Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 133 REACTION KINETICSANDTHE DEVELOPMENTAND OPERATION OF CATALYTIC PROCESSES
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 133 REACTION KINETICSANDTHE DEVELOPMENTAND OPERATION OF CATALYTIC PROCESSES
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S t u d i e s in S u r f a c e S c i e n c e a n d C a t a l y s i s Advisory Editors:
B. Delmon and J.T. Yates
Vol. 133
REACTION KINETICSANDTHE DEVELOPMENTAND OPERATION OF CATALYTIC PROCESSES Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium, Oostende, Belgium, April 22-25, 2001
Edited by G.E Froment
TexasA&M University, Department of Chemical Engineering, College Station, TX 77843, USA
K.C.Waugh
UMIST, Department of Chemistry, Manchester, UK
I
2001 ELSEVIER Amsterdam - - London -- New York -- Oxford - - Paris -- Shannon - - Tokyo
E L S E V I E R S C I E N C E B.V. S a r a B u r g e r h a r t s t r a a t 25 P.O. B o x 2 1 1 , 1 0 0 0 AE A m s t e r d a m , T h e
Netherlands
92001 E l s e v i e r S c i e n c e B.V. A l l r i g h t s r e s e r v e d . This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Science, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission ofthe Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, PO Box 800, Oxford OX5 1DX, UK; phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected] may also contact Global Rights directly through Elsevier's home page (http://www.elsevier.nl), by selecting 'Obtaining Permissions'. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS),90 Tottenha m Court Road, LondonWl P0LP,UK; phone: (+44) 207 6315555; fax: (+44) 207 6315500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. DerivativeWorks Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of Elsevier Science is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission ofthe Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, at the mail, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Becauseof rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made.
First edition 2001 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Reaction kinetics and the development and operation of catalytic processes : proceedings of the 3rd international symposium, Oostende (Belgium), April 22-25,2001 / editors, G.F. Froment, K.C. Waugh. p. cm. -- (Studies in surface science and catalysis ; 133) Includes index. ISBN 0-444-50559-8 1. Catalysis--Congresses. 2. Chemical kinetics--Congresses. 3. Chemical processes--Congresses. I. Froment, Gilbert F. II. Waugh, K. C. III. Series. TP 156.C35 R28 200 l 660'.2995--dc21 2001023023 ISBN: 0-444-50559-8 I S S N : 0167-2991
O T h e p a p e r u s e d in t h i s p u b l i c a t i o n m e e t s t h e r e q u i r e m e n t s ( P e r m a n e n c e of Paper). P r i n t e d in T h e N e t h e r l a n d s .
of ANSl/NISO Z39.48-1992
Ontvn,8 Introduction
XlII
KEYNOTE LECTURES Adventures in catalytic nanospace: 'seeing' spillover in-situ for the first time
M. Bowker, R.A. Bennett, A. Dickinson, D. James, R.D. Smith and P. Stone
From first-principles to catalytic turnovers: ethylene hydrogenation over palladium
19
Development of microkinetic expressions by instationary methods
41
Self sustained oscillations over copper in the catalytic oxidation of methanol
57
Novel reactor configurations and modes of operation
71
New methodologies and reactors for catalytic process development
87
M. IVeurock, E. Hansen, D. Mei and P.S. Venkataraman
F.J. Keil
L B6ttger, B. Pettinger, Th. SchedeI-Aliedrig, A. Knop-Gericke and R. Schlo'gl D.Luss
M.P. Harold, P.L. Mills andJ.F. Nicole
KINETICS: STEADY STATE OPERATION Hysteresis kinetics of propene oxidation characterized by a Ag-Re supported membrane reactor
105
Kinetics of oxidative dehydrogenation of LPG to olefins on Dy-Li-CI-Zr-O catalyst
113
De Donder relations and the theory of reaction routes
123
A kinetic study of NO reduction by CO over a NiO/AI203 catalyst
131
M. Kobayashi, T. Kanno, J. Horiuchi, S. Hoshi, IV. Hattori and J. Togawa
M.L. Kaliya, O.V. Malinovskaya, M.V. Landau, M. Herskowitz and P.F. van den Oosterkamp I. Fishtik and R. Datta
T.N. Angelidis and M. Papapetrou
vi Reaction kinetics of the hydrodenitrogenation of methylcyclohexylamine over fluorinated NiMoS/AI203 catalysts
139
Use of the "dusty-gas" model for the analysis of ethylbenzene oxidehydrogenation process
147
Using low melting point alloy intrusion to quantify pore structure: Studies on an alumina catalyst support
155
L. Qu and R. Prins
D. Ardissone, A. Bachiller and J. Orejas
L. RuftTno, R. Mann, R.J. Oldman, S. Rigby and S. Allen
CATALYTIC PROCESSES Mass and heat transfer effects in the kinetic modelling of catalytic cracking
165
Kinetics of ethylene polymerisation over CrY zeolites
173
Investigations of the selective partial oxidation of methanol and the oxidative coupling of methane over copper catalysts
181
A new kinetic model for hydrodesulfurization of oil products
189
Low-temperature, carbon-catalyzed, solvent-washed, trickle-bed sulfuric acid process
195
Butane oxidation to maleic anhydride over a VPO catalyst following the riser regenerator approach
205
Effects of particle size and modified SAPO-34 on conversion of methanol to light olefins and dimethyl ether
211
P. Hagelberg, V. Alopaeus, K. Lipi~inen, J. Aittamaa and A.O.I. Krause Y. Zhang, X. Wang, M.A.N.D.A. Lemos, F. Lemos, R.T. Henriques and M.M. Marques
H.-J. W61k, G. Weinberg, G. Mestl and R. Schlo'gl
T. Mejdell, R. Myrstad, J. Morud, J.S. Rosvoll, P. Steiner and E.A. Blekkan
P.L. Silveston, M.A. Panthaky, K. Duval, R.V. Vladea, A. Lohi and R.R. Hudgins
St. Hess, H. Freund, M.A. Liauw and G. Emig
M.G. Abraha, X. Wu and R.G. Anthony
MOLECULAR MODELING From DFT calculations to dynamic Monte Carlo simulations. The reactivity of CHx on the Ru(0001) surface I.M. Qb/~'c~ F. Frechard, A.P.3. Jansen and R.A. van Santen
221
REACTORS : NON STEADY STATE OPERATION Non-steady state operation of trickle-bed reactors
E.G. Boelhouwer, H.W. Piepers and A.A.H. Drinkenburg
231
vii
Performance enhancement of a microchannel reactor under periodic operation
239
A dynamic study of steam-methane reforming
247
Model-based optimization of the periodic operation of the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis R.M. de Deugd, S.M. Ypma, F. Kapteijn, ~:.IV~.Meeuse,J.A. Moul/jn and P.J.T. Verhe/jen
255
Direct determination of periodic states of cyclically operated packed bed reactors
263
Dynamics and control of a radial-flow ammonia synthesis reactor
271
A.Rouge and A. Renken
M.A. EI-Bousifti and D.J. Gunn
T.L. van Noorden, S.IV/. Verduyn Lunel and A. Bliek
N.S. Schbib, M.N. Pedernera and D.O. Borio
MISCELLANEOUS Mass transfer through the gas-liquid interface at the presence of adsorbed active phospholipid monolayer
283
Oxygenates and olefins from catalytic partial oxidation of cyclohexane and n-hexane in single-gauze chemical reactors R.P. O'Connor and L.D. Schmidt
289
Mechanistic studies of hydroxyl radical-induced catalytic wet oxidation of dyehouse effluents at atmospheric pressure
297
Reaction pathways of photocatalytic oxidation of PCE in water with the TiO2film on glass
303
Liquid phase hydrogenation of naphthalene on Ni/AI203
309
Effect of NO and oxygen upon the deactivation of Cu-ZSM-5 in NO decomposition
317
L. Grado~ and T.R. Sosnowski
D.-K. Lee, D.-S. Kim and S.-C. Kim
D.-K, Lee and I.-C. Cho
P.A. Rautanen, M.S. Lylykangas, 3.R. Aittamaa and A.O.I. Krause
V.I. P~rvulescu, E. Segal, B. Delmon and P. Grange
KINETICS: TRANSIENTS Non steady-state production of hydrogen from natural gas: Experiments and modeling E. Odier, Y. Schuurman, H. Zanthoff, C. M//let and C. Mirodatos
327
viii
Dynamic study of methane interaction with active sites involved in the total oxidation of methane over Pd/AI203 catalyst
333
A non-stationary kinetics approach for the determination of the kinetic parameters of the protolytic cracking of methylcyclohexane
341
Kinetic modelling of transient NO reduction by CO in the presence of 02 over an automotive exhaust gas catalyst
349
Transient kinetics of lsNO-decomposition on Pt/AI203
357
Transient kinetics of the propene oxidation over silver catalysts
365
s. Fessi, A. Ghorbel, A.Rives and R. Hubaut
v. Fierro, J i . Duplan, J. Verstraete, K Schuurman and C. Mirodatos
J.M.A Harmsen, J.H.B.J. Hoebink and J. C. Schouten
A.R. Vaccaro, G. Mul and J.A. Moulijn
A. Zwijnenburg, IV~.Boer, G. Mul, IV~.Makkee and J.A. Moulijn
CATALYST
n9Xe NMR of absorbed xenon and IH NMR imaging" new methods to study the diffusion of gaseous hydrocarbons in a fixed bed of zeolite P. N'Gokoli-Kekele, Iv~.-,4. Springuel-Huet, 3.-L. Bonardet, I-M. Dereppeand3. Fraissard
375
Catalytic activity of carbon nanotubes and other carbon materials for oxidative dehydrogenation of ethylbenzene to stryrene
383
Heterogenous catalysis at high temperature for space applications
391
Catalyst design for reactions with synthesis gas
399
IV. Maksimova, G. Mestl and R. Schldgl M. Balat-Pichelin andJ.M. Badie
G.P. Valenga and E.S. Gongalves
REACTORS : STEADY STATE OPERATION
Enhancement of non isothermal autocatalytic reactions by intraparticle diffusion
411
An adsorptive reactor for operation of exothermic series reactions
419
M. Grzesik andJ. Skrzypek A.J. Kodde and A. Bliek
POSTERS CATALYSIS
Catalytic activity and characterization of quaternary ammonium(methylstyrene-co-styrene) resin in an organic solvent/alkaline solution H.-S. Wu and C.-S. Lee
429
Catalyst development for methanol and dimethyl ether production from blast furnace off gas
435
Heterogeneous photo- and thermal catalytic oxidation of CO: effects of metal deposition
445
Harmonization of the empirical information on the de-NOx catalysts for the comparison of the catalyst performance through reaction modeling
453
Synthesis of cumene (isopropylbenzene) from diisopropylbenzenes in the presence of benzene using triflic acid as catalyst at room temperature
459
J. Yagi, T. Akiyama and A. Muramatsu
I. Ozen and D. Uner
D. Liner and S. Kaya
M.C. AI-Kinany, S.H. AI-Khowaiter and F.H. AI-Malki
D I F F U S I O N A N D MASS T R A N S F E R
Diffusion analysis of cumene cracking over ZSM5 using a jetloop reactor
465
Simulation of the effect of mass transfer limitations in complex gas-liquid reactions
471
Evaluation of external diffusional effects in a microreactor for SRGO hydrotreating
477
A study of a phase transfer catalytic reaction between N-butyl bromide and sodium phenolate in an oscillatory baffled reactor
481
Kinetics of the main and side .reactions of the methanol oxidation over iron molybdates
489
P. Schwan, P.J. Henry and K.P. MSIler
M. Pisu, A. Cincotti, G. Cao and F. Pepe
L.C. CastaEeda-L6pez,F. Alonso-Mart[nez and J. Ancheyta-Ju~rez
B. Wilson, X. Ni and D.C. Sherrington
A.P. Vieira Soares, M. Farinha Portela and A. Kiennemann MECHANISMS
Mechanistic investigations of oxidation of purine and pyrimidine base components of nucleic acids by bromamine-B in aqueous alkaline medium: a kinetic approach
495
Activity-acidity relationships in solid acid catalysis a quantum chemical study
501
N. Vaz and Puttaswamy
X.. Wang, M.A.N.D.A. Lemos, F. Lemos and F. Ram6a Ribeiro
Catalytic reactions mechanisms with some nonlinear conservation laws E.S. Patmar and N.I. Koltsov
507
PROCESSES Modelling diffusion, cracking reactions and deactivation in FCC catalysts
509
Oxidehyrogenation of ethylbenzene to styrene on P-O-Ni-Mn/alumina catalysts
515
Hydrodechlorination of chlorobenzene-tetrachloroethylene mixtures over a Pd/AI203 catalyst E. L6pez, S. Ord6fiez, F.V. D/ezand H. Sastre
521
Kinetic study of the liquid-phase hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene and n-butenes on a commercial Pd/AI203catalyst
527
F. L6pez-Isunza, N. Moreno-Montiel, R. Quintana-Sol6rzano, J.C. Mor~no-Mayorga and F. Hern~ndez-Beltr~n
D. Ardissone, A. Bachiller, M. Ponzi and J. Orejas
N.O. Ardiaca, S.P Bressa, J.A. Alves, O.M. Mart[nez and G.F. Barreto
KINETICS Kinetics and mechanism of ruthenium(III) and osmium(VIII) catalyzed oxidation of dopamine with bromamine-B in acid and alkaline media
535
Kinetic models for esterification of methacrylic acid using n-propanol and isopropanol
541
Kinetics models for esterification of levulinic acid with 2-ethylhexanol using different catalysts
547
Time resolution of the TAP reactor
553
A novel catalyst preparation and kinetic study on the dechlorination of chlorinated hydrocarbons
559
Kinetics of copolyesters of poly(butylene terephthalate), hydroquinone diacetate and terephthalic acid: a simple rate model for catalysed synthesis in melt
565
Catalytic oxidation of sulfite/bisulfite in a falling-film absorption column
575
Puttaswamy and N. Vaz
M. Grzesik, J. Skrzypek and M. Witczak
M. Grzesik and 7:. Gumula D. Wang and Z. Li
Y.S. Cho, J.-C. Park, B.-S. Choi, J. Moon and J. Yi
A. AI-Haddad and J. Mathew
M. Vorbach, R. Marr and M. Siebenhofer
Influence of fluorination on the kinetics of the HDN of o-toluidine over tungsten sulfide catalysts ex ammonium tetrathiotungstate
581
Kinetics of the hydrodenitrogenation of cyclohexylamine over suifided NiMo/y-AI203
587
H2-TPR-kinetics; case study on the reduction of a CrOJAl2Os catalyst ./.M. Kanervo and A.O.I. Krause
593
Kinetic study of methane combustion over Lao.gCeo.lCOO3
599
Theoretical determination of the kinetic parameters of a reaction intermediate by degeneration of the precursor process
605
An easy methodology for estimating kinetic constants in complex kinetic models
611
Experimental validation of a kinetic model for naphtha reforming
615
Kinetic analysis of enzymatic esterification of fatty acids and ethanol
619
Catalytic combustion of methane over Pd/y-AI203 in a monolithic reactor: kinetic study
625
Software functionality assessment for kinetic reaction model development, model discrimination, parameter estimation and design of experiments
631
-Authors' index
637
M. Sun and R. Pdns
F. Rota and R. Prins
R. Auer, L. Warnier and F.C. Thyrion
M. Elkhatib, C. Duriche, R. Metz, J.R. Vignalou and H. Delalu
3. Ancheyta-3u~rez and R. 5otelo-Boy~s
3. Ancheyta-3u~rez and E. Villafuerte-Madas
v.u. Miguel, G.C. Trubiano, G. Perez, D.O. Borio and A.F. Errazu
E. Ldpez, C. G[gola, D.O. Borio and V. Bucal~
R.3. Berger, 3. Hoorn, 3. Verstraete and3. W. Verwijs
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
...
Xlll
The 3rd International Symposium on "Reaction Kinetics and the Development and Operation of Catalytic Processes" will be a trendsetter. The Keynote Lectures, authored by top scientists, will cover a broad range of topics like fundamental aspects of surface chemistry, in particular dynamics and spillover, the modeling of reaction mechanisms, with special focus on the importance of transient experimentation and the application of kinetics in reactor design. Most of these topics are reflected in the communications, oral or poster. Fundamental and applied kinetic studies are well represented. More than half of these deal with transient kinetics, a new trend made possible by recent sophisticated experimental equipment and the awareness that transient experimentation provides more information and insight into the microphenomena occurring on the catalyst surface than steady state techniques. The trend is not limited to purely kinetic studies since the great majority of the papers dealing with reactors also focus on transients and even deliberate transient operation. It is to be expected that this trend will continue and amplify as the community is getting more aware of the predictive potential of fundamental kinetics when combined with detailed realistic modeling of the reactor operation. The response to our call for studies related to commercial processes is rewarding. We hope that this attitude will further develop. The field has reached a state at which commercial processes can be analyzed and modeled in their full complexity without resorting to the gross simplifications of the past and thus contribute to a more optimal and safe operation in today's more protected environment. G.F. Froment Department of Chemical Engineering Texas A & M University
K.C. Waugh Department of Chemistry UMIST
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
[GcturGr
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 133 G.F. Froment and K.C. Waugh (Editors) Published by Elsevier Science B.V., 2001
Adventures in Catalytic Nanospace: 'Seeing' spillover in-situ for the first time. Michael Bowker, Roger.A. Bennett 1, Amanda Dickinson, David James, Rupert D. Smith and Peter Stone Centre for Surface Science and Catalysis, Dept. Chemistry, Univ. Reading, Reading RG6 6AD. Email
[email protected] 1
now at Physics Dept., University of Reading.
Abstract. The interaction between metal nanoparticles and a support may result in a changed reactivity pattern from what might be expected, for a variety of reasons. Here we give two examples of this, one where the active site involves the support, and one where transfer of material from the metal particle to the support occurs. In the first example, namely the photocatalytic reforming of methanol on Pd/TiO2 at ambient temperature, we believe that the reaction is determined by sites at the interface between the metal and the support. In the second example, and in a related vein, we have used STM to image Pd nanoparticles on a rutile TiO2 (110) surface, a model catalyst, and have identified spillover of oxygen from the Pd particles onto the surrounding TiO2 surface. This is witnessed by growth of new layers of TiO2 in the immediate vicinity of the nanoparticles, due to reaction between spillover oxygen and interstitial Ti3+ ions which migrate to the surface. We propose that this is a method of oxygen storage akin to that used in automobile catalysts.
Introduction.
The modem era of surface science began in the 1960's with the aim of simplifying complex heterogeneous systems by using well-defined, single crystal samples of known surface atomic structure, and utilising very simple adsorbates, often diatomics. In the new millenium surface science has advanced to studying more complex surfaces, with much more complex adsorbates, under a wide range of conditions, including high pressure and liquid phases. This is the proper situation for a subject which is as widely based as the term 'surface science' implies. One of the major areas of impact of surface science has been in the field of catalysis, as recently acknowledged by one of the most prestigious practitioners of catalysis in the 20th century, namely Michel Boudart [1], who says" .. the methods of surface science have permeated theory and practice of heterogeneous catalysis. Some key findings of surface science include the importance of surface reconstruction [2] and of the diffusion of weakly held precursors in surface reaction kinetics [3]. Much of this fundamentally important information has been obtained using single crystals, and it is imperative that this kind if work continues. However, it is also very important to recognise that such model surfaces are 2-D catalysts, whereas the industrial catalyst is usually a 3-D surface, as depicted in fig 1, and this may have different properties to a single crystal, especially when the nanoparticle is very small (sayl-2nm.). These differences are 1. If a particle is very small it is no longer a metallic conductor, because the conduction band splits into individual levels, the spacing of which is given approximately b y AE =EtCn Thus a lnm diameter particle (ca. 16 atoms) has energy levels split by approximately 0.3eV, or 30kJ mole 1, which makes electron excitation a significantly activated process.
Very small particles are not metallic
IMetai i
Edge sites
Support
Spillover, Reverse Spiliover
Electron transfer
Figure 1. Schematic model of a metal nanoparticulate surface, showing several of the ways in which it may differ from a bulk metal.
lOO t 80 A
"E 60 3
m 40
0
0
0
0
0
..,= (II
IZ:
20 0 0.001
oq 0 0.01
0.1 Wt. Loadingi%
1
10
Figure 2. The dependence of rate upon Pd loading for the photocatalytic reforming of methanol at 320K. Circles are data points, while squares and the fitted line are data from the theoretical model [7].
2. The particle-support interface may affect the reactivity, and the following
effects are all enhanced in several ways at small particle size due to the increased number of atoms at the interface compared with those elsewhere in the particle, i)
The active site may be at the interface between the support and
the particle, an example of Which is given below, and is therefore likely to be very different from the behaviour of the bulk metal. ii)
Spillover may occur, either from or to the support, which will then affect the reaction kinetics
iii)
Electron transfer can result in charging of a small particle and an
alteration of the electronic structure For these reasons it is important to study supported nanoparticles in a rigorous way using the methods of surface science. A number of surface scientists have embarked on this path in recent years, and reviews of some of this work are available [4-6]. In this paper we will highlight some of the work at the University of Reading in the last two years which relates to catalysis by nanoparticles. In the following section we will highlight the importance of point 2i above, namely photocatalytic reforming of methanol at ambient temperature. We will then go onto describe some of the beginnings of surface science work on models of the catalyst used in that work using STM as the probe of surface structure. We can directly observe the spillover of active species from the metal to the support in such experiments.
Photocatalysis Involves Sites at the Interface between the Precious metal and Support.
We have recently reported on the photocatalytic reforming of methanol under anaerobic conditions using Pd/TiO2 catalysts [7-9]. The rate of this reaction has a very marked dependence on loading of Pd as shown in fig. 2. The rate is quite high at very low loadings of Pd, whereas TiO2 alone, or even TiO2 loaded with other non-precious metals, has a very low rate [8,9]. As loading increases, so there is a slow increase in the reaction rate, with a maximum at around 0.5 wt% Pd and a sharp drop in rate above that loading to
give zero initial rate at 2 wt%. This can be modelled on the assumption that only those sites at the interface are the active ones and these are given by the following equation Na = N2/3.(12n2V)1/3.{ 1-(cos'l[d/(3V/2Nn)l/3]/O)}
Here Na is the number of active sites, N is the number of particles, V is the volume of metal in the sample, d is the particle separation, and 0 is the angle between particles (30 degrees for a hexagonal array).This has the functional form of the real data. However the maximum should be at much higher loadings, which has lead us to conclude that the active region is at a perimeter related to the Pd particles, but remote from them. The details of this modelling will be given in a future publication, though the outline is in the earlier paper [7]. This modelling then leads us to a mechanism for the reaction as shown in figure 3, which schematically illustrates then course of the reaction. Essentially methanol dehydrogenation takes place on the Pd, which then becomes poisoned with CO in the absence of light, but which is relieved by light-induced oxidation of the CO by active oxygen species from the TiO2 support created by band gap excitation. Water is oxidised then on the support. In the next section we report beginnings of surface science work which is related to this, concerning the fabrication of model catalysts, their thermal stability and the first studies in the Reading group of their reactivity [ 10-13]. We have not yet studied photocatalytic reactions on these materials.
Fabrication and Properties of Model Catalysts A number of methods can be used to make model catalysts consisting of an array of nanoparticles on a flat, well-defined (usually single crystal) support, and these are outlined in a review by Campbell [4]. We have used both metal-vapour deposition (MVD) and metal- organic chemical vapour deposition (MOCVD) [13]; here only data for the former method will be presented. Fig 4 shows images for a layer deposited at 300K, and heated to several temperatures [ 10]. It is clear that sintering occurs at the highest temperatures, but at intermediate temperatures it appears that the main effect is one of wetting the surface - the particle diameter increases, but the particle height
@
CH3qH
@
+~l~c.,.,
=
c.
9
Light > 3 . 2 e V
Ca)
CH3OH
oO
-.r
I
|
C]
,
CO2
v /OOoo
c |
i
(~
.....
~
o~
~++,
ooOO ~ & ~o
~~~,o::l
Figure 3. Proposed model for the photocatalytic reforming of methanol on Pd/TiO2 [7-9]. This involves dissociation of the methanol on the Pd surface to yield hydrogen and adsorbed CO (a). The CO poisons further reaction in the absence of light, but band gap excitation produces an active oxygen species which strips it off (b,c). The resulting vacancy on the Pd is filled by another methanol molecule, and the anion vacancy in the titania is filled by water splitting, both producing hydrogen (d,e). The cycle is complete at f, which is identical to b.
o
~
Figure 4. STM images of a Pd/TiOz layer deposited at 300K and heated to various temperatures. Significant sintering only begins above 700K. After annealing to high temperature (F) a range of particle types are produced, which clearly depend on the exact nature of the substrate close to them, and which exhlbit facetting.
rz)
10 decreases (fig. 5). Frenken has shown that these sintering processes occur with high fractional order power laws [14], as has generally been reported earlier for powdered materials [ 15]. Fig 4f shows that particles can facet, but apparently have strongly varying morphology, depending upon the local environment. Thus the Wulff construction approach [ 16] may be invalid here, because the nature of the metal-support interface may play a dominant role in dictating high temperature particle structure. In this way we can make nanoparticles which, at least in their size distribution have a strong similarity to those found in powdered, high surface area catalysts We can also control the size distribution by varying the loading on the surface and by controlling the annealing temperature.
Spillover, Encapsulation, SMSI and Oxygen Storage Seen for the First Time It is important that we understand something about the properties of the support TiO2 (110) crystal. The treatment in UHV to clean the sample (a major surface impurity initially is Ca) results in slight bulk reduction. We estimate that for the stoichiometric formula TiO2.• x is always less than 0.001 in the work reported here. However, this has a substantial effect on i) the bulk conductivity and ii) the surface structure. The evolution of surface structure with use is shown in fig 6 and shows a transformation from the expected (lxl) termination to (lx2), to (nx2), where n is large, for instance 12 [17]. This is often called the 'cross-linked (lx2)'. With even more bulk reduction crystallographic shear planes can terminate at the surface in long-range, straight line steps [18]. The (nx2) structures are relatively easily oxidised by annealing in low pressures of oxygen, but this oxidation occurs in very particular ways. It appears that, at least at elevated temperature, the dominant defect is not an anion vacancy, but is an interstitial Ti 3§ Part of the evidence for this is that, as the surface is heated at 673K in low pressures of oxygen, new layers of TiO2 grow at the surface, and they grow in a special way [19]. The (nx2) fills in with material to make the denser surface layer of the (lxl), then the (nx2) structure forms a new layer on top of this, then fills in to (lxl), and so on in a cyclic fashion, building up new layers on the surface. This behaviour can be viewed as a movie elsewhere [20]. Since this is the case we might expect to see novel effects when a nanoparticulate layer is exposed to oxygen, as indeed we do. Figure 7 shows the effect of dosing oxygen
11
. . . .
0.0 0.5
125 ZO
Z5
310
1.0 125 2.0 215 310 300 125
2.0 215 310
400 ,
1.6
i
500 ,
i
600 ',
!
700 ,
iI
800 ,
i
900 1000 ,
!
,
i
1200 1000
,4
z t-"
125 2.0 225 310
0" 0:0 015 li0
0.0 o.s
125 2.0 225 310
1673K1
1.0 1~5 2 . 0 2 1 s 3 i 0
800 ~-
.E 1.0
.-.,I
0.6
,-..,..,,_..,..., _
0.2 0.0
,
. . . . . . . .
,
,
. __
9
/
310
o.a'-o~s 1.o 1 . s ' z o Z s 3 . o
i!
o ~ 015 ~ 110~ ~115 ~ 2.0 R 215 ~ 310 Particle
Height
400
3~,
200
~i~=
Temperature / K i25 -2.0 Z5
~
~-
0.4
300 400 500 800 700 800 900 1000
iO 025 li0
6o0
/ nm
Figure 5. Height distributions for the particles shown in fig 4. Note that up to 573K the particles appear to 'wet' the surface better and spread.
12
) ? ) D
,) P ,)
~ ~
0
r~
x
e~C'q
o~ -o"
1
•
X
9 o ,,,,~
0
[.-,
t)
IN
Figure 7. Images of Pd nanoparticles on Ti02 (1 10) at 723K,during treatment in oxygen, showing spillover and encapsulation. In A several particles are imaged before oxygen treatment. Spillover is evident in C as a circle of added Ti02 in the region close to the particles. Several layers of TiOz are built up next to the particle and in F the central particle is finally completely buried by TiO2.
14 onto the model Pd/TiO2 (110) surface, where the particles are adsorbed onto the (nx2) cross-linked surface of TiO2 (110) [11,12]. A number of phenomena can be witnessed here:1) Spiilover of oxygen from the Pd to the support occurs (see fig.7C for instance) seen as a patch of additional TiO2 grown preferentially around the Pd particle. This layer grows in a slightly different way from that on the clean surface. Instead of oscillating between (nx2) cross-linked structures and (lxl) the region adjacent to the particle always grows in a (lxl) structure. The growth of these layers is faster here than in areas remote from the particle due to an enhanced rate of adsorption on the Pd compared with the titania, and an enhanced supply of oxygen to the TiO2 surface in the adjacent region. 2) Encapsulation and burial. The layers adjacent to the particle build up so much as to completely bury the particle after 7 layers have grown. After this the rate of titania growth slows considerably. 3) Oxygen storage. Clearly by this process oxygen is stored adjacent to the Pd particle; this is reminiscent of the use of CeO2 as an oxygen storage medium in car catalysts. Although CeO2 has a different bulk structure (fluorite vs. rutile), it also possesses a 3+/4+ redox couple like TiO2, which is the source of the oxygen storage capability. Of course, this storage ability is only the property of MO2.x, that is sub-stoichiometric oxides.
It is not likely that this phenomenon is akin to classical SMSI, since those are observed after reducing the catalyst. However, the SMSI has probably been seen, by Diebold et al. For Pt [21] and by us for Pd, as shown in fig 8. It appears that the surfaces of the Pd particles, after heating above 600K are decorated by a new structure, which is related to the titania [22]. We believe this to be a TiO layer by structural analysis and comparison with bulk structures. This layer severely modifies the adsorption capability of the surface [23].
