SEDIMENTARY FACIES ANALYSIS
Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading E...
157 downloads
2087 Views
52MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
SEDIMENTARY FACIES ANALYSIS
Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading Edited by A. Guy Plint © 1995 The International Association of Sedimentologists ISBN: 978-0-865-42898-0
S P E C I A L P U B LI CA TI O N N U M B E R 22 I N T E R N A T I O NA L A S S OCIA T I O N
OF
THE
OF S ED I M E N T O L O GI S T S
Sedimentary Facies Analysis A TRIBUTE TO THE RESEARCH AND TEACHING OF HAROLD G. READING
EDITED BY A. GUY
b
Blackwell Science
PLINT
© 1995
The International Association
of Sedimentologists and published for them by Blackwell Science Ltd Editorial Offices: Osney Mead, Oxford OX2 OEL
DISTRIBUTORS
Marston Book Services Ltd PO Box 87 Oxford OX2 ODT
(Orders:
Tel: 01865 791155 Fax: 01865 791927
25 John Street, London WClN 2BL
Telex: 837515)
23 Ainslie Place, Edinburgh EH3 6AJ 238 Main Street, Cambridge Massachusetts 02142, USA 54 University Street, Carlton Victoria 3053, Australia
USA Blackwell Science, Inc. 238 Main Street Cambridge, MA 02142
(Orders:
Tel: 800 215-1000
Other Editorial Offices:
617 876-7000
Arnette Blackwell SA 1, rue de Lille, 75007 Paris France Blackwell Wissenschafts-Verlag GmbH KurfUrstendamm 57 10707 Berlin, Germany Feldgasse 13, A-1238 Wien Austria
Fax: 617 492-5263) Canada Oxford University Press 70 Wynford Drive Don Mills Ontario M3C 119
(Orders:
Tel: 416 441 2941)
Australia Blackwell Science Pty Ltd 54 University Street
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
Carlton, Victoria 3053 Tel: 03 347-0300
(Orders:
Fax: 03 349-3016)
transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act
A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library ISBN 0-86542-898-0
1988, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. First published 1995
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Sedimentary facies analysis: a tribute to
Set by Setrite Typesetters, Hong Kong
the research and teaching
Printed and bound in Great Britain
of Harold G. Reading/
at the Alden Press Limited,
edited by A. Guy Plint.
Oxford and Northampton
p.
em.
(Special publication number 22 of the International Association of Sedimentologists) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-86542-898-0 1. Facies (Geology) 2. Sedimentation and deposition. II. Reading, H.G.
[[[.
I. Plint, A. Guy.
Series: Special publication
of the International Association of Sedimentologists; no. 22. QE651.S43 1995 552' .5-dc20
94-30445 CIP
To Harold
Photograph courtesy of Tim Barrett
We offer this collection of papers as a token of our appreciation for your friendship, guidance and inspiration. In remembering your infectious enthusiasm, dedication and sometimes daunting expectations, we realize how deeply we were influenced by your philosophy and attitude; a gift that has, in no small measure, shaped the course of our professional ]jves. Your former students
Contents
IX
Preface
XI
Harold G. Reading
xm
Introduction
Clastic Facies Analysis 3
Alluvial palaeogeography of the Guaritas depositional sequence of southern Brazil Paulo S. G. Paim
17
Sedimentology of a transgressive, estuarine sand complex: the Lower Cretaceous Woburn Sands (Lower Greensand), southern England Howard D. Johnson and Bruce K. Levell
47
An incised valley in the Cardium Formation at Ricinus, Alberta: reinterpretation as an estuary fill Roger G. Walker
75
Gravelly shoreface and beachface deposits Bruce S. Hart and A. Guy Plint
101
The return of 'The Fan That Never Was': Westphalian turbidite systems in the Variscan Culm Basin: Bude Formation (southwest England) Robert V. Burne
137
Depositional controls on iron formation associations in Canada Philip Fralick and Timothy J. Barrett
157
Facies models in volcanic terrains: time's arrow versus time's cycle Geoffrey J. Orton
Tectonics and Sedimentation 197
Coarse-grained lacustrine fan-delta deposits (Pororari Group) of the northwestern South Island, New Zealand: evidence for Mid-Cretaceous rifting Malcolm G. Laird VII
Contents
vm
219
Sedimentation and tectonics of a synrift succession: Upper Jurassic alluvial fans and palaeokarst at the late Cimmerian unconformity, western Cameros Basin, northern Spain Nigel H. Platt
237
The use of geochemical data in determining the provenance and tectonic setting of ancient sedimetary successions: the Kalvag Melange, western Norwegian Caledonides Rodmar Ravnas and Harald Fumes
265
Differential subsidence and preservation potential of shallow-water Tertiary sequences, northern Gulf Coast Basin, USA Marc B. Edwards
Sequence and Seismic Stratigraphy in Facies Analysis 285
Seismic-stratigraphical analysis of large-scale ridge-trough sedimentary structures in the Late Miocene to Early Pliocene of the central North Sea Joe Cartwright
305
Millstone Grit cyclicity revisited, II: sequence stratigraphy and sedimentary responses to changes of relative sea-level Ole J. Martinsen, John D. Collinson and Brian K. Holdsworth
Facies Analysis in Reservoir Sedimentology 331
Productive Middle East clastic oil and gas reservoirs: their depositional settings and origins of their hydrocarbons Ziad R. Beydoun
355
The evolution of Oligo-Miocene fluvial sand-body geometries and the effect on hydro carbon trapping: Widuri field, west Java Sea Ray Young, W.E. Harmony and Thomas Budiyento
381
Index
Preface
This book stands out in the series of Special Publi
Bureau considered that this would be best done
cations of the International Association of Sedimen
through a Special Publication on a subject in line
tologists.
It
is
an
acknowledgement
of Harold
with Harold's work (obvious topics were clastics,
Reading's commitment to lAS, for whom he has
facies and depositional environments, sedimentation
been Publications Secretary, General Secretary and
and tectonics).
President successively, over the last 30 years.
It is therefore most appropriate that Guy Plint,
Harold has not only been source and inspiration
as Editor chosen for this special publication, has
of many of the lAS policies and activities over this
brought together a collection of original scientific
time, he has also been at the roots of 'facies sedimen
papers authored by Harold Reading's students, or
tology' as an art in itself, and as a major tool in the
students of theirs. To honour Harold Reading's own
broader field of geology.
scientific scope, the subject chosen is broad: sedi
More than providing his own personal contribution
mentary facies analysis. The contributions contained
to this branch of the earth sciences, Harold created a
in this Special Publication show to what extent facies
flourishing school of teaching and research. Harold's
sedimentology, as fostered by Harold Reading, is
approach has burgeoned from Parks Road, Oxford,
now established as a necessary basis to any under
to
standing of sedimentary rocks.
become
international
not
only
through
his
students, but also through 'his book'.
PETER HOMEWOOD
The Bureau of the lAS, taking up a suggestion by
/AS Publications Secretary
Robert Campbell of Blackwell Science, decided to put together a scientific tribute to Harold. The
IX
Harold G. Reading
Harold Reading was born in 1924 and, on leaving
at Rijswijk, arranged for Harold to investigate the
school, joined the Indian Army. This early experience
context of reported turbidites associated with English
left a lasting impression and undoubtedly contributed
Carboniferous deltaics in the Pennines and in south
to Harold's later concern for international cooper
west England.
ation. He went up to Oxford in 1948, initially to read
Cooperation with de Raaf and with Roger Walker,
Forestry, but his interests were diverted towards
one of Harold's earliest research students, developed
geology and he graduated in that subject in 1951.
a detailed appreciation of sedimentary structures
As an undergraduate, he visited North Norway to
and their role in understanding processes, and led
investigate the Late Precambrian and Cambrian
to the development of the style of facies analysis
stratigraphy of the Digermul Peninsula. This under
exemplified by the 1965 classic paper on the Carbon
graduate expedition not only shed significant new
iferous cycles of North Devon. Thereafter, Harold's
light on the stratigraphy of the area but also sowed
stable of research students grew rapidly as this volume
the seeds of a later rich sedimentological harvest.
amply testifies. Until his retirement, it was unusual
Three years at Durham under K.C. Dunham led to a
for him to have fewer than five or six doctoral
PhD with a project that involved mapping Carbon
students at any one time, this in addition to a full
iferous Y oredale cycles across an area of bleak
undergraduate teaching programme and responsi
Pennine moorland. Although the main thrust of the
bilities in college. This formidable work load was
study was stratigraphy and structure, the experience
carried out with great conscientiousness but Harold
of Carboniferous cyclicity was to set a further pointer
still had time to spare for external activities such
for the future.
as his involvement with lAS and JAPEC. During
On completion of his PhD Harold joined Royal
Harold's long career in Oxford, he only spent sus
Dutch Shell and immediately found himself in the
tained periods away on sabbatical on two occasions,
contrasting field conditions of Venezuela. This multi
the first in Leyden in the mid-1960s and the second
national, multidisciplinary environment developed
in Canada in 1972. The period in Holland led to
an appreciation of broader geological perspectives
close cooperation with structural geologists working
and the pragmatic, though rigorous, approach to
in the Cantabrians, an important extension of his
problem solving that has characterized Harold's
interests outside Britain.
career.
Of particular significance was a visit to
Harold's earliest students developed his early
Venezuela by Ph. Keunen who was, at that time,
interests, the Carboniferous deltas of Britain, and
actively promoting his pioneering work on turbidity
the tillites, shallow-marine and fluvial sediments of
currents
rigorous
northern Norway. Later, the Lower Palaeozoic of
approach to understanding depositional processes
Ireland and the Carboniferous of northern Spain
struck a chord with Harold, which was to be a
were added. As students were attracted to Oxford
and
their
deposits.
Kuenen's
cornerstone of his approach to sedimentology.
from around the world, the geographical spread
Harold returned to Oxford in 1957 as lecturer in
grew. However, geographical diversification was not
geology, a position that he held until retirement in
an end in itself but largely a result of Harold's
1991. When he took up his post, his teaching responsi
curiosity about wider controls on sedimentation,
bilities included mapping and palaeontology and
particularly the role of tectonics. He understood
stratigraphy. Sedimentology, as we know it, hardly
very early the implications for sedimentology of
existed. Harold first revived his interests in northern
Plate Tectonics, as exemplified by his pioneering
Norway through a further, largely stratigraphical
paper with Andrew Mitchell. Curiosity about new
expedition to Digermul. Perhaps more importantly,
geological ideas and the need to investigate their
he developed his interest in sedimentary process and
implications for sedimentology and vice versa has
environments through a relationship with Shell.
been a hallmark of Harold's geological thinking. By some standards, Harold has not been a prolific
Maurits de Raaf, then Head of Geological Research
XI
Harold G. Reading
XII
author, although his papers are always thoughtful
President have already been acknowledged by the
and stimulating. Published evidence of Harold's
Association
influence lies mainly in the rigour, originality and
Membership to Harold. It is worth remembering
appreciation of the wider geological perspective that
that it was in no small measure due to Harold's
itself
in
the
granting
of
Honorary
characterize many of the publications of his research
efforts that the Association changed from a largely
students and of second and third generation students.
European organization to one of real international
Harold edited one Special Publication of the lAS
stature. Harold's tireless efforts to meet and encour
on-strike-slip mobile belts, but his most valued publi
age sedimentologists of all ages and backgrounds
cation is the textbook Sedimentary Environments and
around the world and his endless patience and
Facies, initially written largely by Harold's former
diplomatic skill have been well rewarded in the
students and rigorously edited to reflect the high
healthy Association that we enjoy today. Harold
standards he espouses. The 3rd edition currently
has additionally been honoured by the Geological
occupies much of his 'retirement'.
Society of London with the award of the Lyell Fund
Although this book is essentially a celebration
and the Prestwich Medal and, most recently, by
of Harold's scientific influence, it is important,
SEPM with the award of its prestigious Twenhofel
especially in a Special Publication of the lAS, to
Medal.
acknowledge
his
enormous
contribution
to
the
development of sedimentology internationally. His unstinting efforts on behalf of the lAS, as Publi cations Secretary,
as General Secretary and as
JOHN CoLLINSON Shrewsbury, UK
Introduction
This volume is a very personal compilation. Unlike
from Harold's former graduate students and their
previous lAS Special Publications, it is not centred
students and co-workers, but to impose no constraint
on a specific geological theme, and for that I make
on topic, in order to illustrate the scope of Harold's
no apology. Instead, my intent was to illustrate, and
knowledge, interest and vision. In consequence, the
celebrate, the breadth of interest, energy and inspi
contents of this book are eclectic. The collection
ration that Harold Reading has brought to the field
of papers serves to highlight the power of facies
of sedimentary geology.
analysis, whether the rocks be volcanogenic, bio
Few would deny the depth of Harold's influence
genic, siliciclastic,
or even 'catastrophic'
on sedimentology, world-wide. In part, this is due to
olistoliths!),
his publications, in particular the enormously suc
method fostered by Harold.
cessful
Sedimentary
Environments
(mega
the scientific
Facies,
It is particularly appropriate that, amongst the
unquestionably the cornerstone for all those who
contributions, Ole Martinsen, John Collinson and
embark on sedimentary facies
and
and of course reflect
analysis! Equally
Brian
important of course, has been his pivotal role in the
Holdsworth
offer
new
interpretations
of
Namurian deltaic rocks in the northern Pennines,
foundation and development of the lAS, a contri
(upon which Harold cut his sedimentological teeth),
bution acknowledged recently with honourary mem
but which, judging from referees comments, still
bership of that Association.
provide fuel for heated debate! In similar vein,
His philosophy and attitude has of course travelled
Bob Burne presents a review and discussion of the
with his graduate students, drawn from 13 countries
depositional environment of the enigmatic Bude
on six continents. Because many of these students
Formation
returned home upon completion of their work in
1960s), but which is still subject to sharply divergent
Oxford, and others now work and teach outside
interpretations.
the UK, the approach Harold fostered during their
Roger Walker shows how important it is, both to
(which In
Harold a
studied
salutory
in
lesson
the to
early
us
all,
graduate days has continued to spread. (He may not
separate facts from interpretations, and to ques
know this, but in a geneological sense, Harold
tion one's cherished interpretation, when he boldly
is now a great-great grandfather to at least one
reinterprets as an incised valley fill, rocks he pro
young sedimentology student who doubtless is quite
claimed a turbidite channel deposit just nine years
unaware of the history of the supervisory influence
ago! As Editor of this volume, I am indebted to the
that has been passed down!)
following people whose thorough reviews served
Although initially conceived as a thematic volume with contributions to be invited from a panoply of
to clarify the papers, and who made my job that
leading
much easier: Gail M. Ashley, Timothy R. Astin, T.
sedimentologists,
two difficulties quickly
arose: first, just what was to be the theme? As
Christopher
Harold has been involved in so many areas of
Charlie S. Bristow, H. Edward Clifton, Thomas C.
Baldwin,
sedimentary geology, selection of any one topic
Connally,
simply served to highlight gross neglect of another.
Peter G. DeCelles, Frank G. Ethridge, Jill Eyers,
Edward
Janok
Cotter,
P.
Bhattacharya,
William
R.
Dupre,
Secondly, it rapidly became apparent that numerous
Stephen S. Flint, Edward C. Freshney, Robert L.
former students were anxious to pay their own
Gawthorpe, Roland Goldring, Anthony J. Hamblin,
personal tribute, and whose contributions could,
Alan P. Heward, Phillip R. Hill, Richard N. Hiscott,
alone, easily constitute a hefty volume! Of the 34
Richard S.
students whom Harold guided through doctoral
McCabe, Kathleen M. Marsaglia, Franco Massari,
theses between 1961 and 1994, 16 have authored, or
Gerrard V. Middleton, Robert A. Morton, George
co-authored papers in this volume.
Postma, William C. Ross, Alastair H. Ruffell, Bruce
In keeping with the sentiment of this festschrift, I
Hyde, Elana L.
Leithold,
Peter J.
W. Sellwood, Gary A. Smith, Roger G. Walker,
took the decision to limit contributions to those
James
xiii
D. L.
White,
John
A.
Winchester
and
Introduction
XIV
Jonathon Wonham, plus two people who chose to
clandestine spmt of this project,
remain anonymous.
essential intelligence on both Harold and his former
I am very grateful to Susan Sternberg, Edward Wates and Julie Elliott at Blackwell Science who provided guidance at critical phases in the prep aration of this book. I also thank Diana Relton (Earth Sciences,
Oxford) who entered into the
graduate students.
A. GuY PuNT London, Ontario
and provided
Clastic Facies Analysis
Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading Edited by A. Guy Plint © 1995 The International Association of Sedimentologists ISBN: 978-0-865-42898-0
Spec. Pubis int. Ass. Sediment.
(1995) 22, 3-16
Alluvial palaeogeography of the Guaritas depositional sequence of southern Brazil P A U L O S. G. P AlM* Earth Sciences Department , Oxford University, Parks Road, Oxford OXI 3PR, UK
ABSTRACT
The Guaritas sequence is the uppermost stratigraphical level of the Camaqua Basin (southern Brazil) and comprises an alluvial, deltaic and aeolian continental facies association up to 800 m thick. Facies mapping of this unit has revealed a lateral association of tributary fans and trunk braided rivers developed under semi-arid conditions. Two main regions (lobes) of alluvial fan development can be discriminated and the source points of both coincide with synforms in the nearby basement. This depositional system presents a normal down fan facies change. An anomalous lateral change of facies within the trunk river system is interpreted as having been inherited from pre-existing alluvial fan deposits. The main alluvial facies comprise trough cross-stratified (74%) and horizontally bedded (7%) sandstones, massive (16%) and tabular cross-stratified (2%) orthoconglomerates, and massive mud stones (1%) . Vertical aggradation of three-dimensional subaqueous dunes, followed by an upper flow regime plane-bed phase, characterized the depositional events of the sandy areas of the alluvial system. Diffuse gravel sheets and minor longitudinal and transverse bars were the main geomorphological features of the gravelly alluvial reaches. Fine-grained sediments represent temporarily abandoned areas within the braided channel network.
INTRODUCTION
trending tectonic structure, in southern Brazil (Fig. 1}, and evolved during the latest phases of the Brasilia no orogenic cycle (strike-slip basins of Brito Neves & Cordani (1991}}. An extensional or transtensional event at the end of the Brasiliano orogenic cycle, and the consequent formation of intermontane basins, has been pro posed as the tectonic setting of the Camaqua Basin during the deposition of the Guaritas sequence (Fragoso-Cesar et al., 1984, 1992; Beckel, 1990, 1992). In the past decade, the Guaritas depositional sequence has received attention from several authors in terms of facies analysis and palaeoenvironmental interpretation (Becker & Fernandes, 1982; Fragoso Cesar et al., 1984; Jost, 1984; Lavina et a!., 1985; Beckel, 1990). Generally, these papers have indi cated continental sedimentation characterized by
The Guaritas depositional sequence constitutes the uppermost unit of the Camaqua Basin infilling and it is an unconformity-bounded stratigraphical unit: it overlies older deformed molasse strata (angular unconformity) and is covered by Permian sedimen tary rocks of the Parana Basin. The Guaritas sequence, about 800 m thick, is almost always flat-lying, although, near to regional faults some extensional reactivation has tilted the Guaritas deposits. The available radiometric dating, summarized in Soliani et al. (1984) and Fragoso Cesar et al. (1984), indicates a Cambro-Ordovician age for the deposition of the Guaritas sequence. The Camaqua Basin is located in a NE-SW * Permanent address: UNISINOS- Departamento de Geologia, Av. Unisinos 950, Sao Leopoldo RS, Caixa Postal 275, CEP 93022-000, Brazil.
Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading Edited by A. Guy Plint © 1995 The International Association of Sedimentologists ISBN: 978-0-865-42898-0
3
P.S.G. Paim
4
Permo Triassic
T �
BRAZIL
>-
� L:...:!l
Upper Vendian to Ordovician
t-':(:�: ., .. . .•
� >:<: c::
-�
Guaritas depositional sequence older molasse sequences
Middle to Upper Proterozoic
1· ;;; � :f:f �
N
granites
1
meta volcanic/sedimentary rocks
Archean to Lower Proterozoic
Study area
Br153 .....--_
� B.:::J
Main roads
Scale (Km)
Major faults Ca9apava do Sui 2
6
-
-
0
6
3
12
18
Santana da Boa Vista
Fig. I. Location map and geological setting of the Camaqua Basin. Modified from DNPM/CPRM (1987).
alluvial fan and braided alluvial plain deposits, with associated aeolian and lacustrine sediments. A semi arid environment has been proposed for the overall Guaritas sequence. The most detailed study on the depositional sys-
terns of the Camaqua Basin was presented by Lavina et al. (1985). In this paper the alluvial facies were related to marginal alluvial fans (channel and debris flow deposits) associated with an axial braided alluvial plain. Gravelly longitudinal bars and sandy
5
Palaeogeography of the Guaritas sequence subaqueous dunes and transverse bars were the main morphological elements attributed to the alluvial palaeostreams. Petrological studies by De Ros et al. (1994) on samples from alluvial and aeolian facies of the Guaritas sequence indicate the presence of: (i) fresh feldspar and volcanic lithoclasts; (ii) aggregates of hematite; (iii) oxidized grains; (iv) caliche (concen tric interlayering of calcite and iron oxide); and (v) silcretes. These early diagenetic features reflect arid to semi-arid conditions during the deposition of the Guaritas sequence. Basin-wide facies mapping of the Guaritas se quence carried out by the author in 1988, reinforce previous interpretations indicating intermittent vol canic activity and an aeolian, alluvial and deltaic facies association (Fig. 2). Basin-scale changes of the alluvial facies charac teristics suggest that an objective delineation of dis tinct alluvial subenvironments is possible. These alluvial subenvironments, as well as a brief descrip tion and interpretation of the main alluvial facies, are the main subject of this paper. The alluvial deposits will be discussed in terms of their general features of texture, fabric, sedimentary structures and palaeocurrent pattern on a basin wide scale. Both the mean sedimentary facies charac teristics and the lateral facies changes within the alluvial system are described. The data base includes 403 outcrop descriptions distributed over an area of nearly 1600 km2 (see Fig. SA). This area was subdivided into 46 equal rec tangles (8 x 9 km) and mean values of several par ameters were calculated for each subdivision. The results of this approach are presented in Tables 1 & 2 and summarized in Figs 5 & 6. This approach involves comparison of values from different strati graphical levels. The consistent results (see Fig. 5) throughout the basin, with sampling at several stratigraphical levels (Fig. 2), suggest that the palaeoenvironments were more or less stationary throughout deposition of the Guaritas sequence. A detailed three-dimensional facies architecture analysis (architectural elements approach of Allen (1983) and Miall (1985)), aiming to build up a local alluvial model on a channel-fill scale, is part of my ongoing studies and will be the subject of another publication.
ALLUVIAL GENERAL
FACIES:
FEATURES
To simplify terminology the lithofacies classifi cation proposed by Miall (1977), as modified by Miall (1978), Rust (1978) and Bromley (1991), was adopted. Table 1 presents the main characteristics of each sedimentary facies described in the field. The terminology and classification scheme pro posed by the SEPM (Society of Economic Paleon tologists and Mineralogists) Bedforms and Bedding Structures Research Symposium (Ashley, 1990) for description of large-scale flow-transverse bedforms (excluding antidunes) was adopted. The alluvial deposits (Table 1) are sand dominated (facies S, 81% ) with a smaller amount of conglom erates (facies G, 18% ) and an insignificant amount of pelites (facies F, 1%). Facies S is composed mainly of medium- to coarse-grained sandstones (41% ), with a significant proportion of pebbly to very coarse-grained (25%) and fine- to very fine grained (15%) sandstones. Facies G is composed of pebbles (9%) and granules (8% ) and minor amounts of cobbles (1% ). A few boulders occur in the base of some conglom erate beds, mainly near the eastern border of the Camaqua Basin. The alluvial deposits are usually arranged in fining upward cycles bounded by fifth-order surfaces (sensu Miall, 1988). These cycles are 0.5-4 m thick and tens of metres in lateral extent (Fig. 3), both parallel to and perpendicular to palaeoflow, and can be classified as laterally extensive to sheet-like deposits following the classification of Friend et al. (1979). The proportion of the different textural classes within the fining upward cycles changes laterally with increasing gravel content toward both margins. Conglomerates (G)
Clast-supported conglomerates comprise around 18% of the alluvial facies and massive conglomerates are the most common (Table 1). Clast-supported conglomerates are a very common facies in the lowermost parts of the fining upward cycles. Massive clast-supported conglomerates (facies Gm, Table 1) are the main lithotype of facies G and normal grading, clast orientation and imbrication are their most conspicuous sedimentary features. Facies Gp is characterized by gravels (mainly pebbles) arranged in small- to large-scale, normally isolated, sets of tabular cross-stratification. This
P.S.G. Paim
6 A
10km B
\; ·>.1 � t:;;:.t1
Mainly alluvial facies
Mainly volcanic rocks
Q o
Mainly eolian facies Pre-Guaritas basement
E:f=3-g
Mainly deltaic facies
LA: j
Permo Triassic
Fig. 2. Three-dimensional view of Camaqua Basin and surrounding area (same region of Fig. 1): (A) topography and (B) sketch of the Guaritas sequence facies.
7
Palaeogeography of the Guaritas sequence
Table 1. Classification and relative percentage of the sedimentary lithofacies (lithofacies code adapted from Miall (1977, 1978) and Rust (1978)) Rock type Conglomerates (G)
Sandstones (S)
Mudstones (F)
Facies code
Description
Percentage
Gm
Massive or crudely bedded conglomerates (cobbles, pebbles and granules)
l6
Gp
Small- to large-scale tabular cross-stratified conglomerates (granules and pebbles)
Gt
Small- to large-scale trough cross-stratified conglomerates
Gms
Massive, matrix-supported conglomerates (boulders to granules dispersed in a muddy sand matrix)
St
Small- to large-scale trough cross-stratified sandstones (pebbly to very fine-grained)
Sh
Horizontally bedded sandstones (medium to very fine-grained)
Sp
Medium to pebbly sandstone with small- to large scale planar cross-stratification
Fm
Massive mudstones with mudcracks
Fl
Laminated to rippled very fine sandstone to siltstone
Table 2. Relative percentage of trough cross-stratification and horizontal lamination in each sandy textural class Texture Pebbly to very coarse grained
Facies St
Sedimentary structures
Percentage
Small scale Medium scale Large scale
10 49 41
Sh Coarse to medium grained
St
0 Small scale Medium scale Large scale
10
Sh Fine to very fine grained
St
Sh
10 43 37
Small scale Medium scale Large scale
15 37 28 20
facies commonly occurs associated with facies Gm (Fig. 3). Facies Gt is rare, finer grained than facies Gm and Gp and characterized by small- to large-scale trough cross-stratification (alternations of small pebbles and gravelly sands). This facies interfingers with facies Gm and grades into facies St (Fig. 4). Matrix-supported conglomerates (facies Gms) are
2
74 7
also rare and occur, locally, near the eastern border of the Camaqua Basin. The main characteristic of this facies is its chaotic arrangement of pebbles, cobbles and, less commonly, boulders floating in a muddy to sandy matrix. Sandstones
Trough cross-stratification (facies St, 74% ), in places disrupted and/or deformed by convolution, and horizontal bedding (facies Sh, 7% ) are the main features of the alluvial sandy deposits (Figs 3 & 4). Planar cross-stratification (facies Sp) is rare. Facies St is characterized by very fine- to very coarse-grained sandstones with trough cross-bedding (Table 1). The cross-strata are predominantly of medium to large scale in all textural classes, but the proportion of small-scale trough cross-stratification increases as sandstones become finer grained (Table 2). This facies is the most common in the fining upward cycles. Convolute bedding is common in trough cross stratified sandstones (facies St). Within a single cross-stratified set, all gradations may occur from oversteep foresets, recumbent folding to intense deformation and even complete destruction of the former bedding (facies Sm and Spo of Bromley, 1991). Deformation near the top of the cross-
8
P.S.G. Paim
Fig. 3. Main alluvial lithofacies: facies Gt, St, Sh, Spo and, in the uppermost part of the picture, Fl, Gm and Gp. Bar scale is 2 m long.
stratified set is commonly characterized by downcur rent oversteepening of the cross-strata (Figs 3 & 4), and the intensity of convolution increases down the slip-face. Horizontal bedding (facies Sh) does not occur associated with pebbly and very coarse-grained sand stones and comprises 10% of the sedimentary struc tures of medium- to coarse-grained sandstones and 20% of the fine- to very fine-grained sandstones (Table 2). This facies is often related to the upper most parts of the fining upward alluvial cycles (Figs 3 & 4). Planar-tabular cross-stratified sandstones (facies Sp) are not common in the Guaritas sequence alluv ial deposits (Table 1). They occur as small- to large scale sets in pebbly to medium-grained sandstones and are normally interlayered with facies St. Other facies
Massive mudstones are rare and commonly mud cracks are their most conspicuous feature (facies Fm). Very fine-grained sandstones and siltstones (facies Fl) are also, and can be either horizontal (Fig. 3) or, more rarely, cross-laminated (Table 1). Both usually occur in the uppermost parts of the fining upward alluvial cycles. Alluvial facies: summary of general features and interpretations
The textural aspects (Table 1) suggest that the alluv ial facies of the Guaritas sequence represent bedload stream deposits in which the bedload was predomi-
nantly sandy and the suspension load, if deposited, was almost completely eroded by subsequent flood events. This type of stream commonly has a braided pattern characterized by low sinuosity and highly mobile channels (Collinson, 1986). The sheet-like geometry of the fining upward cycles enclosed by fifth-order bounding surfaces suggests broad, shallow channels. In terms of the gravelly facies, the dominance of clast-supported conglomerates (Table 1) is indicative of gravel deposition by strong tractive flows, whereas the finer grained material (sand and mud) was still being carried in suspension (Rust & Koster, 1984). Thin beds of facies Gm associated with laterally extensive channels suggest the development of dif fuse gravel sheets (Hein & Walker, 1977) by very extensive and shallow sheet-floods (Collinson, 1986). Thicker deposits of facies Gm suggest deeper and less ephemeral flows (Rust, 1978) causing more extensive vertical aggradation of gravel bars with low depositional dips. These deposits commonly have been associated with the development of longi tudinal and/or diagonal gravelly bars (Smith, 1970; Rust, 1972, 1978; Miall, 1977, 1978; Rust & Koster, 1984; Collinson, 1986) under high water and sedi ment discharge (Hein & Walker, 1977). Conglomerates with planar cross-stratification (facies Gp) has been related to (i) two-dimensional dune migration (transverse and/or linguoid gravel bars of Hein & Walker (1977), Miall (1977) and Middleton & Trujillo (1984)) as well as to (ii) later modifications of longitudinal bars (Smith, 1970; Rust, 1978; Enyon & Walker, 1974) in modern alluvial gravelly reaches. The frequent occurrence of
;;,o
!:)
�
�
-§ � -.:;, �
"'
C)
§
;::. s
"' "'
.E Fig. 4. Detailed view of Fig. 3 (enlargement of its lower part): facies Gt, St, Sh, Spo and thin tabular beds of Gm. Bar scale is 2 m long.
