Short Story Writers Revised Edition
MAGILL’S C H O I C E
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
Volume 1 Chinua Achebe...
1627 downloads
8982 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
MAGILL’S C H O I C E
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
Volume 1 Chinua Achebe — Louise Erdrich 1 – 378
edited by
Charles E. May California State University, Long Beach
SALEM PRESS, INC. Pasadena, California
Hackensack, New Jersey
Cover photo: Shawn Gearhart/©iStockphoto.com
Copyright © 1993, 1997, 2008, by Salem Press, Inc. All rights in this book are reserved. No part of this work may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the copyright owner except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information address the publisher, Salem Press, Inc., P.O. Box 50062, Pasadena, California 91115. Some essays in these volumes originally appeared in Critical Survey of Short Fiction, Second Revised Edition, 2001. New material has been added. ∞ The paper used in these volumes conforms to the American National Standard for Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, Z39.48-1992 (R1997). Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Short story writers / edited by Charles E. May. — Rev. ed. v. cm. — (Magill’s choice) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-58765-389-6 (set : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-58765-390-2 (vol. 1 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-58765-391-9 (vol. 2 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-58765-392-6 (vol. 3 : alk. paper) 1. Short story. 2. Short stories—Bio-bibliography—Dictionaries. 3. Novelists—Biography—Dictionaries. I. May, Charles E. (Charles Edward), 1941PN3373.S398 2008 809.3’1—dc22 2007032789
First printing
printed in canada
Contents – Volume 1 Contents
Publisher’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii List of Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix Complete List of Contents. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv Achebe, Chinua . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Adams, Alice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Aiken, Conrad . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Alexie, Sherman . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Allende, Isabel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Andersen, Hans Christian . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 Anderson, Sherwood . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 Angelou, Maya . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 Atwood, Margaret . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 Babel, Isaac . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58 Baldwin, James . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66 Bambara, Toni Cade . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 Banks, Russell . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79 Barthelme, Donald. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86 Beattie, Ann . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 Bellow, Saul . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 Bierce, Ambrose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112 Boccaccio, Giovanni . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118 Borges, Jorge Luis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 Bowen, Elizabeth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 136 Boyle, Kay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143 Boyle, T. Coraghessan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152 Bradbury, Ray . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 160 Callaghan, Morley . . . . . Capote, Truman . . . . . . Carver, Raymond . . . . . . Cather, Willa . . . . . . . . Chaucer, Geoffrey . . . . . Cheever, John . . . . . . . . Chekhov, Anton. . . . . . . Chesnutt, Charles Waddell. Chesterton, G. K. . . . . . . Chopin, Kate . . . . . . . . Cisneros, Sandra . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . v
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
173 182 188 198 205 220 231 242 250 258 264
Short Story Writers
Clark, Walter Van Tilburg Clarke, Arthur C. . . . . . Conrad, Joseph . . . . . . Coover, Robert . . . . . . Coppard, A. E. . . . . . . Cortázar, Julio. . . . . . . Crane, Stephen . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
271 277 285 295 303 310 317
De la Mare, Walter . . . . Dinesen, Isak . . . . . . . Dostoevski, Fyodor . . . . Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan . Dubus, Andre . . . . . . . Dybek, Stuart . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
327 333 342 348 358 364
Ellison, Ralph . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 368 Erdrich, Louise . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 374
vi
Publisher’s Note Publisher’s Note
Short Story Writers, Revised Edition, is the first revision of a Magill’s Choice set published in 1997. To that earlier edition’s collection of 102 articles, this edition adds 44 more articles on important authors of short fiction. The revised three-volume set thus has 146 articles on the most frequently taught, most frequently read, most acclaimed, and most often researched short-fiction writers studied in American schools and colleges. The essays in these volumes have been culled from the 480 author essays in Salem Press’s Critical Survey of Short Fiction, Second Revised Edition (2001) and have been updated. They collectively provide an essential look at the best in short-fiction writing in an easy-to-use and student-friendly format. Any list of contents in a work such as this is necessarily subjective, making the inclusion of one author over another open to debate. Nevertheless, the editors have done their best to meet the needs of core-literature curricula in schools by including the authors who most commonly appear on basic reading lists. Thanks to the greater than 40-percent expansion of coverage in Short Story Writers, Revised Edition, users are more likely than ever to find articles on the authors whom they are studying. The selection of authors in these volumes focuses mainly on modern short-story writers, with a brief nod to the classic fourteenth century writings of Giovanni Boccaccio (The Decameron) and Geoffrey Chaucer (The Canterbury Tales). The set also takes into account the influence of the contes or Märchen, represented here by Germany’s Brothers Grimm. More than two dozen of the authors did most of their writing during the nineteenth century. Among the best known of these are Nathaniel Hawthorne, Edgar Allan Poe, Ivan Turgenev, Mark Twain, Bret Harte, Henry James, Guy de Maupassant, Kate Chopin, and Anton Chekhov. By the middle of the nineteenth century, two distinct types of short fiction existed: the tale and the essaysketch. The modern short story brings together the best of these two traditions. Although questions of how, when, and where short fiction developed have generated lively debate, most scholars of the genre agree that the modern short story began in the United States and specifically in the writings of Washington Irving. Indeed, it is often conceded that Irving’s “Rip Van Winkle” (1809) was the first great modern short story. Although Irving is often regarded as the inventor of the short story form, modern short stories appeared at almost exactly the same time he was writing—in Russia, France, Germany, and elsewhere in the United States. Consequently, credit for creating the form has also been attributed to Russia’s Nikolai Gogol, France’s Prosper Mérimée, and America’s Nathaniel Hawthorne and Edgar Allan Poe. Among these other writers, Poe stands out; he not only wrote short stories but also wrote about the short story form in theory. He addressed it as a distinct genre, advancing the thesis that a story should have a unified effect and be compact—principles that still guide short-story criticisms. Many outstanding writers of the genre followed the nineteenth century pioneers. Other authors covered in this set reflect the range and diversity of nineteenth and twentieth century short-story writing. More than half of those covered (87) are from the United States, reflecting the strength of the genre in one of its most important birthplaces. These American writers include 10 African Americans, 4 Native Amerivii
Short Story Writers cans, and 3 Latinos. The second largest national grouping is England (19), added to which are some of the great authors of Ireland (7) and Scotland (3). Readers will also find some of the cornerstone short fiction writers of Canada, the Continent, Russia, Asia, Africa, and South America. Women authors have excelled in the genre, and of the 49 surveyed in these volumes, 21 are new to this edition. Organization The essays are arranged alphabetically, by authors’ surnames, in the three volumes, and their concise and accessible formats follow an easy-to-use template. Each essay begins with the author’s name, birth date and place, death date and place when appropriate, and a chronological list of the subject’s major publications of short fiction. The text of the essay is divided into four subsections: • Other literary forms describes other genres in which the author has worked • Achievements addresses what the author has contributed to the genre and mentions any important honors and awards the author has received • Biography summarizes the author’s life • Analysis, the main body of the text, is a detailed examination of the author’s short-story writing that usually includes three or four subheaded sections focusing on individual stories that help explain the author’s work The back matter of each essay includes “Other major works,” which lists the author’s publications in genres other than the short story, and a solid annotated bibliography. All the bibliographies—which average ten citations—have been substantially updated. More than half the titles cited have been published since 1994, and nearly one-third have been published since the first edition of Short Story Writers was issued. Volume 3 concludes with a glossary of 118 terms and techniques relevant to the study of short fiction, a time line listing all the covered authors by their dates of birth, and a comprehensive index. Achnowledgments Salem Press would like to thank the nearly 170 scholars who contributed their time and knowledge to writing the essays and providing updates for this set. Their names and affiliations are listed the pages that follow this note. Salem especially wishes to thank Dr. Charles E. May of California State University at Long Beach for lending his expertise on the short-story genre to this project by serving as its Editor.
viii
List of Contributors List of Contributors
Michael Adams City University of New York, Graduate Center
Lynn Z. Bloom University of Connecticut
Thomas P. Adler Purdue University
Julia B. Boken State University of New York, College at Oneonta
Karen L. Arnold Independent Scholar
Jo-Ellen Lipman Boon Independent Scholar
Marilyn Arnold Independent Scholar
Jerry Bradley Original Contributor
Robert W. Artinian University of Virginia
Harold Branam Savanna State University
Stanley S. Atherton Original Contributor
Gerhard Brand California State University, Los Angeles
Bryan Aubrey Independent Scholar
Laurence A. Breiner Boston University
Jane L. Ball Wilberforce University
Keith H. Brower Salisbury State University
Mary Baron University of North Florida
Mary H. Bruce Monmouth College
Melissa E. Barth Appalachian State University
Louis J. Budd Duke University
Bert Bender Original Contributor
Rebecca R. Butler Dalton College
Alvin K. Benson Utah Valley State College
Edmund J. Campion University of Tennessee
Dorothy M. Betz Georgetown University
John Carr Original Contributor
Cynthia A. Bily Adrian College
Warren J. Carson University of South Carolina, Spartunburg
Margaret Boe Birns New York University
Mary LeDonne Cassidy South Carolina State University
Nicholas Birns Eugene Lang College, New School
Thomas Cassidy South Carolina State University
Carol Bishop Indiana University, Southeast
Hal Charles Eastern Kentucky University ix
Short Story Writers Lisa-Anne Culp University of South Florida
Kenneth Funsten Independent Scholar
Bill Delaney Independent Scholar
Ann D. Garbett Averett University
Joan DelFattore University of Delaware
Linda S. Gordon Worcester State College
Kathryn Zabelle Derounian University of Arkansas, Little Rock
Peter W. Graham Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
John F. Desmond Whitman College
Julian Grajewski Original Contributor
Grace Eckley Independent Scholar
James L. Green Arizona State University
Wilton Eckley Colorado School of Mines
William E. Grim Ohio University
Robert P. Ellis Worcester State College
David Mike Hamilton Independent Scholar
Thomas L. Erskine Salisbury University
Stephen M. Hart University College London
Walter Evans Augusta College
Terry Heller Coe College
James Feast Baruch College, City University of New York
Diane Andrews Henningfeld Adrian College
John W. Fiero University of Louisiana, Lafayette
Allen Hibbard Middle Tennessee State University
Edward Fiorelli St. John’s University, New York
Jane Hill Independent Scholar
James K. Folsom University of Colorado, Boulder
Nika Hoffman Crossroads School
Carol Franks Portland State University
William Hoffman Independent Scholar
Timothy C. Frazer Western Illinois University
Theodore C. Humphrey California State Polytechnic University, Pomona
Terri Frongia University of California, Riverside
Archibald E. Irwin Indiana University, Southeast
Miriam Fuchs Independent Scholar
Eunice Pedersen Johnston North Dakota State University
Jean C. Fulton Malarishi University of Management
x
List of Contributors Theresa Kanoza Lincoln Land Community College
Charles E. May California State University, Long Beach
Karen A. Kildahl South Dakota State University
Laurence W. Mazzeno Alvernia College
Sue L. Kimball Methodist College
Kenneth W. Meadwell University of Winnipeg
Cassandra Kircher Elon College
Martha Meek University of North Dakota
Carlota Larrea Pennsylvania University
Ann A. Merrill Emory University
Eugene S. Larson Los Angeles Pierce College
Vasa D. Mihailovich University of North Carolina
Donald F. Larsson Mankato State University
Paula M. Miller Biola University
Norman Lavers Arkansas State University
Robert W. Millett Original Contributor
Leon Lewis Appalachian State University
Christian H. Moe Southern Illinois University, Carbondale
Douglas Long Independent Scholar
S. S. Moorty Southern Utah State College
R. C. Lutz CII, Jüterbog, Germany
Robert A. Morace Daemen College
Joanne McCarthy Independent Scholar
Sherry Morton-Mollo California State University, Fullerton
Richard D. McGhee Arkansas State University
Earl Paulus Murphy Harris-Stoew State University
Victoria E. McLure Texas Tech University
Brian Murray Youngstown State College
Bryant Mangum Independent Scholar
John M. Muste Ohio State University
Barry Mann Alliance Theatre
Susan Nayel Original Contributor
Patricia Marks Valdosta State College
William Nelles University of Massachusetts, Dartmouth
Karen M. Cleveland Marwick Independent Scholar
Evelyn Newlyn Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
Paul Marx University of New Haven
Emma Coburn Norris Troy State University xi
Short Story Writers George O’Brien Georgetown University
Paul Rosefeldt Delgado Community College
Keri L. Overall University of South Carolina
Ruth Rosenberg Original Contributor
Cóilín Owens George Mason University
Gabrielle Rowe McKendree College
Janet Taylor Palmer Caldwell Community College & Technical Institute
David Sadkin Nigara University
Robert J. Paradowski Rochester Institute of Technology Leslie A. Pearl Independent Scholar David Peck California State University, Long Beach Susan L. Piepke Bridgewater College Constance Pierce Miami University, Ohio Mary Ellen Pitts Rhodes College Victoria Price Lamar University Karen Priest Lama University, Orange Norman Prinsky Augusta State University Jere Real Lynchburg College Peter J. Reed University of Minnesota Rosemary M. Canfield Reisman Charleston Southern University Martha E. Rhynes Independent Scholar Mary Rohrberger University of Northern Iowa Jill Rollins Trafalgar College
Chaman L. Sahni Boise State University David N. Samuelson California State University, Long Beach Victor A. Santi University of New Orleans Barbara Kitt Seidman Linfield College D. Dean Shackelford Concord College Allen Shepherd Original Contributor Jan Sjåvik University of Washington Roger Smith Willamette University Ira Smolensky Monmouth College Katherine Snipes Independent Scholar Jean M. Snook Memorial University of Newfoundland George Soule Carleton College Madison V. Sowell Brigham Young University Sandra Whipple Spanier Pennsylvania State University John Stark Original Contributor
xii
List of Contributors Karen F. Stein University of Rhode Island
Richard Tuerk Texas A&M University, Commerce
Judith L. Steininger Milwaukee School of Engineering
Scott D. Vander Ploeg Madisonville Community College
Louise M. Stone Bloomsburg University
Dennis Vannatta University of Arkansas, Little Rock
W. J. Stuckey Purdue University
Barbara Wiedemann Auburn University, Montgomery
Alvin Sullivan Southern Illinois University
Albert Wilhelm Tennessee Technological University
Eileen A. Sullivan Original Contributor
Patricia A. R. Williams Texas Southern University
James Sullivan California State University, Los Angeles
Judith Barton Williamson Sauk Valley Community College
Catherine Swanson Independent Scholar
Michael Witkoski University of South Carolina
Roy Arthur Swanson University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee
Anna M. Wittman University of Alberta
Terry Theodore University of North Carolina, Wilmington
Mary F. Yudin Pennsylvania State University
Lou Thompson Texas Woman’s University
Gay Annette Zieger Independent Scholar
Christine Tomei Columbia University
xiii
Complete List of Contents Complete List of Contents
Volume 1 Achebe, Chinua, 1 Adams, Alice, 7 Aiken, Conrad, 13 Alexie, Sherman, 20 Allende, Isabel, 24 Andersen, Hans Christian, 28 Anderson, Sherwood, 35 Angelou, Maya, 43 Atwood, Margaret, 48 Babel, Isaac, 58 Baldwin, James, 66 Bambara, Toni Cade, 73 Banks, Russell, 79 Barthelme, Donald, 86 Beattie, Ann, 96 Bellow, Saul, 104 Bierce, Ambrose, 112 Boccaccio, Giovanni, 118 Borges, Jorge Luis, 125 Bowen, Elizabeth, 136 Boyle, Kay, 143 Boyle, T. Coraghessan, 152 Bradbury, Ray, 160 Callaghan, Morley, 173 Capote, Truman, 182
Carver, Raymond, 188 Cather, Willa, 198 Chaucer, Geoffrey, 205 Cheever, John, 220 Chekhov, Anton, 231 Chesnutt, Charles Waddell, 242 Chesterton, G. K., 250 Chopin, Kate, 258 Cisneros, Sandra, 264 Clark, Walter Van Tilburg, 271 Clarke, Arthur C., 277 Conrad, Joseph, 285 Coover, Robert, 295 Coppard, A. E., 303 Cortázar, Julio, 310 Crane, Stephen, 317 De la Mare, Walter, 327 Dinesen, Isak, 333 Dostoevski, Fyodor, 342 Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan, 348 Dubus, Andre, 358 Dybek, Stuart, 364 Ellison, Ralph, 368 Erdrich, Louise, 374
Volume 2 Faulkner, William, 379 Fitzgerald, F. Scott, 388 Flaubert, Gustave, 397 Forster, E. M., 407 Gallant, Mavis, 413 García Márquez, Gabriel, 420 Garland, Hamlin, 428 Gogol, Nikolai, 435 Gordimer, Nadine, 444 Greene, Graham, 453 Grimm Brothers, 461
Harte, Bret, 469 Hawthorne, Nathaniel, 475 Hemingway, Ernest, 486 Hempel, Amy, 495 Henry, O., 499 Hughes, Langston, 505 Hurston, Zora Neale, 512 Irving, Washington, 519 Jackson, Shirley, 526 James, Henry, 533 xv
Short Story Writers Jewett, Sarah Orne, 543 Jhabvala, Ruth Prawer, 550 Joyce, James, 555 Kafka, Franz, 565 Kincaid, Jamaica, 576 Kingsolver, Barbara, 583 Kipling, Rudyard, 588 Lardner, Ring, 598 Lavin, Mary, 603 Lawrence, D. H., 611 Le Guin, Ursula K., 621 Lessing, Doris, 628 London, Jack, 636
McCullers, Carson, 641 Malamud, Bernard, 649 Mann, Thomas, 659 Mansfield, Katherine, 670 Mason, Bobbie Ann, 680 Maugham, W. Somerset, 687 Maupassant, Guy de, 695 Melville, Herman, 704 Mérimée, Prosper, 712 Mishima, Yukio, 717 Mukherjee, Bharati, 723 Munro, Alice, 734 Nabokov, Vladimir, 743 Narayan, R. K., 752
Volume 3 Oates, Joyce Carol, 759 O’Brien, Edna, 770 O’Connor, Flannery, 778 O’Connor, Frank, 788 O’Faoláin, Seán, 796 O’Flaherty, Liam, 803 Olsen, Tillie, 810 Ozick, Cynthia, 816 Paley, Grace, 823 Parker, Dorothy, 830 Perelman, S. J., 835 Petry, Ann, 841 Pirandello, Luigi, 850 Poe, Edgar Allan, 857 Porter, Katherine Anne, 867 Powers, J. F., 876 Pritchett, V. S., 881 Proulx, E. Annie, 891 Purdy, James, 896 Saki, 905 Salinger, J. D., 910 Saroyan, William, 919 Sillitoe, Alan, 925 Singer, Isaac Bashevis, 931 Spark, Muriel, 941 Steinbeck, John, 948 Stevenson, Robert Louis, 954
Tan, Amy, 961 Taylor, Peter, 966 Thomas, Dylan, 973 Thurber, James, 981 Tolstoy, Leo, 987 Trevor, William, 998 Turgenev, Ivan, 1006 Twain, Mark, 1015 Tyler, Anne, 1022 Updike, John, 1029 Viramontes, Helena María, 1042 Vonnegut, Kurt, 1047 Walker, Alice, 1056 Warren, Robert Penn, 1066 Welty, Eudora, 1073 Wharton, Edith, 1083 Williams, Joy, 1090 Williams, Tennessee, 1095 Williams, William Carlos, 1103 Wolff, Tobias, 1109 Woolf, Virginia, 1116 Wright, Richard, 1123 Terms and Techniques, 1129 Time Line, 1140 Index, 1147 xvi
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
1
Chinua Achebe Born: Ogidi, Nigeria; November 16, 1930 Principal short fiction • “Dead Men’s Path,” 1953; The Sacrificial Egg, and Other Stories, 1962; Girls at War, 1972. Other literary forms • In addition to his short-story collections, Chinua Achebe is known for essays, children’s literature, and collections of poetry, which include Collected Poems (2004). He is best known, however, for his novel No Longer at Ease (1960), which became a modern African classic. The book is the second in a trilogy about change, conflict, and personal struggle to find the “New Africa.” The first is Things Fall Apart (1958) and the third is Arrow of God (1964). Achebe’s fourth novel, A Man of the People (1966), was followed twenty-one years later by Anthills of the Savannah (1987), his fifth novel. In 1984 he became the founder and publisher of Uwa Ndi Igbo: A Bilingual Journal of Igbo Life and Arts. Achebe edited volumes of African short fiction, including African Short Stories (1985) and The Heinemann Book of Contemporary African Short Fiction (1992), both with C. L. Innes. Achievements • Chinua Achebe received awards or award nominations for each of his novelistic works, from the Margaret Wrong Memorial Prize for Things Fall Apart to a Booker McConnell Prize nomination for Anthills of the Savannah. He was also awarded a Rockefeller travel fellowship in 1960 and the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) Fellowship for creative artists in 1963. In 1979 he received the Nigerian National Merit Award and was named to the Order of the Federal Republic of Nigeria. Achebe received honorary doctorates from universities around the world, including Dartmouth College in 1972 and Harvard University in 1996. Biography • Chinua Achebe, christened at birth Albert Chinualumogu Achebe, was born in Ogidi in Eastern Nigeria on November 16, 1930, near the Niger River. His family was Christian in a village divided between Christians and the “others.” Achebe’s great-grandfather served as the model for Okonkwo, the protagonist of Things Fall Apart. Because he was an Ibo and a Christian, Achebe grew up conscious of how he differed not only from other Africans but also from other Nigerians. Achebe was one of the first graduates of University College at Ibadan in 1953. In 1954, he was made producer of the Nigerian Broadcasting Service and in 1958 became the founding editor of Heinemann’s African Writers series; this position and the publication, in that series, of Things Fall Apart, account for his vast influence among writers of his and the following generation. Achebe married Christie Chinwe Okoli in 1961 and became the father of four children. When a civil war began in Nigeria in 1966 with the massacre of Achebe’s fellow tribesmen in the northern part of the country, Achebe returned to the east, hoping to establish in the new country of Biafra a publishing house with other young Ibo writers. One of this band was the poet Christopher Okigbo, killed later that year in action against federal forces. After Biafra’s defeat in the civil war, a defeat which
2
Short Story Writers
meant for many of his compatriots imprisonment in camps and “reeducation,” Achebe worked as an educator as well as a writer. He traveled to the United States on several occasions to serve as a guest lecturer or visiting professor, and he visited many countries throughout the world. In addition, his interest in politics led to his serving as the deputy national president of the People’s Redemption Party in 1983 and then as the president of the town union in Ogidi, Nigeria, in 1986. Achebe served as visiting professor on an international scale. Universities at which he taught include Cambridge University, the University of Connecticut, and the University of Rocon/Enugu, Nigeria California, Los Angeles. A 1990 car accident injured Achebe’s spine, confining him to a wheelchair. He spent six months recovering, then accepted an endowed professorship at New York’s Bard College. He continued to teach and write throughout the 1990’s. Analysis • Chinua Achebe is an African English-language writer. As an author, Achebe uses the power of English words to expose, unite, and reveal various aspects of Nigerian culture. His subjects are both literary and political. In general, Achebe’s writings reflect cultural diversity in twentieth century African society. He focuses on the difficulty faced by Africans who were once under the rule of British colonials but later had to struggle with issues of democracy, the evils of military rule, civil war, tribal rivalries, and dictatorship. Achebe seeks to preserve the proverbs and truths of his Ibo tribal heritage by incorporating them into his stories, whether they be in his contemporary novels or his children’s tales. His works do more, however, than entertain; they reveal truths about human nature and show the destructiveness of power corrupted. Achebe’s writing does not cast blame but delivers a message to his readers, concerning unity and the necessity for political stability in Nigerian culture. “Vengeful Creditor” • Achebe’s “Vengeful Creditor” is a story that seems to be about what a misconceived government decree guaranteeing free education to all can lead to, including some rather comic developments. It appears to be a story about class struggle, and then, as readers see layer after layer of meaning stripped away and one theme leading directly to another, it seems to be—and is—about something really quite different from either education or the class system. Mr. and Mrs. Emenike are part of the Nigerian upper class: He is a parliamentary secretary, and he and his wife own a Mercedes and a Fiat and employ servants from the still-uneducated masses, most of them from the village of their birth, to which the Emenikes return periodically to shower largesse upon the populace. At the begin-
Achebe, Chinua
3
ning of the story, a free-education bill has caused a mass desertion of servants, even those of college age, all of whom wish to go back to their villages and qualify for an education. Apparently many others have the same idea, for the turnout for free schooling is double what the government statisticians had predicted. Readers see Emenike and his running buddies at the cabinet meeting at which it is decided to make everyone pay, after all, because the army might have to be called out if new taxes are announced to pay for the unexpected costs of the program. The Emenikes, finding themselves with this “servant problem,” return to their native village and ask Martha, a village woman known to them, if her daughter Vero will be their baby nurse for the princely sum of five pounds per year. Martha has led a rather sad life: She was educated at a Christian school whose reason for being was the education of African girls up to the standards expected of the wives of native pastors. The woman in charge of her school, however, by way of furthering her own romantic aspirations, persuaded Martha to marry a carpenter being trained at an industrial school managed by a white man. Carpentry never came into its own, however, at least not as much as preaching and teaching, and Martha had a “bad-luck marriage,” which eventually left her a widow with no money and several children to support, although she was a Standard Three (beginning of high school) reader and her classmates were all married to prosperous teachers and bishops. The withdrawal of the free-education decree has cast Martha’s daughter, Vero, back onto the streets. When Mr. Emenike says that one does not need education to be great, Martha knows he is patronizing her; she knows exactly what the fate of an uneducated person usually is, but she needs the money from this job. Mr. Emenike rounds out his recruiting pitch by saying he thinks there is plenty of time for the tenyear-old girl to go to school. Martha says, “I read Standard Three in those days and I said they will all go to college. Now they will not even have the little I had thirty years ago.” Vero turns out to be quick, industrious, and creative, but there also begins to be a connection between her charge’s maturing and her own chance of an education. Finally, as she comes to realize the child will need care until hope of an education has passed her, she tries to poison him by making him drink a bottle of red ink. Mrs. Emenike, one of the least sympathetic Africans in any short story ever written by an African, beats Vero unmercifully. They drive back to the village where they were all born and pull her out of the car. Martha hears from Vero that she has been fired, sees the blood on her daughter, and drags her to the Emenikes. Called one who taught her daughter murder, she retorts to Mrs. Emenike that she is not a murderer. Mr. Emenike, trying to break up this confrontation, says, “It’s the work of the devil. . . . I have always known that the craze for education in this country will one day ruin all of us. Now even children will commit murder in order to go to school.” “Uncle Ben’s Choice” • “Uncle Ben’s Choice” is a ghost or magical story which involves the element of human choice. A succubus-goddess known as the Mami-Wota, capable of many disguises, is both a seducer and a betrayer. She makes it possible for a young girl who offers herself to a man to guarantee not only sexual relations but also success, riches, and whatever material things the man desires. The only condition is that the Mami-Wota prevents the man from marrying her. “Uncle Ben’s Choice” is a monologue told by Uncle Ben in a tone that is skeptical yet simultaneously sincere and ingenuous. Uncle Ben is a clerk determined not to marry, whose passions are scotch, a brand-new phonograph, and his bicycle. His affluence brings him to the attention of the Mami-Wota because he not only lives better
4
Short Story Writers
than the average African but also is much more concerned with the material rewards of life than even his fellow clerks. A “light” girl who is Roman Catholic falls for him, and he tries to stay out of her way. However, he comes home one night after some heavy drinking and falls into bed, only to find a naked woman there. He thinks at first that it is the girl who has been making a play for him, then he feels her hair—it feels European. He jumps out of bed, and the woman calls to him in the voice of the girl who has a crush on him. He is suspicious now and strikes a match, making the most fateful decision of his life: to abjure wealth gotten from being the exclusive property of the Mami-Wota, her lover and her slave. “Uncle Ben’s Choice” is about the innate morality of men in society. Uncle Ben honors his society by suppressing his own urges and fantasies in favor of remaining a part of his family, clan, and tribe, whose rewards he values more than riches. “Girls at War” • “Girls at War” is a story about the war between the seceding state of Biafra and Nigeria, and both the theme and the plot are foreshadowed in the spare sentence introducing the principal characters: “The first time their paths crossed nothing happened.” The second time they meet, however, is at a checkpoint at Akwa, when the girl, Gladys, stops Reginald Nwankwo’s car to inspect it. He falls back on the dignity of his office and person, but this fails to impress her, which secretly delights and excites him. He sees her as “a beautiful girl in a breasty blue jersey, khaki jeans and canvas shoes with the new-style hair plait which gave a girl a defiant look.” Before, in the earlier stages of the war, he had sneered at the militia girls, particularly after seeing a group recruited from a high school marching under the banner “WE ARE IMPREGNABLE.” Now he begins to respect them because of the mature attitude and bearing of Gladys, who seems both patriotic and savvy, knowing and yet naïve. The third time they meet, “things had got very bad. Death and starvation had long chased out the headiness of the early days.” Reginald is coming back to Owerri after using his influence as an official to obtain some food, unfortunately under the eyes of a starving crowd who mock and taunt him. He is something of an idealist, and this embarrasses him, but he has decided that in “such a situation one could do nothing at all for crowds; at best one could try to be of some use to one’s immediate neighbors.” Gladys is walking along in a crowd, and he picks her up, but not because he recognizes her. She has changed: She is wearing makeup, a wig, and new clothes and is now a bureaucrat and no doubt corrupt. She reminds him that she was the one who searched him so long ago; he had admired her then, but now he just wants her, and as soon as they get into town he takes her into an air-raid bunker after Nigerian planes fly over, strafing. Later, they go to a party, where in the midst of Biafran starvation there is scotch, Courvoisier, and real bread, but a white Red Cross man who has lost a friend in an air crash tells them all that they stink and that any girl there will roll into bed for a fish or a dollar. He is slapped by an African officer who, all the girls think, is a hero, including Gladys, who begins to appear to the protagonist—and to the readers—as the banal, improvident child she really is. Finally, Gladys goes home and to bed with Reginald, who is shocked by the coarseness of her language. He has his pleasure and writes her off. Then he begins to think she is nothing but a mirror reflecting a “rotten, maggoty society” and that she, like a dirty mirror, needs only some cleaning. He begins to believe she is under some terrible influence. He decides to try to help her;
Achebe, Chinua
5
he gives her food and money, and they drive off together to her house. He is determined to see who is there and who her friends are, to get to the bottom of her life of waste and callousness. On the way he picks up a soldier who has lost part of one leg. Before, he would not have picked up a mere private, not only sweaty but also an inconvenience with his crutches and his talk of war. Then there is another air raid. He pushes past Gladys, who stops to go back to help the disabled soldier, and, terrified, goes into the timberline, where a near-miss knocks him senseless. When he awakes, he finds the driver sobbing and bloody and his car a wreck. “He saw the remains of his car smoking and the entangled remains of the girl and the soldier. And he let out a piercing cry and fell down again.” With Gladys’s horrible death, the protagonist understands the potential for nobility within the heart and soul of even the most banal and superficial of human beings. “Girls at War” confirms Achebe’s faith in humanity and in Africa. “Civil Peace” • Because of the remarkable portrayal of Nigerian culture, Achebe’s works, like the three stories analyzed above, are frequently anthologized. Achebe himself edited and published the collection African Short Stories (1985). It is subdivided by regions of the African continent. In the West African section, Achebe included his own work “Civil Peace,” originally published in Girls at War. This story takes place in the time period just after the Biafran War. It points out with the ironic title that there may not be much difference between civil war and civil peace. Jonathan Iwegbu feels fortunate that he, his wife, and three of their four children have survived the war. As an added bonus, so has his bicycle, which Jonathan had cleverly buried in his yard to keep it from the marauding troops. After the war, Jonathan’s entrepreneurial instincts can flourish because he has the bicycle. Jonathan’s business ventures do well and, in addition, he receives a cash payment of Nigerian money (called the ex-gratia award or egg-rasher by the Nigerians struggling with the foreign term) for turning in rebel money coined during the conflict. Unfortunately, a band of thieves, many of them former soldiers, armed with machine guns and other weapons, learn of his windfall and terrorize Jonathan and his family in a way reminiscent of wartime, until Jonathan gives them the money. Fatalistically, yet realistically, Jonathan realizes he is back to square one, and, at the end of the story, he and his family are once again preparing to go out and start all over again. In Jonathan’s own words, “I say, let egg-rasher perish in the flames! Let it go where everything else has gone.” This story illustrates one of Achebe’s major themes, a portrayal of both the problems or weaknesses and the strengths of the Nigerian people. The society has been vicious and cruel to itself, yet the strength and spirit of individuals will carry it onward. John Carr With updates by Paula M. Miller and Judith L. Steininger Other major works children’s literature: Chike and the River, 1966; How the Leopard Got His Claws, 1972 (with John Iroaganachi); The Drum, 1977; The Flute, 1977. anthologies: The Heinemann Book of Contemporary African Short Stories, 1992 (with C.L. Innes); Aka Weta: An Anthology of Ibo Poetry, 1978; Don’t Let Him Die: An Anthology of Memorial Poems for Christopher Okigbo, 1932-1967, 1978 (with Dubem Okafor); African Short Stories, 1985 (with C. L. Innes); Beyond Hunger in Africa, 1990 (with others).