Conclusions. Model catalysts can now be made routinely, and these have proved amenable to surface science studies of their properties. By the use of high
15
,.,
.
~..
,
1 .
-.,
9 :
.-o~Y
. . . .
,
-'.-
.r.,
-,
.i"'
:]
.:
9
t~...
.
::~ o.~,
- .~.
.,. ,...~-;
..
"
?i~
~: ~.:~:
",.
: ,.,A'..~.
'
'L
.. ' "" ' ,;:
..-
~'";"z
' ''~:~ "
.'4
, ~ . .
:~ . . ' . : ~ ? . '
..
~-' .
.:
. ~:
9 ,
.
", ~
"
"~i;~:~..'~: ' ~
9. , ~ . ,
'"
.~ '~ -.
:..
r
..
.,.,,. 9
..,
; l ~ ..
...~ . . . .
- ~.
,,~.~,. ".1
.
.
..
6...
~
_..~ ,,"
.
'
*'i;"
'7,.
'-,
'
.. 9
!
I II II I
II III III I
IIII
II I I I I
I
IIIIIIIII
I
IIIIIIII
,
"
:<: . . . . ....... .
Figure 8. High resolution image of the encapsulation layer over a Pd film on TiO: (110). Two different structures can be seen a zig-zag structure on the left and a cartwheel arrangement on the right.
r|
16 temperature STM we have directly observed spillover for the first time in-situ. This is also related to the phenomena of oxygen storage in car catalysts, to metal particle encapsulation and to the SMSI effect.
References
1. M. Boudart, Topics in Catal., 13(2000)149. 2. See, for instance, G.A. Somorjai and G. Rupprechter, J. Chem. Ed. 75(1998)161. 3. M. Bowker, L. Bowker, R.A. Bennett, P. Stone and A. Ramirez-Cuesta, J. Mol Cat, in press. 4 P. Gunter, J. Niemantsverdriet, F. Ribeiro and G.A. Somorjai, Cat. Revs.Sci.Eng., 39(1997)77 5.C.T. Campbell, Surf. Sci. Rep., 30(1997)227. 6.C.R. Henry, Surf. Sci. Rep., 31(1998)231. 7. A. Dickinson, D. James, N. Perkins, T. Cassidy and M. Bowker, J. Mol. Catal., 146(1999)211. 8. A. Dickinson, PhD Thesis, University of Reading, 1997. 9. D. James, MSc Thesis, University of Reading, 1998. 10. P. Stone, S. Poulston, R. Bennett and M. Bowker, J. Chem Sot., Chem. Comm., (1998)1369-70. 11. R.A. Bennett, P. Stone and M. Bowker, Cat. Letts, 59(1999)99-106. 12. R.A. Bennett, P. Stone and M. Bowker, Faraday Disc.114 (1999) 267-78. 13. M. Newton, R.A. Bennett, R.D. Smith, J. Evans and M. Bowker, Chem. Comm., 1677-8(2000). 14. M.J. Jak, C. Konstapel, A. van Kreuningen, J. Verhoeven and J.W.M. Frenken, Surf. Sci., 457(2000)295. 15. See, for instance, S. Wanke and P. Flynn, Cat. Rev.-Sci.Eng., 12(1975)93. 16. K.H. Hansen, T. Worren, S. Stempel, E. Laegsgaard, M. Baumer, H.J. Freund, F. Besenbacher, I. Stensgaard, Phys. Rev. Lett, 1999, 83(20), 4120-4123. 17. R. Bennett, P. Stone, R.D. Smith and M. Bowker, Surface Sci., 454-6(2000)390-5.
17 18 R.A. Bennett, S. Poulston, P. Stone and M. Bowker, Phys. Rev. B. 59 (1999)10341-6. 19. R.A. Bennett, P. Stone, N. Price and M. Bowker, Phys. Rev. Letts 82(1999)3831-4. 20 P. Stone, R.A. Bennett, M. Bowker, New J. Phys., 1(1999) 8 (www.nip.org) 21. O. Dulub, W. Hebenstreit, U. Diebold, Phys. Rev. Lett, 84 (2000) 3646. 22. M. Bowker, R.A. Bennett and R. Smith, to be published 23. M. Bowker and N. Perkins, to be published
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studiesin SurfaceScienceandCatalysis133 G.F.Fromentand K.C.Waugh(Editors) Publishedby ElsevierScienceB.V.,2001
19
From First-Principles to Catalytic Turnovers: Ethylene Hydrogenation Over Palladium Matthew Neurock*, Eric Hansen, Donghai Mei, and Pallassana S. Venkataraman
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, 22903. Abstract We present a first-principles-based dynamic Monte Carlo method which can be used to model the kinetics of metal catalyzed reaction systems by following the explicit atomic surface structure and individual molecular transformations. The approach uses first-principle density functional quantum chemical calculations to build a comprehensive database of adsorption energies, overall reaction energies, activation barriers, and intermolecular interaction energies. The ab initio calculated lateral interaction energies were subsequently used to develop more approximate but universal interaction models that could be used in-situ in the MC. A radial function model and a bond order conservation model were both developed. The simulation algorithm was used herein to examine ethylene hydrogenation over palladium. The results indicate that it is the repulsive interactions in the adlayer that weaken the metal-carbon and metal-hydrogen bonds thus lowering the barriers for hydrogenation from 15 for ethylene to ethyl and 14.5 for ethyl to ethane to 8.5 and 8.0 kcal/mol for the same steps taken at higher surface coverages. The simulation results provide a very good match against known experiment results. The simulation was subsequently used to examine both the effects of alloying and surface structure. The addition of gold decreased the overall turnover number simply because the number of sites was reduced. On a per palladium basis, however, the activity remains approximately the same. The addition of gold indirectly leads to less hydrogen on the surface since it shuts down H2 dissociation steps. This, however, is countered by a reduction in the metal-hydrogen bond strength which helps to enhance the activity. These two features tend to balance one another out as the turnover frequencies remain nearly constant. We provide a simple cursory look at the effects of surface structure by examining the changes in the kinetics over Pd(100) and Pd(111) surfaces. The barriers over these two surfaces are 7.1 and 6.4 kcal/mol respectively suggesting that the chemistry is relatively structure insensitive.
I. Introduction Kinetic modeling of catalytic reaction systems plays a critical role in the design and optimization of chemical reactors and processes. The models that have been developed over the years have been the result of our understanding of the chemistry, available analytical capabilities, and the desired level of the results. Many of the earliest kinetic models were simply power-law models, i.e. empirical relationships between the measured partial pressures (or compositions) and the reaction rate. The earliest models were based solely on overall composition, conversion and yields since that was all that could be routinely determined. Despite their simplicity, power-law models are still used to model a number of industrial chemical processes. They capture the relevant information and can be used to predict daily operation and control of industrial reactors.
20 As our understanding of the elementary catalytic reaction steps and our analytical capabilities improved, the basic kinetic models were expanded in order to reflect this finer level of detail. Langmuir-Hinshelwood and Hougen-Watson (1,2) w e r e some of the first to formulate mathematical models that embody the elementary adsorption, surface reaction and desorption steps. These models have stood the test of time and have played a very valuable role in the chemical process industry as many of the current catalytic processes are modeled via some form of LHHW rate expression. For most of these systems, however, the parameters were (and still are) fit to laboratory data. A number of significant advances in analytical characterization techniques occurred over the past decade that have greatly improved our understanding of the chemistry and resolution of the molecular level0f details. By the late 1980's it became possible to characterize and model the fate of large numbers of the molecular intermediates relevant to the reaction mechanism. Up until the 1980's modeling of complex petroleum feedstocks, for example, had focused on lumping all species into measurable boiling point and solubility fractions and following the kinetics of these "thermodynamically-derived" lumps (3). The 3- and 10-lump models for fluid catalytic cracking of gas oils are classic text-book examples. By the mid 1980's it became apparent that with the increase in analytical capabilities, and computer hardware that more detailed and robust models could be developed that would enable users to span a wider range of process conditions (3). Froment (4,5,2,6),Dumesic (7-10), Stolze and Norskov (11,12), Klein (13-18), Boudart (19,20), and Ertl (21) helped to pioneer what is now termed as microkinetic modeling thus following the detailed reaction mechanisms for a number of different chemical processes. These include fluid catalytic cracking of gas oils, upgrading of heavy petroleum feedstocks, coal pyrolysis, ammonia synthesis, alkane and olefin hydrogenolysis. Microkinetics (7), as defined by Dumesic, "is the examination of catalytic reactions in terms of elementary chemical reactions that occur on the catalytic surface and their relation with each other and with the surface during a catalytic cycle." This definition can easily be expanded into covering non-catalytic systems as well. Microkinetics, for the most part, has focused on analysis or understanding of the reaction mechanism. The approach, however, also holds the promise of being used to aid in the synthesis of new materials. Microkinetic modeling is now an important tool for many of the practicing reaction engineers. This approach enables one to formulate and follow the detailed concentration profile for most if not all of the reaction intermediates. Despite the tremendous progress, the models that have been developed are still simplified descriptions of the molecular transitions of physicochemical processes that govern the kinetics. The kinetic constants used are, in most cases, still fit to experiments on the actual system, thus introducing empiricism. In many of these catalytic reaction systems the adsorption and kinetic terms are considered constant but in fact it is well established that they change as one moves to different processing conditions. Z a e r a (22,23), for example, recently showed that the adsorption constants in a simple Langmuir-Hinshelwood model could only be considered constant if the operating conditions were chosen close to where the parameters were regressed from experimental data. In order to extend their model for NO reduction, it was critical to include coverage dependent adsorption parameters. It is important to stress that many of the models that have been developed are simply just that, "models", and we should exercise caution when in using them outside the range at which they've been parametrized or reading more into the mechanisms than can be justified. There are now many examples in the literature whereby more complicated scenarios concerning different surface sites, competitive and noncompetitive
21 adsorption, and other features are added to the basic Langmuir model in an attempt to better fit the data. These features provide more parameters and usually do a much better job when fit to the experimental data simply because more parameters offer more flexibility. It is implicitly assumed, however, that the Langmuirian models are correct. The problem may not necessarily be in the reaction mechanism but the way in which one idealizes the surface. 9
The classical Langmuir-Hinshelwood model which is used as the foundation for most of the microkinetic approaches is formulated so as to average over the entire surface structure. As such it averages, over all of the local structural and compositional features of the surface and treats them in an average way. This includes the effects of local defect sites, promoters, poisons, bimetallics and metal support interactions. Figure 1 depicts a schematic which identifies various local regions of the metal surface which likely give rise to different reactivity for NO. The classical Langmuir Hinshelwood model, however, would average over the surface and treat each of these NO species as equivalent. We can see, however, that each of the NO Step Edge Covera species may, in fact, be quite different, by virtue of their local environment. Clearly the NO species on the flat terrace should react differently than the one sitting next to defect site Promotors or that next to a promoter or a step edge. The considerable improvements in both analytical as well as computational chemistry Ordered Overlayers that have occurred over Defect Sites the past decade, Figure 1 Schematic illustration of an idealized Rh surface which however, now make it depicts various local regions for NO dissociation. possible to begin to think about moving to atomic and molecular-level descriptions of the surface kinetics, in order to capture a more realistic picture of the surface chemistry and its impact on the catalytic performance. Figure 2, for example, is a recent STM figure from Bowker (24,25) which shows the presence of p(2xl) islands of oxygen on Cu(110). Methanol preferentially attacks at the edges of these islands and reacts to form formaldehyde and water. In the sequence of time progressions shown in Fig. 2, the p(2xl) islands of oxygen are reacted away by methanol and the Cu(110) surface is restored. These islands are highlighted in the overlayed boxes. This figure clearly demonstrates that these advances in spectroscopy are enabling us to begin to image active atomic surface ensembles, at least at well defined conditions. Similar advances, in AFM, HREELS, SFG and EXAFS are also beginning to provide molecular and nanoscale resolution of surface structure, and reactive
22 surface intermediates. The integration of these techniques with traditional kinetic isotopic labeling studies offer the opportunity of elucidating the elementary processes that govern catalytic reactions.
~?l.U'~..~"~'
~.~ti~
. "..
, -
-~ ~
,
~
,
,i c' ,'. ~' s'.s,
,' ~ - , ~
i I.~i I,I'{"
q .,t,i -4
tt
"~" ~' " :" J'~'+~'~';'~
Figure 2
> t'i'-~" r
" ,;J "..-~" "~'" "~ '?"' I P. !,..,:": ":> :'-~~...
i' "ii' .r,: ~':' ',i:',i~: .... if: lT:l]'.if"~. ;-.lit!
A recent STM study of the oxidative decomposition of methanol on Cu(110) by Bowker (24). The figures show that methanol preferentially attacks at the edges of the p(2xl) islands of oxygen to form products and sequentially consumes the oxygen adlayer leaving the Cu(110) surface.
Advances in computational chemistry and molecular simulation have also reached the stage whereby they can be Used to develop more advanced and robust kinetic models for catalytic systems. First-principle quantum chemical methods, for example, are being used to routinely calculate thermochemistry and kinetics for gas phase chemistry with accuracies on the order of 0.5-2 kcal/mol (26) The situation for the kinetics of heterogeneous reaction systems has also improved considerably but due to the complexity in these systems the accuracy is more on the order of 5-7 kcal/mol (27,28) In addition to the advances in raw computational power and more accurate quantum chemical methods, molecular simulation tools have also made great progress and can now begin to capture detailed quantum chemical results. In this paper, we discuss some of our recent results in coupling ab initio density functional quantum chemical methods along with dynamic Monte Carlo algorithms in order to simulate a detailed myriad of competing molecular transformations that govern the kinetics on metal surfaces. Stochastic models enable us to take full advantages of the atomic detail that is offered from the detailed analytical spectroscopies as well as the information from ab initio quantum mechanical modeling efforts since they can explicitly account for atomic surface structure. Rather than averaging the details over the entire surface by invoking deterministic methods, the Monte Carlo approach follows the position of each atom on the surface as a function of reaction conditions, As such, we can begin to map out the molecular transformations along with kinetic behavior. In particular, we will focus on the hydrogenation of olefinic intermediates. Ethylene is used as a model toward understanding the hydrogenation of complex olefin and aromatic intermediates (29) It is therefore relevant to various hydrocarbon processes. In addition, understanding ethylene hydrogenation kinetics is also important in the manufacturing of high purity ethylene feeds for polyolefin production. It is necessary to remove acetylene from the ethylene feeds for polyolefin
23 manufacturing because acetylene leads to a host of different processing problems. Ethylene feeds are first hydrotreated to selectively convert acetylenic intermediates to ethylene. The chemistry, however, is very sensitive to process conditions. Unselective routes lead to ethylene hydrogenation to form ethane. This will sharply decrease the overall selectivity, and can also lead to runaway reactors since ethylene hydrogenation is fairly exothermic. The mechanism for olefin hydrogenation has been debated for well over 30 years. The general chemistry is thought to involve a Horiuti-Polanyi (3~ like scheme. Hydrogen dissociatively adsorbs producing chemisorbed atomic hydrogen on the surface. Ethylene co-adsorbs in either di-~ or n-bound arrangement and then reacts with hydrogen to form the ethyl surface intermediate. The ethyl intermediate can subsequently react with a second surface hydrogen atom to form ethane or dissociate back to form ethylene and atomic hydrogen (29). Although the overall paths appear to be well established, the nature of the active site and the details of what controls the chemistry are still openly debated in the literature. A number of different schemes have been devised in order to appropriately fit the kinetic data (31,8,9,7). They include some of the following ideas: 1) hydrogen and ethylene compete for the same surface sites, 2) hydrogen and ethylene reversibly adsorb into separate islands and reaction occurs at the edges of these islands, and 3) hydrogen is adsorbed on two different sites- one is competitive with ethylene adsorption while the other site is not. There is little evidence, however, to support these ideas other than they provide a better fit the kinetic data. Fitting of the kinetic data alone, however, does not say very much about the mechanism. Westerterp (32) for example, recently showed that over eight different models could be readily correlated with the kinetic results for hydrogenating ethylene and acetylene mixtures. Rather than start with a preconceived notion about the mechanism, we have carried out a comprehensive series of first principle calculations in order to determine the intrinsic activation barriers, heats of adsorption and overall reaction energies for various speculate routes. Transition state theory as well as classical statistical mechanics are used to subsequently establish the Arrhenius factors and thus provide the intrinsic rate constants. One of the critical issues in using first-principles data involves the great difference between the ideal reaction environment that is chosen for the model and the actual environment under operating conditions. Most of the quantum chemical results that have been published over the past decade have examined the zero or low coverage limit in order to avoid introducing coverage effects. In order to model the active surface under reaction conditions, however, we need to explore the effects of the reaction environment. In particular, we focus here on the interactions between species on the surface. We explore these interactions in detail to determine their effects on adsorption and surface reactivity. First principle calculations enable us to easily calculate the interaction between two species coadsorbed to the surface. As we begin to think about more realistic systems, it very quickly becomes apparent that this essentially becomes impossible to do for more than two species because of the infinite number of ways in which adsorbates can assemble on a surface. For example, figure 3 depicts a single snapshot from kinetic Monte Carlo simulation that we performed for NO decomposition over Rh.
24
I :~ .-,.,r :,.: ~,..~~
~......~,. ~ i:~-~:-::_-_:!:....... !:~'--'i: ~:-~,J :~ :~ '::
' " .....
~ .:
'
' ,ii~ ~
.... ~ ": ~' . "
i
,, ~ ," ~. . . . : ". ' "
i
Figure 3 Snapshot of the Rh surface taken in-situ from the dynamic Monte Carlo simulation of NO decomposition over Rh(100). This figure highlights just two of the local regions: their compositional and spatial positioning and adsorbates. There are clearly many other regions thus making a firstprinciples analysis of all of these regions essentially impossible,
We have chosen a smaller unit cell size and also the chemistry in this system is quite limited. Despite these simplifications, this system still contains hundreds to thousands of different configurations for just this single snapshot in time. As we begin to look at the myriad of events that can occur, it becomes clear that it would be simply impossible for us to carry out all of these configurations directly from first-principle calculations. Instead, we use set of first-principle calculations to map both the nearest and next-nearest neighbor interactions. This information is then used to parametrize a semiempirical model which can be called internally within the simulation. The Monte Carlo simulation therefore, builds up the database of calculated rate constants, calculates (through model equations) the influence of the
environment and subsequently simulates the outcome of different reaction steps. The apparent rate constants are subsequently used to calculate a reaction probability distribution, ri/Zri which is then used in the simulation to establish which events occur as we proceed in time. In addition to modeling coverage effects, the Monte Carlo algorithm also enables us to track individual sites, i.e. atop, bridge, hollow sites. It is well known from the surface science literature that while one site may prove to be strongest adsorption site, it may or may not be active site that drives the kinetics. We therefore intrinsically allow for site-specificity in the model.
II. Developing The Intrinsic Kinetic Data Base from Ab Initio Methods We have performed a number of cluster and periodic slab quantum chemical calculations to determine the intrinsic energetics for sequence of adsorption and reaction steps that control ethylene hydrogenation and decomposition. The methods are briefly described below. The (33-36) details can be found in the following papers:
A) OFT Calculations Large nineteen atom palladium clusters were used to model the Pd(111) surface (34). All calculations were performed using spin-polarized Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations with nonlocal gradient corrections for the correlation and exchange energies. The local exchange correlation potential was modeled using the Vosko-Wilk-Nusair (VWN) potential along with nonlocal gradient corrections from Becke (37) and Perdew (38)for the exchange and correlation terms respectively. DFT-optimized double zeta gaussian type orbital basis sets which include
25 spin polarization were employed for all atoms. (39,40) The spin states were fully optimized for all calculations. The Pd cluster was held fixed at the metal positions of the ideal surface. The adsorbates however were allowed to fully optimize.
B. Periodic Pd(l l l) Calculations To examine higher coverage situations and the effect of surface relaxation, periodic DFT calculations were performed. The results were found to be quite consistent with calculations on the large Pd19 clusters (34) which helps to confirm the cluster results. The Pd(111) surface was described by constructing a supercell which is translated along the lattice vectors that lie in the surface plane to describe ( . ~ x.~/~) R30 ~ and (2x2) surfaces. The surface is defined here by three layers of Pd atoms. A vacuum layer of 10 A was placed above the adsorbate surface to avoid any electronic interactions between the slabs. In previous calculations we examined the effect of the number of metal layers on the binding energies for hydrogen on Pd(111) and found that the energy changes were less than 1 kcal/mol as the slab thickness was increased to three layers and beyond. In addition, the structural changes which occur in going beyond three layers were found to be negligible. Three layers of Pd, therefore, appeared to provide a computationally efficient and tractable model of the Pd(111) surface (41). The Kohn-Sham (KS) equations were solved using a plane wave basis set with a maximum kinetic energy of 40 Rydberg. Eighteen special k-points (Bloch vectors) were used in the description of the first Brillouin zone. The special k-points were chosen based on symmetry by the method developed by Chadi-Cohen. All calculations were performed self consistently by using non-local exchange and correlation potentials in the form of the Perdew-Wang 91 Generalized Gradient Corrections. Scalar relativistic corrections were described through the use of norm-conserving pseudopotentials. The first two palladium layers were allowed to relax in an effort to understand the effects of surface relaxation. The bottom layer was held fixed at the bulk structure of Pd(111). Adsorbates were then spaced in either a ( ~ x,~/~) R30 ~ or a (2x2) surface structure. The ( , ~ x,~/3) R30 ~ structure was found to lead to repulsive interactions between neighboring ethyl intermediates. The (2x2) structure was therefore used to help eliminate any through-space repulsive interactions. The geometries of the first two layers of the surface along with the adsorbates structure were completely optimized. (34)
C. The Catalytic Potential Energy Surface The low coverage adsorption energies for the relevant intermediates are shown in Table 1. Ethylene binds in both the n and di-cy adsorption states. At the low coverage, the di
26
Species Ethylene (di-cy) (~) Vinyl q2(~tl,~t2) Ethyl Atop Bridge Ethylidyne 3-fold fcc 3-fold hcp Bridge Atomic Hydrogen Atomic Oxygen Atomic Carbon
AEADs Pdl9 (kJ/mol)
AEADs Pd (111) 2x2 (kJ/mol)
Experiment (kJ/tool)
-60 -30
-62 -27
-237
-254
-130 -75
-140 -
-620
-636 (CH3C"quartet) -511 (CH3C-doublet)
-603 -587 -271 -375 -610
-266 -400 -635
-59
-262
Table 1 DFT-calculatedadsorption energies for C2Hxand atomic surface intermediateson the Pdl9 cluster and the Pd(111) 2x2 3 layer slabs [Reprinted from (34) ]. By examining various different configurations for two and three ethylene molecules on the (111) and (100) surfaces, we are able to establish the most basic lateral interactions. For example, ethylene adsorption in the well-defined p(2x2) arrangement shown in Fig. 4 leads to an adsorption energy o f - 8 4 kJ/mol. This indicates that the attractive interactions per pair of ethylene molecules is 11 kJ/mol. As the ethylene molecules move closer or sit perpendicular to one another they become repulsive at about the 8-15 kJ/mol. While these interactions may appear to be small, they become quite important as the coverage is increased because the number of these interactions increases. These are just a few of the interactions that were calculated. These values were subsequently used to parameterize simpler empirical or semiempirical lateral models. Extended Htickel theory, for example, was used in order expand our database of different lateral interactions (42). We let the computer then generate thousands of different plausible surface configurations and their corresponding interaction energies. Hydrogen readily dissociates over Pd(ll 1) to form atomic hydrogen on the surface. The energy for the dissociative adsorption of hydrogen i s - 7 8 kJ/mol. Ethylene hydrogenates to form the ethyl intermediate. Ethyl prefers the atop adsorption site were it binds w i t h - 1 4 1 kJ/mol. Higher coverages weakened the Pd-H interaction by about 10 kJ/mol. The overall reaction energy for the hydrogenation of ethylene from the di-cy adsorption state at zero coverage is +3 kJ/mol. The barrier for the metal catalyzed reaction of ethylene to ethyl at zero coverage is +72 kJ/mol. The reference state for the reactants are ethylene (di-cy) and hydrogen sharing a single metal center. If we use ethylene and hydrogen that are separated from one another as our reference state, the calculated barrier increases to +87 kJ/mol. In the Monte Carlo simulations, the diffusion of ethylene and hydrogen to the reactive site are treated as a separate step. We therefore use the value of +72 as the reference state. As the coverage is increased to 0 = 0.6 ML both of these barriers decrease by about 5 -10 kJ/mol.
27
Figure 4
Ethylene adsorption in p(2x2) arrangement on Pd(100). The specific positioning of ethylene is such that it stabilizes each ethylene pair by 11 kJ/mol due to attractive through-surface interactions. The more interesting situation, however, is that for the n-bound ethylene. At low surface coverages we find that n-bound ethylene does not hydrogenate but simply coverts to the di-cy intermediate. At higher coverages, however, the n-bound state becomes pinned within the adlayer whereby it can no longer translate along the surface to convert to a di-cy species. It can now either react with hydrogen or desorb. We were able to isolate the transition state for the transient n-bound state at high coverage which is shown in Fig. 5. The barrier is reduced from +72 kJ/mol (low coverage) to + 3 6 (high coverage) kJ/mol (36) as we move to higher coverages. Although the di-cy site is the more favorable site, at high surface coverages the n-bound state is actually more reactive.
A)
Figure 5 DFT isolated transition states for ethylene hydrogenation from the di-cyand n-bound intermediates at higher surface coverages (adapted from (36)).
Once ethyl is formed one the surface it can readily dissociate back to form ethylene or undergo successive hydrogenation to form ethane. The DFT calculated barrier for the back reaction is +63 kJ/mol which is lower
28 than that for the forward reaction. The barrier for the addition hydrogen to ethyl to form ethane is +71 kJ/mol. The results suggest that the forward path for ethyl to ethane competes with the reverse path for 13 C-H bond activation which leads back to ethylene. An equilibrium is established between the two. This equilibrium is consistent with known experimental results (43) The final hydrogenation step to form ethane is not very reversible due to the high barrier height for the reverse reaction of ethane C-H bond activation (+105 kJ/mol). In addition, ethane does not readily readsorb. The overall hydrogenation energetics are shown in detail in Fig. 6.
cW4 (g)+H2 (g)
Zero Coverage Limit
-13.2
-20.6 -21.6
c w 4 (g)+2H (a) cW6 (g) C2H5 (a)+ H (a) u
l
-31.8
-35.6 I L l
]C2H4 (a)+ 2H (a)
Figure 6
The overall hydrogenation energetics for ethylene hydrogenation as computed by DFT at the zero coverage limit. O. Selectivity I s s u e s
It is well established that ethylene decomposes over Pd to form ethylidyne and carbonaceous surface intermediates (44-49) Decomposition readily occurs at lower partial pressures of hydrogen and leads to a loss in selectivity. Under these conditions, ethylidyne is the primary surface intermediate. While ethylidyne is thought to form directly from the interconversion of ethylene, there is little proof that this is indeed the actual route. We have tried to isolate a direct path for the formation of ethylidyne from ethylene with very little success. The barriers for the direct path are simply too high. We have, however, found a low energy path which involves the C-H activation of ethylene to form surface vinyl. The surface vinyl intermediate can subsequently hydrogenate to form ethylidene which can then undergo a C-H bond scission to form ethylidyne. This indirect path along with the calculated energetics are shown in Fig. 7. The limiting step for this sequence involves the formation of the surface vinyl intermediate at +140 kJ/mol. Subsequent steps occur much more readily leading to ethylidene and ethylidyne. A very similar route has also been suggested from UHV studies for ethylene on Pt by Zaera (43) Although ethylidyne is strongly bound to Pd, its barrier for surface diffusion is fairly low. It's primary role may simply be that as a spectator.
29
E. Lateral Interactions The overall potential energy profile calculated for this system at zero coverage shown in Fig. 6 provides the necessary preliminary input for the simulation. As discussed above, we have calculated a set of basic lateral interactions to determine the pair interactions of ethylene from first-principle calculations. These calculations were supplemented by carrying out over 1750 Extended Hiickel Theory (EHT) calculations in order to develop a semiempirical model for lateral interactions (42) These calculations were determined from the number of plausible scenarios that are generated by the Monte Carlo simulation code. The resulting DFT and EHT results were then fit to the model which is a function of the radial distance between the specific adsorbates. The model allows for both attractive as well as repulsive interactions between adsorbates. In addition, a bond order conservation (BOC) model was parametrized by the DFT lateral interaction results and used to calculate local lateral interactions on the measured activation barriers. As was discussed above, these interactions can markedly affect reactivity and control the predominant surface interactions. In previous Monte Carlo TPD studies for example, we found that the shape of the curve and the peak locations were quite sensitive to lateral interactions. Higher coverages displayed repulsive interactions which lead to a lower temperature of desorption. At lower coverages, lateral interactions became attractive. These attractive interactions stabilized the formation of a p(2x2) ordered overlayer.
vinyl formation
,".f" ~
AEact =+151kJ/mol
9
AErxn= +73~l/mol ~
i m i
I A.Eact=+84kJ/tool
vinyl V AErxn=-44kJ/m~ hydrogenation
i Isomerization
m s
g thy lidy
Figure 7.
e th y lidy n e formation
~ ) ~ o ~
AEact =+75kJhnol
,,, _ ~ ~ ~ ~ r
AErxn=-20 kJ/nlol
lide ne
.?Y" ,,:_~~~.,~~
Catalytic paths for the decomposition of ethylene to ethylidyne. Direct isomerization and the sequential hydrogenation/dehydrogenation processes.
