Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Petr Suchomel • Ondrˇej Choutka
Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction With contributions by Jan Hradil Lubomir Jurák Radim Brabec Pavel Buchvald Pavel Barsa Vladimír Beneš Radek Frič
Authors Petr Suchomel Regional Hospital Liberec Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter Husova St. 10 460 63 Liberec Czech Republic
[email protected]
ISBN 978-3-642-13157-8
Ondrˇej Choutka University of Cincinnati Medical Center Dept. Neurosurgery Albert Sabin Way 231 45267-0515 Cincinnati Ohio USA
[email protected]
e-ISBN 978-3-642-13158-5
DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5 Springer Heidelberg Dordrecht London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2010937980 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Product liability: The publishers cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information about dosage and application contained in this book. In every individual case the user must check such information by consulting the relevant literature. Cover design: eStudioCalamar, Figueres/Berlin Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
To my wife Jana. She has unconditionally supported my efforts for 25 years and without her patience and love, this book would never have been finished. Petr Suchomel To my wife Petra and my boys Honzik and Lukas. Your eternal patience, support, tolerance, and love made this endeavor possible. Ondrˇej Choutka
v
Preface
The spine is a “scaffold” for the erect human body and spinal cord that allows for information to travel between the central nervous system and the peripheral movement executers. Without good signal transition or intact scaffold, a human being cannot walk efficiently. Last century has seen a growing interest and need by many surgeons to strengthen collapsing scaffold and to improve relay of neural signals along the spinal cord. Craniovertebral junction represents the ultimate link between the head and spine with its absolute need for structural support as well as mobility. Historically, orthopedic surgeons and neurosurgeons became intimately involved in the care of the spinal patient, rarely working together. One was more interested in the strength and shape of the scaffold; the other was more concerned about the quality of information passing through the spinal cord and assuring it remained free from compression. The two differing approaches resulted in two schools of spinal practice: one perfecting reconstructive and fusion techniques, the other mastering microsurgical decompressive aspects of spinal care. Both sides failed to realize that for a patient to enjoy a functional, ambulatory life, they are both necessary. The multilevel decompressive procedure that potentially results in spinal instability may require good structural support with anatomical alignment. The era of admiration of beautiful constructs without respect for neural structures or microsurgical decompression without the thought for good structural support is over. Spine surgery has undergone tremendous development in last 30 years allowing surgeons to operate safely and effectively in previously forbidden or dangerous areas. Development of imaging modalities, surgical instruments, implants, intraoperative monitoring, and anesthetic techniques allowed for spinal techniques to flourish with improved safety and ambulating patients! The new generation spine surgeon is here to stay and rid us off the artificial separation between structure and nervous system. Our daily work clearly demonstrates that there is a whole array of common spinal problems treated frequently. On the other hand, there are certain, more complex diagnoses even in spinal care that require special expertise, skills, and equipment. There are still some super specialized topics which, in our opinion will remain under the wings of original specialties. It is the orthopedic correction of thoracolumbar deformities namely those congenital and neurosurgical microsurgery of spinal cord pathologies. All the other surgically treatable diseases would encompass the “general spine surgery.” Spinal trauma, degenerative disorders, tumors, and inflammatory diseases all need fully devoted people able to be at service in a 24 h regime. This book, based on our own experience with nearly 300 upper cervical spine reconstruction surgeries, should serve to all those who would not only like to begin with surgery in this region but also to those who are already involved, offering them
vii
viii
Preface
a summarized information about the current possibilities of upper cervical spine reconstruction and a step by step guide of modern potential treatment options for disorders in the CVJ. This book would not be complete without the beautiful illustrations of Petr Polda and radiographic contributions by Dr. Ladislav Endrych, Chairman of the Radiology Department in Regional Hospital Liberec. Last but not least, our thanks goes to Drs. Jan Hradil, Vladimir Benes, Pavel Buchvald, Radek Fricˇ (currently Rikshospitalet Oslo), Pavel Barsa, Robert Frohlich, Lubomir Jurak, Miroslav Kaiser, and Radim Brabec for their significant contributions to this book. Their relentlessness reflects the team spirit of the Neurosurgery Department in Liberec, Czech Republic. Liberec, Czech Republic Cincinatti, Ohio, USA
Petr Suchomel Ondrˇej Choutka
Contents
Section I Anatomy, Biomechanics and Radiology 1 Surgical Anatomy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. Suchomel, O. Choutka, and P. Barsa
3
2 Biomechanical Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. Suchomel and P. Buchvald
17
3 Special Radiology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . O. Choutka and P. Suchomel
23
Section II Principles of Reconstruction Techniques 4 Surgical Approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. Suchomel, J. Hradil, and R. Fricˇ
39
5
55
Basic Principles of Reconstruction Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . O. Choutka and P. Suchomel
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. Suchomel and O. Choutka
65
7 Virtual and Real Time Navigational Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 P. Suchomel and O. Choutka
Section III Indications for Surgery and Examples of Reconstruction 8 Traumatic Atlantooccipital Dislocation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139 P. Suchomel and V. Beneš 9 Occipital Condyle Fractures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 P. Suchomel and L. Jurák
ix
x
10 Atlas Fractures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151 P. Suchomel and R. Brabec 11 Odontoid Process Fractures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165 P. Suchomel and L. Jurák 12 Fractures of the Ring of Axis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 P. Suchomel and J. Hradil 13 Miscellaneous C2 Fractures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197 P. Suchomel and J. Hradil 14 Multiple Fractures of Axis and Atlas-Axis Fracture Combinations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 209 P. Suchomel and J. Hradil 15 Acute Traumatic Atlantoaxial Dislocation in Adults . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 215 P. Suchomel and R. Fricˇ 16 Posttraumatic Deformity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 219 P. Suchomel and R. Fricˇ 17 Non Specific Inflammation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 227 P. Suchomel and O. Choutka 18 Rheumatoid Arthritis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 P. Suchomel, P. Buchvald, and O. Choutka 19 Tumors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 247 P. Suchomel, V. Benes, and M. Kaiser 20 Congenital and Developmental Abnormalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 285 P. Suchomel and O. Choutka 21 Degenerative Disorders . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 299 P. Suchomel and P. Barsa 22 Surgical Failures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 307 P. Suchomel and O. Choutka Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 313
Contents
Abbreviations
2D 3D AA AAD AADI AAI AAOA AARF ABC ACDF ALL AO AOI AOD AP AREZ ASA AT ATB BAI BDI BMP CCI CAD CCJ CEP CMA CN CTA CTA 3D CVJ DRA DREZ EEA EOP EP ES
Two dimensional Three dimensional Atlantoaxial Atlantoaxial dislocation Anterior atlantodental interval Atlantoaxial instability Atlantoaxial osteoarthritis Atlantoaxial rotatory fixation Aneurysmal bone cyst Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion Anterior longitudinal ligament Atlantooccipital Atlantooccipital interval Atlantooccipital dislocation Anteroposterior Anterior root exit zone Anterior spinal artery Anterior translation Antibiotic Basion-posterior axial line interval Basion-dental interval Bone morphogenetic protein C1-condyle interval Computer aided design Craniocervical junction Condylar entry point Cervicomedullary angle Cranial nerve CT angiography Spatial, 3 dimensional CT angiography Craniovertebral junction Dynamic reference array Dorsal root entry zone Expanded endonasal approach External occipital protuberance Evoked potentials Ewing sarcoma xi
xii
ETO FOM FT GCT IAAD IAR ICA INL IOM LCH LTA IOP MDCT MRA MRI MVA NPV NSAID OAA OC OCF OF OS PADI PLL PICA PMA PSA RA SAC SAS SCM SNL SOMI TAL TBC TBI TO UCS VA VAAII
Abbreviations
Endoscopic transcervical odontoidectomy Foramen occipitale magnum Foramen transversarium, transverse foramen Giant cell tumor Irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation Instantaneous axis of rotation Internal carotid artery Inferior nuchal line Intraoperative electrophysiological monitoring Langerhans cells histiocytosis Ligamental tubercle avulsion Internal occipital protuberance Multi-detector row CT Magnetic resonance angiography Magnetic resonance imaging Motor vehicle accidents Negative predictive value Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs Occipito-atlanto-axial Occipitocervical Occipital condyle fracture Odontoid fracture Osteogenic sarcoma Posterior atlantodental interval Posterior longitudinal ligament Posterior inferior cerebellar artery Posterior meningeal artery Posterior spinal artery Rheumatoid arthritis Space available for the spinal cord Space available for screw Sternocleidomastoid muscle Superior nuchal line Sternal occipital mandibular immobilizer Transverse atlantal ligament Tuberculosis Traumatic brain injury Transoral Upper cervical spine Vertebral artery Vertical atlantoaxial instability index
Section Anatomy, Biomechanics and Radiology
I
1
Surgical Anatomy P. Suchomel, O. Choutka, and P. Barsa
The goal of surgical anatomy is to avoid the descriptive aspect of “pure form.” On the other hand, it emphasizes important structures with respect to the pathological condition and surgical approach. In descriptive anatomy of bony structures, one has to realize what the origin of its data is. Obviously, there are differences owing to gender variations (e.g., lower values in females); however, other factors also can influence anatomical variations, such as race or age. For example, data from Asian population show lower values in general relative to their population height. Old anatomical data can show slightly lower values due to a change in the average population height over a longer time period. The other differences can arise from the study design. CT measurements are frequently performed in young individuals due to traumatic injuries in another spinal region, whereas cadaveric data are often obtained from old or diseased people with possibly smaller vertebral sizes. In general, the exact descriptive anatomical data can only be used to give the proportional anatomical relationships. The absolute values have to be used cautiously and cannot be blindly applied to the individual patient. Pure anatomical knowledge has to be supported by the exact imaging and precise measurements of each individual patient. Nowadays, bony structures can be
clearly visualized by CT with 3D reconstructions, the status of soft tissue (spinal cord, disks, and ligaments) by MRI, and vascular structures by CTA and/or MRA. Plain films, although a good initial screening tool, are, in general, less helpful in surgical planning. Modern surgical anatomy should be comprehensive but practical so that readers can follow the guidelines and confirm the data in their daily experience. In this chapter, we are provide such a guide through the surgical anatomy the craniovertebral junction.
1.1 Bony Structures 1.1.1 Occipital Bone (C0) Understanding occipital bone anatomy is important as the posterior squamous part is often used as cranial anchor in occipito-cervical constructs. Foramen magnum is the exit foramen of the skull and is frequently involved in surgical procedures. Occipital condyles are unique joint projections connecting the spine to the skull. Anteriorly, the clivus is a structure also frequently involved in decompressive or reconstructive procedures.
1.1.1.1 Occipital Squama P. Suchomel (), P. Barsa Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St. 10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic O. Choutka Department of Neurosurgery, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 231 Albert Sabin Way, Cincinnati, OH 45267-0515, USA
This part of occipital bone creates an externally convex surface directly visible during most dorsal approaches to CVJ. From surgical viewpoint, it is not just the bone thickness that is relevant, it is the relationship of exterior landmarks to the underlying intracranial venous sinuses and neural tissue that is of utmost importance when it comes to occipital bone.
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_1, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
3
4
There are only a few external landmarks visible during surgery – superior nuchal lines (SNL) and inferior nuchal lines (INL), external occipital protuberance (EOP, Inion), external midline occipital crest, and the edge of foramen magnum. There is great variability in the position of the superior nuchal line and therefore, it does not reflect the internal position of transverse sinus accurately. The relation of confluence of sinuses (torcular Herophili) to EOP is more consistent [47]. According to work of Nadim et al. [39], the safe zones where the injury of transverse sinuses and torcular can be avoided are located more than 2 cm caudal from EOP and SNL. The bone thickness is greatest at the EOP and decreases radially [11, 61]. Most authors describe bone thickness in the region of EOP round 15 mm in males and 12 mm in female Caucasian population but approximately 6 mm or less is available over the cerebellar hemispheres [11, 14, 42]. The safe zone for an 8 mm occipital squama screw insertion covers an area 2 cm laterally from EOP and narrows down inferiorly. So, at 1 cm below EOP, the safe zone is only within 1cm of the midline, and at 2 cm below the EOP, it falls to 0.5 cm of the midline (Fig. 1.1). The thinnest bone (sometimes less than 1 mm) was measured laterally from midline between INL and foramen magnum [47]. The outer cortex contributes 45% to bone thickness whereas the inner table only 10% [61]. Practical conclusion: The thickest bone is available around the SNL and EOP and then along the midline occipital crest, but one has to be aware of injury of intracranial venous sinuses in this region. The exact preoperative bone thickness as well as localization of principal venous sinuses should be determined on
1 Surgical Anatomy
preoperative CT in each individual patient planned for occipital bone fixation.
1.1.1.2 Occipital Condyles There is a great variability in the shape and size of occipital condyles. Most often, the occipital condyles are kidney shaped, biconvex, and medially oriented bone structures localized in the anterior half of foramen magnum. The mean distance between both condyles is 41.6 mm posteriorly and 21 mm anteriorly [38]. The mean condyle length is 23.6 mm (15–30.6), the width 10.5 mm (6.5–15.8), and the height 9.2 mm (5.8–18.2) [28, 29, 36, 38]. Both condyles form an angle of 50°–60° in transverse plane and 124°–127° (male-female) in frontal plane (atlanto-occipital joint angle) [29]. The single condyle axis angle to midline is in average 30° but can vary 10°–54° in adults [36, 38]. Hypoglossal nerve canal is passing transversally through the bone just above the base of the condyle antero-laterally in an axial angle of 45°. It is directed slightly superior with the mean distance of 11.5 mm between the hypoglossal foramen and the inferior border of the condyle [36]. The canal itself is 6.2 mm long, ovoid in shape with 4 mm internal diameter [28]. Jugular foramen with its important contents (jugular vein, n IX,X,XI.) is located 12–25 mm antero-laterally from the condyle. Condylar emissary vein can be identified in the dorsal superolateral condyle border during dissection.
Protuberantia occipitalis externa Linea nuchalis superior Linea nuchalis inferior
Foramen magnum Condylus occipitalis
Fig. 1.1 Schematic drawing of the occipital bone external surface with depicted areas for safe occipital squama screw purchase
1.1 Bony Structures
Carotid artery is often located more than 5 mm anterolateral to the anterior condylar cortex [28]. The condyles are separated by intra-occipital synchondrosis in two (anterior, posterior) parts until the age of six but it can sometimes persist bifacet into adulthood. Third occipital condyle (condylus tertius) is an ossified remnant of the hypochondral bow of the fourth sclerotome (proatlas) at the distal end of clivus that can occasionally be seen as an individual or multiple ossicles directly above and anterior to arch of C1. Practical conclusion: The occipital condyle is normally twice as long (approx. 20 mm) as it is wide (approx. 10 mm), medially oriented structure (20°– 30°). Because of its variability, only CT scan can depict its exact shape, orientation, mass, and relationship to neighboring structures in each individual case.
1.1.1.3 Clivus The upper part of clivus belongs to sphenoid bone whereas the lower part to basilar portion of occipital bone. These two parts are separated by spheno-occipital synchondrosis till the age of 16.5 (13–18) in males and 14.4 (12–15) in females [50]. The suture allows for growth and correct formation of the skull. In normal adults, the length of the entire clivus is 4.5 cm (3.7–5.2), with the basilar portion of occipital bone representing 3.1 cm (SD 0.3). In occipital hypoplasia, the basilar portion could be as short as 1.7 cm [29]. The thicker part of clivus is located anterosuperiorly and contains cancellous bone. The thinner part, formed by cortical bone only, is in the region of foramen magnum (FOM). Usually, the outer cortex is more solid and thicker than the inner one [29]. Practical conclusion: The clivus can vary in shape and size especially in developmental anomalies. As a part of bone firmly connected to skull, it can be navigated using the skull data.
1.1.2 Atlas (C1) The atlas is a ring-shaped unique vertebra having no vertebral body and no intervertebral disk attached. It consists of two lateral masses connected with short anterior and longer posterior arches (Fig. 1.2). Its anatomic integrity is crucial for stability of the CVJ and movement of the head.
5
In older European anatomical studies of atlas, the average outer distance between anterior and posterior tubercle (length) was 46.3 mm in males and 43.2 mm in females. The external transverse diameter (width) was 83 mm and 72 mm, respectively [6]. Exact measurements performed later by Doherty [7] on 80 European C1 specimens, generally confirmed the old anatomical data. An average atlas outer length was 45.8 mm (SD = 2.9) and outer width 78.6 mm (SD = 8.1). The internal width was 32.2 mm (SD = 2.3) and internal length was 31.7 mm (SD = 2.2). Similar values were obtained by Kandziora from 50 dry specimens [25] and also when later measured electronically by Rocha in 20 cadaveric bones [48]. Atlas is the vertebra with the widest internal diameter. The internal length and width were 32.6 mm (range 29.6–36.4 mm) and 29.7 (25.7– 32.2 mm), respectively [48]. The transverse ligament tubercles serve as an attachment place of the ligament and are located internally on the medial wall of the lateral masses. Rocha measured the internal “intertubercle” distance to be 22.9 mm (18.7–27.9 mm) [48]. The largest published anatomical series was done by Christensen et al. [4] who measured 120 dried atlases from a defined American population (average age 52.9 years, average height 169.7 cm). Electronic caliper was used with the average outer width being 75.61 mm (SD = 5.94) and outer length 45.67 mm (SD = 3.61). Anterior arch is a strong structure that harbors anterior tubercle in the midline. The anterior tubercle is regularly visible on plain lateral radiographs and often serves as anatomical and radiographic landmark during surgical procedures especially during instrumentation. The internal wall of the anterior arch is in contact with odontoid process forming a facet (fovea dentis). The height of the anterior ring is 15.4 mm (SD = 3.2) [7], the length is 30 mm [25, 29], and the thickness is 6 mm in the midline [4]. This thickest cortical bone of the whole C1 is in agreement with its biomechanical load demands. Posterior arch is longer (usually 2/5 of C1 circumference) and weaker because of the bony groove for horizontal segment of the vertebral artery. The posterior arch has the thinnest cortex of the entire vertebra [7]. The posterior midline arch height is 9.58 mm (SD = 2.26) and its thickness is 7.82 mm (SD = 2.64) [4], in the area of vertebral artery(VA) groove, the height is a mere 4.5 mm (4.3–6.1) [48]. The distance between the posterior midline tubercle and the most medial aspect of the VA groove is approximately 15 mm [37, 48]. Lateral masses are in fact the most voluminous bony parts of atlas forming four facet joints. The superior
6
1 Surgical Anatomy
Fig. 1.2 Artistic drawing of C1 with marked parameters simplified for practical purpose
joints differ from the inferior ones in size and shape. Its average midportion (central) length is 16.82 mm (SD 1.0), width 16.06 mm (SD 0.91), and height 15.68 mm (SD 0.98) [51]. The lateral mass cones in medially in the coronal plane and wedges posteriorly in the sagittal plane. Medial wall height was measured 11 mm (SD = 1.21) and lateral 22 mm (SD = 1.89) [25]. Its mean height anteriorly is 18.5 mm (SD = 2.39 mm) and posteriorly 10.2 mm (SD = 2.0) [1]. The superior articular surface (fovea articularis superior) is a medially tilted, concave ellipsoid (kidney shaped), with an approximate length of 20 mm and width of 10 mm [4, 29, 56]. This naturally corresponds to the shape and size of the articular surface of the c ondyle. In coronal plane, it overlaps the smaller lower facet. Sometimes it can be developmentally divided into two contact surfaces. Superior facet angle to midline was measured in horizontal plane 22.4° (SD = 1.52) [25].
The lower articular surface (fovea articularis inferior) is less concave, round shaped, and smaller than the upper one with a common length of 17 mm (14– 23 mm) and width 17 mm (14–23 mm) [1, 13, 29, 32]. The pillar between lower facet and posterior arch is often used for screw anchorage. The height of this “working window” is 3.6 mm (2.13–4.09 mm) and width 9.5 mm (6.98–13.34 mm) [15]. Other studies on non Indian population are suggestive of a larger area with the mean height of 4.5 mm, ranging from 4.1 to 6.1 mm [48, 51]. Normally, the transverse process forms a transverse foramen (FT) for vertebral artery (VA). It has a variable diameter and position and can be opened in an anterolateral direction. Relatively often (15.6%), there is a partial or total covering (arcuate foramen) of artery (Fig. 1.3) in the C1 groove creating a so called “ponticulus posticus” [20, 30, 60]. This can be very
7
1.1 Bony Structures
1.1.3 Axis (Epistropheus, C2)
Fig. 1.3 Arcuate foramen of C1 and high riding VA in C2 pars. Sagittal CT reconstruction. Note the broken transarticular screw (case referred for revision from another department)
important during sub-periosteal exposure of C1 lamina and during C1 lateral mass screw placement. One can suppose that the lamina is too broad and the VA could thus be injured through a poor planning of the entry point. The distance of medial FT border to midline is approximately 25 mm [19, 25, 54]. For practical surgical purposes we can summarize: In average the atlas outer width is approximately 75 mm and outer length 45 mm. Internal AP diameter is usually 30 mm. Anterior arch is the strongest bony structure approximately 30 mm long, 15 mm high, and 6 mm thick. Posterior arch is the weakest part of atlantal ring having a medial height of approximately 10 mm but in the region of VA groove only 5 mm or less. The lateral mass is wedge shaped in sagittal and frontal planes. Superior facet is approximately 20 mm long and 10 mm wide with the axis angled in at about 20°–30° medially. Lower facet is round shaped with a 17 mm diameter. The lateral mass pillar below the posterior arch has a rectangular shape with 4.5 mm height and 10 mm width forming the working window for eventual screw introduction. The VA containing transverse foramina are approximately 25 mm from midline but the VA containing groove comes as close as 15 mm to midline.
Second cervical vertebra is also a unique spinal structure. It is composed of vertebral body with upward directed odontoid process, which articulates with the posterior aspect of anterior C1 arch (Fig. 1.4). The body is connected to the lateral mass by short and strong pedicles. Lateral mass pillar between upper and lower articular processes is pars interarticularis and its narrowest part is the isthmus. Transverse foramen can vary in shape and size. Posterior arch is similar to other subaxial cervical arches but is larger, in general. The spinous process is often bifid. The cortical bone covering the anterior aspect of odontoid process, its tip, and the anterior vertebral body surface is extremely thick, especially in the area of an anterior midline ridge named “promontory“ by Doherty [17]. The thickness here is approximately 1.7 mm whereas the lateral and posterior parts of odontoid and body are covered by only a 1.0 mm or less thick cortical bone. The inside dens trabecular bony architecture is organized to resist the antero-posterior and lateral forces. Strong trabeculae that span fanlike from the upper facets to the inferior bony endplates assist to bear and transmit the axial load. The weakest bone density is in the body below the base of odontoid [17]. The external axis width is 56 mm (48–69 mm) [25] and length approximately 55 mm. Vertebral body is connected to C3 by intervertebral disk. The C2 endplate shape is sagittally concave with a prominent anterior edge. The distance between this edge and the base of dens is on an average 22 mm (17– 31 mm) [25]. The caudal body width is 18–19 mm and AP diameter 15–17 mm [25, 27, 59]. Both parameters decrease superiorly. Consequently, the internal spinal canal AP diameter is smaller at the C2 body base (14.8 mm) than at the level of odontoid process attachment 17.35 mm [59]. The average canal width, measured as 21.6 mm [59], does not change throughout the height of the vertebra. The odontoid process diameter is usually smaller at the base (waist) than in the middle of its shaft. The process is composed of thick cortical bone surrounding internal cancellous component with an internal diameter reaching 4.3–6.2 mm [18]. It is usually 20 mm (15–25.4 mm) long and posteriorly tilted in an angle of 64° in respect the endplate [25, 59]. Anterior surface forms an articulation with the atlas. Basal (waist) odontoid diameter is approximately 9 mm
8
1 Surgical Anatomy
Fig. 1.4 Artistic drawing of C2 with marked parameters simplified for practical purpose
(7.8–14.1 mm) and the maximal one 11 mm (8.4– 14.1 mm) [25, 59]. The pedicles of C2 vertebra, despite being very short, are the strongest and widest pedicles in the cervical spine connecting the body to lateral masses nearly in right angle to sagittal plane. From a surgical viewpoint, the most critical value is the mean transverse pedicle diameter at the level of the VA. It was measured 6.4 mm (2.09–13.2 mm) [35]. Lateral masses form an oblique column between upper and lower facets. This part of bone is very important for possible screw purchase is usually called pars interarticularis or simply “pars” in the anatomical literature. This pillar is more or less thinned by the groove of VA in its narrowest point called the isthmus. Despite the above nomenclature corresponding exactly to that of the other spine regions, one has to be careful when interpreting publications even from wellaccepted authors [11, 26, 31, 33, 34, 46, 53, 59], who
commonly refer to the pars interarticularis as the C2 pedicle. The pars is inclined 35.2° (29°–41°) medially and 38.8° (22°–52°) rostro-caudally [21]. The width and height of the isthmus at the level of the transverse foramen is 7.9–8.6 mm (female vs. male) and 6.9– 7.7 mm (female vs. male), respectively [59]. It can, however, vary to values less than 3.5 mm at least on one side in approximately 18–23% of patients [23, 45, 46]. The upper facet is slightly convex and faces upward and outward with the shape and size corresponding to the inferior articular process of C1. The outward angle in coronal plane is approximately 24° [25]. Its length and width are similar, approximately 17 mm [25], depending on gender and body size. The articular surface atypically arises directly from the C2 pedicle laterally. The lower facet forms a typical, forward-facing subaxial spine joint surface to articulate with C3. C2 arch is the strongest arch in cervical spine usually containing enough cancellous bone to accommodate a
9
1.2 Ligaments and Joints
3.5 mm laminar screw. The mean laminar thickness was measured 5.77 mm (1.35–9.77 mm) [3]. On 37 adult specimens, Xu et al. [58] measured the C2 laminar height to be 11.2 mm (SD = 1.1 mm), its half length 15.6 mm (SD = 1.2 mm), and average thickness 4.3 mm (SD = 0.9 mm). Both the laminas formed an angle of 99.1° (SD = 8.0°) called laminar width, which is the narrowest in the spine. The downslope laminar angle was determined as 111.7° (SD = 9.3°). The spinous process is likewise a strong structure serving as an attachment point of important suboccipital triangle muscles and the nuchal ligament. Transverse foramen incorporating VA is of utmost surgical importance. Usually, the VA enters the C2 transverse foramen vertically approximately 15 mm from the midline, passes cranially, and then courses 45° laterally to form an upward loop around the transverse process to reach the vertically oriented C1 transverse foramen. In about 80% of population, the VA bends sharply outward inside the C2 VA groove, leaving enough bone of the isthmus for transisthmic or transpedicular screw purchase. The VA curve located directly below the superior articular process of C2 can occasionally be more superior, dorsal, or medial than expected, thus directly influencing the pars and pedicle size. Such “high riding VA” occurs at least unilaterally in up to 23% of patients undergoing craniocervical procedures [34, 40, 45]. Despite this, it is clear that the diameter of the bony VA canal and foramen does not represent the external diameter of the actual artery [2, 35]. The artery is surrounded by venous plexus and connective and periostial tissue, and this fact often allows for certain amount of foraminal breach during screw placement.
For practical surgical purposes we can summarize: On an average, the axis outer width is around 56 mm and outer length 55 mm. Internal AP diameter increases from 15 mm at the level of C2/3 disk to 17 mm at the base of odontoid process. The internal width remains relatively constant measuring approximately 22 mm. The odontoid process has an average diameter of 10 mm and is tilted backwards relatively to the C2 endplate in an approximately 60° angle and about 10° relatively to horizontal plane. The distance from the anterior inferior edge of C2 body to the odontoid tip is approximately 40 mm (shorter in females). The AP C2 body diameter decreases with upward direction. The diameter of the isthmus (the narrowest part of the pars) is approximately 7–8 mm but in 18–23% of patients it can be significantly thinner due to a high riding VA.
1.2 Ligaments and Joints The UCS and CVJ ligamentous connections are very complex (Fig. 1.5) providing one of the most complicated movement patterns in the human body. Atlantooccipital together with atlantoaxial joints are always working together in a synchronized fashion. Upper cervical spine is the most mobile part of the entire vertebral column with a unique anatomical structure. There are no intervertebral disks and yellow ligament. Movement is restricted not only by the bony shape of the vertebra but mostly by the strong ligaments. The axis is firmly connected to the occiput and atlas is quite freely floating in between.
Membrana tectoria (cut off) Canalis hypoglossi Ligamentum apicis dentis Ligamenta alaria Articulatio atlantooccipitalis Ligamentum transversum atlantis (TAL) Ligamentum atlantoaxiale accesorium Articulatio atlantoaxialis
Fig. 1.5 Schematic picture of UCS ligamentous structures (internal posterior view)
Fasciculus longitudinalis ligamenti cruciformis
10
Posterior atlanto-occipital and atlantoaxial membranes are relatively weak structures compared to the interarcual subaxial ligamentum flavum. The anterior longitudinal ligament (ALL) loosely attaches to the vertebral bodies of the subaxial spine. However, it is firmly connected to the disk annulus at each level and finally inserts to the anterior tubercle of atlas. Anterior atlanto-occipital membrane replaces the ALL between atlas and the clivus. The posterior surface of C2 body and odontoid process is covered by tectorial membrane which is, in fact, a strongly developed cranial part of the posterior longitudinal ligament (PLL). Cranially, it is inserted into the clivus with lateral extend to hypoglossal canals. Caudally, the membrane is attached to C2 body continuing into the PLL. The most important structure for atlantoaxial translational stability is the transverse ligament. This ligament is the strongest of the entire complex and attaches to the bony tubercles located on the medial surface of lateral masses of atlas. It is 10 mm high and 2 mm thick with an average length of 23 mm [29, 48]. Together with the longitudinal bundles attached to the posterior aspect of C2 body and anterior edge of foramen magnum, the transverse ligament forms the cruciate (cruciform) ligament. The axis is connected to the occipital bone with three other ligamentous structures. The apical ligament, a possible remnant of chorda dorsalis, connects the tip of the dens to the anterior edge of foramen magnum. This relatively weak band runs forward in a 20° angle and is around 8 mm long and 2–5 mm wide [29, 43, 44]. Symmetrical allar ligaments are extended between the lateral odontoid apex and the medial surface of each occipital condyle. Regularly, these 10 mm-long ligaments also have small insertions into the lateral masses of atlas [9, 10]. Atlantoaxial accessory ligaments found irregularly on both sides are not only connecting the atlas to the axis but also continued cephalically to the occipital bone. The approximate length of this structure is 30 mm and thickness 5 mm [57]. Occasionally, one can also find atlantodental ligament connecting the base of the odontoid process with the anterior arch of atlas [9, 10].
1.2.1 Atlanto-Occipital Joints The two atlanto-occipital joints are true synovial joints similar to the others in UCS. The articulation between
1 Surgical Anatomy
the condyle and the upper C1 articular process allows mainly flexion and extension. The shape, angle, and congruence of joint surfaces are natural restraints of other movement directions. The joints contain synovial membrane and are covered by capsular ligaments.
1.2.2 Atlantoaxial Lateral Joints These two most mobile joints in the entire spine provide predominantly rotational movement; however, movement in other directions and planes is also possible. This is due to the naturally incongruent articular surfaces that do not limit any direction of movement and due to the laxity of restricting ligamentous structures. They consist of encapsulated synovial joint between inferior articular process of C1 and superior process of C2. Their capsular ligaments are reinforced by medial and posterior accessory ligaments.
1.2.3 Atlantodental Joint This synovial joint forms anterior and posterior articulation between the odontoid process and anterior arch of C1 and the odontoid process and transverse atlantal ligament, respectively. The transverse ligament is obviously so rigid to keep the odontoid process in contact with anterior arch of C1 under all circumstances. There is only a very limited freedom for lateral movement of the odontoid process. Further, a greater degree of elasticity in childhood allows for greater movement in this joint.
1.3 Muscles of CVJ and UCS Several complex muscular attachments of the upper cervical spine act together to provide three main functions: muscular tension stabilizes the position of head in space; multiple small muscles attached to the skull, C1, and C2 provide movement of the head in all directions; and the massive posterior muscular layer aids in protection of the CVJ from external violence. Good working knowledge of the muscular attachments allows for anatomical dissection during
11
1.3 Muscles of CVJ and UCS
exposures of the CVJ and prevents unnecessary damage to soft tissues. Similarly to the other spine regions, the musculature can be divided in musculi brevii (proprii) connecting one motion segment only and musculi longi bridging two or more segments. In UCS, the short muscles are more important and more specifically developed than in subaxial cervical spine (Fig. 1.6). The nuchal ligament has two portions and knowledge of the presence of fatty areolar tissue between the two leaves of the deeper lamellar portion can prevent blood loss during posterior exposure of cervical spine [24]. The large, posterior superficial muscles of the neck consist of trapezius, semispinalis, sternocleidomastoid, and splenius capitus. They merely cross/attach at the CVJ but are encountered during posterior, posterolateral, and lateral approaches to the region. The deep short muscles are more specific in their structure and function as head extenders, rotators, and lateral
benders. The atlas is connected to the skull through a series of short capitis muscles (posterior rectus capitis minor and superior obliquus capitis). The axis is connected to the atlas by inferior obliquus capitis and to the skull by rectus capitis posterior major. The insertion of this muscle to the spinous process of C2 merges with the insertion of inferior obliquus capitis. These muscles allow mostly for rotation and extension. The anterior muscles of the CVJ include the paired, short rectus capitis anterior that connect the atlas to the clivus. Rectus capitis lateralis runs vertically between the transverse process of C1 and the jugular process of the occipital bone. These two muscles are separated by the ventral ramus of the first cervical nerve. The longus capitis muscle originates on transverse processes of lower cervical vertebrae crosses the CVJ anteriorly to attach to the base of the skull. The function of the anterior muscle group is mostly stabilization of the skull on the vertebral column.
M. obliquus capitis superior M.splenium capitis A. occipitalis N. occipitalis major M. semispinalis capitis M. rectus capitis post. minor M. rectus capitis post. major Membrana atlantooccipitalis post. A. vertebralis N. suboccipitalis Tuberculum post. atlantis Procesus spinosus axis M. obliquus capitis infeerior M. spinalis cervicis M. splenium capitis Proc. articularis inf. axis M. semispinalis capitis
Fig. 1.6 Schematic drawing of anatomical structures of suboccipital triangle
Proc. transversus atlantis M. longissimus cappitis
12
1 Surgical Anatomy
1.4 Vascular Anatomy of CVJ and UCS 1.4.1 Vertebral Artery (VA) Vertebral artery course in the cervical spine can be divided in four segments (V1–4). The first segment represents the course of the artery between its origin on the subclavian artery and its entrance into the transverse foramen of the C6 vertebra (most frequently). The second segment involves the cervical transverse foraminal portion of the VA course (C6 to C1). The horizontal portion of the VA (V3) is from the transverse foramen of the atlas to entrance to the dura. The VA runs in the groove of the C1 lamina, is surrounded by venous plexus, and ultimately passing the posterior wall of the condyle to pierce the atlanto-occipital membrane in its lateral aspect. The intradural course of the VA represents the fourth segment (V4) to terminate in the formation of basilar artery after joining the contralateral VA. The left VA is dominant in 35.8% of patients, hypoplastic in 5.7%, and absent in 1.8%. The right VA is dominant in 23.4% of subjects, hypoplastic in 8.8%, and absent in3.1%. Equivalent right and left VA can be detected in 40.8% of subjects; however, a great diversity exists in the percentual representation of these varieties [55]. The VA course in the region of upper cervical spine is curved and with some redundancy, particularly between C1 and C2 to allow not only for flexion and extension but for rotation so prominent at this spinal segment (Fig. 1.7). The VA redundancy decreases with age [8]. In subjects with a healthy upper cervical spine, the typical five-curve course of VA at the CVJ was seen in 81.8% of CTA evaluations. The rest of the subjects carried various anomalies of the VA course at the CVJ [8]. Surprisingly, in up to 15.6% of patients, one can discover a partial or total bony covering (arcuate foramen) of the horizontal segment of VA, so called “ponticulus posticus” [4, 20]. It is important to be aware of a rather dangerous variable that is, the persistent primitive first cervical intersegmental artery. This aberrant vessel may partially or completely substitute the VA and course below the posterior arch of atlas. Such course would complicate a subarcuate approach to the posterior lateral mass of C1 for screw insertion. In a very large series of 1,013 patients with CT angiography, Hong et al found persistent first
Fig. 1.7 CT angiogram showing the AV redundancy below the C1 entry allowing free C1–2 rotation
intersegmental artery on one side in 3.8% and bilaterally in 0.8 % [20]. Reports of tortuous VA coursing below the posterior arch of atlas without passing through the transverse foramen were also described [22].
1.4.1.1 Branches of VA Certain branches of the VA may have anomalous origins and thus become susceptible to injury during procedures of the CVJ. The posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA) usually originates from the fourth segment of the VA intradurally. However, an extradural origin of PICA may be present in 5–20% of people [12]. This makes it a relatively common variation. An extradural origin may be highly variable and PICA can arise close to the entrance of the VA into the dura or as far as atlantoaxial portion of the artery and course below the C1 arch. An extradural origin PICA, usually, does not supply anterior medulla. PICA may originate from other vessels in the region (ascending pharyngeal, ICA etc.) also. Posterior meningeal artery (PMA) should not be confused with an extradural PICA. It usually arises from the extracranial segment of VA and supplies posterior fossa dura and falx cerebelli and cerebri. It originates from the left VA in 17–30% of people and right VA 8–40% [16, 41]; however, just like PICA, it can
13
1.5 Neural Anatomy
originate from other vessels in the area (ascending pharyngeal, ICA, and occipital artery). Posterior spinal artery (PSA) usually originates from the VA, 50% intradurally and 46% extradurally from V3 [52]. However, PSA has also been described to originate from PICA, usually with an extradural origin. Anterior spinal artery (ASA) arises invariably intradurally from the vertebral arteries; however, the relationship of its origin to PICA and vertebrobasilar junction varies. ASA was a direct branch of left VA in 30% of cadaveric specimens, right in 8%, and directly from basilar artery in 2%. The “typical” pattern of dual anterior ventral spinal arteries merging into a single ASA was observed only in 18% of examined brainstems [49].
1.4.2 Internal Carotid Artery (ICA) Although, the ICA is not directly involved in UCS and CVJ, its adjacent position could be of importance in some UCS reconstructive techniques. The lumen of internal carotid artery (ICA) is medial to the transverse foramen of C1 in more than 80% of cases [5] (Fig. 1.8). In such cases, it lies directly in front of C1 lateral masses. With tortuous ICA, the vessel may even be located in front of the C2 vertebral body. Knowledge of ICA variation becomes relevant during direct anterior or anterolateral exposure of CVJ or during posterior reconstruction with instrumentation potentially perforating anterior cortex of vertebrae of UCS and putting the ICA at risk.
Fig. 1.8 Axial CT with contrast media application depicting the normal position of carotid artery in front of the atlas
1.5 Neural Anatomy 1.5.1 Spinal Cord Neural structures are occupying funnel-like cavity of craniocervical junction. The medulla oblongata merges into the spinal cord at the CVJ. The upper limit of spinal cord is defined by anatomists as an exit point of the uppermost root fibers of C1 or the lower end of pyramidal tract decussation. The morphology of spinal cord changes at different levels. There is significant individual variation in size. Nonetheless, it is flattened in anteroposterior direction and usually has a larger transverse diameter. Its surface is divided by the longitudinal fissure and several sulci. The anteromedial fissure and posteromedial sulcus divide spinal cord sagittally into symmetrical halves. The central canal originating from the fourth ventricle passes in the midline and is surrounded by an inner butterfly-shaped gray matter. The gray matter consists of cell columns that extend in posterolateral directions almost to the surface (the posterior horns) and anterolaterally, not reaching the anterior surface of the cord (the anterior horns). Posterior horns contain somatosensory neurons while anterior horns somatomotor neurons. A gray commissure connects the gray substances encircling the central canal. The white matter comprises ascending and descending fibers organized into distinct tracts. Anatomically, it is divided into three columns symmetrically in both halves of the cord: posterior, lateral, and anterior. The posterior column is ascending one localized between the posterior horns of the gray matter. Medially, it is symmetrically divided by the posteromedial sulcus that cranially extends to the caudal cusp of the fourth ventricle in the brain stem. Lateral column is located between anterior and lateral root entry zones and consists of the lateral corticospinal tract intermediating voluntary discrete and skillful motor function and the lateral spinothalamic tract transmitting painful and thermal sense from contralateral side. The anterior columns lie between the anterior entry zones and are symmetrically divided by the anterior spinal fissure. Its most important structure is the descending corticospinal tract concerned with fine motor skills. Of descending corticospinal axons localized in the anterior columns, 75–90% decussates, forming the crossed lateral corticospinal tract and anterior corticospinal tract involving uncrossed fibers.
14
1.5.2 Cervical Spine Nerves Spinal nerves arise from anterior and posterior root filaments. Ventral root filaments exit the anterolateral aspect of the cord in the anterolateral sulcus, in the region termed the anterior root exit zone (AREZ) and are purely motor. Posterior rootlets enter the spinal cord in dorsal root entry zone (DREZ), the region along the posterolateral sulcus and are sensitive ones. The rootlets pass obliquely and laterocaudally within the canal of craniocervical junction entering the root sleeve where the sensory and motor filaments are separated by the interradicular septum, a lateral extension of dura. The dorsal rootless present an oval bulge, the ganglion as it approaches or enters the intervertebral foramen. Distally to the ganglion, the dorsal and ventral roots combine to form a spinal nerve. The cervical nerve root occupies approximately one third of the foraminal section area, usually its inferior aspect. The residual foraminal space is filled with fat and associated veins. The first spinal cervical nerve leaves the canal through the orifice between the occiput and C1. Further cervical nerves exit above correspondingly numbered vertebrae.
References 1. Blagg, S.E., Don, A.S., Robertson, P.A.: Anatomic determination of optimal entry point and direction for C1 lateral mass screw placement. J Spinal Disord Tech 22, 233–239 (2009) 2. Cacciola, F., Phalke, U., Goel, A.: Vertebral artery in relationship to C1-C2 vertebrae: an anatomical study. Neurol India 52, 178–184 (2004) 3. Cassinelli, E.H., Lee, M., Skalak, A., et al.: Anatomic considerations for the placement of C2 laminar screws. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 2767–2771 (2006) 4. Christensen, D.M., Eastlack, R.K., Lynch, J.J., et al.: C1 anatomy and dimensions relative to lateral mass screw placement. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 32, 844–848 (2007) 5. Currier, B.L., Maus, T.P., Eck, J.C., et al.: Relationship of the internal carotid artery to the anterior aspect of the C1 vertebra: implications for C1-C2 transarticular and C1 lateral mass fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 33, 635–639 (2008) 6. Debreuil-Chambardel, L.: Variations sexuelles de l’Atlas. Bull Soc Anthropologie de Paris 5, 399 (1907) 7. Doherty, B.J., Heggeness, M.H.: The quantitative anatomy of the atlas. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 19, 2497–2500 (1994) 8. Duan, S., Lv, S., Ye, F., et al.: Imaging anatomy and variation of vertebral artery and bone structure at craniocervical junction. Eur Spine J 18, 1102–1108 (2009)
1 Surgical Anatomy 9. Dvorak, J.: Rotation of the cervical spine by using computerized-tomography (CT). Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13, 595–597 (1988) 10. Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M.M.: Functional anatomy of the alar ligaments. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 183–189 (1987) 11. Ebraheim, N.A., Lu, J., Biyani, A., et al.: An anatomic study of the thickness of the occipital bone. Implications for occipitocervical instrumentation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 1725– 1729 (1996). discussion 1729–1730 12. Fine, A.D., Cardoso, A., Rhoton Jr., A.L.: Microsurgical anatomy of the extracranial-extradural origin of the posterior inferior cerebellar artery. J Neurosurg 91, 645–652 (1999) 13. Francis, C.C.: Variations in the articular facets of the cervical vertebrae. Anat Rec 122, 589–602 (1955) 14. Grob, D., Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M.M., et al.: The role of plate and screw fixation in occipitocervical fusion in rheumatoid arthritis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 19, 2545–2551 (1994) 15. Gupta, T.: Cadaveric morphometric anatomy of C-1 vertebra in relation to lateral mass screw placement. Surg Radiol Anat 30, 589–593 (2008) 16. Hawkins, T.D., Melcher, D.H.: A meningeal artery in the falx cerebelli. Clin Radiol 17, 377–383 (1966) 17. Heggeness, M.H., Doherty, B.J.: The trabecular anatomy of the axis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 18, 1945–1949 (1993) 18. Heller, J.G., Alson, M.D., Schaffler, M.B., et al.: Quantitative internal dens morphology. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 17, 861– 866 (1992) 19. Hong, X., Dong, Y., Yunbing, C., et al.: Posterior screw placement on the lateral mass of atlas: an anatomic study. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 29, 500–503 (2004) 20. Hong, J.T., Lee, S.W., Son, B.C., et al.: Analysis of anatomical variations of bone and vascular structures around the posterior atlantal arch using three-dimensional computed tomography angiography. J Neurosurg Spine 8, 230–236 (2008) 21. Howington, J.U., Kruse, J.J., Awasthi, D.: Surgical anatomy of the C-2 pedicle. J Neurosurg 95, 88–92 (2001) 22. Jian, F.Z., Santoro, A., Wang, X.W., et al.: A vertebral artery tortuous course below the posterior arch of the atlas (without passing through the transverse foramen). Anato mical report and clinical significance. J Neurosurg Sci 47, 183–187 (2003) 23. Jun, B.Y.: Anatomic study for ideal and safe posterior C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1703–1707 (1998) 24. Kadri, P.A., Al-Mefty, O.: Anatomy of the nuchal ligament and its surgical applications. Neurosurgery 61, 301–304 (2007). discussion 304 25. Kandziora, F., Schulze-Stahl, N., Khodadadyan-Klostermann, C., et al.: Screw placement in transoral atlantoaxial plate systems: an anatomical study. J Neurosurg 95, 80–87 (2001) 26. Kazan, S., Yildirim, F., Sindel, M., et al.: Anatomical evaluation of the groove for the vertebral artery in the axis vertebrae for atlanto-axial transarticular screw fixation technique. Clin Anat 13, 237–243 (2000) 27. Koller, H., Kammermeier, V., Ulbricht, D., et al.: Anterior retropharyngeal fixation C1-2 for stabilization of atlantoaxial instabilities: study of feasibility, technical description and preliminary results. Eur Spine J 15, 1326–1338 (2006) 28. La Marca, F., Zubay, G., Morrison, T., et al.: Cadaveric study for placement of occipital condyle screws: technique and
References effects on surrounding anatomic structures. J Neurosurg Spine 9, 347–353 (2008) 29. Lang, J.: The cranio-cervical junction – Anatomy. In: Voth, D., Glees, P. (eds.) Diseases in the cranio-cervical junction. Anatomical and pathological aspects and detailed clinical accounts, pp. 27–61. Gruyter, Berlin, New York (1987) 30. Lee, M.J., Cassinelli, E., Riew, K.D.: The feasibility of inserting atlas lateral mass screws via the posterior arch. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 2798–2801 (2006) 31. Lee, J.H., Jahng, T.A., Chung, C.K.: C1-2 transarticular screw fixation in high-riding vertebral artery: suggestion of new trajectory. J Spinal Disord Tech 20, 499–504 (2007) 32. Lu, J., Ebraheim, N.A., Yang, H., et al.: Anatomic considerations of anterior transarticular screw fixation for atlantoaxial instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1229–1235 (1998). discussion 1236 33. Madawi, A.A., Casey, A.T., Solanki, G.A., et al.: Radiological and anatomical evaluation of the atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation technique. J Neurosurg 86, 961–968 (1997) 34. Madawi, A.A., Solanki, G., Casey, A.T., et al.: Variation of the groove in the axis vertebra for the vertebral artery. Implications for instrumentation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 79, 820–823 (1997) 35. Moftakhar, P., Gonzalez, N.R., Khoo, L.T., et al.: Osseous and vascular anatomical variations within the C1-C2 complex: a radiographical study using computed tomography angiography. Int J Med Robot 4, 158–164 (2008) 36. Muthukumar, N., Swaminathan, R., Venkatesh, G., et al.: A morphometric analysis of the foramen magnum region as it relates to the transcondylar approach. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 147, 889–895 (2005) 37. Naderi, S., Cakmakci, H., Acar, F., et al.: Anatomical and computed tomographic analysis of C1 vertebra. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 105, 245–248 (2003) 38. Naderi, S., Korman, E., Citak, G., et al.: Morphometric analysis of human occipital condyle. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 107, 191–199 (2005) 39. Nadim, Y., Lu, J., Sabry, F.F., et al.: Occipital screws in occipitocervical fusion and their relation to the venous sinuses: an anatomic and radiographic study. Orthopedics 23, 717–719 (2000) 40. Neo, M., Matsushita, M., Iwashita, Y., et al.: Atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation for a high-riding vertebral artery. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, 666–670 (2003) 41. Newton, T.H.: The anterior and posterior meningeal branches of the vertebral artery. Radiology 91, 271–279 (1968) 42. Olivier, G.: Biometry of the human occipital bone. J Anat 120, 507–518 (1975) 43. Panjabi, M., Dvorak, J., Crisco 3rd, J.J., et al.: Effects of alar ligament transection on upper cervical spine rotation. J Orthop Res 9, 584–593 (1991) 44. Panjabi, M., Dvorak, J., Crisco 3rd, J., et al.: Flexion, extension, and lateral bending of the upper cervical spine in response to alar ligament transections. J Spinal Disord 4, 157–167 (1991)
15 45. Paramore, C.G., Dickman, C.A., Sonntag, V.K.: The anatomical suitability of the C1-2 complex for transarticular screw fixation. J Neurosurg 85, 221–224 (1996) 46. Resnick, D.K., Lapsiwala, S., Trost, G.R.: Anatomic suitability of the C1-C2 complex for pedicle screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 27, 1494–1498 (2002) 47. Roberts, D.A., Doherty, B.J., Heggeness, M.H.: Quantitative anatomy of the occiput and the biomechanics of occipital screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1100–1107 (1998). discussion 1107–1108 48. Rocha, R., Safavi-Abbasi, S., Reis, C., et al.: Working area, safety zones, and angles of approach for posterior C-1 lateral mass screw placement: a quantitative anatomical and morphometric evaluation. J Neurosurg Spine 6, 247–254 (2007) 49. Santos-Franco, J.A., de Oliveira, E., Mercado, R., et al.: Microsurgical considerations of the anterior spinal and the anterior-ventral spinal arteries. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 148, 329–338 (2006). discussion 338 50. Schmidt, H., Fisher, E.: Die okzipitale Dysplasie. Thieme, Stuttgart (1960) 51. Seal, C., Zarro, C., Gelb, D., et al.: C1 lateral mass anatomy: proper placement of lateral mass screws. J Spinal Disord Tech 22, 516–523 (2009) 52. Seckin, H., Ates, O., Bauer, A.M., et al.: Microsurgical anatomy of the posterior spinal artery via a far-lateral transcondylar approach. J Neurosurg Spine 10, 228–233 (2009) 53. Solanki, G.A., Crockard, H.A.: Preoperative determination of safe superior transarticular screw trajectory through the lateral mass. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 1477–1482 (1999) 54. Tan, M., Wang, H., Wang, Y., et al.: Morphometric evaluation of screw fixation in atlas via posterior arch and lateral mass. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, 888–895 (2003) 55. Tokuda, K., Miyasaka, K., Abe, H., et al.: Anomalous atlantoaxial portions of vertebral and posterior inferior cerebellar arteries. Neuroradiology 27, 410–413 (1985) 56. Tsusaki, T.: Über den Atlas und Epistropheus bei den eingeborenen Formosanern. Folia Anatomica Japonica 2, 221–246 (1924) 57. Tubbs, R.S., Salter, E.G., Oakes, W.J.: The accessory atlantoaxial ligament. Neurosurgery 55, 400–402 (2004). discussion 402–404 58. Xu, R., Burgar, A., Ebraheim, N.A., et al.: The quantitative anatomy of the laminas of the spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 107–113 (1999) 59. Xu, R., Nadaud, M.C., Ebraheim, N.A., et al.: Morphology of the second cervical vertebra and the posterior projection of the C2 pedicle axis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 20, 259–263 (1995) 60. Young, J.P., Young, P.H., Ackermann, M.J., et al.: The ponticulus posticus: implications for screw insertion into the first cervical lateral mass. J Bone Joint Surg Am 87, 2495–2498 (2005) 61. Zipnick, R.I., Merola, A.A., Gorup, J., et al.: Occipital morphology. An anatomic guide to internal fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 1719–1724 (1996). discussion 1729–1730
2
Biomechanical Remarks P. Suchomel and P. Buchvald
Knowledge of normal biomechanics of the cervical spine is very important as it can be modified by various pathological situations. The changes that occur during injury and/or in consequence with other pathological conditions or surgical procedures can substantially influence the stability of this most important spinal joint complex. It is difficult to determine what the normal motion of the cervical spine is as it depends on the size, weight, anatomy, degree of degeneration, bone quality, and age of each person or specimen. Both in vivo and in vitro investigations have been undertaken to accumulate the clinically important biomechanical data. Performing the in vitro studies, various fresh cadaver spine specimens were tested. Most often, the six motion components were evaluated: flexion/extension, axial rotation, lateral bending, and translation about each axis. A number of techniques have been developed to apply loads and to measure these motion components. Pioneering work in this field is credited to Panjabi et al. [21]. They monitored the three- dimensional motion by an optoelectronic system based on the principles of stereophotogrammetry. In vivo motion analyses are usually based on the CT investigations [27], the electrogoniometer gauging technique, [1] or the stereophotogrammetry [25]. The occipitoatlantoaxial complex (C0-C1-C2) is a very complicated structure with motion determined by the bony morphology and orientation of the articular processes and limited by ligaments and joint capsules. It is composed of the occipitoatlantal (C0-C1) and atlantoaxial (C1-C2) joint complexes. We should emphasize that these two motion segments are intimately linked and the motion is always coupled. P. Suchomel () and P. Buchvald Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St. 10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic
The atlantooccipital joints (C0-C1) are anteromedially oriented, concave spheroid articulations connected by very tight capsules. Their mechanical properties are determined mainly by the shape of bony elements. Flexion and extension reported between 13° and 25° (in total range), according to different investigators, is their dominant movement [10, 23, 26, 30, 33]. Flexion is limited by the tip of the dens impinging on the anterior margin of the foramen magnum (bursa apicis dentis) [33] and extension is restricted mainly by the tectorial membrane inserted to the body of axis and the anterior rim of the foramen magnum; nevertheless, the exact function of tectorial membrane is still a matter of debate [18, 30, 31, 33]. Translation at this junction is minimal under normal conditions and during sagittal movement should not change more than 1 mm [24, 37]. Allowed lateral bending is between 3° and 5° to each side [23, 26, 30]. Although the idea of possible axial rotation had been refused in the past, more recently some authors have documented existence of minimal axial rotation in this joint. The one-side rotational movement range was measured between 1° and 7.2° [4, 10, 23, 27]. The rotation and lateral bending of C0-C1 is controlled mainly by the joint capsules but also the allar ligaments. The instantaneous axis of axial rotation (IAR) for the C0-C1 articulation is ventral to foramen magnum. The atlantoaxial complex (C1-C2) is composed of four joints: two AA lateral joints, the atlantoaxial median joint (between the anterior arch of the atlas and the dens axis), and the joint between the posterior surface of the dens and the transverse ligament. Stability at this highly mobile junction is dependent predominantly on ligamentous structures. Sagittal plane motion (flexion-extension) in C1-C2 has been reported to be on an average 20° (10°– 30°) by several authors [7, 16, 33]. Lateral bending limited by allar ligaments is inconsequential under normal conditions by some authors [33] but reaching 7°–10° to
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_2, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
17
18
one side by others [23, 27]. In the occipitoatlantoaxial complex, 85–90% of all axial rotation comes from the atlantoaxial segment [10, 23]. Penning and Wilmink [27] found that atlantoaxial complex accounted for 56% of the whole cervical rotation with respect to the first thoracic vertebra. Normal range of rotation between C1 and C2 is determined on an average about 40° to each side [3, 17, 34]. Range of axial rotation to one side in C1-C2 has been reported in the various studies to be between 23° [10] and 47° [33]. The great differences in the results are mostly due to the differences in the methods used and dissimilarities of in vitro and in vivo studies. For example, Dvorak et al. reported in their in vivo (CT) tests an average range of axial rotation 32.2° and consecutively, 43.1° [4]. The high rotational motion range is facilitated by very loose AA joint capsules and limited quite freely by allar ligaments. The allar ligaments (connecting the dens axis with occipital condyles and the anterior arch of the atlas) consist of high amount of collagen fibers and their major function is to prevent redundant axial rotation to the contralateral side [6, 22, 33]. These ligaments together with tectorial membrane also limit the flexion of the occiput and during lateral bending are responsible for the forced rotation of the axis [3]. The cruciate ligament is formed by horizontally oriented TAL and vertically oriented longitudinal fibers (Fig. 1.5, Chap. 1). Between the odontoid process and transverse ligament is a thin layer of cartilage, which allows for TAL to move freely during rotation and preserves it from friction damage.
