Henry Smith here develops a theory of syntactic case and examines its synchronic and diachronic consequences. Within a u...
300 downloads
1161 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Henry Smith here develops a theory of syntactic case and examines its synchronic and diachronic consequences. Within a unification-based framework, the book draws out pervasive patterns in the relationship between morphosyntax ("linking") and grammatical function. The theory proposed consists of three ordered constraints on the association of NPs and arguments, based on the central notion of "restrictiveness." Beginning with a detailed study of dative substitution in Icelandic, the author moves on to examine a wide array of synchronic and diachronic data and to construct a typology of case. Theoretically innovative and sophisticated, and descriptively wideranging, this book will appeal to all those interested in the crosslinguistic marking of case and the ways in which case systems may change over time.
CAMBRIDGE STUDIES IN LINGUISTICS General Editors: s. R. ANDERSON, J. BRESNAN, B. COMRIE, W. DRESSLER, R. HUDDLESTON, R. LASS, D. LIGHTFOOT, J. LYONS, P. H. MATTHEWS, R. POSNER, S. ROMAINE, N. V. SMITH, N. VINCENT
Restrictiveness in case theory
In this series
52
53 54 55 56
MICHAEL s. ROCHEMONT and PETER w. CULICOVER: English focus constructions and the
theory of grammar PHILIP CARR: Linguistic realities: an autonomist metatheory for the generative enterprise EVE SWEETSER: From etymology to pragmatics: metaphorical and cultural aspects of semantic structure REGINA BLASS: Relevance relations in discourse: a study with special reference to Sissala ANDREW CHESTERMAN: On definiteness: a study with special reference to English and Finnish
57
ALESSANDRA GIORGI and GIUSEPPE LONGOBARDI: The syntax of noun phrases: configura-
62
STEPHEN R. ANDERSON: A-Morphous Morphology
69
R. M. w. DIXON: Ergativity
74 75 76
ALICE c. HARRIS and LYLE CAMPBELL: Historical syntax in cross-linguistic perspective LILIANE HAEGEMAN: The syntax of negation PAUL GORRELL: Syntax and parsing
tion, parameters and empty categories 58 MONIK CHARETTE: Conditions on phonological government 59 M. H. KLAIMAN: Grammatical voice 60 SARAH M. B. FAGAN: The syntax and semantics of middle constructions: a study with special reference to German 61 ANJUM p. SALEEMI: Universal Grammar and language learnability
63 LESLEY STIRLING: Switch reference and discourse representation 64 HENK J. VERKUYL: A theory of aspectuality: the interaction between temporal and atemporal structure 65 EVE v. CLARK: The lexicon in acquisition 66 ANTHONY R. WARNER: English auxiliaries: structure and history 67 p. H. MATTHEWS: Grammatical theory in the United States from Bloomfield to Chomsky 68 LJILJANA PROGOVAC: Negative and positive polarity: a binding approach 70 YAN HUANG: The syntax and pragmatics of anaphora 71 KNUD LAMBRECHT: Information structure and sentence form: Topic, focus, and the mental representations of discourse referents 72 LUIGI BURZIO: Principles of English stress 73 JOHN A. HAWKINS: A performance theory of order and constituency
77 GUGLIELMO CINQUE: Italian syntax and Universal Grammar 78 HENRY SMITH: Restrictiveness in case theory
Supplementary volumes MICHEAL o. SIADHAIL: Modern Irish: grammatical structure and dialectal variation ANNICK DE HOUWER: The acquisition of two languages from birth: a case study LILIANE HAEGEMAN: Theory and description in generative syntax: A case study in West Flemish A. E. BACKHOUSE: The lexical field of taste: A semantic study of Japanese taste terms NIKOLAUS RITT: Quantity adjustment: Vowel lengthening and shortening in early Middle English
Earlier issues not listed are also available
RESTRICTIVENESS IN CASE THEORY HENRY SMITH
CAMBRIDGE
UNIVERSITY PRESS
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, Sao Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521462877 © Cambridge University Press 1996 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1996 This digitally printed first paperback version 2006 A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data Smith, Henry. Restrictiveness in case theory / Henry Smith. p. cm - (Cambridge studies in linguistics) Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0 521 46287 8 (hardback) I. Grammar, Comparative and general - case. I. Title. II. Series. P240.6.S64 1996 415-dc20 95-32776 CIP ISBN-13 978-0-521-46287-7 hardback ISBN-10 0-521-46287-8 hardback ISBN-13 978-0-521-02655-0 paperback ISBN-10 0-521-02655-5 paperback
For Sun-Joo
Contents
A cknowledgemen ts
page xi
1 1.1 1.2 1.3
Introduction Preliminaries Theoretical framework Overview
1 1 3 20
2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
Argument case and case alternations Case alternations and the problem of case Case, argument structure, and interpretation Basic clause structure Case alternations and restrictiveness Why argument structure? Conclusion
22 22 31 48 51 60 69
3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5
A typology of case systems Two accusatives A typology of case Four types of case system Split ergativity Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
70 70 74 86 115 118
4 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4
Linker interactions Other elsewhere patterns Passive and antipassive Word order Obliqueness and compatibility of case and configuration Comnatibilitv of linkers
130 130 146 154
4.5
158 166
x
Contents
5 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5
Icelandic Case, agreement, and word order Case preservation and nominative objects Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric? Coordination More on the lexical accusative
171 171 180 194 208 213
6 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6
Changes in linking Previous work on linking change Diachronic aspects of case alternations A theory of analogical change in linking Acquisition of termhood Scandinavian Conclusions
221 221 226 233 236 245 255
7 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5
Case semi-preservation Case (non-)preservation "Scattered cases" and semi-preservation Further implications Diachronic predictions Conclusion
259 259 274 282 287 288
8
Conclusions
289
Notes References Index
293 307 317
Acknowledgements
The present study grew out of my Ph.D. dissertation in Linguistics at Stanford University. I would like to thank Paul Kiparsky, Rob Robinson, Elizabeth Traugott, and Tom Wasow for their support and valuable advice throughout this project. Without the encouragement of Elizabeth Traugott and Tom Wasow the dissertation would never have turned into this book. I also have many people to thank for their useful suggestions, including Thora Arnadottir, John Ole Askedal, Joan Bresnan, Michael Barnes, Chris Culy, Cathrine Fabricius-Hansen, Vjacheslav Ivanov, Tracy King, Paul Kroeger, Andreas Ludwig, Joan Maling, Chris Pinon, Peter Sells, Hoskuldur Thrainsson, Steve Wechsler, and Annie Zaenen. Thanks also to Ted Andersson for his inspiring courses on Germanic languages and to Michelle Murray, Gertrud Pacheco, Emma Pease, and Gina Wein for their generous assistance during graduate school. I would also like to give thanks to two anonymous reviewers from Cambridge University Press for their valuable comments and to Judith Ayling, Hilary Gaskin, Kay McKechnie, and Joanna West for their help in the publication of this book. I am grateful to Stanford University, the Fulbright Foundation, and the Center for the Study of Language and Information for financial support and to my students and colleagues at Indiana University, Bloomington, for a congenial setting for continuing this project. I also wish to thank my parents. Most of all, I thank my wife, Sun-Joo, for being the best possible emotional and intellectual companion. Material from my article "'Dative Sickness' in Icelandic," Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 12 (1994) 675-736, appears in Section 1.2 and scattered throughout Chapter 2.
XI
1
1.1
Introduction
Preliminaries
The study of case has many facets, and the word "case" itself has come to mean many things. This study aims at a better understanding of the way case functions in syntax by providing a new theory of the syntactic functioning of case and other morphosyntactic devices. Because the focus is on case as it functions in syntax rather than case as a morphological category, I will make certain assumptions which will figure prominently below. First, I will assume that morphological case and syntactic case do not always coincide. Morphological case will simply be the paradigms of affixes which may carry other information as well, e.g. gender and number. For example, the "dative" case as a morphological category is a set of endings. My primary concern is with syntactic case, and here the distinctions are not quite so visible. A syntactic case will be defined by its basic distribution and its interaction with other cases. For instance, if we observe that dative marks the goals of various verbs - what might be termed "indirect objects" - we have a situation very common in the world's languages: I(NOM) gave you(DAT) the book(ACc). But quite often we then notice that the dative marks an NP that is an experiencer in a sentence based on a two-place predicate: I(DAT) like the book(NOM). At this point we have a choice. We can assert that the " I " NP in such a sentence is the "same" in some sense as the "VOU(DAT)" in the sentence with the three-place predicate. The "sameness" might be identity of "grammatical relation," for example indirect object (or 3 in Relational Grammar). Another ("localist") approach would be to seek some shared semantic characteristics, making them both the endpoint of some motion, either physical or metaphorical. Either way, the appearance of a morphological dative is coextensive with some more abstract category. 1
2
Introduction
The problem becomes more difficult when we find isolated verbs taking this same morphological case, where we expect another case, e.g. accusative: I(NOM) lost the book(DAT). We can try to save the match between dative and our abstract categories like indirect object or experiencer, but only at a price. If we say that such a verb (Icelandic has many such verbs) selects an indirect object, then we are well on our way to reducing indirect object to the category of morphological dative. Saying that dative is assigned to indirect objects approaches being a tautology. However, if the distinction between case as a morphological category and case as a syntactic category is made, then we have another option, taken in this work. One morphological case can correspond to multiple syntactic cases. This is like saying that we have various "rules" for assigning dative, one for "indirect objects" (or whatever category is appropriate for datives in ditransitives), and one for "experiencers". And verbs can assign dative in their lexical entries, the limiting case of a rule that applies to one item. This distinction is an interesting one to the extent that it leads to the discovery of new phenomena. One of the primary motivations of this study is to show that this is so. Furthermore, if the definition of syntactic cases involves, as I will argue, a consideration of their basic distributions and effects on the syntax of the clause, then it is proper to consider other morphosyntactic devices as forming similar syntactic categories. It is well-known that agreement and/or a particular position, e.g. sentence-initial position, correlate with what we might want to call subjecthood. That is, NPs that are special in a sense to be described shortly, are often the target of agreement or occur in a special position. For languages that have such behavior, I will treat agreement and word order as syntactic "case" categories which do not correspond to a morphological case. All such syntactic "cases" will be called "linkers." I will use "case" and "linker" interchangeably, except that I will use "linker" as the general term whenever I wish to draw attention to the distinction between case proper and linkers generally. What they all have in common is that they "link" mediate between in a sense to be described shortly - arguments on the one hand and surface NPs on the other. Predicting surface form based on the number and type of NP complements a verb selects is not the only goal. I will argue, in the tradition of direct linking (about which more in the next section), that grammatical relations like "subject o f and "object o f can be defined on the order of the verb's complements and the nature of the linking they undergo. To
Theoretical framework 3 this end one distinction often made is crucial here. Subjecthood properties come in two varieties, coding and behavioral (Keenan (1976)). Coding properties are nominative case in some languages, preverbal position in some languages, etc. Behavioral subjecthood properties are the ability to participate in certain syntactic constructions in certain ways, for example to be the target of control, to be the antecedent of certain kinds of reflexive pronouns, etc. One of the main claims in the following is that the second type of property, the participation in characteristic constructions, is predictable on the basis of linking, i.e. coding properties. From the argument structure of a verb and from linkers like nominative and dative and their nature, we will be able to derive the grammatical function behavior of the various NPs. A final goal of the present study is to provide a theory that can begin to account for another type of case behavior, the change of cases over time. Once again, I will focus on changes in linking rather than purely morphological changes in sets of endings. Of course I will not take the history of linking in any language to be synchronically represented as part of any speaker's competence. I will, however, try to show that the theory developed to account for syntactic case behavior has diachronic implications which are supported by a wide range of data.
1.2
Theoretical framework
In the following chapters I will develop a theory of case within a framework based on two traditions, direct linking and the extended categorial framework. Since the second is more widely known, this section will focus on direct linking and on which aspects of it will be adopted below. 1.2.1 What is linking? Generally speaking, a theory of linking deals with generalizations involving argument structure (possibly including thematic structure), grammatical functions (subject, object, oblique), and morphosyntactic expression (case marking, word order, and agreement). A very simple linking theory for English based on traditional grammar would be as follows: (1)
a. NPs that denote agents bear the grammatical relation subject, b. NPs that denote patients bear the grammatical relation direct object.
4
Introduction c. NPs that denote beneficiaries or recipients bear the grammatical relation indirect object.
(2)
a. Subjects normally occur in preverbal position. b. Indirect objects occur immediately after the verb. c. Direct objects occur within the verb phrase.
Latin, on the other hand, being a language with the nominative-dativeaccusative system alluded to in the previous section, would share the rules in (1) with English but would have (2') instead of (2), which would account for the distribution of cases in a ditransitive like (3): (2')
a. Subjects are marked nominative and the verb agrees with the subject. b. Direct objects are marked accusative. c. Indirect objects are marked dative
(3)
Magister pueris librum dat. teacher(NOM) boys(DAT) book(Acc) gives 'The teacher gives the boys the book.'
The rules in (1) express generalizations about the semantic content of NPs, and the rules in (2) and (2 ; ) state generalizations about the expression of NPs. Notice that mediating between notions like agent and patient on the one hand and morphosyntactic categories like nominative and dative on the other are the grammatical relations. Morphosyntactic expression is assigned to grammatical relations which in turn are correlated with thematic relations. The above toy theory does of course contain many inadequacies. Under (1), we have two problems. First, the rules are too strong and too weak. It is not true that agents are always subjects: for example, in the passive the patient is the subject and the agent is expressed in a byphrase, if at all. Nor is it true that subjects are always agents, as shown by sentences like John died. So just reversing the direction of the generalizations (Subjects are agents, etc.) above would not work. The second problem is the nature of the thematic relations themselves. Providing a satisfactory definition of "agent" or "patient" has been very difficult indeed (see Dowty (1991) for a thorough discussion of this problem). At this point we are faced with two choices. One is to use thematic relations provisionally in the hope of discovering an adequate definition
Theoretical framework
5
later. The second is to try to do without them. This is the route taken in the following work (see §1.2.3 and Chapter 2 below). The term "linking" is applied to a theory that deals with generalizations like those in (1) or those in (2). A theory of linking is said to be "direct" in the sense of Kiparsky (1987) if the mapping between arguments (for Kiparsky, thematic roles) and morphosyntactic form is direct rather than mediated, as in (1) and (2), by grammatical functions like subject and object. Rather, the mapping between arguments and morphosyntactic expression is primary, and grammatical relations can be defined as the result or output of the linking itself. Very roughly, mediated and direct linking can be schematized as in (4):1 (4)
mediated linking: arguments —> grammatical functions —• morphosyntax direct linking: arguments —> morphosyntax —• grammatical functions
In mediated linking, some rule (or the equivalent) assigns grammatical functions to arguments and then case is assigned to grammatical functions. In direct linking, rules assign case and other morphosyntactic categories to arguments directly and grammatical functions can be assigned to the resulting case-marked NP. In fact, as we will see, this assignment is hardly an assignment at all if one defines grammatical functions in terms of the result of the linking (the assignment of morphosyntactic expression to the arguments). 7.2.2 Background to this study: direct linking The direct linking approach has its antecedents in Panini's theory of karakas and, more recently, in Case Grammar (Fillmore (1968)) and in the theory of Ostler (1979). Since I will be using the direct linking framework and since the theory to be proposed shortly is most closely related to that of Kiparsky (1987), I will present the basics of Kiparsky's Linking Theory (henceforth KLT) in this subsection. In the next subsection I will outline which aspects of direct linking will be incorporated into the present work. Since it is a direct linking theory, KLT assumes that morphosyntactic expression is assigned directly to arguments. In Kiparsky (1987) these arguments are taken to be thematic roles, i.e. arguments with labels that reflect lexical semantic classifications. Arguments are classified into thematic roles by the entailments that the argument is involved in
6
Introduction
(Ladusaw and Dowty (1987), Dowty (1989)). Thus an argument is an experiencer if a positive sentence with the verb entails that the entity corresponding to that argument is sentient and aware of something. Leaving aside for now the problem that such definitions pose, the resulting thematic roles are then organized into a hierarchy (many versions exist; Jackendoff (1972) is an especially famous one). KLT assumes the partial hierarchy in (5): (5)
( agent/source ( goal (instrument (theme (locative ( verb ))))))
The argument structures of individual verbs will be a list of thematic roles obeying the order in (5), i.e. the argument structure of a given verb is a portion of this hierarchy. For example the verb kick will have the argument structure in (6): (6)
( agent (theme ( kick )))
Roles lower on the hierarchy are closer to the verb (combine with the verb last), as indicated by the complex bracketing in (5). Thus in (6), the claim is that the theme is more closely related to the verb than the agent. Kiparsky (1987) claims support for this view from (i) unmarked word order and (ii) interpretational dependencies. First, if the thematic hierarchy defines the order in which arguments are semantically combined with their predicates (Kiparsky (1987: 34)), then the "unmarked" word order should be determined by the hierarchy. The idea is that the order that reflects the combining of the arguments with the verb will show up on the surface, provided that no grammatical constraints or extragrammatical factors intervene. Language-specific grammatical factors do indeed intervene in strict word-order languages like English, but the hypothesis seems to be supported in some well-known languages like German and Japanese. However, the proviso concerning grammatical or extra-grammatical factors is a major one, making it very unclear whether there is a cross-linguistic unmarked word order, as Kiparsky (1987: 34) admits. The second piece of evidence for the thematic hierarchy is from interpretational dependencies between the arguments of a verb. The claim is that the interpretation of higher thematic roles often depends on the result of composing the predicate with lower roles but not vice versa. Take the verb keep as an example. When the agent is combined, the presence or absence of a source (e.g. from Bill) determines whether the agent is entailed to "possess" the theme or not. So in John kept the
Theoretical framework
7
money, John is entailed to have the money, whereas in John kept the money from Bill, John is not entailed to have the money. A related piece of evidence for the hierarchy comes from idioms. Marantz (1984) argued for a logical subject/logical object asymmetry on the basis of the greater frequency of object idioms (idioms with a "frozen" object, e.g. kick the bucket) relative to the frequency of subject idioms (idioms with a "frozen" subject, e.g. the devil take . . . ). Kiparsky (1987: 35f.) makes the stronger claim that frequency of idiom type correlates with how far down the thematic hierarchy the idiom type's "frozen" thematic role is. So we should expect most verb-locative idioms (throw X to the wolves, etc.) and fewest verb-agent idioms. This is difficult to show, even for one language, and the list in Kiparsky (1987: 36) shows that verb-locative, verb-theme and verb-locative-theme idioms are common, while verb-theme-goal, verb-goal, verb-agent, etc. are scarce. This is a first step, but all this really shows is a major divide between locative and theme on the one hand and goal and agent on the other. The evidence from idioms is suggestive, but it cannot be taken as a justification of distinctions as fine-grained as those of even the partial thematic hierarchy above. Regardless of whether one accepts the thematic roles approach to argument structure, KLT is a theory of linking and so covers argument relations and morphosyntactic expression but does not extend to WhMovement. This makes sense in terms of Government and Binding Theory (GB) (Chomsky (1981)) as well, since Wh-Movement is never movement to get Case. Rather, linking is concerned with what in GB would be handled through the lexicon, Theta Theory, and Case Theory. Since KLT deals with "NP-Movement" phenomena in a very different way from the GB treatment (KLT has no NP-Movement, as we will see), and Wh-Movement falls outside the area of linking, Kiparsky (1987) adopts the lexical structure of Hale (1983) as the locus of linking (lexical structure is similar to NP-Structure of Riemsdijk and Williams (1981)). Lexical structure consists of trees, and (like NP-Structure in Riemsdijk and Williams (1981)) it corresponds to what in GB would be the structure after NP-Movement and before Wh-Movement (this is not a level in conventional GB: it would be an intermediate stage of the derivation from D-Structure to S-Structure). Since Kiparsky makes these assumptions, his definition of linking is:
8 Introduction (7)
Linking is a three-place relation between a 0-role, an argument (at lexical structure), and a morphosyntactic linker.
A linker is a morphosyntactic device such as a case, a word-order position or an agreement marker, i.e. a "syntactic case," as described in the last section. Linking rules will establish relations of the type in (7). So for instance, the rule "goal gets dative" will establish that an NP argument at lexical structure marked dative will be associated with the goal 0-role of the verb of the clause: (8) < agent NOM
1
DAT 1
Magister
1
N
puerls N
NP
NP
< theme < d a t > » 1 1 ACC
librum
dat
N
1
V
NP
This is the result of linking for the Latin clause in (3) above. Note that the morphologically dative argument at lexical structure is linked via the dative morphosyntactic category (the dative linker) to the goal at thematic structure. Note further the caret sign next to the goal. This denotes "demoted," i.e. syntactically oblique.2 All this means is that the indirect object in Latin is a syntactical oblique, i.e. it does not show any of the behavioral subjecthood or objecthood properties mentioned in the last section and examined more closely in the next chapter. To get this complete result though, two other linkings (for the agent and theme) had to be completed. To get (8) it will be necessary to go into more detail about linking in KLT. Kiparsky (1987: 37), following Ostler (1979), distinguishes two kinds of linking, grammatical and semantic: (9)
a. Grammatical linking: agreement morphology, "grammatical" cases or adpositions, case, or position under verb government. Grammatical linking operates on the projection of (non-
Theoretical framework
9
demoted) roles in the 0-structure. Grammatical linking is of two types, unrestricted and semantically restricted (i.e. limited to a given 0-role). b. Semantic linking: role assigners such as semantic ("oblique," "adverbial") cases or adpositions, and serial verbs. Any 0-role is eligible for semantic linking. Roughly speaking, the distinction between grammatical and semantic linking corresponds to the term/non-term distinction in Relational Grammar, since the significance of the grammatical/semantic linking distinction lies in the definition of grammatical functions, which, it should be recalled, are defined on the result of linking. The definitions are as follows: (10)
a. b. c. d.
Term: any grammatically linked argument3 Oblique: any non-term Subject: highest term of a predicate 4 Object: non-subject term of a predicate
Thus in the Latin in (8) above, the NP magister 'teacher' is linked by a grammatical linker, verb agreement, so this NP is said to be grammatically linked. It is the thematically highest grammatically linked NP and so, since it is the highest non-oblique, it is by definition the subject. An oblique like the dative NP in (8) is linked to a demoted role. Since the role is demoted, only semantic linking is possible. And, since the NP is semantically rather than grammatically linked, it is an oblique rather than a term. The significance of the definitions is even clearer in the passive. KLT, like many current theories (including GB and the Lexical Mapping Theory of recent Lexical Functional Grammar (Bresnan and Kanerva (1989)), takes passive to result from the demotion of the "logical subject," i.e. the thematically highest argument. For the verb do 'give' in (3) and (8) above, that argument is the agent. For the passive in (11), the passive rule in (12) is used to derive the argument structure in (13): (11)
Liber pueris a magistro datur. book(NOM) boys(DAT) by teacher is-given 'The book is given to the students by the teacher.'
(12)
(9 ...) -> (9* ...)
(13)
(agentA (goalA (theme ( datur ))))
10
Introduction
Again, the caret sign denotes "demoted," i.e. unavailable for grammatical linking (oblique). Thus if the passive verb is the basis for linking, we cannot use any grammatical linker, including verb agreement, to link the agent as we did in the active version above. The demoted agent will be available only for semantic linking, by the preposition meaning 'by': (14)
< agentA
DAT
Liber
pueris
< theme
AGR,N0M
a
magistro
datur
N N
N
NP
NP
P
NP PP
Note that the goal, if it had been grammatically linked, would have been the new subject, and, for example, in English where the goal is nonoblique, it could be the subject (The students were given the books). In Latin, though, the goal is demoted, so that the highest role available for grammatical linking in the passive is the theme. It is linked by agreement, a grammatical linker, and so is the thematically highest grammatically linked 9-role, i.e. the subject. Thus in both active and passive subjecthood falls out of the linking itself. So far we have not been explicit about how the linking is done, i.e. which NP arguments and morphosyntactic devices to match up with which arguments. This will be the major topic of this book, and, although our conclusions will differ significantly from those of Kiparsky (1987), it will be useful to spell out the positions taken in Kiparsky (1987) beforehand. First of all, linking is subject to several constraints, which are the rough analogues in Kiparsky (1987: 37) of the Case Theory and Theta Theory of GB: (15)
a. One-to-one: Every linker must link a unique argument to at most one unique 6-role.
Theoretical framework
11
b. Obligatoriness:
(i) Lexically realized arguments must be linked, (ii) Terms must be linked (parametric). c. Priority clause: (i) Grammatical linking has priority over semantic linking. (ii) Inner 6-roles have priority over outer 9roles.
The condition in (15a) disallows one NP expressing more than one 9-role and disallows a 9-role's being expressed by more than one NP (cf. the Biuniqueness Condition in GB). The Obligatoriness Condition Part (i) disallows unlinked NPs, i.e. linking is a precondition on the occurrence of an NP at the surface. This is similar in effect to the Case Theory of GB which disallows phonetically realized NPs from being Caseless. The Priority Clause deals with the relative priority of the linking of certain 9-roles over other 9-roles (ii) and some linkers over other linkers (i). In other words, if a given 9-role is eligible for both a grammatical linker and a semantic linker, the 9-role must be grammatically linked. We have already seen a case where this clause operates: in the active clause in (8) above, the logical subject, since it is not demoted, is eligible for the grammatical agreement linker and, since it is an agent, it is always eligible for the preposition a 'by' (this is a semantic linker for agents). In this case the agreement linker has priority by (15c)(i). In the passive, however, the agent is demoted and so is available only for semantic linking. Finally, in any direct linking theory, the inventory of linkers and the conditions on their distribution are paramount. Since the proposals of Kiparsky (1987) will be taken as a starting point for developing an alternative, I begin with Kiparsky's (1987, 1989) analysis of English. "Grammatical relations," whether primitive or derived, correlate with word-order position in English. This effect can be achieved in direct linking by means of the rules he proposes for English: (16)
Grammatical Linkers (Kiparsky (1989)) a. Agreement and _V": unrestricted b. V_ : unrestricted c. V'_ : Theme
(17)
Semantic Linkers (Partial List, Kiparsky (1987: 14)) a. by_ : highest 9-role5 b. to_ : Goal, Allative
12
Introduction c. d. e. f. g.
into_ : Illative in_ : Inessive at_ : Adessive with_ : Instrumental, Comitative, Non-affected Theme V_ : Benefactive, Experiencer
The rules (linkers) in (16) and (17) are in a format where a symbol or symbols representing the morphosyntactic category is given to the left of a colon, and the restrictions, if any, on which 0-roles the linker may link are given to the right of the colon. If multiple roles appear here, the rule is to be read disjunctively, e.g. (17b) is "Goal or Allative." Roles like allative, illative, inessive, and adessive are subvarieties of locatives. The linkers are somewhat like abstract Cases in GB with surface form more fully specified (in GB it is possible for NOM to stand for no morphological ending) and its assignment possibilities spelled out.6 Since V" is the second verbal projection ( = VP), the symbol " _ v " " means VP-external position (cf. NP-of-S). The symbol "V_" means sister of the verb, and the symbol " V i " means sister of the first projection above the verb, all in accordance with the phrase structure rules in (18): (18)
a. S - • V" N " P " b . V" -> V N " P " c. V' -> V N " (Prt)
Note that sister-of-V is both a grammatical linker for any role (16c) and a semantic linker for benefactives and experiencers (17g). Although it is not reflected in these rules he proposes, Kiparsky asserts that agreement always links the highest available (non-demoted) role, making agreement an exception to the Priority Clause Part (ii) in (15c)(ii). To support this, Kiparsky cites the diachronic development of agreement from anaphors, and the fact that anaphors often require a subject antecedent of some sort. Kiparsky assumes that the anaphoric property of "subject orientation" is synchronically still present in agreement markers. Since he asserts that agreement "inherently" seeks the highest available role, it is not stipulated in the agreement rule.7 Kiparsky further assumes that the VP-external position is associated with agreement and so is also highest-role-oriented. To take a simple example, consider the following ditransitive: (19)
John gave me the books.
Theoretical framework
13
The 9-structure of give is: (20)
( agent ( goal ( theme ( give ))))
By the Priority Clause (15c) we should start with lower roles and with grammatical linkers. The theme is lowest and is eligible for linking by the sister-of-V position (16c) or the sister-of-V' position (16c) (agreement and VP-external position (16a) are not available, since there are higher nondemoted roles, the agent and the goal). Since sister-of-V' (16c), although a grammatical linker, is semantically restricted to theme, and the lowest 0-role here is a theme, this 6-role is linked by (16c): (21)
( agent ( goal ( theme ( give ))))
Moving on to the next lowest role - in accordance with the Priority Clause (ii) - the goal is eligible for linking by the sister-of-V linker only (goal is not the highest available role for grammatical linking and so agreement and VP-external position may not apply). Goal is linked by (16b): (22)
( agent ( goal ( theme ( give ))))
I
I
V_
V'_
All that remains is the agent, and it is linked by agreement and VPexternal position (16a): (23)
( agent
I
agr, _V"
( goal ( theme ( give ))))
I
V_
I
V'_
All G-roles are linked, and so the NPs at lexical structure pass the Obligatoriness Condition. Kiparsky's analysis captures the other possibilities for ditransitives, including those involving a particle, like send up, since he assumes that goals in ditransitives are optionally demoted: (24)
( agent ( goal(A) ( theme ( give ))))
14
Introduction
The possibilities for linking correspond to acceptability judgments: (25)
V"
V a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h.
V
N"
N'
Prt
sent a drink sent sent John *sent John *sent a drink *sent *sent *sent
P"
up up a drink up a drink a drink up John up John up to John up a drink
to John to John up a drink a drink John
In all of the versions in (25), the agent is linked by agreement and VPexternal position as already noted. The first possibility (25a) is based on a demoted goal linked by means of the semantic linker to. The theme is linked by sister-of-V position. In (25b) the goal is similarly linked by to, but this time the theme is linked by sister-of-V'. This is possible, since in KLT neither of the two possible positional linkers for the theme has priority over the other. In (25c) the goal is not demoted. Only the theme qualifies for the sister-of-V'; so if both goal and theme are to be positionally linked, it will be theme by sister-of-V' position and goal by the inner position. In the remaining VPs in (25d-h), something has gone wrong. In (25d) the sister-of-V position has linked two 6-roles (goal and theme), which violates the One-to-One Constraint in (15a) above. The same is true of the outer verbal position in (25f); here it links both the goal and the theme. In (25e), the outer verbal position has linked a non-theme, contrary to that linker's own distributional constraint. Finally, in (25g) and (25h), one NP, a drink and John, respectively, is not linked at all: in each, the offending NP is in a position that corresponds to no linker and neither has an appropriate prepositional linker. Note that (25h) could be saved by linking the final NP, John, with the preposition to. This, in fact, would yield the acceptable (25b).
Theoretical framework
15
Direct linking, by deriving grammatical functions, makes several claims. Most obviously, the more that can be derived rather than taken as primitive the better. However, a defender of grammatical functions as primitives might counter that the linkers themselves would not be necessary if grammatical functions are taken as primitives. The real questions are rather which theory is simpler overall and which theory is empirically better supported. On the first score, the elegance of the definitions of grammatical functions should carry some weight. More importantly, direct linking makes a range of empirical claims which stem from the elimination of grammatical functions as primitives. First of all, direct linking does not provide for "deep grammatical relations" like those in Relational Grammar (RG) (see especially Perlmutter (1982)). Notions of subject in RG include initial 1, working 1, acting 1, and final 1 (and correspondingly for other grammatical relations). In direct linking there are no intermediate strata and no grammatical relations at all until linking is complete. In fact, direct linking allows no use of grammatical relations in capturing morphosyntactic generalizations like the distribution of nominative and accusative cases. And, since only final grammatical relations are defined, the most that other processes like binding can mention is logical subject (highest argument in argument structure) and (final, surface) subject. For areas other than morphosyntax, then, notions like working 1 and acting 1 are not available. Finally, it should be noted that logical subject and logical object are not the same as initial 1 and initial 2 in RG, which are also unavailable in direct linking. In a theory like RG based on grammatical relations, there are normally rules based on grammatical relations. Passive is an example, since on the RG view it turns a subject into an oblique and an object into a subject. Once again this is a morphosyntactic process and direct linking cannot capture it using grammatical relations (as we have already seen, direct linking holds passive to be the demotion of the logical subject). In RG, the rules that change grammatical relations can furthermore be used to make possible entire levels that are more abstract than would otherwise be possible. A typical example is the RG approach to unaccusativity (also essentially adopted by GB). RG has an unaccusative rule for so-called unaccusative verbs like die. Roughly speaking, unaccusative verbs like die have non-agentive subjects. RG assumes that, unlike unergative verbs (which do have agentive subjects, e.g. work), unaccusative
16
Introduction
verbs have underlying initial objects rather than subjects. This object is transformed into a subject before the surface. In direct linking, however, such an approach is not possible. The single argument of all intransitives, whether unaccusative or unergative, is a logical subject. To the extent that unaccusativity is really a syntactic phenomenon, then, it must be captured in some other fashion, e.g. by making a distinction between external and internal arguments (i.e. the sole argument of an unaccusative would be an internal argument, but the sole argument of an unergative would be an external argument). In the next subsection I will discuss how the proposals of this book differ from those of KLT. Before doing so I want to emphasize both what is common to direct linking theories and what places the theory I will develop firmly in the class of direct linking theories. First, a direct linking theory relates argument structure to surface form "directly." This relationship is not wholly direct in that we have a distinction between surface form versus syntactic linkers which "assign" that form, i.e. the morphological vs. syntactic case distinction mentioned earlier. However, relating arguments to surface form by syntactic linkers is more "direct" than relating argument structure to surface form via grammatical relations. The reason is that our syntactic linkers will have strong limits on how abstract they can be. If an NP is dative in one sentence and is accusative in another sentence, traditional theories would allow us to claim that both NPs are objects but that the objects get different case marking. The category object relating the arguments to cases is abstract in the sense that the cases do not constrain our choice of grammatical function analysis for the NPs Linkers are syntactic "cases" in the sense that they do place a limit on this kind of abstractness. If one NP is dative and another accusative, they cannot be said to be linked by the same linker.8 More generally: (26)
If two NPs are linked by the same linker, they must show the same corresponding surface form. Equivalently, if two NPs show different surface form, they cannot be linked by the same linker (s).
By "surface form" I mean the surface correlate of a morphosyntactic category. So, to return to the hypothetical example, if one NP is dative, another is accusative, and we have already analyzed the language as having a dative and an accusative linker, it would not be possible to say that both NPs are linked by the dative linker, but one just appears
Theoretical framework
17
accusative. This is quite unlike the situation with grammatical functions, where it is perfectly fine to say that two NPs are direct objects but one appears dative and the other accusative. The same is true for other types of linkers as well. Take the situation where, based on other facts, our analysis of a language has some combination of word-order positions as the linkers. Where an NP appears in the phrase structure (the result of another kind of analysis) will put limits on which linker we could claim to be linking the NP. An NP that appears outside V' cannot be said to be linked by sister-of-V or VP-external position. So in direct linking the surface form - case, configuration, and/or agreement - does limit the possibilities for morphosyntacic analysis. A fundamental assumption of direct linking is that different morphological categories imply different linkers.9 Morphology strongly constrains the theory of linking. The general question about direct linking of any kind is whether it captures morphosyntactic generalizations better than an approach using grammatical functions (or their equivalents, such as structural positions in GB). 10 There are three ways that direct linking or mediated linking could be better at capturing such generalizations. First, we should ask whether one or the other leads to a confirmed generalization that the other does not. Second, the generalizations that one approach can capture may be more accurate than those made possible by the other one. Third, it will be important to find out whether the generalizations on one approach are more general and the set of generalizations is more elegant. This last criterion can be seen as the criterion of explanatory value. 1.2.3 Notation and basics The theory to be presented below is one of direct linking, and, although KLT is its point of departure, it will be useful to have an overview of how the proposals of the following chapters differ from KLT. The differences are both substantial and notational. First, I will not assume thematic roles or thematic role labels for arguments. I will propose a distinction between argument types and argument categories and will use only the latter in linking. Argument types are classes of arguments based on the entailments in which they participate (see Dowty (1989)). Argument types are basically thematic roles. Argument categories, however, are defined as syntactic classes of arguments that bear only a looser connection to corresponding argument types. For example, in some languages which we will examine, many
18
Introduction
"experiencer" arguments are dative, but many are nominative. If the 0role experiencer is used in linking we get a rule like "Some experiencers are dative" or "Experiencers are dative unless otherwise indicated by exception feature." In the next chapter I will suggest that we instead adopt a syntactic category EXP whose members must be interpreted as experiencers in the semantic sense. The implication is from syntactic experiencerhood to semantic experiencerhood. But the implication is only one way. An argument can be interpreted as an experiencer without belonging to this EXP category. Analogously, in the case of the category auxiliary (AUX), the members of the category AUX must express tense, aspect, or modality, but not all words (or even verbs) that express tense, aspect, or modality belong to this AUX category (cf. must vs. have to - must inverts, but have to does not, even though they both express necessity). If this way around the problem of thematic roles is adopted, we can avoid having to complicate the semantic definition of an argument type just to make the definition cover syntactic facts, like subject selection, binding, etc. Subject selection is another area in which 0-roles have been invoked, and if one is to do without them, a word about subject selection is in order. One of the virtues of the hierarchy in (5) above is that arguments are ordered with much less stipulation than if one simply ordered arguments for each individual verb. The hierarchy embodies a claim that the syntactic "eligibility" for subjecthood (modulo demotion, as in, e.g. passive) is completely predictable on the basis of lexical semantics. This is a strong claim, and in many cases it works. For example, verbs which express the inverse relation of hit, where theme would be subject and agent would be object (a lexicalized version of got hit by) are rare or non-existent. But such predictions are subject to some obvious counterexamples. One such is strike in English as in John strikes me as brilliant, where the theme rather than the experiencer (a subvariety of goal in KLT) is the subject. This is the opposite of what we expect from the hierarchy which has goal higher than theme. I will follow Dowty (1991) in taking generalizations about the semantic basis for subject selection to be defaults, possibly to do with language acquisition - rather than to do with synchronic grammar. That is, a verb with a "theme" subject and "agent" object would be harder to acquire or more costly (on a redundancy rule approach, e.g. Jackendoff (1975)) than verbs the other way around. Thus in the theory to be proposed below, argument structure consists of ordered arguments, but the ordering will be by default -
Theoretical framework
19
or in the worst case, by stipulation, as in standard ordered argument theories like most versions of Categorial Grammar. No thematic role labels are involved. I will also propose that one piece of functional information, obliqueness versus non-obliqueness, be part of a linker's specifications. In Kiparsky (1987) if, say, a dative experiencer, although the logical subject, is not the behavioral subject (i.e. it is an oblique), this is handled by including lexically stipulated demotion on the experiencer 0-role in the verb's lexical entry: (27)
Mir gefallt me(DAT) pleases 'I like the essay.'
der the(NOM)
(28)
( goalA ( theme ( gefallen ))
Aufsatz. essay
The demotion is lexically specified here as it was for certain goals in some of the ditransitives above in (25). There are several disadvantages to this. One is that this makes it very easy to write a grammar in which some dative experiencers are syntactically oblique but some are not. Nonsyntactically oblique (behavioral subject) experiencers are found in Icelandic and some other languages (see the next chapter for references and discussion), but in these languages all dative experiencers behave as subjects, i.e. are not syntactically oblique. Although dative subjects are well-known, it seems that no language has been found with both dative behavioral subjects and behaviorally oblique dative logical subjects. Therefore in the following I will assume that linkers themselves are specified for obliqueness and obliqueness is inherited (across-the-board) by the NPs they link. So in German the experiencer dative is both morphologically and syntactically oblique, whereas in Icelandic the experiencer dative is morphologically oblique but syntactically non-oblique. The definitions in (10) will still work, but the source of (syntactic) obliqueness will be the linkers themselves rather than features stipulated at verbal lexical entries. I will further assume that linkers come in three kinds or types: case, agreement, and word order. But I will not assume that agreement has any special synchronic "subject orientation." Rather it is proposed that orientation towards highest (or lowest) argument will be taken care of by constraints otherwise needed for cases like nominative. Nominative case, and, in English, VP-external position normally link the highest argument, and however this is handled can be extended to agreement.
20
Introduction
Likewise I will not assume a priority of grammatical linking over semantic linking, and it will not even be necessary to assume this particular distinction. Priority of one linker over another will be handled by means of constraints stated in terms of a notion of restrictiveness. The intuitive idea behind restrictiveness is relative information content. Cases (and other devices) of greater information content will have priority. This theory will provide a way of predicting on the basis of the complements that a verb selects what cases, agreement markers, and positions those complements will show, and, from there, of predicting their characteristic grammatical functionhood behavior. To do this, several universal principles will interact with language-specific inventories of morphosyntactic devices to yield the correct syntactic "case" (linker) frames. Neither part of the Priority Clause (15c) will be assumed: any priority of one linker over another or one argument over another should follow from general constraints and minimal assumptions about individual linkers. Since the basic notion behind restrictiveness is intuitively simple and general, many of the proposals made below are compatible with more than one theoretical framework. I have found it quite convenient, though, to couch the main constraints which constitute the theory in a unification-based framework. The basic notion of restrictiveness will rely on the notion of subsumption. If linker A is more specific than linker B in terms of linking features, A will be the more restrictive linker and will have priority over B. The linking features over which specificity will be determined will be features and values which will refer to basic distribution, upon which a theory of syntactic - not morphological - case rests. So for example, assume a language has a special dative case for arguments belonging to the syntactic category EXP (syntactic analogue of experiencer) and a nominative case that in principle marks any argument. When it comes to linking a given EXP argument, the dative will have priority because its environmental specification, "EXP arguments," is more specific than the environmental specification for nominative ("arguments"). This is the basic idea, and the details are a large part of what this book is about. 1.3
Overview
This book is organized as follows. Chapter 2 presents the basics of the theory after examining the phenomenon of case alternations. The focus will be on Icelandic and its Germanic relatives. I will present there the
Overview 21 three main constraints which together constitute the theory of linking. The theory will first be shown to cover the data from the Germanic languages, and in Chapter 3 this theory will be generalized by adding two parameters. The resulting typology of two-linker systems will predict the existence of unexpected language types which do exist. The behavior of superficially quite different case systems will be shown to have a surprising unity, which the theory captures. Chapter 4 will examine the interaction of multiple morphosyntactic processes, such as passive and case marking. The implications of the theory for the interaction of case, position, and obliqueness will be drawn out. Chapter 5 will continue the discussion of case and word-order position with a more detailed analysis of Modern Icelandic. In Chapter 6, it will be shown that, in conjunction with certain assumptions about change, the theory accounts for a wide range of non-parametric changes in linking. Finally, Chapter 7 will provide an account of some new facts about case preservation and passive not accounted for by present theories of case but which follow from a minimal extension of the theory.
2
Argument case and case alternations
In this chapter I introduce the outlines of a theory of case. As a way into this problem and for concreteness I will first examine a problem that highlights the need for a constrained theory of case. This is the problem of case alternations, where two cases alternate with little or no change in meaning. After presenting this problem, I lay out the fundamentals of a theory of linking and some of its most basic consequences. Later I return to the case alternations and show that the theory just developed turns out to handle the alternations with no extra machinery beyond what is motivated for the most basic phenomena. Finally, I summarize the implications of this theory of argument case for the notion of argument structure and the distinction between arguments and adjuncts.
2.1
Case alternations and the problem of case
2.1.1 Basic facts Recent work in syntax has touched upon a case alternation in Icelandic known to traditional Icelandic grammar as Dative Sickness (pdgufallssyki) or Dative Substitution (henceforth DS). At first approximation it can be described as the tendency for accusative subjects to become dative, as with the verb langa 'long' in (1): (1)
a. Mig langar ad me(ACc) longs to 'I long to go.' b. Mer langar ad me(DAT) longs to
fara. go fara. go
The accusative variant (la) is original in Icelandic, the dative (lb) an innovation. Icelandic also shows a further alternation of impersonal (1) with personal constructions like (2):1 22
Case alternations and the problem of case 23 (2)
Eg
langa ad fara. long to go 'I long to go.'
I(NOM)
For parallelism, I will call this second alternation Nominative Sickness or Substitution (NS). Diachronically, there are two tendencies, one from accusative to dative and another from either accusative or dative to nominative. Both "substitutions" have a synchronic aspect as variation and a diachronic aspect as trends. This section will establish that DS and NS have to do with case only, not grammatical function. However, as we will also see, DS and NS differ in two respects: (i) DS but not NS is limited to experiencer NPs and (ii) DS (not NS) is limited to the "replacement" of accusative case. 2.1.2 Case alternations and subjecthood It is necessary first of all to inquire whether the case alternations depend on grammatical functions. That they do not can be easily established by comparing Icelandic and German, two languages with different grammatical subjecthood properties but which share DS and NS. The alternations in (1-2) in Icelandic involve the "thematically most prominent" argument or "logical subject." It is one of the most interesting results of recent work on Icelandic syntax (Andrews (1976), Thrainsson (1979), Andrews (1982), and Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985)) that all of the initial NPs in sentences like (1-2) also behave as subjects grammatically. On a wide variety of tests which distinguish subjects from topicalized NPs, the lexically case-marked NPs pattern with the subjects, e.g. lexically case-marked NPs can be the target of control, like subjects (and unlike topicalized NPs, cf. Andrews (1982: 55)):2 (3)
a. Eg
vonast til ad vanta ekki efni i ritgerdina. hope for to lack not material(NOM) for thesis-the 'I hope not to lack material for the thesis.' b. Barnid vonast til ad batna veikin. child-the(NOM) hopes for to recover-from disease-the(NOM) T h e child hopes to recover from the disease.' I(NOM)
And, like subjects, lexically case-marked NPs undergo Raising: (4)
a. Hana virdist vanta peninga. her(ACc) seems to-lack money(Acc) 'She seems to lack money.'