"' "' ;:s '"' "'
'.0
10
P.S.G. Paim
isolated sets of facies Gp within deposits of facies Gm could be explained more easily by the second hypothesis. Trough cross-stratified conglomerates are rare (facies Gt) and have been associated with (i) three dimensional dune migration, as observed by Fahnestock & Bradley (1973) and Galay & Neill (1967), and (ii) channel scour-and-fill structures (Miall, 1977; Middleton & Trujillo, 1984). The same criteria previously used to interpret facies Gp can also be applied in this case: the solitary nature of this facies suggests the deposition of gravel in depressions around diffuse gravel sheets. Matrix-supported conglomerates (facies Gms) are also rare and represent mud- and debris-flow deposits commonly associated with an alluvial fan setting (Blackwelder, 1928; Bull, 1963; Hooke, 1967; Rust & Koster, 1984; Collinson, 1986; Blair & MacPherson, 1992). Sandy sediments constitute the majority of the Guaritas alluvial deposits (Table 1) and are exten sively dominated by facies St (Table 2). Trough cross-stratified sandstones have been related almost invariably to migration of three-dimensional dunes (e.g. Collinson, 1970; Williams, 1971; Harms et al., 1975; Miall, 1977; Rust, 1978). In braided alluvial settings these bedforms usually have been associated with in-channel deposition (Cant & Walker, 1976, 1978; Cant, 1978; Walker & Cant, 1984). Such repetitive sand deposits commonly are considered as flood-stage bedforms (Williams, 1971) and are larger in deep channels (Cant, 1978). The association of facies St with the lower and middle part of sheet-like fining-upward cycles suggests this facies could be related to flood stage in shallow channels. Subcritical climbing trough cross strata (facies St) indicate subaqueous dune aggra dation. Sporadic lateral accretion of these bedforms is indicated by inclined planes (first-order bounding surfaces of Miall (1988)) dipping perpendicular to the dune migration direction (Paim, 1994). The absence of third-order surfaces (except the rare occurrence of lateral accretion surfaces) associ ated with the subcritical climbing of the trough cross-bedded sets (facies St) suggests rapid depo sition of a sandy load, transported by traction plus suspension, without macroform (sensu Jackson, 1975) development. Deformation of trough cross-stratified sandstones is a very conspicuous feature of the Guaritas sandy alluvial facies. Recumbent folding in cross-bedded sandstones commonly has been attributed to shear
stress acting on a liquefied sand bed and caused by current drag (Allen & Banks, 1972; Doe & Dott, 1980; Owen, 1987) or by the movement of large bedforms over an unconsolidated substrate during high-flow stages (Plint, 1983). Horizontal bedding (facies Sh) occurs most often in the finest fraction of the sandy deposits (Table 2). This textural control, associated with the occurrence of parting lineation and scattered small pebbles and granules near the base of the horizontally bedded sets, indicates its origin as an upper flow regime bedform. Deposits with the same characteristics of facies Sh usually have been linked to an upper flow regime phase developed during flood stages on the channel floor (McKee et al., 1967; Williams, 1971; Miall, 1977) or under the influence of high-velocity and low depth flows on the top of sand-flats (Cant and Walker, 1978; Miall, 1977; Collinson, 1986). The common occurrence of this facies (Sh) on the upper most parts of the fining upward cycles supports an interpretation involving upper flow regime currents reworking the top of the previous alluvial deposits. Planar-tabular cross-stratified sandstones (facies Sp) are rare. Within alluvial settings this facies commonly has been related to slip-face advance of two-dimensional dunes (transverse -linguoid or lobate bars of Collinson (1970, 1986), Smith (1970), Williams (1971), Asquith & Cramer (1975), Miall (1977), Cant & Walker (1978) and Cant (1978); or sand waves and straight-crested megaripples of Smith (1970), Collinson (1986) and Miall (1978)). Smith (1970) related the origin of the two dimensional dunes to the development of 'deltas' in pre-existing channel-floor depressions, whereas Cant & Walker (1978) related them to flow expansion at channel junctions or places where the channels widen. Facies Fm and Fl are not common in the alluvial system of the Guaritas sequence (Table 1). Their rarity and generally lenticular geometry (Fig. 3) are suggestive of waning flood deposits settling on to temporarily abandoned areas of the braided system (Cant, 1978; Cant & Walker, 1978; Miall, 1978). In general, diffuse gravel sheets and longitudinal/ diagonal bars were the main geomorphological elements of the gravelly reaches, whereas sub aqueous three-dimensional dunes characterized the sandy portions of the Guaritas alluvial system. The predominance of vertical aggradation of dunes instead of downstream and/or lateral accretion of more stable sandy accumulations (e.g. sand-flats)
11
Palaeogeography of the Guaritas sequence suggests a highly variable hydrological character and predominance of the upper part of lower flow regime conditions within the channels. Debris-flow and sheet-flood deposits suggest the presence of alluvial fans within the alluvial system as well as flashy discharge due to sporadic, but torren tial, rainy seasons. The above interpretations together suggest an alluvial drainage developed under semi-arid con ditions (large discharge fluctuations) with alter nation of flood events and dry seasons. These conclusions are reinforced by the aeolian associ ation (Lavina et al., 198S) and by petrographical evidence related to early diagenetic processes (De Ros et a/., 1994).
ALLUVIAL
FACIES:
LATERAL CHANGES
The previous section describes the pattern of alluvial sedimentation in terms of mean regional values and, in this way, reflects the major features of the alluvial deposit. In the following section, spatial variation in some sedimentary features is described and, when possible, interpreted. To achieve this, the mean values, per unit area, of several sedimentary par ameters were calculated using the outcrop locations and grid presented in Fig. SA.
Palaeocurrent pattern
The pattern of sediment transport within the entire Camaqua Basin was calculated using the grid and outcrops shown in Fig. SA. In order to eliminate problems associated with the analysis of several types and scales of sedimentary features (Miall, 1977) mean vectors were calculated only from trough cross-stratification. By using only one rank of sedimentary features, difficulties related to vector magnitude were eliminated (Allen, 1963; Miall, 1974). In addition, dunes seem to be associ ated with high-stage flow and, consequently, should be good indicators of the true downstream direction (Miall, 1977). The distribution of the palaeocurrent vector means (Fig. SB) indicates two major dispersal compart ments within the alluvial system: 1 from the eastern border to the basin axis the sedimentary transport was almost perpendicular to the regional tectonic trend (a general mean vector of
282°, with a correlation coefficient of 0. 86), reflecting a sedimentary input towards the basin axis; 2 from the basin axis to the western border, palaeo currents were predominantly parallel to the struc tural trend (general mean vector of 211 with a correlation coefficient of 0.96). o,
Pattern of textural dispersion
The alluvial deposits of the Guaritas sequence are composed primarily of sandstones (mainly facies St and Sh), minor conglomerates (mainly facies Gm and Gp) and trace amounts of fine-grained sediments (facies Fm and Fl), as has been described in the previous section. In this paper three types of alluvial deposits are distinguished: sandy (:2: 70% sand stones); mixed (70-30% sandstone); and conglom eratic ( ::::: 30% sandstone). Figure SC shows the percentage of sandstone (rela tive to conglomerate) through the entire basin and illustrates a gradual decrease from sand dominated alluvial deposits along the basin axis (axial alluvial sedimentation), to mixed alluvial deposits toward both basin margins (marginal alluvial sedimen tation). Likewise, Fig. SD presents a plan view of the spatial changes of the percentages of coarser grained sediments (conglomerates plus pebbly and very coarse-grained sandstones) relative to finer grained sediments (coarse to very fine sandstones). A pattern quite similar to the former (Fig. SC) can be seen. Clearly, the facies St and Sh are gradually replaced by facies Gm towards both basin borders. In both cases (Figs SC & SD) the only exception to the general pattern of sediment distribution is a NW -SE trending intrusion of coarse material in the southeast region of the basin. Alluvial facies: interpretation of lateral changes
Figure 6 presents an interpretation of the alluvial palaeogeography of the Guaritas sequence based on the lateral variations of the textural and palaeocur rent data. This figure was constructed according to the following considerations. The palaeocurrents suggest the coexistence of two distinct alluvial subenvironments (Fig. SB) with almost orthogonal mean sedimentary transport pat terns (282° versus 211°). 1 The first dispersal system (282°), developed in the eastern part of the basin, is characterized by the highest palaeocurrent vector dispersion and by palaeo flow almost perpendicular to the tectonic trend of
12
P. S.G. Paim B
12 -
Mean vector and number of readings per area Boundary between tributary alluvial fan system and trunk braided river system
50
�
Mean vector and number of readings of both alluvial systems
\
5
A
3 46 ,514 / 44 ti 99
!
26 / 64 /
;;
101
I
--
32
-36
c
§
>90 80-89 70-79
D
1
60 41
\
100 ""'-89 14
"4
/
3 N
---
""'...... 26
H 30-39 ��29 � 0
Fig. 5. Lateral changes within the alluvial system: (A) grid and location of alluvial outcrops used to calculate palaeocurrent and textural mean values; (B) palaeocurrent mean values per area; (C) percentage of sandstone relative to conglomerate; and (D) percentage of coarser grained sediments (gravel plus pebbly to very coarse-grained sand) relative to finer grained sediments (coarse to very fine-grained sand plus mud).
the basin. This subenvironment is interpreted as a tributary alluvial fan (sensu Rust & Koster, 1984). 2 The second dispersal system (211°), represented by palaeoflow parallel to the basin axis, by low palaeocurrent vector disperson, and characteristic of
the western portion of the basin, is interpreted as a trunk braided river (sensu Rust & Koster, 1984). As Collinson (1986) stated, 'it is sometimes poss ible to identify individual fans by the establishment of a radial pattern of palaeocurrents over an area'.
13
Palaeogeograph y of the Guaritas sequence
E
c
Gm Gt St
Sh Spo
n
o -
Sm 1
-
2
-
3
-
Mudstones
Sandstones
Conglomerates
Sandy alluvial deposiiS
Mixed alluvial deposiiS Tributary fan streams Braided trunk river streams Reworked tributary fans
--A
Boundary between trunk rivers and tributary fans Plan view of the alluvial palaeogeography
B
Western margin trunk river facies association
C
Axial sandy trunk river facies associalion
(reworked alluvial fans)
D
Eastern margin proximal alluvial fan facies
E
Summary of the alluvial facies
association
Fig. 6. Alluvial palaeogeography and lateral facies changes: (A) plan view of the alluvial subenvironments; (B) and (D) vertical profiles of marginal facies association; (C) vertical profile of axial facies association; and (E) ideal vertical arrangement of the main facies. Facies code from Miall (1978); Bromley (1991).
Here, the tributary fan mean vectors (Fig. 5B) indicate the coalescence of two main fan lobes (Fig. 6A). The northern fan has a radius of 15 km, whereas the southern fan has a radius of 20 km. These dimen sions are comparable to the size of recent examples of semi-ariel and arid alluvial fans documented by Heward (1978). The point source of both lobes coincides with structural lows (synforms composed
of easily erodible metapelites) in the nearby base ment (Fig. 2). The southern lobe was more important than the others in terms of sedimentary input, as can be deduced both from it having penetrated furthest into the basin (Fig. 5B) and from the major intrusion of coarsest material from southeast to northwest (Figs 5C & 5D) in the southeast region of the basin. Comparison of the grain size distribution (Figs 5C
14
P. S.G. Paim
& 50) and palaeocurrent mean vectors (Fig. 5B) reveals some obvious relationships as well as some discrepancies. The gradual decrease of grain size, from both basin margins towards the basin axis (Figs 5C & 50) can be interpreted as a consequence of lateral alluv ial fan input. This matches the palaeoflow data of the eastern side of the basin, but not that on the western side (Fig. 5B). The textural, palaeocurrent and facies data sum marized in Fig. 6A demonstrate that the grain-size distribution within the trunk braided river system does not show a downcurrent fining, which is a very common characteristic of many braided alluvial environments (e.g. Smith, 1970; Miall, 1977, 1978; Rust, 1978; Collinson, 1986). Instead, the trunk rivers present a lateral change from sand-dominated deposits near the basin axis to mixed deposits towards the western basin border. Such a discrepancy can be related to a dominant alluvial input from the eastern border (tributary alluvial fans) causing the development of a trunk braided river system on the western side of the Camaqua Basin. The emplace ment of trunk rivers in the western region could cause a major remoulding of the alluvial fan deposits on the western border without erasing the down-fan fining. Some of these previous alluvial fan deposits could be preserved and thus could explain some atypical palaeocurrent readings made near the west ern margin, which point to a southeasterly directed sediment discharge. Transitions between purely sandy or gravelly reaches were the norm inside the alluvial system of the Guaritas sequence. The facies are usually arranged as fining upward cycles, bounded by fifth order bounding surfaces, with the major facies super imposed in the following order: Gm-Gp-St-Sh Fm. This characteristic vertical arrangement, reflecting the proportion of each facies (Table 1), is illustrated in a summary (idealized) vertical profile (Fig. 6E) incorporating the mean values of the principal facies observed throughout the basin. Comparison of the summary profile (Fig. 6E) with actual sections around the basin, and with the regional textural variation (Figs 5C & 50), facilitates the identification of some common marginal and axial facies associ ations, summarized in Figure 6: profiles B and D typify common marginal facies associations, whereas profile C represents the axial part of the basin.
CONCLUSIONS
The alluvial deposits of the Guaritas sequence reflect a lateral association of tributary alluvial fans and trunk braided rivers. The alluvial fans show a down stream decrease in mean grain size whereas the trunk rivers present no longitudinal variation in texture. Instead, the trunk rivers show a lateral grain-size change that is interpreted to have been inherited from a hypothetical alluvial fan system fed from the western margin of the basin. The alluvial fans are dominated by water laid deposits and comprise two main lobes. The source points of both alluvial fan lobes coincide with structural lows, suggesting control by basement topography. Semi-arid conditions during the alluvial depo sition are suggested by: sheet-flow and debris-flow deposits; petrological evidence, such as fresh feld spar and volcanic lithoclasts, interstitial hematite aggregates, caliche and silcretes; and the association with aeolian facies (although aeolian facies are com mon in early Palaeozoic sequences because of the absence of land vegetation regardless of climate). Diffuse gravel sheets and longitudinal bars were the main geomorphological elements in the alluvial gravelly reaches. Subaqueous dune aggradation, fol lowed by partial reworking of the deposit by upper flow regime currents, characterized the sandy reaches. An idealized channel-fill succession is typified, from base to top, by: (i) a horizontal to slightly undulatory erosional surface; (ii) gravel deposits, representing diffuse gravel sheets and longitudinal bars (Gm), locally with avalanche faces (Gp); and (iii) sandy deposits, consisting mainly of three dimensional subaqueous dunes (St), rare two dimensional dunes (Sp), and plane beds (Sh), on the top.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Thjs study was carried out during the tenure of a postgraduate scholarship awarded by the Research Council of the Brazilian Government (CNPq), and forms part of the author's D .Phil. thesis at the University of Oxford, England, written under the supervision of Dr H.G. Reading. Field-work costs were supported by CNPq (Grant 413321/ 88-6), Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos (UNISINOS), and Company of Research of Mineral
Palaeogeography of the Guaritas sequence Resources (CPRM) of the Brazilian Government. The author wishes to thank H. G. Reading and H.C. Jenkyns for criticism and revision of an earlier version of the manuscript. Later reviews by G. Plint, G.V. Middleton, A.P. Hamblin and P.A. Allen have enabled me to make several very useful improve ments to the paper.
RE FERENCES
J.R.L. (1963) The classification of cross-stratified units, with notes on their origin. Sedimentology, 2, 93-114. ALLEN, J.R.L. (1983) Studies in fluviatile sedimentation: bars, bar-complexes and sandstone sheets (low-sinuosity braided streams) in the Brownstones (L. Devonian), Welsh borders. Sediment. Geol., 33, 237-293. ALLEN, J.R.L. & BANKS, N.L. (1972) An interpret atiOn and analys1s of recumbent-folded deformed cross bedding. Sedimentology, 19, 257-283. ASHLEY, G.M. (1990) Classification of large-scale sub aqueous bedforms: a new look at an old problem. 1. sediment. Petrol., 60(1), 160-172. AsQUITH, G.B. & CRAMER, S.L. (1975) Transverse braid bars in the Upper Triassic Trujillo sandstone of the Texas Panhandle. J. Geol., 83, 657-661. BECKEL, J. (1990) Metalogenia del Cu, Pb y Zn en ALLEN,
Ia Cuenca de Camaquii durante e/ Cicio Orogenico Brasiliano- Rio Grande del Sur (Brasil). Unpublished PhD thesis, Universidad de Salamanca,274 pp. BECKEL, J. (1992) Evolus;ao geotect6nica da Bacia do Camagua, RS- Proposta de classificas;ao dentro de um conceito mobilista. J Workshop s6bre as bacias molassicas brasilianas,
Boletim
Especial
Resumos
Expandidos,
pp. 1-5. Sao Leopoldo. BECKER, M. R. & FERNANDES, L.A.D. (1982) Caracter izas;ao faciol6gica de uma sequencia vulcano-sedimentar eo-Paleoz6ica na f6lha Passo do Tigre ( RS). Acta geo/. Leopold. , 13(6), 287-321. BLACKWELDER, E. (1928) Mudflow as a geologic agent in semi-arid mountains. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 39, 465-483. BLAIR, T.C. & McPHERSON, J.G. (1992) The Trollheim alluvial fan and facies model revisited. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 104, 762-769. BRITO NEVES, B.B. & CoRDANl, U.G. (1991) Tectonic evolution of South America during the Late Protero zoic. Precam. Res. , 53, 23-40. BROMLEY, M.H. (1991) Variation in fluvial style as revealed by architectural elements, Kayenta Formation, Mesa Creek, Colorado, USA: evidence for both ephem eral and perennial fluvial processes. In: The Three dimensional Facies Architecture of Terrigenous Clastic Sediments and its Implication for Hydrocarbon Discovery
(Eds Miall, A.D. & Tyler, N.). Soc. Econ. Paleontol. Mineral. Spec. Publication, Concepts Sedimentol. Paleontol. Tulsa, 3, 94-102. BuLL, W.B. (1963) Alluvial fan deposits in Western Fresno County, California. J. Geol., 71, 423-251. CANT, D.J. (1978) Development of a facies model for a_nd Recovery
15
sandy braided river sedimentation: comparison of the South Saskatchewan river and the Battery Point Forma tion. In: Fluvial Sedimentology (Ed. Miall, A.D.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol., Calgary, Memoir 5, pp. 627-639. CANT, D.J. & WALKER, R.G. (1976) Development of a braided-fluvial facies model for the Devonian Battery Point, Quebec. Can. J. Earth Sci. , 13, 102-119. CANT, D.J. & WALKER, R.G. (1978) Fluvial process and facies sequence in the sandy braided South Saskatchewan river, Canada. Sedimentology, 25, 625-648. CoLLINSON, J.D. (1970) Bedforms of the Tana river, Norway. Geogr. Annaler, 52A, 31-55. COLLINSON, J.D. (1986) Alluvial sediments. In: Sedimen tary Environments and Facies (Ed. Reading, H.G.). pp. 20-62. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. DERos, L.F., MORAD,S. & PAlM,P.S.G. (1994) The role of detrital composition and climate on the diagenetic evolution of continental molasse: evidence from the Cambro-Ordovician Guaritas sequence, southern Brazil Sediment. Geo/., 92, 197-228. DNPM/CPRM (1987) Cachoeira do Sui- F6lha SH. 22-Y-A. Projeto mapas metalogeneticos e de previsao de recursos minerais, texto e mapas. Escala 1:250000. Brasflia. MME/DNPM/CPRM, 13 pp. DoE, T.W. & Dorr, R.H.,J R. (1980) Genetic significance of deformed cross bedding- with examples from the Navajo and Weber sandstones of Utah. J. sediment. Petrol., 50(3), 793-812. EYNON, G. & WALKER, R.G. (1974) Facies relationships in Pleistocene outwash gravels,Southern Ontario: a model for bar growth in braided rivers. Sedimentology, 21, 43-70. FAHNESTOCK, R.K. & BRADLEY, W.C. (1973) Knik and Mantanuska rivers, Alaska: a contrast in braiding. In: Fluvial Geomorphology (Ed. Morisawa, M.). State University of New York, Binghamton, Proc. 4th Geomorph. Symp., pp. 220-250. FRAGOSO-CESAR, A.R.S., LAVINA, E.L., PAlM, P.S.G. & FACC!Nl, U.F. (1984) A antefossa molassica brasiliana do cinturao Dom Feliciano no escudo do Rio Grande do Sui. Congress. Bras. Geol., 33 (Anais 7), 3272-3283. FRAGOSO-CESAR, A.R.S., MACHADO, R., SAYEG, H.S. & FAMBRJNJ, G.L. (1992) Bacias orogenicas do ciclo brasiliano no Rio Grande do Sui e Uruguai. J Work shop
s6bre
bacias
moltissicas
brasilianas,
Boletim
pp. 47-53. FRIEND, P.F., SLATER, M.J. & WILLIAMS, R.C. (1979) Vertical and lateral building of river sandstone bodies, Ebro Basin,Spain. J. geo/. Soc. London, 136,39-46. GALAY, V.J. & NEILL, C.R. (1967) Discussion of 'No menclature for bed forms in alluvial channels'. J. Hydr. Div. A mer. Soc. Civ. Eng. , 93, 130-133. HARMS, J.C.,SOUTHARD, J.B., SPEARING, D.R. & WALKER, R.G. (1975) Depositional Environments as Interpreted Especial Resumos Expandidos,
from Primary Sedimentary Structures and Stratification
Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Tulsa,Short Course 2. HElN, F.J. & WALKER, R.G. (1977) Bar evolution and development of stratification in the gravelly braided Kicking Horse River, British Columbia. Can. J. Earth Sci. , 14, 562-570. HEWARD, A.P. (1978) Alluvial fan sequence and mega sequence models: with examples from Westphalian Sequences.
16
P.S.G. Paim
D- Stephanian B coalfields, Northern Spain. In: Fluvial (Ed. Miall, A.D.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol.,Calgary, Memoir 5,597-604. HooKE, R. L E B. (1967) Process and arid-region alluvial fans. J. Geol., 75, 438-460. JACKSON, R.G., II (1975) Hierarchical attributes and a unifying model of bed forms composed of cohesionless material and produced by shearing flow. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 86,1523-1533. losT,H. (1984) Sedimentacao e vulcanismo durante o ciclo Brasiliano no Rio Grande do Sui: Uma revisao. Congres. Bras. Geol., 33, 3421-3457. LAVINA, E.L., FACC!Nl, U.F., PAlM, P.S.G. & FRAGOSO CESAR, A.R.S. (1985) Ambientes de sedimenta�ao da Bacia do Camaqua, RS. Acta geol. Leopold., 21, 185-227. McKEE, E.D., CROSBY, E.J. & BERYHILL, H.L. (1967) Flood deposits, Bijou Creek, June (1965) J. sediment. Petrol. , 37, 829-851. MIALL, A.D. (1974) Palaeocurrent analysis of alluvial sedi ments: a discussion of directional variance and vector magnitude. J. sediment. Petrol. , 44(4), 1174-1185. MIALL, A.D. (1977) A review of the braided-river depo sitional environment. Earth Sci. Rev. , 13, 1-62. MIALL, A.D. (1978) Lithofacies types and vertical profile models in braided river deposits: a summary. In: Fluvial Sedimentology (Ed. Miall, A.D.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol., Calgary, Memoir 5, 597-604. MIALL, A.D. (1985) Architectural-element analysis: a new method of facies analysis applied to fluvial deposits. Earth Sci. Rev. , 22, 261-308. MIALL, A.D. (1988) Architectural elements and bounding surfaces in fluvial deposits: anatomy of the Kayenta Formation (Lower Jurassic), Southwest Colorado. Sedi ment. Geol., 55,233-262. MIDDLETON, L.T. & TR UJ IL LO,A.P. (1984) Sedimentology and depositional setting of the Upper Proterozoic Scan lan Conglomerate, Central Arizona. In: Sedimentology of Gravels and Conglomerates (Eds Koster, E.H. & Sedimentology
Steel, R.J.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol.,Calgary, Memoir 10, 189-201. OwEN, G. (1987) Deformation process in unconsolidated sands. In: Deformation of Sediments and Sedimentaty Rocks (Eds Jones, M.E. & Preston, R.M.F.). Geol. Soc. London, Spec. Pub!., No. 29, 11-24. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. PAlM, P.S.G. (1994) Depositional Systems and Palaeogeo graphical Evolution of the Camaqua and Santa Barbara Basins, Brazil. Unpub. D.Phil. thesis, University of Oxford,277 pp. PuNT, A. G. (1983) Sandy fluvial point bar sediments from the Middle Eocene of Dorset, England. In: Modern and Ancient Fluvial Systems (Eds Collinson, J.D. & Lewin,J.). Spec. Pub!. int. Ass. Sediment. No. 6, 1933. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. RusT,B.R. (1972) Structure and process in a braided river. Sedimentology, 18,221-245. RusT, B.R. (1978) Depositional model for braided alluv ium. In: Fluvial Sedimentology (Ed. Miall, A. D.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol., Calgary, Memoir 5, 605-625. RusT, B.R. & KosTER, E.H. (1984) Coarse alluvial deposits. In: Facies Models (Ed. Walker,R.G.). Geosci. Can., Reprint Ser. 1, 71-89. SMITH, N.D. (1970) The braided stream depositional environment: comparison of the Platte River with some Silurian clastic rocks,North Central Appalachians. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. , 81,2993-3014. SOLIANI, E., JR.,FRAGOSO-CESAR, A. R.S.,TEIXEIRA, W. & KAWASHITA, K. (1984) Panorama geocronol6gico da por�ao meridional do escudo Atlantica. Congress. Bras. Geol., 33, 2435-2449. WALKER, R.G. & CANT, D.J. (1984) Sandy fluvial systems. In: Facies Models (Ed. Walker, R.G.). Geosci. Can., Reprint Ser. 1,71-89 (2nd Edn). WILLIAMS, G.E. (1971) Flood deposits of the sand-bed ephemeral streams of central Australia. Sedimentology, 17, 1-40.
Spec. Pubis int. Ass. Sediment. (1995) 22, 17-46
Sedimentology of a transgressive, estuarine sand complex: the Lower Cretaceous Woburn Sands (Lower Greensand), southern England H O W A R D D . J O H N S O N* and B R U C E K . L E V E L L t
* Department of Geology, Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine, t Shell
Prince Consort Road, London SW7 2BP, UK; and Exploration and Production Ltd, Shell-Mex House, Strand, London WC2R ODX, UK
UK
ABSTRACT
A sedimentological investigation of the Lower Cretaceous Woburn Sands of southern England has been used to develop a depositional model for a transgressive estuarine (or embayment) sand complex. The Woburn Sands average 70 m in thickness, but are over 100 m thick in places, and infill a NE-SW trending trough 25-30 km wide, which cuts into the western end of the NW-SE trending London Brabant land mass. Initially, this trough was of limited extent to the northeast but opened out into a broader shallow sea to the south and southwest. Subsequently, during the course of the major Early Cretaceous (Aptian-Albian) transgression, this feature formed a seaway connecting two previously separate basins (the North Sea Basin to the north and the Weald-Wessex-Channel Basin to the south) . The Woburn Sands record this overall transgressive history i n the form of six main facies bodies, which occur in five erosionally based units (from bottom to top) : (i) Orange and Heterolithic Sands; (ii) Silver Sands; (iii) Silty Beds; (iv) Red Sands; and (vi) Transition Series. The lowermost deposits (the Orange and Heterolithic Sands; equivalent to the Lower W oburn Sands) display convincing evidence of tidal current deposition (e.g. bimodal-bipolar palaeocurrent patterns, herringbone cross-bedding, clay drapes and wavy- flaser bedding) . They are further character ized by large-scale, subhorizontal and low-angle erosion surfaces, which are interpreted as tidal channel bases and tidal shoal accretion surfaces, respectively. The overlying sand deposits (the Silver and Red Sands; equivalent to the Upper Woburn Sands) display similar evidence of tidal current activity but are distinguished by overall coarser grain sizes, better sorting, lack of clay layers and the abundance of large-scale cross-bedding. The large-scale structures in the Silver and Red Sands dip mainly towards the south (inferred ebb direction), whereas similar structures in the exposed Orange Sands dip mainly to the northwest (inferred flood direction) . The overall sequence is interpreted in terms of a transgressive tide-dominated estuary or embayment model. The Lower Woburn Sands (Orange and Heterolithic Sands) were deposited in m utually evasive ebb and flood tidal channels and intervening tidal shoals, probably in an inner estuarine environment . In contrast, the higher energy Silver and Red Sands were deposited in the outer reaches of an estuary or embayment where greater water depths allowed the build-up of large-scale bedforms. The southward increase in both cross-bed set size and sand-body thickness in the Red Sands probably reflects general southward deepening. The final element in this facies succession is the draping of the sand complex by slowly deposited fossiliferous marine beds (Transition Series and Basal Beds of the Gault), which are overstepped to the north by the shallow-marine muds of the Gault. The description, interpretation and depositional model outlined here may assist in the recognition and prediction of similar shallow marine sand bodies. This study demonstrates, for example, that thick, high reservoir-quality sands with favourable geometries for stratigraphical traps can accumulate in transgressive estuaries and embayments. The resulting sand complex could be expected to comprise several erosively bounded, lenticular units displaying rapid lateral thickness and facies variations and an upward increase in reservoir quality and sand continuity. This would contrast with the more tabular geometry and more gradual lateral thickness and facies variations of similar tide-dominated deposits developed in offshore/shelf environments. Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading Edited by A. Guy Plint © 1995 The International Association of Sedimentologists ISBN: 978-0-865-42898-0
17
18
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell INTRODUCTION
Shallow-m arine sands (i.e those deposited in w ater depths of 10-200 m and rangi n g from inshore/sub tidal to offshore/neritic environmen ts) h ave received less attention th an most other cl astic deposits and , despite recent adv ances, current facies models remain rel atively generalized. Recent studies demonstrate that sh allow-marine sands occur in a v ariety of settings and owe their variability to several factors, p articularly the complex relationships between fluctu ations in w ater depth , subsidence rates, morphology of the coastal zone, sediment supply and the hydraulic regime of the b asin, includin g the shoreline (e . g. Swift & Thorne, 1991) . Most studies of shallow-marine sand bodies distin guish those resulting from tide-domin ated processes and those formed m ainly by w ave- and storm-domin ated processes (Johnson & B aldwin , 1986; Dalrymple, 1992; W alker & Plint, 1992). In this context the Lower Cretaceous Woburn S ands of southern E n gl and h as been quoted repe atedly as a prime example of an ancient tide-domin ated shallow-marine sand complex, with the spectacul ar l arge-scale cross-beddin g interpreted as the deposits of tid al sand w aves (e . g. Ben tley , 1970; de R aaf & Boersma, 1 97 1; Walker, 1984; Buck , 1985 ; Dalrymple, 1992). However, there h as been less agreement on the specific type of tid al environment preserved in the Woburn S ands and on its overall genetic evolution. Because the resultin g product is a thick sand of high reservoir quality, i t w as felt th at a better understanding of the Woburn S ands would assist in the development of strati graphical models of tid al sand bodies. This could aid their recognition in the subsurface , allow comparison with the geo metry and intern al ch ar acteristics of other sh allow m arine s and bodies (e. g. Exum & H arms, 1968; McCubbin, 1969; Campbell, 1971; Spearin g, 1 975) and contribute to the development of depositional models for hydrocarbon exploration and production. This w as the b ackground to a field study conducted in 197 9 when both authors were employed by the Koninklijke/Shell Exploratie en Produktie L ab oratorium (KSEPL) in Rijswijk , The Netherlands. Subsequently, the results were presented at the 1 980 Annu al Conference of the AAPG (Johnson & Levell, 1980) and documented in an internal report in 1 982. This l atter report forms the b asis for this p aper, which is presented here for several re asons. First, the model presented here is different in several respects to those interpretations published
both before and since completion of our work. Secondly, the 1 980 Abstract is cle arly an i n adequate reference document, but is nevertheless quoted by workers studying these exposures. Thirdly, these exposures comprise sand quarries, which are constantly changing as a result of con tinuing s and extraction. Hence, new observations are frequently m ade and so the d at a acquired during the course of this study, despite the time l apse , are still worthy of fuller documentation. Publishin g the results of this study will also allow our interpretation to be more critically eval u ated and will form a more l astin g contribution to the analysis of this important geological unit. The m ain aim of this p aper, therefore , is to provide a sedimentological description and to argue a deposi tional model for the Lower Cretaceous (Apti an- Albi an) Woburn S ands at Lei ghton Buzzard, southern E n gl and (Fi gs 1 & 2). It is not our intention to comprehensively evalu ate our findin gs in the context of more recent rese arch undertaken on the Woburn S ands, p artly because much of this remains unpublished, p articularly a detailed an alysis of sedimen tary structures of Buck ( 1987) , a litho strati graphical study by Eyers ( 1992 a) and a recent sequence strati graphical analysis by Won h am ( 1993).
GEOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK Stratigraphic framework
The Woburn S ands h ave been shown throu gh field m appin g and borehole evidence to comprise a lens shaped sand complex up to c. 100 m thick (Fig. 3 ) , which in fills a rel atively n arrow (25 -3 0 km wide) N E - SW trendin g trough (Bristow, 1963; Wy att et a/., 1986). The trough, which m ay be p artly tec tonic in ori gin (Eyers, 1 991) , came into existence in the L ate J ur assic, but w as infilled only in the E arly Cre taceous. At Lei ghton Buzzard, which is on the western m argin of the trough, the upper Aptian to lower Alb i an Woburn S ands unconformably overlie Upper Jurassic cl ays and are overstepped northwards by the Albian G ault (Fig. 4). Ammonites and brachiopods found in the b asal phosphatic gr avels of the Woburn S ands are assi gned to the upper Apti an ( nutfieldiensis zone; Casey, 196 1) . Althou gh the Woburn S ands currently exposed contain an abundan t and diverse ichno-
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
19
0'
2'
- Aptian-Albian Lower Greensand outcrop distribution
0
50
100km
,
LHTON BUZZARD
I
l. Location map showing the distribution of Lower Cretaceous outcrops.
Fig.
fauna they do not contain a shelly fauna, possibly because of leaching of calcium carbonate. The over l ying beds be long to the Transition Series, which comprises a thin ( 1 -2 m) , complex and relatively poorly exposed succession of variable lithologies, including the Shenle y Limestone and various iron cemented beds referred to locall y as 'Carstone ' ( Fi g. 3). The Shenle y Limestone contains lower Albian (tardefurcata to mammillatum zone) fauna and represents a depositional hiatus with a complex depositional and diagenetic history (Eyers, 1992b). The condensed lower Albian Gau lt (dentatus zone) represents a northward overstep, which can be related to the ' 108 Ma' maximum floodin g surface of Haq et a!. ( 1987). The paucity of datable fauna within the Woburn Sands essentially precludes further correlation wi th events elsewhere in the Lower Greensand basin (Ruffell & Wach, 199 1 , i n press). Palaeogeographical setting and depositional environments
Duri n g
the
Early
Cretaceous
( Ryazanian
to
Barremian) the London- Brabant land mass formed an intermi ttent land barrier between a shallow marine southern North Sea Basin (the Boreal Sea) to the north, and a freshwater Wealden Basin to the south (Fi g. 5A) . This southern basin, to ge ther with the Channel, Southwestern Approaches, Celtic Sea and Bristol Channel Basins ( Ziegler, 1988, 1990) , formed a series of mainly separate and active, fault bounded basins in the southern British Isles , which underwent a c. 40-million-year period of alluvial sedimentation and the deposition of 'Weald en ' facies ( P. Allen, 198 1 ) . This period o f non-marine sedimentation was terminated by the major Aptian-Albian marine trans gression and the deposition of the Lower Greensand Group. This was mainly a consequence of continued sea-floor spreading and northward extension of the Atlantic Ocean and the Early Cretaceous eustatic sea-level rise. This resulted in progressive, northeastward marine inundation of the Southwestern Approaches, Channel and Weald Basins. Simultaneously, there was also marine northwestward-directed transgression through the Paris Basin into sou thern England and
20
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
@
f!7' Jane's Pit
Heath and Reach
A
@
Old { Llnslade Road
0
Three main periods of marine transgression are recorded in the Lower Greensand of southern England, each associated with depos it ion of exten s ively cross-bedded t idal deposits (Bridges, 1982). The upper Apt ian to lower Alb ian Woburn Sands are associated w ith the transgressive breaching of the London-Brabant land ma�s (Figs SB & SC) . However, although the Woburn Sands clearly represent, in broad terms, a transgressive shallow marine sand deposit , more precise environmental interpretations have remained uncertain. The large scale cross-bedding, extensive bioturbation and evi dence of reversin g currents has led most authors to su ggest a t idal environment (Lamplugh, 1922; Schwarzacher, 1953; Bentley, 1970; de Raaf & Boersma, 197 1 ) , but these authors d isagree , or are non-committal, about specific t idal subenviron ments, with su ggestions ranging from open shelf to tidal fiat for different facies in the complex. From these possibilities, two main deposit ional models emerge for all or part of the Woburn Sands: 1 t idal shelf or seaway, such as the present-day Straits of Dover/En gl ish Channel (e. g. Brid ges, 1982 ) ; 2 tidal estuary o r embayment (e. g. Johnson & Levell, 1980) . These alternatives w ill be considered here in the light of our observations. Similarly, the uncerta inty as to whether the breakthrou gh across the London Brabant land mass (the 'Bedforsh ire Strait' of K irkaldy ( 1939)) occurred as a result of southward or northward extension of a coastal embayment will also be considered.
1km
Lithostratigraphical subdivision and relationships Fig.
2. Location of the sand pits used in this study and the
line of the cross-section illustrated in Fig. 4.
southerly expansion throughout the southern part of the North Sea Basin and adjacent areas (e . g. West Netherlands, Broad Fourteens and Lower Saxony Basins; Ze igler, 1990) . The precise t iming of full marine connection between these basins is uncertain, but most recent reconstructions show this to have occurred by the late Aptian or early Alb ian, at around the time of deposit ion of the Woburn Sands and the overlyin g Gault. Hence , on a regional scale, the depositional h istory of the Woburn Sands would appear to be related to marine transgression that resulted in the connection of two main intracratonic basins.
cThe Woburn Sands comprise up to six facies bodies, which are readily d istinguished on the basis of their l ithofac ies characteristics (mainly grain size, com posit ion , colour, clay content, sed imentary struc tures and bioturbation) . Most of these facies bodies are separated by major subhorizontal to low-an gle erosion surfaces, and five discontinuity-bounded units have been defined as follows (Table 1 & Fi g. 3 ) : 1 Transition Series (you n gest) ; 2 Red Sands;
Fig. 3. (Opposite.) Composite vertical section through the Woburn Sands.
LITHOSTRATIGRAPHIC NOMENCLATURE
-�--'·-·
-�------,
ENVIRONMENTAL SUMMARY
0- ·-:__-_c
"' :0
:;;: :;;
-' 3:
0
------
.. 0 ..
,., :; "' (.')
:;
:;
"'
(.')
- . "Dentatus "--
Cl
�����
Blanket shelf muds
t:=== = -:::::-=---
Carstone and Shanley Limestone
-
BURROW TYPES
u
-
10 Transition Series
u c
"'
rocn
(f) u
u
a:
�� 0
--- -- · "'"'''
\���-
Red Sands
''- -- ...Y.C
<1>
20�"'
en�
- _____/Slow deposition/reworked, transgressive e:i3> deposits
"����
"'
<1>
0:<1> u
--
"'
�u
:=C
en"' (f)
Silly Beds
�\�� ''\�
� . ''''"
,,,,,
''-'-'-'->--."."''-':-
c
"'
5
.0"'
�-g �"'
Q)(f)
a. a.
=>
u c
"'
Silver Sands
(f)
:;;
.2 Ui
30-
"'
..: :;;
a. a. =>
"'
u c
"'
(/)
E
40 -
::l .0 0
Heterolithic Sands
3:
--
"'
u c "' (f) c
5
.0 0
3: :;;
-'
�� ------�-
-s==: �L
-
�-
�
.. ...
----� ---� !"- .,_.
-- -- ----
High energy, ebb dominated channel! shoal complex (estuary mouth or open marine, sea strait environment)
(:==.:r> =
==M /Low energy, estuary abandonment! transgressive deposits
J High energy, ebb dominated, estuary mouth channel/shoal complex (= ebb-tidal delta environment)
�-
c
"li
� -� ��
=
= =M
= = = =
Low-moderate energy, estuary shoal deposits
=
�
�--.1!....,
"' u c
50 -
"'
� ..}.\.._ �
(f) c 3:
-
e
en
�-
�
�� ��
..... � -:::'{J! � � � /// !))})
3:
0
�
·-··--�
Orange Sands 60-
.__
�
Moderate-high energy, flood dominated, channel-fill sands intercalated with tidal shoal deposits
�--��---""!.
? 70 -
Large-scale cross-bedding Trough cross-bedding Ripple cross-lamination Intraclasts
Basal transgressive deposits with phosphate nodules and reworked faunas
��[�
UPPER JURASSIC
J:?/-::-1 B. Q D
== =
. EJ c=J 1:-�;1 E;J '
Wavy bedding
� Strongly bioturbated
Flaser bedding
6:11 Shells and shell debris
Low-angle erosion surfaces
Q Plant debris
Concretions/nodules
-& Occasional burrows
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
22
Table 1. Summary of the l ithofacies and reservoir characteristics of the main units within the Woburn Sands Interval
Lithology
Gault Clay
Grey fossiliferous claystones
Transition Series
Iron-cemented pebbly sands (basal beds); glauconitic & phosphatic fine-coarse, partly argillaceous Transgressive lag deposits. sands. In-situ lenses of richly fossiliferous limestone (Shenley Lmst.). Reworked clasts of iron-cemented sst. (Carstone) & Shenley Lmst. Rapid lateral lithological variations.
Muddy shelf.
Three main types of cross-bedding: I
Red Sands
Med.-v.coarse sand Mod.-poorly sorted. Ferruginous with up to 20% bv detrital iron oxide (red colouration) up to 2.5% bv heavy minerals 100% sand.
Silty Beds (/) Q z <( (/) z a:
::;:)
Ill 0 Silver
;:
Dep. environment
Physical sedimentary structures
Sands
"//!/1/1/1
0.-":
11
l
��T �1 %
III
;;
�:JtYti,;;tff
J
Giant cross-bedding with avalanche foresets & infilling, large scours ca 3m deep and 1OOm wide. Wedge-shaped sets (-2-3m thick) superimposed on low-angle (4-8°), S-dipping surfaces.
-�-am0.1-4m thick tabular & J trough cross-bedding.
Grey-green glauconitic & lignitic Coarse sands have flat bases, large rippled or flat surfaces & internally cross-bedded or horizontally laminated. clays, silts & f. sands. Minor crs., well sorted sand Fine sands occasionally show low-angle to horizontal lamination but mainly layers & lenses. bioturbated. -20-40% sand. Med.-v.crs. sand. Well-sorted. Quartz arenites. Minor carbonaceous debris. Locally Fa-cemented e.g. clay clasts on erosion surfaces). 100% sand.
��/-71"lr ��: +m Northern area:
(J.t,t,l,ffZt:;Z,'
1
'L1 1 n-:
Southern area:
Large-scale, low-angle (2-4°) surfaces separated m by o.5-2m thick, tabular cross-bed sets. 1-3m avalanche-type cross-bedding, partly filling urs. Complex low-angle s
���
Main structures (in order of decreasing importance) current ripple Numerous thin clay cross-lamination, trough cross-bedding, scour & fill structures & low-angle layers. Intraclasts of cross lamination. Herringbone cross-bed patterns. Abundant clay drapes clay & carbonac. produce wavy & !laser bedding. Large-scale low-angle surfaces (dipping debris. -90% sand. -40)
3
Fine to crs. mod. sorted sands. Scattered quartz granules, clay pebbles & clay drapes. Iron oxide cement in liesegang rings & around clay deposits. -95-100% sand.
Large-scale subhorizontal (1) & low-angle (2) erosion surfaces.
1
��
=
2
D
/////////////////////I
I
�
Large avalanche foresets fill deep scours (1-5m thick). Low angle surfaces separated by cross-laminated, cross-bedded & bioturbated sands. Flaser & wavy bedding/clay drapes.
S ilty Beds; Silver S ands; Oran ge S ands and the Heterolithic S ands ( Lower Woburn S ands or Brown S ands). This inform al scheme generally follows that of Ben tley ( 1970) and is read il y correl ated w ith the
4 5
Transgressive or local abandonment deposit.
Variety of large-scale cross-bedding:
Heterolithic Fine to v.fine mod. Sands sorted sands.
Orange Sands
High-energy, ebb-dominated complex (estuary/embayment mouth or open marine sea strait).
High-energy ebb-dominated embayment mouth channel-shoal complex (cf ebb-tidal deltas)
Moderate-energy, tidal shoal deposits within an inner estuarine/inner embayment ?margmal to tidal channel complex (=Oranae Sands). High-energy flood-dominated tidal channel-fill sands with intercalated moderate-to high-energy tidal shoal deposits.
term inology of prev ious workers (Table 1 & Fig. 3 ) , inclu d in g the schemes o f W yatt e t al. ( 1 986) and the more recent form al l ithostratigraphy of Sheph ard Thorn et a/. ( 1986) . The vertical and l ater al rel ationsh ips of these units are summar ized in Figs 3 & 4, respectively. The b ase
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
23
Table 1. (Continued. ) Fauna and biogenic sedimentary structures
�'it�fe':.�ent SEAL
Ammonites, belemnites, bivalves, brachiopods.
g
POOR to V-POOR -partly sealing due to cementing & argill. content
Abundant ammonites, bivalves, belemnites, astropods & oysters. Partly reworked & phosphatized. henley Lmst.= brachipods, echinoids & crustacea.
No preserved fauna (?leached) 2 main types of bioturbation:
Reservoir characteristics
Pal
Unimodal to the S-SSE GOOD Very locally reduced by minor Fe cementation. No shale layers.
Minor reversals II Funnel to v-shaped burrows due to vertical animal escape or sediment collapse/inti II. Large burrows (1O's & herringbone patterns mm wide, up to -1OOmm high) caused by large bivalve or crustacaean.
No distinct burrow types.
Unfossiliferous. Negligible bioturbation-rare single clay-lined burrows (Ophiomorpha) towards the top in some places (e.g. New Trees).
Unfossiliferous (?leached). Extensively bioturbated (ca. 10-50% of primary structures destroyed). Horizontal, slightly sinuous, clay-lined burrows are the most common type & occur mainly in cross-laminated sands. Occasional vertical to oblique burrows.
Unfossiliferous (?leached). Moderately to strongly bioturbated (30-50% of primary structures destroyed) & variety of burrow types: (i) narrow vertical tubes, (ii) sinuous subhorizontal burrows producing colour mottling. (iii) iron-cemented vertical to steeply inclined burrows, (iv) subhorizontal branching burrows Thalassinoides. (v) v-shaped burrows.
-?Om max. 1-2m
0->15m
I Intense, small-scale colour mottling (5mm diam.) -pale core & darker rim. Caused by horizontal burrows & resulting in negligible destratificatation.
No fauna observed. Strongly bioturbated throughout- fine sediments effectively destratified.
Thickness
(?up 1o10's m max.)
Bimodal-bipolar S-SW modes are dominant (directions of all major structures)
Bimodal-bipolar WSW mode dominant & ENE mode slightly subordinate
Bimodal-bipolar NW mode dominant with minor S-SSW mode
of the lowest unit, the Orange and Heterolithic Sands, was not seen but is thought to directly overlie the phosphati c gravels and sands of the fossiliferous basal beds re corded in abandoned pits ( Lamplugh, 1922). The relationship between these two lower most sands has also not been observed directly, with
-thin permeable sands probably laterally extensive (=Storm layers)
VERY GOOD vertically & laterally uniform
MODERATE to POOR -discontinuous shale layers
1-2m
Sheet-like/tabular
E-W lenticular geometry in N
Large-scale southward thickening wedge in S.
g
-drapes irre . surface of ilver Sand. -dissected cut-out by erosional base of the Red Beds.
2-15m
Tabular within study area.
<25m
Uncertain-restricted to E part of study area. Possibly interfinger to W with Orange Sands.
up to -50m
Uncertain, greater N-S continuity ct. E-W.
MODERATE to GOOD -distinct higher permeability zones within N-S trending channels.
Sheet-like
Lenticular
POOR/SEAL Isolated structures show dips to S
Geometry
either lateral interfingering or erosional contact both possible. However, facies similarities (discussed later) suggest that the Orange and Heterolithic Sands are probably lateral equivalents. The boundary between the top of the Woburn Sands and the overlying Gault is generally poorly
24
H. D. Johnson and B. K. Levell
D Gault Cia'{ D Transition Series [(g);j Red Sands (RS)
�j:j:j:j Silty Beds
- Silver Sands (SS) � Heterolithic Sands (HS) EO(,<�J Orange Sands (OS) North D Jurassic clays ..,.
0
2km
w
--
Approx. depth of present-day exposures
0 10 E: "
20 )§
0
30
10
·t <.) Q)
40.0 :: 0 50 a; .0
20 30
60 �
Q)
70::2:
40
80
50 60
Fig. 4. Cross-section through the Woburn Sands illustrating the vertical and lateral relationships between the main lithostratigraphical units (sec Fig. 2 for location) . The locations at which some of the main lithostratigraphical boundaries can be seen arc indicated by single vertical lines. Note the dashed line indicating the approximate depth of present-day exposures. Datum is the base of the cristatum subzone.
exposed and has not been studied here in any detail . However, this impo rtant and richly fossilife ro us inte rval has been studied e xtensively in the past by palaeontologists and biostratigraphe rs, who have meas ured many detailed vertical profiles (e.g. Lamplugh, 1 922; Wright & W right, 19 47; Casey, 19 61 ; Owen, 1 9 72). These data have been incor porated into Table 1 and Figs 3 & 4.
SEDIMENTOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS
This section outlines in detail the sedimentological cha racteristics of the six main facies types. The key points of description and interp retation are summarized in Table l .
Transgressive estuarine sand complex A
25
B
BOREAL BOREAL
SEA
SEA
:r:
,'
�
Main palaeocurrent directions 50 100km �---
5. Three schematic palaeogeographical maps illustrating the transgressive history of the Lower Cretaceous in the southern North Sea- English Channel area, and the evolution of the 'Bedfordshire Strait' which ultimately connected the Boreal Sea and the Wealden Basin. Aptian-Albian outcrop shown in black (a) Ryazanian-Valanginian; (b) Aptian: Woburn sands, Folkcstonc sands, Hythe and Sandgate beds; (c) Albian, Gault clay. (Based on Ziegler, 1988, 1990.) Fig.
'----'"'---..J100km
H. D . Johnson and B. K. Levell
26 Orange Sands
D_escription
Based on the available exposures at the time of our field-work in 1 9 79 (B ryant's Lane, Stone Lane and Sheepcott quarries; Fig. 2), these sands a re moder ately sorted, fine- to coa rse-grained and contain some quartz granules, clay pebbles and wood frag ments. The o range colour is due to widespread iron oxide, whi ch o ccurs as a cement, in Liesegang rings and in rims around clay (e.g. clay pebbles, drapes and burrow linings). Large-scale erosion surfaces within the unit have been divided a rbitra rily into two types:
NE
I Subhorizontal erosion surfaces a re essentially flat and extend up to 200 m. Lo cally they cut down in con cave-upward scours 4- 6 m deep ( Fig. 6) . The e rosion surfaces are spa ced 5 - 10 m apart verti cally and a re normally overlain by coa rse lags of granules and mud flakes. 2 Low-angle erosion surfaces o ccur within the units bounded by e rosion surfaces of type I and pass laterally and down-dip into the subhorizontal e rosion surfa ces ( Fig. 6) . They are spaced at intervals of a few decimetres to 1 m and separate inte rvals with a variable array of cross-bedding, cross-lamination and burrows ( Fig. 7) . The more deeply e rosive parts of the subhorizontal erosion surfaces a re overlain by 1 -5 m thick tabular
f<---- Flood-dominated tidal channel
Tidal bar -----+1
SW
metres 0
8 .
Transport toN
Photograph location
+----- 150metres--------•
6. An example of large-scale facies relationships in a flood tidal-channel complex in the Orange Sands. The base of the channel is a horizontal erosion surface lined with intraformational clay clasts. A series of low-angle (4-8°) erosion surfaces (right side of the photograph) mark the flanks of a tidal bar, which is characterized by small-scale cross-bedding and moderate to strong bioturbation . The inclinations of the low-angle erosion surfaces (inferred bar flank surfaces) increase laterally (to the left) and eventually pass into high-energy, channel-fill deposits displaying tabular avalanche foresets up to 4 m high. A second flood-tidal channel sequence is also exposed in the lower part of the section. The simplified field sketch (sec Fig. 3 for legend) shows the broader relations between the bioturbated tidal bar sands and the avalanche foresets of flood-dominated, tidal channel-fill sands (from Bryant's Lane pit) .
Fig.
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
27
7 . Physical and biogenic sedimentary structures i n the Orange Sands. (A) Tidal bar deposits comprising small- to moderate-scale cross-bedding (10-SOcm thick) separated by horizontal and low-angle erosion surfaces with thin intraformational mud-flake conglomerates, and occasional clay layers. The numerous low-angle reactivation surfaces give a characteristic wedge-shaped appearance to the cross-bed sets (see also ( D ) ) . ( B ) Close-up of the central part of (A) illustrating some details of the bioturbation. Note in particular the simple vertical burrows and a large V-shapcd burrow (lower centre of photo) . (C) Large-scale tabular cross-bedding infilling a flood tidal channel (upper half of photo) . Vertical burrows increase in density in the deeper part o f the channel and arc inclined perpendicular t o the forcscts. The underlying deposits display oppositely-dipping cross-bedding, horizontal and inclined erosion surfaces and moderate bioturbation. (D) Wedge-shaped cross-bedding with numerous reactivation surfaces, which arc occasionally overlain by clay drapes or oppositely-dipping cross-lamination. Fig.
or wedge-shaped c ross-bedding with NE-dipping avalanche foresets separated by large-scale , low angle erosion surfaces (Fig. 6) . These low-angle e rosion surfaces may flatten up-dip into more closely spaced, subhorizontal e rosion surfaces. This is ac companied by a change in sedimentary structures from 1-5-m-thick avalanche cross-bedding to 0.20. 7-m-thick sets of t rough cross-bedding, cu rrent ripple cross-lamination and flaser and wavy bedding. Palaeocurrent directions from all these deposits a re variable, but there is abundant evidence of reve rsals , especially in the smaller-scale structures. The larger structures show mainly northwest-flowing palaeo cu rrents but with clear, subordinate reve rsals (Fig. 8).
Burrowing has destroyed , on average, some 3050% of the p rimary structures and has been sub divided into five types: 1 Na rrow ( c. 2 mm) vertical tubes that form a branching network with sections 10 -20 mm long. These tubes have no clay lining and a re extremely fragile, being visible only on wind-sculpted faces. They resemble burrows p roduced by polycheate worms in modern sands of estuaries and tidal flats (Schafer, 1 9 72 ) . 2 Sinuous, subho rizontal burrows p roducing c. 5-mm-diameter colour mottling. These burrows occur mainly in the ripple-laminated sands. 3 Simple , ve rtical or steeply inclined tubes ( c. lO mm diameter and 50-200 mm long) with clay linings,
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
28
N
I
N
I
Red Sands
n=89
Silver Sands
n=157
Interpretation
The interbedding of deposits wi th opposed palaeo current modes, evidence of rapid lateral variation in flow regime (as shown by the intercalation of large and small-scale structures), the range of burrow types , and the clay drapes, are all common character istics of high-energy, shallow-water tidal deposits (de Raaf & Boersma , 197 1 ; N io & Yang, 1 99 1 ) . The subhorizontal erosion surfaces, therefore, probably define the bases of tidal channels and, at least in the areas of deepest scour, these channels carried northwestward flowing water. The low-angle erosion surfaces are interpre ted as the accretionary flanks of in-channel bars on which curren t dominance was less pronounced and low-energy structures were preserved (e.g. Yang & N io, 1989 ) . There is no evidence that the preserved portions of these bars were e ither emergent or suffered severe wave activity . The Orange Sands thus represent a h igh energy, tidal channel complex w ith mutually evasive ebb and flood tidal currents. Heterolithic Sands
Description
Orange Sands
n=203
Heterolithic Sands (scale x2)
n=52
8. Palaeocurrent distributions based mainly on l arge scale cross-bedding.
Fig.
wh ich are frequently the sites of iron-oxide precipi tation (Fig. 7A & B) . Th is type projects normal to the bedding even when this is inclined (Fig. 7 C) , and is w idespread throughout the Orange Sands. 4 Complex, subhorizontal to inclined, branching burrow networks c. 10-40 mm in diameter and w ith enlarged, bulbous junctions (Fig. 7D). Iron cementation preserves these in three dimensions. This type most closely resembles the crustacean burrow system Ophiomorpha. 5 Nested cone-shaped burrows (V-shaped in two dimensions, Fig. 7 B) . These appear to represent the collapse of sedimentary lamination i n to 20-30-mm w ide horizontal tubes, but may also occur as iron cemented , V-shaped laminae. They are especially common in sands just above and below major erosion surfaces.
This unit comprises moderately sorted, fine to very fine grained sands w ith numerous clay layers, scattered clay flakes and woody detritus. The sands are largely grey, while the clay drapes and surround ing sands are some times rust-coloured due to iron oxides. The sands contain low-angle ( c. 4 °) erosion sur faces tens of metres long that closely resemble those of the Orange Sands, with the exception that they do not pass downwards into channel-fill facies and are often overlain by relatively continuous clay drapes. The main sedimentary s tructures are, in order of decreasing importance: current ripple cross lamination (Fig. 9A) , trough cross-bedding, scour and-fill s tructures and low-angle cross-lamination. Clay drapes occur on set boundaries and foresets w ith in all types of cross-stratification and sometimes produce wavy and flaser bedding (Fig. 9A & B). Although not measured in detail , clay drape d istr i bution is suggestive of tidal bundles, possibly w ith neap-spring tide cycles (e.g. Visser, 1980). Evidence of bidirectional currents is ubiquitous in all these s tructures (e.g. Fig. 9A) . The larger foresets commonly have superimposed smaller sets w ith reversed dips . Cross-stratification type varies over
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
29
Fig. 9. Physical sedimentary structures in the Heterolithic Sands. (A) Flaser bedding associated with small-scale, current ripple cross lamination. Herringbone patterns are occasionally developed but normally the southwest ebb direction is dominant. (B) Clay draped foresets separated by thick clay layers, which are internally disrupted by bioturbation.
short distances, both laterally and vertically, and there are no progressive vertical changes in either set thickness or grain size. Palaeocurren ts are bimodal-bipolar, with a dominant southwest directed mode (Fig. 8). Burrowing, which has destroyed around 10-50% of the primary sedimentary fabric, is dominated by sinuous, horizontal, clay-lined forms (Fig. 10). Burrows are most common in the flaser and wavy bedded subfacies and may be virtually absent in the larger decimetre-scale cross-bed sets. The pre dominance of horizon tal burrows results in little disturbance of the sedimentary structures. Less common types are vertical to oblique and rare , spiral clay-lined burrows (Fig. lOD).
Interpretation
The bimodal-bipolar palaeocurrent pattern , and the assemblage and variability of sedimentary structures in this unit suggest a shallow-marine tidal origin . The thickness o f this facies (up t o 25 m was recorded by Bentley ( 1970)) and the lack of features rep resenting emergence (rootlets, wave-reworked sur faces, desiccation cracks, etc . ) suggest deposition in a subtidal environment of moderate water depth and fluctuating flow conditions. The lack of distinct channel-fill facies and the ubiqui tous presence of low-angle inclined erosion surfaces wi th a constan t south-eastward dip suggests accretion on a broad subtidal shoal. Relatively low-energy curren ts are
30
H.D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
Fig. 10. Biogenic sedimentary structures i n the Heterolithic Sands. (A) Strong bioturbation i n current ripple cross laminated and partly ftaser bedded sands. The dominant biogenic structures are horizontal, clay-lined burrows. (B) Moderate bioturbation mainly by horizontal, clay-lined burrows with a single inclined burrow (southeast of lens cap) . Bidirectional, cross-lamination with occasional clay-ftasers is still well-preserved. (C) Plan view of the dominant burrow type in this facies comprising horizontal, sinuous, clay-lined burrows with back-fill laminae. (D) Isolated example of a vertical, clay-lined burrow resembling Ophiomorpha. Background facies is ripple laminated, ftaser bedded sand.
suggested by the small scale of cross-bedding and the predominance of r ipple cross-lamination , whereas the extensive clay drapes suggest relatively long periods of quiet water conditions. Silver Sands
Description
The Silver Sands consist of well-sorted , medium- to very coarse-grained quartz arenites (previously used as glass sands ) . Sooty and woody carbonaceous matter is locally abundant, but clay drapes are absent. These sands truncate all earlier deposits w ith a major planar to regionally concave -upwards erosion surface which is lined with granules and clay flakes. The lag deposit overlying this erosion surface is well cemented by iron oxides.