2 Biomechanical Remarks
The transverse ligament consists of collagen fibers and is very resistant to breakage. Spence et al. in their original cadaver tests reported stress necessary to TAL rupture in average 580 N (38–104 kg) [29]. Dvorak et al. described experimental failure of TAL only under the force 170– 700 N (corresponding about 17–70 kg) [8]. Restriction of anterior translation of the atlas during flexion of the head is the main function of TAL while still permitting its axial rotation around the dens. The secondary restriction of this motion is secured by atlantodental component of the allar ligaments. The tertiary stabilizers are the accessory atlantoaxial ligaments and capsular ligaments [5, 6]. TAL partially protects the C1-C2 joint also from a rotary dislocation. Posterior translation is prevented by mechanical bracing of the anterior portion of C1 on the dens. The apical ligament due to its laxity probably has no important function is movement restriction [15]. The IAR for sagittal plane motion is located in the region of the middle third of the dens and for axial rotation in the central axis of the dens, respectively [33].
2.1 CVJ and UCS Axial Load Distribution The motion characteristics of UCS are unique; nevertheless, the axial load distribution in CVJ represents another exceptional situation irreproducible in other parts of spine (Fig. 2.1). The weight of the head and the axial
Fig. 2.1 Diagram showing the axial load distribution changing from two to three force vectors at the C2 level. (a) CT in 3D reconstruction in frontal plane. (b) CT in 3D reconstruction in sagittal plane. Note the consequent hangman type fracture
2.2 Clinical and Morphological Instability of CVJ and UCS
19
Fig. 2.2 Traumatic consequences of atypical axial load distribution in CVJ and UCS depicted on coronal CT reconstructions. (a) fracture of occipital condyle. (b) lateral C1 mass fracture
simultaneous with condyle fracture. (c) fracture of lateral facet C2 pillar. Note the TAL avulsion fragment and type III odontoid fracture
loads applied to the head are transmitted through the two occipital condyles to two AO joints. The wedge-shaped lateral masses of C1 transfer the weight downwards with logical tendency to distract laterally. If the C1 ring and TAL act properly, the force is further transmitted to two C2 facets; however, further load distribution in C2 vertebra is divided from two force vectors into three points at the C2-C3 interface [14]. Most of the load is thus transmitted to the C2-C3 disk and less to the posterior C2/C3 facetal joints. The force transmission divergence has some critical places where consequently fractures can arise in the case of overload (Fig. 2.2). First critical place is the atlas. Wedge-shaped lateral masses and the C1 free floating “washer” ring have to buffer the axial force and if overloaded the atlas bursting leading to Jefferson-like fractures can happen (Chap. 10). The second critical location is the C2 pars interarticularis and mainly its isthmus as locus of minor resistance. The axial force overload can lead to overstressing of the bone resistance and create the hangman type fractures. Certainly, previously described model situations can be further modified by concomitant rotation, lateral bending of sagittal movement. This physiological CVJ and UCS load distribution has to be respected during reconstruction procedures also.
choice in various types of pathological lesions in this region. Clinical stability at the C0-C1 and C1-C2 joints is intimately linked to their functional anatomy. Clinical instability can occur as a result of trauma, degenerative conditions, tumors, inflammation, or surgery; however, its definition is still controversial. Significant disagreement exists even among experts. White and Panjabi [35] defined clinical instability as the loss of the ability of the spine under physiologic loads to maintain relationships between vertebrae in such a way that there is neither initial nor subsequent damage to the spinal cord or nerve roots, and in addition, there is neither development of incapacitating deformity nor severe pain. They further defined physiological loads as loads that are incurred during normal activity. Incapacitating deformity was defined as gross deformity that the patient finds intolerable. Severe pain was defined as pain that cannot be controlled by non-opioid analgesic medications. In short, it means that the spine is unable to resist the physiological loads without pain, deformity and/or neurological deficit. Such a broad definition, in fact, encompasses nearly all the pathological conditions detectable in UCS. The definition of mechanical instability is more exactly specified than clinical one. In fact, whatever static or dynamic position of UCS beyond the physiological limits is detected must be considered as instability. Static and dynamic radiographic investigations with consecutive exact measurements are providing us information necessary to decide if the spine is stable or not (see Chap. 3).
2.2 Clinical and Morphological Instability of CVJ and UCS It is of utmost importance to decide whether the UCS is stable or not in order to determine correct treatment
20
2 Biomechanical Remarks
Table 2.1 Morphological criteria for upper cervical spine instability [35] >8°
Axial rotation C0-C1 to one side (measurable only on CT)
>1 mm
C0-C1 translation (measurable only on C)
>7 mm
Overhang C1-C2 (total right and left, on anteroposterior radiograph)
>45°
Axial rotation C1-C2 to one side
>3 mm
C1-C2 translation at anterior atlantodental interval (AADI)
<13 mm
posterior atlantodental interval (PADI)
Avulsed transverse ligament
2.3 Occipitoatlantal Joint Stability and Instability Stability in this joint is secured mainly by their tight capsules, the anterior and posterior atlanto-occipital membrane, and through the ligaments between the occiput and the axis: the tectorial membrane, allar ligaments, and apical ligament [13]. Instability in the C0-C1 joints is less common than at the C1-C2 level. It can be result of trauma, rheumatoid arthritis, infection, tumor, or destabilizing surgery. Vishteh et al. experimentally demonstrated the AO hypermobility caused by resection of occipital condyle. They found flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation increased 15.3%, 40.8%, and 28.1%, respectively after 50% condylectomy [32]. The AO joint is relatively unstable in children because of its structural characteristic and ligamentous laxity. Its stability increases in adulthood due to a decrease in elasticity of the ligaments [24]. OA dislocations (AOD) can be in the anterior, posterior, or longitudinal directions. Normally, the AO joint sagittal translation should not exceed 1mm, and the distraction distance (CCI) can reach 2 mm maximally on parasagittal CT images [19, 20, 36]. From other parameters used to evaluate the AOD, the Powers ratio is most frequently used [28]; however, the basion-dental interval (BDI) and basion-posterior axial line interval (BAI) both of which should not exceed 12 mm (“rule of twelve”) are considered as the most exact and AODspecific measurements [2, 11, 12]. Greater than 8° of unilateral axial rotation as other instability sign can be seriously measured only on superimposed CT scans
[4, 6]. Basilar invagination and/or basilar impression represent the vertical instability. It appears most often in developmental anomalies and rheumatoid arthritis but also can occur in tumors or trauma. Methods of determining vertical CVJ instability are described in detail in appropriate chapters (see Chaps. 3 and 20).
2.4 Atlantoaxial Joint Stability and Instability The transverse atlantal ligament has a key role in the maintaining AA stability. Especially, allar ligaments but also atlantoaxial accessory ligaments, apical ligament, and joint capsules provide secondary security [13, 22]. Instability at the AA joint is often presented as abnormal translation and/or axial rotation; nevertheless, other dislocations are also possible. Mainly TAL limits anterior translation of C1 on C2 as it will be described in further chapters. Fielding et al. [9] noted that anterior AADI is normally not more than 3 mm. AADI of 3–5 mm implies damage of the transverse ligament, and AADI measured 5 mm or more indicates that the accessory stabilizing system (especially, the allar ligaments) has been also damaged. A PADI of less than 13 mm may also denote anterior translational instability. The allar ligaments alone are not capable of preventing excessive anterior horizontal displacement if the transverse ligament is ruptured. If the odontoid process is hypoplastic, fractured, or resected logically the ligaments also cannot provide their stabilizing function. Posterior AA translation, despite being rare, can be detected in trauma, tumor, or other pathologies destroying odontoid – TAL catch system as well. Nonetheless, more frequently, the rotational dislocations of different types are diagnosed [3, 4, 6]. The rotation-limiting ability of the alar ligament was investigated by Dvorak et al. [6] in cadaver studies. They observed a mean increase of 9° or 30% of the original mean rotation divided equally between the C0-C1 (+5°) and C1-C2 (+4°) complexes in axial rotation in response to an alar ligament lesion on the opposite side. The laboratory findings of Dvorak and Panjabi were verified with a clinical CT study of 9 healthy adults and 43 patients with cervical spine instability with conclusion that axial rotation of the C0-C1-C2 complex can be increased after trauma-lesions of the alar ligaments [5]. In general, these studies showed that the main function
References
of the alar ligament is to limit axial rotation to the contralateral side. The transverse ligament also protects the atlantoaxial joint from a rotatory dislocation. Fielding et al. [9] described that with the intact transverse ligament, a complete bilateral rotational AA dislocation can occur if 65° or more is reached. With transverse ligament disruption dislocation can occur at 45° of rotation already. Total lateral displacement of more than 6.9 mm of the lateral masses of C1 over the C2 facets, as measured on the cadaver tests, determines disruption or avulsion of the transverse ligament [29].
2.5 For Practical Purposes We Can Summarize The motion of AO-AA joint complex is always coupled. UCS is responsible for 60% of rotation and 40% flexion and extension of the whole cervical spine. Atlas has the widest range of motion of any vertebra in the spine. It is almost freely floating in between the occiput and C2 buffering the axial loads coming from head to spine. The AO joint mainly provides flexion and extension in the range of 20°, lateral bending is possible up to 10°. Negligible rotation is possible; however, translation of more than 1 mm is considered as pathological. The joint distraction measured on CT should not exceed 2 mm. The AA joint is responsible for 90% of axial rotation of the UCS complex with the average range of rotational motion to one side of 40°. Flexion-extension is possible at an average of 20° and the lateral bending can reach up to 10°. Whatever parameter measured beyond the physiological limits has to be considered as mechanical instability. Performing complex reconstruction of the UCS the load distribution typical for this spine region has to be respected and the non-affected segments spared to preserve as much movement as possible.
References 1. Alund, M., Larsson, S.E.: Three-dimensional analysis of neck motion. A clinical method. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 15, 87–91 (1990) 2. Bono, C.M., Vaccaro, A.R., Fehlings, M., et al.: Measurement techniques for upper cervical spine injuries: consensus statement of the Spine Trauma Study Group. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 32, 593–600 (2007)
21 3. Dvorak, J., Froehlich, D., Penning, L., et al.: Functional radiographic diagnosis of the cervical spine: flexion/extension. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13, 748–755 (1988) 4. Dvorak, J., Hayek, J., Zehnder, R.: CT-functional diagnostics of the rotatory instability of the upper cervical spine. Part 2. An evaluation on healthy adults and patients with suspected instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 726–731 (1987) 5. Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M.M.: Functional anatomy of the alar ligaments. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 183–189 (1987) 6. Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M., Gerber, M., et al.: CT-functional diagnostics of the rotatory instability of upper cervical spine. 1. An experimental study on cadavers. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 197–205 (1987) 7. Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M.M., Novotny, J.E., et al.: In vivo flexion/extension of the cervical spine. J Orthop Res 9, 824–834 (1991) 8. Dvorak, J., Schneider, E., Saldinger, P., et al.: Biomechanics of the craniocervical region: the alar and transverse ligaments. J Orthop Res 6, 452–461 (1988) 9. Fielding, J.W., Cochran, G.B., Lawsing 3rd, J.F., et al.: Tears of the transverse ligament of the atlas. A clinical and biomechanical study. J Bone Joint Surg Am 56, 1683–1691 (1974) 10. Goel, V.K., Clark, C.R., Gallaes, K., et al.: Moment-rotation relationships of the ligamentous occipito-atlanto-axial complex. J Biomech 21, 673–680 (1988) 11. Harris Jr., J.H., Carson, G.C., Wagner, L.K.: Radiologic diagnosis of traumatic occipitovertebral dissociation: 1. Normal occipitovertebral relationships on lateral radiographs of supine subjects. AJR Am J Roentgenol 162, 881– 886 (1994) 12. Harris Jr., J.H., Carson, G.C., Wagner, L.K., et al.: Radiologic diagnosis of traumatic occipitovertebral dissociation: 2. Comparison of three methods of detecting occipitovertebral relationships on lateral radiographs of supine subjects. AJR Am J Roentgenol 162, 887–892 (1994) 13. Hecker, P.: Appareil ligamenteux occipito-atloidoaxoidien: étude d’anatomie comparée. Arch Anat Hist Embryol 2, 57–95 (1923) 14. Jeszenszky, D., Fekete, T.F., Melcher, R., et al.: C2 prosthesis: anterior upper cervical fixation device to reconstruct the second cervical vertebra. Eur Spine J 16, 1695–1700 (2007) 15. Lang, J.: The cranio-cervical junction – Anatomy. In: Voth, D., Glees, P. (eds.) Diseases in the cranio-cervical junction. Anatomical and pathological aspects and detailed clinical accounts, pp. 27–61. Gruyter, Berlin, New York (1987) 16. Lin, R.M., Tsai, K.H., Chu, L.P., et al.: Characteristics of sagittal vertebral alignment in flexion determined by dynamic radiographs of the cervical spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, 256–261 (2001) 17. Monckeberg, J.E., Tome, C.V., Matias, A., et al.: CT scan study of atlantoaxial rotatory mobility in asymptomatic adult subjects: a basis for better understanding C1-C2 rotatory fixation and subluxation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34, 1292–1295 (2009) 18. Oda, T., Panjabi, M.M., Crisco 3rd, J.J., et al.: Role of tectorial membrane in the stability of the upper cervical spine. Clin Biomech 7, 201–207 (1992) 19. Pang, D., Nemzek, W.R., Zovickian, J.: Atlanto-occipital dislocation: part 1 – normal occipital condyle-C1 interval in 89 children. Neurosurgery 61, 514–521 (2007). discussion 521
22 20. Pang, D., Nemzek, W.R., Zovickian, J.: Atlanto-occipital dislocation – part 2: The clinical use of (occipital) condyleC1 interval, comparison with other diagnostic methods, and the manifestation, management, and outcome of atlantooccipital dislocation in children. Neurosurgery 61, 995–1015 (2007). discussion 1015 21. Panjabi, M.M., Duranceau, J., Goel, V., et al.: Cervical human vertebrae. Quantitative three-dimensional anatomy of the middle and lower regions. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 16, 861–869 (1991) 22. Panjabi, M., Dvorak, J., Crisco 3rd, J.J., et al.: Effects of alar ligament transection on upper cervical spine rotation. J Orthop Res 9, 584–593 (1991) 23. Panjabi, M., Dvorak, J., Duranceau, J., et al.: Threedimensional movements of the upper cervical spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13, 726–730 (1988) 24. Panjabi, M.M., Yue, J.J., Dvorak, J., et al.: Cervical spine kinematics and clinical instability. In: Clark, C.R., Benzel, E.C., Currier, B.L., et al. (eds.) The cervical spine, vol. 4, pp. 55–78. Lippincott, Philadelphia (2005) 25. Pearcy, M.J., Whittle, M.W.: Movements of the lumbar spine measured by three-dimensional X-ray analysis. J Biomed Eng 4, 107–112 (1982) 26. Penning, L.: Normal movements of the cervical spine. AJR Am J Roentgenol 130, 317–326 (1978) 27. Penning, L., Wilmink, J.T.: Rotation of the cervical spine. A CT study in normal subjects. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 732–738 (1987)
2 Biomechanical Remarks 28. Powers, B., Miller, M.D., Kramer, R.S., et al.: Traumatic anterior atlanto-occipital dislocation. Neurosurgery 4, 12–17 (1979) 29. Spence Jr., K.F., Decker, S., Sell, K.W.: Bursting atlantal fracture associated with rupture of the transverse ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Am 52, 543–549 (1970) 30. Steinmetz, M.P., Mroz, T.E., Benzel, E.C.: Craniovertebral junction: biomechanical considerations. Neurosurgery 66, A7–A12 (2010) 31. Tubbs, R.S., Kelly, D.R., Humphrey, E.R., et al.: The tectorial membrane: anatomical, biomechanical, and histological analysis. Clin Anat 20, 382–386 (2007) 32. Vishteh, A.G., Crawford, N.R., Melton, M.S., et al.: Stability of the craniovertebral junction after unilateral occipital condyle resection: a biomechanical study. J Neurosurg 90, 91–98 (1999) 33. Werne, S.: Studies in spontaneous atlas dislocation. Acta Orthop Scand Suppl 23, 1–150 (1957) 34. White, A.P.M.: Kinematics of the spine. Lippincott, Philadelphia (1990) 35. White, A.A., Panjabi, M.M.: Clinical biomechanics of the spine. Lippincott, Philadelphia (1990) 36. Wiesel, S., Kraus, D., Rothman, R.H.: Atlanto-occipital hypermobility. Orthop Clin North Am 9, 969–972 (1978) 37. Wiesel, S.W., Rothman, R.H.: Occipitoatlantal hypermobility. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 4, 187–191 (1979)
3
Special Radiology O. Choutka and P. Suchomel
The anatomy and pathology of the craniovertebral junction (CVJ) may be complex but can be readily visualized by a variety of radiological means. The primary modalities include simple plain radiographs, computer tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Each clinical scenario warrants a different imaging modality or, more commonly, a combination of multiple modalities. This chapter describes these imaging modalities as they pertain to the CVJ. Specific pathologies are discussed in separate chapters. Historically, plain films have been the radiographic gold standard for assessment of the spine in general and form an essential part of spinal evaluation today, more than 100 years since Wilhelm Roentgen shared the firstever radiograph of his wife’s hand in 1895 [23]. Bony and some soft tissue abnormalities are well visualized on plain films. Lateral cervical radiographs are the most commonly used images in acute evaluation of the cervical spine. For example, they are used while patient is still on the stretcher and further determine the way patient can be handled through their traumatic work up. This is even more important for the unconscious patient. The most commonly missed traumatic injuries are at the lower end of the cervical spine [44] and different projections such as swimmer’s (“flying angel”) view have been designed to enhance the visibility of the cervicothoracic junction. Similarly, multiple views exist to carefully delineate CVJ.
O. Choutka Department of Neurosurgery, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 231 Albert Sabin Way, PO Box 670515, Cincinnati, OH 45267-0515, USA P. Suchomel Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St. 10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic
Lateral projection allows for a good assessment of the alignment of the bony components of the spine and also sagittal balance when performed upright. Any abnormality detected on bony spinal canal (fracture, subluxation) necessitates further examination to determine its cause. Prevertebral soft tissue swelling can point one to the area of injury as it often indicates a presence of a hematoma secondary to a fracture. Anteroposterior view is commonly obliterated by the jaw; so, openmouth view films are particularly useful in assessing odontoid pathology as well as the integrity of the atlantoaxial and atlanto-occipital relationships. Allesandro Vallebona proposed to represent a single slice of a body part on a radiograph, the so-called tomography, a technique that remained the pillar of radiology until the late 1970s [32]. However, the availability of computers and transverse axial scanning resulted in the development of CT by Godfrey Hounsfield and Allan McLeod Cormack [36]. Since then, multi-slice CT has revolutionized cross-sectional imaging with scanning time down to a single breath hold today. Isotropic voxels allow for two-dimensional reformatting and thus production of high quality threedimensional images that are particularly useful when assessing complex bony abnormalities of the CVJ. However, the disadvantage of CT is increased radiation dose to patients with its ever more prevalent sequelae, particularly in pediatric population [4]. Although myelography with CT allows for excellent neural structure delineation and skeletal correlation, it has been largely replaced by MRI technology credited to Paul Lauterbur and Sir Peter Mansfield who were awarded Nobel Prize in 2003, albeit some controversy surrounds the award [40]. MRI is excellent in evaluation of neural, ligamentous, and disk structures. Sagittal images become particularly useful in CVJ, evaluation of alignment, and assessment of various craniometric lines and angles.
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_3, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
23
24
3 Special Radiology
Upright films (plain radiography or even MRI) can be a useful adjunct to evaluation of any spinal pathology that may change under loading conditions of the erect human body [13, 47]. Under appropriate supervision, plain films, CT, and MRI can be obtained in dynamic positions when concern for instability exists, thus providing further information about soft tissue and bony dynamics of the CVJ. Multiple parameters based on static and dynamic films have been developed to grade clinical status or instability of the CVJ. Vascular anatomy of the CVJ can be evaluated by multiple modalities. Angiography later improved by digitalized subtraction was the standard since its development by Egas Moniz in 1927 [43]. However, with CT and MR angiography available, only very specific situations [51] would require the patient to be subjected to the potential risks of conventional angiography nowadays.
3.1 Radiographic Data Analysis Advances in neuroimaging allow for excellent visualization of the CVJ and UCS. Therefore, an effective diagnostic approach is necessary to prevent unnecessary secondary neurological sequelae (e.g., spinal cord injury from a missed traumatic atlantooccipital dislocation). Plain radiography remains the mainstay of early evaluation of the cervical spine in majority of hospitals. One has to be aware that lateral cervical spine films are centered on the C3 vertebra; therefore, the visualization of CVJ may be skewed by the oblique nature of the atlanto-occipital joints relative to the x-ray beams. Coned down views of the UCS or lateral skull films can clarify this relationship a
[8]. Although plain films have been surpassed by the quality of other modalities in this region, there are multiple indirect signs on plain films, pointing to craniocervical junction abnormalities. These include prevertebral soft tissue swelling, lack of override of mastoid processes of the odontoid tip, and disruption of UCS laminae [31]. Once seen, further evaluation is warranted. Over the years, numerous craniometric parameters (lines, planes, angles, and relationships) have been described and tested in practice to assess radiographic alignment of the structures of CVJ (Table 3.1). Specific osseous anatomical landmarks need to be visualized on imaging to derive those lines/angles to be able to detect and quantify an abnormality. Those include nasion, tuberculum sellae, basion (anterior margin of FM), opisthion (posterior margin of FM), posterior hard palate edge, anterior and posterior arches of atlas, odontoid process, and C2 vertebral body (Fig. 3.1).
3.1.1 Basal/Clival Parameters The Welcher basal angle can be measured on plain films or mid-sagittal CT or MRI images and is formed by the nasion-tuberculum and tuberculum basion lines [45]. It is a modification to the angle of Landzert, which represents an angle between planum sphenoidale and the clivus. Welcher basal angle averages 132° and should always be less than 140° [10]. Lanzert’s angle changes during fetal development and then averages 113.9° in adults [16, 55]. Both angles abnormally increase when the skull base is flat as in platybasia with or without basilar impression (Fig. 3.2).
b
Fig. 3.1 Relevant anatomical landmarks needed to be visualized for analysis of CVJ craniometric parameters: 1 nasion, 2 tuberculum sella, 3 basion (anterior margin of FM), 4 opisthion (posterior margin of FM), 5 posterior hard palate edge, 6 anterior
and 7 posterior arches of atlas, 8 odontoid process, and 9 C2 vertebral body. (a) lateral plain radiogram. (b) CT in sagittal plane. (c) MRI in sagittal plane
25
3.1 Radiographic Data Analysis Table 3.1 Craniometric parameters Line/angle Film
Anatomic landmarks/relationship
Normal value
Pathology
Wackenheim line
L
Posterior surface of clivus and dens
Tangent to the dens and behind it, may cross its posterior third
BI
Chamberlain line
L
Hard palate to opisthion and dens
Dens protrudes <5 mm above it
BI
McRae line (FM line)
L
Basion to opisthion and dens
Dens below line
BI
McGregor line
L
Hard palate to basiocciput and dens
Dens protrudes <7 mm above it
BI
Ranawat line/criterion
L
Distance in mid-dens coronal plane, between transverse axis of atlas and midpoint of C2 pedicle
>15 mm in males >13 mm in females
BI
Redlund-Johnell and Pettersson distance
L
McGregor line to midpoint of inferior C2 endplate
>34 mm in males >29 mm in females
BI
Fischgold and Metzger
AP
On AP films. Line between the mastoid tips and dens
Dens below the line
BI
Klaus posterior fossa height index
L
Perpendicular distance between dens and tuberculum/internal occipital protuberance line
>30 mm
BI
Welcher basal angle
L
Nasion to tuberculum line and tuberculum to basion line
<140°
Platybasia
Clivus-canal angle
L
Wackenheim line and posterior axial line
150°–180°
BI
Platybasia
Platybasia
Cervico-medullary angle
L
Measured on MRI, anterior medullary line and cervical spinal cord line
>135°
BI Cranial settling
Basion-dental interval (BDI)
L
Distance of basion to dens tip
<12 mm
AOD
Basion-axial interval (BAI)
L
Perpendicular distance from basion to posterior axial line
<12 mm
AOD
Atlanto-dental interval (ADI)
L
Distance dens to anterior C1 arch
<3 mm in adults <5 mm in children
AAI
Posterior ADI (PADI) Space available for cord
L
Distance dens to posterior C1 arch
>18 mm no neurology <14 mm always compromised
Neurological compromise in AAI
Atlanto-occipital joint axis angle
AP
On AP films. Angle between two lines parallel to AO joints
124°–127°
Condylar hypoplasia
Condyle-C1 interval (occipito-atlantal joint gap)
AP or L
Distance C1 lateral mass and occipital condyle
AOD
Clark Station
L
Atlantoaxial vertical relationship. Anterior atlas ring relative to axis height divided into equal vertical thirds
<2 mm adults <5 mm children Ring of atlas opposite the upper third of axis
BI
26
3 Special Radiology
Fig. 3.2 Welcher basal angle (nasion-tuberculum-basion angle). (a) Normal angle as measured on plain lateral radiograph. (b) platybasia measured on 3D CT sagittal reconstruction
Fig. 3.3 The Wackenheim clivus line in a case of atlas settling and odontoid process slight invagination
3.1.2 Craniocervical Parameters The Wackenheim clivus line is drawn along the posterior surface of clivus and extended inferiorly [52] (Fig. 3.3). The line delineates the relationship between clivus and the odontoid process. In a normal CVJ alignment, the clivus baseline falls behind the odontoid tip
Fig. 3.4 Clivus-canal (craniovertebral) angle
or may cross the posterior third. Any greater degree of odontoid transaction is seen in basilar invagination or AAD. The angle formed by Wackenheim line and posterior axial line represents the clivus-canal (craniovertebral) angle (Fig. 3.4). This angle varies between 150° and 180° depending on flexion/extension position and may represent spinal cord compression in situations of it being less than 150° [50]. The clivus-canal angle
27
3.1 Radiographic Data Analysis
is important in platybasia/basilar impression description as it is not unusual for this angle to become rather acute (even 90°) sometimes without abnormal violation of the above described Wackenheim clivus baseline. Due to common difficulties with visualization of bony structures required for the measurement of clivus-canal angle, particularly after decompressive procedures and the indirect nature of bony parameters attempting to represent neurological compromise, Bundschuh et al. described cervico-medullary angle (CMA) in order to directly demonstrate the degree of brainstem and spinal cord compression in basilar invagination or cranial settling in rheumatoid patients [5]. They compared those values with 50 normal patients and concluded that all patients with CMA of less than 135° had evidence of brainstem compression, cervical myelopathy, or C2 nerve root pain. The angle is measured at the intersection of lines drawn parallel to ventral surfaces of the medulla and upper cervical cord on MRI (Fig. 3.5). Multiple publications since then have correlated the CMA with clinical syndrome as well as therapeutic indications and outcomes [39, 54]. However, the largest study defining the normal values of CMA found it to be approximately 158° (139°–175° range) when evaluating 200 patients’ MRI without craniovertebral anomalies [53]. Furthermore, the authors also found the CMA to have an excellent inter- and intra-observer reliability. Similar to Wackenheim clivus baseline, most of the original craniometric lines for detection of basilar
invagination or cranial settling in rheumatoid patients were originally based on plain radiographic assessment. The use of CT makes those measurements easier as bony structures can be easily visualized in the midsagittal plane. Historically, the most useful parameters measured on lateral films include Chamberlain, McGregor, and McRae’s lines (Fig. 3.6) as well as the Klaus index. Other criteria are listed in Table 3.1. (Clark station, RedlundJohnell and Pettersson, Ranawat, Fischgold and Metzger). All of these are less applicable to traumatic situations where distraction, rather than settling, occurs. Basilar invagination or impression can be diagnosed on plain radiographs when the odontoid tip protrudes at least 2 mm above the Chamberlain line: hard palate to opisthion line [6]; 4.5 mm above the McGregor line: posterosuperior aspect of the hard palate to the most caudal point on the mid-occipital curve line [28]; or any distance above the McRae line: basion to opisthion [29] (Fig. 3.6). Redlund-Johnell criterion represents the distance between McGregor line and inferior C2 vertebral body measured through its midpoint [38]. Distance of less than 34 mm in males or 29 mm in females is indicative of basilar invagination. Similarly, according to the Ranawat criterion, the distance between the center of the second cervical pedicle and the transverse axis of atlas along the odontoid process needs to be less than 15 mm in males and 13 mm in females to indicate invagination [37]. On AP transoral plain film, one can draw a line connecting the mastoid tips (FischgoldMetzger line) and if the odontoid protrudes above it, it again indicates basilar invagination [3, 30]. Using any criterion that requires exact odontoid process visualization in rheumatoid patients may be difficult. Therefore, criteria that utilized other landmarks than the odontoid process were developed as mentioned above. Indeed, the hard palate was seen in 93% of patients, followed
McRae Chamberlain
Fig. 3.5 Cervicomedullary angle as measured on MRI
Fig. 3.6 Schematic drawing of basal lines
McGregor
28
by the atlas (88%) but the odontoid tip in only 34% of patients in a study of 131 rheumatoid patients [41]. The authors went on to determine the sensitivity and specificity of the above-mentioned criteria in diagnosing basilar invagination and found that individually, none of them reached sensitivity or negative predictive value (NPV) greater than 90%, not even those that did not require odontoid visualization (i.e., RedlundJohnell and Ranawat). However, when combining Clark station, the Redlund-Johnell, and the Ranawat criteria to plain film assessment, the combined sensitivity and negative predictive value reached 94% and 91%, respectively. Practically, they recommended further imaging if basilar invagination was suspected by the combined criteria in rheumatoid patients. Using the combined criteria, 55% patients could be spared of unnecessary MRI evaluation in their opinion. The Klaus height index measures the perpendicular height from the tip of the odontoid process to the line connecting tuberculum sellae and the internal occipital protuberance [24]. This measurement can be more accurate if obtained from an MRI as the tentorium is clearly visible. If the posterior fossa height is less than 30 mm, it suggests platybasia and basilar invagination. All criteria/lines mentioned above utilized some sort of relationship between the skull and the cervical spine. However, Clark station of the atlas uses the vertical atlantoaxial relationship to predict presence of basilar invagination [7]. It divides the axis into three equal parts on sagittal film, and if the anterior ring of atlas crosses the middle or caudal thirds, basilar invagination exists. In fact, this method had 83% sensitivity and 85% NPV in diagnosing the condition in the abovementioned study by Riew et al. The vertical atlantoaxial index also describes the relationship between the first two cervical vertebrae and was actually developed with the understanding that a subgroup of patients with basilar invagination may, indeed, have a problem of the atlantoaxial joints rather than atlanto-occipital ones [26]. Their subgroup of patients was treated with a posterior atlantoaxial joint release, distraction, graft, or cage placement and fixation and thus avoiding transoral surgery. In anteroposterior view, the atlantooccipital joint axis angle formed by lines parallel to those joints is useful in detecting occipital condyle hypoplasia, with normal values ranging 124°–127° and increasing to even over 180° with the condition [45]. The majority of the above-mentioned parameters apply to non-traumatic situations and mostly to rheumatoid patients with CVJ involvement. The
3 Special Radiology
pathophysiology of the process results in cranial settling/basilar invagination. However, in the setting of trauma, highly sensitive and specific criteria are essential to detect atlanto-occipital and atlantoaxial dislocations and instabilities that are commonly missed. These injuries result in distraction, translation, or rotation between the individual components of the CVJ, making the above criteria obsolete for their use in most traumatic scenarios. However, multiple indices and ratios have been described to alert physicians to usually subtle and often missed signs of injury at the CVJ. Starting with survivors of atlanto-occipital dissociations, the most commonly used craniometric parameters include Harris’ measurements, Powers ratio, Lee’s lines, and occipital condyle displacement. Harris et al. derived the so called “Rule of Twelve” in a normal adult spine (Fig. 3.7). He used the basion-dental interval (BDI) previously described by Wholey et al. [57] and basion-axial (BAI) interval (distance between basion and posterior C2 tangent) to describe normal values in adults and children [17]. It was found, that in adults, the CVJ is intact if BDI and BAI are less than 12 mm. The BDI cannot be applied to children in whom the dens ossification has not been completed. Harris et al. then applied those rules retrospectively to analyze plain radiographs of 37 patients previously diagnosed with AOD on the basis of Lee X-lines, Powers ratio, and BDI/BAI [18]. In all 23 patients with frank AOD, the BDI and BAI were both greater than 12 mm. Neither Powers ratio nor Lee X-lines could be applied to 46% of patients due to anatomical variants. In the remaining 20 patients, Powers ratio detected the correct type of atlantooccipital subluxation in only 60% and Lee X-lines in only 20% of cases. The types of atlanto-occipital subluxations identified were purely anterior, purely distracted, combined anterior and distracted, and purely posterior. The in specificity inferior Powers ratio is calculated as a distance between basion and posterior C1 arch divided by the distance between anterior C1 arch and opisthion [35]. It is considered normal when the value is less than 1 (Fig. 3.7). However, it will remain normal in purely vertical distraction and posterior types of AOD, thus resulting in delay in diagnosis. Lee X-lines [27] were applied to 12 cases of AOD as well as 100 normal patients and compared with Powers ratio, Wholey’s BDI, the Dublin method, and direct atlanto-occipital joint measurement. The Lee X-line method was the most accurate on plain radiograph assessment and correct in 75% of cases; the other methods were accurate
29
3.1 Radiographic Data Analysis Fig. 3.7 Different measurements of CVJ and UCS alignment
BAI – basion-posterior axial line interval BDI – basion-dental interval
Basion
B
Anterior arch. of C1
A
ADI – anterior atlanto-dental interval
O C
Opisthion
Posterior arch. of C1
PADI – posterior atlanto-dental interval
in 50% or less. Ultimately, all cases were confirmed by 2 mm cut CT with reconstructions. The X-line method is considered abnormal if the basion-axis spinolaminar junction line does not intersect C2 and if the opisthionaxis line does not cross C1. According to Wholey et al., the direct measurement of the width of the atlantooccipital joints (condyle-C1 interval – CCI, atlantooccipital interval – AOI) should be less than 2 mm in adults and 5 mm in children [57].
3.1.3 Atlanto-Axial Parameters The atlanto-axial relationship can be described by means of an anterior atlantodental interval (AADI, predental space) on plain radiographs [20]. Closely related is the posterior atlantodental interval (PADI) (Fig. 3.7). Both have been defined validated on dynamic plain films of patients with rheumatoid arthritis, developmental anomalies, and/or chronic posttraumatic instabilities but traumatic atlantoaxial instability is relatively uncommon and thus no such validation exists in the setting of acute trauma [2]. The AADI should be less than 3 mm in adults and less than 5 mm in children on plain dynamic films. Posterior ADI of 14 mm or less in combination with abnormal AADI warrants an MRI evaluation, even in the absence of neurological signs and symptoms. The craniocervical relationships were thus restudied in the era of multi-slice CT and the previously mentioned
plain radiograph parameters challenged. Rojas et al. studied 200 patients with a multidetector row CT (MDCT) and re-examined Harris’ measurements, Powers ratio, as well as atlantodental and atlanto-occipital intervals [42]. They found significant variances from the previously accepted normal values. Firstly, they found no differences when comparing men and women. Secondly, the Rule of Twelve described above was valid but on CT those values were much tighter for BDI (<8.5 mm) but unreliable for BAI. Powers ratio was less than 0.9 when measured on MDCT, thus not significantly different. Pang et al. found the normal CCI to be less than 2 mm in 89 children [34] and recommended surgical treatment in patients with greater than 4 mm widening of CCI. The differences in craniometric values on CT and plain radiographs were probably a result of magnification, landmark visualization difficulties, and patient positioning. Similarly, when craniometric parameters for basilar invagination were validated on MRI, there were significant differences when compared to plain radiographic criteria [48]. Historically, one of the most commonly used indicators of atlantoaxial instability secondary to transverse ligament (TAL) injury was the rule of Spence [46], which states that if the combined overhang of the C1 lateral masses over C2 adds up to 7 mm or more, the TAL is likely disrupted (Fig. 2, Chap. 10). One has to be aware of the fact that the original study was done on cadaveric specimens and therefore, the number is actually greater than 8.1 mm when assessed on plain films [19]. Spence’s actual number of 6.9 mm can be resurrected in the era
30
of CT with direct measurement of the displacement on coronal reconstructions, although a direct assessment of TAL integrity can always be confirmed on MRI [9].
3.2 Dynamic Imaging Several mobile CVJ and UCS abnormalities require testing under loading, i.e., in dynamic conditions of flexion and extension, or rotation. These include, for example, reducible cranial settling, AA instability, os odontoideum, or fracture malunions. Just as for static films, several radiographic indices have been developed to describe dynamic relationships of structures of the CVJ. Abe et al. proposed an atlantoaxial instability index, defined as a change of rate of space available for the spinal cord between flexion and extension [1]. They recommended surgical intervention for all patients with neurological deficit, or instability index greater than 20% or maximum space for cord of less than 14 mm. This is useful for sagittal instability but, for example, in patients with os odontoideum, the instability is multidirectional. Therefore, Watanabe attempted to define a sagittal plane rotation angle as well as the above-mentioned indices in 37 patients with AAI on dynamic tomograms and concluded that not only the instability index of more than 40% but also rotation angle of more than 20° is predictive of cord signs and
3 Special Radiology
symptoms [56]. The extent of instability as measure by any dynamic means in an awake patient can be an underestimate of that seen during anesthesia. The previously mentioned vertical atlantoaxial instability index (VAAII) as described by Kulkarni and Goel is a good indicator of vertical instability. Goel et al. successfully used the VAAII to predict the feasibility of a pure vertical instability reduction and fixation without transoral decompression in cases of vertically mobile instability [14]. Although the majority of atlantoaxial pathologies mentioned so far affect the complex in vertical or anteroposterior or coronal planes, the primary movement within the AA complex is that of rotation. Atlantoaxial rotatory fixation (AARF) represents a pathological phenomenon that gained a standardized definition based on dynamic imaging of the CVJ only in recent years. Pang et al. were exemplary in defining the norm of atlantoaxial rotation in normal subjects using dynamic CT scans in rotation [34]. They defined the dynamic relationship of C1 on C2 throughout the turn and found very little variance from the mean. When C1 rotates on C2, it crosses it at 0°, moves alone until 23° then moves faster than C2 up to 65° and then they move in unison beyond that angle with a maximal separation angle of 43°. They used a three-position CT to generate a physiological motion curve (Fig. 3.8) according to which they classified AARF into three subtypes based on a diagnostic paradigm [33]. Type I AARF represented a fixed deformity whereas
Fig. 3.8 Atlantoaxial rotatory fixation (AARF) is defined on the basis of a normal three position CT evaluation that generates a physiological curve of the atlantoaxial relationship change in rotation
31
3.3 Vascular Imaging
Fig. 3.9 Dynamic MRI. Neural compression that would otherwise not be obvious can be visualized on MRI in flexion and extension (a–d)
Type III was the least severe type with C1 crossing C2 axis with rotation to contralateral side. More recently, MRI evaluation of the CVJ was done in flexion and extension to further visualize soft tissue compression or changes in instabilities of the region. Epstein et al. was the first to use the term “dynamic” MRI [12] when she documented cord compression in flexion/extension MRI although the dynamic plain films failed to show osseous instability (Fig. 3.9). Gupta et al. studied 25 patients with suspected CVJ abnormalities due to various reasons with MRI and CT performed in neutral, flexion, and extension positions. They found that dynamic MRI detected every cord compression under loading that was not apparent in neutral position [15]. Other authors have also utilized dynamic MRI to assess patients with RA and suspected atlantoaxial instability [22] and correlated it to
findings on plain radiographs. Krodel et al. even argued that dynamic MRI plays a role in surgical planning when treating patients with rheumatoid-related upper cervical instabilities [25]. Three out of his 11 patients did not demonstrate reduction of cord compression on dynamic MRI and thus required removal of the synovial proliferative tissue around the dens.
3.3 Vascular Imaging Conventional cerebral angiography, CTA, and MRA have been used to assess vasculature at the CVJ. CTA and MRA, in particular, have revolutionized preoperative evaluation of the vascular tree at the CVJ and obviated the need for invasive angiography (Fig. 3.10). With
Fig. 3.10 Vascular evaluation of CVJ vessels. (a) CTA is particularly useful in delineating the relationship between VA and bone. (b) MRA
32
3 Special Radiology
respect to surgical reconstruction techniques, one is particularly interested in anatomical variants of the vertebral arteries and their relationship to bony anatomy. The details of VA anatomy, its variants and relationships are discussed in detail in Chap. 1. Nonetheless, we would like to mention dynamic angiography that is performed in rare cases of dynamic vertebral artery compression at the CVJ due to bony spurs, AAI or cranial settling. Janeway et al. described positional VA
occlusion with head turning in a patient with basilar impression diagnosed on dynamic angiography already in 1966 [21]. Our case (Fig. 3.11) demonstrates an example of V3 segment injury due to bone spur compression of the VA in rotation in a 16-year-old boy with recurrent posterior circulation strokes. Dynamic angiogram demonstrated vessel occlusion with head rotation. He was successfully treated by C1 partial laminectomy. Similar cases are described in the literature such as that
Fig. 3.11 Sixteen year old boy with recurrent posterior fossa strokes as seen on MRI (a). Complete VA occlusion on left head turn (b). CTA demonstrating posterior C1 arch bone spur
(c). Dynamic intraoperative angiogram with complete release of compression in rotation (d) (courtesy of T. Abruzzo MD, Mayfield Clinic, Cincinnati)
33
3.4 Our Preference
of a 34-year-old man with recurrent embolic strokes and vertebrobasilar insufficiency secondary to dynamic VA compression during head rotation [49]. He was also successfully treated by osseous decompression. Dynamic angiogram is a rare investigation required for only specific problems at the CVJ; however, it may be essential to diagnosis and management in those rare cases. Dumas et al. further assessed the use of dynamic MRA and CTA to evaluate VA compression during head rotation in healthy volunteers as well as an actual symptomatic patient [11]. However, these non-invasive, dynamic vascular imaging techniques have not been validated further.
in clinical situations. A combination of multiple parameters relevant to the clinical scenario should always be applied which can lead to further, more detailed evaluation if abnormal. In non-traumatic cases with disease processes that result in cranial settling, basilar impression/invagination, or platybasia, we find the following parameters the most useful: Wackenheim basal clival line, cervicomedullary and basal angles, McRae and Chamberlain lines, and the BDI. We select a combination of multiple parameters in questionable cases and sometimes we are forced to use a particular parameter due to limited visualization of structures at the CVJ. For all of them, mid-sagittal CT reconstructions have certainly made the process significantly easier.
3.4 Our Preference 3.4.2 Traumatic Cases Radiographic evaluation of disorders of CVJ is not complex but requires knowledge of patient’s clinical details to guide an appropriate selection of modalities for a particular clinical scenario. Rather than using all imaging modalities for everyone, we like to divide the patients in traumatic, degenerative/inflammatory, and neoplastic scenarios.
