. M. Carlson, BBRC 60, 249 (1974). 17. D. L. Kauffman and P. J. Keller, Arch. Oral B i d . 24, 249 (1979). 18. J. Muenzer, C. Bildstein, M. Gleason and D. M. Carlson, JBC 254, 5623 (1979). 19. J. Muenzer, C. Bildstein, M. Gleason and D. M. Carlson, JBC 254, 5629 (1979). 20. R. S. C. Wong and A. Bennick, JBC 255, 5943 (1980). 21. H. Mehansho, S. Clements, B. T. Sheares, S. Smith and D. M. Carlson, JBC 260, 4418 (1985). 22. A. Bennick, J . Dental Res. 66, 457 (1987). 23. A. Bennick, J . Dental Res. 68, 2 (1989). 24. I. D. Mandel, R. H. Thompson and S. A. Ellison, Arch. Oral B i d . 10, 499 (1965). 25. T. Barka, Exp. Cell Res. 37, 662 (1965). 26. R. Baserga, FP 29, 1443 (1970). 27. C. A. Schneyer, in “Regulation of Organ and Tissue Growth” (R. J. Gross, ed.), 211 pp. Academic Press, New York, 1972. 28. M. R. Robinovitch, P. J. Keller, D. A. Johnson, J. M. Iverson and D. L. Kaufman,]. Dental Res. 56, 290 (1977). 29. M. A. Ziemer, A. Mason and D. M .Carlson, JBC 257, 11176 (1982). 30. H. Mehansho and D. M. Carlson, ]BC 258, 6616 (1983). 31. H. 0. Madsen and J. B. Hjorth, NARes 13, 1 (1985). 32. D. King, L. D. Snider and J. B. Lingrel, MCBiol 6, 209 (1986). 33. N. Maeda, H . 4 . Kim, E. A. Azen and 0. Smithies, JBC 260, 11123 (1985). 34. D. Kauffman, R . Wong, A. Bennick and P. Keller. Bchem 21, 6558 (1982). 35. M . F. Singer and J. Skowronski, TZBS 10, 119 (1985). 36. D. K. Ann, D. Gadbois and D. M. Carlson, JBC 262, 3958 (1987). 37. Y. Nakamura, M. Leppert, P. O’Connell, R. WOK, T. Holm, M. Culver, C. Martin, E. Fujimoto, M. Hoff, E. Kumlin and R. White, Science 235, 1616 (1987). 38. A. J. Jeffreys, V. Wilson and S . L. Thein, Nature 314, 67 (1985). 39. H. Mehansho, D. K. Ann, L. G. Butler, J. Rogler and D. M. Carlson, JBC 262, 12344 (1987). 40. G. von Heijne, J M B 173, 243 (1984). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
22
DON M . CARLSON ET AL.
41. B. de Crombrugghe, S. Busby and H. Buc, Science 224, 831 (1984). 42. W. J. Roesler, G. R. Vanderback and R. W. Hansen, JBC 263, 9063 (1988). 43. Y.-S.Lin and M. R. Green, Nature 340, 656 (1989). 44. P. K. V. Vogt and T. J. Bos, TZBS 14, 172 (1989). 45. C. Santoro, N. Mermod, P. C. Andrews and R. Tjian, Nature 334, 218 (1988). 46. N. Mermod, E. A. O’Neill, T. J. Kelly and R. Tjian, Cell 58, 741 (1989). 47. J. Zhou and D. M. Carlson, FASEB]. 4, 2131 (1990). 48. P. S. Wright, C. Lenney and D. M. Carlson, J . Mol. Endocrinol. 4, 81 (1990). 49. P. S Wright and D. M. Carlson, FASEB]. 2, 3104 (1988). 50. H. Mehansho, A. Hagerman, S. Clements, L. G. Butler, J. Rogler and D. M. Carlson, PNAS 80, 3948 (1983). 51. A. Hagerman and L. G. Butler, JBC 256, 4494 (1981). 52. V. N. Subramaniam and D. M. Carlson, FASEB J. 4, 1980 (1990). 53. T. F. Warner and E. A. Azen, Am. Reu. Respir. Dis. 130, 115 (1984). 54. S. Ito, S. Isemura, E. Saitob, K. Sanada, T. Suzuki and A. Shibita, Acta Endocrinol. 103, 544 (1983). 55. R. G. Goodwin, C. L. Moncman, F. M. Rottman and J. H. Nilson, NARes 11, 6873 (1983). 56. T. Tsukada, J. S. Fink, G. Mandel and R. H. Goodman, JBC 262, 8743 (1987).
Recognition of tRNAs by Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases’
I
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN Albert Einstein College of Medicine Bronx, New York 10461
I. Recognition versus Identity
................
11. Assays of the Amino-acid-am A. In Vitro Assays
B. In Vioo Assays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Role of the Anticodon
IV.
V.
VI. VII. VIII. IX.
A. Anticodon Recognition in E . coli tRNAs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Anticodon Recognition in Yeast tRNAs C. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . Role of the Acceptor Stem and the “Discriminator” Base at Position 73 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Alanine Synthetases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. E. coli Serine Synthetase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. E. coli Glutamine Synthetase . . . . D. Other E . coli Synthetases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Other Recognition Profiles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. E . coli Arginine Synthetase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Yeast Phenylalanine Synthetase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. E. coli Phenylalanine Synthetase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Summary ...................... Role of Modified Bases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Complex of E. coli Glutamine tRNA and Glutamine Synthetase . . . tRNA Binding Domains of Other Synthetases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concluding Remarks References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
24 2.5 25 25 29 30 43
44 44 44 51 53
55 57 58 58 60 62
63 64 66
72 81 82
The highly specific selection of tRNA substrates by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases is an intriguing problem in RNA-protein recognition. Synthetases specific for each of the 20 amino acids encounter a pool of tRNAs in the cell having similar overall structures (1-3). Selection of the appropriate tRNAs for attachment of each amino acid occurs by the formation of RNA-protein contacts unique to each cognate tRNA-synthetase pair. The sites in tRNAs that govern these interactions have been investigated by a variety of techAbbreviations: synthetase, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase; MetRS, methionyl-tRNA synthetase; GlnRS, glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase, etc.; tRNAMet(CAU), methionine tRNA have the anticodon sequence 5‘CAU3‘; tRNATw(CCA), tryptophan tRNA having the anticodon sequence 5’CCA3’, etc.; DIIFR, dihydrofolate reductase.
23 Progress in Niicleic Acid Research and Molecular Biology, Vol. 41
Copyright 0 1991 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
24
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
niques for over 20 years, and numerous reviews cover this literature (4-6). However, recent technical advances have allowed a burst of new activity in this area, leading to the identification of nucleotide bases required for the recognition of a number of specific tRNAs (7-11).In addition, new studies have begun to reveal the corresponding sites in the synthetases that govern specific tRNA interactions (12-18). This article focuses on these exciting recent developments, dealing first with the tRNA studies, and following with a summary of data on tRNA recognition sites in synthetases.
1. Recognition versus Identity The terms “tRNA recognition” and “tRNA identity” have both been widely used in discussions of tRNA aminoacylation specificity. I use “recognition” here to refer to the specific identification of a cognate tRNA by its corresponding synthetase. The recognition elements in a given tRNA are defined as the set of structural features unique to that tRNA required for its efficient aminoacylation by the cognate synthetase. Recognition elements are identified by structural changes that significantly reduce the efficiency of aminoacylation by the cognate synthetase in in oitro assays. In addition, recognition elements can be transferred to noncognate tRNAs, allowing them to be charged with the corresponding amino acid in uitro and/or in oiuo. Further, loss of an important recognition element from an essential tRNA in uiuo should lead to a decrease in aminoacylation efficiency sufficient to impair cell growth. In the case of several tRNAs, recognition is now known to require only a small number of specific nucleotides. The prospects are good in the next few years for identification of the major recognition elements in tRNAs specific for all 20 amino acids in Escherichia coli. “tRNA identity” (19)is the term currently in general use to indicate the amino-acid-acceptor specificity of a tRNA. Identity elements include recognition elements for the cognate synthetase plus additional structural features that prevent recognition of the tRNA by noncognate synthetases. The locations of these positive and negative identity elements coincide when two synthetases recognize the same sites in their cognate tRNAs, but diverge in cases in which the recognition patterns differ. Identity elements need not be conserved among tRNAs specific for the same amino acid, as isoacceptor tRNAs could require different negative elements to protect against mischarging by different noncognate synthetases. Analysis of an extensive set of mutant tRNAs is often required to distinguish between positive and negative identity elements, and mutants having dual or multiple identities can be created readily. At present, the size of the identity set for specific tRNAs is largely unknown. In addition, inherent difficulties in setting up appropriate in oioo assays may hamper complete solution of the tRNA identity problem for some time.
RECOGNITION OF
25
tRNAs
II. Assays of the Amino-acid-acceptor Specificity of tRNA A. In Vitro Assays In oitro assays of tRNA charging and mischarging by purified synthetases, together with sequence comparisons of the test tRNAs, were used in earlier studies to attempt to define tRNA recognition elements (6, 20-23). In addition, chemical modification experiments helped to identify sites where structural changes led to loss of recognition by cognate synthetases (5, 6, 24). Nonsense and missense suppressor tRNAs generated in genetic experiments were also isolated from cells for in oitro analysis (25-28). Studies using tRNAs synthesized in oioo were sometimes complicated by the fact that mutations, especially those in the anticodon loop, altered the normal patterns of post-transcriptional base modification, and the effects of the two changes could not easily be distinguished (28). In 1982, a method for in uitro anticodon replacement using T4 RNA ligase was reported that avoids this problem (29). T4 RNA ligase was also used subsequently to introduce mutations near the 3' end of tRNAs (30) and to join synthetic oligoribonucleotides into intact tRNA structures (31). More recently, wild-type and synthetic tRNA genes have been cloned, and a variety of tRNAs have been overproduced and purified for in oitro studies (3236). In addition, in oitro transcription of tRNAs using "7 RNA polymerase has allowed the preparation of milligram quantities of specific tRNA sequences for enzymatic assays and physical studies (37-39). Fortunately, these transcripts lacking base modifications have generally been efficient substrates for aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (Table I), allowing quantitative comparisons of the effects of base changes at specific sites on recognition by purified cognate and noncognate enzymes. This technique has also provided tRNA sequences difficult to obtain from cells due to the effect of mutations on tRNA biosynthesis or cell viability.
B. In Vivo Assays 1. NONSENSESUPPRESSION While much can be learned about tRNA recognition from in vitro experiments, the complete set of tRNA identity elements can only be derived from in oioo studies in which synthetases specific for all 20 amino acids compete for tRNA substrates under normal physiological conditions. Unfortunately, no direct in oioo assay of tRNA amino-acid-acceptor specificity exists. In early in oioo studies using amber suppressor derivatives of E. coli tRNATyr, genetic selections were devised for tRNA base changes that allow suppres-
26
LADONNE
n. SCHULMAN
TABLE I OF AMINOACYLATION OF NATIVE tRNAs AND in Vitro SYNTHESIZED tRNA COMPARISON WITH COGNATE SYNTHETASES" TRANSCRIPTS ~
Organism
E. coli Yeast
E . coli E. coli Yeast
E. coli E. coli
tRNA
[Mg2+](mM)
Asp Native Transcript Asp Native Transcript His Native Transcript Met Native Transcript Phe Native Transcript Thr, Native Transcript Val, Native Transcript Native Transcript
10 10 15 15 10 10 5 8
15 15 8
8 5 11 15 15
Relative specificityd transcript/ native
Reference
1.0
40
0.3Bb l.O=
0.9
41
4.0 0.6
0.80
0.7
42
1.1
0.9r 1.oc 0.8= 1.oc
0.5
43
0.2
37
1.2=
0.4
44
0.75~ 1.0=
0.4
43
0.94c
0.9
45
Apparent K, ( F M )
0.33 0.32 0.044 0.028
3.5
0.096
0.380 0.06 0.20 0.5 1.0 1.6 1.6
kb.c
1.oc 1.oc 0.66b
1.0"'
1.oc
Kinetic parameters vary with aminoacylation conditions. Native tRNAs and tRNA transcripts were assayed in parallel in each case, except for Mgz+ concentration. Transcripts normally require higher [Mgz'] for optimal aminoacylation. It is not clear in all cases whether experiments were carried out at the Mgz+ optimum for the native tRNA or for the transcript. Apparent K,'s are given since assays are carried out at suboptimal amino-acid concentrations. See specific references for details.
bkcal (s-'). Relative V,-. "[ k,,,/K,,,]transcript/[ k,,,/K,]native
or [ V,,/K,]transcript/[
V,,/K,]native.
sion of amber codons at sites for which Tyr insertion fails to yield a biologically active protein (46,47). A number of mutant tRNAs were isolated, a11 of which inserted Gln (48-51). In 1986, the powerful genetic approach to the study of tRNA identity was revived, taking advantage of automated DNA synthesis to construct genes of E. coli amber suppressor tRNAs containing base changes at any desired location (19,52, 53). The genes were cloned in a tRNA expression vector and the amino acid inserted by the suppressor tRNA at the site of specific amber codons in uiuo was directly determined by protein sequencing. E. coli dihydrofolate reductase, containing an amber codon at position 10 of the gene, was used as the target protein due to its ease of purification by methotrexate affinity chromatography and the neutral
RECOGNITION OF
27
tRNAs
effect of amino-acid substitutions at position 10 on enzyme activity (Fig. 1). This approach has also recently been widely used by others (54-61). Much important information on tRNA identity has resulted from these studies; however, there are several problems inherent in such suppression assays. First, the anticodon of the tRNA must be changed to one that is complementary to the nonsense codon. As discussed in greater detail in Section 111, such changes frequently affect recognition of the tRNA by one or more synthetases. Second, the efficiency of suppression cannot be directly related to the efficiency of aminoacylation. Suppression efficiency is usually measured by the rate of translation of a nonsense codon by a given suppressor tRNA relative to the rate of translation of a wild-type codon at the same site by an endogenous tRNA. Suppression efficiency can be affected by the level of synthesis of the tRNA, the type and extent of base modifications (particularly in the anticodon loop), and the interaction of the tRNA with ribosomes and translation factors. Evaluation of the effects of some of these factors on suppression efficiency can readily be made (62); however, it is difficult to access the effect of others. Several types of data are particularly useful in maximizing the information to be obtained on tRNA identity from in uiuo suppression studies. One is knowledge of the relative intracellular levels of tRNAs competing for the same synthetase. It is clear from theoretical considerations (63), as well as from a variety of experimental observations (59, 62, M), that in uiuo mischarging of tRNAs can be brought about by an imbalance of tRNAs and synthetases in the cell. Test tRNAs are normally overproduced in the sup2
Wild-type DHFR
Ile
1 2
Ser
Leu
Ile
Ah
Ala
Leu
Ala
Val
Asp
Arg
ATC AGT CTG A T T GCG GCG T T A GCG G T A G A T CGC DHFR-amber
........................ ........................
... ...
A A ' Asn TAG AAT
2
Pseudo-DHFR
Met
Lys
Leu V a l S e r
Ala
ATG AAG C T T G T A AGC GCG DHFR-start
AA'
Ser
Leu
Ile
Ale
ATC AGT CTG A T T GCG
..............................
NNN... DHFR-shift
Ile
...........................
. . . . . . . . . AA' . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . NNNN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . FIG. 1. The sequence of the amino terminus of wild-type E . coli DHFR (118) and DHFR derivatives (19, 670), used for in oioo assays of tRNA identity.
28
LADONNE
n.
SCHULMAN
pression assay to maximize the amount of suppressed protein generated for sequencing. This “fixes the game” in the intracellular competition between the test tRNA and endogenous tRNAs. On the other hand, some mutations drastically reduce the amount of mature tRNA produced in the cell, complicating the interpretation of the effect of specific mutations on amino-acid specificity when comparing tRNAs expressed at different levels. Another valuable piece of information is knowledge of whether aminoacylation is rate-limiting in the suppression assay. This can be assessed by determining the effect on suppression efficiency of overproducing the synthetase(s) corresponding to the amino acid(s) inserted by the test tRNA. Genetic screens have also been used to examine tRNA identity in uiuo, using cells that require insertion of a specific amino acid at a nonsense codon for normal growth (19, 56, 58, 64).This assay is a minimal test of tRNA identity, however, since low levels of aminoacylated tRNA (below the amount detectable by sequencing dihydrofolate reductase) have been found to support growth in some cases, and in uiuo charging with other amino acids is not assessed. Interesting tRNA mutants with altered amino-acid-acceptor specificity can also be obtained by selection for changes in chromosomal tRNA genes that suppress missense mutations in specific proteins (65,66). However, such mischarging mutants insert incorrect amino acids at normal translation codons; they are therefore expected to be significantly defective in aminoacylation or some subsequent step in translation, or else they would be highly toxic.
2. NEW in Viuo ASSAYS
The inability to assay tRNAs containing wild-type anticodons has been a major problem in in uiuo studies of tRNA identity. If tRNAs containing anticodon base changes are efficiently charged by their cognate synthetases or by more than one synthetase, they are toxic to cells, frequently inserting incorrect amino acids into proteins. If the tRNAs are completely converted to the identity corresponding to the new anticodon, the usual assay is lost, since proteins indistinguishable from those synthesized by endogenous tRNAs are made. My group has recently been attempting to develop new in uiuo assays that allow studies of tRNAs containing wild-type anticodons (67, 67a). One such assay uses the E. coli initiator Met tRNA (tRNAfMet)as the test tRNA for the effect of specific mutations on amino-acid-acceptor specificity. Plasmid-borne tRNAfMet genes containing non-Met anticodons are expressed in cells harboring a compatible plasmid carrying a target protein gene with a complementary non-Met initiation codon. As in the nonsense suppression assay, dihydrofolate reductase has usually been used as the target protein; however, the gene has been altered to encode six additional
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
29
amino-terminal amino acids fused to the second amino acid of the wild-type protein (Fig. 1).Anticodon derivatives of tRNAfMetinitiate DHFR synthesis in this system (see below) and produce biologically active proteins that retain the initiating amino acid ( 6 7 ~ )The . amino-terminal amino acid is identified by protein sequencing to determine the amino-acid-acceptor specificity of the tRNA. An advantage of this system is that anticodon mutants of tRNAfM” are not toxic to cells, because they are unable to participate in polypeptide chain elongation (68,69). However, it remains to be determined whether this assay will be useful for all non-Met amino acids, and to what extent the structure of the tRNA outside of the anticodon can be altered without complete loss of its initiator function. A second potentially useful in uiuo assay now being explored is the use of frameshift-suppressor tRNAs having eight-membered anticodon loops to translate four-base codons near the amino terminus of the target protein. Several such tRNAs are aminoacylated quite efficiently in uitro (70, 71), and many more function as frameshift-suppressor tRNAs in uiuo (72-76). The potential advantages of this system are that any tRNA structure that allows translation can be tested for its effect on tRNA identity in the presence of the wild-type anticodon sequence. The disadvantages include the typically low suppression efficiencies of frameshift tRNAs and the potential of toxic effects caused by frameshifts in essential cellular proteins. Other in uiuo experiments could provide useful information on tRNA identity. Mutant elongator tRNAs that contain the presumed recognition elements and the known anticodon sequence of a noncognate tRNA could be expressed in uiuo and the effect on cell growth determined. Normal growth should be observed if the tRNA has been completely converted to a new identity. A more stringent test of such an “identity swap” would be complementation of cells in which the chromosomal gene(s) for the original tRNA has been inactivated. The latter is the only kind of in uiuo experiment that addresses the issue of aminoacylation efficiency as well as specificity. Such studies have not yet been attempted, and might fail in any case due to effects of the mutant tRNA on cell growth unrelated to tRNA identity.
111. Role of the Anticodon As was pointed out early in the study of tRNA recognition (77), the anticodon is the most logical site to specify the amino acid to be coupled to a tRNA, since this would directly link aminoacylation to the genetic code. Despite considerable evidence in favor of anticodon recognition for a number of tRNAs (reviewed in 5), the importance of the anticodon was not widely accepted until quite recently. Indeed, some current textbooks still state that the anticodon is not a recognition element for tRNAs (78).Arguments against
30
LADONNE H . SCHULMAN
the involvement of the anticodon in tRNA recognition were largely based on early studies of nonsense suppressors derived from Gln, Leu, Ser, and Tyr tRNAs, which insert the correct amino acid despite the presence of singlebase changes in the anticodon. Nevertheless, one of the first amber suppressor tRNAs studied, su +7 tRNATw containing a CCA-CUA anticodon change, has an ambiguous identity, inserting both Gln and Trp in oiuo (79). Subsequent in oitro studies showed that this single mutation affects recognition of the tRNA by both TrpRS and GlnRS, decreasing interaction with the cognate synthetase and increasing interaction with the noncognate synthetase (80, 81). At about the same time, anticodon base changes generated in oitro were shown to have dramatic effects on the recognition of E. coli tRNAfMef(82,), tRNAArg (83), and yeast tRNAVal(84,), and missense suppressors derived from tRNAC1y were found to be highly defective in aminoacylation by E. coli GlyRS (27,28). These early results were just a prelude of things to come. Kisselev presented an extensive review of the literature on anticodon recognition in this series in 1985 (5). I will attempt to summarize here the' data obtained in the following 5 years, with emphasis on E . coli tRNAs, which have been the focus of many of the recent investigations.
A. Anticodon Recognition in E. coli tRNAs 1. In Vitro STUDIES
Tables I1 and I11 summarize the effects of anticodon base changes on the recognition of tRNAs by cognate and noncognate synthetases in oitro. Significant reductions in the efficiency of aminoacylation of E. coli tRNAs specific for Arg, Gly, Ile, Met, Phe, Thr, Trp, Tyr, and Val result from base changes in the anticodon. The magnitude of the effect varies with the particular synthetase, and may be related to the total number of recognition elements in a given tRNA. MetRS and ThrRS also strongly protect the anticodons of their cognate tRNAs from chemical modification and nuclease attack (85, 86). Even stronger evidence for the role of the anticodon in recognition of tRNAs by specific synthetases is obtained when mischarging occurs in an anticodon-dependent manner. Substitution of the anticodons of noncognate tRNAs with anticodons corresponding to those of E . coli tRNAs for Arg, Met, Thr, and Val leads to increases of 104 to lo6 in mischarging by the corresponding synthetases (Table 111). In addition, 103- and 105-fold increases in the efficiency of mischarging of tRNAfMefand tRNATrpby E. coli GlnRS are observed when the wild-type anticodons of these tRNAs are replaced with the amber anticodon CUA. The efficiency of aminoacylation of noncognate tRNAs containing Met and Val anticodons by MetRS and ValRS is similar to that of the corresponding cognate tRNAs, suggesting that the
TABLE I1 EFFECT OF ANTICODONBASE CHANGESON in Vitro RECOGNITIONOF tRNAs Apparent Organism
tRNA".'
Anticodon"
K, (CLW
keJ
E. coli
.41a, Ala,
2.2 ND
1.oe ND 1.W
Yeast
Ala,
VIGC (wt) G G C (wt) CUA IGC (wt) IGU AGC GGC GGCC GC ICG (wt) IUG G U C (wt)
E.coli
A%,
Yeast
Asp"
E. coli E. coli
Glu
Gly I
uuc AUC U8UC (wt) UUA U8UU
2.9
0.039 0.326 0.250
0.7~ 0.035e 0.036<
ccc (wt)
ucu ucc
1.0 ND 1.4 1.0 Active Active Active Active Active 1.0 Inactive 1.0 0.006 0.008
Comments
Reference 36 36
Also U, + A,
36 87 88 88 89 89 83 1
1 1
Also C,2+U32
90 91 92 93
1.0
u * c c (wt) GCC (wt) GCA
Relative specificitye or activity
Active Inactive 1.0 Slightly reduced rate Slightly reduced rate
cccc Gly,
COGNATESYNTHETASES~
1.0
CUC Gly,
BY
0.16 1.3
1.Of 0.005r
Relative rate 10-4 1.0 6 x 10-4 Normal activity
Also A,+tGA,, Also A,7-+ms2i6A,7
27 28 28 27
(continued)
TABLE I1 (Continued) Apparent Organism
tRNAb.c
E . coli
Ile,c
E . coli
Mek MeV
Anticodon
K, (PM)
kef
1
GCU GUC C7AU CAU CAU (wt) CAU (wt) UAU AAU GAU
ccu cuu
E . coli
Met,,, Met,”
Yeast
Met,&
E. coli
Pheb
Yeast
Phe
CAG CAC CUA c 4 A u (wt) CAU CAU UAU GAU CCG GGU UAC CAU (wt)
5.7
0 . W
0.6
1.w
1.1 >100 >100 2.9 >100 >100
1.Of
0.030
Comments
Reduced rate
Mixture of species
1.0 Greatly reduced rate 1.0 1.0
lo-‘ 0.0001f
10-5 4 x 10-5 10-5 10-7
ccu
GAA (wt) AAA CUA GBAA (wt)
Relative specificityg or activity
1.Of
1.0 0.002 1.0 <0.01 Greatly reduced activity 1.00
Reference
94 95
96 96 96 96 96 96 96 96 96 97 98 98 43 18, 43 18, 43 100 18, 44 18, 43
j
k k 101
E . coli
Thr
GAA GAC GAU GCA GUA AAA CAA UAA UGU (wt)
0.043 0.121 0.071 0.104
0.118 0.306 0.250
0.217
1.5f 0.W
0.9w 0.46-f 0.42f 0.84f 0.77f 1.Wf
ucu CUA
E . coli
Trp
Bovine Liver
Trp
E . coli
TYr Tyrb
Yeast
TYr TyrC
CCA (wt) CUA C3CA (wt) U3CA C3UA QUA (wt) CUA GUA (wt) GGA GJlA (wt) GJlA (wt) UJlA CJlA AJlA GUA GCA GAA CUA CCA
0.13 7.7
5.0 8.2 0.32 5.0 0.054
0.052 0.27 0.23 0.55 0.096 0.34 0.43
0.53 2.50
l.W 0.1s
20.50 1.4~ 1.Of 0.076-f 1.W 0.98.f 0.71f 0.48f 0.80f 0.9of 0.72f 0.57f 0.27f 0.1w
1.06 0.24 0.42 0.13 0.11 0.08 0.09 0.14 1.0 Greatly reduced activity Greatly reduced activity 1.0 0.0025 1.0 Inactive Active 1.0 0.043 1.0 0.005 1.0 1.0 0.14 0.11 0.08 0.49 0.11 0.07 0.05 0.01
Also Y,,+G,, Also Y,,+G,, Also Y,,+G,, Also Y,,+G,, Also Y,,+G, Also Y,,+G,, Also Y,,-*G,, Also Y3,-+G3,
101 101 101 101 101 101 101 101
UCU more defective than CUA in oioo
102 102 80
80 103 103 59 59 lOla lOla 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 (continued)
TABLE I1 (Continued) ~~~
Organism
tRNA6.C
E. coli
Val, b
Yeast
Val,
An ticodon UUA UCA UAC (wt) CAU IAC (wt) IAU
Apparent K , (W) 1.10 2.50 1.0 <90
kef 0.51f 0.1w 1.Of
Relative specificityg or activity 0.07
Comments
Reference 104
0.015
104
1.0 10-5
43 43
1.0 Inactive
84
aZn oitro assays have been carried out with native tRNAs unless otherwise indicated. See also footnote a, Table I. wt, wild type. ND, not determined. btRNA in oitro transcript. CAnticudon change introduced using T4 RNA ligase. dMinor bases in anticodons are indicated using the abbreviations of Sprinzl et al. (112) as follows: V1 = uridine-Soxyacetic acid; U8 = 5-methylaminomethyl-2-thiouridine; C7 = lysidine = Nz-(5-amino-5carboxypentyl)cytidine; C4 = N,-acetylcytidine; G 3 = 2'-O-methylguanosine; C3 = 2'-0methylcytidine; U3 = 2'-O-methyluridine. U* in Gly,(U*CC) is an unknown modified U. ekcat (sec-1). fRelative V,=. gRatio of k,/K,,, or V,,/Y, values for mutant versus wild-type tRNAs. hRelative rate at 40 nM tRNA. See (71)and (155) for additional anticodon mutants of E. coli tRNAWc'. 'A. Garcia and R. Giege, unpublished. j F. Fasiolo, personal communication. kE. F. Tinkle and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, unpublished.
RECOGNITION OF
35
tRNAs
TABLE 111 ANTICODON-DEPENDENT RECOGNITIONOF NONCOCNATE tRNAs in Vitro" ~
Organism
tRNALc
E. coli
Arglb (cognate) Met,"
E . coli
Gln, (cognate) Metflr Met,,
Gln,
+ Gln,
(cognate)
Trr,
E. coli
Met, (cognate) Val," Trp" Phe Ile,c
Yeast
E. coli
Phe (cognate) Tvr< Thr," (cognate) Met,"
Yeast
Tyrr (cognate) Phec
E. coli
Val," (cognate) Met,"
Anticodon" CCGl CAU-CCG CAU CUG CAU+CUA CAU CAU-CUA U*UG, CUG CCA-CUA CCA CAU UAC-CAU UAC CCA-CAU CCA GAA-CAU C7AU-+CAU C7AU G3AA GJIAjGAA GGU
CAU-r G G U CAU GW GAA-rCUA UAC CA U-* UAC UAU CAU
Apparent Relative K, ( p M ) V,
1.1 5.2
1.0 0.015
0.12 2.2 >100
1.0 0.05
0.19 6.7
1.0 0.21
0.6 1.2 >loo 2.9
1.0 1.9 0.1
>loo
0.093 1.20 2.50 0.20 0.9
1.0 0.015 0.002 1.0 0.03
1.0 5.0
1.0 0.5
Relative specificity' or activity 1.0 3.3 X 0.8 x 10-7 1.0 2.8 X 10-3 2 x 10-6 4.6 X 1.0 5.9 x 10-3 <10-7 1.0 1.0 1.5 X 10-6 2 x 10-2 2 x 10-6 Normal activity Active Inactive 1.0 1.2 x 10-3 0.7 x 10-4 1.0 7 x 10-3 7 x 10-7 1.0 Increased activity 1.0 0.1
4 x 10-5 5 x 10-6
Reference 100 100 100
97 97 97 69 80 80 80 43 43 43 g
g
h 95 95 105 105
105 44 44 44 106
43 43 43 43
eAs in Table I1 footnotes. Noncognate tRNAs are from the same organism as cognate tRNAs. &Asin Table I1 footnotes. cAs in Table I1 footnotes. "As in Table I1 footnotes. e[ V,,,,/K,, ]noncognate/[ V,,IK,,,]cognate. /The wild-type anticodon for tRNAPg is ICG. EL. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, unpublished. JIB. Bahramian, C. P. Lee and U. L. RajBhandary, unpublished.
36
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
anticodon is the dominant recognition element for these synthetases. Other mutant tRNAs are aminoacylated less efficiently than the wild-type species, suggesting that important recognition elements are also to be found outside of the anticodon (see Sections IV and V).
2. In Viuo STUDIES In uiuo data also provide strong evidence of the important role of the anticodon in the recognition of cognate tRNAs and discrimination against noncognate tRNAs by E. coli synthetases. Abelson, Miller, and co-workers have constructed genes for amber suppressor derivatives of tRNAs specific for all of the amino acids not represented in the original collection of genetically derived amber suppressors, and have tested their amino-acid-acceptor specificity in the amber suppression assay described earlier (52, 53, 107, 108). Of the 16 different tRNAs tested that were active in translation, nine were mischarged (Table IV). Amber suppressor derivatives of Asp, Ilel, Ile2, Met,, and Val tRNAs did not insert their cognate amino acids in uiuo, while derivatives of Arg,, Glu, Gly,, and Thrz partially retained their original identity. Additional genetic experiments also strongly support a role for the anticodon in the recognition of threonine tRNAs by E. coli ThrRS (102,109111). All of the completely or partially mischarged amber suppressor tRNAs accepted either Lys or Gln (Table IV), indicating the importance of the anticodon for the in uiuo recognition of tRNAs by LysRS and GlnRS as well. Although it is tempting to conclude that the anticodon is not important for in uiuo recognition of the other nine amber suppressor tRNAs that specifically retain their original identity, this conclusion is incorrect. Use of anticodon derivatives of tRNAfMet in the initiation assay described earlier shows anticodon-dependent mischarging of this tRNA by synthetases specific for Ile, Phe, and Val (Table V). Phe is one of the tRNAs that retain their identity as an amber suppressor. The importance of anticodon base A3, (Fig. 2) in the recognition of tRNAs by PheRS is shown by the high level of insertion of Phe by tRNAf Met containing the wild-type Phe anticodon GAA, and the absence of Phe in protein initiated by tRNAfMet containing the closely related GAU,, and GAC,, anticodons. The amber suppressor derivative of tRNAPheretains A3, in the amber anticodon CUA,, and this partially accounts for the retention of Phe identity by this tRNA. A3, is not sufficient to specify Phe, however, since other derivatives of tRNAfMet that contain A3, insert no Phe (67a). Sites outside of the anticodon also contribute to the identity of E. coli tRNAPhe (see Section V,C). The apparent paradox of the retention of Phe identity by tRNAPhe(CUA)and recognition of all three Phe anticodon bases by PheRS is resolved by the following scenario: tRNAPhe(CUA)retains suffi-
ON
TABLE IV EFFECTOF THE AMBER ANTICODON CUA THE MISCHARGING OF E . coli tRNAs in Vioo" Partially mischarged
Mischargedb AspMe Ile, (748)f (16%)r Ile,. Metme Val,e
(a).
Arg (55%)p G h A (17%)f,g Gly, (37%)J Met,$ Thr, (86%). su+7 Trpd
Not mischargedd A h CYS Gln, (su+2) GlY, HisA Leu, (su+6) LYs Phe ProH Ser (su+l) Tyr (su+3)
OBased on the insertion of amino acids into position 10 of DHFR-amber unless otherwise indicated. All of the tRNAs conU,,, tain a CUA anticodon. In addition, AspM contains A, A,, . U,, and A,; Ala,, GluA, and HisA contain A,; and ProH contains residues 1-26 and 44-76 from tRNAproand residues 27-43 from tRNAPhe(CUA).The suppressor tRNAs are derived from the following wild-type tRNAs: Ile,, tRNA:"(GAU); Ile,, tRNAp(C,AU); Val, tRNA?'(U*AC); Arg, tRNAtrp(ICG); Gly,, tRNA?''(CCC); Gly,, tRNAglY(U*CC); Thr,, tRNAThr(UCU), Ala,, tRNA;'"(GGC); Gln,, tRNAg'"(CUG); Leu, tRNAp(U*AA); ProH, tRNAPro(CGG);Ser, tRNA,s"(CCA). The effect of changes in base modifications, if any, have not been assessed. All tRNAs were overproduced except Al%, Gly,, HisA, and Trp. Data for AI%, AspM, GluA, Gly,, Gly,, HisA, Ile,, Ilez, Lys, Met,,,, ProH, Thr,, and Val are from 107 and 108. Data for Arg is from 55; for Cys and Phe, from 52; for Gln,, Leu,, and Ser, from 26; for Tyr, from 59; and for Trp, from 79-81. Mischarging of Metf with Gln is based on in oitro (97, 69) and in oioo (113) data. No data are presented for Asn, which is inactive as an amber suppressor tRNA. U* in the anticodon of tRNAy" is uridine-5-oxyacetic acid, and in the anticodon of tRNA:IY and t R N A p is an unknown modified U. bMischarging is at least 95% based on DHFR-amber sequence analysis. "Partially mischarged tRNAs insert a mixture of cognate and noncognate amino acids into DHFR-amber. The percentage of noncognate amino acid inserted is indicated; however, it should be noted that this value does not necessarily correspond to the percentage of in oiuo mischarging. For example, tRNATrP(CUA)inserts 90% Gln, 10%Trp, but is charged equally with Gln and Trp in oioo (81). dLess than 5% of any other amino acid inserted into DHFR-amber. eMischarged with Lys. fMischarged with Gln. EAlso 6% Tyr and 6% Arg.
38
LADONNE A 76 C C
A I
3
.-. .-.
Acceptor stem D loop .''A
G
G
.-.
0
72
"Discriminotor"
70
.-.-. . . . . cT loop. 6.0
. D stem .-. .-.
T S .*45
.-.
*
.-.
30--*40
U
!b
I '
I?.
25'
0'2
n. SCIIULMAN
. . 35
Variable loop
A
3' end
1
Acceptor stem
Anticodon stem
w
Anticodon
FIG. 2. (A) Cloverleaf structure of a typical class-I tRNA, numbered according to 112. Bases conserved in all E . coli tRNAs are indicated. (B) Three-dimensional structure of yeast tRNAPhe (1, 2).
cient recognition elements to be aminoacylated by PheRS in uiuo (undoubtedly with significantly reduced efficiency). The amber suppressor tRNA is overproduced several hundred fold (52, 53), partially compensating for its lower affinity for PheRS; the level of charged tRNAPhe(CUA)is sufficient for translation of the relatively low concentration of UAG codons in the in uiuo suppression assay; and tRNAPhe(CUA)is a poor substrate for GlnRS and LysRS due to the presence of negative elements outside of the anticodon which prevent mischarging by these synthetases. Isoacceptor Val tRNAs contain either U or G at position 34 of the anticodon. The remaining two anticodon bases, A, and c36, are critical for in uiuo recognition of tRNAs by ValRS, since tRNAfMefcontaining the anticodon GAC,, inserts only Val, while tRNAfMet(GAU3&and tRNAfMCt (GC,,C) insert no detectable Val (Table V; 67a). A summary of key anticodon bases for in uiuo recognition of tRNAfMetand nonsense suppressor tRNAs by different synthetases derived by analyses of this kind is included in Table VI. It should be noted that the in uiuo data obtained by both the nonsense suppression and initiation assays are in excellent agreement with in uitro data, where available.
RECOGNITION OF
tHNAs
39
TABLE V ANTICODON-DEPENDENT MISCHARCINC OF E. coh tRNAfMetin Viuoa tRNAfMet anticodonb
Cognate amino acid.
GAU GAA GAC CUA
Ile Phe Val
-
Amino acid inserted Ile (>90%) Phe (>90%) Val (>90%) Gln (ND)
aBased on the insertion of amino acids into position 1 of pseudo-lacZ (Phe and Val; 67) or position 1 of DHFR-start (Ile; L. Pallanck and L. H. Schulman, 67a). tRNAfMetGAU, GAA, and GAC anticodon derivatives were expressed in oioo at a level comparable to that of endogenous tRNAs. tRNAfMet(CUA)was overproduced in oioo and was shown to initiate protein synthesis from a UAG codon at the start site of the chloramphenicul-acetyltransferasegene. The protein was not sequenced; however, complementary in oitro experiments showed that Gln was inserted by the tRNA (113). ND, Not determined. hChanges in base modifications have not been assessed. CAmino acid corresponding to the anticodon in the mutant tRNAfMet.
As illustrated by the example of Phe, it is not safe to assume that anticodon recognition is unimportant for the other amber suppressor tRNAs that retain their identity in oioo. Several such tRNAs, in addition to Phe, retain one or more bases present in the wild-type anticodon: Cys, As6; His, U3,+ and Tyr, U3,A3,. In uitro studies show that U,, is a recognition element for TyrRS (101~). However, it is likely that amber suppressor tRNAs that retain their identity have important recognition elements outside of the anticodon, and they may also contain negative elements for GlnRS and LysRS. Direct investigation of the effects of base changes at each site of the anticodon on the efficiency of aminoacylation by cognate synthetases will be required to determine the role of the anticodon in recognition of these tRNAs. Such experiments have been carried out only on tRNAA1"(36).This tRNA requires no specific anticodon bases for recognition by AlaRS (Table 11). The recognition of five Ser tRNAs containing different anticodon sequences by a single E. coli SerRS also suggests that the anticodon plays no role in the recognition of tRNAs by this enzyme. Table VI summarizes current knowledge on the role of the anticodon in recognition of specific E. coli tRNAs.
40
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
ROLE OF
TABLE VI ANTICODON IN THE RECOGNITIONOF E. coli tRNAs BY E . coli AMINOACYL-tRNA SYNTHETASES~
THE
~
Anticodon recognized ‘4% Gln GlY Ile LYs Met Phe Thr Trp TYr Val
~~~~~~~
An ticodon recognition elements
,Y
c,
’
u,
’
G,
G5 c36 ’
b
usc C, A,. G , . A,.
U, A,
Unknown Asn Aspd CYS Glud His Leu Pro
Anticodon not recognized Ala Sere
c3-5 u, ’
Cmc urnc ‘43-5
’
c,
‘See Tales II-V, XIV, and XV for references. Anticodon-dependent insertion of an amino acid in t h o and/or in oitro aminoacylation studies have been used to assign the E. coli tRNAs that contain recognition eleY in Gln is assigned on the basis of the X-ray ments in the anticodon. , crystal structure of the tRNAC’” GlnRS complex and unpublished data of M. Jahn and D. SOIL b Anticodon recognition sites are unknown. CAdditional anticodon recognition sites may exist. dThe anticodon is required for in oioo identity (107, 108). Data on recognition are unclear. eSerine isoacceptor tRNAs contain base changes at all three positions of the anticodon; therefore, the anticodon probably does not contain recognition elements for SerRS, but this has not been directly determined.
3. E. coli METHIONINESYNTHETASE
The strongest evidence that the anticodon contains the major determinants for recognition of tRNAs by a synthetase comes from the case of E. coli MetRS (43, 82, 96-100). An extensive set of mutants of both tRNAfMetand tRNAMet shows that all three anticodon bases are required for efficient aminoacylation by the cognate synthetase, with the largest effects seen at C, in the “wobble” position (Table 11). In addition, transfer of the Met anticodon to E. coli tRNAVa’, tRNAPhe, or tRNA&Ieleads to efficient mischarging of these tRNAs by MetRS (Table 111). The importance of C, for in oioo recognition of Met tRNAs is illustrated by the loss of Met insertion by tRNAfMefon substitution of G,AU for the normal C,AU anticodon (Table V) and partial retention of Met identity by tRNAfMethaving the anticodon C,,CA (67a).
41
tRNAs
RECOGNITION OF
Comparison of the primary sequences of tRNAs efficiently aminoacylated by MetRS shows that, aside from the conserved bases in all E. coli tRNAs, only the anticodon bases are common (Fig. 3). However, examples of small effects of sequence changes at other sites have been observed. For example, transfer of the Met anticodon to E. coli tRNATv increases the specificity for aminoacylation (V/K,,,)of this tRNA by MetRS 15,00-fold, but is still l/50th of that of wild-type Met tRNAs (Table VII). A conversion of G,, to A,, in tRNATv(CAU) increases V / Y , 10-fold, and an additional change from G,-C,, to C3eG70 raises the activity of the tRNA to that of cognate Met tRNAs. Independent studies of the role of base 73 in aminoacylation of tRNAfMet have shown that A,, is not a recognition element for MetRS (Table VII; 30). Substitutions at this site lead to only small (two- to three-fold) changes in Vma, in the order A,, > U,, > C,,, C,,. Since A and U share no functional groups, direct positive contacts between MetRS and base 73 are unlikely. U,, is also found in bacteriophage T5 tRNAfMet, which is expected to be aminoacylated by MetRS in oioo. We conclude that G,, is a negative ele-
TABLE VII AMINOACYLATION OF tRNAs WITH E . coli MetRS ~~
~~~
tRNA Transcripts"
V (pnol /min/mg)
VlY,
1.1 1.2 1.2
1.9 1.5 1.5
1.7 1.3 1.3
1.4 2.9 >lo0 >loo
0.7 0.08 -
0.5 0.03 2 x 10-6 2 x 10-6
Apparent K , (pM)
tRNA,Met(CAU) tRNAval(CAU) tRNATrP(CAU)G,,+A,, + G, ' C7n+C3 G7n tRNATrP(CAU)G7,+A7, tRNATrP(CAU) tRNATrP(CCA) t RNAVal(UAC)
Relative VIK,
9 x 105 7 x 105 7 x 105
'
Apparent
K, ( W M )
Native tRNAs6 tRNAf'Met(CAU)A7, tRNAfMPt(CAU)A7,+ U, c'73 c73
1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1
-
2 x 105 0.15 X 105 1 1
Relative Vmax
Extent of aminoacylation (96)
1.0
100 99 57 48
0.64
0.36 0.34
OtRNAs were prepared by in oitro transcription. Data are from 43 and from L. H . Schulman and H. Pelka, unpublished. btRNAs were prepared by the addition of N7,CCA-OH to tRNAfMPtmissing the four 3'-terminal nucleotides using T4 RNA ligase (30).
42
n. SCHULMAN
LADONNE
76
0
0 0
0
10-0 0-0 0 - 0 ' 0
0-0 0 - 0 0-0
60
0-0 o
m
0
0
0
O
0 0
0
50
e e . 0 O
0
00.00
0 .
I I I I
0
.
I I I I I
10 0
0
0.0.0
0
0
0
0
20
0 - 0 0 - 0 0-•
30
-
40
0-0 0
0
35
FIG. 3. Composite structure of tRNAs aminoacylated by E. coli MetRS with kinetics similar (within a factor of 2 or 3) to cognate E. coli Met tRNAs (24, 114-117 and B. L. Seong, C. P. Lee and U.L. RajBhandary, unpublished). Open circles indicate the sites of bases conserved in most or all class-I E. coli tRNAs (see Fig. 2). A21 is also conserved in all class-I tRNAs except tRNAcYs. Letters indicate the positions of other conserved bases. Arrowheads indicate the positions of known major recognition elements. Dots indicate the positions of sequence variation. Small dots indicate sites where two different bases have been found; medium dots, where two unbonded bases that share no functional groups or three different bases have been found; large dots, where all four bases have been found. In addition, the size of the D-loop can vary from seven to nine nucleotides, the variable loop can contain four or five nucleotides, and a base-pair is not required at position 1.72 and several other internal sites. Base modifications have been ignored in compiling the composite.
RECOGNITION OF
tHNAs
43
ment for MetRS, which somewhat weakens interaction with noncognate tRNAs having this base. This could be particularly important to maintain fidelity in cases like that of wild-type tRNATrp, which has C , in the anticodon. The magnitude of the negative effect on MetRS produced by G,, is seen to vary with the tRNA context, being greater in tRNATq than in tRNAfMct(Table VII). The small effect (three- to four-fold) of the base-pair change at position 3.70 is also a context effect. C,*G,, is found in E. coli tRNAVa', which is efficiently charged by MetRS (Table VII) and A,.U,, is also an acceptable sequence at this site in tRNAfMet(B. L. Seong, C. P. Lee and U. L. RajBhandary, unpublished). As different nucleotides are functional at all sites outside of the anticodon (Fig. 3), the anticodon bases contain all of the base-specific recognition elements for E. coli MetRS. Functional groups shared by two different nucleotide bases could emerge as additional recognition elements at other sites.
B. Anticodon Recognition in Yeast tRNAs Much less information is available on the role of the anticodon in the recognition of yeast tRNAs. Tables I1 and I11 summarize the effect of anticodon base substitutions on the recognition of cognate and noncognate tRNAs by yeast Ala, Asp, Met, Phe, Tyr, and Val synthetases. In considering these data, it should be realized that, in general, yeast synthetases discriminate less well than E. coli synthetases between cognate and noncognate tRNAs. E. coli synthetases commonly show a specificity for aminoacylation of cognate tRNAs of 105 to 108, while yeast synthetases select cognate tRNAs with a specificity closer to 1W to lo6. The contribution of individual recognition elements, including those in the anticodon, to overall specificity is thus expected to be significantly lower for the yeast enzymes. Strong effects (>1O2) of single anticodon base changes on the recognition of cognate yeast tRNAs have been observed for yeast Asp, Met, and Val synthetases. Genetic studies have also implicated the anticodon as a recognition element for yeast MetRS (119). Single-base changes in the anticodons of yeast tRNAPhe and tRNATyr decrease the efficiency of aminoacylation by the cognate synthetase in uitro; however, the magnitude of the effect of such changes on recognition by these enzymes is much smaller, in the range of 3- to 14-fold (Table 11). Nevertheless, the effects of individual base substitutions are roughly additive, creating large effects on activity in tRNAs containing multiple mutations. In addition, the anticodon bases compose a significant part of the overall recognition set, at least in the case of tRNAPhc(see Section V, B), and switching the anticodons of tRNAPhe and tRNATyr leads to increased mischarging by the corresponding noncognate synthetase (Table 111).
44
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
Base changes in the anticodon of yeast tRNAAla have little or no effect on the recognition by yeast AlaRS, as was observed for the E. coli Ala synthetase.
C . Summary The anticodons of 11E . coli tRNAs clearly contain one or more important recognition elements for cognate synthetases, and it is likely that this number will increase. In addition, two other E. coli tRNAs have been shown to have identity elements in the anticodon. Although the anticodon is not required for the recognition of tRNAAIa,and possibly tRNASer,these and all other E. coli tRNAs probably contain identity elements in the anticodon that are crucial for the discrimination of cognate and noncognate tRNAs by synthetases in uiuo. Where information is available, yeast tRNAs follow a similar pattern to that observed in E. coli. Thus, it is expected that many eukaryotic tRNAs have retained essential recognition elements in the anticodon as well, as directly demonstrated for bovine tRNATm (103).
IV. Role of the Acceptor Stem and the ”Discriminator” Base at Position 73 Aside from the anticodon, the region of tRNA structure most frequently implicated in synthetase recognition is the domain adjacent to the 3’-terminal CCA sequence, containing the first 3 bp of the acceptor stem (positions 1.72, 2.71, and 3.70) and the fourth base from the 3’ end (position 73) (Fig. 2). The latter base has been suggested to be a universal “discriminator” site that assists synthetases in sorting tRNA substrates (120);the acceptor stem has been postulated to be the site of the earliest recognition elements in the evolution of tRNAs (121).