24
Argument case and case alternations b. Barninu virdist hafa batnad veikin. child-the(DAT) seems to-have recovered-from disease-the(NOM) T h e child seems to have recovered from the disease.'
Note that the lexical case is preserved under Raising, showing that the subjecthood behavior could not be dependent on some kind of case absorption. In Modern Icelandic generally, behavioral subjects are normally nominative, but may be in any of the other cases. Which case is possible depends on the verb and, for some cases, is partially predictable from the verb's meaning. Some verbs take experiencer arguments (i.e. whose referents are entailed to be aware of something and to be sentient beings), which are often dative: (5)
a. Mer kolnar. me(DAT) is-getting-cold 'I am getting cold.' b. Barninu batnadi veikin. child-the(DAT) recovered-from disease-the(NOM) T h e child recovered from the disease.' c. Mer bydur vid setningafraedi. me(DAT) is-nauseated at syntax 'I abhor syntax.'
The variant in (lb) above with the verb langa 'long' also shows a dative experiencer. Another group of experiencer subject verbs take nominative only, a typical example being sjd 'see':
(6)
Eg
se
I(NOM) see
frig. you(Acc)
'I see you.' Note, too, that the NS variant of langa 'long' in (2) likewise shows a nominative experiencer (for those speakers that get (2)). The experiencer subjects of a small class of verbs is accusative. Example (la) with langa 'long' is one, as are the following: (7)
a. Mig kelur. me(ACc) is-freezing 'I am freezing.'
Case alternations and the problem of case 25 b. Mig me(Acc) 'I lack a c. Mig me(Acc) 'I abhor
vantar hnif lacks knife(ACc) knife.' velgir vid setningafraedi. is-nauseated at syntax syntax.'
Andrews (1982: 463) examines this accusative-subject class and concludes that the accusative here is probably idiosyncratic, since there seems to be no semantic criterion that would distinguish these verbs from nominativesubject verbs and dative-subject verbs. Andrews does notice certain tendencies, which also feature prominently in the handbooks. Accusatives tend to appear with physiological states, while the datives appear with psychological states. This and other generalizations are just tendencies, and pairs like (5c) and (7c) seem to be truth-conditionally equivalent. There are also dative and accusative subjects which are not experiencers, making the correlation between experiencerhood and morphological case even less direct.3 German also has lexical cases for experiencer arguments. Unlike in Icelandic, experiencer NPs in German are behavioral obliques, not subjects or objects (Cole et al. (1980), Reis (1982)). Depending on the verb, an experiencer may be nominative (8), dative (9) or accusative (10): (8)
Der Mann sieht den Tisch. the(NOM) man sees the(Acc) table T h e man sees the table.'
(9)
Mir ist iibel. me(DAT) is sick 'I am sick.'
(10)
Mich hungert. me(ACc) hungers 'I am hungry.'
(cf. Icelandic (6))
The latter two classes, dative and accusative experiencers, do not behave as subjects in contrast to their counterparts in Icelandic, e.g. they cannot be the target of control: (11)
*Ich hoffe iibel zu sein. I(NOM)hope-lsg sick to be 'I hope to be sick.'
26 (12)
Argument case and case alternations *Ubel zu sein ist unangenehm. sick to be is unpleasant 'To be sick is unpleasant.'
On the other hand, nominative experiencers do pattern with normal subjects: (13)
Er hofft mich dort zu sehen. he(NOM) hopes me(Acc) there to see 'He hopes to see me there.'
The experiencer subject of sehen 'see' can be controlled, but the experiencers of dative verbs cannot. This situation contrasts with that in Icelandic, where lexically case-marked NPs do behave as subjects. Very interestingly, German has precisely the same types of case alternations as Icelandic, despite the radically different functional status of the NPs in question. German shows alternation of accusative with dative on experiencer NPs, although, as we have seen, these NPs are obliques. Almost all of these verbs can take a dative (and sometimes nominative) as well. The accusative in (14) varies with the dative in (15): (14)
a. Mich ekelt. me(ACc) is-disgusted 'I am disgusted.' b. Mich schaudert vor Baren. me(ACc) shudders at bears 'I shudder at bears.'
(15)
a. Mir me(DAT) b. Mir me(DAT)
ekelt. is-disgusted schaudert vor Baren. shudders at bears
Any condition on DS that the NP involved must be a subject, while true for Icelandic, would not generalize to German DS. For a truly general explanation of the DS phenomenon, we will have to avoid any appeal to the special status of oblique case in Modern Icelandic. Many of the accusative and/or dative experiencer verbs in German can alternatively take nominative, i.e. they can show NS: (16)
Ich
hungere.
I(NOM) am-hungry
'I am hungry.'
Case alternations and the problem of case 27 (17)
Ich
schaudere vor Baren. shudder at bears 'I shudder at bears.'
I(NOM)
The nominative in (16) varies with the accusative in (10), and the nominative in (17) varies with the the accusative in (14b) and the dative in (15b). Therefore, NS is not dependent on DS, since an accusative-taking verb that does not undergo DS for some speakers, e.g. hungern 'hunger,' can undergo NS for those speakers. For many further examples, see Curme (1922: §219) and Dal (1966: §124). 2.1.3 Systematic limitations on the case alternations I now turn to some systematic limits on DS. DS is variously described as a replacement by dative, an analogy based on a default dative, or an analogy based on experiencer dative (Barnes (1986)). I will first show that only this last view is correct, because only those accusative subjects that might be called experiencers can undergo DS. We can first ask whether a non-experiencer argument can take dative by DS. In (18a) the sole NP is accusative. It nonetheless cannot become dative (19) but can become nominative (18b): (18)
a. Kjarkinn courage-the(Acc) T h e courage was b. Kjarkurinn courage-the(NOM)
brast. was-lacking lacking.' brast. was-lacking
(19)
*Krafti brestur. strength(DAT) lacks 'Strength is lacking.'
The accusative in (18a) is best taken as lexical since sole NPs otherwise get nominative, but it cannot show DS, so DS cannot just be the replacement of accusative with dative on subjects. Other non-experiencer subjects likewise do not show DS. Thus the result of replacing the accusative on the subjects in (20) with dative is ill-formed (accusative examples are from Svavarsdottir (1982: 22)): (20)
Bdtinn/*Bdtinum boat-the(Acc)/boat-the(DAT) 'The boat drifted to sea.'
rak til hafs. drifted to sea
28 (21)
Argument case and case alternations Manninn/ *Manninum bar vid baeinn. man-the(ACc)/man-the(DAT) could be seen against house-the 'The man could be seen against the house.'
What is common to these verbs as opposed to the DS verbs is that their subjects are not experiencers, i.e. none of these sentences entails that the individual denoted by the subject NP is aware of anything or sentient. DS is not the tendency for all accusative subjects to become dative but rather the tendency for accusative experiencer subjects to become dative. Several previous explanations (e.g. van Valin (1991)) have relied on analyzing the dative as the default lexical case in Icelandic in order to explain DS. This leads to an expectation that genitive subjects could become dative. This does not happen: (22)
Verkjanna/*Verkjunum gaetir pains-the(GEN)/pains-the(DAT) be-noticeable T h e pains are not noticeable.'
ekki. not
This is all the more surprising given the rarity of genitive subjects. Despite their low numbers and lack of semantic motivation they cannot participate in DS. Note that the genitive subjects are not experiencers either, forming another class of non-experiencers which do not undergo DS. Finally, DS is often closely associated with NS on another argument. For the accusative subject verbs in (1) and (7a) above with only one argument, DS is simply the replacement of the sole accusative by a sole dative. However, for verbs like vanta lack' (7b) with more than one argument, there is another accusative NP which can also alternate, but with the nominative. Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987: 23If.) mention in passing that this NP is treated differently depending on the verb. With verbs of lacking, the second NP becomes nominative except for vanta 'lack' (23c ( = 7b)), where it remains accusative: (23)
a. Mig brestur kjark me(Acc) lacks courage(Acc) 'I lack courage.' b. Mennina Jsrytur mat the-men(Acc) lacks food(ACc) 'The men lack food.'
Case alternations and the problem of case 29 c. Mig vantar hnif me(ACc) lacks knife(ACc) 'I lack a knife.' (24)
a. Mer brestur me(DAT) lacks b. Honum J)raut him(DAT) lacked c. Mer vantar me(DAT) lacks
kjarkur courage(NOM) J)rottur strength(NOM) hnif knife(ACc)
Other case combinations occur for other speakers and so are possible in principle; e.g. the verb bresta 'lack' appears not only in the ACC-ACC frame (23a) and the DAT-NOM frame (24a) but also in the DAT-ACC frame (25) and occasionally in the ACC-NOM frame (Halldorsson (1982: 168)): (25)
Mer brestur kjark me(DAT) lacks courage(ACc) 'I lack courage.'
(26)
l>a brast £>olinmaedin hann sem snoggvast og then lacked patience(NOM) him(ACc) for a moment and hann sagdi he(NOM) said 'Then he ran out of patience for a moment and he said . . . '
Likewise vanta 'lack' is not confined to ACC-ACC and DAT-ACC, since ACCNOM examples occur (Halldorsson (1982: 178)). Previous theoretical discussion of DS has largely ignored the case alternation on the nonexperiencer NP and why it becomes nominative. Note, too, that no dialect seems to allow NS on both arguments: (27)
*k>eir vanta kjarkur. They(NOM) lack courage(NOM) 'They lack courage.'
Thus, with verbs like vanta, accusative, dative, and nominative vary on the first argument (DS, NS), and accusative and nominative (NS) vary on the second argument independently, but when the first argument suffers NS the second argument cannot show nominative. Finally, it is worth pointing out that, unlike DS, NS is extremely common in the world's languages. The Relational Grammar (RG) litera-
30 Argument case and case alternations ture presents examples of languages with what is termed optional inversion. This means that the logical subject (RG initial 1) of psych verbs will have the option of being a final 3 or a final 1. In RG, analyses are generally set up so that final relations map directly onto surface morphology. So final 3 translates into other frameworks as dative and final 1 translates as nominative. The case alternation in optional inversion is between dative and nominative, a type of NS. Examples are Kannada (Sridhar (1976), Dryer (1982)) and Udi (Harris (1984)). That some verbs in Korean alternate between dative and nominative for experiencers is well known, for example with the verb chohta 'to like': (28)
a. na-ege chaek-i chohta. me-(DAT) book-NOM like 'I like the book.' b. ne-ga chaek-i chohta. I-NOM book-NOM like 'I like the book.'
In our terms, Korean shows NS with these verbs. Tentatively speaking, the NS phenomenon is quite common cross-linguistically, in contrast to DS which (so far) seems to be confined to Germanic. The fact that some verbs allow DS but not NS while others allow NS but not DS clearly means that one cannot be the precondition for the other. When considered diachronically, the change of which each alternation is a slice must be able to begin independently. I will take up the diachronic aspect of the two alternations in Chapter 6. In this section it has been shown that, although DS and NS are case alternations, DS is limited to experiencers and to accusative NPs, unlike NS. DS and NS are usually thought of as either replacement rules or variation conditioned only by sociolinguistic factors. The problem with replacement rules is that they are too powerful; they do not come with any limits on what can be replaced with what. And many replacements should be made difficult or impossible to capture, such as the replacement of dative with genitive. On the other hand, it should be emphasized that labelling these alternations "sociolinguistic variation" does not answer the question why DS systematically shows these two restrictions and NS does not. At the very least, it must be acknowledged that the variations are grammatically conditioned. 4 The rest of this chapter will be an attempt to show what those grammatical conditions are.
Case, argument structure, and interpretation 2.2
31
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
This section will briefly develop a theory of morphological and syntactic case, which will be able to solve these problems. The general framework is unification-based, and, although I will not invoke one theoretical framework, these proposals are most compatible with Generalized Phrase Structure Grammar (GPSG) (Gazdar et al. (1985)) and its relatives. I will start from a standard ordered argument theory and present a general way, given a verb and its argument structure, of building up case frames. This theory is based on three main constraints, introduced in §§2.2.1-3. 2.2.1 Linking features One way to separate out the universal aspect of linking is to generate case frames and subject them to universal well-formedness conditions. I will propose three such constraints. Before turning to the constraints, it is essential to assume two notions, subsumption and unification. As mentioned earlier, linkers and the NPs to be linked will be defined as feature structures5 and these will be presented in Attribute-Value Matrix (AVM) notation familiar from LFG. An AVM is a directed acyclic graph, and an important property for us will be that a feature can take either an atomic (e.g. + ) or a structured (e.g. [NUM [SING]]) feature structure as a value. An important instance of this is that, as in LFG (subsequently borrowed in other frameworks), a verb "takes" arguments in the sense that it has a feature whose value is a feature structure made up of the feature structures of its arguments: (29)
CAT [v] CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [EXP [PLACE [1]]]]] SUBCAT
. REAL [
]
CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE [2]]]]] - REAL [
]
This feature structure includes many of the features we will be using. The feature SUBCAT is from GPSG and its descendants and is for subcategorization. LINK is for linking specifications and will take as a value a feature structure indicating the properties relevant for linking which the category in question (usually an NP) has. The feature ARG is
32 Argument case and case alternations for argument, CAT is for argument category, EXP is for experiencer, and DIR is for direct (see the next subsection). The PLACE feature is just a way of indexing arguments to get an ordering of arguments. The logical subject will by definition have [PLACE [1]]. REAL is a feature for realization and takes as values various morphosyntactic categories. I will take linking to be the filling in of values for REAL (SO far unspecified in (29)) on the basis of the value of LINK. In other words we are deriving case frames of verbs from properties like argumenthood and experiencerhood in the NP the verb selects. A path is a sequence of features, and, by way of extension, we can say that a path takes as a value the value that the last feature in the path takes. Thus in (29) the path SUBCAT LINK ARG CAT DIR PLACE has the value [2]. The main constraint below states that the more specific the linker, the higher priority it gets. In the unification-based framework this is handled through subsumption. Feature structure A subsumes feature structure B if B is no more informative than A: (30)
a. A: [ ] b. B: [ARG] c. C:
[ARG [EXP]]
d. D:
[ARG [EXP
[2]]]
A subsumes B which subsumes C which subsumes D. Note too, that A subsumes C and D, B subsumes D and that each feature structure subsumes itself.6 We will say that A properly subsumes B if A subsumes B but B does not subsume A. In this case A is less informative than B. All of the non-reflexive subsumptions in (30) are proper subsumptions. Unification will also be important in what follows. Basically, to take the unification of A and B, pool the information of A and B. If the information is incompatible, unification is undefined and is said to "fail." 7 To take a couple of examples like those we will see later, consider (31). NPs have certain properties like argumenthood, experiencerhood, etc., captured in the LINK value. Linkers have these same properties and a large part of constraining linking will be to "match" the linker to an NP with appropriate properties, REAL is a feature that indicates the morphosyntactic expression that the linker "assigns." It is like the "operation" that - by way of the linker - comes to be associated with a given NP. So for instance, the unification of (31a) and (31b) is (31c):
Case, argument structure, and interpretation (31)
a.
33
[CAT[NP] LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE [2]]]]] .REAL [
b.
]
[ LINK [ARG] REAL [NOM
C.
CAT [ N P ]
I
LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE [2]]]]] REAL [NOM]
J
In other words, an NP is linked by unifying with the linker. Note that if unification fails no linking can occur, as with an experiencer dative and a direct argument : (32)
a.
• CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE [2]]]]] . REAL [
b.
]
LINK [ARG [EXP]] REAL [DAT]
No unification can take place because the dative is specified for experiencers whereas the NP target is a direct argument. The experiencer dative must link experiencer NPs. 2.2.2 How semantic is "semantic" case? If one takes a closer look at this type of case, a problem emerges immediately. Some of these inherent cases seem to be partially predictable from a verb's meaning, while others are not. First, a case can specially mark a particular argument of a particular verb. When this happens, the verb is generally said to assign case idiosyncratically to that argument. One Icelandic verb that assigns dative to its second argument is tyna 'lose' (33), and one that assigns genitive is sakna 'miss' (34): (33)
(34)
Barnid tyndi bokinni. child-the(NOM) lost book-the(DAT) 'The child lost the book.' Eg
sakna J)in. miss you(GEN) 'I miss you.'
I(NOM)
Such idiosyncratic cases are located in the lexical entries of the verbs involved.
34 Argument case and case alternations On the other hand, some lexical cases do seem to have some thematic basis (see, e.g. Zaenen, Maling, and Throinsson (1985)). For example, as we have seen above, it is a loose generalization that experiencers - arguments whose referents are entailed to be sentient and aware of something - take dative in Icelandic and German. But this generalization is only partial. Some experiencers are nominative and a few accusative. Nevertheless, the experiencer dative is fairly robust and productive (see also Chapter 6). At this point, we are faced with at least two choices in handling such partial generalizations. We could list exceptions to the experiencer-dative rule. We already noted that this leads to a very large number of exceptions. This approach faces two further problems, the first being that thematic roles are notoriously difficult to define in the first place, so that an exception-ridden rule referring to them is on very shaky ground. Another difficulty is that if the nominative-experiencer class is an exception to the regular dative pattern, we might expect this class to show marked behavior, including being less frequent. However, evidence for this is lacking. Icelandic and German have quite a number of nominative experiencer verbs as well, and they show no marked behavior. These partial "thematic" statements can, however, be replaced by generalizations about the interpretation of certain NPs. If we ask in what sense a dative experiencer subject is more predictable than a genitive subject, the answer must be not that experiencers are dative (too many exceptions) but rather that dative logical subjects are almost always experiencers. The predictability runs from the syntax (argument structure) to the semantics, not from the semantics to the syntax as usually assumed for "thematic case," and so we might derive an interpretation from the argument structure rather than vice versa. Thematic role theory also assumes that lexical cases "select" for a given thematic role (or piece of a lexical decomposition). However, as we have seen, the generalizations such a move is meant to capture are partial at best, with the predictability of information running rather from the syntax to the semantics. One way to capture this insight is to posit syntactic classifications of arguments such as experiencer or goal, as I will here: (35)
a. Argument categories: DIR, EXP, GOAL b. Default: [CAT [
]] —> [CAT [DIR]]
In this, I am following the strategy for thematic relations proposed in Dowty (1991) of positing just those aspects of thematic roles as necessary
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
35
for a given area. I will take "thematic roles" to be argument types picked out by sets of entailments (Chierchia (1984, 1989), Dowty (1985, 1989), Ladusaw and Dowty (1987)). But I will not assume that these argument types are directly accessible to case marking. For the area of case, arguments are organized into (syntactic) argument categories which are distinct from (semantic) argument types. A syntactic experiencer is necessarily interpreted as a semantic experiencer, i.e. as a being who is aware of something and is sentient. The first argument of langa 'long' will be a syntactic experiencer and so bears Exp(eriencer): (36)
langa ( X|EXP, y VP ) 'long'
But the reverse is not necessarily true: a participant entailed to be aware of something and sentient does not necessarily correspond to a syntactic experiencer: (37)
If an argument belongs to the syntactic category experiencer (X|EXP), then its referent is entailed to be aware of something and be a sentient being, i.e. a semantic experiencer (syntactic experiencer —» semantic experiencer).
There is thus a one-way implication: if an argument is a syntactic experiencer (it bears EXP) it must be a semantic experiencer (the entailment holds). The converse does not hold: it is not the case that every argument corresponding to the subjects of the entailments in (37) bears the value EXP, i.e. it is not the case that all semantic experiencers correspond to syntactic experiencers. The verb sjd 'see' is an example of this: (38)
sja ( x, y ) 'see'
The first argument, although a semantic experiencer, is direct, the default argument category which places no additional constraints on the interpretation of an argument. In the abbreviated forms of lexical entries like (38) I will supress DIR. Similarly, a syntactic goal (GOAL) is necessarily interpreted as an entity to which something moves. As with the EXP category, the converse is not necessarily true: a participant entailed to be an entity to which something moves is not necessarily a syntactic goal. In a fashion parallel to (37) for EXP, the following will constrain the interpretation of syntactic goals:
36 Argument case and case alternations (39)
If an argument of a verb belongs to the syntactic category goal (X|GOAL), then a positive sentence containing that verb entails that something moves to the referent of that argument, i.e. a semantic goal (syntactic goal —> semantic goal).
Once again we have a one-way implication: if an argument is a syntactic goal (it bears GOAL) it must be a semantic goal (the entailment holds). However, not all semantic goals are syntactic goals. The well-known problem of commercial transaction verbs (see, e.g. Jackendoff (1987: 381) and Dowty (1991: 556)) is avoided this way. These verbs are a problem for theories of thematic roles which claim that each of a verb's arguments receives a unique and distinctive thematic role from that verb. Take the following Icelandic sentences: (40)
Jon seldi Olafi bilinn. John(NOM) sold Olaf(DAT) car-the(Acc) 'John sold Olaf the car.'
(41)
Olafur kaupti bilinn fra Olaf(NOM) bought car-the(ACc) from 'Olaf bought the car from John.'
Joni. John(DAT)
Both sentences describe the same situation; they have the same truth conditions. Both human participants are entailed to act agentively. There are two entities which change hands, the car and the means of payment. Further, there are two goals: both verbs entail that something moves to each human participant. The car goes to Olaf, and the money or other means of payment goes to John. However, the participant that is lexicalized as subject in (40) is expressed by a PP in (41). The problem is that both entail that something goes to each of the two human participants. Yet only one of the NPs gets dative. In our terms, although the verb selja 'sell' has two semantic goals, it has only one syntactic goal: (42)
selja ( x, y|GOAL, z ) 'sell'
The fact that the implication is one-way - a syntactic goal must be a semantic goal - but not vice versa is supported by such otherwise problematic examples. One might ask why we do not get a verb with two datives. In other words, why do we not get two syntactic goals? This might be stipulated, as thematic uniqueness usually is. But we will see later that the uniqueness of syntactic argument categories follows from
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
37
the general constraint on linking called the "Linking Dissimilation Constraint." In several important respects, argument category features such as EXP and GOAL are like the feature AUX + (Steele et al. (1981), Gazdar et al. (1985) and references there). They define subcategories of arguments just as AUX + defines a subcategory of verb. And both EXP and AUX + bear the same relation to interpretation, AUX + by definition expresses tense, aspect, and/or modality, but it is not the case that any time one of these notions is expressed, we get auxiliary behavior (e.g. have to in English expresses obligation but is not an auxiliary, i.e. it does not invert or take a bare verb complement). So too each argument category like EXP is constrained to be interpreted in a specific way (e.g. (37), (39)), but it is not the case that every time an argument is interpreted in such a way, we necessarily get the corresponding argument category. In each case the syntax implies an interpretation but not vice versa. Traditional thematic roles, on the other hand, are "bidirectional." We will see that the unidirectional approach is ideal for case marking. The claim is not that syntactic cases like the dative in Icelandic reflect thematic roles but simply that they receive a predictable, redundancy-decreasing interpretation. One immediate advantage of the present approach becomes apparent if we ask what syntactic rules in general can mention. As we have seen, the thematic roles approach requires exception features to allow for exceptions to case-marking rules like dative-to-experiencers. Thus such an approach gives us access to the thematic roles themselves and the thematic roles minus instances with one or more exception features. Now note that an argument category like EXP in Icelandic has the same extension as the conjunction of the thematic role experiencer and the exception feature which allows an argument like the logical subject of sjd 'see' to be nominative. The thematic roles approach allows mention of both the equivalent of our argument categories and the pure thematic relations in addition to all sorts of categories defined by the conjunction of a thematic role and various combinations of exception features. Thus the present approach is just positing exactly what is needed for case marking while avoiding the claim that the entities involved in case marking should be universal and wholly semantically defined. This fits in with the general picture that many generalizations that were thought to make mention of thematic role turn out not to be best stated in terms of thematic roles (Dowty (1991)).8
38 Argument case and case alternations 2.2.3 The range of cases In this section I motivate some basic distributional features for the cases. The discussion proceeds from the most specific to the most general types of case. Later I will make this specific-to-general order more precise, terming it restrictiveness. I will assume that syntactic cases are specified for distribution, and this specification will be captured by means of the value of the feature LINK in the entries of the various cases (and other linkers). First, as we have seen, a case can mark a single argument of a single verb. When this happens, the verb is generally said to assign case to that argument as in (33) and (34) above. Such idiosyncratic cases are located in the lexical entries of the verbs involved. The case assigned will have distributional specifications as follows: (43)
a.
[DAT [LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE
[2]]]]]]] (in lexical entry for
tyna) b.
[GEN [LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE
[2]]]]]]] (in lexical entry for
sakna) The first entry is for the dative with the verb tyna 'lose.' Here the specifications are that the dative is assigned to an NP which is furthermore an argument - modelled by the the feature ARG - which is of category DiR(ect) and is the second argument. For convenience, the LINK values of cases will be abbreviated and placed after a colon as in (44): (44)
a DAT: [ARG|2] (in the lexical entry for tyna 'lose') b. GEN: [ARG 12] (in the lexical entry for sakna 'miss')
The fact that the "dative" argument is the second argument of just this verb is handled by the location of this dative within the lexical entry for the verb tyna. It has scope only over that entry. The genitive with sakna 'miss' works similarly. One of the prime motivations for introducing syntactic argument categories in the last section was in order to formulate so-called thematic cases like the "experiencer" dative in Icelandic. This is the kind of case commonly thought to require mention of thematic relations by syntax. In the present scheme, such cases refer to argument categories, e.g. (syntactic) experiencer dative:
Case, argument structure, and interpretation (45)
39
DAT: [ARG|EXP]
The question is what the range of such argument categories is. Since argument category case is formulated in terms of argument categories, this question reduces to the range of possible argument cases, i.e. what range of predictable interpretations an argument case may have. Most interesting is whether cases need to refer to the most difficult to define thematic roles, agent and theme/patient, or to argument categories correlating with them. I turn now to a way to formulate syntactic case without "agent," "patient" or argument categories loosely correlating with them (so no AGT or PAT). Some cases seem to mark subjects and objects regardless of thematic relations or argument categories. Such cases have traditionally been analyzed as being dependent on grammatical functions. Case rules then take the form of statements such as "Subject gets nominative" or "Highest available grammatical function gets nominative." For the Germanic languages and many others, the two cases which correlate with grammatical functions are nominative and accusative. I will, however, argue that a characterization of these cases in terms of the notion of argument removes the need for functional information other than obliqueness in capturing case marking. The only information needed for the environmental specification of these syntactic cases is whether an NP is an argument or not. In languages like the ones I am considering in this chapter, the nominative marks NPs only if they are arguments and the accusative marks NPs without restriction: 9 (46)
a. b.
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
Ever since Jakobson's (1936) pioneering study of Russian case, nominative has usually been taken to be the lack of case. 10 Since Jakobson, the further assumption has been made that nominative is also the Elsewhere in the domain of NPs that must receive case, but a notable exception is Gaedicke's (1880) analysis of Vedic Sanskrit, in which he argues that there is no core function of the accusative but rather the accusative fulfills whatever functions are not fulfilled by the other cases.11 He thus unifies the long and disparate list of uses of the accusative under a notion of accusative-as-default similar in many respects to the one proposed here. Delbriick (1893: §§70, 176) follows this approach
40
Argument case and case alternations
in his analysis of Indo-European accusatives. Whitney (1892: 286) objects to this view on the grounds that any other case could be formulated as the case that fulfills those functions not fulfilled by any other case. This misses the point, however, spelled out at length by Gaedicke, that the greater difficulty in unifying the more disparate functions of the accusative than in unifying the functions of the other cases is the advantage to having accusative as a default. We gain more by way of economy of rules (or their equivalents) by postulating a default accusative than a default dative, a default nominative, etc. Nevertheless the majority view these days is that nominative is the Elsewhere as assumed in most versions of the Principles and Parameters framework, where NPs that do not receive Case by some other source are forced to move to receive nominative (Chomsky (1981)). However, (46) distinguishes morphological zero or default case from default case for linking.12 I now present some arguments for why accusative in the languages in this chapter should be analyzed as the ultimate Elsewhere for linking. The important difference between nominative and accusative is that accusative can mark non-arguments, NPs that Jakobson, following Peskovsky, termed weakly governed accusatives. These are accusatives that bear a looser relation to the verb, i.e. in our terms, they are not subcategorized for and so are non-arguments. They occur freely, leading to multiple accusatives per clause. Nominative never marks nonarguments. The first class of weakly governed accusatives are the accusatives of path. Both Icelandic and German have this construction, as demonstrated for Icelandic by the following (Zaenen, Maling and Thrainsson (1985)):
(47)
a. Hann keyrdi bilinn fcessa he(NOM) drove car-the(ACc) this(ACc) route(ACc) 'He drove the car this route.' b. Bilinn var keyrdur J>essa leid. car-the(NOM) was driven(NOM.m.sg) this(ACc) route(ACc) 'The car was driven this route.' c. *J)essi leid var keyrd bilinn. this(NOM) route(NOM) was driven car-the(ACc) 'This route was driven the car.'
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
41
The semantic contribution of the accusative of path is like that of an adverbial, not that of an argument. Nor does it normally passivize, leading to the view that it is not an argument.13 Icelandic exhibits other nonargument accusatives, such as the accusative of time (48) and duration (49) adverbials (see also Kress (1982: 224)): (48)
t>ad rigndi vikuna sem leid. It rained week-the(Acc) REL passed 'It rained last week.' (Einarsson (1949: 106))
(49)
Eg
var t>ar tvo daga. was there two(Acc) days(Acc) 'I was there two days.'
I(NOM)
(Einarsson (1949: 106))
German has similar constructions (Dal (1966: §13)). What is predicted by the case specifications in (46) above is that accusative will show Elsewhere behavior. This it does in the languages under consideration. I conclude that the accusative is the ultimate default case in the languages discussed.14 This has the immediate advantage of unifying the treatment of many uses of accusative. Instead of having separate rules for accusative of object, accusative of path, cognate accusative, and adverbial accusatives, accusative is simply the least restrictive case.15 We are now in a position to ask about the syntactic nature of the various cases involved in DS and NS. As we have seen, the dative is for syntactic experiencers and the nominative for arguments. The accusative is used for a much smaller class of experiencer verbs. This is best treated as an idiosyncratic case, because there is no semantic generalization which distinguishes it from the other cases, and the class is very small. I will return to the lexical accusative and alternative ways of analyzing it below.
2.2.4 Three constraints Every NP has to be linked, but this does not tell us what argument any NP will be linked to, nor how the linking will be realized (as a case, a particular configuration, or agreement). These two aspects of linking can be expressed formally using the attribute-value matrix notation introduced above. The problem, then, is to devise a substantive theory of which NP is linked to which argument and how the linking is realized. Three constraints are now offered that together constitute such a theory.
42
Argument case and case alternations
2.2.4.1 Linking and the applicability constraint It will be assumed that case frames are generated freely subject to constraints, which will rule out many frames. I will assume that linkers are like rules in that they apply wherever they can: (50)
Linking Condition: All NPs must be linked, and an NP is not linked unless there is no linker which has not applied but whose application would not violate any other constraint.
The Linking Condition ensures that every NP has a non-null value for 16 REAL, i.e. that it will be linked. So far, any linker can link any NP. But we want to narrow down the class of licit linkings on the basis of the LINK value of the NP, i.e. on the basis of properties such as argumenthood. Three constraints will suffice to narrow the class of case frames to the ones we want by constraining the relationship of an NP's linking properties (LINK) and the linking it actually undergoes (REAL). The first constraint is the Applicability Constraint (AC). This simply says that the specifications of the linker must unify with those of the NP. Otherwise the case would not be applicable. Some NPs are arguments of verbs. This is represented by having that NP contain the specification ARG for LINK, [ LINK [ ARG ]], and, if the argument is direct (the default argument category), it will be [ LINK [ ARG [ CAT [ DIR ]]]]. Cases also will have LINK values to determine their distribution. For example, I have argued that nominative should be a case applicable in principle to any argument and so should have the LINK value [ARG]. SO to an NP direct argument the nominative is applicable, but a case specified [ LINK [ ARG [ CAT [ EXP ]]]], e.g. one of the types of dative in Icelandic, will not unify with that NP, since EXP and DIR will clash. The AC requires the case and the NP it links to have unifiable LINK specifications: (51)
Linking is the unification of an NP and a linker.
A corollary to this is the Applicability Constraint: (52)
Applicability Constraint: An NP and its linker must unify.
I will say that a linker is applicable to an NP if and only if it can unify with the NP. Thus if the linker's LINK value contains some distributional feature incompatible with the LINK value of the NP, then the result of using that linker to link the NP is ill-formed. This is what is meant by LINK'S being distributional information for the linkers. The LINK value in the lexical entry of the linker will, in conjunction with the AC, determine
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
43
its distribution. Take nominative as an example. The NP argument and the nominative linker unify, resulting in an argument that is specified for morphosyntactic category. The verb gefallen 'please' in (53) has an abbreviated entry like (54) and a full entry like (55). Unifying the verb's entry and that of the nominative (56) gives (57): (53)
Mir gefallt der Aufsatz. me(DAT) pleases the(NOM) essay 'I like the essay.'
(54)
gefallen (
(55)
[V]
y ) 'please'
X|EXP
CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [EXP [PLACE [1]]]]] SUBCAT
REAL [
]
CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE [2]]]]] L REAL [
(56)
]
Entry for Nominative LINK [ARG] 1 REAL [NOM] J
(57)
CAT [V] CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [EXP [PLACE [1]]]]] SUBCAT
REAL [
]
CAT [ N P ] LINK [ARG [CAT [DIR [PLACE [2]]]]] REAL [NOM]
Note that the nominative would fail to unify with the first argument of this verb, which will have to be linked by dative. 2.2.4.2 Restrictiveness and the Restrictiveness Constraint So far we have only provided necessary conditions for the appearance of any given case, not sufficient ones. Nominative does not in fact appear on all arguments, nor does accusative appear on all NPs. In this section and the next, I will present two further constraints on case which will make case frames fully predictable.
44
Argument case and case alternations
These two constraints use the independently needed distributional information from the last sections, the necessary conditions on case distribution (the value of the feature LINK). The fact that the remaining constraints converge on the same set of features provides considerable evidence for their identity as a class. In this section, I introduce the most important constraint of the system. Intuitively, it says that a linker that carries information that properly contains the information carried by another linker will have priority in places where they both might apply. This is a more precise version for cases of the specific-blocks-general principle, originally due to Panini, and an extension of the Elsewhere Condition in phonology (Anderson (1969), Kiparsky (1973), Koutsoudas, Sanders, and Noll (1974)). On the present view, there are no case rules and hence no rule ordering for cases. The ordering effect is achieved by means of the notion of restrictiveness: (58)
A linker X is said to be more restrictive than a linker Y if and only if X's LINK value (linking specifications) is properly subsumed by Y's.
Restrictiveness is based on subsumption and the already motivated value of LINK, and transitivity is built in. Looking back at some Icelandic cases discussed so far, the idiosyncratic cases and argument category cases (which both fit the schema [ARG|X], X ^ 0 ) are more restrictive than nominative or accusative, since their linking specifications are properly subsumed by those of the latter two (grammatical) cases. Furthermore, nominative is more restrictive than accusative, since [ARG] is properly subsumed by [ ]. The Restrictiveness Constraint (RC) uses this notion of restrictiveness to derive the priority of cases. In general, more specific cases have priority over more general ones: (59)
Restrictiveness Constraint: If an NP is linked by a linker A, and there is a linker B that is more restrictive than A and violates no other constraint, then linking the NP with A is ill-formed.
This relation replaces any notion of rule ordering. What the Restrictiveness Constraint says is that if any linker applies (and at least one must by the Linking Condition (50)), then that linker will be the most restrictive one available. It is now clear in what sense the non-lexical accusative is the default case. Since the accusative's specifications sub-
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
45
sume those of all the other cases, the accusative must be less restrictive than any other case, hence its default status for linking. The RC does not by itself rule out multiple linking. In most but not all cases, only one linker is used per argument. I will assume for present purposes that case and position are always compatible but that two cases will always be incompatible.17 Case and position are linkers of different types. The RC imposes 'disjunctive ordering' only when the linkers are incompatible, but linkers of different types are in general compatible. One property of Icelandic is that the subject, no matter what its case, must in non-inverted sentences come before the verb. This can be captured in the present system by adding to the inventory of Icelandic linkers a second nominative-like linker: (60)
_V:
[ARG]
The symbol "_V" is for a morphosyntactic feature for preverbal position and will indicate that the preferred position of this NP is before the verb and, in inverted sentences, just after it.18 The identity of its specifications to those of NOM will cause the preverbal configuration and nominative to behave similarly with respect to the RC. The fact that they belong to different morphosyntactic types - one is a case, the other a position will cause them to interact with other linkers differently. An example will illustrate. Take the sentence in (5b), repeated here: (61)
Barninu batnadi veikin. child-the(DAT) recovered-from disease-the(NOM) T h e child recovered from the disease.'
The following may apply to the first argument: (62)
a. DAT: [ARG|EXP]
b. NOM: [ARG] c. _V: [ARG] d. ACC: [ ] By the RC, the dative must apply since it is the most restrictive. Nominative and accusative cannot apply, because they are of the same type as the dative. As we will see next, nominative (62b) is left for the second argument, to which it correctly applies. However, the preverbal positional linker may also apply to the first argument, leading to a dative subject in preverbal position.
46 Argument case and case alternations 2.2.4.3 A dissimilation constraint on linkers The third and last constraint based on LINK values limits the use of all but the default case. For instance, nominative does not mark all arguments, but rather as Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985) note, it marks only the highest available grammatical function. Our last constraint will make this follow. It will be easier to see how this third constraint works if we consider more closely what it is supposed to do. Intuitively, we can think of case marking in a language as working top-down according to the following procedure: (i) Link the highest argument with the linker that passes both the AC and the RC, i.e. the most restrictive case available, (ii) Move down the list to the next argument, (iii) List all the linkers that could apply to the argument, (iv) Delete from the list any linker that could already have been used, i.e. delete a linker (e.g. a case) if it is the most restrictive applicable (AC) linker of that type (e.g. case) to any "earlier" (higher) argument, (v) Use the most restrictive case remaining on the list, (vi) If another argument remains on the argument list, go to (ii); otherwise stop. 19 In other words, for arguments lower on the argument list, avoid the use of linkers that would otherwise be applicable "in principle" to a higher argument. Assuming that linking is "top-down" then this amounts to saying, very roughly, do not use a linker if it could already have been used earlier. So, to take nominative as an example, one could not use it on the second argument in (63) ( = (6)), because it "could" apply (and does) to the higher argument: (63)
Eg
se frig.
I(NOM) see you(Acc)
'I see you.' Rather the second argument gets the remaining applicable case, the accusative, since the nominative has been preempted by the highest argument. As mentioned earlier, I will assume that case frames are freely generated and subjected to constraints, rather than assuming that linking "proceeds" top-down (or bottom-up). Therefore I have formulated the constraint in (64) and its graphical version in (65) to say that no two arguments of the same predicate may get the same case if there is another alternative for the lower one, and similarly for word order and agreement:
Case, argument structure, and interpretation
Al
(64)
Linking Dissimilation Constraint: Given two co-arguments, x and y, x higher than y, if y is linked by a linker B that has the same LINK value as the most restrictive linker of that type applicable by the AC to x, call it A, and there is a less restrictive linker C, applicable by the AC to y, then the linking is ill-formed.
(65)
*verb (... x A: [a]
... y ... ) B: [b] C:[c] where A and B are of the same type, a = b, and C is applicable by the AC to y (c unifies with y's LINK value)
In (65) and henceforth, applying cases are noted in italics. Note that this constraint is asymmetric in that it "questions" the linking of the lower argument y but not the higher argument x. It is this asymmetry that gives the system its "directional" procedural interpretation, which will become clear with the next example. As noted before, an alternative to (64-65) would be to have linking proceed top-down. The higher arguments would then correctly have priority over the lower ones. This means that on the present approach the nominative is correctly predicted to be used only once in languages like Icelandic and German, on the assumption that nominative is not also a lexical case. A "second" use of the nominative would violate the LDC. This is borne out: in Icelandic, a sentence like (63) above or (66) is well-formed only with the accusative on the second argument, not with the nominative:20 (66)
Hann lamdi mig/*eg. he(NOM) hit me(ACc)/me(NOM) 'He hit me.'
First, the verb lemja 'hit' has the following argument structure: (67)
lemja ( x y ) 'hit'
Then let all the cases and other linkers apply that can: (68)
lemja ( x
y
NOM
V ACC
) 'hit'
*NOM
*_V ACC
Use of either of the two linkers with an asterisk would lead to a violation of the LDC, and here and in the future I will indicate with an asterisk
48
Argument case and case alternations
linkers whose use at an argument would violate the LDC. I list the cases in the order that restrictiveness supplies, an order that is, of course, not stipulated. The case that actually applies, indicated by italics, is the most restrictive one. Note the order in which the constraints apply. The AC is an absolute constraint, and one can tell if a structure violates it without reference to any other constraint. The LDC depends on the AC, since it asks if there is a less restrictive alternative under the AC for the lower argument. In other words, it does not rule out a structure unless there is another linker that passes the AC on the lower argument. The RC depends on both the other constraints. It says that of all the applicable linkers the most restrictive must apply. Applicability here depends on both the AC and the LDC. Linkers that do not pass the AC for an argument are not favored by the RC whether they are more restrictive than the applicable linkers or not. And a less restrictive linker can be used on lower arguments if the more restrictive linker(s) would violate the LDC. The last example illustrates this nicely: the RC does not force the LDC-violating nominative on the lower argument in (66), despite the fact that it is more restrictive than the accusative.
2.3
Basic clause structure
In the last section, I illustrated how the three constraints narrow in on the case frame for a basic transitive. This section will demonstrate that these constraints handle basic clause structure generally. Turning first to the passive of a simple transitive like that from the last section, we find that things work similarly. The passive counterpart of (66) is (69): (69)
Eg
var
I(NOM) was
laminn (afhonum). hit
by him(DAT)
'I was hit (by him).' As mentioned in the previous chapter, I adopt a suppression view of the passive (Kiparsky (1987), Bresnan and Kanerva (1989), cf. Chomsky (1981) and see Chapter 4). The top argument in the lexical entry in (67) is suppressed, i.e. it is no longer treated as being on the argument list:21 (70)
lemja-PASS ( xA y ) 'hit'
Basic clause structure
49
Now let all the linkers apply to this derived structure: (71)
lemja-PASS ( xA
y
) 'hit'
NOM
ACC
Since in the passive the top argument is suppressed, neither the nominative nor the accusative may apply to it, leaving the two syntactic cases to compete for the only remaining argument. The nominative, as the more restrictive, wins. The account of the passive also relies on the nominative's being more restrictive than the accusative. Since the analysis of the passive relies on the different status of the nominative and the accusative, it is another confirming instance for the analysis of Icelandic nominative as the argument case and the accusative as the default. The priority of lexical case follows directly from the RC. Consider again the verb tyna 'lose' and its passive: (72)
a. Barnid tyndi bokinni. child-the(NOM) lost book-the(DAT) 'The child lost the book.' b. Bokinni var tynt (af barninu). book-the(DAT) was lost by child-the(DAT) 'The book was lost (by the child).'
In these two sentences, the following linkers are applicable: (73)
a DAT: [ARG|2] b. NOM: [ARG] c. _VP: [ARG] d. ACC: [ ]
(part of the lexical entry for tyna 'lose')
Taking the active in (72a) first, we get the linking in (74): (74)
tyna ( x
y)
'lose'
NOM
DAT
_ VP
*NOM
ACC
*_
VP
ACC
The only difference from the active clause previously considered is the applicability of the dative case in (73a) for the second argument. Here the dative blocks the accusative, since the environment in (73a) properly
50 Argument case and case alternations includes the environment in (73d). Restrictiveness automatically captures the priority of lexical case. In the passive in (72b), the dative likewise blocks the nominative as well as the accusative: (75)
tyna-PASS ( xA
y)
lose'
DAT NOM
_VP ACC
The dative in (73a) is more restrictive than the nominative in (73b) (and the accusative in (73d)) and so wins. The theory correctly predicts a sentence containing only a dative. Thus the effects of all types of rule ordering including the prevalent "pre-linking" of lexical case (Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987)) come without any stipulations beyond those independently necessary to capture the distribution of cases in the first place. The essential feature of this account is that it takes the values which comprise the value of LINK and which are necessary to get cases to be applicable in the right places and uses them to derive their "order" of priority. As there is no a priori reason why the distributional features of a linker should define linker priority, the result is all the more unexpected. In this section and in many examples to follow, it is clear that one special type of priority, "case preservation," follows directly from the restrictiveness-based theory. The priority of idiosyncratic case depends on the relation of the idiosyncratic case to the syntactic cases. All idiosyncratic cases are more restrictive than the syntactic cases and so have priority. This of course generalizes to the other type of lexical case, argument category case. An argument category case like the dative of goal is more restrictive than both the nominative and the accusative and so will be preserved in Icelandic, a fact that I will discuss in Chapter 5. Finally, the LDC also provides for so-called "nominative objects."22 To illustrate, we now provide the full derivation for the nominative object example from the last section: (76)
batna
(X|EXP
y
DAT: [ARG/EXP]
NOM: [ARG]
NOM: [ARG]
*_V:
_ V: ACC:
[
[ARG]
]
) 'recover-from'
ACC:
[ARG]
[
]
Case alternations and restrictiveness
51
Here nominative is fine on the lower argument, because nominative is not the most restrictive case applicable to any higher argument. Dative, not nominative, is the most restrictive case applicable to the first argument. Nominative objects are correctly allowed just when there is some more restrictive case for the higher argument.