3.4.1 Developmental/Degenerative/ Inflammatory The majority of rheumatoid patients belong to this group. Most of them are referred based on clinical history of the disease with associated neck pain and/or neurological symptoms and have had plain radiographs obtained prior to the referral. We proceed with obtaining standard neutral, non-contrast MRI images, particularly in patients with neurological compromise. If bony relationships remain questionable on plain radiographs, we obtain a thin cut CT with sagittal, coronal, and threedimensional images. This is mandated prior to any surgical intervention at the CVJ. These images are also supplemented by dynamic flexion-extension lateral plain radiographs. The CT images as well as plain radiographs allow for direct electronic measurement of the earlier mentioned craniometric parameters for disease severity assessment as well as surgical planning. It is clear that no single parameter should be used in isolation for evaluation of the alignment of CVJ structures due to individual anatomical variations and differences
For patients with traumatic situations, basilar impression parameters are not very useful as our biggest concerns are: (1) distraction injuries of the occipito-cervical junction, (2) atlantoaxial instability secondary to bony or ligamentous injuries, (3) coronal alignment in injuries of atlas, and (4) sagittal alignment of axis/dens. At our institution, all victims of traumatic injuries are transported with spinal precautions and with a hard collar, until radiographically and clinically cleared. In majority of emergently admitted trauma victims with suspicion of spinal injury (particularly if polytraumatized), we perform directly helical CT with appropriate reconstructions. Those referred from other hospitals or patients with isolated UCS trauma without neurological deficit are standardly assessed by plain radiography first. An MRI evaluation is often indicated in the acute setting unless partial spinal cord injury exists or an injury remains questionable based on mechanism of injury, clinical syndrome, and CT evaluation (Fig. 3.12).
3.4.3 Neoplastic Conditions In patients with suspected neoplastic disease of the CVJ, a contrast enhanced MRI is added to the above modalities. As tumors (metastatic or primary) commonly result in bony erosion and instability, relevant indices described above still apply and thus require a careful evaluation of bony structures by CT, stability by dynamic films, and neural compression by MRI. Occasionally, with
34
3 Special Radiology
Fig. 3.12 MRI depicting posttraumatic extra medullary intraspinal hematomas. (a, b) clinically silent posttraumatic subdural hematoma of CVJ. (c, d) initially clinically silent but
later decompensated epidural midcervical posttraumatic hematoma in another patient
invasive tumors, vascular invasion/occlusion needs to be evaluated by CTA/MRA or DSA. In conclusion, in the modern era of continuous improvement of imaging modalities, many craniometric parameters have become obsolete. However, their knowledge is important for the CVJ surgeon as they define “normal” relationships of the complex joints of the CVJ and UCS.
References 1. Abe, H., Tsuru, M., Mitsumori, K.: Atlanto-axial dislocation–instability index and indications for surgery (author’s transl). No Shinkei Geka 4, 57–72 (1976) 2. Bono, C.M., Vaccaro, A.R., Fehlings, M., et al.: Measurement techniques for upper cervical spine injuries: consensus statement of the Spine Trauma Study Group. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 32, 593–600 (2007)
References 3. Boudin, G., Fischgold, H., Pepin, B., et al.: Syringomyelitic syndrome and associated complex malformations, especially of the atlanto-occipital joint and of the cervical vertebrae. Rev Neurol (Paris) 87, 347–352 (1952) 4. Brenner, D., Elliston, C., Hall, E., et al.: Estimated risks of radiation-induced fatal cancer from pediatric CT. AJR Am J Roentgenol 176, 289–296 (2001) 5. Bundschuh, C., Modic, M.T., Kearney, F., et al.: Rheumatoid arthritis of the cervical spine: surface-coil MR imaging. AJR Am J Roentgenol 151, 181–187 (1988) 6. Chamberlain, W.E.: Basilar impression (platybasia): A bizarre developmental anomaly of the occipital bone and upper cervical spine with striking and misleading neurologic manifestations. Yale J Biol Med 11, 487–496 (1939) 7. Clark, C.R., Goetz, D.D., Menezes, A.H.: Arthrodesis of the cervical spine in rheumatoid arthritis. J Bone Joint Surg Am 71, 381–392 (1989) 8. Deliganis, A.V., Mann, F.A., Grady, M.S.: Rapid diagnosis and treatment of a traumatic atlantooccipital dissociation. AJR Am J Roentgenol 171, 986 (1998) 9. Dickman, C.A., Greene, K.A., Sonntag, V.K.: Injuries involving the transverse atlantal ligament: classification and treatment guidelines based upon experience with 39 injuries. Neurosurgery 38, 44–50 (1996) 10. Dolan, K.D.: Cervicobasilar relationships. Radiol Clin North Am 15, 155–166 (1977) 11. Dumas, J.L., Salama, J., Dreyfus, P., et al.: Magnetic resonance angiographic analysis of atlanto-axial rotation: anatomic bases of compression of the vertebral arteries. Surg Radiol Anat 18, 303–313 (1996) 12. Epstein, N.E., Hyman, R.A., Epstein, J.A., et al.: “Dynamic” MRI scanning of the cervical spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13, 937–938 (1988) 13. Gilbert, J.W., Wheeler, G.R., Lingreen, R.A., et al.: Open stand-up MRI: a new instrument for positional neuroimaging. J Spinal Disord Tech 19, 151–154 (2006) 14. Goel, A., Shah, A., Rajan, S.: Vertical mobile and reducible atlantoaxial dislocation. Clinical article. J Neurosurg Spine 11, 9–14 (2009) 15. Gupta, V., Khandelwal, N., Mathuria, S.N., et al.: Dynamic magnetic resonance imaging evaluation of CVJ abnormalities. J Comput Assist Tomogr 31, 354–359 (2007) 16. Guyot, L., Richard, O., Adalian, P., et al.: An anthropometric study of relationships between the clival angle and craniofacial measurements in adult human skulls. Surg Radiol Anat 28, 559–563 (2006) 17. Harris Jr., J.H., Carson, G.C., Wagner, L.K.: Radiologic diagnosis of traumatic occipitovertebral dissociation: 1. Normal occipitovertebral relationships on lateral radiographs of supine subjects. AJR Am J Roentgenol 162, 881–886 (1994) 18. Harris Jr., J.H., Carson, G.C., Wagner, L.K., et al.: Radiologic diagnosis of traumatic occipitovertebral dissociation: 2. Comparison of three methods of detecting occipitovertebral relationships on lateral radiographs of supine subjects. AJR Am J Roentgenol 162, 887–892 (1994) 19. Heller, J.G., Viroslav, S., Hudson, T.: Jefferson fractures: the role of magnification artifact in assessing transverse ligament integrity. J Spinal Disord 6, 392–396 (1993) 20. Hinck, V.C., Hopkins, C.E.: Measurement of the atlantodental interval in the adult. Am J Roentgenol Radium Ther Nucl Med 84, 945–951 (1960)
35 21. Janeway, R., Toole, J.F., Leinbach, L.B., et al.: Vertebral artery obstruction with basilar impression. An intermittent phenomenon related to head turning. Arch Neurol 15, 211– 214 (1966) 22. Karhu, J.O., Parkkola, R.K., Koskinen, S.K.: Evaluation of flexion/extension of the upper cervical spine in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: an MRI study with a dedicated positioning device compared to conventional radiographs. Acta Radiol 46, 55–66 (2005) 23. Kevles, B.: Body imaging. How doctors learned to peer beneath our skin to see what might be wrong without using surgery. Newsweek 130, 74–76 (1997) 24. Klaus, E.: Roentgen diagnosis of platybasia & basilar impression; additional experience with a new method of examination. Fortschr Geb Rontgenstr Nuklearmed 86, 460– 469 (1957) 25. Krodel, A., Refior, H.J., Westermann, S.: The importance of functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the planning of stabilizing operations on the cervical spine in rheumatoid patients. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 109, 30–33 (1990) 26. Kulkarni, A.G., Goel, A.H.: Vertical atlantoaxial index: a new craniovertebral radiographic index. J Spinal Disord Tech 21, 4–10 (2008) 27. Lee, C., Woodring, J.H., Goldstein, S.J., et al.: Evaluation of traumatic atlantooccipital dislocations. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 8, 19–26 (1987) 28. McGregor, M.: The significance of certain measurements of the skull in the diagnosis of basilar impression. Br J Radiol 21, 171–181 (1948) 29. McRae, D.L., Barnum, A.S.: Occipitalization of the atlas. AJR Am J Roentgenol 70, 23 (1953) 30. Metzger, J., Fischgold, H., Appel, L.: Special radiographical examinations in fractures of the base of the skull. Ann Med Leg Criminol Police Sci Toxicol 42, 5–12 (1962) 31. Monu, J., Bohrer, S.P., Howard, G.: Some upper cervical spine norms. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 515–519 (1987) 32. Oliva, L.: Alessandro Vallebona (1899–1987). Radiol Med 76, 127129 (1988) 33. Pang, D.: Atlantoaxial rotatory fixation. Neurosurgery 66, A161–A183 (2010) 34. Pang, D., Nemzek, W.R., Zovickian, J.: Atlanto-occipital dislocation: part 1 – normal occipital condyle-C1 interval in 89 children. Neurosurgery 61, 514–521 (2007). discussion 521 35. Powers, B., Miller, M.D., Kramer, R.S., et al.: Traumatic anterior atlanto-occipital dislocation. Neurosurgery 4, 12–17 (1979) 36. Raju, T.N.: The Nobel chronicles. 1979: Allan MacLeod Cormack (b 1924); and Sir Godfrey Newbold Hounsfield (b 1919). Lancet 354, 1653 (1999) 37. Ranawat, C.S., O’Leary, P., Pellicci, P., et al.: Cervical spine fusion in rheumatoid arthritis. J Bone Joint Surg Am 61, 1003–1010 (1979) 38. Redlund-Johnell, I., Pettersson, H.: Radiographic measurements of the cranio-vertebral region. Designed for evaluation of abnormalities in rheumatoid arthritis. Acta Radiol Diagn (Stockh) 25, 23–28 (1984) 39. Reijnierse, M., Bloem, J.L., Dijkmans, B.A., et al.: The cervical spine in rheumatoid arthritis: relationship between neurologic signs and morphology of MR imaging and radiographs. Skeletal Radiol 25, 113–118 (1996)
36 40. Riederer, S.J.: MR imaging: its development and the recent Nobel Prize. Radiology 231, 628–631 (2004) 41. Riew, K.D., Hilibrand, A.S., Palumbo, M.A., et al.: Diagnosing basilar invagination in the rheumatoid patient. The reliability of radiographic criteria. J Bone Joint Surg Am 83-A, 194–200 (2001) 42. Rojas, C.A., Bertozzi, J.C., Martinez, C.R., et al.: Reassessment of the craniocervical junction: normal values on CT. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 28, 1819–1823 (2007) 43. Sassard, R., O’Leary, J.P.: Egas Moniz: pioneer of cerebral angiography. Am Surg 64, 1116–1117 (1998) 44. Scher, A., Vambeck, V.: An approach to the radiological examination of the cervico-dorsal junction following injury. Clin Radiol 28, 243–246 (1977) 45. Smoker, W.R.: CVJ: normal anatomy, craniometry, and congenital anomalies. Radiographics 14, 255–277 (1994) 46. Spence Jr., K.F., Decker, S., Sell, K.W.: Bursting atlantal fracture associated with rupture of the transverse ligament. J Bone Joint Surg Am 52, 543–549 (1970) 47. Suzuki, F., Fukami, T., Tsuji, A., et al.: Discrepancies of MRI findings between recumbent and upright positions in atlantoaxial lesion. Report of two cases. Eur Spine J 17(Suppl 2), S304–S307 (2008) 48. Tassanawipas, A., Mokkhavesa, S., Chatchavong, S., et al.: Magnetic resonance imaging study of the craniocervical junction. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong) 13, 228–231 (2005) 49. Tominaga, T., Takahashi, T., Shimizu, H., et al.: Rotational vertebral artery occlusion from occipital bone anomaly: a rare cause of embolic stroke. Case report. J Neurosurg 97, 1456–1459 (2002)
3 Special Radiology 50. van Gilder, J.C., Menezes, A.H., Dolan, K.A.: Radiology of the CVJ and its abnormalities, pp. 29–68. Futura Mount Kisco, New York (1987) 51. Vates, G.E., Wang, K.C., Bonovich, D., et al.: Bow hunter stroke caused by cervical disc herniation. Case report. J Neurosurg 96, 90–93 (2002) 52. Wackenheim, A.: Radiologic diagnosis of congenital forms, intermittent forms and progressive forms of stenosis of the spinal canal at the level of the atlas. Acta Radiol Diagn (Stockh) 9, 759–768 (1969) 53. Wang, C., Wang, S.: Letter to the Editor concerning “The single transoral approach for Os odontoideum with irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation” by Wang X, Fan CY, Liu ZH, Eur Spine J. 2009 Jul 14. Eur Spine J 19, 502–504 (2009). author reply 505–507 54. Wang, C., Yan, M., Zhou, H.T., et al.: Open reduction of irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation by transoral anterior atlantoaxial release and posterior internal fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, E306–313 (2006) 55. Watanabe, I.S., Madeira, M.C., Watanabe, I.S., et al.: The clivus-sphenoidale angle in children (postnatal flexion of the cranial base). Rev Bras Pesqui Med Biol 10, 325–329 (1977) 56. Watanabe, M., Toyama, Y., Fujimura, Y.: Atlantoaxial instability in os odontoideum with myelopathy. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 1435–1439 (1996) 57. Wholey, M.H., Bruwer, A.J., Baker Jr., H.L.: The lateral roentgenogram of the neck; with comments on the atlantoodontoid-basion relationship. Radiology 71, 350–356 (1958)
Section Principles of Reconstruction Techniques
II
4
surgical approaches P. Suchomel, J. Hradil, and R. Fricˇ
In the majority of procedures in CVJ, the surgical field should lie slightly higher or at the level of right cardiac atrium. The operating table should allow position changes in up and down directions in case of uncontrollable bleeding or, conversely, to prevent possible venous air embolism. CVJ region, intentionally set higher than heart, represents predisposition to venous air embolism, and adequate precautions such as central venous line and transesophageal echocardiography monitoring should be considered. On the contrary, the lower position of the surgical field may predispose to increased venous bleeding from epidural venous plexuses and veins surrounding C2-roots. Majority of surgical procedures in UCS have to be performed under guidance with fluoroscopy. X-ray visibility of target bony structures must not be compromised by operating table or any other hardware. Surgical position should not interfere with anesthesiological equipment, especially with reinforced tubes securing airways. To retain preoperative stability but also to reduce possible UCS deformation, the head is often fixated in a Mayfield three-point clamp (Fig. 4.1). When performing a rigid fixation of the head, appropriate position of patient’s body has to be considered, particularly in cases where the body can counteract by its weight. When a controlled axial skeletal traction is needed, it is better to use a halo ring or other freely adaptable skull fixation clamp than the table-fixed Mayfield clamp. Last but not the least, the surgical position should allow the surgeon
P. Suchomel () and J. Hradil Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St. 10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic R. Fricˇ Department of Neurosurgery, Rikshospitalet, Oslo University Hospital, Sognsvannsveien 20, 0027 Oslo, Norway
Fig. 4.1 Preparing of the patient for posterior UCS surgery. Notice the attached IOM electrodes
to operate in an ergonomic and physically comfortable position. The overall setting of the operation theater should enable the use of extensive surgical armamentarium, surgical microscope, and other devices that are commonly used in contemporary surgical techniques (C-arm, navigation workstation, electrophysiological monitoring etc.). Many surgical approaches to CVJ and UCS area have been used and myriad access variants used mostly by neurosurgeons to reach tumors, vascular anomalies, and other CVJ pathologies have been reported. Most of those intended to decompress the neural structures are however not suitable for reconstruction of the spine and CVJ. In the following text only those approaches suitable for spinal procedures will be described in detail.
4.1 Posterior Midline Approach This is the most traditional, the simplest, and truly the most often used approach to the region of UCS and CVJ. It is suitable for simple decompression of the
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_4, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
39
40
Fig. 4.2 Artistic drawing of structures visible from posterior midline approach
neural structures (in trauma, Chiari malformation, etc.) and is also commonly used to access the spinal cord and structures in posterior fossa. The posterior midline approach (Fig. 4.2) is, in principle, the easiest and safest approach for different techniques of posterior fixation (see Chap. 6) and therefore, it is most frequently used for UCS reconstruction and/or stabilization.
4.1.1 Surgical Technique Patient positioning largely depends on the type of the surgery. The specific types of surgery require specific positions. To limit the risk of venous bleeding, so called “landing Concorde” setting with the lowered position of the body and lower limbs flexed in knees can be of advantage. The “braking horse” position with straight neck and flexed UCS performed under lateral fluoroscopy enables an adjustment of the correct angle for C1-2 transarticular screw fixation. Nevertheless, no general rules can be given and surgeon’s individual preference and experience often plays the most important role. The posterior midline incision typically extends from the inion to the spinous process of C3. The surgeon advances along the nuchal ligament, preferably using a monopolar electrocautery. The dissection of the upper portion of the wound does not vary from that in cranial procedures, detaching nuchal insertions to the posterior skull base to achieve a proper exposure of the occipital squama. The external occipital protuberance is identified. SNL and INL muscle attachments are dissected and retracted laterally using bended self-retaining (“posterior fossa”) retractors. Continuing along the midline
4 surgical approaches
caudally, the spinous process of C2 is, usually, clearly palpable. Subperiostal exposure of lateral walls of C2 lamina allows the introduction of the second angled retractor caudally, e.g., opposite to the first one. The posterior atlantal tubercle is the most important anatomical landmark. Its muscle attachments are sharply cut off and subperiostal dissection continues laterally, first along the inferior border of C1 lamina. This is a very important step to avoid potential injury to VA in C1 posterior groove, especially if bone ponticuli are present as described in Chaps. 1 and 6. The extent of the exposure and dissection of muscular attachments should be limited only to expose the desired target structure. Muscle connections to the spinous process of the C2 are biomechanically important. However, for most open procedures and surgical techniques in this area, the dissection of muscular detachments is unavoidable.
4.2 Posterior Paramedian Approach This route is used mostly in minimally invasive procedures in the subaxial spine. There are not many indications for this approach in the region of the UCS. However, as minimally invasive techniques become more common, lateral paramedian incisions can be used for screw introduction via tubular retractors, particularly in case of percutaneous surgical techniques (Figs. 7.6 and 7.7; Chap. 7).
4.3 Lateral Approaches There are several versions and numerous modifications of lateral and posterolateral approaches such as farlateral or extreme-lateral. In neurosurgery, far-lateral approach stands for a low suboccipital approach that extends up to the occipital condyle and atlas, but it does not include removal of these structures [32]. Its caudal extensions merge with procedures designed specifically for the UCS.
4.3.1 Posterolateral Approaches These approaches are primarily designed for decompressive procedures and tumor resections. The surgery
4.3 Lateral Approaches
should not destabilize the UCS. The anatomy is complex and the course of the VA represents a major obstacle. Different surgical techniques have been described in detail, most of them introduced by neurosurgeons [3, 9, 22, 23, 54, 61, 69]. However, once the surgical dissection affects the natural stability of the spine, the reconstruction may be troublesome. Resection of 50% of occipital condyle may increase the flexion/extension movement by 153%, lateral bending by 41%, and rotation by 28% [73]. All posterolateral reconstruction techniques involve unilateral occipitocervical fixation, which does not provide sufficient primary stability. On the other hand, a substantially better functional outcome may be achieved when the C0-C1 joints are adequately preserved [66]. Because of the issues mentioned above, we do not use posterolateral approach as a primary route to reconstruct the UCS.
4.3.2 Lateral Approach for C1-C2 Transarticular Fixation There are several early notes describing lateral approach to the region of UCS. Henry (1957) used a sternomastoid eversion in order to reach important structures of the UCS [31]. Whitesides (1966) described an approach designed for the UCS fusion [76]. Barbour (1973) gave description of a technique of transarticular C1-C2 fixation and reported it being used since 1956. As he noted, it is necessary to perform this approach bilaterally, because unilateral fixation is not sufficient [8]. DuToit and Blignaut employed Barbour’s technique in 1973 [20] and found it quite difficult to place the screws accurately. Several modifications were therefore suggested [20, 62].
4.3.2.1 Surgical Technique The patient is positioned supine. For the purpose of the approach, the head is turned away; however, it must be realigned into the neutral position before fixation. Original Barbour’s technique was very straightforward. The incision was an oblique line starting at the anterior border of the mastoid process, passing down over the palpable transverse process of C1 and running a little further behind the angle of the mandible [8]. Anterior margin of the insertion of sternocleidomastoid muscle was identified. Advancing medially,
41
the surgeon cleared fascial cover and exposed the transverse process of atlas. The accessory nerve, which passes in a posteroinferior direction, was displaced, the transverse process was partially resected, and paravertebral muscles cleared to expose the anterior aspect of the C1/C2 joint. The head was then realigned to the neutral position before C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation was performed. The author was concerned about too posterior dissection as it could easily lead to injury of the VA or surrounding venous plexuses. After detailed cadaver studies, Du Toit suggested several improvements. Transverse incision over the base of the mastoid with extension downward and curving anteriorly along a neck crease was preferred for better cosmetic result. Ear lobe was retracted anteriorly and detachment of the sternocleidomastoid muscle from its cranial insertion was suggested for better exposure. Roy-Camille [58] tried to avoid the muscle detachment and inserted screws from a retro-SCM approach. The authors admitted, nevertheless, frequent collisions of the drill and the trajectory of the screws with the mastoid process. In the original Du Toit’s setting, the transverse process of the C1 was exposed by advancement just in front of the anterior margin of the sternocleidomastoid muscle. Care should be taken to avoid injury to the greater auricular nerve and external jugular vein during the exposure of the anterior border of the sternocleidomastoid muscle. These structures are crossing obliquely in upward and forward directions. The accessory nerve is located 2–3 fingerbreadths below the tip of the mastoid, running in posteroinferior direction and it is hardly ever encountered during the dissection. Posterior belly of the digastric muscle is retracted anterosuperiorly in order to fully expose the tip of the transverse process of the atlas. The occipital artery and vein pass directly across the tip of the transverse process and should be mobilized and retracted. Prevertebral fascia covering the process is incised and subperiostally dissected along the anterior border of the transverse process up to the lateral mass of the atlas. Finally, the antero-lateral aspect of the lateral mass is identified and cleared for insertion of the screws. The head is realigned to the neutral position; a proper adjustment of the joint has to be achieved and secured by temporal fixation with a Kirschner wire passing through the C1/C2 joint. Drilling proceeds with an angle of 25° below the horizontal plane and 10° behind the coronal plane
42
Fig. 4.3 Schematic picture of C1-2 transarticular screw introduced from lateral approach
(Fig. 4.3). The authors used a special guiding device to achieve proper angles and to protect surrounding structures while drilling. Twenty degrees in posterior direction was considered as the maximum safe angle to avoid injury to the content of spinal canal. Navicular bone screw was inserted and the joint was curetted and packed with bone chips before final tightening. The same procedure had to be performed contralaterally in order to achieve a solid C1-C2 fixation.
4.3.2.2 Our Preference We do not use the previously described approach for UCS reconstruction because of its anatomical complexity and necessity for bilateral dissection. However, the practical knowledge of the lateral approach can surely be useful in certain indications, such as in case of radical tumor removal.
4.4 High Anterolateral Approach High anterolateral cervical approach is derived from the subaxial access described to reach C3-T1 spine [64]. DeAndrade and McNab [16] developed the cranial extension of standard approach to reach C1-2 area. McAfee et al. suggested transecting the digastric
4 surgical approaches
muscle and resecting the submandibular gland in order to enlarge the previously described access [45]. In order to directly expose the atlantoaxial joints for intraarticular cartilage debridement and to allow the perpendicular transarticular C2 to C1 anterior screw introduction, Vacaro et al. performed extensive rightsided high cervical approach accompanied by additional smaller incision on the left side [71]. Several authors have advocated this approach (either mono or bilateral) for treatment of different pathologies [55, 63]. However, lesions extending over the C1 level are treated rarely [35]. Recently, this approach has been successfully used in endoscopic resection of the odontoid [77]. The anterior aspect of the UCS can also be approached by a route passing behind the carotid artery [31, 75]. As compared to the previously described “prearterial” route, it is less straightforward. Although the connecting arteries and veins can be spared, the medial dislocation of the neurovascular bundle can be difficult and this approach did not gain wide popularity.
4.4.1 Surgical Technique In case of simple decompression of the UCS, the head can be slightly rotated to the contralateral side in order to achieve a better exposure. However, neutral head position should be maintained when subsequent fusion is planned. The skin incision is located either submandibularly or vertically along the sternocleidomastoid muscle (STCM). Platysma is divided along its fibers, the anterior border of STCM is dissected, and the muscle is retracted laterally. Then the anterior surface of the spine can be approached between the neurovascular bundle medially and the pharyngeal wall laterally. The parotid gland containing facial nerve tree is retracted cranially, the digastric muscle is transected, and the facial vein and external carotid artery branches are ligated. Division of descending loop of ansa cervicalis from n. XII. allows cranial dislocation of hypoglossal nerve. Finally, the prevertebral fascia is sharply cut and the longus colli muscle subperiostally is exposed with the help of bipolar electrocautery. Adequate release of the longus colli muscle is necessary for a safe anchorage of wound retractors beneath the muscle. Elevation of pharyngeal wall in a cranial direction enables direct visibility of anterior C1 arch.
43
4.5 Transoral Approach
4.4.2 Our Preference The greatest advantage of high anterolateral cervical approach is its anatomical similarity to the anterior approach to subaxial cervical spine, which most of the spine surgeons are very familiar with, performing it on a daily basis. Furthermore, no potentially infected cavity is opened during this approach and the use of metal implants is therefore safe. Difficulty can be encountered in case of low position of the mandible or immobile degenerative spine. Postoperative swallowing difficulties are frequent, though most often temporary. At our institution, the high anterolateral approach is most frequently used in cases of UCS injury. The graft and anterior plate is typically used in dislocated hangman’s fracture to fixate C2/3 segment (Figs. 12.14 and 12.18, Chap. 12). When performing the odontoid screw fixation, we do not need a large exposure and oblique approach starting at the C4/5 level suits well. Nearly all pathologies of C2 vertebra can be treated by this retropharyngeal approach, including palliative resection of tumors, evacuation of inflammatory tissue, and/ or C1-2 or even C0-1-2 transarticular fixation in case of instability (Figs. 14.2 and 14.3, Chap. 14). Major drawbacks of this approach are the oblique view of the
Fig. 4.4 Artistic drawing depicting the limited oblique visibility of UCS during high anterolateral cervical approach
spine where estimation of the midline may be difficult (Fig. 4.4), impossibility to expose the clival region, and limited radicality in tumor resection. The exposure achieved by this approach is frequently compromised by the mandibular angle.
4.5 Transoral Approach Transoral surgery is defined as a procedure carried out through the oral cavity to gain access to anterior midline structures of CVJ and UCS. Under normal conditions, the surgeon should be able to expose the area from the lower rim of clivus cranially to the level of disk space C2-3 caudally. The simple transoral approach can be extended upwards by transsection of the maxilla or downwards by splitting the mandible. Currently, minimally invasive and endoscopic techniques are increasingly used.
4.5.1 Transoral-Traspharyngeal Approach The first documented transoral (TO) surgery was performed by Kanavel (1919) who removed a bullet located between anterior arch of atlas and a skull base [39]. Scoville and Sherman (1952) studied the transoral route on cadavers and recommended its clinical use for approach to the rim of FM [60]. Southwick and Robinson successfully performed transoral removal of C2 osteoma and evacuation of an abscess [64]. The first series of patients surgically treated by transoral route was presented by authors from Hong Kong when Fang and Ong (1962) reported six cases of posttraumatic C1-2 dislocations and inflammatory process in CVJ, respectively. Mullan et al. used the transoral route for removal of tumors in CVJ [51]. Sukoff et al. were the first who reported a successful transoral decompression of the spinal canal in a case of myelopathy caused by rheumatoid disease [68]. Numerous papers dealing with this problematic issue were published later [17, 33, 44, 56, 65]; most of them case reports and small series of patients. The main obstacles for a wider acceptance of the transoral approach were: (1) need for special instruments, (2) poor illumination, and (3) depth of the surgical field.
44
The risk of infection was a big concern particularly in cases when the subarachnoid space had to be opened. The initial enthusiasm vanished after reports of high frequency of meningitis and CSF fistulas, the complications with possible catastrophic sequelae. Some other causes of high morbidity/mortality were also reported [36, 38]. Only few surgeons continued to develop the technique of transoral approach, trying to reduce the frequency of complications [13–15, 28, 47, 48]. Crockard published his results from more than 350 transoral procedures in 1993 [13–15] and later shared the lessons learned from his vast experience [14]. He defined the pathologies indicated for transoral approach, described his technique, and emphasized possible risks. Frequency of infectious complications was reduced to less than 3% in his series. Hadley et al. reduced the perioperative mortality to zero [28]. Transoral approach is often necessary in case of irreducible CVJ deformity where anterior pressure to neural structures is present [48]. This situation may be caused by a wide variety of disorders. From the historical perspective, the majority of cases were patients suffering from rheumatoid arthritis where compression caused by rheumatoid pannus was further enhanced by posterior displacement of the odontoid. This indication has become less frequent today because of studies proving that atlantoaxial fusion alone can prevent not only the vertical migration of the odontoid [26] but also reduce the size of pannus (or even lead to its disappearance) [27, 49, 80, 82]. The other frequent indications for transoral route include developmental or acquired deformities where the anterior pressure cannot be reduced by simple reduction; namely, an infection of the odontoid and its surroundings can be a reason for TO intervention in order to evacuate the pus and debride the infected tissue. Also, tumors can be biopsied or resected via transoral route. Transoral decompression can induce significant multidirectional instability of UCS and/or CVJ. This applies particularly for cases with pre-existing partial instability due to the disease itself, complete odontoidectomy, or transsection of the atlantal ligament [18, 19]. Similarly, resection of the anterior arch of atlas may influence the translational and particularly the vertical stability of the CVJ [52]. The atlas loses its anterior tension band. Due to its wedge-shaped profile, the lateral masses separate horizontally under the
4 surgical approaches
vertical load caused purely by head’s weight and/or rotations in the C1-C2 joint. Such mechanism is probably often responsible for development and progression of basilar impression. This condition can occur after simple transoral odontoidectomy without fusion, but even after vertically unstable posterior fixation techniques such as with Lugue type rods fixed with wires [53]. Precautions of atlas settling are twofold: first, as recommended by Spetzler [65], not to resect the anterior arch completely. Second, modern stable posterior fixation constructs (plate/rod and screws) have to be used. There were attempts to stabilize the UCS anteriorly with plates in one session surgery [30, 41]. However, the biomechanical insufficiency of this fixation [40] combined with the risk of hardware infection speak in favor of UCS stabilization from posterior approach. Rare cases of complex surgeries, namely tumor resections, result in total destabilization of CVJ and require a reconstruction using a complex 360° fixation [57, 67]. Current opinion on transoral procedures favors direct extradural decompression which, however, is inappropriate for intradural pathology. Watertight dural closure is still an issue as potential risk of CSF leakage and consequent infection is unacceptably high.
4.5.1.1 Anatomical Background The transoral approach to the midline is generally very safe as there are no important structures interposed (Fig. 4.5). Nevertheless, a detailed knowledge of anatomy is mandatory, particularly when facing anatomical variations during surgery. The pharyngeal mucosa, constrictor muscles, prevertebral fascia, and anterior longitudinal ligament are overlying the target area. The thickness of posterior pharyngeal wall is approximately 4 mm above the level of C1 tubercle and 6 mm above the level of the lateral masses and central part of C2 [1]. Most of the authors use the midline splitting; however, the use of mucosal flap has also been recommended [59]. Midline approach to anterior aspect of UCS is safe. Once leaving the midline as in flap technique, we have to keep in mind that important structures must be protected by using a subperiostal dissection. Cranially, care has to be taken not to injure the XII nerve at its exit from the base of condyle and the jugular foramen. Variant position of carotid artery (deformed by subbasal kinking or coiling) can be very
45
4.5 Transoral Approach
4.5.1.2 Surgical Technique
Fig. 4.5 Artistic drawing of structures visible during simple transoral approach
treacherous (Fig. 6.8, Chap. 6). Anterior tubercle of the atlas is considered to be a crucial point for safe dissection. The attachments of longus colli and longus capitis muscles are less strong than the attachment of anterior longitudinal ligament here. Anterior arch of the atlas is approximately 30 mm long, 15 mm high, and 6 mm thick. Usual working space created by resection of the anterior arch is a little smaller, reaching about 12–15 mm. Synovial joint with fluid filled capsule can sometimes be encountered behind the arch. The odontoid process is usually 20 mm (15–25.4 mm) long and slightly tilted posteriorly. The diameter at its base (“waist”) is approximately 9 mm (7.8–14.1 mm) and the maximal diameter is 11 mm (8.4–14.1 mm). The expected distance of vertebral artery from the midline is approximately 25 mm at the level of C1 and 11–15 mm at the level of C2. Detachment of more or less damaged allar and apical ligaments is necessary to release the odontoid process. The crucial ligament, tectorial membrane, and dura mater are located behind the resected odontoid. While reaching the clival ridge one has to be aware of venous sinus at its margin and possible venous bleeding.
Neurosurgeons tend to perform a decompression of neural structures first, followed by stabilization of the CVJ, while orthopedic surgeons usually prefer to work in reverse order. The extent of adequate exposure of anterior surface of the CVJ and USC very much depends on preoperative imaging and the extent of the pathological process to be treated. As emphasized above, all relevant radiological investigations should be performed before planning the TO procedure. Potential fixation points for the UCS stabilization have to be defined before the surgery also. Simple transoral procedure can be performed only if the patient’s orifice can be opened wide enough to allow insertion of the instruments. Minimal opening must be more than 2–3 cm [14, 48]. This is of special importance in RA patients in whom the motion of mandibular joints is often limited. The oral cavity must be free of infection, including possible dental focuses which have to be sanated. Prophylactic antibiotics should always be administered. Corticosteroids are given in order to prevent soft tissue swelling and potential secondary damage to the spinal cord. The majority of surgeons recommend intraoperative electrophysiological monitoring (IOM). Patients are often intubated awake with the help of fiberoptic guidance. Tracheostomy is performed only in very complex surgeries with expected difficult postoperative course [50]. Some surgeons fixate the head into three-point Mayfield type clamp, others use the “horse shoe” support only. Oral cavity should be disinfected very carefully. Different types of transoral distractors are available to open the mouth and to push down the tongue. The soft palate is often hindering the view. It can either be split in the midline, leaving the uvula on one side [48], or retracted up into epipharynx with the help of a stitch attached to a rubber tube inserted transnasally [14, 28]. The incision site is usually infiltrated with a mixture of local anesthetics and adrenalin. The optimal way of mucosal incision is still being debated. A better visibility of target structures, more lateral exposure, and easier wound closure advocate for use of broadbased mucosa-muscle flap [59]. This so called U-flap may be based either cranially [37] or caudally [43]. On the other hand, U-flaps do not allow vertical extension of the wound and more extensive lateral distraction of the wound is often needed. Wound healing can be
46
troublesome especially if ischemized during the surgery. Currently, most authors recommend a simple midline incision starting at the anterior tubercle of atlas [13–15, 28, 47, 48]. Lateral fluoroscopy is used to determine the target part of the bone and also for final estimation of the extent of resection. Filling the resection cavity with contrast medium can be helpful. Most surgeons sit behind patient’s head while operating. Use of microsurgical techniques is mandatory. The maximal safe lateral extent of subperiostal dissection is considered to be 40 mm at the level of C1 and 30 mm at the level of the base of C2 [1]. The anterior arch of the atlas is usually removed by high-speed drill and borders of the odontoid are identified. The egg-shell type resection of the odontoid is then performed starting either at its tip or its base. Posterior remnants of the odontoid are removed last. If dura has to be opened, watertight suture is supplemented with patch and glue. Postoperative lumbar drainage seems to be mandatory if the risk of CSF leakage and meningitis shall be minimized. Duration of external lumbar drainage recommended varies from only 4 days [28] to 10 days or more, as practiced by most authors [13–15, 47, 48]. Final wound closure is recommended to be performed in two layers, e.g., muscle and mucosa layer, but successful results after closure in just one layer has also been described. Postoperatively, the gastric tube is used for feeding for approximately 10 days. Depending on the type and the extent of surgery, some patients are left intubated for 2–3 days following the surgery. If indicated, posterior stabilization may be performed either in the same session or it may be postponed to a later time, while the patient is wearing a halo vest fixation in the meantime.
4.5.2 Extended Transoral Approaches Under normal anatomical circumstances, the classical transoral approach (with or without splitting of the soft palate) allows the surgeon to reach the lower edge of clivus in a cranial direction and the C2/3 disk space in a caudal direction. The lower third of clivus and part of anterior C3 body surface can sometimes be exposed in patients with large orifice. This variation may certainly be helpful in some patients, but it is wise to be prepared for a situation when the approach has to be extended. When extending the simple transoral route to more complex approaches to UCS and CVJ, several factors
4 surgical approaches
have to be taken into account, including patient’s specific anatomical variations, size, location, and biology of the lesion, whether en bloc or piecemeal resection is intended, and last but not the least, the surgeon’s own preference, most often given by his/her familiarity with the procedure. Anatomical studies documented that cranial or caudal extensions of transoral approach not only increase the surgical field in vertical direction but also make the operative field more superficial [81]. On the other hand, a need for more extensive dissection and potential surgical injury to structures such as dental system possesses an increased risk of complications and/or worse functional outcome.
4.5.2.1 Transoral – Transmaxillar Approach By this technique, the dissection plane is extended cranially, which is necessary for surgical targets located above the level of the hard palate. It is the case in some primary or secondary basilar invaginations/impressions or in platybasia where obtuse-angled clivus anatomically elevates the FM cranially. Tumors with cranial extension, typically chordomas, may require a surgical route providing the approach to intact part of the clivus so that a radical resection can be achieved (Fig. 7.1, Chap. 7, Fig. 20.13, Chap. 20). Transfacial approaches had been used in maxillofacial surgery historically, but only in later years as a route to the upper two-thirds of the clivus [4]. To reach the clivus, Archer et al. [6] modified Le Fort I osteotomy (called as “Cheever’s operation”). Crockard [34] developed a complex technique to get an approach to lower clivus by adding a midline maxillary splitting to Le Fort type maxillotomy and called the procedure an “open-door maxilotomy”. In the largest published series of patients operated on by transoral route (with a remarkable number of developmental deformities), the maxillary extension of the approach was reported to be necessary in approximately 3% of cases [10].
4.5.2.2 Transoral – Transmandibular Approach This approach is only seldom used in adult patients in cases where a lesion, most frequently a tumor, extends from C2 downwards below the level of vertebra C3. Other indication is a limited opening of the mouth (less than 2 cm) in patients where no other approach is
4.5 Transoral Approach
47
possible. The transmandibular route is very old although it was originally developed for treatment of oropharyngeal malignancies; its adaptation for upper cervical spine surgery dates back to the early 1980s [5, 17]. Some of the authors use medial glossotomy [78, 81], some avoid it [12, 24, 25], but this decision is usually based on the character of the lesion and require careful preoperative radiological analysis. There are recent reports of this approach in children with complex developmental anomalies [11].
4.5.2.3 Our Preference We tend to perform decompression first, followed by stabilization procedure. Patients treated by transoral route suffer from lesions causing an anterior compression, which cannot be reduced by traction or posterior fixation alone. The indication becomes emergent in the presence or imminent danger of neurological deficit. In specific cases, transoral biopsy is the simplest way to obtain samples for biopsy (tumors, infection). All available standard radiological workouts are always performed. MRI is mandatory and CTA can give an important information regarding the course of vertebral and carotid arteries in selected cases. Careful inspection of the mouth, extent of orifice opening, and mobility of cervical spine is always examined before transoral surgery. Specific investigations can be performed, such as simulation of reachable areas under fluoroscopy in an awake patient. This is performed with a blunt metal rod after the dorsal part of the tongue and oropharynx is locally anesthetized. Although this procedure can be uncomfortable for the patient, it is the most objective and valuable way of estimating the achievable extension of the approach in a specific patient (Fig. 4.6). Under fluoroscopy, possible asymptomatic hyperextension of UCS can also be tested preoperatively. We find this method safer and more reliable than complicated calculations. IOM is almost always a necessity in UCS surgery; ventral aspect of the medulla lies close to the surgical field and MEPs are therefore more useful than SSEPs. Electrophysiology gives the surgeon vital information and confidence in certain situations. It is also useful to control the effect of anterior spinal decompression and it allows a safe rotation of the patient prior to posterior fusion. Airways are secured via orotracheal tube. Tracheotomy is reserved for complex surgeries or cases with high probability of prolonged respirator-
Fig. 4.6 Preoperative fluoroscopical testing of transorally reachable areas in awake patient
assisted ventilation postoperatively. We use a local surface application of naphazoline in order to achieve vasoconstriction in nasal and oral mucosa, and local cortisone ointment to prevent swelling of lips. The antibiotic prophylaxis according to hospital’s policy is administered before anesthesia. The transoral intubation with reinforced tube is performed with or without fiberoptical guidance. In patients with marked compression and/or neurologic deficit, awake intubation is preferred. Although it is better tolerated in awake patients, we do not use nasotracheal intubation as the tube would cross the surgical field and possibly limit lateral extension of the field, as well as increase the risk of infection. The head is positioned onto “horseshoe” pads for cases of simple decompression. Mayfield clamp is always used when stabilization is planned in the same session (Fig. 4.7). The positioning of the head is very important. Slight extension of the cervical spine may enhance the surgical access to the clival edge. Possible craniocaudal extension of TO approach is tested again using a metal rod and a fluoroscope prior to fixation in the final position. Fluoroscopical visibility of anterior atlantal tubercle and other important anatomical landmarks have to be checked. Simple laryngoscope can be helpful when disinfecting the oral cavity thoroughly. The incisives are protected with silicon rubber half-tube. In patients with irregular dentition, it might be difficult to anchor the distraction frame cranially. Polymethacrylate template of upper jaw made preoperatively can make the maxillary anchorage easier. After the first disinfection and circumferential
48
4 surgical approaches
Fig. 4.9 Final setup for microsurgical transoral odontoidectomy Fig. 4.7 Head fixed to Mayfield holder with inserted Crockard’s mouth distractor. Notice the attached DRA for navigational system
wrapping, we insert Crockard’s transoral distraction frame (Codman™). The insertion and stability of the frame is crucial for uneventful surgery and it is frequently secured by a submandibular support of its lower part. The tongue must not be interposed between the teeth and the lower blade of the distractor. The endotracheal tube is located laterally (on the right side in our setup) under the large caudal lingual distractor blade. The uvula is stitched to a rubber tubing inserted through nostril to epipharynx, and then everted cranially (Fig. 4.8). Additional isolated spatulas for reverting the soft palate are also available in the set. It is possible to split the soft palate in order
Fig. 4.8 Soft palate reverted to nasopharynx by traction of transnasally introduced cannula stitched to uvula
to get a better view cranially, no more than 1 cm can be achieved by this maneuver, however. If performed anyway, the uvula has to be left on one side. We always try to avoid any incision in soft palate as there is a high risk of postoperative velopalatal insufficiency causing rhinolalia and nasal alimentary regurgitation. We have never drilled away any part of the hard palate in our series of TO-treated patients. When necessary, opendoor maxillotomy offers a more convenient option. After final positioning of Crockard’s frame, we disinfect the surgical field again and perform the final wrapping (Fig. 4.9). The anterior tubercle of the atlas is palpated to localize the midline. Uvula may be used as an optional orientation point in case of rotatory dislocation of atlas. A vertically oriented longitudinal knife scratch is performed on the surface of retropharyngeal mucosa at the level of anterior atlantal tubercle and local anesthetic with adrenalin is applied. The injection distorts natural anatomy and marking with a knife scratch keeps surgeon’s eye on the midline. Infiltrated mucosa is incised above the tubercle and all the way to the bone. This incision avoids any anatomical structures of importance. The anterior tubercle of C1 must be dissected free as the crucial landmark. It is of utmost importance to be sure that the atlas is not rotated as this may substantially change the position of the tubercle! The muscle attachments but namely the firm attachment of anterior longitudinal ligament should be cut sharply off the tubercle with the sharp long-shaft knife. The anterior arch of the atlas is exposed bilaterally by subperiostal dissection (around 1 cm to both sides; VA is normally located more than 2 cm from the midline). We continue to dissect sharply caudally to the body of C2. In the exposure designed for the purpose
4.5 Transoral Approach
of odontoidectomy, the disk C2/3 represents the most caudal landmark. Its position may be verified with a dissector and palpation or fluoroscopy. If necessary, it is usually possible to expose approximately the upper half of C3 body caudally. Lateral extent of the exposure at the level of C2 is limited by the position of VA (10–15 mm from the midline at this level). Cranial dissection, in particular, should be performed carefully as only the anterior atlanto-occipital membrane protects the dura laterally between atlas and clivus. The clival edge has to be identified before exposed subperiostally. Caudal and cranial ridge of the atlas arch can then be dissected with a thin periostal elevator. The anterior C1 arch can then be removed easily either macroscopically with a rongeur (Fig. 4.10) or drilled out under microscope. The interlaminar distance of 12–15 mm allows full anterior exposure of the odontoid. If necessary, the approach can be safely extended laterally to the lateral masses of C1. Further steps depend on whether dens deformity caused by underlying pathology is present or not. If well demarcated, the apical ligaments (e.g., apical and allar) are sharply cut and resected before the odontoid is cut at its base so that PLL may be reached (Fig. 4.11a, b, c). The odontoid peg is then mobilized from its tip while elevated with a flat bone hook (Caspar’s osteophyte hook) until it breaks (Fig. 4.11d). The free fragment can thus be removed en bloc. The odontoid is sometimes poorly delimited or dislocated too deep or even behind clivus. In such
Fig. 4.10 Anterior arch of atlas grasped by rongeur before its removal
49
situations, we use an egg-shell milling with high-speed drilling through the tissue until the opposite cortical bone is reached. We often start the removal at the tip and continue caudally to avoid free movement of the apical fragment during drilling. The transversal atlantal ligament can be seen behind the peg finally. It is loosened in cases of RA or developmental deformities and can be then removed. However, it should be left in place if it is strong and does not cause compression of the spinal cord. Leaving the strong ligament in place helps to resist eventual distracting forces on atlas and its vertical movement. Removal of the odontoid is often satisfactory for adequate decompression. It is not necessary to remove the soft tissue in patients with RA or odontoid pseudoarthrosis if we plan a posterior stabilization later during the same surgery. Previous recommendation is not applicable in patients with developmental anomalies, infectious bone damage, and/or tumors. Depending on the type of procedure and pathology, the standard transoral approach should be appropriately modified: the atlas arch partially spared, the clivus edge cut out, the whole anterior axis removed (with or without cage or prosthesis replacing C2 body) etc. The approach can be extended cranially (maxillotomy) and/or caudally (mandibulotomy), but such an extension should better be a planned step rather than a result of decision made intraoperatively. The subarachnoid space has to be opened very exceptionally, mainly in case of tumors (clival chordoma). Whenever possible, we prefer the far lateral approach to remove midline intradural pathologies of CVJ. Watertight suture with use of dural substitutes is necessary. It might be technically difficult and adhesives and self-adhering patches are often applied. Use of external lumbar drainage is mandatory in cases of intradural procedure. However, the pressure of cerebrospinal fluid should be maintained positive, so that the content of oral cavity including potentially pathogenic microbial flora is not prompted to migrate intradurally as a result of negative pressure gradient. Under normal circumstances, we leave external CSF drainage for 7–10 days postoperatively. The decompressive procedure is finished by closing the pharyngeal wall in one or two layers. Nasogastric feeding tube is inserted at the end of surgery and left in place for 5–7 days. Most of our transoral surgeries involved a primarily unstable situations or such a situation was created by the decompression performed. Stabilization is therefore often necessary and we tend to perform it in a
50
4 surgical approaches
Fig. 4.11 Transoral odontoidectomy. (a) Demarking of the odontoid process. (b) High speed drill undercutting of the base. (c) Drilling of the odontoid base controlled by fluoroscopy. (d) Outward braking of the peg
single session, e.g., immediately after the closure of the transoral wound. It is of advantage to attach the Mayfield’s head clamp in a way that allows head fixation in both prone and supine positions without any need for replacement of the skull pins (Fig. 4.1). The motor-evoked responses must be carefully monitored and should not alter during repositioning of the patient. There are only few distinct situations where the extension of the classical TO approach makes sense, as example when the border of pathological process cannot be reached and/or the mouth cannot be opened wide enough to insert instruments. A need for cranial extension is more frequent. Maxillotomy may be used in adult patients with tumors (chordoma, sarcoma, chondroma, osteoblastoma, etc.) and/or with congenital/ acquired deformities causing flattening of the skull base (Fig. 7.1, Chap. 7, Fig. 20.13, Chap. 20). Mandibulotomy
without splitting of the tongue can be justified if the mouth cannot be opened enough. Most of tumors of the UCS are of metastatic origin and radical extirpation is seldom possible. For palliative tumor resection and stabilization, the high anterolateral approach is sufficient in the majority of cases. We always invite the maxillofacial surgeon to perform the extension of the approach.
4.5.3 Minimally Invasive Approaches to Retropharyngeal UCS Endoscopic techniques were brought to the area of UCS by neurosurgeons familiar with endoscopic and image-guided surgery of the brain. Veres et al. used navigation-based technique for transoral surgeries in three patients. By using a halo vest during
51
References
a preoperative scanning, he elegantly overcame the problem of the shift due to mobility. The resulting accuracy was reported to be 1.5–3 mm [72]. Other authors have confirmed positive experience with image guidance for TO surgery [70, 74]. The main problem of image-guided techniques in spine surgery – the accurate registration of mobile vertebras as landmarks – has been solved by the use of fluoroscopy for in situ registration. These technologies represent a futuristic reality that is available already today, and they are helpful particularly in complex surgical cases. Endoscopy-assisted surgery was originally introduced to increase the visibility as well as illumination of the surgical field, but also to avoid soft palate split during standard TO approaches [21]. Increasing popularity of endoscopy and experience from using it in pituitary surgery allowed neurosurgeons to extend its use to the surgery of the clivus and the region of CVJ. Based on cadaveric study of Alfieri et al. [2], Kasam et al. resected the odontoid process in a 73-year-old woman, using a transnasally introduced endoscope [42]. They used binostril approach. The caudally based mucosal flap was located above the level of soft palate. Introduction of adapted long instruments was image guided and controlled with fluoroscopy. Their patient (suffering from RA) did well after the surgery and the extent of odontoidectomy was nicely documented by CT. The authors called the approach as “expanded endonasal” (EEA). Similarly, Hansen et al. performed a transnasal decompression in a patient with basilar invagination [29]. Wu et al. [79] performed endoscopic removal of odontoid in three patients (RA in two, trauma in one) using only one nostril and self-retaining holders. Transclival trajectory allows sparing of C1 arch, thus reducing the risk of extensive destabilization. To avoid infectious complications of transoral or transnasal surgery (transcavital approach), Wolinsky et al. [77] developed endoscopic transcervical imageguided odontoidectomy (ETO). The procedure was successfully performed in three patients with basilar impression, with only one complication (CSF leakage). The endoscope was introduced through adapted tubular retractor (METRx™, Medtronic) to the base of C2 in a similar fashion as screws for odontoid fixation. The anatomical landmarks were registered using C-arm fluoroscopy and following surgical steps were performed under image guidance. The authors were able to decompress CVJ by gradual drilling under endoscopic control. ETO technique was later used at the
same institution for successful treatment of four pediatric patients suffering from basilar invagination and cranial settling [46]. Although ETO and EEA are really minimally invasive techniques, they cannot be regarded as pure endoscopy because the endoscope is introduced via a tubular system or nostrils, parallel with drill and suction. Recently, Baird et al. [7] compared all three endoscopic techniques in a cadaver study. Evaluating findings from nine cadavers, the authors found the average distance to the surgical target to be similar for all three methods – 94 mm by endonasal, 102 mm by transoral, and 100 mm by transcervical route. However, the approach angles necessary to reach the target structures differed significantly. The authors concluded that endoscopic transoral approach allows exposure of the largest surgical field. The transcervical route, certainly suitable for resection of the odontoid, does not allow safe resection of the lower clivus.