A. Alanine Synthetases Among E. coli tRNAs, the acceptor stem contains recognition elements for Ala, Gln, His, and Ser, and this region has been implicated in recognition by several other synthetases. The most dramatic results have been obtained with Ala tRNAs, in which a single G,*U, base-pair is a major recognition element for AlaRS both in uiuo (35, 54) and in uitro (35, 36, 59). Amber suppressor tRNA derivatives of Ala tRNAs undergo a large loss of activity on conversion of G,-U,, to a standard Watson-Crick base-pair or on substitu-
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
45
tion of a U,*G,, sequence (Table VIII). In addition, transfer of the G,.U,, base-pair to amber suppressor derivatives of tRNAPhe, tRNAcys, and tRNALys converts each of these tRNAs into efficient Ala-inserting tRNAs. The mutant Cys and Lys tRNAs insert only Ala; however, tRNAPhe (CUA)G,-U,, inserts both Ala and Phe, indicating that PheRS can still recognize the mutant tRNAPhe. Mutations at several additional sites (Table VIII) lead to almost complete conversion of the identity of tRNAPheto that of Ala. This could result from a more favorable interaction of the altered tRNA with AlaRS and/or a less favorable interaction with PheRS. McClain et al. (56) have shown that sequences other than G,*U,O allow the insertion of Ala into protein by tRNAAIa(CUA)with low efficiency. Some of these sequences contain neither G, nor UT0. These workers have therefore suggested that a "helix irregularity," rather than a specific sequence at position 3.70, is recognized by AlaRS. However, in uitro data argue that some feature of the G,.U,, basepair is specifically recognized, as no activity is observed with tRNAs containing G,*C,; A,*U70, or U,'G70 using high concentrations of purified enzyme (Table IX). A minihelix consisting of the acceptor and T-stems of tRNAAla plus the unmodified T-loop (Fig. 4) is aminoacylated with a specificity only a fifth of that of the native tRNA, indicating that this truncated RNA contains the major determinants for recognition by AlaRS (122).A microhelix containing only the acceptor stem and a seven-membered loop is aminoacylated with a fiftieth of the specificity of the intact tRNA, indicating loss of contacts that improve both binding and the efficiency of aminoacylation. In uitro footprinting of the tRNAAla.AlaRScomplex show that the enzyme protects phosphates in the acceptor stem on the 3' side of residues 64-70 from nuclease attack (123).Base changes at positions 1.72, 2.71, 5.68, 6.67, and 7.66 in the acceptor stem, and 49.65, 50.64, and 51-63 in the T$C-stem allowed insertion of Ala by tRNA$'"(CUA) in uiuo (35),indicating that none of these sites is essential for recognition by AlaRS. In addition, base-pairs 5-68, 6-67, 7.66, 49.65, 50.64, and 51-63 are not conserved in amber suppressor derivatives of B. mori and human tRNAAla,which are efficiently aminoacylated by E . coli AlaRS in uitro and insert only Ala into DHFR-amber in E. coli (60).It has been suggested that bases 16, 17, 20, and 60 play a role in Ala identity (54); however, these bases are not conserved in the B. mori and human Ala tRNAs. In addition, the low levels (4-6%) of insertion of Lys brought about by mutations at these sites in E. coli tRNAAla(CUA)would very likely be blocked by the presence of a wild-type Ala anticodon containing G,,, making the significance of the Lys mischarging unclear. Sites outside of the acceptor and T-stems are likely to be involved in Ala identity by making negative contacts with noncognate synthetases.
TABLE VIII
EFFECTOF MUTATIONSON THE RECOGNITIONOF tRNAs in Vioo BY E . coh AlaRs tRNA ( a n t i d o n change)
tRNAtL"(GGC)+(CUA)
tRNAPhe(GAA+(CUA)
Additional mutations
Amino acid inserted
(%)a
Ala, 96 Ala, 18; Lys, 29; Gln, 44 Ala, 89 Ala, 55; Lys, 29; Gln, 6 Ala, 83;Gln, 12 Ala, 90 Ala, 75; Lys, 12 Ala, 97
Phe, 100 Ala. 24; Phe, 76 Ala, 63; Phe, 37. Ala, 96; Lys, 4
Suppression efficiency ( % ) b . c 4.126 0.076 0.636 0.3Qb 0.556 0.36h
0.22" 21c Inactive' Inactivec Very weakly activec 12= 786d 106
ND 146
tRNACys(GCA+(CUA)
None c3
tRNAL~5(U,,UU+(CUA)
'
G70*G3
'
u70
None G3
. C70+G3
.
G3 . AiO A3 c i o '
tRNAz'Y(U*CC+(CUA)
None G , C,O+G, None None '
tRNATYr(QUA+(CUA)
u3
3
'
U7"
.
'
7 '0
u3 .
'
7 '0
(1 X (17 x (1 X (17 X
AlaRS)
AlaRS) AlaRS) AlaRS)
CYS Ala, > 9 Y
Xbd
LYS, 94 Ala, 94 Ala, 39; Lys, 49 Ala, 22; Lys, 69 Gly, 16; Gln, 84
31" 34" 1.66
Gly, 5; Gln, 95 Tyr onlyf Tyr onlyf Tyr, 95; Gln, 5.f Ala, 95; Gln, Y
ND
3.6" 24
3" ND ND ND ND
"Insertion into DHFR-amber. The percentage of each amino acid at position 10 is given. Note that this may not correspond to the percentage of aminoacylation of the tRNA in oioo. All tRNAs were overproduced. See Table 11, footnote d, for the definition of anticodon minor bases. bSuppression of the amber allele A,, in the hcZ-Z fusion gene (52). Data are from 56 unless otherwise noted. See this reference for additional mutants. (125). Data are from 35. cSuppression of TrpA(UAG,) dData are from 52. eData are from 35. /Data are from 59.
48
LADONNE
n. SCHULMAN
FIG.4. (A) Structures of E . coli tRNAf", minihelix*la, microhelixAla, and minihelixTYr. Base changes from the wild-type sequence are indicated by arrows. (From 8 with permission.) (B) Sites of known major recognition elements in E. cob Ala tRNAs are indicated by arrows.
RECOGNITION OF
49
tRNAs
Retention of very weak Ala-inserting activity by tRNAA1"(CUA)mutants containing non-G,*U7, sequences may indicate the presence of additional weak recognition elements at other sites. Sequestering of low levels of aminoacylated tRNA by EFTu-GTP may also contribute to the in uiuo activity of these mutants. However, it is likely that these weak suppressor tRNAs would show no measurable in uiuo activity if they were not significantly overproduced. Two nonstandard base-pairs, G3eA70 and A3C70, also lead to the insertion of low levels of Ala by tRNALYs(CUA)(56), suggesting that mismatches at position 3.70 may assist in adapting the structure of a tRNA to the surface of AlaRS in a manner leading to inefficient aminoacylation in the absence of G,*U,,. These results are somewhat reminiscent of those seen in the mischarging of tRNATyr(CUA)acceptor-stem mutants with Gln, where introduction of sequences different from those present in tRNAGln leads to mischarging by GlnRS (see Section IV,C). Several suppressor tRNAs to which the G3.U7, sequence was transferred failed to insert Ala in uiuo, including tRNA,G'y(CUA) and tRNATYr(CUA) (Table VIII). The activity of tRNATyr(CUA)G3-U7,was examined in uitro and found to be a tenth of that of tRNAAIa(Table IX). Comparison of the kinetic
B
I
FIG.4. (cont.)
50
LADONNE
H.
SCHULMAN
TABLE IX AMINOACYLATION OF RNAs WITH E . coli AlaRSO Apparent K, (pM)
RNA
k,,, (SKI)
k , t K
( M - 1 s - 1 x 10-5)
Relative
k,,,lK,,
~~
tRNA:'"(UGC) tRNAf"(CUA) + U3,4+A, tRNATYr(CUA)+ C3G,o-*G,. U7, MinihelixA'a MinihelixTyrC, G7,+G3 . U7, Minihelixc~'C3. G7O+G3 . u70 + U,,+A7, MicrohelixAla tRNA;'"(CUA)G, U,,+G, C, '4, ' G,o '
MinihelixcW, . G7O+G3 MinihelixAlaA7,+ N7,
c70
u70
2.2 2.9 14.0 9.1 8.8 8.8
1.0 1.8 0.6 0.9 0.5 0.3
35.9
0.3 0.078 0.02 No activity at 4-pM tRNA, 20-pM AlaRS No activity at 4-pM tRNA, 20-pM AlaRS No activity at 4-pLM tRNA, 20-pM AlaRS No activity at 2-pM RNA, 0.75-pM AlaRS Rate A,, S- C7, > U,, > G7,
>90
4.5 6.2 0.43 1.0 0.53 0.32
1.0 1.38 0.10 0.22 0.12 0.07
a Data are from 36.59, 122, and 126. The concentration of Ala in the assays is suhsaturating; however, this does not greatly affect the kinetics of aminoacylation by AlaRS (127).
parameters for aminoacylation of the tRNA by TyrRS and AlaRS in uitro and estimates of the endogenous levels of the two synthetases suggested that the intracellular concentration of AlaRS was too low to compete effectively with TyrRS for tRNATYr(CUA)G3.U7,. Elevation of the AlaRS concentration by introducing a plasmid carrying the alas gene resulted in insertion of Ala by the tRNA in uiuo (Table VIII). The failure of tRNA,G'Y(CUA)G,-U,, to insert Ala in uiuo could be due to more favorable interaction of this tRNA with GlnRS (Table VIII) and/or to the presence of negative elements for AlaRS. A missense suppressor derived from wild-type tRNALYs(U*UU)containing a G , ~ C 7 0 ~ G , * U 7mutation 0 was isolated earlier in genetic studies and shown to insert either Gly or Ala in uiuo (124).Suppressor activity is lost when cells containing the mutant tRNA and a temperature-sensitive AlaRS are grown at an intermediate temperature, indicating that Ala is inserted by this tRNALys derivative (F. T. Page1 and E. J. Murgola, unpublished). The mutant Lys tRNA has also been known to accept Ala in uitro. The G3eU70 base-pair was predicted by sequence analysis to be a recognition element for E. coli AlaRS (128,129),as it is uniquely present in Ala tRNAs in E. coli. This structural feature has also been preserved in higher organisms (112).Early studies using reannealed acceptor-stem fragments derived from yeast tRNAAla showed that the acceptor stem contains sufficient information for in uitro aminoacylation by yeast AlaRS (130). The G,.U7, base-pair has recently been shown to be required for in uitro ami-
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
51
noacylation of human and B. mori Ala tRNAs by homologous and heterologous Ala synthetases (60), suggesting that this sequence is an important recognition element for all of the Ala enzymes. Although tRNACys(CUA)G,*U7,inserts only Ala in uiuo, this tRNA was inefficiently aminoacylated by AlaRS in uitro (35).Recent studies (126)indicate that this may be due largely to the presence of U,, in tRNACys. A minihelix containing the acceptor and T-arms of the Cys tRNA plus a change of U,, to A,, was aminoacylated in uitro by AlaRS with a specificity only a third of that of the Ala minihelix, while the U,,-containing minihelix was inactive (Table IX). Substitutions of any other base in place of the wild-type A,, sequence in the Ala minihelix also resulted in a significant reduction in both the rate and extent of aminoacylation, indicating that A,, is also a recognition element for AlaRS (Fig. 4). The effect of changes at A,, appear to be mainly on kcat, while changes at G3.U70 strongly affect both kcat and K,,, (36, 126). A change of A,, to U,, in the amber suppressor derivative of tRNA$Ia has no detectable effect on the identity of the tRNA in uiuo, indicating that G,.U,, is a dominant recognition element for this tRNA (Table VIII).
B. E. coli Serine Synthetase The in uiuo amber suppression assay has been very effectively used to study the structural requirements for recognition of tRNAs by E. coli SerRS. The original identity swap type of experiment was carried out by Normanly et al. (19), inserting 12 base changes into the structure of tRNA,L""(CUA)to convert it into a Ser amber suppressor tRNA (19).Subsequent studies show that only eight of these changes (in addition to the anticodon changes) are required for the Leu-Ser conversion (Fig. 5; 7). Six of the important sites are located near the acceptor end of the tRNA. Four generate sequences conserved in all E. coli Ser tRNAs and bacteriophage T, tRNASer: G,.C,,, G,C,,, and G73. Sequences found at position 3.70 in wild-type Ser tRNAs are either A,.U,, or U,*A,,; however, only A,*U,O brought about the desired conversion to Ser identity, possibly by blocking interaction of the tRNA with LeuRS (7). Thus, position 3.70 contains an identity element, but not necessarily a recognition element for SerRS. Substitution of 2 bp at positions 1-72and 3-70 in tRNASer(CUA)leads to a large loss of Ser suppressor activity and a gain of Gln-inserting activity (61) (Table X). The changes are to sequences important for the recognition of tRNAs by GlnRS (see Section IV,C); however, it is not clear that GlnRS would recognize native tRNAser(U*GA) containing the anticodon base G,, and having the same acceptor-stem mutations. Such a tRNA might retain Ser identity. In addition to the mutations in the acceptor-stem region, the complete conversion of tRNAp(CUA) to a Ser-inserting tRNA required an additional change at position 11.24 in the D-stem (Fig. 5). A C,,*G,4 sequence is found
52
LADONNE
N. SCHULMAN
16
0
0 I
G-C G -C
G
.-. .-.
0 - 0 7 0
0-0 0-0
G 0
O 0 * .
20..
.
p,
@$* ..GO
21
b* ttii;
Yo..
C-G 0 - 0 .-• 30 0 60
-
0-0
\
A
C
A A
e
* 35 U
O
0
35
FIG. 5. (A) Base changes involved in the in oiuo conversion of E. coli tRNAk' identity from Leu to Ser (7, 19). (B) Composite structure of E. coli and bacteriophage T, Ser tRNAs (112). Due to uncertainty in the alignment of the D-stem, this region of the selenocysteineinserting tRNASer has been omitted from the composite (see text). The large variable loop is not conserved in size or sequence. See the legend to Fig. 3 for definition of the symbols.
in T4 tRNASer and all four E. coli Ser tRNAs; however, the Ser tRNA that normally inserts selenocysteine at the site of UGA codons in specific E . coli proteins (131)has unusual D-stem and acceptor-stem structures (132).There are 8 bp in the acceptor stem, followed by two unpaired bases (9 and lo), and a 4-bp D-stem. By the conventional cloverleaf arrangement, the base-pair in the position equivalent to 11.24 in the other Ser tRNAs is a G C sequence, raising questions about the exact role of the 11-24 base-pair in the recognition of tRNAs by SerRS. Three of the five Leu tRNAs contain Cll.G24, suggesting that C - G does not inhibit LeuRS. Thus, structural features other than primary sequence may play a role in the interaction of SerRS with this region of its tRNA substrates. The long variable arm of Ser tRNAs also plays a role in discrimination between cognate and noncognate tRNAs by SerRS (101~). In uitro identity swap experiments designed to convert tRNATyr into a Ser-accepting tRNA suggest that the orientation of the variable arm, rather than its primary sequence, influences the interaction of tRNAs with SerRS. Comparison of the conserved sequences in Ser tRNAs (Fig. 5 ) suggests
RECOGNITION OF
53
tRNAs
TABLE X MUTATIONSAFFECTING in Vivo AMINOACYLATIONOF tRNAs
tRNA tRNA;*''
tRNAp
Amino acid inserted ( % ) c
Mutations" U*AA+CUA All (see Fig. 5) Omit G I . U,,+G, Omit C, G7,+GP Omit G , . C,,+A, Omit A,,+G,, Omit U,, Az4+Cl, VIGA-CUA VIGA+CUA + GI VIGA+CUA + A,
Leu, 99 Ser, 92 Leu, 15; Gln, Leu, 91; Gln, Leu, 72; Gln, Leu, 99 Leu, 38; Gln, Ser only
C,, C,,
, U . G,, '
'
C7z+U, U,O+G,
BY
'
A72
'
C70
78; Ser, < I 9 6; Ser, 20
39; Ser, 16
Gln, >90; Ser, 5-6
SerRSa Suppression efficiency (%)d.e 52-5gd 33-49d 12d 5-9d ll-12d 20-35d 35-48d 47e 47p
UData from t R N A p are from 7 and 19 and from Normanly and Abelson, unpublished. Data for tRNA? are from 61. bunnumbered sequences are anticodon sequences. c h e r t i o n into DHFR-amber at position 10. "Efficiency of suppression of derivatives of locl-Z containing amber mutations at different sites in the locl portion of the fusion gene. tRNAs were overproduced. "Etficiency of suppression at the A,, amber allele of lad-Z. tRNAs were not overproduced.
that there are few other sites outside of the acceptor stem region that could contribute to base-specific recognition by SerRS.
C. E. coli Glutamine Synthetase In addition to important sites in the anticodon, E. coli GlnRS also recognizes key structural features in the acceptor-stem region of tRNA substrates. Early evidence for this came from genetic studies, in which mutants of an amber suppressor Tyr tRNA were isolated that insert Gln at the site of UAG codons in uiuo and accept Gln in uitro (Table XI; 46-52). The first mutation obtained converted A,, to the Gln sequence G,, and led to insertion of Gln, but not Tyr, in uiuo. This mutation has the dual effect of increasing activity with GlnRS and reducing activity with TyrRS (49). Mutations at position 1.72 were subsequently isolated that converted the wild-type Tyr G,.C,, sequence to weak or mismatched base-pairs and led to the insertion of both Tyr and Gln in uiuo. These sequences did not correspond to the Gln sequence U,.A,,, suggesting that an easily disrupted base-pair, rather than a specific primary sequence, favors interaction with GlnRS. This was further suggested by later experiments with an amber suppressor derivative of E. coli tRNAfMet,which contains a C,.A,, mismatch at the 5' terminus and is also a substrate for GlnRS in uitro (97). An A*C mismatch at position 2.71 in
AMINOACYLATION
tRNA tRNA:'"(CUG) tRNAfMet(CAU-&UA)
Additional mutations None None 1'
'
A72+U1 1'
cl
tRNATYr(QUA+CUA)
. . G7?. . G72 +
A73jG73 GI . C 7 p A I . C7, GI - u,, '1
G2
'
'71jAP
'
. 7' 2 . 7' 1 '
tRNATyr(QU A)
OF
'71
G* . u,, Wild-type tRNA
tRNAs
TABLE XI BY E. coli GlnRS in Vioo AND in Vitro" Relative V,,,.J&b
6325 29 9 1 5
In oitro activity Incomplete charging at high [GlnRS] Complete charging at high [GlnRS] Complete charging at high [GlnRS] Complete charging at high [GlnRS] ND Active at high [GlnRS] Inactive at high [GlnRS] Inactive at high [GlnRS] Rate relative to tRNA2'" at 1 0 - ~ MtRNA'
aData on tRNAfMctare from 69 and data on tRNATyr are from 46-51. ND, Not determined. bApparent K,,,at subsaturating amino acid concentration. =Amino acids are inserted by tRNATyr derivatives into T4 am H36 head protein. dNo Tyr, according to 48; some Tyr, 46. eData are from 133.
Amino acid inserted in oiooc Gln ND ND ND ND Gln > Tyrd Gln Gln, 20; Tyr, 80 Neutral amino acid Gln, 30;Tyr, 70 Gln and Tyr TYr TYr TYr
+ Tyr
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
55
tRNATYr(CUA)also allowed in uiuo mischarging by GlnRS, although this sequence change is actually away from the wild-type G,*C,, sequence of tRNA”’I1. Again, the data suggest that unpairing of the acceptor stem facilitates interaction with GlnRS (49). tRNAfMef(CUA) and the position 1.72 mutants of tRNATYr(CUA)contain A,,, indicating that G,, is not essential for GlnRS recognition. This conclusion is also consistent with the results on the Gln-inserting amber suppressor tRNAs (Table IV), where only three of the five tRNAs mischarged by GlnRS have G,, (two have A,,). Conversion of the C,*A,, sequence in tRNAfMet(CUA)to a “glutamine” U,.A,, base-pair actually reduces the specificity for aminoacylation by GlnRS (Table XI; 69), suggesting that G,, plays a more important role when no mismatch is present at 1-72. The stronger C,*G7, base-pair further reduces the activity of tRNAmet(CUA), and in this structural context, G, is seen to enhance interaction with GlnRS fivefold. The X-ray structure of the tRNAG’”.GlnRS complex (12)reveals that the base-pair at position 1-72 is broken, and base-specific contacts are made at both positions 2.71 and 3.70 by GlnRS (see Section VII). G,, is involved in an RNA.RNA contact that facilitates the conformational change at the 3’ end of the tRNA. Each of the recognition elements in the acceptor stem contributes to the overall interaction between GlnRS and its tRNA substrates, but none is essential. Of the suppressor tRNAs mischarged by GlnRS, only tRNATrl’ (CUA) contains all of these elements. In addition, individual changes at each site do not eliminate the Gln acceptor activity of tRNAG1I1(CUA)in uiuo (M. J. Rogers and D. Soll, unpublished). U,, in the anticodon makes a much larger contribution quantitatively to recognition by GlnRS, increasing the specificity of the enzyme for tRNATq (C,,--*U,,) by 105 and for tRNAfMet(A,,.U,,+U35.A36) by 103 (Table 111). Nevertheless, the sum of the recognition elements in the acceptor stem makes a significant contribution to the recognition of tRNAs by GlnRS.
D. Other E. coli Synthetases tRNA1Iis is unique among E . co2i tRNAs in having only three unpaired bases at the 3’ terminus, plus an acceptor stem containing 8 bp (134)(Fig. 6). The role of this unusual structure has been investigated by examination of a series of tRNAHisderivatives prepared by in uitro transcription (Table XII; 42). In one set of experiments, the extra base at the 5‘ end (designated G- ,) which is paired with C,, has been removed to generate a “standard” tRNA 3’ terminus. This change causes a large decrease in the specificity for aminoacylation of the tRNA by HisRS, indicating the importance of the structure for recognition by the enzyme. The primary sequence at the -1.73 position is also important for efficient aminoacylation by HisRS. C, is
56
LADONNE ? I
H.
SCHULMAN
76
FC
F, - ;73 4 I
w
-I
IG-CC72
-
-
-
-
-
FIG. 6. The unusual structure at the acceptor end of E . coli tRNAHiS(134). Known major recognition elements (42) are indicated by arrows.
unique to His tRNA in E. coli (112),and conversion to any other nucleotide causes significant loss of activity, whether or not G - is present. Substitution of G - 1.C7-3 by an A- 1-U73base-pair also reduces activity to below 0.1%. Most of the observed effect is on the maximal velocity of the reaction. These data indicate that the G - ,*C, base-pair is an important recognition element for E. coli HisRS, affecting the positioning of the 3' end in the catalytic step of the aminoacylation reaction. The extra 5' G but not the base pair has been preserved in the His tRNAs of yeast and higher eukaryotes (112).The 5'-terminal G - is encoded in E. coZi, but is added post-transcriptionally to the cytoplasmic tRNAHisof higher organisms (135, 136). The nature of the base at position 73 plays an important role in the recognition of E. coli tRNAASpby AspRS (Table XIII; 40). Alterations of G,, reduce activity to 1/200 or less. In this case, significant changes in both K , and V,, are observed. The nucleotides that substitute best for G,, (U > A) share some functional groups with G , suggesting that direct contacts may be made by the enzyme at this site. The discriminator base also plays a role in the recognition of tRNATyr by E. co2i TyrRS, since conversion of A,, to G,, greatly reduces the Tyr-insert-
RECOGNITION OF
ROLE OF
57
tRNAs
THE
TABLE XI1 EIGHT-MEMBERED ACCEPTOR STEM IN THE AMINOACYLATION OF E. coli tRNAHisTRANSCRIPTS"
Sequence change
Apparent K , (PM)
Vmax (pmol/minlmg x 10-2)
4.0 3.7 4.8
100 7.8 1.5
None G-I C 7 p C 1 A,, G-I u73 G-I ' CiR Delete G - , Delete G - , + C,,+A,, '
10
6.1
10
4.1
Relative VIK, 1.0 0.084 0.013
u73
G7,
G-lC73+A-l . C, A-I A73 A-, u73 A-I ' G73 '
'
" D a t a a r e from 42
+,
ing activity of su tRNATyr(CUA)in oioo and the rate of aminoacylation by TyrRS in oitro (49, 101a). Modeling of the interaction between Bacillus stearothermophilus TyrRS and the acceptor stem of tRNA substrates has suggested that recognition of A,, may play a critical role in positioning the 3' terminus of tRNATyr at the active site (137; see Section VIII).
E. Summary A number of E. co2i tRNAs contain important recognition elements for their cognate synthetases in the acceptor stem and/or at the discriminator site (position 73). Neither AlaRS nor SerRS appears to recognize the anticodon of cognate tRNAs, and for these synthetases, critical recognition ele-
ON
TABLE XI11 EFFECT OF CHANGES IN THE "DISCRIMINATOR" BASE THE AMINOACYLATION OF tRNA TRANSCRIPTS BY E . coli AsuRS' tRNA
tRNAASP(GUC)G7, tRNAATP(GUC)G73-+A7, u73 c73 a
Data a r e from 40.
Apparent K", (PM)
Relative
0.32 1.4 5.0
1.0 0.008 0.08
a,x'
Relative VIK, 1.0 0.0018 0.0051 <0.0015
58
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
ments are found in the acceptor-stem region. GlnRS binds to sites in the anticodon as well as the acceptor stem of tRNAGII1(see Section VII). The unusual acceptor stem of tRNAHisserves as a recognition element for HisRS, and the discriminator base is important for the recognition of tRNAAla, tRNAAsp, tRNAGln, tRNAHiS,tRNASer, and tRNATyr. Other E. coli synthetases, such as MetRS (Table VII) and PheRS (Table XVII), do not strongly discriminate one base from another at position 73. However, many E. coli tRNAs may contain identity elements at this site, for example, sequences protecting against mischarging by those synthetases that strongly interact with base 73 in their cognate tRNAs. Similarly, tRNAs recognized primarily through contacts at sites outside of the acceptor stem may contain important negative identity elements in this helical region near the amino-acid attachment site, which is likely to approach closely the surface of a synthetase as it discriminates between cognate and noncognate tRNAs.
V. Other Recognition Profiles A. E. coli Arginine Synthetase Comparison of tRNA sequences by computer analysis (128) led to the prediction that nucleotides 20 and 35 in E. coli Arg tRNAs might be recognition elements for ArgRS. The role of A,, in the D-loop of tRNAArghas been investigated, using an amber suppressor tRNA derivative (55,108).Deletion of A,, or conversion to U,, resulted in almost complete loss of Arg-inserting activity (Table XIV). Introduction of A,, into the D-loop of tRNAPhe(CUA) resulted in little production of mature tRNA from the plasmid-encoded gene. A second mutation at position 59 restored synthesis and resulted in the insertion of mainly Arg into H, folate reductase-amber. Positions 16, 17, 20, 59, and 60 contain some single-stranded bases that are brought into close proximity by tertiary structure interactions between the D- and T-loops (see Fig. 2). This has been referred to as a “variable pocket,” since this cluster contains different numbers and types of bases in different tRNAs. Early in the analysis of tRNA structure, it was suggested that this cluster, located in an accessible patch between sets of highly conserved residues, could serve as a recognition system for the discrimination of tRNAs by synthetases (138). A,, could be a recognition element which directly interacts with ArgRS, since it is unique to Arg tRNAs in E. coli. The exact position of this residue in the three-dimensional structure of the tRNA is dependent on the structure of the variable pocket. In the case of tRNAArg,residues in the T-loop do not appear to contribute directly to recognition by ArgRS, since none of these bases is conserved in Arg tRNAs (Fig. 7).
RECOGNITION OF
59
tRNAs TABLE XIV
EFFECTOF MUTATIONSON
THE RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs in Vivo BY E . coli ArgRSa
Amino acid inserted tRNA tRNAfrp(ICG)
CUA CUA CUA CUA UCA tRNAPhe(GAA) CUA CUA CUA CUA
Mutationsb
+ A,,+U,
+ AsS+Us,
+ A, + A,
+ +
deletion
insertion A, + Us9+A, Us9+A,
Efficiency (%)d Arg, 37; Lys, 55 Lys, 91 Arg, 38; Lys, 50 Arg, 5; Lys, 91e Arg only f Phe, 86 Arg, 72; Lys, 6; Thr, 16 Phe, 91; Leu, 7
30-62 12-28 29-59 43-55' 11-22 Poor tRNA synthesis 3-11 4-13
Data are from 55 unless otherwise noted. bunnumbered sequences are anticodon bases 34, 35, and 36. c h e r t i o n into DHFR-amber at position 10. dEficiency of suppression at the A,, and A, amber alleles of lacl-Z. eData are from 107 and 108. fData are from 1380. (1
The amber suppressor derivative of tRNAArgcontains a base change at C,,, a residue implicated in ArgRS recognition by earlier biochemical studies (83).Consistent with an important role for C, tRNAArg(CU,A) inserts mainly Lys in oioo (55), while the corresponding opal suppressor tRNA having a UC,,A anticodon inserts only Arg (138~). In oitro experiments using tRNA transcripts of tRNAArgwere carried out to evaluate the relative contributions of A,, and C, to recognition of tRNAs by ArgRS (Table XV; 100). The primary sequence of E. coli tRNAMetdiffers from the consensus sequence of conserved sites in Arg tRNAs by only these two nucleotides (Fig. 7). Conversion of the Met anticodon to an Arg anticodon resulted in a 40,OOO-fold increase in V,,/K, for aminoacylation by ArgRS, while substitution of A,, increased the activity 1000-fold. Introduction of both changes yielded a tRNAMefderivative that had nearly normal Arg acceptor activity (Table XV). Thus, A,, and C,, are both important recognition elements for ArgRS, and the bases at these sites make a large contribution to both the K , and V,, for aminoacylation. Few other conserved sites are found in the consensus structure of Arg tRNAs (Fig. 7). Nevertheless, tRNAArg(CUA)having a deletion of A,, and a base change at C,, retains the ability to insert a low level of Arg in uiuo (Table XIV). This raises the possibility of additional recognition elements, or of a weak compensating interaction with C, in the absence of C, as has been suggested for tRNAArg(CUA)having a deletion of base 26 (55).
60
LADONNE H . SCHULMAN 76
0
A
0
B
.
0
I
.-. .-. .-.
G--.
.-a70
-a
0-0
-
c
I I I I I
n
1 1 1 1 I
'
- 0
..... ....
U,D 20-1
G
0
.%
I l l 1
20A
OG
10.
0 - * G
0
4
: a e
C.
0 . .
G
e
.
..-. .-. -0
0-0
30.-040
C
.
A
a
c
C I,
.
35
35
FIG. 7. (A) Base changes involved in the in uitro conversion of E . coli tRNAMet into an efficient arginine acceptor tRNA (100)are indicated by arrowheads. Other bases shared by E. coli tRNAMet and E . coli and bacteriophage T4 Arg tRNAs are also indicated on the cloverleaf structure. (B) Composite structure of E. coli and bacteriophage T4 Arg tRNAs (112). The sequence of tRNAfB(ACG) is in question (55) and has been excluded from the composite. Arrowheads indicate major known recognition elements. See the legend to Fig. 3 for definition of the symbols.
B. Yeast Phenylalanine Synthetase Earlier in uitro studies revealed the importance of the anticodon nucleotides to the recognition of tRNAs by yeast PheRS (Table 11; 101).Subsequent experiments show that bases at positions 20 and 73 also play an important role in the aminoacylation of tRNAPhe (Table XVI; 37, 139-141). TABLE XV AMINOACYLATIONOF tRNA TRANSCRIPTS WITH E. coli ArgRSa Apparent
K,,, (+M)
tRNA ~~~~
tRNA*=(CCG) tRNA,Met(CCG)Uzo+Azo tRNA,Met(CCG) tRNA,Mct(CAU)Uzo+Az, t RN A,Met(CA U) Data are from 100.
~
1.1 1.2 5.2 4.4
>loo
V (+mol/min/mg)
Relative
VIK,
~
2.0 0.9 0.03 0.0007 -
10 x 1oR 5 x 106 40 X I@ 1 x 18 1
61
tRNAs
RECOGNITION OF
TABLE XVI AMINOACYLATION OF tRNA TRANSCRIPTS WITH YEAST PheRSa tRNA Yeast tRNAPhe(CAA) Yeast tRNAPhe(GAA)Gzo+U,, A7dJ7, E . coli tRNAPhe(GAA)U,, + c, G7n+G, c70 E . coli tRNAPhe(CAA)Uz,+G,, + c, G7,-rC3 c7, Yeast tRNAMet(GAA)A,,+G, + G,, . C,+C,, C , + A,g+U5g Yeast tRNAAr~(GAA)Cz~+G,o+ U,, + c59+u59 + C73+A7, Yeast tRNAArg(GAA)Cm+Czo + U,, + c59+us9 Yeast tRNATyr(GAA) U,u~o_,U,-2+~,, + other changes6
Apparent K , (PW
k,,,
Relative
(min-1)
kcatlKm
0.35
160
2.10
80
1.0 0.083 0.083
'
'
1.80
35
0.042
'
'
0.42
100
0.52
0.41
130
0.68
0.38
110
0.64
1.00
60
0.13
0.36
250
1.5
Data are from 37 and 139. b o t h e r changes: C , . G72+G, . c72, U S A7,+C2 U,, A,, A,, A,,-C,, . G,, and A4,pG&. 0
G,,,
c, . G7o+G3.
c70, c12. G,+
Conversion of G,, to U,, or of A?, to G,,, reduces k,,,lK, for Phe acceptor activity to 1112th. G,, is unique to tRNAPhe in yeast and is one of the variable pocket nucleotides. High-resolution NMR studies of tRNAPhetranscripts containing G or U at position 20 indicate that the structures of the two tRNAs are nearly identical (142), suggesting that the change in activity on mutation of this site is due to the loss of specific contacts with PheRS. Footprinting studies of the yeast tRNAPhe.PheRS complex show that the protein contacts the entire surface of the tRNA (143),consistent with the location of widely separated recognition elements. Extensive studies of the interactions involved in maintaining the threedimensional structure of tRNAPhe reveal that none of the specific bases involved is required for PheRS recognition; however, the proper tertiary structure must be maintained (141).In addition, changes in unbonded bases at positions 16, 17, 59, and 60 have less than a two-fold effect on activity, indicating that G,, is the only required base in the variable pocket. Transfers of the GAA anticodon, G,,, and A,, to other yeast tRNAs yield mutants with nearly wild-type Phe acceptor activity (Table XVI). In addition, conversion of U,, in E. coli tRNAPheto G,, makes the E. coli tRNA a good substrate for the enzyme. Comparison of the sequences of all of the tRNAs that are efficient substrates for PheRS (Fig. 8) indicates that there are few additional conserved sites.
62
LADONNE €1. SCHULMAN 0
76
0 0
.-. .-.
1G 0
A
-
-
4
c
.
0 - a 7 0 - 0
0
.-a
60 m
0 - 0
0
0 0 0 O
.
0
50
0
0
O
0
.
U
I I I I *.*.
0
0
G
20
A
G
I I I I I
0e.e
lo.
.
0
..*.o
0 0
.
0 .
0 - 0 0 - 0 30 G CtO
-
- u
A
0
s
0 A
G
35 FIG. 8. Composite structure of tRNAs aminoacylated by yeast PheRS with kinetics similar (within a factor of 2 or 3) to cognate yeast tRNAPhe(139-141). Arrowheads indicate major known recognition elements. See the legend to Fig. 3 for definition of the symbols. (Adapted from 139 with permission.)
C. E. coli Phenylalanine Synthetase Both in uiuo and in uitro studies indicate that the anticodon contains major recognition elements for E. coli PheRS (Tables V and XVII; 67, and E. F. Tinkle and O.C. Uhlenbeck, unpublished). In uiuo experiments using the amber suppressor derivative of tRNAPhehave suggested that additional sites, including U,,, G27.C43, G,,*C,,, G,,, U,,, U,,, ,U and A,, contribute to Phe identity based on mischarging of tRNAs containing mutations at these sites (54,57). Since tRNAPhe(CUA)retains its identity in uiuo with only one
RECOGNITION OF
63
tRNAs
TABLE XVII AMINOACYLATION OF E . coli tRNAPheTRANSCRIPTS WITH E . coli PheRSa Apparent
K , (PM)
Mutation None C3 ' G7n-tC3 G o G3 C, + GAA-tAAA CUA '
+
ul6-tcl6
+ Cl7-tUl7
+ U2n-tGzo +
'27
'
c43+A27
+ U45+G, + u.5Ll-tc.59
+ u,+c, +
A73-tG73 c73
u73
'
'43
Relative
k,
0.20 0.11
100 70
0.22 0.19 1.10 0.30 0.11 0.95 0.19 0.23 0.35 0.35
80 80 110 100 110 70 70 80 80
70
Relative
k,llK, 1.0 1.2 <10-2 Greatly reduced 0.7 0.8 0.2 0.7 0.12 0.15 0.7 0.7 0.5 0.4
aE. F. Tinkle and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, unpublished.
wild-type anticodon base (A3&,it is likely that additional recognition elements exist outside of the anticodon. However, the interpretation of results obtained in the absence of G , and A,, is unclear, since these bases contain strong recognition elements that would enhance interaction with PheRS and inhibit mischarging by noncognate enzymes. Examination of the effect of mutations on in uitro aminoacylation of E . coli tRNAPheby E . coli PheRS (Table XVII) shows that the largest effects outside ofthe anticodon occur at positions 20,45, and 59 (five- to eight-fold reductions in kcat/&), suggesting that these sites play some role in tRNAPherecognition. It remains to be determined whether other positive or negative identity elements are present in E. coli tRNAPhe. The exact role of nucleotides in the variable pocket is also unclear. Native tRNAPhecontains a modified base, dihydrouridine, at position 20. This base occurs commonly at position 20 in E . coli tRNAs. In addition, it is structurally quite different from U, which also functions well at position 20.
D. Summary Both the anticodon and the variable pocket have been implicated in the recognition of E. coli Arg tRNAs and yeast and E. coli Phe tRNAs. While specific contacts may be made with cognate synthetases in the variable pocket domain, particularly at position 20 in the D-loop, the structural complexity of this region of tRNA structure leaves some doubt as to the nature of the interaction. The variable pocket also contains a metal-ion binding site
64
LADONNE €1. SCHULMAN
(144),which could play a role in tRNA-synthetase recognition. In addition, changes in the anticodon loop affect the structure at the junction of the D- and T-loops (145,146), suggesting that interaction of synthetases with bases in the anticodon could affect recognition sites in the variable pocket domain in a complex manner. The distribution of recognition elements over a larger number of widely separated sites also places more stringent constraints on the overall structure of the tRNAs recognized by the enzymes in this group.
VI. Role of Modified Bases A. E. coli lsoleucine Synthetase A minor species of E. coli Ile tRNA that reads the codon AUA (147) contains a modified base at the wobble position of the anticodon (148).This base, called lysidine, is derived from cytidine by attachment of a Lys residue to the 2 position of the pyrimidine ring (Fig. 9). Prior to modification, the tRNA contains a CAU Met anticodon and is efficiently aminoacylated in uitro by E. coli MetRS, but not by IleRS (149).Conversely, the modified tRNA1Ie is a poor substrate for MetRS, but a good substrate for the cognate synthetase. Thus, the lysidine base plays a dual role in the identity of the tRNA, blocking mischarging by the noncognate enzyme and enhancing interaction with IleRS. A post-transcriptional modification also occurs in the AUA-reading Ile tRNAs of bacteriophage T4and spinach chloroplasts, which similarly encode tRNA"" genes having a CAU anticodon (112). The major species of E. coli tRNA"" has the anticodon GAU. If the base at the wobble position is directly recognized by IleRS, either two different interactions occur with G,, and lysidine 34, or an equivalent functional group is contacted (Fig. 9). C, may also be a negative element for IleRS, while any base other than C,, strongly inhibits the recognition of tRNAs by
a
b
C
FIG. 9. Structures of nucleotides present at position 34 of the anticodons of E . coli Ile tRNAs before and aRer post-transcriptional modification (148).(a) Guanosine, (b) lysidine, and (c) cytidine.
RECOGNITION OF
65
tRNAs
E. coli MetRS, as noted earlier. Substitution of the Ile anticodon GAU for the Met anticodon CAU in E. coli tRNAfMetconverts this tRNA into an Ileinserting species (Table V; 67a). This suggests direct recognition of one or more anticodon bases by IleRS; however, post-transcriptional modifications resulting from the anticodon substitution have not yet been determined.
6. Yeast Arginine Synthetase I n oitro studies indicate that base modifications play an important role in the discrimination of yeast ArgRS against yeast tRNAAsp (150).Transcripts of wild-type tRNAAsP containing no modified bases are aminoacylated by ArgRS with a specificity 500-fold that of fully modified native tRNAAsPp, reducing the discrimination to only 20-fold (Table XVIII). Mischarging of unmodified tRNAAsPwas not observed with yeast HisRS, PheRS, or ValRS (150). tRNAAspcontains unique modified bases at only three sites (IJI13, ,IJ and mlG,,). Native tRNAAsPhas a K, for aminoacylation by ArgRS only 12fold higher than that of tRNAArg,indicating significant &nity of the native noncognate tRNA for the synthetase. Mischarging of native tRNAAsp is mainly avoided by a reduced kcat for aminoacylation (Table XVIII), as observed for a number of other noncognate interactions (151). The unmodified tRNA has an altered conformation, which may allow it to be more readily accommodated to the tRNA binding site of ArgRS, and/or one or more of the modified bases in native tRNAAspmay interfere directly with aminoacylation by the noncognate enzyme (150).
C. Summary Modified bases could contribute to tRNA identity by serving as positive recognition elements for synthetases or as negative elements blocking mischarging reactions. E. coli IleRS and yeast ArgRS are examples of synthetases for which modified bases clearly assist in the discrimination of TABLE XVIII
MISCHARCINCOF YEAST tRNAAsP TRANSCRIPT BY YEAST ArgRSa tRNA
Yeast synthetase
Native tRNAAsP(GUC) tRNAAsP(GUC) transcript Native tRNAArqUCU) Native tRNAA\p(GUC) tRNAAsP(GUC) transcript
Asp Asp Arg Arg Arg
K, (pM)
0.044 0.028 0.073 0.86 0.11
k,,, (s-l)
Relative k,,J~,”
0.66 0.38 0.70
1.0 0.9 1.0
O.ooo65
O.ooOo79
0.045
0.043
“Data are from 150. ‘Jk,,,/K,,, are relative to the native tRNA for each synthetase.
66
LADONNE H . SCHULMAN
tRNAs. Enhanced activity resulting from a base modification was reported earlier, when it was shown that methylation of G,, in E. coli tRNAPhe increases its rate of aminoacylation by yeast PheRS 10-fold (152). The interpretation of this result is unclear, however, since Schizosaccharomyces pombe tRNAPhe lacks this modification and is aminoacylated with the same kinetics as yeast tRNAPhecontaining the modification (153).A modified base in the middle position of the anticodon of yeast tRNATyr ($35) also has a small effect on the aminoacylation of this tRNA by yeast TyrRS (Table 11). The efficient aminoacylation of plant viral RNAs by yeast and plant synthetases (154) and of tRNA transcripts by cognate enzymes (Table I) suggests that modified bases have no direct positive role in the recognition of most tRNAs. Native tRNAs have a more rigid ordered structure, however, which can be mimicked in tRNA transcripts by elevating the divalent cation concentration (37). Thus, modifications enhance aminoacylation activity by “fine-tuning” the structure of tRNAs. At present, there is little direct evidence for a general role for modified bases as negative elements for tRNA identity, although modified bases in or near the anticodon are likely candidates. In uitro transcripts of yeast tRNAPhe are discriminated against by yeast TyrRS to the same extent as native tRNAPhe (37). Similarly, transcripts of E. coli tRNAMetand tRNAVa’ are not mischarged by E. coli GlnRS, GluRS, IleRS, LysRS, or PheRS (43), and transcripts of E . coli tRNAVa’, tRNAThr, and tRNAArg are not mischarged by E. coli MetRS (43, 44, 100). The results with E. coli IleRS and yeast ArgRS suggest, however, that other specific examples of negative regulation of aminoacylation by post-transcriptional tRNA modifications will come to light as more extensive studies are carried out.
E. coli Glutamine tRNA and Glutamine Synthetase
VII. The Complex of
The most exciting event in recent studies of tRNA-synthetase interactions has been solution of the crystal structure of a complex of E. coli tRNAGIn, GlnRS, and ATP at 2.8A resolution (12), allowing details of the molecular basis for the recognition of a tRNA by a synthetase to be revealed for the first time. This achievement was made possible by the earlier cloning and sequencing of the gene for GlnRS and overproduction of the protein and the isoacceptor tRNAF’”(CUG) (156-158). GlnRS is a 63.4-kDa protein containing 553 amino acids arranged in an elongated structure made up of four domains (12).The surface of the protein contacts regions of the tRNA extending from the anticodon to the 3’terminus, along the inside of the L-shaped tRNA structure (Fig. lo), in a manner similar to that originally proposed by Rich and Schimmel (159) as a general binding mode for tRNA-synthetase
FIG. 10. E. coli GlnRS complexed with E. coli tRNA;ln(CUG) and ATP. Protein a-helices are represented as tubes sequentially lettered and p-strands are shown as arrows sequentially numbered, both from the amino terminus. The dinucleotide fold domain includes residues from P-strands 1-3 plus a-helix G and P-strand 10. The acceptor-end binding domain includes the chain between the amino end of a-helix D to the carboxyl end of P-strand 8. The two P-barrel anticodon binding domains consist of P-strands 13-19 and P-strand 20 to the carboxy terminus plus p-strand 12. (From 12 with permission.)
68
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
complexes. The tRNA adopts an unusual conformation at both ends of the molecule. Bases C,, and G,, in the anticodon are unstacked, and the central anticodon base (U35) is stacked under A,, and buried in a tightly fitting protein pocket. The base-pair at the end of the acceptor stem (1.72) is broken, and the 3' terminus forms a hairpin structure in which the unbonded bases loop back toward the anticodon, rather than extending away from the body of the tRNA (Fig. 10). Base-specific contacts are made in both of these widely separated regions of the tRNA. Refinement of the crystal structure in the anticodon binding domain reveals a set of amino-acid side-chains that interact with a known major recognition element, U,, (99). These strong interactions, involving several charged amino-acid residues, explain the requirement for U at the middle position of the anticodon of GlnRS substrates, since no other base could make the appropriate hydrogen bonds with the protein (Fig. 11). Contacts are also made between the protein and each of the other anticodon bases. The protein pocket containing C,, could also accommodate a U residue, the base present in tRNA7'" (U*UG), but not a purine. Most of the contacts to G,, could not be made with the A residue found at the corresponding position of the amber anticodon CUA,,, and in uitro studies show that tRNA,G'"(CUA) is less efficiently aminoacylated by GlnRS than wild-type tRNA,Gln(CUG)(M. Jahn and D. Sol], unpublished). Thus, all three anticodon bases appear to contribute to the recognition of Gln tRNAs, with U,, having the dominant role. In addition, residues 37 and 38 on the 3' side of the anticodon interact with the protein, although it is not yet clear whether these are base-specific contacts (99). The hairpin structure at the 3' end of tRNAGlnis stabilized by extensive interactions with GlnRS and by a sequence-specific RNA-RNA interaction between the 2-amino group of G,, and a phosphate oxygen of A,, (Fig. 12). The bases of residues A,, C,,, and G,, are stacked on each other, while C,, is looped out to contact side-chains of the protein. The side-chain of an aliphatic amino acid (Leu,,,) is wedged between base A,, of the disrupted U,.A72 base-pair and base-pair G2.C7, (Fig. 12). No sequence-specific contacts are made with base 1 or 72, in keeping with the data described earlier showing that a variety of weak or mismatched base-pairs can function at this position. However, base-specific contacts are made with the adjacent basepairs G,.C7, and G3*C70, implicating these sites as recognition elements for GlnRS (12). Consistent with this, in uitro studies show that a G,*C,,+A,.U7, mutation in tRNAg'"(CUA) greatly reduces the rate of aminoacylation of the tRNA by GlnRS (M. Jahn and D. Sol], unpublished). The side-chain of Asp,,, contacts the 2-amino group of base G, in the minor groove of the acceptor stem, and the main-chain carbonyl of Pro181is hydrogen-bonded to the 2-amino group of G2. These amino-acid residues plus
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
69
Cytosine
H\N/H
I
I Adenine
Guanine
FIG.11. Schematic drawing of hydrogen-bonding interactions between the anticodon base Us in tRNACln and GlnRS (99). The protein binding pocket excludes cytidine due to ionic hydrogen bonds from an Arg residue to the pyrimidine 0 - 4 and from a Glu residue to the ring N-3. Adenine and guanine are excluded by size from the binding site. (Courtesy of T. Steitz.)
70
LADONNE
n.
SCHULMAN
FIG. 12. The acceptor end of tRNAClnin the complex with E . coli GlnRS. The side-chain of L e ~ extends ~ 3 ~from a p-turn and wedges between the bases of G2 and A72, disrupting the last base-pair of the acceptor stem, UI.A72. The enzyme stabilizes the hairpin conformation via the interaction of several basic side-chains with the sugar-phosphate backbone. An intramolecular hydrogen bond between the 2-amino group of G73 and the phosphate of A71 further stabilizes this conformation. (From 12 with permission.)