2.4
Case alternations and restrictiveness
It turns out that this restrictiveness-based theory of case handles the problems of DS and NS from §2.1 automatically. Both alternations will follow from the optionality of the original case. When that case (accusative in DS, accusative and/or dative in NS) cannot apply, the next most restrictive case is predicted to apply. In DS, the next most restrictive case is the experiencer dative, and in NS the next most restrictive case is the argument nominative. The failure of the original case to apply forces the replacement case to apply. This is accomplished without any actual replacement. The mechanism inherent in the restrictivenessbased theory provides exactly what is needed to capture the alternations. The limitations on DS follow automatically from how the theory is set up.
2.4.1 Non-substitutions DS involves the lexical accusative and the lexical dative. Experiencers of some verbs get accusative, and experiencers generally get dative. In the present theory, these two cases are as follows: (77)
ACC: [ARG|EXP|1]
(part of lexical entry of langa 'long,' of bresta
'lack,' etc.) (78)
DAT: [ARG|EXP]
The accusative applies to the experiencer logical subjects of various verbs. It is an idiosyncratic case analogous to the dative with tyna 'lose' and the genitive with sakna 'miss' of §2.1.2. The method chosen to represent this is not as important as the fact that this accusative mentions something more specific than the dative. Any other way of representing the information that reflects this fact would work just as well.23 It is clear that anything to which accusative in (77) can apply is something to which the dative (78) could apply but not vice versa. By the RC, the accusative must
52 Argument case and case alternations apply, and, since both cases may not apply, the dative (along with other less restrictive cases such as nominative) is blocked. This correctly describes the state of affairs with most verbs in earliest Old English and Old Icelandic (see Chapter 6) and non-DS accusative psych verbs in German and Icelandic. It equally follows from the RC that, if the accusative is unavailable for any reason, the dative will apply (and block the rest of the cases). Therefore DS can be completely captured as the optionality of the lexical accusative. DS results from a quadruple case competition for the first argument of the verbs in §2.1, combined with the optionality of the most restrictive case. When the most restrictive case, the lexical accusative, becomes optional, then the next most restrictive case, the dative, should be able to apply: (79)
a.
ACC: [ARG|EXP|1]
(part of lexical entry of langa 'long,' bresta
'lack,' etc.) b. DAT: [ARG|EXP]
c. NOM: [ARG] d. _V: [ARG] e. ACC: [ ] The simplest situation is DS with one-NP verbs like langa 'long' for speakers who do not accept NS with this verb (i.e. find (2) above ungrammatical). Such speakers get both (la) and its DS variant (lb), repeated here: (80)
Mig/Mer langar ad fara. me(Acc)/me(DAT) longs to go 'I long to go.'
The lexical entry for such speakers is as follows: (81)
langa
(X|EXP (ACC: [ARG|EXP|1])
y V p) 'long'
The lexical accusative in (81) is optional, as indicated by the parentheses. As usual, this device for capturing optionality means that what is contained in the parentheses is an optional part of the entry. It is an abbreviatory convention for collapsing what amount to two lexical entries, one with the accusative, one without. It is important, however, that we not be able to collapse any two possible entries in this way. In fact, entries of the type (81) can relate
Case alternations and restrictiveness 53 only the disjunction of something and its absence, not something and something else, as would be possible if we used full-fledged disjunction (curly brackets). Thus, DS on this account only involves the power to relate accusative to its absence. It does not allow us to relate accusative directly to dative which would carry with it the undesirable power to relate accusative to anything else, e.g. genitive. The linking for langa 'long' on the non-NS dialect is straightforward. The lexical entry can be written with or without the accusative, leading to two linkings. First, if the accusative option is taken, we get the following: (82)
langa ( X|EXP
yVp
ACC:
) iong'
[ARG/EXP/1]
DAT: [ARG|EXP] NOM: [ARG]
_ V:
[ARG]
ACC:
[ ]
This is the linking for the accusative variant. By the RC, the accusative must apply. No other case can be compatible, but the position is compatible, so it also applies. This argument is the highest non-obliquely linked argument and so is the subject. The non-accusative option is as follows: (83)
langa ( X|EXP
y V p) 'long'
DAT: [ARG/EXP] NOM: [ARG]
_ V:
[ARG]
ACC:
[ ]
The RC mandates that the most restrictive case must apply, which here is dative. So the dative is the case that applies. This yields the DS variant. NS follows in a similar fashion. Recall that many semantic experiencers get nominative. This followed from their NPs' not bearing the syntactic value EXP. Thus one view of NS is as the variation of a verb between the one class and the other, i.e. variation between the presence and absence of EXP. For speakers who accept (2) (i.e. have NS with langa 'long'), the first argument is optionally a syntactic experiencer. Generally, for any verb, if EXP is optional the NS effects follow. So, to the lexical entry in (81) above, we add the optionality of EXP: (84)
langa (
X|EXP)
y V p) 'long'
(ACC: [ARG I EXP 11])
54 Argument case and case alternations This does not necessarily mean any semantic difference, since, even if the argument is not constrained to be interpreted as an experiencer by the feature, it may nonetheless be interpreted this way on account of the verb's meaning. Note that, if the EXP option is not taken, neither accusative nor dative can apply, leaving nominative as the next most restrictive case. By the RC, nominative must apply, yielding NS. Note again that optionality allows us to relate an entry with EXP and one without. It does not allow one to relate EXP to anything else but its absence. The NS verbs merely vary between two independently existing classes, the EXP class and the direct, nominative class, e.g. sjd 'see.' To demonstrate concretely how this works, consider both options. The option with EXP will, of course, be the same as the last two examples. What is new for this dialect is the option without: (85)
langa ( x
y V P ) long'
NOM: [ARG]
_V:
[ARG]
ACC:
[ ]
The most restrictive applicable linkers are nominative and preverbal position, and they are both compatible, so by the RC they apply. Note that this variant of langa 'long' is just like sjd 'see.' The non-EXP option puts the verb in the nominative experiencer class. It was noted in §2.1 above that for accusative verbs DS is not a necessary condition for NS. A verb can fail to show DS but still show NS, as is true of German hungern 'hunger' which takes accusative or nominative but not dative (for some speakers): (86)
(87)
Mich hungert. me(ACc) hungers 'I am hungry.' Ich
hungere.
I(NOM) am-hungry
The present system is equipped to handle this, because the two uses of optionality in lexical entries are independent. One can construct a lexical entry where the accusative is not optional, but the EXP classification is: (88)
hungern ( X|EXP ACC:
) 'hunger' [ ARG EXP 1 [OBL
Case alternations and restrictiveness
55
If the non-EXP option is taken, neither the accusative nor the dative can apply, since they are both specified for EXP. The nominative is the most restrictive remaining case. This example is also interesting because it shows how we can capture the independence of DS and NS from the oblique subject phenomenon of Icelandic. Take German ekeln 'be disgusted,' which varies between accusative, dative, and nominative: (89)
ekeln (
) 'be disgusted'
X|(EXP) [OBL
The three linkings are as follows: (90)
ekeln ( X|EXP
) 'be disgusted' /
ACC:
ARG/EXP/1
I OBL
/
J
|~ARG|EXP]
DAT:
[OBL
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
(91)
[ ] 'be disgusted'
ekeln ( X|EXP DAT:
ARG/EXP
OBL NOM: [ARG] ACC:
(92)
[ ]
ekeln ( x
) 'be disgusted'
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
Note that, if the accusative or dative applies, the first argument will be oblique, since the German lexical cases are oblique. If neither of these cases apply, leaving the nominative to apply, then (and only then) will the first argument be the highest non-obliquely linking argument and so be the subject. In German, both DS and NS are compatible with oblique lexical case. In Icelandic, which also shows DS and NS, the lexical cases are not oblique. The present theory, by making obliqueness dependent on the cases, captures the independence of the oblique or non-oblique status of lexically case-marked NPs on the one hand and the case alternations on the other.
56 Argument case and case alternations 2.4.2 Further predictions It was noted in §1 that transitive DS verbs show an interesting interaction of DS and NS. On any explanation of DS and NS it should follow that the second argument can show NS but not if the first argument does. The present approach to DS and NS extends naturally to the transitive verbs. The only additional factor is the second argument and its accusative: (93)
ACC: [ARG|2]
(part of lexical entry of bresta 'lack,' etc.)
An accusative specified as in (93) is present in the lexical entry of each of the ACC-ACC verbs. As with the first accusative, this second accusative is optional, as illustrated for bresta 'lack': (94)
bresta ( X|EXP (ACC)
y
) 'lack'
(ACC)
The optionality of this second accusative in conjunction with the theory of case above gives all the correct frames for the most liberal speakers. In the following, for each demonstrated linking the corresponding example is given on the right, as well as the case frame it produces. First, the ACC-ACC version is given in (95), where both accusative options are taken: (95)
bresta bresta (( X|EXP
y
ACC
ACC
DAT
NOM
NOM
_v
) 'lack'
ACC-ACC
(23a)
*_v ACC
ACC
If neither accusative option is taken, we get the (96)
bresta ( X|EXP
y
DAT
NOM
NOM
*_y
_V
ACC
) 'lack'
DAT-NOM
variant:
DAT-NOM
(24a)
ACC
As before with langa 'long,' the next most restrictive case for the first argument is dative, since it qualifies as a syntactic experiencer. The second argument does not, and so the next most restrictive case for the second argument is nominative, not dative. This accounts for the ungrammaticality of DS with this argument (see (19) above). It is also clear why DS should be equally ungrammatical even when this argument
Case alternations and restrictiveness 57 is the only overtly expressed one (and so subject). Either way, it does not qualify for dative and so cannot show DS. Nothing in the present theory makes the choice of the two accusatives dependent on each other. Rather they are logically independent. If the no-Ace option is taken on the first argument, but the ACC option is taken on the second one, then we get the DAT-ACC frame: (97)
bresta ( X|EXP DAT
NOM
y
) lack'
DAT-ACC
(25)
ACC
NOM
y
*_v
ACC
ACC
Contrariwise, taking the ACC option on the first argument and the no-Acc option on the second gives the ACC-NOM frame: (98)
bresta ( x EXP ACC DAT NOM
y
'lack'
ACC-NOM
(26)
NOM
*_v
ACC
_v ACC
However, the one frame that is not allowed is NOM-NOM, since it would violate the RC (and even if the logical subject were not EXP, such a frame would be ruled out by the LDC under the assumption that NOM is not a lexical case), and indeed such a frame leads to unacceptability (27). Quite generally, the simple optionality of the lexical case automatically leads to the application of the correct case. Most interestingly, the application of DS or NS and their interaction follow automatically as consequences of the optionality of the accusatives. What the accusative alternates with need not be specified but follows from general principles and the otherwise motivated grammar of Icelandic. Further, the transitive verbs can show NS for some speakers. A small number of Svavarsdottir's (1982: 3Iff.) informants gave nominative for the experiencers of some normally accusative and dative verbs on her questionnaire. Likewise, two out of the seventeen participants in Andrews' (1990: 204) survey found (99b) fine, and seven more found it marginal (unsurprisingly, all seventeen found (99a) grammatical):
58 Argument case and case alternations (99)
a. Stulkuna vantar efni girl-the(ACc) lacks material(NOM/Acc) 'The girl lacks material for the paper.' b. Stulkan vantar efni girl-the(NOM) lacks material(NOM/ACc)
i ritgerdina in paper-the(Acc) i ritgerdina. in paper-the(ACc)
The neuter noun efni 'material' is ambiguous between nominative, accusative, and dative, but in (99b) it is likely to be accusative (double nominative never occurs in languages like Icelandic - see Chapter 3 for the other type - and unambiguous dative is not possible here). The accusative on the second argument in (99b) is ambiguous between a lexical accusative and a syntactic accusative. I tentatively assume for vanta 'lack' that the second argument's accusative is lexical, because its accusative seems not to be optional for most speakers (see (24) above), but of course this may not be true of Andrews' two speakers: (100)
vanta ( xX
yy
) 'lack'
NOM
ACC
_v
*NOM
ACC
NOM-ACC
(99b)
*_v ACC
Verbs of this class show clear instances in the intransitive use (cf. (18)) of what on most theories must be lexical accusative, and, on the present proposal, the normal ACC-ACC and the DAT-ACC uses must involve a lexical accusative for the logical object. Thus the simplest assumption is that this accusative is lexical here, but the other assumption would lead to no further problems. Note, finally, that this theory is equipped to capture the full range of speaker variation as to which subset of the case frames above are acceptable. Less liberal dialects just have optionality in fewer places. Furthermore, this can vary from verb to verb. So, for example, Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987: 23If.) report that vanta 'lack' usually can show DS on the first argument but not NS on the second. A lexical entry for vanta may be set up with only the first accusative optional for such speakers: (101)
vanta (
X|(EXP)
y
(ACC)
ACC
) 'lack'
Case alternations and restrictiveness
59
This entry will lead to frames with accusative only for the second argument, whether or not it is the only overtly expressed argument. Once again, this follows from the cases and the RC. Being non-optional, the accusative will always compete for the second argument. As the most restrictive competing case, it will always block the others. Other variations by speaker and lexical item can be handled in a similar way. This account also correctly predicts when DS is not an option. Some verbs take a non-experiencer accusative on their subject. One such verb was reka 'drift' (20). This verb can have accusative or nominative but not dative: (102)
Batinn/Baturinn/*Batinum rak til hafs boat-the(Acc)/boat-the(NOM)/boat-the(DAT) drifted to sea 'The boat drifted to sea.'
The lexical entry for this verb includes an idiosyncratic accusative: (103)
reka ( x
y ) 'drift'
(ACC: [ARG|1])
When the accusative option is taken, that case is the most restrictive and will apply. When the accusative option is not taken, the nominative applies as the next most restrictive applicable case. Since reka 'drift' has no syntactic (or semantic) experiencer, the dative is out. The impossibility of DS and possibility of NS with non-experiencers both follow. The present approach makes the solution to DS and NS an automatic consequence of the optionality of some element. Because everything follows from simple optionality, the descriptive and explanatory problems are both addressed. First, as for the descriptive problem, it was emphasized that DS shows many restrictions that NS does not. These were the restrictions to accusatives and to experiencers. These limitations on DS follow from the subsumption relation of the lexical accusative of the DS verbs and the dative of the argument category experiencer: accusative mentions everything dative does (argumenthood, experiencerhood) and some verbspecific information besides, making the lexical accusative more restrictive than the experiencer dative. For there to be alternation with an experiencer dative, the other case must be more restrictive, which means in turn that it must be an idiosyncratic case for experiencers. The only case like this in the languages in question is accusative. The fact that DS arguments must "become" dative follows from the fact that it is the dative
60
Argument case and case alternations
that picks up that argument when its idiosyncratic case option is not taken. This dative is for experiencers, and so the experiencer limitation on DS is built into the dative, where it is needed for independent reasons. As for NS, the fundamental similarity of this alternation with the other one is captured by their both involving optionality. In both alternations, the zero option leads to the application of a less restrictive case. In NS, the take-over by the nominative is also automatic. But since nominative is not limited to any particular argument category, so too NS is automatically not limited, which is empirically correct. The fact that NS is not limited to affecting accusatives follows from the fact that the specification of nominative subsumes the specifications of all the lexical cases.24 Thus, any optional, more restrictive case will automatically show NS when nominative is available. Furthermore, the present approach addresses the explanatory problem of the case alternations. The excessive power to relate any two cases is not inherent in this system. Rather, the AC, RC, and the LDC place strong limits on case frames and case alternations while correctly characterizing the actual alternation types.
2.5
Why argument structure?
The theory of case proposed above and developed in the following chapters is equipped to handle a wide variety of facts in a constrained way. From the argument structure of any verb, the notion of obliqueness as a property of cases, and the three constraints (the AC, the RC, and the LDC), it is possible to derive the functional structure of clauses. Before concluding this chapter, it is natural to ask why argument structure has been chosen for such a fundamental role in the theory. In this section I look at this question from three angles. First, the argument categories proposed above are not only useful in capturing facts like the case alternations, as we have seen, but they also may explain why DS and NS are both very common in Germanic, and NS is common cross-linguistically, but DS is rare to non-existent outside of Germanic. The argument categories depend on a central role for argument structure. Second, the constraints proposed here, especially the RC, would not work if formulated at a level other than argument structure. In particular, an RC defined on some level of thematic or semantic structure will not cover as much ground as the RC in the present theory. Finally, by having the theory
Why argument structure? 61 operate on argument structure, the operation of the three constraints can be used as a diagnostic for arguments and adjuncts.
2.5.1 Argument categories and case alternations By basing the theory of linking on argument structure, and argument categories in particular, it is possible to explain one of the most intriguing differences between the two case alternations addressed in the last sections. One of their most striking similarities is that they are both common in Germanic, and one of their most striking differences is that only NS is common outside of Germanic. The present theory generates a proposal that the cross-linguistic rarity of DS can be derived from the limited access of cases to "thematic" information. In fact, I know of no other example cross-linguistically of what I will call Generalized DS. This would be the alternation of two cases which are both more restrictive than the nominative, i.e. variation between (104a,b): (104)
a. [ARG|X|Y] b. [ARG|X]
c. [ARG] d. [ ]
(NOM in Icelandic-type languages) (NOM in "type 2" languages - see Chapter 3)
One answer to this problem may come from what can substitute for X and Y in (104a,b). If the features that may substitute for X and Y in (104) are few, we predict that the Generalized DS configuration is unlikely to arise. The DS phenomenon can be regarded as providing evidence for the syntactic argument category of experiencer. Without EXP in the context of the restrictiveness-based theory of case, we would lose our explanation of DS. The success of the explanation lends further support to the assumption it rests on, the positing of EXP. The assumption, more generally, is that EXP and ARG, etc. (parts of the value of LINK) form a class of features in the classical sense. Their identity as class is supported by the fact that various independent criteria select these features. The three constraints, AC, RC, and LDC, are three such criteria. However, it is not so clear what the exact boundaries of this class are. How many argument categories should we admit? For example, do we need argument categories like "lacker" which would be interpreted as the experiencer participant of the lacking relation? One might think so, since all the verbs of lacking in Icelandic take an accusative subject:
62 Argument case and case alternations (105)
Case:
[ARG|EXP|LACKER]
Another way to frame this issue is to ask how much of the semantics has been grammaticalized. The RC and the LDC would work with cases like (105), but they are not necessary to get blocking. If each verb of lacking has its own idiosyncratic case, it will also stand in the correct relation to the experiencer dative. One piece of evidence that verbs of lacking do not have a more general (less restrictive case) like (105) is that the verbs of lacking do not lose the accusative less quickly than other accusative subject psych verbs, as might be expected if one hypothesizes that less restrictive cases are more stable. Another source of evidence that there is no "lacker accusative" would be its lack of productivity: if new verbs of lacking do not take accusative but rather dative or nominative this would be evidence that speakers have not acquired a rule like (105). This would be difficult but not impossible to find out. Generally speaking, the accusative for the various experiencer arguments seems not to be productive (see Chapter 6). The importance of DS lies partly in the evidence it provides that the class of linking features should be as small as possible. If DS rests on the assumption of the category based on EXP, the further assumption that such features are not to be posited unless necessary can explain the actual rarity of DS. If argument categories are rare, then the generalized DS configuration in (104) is rare. NS, on the other hand, does not depend on there being two lexical cases in a subsumption relationship. All that is required is one lexical case on the one hand and an any-argument case (instantiated as nominative in Icelandic) or some other less restrictive syntactic case (see the next chapter) on the other. The any-argument linker is a feature of many if not most languages, so the conditions for NS are not as hard to fulfill. NS, then, is correctly predicted to be crosslinguistically common. The evidence that the rarity of DS provides for a maximally small set of linking features fits in well with the present approach. An important aspect of the restrictiveness-based theory of case is that the more problematic thematic roles agent and patient/theme do not need to be reconstructed here in order to handle grammatical case. The grammatical cases can be defined in terms of the notion argument, the order of arguments and their linking, and three constraints. Functional information can in turn be predicted from this information. As for the argument categories needed, I have focused partiularly on experiencer in DS. I have not
Why argument structure? 63 proved that it is exactly this category that is needed. The X in (104a,b) could be indirect object, the notion 3 in RG, generalized "goal" (which would require definition). Experiencer (EXP) is the smallest category consistent with the facts, and it works. The question of the exact characterization of the set of argument categories must remain open, but the present approach reduces the reliance on thematic role-like entities and makes more modest semantic claims, along the lines of AUX.
2.5.2 The semantic selection alternative All three constraints, the AC, the LDC, and the RC, work well if one assumes the vocabulary of argument structure: [ARG], argument categories, and individual arguments. If we now accept that the constraints express desirable generalizations, the question is how essential argument structure is to these constraints. I would like briefly to consider an alternative. Consider the RC. I have defined the RC on syntactic argument structure which is the input to translation in the standard way. There is no "level" of semantic structure. But there is a common view about case that it selects for Lexical Conceptual Structure (LCS) or some other "lexical semantic structure" (for example, Grimshaw (1990), Jackendoff (1990)). On this view, the RC would be a sort of semantic blocking principle. Cases that select for more of the "semantic structure" would block cases that select for less. So the dative of goal might select the TO function in LCS, where TO is a function from individuals to paths with that individual as an endpoint (Jackendoff (1987, 1990)): (106)
DAT: TO
If this view were correct, then we might try to do without the argument categories at argument structure and just have the Restrictiveness Constraint mandate the use of the case that selects for the most of this semantic structure. This is fine as far as "semantic" case versus "grammatical" case is concerned. The dative'might select the path function TO in LCS whereas nominative and accusative did not. The problem with this semantic selection view is that it can handle neither the least nor the most restrictive linkers. I have argued that, for languages like Icelandic and German, nominative is more restrictive than the accusative, and I will extend this view of syntactic case in the next chapter. But it is not clear that the nominative or the accusative selects
64 Argument case and case alternations for LCS or, if they do, that nominative selects for more than the accusative in Icelandic and German. Of course, LCS may be enriched to reflect information we need for nominative and accusative assignment, but only, it seems, in ways which cause LCS to lose its explanatory potential. For example, Jackendoff (1990: 252ff., 1993: 294) proposes annotations at Lexical Conceptual Structure that indicate which positions in the LCS correspond to arguments in the syntax (versus ones which correspond to adjuncts or no NP at all). Jackendoff takes the entry for "enter" as typical: (107)
/enter/ V [Event GO ([xhing
] A', bath TO ([ P i a c e IN ([xhing
] )])])]
Here, types of positions in such LCS are supposed to define certain theta roles. For example, since "Theme' is shorthand for 'first argument of GO, BE, SAY, or ORIENT'" (Jackendoff (1993: 290)), the argument that satisfies the lefthand open position in the entry is a theme. But the annotations, the subscripts "simply stipulate by means of an A that this constituent must be syntactically realized; (A) stipulates optional syntactic realization" (Jackendoff (1993: 294)). In other words, syntactic information realization as an argument in the syntax - is being explicitly stipulated at LCS. This being so, LCS is not a "semantic" level (whatever that would be), and explanations of argument linking involving LCS cannot be guaranteed to be anything other than syntactic. Surface expression plays a crucial role in determining what the LCS is. But if syntax plays a crucial role in determining LCS, then a theory of LCS is not a purely semantic theory nor one that explains or derives argumenthood. 25 Nominative could be formulated to be applicable to annotated positions. However, once this move is made, the claim that cases "select" LCS becomes meaningless, since the syntactic information we need for case marking is simply being imported into LCS for no other reason except to capture syntactic facts (e.g. subject selection and the argument adjunct distinction). More generally, the adoption of annotations at LCS which are motivated for purely syntactic reasons should call into question how "semantic" LCS actually is. Neither LCS, thematic roles, nor "semantic" explanations for syntactic phenomena in general can claim much significance or superiority over purely syntactic approaches when the "semantic" model is (covertly) syntacticially motivated.
Why argument structure? 65 At the other end of the range of cases, idiosyncratic case is also a problem for the semantic selection view. Two synonymous verbs can take different cases on their logical objects. Say that one of them takes an idiosyncratic dative and the other has normal grammatical case (accusative in the active). Now the dative cannot "select" for any part of the LCS of that verb that is not present in the LCS of the nonidiosyncratic case synonym.26 Thus to maintain that the idiosyncratic case selects for LCS, we would have to make any synonym not assigning idiosyncratic case an exception to the idiosyncratic case. On the other hand, if idiosyncratic case does not select for LCS, then it cannot be brought under the alternative Restrictiveness Constraint which on the LCS-based view refers to amount of LCS selection. So idiosyncratic cases would either have to have exceptions to their exceptional status, or they would fail to be part of the same case system as the other cases. In general, argument structure provides both the right primitives and the right place to carry out the kind of linking envisioned here. 2.5.3 Arguments and adjuncts One consequence of this theory is that it leads to a more precise characterization of argument and adjunct. The theory being developed here is mainly a theory of argument case. The specific-over-general principle has found many applications. Something like this specific-over-general principle seems to be at work in various aspects of grammar and general extra-grammatical behavior. The Elsewhere Condition is most famous in phonology (S. Anderson (1969), Kiparsky (1973), Koutsoudas, Sanders, and Noll (1974)) and more recently in morphology (e.g. S. Anderson (1986) and references there). The Elsewhere Condition is sometimes regarded as a special instance of a more general semantic blocking principle, which disallows paraphrases of lexical items, so that, for instance, the day after today is ungrammatical or at least strange compared to the synonymous lexical item tomorrow, and pink blocks light red. However, as S. Anderson (1986) points out, these semantic Elsewhere-like phenomena differ depending on the area of grammar. Thus pink blocks light red, but light red does not lead to ungrammaticality. The Gricean imperative to be brief does induce Elsewhere-like blocking, but it is not a rule of grammar. Violating it does not lead to ungrammaticality. A similar contrast can be observed for Elsewhere effects in arguments and adjuncts. One of the central claims of this chapter and the following
66 Argument case and case alternations is that argument linking operates according to the specific Elsewhere-like constraint I have called the Restrictiveness Constraint. If this is correct, the blocking behavior of linkers should be more like the strict one found in phonology and morphology and not like the loose Gricean one. The competition among cases is grammatical and absolute. The competition among adjuncts, however, is the competition between independent words. It is like the competition between pink and light red, and so is expected to be looser. In fact, many complements display exactly this behavior, and this class we will identify as adjuncts. Adjuncts, it is well known, are not identical with the class of optional NPs, since both arguments and adjuncts can be obligatory or optional. Uszkoreit (1987: (27a-d)) illustrates the four-way contrast with German examples like the following. The first sentence (108a) contains a postverbal obligatory argument, den Tisch 'the table,' the second sentence has an optional one, einen Brief 'a letter.' Recall too that the verbs of lacking in Icelandic generally had an optional first argument. The next sentence (108c) contains an obligatory adjunct and the last (108d) an optional one: (108)
a. Der Mann hatte den Tisch geschlagen. the(NOM) man had the(Acc) table hit T h e man had hit the table.' b. Der Spion schrieb (einen Brief). the(NOM) spy wrote a(Acc) letter T h e spy wrote (a letter).' c. Er wohnt in Frankreich in Paris in einem Vorort he(NOM) lives in France in Paris in a suburb in einer alten Villa . . . in an old villa 'He lives in France in Paris, in a suburb, in an old villa d. Der Spion traf ihn (in Berlin) (in einem Cafe). the(NOM) spy met him(ACc) in Berlin in a(DAT) cafe T h e spy met him (in Berlin), (in a cafe).'
The adjuncts are not distinguished by being optional, since some adjuncts are obligatory, and some arguments are optional. However, these adjuncts, unlike the arguments, are repeatable, as (108c,d) demonstrate. However, adding another NP in (108a) does not allow that second NP to be interpreted as another entity hit by the man. This will follow from the fact that argument linking requires an argument to be linked to, whereas adjuncts can be added freely as long as they are interpretable. So verbs
Why argument structure? 67 must have argument structures but also be able to syntactically require an adjunct: (109)
a. b. c. d.
schlagen ( x, y ) 'strike' schreiben ( x, (y) ) 'write' wohnen ( x ) NP 'live' treffen ( x, y ) 'meet'
The extra NP in (109c) will require at least one adjunct. The difference between this NP and the NP arguments is that additional (adjunct) NPs can be added in (108c) without ungrammaticality. Whether or not we have a level of argument structure, this difference must be encoded somewhere. Note that the present theory provides evidence for the argumentadjunct distinction and a diagnostic for distinguishing them. Consider the LDC and the sentences in (108). It is clear that the repeated adjuncts can be linked by the same preposition, e.g. in 'in.' If the LDC applied to these NPs, they would clearly violate it, since they are linked by the same preposition and no other linkers. But the LDC is explicitly a constraint on argument linking and so should not rule these out. Repeatability of adjuncts provides confirmation for the LDC as a constraint on argument linking. We can take this line of argumentation further, and ask what this means for argument categories. The LDC is not applicable to adjuncts, but it does seem to be sensitive to argument category features like EXP and GOAL, as evidenced by the dative-nominative sentence in (5b) above and the following ditransitive passive and its linking (for more on Icelandic ditransitives, see Chapter 5): (110)
Konunginum voru gefnar ambattir. king-the(DAT) were given(f.pl) slaves(NOM.f.pl) 'The king was given maidservants.' (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985:(44)))
(111)
gefa (x A
y|GOAL
z) 'give'
DAT: [ARG/GOAL]
NOM: [ARG]
NOM: [ARG]
_VP
[ARG]
ACC:
[ ]
*_VP: [ARG] [ ]
ACC:
Here the feature GOAL is the only thing preventing the LDC from ruling out nominative on the second argument, since it is all that distinguishes
68
Argument case and case alternations
the nominative from the most restrictive linker of that type (case) applicable to the higher argument. The LDC must not rule this structure out, because the sentence is good. However, if the LDC has to refer to an argument category, but it does not refer to adjuncts, then they evidently are argument categories and not of one piece with the adjuncts. To unify the goal of transfer and the locational goal in one semantic supercategory like the thematic role goal would miss an important aspect of explanation. It would not allow the LDC to be consistently formulated in terms of argument structure, which it needs to be. Another major difference between arguments and adjuncts that also follows from the constraints is their different mode of "blocking." The RC is an absolute blocking constraint, and only argument cases seem to be linked in accord with this constraint. Thus while goal dative must block default accusative, we get free variation for the adjuncts: (112)
a. The bird flew to the tree. b. The bird flew onto the tree.
The proposition that (112b) denotes entails the one denoted by (112a). The sentence in (112b) carries more information than the sentence in (112a), and in that sense the preposition onto in (112b) is more "specific" than the preposition to in (112a). But there is no question of onto "blocking" to. At most, if one knows that (112b) describes a state of affairs but uses (112a) one is violating the Gricean imperative of informativeness. The choice of onto is far from being obligatory, but the choice of dative over accusative in (110) is obligatory. The argument cases in DS competed with each other by the RC. But the adjuncts' LINK value I will take to be non-null, atomic, and different from the arguments' LINK values. This is accomplished by the feature ADJUNCT. Thus for (112), the following compete: (113)
Adverb (NP) to: [ADJUNCT], onto: ACC: [ ]
[ADJUNCT],
...
Either of the prepositions blocks the accusative, but neither blocks the other. Both sentences in (112) are generated by Phrase Structure. Both are interpretable. The use of the accusative is not admissible, because under any interpretation it might get, there is a more restrictive linker, to or onto, etc. The RC rules out accusative, but it does not decide between prepositions. The non-blocking of adjunct linkers follows from
Conclusion 69 their not having features like the argument categories. Once again, it is essential that the present theory treat argument categories as fundamentally distinct from the semantics, unlike in thematic role theory. 2.6
Conclusion
The restrictiveness-based theory of case captures the systematic similarities and differences between DS and NS without introducing unneeded devices into case theory. The solution to these particular problems was a by-product of a solution to the independent problem of generating case frames and predicting grammatical functions from argument structure. The uniform treatment of case, a novel feature of this theory, allows DS and NS to receive a unified account. In each alternation, the optionality of one case automatically leads to take-over by the "replacement" case. One key aspect of the account was the analysis of nominative as the anyargument case and accusative as the default case in Icelandic and some of its relatives. This will turn out to be a special case of a more general scheme of syntactic case which will be taken up in the next chapter.
3
A typology of case systems
This chapter will explore some consequences of the theory introduced in the previous chapter. There each case was associated with certain syntactic features, implemented there as the value of the feature LINK, which determine that case's syntactic behavior. In this chapter, I will extend this treatment of case to cover languages of different types and, in the next, to languages that make extensive use of linkers other than morphological cases. By "languages of different types" I mean languages whose cases show superficial differences from the system introduced in the last chapter, which had a nominative for arguments and an accusative as default. Some languages have a default nominative rather than the default accusative. And in some languages, the case of the object of a transitive verb is the same as the case of the subject of an intransitive verb, and a different case marks the subject of a transitive verb. The former case would be called "absolutive," the latter "ergative." This chapter extends the particular system of Chapter 2 to cover all these types. The main result of this chapter is that a generalization of the theory of the last chapter involving just two parameters correctly predicts four main types of two-case system. This four-way typology will lead to a range of predictions about the behavior of case in individual languages. In the next two sections, I will generalize the theory of linking and case frames already formulated and spell out the predictions it makes. Then I will present examples of each of the major predicted case systems and how the predictions fare in each of the languages considered. 3.1
Two accusatives
In the last chapter I argued that accusative in Icelandic and some related languages is the default in the domain of linking, rather than nominative as commonly assumed. The accusative could potentially link any NP 70
Two accusatives
71
whether argument or adjunct, and does so if there is no more restrictive linker available. This correctly predicts an Elsewhere pattern for linking by accusative in languages like Icelandic, and such languages will belong to one type (type 1) in the typology below. But some languages which we call "nominative-accusative" show the reverse pattern. Their nominative can appear on both arguments and adjuncts, whereas their accusative is highly limited. Nevertheless, they are nominative-accusative in the sense that the case which marks the subject of a transitive is the same as that which marks the subject of an intransitive - this is called "nominative" - and this case is distinct from the case which marks the object of a transitive, called "accusative". I will first generalize the system of Chapter 2 to handle this second type of nominative-accusative language. One of the most studied of nominative-accusative languages of this second, default-nominative, type is Japanese. In Japanese the accusative case marker -o marks the direct objects of transitive clauses: (1)
Taroo ga kodomo o sikatta. John NOM child ACC scold-PAST 'Taro scolded the child.'
In general, the Japanese accusative marks only arguments but never the highest argument. The evidence for this view will be presented at length in 3.3.2. The Japanese accusative will be associated with the feature specification [-H(ighest)A(rgument)], meaning "cannot appear on the highest argument": 1 (2)
ACC2: ^
The subscript 2 on accusative distinguishes the accusative here from the accusative in the last chapter and refers to type 2. Later I will show that an accusative like (2) is characteristic of type 2 languages in the typology of this chapter. The accusative entry in (2) makes Japanese -o like Icelandic nominative (both restricted to arguments) but with the addition of the specification [—HA]. Japanese nominative (-ga) will have the same LINK value as the accusative in Icelandic, i.e. it is the linking default: (3)
NOM2: [
]
The linking for (1) will be as follows:
72 (4)
A typology of case systems sikar- (X|+HA NOM2: [
y|-HA ) 'scold' ]
ACC2'.
\ARG 7
[-HAJ NOM2: [
]
The accusative is applicable to the second argument, because it is not the highest. It is not applicable to the highest argument precisely because it is highest. From now on, I will omit the redundant [HA] specifications from the argument structure, since it is immediately clear which arguments are highest and which are not. One immediate correct consequence of the use of [—HA] for the LINK value of the Japanese accusative is that it predicts that accusative will not be preserved in the passive. Wherever accusative and nominative compete in Japanese, the accusative should win, because it is the most restrictive. One desirable effect of [-HA] on the accusative is that accusative does not compete on the first argument of the passive. Thus, the linking for the passive in (5) is as in (6): (5)
Kodomo ga Taroo ni sikar-are-ta. child NOM Taroo by SCOW-PAST T h e child was scolded by Taro.'
(6)
sikar- (xA
y) 'scold' NOM: [ ]
In the passive the second argument becomes the highest, ruling out the use of accusative, which is prohibited on highest arguments. The passive correctly gets nominative. One question that immediately arises is whether this specification for [—HA] belongs in the same class as the features introduced thus far. Should the [—HA] specification, if present, be a part of the value of LINK or not? Certainly, since this feature does have a great deal to do with the linking properties of its case, the natural assumption is that it is part of the LINK value. This tentative assumption leads to interesting and correct consequences for the analysis of Japanese. Consider the situation that would arise with idiosyncratic case in a language like Japanese. The idiosyncratic case will either have the specification [-HA] or it will not (the only two logical possibilities). If the idiosyncratic case is not specified [—HA], then neither the idiosyncratic case nor the accusative is more restrictive than the other:
Two accusatives 73 (7)
a.
DAT: [ARG|2]
b. ACC2:
(part of the lexical entry of soodan suru 'consult,' etc.)
[ ARG —HA
Neither case's LINK value subsumes the other's, so blocking between the two cases is not defined, an undesirable state of affairs. When the logical object of an idiosyncratic dative verb needs to be linked, neither case will have priority. But the dative should have priority, since only dative (not accusative) is grammatical with a dative verb like soodan suru 'consult' (Kuno (1973), Marantz (1984: 78)): (8)
John ga Mary ni soodansita. John NOM Mary DAT consult-PAST 'John consulted Mary.'
To get this result, either [—HA] is not a part of LINK (the less natural assumption), or the other possibility above must be considered: the dative is [—HA].
If [-HA] is indeed part of the LINK value of the idiosyncratic case, then we get two predictions. First, the idiosyncratic case is correctly predicted to block the accusative, since its LINK value now does properly contain that of the accusative: (9)
a. DAT2:
ARG 12 (part of the lexical entry of soodan suru —HA J 'consult,' etc.)
b. ACC2:
ARG -HA
The dative blocks the accusative as in (10): (10)
soodan suru (x NOM2: f
y) 'consult' J
DAT2:
ARG/2 —HA
ACC 2 :
I ARG
I -HA NOM 2 : [
]
The accusative is correctly blocked despite its being potentially applicable by the AC to the second argument in (10). Only the dative is grammatical. If idiosyncratic datives generally have [-HA] in Japanese, then dative is more restrictive than accusative, and there is no need to revise
74 A typology of case systems the definition of restrictiveness or make [-HA] an exception to it. Nonnominative cases in Japanese generally need to bear [—HA]. The second prediction is that the idiosyncratic cases, like the accusative, should not be preserved in the passive, since, like accusative, they bear [—HA]. It turns out that idiosyncratic case behaves in exactly this way in Japanese (Kuno (1973), Marantz (1984)), as demonstrated by the passive corresponding to (8): (11)
Mary ga John ni soodans-(r) are-ta. Mary NOM John DAT/by consult-PASS-PAST 'Mary was consulted by John.'
In the passive, the second argument (Mary) is the highest, and the dative, being by hypothesis [—HA], is inapplicable. The accusative also is inapplicable, and so this leaves nominative, correctly predicting the active-passive pattern: (12)
soodan suru-PASS (xA
y) 'consult' NOM2: [
]
Nominative correctly applies in the passive of a verb with idiosyncratic case in the active. In this section I have extended the restrictiveness-based theory to a second type of nominative-accusative type of language. I will return to this type of nominative-accusative system in §3.3.2 after deriving the full typology, to which I now turn. 3.2
A typology of case
The extension of the theory to the second type of nominative-accusative language is the first of two steps on the way to a four-way typology. The hypothesis to be proposed is that there are two basic parameters at work in case theory and that, from these two parameters alone, four types of two-case system are predicted. The first parameter, the Limitation Parameter, is based on the distinction already introduced between the two types of nominative-accusative system. Some languages have a limitation like [—HA] on their any-argument linker (e.g. Japanese accusative), and some do not (e.g. Icelandic nominative). The second parameter, the Preference Parameter, is a choice of whether this feature refers to highest or lowest argument and simultaneously whether the LDC is a constraint on possible case for the higher or lower of two arguments.
A typology of case 75 Crossing these two parameters provides a four-way typology. In this section the two parameters will be formulated as will the predictions that follow from them. These will be tested against data from a variety of languages in §3.3.
3.2.1 The two-parameter hypothesis The hypothesis to be explored here is that two parameters derive a correct four-way typology. I start out from the assumption that each two-case system has an any-argument case and a default case. This yields the general system in (13): (13)
a. Case A: [ARG] b. Case B: [ ]
Each of the languages considered so far has two cases like these, although their labels differ. Icelandic's Case A is nominative, and its Case B is accusative. In Japanese Case A is accusative, and Case B is nominative. The difference between them consists so far in the extra limitation on Case A in Japanese. This first difference will be the basis of the first parameter, the Limitation Parameter. This parameter provides that some languages have a limitation on their any-argument case, their Case A: (14)
Limitation Parameter (preliminary): Languages can have the limitation [—HA] in the LINK value of their any-argument case.
The parameter yields the following possibilities: (15)
a. Case A: [ARG] , ~ A [ARG b. Case A: I—HA
Icelandic has (15a), Japanese (15b). The feature [—HA] can be present on the any-argument case (and lexical cases as in Japanese). I leave it open whether the default case might be limited to non-highest arguments. For typographical ease I will often abbreviate (15) further as in (16), but we have reason to reconsider the relation of [ARG] to [-HA] at several points below: (16)
a. Case A: [ARG] b. Case A: [ARG|— HA]
76 A typology of case systems Since
is all or part of the value of [ARG], its presence depends on [ARG]. I have already presented a little evidence for this parameter in the last section and will present more in §3.3.2 and §3.3.3. The second parameter, the Preference Parameter, rests on the hypothesis that the way [—HA] works in a language is closely related to the way the Linking Dissimilation Constraint (LDC) of the last chapter works in that language. Recall that the LDC is asymmetric. It considers the linking of pairs of arguments and asks for alternatives for only one of those arguments. In Icelandic, the LDC asks for alternatives on the lower of two arguments, and I repeat the version of the LDC which I gave in Chapter 2: (17)
[—HA]
Linking Dissimilation Constraint: Given two co-arguments, x and y, x higher than y, if y is linked by a linker B that has the same LINK value as the most restrictive linker of that type applicable by the AC to x, call it A, and there is a less restrictive linker C, applicable by the AC to y, then the linking is ill-formed.
In the notation I have been using, this is as follows: (18)
* verb
(...X
A: [a]
y • ••) B: [b] C: [c]
where A and B are of the same type, a = b, and C is applicable by the AC to y (c unifies with y's LINK value) Note that this constraint is asymmetric in that it "questions" the linking of the lower argument y but not the higher argument x. It is this asymmetry that gives the system its "directional" procedural interpretation. An alternative to (17-18) would be to have linking take the argument list top-down in Icelandic. Once the more restrictive linker (e.g. with LINK value [ARG]) is used on the first argument it can apply to, then subsequent (in the procedure) arguments cannot get this case without violating the prohibition on identical most restrictive linkers, which would still be necessary. So "early" use of the nominative on the higher argument precludes its "later" use on a lower argument. It has been noted in the literature that ergative-absolutive languages are in some sense the "reverse" of nominative-accusative languages. This view has found its clearest form in the Case Tier Hypothesis (Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987)). This hypothesis holds that the difference
A typology of case 11 between nominative-accusative languages and ergative-absolutive languages consists in the direction of association of cases on a Case Tier and NPs on their tier. So if we have one or two NPs and two cases (19), we will get the nominative-accusative pattern if we associate cases with arguments rightwards (20), and we will get the ergative-absolutive pattern if we associate leftwards (21): (19) (20)
a.
Case
Case
NP
NP
NOM
ACC
NP b . NOM
(21)
ACC
I
NP
NP
a.
ACC
NOM
b.
ACC
NOM
NP
NP
NP
I
In leftward association, the NOM shows an absolutive pattern (subject of intransitive, object of transitive). The ACC shows an ergative pattern. In terms of the present approach to linking, under the procedural interpretation of the system, the Case Tier Hypothesis translates to the idea that Icelandic is top-down (or that the higher arguments are linked "earlier" than lower ones). Note that this would build directionality into the system. It would not mean that the cases would be on tiers. Specifically, what most versions of the Case Tier Hypothesis assume is that nominative and accusative are basically the same, and that the only difference between them results from directionality. This aspect of the hypothesis is incompatible with what is being developed here, since it is a central claim that the two syntactic cases should be distinguished by one being limited to arguments (the [ARG] case), and the other being the default. I propose to introduce a parameter into the system which has the effect of directionality of linking. Note that what leads to the directional interpretation is the asymmetry built into the LDC. It turns out that the two
78 A typology of case systems nominative-accusative types of languages differ in directionality of linking and that - correspondingly - there are two types of ergative-absolutive language. We can ask now, in the directional spirit of the Case Tier Hypothesis, what it would be like in each case if this asymmetry in the LDC were the reverse (or, equivalently, if lower arguments are linked "early" and higher arguments are linked "late"). If the LDC considered alternatives to the linking for the higher argument we would get the following: (22)
Linking Dissimilation Constraint: Given two co-arguments, x and y, y higher than x, if y is linked by a linker B that has the same LINK value as the most restrictive linker of that type applicable by the AC to x, and there is a less restrictive linker C, applicable by the AC to y, then the linking is disallowed.