4.5.3.1 Our Preference The philosophy of minimally invasive approaches performed either from small incisions with the help of image guidance or endoscopically assisted clearly stand opposite to the techniques aiming at maximal exposure, represented by transpalatopharyngeal route with medial mandibuloglossotomy. Although we do not have personal experience with endoscopy in surgery of UCS and CVJ at our institution, we feel that there is a place for it in selected indications. Further development of minimally invasive techniques based on virtual image guidance can definitely be expected.
References 1. Ai, F., Yin, Q., Wang, Z., et al.: Applied anatomy of transoral atlantoaxial reduction plate internal fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 128–132 (2006) 2. Alfieri, A., Jho, H.D., Tschabitscher, M.: Endoscopic endonasal approach to the ventral cranio-cervical junction: anatomical study. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 144, 219–225 (2002). discussion 225 3. al-Mefty, O., Borba, L.A., Aoki, N., et al.: The transcondylar approach to extradural nonneoplastic lesions of the craniovertebral junction. J Neurosurg 84, 1–6 (1996) 4. Alonso, W.A., Black, P., Connor, G.H., et al.: Transoral transpalatal approach for resection of clival chordoma. Laryngoscope 81, 1626–1631 (1971)
52 5. Arbit, E., Patterson Jr., R.H.: Combined transoral and median labiomandibular glossotomy approach to the upper cervical spine. Neurosurgery 8, 672–674 (1981) 6. Archer, D.J., Young, S., Uttley, D.: Basilar aneurysms: a new transclival approach via maxillotomy. J Neurosurg 67, 54–58 (1987) 7. Baird, C.J., Conway, J.E., Sciubba, D.M., et al.: Radiographic and anatomic basis of endoscopic anterior craniocervical decompression: a comparison of endonasal, transoral, and transcervical approaches. Neurosurgery 65, 158–163 (2009). discussion 163–154 8. Barbour, J.R.: Screw fixation in fracture of the odontoid process. S Aust Clin 5, 20–24 (1971) 9. Bertalanffy, H., Seeger, W.: The dorsolateral, suboccipital, transcondylar approach to the lower clivus and anterior portion of the craniocervical junction. Neurosurgery 29, 815– 821 (1991) 10. Bhangoo, R.S., Crockard, H.A.: Transmaxillary anterior decompressions in patients with severe basilar impression. Clin Orthop Relat Res 359, 115–125 (1999) 11. Brookes, J.T., Smith, R.J., Menezes, A.H., et al.: Median labiomandibular glossotomy approach to the craniocervical region. Childs Nerv Syst 24, 1195–1201 (2008) 12. Cocke Jr., E.W., Robertson, J.H., Robertson, J.T., et al.: The extended maxillotomy and subtotal maxillectomy for excision of skull base tumors. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 116, 92–104 (1990) 13. Crockard, H.A.: Transoral approach to intra/extradural tumors. In: Sekhar, L.N., Janecka, I.P. (eds.) Surgery of cranial base tumors, pp. 225–234. Raven, New York (1993) 14. Crockard, H.A.: Transoral surgery: some lessons learned. Br J Neurosurg 9, 283–293 (1995) 15. Crockard, H.A., Johnston, F.: Development of transoral approaches to lesions of the skull base and craniocervical junction. Neurosurg Q 3, 61–82 (1993) 16. de Andrade, J.R., Macnab, I.: Anterior occipito-cervical fusion using an extra-pharyngeal exposure. J Bone Joint Surg Am 51, 1621–1626 (1969) 17. Delgado, T.E., Garrido, E., Harwick, R.D.: Labiomandibular, transoral approach to chordomas in the clivus and upper cervical spine. Neurosurgery 8, 675–679 (1981) 18. Dickman, C.A., Crawford, N.R., Brantley, A.G., et al.: Biomechanical effects of transoral odontoidectomy. Neurosurgery 36, 1146–1152 (1995). discussion 1152–1143 19. Dickman, C.A., Locantro, J., Fessler, R.G.: The influence of transoral odontoid resection on stability of the craniovertebral junction. J Neurosurg 77, 525–530 (1992) 20. Du Toit, G.: Lateral atlanto-axial arthrodesis. A screw fixation technique. S Afr J Surg 14, 9–12 (1976) 21. Frempong-Boadu, A.K., Faunce, W.A., Fessler, R.G.: Endoscopically assisted transoral-transpharyngeal approach to the craniovertebral junction. Neurosurgery 51, S60–S66 (2002) 22. George, B., Laurian, C.: Surgical approach to the whole length of the vertebral artery with special reference to the third portion. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 51, 259–272 (1980) 23. Gilsbach, J.M., Eggert, H.R., Seeger, W.: The dorsolateral approach in ventrolateral craniospinal lesions. In: Voth, D., Glees, P. (eds.) Diseases in the cranio-cervical junction. Anatomical and pathological aspects and detailed clinical accounts, pp. 359–364. Gruyter, Berlin, New York (1987)
4 surgical approaches 24. Grime, P.D., Haskell, R., Robertson, I., et al.: Transfacial access for neurosurgical procedures: an extended role for the maxillofacial surgeon. I. The upper cervical spine and clivus. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 20, 285–290 (1991) 25. Grime, P.D., Haskell, R., Robertson, I., et al.: Transfacial access for neurosurgical procedures: an extended role for the maxillofacial surgeon. II. Middle cranial fossa, infratemporal fossa and pterygoid space. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 20, 291–295 (1991) 26. Grob, D.: Atlantoaxial immobilization in rheumatoid arthritis: a prophylactic procedure? Eur Spine J 9, 404–409 (2000) 27. Grob, D., Wursch, R., Grauer, W., et al.: Atlantoaxial fusion and retrodental pannus in rheumatoid arthritis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 22, 1580–1583 (1997). discussion 1584 28. Hadley, M.N., Spetzler, R.F., Sonntag, V.K.: The transoral approach to the superior cervical spine. A review of 53 cases of extradural cervicomedullary compression. J Neurosurg 71, 16–23 (1989) 29. Hansen, M.A., da Cruz, M.J., Owler, B.K.: Endoscopic transnasal decompression for management of basilar invagination in osteogenesis imperfecta. J Neurosurg Spine 9, 354–357 (2008) 30. Harms, J., Schmelze, R., Stolze, D.: Osteosynthesen im occipito-cervikalen Übergang vom transoralen Zugang aus, XVII SICOT World Congress Abstracts. Demeter Verlag, Munich (1987) 31. Henry, A.K.: Extensile exposure, pp. 58–74. E & S Livingstone, Edinburgh and London (1957) 32. Heros, R.C.: Lateral suboccipital approach for vertebral and vertebrobasilar artery lesions. J Neurosurg 64, 559–562 (1986) 33. Hitchcock, E., Cowie, R.: Transoral-transclival clipping of a midline vertebral artery aneurysm. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 46, 446–448 (1983) 34. James, D., Crockard, H.A.: Surgical access to the base of skull and upper cervical spine by extended maxillotomy. Neurosurgery 29, 411–416 (1991) 35. Jiang, L.S., Shen, L., Wang, W., et al.: Posterior atlantoaxial dislocation without fracture and neurologic deficit: a case report and the review of literature. Eur Spine J 28, 28 (2009) 36. Jones, R.E., Bucholz, R.W., Schaefer, S.D., et al.: Cervical osteomyelitis complicating transpharyngeal gunshot wounds to the neck. J Trauma 19, 630–634 (1979) 37. Jones, D.C., Hayter, J.P.: The superiorly based pharyngeal flap: a modification of the transoral approach to the upper cervical spine. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 35, 368–369 (1997) 38. Jones, D.C., Hayter, J.P., Vaughan, E.D., et al.: Oropharyngeal morbidity following transoral approaches to the upper cervical spine. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 27, 295–298 (1998) 39. Kanavel, A.B.: Bullet locked between atlas and the base of the skull: Technique for removal through the mouth. Surg Clin 1, 361–366 (1919) 40. Kandziora, F., Kerschbaumer, F., Starker, M., et al.: Biomechanical assessment of transoral plate fixation for atlantoaxial instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25, 1555–1561 (2000) 41. Kandziora, F., Mittlmeier, T., Kerschbaumer, F.: Stagerelated surgery for cervical spine instability in rheumatoid arthritis. Eur Spine J 8, 371–381 (1999) 42. Kassam, A.B., Snyderman, C., Gardner, P., et al.: The expanded endonasal approach: a fully endoscopic transnasal
References approach and resection of the odontoid process: technical case report. Neurosurgery 57, E213 (2005). discussion E213 43. Kingdom, T.T., Nockels, R.P., Kaplan, M.J.: Transoraltranspharyngeal approach to the craniocervical junction. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 113, 393–400 (1995) 44. Lee, S.T., Fairholm, D.J.: Transoral anterior decompression for treatment of unreducible atlantoaxial dislocations. Surg Neurol 23, 244–248 (1985) 45. McAfee, P.C., Bohlman, H.H., Riley Jr., L.H., et al.: The anterior retropharyngeal approach to the upper part of the cervical spine. J Bone Joint Surg Am 69, 1371–1383 (1987) 46. McGirt, M.J., Attenello, F.J., Sciubba, D.M., et al.: Endoscopic transcervical odontoidectomy for pediatric basilar invagination and cranial settling. Report of 4 cases. J Neurosurg Pediatr 1, 337–342 (2008) 47. Menezes, A.H.: Anterior approaches to the craniocervical junction. Clin Neurosurg 37, 756–769 (1989) 48. Menezes, A.H., VanGilder, J.C.: Transoral-transpharyngeal approach to the anterior craniocervical junction. Ten-year experience with 72 patients. J Neurosurg 69, 895–903 (1988) 49. Milbrink, J., Nyman, R.: Posterior stabilization of the cervical spine in rheumatoid arthritis: clinical results and magnetic resonance imaging correlation. J Spinal Disord 3, 308–315 (1990) 50. Mouchaty, H., Perrini, P., Conti, R., et al.: Craniovertebral junction lesions: our experience with the transoral surgical approach. Eur Spine J 18(Suppl 1), 13–19 (2009) 51. Mullan, S., Naunton, R., Hekmat-Panah, J., et al.: The use of an anterior approach to ventrally placed tumors in the foramen magnum and vertebral column. J Neurosurg 24, 536– 543 (1966) 52. Naderi, S., Crawford, N.R., Melton, M.S., et al.: Biomechanical analysis of cranial settling after transoral odontoidectomy. Neurosurg Focus 6, e7 (1999) 53. Naderi, S., Pamir, M.N.: Further cranial settling of the upper cervical spine following odontoidectomy. Report of two cases. J Neurosurg 95, 246–249 (2001) 54. Oya, S., Tsutsumi, K., Shigeno, T., et al.: Posterolateral odontoidectomy for irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation: a technical case report. Spine J 4, 591–594 (2004) 55. Park, S.H., Sung, J.K., Lee, S.H., et al.: High anterior cervical approach to the upper cervical spine. Surg Neurol 68, 519–524 (2007). discussion 524 56. Pasztor, E., Vajda, J., Piffko, P., et al.: Transoral surgery for craniocervical space-occupying processes. J Neurosurg 60, 276–281 (1984) 57. Rhines, L.D., Fourney, D.R., Siadati, A., et al.: En bloc resection of multilevel cervical chordoma with C-2 involvement. Case report and description of operative technique. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 199–205 (2005) 58. Roy-Camille, R., de la Caffiniére, J.H., Saillant, G.: Les traumatismes du rachis cervical superieur C1-C2. Masson et Cie, Paris (1973) 59. Ruf, M., Melcher, R., Harms, J.: Transoral reduction and osteosynthesis C1 as a function-preserving option in the treatment of unstable Jefferson fractures. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 29, 823–827 (2004) 60. Scoville, W.B., Sherman, I.J.: Platybasia, report of 10 cases with comments on familial tendency, a special diagnostic sign, and the end results of operation. Ann Surg 133, 496– 502 (1951)
53 61. Sen, C.N., Sekhar, L.N.: An extreme lateral approach to intradural lesions of the cervical spine and foramen magnum. Neurosurgery 27, 197–204 (1990) 62. Simmons, E.H., Du Toit Jr., G.: Lateral atlantoaxial arthrodesis. Orthop Clin North Am 9, 1101–1114 (1978) 63. Skaf, G.S., Sabbagh, A.S., Hadi, U.: The advantages of submandibular gland resection in anterior retropharyngeal approach to the upper cervical spine. Eur Spine J 16, 469– 477 (2007) 64. Southwick, W.O., Robinson, R.A.: Surgical approaches to the vertebral bodies in the cervical and lumbar regions. J Bone Joint Surg Am 39-A, 631–644 (1957) 65. Spetzler, R.F., Selman, W.R., Nash Jr., C.L., et al.: Transoral microsurgical odontoid resection and spinal cord monitoring. Spine (Phila Pa 1976 4, 506–510 (1979) 66. Steinmetz, M.P., Mroz, T.E., Benzel, E.C.: Craniovertebral junction: biomechanical considerations. Neurosurgery 66, A7–A12 (2010) 67. Suchomel, P., Buchvald, P., Barsa, P., et al.: Single-stage total C-2 intralesional spondylectomy for chordoma with three-column reconstruction. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 6, 611–618 (2007) 68. Sukoff, M.H., Kadin, M.M., Moran, T.: Transoral decompression for myelopathy caused by rheumatoid arthritis of the cervical spine. Case report. J Neurosurg 37, 493–497 (1972) 69. Ture, U., Pamir, M.N.: Extreme lateral-transatlas approach for resection of the dens of the axis. J Neurosurg 96, 73–82 (2002) 70. Ugur, H.C., Kahilogullari, G., Attar, A., et al.: Neuronavigationassisted transoral-transpharyngeal approach for basilar invagination – two case reports. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo) 46, 306–308 (2006) 71. Vaccaro, A.R., Lehman, A.P., Ahlgren, B.D., et al.: Anterior C1-C2 screw fixation and bony fusion through an anterior retropharyngeal approach. Orthopedics 22, 1165–1170 (1999) 72. Veres, R., Bago, A., Fedorcsak, I.: Early experiences with image-guided transoral surgery for the pathologies of the upper cervical spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976 26, 1385–1388 (2001) 73. Vishteh, A.G., Crawford, N.R., Melton, M.S., et al.: Stability of the craniovertebral junction after unilateral occipital condyle resection: a biomechanical study. J Neurosurg 90, 91–98 (1999) 74. Vougioukas, V.I., Hubbe, U., Schipper, J., et al.: Navigated transoral approach to the cranial base and the craniocervical junction: technical note. Neurosurgery 52, 247–250 (2003). discussion 251 75. Whitesides, TEj: Lateral retropharyngeal approach to the upper cervical spine. In: Sherk, H.H., Dunn, E.J., Eismont, F.J., et al. (eds.) The cervical spine, pp. 796–804. Lippincott, Philadelphia (1989) 76. Whitesides, T.E., Kelly, R.P.: Lateral approach to the upper cervical spine for anterior fusion. South Med J 59, 879–883 (1966) 77. Wolinsky, J.P., Sciubba, D.M., Suk, I., et al.: Endoscopic image-guided odontoidectomy for decompression of basilar invagination via a standard anterior cervical approach. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 6, 184–191 (2007) 78. Wood, D.E., Good, T.L., Hahn, J., et al.: Decompression of the brain stem and superior cervical spine for congenital/
54 acquired craniovertebral invagination: an interdisciplinary approach. Laryngoscope 100, 926–931 (1990) 79. Wu, J.C., Huang, W.C., Cheng, H., et al.: Endoscopic transnasal transclival odontoidectomy: a new approach to decompression: technical case report. Neurosurgery 63, ONSE92–ONSE94 (2008). discussion ONSE94 80. Young, W.F., Boyko, O.: Magnetic resonance imaging confirmation of resolution of periodontoid pannus formation following C1/C2 posterior transarticular screw fixation. J Clin Neurosci 9, 434–436 (2002)
4 surgical approaches 81. Youssef, A.S., Guiot, B., Black, K., et al.: Modifications of the transoral approach to the craniovertebral junction: anatomic study and clinical correlations. Neurosurgery 62, 145–154 (2008). discussion 145–154 82. Zygmunt, S., Saveland, H., Brattstrom, H., et al.: Reduction of rheumatoid periodontoid pannus following posterior occipito-cervical fusion visualised by magnetic resonance imaging. Br J Neurosurg 2, 315–320 (1988)
5
Basic Principles of Reconstruction Techniques O. Choutka and P. Suchomel
The craniovertebral junction (CVJ) is a mechanical part of the spine that offers the most significant amount of mobility when compared to other segments, particularly in flexion, extension, and rotation. Under physiological circumstances, stability and mobility of the CVJ is facilitated by unique morphology of the upper cervical vertebrae that form the levers in motion that are restrained by ligaments and facilitated by surrounding local and distant muscles. The atlanto-occipital and atlantoaxial joints act as pivots of the complex motion. Pathological processes, such as arthritides and tumors, as well as surgical decompressive procedures can result in profound violation of the balanced construct and thus cause instability, loss of function, pain, and neurological compromise. Prior to embarking on any potentially destabilizing procedure at CVJ, a surgeon should have a plan for reconstruction that will stabilize appropriately. The unique nature of the upper cervical spine (UCS) vertebrae offers an opportunity for not only stabilizing rigid constructs but also for a number of direct osteosynthetic designs that preserve motion of the segment. In general, constructs of the CVJ involve those designed for ventral approaches and posterior instrumentation, or both. Basic biomechanical principles and forces generated by any implant must be respected and understood when instrumenting the UCS and are covered elsewhere in the book. The biomechanical properties of the CVJ must be either
O. Choutka Department of Neurosurgery, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 231 Albert Sabin Way, Cincinnati, OH 45267-0515, USA P. Suchomel Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St.10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic
matched or appropriately counteracted by any construct that is to stabilize and maintain motion and appropriate alignment. Several basic reconstruction techniques are discussed in this section but the reader should refer to Chap. 2 for biomechanical principles and Chap. 6 for specific reconstructions.
5.1 Defect/Instability/Decompression Most of the axial rotation (60%) and some of the flexion-extension (40%) and lateral bending of the head occur in the UCS (C0-C2) [14, 30, 39]. The highly specialized anatomy and osteoligamentous integrity provides for a relatively paradoxical kinetic profile with loose enough arrangement to allow for the above-mentioned range of motion but tight enough to prevent injury to spinal cord, nerves, and vertebral arteries. When the integrity is interrupted for any reason (trauma, tumor, inflammation, and degeneration or iatrogenic decompression), instability ensues. White and Panjabi defined clinical instability as “the loss of the ability of spine under physiologic loads to maintain relationships between vertebrae in such a way that there is neither initial nor subsequent damage to the spinal cord or nerve roots, and in addition, there is neither development of incapacitating deformity nor severe pain” [40]. The biomechanical profile of various types of instability affecting the UCS is described in Chaps. 2 and 3. Irrespective of the etiology of mechanical instability (acute vs. chronic) of the UCS, one has to be aware of the biomechanics involved in the development of the condition in order to be able to determine if a surgical construct is necessary to restore stability and balance to the region, and if so, what kind of construct can withhold the forces involved while fusion is taking place.
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_5, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
55
56
5.2 Construct Design The concept of surgical spinal stabilization for a fracture was introduced in 1891 by Hadra [19] when he operated on a fracture dislocation of a cervical spine in a child showing progressive cord deterioration, using wires wrapped around the spinous processes to stabilize the vertebral sector. This was a new concept for the time of “holding broken or diseased bones together” and was widely adapted until 1911 when spinal fusion was first described as a treatment for Pott’s Disease [3, 23]. Albee and Hibbs worked independently on patients with Pott’s disease to design a method of spine fusion. Albee used tibial cortical autograft and Hibbs used spinous processes to produce surgical fusion. Spinal constructs since then have changed significantly but the concept of fixation and fusion remains the mainstay of treatment of spinal instabilities, including the UCS and CVJ. Screws, cages, and wiring/cable techniques are all used in this region and must be able to withhold the main forces with OA and AA joints, flexion/extension, and rotation, respectively. Multiple basic principles have been described for application of metallic implants in the UCS. Most commonly used implants at the CVJ include both anterior and posterior techniques and each individual clinical scenario determines the most appropriate approach. Anterior implants include direct osteosynthetic screw of the dens (lag) or cage constructs after odontoidectomy/corpectomy/spondylectomy or atlantoaxial transarticular screws. Posterior constructs can include occipitocervical and atlantoaxial fixations through means of various screw and rod/plate constructs or direct osteosynthetic screws or wire/cable techniques (Chap. 6). Buttressing, tension band, and neutralization principles usually apply to the constructs of the CVJ [2] with the primary goal being immediate rigid fixation so that favorable environment for bone fusion is created.
5 Basic Principles of Reconstruction Techniques
for use in cervical trauma patients [8]. His plating technique has gained wide popularity in the subaxial spine in particular and offered immediate stability without the use of external orthosis. The stability of an anterior plate, however, is dependent on screw purchase within the vertebral bone. The initial Caspar design was thought to be dependent on bicortical screw purchase to prevent screw toggling. However, this requirement was deemed unnecessary once locking screw plates were developed and unicortical screws were sufficient [6, 27]. Plate and screw constructs have been used in orthopedic trauma management of various long and short bone fractures well before the use in spine surgery and follow the tenets put forth by the AO group in late 1950s [15]. The use of plate and screw constructs in the ventral UCS is limited to C2-3 fusion when done for treatment of hangman’s fracture [37], one can argue that certain anterior cage constructs also follow buttressing principle when used in combination with anterior screws such as demonstrated by the anterior clival-C3 construct in our patient with C2 chordoma resection [36] (Fig. 5.1). Posteriorly, buttressing principle is applied with use of plating systems with either screws or wires. Lateral mass screw and plate construct offers similar rigidity in
5.2.1 Plate and Screw Constructs in the CVJ Buttressing implants prevent axial deformity and are placed on the side of load application [2]. An example includes anterior cervical plate as developed by Caspar
Fig. 5.1 Sagittal CT demonstrating a complicated UCS cage/ screw construct after C2 spondylectomy. Anterior cage does not only serve as the major load-bearing apparatus for the anterior column but through its attachment to the clivus and C3 vertebral body acts as a buttress
57
5.2 Construct Design
biomechanical in vitro studies to other types of posterior cervical constructs [12]. Even further, the authors found no significant difference in rigidity between combined anteroposterior and posterior only constructs. It needs to be reiterated that the strength of a construct is more dependent on the screw than the plate itself. Magerl lateral mass screw technique is biomechanically superior to the Roy-Camille method, probably due largely to the difference in screw length and trajectory [10]. Posterior cervical plate constructs are a safe construct with low complication rate [21]. Nonetheless, failure can be related to either the plate or the screw. Screw bone interface (surface area) will influence the pullout strength of any given, but a tapered or conical screw configuration does not alter the pullout strength [17]. Wellman et al. examined the safety and complications associated with lateral mass screws in their 43 patients [38]. Although, a proponent of bicortical screw purchase in lateral mass screws to increase pullout strength, he concluded that bicortical screw purchase did not offer decrease biomechanical failure rate (none in his series) and therefore, was not worth the potential neurovascular risk. On the other hand, Heller et al. argued that engaging the far cortex increases the pullout strength by 28% [20] with less than 2% risk of radiculopathy [21]. The issue of bicortical vs. monocortical screw purchase is a common discussion point when it comes to the instrumentation of UCS and, perhaps, the key to differentiation between a bicortical screw and bicortical penetrating screw needs to be made (Fig. 5.2). The former offers the potential biomechanical advantages of a bicortical purchase whereas the latter may, in addition, increase the chance of neurovascular injury. It may be sensible to weigh the risk/benefit ratio in each clinical scenario and consider the true need for bicortical screw purchase in a good quality bone versus not achieving far cortex purchase in osteoporotic bone. The bicortical screw discussion surrounds also occipital screw [22] and odontoid screw [35] placement (indirectly with one vs. two screw conflict). Anterior odontoid screw fixation is a well-accepted method of direct, compressive, and osteosynthetic construct that has evolved over time with multiple variations all resulting in fracture line apposition, alignment and compression, thus creating a favorable bone-healing condition [1, 29]. All modifications of anterior direct osteosynthetic odontoid screw, such as fully threaded screw [7], cannulated K-wire guided
Fig. 5.2 Monocortical screws are at risk of toggling. Bicortical screw purchase increase the pullout strength in many constructs. Penetrating bicortical screws may, however, increase the risk of neurovascular injury. Nearly bicortical screw purchase may present an alternative
screw [1], and double-threaded screw [9, 25] utilize the same principle of fracture reduction, alignment, and compression. However, even a good reduction is not always feasible with anterior odontoid screw as up to 19% of cases end up malaligned [1]. The compressive lag screw effect can be achieved through a differential thread design, proximal overdrilling or a standard lag screw design (Figs. 5.3 and 5.4). When using a fully threaded screw, without overdrilling, the lag principle does not apply and the screw simply becomes a neutralizing/stabilizing one. This obviously creates different bone-healing conditions than compressive constructs. Neutralization does still provide stability through minimization of torsional bending and shearing but may undergo indirect bone healing (i.e., formation of a callus rather than going through tissue differentiation and resorption of bone surface [32]. Similar compressive, lag principle is applied to certain posterior techniques. Direct osteosynthesis of hangman’s fracture as described by Judet [26] is a classic example (Fig. 12.19, Chap. 12). We have applied this principle to a patient with a unilateral C1 lateral mass fracture with fracture displacement (Figs. 7.5– 7.8, Chap. 7). A cannulated lag screw over a K-wire was used to successfully reduce and fix this fracture under CT guidance.
58
5 Basic Principles of Reconstruction Techniques
Fig. 5.3 Lag screw principle – fully threaded screw with the need of proximal overdrilling
Fig. 5.4 Lag screw principle – partially thread screw without necessity of proximal overdrilling
Other unique posterior screw constructs include atlantoaxial transarticular screws as initially described by Magerl, in 1979 [28]. The pronounced rotator and translational instability present with Type II odontoid fractures or TAL injury results in decreased fusion rates when the initial posterior wiring techniques alone
were used. Therefore, any form of rigid fixation at this level was going to enhance fusion success rates (Chap. 6). The transarticular screw resulted in immediate fixation that allowed for posterior fusion of any kind (Gallie, Sonntag, Brooks) to take place. This took away the new, abnormal axis and amount of rotation
59
5.2 Construct Design Fig. 5.5 For adequate stability, atlantoaxial screws need to be placed sufficiently deep within C1 lateral mass (tricortical) or even through the far cortex of C1 (quadricortical). Increased risk of neurovascular injury with long screws exists
and translation seen after isolated posterior wire/cable constructs [13], offered significant shear shielding and decreased pseudoarthrosis rate [18]. The atlantoaxial screws can offer a neutralizing and compressive effect on the AA complex. Although, theoretically, they do not need to offer any kind of compression across the joint as the point of fusion is distant from the joint (i.e., posterior if C1 arch remains intact), the strength of the transarticular screw can be enhanced by quadricortical rather than tricortical screw purchase (Fig. 5.5). Quadricortical screw purchase obviously carries a risk of neurovascular injury anterior to the C1 as described in Chap. 6. Quadricortical screw purchase can be intentional for screw pull out strength and toggle avoidance as mentioned above, or can serve as a rescue option. C2 pedicle screws are a good example. The technique (Chap. 6) and anatomical reasoning (Chap. 1) are discussed elsewhere; however, a small C2 pedicle can make placement of a 3.5 mm screw impossible. Exceptionally, as an alternative, a more medial trajectory through the lateral spinal canal can provide a robust screw anchor through four cortices (Fig. 5.6).
Fig. 5.6 C2 quadricortical pedicle screws
5.2.2 Anterior Structural Constructs The anterior column reconstruction techniques at the CVJ, just as elsewhere in the spine, must result in restoration of a stable load-bearing column, maintenance of appropriate height, and sagittal alignment for a long enough period, so that bony integration and fusion can take place. The eventually biologically integrated construct will be replaced by living bone and become obsolete. The available constructs include tricortical autografts or allografts and synthetic cages. The lack of vertebral body at the C1 level and the unique biomechanical profile of the UCS make structural anterior constructs much less common. Unlike in the subaxial spine, axial loading forces are transmitted from the head to C2 via the occipital condyles, C1 lateral masses, atlantoaxial joints in the middle column, and then C2/3 disk space. Therefore, from a biomechanical viewpoint, an isolated anterior column construct at the CVJ (except C2/3 interbody cages/
60
5 Basic Principles of Reconstruction Techniques
grafts) does not make sense and most likely would fail without posterior support. Nonetheless, they can be used for stability restoration in defects created by treatment of neoplastic, inflammatory, or infectious lesions in combination with posterior techniques. The presence of a robust anterior weight-bearing column with a posterior tension band (occipitocervical fusion) represents a tension band principle that allows dynamic compression of the anterior column and thereby encourages fusion [4]. The difficulty of anterior column reconstruction at the CVJ is the relative lack of sufficient anchors at the superior end of the construct (i.e., clivus or C1 attachment) and the forces applied by the head. Some authors have attempted to replace anterior elements of C2 vertebra with a specific C2 prosthesis [24] that utilizes a load-bearing interbody device with buttress-platelike attachment principles. The authors gradually developed an implant that respects the loading force distribution of the head from a two-column system of the C0-C1-C2 segment to the three-column one present in the subaxial spine. When C2 corpectomy or vertebrectomy is undertaken, a clear reconstructive plan must be present. In our opinion, two main strategies
exist: (1) reconstruction is going to include both anterior and posterior instrumentation from the occiput/ clivus to subaxial spine as shown in Fig. 5.1 where anterior cage was anchored into clivus and middle column support was created through inter-facet cages between C1 and C3 or (2) decreasing the forces transmitted to the construct from the large lever arm of the head by a structural attachment to C1 both anteriorly and posteriorly (Fig. 5.7) and thus excluding the C0-C1 segment from the construct and allowing for a shorter period of postoperative immobilization [33]. Without anterior column reconstruction at the C2 level, a bridge fixation principle needs to be applied [4] with posterior constructs. An increased stress transfer and thus minimized fatigue failure can be achieved by creation of a posterior construct with multiple points of fixation. At the CVJ, that means extension of the construct to the lower cervical spine [16] over segments not involved in the pathological process. And, without the prospect of any anterior support over time, it also means a likely fatigue failure of the construct, which would need to be able to endure three million loading cycles to survive one year after insertion [4]. Long term, a posterior fusion
Fig. 5.7 Combined atlanto-cervical construct utilizing an interbody cage anteriorly and bicortically anchored screws posteriorly used to reconstruct a C2 spondylectomy defect. Compare to Fig. 5.1. This construct is off-loaded by exclusion
of the normal C0-C1 segment. (a) Sagittal CT reconstruction. (b) Axial images (courtesy of R. Bohinski, MD, Mayfield Clinic, Cincinnati, OH)
61
5.3 Fracture Healing/Bone Fusion
with instrumentation cannot compensate for a complete defect in the anterior column. Irrespective of the construct created, the basic principle of sufficiently rigid immobilization of the involved segment must be achieved in order for a bone fusion to take place. Ideally, the construct design allows for both anterior and posterior (or lateral) with sufficient mediation of bone growth, as solid, stable bony fusion in an anatomically aligned and balanced CVJ is the ultimate goal of any construct created.
5.3 Fracture Healing/Bone Fusion Although, historically, spinal instrumentation [19] preceded attempts at fusion [3, 23], it is clear that the two need to go hand in hand. Frequently, a spinal reconstruction cannot be considered successful without the presence of bone fusion. Fractures heal by means of an indirect bone healing [32] that involves sequential steps of tissue differentiation, resorption of surfaces of the fracture, uniting of the fracture fragments by callus, and internal remodeling [31]. Therefore, with any fracture, there is an attempt to reduce it, align it, and maintain it in reduced position until bone healing is complete (i.e., biological fixation has taken place). On the other hand, internal fixation produces a stable, rigid construct until bone healing occurs (direct bone healing). Direct healing occurs under compressive conditions and skips the intermediate steps of the indirect process and proceeds directly (not necessarily faster) to internal remodeling of the Haversian system. Therefore, direct healing does not result in callus formation. If this is visible after an internal fixation, it is understood that the stability did not reach the intended levels [32]. However, a completely rigid fixation of a fracture gap results in lack of mechanical induction of callus formation (strain theory) [11]. These basic orthopedic concepts, derived from fractures of long bones, hold value when assessing healing of fractures at the CVJ that were treated by means of an internal fixation with direct osteosynthesis (e.g., odontoid screw, C2 compressive pedicle screws). Vascular supply to the fracture site also plays a role in healing [34]. Unlike fractures, fusion techniques at the CVJ (Brooks, Gallie, Sonntag, anterior cage construct)
require deposition of a new bone in intersegmental locations that are not biologically structured for bone formation. Although instrumentation significantly improves fusion rates as demonstrated by addition of atlantoaxial screws to posterior fusion techniques in atlantoaxial instability treatment [18], failures of long-term stability occur. Fusion rates are dependent on multiple local, host’s, technical, and environmental factors. The internal fixation factors affecting healing are discussed above. Graft properties (osteo-induction, -conduction and –genecity) and type (autograft, allograft, xenograft), mechanical stability, and graft site preparation are among some of the local factors determining fusion occurrence [5]. Nicotine, osteoporosis, hormonal imbalance, and certain pharmacotherapy are well-known interferers of bone fusion. An organized effort has been made to supplement bone graft materials with fusion enhancers, such as growth factors or electrical stimulation [5]. Discussion of those factors is, however, beyond the scope of this chapter.
5.3.1 Our Preference Constructs at the CVJ are complex and basic biomechanical as well as biological principles need to be applied to each individual scenario. During anterior decompressive procedures at the UCS, we favor the use of perimesh cage reconstruction fashioned in such a manner as to be utilized as an anterior plate also. This then fulfills the role of a buttress plate, interbody loadbearing construct with packed autograft to facilitate anterior column stability, minimize subsidence, and allow anterior fusion. We believe bicortical screw purchase is important in design of a stable construct and we aim for all hardware to be well anchored. We do not use a cannulated odontoid lag screw construct over a K-wire with the understanding that it could be inadvertently advanced with catastrophic results (Fig. 5.8). Economic restraints only allow selective use of bone morphogenic enhancers of fusion in our practice but all patients are screened for any potential factors that would influence adequate healing.
62
5 Basic Principles of Reconstruction Techniques
Fig. 5.8 Lag screw introduction along the K-wire. Note that if odontoid apex is drilled through the wire become free (not fixed) presenting a danger of its cranial dislocation during screw purchase
References 1. Aebi, M., Etter, C., Coscia, M.: Fractures of the odontoid process. Treatment with anterior screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 14, 1065–1070 (1989) 2. Aebi, M., Thalgott, J.S., Webb, J.K.: Priniciples of surgical stabilization. AO ASIF principles in spine surgery, pp. 5–12. Springer, New York (1998) 3. Albee, F.H.: Transplantation of portion of the tibia into the spine for Pott’s disease. JAMA 57, 885 (1911) 4. Arlet, V., Datta, J.C.: Upper cervical spine. In: Aebi, M., Arlet, V., Webb, J.K. (eds.) AO spine manual: principles and techniques, vol. I, pp. 265–288. Thieme Verlag, New York, Stuttgart (2007) 5. Babat, L.B., Boden, S.D.: Biology of spine fusion. In: Benzel, E.C. (ed.) Spine surgery, techniques, complication avoidance, and management, pp. 169–177. Elsevier, Philadelphia (2005) 6. Benzel, E.C.: Upper cervical and occipitocervical arthrodesis. In: Benzel, E.C. (ed.) Spine surgery, techniques, complication avoidance, and management, pp. 329–340. Elsevier, Philadelphia (2005)
7. Bohler, J.: Anterior stabilization for acute fractures and nonunions of the dens. J Bone Joint Surg Am 64, 18–27 (1982) 8. Caspar, W., Barbier, D.D., Klara, P.M.: Anterior cervical fusion and Caspar plate stabilization for cervical trauma. Neurosurgery 25, 491–502 (1989) 9. Chang, K.W., Liu, Y.W., Cheng, P.G., et al.: One Herbert double-threaded compression screw fixation of displaced type II odontoid fractures. J Spinal Disord 7, 62–69 (1994) 10. Choueka, J., Spivak, J.M., Kummer, F.J., et al.: Flexion failure of posterior cervical lateral mass screws. Influence of insertion technique and position. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 462–468 (1996) 11. Claes, L.E., Heigele, C.A.: Magnitudes of local stress and strain along bony surfaces predict the course and type of fracture healing. J Biomech 32, 255–266 (1999) 12. Coe, J.D., Warden, K.E., Sutterlin 3rd, C.E., et al.: Biomechanical evaluation of cervical spinal stabilization methods in a human cadaveric model. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 14, 1122–1131 (1989) 13. Dickman, C.A., Crawford, N.R., Paramore, C.G.: Bio mechanical characteristics of C1-2 cable fixations. J Neurosurg 85, 316–322 (1996)
References 14. Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M.M., Novotny, J.E., et al.: In vivo flexion/extension of the cervical spine. J Orthop Res 9, 824–834 (1991) 15. Egol, K.A., Kubiak, E.N., Fulkerson, E., et al.: Biomechanics of locked plates and screws. J Orthop Trauma 18, 488–493 (2004) 16. Fourney, D.R., York, J.E., Cohen, Z.R., et al.: Management of atlantoaxial metastases with posterior occipitocervical stabilization. J Neurosurg 98, 165–170 (2003) 17. Griffith, S.L., Zogbi, S.W., Guyer, R.D., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of anterior instrumentation for the cervical spine. J Spinal Disord 8, 429–438 (1995) 18. Grob, D., Jeanneret, B., Aebi, M., et al.: Atlanto-axial fusion with transarticular screw fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 73, 972–976 (1991) 19. Hadra, B.E.: Wiring of the vertebrae as a means of immobilization in fractures and Pott’s disease. Med Times Reg 22, 423 (1891) 20. Heller, J.G., Estes, B.T., Zaouali, M., et al.: Biomechanical study of screws in the lateral masses: variables affecting pull-out resistance. J Bone Joint Surg Am 78, 1315–1321 (1996) 21. Heller, J.G., Silcox 3rd, D.H., Sutterlin 3rd, C.E.: Compli cations of posterior cervical plating. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 20, 2442–2448 (1995) 22. Heywood, A.W., Learmonth, I.D., Thomas, M.: Internal fixation for occipito-cervical fusion. J Bone Joint Surg Br 70, 708–711 (1988) 23. Hibbs, R.A.: An operation for progressive spinal deformities. NY State J Med 93, 1013–1016 (1911) 24. Jeszenszky, D., Fekete, T.F., Melcher, R., et al.: C2 prosthesis: anterior upper cervical fixation device to reconstruct the second cervical vertebra. Eur Spine J 16, 1695–1700 (2007) 25. Knoringer, P.: Osteosynthesis of injuries and rheumatic or congenital instabilities of the upper cervical spine using double-threaded screws. Neurosurg Rev 15, 275–283 (1992) 26. Leconte, P.: Fracture et luxation des deux premieres vertebres cervicales. In: Judet, R. (ed.) Luxation Congenitale de la Hanche. Fractures du Cou-de-pied Rachis Cervical. Actualites de Chirurgie Orthopedique de l’Hospital Raymond-Poincare, vol. 3, pp. 147–166. Masson et Cie, Paris (1964)
63 27. Lehmann, W., Briem, D., Blauth, M., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of anterior cervical spine locked and unlocked plate-fixation systems. Eur Spine J 14, 243–249 (2005) 28. Magerl, F., Seemann, P.S.: Stable posterior fusion of the atlas and axis by transarticular screw fixation. In: Kehr, P., Weidner, A. (eds.) Cervical spine, pp. 322–327. Springer, Wien (1987) 29. Montesano, P.X., Anderson, P.A., Schlehr, F., et al.: Odontoid fractures treated by anterior odontoid screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 16, S33–S37 (1991) 30. Penning, L., Wilmink, J.T.: Rotation of the cervical spine. A CT study in normal subjects. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, 732– 738 (1987) 31. Perren, S.M.: Physical and biological aspects of fracture healing with special reference to internal fixation. Clin Orthop Relat Res 138, 175–196 (1979) 32. Perren, S.M.: Evolution of the internal fixation of long bone fractures. The scientific basis of biological internal fixation: choosing a new balance between stability and biology. J Bone Joint Surg Br 84, 1093–1110 (2002) 33. Piper, J.G., Menezes, A.H.: Management strategies for tumors of the axis vertebra. J Neurosurg 84, 543–551 (1996) 34. Schiff, D.C., Parke, W.W.: The arterial supply of the odontoid process. J Bone Joint Surg Am 55, 1450–1456 (1973) 35. Stulik, J., Suchomel, P., Lukas, R., et al.: Primary osteosynthesis of the odontoid process: a multicenter study. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 69, 141–148 (2002) 36. Suchomel, P., Buchvald, P., Barsa, P., et al.: Single-stage total C-2 intralesional spondylectomy for chordoma with three-column reconstruction. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 6, 611–618 (2007) 37. Tuite, G.F., Papadopoulos, S.M., Sonntag, V.K.: Caspar plate fixation for the treatment of complex hangman’s fractures. Neurosurgery 30, 761–764 (1992). discussion 764-765 38. Wellman, B.J., Follett, K.A., Traynelis, V.C.: Complications of posterior articular mass plate fixation of the subaxial cervical spine in 43 consecutive patients. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 193–200 (1998) 39. Werne, S.: Studies in spontaneous atlas dislocation. Acta Orthop Scand Suppl 23, 1–150 (1957) 40. White, A.A., Panjabi, M.M.: Clinical biomechanics of the spine. Lippincot, Philadelphia (1990)
6
Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction P. Suchomel and O. Choutka
A thorough knowledge of anatomy is necessary when instrumenting the upper cervical spine. Because of the frequency of anomalies of the bone and neurovascular structures in this region, multiple diagnostic studies are usually required for a comprehensive evaluation and surgical planning. The use of simple axial CT imaging is insufficient. In the majority of cases, using CT reconstructions and MRI is essential. At times, other imaging modalities such as CT angiography or CT myelogram may be required. Generally, for a safe 3.5 mm screw purchase, the diameter of available bone surrounding the screw should exceed 5 mm if visual and/or fluoroscopic control is used [153, 232]. When using image-guided navigation, the diameter of available bone should be at least 4 mm [19]. Some authors primarily prefer the use of 4 mm screws [9, 234], and thus the available bone amount in the plane perpendicular to the axis of screw trajectory should be adapted by adding a minimum of 1 mm to the previously mentioned dimensions. If, in exceptional cases, direct real-time visualization is used (prioperative CT or isofluoroscopy), the outer diameter of the bone can be the same diameter as the screw. Some experienced surgeons will accept the core diameter of screw being
P. Suchomel Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St. 10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic O. Choutka Department of Neurosurgery, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 231 Albert Sabin Way, Cincinnati, OH 45267-0515, USA
slightly smaller than the diameter of pedicle, arch, or isthmus in the belief that the slight cortex “blow-out” is not dangerous. In our opinion, this philosophy can be accepted only if there are no other options and if the target structure has an appropriate “guiding tunnel” of cancellous bone surrounded by cortex. The other extreme possibility is to intentionally go out of the bone (e.g., out of the pedicle) when the standard purchase can endanger vitally important structures. In such a situation, one can select tri- or quadri-cortical purchase involving the spinal canal and/or extravertebral space. Despite numerous techniques of fixation described in the literature using different types of very sophisticated constructs manufactured from state-of-the-art materials, these technical developments are only supportive tools facilitating the correct environment for bony fusion and healing. The preparation of fusion surface and the use of osteoinductive and osteoconductive biomaterials are of paramount importance. Only a stringent, independent evaluation of fusion result can confirm the validity of one’s own work. Certainly, in some situations (e.g., the elderly), radiographic and functional stability without evident bony fusion can be enough. Strictly, the term “fusion” should not apply to a situation when there is lack of movement on dynamic radiographs. There should also be evidence of bony mass bridging the fused segment (best documented on CT) without any radiolucency surrounding the hardware. First, we shall describe occiput, atlas, and axis one by one as anchoring structures and then the potential fusion constructs of craniovertebral junction(CVJ) and upper cervical spine (UCS).
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_6, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
65
66
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
6.1 Occipital Bone as Anchoring Structure 6.1.1 Occipital Squama In any type of CVJ instability, the head has to be included in the stabilization construct. The occipital bone therefore is always involved and most frequently the occipital squama is used as a cranial anchor. Historically, pure onlay bone grafting was used [169] and then various wiring techniques were utilized to fix either bone strut grafts [78, 235] or polymethacrylate inlays [160] between occiput and UCS and thus stabilize the CVJ. Despite mandatory use of external supports (halo or Minerva), previous techniques often fail in the long term. The application of contoured rods, loops, and frames which are fixed to intact posterior spinal elements and doubled holes in the occiput started the semirigid era of craniovertebral fixation [183]. To increase the solidity and reliability of CVJ fixation, screws connected to plates, both locked and unlocked, were used in the early 1990s [84, 143, 199, 207]. These constructs demonstrated much higher rigidity and substantially increased the fusion rate. This decreased the necessity of rigid external fixation; however, the fixed design of the plates often dictated the position of screw to suboptimal locations. Additionally, a straight line concordant with UCS fixating points and the plated was essential. This was disadvantageous, especially when the lateral placement of screws in the thin part of occipital bone often leads to loosening or breakage. Currently, a
modular screw – rod fixating systems are available [1, 115, 178]. They provide flexibility to place occipital screws in the area of thickest bone independently of the positions of the spine screws. The majority of occipital plates have movable and multiaxial U-shaped fixating heads that enable variable positioning of the contoured rods to the cervical polyaxial screws. Such variable rigid constructs allow shorter segments of fixation preserving more motion segments. When instrumenting the occipital squama, a thorough knowledge of anatomy and any patient variation is necessary. Evaluating the bone thickness in the planned screw locations and the intracranial position of venous sinuses is paramount.
6.1.1.1 Anatomical Background The occipital squama bone thickness is the greatest at the external occipital protuberance (EOP) and decreases in a radial distribution (Fig. 1.1, Chap. 1) [55, 250] The superior nuchal line does not reflect the internal position of transverse sinus accurately; the relation of the confluence of sinuses to EOP is more consistent [189]; therefore, our screw position should be approximately 1 cm below it and not more than 2 cm, laterally. As was described in the prior chapter on anatomy, we can expect the bone thickness in the EOP to be 15 mm in males and 12 mm in females on an average (Fig. 6.1a). The other “safe area” is relatively thin strips of bone that extends caudally from the EOP and is a reflection of the internal occipital crest. The thinnest bone is directly above the cerebellar hemispheres inferior to INL (Fig. 6.1b). b
Fig. 6.1 Normal thickness of occipital bone visible on CT sagittal reconstructions documented in a male patient. (a) Midsagittal scan with bone thickness between 10–15 mm. (b) Less than 4 mm thin bone over cerebellar hemisphere in the same patient
67
6.1 Occipital Bone as Anchoring Structure
6.1.1.2 Surgical Technique Usually, the posterior midline skin incision starts 1 cm above the inion and continues splitting the nuchal ligament inferior to the desired level of cervical spine. Subperiostal dissection with or without sparing the EOP muscular attachments exposes the external anatomical landmarks, the SNL, INL, and the edge of foramen magnum. Palpating the C2 spinous process and critically, the C1 posterior tubercle helps to identify the posterior FM rim. Depending on technique chosen, the extent of occipital bone exposure is defined. In the case of in line lateral plates, which are in continuity with lateral masses of spine, more lateral dissection is required, whereas midline fixation only needs limited exposure. Reviewing the anatomical landmarks, preoperative radiographs, and CT, the holes corresponding to plate are drilled. On an average, 12 mm screw purchase in midline is safe. If lateral screw location is chosen then the necessary bone thickness for screw purchase should be at least 6 mm but preferably, 8 mm. Bicortical screw purchase is probably not necessary in occipital area. This is supported by Zipnick’s paper, which demonstrates that the outer cortex contributes 45% of total occipital bone thickness whereas the inner one is providing only 10% [250]. However, Haher et al. [90] found that bicortical pullout strength was 50% greater than unicortical. Because the strength of screw fixation is proportional to thickness of the bone, the EOP (inion) and caudal midline are ideal for screw placement [177, 189]. Whichever type of screw introduction is selected, the holes should be tapped as the bone can be very hard and the screw may break during tightening. Four to six millimeters diameter occipital screws are used to fix the plates. Although the length of screws is often established preoperatively, lateral fluoroscopy is recommended to double-check the desired length, to achieve correct perpendicular screw angle and to verify the full contact between the plate and the bone. Final tightening is done in controlled fashion with the torque wrench.