IleIs3 and a buried water molecule which contacts G,C,, form a hydrogenbonding surface which is complementary to that of the two G.C base-pairs at positions 2.71 and 3-70. Interestingly, mutation of Asp,, to Asn,,, leads to a partial relaxation of specificity of GlnRS, allowing in vivo and in uitro mischarging of the amber suppressor derivative of tRNATyrand in uitro mischarging of a specific subset of wild-type E. coli tRNAs (13, 133, 160), further establishing a role for this
RECOGNITION OF
71
tRNAs
region of the protein in tRNA recognition. The mutant enzyme aminoacylates tRNAF'"(CUG) with one-tenth the K,,,of wild-type GlnRS, and much more efficiently aminoacylates the A,.U,, derivative of tRNA2'" (CUA) than the wild-type enzyme (S. Englisch, P. Hoben and D. Soll, unpublished). A mutation from Ile~,gto ThrlZ9 in GlnRS allows weaker mischarging of su 3 tRNATYr(CUA)than observed with the Asn,,, mutant (13).I1elzglies close to the phosphate of C74, and the mutation may result in the formation of a stabilizing contact not made by wild-type GlnRS (13). The known recognition elements in tRNAz'"(CUG) are summarized in Fig. 13. Other bases that contact the protein and that may provide additional discrimination are also indicated. Recognition elements include bases that make sequence-discriminating interactions with GlnRS, and two structural features that facilitate the essential conformational change at the 3' terminus of tRNAFln(CUG), the RNA-RNA interaction involving G,, and the weak base-pair at position 1.72. +
35
FIG.13. Major known recognition elements in E . coli Cln tRNAs are indicated by arrowheads. Additional bases that contact GlnRS in the complex are also indicated. See Sections 1v.C and V11 for references and discussion.
72
LADONNE I f . SCHULMAN
VIII. tRNA Binding Domains of Other Synthetases E. coli AlaRS is the largest of the E. coli synthetases, having four identical subunits, each containing 875 amino acids (161).Deletion analysis has revealed that the functional domains of each subunit are arranged in an approximately linear fashion, with the amino-acid activation domain nearest the amino terminus of the polypeptide, followed by sequences required for the aminoacylation of tRNAAIa, and then by an oligomerization domain near the carboxy terminus (162).Several other synthetases have an arrangement of functional domains similar to that seen in AlaRS (4).The smallest fragment of AlaRS able to complement an alaS null mutant strain is a monomeric enzyme containing amino acids 1 to 461. Further deletions show that sequences that contribute most to tRNA binding are located between residues 368 and 461 (Table XIX). In addition to interactions in this domain, the 3' end of the tRNA must also bind to amino-acid residues near the active site during the transfer step of the aminoacylation reaction. An amino-acid residue (Lys?,), which lies close to the acceptor end of tRNAAla in the AlaRS*tRNAA'"complex, has been identified by crosslinking and shown by site-directed mutagenesis to affect tRNA binding (163;Table XIX). Mutations in the protein that allow aminoacylation of an amber suppressor derivative of tRNAA1"containing a G,.U70+G,C70 base change have also recently been obtained (P. Schimmel, personal communication). Characterization of these mutants should lead to the identification of amino-acid residues important for recognition of the key structural feature required for tRNAAIaidentity. High-resolution X-ray crystal structures are available for E. coli MetRS and B. stear. TyrRS (16,167-172);However, cocrystals of complexes containing the cognate tRNAs have not yet been obtained. Native E. coli MetRS is a dimeric protein of identical subunits, each containing 676 amino acids (173,174). Limited trypsin digestion releases peptides from the carboxy terminus of the protein to produce a biologically active monomeric enzyme containing amino acids 1 to 547 (MetRS,,) (175,176). This form of the synthetase has been crystallized in both the presence and absence of ATP (16).Crosslinking experiments show that the tRNA binding site is located largely in the carboxy-terminal half of MetRS (177,178),with residues close to the 3' end of the tRNA located in the amino-terminal domain near the active site (179). Coupling of a crosslinker between anticodon base C,, and Lys,= in MetRS identified a region of the protein near the anticodon binding domain (178).This domain is located at the extreme periphery of the MetRS molecule at a maximal distance from the active site (16,167).Site-directed mutagenesis of nine amino acids in this region having side-chains potentially
SYNTHETASE MUTATIONS THATAFFECT
Synthetaseb (subunit structure)
E . coli AlaRS,,
(wt)
tRNA binding sites
4
Mutation None
TABLE XIX THE BINDINGAND/OR AMINOACYLATION OF tRNAs"
KmCor relative binding d
Relative
k.f
klK,,,
Location of amino acid in synthetase-tRNA complex
Comments
l.Od.9
1.0f
1.0
12.19
0.w
0.02
Near active site
Crosslinks to oxidized A76
0.29 2.19
1.0f 0.05.f
5.0 0.02
Dispensible domain
2.89
0.121
0.04
Dispensible domain
Coupling between dispensible and indispensible domains Coupling between dispensible and indispensible domains Complements ahS null strain Complements alas null strain Does not complement alas null strain Does not complement alas null strain
Reference
(a,)
4
Delete 809-875
1
Delete 462-875
1
Delete 386-875
1
Delete 369-875
2
None
0.8 at pH 5.0d 5 x lo-* at pH 5.0d 5 x lo-, at pH 5.0d < 5 x 10-5 at pH5.0d 1.0e
Delete 553-557 and 1.og add four unrelated AAs (RQRD)
-0.001f -0.001f
1.W
1.0
0.W
0.2
163 164
165
165
162, 166 162, 166 162, 166 162. 166
182
(continued)
TABLE XIX (Continued)
Synthetaseb (subunit structure)
E . coli GlnRS,
(wt)
kcor
tRNA binding sites
1
Mutation
relative bindingd
kf
Relative klK,
Location of amino acid in synthetase-tRNA complex
Comments
Reference
None
(a)
E . coli GlyRS a303 (wt) (a282)
2
Aspm+Asn
Contacts NH, of G ,
Mischarging mutant
GlY Ile129+Thr None
Near phosphate 74
Mischarging mutant Mischarging mutant
1.0
Cys,+Gln
0.08
13, 133, 160 13 13
8689
%A 4
Ala
Steric or conformational effect
191
0.80
191
0.01
192
Inactive Inactive
192 189, 192
Inactive
189, 192 197
a303 p575
Delete 8576-689
a303 P383 a303
Delete 0384-689 No p subunit
PM9
No a subunit
E . coli MetRS,,,
(wt)
1
None
Does not bind tRNAGly Binds tRNAGlY 1.09
1
Delete 548-676
1.09
1.0
1.0
Prow+Leu
6.0c
1.0
0.16
2.9f
2.9
(a2)
MetRS,,
Complements metG mutant strain
(a)
Near anticodon
176
18
Yeast MetRS,,
(wt)
1
Tyr,,+Ala In 531J None
62.59
1.3
0.02
2.99 8005300K
0.6 1.5 1.0
0.2 0.002
1.0a
Near anticodon base C, Near active site Near active stie
18 176 176
1.0
(4 Asp,,+Tyr
Acquires ability to acy- 119 late tRNA?, (CAUt.(CCU)
Lysffi,+Ala
0.5 0.5
Asn
0.1 0.1 u1 4
Yeast PheRS a595 (wt) (azP2) P503 a595 Pa1 E. coli ThrRS,, (wt) ( 4
(wt)
m
h
m
h
m
1960
m
196a
1.0
0
2&
Delete Pl-172 None
1
+
No binding
Inactive
0.115=
1.Of
1.0
0.025c
0.W
1.7
Glu,,+ Lys Arh-His
1.66C
1.W
0.07
None
1.4~
0.45e
1.0
Gln,,+Ala
2.7~
0.4SC
0.52
Glu,+Lys
B. stear TyrRS,,,
Presumably near anticodon Presumably near anticodon Presumably near anticodon Presumably near anticodon
196 202 Super-repressor of thrS translation Defective in repression of thrS translation
202 202
187
(a21 ~~
Near G ;
188
(continued)
TABLE XIX (Continued)
Synthetaseb (subunit structure)
tRNA binding sites
0
Mutation
K,,,c or relative bindingd
Thr,,+Ala Lys,,+Asn
0.6~ Footnote 1
Ar&+Gln Asn,,,+Ala Lys,,,+Asn
Footnote 1 >looc 1.2c
Gln Glu,,,+Asp Gln Ala Trp,,+Ala Phe Gln Arg,,-Gln Lys,+Asn Lys, and Lysm Ar&+Gln Ar&,,+Gln Arh,+Gln Arb+Gln Lys,,,-,+Asn Lys,,,+Asn Delete 320-419
kf 0.14e
Relative klK,,,
0.73
Location of amino acid in synthetase-tRNA complex
Comments
Ribose 1" Greatly reduced rate of transfer from preformed Tyr-AMP
ND 0.003e
0.52 0.007
Phosphates 69, 70n Near A,,"
0.6~ 1.4~ 0.3=
O.6ge 0.99' 0.38e
3.65 2.24 4.25
Phosphates 73, 74"
8. 3c 1.7~ 11.4~
0.10e 0.87~ 0.84e ND ND
0.04 1.62 0.23 0.062 0.036
ND ND ND ND ND ND
0.008
Additional tRNA contact in transtition state
Toxic mutation
>l o o C >28=
>looc >loo=
>l o o C >l o o C >loo=
>l o o C No binding
van der Walls contacts to GI and
0.054
0.038 0.052
0.030 0.041 Inactive
188 188 188 188 187 188 188 188 1 1
1 1
'473"
Phosphate 67" Phosphate 6 8 n Near ribose 76"
Reference
0
187 187 188 187 187 187 187 187 187 184
TvrRS,,,
1
Phe,,+Asp
tRNA binds
(a)
Inactive
Mutation at subunit interface
186
aData are for the aminoacylation of cognate tRNAs. Mutations listed have little or no effect on the kinetic parameters for amino-acid activation unless otherwise noted. wt, Wild-type. ND, not determined. bSubscript indicates the number of amino acids in each subunit. c& in pM. dBinding relative to the corresponding wild-type synthetase.
ekc,t (s-l).
fRelative Vma. gRelative K,,,. h F. Fasiolo, personal communication. i H. Bedouelle, personal communication. iThe in531 mutant contains Lys,=+Met Tyr,,+Ala + an insertion of Glu-Leu-Ala between amino acids 531 and 532. kFrom 203. T h e s e mutations also affect the activation of Tyr. mResidues 657-659 in yeast MetRS correspond to residues 459-461 in the anticodon binding domain of E. coli MetRS. “Based on the model of the B. steor. TyrRS tRNAphecomplex (188). OEquivalent to Lysm and Lys,, in E. coli TyrRS. These residues are crosslinked to the 3’-oxidized terminus of tRNATyr (180).
+
4
78
LADONNE
n. SCHULMAN
capable of forming hydrogen bonds to anticodon bases showed that only one mutation, Trp,,,+Phe, had a significant effect on the recognition of tRNAMet (18). The effect of the mutation is only on the initial complex formation, with the rate of aminoacylation remaining unchanged (Table XIX). Examination of the interaction of the Phe,,l mutant enzyme with a series of anticodon derivatives of tRNAMet and several noncognate tRNAs (Table XX) suggests that Trp461stabilizes the interaction with the Met anticodon, interacts with the 5' while blocking binding to non-Met anticodons. Trp461 end of the anticodon, possibly directly with the key anticodon base for the recognition of tRNAMet, C,, and strongly excludes anticodons containing U, G, or A at this position (18).Mutation of the adjacent Pro,, residue to Leu increases the K,,,somewhat, but does not alter the anticodon preference of the wild-type enzyme, suggesting that this mutation only introduces a structural alteration of the a-helix containing TT~,,~. The crystal structure of MetRS,,, reveals that the extreme carboxy terminus of the truncated protein is connected to the amino-terminal domain and forms part of the active site of the enzyme (16, 176).The shortest protein to complement an E . coli strain having a defective chromosomal metG (MetRS) gene contains amino acids 1 to 537 (176). Site-specific changes at amino acids 528 and 531 plus a three-amino-acid insertion between residues 531 and 532 lead to a drastic increase in K, for the aminoacylation of tRNAMet (176; Table XIX), implicating the 528-531 region in interaction with the 3' end of the tRNA. Periodate-oxidized tRNAMet crosslinks through the 3'-terminal A?, to several Lys residues near the active site, including Lys,, and Lys,,,. Sequences similar to that surrounding Lys,,, in MetRS (Lys-Met-Ser-LysSer) occur in several other synthetases, including a site in E . coli TyrRS TABLE M AMINOACYLATION OF tRNAs BY WILD-TYPEAND MUTANTE . coli MetRS,," ~~
~
~~
Wild-type MetRS,, Km
tRNA
Anticodon
(PM)
tRNA,Mel
CAU (wt) CAG UAU GAU
1.2f 0.2 63 f 16 >100 >loo
GGU tRNAnr tRNAVd
GGU UAC
>100 >100 >100
Trp,,pPhe
Relative
1.0 1.8 x 10-3
0.8 x 1.2 x 1.5 x 2.6 X 1.7 x
Km
(PM)
k,llK,
>100 >100
10-4
134 2 56
10-5
27 2 4 17 2 1 10 2 4 71 2 34
10-5 10-5 10-6
Relative k,,llK, 0.7 X 10-2 1.4 x 10-5 0.6 x 10-5 0.6 x 10-5
2.8 X 10-6 1.3 x 10-6 2.9 X 10-7
OData are from 18. All tRNAs were prepared by in oitro transcription. MetRS,, monomeric, truncated derivative of native MetRS (see Table XIX). wt, Wild-type.
is a
RECOGNITION OF
tHNAs
79
crosslinked to the oxidized 3' terminus of tRNATyr(180).This has led to the suggestion that sequences related to Lys-Met-Ser-Lys are important for binding the 3' end of tRNAs during aminoacylation (181).A Lys,,,+Glu mutation in E. coli MetRS leads to inactivation of the ATP-PP, exchange activity of the protein (198),however, and the corresponding Met-Ser-Lys sequence in E . coli GlnRS contacts ATP, not tRNAG'", in the crystal structure of the complex (12),suggesting that the conserved sequence is important for the catalytic site of synthetases rather than for tRNA binding. Site-directed mutagenesis of amino-acid residues in yeast MetRS corresponding to the anticodon binding domain of E. coli MetRS reduce the aminoacylation activity of the yeast enzyme as well (F. Fasiolo, personal communication; Table XIX). Genetic experiments also reveal a mutation in yeast MetRS that compensates for an anticodon base change from CAU to CCU in the yeast initiator tRNA (119).This mutation (Asp,,,pTyr) is located some distance from the presumed anticodon binding domain, based on a model of the enzyme made by sequence comparison with E. coli MetRS, and has not yet been characterized biochemically. B. stearothermophilus TyrRS utilizes a different mode of tRNA binding from those discussed above. The enzyme is a small dimer of identical subunits, each containing 419 amino acids (183).Residues in the amino-terminal domain (1 to 319) make up the active site and the dimerization interface, while residues in the carboxy-terminal domain (320 to 419) are required for tRNA binding (184). A single tRNA binds to both subunits of the enzyme, with protein contacts between the amino-terminal domain of one subunit and the acceptor stem of tRNATyr, and additional strong contacts between the carboxy-terminal domain of the second subunit and other regions of the tRNA (185). A truncated dimer containing only amino acids 1 to 319 does not bind tRNATyr;however, dissociation of the subunits by introducing a mutation at the subunit interface yields monomers capable of binding, but not aminoacylating, the tRNA (186). An extensive set of site-directed mutants of B . stearothermophilus TyrRS has been generated to define the amino-acid residues critical for tRNA binding (187, 188;Table XIX). This analysis has revealed a set of eight positively charged amino acids that make strong contacts to the tRNA, in a manner analogous to the backbone interactions seen in the GlnRS*tRNAG'l) complex. Many of these residues are located in the disordered carboxyterminal domain of the crystal structure of B. stearothermophilus TyrRS (170).However, high-resolution structures of amino acids 1 to 319 complexed with tyrosyl-adenylate and with tyrosine are available (170, 172). These structures, along with the crystal structure of yeast tRNAPhe, and the TyrRS mutational analysis, allow detailed modeling of the interaction between the amino-terminal domain of the protein and the tRNA acceptor stem (187,188).
80
LADONNE
n. SCHULMAN
In the model, contacts are made between GIU,,~, Arg,,,, and Lys,, and phosphate groups 67-70, 73, and 74 (Table XIX). In contrast to the GlnRS complex, the TyrRS model also postulates direct protein contacts to the discriminator base, A,,, a known recognition element of tRNATyr. It is suggested that this base plays a key role in orientation of the 3' end of the tRNA at the active site through interaction with Lys,,,, Glu152, and the main-chain carbonyl of Ala,,, and van der Waals contacts with Trp1=. Study of a mutant of Lys,,, reveals that this amino acid makes an additional contact with tRNATyr in the transition state. Location of Lys,,, near A,, in the model has led to the suggestion that recognition of A,, in the transition state may govern the rate of aminoacylation of tRNAs by TyrRS (188).A,, is positioned close to Lys,, and ArG, at the active site, and the side-chains of Lys,, and Lys,, are near the 2' and 3' OH groups of the terminal ribose in the model. As was observed in the GlnRS*tRNAG'" complex, the TyrRS model reveals a tight complementarity in shape between the structure of the tRNA and the synthetase (188). Overproduction of either E. coli or B . stearothermophilus TyrRS is toxic to E. coli cells (H. Bedouelle, personal communication), suggesting that the Tyr synthetases weakly interact with other tRNAs and mischarge one or more noncognate species when present at elevated concentrations. E. coli GlyRS, yeast PheRS and E. coli PheRS have the subunit structure O L ~ Pbind ~ , two molecules of tRNA per molecule of enzyme, and require both subunits for activity (189-196). Construction of deletion mutants of E. coli GlyRS has shown that the carboxy-terminal half of the @subunit is required for tRNA aminoacylation, but not for ATP-PP, exchange (192).In contrast, the amino-terminal portion (1 to 172) of the P-subunit of yeast PheRS contains the main tRNA binding sites (196). E. cob ThrRS regulates its own expression at the translational level by interacting with a site in the 5' leader region of its mRNA that resembles the anticodon stem and loop of Thr tRNAs (199,200).ThrRS mutants defective in translational repression have been isolated and shown to have increased &'s for the aminoacylation of tRNAThr (201, 202). Point mutations in the mRNA stem-loop structure lead to constitutive synthesis of ThrRS. Mutants of the enzyme (super-repressors) capable of compensating for mutations in the stem structure have been isolated; they aminoacylate tRNAThr with a decreased K , (201,201;Table XIX). In addition, these mutants increase the suppressor activity of an amber suppressor derivative of tRNAzhr which is poorly aminoacylated by wild-type ThrRS (202). Attempts to isolate ThrRS mutants that compensate for mutations in the anticodon-like G.U sequence in the loop of the mRNA structure were unsuccessful, suggesting that such mutants may be toxic to cells as a result of altered specificity in the recognition of tRNA anticodons and the mischarging of noncognate tRNAs.
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
81
As can be seen from the above discussion, there is considerable diversity in the way that tRNAs interact with their cognate synthetases, and no obvious correlation exists between the mode of tRNA binding and the pattern of recognition elements present in the tRNA. Knowledge of the detailed interactions that occur in additional tRNA-synthetase complexes will be required before any common features are revealed, if they exist. Cocrystals of a complex of yeast AspRS(a,), and two molecules of tRNAASpsuitable for high-resolution X-ray analysis have recently been obtained (204). Solution of the structure of this complex is eagerly awaited.
IX. Concluding Remarks The next few years promise exciting new developments in our understanding of tRNA-synthetase recognition. Mutational analysis of tRNAs is proceeding at a rapid pace, and should lead to the definition of major recognition sites in many tRNAs in the near future. Solution of new crystal structures and accompanying mutational studies will soon provide new insights into the tRNA binding sites of additional proteins. The wealth of information obtained from the cocrystal structure of E. coli GlnRS and tRNAGln has inspired renewed efforts in many laboratories to obtain crystals of additional tRNA-synthetase complexes. Recognition of tRNAs by GlnRS involves base-specific protein-RNA contacts, a base-specific RNA-RNA contact, and dramatic local conformational changes in the tRNA. It remains to be determined whether all or only some of these features are conserved in other tRNA-synthetase interactions, and to what extent recognition involves conformational changes in the proteins as well. The requirement for cognate tRNA in the activation of amino acids by ArgRS, GlnRS, and GluRS implies the induction of structural changes at the active sites of these enzymes on tRNA binding. The structure of the GlnRS.tRNAG’”complex suggests that there may be structural connectivity between the anticodon binding domain and the active site domain. Changes in key recognition elements are often seen to d e c t both K , and kcat for aminoacylation, suggesting that initial binding may be followed by a reorientation of the 3’ terminus of the tRNA at the active site and/or by induced changes in the enzyme structure. Early experiments suggested that synthetases may undergo conformational transitions dependent on the binding of cognate tRNAs (205). Additional solution studies directed at resolving discrete steps in tRNA recognition and catalysis during aminoacylation and their dependence on specific sequences in the tRNA and protein would be useful in clarifying the dynamic aspects of the recognition process. Additional studies of the deacylation activity of synthetases toward mischarged tRNAs would also be useful to determine whether identical struc-
82
LADONNE
n. SCHULMAN
tural features in tRNAs govern the aminoacylation reaction and the aminoacyl-tRNA hydrolysis reaction catalyzed by these enzymes. In vioo approaches to the study of tRNA identity would benefit from greater flexibility in the types of test tRNAs that can be assayed, and from greater attention to the balance of tRNA and synthetase levels in the cell. The design of suitable in uiuo assays remains a formidable challenge, which will occupy some of us for years to come.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank all my colleagues who provided preprints and results of unpublished studies for use in this review. I am also grateful to Gourisankar Ghosh and Leo Pallanck for a critical reading of the manuscript, and to Rita Romita for expert typing. Studies carried out in my laboratory were supported by research grants GM16995 from the National Institutes of Health and NP-19 from the American Cancer Society.
REFERENCES 1. S.-H. Kim, F. L. Suddath, G. J. Quigley, A. McPherson, J. L. Sussman, A. H. J. Wang, N. C. Seeman and A. Rich, Science 185,435 (1974). 2. J. D. Robertus, J. E. Ladner, J. T. Finch, D. Rhodes, R. S. Brown, B. F. C. Clark and A. Klug, Nature 250, 546 (1974). 3. E. Westhof, P. Dumas and D. Moras, ] M B 184, 119 (1985). 4. P. Schimmel, ARB 56, 125 (1987). 5. L. L. Kisselev, This Series 32, 237 (1985). 6. P. R. Schimmel and D. So11, ARB 48, 601 (1979). 7. J. Normanly and J. Abelson, ARB 58, 1029 (1989). 8. P. Schimmel, Bchem 28, 2747 (1989). 9. L. H. Schulman and J. Abelson, Science 240, 1591 (1988). 10. M . Yarus, Cell 55, 739 (1988). 11. U. L. RajBhandary, Nature 336, 112 (1988). 12. M . A. Rould, J. J. Perona, D. So11 and T. A. Steitz, Science 246, 1135 (1989). 13. J. J. Perona, R. N. Swanson, M. A. Rould, T. A. Steitz and D. Soll, Science 246, 1152 (1989). 14. H. Bedouelle and G. Winter, Nature 320, 371 (1986). 15. E. Labouze and H. Bedouelle, ] M B 205, 729 (1989). 16. S. Brunie, C. Zelwer and J.-L. Rider, ]MB 216, 411 (1990). 17. P. Mellot, Y. Mechulam, D. LeCorre, S. Blanquet and G . Fayat, J M B 208, 429 (1989). 18. G. Ghosh, H. Pelka and L. H. Schulman, Bchem 29, 2220 (1990). 19. J. Normanly, R. C. Ogden, S. J. Horvath and J. Abelson, Nature 321, 213 (1986). 20. R. Cieg6, D. Kern and J.-P. Ebel, Biochimie 54, 1245 (1972). 21. D. Kern, R. Gieg6 and J.-P. Ebel, EJB 31, 148 (1972). 22. M. Yarus, Bchem 11, 2352 (1972). 23. M. Mertes, M. A. Peters, W. Mahoney and M. Yam, ] M B 71, 671 (1972). 24. L. H. Schulman, in “Transfer RNA: Structure, Properties and Recognition” (P. Schimmel, D. Sol1 and J. Abelson, eds.), p. 311. CSHLab, Cold Spring Harbor, New York, 1979. 25. J. D. Smith, in “Nonsense Mutations and tRNA Suppressors” (J. E. Celis and J. D. Smith, eds.), p. 109. Academic Press, New York, 1979. 26. H. Ozeki, H. Inokuchi, F. Yamao, M. Kodaira, H. Sakano, T. Ikemura and Y. Shimura, in
RECOGNITION OF
27. 28. 29. 30. 31.
32. 33. 34.
35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41.
tRNAs
83
“Transfer RNA: Biological Aspects” (D. So11, J. Ahelson and P. R. Schimmel, eds.), p. 341. CSHLab, Cold Spring Harbor, New York, 1980. C. Squires and J. Carbon, Nature N B 233, 274 (1971). J. W. Roberts and J. Carbon, Nature 250, 412 (1974). A. G. Bruce and 0. C. Uhlenheck, Bchem 21, 855 (1982). H. Uemura, M. Imai, E. Ohtsuka, M. Ikehara and D. SOH, NARes 10, 6531 (1982). E. Ohtsuka, S. Tanaka, T. Tanaka, T. Miyake, A. F. Markham, E. Nakagawa, T. Wakahayashi, Y. Taniyama, S. Nishikawa, R. Fukumoto, H. Uemura, T. Doi, T. Tokunaga and M. Ikehara, PNAS 78, 5493 (1981). B. L. Seong and U. L. RajBhandary, PNAS 84, 334 and 8859 (1987). J. J. Perona, R . Swanson, T. A. Steitz and D. Soll, J M B 202, 121 (1988). T. Meinnel, Y. Mechulam and G . Fayat, NARes 16, 8095 (1988). Y.-M. Hou and P. Schimmel, Nature 333, 140 (1988). S. J. Park, Y.-M. Hou and P. Schimmel, Bchem 28, 2740 (1989). J. R. Sampson and 0. C. Uhlenheck, PNAS 85, 1033 (1988). T. Samuelsson, T. Boren, T.-I. Johansen and F. Lustig, JBC 263, 13692 (1988). K. B. Hall, J. R. Sampson, 0. C. Uhlenheck and A. G. Redfield, Bchem 28,5794 (1989). T. Hasegawa, H. Himeno, H. Ishikura and M. Shimizu, BBRC 163, 1534 (1989). V. Perret, A. Garcia, H. Grosjean, J.-P. Ehel, C. Florentz and R. Gieg6, Nature 344, 787 (1990).
42. H. Himeno, T. Hasegawa, T. Ueda, K. Watanahe, K. Miura and M. Shimuzu, NARes 17, 7855 (1989).
43. 44. 45. 46.
L. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, Science 242, 765 (1988). L. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, NARes 18, 285 (1990). W.-C. Chu and J. Horowitz, NARes 17, 7241 (1989). Y. Shimura, A. Aono, H. Ozeki, A. Sarahhai, H. Lamfrom and J. Ahelson, FEBS Lett. 22, 144 (1972).
47. M. L. Hooper, R. Russell and J. D. Smith, FEBS Lett. 22, 149 (1972). 48. J. D. Smith and J. E. Celis, Nature N B 243, 66 (1973). 49. J. E. Celis, M. L. Hooper and J. D. Smith, Nature N B 244, 261 (1973). 50. A. Ghysen and J. E. Celis, J M B 83, 333 (1974). 51. H. Inokuchi, J. E. Celis and J. D. Smith, J M B 85, 187 (1974). 52. J. Normanly, J.-M. Masson, L. G. Kleina, J. Ahelson and J. H. Miller, PNAS 83, 6548 (1986).
53. J.-M. Masson and J. H. Miller, Gene 47, 179 (1986). 54. W. H. McClain and K. Foss, Science 240, 793 (1988). 55. W. H. McClain and K. Foss, Science 241, 1804 (1988). 56. W. H. McClain, Y.-M. Chen, K. Foss and J. Schneider, Science 242, 1681 (1988). 57. W. H. McClain and K. Foss, J M B 202, 697 (1988). 58. Y.-M. Hou and P. Schimmel, Nature 333, 140 (1988). 59. Y.-M. Hou and P. Schimmel. Bchem 28, 4942 (1989). 60. Y.-M. Hou and P. Schimmel, Bchem 28, 6800 (1989). 61. M. J. Rogers and D. Soll, PNAS 85, 6627 (1988). 62. M .Yarus, S. W. Cline, P. Wier, L. Breeden and R. C. Thompson,JMB 192, 235 (1986). 63. M. Yarus, Nature N B 239, 106 (1972). 64. R. Swanson, P. Hoben, M. Sumner-Smith, H. Uemura, L. Watson and D. SOH, Science 242, 1548 (1988). 65. E. J. Murgola, ARGen 19, 57 (1985).
66. N. E. Prather, E. J. Murgola and B. H. Mims,JMB 172, 177 (1984). 67. R. Chattapadhyay, H. Pelka and L. H. Schulman, Bchem 29, 4263 (1990).
a4
LADONNE H. SCHULMAN
670. L. Pallanck and L. H. Schulman, PNAS 88, in press (1991). 68. B. L. Seong and U. L. RajBhandary, PNAS 84, 8859 (1987). 69. B. L. Seong, C.-P. Lee and U. L. RajBhandary, JBC 246, 6504 (1989). 70. D. L. Riddle and J. Carbon, Nature N B 242, 230 (1973). 71. L. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, PNAS 80, 6755 (1983). 72. J. F. Curran and M. Yarus, Science 238, 1545 (1987). 73. C. M. Cummins, T. F. Donahue and M. R. Culbertson, PNAS 79, 3565 (1982). 74. R. F. Gaber and M. R. Culbertson, MCBiol4, 2052 (1984). 75. L. Bossi and D. M. Smith, PNAS 81, 6105 (1984). 76. J. R. Roth, Cell 24, 601 (1981). 77. L. Fralova and L. L. Kisselev, Biokhimiya (Moscow) 29, 1177 (1964). 78. C. Mathews and K. van Holde, “Biochemistry,” p. 962. Benjamin-Cummings, Redwood City, California, 1990. 79. M. Yaniv, W. R. Folk, P. Berg and L. Soll, J M B 86, 245 (1974). 80. M . Yarus, R. G . Knowlton and L. Soll, in “Nucleic Acid-Protein Recognition” (H. Vogel, ed.), p. 391. Academic Press, New York, 1977. 81. R. G. Knowlton, L. Sol1 and M. Yarus, ] M B 139, 705 (1980). 82. L. H. Schulman and J. P. Goddard, JBC 248, 1341 (1973). 83. K. Chakraburtty, NARes 2, 1793 (1975). 84. R . W. Chambers, S. Aoyasi, Y. Furukawa, H. Zawadzka and 0. Bhanot, JBC 248, 5549 (1973). 85. H. Pelka and L. H. Schulman, Bchem 25, 4450 (1986). 86. A. Theobald, M. Springer, M. Grunberg-Manago, J.-P. Ebel and R. GiegC, EJB 175,511 (1988). 87. R. W. Chambers, 0. S. Bhanot, S. Aoyagi, Y. Furukawa and H. Zawada, FP 33, 1422 (1974). 88. M. S. Qiu, Y. X. Jin, W. Q. Li, J. R. Bao and D. Wang, Sci. Sin. [ B ] 31, 695 (1988). 89. Y. X. Jin, M. S . Qiu, W. Q. Li, K. Q. Zeng, J. Bao, P. Gong, R. Wu and D. Wang, Anal. Biochem. 161, 453 (1987). 90. L. Raftery and M. Yarus, J M B 184, 343 (1985). 91. R. P. Singhal, Bchem 13, 2924 (1974). 92. C. W. Hill, G. Combriato and W. Dolph, J . Bact. 117, 351 (1974). 93. D. L. Riddle and J. Carbon, Nature N B 242, 230 (1973). 94. E. L. Sabban and 0. S. Bhanot, JBC 257, 4796 (1982). 95. T.Muramatsu, K. Nishikawa, F. Nemoto, Y. Kuchino, S. Nishimura, T.Miyazawa and S. Yokoyama, Nature 336, 179 (1988). 96. L. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, PNAS 80, 6755 (1983). 97. L. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, Bchem 24, 7309 (1985). 98. L. Stern and L. H. Schulman, JBC 252, 6403 (1977). 99. M. Rould, J. J. Perona and T. Steitz, personal communication. ZOO. L. H. Schulman and H. Pelka, Science 246, 1595 (1989). 101. A. G . Bruce and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchern 21, 3921 (1982). 101a. H. Himeno, T. Hasegawa, T. Ueda, K. Watanabe and M. Shimizu, NARes. 18, 6815 (1990). 102. M. Springer, M. GraEe, J. Dondon and M. Grunberg-Manago, E M B O J . 8, 2417 (1989). 103. V. Scheinker, S. F. Beresten, T.D. Mashkova, A. M. Mazo and L. L. Kisselev, F E E S Lett. 132, 349 (1981). 104. L. A. Bare and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 25, 5825 (1986). 105. L. A. Bare and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 24, 2354 (1985). 106. 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Chem. Scr. 26B, 97 (1986).
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
85
107. L. G. Kleina, J.-M. Masson, J. Normanly, J. Abelson and J. H. Miller, J M B 213, 705 (1990). 108. J. Normanly, L. G. Kleina. J.-M. Masson, J. Abelson and J. H. Miller, J M B 213, 719 (1990). 109. M . Springer, M. GrafTe, J. S. Butler and M. Grunberg-Manago, PNAS 83, 4384 (1986). 110. H. Moine, P. Romby, M. Springer, M. Grunberg-Manago, J.-P. Ebel, C. Ehresmann and B. Ehresmann, PNAS 85, 7892 (1988). 111. M .Springer, M. Graffe, J. Dondon, M. Grunberg-Manago, P. Romby, B. Ehresmann, C. Ehresmann and J.-P. Ebel, Biosci. Rep. 8, 619 (1988). 112. M . Sprinzl, T. Hartmann, J. Weher, J. Blank and R. Zeidler, NARes 17, r l (1989). 113. U. Varshney and U. L. RajBhandary, PNAS 87, 1586 (1990). 114. U. L. RajBhandary and H. P. Ghosh, JBC 244, 1104 (1969). 115. K. Takeishi, T. Ukita and S. Nishirnura, JBC 243, 5761 (1968). 116. M. Simsek, U. L. RajBhandary, M. Boisnard and G. Petrissant, Nature 247, 518 (1974). 117. P. Guillemaut and J. H. Weil, BBA 407, 240 (1975). 118. D. R. Smith and J. M. Calvo, NARes 8, 2255 (1980). 119. A. M. Cigan, L. Feng and T. F. Donahue, Science 242, 93 (1988). 120. D. M. Crothers, T. Seno and D. G. Still, PNAS 69, 3063 (1972). 121. C. deDuve, Nature 333, 117 (1988). 122. C. Francklyn and P. Schimmel, Nature 337, 478 (1989). 123. S. J. Park and P. Schimmel, JBC 263, 16527 (1988). 124. N. E. Prather, E. J. Murgola and B. H. Mims, JMB 172, 177 (1984). 125. E. J. Murgola and K. A. Hijazi, MGG 191, 132 (1983). 126. J.-P. Shi, C. Francklyn, K. Hill and P. Schimmel, Bchem 29, 3621 (1990). 127. M. Jasin, L. Regan and P. Schimmel, JBC 260, 2226 (1985). 128. T. Atilgan, H. B. Nicholas, Jr., and W. H. McClain, NARes 14, 375 (1986). 129. W. H. McClain and H. B. Nicholas, Jr.. JMB 194, 635 (1987). 130. N. Imura, G. B. Weiss and R. W. Chambers, Nature 222, 1147 (1969). 131. F. Zinoni, A. Birkman, T. Stadtrnan and A. Bock, PNAS 83, 4650 (1986). 132. W. Leinfelder, E. Zehelein, M. Mandrand-Berthelot and A. Bock, Nature 331, 723 (1988). 133. P. Hoben, Ph.D. thesis, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, 1984. 134. C. E. Singer and G. R. Smith, JBC 247, 2989 (1972). 135. 0. Orellana, L. Cooley and D. Soll, MCBiol 6, 525 (1986). 136. L. Cooley, B. Appel and D. Soll, PNAS 79, 6475 (1982). 137. E. Labouze and H. Bedouelle, J M B 205, 729 (1989). 138. J. E. Ladner, A. Jack, J. D. Robertus, R. S. Brown, D. Rhodes, B. F. C. Clark and A. Klug, PNAS 72, 4414 (1975). 1380. W. H. McClain, K. Foss, R. A. Jenkins and J. Schneider, PNAS 87, 9260 (1990). 139, J. R. Sampson, A. B. DiRenzo, L. S. Behlen and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Science 243, 1363 (1989). 140. J. R . Sampson, A. B. DiRenzo, L. S. Behlen and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 29,2515 (1990). 141. L. S. Behlen, J. R . Sampson, A. B. DiRenzo and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem29,2523 (1990). 142. K. B. Hall, J. R . Sampson, 0. C. Uhlenbeck and A. 6. Redfield, Bchem 28,5794 (1989). 143. P. Romby, D. Moras, M. Bergdoll, P. Dumas, V. V. Vlassov, E. Westhof, J. P. EbelandR. Giegk, J M B 184, 455 (1985). 144. A. Jack, J. E. Ladner, D. Rhodes, R. S. Brown and A. Klug, JMB 111, 315 (1977). 145. W. J. Krzyzosiak, T. Marciniec, M. Wiewiorowski, P. Romby, J. P. Ebel and R. Gieg6, Bchein 27, 5771 (1988).
86
LADONNE 11. SCHULMAN
146. D. Moras, A. C. Dock, P. Dumas, E. Westhof, P. Romby, J. P. Ebel and R. GiegC, PNAS 83, 932 (1986). 147. F. Harada and S. Nishimura, Bchem 13, 300 (1974). 148. T.Muramatsu, S. Yokoyama, N. Horie, A. Matsuda, T.Ueda, Z. Yamaizumi, Y. Kuchino, S. Nishimura and T.Miyazawa, JBC 263, 9261 (1988). 149. T.Muramatsu, K. Nishikawa, F. Nemoto, Y. Kuchino, S. Nishimura, T.Miyazawa and S. Yokoyama, Nature 336, 179 (1988). 150. V. Perret, A. Garcia, H. Grosjean, J,-P, Ebel, C. Florentz and R . GiegC, Nature 344, 787
(1990). 151. J. P. Ebel, R. Gieg6, J. Bonnet, D. Kern, N . Befort, C. Bollack, F. Fasiolo, J. Gangloffand G . Dirheimer, Biochimie 55, 547 (1973). 152. B. Roe, M . Michael and B. Dudock, Nature 246, 135 (1973). 153. T.McCutchan, S. Silverman, J. Kohli and D. Soll, Bchem 17, 1622 (1978). 154. A. L. Haenni, S. Joshi and F. Chapeville, This Series 27, 85 (1982). 156. F. Yamao, H. Inokuchi, A. Cheung, H. Ozeki and D. Soll, JBC 257, 11639 (1982). 157. P. Hoben, N. Royal, A. Cheung, F. Yamao, K. Biemann and D. Soll, JBC 257, 11644 158. 159. 160. 161. 162. 163. 164. 165. 166. 167. 168. 169. 170. 171. 172. 173. 174. 175. 176. 177. 178. 179. 180. 181. 182. 183. 184. 185. 186. 187.
(1982). J. J. Perona, R. Swanson, T.A. Steitz and D. Soll,]MB 202, 121 (1988). A. Rich and P. R. Schimmel, NARes 4, 1649 (1977). H. Inokushi, P. Hoben, F. Yamao, H. Ozeki and D. Soll, PNAS 81, 5076 (1984). S. D. Putney, N. J. Royal, H. N. deVegvar, W. C. Herlihy, K. Biemann and P. Schimmel. Science 213, 1497 (1981). M. Jasin, L. Regan and P. Schimmel, Nature 306, 441 (1983). K. Hill and P. Schimmel, Bchem 28, 2577 (1989). L. Regan, L. Buxbaum, K. Hill and P. Schimmel, JBC 263, 18598 (1988). M. Jasin, L. Regan and P. Schimmel, JBC 260, 2226 (1985). L. Regan, J. Bowie and P. Schimmel, Science 235, 1651 (1987). S. Brunie, P. Mellot, C. Zelwer, J.-L. Risler, S. Blanquet and G . Fayat, J . Mol. Graphics 5, 18 (1987). C. Zelwer, J. L. Risler and S. Brunie, J M B 155, 63 (1982). T.N. Bhat, D. M. Blow, P. Brick and J. Nyberg, JMB 158, 699 (1982). D. M. Blow and P. Brick, in “Biological Macromolecules and Assemblies” ( J . A. Jurnak and A. McPherson, eds.), Vol. 2, p. 442. Wiley, New York, 1985. P. Brick, T. N. Bhat and D. M. Blow, J M B 208, 83 (1989). P. Brick and D. M. Blow, J M B 194, 287 (1987). D. G. Barker. J. P. Ebel, R. Jakes and C. J. Bruton, EJB 127, 449 (1982). F. Dardel, G. Fayat and S. Blanquet, J . Bact. 160, 1115 (1984). D. Cassio and J. P. Waller, EJB 20, 283 (1971). P. Mellot, Y. Mechulam, D. LeCorre, S. Blanquet and 6. Fayat, ] M E 208, 429 (1989). D. Valenzuela and L. H. Schulman, Bchem 25, 4555 (1986). 0. Leon and L. H. Schulman, Bchem 26, 5416 (1987). C. Hountondji, S . Blanquet and F. Lederer, Bchem 24, 1175 (1985). C. Hountondji, F. Lederer, P. Dessen and S. Blanquet, Bchem 25, 16 (1986). C. Hountondji, P. Dessen and S. Blanquet, Biochimie 68, 1071 (1986). G. Prevost, G. Eriani, D. Kern, G. Dirheimer and J. Gangloff, EJB 180, 351 (1989). G. Winter, G. L. E. Koch, B. S. Hartley and D. G. Barker, EJB 132, 383 (1983). M. Waye, G . Winter, A. J. Wilkinson and A. R. Fersht, EMBO J . 2, 1827 (1983). P. Carter, H. Bedouelle and G. Winter, PNAS 83, 1189 (1986). A. R. Fersht, Bchem 26, 8031 (1987). H. Bedouelle and G. Winter, Nature 320, 371 (1986).
RECOGNITION OF
tRNAs
87
188. E. Labouze and H. Bedouelle, J M B 205, 729 (1989). 189. G . M. Nagel, S. Cumberledge, M. S. Johnson, E. Petrella and B. Weber, NARes 12, 4377 (1984). 190. T. A. Wehster, B. W. Gibson, T. Keng, K. Biemann and P. Schimmel, JBC 258, 10637 (1983). 191. A. T. Profy and P. Schimmel, JBC 261, 15474 (1986). 192. M. J. Toth and P. Schimmel, JBC 265, loo0 (1990). 193. Y. Mechulam, G . Fayat and S. Blanquet, J. Bact. 163, 787 (1985). 194. A. Dueruix, N. Hounwanou, J. Reinbolt, Y. Boulanger and S. Blanquet, BBA 741, 244 (1983). 195. F. Fasiolo, N . Befort, Y. Boulanger and J:P. Ebel, BBA 217, 305 (1970). 196. F. Fasiolo, A. Sanni, S. Potier, J.-P. Ebel and Y. Boulanger, FEBS Lett. 242, 351 (1989). 196a. P. Walter, L. Despoils, M. Laforet, J.-P. Ebel and F. Fasiolo, Biochimie 72, 537 (1990). 197. F. Lawrence, S . Blanquet, M. Poiret, M. Robert-Gero and J. P. Waller, EJB 36, 234 (1973). 198. A. Brevet, J. Chen, F. Leveque, P. Plateau and S. Blanquet, PNAS 86, 8275 (1989). 199. H. Moine, P. Romby, M. Springer, M. Grunberg-Manago, J.-P. Ebel, C. Ehresmann and B. Ehresmann, PNAS 85, 7892 (1988). 200. M. Springer, M . Graffe, J.S. Butler and M. Grunberg-Manago, PNAS 83, 4384 (1986). 201. M. Springer, M. Graffe, J. Dondon, M. Grunberg-Manago, P. Romby, B. Ehresmann, C. Ehresmann and J.-P. Ebel, Biosci. Rep. 8, 619 (1988). 202. M. Springer, M. Graffe, J. Dondon and M. Grunherg-Manago, E M B O J . 8, 2417 (1989). 203. K. Muench, JBC 251, 5195 (1976). 204. M. Ruff, J. Caverelli, V. Mikol, B. h r b e r , A. Mitschler, R. Gieg6, J. C. Thierry and D. Moras, J M B 201, 235 (1988). 205. D. Riesner, A. Pingoud, D. Boehme, F. Peters and G . Maass, EJB 68, 71 (1976).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Ribosome Biogenesis in Yeast'
I
I
H. A. RAud
AND
R. J. PLANTA~
Biochemisch kboratorium Vrije Unioersiteit 1081 HV Amsterdom, The Netherlands
I. Transcription of Ribosomal-RNA Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Genetic Organization and Structure of Yeast rRNA Genes . . . . . . . . . 8. Transcription Initiation by Yeast RNA Pol I ...................... C. Transcription Termination by Yeast RNA Pol D. Regulation of Yeast RNA-Pol-I Transcription .............. E. Transcription of 5-S rRNA by Yeast RNA Pol 11. Expression of Ribosomal-protein Genes . . . . . . . A. Genetic Organization and Structure of Yeast Ribosomal-protein Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Transcriptional Regulation of Ribosomal-protein Synthesis . . . . C. Post-transcriptional Regulation of Ribosomal-protein Synthesis . . . . . 111. Processing and Assembly of Ribosomal Constituents . . , , , , . , A. Processing of Pre-rRNA ................... B. Modification of Pre-rRNA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Modification of Ribosomal Proteins ........................ D. Nucletxytoplasmic Transport and Assembly ..................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
91 91 92 99 101 102 103 103 104 109 111 111 116 117 118 124
The formation of functional ribosomes is a highly complex phenomenon requiring the interplay of a large number of molecular processes. Ribosomes contain, depending on their origin, some 60-80 different components, proteins as well as RNA molecules, most in a single copy per ribosome. Since normally growing cells generally contain no free pools of these ribosomal components, the expression of the numerous ribosomal genes must be subject to tight coordinate control to ensure the production of equimolar amounts of the various rRNA and ribosomal-protein (r-protein) constituents.
1 Abbreviations and terminology: r-protein or rp-: ribosomal protein; rp-mRNA, rp-gene: mRNA, gene encoding r-protein; snRNA: small nuclear RNA; ITS: internal transcribed spacer; ETS: external transcribed spacer; NTS: non-transcribed spacer; YEp: yeast episomal plasmid; YCp: yeast centromeric plasmid; UAS: upstream activating sequence; NLS: nuclear localization signal; RAP: repressor-activator protein; ABF: ARS-binding factor (SUF); linker-scanning: mutational analysis in which consecutive regions of a DNA sequence are replaced one by one by a synthetic oligonucleotide; confocal laser scanning microscopy: microscope technique employing zero depth-of-field, which allows sequential focusing on different planes within a cell; RPG: ribosomal protein gene; TUF: transcription upstream factor. 2 To whom correspondence may be addressed.
89 Progress in Nucleic Acid Hesearch and Molrrular Liiol0gy. Nil, 41
Copyright 0 1991 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights nfreproduction in any form reserved.
90
n. A.
F L W ~ AND R. J. PLANTA
In addition, cells can increase or decrease the expression of all members of the set of ribosomal genes in a concerted fashion in response to variations in environmental conditions, such as amino-acid deprivation, and changes in carbon source or temperature, which alter the demand for protein biosynthetic capacity. As far as prokaryotic (i.e., Escherichia coli) ribosome biogenesis is concerned, the main features of this regulation have now been elucidated (1,2). Control of ribosome biogenesis in E. coli involves a number of linked feedback loops in which excess ribosomes, in some as yet not completely understood way that requires translational initiation, inhibit rRNA (and incidentally also tRNA) transcription. The balance between the synthesis of rRNA and r-protein is subsequently redressed mainly, although not exclusively, through the action at the translational level of a small number of r-proteins. These “repressor” r-proteins all bind individually to either 16-S or 23-S rRNA. However, upon failing to find an rRNA partner, they instead associate with their own mRNA and in this way prevent further translation. Since the polycistronic E. cob mRNAs encoding r-proteins (rp-mRNA) show a phenomenon called “translational coupling,” binding of a single specific repressor r-protein blocks expression of a complete translational unit and thus the production of all, or at least a large number, of the r-proteins encoded by the mRNA in question. In this way, r-protein translation is directly coupled to the assembly process. Ribosome assembly in prokaryotes has been studied mainly in in uitro assembly systems. These studies have led to the elucidation of the assembly pathways for both the small and large subunits (3, 4 ) and have recently resulted in the identification of the “initiator” r-proteins (5, 6), whose association with the rRNA forms the first step in the assembly process. While the end result of regulation of ribosome biogenesis in eukaryotes is the same as in prokaryotes-namely, equimolar production of all ribosomal constituents-it should be realized that different means must be used to achieve this goal, since ribosome formation in eukaryotic cells differs from that in prokaryotes in several hndamental aspects: (a) it involves the participation of three different RNA polymerases; (b) there are (often considerable) differences in gene dosage for the individual components, even those of the same type; (c) the genes encoding r-proteins (rp-genes) do not form operons; and (d) the various stages in the formation of ribosomal constituents, as well as their assembly into active ribosomes, occur in different cellular compartments. Because of its accessibility to genetic and physiological manipulation, the yeast Saccharomyces cereuisiae has become one of the most popular organisms for studying the questions raised by the coordinate control of ribosome biogenesis in eukaryotes. The genes for the various yeast rRNAs as well as
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
91
those for about 40 of the yeast r-proteins have been cloned and subjected to detailed studies. As a result, the amount of information collected on the structure and function of ribosomal genes in yeast surpasses that available for any other eukaryote. This information has given us important insights into the regulatory mechanisms controlling the expression of these genes. In addition, progress has been made in our laboratory in developing systems that provide access to the hitherto largely unexplored field of eukaryotic ribosome assembly, including the mechanism of rRNA processing. Although there is still a long way to go, these studies should eventually lead to a full description of the way in which ribosomes are formed in yeast cells, as well as the mechanisms by which the rate of ribosome formation is adjusted to the requirements of the cell at any given moment.