I have placed emphasis on the change in the LDC for the "reverse." Graphically, we get the following: (23)
* verb (...y B: fb] C:[c]
...
x ...) A: [a]
where A and B are of the same type, a = b, and C is applicable to y (c unifies with y's LINK value) This reverse LDC is the same as the original one modulo the substitution of higher for lower in (17-18) above. The system which is exactly like Icelandic but has this reverse LDC is what I will call "type 4" below. An example of such a language is Kabardian, discussed in §3.3.4. The following sketch will make clear what is meant. Consider the case of a transitive in such a type 4 language. The argument structure and the linking will be as follows: (24)
verb ( x *Case A: [ARG] Case B: [ ]
y) Case A: [ARG] Case B: [ ]
The RC causes the most restrictive linker to apply consistent with the LDC. If the LDC is asymmetric in the "reverse" way, then the lower argument, y, is linked by the more restrictive Case A and the LDC has nothing to say, because the reverse LDC only looks for alternatives on the higher of a pair of arguments, which y cannot be. As for the other,
A typology of case 79
higher argument, its most restrictive linker consistent with the "reverse" LDC is Case B. The more restrictive Case A is out, because it would mean both arguments are identically linked where there is an alternative for the higher argument. Now consider an intransitive: (25)
verb ( x ) Case A: [ARGJ Case B: [ ]
The case that links a solitary argument is of course Case A. Now compare the intransitive (25) and the transitive (24). The same linker, Case A, links both the subject of the intransitive in (25) and the object of the transitive in (24) with Case B linking the subject of the transitive. Because of this distribution, Case A would be called "absolutive" and Case B "ergative." Hence such a language would be the ergative-absolutive reverse-wise counterpart to Icelandic. If this last type, our type 4 below, is the reverse of Icelandic (type 1), what is the reverse of Japanese, our type 2? Now that we have two instantiations of the LDC depending on whether the LDC considers alternative linkers for the lower (Icelandic) or higher (Kabardian) of two co-arguments, we can ask which is appropriate for Japanese. Looking back at the demonstrations of the last section, this is not so clear. Since the accusative in Japanese is limited to non-highest arguments, the LDC is not crucial in the linking of transitives (but will be in ditransitives). However, as we will see in Japanese causative constructions, the LDC should consider alternatives for higher arguments, like Kabardian, but unlike Icelandic. Note that, if so, this is the second place in the Japanese case system where the notion "high" is used. It was and will be argued that Japanese has the restriction [—HA] "not allowed on highest arguments" on its [ARG] linker. The second parameter, the Preference Parameter, consists in the claim that these two places where the notion "high" is used are related and can likewise be reversed. So the answer to the question of what the reverse of Japanese is would be a language with the opposite value, i.e. "low" in both places. It would have [-LA] "not allowed on lowest arguments" on its any-argument linker, and its LDC would consider alternatives for lower arguments, just as in Icelandic. Such languages will be called type 3, an example of which is Warlpiri, discussed in §3.3.3. The situation in type 3 is sketched schematically in the following for transitives and intransitives:
80 (26)
(27)
A typology of case systems verb ( x Case A: [ARG/-LA] Case B: [ ] verb ( x ) Case B: [
y) Case B: [
]
]
Case A shows an ergative pattern, Case B an absolutive one. But the cases themselves are different from those in the previous type of ergativeabsolutive language. Here what is called "absolutive" is the default case, whereas in type 4, the default shows the ergative pattern. We get two types of ergative-absolutive language - exactly parallel to the two types of nominative-accusative language. To keep the LDC general, we should factor out the high versus low aspect and leave the rest as part of Universal Grammar: (28)
Linking Dissimilation Constraint: Given two co-arguments, x and y, y high- /low-er than x, if y is linked by a linker B that has the same LINK value as the most restrictive linker of that type applicable by the AC to x, and there is a less restrictive linker C, applicable by the AC to y, then the linking is disallowed.
The choice of low versus high will be set by individual languages. And, similarly, the feature [ - H A / - L A ] must be set by the same parameter. We can say that [-HA] and [-LA] are the same feature in Japanese and Warlpiri but it must be "set" as to whether it prohibits the [ARG] case from linking highest or lowest arguments. So one way to do this is have a feature like the following universally with the choices:2 (29)
[-XA] where x = H if the feature means "prohibited on highest arguments" and x = L if the feature means "prohibited on lowest arguments"
To reflect this generalization of the feature [-HA] to [-XA] with H filled in as only one of two possible values of a parameter, we need the following revised Limitation Parameter: (30)
Limitation Parameter (revised): Languages can have the limitation [—XA] in the LINK value of their any argument case.
The Preference Parameter simply chooses a value for H(igh) versus L(OW) in (28) and (29):
A typology of case 81 (31)
Preference Parameter: Choose one of {high, low} in (28) and (29).
The claim behind the Preference Parameter is that the setting high versus low in the LDC and the argument case limitation feature is one setting. Crossing the two parameters, the Limitation Parameter and the Preference Parameter, gives a four-way typology. I will call Icelandic type 1. This type has no limitation on the [ARG] case and has the value low for the Preference Parameter which induces top-down directionality of linking under a procedural interpretation: (32)
Type 1: Limitation Parameter: No Preference Parameter: Low (Top-Down)
Type 2 differs in both respects: (33)
Type 2: Limitation Parameter: Yes Preference Parameter: High (Bottom-Up)
Type 3 is the reverse of type 2 with respect to the Preference Parameter, so it shares with type 1 the low value of the Preference Parameter: (34)
Type 3: Limitation Parameter: Yes Preference Parameter: Low (Top-Down)
Finally, the type which is the reverse of type 3 in both respects is type 4: (35)
Type 4: Limitation Parameter: No Preference Parameter: High (Bottom-Up)
This last type is thus like type 1 except opposite with respect to the Preference Parameter. Note that the theory as developed in this section provides a crosslinguistic way of defining cases in a syntactic sense. The syntactic behavior of any given linker is determined by the three constraints of Chapter 2, as modified in this chapter. Each of these constraints makes reference to the case not by its name but by its LINK value. Hence the syntactic behavior of any linker is determined by its LINK value. But note now that this gives us an elegant way to identify cases cross-linguistically. In fact,
82
A typology of case systems
this identification is possible precisely because the LINK value of a linker defines it syntactically. The equivalences are given in the following table: (36)
type of information
defined linker
[
ACCi, NOM2, ABS3, ERG4
]
[ARG]
NOM1? ACC2, ERG3, ABS4
[ARG|X], X = EXP, GOAL
argument category case (e.g. dative) idiosyncratic case
Y], Y = 1, 2 in lexical entry
[ARG|...
Argument category cases can be identified across languages to the extent that the feature GOAL in one language can be identified with the feature GOAL in another language. At any rate, argument category case and idiosyncratic case receive cross-linguistic definitions based on the type of LINK information they contain, i.e. information besides [ARG] (and [-XA]). More importantly for the typology of two case systems, the two syntactic linkers are defined by the feature [ARG] and its absence. One syntactic case has a null LINK value, and the other has the information that it is limited to arguments. One of the most noteworthy results that emerges from this typology is that the labels for cases are only labels. They do not define cases. The nominative-accusative and ergative-absolutive patterns each come in two radically different varieties, if this scheme is correct. 3.2.2 Predictions These new, more general definitions of cases (and other linkers) allow us to generalize the predictions about case in Chapter 2 about type 1 languages up to their full cross-linguistic generality. Any prediction about nominative in Chapter 2 we can now see was really a prediction about the any-argument case and so is a prediction about type 2 accusative, type 3 ergative, and type 4 absolutive. Similarly, predictions about the accusative in Chapter 2, especially, the prediction that it will show Elsewherelike behavior, is just a special case of a wider prediction about default cases, so about type 2 nominative, type 3 absolutive, and type 4 ergative as well. Before turning to more languages, I summarize these predictions in their most general form. First of all, an [ARG] linker no matter what label it receives is predicted to show LDC effects. If two co-arguments have an [ARG] linker as their most restrictive linker, that linking will be ruled out. This is because there
A typology of case 83 is always the less restrictive default case as an alternative for one of the arguments. Thus we get the following prediction, which is the LDC applied to the [ARG] linker: (37)
Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction: A linker with the LINK value [ARG] may not link two co-arguments.
This prediction of course follows directly from the LDC and the nature of the any-argument linker. It also follows from the LDC that one of two co-arguments will get the default case, since the LDC only rules out a linking if there is an alternative for a certain one of the co-arguments. So any time in the absence of the LDC we would get two co-arguments linked by the [ARG] linker (or two [ARG] linkers), then the LDC will force the use of the default. So we get the following corollary: (38)
Corollary: If the [ARG] case is the most restrictive linker that passes the Applicability Constraint for two arguments, one of those arguments will show default case.
In Chapter 2, we saw that this means that in a type 1 language, anywhere the nominative is the most restrictive case that passes the AC for two coarguments, that clause will contain an accusative.3 Since type 1 languages have the low-value for the Preference Parameter the accusative will appear on the lower of any such pair of co-arguments. A closely related prediction concerns the repeatability of the default case. The default case has a special status with respect to the LDC, because the LDC only rules out linkings where there is an alternative for a designated member of a pair of similarly linked co-arguments. If two co-arguments are linked by the default case, there can of course be no alternative case, since there is no less restrictive case than the default case, whose LINK value subsumes any LINK value. From this it follows that the LDC will never rule out the multiple use of default cases, regardless of what the language labels it (accusative, nominative, absolutive, or ergative), and we get the following: (39)
Default Linker Non-Dissimilation Prediction: Default (LINK: [ ]) linkers never show LDC effects and so are repeatable.
In fact, it is easy to see that the default case is the only case with this property. For any non-default case, there is always an alternative that will cause the LDC to rule out the linking. So, for nominative, if it is the most restrictive linker linking two co-arguments, the fact that the default
84 A typology of case systems is an alternative will cause that linking to be blocked. This is not just true for nominative or [ARG] linkers generally - as emphasized in the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction - but rather is true for any non-default linker. The default is always a less restrictive alternative in all contexts except where it is the only case that passes the AC. There is no less restrictive alternative to the default. From this it follows that all linkers except for the default linker will show LDC effects: (40)
Corollary: Non-default linkers show LDC effects, and so they are not repeat able.
This means that if a linker does not dissimilate we are forced to analyze it as a default. This will further mean that it cannot "block" any other linker by the Restrictiveness Constraint. An analysis of a case as the default makes predictions in all three areas, distribution, blocking, and dissimilation which must all hold true. The last prediction also relates to the default case, and has a somewhat different status than the others. Recall from Chapter 2 that the way a default status for accusative in Icelandic was justified was by showing that it, but not nominative, could mark adjuncts such as time adverbials. From this we can derive a predicted tendency: (41)
Elsewhere Pattern Prediction: Only default case will have an Elsewhere distribution, the distribution that reflects the complement of the conditions on the other linkers combined, and is likely to mark adverbials and other adjuncts.
The second half of the prediction must read "likely," because it is well known that adverbials and other adjuncts may be marked with a case otherwise used for arguments. It is a matter of great controversy whether a dative of time-at-which should be introduced by the same rule as a dative of "indirect object." As I indicated at the end of the last chapter, I am advocating that such datives be kept syntactically distinct. But once we allow for adjunct cases that happen to use the same morpheme as a syntactic case, we admit of the possibility of apparent counterexamples to the claim that there is one default linker and that it alone will be likely to mark a range of adjuncts. We can ask what empirical content the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction has. There are two specific ways in which (41) has a great deal of empirical content. The first relates to the markedness of different options for adverbials. The default in a language is the linker that applies just in case no
A typology of case 85 other linker can. Nothing requires that the default be used. The extent of its applicability is the complement of the extent of applicability of all the other linkers combined. This means that if a language has a specific case or adposition for every adverbial and for various argument types (especially GOAL), it may be true that the default happens never to be allowed to be used more than once per clause. For this reason, we cannot make the stronger prediction that default linker must be used more than once in some sentence of each language. The default of course will be used in the absence of more restrictive linkers that pass the AC and the LDC, but only there. Now, consider an adverbial that has no special case. It costs nothing at all for that adverbial to be linked by the default linker. On the other hand, if the morphological dative or the morphological genitive marks many adverbials, this is just coincidence or historical residue and so should be less likely to happen than a wide range of adverbials bearing default case. Within a given language, certain facts like a uniquely wide and disparate set of uses for one case calls for an analysis in terms of default. Recall in this regard Gaedicke's (1880) justification for treating accusative as default in his grammar of Vedic Sanskrit, discussed in Chapter 2. Thus it is a cross-linguistic prediction that the default case is more likely on a range of adverbials than any other case. This is what is meant in (41). If more languages have some other morphological case marking adverbials, then this would be a major problem for the theory. The second way the theory confronts the data in (41) is that the default case is expected to show Elsewhere behavior in the realm of argument linking. This means that if some case demands to be treated as the Elsewhere since its distribution is so heterogeneous, then this case must have the other attributes of the default, i.e. repeatability, least priority, etc. This brings us to the last and most important point of all. The theory here in conjunction with analyses of particular languages not only makes the predictions above and many others about which case blocks which, but it makes a tightly interconnected set of predictions. Once a case is analyzed as the [ARG] case on the basis of its distribution, it must obey the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction. In other words, if a case is the [ARG] case with respect to the AC and the RC, it must be the same case with respect to the LDC. The same goes for the default. Each linker must behave consistently with respect to all three constraints. If a case is repeatable but blocks another case, then this is a clear counterexample
86 A typology of case systems to the theory being developed. The theory makes the predictions for a given case simultaneously and for a group of cases. The theory, in conjunction with the analysis of a particular language's cases in terms of LINK values, is meant to predict every possible case frame in a language and rule out all the impossible ones. Thus each analysis bears on the theory in the strongest way.
3.3
Four types of case system
This section will examine the preliminary evidence for this typology. The first and most important prediction inherent in the typology is that each of the four types should exist. This section will present evidence that each type is indeed attested. For each type, I will examine several languages to test the predictions of the last section. I will also indicate other languages that may fall into each of these types. 3.3.1 Type 1 In Chapter 2 we saw our first example of a type 1 language. The account of Icelandic and related languages there can now be seen as a special case of the four-way typology. I will return to Icelandic in greater detail in Chapter 5. This section examines data from another type 1 language, Classical Greek, and tests the predictions that follow from calling Greek type 1. A type 1 language has no limitation on its argument case and has the value low for the Preference Parameter: (42)
Type 1: Limitation Parameter: No Preference Parameter: Low (Top-Down)
The no value of the Limitation Parameter means that the any-argument case (Case A) will not be prohibited on the highest or lowest argument. The low value of the Preference Parameter means that the LDC will question the linking of the lower of each pair of co-arguments. The result of this is that Case A will have a nominative distribution and Case B an accusative one, with nominative as the any-argument case and accusative as the default: (43)
a. NOMI: [ARG] b. ACCI: [
]
Four types of case system
87
So the predictions of §3.2.2 that referred to the any-argument case are predictions about nominative in Classical Greek (just as they were in Icelandic, another type 1 language), and predictions about the default case are, for Greek, predictions about accusative (once again like Icelandic). I will now confirm that the predictions are borne out in Greek. The first prediction for the argument case is the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction, a special case of the LDC. Linking twice by the [ARG] linker will inevitably violate the LDC. For Greek this means that any clause containing more than one argument of the same verb will contain at most one nominative. Further, by the corollary in (38) applied to Greek, we expect that if nominative is the most restrictive linker that passes the AC on two arguments, then the lower will show accusative. Greek seems to be like Icelandic and its relatives considered in Chapter 2 in not allowing two nominatives per clause except in predication. Although this is based on negative evidence from a dead language, the absence of such double nominative sentences is striking, when compared to Japanese (next section). As for the corollary, it is indeed true that the accusative is used when the nominative is the most restrictive linker for more than one argument. The simplest situation is an intransitive (44) which I present with a simple transitive (45) for comparison: (44)
(45)
Proxenos paren Proxenos(NOM) was-present Troxenos was present.'
(X.A.I.2.3)
proseilephe ten ton ponerOn koin^n received the(ACc) the(GEN) vile(GEN) common(ACc) eponumian sukophantes appelation(ACc) informer 'he received the common appelation of the vile, "informer"' (Aeschines 2.99)
First of all, the nominative-accusative pattern is obvious. Where both nominative and accusative may apply, and the LDC is irrelevant, i.e. in the intransitive and for the highest argument of the transitive, the nominative must apply by the RC, and in fact it does. On the lower argument of the transitive, use of the nominative violates the LDC. The only wellformed structure has the less restrictive accusative, fulfilling the prediction.
88
A typology of case systems
If accusative is the default linker, it must not dissimilate, according to the Default Linker Non-Dissimilation Prediction. I know of no sentences where we would wish to have accusative dissimilation. This prediction also says that accusative is in principle repeatable. As noted above, if a language is so rich in more restrictive linkers that the default has little chance to apply by the RC, then it may turn out that the default linker is never actually repeatable. The fact that the default cannot repeat in that language would be an accidental gap. However, cross-linguistically, the default should be likely to repeat. And in each language, if any case can be used for more than one argument per clause, it is the default, which in Greek is accusative. Greek actually shows a wide range of multiple accusatives. First, two arguments per clause may take accusative. In Greek, ditransitive verbs take dative for the goal and accusative for the last argument, but a number of verbs take two accusatives: (46)
Kuros didosin autOi hex men6n misthon Cyrus(NOM) gives him(DAT) six months pay(Acc) 'Cyrus gives him pay for six months.' (X.^4.1.1.10)
(47)
oudeis edidaxe me tauten ten technen nobody(NOM) taught me(ACc) this(ACc) the (ACC) skill(ACc) 'Nobody taught me this skill.' (X.0.319.16)
This can be handled in a fashion very similar to the nominative versus dative experiencer classes in Icelandic (Chapter 2). The second argument of both types of verb are semantic goals, i.e. they correspond to participants who are entailed to have something move to them. The semantic goal of the first class of ditransitives is a syntactic goal as well. The second class will have three direct arguments, one of which is a semantic but not syntactic goal: (48)
didomi ( x
y|DAT z) 'give'
(49)
didasko ( x
y
z) 'teach'
The dative of (syntactic) goals is not applicable to the second argument of the second class. The most restrictive case that passes the AC for that argument is the any-argument case, in Greek the nominative, as shown in (50):
Four types of case system (50)
didasko (x
y
89
z) 'teach'
NOM
*NOM
*NOM
ACC
ACC
ACC
The nominative, although it is the most restrictive case that passes the AC for the second argument, is not the most restrictive applicable case, because its use would violate the LDC. Greek, being type 1 with the low value for the Preference Parameter, questions the linking of lower arguments versus higher arguments by the LDC. The nominative is the most restrictive applicable case that passes the AC for the highest argument. Therefore, by the LDC, use of the nominative on the second (or any lower argument) would violate the LDC's prohibition on identity. So accusative is the only available option, as it is for the last argument as well. The other possible analysis is that the semantic goal in (47) takes a lexical accusative, although Greek has no other lexical accusatives. On the view I am taking, that the accusative is not lexical, one predicts that this accusative will not be preserved in the passive. The goal argument does passivize, and the other argument remains accusative: (51)
ouden allo didasketai anthropos e epistemen nothing(Acc) else teach-PASs man(NOM) than knowledge(ACc) 'Man is taught nothing else except knowledge.' (P.Men.Slc)
This receives the following analysis: (52)
didasko (xA
y
z) 'teach'
NOM
*NOM
ACC
ACC
The "retained" object must get accusative by the LDC. Note that the accusative in these ditransitives shows the distribution we predict, because it applies exactly when no other case is applicable. The ditransitives are also the first evidence for the other facet of the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction: that the default is likely to mark a heterogeneous class of NPs. Already we have seen that the accusative links the logical object of most verbs, the goal of a class of ditransitives and the "retained" object in the ditransitive passives. In addition, Greek shows a wide range of non-argument accusatives (Smyth (1956: 355-63)), which are expected on the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction. In Greek, accusatives of path are common and quite free:
90 (53)
A typology of case systems hopos agein (stratian) e stenas e how to-lead army(ACc) either narrow(ACc) or plateias hodous broad(Acc) roads(Acc) 'how to lead an army over either narrow or broad roads' (Xen.Cyrop. 1.6.43: 10-11)
Another non-argument accusative in Greek is the accusative of extent. Sentence (54a) exemplifies the accusative of extent of time, and (54b) the accusative of extent of space: (54)
a. entautha emeinen hemeras hepta. there remained days(Acc) seven 'There he remained seven days.' (Xen.Anab. 1.2.6: 28) b. apekhei de he Plataia t6n Thebdn be-distant PTCL the Plataea the(GEN) Thebes(GEN) stadious hebdomekonta stades(Acc) seventy 'Plataea is seventy stades distant from Thebes.' (Thuc.2.5.2:
These adverbial accusatives need no special "semantic accusative" or separate rules but follow from the ultimate default nature of type 1 accusative. The linking for (54a) is as follows: (55)
meno (x) 'remain' Adverb (NP) NOM
ACC
ACC
Additionally, the adverb will contribute to the interpretation, but this is not represented at argument structure. A similar analysis can be given to "cognate accusatives": (56)
a. pollen phluarian phluarounta much(Acc) nonsense(Acc) nonsense-talking-PART(ACc) 'talking much nonsense' (P.A. 19c) b. esthenese tauten ten noson fell-ill(3sg) this(ACc) the(ACc) disease(ACc) 'He fell ill of this disease.' (Isoc. 19.24)
The linking for these is essentially the same as in (55). The particular significance of the cognate accusative is that as a non-argument that
Four types of case system
91
normally has no special case, it is one of the best diagnostics for which linker is the ultimate default linker. The "free" use of the accusative in Greek extends to any loose adverbial connection to the rest of the clause. Such accusatives are traditionally known as "accusatives of respect": (57)
deinoi de terrible(NOM.pl) PTCL 'terrible in battle'
makhen battle(ACc) (AQSch.Pers.21)
For other non-argument accusatives in Classical Greek, see Smyth (1920: 355-63). The general characteristic of these constructions is that they contribute semantically like an adverbial, they do not passivize except under special circumstances, and they are compatible with another accusative in the sentence.4 They are as freely addable to clauses as adverbials of the same meaning. By having the accusative as in (43b), we can get all of these uses of the accusative without special rules. However, anytime there is a preposition to mark an adjunct, the preposition is used if it is obligatory. The accusative is the default and so will pick up any NPs that are not marked by more restrictive prepositions or cases. Accusative thus marks a range of non-argument NPs. Nominative, however, never marks adjuncts but rather is limited to arguments. Assuming the general linkers proposed and that Greek is type 1 gets us a range of predictions which are fulfilled, i.e. the universal network of predictions from §3.2.2. In the next chapter I will show that English is type 1, and in Chapter 5 I provide a more detailed analysis of another type 1 language, Icelandic.
3.3.2 Type 2 As the representative of the other main type of nominative-accusative system, type 2, I take Japanese. Section 3.1 showed that there is basic motivation for thinking Japanese accusative to be like type 1 (Icelandic, Classical Greek, etc.) nominative with the addition of a limitation, [—HA]. Further, the assumption of the high value for the Preference Parameter would ensure that this [ARG] accusative would appear as far down in the argument hierarchy as possible, leading to a basically nominative-accusative pattern, which we find. I summarize the parameter values in (58):
92 (58)
A typology of case systems Type 2: Limitation Parameter: Yes Preference Parameter: High (Bottom-Up)
This section will test the various predictions for Japanese and will show that a wide variety of phenomena previously thought to require a special account follow directly from the universal principles and the analysis of Japanese as type 2. 3.3.2.1 The Double -o Constraint In this section I will show that the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction, in conjunction with our analysis of accusative in Japanese in §3.1, predicts exactly the behavior that has been said to require a "Double -o Constraint" in Japanese. In other words, the behavior of Japanese, far from requiring any special constraint, will follow from the universal LDC. In Japanese the accusative case marker -o marks the direct objects of transitive clauses: (59)
John ga hon o yondeiru. John NOM book ACC read-PROG-PRES 'John is reading a book.'
One fact about Japanese is that it has two double -o constraints (Harada (1973), Poser (1991)). One is a stylistic surface constraint against two -o marked NPs which varies from speaker to speaker. The other, the deep Double -o Constraint, disallows two NPs that would receive -o even if some other process causes one of the -os not to appear on the surface. In the causative of an intransitive verb, the causee can be marked by the accusative marker -o or by the dative/agentive marker -ni with a slight meaning difference: (60)
a. John ga Mary ni arukaseta. John NOM Mary DAT walk-cAus-PAST 'John let Mary walk.' b. John ga Mary o arukaseta. John NOM Mary ACC walk-CAus-PAST 'John made Mary walk.'
If the causative is of a transitive verb, only the dative/agentive marker is possible and has either the 'let' or 'make' interpretation:
Four types of case system (61)
93
a. *John ga Mary o hon o yomaseta. John NOM Mary ACC book ACC read-CAus-PAST 'John made Mary read a book.' b. John ga Mary ni hon o yomaseta. John NOM Mary DAT book ACC read-CAus-PAST 'John let/made Mary read a book.'
The Double -o Constraint is meant to capture the fact that (61a) is ungrammatical. Poser (1991) argues that the deep Double -o Constraint is not a constraint on surface case, since neither movement nor processes which cause the NP not to receive -o on the surface can affect the ungrammaticality of sentences like (61a). Topicalization normally replaces nominative and accusative on the topicalized NP with the topic marker -wa, but Poser (1991) shows that it cannot improve (61a) despite the surface non-appearance of -o. First, a simple transitive like (62) can have either John or the book NP topicalized: (62)
a. John wa hon o yondeiru. John TOP book ACC read-PROG-PRES 'As for John, he is reading a book.' b. Hon wa John ga yondeiru. book TOP John NOM read-PROG-PRES 'As for the book, John is reading it.'
In the causative, the replacement of -o by -wa does not improve (61a): (63)
a. *Hon wa John ga Mary o yomaseta. book TOP John NOM Mary ACC read-CAus-PAST 'As for the book, John made Mary read it.' b. Hon wa John ga Mary ni yomaseta. book TOP John NOM Mary DAT read-CAus-PAST 'As for the book, John made Mary read it.'
The Double -o Constraint cannot be a constraint on surface case, since such a constraint would not rule out (63a), which one expects to be bad for the same reason as (61a). Another of Poser's (1991) arguments for the non-surface nature of the Double -o Constraint comes from relativization. Here the relativized NP receives no surface case marker at all. Nonetheless, relativization does not improve (61a) either:
94 A typology of case systems (64)
a. *John ga Mary o yomaseta hon John NOM Mary ACC read-CAUs-PAST book 'the book which John made Mary read' b. John ga Mary ni yomaseta hon John NOM Mary DAT read-CAus-PAST book 'the book which John made Mary read'
Once again we want the constraint that rules out (61a) to rule out (64a) as well, but a surface constraint on morphological accusative case markers will not do the job. The same holds true of the phenomenon of Case Marker Drop. Even if the accusative case marker is "dropped" (or at least does not appear on the surface), the sentence is still unacceptable: (65)
a. *John ga Mary o hon yomaseta. John NOM Mary ACC book read-CAus-PAST 'John made Mary read a book.' b. John ga Mary ni hon yomaseta. John NOM Mary DAT book read-CAus-PAST 'John let/made Mary read a book.'
If some constraint is to rule out (65a) and (61a), it cannot be a surface constraint. The Double -o Constraint is a special case of the LDC as applied to argument linkers. In the ungrammatical sentence in (61a), co-arguments are linked by the non-null, non-default accusative, which the LDC rules out:5 (66)
yomaseta ( x NOM
y -ni,
z ) 'caused to read' ACC
NOM
ACC NOM
In the linking in (66) the dative/agentive -ni must be used. Use of -o (whether dropped or not) would lead to a LDC violation. For the other ungrammatical sentences, all that need be said is that the NP that would surface as -o is linked by the same case but that the case is not spelled out as -o. But this also follows from the general condition that all arguments and NPs must be linked. For instance, the realization of the sequence -o-wa (accusative and topic marker) is just -wa. Another alternative would be to define the LDC on surface form. Such a constraint would be as follows:
Four types of case system 95 (67)
Alternative LDC: Do not link co-arguments with the same nondefault linker.
This alternative LDC would have many of the same desirable effects as the one I am proposing. For instance, two nominatives per clause would be ruled out for Icelandic. This alternative solution runs into problems with Japanese, which, as Saito (1983) observes, can have -o or adjacency to V (_V) as its "accusative" linker. We might capture Saito's observations by proposing the following linkers: (68)
a. -o: [ARG|-HA] b. _V: [ARG|— HA]
The LDC as presently formulated says that, all else being equal, two argument NPs of the same predicate linked by -o and _ V would dissimilate. Under the alternative LDC, however, two co-arguments linked only by (68a) and (68b) should not dissimilate, because they are different linkers, and the alternative LDC is defined over linkers not LINK values. It turns out that there is dissimilation and that our LDC can explain some of the scrambling behavior of Japanese, if we assume the additional linker in (68b). In Japanese, objects may appear with (69a,c) or without (69b) the accusative case marker, but, if they appear without it, they must be adjacent to the verb ((69b) versus (69d)) (Saito (1983)): (69)
a. Masao ga hon o katta. Masao NOM book ACC bought 'Masao bought a book.' b. Masao ga hon katta. Masao NOM book bought c. Hon o Masao ga katta. book ACC Masao NOM bought d. *Hon Masao ga katta. book Masao NOM bought
In (69d) Hon is not linked and so violates the Linking Condition that requires all NPs to be linked. Now note that the LDC gets the following correctly ruled out: (70)
*John ga Mary hon o yomaseta. John NOM Mary book ACC read-CAus-PAST 'John made Mary read a book.'
96
A typology of case systems
This sentence violates the double accusative constraint, even though one could say that Mary is linked by -o and hon is linked by _V. Under the alternative LDC, (70) is not ruled out, since -o and _V count as separate syntactic cases because of their form. One way out of this problem is to follow Kiparsky (1987) and have -o or _V as the alternate realizations of one linker. Then the alternative LDC will rule out use of -o and _V for two arguments of the same verb, because those two arguments would be linked by the same linker, which the alternative LDC rules out. The question then arises how to decide what are separate linkers (_VP and nominative in Icelandic) and what are not (-o and _V in Japanese). The alternate realization hypothesis is most suspicious when there is no morphological relation between the two realizations/linkers, e.g. an accusative postposition versus a word-order position.6 This problem is very reminiscent of the problem posed by the case alternations of Chapter 2. There it was noted that the power to relate a case to another case rather than just to its absence carries with it undesirable power. So too here, the alternate realization hypothesis carries the same potential to relate any two cases. This is not necessary under the present account. Linkers of different types (case, agreement, word order) are separate linkers but are syntactically identical and behave as identical for the LDC as formulated above. The result is that such syntactically identical linkers may be used for different arguments as long as some other linker (e.g. dative) provides an additional distinguishing feature, as with the "dative subject-nominative object constructions." This approach allows the tightest connection between (morphological) case and (syntactic, abstract) Case. If, however, a case and a word-order position can be alternate realizations of the same abstract linker, then the richness of the realization component makes the distance between case and Case larger. On the present approach case and Case are as close as possible, constraining heavily the notion of Case. On this account, the ungrammatical sentence in (65a) above actually might have two derivations, but the LDC correctly rules them both out. One involves case marker drop as mentioned above. Case marker drop does not affect linking and so is irrelevant for the LDC. The other derivation of (65a) would involve using both -o and adjacency to the verb (_V) with the accusative on the causee and adjacency to V on the lowest argument:
Four types of case system (71)
*yomaseta ( x NOM
y -ni, -o
z ) 'caused to read' _V
NOM
NOM
97
The LDC disallows this structure since the linking features for the y and z arguments are the same. Syntactically the two linkers, accusative case and adjacency to V, are the same and so show LDC effects. Further confirmation for the theory comes from dative object verbs discussed in Poser (1991). In the causative of a dative object verb, the causee may be accusative: (72)
John ga Mary o Bill ni kataseta. John NOM Mary ACC Bill DAT defeat-CAUs-PAST 'John made Mary defeat Bill.'
According to the theory, the following cases are involved: (73)
a. -ni:
(part of lexical entry of katu 'defeat')
[ARG|2|-HA]
b. -o: [ARG]—HA]
The case in the lexical entry (73a) blocks (73b) since the LINK value of the dative properly includes that of the accusative. Thus Bill gets dative, and the accusative is still available for the causee. The dative with katu 'defeat' and the accusative do not have identical LINK values. The LDC will allow the causee to receive accusative: (74)
kataseta ( x NOM
y
z ) 'caused to defeat'
-ni, -o
-ni: [ARG|2|-HA]
NOM
-o, _V NOM
Note that the dative for the lowest argument comes from the lexical entry. There are no identical Unkings in (74). The LDC is satisfied, and the sentence is correctly generated. 3.3.2.2 Nominative If, as our analysis of Japanese requires, nominative is the default case, then it falls under the Default Linker Non-Dissimilation Prediction. The nominative should not show LDC effects and so should be repeatable in principle. Further, by the corollary in (40), the fact that nominative is repeatable will mean that it cannot be analyzed as anything but the default. The position that nominative is the default case in Japanese is
98
A typology of case systems
not new, although it should be kept in mind that nominative is taken to be the default in some type 1 languages, a position that did not square with the notion of default in the present theory. I will now show in this section and the next that the nominative in Japanese is the default in the sense required by this theory. It passes both predictions for the default case. First, as predicted the nominative is repeatable. Double nominative sentences occur.7 The first class of double nominative sentences are with verbs that optionally do not take a morphological accusative. In (75) the nominative can mark both arguments of desideratives in -tai and potential forms in -re I are (Kuno (1973: 93)): (75)
Dare ga nihongo ga/o hanaseru ka who NOM Japanese NOM/ACC speak-can Q 'Who can speak Japanese?'
Kuno (1973) proposes the following generalization with exceptions: stative verbs may take nominative objects. Poser (1991) demonstrates that this is a fact about surface -o since the statives may take nominative in place of an accusative of path (about which more shortly): (76)
a. Boku wa Asahidake ga I TOP Asahi-peak NOM 'I want to climb Mt. Asahi.' b. Konban hamabe ga this-evening beach NOM This evening I want to take
noboritai. climb-want sanpoositai. take-a-walk-want a walk along the beach.'
In the present approach the generalization can be reconstructed as a systematic exception to any case of the form -o: (77)
[ + stative] -> [- -o]
(optional)
At first this might seem to be evidence against syntactically separate accusatives, but the exceptions to (77) documented by Kuno are stylistic, suggesting this is not a regular linking condition but a condition on form. Alternatively, (77) could be replaced by a spell-out rule that makes -o into -ga. But this involves an extra degree of power that we tried to avoid in Chapter 2. The theory here can do better than having a rewrite rule. The fact that the NP that might have received -o receives -ga rather than some other case follows automatically from the theory. The case -ga is the next most restrictive applicable case. The only unusual thing about the
Four types of case system
99
situation with the statives in Japanese is that a case (actually a group of cases) is prohibited by verbs on a morphological basis. The stative restriction picks out this class on the basis of form as in (77). But the non-application of these phonologically related cases leads to the application of the default nominative, as required by the theory. 3.3.2.3 Adverbial case If, as I have argued, Japanese has accusative as the more restrictive case (and nominative as the default), one should expect few of Jakobson's (1936) "weakly governed" accusatives in Japanese. Rather, one should, by the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction, expect there to be a wide range of nominative adverbials. In fact, both expectations are borne out. Japanese does not use -o to mark time adverbials or cognate objects. Japanese does sometimes mark paths with -o: (78)
a. Kawa o kare ga sono nimotu o watasita. river ACC he NOM that baggage ACC cross-PAST 'He moved that baggage across the river.' b. Sono miti o Isao ga uma o hasiraseta. that road ACC Isao NOM horse ACC run-CAus-PAST 'Isao made the horse run along the road.'
This path accusative is compatible with other accusatives, so it cannot be the same accusative on the present approach. One possibility would be for Japanese to have a default accusative, but we would need some special constraint to block this other accusative from applying in many places. This would be cumbersome. But the accusative of path in Japanese does not seem to be an epiphenomenon of default as in Russian, Greek, Icelandic, and languages like them. Rather the accusative path seems to be a separate and old rule. Its identity of form with the syntactic accusative is more likely to be historical, since historically -o seems to have originated in a focus marker (references in Miyagawa (1989)). Note that, while the present theory does not predict the adverbial accusatives in Japanese, it does not disallow them; they are just no more likely than any other case homophony. The prediction about adverbial case is not absolute. What would be a problem for the theory would be a wide range of adverbial accusatives in a language like Japanese. Also, cognate accusatives should not occur in a language like Japanese. On the other hand, as expected, nominative marks a wide range of nonargument NPs. Saito (1983: 248) argues for a "default" status of nomi-
100 A typology of case systems native in Japanese on the basis of examples like these (bracketings are Saito's on an example from Kuno (1973: 71)): (79)
a. yahari [s natu ga [s biiru ga umai ]] after all summer NOM beer nom tasty 'After all it's during summer that beer tastes good.' b. [s bunmeikoku ga [s dansei ga cilivized-country NOM male NOM [s heikinzyumyoo ga mizikai ]]] average-life-span NOM short 'It is in civilized countries that men are such that their average life-span is short.'
As suggested by Saito's bracketings, it is not at all clear that these NPs are clausemates of any other NPs. However, if the nominative here is a linker then it must be the any-NP case since these NPs are not arguments. Analyzing Japanese as type 2 allows a coherent account of a wide variety of facts about Japanese syntax. It allows the derivation of the Double -o Constraint from the general LDC. It also allows an account of some scrambling facts and the distribution of accusatives and nominatives on adjuncts. Most of all, it provides a unified account of these phenomena from general principles. The class of type 2 languages probably includes many of those dis : cussed by Comrie (1976: 284f.) and so may include Hindi, Punjabi, Persian, Turkish, Finnish, Hungarian, Georgian, Songhai, and Tagalog. Some of these cannot be pure type 2 systems, since they show split ergativity, but many are probably type 2, and others partially so (see §3.4). 3.3.3 Type 3 The next type, type 3, bears a strong resemblance to the last type, type 2. In the present system, the similarities will be captured by the minimal difference between these two types. Type 3 shares with type 2 the yes value for the Limitation Parameter but differs from type 2 in the Preference Parameter, where it has the value low. In this latter respect it is like type 1: (80)
Type 3: Limitation Parameter: Yes Preference Parameter: Low (Top-Down)
Four types of case system
101
As an example of a type 3 language I take Warlpiri. This will lead the Case A of Warlpiri to show an absolutive distribution and the Case B to show an ergative one: (81)
a. ERG: [ARG|-LA]
b.
ABS:
[
]
The absolutive is the default and the ergative is the argument case. The argument case is limited in a way similar but reverse from the accusative in Japanese (type 2). Of the two ergative-absolutive types, type 3 is less unexpected than type 4 of the next section. This is because in type 3 absolutive is the default case. Like nominative case in nominative-accusative systems, the absolutive is the morphologically unmarked, often zero, case. As with nominative, this has led to a general assumption that it is also a default for linking. On the present theory this only holds for type 3, not for type 4. The predictions for type 3 are somewhat less unexpected than for type 4, since type 3 has absolutive as the default case. Accordingly, I will concentrate more on type 4 than on type 3. In this section I will present an analysis based on Simpson (1991) that Warlpiri is type 3 with absolutive default case. In the next section I will present the unexpected ergative type. First of all, the linking of a simple transitive and intransitive is given in (82) and (83) respectively (Hale (1983: 6, 13)): (82)
Ngarrka-ngku ka wawirri panti-rni. man-ERG AUX kangaroo(ABs) spear-NONPAST 'The man is spearing the kangaroo.'
(83)
a. Kurdu child(ABs) 'The child b. Kurdu child(ABS) 'The child
ka wangka-mi. AUX speak-NONPAST is crying.' kapi wanti-mi. AUX fall-NONPAST will fall.'
Hale points out that the absolutive is the regular case of intransitive subjects regardless of theta role. This alone makes the absolutive much more likely to be syntactic than semantic. The linking for these first examples is straightforward and is the reverse of Japanese intransitives and transitives. The transitive will have two
102 A typology of case systems different cases. The ergative, being specified [-LA], cannot apply to the lower of the arguments. It is more restrictive than the default absolutive and so we get ergative on the higher argument, absolutive on the lower argument: (84)
panti- ( x
y ) 'spear'
ERG: [ARG/—LA] ABS:
ABS: f
]
[ ]
Since both cases are non-oblique (about which more below), the ergative NP is the subject, because it is the highest non-obliquely linked argument. In the intransitive, the [—LA] specified ergative is not applicable, because the only argument is the lowest (as well as the highest). This argument being the lowest, no [-LA] case can link it. This leaves the default absolutive for (83a): (85)
wangka ( x ) 'cry' ABS: [
]
The identity of the case which marks the subject of the intransitive and the object of the transitive above is what leads to the label "absolutive." So far, as in the case of type 1 versus type 2, we do not have evidence to distinguish type 3 from type 4. The simple data from transitives and intransitives could reflect type 3 or type 4 case systems. Simple one or two argument clauses are not enough to distinguish type 3 from type 4. Analyzing ergative as the argument case, restricted by [-LA], makes it subject to the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction. Double ergative sentences do not seem to occur in Warlpiri. The related Default Linker Non-Dissimilation Prediction says that in principle the absolutive should be repeatable. Warlpiri has a dative of goal and a rich set of semantic cases, with the effect that the default rarely gets a chance to apply more than once per clause. There is, however, one class of double absolutive sentences, the so-called cognate absolutives. These are syntactically and semantically parallel to the cognate objects of Icelandic and Classical Greek. And, in the present scheme, they receive identical analyses. Once again, we analyze the cognate object as a nonargument NP. The case that applies to such a non-argument NP will, in the absence of a more specific case, be the default case. In Warlpiri, the absolutive, as predicted, links cognate objects (Nash (1980: 196)):
Four types of case system (86)
a. Ngaju ka-rna
103
wangka-mi.
I(ABS) PRES-lSgNOM
Speak-NONPAST
'I am speaking.' b. Warlpiri ka-rna ngajulu wangka-mi. Warlpiri(ABs) Pres-I I(ABS) speak-NONPAST 'I am speaking Warlpiri.' This can be analyzed as follows. The verb wangka- 'speak' has the following argument structure in the linking for (86b): (87)
wangka ( x ) ABS:
[
]
( NP ) ABS: [
]
The cognate object has no special case and it is not an argument. The only case that is applicable is the absolutive. The treatment of absolutive as the default captures the cognate object construction. Further, we are forced to analyze the absolutive as the default, since it is repeatable and so does not show LDC effects. The only alternative would be to analyze the absolutive as a special homophonous lexical case for cognate objects. The main problem with this is that lexical cases are rarely if ever zero cases morphologically. The present approach makes interesting predictions about the status of dative NPs in Warlpiri. The verb in (86) and some other verbs in Warlpiri seem to occur in an ABS-DAT case array: (88)
a. Ngaju I(ABS)
ka-rna
wangka-mi.
PRES-1 SgNOM
Speak-NONPAST
'I am speaking.' b. Ngaju ka-rna-rla
(Hale (1983: 18)) ngarrka-ku wangka-mi.
I(ABS) PRES-lsgNOM-3DAT man-DAT
'I am speaking to the man.'
Speak-NONPAST
(Hale (1973: 333))
Although, as mentioned in §2.10 above, optionality of an NP is not a sure sign of adjuncthood, optional complements are very often adjuncts. And Levin (1983: 211) provides arguments that the dative with such verbs should be treated as semantic and the NP as an adjunct. Interestingly, the analysis of Warlpiri as type 3 in the present theory actually forces us to this conclusion. Consider again the argument structure of a verb like wangka- 'speak.' The two possibilities are that the NP for the one spoken to corresponds to an argument or not: (89)
a. wangka- ( x y|GOAL ) 'speak' b. wangka- ( x ) 'speak'
104 A typology of case systems If the argument structure is as in (89b), then the dative must arise as an adjunct.8 Note that, if the argument structure is as in (89a), the ergative will incorrectly apply to the first argument, since it is not the lowest. But this would be wrong. On the other hand, if the argument structure is as in (89b), the ergative is inapplicable, since the argument is the lowest, and so the absolutive is the only applicable case. Thus the present theory forces the conclusion that Levin argues for anyway, a desirable result. Furthermore, this theory makes the prediction that if there are dative arguments in second place in the argument list, then the ergative is not only possible but obligatory. This is confirmed: the ERG-DAT array is also possible: (90)
Ngajulu-rulu ka-rna-rla I-ERG
karli-ki
warri-rni.
PRES-lsgNOM-3DAT boomerang-DAT seek-NONPAST
'I am hunting a boomerang.'