6
Short Story Writers
novels: Things Fall Apart, 1958; No Longer at Ease, 1960; Arrow of God, 1964; A Man of the People, 1966; Anthills of the Savannah, 1987. miscellaneous: Another Africa, 1998 (poems and essay; photographs by Robert Lyons). nonfiction: Morning Yet on Creation Day, 1975; The Trouble with Nigeria, 1983; Hopes and Impediments, 1988; Conversations with Chinua Achebe, 1997 (Bernth Lindfors, editor); Home and Exile, 2000. poetry: Beware: Soul Brother, and Other Poems, 1971, 1972; Christmas in Biafra, and Other Poems, 1973; Collected Poems, 2004. Bibliography Achebe, Chinua. “The Art of Fiction CXXXIX: Chinua Achebe.” Interview by Jerome Brooks. The Paris Review 36 (Winter, 1994): 142-166. In this interview, Achebe discusses his schooling, work as a broadcaster, and views on other writers, as well as the nature of his writing process and the political situation in Nigeria. ____________. Home and Exile. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. Exploration, based on Achebe’s own experiences as a reader and a writer, of contemporary African literature and the Western literature that both influenced and misrepresented it. Booker, M. Keith, ed. The Chinua Achebe Encyclopedia. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 2003. Helpful reference in an encyclopedia format. Ezenwa-Ohaeto. Chinua Achebe: A Biography. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1997. Full-length biography of Achebe, this book benefits from its author’s insights as a former student of Achebe’s, a native of Nigeria, and a speaker of Igbo. Ezenwa-Ohaeto examines Achebe’s life and literary contributions and places them within their social, historical, and cultural contexts. Written with the cooperation of Achebe and his family, the book includes several rare and revealing photographs. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Gikandi, Simon. Reading Chinua Achebe: Language and Ideology in Fiction. Portsmouth, N.H.: Heinemann, 1991. Analyzes Achebe’s short stories and novels. Joseph, Michael Scott. “A Pre-modernist Reading of ‘The Drum’: Chinua Achebe and the Theme of the Eternal Return.” Ariel 28 (January, 1997): 149-166. In this special issue on colonialism, postcolonialism, and children’s literature, Achebe’s “The Drum” is discussed as a satirical attack on European colonial values and a text dominated by nostalgia for a lost Golden Age. Lindfors, Bernth, ed. Conversations with Chinua Achebe. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1997. Twenty interviews with Achebe in which he discusses African oral tradition, the need for political commitment, the relationship between his novels and his short stories, his use of myth and fable, and other issues concerning being a writer. Olubunmi Smith, Pamela J. “Dead Men’s Path.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 2. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Analysis of “Dead Men’s Path” with sections on themes and meaning and style and technique. Also includes a detailed synopsis of the story. Petersen, Kirsten Holst, and Anna Rutherford, eds. Chinua Achebe: A Celebration. Portsmouth, N.H.: Heinemann, 1991. Compilation of essays analyzing Achebe’s work to honor his sixtieth birthday.
7
Alice Adams Born: Fredericksburg, Virginia; August 14, 1926 Died: San Francisco, California; May 27, 1999 Principal short fiction • Beautiful Girl, 1979; To See You Again, 1982; Molly’s Dog, 1983; Return Trips, 1985; After You’ve Gone, 1989; The Last Lovely City: Stories, 1999; The Stories of Alice Adams, 2002. Other literary forms • Though Alice Adams was first successful in short fiction, she also published several novels, including Careless Love (1966), Families and Survivors (1974), Listening to Billie (1978), Rich Rewards (1980), Superior Women (1984), Second Chances (1988), Caroline’s Daughters (1991), Almost Perfect (1993), A Southern Exposure (1995), Medicine Men (1997), and After the War (2000). In addition, her story “Roses, Rhododendrons” appeared as an illustrated gift book. Achievements • Alice Adams did not publish her first collection of stories until she was in her fifties, but she quickly assumed a place among the leading practitioners of the genre. Twenty-two of her stories have appeared in Prize Stories: The O. Henry Awards. A full collection of her stories appeared in 2002, three years after her death. In 1976, Adams received a grant from the National Endowment for the Arts and, in 1978, she received a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship. In 1982, Adams received the O. Henry Special Award for Continuing Achievement, given for only the third time; her predecessors were Joyce Carol Oates (in 1970) and John Updike (in 1976). She also received the American Academy of Arts and Letters Award in literature in 1992. Biography • Alice Boyd Adams was born in Fredericksburg, Virginia, on August 14, 1926, the daughter of Nicholson Adams, a professor, and Agatha (née Boyd) Adams, a writer. Shortly after her birth, the family moved to Chapel Hill, North Carolina, where Adams spent her first sixteen years. After receiving her bachelor’s degree from Radcliffe College in 1946, she married Mark Linenthal, Jr. Two years later, they moved to California, and in 1951, their only child, Peter, was born. Their marriage ended in divorce in 1958, following which Adams held a number of part-time clerical, secretarial, and bookkeeping jobs while rearing her son and writing short stories. It was not until 1969 that she broke into the magazine market when The New Yorker bought her story “Gift of Grass.” Since then, her stories have continued to appear in The New Yorker as well as Redbook, McCall’s, and The Paris Review. In addition, Adams taught at the University of California at Davis, the University of California at Berkeley, and Stanford University. She died on May 27, 1999, in San Francisco after being treated for heart problems. Analysis • Most of Alice Adams’s stories revolve around common themes, and her characters, mostly educated, upper-middle-class women, are defined by a set of common traits and situations which reappear in somewhat different combinations. They find their lives flawed, often by unhappy relationships with lovers, husbands, parents,
8
Short Story Writers
friends, sometimes with combinations of these, usually with a living antagonist, occasionally with one already dead. Often, they resolve these problems, but sometimes they do not. Frequently, the tensions of Adams’s plots are resolved when her central female characters learn something new or find a new source of strength, which enables them to part with unsatisfactory husbands, lovers, or friends. Claire, in “Home Is Where” (in Beautiful Girl), leaves both an unsatisfactory marriage and a miserable love affair in San Francisco, where she feels “ugly—drained, discolored, old,” to spend the summer with her parents in her North Carolina hometown, where she had been young and “if not beautiful, sought after.” Refreshed and stimulated by the sensual landscape and a summertime affair, Claire returns to San Francisco to divorce her husband, take leave of her unpleasant lover, and, eventually, to remarry, this time happily. Cynthia, in “The Break-in” (To See You Again), finds herself so different from her fiancé Roger, when he automatically blames the burglary of his home on “Mexicans,” that she leaves him without a word. The narrator of “True Colors” (To See You Again) discovers, in Las Vegas, David’s ugly side as an obsessive gambler and leaves him: “From then on I was going to be all right, I thought.” Clover Baskerville in “The Party-Givers” (To See You Again) leaves behind her malicious friends when she realizes that she need not call them if she does not want to see them. All these characters have learned that “home is where the heart” not only “is” but also chooses to be. Adams’s heroines sometimes reach out from their lonely and isolated lives to find sympathetic bonds with poor or troubled people from other cultures. In “Greyhound People” (To See You Again), a divorced, middle-aged woman’s discovery of kinship with her (mostly black and poor) fellow commuters, along with her discovery that her commuter ticket will take her anywhere in California, is so liberating that she can finally break free of her repressive, domineering roommate and friend Hortense. In “Verlie I Say unto You” (Beautiful Girl), Jessica Todd’s sensitivity to her black maid Verlie’s humanity underscores a fundamental difference between herself and her insensitive husband (see also “The Break-in” in this regard). In “Mexican Dust” (To See You Again), Marian comes to prefer the company of the Mexican peasants to that of her husband, friends, and other Americans as they bus through Mexico on vacation; she abandons her party and returns to Seattle, where she plans to study Spanish, presumably to prepare for a return to Mexico alone. In fact, one sign of a strong character in Adams’s stories is a marked sensitivity to other cultures. Elizabeth, in the story by that name, purchases her Mexican beach house in the name of her Mexican servant Aurelia and leaves Aurelia in full possession of the house at her death. The central focus in “La Señora” (Return Trips) is the friendship between a wealthy, elderly American woman, who vacations annually at a Mexican resort, and Teodola, the Mexican maid in charge of her hotel room. Adams’s own concern for the human plight of those of other cultures can be seen in “Teresa,” in Return Trips, a story about the privation, terror, and grief of a Mexican peasant woman. “Molly’s Dog” and “A Public Pool” • In two of Adams’s most effective stories, female protagonists learn to live confidently with themselves: “Molly’s Dog” and “A Public Pool” (both from Return Trips). In the former, Molly returns with her homosexual friend Sandy to a small cabin by the ocean, where she experienced a love affair so intense she cannot think of it without weeping. A friendly dog attaches itself to
Adams, Alice
9
them on the beach and follows them as they leave; Molly pleads with Sandy to go back for the dog, but he drives faster, and the dog, though running, falls back and shrinks in the distance. Molly and Sandy quarrel over the dog, and Molly, realizing that she is much too dependent on men, comes to see less of Sandy back in San Francisco. She finally learns to think of the dog without pain but cannot forget it, and the place by the ocean becomes in her memory “a place where she had lost, or left something of infinite value. A place to which she would not go back.” In “A Public Pool,” the protagonist, though working class, neither part of the literary or artistic world nor so well educated as many of Adams’s female characters, shares with many of them a dissatisfaction with her body and a sense of being cut off and alone. She cannot bear to meet people or even look for a job (“We wouldn’t even have room for you,” she imagines an employer saying), so that life at the age of thirty is a grim existence in a cold apartment with a penurious mother. Though swimming offers an escape from home and a chance for meeting new people, it also has its fears: of exposing her body in the locker room and enduring the rebukes of strangers, of the faster swimmers whose lane she blocks, of the blond-bearded man who goes by so swiftly that he splashes her, and of a large black woman who tells her that she should stay by the side of the pool. After a few months of lap swimming, her body changes and her fear of others lessens. An early remark of the blond-bearded man made her babble nervously, but now she responds to his conventional questions with brief assent. On the day the black lady compliments her on her stroke and they leave the pool together, she is finally able to find a job and thinks of moving out of her mother’s apartment. She walks happily about the neighborhood, thinking that she and the black woman might become friends. At that moment, she meets in the street the blond-bearded man, who smells of chewing gum and is wearing “sharp” clothes from Sears. He invites her for coffee, but, “overwhelmed” by the smell of gum and realizing that “I hate sharp clothes,” she makes her excuses. Like other Adams women, she has experienced loneliness, but, also like many other women in these stories, she finds new strength that will mitigate her isolation by giving her independence. Yet it is primarily achieved by herself, and Adams’s always masterful use of language here is especially striking. As Adams’s character goes off independently from the blond-bearded man, she says confidently, “I leave him standing there. I swim away.” “You Are What You Own” and “To See You Again” • Not all these stories, however, end so conclusively; in others, it is unclear whether the heroines’ chosen resolutions to the problems confronting them will be satisfactory. The young housewife of “You Are What You Own: A Notebook” (Return Trips) lives in a house crammed with her domineering mother’s furniture, which the girl seems doomed to polish for all eternity. Her boring graduate-student husband complains that she does not polish the furniture enough and even starts to do it himself. She escapes in fantasy, fictionalizing the artists who live in a house down the street from her, assigning them her own names (not knowing their real ones), and indulging in imagined conversations with them. At the end of the story—recorded in her notebook—she tells her husband in a letter that she is leaving him the furniture and going to look for a job in San Francisco. Does she go? Is she capable? Similarly, the lonely young wife in “To See You Again” uses the image of a beautiful adolescent boy in her class to re-create the image of her husband as he was when they fell in love—slim and energetic, not as he is now, overweight and frequently paralyzed by chronic, severe depression. The story ends
10
Short Story Writers
with her fantasizing that somehow she has escaped her grim life with him, that things are as they once were, her husband somehow reclaimed in the body of the young student. “Beautiful Girl” • The story plots summarized here raise a possible objection to Adams’s fiction—that many of her female characters are too obsessed with the attention of men, even to the point where the women’s own highly successful careers seem to matter little. This issue, however, must be placed in historical perspective. Most of the women in her stories, like Adams herself, grew up and entered adulthood during the period after World War II, when women’s roles in American society were constricted, when women were sent home from their wartime jobs to take on what then seemed an almost patriotic duty: submitting themselves to the roles of wife and mother. From this point of view, Adams’s female characters are victims of that culture, dependent on men and falling desperately in love with them because they were expected to do just that. Given these crushing expectations, it is no wonder that Adams’s heroines feel lost when bereft, by divorce or widowhood, of the men in their lives. The young people in these stories often reach out to surrogate parents, usually mothers, when the incredible strain on the postwar nuclear family cracks and splinters it (a character in “Roses, Rhododendrons,” in Beautiful Girl, says “we all need more than one set of parents—our relations with the original set are too intense, and need dissipating”). Emblematic of the plight of this generation is Ardis Bascombe in “Beautiful Girl,” an ironic title because Ardis, though in her youth beautiful and popular, is now fleshy, drinking herself to death in her San Francisco apartment. She has failed as a wife and, as her filthy kitchen attests, failed as a homemaker. She had been independent enough to leave her unhappy marriage, but, like other women of her generation, despite her intelligence, idealism, courage, and sophistication, she was unable to make a new life. The life of this beautiful girl demonstrates graphically the destructive pressures on postwar women. The Last Lovely City • In this, her final collection of stories, Alice Adams also focuses on sophisticated contemporary women dealing with wandering husbands, belligerent children, and the tribulations of being divorced or widowed; however, because Adams was in her late sixties when she wrote most of these stories, her protagonists are older, albeit not always wiser, veterans of the domestic wars of the 1960’s and 1970’s. Adams was always a favorite of the judges of Prize Stories: The O. Henry Awards, and three of these stories were chosen for that prestigious collection: “The Islands” in 1993, “The Haunted Beach” in 1995, and “His Women” in 1996. Two of these are among the best stories in the collection, for they economically and without selfindulgence focus on futile efforts to repeat the past. What “haunts” the beach in “The Haunted Beach” is one woman’s previous marriage. Penelope Jaspers, a San Francisco art dealer, takes her new lover, a middle-aged superior court judge, to a West Coast Mexican resort that she and her dead husband used to visit. Although she remembers it as charming, she now sees it as “unspeakably shabby” and returns to San Francisco, having decided not to marry the judge. The persistence of the past also haunts “His Women,” as a university professor cannot reconcile with his lover because of memories of the previous women in his life. In the title story, Benito Zamora, a Mexican cardiologist and “sadhearted widow,” is forced to dredge up unpleasant moments from his past by an attractive young re-
Adams, Alice
11
porter who he mistakenly thinks is interested in him sexually. In “Old Love Affairs,” a woman’s living room is filled with keepsakes that remind her only that she is growing old and can no longer hope for love in her life. The last four stories in the book—“The Drinking Club,” “Patients,” “The Wrong Mexico,” and “Earthquake Damage”—are linked stories, somewhat like chapters of a novella, in which two Bay Area psychiatrists, who are sometimes lovers, move in and out of various affairs. Both are passive professionals, as are many Adams characters— watchers rather than active participants, caught in a recurrent round of unhappy marriages and unfulfilling affairs. The weakest stories in the collection—“The Islands,” “Raccoons,” and “A Very Nice Dog”—are simple paeans to pets. The most interesting, “The Islands,” begins with the sentence: “What does it mean to love an animal, a pet, in my case a cat, in the fierce, entire and unambivalent way that some of us do?” Although readers who share such a pet passion might find the question intriguing, many others will view this story about the death of a beloved cat as sentimental rather than sensitive. Although the fact that Adams died at the age of seventy-two, a few months after this book appeared, gives it some poignancy, on a purely critical level, these stories represent a falling off from the crisp and sophisticated stories of the writer in her prime. Timothy C. Frazer With updates by Louise M. Stone and Charles E. May Other major works novels: Careless Love, 1966; Families and Survivors, 1974; Listening to Billie, 1978; Rich Rewards, 1980; Superior Women, 1984; Second Chances, 1988; Caroline’s Daughters, 1991; Almost Perfect, 1993; A Southern Exposure, 1995; Medicine Men, 1997; After the War, 2000. nonfiction: Mexico: Some Travels and Some Travelers There, 1990. Bibliography Adams, Alice. Interview by Patricia Holt. Publishers Weekly 213 (January 16, 1978): 8-9. In talking about her life with interior designer Robert McNee, Adams emphasizes the importance of her work as the foundation for the self-respect necessary in a long-term relationship. Blades, L. T. “Order and Chaos in Alice Adams’ Rich Rewards.” Critique: Studies in Modern Fiction 27 (Summer, 1986): 187-195. In an issue devoted to four women writers—Adams, Ann Beattie, Mary Gordon, and Marge Piercy—Blades explores the artificially imposed order created by Adams’s female characters and the world of chaos that threatens it. Like Jane Austen’s characters, Adams’s women enter into unstable relationships but eventually realize that they must concentrate on work and friendships, not romance, to have a healthy self-respect. Bolotin, Susan. “Semidetached Couples.” Review of The Last Lovely City: Stories. The New York Times, February 14, 1999. Detailed review of Adams’s collection, commenting on several of the stories, particularly the characters and the social world in which they live. Chell, Cara. “Succeeding in Their Times: Alice Adams on Women and Work.” Soundings 68 (Spring, 1985): 62-71. Work is the catalyst that enables Adams’s characters to realize their self-worth. Chell provides an interesting treatment of this theme throughout Adams’s career.
12
Short Story Writers
Flower, Dean. “Picking Up the Pieces.” The Hudson Review 32 (Summer, 1979): 293307. Flower sets Adams among other American storytellers who look to the past for explanations and intensification of feelings. He explores how this orientation leads to a preoccupation with growing old. Herman, Barbara A. “Alice Adams.” In Contemporary Fiction Writers of the South, edited by Joseph M. Flora and Robert Bain. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1993. Brief biography and discussion of Adams’s novels and short stories; suggests her two major themes are the maturation of middle-class women seeking self-respect, identity, and independence and women’s relationships with husbands, lovers, and friends. Includes a survey of Adams’s own criticism and a bibliography of works by and about her. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Adams: “Greyhound People” (vol. 3); “Roses, Rhododendron” (vol. 6); and “Snow” and “Truth or Consequences” (vol. 7). Pritchard, William H. “Fictive Voices.” The Hudson Review 38 (Spring, 1985): 120-132. Pritchard examines Adams’s narrative voice in the context of other contemporary writers. Though the section on Adams is not long, it provides a useful approach to analyzing her stories. Upton, Lee. “Changing the Past: Alice Adams’ Revisionary Nostalgia.” Studies in Short Fiction 26 (Winter, 1989): 33-41. In the collection of stories, Return Trips, Adams’s female characters turn to memories of the past as their most valued possessions. Upton isolates three different relationships with the past and shows how each enables Adams’s characters to interpret nostalgic images so that they produce more satisfying relationships with the present. Woo, Elaine. “Alice Adams.” Los Angeles Times, May 29, 1999, p. B8. Biographical and critical sketch and tribute; notes Adams’s specialization in contemporary relationships among white, urban, middle- and upper-class women; charts her career and her critical reception.
13
Conrad Aiken Born: Savannah, Georgia; August 5, 1889 Died: Savannah, Georgia; August 17, 1973 Principal short fiction • The Dark City, 1922; Bring! Bring!, and Other Stories, 1925; Costumes by Eros, 1928; “Silent Snow, Secret Snow”, 1932; Impulse, 1933; Among the Lost People, 1934; “Round by Round”, 1935; Short Stories, 1950; Collected Short Stories, 1960; Collected Short Stories of Conrad Aiken, 1966. Other literary forms • Best known as a poet, Conrad Aiken published dozens of volumes of poetry from 1914 until his death in 1973. He also published novels, essays, criticism, and a play. In addition, he edited a considerable number of anthologies of poetry. Achievements • Conrad Aiken’s reputation as a writer of short fiction rests on two frequently anthologized short stories: “Silent Snow, Secret Snow,” which has twice been adapted to film, and “Mr. Arcularis,” which was adapted to a play. Although he published several collections of short stories—they were collected in one volume in 1950—he did not contribute significantly to the development of the short story. Biography • When Conrad Aiken was eleven, his father killed his mother and then committed suicide. This incident could very well have influenced the subject matter of a great number of his stories, where one step more may take a character to an immense abyss of madness or death. After graduating from Harvard University in 1911, Aiken became a member of the famous Harvard group that included T. S. Eliot, Robert Benchley, and Van Wyck Brooks. He published his first volume of poems in 1914. A contributing editor of The Dial from 1917 to 1919, Aiken later worked as London correspondent for The New Yorker. Through the course of his career he was the recipient of many awards, including the Pulitzer Prize in 1930 for Selected Poems (1929), the National Book Award in 1954 for Collected Poems (1953), and the Bollingen Prize in Poetry in 1956. He died in 1973 at the age of eighty-four. Analysis • The fictional “voice” in Aiken’s stories so closely approximates his poetic “voice” that his stories are often seen as extensions of his more famous poems. His best-known stories, “Silent Snow, Secret Snow” and “Mr. Arcularis” are both “poetic” expressions of characters’ psychological states. “Silent Snow, Secret Snow,” in fact, is often read as the story of a creative artist, a “poet” in a hostile environment. Aiken’s Freudian themes, his depiction of a protagonist’s inner struggle and journey, and his portrait of the consciousness—these are perhaps better expressed in lengthy poetic works than in prose or in individual poems, which are rarely anthologized because they are best read in the context of his other poems. “Silent Snow, Secret Snow” • In “Silent Snow, Secret Snow,” a story once included in almost every anthology of short fiction, Conrad Aiken describes a young boy’s alienation and withdrawal from his world. The story begins one morning in Decem-
14
Short Story Writers
ber when Paul Hasleman, aged twelve, thinks of the postman, whom the boy hears every morning. The progress of the postman as he turns the corner at the top of the hill and makes his way down the street with a double knock at each door is familiar to the boy, and, as he slowly awakens, he begins to listen for the sounds on the cobblestones of the street of heavy boots as they come around the corner. When the sounds come on this morning, however, they are closer than the corner and muffled and faint. Paul understands at once: “Nothing could have been simpler—there had been snow during the night, such as all winter he had been longing for.” With his eyes still closed, Paul imagines the snow—how it sounds and how it will obliterate the familiar sights of the street—but when he opens his eyes and turns toward the window, he sees only the bright morning sun. The miracle of snow has not transformed anything. The moment and his feelings about the snow, however, remain with him, and later in the classroom as his geography teacher, Miss Buell, twirls the globe with her finger and talks about the tropics, Paul finds himself looking at the arctic areas, which are colored white on the globe. He recalls the morning and the moment when he had a sense of falling snow, and immediately he undergoes the same experience of seeing and hearing the snow fall. As the days go by, Paul finds himself between two worlds—the real one and a secret one of peace and remoteness. His parents become increasingly concerned by his “daydreaming,” inattentive manner, but more and more he is drawn into the incomprehensible beauty of the world of silent snow. His secret sense of possession and of being protected insulates him both from the world of the classroom, where Deidre, with the freckles on the back of her neck in a constellation exactly like the Big Dipper, waves her brown flickering hand, and from the world at home where his parents’ concern and questions have become an increasingly difficult matter with which to cope. Aiken’s presentation of the escalation of Paul’s withdrawal is skillfully detailed through the use of symbols. The outside world becomes for Paul fragmented: scraps of dirty newspapers in a drain, with the word Eczema as the addressee and an address in Fort Worth, Texas; lost twigs from parent trees; bits of broken egg shells; the footprints of a dog who long ago “had made a mistake” and walked on the river of wet cement which in time had frozen into rock; the wound in an elm tree. In the company of his parents Paul neither sees them nor feels their presence. His mother is a voice asking questions, his father a pair of brown slippers. These images cluster together in such a way as to foreshadow the relentless progress of Dr. Howells down the street to Paul’s house, a visit which replicates the progress of the postman. The doctor, called by the parents because their concern has now grown into alarm over Paul’s behavior, examines the boy, and, as the examination and questioning by the adults accelerate, Paul finds the situation unbearable. He retreats further into his secret world where he sees snow now slowly filling the spaces in the room—highest in the corners, under the sofa—the snow’s voice a whisper, a promise of peace, cold and restful. Reassured by the presence of the snow and seduced by its whisperings and promises, Paul begins to laugh and to taunt the adults with little hints. He believes they are trying to corner him, and there is something malicious in his behavior: He laughed a third time—but this time, happening to glance upward toward his mother’s face, he was appalled at the effect his laughter seemed to have upon her. Her mouth had opened in an expression of horror. This was too bad! Unfortunate! He had known it would cause pain, of course—but he hadn’t expected it to be quite as bad as this. . . .