In the northwest of the area (around Heath and Reach, Fig. 2) several pits expose up to 20 m of S ilver Sands, and major low-angle (2-4° apparent dips) erosion surfaces w ith a constant southwestward dip can be p icked out throughout the u n it (Fig. llA ) . Between these planar to slightly undulose erosion surfaces tabular cross-bed sets from 0.5 to 2 m thick occur (Fig. 1 1B ) . The erosion surfaces terminate abruptly down-dip, resulting in thickening of some cross-bed sets, and formation of hanging set bound aries. No s ingle surface could be traced from the top of the 1 5 -m -thick unit to the base. There is only occasional evidence of reversing palaeo currents, such as at the base of the unit in Munday's H ill quarry, resulting in an overwhelmingly domi nant southwestward dip to all scales of forese t (Figs 8 & 1 1) . I n the extreme north o f the area o f the Silver
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
31
Fig. 11. Physical sedimentary structures i n the Silver Sands from the northern part of the study area. (A) A complete vertical section through the Silver Sands ( c. 15 m thick) illustrating a sequence of moderate- to l arge-scale cross-bedding (set thickness c. 0.5-2.0 m ) separated by undulatory horizontal to low-angle erosion surfaces (dipping to right ) . Cross bedding is mainly undirectional to the southwest (ebb-sets) . A prominent erosion surface lined with intraformational clay clasts and quartz granules forms a ledge j ust below the contact between the dark and light coloured sands. The dark sands represent ebb-dominated channel-fill sands within the upper part of the Orange Sands. (B) Closer view of the southwest directed, ebb-dominated Silver Sands (quarry face c. 10 m high ) . Note the undulatory nature of the erosion surfaces and corresponding irregularities in cross-bed set thickness (c. 0.5-2 m ) . There are no positive signs of reversing currents in these ebb-dominated sands. The ledges produced along the various erosion surfaces are not lined with clay; these sections are in c. 100% quartz sand.
Sands are somewhat thinner and more iron-stained. Cross-bedding is predominantly of the avalanche type in se ts 1 - 2 m thick . Three-dimensional ex posures show these sets to be the infills of spoon shaped scours with the appearance of micro-de ltas, rather than the deposits of migrating large-scale megaripp les (or sand waves) with flat bases. In the Shenley Hill area further to the east (Fig. 2), tabular sets 2-4 m thick comprise the bulk of the Silver Sands (Fig. 1 2 ) . These were relative ly poorly exposed during our fie ld -work but were photographed by Bentley ( 1970) and have been
re-exposed recently ( J . Eyers, 1994 pers. comm . ) . Internally these sets show complex lateral transitions from single avalanche se ts, which are a lways directed to the south or southwest (Fig. 8) , and which pass into thinner tabular or wedge-shaped sets of up- and down-slope dipping foresets, separated by low-angle or subhorizontal erosion surfaces (Fig. 13). These sets have only been seen in sections paralle l to the transport direction , and their strike configuration is unknown. Bentley ( 1970) claimed to be able to map the E -W trend of individua l sand-wave crests in this area.
V.> N
::t: \:::)
0' �
a
Cl
;: ., ;: "' t:l;)
;>;: !:""'
"' "' "' :::::
Fig. 12. Large-scale, sand-wave-type cross-bedding in the Silver Sands (Munday ' s Hill Quarry) . Individual sets are up to 4 m thick and are internally complex, ranging from avalanche foresets to low-angle surfaces (6-8°) separated by upslope- and downslope-dipping cross-bedding (see Fig. 13 for details) . Note also the sharp, planar contact between the Silver Sands and Silty Beds and the erosional contact between the Silver and Red Sands. The dark area along this contact represents a ridge of strong iron cementation ('Carstone rib ' ) . Finally the sequence is capped by the marine Gault Clay.
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
33
Fig. 13. Internal characteristics of the sand-wave-type cross-bedding in the Silver Sands in the Munday 's Hill- Double Arches area (large-scale structures illustrated in Fig. 12). (A) Tabular cross-bedding with simple, angle-of-repose foresets. Note small oppositely-dipping set (by lens cap) separating the main , thick sets and a prominent reactivation surface in the upper thick set (Double Arches Quarry) . (B) Relatively small tabular cross-beds, with each displaying an upward decrease in grain size (Munday's Hill Quarry) . (C) The low-angle surfaces dipping to the left represent an ebb directed (to southwest) sand-wave lee face . Internally these coarse to granule grade sands display upslope dipping cross bedding which represents flood-directed megaripples (Munday ' s Hill Quarry ) . (D) Herringbone patterns developed in relatively small sets of trough cross-bedding (Munday's Hill Quarry ) .
In the extreme west of the area, west of Heath and Reach (Sheepcott quarry; Fig. 2) , a heterolithic facies of decimetre-scale cross-bedded sands with persistent clay drapes overlies the Orange Sands. These beds, formally assigned to the Lower Woburn Sands, could be a lateral facies variant of the Silver Sands. In general, the Silver Sands are weakly bio turbated, apart from the upper few metres in some pits (e.g. New Trees) , where clay-lined Ophiomorpha-type burrows occur. Interpretation
The textural and mineralogical maturity of the Silver Sands, the uniformly large size of cross-bedding and
the lack or scarcity of clay drapes and burrows suggest deposition in a higher energy environment than both the Heterolithic and Orange Sands. None the less, the relatively infrequent evidence of revers ing palaeocurrents still suggests tidal deposition. The extensive subhorizontal erosion surface at the base of the unit and the evidence of a bedform complex up to 1 5 m thick, at least in the Heath and Reach area, suggest deposition in a high-energy, current-dominated bar system after a period of wide spread erosion. There is no clear channel-fill facies and it is possible that deposition occurred in an environment in which interbar depressions were created by the accretion of shoals rather than the active cutting of channels. In more detail, the cross-bedding indicates large ,
34
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
possibly sand-wave-type bedforms with super imposed megaripples over the majority of the out crop area, and microdelta-like forms infilling scour hollows in the north. Taken together with a similar change in cross-bedding style in the younger Red Sands (see below ) , this change could be related to a southward increase in water depth across the study area (Fig. 2 ) , which allowed the construction of larger bedforms in the south of the area. In comparison with the shoal complex of the Heterolithic Sands, current energy was apparently much higher and there was less time for the settling of suspended clay. The textural and mineralogical maturity of the sands also indicates a more intensive phase of reworking prior to final deposition. Silty Beds
Description
The Silty Beds (Lamplugh & Walker, 1903; Lamplugh , 1922) comprises a thin interval (mainly 1 - 2 m ; maximum 3 .6 m) of grey-green, glauconite and carbonaceous-rich clays, silts and argillaceous fine-grained sands with rare thin beds of coarse- to very coarse-grained, well-sorted sands. The fine grained sediments are strongly (90- 100 % ) bio turbated (Fig. 14) and have in places suffered soft-sediment deformation. The coarse beds are 50- 1 00 mm thick , have sharp bases and flat or rippled tops, and are internally cross-laminated or plane-laminated. The unit sharply overlies a slightly undulating surface on top of the Silver Sands (Fig. 12). This undulose surface was considered by Lamplugh ( 1922) and Bentley ( 1970) to represent the preserved morphology of shoal or sand-wave crests in the underlying Silver Sands. The Silty Beds are sharply overlain by either the Transition Series or the Red Sands (Fig. 4). Interpretation
This interval represents a period of slow sedimen tation in a marine environment in which both current and wave energy were apparently too weak to cause significant erosion of the unconsolidated sands on the sea-floor. The coarser grained sand layers are interpreted as lags, resulting from reworking and winnowing of the Silver Sands (cf. Levell, 1980). The Silty Beds are interpreted to represent a phase of low energy and low sediment influx (an estuarine abandonment phase) relative to the high-energy,
14. Silty Beds, overlying the Silver Sands with a sharp, planar contact (next to trowel ) . The mottled texture in the Silty Beds is the .result of extreme bioturbation. A low-angle laminated sand bed with an erosional base (storm layer) is present in the upper part of the sequence (Bryant's Lane Quarry) .
Fig.
subtidal sand shoal and channel complexes described from the underlying deposits. The precise depositional environment of this unit is debatable. The lack of marine fauna and abundant carbonaceous material could indicate restricted marine conditions, possibly within a deeper, pro tected part of an estuary ( Lamplugh, 1922). The facies could also be interpreted as tidal flat deposits (Eyers, 1992b) , although the absence of tidal channels and the characteristic fining upward sequence capped by in situ marsh deposits (e.g. Evans, 1965) fails to support this. Alternatively, the abrupt cessation of high-energy conditions marked by the sharp base of this unit, and the presence of reworked and glauconite-rich horizons within it, is more characteristic of a sudden deepening, rather
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
than shallowing in water depth. Hence , a more offshore shallow marine environmen t is a further possibility . The Silty Beds probably represen t a relatively long time interval, which marks the end of the underlying Orange- Heteroli thic and Silver Sands depositional succession. This i n terpreta tion implies that the overlying Red Sands form a genetically separate sand body. Red Sands .
Description
The unit comprises moderately to poorly sorted, medium- to very coarse-grained sands (occasionally gravelly), which are distinguished from all older units of the Woburn Sands by their high conte n t (up to 20% bulk volume) of detri tal iron oxide in the form of rust-coloured ooliths of goeth i te and angular ir9nstone chips. It is also rich in heavy minerals ( Bentley, ( 1970) reports up to 2 . 5 % bulk volume) . I n addition, diagene tic iron oxide occurs a s a local cement around mud clasts and on certain foresets. The Red Sands erosionally truncate all earlier deposits. In the Shenley Hill area they were shown by Bentley ( 1970) to occupy E- W trending shallow scours up to 6 m deep and 100 m wide. South of this area the Silty Beds and the Silver Sands are progressively cu t out by erosion beneath the sou th ward thickening Red Sands until, south of Leighton Buzzard, the sand pits expose only this last unit (Fig. 4), which is presumed to overlie Orange and/ or Heterolithic Sands. The erosion surface at the base of the Red Sands is i n terpreted as a sequence boundary by Ruffell and Wach (in press). Three main types of cross-bedding characterize the Red Sands. Type I consists of thick (up to 5 . 5 m) sets of avalanche cross-bedding that overlie prominent erosional scours up to 3 m deep and more than 100 m wide . The overall set geome try thus resembles giant scale trough cross-bedding. The uppermost se t of the unit is overlain by a coset of successively smaller se ts with a particularly i n triguing geometry (Fig. 15). The thick set of avalanche foresets at the base dip at 25 -30° and abut sharply against a basal erosion surface locally lined with granules and pebbles. Major reactivation surfaces periodically separate bundles of foreset laminae with an average thickness of 130 mm (range 50-220 mm) . Each of
35
these tabular or wedge-shaped bundles is in turn subdivided by some times i n tersecting minor dis continuity planes that define the individual foresets. The major reactivation surfaces are convex-up, flattening toward the top of the set, where they are separated by cosets or sol i tary sets of decimetre scale cross-bedding. At the top of the sets, where the reactivation surfaces flatten out, there are some up-dip thinning sets 0.05 - 0.2 m thick of oppositely dipping cross-bedding. This geometry closely resembles, on a large scale, the ebb and flood shields described from several modern tidal environments (e.g. Klein , 1970) . Type ll is characterized by wedge-shaped cross-sets (0.3- 2 m thick) with sou th- or southwest-dipping foresets, which are superimposed on 2-4-m-thick sets of low-angle southward-dipping erosion surfaces (dips 4-8°) . Individual cross-sets taper either up or down the inclined surfaces. Small sets (less than 0.5 m thick) occasionally thicken down-dip into single large-scale ( c. 2-3 m thick) avalanche sets. Type II cross-bedding passes laterally i n to type I in both down- and up-palaeocurren t direction . Type III comprises 0. 1 -0.4-m-thick sets o f trough and tabular cross-bedding bounded by subhorizontal erosion surfaces, and forms the bulk of the Red Sands in the channelized facies of the northern area.
Additional information on the complex and varied geometry of these sedimen tary structures has been obtained recently from ground-penetrating radar studies ( Bristow, in press) . The Red Sands are extensively bioturbated (Fig. 16). The most widespread burrow type is a c. 5-mm diameter colour mottling in which pale-coloured burrow fills contrast with the darker iron-rich sands surrounding them (Fig. 16A) . This structure results from horizontal burrowing and has caused only minimal disruption of the primary stratification. Such bioturbation is apparently similar to that termed 'cryptobioturbation' by Howard & Frey ( 1975) . This structure was found by them in the G eorgia (USA) estuaries and a ttributed by them to amphipod crustaceans. The colour mottling could be due either to a slight grain-size fractionation ( the iron pellets fall mostly in the fine- to very fine-grained sand classes ( Bentley, 1970) or to some oxidation/ reduction difference caused by organic slime. The second and most distinctive burrow type is the nested inverted cone or funnel-shaped struc-
36
H. D. Johnson and B. K. Levell
Fig. 15. Large-scale (c. 3-4 m thick ) , ebb-directed (to south) , avalanche foresets and associated top set deposits.,.(A) Foreset packets are separated by major reactivation surfaces. The latter are ascribed to stronger than normal flood-currents because they are overlain by packets of oppositely dipping, wedge-shaped cross-beds. The large-scale structure is interpreted as an ebb-dominated bedform which filled an erosional hollow. (B) Close-up of central part of (a) showing oppositely-dipping (to northeast), flood-directed sets, possibly analogous to flood-shield bedforms. Locality: Pratts' Lane Quarry.
ture (Fig. 1 6 B) . The V-shaped laminae (in two dimensions) of these structures could have formed either by sediment collapse i n to the underlying horizontal tubes, which are sometimes associated with these structures, or could have formed as an escape structure by upward movement of an animal (e.g. large pelecypod or crustacean). The escape s tructure interpretation may be supported by the association of this sort of burrow with large erosion surfaces overlain by migrating bedforms. Perhaps the animals preferred the relatively slow deposition areas of channel floors but were none the less able to escape by efficient vertical burrowing when buried beneath advancing bedforms.
A third burrow type consists of horizontal 40-mm diameter subhorizontal tubes with miniscus-shaped spreiten. The size, shape and back-filling spreiten resemble the 'press structures' produced by £chino cardium cordatum ( Reineck & Singh , 1973). If these burrows are echinoid burrows, they would indicate fully marine conditions. Interpretation
The Red Sands accumulated in a high-energy marine or marginal marine environment dominated by southward flowing, but sometimes reversing, cur rents (Fig. 8) . There is no evidence of distinct
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
37
Fig. 16. Biogenic sedimentary structures in the Red Sands. (A) Typical mottled appearance of the Red Sands resulting from horizontal burrows. Note the alternation of non-bioturbated laminae and the retention of structure within the bioturbated layers. Locality: Pratt's Lane. (B) Two V-shaped burrows occurring within a large-scale cross bedded sand body at the contact between two different sediment types (coarser, massive sands above) . The lower cross-bedded sands also display the mottled texture detailed in (a) . Locality: Grovebury South.
channel-fill or shoal deposits, and the whole uni t seems to represent rather a blanke t-like field of megaripples and megarippled sand waves (cf. J . R.L. Allen, 1980) , which increased systematically in height southwards. The sedimentary s tructures closely resemble tidal sand waves found in modern subtidal environments (e.g. Berne et a!. , 199 1 ) . There i s no evidence of emergence o r s ignificant wave activity , but the b ioturbation suggests similar marine or marginal marine cond itions to the under lying units. The lack of clay drapes indicates a more or less constantly active water column .
Transition Series
Description
The Transition Series comprises a d istinctive thin (c. 1 -2 m thick) , and laterally extensive deposit at the junction between the previously described units and the overlying Gault. I t has been studied inten sively by palaeontologists because of its rich fauna (for more extensive descriptions see Lamplugh ( 1922 ) , Wright & Wright ( 1947 ) , Hancock ( 1958) , Casey ( 1961 ) and Owen ( 1972)) . Lithologically the Transition Series is laterally variable , consisting mainly of partly cemented pebbly
38
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
sands (at the base) and argillaceous, glauconitic and phosphatic fine- to coarse-grained sands and sandy clays. A distinctive and unusual limestone, the Shenley Limestone, occurs as discontinuous in situ bands, up to c. 0.6 m thick , and as reworked frag ments in the lower part of this unit. This limestone, which sharply overlies the underlying deposits, contains a unique fauna, including rich and dis tinctive brachiopods and a unique assemblage of echinoids and Crustacea. The whole Transition Series is highly fossiliferous, with abundant ammon ites, bivalves, belemnites, gastropods and oysters. There is abundant evidence of reworking and dis continuous sedimentation in the form of reworked faunas and several condensed horizons. The Tran sition Series forms a laterally extensive drape over the underlying Woburn Sands and extends laterally over Jurassic sediments (Owen, 1972) . Interpretation
The Transition Series represents a composite trans gressive , shallow-marine lag, which forms a type of abandonment deposit on top of the underlying, mainly high-energy, subtidal deposits. The rework ing of limestone beds, concretions and iron cemented sandstones ( ' Carstone'), mixing of faunal zones and condensed intervals indicate slow depo sition and strong current activity. The abundant and highly varied fauna supports a shallow marine, probably offshore, depositional environment, with the coarser grained layers representing winnowed lag deposits.
PALAEOGEOGRAPHICAL EVOLUTION
Reconstruction of the palaeogeographical evolution of the five erosionally bounded units depends not only on the process interpretations given above but also on the overall palaeogeographical setting and the stratigraphical relationships between the units. The first point to establish is the direction of the transgression . Several factors lead us to propose a northward transgression . 1 The affinities of the fauna described by Casey ( 196 1 ) from the lower part of the complex are with faunas from the southern Wealden Basin, rather than from the northern Southern North Sea Basin. 2 In tidal embayments it is common for ebb-directed sets to be preferentially preserved, either because ebb flows are often enhanced by freshwater run-off
or because these flows reach maximum velocities at times of lower water, and are thus preferentially preserved in the topographically lower parts of the deposit. The predominance of southwestward directed palaeocurrents leads to the proposal of open sea in the southwest. 3 The increase in set size southwards in the Red Sands (and possibly in the Silver Sands) , coupled with a southward increase in the thickness of the Red Sands, could be explained by greater water depth in the south. Water depth is, of course , of especial importance in the preservation of sets up to 5 . 5 m thick. In modern tidal basins (e.g. estuaries and embayments) the largest bedforms frequently occur in the deeper areas (see Fig. 17). 4 The geometry of the deposit is one of southward dipping facies units (Fig. 4) . This is most readily explained by a northward transgression . Two factors lead us to suggest that the Red Sands should be considered separately from the older sub divisions of the Woburn Sands. 1 They rest erosively on the Silty Beds, which appears to be a slowly deposited unit representing the cessation of sand supply to the underlying Silver Sands shoal system. 2 Their distinctive petrography, rich in detrital iron oxide fragments with goethite ooliths, suggests a change in the source material. The most likely possibility is the erosion of presently unexposed iron-rich intervals derived from further updip to the north , which may include the iron-stained Orange Sands, the carstones of the Silver Sands or some other, older or laterally equivalent formation(s) (e.g. the early Cretaceous Carstone of the Norfolk area, Casey & Gallois, 1 973). The only reported occurrence of similar goethite ooliths is from an early Cretaceous oolith-rich sand unit further north (Deepdale Pit), which may be equivalent to the Silver Sands (Eyers, 1992a) . The deposition of the Woburn Sands began with the partly erosional and partly tectonic creation of a trough trending NE-SW through the Bedfordshire area. The basal deposits are gravels and phosphates with rolled, derived faunas and abundant wood material, suggesting transgressive coastal erosion (whether open-marine or on the margins of a brackish embayment is unknown). The overlying Orange and Heterolithic Sands represent subtidal channel and shoal deposits, respectively. The relationship between these two units could be either lateral interfingering or a sharp erosional contact (Fig. 17). l n the first case
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
39
�� Tidal channel fills I . I High-energy tidal shoals C:=J Moderate-energy tidal shoals
}
}
Orange Sands Heterolithic Sands
b) Model 1
� "'A :, ::-:=--. ·:-::::_� -:-::=· ::- :: -_-.-_. -.::-:.: ::���-::-.� �;:.;_ -::-::-.·-. .�- �=._ � :s_ �:::. _.:.:.:::= � �;=-; ;�;� CHANNEL
. __ .•.•.. •
::::
HIGH ENERGY CHANNE HIGH ENERGY L SHOAL SHO L - -. . . ::::::::::-::=·. .� : - .:0 - _ - =-== = . '\ . ;- _
MODERATE ENERGY SHOAL
== -==;::;===;;:::_:::: ----== _ :: :; :
B
0
?
c) Model 2
A
5m B
17. (a) Distribution of the Orange and Heterolithic Sands (Lower Woburn Sands or Brown Sands) below the Silver Sands erosion surface, and (b) two possible models depicting possible lateral relationships (model 1 preferred) .
Fig.
40
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
(Fig. 17b) , the Heterolithic Sands would be situated towards the centre of the estuary or embayment, with the Orange Sands being a marginal , flood dominated , channel complex. Such a palaeo geography with marginal channels hugging the edges of an embayment or estuary would be consistent with the generally rotary circulation models for estuaries, where tidal currents are deflected by Coriolis force to the margins (e.g. Schubel , 197 1 ) . Nevertheless, a problem remains with this inter pretation in that it is difficult to understand why the Heterolithic Sands shoal complex accreted steadily to a thickness of 25 m , without being dissected by a migrating channel system. However, the similarity between the Heterolithic and Orange Sands leads us to infer a laterally interfingering relationship (Fig. 17b). Two features place these two units in the relatively landward and protected parts of the embayment or estuary, rather than on the open shelf. 1 The clear presence of distinct channel and shoal complexes is characteristic of the estuary proper, rather than the seaward extensions. Furthermore the flood dominance of the Orange Sands channels indicates mutually evasive ebb and flood channels. 2 The well-developed clay drapes indicate periods of slack water in a generally current-dominated regime. Whether these are diurnal drapes or not, periods of tidal slack water are more likely to occur in systems with rectilinear tides. Such tides are more common in the inner and more restricted parts of estuaries, whereas in estuary mouths and on the open shelf, tides tend to be rotary (Terwindt, 1973). The major erosion surface at the base of the Silver Sands indicates a shift in depositional setting, and is explained most readily by the lateral shift of a major, wide, estuary mouth channel system. The overlying Silver Sands, with the lack of a distinct channel-fill facies and the large-scale bedform complexes up to 15 m high , suggest, in the context of a continuing northward transgression, deposition in estuary mouth subtidal shoals. Modern analogues might be the outer reaches of Chesapeake Bay ( Ludwick 1970, 1974; Colman eta/. , 1988), or Delaware Bay ( Knebel et al . , 1988) , or the seaward portions of ebb-tidal deltas (Greer, 1975 ; Hayes, 1975 ) . A s mentioned above , the Silty Beds represent the cessation of sand supply to the Silver Sands shoal, followed by a period of slow deposition. Reasons for the abandonment of this shoal could be autocyclic (e.g. a shift in the shoal pattern related to the movement of main tidal channels) or allocyclic (e.g.
sea-level rise leading to the area becoming an open marine shelf rather than an estuary mouth. However, alternative interpretations consider this interval to represent tidal flat deposits and hence a relative shallowing of sea-level of the facies succession has been proposed (Eyers, 1992b) . In gross facies terms (e.g. the style of cross bedding, grain size and lack of clay drapes) the Red Sands closely resemble the Silver Sands. However, there is a major difference in their petrography. The Red Sands could, therefore , represent a similar outer estuarine shoal complex but formed at a time when the up-dip tidal channels were eroding different material. They would therefore represent the shift of tidal channels to debouch again in the Leighton Buzzard Area. An alternative and more dramatic interpretation would relate the Red Sands to the final breaching of the London-Brabant land mass and thus to continued coastal erosion at the margin of the transgressing embayment. As discussed above, the erosion surface at the base of the Red Sands has been interpreted as evidence for a sea-level low stand (sequence boundary) punctuating the overall late Aptian transgression. This explanation would presumably equate the depositional settings of the Silver Sands and Red Sands, with the Silty Beds representing either the most distal (offshore) or most proximal (tidal flat) depositional settings. On the grounds of the facies differences we have described , and of simplicity, we prefer to view the succession as one of continued overall transgression and attribute the baSal erosion surface of the Red Sands to changes in tidal dynamics, possibly associ ated with the breaching of the Lori don - Brabant land mass. The Transition Series marks the final abandon ment of the high-energy, tide-dominated sanely shoal complexes. Sedimentation was slow, discontinuous and interspersed with periods of physical reworking. Subsequent basin deepening resulted in the wide spread deposition of shallow-marine/shelf muds (the Gault) .
DEPOSITIONAL MODEL FOR A TRANSGRESSI V E ESTUARINE - EMBAYMENT SYSTEM
A generalized depositional model can be constructed for a transgressive estuarine -embayment system based on observations from both the Woburn Sands and from known facies and bedform distributions
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
within modern meso- and macrotidal estuaries and embayments (Fig. 18). This model also can be compared with estuarine facies models developed mainly from a synthesis of modern environments and from conceptual considerations (Dalrymple et al., 1 99 1 ) . The essential elements o f the inner estuarine environment are as follows. 1 Discrete , mutually evasive, ebb and flood tidal channels and interchannel tidal shoals. 2 Tidal channel sands will be relatively coarse-grained and characterized by large-scale cross-bedding. 3 Tidal shoals will consist of more heterolithic sands, generally with smaller scale structures, stronger bio turbation and more frequent and laterally extensive clay layers than the higher energy channel-fill deposits.
b)
41
4
Reservoir quality and heterogeneity will be strongly influenced by the contrast between channel and shoal deposits. In general, the channel fills may be expected to form discrete zones of higher per meability (Fig. 18b), whereas the tidal shoals will comprise variable but generally lower quality and more heterogeneous reservoirs ( c.f. Orange and Heterolithic Sands). The essential features of the outer estuarine environ ment are as follows. 1 Minor lithological differentiation between tidal channel and shoal deposits. 2 Well-sorted sands with fewer clay intercalations and less bioturbation compared with the inner estuarine sands. 3 Large-scale cross-bedding, partly reflecting large estuary mouth bars and sand waves, and also
Tidal shoals
'
3
a)
Basic Characteristics
Woburn S. Equiv.
Fossiliferous clays
Gault Clay
Reworked, fossiliferous, partly cemented sands
TRANSGRESSIVE LAG
Transition Series
Well-sorted sands. Large-scale, complex cross-bedding. Ebb-dominated palaeocurrent directions. Mainly minor bioturbuation.
OUTER ESTUARINE/ EMBAYMENT TIDAL SHOALS
Silver Sands and Red Sands
Pre-transgressive deposits
� l
Upper Jurassic Clays
18. A model for a transgressive estuarine- embayment depositional system (see Fig. 3 for legend). (a) Idealized vertical section through a transgressive estuarine-embayment complex based on the Woburn Sands. (b) Block diagram illustrating some of the essential differences in sand body characteristics between the inner estuarine/embaymer.t and outer estuarine/embayment environments. (c) Idealized section through a transgressive estuarine- embayment indicating the potential stratigraphic trap geometry.
Fig.
H. D. Johnson and B.K. Levell
42
the infilling 0f deep ebb-dominated channels and interbar troughs. 4 Possibly an overall seaward i ncrease in the size of cross-bedding in response to deeper-water conditions. 5 Higher quality and more homogeneous reservoir characteristics compared with the inner estuarine sands as a result of both stronger tidal currents and increased wave activity. Shale layers are likely to be very thin and discontinuous, or absent. The vertical sequence through this type of trans gressive sand complex would tend to have lower reservoir quality sands in the lower part and higher reservoir quality sands towards the top (Fig. 1 8a) . The transgressive nature of the sequence would lead ultimately to the blanketing of the overall lenticular sand-body complex by shelf muds and could thereby, form a stratigraphical trap (Fig. 1 8c) .
DISCU S S ION
The difficulty of postulating a generalized facies model for this type of succession is that these deposits are influenced by a particularly wide range of physical processes, both autocyclic and allocyclic; they may receive sediment supplied from different sources (landward and/or seaward; Schubel, 197 1 ) and their preservation potential i s linked closely to the rate and sense of relative sea-level fluctuations. These variables form the basis of Dalrymple et al. 's ( 199 1 ) classification of estuarine facies, in which they argue that these deposits are diagnostic of transgressive conditions. In this scheme the Woburn Sands would be classified as a tide-dominated estuary in which fluvial processes were negligible . Compar able modern environments in terms of physical processes, facies and sedimentary structures would include the southwest Netherlands area (e.g. Haringvliet and Oosterschelde Estuaries) (Oomkens & Terwindt, 1960; Terwindt, 1973; van den Berg et al. , 1980; Yang & Nio, 1989 ) , Severn Estuary/ Bristol Channel area, (Hamilton, 1979; Harris & Collins, 1985 ; J . R . L. Allen, 1 990) , Ossabaw Sound (Greer, 1975 ) , Jade Estuary/German B ight ( Reineck, 1963; Reineck & Singh, 1973) and Broad Sound, Australia (Cook & Mayo, 1977). The stratigraphical relationships recorded in the Woburn Sands and summarized in the depositonal model allows comparison with other stratigraphical models associated with tide-dominated estuaries, incised valleys and transgressive systems tracts , and
allows consideration of their sequence stratigraphical implications (e.g. van Wagoner et at. , 1990) . The major third-order lowstand and maximum flooding events would be recorded respectively by the basal lag deposit of the Woburn Sands and by the condensed horizons in the Lower Gault Clay. We have seen no direct (i.e. preserved) evidence of fluvial incision at the base of the Woburn Sands, which comprises a typical shallow-marine lag deposit. The non-preservation of predicted lowstand fluvial deposits among shallow marine sandstones successions is commonly argued to be the result of either (i) minor lowstand fluvial deposition, due to a predominance of fluvial bypassing during incision, and/or (ii) extensive shallow marine reworking during subsequent relative sea-level rise. In many cases this combination results in the apparent merging of lowstand and initial marine flooding sur faces, and removal of all lowstand fluvial deposits (e.g. Bergman & Walker, 1987; Plint & Walker, 1987; Plint & Norris, 1 99 1 ; Thorne & Swift, 199 1 ; Walker & Bergman, 1992). The greatest amount of such reworking is likely to occur in tide-dominated settings, particularly in confined areas such as estuaries or embayments, due to high-energy tidal currents and their ability to incise deeply into the substrate. Holocene incised valleys on the inner continental shelf of southeastern USA , for example, show a hierarchy of erosional events that reflect not only earlier fluvial incision but later deep tidal scour (c. 15 -30 m ) , particularly at the confluence of tidal streams, in tidal channels associated with tidal flats, in tidal inlets and in channels associated with ebb tidal delta shoals (Oertel et a/. , 199 1 ) . Preservation potential o f transgressive estuarine successions is relatively high due to their relatively protected position within palaeovalleys (Swift et a/. , 1980; Demarest & Kraft , 1987). The degree of preservation is related most closely to the depth of incision of the basal erosion surface , or sequence bounding fluvial incision, plus any additional down·· cutting by tidal scour associated with the initial flooding surface and , to a lesser extent, the degree of erosion associated with the ravinement surface (Dalrymple, 1992). The latter is equivalent to the ravinement/shoreface erosion surface of wave dominated shorelines , but in tide-dominated systems it is characterized by tidal current erosion (e.g. the bedload parting zones of tidal seas; Stride, 1982 ) . Complete preservation of an idealized tide dominated transgressive stratigraphy, which seems to be extremely rare, would predict tidal shelf sand
Transgressive estuarine sand complex
deposits (e.g. tidal sand ridges and tidal sheet sands with sand waves and associated deposits; Stride, 1982; Nummedal & Swift, 1987; Dalrymple, 1992) overlying the ravinement surface . All the main sand bodies in the Woburn Sands appear to occur below the transgressive marine erosion surface and hence are assigned to the estuarine part of the sequence. Shelf sand wave deposits may occur further to the south and southeast within the Folkestone Beds (Narayan, 1 97 1 ; J . R. L . Allen, 1 982; Bridges, 1982). The main difference between tidal shelf sands and tidal estuarine sands is that the latter will be domi nated by complex interfingering of tidal-channel, tidal-shoal and, in places, tidal-flat deposits (cf. Maguregui & Tyler, 1 99 1 ) . Thus in the Woburn Sands, concave-upward erosion surfaces and rela tively rapid lateral thickness changes are common. In more basinward settings individual sand bodies are likely to have tabular geometries, with individual sand and shale layers having much higher continuity (cf. Surlyk and Noe-Nygaard, 1 99 1 ) . Distinguishing between these different types of shallow-marine sand body is particularly important in evaluating the nature of such deposits in the subsurface because of their different geometries and lateral extent (e.g. Banerjee, 199 1 ; Brownridge & Moslow, 199 1 ; Jenette et a!. , 1992).