(Hale (1973: 335))
It seems, though, that these datives are different at least in being obligatorily expressed. I take them to be lexically case-marked arguments, which is required by the theory. Otherwise the ergative-marked argument is lowest, which is not possible in the theory, since the ergative cannot apply to lowest arguments in type 3. A complete analysis is beyond the scope of the present section. But one issue that does directly concern the conclusions here is the considerable controversy over whether Warlpiri ergative is a syntactic case or a semantic case. The latter view is necessitated by the analysis proposed by Jelinek (1984). She analyzes the NPs in Warlpiri as adjuncts and the agreement markers/pronouns in the verbal complex as the true arguments. This approach gets the optionality of NPs (since adjuncts are usually optional), but under this account the case-marking facts still need to be explained. The first problem with the NPs being linked by semantic case is that the absolutive is not restricted to any particular semantic class of arguments. The absolutive must at least be a default case as argued here and, in a different framework, by Simpson (1991). I will assume double linking by agreement and case. In that case, Warlpiri allows free compatibility of these two types of linkers. I will now review two possible views of ergative, as a semantic adjunct case or as a grammatical case specified [ARG|-LA]. Evidence that the ergative might be "semantic" comes from intransitives with the sole argument in the ergative (Levin (1983: 149) citing Hale (1982: (232a-d))):
Four types of case system (91)
105
a. Ngarrka-ngku ka ngungkurru-pangi-rni. man-ERG PRES snore-dig-NONPAST 'The man is snoring.' b. Kurdu-ngku ka ngaany-kiji-rni. man-ERG PRES breath-throw-NONPAST 'The child is breathing, expelling breath.' c. Kurdu-ngku ka ngal-ngal-kiji-rni. child-ERG PRES pulsing-throw-NONPAST 'The child is panting (from exhaustion).' d. Karnta-ngku ka kuntul-pi-nyi. woman-ERG PRES cough-hit-NONPAST 'The woman is coughing.'
As indicated in the glosses, these verbs are morphologically complex (nominal preverb plus verb) and denote the performance of a bodily function and so should be regarded as having agents. Most interestingly, however, Hale notes that the verbs in (91b-d) have all been found with the absolutive as well. He suggests a diachronic explanation that the preverb is historically an incorporated nominal and that the verbs are changing towards the regular intransitive pattern. Thus all the stages would fit in with Warlpiri's being a type 3 language. To summarize, two possibilities for the ergative are as follows: (92)
a. ERG: [ARG|-LA] b. ERG: [ARG|AGENT]
While it is true that there is a loose correlation of ergative with agent of causation, if we analyze the ergative as the case for the agent, we would face the following problem: why is the ergative obligatory in transitive sentences but optional in the few intransitive sentences where it can appear? On the semantic ergative account, there is no reason to expect that only ergatives in intransitves will alternate with the absolutive. The correlation of the alternation with intransitivity is left unexplained. Second, if the ergative is a semantic case, it does not seem to pick out a natural semantic class. Nash notices that, in traditional thematic role terminology, the ergative marks agents ((82), (90), (91)) and experiencers of perception: (93)
Ngatjulu-rlu ka-rna-ngku I-ERG
'I see you.'
njuntu
nja-nji.
PRES-lSgNOM-2sgACC yOU(ABS) See-NONPAST
106 A typology of case systems Thus if all ergatives in Warlpiri are semantic, the range is unexpected, or else we need multiple semantic uses of the ergative. The problem still is why we do not get more ergatives on intransitives, if those intransitives qualify for a semantic ergative. Why is there no ergative in (83a) above? Warlpiri is far from being of the "active" type, where the agent gets a special case regardless of transitivity. Two solutions are possible that are compatible with the analysis of Warlpiri as type 3. The first is to follow Nash (1980) and Simpson (1991) in taking the intransitive uses .of the ergative to be quirky case for subjects, e.g. (91b) above: (94)
ngaany-kiji ( x ) 'breathe' (ERG: [ARG|1])
As noted by Levin (1983), this quirky case violates the GB approach to external argument. The obligatoriness of the transitive ergative versus the optionality of the idiosyncratic ergative can be captured by making the idiosyncratic ergative optional as in (94). The homophony of the two ergatives is historically explained. The other possible tack in the present set-up is to adopt a synchronic version of Hale's (1982) solution for this class. The morphological complexity of the verbs in (91) would be taken to reflect their ambiguity between a complex verb with two arguments and a verb with one argument: (95)
a. kiji ( x y[ngaany 'breath'] ) 'throw' b. ngaany-kiji ( x ) 'breathe'
The verb is structurally ambiguous between having two arguments one of which is incorporated into the verb (95a) and the other structure where a complex verb takes one argument. The diachronic trend is from the complex structure (95a) to the simple structure (95b). Note that in the first case the ergative will apply regularly to the first argument, because it is not the lowest, there being a lower argument. And in (95b), the absolutive must apply, since the only argument is the lowest. The optionality of the ergative in these cases is captured by the fact that there are two structures only one of which leads to ergative on the subject. The reason this is probably the less attractive of the two approaches is that this verbal compounding is no longer productive (Nash (1980: 201f.)). I do not have the data to decide between these alternatives.9 It is worth pointing out that both of them are equally compatible with the present
Four types of case system
107
theory and that both seem preferable to the "semantic" case alternative. Both the idiosyncratic case solution of Nash (1980) and Simpson (1991) and the synchronic version of Hale's (1982) solution handle the optionality of the ergative in "intransitive" contexts better than the semantic case view. If ergative is semantic everywhere, there is no reason to expect the different treatment of ergative in the two contexts. Further, the class of verbs that allows ergative in the apparent intransitive context is extremely small. If ergative is semantic, there is no reason why it should be disfavored on intransitives, but the fact is that almost all agentive intransitives take absolutive obligatorily. The two alternatives advocated here actually lead one to expect this pattern. If Nash and Simpson are right, then the rarity of the intransitive ergative follows from the marked character of idiosyncratic case. If the synchronic version of Hale's solution is correct, then the rarity of the ergative "intransitives" follows from the small number of structurally ambiguous verbs. The structural ambiguity is marked and so the apparent intransitive ergative is marked. Type 3 is the expected ergative type with default absolutive. I have argued, albeit tentatively, that Warlpiri is such a language. This is not to deny that there is an active type, and that for these languages we need an ergative of agent.10 However, some languages do seem to be type 3 and bear out the predictions above. In addition to Warlpiri, other likely type 3 languages are surveyed by Austin (1982). This wide range of Australian languages all take absolutive cognate objects and so are probably to be taken as type 3.
3.3.4 Type 4 Type 4 is the ergative-absolutive type not expected on the usual nominativeor-absolutive-as-default view. The prediction that the case with a basic ergative distribution might be the default case is not expected under most theories of syntax. If such a type exists, it would provide a striking confirmation of the typology and the theory that produces it. In this section I will analyze Kabardian, a Northwest Caucasian language, as type 4 and test the resulting predictions. It will turn out that type 4 languages should be the mirror image of type 1. The Limitation Parameter has the value no, and the preference parameter has the value high: (96)
Type 4: Limitation Parameter: No Preference Parameter: High (Bottom-Up)
108 A typology of case systems This leads to an ergative-absolutive system where the ergative behaves as a reverse type 1 accusative and the absolutive as a reverse type 1 nominative: (97)
a. b.
ABS: [ARG] ERG:
[
]
Such behavior follows from the reversal of only one of the parameters in comparison to type 1. Thus the absolutive should only appear once per clause and should mark the lowest available argument. The ergative, on the other hand, should be able to appear multiple times in accord with its default status. Furthermore, in the absence of more specific cases, the ergative should appear. Thus a range of adverbials, barring the availability of specific adverbial case, should appear in the ergative. I will argue that the Northwest Caucasian language Kabardian is of type 4. Kabardian is the name given to Eastern Adyghe (or Circassian, as Adyghe is also known). Eastern and Western Adyghe are extremely closely related and may be considered dialects of one language. Most data will come from Kuipers (1962) who describes a dialect of Kabardian, so I will use this name. The conclusions drawn for Kabardian apply equally to Adyghe generally. For some other descriptions of the language, see Kuipers (1955, 1960), Rogava and Keraseva (1966), and Catford (1976). I will assume for the purposes of the following discussion that Kabardian is syntactically accusative, but nothing depends on this. Rather, in the following, I wish to establish the relation of the ergative as default case and the absolutive as the any-argument case.11 That is, Kabardian is to be shown to be type 4 and all that that entails. Like many Caucasian languages, Kabardian has an ergative-absolutive case-marking system and verbal prefixes. In the basic transitive the subject is ergative and the object is absolutive: (98)
I's-m ss-r j man-the-ERG horse-ABS (ABs3rd)ACT-killed T h e man killed the horse.' (Kuipers (1962: 234, 238))
The linking for this sentence is the following: (99)
J9-W9h'ah§ ( x
y ) 'killed'
*ABS: [ARG] ERG:
[
]
ABS: [ARG] ERG:
[ ]
Four types of case system
109
If Kabardian is type 4, it has the high value of the Preference Parameter. This means that the LDC will question the linking of the higher of pairs of arguments. Applied to (99), this means that if the higher argument were linked by the absolutive, the structure would violate the LDC, because the higher of two arguments would be linked by a case with the same LINK value as the most restrictive case applicable to the lower argument. The use of absolutive on the lowest argument of course cannot violate the LDC. Thus we get absolutive on the lower argument but not the higher one. For the higher one, the only case that passes the AC, the LDC, and the RC is the default ergative. It applies, correctly giving us the linking for the example in (98). The reason that ergative is called "ergative" and absolutive "absolutive" is that the same case links the objects of transitives and the subjects of intransitives, and another case marks the subjects of transitives. In type 4, the reasons for this are different from those for type 3. In type 3, the ergative was limited by the specification [—LA] to appearing on arguments that are not the lowest on the argument list. Otherwise the default absolutive applies. In type 4, on the other hand, the ergative is the default. The ergative-absolutive distribution follows from the high value of the Preference Parameter and the LDC. The [ARG] case could only appear once, by the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction (a consequence of the LDC). Because the Preference Parameter is set at high, the [ARG] case could only appear on the lower of two arguments in a transitive. In an intransitive, this same case will be the most restrictive case that passes the AC for the sole argument. The [ARG] case in type 4 is not limited to lowest or highest arguments - type 4 has the value no for the Limitation Parameter. Thus in an intransitive the sole NP is absolutive and the verb agrees with the absolutive NP: (100)
i'a-r k'°-ah§. man-ABS (ABs3rd)went T h e man went.'
(Kuipers (1962: 236))
If the absolutive is 3rd person (singular or plural), as in this example, we get zero agreement. The absolutive agreement for non-third person is overt (see Kuipers (1962: 234)). In the present system, both syntactic cases are applicable to this sole argument, and so the more restrictive absolutive links the NP:
110 A typology of case systems (101)
k'°-ah§ ( x ) 'went' ABS: [ARG] ERG:
[ ]
With only one argument, the LDC is irrelevant. The RC dictates absolutive. Since the same case is used here and on the second argument of the transitive, type 4 and Kabardian in particular are called "ergativeabsolutive." As noted in the last section, such simple examples are consistent with an analysis as type 3 or type 4. Once again, the analysis of a language as of a given type makes a network of predictions. I will now show that these predictions are borne out in the case of Kabardian. Before proceeding, a note on agreement is in order. As with type 1 languages, it is not always clear whether absolutive (or nominative) is the linker and the verb agrees with the absolutive NP or whether agreement is the linker and the absolutive or nominative is the lack of case that complements this type of linking. A third possibility is that both are linkers. Which of these is the right way to analyze agreement does not affect the main point here which has to do with the interaction of this kind of linking with other forms of linking in the language. In the following, the symbol ABS abbreviates absolutive and its corresponding agreement. In Kabardian, the first agreement slot is always with the absolutive. Kabardian, like other Northwest Caucasian languages, has a wide array of other verbal agreement markers which are usually analyzed as agreement slots in the verbal complex. The other agreement morphemes will need more restrictive information, but they will also be compatible with the ergative, my main focus. The actor prefix (see (98)) I will analyze as marking the highest ergative argument (cf. agreement in South Asian languages) and so need not be considered a linker. Whether or not the other agreement markers are linkers is an open question, but, if they are, then they can be handled as follows. First the "indirect object" prefix I will treat as a standard dative of goal: (102)
IOagr: [ARG | GOAL]
I use this terminology to follow tradition without any theoretical significance. The other relevant prefixes are very much like incorporated prepositions, although their synchronic status is not clear from the literature (Kuipers (1955: 202)). They must be more restrictive than the ergative, but they are all compatible with it.
Four types of case system
111
The first prediction, the Argument Linker Dissimilation Prediction, when applied to Kabardian under the type 4 analysis, yields the expectation that no co-arguments are both absolutive. From the sources available, this seems to be correct. Rather, wherever we might get two absolutives, i.e. where there are two co-arguments, the higher should appear ergative. This was true of the simple transitive. I will now show that it is true of many other sentence types as well. As far as the ergative is concerned, we have two predictions. The first is the Default Linker Non-Dissimilation Prediction, which means that multiple ergatives per clause are in principle possible. If two or more co-arguments are not subject to any lexical cases, all but one must be ergative. The first piece of evidence that ergative is the default is that in ditransitives the goal is ergative. Kabardian does not have a case for goals, although it does have goal agreement (see (102) above). In a ditransitive, we will have three arguments, none of which is eligible for a lexical case. In such a clause, the theory leads us to predict ERG-ERG-ABS, and this is precisely what we get: (103)
I'a-m ss-r f6z9-m jarajtahs. man-the-ERG horse-ABS woman-ERG (su3rd)IO-ACT-gave 'The man gave the horse to the woman.' (Kuipers (1962: 238))
The linking for this sentence follows directly. Recall that IOagr and ergative case are compatible: (104)
give ( x
y|GOAL
*ABS
IOagr
ERG
*ABS
z) ABS ERG
ERG
For all three arguments, the most restrictive applicable linker of the type case is absolutive. The LDC in Kabardian will question and reject the absolutive on each of the two higher arguments, because the absolutive is the most restrictive linker of that type (case) that passes the AC for the lowest argument. The absolutive is more restrictive than the ergative, so where the LDC does not rule it out, here on the lowest argument, it will have priority by the RC. For the higher two arguments, the only remaining case is the default ergative, which applies to both arguments.12 Goal agreement is not the only verbal agreement marker which is compatible with the ergative case. The prepositional agreement mor-
112 A typology of case systems phemes are also compatible with the ergative. For instance, a comitative (105a) or benefactive (105b) prefix co-occurs with ergative nominals: (105)
a. I'a-m s9-da-lazah§. man-the-ERG su 1 st-coM(3rd)-worked 'I worked (together) with the man.' (Kuipers (1962: 238)) b. I's-m s3-x°a-lazahs. man-the-ERG su 1 st-BEN(3rd)-worked 'I worked for (in the interest of) the man.' (Kuipers (1962: 238))
One question that immediately arises is whether the benefactives and comitatives are arguments (original arguments or promoted from adjunct) or adjuncts. I will assume that they are adjuncts in view of their free omissability and more importantly their apparent free addability: (106)
lazahs ( x ) 'worked' ABS
da- ( y ) 'together with' ERG
ERG
The comitative adjunct predicate is incorporated into the verb with the comitative morpheme occupying a slot in the verbal complex. Since this comitative NP is not a verbal argument, only the default may apply. In Kabardian the default is the ergative, and so we get ergative comitatives (and similarly ergative benefactives). These last examples also provide evidence for the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction. Adjunct NPs are likely to be marked ergative, and, in the absence of some case to block them, have to be ergative. The comitatives and benefactives are such adjuncts. They have a verbal agreement marker, but this does not preclude case, and so they must get default case, i.e. ergative. The two predictions about the default, the repeatability and Elsewhere predictions, are even more strikingly supported by "semantic" uses of the ergative, where there is no corresponding verbal prefix. In these sentence types, there is no verbal prefix targeting the ergative NP in question, but the ergative appears on the NP. Adjuncts, if they are not linked by a relatively restrictive linker incompatible with case, are eligible for ergative and receive it. The comitatives and benefactives demonstrated possible double linking of adjuncts by prefix and ergative. I now turn to ergative acting as the sole linker of an adjunct.
Four types of case system
113
The ergative applies whenever there is no case at all for the adjunct. I now review adjunct linking where there is no verbal prefix. First, the ergative can link what would be translated by an (in) to PP in English: (107)
a. q'ahla-m mahk'°a. town-ERG (su3rd)goes 'He goes to the town.' b. maza-m jahh. forest-ERG ACT-(ABs3rd)carry They carry it to the forest.'
(Kuipers (1962: 238))
(Kuipers (1962: 238))
Similarly, the ergative can mark an NP denoting the time at which an event occurs: (108)
har za$9-m mabahna. dog-ABS night-ERG (ABs3rd)barks T h e dog barks at night.'
(Kuipers (1962: 238))
The ergative also marks the "object of comparison" with no corresponding verbal prefix: (109)
1'a-r faza-m naxra nax"6z$. man-ABS woman-ERG older (ABs3rd)is T h e man is older than the woman.'
(Kuipers (1962: 238))
The sentence in (108) with the ergative time-at-which adjunct receives the following analysis: (110)
mabahna ( x ) 'bark' ABS
Adverb ( y ) ERG
ERG
In the verb's argument structure there is one argument. The absolutive, as the more restrictive case, wins. The only case that can link the adjunct is the ergative default, since apparently there is no preposition or case meaning 'at.' At least, if there is such a preposition, it is optional. When such a preposition does not apply, the theory predicts the ergative must apply. Either way, the theory correctly predicts the ergative here and similarly for the other adverbial constructions. Note that Kabardian poses a problem for GB Case Theory. If ergative is the surface manifestation of an Abstract Case, this Case is assigned to a class of NPs that do not form a natural class under normal GB assumptions. In GB the thematically highest NP is generated outside VP or more
114 A typology of case systems recently outside V'. At any rate, the external argument is supposed to get the INFL case. If the INFL case is absolutive then it is a mystery why the external argument is ergative in transitives. If the ergative is the INFL case then it is not clear why we can get more than one ergative per clause or why ergatives should appear without agreement. Ergatives on adjuncts would also be a mystery. The present account actually predicts that a language like Kabardian should exist. The absolutive only appears once, but the ergative can appear more than once on co-arguments, as predicted by the LDC interacting with the specifications making absolutive the argument case and ergative the default case. The range of ergative NPs receives a unified treatment. In this section I have demonstrated that Kabardian is an excellent candidate for type 4. Other Northwest Caucasian languages seem to have multiple ergatives (Comrie (1981: 209)) and so should probably be analyzed as type 4. Thus the most unexpected type and the one which rounds out the typology of two-case systems has been found. The theory allows an elegant and unified solution to some very problematic data. 3.3.5 Summary In this section I have shown that the theory of case outlined in §3.1 induces a typology of two-linker systems on the basis of two simple parameters. I have further shown that all the predicted types occur and that they show exactly the Case behavior expected on the present theory. Finally, I would like to consider possible directions for further crosslinguistic work. Some of the predictions made here are based on likelihood. If a given case is the default case for a given language, it is likely to occur more than once per clause, and it is a good candidate for a general purpose adjunct case. Further testing of these predictions is required, but the initial indications above are promising. Note that this is a generalization of an observation suggested by Poser (p.c.) that languages with a double accusative constraint (like Japanese) tend not to have adverbial accusatives. We can now extend this generalization to all the four cases in all the four types. The [ARG] case should show LDC effects, and, since it is limited to arguments, it is not a candidate for general purpose adjunct case. In languages with two grammatical cases, it should be the other, default, grammatical case that shows Elsewhere behavior. By providing cross-linguistic definitions of case based on independently motivated features and by embedding the definitions in a systematic theory of linking,
Split ergativity 115 we get for each language an explanatory account of a wide range of facts. Specific constraints can be seen to follow from universal principles. 3.4
Split ergativity
As touched upon in the previous section, most ergative languages are not uniformly ergative but rather are "split ergative": some classes of NPs show ergative-absolutive marking but other classes show a nominativeaccusative pattern. The "split" may be conditioned by a number of factors.13 Some split ergative languages have a split between an ergative-absolutive system for one set of NP types and a nominativeaccusative system for another set of NP types (those higher on the hierarchy of features). Other split systems are conditioned by properties of the verb or the clause. The system developed so far can handle such systems at least as well as previous theories and may have some special advantages. It is also well known since Silverstein (1976) that some classes of NPs are implicationally more likely to show a nominative-accusative pattern. For example, if pronouns and nouns denoting humans show an ergativeabsolutive pattern then other nouns will. NPs can be ranked on an implicational scale or "hierarchy of ergativity" with pronouns and human-denoting NPs on the "least ergative" end of the hierarchy. The question of course is whether the system outlined in the previous sections can be naturally extended to handle split-NP ergativity. I will outline first a conventional solution which has the same advantages and disadvantages of analogous solutions in other theories. I will then turn to a less conventional solution which draws on the unique strengths of the present approach. First, split systems demand that the two parameters suggested at the outset of this chapter need to be set in a more refined way than I indicated. In general, a language will have to be able to have multiple values of the parameters depending on just those sets of factors that condition case splits (for discussions of case splits, see, for example, Silverstein (1976), Dixon (1979)). So, for instance, Warlpiri is type 3 in nouns, but it is nominative-accusative in its pronouns and agreement markers/verbal clitics. Thus, for a complete account of Warlpiri, we would need to set the values of the parameters differently for different NP classes. The range of such features that can be relevant to case marking suggests another modification to our approach. So far, I have assumed that
116 A typology of case systems linking is done in the lexicon. Argument structures are assigned linkers freely and then subjected to the three constraints. Surface realization must conform to the information contained in the fully specified argument structures, including the information from linking (expressed in the AVM formalism by the value REAL). If an argument is linked by dative at argument structure, it must correspond to a dative NP in PS Structure. The checking between argument structure and PS is maximally simple, because all the work of linking is done at argument structure itself. The problem comes with split systems and other case marking that makes reference to features that are more plausibly characteristic of lexical items than of argument structure. We will see this more in the next chapter (§4.1.2) with Nama linking. To do linking at argument structure in Nama, we will need to specify clause level properties like declarativeness. Verbs may be specified for declarativeness. But the real question is the split systems. If we are to handle a split by noun versus pronoun at argument structure, we would have to freely instantiate features for pronounhood and nounhood on the arguments and generate a case frame for each of the possible combinations of pronouns and nouns. The potential for redundancy is very great. One way out is to have linking occur "after" lexical insertion, as in Kiparsky (1987).14 In the present theory, the only change this would entail from our previous practice would be to treat each of our three main constraints as constraints on lexical insertion. Items would be freely inserted and then checked against the AC, the LDC, and the RC. The AC would refer to applicability not just of the linkers' LINK value in comparison with the argument structure (as above) but also with inherent features of the NP. So a case, say ergative, limited to nouns would be checked both against the argument and the NP it links. The problem, of course, is to limit the number of such features that can be checked. I leave this open for further work. On the lexical insertion approach, the LDC would check pairings of inserted NPs and arguments to make sure there is no higher argument with the linker on that argument-NP pair as its most restrictive possibility of that type. And the RC similarly would check inserted items and their associated arguments for other more restrictive and otherwise legal Unkings. If any are found, the whole structure is out. I leave it open which of the two approaches, linking at argument structure and linking after lexical insertion, is preferable in the long run. What I am developing here is equally compatible with either view.
Split ergativity
117
Because none of the data I examine directly requires the lexical insertion approach, I will for simplicity's sake still speak in terms of linking at argument structure. Before turning to three case systems and a less conventional approach to NP split ergativity, I will first demonstrate for the sake of illustration how the present system can incorporate a conventional feature-based approach to split ergativity and what advantages the present system has. The feature-based approach seems to be most inescapable with splits conditioned on tense and/or aspect. The analysis here is meant as purely illustrative and I do not pretend to make strong claims about this particular analysis. I will use some simple examples from Georgian, a South Caucasian (Kartvelian) language which has an ergative-absolutive system with verbs in the aorist tense, and a nominative-accusative system for present tense verbs (data are from Comrie (1978: 351f.)):15 (Ill)
a. Student-i midis. student-NOM goes T h e student goes.' b. Student-i ceril-s cers. student-NOM letter-Ace writes T h e student writes a letter.' c. Student-i mivida. student-ABS went The student went.' d. Student-ma ceril-i dacera. student-ERG letter-ABS wrote T h e student wrote the letter.'
Note that the same ending, -/, is used both as an absolutive case in the ergative-absolutive system and as a nominative case in the nominativeaccusative system. Although there seems to be no way of avoiding introducing tense into linking on any theory, the present theory does have the advantage of allowing the morphological -/ to correspond to one case regardless of the label:
118 A typology of case systems (112)
a. ERG:
ARG
(-ma)
-LA
b. ACC:
ARG —HA
c. NOM/ABS: [
(-0
Note again that default for linking is not necessarily the same as morphological zero case (or alternatively, lack of case), especially since none of the cases in Georgian is a zero case. This default case need not be specified for tense or aspect. Only the other two cases have to have some additional feature or other provision to limit their occurrence to verbs of a particular tense. This can be done by specifying the cases for tense, but I have not done this in (112). Rather, the arguments they are to unify with must also be specified for tense. Alternatively we could use a feature co-occurrence restriction (FCR), stated as a material conditional, mandating present tense when ergative case is used for linking, i.e. prohibiting any feature structure from containing the path [SUBCATJREAL|ERG] and [TENSE|PRES]:16 (113)
[SUBCAT|REAL|ERG] D [TENSE |AOR]
(114)
[SUBCAT|REAL|ACC] D [TENSE |PRES]
The FCR in (113) will rule out the following AVM and any it subsumes, because [TNS [PRES]] and [TNS [AOR]] are incompatible:
(115)
17
CAT [V] TNS [PRES] SUBCAT [REAL [ERG]]
This gets us the restriction that ergative case will only show up with verbs in the aorist tense. Similarly, the FCR for accusative case will ensure that anywhere we find accusative we find the present tense verb. The main advantage of the present system consists in its ability to capture the identity of cases across the split of a system. For the rest, a feature-based analysis will be required, as in other theories. 3.5
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
The foregoing sections have explained the typology of two-case systems predicted on the present theory and shown that the predicted types actually occur. Two-case systems, however, do not exhaust the possibilities
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
119
of the theory, nor do they represent a limit of the data for there are a number of languages with what must be analyzed as a system of three grammatical cases.18
3.5.1 Three-case systems: Diyari So far the discussion has centered on the question of whether "the" ARG case has the further limitation to [—LA] (type 2 accusative) or [-HA] (type 3 ergative). But the system would allow us to have a language in which there is both an ARG case and an ARG case limited by [—LA] or [—HA]. We have already noted that when dealing with two-case systems, it does not matter whether [—LA] or [-HA] are taken to be values dependent on [ARG] or on [LINK] directly. The reason is that the LDC just compares linkers on the basis of identity versus non-identity of their LINK values: (116)
Linking Dissimilation Constraint: Given two co-arguments, x and y, x higher than y, if y is linked by a linker B that has the same LINK value as the most restrictive linker of that type applicable by the AC to x, call it A, and there is a less restrictive linker C, applicable by the AC to y, then the linking is ill-formed.
Thus the following two cases will not show dissimilation effects with respect to each other; that is, the use of one will not preclude the use of the other: (117)
a. X: [ARG|-LA]
b. Y:
[ARG]
In two-case systems only one of these cases is present, in addition to the default case. But in three-case systems, we do want these two cases. Now it matters whether these cases dissimilate. In the following I will examine only cases where these cases, while separate, do dissimilate. I do not claim that this is the only possibility.19 However, a fully general LDC which would provide for both languages which do have distinct but dissimilating [ARG] cases (see note 18) and those that have distinct but nondissimilating cases would be based not on identity of LINK value but something like following: (118)
Distinctness: Two Linkers A and B are distinct if and only if the LINK value of each contains a path not found in the other. Otherwise they are non-distinct.
120 A typology of case systems Thus, among the following, X is distinct from X' and Y r , but, most importantly, X' is not distinct from Y: (119)
a. X: [ARG|-LA]
b. X':
[ARC
[-LA c. Y:
[ARG]
Since the only path in the LINK value of Y, namely [ARG], is also contained in the LINK value of X', the two linkers are non-distinct. They will therefore not dissimilate under the revised LDC: (120)
Linking Dissimilation Constraint: Given two co-arguments, x and y, y higher or lower than x, if y is linked by a linker B that is not distinct from the most restrictive linker of that type applicable by the AC to x, and there is a less restrictive linker C, applicable by the AC to y, then the linking is disallowed.
The only difference in the new LDC is that dissimilation is based on nondistinctness as defined above, rather than on identity as earlier. Thus the X case above will dissimilate with the Y case, but the X' case will not dissimilate with Y. 20 The system now provides for three-case systems. One case will be the default, one the plain [ARG] case and the other the limited ARG case, i.e. [ARG|— XA] instantiated as [ARG|— HA] or [ARG|-LA] depending on how the Preference Parameter is set. In the following I will concentrate on the latter possibility, i.e.: (121)
a. ERG: TARG
[-LA b. c.
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
Note that restrictiveness strictly orders this inventory of three cases. The reason I have labelled (121a-c) "ERG," "NOM," and "ACC," respectively, will become apparent once we consider how they would interact: (122)
( x } intransitive NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity (123)
121
y ) transitive
(x ERG:
\ARG
1
*NOM: [ARG]
[-LAJ NOM: [ARG] ACC:
ACC:
[
]
[ ]
To the sole argument of an intransitive verb, only the nominative and the accusative can apply, since the other case, the ergative, cannot appear on lowest arguments. It can apply to the higher of the two arguments of the transitive, and since it is the most restrictive and passes the LDC (the value low is selected for the Preference Parameter). On the remaining argument of the transitive, the nominative and the accusative pass the AC but the accusative must apply since the NOM would violate the LDC. This is because the NOM is non-distinct from the most restrictive case applicable to the higher argument, the ERG. There are languages with three distinct case forms for some class of nominals, and for such languages, a three-case system is called for. One such language is Diyari (Austin (1981), Goddard (1982)) where female personal names, derived dual and plural common nouns, singular first and second person pronouns, and third person pronouns of all numbers have three distinct case forms. These are labelled "A" (mnemonic for transitive subject or - loosely - "agent"), and " O " (for object), " S " (for intransitive subject). Contrast the non-feminine ('nF') singular pronouns in the following (Austin (1981: 241)): (124)
a. tinka-ni nulu nayi-yi parati/ tudu night-LOC 3sg.nFA see-PRES light-ABS fire-ABS y arki-y arki-1 adi-nani REDUP-bum-DUR-RELds
'In the night he saw the light of the fire burning.' b. rjada-ni pulali nina warara-yi patara miri then-LOC 3DIA 3sg.nFO leave-PRES box tree above Then they left him at the top of the box tree.' c. nawu miri-ta tara-irja-na tadi-yi 3sg.nFS above-OI go UP-PROL-PART -PRES
'He went up and up at the top (of the tree).' These forms are also often labelled "ergative" for the case which appears on transitive subject nouns of those classes; "accusative" for the case of object nouns of those classes; and "ergative" for the case which appears
122 A typology of case systems on transitive subject nouns of those classes. The analysis of these sentences would be along the lines of (122) and (123): (122) is the analysis for (124c), and (123) for (124a,b). Other nominals do not show three distinct forms. The morphology of these other nominal classes seems to be on an ergative-absolutive pattern with a zero ending for the S and the O and an ending -// (or -yali), for A. Goddard (1982) argues that the best analysis of this situation is not to say that this second group of NPs has a different case system but rather that it too has a three-case system with syncretism between the S (nominative) and the O (accusative). This results in an "absolutive" pattern that is merely an artifact of the syncretism of forms, not an aspect of the system. Goddard is careful (as many are not) to distinguish between case forms and (morphological) "case systems." These case systems are systems of morphological oppositions and are defined as substitution classes of nominals. There is no reason why a morphological case cannot be defined more abstractly than as the collection of instances of an identical ending. To illustrate how uncontroversial such morphological analyses are, Goddard points out that the traditional analysis of Indo-European languages provides for three cases for all nouns even if one class of them, neuter nouns, never shows a surface distinction between nominative and accusative. Masculine and feminine nouns show a distinction between nominative and accusative (in fact both in the singular and the plural), but neuter nouns never have distinct forms for nominative and accusative: neuter nouns have one form for the singular of both the nominative and accusative and one form for the plural of those cases, e.g. penculum 'danger' (nom/acc sg) and pencula 'dangers' (nom/acc pi). Nonetheless morphological analyses of Latin (and other Indo-European languages with a nominative-accusative distinction on some noun class(es)) have a neuter nominative and a neuter accusative, which happen to sound the same. The test is substitution: substitute (or in the case of a dead language, look for an example of) a noun from one of the classes that does show a distinction and one can "tell" which case the neuter noun bears morphologically, but covertly. According to Goddard's (1982: 169) definition, a case is "a class of nominal forms which are mutually substitutable in certain syntactic or semantic environments given that any two cases, casei and casej, are formally distinguished by at least one subclass of nominals." Interchangeability as a criterion of case facilitates the statement of morphological patterns.
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
123
In fact, there are, according to Goddard, good reasons for preferring a more abstract analysis of the system in languages like Diyari as follows: all nominals have the three-case system but not all have three distinct forms. Some have only two. This analysis follows from the substitution class definition of case. If we substitute a dual nominal which does have three distinct case forms, then we can "tell" which case a given nondistinct nominal has but does not exhibit directly: (126)
f yula 1 \ yunduj
fkintala 1 \ kintala-wula-naj
nanda-na wara-yi
J 2du(ERG) 1 J dog(ACC) 1 hit-PART AUX PRES \ 2sgERG J [2-du-ACC J 'You two/you(sg) hit the dog/two dogs.' Here in each of the NP positions we can substitute for an endingless pronoun (yula) or noun (kintala) one that does show three distinct forms. Thus we can say, based on the substitution test that yula here is ergative even though in the context of an intransitive sentence, the same surface-ambiguous second person singular form yula would be replaceable with the unambiguously nominative second person singular form yini. Thus by the substitution test, the yula in (126) is morphologically ergative and the yula in an intransitive is morphologically nominative despite the lack of a surface opposition. The three-case analysis has several major advantages. Goddard points out that the three-case analysis makes the treatment of certain constructions much more straightforward. First, there is a construction found in many Australian languages including Diyari, in which an NP denoting something possessed as an inalienable part of the person or thing possessing it appears next to the NP denoting the possessor and appears marked for the same syntactic function (Austin (1981: 138)). On Goddard's analysis some NPs have a three-way case distinction and some an ergativeabsolutive distinction. Goddard (1982: 172) points out that the generalization can be stated more simply on a uniform three-case analysis: both NPs appear in the same case (Austin (1981: exs. 286, 287); Goddard (1982: exs. 2-3)):
124 A typology of case systems (127)
a. nulu
feana
mara]
nanda-na wara-yi
3sg.nF-ERG lsg-ACC hand(ACc) hit-PART AUX-PRES
'He hit my hand.' b. [yini milki] fanma-yi-la 2sgNOM eye(NOM) be-open-PRES-Ni
'Your eyes are open now.' In (127a), mara 'hand' is in the accusative just as unambiguous rjana 'me' is. Similarly in (127b), milki 'eye' is in the same case as unambiguous yini 'you'. The three-case analysis is even more advantageous in the pronoun-asdeterminer construction. In Diyari, a third-person pronoun in front of a common noun may form an NP interpreted definitely. Third-person pronouns have three distinct forms but common nouns do not. On the uniform three-case analysis the "definite" NP can be analyzed as consisting of two elements with the same case and can in turn be analyzed as having that single case (Austin (1981: exs. 176, 181); Goddard (1982: exs. 4-5)): (128)
a. [nawu kana] wapa-yi 3sg.nF.NOM man(NOM) go-PRES 'The man is going.' b. nulu pulana [nina putu] yirjki-na wara-yi 3sg.nF.ERG 3duAcc 3sg.nF.ACC thing(ACc) give-PART AUX-PRES 'He gave them that thing.'
On the analysis with three cases for some noun classes and two cases (ergative, absolutive for others - absolutive covering what on the uniform three-case analysis is analyzed as covert nominative and accusative) the "definite N P " in (128a) would be made up of a pronoun in nominative case and a noun in absolutive case. What's worse, what case does the NP as a whole have? On the three-case analysis one can simply say that both parts and the whole have nominative case. Similarly in (128b) the straightforward accusative for both constituents of the bracketed NP and the NP itself would, on the conventional split-system analysis, involve an NP of hard-to-decide case consisting of an accusative pronoun and an absolutive noun. 21 This morphological analysis, if accepted, does have syntactic consequences on the present theory. Recalling that "direct" linking is direct in the sense that difference of morphological case implies difference of
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
125
syntactic case, the three-case linking system is the appropriate analysis for languages like Diyari. Before turning to Goddard's extension of the three-case analysis to some split-ergative systems, it is worth pointing out that the three-case analysis within the present approach accounts very nicely for certain additional facts of Diyari. First, according to the analysis above, the default case in Diyari is accusative, as in type 1 languages. Indeed, Diyari would be of type 1 if it were not for the "additional" ergative case. Since accusative is the default, we have at least a weak expectation that accusative should occur multiple times per clause and that accusative should be the case on adverbials in a heterogeneous "elsewhere" pattern. Both expectations are fulfilled in Diyari. First, one can get multiple accusatives per clause. In fact ditransitives have double accusative. Although this could be the result of accusative dative-accusative homophony, the present system can handle a sentence like that in the previous example: (129)
(x ERG:
IARG f
z ) ditransitive
*NOM: [ARG]
*NOM: [ARG]
—LA
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
y
[ ]
ACC:
[
7
ACC:
f
J
As with the transitive, the use of the ergative is required by the RC on the first argument, precluding (by the LDC) its use on the lower arguments. On each of these the default accusative is the only remaining alternative. A wide and heterogeneous class of adverbs in Diyari arguably gets accusative case. Austin (1981: 116) provides a list of intransitive verbs that take a complement often called a "cognate object":22 (130)
rjani [nina-ya yawada] yata-yi lsgNOM 3sg.nF.Acc-NEAR language-Ace speak-PRES 'I speak this language.'
One can easily tell that this is an intransitive verb with an extra complement, since the subject pronoun which has three distinct case forms is in the form for subjects of intransitives (S rather than A or O on Austin's analysis). On Austin's analysis the other (bracketed) NP here would consist of an accusative pronoun and an absolutive noun. Again, Goddard's (1982) across-the-board three-case analysis allows us to analyze the entire NP and all its constituents as being accusative. Note that
126 A typology of case systems accusative is the default case in this system and is appearing on cognate objects, as in many type 1 languages. The accusative also shows a default pattern in being used on a heterogeneous class of adverbs and in being the case that takes over when a more specific case is optional. First Austin (1981: 110) shows that many adjectives and noun-plus-adjective combinations may function as adverbs without any ending: (131)
kanku nawu miri kari-yi pita-ni boy-NOM 3sg.nF.NOM above climb-PRES tree-LOC 'The boy is climbing up above in the tree.'
The same word can be part of the locative NP with a slight difference in meaning: (132)
kanku nawu kari-yi pita miri-ni boy-NOM 3sg.nF.NOM climb-PRES tree above-LOC 'The boy is climbing in the top of the tree.'
Austin (1981: 110) further notes that in this latter sentence the LOC -ni "can be deleted with apparently no change in meaning." On the present analysis, this is a typical instance of a more restrictive but optional adverbial case giving way to the default case when the more restrictive option is not taken. This is strong additional evidence for the accusative as a default case in Diyari. Tentatively, we can conclude that the present system is equipped to handle three-case systems quite well. 3.5.2 Split ergativity revisited: quasi-split ergativity The three-case system can also form the basis for an analysis of split NP ergativity. Goddard (1982) proposed such an approach for split NP ergativity, and his analysis can be easily adopted in the present scheme, since three-case systems are provided for already. What Goddard proposes is to extend his "uniform" analysis of languages like Diyari with a split between nouns that show three case forms and those that show two to other languages that show an ergative-absolutive form for some noun types and a nominative-accusative distinction for others. No one noun class shows three forms - indeed all show only two - but Goddard argues that all have three cases (nominative, ergative, and accusative) with one set of nouns having syncretism of nominative and accusative, yielding a (misleading) ergative-absolutive pattern and the other class with syncretism of ergative and nominative, thus showing what merely
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
127
appears to be a nominative-accusative pattern. Again, the substitution test is used to tell which case an "ambiguous" NP covertly bears. Goddard demonstrates the advantages of such an approach with data on split NP ergativity from the Yankunytjatjara dialect of the Western Desert Language, another Australian language. The pattern of marking for nominals is the following: (133)
Common nouns
Proper nouns, kin names
Pronouns, anaphors
A -ngku -lu 0 S 0 -nya 0 O 0 -nya -nya Yankunytjatjara case endings (vowel final stems) (Goddard (1982: 179)) On a conventional analysis, all but the anaphors and pronouns would be analyzed as having an ergative and an absolutive (albeit with different endings), and the anaphors and pronouns would have nominative and accusative. Goddard (1982: 179), however, proposes a three-case analysis for Yankunytjatjara despite the fact that no one class of nominals shows three distinct forms. According to Goddard's definition of (morphological) case based on interchangeability, ergative is defined as the case on the class of nominals for which a common noun with the suffix -ngku could be substituted. Similarly, accusative is the case on the class of nominals for which a pronoun suffixed with -nya could be substituted. As for nominative, Goddard notes that nominative case is the class of forms for which either an unmarked pronoun or an unmarked noun can be substituted and notes that this same class of forms appears in the context of citation and in predication. Using his definition of morphological case, Goddard defines nominative in Yankunytjatjara as "a class of forms mutually substitutable in certain syntactic environments (intransitive subject, citation, predicate nominal); nominative and accusative case (casej) are formally distinguished by one subclass of nominals, namely pronouns, and similarly nominative and ergative are formally distinguished by one subclass of nominals, namely nouns" (Goddard (1982: 180)).23 The advantages to a three-case analysis for seemingly split ergative Yankunytjatjara are similar to those for seemingly split 3case/2case Diyari. Analogous constructions receive similarly simple statement under the three-case analysis. First, for "inalienable possession," the
128
A typology of case systems
statement of the similarity between the NP denoting the possessum and the NP denoting the possessor can be directly in terms of identity of case whether accusative (134a), locative (LOC) (134b) or purposive (PURP) (134c): (134)
a. Katja-lu wangka ngayi-nya kuli-ntja wiya. son-ERG talk(Acc) lsg.Acc listen-NOML NEG '(My) son doesn't heed my words.' b. Punpun tjuta wati-ngka mara-ngka nyina-ni. fly many(NOM) man-LOC hand-LOC sit-PRES 'There are a lot of flies on the man's hand.' c. Ngayulu Yami-ku yunpa-ku ngurpa-ri-ngu. lsgNOM Yami-PURP face-PURP ignorant-iNCHO-PAST 'I forgot Yami's face.'
Similarly, in the "phrasal conjunction" of NPs in Yankunytjatjara, a three-case analysis allows one to state the rule more simply. Phrasal conjunction is the placement after one or more nominals of a pronoun of a number subsuming that of the preceding elements. The rule on Goddard's three-case analysis is that the initial words and the final pronoun must be of the same case: (135)
a. [Nyuntu 2sg(NOM)
ngali]
ya-nu.
ldu(NOM) gO-PAST
'You and I went.' b. [Kanytji-nya ngali]
ya-nu.
Kanytji(NOM) ldu(NOM) go-PAST
'Kanytji and I went.' c. Ngayulu [Kanytji-la lsg(NOM) Kanytji-LOC
tjana-la] nyina-ngi. 3pl-LOC
Sit-PAST.IMPERF
'I stayed with Kanytji and the others.' d. Wati-ngku [nyuntu-nya ngali-nya] nya-ngu. man-ERG 2sg.Acc ldu-Acc see-PAST 'The man saw you and me.' On a conventional two-case analysis, for instance, (135b) would have to be analyzed as having an absolutive NP (Kanytji-nya) and a nominative pronoun (ngali), whereas on the three-case analysis they match - both are nominative (see the table in (133)).24 If the three-case analysis of at least some split ergative languages is on the right track, the scheme developed in the present chapter can incorpo-
Three-case systems and quasi-split ergativity
129
rate these insights very easily. We have seen how the system allows for three-case systems. These three case-linkers specify the morphological form for an NP based on linking properties like argumenthood and not-being-the-lowest-argument. There is no barrier in this system to syncretism of morphological cases of the sort argued for by Goddard. We just use a three-linker analysis - one linker for each of the morphological cases proposed by Goddard. These cases show some syncretism. Note that this does not weaken the system here in the slightest. Most of the time, the morphological analysis is not controversial as far as number of cases goes. But even where the morphological analysis is not so straightforward, each of the approaches has consequences for linking. If two NPs are (morphologically) analyzed as having the same case they may involve different linkers, but if two NPs are analyzed as having different cases we cannot say they are linked by the same case. In fact if we adopt the Goddard analysis we have to use a three-linker analysis. Morphology constrains the theory of linking; morphological analysis will make a difference to the linking analysis.
4
Linker interactions
This chapter will be devoted to the interaction of various aspects of morphosyntax. First I will continue with some implications of the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction for linker interaction. The default is supposed to apply whenever nothing else can. The strongest evidence for the default status of any case is when its opportunities for application form as unnatural a class as possible. The choice is between, on the one hand, positing a very unlikely set of homophonous cases (or other linker type) which just happen to fill in all the gaps of the other linkers and, on the other, simply positing a default linker. The second type of interaction examined in this chapter will be between the valence-changing operations known as passive and antipassive and the linkers. The question is whether the system as it stands will predict the correct case even under circumstances of changed valence. Section 4.2 will show that a suppression view of the passive and the present theory of case interact to give exactly the right derived case frames. I will then extend the discussion, which has so far concentrated mostly on case (and to a limited degree on agreement), to linking by word-order position. I will present an analysis of a language that relies primarily on word-order position, English. Finally, it will be shown that the present system is equipped to handle the interaction of case and configuration in oblique and non-oblique contexts.