Aiken, Conrad
15
The hints, however, explain nothing to the adults, and, continuing to feel cornered, Paul pleads a headache and tries to escape to bed. His mother follows him, but it is too late. “The darkness was coming in long white waves,” and “the snow was laughing; it spoke from all sides at once.” His mother’s presence in the room is alien, hostile, and brutal. He is filled with loathing, and he exorcizes her: “Mother! Mother! Go away! I hate you!” With this effort, everything is solved, “everything became all right.” His withdrawal is now complete. All contact with the real world is lost, and he gives himself over to a “vast moving screen of snow—but even now it said peace, it said remoteness, it said cold, it said Library of Congress sleep.” Paul’s withdrawal is, as the snow tells him, a going inward rather than an opening outward: “It is a flower becoming a seed,” it is a movement toward complete solipsism and a closure of his life. “Strange Moonlight” • “Strange Moonlight,” another story of a young boy’s difficulty in dealing with the realities of life and death, could be a prelude to “Silent Snow, Secret Snow.” In “Strange Moonlight” a young boy filches a copy of Poe’s tales from his mother’s bookshelf and in consequence spends a “delirious night in inferno.” The next day the boy wins a gold medal at school which he later carries in his pocket, keeping it a secret from his mother and father. The desire to keep a secret recalls Paul’s need to keep from his parents his first hallucination of snow. The gold medal is “above all a secret,” something to be kept concealed; it is like a particularly beautiful trinket to be carried unmentioned in his trouser pocket. The week’s events include a visit to a friend’s house where the boy meets Caroline Lee, an extraordinarily strange and beautiful child with large pale eyes. Both Caroline Lee and the house in which she lives, with its long, dark, and winding stairways, excite and fascinate him. Within a few days, however, the boy learns that Caroline Lee is dead of scarlet fever. He is stunned: “How did it happen that he, who was so profoundly concerned, had not been consulted, had not been invited to come and talk with her, and now found himself so utterly and hopelessly and forever excluded—from the house as from her?” This becomes a thing he cannot understand. The same night he is confronted with another disturbing mystery. He overhears an intimate conversation between his father and mother. Filled with horror, the boy begins at once to imagine a conversation with Caroline Lee in which she comes back from the grave to talk with him. The next day his father unexpectedly takes the family to the beach, and the boy wanders away and finds a snug, secret hiding place on a lonely hot sand dune. He lies there surrounded by tall whispering grass, and Caroline’s imagined visit of the night before becomes real for him. Rather than ending in
16
Short Story Writers
unreality as one would expect, however, Aiken inexplicably brings the boy back to reality without resolving any of the problems set up in the story. He thus leaves a gap between the protagonist’s conflicts with sexuality, reality, and unreality, and their final resolution. “Your Obituary, Well Written” • In another story, however, “Your Obituary, Well Written,” Aiken presents a young man identified only as Mr. Grant, who confronts a similar circumstance. Told in the first person by the protagonist, Mr. Grant, the story repeats what is basically the same pattern of events. Although supposedly a portrait of Katherine Mansfield, to whom Aiken is strongly indebted for the forms his stories take, the character of Reiner Wilson is also strongly reminiscent of Caroline Lee, the little girl in “Strange Moonlight.” The narrator says of Reiner Wilson: “I was struck by the astonishing frailty of her appearance, an otherworld fragility, almost a transparent spiritual quality—as if she were already a disembodied soul.” Knowing from the first that she is not only married but also fatally ill, he manages to see her one time and fall in love with her, and then he almost simultaneously withdraws. “At bottom, however, it was a kind of terror that kept me away. . . . The complications and the miseries, if we did allow the meetings to go further might well be fatal to both of us.” The same conflicts which Paul, the child in “Silent Snow, Secret Snow,” experienced are again faced by the man who is not able to resolve the riddles of sex and love, life and death. The narrator never sees Reiner again, and at her death he is left on a park bench under a Judas tree wanting to weep, but unable to: “But Reiner Wilson, the dark-haired little girl with whom I had fallen in love was dead, and it seemed to me that I too was dead.” Another similarity between “Silent Snow, Secret Snow” and “Your Obituary, Well Written” is Aiken’s use of a natural element as major metaphor. In “Your Obituary, Well Written,” rain functions in the same manner that snow does in “Silent Snow, Secret Snow.” During Grant’s one meeting alone with Reiner Wilson, the room had suddenly darkened, and rain fell, sounding to him as though it were inside the room. The sensations the man feels in response to the rain are similar to those Paul feels in response to the snow. Grant tells Reiner about a time when as a boy he went swimming, and it began to rain: The water was smooth—there was no sound of waves—and all about me arose a delicious seething . . . [T]here was something sinister in it, and also something divinely soothing. I don’t believe I was ever happier in my life. It was as if I had gone into another world. Reiner calls Grant “the man who loves rain,” and her estimate of him is correct. Unable to open up himself, unable to make himself vulnerable and live in the real world, he is at the end of the story as withdrawn from reality as is Paul, who chooses the silent and secret snow. “Thistledown” • Besides dealing with various subconscious desires projected by means of hallucinating visions, many of Aiken’s stories reflect preoccupations of the times in which the stories were written. Chief among these themes is the changing roles of women and sexual mores of the 1920’s. In most of Aiken’s stories, these conflicts are presented through the male point of view. “Thistledown,” a first-person narrative told by a man who is married and living with his wife, opens with private musings of the narrator, wherein he associates a young woman named Coralyn with thistledown, which is being swept in every direc-
Aiken, Conrad
17
tion by the wind but which is ultimately doomed for extinction. Coralyn had been his wife’s secretary, and, attracted to her, Phillip, the narrator, became bent on seduction. Far from being “frighteningly unworldly,” Coralyn is a “new woman” who has had numerous lovers. He finds her cynical and detached, she finds him an oldfashioned and sentimental fool. The affair is brief. Coralyn leaves, and as the years pass she is in and out of his life, until she disappears altogether, leaving him bitter, disappointed, and angry. The irony that marks “Thistledown” is characteristic of the stories in which Aiken examines the conventional sexual mores, holding a doublefaced mirror to reflect the double standard by which men and women are judged. “A Conversation” • In “A Conversation,” the theme of double standards is examined within the framework of a conversation between two men, probably professors, taking place on a train in a sleeping car. The conversation is overheard by a visiting lecturer at the University who occupies the adjacent sleeping car. The lecturer is tired of “being polite to fools” and wants desperately to go to sleep; but the conversation he overhears keeps him awake, as do clock bells that ring marking every quarter hour. The conversation concerns the fiancée of one of the men, and the other is trying to convince his friend that the woman is not as innocent as she looks; indeed, she has been “manhandled.” The engaged man keeps trying to protect his own views of the woman: her central idealism, her essential holiness—views that attach themselves to women who are not prostitutes. By the end of the story, however, the point is made; the engagement will not last, and the woman will be put aside like a used razor or a cork that has been tampered with, images used earlier in the story. The clock bells do not ask a question; they simply continue to toll. In the end, the men cannot accept a female sexuality which is not exclusively directed toward a husband, although there is never a question about their own sexual behavior. Mary Rohrberger With updates by Thomas L. Erskine Other major works plays: Fear No More, 1946, pb. 1957 (as Mr. Arcularis: A Play). anthologies: A Comprehensive Anthology of American Poetry, 1929, 1944; Twentieth Century American Poetry, 1944. novels: Blue Voyage, 1927; Great Circle, 1933; King Coffin, 1935; A Heart for the Gods of Mexico, 1939; Conversation: Or, Pilgrim’s Progress, 1940; The Collected Novels of Conrad Aiken, 1964. nonfiction: Skepticisms: Notes on Contemporary Poetry, 1919; Ushant: An Essay, 1952; A Reviewer’s ABC: Collected Criticism of Conrad Aiken from 1916 to the Present, 1958; Selected Letters of Conrad Aiken, 1978. poetry: Earth Triumphant, and Other Tales in Verse, 1914; The Jig of Forslin, 1916; Turns and Movies, and Other Tales in Verse, 1916; Nocturne of Remembered Spring, and Other Poems, 1917; Senlin: A Biography, and Other Poems, 1918; The Charnel Rose, 1918; The House of Dust, 1920; Punch: The Immortal Liar, 1921; Priapus and the Pool, 1922; The Pilgrimage of Festus, 1923; Changing Mind, 1925; Priapus and the Pool, and Other Poems, 1925; Prelude, 1929; Selected Poems, 1929; Gehenna, 1930; John Deth: A Metaphysical Legend, and Other Poems, 1930; Preludes for Memnon, 1931; The Coming Forth by Day of Osiris Jones, 1931; And in the Hanging Gardens, 1933; Landscape West of Eden, 1934; Time in the Rock: Preludes to Definition, 1936; And in the Human Heart, 1940; Brownstone Eclogues,
18
Short Story Writers
and Other Poems, 1942; The Soldier: A Poem by Conrad Aiken, 1944; The Kid, 1947; Skylight One: Fifteen Poems, 1949; The Divine Pilgrim, 1949; Wake II, 1952; Collected Poems, 1953, 1970; A Letter from Li Po, and Other Poems, 1955; The Fluteplayer, 1956; Sheepfold Hill: Fifteen Poems, 1958; Selected Poems, 1961; The Morning Song of Lord Zero, 1963; A Seizure of Limericks, 1964; Cats and Bats and Things with Wings: Poems, 1965; The Clerk’s Journal, 1971; A Little Who’s Zoo of Mild Animals, 1977. Bibliography Aiken, Conrad. Selected Letters of Conrad Aiken. Edited by Joseph Killorin. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1978. Includes a representative sample of 245 letters (from some three thousand) written by Aiken. A cast of correspondents, among them T. S. Eliot and Malcolm Lowry, indexes to Aiken’s works and important personages, and a wealth of illustrations, mostly photographs, add considerably to the value of the volume. Butscher, Edward. Conrad Aiken: Poet of White Horse Vale. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1988. This critical biography emphasizes Aiken’s literary work, particularly the poetry. Butscher’s book nevertheless contains analyses of about fifteen Aiken short stories, including his most famous ones, “Silent Snow, Secret Snow” and “Mr. Arcularis.” Includes many illustrations, copious notes, and an extensive bibliography that is especially helpful in psychoanalytic theory. Dirda, Michael. “Selected Letters of Conrad Aiken.” The Washington Post, June 25, 1978, p. G5. A review of Aiken’s Selected Letters, with a brief biographical sketch; suggests that the letters will help redress the neglect Aiken has suffered. Hoffman, Frederick J. Conrad Aiken. New York: Twayne, 1962. The best overview of Aiken’s short fiction. Hoffman’s volume contains careful analyses of several individual stories, including “Mr. Arcularis,” which receives extensive discussion. Hoffman, who believes Aiken’s short stories are more successful than his novels, stresses “Aiken’s attitude toward New England, his obsession with “aloneness,” and his concern about human relationships. Contains a chronology, a biographical chapter, and an annotated bibliography. Lorenz, Clarissa M. Lorelei Two: My Life with Conrad Aiken. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1983. Lorenz, Aiken’s second wife, discusses the 1926-1938 years, the period when he wrote his best work, including the short stories “Mr. Arcularis” and “Silent Snow, Secret Snow.” She covers his literary acquaintances, his work habits, and the literary context in which he worked. The book is well indexed and contains several relevant photographs. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Aiken: “The Dark City” (vol. 2); “Impulse” (vol. 4); “Round by Round” (vol. 6); and “Silent Snow, Secret Snow” (vol. 7). Seigal, Catharine. The Fictive World of Conrad Aiken: A Celebration of Consciousness. De Kalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 1993. Chapters on the Freudian foundation of Aiken’s fiction, on his New England roots, and on many of his novels. Concluding chapters on Aiken’s autobiography, Ushant, and an overview of his fiction. Includes notes, selected bibliography, and index. Spivey, Ted R. Time’s Stop in Savannah: Conrad Aiken’s Inner Journey. Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 1997. Explores Aiken’s thought processes and how they translate to his fiction.
Aiken, Conrad
19
Spivey, Ted R., and Arthur Waterman, eds. Conrad Aiken: A Priest of Consciousness. New York: AMS Press, 1989. Though their focus is on Aiken’s poetry, Spivey and Waterman include essays on the short stories and a review of criticism of the short stories. Contains an extensive chronology of Aiken’s life and a lengthy description of the Aiken materials in the Huntington Library. Womack, Kenneth. “Unmasking Another Villain in Conrad Aiken’s Autobiographical Dream.” Biography 19 (Spring, 1996): 137. Examines the role of British poet and novelist Martin Armstrong as a fictionalized character in Aiken’s Ushant; argues that Aiken’s attack on Armstrong is motivated by revenge for Armstrong’s marriage to Aiken’s first wife.
20
Sherman Alexie Born: Spokane Indian Reservation, Wellpinit, Washington; October 7, 1966 Principal short fiction • The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, 1993; The Toughest Indian in the World, 2000; Ten Little Indians, 2003. Other literary forms • A prolific writer, Sherman Alexie has published more than three hundred stories and poems. His poetry and poetry/short fiction works include The Business of Fancydancing (1992), I Would Steal Horses (1992), First Indian on the Moon (1993), Old Shirts and New Skins (1993), Seven Mourning Songs for the Cedar Flute I Have Yet to Learn to Play (1994), Water Flowing Home (1994), The Summer of Black Widows (1996), One Stick Song (2000), and Dangerous Astronomy (2005). He has also written the novels Reservation Blues (1995), Indian Killer (1996), and Flight (2007), a contemporary story about an adolescent boy who is half Irish and half Native American. Achievements • Sherman Alexie began accruing his numerous accolades and awards while in college, including a Washington State Arts Commission poetry fellowship (1991) and a National Endowment for the Arts poetry fellowship (1992). He also won Slipstream’s fifth annual Chapbook Contest (1992), an Ernest Hemingway Foundation Award Citation, a Lila Wallace-Reader’s Digest Writer’s Award (1994), an American Book Award (1996), and The Ernest Hemingway Foundation/PEN Award for First Fiction. His first novel, Reservation Blues (1995), won the Before Columbus Foundation’s American Book Award, the Murray Morgan Prize, and prompted Alexie to be named one of Granta’s Best of Young American Novelists. Indian Killer (1996), his second novel, was listed as a New York Times notable book. Biography • A self-described Spokane/Coeur d’Alene Indian who believes “Native American” is a “guilty white liberal term,” Sherman Joseph Alexie, Jr., grew up in Wellpinit, Washington, on the Spokane Indian Reservation. His father, an alcoholic, spent little time at home, and his mother supported the family by selling hand-sewn quilts at the local trading post. Born hydrocephalic, Alexie spent most of his childhood at home voraciously reading books from the local library. He later attended high school outside the reservation. His academic achievements there secured him a place at Spokane’s Jesuit Gonzaga University in 1985. While there, he turned to alcohol as a means of coping with the pressure he felt to succeed. His goal to become a medical doctor was derailed by fainting spells in human anatomy class, and Alexie later transferred to Washington State University in 1987, where he began writing and then publishing his poetry and short stories. During a 1992 National Endowment for the Arts fellowship, he wrote his award-winning The Business of Fancydancing and The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven. With this success came sobriety. Drawing on his collection of short stories in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, Alexie wrote and directed the award-winning Smoke Signals (1998), the first feature film ever made with an all-Native American cast and crew. Alexie, his child, and wife Diane, a member of the Hidatsa nation and college counselor, settled in Seattle, Washington.
Alexie, Sherman
21
Analysis • According to Sherman Alexie in an interview with CINEASTE, the five major influences on his writing are “my father, for his nontraditional Indian stories, my grandmother for her traditional Indian stories, Stephen King, John Steinbeck, and The Brady Bunch.” It is no wonder then that Alexie’s work, in particular the short stories in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, has been described by American Indian Quarterly as resembling a “casebook of postmodernist theory” that revels in such things as irony, parody of traditions, and the mingling of popular and native cultures. The result is a body of work that allows Alexie to challenge and subvert the stereotypes of Native Americans seen in the mass media (the warrior, the shaman, the drunk) and explore what it means to be a contemporary Native American. In commenting on Native American poets and writers, writers such as Leslie Marmon Silko describe how Native American artists often create their strongest work when they write from a position of social responsibility. In Alexie’s case, his work is often designed to effect change by exposing other Indians and whites to the harsh realities of reservation life. In Alexie’s early work—work influenced by his own alcoholism and father’s abandonment (as seen in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven)—he uses the Spokane Indian community as a backdrop for his characters, who often suffer from poverty, despair, and substance abuse. Yet it is his use of dark humor and irony that enables these characters to survive both their own depressions and self-loathing and the attitude and activities of the often ignorant and apathetic white society. Alexie writes in his short story “Because My Father Always Said He Was the Only Indian Who Saw Jimi Hendrix Play ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’ at Woodstock”: On a reservation, Indian men who abandon their children are treated worse than white fathers who do the same thing. It’s because white men have been doing that forever and Indian men have just learned how. That’s how assimilation works. With sobriety, Alexie claims that from The Business of Fancydancing in 1992 to Smoke Signals in 1998, his personal vision of Indian society has brightened and his writing has moved from focusing on the effects to the causes of substance abuse and other selfdestructive behaviors. In CINEASTE, Alexie describes his growth as a writer in this way: As I’ve been in recovery over the years and stayed sober, you’ll see the work gradually freeing itself of alcoholism and going much deeper, exploring the emotional, sociological, and psychological reasons for any kind of addictions or dysfunctions within the [Indian] community. . . . It’s more of a whole journey, you get there and you get back. The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven • Alexie’s first collection of (only) short stories, The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, received much critical acclaim. Many of the Native American characters that he introduced in his earlier poetry—like the storyteller Thomas Builds-The-Fire and his friend Victor Joseph—appear here as vehicles through which Alexie illustrates how Indians survive both the hardships they face on reservations and the gulfs between similar and dissimilar cultures, time periods, and men and women. In a number of the twenty-two often autobiographical stories in this collection, Alexie infuses irony into tales that illustrate the destructive effects of alcohol on both children and adults on reservations. For example, in “The Only Traffic Signal on the
22
Short Story Writers
Reservation Doesn’t Flash Red Any More” he weaves the tradition of storytelling with the contemporary issue of how cultures create their own heroes. In this story, the narrator and his friend Adrian, both recovering alcoholics, are sitting on a porch playing Russian roulette with a BB gun. They stop and watch a local high school TO VIEW IMAGE, basketball player walk by with his friends. PLEASE SEE As the narrator talks, readers learn that contemporary heroes on the reservation PRINT EDITION are often basketball players, and stories OF THIS BOOK. about their abilities are retold year after year. Yet, these heroes, including the narrator himself, often succumb to alcoholism and drop off the team. From the narrator’s reminiscences, it becomes clear that, while all people need heroes in their lives, creating heroes on a reservation can be problematic. In “A Drug Called Tradition,” the nar© Marion Ettlinger rator tells the story of Thomas BuildsThe-Fire and the “second-largest party in reservation history” for which he pays with money he receives from a large utility company land lease. Although the narrator claims that “we can all hear our ancestors laughing in the trees” when Indians actually profit in this way, who the ancestors are truly laughing at is unclear. Are they laughing at the white people for spending a lot of money to put ten telephone poles across some land or the Indians for spending that money on large quantities of alcohol? Later in the story, Victor, Junior, and Thomas go off and experience a night of drug-induced hallucinations about the faraway past, the present, and future. In the present, the boys return to a time before they ever had their first drink of alcohol. From this story, readers learn that it is best for people to stay in the present and keep persevering and not become stuck in the past or an imagined future. Several of the stories in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven that were eventually adapted for the film Smoke Signals explore both the connections and fissures between people of different genders and similar or dissimilar cultures. In “Every Little Hurricane,” readers are introduced to nine-year-old Victor, who is awakened from his frequent nightmares by one of the many family fights, this one occurring between his uncles during a New Year’s Eve party. Memories of other seasonal alcohol and poverty-induced “hurricanes” ensue, such as that of the Christmas his father could not afford any gifts. At the end of the story, as all the relatives and neighbors pick themselves up and go home, Victor lies down between his father and mother, hoping that the alcohol in their bodies will seep into his and help him sleep. This story is about how Indians continue to be “eternal survivors” of many types of storms. In “Because My Father Always Said He Was the Only Indian Who Saw Jimi Hendrix Play ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’ at Woodstock,” the narrator details the love-hate relationship between his mother and his father (who would later leave the family), while using a popular music icon to illustrate how Native Americans and whites share
Alexie, Sherman
23
at least one common culture. The narrator of this story, the abandoned Victor, later teams up with former childhood friend and storyteller Thomas in “This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona,” to collect Victor’s father’s ashes in Phoenix. In their ensuing journey, the characters grow spiritually and emotionally, while exploring what it means today to be a Native American. Lisa-Anne Culp Other major works novels: Reservation Blues, 1995; Indian Killer, 1996; Flight, 2007. miscellaneous: The Business of Fancydancing: Stories and Poems, 1992; First Indian on the Moon, 1993; The Summer of Black Widows, 1996 (poems and short prose). poetry: I Would Steal Horses, 1992; Old Shirts and New Skins, 1993; The Man Who Loves Salmon, 1998; One Stick Song, 2000; Dangerous Astronomy, 2005. screenplays: Smoke Signals, 1998; The Business of Fancydancing, 2002. Bibliography Alexie, Sherman. “Sending Cinematic Smoke Signals: An Interview with Sherman Alexie.” Interview by Dennis West. CINEASTE 23, no. 4 (1998): 28-32. Discusses both the film Smoke Signals and short stories in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, followed by an interview with Alexie about his early influences and work. Andrews, Candace E. “This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 7. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Analysis of “This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona,” with sections on themes and meaning and style and technique. Also includes a detailed synopsis of the story. Baxter, Andrea-Bess. “Review of Old Shirts and New Skins, First Indian on the Moon, and The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven.” Western American Literature 29, no. 3 (November, 1994): 277-280. A review of the three works with commentary on the appeals of Alexie’s writing and its strengths. Bogey, Dan. Review of The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, by Sherman Alexie. Library Journal 118 (September 1, 1993). Admires Alexie’s narrative voice. Lincoln, Kenneth. Native American Renaissance. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1983. Gives a general social and literary overview of American Indian writers. Low, Denise. The American Indian Quarterly 20, no. 1 (Winter, 1996): 123-125. In examining Alexie’s work through a postmodern lens, Low discusses his characters and rhetorical strategies in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven and The Business of Fancydancing. May, Charles E. “The Toughest Indian in the World.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 7. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Student-friendly analysis of “The Toughest Indian in the World” that covers the story’s themes and style and includes a detailed synopsis. Schneider, Brian. Review of The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, by Sherman Alexie. Review of Contemporary Fiction 13 (Fall, 1993). Praises Alexie’s passionate lyrical voice. Silko, Leslie Marmon. “Bingo Man—Reservation Blues by Sherman Alexie.” The Nation 260, no. 23 (June 12, 1995): 856-860. A review, by a celebrated Native American writer, of Alexie’s short stories and poems with special focus on his first novel, Reservation Blues.