30
IIl. Simulating Reaction Chemistry A. Monte Carlo Simulation Algorithm A variable time step dynamic Monte Carlo simulation algorithm was constructed in order to model temporal surface reactivity and kinetics (42). The algorithm explicitly accounts for all atop, bridge, and hollow sites on the surface. The simulation follows the elementary physicochemical processes as a function of time and can therefore, track the changes in the spatial arrangement and positioning of the molecules that make up the surface adlayer. As such we can simply count the number of product molecules that desorb from the surface as a function of time in order to determine the turnover frequency. The algorithm is based on a variable time step kinetic Monte Carlo approach whereby we examine the entire surface for all possible kinetic events that can occur. The overall structure of the simulation algorithm is shown in Fig. 8.
I Kinetic ~ Input J At -
~Construct~ ( Process 1 "~Surfacef ~ Input ~ompute'Total Pmt~-~
ln(1- RN)
'=' ~
[
IC~
I
~/~. Event1
IK~ \
IpdatoSurfa el ' '
'1
' ."
Because of the disparity in timescales between diffusion and reaction we separate these events and treat the diffusion events as quasi-equilibrated. At any instant in time we simply add up all of the rates for all of the different kinetic processes that can occur, Y~ri. This value is then used to calculate the time at which some event in the system occurs based on the following equation:
Yes
Figure 8.
Schematic for the dynamic Monte Carlo simulation algorithm.
At
=
-
(~)
ln(RN)
Zjr
We use these same individual rates (or rate-constants) to calculate the probable selectivity for each specific event. By drawing a second random number we specify which event actually occurs from the cumulative probability distribution. This value is used to compare to the cumulative reaction probability distribution Si (equation2). If the value drawn is between Si and Si+~, event Si is chosen. We update the event and then continue back through the process of monitoring time and events.
Si
_
]/'i
Sr
(2)
The simulation tracks the detailed occupation of all surface sites along with the identity of all molecules that desorb, diffuse or react thus providing a full accounting of the spatiotemporal behavior. The size of the simulation cell employed is chosen so as to optimize the accuracy and
31 precision with the balance on the CPU requirements. Larger unit cells offer more accurate and precise results. Smaller unit cells averaged over numerous runs can reduce the CPU requirements while maintaining accuracy and precision. We will typically use lattices that are on the order of 40x40 which, for a (100) surface, has over 4800 sites. Before the simulation results are tabulated in a production mode we typically allow the simulation to run for a block of time in order to equilibrate the system. The lateral interactions between molecules are quite important in determining the surface coverage as well as the surface kinetics. B. Monte Carlo Simulation Results 1) Ethylene Hydrogenation over Pd(100) The simulation is currently setup to enable the user to change initial process variables and simulate the output product distributions. As such the simulation can be run as a "virtual experiment". We initially examined the hydrogenation of ethylene over the Pd(100) surface. A series of simulation runs were performed at different temperatures to follow the effects of temperature on the reaction rate. The resulting TOFs were plotted against 1/T in the same way that experimental data would be examined, in order to determine the overall apparent activation energy. In addition, we can also back out the apparent activation barriers for specific elementary adsorption and reaction steps. The resulting potential energy profile for ethylene hydrogenation that results from the simulation is quite a bit different than that established at zero coverage. The activation barrier for ethylene hydrogenation to ethyl is reduced from 15 kcal/mol to 10.8 as we move from the zero coverage limit to the more realistic simulation surface coverages (0.3-0.5 ML). The barrier for the hydrogenation of surface ethyl to ethane is reduced from 14.5 kcal/mol (zero coverage) to 8.1 kcal/mol (reaction simulation coverages). This is shown in the overall potential energy diagram in Figure 9 for ethylene hydrogenation at higher coverages. This reduction in the activation barrier is primarily due to the repulsive interactions between surface intermediates. Repulsive interactions reduce the strength of the metal-adsorbate (M-C and M-H) bonds and thus lower the barrier for hydrogenation. Our DFT calculation results showed a similar effect. The barrier for ethylene hydrogenation at higher ethylene (0.3 ML) and hydrogen (0.3 ML) surface coverages was 8-10 kcal/mol which is 3-4 kcal/mol lower than the 11-15 kcal/mol barriers calculated at the zero coverage limit. The high coverage ethylene hydrogenation barriers calculated from both DFT (8-10 kcal/mol) and Monte Carlo simulation (8-11 kcal/mol) results are consistent with known experimental results which are on the order of 7-12 kcal/mol.
In addition to temperature effects, we can also simulate changes in reaction kinetics as we increase the partial pressure for each of the reactants. A series of simulation runs were carried out at different partial pressures of ethylene and hydrogen to examine their effect on the rate. The measured turnover frequencies were fit to the following power law expression in order to establish the reaction orders of hydrogen (x) and ethylene (y).
TOF
-
v.exp
(
-Ea).pH RT
x .p
c~.,
y
(3)
The turnover frequency is simply the number of ethane molecules that desorb per surface site per time. The reaction orders calculated from the simulation results were-0.16 to +0.03 for ethylene
32 and 0.38 to 0.56 for hydrogen. This is in very good agreement with known experimental results which indicate reaction rates that are zero order in ethylene and half order in hydrogen (50,7) In addition to the overall kinetic properties, the C2H 4 (g)+ H 2 (g) simulation also provides a comprehensive -11 accounting of the atomic positions of all -16.4 of the surface -18.7 intermediates as a i, -19.1 10.8 function of time and process conditions. For C2H4 (g)+ 2H (a) -27.2 C2H6 (g) example, the snapshots C2H 5 (a)+ H (a) -3""].8 shown in Fig. 10 are C2H 4 (a)+ 2H (a) taken at subsequent elementary steps and depict the change in the T= 298 K, PC2H4= 25 Torr, PH2=25 Torr molecular arrangements Figure 9 The "apparent" overall energetic cycle for the hydrogenation of on the surface as a ethylene due to lateral surface interactions. function of time. The majority of the surface is covered with the di-~ bound ethylene intermediate along with hydrogen which is isolated at the 4-fold hollow sites. The surface contains only 1-5% of the n-bound ethylene which is actually the much more reactive intermediate. Our first-principle DFT calculations show that the n-bound ethylene has a barrier that is almost half of that for the di-cy ethylene. The n-bound ethylene is more weakly bound and therefore reacts much more readily than the di-~ ethylene. This is in good agreement with the results by Cremer and Somorjai (45-48) who used Sum Frequency Generation experiments to follow the characteristic stretch modes for the n and di-~ bound ethylene throughout reaction over Pt. Their results suggest that the n-bound ethylene makes up only 4-5% of the surface coverage but is solely responsible for catalytic turnovers. The di-~ intermediate is thought to be only spectator species. In our simulations, we see a much higher rate of reaction from the n-bound intermediates but the di-~ species also plays an important role in the measured rate. Effects of Lateral Interactions Barrie1:v Reduced
The apparent activation barrier for the first hydrogenation step as established by the simulation is slightly greater than the second hydrogenation step. The barrier for the reverse reaction of ethyl dissociation back to ethylene and hydrogen, however, is also rather low. The ethyl that forms readily reacts back to form ethylene and hydrogen rather than hydrogenate to from ethane. This exchange process between ethylene-ethyl-ethylene occurs quite readily with increasing temperatures. This exchange process is well known experimentally over various transition metals (43,49)
33
Event Snapshots
Ethylene Figure 10
Ethyl
Snapshotsfrom the kinetic Monte Carlo simulationfor ethylene hydrogenationover Pd(100).
The detailed information offered from the simulation enables us to point out the molecular features that govern the chemistry. By calculating all of the barriers and reaction energetics from first-principle quantum chemical calculations, the simulations are free of any experimentally regressed parameters. The results for the simulation agree remarkably well with the known experimental data (51,50,31,52,53).A simple power law rate model derived from the simulations is compared with that known from experiments below in Eqs. 4 and 5.
Rsimuta"~
-
9.5 + 2.5 kcal/mol'~po.65_l.Op_o.4_o.o 105.4-+0.0exp(7 RT ) H2 -- C2H4
(4)
8.5 + 2.5 kcal/mol)pO.5_,.op_o3_oo RT ) H2 C2H4
(5)
RExhPern~merit = 1 0 6.3+0.07 exp
-
We didn't expect the match to be this close. In any event, the simulations provide a framework for which we can now begin to test mechanistic ideas. As indicated in the introduction most of the current models in the literature require arbitrary assumptions about site specificity or competitive and uncompetative sites in order for them to match the experimental results. These assumptions provide more flexibility in the model through the introduction of another fitting parameter. We were able to match the experimental results here without invoking assumptions about the different surface sites and different site competitions or fitting parameters. The elementary step rate constants used in the simulation were derived solely from quantum chemical calculations and transition state theory estimates without regression back against the experimental data. One of the limitations of the models posed in the literature is their assumption of "constant" adsorption constants over different inlet partial pressures. Our results here indicate that the lateral repulsive interactions between surface species play a very important
34 role in reducing the activation barriers. Changes in the surface coverage markedly impact the nature of the intermolecular interactions, this dictates the relative surface coverages and as well the reaction rate. All of these features can be easily captured in the Monte Carlo simulation.
2) Effect of Gold Olefin as well as acetylene hydrogenation is carried out industrially over PdAu, PdAg or PdCu alloys in order to increase selectivity. Palladium catalyzes the hydrogenation of olefins but is also active in catalyzing unselective hydrocarbon decomposition paths. The question of whether gold alters the electronic or the geometric features that control selectivity is still debated. Gold is modeled here by parametrizing a bond order conservation approach with ab initio DFT values, similar to the model described above for Pd. DFT results indicated that ethylene adsorption is reduced by only 30 kJ/mol as we move from Pd (-60 kJ/mol) to Au (-30 kJ/mol), but atomic hydrogen is reduced by almost 80 kJ/mol in moving from Pd (-271 kJ/mol) to Au (-195 kJ/mol). The more strongly bound intermediates are those which are most critically affected by the presence of gold. The DFT results on the pure Pd and Au were subsequently used to estimate the adsorption and reaction energies on the alloyed surfaces through the use of bond order conservation estimates and Eq. 6.
(6)
We have performed a series of simulations on various different PdAu alloyed surfaces. The systems examined along with the corresponding ethane turnover frequencies (on a per Pd atom basis) are given in Table 2. As would be expected, the overall turnover frequency is decreased simply due to ensemble size (geometric arguments) effects. Gold is inactive, and therefore when it is substituted for Pd it reduces reactive sites. The calculated turnover frequency, measured on a per Pd basis, however remains essentially constant over a range of different alloy configurations examined. In these simulations, it is clear that gold acts to shut down sites for hydrogen dissociation. This leads to lower surface coverages of hydrogen which ultimately lowers the rate. On the other hand, gold also acts to weaken the binding energies of both ethylene and hydrogen on the surface. This leads to a faster rate of hydrogenation. These two effects counter one another and therefore there is little measurable change in the TOF on a Pd atom basis. The effect of gold composition and temperature on ethylene and hydrogen coverages and binding energies are shown in Fig. 11 and 12. As the gold composition in the surface is increased from 0 to 12%, the hydrogen surface coverage changes from 0.21 to 0.11 ML. In addition the hydrogen binding energy can decrease from 61 kcal/mol to 59.5 kcal/moi. These changes in the binding energies are much more subtle with gold coverage but their effects are just as important to the rate. The changes in the ethylene coverage and ethylene binding energy as shown in Figures 11 and 12 are much less sensitive to the composition of Au. The ethylene coverage changes by only 0.01 to 0.02 ML. Although Au decreases the number of Pd sites, it does not really change the activity of the remaining Pd atoms. This is shown in Table 2.
35
3713,~o
Hydrogen Surface6"overage
370
Ethylene Surface Coverage
(1 17
35(1
~
i .~3o
330
310
2911
27(1
25.
,
i1(111
1102
(1114
,
0(16
oox
0 i(1
0 12
25(1
A u Conll~),ltlon
o (HI
,
0 (12
,
(1 (14
0 O6
o ()8
o |2
o io
Au Composition
Figure 11
The effect of gold and temperatureon the average surface coverages.
37(1
35o
HydrogenBindingEnergy
/
3711
14.O
2711
2711
2S0
111111
(1112
111111 Au Composition
Figure 12
1) 11~
11111
(112
. iii)
002
004
o116
oo1~
o IO
o.12
Au Compo,ttlon
The effect of gold and temperatureon the average binding energies.
The results presented so far only examine the selective hydrogenation pathways. Carbon formation is not explicitly explored in the Monte Carlo simulation. We have, however, worked out the reaction paths and energetics for ethylidyne and carbon formation from DFT QM calculations. The results indicate that gold shuts down the sites for ethylidyne formation, thus increasing the stability of ethylene and ethyl surface intermediates. The barrier for ethylidene to react to form ethylidyne (see Fig. 7) increases by 30 kJ/mol when gold is substituted into the surface. This helps to improve the reaction selectivity without sacrificing the activity of reactive metal (in this case Pd). The activities reported here (on a Pd atom basis) are essentially constant. This is consistent with what is known experimentally. Davis and Boudart (511 for example, report little changes in the TOF (on a pure Pd basis) as Pd is alloyed with Au. The apparent effects discussed in the literature suggest that the role of Au is simply geometric. Our results herein show that the electronic effect is important in increasing the rate of hydrogenation of ethylene which ultimately compensates the reduced number of sites on activity.
36
I
g m / R B m
Turn-over Frequency
H* Coverage (ML)
0.10
0.15
60.0
10.7
0.1875
0.10
0.27
61.6
9.7
0.176
0.13
0.25
62.3
9.3
0.184
0.11
0.29
61.3
8.5
0.179
0.13
0.27
61.3
10.3
0.176
0.15
0.28
61.2
9.1
0.18
0.14
0.36
62.1
9.1
0.19
0.42
62.5
9.1
0.182
0.14
Eads(H* ) Eads(C2H4*) C2H4" Coverage (kcal/mol) (kcal/mol) (ML)
:ll,
TOF/per Pd
Table 2 The effect of gold on the ethylene hydrogenation turnover frequencies for ethane formation.
3) Structure Sensitivity Hydrogenation reactions are known to be relatively structure insensitive. We examine the effects of structure sensitivity by simulating ethylene hydrogenation over Pd (100) as well as Pd(111) surfaces. The relative surface coverages and adsorbate binding energies again appear to be the two factors that control the kinetics. The (100) surface is more open than the (111) surface and therefore allows for slightly higher surface coverages of ethylene and hydrogen. Monte Carlo simulations performed at UHV conditions where T= 100 K, indicate saturation coverages of 0.33 and 0.37 ML for ethylene on P d ( l l l ) and Pd(100) respectively. These are in very good agreement with reported experimental saturation coverages of 0.30 and 0.37 ML for ethylene on Pd(111) (54) and Pd(100) (55) surfaces respectively. The resulting adlayers that form are shown in Fig. 13. Thespacing on the (111) surface is ideal in that it allows for ethylene to begin to order into ('~/'3x'~) R30 ~ patches of ethylene in the adlayer. In the presence of hydrogen, the saturation coverages drop to 0.19 and 0.25 on Pd(111) and Pd(100) respectively. The coverage of hydrogen over Pd(100) in the presence of ethylene ranges from 0.35 ML to 0.20 ML over the range of 250-375 K. The corresponding coverage of hydrogen on the (111) surface is 0.22 to 0.15 ML. The (100) surface therefore can accommodate up to 10-30% more than the (111) surface. The average binding energies calculated from the simulation are slightly lower on the (100) than on the (111) surface. The lower binding energy on the more open surface is the result of increased repulsive interactions which weaken the metal-adsorbate surface bonds. The average binding energy for ethylene changes from 60.0 to 61.5 kJ/mol on Pd(111) whereas the value is about 62.0 kcal/mol on Pd(100). The weaker interactions and the higher surface coverages of ethylene lower the intrinsic activation barrier for hydrogenation on the (100) surface. This will tend to increase the rate of ethylene hydrogenation. This increase however is countered by an increased rate of the reverse reaction of ethyl back to ethylene. As was reported earlier, the rate of ethane formation is
37
controlled by a delicate balance of the first hydrogen addition step, its reverse reaction of ethyl dissociation and the final hydrogen addition step. The lower barriers for hydrogen addition are offset by lower barriers for the reverse reaction back to ethylene and hydrogen. The end result is that the overall apparent activation barrier over Pd(100) and Pd(111) are quite similar. There are hardly any measurable differences in the calculated turnover frequencies on these two surfaces.
Pd(111)
Pd(lO0)
..
,,
~-~'~.~
'
N
Osat at 100 K = 0.37 M L
~i'
'
Osat at 100 K = 0.33 M L
(Experimental Saturation is 0.37 ML) Figure 13
The Pd(100) and Pd(111) ethylene saturation coverages at low temperature UHV conditions.
This is shown in the Arrhenius plot shown in Fig. 14. This is consistent with the experimemal evidence which indicate little or no structure sensitivity for olefin hydrogenation.
,El ./~--- l~l
12
Pd(111)
Ea = 7.17 kcal/mol
,/k
Pd(lO0)
Ea = 6.38 kcal/mol
9
-2
0.0020
,
I
0.0025
,
I
0.0030
,
I
0.0035
,
I
0.0040
,
0.0045
1/T (K'I)
Figure 14
The effect of surface structure on the activation barriers and turnover frequencies for ethylene hydrogenation over Pd. The Pd(100) and Pd(lll) surfaces show nearly identical activtiy. The activation barriers for ethylene hydrogenation are 7.1 and 6.4 kcal/mol respectively.
38
IV. Summary and Conclusions Many of the issues that currently impede the development of robust reaction engineering models are those which target molecular level details. Our analytical and computational capabilities will continue to improve. We can therefore begin to develop molecular and even atomic level reaction engineering models that track the basic elementary surface processes and the intermolecular transformations that govern the catalytic surface chemistry. This will not only improve the depth of our reaction engineering models but should also nicely complement experimental catalyst design efforts. In this paper, we focused our attention on olefin hydrogenation and present just a small subset of what is currently possible in terms modeling and developing structure-property relationships for alloys and structure sensitivity. Herein we coupled first-principle quantum mechanical calculations with kinetic Monte Carlo simulation in order to follow the spatiotemporal changes in the surface adlayer and its effect on the measured catalytic turnover frequencies. The atomic surface structure was explicitly tracked thus providing the ability to examine the effects of the local reaction environment on the intrinsic surface kinetics. Ethylene hydrogenation is controlled by the reactivity of weakly bound ~ and dicy ethylene species. Lateral repulsive interactions that exist between neighboring ethylene and ethylene and hydrogen surface species weaken the metal-adsorbate bond strengths and lower the barriers for hydrogenation. The n-bound intermediate, for example, which is present on the surface at coverages of less than 4% is highly reactive. Although the barrier for the first hydrogenation step is the highest, the reverse reaction.of ethyl dissociation to ethylene and hydrogen can significantly impact the rate by sending the reactive ethyl intermediate back to ethylene and hydrogen. Alloying the surface with gold shuts down the conversion of ethylene to ethylidyne and surface carbon by simple geometric effects. While gold also decreases the number active sites, it has little apparent effect on the activity of the palladium sites. This is due to a balance whereby gold decreases the surface coverage of hydrogen, it also decreases the binding energies for surface hydrogen and ethylene. These two factors counter one another, and thus maintain a nearly constant activity on a per palladium basis. Ethylene hydrogenation appears to be relatively structure insensitive. The (100) surface has an increase in the surface coverage of about 10% over the (111) surface. This acts to lower the barriers for both the first and second hydrogen addition steps. The reverse path of ethyl reacting back to form ethylene is also increased, thereby countering some of the increased activity. The apparent activation barriers on the (111) and (100) surfaces are 7.1 and 6.5 kcal/mol respectively. There is also little change in the turnover frequency. We have focused solely on chemistry issues and improved kinetic models. The fluid mechanics and heat and mass transfer will also be quite important to assess.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank Dow Chemical Company, DuPont Chemical Company, and the National Science Foundation for the financial support of this work.
39 References (1) (2) (3) (4)
(5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15)
(16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24)
(25) (26)
(27) (28) (29) (30) (31) (32) (33) (34)
(35) (36)
Hougen, O. A., and K.M. Watson Chemical Process Principles New York, 1947; Vol. III. Froment, G., and K.B. Bischoff Chemical Reactor Analysis and Design, 2nd Edition ed.New York, 1990. Katzer, J., and A. Sapre Chemical Reactions in Complex Mixtures: The Mobil Workshop, 1991. Baltanas, M. A., K.K. Vanraemdonck, G.F. Froment, and S.R. Mohedas, Ind. Eng. Res. Chem. 8, 899-910 (1989). Feng, W., E. Vynckier, and G.F. Froment, Ind. and Eng. Chem. Res. 32, 2997-3005 (1993). Froment, G. F., Chem. Eng. Sci. 47, 2163-2177 (1992). Dumesic, J. A., D.F. Rudd, L.M. Aparicio, and J.E. Rekoske, and A.A. Trevino The Microkinetics of Heterogeneous Catalysis; American Chemical Society:, 1993. Cortright, R., S. Goddard, J. Rekoske, S. Sharma, and J.A. Dumesic, J. Catal. 127, 342 (1991). Rekoske, J. E., R. Cortright, S. Goddard, S. Sharma, and J.A. Dumesic, J. Phys. Chem. 96, 1880 (1992). Dumesic, J. A., and A.A. Trevino, J. Catal. 116, 119-129 (1989). Stoltze, P., and J.K. Norskov, J. Catal. 110, 1-10 (1988). Stoltze, P., and J.K. Norskov, Surf. Sci. Lett. 197, 1230 (1988). Neurock, M., C. Libanati, A. Nigam, and M.T. Klein, Chem. Eng. Sci. 45, 2083-2088 (1990). Libanati, C., C. LaMarca, and M.T. Klein; 1991, FUEL Part I 37, 201 (1991). Neurock, M., S. Stark, and M.T. Klein. Molecular Simulation of Kinetic Interactions in Complex Mixtures. In Computer-Aided Design of Catalysts; Marcel Dekker, Inc.: New York, 1993; pp 5588. Provine, W. D., and M.T. Klein, Chem. Eng. Sci. 49, 4223-4248 (1994). Korre S.C., a. M. T. K., Catal. Today 31, 79-91 (1996). Joshi, P. V., A. Kumar, TT Mizan, and M.T. Klein, ENERG FUEL 13, 1135-1144 (1999). Boudart, M., and G. Djega-Mariadassou Kinetics of Heterogeneous Catalytic Reactions; Princeton University Press: Princeton, N.J., 1984. Boudart, M. Kinetics of Chemical Processes Stoneham, England, 1991. Ertl, G., In Catalytic Ammonia Synthesis; Jennings, J. R., Ed.; Plenum Press: New York, 1991; pp 128. Zaera, F., CAT2000 Meeting, Lyon France. (2000). Gopinath, C. S.; Zaera, F.,Journal of Catalysis 186, 387-404 (1999) Bowker, M., Topics in Catalysis 3, 461-468 (1996). Francis, S. M.; Leibsle, F. M.; Haq, S.; Xiang, N.; Bowker, M., Surface Science 315, 284-292 (1994). Thompson, T., H.D. Cochran, P.T. Cummings, D.A. Dixon, J.T. Golab, G.S. Hffifinger, B.K. Peterson, A. Redondo, and P.R. Westmoreland "Chemical Industry of the Future: Technology Roadmap for Computational Chemistry," Department of Energy, Office of Industrial Technology and Council for Chemical Research, 1999. Neurock, M. and A. T. Bell. "Future Directions for Theoretical Catalysis, Homogeneous, Heterogeneous, and Surface Reactivity," National Science Foundation and Department of Energy, 1997. van Santen, R. A., and M. Neurock, Catal. Rev. -Sci. Eng. 37, 557-698 (1995). Ponec, V., and G. C. Bond Catalysis by Metals and Alloy; Elsevier: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1995. Horiuti, J., and M. Polanyi, Trans. Faraday Soc 30, 1164 (1934). ; Eley, D., Ed.; Rinhold Corp.: New York, NY, 1955; Vol. III, pp 49. Bos, A. N. R., Bootsma, E.S., F. Foeth, H.W.J. Sleyster, and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. and Process. 32, 53-63 (1993). Neurock, M., Stud. in Stud. Surf Sci. and Catal. 109, 3-34 (1997). Neurock, M., and R.A. van Santen, J. Phys. Chem. B (to appear), (2000). Venkataraman, P. S., and M. Neurock, J. Catal. 191, 301-317 (2000). Neurock, M., P.S. Venkataraman, and R.A. van Santen, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122, 1150-1153 (2000).
40
(37) (38) (39)
(4o) (41)
(42) (43) (44) (45) (46) (47) (48) (49)
(50) (51) (52) (53) (54)
(55)
Becke, A., ACS Symp. Series 394, 165 (1989). Perdew, J., P. Phys. Rev. B 33, 8822 (1986). Andzelm, J., E. Radzio, and D.R. Salahub, J. Comp. Chem. 6, 520-532. (1985). Godbout, N., D.R. Salahub, J. Andzelm, and E. Wimmer, Can. J. Chem. 70, 560 (1992). Venkataraman, P. S., M. Neurock, L. Hansen, B. Hammer, and J.K. Norskov, Phys. Rev. B, 60, 8 (1999). Hansen, E. W., and M. Neurock, J. Catal. (in Press) (2000). Zaera, F.; French, C. R., Journal of the American Chemical Society 121, 2236-2243 (1999); Beebe, T. P., and J. T. Yates, J. Phys. Chem. 91, 54-257. (1987). Cremer, P. S., and G. A. Somorjai, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 91, 3671-3677. (1993). Cremer, P. S., and G.A. Somorjai, J. Chem. Soc. Far. Trans. 91, 3671-3677. (1995). Cremer, P. S., X. Su, Y.R. Shen, and G.A. Somorjai, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 118, 2942-2949. (1996). Cremer, P. S., X. Su, Y. Ron Shen, and G.A. Somorjai, Catal. Lett. 40, 143-145 (1996). Ponec, V., and G. C. Bond Catalysis by Metals and Alloys; Elsevier:, 1995; Vol. 95. Beebe, T. P., and J.T. Yates, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 108, 663 (1986). Davis, R. J., and M. Boudart, Catalytic Science and Technology 1, 129 (1991). Beeck, O., Rev. Mod. Phys. 17, 61 (1945). Takasu, Y., T. Sakuma, and Y. Matsuda, Chem. Lett. 48, 1179 (1985). Tysoe, W., G. Nyberg, and R. Lambert, J. Phys. Chem. 88, 1960 (1984). Stuve, E., and R.J. Madix, J. Phys. Chem. 80, 105-112 (1985).