Comparing these landmarks with preoperative CT and plain X-ray, we select the appropriate position of the occipital plate on the occipital squama inferiorly to SNL. The final position of the occipital plate is also influenced by the availability of skin coverage above it. Sometimes, we have to localize the plate more caudally to avoid the potential of erosion over the plate. Holding the plate in the planned location, we mark the planned drill entry points with high speed burr or awl. Then with a chisel or high speed reamer we prepare the surface of the bone to accept the plate (eventually contoured) without any air gaps in the interface. The plate is held in the final position and the final holes are drilled with the safety stop drill guide. We always start with the deepest screw to firmly attach the plate for further drilling. If bicortical screw placement is attempted, then one has to be aware of dural and/or sinus injury. Potential sinus injury has to be treated properly. The head must not be above the level of right cardiac atrium to avoid air embolism. It is much better to err on the side of venous bleeding than a dry field that is sucking air. In such cases, the “sucking” hole must be plugged with cottonoid and flooded with water. The surgical position of the patient has to be changed immediately (Trendelenburg) and a shorter screw, away from the sinus is placed. Violation of the sinuses can cause not only bleeding but also much more dangerous venous sinus thrombosis. Simple dural penetration is frequently seen with CSF leak plugged with the screw introduction. However, such a “minor complication” can injure surface vessels of the cerebellum causing subdural or epidural hematoma. In conclusion, we can say that the best and the safest anchorage can be achieved in the midline below the EOTP and that bone thickness less than 6 mm is not sufficient for firm screw purchase. We believe that the safest approach to this procedure is ensured by precise preoperative evaluation of occipital bone by thin cut CT (Fig. 6.2).
6.1.1.3 Our Preference
6.1.2 Occipital Condyles
Radiological evaluation prior to any occipital bone screw introduction is essential to achieve firm, bicortical screw placement while avoiding the venous sinuses. We prefer to dissect the occipital bone subperiostally without any midline muscular attachment left in place and then to define the external anatomical landmarks.
In the case of thin or missing (after craniectomy) occipital bone, the occipital condyles can be used as an anchoring structure. Also, a monosegmental transarticular atlantooccipital (atlantocondylar) screw fixation can be used to fix AOD, especially if it is mild and reduced. Other indications include the
68
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
a
b
c
Fig. 6.2 Extreme midline thickness of occipital bone in another female patient. (a) Midsagittal CT reconstruction depicting more than 20 mm of available bone. (b) Perfect monocortical
screw anchorage in the same patient (“tooth-brush appearance”). (c) Axial CT reconstruction in the same patient
desire to fortify a multipoint construct involving the condyle screws and/or failed previous occipitocervical fusion. Currently, the posterior approach using either transcondylar or C1-0 transarticular screws is most frequently discussed [81, 228, 229, 245]. Nevertheless, anterior transcondylar screw purchase has also been described [52, 53]. As was depicted in the anatomy chapter, the occipital condyle is normally twice as long as it is wide and is a medially oriented structure. For practical purposes we can calculate the length as approximately 25 mm, the width around 10 mm, and the height as 10 mm. Because of its variability only CT scan can accurately show its shape, orientation, mass, and relationship to neighboring structures [165]. Since it is a part of occipital bone, cranial image guidance can be used not only to model the ideal screw trajectory, but also to directly guide the instruments. Most of the published
anatomical works show the safety of using 3.5 mm screws for transcondylar purchase [133, 229, 245].
6.1.2.1 Posterior Transarticular Atlantocondylar Screw (Fig. 6.3) Dieter Grob from Zurich was the first who published the posterior transarticular C1-0 screw fixation combined with a Y-shaped C2-occipital plate in a patient with a failed previous wire fixation of AOD [81]. Gonzalez et al. [75] studied the feasibility of C1-0 transarticular screws on cadaveric model. They found that for atlanto-occipital screw fixation the same stiffness as occipitocervical constructs in all directions, with the exception of flexion-extension. Their recommendation was to supplement this technique with a posterior buttress. Similarly to Magerl’s technique it
6.1 Occipital Bone as Anchoring Structure
Fig. 6.3 Schematic drawing of posterior atlantocondylar screw fixation
can be strengthened by a Gallie type of graft [75]. The same group of authors later published a report of a patient with AOD treated using this method [60] and also in two cases of posttraumatic instability where they performed a combined double level transarticular procedure (C1-0 and C2-1), simultaneously [76]. Yan et al. in their works first defined the ideal entry point for atlantocondylar fixation and then analyzed 20 dry specimens and CT reconstructions of 30 healthy volunteers. They also conducted a simulation surgery on another 12 fresh cadavers to establish the safety angle ranges and length of screws [245, 246]. As a safe angle of introduction, they established 53.3° (SD = 3.4°) in sagittal plane and the medial inclination 20° (SD=2.6°) in the axial plane. The appropriate length of transarticular C1-0 screw was between 24 and 34 mm. However, always, one has to consider the individual patient specific anatomy as well as the possible discrepancy in such values obtained in, generally, smaller South-Eastern Chinese population.
69
anatomical works by Uribe et al. [229] and LaMarca et al. [133]. The position of vertebral artery (VA) in the C1 arch posterior groove does not usually affect the condyle screw purchase as it is most frequently located more caudally [133]. From an anatomical point of view, the natural borders for screw placement are as follows: rostrally, the hypoglossal canal; rostrolaterally, the emissary vein; caudally, the occipitoatlantal joint; and medially, the foramen magnum. The condylar emissary vein can be of importance as a major drainage vein in cases of jugular bulb occlusion (tumors) or in congenital anomalies but it can be sacrificed under normal conditions [13, 28]. LaMarca et al. [133] described the ideal transcondylar screw trajectory after analyzing thin sliced CT in a 3D navigational station. They found that it was feasible to achieve safe screw purchase in all the 12 cadaveric condyles studied with a safety rim of bone surrounding the screw larger than 1.5 mm in all cases. The average SAS on the posterior condylar wall was 5–8 mm rostrocaudally and 5–9 mm mediolaterally. Uribe et al. [229] studying the feasibility of transcondylar screw purchase on six silicone injected cadaver heads determined the condylar entry point (CEP) to be 4–5 mm laterally from posteromedial edge of the condyle, anatomically defined as approximately 1–2 mm above the joint fissure. The base of condyle (connection to occipital bone) was used. The pilot hole was made by an awl and the trajectory of drill was 5°
6.1.2.2 Posterior Transcondylar Screw (Fig. 6.4) The idea to use the transcondylar screw purchase as a new point of fixation was described independently in
Fig. 6.4 Schematic drawing of posterior transcondylar screw purchase
70
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
upward and tilted 17° (12°–22°), medially. They used 30–32 mm long screws where the unthreaded shaft 11–13 mm long was protruding above the bone to enable the polyaxial screw head movement. They attempted bicortical screw purchase and combined anatomical guidance with fluoroscopy. All 12 operated condyles were assessed by CT afterwards. Not one screw violated the hypoglossal foramen or other important structures. The screw length inside the bone was, on an average, 22 mm (20–24 mm) and the C1 arch overhang (smooth shaft) 12 mm (11–13 mm). This suggested technique of transcondylar screw placement as a part of longer caudal construct was later successfully used in patients with odontoid type II fracture pseudoarthrosis and cranial settling [228]. Despite the fact that bicortical screw placement is stronger than unicortical, we have to be aware of the potential injury of structures located anteriorly to the condyles. Most commonly, it is the pharyngeal wall but variant carotid arteries can be anterior as well. There are some advantages of posterior condyle screw purchase. Using a polyaxial screw, the contoured rod connecting the occipital plate is not necessary and thus the risk of eventual stress rod fracture can be avoided. Also, the construct connecting the occipital bone with the UCS or subaxial spine is of low profile, and therefore, the muscular damage necessary for occipital plate placement can be decreased as well as the risk of plate erosion.
6.1.2.3 Anterior Transarticular Axial-Atlantocondylar Screw (Fig. 6.5) The original idea to fix the occipital condyle from an anterior approach similar to the technique of anterior atlantoaxial fixation came from Dvorak et al. [52, 53]. They suggested this method as a salvage procedure for those unique situations where posterior fixation is not possible, failed, or has to be fortified. Also, in some very rare situations such as after total tumor removal or in complex reconstruction due to congenital anomalies, these ideas can be utilized. The first part of their work was an anatomical study documented by a successfully treated patient with failed posterior wire and graft fusion after repetitive trauma. The second part was a biomechanical comparison of anterior fixation with posterior methods. They confirmed the superior strength of posterior transarticular
Fig. 6.5 Artistic drawing of anterior C2-C1- occipital condyle screw fixation
screw connected to suboccipital plate for all directions; however, they found comparable stability of their anterior fixation in rotation and lateral bending. Both screw methods were much more stable than posterior graft and wiring alone. They have suggested approaching the anterior surface of C2 the same way as for an odontoid screw (high oblique anterolateral approach), to identify the groove below the middle third of atlantoaxial joint and introduce the K-wires tilted 25° posteriorly and 15° laterally under biplanar fluoroscopical control. Then cannulated self-tapping screws 24–30 mm long were introduced along the wire. From the anatomical and CT studies, they concluded that the angle of introduction can vary substantially (posterior angle 15°–36°, lateral tilt 10°–20°). As a major limitation, they cite the course and volume of hypoglossal canal and the impossibility to add graft material or to abrade the joint surface to enable long-term bony fusion.
6.1.2.4 Our Preference The occipital condyle has been confirmed as a solid structure for screw anchorage. However, it has also been found that the variability of VA course and location of n.XII canal within the condyle can exclude the possibility of safe screw placement in as many as 17% of the specimens studied [52, 53]. Also, in basilar impression
71
6.2 Atlas as an Anchoring Structure
and other compound CVJ congenital anomalies, it could be unsafe or even impossible to expose the occipital condyle. Although case reports describing the successful use of either posterior transcondylar [228] and posterior atlanto-occipital transarticular screw fixation [76, 81] or anterior transarticular C1-0 screw placement [52] were reported, no large series of patients treated with condylar screw placement has been published. In our opinion, the use of the condyle as a part of construct can be more reasonable than transfixation of occipitoatlantal joint without support of bone grafting. Given the technical and anatomical difficulties, although these methods are feasible, they will likely have a limited role mainly as salvage procedures.
the length of the whole clivus is 4.5 cm (3.7–5.2) in the sagittal plane and the basilar portion of occipital bone is 3.1 cm (SD = 0.3). In occipital hypoplasia, the basilar portion may be only 1.7 cm long [134]. The thickest portion is anterior and superior and contains the cancellous bone. The thinner part is formed only by compact bone in the region of foramen magnum. Usually, the outer cortex is more solid and thicker than the inner one. For practical purposes, we can calculate that the wedge-shaped clivus is only 4 mm thick and safely reachable 10 mm on both sides from midline at the level of FM. It gradually increasing in thickness to a maximum of 22 mm at the level of pituitary fossa with a safe strip of bone 10 mm from midline along its entire course. The caudal half of the clivus can be safely resected if necessary or can serve as a screw anchorage or cage support (Fig. 6.6).
6.1.3 Clivus The upper part of the clivus belongs to sphenoid bone whereas the lower part is a basilar portion of the occipital bone. These two parts are separated by spheno-occipital synchondrosis till the age 16.5 (13–18) in males and 14.4 (12–15) in females. This represents the growing potential in correct formation of skull. In normal adults, a
6.2 Atlas as an Anchoring Structure C1 has no vertebral body, and therefore, its bone stock has a limited volume for any screw anchorage; nevertheless, the lateral masses are frequently used for screw b
Fig. 6.6 Two screws 12 mm long introduced in to the anterior lover clivus under image guidance. (a) Midsagittal CT reconstruction showing appropriate screw length. (b) Coronal plane CT reconstruction
72
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
purchase, either from anterior or posterior approach. Additionally, C1 lateral mass and laminar screws are described in the literature. To reach desired lateral mass posterior and/or anterior screw entry points, the arch is the anatomical guiding structure. When performing posterior approach, the dissection of C1 arch should stay strictly subperiostally starting from the clearly distinguishable posterior tubercle. Ebraheim recommended [57] not to extend this dissection more than 12 mm lateral from midline and be aware 8 mm from midline on superior arch. However, it is our experience that following the lower edge of arch where we do not expect any important neurovascular structures, safe microdissection is possible even to the transverse process. The inferior half of the C1 lateral masses can be exposed subperiostally under the thinnest part of posterior arch with care taken not to injure the C2 root, ganglion, and surrounding venous plexuses. Preoperative evaluation of individual VA course is critical. Careful observation of axial CT scans can show different C1 anomalies leading us eventually to further diagnostic modalities (CTA). The anterior approach to the atlas is limited to transoral exposure and/or high anterolateral access and again for any anterior approach the most important guiding point is the anterior tubercle of atlas. It is most often visible on lateral fluoroscopy, it is not surrounded by any danger and clearly localizes the midline, and thus distances to vertebral arteries and spinal cord. We have to be aware of possible slight rotation, nevertheless, the safety defined by anterior tubercle is always valid.
6.2.1 Posterior Lateral Massa Screw Fixation of the lateral mass of atlas with posteriorly placed screws was first described by Atul Goel from Mumbai, India in 1994 (first surgery 1988) as a part of C1-2 plate construct where the inferior screws were placed into the C2 pedicle [72]. This technique was later popularized by Jürgen Harms from Karlsbad, Germany who developed a more adaptable polyaxial screw rod system allowing preservation of the C2 nerve root and enabling manipulation with atlas particularly in fractures and dislocations [94]. Both authors used the middle posterior part of the C1 lateral mass below the arch as the entry point. Harms recommended reaching this area subperiostally and to make
a pilot hole in the middle of mass-arch base and thus avoid bleeding from the venous plexuses surrounding the C2 root. A straight or slightly convergent anteroposterior drilling trajectory parallel to the plane of the C1 posterior arch was advised. The screws were introduced bicortically. Goel described the entry point as the middle of the available bone area but introduced the screws monocortically, initially. In his later works, he conceded using bicortical purchase and an entry point localized in the lower facet joint surface if not enough bone is available in the posteroinferior C1 pillar, especially in children [70]. Other authors [148, 186] under influence of anatomical [225] and biomechanical works [148] suggested penetrating directly through the surface of the posterior arch just above the previously described entry point as another possibility of how to avoid bleeding, not irritate the C2 root, and prolong the screw pathway in order to increase the pullout strength. Such a strong posterior lateral mass screw anchor can also potentially limit previously necessary long occipitocervical constructs to occipitoatlantal or atlantocervical and thus avoid unnecessary fusion of adjacent segments. The originally suggested midline trajectory was criticized by Blagg et al. [18] because of possible injury of the VA in the transverse foramen. They recommend to start more medially, drill straight anteriorly or in medial angle up to 20° and never tilt laterally during the procedure, but they concur with the original concept of following the posterior arch attachment angle in sagittal plane. Because of possible injury of structures situated in front of atlas (n.XII and ICA) another screw entry and trajectory was described by Rocha et al. [191].
6.2.1.1 Anatomical Background The space available for 3.5–4.5 mm lateral mass screw (SAS) introduction had been repeatedly studied on anatomical specimen and CT images [30, 191, 233, 241]. The posterior inferior pillar of the C1 lateral mass is bordered superiorly by the arch and inferiorly by the joint as measured by Blagg et al. [18] on 50 CT scans. They established the height of available space to be 4.6 mm (0–7 mm) and the width to be 14.9 mm (11–18 mm). Rocha et al. measured the same parameters on 20 dried atlantal specimens. They gauged electronically the mean working space height as 4.5 mm (range 4.3–6.1 mm)
73
6.2 Atlas as an Anchoring Structure
and the mean width as 9.6 mm (range 7.7–12.8 mm). To reach the aforementioned height they had to cut out the posterior arch lip in 50% of the studied specimens and they concluded that 93% of studied vertebras are able to accept screws with 4.5 mm diameter [191]. Wang analyzed 74 dried cadaveric spines and found a mean height of 3.9 mm and a width of 7.3 mm of the space for possible lateral mass screw entry [233]. All specimens could accommodate 3.5 mm screws and 97% could accept 4mm diameter screws. In 65% of cases, it was necessary to remove at least a part of the posterior arch overhang to be able to insert a 4mm screw. The possible introductory angle for safe bicortical purchase varied according to the position of entry point from 13° laterally to 45° medially. Cranial angulation without violation of C0/1 joint was acceptable until 19°. Because this technique can be very advantageous in fixation of the pediatric spine, Chamoun et al. [29] has performed a CT morphometric analysis of 76 atlases in children between 1.5–16 years old (mean 7.8 years) and found that only in one case of a 19-month-old infant one of the lateral masses was not of sufficient size to accept 3.5 mm screw. When performing the posterior approach to the atlas surgeon can find different anomalies of the VA course. Up to 15.6% of patients have a partial or total covering (arcuate foramen) of the VA artery in the groove of C1 by the “ponticulus posticus”. (Fig. 1.3, Chap. 1) [31, 104]. Lee et al. in their anatomical work analyzing 709 C1 cadaveric vertebrae found the appearance of ponticuli significantly more frequent in males (15.9%) vs. females (8.1%) [138]. Erroneous evaluation of a “too broad” a lamina can lead to VA injury [249] during arch subperiostal preparation or translaminar screw introduction. There are also anomalies of the course of the horizontal (V3) segment of the VA in 5.4% of the normal healthy population [104] and in 13% of the group of patients selected for CVJ surgery [244]. The most important and dangerous variant is the persistent first intersegmental artery. This aberrant vessel partially or totally substitutes the VA and courses below the posterior atlantal arch and thus prohibits the subarcuate approach to posterior lateral mass screw entry area. In a very large series of 1,013 patients with CT vertebral angiography, Hong found persistent first intersegmental artery on one side in 3.8% and bilaterally in 0.8% [104]. Structures adjacent to the anterior surface of lateral mass represent another risk during bicortical penetration
of drill, tap, or screw. The lumen of the internal carotid artery (ICA) is located medially to FT in more than 80% of cases. The mean distance of the ICA medial border measured from the medial border of FT is 2.78 mm on the left side and 3 mm on the right [37]. The average distance of ICA from anterior lateral mass aspect is less than 3 mm on both sides (left, 2.88 mm; right, 2.89 mm). Rotation of head due to positioning of the patient probably has no effect on any change of ICA position [38]. This close relationship can potentially be dangerous during placement of lateral mass screws, C1/2 transarticular, and/or C2 transpedicular fixation if bicortical purchase is chosen. Such a carotid artery impingement has been described after transarticular fusion [38]. The risk of ICA injury during drilling or tapping or lateral injury due to the screw contact and gradual ICA wall erosion was considered by Currier et al. as high, if the artery was more than 4 mm medial to the medial edge of FT and less than 2 mm from anterior bone surface. In moderate risk are those with the artery less than 2 mm from FT and within 2–4 mm from anterior C1 wall. They found that there was no risk when the ICA is laterally from transverse foramen and more than 6 mm away from the anterior mass aspect [37]. Currier, in his series of 50 atlases analyzed by CT with contrast, found that 12% of patients were at high risk and another 46% at moderate risk of ICA impingement at least on one side. Additionally, the position of the hypoglossal nerve in front of lateral C1 mass is of importance because of possible injury during bicortical screw purchase as described by Hong [103] and Jeanneret [116]. This could be a cause of some reports of swallowing difficulties after purely posterior procedures [86, 151]. The CN XII exits the skull via hypoglossal foramen at the base of occipital condyle with a diameter of 2–3 mm. It lies 2–3 mm laterally from the middle of the mass and courses vertically to the C1/2 joint [56].
6.2.1.2 Surgical Technique In a standard technique first described by Goel [72] and later by Harms [94] the middle subarcuate portion of the posterior lateral mass was used as a screw entry point. Goel, who performed his first procedure in 1988 in order to avoid venous bleeding from plexuses accompanying the second nerve root, and to explore widely the C1-2 joint, always cut out the C2 root with
74
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
its surroundings. This allowed to him to open the joint, distract, or manipulate the joint in C1/2 dislocations and also put bone graft or cages in between the roughened joint surfaces. Such a wide exposure enabled him also to adapt a short plate directly onto the bone. The price for this procedure was the denervation of C2 area which can be sometimes not well accepted by the patients [73, 88]. In order to avoid this “non physiological” dissection and to make the technique more versatile, Harms developed the polyaxial screw-rod modular system and introduced the screws at the midline base of posterior C1 arch. Later, the “transpedicular technique” was developed [186, 225] where the screw is introduced through the posterior arch of atlas straight forward in the lateral mass midplane. Unfortunately, this anatomical term “C1 pedicle” or “C1 pseudopedicle” or “C1 pedicle analog” incorrectly naming the posterior arch of atlas (as the atlas has no pedicles) has gained wider acceptance [30, 31, 148]. Initially, the methods of C1 lateral mass fixation [94, 152] were described with bicortical screw purchase. Currently, there is discussion if that is necessary. Cyr et al. described no statistically significant difference in pullout strength between bicortically or monocortically introduced C1/2 transarticular screw [40]. Eck et al. found that significantly much larger force is necessary to pull out the lateral mass screws if bicortically introduced [58]. Advocates of so called “transpedicular” C1 screws argue from biomechanical work of Ma [148] demonstrating that posterior arch monocortical screws present larger pullout force than bicortically placed screws through the lateral mass in standard fashion. Nevertheless, in all the referenced studies, the pullout strength for standard monocortical screws was much larger than previously reported acceptable values for subaxial spine [119, 126] thus giving rational for surgeon’s preference to choose monocortical introduction whichever entry point is used. Certainly, bone mineral density, presence of background disease (inflammatory bone destruction -RA, pure bone quality in bone diseases or osteoporosis), and surgeon’s feeling of bone solidity play important roles in the decision if opposite cortex penetration can increase the stability of the construct. Some of the advocates of “transpedicular” method accept that 5 mm height of the arch above lateral mass and below VA is enough to accept 3.5 mm screw [30, 138]. Lee, in his series of 709 measured cadaveric atlases, found the average thickness 3.95 mm at the side
of VA groove. He stated that only 6.9% of female and 17.4% male specimens can safely receive the 3, 5 mm “transpedicular screw” and suggested as an alternative the notching technique where the inferior part of arch is drilled with 2 mm burr making a notch in which the screw shaft can be placed. Nevertheless, even this technique was not possible in 26.7% of females and 8.3% of males because the bony area of the atlas arch was less than 3 mm thick [138]. Christensen et al. analyzing 240 lateral masses of cadaveric C1 vertebrae accepted the smallest height of 4 mm and found that in19% of cases there was not enough space available for 3.5 mm screw placement [31]. In other studies [102, 148, 225], the larger portion of studied C1 posterior arches was able to accommodate screw placement and 4 mm arch thickness was considered enough to accept 3.5 mm diameter screws. This is debatable in our opinion because one can hardly imagine this without breaching the cortex in practical application. Other complications can include arch fracture and/or VA injury because of its atypical location [14] or during taping of thin arch bone [8].
6.2.1.3 Our Preference In our opinion, thin sliced CT, with 3D image reconstructions is essential for planning of C1 lateral mass placement. As in other pathologies of UCS we always procure MRI imaging as well. This can help to exclude vascular anomalies and localize the position of VA in relation to C1, as well as the ICA position anterior to the lateral masses (Fig. 6.7). The surgeon could also review if the ipsilateral FT is small or even absent on standard axial scans. If any suspicion of anomalous VA or ICA course arises from previous imaging, MRA, or CTA should be performed to elucidate its course (Fig. 6.8). With all images reviewed and analyzed the longest safe bicortical screw trajectory is planned. Based on anatomical studies, a quadratic area of 5 × 5 mm should be available in the majority of cases but in about 50% of patients the posterior arch lip overhang has to be removed to reach this working space (Fig. 6.9). Normally, the lip is resected with Kerrison rongeur or high speed drill. If the bone overhang is not removed, the subperiostal cleavage plane can be lost and the soft tissue can be violated. The amount of bleeding from injured venous plexuses surrounding the C2 root can be very serious. The elevation of the operative field can help but often we have to use haemostatic sealants and
75
6.2 Atlas as an Anchoring Structure
a
Fig. 6.7 Normal position of both carotid arteries shown on axial CT and MRI. (a) Axial CT scan after contrast media application. Notice the atypical loop of left V3 segment, VA hypoplasia on
a
b
the right side and the position of both carotid arteries. (b) Transversal MRI in case of AA subluxation with clearly seen position of both carotid arteries in front of atlas
b
Fig. 6.8 Course of arteries as shown on 3D CTA in two different patients. (a) Normal position of both carotid arteries, hypoplastic left VA. (b) Abnormal coiling of right and kinking of left ACI just in front of C1 lateral mass
temporary cottonoid pressure. If these methods do not help then we have to coagulate and/or ligate and transect the whole C2 neurovascular bundle. Once in the past we had a case of massive arterial bleeding during subperiostal approach to the subarcuate
lateral mass on the left side. Compressive packing together with a fibrin glue helped us to stop it and solve a very difficult situation. In spite of no pathological vascularization visible on postoperative angiograms, with our current knowledge we hypothesize that it could be
76
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Fig. 6.9 Overhang of posterior arch impeding direct approach to the posterior inferior lateral mass screw entry area
persistent first intersegmental artery. This experience supports our previously mentioned complex preoperative investigation protocol. Theoretically, the previously described difficulties can be avoided if the screw is introduced directly through the arch. However, from daily practice, we know that the so called “transpedicular” drilling through the posterior arch of atlas can be very difficult. Even if an entry hole is prepared with a high speed burr, the drill can easily slip up or down and injure the
VA or C2 root bundle. It is also very complicated to hold the proper trajectory if the arch is less than 5 mm wide. In general, we feel that this technique and its modifications as a more risky option and we reserve the notching technique for specific anatomical situations. We prefer to locate the entry point in the middle of the posterior lateral mass at the top of the arcuate surface, which is palpable by a blunt probe in the base of posterior arch attachment or below it. To know the exact position of medial and lateral mass pillar borders, the thin Penfield probe is used to palpate it directly. Sometimes, the joint fissure can be visible but mostly this is unnecessary. The joint cleft can be frequently visible on lateral fluoroscopy. It is advantageous to make a small entry pilot hole with a high speed drill or awl to avoid dislocation of the drill in the beginning of pilot hole drilling. The C2 neurovascular bundle has to be covered and slightly caudally dislocated during all the work. A special set of instrument guides protecting the C2 bundle from direct contact of drill, tap, screw, etc. can be used as another option. If parallel to the posterior arch the introductory angle of the entry point should be at least 3 mm cranially from C1/2 joint for a safe 3.5–4.0 mm screw placement. Upward trajectory has to be used if the available posterior vertical working distance is smaller than normal. Using cranial trajectory inclination we have to take care not to encroach the C0-1 joint (Fig. 6.10). Most often, we use a trajectory of 10°–15° medial and 10°–15° cranial with active lateral fluoroscopy directing drilling (Fig. 6.11). Considering the
Fig. 6.10 (a) Parasagittal CT reconstructed image showing the vicinity of C1 lateral mass screw to the atlantooccipital joint, (b) coronal plane reconstruction
6.2 Atlas as an Anchoring Structure
77
a
b
Fig. 6.12 Axial CT scan of correctly bicortically introduced C1 posterior lateral mass screw
Fig. 6.11 Schematic drawing of C1 lateral mass posterior screw trajectory: The screw has partially smooth shank. (a) Screw is introduced in medial angle between 10°–15°. (b) Trajectory is tilted cranially in angle 10°–15°.
dominance of the left hemisphere in right-handed people, the author always prefers to put any hardware jeopardizing the left side vessels, last. The length of screw trajectory is defined by the position of the entry point and angle of introduction. Because of ovoid shape of the lateral mass and its medial tilt in transverse plane, (more pronounced in upper facets than in the lower) we can expect that the screw thread length will not correspond with the anatomical length of the lower facet pillar. Using the depth gauge helps us confirm or correct our measurements. The aim is to fully accommodate the screw thread within the bone of lateral mass and to have a smooth contact with C2 root, ganglion, and surrounding veins. Therefore, smooth shank screws with different thread versus shank ratio are used (often 60:40). The polyaxial screw head has to be located freely behind the posterior atlantal arch to enable its multidirectional movement and connection rod attachment. Most frequently we use 4 mm smooth shank screws 30–38 mm long. The final screw positioning is again always checked by lateral fluoroscopy. We prefer bicortical screw purchase because the pullout force is higher than in monocortical placement (Figs. 6.12. and 6.13). However, in our opinion, not
Fig. 6.13 Screw penetration of anterior C1 lateral mass shown on 3D CT
only pullout force is important; especially, in longer constructs, the vertical, horizontal, and rotational stabilities of the screw play an important role. As a simplified example, we will use a rod and brick analogy. The rod is introduced in a predrilled hole of a slightly larger diameter in a wall made from hollow bricks. The resistance is weak if only placed into the hollow portion of the brick; however, its side load resistance can be much improved when the opposite brick wall is drilled and the rod is “bicortically introduced” even though the effect on pullout effect may be negligible. The bicortical screw tip should not overrun the anterior mass surface more than one thread.
78
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Fig. 6.14 Artist’s drawing of anterior C1/2 transarticular screw fixation according to Lesoin
The slightly medial trajectory and preoperative image analysis helps us avoid ICA and hypoglossal nerve injury.
6.2.2 Anterior C1 Lateral Mass Screw The screws are placed in the C1 lateral mass anteriorly in two modalities. First, the transarticular anterior screw fixation serves as a monosegmental C1-2 fixation. This can be eventually extended to fix the occipital condyle as well [52, 53]. The other possibility is using horizontal mass transfixation as anchorage for screws fixating either plates or mesh cages. The anterior lateral mass of the atlas was first used as anchoring structure by Lesoin et al. [141] who performed C1-2 anterior transarticular fusion in six patients (Fig. 6.14). Later, this technique was advocated by others in the case of C1-2 instability secondarily to odontoid fractures [11]. Koller et al. has suggested a different trajectory for the same purpose (Fig. 6.15) [131]. The horizontal trajectories are preferred in the case of C1 lateral mass cranial fixation of plates and mesh cages after odontoidectomy or other anterior decompressions [95, 118, 197]. Similarly, the plate used either for reduction and fixation of isolated atlas fractures [21, 195] or atlas split in deformity [108], can be fixed to the lateral C1 masses with horizontally introduced screws (Fig. 6.16).
Fig. 6.15 Schematic drawing of different trajectory suggested by Koller et al. for anterior AA screw fixation. The screw entry point is localized at the base of anterior C2 body
6.2.2.1 Anatomical Background For proper atlantoaxial transarticular screw purchase, high anterolateral or oblique approaches are used preferentially; however, when planning horizontal screws, transoral exposure is necessary. The anatomical guidance and surgical technique for transarticular screw placement is described elsewhere in this text. The surgical anterior surface of lateral mass can be fully exposed only transorally. From anatomical works of Kandziora et al. [123] and Ai et al. [3] we can find that the maximal safe lateral exposure of anterior lateral mass is 20 mm laterally from the midline. The VA is located another 5 mm far laterally. The anterior lateral mass is trapezoid in shape having mediolaterally an average length of 15 mm. Its medial height is 9 mm and lateral one 22 mm. When calculating the screw diameter of 3.5 mm, Kandziora found a safe trapezoid zone 13.3 mm long (respecting the shape of anterior surface) with a medial height of 4.1 mm and lateral 12.9 mm. This, in fact, means that the screw entry point should be located in the middle of lateral mass. The trajectory angle of drilling should respect the lateral mass’ outward inclination. This angle was established as 20° by Kandziora et al. [123] and 12° by Ai et al. [3].
79
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
plate techniques. This may prove to be especially helpful if the plate is stable enough and gives us the opportunity to reduce kyphosis and allows avoidance of a second posterior stage surgery. Use of this technique is also applicable in anterior constructs in tumor surgery.
6.2.3 Posterior Arch of Atlas Intralaminar Screw
Fig. 6.16 Schematic drawing of anterior plate fixed to C1 by horizontal screw
6.2.2.2 Surgical Technique The anterior surface of the C1 lateral mass is exposed transorally. The atlantoaxial joint can be identified easily at its caudal border. Often difficult but possible is to palpate the cranial atlantooccipital joint. Often the anterior arch of atlas is resected, thus giving us information about the medial mass wall. The most dangerous aspect is to establish the lateral boundaries because of the vicinity of the VA. Despite the knowledge that the VA should be at least 25 mm away from midline, we have to analyze each case especially if the midline (tubercle of C1) is missing or resected. The best choice is to analyze the preoperative CTA when available; however, meticulous subperiostal microtechnique is mandatory in every case. The entry point is located in the middle of lateral mass and the drill passes in a lateral angle of 12°–20°, respecting laterally the midportion of the C1 mass on lateral fluoroscopy. We never drill bicortically because the VA located in VA groove posteriorly can be injured. Usually, the pilot hole is tapped and 3.5 mm screw monocortically introduced.
This type of screw anchorage was first used by Floyd and Grob [63] to transfix the bone graft in the cases of congenital or iatrogenic posterior arch deficiency when the sublaminar wire could not be used. They used this technique in five patients. First, the edge of arch remnant was osteotomized and then carefully drilled and tapped to approximately 10–15 mm depth along its course. The autologous rectangular unicortical graft harvested from iliac crest was transfixed by 2.7 mm screw, wedged between both C1 arch stumps and the decorticated C2 spinous process. Later, similar technique using 3.5 mm screws was recommended by Donnellan et al. [48] as part of C1-2 fixation constructs. They began the procedure with a wide posterior midline arch opening to expose the medullary core and then drilled and tapped the cavity. The screws were introduced laterally enough to minimize overlap of the polyaxial screw heads.
6.2.3.1 Our Preference From a practical standpoint, we can conclude that this technique can help in rather rare situations where the C1 lateral mass screws cannot be used and we would like to avoid the extension of the fixation to the occiput. Especially in cases of concomitant posterior arch congenital deficiency and surgical posterior arch damage, intralaminar C1 screw can be a valuable choice. The anatomical position of the VA, thinning of the proximal part of posterior arch by its groove, and possible anatomical variation have to be encountered in our surgical consideration.
6.2.2.3 Our Preference
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
Our experience with anterior fixation involving the C1 lateral mass is limited; nevertheless, we suppose that there is a place for further development of the anterior
The second cervical vertebra can be approached from all the sides. Currently, most frequently, it is exposed from posterior midline or anterior high lateral
80
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
approaches. Less often is transoral access performed and rarely used is lateral dissection. Screws placed only in the C2 vertebra are used to surgically treat some types of trauma, but more often the screws introduced into the C2 vertebra serve as a part of a longer construct. Transarticular C1-2 screws can be used as a standalone fixation to stabilize the atlantoaxial complex, but nearly all the screws introduced to C2 vertebra can be attached to longer fusion systems involving the occiput, C1, and/or the subaxial cervical spine. Their safe introduction and firm anchorage is therefore very important.
6.3.1 Pedicle Screw First of all, it is necessary to emphasize that the true anatomical pedicle is the connection between the C2 vertebral body and the posterior elements. This strong and very short structure leaves the body almost in the frontal plane (Fig. 1.4, Chap. 1). Therefore, the so called “transpedicular” screws are due to unique C2 anatomy frequently introduced not directly through the pedicle or the pedicle axis as in subaxial cervical spine but passes the true anatomical pedicle obliquely and often only partially. In fact, during modeling of the ideal trajectory on 3D navigational software, sometimes it is questionable if the screw pathway is more transisthmic or transpedicular and the final reached medial angle could be very different from those described in anatomical papers. When reading papers about C2 transpedicular screws one has to be aware because most of the authors are incorrectly labeling the pars interarticularis as “pedicle” or “pseudo-pedicle.” Robert Judet in France was the first surgeon who introduced the C2 transpedicular screw on September 19, 1962 (Ch. Mazel, personal communication). The first published description of the use of C2 transpedicular screw came from Leconte in a book about cervical spine injuries edited by Judet [137]. Judet used this technique to perform direct osteosynthesis of hangman type fractures. Unfortunately, this logical approach did not attract attention until Borne et al. [22] published a larger series on patients treated this way, 20 years later. Axis transpedicular anchorage, as a part of larger construct, was first mentioned by Roy-Camille who published a series of treated patients with C2-related
instability [192, 194]. Nowadays, this method is used not only for compressive osteosynthesis of C2 ring fractures [130, 136, 144, 218, 219, 224, 231] but especially as a part of short [14, 72, 94, 215] and long constructs [5, 201] where the C2 transpedicular screw is usually considered as the most solid anchorage. This philosophy was supported by Dmitriev et al. [47] who biomechanically tested 14 cadaveric specimens and found the largest insertional torque while introducing the screws into C2 pedicle when compared to other types of C2 screws. Also, the postfatigue pull-out strength was significantly larger than in other techniques. Although it is rarely reported up to now [5, 70], the main drawback of C2 transpedicular screw is potential arterial and/or neural injury. An often used argument that the transpedicular trajectory is less dangerous than transisthmic used in transarticular method [70, 94] is not correct in our opinion.
6.3.1.1 Anatomical Background Gupta and Goel [89] analyzing 100 cadaveric dissections recommended to introduce the screws into C2 pedicle in its upper-third with sharp medial inclination targeted to the anterior spinal midline (or anterior C1 tubercle) because the VA groove can occupy up to two-thirds of C2 lateral mass in 15% of patients. Analyzing the surgical pitfalls in his series of 160 patients, Goel [70] described 4 VA injuries during C2 pedicle drilling. Resnick et al. [186] modeling of the ideal screw trajectories on 3D and 2D thin sliced CT reformatted images found the same risk for transpedicular as for transarticular screw trajectories. More than 90% of sides of investigated vertebras offered more than 4 mm space for eventual screw purchase. They idealized the trajectory of “transpedicular” screws to nearly parasagittal angle of introduction; therefore, we suppose that the more correct final statement should be that the risk of VA injury is the same for long transisthmic screw as for transarticular screw. Yoshida et al. [248] very correctly argued that the transisthmic screw is passing above the VA lateral bending inside FT while the transpedicular screw is crossing the bone medially or superomedially to the course of VA. Such a difference hardly can be discovered and compared on 2D images. They have analyzed 3D CT images of 62 patients. The ideal trajectory was modeled in a computer navigational station. They measured the mean
81
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
space available for transarticular screw as 6.2 mm (SD = 1.4) and for transpedicular screw 6.1 mm (SD = 1.4) on 124 vertebral sides. These values did not differ significantly but they found significantly lesser maximal values for female vertebrae. The authors defined the space available for screw less than 4 mm as risky and less than 3 mm as unacceptable. In the groups of limited available space they determined if the most limiting factor was the height or width of available bone. They described 9.7% of transpedicular and 11.3% of transarticular trajectories as risky. Non acceptable bone space for transpedicular screw was found in 4% and for transarticular in another 3.2% of sides tested, respectively. The differences were not statistically significant, but often the screw trajectory judged as risky for one technique was risky for the other one also. In transarticular risky group the height of available bone was the limiting factor in 57.1 % of cases and the width in another 42.9%, whereas in the transpedicular risky group the only limit was the width of C2 pedicle in the place of VA groove. This work is the first available correctly stating that the anatomical risk of VA injury for transpedicular and/or transarticular screw purchase is on the same level. Data obtained from this paper also confirmed that for evaluation of risky situations the 3D modeling should be performed for transarticular trajectory; however, for planned transpedicular screw purchase, the axial CT could give us enough information. Measurements of Yoshida et al. were confirmed by Moftakhar et al. [162] who measured not only the bony space available for the screws but also the distance between the bone and the lumen of VA. They analyzed computer tomographic angiograms (CTA) of 106 patients and found 6.4 mm (range 2.09–13.20 mm) of osseous space available for screw at the VA groove level of C2 pedicle. The isthmus thickness was measured on an average as 5.62 mm (range 2.08–11.00 mm). The distance between the bone and the VA was interestingly more than 1.18 mm on an average in all measurements. However, one has to evaluate this value individually and patient specifically because of great variability, the range was from 0 to 4.94 mm and the distance was measured to intraluminal contrast media without calculation of the arterial wall thickness. They also did not find any correlation between VA groove/foramen size and diameter of VA. Several other anatomical studies were conducted to establish the guidelines for pedicle C2 screw placement
[55, 107, 243]. Although they studied the isthmus rather than the pedicle, they correctly measured the angles of possible screw trajectory. Xu et al. [243] stated that the average angles for a pedicle screw are 33° medially and 20°, rostrocaudally. They also estimated the possible entry point location and created a placement algorithm. However, the same group, while strictly respecting their guidelines, found an unacceptably high rate of cortical breach in their later study [55]. Standardized algorithmic approaches usually fail in C2 pedicle screw placement due to a great anatomical variability and also due to a number of possible screw trajectories. Therefore, Howington et al. [107] repeated the anatomical test on ten cadavers respecting the trajectory given by the surgical visualization of the pedicle. All their screws were correctly placed without cortical breach. The established medial inclination was on an average 35.2° and craniocaudal angle 38.8°. The notable, almost double, difference in craniocaudal angle measurements could be explained by the methodological variance in obtaining of their values. Xu et al. [243] used the line perpendicular to the axis of odontoid process as a reference whereas Howington et al. [107] used the plane of C2 body endplate. Although some discrepancies could be found in pure anatomical works, Sciubba et al. [201] confirmed clinically the prerequisite of Howington et al. in a large (single surgeon J.P. Wolinski) series of patients treated with C2 pedicle screws. They place C2 pedicle screws under a pure visual control with excellent clinical results. However, the same group recently published a retrospective analysis of 170 transpedicularly introduced screws (19.4% with fluoroscopical guidance) and found on the postoperative C2 pedicle focused coronal CT reconstructed images 25% of screw cortical breaches. Most of the cortical wall violations (67.4%) were lateral in FT with one recognized VA injury [5]. They also discovered that the correct screw placement is related to the surgeon’s experience. The average pedicle diameter measured on postoperative CT scans was found 6 mm in its thinnest portion, and the lateromedial angle of screw purchase was approximately 40°.
6.3.1.2 Surgical Technique Standard Technique The C2 spinous process, lamina, C2/3 facets, and lateral pars border are exposed through a standard midline
82
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
posterior approach. Depending on the extent of planned fusion, other structures such as the posterior arch of atlas, occipital bone, or subaxial spine may need to be exposed as well. In situations where an isolated pedicle screw is planned, the muscular attachments can be saved and the approach focused only to the planned screw entry point and important trajectory determining structures. Despite that, it is usually helpful to dissect out the entire pars of C2, superomedial aspect of the isthmus, and the pedicle. The dissection should be carried out in a subperiostal fashion to avoid venous bleeding and/or injury of C2 nerve root and ganglion, if they are to be preserved. Screw placement is carried out under fluoroscopic guidance or, with increasing frequency, with the use of navigational systems. Different authors describe different screw entry points along the pars interarticularis. In the majority of clinical papers, the angle of craniocaudal trajectory is related to the coronal plane crossing the odontoid process midline and the lateromedial angle related to sagittal midplane. In their publication, Borne et al. [22] advised to introduce the pedicle screw angled 20° cephalad and medially. Roy-Camille et al. [193] proposed the entry point located in superomedial quadrant of articular process and direct the drill and screw 15° medially and cranially. In AO Spine manual [12], the geometrical middle of the pars interarticularis is recommended as a standard entry point. The trajectory of drilling and screw purchase is directed 25° cranially and 25°–35° (15°–25° in older edition), medially. Dickman et al. [42] proposed to locate the entry in the pars midline but only 2–3 mm above the lower C2 facet edge. The trajectory was suggested 20°–30° rostrally and medially. Levin et al. [142], while treating hangman’s fractures, suggests to start above the entry point for transarticular screw and to use biplanar fluoroscopy and direct visualization of internal pedicle side to guide the drill in correct angles.
of C2 lamina to direct the screw into the C2 vertebral body while respecting the medial border of isthmus and pedicle to determine the medial angulation. They did not use fluoroscopy and the key point was clear anatomical visualization of medial border of isthmus/pedicle. Postoperative, thin sliced CT done in prospective manner discovered only 15% of cortical breaches. Only two screws (2%) were evaluated as more than half of diameter cortical breakthrough. Both perforations were without clinical consequences.
6.3.1.3 Our Preference Using the C2 pedicle screw since 1993, we began with compressive osteosynthesis of fractures of the ring of axis as was originally described by Judet (Figs. 12.16 and 12.19, Chap. 12) and later we embarked on the use of this method in short C1-2 fusions (Fig. 20.11, Chap. 20) as well as in occipitocervical (Fig. 19.29, Chap. 19) and long subaxial constructs (Fig. 6.17).
Free Hand Technique Sciubba et al. [201] in their single surgeon (J.P. Wolinski) series of 55 patients treated with 100 C2 pedicle screws have done a thorough anatomical preoperative analysis of CT and MRI images to exclude those pedicles not large enough to accommodate a 3.5 mm screw. This was the case in 10% of analyzed pedicles. Their entry point was located more superiorly and laterally than usually recommended. They then used the cranio-caudal slope
Fig. 6.17 Lateral radiogram of circumferential cervical spine reconstruction for deformity. The transpedicular screw is a part of long posterior subaxial construct
83
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
The comprehensive radiological workup always precedes the procedure. Plain lateral and transoral films serve us mainly for basic orientation; however, they can be helpful as a predictor of potential fluoroscopic visibility of the bony structures during the surgical procedure. Dynamic lateral radiographs can reveal potential instability and the effect of eventual UCS movement during surgical positioning of the patient. Although, axial CT images of C2 pedicle are usually sufficient to determine feasibility of a C2 pedicle screw [248], we insist on thin sliced CT images prior to any planned intervention. Currently, only three-dimensional CT imaging with software modeling of ideal screw trajectory (Fig. 6.18), can reliably demonstrate variants of bony anatomy and determine actual individual availability of bone for screw acceptance. An MRI evaluation, although used less frequently than CT, can also provide useful information in our opinion. It clearly demonstrates not only neural anatomy and pathology of interest but can also depict the exact course of vessels (especially, VA) without the need for invasive angiography. If an anomalous VA or ICA is suspected then a standard angiography or CTA (our preference) can be performed. Rarely, VA can be hypoplastic on the side of intended intervention simultaneously with a surprisingly large bony transverse foramen. This
allows for a pedicle screw placement with expected/ intended cortical breach without the risk of arterial injury (Fig. 6.19). Pre-procedural knowledge of such variant can be important if other type of fixation is not possible or fails during the procedure. We will usually plan our entry points and trajectories virtually based on preoperative imaging. Virtual planning is only avoided in situations when unexpected extension of construct to C2 is required intraoperatively.
6.3.1.4 Our Surgical Technique The direct visualization of superomedial aspect of isthmus and pedicle is of utmost importance in guiding screw trajectory without navigation. The medial border of the isthmus and lateral lamina is always exposed, and if possible, the dissection extends to involve the medial surface of the pedicle (Fig. 6.20). Such exposure gives us the correct lateromedial angle and often we find that more than 30° (usually round 35°–40°) of medial inclination is necessary to introduce the drill. Direct visualization of the medial anatomical border of the pedicle practically eradicates the risk of injury of medially located neural structures. The entry point becomes obvious once the intended trajectory given
Fig. 6.18 Navigational plans created in computer station for C2 transpedicular screws purchase in a patient with bilateral high riding vertebral arteries showing high risky trajectories on both sides. (a) Plan for right pedicle. (b) Plan for left side
84 Fig. 6.19 Discrepancy between larger FT osseous diameter and smaller VA caliber in two different patients. (a) Parasagittal CTA 2D reconstruction. (b) CTA in 3D
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
a
Fig. 6.20 Artist’s drawing of entry and exit points of C2 transpedicular screw with emphasize of the area of necessary direct visibility
by previously described anatomical landmarks is established (Fig. 6.21). It is also necessary to calculate the screw diameter to pass safely directly under the isthmus/
Fig. 6.21 Change of C2 transpedicular screw trajectory requires simultaneous change of entry point position. (a) Without entry point change the screw comes closer to dangerous structures. (b) With change of the screw entry point respecting the narrowest part of planned trajectory (fulcrum) the risk can be decreased
b
pedicle ridge superomedially from VA groove toward the C2 body without significant penetration of the cortex. The screw entry is frequently more cranial and sometimes, more lateral than the middle of the lateral mass. It is not absolutely necessary to use fluoroscopic guidance for the initial drilling, but we recommend it as the upper ridge of pedicles can frequently be seen on lateral view and parallel placement can be ensured. Fluoroscopic information is not only useful in determining the correct craniocaudal angle of the screw but also allows for an estimation of screw length. The last parameter is due to the wavy C2 anterior surface rough only. We use a high-speed drill to make a small pilot hole at the entry point. This prevents a slip of the hand drill from the desired entry and allows pure concentration on trajectory. A drill-guide covered 2.5 mm drill used for the initial drilling enables one to feel the opposite cortex and thus minimize the risk of injury of structures located anterior to C2 body. From a technical viewpoint, we feel that higher drill speed gives better feedback of cortex penetration at the front. After a ball tip probe check, the
85
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
hole is usually tapped. In our opinion, tapping is useful in preparing the hole to match the screw thread exactly and thus allowing a firm anchorage. This is important particularly in axis ring fractures where compression is desirable. On the other hand, tapping can result in cortical breach and VA injury. One should be careful, if significant venous bleeding is encountered after initial drilling as this is likely a result of injury to the venous plexus around VA. In such a situation, we do not tap the hole but simply place a self-tapping screw once the hole is checked with a blunt-tip probe. Screw length can be determined during virtual planning and confirmed during tapping with calibrated instrument and/or with a probe gauge. If instruments are not navigation enabled, there may be a slight difference between virtually planned screw length and the actual measured one. This may be due to some discrepancy between actual entry points and screw angles. Screws need to be left somewhat proud if polyaxial screw heads are used to allow their free movement. This facilitates an easier rod application. We usually end up using screws that are 26–38 mm long when part of a construct. However, when treating hangman type fractures, the compression screw is usually shorter than estimated preoperatively and only partially threaded to allow for compression of the fracture gap. It is usually possible to recognize if a shorter screw is required during the compression maneuver and make appropriate changes as necessary. Once again, fluoroscopy can be of value here. We evaluate correct screw placement and construct position by means of a postoperative CT scan (Fig. 6.22 and Fig. 6.10). If significant cortical breach is identified and concern for VA artery injury exists, we obtain a CT angiogram to confirm vessel patency and exclude possible pseudoaneurysm or fistula. Postoperative CT is an important educational tool and an audit of one’s technique, especially if not performing such constructs frequently.
Fig. 6.22 Postoperative coronal CT reconstruction showing correct intra-pedicular screw purchase
6.3.2 Long Pars Interarticularis Screw – Transisthmic Screw Screw passage through the C2 pars interarticularis was first suggested by Friedrich Magerl, Austrian orthopedic surgeon working in St. Gallen, Switzerland, as a part of transarticular screw fixation for the treatment of C1-2 instability [152]. The first surgery using a C1-2 transarticular screws was performed in 1979. Although it was originally suggested for atlantoaxial fixation, it was later also utilized as a part of longer constructs and/or simple C2 anchorage point [86, 199]. Given the potential risk of VA injury, many authors used a shorter version of this trajectory as part of longer constructs and thus avoiding the transverse foramen of C2 [41, 181, 213]. Many surgeons advocate the use of alternative fixation methods due to the potential risk of VA injury with a transarticular screw. However, we believe that the majority of VA injuries do not represent a failure of the method. They are usually a result of poor decision making or preoperative planning. A thorough preoperative anatomical analysis is absolutely essential prior to instrumentation of C2 pars and can avoid potential disasters while allowing for solid fixation.