ACKNOW L E DGEMENTS
We would like to extend our sincerest thanks to Harold Reading for giving us our initial introduction to the Woburn Sands and for making us aware of its sedimentological significance. The basis for this work, its methodology and evaluation stems directly from the lessons learnt by the authors under Harold's previous supervision. We are extremely grateful for this and for his ongoing interest and influence in our work. The authors would also like to thank the Konin klijke/Shell Exploratie and Produktie Laboratorium, Riswijk, The Netherlands, for supporting both the project and its publication. We also acknowledge Shell Research B . V. and Shell Internationale Pet roleum Maatschappij B . V . for their permission to publish this paper. We are also indebted to Guy Plint for his patience and encouragement during the preparation of this paper. The assistance and openness of the two referees, Jill Eyers and Alistair Ruffell , is also gratefully acknowledged. Finally, Ian Glenister is thanked for redrafting the figures.
43 REFERENCES
J . R . L . ( 1 980) Sand waves: a model of origin and internal structures. Sediment. Geol. , 26, 281 - 328. ALLEN, J . R . L . ( 1 982) Mud drapes in sand wave deposits: physical model with application to the Folkestone Beds (Early Cretaceous, southeast England ) . Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A, 306, 291 -345 . ALLEN, J . R. L . ( 1990) The Severn Estuary in southwest Britain: its retreat under marine transgression, and fine sediment regime. Sediment. Geol. , 66, 13-28. ALLEN, P . ( 1981 ) Wealden research - ways ahead. Proc. Geol. Assoc. , 100, 529-564. BANERJEE, I. ( 1991 ) Tidal sand sheets of the Late Albian Joli Fou-Kiowa-Skull Creek marine transgression, Western Interior Seaway of North America. In: Clastic Tidal Sedimentology (Eds Smith, D .G . , Reinson, G . E . , Zaitlin, B .A . & Rahmani, R . A . ) . Can. Soc. petrol. Geol. , Calgary, Memoir 16, 335-347. BENTLEY, A . ( 1 970) Sedimentation studies in the Lower Greensand; a report on the sedimentology of the Aptian and lower Albian strata near Leighton Buzzard, Bedfordshire. Unpublished BSc thesis, University of Oxford, 137 pp. BERGMAN, K.M. & WA LKER , R.G. ( 1987) The importance of sea-level fluctuations in the formation of linear con glomerate bodies; Carrot Creek Member of Cardium Formation, Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, Alberta, Canada. J. sediment. Petrol. , 57, 651 - 665 . BERNE , S . , DuRAND, J. & W EB ER , 0. ( 1991) Architecture of modern subtidal dunes (sand waves ) , Bay of Bourgneuf, France. I n : The Three-Dimensional Facies Architecture of Terrigenous Clastic Sediments and its Implication for Hydrocarbon Discovery and Recovery (Eds Miall, A . D . & Tyler, N . ) . Soc. econ. Paleontol. Mineral. , Concepts Sediment. Paleont . , Tulsa, 3 , 245 -260. BRIDGES, P . H . ( 1982) Ancient offshore tidal deposits. I n : Offshore Tidal Sands: Processes and Deposits (Ed. Stride, A . H . ) , pp. 172- 192. Chapman & Hall , London. BRJSTOW, C . R . ( 1 963) The stratigraphy and structure of the Upper Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous Rocks in the area between Aylesbury (Bucks) and Leighton Buzzard (Beds) , Unpublished PhD thesis, University of London. BRISTOW, C . S . ( 1995) Internal geometry of ancient tidal bedforms revealed using ground-penetrating radar. In: Tidal Signatures in Modern and Ancient Sediments. (Eds Fleiruning, B .W. & Bartholoma). Spec. Pubis. int. Assoc. Sediment. , No. 24. Blackwell Science, Oxford (in press) . BROWNRIDGE, S . & MOSLOW, T.F. ( 1991 ) Tidal estuary and marine facies of the Glauconitic Member, Drayton Valley, central Alberta. I n : Clastic Tidal Sedimentology (Eds Smith, D . G . , Reinson , G . E . , Zaitlin, B .A . & Rahmani, R . A . ) . Can. Soc. petrol. Geol . , Calgary, Memoir 16, 107- 122. BucK, S. ( 1985) Sand-flow cross strata in tidal sands of the Lower Greensand (early Cretaceous ) , southern England. J. sediment. Petrol. , 55, 895-906. BucK, S . ( 1987) Facies and sedimentary structures in the Folkestone Beds (Lower Greensand, Early Cretaceous) and equi valent strata in southern England. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Reading. CAMPBELL, C.V. ( 1971) Depositional model - Upper ALLEN ,
44
H. D. Johnson and B. K. Levell
Cretaceous Gallup beach shoreline, Ship Rock area, northwestern New Mexico. J. sediment. Petrol. , 41, 395-409. CASEY, R. ( 1961 ) The stratigraphical palaeontology of the Lower Greensand. Palaeontology, 3, 486-62 1 . CASEY, R . & GALLOIS, R.W. ( 1973) The Sandringham Sands of Norfolk. Proc. Yorks. geol. Soc. , 40, 1 -22. COLMAN , S . M . , BERQUIST, C . R . , J R . & HOBBS, C.H. , I I I ( 1988) Structure, age and origin o f the bay-mouth shoal deposits, Chesapeake Bay , Virginia. Mar. Geol. , 83, 95 - 1 13 . CooK, P . J . & MAYO, W . ( 1977) Sedimentology and Holocene history of a tropical estuary (Broad Sound, Queensland) . Aust. Bur. Miner. Resow·. , Geol. Geophys. Bull. , 170, 206 pp. DALRYMPLE, R.W. ( 1992) Tidal depositional systems. In: Facies Models: Response to Sea Level Change (Eds Walker, R.G. & James, N . P . ) , pp. 195 - 218. Geological Association of Canada, St Johns. DALRYMPLE, R.W. , ZAITLIN , B . A . & B OYD , R . ( 1991 ) Estuarine facies models: conceptual basis and strati graphic implications. J. sediment. Petrol. , 62, 1 130- 1 146. DEMAREST, J .M. , II & KRAFT, J . C. ( 1 987) Stratigraphic record of Quaternary sea levels: implications for more ancient strata. In: Sea-Level Fluctuation and Coastal Evolution (Eds Nummedal, D . , Pilkey, O . H . & Howard , J . D . ) . Spec. Pub!. Soc. econ. Paleont. Miner . , Tulsa, N o . 4 1 , 223-229. DE RAAF, J . F . M . & BoERSMA, J . R . ( 197 1 ) Tidal deposits and their sedimentary structures (seven examples from Western Europe) . Geol. Mijnbouw, 50, 479 - 50 1 . EvANS, G. ( 1 965) Intertidal flat sediments and their environments of deposition in the Wash. Q. J. geol. Soc. London, 121, 209-245. Exu M , F. A. & HARMS, J .C. ( 1 968) Comparison of marine bar with valley-fill stratigraphic traps, western Nebraska . Bull. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geol. , 52, 1 85 1 - 1868. EYERS, J. ( 199 1 ) The influence of tectonics on early Cretaceous sedimentation in Beclfordshire, England. J. geol. Soc. London , 148, 405 -414. EYERS, J . ( 1 992a) Lithostratigraphy of the Lower Greensand and Gault Clay (Lower Cretaceous) of the Bedfordshire Province, England. Unpublished PhD thesis, Open University. EYERS, J. ( 1992b) Sedimentology and palaeoenvironment of the Shenley Limestone (Albian, Lower Cretaceous): an unusual shallow-water carbonate. Proc. Geol. Assoc. , 103, 293-302. GREER, S . A . ( 1975) Estuaries of the Georgia coast USA: III. Sandbody geometry and sedimentary facies at the estuary/marine transition zone, Ossabaw Sound Georgia; a stratigraphic model. Senckenbergiana Mar. , 7, 105 - 135 . HAMILTON, D. ( 1979) The high-energy, sand and mud regime of the severn estuary, S . W . Britain. In: Tidal Power and Estuary Management (Eds Severn, R .T. , Dineley, D . L . & Hawker, L . E . ) , pp. 162- 1 72. Trans atlantic Arts Incorporated, Albuquerque, Colston Paper 30. HANCOCK, J . M . ( 1 958) The Lower Cretaceous near Leighton Buzzard. I n : The London Region Geologists Association Guide, No. 30, pp . 36-40. HAQ, B . - U . , HARDENBOL, J. & VAIL, P . R. ( 1987) Chron-
ology of fluctuating sea-levels since the Triassic (250 million years ago to the present) . Science, 235, 1 156- 1 167. HARRIS, P.T. & COLLINS, M . B . ( 1985) Bedform distribution and sediment transport paths in the Bristol Channel and Severn Estuary. Mar. Geol. , 62, 153- 166. HAYES, M .O. ( 1 975) Forms of sand accumulation in estuaries. I n : Estuarine Research , Vol . II, Geology & Engineering (eel . Cronin, L . E . ) , pp. 3 -22. Academic Press, London. HowARD, J . D . & FREY, R.W. ( 1 975) Regional animal sediment characteristics of Georgia estuaries. Senckenbergiana Mar. , 7, 33- 103. JENElTE, D .C. , JONES, C.R. , VAN WAGONER, J .C. & LARSEN , J . E . ( 1992) High resolution sequence strati graphy of the Upper Cretaceous Tocito Sandstone: the relationship between incised valleys and hydrocarbon accumulation, San Juan Basin, New Mexico. I n : Sequence Stratigraphy Applications to Shelf Sandstone Reservoirs: Outcrop to Subswface Examples (Eels van Wagoner, J.C. , Jones, C.R . , Taylor, D . R . , Nummedal, D . , Jenette, D .C. & Riley, G.W. ) . American Associ ation of Petroleum Geologists Field Conference, September 199 1 . JOHNSON , H . D . & BALDWIN , C.T. ( 1986) Shallow silici clastic seas. In: Sedimentary Environments and Facies (Ed. Reading, H . G . ) , pp. 229-282. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford . JoHNSON, H . D . & LEVELL, B . K . ( 1 980) Sedimentology of a Lower Cretaceous subtidal sand complex, Woburn Sands, southern England. Bull. Am. Assoc. petrol. Geol. , 64, 728-729. KIRKALDY, J .F. ( 1939) The history of the Lower Cretaceous period in England. Proc. Geol. Assoc. , 50, 379-413. KLEI N , G . DE VRIES ( 1970) Depositional and dispersal dynamics of intertidal sand bodies. J. sediment. Petrol. , 40, 1 095 - 1 127 . KNEBEL, H . J . , FLETCHER, C . H. , III & KRAFr, J . C . ( 1 988) Late Wisconsinan - Holocene paleogeography of Dela ware Bay: a large coastal plain estuary. Mar. Geol. , 83, 1 15- 133. LAMPLUGH, G.W. ( 1922) On the j unction of Gault and Lower Greensand near Leighton B uzzard (Beclfordshire) . Q. J. geol. Soc. London, 78, 1 -80. LAMPLUG H , G.W. & WALKER, J.F. ( 1903) On a fossiliferous band at the top of the Lower Greensand near Leighton Buzzard. Q. J. geol. Soc. London , 59, 234-265 . LEVELL, B . K. ( 1 980) Evidence for currents associated with waves in Late Precambrian shelf deposits from Finnmark, North Norway. Sedimentology, 27, 153- 166. LuDWICK, J .C. ( 1 970) Sand waves and tidal channels in the entrance to Chesapeake Bay, Virginia. Va. J. Sci. , 21 ' 178- 184. LUDWICK, J .C. ( 1 974) Tidal currents and zig-zag sand shoals in a wide estuary entrance. Geo/. Soc. Am. Bull. , 85, 717-726. MAGUEREGUI, J . & TYLER, N. ( 1991 ) Evolution of Middle Eocene tide-dominated deltaic sandstones, Lagunillas field, Maracaibo Basin, Western Venezuala. In: The Three-Dimensional Facies Architecture of Terrigenous Clastic Sediments and Its Implication for Hydrocarbon Discovery and Recovery (Eels Miall, A . D . & Tyler, N . ) .
Transgressive estuarine sand complex Soc. econ. Paleontol Mineral . , Concepts Sediment. Paleont., Tulsa, 3 , 233-244. McCuBBIN, D . G . ( 1 969) Cretaceous strike-valley sandstone reservoirs, Northwestern New Mexico. Bull. Am. Assoc. petrol. Ceo!. , 53, 2 1 14-2140. NARAYA N , J. ( 197 1 ) Sedimentary structures in the Lower Greensand of the Weald, England, and Bas-Boulonnais, France . Sediment. Geol. , 6, 73 - 109. N10, S.-D. & YANG, C .-S. ( 1991 ) Diagnostic attributes of clastic tidal deposits: a review. I n : Clastic Tidal Sedimentology (Eds Smith, D . G . , Reinson, G . E . , Zaitlin, B . A . and Rahmani , R . A . ) . Can . Soc. petro l . Geo l . , Calgary, Memoir 16, 3-28. NuMMEDAL, D . & SwiFr, D .J.P. ( 1987) Transgressive stratigraphy at sequence-bounding unconformities: some principles derived from Holocene and Creataceous examples. In: Sea-Level Fluctuation and Coastal Evol ution (Eds Nummedal, D . , Pilkey, O . H . & Howard, J . D . ) . Spec. Pub!. Soc. econ. Paleont. Mineral, Tulsa, 4 1 , 241 - 260. OERTEL, G . F . , HENRY, V . J . & FOYLE, A . M . ( 1 99 1 ) Impli cations of tide-dominated lagoonal processes on the preservation of buried channels on a sediment-starved continental shelf. In: Shelf Sand and Sandstone Bodies: Geometry, Facies and Sequence Stratigraphy (Eds Swift, D . J . P . , Oertel, G.F. , Tillman, R . W . & Thorne, J . A . ) . Spec. Pubis i n t . Assoc. Sediment., No. 1 4 , 379-393. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford . OoMKENS, E . & TERWINDT, J . H . J . ( 1960) Inshore estuarine sediments in the Haringvliet, Netherlands. Ceo/. Mijnbouw, 39, 701 -710. OwEN , H.G. ( 1 972) The Gault and its junction with the Woburn sands in the Leighton Buzzard Area, Bedfordshire and Buckinghamshire. ?roc. Geol. Assoc. , 83, 287-312. PuNT, A.G. & WALKER, R . G . ( 1 987) Morphology and origin of an erosion surface cut into the Bad Heart Formation during major sea-level change, Santonian of West-Central Alberta, Canada. J. sedim. Petrol. , 57, 639-650. PuNT, A . G . & NORRIS, B . ( 1 99 1 ) Anatomy of a ramp margin sequence: facies successions, palaeogeography, and sediment dispersal patterns in the Muskiki and Marshybank formations, Alberta Foreland Basin. Bull. Can. Pet. Geol. , 39, 18-42. REINECK, H . E . ( 1963) Seclimentgefuge in Bereich cler Sucllichen Norclsee. Abh. Senckenb. Natwforsch. Ges, 505, 1 - 138. REINECK, H . E . & SING H , I . B . ( 1973) Depositional Sedi mentary Environments with Reference to Terrigenous Clastics. Springer-Verlag, New York, 431 pp. RuFFELL, A . H . & WACH, G . D . ( 199 1 ) Sequence strati graphic analysis of the Aptian- Albian Lower Greensand in southern England. Mar. Petrol. Ceo/. , 8, 341 -353 . RuFFELL, A . H . & WACH, G . D . (in press) Comparison of depositional sequences in the arenaceous beds of the Aptian-Albian boundary (Cretaceous) in southern and eastern England. In: The Mesozoic and Cenozoic Sequence Stratigraphy of European Basins (Eels Graciansky, P.C. & Jacquin, T . ) . Soc. econ . Paleont. Mineral. Tulsa. ScHAFER, W. ( 1972) Ecology and Palaeoecology of Marine Environments , p. 568. Oliver & Boyd, Edinburgh, (Also:
45
Aktua-palaeontologie nach Studien in der Nordsee, p. 666. W. Kramer, Frankfurt. ) . ScHUBEL, J . R . ( 1971 ) Sources o f sediments to estuaries. In: The Estuarine Environment, Estuaries and Estuarine Sedimentation (Eel. Schubel, J . R . ) , pp . V, 1 - 19. American Geological Institute, Washington. SCHWARZACHER, W. ( 1953) Cross-bedding and grain size in the Lower Cretaceous sands of E. Anglia. Geol. Mag. , 90, 322-330. SHEPHARD-THORN , E . R . , HARRIS, P . M . , HIGHLEY, D . E . & THORNTON, M . H . ( 1 986) An Outline Study of the Lower Greensand of Parts of South-east England. Report for the Department of the Environment, British Geological Survey, Keyworth. SPEARING, D.R. ( 1975) Shannon Sandstone, Wyoming. In: Depositonal Environments as Interpreted from Primary Sedimentary Structures and Stratification Sequences. Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Short Course No. 2, pp. 104- 1 14. STRIDE, A . H . ( 1982) Offshore Tidal Sands: Process and Deposits. Chapman & Hall, London, 213 pp. SuRLYK, F. & NoE-NYGAARD, N . ( 1991 ) Sand bank and clune facies architecture of a wide intracratonic seaway: Late Jurassic- Early Cretaceous Raukelv Formation, Jameson Land, East Greenland. I n : The Three Dimensional Facies Architecture of Terrigenous Clastic Sediments and Its Implication for Hydrocarbon Discovery and Recove1y (Eels Miall, A . D . & Tyler, N . ) . Soc. econ. Paleontol. Mineral . , Concepts Sediment. Paleont . , Tulsa, 3 , 261 - 276. SwiFT, D . J . P . & THOR N E , J .A . ( 1 99 1 ) Sedimentation on continental margins, 1: a general model for shelf sedimentation. I n : Shelf Sand and Sandstone Bodies: Geometry, Facies and Sequence Stratigraphy (Eels Swift, D . J . P . , Oertel, G.F. , Tillman, R.W. & Thorne, J . A . ) . Spec. Pubis i n t . Assoc. Sediment . , No . 1 4 , p p . 3 - 3 1 . Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. SWIFT, D . J . P . , MOIR, R . & FREELAN D , G . L. ( 1980) Quaternary rivers on the New Jersey shelf: relation of seafloor to buried valleys. Geology, 8, 276-280. TERWINDT, J . H . J . ( 1 973) Sand movement in the in- and offshore tidal area of the southwestern part of The Netherlands. Geol. Mag. , 52, 69-77. THORNE, J . A . & Swwr, D . J . P. ( 1991) Sedimentation on continental margins, VI: a regime model for depositional sequences, their component systems tracts, and bounding surfaces. I n : ShelfSand and Sandstone Bodies: Geometry, Facies and Sequence Stratigraphy (Eds Swift, D . J . P . , Oertel , G . F . , Tillman, R . W . & Thorne, J . A . ) . Spec Pubis int. Assoc. Seclimento l . , No. 14, pp. 189-255. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford. VAN DEN BERG, J . M . , GoESTEN , M . J . B . G . & S M U LDERS, F. ( 1980) Dynamics and sequential analysis of a mesoticlal shoal and intershoal channel complex in the eastern Scheidt (southwestern Netherlands). Sedimem. Geol. , 26, 263 -279. VAN WAGONER, J .C . , MITC H U M , R . M . , CAMPIO N , K . M . & RAHMA N IAN , V . D. ( 1 990) Siliciclastic Sequence Stra tigraphy in Well Logs, Cores, and Outcrops: Concepts for High-resolution Correlation of Time and Facies. American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, Methods in Exploration, 7, 55 pp. ViSSER, M . J . ( 1 980) Neap-spring cycles reflected in
46
H. D. Johnson and B. K. Levell
Holocene subtidal large-scale bedform deposits: a preliminary note. Geology, 8, 543-546. WALKER, R.G. ( 1 984) Shelf and shallow marine sands. I n : Facies Models ( E d . Walker, R . G . ) . Geosci. Can . , Reprint Ser. 1 , 1 4 1 - 170. WALKER, R.G. & BERGMAN , K .M. ( 1992) Late Cretaceous clastics: cores and outcrops. In: Field Trip Guidebook: Trip No. 6. Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists/ American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Calgary, 77 pp. WALKER, R . G . & P uNT, A . G . ( 1992) Wave- and storm dominated shallow marine systems. In: Facies Models: Response to Sea Level Change (Ed. Walker, R.G. & James, N . P . ) , pp. 2 19-238. Geological Association of Canada, St Johns. WoNHAM, J . P . ( 1993) Sedimentology and sequence stra tigraphy of tidal sandstone bodies: implications for reservoir characterisation. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Liverpool.
C.W. & WRIGHT, E . ( 1947) The stratigraphy of the Albian Beds at Leighton Buzzard. Geol. Mag. , 84, 1 6 1 - 168. WvArr, R.J . , LAKE, R . D . , MoORLOCK, B . S . P . & SHEPHARD THOR N , E . R . ( 1986) The Leighton Buzzard Area: Geo logical Report on 1: I 0 000 Sheets SP82NE, Southeast; SP92NW, Southwest; SP93NW, Northeast, Southwest, Southeast. British Geological Survey, Keyworth . YANG, C.-S. & N i o , S.-D. ( 1989) An ebb-tide delta depo sitional model - a comparison between the modern Eastern Schelde tidal basin (southwest Netherlands) and the Lower Eocene Roda Sandstone in the southern Pyrenees (Spain ) . Sediment. Geol. , 64, 175- 196. ZIEGLER, P . A . ( 1 988) Evolution of the Arctic- North Atlantic and the Western Tethys. Mem . Am. Assoc. petrol. Geo l . , 43, 198 pp. ZIEGLER, P.A. ( 1990) Geological Atlas of Western and Central Europe. Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschaappij B . V . , The Hague, 239 pp.
WRJGHT,
Spec. Pubis int. Ass. Sediment. (1995) 22, 47-74
An incised valley in the Cardium Formation at Ricinus, Alberta: reinterpretation as an estuary fill R O G ER G . W A L K E R Department of Geology, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario L8S 4Ml, Canada
ABSTRACT
The Ricinus incised valley (Turonian-Coniacian Cardium Formation) is at least 50 km long, 10 km wide and up to about 30 m deep. It trends NW-SE, parallel to tectonic trends and shoreline trends in the Cardium Formation. I t cuts into shallow-marine mudstones and sandstones (Raven River Allomember of the Cardium), and is truncated by a transgressive surface of erosion (E5). The valley fill forms a small oil reservoir in the subsurface, but the field is disrupted by thrust faults, and the western margin is poorly constrained because of thrusting and Jack of wells. The valley fill consists of interbedded sandstones and mudstones, with both brackish and fully marine trace fossil assemblages. Some of the sandstones are structureless, with individual beds apparently over 4 m in thickness; others are parallel-laminated with beds up to 3 m thick. Cross-bedding in sets thicker than 5 em is extremely rare. The mudstones contain some thin silty and sandy laminations, but are commonly extensively bioturbated with a fully marine trace fauna (robust Helminthopsis, Zoophycos, Planolites, Anconichnus, Skolithos, Ophiomorpha, Thalassinoides, Teichichnus, Asterosoma, Terebellina and Rosselia). The mudstones can be traced as a sheet about 4 m thick along the entire length of the valley; they appear to pinch out against the eastern wall of the valley. Chert-pebble conglomerates are scattered throughout some wells, but tend to be concentrated near the northern end of the valley. Here, they arc associated with sandstones and with fully marine mudstones. The valley was formerly interpreted to have been cut and filled by turbidity currents, but this interpretation is difficult to reconcile with the depositional environments of the rest of the Cardium Alloformation. It is suggested here that the valley was cut by a river during a falling stage of relative sea level, and was filled transgrcssivcly as an estuary. There is absolutely no evidence for tidal currents, and little indication of waves. The very thick and structureless sandstones suggest pulses of sediment swept into the estuary from the bay head, possibly as density underflows. There is little or no evidence for the reworking of these deposits within the estuary. There arc no central basin mudstones (no turbidity maximum), although this could be due to incomplete preservation of the entire length of the estuary. The geometry of the estuary and the facies distribution of the fill suggest that the open sea Jay to the north. Chert pebbles moving in the longshore drift system were introduced into the estuary from the north by storms; they were not introduced from the fluvial (southern ) end of the estuary. The orientation of the incised valley, parallel to depositional strike for over 50 km, remains a maj or problem.
INTRODUCTION
storm-dominated shallow-marine sandstones (Walker & Eyles, 1 988) , and transgressive incised shoreface deposits ( Bergman & Walker, 1987 , 1988; Pattison & Walker, 1 992). The main purpose of this paper is to re-examine the allostratigraphical (NACSN , 1983) position of the sand body (Figs 1 & 2 ) , and to reinterpret the incised valley fill as estuari ne. Ricinus is a small oil field, discovered in 1969.
The Ricinus sand body in the Cardium Formation of Alberta (Figs 1 & 2) is over 50 km long, at least 10 km wide, and up to about 30 m thick (Walker, 1985 ) . I originally interpreted it as a channel fill, with channel cutting and filling by turbidity currents. This interpretation has always been difficult to reconcile with the sedimentology of the other facies in the Cardium Formation, which consist largely of
Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading Edited by A. Guy Plint © 1995 The International Association of Sedimentologists ISBN: 978-0-865-42898-0
47
48
R.G. Walker
9
10
8
7
37
RICINUS 0
Wells
.
Cores
OFF-FIELD 36
o
Wells
"
Cores
60' ALBERTA
35
054'
0
3
/�K�\�9' \ o
I
so
�
1 5:
4
Fig. I. Map showing locations of
6
EDMONTON
w--.:_
E5 fields
�
E4 fields
33
�
� \, U '\.
RICIN
c::
�
116'
sw
32
CALGARY . - 1'
114'
6 miles
5
-10 KM
c.20 km
NE
Cardium fields associated with the E4 (fields outlined) and E5 (black) bounding discontinuities. Note location of Ricinus close to and partly straddling the edge of the deformed belt (thrust symbol, inset lower left). The main map shows locations of wells and cores. All of the wells immediately east of Ricinus are shown, but only a few Caroline wells have been used. Note also the locations of cross-section A-A' through to G-G'. Number at right indicates Townships, and number along top indicates Ranges west of the 5th Meridian (114°).
Fig. 2. Stratigraphy of the Cardium Alloformation in the Ricinus area, drawn roughly to scale vertically. Bounding discontinuities E2, E3, E6 and E6.5 cannot be recognized here. Sandier upward successions A-D are assinged to the Hornbeck Allomembcr (note that succession D is commonly truncated by E4). E5 RSE (regressive surface of erosion) defines the base of the Ricinus Allomember, and E5 TSE (transgressive surface of erosion) defines the top. There is some evidence that E5 TSE cuts downward progressively southwestward. IT and RT refer to initial and resumed transgressions, as discussed in the text.
Cardium Formation incised valley
Initial oil-in-place was estimated as 2.88 x 106m3 (18. 1 million bbl) , with initial recoverable oil esti mated at 2.27 x 106m3 ( 14.3 million bbl) (Geological Survey of Canada, 198 1 a , b). However, the signifi cance of the field goes well beyond its minor econ omic potential. It is the only incised valley known in the Cardium, which is surprising in a formation dominated by eight regionally extensive erosion surfaces, each controlled by major fluctuations of relative sea-level. The incised valley interpretation is complicated by the fact that the valley is straight, at least 50 km long, and is parallel to regional strike (Fig. 1 ) . The new interpretations are based upon all o f the data available as of April 1993 , as illustrated in seven new cross-sections presented here (see Figs 3-9 and Appendix 1 ) . There are 172 on-field wells, of which 71 are cored (Fig. 1 ) . All measurements are given in metric units, except where specific reference is made to wells where the well logs and cored intervals were originally recorded in feet.
INTRODUCTION TO THE CARDIUM ALLOFORMA TION
The Cardium Alloformation (NACSN , 1983) is Upper Cretaceous (Turonian - Coniacian), and occurs in the Alberta foreland basin. This basin is part of the Western Interior Seaway, which was open from the Boreal Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico during the Turonian . Sediment was supplied from the active cordillera in the west. The Cardium is about 100 m thick, and is dominated by open-marine mudstones and storm influenced sandstones with hummocky cross stratification (HCS). There is one prograding shoreface succession (Kakwa Allomember; Plint & Walker, 1987) overlain by non-marine deposits (Musreau Allomember), and several examples of incised transgressive shoreface deposits. The relationships of these various deposits have been documented by mapping eight bounding discon tinuities, at least five of which can be traced basin wide (Piint et a/. , 1986; Wadsworth & Walker, 199 1 ; Walker & Eyles, 199 1). These were originally termed erosion surfaces and lettered El- E6, E6. 5 and E7. The regional trend of the various shoreface sand bodies is consistently NW-SE (Fig. 1 ) , parallel to the active cordillera to the west of the foreland basin.