4.1
Other elsewhere patterns
The Elsewhere Pattern Prediction has further implications which I would like to turn to now. The nature of a default is that it applies in the complement of the places where anything else applies. So if we have a default, another syntactic case, lexical cases, and a range of adjunct cases, then the default case applies in the complement of the conjunction of the domains of all the other cases. In other words, the default's actual 130
Other elsewhere patterns
131
domain of application is determined by the nature and inventory of all the other linkers. I noted above that it would be possible though uneconomical to have separate cases for all the uses of the default. So in Icelandic, which is type 1, we could of course have a range of adverbial accusatives. If we assume that the accusative is the default, we can explain the fact that accusative marks adverbials but nominative does not, an otherwise unexplained fact. Further, we can explain why accusative but not nominative is repeatable and why accusative adverbials correlate cross-linguistically with accusatives that can be used with more than one co-argument. And these predictions generalize to the defaults of languages of the other types. But there is another compelling reason why the accusative of type 1, the nominative of type 2, the absolutive of type 3, and the ergative of type 4 should be regarded as the default. This is because in languages with a very unusual domain for their other cases, the default (as I am analyzing it) applies in exactly the complement of this unconventional distribution. The first of these is optionality. If a wide range of adjunct cases are optional, the accusative is predicted to apply just in case the more restrictive optional case does not. The second area where the default analysis is desirable is where the other, i.e. [ARG], case has an unusual restriction causing it to fail to apply in certain contexts. Here too, we predict that the accusative or other default will apply. The fact that it does is striking confirmation for the restrictiveness-based approach. 4.1.1
Optional adjunct cases
Optionality of an adjunct case is the perfect testing ground for the restrictiveness-based approach. The theory predicts that when any linker X is optional and the no-X option is taken, then the next most restrictive linker must apply. Applied to adjuncts the predictions are particularly clear. For adjuncts the only linkers that could apply are the special very restrictive adjunct case and the default, e.g. accusative in type 1. Recall that the [ARG] linker cannot apply, because by definition it is restricted to arguments and so cannot even pass the AC for adjuncts. Other cases that are restricted to arguments (argument category cases, idiosyncratic cases with verbs) similarly are not applicable to adjuncts. This means when an adjunct case is optional the default is predicted to apply.1 I now present examples of this. The alternation of accusative with prepositions on adjuncts is quite common in Greek. Thus for the accusative of respect, repeated here in
132 Linker interactions (1), one can have the preposition eis 'to,' kata 'according to,' pros 'for' and dative alone: (1)
(2)
(3)
deinoi de makhen terrible(NOM.pl) PTCL battle(Acc) 'terrible in battle'
{KQsch.Pers.21)
pr6tos eis eupsuchian first regarding good-courage(ACc) 'first in good courage'
(Aesch.Pers.326)
en mekei kai platei kai bathei in height(DAT) and breadth(DAT) and depth(DAT) 'in (with respect to) height and breadth and width'
The accusative is simply used when none of the more specific prepositions or cases is not. As noted above, the accusative in Greek can also be used for extent of time adverbials. Many other prepositions can express extent of time (Smyth (1956: §1587)). Two prepositions especially vary with the accusative: para 'for' with accusative (Smyth (1956: §1692.3.b)) and did 'through' with genitive (Smyth (1956: §1685.1.b)): (4)
(5)
para panta ton chronon throughout all(ACc) the(ACc) time(Acc) 'throughout the whole time' dia nuktos through night(GEN) 'through the night'
(D.5.2)
(X.^.4.6.22)
Both these prepositions emphasize the uninterrupted nature of the action or state denoted by the verb. However, truth conditionally, they probably contribute in the same way as the accusative; accusative NPs of duration also imply uninterrupted action or state. Not surprisingly, the accusative is the unmarked case. The default accusative should not contribute to the meaning, other than allowing the NP it attaches to to be linked. The accusative does not constrain the interpretation itself. Note too that the prepositions that alternate with the accusative in the adverbial constructions do not all take accusative, e.g. did 'through' in the last
Other elsewhere patterns
133
example. Therefore we cannot be dealing with some kind of surface preposition deletion. Genitive of duration adverbials is not found. Another place where optionality reveals the default nature of accusative is with time-at-which adverbials. In Greek the dative is normally used for time-at-which adverbials. But in the few cases where the dative does not apply, we get accusative (Smyth (1956: §1583)). The dative in (6) alternates with the accusative in (7) (Note that (6) contains both an accusative of duration and a dative of time-at-which): (6)
tauten men ten hemeran autou emeinan that(Acc) PTCL the(ACc) day(Acc) there waited(3pl) tei de husteraiai . . . the(DAT) PTCL next(DAT) 'throughout that day they waited there, but on the following (day) . . . ' (X.H. 1.1.14)
(7)
tende ten hemeran that(ACc) the(Acc) day(Acc) 'but on that day'
(Aeschines.3.7)
Once again, a more specific adjunct case is optional, and exactly when it does not apply, the accusative appears, providing more evidence for accusative's default status in Greek. In Icelandic, the evidence from optionality is more limited. It was noted that there are a range of non-argument accusatives. In some cases, a preposition is optional with an adjunct. In this case the accusative is the other option: (8)
Eg
var J)ar (um) tvo daga. I(NOM) was there for two(Acc) days(ACc) 'I was there (for) two days.'
Similar alternations occur in German and Ukrainian (Shevelov (1963: 172)). As indicated in the gloss for the last example, a similar phenomenon occurs in English. In the next chapter I will argue that English is type 1 and that its default linker is position within the VP. The morphosyntactic feature [VP] will be assigned to NPs in the same way as accusative is in Icelandic: (9)
VP: [
]
134 Linker interactions This linker can be thought of as the equivalent of the type 1 accusative but with a different realization. Clearly adverbials can be linked by location in the VP, since they do not receive a morphological case nor do they occur with a preposition or agreement marker. If they are linked it must be by position, and by hypothesis the within-VP position: (10)
John stayed there three hours.
(11)
John drove this path.
Note that, prepositions leading to at least roughly the same meaning can be used as well: (12)
John stayed there for three hours.
(13)
John drove along this path.
As with the case-marking languages, this can be captured by the optionality of the adverbial case: (14)
Adverb ( NP ) (for: [ADJUNCT])
VP:[
]
If the /br-option is taken, the preposition applies. If the no-preposition option is taken, then the default VP-linker applies alone leading to the bare NPs in (10-11). One main advantage of the default approach over multiplying homophonous adjunct cases is that the distribution of accusative is no longer accidental. The fact that the accusative applies just when optional cases, especially adjunct cases, do not can hardly be coincidence. The recurring alternation of these cases with the default is evidence for the restrictiveness-based approach. There is also a similarity between this type of optionality and the case alternations of Chapter 2. There it was argued that relating two cases directly, e.g. lexical accusative and lexical dative, was too powerful, because it leads one to expect all sorts of non-occurring alternations, e.g. anti-DS. So too with the adjunct cases, if the adjunct cases alternate with a raft of separate adjunct accusatives rather than with one default, we should equally expect alternation of adjunct cases with other cases, like dative. These alternations do not occur systematically. The fact that the default is the case alternating on adjuncts is further confirmation of the default approach.
Other elsewhere patterns
135
4.1.2 Nama Hottentot nominal suffixation Optionality is not the only way for the conjunction of the distributions of the non-default cases to be unusual. The argument cases can have restrictions which force the default to appear in otherwise unexpected places. Nama Hottentot (Hagman (1977), Sadock (1991: 147ff.)) is one such language. Its [ARG] case has very unusual additional restrictions on its appearance. On the present theory, the default linker is predicted to apply in just those places where the [ARG] linker would apply but for its unusual restriction. Nama presents a striking confirming instance. The inventory of linkers in Nama consists of agreement, position before a "declarative particle" ke, a "subordinative suffix" -a, and various postpositions. Most interestingly, the declarative particle seemingly shows a "nominative" distribution but only for preposed NPs in declarative clauses. Postposed declarative subjects, subjects of interrogative and imperative/hortative clauses, objects, time adverbials and some other NPs all get the subordinative suffix -a. After reviewing linking in Nama, I will show that this pattern is exactly what we expect if Nama is type 1 and the declarative suffix is limited to declarative clauses. In declarative clauses, we can say at first approximation that the highest argument is followed by the particle ke and other argument(s) get the suffix -a. Additionally, Nama shows agreement for person, gender, and number with the highest argument. So, in an intransitive, we get just one NP preceding ke and person/gender/number (PGN) Agreement: (15)
'ao-p
ke
//naapa ke
man-iNFL(3Msg) DECL
there
maa
PAST stand
T h e man stood there.' The morpheme glossed INFL is a clitic and agrees with the highest nonobliquely linked argument, i.e. with the subject. In a transitive, the subject is still the source of sentential agreement, and the other NP appears with the suffix -a: (16)
'ao-p
ke
man-iNFL(3Msg)
DECL dog-3Msg-suB PAST see
'ari-p-a
ke
muu
'The man saw the dog.' As Sadock notes, the -p is both a person/gender/number suffix, which all nouns require, and the sentence-level inflection, which every sentence requires. Both the PGN suffix and the sentential clitic have the same complex allomorphy. The -p on the subject NP seems to satisfy both
136 Linker interactions the requirement for the subject NP and the INFL requirement for S just if the subject NP is before the particle he, as in (15-16). If the subject is not located here, we get separate -ps. For example, some other constituent can be topicalized, e.g. a PP (17) or the verb (18): (17)
!'aa-s !'oa-p ke nee 'ao-p-a ra !uu town-3Fsg to-iNFL(3Msg) DECL this man-3Msg-suB PROG go 'This man is going to the town.'
(18)
!uu-p ke ra nee 'ao-p-a !'aa-s !'oa go-iNFL(3Msg) DECL PROG this man-3Msg-suB town-3Fsg to This man is going to the town.'
In each of these the sentential clitic still agrees with the subject (man), but is attached to the fronted constituent. The subject NP comes later in the sentence and receives the subordinating suffix -a, in addition to the PGN suffix. In the following, the subject seems to be postposed, and there is a conjunction at the front of the sentence. In such sentences, the agreement clitic attaches to the conjunction: (19)
(20)
tsii-p ke nee 'ao-p-a ke !uu and-iNFL(3Msg) DECL this man-3Msg-suB PAST go 'and this man went' 'oo-s
ke
//'u-s-a
ke
til
then-iNFL(3Fsg) DECL this-3Fsg-suB PAST ask
'then she asked Note in (20) that the subject is feminine (s), and the sentential clitic is also feminine. One might be tempted to see this as the operation of some surface filter which disallows the subordinative suffix on the NP preceding the declarative particle he. This cannot be so, however, because if the object is fronted, then the object must have -a even though it precedes the ke: (21)
hai-p-a-p ke 'ao-p-a stick-3Msg-suB-iNFL(3Msg) DECL man-3Msg-suB //'u-p-a ke maa this-3Msg-suB PAST give 'The man gave him a stick.'
Other elsewhere patterns
137
The first NP is the object, and it has its own PGN suffix followed by the suffix -a, followed in turn by the sentential clitic. Contrast this with the situation in (16), where the subject is in pre-fe position, and has only one PGN suffix, which is of course identical to what the sentential clitic would be. This last example (21) also illustrates the uses of -a, to which I now turn. Nama does not have a special case for goals. Rather they are marked with the suffix -a and, according to Hagman (1977), precede the direct object in non-topicalized sentences: (22)
'ao-p ke //'ii-p-a hai-p-a ke maa man-iNFL(3Msg) DECL this-3Msg-suB stick-3Msg-suB PAST give 'The man gave him a stick.'
(23)
'ao-p ke tara-s-a pere-p-a man-iNFL(3Msg) DECL woman-3Fsg-suB bread-3Msg-suB ke maa PAST give 'The man gave the woman bread.'
In the present theory we need linkers like the following, among others: (24)
_V': [ARG|GOAL]
The word-order linker will refer to the syntactic argument category GOAL, just as the dative does. For now, it is just necessary to assume that linking by a word-order position (like (24)) is compatible with linking by -a. I will analyze the suffix -a as the default linker in Nama. Before turning back to linking on declarative subjects, it is very striking that - a fulfills all the expectations of a default case. It is repeatable, as we already saw in the ditransitives in (21-23). It also links the subject under certain circumstances, about which more shortly. But note that it fulfills the Elsewhere Pattern Prediction in marking a wide range of NPs which do not have special cases. Hagman (1977) documents a wide range of uses of -a: equational predicate NP-a (p. 56), direct object (p. 76), indirect object (p. 76), temporal adverb NP-a (p. 105), with certain postpositions (p. 101), postposed subject (p. 109), interrogative subject (p. 139f.), imperative-hortative subject (p. 145). We have already seen the direct and indirect object and postposed subject uses. Time adverbials get the suffix -a:
138 Linker interactions (25)
sii-kxrh ke am tsee-ra PRO-iNFL(lMdu) DECL two day-3F-Cdu(suB) //naapa ke haa there PAST stay 'We stayed there two days.'
The adverbial tseerd 'for two days' has the subordinative suffix.2 The subject of non-declarative clauses also gets the subordinative suffix. Thus in interrogative sentences there is of course no declarative particle ke, and the subject gets the suffix -a:3 (26)
//'n-p-a //an'-e ke PRO-iNFL(3Msg)-suB meat-3Msg(suB) PAST eat 'Did he eat meat?'
Sadock (1991) argues that the PGN suffix on the subject is also the sentential clitic. The use with postpositions is very interesting, because it illustrates the optionality and Elsewhere behavior of the last section. There it was maintained that the fact that what we are analyzing as the default case applies just in the event some optional more restrictive case does not apply is strong evidence for its status as default. This phenomenon occurs with Nama -a as well. According to Hagman (1977), most postpositions require a bare NP (or a locative demonstrative adverb, which need not concern us). In the present theory, the prepositions themselves link their NP. There are two postpositions of motion, however, which combine with an NP which must be followed by -a (NP-a + Postposition): xuu 'from, away from,' and 'MM 'along, following.' These postpositions may be said not to link their NP. But, most interestingly, there is a third postposition of motion,'^ 'to, toward,' which can take an NP with or without -a: (27) v '
., , , sn-kxm
. ke
j/'ae//am-s-a I „ ,,^ , > , < ' //, > ! oa ke !nan [/ae//am-s J f Windhoek-3Fsg-suB I , /1A,, x PRO-iNFL(lMdu) . „ , > to PAST travel v } DECIJ |Windhoek-3Fsg J 'We travelled to Windhoek.'
Note too that (17) above is an example of this postposition with an -a-less NP. This is exactly the same situation as with the optional adjunct linkers of the last section. The analysis would be identical here: whenever the
Other elsewhere patterns
139
option of not linking by the more restrictive linker is taken, the default must apply. Otherwise we would have an unlinked NP. The following five facts need to be explained: (28)
a. The clitic always occurs suffixed to the word before ke. b. If the subject occurs before ke, it has one affix that seems to do double duty as PGN suffix and sentential clitic. (This is the analysis of Sadock (1991).) c. If the subject occurs before ke, it cannot bear the suffix -a. d. The clitic always agrees with the subject (overt or covert). e. If there is no ke, the subject is marked with -a.
Furthermore, the unusual distribution of the subordinative suffix -a needs to be explained. As I indicated above, the analysis of Nama on the present theory should involve type 1 settings for the Limitation Parameter and the Preference Parameter. This will make -a the default and like the accusative in Icelandic and Greek. The one unusual feature of Nama linking is the position before ke, which is a nominative-like linker but only in declarative clauses: (29)
a. _ke:
[ARG] + DECL
b.-a:[
]
The pre-fce positional linker is limited to verbs that are declarative. I assume that verbs are assigned [ + /-decl], [ + /-inter(rogative)], etc. freely, and that positive values of these features are incompatible, because a clause cannot be simultaneously declarative and interrogative or imperative. Feature geometry will not matter here. The linkings for simple intransitive and transitive declarative sentences are straightforward and are just like those for the corresponding sentences in type 1 languages. An intransitive like (15) will get the [ARG] linker, which in Nama declarative clauses is the pre-£e position: (30)
m a a [ + decl] ( x ) 'stand' _ke: [ARG] + DECL
-a:[ ] VP:[ ] There is only one argument, so the LDC is not relevant. The RC dictates use of the more restrictive linker, pre-A;e position. Since it is incompatible
140 Linker interactions with linking by -a or the VP-internal position, the NP shows up before he with no subordinative suffix. The transitive (16) is likewise familiar: (31)
muu [ + decl]
X
_ke:[ARG] + DECL
VP:[ ]
y ) 'see' *_ke: [ARG] + DECL
VP: [ ]
The LDC rules out the use of the pre-fce linker on the lower argument, because that linker is the most restrictive linker of its type applicable to the higher argument. The pre-A;e linker does link the higher argument by the RC. The second argument must get the default. The second argument is also linked by the default word-order linker, but the first one cannot be, since the more restrictive pre-A;e position linker has priority by the RC and the NP cannot be in two places. The only thing on the present account that makes Nama unusual as a type 1 language is the restriction of its [ARG] linker to declarative clauses. The restriction follows from the fact that the [ARG] linker is a declarative particle. On this analysis of Nama, we predict that in all instances where this [ARG] linker cannot be used, the default subordinative suffix will be. This is exactly correct. The linking for non-declarative clauses can be exemplified by the structure for the interrogative in (26) above: (32)
^'uu[ + int](x -a: [ ] VP: [ ]
y)'eat' -a:[ ] VP: [ ]
The [ARG] linker is not available, because this verb is not insertable in a declarative context, captured here by specifying the verb [ + inter(rogative)]. The only linkers applicable to the subject and the object are the -a marker and positional linkers, which apply. A note is in order on topicalization and other "Wh-Movement" processes in relation to linking. Kiparsky (1987) takes linking to happen at a level after the lexicon and before Wh-Movement. Since the present theory of case is embedded in a unification-based approach close to Generalized Phrase Structure Grammar (GPSG) and Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar (HPSG), I assume too that linking happens "before" topicalization, but the meaning of "before" is different. I will assume that topicalization happens "after" linking in the sense that a VP with an NP missing (VP/NP) satisfies the requirement that the NP be linked by
Other elsewhere patterns
141
VP-internal position. In other words, the feature [VP] added to an argument that corresponds to a gap is well-formed, whereas a [VP] feature added to an argument that corresponds neither to an NP within the VP nor to a gap is ill-formed. So in the last example, the subject is linked by the VP-internal position linker but the realization of this linking is a VP/ NP (which is satisfied in turn by the presence of the topicalized NP) rather than an NP dominated by the VP as is true of the object. Topicalization of objects works similarly. Another notable fact about Nama linking was that postposed subjects were linked differently even in declarative clauses. This might seem to contradict what I, following Kiparsky (1987), just assumed, that linking is not affected by "Wh-Movement" type processes. This contradiction is only apparent. The difficulty here relates to the unusual fact noted above that the sentential subject clitic is only allowed if the word it attaches to is not the subject itself. Recall from (16) above that the PGN marker in non-postposed subject sentences seems to be doing "double duty," and this is the analysis of Sadock (1991). Another way to capture these facts is to assume that the clitic, when it appears, is the subject, and so is in complementary distribution with a subject NP. The subject NP has only one PGN suffix which is not a clitic: (33) COMP
I have left off optional positions for adjunct NPs. I assume that adjunct NPs may be generated below any node from S on down. Either an NP or a clitic may be generated in the NP of S position. If it is a clitic, then it must attach leftwards, as Sadock notes. Thus in declarative sentences the clitic is the subject and is linked. The "postposed subject" is then not the subject but rather an adjunct coindexed with the true subject. Evidence for this comes from the fact that the postposed subject is optional:
142 Linker interactions (34)
'/lii tsee-ts ke nil ^'oa !aro-p one day-iNFL(2Msg) DECL FUT go.out forest-3Msg 'One day you will go out into the forest.'
!naa. into
Other NPs in the sentence, e.g. the object, seem not to be optional. Thus the special status of the postposed "subject" needs an account, which it receives from its treatment as an adjunct. The linking for this sentence is the following: (35)
! ^ ' o a [ + decl] ( x ) ' g o ' _ke:
[ARGJ
+ decl -a:[ ] VP:[ ] The sole argument is linked by the pre-ke position as in the normal declarative intransitive in (15), the only difference being that what the NP the argument corresponds to is a clitic in (34) rather than a full NP. Now consider the N P I am analyzing as an adjunct coreferential with the subject. The linking for a sentence containing such an N P is as follows, which is the linking for (21): (36)
maa [ + decl] ( x _ke:
y|GOAL *_ke: [ARG] + decl + decl -a:[ ] *a:[ ] VP:[ ] -V':[ ] VP:f ] [ARG]
z ) 'give' ( NP ) *_ke: [ARG] -a: [ ] +decl VP: [ ] -a: f ] VP:[ ]
This is a ditransitive declarative with a "postposed subject." By the LDC only the highest argument gets linked by the pre-fce position, which it must by the RC. The subject in this case is a clitic. The linking for the coreferential adjunct is separate and is given at the right. On the present theory, the only case that can apply to the adjunct is the subordinative suffix -0, which does apply. The theory correctly predicts that the adjunct must get -a, since, being an adjunct with no special case, that is the only case it is eligible for. This sentence is also interesting because it illustrates the linking of a ditransitive. All arguments not linked by pre-£e position get -#, the default case. Additionally, the goal gets linked by the position adjacent to V' (at the front of the VP). The other object must appear in
Other elsewhere patterns 143 the VP as in (22) or be topicalized, which it is in (21). The VP-internal position also applies vacuously to the goal. To summarize, the present analysis accounts for all the facts in (28) about the subject. First, the clitic must occur suffixed to the word before ke because it is linked by left adjacency to ke. It is a clitic, however, and so phonologically it must attach to the preceding word. The "double duty" phenomenon follows from the choice of generating a clitic pronoun or a full NP as the NP linked to the highest argument. If there is a full NP before ke, the PGN suffix is just a PGN suffix. There is no additional clitic, because the NP is standing where the clitic would be. The subject, if it stands before ke, is linked by ke. This linker is more restrictive than the default linker, the suffix -a, and the two are incompatible by hypothesis. By the RC, linking by means of the pre-£e position will block linking by means of -a, and so a subject NP to the left of ke cannot have -a. The clitic of course appears to agree with the subject, because on this analysis it is the subject. Any adjunct NP coindexed with the subject clitic must agree with it. Finally, in clauses without ke, i.e. all non-declarative clauses, the subject of course gets -a. This is because in such clauses there can be no linking by pre-ke position, and so the next most restrictive linker must apply, i.e. the default -a. The default status of -a is very dramatic in Nama, and the fact that the theory forces us to analyze this subordinating suffix as the default case provides an elegant way to capture the wide and disparate class of NPs that receive -a. Without default -a, the distribution of -a would be accidental, which, in the case of Nama, is very unlikely. 4.1.3 Defaults and grammatical relations Another result of of the present theory's use of a default is that it reduces the number of notions needed to capture morphosyntactic regularities like case marking. Some work in RG has been devoted to the question of what range of grammatical relations need to be referred to by rules of case marking (case marking is effected by rule in RG). The use of final grammatical relations for case marking is the least controversial and has its antecedents in traditional grammar and analogs in other theories. For example, the RG rule assigning nominative to Is is a recasting of the traditional observation that nominative is the subject case. In other contemporary theories, nominative for Is is paralleled by case-marking rules such as "assign Nominative to SPEC of IP" in GB and the rule assigning nominative to SUBJ in much of LFG (but see Zaenen, Maling, and
144 Linker interactions Thrainsson (1985) for a different approach). Direct Linking seeks to minimize even this type of statement, as I have noted above. But RG posits case-marking rules that refer to grammatical relations that are unique to that theory. Two such notions are Initial 1, 2, etc., and Acting 1, 2, etc. An Initial 1 in that framework is a nominal heading an arc which bears the relation 1 at the initial stratum. Thus, in a passive the final subject is a 2 which advances to 1. Acting 2 is more inclusive. Nominals that head arcs that bear the 2 relation at any stratum, but do not subsequently bear a term relation, are Acting 2s. For arguments that linking does not refer to initial grammatical relations, see Kiparsky (1987). I would now like to point out how the facts adduced to support Acting 2 are also fully covered by the present theory which contains a minimum of primitive functional information. As an example of a language requiring the notion Acting 2, Perlmutter (1982: 312f.) cites Latin as typical of languages requiring a rule assigning accusative (or some other morphosyntactic device) to Acting 2s. The construction cited is very similar to the double accusative ditransitives in Greek (German also has a similar construction with three or four verbs): (37)
Magister pueros grammaticam docet. teacher(NOM) boys(ACc) grammar(ACc) teaches 'The teacher teaches the boys grammar.'
The RG analysis proposed for (37) is that the semantic goal starts out as a 3 and advances to 2, forcing the 2 on the previous stratum into chomage: (38)
docere
| | pueros magister grammaticam
Case marking for accusative could be stated just in terms of nominal heading a 2 arc, since both accusative NPs head a 2 arc at some stratum.
Other elsewhere patterns
145
The crucial case for deciding between a nominal that heads a 2 arc and Acting 2 is where a nominal heads a 2 arc (2 at some stratum) and there is a later stratum at which it bears another term besides 2. Such a nominal of course heads a 2 arc but it is not an Acting 2, because an Acting 2 cannot bear another term relation on a stratum later than the last one where it bears the 2 relation. Perlmutter takes the passive of (37) as evidence for the need for Acting 2: (39)
Puerl grammaticam a magistro docentur. boys(NOM) grammar(ACc) by teacher(ABL) are-taught T h e boys are taught grammar by the teacher.'
The relational diagram is the same with the addition of another stratum for the passivization. The 2 created from the previous 3 now advances to 1. Thus puerl 'boys' heads a 2 arc but is not an Acting 2. And it is not accusative. The other nominal is an Acting 2 and is accusative: (38)
docere
| | puerl magistro grammaticam
As noted before, such sentences are handled straightforwardly in the present framework. Just as in Greek, a small number of ditransitives take three direct arguments rather than the more usual two direct arguments and an argument belonging to the syntactic argument category GOAL. With direct arguments, the dative is not applicable: (41)
docere ( x
y
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
z ) 'teach'
*NOM: [ARG] ACC:
f
]
*NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[
]
I assume that the nominative and accusative are specified as in Greek, and Latin indeed shows type 1 characteristics (see Kiihner (1912-14) and Gildersleeve (1894) for details on accusative adverbials and cognate accusatives). If so, the LDC prohibits nominative on all but the first argument, where it must apply by the RC. The lower two arguments must get
146 Linker interactions the next most restrictive case, which is accusative. In the passive, everything is the same, except for the removal of the highest argument from the argument list: (42)
doceri (xA
y
z ) 'teach'
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[
]
*NOM: [ARG] -ACC:
f
]
The second highest argument in the active corresponds to the highest argument in the passive. Since there is no higher argument, the second argument (the semantic goal) gets the nominative. The other remaining argument has no choice left but accusative. The accusative as default is in a position to capture the facts that otherwise would require an additional notion of Acting 2 and 2 itself. The purpose of this section has been twofold. First, we illustrated that an unusual distribution of non-default cases leads to an unusual distribution of default marking. The more unusual this distribution is, the less likely that the case I am analyzing to be the default just happens to have this unusual distribution as a result of the conjunction of specific rules. The more unusual the boundary between non-default and default, the more unlikely that they mesh out of coincidence. I illustrated this prediction from adopting a default case with optional adjunct cases, the declarative particle linking in Nama, and the data for Acting 2, which show the default applying in what is far from being a natural class of environments. The default approach allows a unified account and gains further support. 4.2
Passive and antipassive
The above proposals make interesting predictions about the interaction of case and the passive (and antipassive). This section will start with a review of the interaction of passivization, which, following recent practice, I will take to be the suppression of the highest argument. I will then show how the two parameters proposed in the last chapter provide an account of passive in each of the types in the typology of two-case systems. This approach automatically leads to an account of antipassivization in types 3 and 4. Passive is usually viewed as consisting of two main aspects (Chomsky (1981)): it absorbs the highest theta role and absorbs the structural Case assigned by the verb. The correlation between lack of ability to assign
Passive and ant (passive 147
Case and the absence of an external argument is known as Burzio's Generalization. The correlation of non-Case assignment and lack of an external argument has remained a stipulative generalization, and attempts to derive it from other principles or to derive lack of Case assignment from lack of external argument or vice versa have been largely unsuccessful. The initially most promising route is to derive Case absorption from external argument suppression. One of the main obstacles to doing this is the existence of a class of languages like Ukrainian with non-promotional passives, where the external argument is suppressed but the internal argument still gets accusative rather than the expected nominative from INFL. I will show that, assuming the case theory above, we can derive Burzio's Generalization and begin to explain the distribution of Ukrainian-type passives. In this section I will focus on the interaction of passive and the argument linkers. I will assume a suppression view of the passive, meaning that the one aspect of the passive operation is the removal of the highest argument of an active verb from the argument list. The next highest argument in the active automatically becomes the highest in the passive. The suppressed argument can in some sense be expressed by a by-phrase which will be interpreted in the same way as the highest argument of the active. This by-phrase is sometimes considered an optional argument and sometimes an adjunct coindexed with the suppressed top argument. It is not clear that either of these ways of dealing with the by-phrase is universally valid. For present purposes, however, I will assume it is some sort of adjunct. Some languages do not allow the by-phrase to appear at all, some languages have a range of prepositions for the by-phrase, and some, like English, have only one preposition. For English I will tentatively treat the by-phrase as part of the passive operation since by does not have a consistent semantics, unlike other adjunct prepositions which do. The passive sentence The tree was hit by the car involves at most an actor phrase, not an agent phrase. The essential assumption for the interaction of passive and antipassive with the four main types of two-case system is that the highest or lowest argument of the active no longer be the highest or lowest argument of the passive or antipassive, respectively. 4.2.1
Passive in type 1 and type 2 languages
Type 1 and type 2 languages differ in the status of what is labeled accusative case. In type 1 languages it is the default case, but in type 2 languages it is a more restrictive case with nominative as the default:
148 (43)
Linker interactions Type 1: NOM: [ARG] ACC: [
Type 2: NOM: [ ]
]
ACC: [ARG|-HA]
Since the two types of accusative differ, they might be expected to interact with the passive differently. I now show that for each type, the case absorption property of the passive follows straightforwardly. As touched on briefly in Chapter 2, the accusative in type 1 languages is not actually absorbed but is prevented from applying by the nominative. In a passive sentence like the following, the accusative does not appear: (44)
Eg
var
I(NOM) was
laminn (afhonum). hit
by him(DAT)
'I was hit (by him).' The top argument in the lexical entry of the active is suppressed: (45)
lemja-PAss ( xA y )
The cases apply to this derived structure: (46)
lemja-PAss ( xA y ) NOM ACC
Since this is a type 1 language the NOM ([ARG]) is more restrictive than the ACC ([ ]) and so takes priority. The passive subject is nominative not accusative. In a type 2 language such as Japanese, the accusative should take priority over the nominative. However, the accusative, specified [-HA], will not be applicable to the highest argument of the passivized verb. Consider the active-passive pair in (47) from Kuno (1973): (47)
a. John ga Mary o korosi-ta. John NOM Mary ACC kill-PAST 'John killed Mary.' b. Mary ga John ni koros-(s)are-ta. Mary NOM John by kill-PASs-PAST 'Mary was killed by John.'
The linking for the passive (47b) will start with the lexical entry for koros'kill': (48)
koros- ( x y )
Passive and antipassive
149
In the passive the highest argument is suppressed: (49)
koros-(s)are ( xA y )
When the linkers apply, only nominative not accusative can apply, as in (50): (50)
koros-(s)are ( xA y ) NOM
The accusative, bearing [-HA], is not even applicable. The subject will be nominative. I will continue with the account of passive in the next chapter, where ditransitive passives will be considered. Thus Burzio's Generalization follows from general principles and the parameters of the last chapter in the two types of languages. In type 1 the accusative does not show up in the passive, because it is preempted by the more restrictive nominative. In type 2 languages the accusative (and the dative if it is [—HA]) does not show up in the passive, since it may not apply to the highest argument.
4.2.2 Antipassive in type 3 and type 4 languages The antipassive works in a way very similar to the passive, only it is affixmediated suppression of the lowest rather than the highest argument. If the antipassive is indeed like a reverse passive, the antipassive should work the same in types 3 and 4 as the passive in types 1 and 2. This is because, by the Preference Parameter, these languages bear the same relationship to type 1 and 2 as the antipassive does to the passive. The antipassive should work in type 4 the same as the passive in type 1, but with the ergative left over. The antipassive in type 3 should work the same as the passive in type 2 with the ergative not applicable to the passive's lowest argument since the ergative is [-LA]. Kala Lagaw Langgus is one of the first languages to have been analyzed as having antipassivization (Postal (1977)). Kala Lagaw Langgus is a split-ergative language, where the ergative is limited to common nouns in the singular and dual, and accusative is limited to proper nouns and non-singular pronouns (plural common nouns are never inflected). Klokeid (1978) presents an analysis where absolutive is the default case. In our terms, Kala Lagaw Langgus must be partially type 3 with respect to the ergative (on split ergativity, see §3.5). In other words Kala Lagaw Langgus contains the following cases applicable to a transitive:
150 Linker interactions (51)
a. b.
ERG: [ARG|— LA] ABS:
(limited to certain noun classes)
[ ]
Evidence that the absolutive is the default comes from its Elsewhere distribution. As Klokeid notes, it applies whenever the other cases do not. The fact that a clause can contain multiple absolutives is a good indication in the present theory that it is indeed the default: (52)
Moegikazin ngoena gasamdhin a Zon child(ERG) me(Acc) caught and John(ABs) kosar garaka gasamawmadhin. two youth(ABs) caught The child caught me, and John caught two youths.' (Klokeid (1978: 594))
In the second clause of (52), both nominals are absolutive (the zero case). This follows on Klokeid's account and on ours, because the first nominal is not in the ergative noun class, so it cannot get ergative. It is the highest argument, so if Kala Lagaw Langgus accusative is like the ergative but [-HA], the accusative cannot apply here. The other nominal is in the ergative class, but as the lowest argument here it cannot get ergative. For both nominals, this leaves only the default absolutive. The fact that we can get more than one absolutive per clause means that, in the present analysis, the absolutive is to be analyzed as the default. The antipassive suppresses the lowest argument. In Kala Lagaw Langgus, this will mean that the argument that would be ergative in the active cannot be ergative in the passive because that argument is now the lowest: (53)
a. Ngath (urapun) puuyi pathan. I(ERG) one tree(ABs) chopped-down 'I chopped down (one) tree.' b. Ngay (matha mura) puyin pathi. I(ABS) all tree(ERG) chopped-down 'I chopped down (all) the tree(s).' (Klokeid (1978: 590))
As in many other languages, the case for the by-phrase is homophonous with the ergative. The linking for the active and the antipassive are as follows:
Passive and an tipassive
(54)
a. pathan ( x
y ) 'chopped down'
ERG: [ARG/—LA] ABS:
151
ABS: [
]
[ ] yA ) 'chopped down'
b. pathi ( x ABS: [
]
If the second nominal in (53a) belonged to a different noun class, the accusative would be applicable. As I indicated at the end of the last chapter, the two ways of building in such restrictions are to load argument structure with noun class features and any other features relevant to case marking or to have the constraints (AC, LDC, RC) be constraints on lexical insertion. Probably the latter is better, but exactly how the noun class restrictions are implemented does not affect the main point here which is the effect of the antipassive on type 3 linking. In the active (53a) (the structure for which is given in (54a)), the top argument, provided it belongs to a given set of nominal classes, is eligible by the AC for ergative or absolutive. The argument is the highest, so there can be no problem with the LDC (no argument is higher than it), and ergative applies by the RC. The other argument will get accusative or default absolutive depending on noun class. In the antipassive (53b), represented in (54b), the highest argument of the active is also the lowest argument, making ergative inapplicable, since ergative cannot appear on lowest arguments. This leaves the default absolutive, which is correctly predicted to apply. Note that we get a sort of reverse of Burzio's Generalization in type 3. In type 2 (Japanese) the accusative cannot apply to the logical object in the passive because the logical object is now the highest argument, which the type 2 accusative cannot link (being [-HA]). In type 3, the ergative is precluded in the antipassive for a similar reason. When the antipassive suppresses the lowest argument, the argument that is the highest in the active is now also the lowest and so cannot get ergative. Default absolutive must apply instead. Thus the correlation of antipassive and the inability of ergative to appear follows directly. For a type 4 antipassive, a possible instance comes from Kabardian, the Northwest Caucasian language discussed in §3.3.4 above. Davies (1984: 333) in his discussion of antipassivization cites a construction in Kabardian, giving an example from Catford (1976) originally due to Jakovlev:
152 Linker interactions (55)
a. rie-m dog-ERG 'The dog b. fie-r dog-ABS T h e dog
qwipsrie-r je-dzaq'e bone-ABS bite is biting the bone.' qwipsfre-m je-w-dzaq'e bone-ERG bite is biting the bone.'
(Catford (1976: 45))
Catford cites Jakovlev as claiming that the first construction, the ergative one, implies that the dog bit right through the bone, but the "nominative construction" in (55b) implies that the dog is only gnawing at the bone. It is hard to tell whether this is an antipassive. Davies does take this to be an antipassive and glosses the -w- in \hs je-w-dzaq'e 'bite' as a morphological indication of the antipassive. There is quite a large literature on the "nominative construction" and what its status is. I will assume for the sake of illustration that this is an antipassive but without any certainty that this is the best way of looking at Kabardian sentences like (55b). The antipassive in Kabardian is predicted to work like the passive in type 1 only in reverse. Compare the Unkings for the active and the passive: (56)
a. je-dzaq'e ( x
y ) 'bite'
ABS: [ARG] ERG:
[
]
ABS: [ARG]
[ ] y ) 'bite' ERG: A
b. je-w-dzaq'e ( x ABS: [ARG] ERG:
[ ]
Type 4 languages have the high value for the Preference Parameter, meaning that the LDC will question the linking of higher arguments relative to the possibilities for the lower arguments. This means that the [ARG] case has an absolutive rather than a nominative distribution. If the antipassive suppresses the lowest argument, then the higher argument is no longer prevented from getting the absolutive by the LDC, since there is no lower argument to compare its linking to. This means that where the ergative had to apply in the active, the absolutive now becomes obligatory by the RC. The ergative absorption effect follows from the Preference Parameter and the LDC, just as the accusative absorption effect followed in type 1.
Passive and antipassive
153
4.2.3 Non-promotional passives At the beginning of this section, I mentioned the possibility in some languages of "non-promotional" passives. A well-known instance is Ukrainian from Sobin (1985), exemplified by the Ukrainian sentence in (57): (57)
Cerkvu bulo zbudovano church + fern, ACC be + past + neut build + part + neut v 1640 roc'i. in 1640 T h e church was built in 1640.'
In such passives, the accusative NP of the active remains accusative in the passive. If it is type 1, the accusative is not actually unavailable in the passive but only preempted by the nominative. Thus if there is a way of using the nominative up in the passive then the accusative will automatically apply, and we will get a non-promotional passive. Dummies inserted at the top of argument lists have often been proposed. In fact, Sobin proposes a dummy for Ukrainian. In GB the consequence is that Case absorption cannot be the basic property of the passive. On the present account, this is expected. I would like to show that positing an optional null dummy for Ukrainian gets the right results. First of all, before we can give an account of the interaction between passivization, dummies, and case in Ukrainian, it is necessary to establish what type Ukrainian should be analyzed as belonging to. I take Ukrainian to be type 1, primarily on account of its wide range of adjunct accusatives, including accusative of price, accusative of measure, accusative of quantity, and accusative of time (see Shevelov (1963: 17If.) for details about both literary and colloquial Ukrainian). The non-promotional passive in (57) is a passive with the insertion of a dummy argument. The linking for (57) is given in (58): (58)
xA
build ( DUM NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
y) *NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[
]
The dummy gets the most restrictive case applicable to it. Since it is an NP and a dummy argument it gets nominative. Thus nominative is unallowable on the second argument by the LDC. This leaves accusative, and it does appear in (57).
154 Linker interactions This dummy must be optional, since sentences like the following are also grammatical: (59)
Cerkva bulo zbudovana church + fem.NOM be + past + fern build + part + fem.sg v 1640 roc'i. in 1640 'The church was built in 1640.'
Thus, the dummy is optional. If not inserted, the passive linking is unexceptional, and the passivized subject takes nominative and agreement. Further, if we assume that agreement is the NOM linker and the nominative case is the flip-side of agreement, a sentence in which we get a nominative subject in the passive without agreement should be out, which is correct: (60)
*Cerkva bulo zbudovano church + fem.NOM be + past + fern build + part + neut v 1640 roc'i. in 1640. 'The church was built in 1640.'
Even if we assume that agreement and nominative are syntactically equivalent (their LINK value is [ARG]) but separate linkers, the LDC would still rule out (60). The dummy either absorbs the agreement (NOM) linker as in (57) forcing the accusative to apply or it does not, allowing the agreement and/or nominative to link the passive subject as in (59). There is no way for (60) to be generated. The passive receives a natural account in all four types of two-case language. In the next chapter, I will show how the present account of case interacts with raising. 4.3
Word order
Linking is not accomplished by case alone. In addition to case and adpositions, agreement and word order are the other two major types of linkers. We have already seen two examples of positional linking, the preverbal position in Icelandic (about which more in the next chapter) and the positional linker adjacency-to-V in Japanese. The Icelandic position was like a type 1 nominative, and the Japanese _V linker had the same LINK value as the accusative. In both languages, the positional linker
Word order
155
was in addition to the case linkers, and furthermore the position had the same LINK value as one of the cases in that language. There are, however, many languages that rely primarily on position for linking, a notable example being English. The present approach to direct linking is meant to generalize to all forms of linking, and so such languages should behave similarly to the ones we have examined so far except for the realization of the linkers. The features I have been using (ARG, EXP, GOAL, etc.) as parts of the value of LINK define the cases with respect to the theory, because the theory consists of three constraints that refer only to LINK values. Despite their radically different surface properties, linkers with the same basic distributional properties, captured here as equivalent LINK values, should behave similarly with respect to the AC, the RC, and the LDC. This section will be an analysis of English as a type 1 language, and the next will consider the interaction of case, configuration, and obliqueness. Recall first Kiparsky's (1987, 1989) analysis of English. "Grammatical relations," whether primitive or derived, correlate with word-order position in English. This effect can be achieved in direct linking by means of the rules he proposes for English: (61)
a. Agreement and _V": unrestricted b. V_ : unrestricted c. V'_ : Theme
These rules differ from the linkers on the present approach in the following respects. First, they operate over a list of thematic roles. Each argument is classified into categories such as agent, goal, theme, etc., hierarchically arranged on a universal Thematic Hierarchy. "Unrestricted" in (61) means not restricted to any particular thematic role on the hierarchy. Furthermore, Kiparsky takes agreement to link the highest (available) role because of its special anaphoric nature. On the present approach, however, agreement will be treated as an [ARG] linker and the "highest available" behavior will follow from the type 1 low setting of the Preference Parameter. Then the LDC will allow only one occurrence of agreement per clause, on the highest argument which can get agreement. The LDC, the RC, and the Preference Parameter make the "highest available" nature of English agreement fall out. This makes the correct prediction that if the value of the Preference Parameter is reversed, as in type 4, the analog of English agreement ([ARG]) should
156 Linker interactions show an absolutive pattern, "lowest available" argument. Kabardian was a case of this. Kiparsky's rules in (61) are to be taken with the phrase structure rules in (62): (62)
a. S -> {V", N", P"} b. V" -> {V', N", P"} c. V' -> {V, N", Prt}
For a discussion of how Kiparsky's analysis elegantly captures the possibilities for ditransitives, see Chapter 1: (63)
N' a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h.
sent sent sent *sent *sent *sent *sent *sent
Prt
a drink up up John up John a drink up up up up
to John a drink to John a drink a drink up John John a drink to John a drink a drink John
It will be shown shortly that the present approach also affords a simple analysis of the facts in (63a-h). I will also assume the phrase structure in (62) and (63). For linkers I will adopt the following: (64)
a. _V": [ARG] b. agr: [ARG] c. V":[ ] d. V_: [ARG|GOAL|-HA]
The position _V" ( = VP) and agreement are identical syntactically but distinct with respect to realization. In the unmarked situation they can link the same NP (the subject). The linkers in (64c,d) will, because of the three constraints, normally be used for objects, but they need not be directly stipulated to apply to
Word order 157
objects. One of these linkers needs to be more restrictive than the other. The theory traces restrictiveness back to basic distribution. There are two possibilities. Either we can say that a position to the right of V' is restricted to themes as in Kiparsky's (61c). Goals are then forced into the V_ position in ditransitives. This assumes that linkers make reference to theme, a thematic role which is difficult to define. So far we have avoided making an analog of theme in the system of syntactic argument categories. The other possibility is to reconstruct the notion of an indirect object position after the verb and so have the position V_ limited to goals, as in Wechsler (1995). Translating this into the argument category approach, we would just be using the argument category goal which we have already. This has the virtue of making the position parallel to the goal dative from many languages we have seen already. In the next section we will see that this latter choice, a goal position, is in fact the only one possible in this theory. The default, then, is the within-VP position (V") position, and therefore, like the default in other languages, should link the otherwise unmarked adverbs. If English is indeed a type 1 language, the withinVP position should behave exactly like the accusative in Icelandic, German, and Classical Greek. This position is roughly analogous to structural case in GB: any NP in the VP gets this linker. To show how the present proposal works, I return to the example in (63). For both (63a) and (63b), the linking is as follows: (65)
y|GOAL
agr: [ARG]
to: [ARG/GOAL/-HA] + OBL
z) *_V": [ARG] *agr: [ARG]
V": [ ]
V_: [ARG GOAL - H A ]
V":[
send up ( x
_ F ' : [ARG]
]
*_V": [ARG] *agr: [ARG]
For the first argument the VP-external position and agreement are the most restrictive applicable linkers. There is no higher argument, and so the LDC cannot be violated. VP-external position and agreement are compatible, and so both apply. On the lower two arguments, these linkers are unavailable, because they are the most restrictive linkers that pass the AC for a higher argument. For the goal argument, the preposition competes with the verb-adjacent-position-for-goals and the default VP-internal position. The default must give way to either goal linker since they are more restrictive. Prepositions and word-order linkers are normally not
158 Linker interactions compatible, a subject I return to in the next section. If the preposition option is taken, we get (63a) and (63b). For the lowest argument, the only linker that passes the AC and the LDC is the VP-internal position, which just means that the object must appear somewhere in the VP, either as sister to V (63a) or sister to V' (63b). The VP-internal linker underdetermines the position of the NP, which leads to two options (63a,b). The sentence in (63c) is the result of taking the V_ option over the equally restrictive preposition for the goal. Note that, if this is done, then the last argument cannot appear as sister to the verb. It will still be linked by VP-internal position but will be forced to appear as sister of V', since the sister of V position is taken by the goal. As for the ungrammatical sentence types in (63), in each one some general constraint is violated. First, as in Kiparsky (1989), (63d) is ruled out, because only one NP can be sister to V in the phrase structure. To get (63f,g), at least one constraint must be violated. If the goal is linked by VP: [ ] over to: [ARG|GOAL] and V: [ARG|GOAL], then the RC is violated. Sentence (63e) is well-formed, but only if the NP a drink is linked to the goal argument. This will lead to the bizarre interpretation where a drink is the entity that John is being sent to. If, however, the NP John is linked to the goal argument, then the RC has been violated and the sentence is ungrammatical under the normal interpretation. As for (63g), the adoption of Kiparsky's phrase structure will put a single NP before the PP if both are sisters of V'. The structure necessary for (63g) is not generated. In general, English behaves as a type 1 language with positional linking rather than cases. This should not be too surprising, since most analyses of English identify some position, e.g. SPEC of IP in GB, with nominative case in languages like Greek and Latin, and identify position within the VP with accusative in those languages. As I showed briefly in §4.1.1, the VP-internal position does seem to link a range of adjuncts in the default manner expected. In Chapter 6, Old English will be analyzed as being a case-marking type 1 language. It will be clear that despite radical changes on the surface, English has remained a type 1 language. 4.4
Obliqueness and compatibility of case and configuration
We have already seen several examples of the interaction of case and configuration. One was the preverbal position in Icelandic and the cases. Another was the accusative and V-adjacent position linkers in Japanese. Earlier in this chapter we saw the interaction of the subordi-
Obliqueness and compatibility of case and configuration 159 native suffix -a and the pre-A:e position in Nama. In each of these languages, the cases and the configuration that are interacting are all non-oblique. In the last section, on English, the preposition to and the V-adjacent position conflict in obliqueness, and they are not compatible on the same NP. This will turn out to be true generally. This section will consider the question of the interaction of case and configuration when one or more of those linkers is oblique. It is a commonplace that obliques show a greater freedom within the clause than non-obliques. For example, in English the non-oblique goal phrase has less freedom than the corresponding oblique to phrase (66,67) and the corresponding oblique dative phrase in German (68): (66)
a. It was to Bill that John gave the book, b. ??It was Bill that John gave the book.