1. Transcription of Ribosomal-RNA Genes A. Genetic Organization and Structure of Yeast rRNA Genes The genetic organization of the rRNA genes in S. cerevisiae is basically similar to that found in other eukaryotes. The S. cerevisiae genome contains a cluster of approximately 140-200 repeats of a 9. l-kb rDNA unit arranged in tandem on the long arm of chromosome XI1 (7). In addition, R-loop analysis has revealed the presence in yeast cells of a small number of circular DNA molecules consisting of one or more of these rDNA units, whose function is still unclear (8).However, since replicative intermediates of these circular molecules have been observed occasionally, they may play a role in regulating rRNA gene dosage. The organization of the tandem repeats of S. cereoisiae rDNA, as well as the fine structure of one such repeat, is depicted in Fig. 1A. Each unit contains a single operon transcribed by RNA polymerase I (Pol I), which encompasses one gene each for 1 7 4 , 5 . 8 3 , and 2 6 3 rRNA3, in that order. The three genes are separated by two internal transcribed spacers (ITS1 and -9, while external transcribed spacers (ETSs) are present upstream from the 17-S gene and downstream from the 26-S gene. The latter ETS (3’ ETS) is considerably longer than originally supposed on the basis of structural analysis of the longest Pol-I precursor transcript (37-S pre-rRNA) detectable in yeast cells (see Section 1,C) (9). The ITS and ETS sequences are removed post-transcriptionally in an ordered series of steps (see Section 111,A). Pro-
3 The actual numbers by which the two high-molecular-weight rRNA species as well as the precursor transcripts derived from the rRNA operon are indicated vary slightly from one laboratory to another.
92
ti. A. R A UAND ~ R. J . PLANTA
FIG. 1. Fine structure of the rDNA repeat of the yeast S. cereoisioe. (A) Slightly more than one repeat is shown to clarify the tandem nature of the repeats in the rDNA locus. Regions encoding the mature rRNA sequences are indicated by black bars. Striped boxes represent regions involved in transcription initiation. Pol-I and Pol-111 transcription-initiation sites are indicated by bent arrows. Shaded bars correspond to transcribed, open bars to non-transcribed, spacer sequences. An exception has been made for the region between T2 and T3B, which appears to be transcribed by only a minor portion of the Pol-I molecules (see Section 1.C). TO through Tp indicate the positions of processing sites (0)and termination sites (0)for Pol I. (B) The general structure of an rRNA minigene is shown. The length of the initiating and 3'-endgenerating fragments varies, depending on the purpose of the experiment. The reporter fragment is a piece of DNA not normally present in yeast.
cessing of the 3' ETS must occur rapidly, since no precursor containing this complete ETS can be detected in uiuo. Each pair of rRNA operons in the rDNA cluster is separated by about 2 kb of non-transcribed spacer (NTS), divided into two parts (NTS1 and -2) by a single 5-S rRNA gene. Thus, in S. cereuisiae, in contrast to most other eukaryotes, the number of 5-S rRNA genes equals that of the genes for the other rRNA species. The 5-S gene is transcribed by RNA Pol I11 into a precursor having a short 3' extension (7-13 nucleotides) relative to the mature 5-S rRNA molecule (10). The direction of transcription of the 5-S gene is opposite that of the large rRNA operon. A number of additional 5-S rRNA genes differing from those in the 9.1-kb repeats are located at the telomere-proximal end of the array (11). However, it is not known whether these genes are transcriptionally active. No 5-S rRNA sequence heterogeneity within one specific S. cereuisiae strain has come to our attention.
B. Transcription Initiation by Yeast RNA Pol I The first indication concerning sequence elements important for transcription initiation by yeast Pol I came from a comparative analysis of the regions containing the initiation sites in five different, but evolutionarily relatively closely related, yeast strains (12).The Pol-I transcription-initiation
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
93
site in Saccharomyces arbb berg ens is,^ S. cerevisiae, Saccharomyces rosei, Klu yveromyces lactis, and Hansenula wingei, all members of the subfamily Saccharomycetoideae, has been mapped by SL nuclease, R-loop, and reverse transcription analyses, using the 3 7 4 precursor transcript of the large rRNA operon as a reference. This precursor carries a 5‘-triphosphate group, indicating that it has not been subjected to processing at its 5’ terminus (13,14). In each case, the 5’ end of the 37-S precursor mapped at a unique position located within a 23-bp sequence (positions -9 to $14 with respect to the start site) that, in contrast to the adjacent NTS and ETS sequences, is strongly conserved in all five strains. Therefore, this conservation was taken to indicate an important role for the sequence in Pol-I transcription. Functional analysis of the yeast Pol-I promoter has been limited almost exclusively to in uivo experiments, using cells transformed with mutant rRNA genes, although in vitro systems based on permeabilized cells (15), isolated nuclei (16), or crude cell extracts (17) have been described. However, these systems suffer from the drawback that they are too inflexible to allow detailed mutational analyses. Only recently has a yeast in vitro system been developed that exhibits faithful transcription by Pol I (18). Therefore, most of our present knowledge of the yeast Pol-I promoter is derived from in vivo experiments using cells transformed with genes carrying mutant Pol-I promoters. However, it was necessary to find a way to distinguish the transcripts of these mutant genes from those produced by the inevitable excess of wild-type chromosomal rDNA units. This problem was solved by using the “rRNA minigene assay system” (19-21). The basic minigene (Fig. 1B) consists of two rRNA regions, an “initiating fragment” and a “3’-end-generating fragment” separated by a “reporter” sequence of foreign origin that allows specific detection of the minigene transcript by Northern hybridization. The initiating and 3’-end-generating fragments consist of the 5’ and 3’ ends of the rRNA operon, respectively, each flanked by a length of spacer sequence sufficient to include the elements required for correct initiation on the one hand and formation of a discrete 3’ end on the other. The minigenes of rRNA can be introduced into yeast cells using either episomal (both YEpand YCp-type) or integrating vectors (20, 22, 23). In all cases, the minigenes are indeed transcribed by Pol I, as shown by the insensitivity of their transcription to high concentrations of a-amanitin (20, 22). Using the minigene system, the borders of the yeast Pol-I promoter were defined by deletion mapping (24). Starting with an initiating fragment encompassing the sequence between positions -207 and + 128 with respect to the transcription start site, we found that transcription remained unaffected 4 Recently, it has become clear that S. carlsbergensis is in fact not a separate species, but should also be classified as belonging to the species cerevisiae.
94
H. A. RAUt AND R. J . PLANTA
by 5’ deletions up to position -149. However, removal of an additional 16 bp reduced transcription by more than 80%, indicating that the sequence between positions - 149 and - 133 contains an important part of the yeast Pol-I promoter. Analysis of 3’-deletion mutants showed that no more than 15 bp downstream from the start site are required for accurate and efficient transcription. This downstream border of the Pol-I promoter coincides with the 3’ end of the conserved sequence identified in the comparative studies described above. To analyze the fine structure of the yeast Pol-I promoter, a series of linker-scanning mutants was constructed covering the region between - 146 and +8 (25). When the transcription of minigenes carrying these mutant promoters (in the context of an otherwise wild-type, full-length NTS), was quantified, we found that the yeast Pol-I promoter consists of three distinct domains (Fig. 2). Mutations in either domain I (-28 to +8)5 or domain I1 (-70 to -50) had a severe negative effect on the efficiency of transcription, reducing the amount of correctly initiated transcripts to 4-10% of the control. The sequence of the region separating domains I and I1 appeared not to be crucial for Pol-I transcription, although linker-scanning mutations in this region did reduce the amount of minigene transcripts by about 40%(Fig. 2). However, the length of this region is of vital importance. When the spacing of domains I and I1 was increased by 4 bp (i.e., almost one-half of a helix turn), transcription was reduced to less than 10% (25), suggesting that the formation of a stable transcription complex depends either on simultaneous binding of a single trans-acting factor to both domains, or on interaction between different trans-acting factors binding to these two domains at the same face of the DNA helix. Mutations in domain I11 (- 146 to -76) were considerably less debilitating than those in domains I and I1 (Fig. 2), with the strongest effect shown by mutations at the 5’ end of the domain (-146 to -134). This result is in agreement with the deletion mapping experiments discussed above. The relatively high activity displayed by mutant - 102 to -91 might indicate that the 3’ border of domain I11 is located somewhat farther upstream than position -76. So far, our results do not allow us to conclude whether the spacing between domains I11 and I1 is important. The structure of the yeast Pol-I promoter as revealed by these deletion mapping and linker-scanning experiments shows a considerable degree of similarity with the general model derived from in oitro studies of insect and vertebrate Pol-I promoters (reviewed in 26), which may extend to plants as well (27, 28). In this model, a core element (approximately -40 to - 10) acts as the binding site for a species-specific transcription factor (factor D as used 5
The indicated borders of the yeast Pol-I promoter domains are approximate.
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS I N YEAST
95
FIG. 2. Linker-scanning analysis of the yeast Pol-I promoter. (A) Bars indicate the relative efficiencyof transcription of the various linker-scanning mutants analyzed. The controls, shown to the left, were arbitrarily set at 100%.SIRT is a minigene containing the full-length, wild-type NTS, while NIRT carries a linker in the S m d site located outside the promoter proper (position -208). The position of the linker in the various mutants is indicated by the rectangles. The solid rectangle indicates the - 102 to -91 mutant mentioned in the text. Numbers show the distance (in base-pairs) to the transcription-initiation site, which is indicated by the bent arrow. Asterisks show the limits of the promoter region as determined by deletion mapping. (B) Schematic representation of the domain structure of the yeast Pol-I promoter. (Adapted from 25.)
in 29), while an upstream element (approximately - 150 to - 110) increases the efficiency of transcription, when tested under stringent conditions, by binding of additional transcription factors. The yeast domains I and I1 together, although extending somewhat farther upstream, probably correspond to the core element. It should be noted that in Xenopus Zueuis, the core element may also consist of two, albeit more closely spaced, domains (30, 31).Yeast domain I11 appears to be analogous to the upstream element. So far, no proteins binding to any of these domains have been identified in yeast. Although the region between positions -149 and +15 is both necessary and sufficient for accurate initiation of transcription by yeast Pol I, initiation is stimulated about 10- to 20-fold by the presence of an 160- or 190-bp (depending on the type of transcription unit) EcoRI-Hind111 fragment located about 2 kb upstream from the start site (22, 23, 32; cf. Fig. 1).Again, minigene constructs showed that this element acts as a true enhancer, since its stimulating effect is independent of position or orientation, although the degree of stimulation is influenced to some extent by the nature of the sequence context (22,23). Moreover, a single enhancer stimulates transcrip-
96
H. A. RAW)? AND R. J. PLANTA
tion of both copies of a tandem repeat containing two minigenes, irrespective of its location upstream, downstream, or between the two genes (33). The enhancer segment contains binding sites for two different proteins (32,34)called REBl (or RBPl) and REB2, respectively, that can be detected in crude yeast extracts by gel-retardation analysis. DNase I and chemical footprinting showed the REBl (RBP1) site to encompass a 14- to 20-bp region starting 10 bp downstream from the EcoRI site marking the 5’ end of the enhancer fragment (32, 34). The REBB site (-20 bp) is located some 10 bp downstream from the REBl (RBP1) site (34). Interestingly, a second REBl (RBP1) binding site is centered on position -212 upstream from the transcription-initiation site (32, 34). The two sites display considerable sequence similarity, but have opposite orientations. In particular, an 8-bp sequence in the middle of the binding site is absolutely conserved. Gelretardation assays showed that the promoter-proximal site has a 4- to 5-fold higher affinity for REBl (RBP1) compared to the site within the enhancer fragment (32, 34). Although the promoter-proximal REBl (RBP1) binding site is located outside the actual promoter region, as defined by deletion mapping and linker scanning, its presence suggests a function for REBl (RBP1) in enhancement of rRNA transcription. This suggestion was reinforced by our observation that both REBl (RBP1) sites are actually occupied in uiuo (32). However, when we deleted either part or all of the enhancer site, or destroyed the promoter-proximal site by insertion of a linker into the SmaI site at position -208, there was no detectable effect on the efficiency of minigene transcription (32). A longer 5‘ deletion of the enhancer, which also encompasses about half of the REB2 binding site, reduces transcription by a factor of only about four, which makes it unlikely that REBB binding is essential for enhancer activity (23).Moreover, this reduction may well be an overestimate, since deletions extending to within the REBl (RBP1) binding site, which in our hands did not affect enhancer activity, have been reported (23)to reduce transcription to about a third. The most likely explanation for this discrepancy is that the authors did not correct for differences in copy number. We have found that copy numbers of rDNA-containing centromeric plasmids, as used in 23, can differ significantly from one transformant to another (35). In contrast to deletions at the 5’ end, even small deletions at the 3’ end of the enhancer segment cause a drastic reduction in its stimulator y activity (23).Therefore, the main element responsible for enhancer function appears to reside closely upstream from the HindIII site located about 300 bp downstream from the 3’ end of the 26-S gene. It is interesting to note that the yeast enhancer segment contains additional functional elements. First, the enhancer segment also is one of a pair of rDNA fragments (the other one being a fragment spanning the Pol-I
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
97
transcription-initiation site) that stimulate local mitotic recombination between homologous sequences when inserted together at different sites in the yeast genome (36).This HOTl activity appears to be due to Pol-I transcription of the region adjacent to the insert containing the two homologous regions. The authors suggested that HOTl activity might be responsible for maintaining sequence homogeneity within the rDNA cluster. On the other hand, mitotic recombination within the yeast rDNA cluster was strongly suppressed both by the combined action of DNA topoisomerases I and I1 (37) and by the product of the S I R 2 gene (38),which sheds some doubt on this proposed role of HOTl. Second, a replication-fork barrier lies about midway in the enhancer region (39). However, the most noteworthy additional functional element present in the enhancer region is the major terminator for Pol I, discussed in more detail in Section I,C, which is located about 100 bp downstream from the 5’ border of the enhancer. The close proximity of the Pol-I transcription terminator and enhancer has led us to propose a model for enhancer function that envisages a functional linkage between enhancer and promoter (40) (Fig. 3). In this model, each rDNA transcription unit is thought to form a loop that juxtaposes its enhancer/terminator and promoter elements. Pol-I molecules that have traversed the rDNA unit and have reached the terminator are supposed to be transferred back to the promoter. The enhancer might be actively involved
FIG.3. Model for stimulation of yeast Pol-I transcription by the enhancer located in NTSI. T-E, Terminatodenhancer element; P, promoter. (Adapted from 40.)
98
n. A. mud AND R. J.
PLANTA
in this transfer or, alternatively, might just serve to bring terminator and promoter together, thus generating a local high concentration of Pol-I molecules. This “loop-out” model is supported by the recent observation that both Pol-I and Pol-I1 enhancers can exert their stimulating effect in trans (41,42).The model also takes into account the presence of the independently transcribed 5-S rRNA gene, which forms part of a second loop (Fig. 3). As mentioned above, destruction of either one of the two REBl (RBP1) binding sites leaves enhancer function in minigenes unaffected (32). However, the minigene experiments cannot be taken as absolute proof for the absence of any involvement of REBl (RBP1) in enhancement of transcription of the genomic rRNA operons. It should be kept in mind that the minigenes used in these studies were carried on episomal plasmids, causing their topology and cellular location to differ substantially from that of the genomic rDNA units, which form an array of tandem repeats in the nucleolus. The loop-out model allows for a role of REBl (RBP1) in enhancer function, for example, by anchoring the enhancedterminator and promoter elements of the genomic rRNA operons to the nuclear matrix at closely neighboring sites. However, the fact that REBl (RBP1) is dispensable for transcription enhancement in minigene constructs implies that some sort of interaction between enhancedterminator and promoter occurs even when they are unable to bind this protein. Whatever the role of the REBl (RBP1) protein, its presence is crucial for cell survival, since the gene is essential (Q. Ju and J. R. Warner, personal communication). Recently, it was found that REBl (RBP1) is identical to the Y factor (43, 44),which creates a nucleosome-free region in the GAL1-10 upstream activating sequence (45).REBl (RBP1) binding sites are present in the UASs of many yeast protein genes as well as in centromeres and telomeres (43). Although the protein itself is only a weak activator of Pol-I1 transcription, it acts synergistically with other activators to give as much as 170-fold stimulation. The loop-out model has been extended (33) to account for the observation that the enhancer element also acts from a downstream position and can even stimulate transcription of two adjacent minigenes. In this model, several (or all) enhancer/terminator and promoter elements are juxtaposed, facilitating transfer of a terminating Pol-I molecule to any of a number of different promoters. Again, one should realize that these experiments used minigenes that, although integrated into the yeast genome, were still dislocated from the natural site of Pol-I transcription. Thus, while it is clear that a functional linkage can be established in these minigene constructs between any enhancer and any promoter, irrespective of their relative location, constraints in the chromosomal rDNA locus might be more severe. We are currently trying to resolve this question by using “tagged rDNA units integrated into
RIBOSOME BIOCENESIS IN YEAST
99
the rDNA locus (35;see also Section 111,A). Since the transcripts of these units can be clearly distinguished from those of the wild-type genes, we should be able to analyze the effect of enhancer mutations on the transcription of individual rRNA operons in their natural context.
C. Transcription Termination by Yeast RNA Pol I The longest precursor rRNA molecule detectable in yeast cells ( 3 7 3 prerRNA) has a 3’ end that maps only 7 bp downstream from the 3’ terminus of the mature 26-S rRNA sequence (46). This 3’ end, however, does not correspond to the actual Pol-I transcription-termination site, a conclusion initially drawn from the observation that, in yeast cells carrying the ma82.1 mutation, minigene transcripts extending beyond this point were detected (40). The ma82.1 mutation inactivates an endonuclease first shown to be involved in 3’-end maturation of yeast 5-S rRNA (10).Apparently, the same endonuclease is involved in (rapid) 3‘ processing of longer transcripts of the rRNA operon to 37-S pre-rRNA. Analysis of minigenes in which the processing sites had been deleted (40) showed that yeast Pol I most likely terminates at position +210 downstream from the 3’ end of the 2 6 4 gene. This site, designated T2, is located about 100 bp downstream from the 5’ border of the enhancer segment (cf. Fig. 1).Some transcription up to about position +700 (T3) was also observed when T2 was deleted as well. The conclusion that Pol-I transcription proceeds a considerable distance into the NTS was confirmed by in oitro run-on experiments using both permeabilized cells and isolated nuclei (9). In good agreement with the minigene data, these experiments showed transcription of the genomic NTS sequences up to about position +700, with attenuation occurring at two sites located in regions + 18 to +270 and +270 to +721, respectively. No transcription beyond T3, which is located upstream from the 3‘ end of the 5-S gene (Fig. l), could be detected. Since neither the minigene nor the run-on analyses allow a definitive distinction to be made between a processing site and a genuine temination site, spacer regions containing T2 or T3, as well as the region containing the processing sites TO and T1 (-70 to +100; cf. Fig. 1) were subjected to functional analysis (9). Each region was cloned in the middle of the reporter sequence of an rRNA minigene, and the products of transcription were analyzed for the presence of “upstream” (3’ end at the termination site), “downstream” (5’ end at the termination site), and “read-through” transcripts by Northern blotting, reverse transcription, and S 1 mapping. The results clearly demonstrated that Pol-I transcription does pass TO and T1, marking these sites as processing sites, since downstream transcripts having a 5’ end mapping at the appropriate location could be detected by both reverse transcription and S 1 nuclease analyses. Northern blotting did not
100
n. A. MUG
AND R. J. PLANTA
detect these downstream or read-through transcripts, demonstrating that processing at these sites is highly efficient and that the downstream part of the transcript is rapidly degraded. Identification of TO and T1 as processing sites is confirmed by the recently described in uitro processing of a synthetic rRNA transcript at these sites (47). Analysis of the transcription products of a minigene into which the T2 region had been inserted revealed no downstream transcripts, leading us to conclude that T2 is an actual termination site for yeast Pol I. By the same reasoning, two further termination sites, T3A at position +690 and T3B at position +950, were identified (Fig. 1). Since data from both the run-on and the minigene experiments indicate T2 to be a highly efficient terminator, we suspect that T3A and T3B act as failsafe terminators to prevent any Pol-I molecules that escape T2 from interfering with 5-S rRNA transcription. Our own deletion mapping data (9, 40), in combination with those of others (23),confine the sequences both required and sufficient for termination at T2 to the region between positions +120 and +211. The actual requirements may be even less, since a naturally occurring deletion of basepairs +181 to f197 did not affect the function of T2 (9). Short sequence elements (12-18 bp) direct termination of transcription by Pol I in mice, X. Zueuis, and humans by binding a truns-acting factor (48-50). Our results exclude a role for REBl (RBP1) in termination by yeast Pol I, since deletion of about half of the binding site for this protein, which abolishes its interaction with the DNA, leaves termination unaffected (40). A more extensive deletion reaching about halfway into the REB2 binding site, on the other hand, abolished termination at T2 (23), suggesting a role for the REB2 protein in this process. Comparison of the sequences surrounding T2, T3A, and T3B did not reveal any significant conservation that might mark a cisacting element(s) responsible for transcription termination. However, this does not rule out the involvement of a common truns-acting factor at these three sites, since several examples of proteins that interact with DNA at specific sites in an (apparently) sequence-independent manner are known
(51-53). Whereas none of our experiments revealed any Pol-I transcription beyond T3B (+950), functional analysis of further regions of the NTS nevertheless disclosed the presence of still another (albeit, in our minigene test system, inefficient) termination site at position -300 upstream from the Pol-I transcription-initiation site (Tp; cf. Fig. 1). This situation is similar to that reported for X. Zueuis, mice, and (probably) humans (54-56).However, inactivation of Tp reduces transcription initiation at the associated start site only slightly, even in a situation in which this inactivation leads to considerable read-through transcription by Pol-1 molecules that started at the pro-
RIBOSOME BIOCENESIS I N YEAST
101
moter of a preceding minigene (9). This result, as well as the absence of spacer promoters in yeast, makes it unlikely that Tp has a function similar to that of the promoter-associated terminators in vertebrates, which stimulate transcription initiation at the downstream promoter (54,56, 57) either by “hand-over” of Pol-I molecules transcribing the spacer or, more likely, by preventing disruption by these molecules of the stable pre-initiation complex formed at the promoter (58-60). Inactivation of Tp was achieved by inserting a linker into the SmaI site at position -208 almost 100 bp downstream (9). Thus, an element essential for termination at Tp is located a considerable distance from the actual termination site. Note that, as discussed above, the same linker insertion also destroys the promoter-proximal REBl (RBP1)binding site, which may indicate a role for this protein in termination at Tp.
D. Regulation of Yeast RNA-Pol4 Transcription Since ribosomes constitute a critical component of the protein synthetic machinery, the rate of ribosome production is tightly coupled to the cellular growth rate (61-63). In prokaryotes, there is considerable evidence that the rate at which ribosomes are formed is controlled primarily at the level of initiation of rRNA synthesis (see the introduction to this article and references therein). Although it is likely that in yeast cells, too, initiation of rRNA synthesis is a central point of control in ribosome biogenesis, little is known about the specific mechanisms. Moreover, it is clear that additional important general regulating mechanisms operate in yeast, such as those directly controlling the transcription of the r-protein genes (see Section II). Growth-rate control of ribosome production in yeast has been studied mainly by analyzing the effects of a carbon-source upshift. Changing the carbon source of the growth medium from ethanol to glucose results in a rapid 2.5 to 4-fold increase in the transcription of both r-protein and rRNA genes (64).While the outlines of the mechanism stimulating transcription of r-protein genes under these conditions are becoming visible (see Section II), that responsible for the increase in rRNA synthesis remains obscure, although the Pol-I enhancer may be involved (65).In this respect, it is noteworthy that the promoter of the gene encoding the transcriptional activator TUF of the majority of yeast r-protein genes (the RAP1 gene; see Section II,B) contains a REBl (RBP1) binding site (43) which establishes a possible link between rRNA and r-protein synthesis. An even more direct link is suggested by the Fact that yeast rDNA also contains a TUF binding site about 100 bp downstream from the start of the 2 6 4 rRNA gene (66). However, although this site has a high affinity for TUF in uitro, nothing is known about
102
H. A. RAUk AND R. J . PLANTA
in uiuo binding. Possibly, TUF, a nuclear scaffold protein (67),influences PolI transcription by affecting the topology of the rDNA. The finding that REB2 is probably identical to ABFI (43), a transcriptional activator of r-protein genes not controlled by TUF (see Section II,B), constitutes another possible example of such a direct linkage between rRNA and r-protein synthesis. Finally, an indirect link via TUF may also exist, since the gene for a common subunit of yeast Pol I and Pol I11 contains a TUF binding site in its upstream region (68).Thus, rRNA transcription might also be regulated via changes in the supply of active polymerase molecules. Saccharomyces cereuisiae, like E . coli, shows a stringent response in that amino-acid deprivation leads to a specific inhibition of rRNA transcription (66, 69, 70).The search for ppGpp (or a related compound), known to act as an inhibitor of rRNA transcription in amino-acid-starved E. coli cells, was unsuccessful, however. Also, the availability of a relaxed yeast mutant strain (71)has so far failed to throw more light on the mechanism of the stringent response in yeast. A mild heat-shock (23"C+36"C) transiently decreases transcription of rRNA genes in yeast (72).Again, the basis for this regulatory response in not known. A similar effect, however, is observed for r-protein genes as well as for several genes encoding non-ribosomal proteins (73).
E. Transcription of 5-S rRNA by Yeast RNA Pol Ill As in other eukaryotic cells, transcription of 5-S rRNA in yeast is carried out by RNA Pol 111. Transcription initiation depends on the transcription factors TFIIIA, TFIIIB, and TFIIIC that form a stable initiation complex with the promoter located in the coding region of the 5-S RNA gene (74). TFIIIB is the actual transcription activator protein, while TFIIIA and TFIIIC are required for assembly of TFIIIB into the transcription complex (75).Since yeast 5-S rRNA inhibits its own synthesis in uitro (76),it is likely that production of 5-S rRNA in oiuo is tuned to that of the other rRNA species by the same feedback system operating in vertebrate cells, in which excess 5-S rRNA sequesters TFIIIA (77). It is unclear how Pol-I and Pol-111 transcription remain balanced in a change in physiological conditions that either increases or decreases the cellular demand for ribosomes, although the TUF-controlled production of their common subunit (see Section I, D) may be involved. However, there is no obligatory coupling between Pol-I and Pol-I11 transcription. A yeast strain carrying a temperature-sensitive PolI11 mutation continues to produce 37-S rRNA for a considerable time when placed at the restrictive temperature (78). Although each yeast 5-S rRNA gene is part of an rDNA repeat, transcription of these genes does not respond to the Pol-I enhancer (65).
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS I N YEAST
103
11. Expression of Ribosomal-protein Genes A. Genetic Organization and Structure of Yeast Ribosomal-protein Genes Whereas the equimolar production of the 17-S, 5.8-S, and 26-S rRNA species is ensured by the organization of these genes into multiple tandem copies of a contiguous transcription unit, no such linkage exists for the genes encoding the r-proteins (rp-genes). Even in the few cases in which two rpgenes are located in each other’s immediate neighborhood, they are independently transcribed. Such an arrangement has been reported for the genes encoding r-proteins L46 and S24, which are only 640 bp apart and arranged in a head-to-head fashion (79). A similar situation holds for the genes encoding rp29 and L32, separated by a 600-bp intergenic region (80). Finally, there are two pairs of RP28-S166 genes linked in a head-to-tail fashion, again by about 600 bp of DNA (81,82).A recent remarkable finding is that two yeast r-proteins, S37 from the small and an as-yet-unidentified species from the large subunit, are encoded as the carboxy-terminal part of fusion proteins with ubiquitin (83, 84), a situation also encountered in mammals and plants (83, 85). About three-quarters of the r-proteins in S. cerevisiae that have been analyzed genetically are derived from duplicate genes. In all cases, both gene copies are functional, although their expression levels often differ considerably (86-90). The duplicate copies encode identical, or virtually identical, proteins that are functionally indistinguishable (89, 91). However, their intron, leader, and trailer sequences display substantial differences. The group of r-proteins encoded by single-copy genes so far consists of L3,L29, L25 (92), L32 (go), the ubiquitin-fused S37 (84), and the phosphoproteins L44, L44’, and L45 (93),as well as the related acidic proteins A0 and A 1 (94). Only a few yeast rp-genes have as yet been mapped to specific chromosomes. The first of these were the ones conferring resistance against the antibiotics trichodermin (U), cycloheximide (L29),and cryptopleurin (RP59). The former two-single-copy ones-are located on chromosomes XV and VII, respectively (95, 96). One of the duplicate copies of the RP59 gene has been mapped to chromosome I11 (97). One of the two RP28-Sl6 gene pairs resides on chromosome XIV, the other on chromosome XV (82).The genes for the acidic proteins L44’ and L45 were both traced to chromosome IV, while that for L44 is located on either chromosome VII or XV (98). The general structure of yeast rp-genes is depicted in Fig. 4. The most striking feature of this structure is the presence of an intron close to the 5’ fi
S16 was formerly called rp55.
104
H . A. RAUg AND R. J. PLANTA
I ,
UAS
FIG. 4. Generalized structure of a yeast rp-gene. Coding sequences, the intron, and the leader region are indicated by the vertically striped bars, solid bars, and an open bar, respectively. Highly conserved nucleotides in the intron are shown. Boldface nucleotides are universally conserved. The diagonally striped boxes represent UAS elements; the dotted box, the Trich region. Average distances are indicated in base-pairs. Py, Pyrimidine.
end of the gene, since introns are rare in yeast non-ribosomal genes (reviewed in 99). Of 39 rp-genes analyzed so far, 28 contain an intron, usually within 10-20 codons downstream from the translation start. In two instances (ZIP29 and S31), the intron is located in the 5’-untranslated leader sequence of the gene. In the case of two of the ubiquitinlr-protein fusions, the intron is present in the ubiquitin-encoding part of the gene. The UB13 gene encoding S37 does not contain an intron (82). The common occurrence of an intron in rp-genes has led to speculation about a regulatory role for splicing in rprotein synthesis. So far, however, only one instance of regulation at this level has been uncovered (100; see Section 11,C).
B. Transcriptional Regulation of Ribosomal-protein Synthesis Despite the difference in gene copy number, the cellular levels of the mRNAs for several different yeast r-proteins (rp-mRNA) are approximately equal (101).Since the various rp-mRNAs have about the same stability ( l o ] ) , this suggests that the rate at which r-proteins are produced is controlled primarily at the level of transcription. Over the past few years, ample evidence supporting this suggestion has been accumulated, although additional regulation at the post-transcriptional level has also been detected (see Section 11,C). The first intimation of possible cis-acting elements involved in transcriptional control of r-protein synthesis came from a comparison of the 5’-flanking sequences of 21 different yeast rp-genes (102, 103). This comparison revealed two conserved elements, at that time designated HOMOLl and RPG boxes, located 250-450 bp upstream from the ATG start codon (cf. Fig. 5). Deletion mapping and linker-scanning experiments, carried out on several different rp-genes (104-108), demonstrated that these elements indeed play a central role in controlling rp-gene expression and, therefore, should be considered upstream activating sequences (UASs). These experiments also revealed a third element in the form of a T-rich region located closely downstream from the UAS elements (104; cf. Fig. 4). Similar regions act as promoter elements in other, non-ribosomal, yeast genes (109). Although virtually all yeast rp-genes possess a T-rich region (104-109),the
RIBOSOME BIOCENESIS I N YEAST
105
relative importance of this element seems to vary from one gene to another. Deletion mapping of the RP59 promoter showed 40% residual transcription when only the T-stretch was still present (106). Similar experiments on the L25 promoter, however, demonstrated that the T-stretch by itself does not support significant transcription of this gene (105).Nevertheless, in this case, as well as that of the L16’ (104)and L29 (107) genes, the T-stretch appears to act in conjunction with the UAS elements to promote transcription. On the other hand, the intergenic region separating the S24 and LA6 genes contains only a single T-stretch, located between the (duplicate) UAS elements and the transcription start of the LA6 gene. Since the same UAS elements are essential for expression of the S24 gene (108), either S24 gene transcription does not require a T-stretch, or the T-stretch can also function from a position upstream from the UAS elements. The latter possibility seems less likely in view of the highly conserved 5’+3’ order of UAS elements and T-stretch in rp-genes. The HOMOLl and RPG boxes, although originally considered distinct elements, in fact are different representatives of the same functional UAS (now called the RPG box) that acts as a binding site for an abundant transcription factor variously known as TUF, SBF-E, M P 1 , GRFI, and TBA (this plethora of aliases is due to the multihnctionality of this factor, discussed further on in this section). The first indication for the existence of this transcription factor came from the analysis of protein-DNA interactions in the 5’-flanking sequence of the TEFl and TEF2 genes encoding yeast elongation factor E F - l a (121,112).Using footprint and gel-retardation analyses, a protein, called TUF, was identified that bound to both the HOMOLl and RPG boxes present in the TEFl and TEF2 genes, as well as the RP5lA rp-gene. Subsequently, the same protein was shown to bind to the RPG boxes of various other yeast rp-genes (113).Sequence comparison, as well as determination of the relative affinity of various different RPG boxes for the protein (108),led to the following consensus binding sequence: 5’-ACACCCATACATTT-3’. (The most strongly conserved nucleotides are shown in boldface type. ) With only a few exceptions, yeast rp-genes carry two copies of the RPG box (110) in either orientation. Although there is no evidence for a cooperative effect between the two copies in binding of the TUF factor (113),both contribute synergistically to the final level of transcription, albeit often to a different degree. Removal of the upstream copy from the L16 gene, for example, reduced transcription by more than 90%, while deletion of the downstream copy led to a reduction of only about 30% (104). Similar results were obtained for the L25 gene, although in this case the downstream copy is 7
L16
was formerly
called rp39.
106
H . A. RAUt AND R. J. PLANTA
the stronger (114).The differences in activity are probably due to differences in nucleotide sequence of the RPG boxes, which affect the affinity for the TUF factor (113) and possibly the orientation of a particular RPG box. Replacement of the two naturally occurring copies of this element in an L25galK fusion gene by a single synthetic copy in either orientation revealed a clear orientation-dependent difference in activity (114). Also, a certain distance-dependent variation in activity cannot be excluded, since the stimulatory effect of the synthetic RPG box on transcription of the L25-gaZK fusion gene was found to diminish when its distance from the ATG start codon was reduced to about 100 bp (114). Apparently, the various factors contributing to promoter strength have been carefully balanced in the various yeast rp-genes to ensure the production of (approximately) equimolar amounts of all rp-mRNAs. In cases in which the r-protein is encoded by duplicate genes, the contribution of the individual gene copies to the final amount of mRNA is not necessarily equal. The two RP51 gene copies produce 40% and 60% of the rpdl-mRNA, respectively (86),while for L16 and RP28 genes, this ratio is about 30:70 and 15:85, respectively (89, 115). Again, the same factors mentioned above are probably responsible for these differences. The structures of the two RP28 promoters are particularly suggestive of this idea, since the most highly expressed copy contains two RPG boxes with high affinity for the TUF factor, whereas the other carries only a single low-affinity site (113). However, no comparison of promoter strength between promoters that differ only in their RPG box(es) has so far been described. TUF binding regions are not only able to combine with themselves in a synergistic manner to create stronger activation sites, but also with other sites, notably a T-rich sequence. The basis for this effect is not yet clear, but it may well involve binding of additional protein factors, albeit not in a cooperative manner (116). There is evidence that the rapid increase in transcription of rp-genes observed after a nutritional upshift is mediated through the RPG boxes. Removal of the two RPG boxes of the L25 gene abolished the typical response of this gene to a carbon-source upshift. The response could be restored by insertion of a synthetic RPG box, even in the absence of the T-stretch, demonstrating that a single element is sufficient (115). Similar results were obtained for one of the S16 genes ( I 1 7). However, the transient reduction in rprotein synthesis caused by a heat-shock, although in part due to a lowering of the transcription rate, is not mediated by the RPG boxes (73;see also Section 11,C). Although the rate of rp-gene transcription can be adapted to changes in the physiological conditions via the RPG boxes, it cannot be adjusted further once these conditions are stable. This was demonstrated by inactivating one
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
107
of the two gene copies encoding rp51 (86),L16, or rp59 (89).Such inactivation caused a reduction in the steady-state level of the pertinent rp-mRNA, demonstrating that there is no increase in transcription of the single surviving gene copy to compensate for the deletion (see also Section II,C). So far, four yeast rp-genes have been found that do not carry any RPG box in their 5'-flanking sequence. The first of these were the genes encoding S33 and L3 (113,218).In both cases, again an abundant protein factor, called S U F or TAF, respectively, that binds to a specific sequence in the upstream region of the gene was identified. We have recently demonstrated, by competition-binding experiments, that, in fact, SUF and TAF are the same protein ( 119). Footprinting and methylation interference analyses ( 119) identified the binding site as RTCRYN,ACG (R = purine; Y = pyrimidine; N = nucleotide). The rp-genes for L2 [two copies (120)]and L45 contain this same protein binding site (121,122;our own unpublished results). However, analysis of the role of the UAS (UAS,) for this set of r-proteins has not progressed to the level reached in the studies of the RPG box. As far as S33 is concerned, removal of the UAS, lowers transcription by as much as 80% when cells are grown in 0.04% glucose/2% ethanol. Upon growth in 2% glucose, however, deletion of the UAS, results in only a slight reduction in transcription. Under these conditions, transcription appears to depend on a cis-acting element located downstream from the UAS, , that binds another protein factor (123).Nevertheless, the carbon-source upshift effect, which is normal for S33, depends on the presence of the intact UAS, (123).In contrast to our observations on S33, deletion of the UAS, from the L.3 gene causes a drastic reduction in transcription even in cells grown on 2% glucose
(118). Similar to TUF, S U F binding sites can combine synergistically with themselves and other activator sites to form elements that promote transcription more strongly (116). A solitary S U F site constitutes a relatively weak activator site (5- to 30-fold weaker than a high-afEnity TUF site), but the synergism (e.g., with a T-rich sequence) can cause transcription to rise to a level 4-10 times the sum of the levels obtained with each of the elements separately. As already demonstrated by the occurrence of RPG boxes in the 5'flanking sequences of the TEFl and TEF2 genes, the role of TUF is not limited to transcription activation of yeast rp-genes. The same holds true for SUF/TAF. In fact, both proteins are involved in either positive or negative regulation of quite a number of other, non-ribosomal, genes, and are implicated in the control of several more. Furthermore, both TUF and SUF/TAF play additional important roles in the cell. TUF acts as a nuclear scaffold protein (67) and binds to yeast telomeres (124, 125), whereas SUF/TAF is implicated in DNA replication because it interacts with the conserved B
108
H . A. R A U t AND R. J. PLANTA
domain of a number of ARS elements (125-128). This multifunctional character of the two proteins has caused them to be known by a variety of aliases (Table I). Two proteins (called SBF-E and SBF-B or GRFI and ABFI, respectively) that recognize the same binding sites as TUF and SUF/TAF, play an important role in the functioning of the silencer that suppresses the H M k and HMRa mating-type loci (66, 125, 129, 137). This function of TUF is correlated with its ability to act as a nuclear scaffold protein (67). Since the sequence to which SBF-E binds acts as a transcription activator site when taken out of its context in the silencer, the protein binding to this site was also designated RAPl [for repressor activator protein (129)].This name now appears to be generally accepted. The SUF factor now is generally designated ABFI (for ARS binding factor). RAPl binding (=RPG box) as well as ABFI binding (=UAS,) sites have been found in the 5'-flanking sequences of a large number of yeast genes by sequence comparison (see 121,133 and 138 for recent compilations). Among these are genes encoding components of the transcriptional and translational (including the rp-genes) machinery, as well as genes involved in cellular differentiation, the cell division cycle, nutrient transport, and glycolysis. A TABLE I NOMENCLATUREAND MOLECULAR WEIGHTS OF TUF AND SUF FACTORS" Nameb TU F SBF-E RAPl
MW (kDa)c 150 92.5
120 GRFI TBA
Reference
Nameb
1 1 1 , 112 129 130, 131 131 125 124
SUF TAF SBF-B ABFld
MW (kDa)c
147
135 81.6
GFI BAFl TyBF OBFl
120 123
Reference 113 118 129 125, 126 127 132 133 134 135
"Abbreviations are defined in footnote 1 on p. 89. bIt should he noted that definitive experimental proof for the fact that the proteins listed in this column are indeed identical has not been provided in all cases. GMolecular-weight values were generally derived from electrophoretic analysis on SDSlpolyacrylamide gels. Boldface numbers indicated values calcualted from the nucleotide sequence of the gene. dThere are indications that ABFI may he present in two different forms in the cell, both of which are functional (116, 136).
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
109
number of nuclear genes encoding mitochondria1 components also contain ABFI binding sites (132). The common feature linking these genes is their involvement in cell growth. Although there is experimental proof for only some of the non-ribosomal genes carrying this site that the RAPl and ABFI binding sites are actually involved in transcriptional activation (see 66, 1 2 5 , 133, 138 and 139 and references therein), there is little doubt that both proteins act as global regulators of gene activity. It is therefore not surprising that both RAPl and ABFI are essential for cell survival (127, 131). The nature and efficiency of their regulatory function must be determined by interaction with additional, more specific, factors, that, for the most part, have yet to be characterized. The SIR gene products required for silencer function are likely to be such factors (66). Furthermore, an 82-kDa protein that is crosslinked to both RAPl and ABFI when bound at their respective sites has been identified (118). Finally, the GCRl gene product has been implicated in RAP1-, but not ABFI-, mediated regulation, particularly of the A D H l , T E F l , T E F 2 , and RP59 genes (140). As discussed above, the rapid elevation of rp-gene transcription in response to a nutritional upshift is mediated through the RPG box or UAS, However, the precise role of the RAPl and ABFI factors in this response is not yet clear. The amount of (active) RAPl varies with growth rate (139,141). However, the kinetics of this variation and those of the increase in rp-gene transcription are considerably out of step, the latter being much more rapid than the former (141). Tseng et al. (139) suggested that post-translational modification (phosphorylation) of RAPl might be involved in regulating its activity. On the other hand, an increase in growth rate does cause the level of ABFI to rise rapidly. The question, therefore, remains as to how expression of the two classes of rp-genes, one carrying the RPG box, the other, UAS, elements, is coordinated.
C. Post-transcriptional Regulation of Ribosomal-protein Synthesis As discussed above, transcriptional regulation occupies the foremost position among the processes controlling r-protein synthesis in yeast. However, additional regulation does occur at several post-transcriptional levels, to wit splicing, rp-mRNA stability, and stability of the r-protein. The mechanism of nuclear mRNA splicing in S . cereoisiae, which is almost exclusively limited to rp-gene transcripts, has recently been reviewed (99).There are no fundamental differences between this process in yeast and that in other eukaryotic cells, except that, unlike the situation in metazoan cells, the 3’ portion of the intron (downstream from the branch point) appears not to be involved in the initial phases of yeast spliceosome assembly. Furthermore, the yeast splicing machinery appears to be more fastidious in its sequence requirements. Sequence conservation at the 5’ end and particu-
110
H. A. RAUd AND R. J . PLANTA
lady around the branch point is much stronger in S. cereuisiae than in metazoan pre-mRNA introns (cf. Fig. 4). Despite the fact that introns in yeast occur almost exclusively in rp-gene transcripts, splicing plays only a minor role in the control of yeast r-protein synthesis. In general, splicing is not the rate-limiting step in the production of mature mRNA (142),although splicing of L29 pre-mRNA seems to be an exception (143).However, there is one well-documented example of splicing regulating the production of an r-protein. Introduction of extra copies of a cDNA encoding r-protein L32 into yeast cells did not elevate the level of the protein, but did cause an increase in the level of L32 pre-mRNA (100). Since this effect was not observed when a cDNA clone lacking the ATG translation start codon was used, it was concluded that the L32 protein regulates its own synthesis via feedback inhibition of its pre-mRNA splicing. This regulatory mechanism resembles the translational feedback that plays a central role in controlling r-protein production in E. coZi. It is reasonable to assume that the feedback regulation of L32 pre-mRNA splicing is based on competition between a pre-ribosomal particle and the precursor mRNA transcript for binding of L32. Evidence in support of this mechanism was recently supplied by the observation that blocking rRNA synthesis in a yeast mutant containing a conditionally expressed Pol-I subunit gene also leads to accumulation of L32 pre-mRNA (144). Regions of L32 pre-mRNA important for regulation of its splicing are located close to its 5' end, as well as near the 5' splice site (F. Eng and J. €3. Warner, personal communication). It is not yet clear whether L32 can bind directly to (pre-) rRNA. Of course, such direct L32/rRNA interaction is not essential for competition-based feedback regulation. Binding of L32 to the pre-ribosomal particle via proteidprotein interaction would serve just as well. Feedback regulation of splicing has also been observed for r-protein L1 from X. Zaeuis (145),and a structural similarity between the two introns in question and X . laeuis 2 8 4 rRNA has been noted (146). So far, however, there is no experimental evidence that L1 pre-mRNA and 2 8 4 rRNA directly compete for binding of L1. Subjecting yeast cells to a mild heat-shock (23"+36"C) leads to a severe, though transient, decline in r-protein synthesis, in part due to a temporary, non-rp-gene-specific, transcriptional arrest (73). In addition, however, rpmRNAs are specifically destabilized. The half-lives of S10 and L25 mRNA decrease by a factor of about three. When transcription is blocked prior to, or concomitant with, the heat-shock, either by addition of 1,lO-phenanthroline (73) or by using a temperature-sensitive Pol-11 mutant (147, 148), the stability of rp-mRNA does not change. Thus, de nouo synthesis of a protein factor seems to be required to effect the (temporary) destabilization of rp-mRNA by heat-shock. Both the nature of this factor and its target on the rp-mRNA remain to be identified.
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
111
When yeast cells are supplied with supernumerary copies of an rp-gene, the level of the corresponding rp-mRNA increases proportionally, but the amount of r-protein does not (143, 149-153). Initially, translational control was thought to be responsible, at least in some cases, notably that of L3 (143). Later experiments, however, refuted this notion and, using pulsechase techniques, demonstrated that r-protein levels are kept constant by the rapid turnover of excess protein (149-153). As discussed above, L32 is the only known exception to this rule. Yeast r-proteins, except for the acidic species (see below), appear to be inherently unstable when not immediately assembled into ribosomal precursor particles, a feature also apparent when synthesis or processing of rRNA is blocked (144, 154). The molecular cause of this extreme instability [t,,, = 12 minutes (143, 150, 151)] is unknown. The amino-terminal amino acids of the large majority of yeast r-proteins do not belong to the set conferring instability on a test protein in yeast (91, 155). Possibly, r-proteins contain a destabilizing element within their amino-acid sequences (P. J. Schaap, J. van’t Riet and H. A. RauC, unpublished). Anyway, the data discussed above clearly show that yeast cells fine-tune the supply of most r-proteins by an assembly-mediated rapid degradation of any excess produced. The exception is the set of acidic r-proteins, the only species for which a significant pool of free protein is present in the cytoplasm (156-158). The reason for this excess has yet to be elucidated. Transcriptional regulation of the genes encoding the acidic rp-genes appears to conform to the normal pattern using either RAP1 or ABFI as activators (122;our own unpublished results). Differences in post-transcriptional regulation are probably thus responsible for the “abnormal” amounts of these proteins. Experiments in which the minor (in terms of mRNA production) duplicate copy of an rp-gene was inactivated without a significant effect on growth rate (86, 89, 90) suggest that, even in wild-type cells, r-protein production is (slightly) in excess of actual need. On the other hand, no dosage compensation occurred at the level of translation when the supply of r-protein was curtailed either by knocking out the major copy (86, 89, 90) or by lowering the transcription of a conditionally expressed copy (159).Thus, the rate of translation of an rp-mRNA, like the rate of transcription of the rp-gene, is set at a fixed value by the physiological conditions.