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 133 G.F. Froment and K.C. Waugh (Editors) Published by Elsevier Science B.V., 2001
41
Development of microkinetic expressions by instationary methods Frerich J. Keil Technical University of Hamburg-Harburg, Chemical Reaction Engineering, Eissendorfer Str. 38, 21073 Hamburg, Germany Transient response experiments are discussed from a point of view of microkinetic modeling. Various theoretical and experimental approaches are presented. I. INTRODUCTION Microkinetic analysis is an examination of catalytic reactions in terms of elementary chemical reactions that occur on the catalytic surface and their relation with each other and with the surface during a catalytic cycle [1 ]. The role of kinetic investigations providing data on the mechanismsand kinetics of catalytic reactions cannot be overestimated. Designing of reactors and optimization of the entire chemical plant rely decisively on kinetic data. Inaccurate kinetic data spoil every reactor design, however elaborate the reactor model may be. A catalyst modifies the rate and/or selectivity of chemical reactions. A particular catalyst under certain operating conditions (temperature, pressure, composition of reactants) is characterized by the rates for different elementary steps in the reaction. The common procedure in industrial applications is to fit measured overall rates to a mathematical model, mostly equations of Langrnuir-Hinshelwood type, by taking data from reactors operating over the parameter range of industrial interest. Although the assumptions made in the LangmuirHinshelwood scheme are in most cases not completely fulfilled, this approach was exceptionally successful (Boudart [2]: Successful application of an inadequate model). Details of this problem are also discussed by Weller [3, 6], Doraiswamy [4] and Corma [5]. The simple fitting to a Langmuir-Hinshelwood (LH) equation hides significant features of reactions. Very different reaction mechanisms may predict the same overall reaction rate, and many mechanistic details cannot be deduced from a fitted LH equation. A reaction with a very simple kinetics can have a very complicated mechanism. Unlike this conventional approach, microkinetic analysis incorporates basic surface chemistry including detailed modeling of the elementary reaction steps. This gives a deeper insight into the important parameters of a catalytic cycle, and indicates possible ways to improve a catalyst. The rates of the elementary reactions and the surface coverages obtained are a consequence of the microkinetic analysis. A crucial point is the inclusion of all essential experimental information into the model. Otherwise the predictions of the model will fail. An extensive experimental program, combined with chemical intuition, initiates microkinetic investigations. The ever expanding toolbox of surface spectroscopy [7-10] can be employed, augmented by the more conventional methods like e.g. BET measurements. Spectroscopic studies probe the composition and morphology of the surface and identify possible reaction intermediates on the catalyst surface. Surface science measurements, preferably under real operating conditions, are an essential tool, as any measurements in the gas phase do not always lead in a unique way to a conclusion of what happens on the catalytic surface [22, 23]. Other input data are heats of adsorption
42 together with thermodynamic data for the gas phase above the catalyst. Unfortunately spectroscopic investigations have to be done quite often under ultrahigh vacuum conditions (pressure gap) on single crystals (material gap), but there are new methods unter development, like "summation frequency spectroscopy", which will overcome these difficulties. Measurements of the rate of catalytic reactions are often executed on single crystal surfaces of well-defined catalyst models [ 11, 12]. There is a close interrelation between experiments and microkinetic modeling [6, 13, 14]. Microkinetic analysis in heterogeneous catalysis originated in the early 1970s from a computer program called KINPAK that was written to predict the performance of an industrial naphta cracker [15]. The program, accepted as input a statement of all the elementary reactions involved. These reactions were given their forward and reverse Arrhenius parameters. The program then constructed a matrix of mass balance equations, comprising all of the components in the reactions, including the surface and the adsorbed species, and solved these equations by the Newton-Raphson algorithm which was modified in order to improve convergence. An application of this approach to the microkinetic analysis of the ammonia synthesis and the copper catalysed forward and reverse shift reaction is given by Waugh [ 14]. Rate constants can be estimated by means of transition-state theory. In principle all thermodynamic data can be deduced from the partion function. The molecular data necessary for the calculation of the partion function can be either obtained from quantum mechanical calculations or spectroscopic data. Many of those data can be found in tables (e.g. JANAF). A very powerful tool to study the kinetics of reactions in heterogeneous catalysis is the dynamic Monte-Carlo approach (DMC), sometimes called kinetic Monte-Carlo (KMC). Starting from a paper by Ziff et al. [ 16], several investigations were executed by this method. Lombardo and Bell [17] review many of these simulations. The solution of the problem of the relation between a Monte-Carlo step and real time has been advanced considerably by Jansen [ 18, 19] and Lukkien et al. [20] (see also Jansen and Lukkien [21 ]). First principle quantum chemical methods have advanced to the stage where they can now offer quantitative predictions of structure and energetics for adsorbates on surfaces. Cluster and periodic density functional quantum chemical methods are used to analyze chemisorption and catalytic surface reactivity [see e.g. 24, 25]. Instationary kinetic methods are an important experimental tool for microkinetic modeling. In the present paper theoretical and experimental approaches of instationary kinetics will be considered. After some general discussions, experimental devices will be described, followed by the presentation of selected results. Instationary catalytic methods were reviewed previously by some authors [26-43]. We will confine the considerations to catalytic gas/solid reactions, where the instationary conditions are generated by forced perturbations. Oscillatory kinetics and spatio-temporal selforganization in reactions at solid surfaces are not reviewed here (see e.g. [44-46]). 2. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS In heterogeneous catalysis the overall reaction consists of a sequence of consecutive steps, such as diffusion, adsorption of reactants and products, surface reaction and desorption of the products. The heterogeneous reactions take place on the catalyst surface where some adsorbed
43 species are present during the reaction. The concentration of the adsorbed species depends on the properties of the adsorbing solid, the operating conditions, such as temperature, pressure and gas phase composition, the reaction mechanism and the chemical potential of each of the reaction intermediates. The properties of the catalyst surface are influenced by the reaction itself, e.g. reordering of the surface may occur. Since the catalyst surface is in its working state not a clean surface, it is inavoidable to examine the properties of the catalyst while the reaction takes place. In the past, the catalyst was considered as a "black box", and only the conditions (composition, pressure, temperature) of the entering reactants and the products at the outlet were measured. But as different reaction mechanisms can result in the same kinetic behavior, additional spectroscopic measurements of the adsorbed species can be inevitable. Evaluating kinetic data only from gas phase measurements is an inverse problem which is, from a mathematical point of view, a so-called ill-posed problem. Some solutions of the appropriate system of differential equations describing the kinetics are invariant with respect to the rearrangements of the specific rates of the steps. This means the inverse problem has a nonunique solution, which also dictates the multiplicity of solutions in the direct problem. The same holds for the case that the spectroscopic measurements are incomplete. This problem was treated e.g. by Asadullin [22, 23]. On the basis of indirect information outside the "black box" reaction mechanisms which take place on the catalytic surface can be discussed merely on conjectural assumptions. This holds also if one takes into account some spectroscopic data by surface science methods which were obtained under ultrahigh vacuum conditions on ideal surfaces. A further problem is that some very reactive intermediates may disappear extremely fast such that they cannot be observed. Isotope techniques can in some cases throw light on certain reaction steps. Therefore, surface science techniques applied under real operating conditions are a challenge for kinetic research. There is already a considerable progress in this direction. Under steady-state conditions all elementary steps in series are progressing at the same rate and hence the measured rates cannot give decisive hints about the reaction mechanism. As is well-known, there are quite otlen several plausible reaction rate models even for rather simple reactions which can be nearly equally well fitted to Langrnuir-Hinshelwood equations. A good fit is meaningless with respect to the real mechanism, it is merely decriptive within the parameter range of the measurements. Transient response methods furnish more detailed information on the true mechanism than do steady-state measurements. The system is perturbed by a sudden or periodic change in temperature, pressure, composition, or flow rate. A well-defined forcing function must be used for the sake of simplicity of the analysis of the response. Possible input signals employed are rectangular step functions, rectangular pulses, ramp functions or sinusoidal oscillations. The dynamic response of a catalytic reactor to a change of the input concentration of one or more reactants is very sensitive to the reaction mechanism. The analysis of the products as a function of time give information on elementary steps of the reactions. Therefore, instationary experiments are a useful tool in microkinetic modeling. The periodic response is more sensitive to the reaction mechanism than the transient response. Especially sinusoidal variations allow a quantitative evaluation of kinetic parameters. For stepwise signals this is in general impossible as a step change stimulates very many frequencies simultaneously, the response frequencies of which cannot be assigned to. Wagner and Hauffe [47] first applied a perturbation method to the study of a reaction between oxygen and adsorbed hydrogen on palladium by measuring electrical conductivity response to the change of oxygen flow. A very early application was the pulse method which
44 was introduced by Kokes et al. [48]. This method has been employed extensively as a microcatalytic technique [49]. In the sixtees models on transport kinetics for the transient response of the chromatographic reactors to a pulse input [50, 51] and adsorption effects on kinetics during transient experiments [52] followed. Bennett [52] suggested to use dynamic experiments to calculate the forward and reverse rate constants of individual steps for a trial multistep mechanism for a heterogeneous catalytic reaction. The experiments consisted of the measurement of the composition of the effluent from a CSTR as a function of time as the input composition to the reactor was perturbed. The method of moments was employed to obtain the kinetic constants for a trial mechanism from the experimental data. Experimental verification of these models for the transient kinetics was provided by Kobayashi and Kobayashi [53]. Quite often for steady-state operation, the usual kinetic expression assumes a single ratedetermining step. This step is a function of conversion and temperature. As was shown by Pekar and Koubek [54] the concept of a rate-determining step is not useful in any case, especially not for instationary operation. Non-stationary behavior turned out to be too complex to be described by the rate-limiting step even for their simple three-step reaction mechanism. This rate, the value of which should be limited by the rate-limiting step, was not precisely definable in the transition state. Both the rates of elementary steps and the rates of formation or consumption of components are generally different to the non-steady state. There are nonstationary experiments where more than one rate limiting step having the same speed was observed. Determining mechanisms of complex chemical reactions and constructing adequate kinetic models of a given process can be performed in the following sequence: - A detailed investigation of the chemistry of reactions is done by employing different suitable methods (GC, MS, spectroscopy, etc.). - A system of hypotheses concerning possible mechanisms of a given complex chemical reaction is formulated. Information obtained from the chemical investigations is taken into consideration. - A suitable experimental setup and feed concentration variations are chosen. The feed variations should enable one to discriminate between the suggested kinetic models. Simulation runs can be helpful for this purpose. - The experimental results, together with a model, are employed to estimate the constants of the kinetic models preselected. The estimates of constants are refined by methods of sequential planning of precise experiments. If necessary, additional chemical investigations are executed in order to come to conclusions about the most probable mechanism. Fishtik and Datta [57, 58] have shown that the fundamental equations of thermodynamics have the property of being decomposed into a linear sum of contributions associated with a unique class of reactions referred to as response reactions. This property can also be used for the discrimination among reaction mechanisms. - The finally obtained kinetic expressions are used for prognoses of reaction products under various operating conditions. The results are compared with experiments. -
One should keep in mind that by using classical kinetics approaches one can obtain unrealistic results. Surface adatoms and adsorbed molecules often show a strong non-ideality in their mixing behavior, which cannot be described by classical kinetics. This holds especially
45 when strong lateral interactions lead to surface island formation. In this case statistical mechanics approaches are appropriate [43, 55, 56]. In the next two paragraphs experimental setups, models and results of instationary kinetic experiments will be presented.
3. EXPERIMENTAL METHODS A broad variety of reactors was in use of transient response experiments. A very simple reactor which was widely employed is the fixed-bed pulse reactor. A typical schematic of a microcatalytic pulse reactor is presented in Figure 1. The reactants are injected into a carrier gas by means of a very fast valve, and the products are continuously analyzed by e.g. a mass spectrometer or FTIR spectrometer. Kokes et al. [48] first introduced this type of reactor. The flow rate of the cartier gas is large enough to avoid separation of reactants and products. The micropulse reactor is useful for a preliminary investigation of a large number of catalysts. If accurate mass balances can be obtained, kinetic parameter estimation is possible. A more sophisticated experimental set-up of a fixed-bed reactor and a analytical section is presented in Figure 2 [66]. An appropriate reactor model for the data evalutation is required. For example Froment [59] and Matros [60] discussed corresponding models. A very detailed model of the effect of intraparticle convection inside large-pore catalyts (e.g. selective oxidation catalyts) on the transient behavior of fixed-bed catalytic reactors was published by Quinta Ferreira [75]. Analysis of the transient response data from fixed-bed reactors is in general more complicated than other reactor types as one has to account for the spatial and temporal dependence of the species concentrations and temperature. Catalytic reaction and chromatographic column can be combined in a gas chromatographic pulse reactor. carrier gas
9
T
I
I Reactor
JMS I
injection o f reactants Fig. 1. Micropulse reactor hood.
hood
~
feed
feed
%
Fig. 2. Fixed-bed transient response reactor set-up [66]
,oH|
46 This reactor was introduced by Bassett and Habgood [61 ]. Examples of applications of this reactor are given by Christoffel [62]; modeling of this type was, for example, reviewed by Villermaux [63] and presented by Mills and Dudukovic [64]. Fixed-bed reactors have some disadvantages, such as deviations from plug flow, heat and mass transfer resistances at the catalyst boundaries, deviations from differential operation, and, owing to these properties, the models are quite complicated systems of partial differential equations. A very detailed description of the numerical solution of partial differential equations in the context of parameter estimation based on transient kinetic data is presented by Van der Linde et al. [76]. Backmixing reactors are a way out of this situation. They have advantages, such as welldefined conditions for gradientless operation, the flow rates are known, very small amounts of catalysts can be tested, and modeling can often be done by ordinary differential equations. Of course, there are also some disadvantages. Perfect backmixing sometimes cannot be achieved, considerable homogeneous reactions may occur, and the design can be far more complicated. For transient operation, quite often external recycle reactors were in use. Backmixing reactors are especially useful for frequency response operation with not a too high frequency. In case of very fast adsorption and/or reaction, the step-pulse operation may not be possible, as the material could be adsorbed or react very fast such that the reactor behaves like a plug flow reactor and not like a backmixing reactor. The relative time scales of adsorption/reaction and recycle flow are important. The well-known Berty- or Carberry-reactors can also be used. Models of CSTR's are given in the reviews [28, 29]. The single-pellet diffusion reactor can be employed for transient experiments. Cannestra et al. [65] give an example. Gas composition was measured at the center of one-dimensional pellets. The standard single-pellet diffusion reactor was modified to allow continuous gas analysis and miniaturized in order to reduce the time constants of gas flow mixing. A rather simple model for data evaluation used by the authors was not able to predict major features of the response measurments at the pellet center but gave qualitatively correct results of the external concentration responses. This demonstrates the necessity of an elaborate modeling of instationary multicomponent diffusion and porous structure for this type of reactor. Over the last decade a special experimental device called "Temporal Analysis of Products" (TAP) was used by several groups. The original paper on the TAP was published by Gleaves et al. [67], and an improved version, TAP-2, was described by Gleaves et al. [73]. A simplified schematic of the TAP-2 system is shown in Figure 3. The system is comprised of (1) a high-through-put, liquid nitrogen-trapped, ultrahigh vacuum system, (2) a microreactoroven assembly with temperature controller, (3) a heatable gas manifold with five input ports containing four pulse valves and one manual bleed valve, (4) a valve Control module for actuating the pulse valves, (5) a gas blending station for preparing reactant mixtures from gases and liquids, (6) a pressure transducer oven, (7) a quadrupole mass spectrometer (QMS), (8) a PC based control and data acquisition system, and a slide valve assembly with heated exhaust line attached to a GC. The core item of this apparatus is the very fast pulsing valve which can introduce a small number of molecules (between 1013 to 1020 molecules) into the microreactor. The pulse widths range from about 100 ~ts to seconds. The microcatalytic fixedbed reactor (length ~ 4 cm, diameter 5 mm) consists of three layers: the catalyst is located between two layers of inert material. A void zone of usually less than 1 cm length remained at the reactor outlet. There is no continuous flow through the microreactor. The only flow of gas is caused by the pulse itself, and such a flow lasts only until the pulse has been evacuated completely. The flow is in the Knudsen regime. The TAP reactor was modelled by Zou and
47 Dudukovic [70, 71], Rothaemel and Baerns [72], Gleaves et al. [73], Soick et al. [74] and others. Quinta Ferreira et al. [75] discussed the influence of convective flow in large pores. Van der Linde et al. [76] present a detailed method of solution of the system of partial differential equations which model the TP reactor. Shekhtman et al. [69] developed a model of a so-called "thin-zone reactor" in which the concentration gradients across the short catalyst bed can be neglected, and diffusion and reaction can be separated. A very general model was presented by Garayhi and Keil [112-115] which comprises the TAP reactor as a special case, and which considers also multicomponent diffusion within the pores as well as the possibility to include arbitrarily complicated systems of reaction equations. Mass flow c o n t r o l l e r _ _ ~ ~
~
~ , ~
Gas feed l i n e s - ~
Stirred ~ ~~'~~ blend tank Gas Blending Station and Continuous Feed System
Pressure Transducer
~176
II ."
Manual leak [ valve
Pulse valve
Microreactor ~ ~ " " ~ a s s e m b l y ~ Exhaust line -"I
Mass Spectrometer Controller
Slide ~ valve / Mass spectrometer Gate va_._
q
~ature]
~]~
J
Computer Control and Data Acquisition System
Liquid nitrogen trap Adjustable water cooled baffle
-,,Jx/x/xt~
x / v x / x t x v v , J , . l , , J , o ~ / , . / .
/
<<<<((<<<(( Nil
111
n
To 10 inch oil diffusion pump
Fig. 3. TAP-2 reactor [68]
dontroller
[ I [
48 4. EXAMPLES In this paragraph a selection of some examples of kinetic transient experiments will be presented. Of course, these are very many papers on this subject. Therefore, a limited choice had to be made. Many other important results may be found e.g. in the reviews mentioned above. For several years Renken has been a contributor to the literature on transient processes, especially with respect to modeling [34, 35, 38, 77-91]. The early work of this group was reviewed in ref. [34, 35]. Thullie and Renken [81] investigated two basis models proposed in the literature for reactions with a so-called stop-effect. Koubek et al. [92] reported an unusual behavior of the catalytic dehydration of alcohols and deamination of amines on aluminium oxide catalysts. After having switched off the feed of reactants into the reactor, a steep increase of the reaction rate was observed (see Fig. 4). This stop-effect was explained by two models. The first model assumes that the reactant adsorbs strongly on acid sites but also on adjacent basic sites (see Fig. 5). For the deamination, however, a free basic site is required where the adjacent hydrogen adsorbs. In case of a too high reactant concentration, all basic sites are occupied and, as a consequence, the reaction stops. This type of model was analyzed by Nowobilski and Takoudis [93]. The second model takes into account only one kind of active site and was used by Koubek et al. [92]. This model corresponds to substrate inhibition in enzyme kinetics. It is important to note that sometimes the dynamic behavior of the models after a stop in the supply of the reactant is very similar. Thullie and Renken [91] proved that a simple transient behavior after a stop in the supply of the reactant is a valuable descriminating tool for two cases: (i) several sets of kinetic parameters for one model, and (ii) two models with different sets of kinetic parameters. One can obtain different results for each parameter set. The difference in the reaction rate was profound when the equilibrium constants of the second step differed widely. I~
Inert gas (N,)
100o
/ ~ 5o
N 9
9
S1
C---C
\
/ H
N---R
H 9
9 ~ o
9
9o
e ~
^~
I
"0
3000
Fig. 4. Stop effect [92]
Time [s]
6000 Fig. 5. Two-center mechanism [92]
49 In a series of papers Marwood et al. [82-86] investigated the kinetics of CO2 methanation. In a first paper [83], transient experiments were applied to the study of the adsorbed CO intermediate, (CO)a, formed during the CO2 methanation reaction on a Rn/TiO2 catalyst at 383 K. Step-up experiments showed that the (CO)a hydrogenation was not influenced by the partial pressure of water. Based on the fact that water inhibits the overall CO2 methanation, it was deduced that the rate limiting process in the overall reaction is (CO)a formation. Step-up and step-down transient experiments were performed where the feed composition was changed from an inital to a final feed composition. IR spectra were obtained by means of a DRIFT cell. In a further paper [84] periodic operation was applied to the CO2 methanation reaction on Rn/TiO2. A continuious feed recycle reactor combined with a diffuse reflectance infrared cell and a mass spectrometer allowed to follow simultaneously the gas phase CO2 and CH4 as well as the adsorbed species (CO)~ and (formate)a. The experiments consisted of periodic variations of CO2 in the hydrogen feed and showed response curves with maxima/ minima shit~ed in time in the sequence CO2, (formate)a --~ (CO)a --~ CH4. Similar delays measured for the (CO)~ formation and hydrogeneation indicate that both of these processes are limiting the overall reaction rate. A kinetic model was proposed and verified under periodic conditions. The main experimental trends, which were pronounced time lags between CO2, (CO)a and CH4, could be described satisfactorily. The authors concluded that the overall reaction is not limited by a unique limiting step but rather by two steps of equivalent speed. Similar conclusions were published in a paper by Marwood et al. [86]. The authors refined the mechanism of carbon dioxide methanation by using diffuse reflectance infrared spectroscopy and mass spectrometry [88]. The coupled information of the surface intermediates and the gas phase components time evolution led to accurate identification of spectator species on the surface. Reaction intermediates, CO and formates have been identified. The former is a key intermediate, and its hydrogenation led to methane formation. The latter was found to be fixed on the support, in equilibrium with an active formate species on the interface metal-support. The authors proposed a reaction mechanism including the formation step of the formates through a carbonate species. Randall et al. [87] studied the oxidation of CO on silica-supported hematite (Fe203) by a step-response method in a tubular fixed-bed reactor. The oxidation process appeared to proceed through two stages. Randall et al. [90] investigated also the reduction of NO and NO2 by CO over a silica-supported iron oxide catalyst by a step-response analysis. A completely reduced catalyst (Fe304) and an oxidized state (Fe203) were employed. From the material balance on the gas phase species it was shown that the composition of the catalyst changes during relaxation to steady-state. During the transient period, CO was shown to inhibit N20 as well as NO reductions by adsorption on reduced sites. The activity of the reduced catalyst was found to be substantially higher as compared to the oxidised catalyst for both reactions. By keeping the catalyst in a reduced state, a significant increase in the performance of the reactor with respect to steady-state operation could be achieved for N20 reduction by CO. Golay et al. [89, 91] investigated the dynamic behavior of ethanol adsorption on 3t-alumina by the transient-response (stop-effect) method coupled with FT-IR data of the catalyst surface. The existance of three adsorbates was demonstrated: a reacting species which is the precursor for the formation of the gas-phase ethene; an inhibiting species responsible for the low steadystate reaction rate; and a spectator species accumulation on the catalyst surface. The surface concentration of the reacting species was determined on the basis of the transient ethene response. The surface concentration of the spectator species was determined by ex-situ thermogravimetric experiments. The stop-effect could be utilized to enhance the reactor
50 performance under forced cycling of the inlet feed for the ethanol to ethene dehydration over qt-alumina. The two-sites model mentioned above was able to predict qualitatively the influence of all the cycle parameters. Hofmann and coworkers [94-103] introduced the so-called wave-front analysis. It is an enlargement of known relaxation methods in the sense that it considers in addition to the transition of the disturbed system from the initial to the final state, the relaxation in space of the propagating primary disturbance. Actually, the wavefront analysis is limited to the relaxation processes at the wavefront and the propagation link of the disturbance in the space/time coordinate plane. It supplies an additional degree of freedom compared to a stationary analysis. The authors define as space relaxation the amplitude change of the propagating disturbance, and as time relaxation the rest of the transient response after passage of the wavefront, i.e. the transient originated by the propagated primary disturbance. While the wavefront more or less keeps its identity when flowing through, its amplitude will change because of the exchange with the stagnant phase (space relaxation). As the heat capacity of the catalytic packed-bed reactor is larger than its mass capacity, a temperature wave caused by the heat of reaction or by a change of temperature at the inlet will run through the system more slowly than a concentration wave. The peculiarity of the wave front analysis is in fact based on restricting the analysis of the transition function on the "isothermal" part of the concentration wave. The advantage of this is that the data evaluation can be carried out without the heat balance. The elements of the analysis are: (i) The propagation speed of the disturbance, controlled by capacitive effects in the phases (i.e. chromatographic effects); (ii) the space relaxation of the disturbance, representing a measure of the initial rate (i.e. initial relaxation); (iii) the time gradient of the time relaxation at the front of the disturbance, representing a measure of the initial rate acceleration (i.e. acceleration of the initial relaxation). The advantage of this method is a splitting of the information content of the transient response in pure accumulative and kinetic parts, and in addition initial rate and initial acceleration are directly measurable in dependence on well-defined initial states of temperature and catalyst activities. For practical applications, it is important that the time relaxation is slower than the change on what is practically defined as a "wavefront", which means slower than the space relaxation of the front of the disturbance. The experimental plant should generate a concentration step as sharp as possible and the continuous registration of the response at the exit of the system are indispensible for a succesful performance of a wave-front analysis. The method was applied to various investigations, such as carbon monoxide conversion with steam at an industrial copper-zinc catalyst under atmospheric pressure. The problem whether the periodical operation of a technical reactor with input concentrations which change periodically provides higher selectivities and yields than stationary operating was examined with the example of benzene oxidation into malein anhydride [103]. A rather complex example was the oxide-hydrogenation of isobutyric aldehyde to methacrolein [ 100]. Based on dynamic experiments a reaction scheme is proposed and estimation of kinetic parameters of the main reaction using an Eley-Rideal type rate equation was carried out. The examples revealed that the wave-front analysis provides valuable qualitative and quantitative kinetic information of heterogeneous catalytic reactions.
51 Although frequency response (FR) techniques are in widespread use for the measurement of diffusion coefficients and sorption in zeolites, only a very few applications of this method to heterogeneous catalysis under reactive conditions were published yet [104-115]. The FR technique was originally introduced by Naphtali and Polinski [ 116]. Since a resonance of the system to a well-defined artifical oscillation is observed in the FR method, a fine difference in the time response data can clearly be detected and the kinetic constants derived are necessarily independent of the amount of adsorbent. Yasuda [ 105] varied sinusoidally the gas space of a continuous flow reactor, and every partial pressure variation induced was followed by a mass spectrometer. In subsequent papers [106-108] Yasuda developed the FR method to study kinetic details of a reactive gas/solid system and applied the method to methanol conversion to olefins. As many as thirty rate constants were determined. A second example was the hydrogenation reaction of propylene. Over the last few years Yasuda [109,110] published papers in which a novel kinetic model for heterogeneous catalysis was introduced, based on the flow of free energy (instead of ordinary mass flow), the chemical kinetic model is valid to interpret a reaction rate spectrum obtainable by a frequency response technique. The characteristic function to analyze the spectrum derived from the kinetic differential equations contains complex rate constants, (k + i co 1)'s; k denotes the ordinary rate constant at an elementary step, 1 is the novel rate constant due to the free energy dissipation, and co is the angular frequency scanned in the FR technique. In the FR method, the gas space V of a gas/surface system reacting at a steady-state was perturbed sinusoidally. The approach could be confirmed by actual data obtained in a catalytic hydrogenation of propene over Pt and/or Rh metals on the basis of a three-stage model: X(g) r Ax(a) r Bx(a) ~ Products (s), where X(g) represents propen or hydrogen molecules in the gas phase; Ax(a) and Bx(a) are the intermediates on the catalysts. A cell reactor composed of a proton conducting membrane was adopted. Hydrogen and propene were separated by the membrane in order to investigate separately various rate processes due to either hydrogen or propene. Yasuha [117] reviews frequency response methods. Schrieffer and Sinfelt [104] described an FR analysis of a formal two-step catalytic sequence in which an adsorption-desorption step is followed by a reaction step. Cavers et al. [111] applied FR techniques to determine the dynamics of gas surface interactions of propane adsorption on silicalite and CO oxidation on Rh/A1203. For this case also in situ IR spectra were measured. Garayhi and Keil [112-115] developed a very detailed heterogeneous model of catalysts and reactors which comprises many instationary reactors, such as the TAP reactor. The concentration profiles within the pellets were calculated by the dusty-gas model. Adsorption and desorption phenomena were considered as chemical reactions. All the elementary steps of the reactions can be taken into account. Detailed investigations on the response on different FR inputs were investigated theoretically and experimentally. There are numerous publications of results obtained from TAP experiments. Here only a few will be mentioned. Hinz and Andersson [118] studied the mechanism of propane ammonoxidation on an A1-Ab-V-W-oxide catalyst using a TAP-2 reactor system. The investigations gave a very detailed insight into the reaction mechanism. In a further paper Hinz et al. [119] investigated the propene oxidation over an oxide catalyst with the participation of lattice oxygen. Soick et al. [120] measured particular reaction steps of the
52 partial oxidation of methane to synthesis gas over P t ~ g O , i.e. methane dissociation, CO2 adsorption and CO adsorption and oxidation. Soick et al. [ 121 ] introduced also a TAP reactor model for complex reactions, and applied it to the oxidative conversion of methane to syngas. Gerlach and Baerns employed the TAP reactor to study the mechanism of the reduction of NO2 to N2 by C3H6 over an acidic H-mordenite catalyst. In some cases the so-called "Steady-State Isotopic Transient Kinetic Analysis" (SSITKA) was used for detailed investigations of reaction mechanisms. Shannon and Goodman [123] present an extensive review of this subject. Hinrichsen et al. [124] employed temperature programmed desorption to study the ammonia synthesis on ruthenium catalysts. 5. CONCLUSION Transient methods proved to be a useful tool in microkinetic analysis. Of course, owing to the rather indirect measurements in the gas phase, one has to augment the investigations by surface science approaches, in order to obtain reliable results. As yet, in many cases ad hoe assumptions about the details of the reaction mechanism had to be introduced. REFERENCES
1. J.A. Dumesic, A.A. Trevino, B.A. Milligan, L.A. Greppi, V.R. Balse, K.T. Samo.wski, C.E. Beall, T. Kataoka and D.F. Rudd, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 26 (1987) 1399. 2. M. Boudart, AIChE J., 2 (1956) 62. 3. S. Weller, AIChE J., 2 (1956) 59. 4. L.K. Doraiswamy, Prog. Surf. Sci., 37 (1991) 1. 5. A. Corma, F. Liapsis, J.B. Monton and S. Weller, Chem. Eng. Sci., 43 (1988) 785. 6. S.W. Weller, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng., 34 (1992) 227. 7. D.P. Woodruff and T.A. Delchar, Modem Techniques of Surface Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2 nd Ed.), 1994. 8. J.W. Niemantsverdriet, Spectroscopy in Catalysis, VCH, Weinheim, 1995. 9. R.W. Joyner and R.A. van Santen (Eds.), Elementary Reaction Steps in Heterogeneous Catalysis, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1993. 10. G.A. Somorjai, Introduction to Surface Chemistry and Catalysis, John Wiley, New York, 1994. 11. D.W. Goodman, Surf. Sci., 299/230 (1994) 837. 12.P.L.J. Gunter, J.W. Niemantsverdriet, F.H. Ribeiro and G.A. Somorjai, Cat. Rev.-Sci. Eng., 39 (1997) 77. 13. P. Stoltze, Prog. Surf. Sci., 65 (2000) 65. 14. K.C. Waugh, Catal. Today, 53 (1999) 161. 15. S.F. Bush and P. Dyer, Proc. R. Soc. London, A351 (1976) 33. 16. R.M. Ziff, E. Gulari and Y. Barshad, Phys. Rev. Lett., 56 (1986) 2553. 17. S.J. Lombardo and A.T. Bell, Surf. Sci. Rep., 13 (1991) 1. 18. A.P.J. Jansen, Comput. Phys. Comm., 86 (1995) 1. 19. A.P.J. Jansen, J. Molecu. Catal. A, 119 (1997) 125. 20. J.J. Lukkien, J.P.L. Segers, P.A.J. Hilbers, R.J. Gelten and A.P.J. Jansen, Phys. Rev. E, 58 (1998) 2598. 21. A.P.J. Jansen and J.J. Lukkien, Catal. Today, 53 (1999) 259. 22. R.M. Asadullin, Theoret. Found. Chem. Eng., 32 (1998) 136.