(67)
a. To Bill John gave a book, b. ??Bill John gave a book.
(68)
a. Der Schiiler gab dem Lehrer den Apfel. the(NOM) pupil gave the(DAT) teacher the(ACc) apple The pupil gave the teacher the apple.' b. Der Schiller gab den Apfel dem Lehrer. the(NOM) pupil gave the(ACc) apple the(DAT) teacher 'The pupil gave the teacher the apple.' c. The pupil gave the teacher the apple. d. T h e pupil gave the apple the teacher.
At the level of whole languages it has often been remarked that case and configurationality or strict word order are inversely correlated. The question is whether obliqueness or case is what is incompatible with configurationality and how exactly this relationship works. One initially plausible way to capture this is to have oblique case be incompatible with linking by word order, leading to greater freedom of word order, i.e. relative non-configurationality. Typically behavioral obliqueness is associated with lexical case. But Icelandic shows lexical case that marks NPs that behave otherwise much as they do in configurational languages such as English and Norwegian (see Chapter 6). Two types of approach are possible. One is to say that case and word order are inherently incompatible and claim that special cases like Icelandic involve a special type of case. The problem with this is that it creates an otherwise unnecessary division among cases. Another approach is to say that case and word order are always compatible but
160 Linker interactions not when the case is oblique. I will pursue this possibility and attempt to show why this should be the expected situation. The first generalization that needs to be captured is that the only linkers that are oblique are lexical, i.e. they refer to some information more specific than argumenthood (and [—XA]). Under this approach, a case or a positional linker may be oblique or non-oblique, but only if it is lexical, that is, only if it fits the following: (69)
Obliqueness Constraint Linker: +OBL D Linker: [ARG|X] where X is non-null4 + OBL
Any linker may be non-oblique, but only a lexical linker may be oblique. This leads to the following types of linkers: (70) lexical non-lexical
oblique Y N
non-oblique Y Y
This means that type 1 nominative or accusative (or their equivalents in other types) may not be oblique. A lexical case may be oblique, as in German (see Chapter 2), or it may be non-oblique, as in Icelandic. Furthermore, I will take oblique to be the marked value of the pair [±OBL]. This makes sense, since the less restrictive, i.e. the more general, linkers cannot be oblique. More importantly, obliqueness is a property of only those cases that are language-specific. By hypothesis, all languages have a default linker, and most if not all have an [ARG] linker. Thus there is nothing stipulated about these linkers except their realization. These linkers seem never to be oblique. Therefore it is reasonable to assume that the linkers which are least marked with respect to their basic distribution (LINK) are also the least marked with respect to obliqueness. When obliqueness occurs, it occurs on lexical cases, i.e. those cases involving more language-specific stipulation. It is not surprising that the value for obliqueness of these cases is the marked one. The unmarked status of [—OBL] will be captured by the following default: (71)
[
]->[-OBL]
All linkers that are [ + OBL] cannot get [-OBL] by the default since the values are contradictory. But any linker not specified [ + OBL] is automatically [—OBL]. And, as emphasized already, only the lexical cases can be
Obliqueness and compatibility of case and configuration
161
specified [ + OBL], leading all non-lexical linkers to be [-OBL], the desired result.5 Positional linkers are typically non-lexical. Since non-lexical linkers are non-oblique (by the constraint in (69)), positional linkers are typically non-oblique, which is correct. However, the non-obliqueness of positional linkers is not inherent but rather contingent on their being non-lexical. This dependency leads to the following predictions: (72)
A lexical positional linker can be oblique.
(73)
If a positional linker is oblique, it must be lexical.
In the last section, we saw one lexical word-order position, for goals in English. What (72) says is that such a linker may be oblique in some language. Later I will present Dutch as such a language. One last prediction is that oblique case is not in principle incompatible with linking by position. The only constraint on co-occurrence of case and position is that they should not have contradictory values for obliqueness, which follows if the AVMs of the linkers must unify. The main constraint we need is one to prevent an NP from being linked both by an oblique linker and a non-oblique linker at the same time. This could of course be stipulated, but it should follow from something more basic. Intuitively, what we want to express is a generalization that the properties of a linker are inherited by the NP which is linked by that linker. If two incompatible linkers link the same NP, then in some sense, the NP is a contradiction. It is not clear whether it has the property of the one linker or the other. When it comes to obliqueness, the situation is clear. If an NP is linked by an oblique linker, the NP is not a term but an oblique. If, on the other hand, an NP is linked by a non-oblique linker, then it will be a term, by definition. But if an NP were linked both by an oblique linker and by an non-oblique linker, the NP would have contradictory properties associated with it. What we want is for the information about obliqueness versus non-obliqueness (and presumably other mutually exclusive properties) to transfer (e.g. by "percolation") to the NP where consistency is checked: (74)
Obliqueness Inheritance fLINK
LINK
REAL [LINKERX [OCOBL]]
D
NP
REAL [LINKERX aOBL
NP
162 Linker interactions This constraint may be derivable from more general principles of inheritance, but I will leave (74) as is for the discussion to follow. Turning back to case and configuration, we are now in a position to consider how an oblique case and a non-oblique positional linker will interact. If the oblique case is more restrictive than the position, we have on some argument a competition between the following: (75)
a. Case: [ARG|X]
where X is non-null
+ OBL
b. Position: [Y]
where Y = ARG or is null
—OBL
If both are applicable to some NP (pass the AC and the LDC in isolation), then we have to consider Obliqueness Inheritance and the RC. If both linkers applied, then the linking would violate Obliqueness Inheritance. If just the position applied, then the RC would be violated, because there is a more restrictive unused linker that could apply to that argument in isolation, namely the other case. The case alone is fine and must be used. The oblique case-marked NP is ineligible for positional linking. One interesting prediction is that if a word-order position linker refers to information more specific than argumenthood, i.e. it is lexical, it could be associated with [ + OBL]. Thus we predict the existence of a language in which the English-type goal position links an NP that behaves like an oblique (e.g. does not passivize). A possible example of such an oblique lexical positional linker is the verb-adjacent position in Dutch. In that language the indirect object must appear next to the verb (Verhagen (1986: 202f.) and references there): (76)
a. Toen heeft Jan het kind zijn laatste boterham gegeven. then has Jan the child his last sandwich given Then Jan gave the child his last sandwich.' b. ??Toen heeft Jan zijn laatste boterham het kind gegeven. then has Jan his last sandwich the child given 'Then Jan gave the child his last sandwich.'
From the discussion of these examples it is clear that Verhagen gives (76b) two question marks because the string is well-formed but only under the bizarre interpretation where a child is being given to a sandwich, whereas the pragmatically expected reading goes with (76a) not (76b). So far Dutch is parallel to English. Where they differ is in the
Obliqueness and compatibility of case and configuration
163
fact that the goal may not be the subject of the passive in Dutch (Hoekstra (1984: 159)): (77)
a. dat that 'that b. *dat that 'that c. dat that 'that
ik Marie bloemen gaf I Mary flowers gave I gave Mary flowers' Marie bloemen werd gegeven Mary flowers was given Mary was given flowers' Marie bloemen werden gegeven Mary flowers were given flowers were given (to) Mary'
The ditransitive passivizes only if the lower, "theme" argument is subject of the passive, as indicated by the singular versus plural agreement in (77b) and (77c). Most theories of the passive predict that if neither object is oblique, then either both objects passivize (symmetric) or only the higher object passivizes (asymmetric). By "higher" is meant higher in argument structure or "thematically" higher. To preserve this generalization, the goal must be oblique in Dutch and so not an object. However, there is no oblique case (no dative) on that NP, but its position is fixed, so the oblique linker is likely to be the position. Dutch thus illustrates our prediction in (73) that if a word order is oblique, it has some restriction beyond [ARG]. This can be handled by having a word-order position for goals which is oblique. Consider again the choice for ditransitives we faced in English between a position restricted to themes (as in Kiparsky (1987, 1989)) or one for goals (as in Wechsler (1995). Using argument categories, the latter analysis can be adopted by using the argument category goal which we have made use of already. The other analysis would involve translating the thematic role theme into an argument category. The preference for the goal analysis coincides with the necessity for it in Dutch. The non-passivizability of the goal in Dutch indicates that we should analyze it as an oblique. But, to be oblique, that NP must be linked by a lexical linker. The only way for the goal to be linked by a lexical linker is to posit a positional linker for goals. If the goal were linked by the default position, it could not be oblique on the present theory. The word-order position for goals in Dutch is roughly "before the other object." Very tentatively I suggest _V' as the positional linker for (syntactic) goals in Dutch:
164 Linker interactions (78)
_V':
[ARG|GOAL] + OBL
Just like the German dative, this oblique word-order position will prevent the goal from becoming subject (highest non-oblique argument) in the passive (see Section 5.3 for the German passive). We predicted (in (72)) that an oblique positional linker should be found, and we predicted (in (73)) that if such a linker were found, it would be lexical. Two predictions converge on Dutch and are borne out. This approach further predicts that if a word-order position like the pre-V' position in Dutch can bear [ + OBL], then that word-order linker would be compatible with a lexical oblique case. This would appear as a dative that is fixed in its position. This prediction is particularly interesting, because it contradicts the traditional assumption that case and fixed position are complementary. What we are predicting is that even an NP that is both a behavioral and a coding oblique can be fixed in position. This seems to be borne out by the facts in certain dialects of Swiss German, especially Grisons German (Andreas Ludwig, p.c). In Grisons German, there is a distinct morphological dative, and it appears on goals: (79)
und den het dr dogdor Suarer em Bbuur and then has the doctor Saurer the(DAT) farmer de KB erklart the KB explained 'and then Dr. Saurer explained the KB (artificial fertilization) to the farmer'
(80)
de Bbuur git mier noch duusigg Franka the fanner gives me(DAT) still thousand Francs 'The farmer will give me a thousand Francs.'
The goal is fixed in its position. If it is placed after the other object, the result is ungrammatical. So corresponding to (79) and (80), we get: (81)
*und den het dr dogdor Suarer de KB em and then has the doctor Saurer the KB the(DAT) Bbuur erklart farmer explained 'and then Dr. Saurer explained the KB (artificial fertilization) to the farmer'
Obliqueness and compatibility of case and configuration 165 (82)
*de Bbuur git noch duusigg Franka mier the farmer gives still thousand Francs me(DAT) 'The farmer will give me a thousand Francs.'
The other order of the dative and the accusative NP is ungrammatical. In (82), this could be ascribed to the pronoun following the noun, but in (81) both the dative and the accusative NPs are definite NPs. The lack of the accusative-dative order cannot be reduced to ordering statements based on pronounhood versus nounhood or definiteness versus indefiniteness, familiar from Standard German. Rather Swiss German shows truly fixed order of dative goal before accusative object. The goal, despite its being positionally fixed, is oblique. In ditransitive passives, the goal does not become the subject. This can be tested by trying to make the dative goal NP the target of control: (83)
*ich
hoffe duusig Franke ggee ze werde hope thousand Francs given to become 'I hope to be given a thousand Francs.'
I(NOM)
In general, dative goals, like dative goals in Standard German, do not pass the tests for subjecthood, showing that they are behavioral obliques. The goal in Grisons German seems to be doubly linked by dative and verb-adjacent position. Furthermore, NPs linked by these linkers are oblique. The two goal linkers for Grisons German would be the following: (84)
a. DAT: [ARG|GOAL] + OBL b. _V': [ARG|GOAL] + OBL
Note that the position is oblique and lexical, as predicted: (85)
geen ( x
y|GOAL
NOM: [ARG]
DAT: [ARG/GOALJ
+ OBL ACC: [
]
_ V1:
[ARG/GOAL]
+ OBL NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
z ) 'give' *NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[
]
166 Linker interactions In the passive, the goal is not the subject (highest non-oblique argument), because it is oblique: (86)
geen ( xA
y|GOAL
z ) 'give'
DAT: [ARG 1 GOAL]
NOM: [ARG]
+ OBL
ACC:
[ ]
_ V': [ARG1 GOAL] + OBL NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
The goal is doubly linked by dative and verb-adjacent position, but Obliqueness Inheritance will not cause a clash: (87)
LINK [ARG [CAT [GOAL]]]
[ V_
DAT [ + OBL] 1
[+
OBL]j
+ OBL
NP
The NP is oblique, and this comes from both linkers, so the structure is fine. Grisons German is a confirming instance of the prediction that an oblique word-order linker is possible, and that such a linker must be lexical. Further, such a positional linker is compatible with oblique case in Grisons German, also as predicted. 4.5
Compatibility of linkers
Having opposite values for obliqueness is not the only way for two linkers to be incompatible. I have assumed that different types of linkers are in general compatible, and different linkers of the same type are incompatible. Such a view is too simple, and I will end this chapter with a short discussion of the compatibility of linkers. This discussion will be far from conclusive. Most versions of GB assume some version of "case clash" which prevents more than one Case per theta role. Direct Linking also originally (Kiparsky (1987)) incorporated a restriction that each NP must be linked exactly once. I have formulated the above conditions on linking to keep open the possibility of multiple linking, and have analyzed some languages as involving multiple linking, typically by a case and a wordorder position. The Restrictiveness Constraint disallows a less restrictive
Compatibility of linkers 167 linker to link an NP to the exclusion of a more restrictive linker that is available. The RC, however, says nothing directly about blocking. The RC only enforces disjunctive ordering between linkers if the linkers are incompatible. I now consider the general question of compatibility. Linkers can be divided into three main types: (i) morphological case and adpositions, (ii) agreement and (iii) word order. As discussed already, case and adpositions work similarly, although adpositions have a tendency to be independent predicators, and cases tend to fall on the more grammaticalized end of the spectrum from independent predicators to syntactic linkers. For example, the preposition to in English is both a linker for goal arguments and an independent predicator. Both case and prepositions sometimes co-occur with word-order linking, but generally only if they are highly grammaticalized. I proposed in the last section that, in principle, cases (and adpositions) are always compatible with word-order. However, one factor prevents their co-occurrence in most cases. Word order rarely refers to lexical information and so can rarely be oblique. Lexical case is often oblique. By Obliqueness Inheritance, then, such cases and word-order positions do not mix in general. But if the case and the word-order position are both oblique (Grisons German) or both non-oblique, then they should be able to co-occur. We correctly predict, then, that there are two main ways for case and word order to be compatible. One is if the case is not oblique, as with the syntactic cases (nominative, accusative, ergative, absolutive in all types), or with nonoblique lexical cases (as in Icelandic, see Chapter 2 and the next chapter). The other way to be compatible is if the word-order position is oblique, as we have already seen for Grisons German. Thus the theory seems to handle the relation of case and configuration in an explanatory way. Likewise, agreement and word-order position seem to be in principle compatible. If agreement is much like case but just differs in appearing on the verb rather than the argument, then this is quite expected. Agreement is perhaps for diachronic reasons rarely lexical and so rarely oblique. Thus a combination of agreement and word order should usually be possible. Agreement and case is trickier. Many languages (e.g. Kabardian) have agreement with a wide range of cased NPs. One could say that this agreement linked the NP in addition to the case, instead of the case (but then nominal case is a mystery), or that it does not link. Also, it is not clear whether in these cases agreement picks out NPs on the same basis as a case (e.g. by argument category) or whether it picks out NPs on
168 Linker interactions the basis of their case. This problem is particularly acute for nominative. As I have argued, nominative in Classical Greek, German, Icelandic, etc. is not the default. But it does seem to be the reverse side of agreement in at least some of these languages. Kiparsky (1987) analyzes nominative as a no-case and agreement as the linker. On the other hand, as we shall see, Icelandic allows nominatives which do not agree. Many South Asian languages have an agreement rule that could be described as: agree with the functionally highest nominative (Joshi (1987) on Marathi, Mohanan (1994) for Hindi). Next comes the question of the compatibility of two linkers of the same type. First of all, Obliqueness Inheritance should rule out an oblique and a non-oblique linker of the same type from linking the same NP (e.g. an oblique lexical case and an accusative). I know of no cases of double agreement. Double word order is hard to imagine. Certainly two NPs cannot occupy more than one position at the same level. On the other hand, if an NP were linked by adjacency to the verb and internality to the VP, it could be linked twice, by two word-order positions. I know of no analysis that seems to hinge on this issue. Multiple morphological case may be possible, but two types must be immediately distinguished. Dench and Evans (1988) do show that a given NP may bear more than one case, but their examples are of cases used on different "levels" marking the same NP. An example is the NP warrapala-ku 'grass-LOC-ACc' in (88) from Panyjima (Dench and Evans (1988: 8)): (88)
ngunha watharri-ku nyurna-yu warrapa-la-ku that look for-PRES snake-Ace grass-LOC-ACC karta-larta kurrjarta-ngarni. poke-FUT spear-PROP 'He is looking for the snake in the grass to stab it with a spear.'
Here the NP bears an adnominal case inside a verbal argument (Dench and Evans' "relational") case. The relational accusative case appears on all the constituents of the NP it is associated with and so appears on the dependent NP as well. This NP has a locative case that marks this lower level dependence as well. Dench and Evans document other levels besides adnominal and relational from which case can "percolate down to an NP." They note, however, that some caution is in order, because the different uses of the cases may be related diachronically rather than synchronically. In any event, like GB Case Theory and other case theories, the present framework deals only with what Dench and Evans
Compatibility of linkers
169
term "adnominal" and "relational" case: case that signals the relation of an argument to its predicator. The question still remains whether two cases on the same level, especially two relational cases, are compatible. Dench and Evans give no examples of this. One instance of "case stacking" where both cases are argument cases has been claimed in the literature for Korean (Gerdts and Yoon (1988: 164f.)) on the basis of sentences like (89): (89)
Suni-eykey-ka Chelsu-eyiyhae chaek-i cu-eci-et-ta. Suni-DAT-NOM Chelsu-by book-NOM give-pas-pst-ind 'Sooni was given the book by Chelsu.'
None of the ten or so speakers I have consulted accepts (89), but this does not rule out the possibility that it is fine for other speakers. If any of the sentences that Gerdts and Yoon (1988) cite as instances of case stacking are fine, this can be handled very elegantly within the present system. The cases that can stack must be marked, since not all speakers evidently allow all combinations if they allow one. But once a given combination of cases is allowed, there is the matter of deriving the order which may not be reversed: (90)
*Suni-ka-eykey Chelsu-eyiyhae chaek-i cu-eci-et-ta. Suni-NOM-DAT Chelsu-by book-NOM give-pas-pst-ind 'Sooni was given the book by Chelsu.'
Gerdts and Youn (1988) have a principle that case depth reflects the order of strata in RG. Thus the dative in (89) precedes the nominative, because the NP heads a 3 arc at an earlier stratum than the stratum at which it heads a 1 arc. This can be captured within the present theory by just requiring that the NP plus any case must satisfy the RC. Thus the NP plus the dative does, since there is no more restrictive applicable case than the dative. NP plus nominative does not, because the RC is violated: the more restrictive dative is not present. All other examples of case stacking also show the order predicted by the RC in this way.6 Thus, the RC can derive the order of case stacking to the extent that it occurs. To summarize, I give the following table of compatibilities, leaving open the question of the extent to which multiple linking by linkers of the same type is possible:
170 Linker interactions (91)
case case ? w.o. agreement
word order Y ?
agreement Y/N Y ?
Thus, generally it seems safe to assume that, in the unmarked case, linkers of the same type cannot multiply link an NP. Other combinations of linkers are in principle fine, subject to Obliqueness Inheritance and any language-particular constraints.
5
Icelandic
In this chapter I will provide an analysis of some central problems in Icelandic syntax within the theory developed so far. I would like to follow out one of the consequences of the theory in the last chapter, that of the possibility of double linking. If, as argued there, obliqueness and nonobliqueness (represented by [±OBL]) is introduced to NPs through the linkers that link them, then the possibility of lexical case and word order doubly linking NPs is predicted. Just this double linking, I will argue, is the best way to explain the well-known combination of rich case and relatively strict word order in Modern Icelandic. In the next chapter, I will provide a diachronic explanation of the rise of Modern Icelandic double linking. The essence of the analysis I propose is that lexical case in Icelandic does not carry the [ + OBL] feature specification and that Icelandic is type 1. If the lexical cases are not oblique, they will be non-oblique by default, and so it follows that the lexically cased NPs will behave as terms. This will be true whether or not there is a word-order position to link them as well. I will argue that preverbal or pre-VP position is the only positional linker in Icelandic. Subjects, then, will typically be doubly linked, but objects will not. Finally, the approach advocated here will provide a predictive account of the interaction of case, passivization, and coordination. 5.1
Case, agreement, and word order
Icelandic was the first language considered in Chapter 2. There I provided an analysis of case in Modern Icelandic, and illustrated the basic workings of the theory using Icelandic data. The case alternations Dative Substitution and Nominative Substitution were examined in detail and were found to be well accounted for by the restrictiveness-based theory of case. Later this theory was extended to cover languages of different types, 171
172
Icelandic
and a basic typology of pure two-case systems was presented in Chapter 3. Icelandic, like Greek, is a type 1 language, i.e. it has the characteristic type 1 values for the Limitation Parameter and the Preference Parameter: (1)
Type 1: Limitation Parameter: No Preference Parameter: Low (Top-Down)
These parameter values cause any [ARG] linkers and any default linkers to show a nominative-accusative pattern, with an elsewhere distribution of accusative. The cases are as in (2): (2)
a. b.
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
Any [ARG] linker (nominative and, as seen below, pre-VP position) will appear on the highest argument for which it is possible by the LDC and the RC. The LDC will question the linking of lower arguments in comparison to the most restrictive possibilities of each respective type for higher arguments. For the [ARG] linkers, this means that the LDC will disallow them except in "highest available" position. The no value of the Limitation Parameter means that the any-argument case will not be prohibited on the highest argument. Recall that Icelandic had a dative of experiencers and a dative of goals, which in the present theory are cases referring to the argument categories experiencer and goal. See Chapter 2 for details: (3)
a. DAT: [ARG|EXP] b. DAT: [ARG|GOAL]
The argument category approach in essence says that morphological dative is associated with two interpretations, one as a sentient being aware of something, and the other as the entity towards which something moves, a goal. However, it is not correct that every time verbal entailments are of this nature we automatically get the dative. The implication is one way from syntactic experiencer to semantic experiencer. Some semantic experiencers were nominative. Although the use of argument categories is looser than thematic relations in useful ways, they are quite heavily constrained. First, they embody the non-trivial claim that certain uses of the dative receive a uniform interpretation, and that these uses will have syntactic consequences.
Case, agreement, and word order
173
Most importantly, the features corresponding to the argument categories are referred to by the three constraints, AC, RC, and LDC, which make a wide range of predictions. The LDC will enforce a weaker syntactic analogue of "thematic uniqueness" (see §2.6 above). If we had more than one syntactic goal per clause, then the lower one would never be able to get dative, because that would violate the LDC. Icelandic has a wide range of idiosyncratic cases as well. They are generally of the form in (4): (4)
Case:
[ARG|X|Y]
where Y = 1, 2, ... and X may be null
Each of these cases is part of the lexical entry of some verb. The idiosyncratic datives make reference to the same morphological dative paradigm as the dative of goal, but their syntactic distribution is different, i.e. they have radically different LINK values. Some of the many idiosyncratic cases needed for Icelandic are given in (5): (5)
a. b. c. d.
ACC: [ARG|EXP|1]
e.
GEN: [ARG|2]
ACC: [ARG|1] DAT: [ARG|2] GEN: [ARG|1]
(part of (part of (part of (part of able') (part of
the the the the
lexical lexical lexical lexical
entry entry entry entry
for for for for
langa 'long') reka 'drift') tyna 'lose') gceta 'be notice-
the lexical entry for sakna 'miss')
In this chapter, we will see some more idiosyncratic cases on the third argument of some ditransitives.
5.1.1 Nominative and agreement As I mentioned briefly in the last chapter, the interaction of case and agreement is somewhat special. Nominative and agreement often go together, but the correlation is not perfect. Some languages have nominative and no agreement, and others have agreement that correlates with a nominative case, often a zero case. Kiparsky (1989) proposes that nominative is the absence of case and that the agreement is the real linker. The correlation between agreement and nominative, however, is one way only, as I now show for Icelandic. In Icelandic, if an NP is the source of agreement, it must be nominative. But if an NP is nominative, it may or may not be the source of verbal agreement. Agreement is obligatory with preverbal nominatives:
174 Icelandic (6)
t>eir hafa/*hefur etid. They(NOM) have(3pl)/have(3sg) eaten 'They have eaten.'
If the highest argument is dative, the agreement is never with the dative NP despite the fact it is the highest grammatically linked argument (the subject) and despite the fact that it is the preverbal NP (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985)): (7)
Mer *hef/hefur/hafa alltaf J>6tt me(DAT) have(lsg)/have(3sg)/have(3pl) always thought J>eir leidinlegir. they(NOMpl) boring(NOMpl) 'I have always considered them boring.'
Agreement in (7) can be with the postverbal nominative NP, or it can be default third-person singular agreement. But the verb cannot be in the first-person singular to agree with the preverbal dative NP, although it passes the subjecthood tests. This means that agreement is not a behavioral subjecthood property. The statement that the verb agrees with the behavioral subject does not work for (7). Nor can we say that the verb agrees with the NP in preverbal position, for example by saying that INFL assigns nominative to preverbal position. The preverbal NP is neither nominative nor the source of agreement (INFL in GB). The sentence in (7) demonstrates another interesting generalization about Icelandic, namely that the verb agrees only optionally with postverbal nominatives. Putting this together with the fact that the verb agrees with the preverbal nominative, we get the following: (8)
Agreement with a preverbal nominative is obligatory but optional with a postverbal nominative.1
If we take surface evidence at face value, then the postverbal NP in the non-agreeing version of (7) must be linked by nominative not agreement. Otherwise, that NP would not be linked, thereby violating the Linking Condition (all NPs must be linked). But the sentence with no agreement with the postverbal nominative NP is fine, so the Linking Condition must not be violated. The linker must be nominative. Another question is of course why we get the pattern in (7), i.e. why agreement is obligatory but not if the nominative NP is postverbal. One account that claims to be explanatory is Van Valin (1991). On his analysis the reason agreement is optional in (7) is that the nominative NP is not
Case, agreement, and word order
175
even potentially a subject. He proposes the generalization that agreement with potential subjects is obligatory. Besides being transderivational, this cannot work for the closely related Old Icelandic, where the facts are the same, but the nominative N P is the subject (as I will show in the next chapter). Nygaard (1905: 67f.) gives abundant examples of postverbal plural subjects and singular agreement. First of all, this can happen especially if one or more words intervene between verb and subject: (9)
a. Magniisi konungi likadi ilia storgjafir Magnus king(DAT) liked(3sg) ill big-gifts(NOMpl) t>aer er Hakon konungr hafdigefit those(NOMpl) which Hakon-NOM king-NOM had given bondum til vinsaeldar ser. farmers(DAT) for friendship self(DAT) 'Magnus the king did not like the presents that Hakon the king had given the farmers for their friendship.'
(Hkr.6313) b. i Imnn tima fannst i DanmQrk kvernsteinar at that time was-found(3sg) in Denmark millstones(NOM) tveir sva miklir tWO(NOM) SO
big(NOM)
'At that time there were in Denmark two millstones so big.' (££.78.41) Nygaard further documents that optional agreement with a postverbal nominative is particularly free with the verb pykkja 'seem,' the Old Icelandic precursor of Modern Icelandic pykja 'think' in (7) above. Thus we find examples like the following (Nygaard (1905: 68)): (10)
mer fcotti vit vera i hellinum me(DAT) seemed(3sg) we to-be in hell-the(DAT) 'It seemed to me that we were in hell.' ( 0 / / . 117.28)
In Old Icelandic the nominative was the subject (see the next chapter), and so Van Valin's explanation cannot hold for it. The nominative is definitely the potential subject (Van Valin's pivot), because it is the subject. Thus the Old Icelandic agreement remains to be explained, and it seems likely that the same explanation should cover both Old and Modern Icelandic. I leave open how the agreement rule should be formulated in Modern and in Old Icelandic and what the exact differences, if any, are.
176
Icelandic
5.1.2 Word order Icelandic is notable for being one of the few rich case languages with relatively fixed word order. In the direct linking framework, it is a question to what extent this is linking by word-order position or not. Any positing of word-order linkers depends on a phrase-structural analysis of the language in question. This area of Icelandic grammar has been the subject of some controversy, especially regarding the question of whether Icelandic has a VP or not. I refer the reader to Thrainsson (1986) for a complete discussion. Nevertheless, it is clear that Icelandic is a V2 language: (11)
a. Eg
hef aldrei hitt Mariu. have(lsg) never met Mary(Acc) 'I have never met Mary.' b. Mariu hef eg aldrei hitt. Mary(ACc) have(lsg) I(NOM) never met 'I have never met Mary.' I(NOM)
The correct generalization is that exactly one constituent may precede the verb. 2 The V2 phenomenon has been a subject of intense study, and analyses of Icelandic (e.g. Holmberg (1986) and Rognvaldsson and Thrainsson (1990) and references there) differ in important respects. Most importantly for present purposes, it is possible to tell the difference between topicalized and subject NPs in Icelandic, as demonstrated at length by Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985) and summarized in §2.1.1 above. Only subjects but not topicalized NPs can undergo Raising, be the antecedents to obligatory reflexivization, participate in inversion, be extracted, be postposed if indefinite, participate in subject ellipsis, and be the targets of control (Equi). Further, it is one of the best-known results of Icelandic syntax that the NP that bears these behavioral subjecthood properties is the NP that occupies the preverbal position in uninverted sentences. There is thus a strong correlation between subjecthood and the pre-VP or preverbal position, depending on whether we posit a VP or not: (12)
a. _VP: SUBJ b. _V: SUBJ
(13)
a. _VP: [ARG] b. _V: [ARG]
Case, agreement, and word order 111 The possibilities in (12) refer to grammatical functions and are one way to capture the relation of subjecthood and the sentence-initial position in Icelandic. The versions in (13) are the possible linkers on the present approach. Before comparing them, notice that, in inversion (lib), the subject appears right after the verb. If one accepts (12a) or (13a) with VP, then either V2 involves movement or the realization of _VP in an inversion sentence as immediate postverbal position. If one chooses (12b) or (13b), then _V should be read as "adjacency to V" rather than as "immediately preceding V." This issue is not central here. Tentatively I accept (13a), although nothing that follows depends on this choice. The main point is to establish that a positional linker with the [ARG] specification interacts with the other linkers in the proper way. The other, mediated linking approach works in this case, since it captures subjecthood and the position directly. The linking in (14) demonstrates that this is also true on the present approach: (14)
hitta ( x
y ) 'meet'
NOM: [ARG]
*NOM: [ARG]
_VP:
*_VP: ACC: [
ACC:
[ARG]
[ ]
[ARG]
]
In this plain transitive with the verb hitta 'meet,' the pre-VP position and the nominative, having [ARG], are the most restrictive linkers applicable to the highest argument. Since Icelandic has the type 1 parameter settings, the LDC will not question the linking of the highest argument, because there is no higher argument. By the RC, the top argument is linked by the nominative and the pre-VP position. This is the highest non-obliquely linked argument and so is the subject. The lower argument cannot get either of these linkers, because that would violate the LDC. The only remaining choice is accusative, which links the lower argument. This argument is a non-highest, non-obliquely linked NP and so is the object. Case and word order are in principle compatible, and, if they are both non-oblique, then the dative subject will automatically be linked by the position as in (15): (15)
Barninu batnadi veikin. child-the(DAT) recovered-from disease-the(NOM) 'The child recovered from the disease.'
The linking is as follows:
178 (16)
Icelandic batna ( X|EXP
y ) 'recover'
DAT: [ARG/GOAL]
NOM: [ARG]
NOM: [ARG]
*_VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ]
_ VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ]
In this case the dative of experiencer is the most restrictive linker that passes the AC for the highest argument and so links the NP. The nominative is not compatible, but the pre-YP position is compatible with the dative and so also links the first argument. The second argument is allowed to be linked by the nominative, since that is not the most restrictive linker of its type (case) applicable to a higher argument. Specifically, the dative is the most restrictive case for the higher argument, so the use of nominative on the other argument is fine. The use of the pre-VP position on the lower argument, on the other hand, would violate the LDC, because pre-VP position is the most restrictive linker of its type, word order, applicable to the higher argument. Because they are of different types and because there is a more restrictive case but not position for the higher argument, the second argument gets nominative but not pre-VP position by the LDC, even though they have the same LINK value, [ARG]. None of the linkers are oblique, so both arguments are grammatically (non-obliquely) linked. The highest grammatically linked argument is the preverbal dative and so is the subject. The other argument is the next highest grammatically linked argument and so is an object. By the LDC and the fact that the pre-VP position is the most restrictive linker of its type, the correlation between word order and subjecthood is captured. Turning to non-highest arguments, consider first whether we could have more than one positional linker without a VP. I will not try to answer this general question, but, before answering it for Icelandic, it will be worthwhile to consider the possibilities. If there is no VP in Icelandic, and if there is positional linking for one or both of the latter arguments in (17), then these positions must be radically different from the positional linkers of English (see the previous chapter): (17)
Eg
sagdi barninu soguna. told child-the(DAT) story(Acc) 'I told the child a story.'
I(NOM)
Case, agreement, and word order
179
If the sentence has a flat structure, i.e. no VP, there can be no linkers like _V', VP-internal position, or _VP. At most there could be V_ for the second NP. It is difficult to see how the last NP could be positionally linked unless by reference to the second NP, but this may be feasible, especially if the word order is fixed. Furthermore, if one's framework allows verb movement, NPs non-adjacent to the verb on the surface could be adjacent to the verb at some other level of structure. Just positing a flat structure is not enough to argue against positional linking for the objects in (17). More convincing evidence against positional linking comes from the low degree of fixedness of the word order in (17). The other order of the NPs in (17), given in (18a), is considered bad style but not as unacceptable as the corresponding sentence in English (18b): (18)
a. Eg
sagdi soguna barninu. told story(Acc) child-the(DAT) 'I told the child a story.' b. *I told a story the child. I(NOM)
Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985) report that the following (based on examples of Rognvaldsson's) are both acceptable: (19)
a. Eg
gaf konungi ambattina gave king(DAT) slave-the(ACc) 'I gave the king his maidservant.' b. Eg gaf ambattina konungi I(NOM) gave slave-the(ACc) king(DAT) 'I gave the maidservant to her king.' I(NOM)
sina. self S(ACC) sinum. self S(DAT)
They note that the dative NP need not be especially heavy in order to appear last.3 For one who wanted to propose positional linking in these sentences, this difference between Icelandic and English must be explained. Even if the verb moves from some position nearer the objects in (18) and (19), the relative freedom of order of the objects is unexpected if they are supposed to bear some relation to a fixed, although invisible, verbal position in the sentence. This question of the extent of positional linking is important in that it distinguishes the analysis here from other direct linking analyses (e.g. Smith 1993), Kiparsky (p.c.)). In particular Kiparsky suggests that it should be a general principle that lexical cases are always oblique unless they are also linked by position. As we have seen, a positionally linked
180
Icelandic
NP can be oblique, as in the case of Dutch and Grisons German goals (previous chapter). On the present theory, a lexical case can simply fail to be oblique. If so, it may be linked by a non-oblique position, but it need not be. I take the relative freedom of the postverbal NPs in Icelandic ditransitives as evidence that we are not dealing with positional linking within the VP in Icelandic. If that is so, then the dative goal NP is predicted to behave as an object without being positionally linked. The dative is a non-oblique lexical case, a possibility expected on this theory. I return to this question in §5.4. In this section we have seen that there seems to be one positional linker in Icelandic. Thus in what follows the actual phrase structure (flat versus VP) is not as important as the positing of one positional linker. 5.2
Case preservation and nominative objects
In the last chapter I showed that one of the first results that falls out from the RC is the priority of lexical case over grammatical case. In this section I will extend this result to what will be seen as a closely related problem: nominative objects. 5.2.1 Case preservation Case preservation on the present account is a special case of the RC. Both kinds of lexical case, idiosyncratic and argument-category, are more restrictive than the grammatical cases nominative and accusative. First consider the by now familiar dative of the object of tyna 'lose': (20)
a. Barnid tyndi bokinni. child-the(NOM) lost book-the(DAT) 'The child lost the book.' b. Bokinni var tynt (af barninu). book-the(DAT) was lost by child-the(DAT) 'The book was lost (by the child).'
In these two sentences, the following three cases are applicable, the dative only to the logical object, the other cases to any of the arguments. Additionally, the pre-VP position can potentially apply to any argument: (21)
a. DAT: [ARG|2] b. NOM: [ARG] c. _VP: [ARG] d. ACC: [ ]
(part of lexical entry of the verb tyna 'lose')
Case preservation and nominative objects
181
Taking the active in (20a) first, we get the linking in (22): (22)
tyna ( x
y ) 'lose'
_ VP: [ARG]
DAT: [ARG/GOALJ
NOM: [ARG]
*_VP:
ACC: [
*NOM: [ARG]
]
ACC:
[ARG]
[ ]
The second argument must get dative by the RC, because it is the most restrictive linker that passes the AC and the LDC for that argument. Note in particular that the dative blocks the accusative, since the environment in (21a) properly includes the environment in (21c). Restrictiveness automatically captures the priority of lexical case. In the active, the nominative is not a possible linker for the second argument, because the LDC rules it out. The problem with the nominative for this lower argument is that nominative is the most restrictive linker of its type applicable to the highest argument. In the passive, however, there is no higher argument than the logical object, and so the nominative is not prohibited on this argument. If the nominative is the most restrictive case applicable to this logical object, as in most passives of transitives, then the nominative applies to the logical object and we get a nominative subject in the passive. With a verb that takes an idiosyncratic case for its logical object, however, the nominative, although not ruled out by the LDC for the logical object in the passive, nevertheless cannot apply to the logical object because it is not the most restrictive case passing the AC and the LDC. Rather the idiosyncratic case must apply by the RC, blocking the nominative (and the accusative): (23)
tyna ( xA
y ) lose' DAT: [ARG I GOAL]
_ VP:
[ARG]
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[ ]
The dative in (21a) is more restrictive than the nominative in (21b) (and the accusative in (21c)) and so wins. The theory correctly predicts a sentence containing only a dative. This dative NP is the subject, because it is the highest non-obliquely linked argument. In a language where lexical case is oblique, e.g. German, the dative NP would be an oblique, and we would have a true impersonal passive. The present approach to case preservation makes all types of rule ordering including the prevalent
182 Icelandic "pre-linking" of lexical case (Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987)) come without any stipulation. Case preservation is captured using the same features needed for distribution in the first place. Further, case preservation is seen to be a special instance of a very general phenomenon. The dative is "preserved" for the very same reason that nominative has priority over the accusative. The RC provides a unified account. 5.2.2 Nominative objects Closely related to case preservation is the so-called "nominative objects" problem (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985), Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987), Sigurdsson (1989), Harbert and Toribio (forthcoming)). The problem consists in the unusual association of nominative case (and agreement) with an NP that is neither in subject position (e.g. Spec of IP in GB) nor shows behavioral subjecthood properties. The reasons why this is a problem is that many theories, and most notably GB, make nominative Case assignment by INFL correlate necessarily with subjecthood. The sentences in question are given in (24) and (25): (24)
Mer lika fcessir bilar. me(DAT) like(pl) these(NOM) cars(NOM) 'I like these cars.'
(25)
Honum voru gefnir fcessir bilar. him(DAT) were(pl) given(m.pl) these(NOM) cars(NOM) 'He was given these cars.'
Example (24) exhibits a dative experiencer subject of the verb lika 'like,' and (25) a dative goal subject of a passive on the ditransitive gefa 'give.' Each of these verbs is typical of their respective classes, psych verbs and ditransitives. For some verbs of the DAT-NOM class and ditransitive passives, the other NP can be subject, but I will deal with this question in the next section on the (a)symmetric object question. For now the focus is on sentences where the dative NP is the subject and the nominative NP is not. In (24) and (25) the dative NP but not the nominative NP shows all the subjecthood properties. They can "raise," as in the following examples (for the full range of tests see Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985)):
Case preservation and nominative objects (26)
Hann telur mer lika Jsessir bilar. he(NOM) believes me(DAT) like these(NOM) cars(NOM) 'He believes me to like these cars.'
(27)
tel honum hafa verid gefnir believe him(DAT) have been given(m.pl) fcessir bilar. these(NOM) cars(NOM) 'He believes me to have been given these cars.'
183
Eg
I(NOM)
The preverbal dative is the subject. If there is only one subject per clause, a standard assumption, then the nominative NP cannot be the subject. It must be an object or something else. This problem carries over into infinitives as well. The case marking in infinitives behaves just as if the covert subject (PRO in GB) were assigned a case, and this is in fact the analysis of Sigurdsson (1989). Exactly when the subject of the infinitive would be dative, the object appears as nominative (29): (28)
Olafur vonast til ad kaupa bilinn. Olaf(NOM) hopes COMP to-buy car-the(Acc) 'Olaf hopes to buy the car.'