111. Processing and Assembly of Ribosomal Constituents A. Processing of Pre-rRNA As discussed above, the Pol-I transcript of the yeast rRNA operon extends to position +210 downstream from the 3’ end of the mature 2 6 3 rRNA sequence. However, this transcript is cleaved very rapidly to generate
H. A. RAUd AND R. J. PLANTA
112
the 37-S precursor rRNA having seven extra nucleotides at its 3’ end. This cleavage appears to be carried out by the product of the RNA82 gene (40) also involved in 3’ processing of yeast 5-S rRNA (10).The same endonuclease carries out 3’ processing of the upstream member of a pair of dimeric yeast tRNA genes as well (160).Whereas minigene transcription in wild-type cells produces transcripts having 3’ ends at positions -1 (TO, corresponding to the 3’ end of the mature 26-S sequence) and +7, in rna82.1 mutant cells transcripts ending at positions +15 to +50 (site T1; cf. Fig. 1) abound. However, 3’-end formation at - 1 and + 7 is not completely abolished by the mutation, indicating that yeast cells have the means to circumvent the rna82.1 defect. Normal 3‘ processing of the Pol-I transcript thus appears to entail endonucleolytic cleavage at positions + 15 to +50 by a so-far-unidentified nuclease, followed by further endonucleolytic cleavages at positions + 7 and -1 carried out by the RNA82 gene product. Alternatively, the mature 26-S rRNA terminus might be produced by exonucleolytic removal of the final seven extra nucleotides. Yip and Holland ‘(47) recently reproduced these processing events in uitro, using a partially purified yeast extract. Upon incubation of a synthetic minigene transcript extending to position +210, they observed 3’-end formation at positions -1, +7, and +12. In contrast to the results obtained in uiuo, processing products -70 and 10 nucleotides in length, respectively, did accumulate in uitro. The former should be due to endonucleolytic cleavage in the +15 to +50 region. The identity of the latter was not established, but it could be the product of endonucleolytic cleavage of the 37-S pre-rRNA that generates the mature 3’ end. Formation of 3’-ends at -1 and + 7 requires the presence of an element(s) located between positions -36 and +74 (40)that acts in an orientation-dependent manner (9,47). An imperfect helix extending from positions +9 to +55, conserved in even distantly related Saccharomycetoidae, might constitute such a cis-acting recognition signal (40).Furthermore, this processing depends on the presence of Mg2+ ions. No evidence for the involvement of an RNA-containing component has been obtained so far (47). Figure 5 shows the sequence of processing events leading to the formation of mature 17-S, 26-S, and 5.8-S rRNAs from yeast 37-S pre-rRNA (161, 162). First, virtual simultaneous cleavages at sites A1 and A2 remove the complete 5’ ETS and separate the 17-S and covalently linked 5.8-S and 26-S rRNA sequences. A second pair of (almost) simultaneous cuts at positions B1 and B2 produces the mature 5’ end of 5.8-S rRNA and the mature 3’ end of 26-S rRNA, respectively. A third pair (C1 and C2) then results in the removal of most of ITS2, uncovering the mature 5’ end of 26-S rRNA and producing the 7-S precursor of 5.8-S rRNA. Subsequent cleavage at C 3 leads to the formation of mature 5.8-S rRNA. All cleavage events mentioned so far
-
113
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
M 500 bp
5.5 s a
32 S
-I
A
18s
A
A
A1
A2
A
Bi
' A 82
37 s 29 SA 29 SB
M
c1 c 2 7s
26 S
m-
A
c3
nucleus cytoplasm
18s
A _.
A3
I
5 s
- I
17 S
5.8 S
26 S
FIG.5. Processing of the primary Pol-I transcript in yeast to the mature rRNA species. The top line shows a single rDNA repeat acmrding to the conventions used in Fig. 1. The Pol-I transcription-initiation (bent arrow) and termination (T2) sites are indicated. Below are shown the various processing intermediates identified in yeast cells. The hypothetical primary transcript is shown shaded. Thick bars correspond to the mature sequences; thin bars to the spacer sequences. Processing sites are indicated by arrowheads. The names of the various intermediates are shown to the left and right. The structure of the unusual 3 2 4 precursor produced when site A2 has been deleted (see Section III,A) is outlined above the 3 7 4 precursor.
occur in the nucle(o1)us. The final processing of the 18-S precursor to 17-S rRNA by cleavage at A3, however, is a cytoplasmic event (163). The yeast rRNA processing scheme differs in several respects from that worked out for mammals. In this case, the primary processing event appears to be removal of the 5' ETS by means of two or three consecutive endonucleolytic cleavages (164-166),followed by removal of the 3' ETS, again in two steps (167). Further processing occurs at, or very close to, the ends of the various mature rRNA sequences (168). Processing of Tetrahymena thermophila rRNA appears to follow a similar course of events, except that, as in yeast, the 5' ETS is removed by a single cleavage (169). The lack of an in uitro system for yeast that supports processing at sites Al-C3 has severely hampered identification of the cis-acting elements required for these cleavages. We have now developed a system allowing mutational analysis of yeast rDNA in uiuo that should enable us to delineate these
114
H. A. RAUd AND R. J. PLANTA
elements (35, 170, 171). The system consists of a complete rDNA unit in which both the 17-S and 26-S rRNA genes have been “tagged” by insertion of an oligonucleotide having a unique sequence. The rDNA unit is transformed into yeast cells on a centromeric plasmid to preclude recombination with the chromosomal rDNA repeats. The plasmid-derived transcripts can easily be detected by Northern hybridization using probes complementary to the tags. The presence of the tags, inserted into one of the variable segments of each of the genes (172), in itself does not affect ribosome biogenesis or function. In a first series of experiments, we studied the effect of deletions in the 5’ ETS as well as both ITS regions on the biogenesis of 1 7 4 and 2 6 4 rRNAs. As far as the 5’ ETS is concerned, we found that deletion of XlO-4OO bp from the 5’ end, the 3’ end, or the middle of this region completely abolished formation of mature (tagged) 1 7 4 rRNA. However, accumulation of tagged 26-S rRNA, assembled into functional 604 subunits, remained unaffected even when all but 75 of the 699 bp of the 5’ ETS were deleted (171).This result clearly demonstrates that the presence of the 5’ ETS in cis is essential for the formation of the 40-S ribosomal subunit, whereas it appears to be dispensable for 6 0 3 subunit formation. Deletion of about two-thirds of the 17-S gene also did not affect 6 0 4 subunit formation (35),a surprising result in view of the fact that the first steps in yeast rRNA processing occur at the level of a 90-S ribonucleoprotein particle containing the complete Pol-I transcript (173; see Section 111,D). Deletion of a 160-bp region from ITS1 centered on processing site A2 again abolished accumulation of mature (tagged) 1 7 4 rRNA, while leaving the formation of 60-S subunits from tagged 26-S rRNA unaffected (171). This indicates that cleavage at site A2 is a crucial step in the formation of 40-S subunits. Cells containing the mutant rDNA unit accumulated an unusual 3 2 4 precursor that must have arisen from the processing of 37-S pre-rRNA at site A l . In an snR10.3 yeast mutant, in which the gene encoding snRlO RNA (sn = small nuclear) has been destroyed, processing at A2 is blocked (174).Instead, cleavage at site B1 is used to separate the 1 7 4 rRNA and 5.8Sl26-S rRNA sequences. We assume that in our case also the unusual 3 2 4 precursor is cleaved at B2, resulting in the formation of a normal processing intermediate (29-SB; cf. Fig. 5) en route to mature 26-5 rRNA and 504 subunits. We could not detect the 21-S precursor of 17-S rRNA that should be the other product of this cleavage. Therefore, we infer that this precursor is not an effective substrate for 4 0 4 subunit formation and is rapidly degraded. ITS2 has been called a pseudointron because it separates the 5.8-S RNA, which is homologous to the 5’ terminal 150 nucleotides of prokaryotic 23-S rRNA, from the 26-S rRNA sequence, equivalent to the rest of the 23-S
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
115
molecule (172).However, ITS2 must play a role at some stage of 60-S subunit formation since its complete deletion blocked rRNA processing at the stage of the 29-SB precursor equivalent, which is then degraded (171).The same result was obtained when ITS2 was only partially deleted, which shows that correct removal of ITS2 is crucial for 6 0 4 subunit formation. Since these experiments were carried out using an rDNA unit in which only the 2 6 4 rRNA gene contained a tag, we do not know the effect of the ITS2 deletions on 4 0 4 subunit biogenesis. Apart from the involvement, demonstrated by genetic analysis, of snRlO RNA and the RNA82 gene product, evidence has recently become available for involvement of three further trans-acting factors in yeast rRNA processing. Two of these factors also are snRNAs. The snR128 (U14) species appears to be required for 3 7 3 pre-rRNA processing, because its depletion causes severe underaccumulation of mature 1 7 4 rRNA and its 18-S precursor (175). Most likely, snR128 plays a role in processing at A1 or A2, although an indirect effect of this factor on rRNA maturation cannot be excluded. In contrast to the snR1O gene, the gene encoding snR128 is essential for cell viability ( 1 76). Yeast snR17 RNA is homologous to metazoan U3 snRNA and is associated in uiuo with 37-S pre-rRNA (174).Again, its gene is essential (177).While at present there is no direct evidence for a role of snR17 RNA in yeast rRNA processing, recent in uitro experiments strongly support the notion that its mammalian counterpart is involved in the first processing step that removes the 5'-terminal portion of the 5' ETS from the primary rRNA transcript (178). The in uiuo crosslinking of U 3 snRNA to the 5' ETS of both human (179) and rat (180) pre-rRNA constitutes further support for this role. It is unclear whether the yeast U 3 homolog fulfills the same function, because no equivalent cleavage within the 5' ETS of yeast 374 pre-rRNA has as yet been detected. Nine additional yeast snRNAs have been implicated in rRNA processing by virtue of their probable nucleolar localization and association with one or more precursor rRNA species (174, 176). A further trans-acting factor important for yeast pre-rRNA processing is the product of the RRPl gene, essential for cell viability (181, 182). In cells carrying the rrpl-1 temperature-sensitive mutation, processing of the 29-SB precursor appears to be blocked at 37"C, indicating the protein to be involved, directly or indirectly, in the cleavage at site C1. The precursor is subsequently degraded, in agreement with our studies of the rDNA units containing a partial deletion of ITS2. Remarkably, the same mutation also slows down the conversion of the 18-S precursor to 17-S rRNA (181). Since this conversion occurs in the cytoplasm, whereas processing of 29-SB prerRNA is a nucle(o1)arevent, it seems most likely that the RRP1 gene product affects processing indirectly, possibly because it is responsible for modifica-
116
H. A. RAU6 AND R . J . PLANTA
tion(s) in the rRNAs that play a role in this process. The fact that the rrpl-1 mutation also causes hypersensitivity to aminoglycoside antibiotics, while the gene does not seem to encode a ribosomal protein (181),supports this hypothesis. Many mutations affecting the sensitivity of ribosomes toward aminoglycosides have been mapped to 163 rRNA of E . coli and chloroplasts (183).The rrpl-1 mutation, but not a disruption of the RRPl gene, is (partially) suppressed by a second-site mutation in a locus on chromosome 111 designated SRD1 (182). Thus, either the SRDl protein interacts directly with the RRPl gene product or regulates the expression of this gene (182). The RRPl gene has been sequenced, but the deduced amino-acid sequence of the protein gives no clue to its function (182). Although it is likely that several r-proteins play a role in rRNA processing, only in the case of S37 has any evidence for such a role been reported. Lack of this r-protein retards the conversion of 20-S pre-rRNA to mature 17S rRNA (84; see also Section 111,D).
B. Modification of Pre-rRNA A second type of structural alteration introduced during maturation of pre-rRNA consists of the modification of nucleotides located at specific sites in the chain (172, 184). Most of these modifications concern 2‘-O-methylation of the ribose moiety. At a few positions, methyl groups are linked to the base. As a consequence of this modification, mature yeast 17-S and 2 6 4 rRNAs contain 22 and 43 methylated nucleotides, respectively. In addition, one hypermodified nucleotide, identified as l-methyl-2-(a-amino-a-carboxypropy1)pseudouridine (mx), is present in 17-S rRNA. Furthermore, both 1 7 4 and 2 6 4 rRNAs carry a large number of pseudouridine residues (184, 185), most of which, however, have yet to be assigned a location.N As discussed in more detail elsewhere (173), methylation starts at the level of 37-S pre-rRNA. However, most of the methyl groups are introduced at the level of the individual 18-S and 294 rRNA precursors. Modification takes place in the nucle(o)lus, except for the formation of the two 6-dimethyladenine residues near the 3’ end of the 17-S rRNA and the completion of mX, both of which occur in the cytoplasm shortly before conversion of the 18-S rRNA precursor into mature 1 7 4 rRNA. Virtually nothing is known as yet about the enzymes involved in yeast pre-rRNA modification or the way in which the specific residues to be modified are selected. The same holds true where the role of modification in the biogenesis of ribosomes is concerned. A more detailed discussion of possible roles of individual modified nucleotides in ribosome formation and function can be found in 172. 8 See “The Numerous Modified Nucleotides in Eukaryotic Ribosomal RNA,” by 9. E. H. Maden, in Vol. 39 of this series. [Eds.]
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
117
C. Modification of Ribosomal Proteins Several yeast ribosomal proteins are modified post-translationally, either by methylation (186)or by phosphorylation (187,188). Four methylated r-proteins (S31, S32, L15, and L41) have been detected. The biological relevance of this methylation is not known. Interestingly, however, we have shown L15 to be the yeast equivalent of EL11 (189),one of the most strongly methylated E. cold ribosomal proteins (190).The two proteins are part of the ribosomal GTPase center and appear to play a role in numerous ribosomal functions (189,191). Two phosphorylated species (S2 and S10) are present among the small subunit r-proteins of yeast, while the large subunit contains at least five phosphoproteins (L9, L30, L44, L44',and L45). Of these proteins, only S10 and the three structurally highly related acidic proteins L44, L44', and L45 have been subjected to functional analysis. S10 is the yeast homolog of the mammalian ribosomal phosphoprotein S6 (192).As in other eukaryotes, phosphorylation of S10, which can occur at either (or both) of two adjoining serine residues close to its carboxy terminus, is reversible and depends on the physiological conditions of the cells (see 193 for references). Attachment of the phosphate group(s) is due to the action of CAMP-dependent protein kinase (BCYl), while the product of the PPDl gene, encoding one of the three yeast phosphoprotein phosphatases, seems to be involved in dephosphorylation of S10 (194).Despite the effect of varying growth conditions on the degree of phosphorylation of S10, destruction of the phosphorylation sites of this protein does not lead to detectable growth impairment (193).Apparently, phosphorylation of S10 plays no role in either ribosome assembly or function in yeast. Yeast r-proteins L44, L44', and L45 are the structural and functional equivalents of E. coli r-proteins L7/L12 (93).As mentioned above, these species are the only yeast r-proteins for which a significant pool of free protein is present in the cytoplasm (156-158).Whereas the protein molecules bound to the ribosome are monophosphorylated, the free cytoplasmic molecules carry no phosphate groups (156).In uitro reconstitution experiments demonstrate that the affinity of L44, L44', and L45 for their ribosome binding site is reduced to at least a fourth, and probably considerably more, by dephosphorylation (156).The significance of these observations so far remains unclear. However, there are several indications that the acidic protein content of yeast ribosomes changes both qualitatively and quantitatively in response to changes in the physiological conditions of the cells, the phase of the cell cycle, and even the functional state of the ribosome. Concerning the last of these points, polysomes contain about twice the amount of acidic proteins as do free 804 particles (156, 195). Phosphorylation/dephos-
118
H. A. RAUt AND R. J . PLANTA
phorylation of these proteins might play a role in this process, which could affect the activity of the ribosomes. Gene disruption experiments have shown that L44 is dispensable for cell growth, whereas lack of L45 retards, but does not block, growth. However, cells carrying a disruption of both of these genes are not viable (196). In most cases in which both the nucleotide sequence of the gene(s) and the (amino-terminal) sequence of the r-protein have been determined, the two sets of data are in agreement, except for the occasional lack of the aminoterminal methionine residue. However, two instances of disagreement do exist (91). These concern r-proteins S31 and L15, where the published aminoterminal amino-acid sequence starts at 14 and 16 codons downstream from the AUG start codon, respectively. While this discrepancy might indicate posttranslational removal of an amino-terminal pre-sequence, preliminary results make it more likely that the amino terminus of the two mature r-proteins is blocked (P. J. Schaap, J. van’t Riet and H. A. RauC, unpublished; J. P. G . Ballesta, personal communication). The published amino-terminal sequences probably came from a degradation product.
D. Nucleocytoplasmic Transport and Assembly Ribosome biogenesis in yeast, as in other eukaryotes, entails intensive two-way traffic across the nuclear double membrane, all of which passes through the nuclear pores. The rp-mRNAs must be exported to the cytoplasm in order to be translated into the r-proteins, which then move back to the nucle(o1)us to be assembled with the pre-rRNAs. Finally, the nearly completed subunits relocate to the cytoplasm. So far, relatively little is known about the first and last of these three processes. Nuclear import of (r-)proteins, however, has recently enjoyed increasing interest (see 197 and 198 for reviews), leading to the identification of the cis-acting nuclear localization signal@)(NLS) of several yeast r-proteins. Progress is also being made with respect to the identification of the components of the import machinery and the general mechanism of nuclear protein import in yeast (199-20]) NLSs offour different yeast r-proteins (L3,L29, L25, and S31) have been characterized by fusing various parts of their coding regions to the E. coli gene for P-galactosidase (202-205). The latter protein is a convenient reporter, since it normally remains in the cytoplasm when expressed in yeast cells. The intracellular distribution of the fusion protein is analyzed by indirect immunofluorescence, using mouse antibodies against P-galactosidase followed by mouse anti-IgG coupled to a fluorescent marker. Both standard immunofluorescence microscopy and “confocal” laser scanning microscopy have been used. The latter technique has the advantage of being able to distinguish between perinuclear and intranuclear localization, since it allows
119
RIBOSOME BIOCENESIS IN YEAST
viewing of the cell in a series of consecutive “optical slices” (204). Several points should be kept in mind, however, when trying to identify an NLS by means of fusion proteins. The first is that the NLS may be “masked” by the conformation of the fusion protein. This problem can be solved by introducing a linker peptide between the reporter and the sequence to be analyzed (202). The second point is that the efficiency of an NLS may depend on the nature of the reporter even to the extent that no nuclear localization is observed with one, and full nuclear localization with another, reporter protein (206). A third problem, which so far has not materialized, however, is that a specific sequence might be identified as an NLS even though in its natural context it does not serve that function. The first 21 amino acids of L3 were found to cause nuclear localization of an L3P-galactosidase fusion (202), demonstrating the presence of an NLS in this region of the protein. In L29, two independent NLSs were identified, consisting of amino acids 6-13 and 23-29, respectively (203).The two signals are identical in five of the seven residues (Table 11). Yeast r-protein L25 also contains two NLSs, as does S31 (204, 205). The first NLS of L25 is located in the region encompassing amino acids 1-17. Residues 11-17 contain an essential part of this signal, but by themselves constitute a weaker NLS. The second NLS of L25 is located between amino acids 17 and 62, with its most important part lying between residues 17 and TABLE I1 NUCLEARLOCALIZATION SIGNALS(NLS) OF A NUMBEROF KARYOPHILIC YEAST PROTEINSO Protein
Amino-acid sequence of NLS
Reference
r-proteins
L3
ISHRKY E APRHGHLGFLPRKRA”
L25 L29 S31
I ( M)PPSAKATAAKKAWKKGL7
Others MATa2 H2B GAL4 SV40-T
fiKTRKHRG13 l2AKAAALAGGKKSKKKWSKKSMKDRS IMNKIPIKDLLNPQl3 =TSTSTDGKkRSx3
lsTN$KKALKVR‘P =KHRKHRGZ8
202 204 203 205
lMKLLSSlEQACDLCRLKKLKCSKEKPKCAZg
197 208 206
12fiMPKkKRKV13z
21 0
aThe amino-acid sequences (in one-letter symbols) of the regions of various yeast proteins that cause nuclear localization when fused to a reporter protein (usually P-galactosidase) are shown. It should be noted that the minimal sequence required for NLS function has not been determined in all cases. Numbers indicate the position of the sequence in the original protein. Basic amino acids are displayed in boldface type. Residues identified by an asterisk are crucial for NLS function by mutational analysis. For comparison, the prototypic SV40 large-T-antigen NLS is shown at the bottom. This metazoan NLS is fully functional in yeast cells (204, 206).
,
120
1-1. A. RAUR AND R. J. PLANTA
28. One of the two NLSs of S31 has been traced to amino acids 12-35. The other is located around amino-acid 85 (205). Even from this limited set of data, it is clear that yeast cells do not depend on passive diffusion for import of their r-proteins into the nucleus, even though the size of these proteins is considerably smaller than the cutoff value of 60-70 kDa, below which proteins can pass more or less freely through the nuclear pores (197, 198). Still, not all yeast r-proteins may contain an NLS. First, there is evidence that at least some of the large subunit r-proteins assemble in the cytoplasm and thus require no NLS (see below). Second, we have observed that an S24/P-galactosidase fusion is imported into the yeast nucleus, but have been unable to find any smaller region of S24 that will support nuclear localization of a fusion protein (P. J. Schaap, J. van’t Riet and H. A. RauC, unpublished). Either the NLS of S24 is composed of residues far apart in the primary sequence that are brought together by folding of the protein, or S24 is imported by associating with (an)other protein(s), most likely an r-protein, that does contain an NLS. The first possibility seems less likely in view of the fact that NLSs so far identified generally consist of a small number of consecutive amino acids (197, 198). The second mechanism, however, which has been called “piggy-back import” does operate in vertebrate cells, as shown by the nuclear import of a pentameric assembly of X . Zaeuis nucleoplasmin molecules, in which only one of these molecules carries an NLS (207). Similarly, yeast histone H2B, containing a defective NLS, is probably imported into the nucleus through its association with histone H2A (208). The dependence of cdc2 protein on cdcl3 for nuclear import in Schizosaccharomyces pombe (209)may be a naturally occurring example of piggy-backing. Table I1 shows a comparison of the NLSs of the various yeast r-proteins so far characterized. Apart from the fact that they all contain a number of basic amino acids, no common features can be discerned. Nevertheless, the presence of a cluster of basic amino acids by itself does not constitute an NLS, as demonstrated by the failure of portions of r-proteins containing such clusters to cause nuclear import of a fusion protein (P. J. Schaap, J. van’t Riet and H. A. Raub, unpublished). Mutational analysis (203, 208) has identified single residues crucial for the function of the histone H2B and L29 NLSs (Table II), but these data still do not resolve the question as to what precisely does and what does not constitute a yeast NLS. It is not clear why the majority of the yeast r-proteins analyzed carry two NLSs. The presence of multiple karyophilic signals has been shown to enhance the efficiency of nuclear import in vertebrate cells (197, 198). However, the N-distal signal of L29 appears not to be required for efficient nuclear import of the protein, since its inactivation does not affect the growth rate of yeast cells. On the other hand, inactivation of both NLSs of
RIBOSOME BIOCENESIS IN YEAST
121
L29 has a more severe effect on growth rate than inactivation of the Nproximal one alone (203).This shows that the N-distal signal in its natural context is able to interact with the nuclear import machinery and, thus, is likely to play a functional role. Relatively little is known about the order in which the various yeast r-proteins are assembled into pre-ribosomal particles. Kinetic labeling studies in our laboratory (211)have identified 17 large subunit and 7 small subunit r-proteins that appear to assemble at a relatively late stage. Four members of the first group (L7, L9, L24, and L30) are almost completely absent from nuclear 6 6 4 precursor particles of the large subunit, indicating that they are assembled in the cytoplasm. The same may hold true for the acidic proteins L44, L14’, and L15 (158). On the other hand, seven of the large subunit r-proteins (L10, L12, L20-22, L25, and L37) appear to associate with the 3 7 3 pre-rRNA. Among these is r-protein L25, which binds specifically to a region within domain I11 of the 2 6 4 rRNA (212).The kinetic labeling data are in general agreement with results obtained by controlled dissociation of 60-S subunits with the aid of NH,CI (213), LiCl (214), or treatment with dimethylmaleic anhydride (215).The r-proteins remaining in the core particles produced by these methods predominantly belong to the class of “earlyassembling” species, as identified by kinetic labeling, although only L25 is common to all three types of particle. The compiled data, however, are far from sufficient to establish a precise order of assembly of the various r-proteins in yeast. Analysis at the molecular level of rRNA/r-protein and r-protein/r-protein interactions, which constitute the basis for ribosome assembly, is just beginning in eukaryotes. We have identified a number of large subunit r-proteins in yeast that are likely to interact directly with yeast 26-S rRNA (214, 216). Two of these proteins (L15 and L25) were positively characterized as “primary rRNA-binding proteins,” and their respective binding sites on the 2 6 4 rRNA have been analyzed in detail (189, 212). In both cases, a homologous protein is present in E. coli ribosomes that binds to the corresponding, structurally conserved, site in 23-S rRNA. Moreover, the homologous yeast and eubacterial r-proteins are able to recognize each other’s binding site (reviewed in 183). Thus, at least some of the basic interactions between ribosomal constituents have been conserved during evolution even from proto eukaryotic cells. We have also been able to limit the region in L25 that is essential for its interaction with rRNA to the carboxy-terminal80 (out of 142) amino acids (217).The only other studies of comparable depth are those on the yeast 5-S rRNA binding r-protein Lla, most of which have been carried out by Nazar’s group (reviewed in 218). Six yeast r-proteins (L14, L19, L21, L29, and L33) that bind individually to 5.8-S rRNA (218) have been identified. All of these belong to the class of
122
H. A. €MU$ AND R. J . PLANTA
early-assembling proteins, L21 being one of those assembling with the 37-S pre-rRNA. Finally, the first 64 (out of 135) amino acids of rp51B are sufficient to ensure incorporation of an rp51B/P-galactosidase fusion protein into biological active 40-S particles (219).Such assembly, however, only occurred when the rp51A gene had been destroyed. Thus, the carboxy-terminal region of the rp51 protein contains information that increases the efficiency of its assembly. In a similar way, it was established that the carboxy-terminal 14 amino acids of L3 are dispensable for its assembly into 60-S subunits (202). Interestingly, assembly of the 40-S subunit is facilitated by the fusion of r-protein S37 to ubiquitin. This was concluded from the observation that a mutant in which the UB13 gene encoding the ubiquitin-S37 fusion protein had been disrupted could not be fully complemented by a single copy of a gene encoding only S37. Instead, multiple copies of such a gene were required to restore the growth of the mutant cells to the wild-type value (84). Thus, the covalent attachment of ubiquitin to the amino terminus of S37 either promotes incorporation of this protein into pre-ribosomal particles or serves to protect S37 from premature degradation. As already mentioned (Section III,A), the presence of S37 in the precursor of the 40-S subunit facilitates the final processing step in the biogenesis of 17-S rRNA (84). It is not clear at present whether the fusion of the large subunit r-protein to uniquitin in the UBll and UB12 genes serves the same purpose as the ubiquitin fusion of S37, since no complementation experiments using single copies of a gene encoding only the r-protein tail of the UBIl or UB12 fusions have been carried out (84). One further point of interest in this context is the observation that introduction of the gene encoding mouse r-protein L27’ into yeast cells carrying an inactivated copy of the L29 gene restored viability as well as cycloheximide sensitivity (220). This suggests that yeast ribosomes containing the mouse protein are functional. The large degree of structural similarity between yeast and mammalian r-proteins (91)makes it likely that further examples of such hnctional homology will be uncovered. As mentioned above, association between r-proteins and rRNA initiates at the level of the 37-S pre-rRNA and, as in other eukaryotes (221),is likely to start even before the primary rRNA transcript has been completed. The first pre-ribosomal assembly detectable in yeast nuclei is a 9O-S particle containing 37-S pre-rRNA (222).The 5-S rRNA may also already be present in this particle (223). The 90-S particle is converted into 66-S and 43-S particles by rRNA processing at sites A1 and A2 (cf. Fig. 5). The former, containing 29-S pre-rRNA and 5-S rRNA (223), remains in the nucleus for further processing. The latter, however, is rapidly exported to the cytoplasm,
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
123
where the final steps in maturation to 40-S subunits take place. These include removal of the remaining spacer sequences attached to the 3' end of the 1 7 4 rRNA (see Section 111,A). Processing of the large subunit rRNA is completed in the nucleus. Completion of the 60-S subunits by assembly of a final set of r-proteins also appears to take place in the cytoplasm (see above). Both the 90-S and 6 6 4 but not the 43-S, particles have a boyant density below that of the mature subunits, indicating a higher protein/rRNA ratio (222). Apparently, these particles contain a considerable number of non-ribosomal proteins that are somehow involved in ribosome biogenesis. The identity of these proteins has not been established. Obvious candidates are the enzymes involved in pre-rRNA processing and modification, and the proteins of the snRNP particles implicated in processing (see Section 111,A). Despite their common origin, the production of 40-S and 60-S subunits is not coordinated at the level of assembly (see also Section 111,A). When the supply of either a 60-S or 40-S r-protein is diminished, the production of the corresponding mature subunit decreases without a concomitant decrease in the accumulation of the other subunit (84, 89, 149). So far, eight yeast r-proteins (L3, L16, L25, L29, rp51, rp59, S10, and the unidentified large subunit species encoded by the U B l l and UBZ2 genes) are essential (84,89, 149, 159, 217) and five (L30,L44,L45, L46, and S37) are dispensable to a greater or lesser extent (84, 196, 224; B. Baronas-Lowell and J. R. Warner, personal communication). This is in stark contrast to the situation in E. coli, in which the lack of any one of at least 16 r-proteins is tolerated, albeit usually with considerable deleterious effects on the well-being of the mutant cells (225). Very little information is available on the mechanism causing export of ribosomal subunits to the cytoplasm. Injection of ribosomal subunits into Xenopus oocytes revealed export to be saturable, suggesting a carrier-mediated process (226,227).The nature of the determinant(s) responsible for this export remains to be elucidated, although it seems likely that parts of the rRNA are important in this respect (228).
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank all colleagues who supplied us with reprints and preprints of their papers and who gave us permission to quote unpublished results. The work carried out in our laboratory was supported by The Netherlands Organization for Chemical Research with financial aid from The Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research and by the Program Committee for Industrial Biotechnology with financial aid from The Netherlands Ministry for Economic Affairs.
124
H . A. RAW& AND R . J . PLANTA
REFERENCES 1. R. L. Gourse, R. A. Sharrock and M. Nomura, in “Structure, Function and Genetics of Ribosomes” (B. Hardesty and G. Kramer, eds.), pp. 766-788. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1985. 2. J. R . Cole, M. Yamagishi and M. Nomura, in “Genetics ofTranslation” (M. F. Tuite, M . Picard and M. Bolotin-Fukuhara. eds.), pp. 55-82. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1988. 3. M. Nomura and W. A. Held, in “Ribosomes” (M. Nomura, A. Tissih-es and P. Lengyel, eds.), pp. 193-224. CSHLab, Cold Spring Harbor, New York, 1974. 4. M. Herold and K. H. Nierhaus, JBC 262, 8826 (1987). 5. V. Nowotny and K. H. Nierhaus, Bchern 27, 7051 (1988). 6. V. Nowotny and K. H. Nierhaus, PNAS 79, 7238 (1982). 7 . T. D. Petes and D. Botstein, PNAS 74, 5091 (1977). 8 . J. H. Meyerink, Ph. D. thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, 1979. 9. C. A. F. M. van der Sande, T.Kulkens, A. B. Kramer, I. J. de Wijs, H. van Heerikhuizen, J. Klootwijk and R. J. Planta, NARes 17, 9127 (1989). 10. P. W. Piper, J. A. Bellatin and A. Lockheart, EMBO J . 2, 353 (1983). 11. M. E. McMahon, D. Stamenkovich and T. D. Petes, NARes 12, 8001 (1984). 12. M. P. Verbeet, J. Klootwijk, H. van Heerikhuizen, R. D. Fontijn, E. Vreugdenhil and R. J. Planta, NARes 12, 1137 (1984). 13. J. Klootwijk, P. de Jonge and R. J. Planta, NARes 6, 27 (1979). 14. N. Nikolaev, 0. I. Georgiev, P. V. Venkov and A. A. Hadjiolov, J M B 127, 297 (1979). 15. A. E. Veenstra, Ph.D. thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, 1987. 16. D. Lohr and G. I. Ide,JBC 258, 4668 (1983). 17. J. Klootwijk, M. P. Verbeet, G. M. Veldman, V. C. H. F. de Regt, H. van Heerikhuizen, J. Bogerd and R. J. Planta, NARes 12, 1377 (1984). 18. D. L. Riggs and M. Nomura, JBC 265, 7596 (1990). 19. E. A. Elion and J. R. Warner, Cell 39, 663 (1984). 20. A. E. Kempers-Veenstra, H. van Heerikhuizen, W. Musters, J. Klootwijk and R.J. Planta, EMBO J . 3, 1377 (1984). 21. R. V. Quincey and R. E . Arnold, BJ 224, 497 (1984). 22. E. A. Elion and J. R. Warner, MCBiol6, 2089 (1986). 23. R . Mestel, M. Yip, J. P. Holland, E. Wang, J. Kang and M. J. Holland, MCBiol9, 1243 (1989). 24. A. E. Kempers-Veenstra, W. Musters, A. F. Dekker, J. Klootwijk and R. J. Planta, Curr. Genet. 10, 253 (1985). 25. W. Musters, J. Knol, P. Maas, A. F. Dekker, H. van Heerikhuizen and R. J. Planta, NARes 17, 9661 (1989). 26. 8. Sollner-Webb and J. Tower, ARB 55, 801 (1986). 27. M. L. Schmitz, U.-G. Maier, J. W. S . Brown and G. Feix, JBC 264, 1467 (1989). 28. K. Nandabalan and J. D. Padayatty, BBRC 160, 1117 (1989). 29. Y. Mishima, I. Financsek, R. Kominami and M. Muramatsu, NARes 10, 6659 (1982). 30. J. J. Windle and B. Sollner-Webb, MCBiol6, 4584 (1986). 31. R. H. Reeder, D. Pennock, B. McStay, J. Roan, E. Tolentino and P. Walker, NARes 15, 7429 (1987). 32. T. Kulkens, H. van Heerikhuizen, J. Klootwijk, J. Oliemans and R . J. Planta, Curr. Genet. 16, 351 (1989). 33. S . P. Johnson and J. R. Warner, MCBiol 9, 4986 (1989). 34. B. E. Morrow, S. P. Johnson and J. R. Warner, JBC 264, 9061 (1989).
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
125
35. W. Musters, J. Venema, G. van der Linden, H. van Heerikhuizen, J. Klootwijk and R. J. Planta, MCBiol 9, 551 (1989). 36. K. Volkel-Meiman, R . L. Keil and G. S. Roeder, Cell 48, 1071 (1987). 37. M. F. Christman, F. S. Dietrich and G . R. Fink, Cell 55, 413 (1988). 38. S. Gottlieb and R. Easton-Esposito, Cell 56, 771 (1989). 39. 8. J. Brewer and W. L. Fangman, Cell 55, 637 (1988). 40. A. E. Kempers-Veenstra, J. Oliemans, H. Offenberg, A. F. Dekker, P. W. Piper, R. J. Planta and J. Klootwijk, EMBO J . 5, 2703 (1986). 41. M . Dunaway and P. Droge, Nature 341, 657 (1989). 42. H. P. Miiller, J. M. Sogo and W. Schaher, Cell 58, 767 (1989). 43. D. I. Chasman, N. F. Lue, A. R. Buchman, J. W. LaPointe, Y. h r c h and R. D. Kornberg, Genes Dew. 4, 503 (1990). 44. H. Wang, P. R. Nicholson and D. J. Stillman, MCBiol 10, 1743 (1990). 45. M . J. Fedor, N. F. Lue and R. D. Kornberg, J M B 204, 109 (1988). 46. G. M . Veldman, J. Klootwijk, P. de Jonge, R. J. Leer and R. J. Planta, NARes 8, 5179 (1980). 47. M. T. Yip and M. J. Holland, JBC 264, 4045 (1989). 48. I. Grummt, H. Rosenbauer, I. Niedermeyer, U. Maier and A. Ohrlein, Cell 45, 837 (1986). 49. P. Labhart and R. H. Reeder, MCBiol 7 , 1900 (1987). 50. I. Bartsch, C. Schoneberg and I. Grummt, MCBiol 7 , 2521 (1987). 51. K. Pfeifer, T. Prezant and L. Guarente, Cell 49, 19 (1987). 52. R. P. Fisher and D. A. Clayton, MCBiol8, 3496 (1988). 53. L. C. Garg, A. Dixit and S. T. Jacob, JBC 264, 220 (1989). 54. I. Grummt, A. Kuhn, I. Bartsch and H. Rosenbauer, Cell 47, 901 (1986). 55. K. A. Parker and U. Bond, MCBiol9, 2500 (1989). 56. B. McStay and R. H. Reeder, Cell 47, 913 (1986). 57. S . Firek, C. Read, D. R . Smith and T. Moss, MCBiol 9, 3777 (1989). 58. R. Lucchini and R. H. Reeder, NARes 17, 373 (1989). 59. E. Bateman and M. R. Paule, Cell 54,985 (1988). 60. P. Labhart and R. Reeder, PNAS 86, 3155 (1989). 61. 0. MaaLe and N. 0. Kjeldgaard, “Control of Macromolecular Synthesis.” Benjamin, New York, 1966. 62. R. J. Planta and W. H. Mager, in “The Cell Nucleus” (H. Bush and L. Rothblum, eds.), Vol. XII, pp. 213-226. Academic Press, New York, 1982. 63. C. Waldron and F. Lacroute, J . Bad. 122, 855 (1975). 64. D. R. Kief and J. R. Warner, MCBiol 1, 1007 (1981). 65. J. R. Warner, Microbid. Reu. 53, 256 (1989). 66. A. R . Buchman, N . F. Lue and R. D. Kornberg, MCBiol8, 5086 (1988). 67. J. F.-X. Hofmann, T. Laroche. A. H. Brand and S. M. Gasser, Cell 57, 725 (1989). 68. C. Mann, I.-M. Buhler, I. Treich and A. Sentenac, Cell 48, 627 (1987). 69. R. W. Shulman, C. E. Sripati and J. R. Warner, JBC 252, 1344 (1977). 70. R. W. Shulman and J. R. Warner, MGG 161, 221 (1978). 71. L. Waltschewa, 0. Georgiev and P. Venkov, Cell 33, 221 (1983). 72. L. M. Veinot-Ihebot, R. A. Singer and G . C. Johnston, JBC 264, 19473 (1989). 73. M. H. Herruer, W. H. Mager, H. A. RauB, P. Vreken, E. Wilms and R. J. Planta, NARes 16, 7917 (1988). 74. J. Segall, JBC 261, 11578 (1986). 75. G . A. Kassavetis, B. R. Braun, L. H. Nguyen and E. P. Geidushek, Cell 60, 235 (1990).
126
€3. A. RAUk AND R. J . PLANTA
76. D. A. Brow and E. P. Geidushek, JBC 262, 13953 (1987). 77. E. P. Geidushek and G. P. Tocchini-Valentini, ARB 57, 873 (1988). 78. R. Gudenus, S. Mariotte, A. Moenne, A. Ruet, S. Memet, J.-M. Buhler, A. Sentenac and P. Thuriaux, Genetics 119, 517 (1988). 79. R. J. Leer, M. M. van Raamsdonk-Duin, P. Kraakman, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, NARes 13, 701 (1985). 80. M. D. Dabeva and J. R. Warner, JBC 262, 16055 (1987). 81. C. M. T. Molenaar, L. P. Woudt, A. E. M. Jansen, W. H. Mager, R. J. Planta, D. M. Donovan and N. J. Pearson, NARes 12, 7345 (1984). 82. S. M. Papciak and N. J. Pearson, Curr. Genet. 11, 445 (1987). 83. E. Ozkaynak, D. Finley, M. J. Solomon and A. Varshavsky, EMBO J . 6, 1429 (1987). 84. D. Finley, B. Bartel and A. Varshavsky, Nature 338, 394 (1989). 85. K. L. Redman and M. Rechsteiner, Nature 338, 438 (1989). 86. N. Abovich and M. Rosbash, MCBiol4, 1871 (1984). 87. R. J. Leer, M . M. C. van Raamsdonk-Duin, W. H. Mager and R . J. Planta, FEBS Lett. 175, 371 (1984).
88. R. J. Leer, M. M. vanRaamsdonk-Duin, C. M.T. Molenaar, H. M. A. Witsenboer, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, NARes 13, 5027 (1985). 89. M . 0. Rotenberg, M. Moritz and J. L. Woolford, Jr., Genes Dew. 2, 160 (1988). 90. A. Lucioli, C. Presutti, S. CiafrB, E. CafFarelli, P. Fragapane and I. Bozzoni, MCBiol8, 4792 (1988).
91. H. A. Rau6, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, in “Methods in Enzymology” (Christine Guthrie and Gerald R. Fink, eds.), Vol. 194, p. 453. Academic Press, San Diego, 1991. 92. R. J. Leer, M. M . C. van Raamsdonk-Duin, M. J. M. Hagendoorn, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, NARes 12, 6685 (1984). 93. M . Remacha, M. T. Saenz-Robles, M. D. Vilella and J. P. G. Ballesta, JBC 263, 9094 (1988).
K. Mitsui and K. Tsurugi, NARes 16, 3574 (1988). P. Grant, D. Schindler and J. E. Davies, Genetics 83, 667 (1976). P. Grant, L. Shchez and A. JimBnez, J . Bact. 120, 1308 (1974). D. C. Hawthorne and R. K. Mortimer, Genetics 60, 735 (1960). M. Remacha, L. Ramirez, I. Marin and J. P. G. Ballesta, Curs. Genet. 17, 535 (1990). J. L. Woolford, Yeast 5, 439 (1989). M. D. Dabeva, M. A. Post-Beittenmiller and J. R. Warner, PNAS 83, 5854 (1986). 101. C. H. Kim and J. R. Warner, J M B 165, 79 (1983). 102. J. L. Teem, N. Abovich, N. F. Kaufer, W. F. Schwindinger, J. R. Warner, A. Levy, J. Woolford, R. J. Leer, M. M. C. van Raamsdonk-Duin, W. H. Mager, R. J. Planta, L. Schultz, J. D. Friesen, H. Fried and M. Rosbash, NARes 12, 8295 (1984). 103. R. J. Leer, M. M. C. van Raamsdonk-Duin, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, Curr. Genet.
94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100.
104. 105. 106. 107. 108.
9, 273 (1985). M. 0. Rotenberg and J. L. Woolford, Jr., MCBiol6, 674 (1986).
L. P. Woudt, A. B. Smit, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, E M B O J . 5, 1037 (1986). J. C. Larkin, J. R. Thompson and J. L. Woolford, Jr., MCBiol7, 1764 (1987). W. F. Schwindinger and J. R. Warner, JBC 262, 5690 (1987). L. S. Kraakman, W. H. Mager, C. T. C. Maurer, R. T. M. Nieuwint and R. J. Planta, NARes 17, 9693 (1989). 109. K. Struhl, PNAS 82, 8419 (1985). 110. R. J. Planta and H. A. Rau6, Trends Genet. 4, 64 (1988). 111. J. Huet, P. Cottrelle, M. Cool, M.-L. Vignais, D. Thiele, C. Marck, J.-M. Buhler, A. Sentenac and P. Fromageot, EMBO J . 4, 3539 (1985).
RIBOSOME BIOCENESIS IN YEAST
127
112. J. Huet and A. Sentenac, PNAS 84, 3648 (1987). 113. M.-L. Vignais, L. P. Woudt, G. M . Wassenaar, W. H. Mager, A. Sentenac and R . J. Planta, EMBO J . 6, 1451 (1987). 114. L. P. Woudt, W. H. Mager, R. T. M. Nieuwint, G. M. Wassenaar, A. C. van der Kuyl, J. J. Murre, M. F. M. Hoekman, P. G. M. Brockhoff and R. J. Planta, NARes 15, 6037 (1987). 115. M . H. Herruer, W. H. Mager, L. P. Woudt, R. T. M. Nieuwint, G. M.Wassenaar, P. Groeneveld and R. J. Planta, NARes 15, 10133 (1987). 116. A. R. Buchman and R. D. Kornberg, MCBiol 10, 887 (1990). 117. D. D. Donovan and N . J. Pearson, MCBiol 6 , 2429 (1986). 118. K. G. Hamil, H. G. Nam and H. M . Fried, MCBiol8, 4328 (1988). 119. J. C. Dorsman, M. M. Doorenbosch, C. T. C. Maurer, J. H. de Winde, W. H. Mager, R. J. Planta and L. A. Grivell, NARes 17, 4917 (1989). 120. C. Presutti, A. Lucioli and 1. Bozzoni, JBC 263, 6188 (1988). 121. F. Della Seta, S.-A. CiafrB, C. Marck, B. Santoro, C. Presutti, A. Sentenac and I. Bozzoni, MCBiol 10, 2437 (1990). 122. W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, BBA 1050, 351 (1990). 123. M. H. Herruer, W. H. Mager, T. M. Doorenbosch, P. L. M. Wessels, G. M. Wassenaar and R. J. Planta, NARCS17, 7427 (1989). 124. J. Berman, C. Y. Tachibana and B.-K. Tye, PNAS 83, 3713 (1986). 125. A. R. Buchman, W. J. Kimmerley, J. Rine and R. D. Kornberg, MCBiol 8, 210 (1988). 126. J. F. X. Diffley and B. Stillman, PNAS 85, 2120 (1988). 127. P. R. Rhode, K. S. Sweder, K. F. Oegema and J. L. Campbell, Genes Dew. 3,1926 (1989). 128. S. B. Biswas and E. E. Biswas, MCBiol 10, 810 (1990). 129. D. Shore, D. J. Stillman, A. H. Brand and K. A. Nasmyth,EMBOJ. 6, 461 (1987). 130. A. H. Brand, G. Micklem and K. Nasmyth, Cell 51, 709 (1987). 131. D. Shore and K. Nasmyth, Cell 51, 721 (1987). 132. J. C. Dorsman, W. C. van Heeswijk and L. A. Grivell, NARes 16, 7287 (1988). 133. H. Halfter, U. Miiller, E.-L. Winnacker and D. Gallwitz, EMBOJ. 8, 3029 (1989). 134. A. Goel and R. E. Pearlman, MCBiol8, 2572 (1988). 135. S . C. Francesconi and S. Eisenberg, MCBiol 9, 2906 (1989). 136. K. S. Sweder, P. R. Rhode and J. L. Campbell, JBC 263, 17270 (1988). 137. W. Kimmerly, A. Buchman, R. Kornberg and J. Rine, EMBOJ. 7, 2241 (1988). 138. E. Capieaux, M. L. Vignais, A. Sentenac and A. Goffeau, JBC 264, 7437 (1989). 139. J. S. H. Tsang, A. L. Henry, A. Chambers, A. J. Kingsman and S. M. Kingsman, NARes 18, 7331 (1990). 140. G. M. Santangelo and J. Tornow, MCBiol 10, 859 (1990). 141. M. H. Herruer, Ph.D. thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, 1989. 142. C. W. Pikielny and M. Rosbash, Cell 41, 119 (1985). 143. J. R. Warner, G. Mitra, W. F. Schwindinger, M . Studeny and H. M. Fried, MCBiol 5, 1512 (1985). 144. M. G. Wittekind, J. M. Kolb, J. Dodd, M. Yamagishi, S. MBmet, J.-M. Buhler and M. Nomura, MCBiol 10, 2049 (1990). 145. E. Cdarelli, P. Fragapane, C. Gehring and I. Bozzoni, EMBO J . 6, 3493 (1987). 146. A. P. Gultyaev and B. V. Shestopalov, FEBS Lett. 232, 9 (1988). 147. M. Nonet, C. Scafe, J. Sexton and R. Young, MCBiol 7, 1602 (1987). 148. P. Vreeken, R. van der Veen, V. C. H. F. de Regt, A. L. de Maat, and H. A. Rau6, Biochimie, in press (1991). 149. H. J. Himmelfarb, A. Viissarotti and J. D. Friesen, MGG 195, 500 (1984). 150. N. Abovich, L. Gritz, L. Tung and M. Rosbash, MCBiol 5, 3429 (1985).