6.3.2.1 Anatomical Background According to Magerl’s original description, the screw trajectory passes through pars interarticularis of C2 vertebra in the plane parallel to the sagittal one, reaching the midline of posterior half of C2 superior articular process. The VA groove below the anterolateral portion of C2 superior facet potentially narrows the path of both the pedicle and the pars interarticularis and may preclude screw placement. Initially, exceptionally large C2 transverse foramen was described in several case reports as a rarity. This was usually due to bony erosion by tortuous VA [34, 236]. However, with increasing interest, VA anatomical variability was found to be more common than initially thought and was described by many authors [120, 151, 153, 179, 222, 223]. The majority of those studies were done on cadaveric spines [19, 55, 153, 243] or evaluating bony structures (i.e., transverse foramina) on axial and reconstructed CT images [51, 120, 168, 179]. The true
86
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
course of the VA could not be established in such a study design. Taitz and Arensburg [222] analyzed 300 dried specimens and found 33% incidence of C2 transverse foramen erosion (21% moderate, 12% marked). Although, no VA injuries as a result of isthmic C2 screws were published before 1995, Dull et al. [51] recognized correctly the potential hazard of an anatomical VA groove variability at this level. Good resolution 3D CT reconstructions did not exist at that time and therefore, the authors suggested obtaining images in an oblique plane to better visualize the pars. In order to visualize the potential screw path on CT images, complicated positioning of patient’s elevated torso was required in a maximally tilted CT gantry to respect the screw angle. This method was, obviously, not widely accepted. In the comments to Dull’s article, Paul R. Copper (New York) mentioned two deaths caused by misplaced screw related to VA injuries in the US. Paramore et al. [179] suggested reformatting traditional CT axial and sagittal images to visualize isthmic bone bridge 2–3 mm from the internal lateral canal border and thus evaluate its suitability for a screw. The anatomy would not be suitable for a screw in 17 of 94 (18%) patients on at least one side. In three subjects (3%), this anatomical restriction was seen bilaterally. Another five examined vertebrae were evaluated as risky but the exact anatomical measurements were not mentioned in their study. Their conclusion was that in 18–23% of patients, the transarticular C1-2 screw might be impossible or risky. There was no gender predominance. The authors suggested obtaining a preoperative MRI and/or contrast-enhanced 3D CT to trace the VA course exactly if doubts exist after regular or reformatted CT images. The “pedicle” width and height were studied in cadavers by Ebraheim’s group. In fact, they measured the isthmus and its width was 7.9–8.6 mm (female × male) and height 6.9–7.7 mm (f × m) at the level of transverse foramen [55, 243]. The anatomical nomenclature (Fig. 1.4, Chap. 1) was corrected by the same authors in their later work [54]. Similarly, Madawi et al. [151] wrongly calling pars the “pedicle” measured mean isthmus width 7.8 mm (range 3.4–12.2 mm) and height 7.9 mm (range 4.7– 12.4 mm) on 50 cadaveric specimens. They stated that transarticular screw would be hazardous in 22% of tested vertebrae. Also, the internal height of lateral mass was considered as an important restriction of screw introduction especially if the measured distance
is less than 2.1 mm. The same group also published clinical results of 61 patients treated with transisthmic screws [150]. Mostly due to anatomy distorted by disease or previous surgery, 14% of screws were placed incorrectly and VA injuries occurred in 8% of patients. In their pleasantly honest paper, they proposed that the majority of VA penetrations were due to incorrect (too low) trajectory inside the C2 vertebra. They emphasized that the anterior atlas tubercle often used as a trajectory target endpoint on lateral fluoroscopy can be lower than expected from anatomical studies. This is especially true in rheumatoid arthritis patients with settling of atlas. The other cause of an error when using anterior tubercle of C1 as the target, is its absence after transoral resection. The estimated risk of C1/2 transarticular screw misplacement after transoral odontoidectomy was as high as 55%. Jun [120] tried to establish the risk ratio of transisthmic screw using the sagittal reconstructed images of 64 healthy volunteers. He used reconstructed images of isthmus in strictly parasagittal plane 3.5 and 6 mm laterally from internal spinal canal wall. Modeling the longest trajectory line from the ridge of lower C2 facet, crossing the posterior part of superior facet, he defined the point of intersection as a distance from posterior rim of superior facet. Moving the line anterocaudally he virtually reached the transverse foramen in both (3.5 and 6 mm) parasagittal planes and measured the space available for screw (SAS). If the SAS distance was less than 3.5 mm he defined the situation as non-acceptable and if it was less than 4.5 mm as risky. Logically, the more anterior and lateral trajectories represented higher risk of transverse foramen perforation. Among 64 tested volunteers (128 sides), 4 sides were risky or unacceptable in the 3.5 mm and 21 sides in the 6 mm distant planes. Extrapolating this to per patient risk ratio this means that 6.3% of patients are in danger if the 3.5 mm distant plane is used and 32.6% if the screw is introduced in the longest parasagittal trajectory 6 mm laterally from the canal border. However, this study has some practical limits as a strictly parasagittal trajectory is not mandatory and the entry point can also be adjusted to facilitate an ideal screw trajectory. Solanki and Crockard [208] suggested transferring anatomical knowledge and preoperative CT scans to the computer aided design (CAD) program and plan the ideal trajectory before the procedure. Then they extrapolated the obtained information to the lateral fluoroscopical view. They also determined the safe
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
limits of lateromedial screw inclination as 0–14°. It is not clear how frequently or how successfully this method was used in clinical practice. To minimize VA injury, Goffin et al. [74] proposed a cheaper alternative to image guidance. They used custom-made polymer templates based on preoperative CT planning with imbedded stainless steel drill guides. This technique was only applied twice in clinical setting. Mandel et al. [153] measured 205 dried C2 vertebrae to determine the isthmus height and width at the level of transverse foramen. They found the mean isthmus width of 8.2 mm in male specimens and 7.2 mm in female vertebrae (3.9–14.7 mm). Five subjects (2.4%) had the isthmus width less than 5 mm at least on one side (i.e., not large enough to accommodate a 3.5 mm screw under standard fluoroscopic guidance) and those vertebrae were evaluated by CT to obtain further details. The obtained mean isthmus height was 8.6 mm in male and 6.9 mm in female samples (2.8–14.7 mm). Twenty-four vertebrae (11.7%) had one or both height measurements less than 5 mm. They also demonstrated significantly larger left-sided isthmi and significantly smaller dimensions in female specimens. In selected cases of repeated CT measurements, they found only 1 mm difference in comparison to values obtained by electronic caliper. They concluded that approximately 10% of population might be at risk of VA violation during the placement of an isthmic screw. Bloch et al. [19] tested image-guided placement of isthmic screws on 17 cadavers. Using the standard anatomical requirement of 5 mm of bone available for isthmic screw, they found that 20% of specimens would not be large enough to accommodate a 3.5 mm screw. They proposed that, with computer aided virtual navigation, the available isthmic bone requirement can be decreased to 4 mm. In other words, if the isthmus diameter in perpendicular plane to the ideal computermodeled trajectory is more than 4 mm, then the 3.5 mm screw can safely pass through. They thus concluded that, with the help of image guidance, the rate of isthmi not suitable for a safe screw placement can be reduced from 20% to 5.9%. As mentioned earlier, Resnick et al. [186] tested the ideal trajectories for transarticular and pedicle screws in their series of 50 standard axial CT investigations of trauma patients and 10 selected 3D CT images in patients with UCS anomaly. In fact, their attached figures demonstrate that they probably truly tested the
87
long isthmic screw trajectories rather than the actual pedicle screw. They also noted that the angle of pedicle screw is roughly parallel to the C2 spinous process. This is obviously incorrect from an anatomical point of view. There were no significant differences in 4 mm screw acceptability for both trajectories and the isthmus height was, on an average, 6.6 mm (SD = 1.8). Despite the above, some interesting facts became apparent in this study. First, it was demonstrated that different entry points and directions can be used to pass the C2 isthmus safely. Second, the accuracy of preoperative planning of the possible screw trajectory can be improved with the use of three- rather than twodimensional thin-cut CT images. Igarashi et al. [112] found that there were differences between the two sides in 45% of 98 dried C2 specimens and that 20% of pedicles (he actually measured the isthmus) had diameter smaller than 3.5 mm. This high frequency of isthmus low profile can be explained by generally smaller Japanese population. Neo et al. [168] suggested changing the screw trajectory in cases of aberrant transverse foramen anatomy. They defined as “high-riding” VA anatomical situation where the isthmus height measured on CT sagittal reconstructions was less than 5 mm and/or the internal height of C2 lateral mass less than 2 mm. This situation occurred unilaterally in 7 (26%) of their 27 consecutive patients planned for atlantoaxial fusion. Using the most posterior and most medial possible trajectory, they successfully placed screws even in the seven mentioned patients with only two intraforaminal cortical breaches but without consequent VA injury. They have also constructed special aiming device enabling the most posterior trajectory. However, the extreme cranial angle tilt resulted in screw penetration into C0-1 joint in four of the seven with high-riding VA. Finally, they correctly concluded that the internal height of lateral mass is not as important as the isthmus width and height. The internal lateral mass height becomes important only when the VA groove is located more medially than usual. Lee et al. [139] also tried simulating a different trajectory on a computer and then used it in seven patients with high-riding VA. Mostly, their screws were placed using a more cranially located entry point and more medial trajectory directed in a flat sagittal angle. The problem with flattening of the angle is not only to avoid the VA groove but to adequately anchor the screw in lateral mass.
88
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
The MR flow void or MRA can show an anomalous course of VA; however, the bone-vascular relationship cannot be well appreciated on MR imaging. Therefore, Theodore et al. [226] used CTA to better visualize the VA course in FT in three patients. Clearly, it is not only the course of the VA but also the VA-bone occupancy ratio that are important to assess. Cacciola et al. [26] studied ten cadavers and found that VA completely filled up the bony groove only in 30% of specimens. In the majority of specimens, there was a space between the artery and bone filled by periostial tissue and venous plexus. The mean VA occupancy within the groove was 79% (range 34–100%). This very important fact was reproduced by Moftakhar et al. [162] as mentioned earlier. They performed detailed CTA measurements in 106 patients with stroke or trauma presentations. Their motivation to do so was the fact that the majority of previously mentioned dimensions were obtained from cadaveric specimens or evaluations of only osseous VA groove on CT scans rather than imaging the actual real size and location of VA itself (Fig. 6.19). The potential risk of neurovascular injury anterior to the C1 or C2 body is similar to those described for C1 lateral mass screws and pedicle screws if bicortical screw purchase is preferred. Jeanneret and Magerl [116] have seen temporary bilateral hypoglossal palsy, which they were not able to explain. Nonetheless, they ended up replacing one of the screws as it was 4 mm longer than desired.
6.3.2.2 Surgical Technique Friedrich Magerl [116, 152] suggested to place the screw entry point on C2 caudal articular process 2 mm laterally and 3 mm cranially from the internal edge of C2-3 facet and to follow strictly parasagittal trajectory to reach posterior or middle thirds on inferior C1 facet surface. The target point on lateral fluoroscopy was the anterior tubercle of atlas in a reduced position. He used a 2.5 mm drill bit and always tapped the pilot hole for a cortical fully threaded 3.5 mm screw. If lagging was required, they over-drilled the proximal part of the hole with a 3.5 mm drill bit. The first drill was always left in place until the second pilot hole was drilled to avoid eventual dislocation. He emphasized the importance of visibility of the upper isthmus edge up to the atlantoaxial joint capsule and always used a bone
adjunct, usually in the form of Gallie’s graft or intraarticular bony chips to enable fusion. Magerl and his followers have described most of the surgical tricks in their initial descriptions although they were later attributed to other authors [83, 116]. For example, they have initially described: the possibilities of manual atlantoaxial dislocation reductions, how to perform the intraarticular bone fusion in cases of missing C1 posterior arch, how to achieve the correct sagittal working angle by means of cranial C2 spinous process traction, and/or creating caudal stab wounds for trocars. Ongoing widespread use of Magerl’s technique led to more frequent descriptions of complications. The first VA injury caused by transisthmic screw was published by Sasso et al. [199]. Madawi et al. [151] has described 8% of VA injuries without any mortality. Wright and Lauryssen [240], in their retrospective survey analysis of 1,318 patients treated with transarticular screws, estimated the risk of VA injury 4.1% per patient or 2.2% per screw inserted with a 0.2% per patient incidence of subsequent neurological deficit and 0.1% mortality. However, the actual incidence of VA penetration might be higher because of a low survey response (25.1%). Gluf et al. [69] later reported 2.6% incidence of VA injury and a 0.5% mortality rate as a result of transarticular screw fixation in 191 patients. Recently, the same group of authors published their series enlarged by 78 additional patients (269 total) emphasizing that increased experience and more careful radiological planning can dramatically decrease the frequency of VA injuries [61]. In this largest published series worldwide, they evaluated the risk of VA injury as 1.9% per patient and 1.2% per screw having 13.3% sides anatomically unable to accept the transarticular screw. Conversely, there are large studies available describing no VA injury [86, 154]. In the meantime, there were a lot of other studies describing the use of transarticular screw and its modification [36, 44, 69, 86, 116, 154].
6.3.2.3 Our Preference So far there is no published study substantially modifying the originally and, in our opinion, genially described technique by Magerl. The technical development since then only allowed performing this surgery more precisely, less invasively, and using hardware
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
made of better materials. The crucial step forward was the evolution of imaging techniques. The precise knowledge of anatomy of the isthmus of pars interarticularis and VA course can substantially decrease the frequency of complications if correct screw trajectory is preplanned and if those who cannot accommodate the screw are primarily excluded. The main drawback of this technique is that the screw passage cannot be controlled by naked eye and the sagittal angle is not very comfortable and sometimes even not achievable. Interestingly, there is an important difference between VA injury risk established from cadaveric anatomical studies or 2D CT reconstructions (up to 23% risky) and those where thin sliced CT with threedimensional reconstruction were used (6% of risky or unacceptable). The VA injury risk is very variable among the published studies [69, 86, 151]. This fact brings about a suspicion that approximately one half of these events are not only the technique but possibly more surgeon related. We suspect that this failure can hypothetically be caused by an incorrect angle of placement in sagittal plane or wrong preoperative planning and/or decision
89
to use this technique on unsuitable patients and/or sides. Many authors warn about the potential injury of the spinal canal contents. It needs to be stressed that no spinal cord injury has ever been described in the literature when placing pars or pedicle screws in C2. This fact can be explained by the usual direct visualization of isthmus. Also, the medial cortex can be exceptionally breached without a significant risk of dural/neural injury. Such or even quadricortical (intra-canal) screw purchase in the case of pedicle screw placement is an important bailout technique in certain situations where other methods fail or are not possible (destructive arthropathy in rheumatoid arthritis patients). It is the circular bone stock available for round-shaped screw in the narrowest place of its trajectory that we find critical (Fig. 6.23). The SAS can only be measured on 3D models in the plane perpendicular to its planned trajectory. The preoperative modeling can be done on the CT workstation or with the help of navigational machine and its software (Fig. 6.24). The SAS should be at least 5 mm in diameter to allow a safe passage of a 3.5 mm screw while using the standard technique guided by anatomical landmarks and fluoroscopic guidance. If a
Fig. 6.23 Space available for long transisthmic screw modeled on navigational computer station. (a) Model of 3.5 mm screw passage through the isthmus depicting critical SAS in coronal plane. (b) Model of 3.5 mm screw showing critical SAS in parasagittal plane
Fig. 6.24 Correct transarticular screw trajectory plan prepared on navigational workstation. (a) 3D image. (b) Parasagital projection. (c) Tilted axial section
90
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
4 mm screw is to be used then the SAS must be at least 6 mm. In cases where image guidance, real-time CT or isofluoroscopy are used, the SAS diameter can be 1 mm less. In cases where morphology makes the screw placement impossible (worst case scenario), it has to be recognized on preoperative planning and other options need to be considered. The screw trajectory can vary substantially. If the aim of the screw is to fix C1 in reducible dislocations, then it has to pass through the posterior half of C2 upper facet. In cases of irreducible anterior dislocation or settling of the atlas, the screw trajectory has to primarily respect a safe passage through the C2 pars and only secondarily consider if C1 anchorage is sufficient or even possible. Targeting of anterior tubercle of the atlas is never as important as achieving a safe C2 transisthmic trajectory. At least 5 mm of screw should pass through the bone of C1 lateral mass to achieve a firm anchorage. Change of trajectory due to dislocated C1 or high located VA groove can result in undesirable deviation of the screw. Thus, for example, the hypervertical trajectory can penetrate the C0-1 joint and in such a situation, an adequately shorter screw has to be selected. Medial or lateral tilt can be acceptable if sufficient anchorage of C1 is possible and if the screw does not leave the middle third of the lateral mass in coronal plane. An intentional decrease in cranial angle could potentially be the most dangerous. If such caudal tilt is necessary, the screw entry point needs to be adjusted more cranially; otherwise, the VA groove would be violated (Fig. 6.25). Similarly, a more lateral
trajectory can increase the risk of VA tear if the pathway is not changed appropriately according to 3D modeling. Too long a screw can injure the anterior retropharyngeal structures. Internal carotid artery, hypoglossal nerve, and the posterior pharyngeal wall can be injured if the tip of bicortical screw is too lateral and protrudes more than 5mm out of the vertebra. More freedom exists if the C1 anchorage is not intended to fix C1 but rather is a part of a longer construct. In such situations, a nearly pedicular trajectory can be selected. Alternatively, a concomitant caudal tilt of the screw with a more superior location of entry point can be advantageous in bicortically or monocortically placed isthmic screws. With respect to the VA, one has to pay attention not only to the shape and direction of pure bony canal or the groove of VA but also to the actual artery itself as it occasionally occupies only a part of the foramen/groove. This becomes obvious in cases of arterial asymmetry due to hypoplastic VA as seen on a CTA (Fig. 6.19). The other choice is to place only a short pars screw as described below.
Fig. 6.25 Schematic picture of possible trajectories of C1-2 transarticular screw demonstrating that changing of trajectory must be accompanied by the change of screw entry point. (a) Tilting of the screw in sagittal plane without change of entry point can lead
either to inadequate C1 lateral mass bone anchorage (cranial tilt) or undesirable VA vicinity. (b) Synchronous change of trajectory and screw entry point is much more relevant
6.3.2.4 Our Surgical Technique Patients treated for C1-2 instability are carefully and often fiber-optically intubated and electrophysiological monitoring electrodes are attached in the initial recumbent position if needed. Prone positioning is performed gradually holding the head in neutral position sometimes secured with a hard collar or halo vest. The
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
operating surgeon is always responsible for this maneuver and most often he is the person holding the head and directing others to rotate the patient. Three-point head fixation (e.g., Mayfield clamp) can be advantageous to allow for reduction of atlantoaxial dislocation as well as positioning the C2 vertebra appropriately for isthmic screw placement (40°–50° tilt). This maneuver flexes the head while keeping the cervical spine straight. Lateral fluoroscopy is always used during positioning of the patient and the planned trajectory angle is tested with metal probe (Fig. 6.26). Occasionally, barrel chest or fixed hyperlordosis do not allow for the correct trajectory. This is crucial and one must not be satisfied if an absolutely perfect angle cannot be achieved. It is also necessary to figure out the angle achieved by extended instruments (drill etc.) as the dorsal chest can dictate how much upward angle is possible. The other trick is the “landing Concorde” position of cervicothoracic junction. The head and UCS should be located higher than right cardiac atrium to avoid excessive venous bleeding from potentially injured plexuses around the C2 nerve root. It is necessary to emphasize repeatedly that the positioning of the patient before incision has the same substantial value for final success as a clean and anatomically clear surgical approach. We should do everything possible to increase patient’s safety, and also our comfort to be concentrated to the critical parts of the procedure. As neurosurgeons, we feel that any unnecessary bleeding results in blurring of anatomical structures and we therefore insist on meticulous hemostasis from the beginning of the procedure. We use subcutaneous local anesthetic with adrenaline (epinephrine) infiltration
Fig. 6.26 Testing of achievable trajectory angle with metal probe on lateral fluoroscopical view preoperatively. (a) Screen view. (b) Video print
91
and electrocautery to decrease bleeding from skin and subcutaneous tissue. It is important to maintain midline on deeper dissection through the nuchal ligament and the muscular fascia as this will prevent blood loss and allow for subperiostial dissection of neck muscles off the spinous processes and laminae. The C2 spinous process is often bifid, readily palpable, and is the largest one in the UCS thus allowing orientation. The other important point of orientation is the posterior tubercle of atlas. When placing the long isthmic screw, we expose the posterior arch of atlas, C2 laminae, C2/3 joint, and adequate part of occiput. If a simple C1-2 transarticular screw is to be placed with intra-articular bone fusion only, the approach can be less invasive with sparing of some of the muscles attached to the C2 spinous process. However, when atlantoaxial reduction and posterior midline graft fusion are required, the exposure needs to be extended to see all previously mentioned structures. When placing an isthmic screw, we believe it is critical to expose the whole C2 pars interarticularis and the cranial ridge of C2 isthmus. The desired sagittal angle for drilling is very often achievable only via a caudolateral stab wound incisions. The entry points most often located 2 mm laterally and 3 mm cranially from lower medial aspect of lower C2 facet are predrilled with a high-speed drill to avoid drifting of the drill. The trocar is introduced through the caudal stab incision and long drill in appropriate sleeve is passed through to reach the entry point. Lateral fluoroscopy is now brought into the field and the sagittal angle checked. We usually draw a line on the fluoroscopy display to extend the line of drilling and thus better predict the target. Frequently, the
92
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
anterior atlas tubercle is the endpoint of our drilling. This is, however, not true in dislocated situations as was emphasized earlier. Before the drilling begins, the superomedial ridge of C2 isthmus is visualized with a Penfield dissector, thus enabling the surgeon to directly monitor the lateral wall of the spinal canal. Usually, a parasagittal plane or slightly medial (up to 15°) trajectories are used. If known, the screw hole is pre-drilled on the non-dominant side first. Otherwise, we usually choose the right side first. The drilling is discontinued when the end cortex (most often, anterior C1 lateral mass) is penetrated. If no excessive bleeding is seen after the drill removal the tap is introduced through the same trocar sleeve and the hole is tapped. This is the most dangerous part of the procedure. The tap is a very sharp instrument and can injure the VA more easily than the drill and the trajectory of the original drill hole can be changed unintentionally. Because of the mentioned drawbacks, some authors do not recommend use of a tap and continue with self-tapping screw. Nevertheless, we believe that tapping can increase the strength of screw anchorage and also avoids unintentional redirection as is possible with self-tapping screw. A full-threaded or half-threaded screw is finally introduced via the same trocar. A specially developed selfretaining screw driver can be very helpful during the trocar passage of the screw. All steps of the screw placement are monitored by lateral fluoroscopy. In our series of 100 transisthmic screws, we have seen two VA injuries. It was always during tapping. One has to consider this complication whenever significant venous bleeding is encountered out of the drill hole. This can be a warning sign caused by injury of venous plexuses surrounding the VA. If the VA is violated, pulsatile arterial bleeding may be seen out of the drill hole. In such situations, a second attempt to pass the screw would be ill-advised, in our opinion. The transisthmic screw can also be introduced under image guidance. One has to consider that only C2 vertebra is registered. We only use image guidance in borderline cases where we believe that transisthmic screw is necessary and where the SAS is between 4 and 5 mm.
6.3.3 Short C2 Pars Interarticularis Screw The use of a short screw in the C2 pars interarticularis to avoid the vertebral artery was suggested by Resnick
and Benzel, in 2001 [185]. They have chosen this technique in a very obese woman with odontoid pseudoarthrosis where the low angle of a transarticular screw was impossible and patient’s obesity made fluoroscopy guidance difficult. They used an entry point located 14 mm above the C2-3 facet line, approximately in the center of the pars. A 20 mm screw was introduced in a sagittal angle parallel to the spinous process. Unfortunately, as other authors, they called this screw a “pedicle” screw despite it being placed in the actual C2 pars in terms of anatomy. The construct was finished by a rod connection to C1 lateral mass screws bilaterally. Stokes et al. [213] described C2 “pedicle” screws placed via the same entry point as Magerl’s screw in his series of four patients (first 1999) treated by “Harms” technique. However, the trajectory was less cranial and more medial. In fact, he placed short pars screws not reaching the VA groove. Many other authors presented good clinical and morphological results using the connection between C1 lateral mass screws and short pars screws while describing them as “pedicle” ones [41, 181].
6.3.3.1 Our Preference The short screws placed monocortically in the pars represent the least stable method of C2 fixation [47]. The only real advantage is a minimal risk of VA injury. This technique can be used very seldom if all other possibilities are not possible or fail. This can be of importance, for example, in very obese patients where achieving of required angles can be difficult.
6.3.4 Laminar C2 Screws Wright [238, 239] was the first to describe the possibility of C2 laminar screw instead of a more technically demanding and risky isthmic or pedicle fixations in atlantoaxial stabilization techniques. He performed the first surgery using crosslaminar C2 screw in 2002. Independently the same method was described later by Gorek et al. [77] who used unilateral laminar screw as a salvage technique in cases where one side C2 pars/ pedicle was not large enough to accept a 3.5 mm screw. As an alternative, for cases with deeply furrowed C2 spinous processes, Sciubba et al. [200] recently developed a technique where shorter, not crossing screws
93
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
are introduced into the laminae after removal of bifid spinous process. Laminar screws currently represent a viable alternative to the other techniques using C2 vertebra as an anchoring structure. Their stability was tested by Nassos et al. [167] on cadaveric specimens and compared to other methods of C2 fixation in occipitocervical constructs (pedicle and transarticular screws). Although similar in its ability to limit motion, laminar screws tended to be weaker in lateral bending. Their long-term stability remains questionable. Parker et al. [180] analyzed a cohort of 167 patients treated with 152 C2 laminar and 161 pedicle screws in C1-C3 fusions or subaxial long constructs. On postoperative CT scans, they documented lower frequency of cortical breach with laminar screws (1.3%) than with pedicle screws (7%) but both without any clinical sequelae. During at least 1 year follow-up, they confirmed that, especially in the short UCS constructs, the crosslaminar screws remain stable. In longer subaxial constructs they found a higher frequency (6.1%) of laminar screw revisions mostly due to pull out, hardware failure, or pseudoarthrosis. Safety and feasibility of laminar C2 screws were also described by Sciubba et al. [200]; however, 12.5% of their patients required revision a few months after surgery because of pseudoarthrosis and screw pullout. Wang [232] also reported early hardware failure in 6.6% of treated patients. Wright [239] described 100% fusion in a 1-year follow-up in his series of 20 patients treated for various pathologies with different constructs using the C2 laminar screws. He did not have any clinical complications but postoperative CT revealed 15% of cortical breach of C2 laminae. Most authors [105, 180] prefer a free-hand technique respecting anatomical landmarks with occasional help of fluoroscopy when placing laminar screws. Although, the accuracy of laminar screws is generally very good, some authors suggest more precise techniques. Nottmeier [172] placed 4mm laminar screws in eight patients using 3D isofluoroscopy image-guided technique with excellent accuracy. Lu et al. [147] suggested the use of a patient-specific navigational template attached to C2 spinous process. This template was created according to a plastic model of C2 vertebra prepared before the procedure with the help of CAD and 3D CT image. Recently, Dmitriev et al. [47] biomechanically tested 14 cadaveric specimens and found similar insertional torque while placing the screws into C2 pedicle or lamina but significantly lower values were registered with short monocortical isthmic screws. Interestingly, the
postfatigue pull-out strength was significantly better for pedicle than for laminar or isthmic screws. The strength of laminar screw pull-out resistance can be increased by bicortical purchase as described by Jea et al. [114]. This modification of Wright’s method is also safer because the tip of the screw is visible at the distal end of its pathway. On the other hand, it is probably not possible in all C2 arch variations.
6.3.4.1 Anatomical Background C2 lamina is considered to be the largest in the upper and middle cervical spine; nonetheless, a great variability in its diameter and length is documented by anatomical works [27, 232, 242]. The average laminar angle to sagittal plane was 44.1° (range 37°–50°) when measured on 38 dried cadaveric specimens (76 C2 laminae) by Wang [232]. The laminar length available for a screw (including the width of spinous process) was, on an average, 31.6 mm (range 27.0–37.0 mm). The same author measured the cross-sectional diameter of the C2 lamina. He found that, in its thinnest portion, the average height of the lamina was 11.5 mm (range 9.0– 14.1 mm) and average thickness was 6.3 mm (range 3.6–9.1 mm). He thus found that 21% of laminae could not accommodate a 3.5 mm screw (less than 5.5 mm space available) if allowing for an extra circumferential millimeter 42% of tested sides cannot accommodate a 4 mm screw (less than 6 mm space). Cassinelli et al. [27] observed a similar C2 lamina thickness on 420 dried C2 vertebrae similar but found a gender difference with larger values obtained from male specimens. They concluded that 70.5% of laminae had thickness equal to or greater than 5 mm, 92.6% more than 4 mm, and 96.7% more than 3.5 mm. The average length of arches was lower than in previous series. Only 45.2% of laminae were able to accept 25 mm screws and only 1.9% could accommodate 30 mm screws without entering the lateral mass (internal distance measured). As others [203, 242], they found that caudal part of lamina is thicker than cranial one and recommended to aim the screw to lower laminar margin.
6.3.4.2 Surgical Technique According to Wright’s recommendation [239], after a subperiostal exposure of C2 spinous process and
94
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
laminae, a small cortical window is created on the right side of rostral part of C2 spinous process at its junction with the right lamina. The hand drill is used to drill the pilot hole along the visible left-sided C2 lamina. The trajectory should be kept slightly away from the spinal canal than the downslope of the lamina. A ball probe confirms the integrity of the intralaminar canal. A 30 × 3.5 mm screw was placed and no tap mentioned. The opposite screw is introduced in the same manner but the entry point is located more caudally in order to allow the screw intralaminar crossing. According to the author, no fluoroscopy or navigation is necessary to introduce 3.5 mm crosslaminar screws but a preoperative CT evaluation of laminae and their size is mandatory. To avoid canal content damage, the internal surface of C2 lamina can be palpated in cases of angle or thickness uncertainty. Gorek [77] advised to tap the initial part of screw hole located in the middle of the junction of spinous process and lamina for unilateral screw purchase. The appropriate screw length with endpoint located no further than the junction between pars and lamina was determined by depth gauge. Jea et al. [114] prefer the penetration of the distal cortex with a screw tip by modification of the introductory angle.
6.3.4.3 Our Preference Influenced by the mentioned anatomical works and our own experience, we argue that prior to any C2 laminar screw placement, a thin-sliced CT should be obtained to determine the thickness of C2 laminae. It also allows establishing the ratio between cortex and cancellous intralaminar bone canal and the appropriate screw length in order to avoid penetration of C2/3 joint (Fig. 6.27). In our opinion, this technique is a useful salvage procedure (Figs. 6.28 and 6.51). Laminar C2 screw technique can be helpful in cases of small pedicles or pars or erroneous attempt of pedicle or isthmus cannulation resulting in weak bone or need for a different (now risky) trajectory. It seems obvious that a correct transpedicular or transisthmic screw technique with bicortical purchase should provide stronger screw anchorage than a screw placed in the cancellous bone cavity of C2 lamina. A further potential and so far unknown risk is that of a ventral laminar breach of the screw during daily life overload. Fortunately, such complication with clinical sequelae has not yet been described. An early
postoperative CT confirms proper screw position and is highly recommended as plain radiographs will not show any ventral cortical penetration [140]. When planning various types of fixation with axis serving as anchoring structure, the preoperative CT analysis should always include a study of possible “salvage” options. Routine production of patient-specific templates will, probably, not be available to every surgeon but the use of 3D isofloroscopes connected to navigational systems seems to be the feature allowing not only a precise screw placement but also an immediate check of their real-time position.
6.3.5 Odontoid Process Screw This specific screw is used only for the treatment of odontoid process fractures and not as a part of any segmental fixating construct. It was first used by Nakanishi et al. from Japan in August 1978 [166] and independently Friedrich Magerl performed the same procedure in January 1979 [87] in Switzerland for odontoid pseudoarthrosis. He also suggested using this technique for the treatment of fractures. First documented series of 12 fractures treated this way was published by Böhler [20] with annotation that the idea came from Magerl. The pioneers described the necessity of use of two screws where the longer one is acting as a lag screw and the shorter securing the rotational stability. Numerous papers then described the success of this method in the treatment of type II and shallow type III odontoid fractures [2, 68, 128, 182, 220]. Later, especially North American authors, under influence of biomechanical works [79, 198] began to advocate single screw fixation of odontoid fractures [117, 216]. Overall fusion rate achieved by direct odontoid screw was between 85% and 95%.
6.3.5.1 Anatomical Background The approach trajectory is oblique to allow the screw passage from anteroinferior edge of C2 vertebral body to the tip of the odontoid process. There is approximately 14 mm of available space for a safe screw purchase in the midline of the base of C2 [131]. The distance to the base of the odontoid is approximately 20 mm and the process itself is another 20 mm long, on
95
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
Fig. 6.27 Modeling of SAS for C2 intralaminar screw placement on navigational workstation documenting large SAS
an average. Thus, one can calculate that the length of the lag screw should theoretically be between 36 and 44 mm. The odontoid process diameter is approximately 10 mm at its base, just enough space for two 4 mm screws under normal conditions. Certainly, there is large gender, race, and age variability, which has to be taken into account and patient-specific individual parameters have to be measured exactly (best on CT).
The odontoid tip is covered by very dense cortical bone, which has to be penetrated with a longer screw.
6.3.5.2 Surgical Technique Odontoid fractures can be treated with a direct screw compressive osteosynthesis only if reduced
96
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Fig. 6.28 Crosslaminar screw used as salvage procedure on the side where the transpedicular and transisthmic screw introduction was not feasible. (a) Left high riding VA visible on coronal CT reconstruction. (b) Left parasagittal reconstruction showing unfeasibility of transisthmic screw. (c, d) Postoperative axial CT scan showing left C2 crosslaminar screw and Magerl’s screw on the right side
preoperatively. Therefore, patient positioning on the table allows for oblique introductory angle without dislocation of the fracture and is, indeed, a critical step in the surgical procedure. The screw angle can be a limiting factor in obese people, patients with fixed cervical kyphosis, and those with a barrel chest. The obliquity of this approach usually starting at the level of C5 and steep cranial angle allows only for a fairly limited illumination. This fact led to further development of various self-retaining and tubular retractors [96, 204]. Also, the screws come in a variety of shapes and materials: full-threaded or partially threaded; double-threaded; 3.5 or 4 mm diameter; steel, titanium alloy or PLDLA, and full or cannulated [2, 6, 9, 129]. Initially, the fullthreaded 3.5 mm stainless steel screws were used and the proximal part of the pilot hole for the lag screw was over-drilled with larger diameter drill to achieve compression [20]. Later, cannulated screws guided by a Kirschner wire were used with a short apical thread and long smooth shaft [2]. The fixation itself started with drilling followed by tapping and screw placement performed under real-time double fluoroscopy.
6.3.5.3 Our Preference There is no doubt, in our opinion, that direct compressive osteosynthesis of type II and shallow type III odontoid fractures is the most physiological method available with highest fusion rates if correctly indicated and performed. Main advantage of the direct osteosynthesis is that no other motion segment is involved in the fusion. It can be performed only if the fracture is reduced and the introductory angle is possible.
6.3.5.4 Our Surgical Technique In our experience it often took more time to position the patient on transparent table correctly, than the surgery itself. The patient’s head is fixed in halo ring (not necessary in every case) to enable free manipulation with continuous traction (Fig. 6.29). The patient is intubated without changing of the spine position (under fluoroscopical control, fiberoptically, or awake), and his/her mouth is held open with mouth distractor or simple roll
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
97
Fig. 6.29 Setup of two rectangular fluoroscopes. (a) Position of C-arms and the transparent surgical table. (b) Peroperative haloring traction
of gauze. It is very difficult and very important to set the C2 vertebra in sagittal plane correctly to achieve acceptable angle for screw placement and not to dislocate the fracture especially in posteriorly dislocated or oblique fractures. Positioning maneuvers and the introductory angle are checked on lateral fluoroscopy using an extended radiopaque marker (e.g., long K-wire) (Fig. 6.30). Following that, a second fluoroscopic machine is set up perpendicular to the first one to allow for a transoral view. It is usually adjusted in such a way as to visualize the tip and shaft of odontoid process and the base of C2 simultaneously on both screens (Fig. 6.31). The screens are always positioned in front of the operating surgeon and the pictures turned to depict the same orientation as the patient position (Fig. 6.32). We never start the procedure if the previously described harmony of position and radiographic visibility is not achieved. A right-sided horizontal incision is made just above the C4-5 interspace and the anterior spine is exposed through a standard, bloodless anterolateral approach.
Fig. 6.30 Preoperative fluoroscopical testing of correct angle achievability with metal probe
The prevertebral fascia is sharply cut and oblique tunnel reaching the base of C2 is created by blunt dissection. The extent of exposure can be checked by lateral
98
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Fig. 6.31 Necessary preoperative fluoroscopical visibility. (a) Odontoid process shank and tip. (b) Unobstructed lateral C2 view
Fig. 6.32 Surgeons position with direct view on the fluoroscreens
fluoroscopy. We do not damage the C2-3 intervertebral disk. Because of lack of illumination in the oblique approach tunnel, we use the headlight and the space is held open either with the Apfelbaum retractor or simply by the assisting surgeon using a Hohmann hook fixed to C2 body (Fig. 6.33). We do not have experience with tubular retractors that may have the advantage of being fixed to the table and having tubular lighting. Thin and sharp probe or K-wire is positioned on the expected midline of the inferior C2 ridge and its correct position is checked on both fluoroscopes. A long, straight probe can also predict the final sagittal screw angle needed. If a double-screw construct is planned (more common), two entry point holes are created approximately 4–5 mm from the midline at the C2 inferior edge with a high-speed drill (3 mm burr). If a single screw
fixation is planned, the entry point is created in the midline. We always attempt to first drill the pilot hole for the lag screw. This strategy allows for a potential second chance in case of an initially wrong trajectory that is difficult to fix by a simple change of the drill angle. The drill is covered by a drill guide with a depth gauge; however the depth measurement is usually fairly inaccurate as it is difficult to obtain a good contact of the sleeve with the oblique surface of the vertebra. Drilling is performed slowly step-by-step under continuous fluoroscopy but with high drill speeds as this provides better tactile feedback of resistance. The drill is stopped once the condense bone of the apex is completely perforated. According to anatomical works, there is, on an average, a 6 mm safety zone between the apex and the brainstem. However, maximum attention must be paid to this part of the drilling (i.e., fixed elbows to prevent unintentional “plunge”). While drilling the first hole, we already plan the position of the second screw as sufficient space needs to be maintained. The screw should not be located too far anteriorly within the C2 body as this may predispose the screw to anterior breakout. The hole is then tapped including the dens apex using the same drill guide (Fig. 6.34). We use the Apfelbaum titanium, short-threaded 4 mm screws attached to self-retaining screw driver for odontoid fixation. Thus, no overdrilling of the proximal screw hole is necessary. The screw is forcefully tightened to perforate the apex approximately by one thread. In our opinion, this is another essential part of the procedure. If the screw does not perforate the apex it can distract the fracture rather than compress it. It is possible to note any rotational instability during
6.3 Axis as an Anchoring Structure
99
Fig. 6.33 Fluoroscopical view of two possibilities of oblique surgical canal spreading. (a) With Apfelbaum’s distractor. (b) With pediatric Hohmann retractor held by assistant
Fig. 6.34 Tapping of the pilot hole including the odontoid process tip
Fig. 6.35 AP radiogram of double odontoid screw purchase
tapping or screw tightening as rotation of the odontoid becomes apparent on fluoroscopic images. In such a situation, we drill a second screw hole and the lag screw is tightened with the drill left in place. Under normal conditions, the second screw is placed in the same manner with the aim to simply cross the fracture line sufficiently
(Fig. 6.35) to fulfill the anti-rotational purpose. Finally, the wound is closed in a standard fashion. Anteriorly oblique fractures are usually considered a contraindication to the odontoid screw fixation due to the dislocation risk during screw tightening. In our opinion, this fracture type can also be treated by this
100
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Currently, the use of a single versus two odontoid screws remains controversial. In our opinion, only those who are technically able to place two screws can discuss the possibility of a single screw fixation. If the fracture surface is rough (irregular) and the fracture can be well compressed, then a single screw fixation can be sufficiently strong (Fig. 6.37). We feel that the crucial point is the perforation of apical cortex to allow strong compression. Otherwise, distraction of the fracture and rotational dislocation of the dens will prevent bony healing and the screw will subsequently break (Fig. 6.38). Another possible drawback of direct odontoid screw fixation is poor bone quality in some patients preventing adequate screw anchorage.
Fig. 6.36 AP fluoroscopical view of parallel K-wire introduced to allow lag screw tightening without odontoid rotation
technique provided enough bone is available below the fracture line in the C2 body. This is the fracture that needs to be reduced preoperatively with positioning, as emphasized earlier. First, the Kirschner wire (1.5 mm) is passed to the tip of the dens without cortical perforation. Then, a pilot hole for lag screw is drilled penetrating the odontoid apex with subsequent tapping. A short-threaded screw is placed and forcefully tightened to achieve compression of the fracture while the Kirschner wire is holding the odontoid in place not allowing anterior dislocation (similarly to rotational instability) (Fig. 6.36). Finally, the wire is replaced by a short antirotational screw. We do not use cannulated screws. The main reason is that we consider apical penetration and compression of fracture very important and therefore, if a K-wire was to be in place during tapping or screw tightening, it could be inadvertently advanced into the canal with catastrophic consequences. a
Fig. 6.37 Compression needed for fracture alignment and healing. (a) Double screw purchase. (b) Single screw compression
6.3.6 Screw Introduced into C2 Body Either monocortically or bicortically introduced screws into the C2 body are used almost exclusively to fix the plate stabilizing the axis to C3 and/or lower cervical vertebras. High anterolateral cervical approach is derived from the subaxial access described to reach C3-T1 spine as described in detail in Chap. 4.
6.3.6.1 Our Preference We use this type of screw purchase only to fix the plate stabilizing subaxial cervical segments. We prefer to introduce the screws bicortically in trauma cases especially in hangman type fractures (Figs. 12.14d and 12.18, Chap. 12) or combined injuries (Figs. 14.2 and 14.3, Chap. 14). The monocortical purchase can be chosen in traumatic and degenerative disk prolapses without marked segmental instability. From technical b
101
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs
6.4.1.1 Posterior C0-1 Fixation Methods
Fig. 6.38 Tomogram of improperly tightened screw 9 months after surgery. Note distraction – pseudoarthrosis
point of view, compared to standard anterolateral ACDF, the only difficulty represents the distant upper C2 screw purchase. To enable the C2 anterior surface perpendicular drilling trajectory quite important midline dislocation is necessary. In such a case, we remove all the automatic wound retractors. This wound release allows for more easy medial pharyngeal and laryngeal dislocation. Usually, the drilling and screw purchase are performed with manual wound distraction and with instruments covered by a protection sleeve.
Grob [81] speculated that the ideal fixation should only fix the target segment. Therefore, atlanto-occipital instability or dislocation should only be stabilized through the CVJ if possible. Currently, there are two main options for posterior stabilization of atlanto-occipital joint. As described above, Grob [81] suggested performing a C1-0 transarticular fixation similar to Magerl procedure for C1-2 (Fig. 6.3). Because of biomechanical weakness in flexion, Gonzalez et al. [75] proposed the use of a bone graft between occiput and the atlas, similar to Gallie type fusion. The same group successfully performed three such posterior stabilizations [60]. Maughan et al. (Fig. 6.39) described another option for atlanto-occipital fixation in a patient with circular avulsion fracture of foramen magnum. It involved occipital plate and C1 lateral mass screws connected by a rod [156]. Bambakidis et al. [16] compared the two previously mentioned techniques with occipitoatlantal wire and rod fixation, biomechanically. They found that both screw techniques are substantially stiffer than the wirerod method. Nevertheless, they also confirmed that the transarticular screw supplemented with a buttress graft is slightly more rigid than the plate-screw-rod system.
6.4.1.2 Our Preference For mild types of AOD, isolated condyle fracture dislocations, and chronic atlanto-occipital instabilities, the short monosegmental posterior fixation is sufficient.
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs 6.4.1 Posterior Monosegmental Fusion Constructs Posterior monosegmental fusion constructs are usually strong enough to maintain stability without the need for external bracing and allow for exclusion of mobile segments not involved in the pathological movement.
Fig. 6.39 Artistic drawing of atlantooccipital fixation according to Maughan
102
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
However, for typical AOD caused by high impact trauma disconnecting the ligamentous attachments of the head to the spine, the short construct is insufficient. Such patients, if they survive, are often bedridden and ventilator dependent needing very frequent positioning and passive manipulation. Instability can have catastrophic consequences. Taking patient’s prognosis into account, a construct extended to C2 or more caudally may have negligible influence on further quality of life.
6.4.1.3 Posterior C1-2 Fixation Methods Mixter and Osgood Silk Loop In 1910, Mixter and Osgood [161] were the first to describe surgical treatment of atlantoaxial instability in a 15-year-old boy who fell from a tree. He came to be operated in Massachusetts General Hospital, 6 months after unsuccessful conservative treatment of unrecognized odontoid fracture with C1/2 dislocation. He had pain but no neurological deficit. He was first manipulated under anesthesia. Then new radiographs, including transoral projections, revealed the old odontoid fracture. A leather external orthosis was manufactured. Surgery was performed by Dr. Mixter from posterior midline approach. Benzoin-soaked, braided silk loop was passed below the C1 arch and around spinous C2 process and no bone graft was added. The patient survived and fused without complications. In this report, we can recognize some interesting facts. They performed “open mouth” films to visualize the UCS. They reviewed the available literature and concluded that in the UCS trauma cohort, the most common abnormality was atlantoaxial dislocation without fracture, followed by odontoid fractures and then fractures of C1 and C2 arches, and lateral masses.
imperative. Posterior surgical treatment was indicated whenever displaced facets were irreducible by traction, or failed to maintain reduction in external orthosis or in cases of non-reduced malunion. He stated that “recurrence of displacement can be prevented by fastening the two vertebrae together by fine steel wire passed around the laminae or spines. And the risk of late recurrence can be eliminated by bone grafts laid in the spines or on the laminae and articular facets.” So, no typical H shape graft was mentioned neither depicted on the pictures in the original paper. Other authors also describe the technique of posterior graft and wiring, even 2 years earlier [33]. Fried used the “Gallie method” of C1-2 wiring and grafting after scraping the atlantoaxial joints with failure rate of 80% [66]. The first paper describing an H-shaped onlay notched graft placed on the surface of C1 and spinous process of C2 is that of McGraw and Rusch [158]. It can be summarized that the original technique of onlay grafting is the simplest fusion method but also the least stable when compared to other techniques, especially in rotation [82]. Today, the notched onlay graft positioned on the surface of C1 and around the spinous process of C2 is called “Gallie – type graft” (Fig. 6.40). Failure (pseudoarthrosis, wire breakage, or loosening) of Gallie type fusion can be seen in up to 80% of cases if used as standalone method [66]. Fusion rate can be improved with halo bracing, but even then 25% of cases still fail [36].
Brooks and Jenkins – Wire and Graft In order to increase the stability of posterior wire and graft fusion, Brooks and Jenkins suggested interposing
Atlantoaxial Wire and Graft The addition of an H-shaped bone graft currently used as supplement to other more solid metal constructs, is usually attributed to W.E. Gallie, surgeon from Toronto. He published his algorithm in 1939, describing how to treat fractures and dislocations in cervical spine [67]. He suggested to always begin with skeletal head traction in cases of subluxation anywhere in the cervical spine, emphasizing that reduction of dislocation is
Fig. 6.40 Gallie’s type of posterior AA fixation
103
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs
Fig. 6.41 Brooks and Jenkins type of grafts and wire posterior AA fixation
two grafts laterally between the C1 and C2 laminae by wedge compression technique [24]. Beveled iliac crest autografts were fixed in place with doubled 20 gauge stainless steel sublaminar wires (Fig. 6.41). It is the need for bilateral sublaminar cable passage that has a higher potential rate of neurological or dural injury. They successfully treated 15 patients with final fusion rate of 93%. They supplemented their surgical procedure by postoperative use of either a Minerva or SOMI brace. Later works evaluating larger series using Brooks method for C1-2 fixation reported failure rate up to 30% [36, 80].
Sonntag – Wire and Graft Sonntag et al. modified the Gallie graft fusion technique in the early 1990s in an attempt to improve stability of the construct and avoid bilateral C2 sublaminar cables [46]. They decorticated the contact surfaces of C1 and C2 arches and interposed curvilinear strut graft approximately 4 cm long with caudal notch for the C2 spinous process. The graft was then fixed by a cable passing under the posterior arch of C1 and looped around a notched inferior C2 spinous process (Fig. 6.42). However, in patients treated with posterior wiring techniques only, they treated them with three months of postoperative halo immobilization. This approach achieved 97% fusion rate in their series of 36 patients.
Acrylic C1-2 Fusions Poly-methyl-methacrylate (PMMA) onlay for atlantoaxial fixation was advocated as a fast option for surgical immobilization in patients with traumatic atlantoaxial
Fig. 6.42 Sonntag’s modification of AA graft and wire fixation
instability. Kelly et al. [124] successfully treated seven patients suffering from traumatic AA instability with pure C1-3 acrylic and wire fusion. Authors reported “fusion” in all cases in “satisfactory” position during an 8–9 year follow-up. Good, long-term results were also reported in other series [50, 206]. The experienced authors recommended using screw anchors imbedded in the acrylate to increase the long-term stability [50]. However, the main objections of polymethacrylate fixation method are the heat produced during polymerization process and the inability of PMMA to bond to bone. Further, a large number of revisions due to infection, inlay loosening, or inability to maintain spinal alignment led to substantial decrease in popularity of PMMA fixations [157]. In our opinion, PMMA can still be used as a palliative measure in UCS tumor surgery and/or if used in other indications, it has to be supplemented with additional bone grafting.