(29)
a. Konungurinn vonast til ad verda gefnar king(NOM) hopes COMP to-be given(f.pl) ambattir. slaves(NOM.f.pl) 'The king hopes to be given maidservants?' b. Ad vera gefnar ambattir var to be given(f.pl) slaves(NOM.f.pl) was mikill heidur. great honor 'To be given maidservants was a great honor.' (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985: (52))
The nominative objects are a problem for GB since they get nominative Case, which is assigned by INFL, without being in the Spec of IP position where it is assigned. Many solutions to this problem have been proposed, and many are summarized in Harbert and Toribio (forthcoming). The solution in LFG is quite straightforward. LFG would have the same problem as GB if the rule for nominative were "assign nominative
184 Icelandic to the subject." But instead, Zaenen, Maling and Thrainsson (1985: 466) have the following case-marking rules: (30)
Default Case Marking: the highest available GF is assigned NOM case, the next highest ACC (Universal)
This gets the nominative objects. The assignment rule is an instance of the Case Tier Hypothesis. Case is assigned to GFs (as in (30) or NPs (as in Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (1987)) left-to-right, and the first GF (or NP) that is not pre-specified for a lexical case will get nominative and subsequent NPs accusative. When the first GF is prespecified dative, the second NP is nominative, a nominative object. Although they do not discuss case in infinitives, the Case Tier approach in (30) assumes that GFs with no corresponding NP in c-structure also get case. For the postverbal NP in (29) we might say that the non-overt subject is not available because it is non-overt, causing nominative to appear on the object. But this will not work where the covert subject would not be lexically case-marked as in (28) above. There the covert subject corresponds to a nominative NP in a free-standing clause, and the object of this lower clause in (28) is accusative, not nominative. Given the association principle in (30), the only way the ACC can be assigned to the overt object is for there to be a higher GF that gets the nominative. Otherwise, the overtly expressed GF would be the highest available and get nominative, but it should get the accusative. In the present framework, the case marking of nominative objects follows automatically from the nature of nominative and of accusative cases and the Restrictiveness Constraint. The specifications for nominative, [ARG], and accusative, [ ], were independently justified on the basis of their distribution. Further, the dative of experiencer, [ARG|EXP], and goal, [ARG|GOAL], are similarly justified on distributional grounds. Putting these together with the RC, we get both case preservation (last section) and the explanation of nominative objects. To see why, consider the linking for the passive of the ditransitive: (31)
gefa-PASs ( xA
y|GOAL
z ) 'give'
DAT: [ARG I GOAL]
NOM: [ARG]
NOM: [ARG]
*_VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ]
_ VP: [ARG] [ ]
ACC:
Case preservation and nominative objects
185
Since this is a type 1 language, the LDC questions the linking of lower arguments relative to the possibilities for higher arguments. Given this, it follows that dative, pre-VP position, nominative, and accusative are the possibilities by the AC for the goal argument. In this passive, this is the highest argument, so the LDC cannot disallow any possibilities. From the RC and the incompatibility of two morphological cases, it follows that dative will block nominative. Similarly, dative precludes accusative. Dative and pre-VP position are compatible, so both dative and the position apply. For the next argument, nominative is the most restrictive case that passes the AC and the LDC and so applies. It is just because there is a lexical case applicable to the higher argument that nominative is not the most restrictive linker of its type applicable to the higher argument. This means that the nominative is allowed by the LDC for the lower argument, where it must apply by the RC over the less restrictive accusative. The present theory directly relates the presence of the dative case for the higher argument and the possibility of nominative on the other argument. Both the priority of lexical case and the "highest available" behavior of nominative follow from the same principles, and the connection between lexical case and nominative objects is captured. The notion of "highest available" in the LFG of Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985) and previous direct linking accounts (e.g. Kiparsky (1987)) is not needed. Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson use "highest available G F " and Kiparsky uses "highest available role" to restrict the nominative. Given the parameters behind the case system typology and the RC, the "highest available" aspect of the nominative's distribution follows automatically. Given that Icelandic is type 1, the LDC and the RC ensure that the nominative has "highest available" distribution. This complex distribution is ultimately derived from general principles, the parameters of Chapter 2, and the basic nature of the cases. From the specifications of the linkers, compatibility (morphological and LDC), and the constraints, the nominative objects phenomenon is directly accounted for. Note that all these elements of the account (specifications, compatibility, and constraints) are independently needed and justified, and so in essence the nominative objects account comes for free. More importantly, the approach taken here captures the relation between case preservation and nominative objects. Nominative objects occur on a lower argument when the higher argument is linked by some case more restrictive than the nominative. The nominative in turn is more
186
Icelandic
restrictive than the accusative and so gets that next argument. Case preservation and nominative objects are thus seen to be two manifestations of the same relation: restrictiveness in linking. Note that although the pre-VP position and the nominative have the same syntactic specifications, the compatibility of the word-order position with the lexical case and the incompatibility of nominative with the lexical case cause the characteristic pattern of distribution of the two [ARG] linkers. Since it is compatible with the more restrictive case linker, the pre-VP position always links the highest argument. Since the nominative is not compatible with the dative and is less restrictive, it is forced into its characteristic "highest available" pattern. Thus from the specifications, restrictiveness, and compatibility it is possible to explain the "highest" versus "highest available" behavior of pre-VP position and the nominative.
5.2.3 Nominative objects and control This analysis carries over to the infinitival constructions. This section will deal with control and the next with Raising. Approaches to control or Equi have involved relating two positions, only one of which is "overt." The original transformational rule of EquiNP Deletion related two coreferential NPs in Phrase Structure and deleted the lower of the two. PRO in GB is a coindexed non-overt NP. In lexicalist theories, the two related positions are not NP positions in phrase structure but two positions at functional structure or argument structure, only one of which corresponds to an overt NP. What will be essential to the theory of case we are developing and its relation to control is that the non-overt position receives case. Translating the LFG and HPSG approach to control (Bresnan (1982), Pollard and Sag (1987)) into the present framework, what we need to do is identify two argument positions through coindexing. Thus an Equi verb like vonast til 'hope' should have a partial lexical entry like this: (32)
[vonast til ( wi [verb ( . . . Xi . . . ) ] ) 'hope']
The two arguments are coindexed so they will be coreferential but will not be syntactically identical. Given that there are two arguments, they will be linked separately. They will both need to be linked, even though there is only one position in phrase structure. Henniss (1989) presents arguments from Malayalam that potential NPs such as PRO should also
Case preservation and nominative objects
187
get case, leading her to propose a Determinate Case Principle whose effect is very similar. Furthermore, we must ensure that the target of the control is not oblique. For Icelandic we must further be sure that the target of control is the subject (This may not be universally true (Kroeger (1993)). Lexical entries like (32) should be combined with the following constraint which ensures that the the controllee is the subject: (33)
Controllee Constraint [ verbl ( Wi [ verb2 {... x{ ...)])] D [ verbl ( Wi [ verb2 ( . . . X^-OBL] . . . ) ] > ] and there is no higher non-oblique argument of verb2
If grammatical subjecthood is not a universal condition on controllees, as Kroeger (1993) argues, then the last clause in (33) should be dropped. The specification of non-obliqueness on the controlled argument does, however, seem to be universal. To get the combined argument structure for the sentences in (29) above, we insert the argument structure of the passive of gefa 'give' into the argument structure of vonast til 'hope': (34)
[vonast til ( Wi [gefa-PASS ( xA yi|GOAL[-OBL] z ) 'give'] ) 'hope']
Now if we allow the linkers to apply to all the arguments, including both coindexed ones, we get the following: (35)
[vonast til ( wA [gefa-PASS ( xA yi|GOAL[—OBL] Z ) 'give']) 'hope'] _VP NOM ACC
DAT NOM ACC
NOM ACC
First, the goal argument of the ditransitive passive does satisfy the Controllee Constraint, since it is indeed the highest non-obliquely linked argument of the lower predicate, i.e. it is a covert subject. As for the linking of these arguments, the LDC disallows the use of a linker if it is the most restrictive linker of its type applicable to a higher co-argument. The top argument of the lower verb is not a co-argument of the top argument of the matrix verb and so the LDC does not disallow nominative. The effect is that each of the verbs defines its own case domain. The non-overt argument, the goal, gets the dative by the RC. The lower argument of the lower verb gets nominative for exactly the same reason as the nominative objects in the simple sentences of the last
188 Icelandic section. Since the higher argument of the lower predicate has dative as its most restrictive applicable case, the lower argument is free by the LDC to take nominative. As predicted, this argument even shows agreement in the infinitival construction in (29). More generally, the effect of linking covert arguments is to make the linking of the arguments of embedded predicates work exactly the same as the linking of the arguments in the corresponding simple sentence. If the embedded verb has a covert top argument that is linked by a lexical case, then the next argument will be nominative. If the covert argument is nominative, then the other argument is accusative by the LDC. Far from being caseless like PRO, the covert argument's being linked is central to the account. The present theory, in conjunction with the assumption that covert arguments are linked, captures the similarity of the linking of infinitival complements and simple clauses. The LDC and the RC get exactly the right results for the interaction of case and control, but only under the assumption that non-overt arguments are linked. This does not necessarily mean that phrase structure must contain some empty position PRO, although adoption of such an empty position is consistent with the present theory of linking. Rather, what control shows is that arguments with no phonological content must be linked like any other argument. If phrase structure does not contain any position for the non-overt argument, as in LFG where Equi verbs take VP rather then S' complements, then linking of arguments that do not correspond to NPs must be allowed for. If linking is done at argument structure, this result is hardly surprising. If, however, linking is best done at some postlexical level, then we nevertheless must allow for linking of NP-less arguments. Either way, the present theory of case provides strong motivation for the linking of non-overt arguments in control.
5.2.4 Case preservation and Raising The other infinitival construction that the restrictiveness-based theory of case must take into account is Raising. Traditionally Raising is regarded as the other "NP-Movement" type of construction along with passive. One very striking similarity between passive and Raising in Icelandic is that lexical case is "preserved" in both constructions. Whether or not passive and Raising receive similar analyses, the preservation effect must follow in each case.
Case preservation and nominative objects
189
Raising is different from control in that the argument that is shared between the higher and the lower predicates belongs semantically to the lower predicate but syntactically to the higher predicate. The following sentences are truth-conditionally equivalent, despite the fact that different arguments are raised in (36a) and (36b): (36)
a. John believes the doctor to have examined Bill. b. John believes Bill to have been examined by the doctor.
The paraphrase relation between the embedded active and passive is preserved in Raising. It does not matter which argument is raised. This contrasts with Equi where active and passive do not lead to truthconditional equivalence under embedding: (37)
a. John persuaded the doctor to examine Bill. b. John persuaded Bill to be examined by the doctor.
Most theories distinguish Raising and Equi by the role of the lower argument in the matrix clause. In both Raising and Equi, this NP belongs syntactically to the matrix clause at surface structure, but only in Equi is it semantically an argument of the matrix predicate. The verb persuade entails that the person persuaded is at least sentient. In (37a), this is the doctor, and in (37b) it is Bill. Raising verbs do not entail anything about the raised argument, which is considered to belong semantically to the lower predicate exclusively. The analysis of Equi, following LFG and HPSG, involved coindexation of two arguments. The upper argument is an argument of the upper predicate and can participate in entailment relations involving the matrix predicate. Coindexation would not work for Raising, however, because we do not want an independent argument in the matrix clause. The standard analysis in LFG and HPSG distinguishes Raising from Equi by analyzing Raising as involving structure sharing between the upper and lower predicates. In LFG the values of the grammatical function features of one argument of the higher predicate and one argument of the lower predicate are shared. Since semantic interpretation is off the functional structure, the position in the upper clause will belong to the lower clause semantically. In HPSG, the entire sign for the raised argument is shared between the lower and the higher arguments. The basic insight of these approaches is that the upper argument is essentially a placeholder and that whatever it contributes to the interpretation is only by way of the lower argument. In the present theory, NPs
190
Icelandic
are syntactic arguments if they bear the value ARG for LINK. Any NP that bears ARG is syntactically selected by the verb. What makes an argument more than a placeholder is its value for ARG. SO I will further assume that semantic interpretation will be off values of ARG. This was necessary for argument categories like experiencer and goal, where the interpretation of the argument is constrained by its membership in the argument category. Generalizing this, an argument is interpreted as belonging semantically to whichever predicate it gets its argument category from. If the matrix NP is to be treated as an argument of the lower predicate, what should be shared between the lower and the upper arguments is this value for argument category (and dependent values). A raising verb will have an entry like the following: (38) " NP [LINK [ARG [CAT [...]]]] NP [LINK [ARG [CAT [ \\\ ]]]] believe
SUBCAT
VP | SUBCAT
|p NP ,
LINK [ARG [CAT [...] [T] ]] —OBL
In (38) the verb's list of arguments is the value of a feature SUBCAT as in HPSG. The value ARG takes an Attribute-Value Matrix (AVM) containing the feature CAT (argument category) and its value in turn (e.g. DIR, GOAL). An example is [ ARG [ CAT [ DIR ]]] for an argument belonging to the default category of arguments and [ ARG [ CAT [ GOAL ]]] for a syntactic goal. This value for ARG is shared between the complement verb's argument and the upper verb's argument.4 This means that the upper argument will be interpreted just like an argument of the lower predicate. Representations like (38) are cumbersome, and for convenience I will represent this informally using a line connecting the arguments which share values of ARG: (39)
[verbl (. . . x . . .[ verb2 (. . . Z[-OBL]. . . ) ] ) ]
The lower verb, verb2, is the verb heading the VP complement. There are two argument positions in the structure, and so both must be linked. However, as in LFG and HPSG, there will be only one position in the phrase structure for an argument and that will be in the upper clause. The lower verb cannot combine with an NP that corresponds to this argument. Overall, the lower clause will correspond to a VP in the syntax. Thus the lexical entry for a verb like believe is as follows:
Case preservation and nominative objects (40)
believe ( x
y
191
[verb (. . . Z[-OBL]. . . ) ] )
i
i
The fact that the argument belongs semantically to the lower clause follows from the fact that the upper argument position shares structure, namely the value of ARG, with the lower argument, which is in turn the input to semantic interpretation of the lower predicate. As for linking, the only novel aspect about linking for arguments like the second argument of believe is that there are two sources for applicable linkers. This argument will be eligible by the AC for (i) all the linkers that apply by virtue of its syntactic selection by the verb believe ([ARG] and default linkers) and (ii) all linkers that can apply by virtue of the shared material with the argument of the lower clause. So if the lower argument belongs to some argument category that receives a special case or if it is assigned an idiosyncratic case, then this information is passed up to the higher argument and the lexical case is applicable there as well. This will be our account of case preservation in Raising. Turning back now to the Icelandic examples of Raising, we must explain the following: (41)
J)eir telja Mariu hafa skrifad ritgerdina they(NOM) believe Mary(ACc) to-have written thesis-the(Acc) They believe Mary to have written her thesis.'
First, the lexical entry for telja 'believe' will be similar to that for English believe: (42)
telja (x
y [verb (. . . z[—OBL]. . . ) ] ) 'believe'
The lower verb, skrifa 'write', has an ordinary transitive lexical entry: (43)
skrifa ( x y ) 'write'
When the larger argument structure is created out of the argument structure of telja 'believe' and the argument structure for skrifa 'write,' then we get (44): (44)
telja ( w x
[skrifa (y[—OBL] Z ) 'write' ] ) 'believe'
Now if the linkers apply to this combined argument structure, then we get the following:
192 Icelandic (45)
telja ( w NOM
VP ACC
x [skrifa ( y[-OBL]
z ) 'write' ] ) 'believe'
*NOM
*NOM
*_VP ACC
NOM
_VP
*_VP
ACC
ACC
This gets the correct cases in the correct places. To see how, consider first the upper predicate. As usual, the highest argument gets nominative over accusative and the pre-VP position is compatible. For the next argument, the linkers that might apply (pass the AC) are those that it would get by being a syntactic argument of the upper predicate (nominative, pre-VP position, accusative). No lexical cases refer to the shared material, so no extra linkers apply. By the LDC neither nominative nor pre-VP position is applicable. For the lower predicate, the highest argument is linked as highest arguments usually are, but in the phrase structure there is no place for it, and so it cannot show its linking overtly. An alternative that must be considered is that the lack of nominative in the last example is due to the incompatibility of agreement and infinitivals. On this alternative, if we take agreement to be the real linker, we could say that, since the lower verb is infinitival, there can be no agreement and so no nominative, and similarly there is no preverbal position available. Or raising might be said to absorb nominative case. However, these approaches would have the additional problem of the nominative objects again. If an argument that corresponds to a lexically case marked NP in the active is "raised," then the other argument gets nominative (example from Andrews (1982: 464)): (46)
Hann telur barninu i barnaskap sinum hafa he(NOM) believes child-the(DAT) in foolishness self s to-have batnad veikin. recovered-from disease-the(NOM) 'In his foolishness he believes the child to have recovered from the disease.'
It cannot be true that raising in any way absorbs agreement-nominative, since the lower verb agrees with the nominative NP in (46). The present analysis of (46) is as follows, with the lexical entry for batna 'recover' combined with the lexical entry for telja 'believe': (47)
batna ( X|EXP y ) 'recover from'
Case preservation and nominative objects (48)
telja (w
193
x [batna (y|EXp[-OBL] z) 'recover from'] ) 'believe'
NOM
DAT
DAT
NOM
_VP
*NOM
NOM
*_VP
ACC
*_VP
_FP
ACC
ACC
ACC
The only difference here is the applicability of the experiencer dative. Since argument category is shared from the lower argument to the higher argument, the dative of the argument category experiencer is applicable in both clauses. The LDC does not rule out identical linking across a predicate boundary, so both the lower argument and the higher argument are dative. As in other nominative object constructions, the LDC allows nominative for the last argument, and this is the correct result. We can thus explain why the nominative is available for the non-raised argument just in case the raised argument would get non-nominative case (46) and why the lower argument gets accusative when the raised argument would get nominative (41). On the present analysis this is because the raised argument does get two cases. This two-case analysis contrasts with the HPSG analysis where the entire sign for the raised NP is structure-shared. Because the case on the second argument of the lower predicate in the present theory depends so much on what case the higher argument gets, we have no choice but to say that only the argument specifications are shared but not case. Values of ARG are shared, but the values for linkers (REAL) are not. Case is assigned to subcategorized NPs, and, there being two of these in the matrix SUBCAT list, there are two Unkings. The matrix argument is a syntactic argument of both predicates, but its ARG path comes from the lower predicate, and so it is only a semantic argument of the lower predicate. Since case depends on the specifications of the arguments and the specifications are shared, the same cases will be applicable to the arguments in the sharing relationship. Which linkers actually apply depends on the LDC and the RC in both clauses. We can explain why dative but not nominative is "preserved" under raising. Unlike in HPSG, case is not shared directly. Preservation only occurs when the linker is applicable by referring to the shared material, but type 1 nominative does not refer to the value of [ARG] but [ARG] itself. Lexical cases are preserved because they both pass the LDC (no higher argument in the upper clause has this linker as a possibility), and the RC requires it as the most restrictive linker passing the AC and the LDC. 5
194 5.3
Icelandic Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
In this section I will address the question of whether Icelandic is a symmetric- or an asymmetric-object language. Symmetric-object languages are those in which either of the two lower arguments of a ditransitive shows primary-object behavior, e.g. the ability to be the subject of a passive. In asymmetric-object languages, only the higher of the internal arguments can be primary object. Icelandic shows elements of both patterns. As is well known, lexical case in Icelandic interacts with the ability of a ditransitive to passivize on the lowest argument. One class, the NOM-DAT-ACC class, represented by segja 'tell' below, allows either object to passivize, while all other ditransitives only allow the goal to passivize. Therefore, the question of whether Icelandic is a symmetric- or an asymmetric-object language has no ready answer. Icelandic seems to be symmetric for the segja 'tell' class but asymmetric for the others. The proper question to ask is: is Icelandic basically symmetric, asymmetric, or neither. I will present evidence that Icelandic is basically symmetric, but that the symmetric-object question is more complex than the setting of a parameter for the whole language. Icelandic has the symmetric value for the symmetric-object parameter for ditransitives, but the assignment of idiosyncratic case blocks symmetric-object behavior for the non-NOM-DAT-ACC classes. It also shows symmetric behavior with some two-argument verbs. This mixed behavior requires a more fine-grained approach to symmetric objects than a single parameter setting. I will show how the treatment of the symmetric-object parameter in the present theory predicts the full range of phenomena in Icelandic. Before trying to locate Icelandic within the range of possibilities that languages have for ditransitives, it is necessary to lay out the three main types of language. Ditransitive passives are of interest, because they contain two arguments after the suppression of the highest argument of the active counterpart. The first division among languages with respect to ditransitives is between what Bresnan and Moshi (1990) call "symmetric-" and "asymmetric-object" languages. In the symmetric-object languages, either of the two lower arguments of a ditransitive can show primaryobject behavior. Most strikingly, either can be the subject of a ditransitive passive, leaving the other argument behind as some type of object. In asymmetric-object languages, on the other hand, only one of the two lower arguments shows primary-object behavior, and only that
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
195
argument can be the subject of a ditransitive passive. Of languages we have examined already, Japanese is symmetric, and German is asymmetric with only the non-goal showing primary-object behavior. One dialect of English is asymmetric with only the goal as primary object. Japanese is typical of symmetric-object languages. In Japanese ditransitives, the goal is marked by the dative particle -ni and the lowest argument receives the accusative (-o or _V): (49)
Daitooryoo ga gakusei ni kunsyoo o ataeta. president NOM student DAT medal ACC gave 'The president gave a medal to the student.'
As indicated in §3.1 above, the proper treatment of lexical cases in Japanese in the present theory involves specifying them [-HA] like the accusative (-o) and the V-adjacent position (_V). The dative will by hypothesis be as follows: (50)
DAT: [ARG|GOAL|—HA]
The ditransitive in (49) forms two passives: (51)
a. Kunsyoo ga daitooryoo ni (yotte) gakusei medal NOM president by student ni atae-rare-ta. DAT give-PASS-PAST
'A medal was given to the student by the president.' b. Gakusei ga daitooryoo ni kunsyoo o atae-rare-ta. student NOM president by medal ACC give-PASS-PAST T h e student was given a medal by the president.' As evidenced by (51), Japanese is a symmetric-object language. On the present scheme, a necessary condition for one argument to outrank another in GF is for it to outrank it on the argument structure. The fact that either of two arguments can outrank the other in the passive of a ditransitive in Japanese suggests that each ditransitive is associated with two argument structures differing minimally in the order of the lowest two arguments. A conventional approach on ordered argument theories is to allow an operation permuting the lower two arguments of a ditransitive (see, e.g. Uszkoreit (1987)): (52)
Symmetric Object Operation (Optional) verb ( x y z ) -» verb ( x z y )
196 Icelandic The Symmetric-Object Parameter here is the presence or absence of this operation in a language. Symmetric-object languages have (52); asymmetric-object languages do not. This operation permuting arguments is not associated with any morphology, making it quite unlike the passive. Furthermore, as we will see, a major constraint on such permutation seems to be that only adjacent arguments may flip. This suggests that the operation, if it is an operation, is not one of permutation but rather one which suspends the order of two arguments. I will return to this possibility later. Turning back to the ditransitive in Japanese, we see first that the goal passive works as follows: (53)
give-PASS ( xA
y|GOAL NOM: [
z) ]
ACC: [ARG/—HA] NOM:
[ ]
Japanese, being type 2, has the low value of the Preference Parameter, so that the LDC will question the linking of higher arguments in the light of the most restrictive linkers of each type applicable to lower arguments. On the lower argument, the accusative and nominative compete, and the LDC says nothing about the linking, because there is no lower argument to compare with. The accusative is more restrictive than the nominative and so applies. On the goal argument, the accusative and the dative cannot apply, because the goal is the highest argument, and those cases have [-HA] (similarly for V-adjacent position which I am leaving out for expositional ease). The nominative, although the least restrictive, is the only possible case. The other passive is the result of passivizing the verb whose argument structure has undergone the Symmetric-Object Operation. In this other passive, we get roughly the same linking: (54)
give-PASS ( xA
z NOM: f
y|GOAL ) ]
DAT:
[ARG/GOAL/—HA]
ACC: [ARG|-HA] NOM:
[ ]
This time the goal is lowest argument and so all three cases might apply by the AC, and the LDC has nothing to say about the linking of this argument, because there is no lower argument. The dative applies by the RC, since it is most restrictive. For the highest argument, i.e. z, the
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
197
accusative this time is not applicable, since it has [—HA]. The only remaining possibility is nominative. One dialect of English is asymmetric. In a ditransitive passive, only the goal may be the subject of the passive: (55)
John gave Mary the book.
(56)
a. Mary was given the book, b. *The book was given Mary.
Unlike Japanese, the ditransitive passive with the "theme" in subject position is ungrammatical (56b) for such speakers. This is expected if the goal is consistently higher than the other remaining argument, which it will be if this dialect lacks the Symmetric-Object Operation (52). In the passive the goal is the highest grammatically linked argument and so the subject (see Chapter 3 for details). German also appears to be an asymmetric object language, but it only allows the other, non-goal, argument to passivize. I will argue that this type of asymmetric-object language really is not asymmetric. The appearance of asymmetric behavior stems from the obliqueness of the lexical cases including the goal dative. In a ditransitive, the goal may not be the subject: (57)
Der Schiiler hat dem Lehrer einen Apfel gegeben. the(NOM) pupil has the-DAT teacher a(ACc) apple given T h e pupil gave the teacher an apple.'
(58)
a. Dem Lehrer ist ein Apfel gegeben worden. the(DAT) teacher ist an(NOM) apple given become(pAss) 'An apple was given to the teacher.' b. Ein Apfel ist dem Lehrer gegeben worden. an(NOM) apple is the(DAT) teacher given become(pAss) 'An apple was given to the teacher.'
Although two word orders are possible for the German ditransitive passive, both orders reflect the same functional structure. In both (58a) and (58b), the nominative NP is the subject, unlike in Icelandic. Recall from Chapter 1 that Icelandic and German differ in the status of their lexically case-marked NPs. Icelandic is well known for its false obliques: lexically case-marked NPs which behave nonetheless as terms. German, however, does not have this property. So in the dative experiencer construction, the dative NP was not the subject in German (but was in Icelandic). The
198
Icelandic
lexically case-marked NPs fail all the subjecthood tests. So too the dative goal in the ditransitive passive does not behave as the subject, e.g. it cannot be the target of control: (59)
*Er hofft einen Apfel gegeben zu werden. he(NOM) hopes an(Acc) apple given to become 'He hopes to be given an apple.'
But the other NP can be the target of control: (60)
Der Sklave hofft dem Konig gegeben zu werden. the(NOM) slave hopes the(DAT) king given to become 'The slave hopes to be given to the king.'
Thus, German appears to be asymmetric with only the non-goal passivizable. But consider the definition of subject, which any subject of a ditransitive passive or any other passive must satisfy: it must be the highest grammatically linked argument of its clause. Since syntactic goals (argument category GOAL), are linked by an oblique case, dative, the NPs corresponding to GOAL arguments are never terms and hence never highest terms, i.e. never subjects. The "asymmetric" behavior of ditransitives in German follows directly from the status of lexical case in German. Ditransitive verbs in Icelandic take a wide range of case frames. I illustrate these case frames in (61) (Thrainsson (1979: 21-2)): (61)
a. t>eir leyndu Olaf sannleikanum. they(NOM) concealed Olaf(Acc) truth-the(DAT) 'They concealed the truth from Olaf.' (NOM-ACC-DAT) b. Jon bad mig bonar. John(NOM) asked me(ACc) favor(GEN) 'John asked me a favor.' (NOM-ACC-GEN) c. Eg sagdi J>er soguna. I(NOM) told you(DAT) story(ACc) 'I told you a story.' (NOM-DAT-ACC) d. Olafur lofadi Mariu ^essum hring. Olaf(NOM) promised Mary(DAT) this-DAT ring(DAT) 'Olaf promised Mary this ring.' (NOM-DAT-DAT) e. Maria oskadi Olafi alls gods. Mary(NOM) wished Olaf(DAT) everything(GEN) good(GEN) 'Mary wished Olaf everything good.' (NOM-DAT-GEN)
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric? 199 The fact that the subject is nominative follows from the system above. Icelandic is type 1 which will result in the [ARG] linkers both applying to the highest argument, as long as there is no more restrictive lexical case to displace the nominative. As for the lowest argument, it can get any of the three remaining cases. At the very least, we need special datives and genitives for (61a,d) and (61b,e), respectively. Finally, the middle NP is a goal in all of the sentence types in (61), and so the datives in (61c-e) follow directly from the general dative for goals. The accusative second arguments in (61a,b) are goals semantically without belonging to the syntactic argument category goal. Recall that syntactic goals are semantic goals but not necessarily vice versa. We have already seen accusative goals in Classical Greek which behave as arguments of default category (direct).6 Putting these pieces together, we get the following lexical entries for the verbs in (61): (62)
a. leyna ( x y z ) 'conceal' DAT: [ARG13]
b. bidja ( x y z ) 'ask for' GEN: [ARG 13] c. segja ( x y|GOAL z ) 'tell' d. lofa ( x y|GOAL z ) 'promise' DAT: [ARG13]
e. oska ( x y|GOAL z ) 'wish' GEN: [ARG13]
Note that the entries in (62) make some correct predictions about the relative frequency of the different classes of ditransitives, if we assume that relative markedness should predict relative frequency. In particular the NOM-DAT-ACC pattern should be most common, since it is the least marked. The class in (62c) both has the least number of specifications and is subject to fewer of the more restrictive cases. Yip, Maling, and Jackendoff (citing a verb list in Maling ms.) show that the NOM-DATACC pattern is by far the most common with more than seventy-five entries, compared to twenty-five for the NOM-ACC-DAT pattern which is the next highest. The other verb classes have smaller numbers, about which it is harder to draw statistical conclusions. Following previous authors I take the lack of a NOM-ACC-ACC frame to be an accidental gap. 7 Some of the lexical entries in (62) contain idiosyncratic cases which have scope over only that entry. Some contain arguments of the category
200
Icelandic
goal, to which dative is regularly assigned. Putting these cases together with the other linkers proposed for Icelandic, we have the following inventory of linkers applicable with ditransitives: (63)
a.
DAT: [ARG|3]
b.
GEN: [ARG|3]
(part of the lexical entry of leyna 'conceal,' lofa 'promise,' etc.) (part of the lexical entry of bidja 'ask for,' oska 'wish,' etc.)
c. DAT: [ARG|GOAL]
d. NOM: [ARG] e. _VP: [ARG] f. ACC: [ ] In connection with (63) the natural question arises whether we need multiple dative cases in (63a,c) or whether they could be collapsed. All the datives are morphologically the same, including all allomorphy. All this may mean is that each of the syntactically distinct datives makes reference to the same dative paradigm. This is symbolized with the label DAT. It is a separate question whether the datives are syntactically unitary or distinct. The present theory provides some justification for making a synchronic syntactic distinction between the datives. If the LDC holds in Icelandic, which by hypothesis it should, then we are actually forced into the position that the two datives in (6Id) are syntactically distinct. If goal datives and idiosyncratic datives came from the same syntactic case (or, alternatively, were outputs of the same rule), then (6Id) is a clear violation of the LDC. To the extent that the LDC is motivated both cross-linguistically and within the grammar of Icelandic, there is solid motivation for the separateness of the two datives. Pushing this point further, the most obvious way the two datives are different is that one marks goals and the other does not. Thus we have yet more evidence for the argument category GOAL or some representation of goalhood at argument structure. Ditransitives in Icelandic show two patterns with respect to the passive. The NOM-DAT-ACC class allows either object to passivize and become subject. If the goal is passivized, the dative case remains (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985: 460)): (64)
a. Konunginum voru gefnar ambattir. king-the(DAT) were given(f.pl) slaves(NOM.f.pl) 'The king was given maidservants.'
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
201
b. Ambattin var gefin konunginum. slave-the(NOM.f.sg) was given(f.sg) king-the(DAT) 'The maidservant was given to the king.' That the preverbal NP in both (64a) and (64b) is a subject is now well known. For complete details, see Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985: 461f.). Of their seven tests I will reproduce just one, subject-verb inversion. Subjects but not topics show inversion, making inversion a test for behavioral subjecthood. For both of the sentences in (64), the preverbal NP shows inversion: (65)
a. Voru konunginum gefnar ambattir? were king-the(DAT) given(f.pl) slaves(NOM.f.pl) 'Was the king given maidservants?' b. Var ambattin gefin konunginum? was slave-the(NOM.f.sg) given(f.sg) king-the(DAT) 'Was the maidservant given to the king?'
Thus, as is true for all passives in symmetric object languages, NOM-DATACC ditransitives in Icelandic allow either passive. The other classes in the passive all show asymmetric-object behavior: only the immediately postverbal NP in the active passivizes. The NOMDAT-DAT class in (61d) is representative. Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985: 459) demonstrate the behavior of this class with skila 'return'. The active has the NOM-DAT-DAT pattern: (66)
Eg skiladi henni peningunum. I(NOM) returned her(DAT) money-the(DAT) 'I returned her the money.'
As with all of the remaining verbs, skila 'return' only allows the postverbal NP, the goal, to passivize: (67)
a. Henni var skilad peningunum. her(DAT) was returned money-the(DAT) 'She was returned the money.' b. *Peningunum var skilad henni. money-the(DAT) was returned her(DAT) 'The money was returned (to) her.'
Furthermore, only the goal in the passive in (67) can raise, showing that it alone is the subject:
202 (68)
Icelandic a. Eg
tel henni hafa verid skilad I(NOM) believe her(DAT) to-have been returned peningunum. money-the(DAT) 'I believe her to have been returned the money.' b. *Eg tel peningunum hafa verid I(NOM) believe money-the(DAT) to-have been skilad henni. returned her(DAT) 'I believe the money to have been returned (to) her.'
Only the second but not the third argument of all ditransitives of these other classes can become the subject in a passive. This asymmetric-object behavior is characteristic of all but the NOM-DAT-ACC verbs. Since, for all the verbs in the asymmetric class, the non-passivizing argument is idiosyncratically case marked, it is tempting to say that idiosyncratic case prevents these NPs from passivizing. The simplest way to implement this would be to say that these idiosyncratic cases are oblique. This simple solution cannot work since the lowest argument can passivize if it is the only overt postverbal argument: (69)
a. Eg skiladi peningunum. I(NOM) returned money-the(DAT) 'I returned the money.' b. Peningunum var skilad. money-the(DAT) was returned 'The money was returned.'
Further, if the goal surfaces as a prepositional phrase, then the "theme" also can passivize (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985: 460)): (70)
a. Eg skiladi peningunum I(NOM) returned money-the(DAT) 'I returned the money to her.' b. Peningunum var skilad til money-the(DAT) was returned to 'The money was returned to her.'
til hennar. to her(GEN) hennar. her(GEN)
The sentences with the PP goal (70) behave exactly as the sentences without an overt goal (69), with the dative NP passing the behavioral subjecthood tests (Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985)). In light of (69)
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
203
and (70), it is not possible to make the inability of the lowest argument of the non-NOM-DAT-ACC ditransitives dependent on the nature of the idiosyncratic case. If one said that the dative for the lowest argument of skila 'return' is oblique, one would wrongly predict that the dative NP in (69) and (70) should be non-subjects, which is incorrect. The correct generalization for the data so far is that the lowest argument of a ditransitive can passivize only if a) it is not lexically case-marked or b) it is the only NP eligible to be subject in the passive. If both conditions fail, the lowest argument cannot passivize. Only if at least one of these conditions holds can the lowest argument passivize. Thus accusative lowest arguments passivize (condition (a) holds), and solitary dative and genitive argument NPs passivize (condition (b) holds, e.g. ((69), (70)). I would now like to show how the split properties of Icelandic grammar with respect to the symmetric-object parameter follow from the theory being developed. The basics are that Icelandic has the Symmetric-Object Operation permuting the lower two arguments of ditransitives in general, but that the designation for lexical case blocks the additional argument order. Recall that I am assuming a hierarchical argument structure. Thus for a basic ditransitive, the argument structure is as follows: (71)
verb ( x y|GOAL z )
If Icelandic has the symmetric-object operation, then we have the following order in addition: (72)
verb ( x z y|GOAL )
If a ditransitive is formed on this argument structure, then the "theme" will be the subject. By hypothesis, Icelandic is a symmetric-object language, i.e. it has statement (52). In the present framework we are almost forced to this hypothesis because there is no other way to account for the symmetric behavior displayed by the unmarked DAT-ACC verbs. Thus for the verb segja 'tell,' the lexical entry is as in (62c), repeated here: (73)
segja ( x y|GOAL z ) 'tell'
This entry qualifies for the operation in (52) and so allows both orders: (74)
a. segja ( x y|GOAL z ) 'tell' b. segja ( x z y|GOAL ) 'tell'
204
Icelandic
The order in (74a) results in (64a), and the one in (74b) results in (64b). Thus if (74a) is chosen and passive is done, suppressing the top argument, then the goal is subject as demonstrated in (65a). This order (74a) is universally available. The other order (74b) is also available, since Icelandic by hypothesis is basically symmetric for the ditransitives, i.e. has the Symmetric-Object Operation. The extra order in (74b) in the passive will have the "theme" as subject as in (64b). The two possibilities are presented in (75): (75)
a. segja-PAss ( xA
y | GOAL
z ) 'tell'
DAT: [ARG/GOAL]
NOM: [ARG]
NOM: [ARG]
b. segja-PAss ( xA
*_VP: [ARG] [ ]
_ VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ] z
ACC:
NOM: [ARG]
DAT: [ARG I GOAL]
_ VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ]
*NOM: [ARG]
y | GOAL ) 'tell'
*_VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ]
Note that in the first of the pair, the goal is the highest non-obliquely linked argument and so is the subject. In the other order (75b), the nongoal argument is the subject. Generally the lower two arguments of a ditransitive permute. This leads to the symmetric-object behavior, since either of these arguments can be the primary object (subject in the passive), depending on whether the permutation is carried out or not. The other class of ditransitives, the class with an idiosyncratic case on the lowest argument in the unmarked order, do not show symmetric-object behavior. The generalization is that verbs that assign idiosyncratic case do not allow the permutation of their lowest arguments. The idiosyncratic case is assigned to one of the arguments that might permute, so the generalization seems to be the following: (76)
An argument assigned idiosyncratic case may not permute.
This might be left as a possibly language-specific stipulation or it may reflect a general principle. I return to this question after showing how (76) would work as a stipulation. Note that as a stipulation it woulcj have much the same effect as Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson's (1985) language-specific rule assigning the lowest available GF to case-marked
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
205
themes. Case-marked themes will, then, never outrank goals. In a ditransitive passive, the goal must be the subject, if there is a goal. Case-marked themes may only be the subject of the passive if there is no other argument. The behavior of the quirky case ditransitives follows from (76). For these verbs the lexical entry is like that in (77) for skila 'return': (77) skila ( x y|GOAL z ) 'return' DAT: [ARG|3]
This argument structure does not allow permutation, because one of the arguments that would be permuted is assigned idiosyncratic case. Since an entry with the reverse order of the lower two arguments is out, the grammar will not generate passives with the z argument of these verbs as subject. We only get the following goal passive, not the theme passive: (78)
a. skila-PASs ( xA
y| GOAL
z ) 'return'
DAT: [ARG/GOAL] NOM: [ARG]
*_VP: [ARG] ACC: [ ]
NOM: [ARG]
_VP: [ARG] []
ACC:
b. *skila-PASs ( xA z
y| GOAL ) 'return'
NOM: [ARG]
DAT: [ARG I GOAL]
_ VP: [ARG] [ ]
*NOM: [ARG]
*_VP: [ARG] [ ]
ACC:
ACC:
The only well-formed passive will have the goal as the subject. As for the sentences in which the goal is not expressed (69) or is expressed by a PP (70), the passivizability of the remaining lexically case-marked argument also follows. The linking for (69) is as follows. Unlike for Japanese implicit arguments, we must assume that the goal argument is not linked. One way this can be done is to follow Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985) in saying that verbs like skila have the goal as an optional argument. Thus the revised lexical entry for skila 'return' is as follows: (79)
skila ( x
(y|GOAL)
z
) 'return'
GEN: [ARG|3]
The linking for (69) is as follows with the non-goal expansion:8
206 (80)
Icelandic skila ( xA
z
) 'return'
GEN: [ARG/3]
_ VP:
[ARG]
NOM: [ARG] ACC:
[
]
The genitive is the most restrictive and so links the non-suppressed argument. The pre-VP position is compatible and so also applies. This argument is the highest non-oblique argument (it is the only argument) and so is the subject. The PP in (70) might be said to arise in one of two ways. Either it is an adjunct added to (80), or it is linked by the preposition as an argument (cf. English to). The latter, however, is unlikely, since the preposition til does not generally link goal arguments. So I take the PP to be an adjunct PP. The interesting possibility is that the interaction of case and the symmetric-object parameter, stipulated on a language-specific basis in (76), actually follows from general principles on the present theory. What is noteworthy is that the argument permutation and idiosyncratic case both refer to one of the arguments of a ditransitive verb. The permutation operation refers to ditransitive verbs in general, while the idiosyncratic case refers to one verb in particular. It has scope over only that entry. It is possible that the blocking of the permutation by the presence of the idiosyncratic case is an instance of Elsewhere-type blocking. In this case, it would follow from a general condition which would have the RC as a special case. This general condition would compare not only LINK values but other environmental specifications. The specifications of a lexical entry with an idiosyncratic case would then properly contain those of the permutation operation: (81)
a. verb ( x y z ) - ^ verb ( x z y ) b. skila ( x (y|GOAL) z ) 'return' GEN
The idiosyncratic case will block the symmetric-object operation because it refers to the lowest argument but in a more specific way. I will not formulate exactly what should count as the environmental specification but will leave this open for further work. There is in fact good evidence from Icelandic that the permutation of arguments can be lexically stipulated, making permutation and lexical case more similar than they might otherwise appear. The present account
Is Icelandic symmetric or asymmetric?
207
also extends to the class of verbs first noticed by Bernodusson (1982: 38) which allow either the dative or the nominative to be the subject. (82)
a. t>etta this(NOM) This loan b. ]3etta this(NOM) 'Sven had
Ian hafdi Sveini stadid loan(NOM) had Sven(DAT) stood had been on offer to Sven.' Ian hafdi stadid Sveini loan(NOM) had stood Sven(DAT) this loan on offer.'
til boda. for offer til boda. for offer
In (82a) the dative NP Sveini immediately follows the finite verb like a subject, but in (82b) it follows the past participle like an object. Other subjects cannot follow the past participle (Bernodusson (1982: 38)): (83)
a. Pali hafdi Paul(DAT) has T h e teacher has b. *Pali hafdi Paul(DAT) has T h e teacher has
kennarinn hjalpad. teacher-the(NOM) helped helped Paul.' hjalpad kennarinn. helped teacher-the(NOM) helped Paul.'
Here the nominative NP is the subject, and if the object is topicalized as in (83), the subject must immediately follow the finite verb. However, with standa til boda 'be on offer,' the NP Sveini can appear either immediately following the finite verb or after the participle. To further test whether this verb, standa til boda 'be on offer', really has two possible GF assignments, we can try the subject-verb inversion test. Recall that Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985) showed that subjects, both nominative subjects and lexically case-marked subjects, do participate in inversion but that topics do not. For standa til boda 'be on offer,' either NP can invert like a subject: (84)
a. Hefur honum nokkurn tima stadid !>etta has him(DAT) any(Acc) time(ACc) stood this(NOM) til boda? for offer 'Has he ever had this on offer?' b. Hefur Jsetta nokkurn tima stadid honum has this(NOM) any(ACc) time(ACc) stood him(DAT) til boda? for offer 'Has this ever been on offer to him?'
208
Icelandic
Other verbs that seem to work this way, i.e. allow either the dative or the nominative to be subject, are sdrna 'wound,' hugnast 'like,' among others. What this means on the present approach is that argument permutation is not just a parameter at the level of entire grammars but rather can be lexically stipulated. The verbs like standa til boda 'be on offer' and hugnast 'like' permute their arguments on an idiosyncratic basis. The small class of verbs which do this apparently has no semantic unity. Near synonyms can show different behavior. For instance, lika 'like' allows only the dative to be subject, but hugnast 'like' allows either the dative or the nominative to be subject. One generalization is that the verbs that allow either to be subject are a small class including many rare and literary sounding verbs. The way to handle this in the present approach is to say that some verbs exceptionally call for the additional symmetric argument order. So for hugnast 'like' we have the following: (85)
hugnast ( X|EXP y ) 'like' -> hugnast ( y X|EXP ) 'like'
The important conclusion to draw is that the "symmetric-object parameter" needs to admit lexical exceptions. A language cannot just select one value once and for all as in current LFG. To sum up, Icelandic is basically symmetric for ditransitives, because it has the permutation operation. Lexical case blocks this operation, possibly by a generalized RC. Furthermore, argument permutation can be stipulated by individual verbs, just like idiosyncratic case. What Icelandic demonstrates is the need for a more fine-grained approach to the symmetric-object parameter.
5.4
Coordination
One way to distinguish the predictions made by the present account of Icelandic case and previous accounts is in coordination. I first sketch out two other approaches and then contrast them with the present one on the basis of coordination data. One reason Icelandic presents such a challenge to linguistic theories is that its grammatical function behavior does not match well with its case morphology. This problem is most acute for direct linking which seeks the tightest possible connection between Case and case. If grammatical functions did not correlate with the surface morphosyntax, then it would
Coordination
209
be necessary to abandon direct linking in its strongest form. In this section, I will review some previous analyses of Icelandic. It will become apparent that the behavior of Icelandic has led to the exploitation in various theories of precisely the freedom direct linking does not allow: a separation of grammatical functions and surface morphosyntax. In the classic analysis of Zaenen, Maling, and Thrainsson (1985), the following principles for Icelandic are proposed: (86)
Icelandic Association Principles a. If there is only one thematic role, it is assigned to SUBJ; if there are two, they are assigned to SUBJ and OBJ; if there are three, they are assigned to SUBJ, OBJ, 2OBJ. (Universal) b. AGENTS are linked to SUBJ. (Univers