53 23. S.I. Spivak and R.M.Asadullin, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 109 (1997) 577. 24. R.A. van Santen, Theoretical Heterogeneous Catalysis, World Scientific, Singapore, 1991. 25. M.Neurock, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 109 (1997) 3. 26. H.M. Hulburt and Y.G. Kim, Ind. Eng. Chem., 58 (1966) 20. 27. G. Paravano, Cat. Rev. Sci. Eng., 3 (1969) 207. 28.H. Kobayashi and M. Kobayashi, Cat. Rev. Sci. Eng., 10 (1974) 139. 29. C.O. Bennett, Cat. Rev. Sci. Eng., 13 (1976) 121. 30. T. Furusawa, M. Suzuki and J.M. Smith, Cat. Rev. Sci. Eng., 13 (1976) 43. 31.P. Biloen, J. Mol. Cat. 21 (1983) 17. 32. K. Tamaru in: J.R. Anderson and M. Boudart (Eds.) Catalysis - Science and Technology, Vol. 9, Springer Verlag, 1991, p. 87. 33. K. Tamaru, Dynamic Heterogeneous Catalysis, Academic Press, New York, 1978. 34. A. Renken, R. Doepper and M. Schmid, Dechema Monographs, Vol. 120, VCH Verlagsgesellschatt, Weinheim, 1989, p. 273. 35.A. Renken, Chem.-Ing.-Techn., 62 (1990) 724. 36. J.L. Falconer and J.A. Schwarz, Cat. Rev. Sci. Eng., 25 (1983) 141. 37.J. Happel, Catal. Rev., 6 (1972) 221. 38.R. Doepper and A. Renken, Chemia, 50 (1996) 61. 39. H. Hofmann, Dechema Monographs, Vol. 120, VCH Verlagsgesellschaft, Weinheim, 1989, p. 31 40. R.J. Cvetanovic and Y. Amenomiya, Catal. Rev., 6 (1972) 21. 41. P.L. Mills and J.J. Lerou, Rev. Chem. Eng., 9 (1993) 1. 42. A. Garayhi and F.J. Keil, Chem. Technik (Leipzig), 52 (2000) 80. 43. F.J. Keil, Diffusion und chemische Reaktionen in der Gas/Feststoff-Katalyse, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg, 1999. 44. M.M. Slinq(o and N. Jaeger, Oscillating Heterogeneous Catalytic Systems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994. 45.F. Schtith, B.E. Henry and L.D. Schmidt, Adv. Catal., 39 (1993) 51. 46. R. Imbihl and G. Ertl, Chem. Rev., 95 (1995) 697. 47. C. Wagner and K. Hauffe, Z. Elektrochem., 45 (1939) 409. 48. R.J. Kokes, H. Tobin and P.H. Emmett, J. Amer. Chem. Sot., 77 (1955) 5860. 49. R. Mezahi and J. Happel, Catal. Rev., 3 (1970) 241 50. M. Kubin, Coll. Czech. Chem. Commun., 30 (1965) 1104. 51.E. Kucera, J. Chromatog., 19 (1965) 237. 52. C.O. Bennett, AIChE J., 13 (1967) 890. 53. M.Kobayashi and H. Kobayashi, J. Catal., 27 (1972) 100. 54.M. Pekar and J. Koubek, Chem. Eng. Sci., 52 (1997) 2291. 55. R.J. Gelten, R.A. van Santen and A.P.J. Jansen, in: P.B. Balbuena, J.M. Seminario, Molecular Dynamics: From classical to Quantum methods, Theoretical & Comput. Chemistry, Vol. 7, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1999. 56. A.S. McLeod and L.F. Gladden, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 122 (1999) 65. 57. I. Fishtik and R.Datta, J.Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 92 (1996) 3625. 58. I. Fishtik and R. Datta, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 122 (1999) 275. 59. G.F. Froment in: Y.S. Matros (Ed.), Unsteady State Processes in Catalysis, VSP BV, Utrecht, 1990, p. 57. 60. Y.S. Matros, Unsteady State Processes in Catalysis, VSP BV, Utrecht, 1990. 61. D.W. Bassett and H.W. Habgood, J. Phys. Chem., 64 (1960) 769.
54 62. E.G. Christoffel, Laboratory Studies of Heterogeneous Catalytic Processes, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989. 63. J. Villermaux, in: A.E. Rodriguez and D. Tondeur (Eds.), Percolation Processes: Theory and Application, Sijthoff and Noordhoff, Rijn, 1981, p. 83. 64. P.L. Mills and M.P. Dudukovic, Comput. Chem. Eng. 13 (1989) 881. 65. A.F. Cannestra, L.C. Nett and R.K. Herz, J. Catal., 172 (1997) 346. 66. H. Randall, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Can. J. Chem. Eng., 74 (1996) 586. 67. J.T. Gleaves, J.R. Ebner and T.C.Kueckler, Cat. Rev. Sci. Eng., 30 (1988) 49. 68. Y. Schuurmann and J.T. Gleaves, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 33 (1994) 2935. 69. S.O. Shekhtman, G.S. Yablonsky, S. Chen and J.T. Gleaves, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999) 4371. 70.B. Zou, M. Dudukovic and P.L. Mills, J. Catal., 145 (1994) 683. 71. B. Zou, M. Dudukovic and P.L. Mills, Chem. Eng. Sci., 48 (1993) 2345. 72. M. Rothaemel and M. Baems, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 35 (1996) 1556. 73. J.T. Gleaves, G.S. Yablonsky, P. Phanawadee, Appl. Catal. A., 160 (1997) 55. 74. M. Soick, D. Wolf and M. Baems, Chem. Eng. Sci., 55 (2000) 2875. 75. R.M. Quinta Ferreira, C.A. Almeida-Costa and A.E. Rodrigues, Computers Chem. Eng. 20 (1996) 1201. 76. S.C. van der Linde, T.A. Nijhuis, F.H.M. Dekker, F. Kapteijn and J.A. Moulin, Appl. Catal. A., 151 (1997) 27. 77. A. Renken, Int. Chem. Eng., 24 (1984) 202. 78.B. Walker and A. Renken, Chem.-Ing.-Techn. 55 (1983)806. 79. M. Dettmer and A. Renken, Ger. Chem. Eng. 6 (1983) 356. 80. M.A. Truffer and A. Renken, AIChE J. 32 (1986) 1612. 81.J. Thullie and A. Renken, Chem. Eng. Sci., 48 (1993) 3921. 82. M. Marwood, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Chem.-Ing.-Techn., 66 (1994) 971. 83. M. Marwood, R. Doepper, M. Prairie and A. Renken, Chem. Eng. Sci., 49 (1994) 4801. 84.M. Marwood, F. van Vijve, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Cat. Today, 20 (1994) 437. 85. S.H. Randall, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Can. J. Chem. Eng., 74 (1996) 586. 86. M. Marwood, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Can. J. Chem. Eng., 74 (1996) 660. 87. H. Randall, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 36(1997) 2996. 88. M. Marwood, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Appl. Catal. A, 151 (1997) 223. 89. S. Golay, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Appl. Catal. A, 172 (1998) 97. 90.H. Randall, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Appl. Catal. B, 17 (1998) 357. 91. S.Golay, R. Doepper and A. Renken, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999) 4469. 92. J.Koubek, J. Pasek and V. Ruzicka in: Proceedings of the 7th International Congress on Catalysis, Tokyo (1980), Vol. 7B, p. 853. 93. P.J. Nowobilski and Ch. G. Takoudis, Chem. Eng. Commun., 40 (1986) 249. 94. E. Fiolitakis and H. Hofmann, Catal. Rev. Sci. Eng., 34 (1979) 677. 95. E. Fiolitakis and H. Hofmann, Catal. Rev. Sci. Eng., 24 (1982) 113. 96. E. Fiolitakis, U. Hoffmann and H. Hofmann, Chem. Eng. Sci., 35 (1980) 1021. 97. E. Fiolitakis and H. Hofmann, Chem.-Ing.-Tech., 51 (1979) 800. 98. E. Fiolitakis and H. Hofmann, J. Catal., 80 (1983) 328. 99. E. Miiller and H. Hofmann, Chem. Eng. Sci., 42 (1986) 1695. 100. E. Miiller and H. Hofmann, Chem. Eng. Sci., 42 (1986) 1705. 101. E. Miiller and H. Hofrnann, Chem.-Ing.-Tech., 58 (1986) 986. 102. E. Miiller and H. Hofmann, Chem.-ing.-Tech., 59 (1987) 956.
55 103. E. Fiolitakis, H. Schmidt, H. Hofmann and P.L. Silveston, Can. J. Chem. Eng., 61 (1983) 703. 104. J.R. Schrieffer and Sinfelt, J. Phys. Chem., 95 (1990) 1047. 105. Y. Yasuda, J. Phys. Chem., 93 (1989) 7185. 106. Y. Yasuda, J. Phys. Chem., 97 (1993) 3314. 107. Y. Yasuda and K. Namura, J. Phys. Chem., 97 (1993) 3319. 108. Y. Yasuda, K. Iwai and K. Takahura, J. Phys. Chem., 99 (1995) 17852. 109. Y. Yasuda and Y. Kuno, Ji Phys. Chem. A, 102 (1998) 4878. 110. Y. Yasuda and Y. Kuno, J. Phys. Chem. B, 103 (1999) 3916. 111. M Cavers, J.M. Davidson, I.R. Harkness, G.S. MacDougall and L.V.C. Rees, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 122 (1999) 65. 112. A. Garayhi and F.J. Keil, Chem.-Ing.-Tech., 71 (1999) 230. 113. A. Garayhi, Characterization of heterogeneous catalytic reactions by dynamic methods, Ph. D. thesis, Technische Universit~it Hamburg-Harburg, 2000. 114. A. Garayhi and F.J. Keil, Chem. Eng. Sci. (in press). 115. A. Garayhi and F.J. Keil (submitted). 116. L.M. Naphtali and L.M. Polinski, J. Phys. Chem., 67 (1963) 369. 117. Y. Yasuda, Heterogeneous Chem. Rev. 1 (1994) 103. 118. A. Hinz and A. Andersson, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999) 4407. 119. A. Hinz, B. Nilsson and A. Andersson, Chem. Eng. Sci., 55 (2000) 4385. 120. M. Soick, O. Buyevskaya, M. H6henberger and D. Wolf, Catal. Today, 32 (1996) 163. 121. M. Soick, D. Wolf and M. Baerns, Chem. Eng. Sci., 55 (2000) 2875. 122. T. Gerlach and M. Baems, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999) 4379. 123. S.L. Shannon and J.G. Goodwin, Chem. Rev., 95 (1995) 677. 124. O. Hinrichsen, F. Rosowski, M. Muhler and G. Ertl, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 109 (1997) 389.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studiesin SurfaceScienceandCatalysis133 G.F.FromentandK.C.Waugh(Editors) Publishedby ElsevierScienceB.V.,2001
Self Sustained Oscillations Oxidation of Methanol
57
over Copper
in the Catalytic
I. B6ttger, B. Pettinger, Th. Schedel-Niedrig, A. Knop-Gericke a n d R. SchlSgl Fritz-Haber-Institut der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, F a r a d a y w e g 4-6, 14195 Berlin, G e r m a n y Pre-treated polycrystalline copper foil catalysts show rate oscillations u n d e r conditions of the partial m e t h a n o l oxidation over a wide range of the m e t h a n o l to 02 flow a n d t e m p e r a t u r e p a r a m e t e r s . The gas p h a s e composition was monitored by m e a n s of a calibrated m a s s s p e c t r o m e t e r t h a t was coupled with in situ R a m a n s p e c t r o m e t r y a n d video recordings. The gas p h a s e oscillations are partly linked with visible oscillations of the copper oxidation state of the surface, d e p e n d i n g on the o~ygen to m e t h a n o l ratio a n d the t e m p e r a t u r e . It will be s h o w n t h a t the catalyst b u l k is directly involved in the catalytic oscillation process due to the d e p e n d e n c e on the composition a n d the thermal conductivity of the gas phase. We observed oscillations with different b e h a v i o u r a n d a s s u m e different reaction p a t h w a y s a n d hence chemical origins for the d y n a m i c behaviour.
1 .Introduction
Copper is in its c o m p o u n d s with oxygen an efficient catalyst for the partial oxidation of alcohols to aldehydes. In m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n - m i x t u r e s copper catalyses efficiently the partial oxidation of m e t h a n o l to formaldehyde at a t m o s p h e r i c p r e s s u r e in the t e m p e r a t u r e range of a b o u t 600 - 770 K. The m o s t i m p o r t a n t reaction c h a n n e l s are: (i) CH3OH > CH20 + H2 ARH~ +84 k J / m o l (dehydrogenation) > CH20 + H 2 0 A R H ~ = -159 k J / m o l (2) CH3OH + Y2 02 (oxidehydrogenation) (3) CH3OH + 3/2 02 > CO2 + 2 H20 ARH~ = -674 k J / m o l (total oxidation I) (4) CH20 + 02 > C02 + H20 ARH~ = -519 k J / m o l (total oxidation II) The reactions 1 a n d 2 lead to the desired partial oxidation p r o d u c t formaldehyde, w h e r e a s the total oxidation reactions p a t h w a y s 3 a n d 4 yield the m a i n b y - p r o d u c t s C02 a n d H20. The total oxidation is of specific relevance for the entire reaction s y s t e m due to the h e a t evolved from this highly exothermic reaction.
58
In the surface science based studies on the methanol oxidation over single crystalline Cu(110), Wachs and Madix [1, 2] have shown that the active state of the copper surface for the methanol oxidation was a partially oxidized copper surface exhibiting nucleophilic oxygen ad-atoms. The oxygen activated the surface for methanol adsorption and removed hydrogen released b y water formation on the surface via a low-energy reaction pathway. From investigations of the active phase of a bulk metalliC copper catalyst u n d e r reaction conditions of the partial methanol oxidation by m e a n s of in situ XAS at the oxygen K-edge and copper L2-,L3-edges it was concluded that the partial oxidation of methanol to formaldehyde is catalysed by a copper plus oxygen phase where oxygen atoms probe defects of the copper lattice, which represent the catalytically active sites [3, 4, 6]. Self-organised, periodic p h e n o m e n a have been found in several heterogeneous catalytic systems [7]. Such systems exist in a state far from thermodynamic equilibrium and exhibit at constant adjusted parameters of temperature, pressure and feed gas flow self-sustaining catalytic oscillations. Oscillations in the methanol-oxygen-copper-system were observed for the first time by H. Werner et al. [8]. They observed with stoichiometric methanol/oxygen mixtures (2:1) over Cu chips in a tube reactor at 660 K rate oscillations with a cycle duration of ca. 3.5 min. Characteristic were sharp maxima (several seconds) of the methanol conversion leading to maxima in the formaldehyde and the CO2 productions, followed by a decline of the methanol conversion and the CO2 partial pressure whilst the formaldehyde partial pressure showed a slow decrease to the next period. Oscillations were also found in other reactions, catalysed by copper or copper oxides, e. g. town gas combustion over supported Cu [9]; selective oxidation of propene to acrolein over Cu oxides [10, 11]; hydrogenation of PhNO2 (supported Cu [12]) and CO oxidation, catalysed by supported CuO [131. It is the purpose of the present work to investigate copper surfaces with regard to t h e self-organised periodic phenomena in methanol oxidation and to corresponding near surface and bulk properties. Therefore, oxygen/methanol pre-treated copper is studied u n d e r the conditions of methanol oxidation at atmospheric pressure in situ with m a s s spectrometry (MS), Raman spectrometry and visual video records in order to couple the oscillating variations of the catalytic conversion with macroscopic catalyst (near-) surface and bulk properties. The near surface related electronic structure of a model catalyst is studied by using core-level (XPS) and valence band (UPS) photoemission spectroscopy u n d e r clean UHV conditions in order to characterise the oxygen segregation process and copper sub-oxide formation. Both the photoemission study in this work and the EXAFS investigation [5] point to the importance of the participation of copper bulk oxygen species in the formation of the catalytic active surface. Such a participation was predicted from Werner et al. [8] and verified for the silver catalyst [14, 15] also active in the partial oxidation of methanol.
59
2.Experimental E x p e r i m e n t s with a copper (111) single crystal, cleaned by s t a n d a r d p r o c e d u r e s at T = 573 K in UHV were carried out in a modified Leybold LHS 12 MCD s y s t e m equipped with facilities for XPS, UPS a n d ISS. The base p r e s s u r e in the a n a l y s e r c h a m b e r was 1 x 10 -10 mbar. 120 W of Mg K non m o n o c h r o m a t i s e d radiation (1253.6 eV) a n d a fixed a n a l y s e r p a s s energy of 108 eV c o r r e s p o n d i n g to a resolution of 1.0 eV were u s e d to obtain XPS data. HeI s p e c t r a were a c q u i r e d u s i n g a n a l y s e r p a s s energy of 6 eV. Surface compositions were calculated from O i s a n d Cu 2p p e a k a r e a s after s u b t r a c t i o n of a Shirley-type b a c k g r o u n d u s i n g the cross sections from Ref. [16]. The Cu(111) s a m p l e was pre-oxidised with p u r e oxygen (Linde, purity: 99.9999 %) (30 min, T = 623 K, po2 = 1 mbar). Thereafter, the oxidised sample was step by step treated with m e t h a n o l (up to 2 5 0 0 0 0 L, at a p r e s s u r e of 1" 10 -4 m b a r , Merck, purity: 99.9 %, "for spectroscopy") a n d finally s p u t t e r e d by He + ions In situ m a s s s p e c t r o m e t r y investigations of the c o p p e r / o x y g e n / m e t h a n o l s y s t e m d u r i n g rate oscillations were carried o u t u s i n g as catalyst a polycrystalline copper foil (Goodfellow, purity: 99,99 %, surface size: 67 m m 2, thickness: 0.1 mm). To clean the fresh Cu s a m p l e s they were cyclical treated at high t e m p e r a t u r e s (720 - 770 K) with 02 a n d H2 prior the m e t h a n o l / o x y g e n t r e a t m e n t . The e x p e r i m e n t s were c o n d u c t e d in a microreactor equipped with a calibrated q u a d r u p o l e m a s s s p e c t r o m e t e r (Balzers QMS 200) coupled to the reactor outlet via a capillary (RESTEK Silicosteel i m p r e g n a t e d , i n n e r diameter: 0.25 m m , length: 2 m). The working p r e s s u r e in the reactor was 1 bar. The t e m p e r a t u r e of the sample (copper foil) was held c o n s t a n t l y by a n electronic t e m p e r a t u r e controller (the thermo couple was s i t u a t e d between the sample a n d a ceramic h e a t plate). The feed gases were supplied by Linde a n d h a d the following purities: 02, 99.995 %; He: 99.9999 %. Helium w a s s a t u r a t e d with m e t h a n o l (purity: 99.9 %, Merck, "for spectroscopy").The well mixed feed gases were a d m i t t e d t h r o u g h t h e r m a l m a s s flow controllers in the reactor. In situ R a m a n s p e c t r a of the copper s a m p l e were recorded d u r i n g reaction by a R a m a n s p e c t r o m e t e r from Dilor (Labram II). The s p e c t r o m e t e r integrated He-Ne laser was u s e d to obtain excitation radiation employing a laser power of 25 mW. The laser light was focussed to the sample t h r o u g h the q u a r t z window of the reactor by u s i n g a microscope. Video records were t a k e n from the sample with a CCD PAL colour video c a m e r a (SONY XC-999P).
60
Cu(111)
He/difference spectra
/
:
.,."\
E-D
3. R e s u l t s
.
3.1. S u r f a c e
'.....
The pre-oxidation of the Cu(111) sample resulted according to XPS analysis in a mixture of C u O / C u 2 0 . The total methanol treatment shifted the stoichiometry from Cui.20 to Cu3.20. The stoichiometry changed strongly for 0 L to 15000 L (1L= l x 1 0 -6 m b a r applied for ls) m e t h a n o l exposures (Cui.20 to
"'"
L ,+++6" % ="
j
............... Cu20-Reference'..... f ....... CuO-Reference "'"
. . . . 8
t
+
Fit Sum (Cu- + Cu20- + CuO-Ref.) 6 4 2 Binding Energy / e V
analysis
0
FIG. 1. The UPSHel-difference spectra of the methanol t r e a t m e n t of a preoxidised Cu(111) sample r e p r e s e n t the c h a n g e s of the sample of every methanol treatment step. C h a n g e s of the single p h a s e s of copper a n d copper oxides are revealed by the fits with linear c o m b i n a t i o n s of Cu, C u 2 0 a n d CuO. The CuO spectrum also served as model for the novel sub-oxide (see text).
Cu2.20). Whereas the stoichiometry Cu2.1- 2.20 remained a l m o s t u n c h a n g e d in the range from 15000 L to 100000 L m e t h a n o l t r e a t m e n t , the stoichiometry c h a n g e d more strongly u p to Cu3.20 for t r e a t m e n t s of 100000 L to 2 5 0 0 0 0 L m e t h a n o l . Valence b a n d spectra are p r e s e n t e d as difference d a t a between successive t r e a t m e n t steps to highlight the spectral changes. The Heldifference spectra were fitted [17] in the range from -0.5 to 4.9 eV BE by a linear combination of Cu-, Cu20- a n d CuO- reference spectra (Fig. 1). The
61 t r e a t m e n t u p to 15000 L led to a reduction of CuO to Cu20 (Fig. 1, C- B). The HeI difference s p e c t r u m for 50000 L - 15000 L m e t h a n o l t r e a t m e n t indicated despite a unmodified stoichiometry of Cu2.20, the r e d u c t i o n of CuO to a Cu20 like species a n d also a decrease of the a b u n d a n c e of metallic copper. Also the difference s p e c t r u m 150000 L - 100000 L m e t h a n o l shows similar changes. The difference s p e c t r u m of the i n t e r m e d i a t e m e t h a n o l t r e a t m e n t 5 0 0 0 0 L to 100000 L ( E - D ) i n d i c a t e s s u r p r i s i n g l y inverted changes, i. e. the d e c r e a s e of Cu20 features a n d the increase of a diffuse spectral c o m p o n e n t a n d of metallic Cu features. The HeI-difference s p e c t r u m of the last m e t h a n o l t r e a t m e n t (250000 L - 150000 L methanol) revealed a reduction of Cu20 to metallic Cu. However, a suitable fit of this difference s p e c t r u m is obtained only with a linear combination of Cu, Cu20 a n d the diffuse additional species. The r e d u c t i o n of Cu20 to Cu is inhibited, w h e r e a s this is not the case for the initial reduction of CuO to Cu20. The not inhibited CuO reduction is indicated by the s h a r p decline of stoichiometry from 0 L to 15000 L m e t h a n o l t r e a t m e n t (Fig. 1, A - C). This indicates t h a t CuO is highly unlikely species to exist u n d e r all practical reaction conditions applied here. A r e t a r d e d r e d u c t i o n of Cu20 by m e t h a n o l / o x y g e n m i x t u r e s was already observed by H. W e r n e r et al. [8]. They ascribed this finding to a possible generation of a copper sub-oxide t r a n s i e n t state on the way of the Cu20 reduction to Cu. The HeI difference s p e c t r a reveal also c h a n g e s of the chemical s t r u c t u r e for the t r e a t m e n t steps between 15000 L (C) a n d 100000 L (E) methanol. The s p e c t r a were fitted by linear c o m b i n a t i o n s of reference spectra of Cu a n d the known, stable copper oxides CuO a n d Cu20. It was n e c e s s a r y to include a n additional diffuse spectral c o m p o n e n t well compatible with a sub-oxide containing oxygen a t o m s in a w e a k chemical bonding to copper in order to fit the s p e c t r a of progressing reduction. The surface composition c h a n g e d d u r i n g reduction in the intermediate compositional range alternatingly between Cu20 --~ CuxO + Cu a n d CuxO --~ Cu20 + Cu. The fit r e s u l t s with the linear c o m b i n a t i o n of Cu, Cu20 a n d CuO show significant differences c o m p a r e d to the experimental d a t a at a r o u n d 6 eV binding energy. Emission at this binding energy is typical for oxygen species [18, 19]. This difference is particularly high after the m e t h a n o l deposition in the range of 15000 L to 150000 L methanol. The emission at this energy position c h a n g e s less t h a n the emission at lower binding energy. Hence the intensity of this emission is not exclusively linked with the Cu 3d b a n d from the spectral features of the k n o w n copper c o m p o u n d s Cu, Cu20 a n d CuO. This is an i n d e p e n d e n t hint to oxygen species not b o u n d in the k n o w n copper oxide p h a s e s of CuO or Cu20, with w e a k i n t e r a c t i o n s with copper, typical for e.g. a d s o r b e d oxygen species [18] or copper s u b oxide which can be i m p o r t a n t for the catalytic oxidation of m e t h a n o l [3,8]. 3.2.Self Sustained Oscillations-General
Rate oscillations were observed in the range of m e t h a n o l to oxygen ratios 1.0... 6.0 a n d a t e m p e r a t u r e range --640 ... 800 K. Cycle times r a n g e d from
62 ~1 to 5 min d e p e n d i n g on the m e t h a n o l / o x y g e n ratio a n d the s a m p l e t e m p e r a t u r e . An increase of t e m p e r a t u r e led to the d e c r e a s e of the periods a n d of the a m p l i t u d e of oscillations. With increasing 02 c o n c e n t r a t i o n s the periods b e c a m e longer. The copper catalyst consisted u n d e r the conditions of the p r e s e n t e x p e r i m e n t s mainly of copper oxide. At higher m e t h a n o l oxygen ratios, the rate oscillations were coupled with visible oscillations of the oxide state of the copper foils. At lower m e t h a n o l to oxygen ratios the rate oscillations also proceeded with optically p e r m a n e n t l y oxidised copper. In a g r e e m e n t with the surface analytical d a t a the oxidised surface u n d e r in-situ conditions m a i n l y consists of Cu20 according to R a m a n s p e c t r a recorded from the copper s a m p l e d u r i n g the oscillations. The formation of Cu20 w a s a p p a r e n t in m o s t s p e c t r a from the p e a k at ~220 cm -1 [20, 21, 22]. However, formation of additional CuO or metallic Cu c a n not be excluded b e c a u s e Cu metal is generally R a m a n inactive a n d CuO is k n o w n to be invisible by a laser excitation with 632 n m [23]. F r o m the c a r b o n b a l a n c e of the catalytic d a t a it o c c u r r e d t h a t no o t h e r species t h a n the deep oxidation p r o d u c t s a n d formaldehyde were formed in detectable a m o u n t s . Neither formic acid nor a n a d s o r b a t e which would deactivate the surface ( c a r b o n a c e o u s deposits) were observed.
3.3. Activationlpre-treatment of the copper samples A m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n p r e - t r e a t m e n t of the c o p p e r - c a t a l y s t s at high temperatures is n e c e s s a r y to obtain catalytic oscillations in the c o p p e r / o x y g e n / m e t h a n o l - s y s t e m . For the p r e - t r e a t m e n t the s a m p l e c a n be either treated with m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n m i x t u r e s or a l t e r n a t i n g with oxygen a n d m e t h a n o l at t e m p e r a t u r e s above 730 K. In a m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n - h e l i u m flow (methanol to oxygen ratio around 2:1, T > 730 K) the c o p p e r / o x y g e n / m e t h a n o l s y s t e m always oscillated within a few m i n u t e s after a d j u s t m e n t of the p a r a m e t e r s . After the p r e - t r e a t m e n t the s y s t e m oscillated also at lower s a m p l e t e m p e r a t u r e s down to N 650 K in m e t h a n o l oxygen-helium mixtures. An activation can also be achieved by a n e x t e n d e d t r e a t m e n t of several h o u r s at lower t e m p e r a t u r e s (N 670 K) in a m e t h a n o l oxygen mixture. After this low t e m p e r a t u r e t r e a t m e n t long r e d u c e d p h a s e s of the Cu sample u p to 30 s were observed, w h e r e a s after the high t e m p e r a t u r e p r e - t r e a t m e n t the r e d u c e d state h a s also at low sample t e m p e r a t u r e s a very short lifetime of ~0.2 s. Different cleaning p r o c e d u r e s of the copper s a m p l e s like polishing with d i a m o n d paste, cyclic oxidation (oxygen) a n d r e d u c t i o n (hydrogen) at t e m p e r a t u r e s u p to 770 K as well as rinsing of the s a m p l e s with different solvents like methanol, acetone a n d w a t e r h a d no positive influence on obtaining the oscillations.
3.4. Variation of the oxygen-methanol proportion At c o n s t a n t sample t e m p e r a t u r e T = 720 K the m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n flow ratio in the gas feed was gradually d e c r e a s e d from 1.6 to 1.1, respectively
63 from 7.9 vol-% to 12.2 vol-% 02. The m e t h a n o l c o n t e n t was held c o n s t a n t at ~12.8 vol-%. In general, the cycle times b e c a m e longer with d e c r e a s i n g m e t h a n o l to oxygen ratios (Fig. 2). At m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n ratios from 1.6 to 1.3 (phase I, Fig. 3) the sample showed a n oscillating oxidation state (see video pictures, at a m e t h a n o l oxygen flow ratio of 1.2 (phase II, Fig. 3) the sample h a d been p e r m a n e n t l y oxidised while catalytic oscillations still sustained. Below a m e t h a n o l - o x y g e n ratio of 1.1, no rate oscillations were observed.
110 55
IO0
~ 90 ~ 8o R o
.
/ Phase,i, ase"
,,,
50 ~ 0
70
60 ,
1.6
i,
45 ~
"
1.4 1.2 Methanol/02 (Educts)
FIG. 2. Rate oscillations with a methanol/O2/He flow over Cu: The m e t h a n o l conversion a n d the cycle time related to the m e t h a n o l : oxygen ratio. P h a s e I: oxide state oscillations of the Cu sample, p h a s e II: sample p e r m a n e n t l y oxidised.
1
Typical for the visible reduction process of the s a m p l e surface is a reduction front travelling over the entire surface a n d leading to a p p a r e n t l y metallic copper (video pictures). The lifetime of the r e d u c e d state is very short (N1 s). Shortly after the metallic state, a progressing surface re-oxidation could be followed by eye as a s u c c e s s i o n of various colours due to light interference in thin Cu20 films of increasing thickness. The m a x i m a l surface layer t h i c k n e s s c a n be e s t i m a t e d by the interference colours [24, 25] of at least 300 m o n o l a y e r s Cu20. After surface reduction of the sample the m e t h a n o l conversion increases strongly, i.e. the catalytic activity of the metallic sample is s u b s t a n t i a l l y larger t h a n FIG. 3. Volume fractions t h a t of the thick oxidised state. After surface a n d m e t h a n o l conversion (calculated from mass .5 .... . spectra). M e t h a n o l / O 2 / H e [Phase I I ', IP"~e Ill flow over a copper sample 60 4 (Cu foil), Tsample = 720 K. ~o ~ The volume fractions of 3 CO2 a n d formaldehyde as 40 N 0 well as the methanol 2 conversion exhibit rate ~~ ~ oscillations. The para1 20 " C m e t e r s in p h a s e I and p h a s e II differ slightly in 0 ,i . ,I , 50 55 60 65 the m e t h a n o l to oxygen Time ! min ratios: m e t h a n o l : o x y g e n reduction the CO2 yield increase m u c h = 1 : 1 . 3 / 1 . 2 (phase I/II), stronger t h a n the formaldehyde yield - the ~77 % He, ptotal 1 bar. =
64 selectivity to formaldehyde decrease significantly. As shown in Fig. 3 the amplitudes of the CO2 production (total oxidation activity) are substantially larger t h a n the amplitudes of the formaldehyde production. A methanol to oxygen ratio of 1.2 giving rise to a permanently oxidised sample induced only weak rate oscillations in agreement with the low activity of bulk oxide for catalytic action. Under the reaction conditions also the steam reforming of methanol (CH3OH + H20 > CO2 + 3 H2 ARH~ +62 kJ/mol) is possible, because water (ca. 6 vol-%) exist in the reactor. This reaction is catalysed by copper. It is well known from literature [26] that only metallic copper is the active site for this reaction channel. Since the H2 volume fraction does not strongly increase with the metallic episodes we conclude t h a t steam reforming did not take place indicating that the reduction was incomplete giving a further hint to the existence of a sub-oxide with a p p a r e n t metallic lustre. 3.5. Transition from an oscillating surface oxide state to a permanently oxidised sample during gas phase oscillation
In the following the transition of the visible oscillating oxide-metal state ("phase I") to a permanently oxidised state ("phase II") of the catalyst surface (see Figure 3) will be discussed. ' i i i I i i
62
' , "|
" ..... ~
i'
60
i i I
L5
45
"Phase I P h a s e II
t i i
.