Halifax Atlantoaxial Interlaminar Clamps After a very successful application of interlaminar clamps in the treatment of subaxial cervical spine trauma [101, 227], this method was applied in the treatment of atlantoaxial instability as well. Cybulski et al. [39] confirmed the safety of interlaminar clamps with one out of eight clamps loosening prior to fusion. Clamps with claw-type construct avoid the need for sublaminar cable and its potential risks but the risk of neural injury is not completely depleted (Fig. 6.43). The exact fit of the clamps can be of concern under certain anatomical conditions, so can be the loosening of compressing screws. Previously described problems were the main reason for failure and revision of up to 20% of cases, especially in the absence of bony graft
104
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Fig. 6.43 Halifax clamp with interlaminar grafts
[4, 163, 210]. If iliac crest autograft is interposed and the halo vest applied then fusion rate improves dramatically [109]. Historically, other claw type constructs were also used. In summary, methods using posterior C1 and C2 arches to fix the segment do have some advantages but also some important disadvantages: Advantages – Simple to apply – Valuable addict to other more firm fusion methods – Can be a salvage procedure (AV injury during screw techniques) Disadvantages – Posterior elements must be intact – Not possible in low bone quality of arches (osteopenic status) – Cable has to pass bellow the arch of C1 (dangerous in dislocation) – High failure rate – Necessity for hard external support – Autologous graft-related complications
Our Preference Posterior wiring techniques have long been the mainstay of surgical stabilization of atlantoaxial complex. They are relatively easy but of limited stiffness. In particular, they cannot reach the same stability in translation and rotation when compared to other screw constructs. The “parallelogram effect” was well described by Panjabi [176]. The other concern is that they provide less than optimal fusion rates and external rigid immobilization is mandatory. Graft breakage or
wire loosening are relatively common complications of wiring techniques [251]. If there is a need for standalone posterior wiring technique, then the Sonntag modification should be used supplemented by external hard brace (SOMI) or a halo vest. It is generally accepted that solid bony fusion, when desired, is most reliably achieved when the segmental fixation minimizes motion. This is why the previously mentioned techniques were not the last point in C1-2 fixation development and more rigid screw constructs followed.
Transarticular C2-1 Screw Fixation (Magerl) Magerl’s technique of C1-2 fixation (Fig. 6.44), introduced in 1987 [152], gradually achieved a high degree of acceptance and success, mainly because of high fusion rates, instant stability, and relatively low incidence of complications. It has gained popularity over the wiring techniques used earlier for posterior atlantoaxial stabilization especially because of higher proven biomechanical stability avoiding the necessity of postoperative hard external support [82, 164, 188, 237]. High fusion rate (between 87 and 100%) was documented by many authors [36, 44, 69, 86, 91, 116, 154, 212, 214, 219]. As described earlier, a meticulous technique must be used to achieve a safe C2 transisthmic passage and adequate C1 lateral mass anchorage. Thorough preoperative anatomical analysis with 3D modeling in potentially risky cases is invaluable in identifying patients/sides unsuitable for the transisthmic screw [234]. As the risk of VA injury can be as high as 23% per patient in borderline cases, navigational systems can prove to be a useful adjunct [99, 100, 234]. Strong C1 anchorage is important, therefore the screw should be placed at least 5 mm within the bone and should not protrude more than 5 mm. Grob et al. [86] evaluated 161 patients in a multicentre Swiss study and found a 15% rate of less than perfectly positioned screws with 3.4% of them missing the C1 lateral mass. In our cohort of 80 patients collected from 4 centers, 150 screws were placed [219]. The morphology on one side of six patients prevented adequate screw placement and two procedures needed to be converted to posterior wire fusion. VA injury was encountered in four patients (5%) without clinical consequences. We found 28.6% of screws to be suboptimally placed. They were adequately imbedded in the
105
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs Fig. 6.44 Transarticular C2-1 fixation according to Magerl. (a, b) Posterior and lateral view. (c) Transarticular AA fixation supplemented with posterior graft and wire fusion
C1 lateral mass but in 6% they were too short, in 5.3% too long, and in the other 17.3% deviated out of middle third of the mass (Figs. 6.45–6.47). Four screws (2.7%) were misplaced (i.e., out of C1 lateral mass). Computerized navigation can substantially improve accuracy. Foley et al. [65] were the first who used stereotactic guidance to place atlantoaxial transarticular screws with improved safety. Weidner et al. [234]
placed 72 screws with image guidance and significantly decreased the frequency of suboptimally placed screws. On postoperative CT, they found lateral deviation only on three sides and medial, on only one. The anchorage within C1 lateral mass was always sufficient. Several authors reported a successful and safe placement of transarticular C1-2 screws in pediatric population as young as 3 years of age [23, 97].
Fig. 6.45 Correct transarticular screw position and length. (a) Transoral radiograph. (b) Lateral view
106
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Biomechanical superiority over posterior graft fixation techniques is given by more central position of the screws and was, indeed, confirmed in many biomechanical studies [82, 93, 132, 164, 188, 237]. The stability of the construct in flexion-extension is certainly improved by and comparable to Goel-Harms procedure if posterior wire-fixed graft is added [202]. On the
other hand, Naderi et al. [164] found that unilateral screw fixation is much less stable than bilateral one in all directions, especially in rotation. Sven Olerud suggested a modification of Magerl’s method to decrease the frequency of graft-related problems but mostly to increase the stability of the construct [174]. He connected transarticular screws to an
Fig. 6.46 Postoperative evaluation of transarticular screw position and length from plain X-rays (suboptimal means sufficient anchorage of C1 lateral mass). (a) Suboptimal purchase, too long screws. (b) Too short screws, suboptimal introduction.
(c) Suboptimal position, too medially located left screw. (d) Suboptimal purchase, too laterally located left screw. (e) Wrong trajectory, the screw is outside of C1 lateral mass
107
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs
Advantages of Magerl’s technique – Immediate and strong stability, no external support needed – Laminae could be absent, no wiring necessary – Longer construct incorporation is feasible if polyaxial screw heads are used – High fusion rate – If bone block-wire fusion added, biomechanically superior – Cost (it is significantly cheaper than other techniques) – Low profile of hardware Disadvantages of Magerl’s technique
Fig. 6.46 (continued)
adaptable claw attached to the posterior arch of C1 with a 3.5 mm rod. This innovative technique allows for use of morselized graft only because a structural block of bone was not necessary to create a posterior band. Another theoretical advantage is that the claw can grasp even a partially defective posterior C1 arch in situations where cable fixation would not be possible. The Olerud modification was later successfully used in 26 patients with 91% fusion rate treated for AA instability caused by trauma, RA, and developmental anomalies [35]. In our experience, there are advantages and disadvantages of the described technique:
– VA injury risk in up to 23% of patients – The angle of C2 transpedicular trajectory is not easy to achieve – Reduction feasibility of atlantoaxial dislocation possible, but limited – Cannot be used if target structures are comminuted or destructed – C1-2 joint is damaged – Learning curve necessary – Fluoroscopy mandatory
Our Preference Magerl’s fixation is often described as unsafe but it is not dangerous because of the technique itself. It is the surgeon who can make the procedure unsafe, usually as a result of inadequate preoperative radiological analysis
Fig. 6.47 CT verification of correct transarticular screw positions. (a) Oblique axial reconstruction. (b, c) Parasagittal reconstruction of both sides of pars interarticularis screw position
108
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
and deviating from the recommended trajectory through the C2 isthmus. Incorrect screw angle can often be a result of inappropriate patient positioning, a short neck, spine deformity, or hyperlordotic spine curve. Further, atlas settling, absent C1 anterior tubercle after transoral decompression or VA variability (in approximately 20% of patients) can lead to VA injury. On the other hand, if atlantoaxial transarticular fixation is correctly indicated and performed, it represents a very stable fixation avoiding the need for hard external bracing and providing high fusion rates. Certainly, in some countries, the lower cost of two screws when compared to other methods may be an important factor.
1 Lateral Mass – C2 Pedicle Screw C and Rod Fixation (Goel, Harms) Goel and Laheri performed the first C1-2 fusion in 1988 [72]. To achieve a wide exposure of the C1-2 joint they amputated the C2 nerve root in all cases. Both the C1 lateral mass and C2 pedicle screw were placed monocortically over a steel plate regularly used for finger bone osteosynthesis (economic reasons – personal communication) (Fig. 6.48). In some of their patients a longer plate was used to allow for occipitocervical fusion. Later, they analyzed a series of 160 patients treated for various C1-2 instabilities by their method [70]. They accepted a bicortical screw purchase as a more stable option and described some of the pitfalls of their method. In few cases, screw placement was impossible due to the encountered morphology. Eighteen patients described specific sensory loss in C2 root area. In four patients, they have seen profound arterial bleeding while drilling the pilot hole for C2 pedicle screw. Although it was not confirmed angiographically as
Fig. 6.48 Screw and plate AA fixation according to Goel
there were no neurological sequelae, they concluded that the bleeding was related to VA injury. They considered all constructs stable after 5 months of follow-up and only one screw was broken after 18 months. Postoperative CT was not routinely performed. The same method, supplemented by joint distraction and placement of a hydroxyapatite or titanium spacer was used in fixed atlantoaxial dislocation in 19 patients [71] to treat atlas settling or dislocation. Most of the patients (18) were suffering from fixed dislocated odontoid pseudoarthrosis and/or os odontoideum. Construct stability was not biomechanically tested and the authors had their patients wear a hard cervical collar for 3 months. Harms and Melcher, who advocated bicortical screw purchase, improved the technology of previously described fixation [94]. They developed polyaxial screws allowing top loaded rod connection (Fig. 6.49). The longer C1 screws with a smooth proximal shaft allowed sparing of the C2 nerve root and indirect manipulation of the atlas (in case of fracture distraction) and consequently in connection to C2 pedicle screws to manipulate the atlantoaxial joint. Their construct can easily be extended either cranially if occipitocervical fusion is required or caudally to fix the UCS to subaxial cervical spine. Bone graft can be packed either directly into the atlantoaxial joint or as a posterior onlay graft. The above-described techniques enable significantly more comfortable angles of screw placement; however, the risk of VA injury is not eliminated. Increasing number of publications documented successful use of Goel’s technique. Stulik et al. [215] performed atlantoaxial fusion with Harms instrumentation in 46 patients. They used the system either for temporary or permanent fixation. Twenty four patients were evaluated retrospectively with at least a 12-month follow-up. Three C2 screws (5.4%) were considered malpositioned on the postoperative CT scan, with one breaching the canal cortex and two encroaching the FT. They did not have any clinical complications and documented 100% fusion rate. Arayan et al. [14] retrospectively evaluated 102 patients treated with Harms fixation/fusion. In this probably largest available series, most of the patients (48 patients) were treated for instability caused by odontoid pseudoarthrosis. The authors used navigational system in first third of treated patients and neuromonitoring in all of them. They always cut the C2 nerve root with only one case of neuropathic pain in follow-up. They distracted the atlantoaxial joint when
109
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs
Fig. 6.49 (a) posterior (b) lateral view
needed using force transmitted through screws and in 38% of procedures introduced bilateral allograft spacer intra-articularly. In 23% of patients, at least one side was anatomically not suitable for C2 pedicle screw. Therefore, pars screws were placed (probably, the short ones) instead. The risk of VA injury in this study is similar to that of Magerl. Two VA injuries were encountered but happened during subperiostal exposure of C1 due to atypical VA loop. The strength of the construct was increased by regular use of crosslink. The followup revealed 98% fusion rate. The Goel-Harms technique was also successfully used in a limited number of pediatric patients (6 patients, the youngest being 7 years old). Similar restrictions applied to children as they do for adults [98]. The biomechanical stability of Harms technique was tested in multiple studies and it is similar to transarticular screw fixation if supplemented by posterior wiring [106, 132, 159]. Again, there are advantages as well as disadvantages of the described technique: Advantages of Goel-Harms technique – Immediate stability, no external support needed – The angle of C2 pedicle screw trajectory is easy to achieve – The screw placement is not dependent on relative C1-2 position – Reduction of atlantoaxial dislocation feasible during procedure – C1-2 joint is not damaged, temporary fixation is possible – Isolated C1 fracture compression practicable – Laminae could be absent, no wiring necessary
– Prolonging of construct easy – High fusion rate Disadvantages of Goel-Harms technique – VA injury risk underestimated and possibly as high as 23% of patients – Cannot be used if target structures are comminuted or destructed – Steep learning curve – Cost (Harms fixator is much more expensive than other techniques) – Fluoroscopy mandatory – High profile of the polyaxial construct Our Preference The Goel-Harms technique is a valuable tool in all types of C1-2 instability providing excellent immediate immobilization. The specific advantages in comparison to Magerl’s technique are of two kinds. First, the angle necessary for C2 pedicle screw placement is much easier to achieve and secondly, in cases of dislocated or fractured atlas, the vertebra can be manipulated independently. We would like to emphasize, however, that there is no evidence that this method has a lower risk of VA injury. 1 Lateral Mass – C2 Crosslaminar C Screw and Rod Fixation (Wright) Due to limited stability of C1-2 wiring fixations more rigid methods using C2 isthmic and/or pedicle screws were developed. All those techniques required for a
110
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
screw to pass through an anatomically variable area neighboring the C2 VA groove and thus posing a substantial risk to the artery. In order to avoid this technically demanding procedure, Wright [238] suggested to place two crossing laminar screws and connect them to C1 lateral mass screws with rods (Fig. 6.50). The acute stability of C1 lateral mass – C2 laminar screw fixation was biomechanically tested and compared to Harms construct and combination of laminar/ pedicle construct by Gorek et al. [77]. No statistically significant differences in stiffness were found and, at least in cadaver models, the laminar screw construct is comparable to other atlantoaxial fixation techniques. However, other authors demonstrated less rigidity with laminar screw constructs when compared to pedicle screw anchor, most pronounced during lateral bending and rotation [32, 135]. Similar results were confirmed by Dmitriev who studied construct stiffness after an experimental odontoid process transection [47]. The position of laminar polyaxial screw heads does not allow the use of sublaminar wire in C1-2 fixations. The eventual bone graft has to be fashioned to stay below the rods. The other concern, in comparison to Harms technique, is the possibility to manipulate C1 on C2 with the help of distraction/compression forceps when the screw heads are near to the spinous process of C2. Although never biomechanically proven, the proximity of the laminar screw heads to the medial axis and the curvilinear rod needed to connect them can potentially be less resistant to lateral translation, bending, and rotational forces. This can be of increased importance if unexpected polyaxial screw head would not retain initial stability. Advantages – No risk of VA injury – Less technically demanding
Fig. 6.50 Artist’s drawing of C1 lateral mass – C2 crosslaminar AA fixation according to Wright
– Can be used if C2 pedicle or pars is not large enough to accept a 3.5 mm screw – Can be a salvage procedure in cases of C2 pedicle/ pars erroneous placement – Decreased perioperative radiation exposure – Direct visualization of the target structure (i.e., C2 laminae) – Retained possibility to reduce the C1-C2 dislocation – Independence on C1 position – Easy angle of screw trajectory – Immediate C1-2 construct stability compared to other rigid techniques – Good long-term stability of translaminar screws in short C1-3 constructs Disadvantages – Cannot be used if C2 laminae are absent – If the core diameter of lamina is less than 3.5 mm, cortical breach can occur – Potential risk of spinal cord injury – Fixation of Gallie’s type graft can be difficult – Not enough space to connect C2 to C3 lateral mass screw – Offset connectors or significant rod contouring necessary – Problematic long-term stability in long subaxial constructs
Our Preference In our department, we use Wright’s technique with increasing frequency, mostly as a salvage procedure in situations where a high-riding VA prevents a pedicle or transarticular screw placement. This is usually only on one side in the construct. So far only once, has this situation occurred bilaterally (Fig. 6.51).
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs
111
Fig. 6.51 Bilateral high riding VA in patient with odontoid pseudoarthrosis not allowing any C2 postero-anterior (transisthmic, transpedicular) screw introduction treated by crosslaminar screw C2 – massa lateralis C1 fixation acc. to Wright. (a) Frontal
plane reconstruction. (b) Postoperative axial scan in the C2 arch plane. (c) Plain postoperative laterogram. (d) CT in 3D posterior crosslaminar C2 screw purchase and C1 lateral mass screw fixation supplemented with autologous graft
Intralaminar Screws C1 – Short Pars C2 (Donnellan)
nor lateral mass fixation or wiring of the atlas. Donnellan et al. [48] suggested to use a combination of intralaminar C1 screws connected to short C2 pars screws (Fig. 6.52). They have documented good results and 100% fusion rate in three patients treated with this technique. The method seems safe, avoiding all the known risks of arterial injury but has not been biomechanically tested so far.
In rare cases, the posterior C1 arch can be defective and the lateral mass eroded by inflammatory or degenerative process together with concomitant C2 high riding VA. This situation does not allow either placement of transarticular or pedicle screw fixation in the axis
112
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
Fig. 6.52 Artistic drawing of intralaminar C1 – short isthmic C2 AA fixation suggested by Donnellan
Our Preference In our opinion, only rarely does a situation arise requiring the use of this construct. Nonetheless, it does represent a salvage option if more robust constructs are impossible. We suppose that a construct connecting C1 and C1 laminar screws is another less stable, salvage option of atlantoaxial fixation.
6.4.2 Anterior Monosegmental Fusion Constructs 6.4.2.1 Anterior Screw Fixation of C2-1 Lesoin et al. [141] were the first to perform anterior transarticular C2-1 fusion in six patients with acute or chronic posttraumatic C1-2 instability (Fig. 6.14). They used right-sided high anterolateral approach to place 25–35 mm long screws from C2 body perpendicularly through the joint reaching the C1 lateral masses. However, their approach was quite extensive and the head rotated 15° away from the exposed side. Also, the indications were not in concordance with current expert opinions. A similar technique, but performed from less invasive, oblique approach (like for odontoid screw) with intraarticular curette decortications, was described by Sonntag and Dickman [45, 209]. The same group of authors later used a combination of odontoid screw and two anterior transarticular screws as a salvage procedure to stabilize an 85-yearold man with combined atlas-axis fracture [11]. Analyzing dry specimens and embalmed cadavers, anatomical guidelines for anterior atlantoaxial fixation were suggested by Lu et al. [146]. Using the same entry points as previous authors, they recommended to place 15–25 mm long screws in lateral angle of 5°–25°
and posterior angle of 10°–25°. Vaccaro et al. [230] performed bilateral high cervical approach, directly decorticated the atlantoaxial joints and packed them with bone graft and placed bilateral transarticular screws. They used K-wires introduced under biplanar fluoroscopy followed by tapping and cannulated screw placement. Although, the usual lateral trajectory angle of 30° is described, they actually used a 0° angle in coronal plane and 25° posterior tilt in sagittal plane. The screws were 26 mm long on both sides in their case. The patient was placed in long-term, postoperative halo vest as the original indication for surgery was a failed posterior Brooks’s fixation for odontoid pseudoarthrosis. In 1999, Knöller et al. presented the first larger series of patients (11) treated for odontoid process pseudoarthrosis with only temporary anterior transarticular fixation [127]. Another case of fixation of combined unstable atlantoaxial fractures (odontoid and C1) treated with anterior triple screw fixation was published by Reindl et al. [184]. The initial concerns about the short-term stability of anterior atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation techniques were disputed by biomechanical work of Sen et al. [202]. They tested posterior versus anterior transarticular fixation techniques in nine cadavers and did not find any significant differences between these two techniques. However, they discovered that if a cable fixed graft is added to the posterior fixation, stability was significantly higher especially in flexion and extension. They placed the screw in lateral angle of 20° and posteriorly tilted in an angle of 30°. The screws were introduced perpendicularly to the joint fissure in the middle third of articulation. The entry point was located in the groove created by articulation process in the middle of C2 body. Koller et al. suggested different trajectory for anterior transarticular screw fixation, having performed a thorough anatomical analysis of fine CT scans with 3D reconstructions in 42 healthy individuals and
113
6.4 Monosegmental Fusion Constructs
comprehensive literature review [131]. They described a safe zone of approximately 14 mm in the midsagittal base of C2 vertebral body. They proposed a precise algorithm for safe screw placement from the base of C2 through the body to the C1 lateral mass (Fig. 6.15). The transcorporeal route logically enables the use of a longer screw bone passage and therefore also a higher construct stiffness. On the other hand, using the C2 pinafore does not allow triple screw introduction if odontoid screw is needed. Respecting their own anatomical results, the authors successfully fused atlantoaxial joint in seven patients concluding that the indication for anterior can be the same as for posterior fusion and thus anterior procedure can be recommended especially if anatomical situation precludes the posterior one. Advantages – – – – – –
Less muscular damage Smaller risk of VA injury Relatively easy approach (no cavity opened) Trajectory angle is easy to achieve Possible combination with odontoid screw technique Comparable short-time stability to other screw techniques – Theoretical possibility to extend the screw trajectory to fix the occipital condyle
occipital joint. The exact preoperative radiological analysis and perioperative biplanar fluoroscopy are mandatory. In our opinion, the main disadvantage is that only intra-articular surface can be used to potentiate the fusion but no additional graft can be added out of it. Questionable long-term stability makes this method more exceptional and useful in rare specific cases as it is documented by the lack of published larger series of patients.
6.4.2.3 Anterior Plate or Construct C1-2 Anterior atlantoaxial plate to stabilize the C1-2 after transoral odontoidectomy was proposed by Harms et al. [95]. The plate was fixed by two screws to the anterior lateral C1 masses and by two other to the C2 vertebral body (Fig. 6.53). Fifth screw transfixed the axis body at the base of the odontoid process. Their technique was biomechanically tested by Kandziora et al. [121] who found out that, only if supplemented by posterior Brooks fusion, is this technique comparable in rigidity to Magerl’s procedure alone. Previous biomechanical conclusion was confirmed by clinical series of 15 patients treated for irreducible atlantoaxial
Disadvantages – – – – –
Limited amount of bone graft, only intraarticularly Long-term stability questionable Biplanar fluoroscopy necessary Decompression, if necessary, hardly possible Possible violation of spinal canal (too posterior trajectory) – Possible violation of atlanto-occipital joint (too long screw) 6.4.2.2 Our Preference The technique is very elegant in some atlantoaxial combination fractures where the anterior transarticular screw technique can be combined with odontoid screw or anterior C2/3 plate (Fig. 14.3, Chap. 14). Also, in cases of failed posterior fusion or anatomical situation not allowing posterior fixation, this method can serve as a salvage procedure. The attention should be focused not only to the angles of purchase but also to the length of screws, not to unintentionally damage the atlanto-
Fig. 6.53 Anterior plate for transoral AA transoral fixation designed by Harms
114
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
kyphosis [125]. Kerschbaumer et al. saw two cases of screw loosening in their first three patients treated with Harms plate as a standalone fixation and they, therefore, always supplemented the anterior plate with posterior Brooks’s fusion with good long-term results [125]. Kandziora et al. [122] also criticized the design of Harms plate and suggested a new one with locked screws located in more condensed subarticular bone in C2 near to the base of odontoid (subarticular atlantoaxial locking plate (SAALP)). They confirmed higher biomechanical stability for their type of plate; however, clinical data for the new plate are not available. In order to avoid the need for posterior stabilization, another plate with locked screws and option to reduce atlantoaxial kyphosis was designed by Yin et al. [247]. This is done with special forceps distracting the cranial part of plate against temporarily inserted C2 body screw ( transoral atlantoaxial reduction plate (TARP)). They have successfully reduced and fixed 4 patients with odontoid pseudoarthrosis and kyphotic deformity. The demand to reconstruct anterior column with sparing of adjacent segment motion, resulted in design of more complex constructs replacing the C2 vertebral body in tumor surgery. Sar and Eralp [197] used a custom-modified Harms cage fixed with screws in C1 and C2 to replace the C2 anterior body in a patient with C2 sarcoma. For the same purpose, C2 body prosthesis was developed and used by Jeszenszky et al. [118].
achieve this goal, anterior atlantoaxial release must be possible. This is not always the case. In RA patients and some developmental anomalies, the joint could be severely deformed and it can be very difficult to circumferentially release it. If incompletely released, it can be dangerous to use inappropriate force to reduce it. The bone is often very weak and does not provide strong support for intra-articular distraction instruments. C1 lateral masses can be so deformed and pronounced that any screw purchase is problematic. In our opinion, if the reduction is not achievable with traction prior to the surgery, its surgical reducibility can only be realized during the procedure thus postponing the decision to use or not to use the plate to this moment. The infection risk is higher than for standard transoral procedure because the time necessary for fixation prolongs the surgery and also the lateral exposure necessary to fix the plate to C1 is much larger implicating important soft retropharyngeal tissue damage. In summary, anterior C1-2 plating can be advantageous if preoperatively irreducible AAD can be released during the surgery. Then, the most sophisticated locking plate should be used. The complex constructs used to support anterior column after tumor resection represent a different topic, which will be described in tumor chapter.
6.4.3 Lateral Monosegmental Fusion
Advantages – Direct anterior decompression – Sophisticated plate can reach enough stability to avoid posterior fixation – Atlantoaxial release possible – Atlantoaxial kyphotization can be reduced – Atlantoaxial joint can be distracted Disadvantages – Risk of infection of intracavitary approach – Wide exposure causing more damage of soft tissue (approx. 4 cm) – Possible screw loosening – Risky revision (infection) – If reduction fails, posterior compression cannot be eliminated 6.4.2.4 Our Preference A sophisticated locking plate with realignment ability can really address the problem of IAAD. However, to
Lateral atlantoaxial fusion was first used by Barbour from Australia to treat the odontoid fractures in 1971 [17]. As he mentioned, starting in 1956, he was probably the first who used stable screw fixation of C1-2. He used a skin incision along the anterior border of sternocleidomastoid and extended it behind the mandibular angle to reach the lateral position of C1 transverse process. He nibbled it partially away and asked anesthesiologist to turn the head to neutral position and introduced the screw from C1 lateral mass medially and downward transarticularly to C2 (Fig. 6.54). The same procedure was then performed from the opposite side. He recommended placing iliac crest onlay grafts on the lateral vertebral surface. Unfortunately, neither number of treated patients nor the follow-up data are presented in his original paper. Encouraged by Barbour’s work but not satisfied with approach difficulties, Du Toit modified the technique and successfully treated a patient with odontoid fracture [49]. He learnt from cadaveric dissections and used an angled skin incision to cut off the proximal attachment of SCM to reach the
115
6.5 CVJ and UCS as a Part of Multisegmental Constructs
Fig. 6.54 Drawing of lateral down-slope transarticular C1-2 fixation performed from bilateral approach according to Barbour and DuToit
transverse process of C1. Anterolateral aspect of atlas and lateral joint fissure was reached strictly subperiostally. Then he denuded the joint and filled it with autologous morselized bone. The drilling was performed caudally (25° below horizontal plane) and posteromedially with custom-made drill guide allowing maximal 10° of backward angle and had 24 mm depth stop. The pilot hole was tapped and the joint transfixed with AO navicular screws. To avoid eventual spinal canal penetration, he established 20° as a maximal posterior tilt of drilling. Later, this group described four other cases (os odontoideum and dens pseudoarthrosis) successfully treated with bilateral transarticular screw fusion [205].
6.4.3.1 Our Preference We see some important drawbacks to have this procedure in standard fusion armamentarium. First of all the bilateral access is needed, the anatomy of the approach is complicated with the accessory nerve, auricular nerve, jugular vein but namely VA in dangerous positions. Second, there is not enough bony surface for eventual bone graft insertion and one has to believe that intra-articular fusion potential would be enough.
6.5 CVJ and UCS as a Part of Multisegmental Constructs CVJ and UCS instability are disorders caused by various etiologies including trauma, inflammation, developmental anomaly, tumors, degenerative disease,
and/or iatrogenic decompression. During stabilization procedures, one should avoid undesirable fusion of disease-free segments and attempt to fix only the unstable spinal motion units. This is of utmost importance in CVJ, the most mobile area of the spine. Generally, we can divide long constructs to those involving the occiput (occipitocervical) and those starting subaxially and ending at C2 or C1 (suboccipital constructs). The decision process always involves striking a balance between the loss of range of motion versus the required extent of construct anchorage. Occipitocervical fusion is indicated when the CVJ, namely occipitoatlantal segment, is unstable or it is expected that further progression of pathological process can involve this joint (RA patients, tumors, etc.). Any multisegmental fusion has to be supplemented with bone grafts with or without addition of bone growth accelerators. The exceptions from this rule are those with secondary bone tumors with limited life expectancy.
6.5.1 Occipitocervical Constructs By definition, this technique always involves the occipital bone. The fusion extends at least to C2, often to subaxial vertebrae, and sometimes is performed as skip framework starting at occiput skipping C1 and/or C2 and ending usually in two or three level fixation to subaxial lateral masses or pedicles. Performing any procedure fixating the cervical spine to head the surgeon must adapt the craniospinal angle in sagittal plane and respect the neutral rotational position [155]. This is to allow the patient neutral horizontal view otherwise the dictated position in non physiological flexion, extension, and/or rotation will lead to compensatory deformation of spine balance. In patients with substantial sagittal profile derangement, we also have to calculate the whole spine profile with potential planning of corrective spinal osteotomy in other regions. It is well known that hyperflexed cervical spine can also cause swallowing and breathing difficulties [15]. Foerster was the first who described the occipitocervical fusion with the use of fibular strut graft, in 1927 [64]. Newman and Sweetman, in 1969, reported a series of nine patients treated with occipitocervical onlay autograft. They had only one pseudoarthrosis but their patients were postoperatively treated with 6 weeks of tong traction and then placed in Minerva
116
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
jacket for another 6 weeks [169]. Freely lodged standalone grafts did not secure any stability and the fusion rate can be also very low [62]. Therefore, wiring techniques were introduced to fix these grafts [78, 92, 110, 235]. Also, methylmethacrylate was used to enhance the occipitocervical stabilization [25]. Later, Ransford et al. introduced contoured Lugue rod again fixed with wire to posterior elements as a more stable technique [183]. This wire and frame application was further modified using different metal rods or pins [10, 59, 113]. All the techniques using wires for fixation, however, had some drawbacks. The stability was not very high and the external fixation with halo vest or Minerva jacket had to be used, the posterior elements (occipital bone, laminae) had to be intact, sublaminary introduced hardware can injure the underlying neural structures and their coverings [149, 171, 211, 221] and the wires often have a tendency to abrade through the bone [43]. Despite prolonged external immobilization, in halo vest or Minerva cast, the wire fixation methods have failure rates up to 30% [145, 190]. The previously mentioned techniques most often used doubled holes in the occipital calvarium to pass the wires through. To increase the stability of so called “semi-rigid techniques,” Grob et al. [81] described Y plate connecting the transarticular C1-2 screws with the occiput, where two screws fixed it to midline. Comparing cohort of patients treated with this technique with another group of patients fixed with older graft wiring, the same authors found pseudoarthrosis rate of 6% vs. 27%, respectively [85]. Grob was also the first who performed the occipital midline screw placement as he knew that there is the thickest bone available. This new plate and screw “rigid” technique was confirmed as good enough to provide up to 100% of fusion without indispensability of hard external supports by Sasso et al. using two AO plates fixed by screws to occiput and to Magerl screws, caudally [199]. Promising results of other authors gained popularity for plate and screw occipitocervical fusion [175, 196, 207]. Screw and plate techniques were also confirmed as much more stable than all the other previous by many biomechanical studies thus allowing to fuse less segments than before [7, 111, 173]. Their main concern is that the plate, although contoured, has defined holes for screws and thus determines their position often to less than optimal location. The other problem is in lining of the construct. This means that most of plates even if bended are reaching lateral occipital regions where
there is limited thickness of the bone. Screw purchase cannot be strong enough and bicortical introduction is potentially dangerous. Pait et al. suggested the insideoutside technique to avoid the screw loosening, subdural injury, and allow lateral occipital purchase [175]. They performed a trephination out of finally planed screw location and then cut a slit with craniotome ending at the desired position. The flat screw head is passed to this position epidurally from trephination hole and the nut is then used to fix it to the plate. Nevertheless, this sophisticated technique could be impossible in patients with very thin bone. Another concern of plate and screw technique is higher frequency of screw breakage and pullout caused by stress transmitted to hardware interfaces. To overcome the problem, modular systems were introduced [1, 170, 178]. Most of them have isolated (non dependent) occipital plate with a variety of available screw positions. This plate is connected with malleable rod to the screws (mostly, polyaxial ones) introduced in C1 lateral masses, C2 anchors, and/or to subaxial spine screws. Currently, the instrumentation is made up from Titanium alloy and the rods usually fortified or thickened in the place of craniovertebral bending. Although the variability of modular systems is providing much more flexibility in surgical decision there are still advocates of the use of the plate and screw systems [170]. Their main argument is higher resistance in lateral bending confirmed by biomechanical works [7] and the ability to correct deformity according the pre-shaped contour of the plate during tightening of the screws. Nevertheless, the potential to correct a deformity is probably higher using the modular systems [1].
6.5.1.1 Our Preference According to Grob [84], the ideal CVJ fixating system should: fix only the target segment, not encroach into the spinal canal, provide immediate reduction and stability, and be effective if laminae are absent. We would like to add that currently there is also a desire to have a system strong enough to provide long-term stability, made up from biocompatible and MRI-friendly materials and modular – means easy to use. The modular facility is very important not only because it makes the surgical work more comfortable but also it allows correct placement of anchoring elements (screws) without any stress created either to hardware or the underlying
117
References
bone. The other demand is its low profile especially in occipital region and connectivity to eventual continuing caudal fusion constructs (RA patients). In summary, there is a very rare indication for semirigid fixation of adult CVJ nowadays. On the other hand, there is still a place for autologous grafts and wires in very small children with surgically corrected instabilities and deformities in our opinion. Their potential for bony healing is very high as well their adaptability to external hard brace wearing. The correctly longitudinally placed autograft (often, the rib) can grow without limitations given by fixed hardware. In some cases, temporary metal fixation can be considered as well. Nowadays, we are not using the plates and screws. The restraints of screw positioning determined by fixed position of holes do not allow introducing the screws correctly and the mechanical stress created after tightening of screws is too large. The consequent potential screw breakage and/or loosening usually require revision and prolong the bone fusion. Also, the required contouring of the plates to reach the acceptable angle in craniovertebral transition (up to 80°) can lead to material microfractures and weakness. The midline occipital screw anchorage, which is in our opinion the strongest and safest, can be hardly achieved even with pre-bend and medially angulated plates. The biomechanical argument supporting the use of plates because of greater stiffness can be overcome with the new developments where the connecting rods are reinforced and the use of strut grafts is a regular part of the constructs. Modern modular systems allow independent placement of screws in the most suitable positions without any stress (Figs. 19.23 and 19.29, Chap. 19). They allow multidirectional manipulation (reduction, distraction, rotation, etc.) with the help of supplemented forceps adapted to be able to connect different screws. The grafts can be placed easily because the constructs are more subtle and not covering the acceptor side. The fusion rates and stability achieved are similar or even superior to previously described modalities. As in other long constructs, the final goal – bony fusion has to be achieved. This is of utmost importance, especially in the dangerous UCS region. Correct decortication of acceptor area and preferably autologous bone should be used in our opinion. Despite all the potential complications accompanying the autologous bone harvesting, its osteogenic, osteoinductive, and osteoconductive potential cannot be substituted by any other material. Although the allograft, bone
substitute, or BMP can be added, autologous bone should always form the majority of the graft content.
6.5.2 Suboccipital Constructs Whenever possible, we prefer to exclude the occiput out of the fusion. Atlanto-occipital joint is responsible for up to 40% of cervical flexion and extension and therefore should be spared. The same can be said about the atlantoaxial connection responsible for 60% of cervical spine rotations. It is clear that if a solid anchorage can be used then it is not necessary to prolong the fixation to a desirable length. For example, a C2 pedicle screw, if acceptable as cranial construct end, is one of the most firm anchorages available in cervical spine. On the other hand, if short isthmic screw is chosen, then one can hesitate about its strength and extend the fixation to C1. The majority of suboccipital multisegmental fusions are performed for complex, combined surgeries treating multilevel stenosis, deformity, tumors, or infection [201].
6.5.3 Anterior Multisegmental Constructs Large decompressions in the deformity cases and mainly in tumors can lead to important loss of structures supporting anterior CVJ and UCS. In such cases, posterior occipitocervical fusion can be considered as insufficient and the anterior column is reconstructed with custom-made titanium mesh cages fixed with or without plates to different anatomical structures, anteriorly [187, 217].