128
H . A. RAUt AND R. J . PLANTA
151. T. T. A. L. El-Baradi, C. A. F. M. van der Sande, W. H. Mager, H. A. Rau6 and R. J.
Planta, Curr. Genet. 10, 733 (1986). 152. Y.-F. Tsay, J. R. Thompson, M. 0. Rotenberg, J. C. Larkin and J. L. Woolford, Jr., Genes Deu. 2, 664 (1988). 153. E. Maicas, F. G. Pluthero and J. D. Friesen, MCBiol 8 , 169 (1988). 154. C. Gorenstein and J. R. Warner, MGG 157, 327 (1977). 155. A. Bachmair and A. Varshavsky, Cell 56, 1019 (1989). 156. F. SBnchez-Madrid, F. J. Vidales and J. P. G. Ballesta, EJB 114, 609 (1981). 157. S. Zinker, BBA 606,76 (1980). 158. K. Mitsui, T. Nakagawa and K. Tsurugi, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 104, 908 (1988). 159. H. G . Nam and H. M. Fried, MCBiol6, 1535 (1986). 160. P. W. Piper and K. B. Striby, FEBS Lett. 250, 311 (1989). 161. S. A. Udem and J. R. Warner, J M B 65, 227 (1972). 162. G. M. Veldman, J. Klootwijk, H. van Heerikhuizen and R. J. Planta, NARes 9, 4847 (1981). 163. J. Trapman and R. J. Planta, BBA 442, 265 (1976). 164. S. Kass, N. Craig and B. Sollner-Webb, MCBiol7, 2891 (1987). 165. Y. Mishima, M. Katayama and K. Ogata, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 104, 515 (1988). 166. N. Craig, S . Kass and B. Sollner-Webb, PNAS 84, 629 (1987). 167. T. Gurney, Jr., NARes 13, 4905 (1985). 168. R. Crouch, in “Processing of RNA” (D. Apirion, ed.), pp. 214-226. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, 1984. 169. B. Miiller and W. A. Eckert, Eur. J . Cell Biol. 49, 225 (1989). 170. W. Musters, R. J. Planta, H. van Heerikhuizen and H. A. Rau6, in “The Ribosome: Structure, Function, and Evolution” (W. E. Hill, A. Dahlberg, R. A. Garrett, R. B. Moore, D. Schlessinger and J. R. Warner, eds.), pp. 435-442. Am. Soc. Microbiol., Washington, D.C., 1990. 171. W. Musters, Ph.D. thesis, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, 1990. 172. H. A. Rau6, J. Klootwijk and W. Musters, Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 51, 77 (1988). 173. J. Klootwijk and R. J. Planta, Methodr Entymol. 180, 92 (1989). 174. D. Tollervey, EMBOJ. 6 , 4169 (1987). 175. H. V. Li, J. Zagorski and M. J. Fournier, MCBiol 10, 1145 (1990). 176. J. Zagorski, D. Tollervey and M. J. Fournier, MCBiol8, 3282 (1988). 177. J. M. X. Hughes, D. A. M. Konings and G. Cesareni, EMBOJ. 6 , 2145 (1987). 178. S. Kass, K. Tyc, J. A. Steitz and B. Sollner-Webb, Cell 60,897 (1990). 179. R. L. Maser and J. P. Calvet, PNAS 86, 6523 (1989). 180. I. L. Stroke and A. M. Weiner, J M B 210, 497 (1989). 181. G. R. Fabian and A. K. Hopper, MCBiol7, 1571 (1987). 182. G. R. Fabian, S. M. Hess and A. K. Hopper, Genetics 124, 497 (1990). 183. H. A. Rau6, W. Musters, C. A. Rutgers, J. van? Riet and R. J. Planta, in “The Ribosome: Structure, Function, and Evolution” (W. E. Hill, A. Dahlberg, R. A. Garrett, P. B. Moore, D. Schlessinger and J. R. Warner, eds.), pp. 217-235. Am. SOC. Microbiol., Washington, D.C., 1990. 184. G. M. Veldman, J. Klootwijk, V. C. H. F. de Regt, R. J. Planta, C. Branlant, A. Krol and J.-P. Ebel, NARes 9, 6935 (1981). 185. R. C. Brand, J. Klootwijk, C. P. Sibum and R. J. Planta, NARes 7, 121 (1979). 186. T. Kruiswijk, A. Kunst, R. J. Planta and W. H. Mager, BJ 175, 221 (1978). 187. T. Kruiswijk, J. T. de Hey and R. J. Planta, BJ 175, 213 (1978). 188. F. J. Vidales, M. T. Saenz-Robles and J. P. G. Ballesta. Bchem 23, 390 (1984). 289. ‘ I T. A. L. El-Baradi, V. C. H. F. de Regt, S. W. C. Einerhand, J. Teixido, R. J. Planta, J. P. G. Ballesta and H. A. RauB, JMB 195, 909 (1987).
RIBOSOME BIOGENESIS IN YEAST
129
190. M. J. Dognin and €3. Wittmann-Liebold, FEBS Lett. 84, 342 (1977). 191. F. Gotz, C. Fleischer, C. L. Pon and C. 0. Gualerzi, EJB 183, 19 (1989). 192. R. J. Leer, M. M. C. van Raamsdonk-Duin, C. M. T. Molenaar, L. H. Cohen, W. H. Mager and R. J. Planta, NARes 10, 5869 (1982). 193. S. P. Johnson and I. R. Warner, MCBiol7, 1338 (1987). 194. E. Otaka, T. Kumaiaki and K. Matsumoto, ]. Bact. 167, 713 (1986). 195. M. T. Saenz-Robles, M. D. Villela, M. Remacha, J. P. G. Ballesta and S. Zinker, unpublished. 196. M. Remacha, C. Santos and J. P. G. Ballesta, MCBiol 10, 2182 (1990). 197. P. A. Silver and M. N. Hall, in “Protein Transfer and Organelle Biosynthesis” (R. C. Das and P. W. Robbins, eds.), pp. 749-769. Academic Press, San Diego, California, 1988. 198. B. Roberts, BBA 1008, 263 (1989). 199. W.-C. Lee and T. M618se, PNAS 86, 8808 (1989). 200. J. F. Kalinich and M. G . Douglas, JBC 264, 17979 (1989). 201. P. Silver, I . Sadler and M. A. Osborne, J . Cell Biol. 109, 983 (1989). 202. R . B. Moreland, H. G. Nam, L. M. Hereford and H. M. Fried, PNAS 82, 6561 (1985). 203. M. R. Underwood and H. M. Fried, EMBO]. 9, 91 (1990). 204. P. J. Schaap, 1. van’t Riet, C. L. Woldringh and H. A. RauC, submitted. 205. P. J. Schaap, J. van’t Riet and H. A. RauC, in preparation. 206. M. Nelson and P. Silver, MCBiol9, 384 (1989). 207. C. Dingwall, S . V. Sharnick and R. A . Laskey, Cell 30, 449 (1982). 208. R. B. Moreland, G . L. Langevin, R. H. Singer, R. L. Garcea and L. M. Hereford, MCBiol 7, 4048 (1987). 209. R. H. Booher, C. E . Alfa, J. S. Hyams and D. H. Beach, Cell 58, 485 (1989). 210. D. Kalderon, W. D. Richardson, A. F. Markham and A. E. Smith, Nature 311,33 (1984). 211. T. Kruiswijk, R. J. Planta and J. M. Krop, BBA 517, 378 (1978). 212. T. T. A. L. El-Baradi, H. A. Rau6, V. C. H. F. de Regt and R. J. Planta, EMBO]. 4,2101 (1985). 213. J. C. Lee, R. Anderson, Y. C. Yeh and P. M. Horowitz, ABB 237, 292 (1985). 214. T. T. A. L. El-Baradi, H. A. Rau6, V. C. H. F. de Regt and R. J. Planta, EJB 144, 393 (1984). 215. M. A. Nieto, F. Hernfindez and E. Palacian, MCBchern 86, 55 (1989). 216. T. T. A. L. El-Baradi, H. A. Rau6, M. Linnekamp and R. J. Planta, FEBS Lett. 186, 26 (1985). 217. C. A. Rutgers, P. J. Schaap, J. Van’t Riet, C. L. Woldringh and H. A. Rau6, BBA 1050,74 (1990). 218. J. C. Lee, in “The Yeasts,” 2nd ed. CSHLAb, Cold Spring Harbor, New York, in press (1990). 219. L. Gritz, N . Abovicb, J. L. Teem and M. Rosbash, MCBiol 5, 3436 (1985). 220. G. Fleming, P. Belhumeur, D. Skup and H. M. Fried, PNAS 86, 217 (1989). 221. A. A. Hadjiolov, Cell B i d . Monogr. 12, (1985). 222. J . Trapman, J. Retd and R. J. Planta, Exp. Cell Res. 90, 95 (1975). 223. J . Trapman, R. J. Planta and H. A. Rau6, BBA 442, 275 (1976). 224. A. B. Sachs and R. W. Davis, Cell 58, 857 (1989). 225. E. R. Dabbs, in “Structure, Function and Genetics of Ribosomes” (B. Hardesty and G. Kramer, eds.), pp. 733-748. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1985. 226. A. Khanna-Gupta and V. C. Ware, PNAS 86, 1791 (1989). 227. N . BataillC, T. Halser and H. M. Fried, J . Cell B i d . 111, 1571 (1990). 228. S . 1. Dworetzkv and C. M. Feldherr, J. Cell B i d . 106, 575 (1988).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Structural Elements in RNA MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND
IGNACIOTINOCO,JR.
Unioersity of California Berkeley, California 94720
1. Secondary Structure B. Single-stranded Regions C. Hairpins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
E. Internal Loops ..................... F. Junctions ..........................
136
. . . .
111. Tertiary Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Tertiary Base-pairing ................................ B. Single Strand-Helix Interactions ............................... C. Helix-Helix Interactions 1V. Predicting Tertiary Inter V. Three-dimensional Structure VI. Determining RNA Struc VII. Protein-RNA Interactions . . . VIII. RNA-RNA Interactions IX. RNA-DNA Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...........................................
150 150 153
170 171
The discovery that RNA molecules can catalyze phosphodiester bond cleavage and formation (1,2)dramatically changed our view of RNA function and greatly increased interest in RNA structure. There are several examples of RNA molecules that catalyze the cleavage, and in some cases the formation, of phosphodiester linkages. The first discovery of catalytic RNA was the generation of active rRNA from pre-rRNA in Tetrahymena by self-splicingthe excision of a region of RNA from the middle of a precursor RNA and ligation of the two ends to give an active rRNA and an intron (1).Similar reactions have been observed in a number of organisms for other introns (3, 4). Several other catalytic RNA structures that undergo self-cleavage, but not ligation, have been discovered. These include structures within the minus strand of tobacco ringspot virus (5, 6), the human 6 virus (7), and the “hammerhead” structure found in several organisms (8, 9). In an intermolecular reaction, the RNA component of RNase P (EC 3.1.26.5) is sufficient to cleave mature tRNA from a tRNA precursor (2). There is growing evidence that mRNA structure regulates processes such as transcription (10, 11), splicing (12),translation (13,14), and mRNA decay 131 Progress in Nucleic Acid Research and Molecular Biology. Vol. 41
Copyright 8 1881by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
132
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
(15-17). For example, protein synthesis is reduced in prokaryotic systems if the nucleotides within the Shine-Dalgarno region upstream from the initiation codon form a stable structure, since these nucleotides must pair with the 3’ end of the ribosome to initiate translation (18-21). The structure of the mRNA for topoisomerase gene 60 in bacteriophage T4 has a more dramatic effect on protein synthesis (22). A sequence of 50 nucleotides in the mRNA is skipped by the ribosome during translation so that amino acids corresponding to these nucleotides are not incorporated into the protein. Different aspects of RNA structure influence biological processes. The three-dimensional structure of self-splicing RNAs arranges functional groups to catalyze specific phosphodiester bond cleavage and formation. The global folded structure of an mRNA is less likely to regulate translation since the ribosome unfolds the mRNA as it is translated; however, the local structure of the mRNA can influence the ability of the ribosome to bind and translate the mRNA. The increased interest in RNA function has led to a corresponding interest in RNA structure. Two problems have slowed the characterization of RNA structure. One is that techniques for synthesizing RNA were limited in their ability to generate large quantities of many RNA sequences. The second problem is that biological RNA molecules, with the exception of tRNA, have not formed crystals suitable for X-ray diffraction. The development of enzymatic (23)and chemical (24, 25) methods for synthesizing large amounts of RNA oligonucleotides, plus the development of new techniques for determining RNA structure, have now led to the characterization of several RNA molecules. Here we describe the RNA structural characteristics that have emerged so far. In those cases in which RNA studies are incomplete, studies of DNA are described with the rationalization that RNA structures may be analogous to DNA structures, or that the techniques used to study DNA could be applied to the analogous RNA structures. We focus on aspects of RNA structure that affect the three-dimensional shape of RNA and that affect its ability to interact with other molecules.
1. Secondary Structure Folded RNA molecules are stabilized by a variety of interactions, the most prevalent of which are stacking and hydrogen bonding between bases. Watson-Crick base-pairing is usually thought of first, but the importance of base stacking is seen in the crystal structure of tRNAPhe, where 71 of the 76 bases are stacked (26).Many interactions between backbone atoms also occur in the structure of tRNA, although they are often ignored when considering RNA structure since they are not as well-characterized as interactions be-
133
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
tween bases. Backbone interactions include hydrogen bonding and stacking of sugar or phosphate groups with bases or with other sugar and phosphate groups. The interactions found in a three-dimensional RNA structure can be divided into two categories: secondary interactions and tertiary interactions. This division is useful for several reasons. Secondary structures are routinely determined by a combination of techniques discussed in Section 11, whereas tertiary interactions are more difficult to determine. Computer algorithms that generate RNA structures can search completely through possible secondary structures, but inclusion of tertiary interactions makes a complete search of possible structures impractical for RNA molecules even as small as tRNA. Finally, the division of RNA structure into building blocks consisting of secondary or tertiary interactions makes it easier to describe RNA structures. To distinguish tertiary interactions from secondary structure, the sequence of the RNA is drawn on a plane; the backbone forms a continuous closed boundary if a line is drawn joining the 5’ end to the 3’ end. Hydrogen bonding between bases in the sequence may be depicted by lines joining the bases; these lines must remain within the closed boundary. A secondary structure can be represented without any lines crossing. Tertiary interactions occur when lines cross; this is called chord crossing. Secondary and tertiary structures of tRNAPhe are shown in Fig. 1. The secondary structure of RNA consists of duplex and loop regions that can be divided into six different types, as shown in Fig. 2: duplexes, single-
0 60
* *
* * 35
FIG.1. The definition of secondary structure and tertiary structure in terms of chord crossing. The lines between points represent base-pairs. (a) The secondary structure of tRNAPhe. (b) The secondary and tertiary structures of tRNAPhe.
134
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND ICNACIO TINOCO, JR.
a. DUPLEXES
b. SINGLE STRANDED REGIONS
c. HAIRPINS
d. BULGES
HAIRPIN LOOP
HAIRPIN STEM
IIULGE
e. INTERNAL LOOPS
hllSMA'I'CH
ASYMMKI'RIC SYMMWRIC INI'KRNAL LOOP INI'ERNAL LOOP
SINGLE-BASE IIULGE
f. JUNCTIONS
THREE STEM
FOUR STEM
FIG. 2. Secondary structures of RNA.
stranded regions, hairpins, internal loops or bubbles, bulge loops or bulges, and junctions.
A. Duplexes Duplex RNA forms a right-handed double helix stabilized by stacking between adjoining bases and by hydrogen bonds between bases on opposite, antiparallel strands. The conformations of double-helical regions in RNA
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
135
have been determined by X-ray diffraction studies of fibers and single crystals (26-28). The structures are all similar to that found for DNA fibers at low humidity; the geometry of these helices is termed “A-form.” Proton NMR measurements on a variety of RNA oligonucleotides in solution are also consistent with A-form geometry (24, 29-32). The A form of duplex RNA differs in several ways from DNA duplexes, which typically have B-form geometry in aqueous solution. The riboses in Aform RNA adopt a 3‘-endo conformation, whereas B-form DNA deoxyriboses are in the 2‘-endo conformation; with the usual phosphodiester backbone angles, the distance between phosphorus atoms in RNA is 5.9 A, compared to a distance of 7.0 8, in B-form DNA (26). The base-pairs in A-form helices are tilted with respect to the helix axis and displaced from it by about 4 A; this causes the minor groove in RNA to be wide and shallow, and the major groove to be very narrow and deep (Fig. 3). In crystals, the A-form RNA helix has 11 bp per turn, as opposed to 10 bp per turn of B-form DNA helix. In both RNA and DNA, the helices wind tighter in aqueous solution. The helical repeat of RNA in solution is reported (34) as 11.3 bp per turn or as 11.6 bp (34a), as compared to 10.6 bp per turn for DNA (35-37).
FIG.3. A- and B-form helices tilted from the helix axis so that the groove sizes are visible. Fiber-diffraction coordinates are used (27.33). Note (a) the deep and narrow major groove of Aform geometry compared to (b) the wide major groove of B-form geometry.
136
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
Although there are local variations in conformation depending on base sequence, RNA duplex regions are, in general, in standard A-form geometry. Unusual sequences may adopt other conformations. For example, Z-RNA is formed by alternating C-G base-pairs in the presence of high salt concentrations (29, 38).
B. Single-stranded Regions Single-stranded regions consist of unpaired nucleotides at the 5’ or 3’ end or between duplex regions of an RNA secondary structure. The conformation of these nucleotides differs from that of nucleotides in loop regions of secondary structure, since the ends of loop regions such as hairpins are constrained by the secondary structure. In the absence of tertiary interactions to constrain single-stranded regions, these regions are assumed to be roughly ordered by base stacking in a helical geometry similar to the structures of single-stranded RNAs that have no potential for base-pairing (26).
C. Hairpins A hairpin consists of a duplex bridged by a loop of unpaired nucleotides. Hairpin loops are known to bind proteins, form tertiary interactions, and serve as nucleation sites for RNA folding. The conformation of the backbone in hairpin loops must differ from the conformation of the backbone in helical regions in order to reverse the direction of the RNA strand. The goal of studies on hairpin loops is to understand how the conformation of the loop nucleotides depends on the size and sequence of the loop. The smallest loop capable of bridging a duplex was originally thought to be three nucleotides (39), but there is growing evidence that in some sequences, two unpaired nucleotides suffice to form hairpins in both RNA (40) and DNA (41).Thermodynamic studies of hairpins with loop sequences (U),, (C),, or (A), (n ranging from 3 to 9) showed that loops containing four or five nucleotides are the most stable (42). Loops containing four unpaired bases are the most prevalent in 1 6 4 rRNA (43). Eight different four-base-loop sequences (tetraloops) account for over 60% of the ribosomal tetraloop sequences (44;R. Gutell and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, personal communication). Two of these sequences form unusually stable hairpins: UUCG (45) and GAAA (44, 46; 0. C. Uhlenbeck, personal communication). The interactions that stabilize particular loop sequences can be determined by examining the structures of hairpins determined by X-ray crystallography or NMR. NMR studies of the hairpin GGAC(UUCG)GUCC show that interactions between loop bases and between loop bases and the sugar-phosphate backbone contribute to the unusual stability of the UUCG loop sequence (40, 40a; see Fig. 4). U, and G, form a reverse wobble U*Gpair (shown in Fig. 5 )
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
137
FIG.4. The structure of an unusually stable hairpin with the loop sequence UUCG as determined by NMR. Interactions stabilizing the loop include a reverse wobble G.U base-pair with a syn G and a hydrogen bond between a cytosine amino proton and a phosphate oxygen. Thin circles represent CY-endo sugars; thick circles represent CB'-endo sugars. Thin rectangles indicate anti bases; thick rectangles indicate syn bases. Dotted circles represent phosphates. Ellipses (. . .) indicate hydrogen bonds. Solid boxes represent stacking. (Reprinted from 40.)
with the guanosine in the syn conformation. This leaves a loop of only two unpaired nucleotides: u6 and C,. The u6 base stacks on the sugar of C,, and the C, base stacks on the Us base. The C, amino proton is close to a 3' phosphate oxygen of Us, implying the formation of a base-phosphate hydrogen bond. The presence of this hydrogen bond is consistent with the 1.4 kcal/mol destabilization of the loop (in 10 mM buffer, pH 6.5, at 25°C) when the cytidine at position 7 is changed to uridine. NMR studies of the U, mutant show little change in loop conformation. G, is still syn, and most of the chemical shifts are the same as in the original molecule. The destabilization can be explained by the replacement of the favorable contact between the C, amino and a 3' phosphate oxygen of U, by an unfavorable interaction of the U, keto with the phosphate oxygen. The loop is also destabilized by switching the closing base-pair from C4.Ggto G4Cg(45);N M R studies have not yet been done to try to understand this effect. N M R studies of three hairpins with small loops indicate that the conformation of the sugar-phosphate backbone throughout the loop is very different from A-form geometry. In the UUCG loop just described, U6 and C, have 2'-endo sugar conformations different from the 3'-endo conformations of the A-form stem. Furthermore, the presence of two phosphate resonances in the downfield region of the spectrum indicates that some of the loop backbone torsion angles are different from the backbone conformation found in duplex regions. These changes enable the sugar-phosphate backbone of the small loop to bridge the duplex region. N M R studies ofa hairpin with loop sequence UCU (31)and a hairpin with loop sequence UUU (P. Davis, personal communication) show similar behavior. The three nucleotides in these loops have 2'-endo sugar puckers, and some of the phosphate resonances are in the
138
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR,
A.A
u. u
C*AII*
c.c
A.C
c.u
WObb*
Rvmrw Watson-Crkh
Rmvoru Hooprian
FIG. 5. Non-Watson-Crick hydrogen-bonding schemes. Most mismatches have more than one possible hydrogen-bonding scheme; a complete list is found in 26.
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
139
downfield region of the spectrum, indicating non-A-form backbone conformations. In the case of the hairpin with loop sequence UUU, the deviation from A-form geometry extended 1 bp into the stem region. We suspect that changes in the sugar-phosphate backbone, including 2’-endo sugar puckers, are a general property of small hairpin loops. A-form geometry is preserved in portions of larger hairpin loops. As proposed prior to the crystal structure determination (47), five of the seven nucleotides in the anticodon loop of yeast tRNAPhecontinue stacking on the 3’ strand (26). The stacking of the anticodon bases in A-form helix geometry leaves these nucleotides accessible for base-pairing with the mRNA. The five stacked nucleotides are followed by a turn in the sugar-phosphate backbone created by a change in the phosphodiester torsion angles between G, and U,. The turn structure is stabilized by a hydrogen bond between the imino proton of U,, and a 3’ phosphate oxygen of A,, as well as stacking between the phosphate of G, and the base of U33. One-dimensional NMR studies of the anticodon loop of yeast tRNAPheshowed that the structure in solution is consistent with the crystal structure described (48),although two-dimensional NMR methods are needed to give unambiguous assignments. A hairpin that occurs in wheat germ 5-S rRNA containing a loop of 12 nucleotides has been studied by N M R (49, 50). A-form stacking does continue into the loop from the stem, but, unlike the anticodon loop, the stacking continues for several nucleotides along the 5’ strand. The loop is also stabilized by C-U mismatch hydrogen bonding (see Fig. 5 ) between the first two loop nucleotides. The hairpins studied so far show that the stability of a hairpin loop changes with different loop sequences and sizes. The structures of the tRNA anticodon loop and the UUCG loop suggest that the specific loop sequences adopt conformations that are more stable because they contain more hydrogen bonding and stacking interactions-particularly interactions with the sugar-phosphate backbone. It has been suggested (51)that loop nucleotides stacked in A-form geometry along the 3’ strand are a common feature of RNA hairpins. The examples discussed here show that there is a range of loop structures. The anticodon loop contains nucleotides stacked along the 3’ strand, but the hairpin from 5-S rRNA has nucleotides stacked along the 5’ strand. In the three small hairpin loops-UUCG, UCU, and UUU-the backbone angles of each loop nucleotide differ significantly from A-form geometry. The conformations of the nucleotides in these small loops suggest that these nucleotides are not very accessible for base-pairing with other regions of RNA. Five of the nucleotides in the anticodon loop, on the other hand, are stacked in normal A-form geometry which facilitates pairing with other nucleotides. The structures of hairpin loops determine how the loop nucleotides can
140
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND ICNACIO TINOCO, JR.
interact with regions of the same RNA molecule, with other RNA molecules, and with proteins. Further studies of RNA hairpins are needed to determine more about the interactions that stabilize hairpin loops. Helical regions are stabilized by hydrogen bonding and stacking between bases. The nucleotides in hairpin loops are stabilized by hydrogen bonding between base protons and phosphate oxygens, and by stacking between bases, sugars, and phosphates. The effect that the closing base-pair of the stem has on the stability and structure of hairpin loops must be determined.
D. Bulge Loops Bulge loops (or bulges) are defined as unpaired nucleotides on one strand of a double-stranded region; the other strand has continuous base-pairing. Bulges range in size from one to many nucleotides. The main structural questions of interest are: (1) Does one unpaired base intercalate into the helix, or is it extrahelical, with the base-pairs on either side stacked on each other? (2) How much does a bulge bend or kink the helix? (3) What is the effect of very large bulge loops? Do the surrounding base-pairs break to form an internal loop instead of a bulge? The local conformation of single-base bulges in several DNA oligonucleotides has been studied, but there has been very little work on RNA bulges. The equilibrium between a nucleotide bulge intercalating in or looping out of the helix depends on temperature, the identity of the bulge nucleotide, and the sequence of base-pairs in the duplex surrounding the bulge. This equilibrium is demonstrated by NMR studies on DNA oligonucleotides containing a thymidine bulge that loops out of the helix at 0°C and intercalates into the helix at 35°C when located between two guanosines, whereas a thymidine bulge located between two cytidines remains looped out of the helix independent of the temperature (52). NMR studies on an RNA duplex with a uridine bulge between two guanosines show that it loops out of the helix (53). The local conformation of nucleotides in bulge loops containing more than one nucleotide have not been studied by high-resolution structural techniques. Determining the conformation of these loops in RNA is important for understanding how these nucleotides interact with other elements of secondary structure to form tertiary interactions and for understanding how proteins bind to bulge loops. The chemical reactivity of bulge loops in 1 6 4 rRNA (54)has been studied. A bulge loop containing six nucleotides appears to exist without breaking the base-pairs on either side, since these pairs are protected from chemical modification. Some of the nucleotides within the bulge loop were also protected from modification, which suggests either that
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
141
the loop nucleotides form a structure involving stacking and hydrogen bonding, or that the nucleotides form tertiary interactions. Bulge loops can affect the long-range structure of nucleic acid helices by creating a bend in the double helix. Bending has been detected by the altered mobility in nondenaturing gel electrophoresis for both RNA and DNA helices containing bulge loops (55-57). Bulge loops in DNA or RNA helices containing five adenosines were found to alter the gel mobility more than bulge loops containing five thymidines or uridines (34,55),which shows that the structure of the bend depends on the identity of the bulge nucleotides. The bending was also shown to be affected by the base-pairs surrounding the bulge loop. The gel mobility for bulge loops of adenosines in DNA differed when the sequence flaking the bulge was d[AGG(A),TCG].d[CGACCT] rather than d[CGA(A),CCT].d[AGGTCG] (55). One of the assumptions made when studying RNA secondary structure is that the structure is independent of the surrounding conformations. For example, a short region of duplex RNA is assumed to be the same whether it occurs next to a hairpin or next to a junction. Several studies suggest that bulge nucleotides affect the structure of the duplex surrounding them for several base-pairs. Thermodynamic studies showed that the free energies of bulge loops containing adenosines were 2 kcal/mol more stable (at 37°C) for the sequences GCG(A),GCGACGCCGCA than for GCG(A),GUCA-GACCGCA. Helices containing dangling nucleotides were more destabilized by bulge loops than were helices without dangling nucleotides (58). Nuclease V, (EC 3.1.22.3 or 3.1.27.8) cutting in duplex regions containing bulges and intercalated ethidium showed that ethidium intercalation into a double helix is affected for several base-pairs around a bulge nucleotide (59).A distortion in the duplex region near an adenosine bulge (in boldface) in the sequence d[CGCGAAATTTACGCG], was observed by NMR. The presence of a phosphate resonance in the downfield region of the spectrum indicated an unusual backbone conformation. The downfield resonance was assigned to the 5’ phosphate of the guanosine one nucleotide removed from the bulge (60). Thus, the distortions due to bulges are not necessarily localized at the bulge, but may extend into the surrounding duplex region. Many questions remain about bulge loop structures. Bulge loops bend RNA, but a correlation between the number and sequence of bases in the bulge and the extent of bending has not been established. Does a single base bulge that is looped out of the helix create a bend? Bulge loops containing more than one nucleotide have not been structurally characterized at high resolution. The structures of these loops determine the ability of bulge loop nucleotides to form tertiary pairs. Finally, the effect bulge loops have on the surrounding duplex structures must be determined.
142
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
E. Internal Loops 1. MKSMATCHES Two apposed nucleotides that cannot form a Watson-Crick pair are called mismatches. The two mismatched bases can engage in some other form of hydrogen-bonding, or they can form an open loop of two nonbonded nucleotides. Figure 5 shows some of the hydrogen-bonding schemes proposed for mismatches with two hydrogen bonds, although mismatches containing only one hydrogen bond have been found in tRNA (26). Mismatches occur frequently in proposed secondary structures. The stability, the contribution of the surrounding sequences to the stability, the hydrogen bonding, and the effect on the sugar-phosphate backbone of the various mismatches has not been determined systematically in RNAs. The most-characterized mismatch is the wobble G*Upair (Fig. 5),which forms two hydrogen bonds and is virtually as stable as an A-U pair (61). Crystal structures of tRNAPhe and tRNAAsp containing G.U mismatches show that they are usually incorporated into the helix without creating distortions in the backbone. However, one of the G*Upairs in the crystal structure of yeast tRNAASpdoes have an irregularity in the backbone. Two of the sugar-phosphate backbone angles (aand y in Fig. 6) at the G-Upair in the anticodon stem are in the trans conformation instead of the normal gauche conformation found in helical regions (62).The distortion in the helix backbone is presumably caused by the difference in the width of a mismatch pair (C1’-Cl’ distance) versus that of Watson-Crick base-pairs. The difference in width could also explain why G-Umismatches are slightly less stable when they are in the middle of a Watson-Crick region of a helix than at the end (61)and why many of the mismatches in proposed rRNA secondary structures are found at helix termini (43, 63). A change in backbone
RASE
FIG.6. The nomenclature describing the torsion angles that define the conformation of a nucleotide. Another parameter describing the sugar conformation is needed to completely define the conformation, hut this parameter, the sugar puckering amplitude, has not varied in crystal structures of RNA and is usually assumed to be constant (26).
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
143
conformation may be a recurring feature of mismatches, although these distortions seem to depend on the sequence surrounding the mismatch. The hairpin GCGA,UU,(UCU)G,&,,CGCC has been studied by NMR (31).It has a stem of 6 bp, including A$ *C12and U,.G,, mismatches. Interproton distances by NMR were consistent with A-form stem geometry, even at the mismatches. The A + .C pair forms by protonation (at pH 6.5) of the adenine at the imino nitrogen, and is proposed to result in a pair containing two hydrogen bonds whose geometry is very similar to that of a G.U pair (Fig. 5). The free energy of formation of the A + C pair, is 2 kcal/mol less stable than an A*U pair at 37°C. Two hydrogen bonds form in the G-A mismatch (Fig. 5 ) found at the end of the anticodon helix in tRNAPhe. G-A mismatches occur frequently at helix termini in rRNA (63),and hydrogen bonding in G*A mismatches has been proposed (on the basis of chemical modification) to occur in several internal loops in rRNA (64,65). A symmetrical RNA duplex containing two G.A mismatches (in boldface) and 3’ dangling guanosines, [GCGAGCG],, is 1.9 kcal/mol more stable at 37°C than predicted by the nearest-neighbor parameters, suggesting that G*Amismatches from stable structures (58). More data are available on mismatches in DNA than in RNA. The gel mobilities of DNA restriction fragments containing all 12 possible mismatches are unchanged compared to a fully Watson-Crick helix; this shows that mismatches do not cause significant bends in the helix axis (66). Thermodynamic studies on mismatches in the DNA oligonucleotides dCAAAXAAAG + dGTTTYTTTC showed that mismatches involving guanine (GaT, G-G, G-A) are the most stable, and mismatches involving cytosine ( C C , C*A)are the least stable (67).
2. INTERNALLOOPS Internal loops contain three or more nucleotides not capable of forming Watson-Crick base-pairs; there is at least one unpaired nucleotide on each strand. Internal loops containing equal numbers of unpaired nucleotides on each strand are symmetrical, and those containing unequal numbers are asymmetrical. Comparison of computer-predicted secondary structures to phylogenetically derived ones suggests that asymmetrical internal loops are thermodynamically less stable than symmetrical ones (68).It is not known what determines whether internal loops are open or whether they close by forming non-Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding. The effect that internal loops, particularly asymmetrical ones, have on the helical backbone of RNA has not been determined. Chemical modification of two asymmetrical internal loops in the S8 protein binding site of 1 6 4 rRNA suggests that one is open and the other is closed by the formation of mismatch hydrogen bonding (69).The accessi-
144
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
bility of all of the nucleotides in a loop to either chemical or enzymatic modification is good evidence that the loop remains open. Uridines in the second loop were protected from modification, suggesting the formation of hydrogen bonds in a U-U mismatch (Fig. 5);the U-U pair, together with the accessibility of three adenosines in this loop to chemical modification, suggests that the loop closes with the three adenosines looped out of the helix. NMR studies have been done on a symmetrical internal loop of Escherichia coli 5-S rRNA, known as loop E (70).The chemical shift and exchange behavior of the imino protons assigned to nucleotides in the loop indicate that the loop does not close by forming hydrogen bonds in G - G or G-A (Fig. 5) mismatch pairs. An open conformation was also found for a symmetrical internal loop similar to loop E of Xenopus Zueuis 5-S rRNA by NMR studies (30).This internal loop (Fig. 7) has the potential to close by the formation of hydrogen bonds in G*A mismatches, but the imino proton spectrum indicates that the nucleotides in the loop are not involved in hydrogen bonding. NMR studies on the nonexchangeable protons showed that the bases within this open loop stack extensively with only minor distortions from A-form geometry. A uridine was added to this internal loop to make the sequence identical to that within loop E of X. Zueuis 5-S rRNA (B. Wimberly, unpublished
b
a
5'
5'
G A
G-C G-C C-G G-C
A U
G-C G-C C-G G-C, G A +A UG A A
u u
C-G c-G G-c C-G
5'
A-U C-G C-G G-C C-G
s'
FIG.7. Conformations of two internal loops, as determined by NMR. Breaks in NOE connectivities between adjacent nucleotides are marked by arrows. (a) An open internal loop structure is formed by an eight-base symmetrical internal loop (30). (b) Adding a single nucleotide to form an asymmetrical nine-base internal loop results in a closed structure with mismatch hydrogen bonding and a guanosine looped out of the helix (9. Wimberly, personal communication).
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
145
results). The structure of the asymmetrical internal loop which contains four nucleotides on one strand and five on the other (Fig. 7) is very different from the structure of the symmetrical one, despite the addition of only one nucleotide. NMR studies of the asymmetrical loop show that it closes with the guanosine on the longer strand looped out of the helix and hydrogen-bond formation in at least one of the mismatches in the loop. A closed structure for this loop was also proposed on the basis of chemical modification (M),although the guanosine thought to be extrahelical on the basis of NMR was proposed to be involved in a G-A pair (Fig. 5). Determining where bends occur in RNA structures is important for understanding which regions of secondary structure are close together in the tertiary structure. It has been proposed in a model of the 16-S rRNA structure that a large bend occurs in a six-nucleotide symmetrical internal loop (71), but the effect of internal loops on the sugar-phosphate backbone in RNA has not been studied experimentally. Gel-mobility studies show that symmetrical internal loops of six or ten adenosines or thymidines in DNA bend the helix axis very much less than bulge loops (55). The structures of internal loops in RNA remain poorly defined. The influence of loop sequence and size on the ability of internal loops to close by the formation of non-Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding must be determined. The accessibility of nucleotides in internal loops to tertiary pairing depends on the loop conformation. Extensive stacking of the bases within open internal loops may facilitate tertiary pairirig, whereas bases in closed internal loops would be unavailable. Finally, the effects of symmetrical and asymmetrical internal loops on the sugar-phosphate backbone must be explored: Do bends occur at internal loops?
F. J unctions Junctions, or multibranched loops, contain three or more double-helical regions with a variable number of unpaired nucleotides where the helical regions come together. Junction regions are important because helical regions can stack coaxially at these regions, and because the alignment of helical regions at junctions gives these regions characteristic shapes. The only RNA junction whose conformation has been established is the four-stem junction in tRNA. For each tRNA for which a crystal structure has been determined, the acceptor stem stacks coaxially on the T stem, and the D stem stacks on the anticodon stem forming two long helical regions. These two helical regions are oriented roughly perpendicular to each other, cresting the overall L shape of the molecule. Several of the unpaired nucleotides in the junction are involved in tertiary interactions, which are discussed in Section 111. An example of an RNA junction whose conformation plays a role in
146
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
protein binding is found in the 5-S rRNA from X. Zueuis. This three-stem junction contains four unpaired nucleotides critical for binding transcription factor IIIA. Mutations of the unpaired nucleotides in the junction greatly reduce protein binding (72), even though the protein does not directly contact these nucleotides (73). The implication of these studies is that the unpaired nucleotides in the junction act as a hinge controlling how the helical regions stack on each other, thus determining the overall three-dimensional conformation of the 5-S rRNA. The conformation of a four-stem DNA junction, a model of recombination intermediates, has been determined (74). The conformation of the fourstem DNA junction was determined by measuring fluorescence energy transfer between acceptor and donor groups located on the four different helical regions. The four stems of the junction stack coaxially in pairs to form two long helical regions oriented in an X shape. The difference between the shapes of four stem-junctions in tRNA and in the four-stem DNA junction could be caused by the presence of unpaired nucleotides in the junction of tRNA. On the basis of the tRNA structure, 5-S rRNA studies, and the DNA four-stem junction structure, it seems to be a general feature of junction regions that different stems stack coaxially to form longer helical regions. Coaxial stacking between helical regions in the 1 6 4 rRNA has been proposed on the basis of phylogenetic comparison (75). One criterion for deciding whether two helical regions stack is that their combined length in basepairs is conserved between different organisms, although the lengths of individual helices are not conserved. It has also been suggested (76)that the helical regions separated by the fewest unpaired nucleotides will stack coaxially. Both of these methods for predicting coaxial stacking predict more coaxially stacked helical regions than are found in a 16-S rRNA model based on chemical crosslinking (77). Experimental studies must be done to determine which factors, such as the number of stems and unpaired nucleotides in the junction, govern the stacking of different helices. In addition to stacking helical regions together, junction regions act as hinges that orient the different helical regions in space. The four-stem junction in tRNAs adopt an L shape and the four-stem DNA junction adopts an X shape. The conformations of more RNA junctions should be characterized in order to learn the various shapes that junctions can adopt. Junction regions appear to constitute catalytic RNA sites. The hammerhead self-cleaving RNA region is coded for by newt satellite DNA (78) and is found in plant viruses (8), virusoids (79), and viroids (9).The consensus secondary structure for the catalytic domain contains a three-stem junction containing 11 unpaired nucleotides. Most of the unpaired nucleotides of the junction region are conserved (Fig. 8) and are required for the self-cleavage
147
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
N J
FIG. 8. The “hammerhead” self-cleavage RNA structure found in several organisms is shown, with the position of specific cleavage marked by an arrow and the conserved nucleotides boxed.
reaction (80, 81). The specific cleavage takes place between one of the unpaired nucleotides and a stem region (Fig. 8);a 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate and a 5’-OH group are formed (9).The catalytic activity must involve the conformation of the unpaired nucleotides in the junction since these comprise almost all of the required nucleotides. Growing evidence implies that the unpaired nucleotides in a five-stem junction of the 2 3 4 rRNA form the peptidyl transferase site of the ribosome, where peptide bonds are formed when amino acids are transferred from tRNAs to the nascent protein (82). Chemical “footprinting” experiments have established that unpaired nucleotides in this junction are protected from chemical modification when tRNA is bound to the peptidyl transferase site (83).Direct chemical crosslinking of the tRNA to the five-stem junction has also been seen (84, 85). The examples of the hammerhead catalytic domain and the peptidyl transferase junction of 23-S rRNA illustrate the importance of determining the conformation of unpaired nucleotides in junction regions. Not only do the conformations of these nucleotides have a great impact on the threedimensional structure by orienting the stem regions that meet at the junction, but also these nucleotides can be positioned to catalyze specific reactions.
II. Predicting Secondary Structure Two techniques that are commonly used either separately or together to predict RNA secondary structure are phylogenetic comparison (43, 86) and thermodynamic stability (39, 61). Phylogenetic comparison is the method
148
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND ICNACIO TINOCO, JR.
currently used as the standard for determining secondary structure. The underlying principle is that mutations that do not alter function will be preserved. Since function is assumed to depend on structure, the preservation of a structure between different organisms, despite changes in the base sequence, is good evidence for the structure’s existence.
A. Phylogenetic Comparison Phylogenetic comparison requires that RNA sequences from several different organisms be known. The sequences are first aligned and then searched for regions capable of base-pairing. since helical regions are maintained if G*C pairs are replaced by A*U pairs or vice versa, covariance of nucleotides establishes which regions are involved in base-pairing and which are not. A helix is usually considered to exist if two or more covariations are found in it (43, 86). In practice, organisms whose primary sequences differ by 20-40% give the best results with phylogenetic comparison (86). Sequences that are too dissimilar are difficult to align, and sequences that are too similar do not have enough compensatory base changes to establish the existence of helical regions. A limitation of the phylogenetic method is that it cannot provide any information about regions of secondary structure that contain conserved nucleotides. Thus, phylogenetic methods tend to predict fewer helices than actually exist in the molecule.
B. Thermodynamic Stability Thermodynamic stabilities are used routinely to predict secondary structure. Computer algorithms predict structures by calculating the free energies for all possible base-pairing schemes and finding the secondary structure of lowest free energy. Computer algorithms that find several different secondary structures whose calculated free energies are close to the lowest free energy (87, 88) are important for several reasons. One reason is that the calculated energies are based on incomplete experimental data and thus have significant uncertainties. Another reason is that biological RNA molecules begin folding as they are synthesized; they could become kinetically trapped in a structure that is not the structure of lowest energy. Furthermore, tertiary interactions may stabilize a secondary structure that is not calculated to have the lowest free energy. The most fundamental reason for calculating alternate secondary structures is that biological RNA molecules may not form a single secondary structure, but may instead have several structures in equilibrium. This has been suggested, for example, for the cIZ1 gene mRNA of bacteriophage X (19). Free energies are calculated from experimentally determined parameters by the computer algorithms using a nearest-neighbor model. Since stacking interactions are short-range, it is reasonable to assume that the free energy of a helical region depends on the sequence of dinucleotide steps it
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
149
contains (39). This nearest-neighbor model has been tested for short duplexes with different sequences, but with the same set of dinucleotide steps; with only a few exceptions, the average agreement between the predicted and measured free energies is within 6% (61). The free energies of loop regions (hairpins, internal loops, and bulges) are more difficult to quantitate. Originally, loop free energy was assumed to depend only on the number of unbonded nucleotides within the loop. This was based on free energies of loop formation of a small set of molecules with limited sequence variation (89, 90). There are now examples of loop regions whose free energy of formation depends markedly on the sequence of nucleotides within the loop. For example, the hairpin loop UUCG discussed above is much more stable than would be predicted by the current freeenergy parameters. So is the internal loop containing two G-Amismatches (in boldface) formed by the duplex with 3’ dangling guanosines [GCGAGCG],. As more thermodynamic data are collected for loop regions, more accurate formulas for predicting the free energy of loop regions will become possible. Junction regions present bigger problems than other loop regions. No thermodynamic data have been measured for the free energy of junction formation in RNA. The present computer programs typically assume that the free energy of a junction region depends on the number of stems and the number of unpaired nucleotide within the junction (88). The values of the parameters are empirically derived to best fit the structures of RNA sequences whose secondary structures are well established. Despite the problems with free energy of loop formation, current computer algorithms do remarkably well in predicting RNA secondary structure. The lowest free-energy structures calculated by the Zuker program for over 200 molecules predicted 70% of the helices deduced from phylogeny (44). Furthermore, the best structure within 10% of the lowest free energy predicted 90% of the helices correctly. The number of correctly predicted helices will surely increase as more free energies are measured for loop formation. In practice, both phylogenetic comparison and computer algorithms are used to predict secondary structure. If only a few sequences that are not homologous enough to align for phylogenetic comparison are available, they can be folded with computer algorithms. A model secondary structure can be determined by searching for a common secondary structure among the various suboptimal foldings generated for the different sequences (91). Determining a secondary structure by either method is usually an iterative process. The secondary structure model is refined as more sequences are determined or as the model is compared to the results of chemical and enzymatic modification procedures that map the accessibilities of different nucleotides.
150
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
111. Tertiary Interactions RNA molecules fold into compact structures stabilized by tertiary interactions not included in the secondary structure. Secondary and tertiary interactions are distinguished in terms of chord crossing (Fig. 1).Tertiary interactions are considered separately from secondary structure, since the formation of tertiary interactions depends not only on the nucleotides that form the tertiary interaction but also on the rest of the secondary structure. For example, the conformation about the four-stem junction in tRNA brings the T loop and the D loop close together; this allows tertiary pairing between nucleotides in these loops. The nucleotides in the anticodon loop cannot interact with either of the other loops, since the anticodon loop is fixed at one end of the molecule by the junction conformation. The biological functions of RNA molecules-in particular, catalytic behavior-are determined by their three-dimensional structures. Characterizing all of the tertiary interactions that occur in an RNA molecule does not completely describe the three-dimensional structure, but tertiary interactions do indicate regions of the secondary structure that are close together in space. Most of what we know about tertiary interactions comes from a few tRNA crystal structures, but we are beginning to learn more about tertiary interactions from a variety of methods (discussed in Section IV) to study an increasing number of RNA molecules. The goal is to find recurring tertiary elements: specific arrangements of secondary structure elements stabilized by tertiary contacts. Here we discuss the three types of tertiary interactions so far characterized: tertiary base-pairing, single-strand-helix interactions, and helix-helix interactions.
A. Tertiary Base-pairing 1. PSEUDOKNOTS
Nucleotides that are unpaired in the secondary structure of an RNA molecule can form tertiary contacts by hydrogen bonding to other nucleotides unpaired in the secondary structure. In general, this could occur between any of the secondary structure regions containing unpaired nucleotides (single-stranded regions, hairpin loops, bulge loops, internal loops, and junction loops). All of these interactions were originally termed knots or pseudoknots (92); here, we use the term “pseudoknot” to describe only the structure in which nucleotides in a loop (hairpin, internal, or bulge) pair with nucleotides in a single-stranded region. Different types of pseudoknots are shown in Fig. 9 (93). Pseudoknots have been found in an increasing number of biological sys-
151
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
a
b
C
@ EB 3'
5'
FIG. 9. The different types of pseudoknots are diagrammed for hairpin loops pairing with an adjacent single-stranded region. (a) In the best-characterized form of pseudoknot, the loop at the top crosses the major groove, and the loop at the bottom crosses the minor groove. (b) This form of pseudoknot, in which one loop crosses the major groove and the other loop bridges the whole helix, has not been found. (c) This type of pseudoknot was proposed to occur in the amRNA of E . coli (94). One loop crosses the minor groove, and the other loop bridges the whole helix.
tems since their discovery at the 3' end of several plant RNAs (95, 96). The viral RNAs were recognized by tRNA-specific enzymes, but the secondary structures predicted for these sequences did not include an amino-acid acceptor stem. The formation of a pseudoknot allows these molecules to fold into a tertiary structure functionally similar to tRNA, even though the secondary structures are different. Pseudoknot formation also enhances frameshifting during translation in the coronavirus IBV (97). The mechanism by which pseudoknots contribute to frameshifting has not been determined, but the combination of an (A+ U)-rich sequence and a pseudoknot results in a frameshift. One possible explanation is that the pseudoknot causes the ribosome to pause, allowing slippage to occur at the A+U-rich sequence. This mechanism seems to be a general one, since 14 of 22 sequences from a variety of viruses, known or suggested to contain frameshifting sites, have the potential to form pseudoknots (97). A pseudoknot of the type diagrammed in Fig. 9a formed by a short oligonucleotide has been studied by N M R (98). The interproton distances, determined by NMR, were consistent with the two stem regions, one containing 5 bp and the other containing 3 bp, with A-form helix geometry. The distances between protons located in the two different stem regions indicate that the two stem regions stack coaxially to form one continuous helical
152
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
region. The pseudoknot appears to be a normal duplex from one side, but on the other side, two loops bridge the duplex, one crossing the major groove and one crossing the minor groove. The size of the loops was varied without changing the stem sizes to show that the minimum loop size for crossing the minor groove of the 3-bp stem is three nucleotides, and the minimum loop size for crossing the major groove of the 5-bp stem is two nucleotides. The pseudoknot is only marginally more stable than either of the two potential hairpin structures that the sequence could form. The equilibrium between pseudoknot and hairpins depends on salt concentration, temperature, and nucleotide sequence (99). 2. LOOP-LOOPINTERACTIONS There are several examples of RNA molecules containing tertiary contacts between nucleotides that are in loop regions of secondary structure. Phylogenetic comparison suggests that the RNA component of RNase P, which catalyzes the processing of tRNA precursors, makes Watson-Crick pairs between four nucleotides in one junction loop and four nucleotides in a second junction loop (100).These are interactions between secondary structure loop regions in the crystal structure of yeast tRNAPhe. Two of the nucleotides in the D loop form parallel pairs with two nucleotides in the T loop: G,,*IJJ, and G,,C,. Two additional tertiary base-pairs are formed between unpaired nucleotides in the central four-stem junction and nucleotides in the D loop: a reverse-Hoogsteen pair (Fig. 5), U,.A,,, and a parallel-stranded reverse-Watson-Crick pair (Fig. 5), G15*C,, (26). These tertiary pairs are stabilized by hydrogen bonding and stacking interactions with adjacent nucleotides; they are partially responsible for stabilizing the L shape of tRNA. Tertiary pairs between loop regions have also been proposed on the basis of phylogenetic comparison in the 16-S and 2 3 4 rRNAs (101,
102). The high frequency with which known RNA structures contain tertiary pairing between nucleotides that are unpaired in the secondary structure stresses the importance of learning more about such interactions. Can unpaired nucleotides in all of the secondary structure loop types engage in tertiary pairing? There are several examples of pairing involving nucleotides in hairpin loops and junction loops, but it is not known whether nucleotides in bulge loops or internal loops form tertiary interactions. The fact that tRNA has tertiary pairing between parallel strands shows that the rules for forming tertiary pairs can be different from the rules for secondary structure. The thermodynamics of tertiary pairs is of critical importance for predicting their existence. In the tRNAs and pseudoknots, tertiary pairs contribute less to the free energy than secondary structure does, but it may be possible for very stable tertiary interactions to replace secondary structure.
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
153
6. Single Strand-Helix Interactions 1. INTERCALATION Base stacking is one of the most important factors stabilizing RNA structures. One of the ways in which stacking can stabilize the tertiary structure is for nucleotides that are unpaired to intercalate between base-pairs. An example of intercalation is seen in the crystal structure of yeast tRNAPhe, where G,,, an unpaired nucleotide in the T loop, intercalates between two nucleotides of the D loop, G,, and G,,, which form tertiary pairs with nucleotides in the T loop. To accommodate the intercalated guanine between the two tertiary pairs, the sugar-phosphate backbone is extended by a change in the G,, sugar conformation to 2'-endo (26).