24
Isabel Allende Born: Lima, Peru; August 2, 1942 Principal short fiction • Cuentos de Eva Luna, 1990 (The Stories of Eva Luna, 1991). Other literary forms • Although greatly respected as a writer of short stories, Isabel Allende is probably better known for her writing in other genres. She published eight novels through 2006. These include La casa de los espíritus (1982; The House of the Spirits, 1985), which established her reputation, De amor y de sombra (1984), Eva Luna (1987), El plan infinito (1991), Hija de la fortuna (1999), Portrait sépia (2000; Portrait in Sepia, 2001), Zorro (2005; English translation, 2005), and Inés del alma mía (2006; Inés of My Soul, 2006). Allende has also published an account of her daughter’s death in Paula (1994); a memoir about her homeland, Mi país inventado (2003; My Invented Country: A Nostalgic Journey Through Chile, 2003); and a collection of humorous pieces poking fun at machismo, originally published in the magazine Paula, entitled Civilice a su troglodita (1974). In 1984 she published a collection of children’s stories in Spanish, La gorda de Porcelana. Two decades later, she returned to that genre with Ciudad de las bestias (2002; City of the Beasts, 2002), El reino del dragón de oro (2003; Kingdom of the Golden Dragon, 2004), and El bosque de los Pigmeos (2004; Forest of the Pygmies, 2005). Achievements • Isabel Allende has been the recipient of numerous prestigious literary prizes, including the Panorama Literario Novel of the Year (1983), Author of the Year in Germany (1984 and 1986), and the Grand Prix d’Évasion in France (1984), as well as the Colima prize for best novel in Mexico (1985). A 1993 film version of La casa de los espíritus, directed by Bille August, was a box-office success. Biography • Though Chilean by nationality, Isabel Angelica Allende was born in Lima, Peru, on August 2, 1942. The niece of the former Chilean president Salvador Allende, who died in September, 1973, during the military coup d’état engineered by Augusto Pinochet, Allende attended a private high school in Santiago, Chile, from which she graduated in 1959. She worked as a secretary at the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization until 1965. She married Miguel Frías in 1962, had a daughter, Paula, and a son, Miguel. In Santiago, she worked as a journalist, editor, and advice columnist for Paula magazine from 1967 to 1974 and as an interviewer for a television station from 1970 to 1975. She was also an administrator for Colegio Marroco, in Caracas, from 1979 to 1982. Allende divorced her husband in 1987 and married William Gordon in 1988. Her daughter died in 1993, and this event formed the basis of the novel named after her. Analysis • Isabel Allende’s literary career is notable in that it stands outside the shifting fashions of the Latin American literary scene. Since the 1960’s in Latin America the literary fashion has tended to favor intricate, self-conscious novels that test readers’ interpretative powers. Flying in the face of this trend, however, Allende’s novels favor content over form, reality over novelistic devices. Though her fiction has been
Allende, Isabel
25
dismissed by some critics as simply an imitation of Gabriel García Márquez’s work, especially his so-called Magical Realist style, it is clear that Allende enjoys unparalleled popularity. Her novels and short stories have attracted an enormous readership in Spanish as well as in English, French, and German. Allende tends to write plotcentered, reader-friendly fiction. Her stories often focus on love and sex as seen from a feminine perspective. The Stories of Eva Luna • The short-story collection The Stories of Eva Luna is essentially a sequel to her novel Eva Luna (1987), published three years earlier; thus the narrator of The Stories of Eva Luna is the Eva Luna who appeared in the earlier novel, that is, a resourceful, bright young woman who, though born to poverty, rises to riches as a result of becoming a famous soap-opera writer. Two of the stories provide a direct link to Eva Luna the novel. “El huésped de la maestra,” for example, finishes a story that was left unresolved in the novel. The novel describes how Inés, the schoolmistress of Santa Agua, saw her son brutally murdered at the hands of a local man, who caught him stealing mangoes in the garden. Riad Halabí, by an ingenious plan, managed to force the murderer to leave town. In the short story, readers learn that the murderer returns many years later to Santa Agua and is then killed by Inés in an act of revenge; much of the short story is taken up by a description of the ingenious way in which Halabí disposes of the body. Also related to the novel is the short story “De barro estamos hechos.” The novel introduces Rolf Carlé, a cameraman, who eventually becomes Eva’s companion. Here readers see firsthand his experience of the floods that ravaged the country and that caused a young girl called Azucena to die slowly and painfully, even while he was filming her. The short story focuses on how this experience has changed Rolf’s life. These two short stories can be seen as sequels to Allende’s long fiction and show continuity of theme and character. There are twenty-three short stories in The Stories of Eva Luna and only two of them, as described above, use the same characters that the novels do. In other words, above all, they are new stories that Eva Luna has invented for the enjoyment of her lover, Rolf Carlé. The overriding structure is provided by the theme of Alf layla walayla (fifteenth century; The Arabian Nights’ Entertainments, 1706-1708), in which the female narrator, Scheherazade, must tell a story each night in order to avoid being executed by the king. The collection of short stories opens, indeed, with Rolf Carlé asking the narrator, who, though unnamed, is obviously Eva Luna, to tell him a story that has never been told to anyone else. The first story, “Dos palabras,” explores the same theme. Here the protagonist, Belisa Crespusculario, wrote a speech for a man who wanted to become president; and she also gave him two secret words. The speech was an enormous success, but the Colonel soon discovers that he is fatally attracted to Belisa as a result of the linguistic spell she has cast over him. There are a number of themes that run through the stories. The most obvious one is that of sexuality and love, which forms the focus for nineteen of the twenty-three stories in the collection. Love is often presented as occurring purely through chance. In “Tosca,” for example, a love relationship begins in this short story as a result of the apparently insignificant fact that Leonardo is seen by Laurizia reading the score of the work Tosca by the famous Italian composer Giacomo Puccini. From this chance encounter a passionate affair develops. Of the nineteen stories that focus on love and sexuality, ten focus on illicit sex. A good example is “Si me tocaras el corazón,” which tells the story of Amadeo Peralta, who, while on a visit to Santa Agua, seduces a fifteen-year-old girl called Hortensia; when he tires of her, he decides to lock her
26
Short Story Writers
up permanently in the basement of a sugar refinery. Years later, some children hear monstrous noises coming from the basement, and Hortensia is discovered, diseased and at the brink of death, which leads to Amadeo’s discomfiture. The moral of this short story seems to be that unbridled sexual passion can have disastrous consequences. Some of the stories, such as “Boca de sapo,” “María, la boba,” and “Walimai,” explicitly allude to prostitution. Other themes covered in the stories include vengeance, as in “Una venganza,” in which revenge for rape is enacted on the rapist; the clash between cultures, as in “Walamai,” which describes the struggles between the tribe of the Sons of the Moon and the white man, told from an Indian perspective; the miracle, as in “Un discreto milagro,” which tells how Miguel, a priest, has his sight restored by a local saint, Juana de los Lirios; as well as predestination, as in “La mujer del juez,” a well-written, suspense story which focuses on the protagonists, Nicolás Vidal and Casilda Hidalgo, who conduct an illicit affair even though they know beforehand that it will lead to their deaths. One particularly powerful story, “Un camino hacia el norte,” contains a strong social critique. It describes how Claveles Picero, and her grandfather, Jesús Dionisio Picero, are tricked into giving up Claveles’s illegitimate son Juan to a United States adoption agency, which is later discovered to be a front for a contraband agency which sells human organs. The story ends with a description of their journey to the capital in an attempt to discover Juan’s fate; they, like the readers, fear the worst. The message is that poverty leads to exploitation and death. A common technique in the stories involves the story opening with a scene (whose import is not understood) and then cutting to the past, at which point the narrative of the lives of the main protagonists is told. This occurs in a number of stories, including “El camino hacia el norte” and “El huésped de la maestra.” Most of the stories are told in the third person, although some, such as “Walimai,” are told in the first person. Stephen M. Hart Other major works children’s literature: La gorda de porcelana, 1984; Ciudad de las bestias, 2002 (City of the Beasts, 2002); El reino del dragón de oro, 2003 (Kingdom of the Golden Dragon, 2004); El bosque de los Pigmeos, 2004 (Forest of the Pygmies, 2005). novels: La casa de los espíritus, 1982 (The House of the Spirits, 1985); De amor y de sombra, 1984 (Of Love and Shadows, 1987); Eva Luna, 1987 (English translation, 1988); El plan infinito, 1991 (The Infinite Plan, 1993); Hija de la fortuna, 1999 (Daughter of Fortune, 1999); Portrait sépia, 2000 (Portrait in Sepia, 2001); Zorro, 2005 (English translation, 2005); Inés del alma mía, 2006 (Inés of My Soul, 2006). miscellaneous: Afrodita: Cuentos, recetas, y otros afrodisiacos, 1997 (Afrodite: A Memoir of the Senses, 1998). nonfiction: Civilice a su troglodita: Los impertinentes de Isabel Allende, 1974; Paula, 1994 (English translation, 1995); Conversations with Isabel Allende, 1999; Mi país inventado, 2003 (My Invented Country: A Nostalgic Journey Through Chile, 2003). Bibliography Allende, Isabel. Conversations with Isabel Allende. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1999. Edited by John Rodden. A collection of interviews from the University of Texas’s Pan-American series.
Allende, Isabel
27
Correas Zapata, Celia. Isabel Allende: Life and Spirits. Houston, Tex.: Arte Público, 2002. The first biographical discussion of Allende in book form. This intimate glimpse of Allende’s life is written by her admiring but scholarly friend. De Carvalho, Susan. “The Male Narrative Perspective in the Fiction of Isabel Allende.” Journal of Hispanic Research 2, no. 2 (Spring, 1994): 269-278. Shows that “Walimai” is different from the other short stories in Los cuentos de Eva Luna in that it is written in the first person and from a male perspective. Argues that the firstperson, male perspective in this story represents the ideal narrative voice. García Pinto, Magdalena, ed. Women Writers of Latin America: Intimate Histories. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1991. Contains an excellent interview with Allende with a great deal of insight into the way she views her writing. It is here that Allende mentions that she sees herself as a troubadour going from village to village, person to person, talking about her country. Hart, Stephen M. White Ink: Essays on Twentieth-Century Feminine Fiction in Spain and Latin America. London: Tamesis, 1993. Sets Allende’s work within the context of women’s writing in the twentieth century in Latin America. Examines the ways in which Allende fuses the space of the personal with that of the political in her fiction and shows that, in her work, falling in love with another human being is often aligned with falling in love with a political cause. Levine, Linda Gould. Isabel Allende. New York: Twayne, 2002. This volume from Twayne’s World Authors series includes useful bibliographical references and an index. Marketta, Laurila. “Isabel Allende and the Discourse of Exile.” In International Women’s Writing, New Landscapes of Identity, edited by Anne E. Brown and Marjanne E. Gooze. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1995. This book is helpful both for Marketta’s analysis of Allende’s use of the language of exile and for other Allende materials in the collection. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Allende: “Clarisa” (vol. 2), “Toad’s Mouth” (vol. 7), and “Wicked Girl” (vol. 8). Roof, Maria. “W. E. B. Du Bois, Isabel Allende, and the Empowerment of Third World Women.” CLA Journal 39, no. 4 (June, 1996): 401-416. A good source for readers interested in the feminist elements in Allende.
28
Hans Christian Andersen Born: Odense, Denmark; April 2, 1805 Died: Rolighed, near Copenhagen, Denmark; August 4, 1875 Principal short fiction • Eventyr, 1835-1872 (The Complete Andersen, 1949; also Fairy Tales, 1950-1958; also The Complete Fairy Tales and Stories, 1974); It’s Perfectly True, and Other Stories, 1937; Andersen’s Fairy Tales, 1946; Hans Andersen’s Fairy Tales, 1953. Other literary forms • Hans Christian Andersen’s first publication was a poem in 1828, and his first prose work, a fantasy of a nightly journey titled Fodreise fra Holmens Canal til Østpynten af Amager (1829; a journey on foot from Holman’s canal to the east point of Amager), was an immediate success. He wrote six novels, of which Improvisatoren (1835; The Improvisatore, 1845) securely established his fame. His nine travel books began with En digters bazar (1842; A Poet’s Bazaar, 1846) and mainly concern his European travels. Other works are Billebog uden billeder (1840; Tales the Moon Can Tell, 1855) and I Sverrig (1851; In Sweden, 1852). His autobiographies are Levnedsbogen, 1805-1831 (1926; Diaries of Hans Christian Andersen, 1990), discovered fifty years after his death; Mit Livs Eventyr (1847; The Story of My Life, 1852); and the revised The Fairy Tale of My Life (1855). Other publications include his correspondence, diaries, notebooks and draft material, drawings, sketches, paper cuttings, and plays. Achievements • Although hailed as the greatest of all fairy-tale writers in any language, throughout most of his life, Hans Christian Andersen considered his fairy tales to be of far less importance than his other writings. He considered himself much more of a novelist, playwright, and writer of travel books. It was his fairy tales, however, that spread his fame across Europe and, immediately upon publication, were translated into every European language. Andersen was much more famous, courted, and honored abroad than in his native Denmark. In his later years, however, his compatriots did at last recognize Andersen’s greatness. He became a friend and guest to royalty, was made a state councillor, and had a touching tribute paid to him in the form of the statue of the Little Mermaid, which sits in the Copenhagen harbor. Biography • The son of a shoemaker, who died when Hans was eleven, and an illiterate servant mother, Hans Christian Andersen from his early childhood loved to invent tales, poems, and plays and to make intricate paper cuttings; he loved to recite his creations to any possible listener. Later he yearned to be a creative writer of divine inspiration and an actor. In 1819 he journeyed to Copenhagen where he lived through hard times but developed a talent for attracting benefactors. Among them was Jonas Collin, whose home became Andersen’s “Home of Homes,” as he called it, who acted as a foster father, and whose son Edvard became a close friend. Through Jonas’s influence and a grant from the king, Andersen attended grammar school (1822-1827) and struggled with a difficult headmaster as well as with Latin and Greek. Andersen never married, although he was attracted to several women, among them the singer Jenny Lind. Although he was very tall and ungainly in appearance, with large feet, a large nose, and small eyes, and although he was sentimental and excep-
Andersen, Hans Christian
29
tionally concerned with himself, his fears and doubts, Andersen enjoyed the company of Europe’s leading professionals and nobility, including kings and queens; in later life many honors were bestowed on him. His last nine years he lived at the home of the Moritz Melchiors, just outside Copenhagen, and he died there on August 4, 1875. Analysis • Following publication of his 1844 collection of tales, Hans Christian Andersen explained in a letter that he wanted his tales to be read on two levels, offering something for the minds of adults as well as appealing to children. Three examples of such adult tales, “The Snow Queen,” “The Shadow,” and “The Nightingale,” demonstrate how, as Andersen said, in writing from his own breast instead of retelling old tales he had found out how to write fairy tales. “The Snow Queen” • Comprising seven stories, “The Snow Queen” begins with a mirror into which people can look and see the good become small and mean and the bad appear at its very worst. Andersen could remember, in later years, that his father had maintained that “There is no other devil than the one we have in our hearts”; and this provides a clue to the plot and theme of “The Snow Queen.” Only when the demon’s followers confront heaven with the mirror does it shatter into fragments, but unfortunately those fragments enter the hearts of many people. The second story introduces Little Kay and Gerda, who love each other and the summer’s flowers until a fragment of the evil mirror lodges in Little Kay’s eye and another pierces his heart. Having formerly declared that if the Snow Queen visited he would melt her on the stove, Kay now views snowflakes through a magnifying glass and pronounces them more beautiful than flowers. He protests against the grandmother’s tales with a but for the logic of each one, and, apparently arrived at adolescence, transfers loyalty from the innocent Gerda to the knowing Snow Queen. He follows the visiting queen out of town and into the snowy expanses of the distant sky. The journey from adolescence to maturity becomes for Gerda her quest for the missing Kay, her true love and future mate. Fearing the river has taken Kay, she offers it her new red shoes; but a boat she steps into drifts away from shore, and, riding the river’s current, she travels far before being pulled ashore and detained by a woman “learned in magic.” Gerda here forgets her search for Kay until the sight of a rose reminds her. In one of the story’s most abstract passages, she then asks the tiger lilies, convolvulus, snowdrop, hyacinth, buttercup, and narcissus where he might be; but each tells a highly fanciful tale concerned with its own identity. The narcissus, for example, alludes to the Echo and Narcissus myth in saying “I can see myself” and fails to aid Gerda. Barefoot, Gerda runs out of the garden and finds that autumn has arrived. A crow believes he has seen Kay and contrives a visit with the Prince and Princess, who forgive the invasion of their palatial privacy and then outfit Gerda to continue her search. All her newly acquired equipage attracts a “little robber girl,” a perplexing mixture of amorality and good intentions, who threatens Gerda with her knife but provides a reindeer to carry Gerda to Spitsbergen, where the wood pigeons have reported having seen Kay. At one stop, the reindeer begs a Finnish wise woman to give Gerda the strength to conquer all, but the woman points out the great power that Gerda has already evidenced and adds, “We must not tell her what power she has. It is in her heart, because she is such a sweet innocent child.” She sends Gerda and the reindeer on their way, with Gerda riding without boots or mittens. Eventually the reindeer deposits her by a red-berry bush in freezing icebound Denmark, from which she walks to the Snow Queen’s palace.
30
Short Story Writers
Here she finds a second mirror, a frozen lake broken into fragments that is actually the throne of the Snow Queen; the queen calls it “The Mirror of Reason.” Little Kay works diligently to form the fragments into the word “Eternity,” for which accomplishment the Snow Queen has said he can be his own master and have the whole world and a new pair of skates. Gerda’s love, when she sheds tears of joy at finding Kay, melts the ice in his heart and the mirror within his breast; and Kay, himself bursting into tears at recovering Gerda and her love, finds that the fragments magically form themselves into the word “Eternity.” The two young people find many changes on their return journey but much the same at home, where they now realize they are grown up. The grandmother’s Bible verse tells them about the kingdom of heaven for those with hearts of children, and they now understand the meaning of the hymn, “Where roses deck the flowery vale,/ There Infant Jesus, thee we hail!” The flowers of love, not the mirror of reason, make Kay and Gerda inheritors of the kingdom of heaven, the Snow Queen’s elusive eternity. Only the style makes such stories children’s stories, for “The Snow Queen,” with devices such as the snowflakes seen under a microscope, obviously attacks empiricism; at the same time, the story offers the symbol of the foot, important to folklore, and the journey of Gerda through obstacles and a final illumination constitutes a “journey of the hero” as delineated by the mythologist Joseph Campbell. “The Shadow” • Andersen’s “The Shadow” presents an alter-ego with psychic dimensions well beyond the ken of children. The setting with which “The Shadow” begins reflects Andersen’s diary entries from his trip to Naples in June, 1846, when he found the sun too hot for venturing out of doors and began writing the story. With the hot sun directly overhead, the shadow disappears except in morning and evening and begins to assume a life of its own. Its activities, closely observed by its owner, the “learned man from a cold country,” leads him to joke about its going into the house opposite to learn the identity of a lovely maiden. The shadow fails to return, but the learned man soon grows a new shadow. Many years later, once more at home, the original shadow visits him but has now become so corporeal that it has acquired flesh and clothes. Further, it divulges, it has become wealthy and plans to marry. Its threeweek visit in the house opposite, it now reveals, placed it close to the lovely maiden Poetry, in whose anteroom the shadow read all the poetry and prose ever written. If the learned man had been there, he would not have remained a human being, but it was there that the shadow became one. Emerging thence he went about under the cover of a pastry cook’s gown for some time before growing into his present affluence. Later, the learned man’s writing of the good, the true, and the beautiful fail to provide him an income; only after he has suffered long and become so thin that people tell him he looks like a shadow does he accede to the shadow’s request that he become a traveling companion. Shadow and master have now exchanged places, but the king’s daughter notices that the new master cannot cast a shadow. To this accusation he replies that the person who is always at his side is his shadow. When the new master cannot answer her scientific inquiries, he defers to the shadow, whose knowledge impresses the princess. Clearly, she reasons, to have such a learned servant the master must be the most learned man on earth. Against the upcoming marriage of princess and shadow, the learned man protests and threatens to reveal the truth. “Not a soul would believe you,” says the shadow, and with his new status as fiancé he has the learned man cast into prison. The prin-
Andersen, Hans Christian
31
cess agrees that it would be a charity to deliver the learned man from his delusions and has him promptly executed. The fact that Poetry would make a human being divine or “more than human” gives Poetry the identity of Psyche, whose statue by Thorvaldsen Andersen had admired in 1833 in the Danish sculptor’s studio. (Also, Andersen in 1861 wrote a story called “The Psyche.”) In “The Shadow,” the human qualities with which Poetry’s presence infuses the shadow function for him as a soul. Thereafter, his incubation under the pastry cook’s gown provides him a proper maturation from which, still as shadow, he looks into people’s lives, spies on their evils and their intimacies, and acquires power over them. This phase of his existence explains the acquisition of wealth, but as the shadow grows human and powerful the learned man declines. The shadow, the other self of the learned man, reflects the psychic stress Andersen suffered in his relationship with Edvard Collin. What Andersen desired between himself and Collin has been recognized by scholars as the Blütbruderschaft that D. H. Lawrence wrote about—a close relationship with another male. Collin persisted, however, in fending off all Andersen’s attempts at informality, even in regard to the use of language. In the story the shadow is obviously Collin, whose separate identity thrives at the expense of the learned man’s—Andersen’s—psyche. Writing in his diary of the distress and illness brought on by a letter from Edvard Collin, Andersen contemplated suicide and pleaded “he must use the language of a friend” (1834); so also the story’s shadow rejects such language and commits the learned man to prison and to death. The problem of language appears twice in the story, although various translations diminish its effect. On the shadow’s first visit to his former master, his newly acquired affluence provides him with the daring to suggest that the learned man speak “less familiarly” and to say “sir” or—in other translations—to replace “you” with “thee” and “thou.” Frequently argued between Andersen and Collin as the question of Du versus De, the problem reappears in the story when the learned man asks the shadow, because of their childhood together, to pledge themselves to address each other as Du. (In some translations, this reads merely “to drink to our good fellowship” and “call each other by our names.”) In the shadow’s reply, Andersen improved on Collin’s objection by having the shadow cite the feel of gray paper or the scraping of a nail on a pane of glass as similar to the sound of Du spoken by the learned man. “The Emperor’s New Clothes” • Such touches of individuality made Andersen’s writing succeed, as evidenced by a tale he borrowed from a Spanish source, the tale of “The Emperor’s New Clothes,” which he said he read in a German translation from Prince don Juan Manuel. Andersen’s version improved on the original in several respects, including his theme of pretense of understanding as well as ridicule of snobbery and his ending with the objection of the child—an ending which Andersen added after the original manuscript had been sent to the publisher. Andersen’s talent for universalizing the appeal of a story and for capitalizing on personal experiences appears time and again throughout his many tales. Because of his grotesque appearance, which interfered with his longed-for stage career, Andersen knew personally the anguish of “The Ugly Duckling,” but his success as a writer made him a beautiful swan. His extreme sensitivity he wrote into “The Princess and the Pea,” detailing the adventures of a princess who could feel a pea through twenty mattresses. Andersen in this story borrowed from a folktale in which the little girl understands the test she is being put to because a dog or cat aids her by relaying
32
Short Story Writers
the information; however, Andersen contrived that her sensitivity alone would suffice. Nevertheless, some translators could not accept the idea of her feeling a single pea and changed the text to read three peas and the title to read “The Real Princess.” Andersen’s stories thus objectify psychic conditions, and among these his frequent association with nobility enabled him to depict with humor the qualities of egotism, arrogance, and subservience found at court. In “The Snow Queen” the crow describes court ladies and attendants standing around; the nearer to the door they stand the greater is their haughtiness. The footman’s boy is too proud to be looked at. The princess is so clever she has read all the newspapers in the world and forgotten them again. “The Nightingale” • One of Andersen’s best depictions of court life and, at the same time, one of his best satires is “The Nightingale,” which he wrote in honor of Jenny Lind, the singer known as the Swedish Nightingale. The story’s theme contrasts the artificial manners and preferences of the court with the natural song of the nightingale and the ways of simple folk. Far from the palace of the emperor of China where bells on the flowers in the garden tinkle to attract attention to the flowers, the nightingale sings in the woods by the deep sea, so that a poor fisherman listens to it each day and travelers returning home write about it. The emperor discovers this nightingale from reading about it in a book, but his gentleman-in-waiting knows nothing about it because it has never been presented at court. Inquiring throughout the court, he finds only a little girl in the kitchen who has heard it and who helps him find it. Brought to the court, it must sing on a golden perch, and, when acclaimed successful, it has its own cage and can walk out twice a day and once in the night with twelve footmen, each one holding a ribbon tied around its leg. When the emperor of Japan sends as a gift an artificial nightingale studded with diamonds, rubies, and sapphires, the two birds cannot sing together, and the real nightingale flies away in chagrin. The court throng honors the mechanical bird with jewels and gold as gifts, and the Master of Music writes twenty-five volumes about it. The mechanical bird earns the title of Chief Imperial Singer-of-the-Bed-Chamber, and in rank it stands number one on the left side, for even an emperor’s heart is on the left side. Eventually the mechanical bird breaks down, and the watchmaker cannot assure repair with the same admirable tune. Five years later the emperor becomes ill, and his successor is proclaimed. Then, with Death sitting on his chest and wearing his golden crown, he calls on the mechanical bird to sing. Although it sits mute, the nightingale appears at the window and sings Death away and brings new life to the emperor. With the generosity of a true heroine, it advises the king not to destroy the mechanical bird, which did all the good it could; however, it reminds the emperor, a little singing bird sings to the fisherman and the peasant and must continue to go and to return. Although it loves the emperor’s heart more than his crown, the crown has an odor of sanctity also. The nightingale will return, but the emperor must keep its secret that a little bird tells him everything. Andersen’s comment comparing the heart and the crown of the emperor may be his finest on the attraction of the great, an attraction which he felt all his life. Early in 1874, after visiting a count in South Zealand, he wrote to Mrs. Melchior that no fairy tales occurred to him any more. If he walks in the garden, he said, Thumbelina has ended her journey on the water lily; the wind and the Old Oak Tree have already told him their tales and have nothing more to tell him. It is, he wrote, as if he had filled
Andersen, Hans Christian
33
out the entire circle with fairy-tale radii close to one another. On his seventieth birthday, April 2, 1875, the royal carriage was sent to fetch him to the castle, and the king bestowed another decoration. It was his last birthday celebration, for in a few months Andersen had filled out the circle of his life. Grace Eckley With updates by Leslie A. Pearl Other major works plays: Kjœrlighed paa Nicolai Taarn: Elle, Hvad siger Parterret, pr. 1829; Agnete og havmanden, pr. 1833; Mulatten, pr. 1840. novels: Improvisatoren, 1835 (2 volumes; The Improvisatore, 1845); O. T., 1836 (English translation, 1845); Kun en Spillemand, 1837 (Only a Fiddler, 1845); De To Baronesser, 1848 (The Two Baronesses, 1848); At vœre eller ikke vœre, 1857 (To Be or Not to Be, 1857); Lykke-Peer, 1870 (Lucky Peer, 1871). miscellaneous: The Collected Works of Hans Christian Andersen, 1870-1884 (10 volumes). nonfiction: Fodreise fra Holmens Canal til Østpynten af Amager, 1829; Skyggebilleder af en reise til Harzen, det sachiske Schweitz, 1831 (Rambles in the Romantic Regions of the Hartz Mountains, Saxon Switzerland, etc., 1848); Billebog uden billeder, 1840 (Tales the Moon Can Tell, 1855); En digters bazar, 1842 (A Poet’s Bazaar, 1846); I Sverrig, 1851 (In Sweden, 1852); Mit Livs Eventyr, 1855 (The True Story of My Life, 1847; also as The Fairy Tale of My Life, 1855); I Spanien, 1863 (In Spain, 1864); Et besøg i Portugal, 1866 (A Visit to Portugal, 1870); Levnedsbogen, 1805-1831, 1926 (Diaries of Hans Christian Andersen, 1990). poetry: Digte, 1830. Bibliography Andersen, Jens. Hans Christian Andersen: A New Life. Woodstock, N.Y.: Overlook Press, 2005. Highly readable and useful biography examining the writer’s life and literary work. Book, Frederik. Hans Christian Andersen. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1962. This biography studies Andersen’s personal and literary history. It considers how psychiatry, folklore, and the history of religion affected Andersen’s life. Andersen’s autobiographies are examined in the light of what was real and what was the fairy tale he was creating about his life. Contains illustrations of his fairy tales and photographs. Bresdorff, Elias. Hans Christian Andersen: The Story of His Life and Work, 1805-1875. New York: Noonday Press, 1994. This book is divided in two sections: The first part is a biographical study of Andersen’s complex personality; the second is a critical study of his most famous fairy tales and stories. Dollerup, Cay. “Translation as a Creative Force in Literature: The Birth of the European Bourgeois Fairy-Tale.” The Modern Language Review 90 (January, 1995): 94102. Discusses the European bourgeois fairy tale’s development as the result of translation of the stories of the Brothers Grimm into Danish and the stories of Hans Christian Andersen into German because children would not be familiar with foreign languages. Argues that the Grimms and Andersen were adapted to European middle-class values. Grobech, Bo. Hans Christian Andersen. Boston: Twayne, 1980. Grobech provides a solid introduction to Andersen’s life told in entertaining narrative style. The book
34
Short Story Writers
includes studies of Andersen’s fairy tales, his international influence, and his influence in the twentieth century. It can be read by the general reader as well as literary specialists. Johansen, Jorgen Dines. “The Merciless Tragedy of Desire: An Interpretation of H. C. Andersen’s Den lille Havfrue.” Scandinavian Studies 68 (Spring, 1996): 203241. Provides a psychoanalytic interpretation of “The Little Mermaid,” focusing on the tension between earthly love and religious reparation in the story. Discusses the themes of love and salvation in an extensive analysis of love and sexuality in the tale. Nassaar, Christopher S. “Andersen’s ‘The Shadow’ and Wilde’s ‘The Fisherman and His Soul’: A Case of Influence.” Nineteenth-Century Literature 50 (September, 1995): 217-224. Argues that Oscar Wilde’s tale is a Christian response to Andersen’s nihilistic tale. Claims that, while Andersen’s tale is about the triumph of evil, Wilde’s story is about the triumph of Christian love. ____________. “Andersen’s ‘The Ugly Ducking’ and Wilde’s ‘The Birthday of the Infanta.’” The Explicator 55 (Winter, 1997): 83-85. Discusses the influence of Andersen’s “The Ugly Duckling” on Wilde’s story. Argues that, in spite of the surface differences, Wilde’s story is a direct reversal of Andersen’s. Rossel, Sven Hakon, ed. Hans Christian Andersen: Danish Writer and Citizen of the World. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1996. This scholarly collection of essays establishes Andersen as a major European writer of the nineteenth century. Special attention is given to his biography as well as his travel writing and fairy tales. Spink, Reginald. Hans Christian Andersen and His World. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1972. Excellent overview of Andersen’s life. Emphasizes how his background and childhood affected his art. Extensively illustrated with photographs, drawings, and reprints of the illustrated fairy tales in several foreign-language editions. Wullschlager, Jackie. Hans Christian Andersen: The Life of a Storyteller. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2001. Thorough biography of the writer.