References 1. Abumi, K., Takada, T., Shono, Y., et al.: Posterior occipitocervical reconstruction using cervical pedicle screws and platerod systems. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 1425–1434 (1999) 2. Aebi, M., Etter, C., Coscia, M.: Fractures of the odontoid process. Treatment with anterior screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 14, 1065–1070 (1989) 3. Ai, F., Yin, Q., Wang, Z., et al.: Applied anatomy of transoral atlantoaxial reduction plate internal fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 128–132 (2006)
118
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
4. Aldrich, E.F., Weber, P.B., Crow, W.N.: Halifax interlaminar clamp for posterior cervical fusion: a long-term follow-up review. J Neurosurg 78, 702–708 (1993) 5. Alosh, H., Parker, S.L., McGirt, M.J., et al.: Preoperative radiographic factors and surgeon experience are associated with cortical breach of C2 pedicle screws. J Spinal Disord Tech 23, 9–14 (2010) 6. Ames, C.P., Crawford, N.R., Chamberlain, R.H., et al.: Biomechanical evaluation of a bioresorbable odontoid screw. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 182–187 (2005) 7. Anderson, P.A., Oza, A.L., Puschak, T.J., et al.: Biomechanics of occipitocervical fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 755–761 (2006) 8. Aota, Y., Honda, A., Uesugi, M., et al.: Vertebral artery injury in C-1 lateral mass screw fixation. Case illustration. J Neurosurg Spine 5, 554 (2006) 9. Apfelbaum, R.I., Lonser, R.R., Veres, R., et al.: Direct anterior screw fixation for recent and remote odontoid fractures. J Neurosurg 93, 227–236 (2000) 10. Apostolides, P.J., Dickman, C.A., Golfinos, J.G., et al.: Threaded steinmann pin fusion of the craniovertebral junction. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 1630–1637 (1996) 11. Apostolides, P.J., Theodore, N., Karahalios, D.G., et al.: Triple anterior screw fixation of an acute combination atlasaxis fracture. Case report. J Neurosurg 87, 96–99 (1997) 12. Arlet, V., Datta, J.C.: Upper cervical spine. In: Aebi, M., Arlet, V., Webb, J.K. (eds.) AO spine manual: principles and techniques, vol I, pp. 265–288. Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart, New York (2007) 13. Arnautovic, K.I., al-Mefty, O., Pait, T.G., et al.: The suboccipital cavernous sinus. J Neurosurg 86, 252–262 (1997) 14. Aryan, H.E., Newman, C.B., Nottmeier, E.W., et al.: Stabilization of the atlantoaxial complex via C-1 lateral mass and C-2 pedicle screw fixation in a multicenter clinical experience in 102 patients: modification of the Harms and Goel techniques. J Neurosurg Spine 8, 222–229 (2008) 15. Bagley, C.A., Witham, T.F., Pindrik, J.A., et al.: Assuring optimal physiologic craniocervical alignment and avoidance of swallowing-related complications after occipitocervical fusion by preoperative halo vest placement. J Spinal Disord Tech 22, 170–176 (2009) 16. Bambakidis, N.C., Feiz-Erfan, I., Horn, E.M., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of occipitoatlantal screw fixation techniques. J Neurosurg Spine 8, 143–152 (2008) 17. Barbour, J.R.: Screw fixation in fracture of the odontoid process. S Aust Clin 5, 20–24 (1971) 18. Blagg, S.E., Don, A.S., Robertson, P.A.: Anatomic determination of optimal entry point and direction for C1 lateral mass screw placement. J Spinal Disord Tech 22, 233–239 (2009) 19. Bloch, O., Holly, L.T., Park, J., et al.: Effect of frameless stereotaxy on the accuracy of C1-2 transarticular screw placement. J Neurosurg 95, 74–79 (2001) 20. Bohler, J.: Anterior stabilization for acute fractures and nonunions of the dens. J Bone Joint Surg Am 64, 18–27 (1982) 21. Bohm, H., Kayser, R., El Saghir, H., et al.: Direct osteosynthesis of instable Gehweiler Type III atlas fractures. Presentation of a dorsoventral osteosynthesis of instable atlas fractures while maintaining function. Unfallchirurg 109, 754–760 (2006) 22. Borne, G.M., Bedou, G.L., Pinaudeau, M.: Treatment of pedicular fractures of the axis. A clinical study and screw fixation technique. J Neurosurg 60, 88–93 (1984)
23. Brockmeyer, D.L., York, J.E., Apfelbaum, R.I.: Anatomical suitability of C1-2 transarticular screw placement in pediatric patients. J Neurosurg 92, 7–11 (2000) 24. Brooks, A.L., Jenkins, E.B.: Atlanto-axial arthrodesis by the wedge compression method. J Bone Joint Surg Am 60, 279–284 (1978) 25. Bryan, W.J., Inglis, A.E., Sculco, T.P., et al.: Methyl methacrylate stabilization for enhancement of posterior cervical arthrodesis in rheumatoid arthritis. J Bone Joint Surg Am 64, 1045–1050 (1982) 26. Cacciola, F., Phalke, U., Goel, A.: Vertebral artery in relationship to C1-C2 vertebrae: an anatomical study. Neurol India 52, 178–184 (2004) 27. Cassinelli, E.H., Lee, M., Skalak, A., et al.: Anatomic considerations for the placement of C2 laminar screws. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 2767–2771 (2006) 28. Castillo, C., Vinas, F.C., Gutikhonda, M., et al.: Microsurgical anatomy of the suboccipital segment of the vertebral artery. Neurol Res 20, 201–208 (1998) 29. Chamoun, R.B., Whitehead, W.E., Curry, D.J., et al.: Computed tomography morphometric analysis for C-1 lateral mass screw placement in children. Clinical article. J Neurosurg Pediatr 3, 20–23 (2009) 30. Chen, J.F., Wu, C.T., Lee, S.C., et al.: Posterior atlantoaxial transpedicular screw and plate fixation. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 386–392 (2005) 31. Christensen, D.M., Eastlack, R.K., Lynch, J.J., et al.: C1 anatomy and dimensions relative to lateral mass screw placement. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 32, 844–848 (2007) 32. Claybrooks, R., Kayanja, M., Milks, R., et al.: Atlantoaxial fusion: a biomechanical analysis of two C1-C2 fusion techniques. Spine J 7, 682–688 (2007) 33. Cone, W., Turner, W.G.: The treatment of fracture-dislocations of the cervical vertebrae by skeletal traction and fusion. J Bone Joint Surg Am 19, 584–602 (1937) 34. Cooper, D.F.: Bone erosion of the cervical vertebrae secondary to tortuosity of the vertebral artery: case report. J Neurosurg 53, 106–108 (1980) 35. Cornefjord, M., Henriques, T., Alemany, M., et al.: Posterior atlanto-axial fusion with the Olerud Cervical Fixation System for odontoid fractures and C1-C2 instability in rheumatoid arthritis. Eur Spine J 12, 91–96 (2003) 36. Coyne, T.J., Fehlings, M.G., Wallace, M.C., et al.: C1-C2 posterior cervical fusion: long-term evaluation of results and efficacy. Neurosurgery 37, 688–692 (1995). discussion 692-683 37. Currier, B.L., Maus, T.P., Eck, J.C., et al.: Relationship of the internal carotid artery to the anterior aspect of the C1 vertebra: implications for C1-C2 transarticular and C1 lateral mass fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 33, 635–639 (2008) 38. Currier, B.L., Todd, L.T., Maus, T.P., et al.: Anatomic relationship of the internal carotid artery to the C1 vertebra: a case report of cervical reconstruction for chordoma and pilot study to assess the risk of screw fixation of the atlas. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, E461–E467 (2003) 39. Cybulski, G.R., Stone, J.L., Crowell, R.M., et al.: Use of Halifax interlaminar clamps for posterior C1-C2 arthrodesis. Neurosurgery 22, 429–431 (1988) 40. Cyr, S.J., Currier, B.L., Eck, J.C., et al.: Fixation strength of unicortical versus bicortical C1-C2 transarticular screws. Spine J 8, 661–665 (2008)
References 41. De Iure, F., Donthineni, R., Boriani, S.: Outcomes of C1 and C2 posterior screw fixation for upper cervical spine fusion. Eur Spine J 18(Suppl 1), 2–6 (2009) 42. Dickman, C.A., Mariano, F.F.: Principles and techniques of screw fixation in the cervical spine. In: Menezes, A.H., Sonntag, V.K.H. (eds.) Principles of spinal surgery, pp. 123–139. McGraw-Hill, New York (1996) 43. Dickman, C.A., Papadopoulos, S.M., Crawford, N.R., et al.: Comparative mechanical properties of spinal cable and wire fixation systems. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 22, 596–604 (1997) 44. Dickman, C.A., Sonntag, V.K.: Posterior C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation for atlantoaxial arthrodesis. Neurosurgery 43, 275–280 (1998). discussion 280–271 45. Dickman, C.A., Sonntag, V.K.H., Marcotte, P.J.: Techniques of screw fixation of the cervical spine. BNI Q 8, 9–26 (1992) 46. Dickman, C.A., Sonntag, V.K., Papadopoulos, S.M., et al.: The interspinous method of posterior atlantoaxial arthrodesis. J Neurosurg 74, 190–198 (1991) 47. Dmitriev, A.E., Lehman Jr., R.A., Helgeson, M.D., et al.: Acute and long-term stability of atlantoaxial fixation methods: a biomechanical comparison of pars, pedicle, and intralaminar fixation in an intact and odontoid fracture model. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34, 365–370 (2009) 48. Donnellan, M.B., Sergides, I.G., Sears, W.R.: Atlantoaxial stabilization using multiaxial C-1 posterior arch screws. J Neurosurg Spine 9, 522–527 (2008) 49. Du Toit, G.: Lateral atlanto-axial arthrodesis. A screw fixation technique. S Afr J Surg 14, 9–12 (1976) 50. Duff, T.A., Khan, A., Corbett, J.E.: Surgical stabilization of cervical spinal fractures using methyl methacrylate. Technical considerations and long-term results in 52 patients. J Neurosurg 76, 440–443 (1992) 51. Dull, S.T., Toselli, R.M.: Preoperative oblique axial computed tomographic imaging for C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation: technical note. Neurosurgery 37, 150–151 (1995). discussion 151–152 52. Dvorak, M.F., Fisher, C., Boyd, M., et al.: Anterior occiputto-axis screw fixation: part I: a case report, description of a new technique, and anatomical feasibility analysis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, E54–E60 (2003) 53. Dvorak, M.F., Sekeramayi, F., Zhu, Q., et al.: Anterior occiput to axis screw fixation: part II: a biomechanical comparison with posterior fixation techniques. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, 239–245 (2003) 54. Ebraheim, N.A., Fow, J., Xu, R., et al.: The location of the pedicle and pars interarticularis in the axis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, E34–E37 (2001) 55. Ebraheim, N.A., Lu, J., Biyani, A., et al.: An anatomic study of the thickness of the occipital bone. Implications for occipitocervical instrumentation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 1725–1729 (1996). discussion 1729-1730 56. Ebraheim, N.A., Misson, J.R., Xu, R., et al.: The optimal transarticular C1-2 screw length and the location of the hypoglossal nerve. Surg Neurol 53, 208–210 (2000) 57. Ebraheim, N.A., Xu, R., Ahmad, M., et al.: The quantitative anatomy of the vertebral artery groove of the atlas and its relation to the posterior atlantoaxial approach. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 320–323 (1998) 58. Eck, J.C., Walker, M.P., Currier, B.L., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of unicortical versus bicortical C1 lateral mass screw fixation. J Spinal Disord Tech 20, 505–508 (2007)
119 59. Fehlings, M.G., Errico, T., Cooper, P., et al.: Occipitocervical fusion with a five-millimeter malleable rod and segmental fixation. Neurosurgery 32, 198–207 (1993). discussion 207–198 60. Feiz-Erfan, I., Gonzalez, L.F., Dickman, C.A.: Atlantooccipital transarticular screw fixation for the treatment of traumatic occipitoatlantal dislocation. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 381–385 (2005) 61. Finn, M.A., Apfelbaum, R.I.: Atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation: update on technique and outcomes in 269 patients. Neurosurgery 66, A184–A192 (2010) 62. Finn, M.A., Bishop, F.S., Dailey, A.T.: Surgical treatment of occipitocervical instability. Neurosurgery 63, 961–968 (2008). discussion 968–969 63. Floyd, T., Grob, D.: Translaminar screws in the atlas. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25, 2913–2915 (2000) 64. Foerster, O.: Leitungsbahnen des Schmerzgefuhls und die chirurgische Behandlung der Schmerzzustande. Urban & Schwarzenberg, Berlin (1927) 65. Foley, K.T., Silveri, C.P., Vaccaro, A.R., et al.: Atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation: Risk assessment and bone morphology using an image guidance system. J Bone Joint Surg Br 80(Suppl), 245 (1998) 66. Fried, L.C.: Atlanto-axial fracture-dislocations. Failure of posterior C.1 to C.2 fusion. J Bone Joint Surg Br 55, 490– 496 (1973) 67. Gallie, W.E.: Fractures and dislocations of the cervical spine. Am J Surg 46, 495–499 (1939) 68. Geisler, F.H., Cheng, C., Poka, A., et al.: Anterior screw fixation of posteriorly displaced type II odontoid fractures. Neurosurgery 25, 30–37 (1989). discussion 37–38 69. Gluf, W.M., Schmidt, M.H., Apfelbaum, R.I.: Atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation: a review of surgical indications, fusion rate, complications, and lessons learned in 191 adult patients. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 155–163 (2005) 70. Goel, A., Desai, K.I., Muzumdar, D.P.: Atlantoaxial fixation using plate and screw method: a report of 160 treated patients. Neurosurgery 51, 1351–1356 (2002). discussion 1356–1357 71. Goel, A., Kulkarni, A.G., Sharma, P.: Reduction of fixed atlantoaxial dislocation in 24 cases: technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 505–509 (2005) 72. Goel, A., Laheri, V.: Plate and screw fixation for atlanto-axial subluxation. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 129, 47–53 (1994) 73. Goel, A., Shah, A., Rajan, S.: Vertical mobile and reducible atlantoaxial dislocation. Clinical article. J Neurosurg Spine 11, 9–14 (2009) 74. Goffin, J., Van Brussel, K., Martens, K., et al.: Threedimensional computed tomography-based, personalized drill guide for posterior cervical stabilization at C1-C2. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, 1343–1347 (2001) 75. Gonzalez, L.F., Crawford, N.R., Chamberlain, R.H., et al.: Craniovertebral junction fixation with transarticular screws: biomechanical analysis of a novel technique. J Neurosurg 98, 202–209 (2003) 76. Gonzalez, L.F., Klopfenstein, J.D., Crawford, N.R., et al.: Use of dual transarticular screws to fixate simultaneous occipitoatlantal and atlantoaxial dislocations. J Neurosurg Spine 3, 318–323 (2005) 77. Gorek, J., Acaroglu, E., Berven, S., et al.: Constructs incorporating intralaminar C2 screws provide rigid stability for atlantoaxial fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 30, 1513–1518 (2005)
120
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
78. Grantham, S.A., Dick, H.M., Thompson Jr., R.C., et al.: Occipitocervical arthrodesis. Indications, technic and results. Clin Orthop Relat Res 65, 118–129 (1969) 79. Graziano, G., Jaggers, C., Lee, M., et al.: A comparative study of fixation techniques for type II fractures of the odontoid process. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 18, 2383–2387 (1993) 80. Griswold, D.M., Albright, J.A., Schiffman, E., et al.: Atlantoaxial fusion for instability. J Bone Joint Surg Am 60, 285–292 (1978) 81. Grob, D.: Transarticular screw fixation for atlanto-occipital dislocation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, 703–707 (2001) 82. Grob, D., 3rd Crisco, J.J., Panjabi, M.M., et al.: Biomechanical evaluation of four different posterior atlantoaxial fixation techniques. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 17, 480–490 (1992) 83. Grob, D., Bremerich, F.H., Dvorak, J., et al.: Transarticular screw fixation for osteoarthritis of the atlanto axial segment. Eur Spine J 15, 283–291 (2006) 84. Grob, D., Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M., et al.: Posterior occipitocervical fusion. A preliminary report of a new technique. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 16, S17–S24 (1991) 85. Grob, D., Dvorak, J., Panjabi, M.M., et al.: The role of plate and screw fixation in occipitocervical fusion in rheumatoid arthritis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 19, 2545–2551 (1994) 86. Grob, D., Jeanneret, B., Aebi, M., et al.: Atlanto-axial fusion with transarticular screw fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 73, 972–976 (1991) 87. Grob, D., Magerl, F.: Operative stabilisierung bei frakturen von C1 und C2. Orthopäde 16, 46–54 (1987) 88. Gunnarsson, T., Massicotte, E.M., Govender, P.V., et al.: The use of C1 lateral mass screws in complex cervical spine surgery: indications, techniques, and outcome in a prospective consecutive series of 25 cases. J Spinal Disord Tech 20, 308–316 (2007) 89. Gupta, S., Goel, A.: Quantitative anatomy of the lateral masses of the atlas and axis vertebrae. Neurol India 48, 120–125 (2000) 90. Haher, T.R., Yeung, A.W., Caruso, S.A., et al.: Occipital screw pullout strength. A biomechanical investigation of occipital morphology. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 5–9 (1999) 91. Haid Jr., R.W., Subach, B.R., McLaughlin, M.R., et al.: C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation for atlantoaxial instability: a 6-year experience. Neurosurgery 49, 65–68 (2001). discussion 69–70 92. Hamblen, D.L.: Occipito-cervical fusion. Indications, technique and results. J Bone Joint Surg Br 49, 33–45 (1967) 93. Hanson, P.B., Montesano, P.X., Sharkey, N.A., et al.: Anatomic and biomechanical assessment of transarticular screw fixation for atlantoaxial instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 16, 1141–1145 (1991) 94. Harms, J., Melcher, R.P.: Posterior C1-C2 fusion with polyaxial screw and rod fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, 2467–2471 (2001) 95. Harms, J., Schmelze, R., Stolze, D.: Osteosynthesen im occipito-cervikalen Übergang vom transoralen Zugang aus, XVII SICOT World Congress Abstracts. Demeter Verlag, Munich (1987) 96. Hashizume, H., Kawakami, M., Kawai, M., et al.: A clinical case of endoscopically assisted anterior screw fixation for the type II odontoid fracture. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, E102–E105 (2003)
97. Hedequist, D., Proctor, M.: Screw fixation to C2 in children: a case series and technical report. J Pediatr Orthop 29, 21–25 (2009) 98. Heuer, G.G., Hardesty, D.A., Bhowmick, D.A., et al.: Treatment of pediatric atlantoaxial instability with traditional and modified Goel-Harms fusion constructs. Eur Spine J 18, 884–892 (2009) 99. Holly, L.T., Foley, K.T.: Intraoperative spinal navigation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, S54–S61 (2003) 100. Holly, L.T., Foley, K.T.: Percutaneous placement of posterior cervical screws using three-dimensional fluoroscopy. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 536–540 (2006). discussion 541 101. Holness, R.O., Huestis, W.S., Howes, W.J., et al.: Posterior stabilization with an interlaminar clamp in cervical injuries: technical note and review of the long term experience with the method. Neurosurgery 14, 318–322 (1984) 102. Hong, X., Dong, Y., Yunbing, C., et al.: Posterior screw placement on the lateral mass of atlas: an anatomic study. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 29, 500–503 (2004) 103. Hong, J.T., Lee, S.W., Son, B.C., et al.: Hypoglossal nerve palsy after posterior screw placement on the C-1 lateral mass. Case report. J Neurosurg Spine 5, 83–85 (2006) 104. Hong, J.T., Lee, S.W., Son, B.C., et al.: Analysis of anatomical variations of bone and vascular structures around the posterior atlantal arch using three-dimensional computed tomography angiography. J Neurosurg Spine 8, 230–236 (2008) 105. Hong, J.T., Yi, J.S., Kim, J.T., et al.: Clinical and radiologic outcome of laminar screw at C2 and C7 for posterior instrumentation-review of 25 cases and comparison of C2 and C7 intralaminar screw fixation. Surg Neurol 6, 6 (2009) 106. Hott, J.S., Lynch, J.J., Chamberlain, R.H., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of C1-2 posterior fixation techniques. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 175–181 (2005) 107. Howington, J.U., Kruse, J.J., Awasthi, D.: Surgical anatomy of the C-2 pedicle. J Neurosurg 95, 88–92 (2001) 108. Hu, Y., Ma, W., Xu, R.: Transoral osteosynthesis C1 as a function-preserving option in the treatment of bipartite atlas deformity: a case report. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34, E418–E421 (2009) 109. Huang, C.I., Chen, I.H.: Atlantoaxial arthrodesis using Halifax interlaminar clamps reinforced by halo vest immobilization: a long-term follow-up experience. Neurosurgery 38, 1153–1156 (1996). discussion 1156-1157 110. Huhn, S.L., Wolf, A.L., Ecklund, J.: Posterior spinal osteosynthesis for cervical fracture/dislocation using a flexible multistrand cable system: technical note. Neurosurgery 29, 943–946 (1991) 111. Hurlbert, R.J., Crawford, N.R., Choi, W.G., et al.: A biomechanical evaluation of occipitocervical instrumentation: screw compared with wire fixation. J Neurosurg 90, 84–90 (1999) 112. Igarashi, T., Kikuchi, S., Sato, K., et al.: Anatomic study of the axis for surgical planning of transarticular screw fixation. Clin Orthop Relat Res 408, 162–166 (2003) 113. Itoh, T., Tsuji, H., Katoh, Y., et al.: Occipito-cervical fusion reinforced by Luque’s segmental spinal instrumentation for rheumatoid diseases. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13, 1234–1238 (1988)
References 114. Jea, A., Sheth, R.N., Vanni, S., et al.: Modification of Wright’s technique for placement of bilateral crossing C2 translaminar screws: technical note. Spine J 8, 656–660 (2008) 115. Jeanneret, B.: Posterior rod system of the cervical spine: a new implant allowing optimal screw insertion. Eur Spine J 5, 350–356 (1996) 116. Jeanneret, B., Magerl, F.: Primary posterior fusion C1/2 in odontoid fractures: indications, technique, and results of transarticular screw fixation. J Spinal Disord 5, 464–475 (1992) 117. Jenkins, J.D., Coric, D., Branch Jr., C.L.: A clinical comparison of one- and two-screw odontoid fixation. J Neurosurg 89, 366–370 (1998) 118. Jeszenszky, D., Fekete, T.F., Melcher, R., et al.: C2 prosthesis: anterior upper cervical fixation device to reconstruct the second cervical vertebra. Eur Spine J 16, 1695–1700 (2007) 119. Jones, E.L., Heller, J.G., Silcox, D.H., et al.: Cervical pedicle screws versus lateral mass screws. Anatomic feasibility and biomechanical comparison. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 22, 977–982 (1997) 120. Jun, B.Y.: Anatomic study for ideal and safe posterior C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1703–1707 (1998) 121. Kandziora, F., Kerschbaumer, F., Starker, M., et al.: Biomechanical assessment of transoral plate fixation for atlantoaxial instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25, 1555– 1561 (2000) 122. Kandziora, F., Pflugmacher, R., Ludwig, K., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of four anterior atlantoaxial plate systems. J Neurosurg 96, 313–320 (2002) 123. Kandziora, F., Schulze-Stahl, N., Khodadadyan-Klostermann, C., et al.: Screw placement in transoral atlantoaxial plate systems: an anatomical study. J Neurosurg 95, 80–87 (2001) 124. Kelly Jr., D.L., Alexander Jr., E., Davis Jr., C.H., et al.: Acrylic fixation of atlanto-axial dislocations. Technical note. J Neurosurg 36, 366–371 (1972) 125. Kerschbaumer, F., Kandziora, F., Klein, C., et al.: Transoral decompression, anterior plate fixation, and posterior wire fusion for irreducible atlantoaxial kyphosis in rheumatoid arthritis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25, 2708–2715 (2000) 126. Klekamp, J.W., Ugbo, J.L., Heller, J.G., et al.: Cervical transfacet versus lateral mass screws: a biomechanical comparison. J Spinal Disord 13, 515–518 (2000) 127. Knoller, S., Jeszenszky, D., Willms, R., et al.: Transaxial spongiosa-plasty and ventral, temporary atlanto-axial fixation for therapy of dens pseudarthrosis. Z Orthop Ihre Grenzgeb 137, 232–235 (1999) 128. Knopf, W., Vater, H., Meier, U., et al.: Axial osteosynthesis of dens axis fracture as a routine procedure in neurotraumatology. Diagnosis–Surgical-technique–Complications– Follow-up. Zentralbl Neurochir 51, 85–90 (1990) 129. Knöringer, P.: Internal fixation of dens fractures by doublethreaded screws. Orthop Traumatol 4, 231–245 (1992) 130. Kocis, J., Wendsche, P., Visna, P., et al.: Traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 70, 214–218 (2003) 131. Koller, H., Kammermeier, V., Ulbricht, D., et al.: Anterior retropharyngeal fixation C1-2 for stabilization of atlantoaxial instabilities: study of feasibility, technical descrip-
121 tion and preliminary results. Eur Spine J 15, 1326–1338 (2006) 132. Kuroki, H., Rengachary, S.S., Goel, V.K., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of two stabilization techniques of the atlantoaxial joints: transarticular screw fixation versus screw and rod fixation. Neurosurgery 56, 151–159 (2005). discussion 151-159 133. La Marca, F., Zubay, G., Morrison, T., et al.: Cadaveric study for placement of occipital condyle screws: technique and effects on surrounding anatomic structures. J Neurosurg Spine 9, 347–353 (2008) 134. Lang, J.: The cranio-cervical junction – Anatomy. In: Voth, D., Glees, P. (eds.) Diseases in the cranio-cervical junction. Anatomical and pathological aspects and detailed clinical accounts, pp. 27–61. Gruyter, Berlin, New York (1987) 135. Lapsiwala, S.B., Anderson, P.A., Oza, A., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of four C1 to C2 rigid fixative techniques: anterior transarticular, posterior transarticular, C1 to C2 pedicle, and C1 to C2 intralaminar screws. Neurosurgery 58, 516–521 (2006). discussion 516–521 136. Latal, J., Lohnert, J.: Treatment of fractures of the upper cervical spine (C1 and C2). Bratisl Lek Listy 94, 483–488 (1993) 137. Leconte, P.: Fracture et luxation des deux premieres vertebres cervicales. In: Judet, R. (ed.) Luxation Congenitale de la Hanche. Fractures du Cou-de-pied Rachis Cervical. Actualites de Chirurgie Orthopedique de l’Hospital Raymond-Poincare, vol. 3, pp. 147–166. Masson et Cie, Paris (1964) 138. Lee, M.J., Cassinelli, E., Riew, K.D.: The feasibility of inserting atlas lateral mass screws via the posterior arch. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 31, 2798–2801 (2006) 139. Lee, J.H., Jahng, T.A., Chung, C.K.: C1-2 transarticular screw fixation in high-riding vertebral artery: suggestion of new trajectory. J Spinal Disord Tech 20, 499–504 (2007) 140. Lehman Jr., R.A., Sasso, R.C., Helgeson, M.D., et al.: Accuracy of intraoperative plain radiographs to detect violations of intralaminar screws placed into the C2 vertebrae: a reliability study. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 32, 3036–3040 (2007) 141. Lesoin, F., Autricque, A., Franz, K., et al.: Transcervical approach and screw fixation for upper cervical spine pathology. Surg Neurol 27, 459–465 (1987) 142. Levine, A.M., Dacre, A.: Traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis: hangman’s fracture. In: Clark, C.R., Benzel, E.C., Currier, B.L., et al. (eds.) The cervical spine, pp. 629–650. Lippincott, Philadelphia (2004) 143. Lieberman, I.H., Webb, J.K.: Occipito-cervical fusion using posterior titanium plates. Eur Spine J 7, 308–312 (1998) 144. Lohnert, J., Latal, J.: Fracture of the axis–surgical treatment. II. Axial isthmus. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 60, 47–50 (1993) 145. Lowry, D.W., Pollack, I.F., Clyde, B., et al.: Upper cervical spine fusion in the pediatric population. J Neurosurg 87, 671–676 (1997) 146. Lu, J., Ebraheim, N.A., Yang, H., et al.: Anatomic considerations of anterior transarticular screw fixation for atlantoaxial instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1229–1235 (1998). discussion 1236
122
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
147. Lu, S., Xu, Y.Q., Zhang, Y.Z., et al.: A novel computerassisted drill guide template for placement of C2 laminar screws. Eur Spine J 18, 1379–1385 (2009) 148. Ma, X.Y., Yin, Q.S., Wu, Z.H., et al.: C1 pedicle screws versus C1 lateral mass screws: comparisons of pullout strengths and biomechanical stabilities. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34, 371–377 (2009) 149. MacKenzie, A.I., Uttley, D., Marsh, H.T., et al.: Craniocervical stabilization using Luque/Hartshill rectangles. Neurosurgery 26, 32–36 (1990) 150. Madawi, A.A., Casey, A.T., Solanki, G.A., et al.: Radiological and anatomical evaluation of the atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation technique. J Neurosurg 86, 961–968 (1997) 151. Madawi, A.A., Solanki, G., Casey, A.T., et al.: Variation of the groove in the axis vertebra for the vertebral artery. Implications for instrumentation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 79, 820–823 (1997) 152. Magerl, F., Seemann, P.S.: Stable posterior fusion of the atlas and axis by transarticular screw fixation. In: Kehr, P., Weidner, A. (eds.) Cervical spine, pp. 322–327. Springer, Wien (1987) 153. Mandel, I.M., Kambach, B.J., Petersilge, C.A., et al.: Morphologic considerations of C2 isthmus dimensions for the placement of transarticular screws. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25, 1542–1547 (2000) 154. Marcotte, P., Dickman, C.A., Sonntag, V.K., et al.: Posterior atlantoaxial facet screw fixation. J Neurosurg 79, 234–237 (1993) 155. Matsunaga, S., Onishi, T., Sakou, T.: Significance of occipitoaxial angle in subaxial lesion after occipitocervical fusion. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, 161–165 (2001) 156. Maughan, P.H., Horn, E.M., Theodore, N., et al.: Avulsion fracture of the foramen magnum treated with occiput-to-c1 fusion: technical case report. Neurosurgery 57, E600 (2005). discussion E600 157. McAfee, P.C., Bohlman, H.H., Ducker, T., et al.: Failure of stabilization of the spine with methylmethacrylate. A retrospective analysis of twenty-four cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am 68, 1145–1157 (1986) 158. McGraw, R.W., Rusch, R.M.: Atlanto-axial arthrodesis. J Bone Joint Surg Br 55, 482–489 (1973) 159. Melcher, R.P., Puttlitz, C.M., Kleinstueck, F.S., et al.: Biomechanical testing of posterior atlantoaxial fixation techniques. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 27, 2435–2440 (2002) 160. Menezes, A.H., VanGilder, J.C.: Transoral-transpharyngeal approach to the anterior craniocervical junction. Ten-year experience with 72 patients. J Neurosurg 69, 895–903 (1988) 161. Mixter, S.J., Osgood, R.B.: IV. Traumatic lesions of the atlas and axis. Ann Surg 51, 193–207 (1910) 162. Moftakhar, P., Gonzalez, N.R., Khoo, L.T., et al.: Osseous and vascular anatomical variations within the C1-C2 complex: a radiographical study using computed tomography angiography. Int J Med Robot 4, 158–164 (2008) 163. Moskovich, R., Crockard, H.A.: Atlantoaxial arthrodesis using interlaminar clamps. An improved technique. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 17, 261–267 (1992) 164. Naderi, S., Crawford, N.R., Song, G.S., et al.: Biomechanical comparison of C1-C2 posterior fixations. Cable, graft, and screw combinations. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1946–1955 (1998). discussion 1955–1946
165. Naderi, S., Korman, E., Citak, G., et al.: Morphometric analysis of human occipital condyle. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 107, 191–199 (2005) 166. Nakanishi, K., Sasaki, T., Tokita, N., et al.: Internal fixation for the odontoid fracture. Orthop Trans 6, 176 (1982) 167. Nassos, J.T., Ghanayem, A.J., Sasso, R.C., et al.: Biomechanical evaluation of segmental occipitoatlantoaxial stabilization techniques. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34, 2740–2744 (2009) 168. Neo, M., Matsushita, M., Iwashita, Y., et al.: Atlantoaxial transarticular screw fixation for a high-riding vertebral artery. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, 666–670 (2003) 169. Newman, P., Sweetnam, R.: Occipito-cervical fusion. An operative technique and its indications. J Bone Joint Surg Br 51, 423–431 (1969) 170. Nockels, R.P., Shaffrey, C.I., Kanter, A.S., et al.: Occipitocervical fusion with rigid internal fixation: longterm follow-up data in 69 patients. J Neurosurg Spine 7, 117–123 (2007) 171. Nordt, J.C., Stauffer, E.S.: Sequelae of atlantoaxial stabilization in two patients with Down’s syndrome. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 6, 437–440 (1981) 172. Nottmeier, E.W., Foy, A.B.: Placement of C2 laminar screws using three-dimensional fluoroscopy-based image guidance. Eur Spine J 17, 610–615 (2008) 173. Oda, I., Abumi, K., Sell, L.C., et al.: Biomechanical evaluation of five different occipito-atlanto-axial fixation techniques. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 2377–2382 (1999) 174. Olerud, S., Olerud, C.: The C1 claw device: a new instrument for C1-C2 fusion. Eur Spine J 10, 345–347 (2001) 175. Pait, T.G., Al-Mefty, O., Boop, F.A., et al.: Inside-outside technique for posterior occipitocervical spine instrumentation and stabilization: preliminary results. J Neurosurg 90, 1–7 (1999) 176. Panjabi, M.M.: The stabilizing system of the spine. Part I. Function, dysfunction, adaptation, and enhancement. J Spinal Disord 5, 383–389 (1992). discussion 397 177. Papagelopoulos, P.J., Currier, B.L., Stone, J., et al.: Biomechanical evaluation of occipital fixation. J Spinal Disord 13, 336–344 (2000) 178. Paquis, P., Breuil, V., Lonjon, M., et al.: Occipitocervical fixation using hooks and screws for upper cervical instability. Neurosurgery 44, 324–330 (1999). discussion 330–321 179. Paramore, C.G., Dickman, C.A., Sonntag, V.K.: The anatomical suitability of the C1-2 complex for transarticular screw fixation. J Neurosurg 85, 221–224 (1996) 180. Parker, S.L., McGirt, M.J., Garces-Ambrossi, G.L., et al.: Translaminar versus pedicle screw fixation of C2: comparison of surgical morbidity and accuracy of 313 consecutive screws. Neurosurgery 64, 343–348 (2009). discussion 348349 181. Payer, M., Luzi, M., Tessitore, E.: Posterior atlanto-axial fixation with polyaxial C1 lateral mass screws and C2 pars screws. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 151, 223–229 (2009). discussion 229 182. Pointillart, V., Orta, A.L., Freitas, J., et al.: Odontoid fractures. Review of 150 cases and practical application for treatment. Eur Spine J 3, 282–285 (1994) 183. Ransford, A.O., Crockard, H.A., Pozo, J.L., et al.: Craniocervical instability treated by contoured loop fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 68, 173–177 (1986)
References 184. Reindl, R., Sen, M., Aebi, M.: Anterior instrumentation for traumatic C1-C2 instability. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, E329–E333 (2003) 185. Resnick, D.K., Benzel, E.C.: C1-C2 pedicle screw fixation with rigid cantilever beam construct: case report and technical note. Neurosurgery 50, 426–428 (2002) 186. Resnick, D.K., Lapsiwala, S., Trost, G.R.: Anatomic suitability of the C1-C2 complex for pedicle screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 27, 1494–1498 (2002) 187. Rhines, L.D., Fourney, D.R., Siadati, A., et al.: En bloc resection of multilevel cervical chordoma with C-2 involvement. Case report and description of operative technique. J Neurosurg Spine 2, 199–205 (2005) 188. Richter, M., Schmidt, R., Claes, L., et al.: Posterior atlantoaxial fixation: biomechanical in vitro comparison of six different techniques. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 27, 1724–1732 (2002) 189. Roberts, D.A., Doherty, B.J., Heggeness, M.H.: Quantitative anatomy of the occiput and the biomechanics of occipital screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 1100–1107 (1998). discussion 1107–1108 190. Robertson, S.C., Menezes, A.H.: Occipital calvarial bone graft in posterior occipitocervical fusion. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 23, 249–254 (1998). discussion 254–245 191. Rocha, R., Safavi-Abbasi, S., Reis, C., et al.: Working area, safety zones, and angles of approach for posterior C-1 lateral mass screw placement: a quantitative anatomical and morphometric evaluation. J Neurosurg Spine 6, 247–254 (2007) 192. Roy-Camille, R.: Current trends in surgery of the spine. Int Orthop 13, 81–87 (1989) 193. Roy-Camille, R., Saillant, G.: Surgery of the cervical spine. 4. Osteosynthesis of the upper cervical spine. Nouv Presse Med 1, 2847–2849 (1972) 194. Roy-Camille, R., Saillant, G., Laville, C., et al.: Treatment of lower cervical spinal injuries – C3 to C7. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 17, S442–S446 (1992) 195. Ruf, M., Melcher, R., Harms, J.: Transoral reduction and osteosynthesis C1 as a function-preserving option in the treatment of unstable Jefferson fractures. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 29, 823–827 (2004) 196. Sandhu, F.A., Pait, T.G., Benzel, E., et al.: Occipitocervical fusion for rheumatoid arthritis using the inside-outside stabilization technique. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, 414–419 (2003) 197. Sar, C., Eralp, L.: Transoral resection and reconstruction for primary osteogenic sarcoma of the second cervical vertebra. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 26, 1936–1941 (2001) 198. Sasso, R., Doherty, B.J., Crawford, M.J., et al.: Biomechanics of odontoid fracture fixation. Comparison of the one- and two-screw technique. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 18, 1950–1953 (1993) 199. Sasso, R.C., Jeanneret, B., Fischer, K., et al.: Occipitocervical fusion with posterior plate and screw instrumentation. A long-term follow-up study. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 19, 2364–2368 (1994) 200. Sciubba, D.M., Noggle, J.C., Vellimana, A.K., et al.: Laminar screw fixation of the axis. J Neurosurg Spine 8, 327–334 (2008) 201. Sciubba, D.M., Noggle, J.C., Vellimana, A.K., et al.: Radiographic and clinical evaluation of free-hand placement of C-2 pedicle screws. Clinical article. J Neurosurg Spine 11, 15–22 (2009)
123 202. Sen, M.K., Steffen, T., Beckman, L., et al.: Atlantoaxial fusion using anterior transarticular screw fixation of C1-C2: technical innovation and biomechanical study. Eur Spine J 14, 512–518 (2005) 203. Senoglu, M., Ozbag, D., Gumusalan, Y.: C2 intralaminar screw placement: a quantitative anatomical and morphometric evaluation. Turk Neurosurg 19, 245–248 (2009) 204. Shalayev, S.G., Mun, I.K., Mallek, G.S., et al.: Retrospective analysis and modifications of retractor systems for anterior odontoid screw fixation. Neurosurgical Focus 16, 1–4 (2004) 205. Simmons, E.H., du Toit Jr., G.: Lateral atlantoaxial arthrodesis. Orthop Clin North Am 9, 1101–1114 (1978) 206. Six, E., Kelly Jr., D.L.: Technique for C-1, C-2, and C-3 fixation in cases of odontoid fracture. Neurosurgery 8, 374–377 (1981) 207. Smith, M.D., Anderson, P., Grady, M.S.: Occipitocervical arthrodesis using contoured plate fixation. An early report on a versatile fixation technique. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 18, 1984–1990 (1993) 208. Solanki, G.A., Crockard, H.A.: Peroperative determination of safe superior transarticular screw trajectory through the lateral mass. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 477–1482 (1999) 209. Sonntag, V.K., Dickman, C.A.: Craniocervical stabilization. Clin Neurosurg 40, 243–272 (1993) 210. Statham, P., O’Sullivan, M., Russell, T.: The Halifax Interlaminar Clamp for posterior cervical fusion: initial experience in the United Kingdom. Neurosurgery 32, 396–398 (1993). discussion 398–399 211. Stevenson, K.L., Wetzel, M., Pollack, I.F.: Delayed intracranial migration of cervical sublaminar and interspinous wires and subsequent cerebellar abscess. Case report. J Neurosurg 97, 113–117 (2002) 212. Stillerman, C.B., Wilson, J.A.: Atlanto-axial stabilization with posterior transarticular screw fixation: technical description and report of 22 cases. Neurosurgery 32, 948–954 (1993) 213. Stokes, J.K., Villavicencio, A.T., Liu, P.C., et al.: Posterior atlantoaxial stabilization: new alternative to C1-2 transarticular screws. Neurosurg Focus 12, E6 (2002) 214. Stulík, J., Krbec, M.: Magerl’s Technique of C1-2 Fixation. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 67, 93–99 (2000) 215. Stulik, J., Vyskocil, T., Sebesta, P., et al.: Atlantoaxial fixation using the polyaxial screw-rod system. Eur Spine J 16, 479–484 (2007) 216. Subach, B.R., Morone, M.A., Haid Jr., R.W., et al.: Management of acute odontoid fractures with single-screw anterior fixation. Neurosurgery 45, 812–819 (1999) 217. Suchomel, P., Buchvald, P., Barsa, P., et al.: Single-stage total C-2 intralesional spondylectomy for chordoma with three-column reconstruction. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 6, 611–618 (2007) 218. Suchomel, P., Hradil, J., Barsa, P., et al.: Surgical treatment of fracture of the ring of axis – “hangman’s fracture”. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 73, 321–328 (2006) 219. Suchomel, P., Stulik, J., Klezl, Z., et al.: Transarticular fixation of C1-C2: a multicenter retrospective study. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 71, 6–12 (2004) 220. Suchomel, P., Taller, S., Lukas, R., et al.: Surgical treatment of fractures of the odontoid process. Rozhl Chir 79, 301–308 (2000) 221. Sudo, H., Abumi, K., Ito, M., et al.: Spinal cord compression by multistrand cables after solid posterior atlantoaxial
124
6 Specific Reconstruction Techniques of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction
fusion. Report of three cases. J Neurosurg 97, 359–361 (2002) 222. Taitz, C., Arensburg, B.: Erosion of the foramen transversarium of the axis. Anatomical observations. Acta Anat (Basel) 134, 12–17 (1989) 223. Taitz, C., Arensburg, B.: Vertebral artery tortuosity with concomitant erosion of the foramen of the transverse process of the axis. Possible clinical implications. Acta Anat (Basel) 141, 104–108 (1991) 224. Taller, S., Suchomel, P., Lukas, R., et al.: CT-guided internal fixation of a hangman’s fracture. Eur Spine J 9, 393–397 (2000) 225. Tan, M., Wang, H., Wang, Y., et al.: Morphometric evaluation of screw fixation in atlas via posterior arch and lateral mass. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 28, 888–895 (2003) 226. Theodore, N., Partovi, S., Walker, M.P., et al.: Preoperative helical CT angiography for C1-2 transarticular screw placement. A new technique. BNI Q 17, 49–52 (20001) 227. Tucker, H.H.: Technical report: method of fixation of subluxed or dislocated cervical spine below C1-C2. Can J Neurol Sci 2, 381–382 (1975) 228. Uribe, J.S., Ramos, E., Baaj, A., et al.: Occipital cervical stabilization using occipital condyles for cranial fixation: technical case report. Neurosurgery 65, E1216–E1217 (2009) 229. Uribe, J.S., Ramos, E., Vale, F.: Feasibility of occipital condyle screw placement for occipitocervical fixation: a cadaveric study and description of a novel technique. J Spinal Disord Tech 21, 540–546 (2008) 230. Vaccaro, A.R., Lehman, A.P., Ahlgren, B.D., et al.: Anterior C1-C2 screw fixation and bony fusion through an anterior retropharyngeal approach. Orthopedics 22, 1165–1170 (1999) 231. Vlach, O., Leznar, M., Bayer, M.: Diagnosis, classification and treatment of so-called hangman’s fractures. Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech 55, 456–466 (1988) 232. Wang, M.Y.: C2 crossing laminar screws: cadaveric morphometric analysis. Neurosurgery 59, ONS84–ONS88 (2006). discussion ONS84–88 233. Wang, M.Y., Samudrala, S.: Cadaveric morphometric analysis for atlantal lateral mass screw placement. Neurosurgery 54, 1436–1439 (2004). discussion 1439–1440 234. Weidner, A., Wahler, M., Chiu, S.T., et al.: Modification of C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation by image-guided surgery. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 25, 2668–2673 (2000). discussion 2674 235. Wertheim, S.B., Bohlman, H.H.: Occipitocervical fusion. Indications, technique, and long-term results in thirteen patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am 69, 833–836 (1987) 236. Wickbom, G.I., Williamson, M.R.: Anomalous foramen transversarium of C2 simulating erosion of bone. Neuroradiology 19, 43–45 (1980) 237. Wilke, H.J., Fischer, K., Kugler, A., et al.: In vitro investigations of internal fixation systems of the upper cervical
spine. II. Stability of posterior atlanto-axial fixation techniques. Eur Spine J 1, 191–199 (1992) 238. Wright, N.M.: Posterior C2 fixation using bilateral, crossing C2 laminar screws: case series and technical note. J Spinal Disord Tech 17, 158–162 (2004) 239. Wright, N.M.: Translaminar rigid screw fixation of the axis. Technical note. J Neurosurg Spine 3, 409–414 (2005) 240. Wright, N.M., Lauryssen, C.: Vertebral artery injury in C1-2 transarticular screw fixation: results of a survey of the AANS/CNS section on disorders of the spine and peripheral nerves. American Association of Neurological Surgeons/Congress of Neurological Surgeons. J Neurosurg 88, 634–640 (1998) 241. Xiao, Z.M., Zhan, X.L., de Gong, F., et al.: C2 pedicle screw and plate combined with C1 titanium cable fixation for the treatment of atlantoaxial instability not suitable for placement of C1 screw. J Spinal Disord Tech 21, 514–517 (2008) 242. Xu, R., Burgar, A., Ebraheim, N.A., et al.: The quantitative anatomy of the laminas of the spine. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 24, 107–113 (1999) 243. Xu, R., Nadaud, M.C., Ebraheim, N.A., et al.: Morphology of the second cervical vertebra and the posterior projection of the C2 pedicle axis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 20, 259–263 (1995) 244. Yamazaki, M., Koda, M., Aramomi, M.A., et al.: Anomalous vertebral artery at the extraosseous and intraosseous regions of the craniovertebral junction: analysis by three-dimensional computed tomography angiography. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 30, 2452–2457 (2005) 245. Yan, W., Zhang, C., Zhou, X., et al.: Safe angle scope for posterior atlanto-occipital transarticular screw fixation. Neurosurgery 65, 499–504 (2009). discussion 504 246. Yan, W.J., Zhou, X., Zhang, Y., et al.: The feasibility study on the posterior occipito-atlanto-axial screw fixation. J Spinal Surg 2, 289–293 (2004) 247. Yin, Q., Ai, F., Zhang, K., et al.: Irreducible anterior atlantoaxial dislocation: one-stage treatment with a transoral atlantoaxial reduction plate fixation and fusion. Report of 5 cases and review of the literature. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 30, E375–E381 (2005) 248. Yoshida, M., Neo, M., Fujibayashi, S., et al.: Comparison of the anatomical risk for vertebral artery injury associated with the C2-pedicle screw and atlantoaxial transarticular screw. Spine 31, E513–E517 (2006) 249. Young, J.P., Young, P.H., Ackermann, M.J., et al.: The ponticulus posticus: implications for screw insertion into the first cervical lateral mass. J Bone Joint Surg Am 87, 2495–2498 (2005) 250. Zipnick, R.I., Merola, A.A., Gorup, J., et al.: Occipital morphology. An anatomic guide to internal fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 21, 1719–1724 (1996). discussion 1729–1730 251. Zoma, A., Sturrock, R.D., Fisher, W.D., et al.: Surgical stabilisation of the rheumatoid cervical spine. A review of indications and results. J Bone Joint Surg Br 69, 8–12 (1987)
7
Virtual and Real Time Navigational Techniques P. Suchomel and O. Choutka
All new technology should enable physicians to perform previously undoable tasks or solve unsolved problems, rather than dominating over reason as once elegantly stated by Scott Boden [60]. This certainly applies to spinal surgery and navigational techniques that have developed over the past decade. Such development opened the field of spinal surgery also to less experienced surgeons by improving accuracy and safety. Image-guided spinal surgery (IGS) is certainly a good addition to the armamentarium of a spine surgeon but, by any means, does not replace experience. Due to fairly unique anatomy of the region, experience and sophisticated reconstructive techniques are usually necessary for cases involving the upper cervical spine (UCS) and craniovertebral junction (CVJ). The literature is full of descriptions of various surgical techniques for treating pathologies of the CVJ and UCS [14, 29, 35, 46–51, 59]. Image-guided techniques, therefore, do not necessarily further enhance those solutions. However, there are certain types of operations where the extent of pathology is not directly visible, the resection volume of pathological tissue cannot be predicted, or the implant trajectory is out of sight of direct vision. Here, although useful, simple fluoroscopy can be rather limited and therefore, image-guided techniques have the potential to enhance the safety of such procedures.
Spatial orientation is an important asset for reaching deep-seated lesions in the brain. Similarly, in CVJ, it is essential to understand not only the target but also vital structures en route to the target as they are at risk of injury. Frame stereotaxy [11] and frameless navigational systems [9, 37] proved to be rather useful in this task. Cranial navigation is simplified due to the relatively stable relationship of the brain to the skull (Fig. 7.1). Similar techniques in the spine did succeed in the past [11]; however, the mobility of this structure called for a different approach to stereotaxy. The improvement of modern imaging techniques (CT, MRI, and isocentric fluoroscopy) together with improved computer software, allowed for significantly better, three-dimensional thinking in spinal surgery [5, 15, 45, 54]. The selection of an actual type of image guidance tool is dependent on the goal of the procedure. Different tasks have different needs. For example, tumor resection requires good localization and border demarcation to continuously monitor the extent of resection. On the other hand, a spinal fracture with mobile fragments and deformity can only be registered preoperatively but is inaccurate after any reduction, unless re-registered. It is fairly obvious that technical errors during instrumentation of UCS and CVJ can result in neurological, vascular, or mechanical complications.
P. Suchomel Department of Neurosurgery, Neurocenter, Regional Hospital Liberec, Husova St. 10, 46063 Liberec, Czech Republic
7.1 Technique Description
O. Choutka Department of Neurosurgery, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, 231 Albert Sabin Way, Cincinnati, OH 45267-0515, USA
Surgeons new to navigation techniques must realize that there are two main, relatively different, image guidance options. There are techniques utilizing onetime image acquisition (pre- or intraoperative) with subsequent navigation based on the initial registration
P. Suchomel and O. Choutka, Reconstruction of Upper Cervical Spine and Craniovertebral Junction, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-13158-5_7, © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
125
126
Fig. 7.1 Large clival chordoma approached transmaxillar and removed with the help of cranial frameless navigation. (a) Preoperative MRI showing the extent of tumor. (b) Surface
7 Virtual and Real Time Navigational Techniques
registration for virtual navigation. (c) Preoperative picture depicting the transmaxillar approach. (d) Postoperative MRI showing no residual tumor
127
7.1 Technique Description
(virtual image guidance) and those that utilize intraoperative real-time image techniques that do not require constant re-registration after any data shift (e.g., positioning, tumor removal, reduction of malalignment).
7.1.1 Virtual Image-Guided Surgery (vIGS) Foley and Smith introduced navigation to spine surgery in 1994 after a positive cranial experience [9, 20]. Lack of reliable external surface markers was an initial concern; however, this issue was solved with the registration of dorsal spine bony anatomic landmarks in association with dynamic reference array (DRA) directly attached to the target vertebra [9, 18, 19, 37]. Initially, vIGS was mostly used for
a
lumbar pedicle screw placement [8, 9, 31, 36, 37]. Later, thoracic spine was added to the lumbar and it quickly became obvious that the technique can result in higher accuracy than traditional methods [12, 31, 40]. Now, navigational techniques have been applied to slightly more delicate structures of the UCS [1, 5, 15, 57, 58]. Basically, anatomical data are collected by thinsliced (1–1.5 mm) CT, MRI, or isofluoroscopy and transmitted to a computer workstation. DRA is connected to a solid part of the target area so that it does not obstruct the operative field. Navigated vertebra and instruments being tracked are then registered by the electro-optical camera connected to the computer (Fig. 7.2). Most systems use either passive arrays (reflective spheres) or active arrays (light-emitting diodes) for spatial orientation of the tracked instruments. The virtual image is then displayed on the computer screen and
c
b
Fig. 7.2 Set up of surgical theater prepared for virtual C1-2 posterior transarticular screw image guided surgery (preoperative data acquisition). (a) Navigational computer screen, tracking
optic camera, screen of fluoroscope. (b) Active DRA fixed to spinous process of C2, passive DRA probe C2 surface registration. (c) Image guided drill connected to active DRA
128
7 Virtual and Real TimeNavigational Techniques
positioning of the patient or even after spine exposure but prior to placement of any hardware. One has to be aware of possible movement or intersegmental relationship change after data acquisition and appropriately re-register or use automatic updates. This is more of a potential problem with systems that rely on preoperative rather than intraoperative scan. A comprehensive data acquisition and computer analysis allows essentially for any intervention to be virtually planned (Fig. 7.4). In terms of UCS and CVJ, this usually applies to determination whether a certain screw is anatomically feasible, the location and course of VA, the best tumor approach, and clival anatomy. Virtual planning can determine whether a complex procedure is feasible and can even be utilized in procedures where further intraoperative navigation is not possible or necessary [26, 33, 34].
7.1.1.1 Preoperative Imaging Based vIGS
Fig. 7.3 Comparison of virtual plan with real drill position visible on navigational computer screen
the procedure follows a preoperative virtual plan and can be checked directly on the screen (Fig. 7.3). Images for navigation systems are currently obtained prior to surgery or, more frequently, after
CT-based preoperative vIGS is the most accurate method of spinal bone navigation, especially when it comes to deformity and anatomically difficult regions. With accurate registration (1.5 mm accuracy), this guidance can be utilized for any screw placement in the UCS and CVJ. Its most useful application is the placement of transarticular C1/2 screw [1, 5, 15, 17, 56] due to the lack of direct visualization of anatomical structures and its accuracy is certainly better than with traditional methods [12, 27, 32, 53]. The downside of preoperative CT-based navigation is the need for a specific scanning
Fig. 7.4 Virtual plan for transarticular screw introduction. (a) Left side. (b) Right side (notice high riding VA)
129
7.1 Technique Description
protocol, which obviously increases the cost in cases where a CT has already been obtained but is incompatible with the navigation system. Registration process is lengthy, has a steep learning curve and each individual vertebra requires separate registration. Usually, only C2 vertebra is registered/guided and C1-reduced position is confirmed by lateral fluoroscopy.
7.1.1.2 Intraoperative Imaging Based vIGS Intraoperative use of CT scanner has been well described. Navigation system registers images obtained after patient positioning and spinal exposure and thus minimizing intersegmental movement that can occur with preoperatively obtained data [20]. It also allows for immediate repeat intraoperative scan to check hardware position. However, the cost and common small gentry’s window of a mobile scanner are the major downsides of this technique. Other drawbacks include the need for a special table, draping technique and the fact that, for example, mobile fracture fragments cannot be seen in a changed position without new registration. Virtual two-dimensional fluoroscopy is perhaps better known to most spine surgeons as it combines the use of familiar fluoroscopy and image guidance techniques [4, 20, 37]. Although its accuracy and virtual guidance is only improved in one plane at a time, application to UCS and CVJ surgery has not been described. Nevertheless, when compared to classic fluoroscopy, the radiation exposure is decreased. This type of navigation depends on regular fluoroscope image acquisition and is, therefore, problematic in obese or osteopenic patients and in poorly visualized regions of the spine. UCS anatomy is not always visible, in particular, in patients with deformity and certainly lacks the necessary detail. Therefore, surgeons have adopted three-dimensional fluoroscopy with the use of isocentric C-arm that automatically rotates around the patient, obtaining fluoroscopic images in the surgical position with the spine centered [21, 22]. The iso-C then generates axial, sagittal, and coronal images of the anatomy that are close to CT quality. The iso-C arm can be connected to a navigation station and images are acquired after the patient is positioned on the table prior to or after the exposure. Spinal exposure prior to registration is not necessary thus obviating the surgeon-driven registration process completely. This fact is important for minimally invasive or even percutaneous spinal
procedures [12, 21]. The accuracy in UCS and CVJ has been established in the initial series using iso-C navigational techniques and is frequently good enough [22, 23, 41, 42]. Axial images can be reconstructed three-dimensionally and sent to the navigation system. A real-time position of spinal elements and implants can be transmitted to the computer and any subsequent navigation is actualized and more accurate. Also, the final position of hardware can be monitored at the end of the procedure [22]. The radiation dose is reduced to 57–77% [22] in comparison with standard CT protocols. Images obtained with iso-C arm are obviously of lesser quality than CT and the volume of the scan is limited to 12 cm3, which means visualization of only four cervical or three lumbar vertebrae. Intraoperative spine image acquisition with MRI became possible with open design of the scanner [44]. This has found application mostly in intracranial surgery of intra-axial lesions to define extent of resection. Similarly, resection of intramedullary spine tumors can be controlled with MRI-based navigation techniques; however, bony structures are poorly defined by this modality [28]. The most limiting nature of an intraoperative MRI is its cost, size, and need for nonmagnetic equipment.
7.1.2 “Real Time” Image Guided Surgery (rIGS) Ideally, “real time” image-guided surgery would allow for a continuous check of the extent of an intervention. Although a real-time feedback in its true sense of a word does not currently exist, the real-time techniques available allow for an immediate check of each step of the procedure. It is safer than any virtual navigation. Surgical strategy can be adapted based on changes during the procedure or target movement. Any dynamic process in surgery (e.g., resection of tumor, extent of decompression, deformity reduction, and/or fracture fragment reposition) will be automatically reflected on subsequent intraoperative scan. The drill/screw angle or length can be modified and visualized. Subsequent steps of surgery minimize the risk to vascular or neural structures as long as frequent updated scans take place. The longer the time interval between “real time” updates is, the higher the risk of inadvertent event. Minimally invasive or even percutaneous spine surgery is clearly safer due to real-time imaging guidance.
130
However, the price for improved safety and accuracy is paid in time necessary for repeated scans, need for a good radiographer or radiologist, higher radiation exposure, need for special table hardware connection for CT or MRI, and surgeons’ discomfort caused by ergonomic problems. The most ergonomic real-time navigational tool is probably three-dimensional isofluoroscopy [22, 23]. The machine is smaller and thus offers some flexibility in the management of operating room and the procedure. It fares favorably against CT or MRI in terms of image acquisition times [24, 40]. Bony structures are well visualized on iso-C arm and it is, therefore, a good tool for delicate procedures of the UCS and CVJ (e.g., transpedicular or transarticular C2 screw placement, odontoid-compressive osteosynthesis or C1–0 screw) [22, 23]. Real-time navigation can also be combined with a virtual one whenever necessary. A good example is the placement of an odontoid-compressive screw that can be guided Iso-C arm and also monitored by lateral fluoroscopy instead of using biplanar fluoroscopy [22]. Three-dimensional isofluoroscopy does account for motion of bone fragments or deformity corrections in real time, which is one of its main advantages. Image quality in obese patients as well as increased radiation exposure remains an issue. The use of direct spinal CT guidance in stationary scanners in radiology suites is well known from percutaneous interventions [3, 43]. Alternatively, it was limited to procedures performed in stationary scanners in radiology departments and suites adapted for use of general anesthesia and surgery [10, 54]. Mobile CT scanners with radiolucent surgical tables then allowed for real-time navigational surgery to move to real operating rooms for larger, open procedures [10, 25]. The superior image quality of CT when compared to isofluoroscopy resulted in broader range of intraoperative applications of this modality and also enabled percutaneous procedures at the UCS and CVJ. As with any intraoperative scanner, the major problems are of ergonomic nature due to the gantry size and need for a special operating table. Likewise, intraoperative MRI (iMRI) surgical systems have been extensively described in the literature [28, 60]. Soft tissue pathologies (extra/intradural tumors, intramedullary tumors, or CVJ anomalies compressing the neural tissue) can be imaged very well with iMRI. Again, the advantages are clear and drawbacks were already mentioned above. The widespread
7 Virtual and Real TimeNavigational Techniques
use of iMRI in spine surgery is prohibited by the low yield of high start-up costs, poor bone visualization, significant metal artifact, and low MRI image quality.
7.2 Our Preference We advocate the use of computer guidance in the surgery of UCS and CVJ, in particular in situations when safety and accuracy can be significantly enhanced. This is especially important when navigating invisible areas. Neural compression can be caused by developmental or acquired deformity, trauma, inflammation or tumor. The use of virtual or real-time CT or MRI to localize or monitor the extent of decompression is well described [55, 57, 58]. Whenever pure bony compression exists, the Iso-C arm may be sufficient. Reconstructive techniques during transoral procedures may require the use of navigational techniques for planning and guiding anchorage of construct to the clivus (Fig. 6.6, Chap. 6; Fig. 19.22, Chap. 19). The position of hypoglossal canal can also be monitored in cases of atlanto-occipital instrumentation when screws pass through the condyle [23]. Although, the anatomy of atlas is relatively simple and rarely requires navigational techniques, this technology facilitated percutaneous fixation of an unusual C1 fracture in our department. The fracture comprised a unilateral sagittal split of the lateral mass with an intact transverse ligament (Figs. 7.5–7.8). The reason for surgical treatment in our situation was the intraarticular nature of the fracture and we believe such fractures result in subsequent pain syndrome, deformity, and poor healing, despite the advocated use of conservative treatment only. Indeed, Bransford et al. [7] later reported on three out of six patients with similar injuries that were initially treated with external orthosis developing a late cockrobin deformity with significant pain and rotatory restriction. All three patients were eventually successfully treated with an occipitocervical fusion that might have been avoided with an initial aggressive treatment. Image guidance can be applied to just about any type of a C2 screw. Anterior approaches are complicated by the lack of a stable DRA attachment to the navigated vertebra but IGS is not impossible as demonstrated in placement of odontoid screws with iso-C navigation [23, 52]. Deformity correction and fracture dislocations can make posterior vIGS difficult. Any mobile part of spine
7.2 Our Preference
131
Fig. 7.5 Unstable two part C1 ring fracture with intact TAL. (a) Axial CT image showing intraarticular extend of fracture. (b) CT reconstruction in coronal plane. (c) MRI confirming the intact TAL
Fig. 7.6 First step of “real time” percutaneous CT guided osteosynthesis of distracted C1 lateral mass fracture (the same patient from Fig. 7.5). (a) Planning of introductory angle. (b–d) Consecutive “step by step” introduction of K-wire through the fracture. Each step controlled by repeated CT image
or fracture fragment cannot be registered preoperatively; perioperative data update is time-consuming and it only depicts one actual position of target in space. This becomes obvious when reducing hangman’s fracture posteriorly. This issue was overcome by real-time CT-based guidance [54]. Judet’s transpedicular screw
compressive osteosynthesis [2, 29, 41, 42] can effectively be performed in patients with some Effendi type II fractures without disk bulge or, more appropriately, in Effendi type I injuries, where the fracture gap is larger than 3 mm on the CT scan (see Chap. 12). The UCS is approached through a standard midline approach and
132 Fig. 7.7 Percutaneous drilling and cannulated screw purchase along the K-wire. (a) Cannulated drill introduced along the K-wire. (b) Cannulated screw driver in position. (c, d) Consecutive cannulated lag screw passage
7 Virtual and Real TimeNavigational Techniques
a
b
c
d
Fig. 7.8 Final tightening of the lag screw compressing the fracture (result after 1.5 year on Fig. 10.13, Chap. 10). (a) Before tightening. (b) Final fracture compression
entry points are planned according to the navigation computer optimal trajectory. The gantry of a scanner is accordingly to maximize screw visualization as it passes through the axis. Repeated CT scans monitor the stepby-step gradual screw introduction. The fracture is finally compressed by tightening of the lag screw; the length of which is chosen based on navigation images
(Fig. 7.9; Fig. 12.16, Chap. 12). We believe that, soon many of those procedures will be achievable percutaneously thanks to the development of mobile scanners, Iso-C arms, and better computer software. Currently, we use two main surgical techniques for C1–2 fixation: atlantoaxial screw fixation as described by Magerl in 1987 [35] and the