2. BASE-TRIPLES Base-triples occur when an unpaired nucleotide forms hydrogen bonds with a nucleotide that is already base-paired. The third base of a base-triple may bind to the Watson-Crick pair in either the major or minor groove and be stabilized by the formation of one or two hydrogen bonds as well as stacking interactions. Several biological functions have been proposed for base-triples. Base-triples stabilize the three-dimensional shape of tRNA and several other RNA molecules discussed below. The formation of DNA triples inhibits transcription in uitro (103),and it has been suggested that a small RNA molecule may inhibit transcription by forming a triplex 115 bp upstream from the transcription site of the human c-myc gene (104, 105). The self-splicing intron from Tetruhymenu binds guanosines via base-triple formation during the self-splicing reaction (106). Three base-triples occur in tRNAPhe, all of which involve nucleotides in the junction loop binding in the major groove to Watson-Crick pairs of the D (Fig. lo), the third stem. In two of the triples, Ag*A,,*U,, and G,,*G,,C,, base forms two hydrogen bonds with the purine of the Watson-Crick pair, while only one hydrogen bond is formed by the third base in G,,.G,,C,, (26).Different base-triples are found in the crystal structure of tRNAAsp(62); the A46*G22.+13 triple replaces the G,,*G,,.C,, triple of tRNAPhe, with the adenosine forming one hydrogen bond with the G*+ pair in the major groove. An unusual base-triple occurs at the beginning of the D loop. A,, binds to the tertiary reverse-Hoogsteen pair (Fig. 5) A,,.U, by forming base-base and base-sugar hydrogen bonds. A,, forms one hydrogen bond with an amino proton of A,, and one hydrogen bond with the 2'hydroxyl of U,; the 2' hydroxyl of A,, forms a hydrogen bond with a base nitrogen of A,*. These base-triples in tRNA occur at the hinge region between the two helical domains and help stabilize the tRNA in its characteristic L shape.
154
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
n
I
U*A*U
C-G*CH+
n
U*A*A
C*G*G
FIG. 10. Proposed hydrogen-bonding schemes for base triples. U.A.A and C.G.G base triples have been proposed with several different hydrogen-bonding schemes. For other schemes, see 26 and 108. (Reprinted from 107.)
Another RNA molecule that forms base-triples is the self-splicing intron from Tetrahymena. The intron binds a free guanosine during cleavage at the 5' exon and binds an internal guanosine during cleavage of the 3' exon. It is in the P7 postulated that these guanosines bind to a base-pair, G,,C,,,, stem by forming a base-triple (106).Replacing the G C pair with an A.U pair abolished splicing activity, but cleavage at the 5' exon was restored by adding 2-aminopurine instead of guanine. 2-Aminopurine can form a basetriple with the A * U pair that is isomorphic to the wild-type G.G*C triple.
155
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
This is strong evidence for the existence of the G.G.C triple in the splicing reaction of the wild-type intron. A base-triple has also been proposed to occur between a nucleotide in a junction loop and an adjacent helix in Xenopus Zueuis 5-S rRNA (109).On the basis of chemical modification and model building, it is proposed that an adenosine in the junction loop binds to a G-U pair in the minor groove by forming two hydrogen bonds, one between the adenosine N7 and the 2' hydroxyl of the guanosine, and one between the adenosine amino and a base nitrogen of the guanosine. The formation of base-triples in junction regions where helices stack coaxially may be a recurring RNA structural element. If two helical regions in a junction stack coaxially (Fig. ll), it is a consequence of A-form helix geometry that the 3' strand cannot reach the major groove of the adjacent helix, and the 5' strand cannot reach the minor groove of its adjacent helix.
b
T-stem
D-stem G-C-U-G-
minor groove
c
stem V
major groove
stem I1
c minor groove minor groove
major groove
major groove
d P9.0
minor groove
P7
major groove
FIG. 11. Base-triple formation at regions where helices coaxially stack may be a recurring RNA structure. (a) The 3' strand enters the major groove, and the 5' strand enters the minor groove. (b)Two of the three base-triples in tRNAphe are consistent with this model. The 5' strand does not enter the minor groove as expected, but instead loops back into the major groove to form a third triple. (c) The proposed minor-groove triple in Xenopus loeuis 5-S rRNA (109).(d)The major-groove triple that occurs in the self-splicing intron from Tetrahymenu(106).
156
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
The 3' strand of unpaired nucleotides can follow the minor groove of the adjacent helix, while the 5' strand can follow the major groove of its adjacent helix. Although oversimplified, this picture is consistent with two of the three base-triples that form in tRNAPhe, and with the base-triple proposed to occur in the 5-S rRNA from X. Zueuis (Fig. 11). The base-triple formed during the 3' splicing reaction of the intron from Tetruhymenu also fits this model if the recently identified P9.0 helix near the 3' splice site of the Tetruhymenu intron (106, 110) is stacked on the P7 helix (Fig. 11). To predict the existence of base-triples, the sequences that can form triples must be determined, and their structures and thermodynamic stabilities must be characterized. Triple helices were originally found in polynucleotides with simple repeating sequences. Fiber diffraction studies on the poly(rU).poly(rA)-poly(rU) system showed that the third strand, poly(rU), bound parallel to the purine strand of the Watson-Crick helix in the major groove with two hydrogen bonds between the adenine and uridine (111). In addition to rU.rA*rU, the following polynucleotides have been shown to form triple helices: rA-rA-rU, rC+.rG*rC (at pH7.0), and rG.rG*rC (112) (Fig. 10). Recent NMR studies of DNA triples show that dC + .dG.dC forms a structure isomorphic with dT*dA.dT (113, 114); the corresponding RNA triples are probably isomorphic as well. Structural characterization has not been done on rG-rG*rCor rA*rA.rU triple helices yet, but these base-triples can form isomorphic structures. Replacing the rA.rA*rU base-triple in tRNAPhe with a sequence capable of forming an rG.rG*rC base-triple resulted in no loss of aminoacylation activity, whereas sequences that could not form base-triples did lose activity (108). Unpublished results from our laboratory, including UV absorption mixing curves and circular dichroism spectra, show that poly(rA)*poly(rG).poly(rC) forms a triple helix. A hydrogen-bonding scheme has not yet been determined for this structure, but the poly(rA) strand appears to bind in the minor groove of the Watson-Crick duplex. The evidence for minor groove binding is that a triple helix did not form when the poly(rG) strand was replaced by poly(rI), which lacks the minor groove amino group capable of hydrogen bonding to poly(rA).
C. Helix-Helix Interactions We have already described structures in which helical regions stack coaxially end to end. Helix-helix contacts can form between the grooves of different helices when RNA molecules fold into compact tertiary structures. The negatively charged sugar-phosphate backbones repel each other, but a variety of interactions found in crystal structures of nucleic acid duplexes could stabilize the structure. The importance of the 2' hydroxyl groups in stabilizing helix-helix contacts is seen in the crystal structure
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
157
of an RNA duplex [U(UA),A],. There are 12 intermolecular hydrogen bonds between the 2' hydroxyl groups in one helix and either uracil carbonyl groups or sugars in the minor groove of another helix (28).Another type of helix-helix contact is found in the crystal structure of a DNA duplex, d[ACCGGCGCCACA]-d[TGTGGCGCCGGT]. Cytosine amino protons in the major groove of one helix form hydrogen bonds with phosphate oxygens of another helix (115). In general, helix-helix interactions could include base-phosphate, base-sugar, sugar-sugar, and sugar-phosphate hydrogen bonding. Helix-helix contacts have been implicated in the function of one intriguing biological system. The Tetrahymena intron is capable of binding a nicked duplex RNA containing three oligonucleotides and then ligating the nick (116).Since the nicked duplex is base-paired and the reaction is independent of the duplex sequence, the intron must bind the duplex substrate through the formation of helix-helix contacts. The weakness of the contacts between the intron and the duplex substrate is evidenced by a Michaelis constant greater than 0.1 mM. This system illustrates the complexity of the interactions stabilizing RNA structure. Determining the interactions between bases is not enough to understand the structure and function of RNA; the backbone interactions must be determined as well. Another system in which helical regions may interact involves sequences rich in guanosine. Guanosine-rich DNA sequences have been proposed to form duplex structures (117),and there is evidence that two of these duplexes in solution dimerize to form four-stranded DNA complexes (118-120).It is not known whether similar sequences in RNA can form these structures, but X-ray diffraction studies have shown that poly(rG) forms a structure containing four parallel strands with the four equivalent guanosines hydrogen-bonded in a coplanar arrangement (121).
IV. Predicting Tertiary Interactions The secondary structures for a wide variety of biological RNA molecules have been established by a combination of techniques such as phylogenetic comparison, chemical and enzymatic modification, and computer prediction algorithms. Some biological functions of RNA can be understood once the secondary structure is known, but understanding most biological functions, particularly catalytic RNA activity, requires the determination of RNA three-dimensional structure. The next step toward the prediction of RNA three-dimensional structure is to develop methods to predict its tertiary interactions. The same two methods used to predict secondary structure (phylogenetic comparison and computer algorithms) can be used to predict tertiary interactions. As currently used, both of these methods are limited because
158
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
they predict tertiary interactions only between bases. The tertiary interactions in the crystal structures of tRNA contain many examples of base-sugar, base-phosphate, sugar-sugar, and sugar-phosphate interactions (62, 122).
A. Phylogenetic Comparison Establishing the presence of tertiary structure from phylogeny relies on the replacement of a specific tertiary pairing by an equivalent one. Phylogenetic comparison has been used to predict the existence of WatsonCrick tertiary pairing in the RNA component of RNase P (loo), the Tetruhymenu intron (123, 124), and both the 1 6 4 (125) and 23-S (101,102) rRNAs. Phylogeny can also be used to predict the existence of base triples, as was done for tRNA (126). There are several limitations on predicting tertiary pairs using phylogenetic comparison. All but one of the tertiary pairs formed in tRNA is nonWatson-Crick; these include reverse-Hoogsteen, reverse-Watson-Crick, and parallel-stranded pairing. If this is true for other RNA molecules, phylogenetic comparison will have trouble predicting tertiary pairings. Although phylogenetic evidence has been used to suggest the presence of non-WatsonCrick pairs (101),in general, we do not know which non-Watson-Crick pairs are equivalent. Since phylogenetic comparison depends on sequence variation, the structures of conserved regions cannot be predicted. This is a problem in predicting secondary structure and could be a much greater limitation in the case of tertiary structure. The nucleotides in tRNA that are engaged in tertiary pairing are much more highly conserved than are those involved in secondary structure. If this is true in general, it will be difficult to predict tertiary pairing by phylogeny.
B. Thermodynamic Stabilities The use of thermodynamic stabilities to predict secondary structures has already been discussed. Extending this approach to the prediction of tertiary interactions poses several problems. We discuss the problems inherent in predicting tertiary motifs and then describe an algorithm that predicts the pseudoknot tertiary structure as well as secondary structure. The prediction of tertiary interactions using computer algorithms based on thermodynamic stabilities poses three problems: (1)evaluating free energies for all of the possible secondary and tertiary structures requires prohibitive amounts of computer time; (2) rules governing which regions of secondary structure are sterically allowed to form tertiary interactions have not been established; and (3) the free energies of most tertiary structures have not been determined. The distinction between secondary and tertiary structures was originally made so that an algorithm could rigorously consider all of the possible secondary structures. For an RNA of n nucleotides, the number of different
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
159
base-pairs possible is n(n - 1)/2. If tertiary pairs are allowed, the number of possible structures increases proportional to n factorial instead of n2; this renders impractical a rigorous examination of all possible secondary and tertiary structures for a biological RNA. Since we cannot search every possible combination of secondary and tertiary structures, we must choose criteria that limit the number of structures to be evaluated, but still find the biologically relevant structures, Although the actual path by which RNA molecules fold is a kinetic property, we assume that the structure that forms is the structure of lowest free energy. This means that we can fold the RNA by any path we choose as long as the free energy for each step is known. One way to restrict the number of structures evaluated is first to find the low-free-energy secondary structures by standard programs (88). Then tertiary interactions are added to a small number of calculated secondary structures to obtain the tertiary structure of lowest free energy. We cannot use the approach just outlined for predicting tertiary structures until we know how to look for secondary structure elements that can form tertiary interactions. For example, from the cloverleaf secondary structure of tRNA, how would the algorithm know that the junction conformation brings the D loop close to the T loop, but not to the anticodon loop? Until we learn more about the conformation around the junction, internal, and bulge loops, assumptions must be made about which loop regions can interact. The simplest assumption is that any pair of loop regions can interact. Prediction of tertiary interactions also requires knowledge of the free energy of forming tertiary interactions. Judging from tRNA and pseudoknots, secondary structure is more stable than tertiary structure. If this is true, the calculation of the free energy for tertiary pairs after the calculation of the free energy for secondary structure is justified. Errors in this assumption can be accounted for by predicting tertiary interactions for several secondary structures. Unfortunately, free energies have not been measured for most tertiary structures. The free energy of pseudoknot formation has been determined for a very limited set of molecules (99), but the free energies of other tertiary interactions, such as loop-loop pairing, base-triples, or intercalation, have not been determined. Despite the difficulties of predicting tertiary structure, an algorithm capable of predicting pseudoknots as well as secondary structure has been developed (93).The algorithm calculates the free energy of formation for all of the stem-loops that could be formed by the structure. The predicted structure starts with the stem-loop with the lowest free energy of formation; new stem-loops consistent with those already incorporated are added in order of their stability. The algorithm predicts stem-loops due to pseudoknots as well as those due to normal hairpins. The biggest limitation of this
160
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
algorithm is that it only predicts a single structure. The free-energy contribution of the base-pairs in a pseudoknot were assumed to be the same as in a hairpin stem; the free-energy contribution of the two loops of the pseudoknot was empirically determined so that known pseudoknots were predicted. The program also predicted pseudoknots in sequences that had not previously been shown to contain pseudoknots. The most important information needed to improve tertiary structure prediction are the free-energy parameters for tertiary interactions such as pseudoknots, tertiary base-pairs, and base-triples. Furthermore, rules must be developed indicating which tertiary contacts are sterically possible for a given structure. Realistic predictions of tertiary interactions and three-dimensional structure will not be possible until the conformations around junctions, bulge loops, and internal loops are known.
V. Three-dimensional Structure Once the secondary structure and tertiary interactions contained in an RNA molecule are known, the next step in understanding its structure is the determination of a three-dimensional structure. The concept of one threedimensional structure may be misleading, since it implies that the molecule exists in a single structure and ignores the changes the RNA can undergo. Ultimately, we would like to know all of the conformations an RNA molecule can adopt and the dynamics of their interconversion. The first step toward this goal is determination of the three-dimensional structure of one conformation. Since no three-dimensional structures of RNA are known, with the exception of tRNA, which is discussed extensively elsewhere (26, 62, 122), we discuss the three-dimensional models which have been built for other RNAs. Three-dimensional models are built in an attempt to understand the functions of RNAs and to guide the development of further experiments to refine the models. These models are built from phylogenetically proven secondary structures plus information about the accessibility of nucleotides to chemical probes, the positions of crosslinks, and any phylogenetically suggested tertiary pairing. Models have been built for 1 6 3 rRNA (71, 77, 127-129), 5-S rRNA (log), the 3' end of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA (130), and the self-splicing intron of Tetrahymena (76). Although the details differ, in general, the following assumptions about RNA structure are used. Model builders first assume that helical regions adopt standard A-form geometry; this is supported by NMR experiments on RNA in solution as well as the known crystal structures of RNAs. Only loop regions of RNA are now left with any degrees of freedom. The conformations of loop regions are varied without bringing atoms closer than van der Waals
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
161
contact, so that regions of secondary structure satisfy the crosslinking and tertiary pairing constraints. Helical regions around junction regions are allowed to stack coaxially to form longer helical regions. The process of model building shows the importance of secondary structure loop regions (internal loops, bulge loops, and junctions) in the threedimensional structure of RNA. The ability to predict the conformation of loop regions or even the ability to rule out certain conformations would significantly improve the process of building three-dimensional structures of RNA molecules. The positions of the helical regions in models depend on different types of experimental data. For example, the three-dimensional locations of the proteins bound to 16-S rRNA (131) were combined with protein-RNA crosslinking and footprinting data to generate constraints on 75% of the helices in one of the models of 1 6 4 rRNA (77). Another model, based on much of the same data, is in substantial agreement with this model (71),as is a model built from the accessibility of the 16-S rRNA to DNA oligonucleotide probes, which constrains 40% of the helices in the 16-S rRNA (128). Chemical and enzymatic modification data are useful, but these data are insufficient to determine the relative positioning of helical regions.
VI. Determining RNA Structure RNA structure can be determined at several levels of resolution. The experimental method giving the highest resolution is single crystal X-ray diffraction. In principle, it can provide the coordinates of all of the atoms, although for the large molecules of biological interest the positions of the protons are only inferred. X-Ray diffraction thus reveals the secondary, tertiary, and three-dimensional structures. Unfortunately, RNA molecules often do not form crystals suitable for X-ray analysis, and thus only a few threedimensional structures of RNA molecules have been solved: tRNAphe (132, 133), tRNAAsp(62), and tRNAfMet(134), as well as an oligonucleotide duplex, [U(U-A),Al, (28). The method with the next highest level of resolution is NMR. It complements the X-ray method in that it provides distances between nearby protons (distances less than 5 &; it can also determine backbone torsion angles. Thus, NMR provides details about local conformation and can be used to determine secondary, tertiary, and, in principle, three-dimensional structures. Information about the arrangement of the secondary structure elements in three dimensions can also be obtained from crosslinking and fluorescence energy transfer experiments. Chemical and enzymatic modifications are used to determine the accessibility of functional groups within nucleotides,
162
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
and the effect of mutations introduced into RNAs on biological activity can also determine RNA structure.
A. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance NMR experiments provide a powerful method for determining the structures of proteins and nucleic acids in solution. Detailed explanations of NMR methodology applied to nucleic acids have been published (135, 136), so we only outline the principles of the NMR method here. Then we discuss how well the information determined by NMR defines the three-dimensional structures of RNA molecules. NMR methods provide three types of information that can be used in structure determination: nuclear Overhauser effects (NOES),scalar coupling constants, and chemical shifts. NOE is the transfer of magnetization due to magnetic dipole-dipole coupling between nuclei. The effect is directly proportional to the magnetic moments of the nuclei and depends on the inverse sixth power of the distance between them. NOES can be measured between protons up to 5 A apart. Both the exchangeable and nonexchangeable protons in RNA are used for NOE measurements. Information regarding base-pairing and stacking can be obtained from the measurement of NOES between imino resonances assigned to specific nucleotides. The imino protons resonate in a separate region of the spectrum from other protons, and each Watson-Crick base-pair contains one hydrogen-bonded imino proton. Only imino protons that are hydrogen-bonded, or whose rates of solvent exchange are otherwise decreased, are seen in the NMR spectrum. NOES between imino protons have been measured in molecules as large as tRNA (137).The secondary and tertiary base-pairing as well as the coaxial stacking of helical regions of tRNA in solution have been confirmed by this method (138, 139). NOES between the nonexchangeable base and sugar proton resonances give much more detailed information about RNA structure than exchangeable-proton NMR. About 21 intranucleotide distances (9 base-sugar and 12 intra-sugar) can be measured between base and sugar protons. These distances are sufficient to define the conformation of a nucleoside. Up to 11 additional internucleotide (base-base, base-sugar, and sugar-sugar) distances can be measured, depending on the RNA structure. NMR studies on the nonexchangeable protons are currently limited to oligonucleotides containing no more than 30 or 40 nucleotides. New NMR techniques such as isotopic labeling (70, 140) and three-dimensional NMR methods (141) are being developed, which will allow NMR studies on larger RNA molecules. Oligonucleotides used for NMR studies of nonexchangeable protons are designed to adopt structures found in larger RNA molecules. Lower-resolution studies such as chemical modification can be done to check
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS I N RNA
163
that the structure adopted by the oligonucleotide is similar to the structure within the larger RNA molecule. Scalar coupling constants, also called spin-spin splittings, can be measured for two nuclei separated by two, three, or sometimes four bonds. For a three-bond splitting, for example, H-C-C-H, the value of the coupling constant depends on the torsion angle for rotation around the central bond. Coupling constants are related to torsion angles by Karplus-type equations (142); these relationships have been determined for the sugar-phosphate backbone in RNA by studies of model compounds (143). Coupling constants can be measured between ribose protons as well as between protons and phosphorus atoms. These coupling constants can be used to determine four of the seven torsion angles that completely define the conformation of a nucleotide unit (Fig. 6). Information about two of the three remaining torsion angles can be estimated from phosphorus chemical shift information as described below, and the remaining torsion angle can be determined from the intranucleotide NOEs. In principle, all of the torsion angles can be determined by NMR methods. The chemical shift of a resonance depends on the local magnetic field at the nucleus. The local magnetic field is extremely sensitive to the bonding, and to the proximities and types, of nearby atoms. Unfortunately, no simple correlation between proton chemical shift and structure has been established so far, although chemical shifts have been calculated for protons in several molecules (144). Phosphorus chemical shifts have been correlated with the two phosphodiester torsion angles 0-P-0 (145). Normally, both phosphodiester torsion angles are in the gauche conformation. Both theory (146) and experiment (14,148) suggest that ifeither of the two angles changes to the trans conformation, the phosphorus resonance moves to the downfield region of the spectrum. The two adjacent C - 0 torsion angles and the 0 - P - 0 bond angle have also been shown to effect the phosphorus chemical shift (149).Ifthe information inherent in the chemical shift could be tapped, NMR structure determination would become much more powerful. In principle, NMR experiments on RNA molecules could determine their three-dimensional structures. Accurate measurement of seven torsion angles per nucleotide suffices to specify an RNA structure. If all of the torsion angles and a large number of intra- and internucleotide distances are determined (within experimental uncertainties), the atomic coordinates of the RNA molecule can be generated by distance-geometry algorithms (150152). In practice, not all of the torsion angles are determined, and spectral overlap can preclude the measurement of many NOEs. An important question not yet satisfactorily answered is: Which distances and torsion angles must be measured with what accuracy to specify a three-dimensional structure for RNA molecules?
164
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
The first step in answering this question was made by testing the distance-geometry algorithm on a known DNA duplex structure (153). A set of 117 distances that could be measured easily by NMR was taken from the crystal structure of a 6-bp DNA duplex. The established base-pairing in the duplex was used to add 14 more constraints: the distances between hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors in the base-pairs. Since each nucleotide has seven degrees of freedom, 84 independent constraints suffice to define the structure completely. Although there are more than 84 N M R constraints, the fact that they are not all independent may result in an underdefined structure. The structure generated from these constraints by the distancegeometry algorithm was compared to the starting structure. The results showed that areas of the structure where many interproton distances were used (the sugars and the bases) were well defined. However, the phosphate backbone was not very well defined. The root-mean-square deviation for the generated base hydrogen atoms was 0.43 A, whereas the deviation was 1.99 8, for the phosphorus atoms. For all of the atoms in the structure, the deviation was 1.29 A, comparable to the deviation found for the atoms in a protein structure when a similar procedure is undertaken (154). NMR data can determine structures more accurate than that of the DNA duplex just described. The constraints used to generate the DNA structure did not include distances to the H4’, H5‘, and H5” sugar protons because they cannot always be assigned. More importantly, no torsion angles were used to constrain the structure, although many of these angles can be determined from proton-proton and proton-phosphorus coupling constants (30, 155, 156). The accuracy of structures determined by NMR ultimately depends on the nucleic acid structure itself. The example of the DNA duplex gives us the lower bound for the accuracy of the structures of duplex RNA determined by NMR, but it is the loop regions of RNA that are of most interest. Can the loop regions of RNA molecules be as well-defined as the duplex regions? Compact loop structures are much better defined than more open ones. The hairpin loop UUCG, discussed above, forms a compact structure in which the sugar protons of the cytosine in the loop give NOE effects to all other nucleotides in the loop. This results in a structure that is well defined by the N M R constraints. The structures of loop regions in which the nucleotides are in extended conformations, or in multiple conformations, can be difficult to determine precisely. If the nucleotides in the loop are not stacked, there probably will be very small NOE effects between them, and their resonances will be difficult to assign. In principle, however, these resonances can be assigned by specific isotope labeling, and a structure can be obtained by measuring coupling constants to determine the backbone torsion angles.
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
165
B. Long-range Constraints 1. CROSSLINKING Crosslinks-covalent bonds between different bases-can be introduced into RNA molecules by irradiation with UV light (157) or by using chemical reagents such as psoralen (158) or nitrogen mustard (77). The positions of such crosslinks within the structure can be determined by sequencing the RNA on either side of the crosslink. The crosslinks are of two types. The first type occurs between nucleotides adjacent in the secondary structure. The more interesting crosslinks occur between nucleotides that are not adjacent in the secondary structure. The positions of these crosslinks reveal something of the three-dimensional structure of the molecule, since they show the proximity of two secondary structure elements. Caution must be used when interpreting the results obtained from crosslinking studies. Crosslinks generated by chemical reagents that bind to one base and then crosslink to a second base may not reflect the native structure of the RNA, since the binding of the reagent to the first base may alter the RNA structure.' Some of the molecules studied by crosslinking include the 1 6 4 rRNA (77), the 23-S rRNA (77),tRNA binding to the catalytic subunit of RNase P (159), tRNA binding to ribosomes (84), and protein binding to ribosomes (160).
2. FLUORESCENCE ENERGY TRANSFER Fluorescence energy can be transferred from a donor to an acceptor group by an electric dipole-dipole mechanism. The transfer depends on the inverse sixth power of the distance between these groups. In practice, the transfer can be measured for groups separated by roughly 10-70 W (161). Measuring fluorescence energy transfer in RNA requires adding acceptor and donor groups to the molecule. Some of the applications of this technique include the study of tRNA (162), ribosome assembly (163),and the conformation about a four-stem DNA junction, as described above (74).
C. Chemical Modification Chemical and enzymatic modification methods determine the accessibility of the nucleotides within an RNA molecule to modification by 1 This hazard is discussed by Budowsky and Abdurashidova in their article on UV crosslinking (160). [Eds.]
166
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
chemical reagents or enzymes (164).The reactivity of a nucleotide to chemical reagents is a complicated function of solvent accessibility and electrostatic environment (165,166).The reactivity of nucleotides to chemical modification is used to confirm predicted secondary structures and to learn about tertiary interactions. The advantages of these methods are that they can be used to probe the structure of very large RNAs, and that they require only picomoles of RNA. Chemicals that react with each of the four bases at Watson-Crick hydrogen-bonding positions can reveal which nucleotides are involved in basepairing. Conditions are used in which each RNA is modified at most only once, so that the structural information deduced is not an artifact of the modification procedure. Enzymes that cleave specifically in base-paired or unpaired regions are used to determine base-pairing as well, but the large size of enzymes makes them generally less useful than chemicals, since the compact structure of a large folded RNA yields very few enzymatic cleavage sites (167). Chemical modification of the nucleotides within the RNA is detected by one of two methods. The simplest method induces strand scission at the site of modification; this is most useful for short RNA molecules. Sites of modification within large RNA molecules are located by synthesis of a DNA complementary to the RNA using reverse transcriptase (54).Modified residues in the RNA cause the reverse transcriptase to stop. Separation of the synthesized DNAs by gel electrophoresis determines the positions of modification. Clear interpretation of the results of chemical modification is often difficult. The amount of modification ranges from essentially none through various degrees of partial modification to strong modification. Strong modification of a nucleotide is good evidence that it is not involved in secondary or tertiary pairing. Weak or partial modification can result from nucleotides engaged in either secondary or tertiary interactions.
D. Mutational Analysis Mutations are often introduced into RNA sequences in order to determine RNA structure or protein-RNA interactions (94, 97, 108, 168-172). The effect of these mutations is often assayed by measuring the ability of the mutated sequences to bind a protein that specifically recognizes the wildtype RNA. Although mutational analysis is a powerful technique for determining interactions in RNA structure, caution is necessary with this approach. The results of such experiments can be unclear, since loss of protein binding can result either from a change in RNA structure or from an RNA sequence that maintains the same structure but is not recognized efficiently by the protein.
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
167
VII. Protein-RNA Interactions Since most cellular RNA molecules are complexed by proteins, understanding protein-RNA interactions is vital to understanding cellular RNA functions. Unfortunately, even less is known about the structure of RNA binding proteins than about RNA structure. The protein-RNA interactions studied show that proteins recognize specific secondary structural features of RNA as well as its three-dimensional shape.
A. Protein-Duplex Interactions The interactions between the helix-turn-helix proteins and duplex DNA are well-characterized (173-175). An a-helix lies in the major groove with amino acids forming specific hydrogen bonds to the DNA sequence. As shown in Fig. 3, the major groove in typical A-form RNA is much narrower than in typical B-form DNA. It has been suggested that the narrower major groove in RNA prevents protein structure elements from binding to the bases in the major groove (176-178). However, the fact that a nucleotide strand is capable of binding to duplex RNA in the major groove to form a triple helix, and the fact that there is considerable polymorphism in the size of the A-form major groove in X-ray studies of fibers, suggest that the bases may be accessible to protein structures through the major groove (179). Transcription factor IIIA is a “zinc finger” protein that binds the DNA gene for the 5-S rRNA in X.Zueuis as well as the 5-S rRNA. There is evidence that it binds to the DNA gene in the major groove (180), and it is proposed that it binds to the 5-S rRNA in the major groove (73).Although it could bind to the DNA and RNA sites by different mechanisms, the possibility that proteins bind in the major groove of RNA should not be ruled out.
B. Protein-Loop Binding Most of the protein binding sites in RNA that have been characterized are loop regions: hairpins, bulges, and internal loops. Unpaired nucleotides are more conserved than base-paired nucleotides in 1 6 4 rRNA sequences, suggesting that these nucleotides are involved in either tertiary interactions or protein contacts. Unpaired adenosines occur more frequently than the other nucleosides (181).Direct evidence for the role of unpaired adenosines in protein binding of the 16-S rRNA comes from the decrease in chemical reactivity of these adenosines when the ribosomal proteins are bound to the 16-S rRNA (54). Both bulge and internal loops bind proteins. A purine bulge is required for the coat protein to bind to the R17 viral RNA (182),and an adenosine bulge is part of the L18 protein binding site on the 5-S rRNA (183). An
168
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
asymmetrical internal loop is required for the binding of S8 ribosomal protein to the 16-S rRNA in E. coli (69,184,185). Ribosomal protein L3 binds to the 23-S rRNA at a large asymmetrical internal loop as well (186). Hairpin structures are commonly found to bind proteins specifically (187-194). Hairpins with loop sequences CAGUGN bind to the iron-responsive element (IRE)-binding protein (195). As proposed in other proteinRNA interactions (196-198), free cysteines in the IRE-binding protein are thought to form transient covalent bonds to the RNA hairpin by a nucleophilic attack by the sulfhydryl group on a uracil in the RNA. Iron regulates this system by altering the equilibrium between reduced and oxidized sulihydryl groups. This in turn alters the amount of hairpin bound by protein and alters the translation of the iron receptor mRNA (199). The most-characterized example of a hairpin protein binding site is the R17 coat protein binding site (182). Binding requires a hairpin, whose loop sequence must be ANYA, plus a purine bulge three nucleotides away on the 5' side of the loop. It is not clear what role the purine bulge plays in protein binding, since adding substituents such as methyl groups to an adenosine bulge reduces binding IOW-fold, whereas changing the bulge from adenosine to guanosine leaves binding essentially unchanged. These data are insufficient to determine whether the protein forms specific contacts with the purine bulge, or whether intercalation of the purine alters the structure of the RNA. This study shows the limitation of mutagenesis experiments in which specific nucleotides are changed and the effect on protein binding is measured. Without doing structural studies of the RNA molecules, it is not clear whether the different binding ailhities that result from substituting specific nucleotides are due to disruption of protein contacts to that nucleotide, or whether the overall structure of the RNA has changed.
C. Protein Recognition of Three-dimensional Structure The first high-resolution crystal structure of a protein-RNA complex to be solved was that of E. co2i tRNAG'" and its synthetase (178). Sequencespecific contacts occur at the anticodon loop and at the end of the acceptor stem of the tRNA in addition to contacts along one side of the tRNA. Three bases in the anticodon loop, which form specific contacts with the protein, are unstacked compared to the tRNAPhestructure. The first base-pair in the acceptor stem is unpaired, and the protein contacts the acceptor stem in the minor groove, forming hydrogen bonds with exocyclic amino protons of two guanines. Overall, the crystal1 structure shows that the synthetase recognizes the tRNA shape, but distinguishes it from other tRNAs by forming two types of sequence-specific contacts: binding to anticodon loop nucleotides and binding to guanines in the minor groove of the acceptor stem. Three-dimensional structure is not always recognized by tRNA syn-
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
169
thetases, since a hairpin containing the major recognition feature of tRNAAla is efficiently aminoacylated by E. coli tRNAAIasynthetase (200).The major recognition feature is a single G-U mismatch in the acceptor stem (201). Replacing the G*U mismatch by G*A, C-A, or U*U mismatches (Fig. 5) results in only small losses in aminoacylation activity, although replacing the mismatch by a Watson-Crick pair completely abolishes activity. The fact that other mismatches are almost as efficient as G*U suggests that the protein recognizes a change in the sugar-phosphate backbone caused by the mismatch rather than specific groups on the G-U pair. Many of the tRNA synthetases probably recognize three-dimensional structure, since the nucleotides required for binding are often scattered throughout the tRNA (202-204). Although the structure of only one protein-RNA complex has been determined, several features of protein binding sites in RNA molecules have been characterized. The most frequently found protein binding sites in RNA are specific nucleotides within loop regions. Hairpin loops are the bestcharacterized protein binding sites, but bulge loops and internal loops have been implicated in protein binding as well. Proteins recognize primary sequence [poly(A)binding protein] (205),secondary structure (hairpin, bulge, and internal loops), and three-dimensional shape (tRNA synthetase binding). The specific interactions between proteins and RNA include transient covalent sulihydryl-uracil interactions, positively charged amino acids binding to negatively charged phosphates, hydrogen-bond formation with the exocyclic amino group of guanine in the minor groove, and specific hydrogen bonds and stacking interactions with bases in loop regions. The RNA structures that proteins recognize are better characterized than the protein structural elements that bind to RNA. An 80-amino-acid consensus RNA binding domain, which contains a sequence of eight highly conserved amino acids (205), has been identified in several RNA binding proteins, including human U1A protein as well as the poly(A) binding protein (206-208). The structure of a peptide portion of the gag polyprotein which binds HIV viral RNA has been determined by NMR (209) and is similar to the structure of a zinc finger protein that binds to DNA (210).
VIII. RNA-RNA Interactions Intermolecular RNA interactions occur in a wide range of biological processes, including a “spliceosome” assembly (211, 212), RNA “editing” (213), and protein synthesis (214-216). Intermolecular contacts include base-pairing and backbone interactions. Backbone interactions occur between regions of RNA already base-paired. Although these interactions are not well-characterized, they probably involve the backbone of one helical region interacting
170
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
with the groove of another helical region. These interactions include basesugar, base-phosphate, sugar-sugar, and sugar-phosphate hydrogen bonds. The stabilities of complexes formed between tRNA anticodon loops and short oligonucleotides (217) or between complementary anticodon loops (218) are much greater than the stabilities of short duplexes. The enthalpy changes during formation of anticodon loop complexes are similar to that of duplex formation, but the entropy of formation is significantly more favorable for the anticodons than for the duplexes (217). The favorable entropy change for the codon-anticodon interaction is probably due to the stacked conformation of the nucleotides within the anticodon loop. Often, the nucleotides in small hairpin loops are not stacked in A-form geometry, presumably making base-paired complexes with these loops much less stable than complexes with anticodon loops. The importance of backbone interactions in the formation of RNA-RNA complexes is demonstrated by the Tetrahymena intron. As previously discussed, the intron is capable of binding an RNA duplex through backbone interactions (116). A separate study showed the importance of the 2' hydroxyl when the intron binds a single-stranded oligonucleotide (219).A single-stranded RNA oligonucleotide base-pairs to the intron, forming a complex lo4 times (6 kal/mol) more stable than would be expected for RNA duplex formation; however, the stability of a complex between the intron and a DNA oligonucleotide is only as stable as the formation of short RNA-DNA duplexes. This suggests that either the 2' hydroxyl groups of the oligonucleotide form specific interactions with the intron or that the intron forms interactions with the sugar or phosphate groups along the backbone of an A-form duplex. The complex formed between M 1 RNA, the catalytic component of RNase P, and its tRNA substrate is probably stabilized by the formation of backbone interactions. This suggestion is supported by a chemical crosslink that forms in the M 1 RNA-tRNA complex between base-paired regions of the M 1 RNA and the precursor tRNA (159).As previously noted (159), there is striking sequence and secondary structure homology between the region of the M 1 RNA that crosslinks to the tRNA and the region of the 2 3 4 rRNA which was found to bind tRNA by chemical footprinting (83). Complexes stabilized by backbone interactions may be a general feature of catalytic RNA-substrate complexes since these interactions are weak and allow dissociation of the enzyme-substrate complex after the reaction.
IX. RNA-DNA Interactions Hybrid duplexes form between RNA and DNA during transcription and reverse transcription. The stability of these hybrids is believed to play a role in transcription termination (220).The combination of a stable hairpin forma-
171
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
tion in the nascent RNA followed by a repeating dA sequence in the DNA leads to termination. The explanation for this is that the stable hairpin causes the polymerase to pause and disrupts part of the hybrid duplex (221). The polymerase complex is held together by the remaining hybrid duplex. Since rU*dAhybrid duplexes are much less stable than other hybrids (222, 223), the polymerase falls off and transcription terminates. The discovery that a ribonucleoprotein complex adds DNA sequences to chromosomal ends (224) presents the possibility that an RNA molecule can function as a reverse transcriptase. Tetrahymena telomerase2 adds the DNA sequence TTGGGG to the 5’ end of chromosomes; it contains a protein component and a 159-nucleotide RNA component, including the sequence CAACCCCAA complementary to the synthesized DNA (225). The role of the CAACCCAAA sequence as a template for DNA synthesis was proven by the discovery that mutating this sequence changes the DNA sequence at the ends of chromosomes in uiuo (226). Whether the RNA alone can act as a reverse transcriptase or whether it only serves as a template for DNA synthesis by the protein component of telomerase has not been established.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank Peter Davis, John Jaeger, and Gabriele Varani for their reading of the manuscript, and we particularly thank Jacqueline Wyatt for her reading of the manuscript and for many useful discussions. M.C. is a Howard Hughes Medical Institute Doctoral Fellow. This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grant GM 10840,and by the Department of Energy, Office of Energy Research, Office of Health and Environmental Research under Grant DE-FG03-86ER60406.
REFERENCES 1. K. Kruger, P. J. Grabowski, A. J. Zaug, J. Sands, D. E. Gottschling and T. R. Cech, Cell 31, 147 (1982). 2. C. Guerrier-Takada. K. Gardiner, T. Marsh, N. Pace and S. Altman, Cell 35, 849 (1983). 3. R. van der Veen, A. C. Arnberg, G. van der Horst, L. Bonen, H. F. Tabak and L. A. Grivell, Cell 44, 225 (1986). 4. C. L. Peebles, P. S. Perlman, K. L. Mecklenburg, M. L. Petrillo, J. H. Tabor, K. A. Jarrell and H.-L. Cheng, Cell 44,213 (1986). 5. A. Hampel and R. Tritz, Bchen 28, 4929 (1989). 6. A. Hampel, R. Tritz, M. Hicks and P. Cruz, NARes 18, 299 (1990). 7. H.-N. Wu, Y.-J. Lin, F.-P. Lin, S. Makino, M.-F. Chang and M. M. C. Lai, PNAS 86, 1831 (1989). 8. G. A. Prody, J. T. Bakos, J. M. Buzayan, I. R. Schneider and G. Bruening, Science 231, 1577 (1986). 9. C. H. Hutchins, P. D. Rathjen, A. C. Forster and R. H. Symons, NARes 14, 3627 (1986). 10. C. Yanofsky, Nature 289, 751 (1981). 11. C. L. Chan and R. hndick, JBC 264, 20796 (1989). 12. L. P. Eperon, I. R. Graham, A. D. Griffiths and I. C. Eperon, Cell 54, 393 (1988). 2 Formerly “telomere-adding enzyme,” “T,G,-adding transferase.” [Eds.]
enzyme,” or “telomere terminal
172
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
P. Schimmel, Cell 58, 9 (1989). M. Kozak, PNAS 83, 2850 (1986). K.-0. Cho and C. Yanofsky, JMB 204, 51 (1988). G. Brawerman, Cell 57, 9 (1989). V. J. Cannistraro, M. N. Subbarao and D. Kennell, JMB 192, 257 (1986). U. Blasi, K. Nam, D. Hartz, L. Gold and R. Young, E M B O J . 8, 3501 (1989). S. Altuvia, D. Komitzer, D. Teff and A. B. Oppenheim, JMB 210, 265 (1989). M. H. de Smit and J. van Duin, This Series 38, 1 (1990). L. Gold, ARB 57, 199 (1988). W. M. Huang, S.-Z. Ao, S. Casjens, R. Orlandi, R. Zeikus, R. Weiss, D. Winge and M. Fang, Science 239, 1005 (1988). 23. J. F. Milligan, D. R. Groebe, G . W. Witherell and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, NARes 15, 8783 (1987). 24. S.-H. Chou, P. Flynn and B. Reid, Bchem 28, 2422 (1989). 25. N. Usman, K. K. Ogilvie, M.-Y. Jiang and R. J. Cedergren, JACS 109, 7845 (1987). 26. W. Saenger, “Principles of Nucleic Acid Structure.” Springer-Verlag, New York, 1984. 27. S. Amott, D. W. L. Hukins and S. D. Dover, BBRC 48, 1392 (1972). 28. A. C. Dock-Bregeon, B. Chewier, A. Podjarny, J. Johnson, J. S. de Bear, G . R. Cough, P. T. Gilham and D. Moras, ] M B 209, 459 (1989). 29. P. W. Davis, R. W. Adamiak and I. Tinom, Jr., Biopolymers 29, 109 (1990). 30. G . Varani, B. Wimberly and I. Tinoco, Jr., Bchem 28, 7760 (1989). 31. J. D. Puglisi, J. R . Wyatt and I. Tinoco, Jr., Bchem 29, 4215 (1990). 32. C. S. Happ, E. Happ, N . Nilges, A. M. Gronenborn and G. M. Clore, Bchem 27, 1735 (1988). 33. S. Arnott and D. W. L. Hukins, BBRC 47, 1504 (1972). 34. A. Bhattacharyya, A. I. H. Murchie and D. M. J. Lilley, Nature 343, 484 (1990). 34a. R. S. Tang and D. E. Draper, Bchem 29, 5232 (1990). 35. D. Rhodes and A. Klug, Nature 292, 378 (1981). 36. L. J. Peck and J. C. Wang, Nature 292, 375 (1981). 37. T. D. Tullius and B. A. Dombroski, Science 230, 679 (1985). 38. K. Hall, P. Cruz, I. Tinoco, Jr., T. M. Jovin and J. H. van de Sande, Nature 311, 584 (1984). 39. I. Tinoco, Jr., 0. C. Uhlenbeck and M. D. Levine, Nature 230, 362 (1971). 40. C. Cheong, G. Varani and I. Tinoco, Jr.. Nature 346, 680 (1990). 40a. T. Sakata, H. Hiroaki, Y. Oda, T. Tanaka, M. Ikehara and S. Uesugi, NARes 18, 3831 (1990). 41. M . J. J. Blommers, J. A. L. I. Walters, C. A. G. Haasnoot, J. M. A. Aelen, G. A. van der Marel, J. H. van Bloom and C. W. Hilbers, Bchem 28, 7491 (1989). 42. D. R. Groebe and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, NARes 16, 11725 (1988). 43. H. F. Noller, ARB 53, 119 (1984). 44. J. A. Jaeger, D. H. Turner and M. Zuker, PNAS 86, 7706 (1989). 45. C. Tuerk, P. Gauss, C. Thermes, D. R. Groebe, M. Gayle, N. Guild, G. Stormo, Y. dAubenton-Carafa, 0. C. Uhlenbeck, I. Tinoco, Jr.. E. N. Brody and L. Gold, PNAS 85, 1364 (1988). 46. I. Hirao, Y. Nishimura, T. Naraoka, K. Watanabe, Y. Arata and K. Miura, NARes 17,2223 (1989). 47. W. Fuller and A. Hodgson, Nature 215, 817 (1967). 48. G . M. Clore, A. M. Gronenborn, E. A. Piper, L. W. Mchughlin, E. Graeser and J. H. van Boom, BJ 221, 737 (1984). 49. J. Wu and A. G. Marshall, Bchem 29, 1722 (1990).
13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
173
50. J. Wu and A. G . Marshall, Bchem 29, 1730 (1990). 51. C. A. G. Haasnoot, C. W. Hilbers, G . A. van der Marel, J. H. van Boom, U. C. Singh, N. Pattabiraman and P. A. Kollman, J . Biomol. Struct. Dyn.3, 843 (1986).
52. M. W. Kalnik, D. G. Norman, B. F. Li, P. F. Swann and D. J. Patel, JBC 265, 636 (1990). 53. Y.T. van den Hoogen, A. A. van Beuzekom, E. de Vroom, G. A. van der Marel, J. H. van Boom and C. Altona, NARes 16, 5013 (1988). 54. D. Moazed, S. Stern and H. F. Noller, J M B 187, 399 (1986). 55. A. Bhattacharyya and D. M. J. Lilley, NARes 17, 6821 (1989). 56. C.-H. Hsieh and J. D. Criffith, PNAS 86, 4833 (1989). 57. J. A. Rice and D. M. Crothers, Bchem 28, 4512 (1989). 58. C. E. Longfellow, R. Kierzek and D. H. Turner, Bchem 29, 278 (1990). 59. S. A. White and D. E. Draper, Bchem 28, 1892 (1989). 60. S. Roy, V. Sklenar, E. Appella and J. S. Cohen, Biopolymers 26, 2041 (1987). 61. D. H. Turner, N . Sugimoto and S. M . Freier, Annu. Reu. Biophys. Biophys. Chem. 17, 167 (1988). 62. E. Westhof, P. Dumas and D. Moras, J M B 184, 119 (1985). 63. W. Traub and J. L. Sussman, NARes 10, 2701 (1982). 64. P. J. Romaniuk, I. L. de Stevenson, C. Ehresmann, P. Romby and 8. Ehresmann, NARes 16, 2295 (1988). 65. P. Romby, E. Westhof, R . Toukifimpa, R . Mache, J.-P. Ebel, C. Ehresmann and B. Ehresmann, Bchem 27, 4721 (1988). 66. A. Bhattacbaryya and D. M . J. Lilley, J M B 209, 583 (1989). 67. F. Aboul-ela, D. Koh and I. Tinoco, Jr., NARes 13, 4811 (1985). 68. C. Papanicolaou, M. Gouy and J. Ninio, NARes 12, 31 (1984). 69. M. Mougel, F. Eyermann, E. Westhof, P. Romby, A. Expert-Bezanson, J.-P. Ebel, B. Ehresmann and C. Ehresmann, J M B 198, 91 (1987). 70. P. Zhang and P. B. Moore, Bchem 28, 4607 (1989). 71. S. Stern, B. Weiser and H. F. Noller, J M B 204, 447 (1988). 72. P. J. Romaniuk, Bchem 28, 1388 (1989). 73. J. Christiansen, R. S. Brown, B. S. Sproat and R. A. Garrett, EMBOJ. 6, 453 (1987). 74. A. I. H. Murchie, R. M . Clegg, E. von Kitzing, D. R. Duckett, S. Diekmann and D. M. J. Lilley, Nature 341, 763 (1989). 75. C. R. Woese, R. Gutell, R. Gupta and H. F. Noller, Microbiol. Reu. 47, 621 (1983). 76. S.-H. Kim and T. R. Cech, PNAS 84, 8788 (1987). 77. R . Brimacombe, J. Atmadja, W. Stiege and D. Schiiler, J M B 199, 115 (1988). 78. L. M. Epstein and J. G. Gall, Cell 48, 535 (1987). 79. A. C. Forster and R. H. Symons, Cell 49, 211 (1987). 80. M. Koizumi, S. Iwai and E. Ohtsuka, FEBS Lett. 228, 228 (1988). 81. C. C. Sheldon and R. H. Symons, NARes 17, 5679 (1989). 82. A. E. Dahlberg, Cell 57, 525 (1989). 83. D. Moazed and H. F. Noller, Cell 57, 585 (1989). 84. G . Steiner, E. Kuechler and A. Barta, EMBOJ. 7, 3949 (1988). 85. C. C. Hall, D. Johnson and B. S. Cooperman, Bchem 27, 3983 (1988). 86. N . R. Pace, D. K. Smith, G . J. Olsen and B. D. James, Gene 82, 65 (1989). 87. A. L. Williams, Jr., and I. Tinoco, Jr., NARes 14, 299 (1986). 88. M . Zuker, Science 244, 48 (1989). 89. J. Gralla and D. M. Crothers, J M B 73, 497 (1973). 90. 0. C. Uhlenbeck, P. N. Borer, B. Dengler and I. Tinoco, Jr., J M B 73, 483 (1973). 91. D. A. M. Konings and P. Hogeweg, J M B 207, 597 (1989). 92. G . M. Studnicka, G. M. Rahn, I. W. Cummings and W. A. Salser, NARes 5,3365 (1978).
174
MICHhEL CHASTAIN AND ICNACIO TINOCO, J R .