.
58 , '
w
56
;
.,
...........
Phase I
Phase
II
i o;J"
54
Ii
i
4
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
I
i
i
,
,
,
,
|1 ~
i
0
ii
ii
.......
Phase I P h a s e II
i
I
~
3 2.5
.•
.
0.5
1
1.5
2
Time / min
"- 3.5
U_
' ,
I
......
. ~'C02
.
i/
FIG. 4. Line profile comparison of the methanol conversion (a), the CO2 / formaldehyde volume fraction (b) and the formaldehyde selectivity (c) (calculated from MS) of one period of phase I (oxidation state oscillations) and phase II (permanently oxidized sample). (parameters cf. Fig. 3)
65 This transition was observed after the decreasing of the m e t h a n o l to oxygen ratio from 1.3 to 1.2. P r o n o u n c e d gas p h a s e oscillations were found in both states of the surface (cf. m a s s spectra, Fig. 3). This indicates t h a t the oscillating macroscopic oxide to metal transition is not n e c e s s a r y to s u s t a i n the gas p h a s e oscillations. Thus it is of interest to know if the gas p h a s e oscillation characteristics are identical for p h a s e I a n d p h a s e II. A c o m p a r i s o n of the line profiles (calculated from m a s s spectra) of the m e t h a n o l conversion (Fig. 4a) a n d the yields in CO2 a n d in formaldehyde (Fig. 4b) a n d of the formaldehyde selectivity (Fig. 4c) show similar line profiles whenever the sample is visibly oxidised. The differences between p h a s e I a n d p h a s e II can be solely explained by a modification of the catalyst activity due to the sample reduction in p h a s e I leading to an extra feature s u p e r i m p o s e d over the f u n d a m e n t a l rate variation. A strong d e p e n d e n c e of the cycle time on the m e t h a n o l : 02 ratio was found in the range of 1.5 to 1.2. During the transition from p h a s e I to p h a s e II the e n h a n c e m e n t of the cycle time as a function of the methanol-oxygen ratio does not change, i. e. the cycle time is i n d e p e n d e n t from the transition from an oscillating oxide sample state to a p e r m a n e n t l y 0xidised sample. T h u s it can be concluded t h a t the rate oscillations in p h a s e I a n d p h a s e II have their origin in the same m e c h a n i s m . The macroscopic visible periodic sample oxidation-reduction m u s t be a side effect. Obviously, the oxidation a n d reduction cycles of the copper during the oscillations at a lower oxygen content regenerate the catalyst, while with a p e r m a n e n t l y oxidised sample the catalytic activity decreases c o n t i n u o u s l y indicating t h a t copper oxide Cu20 is a catalyst poison. The same conclusion was also reached from earlier steady state in-situ m e a s u r e m e n t s u s i n g NEXAFS as probe for the oxidation state of the copper [3-6]. Both in p h a s e I a n d p h a s e II (Fig. 3) the m a g n i t u d e s of the a m p l i t u d e s of CO2 are s u b s t a n t i a l l y larger t h a n those of formaldehyde. Thus, u n d e r lean conditions the oscillations of the partial oxidation of m e t h a n o l are probably a side effect which is in s h a r p c o n t r a s t to the observations of Werner et al. [8] who operated in rich conditions. With a higher m e t h a n o l partial p r e s s u r e the selectivity for formaldehyde is higher t h a n t h a t for CO2 a n d also the oscillation a m p l i t u d e s for the formaldehyde volume fraction increase (e.g. Fig. 11). Moreover, the sign of the c h a n g e s in the gas p h a s e volume fractions of formaldehyde a n d of CO2 in a single oscillation period are opposite, s u c h as after re-oxidation (e.g. after the p r o n o u n c e d CO2-peak at 53 min in Fig. 3) the formaldehyde volume fraction rises a n d the CO2 volume fraction falls. This observation strongly point to the existence of different active sites for total a n d partial oxidation, an observation which was also found in the insire NEXAFS experiments [3].
3.6. Modification of the gas-phase heat conductivity In order to reduce the g a s - p h a s e h e a t conductivity, 45.7 % of the He feed gas was replaced by the same flow of Ar (~ - h e a t conductivity - at T = 600 K: E(He) = 252.4 m W / K m, MAr) = 30.6 m W / K [27]). The other p a r a m e t e r s remained u n c h a n g e d .
66 The gas exchange led to an explicit modification of the oscillatory behaviour. The m a s s spectra show oscillations with comparatively long cycle times (approx. 4 min) a n d large a m p l i t u d e s in the case of high g a s - p h a s e h e a t conductivity (Fig. 5a). On the other h a n d , periods are s u b s t a n t i a l l y shorter a n d the a m p l i t u d e s on average smaller at low g a s - p h a s e h e a t conductivity (Fig. 5b). Close inspection of the m a s s spectra reveals a folded p a t t e r n of a long period of a b o u t 5 with a series of short periods with cycle times in the second range, reminiscent to the observations of Werner et al. [8]. In both experiments, the sample was always visibly reduced for a s h o r t time, w h e n the activity j u m p of the long oscillation process occurred. FIG. 5. Change of the rate oscillations with variation of the gas p h a s e h e a t conductivity by partial s u b s t i t u t i o n of He feed gas by Ar: Methanol to oxygen ratio 2.4 : 1 (flow), sample: polycristalline copper foil, T = 688 K. Top: Feed gas 87 vol-% He, bottom: feed gas mixture of 47 vol-%He a n d 40 vol-% Ar.
The bulk sample t e m p e r a t u r e w a s controlled b u t the surface of catalyst O may have been at temperatures deviating significantly from the m e a n 2 bulk value. The s t e a d y state between a c o m b i n a t i o n of exothermic a n d e n d o t h e r m i c reactions (see above) a n d the 0 5 10 15 20 h e a t t r a n s p o r t t h r o u g h the gas p h a s e which is affected Time / min by the heat capacity of the gas mixture d e t e r m i n e s the surface t e m p e r a t u r e . Since the conditions in the sample b u l k are likely to be similar in both experiments the long period oscillations in both experiments are probably c a u s e d by a m e c h a n i s m i n d e p e n d e n t of the h e a t dissipation t h r o u g h the gas phase. The short-time processes, on the other h a n d are significantly more p r o n o u n c e d in their a m p l i t u d e s w h e n the h e a t dissipation t h r o u g h the gas p h a s e is reduced. It is likely t h a t the m o s t exothermic reaction CH30H + 3/2 02 > CO2 + 2 H20, A R H ~ = -674 k J / m o l Is gaining a significant control over the whole system u n d e r conditions of 4
-.,,..
,,...
. v J
67 poor h e a t dissipation. This conclusion is in good a g r e e m e n t with general catalytic conjecture t h a t selective oxidation requires efficient control of energy t r a n s p o r t .
4. Discussion of possible origins of the oscillatory behaviour The gas p h a s e oscillations m a y be controlled by a process at the catalyst surface (red-oxidation) or in co-operation between the surface a n d the bulk (re-structuring). It is proposed t h a t the latter is effective, b e c a u s e in case of a sole surface process at least the cycle time should be drastically influenced by the visible sample reduction a n d re-oxidation, since thereby the surface is completely re-arranged. The h y p o t h e s i s of an oscillation m e c h a n i s m controlled by the catalyst bulk state is s u p p o r t e d by the experiment with variable h e a t conductivity of the gas phase: the b r a n c h of the p h e n o m e n o n which is heat-dissipation i n d e p e n d e n t indicates t h a t a significantly larger sample volume t h a n the near-interface region which should always be in t h e r m a l equilibrium with the gas p h a s e is taking part. Therefore, it is a s s u m e d t h a t the oscillation characterised by long cycle times a n d large a m p l i t u d e s are controlled by a bulk process. Moreover, it is m o s t probable t h a t the oscillation of the macroscopic surface oxidation state n a m e l y metal or oxide as seen by visible inspection is only a secondary process t h a t does not control the oscillating mechanism. The observed rate oscillations reach their m a x i m a in the visibly reduced states. Their occurrence m a y be c a u s e d by the t e m p e r a t u r e rise from the oxide reduction by excessive m e t h a n o l which is c a u s e d by excessive c o n s u m p t i o n of oxygen in the total oxidation reaction.
4.1. Model for a copper-bulk-oxygen based oscillation mechanism XAS (EXAFS)-investigations of copper catalysts u n d e r real catalytic conditions indicated the presence of a metallic copper bulk a n d reversible small c h a n g e s of the C u - C u n e a r e s t n e i g h b o u r distances a n d coordination n u m b e r s correlated with the m e t h a n o l - c o n v e r s i o n a n d with the oxygen c o n t e n t in the gas phase. These c h a n g e s were interpreted as the formation of a nanocrystalline copper bulk s t r u c t u r e by reversible intercalation of atomic oxygen at the interface of the nanocrystallites a n d not in the regular Cu lattice [5]. In situ X A S - m e a s u r e m e n t s of Cu at the oxygen K-edge u n d e r conditions of the partial m e t h a n o l oxidation revealed t h a t a copper oxide different from Cu20 is responsible for the partial oxidation of m e t h a n o l [3, 4, 6]. A surface species of Cu20 is reacting to COx a n d is c o n s u m e d by the m e t h a n o l reaction. Variation of the a b u n d a n c e of this copper oxide m a y therefore cause the oscillations of the CO2 production. The surface analysis d a t a indicate t h a t oxygen from the copper bulk can segregate to the catalyst surface where it forms copper-oxygen c o m p o u n d s similar to Cu20 as well as a novel CuOx-transient state. In this way oxygen stored in the catalyst bulk can influence the surface catalytic properties.
68
C h a n g e s in the a b u n d a n c e of b u l k oxygen or in its t r a n s p o r t kinetics (e.g. by t e m p e r a t u r e fluctuations) can so effect variations of the catalytic activity. We s u p p o s e t h a t the i n d i s p e n s a b l e high t e m p e r a t u r e p r e - t r e a t m e n t of the copper sample generates a n a n o c r y s t a l l i n e copper b u l k s t r u c t u r e with dissolved oxygen. In the p r e s e n t oscillation p h e n o m e n a the CO2 volume fraction oscillates with s u b s t a n t i a l a m p l i t u d e s , w h e r e a s the formaldehyde shows smaller or no oscillations. Therefore, the overall oscillations are mainly due to a variation of the total oxidation activity (cf. E q u a t i o n 3 a n d 4) w h e r e a s the c h a n g e s of the partial oxidation activity are of m i n o r i m p o r t a n c e which is d u e to the choice of a lean reaction mixture. The catalytic m e c h a n i s m of the total m e t h a n o l oxidation m a y be a redox m e c h a n i s m in a m a n n e r first p r o p o s e d of Mars a n d van Krevelen [28]. According to this m e c h a n i s m the c o n s u m e d lattice-oxygen is c o n t i n u o u s l y restored by oxygen from gas phase. It r e m a i n s open w h a t the exact n a t u r e of "lattice oxygen" m e a n s . It m a y well be t h a t this term does not designate a physically discernible oxygen species b u t r a t h e r m e a n s a rate c o n s t a n t of a solid state reaction (the formation of the active oxide) m u c h different from the rate c o n s t a n t s of the catalytic processes. On the basis of this r e s u l t s a model for the c h a n g e s of catalytic activity is p r e s e n t e d which is b a s e d on c o n c e n t r a t i o n c h a n g e s of mobile oxygen species dissolved in the catalyst bulk. The m e t h a n o l - c o n v e r s i o n r e a c h e s its m a x i m u m if the surface is covered with a m a x i m u m of the active oxygen p h a s e which is according to the p r e s e n t surface analytical d a t a a n d to the XAS results a surface p h a s e of Cu20 a n d not a sub-oxide. The active oxygen species is c o n s u m e d by the m e t h a n o l - c o n v e r s i o n a n d is c o n t i n u o u s l y replaced by oxygen from the catalyst bulk. The b u l k reservoir is r e g e n e r a t e d by gas p h a s e oxygen. However, at high m e t h a n o l conversions a large p a r t of the gas p h a s e oxygen is c o n s u m e d by catalytic reactions a n d is so not available for replenishing the b u l k oxygen reservoir. Therefore, the catalyst b u l k oxygen a b u n d a n c e is lowered gradually a n d with it the c o n c e n t r a t i o n of the active surface oxygen species. If now the m e t h a n o l conversion is r e d u c e d a n d vice v e r s a the gas p h a s e oxygen c o n t e n t is increased the c a t a l y s t bulk oxygen reservoir c a n be r e g e n e r a t e d by gas p h a s e oxygen. This process seems to be greatly facilitated by short episodes of r e d u c e d metal surface p a t c h e s which originate from the m e t h a n o l excess due to preceding excessive activity for total oxidation. It is clear, however, t h a t this additional facilitation is not critically required to m a i n t a i n a rate oscillation. 5. Conclusion
From in-situ macroscopic o b s e r v a t i o n s coupled with on-line p r o d u c t analysis a n d ex-situ surface analysis of massive copper u s e d as c a t a l y s t s in m e t h a n o l oxidation the following c o n c l u s i o n s can be d r a w n for the d y n a m i c b e h a v i o u r of the system:
69 9 Two independent pathway for selective and total oxidation exist. Under conditions of lean gas phases the total oxidation pathway exceeds in a rapid reaction the selective oxidation. 9 A surface phase of Cu20, not too thick to inhibit the reaction but thicker as a surface oxide ad-layer is the active phase for total oxidation. Its formation requires a bulk process, be it either segregation of oxygen or diffusion of copper atoms. 9 The steady state of energy flow to the active surface controls critically the reaction scenario, possible surface restructuring effects could not be observed with the crude analytical techniques used here. 9 The origin of the dynamic behaviour is the incompatibility of rate constants between the formation of the active phase which is not pure copper nor a bulk oxide phase with the rate constants for the main gas phase processes. This incompatibility is traced back to the essential participation of the bulk of the catalyst in the generation of the active phase.
Acknowledgement This work was supported by the German Science Foundation (DFG) through its Schwerpunktprogramm "Brfickenschl~ige zwischen Oberfl&chenphysik und Heterogener Katalyse".
References [111. Wachs, R.J. Madix, J. CataL, 1978, 53, 208 [211. Wachs, R.J. Madix, Surf. Sci., 84 (1979) 375. [3]A. Knop-Gericke, M. H&vecker, Th. Schedel-Niedrig and R. Schl6gl, Topics in Catal. 10 (2000) 187-198 [4]Th. Schedel-Niedrig, M. H&vecker, A. Knop-Gericke and R. Schl6gl, PCCP 2(15) (2000) 3473-3481 [51I. B6ttger, Th. Schedel-Niedrig, O. Timpe, R. Gottschall, M. H&vecker, T. Ressler and R. Schl6gl, Chem. Eur. J. 6, No. 10 (2000) 1870 - 1876 [6]A. Knop-Gericke, M. H&vecker, Th. Schedel-Niedrig and R. Schl6gl, Catal. Lett. 66(4)(2000)215-220 [7]F. Schtith, B. E. Henry u n d L. D. Schmidt, Adv. Catal. 39 (1993) [8]H. Werner, D. Herein, G. Schulz, U. Wild und R. Schl6gl, Catal. Lett. 49 (1997) 109 [9]T. Inui u n d T. Iwana, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 19 (1984) 205 [10]S. Arsalane, R. Brochu, C. R. Acad und M. Ziyad, C. R. Acad. Sci. Ser. 2, 311 (1990) 1303 [11 ]A. Amariglio, O. Benall und H. Amariglio, J. Catal. 118 (1989) 164 [12]L. Petrov, C. Vladov, A. Eliyas, N. Kirkov, K. Tenchev, C. Boney, D. Filkova und L. Prahov, J. Mol. Catal. 54 (1989) 237 [13]E. Eckert, V. Hlavacek u n d M. Marek, Chem. Eng Commun. 1 (1973) 95
70 [14]X. Bao, J. V. Bart, G. Lempfuhl, R. Schuster, Y. Uchida, R. Schl6gl, G. Ertl, Surf. Sci. 284 (1993) 14 [15]H. Schubert, U. Tegtmeyer R. Schl6gl, Catal. Lett. 28 (1994) 383 [16]D. Briggs und M. P. Seah Hrsg..: Practical Surface Analysis, Vol. 1: Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, J o h n Wiley & Sons, Chichester, New York; Salle+Sauerl~inder Aarau (1990) 635, 210 [17]T. Ressler, WinXAS 97, version 1.2, software for spectra analysis [18]R. Courts, B. Cord, H. Wern, H. Saalfeld u n d S. Hfifner, Sol. State. Comm., 63(7) (1987) 620 [ 19]A. Spitzer and H. Lfith, Surf. Sci. 118 (1982) 679 [20]A. Compaan, Sol. State Comm., 16 (1975) 293 - 296 [21]P. Dawson, M. M. Hargreave u n d G. R. Wilkinson, J. Phys. Chem. 34 (1973) 2201-2208 [22]J. C. W. Taylor und F. L. Weichman, Can. J. Phys. 49 (9171) 601 - 605 [23]J. C. Irwin, J. Chrzanowski u n d T. Wei, Physica C 166 (1990) 456 - 464 [24]U. R. Evans u n d H. A. Miley, Nature 139 (1937) 283 [25]F. H. Constable, Proc. Roy. Soc., A, 117 (1927) 376 [26]B.A. Pepply, J.C. Amphlett, L.M. Kearns and R.F. Mann, Appl. Catal. A., 179 (1999)32 [27]CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 76th. Ed., Chemical Publishing Company, Boca Raton (1995) 6-251 [28]P. Mars and D. W. van Krevelen, Chem. Eng Sci. 3 (1954) 41
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 133 G.F. Froment and K.C. Waugh (Editors) Published by Elsevier Science B.V., 2001
71
Novel Reactor Configurations and Modes of Operation Dan Luss Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Houston, Houston, TX 77204, USA
Introduction Reaction engineers are expected to transform laboratory discoveries of new synthesis routes or design concepts into economic, safe, and environmentally compatible processes. The highly competitive industrial environment has added the need to shorten the time interval in which this task has to be completed and to decrease the production price. This motivated several innovations. The first was development of novel catalysts, which increased the yield in existing processes, such as the novel Kellogg ammonia-synthesis process, which uses the much more active BP catalyst. Other catalysts were designed to provide either new synthesis routes, such as the production of synthesis gas by direct oxidation, or new products, such as production of novel polymers by metallocene catalysts. Attempts to use cheaper feed stocks led to the development of new processes. For example, the drive to replace olefins as reactants by paraffins led to the development of processes in which ethane rather ethylene is used to produce vinyl chloride, propane rather than propylene to produce acrylonitrile, and butane rather than benzene to produce maleic anhydride. The drive to produce more-economical synthesis gas from methane has motivated various novel process developments. Moreover, environmental regulations and needs caused modifications of many processes in order to minimize the production of pollutants. Most reactors are designed to handle a relatively narrow range of feed concentrations and space velocities. A different design approach has to be used if reactors are to destroy pollutants, as they have to operate at high conversion over a very wide range of feed compositions and feed rates. The development of the new processes led in some cases to the development of novel reactor configurations and/or mode of operation. I shall review here some of these developments and the corresponding design and operation problems and challenges. Specifically, I shall describe some of the challenges encountered in four processes: 1. Reactors for conducting very fast chemical reactions. 2. Periodic operation of chemical reactors. 3. Fuel-cell systems. 4. Gas-phase synthesis ofpolyolefins. I shall review here only a small fraction of the many related contributions. The goal is to point out the problems and challenges encountered in either the design of these reactors
72 or their mode of operation, rather than to present a comprehensive review. contributions of many engineers and scientists will not be described here.
The
Reactors for conducting very fast chemical reactions Almost all commercial heterogeneous catalytic reactions are conducted with a contact time of at least several seconds. Many require much longer contact time. There are, however, a few commercial catalytic processes in which the reaction is completed in a very short time (order of milliseconds). These very fast reactions are usually affected by heat- and mass-transport resistances. They are usually carried out either on catalytic gauzes or on a reticulated structure or monolith coated with a very thin washcoat on which a catalyst is impregnated. A very well-established fast reaction is the oxidation of ammonia to NO over a Pd/Rh gauze [ 1]: 4NH3 + 502 "-)' 4NO + 6H20
AH = -227 KJ/mol NH3,
commercialized by Ostwald in 1906. The NO yield is about 97%-98% in atmospheric commercial reactors and about 95% in reactors operating at 0.8 or 0.9 MPa. A related fast reaction, developed by Andrussov in the early 1930s, is the synthesis of hydrogefi cyanide [ 1]: CH4 +NH3 +1.502 --) HCN + 3H20
AH =-482 KJ/mol.
These fast commercial reactions have been considered to be rather uncommon exceptions. In recent years, the research group of L. Schmidt at the University of Minnesota [2] has discovered several very fast reactions (contact time of the order of 1 ms.) that have several advantages. They are more selective than existing ones, can reduce the amount of undesired by-products, feature lower capital costs, and can use lessexpensive reactants. The first reaction they studied was the production of syngas by direct oxidation of methane, CH4 + 0.5 02 ")' C O + 2H2
AH =-8.5 KJ/mol.
on a reticulated (foam) catalyst on which Rh was impregnated, having a metal surface area of about 100 cmZ/gr. The reactor lengthwas 0.5-10 mm and the inlet velocity about 1 m/s. at a residence time of several ms. About 90% of the methane and nearly 100% of the oxygen were converted at a residence tome of several ms., yielding more than 95% CO yield and over 90% H2 yield. This very fast reaction was insensitive to the form of the catalyst and the metal-loading, but rather sensitive to the specific metal catalyst. A 1ft.-diameter reactor with this very thin catalyst layer is predicted to produce 1 ton/d, of syngas. The same fast reaction was carried out in a laboratory fluidized-bed reactor using 100-~tm alpha-alumina spheres with 5-~tm-diameter holes within them. These beads did
73 not have a washcoat and were impregnated with Rh. The conversion and selectivity obtained at a residence time of 0.05-0.25 seconds were very high and close to those predicted from equilibrium calculations. Schmidt's group discovered another important class of very fast reactions - - the oxidative dehydrogenation of olefins over monolith catalysts. For ethane, the reaction is C2H6 + 0.5 02 -') C2H4 + H20
AH=-25.1 Kcal/mol.
Using a Pt catalyst, they obtained up to 70% selectivity to C2H4 at 80% conversion of C2H6 and nearly complete conversion of O2. The product distribution was very different from that attained under thermodynamic equilibrium, according to which CH4 should be the dominant product and only a small percentage of C2H4 should be obtained. A major advantage of these two processes found by Schmidt's group is that they lead to nearly complete conversion of the reactants with high yield of the desired product, avoiding the usual tradeoff between conversion and yield. Schmidt's experiments involved small hydrocarbons and noble metals. They suggest that by use of other feeds and catalysts, it should be possible to design other efficient processes for fast partial oxidation and maybe even other classes of exothermic reactions. The discovery of these reactions, catalysts, and operating conditions will be a major contribution. Many features of these very fast exothermic reactions need to be elucidated to enhance our understanding of the interaction between the (usually nonselective) homogeneous and heterogeneous reactions and their dependence on the catalyst structure, washcoat diffusion, and fluid velocity. It was suggested that in some cases the exothermic surface reactions generate free radicals which initiate gas-phase reactions that lead to some unstable species. These homogeneous reactions are quenched by mixing with colder gases passing through the gauze. This rapid quenching enables one to obtain valuable nonequilibrium-mixture products. Knowledge of the rates of both the homogeneous and heterogeneous reaction rates is essential for selecting the optimal catalyst configuration and operating conditions. This difficult task of separating the contributions of these two modes of fast reactions requires use of both detailed models of the kinetics of the many reaction steps and of the flow and transport within the complex reticulated structure. An example of such a model is that by Duetschmann and Schmidt [3]. The prediction of the transport coefficients under the extremely steep temperature and concentration gradients introduces additional uncertainties to the simulations. The theoretical model predictions need to be tested and modified by critical experimental data. An intriguing question is what the impact is of the nonuniform pore-size distribution on the performance of this very rapid reaction, especially in systems that involve several reactions, each having a different rate of heat release or consumption. For example, during the fast partial oxidation of methane, the oxygen is completely consumed in the upstream section of the reticulated structure while steam-reforming occurs further downstream.
74 The pressure-drop in shallow catalytic beds or gauzes is very small. Thus, in the design of large-diameter reactors, special attention must be devoted to maintain a uniform velocity and concentration across the reactor. Moreover, the rather short time constant of the fast chemical reactions relative to that of heat conduction in the radial direction raises the possibility of nonuniform temperature distribution on large-diameter industrial reactors. This nonuniform temperature may have a deleterious impact on the reactor performance and may even lead to safety problems. It is also important to prevent radiation-heating from initiating unselective homogeneous reactions from occurring before the hot catalyst bed is reached. The highly exothermic fast reactions may be handled safely only in a bounded region of temperatures and fuel/oxygen ratio. At high temperatures, the catalyst deactivates or melts. At low temperatures, extinction occurs. At a high fuel/O2 ratio, coke forms and deactivates the catalyst. At a low fuel-to-air ration, the reaction becomes homogeneous and may lead to an explosion. It is essential to be able to predict these operation regions to guarantee safe operation and to guide the search for novel fast reactions.
M
Figure 1: Short-Contact-Time Fluidized Reactor (SCTFR), after Bartholic [5]. Many commercial reactions are carried out in fluidized-bed reactors. Several very interesting developments of a short-contact-time fluidized reactor (SCTFR) have been reported in recent years. Professor Bergougnou and his associates at the University of Western Ontario [4] developed a "downer" SCTFR concept with the goal of rapid gasification of biomass. These novel downflow reactors facilitate operation at a short residence time of about 1 second. Ensyn Engineers of Ottawa scaled up the process to 100 kg/min and reported several commercial applications. Bartholic [5] patented an SCTFR for catalytic cracking which has been commercialized by Coastal Corporation. In one configuration, the atomized feed contacts a falling mountain of hot catalyst (above
75 540 ~ C) for a short time (less than 0.5 second). The higher catalyst temperature and shorter residence time of the SCTFR relative to that of a traditional riser reactor increase the fuel-oil conversion at the same coke yield and reduce hydrogen-transfer activity while increasing the yield of light olefins. This novel reactor configuration is expected to find important commercial applications. When the rate of the chemical reaction is very fast (short characteristic time) relative to that of mixing of the reactants, micromixing has an important impact on the conversion and/or selectivity or properties of the product. For example, the mixing in the high temperature conversion of TIC14 to TiO2 strongly affects the particle-size distribution of the product. The quality and hence price of TiO2 used in paints is strongly dependent on this particle-size distribution. Similarly, the mixing intensity in a polymerization reactor can affect the initiator efficiency and the final molecular-weight distribution [6]. Variation of the position of the feed in a crystallizer may lead to large variation in the average crystal size [7]. Unfortunately, a large uncertainty is still associated with the design of reactors involving very fast reactions and mixing. It is essential to improve our ability of a rational design of the configuration of these reactors and mode of operation and to develop a reliable scale-up methodology. It will be very beneficial to discover additional fast reactions and develop reactors in which they can be conducted safely and at a high rate. Their successful commercial operation would be of significant industrial importance and academic interest. Periodic Operation of Chemical Reactors Most chemical reactors operate at a steady state. Theoretical studies predict that the timeaveraged conversion or yield following a periodic variation of the feed concentration and/or temperature usually differs from that of a steady state for the same time-averaged feed conditions. Many experimental studies verified these theoretical predictions that a forced periodic operation can affect the time-averaged performance of a reactor. One of the few reported industrial applications is the cycling of a chain-transfer agent in order to affect the polydispersity of polypropylene [8]. Only two types of periodic processes have found wide technological applications so far. The first is a fluidized-bed reactor in which the catalyst undergoes periodic changes as it circulates through the reactor and regenerator. The first proposed application was by Lewis et al. [9] and was the selective oxidation of methane by a circulating copper catalyst, which was later oxidized in a regenerator. Callahan et al. [10] attempted to apply that concept to the oxidation and ammoxidation of propylene. DuPont has recently applied this concept to the oxidation of butane to maleic anhydride [11]. While this reactor configuration and mode of operation have many potential applications, its success is critically dependent on the ability to develop a catalyst that can reversibly bind a large amount of oxygen, as this determines the required rate of catalyst circulation.
76 The second type of reactor is the reverse-flow reactor (RFR), which has attracted significant interest in recent years. In that operation, the direction of the flow in a packed-bed reactor is periodically reversed to trap a hot zone within the reactor. The cold feed is regeneratively heated up as the high-temperature zone moves downstream. Before the hot zone exits the bed, the feed-flow direction is reversed. A detailed review of the various applications of the RFR was presented by Matros and Bunimovich [12]. Experimental and theoretical studies have shown that many (usually more than 100) flowreversals are needed before the reactor converges to the periodic state. There is still a need to determine the best control policy when the reactor is subjected to changes in the feed concentration and/or load.