49
Structural problems at Ricinus
The exact morphologies of the Ricinus valley and sand body are difficult to reconstruct because Ricinus lies at the eastern limit of the Foothills deformed belt (Figs 1 , 10 & 1 1 ) . The sand body is broken by several SW-NE trending faults, interpreted to have formed in response to different distances of thrusting toward the northeast. The fault positions have been located mainly by offsets in the northeastern margin of the field, which can be fairly well constrained by the close juxtaposition of wells with 'Ricinus' well log responses versus 'off-field' log responses (Figs 1 & 3-7). Within Ricinus, the sand body is repeated by thrusting in many wells (see Fig. 5 ) . In a few wells the dips exceed 45° and are locally vertical. The former turbidite interpretation
The interpretation of Ricinus as a channel cut and filled by turbidity currents (Walker, 1985) was based on the presence of very thick structure less sandstones and the presence of many beds characterized by a Tabc and Toe internal structure (Bouma, 1962). In the early 1980s, the possibility of turbidity currents in the Western Interior Seaway was suggested by the need to explain how a very large number of sharp based HCS beds had been emplaced well below fair weather wave base. Thinking was also influenced by the occurrence of well-defined turbidites overlain by HCS beds in the Jurassic Passage Beds in the Banff area. Here , both the turbidites and HCS beds have identical palaeocurrent orientations (Hamblin & Walker, 1979), suggesting emplacement of the HCS beds by turbidity currents, but above storm wave base. Turbidite ideas were first applied to the Cardium before the presence and significance of sea-level changes in the Cardium had been documented (Piint et a/., 1986), and before much of the important recent work on estuarine deposits had been pub lished (Dalrymple et a/. , 1992). The main purpose of this paper is to suggest an alternative to turbidity currents for cutting and filling the incised valley at Ricinus. Allostratigraphy
The most useful subdivision of the Cardium is allostratigraphical (NACSN , 1983) rather than lithostratigraphical (Fig. 2). An allostratigraphical unit 'is a mappable stratiform body of sedimentary
50
R.G. Walker
rock that is defined and identified on the basis of its bounding discontinuities ... [one may thus define] as single units discontinuity-bounded deposits charac terized by lithic heterogeneity' (NACSN , 1983 , p. 865). I regard the Cardium Alloformation as a formally defined stratigraphical unit, and have appended some thoughts on allostratigraphy in Appendix 2. The Cardium Alloformation has been subdivided into 14 allomembers, with eight well defined bounding discontinuities (E1 through to E7; Plint et al. , 1986) . Throughout this paper, informal use of the term Cardium (without a modifier) implies the Cardium Alloformation. The term Cardium Formation will be used only to designate the litho stratigraphical unit.
regionally extensive sheet-like sandier upward successions of the Hornbeck Allomember (Fig. 2). These successions are labelled A through to D in Figs 2-8 and collectively form the datum in these cross-sections. Succession C is cored in wells 7-9-36-8W5 and 10-17-34-7W5 (Fig. 4; all wells lie west of the 5th Meridian , and the W5 will be omitted from all subsequent well numbers cited). Succession C consists of bioturbated sandy mudstones that gradually become sandier upward; the top consists of a 1-cm-thick layer of chert grains about 0.5 mm (7-9-36-8) or 3 mm (10-17-34-7) in diameter. This sandier upward succession, capped by a gritty layer, is similar to those described by Walker & Eyles ( 1 988) from the Raven River Allomember; suc cessions A, B and D have not been cored but are probably similar to succession C. The sand bodies that form reservoirs at Garrington, Crossfield and Caroline (E4 fields in Fig. 1; Pattison & Walker, 1992) are assigned to the Burnstick Allomember. They rest in NW-SE trending steps on the E4 erosion surface (Fig. 2) , and are inter preted as transgressive shorefaces. Each incised shoreface is underlain by a surface of initial trans gression (IT in Fig. 2) , and is truncated by a surface of resumed transgression (RT in Fig. 2). An RT surface can pass southwestward into an IT surface if and when the transgression pauses and another still stand shoreface becomes incised. An example can be seen in well 7-33-36- 10, section A (Fig. 3 ) , where
OUTLINE OF CARDIUM STRATIGRAPHY AND SEDIMENTOLOGY
The base of the Cardium Alloformation is taken at bounding discontinuity El (Figs 2 -6). In the Ricinus area E1 has never been cored, and it is probably a correlative conformity (see Appendix 2) rather than a surface with demonstrable erosion . Its log identi fication is compatible with the E 11og identifier used by Plint et al. ( 1 986) and Wadsworth & Walker ( 199 1 ) . Erosion surfaces E2 and E3 cannot be ident ified in this area. Surface E4 has demonstrable erosion (Figs 3, 5 & 6), and cuts into a series of
7-33-36-10
7-26-36-10
7-36-36-10
1-31-36-9
8-32-36-9
11-33-36-9
10-34-36-9
11-36-36-9
7-32-36-8
@
® �
���
�
--
-
--
0
�
�Es�
�
�
�TSE�
�
---'
F �
� �
?-
�
�
�-
-
_t
_
Fig. 3.
-EI-
Gamma-ray and resistivity well-log cross-section A-A', hung collectively on a series of more -or-less parallel markers above and below the Cardium. Depths are marked at 50-m intervals and cored intervals are shown as black bars. Wells 7-33-36-10, 7-26-36-10, 7-36-36-10 and 7-32-36-8 have 'off-field' well-log signatures.
51
Cardium Formation incised valley 7-36-36-10 15-23-36-10
® �
5-10-36-9
4-18-36-8
10-18-36-8
-
�� z 0
11-18-36-9
7-19-36-8
7-9-36-8
®
-
�
--- �/
-
----
-TSE �co�
?-
::;;� 0:: 0 LL
__
'3
/
___________
,
BLACK
�E4�
::;; ::;) 0 0:: "' u
'
f\_SE___
�E4�
_,
fc
\ -E. I-
j
Fig. 4.
Cross-section B-B', hung communally on the sandier upward successions A-C, and the top of the black blanket (dashed line). See caption of Fig. 3 for other conventions, and note draping of upper markers over the Ricinus sand body. The shoulder on the resistivity and gamma-ray logs typical of E7 is not present in 7-9-36-8, nor is the narrower waist in the well-log profile immediately below E7. The waist appears to be cut out by E7 toward 7-9-36-8, and E7 is probably only about 2 m above E5 (see Figs 12-14). Wells 7-36-36-10, 15-23-36-10, 11-18-36-9, 7-19-36-8 and 7-9-36-8 have 'off-field' well log signatures.
©
1-5-34-8
6-9-34-8
14-10-34-8
10-10-34-8
6-14-34-8
6-24-34-8
11-20-34-7
10-21-34-7
©
F?
--
-------
-- EI -
Fig. 5.
-
§ a>
----
g
"' "'
g---"'
Cross-section C-C', hung on sandier upward successions A-C. Other conventions explained in the caption of Fig. 3. Wells 1-5-34-8 and 10-21-34-7 have 'off-field' well-log signatures. F indicates a fault repeat of the top of the Ricinus Allomember in 10-10-34-8, and F? indicates possible faulting. RRl is the first sandier upward succession in the Raven River Allomember.
52
R.G. Walker
1 0-8-33-7
4-9-33-7
3-10-33-7
10-12-33-7
7-10-33-7
6-24-33-7
11-25-33-7
®
®
� �
g " N
z 0
--
0 0 N
�:::!:
0::: 0 LJ... 0 ...J ...J <[
?
E4---
BLANKET
rc � TB 15 0::: <[ u
?
�N
--
0
+A
t
g N
-
EI-
-
Fig. 6.
Cross-section D-D', hung on sandier upward successions A-C. Other conventions explained in the caption of Fig. 3. Note the erosional truncation of markers between ES TSE and E7 by the E7 bounding discontinuity between wells 7-10-33-7, 10-12-33-7 and 6-24-33-7. Wells 10-12-33-7, 6-24-33-7 and 11-25-33-7 have 'off-field' signatures.
11-18-33- 7
3-19-33-7
8-19-33-7
6-20-33-7
4-21-33-7
6-23-33-7
©
----- ----
E4 formed during an initial transgression , and sand was deposited on the surface during a stillstand in transgression . This sand was truncated as the E4 transgression continued, leaving a 4-m-thick sand body. However, over most of the study area, E4 is probably overlain only by a thin lag. The Raven River Allomember extends from the top of this lag to the ES bounding discontinuity (Fig. 2). The lower part consists of black mudstones (the 'black blanket' of Walker, 1983) characterized by parallel and featureless gamma-ray and resistivity logs (Figs 2 & 4-8). In logs, the top of the black
Fig. 7.
Cross-section E-E', hung on the B sandier upward succession. Note truncation of the top of the 'black blanket' and top of RR1 by bounding discontinuity ES RSE, and the apparent pinchout of facies D between wells 3-19-33-7 and 8-19-33-7 against the wall of the incision. Facies D and the sandstones above (3-19-33-7) appear to be eroded by ES TSE toward well 11-18-33-7.
blanket is taken at the first deflections of the gamma ray and resistivity logs (the dashed line in Figs 4-8). Here, the black blanket grades into bioturbated siltstones and sandstones, and HCS sandstones , organized into sandier upward successions. The first of these successions is identified as RR-1 (Figs 5 & 7). The successions are eroded to various depths by ES. Erosion surface E5 has received much attention (Fig. 2; Walker & Eyles, 199 1 ) , partly because of its economic importance in locating the shoreface gravels in the Carrot Creek area (Bergman &
53
Cardium Formation incised valley
7-16-34-8
16-16-34-8
®
'-"'"""E7"'"""-
9-16-34-8
®
�,L
Cross-section F-F', hung comunally on sandier upward successions A-C. Note thinning and disappearance of facies C and/ or D from well 16-16-34-8 eastward toward well 10-22-34-8, and possible erosion of these facies by the thick sandstone in well 7-16-34-8 (possible erosion surface shown by question marks). Note also the truncation of markers between ES TSE and E7 by the E7 bounding discontinuity.
3-19-33-7
6-24-34-8
!15
Fig. 8.
�
10-22-34-8
�ISE"""'
�
BLANKET
16-30-34-8
1 2 -19-35-8
ll-30-35-8
16-30-35-8
3-6-36-8
®
3-6-36-8
7-18-36-8
10-18-36-8
16-13-36-9
6-24-36-9
13-26-36-9
1 2-34-36-9
2-4-37-9
) -�
!15 �0 M
Fig. 9.
South (G) to north (G') cross-section showing the continuity of facies C and/or D along the length of the field. These muddy facies can be recognized by their distinctive indentation in the gamma-ray and resistivity well-logs. The mudstones occur in the uppermost part of the core in 12-34-36-9 (Fig. 26), and also appear to occupy the same position in wells 7-18-36-8, 10-18-36-8 and 13-26-36-9. In these wells, the Ricinus Allomember is unusually thin, suggesting that sandstone originally above facies C and/or D has been eroded at the ES TSE bounding discontinuity.
54
R.G. Walker
Walker, 1987, 1988) , and also for determining the remnant erosional topo·graphy on top of major Cardium reservoirs at Pembina, Willesden Green and Ferrier (shown black and identified as E5 fields in Fig. 1 ; Walker & Eyles, 1988, 199 1 ) . In this paper, the base of the Ricinus sand body is correlated with E5 - specifically with a falling stage of relative sea-level (E5 RSE- regressive surface of erosion) . Over most of the Cardium basin, the subaerial E5 surface was modified during transgression , and is designated E5 TSE (transgressive surface of erosion) in Figs 3-9. Erosion beneath E5 RSE is illustrated by the truncation of log markers, particularly in Figs 5 - 8 . The extent o f erosion a t the E 5 R S E surface can also be shown by isopaching the E4 to E5 RSE interval. If it is assumed that E4 is relatively planar in the Ricinus area, the shape of the Ricinus incision can be seen in Fig. 10. The new term Ricinus Allomember (Fig. 2) is introduced here for the sand 10
9
8
7 37
body that rests on E5 RSE and is truncated by E5 TSE. The extent of this sand body, and the type wells are the same as for the Ricinus Member as defined by Walker ( 1985, p. 1 98 1 ) . Discontinuity E 6 i s a n erosion surface with little topographical relief and it cannot be identified reliably in this area. Although E6.5 has more relief than E6 it also is difficult to identify in the study area. Discontinuity E7 consistently forms a small shoulder on the gamma-ray and resistivity logs, and can be identified easily. The topography of the E7 surface has been mapped by Wadsworth & Walker ( 199 1 ) . They showed a deep 'valley' or 'low' on the erosion surface j ust east of Ricinus, and part of this can be seen in Figs 4 & 6. In Fig. 4, E7 is not present in the 'expected' position in 7-9-36-8 (Fig. 12) . The lag associated with E5 is prominent in core (Fig. 13), and is overlain by transgressive mudstones. A second lag, with chert pebbles up to 1 . 1 em diameter, occurs about 2 m above E5 (Fig. 14) ; it shows on the gamma-ray and resistivity logs and is identified as E7 (?) in Fig. 4. A similar relationship is shown in Figs 6-8, where log markers in the E5 TSE to E7 interval are truncated by E7. Log marker E7, which is nor mally well developed and easy to identify, is absent
10
36
9
8
7 37
35
36 34 6
35 33
34
Isopach, E4 to E5 RSE (base of Ricinus
6 32
incised valley), metres Fig. 10.
Isopach map of the interval between E4 and E5. On field, the map shows the E4-E5 RSE interval, and off field, the E4-E5 TSE interval. Isopachs show height above E4; thus the 4 m isopach shows the deepest part of the valley. Note that the edge of the valley is approximated by the 28 m isopach. The line F shows one of the faults at Ricinus (Fig. 1); north of this fault, all of the data points have been shifted southwestward to line up the axis of the field as defined by the well density - see Appendix C.
lsop1ch, E5 RSE to E5 TSE, metres
33
32
Fig. 11.
Isopach map of the E5 RSE to E5 TSE interval (the thickness of the Ricinus sand body). See Fig. 10 and Appendix C for explanation of line F.
55
Cardium Formation incised valley
Fig. 12.
Core from well 7-9-36-8, which lies just east of the margin of Ricinus. B =bottom, T =top. Note siderite horizon (below label) and chert pebbles (above label) associated with ES, and the interval of laminated mudstones (the 'laminated blanket' of Walker, 1983) between ES and E7. Note siderite horizon (under label) and chert pebbles (above label) associated with E7, and the much blacker mudstones without silty laminations above E7. The separation of ES and E7 over Ricinus is 40-48 m, but is about 2m in this core. Thus there is about 40 m of erosional relief on E7 immediately to the east of Ricinus (Wadsworth & Walker, 1991).
in the easternmost wells in these cross-sections, suggesting that E7 and E5 are co-planar (or that E7 has actually cut into and removed E5). The top of the Cardium Alloformation is taken at the top of the lag that rests on E7.
Fig. 13.
Detail of siderite horizon, chert pebbles, and eroded sandstone clast (large triangular shape) at the ES TSE horizon, well 7-9-36-8, 8634 ft. See Fig. 12 for stratigraphical context of this photograph, but note that core has been rotated in Fig. 13 to show different features. Core is 3 in. (7.6 cm) wide.
GEOMETRY OF THE RICINUS INCISED
VALLEY
AND SAND BODY
The geometry of the Ricinus sand body was estab lished initially from many cross-sections - seven are presented here (Figs 3 - 9). After it had been deter-
mined that bounding discontinuities E7 , E5 TSE , E5 RSE , E4 and El could be traced and identified throughout the study area, maps of various strati graphical intervals were made using SURFER 4.0 (Golden Software Inc. , Golden, Colorado) (see Appendix 3). ·
56
R.G. Walker
which is the base of the valley. The eastern edge of the valley is approximated by the 28 m isopach. The valley trends roughly NW-SE, with a straight and well-defined eastern margin that has at least 24 m of relief in T34 R8-9 (Fig. 10). This eastern valley wall has a gradient of about 0.007° westward into the valley. The eastern margin remains a straight and well-defined feature from T35 R8-9 to the southern most fault in T32 R7, but northward, the valley seems to broaden and become less well defined in T36 R9. Erosion at the eastern valley wall is evident in the cross-sections; Figs 3 - 8 all show truncation of log markers by E5 RSE (particularly in Figs 5, 7 and 8) , or convergence of E5 RSE toward the top of the 'black blanket' (Fig. 6) , or convergence toward E4 (Fig. 5). The eastern margin is characterized by a rapid change from on-field to off-field log signatures, allowing a boundary to be drawn to within 600 m (e.g. in land section 2 1 , T35 R8 and land sections 17-20, T36 R8; Fig. 1 ) . The western margin i s very poorly defined because there is little well control; many of the well logs suggest extensive thrusting and are impossible to use in the isopach maps. The maximum depth of the valley is in the centre of the field (T34 R8 -9), and the valley becomes shallower both northwestward and southeastward. The northern and southern ends of the valley are faulted. Wells on line with the Ricinus sand body but outside the faulted ends have 'off-field' well-log signatures. Sand body geometry
Fig. 14. Detail of siderite, bioturbation and chert pebbles
at the E7 horizon, well 7-9-36-8, 8639 ft. See Fig. 12 for stratigraphical context of this photograph. Core is 3 in. (7. 6 cm) wide.
Incised valley geometry
An isopach map of the E4 to E5 interval is shown in Fig. 10. On-field, the map shows the E4 to E5 RSE interval, and off-field, it shows E4 to E5 TSE. Erosion surface E4 is not exactly planar (Figs 3 -8) , but regionally it may be taken to approximate a plane. If so, the E4 to E5 isopach can be interpreted as showing the on-field topography of E5 RSE,
The sand body geometry was defined by isopaching the E5 TSE to E5 RSE interval (Fig. 1 1) , with the assumption that E5 TSE (the upper bounding dis continuity) approximates a planar surface. The sand body isopach map closely resembles the map of the E4 to E5 RSE interval (the morphology of the base of the valley) , with the sand body thinning northwestward and southeastward from a maximum thickness greater than 24 m in T34 R8. In the northwest, the isopach of the sandstone seems to define a valley more clearly than the E4 to E5 RSE map. The prominent eastward deflections of the 8 and 4 m isopachs in T34 R7 -8 are due to the 1 1-m-thick sandstone in well 1 1-20-34-7; this sand stone has apparently been thrust unusually far to the northeast (Figs 2 & 5). With this exception, the eastern edge of the sand body is remarkably straight. The sand body is characterized by a very sharp
Cardium Formation incised valley
base, and blocky to blocky and serrated gamma-ray and resistivity well-log signatures (Figs 3 - 8) ; these will be termed 'on-field' signatures. They contrast with off-field wells (e .g. Fig. 3, wells 7-33-36- 10, 7-26-36- 10 and 7-36-36- 10) , which are characterized by a gradual sandier upward signature between E4 and E5 and a capping sand body that is only a metre or two thick.
57
Facies A: structureless sandstones
This facies consists of sandstones that lack any physical or biological structures (Figs 1 5 - 17), or that are dominantly structureless but contain parallel lamination and/or ripple cross-lamination in the uppermost part of the bed . Grain size is mostly in the fine-grained sand range, with a few beds of very
FACIES OF THE RICINUS ALLOMEMBER
The Ricinus sand body contains a suite of facies that are quite unlike those found in any other part of the Cardium. Five facies were recognized originally (Walker, 1985 ) , and this scheme is modified and simplified here.
Fig. 15.
Structureless sandstones with no apparent bedding surfaces and no mudstone partings. B =bottom, T =top. Core 3 in. (7 .6 em) wide, each core sleeve 2.5 ft (about 75cm) long. Well 8 -10-34-8, 8109-8124 ft.
Fig. 16.
Structureless sandstone. The absence of structure appears to be primary - there is no evidence of the destruction of former structure by dewatering or bioturbation. Core 3 in. (7. 6 cm) wide. Well 8-10-34-8, 8115 ft.
58
R.G. Walker Structureless sandstones: percent of core
100 ••• ••
... .
u
6
. .
Structureless sandstones:
1m)
average bed thickness 5
4
3
2 . .
.
.. .
.
.
.
•
.
..
•
•
.
... . .
.
0 33 Southeast
34
34
35
36
36
37
Northwest
Fig. 17.
Distribution of facies A structureless sandstones from T33 northward to T37.
fine-grained sand and even fewer of medium-grained sand. X-radiographs have not been made of these sandstones, but it is believed that the absence of sedimentary structures is real. Structures are readily observed in other sandstone facies of similar grain size (Figs 18- 20) . It seems reasonable to infer that where the core shows absolutely no indication of structure (Figs 15 - in the four core sleeves on the right - & 16) , there is probably nothing there. The percentage of facies A beds in core varies from zero to 100, but there is no trend from south to north (Fig. 17). Because of the intense fracturing, particularly in the southern part of Ricinus, it is difficult to estimate individual bed thicknesses. However, several cores contain sandstones that are unfractured, contain no internal grain-size breaks, have no mudstone partings, and have no layers of eroded mud clasts (Fig. 15 - note that there is one mudstone parting near the top of the fourth sleeve from the left). Possibly some of these criteria for multiple beds have been lost in places where core is
Fig. 18.
Sandstone showing crude parallel stratification at the base, well-developed parallel lamination in the middle, and ripple cross-lamination at the top. Core 3 in. wide (scale in em). Well 11-18-33-7, 8541 ft.
broken or cut. Nevertheless, there appear to be at least four single beds thicker than 4 m (in wells 1 1-1 8-33-7 , 7-36-33-8, 2-1-34-8, 14-27-36-9), with two more reaching thicknesses of 6.3 (7-28-34-8) and 6.7 m ( 16- 10-34-8). There is an overall tendency for the thicker beds to be concentrated in the southern part of Ricinus; the thinner ( < 1 m) beds occur
Cardium Formation incised valley
59
Fig. 19.
Almost every piece of core in these boxes shows parallel lamination. The individual pieces of core are cut, obscuring possible bed contacts. There are no angular divergences, intersections or truncations of lamination. B =bottom, T =top. Core is 3 in. ( 7. 6 cm) wide, and each core sleeve is 2. 5 ft ( about 75em) long. Well 14-2-34-8, 7726-7740 ft.
throughout the sand body but are more common in the north, particularly in Townships 36 and 37 (Fig. 17). These thinner beds have sharp bases marked by a jumble of eroded mud clasts and/or a concentration of coarse grains and granules of chert. Grading occurs in about half of the beds, either because of an upward disappearance of the coarse grains and granules (coarse tail grading) , or because of a progressive upward fining throughout the bed (dis tribution grading) . Internally, the beds are domi nantly structureless, but some show the development of crude parallel lamination toward the top. About one-third of the beds have a single layer of ripple cross-lamination at the top. The most common association of structures is Tbe (Fig. 18), with a few beds showing the succession Tal>e· These beds are much more common in the northern part of the sand
Fig. 20.
Parallel lamination, commonly emphasized by finely comminuted organic material. Well 14-2-34-8, 7708ft.
body; the average thickness is about 50 em (range 10- 135 cm , n= 153 beds). Trace fossils are very rare in this facies, and are restricted to Ophiomorpha. Facies B: parallel-laminated sandstone
These sandstones are characterized by parallel lamination (Figs 19 & 20); the stratification is characterized by subtle changes in grain size and by very thin carbonaceous laminae (Fig. 20) . I ndividual beds appear to be as thick as 2 m (maximum 6 m) in the southern part of the sand body, and thin north ward to an average of about 60 em . The percentage of parallel-laminated sandstones in the cores shows a very weak tendency to decrease northward (Fig.
R.G. Walker
60
Grain sizes are consistently in the fine-grained sand range. Trace fossils are rare , and are restricted to Ophiomorpha.
21).
100 80
Parallel-laminated sandstones percent of core
60 Facies C: interbedded bioturbated sandstones and mudstones
This facies consists of alternations of sandstones (thickness typically·1 -3 em) and mudstones (thick nesses a few millimetres to about 1 em) (Figs 22 & 23). I t occurs throughout the sand body (Fig. 9), but is thickest (10-15 m) in the central area (T34 R8) (Fig. 11). Contacts with the other sandstone facies (structureless, parallel-laminated) tend to be gra dational , and granules and pebbles of chert are rare (compare with facies D, below) . The sandstones are characterized by small-scale ripple cross-lamination. Where ripple forms can be seen, they are commonly asymmetrical, suggesting current ripples rather than wave ripples. The facies is not intensely bioturbated; the commonest trace fossil is Planolites (Fig. 23), with some examples of Ophiomorpha, Arenicolites , Conichnus and Rosselia (Fig. 22 - the Rosselia in sleeve 12, counting from the right, was figured by McEachern & Pemberton , 1992, p. 63, A). Facies D : bioturbated mudstones
This facies is less sandy and more thoroughly bio turbated than facies C (Figs 24 - 26). It contains a larger suite of trace fossils; the commonest traces are simple, horizontal sand-filled tubes about 1 em diameter (Planolites), with Helminthopsis (Fig. 27). Zoophycos (Fig. 27), Anconichnus, Skolithos, Ophiomorpha,
Thalassinoides ,
Teichichnus, Aste
and Rosselia. Scattered chert granules and pebbles are com monly associated with the bioturbated sandy mud stones (Fig. 26), and they occur throughout the thickness of the facies in many wells. The coarser
rosoma, Terebellina
Fig. 22.
•
40
20
.
.
0
. .
.
..
·-
.
I I I ·-···· ··-····-·-·--· ·-·.· -•
6
Parallel-laminated sandstones average bed thickness (m)
5 4 3 •
2
..
•
.
•
•
·. ·.
.
;,
..
••
0 �---.----.--,,--r33 34
Southeast
34
35
36
36 37
Northwest
Fig. 21.
Distribution of facies B parallel -laminated sandstones from T33 northward to T37.
clasts rarely occur in distinct beds - they are more commonly bioturbated into the sandy mud stone. The clasts occur throughout the field, from the southernmost (11-21-34-8) to northernmost ( 12-34-36-9) occurrences of the facies. Where the lower contact of this facies is seen in core, it is always sharp, and marked by the incoming of chert granules and pebbles (Figs 24, 25 & 28), together with rip-up clasts of mudstone and siderite. Good examples occur in wells 11-21-34-8 (1 mm chert grains; Fig. 24), 16-30-34-8 (3 mm grains) , 2-34-36-9 (with chert pebbles up to 1 . 4cm), 12-34-36-9 (1.3 em pebbles; Fig. 25) and 2-4-37-9
( Opposite. ) Well 12-19-35-8 boxed with the base of the well at the lower right; B =bottom, T =top. Note the sharp base of the Ricinus sandstone (BASE R), overlain by parallel-laminated sandstone that grade into facies C, the interbedded bioturbated sandstones and mudstones (sleeves 11-14 from right). Toward the top of this facies, it becomes interbedded with parallel-laminated sandstones (sleeves 14 and 15), and grades up into structureless sandstones (top five sleeves). Core is 3 in. (7.6 cm) wide, and each core sleeve is 2.5 ft (about 75cm) long. Well 12-9 -35-8, 8990-9048 ft. Note Rosselia (ROSS) in sleeve 12 - this example was figured by McEachern & Pemberton, 1992. During core photography, handwritten labels with way-up arrows, well locations and the words 'Ricinus' and 'bottom' were pinned on to the core boxes. Thus 'Ricinus bottom' refers to each photograph of three or four core boxes, not to the bottom of the Ricinus Allomember. The base of the Ricinus Allomember is marked by the printed letters BASE R.
62
R.G. Walker
and pebble lags mark the very sharp contact with underlying facies. These lags are normally only one to a few centimetres thick, with chert granules and pebbles up to 4 cm diameter, and abundant sideritized mud clasts. These basal lags occur from the southern to northern parts of the sand body, but there is no systematic distribution of clast sizes. Conglomerates also mark the top of the Ricinus Allomember, where they occur as lags on the E5 TSE surface (Fig. 25) . This surface truncates the Ricinus Allomember, and the conglomerates actually belong to the Carrot Creek Allomember. These conglomerates have been cored only in three wells (7- 19-35-8, 12- 18-36-8 and 12-34-36-9) ; they are 1 .2-2.5 m thick and have chert pebbles up to 4 cm diameter (in 12- 18-36-8). In T36 R9 (particularly in land sections 24 -27) conglomerates are abundant from bottom to top of the Ricinus sand body (Figs 26 & 29). The coarser clasts occur at the bases of graded sandstone beds, or form conglomerate beds up to about 1 m thick, with chert pebbles 1 -2 em diameter. A few pebbles reach 3 - 4 cm, with a maximum of 7.5 cm diameter (in 3-27-36-9). These bedded conglomerates are structureless to crudely stratified, and are inter bedded with structureless or parallel-laminated sand stones, and with thin mudstone partings (Fig. 29). The scattered granules and pebbles associated with the bioturbated mudstone facies have been described above. They are typically mixed into the mudstones by bioturbation, or may fill distinct bur rows (Fig. 30) .
LATERAL AND VERTICAL FACIES DISTRIBUTIONS
Fig. 23. Interbedded bioturbated sandstones and
mudstones, showing abundant Planolites (P), and a possible example of Zoophycos (Z) at the bottom of the photograph. Note ripple cross -lamination within the sandstones. Well 12-19-35-8, 9016 ft.
( 1 .7 em pebbles; Fig. 28). Thus the coarser clasts at this sharp contact become generally fi n er grained southward. Facies E: conglomerates
Conglomerates and scattered pebbles occur through out the Ricinus Allomember. At the base, granule
Sandstones
The Ricinus Allomember trends NW-SE, with a maximum thickness of about 25 m in T34 R8 (Fig. 1 1 ) . It thins against the eastern wall of the valley (Fig. 1 1) but the western margin is poorly constrained by data and disrupted by extensive thrusting. Within the main sand body, the sandstone facies (structure·· less, and parallel-laminated) show no preferred vertical trends. Some wells are almost exclusively structureless, others almost exclusively parallel·· laminated. Most wells show interbedding of these two facies. There is a weak tendency for the average bed thickness in both facies to decrease northwest ward (Figs 17 & 2 1 ) , but there is almost no change
Cardium Formation incised valley
63
Fig. 24.