35
Sher wood Anderson Born: Camden, Ohio; September 13, 1876 Died: Colón, Panama Canal Zone (now in Panama); March 8, 1941 Principal short fiction • The Triumph of the Egg, 1921; Horses and Men, 1923; Death in the Woods, and Other Stories, 1933; The Sherwood Anderson Reader, 1947. Other literary forms • Sherwood Anderson published seven novels, collections of essays, memoirs, poetry, and dramatizations of Winesburg, Ohio, as well as other stories. He was a prolific article writer and for a time owned and edited both the Republican and Democratic newspapers in Marion, Virginia. In 1921, he received a twothousand-dollar literary prize from The Dial magazine. While employed as a copywriter, Anderson wrote many successful advertisements. Achievements • Sherwood Anderson, a protomodernist, is generally accepted as an innovator in the field of the short story despite having produced only one masterpiece, Winesburg, Ohio. In his work, he not only revolutionized the structure of short fiction by resisting the literary slickness of the contrived plot but also encouraged a simple and direct prose style, one which reflects the spare poetry of ordinary American speech. Anderson’s thematic concerns were also innovative. He was one of the first writers to dramatize the artistic repudiation of the business world and to give the craft of the short story a decided push toward presenting a slice of life as a significant moment. His concern with the “grotesques” in society—the neurotics and eccentrics—is also innovative as is the straightforward attention he pays to his characters’ sexuality. Anderson’s contemporaries Ernest Hemingway, William Faulkner, and John Steinbeck were influenced by his work, as were several later writers: Carson McCullers, Flannery O’Connor, Saul Bellow, Bobbie Ann Mason, and Raymond Carver. Biography • Sherwood Anderson was the third of seven children of a father who was an itinerant harness maker, house painter and a mother of either German or Italian descent. His father was a Civil War veteran (a Southerner who fought with the Union), locally famed as a storyteller. His elder brother, Karl, became a prominent painter who later introduced Sherwood to Chicago’s Bohemia, which gained him access to the literary world. Declining fortunes caused the family to move repeatedly until they settled in Clyde, Ohio (the model for Winesburg), a village just south of Lake Erie. The young Anderson experienced a desultory schooling and worked at several jobs: as a newsboy, a housepainter, a stableboy, a farmhand, and a laborer in a bicycle factory. After serving in Cuba during the Spanish-American War (he saw no combat), he acquired a further year of schooling at Wittenberg Academy in Springfield, Ohio, but remained undereducated throughout his life. Jobs as advertising copywriter gave him a first taste of writing, and he went on to a successful business career. In 1912, the central psychological event of his life occurred. He suffered a nervous breakdown, which led him to walk out of his paint factory job in Elyria, Ohio. He moved to
36
Short Story Writers
Chicago, where he began to meet writers such as Floyd Dell, Carl Sandburg, and Ben Hecht, a group collectively known as the Chicago Renaissance. A significant nonliterary contact was Dr. Trigant Burrow of Baltimore, who operated a Freudian therapeutic camp in Lake Chateaugay, New York, during the summers of 1915 and 1916. It should be noted, however, that Anderson ultimately rejected scientific probing of the psyche, for he typically believed that the human mind is static and incapable of meaningful change for the better. Publication of Winesburg, Ohio catapulted him into prominence, and he traveled to Europe in 1921, where he became acquainted with Gertrude Stein, Ernest Hemingway, and James Joyce. In 1923, while Library of Congress living in New Orleans, he shared an apartment with William Faulkner. Anderson married and divorced four times. He and his first wife had three children. His second wife, Tennessee Mitchell, had been a lover to Edgar Lee Masters, author of the Spoon River Anthology (1915). His last wife, Eleanor Copenhaver, had an interest in the southern labor movement, which drew Anderson somewhat out of his social primitivism, and, for a time in the 1930’s, he became a favorite of communists and socialists. His death, in Colón, Panama Canal Zone, while on a voyage to South America, was notable for its unique circumstances: He died of peritonitis caused by a toothpick accidentally swallowed while eating hors d’œuvres. Analysis • Sherwood Anderson’s best-known and most important work is the American classic, Winesburg, Ohio. It is a collection of associated short stories set in the mythical town of Winesburg in the latter part of the nineteenth century. The stories catalog Anderson’s negative reaction to the transformation of Ohio from a largely agricultural to an industrial society, which culminated about the time he was growing up in the village of Clyde in the 1880’s. Its twenty-five stories are vignettes of the town doctor; the voluble baseball coach; the still attractive but aging-with-loneliness high school teacher; the prosperous and harsh farmer-turned-religious fanatic; the dirt laborer; the hotel keeper; the banker’s daughter, and her adolescent suitors; the Presbyterian minister struggling with temptation; the town drunk; the town rough; the town homosexual; and the town “half-wit.” The comparison to Masters’s Spoon River Anthology is obvious: Both works purport to reveal the secret lives of small-town Americans living in the Middle West, and ironically both owe their popular success to the elegiac recording of this era, which most Americans insist on viewing idyllically. Anderson’s work, however, differs by more directly relating sexuality to the bizarre behavior of many of his characters and by employing a coherent theme. That theme is an exploration of psychological “grotesques”—the casualties of economic progress—and how these grotesques participate in the maturing of George
Anderson, Sherwood
37
Willard, the teenage reporter for the Winesburg Eagle, who at the end of the book departs for a bigger city to become a journalist. By then his sometimes callous ambition to get ahead has been tempered by a sense of what Anderson chooses to call “sophistication,” the title of the penultimate story. The achievement of George’s sophistication gives Winesburg, Ohio its artistic movement but makes it problematic for many critics and thoughtful Americans. “The Book of the Grotesque” • The prefacing story defines grotesques. A dying old writer hires a carpenter to build up his bed so that he can observe the trees outside without getting out of it. (While living in Chicago in 1915 Anderson had his own bed similarly raised so that he could observe the Loop.) After the carpenter leaves, the writer returns to his project—the writing of “The Book of the Grotesque,” which grieves over the notion that in the beginning of the world there were a great many thoughts but no such thing as a “truth.” People turned these thoughts into many beautiful truths such as the truth of passion, wealth, poverty, profligacy, carelessness, and others; a person could then appropriate a single one of these truths and try to live by it. It was thus that a person would become a grotesque—a personality dominated by an overriding concern which in time squeezed out other facets of life. This epistemological fable, which involves a triple-reduction, raises at least two invalidating questions: First, Can there be “thoughts” without the truth to establish the self-differentiating process which generates thought?, and second, If universals are denied and all truths have equal value (they are all beautiful), then why should a person be condemned for choosing only one of these pluralistic “truths”? “Hands” • The stories in Winesburg, Ohio nevertheless do grapple with Anderson’s intended theme, and a story such as “Hands” clearly illustrates what he means by a grotesque. The hands belong to Wing Biddlebaum, formerly Adolph Myers, a teacher in a Pennsylvania village who was beaten and run out of town for caressing boys. Anderson is delicately oblique about Wing’s homosexuality, for the story focuses on how a single traumatic event can forever after rule a person’s life—Wing is now a fretful recluse whose only human contact occurs when George Willard visits him occasionally. George puzzles over Wing’s expressive hands but never fathoms the reason for his suffering diffidence. “Hands,” besides giving first flesh to the word grotesque, makes readers understand that a character’s volition is not necessarily the factor that traps him into such an ideological straitjacket; sympathy can therefore be more readily extended. “The Philosopher” • “The Philosopher” provides a more subtle illustration of a grotesque and introduces the idea that a grotesque need not be pitiable or tragic; in fact, he can be wildly humorous, as demonstrated at the beginning of the story with the philosopher’s description: Doctor Parcival, the philosopher, was a large man with a drooping mouth covered by a yellow moustache . . . he wore a dirty white waistcoat out of whose pocket protruded a number of black cigars . . . there was something strange about his eyes: the lid of his left eye twitched; it fell down and it snapped up; it was exactly as though the lid of the eye were a window shade and someone stood inside playing with the cord.
38
Short Story Writers
It is George Willard’s misfortune that Dr. Parcival likes him and uses him as a sounding board for his wacky pomposity. He wishes to convince the boy of the advisability of adopting a line of conduct that he himself is unable to define but amply illustrates with many “parables” which add up to the belief (as George begins to suspect) that all men are despicable. He tells George that his father died in an insane asylum, and then he continues on about a Dr. Cronin from Chicago who may have been murdered by several men, one of whom could have been yours truly, Dr. Parcival. He announces that he actually arrived in Winesburg to write a book. About to launch on the subject of the book, he is sidetracked into the story of his brother who worked for the railroad as part of a roving paint crew (which painted everything orange); on payday the brother would place his money on the kitchen table—daring any member of the family to touch it. The brother, while drunk, is run over by the rail car housing the other members of his crew. One day George drops into Dr. Parcival’s office for his customary morning visit and discovers him quaking with fear. Earlier a little girl had been thrown from her buggy, and the doctor had inexplicably refused to heed a passerby’s call (perhaps because he is not a medical doctor). Other doctors, however, arrived on the scene, and no one noticed Dr. Parcival’s absence. Not realizing this, the doctor shouts to George that he knows human nature and that soon a hanging party will be formed to hang him from a lamppost as punishment for his callous refusal to attend to the dying child. When his certainty dissipates, he whimpers to George, “If not now, sometime.” He begs George to take him seriously and asks him to finish his book if something should happen to him; to this end he informs George of the subject of the book, which is: Everyone in the world is Christ, and they are all crucified. Many critics have singled out one or another story as the best in Winesburg, Ohio; frequently mentioned are “The Untold Lie,” “Hands,” and “Sophistication.” However, aside from the fact that this may be an unfair exercise—because the stories in Winesburg, Ohio were written to stand together—these choices bring out the accusation that much of Anderson’s work has a “setup” quality—a facile solemnity which makes his fictions manifest. “The Philosopher” may be the best story because Dr. Parcival’s grotesqueness eludes overt labeling; its finely timed humor reveals Anderson’s ability to spoof his literary weaknesses, and the story captures one of those character types who, like Joe Welling of “A Man of Ideas,” is readily observable and remembered but proves irritatingly elusive when set down. “Godliness” • Anderson exhibits a particular interest in the distorting effect that religious mania has on the personality, and several stories in Winesburg, Ohio attack or ridicule examples of conspicuous religiosity. “Godliness,” a tetralogy with a gothic flavor, follows the life of Jesse Bentley, a wealthy, progressive farmer who poisons the life of several generations of his relatives with his relentless harshness until he becomes inflamed by Old Testament stories and conceives the idea of replicating an act of animal sacrifice. Because of this behavior, he succeeds in terrifying his fifteen-yearold grandson, the only person he loves, who flees from him never to be heard from again, thus breaking the grandfather’s spirit. “The Strength of God” • Two stories, “The Strength of God” and “The Teacher,” are juxtaposed to mock cleverly a less extravagant example of piety. The Reverend Curtis Hartman espies Kate Swift, the worldly high school teacher, reading in bed
Anderson, Sherwood
39
and smoking a cigarette. The sight affronts and preoccupies him and plunges him into a prolonged moral struggle, which is resolved when one night he observes her kneeling naked by her bed praying. He smashes the window through which he has been watching her and runs into George Willard’s office shouting that Kate Swift is an instrument of God bearing a message of truth. Kate remains entirely oblivious of the Reverend Hartman, for she is preoccupied with George, in whom she has detected a spark of literary genius worthy of her cultivation. Her praying episode—an act of desperation which Hartman mistook for a return to faith—was the result of her realization, while in George’s arms, that her altruism had turned physical. “Sophistication” • It is exposure to these disparate egoisms, the death of his mother and a poignant evening with Helen White, the banker’s daughter, which are gathered into the components of George’s “sophistication,” the achievement of which causes him to leave town. George’s departure, however, has a decidedly ambivalent meaning. Anderson as well as other writers before and after him have shown that American small-town life can be less than idyllic, but Winesburg, Ohio is problematic because it is not simply another example of “the revolt from the village.” In the story “Paper Pills,” the narrator states that apples picked from Winesburg orchards will be eaten in city apartments that are filled with books, magazines, furniture, and people. A few rejected apples, however, which have gathered all their sweetness in one corner and are delicious to eat, remain on the trees and are eaten by those who are not discouraged by their lack of cosmetic appeal. Thus the neuroses of Anderson’s grotesques are sentimentalized and become part of his increasingly strident polemic against rationality, the idea of progress, mechanization, scientific innovation, urban culture, and other expressions of social potency. Anderson never wonders why pastorals are not written by pastors but rather by metropolitans whose consciousnesses are heightened by the advantages of urban life; his own version of a pastoral, Winesburg, Ohio, was itself written in Chicago. Anderson published three other collections of short stories in his lifetime, and other stories which had appeared in various magazines were posthumously gathered by Paul Rosenfeld in The Sherwood Anderson Reader. These are anthologies with no common theme or recurring characters, although some, such as Horses and Men, portray a particular milieu such as the racing world or rustic life. Many of the stories, and nearly all those singled out by the critics for their high quality, are first-person narratives. They are told in a rambling, reminiscent vein and are often preferred to those in Winesburg, Ohio because they lack a staged gravity. The grotesques are there, but less as syndromes than as atmospheric effects. “Death in the Woods” • The gothic nature of the later stories becomes more pronounced, and violence, desolation, and decay gain ascendancy in his best story, “Death in the Woods,” from the collection of the same name. This work also has another dimension: It is considered “to be among that wide and interesting mass of creative literature written about literature,” for, as the narrator tells the story of the elderly drudge who freezes to death while taking a shortcut through the snowy woods, he explains that as a young man he worked on the farm of a German who kept a bound servant like the young Mrs. Grimes. He recalls the circular track that her dogs made about her body while growing bold enough to get at her bag of meat when he himself has an encounter with dogs on a moonlit winter night. When the woman’s body is found and identified, the townspeople turn against her ruffian husband and
40
Short Story Writers
son and force them out of town, and their dwelling is visited by the narrator after it becomes an abandoned and vandalized hulk. Because Mrs. Grimes is such an unobtrusive and inarticulate character, the narrator is forced to tell her story, as well as how he gained each aspect of the story, until the readers’ interest is awakened by the uncovering of the narrator’s mental operations. This process leads the narrator to ponder further how literature itself is written and guides him to the final expansion: consciousness of his own creative processes. The transfer of interest from the uncanny circumstances of Mrs. Grimes’s death to this awareness of human creativity lends some credibility to Sherwood Anderson’s epitaph, “Life, Not Death, Is the Great Adventure.” “The Man Who Became a Woman” • “The Man Who Became a Woman,” from Horses and Men, is another critic’s choice. A young horse groom is sneaking a drink at a bar and imagines that his image on the counter mirror is that of a young girl. He becomes involved in an appalling barroom brawl (its horror contradicts the popular image of brawls in Westerns), and later, while sleeping nude on top of a pile of horse blankets, he is nearly raped by two drunken black grooms who mistake him for a slim young woman. The several strong foci in this long story tend to cancel one another out, and the built-in narrative devices for explaining the reason for the telling of the story succeed only in giving it a disconnected feel, although it is the equal of “Death in the Woods” in gothic details. “I Am a Fool” • “I Am a Fool,” also from Horses and Men, is Anderson’s most popular story. Here a young horse groom describes a humiliation caused less by his own gaucheness with the opposite sex than by the gulf of social class and education which separates him from the girl. The story re-creates the universe of adolescent romance so well presented in Winesburg, Ohio and brings a knowing smile from all manner of readers. “The Egg” • In “The Egg” (from The Triumph of the Egg), a husband-and-wife team of entrepreneurs try their hand at chicken-raising and running a restaurant. They fail at both, and the cause in both instances is an egg. This is a mildly humorous spoof on the American penchant for quick-success schemes, which nevertheless does not explain the praise the story has been given. “The Corn Planting” • “The Corn Planting” (from The Sherwood Anderson Reader) is Anderson without histrionics. An elderly farm couple are told that their city-dwelling son has been killed in an automobile accident. In response, the pair rig a planting machine and set about planting corn in the middle of the night while still in their nightgowns. At this concluding point, a generous reader would marvel at this poignant and internally opportune description of a rite of rejuvenation. An obdurate one would mutter Karl Marx’s dictum on the idiocy of rural life (not quite apropos since Marx was referring to European peasants, not technologically advanced American farmers); but this reader shall remark that the story itself functions within its confines and breezily add that Anderson’s favorite appellation (and the title of one of his short stories) was “An Ohio Pagan.” Julian Grajewski With updates by Cassandra Kircher
Anderson, Sherwood
41
Other major works plays: Plays: Winesburg and Others, pb. 1937. novels: Windy McPherson’s Son, 1916; Marching Men, 1917; Winesburg, Ohio, 1919; Poor White, 1920; Many Marriages, 1923; Dark Laughter, 1925; Beyond Desire, 1932; Kit Brandon, 1936. nonfiction: A Story Teller’s Story, 1924; The Modern Writer, 1925; Sherwood Anderson’s Notebook, 1926; Tar: A Midwest Childhood, 1926; Hello Towns!, 1929; Perhaps Women, 1931; No Swank, 1934; Puzzled America, 1935; Home Town, 1940; Sherwood Anderson’s Memoirs, 1942; The Letters of Sherwood Anderson, 1953; Sherwood Anderson: Selected Letters, 1984; Letters to Bab: Sherwood Anderson to Marietta D. Finley, 1916-1933, 1985. poetry: Mid-American Chants, 1918; A New Testament, 1927. Bibliography Appel, Paul P. Homage to Sherwood Anderson: 1876-1941. Mamaroneck, N.Y.: Paul P. Appel, 1970. Collection of essays originally published in homage to Anderson after his death in 1941. Among the contributors are Theodore Dreiser, Gertrude Stein, Thomas Wolfe, Henry Miller, and William Saroyan. Also includes Anderson’s previously unpublished letters and his essay “The Modern Writer,” which had been issued as a limited edition in 1925. Bassett, John E. Sherwood Anderson: An American Career. Selinsgrove, Pa.: Susquehanna University Press, 2006. Biography of Anderson that focuses on his nonfiction and journalistic writing and takes a look at how he coped with cultural changes during his time. Campbell, Hilbert H. “The ‘Shadow People’: Feodor Sologub and Sherwood Anderson’s Winesburg, Ohio.” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (Winter, 1996): 51-58. Discusses parallels between some of Sologub’s stories in The Old House, and Other Tales and the stories in Winesburg, Ohio. Suggests that the Sologub stories influenced Anderson. Cites parallels to Sologub’s tales in such Anderson stories as “Tandy,” “Loneliness,” and “The Book of the Grotesque.” Ellis, James. “Sherwood Anderson’s Fear of Sexuality: Horses, Men, and Homosexuality.” Studies in Short Fiction 30 (Fall, 1993): 595-601. On the basis of biographer Kim Townsend’s suggestion that Anderson sought out male spiritual friendships because he believed that sexuality would debase the beauty of woman, Ellis examines Anderson’s treatment of sexuality as a threat in male relationships in “I Want to Know Why” and “The Man Who Became a Woman.” Hansen, Tom. “Who’s a Fool? A Rereading of Sherwood Anderson’s ‘I’m a Fool.’” The Midwest Quarterly 38 (Summer, 1997): 372-379. Argues that the narrator is the victim of his own self-importance and is thus played for a fool. Discusses class consciousness and conflict in the story. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these seven short stories by Anderson: “Death in the Woods” and “The Egg” (vol. 2), “Hands” (vol. 3), “I Want to Know Why” and “I’m a Fool” (vol. 4), “The Man Who Became a Woman” (vol. 5), and “Sophistication” (vol. 7). Papinchak, Robert Allen. Sherwood Anderson: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Introduction to Anderson’s short stories that examines his search for an appropriate form and his experimentations with form in the stories in Winesburg, Ohio, as well as those that appeared before and after that highly influen-
42
Short Story Writers
tial book. Deals with Anderson’s belief that the most authentic history of life is a history of moments when we truly live, as well as his creation of the grotesque as an American type that also reflects a new social reality. Rideout, Walter B., ed. Sherwood Anderson: A Collection of Critical Essays. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1974. Treats Anderson from a variety of perspectives: as prophet, storyteller, and maker of American myths. Small, Judy Jo. A Reader’s Guide to the Short Stories of Sherwood Anderson. New York: G. K. Hall, 1994. Provides commentary on every story in Winesburg, Ohio, The Triumph of the Egg, Horses and Men, and Death in the Woods. Small summarizes the interpretations of other critics and supplies historical and biographical background, accounts of how the stories were written, the period in which they were published, and their reception. Ideally suited for students and general readers. Townsend, Kim. Sherwood Anderson. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1987. In this biography of Sherwood Anderson, Townsend focuses, in part, on how Anderson’s life appears in his writing. Supplemented by twenty-six photographs and a useful bibliography of Anderson’s work.
43
Maya Angelou Born: St. Louis, Missouri; April 4, 1928 Principal short fiction • “Steady Going Up,” 1972; “The Reunion,” 1983. Other literary forms • Maya Angelou is known primarily as a poet and autobiographer. She has produced more than a dozen volumes of poetry, ranging from Just Give Me a Cool Drink of Water ‘fore I Diiie in 1971 to Amazing Peace in 2005 and Mother: A Cradle to Hold Me in 2006. She has also published six volumes of autobiography and autobiographical essay, starting with I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings in 1970 and ranging through A Song Flung Up to Heaven in 2002 and Hallelujah! The Welcome Table: A Lifetime of Memories with Recipes in 2004. The latter is both a memoir and a cookbook. Her other writings include six published plays, many screenplays, and nine books for children. The latter include Angelina of Italy, Izak of Lapland, Mikale of Hawaii, and Renie Marie of France, all of which she published in 2004. Achievements • I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings was nominated for the National Book Award in 1970, and Maya Angelou’s first volume of poetry (Just Give Me a Cool Drink of Water ‘fore I Diiie) was nominated for the Pulitzer Prize in 1972. Angelou was also nominated for Tony Awards for her performances in Look Away in 1973 and Roots in 1977, and she won a Grammy Award for best spoken word or nontraditional album for “On the Pulse of Morning,” the poem she read at the first inauguration of President Bill Clinton in 1993. She holds more than two dozen honorary doctorates, among numerous other awards. Biography • Maya Angelou was born (as Marguerite Johnson) in St. Louis, Missouri, and spent time as a young girl in Arkansas (in Stamps, near Hope, where Clinton grew up) and California. She was raped at the age of eight by her mother’s boyfriend (a story that is retold in I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings), had a son by the time she was sixteen, and worked at a number of jobs before she became an artist. In her early career, she was a singer and an actor, appearing in plays and musicals around the world through the 1950’s and 1960’s. She has since directed plays and films, recorded music and spoken word, and appeared on television as both a narrator and a series host. She has also taught at various American universities since the 1960’s and at Wake Forest University since 1981. She has been an outspoken advocate of civil and human rights most of her adult life, and she has lectured and written widely about these issues for decades. Analysis • Maya Angelou has produced only a few short stories, but those stories, like her multiple volumes of autobiography, deal directly and poignantly with issues of African American life in America. Since her early years, Angelou has been a political activist and educator, and she is knowledgeable and articulate about civil rights and related issues. Her fiction, like her poetry and her nonfiction, reflects social issues and conditions in the second half of the twentieth century, when racial barriers were falling, but the problems behind them continued. In this sense, Angelou must be con-
44
Short Story Writers sidered a social realist, for her stories demonstrate the difficulties of growing up an African American woman in an America still riven by racism and sexism. Dozens of anthologies and other collections of contemporary literature have excerpted pieces from one or another of Angelou’s autobiographies because they raise so many important issues about modern America—about identity, education, gender, and race. Her short stories are only marginally more fictional and raise many of the same issues.
“Steady Going Up” • “Steady Going Up” was first published in the collection Ten Times Black in 1972 and has since been reprinted several times, including in Gloria Naylor’s Children Courtesy, Central Arkansas Library of the Night: The Best Short Stories by Black Writers, 1967 to the Present (1995). The story seems more dated than “The Reunion” but raises several important questions nonetheless. As the story opens, a young black man, Robert, is traveling by bus from his home in Memphis to Cincinnati. He has never before been out of Tennessee, but this is hardly a pleasure trip, for he is rushing to pick up his younger sister at the nursing school where she has suddenly become ill (possibly from kidney trouble). Robert has raised Baby Sister since their parents died within six months of each other: “He was three years older than she when, at the age of fifteen, he took over as head of the family.” Getting a job as a mechanic at a local garage, he has been able to support Baby Sister, see her through high school, and send her to nursing school. He has had to put his own life on hold (he plans to marry Barbara Kendrick when Baby Sister is finished with school), and now her illness may further complicate his life. The bus ride is full of understandable anxiety for Robert. When the bus makes its last stop before Cincinnati, Robert gets off to relieve himself but is cornered in the “colored” bathroom by two white men, who have also been traveling on the bus. An older black woman, who was sitting across the aisle from Robert during the trip, has already warned him about the two men, who have been drinking and staring at him. Now they confront him, accusing him of going north to find white women. Robert cannot “stand the intention of meanness” in the two men, and he decides to act so that he will not miss the bus: “He wasn’t going to get left with these two crazy men.” When one tries to force him to drink the bourbon that has made them both drunk, Robert kicks him in the groin and then hits the other man over the head with the bottle. Robert manages to get back on the bus, hiding the blood on his hands and shirt, and the bus pulls away with the two men still sprawled in the bathroom. There is no resolution to the story except this escape. Robert has left “those crazy men”—at least for now—but readers wonder what will happen to him. He may be free of them for the moment, but the hatred and violence they repre-
Angelou, Maya
45
sent will continue to follow him. The story ends with a neutral description of the continuing bus trip: “Then he felt the big motor turn and the lights darkened and that old big baby pulled away from the sidewalk and on its way to Cincinnati.” Robert’s problems—as for so many African Americans at this time—still lie before him. “The Reunion” • “The Reunion” has been collected several times, first in the Amina and Amiri Baraka collection Confirmation: An Anthology of African American Women. The story is short (only five pages) but is a much more positive short fiction than the earlier “Steady Going Up,” with its lack of resolution. The story is set in 1958 and is narrated by a jazz pianist named Philomena Jenkins, who is playing the Sunday matinee at the Blue Palm Café on the South Side of Chicago with the Cal Callen band. It is a club filled with other African Americans, but suddenly on this day Philomena spots Miss Beth Ann Baker, a white woman sitting with Willard, a large black man. The sight sends Philomena back in memory to her painful childhood growing up in Baker, Georgia, where her parents worked for the Bakers, and she lived in the servants’ quarters behind the Baker main house. The memories are painful because these were “years of loneliness,” when Philomena was called “the Baker Nigger” by other children, and she has moved a long way from “the hurt Georgia put on me” to her present success in jazz music. She fantasizes about what she will say to Beth Ann when she meets her, but when they finally face each other at the bar a little later in the story, it is Beth Ann who does all the talking. She is going to marry Willard, who is a south side school teacher, she tells Philomena, and she claims she is very happy. However, her parents have disowned her and even forbidden her to return to Baker. It is clear that she is with Willard to spite her parents, for she sounds to Philomena like “a ten-year-old just before a tantrum,” “white and rich and spoiled.” When Beth Ann invites “Mena” to their wedding, the narrator replies simply, “’Good-bye Beth. Tell your parents I said go to hell and take you with them, just for company.’” When she returns to her piano after this break, she realizes that Beth Ann had the money, but I had the music. She and her parents had had the power to hurt me when I was young, but look, the stuff in me lifted me up above them. No matter how bad times became, I would always be the song struggling to be heard. Through her tears, Philomena has had an epiphany and experienced a form of reconciliation with her true self, in the recognition that art can transcend social inequity. In the story’s last lines, “The piano keys were slippery with tears. I know, I sure as hell wasn’t crying for myself.” Like a number of other artists (James Baldwin and Amiri Baraka, among them), Maya Angelou posits art—and thus literature—as one way of getting above and beyond the social injustices that her society has created. Philomena cannot erase the painful childhood memories, but her music can lift her and others above them to another, healthier human plane. The hurt may remain, but the “song struggling to be heard” is stronger. David Peck Other major works children’s literature: Mrs. Flowers: A Moment of Friendship, 1986 (illustrated by Etienne Delessert); Life Doesn’t Frighten Me, 1993 (poetry; illustrated by Jean-Michel Basquiat); Soul Looks Back in Wonder, 1993; My Painted House, My Friendly Chicken, and
46
Short Story Writers
Me, 1994; Kofi and His Magic, 1996; Angelina of Italy, 2004; Izak of Lapland, 2004; Mikale of Hawaii, 2004; Renie Marie of France, 2004. plays: Cabaret for Freedom, pr. 1960 (with Godfrey Cambridge; musical); The Least of These, pr. 1966; Encounters, pr. 1973; Ajax, pr. 1974 (adaptation of Sophocles’ play); And Still I Rise, pr. 1976; King, pr. 1990 (musical; lyrics with Alistair Beaton, book by Lonne Elder III; music by Richard Blackford). nonfiction: I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, 1970 (autobiography); Gather Together in My Name, 1974 (autobiography); Singin’ and Swingin’ and Gettin’ Merry Like Christmas, 1976 (autobiography); The Heart of a Woman, 1981 (autobiography); All God’s Children Need Traveling Shoes, 1986 (autobiography); Wouldn’t Take Nothing for My Journey Now, 1993 (autobiographical essays); Even the Stars Look Lonesome, 1997; A Song Flung Up to Heaven, 2002 (autobiographical essays); Hallelujah! The Welcome Table: A Lifetime of Memories with Recipes, 2004 (memoir and cookbook). poetry: Just Give Me a Cool Drink of Water ‘fore I Diiie, 1971; Oh Pray My Wings Are Gonna Fit Me Well, 1975; And Still I Rise, 1978; Shaker, Why Don’t You Sing?, 1983; Poems: Maya Angelou, 1986; Now Sheba Sings the Song, 1987 (Tom Feelings, illustrator); I Shall Not Be Moved: Poems, 1990; On the Pulse of Morning, 1993; Phenomenal Woman: Four Poems Celebrating Women, 1994; The Complete Collected Poems of Maya Angelou, 1994; A Brave and Startling Truth, 1995; Amazing Peace, 2005; Mother: A Cradle to Hold Me, 2006. screenplays: Georgia, Georgia, 1972; All Day Long, 1974. teleplays: Black, Blues, Black, 1968 (ten epidsodes); The Inheritors, 1976; The Legacy, 1976; I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, 1979 (with Leonora Thuna and Ralph B. Woolsey); Sister, Sister, 1982; Brewster Place, 1990. Bibliography Bair, Barbara J. “Steady Going Up.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 7. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Analysis of “Steady Going Up” with sections on themes and meaning and style and technique. Also includes a detailed synopsis of the story. Bloom, Harold, ed. Maya Angelou. Philadelphia: Chelsea House, 1999. This selection of essays dealing with Angelou’s poetry and prose broaches, among other subjects, the singular relationship of Angelou to her audience and her distinctively African American mode of literary expression. Ducksworth, Sarah Smith. “The Reunion.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 6. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Studentfriendly analysis of “The Reunion” that covers the story’s themes and style and includes a detailed synopsis. Elliott, Jeffrey M., ed. Conversations with Maya Angelou. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1989. Part of the University Press of Mississippi’s ongoing Literary Conversations series, this work is a collection of more than thirty interviews with Angelou that originally appeared in various magazines and newspapers, accompanied by a chronology of her life. Provides a multifaceted perspective on the creative issues that have informed Angelou’s work as an autobiographer and a poet. Guntern, Gottlieb, ed. The Challenge of Creative Leadership. London: ShepheardWalwyn, 1997. Guntern’s criteria for those who inspire others to move beyond mediocrity are explored in these philosophical pieces. Among these criteria are originality, elegance, and profundity. Hagen, Lynn B. Heart of a Woman, Mind of a Writer, and Soul of a Poet: A Critical Analysis of the Writings of Maya Angelou. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America, 1996.