Reverse flow reactor
.
rt
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
-.
axial po~tk~
L
Figure 2" Schematic of reverse flow reactor and temperature profile at the beginning and end of a semi-cycle The RFR has been used so far in two major applications. One is to conduct an exothermic equilibrium-limited reaction so that its conversion increases as the reactants pass over the leading front of the moving hot zone. The second is to conduct reactions in which the adiabatic temperature is lower than that needed to carry out the r e a c t i o n - for example, the catalytic destruction of a dilute mixture of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). It was recently proposed to conduct coke-forming reactions in a RFR [13]. In this operation, the desired reaction is conducted in the upstream section of the reactor while the downstream section is regenerated at the same time from the coke deposited in the previous half-cycle. All the reported applications of the RFR were for systems involving a single reaction. There is a need to determine if it is useful and how to apply it in systems in which several reactions occur simultaneously. Levenspiel [ 14] suggested that one potential application is to conduct an exothermic reaction during the first semicycle and then an endothermic one in the second semicycle. An example of a potential application is conducting the
77 endothermic dehydrogenation of ethylbenzene in one semicycle and the exothermic combustion of hydrogen in the second [15]. Several analyses of this mode of operation [ 15,16] indicate that this periodic operation and its dynamics are rather intricate and that it is difficult to obtain high yields. A major difficulty is that it is not possible to efficiently store the heat of the exothermic reaction without reaching excessive temperatures in the reactor. The operation could be enhanced significantly by placing within the bed some inert material that undergoes a reversible phase-change at the desired operating temperature. The development of robust RFR operation for coupling of endoand exothermic reactions still awaits an imaginative novel approach. When moderately or highly exothermic reactions are carried out in a RFR, cooling is needed to prevent excessive temperatures. Recent theoretical studies have shown that this cooling may lead to rather complex dynamics, including chaotic behavior [17]. Various modes of cooling the RFR have still not established the most efficient and robust fashion of conducting this cooling. Several modifications to the operation of a cooled RFR operation have been suggested. A countercurrent reactor may be used instead of using an RFR with a high frequency of flow-reversal. A major advantage of this operation is that it obviates the need for expensive valves and the operational difficulties encountered during the frequent flow-reversals. Analysis indicates that the same performance and a more robust dynamic operation may be obtained in a cooled folded countercurrent reactor than in a regular one [18]. Gilles' group has developed a novel countercurrent reactor configuration, called the circulation reactor [ 19]. The original development of the RFR was for trapping of a hot-temperature zone within the reactor. It is also possible to use this operation for trapping of reactant zones. Agar and Ruppel [20] proposed to conduct a reverse-flow operation in which a zone of an adsorbed reactant, rather than a high temperature, is trapped in the reactor and used to destroy environmental pollutants. They proposed to use the RFR for isothermal, catalytic destruction of NO by the selective catalytic reaction (SCR), NO
+
NH 3 + 1/4 02 --)'N2 + 1.5 H20
AH = -407 KJ/mol.,
exploiting the catalyst's strong adsorption capacity of the ammonia. The periodic operation consists of four steps. In the first, ammonia in excess of the stoichiometric amount is added to the pollutant stream fed to the bed. In the second step, only the NO is fed to the reactor, and it reacts with the adsorbed excess ammonia. At the end of the semicycle, the flow direction is reversed and the first two steps are repeated. This periodic operation forms a trapped region of adsorbed ammonia in the bed. This periodic operation enables a tight control and prevention of ammonia slip, even under sudden changes in the load or NO concentration. The success of such a process depends on the availability of a catalyst with a high adsorption capacity of the added reactant under the desired operating conditions. In order to form sharp concentration fronts, the reactant adsorption rate should be comparable to that of the reaction, and its desorption rate should be much slower.
78 Agar and Ruppel [20] described the removal of about 1000 mg/m 3 of NO from a feed fed at a space velocity of 300 1/hr to such a RFR. During the first step, ammonia at a concentration of about 2000 ppm was added to the feed for 67 minutes. The ammonia feed was then stopped for the next 83 minutes, following which the flow direction was reversed and the two steps were repeated. The NO conversion exceeded 99% and the effluent contained less that 1 ppm of ammonia. Noskov et aL [21] pointed out that several safety problems are associated with the process. Specifically, ammonium salts that form below 80 ~ C can decompose at higher temperatures. They suggested circumventing this problem by introducing the ammonia to the hot central section of the reactor, rather than at the reactor ends. Snyder and Subramanian [22] have shown that the operation may be more efficiently conducted by injecting the ammonia as a side stream. Significant industrial interest exists in the application of an SCR process for the destruction of Nox. The RFR mode of operation is a promising SCR reactor configuration. Its application would depend on the familiarity and understanding of design engineers of the potential advantages of this periodic mode of operation. Several differences exist between that of trapping a reactant and a high-temperature zone. When an exothermic reaction is carried out in a RFR, increasing the feed temperature increases the maximum temperature of the trapped zone. However, increasing the feed concentration does not increase the maximum concentration of the trapped reactant zone it merely broadens it. Moreover, the width of the trapped concentration zone changes during each semicycle, which consists of two steps. At the 2000 Los Angeles AIChE annual meeting, Bjornborn proposed using the RFR operation for "homogeneous catalyst-trapping." He suggested trapping within a RFR an expensive organometallic catalyst that is reversibly attached to an inert support in order to decrease the rate of catalyst-loss from the loss that occurs in a unidirectional operation. This process may be used to produce fine organic chemicals. Since the catalyst is not consumed by the reaction, it is not possible in this case to obtain sharp fronts that bound the zone containing the catalyst. In fact, dispersion will broaden this trapped catalyst region. It will be interesting to find out if a successful application of this catalysttrapping can be accomplished. This suggested process is just another example of a potential application of a periodic operation. It is realistic to presume that several novel applications of the RFR operation will be commercialized in the future. Most previous theoretical studies of dynamic operating reactors used kinetic expressions obtained under steady-state operation. These models do not account for the detailed dynamics of the adsorption and desorption rate processes, and they may lead to erroneous predictions in periodic operation of the reactor. Thus, simulations of periodic processes may require use of kinetic models that are much more detailed than those used for predicting steady-state operation. These dynamic models also need to account for the rate of adsorption, desorption, and adsorption capacity of the catalyst. As mentioned above, the hot-temperature zone in a cooled RFR may exhibit complex dynamic features under
79 certain operating conditions [ 17]. It would be of interest to see whether complex dynamic behavior may be attained by a trapped concentration zone in an isothermal RFR, and under what conditions.
Fuel-Cell Systems William R. Grove, a British physicist, demonstrated in 1839 that a battery fed with oxygen and hydrogen can generate electricity. The fuel cell is a device that relies on electrochemistry to produce electrical power through noncombustive fuel oxidation. It consists of an anode and cathode separated by an electrolyte. Fuel (e.g., hydrogen) liberates electrons at the anode and forms ions that move towards the cathode. The ions react with oxygen at the cathode, forming water as a by-product. A catalyst such as platinum is usually added to the electrodes to increase the reaction rate. In 1950, Francis T. Bacon developed the first operational 5-kilowatt fuel cell. The first major application of fuel cells was by NASA in the Gemini and Apollo flights. The fuel-cell technology promises many advantages, such as high energy-conversion efficiency, very low chemical and noise pollution, fuel flexibility, cogeneration capacity, modular design, rapid load response, and distributed capacity. The technology is being touted for various applications, including cleaner power for buses and cars; stationary large fuel cells for electric utilities and small ones for homes; and miniature fuel cells for cellular phones, laptop computers, camcorders, and other consumer products. Many research groups around the world are aggressively attempting to lower the price of fuel cells to enhance the competitive position of this technology. Ballard has recently developed a fuel cell for automobiles that costs about $275 per kilowatt. It is estimated that to penetrate the automobile market, their price should be below $50 per kilowatt [23]. The outcome of the efforts to develop economical fuel cells may alter the world energy map. The configuration and mode of operation of the reactors associated with various fuel cells are rather different from those of conventional chemical reactors. Their design and mode of operation raise many challenging reactor-design problems, which require creative application of chemical reaction engineering methodology and tools. Currently, the major force behind fuel-cell development is the huge potential market in the transportation industry. Passenger cars represent the largest potential market, as annual worldwide sales are about 30 million cars. The worldwide urban bus market is about 17,000 vehicles sold annually, of which about 30% are sold in the USA. A major advantage of fuel cells is a more efficient and clean operation of automobiles, and virtually every major manufacturer is now working on the technology. Early demonstration vehicles operated by fuel cells are already on the road. Among others, several prototype Ballard fuel-cell buses have been operated and tested during the last two years in Chicago and Vancouver. Daimler-Benz and Ford expect to produce 100,000 fuel-cell-powered vehicles annually by 2005. The London based Zero Emissions Vehicle Co. (Zeveco) has been testing a prototype fuel-cell-driven taxi.
80 At present, it appears that fuel cells on automobiles will most probably use hydrogen as the fuel. While other fuels may, in principle, be used, their products deactivate the current cells. The leading technology for automobile fuel cells is the proton-exchange membrane (PEM), which uses synthetic polymers as the electrolyte. The membrane needs to be thin, and impermeable to both the fuel and oxygen. Currently, the membranes are made of a fluoropolymer (Nation) on which sulfuric acid groups are stung and supported on a water-repelling mesh (to prevent the membrane from becoming soggy and expanding). The cathode of one cell and the anode of an adjacent cell are separated by a plate that connects them electrically in series. Special gas channels or porous materials are used to distribute the hydrogen and oxygen to the electrodes on each side of the plate. The thickness of an assembly is of the order of 2.5 mm. A series of assemblies and plates is bolted together to a stack that supplies the power. The 45%-60% energy efficiency of the PEM cells is approximately 25% higher than that of the internal combustion engine. The high price of the platinum needed in the fuel cell is a major factor holding back commercial application. Considerable efforts are dedicated at present to reduce the large amount of expensive platinum catalyst needed in these cells to enhance their competitive position relative to that of internal combustion engines. Moreover, the worldwide production of platinum is not sufficient to provide each new car with a PEM fuel cell, unless the amount of platinum needed per cell can be reduced. Zeveco is pursuing the use of alkaline fuel cells, the platinum used in which is one-fifth of that of the PEM models. If fuel cells are to be widely used in vehicles, it is essential to develop on-board efficient hydrogen-storage or-production systems. About 3 kilograms of hydrogen are needed to drive a small car 500 kilometers. At a pressure of 200 atm, this would require a 180-liter tank. Another option is to use liquefied hydrogen. This will reduce the volume of the fuel tank but will lead to about 30% loss in the energy efficiency. Another solution is absorb the hydrogen by metal hydrides or nanotubes. Two other important impediments facing hydrogen-powered vehicles are the lack of infrastructure for delivering them, and safety considerations. Extensive research is currently directed at developing fuel cells that generate the fuel on board from a cartier fuel, such as methanol or even gasoline. The development of these compact reforming reactors is a major challenge for reaction engineers. Gasoline is an obvious fuel option, as the infrastructure for delivering it to cars exists. This option will require the development of a compact reformer that can handle the large mix of hydrocarbons in the gasoline and the impurities present in it. The steam required for the reforming will be generated by burning some of the fuel. This application will require an efficient removal of sulfur-containing compounds to avoid poisoning the catalyst in proton-exchange membrane cells. The technological problems associated with the development of such a reformer have led to the search for other alternative fuels. At present, major efforts are directed at the use of methanol as the fuel. While its energyrelease is only half of that of gasoline, it can be handled and transported more easily than hydrogen. A possible solution is to reform methanol with steam at 280 ~ C in the presence
81 of a catalyst, and burning some of the hydrogen to produce the steam. Phosphoric-acid cells can work well with a methanol-reformer because their relatively high operating temperature can be exploited to provide the steam; this enables them to resist poisoning by a small amount of carbon monoxide. It is much more difficult to combine methanolreforming with a proton-exchange membrane fuel cell, as an additional step is needed to avoid poisoning by the carbon-monoxide product. Major improvements in the reformer are needed. The design of an efficient reformer that produces hydrogen on board a car from a cartier fuel such as methanol or gasoline is a major technological challenge. Its success and wide application will have tremendous economic impact. The use of a reformer on cars will also enhance public understanding and interest in the operation of chemical reactors. Stationary fuel cells have been developed for use by utilities, industrial facilities, and homes. They can use a variety of fuels, and they operate relatively cleanly and silently. Unfortunately, the stationary fuel cell costs about $3000 per kilowatt, as compared to $500-$1000 for the combustion turbines commonly used by utilities [24]. As the concerns mount about the effects of greenhouse gases from power plants, a wider use of fuel cells is expected. The stationary fuel cells usually require use of an external or internal reformer to convert the fuel to a feed suitable for the reaction at the anode. While the reformer emits some pollutants, that level of release is much smaller (between a tenth to a thousandth) than that in a conventional combustion turbine. The energy efficiency of the fuel cell may be increased by recovering the waste heat. Five types of stationary fuel cells have been developed: phosphoric acid, molten carbonate, solid oxide, protonexchange membrane, and alkine [24]. The phosphoric-acid fuel cell is the most mature technology. However, its high price of about $4000/kilowatt and the even higher price of the alkaline fuel cells have motivated the search for other technologies. These include molten carbonate, proton-exchange membrane and solid-oxide fuel cells (SOFCs). The SOFC operates at high temperatures (around 1000 ~ C ) in order to enable the oxygen ions to migrate through a ceramic membrane to the anode. This high temperature requires use of very expensive materials. Recently reported advances [25] may enable operation at the much lower range of 6000-700 ~ C. The goal of the research in this area is to reduce their cost to about $400/kilowatt, which is in the ballpark of plants operating with natural gas. The development of more-efficient fuel cells will require development of new materials, reactor configurations and modes of operation, and creative utilization of the waste heat. This presents a great challenge and opportunity for the Reaction Engineering community to lead a major technological breakthrough.
Polyolefin synthesis The use of metallocene catalysts revolutionized the synthesis of polyolefins [26]. These catalysts consist of two ring molecules connected by a metal (Wilkinson catalyst). The two metallocene tings are also sometimes connected by a bridge molecule. The industrial applications of these catalysts was motivated by the discovery by Prof. Kaminsky, who
82 discovered that their activity can be increased by several orders of magnitude by the presence of a co-catalyst, methylalumoxane (MAO). A major advantage of these catalysts is that they enable a control chemistry (stero-regulation) and rational engineering of the polymer stero, which affects their properties. This control is achieved via changes in either the ring structure, the ring substitute, the presence and type of bridge, or the metal connecting the two tings. For example, polypropylene (PP) has the same backbone as polyethylene, with the exception that a methyl group is sticking out at each pair of carbons. The PP may be either syndiotactic, so that the methyl groups are added on alternating sides of the polymer; isotactic, so that all the methyl groups are always on the same side of the polymer chain; or hemi-isotactic. Ewen [27] provided several examples of this stero-regulation. Additionally, the metallocene catalysts have the ability to produce polymers and copolymers that cannot be synthesized by the Ziegler-Natta catalysts. These advantages and the high rate that they offer have led to the use of metallocene catalysts in many processes. This use has motivated extensive industrial research activity to generate novel products and processes, as well as academic research of their performance. Gaseous polymerization of polyolefins is carried out in fluidized-bed reactors. The conversion per pass is kept rather low (order of 2%) so that the heat of polymerization is removed via convection by the unconverted reactants, which are cooled externally and recycled to the reactor. In some cases, an inert liquid is added to the feed so that its evaporation helps remove some of the heat of the reaction. The Unipol process is one of the most common processes used to carry out this gaseous polymerization. Other processes for producing polyolefins include Hypol, Novolen, Catalloy and Spheriline.
R
R H
Me2
CI ..
CI
structure syndiotactic
r.-.9
I-
[
I
r, I
1
[~,. .u. .~
1-- 1
t-butyl
isotactic
LIA.... I I I 1.......t
methyl
hemiisotactic
[ J I ' I ~ I ' I
!
I
l
Figure 3: Stereo-regulation of polypropylene structure by a metallocene catalyst, after Ewen [27] These processes have been used successfully for many years to carry out gas-phase polymerization of p01yolefins using the Ziegler-Natta catalysts. It was expected that replacement of the Ziegler-Natta by metallocene catalysts in fluidized-bed reactors will be rather straightforward. However, the adaptation of the more active metallocenes to existing commercial fluidized-bed reactors led to many operational problems. For
83 example, it was reported [25] that technical problems led Exxon to declare force major on the production of polyethylene by metallocene at its Mont Belvieu plant in May 1997. The heat carried by the hot, recycled, unconverted ethylene is usually removed in watercooling towers. Thus, the feed temperature to the fluidized-bed reactor is usually in the range of 20~ ~ C, while the melting temperature of polyethylene (depending on the type) is about 450-50 ~ C. Thus, the exothermic polymerization in the fluidized-bed reactors has to be carried out at a rather narrow temperature range to avoid melting or softening of the polymer. One operational problem that hampered the operation of various fluidized-bed reactors using metallocenes was the formation of sheets of fused polymer (sheeting), which required termination of the operation. The sheeting occurs due to the temperature-increase of some particles, which in turn causes the polymer to melt or soften. This causes the sticking of other particles to it. The decreased surface-area-tovolume ratio of this lump of particles further increases its temperature and leads to the formation of a sheet of molten polymer. Several explanations have been proposed for the formation of these sheets of molten polymer, but it has not yet been established what exactly initiates and causes this undesirable event. One proposed explanation is that an electrostatic field attracts small particles to the reactor walls. This, in turn, decreases their velocity and heat-transfer coefficient, which leads to the excessive temperature-rise. Another explanation is that fine particles settle on the expended part of the reactor. The decreased heat-transfer rate of the settled particles and the high reaction rate of these fine particles cause their overheating. The resulting molten or soften polymer initiates sheet-formation. This sheet-formation clearly illustrates the potential problems that may be encountered during use of an existing reactor configuration to conduct the same reaction but with a more active catalyst. It is essential that we enhance our understanding of this deleterious sheeting in order to prevent its occurrence in novel processes utilizing this superior catalyst. The interaction of diffusion and reaction in heterogeneous catalysts is very well understood at present and can be reliably be predicted. Unfortunately, we still lack complete understanding and ability to predict all the interactions among the various rate processes occurring on growing polymer particles. The metallocene and MAO are usually supported on small silica particles (diameter of the order of 50g). As the polymer forms in the pores of the support, it fragments the support to smaller particles. The outward motion of these fragments enables the growing particle to maintain a high activity in spite of the continuous growth of the particle diameter. (The diameter of the polymer particle is usually at least ten times larger than that of the silica catalyst particle.) In the absence of this fragmentation and movement, the diffusional resistance would significantly decrease the reaction rate as the diameter size becomes larger. A recent description of the fragmentation can be found in [28]. It is essential to develop a better ability to predict the dependence of this fragmentation on the properties of the catalyst and the polymerization reaction rate. Too rapid a fragmentation may generate fine
84 particles, which can initiate sheeting. Moreover, it may distort the shape of the particle and hence of the product, which usually replicates that of the catalyst pellet. Another puzzling effect is the sharp increase in the polyethylene activity following the addition of a small amount of a comonomer (such as 1-hexene). The explanation may be due to polymer swelling which increases both the solubility and diffusivity of the ethylene. However, it may be due to a kinetic effect, such as an increase in the propagation rate constant or secondary site activation. The cause may of course be a combination of the physical and chemical effects The determination of the cause of this effect and ability to predict its impact is of both industrial importance and intrinsic academic interest. At present, the interaction of diffusion and reaction in a growing polymer particle is usually described by the multi-grain model [29,30], multi-layer model [31], or some modification of either. These models do not account for any of the rate processes that cause the fragmentation of the catalyst. Thus, they are unable to explain, let alone predict, the known impact of the mechanical properties and structure of the support on the observed reaction rate. It is important to enhance our understanding of the interaction between the reaction transport and catalyst fragmentation in order to enable an optimal choice of the support. Many commercial heterogeneous catalysts are not impregnated in a uniform fashion. For example, various precious-metal catalysts consist of an exterior active shell and an inert core in order to enhance the effectiveness factor. Several automobile-muffler catalysts have a carbon-monoxide-oxidation catalyst in one shell and an NOx-reducing catalyst in another shell. Our understanding of the reaction-diffusion interaction facilitated this rational design of the optimal profile of catalyst-activity distribution and shape. It would be of both practical importance and academic interest to develop a rational procedure for enhancing the performance of metallocenes by their nonuniform impregnation on the support.
Concluding remarks The examples presented here illustrate that application of novel reactor configurations and modes of operation present reaction engineers with important opportunities and challenges. The specific cases discussed here are of important applications, but not necessarily the most important or promising ones. Many future reactor-design and operational innovations are expected to involve nontraditional areas of application. The fuel-cell systems discussed here constitute one example, but many others exist, such as the synthesis of electronic materials and controlled drug-release. A recent novel reactor configuration not discussed here is miniature reactors. These may find novel applications in the production of hazardous chemicals at a site at which they are reacted; in military gas masks to neutralize toxic gases; as a tool in combinatorial catalysis and miniature fuel-cell systems for consumer products; etc. I am convinced that many important
85 contributions will be made in the future by imaginative engineers developing novel reactor configurations and creative, novel modes of operation.
Acknowledgments I would like to thank the National Science Foundation for continued support of my research in reaction engineering.
References 1. C.N. Satterfield, Heterogeneous Catalysis in Industrial Practice, 2 nd edition, McGrawHill, New York (1991 ). 2. L.D. Schmidt, M. Huff and S.S. Bharadwaj, Chem. Eng. Sci., 49 (1994), 3981. 3. O. Duetschmann and L.D. Schmidt, AIChE J., 44 (1998), 2465. 4. A.S. Bassi, C.L. Briens, A.I.M. Bergougnou, "Proc. 4 th Intl. Conf. of CFB" (A. Avidan, ed.), AIChE, New York (1993). 5. D.B. Bartholic, U.S. Patent #2,121,733 (1991). 6. P. Sahm, PhD thesis, Institute National Polytechnique de Lorraine, Nancy (1978). 7. G. Tosun, 6th Europ. Conf. on Mixing, Pavia, Italy, (1988), 161. 8. B.E. Claybaugh, J.R. Griffin and A.T. Watson, U.S. patent #3,472,829 (1969). 9. W.K. Lewis, E.R. Gilliland and W.A. Reed, Ind. Eng. Chem., 41 (1949), 1227. 10. J.L. Callahan, R.K. Grasselli, E.C. Milberger and H.A. Strecker, Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev., 9 (1970), 134. 11. R.M. Contractor, U.S. patent #5,021,588 (1991). 12. Y.S. Matros and G.A. Bunimovich, Catal. Rev.-Sci Eng., 38 (1996). 13. A.M. de Groote, G.F. Froment and T. Koblinski, Can. J. Chem. Eng., 74 (1996), 735. 14. O. Levenspiel, Chem. Eng. Sci., 43 (1988), 1427. 15. G. Kolios and G. Eigenberger, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999), 2637. 16. M.S. Kulkarni and M.P. Dudukovig, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 37 (1998), 770. 17. J. Khinast, Y.O. Jeong and D. Luss, AIChE J., 45 (1999), 299. 18. R. Garg, D. Luss and J.G. Khinast, AIChE J.,46 (2000), 2030. 19. X. Hua, M. Mangold, A. Kienle and E.D. Gilles, Chem. Eng. Sci., 53 (1998), 47. 20. D. Agar and W. Ruppel, Chem. Eng. Sci. 43 (1988), 2073. 21. A.S. Noskov, L.N. Bobrova and Y.S. Matros, Cat. Today, 17 (1993), 293. 22. J.D. Snyder and B. Subramanian, Chem. Eng. Sci., 53 (1998), 727. 23. J. Appelby, Sci. Amer., 281 (July 1999), 74. 24. A.C. Lloyd, Sci. Amer., 281 (July 1999), 80. 25. R.F. Service, Science, 288 (2000), 1957. 26. Chem. Week (21 May 1997), 23. 27. Ewen, Sci. Amer., 276 (May 1997), 86. 28. J. Zechlin, B. Steimetz, B. Tesche, G. Fink, Macromol. Chem. Phys., 201 (2000), 515. 29. I. Yermakov and V. Zakharov, Adv. Cat., 24 (1975), 173. 30. S. Floyd, K.Y. Choi, T.W. Taylor and W. H. Ray, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 31 (1986), 2231. 31. J.B.P. Soares and A.E. Hamielec, Polym. React. Eng., 3 (1995), 261.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studiesin SurfaceScienceand Catalysis133 G.F. Fromentand K.C.Waugh(Editors) Publishedby ElsevierScienceB.V.,2001
87
New methodologies and reactors for catalytic process development M. P. Harold a, P. L. Mills b and J. F. Nicole b aDepartment of Chemical Engineering, University of Houston, 4800 Calhoun St., Houston, TX 77204-4792 USA
bDuPontCompany, Central Research and Development, Experimental Station, E304/A204 Wilmington, DE 19880-0304 USA Recent advances in the development and application of laboratory-scale reactor systems that are intended to accelerate the discovery and development of new catalytic processes are summarized and analyzed. Emphasis is placed upon multiphase gas-solid and gas-liquid systems that use either solid heterogeneous or soluble homogeneous catalysts since these provide the basis for most of the existing and anticipated future process technologies. The emerging role of various reactor configurations and supporting devices that are intended to accelerate discovery of new catalyst compositions is also reviewed. The impact of this approach on the next level of catalytic process development and future challenges is also discussed. 1. INTRODUCTION
1.1. Background The manufacture of a large variety of intermediate and end-products used in commercial and consumer applications is largely based upon process technology where either a soluble organometallic complex or solid heterogeneous catalyst is used to transform reactants into value-added materials. Examples of products and technologies where catalytic processes are widely used include petroleum processing, bulk and commodity chemicals, rubber and plastic products, specialty chemicals and pharmaceuticals, and processes for conversion of undesired by-products from stationary or mobile emission sources into environmentally friendly or recyclable products [ 1]. These products and technologies had shipments that were valued at $US 6.4 x 1011 with chemicals and allied products accounting for nearly one-half of this total [2]. Within the latter category of products, the greatest value was created by sales of drugs, industrial organic chemicals, and plastic materials and synthetics, which is illustrated in Figure 1 [3]. Most of the processes used in these and other related technologies are based on multiphase reaction systems with reactants and products existing as gas, liquid, and/or solid phases along with soluble or solid catalysts. Various reviews summarize catalyst technology commercialized in the United States, Europe and the Far East within the past decade [4-8]. These developments, along with information on the economic drivers associated with the products from these processes, leads to the conclusion that catalyst science and reaction engineering technology are essential for existing processes to maintain economic viability, and for creation of the next generation of efficient processes.
88
Fig. 1. Relative distribution of the shipment value of chemicals and allied products.
1.2. Catalyst development cycle It is generally accepted that discovery, development, and commercialization of catalyst technology for either an existing process or for a novel breakthrough route requires laborious and painstaking efforts by a dedicated team of technologists. Even if diligence and the latest tools for invention are utilized, a breakthrough is not guaranteed. An overview of the various activities that are typically involved in the evolution of a new process catalyst are shown in Figure 2. Each of the phases of the catalyst invention (i.e., discovery, development and commercialization) effort is analogous to a catalytic cycle with both feed-forward and feedback of information. Research
Commercial
Market
Concept "~r ~ Input Catalyst
Application
Modification~,I~ Evaluations~ , ~ \
~-
Catalyst , . .
Synthesis ~..~ Catalyst Characterization
Preliminary ~ Process Economics |
Lab Reactor
Detailed Process Economics
Ra~pldCatalyst ~\9~ Catalyst ~ _~~ 9 ~. BaslcJ~~n " Life _~More Detailed Screening
Discovery "GoodScience.
Kinetics
.
1"
Studies
--~
9Development . .
Kinetics
Pilot-Plant Evaluation
-'~ Catalyst Scale-Up
~ Commercialization
Good Engineering"
Fig. 2. Catalyst invention activities from discovery, development through commercialization.
89 As shown in the upper left of Figure 2, the impetus for discovery of a new catalyst occurs from a new concept that emanates from either research or business-driven market needs. In the discovery stage, new catalyst compositions must be postulated using either knowledge of the given chemistry or by use of previous experience with a related chemical system. The resulting catalyst compositions are synthesized, characterized using various analytical techniques, and subjected to a first level of performance evaluation using a lab-scale catalyst testing system. The information derived from these experiments, such as reactant conversion, product selectivity or yield, activity and global reaction rate can be used to provide basic information needed to obtain a preliminary estimate of the reaction kinetics. The latter information is sometimes used as a key input for assessment of preliminary process economics from which realistic targets for catalyst performance during the discovery stage of research can be surmised. Once a catalyst that meets the minimum required performance standards is identified, the research effort is then shit~ed from discovery toward a development type of activity as shown in the middle cycle. Hence, more detailed evaluation of the catalyst candidates is conducted using a more sophisticated reactor system. This system should be designed so it can provide experimental data that can be used as the basis for discrimination between various proposed kinetic mechanisms and the associated kinetic rate parameters. It should also be capable of providing information on catalyst activity versus time-on-stream for quantification of catalyst deactivation. Since the cost of periodic catalyst replacement or regeneration to maintain plant productivity can have a significant impact on process economics, information on catalyst activity and the catalyst performance parameters over a range of activities is critical for identifying more precise catalyst research milestones. If the minimum required level of catalyst performance versus time-on-stream is not attained, it may be necessary for additional discovery work to be undertaken. Assuming that a catalyst having the required performance is identified that meets the criteria defined by process economics, the development effort can now be focused on the efforts shown in the commercialization part of the development cycle shown in Figure 2. The key activities here include scale-up of the catalyst recipe, performing additional catalyst performance evaluations in a pilot-scale reactor system, interpretation of reaction kinetics and catalyst deactivation, reactor modeling, and translation of these results into a form that can be used to create a more accurate process economic model. It can be surmised that the catalyst would most likely be subjected to a more harsh reaction environment when compared to previous discovery and development cycles. Hence, the potential for unforeseen factors to have a negative impact on catalyst performance increases at this final and critical stage of development. This may require ongoing research effort to solve any issues around the catalyst itself, such as recipe modification, preparation variables, and activation protocol. Once the catalyst meets the specifications that have been defined for commercialization, the technical team responsible for incorporation of the catalyst into the full-scale process would take the lead.