This core is boxed top-to-left; B =bottom, T =top. The parallel-laminated sandstone facies is overlain sharply by the bioturbated mudstone facies. The sharp contact is marked by the incoming of chert granules (CH). The bioturbated mudstones contain Zoophycos (Z; it first appears near the base of the facies), Helminthopsis (H), Rosselia (R), Thalassinoides (TH) and Teichichnus (TE). Chert granules and pebbles are dispersed throughout the bioturbated mudstone facies, but become abundant and coarser toward the top (in the sandier core sleeve on the left). Core is 3 in. (7.6 cm) wide, and each sleeve is 2.5 ft (about 75 em) long. Well 11-21-34-8, 7022-7052 ft. See comment about handwritten label 'Ricinus bottom' in caption of Fig. 22.
along the field in the percentage of each facies in core (Figs 17 & 2 1 ). Mudstones
Because mudstones form an important part of many estuary fills, the position of Facies C and D within Ricinus was investigated in detail. These facies occur throughout the field (Fig. 9) , with a maximum thicknesses in T34 R8-9. An isopach map (not included here) of the interval between the base of the incised valley and the base of facies C or D shows that in the valley axis these facies occur about 12 m above the base. However, toward the north eastern margin , the height above the base decreases progressively to about 4 m (Figs 7 & 8). The isopachs are parallel to the trend of the valley wall. This
relationship can be interpreted to imply partial valley filling (more sand in the centre, less toward the margin) before the muddier facies C and D were deposited as a sheet that pinched out toward the valley wall. The wells that contain facies C or D appear to have no preferred locations within the field. This may be due to thrusting, particularly on the western side. Alternatively, there is some evidence that the distribution of facies C and D is masked by erosion of E5 TSE into the Ricinus sand body. Erosion of facies C and D is strongly suggested in Fig. 7 , between wells 3-19-33-7 and 1 1-18-33-7, and in Fig. 9 (wells 7-1 8-36-8 and 10- 18-36-8, and at the northern end in wells 13-26-36-9, 12-34-36-9 and 2-4-37-9). The patchy distribution of facies C and D may also be due to original depositional pinchout against the
64
R.G. Walker
Cardium Formation incised valley
eastern valley wall, as suggested in Fig. 7 (between wells 3-19-33-7 and 9-19-33-7) and Fig. 8 (between wells 16- 16-34-8 and 10-22-34-8) . Also , it is possible that some deposits of facies C and D were eroded during subsequent filling of the Ricinus valley, and before the development of ES TSE . This is suggested in Fig. 8, where facies C and/or D in well 9-16-34-8 might possibly be scoured by the sandstone with a blocky well-log response in 7-16-34-8. Although relatively few well-logs display the deeply indented pattern shown in Fig. 9 (indicative of facies C and/or D ) , and despite the limited core control , it seems likely that these facies originally extended from the northern to southern parts of the field as a sheet. This sheet averages about 4 m in thickness, and seems to pinch out against the eastern wall of the valley. The western margin is unknown. The mudstones of facies D, with their fully marine trace fauna, are apparently limited to the northern and central parts of the field (2-4-37-9 southward to 1 1-21 -34-8) . They have very sharp, and probably erosive bases in wells 1 1-21-34-8, 16-30-34-8, 2-34-36-9 and 12-34-36-9.
COMPARISON WITH OTHER CARDIUM ALLOMEMBERS
The major differences between the Ricinus ABo member and other Cardium allomembers are reviewed here. Because all of the facies at Ricinus are apparently marine, I will not make any com parisons with the non-marine Musreau Allomember. There are many asymmetrical scoured surfaces in the Cardium. The scours are linear, oriented NW-SE, and have gentle dips to the southwest and steeper dips to the northeast. Surfaces E4 and ES are typical (Walker & Eyles, 199 1 ; Pattison & Walker, 1992) . Ricinus is also a linear scour oriented NW-SE, but incomplete data for the southwestern side preclude any analysis of its symmetry.
Fig. 25.
65
The facies overlying the valley-floor scour at Ricinus are completely different from those over lying E4 and ES elsewhere. At Ricinus, the typical facies are thick, structureless and parallel-laminated sandstones. Elsewhere, the E4 and ES incised scours are overlain by up to 20 m of conglomerate (Carrot Creek Allomember; Bergman & Walker, 1987, 1988 ) , or coarse and pebbly sandstones with sets of cross-bedding 1 0 cm or more thick (Burnstick Allo member; Pattison & Walker, 1992). The coarse facies in the Carrot Creek and Burnstick Allo members are interpreted as transgressive shoreface deposits. The structureless and parallel-laminated sandstones at Ricinus are found nowhere else in the Cardium. Typical open-marine Cardium deposits consist of mudstones, and wave-rippled and HCS sand stones interbedded with bioturbated mudstones. There are no definite HCS sandstones at Ricinus. Common and abundant ichnospecies in the open marine mudstones include Chondrites, Gyrochorte, Palaeophycus, Planolites, Rhizocorallium , Thalas
and Zoophycos (Pemberton & Frey, 1984, p. 282) . This is a different suite from that found in the mudstones at Ricinus, where Rosselia is much more abundant, Palaeophycus is rare and Chondrites was not observed. Finally, the one prograding shoreface in the Cardium , the Kakwa Allomember, is dominated by swaley cross-stratification (Plint & Walker, 1987 ) . Swaley cross-stratification has not been identified at Ricinus.
sinoides
INTERPRETATION OF RICINUS
Could Ricinus be an incised shoreface?
The orientation of the Ricinus sand body suggests the possibility that it is an incised shoreface , similar to those at Garrington , Crossfield and Caroline
( Opposite. ) Sharp base of Ricinus sand body (BASE R) on underlying mudstones of the Raven River Allomember. Note lag j ust above base (L). The sandstones are parallel-laminated and structureless, and are very abruptly overlain by the bioturbated mudstones facies in the upper half of the figure, at CH. Note sudden incoming of chert pebbles (CH) up to 1 em in diameter. The top of the Ricinus sand body is marked by erosion surface E5 TSE (E5 in photograph), which is characterized by eroded sandstone clasts at the base (j ust above E5 label in photograph). The lag on E5 is about 15em thick, and is overlain by transgressive laminated mudstones (the 'laminated blanket' of Walker, 1983; LB in photograph). B =bottom, T =top. Core is 4 in. (10. 2em) in diameter, and each core sleeve is 2ft (about 60cm) long. Well 12-34-36-9, 9254-9307 ft. See comment about handwritten label 'Ricinus bottom' in caption of Fig. 22. Core is boxed top to-right and is continuous from upper to lower panels in the figure.
66
R.G. Walker
Fig. 26. Bioturbated mudstone facies with abundant scattered chert granules and pebbles (small white specks throughout
photograph), and a prominent conglomerate bed (CGL). B =bottom, T = top. Core is 3 in. (7.6 cm) wide and each core sleeve is 2.5 ft (75 em) long. Well 3-32-34-8, 9040-9066 ft. See comment about handwritten label 'Ricinus bottom' in caption of Fig. 22.
(associated with E4; Pattison & Walker, 1992), and at Carrot Creek (associated with E5; Bergman & Walker, 1987, 1988) . However, the abundance of thick beds of structureless sandstone at Ricinus is most atypical of a shoreface, where the sand is normally being constantly reworked by longshore currents, rip currents and waves. The Carrot Creek shorefaces are characterized by conglomerates, and the Burnstick shorefaces by cross-stratified coarse and granule-sandstones, and conglomerates. The prograding Kakwa shoreface is dominated by swaley cross-stratification. None of these features is present at Ricinus. Mudstones 4-5 m thick are not characteristic of shorefaces, although it could be argued that the mudstones at Ricinus formed during a minor trans gression of the postulated shoreface . However, their geometry is incompatable with this hypothesis. At
Ricinus, the mudstones appear to pinch out against the bounding discontinuity on the eastern side. If this discontinuity were interpreted as the initial trans gressive surface underlying a Ricinus shoreface, the mudstones would downlap on to this surface . This would be an almost impossible situation for a minor transgression of a shoreface ; the mudstones ought to pinch out against the western wall and continue seaward parallel to the eastern bounding discon tinuity. All of these arguments, taken together, suggest that Ricinus is not any form of incised shore face, despite the orientation of the sand body. Origin of the valley
The comparisons of Ricinus with other parts of the Cardium, along with discussions of a possible shore face origin , suggest that Ricinus is (i) not an incised
Cardium Formation incised valley
67
Fig. 27.
Zoophycos (Z) and robust Helminthopsis (H; flattened black marks) in well l l -21-34-8, 7035 ft. Core is 3 in. (7.6 cm) wide.
transgressive shoreface deposit, (ii) not a prograding shoreface , and (iii) not an open-marine HCS sand body like those in the Raven River Allomember (Walker & Eyles, 1988) . The basal incision (E5 RSE) appears to define a NW-SE trending valley at least 24 m deep, with a marine fill. I now reject my earlier suggestion that the valley was cut by turbidity currents (Walker, 1985). The Cardium contains mainly shallow-marine to shore line deposits, influenced by about eight major fluc tuations of relative sea-level . In this overall setting, the most likely origin for the Ricinus valley is fluvial , with incision during a falling stage of sea-level. The valley was subsequently filled in an estuarine setting. The basal deposits of the Ricinus sand body consist of structureless and parallel-laminated sandstones, commonly with a lag of chert pebbles, siderite
Fig. 28.
Sharp and erosive basal contact of bioturbated mudstone facies D on underlying sandstones in well 2-4-379, 9326 ft. Chert pebbles are up to 1. 7 em diameter, and siderite intraclasts are larger than 2 em. Note possible Zoophycos (Z) only a few centimetres above base of the bioturbated mudstone facies. Core 3 in. (7 .6 em) diameter.
pebbles and ripped-up mudstone clasts. There is no preserved angle-of-repose cross-bedding in sets thicker than about 5 em, nor any other facies indica tive of fluvial deposition. It therefore appears that any fluvial sediment in the valley was completely reworked by waves during initial transgression of the valley. At the same time , the valley walls were probably wave scoured and the valley widened. The
68
R.G. Walker
Fig. 29. Interbedded parallel-laminated sandstones (facies B, centre of figure), bioturbated sandstones and mudstones (facies C), and conglomerates (facies E, in 2nd sleeve) in well 3-27-36-9, 8885-8914 ft. Chert pebbles are up to about 2 em diameter. B =bottom, T =top. Core is 3 in. (7 .6 em) wide, and each core sleeve is 2.5 ft (75 em) long. See comment about handwritten label 'Ricinus bottom' in caption of Fig. 22.
interpretation of the base of the valley as a regressive surface of erosion (ES RSE) applies to the main phase of valley erosion; if the floor and walls of the valley have indeed been modified during trans gression , the surface seen today is strictly a ravine ment surface, or surface of initial transgression (IT) . P alaeogeography
There are no unquestionable data that indicate flow direction in the valley, and the problem of palaeo geography is compounded by the incomplete preser vation of the valley; both ends are faulted. The following indicators, taken together, suggest that the sea lay to the north. First, the valley appears to widen northward (Fig. 10), and the eastern wall becomes less steep. Second, the bed thicknesses of
the structureless and parallel-laminated sandstones decrease northward (Figs 17 & 2 1 ) . Third, conglom erates are best developed at the northern end of the valley (T36 R9, land sections 24-27) , but they are not cross-bedded fluvial conglomerates. They are interbedded with mudstones and sandstones with a marine trace-fossil fauna, suggesting that the pebbles were being moved by waves in the longshore drift system, and introduced into the marine end of the estuary by storms. There are far fewer granules and pebbles associated with the thick structureless sand stones at the southern end of the valley. Finally, the mudstones of facies D have a sharp base with a conglomeratic lag. In the four wells with data avail able , the clast size in the lag decreases progressively southward , from 1 .7 em to about 1 mm. This also suggests marine transgression from north to south, and hence an open sea to the north.
Cardium Formation incised valley
Fig. 30.
Chert granules and pebbles scattered within the bioturbated mudstone facies. Note granules filling distinct burrows (centre), and Zoophycos (Z) in upper part of photograph. Well 3-32-3411, 9050ft. Core is 3 in. (7.6 cm) wide.
Deposition in the Ricinus estuary
Deposition in the Ricinus estuary is not closely comparable with that of any modern estuaries, nor does it conform to any existing estuary models ( Dalrymple et al. , 1992; Reinson , 1992). The absence of angle-of-repose cross-bedding in sets thicker than about 5 em indicates the absence of two- and three dimensional dunes in the estuary. Tide-dominated estuaries (e.g. the Gironde (Allen , 199 1 ) and the Bay of Fundy ( Dalrymple et al . , 1990)) and river dominated estuaries (e.g. the Mgeni (Cooper, 1993))
69
are both dominated by dune bedforms, and presum ably would be dominated by angle-of-repose cross bedding if these estuaries were preserved in the geological record. Such cross-bedding is absent at Ricinus. Wave-dominated estuaries are characterized by a tripartite facies distribution consisting of (i) an upstream river-dominated bayhead delta, (ii) a central basin (turbidity maximum) where mudstones are deposited, and (iii) a downstream, marine dominated area where sand is introduced into the estuary from the sea. This tripartite subdivision is not seen at Ricinus, although this might be due to incomplete preservation of the entire length of the estuary. There is no suggestion of a bayhead delta prograding northward, or marine sands prograding southward; in both cases, sandier upward facies successions would be expected (but are not present) as the sands built on to central basin mudstones. Wave-formed or wave-influenced sedimentary structures (symmetrical ripples, hummocky cross stratification) are rare at Ricinus. As in many modern estuaries, this is probably due to partial closing of the estuary at the seaward end, and limited pen etration of large waves from the sea. Wave base in the Ricinus estuary may therefore have been only a few metres below sea level. The sandstones at Ricinus commonly contain evidence of rapid deposition from strong currents, with no subsequent reworking. Rapid deposition is suggested by the thick, structureless sandstones; some of the flows may have deposited beds thicker than 4 m, mostly at the southern end of the valley (T33 and T34). Other flows continued along the length of the valley to deposit structureless sand stones 50- 150 em thick in T36 and T37 (Fig. 17). The common occurrence of parallel lamination suggests that flows were rapid. The presence of Tahc and Tbe beds (Fig. 18) indicates that some of the rapid flows waned during deposition. Flow distance from the southernmost fault in T32 and T33 to the northern end of the valley (T37) is more than 45 km. The beds that contain only parallel lamination also imply rapid flows, with single depositional events forming beds up to 3 m thick in the south, and about 1 m thick in the north. The preservation of structure less, parallel-laminated, and Tabc and Tbc beds indi cates that there was no wave reworking after the original deposition of the sand. However, the estua1y was not necessarily deep because these facies have been preserved; their preservation may simply reflect the proposed shallow depth to wave base.
70
R.G. Walker
Because there is no evidence for fluvial or tidal facies in the estuary, and no evidence for wave reworking, I suggest that the structureless, parallel laminated, Tabc and Tbc beds were emplaced by density underflows generated at a bayhead delta (not observed) in the southern end of the estuary. Similar underflows appear to have been generated in the estuary of the Congo (Zaire) River (Heezen et al. , 1964) , and finer grained underflows originated from the delta of the Colorado River in Lake Mead and flowed the entire length of the lake (about lOO km; Grover & Howard, 1938). The mudstones of facies C and D appear to occur as a sheet about 4-5 m thick that spreads from end to end of the valley. In many places, the structureless and parallel-laminated sandstones grade vertically into the interbedded bioturbated sandstones and mudstones of facies C (Fig. 22) . However, the mud stones of facies D are characterized by a very sharp base, and a basal layer of chert pebbles and mudstone clasts (Figs 24, 25 & 29) . The trace-fossil fauna of these mudstones is fully marine. I suggest that after deposition of the lower sandstones, the estuary was rapidly flooded, with wave scouring of the substrate, cut-off of sediment input from the fluvial (southern) end of the estuary, introduction of pebbles by storms from the open (northern) end of the estuary, and quiet deposition of mud. Wave scouring in the estuary could have increased during flooding ( deepening ) if the barrier at the seaward end was removed. Deposition of mud was interrupted periodically by storms, introducing sand and pebbles at various stratigraphical horizons within the mudstones. The relationship between the mudstones of facies C and D is not clear. The log response suggests that both facies tend to occur at the same stratigraphical horizon (Fig. 9); however, facies C appears to have gradational contacts with facies A and B, whereas facies D has a distinctly erosional relationship with underlying facies. None of the cores shows facies C and D occurring together, and there is not enough data to determine their possible lateral relationships. After deposition of the sheet of mudstones, sand was again introduced into the estuary, and the same facies occur both above and below the mudstones. Because of the patchy distribution of the mudstones, there is a strong possibility that a falling stage of relative sea-level caused reintroduction of sand into the estuary and local scouring of the mudstones. This is tentatively suggested in Fig. 8. The depth of scouring would be at least 15 m if facies C and D in
well 16-1 6-34-8 (Fig. 8) have been cut out in well 7-16-34-8 (Fig. 8). Examination of sandstone cores adjacent to preserved mudstones showed no lag horizons or facies changes that might indicate scouring. Estuarine deposition was terminated by a final rise of relative sea-level , and the estuary deposits were truncated by ES TSE. There appears to be some topographical relief on this surface, with deeper scouring down to the west (Figs 3 - 5 & 7). The ES TSE surface is typically overlain by a thin lag of chert pebbles (Figs 13, 25 & 29) , and then by transgressive mudstones with thin silty laminations the 'laminated blanket' of Walker, 1983.
VALLEY ORIENTATION
The Ricinus valley trends parallel to the incised shorefaces in the Burnstick (Pattison & Walker, 1992) and Carrot Creek (Bergman & Walker, 1987, 1988) Allomembers (Fig. 1 ) ; an estuary would be expected to be perpendicular. The valley is incised into black mudstones and open marine HCS sand stones and bioturbated mudstones of the Raven River Allomember, and it is the only known incised valley in the Cardium (both in subsurface and out crop). The orientation of the Ricinus valley seems to require that the depositional strike in the basin changed from NW -SE (incised transgressive shore faces associated with E4) , to N E - SW (perpendicular to the Ricinus valley), and back to NW-SE (incised transgressive shorefaces associated with ES). One possibility that has been considered (and rejected) is that the Ricinus valley is a strike-parallel tributary of a main valley that trends SW- NE. The marine end of Ricinus appears to be at the northern end, so the postulated main valley would most likely be north of Ricinus. No such valley is known. It also seems unlikely that the gravel that occurs throughout the section at the northern end of Ricinus could have been emplaced into the main valley, and thence into the Ricinus valley via a right angle turn. The orientation of Ricinus remains enigmatic!
CONCLUSIONS
1 The sand body at Ricinus is defined by bounding discontinuities below and above. The lower discon tinuity defines an incised valley at least 50 km long, 24 m deep and 10 km wide. The valley trends
71
Cardium Formation incised valley
N W- S E , parallel t o regional tectonic trends and parallel to regional shoreline trends in the Cardium. 2 The valley is filled with structureless and parallel laminated sandstones. There are also mudstones that form a layer 4-5 m thick that appears to extend as a sheet along the entire length of the valley. The sheet probably pinches out against the eastern wall of the valley. The mudstones contain a fully marine trace-fossil fauna. 3 The geometry of the valley and distribution of facies suggest that the open sea lay to the north. 4 There is no evidence of fluvial or tidal processes , and wave reworking of the sandstones is rare. At least part of the fill (the structure less sandstones and the Tahc and Tbe beds) appears to have been emplaced by density currents that maintained sand in suspension, and then deposited it very rapidly. The sand was not reworked after its initial deposition. This suggests that the valley was domi nated by input of large amounts of sand from the fluvial end. This sand appears to have slumped, perhaps on a bayhead delta, and then travelled along the estuary as a density underflow. 5 A phase of marine transgression terminated sand input and led to the deposition of a valley-wide layer of marine mudstone. A subsequent drop of relative sea-level led to renewed sand emplacement, prob ably with local scouring of the mudstones. 6 The valley is interpreted as a lowstand incision formed by a river. The fill consists of a variety of facies, but broadly can be termed estuarine. 7 The orientation of a major valley 50 km long, parallel to depositional strike, remains enigmatic.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I began work at Ricinus in 1982 whilst on sabbatical leave at Amoco Canada. I thank the company for their support. Work on this paper commenced in 1993 , and I thank David James and Wascana Energy I nc. for access to well logs. The research has been financially supported by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada, in the form of Operating and Strategic Grants. I particu larly thank James McEachern for his help in ident ifying and explaining the trace fossils. And finally, none of the work would have been possible without the help of Harold Reading; it was Harold who first emphasized to me in 1961 the difference between gradational and abrupt facies contacts, following the thinking of Johannes Walther and anticipating many
of the better ideas now incorporated into allostra tigraphy and sequence stratigraphy.
AP PENDIX
1
Cross-sections
The choice of a datum for the cross-sections is difficult. Possible datums above Ricinus tend to drape over the sand body. The 'Cardium zone marker' (E7 in the cross-sections) commonly used by industry and some other workers is a very bad choice because it is a mappable erosion surface with more than 40 m of relief (Wadsworth & Walker, 1 99 1 ; Figs 4 & 6-8). In this paper I have chosen a group of resistivity signatures A - D in Figs 3-8 that appear to define four sandier upward successions immediately below E4. The top of the 'black blanket' (Figs 4-8) is almost parallel to the sandier upward successions. Together, horizons A - D can be taken to approximate an original , almost fiat, sea-floor, into which the Ricinus valley is incised. All 71 cores have been measured and photo graphed. All of the off-field well-logs west of Ricinus have been used where the Cardium is present and recognizable , but some cannot be used because the rocks west of Ricinus are too deformed. Enough wells north and south of the valley (Fig. 1) have been used to define the ends of the valley, and most of the wells immediately east of the valley (between Ricinus and Caroline) have been used. Only a small proportion of Caroline wells are shown on the map (Fig. 1 ) . The cross-sections show gamma-ray and resistivity well-logs, with cored intervals shown as black bars. Depths are mostly in metres, with depth markers shown at 50-m intervals, but a few older wells are shown in feet (numbers greater than 6000, with depth markers at 100-ft intervals) . In the northern and central parts of the field , a few cores show dipping beds. However, the generally parallel nature of E 1 , successions A - D , and the top of the black blanket, shows that thicknesses in most wells are not seriously distorted by variations in dip. The southern part of the field appears to be more extensively thrusted, with more fracturing of the sandstones in core. Steeply dipping beds in section D can be identified in cores, and in those parts of the well-logs where thicknesses appear to be expanded. I have assumed that in section D (Fig. 6) the eastern most well ( 1 1-25-33-7) is undeformed because the
72
R.G. Walker
thicknesses of various stratigraphical intervals are very similar to those in the other cross-sections. Other wells in section D have been drilled into dipping rocks, and I have therefore reduced the well logs so that the thicknesses of units A - D below E4 are roughly constant across the section.
AP P ENDIX
2
Allostratigraphy
Allostratigraphy first appeared m the North American Stratigraphic Code in 1983 (NACSN , 1983 ) . It does not appear to have been used in the Western Interior Seaway of North America until 1987 (Plint et a!. , 1987, p. 366) , with reference to the unconformity-bounded members of the Cardium Formation proposed by Plint et al. ( 1 986) . An allostratigraphical unit 'is a mappable stratiform body of sedimentary rock that is defined and identified on the basis of its bounding discontinuities' (NACSN, 1983 , p . 865). I suggest (following the definitions of sequence stratigraphy) that this definition be extended to read ' . . . bounding discontinuities and their correlative conformities' . The bounding dis continuities were not defined in the stratigraphical code, but clearly include erosion surfaces (regressive and transgressive surfaces of erosion) , condensed horizons of reduced or zero deposition (commonly maximum flooding surfaces), and firmgrounds and hardgrounds. Allostratigraphy is descriptive, and does not involve any of the interpretive aspects of sequence stratigraphy. It can commonly be applied on a smaller scale than sequence stratigraphy (where a sequence is a 'relatively conformable succession of genetically related strata bounded by unconformities or their correlative conformities'; van Wagoner et al. , 1990, p. 22) . An unconformity was defined as 'a surface separating younger from older strata along which there is evidence of subaerial-erosional trunc ation, or subaerial exposure, with a significant hiatus indicated' (van Wagoner et al. , 1990, p. 22) . In the Cardium , there i s absolutely n o 'evidence of subaerial-erosional truncation' on surfaces E5, E6, E6.5 and E7, although the surfaces are interpreted to have initially formed subaerially. The 'evidence' was entirely removed during erosive shoreface transgression . Sequence stratigraphers are now recognizing the need to subdivide many stratigraphical units on a finer scale, thus giving rise to discussions of 'high-
resolution sequence stratigraphy'. This subdiscipline is converging on allostratigraphy, but unfortunately retains the concept that units are bounded by uncon formities, and that the strata bounded by the uncon formities are 'genetically related' . I n the Cardium (Fig. 2) , the only type 1 sequence boundary, with valley incision, is E5 RSE at Ricinus. If I ignore Ricinus for a moment, it is possible to define a 'sequence' between E4 and E5, by arguing that both are unconformities, and that both developed initially during subaerial exposure (E4, see Pattison & Walker, 1992; E5, see Walker & Eyles, 199 1 ) . The implication is that the rocks between E4 and E5 are 'genetically related' as a sequence. This sequence consists of coarse sand stones and conglomerates deposited in a trans gressing shoreface (Burnstick member, Fig. 2), overlain by black mudstones (the 'black blanket', Fig. 2) and very fine- to fine-grained hummocky cross-stratified sandstones in the upper part of the Raven River Allomember. There is presumably a maximum flooding surface immediately below or j ust within the black blanket. I suggest that on sedimentological grounds, there is absolutely no 'genetic relationship' between the transgressive con glomerates and the overlying (highstand) black mudstones and HCS sandstones. Water depths were very different, as were the wave climates, sediment transport processes and grain sizes of available sedi ment. The salinities may also have been different. Thus sequence stratigraphy is not the most appro priate technique for descriptive subdivision of a unit like the Cardium. Allostratigraphy does not involve problems of defining terms such as unconformity , genetically related, and evidence of subaerial erosional truncation, and allows the Cardium to be subdivided using bounding discontinuities (however they formed). The most useful bounding discon tinuities are the transgressive surfaces of erosion (E4, E5 TSE, etc. ) , and the flooding surfaces that j uxtapose relatively offshore quietly deposited mud stones on top of nearshore conglomerates (Fig. 25). The allostratigraphical units so defined correspond to transgressive systems tracts (the Burnstick Allomember and its correlative conglomerate lag on E4) and highstand systems tracts (the Raven River Allomember) ; these systems tracts do contain 'genetically related' strata. The Ricinus sand body is also defined by two bounding discontinuities; E5 RSE and E5 TSE. It is therefore defined in this paper as the Ricinus Allomember of the Cardium Alloformation. It is
73
Cardium Formation incised valley
genetically distinct both from the highstand deposits of the Raven River, and the transgressive deposits of the Carrot Creek Allomembers. The scale of allostratigraphical subdivision, like that of lithostratigraphical subdivision , is left to the discretion of the individual worker. In the Cardium , the transgressive surfaces of erosion are complicated by the fact that in many places there appear to be stillstands of sea-level during the overall trans gression. Incised shorefaces are cut during these stillstands. The shoreface is floored by the initial surface of transgression (IT), and is truncated by a surface of resumed transgression ( RT) (Fig. 2, Burnstick Allomember ) . However, the RT surface will pass laterally into another IT surface if there is another stillstand during the transgression (Fig. 2). Thus the two Burnstick sand bodies shown in Fig. 2 are defined by different bounding discontinuities, and hence would qualify as different allomembers. Such fine subdivision seems unnecessary at present; the erosional envelope beneath the sand bodies can be regarded as one bounding discontinuity, as can the contact between the RT surfaces and the over lying transgressive mudstones. Thus the Burnstick Allomember (and the Carrot Creek Allomember) consist of a series of separate sand bodies at slightly different stratigraphical horizons, but all developed during one overall phase of transgression. My final comment on allostratigraphy concerns names. The stratigraphical code does not address this problem - it simply states that 'the principles and procedures for naming allostratigraphical units are the same as those for naming of lithostratigraphi cal units' (NACSN, 1983 , p. 867). The Cardium Formation is a formally defined lithostratigraphical unit. Some workers have suggested that if an allo stratigraphical scheme is to be used, the term Cardium Alloformation is forbidden because Cardium has already been used. It is clear that if existing names are banned, the number of names will double if existing units are subdivided allo stratigraphically. This is ridiculous. I do not believe that the term Cardium Alloformation is in any way confusing. It is defined as those rocks between E l and the top of the transgressive lag o n E7, and encompasses roughly the same rocks as the Cardium Formation. It has the advantage of emphasizing a natural break in sedimentation, whereas the base of the Cardium Formation is defined at the incoming of sandstones at some arbitrary point within the first sandier upward succession. There is room for both a Cardium Formation and a Cardium Alloformation.
Alloformations and allomembers will commonly be heterogeneous, encompassing both horizontal and vertical facies changes. Thus the concept of formally defining a 'type section' needs to be re-evaluated. Also, any formal definition of an allo stratigraphical unit must include descriptions of the bounding discontinuities, so that they can be recog nized by other workers.
AP PENDIX
3
P reparation of computer maps
It has not been possible to restore all of the thrusts that displace sandstones within the field. Conse quently, some of the wells penetrate sandstones that have been thrust northeastward, and some thickness may be slightly exaggerated if the well penetrates dipping strata. The effect of exaggerated thickness is reduced in the mapping because SU RFER calculates each grid-point using data from the 10 closest wells using a kriging method. Thus the thickness distor tions are probably not great, but the maps should be stretched southwestward in the reader's imagination to allow for the foreshortening due to thrusting. It can be seen in Fig. 1 that the main sand body as defined by drilling density does not seem to be displaced laterally by the faults that define the southernmost three compartments. In my data base, the locations of the wells in the northern compart ment have been shifted about 4 km southwestward to bring them on line with the rest of the field; off field wells to the southwest were also shifted, but off-field wells to the northeast were not relocated.
REFERENCES
ALLEN, G.P. (1991) Sedimentary processes and facies in the Gironde estuary: a recent model for macrotidal estuarine systems. In: Clastic Tidal Sedimentology (Eds Smith, D.G . , Reinson. G.E. , Zaitlin, B . A . & Rahmani, R.A.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol . , Calgary, Memoir 16, 29- 40. BERGMAN, K . M. & WA L KER , R.G. (1987) The importance of sea level fluctuations in the formation of linear con glomerate bodies: Carrot Creek Member, Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, Alberta, Canada. J. sediment. Petrol. , 57, 65 1 - 665. BERG MA N , K . M. & WALKER, R.G. (1988) Formation of Cardium erosion surface E5, and associated deposition of conglomerate; Carrot Creek field, Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, Alberta. In: Sequences, Stratigraphy, Sedimentology: Surface and Subswface (Eds James, D.P.