Angelou, Maya
47
Although a number of scholarly works address the different literary forms Angelou has undertaken (most devoted to autobiography), few critical volumes survey her entire opus, and Hagen’s is one of the best. Chapters include “Wit and Wisdom/Mirth and Mischief,” “Abstracts in Ethics,” and “Overview.” King, Sarah E. Maya Angelou: Greeting the Morning. Brookfield, Conn.: Millbrook Press, 1994. Includes biographical references and an index. Examines Angelou’s life, from her childhood in the segregated South to her rise to prominence as a writer. Lisandrelli, Elaine Slivinski. Maya Angelou: More than a Poet. Springfield, N.J.: Enslow, 1996. Lisandrelli discusses the flamboyance of Angelou, comparing her to the earlier African American author Zora Neale Hurston. Their hard work, optimism, perseverance, and belief in themselves are extolled. Lupton, Mary Jane. Maya Angelou: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1998. Although focusing mainly on the autobiographies, Lupton’s study is still useful as a balanced assessment of Angelou’s writings. The volume also contains an excellent bibliography, particularly of Angelou’s autobiographical works. O’Neale, Sondra. “Reconstruction of the Composite Self: New Images of Black Women in Maya Angelou’s Continuing Autobiography.” In Black Women Writers (1950-1980), edited by Mari Evans. Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor Press, 1983. O’Neale argues that Angelou’s primary contribution to the canon of African American literature lies in her realistic portrayal of the lives of black people, especially black women. O’Neale goes on to demonstrate the ways in which Angelou successfully destroys many of the stereotypes of black women. Williams, Mary E., ed. Readings on Maya Angelou. San Diego, Calif.: Greenhaven Press, 1997. This collection of essays by literary scholars and noted faculty offers diverse voices and approaches to Angelou’s literary canon.
48
Margaret Atwood Born: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada; November 18, 1939 Principal short fiction • Dancing Girls, and Other Stories, 1977; Bluebeard’s Egg, 1983; Murder in the Dark: Short Fictions and Prose Poems, 1983; Wilderness Tips, 1991; Good Bones, 1992 (pb. in U.S. as Good Bones and Simple Murders, 1994); Moral Disorder: Atwood Stories, 2006. Other literary forms • Margaret Atwood’s publishing history is a testimonial to her remarkable productivity and versatility as an author. She is the author of numerous books, including poetry, novels, children’s literature, and nonfiction. In Canada, she is most admired for her poetry, which has been collected in more than two dozen volumes, ranging from Double Persephone in 1964 to Eating Fire in 1998. Outside Canada, Atwood is better known as a novelist, particularly for Surfacing (1972) and The Handmaid’s Tale (1985). Her other novels include The Edible Woman (1969), Lady Oracle (1976), Bodily Harm (1981), and Alias Grace (1996). Among her volumes of poetry are The Circle Game (1964), The Animals in That Country (1968), The Journals of Susanna Moodie (1970), Interlunar (1984), Morning in the Burned House (1995), The Blind Assassin (2000), Oryx and Crake (2003), and The Penelopiad (2005). In 1972, Atwood published Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature, a controversial critical work on Canadian literature, and in 1982, Second Words: Selected Critical Prose, which is in the vanguard of feminist criticism in Canada. She later followed those nonfiction works with Negotiating with the Dead: A Writer on Writing (2002) and Moving Targets: with Intent: Essays, Reviews, Personal Prose, 1983-2005 (2005). Her published interviews have been collected in several volumes, including Waltzing Again: New and Selected Conversations with Margaret Atwood (2006). Atwood has also written for television and theater, one of her successful ventures being “The Festival of Missed Crass,” a short story made into a musical for Toronto’s Young People’s Theater. Atwood’s conscious scrutiny, undertaken largely in her nonfiction writing, turned from external political and cultural repression to the internalized effects of various kinds of repression on the individual psyche. The same theme is evident in her fiction; her novel Cat’s Eye (1988) explores the subordination of character Elaine Risley’s personality to that of her domineering “friend” Cordelia. Achievements • Margaret Atwood is a prolific and controversial writer of international prominence whose works have been translated into many languages. She has received several honorary doctorates and is the recipient of numerous honors, prizes, and awards, including the Governor-General’s Award for Poetry in 1967 for The Circle Game, the Governor-General’s Award for Fiction in 1986 and the Arthur C. Clarke Award for Best Science Fiction in 1987 for The Handmaid’s Tale, the Ida Nudel Humanitarian Award in 1986 from the Canadian Jewish Congress, the American Humanist of the Year Award in 1987, and the Trillium Award for Excellence in Ontario Writing for Wilderness Tips in 1992 and for her 1993 novel The Robber Bride in 1994. The French government honored her with the prestigious Chevalier dans l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres in 1994.
Atwood, Margaret
49
Two of Atwood’s novels have been selected for CBC Radio’s Canada Reads competition: The Handmaid’s Tale, supported by former prime minister Kim Campbell in 2002, and Oryx and Crake (2003), supported by Toronto city councillor Olivia Chow in 2005. Biography • Margaret Eleanor Atwood was born in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, on November 18, 1939. She grew up in northern Ontario, Quebec, and Toronto. Following graduation from Victoria College, University of Toronto, she attended Radcliffe College at Harvard University on a Woodrow Wilson Fellowship, receiving a master’s degree in English in 1962. She taught at a number of Canadian universities and traveled extensively. During the early 1990’s Atwood was a lecturer of English at the Courtesy, Vancouver International Writers Festival University of British Columbia at Vancouver. She later settled in Toronto with writer Graeme Gibson and their daughter, Jess. Atwood’s output was steady in fiction and particularly in nonfiction. She made successful forays into the fields of script writing for film and musical theater, and she also produced notable novels. It is her prolific, passionate essay and article writing on a variety of national and international social issues, however, of which human rights is her central concern, that made her a bellwether of Canadian opinion. Her involvement with world political and social issues became evident in her vice leadership of the Writers’ Union of Canada and her presidency of the International Association of Poets, Playwrights, Editors, and Novelists (PEN), where she waged a vigorous battle against literary censorship. Her association with Amnesty International prompted an increasingly strong expression of her moral vision. Analysis • One of Margaret Atwood’s central themes is storytelling itself, and most of her fiction relates to that theme in some way. The short-story collections each focus on key issues. Dancing Girls is primarily concerned with otherness, alienation, and the ways in which people estrange themselves from one another. Bluebeard’s Egg revolves around a favorite theme of Atwood’s, the Bluebeard tale of a dangerous suitor or husband. The title story explores Sally’s excessive concern with her husband and lack of awareness of herself. Wilderness Tips centers on the explanatory fiction people tell themselves and one another, on the need to order experience through such fiction, and on the ways in which humans are posing threats to the wilderness, the forests, and open space. “The Man from Mars” • In Dancing Girls, a gift for comic and satiric invention is evident from the first story, “The Man from Mars.” Christine, an unattractive undergraduate at a Canadian university, is literally pursued by an odd-looking, desperately
50
Short Story Writers
poor exchange student. The daily chases of a bizarre, small, Asian man in hot pursuit of a rather large Christine (a mouse chasing an elephant, as Atwood describes it) attract the attention of other students and make Christine interesting to her male acquaintances for the first time. They begin to ask her out, curious as to the mysterious sources of her charm. She begins to feel and actually to be more attractive. As months pass, however, Christine begins to fantasize about this strange man about whom she knows nothing. Is he perhaps a sex maniac, a murderer? Eventually, through the overreactions and interventions of others, complaints are made to the police, and the inscrutable foreigner is deported, leaving Christine with mingled feelings of relief and regret. She graduates and settles into a drab government job and a sterile existence. Years pass. A war breaks out somewhere in the Far East and vividly revives thoughts of the foreigner. His country is the scene of fighting, but Christine cannot remember the name of his city. She becomes obsessed with worry, studying maps, poring over photographs of soldiers and photographs of the wounded and the dead in newspapers and magazines, compulsively searching the television screen for even a brief glimpse of his face. Finally, it is too much. Christine stops looking at pictures, gives away her television set, and does nothing except read nineteenth century novels. The story is rich in comedy and in social satire, much of it directed against attitudes that make “a person from another culture” as alien as a “man from Mars.” Christine’s affluent parents think of themselves as liberal and progressive. They have traveled, bringing back a sundial from England and a domestic servant from the West Indies. Christine’s mother believes herself to be both tolerant and generous for employing foreigners as domestic servants in her home; she observes that it is difficult to tell whether people from other cultures are insane. Christine also typifies supposedly enlightened, liberal attitudes, having been president of the United Nations Club in high school, and in college a member of the forensics team, debating such topics as the obsolescence of war. Although the story is on the whole a comic and satiric look at the limits of shallow liberalism, there is, however, also some pathos in the end. It seems that the encounter with the alien is the most interesting or significant thing that has ever happened to Christine and that her only feeling of human relationship is for a person with whom she had no real relationship. At the story’s conclusion, she seems lost, now past either hope or love, retreating into the unreal but safe world of John Galsworthy and Anthony Trollope. “Dancing Girls” • Another encounter with the alien occurs in the collection’s title story, “Dancing Girls,” which is set in the United States during the 1960’s. Ann, a graduate student from Toronto, has a room in a seedy boardinghouse. Mrs. Nolan, its American proprietor, befriends Ann because a Canadian does not look “foreign.” Mrs. Nolan’s other tenants are mathematicians from Hong Kong and an Arab who is becoming crazed with loneliness and isolation. Ann’s only other acquaintances are Lelah, a Turkish woman studying Russian literature, and Jetske, a Dutch woman studying urban design. Ann also is studying urban design because she has fantasies of rearranging Toronto. She frequently envisions the open, green spaces she will create, but she seems to have the same limitation as “The City Planners” in Atwood’s poem of that name. People are a problem: They ruin her aesthetically perfect designs, cluttering and littering the landscape. Finally, she decides that people such as Mrs. Nolan, Mrs. Nolan’s unruly children, and the entire collection of exotics who live in the boardinghouse will have to be excluded from urban utopia by a high wire fence.
Atwood, Margaret
51
Yet an event in the story causes Ann to change her mind. The Arab whose room is next to hers throws a rowdy party one night for two other Arab students and three “dancing girls.” Ann sits in her room in the dark, fascinated, listening to the music, drinking sherry, but with her door securely bolted. As the noise level of the party escalates, Mrs. Nolan calls the police but cannot wait for them to arrive. Overcome by xenophobic and puritanical zeal, she drives the room’s occupants out of her house and down the street with a broom. Ann finally sees Mrs. Nolan for what she evidently is, a “fat crazy woman” intent on destroying some “harmless hospitality.” Ann regrets that she lacked courage to open the door and so missed seeing what Mrs. Nolan referred to as the “dancing girls” (either Mrs. Nolan’s euphemism for prostitutes or a reflection of her confused ideas about Middle Eastern culture). The story concludes with Ann again envisioning her ideal city, but this time there are many people and no fence. At the center of Ann’s fantasy now are the foreigners she has met, with Lelah and Jetske as the “dancing girls.” The implication is clear: Ann has resolved her ambivalent feelings about foreigners, has broken out of the need for exclusion and enclosure, and has rejected the racism, tribalism, and paranoia of Mrs. Nolan, who sees the world in terms of “us” versus “them.” “Polarities” • The question of human warmth and life and where they are to be found is more acutely raised in “Polarities,” a strange, somewhat abstract story which also comments on the theme of alienation. Louise, a graduate student of literature, and Morrison, a faculty member, are both at the same western provincial university (probably in Alberta). Both are “aliens”: Morrison is American and therefore regarded as an outsider and a usurper of a job which should have been given to a Canadian; Louise is a fragile person searching for a place of refuge against human coldness. Louise, a student of the poetry of William Blake, has developed her own private mythology of circles, magnetic grids, and north-south polarities. Her friends, who believe that private mythologies belong in poetry, judge her to be insane and commit her to a mental institution. At first Morrison is not sure what to believe. Finally, he discovers that he loves Louise, but only because she is by now truly crazy, defenseless, “drugged into manageability.” Examining his feelings for Louise and reflecting on her uncanny notebook entries about him, Morrison is forced to confront some unpleasant realities. He realizes that his own true nature is to be a user and a taker rather than a lover and a giver and that all his “efforts to remain human” have led only to “futile work and sterile love.” He gets in his car and drives. At the story’s end, he is staring into the chill, uninhabitable interior of Canada’s far north, a perfect metaphor for the coldness of the human heart that the story has revealed and an ironic reversal of the story’s epigraph, with its hopeful reference to humans who somehow “have won from space/ This unchill, habitable interior.” The polarities between Louise’s initial vision of a warmly enclosing circle of friends and Morrison’s final bleak vision of what poet William Butler Yeats called “the desolation of reality” seem irreconcilable in this story. “Giving Birth” • The final story in Dancing Girls is the most ambitious and complex in this collection. “Giving Birth” is about a physical process, but it is also about language and the relationship between fiction and reality. The narrator (possibly Atwood herself, who gave birth to a daughter in 1976) tells a story of a happily pregnant woman named Jeanie. Jeanie diligently attends natural-childbirth classes and
52
Short Story Writers
cheerfully anticipates the experience of birth and motherhood. A thoroughly modern woman, she does “not intend to go through hell. Hell comes from the wrong attitude.” Yet Jeanie is shadowed by a phantom pregnant woman, clearly a projection of the vague apprehensions and deep fears that Jeanie has repressed. When the day arrives, Jeanie calmly rides to the hospital with her husband and her carefully packed suitcase; the other woman is picked up on a street corner carrying a brown paper bag. As Jeanie waits cheerfully for a room, the other woman is screaming with pain. While Jeanie is taken to the labor room in a wheelchair, the other woman is rolled by on a table with her eyes closed and a tube in her arm: “Something is wrong.” In this story, Atwood suggests that such mysterious human ordeals as giving birth or dying can never be adequately prepared for or fully communicated through language: “When there is no pain she feels nothing, when there is pain, she feels nothing because there is no she. This, finally, is the disappearance of language.” For what happens to the shadowy woman, the narrator says, “there is no word in the language.” The story is concerned with the archaic ineptness of language. Why the expression, “giving birth”? Who gives it? And to whom is it given? Why speak this way at all when birth is an event, not a thing? Why is there no corollary expression, “giving death”? The narrator believes some things need to be renamed, but she is not the one for the task: “These are the only words I have, I’m stuck with them, stuck in them.” Her task is to descend into the ancient tar pits of language (to use Atwood’s metaphor) and to retrieve an experience before it becomes layered over by time and ultimately changed or lost. Jeanie is thus revealed to be an earlier version of the narrator herself; the telling of the story thus gives birth to Jeanie, just as Jeanie gave birth to the narrator: “It was to me, after all, that birth was given, Jeanie gave it, I am the rez senses: the biological birth of an infant, the birth of successive selves wrought by experience and time, and the birth of a work of literature which attempts to rescue and fix experience from the chaos and flux of being.” “Bluebeard’s Egg” • A frequent theme in Atwood’s fiction and poetry is the power struggle between men and women. At times, the conflict seems to verge on insanity, as in “Under Glass,” “Lives of the Poets,” “Loulou: Or, The Domestic Life of the Language,” and “Ugly Puss.” The title story in Bluebeard’s Egg, however, seems less bleak. In a reversal of sexual stereotypes, Sally loves her husband, Ed, because he is beautiful and dumb. She is a dominating, manipulating woman (of the type seen also in “The Resplendent Quetzal”), and her relationship to her husband seems to be that of doting mother to overprotected child, despite the fact that he is a successful and respected cardiologist, and she has no meaningful identity outside her marriage. Bored, Sally takes a writing class in which she is admonished to explore her inner world. Yet she is “fed up with her inner world; she doesn’t need to explore it. In her inner world is Ed, like a doll within a Russian wooden doll and in Ed is Ed’s inner world, which she can’t get at.” The more she speculates about Ed’s inner world, the more perplexed she becomes. Required to write a version of the Bluebeard fable, Sally decides to retell the story from the point of view of the egg, because it reminds her of Ed’s head, both “so closed and unaware.” Sally is shocked into a new assessment of Ed, however, when she witnesses a scene of sexual intimacy between her husband and her best friend. Ed is after all not an inert object, a given; instead, he has a mysterious, frightening potential. Sally is no longer complacent, no longer certain she wants to know what lies beneath the surface.
Atwood, Margaret
53
“Significant Moments in the Life of My Mother” • The first and last stories in Bluebeard’s Egg reveal Atwood in an atypically mellow mood. “Significant Moments in the Life of My Mother” is a loving celebration of the narrator’s (presumably Atwood’s) mother and father and of an earlier, simpler time. Yet it is never sentimental because Atwood never loses her steely grip on reality. Looking at an old photograph of her mother and friends, the narrator is interested in the background . . . a world already hurtling towards ruin, unknown to them: the theory of relativity has been discovered, acid is accumulating at the roots of trees, the bull-frogs are doomed. But they smile with something that from this distance you could almost call gallantry, their right legs thrust forward in parody of a chorus line. The “significant moments” of the title inevitably include some significant moments in the life of the narrator as well. Amusing discrepancies between mother’s and daughter’s versions of reality emerge, but not all are funny. For example, the narrator sees that her compulsive need to be solicitous toward men may be the result of early, “lethal” conditioning; her mother sees “merely cute” childhood behavior. The narrator recalls the shock she felt when her mother expressed a wish to be in some future incarnation an archaeologist—inconceivable that she could wish to be anything other than the narrator’s mother. Yet when the narrator becomes a mother herself, she gains a new perspective and “this moment altered for me.” What finally emerges between mother and narrator-daughter is not communication but growing estrangement. Recalling herself as a university student, she feels as though she has become as unfathomable to her mother as “a visitor from outer space, a timetraveler come back from the future, bearing news of a great disaster.” There are distances too great for maternal love to cross. Atwood is too much of a realist to omit this fact. “Unearthing Suite” • The final story, “Unearthing Suite,” another seemingly autobiographical reminiscence, begins with the parents’ pleased announcement that they have purchased their funeral urns. Their daughter is stunned—they are far more alive than she. Mother at the age of seventy-three figure skates, swims daily in glacial lakes, and sweeps leaves off steeply pitched roofs. Father pursues dozens of interests at once: botany, zoology, history, politics, carpentry, gardening. From her torpor, the narrator wonders at their vitality and, above all, at their enviable poise in the face of life’s grim realities, those past as well as those yet to come. Perhaps the answer is that they have always remained close to the earth, making earthworks in the wild, moving granite, digging in gardens, and always responding joyously to earth’s little unexpected gifts such as the visit of a rare fisher bird at the story’s end, for them the equivalent of a visit “by an unknown but by no means minor god.” The narrator appreciates her parents’ wise tranquillity. She cannot, however, share it. Wilderness Tips • Atwood’s stories are frequently explorations of human limitation, presentations of people as victims of history, biology, or cultural conditioning. The theme of isolation and alienation recurs: There are borders and fences; generational gaps, which make parents and children strangers to each other; failed communication between women and men; gaps between language and felt experience. It is easy to overstate the pessimism which is present in her writings, to see only
54
Short Story Writers
the wreckage of lives and relationships with which her work is strewn. It is therefore important not to lose sight of the human strength and tenacity (a favorite Atwood word) which also informs her work. Eight years later, the stories in Atwood’s short-fiction collection Wilderness Tips ultimately celebrated (still grudgingly) the same human strength and tenacity. This and related themes that shaped Atwood’s vision over her writing life are embodied in the sometimes humorous and self-deprecating, often grim and urgent, seekings of the (mostly) female protagonists both to liberate and to preserve themselves in an increasingly ugly world. The conflicts that oppress these characters are rendered more nastily brutish by the realities of middle-class Canadian society in the late twentieth century. The predominant setting is Toronto, no longer “the Good” but now the polluted, the unsafe, the dingy, the dangerous, and, worst, the indifferent. The battle between the sexes is again the focus of most of the ten stories, the combatants ranging from youth through middle age. For the most part, the battles are lost or at best fought to a draw; the victories are Pyrrhic. In “True Trash,” the consequences of adolescent sexual and social betrayals at a wilderness summer camp are dealt with only by escape into the banal anonymity of adulthood in the city. In “Hairball,” Kat, who is in her thirties, is betrayed by both a previously acquiescent lover and her own body. Stripped of the brittle security she had carefully built for herself, she hits back with a spectacularly gross act of revenge. In “Isis in Darkness,” conventional, secretly romantic Richard invests the poet Selena with a spiritual transcendence totally at odds with her real-life alienation and pathetic descent to early death over the years of their tenuous relationship. In “Weight,” the narrator, a woman of substance, lives by compromise, paying defiant homage to the memory of her scrappy, optimistic friend Molly, who was battered to death by her mad husband. For many of these protagonists (as in Atwood’s other works), language is a weapon of choice: In “Uncles,” Susanna, though emotionally unfulfilled, is a successful, ambitious journalist; in “Hack Wednesday,” Marcia is a freelance columnist; in “Weight,” the narrator and Molly, aggressive lawyers, play elaborate word games to ward off threatening realities; in “The Bog Man,” middle-aged Julie mythologizes her disastrous youthful affair with Connor. Nevertheless, as it does so often in Atwood’s works, the gulf between language and understanding yawns, exacerbating the difficulties of human connections. In two of the collection’s most successful stories, however, that gulf is bridged by messages spoken, ironically, by the dead. In “The Age of Lead,” a television documentary chronicles the exhumation from the Arctic permafrost of the body of young John Torrington, a member of the British Franklin Expedition, killed like his fellows by lead poisoning contracted through their consumption of tinned food. The documentary, which protagonist Jane is sporadically watching, weaves in and out of her recollections of Vincent, a friend from her childhood, recently dead. All their lives, his identity was ephemeral and undefined, but as Jane recalls his slow decline and death of an unnamed disease and ponders his enigmatic nature, the television offers the 150-years-dead Torrington, emerging virtually intact from his icy grave to “speak” eloquently to the living. Similarly, in “Death by Landscape,” Lois’s childhood acquaintance Lucy, who vanished on a camp canoe trip, slyly returns to haunt the adult Lois in Lois’s collection of wilderness landscape paintings, assuming a solidity she never had as a live child. Still, despite the pessimism, inadequacies, and guilt of many of the stories’ characters, the readers’ lasting impressions are positive ones. “Hack Wednesday,” the last
Atwood, Margaret
55
story, speaks the same grumpy optimism that informs much of Atwood’s poetry and prose. Marcia knows she will cry on Christmas Day, because life, however horrific at times, rushes by, and she is helpless to stop it: “It’s all this hope. She gets distracted by it, and has trouble paying attention to the real news.” Good Bones and Simple Murders • Good Bones and Simple Murders incorporates some material from Murder in the Dark. The short pieces in this collection have been termed jeux d’esprit and speeded-up short stories. They showcase Atwood’s wit, control, and wordplay as she speculates about hypothetical situations, such as “What would happen if men did all the cooking?”, and revises traditional tales, such as “The Little Red Hen.” In Atwood’s version, the hen remains “henlike” and shares the loaf with all the animals that refused to help her produce it. In these pieces, characters who were silent in the original tales get to tell their side of the story. In “Gertrude Talks Back,” Hamlet’s mother explains matter-of-factly to her son that his father was a prig and that she murdered him. In “Simmering,” the women have been cast out of the kitchens and surreptitiously reminisce about the good old days when they were allowed to cook. Many of the short pieces here are explicitly about storytelling. The first story, “Murder in the Dark,” describes a detective game and presents the writer as a trickster, a spinner of lies. “Unpopular Gals” tells of the mysterious women of traditional stories, the witches and evil stepmothers who tell their own side of the story here. “Let Us Now Praise Stupid Women” explains that it is not the careful, prudent, rational women who inspire fiction but rather the careless “airheads,” the open, ingenuous, innocent women who set the plots in motion and make stories happen. “Happy Endings” plays with variations on a simple plot, answering in different ways what happens after a man and a woman meet. “The Page” explores the blank whiteness of an empty page and the myriad stories that lurk beneath it. Atwood does not imply that human experience is beyond understanding, that evil is necessarily beyond redemption, or that human beings are beyond transformation. Her wit, humor, irony, imagination, and sharp intelligence save her and her readers from despair, if anything can. To write at all in this negative age seems in itself an act of courage and affirmation, an act Margaret Atwood gives no sign of renouncing. Though her readers already know Atwood’s message, it bears repeating. Karen A. Kildahl With updates by Jill Rollins and Karen F. Stein Other major works novels: The Edible Woman, 1969; Surfacing, 1972; Lady Oracle, 1976; Life Before Man, 1979; Bodily Harm, 1981; The Handmaid’s Tale, 1985; Cat’s Eye, 1988; The Robber Bride, 1993; Alias Grace, 1996; The Blind Assassin, 2000; Oryx and Crake, 2003; The Penelopiad: They Myth of Penelope and Odysseus, 2005. poetry: Double Persephone, 1961; The Circle Game, 1964 (single poem), 1966 (collection); Kaleidoscopes Baroque: A Poem, 1965; Talismans for Children, 1965; Expeditions, 1966; Speeches for Dr. Frankenstein, 1966; The Animals in That Country, 1968; What Was in the Garden, 1969; Procedures for Underground, 1970; The Journals of Susanna Moodie, 1970; Power Politics, 1971; You Are Happy, 1974; Selected Poems, 1976; Two-Headed Poems, 1978; True Stories, 1981; Snake Poems, 1983; Interlunar, 1984; Selected Poems II: Poems Selected and New, 1976-1986, 1987; Selected Poems, 1966-1984, 1990; Poems, 1965-1975,
56
Short Story Writers
1991; Poems, 1976-1989, 1992; Morning in the Burned House, 1995; Eating Fire: Selected Poems, 1965-1995, 1998. nonfiction: Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature, 1972; Second Words: Selected Critical Prose, 1982; The CanLit Foodbook: From Pen to Palate, a Collection of Tasty Literary Fare, 1987; Margaret Atwood: Conversations, 1990; Deux sollicitudes: Entretiens, 1996 (with Victor-Lévy Beaulieu; Two Solicitudes: Conversations, 1998); Negotiating with the Dead: A Writer on Writing, 2002; Moving Targets: Writing with Intent, 1982-2004, 2004 (pb. in U.S. as Writing with Intent: Essays, Reviews, Personal Prose, 1983-2005, 2005); Waltzing Again: New and Selected Conversations with Margaret Atwood, 2006 (with others; Earl G. Ingersoll, editor). children’s literature: Up in the Tree, 1978; Anna’s Pet, 1980 (with Joyce Barkhouse); For the Birds, 1990; Princess Prunella and the Purple Peanut, 1995 (illustrated by Maryann Kowalski); Rude Ramsay and the Roaring Radishes, 2004 (illustrated by Dusan Petricic). anthology: The New Oxford Book of Canadian Verse in English, 1982. miscellaneous: The Tent, 2006. Bibliography Bloom, Harold, ed. Margaret Atwood. Philadelphia: Chelsea House, 2000. Collection of critical essays about Atwood that have been assembled for student use, from the series Modern Critical Views. Includes an introduction by Bloom. Brown, Jane W. “Constructing the Narrative of Women’s Friendship: Margaret Atwood’s Reflexive Fiction.” Literature, Interpretation, Theory 6 (1995): 197-212. In this special journal issue on Atwood, Brown argues that Atwood’s narrative reflects the struggle of women to attain friendship. Maintains Atwood achieves this with such reflexive devices as embedded discourse, narrative fragmentation, and doubling. Discusses the difficulty women have in creating friendships because few women think such friendships are important. Cooke, Nathalie. Margaret Atwood: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 2004. Part of the publisher’s series of reference books on popular contemporary writers for students, this volume provides detailed plot summaries and analyses of Atwood’s major works, along with character portraits, a biography of Atwood, and an extensive bibliography. Nathalie Cooke is also the author of Margaret Atwood: A Biography (1998). Deery, June. “Science for Feminists: Margaret Atwood’s Body of Knowledge.” Twentieth Century Literature 43 (Winter, 1997): 470-486. Shows how the themes of feminine identity, personal and cultural history, body image, and colonization in Atwood’s fiction are described in terms of basic laws of physics. Comments on Atwood’s application of scientific concepts of time, space, energy, and matter to the experience of women under patriarchy in an adaptation of male discourse. Howells, Coral Ann. Margaret Atwood. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1996. In this lively critical and biographical study, Howells elucidates issues that have energized all of Atwood’s work: feminist issues, literary genres, and her own identity as a Canadian, a woman, and a writer. Focuses on the fiction. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Atwood: “The Man from Mars” (vol. 5), “Rape Fantasies” (vol. 6), and “The SinEater” (vol. 7).