1.3. Catalyst development methodologies The above discussion suggests that utilization of a sequential approach for catalyst discovery and development reactor selection, and catalytic process design would not be preferred since it would be too time consuming and hence difficult to justify from a project funding perspective. A parallel approach in which various key activities in the catalyst discovery, development and commercialization cycles are simultaneously initiated with
90 closely coupled interaction between the cycles is clearly needed to be economically justified. This paradigm of conducting simultaneous catalyst development, reactor selection, and process synthesis is embedded in the concepts first set forth by Villermaux [9] and later expanded by Lerou and Ng [10]. However, before any serous efforts can be devoted to reaction engineering and postulation of various process concepts, an experimental lead that demonstrates feasibility for the catalytic chemistry of interest is preferred. In the last few years, the development and implementation of parallel or high throughput screening methods for catalyst discovery have gained increasing attention. This is partly supported by Figure 3, which shows that a notable increase in the number of US patents that are generally concerned with the development and application of combinatorial methods for catalyst discovery or development. The application of these methods in catalysis is an extension of similar concepts that have been used to accelerate drug discovery in pharmaceuticals research [ 11]. Most of the open literature on high-throughput combinatorial catalysis is concerned with development of the experimental hardware and demonstration of a proof-of-concept by using a particular gas-solid model reaction. While significant progress is being made toward developing and using high-throughput combinatorial catalysis methods, there have been no company announcements to commercialize a breakthrough process where the key catalyst invention is based on this approach. 250 200 150 100 50 =
~
9 ~--~=-~~,
1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 Year
Fig. 3. Number of US patents yearly issued containing the words "combinatorial" and "catalyst". The main objective of this paper is to provide an overview of recent developments in experimental techniques, supporting devices, and data handling methods as applied to highthroughput combinatorial methods in the context of catalytic process development. Emphasis is placed upon developments that apply to gas-solid and gas-liquid multiphase catalyzed chemistry owing to their technological importance both now and in the future. Another objective is to present a brief overview of various advanced experimental reactors that can provide unique data for a particular catalytic system, but are not yet designed as highthroughput devices. Future needs and areas where advances in experimental devices, analytical methods, and informatics would be useful for accelerating the invention of the next generation of commercial catalytic processes are also discussed.
91 2. HIGH-THROUGHPUT EXPERIMENTAL DEVICES Implementation of high-throughput methods for catalyst discovery and development has prompted the creation of new experimental devices for catalyst synthesis and catalytic performance evaluation. These systems have provided the impetus for development of various devices and methods that are used as sensors, control elements, and analytical characterization, to name a few. ~In this section, an overview is given on the various research tools that have been reported in the literature that address the above aspects of highthroughput methods.
2.1. Catalyst library synthesis One of the claimed advantages of using a combinatorial method for catalyst library synthesis is that it allows, in principle, all possible combinations of the experimental variables to be generated and evaluated. This is a significant departure from the conventional serial approach for generating catalyst candidates in which the composition, preparation, activation, and other variables are studied one at a time. The possible number of combinations is given by Nr = n!/[r!.(n-r)!] where n is the total number of variables and r is the total number of independent variables. Hence a catalyst library containing five elements with eleven discrete compositions would require generation of 1,001 discrete samples. The effort that would be required to accomplish this task using manual synthetic techniques by a single researcher would most likely require at least six months. Development and application of specialpurpose devices for generation of catalyst samples that use parallel high-throughput methods are essential for development of a database that can be used to guide a discovery. The requirements for generation of heterogeneous catalyst libraries are more demanding when compared to soluble organometallic complexes for several reasons [12]: (1) the final heterogeneous catalyst structure exists far from an equilibrium state; (2) heterogeneous catalysts are strongly affected by the synthetic procedures, activation protocol, and other reaction environment procedures; and (3) the elemental or molecular building blocks used to generate the desired composition are often ill-defined from a solid-state structural characterization perspective. Other differentiating factors are that homogeneous catalysis draws upon a large technology base from organic and organometallic chemistry whereas heterogeneous catalysis relies upon a relatively small knowledge base from synthetic inorganic and solid-state chemistry [12]. Hence, different combinatorial approaches must be applied to these two catalyst classes. Some illustrations of the differences between homogeneous organometallic and heterogeneous combinatorial approaches can be seen in recent review by Jandeleit et al. [ 13]. Preparation of catalyst libraries for the discovery phase can be broadly divided into two categories: (1) solution-based methods, and (2) thin-film deposition/based methods. The solution-based methods include those that utilize: (1) multi-tasking robotic workstations [ 1416]; (2) inkjet printhead technology [17], and (3) microjet technology [18]. The thin-film deposition-based methods employ electron beam and thermal evaporation, sputtering, pulsed laser ablation, and chemical vapor deposition (see [60] in [13] for a list of references). A detailed discussion of how these have been applied is provided elsewhere [13]. Web sites provide links to various aspects of combinatorial chemistry (www.combichem.net and www.5z.com). Here, the hardware aspects are lightly sketched. A typical commercially-available multi-tasking robotic workstation for high-throughput solution-based synthesis is shown in Figures 4a and 4b. The key hardware features include:
92 (1) two independent piercing probes for pipetting liquid solutions; (2) reaction blocks containing 6-2m vials where m = 0, ..., 4; (3) a built-in orbital shaker; (4) independently controlled filtration stations for solid-phase unit processes; (5) six on-line solvent sources; (6) inert gas blanketing; and (7) two independent reagent racks that can accommodate up to 60 glass vials. The system software allows a synthesis strategy to be designed and downloaded for implementation through a convenient user interface. Details are available elsewhere [ 14].
A typical array of heterogeneous catalyst powders for a three-component metal oxide that was generated using a robotic workstation is shown in Figure 5. In this example, the reaction block containing the solution was manually placed in a heated vacuum oven and evaporated to dryness. Additional unit operations are needed before the powders can be tested in a catalytic reactor. Typical ones include: (1) removal of the powder from each array holder; (2) additional drying and calcination; (3) granulation and sieving to the desired particle size; and (4) transfer and loading a predetermined amount of catalyst granules into the catalytic reactor. These steps assume that catalyst activation is either performed in situ or not included as part of the testing protocol. Future advances in robotic systems will most likely be able to perform all of the above steps, since these consume the greatest of the total time required to prepare the catalysts for testing. Figure 6 shows a commercially available robotic system that can automatically dispense precise quantities of a powder into a rack of vials, which is one of the time-consuming steps involved in reactor loading. However, this particular system is designed to dispense a single powder into multiple vials as typically encountered in pharmaceutical discovery research. In catalyst discovery, the robotic design would require modification to handle multiple powders that would be created in a synthesis robot. A key requirement would be to minimize cross sample contamination. The utility of using one of the thin-film deposition methods is that handling of liquid and solids-laden is avoided. This may seem as reducing the complexity, but other concerns are introduced. Some of these concerns include obtaining a source of organometallic species that contain the elements of interest, design and safe operation of a vacuum system for containment and delivery of the vapors to the desired surface location, and whether or not the resulting mixed-metal layer structure exhibits catalytic activity that mimics one synthesized using solution-phase methods. These and other related issues are partly discussed in [13] from the context of materials applications versus catalysis.
93
2.2. Combinatorial screening techniques Various techniques have been proposed in the literature for high-throughput screening of catalyst candidates. These techniques can be broadly classified according to a particular type of multiphase catalytic reaction system. This system includes gas-solid reactions, gas-liquid catalyzed reactions, and multiphase polymerization reactions. In this section, recent progress in development of novel hardware configurations will be reviewed.
Gas-solid catalytic techniques. Development of experimental techniques for highthroughput screening of gas-solid catalyzed reactions have received the most attention when compared to either gas-liquid catalyzed or polymerization reaction systems. The two key :lifferences between the techniques for gas-solid systems are in the analytical methods used to extract one or more standard measures of catalyst performance, such as activity, conversion, or selectivity, and the catalyst form that is used. Table 1 gives a summary of the various techniques along with their distinguishing features. The use of a scanning mass spectrometer to detect reaction products from a catalyst array was pioneered by researchers at Symyx Technologies [20-27] who used various model reactions to demonstrate feasibility. Figure 7 shows two of the key system features of the Symyx device that is designed for catalyst discovery [24]. A sectional view of the reaction chamber is shown in Figure 7a which shows the scanning mass spectrometer and a movable surface that contains the catalysts library. Figure 7b shows the method used to expose a particular library member to reaction gas and the subsequent transfer of the product gas to the scanning mass spectrometer. Heating is accomplished by using a selective IR source so that adjacent library members are not in the source beam. This technique was recently applied to screen ternary noble metal catalysts for the oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane [26, 27]. The same concept of using a precision mass spec probe positioning system to sample the reaction product gas from a high-density monolith array has also been described [28], which is shown in Figures 8a and 8b. A system that uses reactors manufactured using microfabrication technology coupled to a mass spec capillary sniffing device has also been demonstrated [29]. An automated high throughput design that can accommodate 10 to 100 micro fixed-bed reactors where each uses up to 5 ml of catalyst powder with sequential sampling of the reaction product gas has been recently commercialized [36]. It can also be
94 customized so that a user-specified analytical device, such as a gas chromatograph or mass spectrometer, can be used. A custom-designed rapid-screening system that used 10 fixed-bed microreactors to identify preferred metal oxide catalysts for the oxidative dehydrogenation of propane was described by Baems and co-workers [28, 37]. Table 1. High throughput screening methods for gas-solid catalyzed systems Method
Substrate
Scanning MS
Si Wafers, Quartz Ceramic monolith Mixed oxide Metals, Ceramics, Glass,... Catalyst support
Scanning MS Stationary MS Scanning MS
REMPI Resonance Enhanced Multiphoton Ionization IR Thermography Alumina disk
Catalyst Form Film
Sampling Mode Sequential
Method of Detection Quadrupole MS
Ref.
[20-
27] Film
i Sequential Quadrupole MS
[28]
Particles Films, particles,
Sequential i Quadrupole MS Sequential i Quadrupole MS
. [28] [29]
Particles
Particles on ),-alumina AMM AMM
IR Thermography Slate Slate Emissivity Corrected IR Thermography (ECIRT) Particles Mixed Parallel oxides, micro reactor supports, ... Particles Mixed Parallel oxides, micro reactor supports,... Film Fluorescence Film FT-IR imaging AMM: Amorphous microporous mixed oxides
Parallel
Microelectrodes with REMPI,
[3032]
Parallel
TOF MS for product verification IR camera
[33]
Parallel Parallel
IR camera IR camera
[34] [35]
Sequential
GC, FT-IR, MS
[36]
Sequential
Multiport valve with MS
[28, 37]
Parallel Parallel
Fluorescence FT-IR
[38] [39]
Another approach that allows parallel screening to be conducted using IR thermography has been investigated as an alternate to the use of mass spectroscopy [33-35]. This method monitors the heat changes that occur as a result of the heat of reaction on the catalyst library surfaces. One of the claimed advantages of this method is that the activity of the catalyst library is monitored as a function of time-on-stream in parallel. However, no information on reactant conversion or product selectivity is obtained so that ranking is based upon
95 temperature versus time data. Using this basis could be misleading depending upon the type of catalytic chemistry that is under investigation.
Fig. 7a. Partial sectional view of the reaction chamber showing the scanning mass spectrometer and library [24].
Fig. 7b. Detailed view of the method used for exposing a library member to the reaction gas and reactor heating [24].
An illustration of the above point is shown in Figure 9a where the selectivities of C02 and maleic anhydride relative to n-butane are compared versus time-on-stream using a fresh vanadium-phosphorus oxide catalyst prepared according to an early patent [40]. The experiment was conducted in a laboratory-scale fixed-bed microreactor at 380~ using a feed containing 9% n-butane, 10% oxygen, 9% nitrogen and 72% helium. The catalyst initially exhibits high selectivity for n-butane to CO2, which is a highly exothermic reaction with (-AHr = 664 kcal/mole). As the catalyst undergoes a solid-state transformation with increasing time-on-stream to the active phase [41 ], the selectivity to maleic anhydride relative to CO2 increases. Figure 9b shows the total heat flow, based upon the addition of the heat flows from the butane oxidation to maleic anhydride reaction and the combustion of butane to CO2. The sudden increase of the heat flow that occurs during the initial part of the catalyst time-on-stream is a consequence of the reaction light-off. Thereafter, the behavior of the heat flow versus time on stream undergoes a slight increase, which is due to the increase in the catalyst activity and change in selectivity. Use of IR thermography for this particular reaction would lead to an incorrect conclusion on catalyst performance since the contribution of selective and non-selective reactions to the heat flow cannot be determined. Hence, the ability to measure product gas composition is essential to properly interpret catalyst performance data along with heat flow or temperature measurements. In summary, high-throughput methods for performing a first-level screening of gas-solid catalyzed reactions are in an early stage of development. Case studies where complex multicomponent catalysts have been identified for a reaction having commercial significance, such as a selective oxidation reaction, have not been reported in the open literature. Methods that allow conventional catalyst synthesis and any pre-treatment steps (e.g., drying, calcination, activation, size reduction, pelletization, etc.) to be conducted at high throughput have not been demonstrated. In addition, the direct coupling of a high-throughput powdered
96 catalyst synthesis system to a micro-fabricated catalyst screening unit that automates all of the unit sub-processes is an unsolved challenge.
Fig. 8a. Microreactor catalyst screening system.A: Array microreactor; B: Capillary sampling probe; C: Mass spectrometer; D: Catalyst pellets; E: Aluminum heating block; F: Insulation [28].
Fig. 8b. Monolith array for high-throughput catalyst discovery [28].
Gas-liquid catalytic techniques. Experimental techniques for high-throughput screening of gas-liquid reactions have been the subject of fewer studies when compared to those for gassolid systems. This mode of operation introduces another level of complexity for several reasons: (1) the magnitude of gas-to-liquid and liquid-to-solid external mass transfer resistances (in the case of heterogeneous catalysts) relative to the intrinsic kinetic resistance should be minimized; (2) in the case of heterogeneous catalysts, solids suspension should be uniform and internal catalyst diffusional resistances should be negligible relative to the interparticle and intrinsic particle resistances: (3) liquid volumes should be small enough to satisfy safety requirements and to minimize the demand for liquid reactants, but large enough so that the design and operation of an individual reactor does not introduce other difficulties; (4) analytical characterization of the reaction products is complicated by the presence of multiple phases, sample volume requirements, and reaction quenching after sampling; (5) operation at elevated temperature and pressure imposes limits on the selection of materials and reaction vessel design requirements; and (6) the choice of an appropriate catalyst loading (i.e., catalyst weight/liquid volume) that provides reasonable global reaction rates without creating mass transfer limitations is difficult without previous data. Other typical concerns that occur when dealing with microscale multiphase systems include the generation of adequate gas-liquid interfacial area through creation of micro bubbles, and creating ideal flow patterns for the gas, liquid and solid phases and maintaining an isothermal reaction environment. Table 2 gives a summary of the various techniques that have been recently proposed for high-throughput screening of gas-liquid catalyzed systems along with their distinguishing features. Figure 10 shows a multiple reactor station that can be used for either liquid phase or gas-liquid catalyzed, which is typical of commercially available systems and some of the systems described in Table 2. Most of these systems are intended for reactions that operate at relatively mild temperatures and atmospheric pressure, which are below the ranges of most commercial gas-liquid catalyzed systems [1, 4-7]. The only exception is the oxidation micro-
97 reactor described in [43], which can operate at 140~ and 10 atm of oxygen. This also points out one of the real advantages of using microreactors to study oxidation reactions, since the small volumes are safer and can be more easily operated in a normal laboratory versus a barricade. However, another issue is that on-line sampling and analysis of microscale gasliquid catalyzed reactors is more complicated than for gas-solid catalyzed microreactors. Capture of a consistent small sample volume, such as 1 to 10 ~tL, and transfer to an on-line analytical device, such as a GC or HPLC, requires the development of special methods that can handle multiple reactors. A special purpose on-line sampling valve that can capture these small volumes with flash vaporization into a GC transfer line was recently demonstrated [50]. This points to one of the future challenges for high-throughput screening methods of gasliquid catalyzed systems. 45
12
30
"~ 15
-
10
o
8
t~ fJ
._Z2
--
Maleic Anhydride
0
.I-
--CO2 r
T
-
.
-
~
5 10 15 Time-on-Stream, hr
6
~
20
I
0
i
l
5 10 15 Time-on-Stream, hr
20
Fig. 9b. Total heat flow versus time-onFig. 9a. Selectivity of maleic anhydride and stream. C02 versus time-on-stream. Conditions: Fresh vanadium-phosphorus oxide catalyst; feed = 9% n-butane, 10% 02, 9% Nz, 78% He, T = 380~ wc = 0.56 g, Q = 37.5 mL/min (NTP), x = 1 s. In summary, experimental systems for high-throughput screening of gas-liquid catalyzed reactions will require a significant development before they can be used on a routine bases under industrially relevant conditions. The work that has been done this far has been mainly focused upon demonstrations using relatively simple chemistries under mild reactions conditions. While it appears feasible to design and fabricate multiphase reactors that have volumes on the order of 1 mL or less, development of systems for catalyst handling, reactant addition, automation, control and on-line sampling with integrated and rapid product analysis have not been demonstrated. Polymerization techniques. High-throughput methods for discovery of new polymerization reactions and catalysts are also in an early stage of development, which is similar to gas-liquid catalyzed systems. Most of the efforts in this area in the open literature have been focused upon combinatorial approaches for olefin polymerization catalysts, which are reviewed in detail in [13]. In one case, a custom high pressure parallel polymerization reactor with a series of 48 reactions chambers was used for screening of ethylene polymerization catalyst performance (see figure 14 in [ 13]), analysis of the polyethylene was performed by high-speed gel permeation chromatography. A combinatorial approach for the synthesis of biocatalytic polymers was recently described [51]. It is expected that techniques that can be applied to a broader range of polymerization systems will soon emerge.
98 Table 2. High throughput screening methods for gas-liquid catalyzed systems.
Catalyst type
Method Description
Application
Analytical Method
Operating Range
Ref.
Immobilized lipase
10 mL stirred batch
Offline GC with FID
65-75~ wc = 0.03 g/ml X ~ 90%
[42]
Ag, Ni, Platinum metals
4 ~tL reactor channel
Diglycerol monolaurate ester synthesis Oxidation of benzyl alcohol
Thin film doped TiOa
96 wells with thin film catalyst
Hydrogen production from water
Chiral catalyst
96 well glass plate 25 stirred reactors
Chiral screening
WO3/Pd Chemooptical sensor Imaging polarimetry Off line GC
..
Catalyst powder 50 ~tm catalyst particles or structured array Homogeneous or heterogeneous
Micro machined packed-bed reactor 12 stirred glass tubes
3 -phase hydrogenations and oxidations 3-phase hydrogenation of cyclohexane Liquid or multiphase reactions
140~
[43]
10 atm 02 wc - 0.25 g/m1 X > 90% Not given
[44]
Not given
[45]
Not given
[46]
Off line GC
Not given
[47, 48]
Off line GC, HPLC, or others
T < 160~ P < 1 arm
[49]
Off line GC with FID
Fig. 10. Carousel reactor station for parallel evaluation liquid phase or multiphase reactions. Key system features include 12 reactors with magnetic stirring, hot plate type heating system, central gas inlet and radial gas distribution system with gas tight PTFE caps and water cooled reflux head [49].
3. CONCLUSIONS Invention of the next generation of catalytic processes will be accelerated by development and application of high-throughput testing. Until now, these methods have been developed without considering reaction engineering issues, such as transport-kinetic interactions. For these methods to have practical applications, they must be benchmarked using more realistic reactions having complex product distributions and catalysts that exhibit a range of activities. It is expected that future methods will be developed for gas-liquid catalyzed and polymerization since these provide the bases for new emerging materials.
99 REFERENCES
1. K. Weissermel and H.-J. Arpe, Industrial Organic Chemistry (2 nd Edition), VCH Press, Weinheim (1993). 2. Anonymous, Stanford Research Institute, Statistical Abstracts, January 1996. 3. Anonymous, Facts and figures for the chemical industry, Chemical and Engineering News, 76 (26), June 29, 1998. 4. J.N. Armour, New catalytic technology commercialized in the USA during the 1980's, Appl. Catal., 78, 141-173 (1991). 5. M. Misono and N. Nojiri, Recent progress in catalytic technology in Japan, Appl. Catal. 64, 1-130 (1990). 6. N. Nojiri and M. Misono, Recent progress in catalytic technology in J a p a n - A supplement, Appl. Catal. A: General, 93, 103-122 (1993). 7. M. Enze and Z. Peiling, Progress in catalytic technology in the People's Republic of China during the 1980's, Appl. Catal. A: General, 95, 1-20 (1993). 8. S.M. Csicsery, Catalysis research in India, The Catalyst Review, 5-12 (19xx). 9. J. Villermaux, Future challenges for basic research in chemical engineering, Chem. Engng. Sci., 50, 2525 (1993). 10. J. J. Lerou and K. M. Ng, Chemical reaction engineering: A multiscale approach to a multiobjective task, Chem. Engng. Sci., 51, 1595 (1996). 11. S. R. Wilson and A. W. Czamik, "Combinatorial Chemistry- Synthesis and Application", John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1997. 12. M Dieterle, G. Mestl, Th. Ressler and R. Schlrgl, Combinatorial heterogeneous catalysis; Partial oxidation with MMO materials, Paper presented at the 2nd Annual Conference on Combinatorial Approaches for New Materials Discovery, San Diego, CA, January 23-25, 2000. 13. B. Jandeleit, D. J. Schaefer, T. S. Powers, H. W. Turner and W. H. Weinberg, Combinatorial Materials Science and Catalysis, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 38, 2494-2532 (1999). 14. Charybdis Technologies Inc., Carlsbad, California, USA, (www.charybdis.com). 15. Argonaut Technologies, San Carlos, California, USA, (www.argotech.com). 16. Mettler-Toledo Bohdan, Vernon Hills, Illinois, USA, (www.bohdan.com). 17. E. Reddington, A. Sapienza, B. Gurau, R. Viswanathan, S. Sarangapani, E. S. Smotkin, and T. E. Mallouk, Science 1998 June 12; 280, 1735-1737. 18. S. M. Senkan, and S. Ozturk, Discovery and Optimization of Heterogeneous Catalysts by Using Combinatorial, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 38, 791-795 (1999). 19. TAP Inc., Wilmington, DE, USA, www.autoprt.co.uk 20. P. C. Cong, R. D. Dooloen, Q. Fan, D. M. Gianquinta, S. Guan, E. W. McFarland, D. M. Poojary, K. Self, H. W. Turner and W. H. Weinberg, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 38, 484 (1999). 21. W. E. Weinberg, E. W. McFarland, P. C. Cong, S. Guan, Mass spectrometers and methods for rapid screening of libraries of different materials, US Patent 5,959,297, assigned to Symyx Technologies, September 28, 1999. 22. B. Jandeleit, H. Weinberg, Putting catalysis on the fast track, Chemistry and Industry, 19, 795 (1998). 23. R. F. Service, High-Speed Materials Design, Science, 1997 July 25,277, 474-475.
100 24. E. McFarland, P. Cong, S Guan and W. H. Weinberg, World Intellectual Property Organization, Publication Number WO 98/15969 (1998). 25. B. Jandeleit, H. W. Turner, T. Uno, J. A. M. van Beek and W. H. Weinberg, CatTech, 4, 101-123(1998). 26. J. R. Engstrom and W. H. Weinberg, Combinatorial Materials Science: Paradigm Shift in Materials Discovery and Optimization, AIChE Journal, 46 (1), 2-5 (2000). 27. Y. Liu, P. Cong, R. D. Doolen, S. Guan, D. M. Poojary, H. W. Turner and W. H. Weinberg, High-throughput synthesis and screening of mixed metal oxides for ethane oxidative dehydrogenation to ethylene, Paper ISO 46 presented at the 6th European Workshop on Selective Oxidation, September 9-10, 1999, Rimini, Italy. See also: Y. Liu, P. Cong, R. D. Doolen, H. W. Turner, W. H. Weinberg, High-throughput synthesis and screening of V-A1-Nb and Cr-A1-Nb oxide libraries for ethane oxidative dehydrogenation to ethylene, Catalysis Today, 61, 87-92 (2000). 28. M. Baems and M. Buyevskaya, Strategies in the Development of Heterogeneous Catalyst for the Partial Oxidation of Propane by Combinatorial and Evolutionary Methods, Paper presented at the 2nd Annual Conference on Combinatorial Approaches for New Materials Discovery, San Diego, CA, January 23-25, 2000. 29. T. Zech and D. Hoenicke, Efficient and reliable screening of catalysts for microchannel reactors by combinational methods, Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Microreaction Technology, AIChE Spring Meeting, Atlanta, March 5-9, 2000. 30. S. M. Senkan, High-throughput screening of solid-state catalyst libraries, Nature, 394, 350-353(1998). 31. S. Senkan, K. Krantz, S. Ozturk, V. Zengin, I. Onal, High-throughput Testing of Heterogeneous Catalyst Libraries Using Array Microreactors and Mass Spectrometry, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 38, 2794-2799 (1999). 32. S. M. Senkan, High-throughput, Parallel Testing of Heterogeneous Catalyst Libraries, Paper presented at the 2nd Annual Conference on Combinatorial Approaches for New Materials Discovery, San Diego, CA, January 23-25, 2000. 33. F. C. Moates, M. Somani, J. Annamalai, J. T. Richardson, D. Luss and R. C. Willson, Infrared Thermographic Screening of Combinatorial Libraries of Heterogeneous Catalysts, lnd. Eng. Chem. Res., 35, 4801-4803 (1996). 34. A. Holzwarth, H.-W. Schmidt and W. F. Maier, Detection of Catalytic Activity in Combinatorial Libraries of Heterogeneous Catalysts by IR Thermography, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 37, 2644-2647 (1998). 35. A. Holzwarth and W. F. Maier, Catalytic Phenomena in Combinatorial Libraries of Heterogeneous Catalysts, Platinum Metals Review, 44, 16-21 (2000). 36. Zeton Altamira, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA, Automated High Throughput Screening Micro-Reactor System for Combinatorial Catalysis, Product Bulletin Rev 1., www.zetonaltamira.com/hts.html. 37. D. Wolf, O. V. Buyevskaya and M. Baems, An Evolutionary Approach in the combinatorial Selection and Optimization of Catalytic Materials, Catalysis Today, submitted (2000). 38. P. Gibbs, R. C. Willson, Imaging Polarimetry for High Throughput Chiral Screening, Paper 336c presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 1217, 2000.
101 39. J. A. Lauterbach, G. Oskarsdottir, C. M. Snively, Novel Imaging System for Screening of Combinatorial Catalyst Libraries, Paper 312f presented at the 1999 AIChE Annual Meeting, Dallas, November 1-5, 1999. 40. R. A. Schneider, Process for producing a mixed oxide of vanadium and phosphorus having an improved intrinsic surface area, US Patent 4,043,943, assigned to Chevron Research Company, August 23, 1977. 41. G. J. Hutchings, Effect of promoters and reacting concentration on the selective oxidation of n-butane to maleic anhydride using vanadium phosphorus oxide catalysts, Applied Catalysis, 72, 1-32 (1991). 42. E. Garcia, F. Ferrari, T. Garcia, M Martinez and J. Aracil, Use of microreactors in biotransformation process. Study of the synthesis of diglycerol monolaurate ester, Proceedings of the 4 th International Conference on Microreaction Technology, AIChE Spring Meeting, Atlanta, March 5-9, 2000. 43. S. Isogai, M. W. Losey, M. A. Schmidt and K. F. Jensen, The Application of Microfabricated Reactors to Catalyst Testing--Liquid Phase Oxidations at High Temperatures and Pressure, Paper 336b presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 12-17, 2000. 44. C. Br'~xidli, E. W. McFarland and T. F. Jaramillo, Combinatorial Photocatalysis for Hydrogen Production, Paper 336e presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 12-17, 2000. 45. P. R. Gibbs and R. C. Willson, Imaging Polarimetry for High Throughput Chiral Screening, Paper 336c presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 12-17, 2000. 46. F. SchtRh, C. Hoffmann, A. Wolf, S. Thomson, D. Farrusseng and T. Johann, Parallel Reactor Technology for the Discovery of Novel Catalysts. Paper 330d presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 12-17, 2000. 47. M. W. Losey, R. J. Jackman, S. Ajmera, M. A. Schmidt and K. F. Jensen, Micromachined Devices for the Study of Heterogeneous Chemical Processes: Transport and Catalysis in microfabricated Fixed-Beds, Paper 350f presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 12-17, 2000. 48. S. Ajmera, M. W. Losey, M. A. Schmidt and K. F. Jensen, Microfabricated Reactors for Catalyst Testing: Novel Design for Kinetics Extraction in Heterogeneous Gas Phase Processes, Paper 336f presented at the 2000 AIChE Annual Meeting, Los Angeles, November 12-17, 2000. 49. Zinsser Analytic GmbH, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, (www.zinsser-analytic.com). 50. P. L. Mills, J.S. McCracken and T. M. Delaney, Novel Micro-Scale Reactor for Liquid Phase and Gas-Liquid Catalyzed Reactions with On-Line GC Analytical System Sampling, Paper 288d presented at the 1999 AIChE Annual Meeting, Dallas, November 1-5, 1999. 51. D.-Y. Kim and J. S. Dordick, A