93. J. P. Abrahams, M. van den Berg, E. van Batenburg and C. Pleij, NAAes 18, 3035 (1990). 94. C. K. Tang and D. E. Draper, Cell 57, 531 (1989). 95. K. Rietveld, R. van Poelgeest, C. W. A. Pleij, J. H. van Boom and L. Bosch, NARes 10, 1929 (1982). 96. C. W. A. Pleij, K. Rietveld and L. Bosch, NARes 13, 1717 (1985). 97. I. Brierley, P. Digard and S. C. Inglis, Cell 57, 537 (1989). 98. J. D. Puglisi, J. R. Wyatt and I. Tinoco, Jr.. J M B 214, 437 (1990). 99. J. R. Wyatt, J. D. Puglisi and I. Tinoco, Jr.. J M B 214, 455 (1990). 100. B. D. James, G. J. Olsen, J. Liu and N. R. Pace, Cell 52, 19 (1988). 101. R. R. Gutell and C. R. Woese, PNAS 87, 663 (1990). 102. H. Leffers, J. Kjems, L. Bstergaard, N. Larsen and R. A. Garrett, J M B 195, 43 (1987). 103. L. J. Maher 111, B. Wold and P. B. Dervan, Science 245, 725 (1989). 104. M. Cooney, G. Czernuszewicz, E. H. Postel, S. J. Flint and M. E. Hogan, Science 241, 456 (1988). 105. T. C. Boles and M. E. Hogan, Bchem 26, 367 (1987). 106. F. Michel, M. Hanna, R. Green, D. P. Bartel and J. W. Szostak, Nature 342, 391 (1989). 107. I. Tinoco, Jr.. J. D. Puglisi and J. R. Wyatt, in “Nucleic Acids and Molecular Biology” (F. Eckstein and D. M. J. Lilley, eds.), p. 205. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1990. 108. J. R. Sampson, A. B. DiRenzo, L. S. Behlen and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 29,2523 (1990). 109. E. Westhof, P. Romby, P. J. Romaniuk, J.-P. Ebel, C. Ehresmann and B. Ehresmann, J M B 207, 417 (1989). 110. J. M. Burke, J. S. Esherick, W. R. Burfeind and J. L. King, Nature 344, 80 (1990). 111. S. Arnott and P. J. Bond, Nature NB 244, 99 (1973). 112. A. G. Letai, M. A. Palladino, E. Fromm, V. Rizzo and J. R. Fresco, Bchem 27,9108 (1988). 113. P. Rajagopal and J. Feigon, Bchem 28, 7859 (1989). 114. C. de 10s Santos, M. Rosen and D. Patel, Bchem 28, 7282 (1989). 115. Y. Timsit, E. Westhof, R. P. P. Fuchs and D. Moras,Nature 341, 459 (1989). 116. J. A. Doudna and J. W. Szostak, Nature 339,519 (1989). 117. E. Henderson, C. C. Hardin, S. K. Wolk, I. Tinoco, Jr.. and E. H. Blackburn, Cell 51, 899 (1987). 118. W. I. Sundquist and A. Klug, Nature 342, 825 (1989). 119. J. R. Williamson, M. K. Raghuraman and T. R. Cech, Cell 59, 871 (1989). 120. D. Sen and W. Gilbert, Nature 344, 410 (1990). 121. S. B. Zimmerman, G. S. Cohen and D. R. Davies, JMB 92, 181 (1975). 122. J. P. Goddard, Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 32, 233 (1977). 123. R. B. Waring, C. Scazzocchio, T. A. Brown and R. W. Davies, JMB 167, 595 (1983). 124. F. Michel and B. Dujon, EMBOJ. 2, 33 (1983). 125. R. R. Gutell. H. F. Noller and C. R. Woese, EMBOJ. 5, 1111 (1986). 126. M. Levitt, Nature 224, 759 (1969). 127. A. Expert-Bezanpn and P. Wollenzien, JMB 184, 53 (1985). 128. M. I. Oakes, L. Khan and J. A. Lake, J M B 211, 907 (1990). 129. I. Hubbard, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 1990. 130. P. Dumas, D. Moras, C. Florentz, R. Giegi., P. Verlaan, A. Van Belkum and C. W. A. Pleij, J . Biomol. Struct. Dyn. 4, 707 (1987). 131. M. S . Capel, D. M. Engelman, B. R. Freeborn, M. Kjeldgaard, J. A. Langer, V. Ramakrishnan, D. G . Schindler, D. K. Schneider, B. P. Schoenborn, I.-Y. Sillers, S . Yabuki and P. B. Moore, Science 238, 1403 (1987). 132. S.-H. Kim, F. L. Suddath, G. J. Quigley, A. McPherson, J. L. Sussman, A. H. J. Wang, N . C. Seeman and A. Rich, Science 185, 435 (1974). 133. J. D. Robertus, J. E. Ladner, J. T.Finch, D. Rhodes, R. S. Brown, B. F. C. Clark and A. Klug, Nature 250, 546 (1974).
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
175
134. N. H. Woo, 8. A. Roe and A. Rich, Nature 286, 346 (1980). 135. K. Wiithrich, “NMR of Proteins and Nucleic Acids.” Wiley, New York, 1986. 136. F. J. M. van de Ven and C. W. Hilbers, EJB 178, l(1988). 137. S. Roy and A. G. Redfield, NARes 9, 7073 (1981). 138. R. E. Hurd and B. R. Reid, Bchem 18, 4017 (1979). 139. A. Heerschap, J.-R. Mellema, H. C . J. M. Janssen, J. A. L. I. Walters, C. A. G. Haasnoot and C. W. Hilbers, EJB 149,649 (1985). 140. A. Bax, R. H. Griffey and B. L. Hawkins, J . Magn. Reson. 55, 301 (1983). 141. G. W. Vuister, R. Boelens, A. Padilla, G. J. Kleywegt and R. Kaptein, Bchem 29, 1829 (1W). 142. M. Karplus, JACS 85, 2870 (1963). 143. C. Altona, Recl. Trau. Chim. Pays-Bas 101, 413 (1982). 144. C. Giessner-Prettre and B. Pullman, Q . Reu. Biophys. 20, 113 (1987). 145. D. G. Gorenstein, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Bioeng. 10, 355 (1981). 146. F. R. Prado, C. Giessner-Prettre. B. Pullman and J.-P. Dandley, JACS 101, 1737 (1979). 147. T. M. Jovin, J. H. van de Sande, D. A. Zarling, D. J. Arndt-Jovin, F. Eckstein, H. H. Fuldner, C. Greider, I. Grieger, E. Hamori, B. Kalisch, L. P. McIntosh and M. RobertNicoud, CSHSQB 47, 143 (1983). 148. A. H.-J. Wang, G. J. Quigley, F. J. Kolpak, G. van der Marel, J. H. van Boom and A. Rich, Science 211, 171 (1981). 149. C. Giessner-Prettre, B. Pullman, F. R. Prado, D. M. Cheng, V. Iuorno and P. 0. P. Ts’o, Biopolymers 23, 377 (1984). 150. T.F. Havel and K . Wuthrich, Bull. Math. Biol. 46, 673 (1984). 151. W. Braun and N. Go, J M B 186, 611 (1985). 152. D. R. Hare, L. Shapiro and D. J. Patel, Bchem 25, 7445 (1986). 153. A. Pardi, D. R. Hare and C. Wang, PNAS 85, 8785 (1988). 154. T. F. Havel and K. Wuthrich, J M B 182, 281 (1985). 155. J. R. Williamson and S. G. Boxer, Bchem 28, 2819 (1989). 156. E. Nikonowicz, V. Roongta, C. R. Jones and D. G. Gorenstein, Bchem 28, 8714 (1989). 157. A. D. Branch, B. J. Benenfeld, C. P. Paul and H. D. Robertson, in “Methods in Enzymology” (James E. Dahlberg and John N. Abelson, eds.), Vol. 180, p. 418. Academic Press, San Diego, 1989. 158. G . D. Cimino, H. B. Gamper, S. T. Isaacs and J. E. Hearst, ARB 54, 1151 (1985). 159. G. Guerrier-Takada. N. Lumelsky and S. Altman, Science 246, 1578 (1990). 160. E. I. Budowsky and G. G . Abdurashidova, This Series 37, 1 (1989). 161. L. Stryer, ARB 47, 819 (1978). 162. K. Beardsley and C. R. Cantor, PNAS 65, 39 (1970). 163. K.-H. Huang, R. H. Fairclough and C. R. Cantor, J M B 97, 443 (1975). 164. C.Ehresmann, F. Baudin, M. Mougel, P. Romby, J.-P. Ebel and B. Ehresmann, NARes 15, 9109 (1987). 165. R. Lavery and A. Pullman, Biophys. Chem. 19, 171 (1984). 166. S. Furois-Corbin and A. Pullman, Biophys. Chem. 22, l(1985). 167. G. Knapp, in “Methods in Enzymology” (James E. Dahlberg and John N. Abelson, eds.), Vol. 180,p. 193.Academic Press, San Diego, 1989. 168. R. Parker, in “Methods in Enzymology” Oames E. Dahlberg and John N. Abelson, eds.), Vol. 180, 510. Academic Press, San Diego, 1989. 169. H. S. Olsen, P. Nelbock, A. W. Cochrane and C. A. Rosen, Science 247, 845 (1990). 170. S. Heaphy, C. Dingwall, I. Emberg, M. J. Gait, S. M. Green, J. Karn, A. D. Low, M. Singh and M. A. Skinner, Cell 60, 685 (1990). 171. K. Ehrenman, R. Schroeder, P. S. Chandry, D. H. Hall and M. Belfort, NARes 17,9147 (1989).
176
MICHAEL CHASTAIN AND IGNACIO TINOCO, JR.
C. L. Williamson, W. M. Tierney, B. J. Kerker and J. M. Burke, JBC 262, 14672 (1987). C. Wolberger, Y. Dong, M. Ptashne and S. C. Harrison, Nature 335, 789 (1988). S. R. Jordan and C. 0. Pabo, Science 242, 893 (1988). A. K. Aggarwal, D. W. Rodgers, M. Drottar, M.Ptashne and S. C. Harrison, Science 242, 899 (1988). 176. S. Stern, R. C. Wilson and H. F. Noller, JMB 192, 101 (1986). 177. J.-H. Wang, Nature 319, 183 (1986). 178. M. A. Rould, J. J. Perona, D. Sol1 and T.A. Steitz, Science 246, 1135 (1989). 179. S. Amott, Nature 320, 313 (1986). 180. L. Fairall, D. Rhodes and A. Klug, J M B 192, 577 (1986). 181. R. R. Gutell, B. Weiser, C. R. Woese and H. F. Noller, This Series 32, 155 (1985). 182. H.-N. Wu and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 26, 8221 (1987). 183. D. A. Peattie, S. Douthwaite, R. A. Garrett and H. F. Noller, PNAS 78, 7331 (1981). 184. R. J. Gregory and R. A. Zimmerman, NARes 14, 5761 (1986). 185. R. J. Gregory, P. B. F. Cahill, D. L. Thurlow and R. A. Zimmerman, J M B 204,295(1988). 186. H. Leffers, J. Egebjerg, A. Anderson, T.Christensen and R. A. Garrett, J M B 204, 507 (1988). 187. S . Feng and E. C. Holland, Nature 334, 165 (1988). 188. C. Dingwall, I. Emberg, M. J. Gait, S. M. Green, S. Heaphy, J. Kam, A. D. Lowe, M. Singh, M. A. Skinner and R. Valerio, PNAS 86, 6925 (1989). 189. B. Berkhout, R. H. Silverman and K.-T. Jeang, Cell 59, 273 (1989). 190. D. k i n s k i , E. Grzadzielska and A. Das, Cell 59, 207 (1989). 191. D. Scherly, W. Boelens, W. J. van Venrooij, N. A. Dathan, J. Hamm and I. W. Mattaj, E M B O J . 8, 4163 (1989). 192. D. R. Turner, L. E. Joyce and P. J. G. Butler, J M B 203, 531 (1988). 193. G . W. Witherell and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 28, 71 (1989). 194. Y. Endo, A. cluck, Y.-L. Chan, K. Tsurugi and I. G. Wool, JBC 265, 2216 (1990). 195. J. L. Casey, M. W. Hentze, D. M. Koeller, S. W. Caughman, T. A. Rouault, R. D. Klausner and J. B. Harford, Science 240, 924 (1988). 196. Y. Wataya, A. Matsuda and D. V. Santi, JBC 255, 5538 (1980). 197. R. M. Starzyk, S. W. Koontz, and P. Schimmel, Nature 298, 136 (1982). 198. P. J. Romaniuk and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Bchem 24, 4239 (1985). 199. M. W. Hentze, T. A. Rouault, J. B. Harford and R. D. Klausner, Science 244,357 (1989). 200. C. Francklyn and P. Schirnmel, Nature 337, 478 (1989). 201. W. H. McClain, Y.-M. Chen, F. Foss and J. Schneider, Science 242, 1681 (1988). 202. J. Normanly and J. Abelson, ARB 58, 1029 (1989). 203. P. Schimmel, Bchem 28, 2747 (1989). 204. J. R. Sampson, A. B. DiRenzo, L. S. Behlen and 0. C. Uhlenbeck, Science 243, 1363 (1989). 205. S. A. Adam, T. Nakagawa, M. S. Swanson, T.K. Woodruff and G. Dreyfuss, MCBiol 6 , 2932 (1986). 206. C. C . Query, R. C. Bentley and J. D. Keene, Cell 57, 89 (1989). 207. I. W. Mattaj, Cell 57, 1 (1989). 208. G . Dreyfuss, M. S. Swanson and S. Pinol-Roma, TlBS 13, 86 (1988). 209. M. F. Summers, T. L. South, B. Kim and D. R. Hare, Bchem 29, 329 (1990). 210. M. S. Lee, G. P. Gippert, K. V. Soman, D. A. Case and P. E. Wright, Science 245,635 (1989). 211. P. A. Sharp, Science 235, 766 (1987). 212. D. A. Brow and C. Guthrie, Nature 334, 213 (1988). 213. B. Blum, N. Bakalara and L. Simpson, Cell 60,189 (1990).
172. 173. 174. 175.
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN RNA
177
214. D. Moazed and H. F. Noller, Nature 342, 142 (1989). 215. D. Moras, A.-C. Dock, P. Dumas, E. Westhof, P. Romby, J.-P. Ebel and R. Gieg6, 1. Bioml. Struct. Dyn. 3, 479 (1985). 216. D. Moras, A.-C. Dock, P. Dumas, E. Westhof, P. Romby, J.-P. Ebel and R. Gieg6, PNAS 83, 932 (1986). 217. K. Yoon, D. H. Turner and I. Tinoco, Jr., J M B 99, 507 (1975). 218. P. Romby, R. Giege, C. Houssier and H. Grosjean, ] M B 184, 107 (1985). 219. D. Herschlag and T. R. Cech, Nature 344, 405 (1990). 220. P. H. von Hippel, D. G. Bear, W. D. Morgan and J. A. McSwiggen, ARB 53,389 (1984). 221. T. Platt, Cell 24, 10 (1981). 222. M. Riley, B. Maling and M. J. Chamberlin, J M B 20, 359 (1966). 223. F. H. Martin and I. Tinoco, Jr., NARes 8 , 2295 (1980). 224. C. W.Greider and E. H. Blackburn, Cell 51, 887 (1987). 225. C. W. Greider and E. H. Blackburn, Nature 337, 331 (1989). 226. G.-L. Yu, J. D. Bradley, L. D. Attardi and E. H. Blackburn, Nature 344, 126 (1990).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nuclear RNA-binding Proteins JACK AND
D. KEENE CHARLES C. QUERY
Department of Microbiology and Immunology Duke Unioersity Medical Center Durham, North Carolina 27710 I. RNA-binding Proteins . . 11. RNA-Protein Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Detection of RNA Binding in Vitro B. Sequence Similarities among RNA-a ............ 111. RRM Family of Proteins . . A. Members . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. RNA Recognition Motif C. Origins of the RRM Family ................................... D . Evidence for Direct Interaction of the RRM with RNA E. Specificity of RNA Recognition ................................ F. Do RRMs Constitute “RNA-binding Domains”? ........... IV. Structural Features of RN V. Regulatory Potentials of the RRM Family of Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Conclusions and Perspectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Note Added in Proof . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
180 181 181 186 187 187 187 188 188 192 194 195 196 198 199 202
The control of gene expression involves several steps at which specific sequences in pre-mRNA transcripts, as well as those in small RNA molecules, are recognized by proteins. RNA-binding proteins can be expected to mediate interactions in a variety of cellular processes, including those occurring in the transcription complex, the spliceosome and the ribosome. Members of one family of nuclear proteins that bind to RNA contain a specific RNA recognition motif (RRM). The RRM family of proteins functions at several levels in RNA processing and some family members are involved in tissue-specific as well as developmentally regulated gene expression. This review describes the proteins that contain this RRM and discusses the potential involvement of these proteins in the control of gene expression at the level of RNA processing. These proteins are modular in structure and often contain at least two types of interactive surfaces, one or more that interacts specifically with RNA and another that interacts with other molecules. Studies to date indicate that, despite the strong homology among these proteins, 179 Progress in Nucleic Acid Research and Molecular Biology, Vol. 41
Copyright Q 1991 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of r e p d u c t i o n in any form reserved.
180
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
they have unique properties of recognition that allow them to distinguish RNAs of diverse structure.
1. RNA-binding Proteins RNA in living cells is rarely naked. In most cases, RNA is bound to proteins recognizing regions that include RNA termini, homopolymeric sequences, or specific stem-loop structures. The attachment of protein to RNA may be covalent, as in the case of the poliovirus VPg protein, or, more commonly, may involve hydrophobic interactions, hydrogen bonding or charge pairing. The less specific proteins may recognize just the phosphate backbone of RNA, and the more specific proteins may interact with RNA bases. The first three-dimensional determination of RNA structure was obtained by X-ray crystallography of phenylalanine tRNA ( 1 , 2 ) ;more recently, co-crystals of glutamine tRNA synthetase and glutamine tRNA have been reported (3).These latter studies demonstrated contacts between the protein and both the bases and the phosphate backbone of the RNA. In some cases the amino-acid-RNA contacts involved unexpected residues. An overview of RNA-associated proteins is presented in Table I. Among the many known RNA-associated proteins, the bacteriophage r17 coat protein is the best understood (4, 5). This protein contacts a stem-loop structure of the phage RNA and depends on specific sequences in the loop for recognition. The sequence of the RNA stem is less critical; however, a specific “bulged” nucleotide in the stem is vital for high-affinity binding of the protein. In other recent examples, bulged nucleotides have been found to be dispensible (0.Uhlenbeck, personal communication). It has long been known that transcription cofactor TFIIIA can bind to the gene encoding 5-S RNA and mediate the function of RNA polymerase I11 (6). TFIIIA can also bind to 5-S RNA, and an autoregulatory mechanism for the control of 5-S transcription was proposed (6). Studies of the structure of TFIIIA have implicated the zinc-binding fingers in nucleic acid recognition (7). In recent years, viral proteins involved in interactions with the RNAs of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) have been identified. These include the tat, rev, and rex proteins implicated in RNA processing and transport of viral mRNA to the cytoplasm (8).These proteins interact with specific regions of the lentivirus RNAs such as the tar and the rev-response element, as recently demonstrated by direct RNA binding studies (8-11). Proteins that are uniquely associated with heterogeneous nuclear RNA (hnRNA) or with small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs) are known, but few studies have demonstrated their direct interaction with RNA. Several of these proteins may attach to ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complexes through proteinprotein interactions and others may bind directly to RNA. Methods to exam-
NUCLEAR HNA-BINDING PROTEINS
181
TABLE I RNA-ASSOCIATED PHOTEINS'
A.
Hctcrogeneoirs nuclear RNP proteins (hnRNP proteins Al, A2/B1, CllC2, E, L) Small nuclear RNP proteins (snRNP proteins 70K, A, B', PRP-24b) mHNP proteins (poly(A)-binding protein, eIF-46) Prc-rRNP protein (nuclcolin) Splicing factors (ASF/SFPc; pl'TW; Drosophila tra-2, S x l ) Transcription factors (La,E. coli rhod) Helix-destabilizing proteins (UPl, HDP, SSBI) Others: Ho-GOK; Neuronal protein (eho);yeast NSHle; Malaria CARP; Phage proteins (T4 gp32d. ~$29gpl0); Maize AAIP; Chloroplast proteins (28, 31, and 33kD); Drosophilo
6.
Ribosomal proteins Signal recognition particle proteins tRNA synthetascs RNA vinis core and nucleocapsid proteins RNA-dependent DNA or RNA polymerases Hibonucleases RNA-RNA helicascs Others (TFIIIA, rev, rex, tat)
bicoidd
aHNA-associated proteins that possess (A) or lack (6)the RNA recognition motif (HRM) depicted in Fig. 2. These proteins arc known to he associated with HNA; some are known to contact HNA directly and others arc present in RNP complexes hut may not be in direct contact with RNA. In most categories within part (A), examples also exist that do not possess the RRM. Abbreviations: PRP, precursor RNA processing; eIF-4B. eukaryotic initiation factor-48; ASF, alternative splicing factor; SF2, splicing factor 2; tra-2, tranrformer-2; Sxl, sex-lethal; SSB1, yeast single-stranded binding protein; eloc, embryonic-lethal abnormal-oisual; M I P , abscisic acid-induciblr protein; NSRI, nuclear signal recognition protein; CARP, clustered-asparaginc-rich protein. pPTB, polypyrimidine tract-binding protein. UP1 is proteolytically derived from huRNPA1. *K. Shannon and C. Guthrie, personal communication. cH. Ge, P. Zuo and J. L. Manley; and A. Krainer, personal communication. dAtypical RRM. These proteins share partial similarity with the conserved RNP-1 and RNP-2 sequences, but do not match at some other positions expected to be critical for the structure of the domain, such as conserved hydrophobic residues (29). =Ten MBIesc, personal communication. fM.Garcia-Blanrw, personal rwmmunication.
ine direct interactions have involved cross-linking with UV light1 (12, 13) and in uitro reconstitution of the RNP complex (see Section 11). In some cases, these approaches have allowed discrimination between direct and indirect attachment of proteins to RNA.
II.
RNA-Protein Interactions
A. Detection of RNA Binding in Vitro Methods of studying RNA-protein complexes isolated from cells have been available for several years (reviewed in 14), but have not allowed determination of which proteins in the complex were in contact with the RNA. 1
See the article on this point by Budowsky and Abdurashidova in Vol. 37 of this series.
[Eds.]
182
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
Several methods have been used to examine directly complexes formed in uitro (e.g., fluorescence quenching), but have had limited applicability because of the requirement for purified components. More recently, other methods that do not require homogeneous materials have been employed. Some useful methods are discussed below, and some examples are shown in Fig. 1 using the U1-snRNP-A protein.
FIG. 1. Five different methods of detecting RNA binding. (A) Immunoprecipitation of an in uitro translated (TI)protein containing an epitope tag using a tag-specific antibody (16, 27). Similar immunoprecipitation methods for RNA binding have used autoantibodies from patients or antibodies produced in animals (26, 32). (B) The WestNorthern blot procedure uses radiolabeled protein and unlabeled RNA transferred to a solid surface (C. C. Query and J. D. Keene, unpublished). (C) A mobility-shift assay with radiolabel in the protein, (D) the Northwestern blot procedure, and (E) a mobility-shift assay with the radiolabel in the RNA are according to published procedures described in the text. In each example shown here, the U1-snRNP-A protein was used to bind to U1 RNA, stem-loop I1 of U 1 RNA (SL2). a deletion of SL2 (ASL2). or stem-loop I of U 1 RNA (SLl). The epitope tag used in (A) is the 12-aminoacid gene-10 peptide of phage T7 (16, 27, 29). Comp, nonspecific competitor RNA.
183
NUCLEAR RNA-BINDING PROTEINS
D. NorthWesltm
C. Mobility Shift
Blol
A 8'.B C D
E. RNA Mobility Shift
UlSLl RNA
UlSL2 RNA
184
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
1. FILTERBINDING A standard approach to the study of both DNA and RNA binding involves attachment to nitrocellulose filters (15). Protein binds directly to various solid substrates, but nucleic acids require special treatments, such as chemical denaturation or UV light exposure, to bind to these materials. However, if the nucleic acid binds to the protein that, in turn, binds to the nitrocellulose, one can identify specific protein-nucleic acid interactions by labeling the nucleic acid. Such methods have been used to study protein-RNA binding quantitatively, and dissociation constants have been approximated in this manner (4). The “Northwestern blot” method is an modification of the filter-binding assay, in which the protein is separated on acrylamide gels prior to transfer to nitrocellulose and probing with labeled RNA (Fig. 1D). When denaturing polyacrylamide gels are used, renaturation of the binding domain of the protein is required. Thus, some RNA-binding proteins are not amenable to analysis by this method. Furthermore, proteins that require accessory factors for RNA binding will not be detected by Northwestern blotting (16). On the other hand, this method has the advantage of not requiring previous purification of protein, and it may serve as an alternative method when antibody precipitation and other methods are not feasible. For example, Northwestern blotting has been used to identify new proteins that bind to an RNA sequence of interest (17, 18),and to determine the RNA sequence specificity of a known RNA-binding protein (19). Recently, this method was used to determine a site of recognition of the Drosophila sex-lethul (Sxl) protein on the alternatively spliced pre-mRNA of the transformer (tra)gene (20). 2. FLUORESCENCE QUENCHING
Under circumstances in which aromatic amino acids such as tryptophan, tyrosine, and phenylalanine are involved in RNA binding, it has been possible to detect binding by measuring the reduction of fluorescence (21).This method is very sensitive if the correct amino acids are involved in RNA contact, but requires the use of highly purified components. The method is most sensitive when tryptophan emission is altered upon binding, and less sensitive for detecting phenylalanines, because their emission can be obscured by nucleic acids. Fluorescence quench techniques have been used to quantitate interactions of the yeast poly(A)-binding protein with poly(A)RNA (22).
3. UV-CROSS-LINKING The ability to cross-link RNA covalently to protein using UV light’ has become increasingly popular in recent years as an indicator of RNA binding. The method is dependent on an appropriate juxtaposition of photoreactive
NUCLEAR RNA-BINDING PROTEINS
185
RNA bases and amino acids (23). For example, pyrimidine bases, especially uracil, can be cross-linked to hydroxylated amino acids (e.g., tyrosine) that are in close proximity. Thus, this method is limited to coincidental proximities, but has proved useful in many cases.l It has also been criticized as not being a measure of specific RNA-protein binding, but only one indication of an association. Under some conditions, one may be able to cross-link proteins that are not directly bound to RNAs. Thus, precautions should be taken in the interpretation of interactions involving UV-cross-linking. More recently, in combination with in uitro RNA competition assays, UV-crosslinking has been used as a method to detect sequence-specific RNA interactions (12, 24). 4. ANTIBODY PRECIPITATION
The presence of autoantibodies reactive with snRNA-binding proteins allows a convenient method of selection of RNPs containing these proteins (25). These antibodies can immunoprecipitate either RNPs synthesized in uiuo or complexes bound in uitro. However, the use of auto-antisera often is compromised by the presence of more than one antibody specificity or by interactions with the RNP that differ from those occurring with the protein alone. Sera from animals immunized with a specific RNA-binding protein or the use of an antibody reactive with an antigenic “tag” that has been attached to a recombinant protein can circumvent these difficulties (26,27). An example of the latter is a phage-T7 gene-10 peptide of 12 amino acids fused to the amino terminus of proteins expressed from certain vectors (28). Antibodies to this tag (16, 27, 29) allowed efficient immunoprecipitation of various in uitro bound complexes (Fig. 1A). 5. MOBILITYSHIFT Nondenaturing gel electrophoresis has been widely used to assay DNAprotein complexes (30). RNA-protein complexes may similarly be examined. For example, a shift in the mobility of a labeled RNA in the presence of cellular extracts and excess competitor RNAs may indicate the presence of a specific binding protein (Fig. 1E). In some cases, resistance of nucleotides in the complex to ribonuclease has been used to indicate specificity (9, 31). Alternatively, RNA binding can be assessed by a change in the mobility of labeled protein, produced by in uitro translation, in the presence of specific RNAs (27, 32) (Fig. 1C). In all cases, competition experiments using nonspecific RNAs are required to verify the specificity of the complex formed. Methods using nondenaturing gels for analysis of large multicomponent complexes such as spliceosomes and polyadenylation complexes have been reviewed recently (33).
186
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
6. BIOTINYLATIONOF RNA Methods have been developed to bind proteins to RNAs containing biotinylated nucleotides so that the RNP complex can be isolated on immobilized avidin. The use of biotinylated RNA as a handle for studying RNAprotein interactions has centered on the isolation of components of the spliceosome (33-35). Recently, such methods also have allowed study of the binding of U 1 RNA to the U1-snRNP-A protein (36). This method has the advantage of allowing detection of labeled proteins from whole-cell extracts, as well as from in uitro translation systems. On the other hand, background binding is often present, and in oitro transcribed RNA must be used. Thus, if the RNA folds incorrectly, if modified bases are required, or if biotinylation interferes with binding, this method would be less useful.
7. WESTNORTHERN BLOTTING A counterpart to the Northwestern blot is the WestNorthern blot (Fig. 1B), which is a Northern blot probed with labeled protein (37).This method of RNA binding has many of the same advantages and disadvantages as the Northwestern blot, but has other applications. For example, conditions of binding need not be compatible with antibodies or gel electrophoresis. However, only a limited number of proteins have been amenable to this technique. One useful application of Northwestern and WestNorthern blots in studying RNA-protein interactions is screening expression libraries to isolate the cognate ligand. We have recently used this method to bind sequences in stem-loop I1 of U 1 RNA that interact with the U1-snRNP-A protein (37). In summary, a variety of RNA-binding methods have been developed that allow the study of RNA-protein interactions, and they have various advantages. No single method is ideal for all such interactions, and different methods may have to be applied in each individual case. Quantitative binding studies using different methods indicate that most RNA-binding proteins studied to date have dissociation constants in the range of lo7 to lo9 M-' (4 16, 22, 27, 37-39).
B. Sequence Similarities among RNA-associated Proteins Sequence elements characteristic of a group of RNA-associated proteins began to emerge with the observation (40) of four copies of an 80-aminoacid repeat in the poly(A)-binding protein. The most conserved region of eight amino acids common among these repeats and in the hnRNP-A1 protein led (41) to the term RNP consensus sequence to describe the octamer. Other groups also noted the presence of conserved sequences in other RNA-associated proteins and speculated that such sequences might be involved in direct RNA binding (42-56). More recently, conservation of the octamer and a separate hexamer sequence in a collection of RNA-associated proteins was noted
NUCLEAR RNA-BINDING PROTEINS
187
(49,50). The amino-acid consensus sequences were referred to as RNP 1and RNP 2, respectively. Several workers independently observed extensively conserved sequences in a diverse collection of approximately 20 proteins ranging in source from Escherichia coli to humans, and the region of sequence similarity was found to span approximately 80 residues (32,42,49,55). The presence of the 80-aminoacid motif in a broad family of proteins and direct evidence for interactions of this motif with RNA led to its designation as an “RNA recognition motif,” or RRM (32).It has also been referred to as an “RNP consensus sequence type-RNA binding domain” (44)and an “RNP-80 motif‘ (36).However, it is certain that not all RNA-binding proteins contain this RRM; other motifs may yet be discovered. The variety of RNAassociated proteins identified to date is outlined in Table I. Those found to contain at least one RRM are listed in Section A, and those apparently lacking this motif are listed in Section B.
111. RRM Family of Proteins A. Members Several members of this family of RNA-associated proteins are involved in aspects of RNA metabolism, including pre-mRNA transcription, splicing, and, possibly, stability and transport. Proteins containing the RRM are associated with hnRNA (Al, Bl/A2, Cl/C2, E, and L proteins), small RNAs (A, B”, 70K,2 La, and Ro-60K2 proteins), mature mRNAs [poly(A)-binding protein (PAB protein) and eIF-4B1, and pre-rRNA (nucleolin) (Table I). Some RRM-containing proteins are helix-destabilizing proteins (UP1, HDP, and SSBl), and one is a translational repressor (T4 gp32). Other members, such as Drosophila embyonic-lethal-abnormul-visual-system(elm), p9, tra-2, and S x l , were implicated in RNA-protein interactions because they contain the RRM. Genes tru-2 and Sxl are linked in a regulatory cascade pathway of alternative pre-mRNA splicing. The product of Sxl interacts with the tra premRNA (20); however, tra-2has not yet been shown to contact any specific RNA molecule. It is logical to predict that it may associate with pre-mRNAs or with the snRNAs that interact with pre-mRNA (reviewed in 45).
B. RNA Recognition Motif The RRM of 80 amino acids contains the RNP consensus octamer near the center. Conserved residues are present on both sides of the RNP octamer, but are more abundant in the amino-terminal half of the motif. About 30 residues toward the amino terminus from the octamer is the hexamer of 2 K here represents kDa, kilodaltons (or kilo-atomic-mass-units, kamu). However, 70K is the name given (53) a 52-kDa protein (32). [Eds.]
188
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
conserved amino acids corresponding to RNP 2 (49). In addition to these regions, there are many other conserved positions in the RRM that contain predominantly phenylalanine, glycine, or alanine residues (32). An aminoacid consensus for the RRM has been derived that assigns residues as shown in Fig. 2. Nine residues within the RRM consensus are conserved as particular amino acids and therefore may be essential for the RNA binding function or for the structure of the RNA-binding domain. In determining structure/function relationships within the RRM, a central question is: Which residues are essential for sequence-specific RNA binding? Furthermore, are sequences inside or outside of the RRM essential for sequence specificity? A short amino-acid sequence flanking the aminoterminal side of the RNP octamer is critical for the specificity of recognition of U l and U2 RNAs by the A and Brrproteins, respectively (16). No information is presently available regarding specific amino-acid contacts with bases and phosphates in the RNA. Thus, it is not known which regions within the RRM influence affinity for RNA, but it has been suggested that the RNP octamer has this potential. These questions can be addressed, in part, by site-directed mutagenesis and subdomain switching among RRMs. Ultimately, three-dimensional structure data will be required to resolve many of these issues.
C. Origins of the RRM Family The similarities manifest among the proteins containing the RRM make it likely that many of these proteins are truly homologous. It has been proposed that, in some cases, exons represent protein domains that rearrange as units in evolution (57). The question of whether the RRM is coded within a single exon has been examined for three cases: La, nucleolin, and U 1 snRNP-70K (the gene for yeast PAB protein has been sequenced, but has no introns). The human La (47)and mouse nucleolin (58) genes contain introns within each of the conserved octamer sequences, although the Xenopus 70K protein does not (59). All three proteins contain introns at positions near the flanking edges of the RRMs. Thus, it appears that the RRMs of these proteins may contain distinct structural elements encoded on separate exons. Exon shuffling as well as gene duplication events may have contributed to the evolution of these RNA-binding proteins.
D. Evidence for Direct Interaction of the RRM with RNA Evidence that the RRMs of RNA-associated proteins interact with RNA comes from several approaches. The 320-aminoacid hnRNP-A1 protein and a 195-aminoacid proteolysis fragment of hnRNP-A1 (UP1) can bind singlestranded (ss) DNA and ssRNA (60). Two 92-aminoacid fragments isolated from the UP1 portion of hnRNP-A1 were UV-cross-linked from their phe-
B P G A O
40
B
A A
A P
A G R G F L O F
*
A P A A A N P C n A H A A A B H P A P C C O C C C P O H A O - A X O A G X X L B G A X - O O L O X A X X H X 50 60 70 80
FWP 1 or RNP octamer
FIG. 2. Amino-acid consensus for the RNA recognition motif family of proteins (32). The residues are designated PO (polar), AL (aliphatic), AR (aromatic), AC (acidic), HO (hydrophobic), AB (amides, acids, or bases), BA (basic), AA (amides or acids), NP (nonpolar), CH (charged), X (unassigned), A (alanine), M (methionine), D (aspartic acid), T (threonine), G (glycine), F (phenylalanine), and R (arginine). The most conserved regions (designated RNP 1 for the RNP consensus sequence and RNP 2) are bracketed (44) and the most highly conserved positions are shaded. Dashes indicate positions of variability between family members, where insertions or deletions occur. Asterisks indicate the two aromatic residues in the hnRNP-A1 protein that were cross-linked to oligo-deoxythymidine (52).
190
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
nylalaine residues to oligo-deoxythymidine [positions 3 (aromatic) and 46 (phenylalanine) in Fig. 21 (52). The yeast PAB protein, which contains four RRMs (Fig. 3) and is essential for growth, can be truncated to a 66-aminoacid fragment and still support some degree of growth (22). This peptide contains the amino half of one RRM, but no RNP octamer, which suggests that the RNP octamer may not be required for the function of the PAB protein. This is so far the only genetic system in which the dispensibility of RRM sequences has been examined. A 33-kDa fragment of nucleolin can interact with processed 184 and 284 RNA in a Northwestern assay, although neither the RNA sequence specificity of this association nor interactions with pre-rRNA was examined (46). This 33-kDa binding fragment encompassed nearly three 80- to 90aminoacid RRM repeats, suggesting that at least part of the RNA-binding activity is associated with the RRMs.
FIG.3. Structural characteristics and modular features of the RNA recognition motif (RRM) family of proteins. Two classes are shown that correspond to the presence of single (classI) or multiple (class-11) repeats of the RHM. The highly charged arginine-rich regions of the U1-snRNP-70K and trunsfonner-2 proteins are designated RD/RE/RS. Potential nucleotide (ATP)-bindingand zinc-binding finger (Zn2+) motifs are also noted. Abbreviated proteins are defined in the text with appropriate references and as described (32). The diagrams are not necessarily to scale, and the size of the regions flanking the RRMs vary. Note that UP2 represents a partial clone.
NUCLEAR RNA-BINDING PROTEINS
191
A prokaryotic example of an RNA-binding protein within the family is the E. coli transcription termination factor rho (61). A proteolytic fragment of 155 amino acids from the amino terminus specifically bound RNAs that contained rho-dependent termination sequences. This domain has subsequently been observed to contain an 80-aminoacid RRM (32), although it possesses less sequence similarity to the consensus than most other members of the RRM family. A minimal region constituting an RNA-binding domain of a protein within the RRM family has been defined for the U1-snRNP-70K protein (32).The protein was progressively truncated until a 125-aminoacid fragment retained the specificity and affinity of the full length portion for U 1 RNA in a direct binding assay, whereas smaller fragments did not retain activity. For the 70KU 1 RNA interaction, 35 residues carboxy-terminal to the RRM were required for the full function of the domain; the RRM alone did not bind to U 1 RNA. Thus, the RNA-binding domain of this protein includes many residues external to the RRM. Determinants of specificity were proposed to reside at nonconserved positions within the RRM or at residues external to the RRM. Recent studies of the U1-snRNP-A protein indicate that a single-unit RNA-binding domain encompasses only one of two RRMs (27, 36). In this case, only six residues in addition to the 80-residue RRM constituted an 86aminoacid RNA-binding domain for U 1 RNA. Thus, the flanking sequences required for the A protein to bind U 1 RNA are fewer than those required for the 70K protein to bind. Studies of the RNA-binding features of the La and Ro-6OK proteins demonstrate that large regions of the protein external to the RRM are essential. The La protein can be deleted at its carboxy terminus and still retain binding activity, but removal of even a few amino acids at the amino terminus completely abolishes binding to precursor transcripts of RNA polymerase I11 (29; S. Clarkson, personal communication). The Ro-6OK protein is more fragile in that removal of even a few amino acids at the amino or carboxy terminus abolishes binding to the hY (human cytoplasmic Y) RNAs (62). Thus, the La (47) and Ro-6OK (48) proteins may be atypical in comparison to other RRM family members, but they demonstrate the diverse nature of the RNA-binding domains in that long-range intramolecular interactions may be involved in dictating the specificity of RNA recognition. Another recent variation on the theme of diversity in the recognition of RNA by members of the RRM family involves the U2-snRNP-B” protein that binds to both U1 and U2 RNAs with low affinity in uitro. Upon addition of the U2-snRNP-A’ protein, however, the affinity of B’ for U2 RNA increases at least 100-fold (16).The A’ protein appears to act on B through proteinprotein interactions involving a region of leucine periodicity in A‘ (81). These findings open the possibility that long-range interactions from within a protein (intramolecular) or interactions involving separate accessory proteins
192
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
(intermolecular) may influence the specificity and affinity of RNA recognition and binding by members of this family of proteins. Analysis of the RNA-binding domain defined for the Ul-snRNP-A protein (27,36)using two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance has revealed a highly ordered structure for this module (D. W. Hoffman, C. C. Query, B. L. Golden, S. W. White, and J. D. Keene, unpublished). This RNA-binding domain consists largely of p-structure, with four antiparallel strands and two a-helices. Critical aromatic residues in RNPl and RNP2 believed to contact RNA are adjacent to one another in a P-sheet, and both project to the surface of the molecule. These adjacent aromatic residues are highly constrained and intolerant to significant variation (37, 62). Evidence to date demonstrates that an RRM can be a component of an RNA-binding domain. However, the requirement of particular residues within this motif and of sequences outside of it, as well as the contributions of accessory proteins, vary among members of the family. These findings indicate that the structural features of the RRM proteins that allow recognition and binding to RNA are complex and are likely to involve a variety of molecular interactions that are unique to each protein.
E. Specificity of RNA Recognition The diverse functions of various members of the RRM family of proteins are reflected in the different RNAs they recognize (Table 11). However, the RNA-binding site has been defined in only a few cases. For example, PAB protein recognizes the homopolymer poly(A) (22, 40, 41). Although the sequence is simple, poly(A) can assume complex higher-order structures (63), and the role of base-stacking in this protein-nucleic acid interaction has not been studied. An affinity of 2 X lo7 M - for one of the binding domains of PAB protein has been determined (22). It is estimated that 12 adenylate residues constitute the binding site on poly(A). It was also suggested (22)that multiple poly(A)-binding domains on PAB protein could allow transfer of the proteins between strands of poly(A). The helix-destabilizing proteins (UPl, UP2, HDP, and SSB1) (32)appear to recognize ssDNA and ssRNA with relatively little sequence specificity and thereby destabilize native base-paired structures (60, 63-65). UP1 has an affinity for ssDNA of approximately lo7 M - (60, 66). The binding to DNA by both UP1 and T4 gp32 proteins has been extensively investigated and reviewed (67). T4 gp32 also binds to an RNA stem-loop structure in the 5'untranslated region of its mRNA in order to autoregulate its translation (68). Binding sites in RNA for the hnRNP proteins A1 and C1/C2 have been studied by in uitro binding and UV-cross-linking. A subset of these proteins has been bound to intron sequences near splice acceptor sites that included the pyrimidine-rich tract in pre-mRNA (69). Others have shown that these proteins can be UV-cross-linked to RNA sequences near the AAUAAA poly-
193
NUCLEAR RNA-BINDING PROTEINS
TABLE I1 RNA SPECIFICITIESOF THE RRM FAMILY“ Protein
RNA
Specific sequence
UP1I u P2 hnRNP proteins E . coli rho PAB protein La Ro-GOK U1 snRNP-70K and -A U2 snRNP-B” Sex-lethal ( S x l ) Nucleolin Others: tra-2,elav, bicoid, AAIP, CARP, NSRl, etc.
Single strand Pre-mRNA RNA transcripts Poly(A) Polymerase-111 transcripts hY RNAs U1 RNA stem-loop U2 RNA stem-loop transformer (tra) pre-mRNA Pre-rRNA Unassigned
Nonspecific Nonspecific& Cytosine-rich Homopolymer 3’-terminal oligo(U) Specific Specific Specific Specific Unknown Unknown ~
RNA sequence specificity involved in recognition by the RRM family of cellular proteins. Proteins that contain the RRM are listed in approximate order of complexity of the specific RNAs with which they associate. bPreferences for homopolymers or pyrimidine-rich sequences have been demonstrated in some cases. 0
adenylation signal (12, 13). These apparently conflicting results may be reconciled by the proposed existence of high- versus low-affinity binding sites along the pre-mRNA for these proteins (69). The technique of UV-crosslinking does not allow measurements of affinity and is also limited by the possibility that cross-linked regions of RNA and protein may represent coincidental proximation of reactive bases and amino acids rather than representing true binding sites (23).These issues will be resolved by the development of direct binding assays and binding affinity determinations. However, the use of UV-cross-linking does have the significant advantage of allowing examination of protein-RNA association in vivo. The specificity of RNA recognition by the La (70, 71) and Ro-6OK (72) proteins has been demonstrated. The main recognition target of the La protein is the sequence of 3‘-terminal uridylates in precursor RNA-polymerase-I11 transcripts (reviewed in 73). The Ro proteins were shown by nuclease protection studies to bind the stem structure of 3’ and 5’ basepaired termini of the hY RNAs, which are also RNA-polymerase-I11 transcripts (72).In uitro binding assays using recombinant La protein (47) and recombinant Ro-6OK protein (48)were recently developed, but the specificity, stoichiometry, and affinity of RNA binding have not been reported. Rho-dependent transcription termination involves the binding of the protein to untranslated regions of mRNA (61). Rho has affinity for both ssRNA and ssDNA, and high affinity for poly(C) (reviewed in 74 and 75).The ability of rho to recognize both RNA and DNA may be related to its function
194
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
in unwinding RNA-DNA duplexes during the process of transcription release. The RNA recognition properties of the snRNP proteins 70K, A, and B” have been studied using both cell extracts and in uitro binding assays. The 70K protein and perhaps the A protein were suggested to contact stem-loop I and probably other regions of U 1 RNA (76, 77). Recombinant 70K protein requires 31 nucleotides of U1 RNA stem-loop I for binding (26). Contacts with other regions of the RNA were not detected by these assays (26), but could not be ruled out. In addition, direct binding assays show that 36 nucleotides in stem-loop I1 of U 1 RNA are sufficient to bind to the A protein (19). It has been suggested (78) that B” binds to stem-loop 111 or IV of U2 RNA. The extensive sequence similarity of its RRMs to those of the U1snRNP-A protein (79) suggests that it probably recognizes a discrete sequence in a manner similar to the U1-snRNP-A protein (19).Recent studies indicate that stem-loop IV of U2 RNA is involved in the major contact with the B” protein (16). Studies of the sequence specificity of RNA binding by the RRM family of proteins have suffered, in part, for lack of precise probing methods. RNase protection, chemical probing, and fragment binding have been used, but each method has distinct limitations. Application of affinity measurements to a broader group of RRM-containing proteins would improve the understanding of RNA binding specificities. Footprinting methods, like those used for DNA-binding proteins, are hindered by the conformations assumed by RNA, and its altered conformation when bound to protein. Thus, improved methods of RNA-protein structural probing will be needed to define further the base and phosphate contacts between members of the RRM family of proteins and their cognate RNAs.
F. Do RRMs Constitute “RNA-binding Domains“? As knowledge concerning this group of proteins has emerged, many investigators have assumed that any region of a protein that contains the RNA recognition motif or the RNP octamer is an active RNA-binding domain. Such assignment must be viewed with caution, because domains are defined as single units with structural integrity or functional activity (80).In contrast, a motif is defined as a pattern of related sequences. As noted above, the RNA-binding domain of the Ul-snRNP-70K protein includes and requires amino-acid sequences carboxy-terminal to the boundaries of the RRM (32). However, some proteins with identified RRMs contain no sequences carboxy-terminal to the motif. It is possible that dissimilar regions flanking the RRM as well as the less conserved positions within the RRM are involved in the specificity of RNA recognition, as noted above (Section
NUCLEAR RNA-BINDING PROTEINS
195
111,B). It is also possible that some of these RRMs are degenerate and do not associate with RNA. Considering the differences between the apparently functional RNA-binding domains of PAB protein (66 amino acids) and U 1 snRNP-70K (125 amino acids), it seems that the amino-acid sequence requirements for RNA binding by different RRM proteins may vary widely. Therefore, it is important to define each RNA-binding domain as a singular structural or functional unit with the same binding efficiency and specificity as the complete protein. In the example described above (Section III,D), it was found that the B' protein component of U2 snRNPs binds with modest affinity to both U 1 and U2 snRNAs (16). Upon addition of the A' component of U2 snRNPs, the binding of B is specific for U2 snRNA, and the affinity increases dramatically. Furthermore, the U2-snRNP-A' protein does not bind U2 RNA alone, but appears to interact with the U2 snRNP through protein-protein contacts involving a region of leucine periodicity in A' (81).The in uiuo significance of these findings are yet to be demonstrated. However, it is possible that some RRMs cannot function as specific RNA-binding domains except in the presence of accessory proteins. Thus, the RNA-binding domain in such cases may require trans-acting accessory factors in addition to the RRM to be functional. Such accessory proteins may also participate in regulating functions involved in RNA processing that are mediated by RNA binding.
IV. Structural Features of RNA-binding Proteins Containing RRMs A. Classes of Proteins within the RRM Family From the collection of proteins identified that contain the RRM, at least two distinct classes within the family are evident. Most members contain a single RRM (class I), but some contain multiple copies (class 11) (Fig. 3). For example, the snRNA-associated proteins A and B" contain two copies of the RRM, the elau protein contains three copies, while PAB protein and nucleolin each contain four copies. The questions of whether class II members contain multiple RNA-binding domains, whether they contact more than one RNA, and whether multiple RRMs act cooperatively to bind a single RNA have not been addressed experimentally. It is possible that the binding domain of a class I1 protein could require the combined interactions of more than one RRM. For the Ul-snRNP-A (27, 36) and the U2-snRNP-B" (16) proteins, only the amino-terminal RRM has been shown to constitute an RNA-binding domain for U 1 and U2 RNAs, respectively. (See Section III,D for a discussion of the tertiary structure of the U1-snRNP-A protein.)
196
JACK D. KEENE AND CHARLES C. QUERY
B. Modular Structure The members of this family show structural analogy to DNA-binding proteins such as Gal 4, A repressor, and homeo-box (POU) proteins