Atwood, Margaret
57
Meindl, Dieter. “Gender and Narrative Perspective in Atwood’s Stories.” In Margaret Atwood: Writing and Subjectivity, edited by Colin Nelson. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Discusses female narrative perspective in Atwood’s stories. Shows how stories such as “The Man from Mars” and “The Sin Eater” focus on women’s failure to communicate with men, thus trapping themselves inside their own inner worlds. Nischik, Reingard M., ed. Margaret Atwood: Works and Impact. Rochester, N.Y.: Camden House, 2000. Solid collection of original (not reprinted) criticism of a wide variety of aspects of Atwood’s writing. Stein, Karen F. Margaret Atwood Revisited. New York: Twayne, 1999. Lucid and thorough overview of Atwood’s writing in all genres. Includes references and a selected bibliography. This volume supersedes an equally fine volume in the same series, Jerome Rosenberg’s Margaret Atwood (1984). Suarez, Isabel Carrera. “‘Yet I Speak, Yet I Exist’: Affirmation of the Subject in Atwood’s Short Stories.” In Margaret Atwood: Writing and Subjectivity, edited by Colin Nelson. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Discusses Atwood’s treatment of the self and its representation in language in her short stories. Demonstrates how in Atwood’s early stories characters are represented or misrepresented by language and how struggle with language is a way to make themselves understood; explains how this struggle is amplified in later stories. Sullivan, Rosemary. The Red Shoes: Margaret Atwood, Starting Out. Toronto: HarperFlamingo Canada, 1998. Biography focusing on Atwood’s early life through the 1970’s. Attempts to explain how Atwood became a writer and to describe the unfolding of her career.
58
Isaac Babel Born: Odessa, Ukraine, Russian Empire (now in Ukraine); July 13, 1894 Died: Butyrka prison, Moscow, Soviet Union (now in Russia); January 27, 1940 Principal short fiction • Rasskazy, 1925; Istoriia moei golubiatni, 1926; Konarmiia, 1926 (Red Cavalry, 1929); Odesskie rasskazy, 1931 (Tales of Odessa, 1955); Benya Krik, the Gangster, and Other Stories, 1948; The Collected Stories, 1955; Izbrannoe, 1957, 1966; Lyubka the Cossack, and Other Stories, 1963; You Must Know Everything: Stories, 1915-1937, 1969. Other literary forms • Although Isaac Babel spent most of his career writing short stories, he tried his hand at other genres without making significant contributions to them. He wrote two plays: Zakat (1928; Sunset, 1960) and Mariia (1935; Maria, 1966). He also wrote several screenplays, most of which remain unpublished. Babel was known to have worked on several novels, but only a few fragments have been published. If he ever completed them, either he destroyed them or they were confiscated by police when he was arrested in 1939, never to be seen in public again. Because of their fragmentary nature, the tendency among critics is to treat them as short fiction. He also wrote a brief autobiography, a diary, reminiscences, and newspaper articles. Achievements • Isaac Babel’s greatest achievement lies in short fiction. From the outset, he established himself as a premier short-story writer not only in Russian but also in world literature as well. He achieved this reputation not only through his innovative approach to the subject matter—the civil war in Russia, for example, or the Jewish world of his ancestry—but also through his stylistic excellence. His mastery of style earned for him, early in his career, a reputation of an avant-garde writer—a model to be emulated, but at the same time difficult to emulate. He elevated the Russian short story to a new level and attracted the attention of foreign writers such as Ernest Hemingway, who read him in Paris. At the same time, it would be unjust to attribute his greatness only to the uniqueness of his subject matter or to his avant-garde style. Rather, it is the combination of these and other qualities that contributed to his indisputably high reputation among both critics and readers, a respect that seems to grow with time. Biography • Isaac Emmanuilovich Babel was born in Odessa on July 13, 1894, into a Jewish family that had lived in southern Russia for generations. Soon after his birth, the family moved from this thriving port on the Black Sea to the nearby small town of Nikolayev, where Babel spent the first ten years of his life. His childhood was typical of a child growing up in a colorful Jewish environment and, at the same time, in a Russian society replete with prejudices against Jews. In his stories, Babel describes the difficult lessons of survival that he had to learn from childhood on, which enabled him not only to survive but also to keep striving for excellence against all odds. He was a studious child who read under all conditions, even on his way home, and his imagination was always on fire, as he said in one of his stories. Among many other subjects, he studied Hebrew and French vigorously, becoming more proficient in them than in Russian.
Babel, Isaac
59
After finishing high school in Odessa—which was difficult for a Jewish child to enter and complete—Babel could not attend the university, again because of the Jewish quota. He enrolled in a business school in Kiev instead. It was at this time that he began to write stories, in French, imitating his favorite writers, François Rabelais, Gustave Flaubert, and Guy de Maupassant. In 1915, he went to St. Petersburg, already thinking seriously of a writing career. He had no success with editors, however, until he met Maxim Gorky, a leading Russian writer of the older generation, who published two of his stories and took him under his wing. This great friendship lasted until Gorky’s death in 1936. Gorky had encouraged Babel to write and had protected him but had published no more of his stories, and one day Gorky told Babel to go out into the world and learn about real life. Babel heeded his advice in 1917, setting off on a journey lasting several years, during which he volunteered for the army, took part in the revolution and civil war, married, worked for the secret police, was a war correspondent, and finally served in the famous cavalry division of Semyon Mikhaylovich Budenny in the war against the Poles. Out of these dramatic experiences, Babel was able to publish two books of short stories, which immediately thrust him into the forefront of the young Soviet literature. The period from 1921 to 1925 was the most productive and successful of his entire career. By the end of the 1920’s, however, the political climate in the Soviet Union had begun to change, forcing Babel to conform to the new demands on writers to serve the state, which he could not do, no matter how he tried. His attempts at writing a novel about collectivization never materialized. His inability (or, more likely, unwillingness) to change marks the beginning of a decade-long silent struggle between him and the state. Refusing to follow his family into emigration, he tried to survive by writing film scenarios, unable to publish anything else. In May, 1939, he was arrested and sent to a concentration camp. On January 27, 1940, he was shot for espionage. His confiscated manuscripts—a large crate of them—were never found. Analysis • Isaac Babel’s short stories fall into three basic groups: autobiographical stories, tales about Jews in Odessa, and stories about the Russian Revolution and civil war. Even though the stories were written and published at different times, in retrospect they can be conveniently, if arbitrarily, classified into these three categories. A small number of stories do not fall into any of these groups, but they are exceptions and do not figure significantly in Babel’s opus. Although it is true that many of Babel’s stories are autobiographical, even if indirectly, a number of them are openly so. Several refer to his childhood spent in Nikolayev and Odessa. In one of his earliest stories, “Detstvo: U babushki” (“Childhood: At Grandmother’s”), Babel pays his emotional due to his kind grandmother, who kept quiet vigil over his studying for hours on end, giving him her bits of wisdom every now and then: “You must know everything. The whole world will fall at your feet and grovel before you. . . . Do not trust people. Do not have friends. Do not lend them money. Do not give them your heart!” Babel loved his childhood because, he said, “I grew up in it, was happy, sad, and dreamed my dreams—fervent dreams that will never return.” This early wistful realization of the inevitable transience of all things echoes through much of his writings. The mixture of happiness and sadness is reflected in one of his best stories, “Istoriia moei golubiatni” (“The Story of My Dovecot”), where a child’s dream of owning a dovecote is realized during a pogrom, but the dove, which his father had promised him if he was accepted to high school, is squashed against his face. The trickling of the dove’s entrails down his face symbol-
60
Short Story Writers
izes the boy’s loss of innocence and a premature farewell to childhood. Babel’s discovery of love as the most potent feeling of humankind came to him rather early. As he describes in “Pervaia liubov” (“First Love”), he was ten years old when he fell in love with the wife of an officer, perhaps out of gratitude for her protection of Babel’s family during the pogrom in Nikolayev. The puppy love, however, soon gave way to fear and prolonged hiccuping—an early indication of the author’s rather sensitive nervous system that accompanied him all his life. This innocent, if incongruous, setting points to a sophisticated sense of humor and to irony, the two devices used by Babel in most of his works. It also foreshadows his unabashed approach to erotica in his later stories, for which they are well known. As mentioned already, Babel lived as a child in a world of books, dreams, and rampant imagination. In addition, like many Jewish children, he had to take music lessons, for which he had no inclination at all. He had little time for play and fun and, as a consequence, did not develop fully physically. He was aware of this anomaly and tried to break out of it. During one such attempt, as he describes it in “Probuzhdenie” (“Awakening”), he ran away from a music lesson to the beach, only to discover that “the waves refused to support” him. Nevertheless, this experience made him realize that he had to develop “a feel for nature” if he wanted to become a writer. Another experience of “breaking out” concerns Babel’s awareness of his social status, as depicted in the story “V podvale” (“In the Basement”). In the story, he visits the luxurious home of the top student in his class and has to use his power of imagination to convince the rich boy that socially he is on equal footing with him. When the boy visits the apartment of Babel’s family, “in the basement,” however, the truth becomes obvious, and the little Isaac tries to drown himself in a barrel of water. This realization of the discrepancy between reality and the world of dreams and the need and desire to break out of various imposed confines were constant sources of aggravation in Babel’s life. Other autobiographical stories, as well as many other stories seemingly detached from the author’s personal life, attest this perennial struggle. Tales of Odessa • The stories about the life of Jews, in the collection Tales of Odessa, demonstrate Babel’s attachment to his ethnic background as well as his efforts to be objective about it. In addition to being an economic and cultural center, Odessa had a strong underground world of criminals made mostly of Jews, which fueled the imagination of the growing Isaac; later, he used his reminiscences about the Jewish mafia in some of his best stories. He immortalized one of the leaders, Benya Krik, alias the King, in “Korol” (“The King”). Benya’s daring and resourcefulness are shown during the wedding of his elderly sister, whose husband he had purchased. When the police plan to arrest Benya’s gang during the wedding celebration, he simply arranges for the police station to be set on fire. He himself married the daughter of a man he had blackmailed in one of his operations. An old man who saw in Babel a boy with “the spectacles on the nose and the autumn in the heart” told him the story of Benya’s rise to fame in “Kak eto delalos v Odesse” (“How It Was Done in Odessa”). Here, Benya orders the liquidation of a man who did not give in to blackmail, but Benya’s executioner kills the wrong man, a poor clerk who had very little joy in life. Benya orders a magnificent funeral for the unfortunate clerk and a lifelong financial support for his mother, thus showing his true nature and revealing that it is not crime that attracted him to the underground life but rather a subconscious desire to right the wrongs and help the downtrodden. Through such characters and their motives, Babel is able to lend
Babel, Isaac
61
his stories a redeeming grace, neutralizing the mayhem saturating them. Loyalty is another quality that binds these lawbreakers, as illustrated in the story “Otec” (“The Father”), where Benya helps an old gangster, who had given him his start, to marry off his daughter to the son of a man who had rejected the marriage. They are assisted by another legendary figure, Lyubka, known also from the story “Liubka Kazak” (“Lyubka the Cossack”). Lyubka, a middle-aged shop and whorehouse keeper, reigns supreme in her dealings with customers, who, in turn, help her wean her baby from breast-feeding. This interdependency in a life fraught with danger and risks gives Babel’s characters a human face and his stories a patina of real drama. Not all stories about Jews in Odessa deal with the underground world, as “Di Grasso,” a colorful tale about theater life in Odessa, shows. Di Grasso, a Sicilian tragedian, and his troupe flop the first night of the show. After a favorable newspaper review praising Di Grasso as “the most remarkable actor of the century,” the second night the theater is full and the spectators are so enthralled that the wife of the theater “mogul,” to whom the fourteen-year-old Isaac had pawned his father’s watch, makes the husband return the watch, sparing Isaac much trouble. Babel’s uncanny ability to intertwine high aspirations and small concerns, pathos with bathos, turns seemingly insignificant events into genuine human dramas. This is even more evident in the story “Konets bogadel’ni” (“The End of the Old Folks’ Home”), where the inmates of a poorhouse near the Jewish cemetery make a living by using the same coffins again and again, until one day the authorities refuse to allow a used coffin for the burial of a revolutionary hero. The ensuing rebellion by the inmates leads to their dispersal and to the end of their life-sustaining scheme. Thus, what began as a clever business proposition turns into tragedy, making Babel’s story a timeless statement of the human condition. Red Cavalry • Babel uses a similar technique in the collection Red Cavalry. Although the stories here are based on Babel’s real-life experiences in the war between the Russian revolutionaries and the Poles, their real significance lies beyond the factual presentation of a historical event, as the author endows every gesture, almost every word, with a potential deeper meaning. It is not coincidental that the entire campaign is seen through the eyes of, and told by, a baggage-train officer named Liutov (a persona standing for Babel), not by a frontline participant. Readers learn about the general nature of the conflict, recognize the place names, and even follow the course of the battles, but they cannot piece together the exact history of the conflict simply because that was not the author’s intention. Babel gives readers single episodes in miniature form instead, like individual pieces of a mosaic; only after finishing the book are readers able to take in the complete picture. The first story, “Perekhod cherez Zbruch” (“Crossing into Poland”), sets the tone for the entire collection. The opening lines reveal that a military objective has been taken, but Liutov’s baggage train that follows sinks into a hazy, dreamy, impressionistic atmosphere, as if having nothing to do with the campaign: Fields flowered around us, crimson with poppies; a noontide breeze played in the yellowing rye; on the horizon virginal buckwheat rose like the wall of a distant monastery. The Volyn’s peaceful stream moved away from us in sinuous curves and was lost in the pearly haze of the birch groves; crawling between flowery slopes, it wound weary arms through a wilderness of hops. . . .
62
Short Story Writers
This passage shows a poetic proclivity of Babel, but it is also his deliberate attempt to take his readers away from the factual course of events and move them to what he considers to be more important—the human perception of the events. Many of the stories in the collection bear the same trademark. Although many stories deserve detailed comment, several stand out for their “message” or meaning that can be culled from the story. Nowhere is the brutal nature of the civil war depicted more poignantly than in “Pis’mo” (“A Letter”). A young, illiterate cossack, Vasily, dictates to Liutov a letter to his mother. He inquires about his beloved foal back home, and only after giving detailed advice about handling him does he tell how his father, who is on the other side, killed one of his sons and was then killed in return by another. This most tragic piece of news is relayed matter-of-factly, as if to underscore the degree of desensitization to which all the participants have fallen prey through endless killing. The cruelty of the civil war is brought into sharp focus by an old Jewish shopkeeper in “Gedali.” Gedali reasons like a legitimate humanitarian and libertarian: “The Revolution—we will say ‘yes’ to it, but are we to say ‘no’ to the Sabbath? . . . I cry yes to [the Revolution], but it hides its face from Gedali and sends out on front naught but shooting.” He understands when the Poles commit atrocities, but he is perplexed when the Reds do the same in the name of the revolution. “You shoot because you are the Revolution. But surely the Revolution means joy. . . . The Revolution is the good deed of good men. But good men do not kill.” Gedali says that all he wants is an International of good people. Liutov’s answer that the International “is eaten with gunpowder,” though realistic, falls short of satisfying the old man’s yearning for justice, which, after all, was the primary driving force of the revolution. It is interesting that, by presenting the case in such uncompromising terms, Babel himself is questioning the rationale behind the revolution and the justification of all the sacrifices and suffering. A similar moral issue is brought to a climactic head in perhaps the best story in Red Cavalry, “Smert’ Dolgushova” (“The Death of Dolgushov”). Dolgushov is wounded beyond repair and is left behind the fighting line to die. He is begging Liutov to finish him off because he is afraid that the Poles, if they caught him alive, would mutilate his body. Liutov refuses. The commander gallops by, evaluates the situation, and shoots Dolgushov in the mouth. Before galloping away, the commander threatens to kill Liutov, too, screaming, “You guys in specks have about as much pity for chaps like us as a cat has for a mouse.” Aside from the revolutionaries’ mistrust of Liutov (alias Babel) and the age-old question of euthanasia, the story poses a weighty moral question: Has a human being the right to kill another human being? Even though Babel seems to allow for this possibility, he himself cannot make that step, making it appear that he is shirking his responsibility (after all, he is fighting alongside the revolutionaries). More likely, he is hoping that there should be at least someone to say no to the incessant killing, thus saving the face of the revolution (as if answering Gedali’s mournful plea). More important, this hope hints at Babel’s real attitude toward the revolution. For such “misunderstanding” of the revolution he was criticized severely, and it is most likely that through such attitudes he sowed the seeds of his own destruction two decades later. Not all stories in Red Cavalry are weighed down with ultimate moral questions. There are stories of pure human interest, colorful slices of the war, and even some genuinely humorous ones. In “Moi pervyi gus’” (“My First Goose”), Liutov is faced with the problem of gaining the respect of the illiterate cossacks in his unit. As a be-
Babel, Isaac
63
spectacled intellectual (“a four-eyed devil,” as they called him), and a Jew at that, he knows that the only way to win them over is by committing an act of bravery. He thinks of raping a woman, but he sees only an old woman around. He finally kills a goose with his saber, thereby gaining the respect of his “peers.” Only then are they willing to let him read to them Vladimir Ilich Lenin’s latest pronouncements. With this mixture of mocking seriousness and irony, Babel attempts to put the revolution in a proper perspective. His difficulties at adjusting to military life are evident also in the story “Argamak,” where he ruins a good horse by not knowing how to handle it. The Jews are frequently mentioned in these stories because the war was taking place in an area heavily populated by them. Babel uses these opportunities to stress their perennial role as sufferers and martyrs, but also to gauge his own Jewish identification. In “Rabbi” (“The Rabbi”), he visits, with Gedali, an old rabbi, who asks him where he came from, what he has been studying, and what he was seeking—typical identification questions. Later, they and the rabbi’s son, “the cursed son, the last son, the unruly son,” sit amid the wilderness of war, in silence and prayers, as if to underscore the isolation of people threatened by an alien war. In “Berestechko,” a cossack is shown cutting the throat of an old Jewish “spy,” being careful not to stain himself with blood. This one detail completes the picture of a Jew as an ultimate victim. Many characters are etched out in these miniature stories. There is Sandy the Christ in the story by the same title (“Sashka Khristov”), a meek herdsman who at the age of fourteen caught “an evil disease” while carousing with his stepfather and who later joined the Reds and became a good fighter. There is Pan Apolek (“Pan Apolek”), an itinerant artist who painted church icons in the images not of the saints but of local people. There is Afonka Bida (“Afonka Bida”), the commander who almost shot Liutov because of Dolgushov, who loses his horse Stepan and disappears hunting for another. After several weeks, he reappears with a gray stallion, but the loss of Stepan still makes him want to destroy the whole world. In “So” (“Salt”), a woman carrying a bundled baby uses him to gain sympathy and hitch a train ride. It turns out that the bundle is nothing but a two-pound sack of salt; she is thrown out of the moving train and then shot from the distance. The man who killed her pronounces solemnly, “We will deal mercilessly with all the traitors that are dragging us to the dogs and want to turn everything upside down and cover Russia with nothing but corpses and dead grass,” which is exactly what he has just done. Finally, in one of the best stories in the book, “Vdova” (“The Widow”), a lover of the dying commander is bequeathed all of his belongings, with the request that she send some of them to his mother. When the widow shows signs of not following the will of the deceased, she is beaten, and, if she forgets the second time, she will be reminded again in the same fashion. These stories are perfect illustrations of Babel’s ability to create unforgettable but credible characters, to set up dramatic scenes, and to conjure a proper atmosphere, while endowing his creations with a truly human pathos—qualities that characterize most of his stories but especially those in Red Cavalry. Among the stories outside the three groups, several are worth mentioning. An early story, “Mama, Rimma, i Alla” (“Mama, Rimma, and Alla”), resembles an Anton Chekhov story in that the domestic problems in a family (a mother finds it difficult to cope with her daughters in absence of her husband) are not solved and the story dissolves in hopelessness. “Iisusov grekh” (“The Sin of Jesus”) is a colorful tale of a woman whose husband is away at war and who goes to Jesus for advice about loneliness. When Jesus sends her an angel, she accidentally smothers him to death in sleep. She goes again to Jesus, but now he damns her as a slut, which she resents, for it is not
64
Short Story Writers
her fault that she lusts, that people drink vodka, and that he has created “a woman’s soul, stupid and lonely.” When finally Jesus admits his error and asks for forgiveness, she refuses to accept it, saying, “There is no forgiveness for you and never will be.” The story displays Babel’s exquisite sense of humor along with a keen understanding of human nature and the complexities of life. A variant, “Skazka pro babu” (“The Tale of a Woman”), another Chekhovian story, again depicts the plight of a widow who, in her loneliness, asks a friend to find her a husband. When she does, he mistreats her and walks out on her, which causes her to lose her job. Finally, “Ulitsa Dante” (“Dante Street”) is a Paris story in the tradition of Guy de Maupassant, showing Babel’s versatility and imagination. Babel’s stylistic excellence has been often praised by critics. His style features a Spartan economy of words, and he is known to have spent years reworking and revising his stories. Babel’s attention to detail, especially to line and color, often result in fine etchings. There is a pronounced poetic bent in his stories, whether they are located in a city milieu or in the countryside. This is reinforced by a prolific use of images and metaphors in the style of the following passages, quoted at random: A dead man’s fingers were picking at the frozen entrails of Petersburg. . . . The gentleman had drooping jowls, like the sacks of an old-clothes man, and wounded cats prowled in his reddish eyes. One finds in Babel also a surprising amount of humor, as if to offset the cruelty and gruesome injustice of his world. Babel’s artfulness is especially noticeable in his treatment of irony as his strongest device. He refuses to accept reality as one perceives it. He also plays games with readers’ perceptions, as he says openly, “I set myself a reader who is intelligent, well educated, with sensible and severe standards of taste. . . . Then I try to think how I can deceive and stun the reader.” This cool intellectual approach, coupled with the strong emotional charge of his stories, gives his stories an aura of not only skillfully executed works of art but also pristine innocence of divine creation. Vasa D. Mihailovich Other major works plays: Zakat, pb. 1928 (Sunset, 1960; also known as Sundown); Mariia, pb. 1935 (Maria, 1966). miscellaneous: Isaac Babel: The Lonely Years, 1925-1939, Unpublished Stories and Private Correspondence, 1964, 1995; The Complete Works of Isaac Babel, 2001 (short stories, plays, screenplays, and diaries). nonfiction: 1920 Diary, 1995. poetry: Morning in the Burned House, 1996. screenplays: Benia Krik: Kinopovest’, 1926 (Benia Krik: A Film Novel, 1935); Bluzhdaiushchie zvezdy: Kinostsenarii, 1926. Bibliography Avins, Carol J. “Kinship and Concealment in Red Cavalry and Babel’s 1920 Diary.” Slavic Review 53 (Fall, 1994): 694-710. Shows how a diary Babel kept during his service in the 1920 Polish campaign was a source of ideas for his collection of stories, Red Cavalry. Claims that Babel’s efforts to conceal his Jewishness, recounted in the diaries, is also reflected in the stories.