74
R. G. Walker
& Leckie, D.A.). Can. Soc. petrol. Geol . , Calgary, Memoir 15, 15-24. B o u M A , A.H. ( 1 982) Sedimentology of some Flysch Deposits. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 168 pp. CooPER, J .A.G. ( 1993) Sedimentation in a river dominated estuary. Sedimentology, 40, 979- 1 0 1 7 . DALRYMPLE, R.W., KNIGHT, R.J . , ZAITLIN , B.A. & MIDDLETON , G. V . ( 1 990) Dynamics and facies model of a macrotidal sand-bar complex, Cobequid Bay - Salmon River · estuary, Bay of Fundy, Canada. Sedimentology, 37, 577- 6 1 2 . DALRYMPLE, R.W. , ZAITLIN , B.A. & BoYD, R. ( 1992) Estuarine facies models: conceptual basis and strati graphic implications. J. sediment. Petrol. , 62, 1 1 30- 1 146. GEOLOGICAL S U RVEY OF CANADA ( 198 1a) Gas Pools of Western Canada. Geol. Surv. Canada, Map 1558A, Ottawa. GEOLOGICAL S u RVEY OF CANADA ( 1981b) Oil Pools of Western Canada. Geol. Surv. Canada, Map 1558B, Ottawa. GROVER, N.C. & HowARD, C.S. ( 1938) The passage of turbid water through Lake Mead. Trans Am. Soc. civ. Eng. , 103, 720- 790. HAMBLIN, A.P. & WALKER, R.G. ( 1979) Storm-dominated shallow marine deposits: the Fernie-Kootenay (Jurassic) transition, southern Rocky Mountains. Can. J. Earth Sci. , 16, 1673- 1690. HEEZEN, B.C., MENZIES, R.J . , SCHNEIDER, E. D . , EWING, W.M. & GRANELLI, N.C.L. ( 1964) Congo submarine fan. Bull. Am. Assoc. petrol. Geol. , 48, 1 126- 1 149. McEACHER N , J.A. & PEMBERTO N , S. G. ( 1992) lchnological aspects of Cretaceous shoreface successions and shore face variability in the Western I nterior Seaway of North America. In: Applications of Ichnology to Petroleum Exploration; a Core Workshop (Ed. Pemberton, S. G. ) Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Tulsa, Core Workshop 1 7 , 57-84. NACSN ( N ORTH AMERICAN COMMISSION ON STRATIGRAPHIC NoMENCLATURE ) ( 1 983) North American stratigraphic code. Bull. Am. Assoc. petrol. Geol. , 67, 84 1 -875. PATTISO N , S. A.J. & WALKER, R. G. ( 1992) D eposition and interpretation of long, narrow sand bodies underlain by a basinwide erosion surface: Cardium Formation, Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, Alberta, Canada. J. sediment. Petrol. , 62, 292-309. PEMBERTO N , S. G. & FREY, R.W. ( 1984) I chnology of storm influenced shallow marine sequence: Cardium For-
mation (Upper Cretaceous) at Seebe, Alberta. In: The Mesozoic of Middle North America (Eds Stott, D.F. & Glass, D.J.) Can. Soc. petrol. Geol . , Calgary, Memoir 9, 281 -304. PuNT, A.G. & WALKER, R. G. ( 1987) Cardium Formation 8. Facies and environments of the Cardium shoreline and coastal plain in the Kakwa field and adjacent areas, northwestern Alberta. Bull. Can. petrol. Geol. , 35, 48-64. PUNT, A. G., WALKER, R.G. & BERGMAN, K.M. ( 1986) Cardium Formation 6. Stratigraphic framework of the Cardium in subsurface. Bull. Can. petrol. Geol. , 33, 2 1 3-225 . PUNT, A. G., WALKER, R.G. & BERGMA N , K.M. ( 1 987) Cardium Formation 6. Stratigraphic framework of the Cardium in subsurface: Reply. Bull. Can. petrol. Geol. , 35, 365-374. REINSON, G.E. ( 1 992) Transgressive barrier island and estuarine systems. In: Facies Models - Response to Sea Level Change (Eds Walker, R.G. & J ames, N.P. ) . pp. 179- 194. Geological Association o f Canada. VAN WAGONER, J.C., MITCHUM, R. M. , CAMPION, K.M. & RAHMANIAN , V.D. ( 1990) Siliciclastic Sequence Stra tigraphy in Well Logs, Cores, and Outcrops. American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, Methods in Exploration Series, 7 , 55 pp. WADSWORTH, J.A. & WALKER, R.G. ( 1 99 1 ) Morphology and origin of erosion surfaces in the Cardium Formation (Upper Cretaceous, Western Interior Seaway, Alberta) and their implications for rapid sea level fluctuations. Can. J. Earth Sci. , 28 , 1507- 1520. WALKER, R. G. ( 1983) Sedimentology and stratigraphy in the Caroline-Garrington area, Bull. Can. petrol. Geol. , 3 1 , 2 1 3 -230. WALKER, R.G. ( 1 985) Cardium Formation at Ricinus Field, Alberta: a channel cut and filled by turbidity currents in the Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway. Bull. Am. Assoc. petrol. Geol. , 69, 1963- 198 1 . WALKER, R.G. & EYLES, C.H. ( 1988) Geometry and facies of stacked shallow marine sandier upward sequences dissected by erosion surface: Cardium Formation, Willesden Green, Alberta. Bull. Am. Assoc. petrol. Geol. , 72, 1469- 1494. WALKER, R. G. & EYLES, C.H. ( 199 1 ) Topography and significance of a basinwide sequence-bounding erosion surface in the Cretaceous Cardium Formation, Alberta, Canada. J. sediment. Petrol. , 61, 473-496.
Spec. Pubis in!. Ass. Sediment. (1995) 22, 75-99
Gravelly shoreface and beachface deposits B R U C E S . H A R T* L and A . G UY P Ll N T"! *Geological Survey of Canada, Box 6000, Sidney, British Columbia VBL 4B2, Canada; and "I Department of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario N6A 5B7, Canada
ABSTRACT
Modern gravel-dominated shoreface deposits are poorly documented, especially from progradational settings. This makes the interpretation of possible ancient analogues very difficult. In the absence of unique diagnostic features, ancient conglomeratic shoreface deposits may be identified on the basis of: (i) the inferred relationship between sedimentary process and deposit, based on sedimentary structures, fabric and texture of the deposit, palaeocurrent data, etc . ; (ii) vertical and lateral successions of facies; (iii) gross morphology of a deposit; and (iv) stratigraphical setting. Much more is known about gravelly beachface deposits because modern analogues are easily accessible. Several distinct 'end-member' types of gravelly shorcface/beachface deposits can be recognized: (i) river mouth bar deposits, which show evidence of rapid deposition, scouring, reworking by waves and (possibly) post-depositional failure; (ii) mixed sand-gravel systems in which sedimentary structures within the sandstones allow determination of depositional environment; (iii) swash-aligned gravelly systems dominated by ncar-perpendicular wave approaches, which show shore-normal facies zonation; (iv) driji-aligned gravelly systems , which show evidence of pronounced longshore transport generated by oblique wave incidence; and (v) transgressive lag deposits. Observations and interpretations of ancient conglomeratic shorefore deposits raise process-related questions that have yet to be addressed by studies of modern equivalents.
INTRODUCTION
depositional environments must rely on interpret ation of the processes which gave rise to the observed lithofacies , and relating these interpreted processes to stratigraphical context, partially analogous modern environments, and the three-dimensional morphology of the deposit. Progradational gravel-dominated shoreface and beachface systems are not common, and are rarely documented. Three 'end-member' settings for grav elly shorefaces may be identified. The first involves areas of active erosion of coastal bedrock outcrops (e.g. Zenkovitch , 1967; Ogren & Waag, 1986). The second setting is in high-latitude areas that were subject to Pleistocene glaciation (e.g. Forbes & Taylor, 1987 ) . There, gravel can be derived from tills, outwash deposits, or other coarse-grained sub- to proglacial deposits. Thirdly, progradational
It is commonly accepted that one of the most fruitful approaches to facies analysis involves comparison of modern sedimentary environments and potential ancient analogues. This approach, based on the uniformitarian principle that the present is the key to the past, forms the basis of most texts dealing with facies models and its roots can be traced back for at least a century to Johannes Walther. Walther advocated an 'actualistic' approach to the examin ation of ancient sedimentary deposits, but knew that ancient facies might exist which have no direct modern analogues (Middleton, 1973) . In such cases, as explained by Reading (1986), reconstruction of 1 Present address: Department of Geosciences, Penn sylvania State University, U niversity Park, Pennsylvania 168 02, USA.
Sedimentary Facies Analysis: A Tribute to the Research and Teaching of Harold G. Reading Edited by A. Guy Plint © 1995 The International Association of Sedimentologists ISBN: 978-0-865-42898-0
75
76
B.S. Hart and A . G. Plint
gravelly coastlines may develop where the shoreline is adjacent to uplands yielding abundant coarse grained sediment. Most modern examples of such coastlines are associated with fan-deltas. In fan delta settings, gravelly shorefaces develop in a 'tran sition zone' between alluvial plain and offshore settings (e .g. Wescott & Ethridge, 1980) . Holocene sea-level rise has inhibited widespread develop ment of progradational systems, and therefore most studies of modern gravelly coasts have involved transgressive gravelly shorelines along bedrock coasts and in glaciated areas. Given the relative scarcity of gravel dominated coastal deposits, and the logistical difficulties involved in their investigation, it is no surprise that modern gravel-dominated shorefaces represent a type of environment that has received very little attention from sedimentologists. Modern gravel beachfaces have been the object of considerable study (Bluck , 1967; Carr, 1969; Dobkins & Fol k , 1970; Carter & Orford , 1984; Forbes & Taylor, 1987 ) , but there have been very few studies of the movement of pebble-sized material on the shoreface (Neate, 1967; Mathews, 1980; Gillie, 1983) and the nature of sedimentary structures present on modern gravelly shorefaces is poorly documented. Studies of gravel on modern inner shelves (e.g. Gillie, 1983; Forbes & Boyd, 1987) are helpful in this regard , and gravels have also been reported from modern sand dominated shorefaces (e . g . Hunter et a/., 1979; Shipp, 1984; Ross & Long, 1989 ) . Ancient conglomeratic shoreface/inner shelf deposits have been recognized in outcrop (e.g. Clifton, 1973, 198 1 ; Leckie & Walker, 1982; Leithold & Bourgeois, 1984; Leckie, 1988; Massari & Parea, 1988; Cheel & Leckie, 1992) but in most of these cases, pebble-size material forms a small pro portion of a sand-dominated sedimentary deposit. Kleinspehn et a!. ( 1984), Massari & Parea ( 1988) and Massari et a!. ( 1 986) described progradational shoreface and beachface gravels associated with fan delta settings. Conglomerates have been described using subsur face data (Bergman & Walker, 1987; Arnott, 199 1 ) and interpreted a s shoreface deposits o n the basis of stratigraphical position and the geometry of the conglomerate bodies as a whole. Ancient con glomeratic beachface deposits are clearly recogniz able, both in outcrop and core (e.g. Nemec & Steel 1984; Plint & Walker 1987; Postma & Nemec, 1990) . This paper will review the sedimentology of gravel dominated shoreface and beachface deposits. M uch
of the data presented was drawn from studies of conglomerates in the Upper Cretaceous Cardium Formation of western Canada (Piint & Hart, 1988; Hart & Plint, 1989, 1 99 1 ; Hart, 1990, 199 1 ) . In the Cardium Formation, sedimentological studies are complemented by extensive stratigraphical studies (e.g. Plint et a!., 1986; Bergman & Walker, 1987; Hart, 1990; Hart & Plint , 1993a ) . This work has demonstrated that the chert-pebble conglomerates in the Cardium were deposited many tens to hun dreds of kilometres basinward of any potential source -they are therefore not interpretable as alluvial fan or fan-delta deposits.
SEDIMENT TRANSPORT PROCESSES
There is considerable disagreement between authors and between disciplines (e.g. geologists and coastal geomorphologists and engineers) about the termin ology used to describe coastal zonation. The shore face is defined here as the broadly concave-upward zone where sediment is transported by wave pro cesses on a regular basis (i.e. between low-tide level and 'fair-weather wave base'; Fig. 1). The upper portion of the shoreface is the region of breaking waves (surf ) or 'nearshore zone' of coastal geomor phologists (see Komar, 1976; Dubois, 1992 ) . The lower shoreface extends seaward from the breaker zone to the depth at which shoaling surface gravity waves no longer entrain sediment (sometimes des cribed as the 'transition zone' between the nearshore and offshore; Komar, 1976; Dubois, 1992). In the stratigraphical record , the vertical transition from interbedded sandstones and mudstones to thick sand stones (and/or conglomerates) in ancient prograding shoreline successions is typically defined as the tran sition from inner shelf to shoreface deposition (e.g. Plint & Walker, 1987 ) . The width and maximum water depth of the shoreface and nearshore are a complex function of sea-floor slope, wave climate and tides, all of which vary between sites and over the course of time at any given site (Wright & Short, 1984) . The beachface comprises that region between low-tide level and the landward limit of wave action (Fig. 1 ) . There exists abundant literature concerning shoreface and beachface processes (e.g. Zenkovitch, 1967; Komar, 1976; Niedoroda et a/., 1985; Carter, 1988) , and an extended discussion will not be presented here. Numerical analysis of the relationship between flow parameters and the movement of gravel in
Gravelly shorefaces
77
SHOREFACE
�....:::--
Swash ------------------- limit
--
����-----�--�Depth at breaker zone
Fairweather
Mean low tide
wave base
Fig. l. Schematic diagram showing coastal zone terminology used in this paper.
shallow marine settings has not advanced to the point where predictive estimates of sediment trans port can be made confidently. This shortcoming can be related both to the logistical problems of working in the high-energy shoreface zone and the problems inherent in understanding the movement of pebble size materials in general (see below). Bulk textural properties of a deposit, clast form and fabric all appear to play important roles, which are not (yet) fully quantifiable. Williams et al. ( 1989 ) , for exam ple, used sophisticated instrument packages to study the movement of marine gravels, yet felt compelled to state that 'caution is required if attempting to deduce bedload transport rates for marine gravels with significantly different grain size distribution or in flow regimes radically different from the present' . Given these uncertainties, only a qualitative over view of the subject will be presented in this section. Shoreface processes
In a general way, there are three main forces respon sible for sediment transport on the shoreface. These are: (i) wave motion; (ii) currents induced by shoaling waves; and (iii) other currents. During wave shoaling, progressive distortion of sinusoidal deep-water waves results in the forward motion under the wave crest becoming shorter but faster, and the backward motion under the trough becoming longer and slower. This time-velocity asymmetry has important consequences for sedi ment. As described by Zenkovitch ( 1967) and Bruun ( 1988) , the shoreface profile is a function of sediment grain size and wave type (height, wavelength, period, form ) . For any particle resting on the shoreface there are forces acting to move the particle upslope (stronger but shorter landward motion under the crest) and downslope (slower but lon2:er seaward
motion under the trough, plus gravity) . For a given grain size, slope and wave conditions, there will exist a point at which the upslope and downslope forces are balanced, and forward motion will equal the backward motion . Seaward of this point, sediment will migrate offshore, whereas further landward, sediment will migrate onshore. This effect is grain size dependent: for the same wave conditions and bottom slope, fine-grained sediments may move off shore whereas coarse-grained sediments move onshore (Zenkovitch, 1967) . When a mix of grain · sizes is available on the sea-floor, a graded profile can be developed with large particles moving onshore and smaller particles offshore (Zenkovitch, 1967 , p. 1 15 ) . Shoreface profiles are a function o f several factors, including wave height, period and sediment grain size. Although gravelly systems appear to respond less quickly to changes in wave regime than their sandy counterparts (Carter, 1988), Hart & Plint (1989) concluded that gravel on the shoreface at Chesil Beach moved offshore during storms then onshore during fair-weather conditions. Gillie ( 1983) described both onshore and offshore movement of gravel on the inner shelf in response to differing wave conditions. Kidson & Carr ( 1959) used radioactively 'tagged' pebbles and found that at some critical (but undefined) distance offshore, pebble movement was very limited (even during storms) and exchange of gravel between the shoreface and shelf did not occur. I ntuitively, this 'critical' distance must be related to the depth at which oscillatory wave motion can initiate movement, and is therefore a function of sediment size, submarine slope and wave climate. Longshore currents (sensu stricto) are generated over the upper shoreface by the dissipation of the longshore component of energy in breaking waves. The upper shoreface, owing to the high energy levels
78
B.S. Hart and A. G. Plint
and potential for unidirectional longshore currents, is considered to be a major sediment transport zone for coarse-grained sediments (e.g. Carter & Orford, 199 1 ) . Rip currents are another type of current induced by breaking waves. Channels can be excavated by these seaward flows (Davidson-Arnott & Greenwood, 1976; Gruszcyriski et a!., 1993) and pebbles and even boulders can be transported off shore (Zenkovitch, 1967; Gruszczynski et a!., 1993 ) . In sandy settings, coarser material accumulates as lags in the base of the rip channels (Davidson-Arnott & Greenwood, 1976; Hunter et a!., 1979). Rip cur rents are not typically well developed on steep, 'reflective' shorelines such as those associated with most modern gravelly shorelines (Carter, 1988) . However, it must be remembered that these are generally transgressive systems and progradational shorelines may have different profiles. Tidal, wind-induced and fluvial currents may also transport sediment on the shoreface . In wave dominated settings, perhaps the most important role of tides is to change water depth and hence the geographical limits of the surf and swash zones (Ross & Long, 1 989) . Currents generated by coastal set-up (with onshore winds) flow offshore along the sea-floor in the shoreface zone, and thus enhance offshore sediment transport during storms (Niedoroda et at., 1985). Close to river mouths, interaction of fluvial and shoreface processes is to be expected. Gravity-driven mass transport processes may occur in 'mouth bar' settings (Kleinspehn et a!., 1984) as rapid deposition leads to oversteepening and resultant instability.
Finally, in some settings, seaweed can enhance both landward and seaward transport (Woodborne et a!., 1989 , and references therein ) , although the geological significance of this process is hard to assess. Pebbles and shell material attached to hold fasts are commonly observed along beaches adjacent to seaweed beds (Fig. 2 ) . Seaweed communities are best developed along rocky or gravelly coasts in cool waters of high latitudes (Carter, 1988). Once trans ported out of its initial habitat, the plant dies and decays, leaving no lasting trace of the holdfast on the clast. Woodborne et a!. ( 1 989) reported kelp rafting of a 30-kg boulder, and kelp rafted pebbles in 350 m water, 120 km offshore, and also reported that about 15% of the kelp along the South African coast is torn from the bottom during storms each year. If only 1% of the algae carried clasts, pebble transport by this process could be 'significant' over geological time (Woodborne et a!., 1989 ) . Beachface processes
Beachface processes along gravelly coasts are better documented than those below low-tide level. The roughness of gravel beachfaces can reduce the velo city and distance travelled by the swash, relative to sandy systems (Carter, 1988). The high porosity and permeability and low water table of gravelly beaches also reduces the run-up distance of swash, and reduces or eliminates backwash by allowing water to freely percolate into _the sediment. When the water table is high, for example during falling tides or storms, surface clasts on the beachface are more susceptible to movement by wave swash and back-
Fig. 2. Clasts attached to seaweed holdfasts on a transgressive shoreline, Island View Beach, British Columbia. Lens cap for scale.
Gravelly shorefaces wash . Forbes & Taylor ( 1 987) reported that beach morphology is sensitive to the amount of sand in the system. Oblique swash motion on the beachface , generated by oblique wave approach , transports clasts alongshore, with grains returning directly sea ward during the backwash. This alongshore 'zig-zig' motion should not be confused with longshore cur rents in the surf zone, even though both processes transport clasts along the shoreline. Overwash may be important during storms on some gravel barrier systems (Carter & Orford , 198 1 , 1984) . Pebble-filled streams and drainage rills (developed by groundwater flow during falling tide) may cut
Fig.
3. Streams cutting across beachface. (A) Pebble-lined stream cutting across sandy beachface, China Beach, British Columbia. Note steep, locally overhanging channels walls. View toward back beach area. Note 'pulse' of gravel in background being transported seaward through the channel. (B ) Large drainage rills incised into Chesil Beach, England.
79
across sandy beaches (Clifton et al., 1973; Fig. 3A) . The permeability of gravel-dominated systems tends to limit the development of such small channels, although they may nevertheless develop (Fig. 3 B ) . Bluck ( 1 967) suggested that particles can b e trans ported through the sediment body in certain portions of coarse-grained beachfaces. Bluck suggested that the backwash percolating through the gravel appeared to 'flush' finer particles seaward. How ever, unless the beach consisted of an open, clast supported framework of pebbles and cobbles, the sieving process is unlikely to operate.
80
B.S. Hart and A . G. Plint GRAIN SIZE AND SHAPE
As with sandy deposits, the textural characteristics of gravels reflect the processes responsible for their deposition. Unfortunately, gravels do not readily lend themselves to the same types of routine size analyses as sands, and therefore much less is known about their grain-size distribution. On the other hand , the size of gravels makes them much more amenable to analysis of clast shape, usually expressed as form indices derived from measurement of long ( L), intermediate (!) and short ( S) axes. As noted in the preceding section, accurate predictions of entrainment velocity are very difficult to quantify as a result of sorting and clast shape effects. Textural trends
The threshold conditions for movement of a given clast depend not only on flow parameters but also on clast shape, fabric of the deposit and the size of the grain relative to that of the host deposit (Komar & Li , 1986) . Although the largest clasts are sometimes used to evaluate flow competence , such grains on the surface of a deposit project higher into the flow and are thus subjected to higher shear stress than the bulk of the sediment. Komar ( 1 987) suggested that flow competence is therefore best evaluated by relating the bed shear stress and the ratio of the diameter of the largest clast to the median diameter of the deposit as a whole . Maejima ( 1 982) found, however, that mean grain size and D10 show very similar trends across gravelly beaches, lending some justification to the use of D10 (D10 =intermediate diameter of the 10 largest clasts ) . Williams & Caldwell ( 1 988) suggested that the short axis of clasts was the most 'hydraulically sensitive' length on gravel beaches. Further investigation appears warranted. In the previous section it was noted that graded shoreface profiles are expected to develop under equilibrium conditions, with larger clasts moving onshore. A vertical section through a progradational shoreface deposit might therefore display an upward coarsening trend . To date, the only attempt to quan tify such a trend appears to be the work presented by Hart & Plint ( 199 1 ) on the Bay Tree outcrop of the Cardium Formation. Representative measured sections through two, well-exposed examples of grav elly shoreface deposits in the Cardium Formation are presented in Fig. 4. Vertical trends in L (long axis length) , I (intermediate axis length) , S (short
axis length) and D10 from two measured sections at the Bay Tree locality are shown in Fig. 5. Regression lines from D10 in section BT2, and L and I from both sections have positive slopes, indicative of an up-section increase in grain size, and high correlation coefficients. These results suggest that upward coarsening trends (not necessarily 'recognized' by D10) may develop on some gravelly shorefaces, although the lack of a distinguishable trend for the S axis suggests that this dimension may not have been hydrodynamically significant at Bay Tree. Dupre et al. ( 1980) , in a study of a Pleistocene, mixed sandy and gravelly shoreface system, reported that the coarsest clasts were to be found within deposits of the upper surf zone. A comparable up section increase in the thickness, abundance and lateral continuity of conglomerate beds in sandstone dominated shoreface deposits can be seen in some sections of the Cardium Formation (Fig. 6). Some studies of beachface deposits indicate that the coarsest sediments are found on the uppermost (landward) part of the beachface (Biuck, 1967; Kirk, 1980; Massari & Parea, 1988) , suggesting that upward-coarsening trends should develop in pro gradational systems. Maejima ( 1982 ) , however, reported that the coarsest sediment was present in a zone of berm accretion on the beachface. In mixed sand-gravel systems, the plunge point (at the toe of the beach during fair-weather conditions) may also be a position where coarse sediment accumulates (Dupre et al., 1980; Kirk, 1980; Short, 1984). Well sorted and stratified very coarse sandstones and granule conglomerates are present as beachface deposits in the Cardium Formation (Piint & Walker, 1987; Arnott, 199 1 ) . Gravelly shorefaces and beaches may reveal along shore trends in grain size generally taken to represent downdrift fining. Two examples from outcrops of the Cardium Formation show that such trends may not always be clear (Fig. 7 ) . Pattison & Walker ( 1992) used along-strike grain-size variations to infer sediment dispersal direction in pebbly sandstone shoreface deposits of the Cardium Formation in the subsurface. This type of trend was inferred to develop in response to preferential longshore trans port of finer grades, with smaller clasts 'out running' coarser sizes. Although such processes are docu mented from modern settings, Carter ( 1988) has emphasized that downdrift coarsening may also develop under some circumstances. Gravels and conglomerates typically consist of at least two grain-size classes of material, gravel clasts
Gravelly shorefaces
81
BT7
BT6 BT2
E
0
Ravinement Surface (Hart & Plint 1993a)
---r-t:l;;;;::--..:.o
A
MNA·IO
MNA·9
, __
0
B
Fig.
.-�Channelized base
/
4. Measured sections of Cardium Formation. (A) Shoreface conglomerates at Bay Tree (Alberta), represented by seven measured sections along cliff face oriented nearly parallel to depositional strike. Total distance between BT7 and BT4 about 300m. Nearly constant thickness along strike suggests tabular geometry. Beach face deposits are preserved at top of BT7. (B) Shoreface/mouth-bar conglomerates at Elephant Ridge (British Columbia) . Sections measured along diff face at slight angle to depositional strike. Total distance along strike about 200m. Note suggestion of channel form, with conglomerates scouring into u nderlying swaley cross-stratified shoreface sandstones. Sections hung on coarse-grained wave rippled surface inferred to be a nearly planar marine flooding surface (Hart, 1990) . Facies codes: A, clast-supported pebble conglomerate; B, imbricated clast-supported conglomerate; C, graded conglomerates; D, decimetre-thick cross-bedded conglomerates; E, matrix-supported conglomerate; F, interstratified conglomerate and sandstone (beachface deposits); G, amalgamated conglomerates; H, matrix-supported pebbly granule conglomerate; I, poorly sorted pebbly sandstones with localized shallow scour-fill conglomerates; 16, swaley cross-stratified sandstones; 17, cross-bedded sandstones, locally pebbly.
82
�• • • • I � iJ !IL�I � (A) BT2
100 80 60 0 40 � 2 o
0�
-----
�
�
.g
I
I
B.S. Hart and A. G. Plint
•• • ••
(B) BT7
•
I
100
: jJ�� • r: .. � �••• • I = r: I
"' c 0
·o;
100 80 E 60 40 20 I 0 o 25
. .
X
�
•
. ..
100 80
�
•
.
_,
.
.
..
I
50
0
75
100
L_ ..1. I __JI _..1. ----=L " O _25- 50_ 7 5 _ 100
Non-dimensional height above base
and sand and/or mud matrix. The proportion of each defines whether the deposit is open framework (lacking matrix completely) , clast supported (clasts in contact with spaces infilled by matrix) or matrix supported (clasts 'floating' in matrix). These differ ences can have significant economic importance, as they directly affect reservoir properties such as porosity and permeability (e.g. Clarke, 1979; Cant & Ethier, 1984; Arnott, 1991). There is a consensus that shoreface and beachface conglomerates tend to be better sorted than fluvial conglomerates, and that sand and gravel tend to be better segregated in deposits of shallow marine environments (e.g. Emery, 1955; Clifton, 1973). It has been suggested that rapid deposition of sand and gravel in fluvial deposits may produce pebbly sands, whereas prolonged reworking of a mixture of sand and gravel by waves will tend to segregate the two constituents (Clifton, 1973). Well-sorted, clast supported conglomerates are common in shoreface conglomerates at the Bay Tree locality and elsewhere in the Cardium Formation (Figs 4 & SA & B ) . Arnott (1991) examined a linear conglomerate body of the Cardium in the subsurface. Although dominantly clast-supported, matrix-supported con glomerates were also present but tended to be con centrated preferentially along the landward margin
Fig.
5. Trends in non-dimensional L, S, I, and 010 versus non dimensional height above base from two sections at Bay Tree , Alberta. See text for explanation. Relative section locations shown in Fig. 4A.
of the body. The matrix-supported conglomerates were interpreted to have been deposited in the vicinity of fluvial distributary mouths. Although these results and others suggest that texture (in particular sorting) is a valuable tool for discriminating between fluvial and littoral conglom erates, texture alone cannot be used to distinguish between fluvial and shoreface conglomerates (Nemec & Steel, 1984). Matrix- or clast-support of conglomerates should not be considered diagnostic of, respectively, fluvial and littoral deposits. For example, Howell & Link (1979) found that, in the Eocene of California, non-marine conglomerates tended to be clast-supported (in places open frame-· work), whereas wave-influenced deposits include both clast- and matrix-supported conglomerates. Leithold & Bourgeois (1984), N ielsen et al. (1988) and Massari & Parea (1988) have also reported matrix-supported conglomerates interpreted to have been deposited in a shoreface setting. Studies of fluvial conglomerates suggest that they too are typi·· cally clast supported (Harms et al., 1982). Low·· wave-energy shorelines may lack sufficient energy to effect wave segregation of sand- and pebble-size material. Finally, the nature of the sediment supplied to the shoreline (ratio of sand to gravel, fluctuations of this ratio through time) and sediment transport
CJ ;:; '<:: "'
� "' ;::.. 0
� .,
8
Fig. 6. Up-section increase in thickness of shallow, pebbly scour fills in swaley cross-stratified shoreface sandstones from a single outcrop of Cardium Formation at Cutbank Lake, Alberta. Photographs (A)-(D) represent a vertical interval of about 6 m . Conglomerates are interpreted as rip-current and longshore trough deposits. Pocket knife (arrowed) for scale.
00 w
84
B.S. Hart and A. G. Plint
N
Vl c 0 ·.::; "'
>
Q;
Vl .c 0 .....
0
Q;
.c
E
::J z
BT4 A
9
I
q C? I
9
s
MNA-10
N
20 30 40 50 60 70
010 (mm)
MNA-9
infiltrate? Comparison of the size of clasts inferred to have been rolled on the bed with the size of the sand in the matrix is sometimes used as a starting point (Harms et al., 1982) . The application of this approach to shoreface conglomerates is difficult because: (i) shallow marine settings are typified by combined flows (especially during significant sedi ment transport events such as storms) and criteria for the threshold of movement under such conditions are not easily established (especially for gravels), and (ii) this approach is probably not valid for high sediment concentrations or transport rates such as might typify the surf zone. Textural evidence can sometimes provide clues as to the origin of the matrix. For example, in the Cardium Formation at Bay Tree, a sandy matrix is common in clast-supported shoreface conglomerates but is typically absent from adjacent finer (granule or fine pebble) conglomerates (Fig. SA) . This may suggest that the sand was able to infiltrate the larger pore throats of the coarser deposits but not through the more restricted openings between smaller clasts.
· MNA-8
MNA-6
Clast shape MNA-4
MNA-3
s
MNA-2
10 B
20
30
40
010 (mm)
50
Fig. 7. Longshore trends in D10 in shoreface conglomerates of Cardium Formation at: (A) Bay Tree and (B) Elephant Ridge (Mount Niles), showing a weak, southeasterly fining trend, which, based on regional palaeocurrent data (Hart, 1990; Hart et a/., 1990) is the dominant longshore transport direction. Each 'observation' at Bay Tree corresponds to a D10 value calculated from individual beds in each section. The D10 values at Elephant Ridge represent averaged values for each measured section. The location of sampling points is shown in Fig. 4A & B .
mode (see next section) must also be considered. Carter & Orford (1991) emphasized that episodic supply can induce textural changes that are inde pendent of process regime. The origin of a sandy matrix in a conglomerate can be p