Babel, Isaac
65
Carden, Patricia. The Art of Isaac Babel. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1972. In this discerning study of Babel’s art, Carden combines biography and analysis of his main works and themes, especially his search for style and form, and philosophical, religious, and aesthetic connotations. The meticulous scholarship is accompanied by keen insight and empathy, making the book anything but cut-anddried. Includes a select bibliography. Charyn, Jerome. Savage Shorthand: The Life and Death of Isaac Babel. New York: Random House, 2005. Fascinating, critically lauded account of Babel’s work and life. Ehre, Milton. “Babel’s Red Cavalry: Epic and Pathos, History and Culture.” Slavic Review 40 (1981): 228-240. A stimulating study of Babel’s chief work, incorporating its literary, historical, and cultural aspects. No attention to detail, but rather a sweeping overview. Falen, James E. Isaac Babel, Russian Master of the Short Story. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1974. Falen’s appraisal of Babel is the best overall. Following the main stages of Babel’s life, Falen analyzes in minute detail his works, emphasizing the short stories. Lucidly written and provided with the complete scholarly apparatus, the study offers an exhaustive bibliography as well. Luplow, Carol. Isaac Babel’s Red Cavalry. Ann Arbor, Mich.: Ardis, 1982. This detailed, full-length study of Babel’s most famous collection focuses on the narrative perspective of the stories, the basic dialectic between the spiritual and the physical which they embody, their style and romantic vision, and the types of story structure and epiphanic vision they reflect. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Babel: “Crossing into Poland” and “Di Grasso: A Tale of Odessa” (vol. 2), “Guy de Maupassant” (vol. 3), “How It Was Done in Odessa” and “In the Basement” (vol. 4), “Lyubka the Cossack” and “My First Goose” (vol. 5), and “The Story of My Dovecot” (vol. 7). Mendelson, Danuta. Metaphor in Babel’s Short Stories. Ann Arbor, Mich.: Ardis, 1982. Scholarly discussion, drawing from linguistic and psychological studies as well as structuralist studies of narrative. Shcheglov, Yuri K. “Some Themes and Archetypes in Babel’s Red Cavalry.” Slavic Review 53 (Fall, 1994): 653-670. Discusses initiatory and otherworldly thematic patterns in “My First Goose,” showing how Babel used archetypes subtly and selectively. Concludes that “My First Goose,” with its density reinforced by archetypal connotations, is an emblematic prototype of later works of Soviet fiction that focus on similar themes. Sicher, Efraim. Style and Structure in the Prose of Isaak Babel. Columbus, Ohio: Slavica, 1986. Primarily a formalist study of the style of Babel’s stories. In addition to discussing Babel’s lyrical prose, the book analyzes setting, characterization, narrative structure, and point of view in Babel’s stories. Terras, Victor. “Line and Color: The Structure of I. Babel’s Short Stories in Red Cavalry.” Studies in Short Fiction 3, no. 2 (Winter, 1966): 141-156. In one of the best treatments of a particular aspect of Babel’s stories, Terras discusses his style in terms of line and color and of his poetic inclination.
66
James Baldwin Born: New York, New York; August 2, 1924 Died: St. Paul de Vence, France; December 1, 1987 Principal short fiction • Going to Meet the Man, 1965. Other literary forms • In addition to one edition of short stories, James Baldwin published more than twenty other works, including novels, essays, two plays, a screenplay on Malcolm X, one play adaptation, a children’s book, two series of dialogues, and a collection of poetry, as well as numerous shorter pieces embracing interviews, articles, and recordings. Achievements • James Baldwin received numerous awards and fellowships during his life, including the Rosenwald, John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation, and Partisan Review fellowships, a Ford Foundation Grant, and the George Polk Memorial Award. In 1986, shortly before his death, the French government made him a Commander of the Legion of Honor. Biography • James Arthur Baldwin grew up in Harlem. While he was still attending DeWitt Clinton High School in the Bronx he was a Holy Roller preacher. After high school, he did odd jobs and wrote for The Nation and The New Leader. A turning point for him was meeting Richard Wright, who encouraged him to write and helped him obtain a fellowship that provided income while he was finishing an early novel. After moving to Paris in 1948 he became acquainted with Norman Mailer and other writers. His first major work, Go Tell It on the Mountain, appeared in 1953 and was followed by a long list of books. He moved back to New York in 1957, and during the 1960’s his writing and speeches made him an important force in the Civil Rights movement. Following the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr., Baldwin returned to Europe several times and again settled in France in 1974, where he lived until his death. He continued his productivity in the 1980’s. In 1985, for example, Baldwin wrote three works, including his first book of poetry. He died in 1987 of stomach cancer and is buried near Paul Robeson’s grave at Ferncliff Cemetery, Ardsley, New York. Analysis • James Baldwin is widely regarded as one of the United States’ most important writers in the latter part of the twentieth century. Baldwin’s writing career spanned more than four decades and is remarkable for its wide diversity of literary expression, encompassing fiction, nonfiction, poetry, and plays. He was considered the most important American writer during the 1950’s, 1960’s, and 1970’s on the issue of racial inequality. The repeated thrust of his message, centered on being black in a white America, touched a responsive chord. Disgusted with American bigotry, social discrimination, and inequality, he exiled himself in France, where he poured out his eloquent and passionate criticism. Baldwin also wrote with compelling candor about the Church, Harlem, and homosexuality. He often fused the themes of sex and race in his work. Today, Baldwin’s essays are considered his most important contribution to literature.
Baldwin, James
67
“The Man Child” • Baldwin’s “The Man Child,” the only story in Going to Meet the Man that has no black characters, scathingly describes whites, especially their violent propensities. The central character is Eric, an eight-yearold. The story opens as he, his mother, and his father are giving a birthday party for Jamie, his father’s best friend. In the next scene Eric and his TO VIEW IMAGE, father walk together and then return PLEASE SEE to the party. After a brief summary of PRINT EDITION intervening events, the story moves forward in time to a day when Jamie OF THIS BOOK. meets Eric, entices him into a barn, and breaks his neck. The story described thus, its ending seems to be a surprise, and it certainly is a surprise to Eric. In fact, his sudden realization that he is in grave danger is an epiphany. “The Man Child” is thus a coming-of-age story, an account of a young person’s realization of the dark side of adult existence. Eric, however, has little time to think about his realization or even to generalize very much on © John Hoppy Hopkins the basis of his intimation of danger before he is badly, perhaps mortally, injured. The story, however, contains many hints that violent action will be forthcoming. A reader can see them even though Eric cannot because Eric is the center of consciousness, a device perfected, if not invented, by Henry James. That is, Eric does not narrate the story so the story does not present his viewpoint, but he is always the focus of the action, and the story is in essence an account of his responses to that action. The difference between his perception of the events he witnesses (which is sometimes described and sometimes can be inferred from his actions) and the perception that can be had by attending carefully to the story encourages a reader to make a moral analysis and finally to make a moral judgment, just as the difference between Huck Finn’s perception and the perception that one can have while reading The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (1884) at first stimulates laughter and then moral evaluation. Eric’s lack of perception is a function of his innocence, a quality that he has to an even larger extent than has Huck Finn, and thus he is less able to cope in a threatening world and his injury is even more execrable. If the measure of a society is its solicitude for the powerless, the miniature society formed by the three adults in this story, and perhaps by implication the larger society of which they are a part, is sorely wanting. To be more specific about the flaws in this society and in these persons, they enslave themselves and others, as is suggested very early in the story: “Eric lived with his father . . . and his mother, who had been captured by his father on some faroff un-
68
Short Story Writers
blessed, unbelievable night, who had never since burst her chains.” Her husband intimidates and frightens her, and his conversation about relations between men and women indicates that he believes she exists at his sufferance only for sex and procreation. Her role becomes questionable because in the summary of events that happen between the first and last parts of the story one learns that she has lost the child she had been carrying and cannot conceive anymore. The two men enslave themselves with their notions about women, their drunkenness (which they misinterpret as male companionship), their mutual hostility, their overbearing expansiveness, in short, with their machismo. Eric’s father is convinced that he is more successful in these terms. He has fathered a son, an accomplishment the significance of which to him is indicated by his “some day all this will be yours” talk with Eric between the two party scenes. Jamie’s wife, showing more sense than Eric’s mother, left him before he could sire a son. Jamie’s violent act with Eric is his psychotic imitation of the relation of Eric’s father to Eric, just as his whistling at the very end of the story is his imitation of the music he hears coming from a tavern. Eric is thus considered by the two men to be alive merely for their self-expression. His father’s kind of self-expression is potentially debilitating, although somewhat benign; Jamie’s version is nearly fatal. “Going to Meet the Man” • “Going to Meet the Man” is a companion to “The Man Child,” both stories having been published for the first time in Going to Meet the Man. Whereas the latter story isolates whites from blacks in order to analyze their psychology, the former story is about whites in relation to blacks, even though blacks make only brief appearances in it. The whites in these stories have many of the same characteristics, but in “Going to Meet the Man” those characteristics are more obviously dangerous. These stories were written during the height of the Civil Rights movement, and Baldwin, by means of his rhetorical power and his exclusion of more human white types, helped polarize that movement. The main characters in “Going to Meet the Man” are a family composed of a southern deputy sheriff, his wife, and his son, Jesse. At the beginning of the story they are skittish because of racial unrest. Demonstrations by blacks have alternated with police brutality by whites, each response escalating the conflict, which began when a black man knocked down an elderly white woman. The family is awakened late at night by a crowd of whites who have learned that the black has been caught. They all set off in a festive, although somewhat tense, mood to the place where the black is being held. After they arrive the black is burned, castrated, and mutilated— atrocities that Baldwin describes very vividly. This story, however, is not merely sensationalism or social and political rhetoric. It rises above those kinds of writing because of its psychological insights into the causes of racism and particularly of racial violence. Baldwin’s focus at first is on the deputy sheriff. As the story opens he is trying and failing to have sexual relations with his wife. He thinks that he would have an easier time with a black, and “the image of a black girl caused a distant excitement in him.” Thus, his conception of blacks is immediately mixed with sexuality, especially with his fear of impotence. In contrast, he thinks of his wife as a “frail sanctuary.” At the approach of a car he reaches for the gun beside his bed, thereby adding a propensity for violence to his complex of psychological motives. Most of his behavior results from this amalgam of racial attitudes, sexual drives, fear of impotence, and attraction to violence. For example, he recalls torturing a black prisoner by applying a cattle prod to his testicles, and on the way to see the black captive he takes pride in his wife’s
Baldwin, James
69
attractiveness. He also frequently associates blacks with sexual vigor and fecundity. The castration scene is the most powerful rendition of this psychological syndrome. The deputy sheriff, however, is more than a mere brute. For example, he tries to think of his relation to blacks in moral terms. Their singing of spirituals disconcerts him because he has difficulty understanding how they can be Christians like himself. He tries to reconcile this problem by believing that blacks have decided “to fight against God and go against the rules laid down in the Bible for everyone to read!” To allay the guilt that threatens to complicate his life he also believes that there are a lot of good blacks who need his protection from bad blacks. These strategies for achieving inner peace do not work, and Baldwin brilliantly describes the moral confusion of such whites: They had never dreamed that their privacy could contain any element of terror, could threaten, that is, to reveal itself, to the scrutiny of a judgment day, while remaining unreadable and inaccessible to themselves; nor had they dreamed that the past, while certainly refusing to be forgotten, could yet so stubbornly refuse to be remembered. They felt themselves mysteriously set at naught. In the absence of a satisfying moral vision, violence seems the only way to achieve inner peace, and the sheriff’s participation in violence allows him to have sex with his wife as the story ends. Even then, however, he has to think that he is having it as blacks would. He is their psychic prisoner, just as the black who was murdered was the white mob’s physical prisoner. Late in this story one can see that Jesse, the sheriff’s eight-year-old son, is also an important character. At first he is confused by the turmoil and thinks of blacks in human terms. For example, he wonders why he has not seen his black friend Otis for several days. The mob violence, however, changes him; he undergoes a coming of age, the perversity of which is disturbing. He is the center of consciousness in the mob scene. His first reaction is the normal one for a boy: “Jesse clung to his father’s neck in terror as the cry rolled over the crowd.” Then he loses his innocence and it becomes clear that he will be a victim of the same psychological syndrome that afflicts his father: “He watched his mother’s face . . . she was more beautiful than he had ever seen her. . . . He began to feel a joy he had never felt before.” He wishes that he were the man with the knife who is about to castrate the black, whom Jesse considers “the most beautiful and terrible object he had ever seen.” Then he identifies totally with his father: “At that moment Jesse loved his father more than he had ever loved him. He felt that his father had carried him through a mighty test, had revealed to him a great secret which would be the key to his life forever.” For Jesse this brutality is thus a kind of initiation into adulthood, and its effect is to ensure that there will be at least one more generation capable of the kind of violence that he has just seen. “Sonny’s Blues” • Whereas “The Man Child” has only white characters and “Going to Meet the Man” is about a conflict between whites and blacks, “Sonny’s Blues” has only black characters. Although the chronology of “Sonny’s Blues” is scrambled, its plot is simple. It tells the story of two brothers, one, the narrator, a respectable teacher and the other, Sonny, a former user of heroin who is jailed for that reason and then becomes a jazz musician. The story ends in a jazz nightclub, where the older brother hears Sonny play and finally understands the meaning of jazz for him. The real heart of this story is the contrast between the values of the two brothers, a contrast that becomes much less dramatic at the end.
70
Short Story Writers
The two brothers have similar social backgrounds, especially their status as blacks and, more specifically, as Harlem blacks. Of Harlem as a place in which to mature the narrator says, “boys exactly like the boys we once had been found themselves encircled by disaster. Some escaped the trap, most didn’t. Those who got out always left something of themselves behind, as some animals amputate a leg and leave it in a trap.” Even when he was very young the narrator had a sense of the danger and despair surrounding him: When lights fill the room, the child is filled with darkness. He knows that every time this happens he’s moved just a little closer to that darkness outside. The darkness outside is what the old folks have been talking about. It’s what they’ve come from. It’s what they endure. For example, he learns after his father’s death that his father, though seemingly a hardened and stoical man, had hidden the grief caused by the killing of his brother. At first the narrator believes that Sonny’s two means for coping with the darkness, heroin and music, are inextricably connected to that darkness and thus are not survival mechanisms at all. He believes that heroin “filled everything, the people, the houses, the music, the dark, quicksilver barmaid, with menace; and this menace was their reality.” Later, however, he realizes that jazz is a way to escape: He senses that “Sonny was at that time piano playing for his life.” The narrator also has a few premonitions of the epiphany he experiences in the jazz nightclub. One occurs when he observes a group of street singers and understands that their “music seemed to soothe a poison out of them.” Even with these premonitions, he does not realize that he uses the same strategy. After an argument with Sonny, during which their differences seem to be irreconcilable, his first reaction is to begin “whistling to keep from crying,” and the tune is a blues. Finally the epiphany occurs, tying together all the major strands of this story. As he listens to Sonny playing jazz the narrator thinks that freedom lurked around us and I understood, at last, that he could help us be free if we would listen, that he would never be free until we did. Yet, there was no battle in his face now. I heard what he had gone through, and would continue to go through. The idea in that passage is essentially what Baldwin is about. Like Sonny, he has forged an instrument of freedom by means of the fire of his troubles, and he has made that instrument available to all, white and black. His is the old story of suffering and art; his fiction is an account of trouble, but by producing it he has shown others the way to rise above suffering. John Stark With updates by Terry Theodore Other major works children’s literature: Little Man, Little Man, 1975. plays: The Amen Corner, pr. 1954, pb. 1968; Blues for Mister Charlie, pr., pb. 1964; A Deed from the King of Spain, pr. 1974. novels: Go Tell It on the Mountain, 1953; Giovanni’s Room, 1956; Another Country, 1962; Tell Me How Long the Train’s Been Gone, 1968; If Beale Street Could Talk, 1974; Just Above My Head, 1979.
Baldwin, James
71
nonfiction: Notes of a Native Son, 1955; Nobody Knows My Name: More Notes of a Native Son, 1961; The Fire Next Time, 1963; Nothing Personal, 1964 (with Richard Avedon); A Rap on Race, 1971 (with Margaret Mead); No Name in the Street, 1971; A Dialogue, 1975 (with Nikki Giovanni); The Devil Finds Work, 1976; The Evidence of Things Not Seen, 1985; The Price of the Ticket, 1985; Conversations with James Baldwin, 1989; Collected Essays, 1998; Native Sons: A Friendship That Created One of the Greatest Works of the Twentieth Century, “Notes of a Native Son,” 2004 (with Sol Stein). poetry: Jimmy’s Blues: Selected Poems, 1983. screenplay: One Day, When I Was Lost: A Scenario Based on “The Autobiography of Malcolm X,” 1972. Bibliography Hardy, Clarence E. James Baldwin’s God: Sex, Hope, and Crisis in Black Holiness Culture. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 2003. Brief exploration of some the most troubling themes in Baldwin’s writing. Kinnamon, Keneth, ed. James Baldwin: A Collection of Critical Essays. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1974. Good introduction to Baldwin’s early work featuring a collection of diverse essays by such well-known figures as Irving Howe, Langston Hughes, Sherley Anne Williams, and Eldridge Cleaver. Includes a chronology of important dates, notes on the contributors, and a select bibliography. Leeming, David. James Baldwin: A Biography. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1994. Biography of Baldwin written by one who knew him and worked with him for the last quarter century of his life. Provides extensive literary analysis of Baldwin’s work and relates his work to his life. McBride, Dwight A. James Baldwin Now. New York: New York University Press, 1999. Stresses the usefulness of recent interdisciplinary approaches in understanding Baldwin’s appeal, political thought and work, and legacy. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Baldwin: “Come Out the Wilderness” (vol. 2); “Going to Meet the Man” (vol. 3); and “Sonny’s Blues,” “Tell Me How Long the Train’s Been Gone,” and “This Morning, This Evening, So Soon” (vol. 7). Miller, D. Quentin, ed. Re-Viewing James Baldwin: Things Not Seen. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2000. Explores the way in which Baldwin’s writing touched on issues that confront all people, including race, identity, sexuality, and religious ideology. Sanderson, Jim. “Grace in ‘Sonny’s Blues.’” Short Story, n.s. 6 (Fall, 1998): 85-95. Argues that Baldwin’s most famous story illustrates his integration of the personal with the social in terms of his residual evangelical Christianity. Argues that at the end of the story when the narrator offers Sonny a drink, he puts himself in the role of Lord, and Sonny accepts the cup of wrath; the two brothers thus regain grace by means of the power of love. Scott, Lynn Orilla. James Baldwin’s Later Fiction: Witness to the Journey. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press, 2002. Analyzes the decline of Baldwin’s reputation after the 1960’s, the ways in which critics have often undervalued his work, and the interconnected themes in his body of work. Sherard, Tracey. “Sonny’s Bebop: Baldwin’s ‘Blues Text’ as Intracultural Critique.” African American Review 32 (Winter, 1998): 691-705. A discussion of Houston
72
Short Story Writers
Baker’s notion of the “blues matrix” in Baldwin’s story; examines the story’s treatment of black culture in America as reflected by jazz and the blues. Discusses how the “blues text” of the story represents how intracultural narratives have influenced the destinies of African Americans. Tomlinson, Robert. “‘Payin’ One’s Dues’: Expatriation as Personal Experience and Paradigm in the Works of James Baldwin.” African American Review 33 (Spring, 1999): 135-148. A discussion of the effect life as an exile in Paris had on Baldwin. Argues that the experience internalized the conflicts he experienced in America. Suggests that Baldwin used his homosexuality and exile as a metaphor for the experience of the African American. Tsomondo, Thorell. “No Other Tale to Tell: ‘Sonny’s Blues’ and ‘Waiting for the Rain.’” Critique 36 (Spring, 1995): 195-209. Examines how art and history are related in “Sonny’s Blues.” Discusses the story as one in which a young musician replays tribal history in music. Argues that the story represents how African American writers try to reconstruct an invalidated tradition.
73
Toni Cade Bambara Born: New York, New York; March 25, 1939 Died: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; December 9, 1995 Principal short fiction • Gorilla, My Love, 1972; The Sea Birds Are Still Alive: Collected Stories, 1977; Raymond’s Run: Stories for Young Adults, 1989. Other literary forms • Before Toni Cade Bambara published her first collection of stories, Gorilla, My Love (1972), she edited two anthologies, The Black Woman (1970) and Tales and Stories for Black Folks (1971), under the name Toni Cade. Her 1980 novel, The Salt Eaters, was well received and won many awards. She was also an active screenwriter whose credits included Louis Massiah’s The Bombing of Osage Avenue (1986), about the bombing of the Movement (MOVE) Organization’s headquarters in Philadelphia, and Massiah’s W. E. B. Du Bois: A Biography in Four Voices (1995). Her friend and editor, Toni Morrison, edited a collection of her previously uncollected stories and essays in 1996 called Deep Sightings and Rescue Missions: Fiction, Essays, and Conversations, and her final novel, Those Bones Are Not My Child, was published in 1999. Achievements • The Salt Eaters won numerous awards, including the American Book Award, the Langston Hughes Society Award, and an award from the Zora Neale Hurston Society. Toni Cade Bambara’s work on The Bombing of Osage Avenue led to an Academy Award for Best Documentary and awards from the Pennsylvania Association of Broadcasters and the Black Hall of Fame. Her other honors include the Peter Pauper Press Award (1958), the John Golden Award for Fiction from Queens College (1959), a Rutgers University research fellowship (1972), a Black Child Development Institute service award (1973), a Black Rose Award from Encore (1973), a Black Community Award from Livingston College, Rutgers University (1974), an award from the National Association of Negro Business and Professional Women’s Club League, a George Washington Carver Distinguished African American Lecturer Award from Simpson College, Ebony’s Achievement in the Arts Award, and a Black Arts Award from the University of Missouri (1981), a Documentary Award from the National Black Programming Consortium (1986), and a nomination for the Black Caucus of the American Library Association Literary Award (1997). Biography • Toni Cade Bambara was born Miltona Mirkin Cade in New York City in 1939 and grew up in Harlem, Bedford-Stuyvesant, and Queens, New York, and in Jersey City, New Jersey. She attended Queens College in New York and received a bachelor’s degree in theater arts in 1959, the same year she published her first short story, “Sweet Town.” From 1960 to 1965, she worked on a master’s degree in American literature at City College of New York, while also working as a caseworker at the Department of Welfare, and later as program director of the Colony Settlement House. Starting in 1965, she taught at City College for four years before moving on to Livingston College at Rutgers University in 1969. She also taught at Emory University, Spelman College (where she was a writer-in-residence during the 1970’s), and Atlanta University, at various times teaching writing, theater, and social work.
74
Short Story Writers
Bambara’s publication of The Black Woman, an anthology of poetry, fiction, and nonfiction by established writers (such as Nikki Giovanni, Alice Walker, and Paule Marshall) and students demonstrated her commitment to both the women’s movement and the Civil Rights campaign. By the time she had published her first collection of short stories, Gorilla, My Love, in 1972, she had adopted the last name of Bambara from a signature she found on a sketch pad in a trunk of her grandmother’s things. Bambara’s belief in the connection between social activism and art was strengthened by a trip to Cuba in 1973, when she met with women’s organizations there. The increased urgency of concern for social activism appears in her second collection of short stories, The Sea Birds Are Still Alive. After her first novel, The Salt Eaters, was published in 1980 and received numerous awards, she increasingly turned her attention to her work in the arts, becoming an important writer of independent films, though she never stopped working on fiction. She died of cancer on December 9, 1995. Analysis • Toni Cade Bambara’s short fiction is especially notable for its creativity with language and its ability to capture the poetry of black speech. In a conversation that was printed in her posthumous collection Deep Sightings and Rescue Missions as “How She Came by Her Name,” she claimed that in the stories from Gorilla, My Love about childhood, she was trying to capture the voice of childhood, and she was surprised that readers received these efforts to use black dialect as a political act. Nonetheless, her writing (like her work as a teacher, social worker, and filmmaker) was always informed by her sense of social activism and social justice in the broadest sense. In her later work outside the field of short fiction (in films and in her last novel), she focused on the bombing of the black neighborhood in Philadelphia where the MOVE Organization was headquartered, the life of W. E. B. Du Bois, and the Atlanta child murders of the 1980’s, all topics that were rife with political meaning. Nonetheless, what enlivens her writing is her originality with language and a playful sense of form which aims more to share than to tell directly. Another essay from Deep Sightings and Rescue Missions, “The Education of a Storyteller” tells of Grandma Dorothy teaching her that she could not really know anything that she could not share with her girlfriends, and her stories seem to grow out of the central wish to share things with this target audience of black women peers. Her stories are usually digressive, seldom following a linear plot. Most of them are structured in an oral form that allows for meaningful side issues with the aim of bringing clear the central point to her audience. Though this technique can be daunting when used in the novel-length The Salt Eaters, it allows her to make her short stories into charming, witty, and lively artistic performances whose social messages emerge organically. Gorilla, My Love • Gorilla, My Love was Toni Cade Bambara’s first collection of her original work, and it remains her most popular book. The stories in it were written between 1959 and 1970, and as she explains in her essay, “How She Came by Her Name,” she was trying to capture the language system in which people she knew lived and moved. She originally conceived it as a collection of the voices of young, bright, and tough girls of the city, but she did not want it to be packaged as a children’s book, so she added some of the adult material to it. “My Man Bovane,” for instance, features a matronly black woman seducing a blind man at a neighborhood political rally, while her children look on in disapproval. Similarly, among the fifteen stories (most of which are written in the first person) that make up this book is “Talkin Bout
Bambara, Toni Cade
75
Sonny,” in which Betty and Delauney discuss their friend Sonny’s recent breakdown and assault on his wife. Delauney claims he understands exactly how such a thing could happen, and it is left unclear how this unstable relationship between Betty and Delauney (who is married) will resolve itself. TO VIEW IMAGE, Most of the stories, however, focus on young girls determined to make PLEASE SEE their place in the world and the PRINT EDITION neighborhood. “The Hammer Man,” OF THIS BOOK. for instance, tells of a young girl who first hides from a mentally disturbed older boy she has humiliated in public but later futilely attempts to defend against two policemen who try to arrest him. The adult themes and the childhood themes come together best in “The Johnson Girls,” in which a young girl listens in as a group of women try to console Inez, whose boyfriend has left with no promise of Joyce Middler return. As the young narrator listens in the hope that she will not have to endure “all this torture crap” when she becomes a woman, it becomes clear that the intimate conversation between women is a form of revitalization for Inez. A delightful preface to Gorilla, My Love assures readers that the material in the book is entirely fictional, not at all autobiographical, but it is hard for a reader not to feel that the voices that populate the work speak for Bambara and the neighborhood of her youth. “Gorilla, My Love” • The title story of Bambara’s first book-length collection of her own work, “Gorilla, My Love” is also her most irresistible work. The narrator is a young girl named Hazel who has just learned that her “Hunca Bubba” is about to be married. She is clearly upset about both this news and the fact that he is now going by his full name, Jefferson Winston Vale. The story proceeds in anything but a linear manner, as Hazel sees a movie house in the background of Hunca Bubba’s photos, and starts to tell about going to the movies on Easter with her brothers, Big Brood and Little Jason. When the movie turns out to be a film about Jesus instead of “Gorilla, My Love,” as was advertised, Hazel gets angry and demands her money back, and not getting it, starts a fire in the lobby—“Cause if you say Gorilla My Love you supposed to mean it.” What is really on her mind is that when Hunca Bubba was baby-sitting her, he promised he was going to marry her when she grew up, and she believed him. Hazel’s attempt to keep her dignity but make her feeling of betrayal known by confronting Hunca Bubba is at once both a surprise and a completely natural outgrowth of her character. Her grandfather’s explanation, that it was Hunca Bubba who promised to
76
Short Story Writers
marry her but it is Jefferson Winston Vale who is marrying someone else, is at once both compassionate and an example of the type of hypocrisy that Hazel associates with the adult world. The example she gives in her story about going to the movie makes it clear that she has always seen her family as better than most, but she sees hypocrisy as a universal adult epidemic. “Raymond’s Run” • “Raymond’s Run,” a short story that was also published as a children’s book, is about the relationship between the narrator, Hazel (not the same girl from “Gorilla, My Love,” but about the same age), her mentally disabled brother, Raymond, and another girl on the block, Gretchen. Hazel’s reputation is as the fastest thing on two feet in the neighborhood, but coming up to the annual May Day run, she knows that her new rival, Gretchen, will challenge her and could win. Mr. Pearson, a teacher at the school, suggests it would be a nice gesture to the new girl, Gretchen, to let her win, which Hazel dismisses out of hand. Thinking about a Hansel and Gretel pageant in which she played a strawberry, Hazel thinks, “I am not a strawberry . . . I run. That is what I’m all about.” As a runner, she has no intention of letting someone else win. In fact, when the race is run, she does win, but it is very close, and for all her bravado, she is not sure who won until her name is announced. More important, she sees her brother Raymond running along with her on the other side of the fence, keeping his hands down in an awkward running posture that she accepts as all his own. In her excitement about her brother’s accomplishment, she imagines that her rival Gretchen might want to help her train Raymond as a runner, and the two girls share a moment of genuine warmth. The central point of the story is captured by Hazel when she says of the smile she shared with Gretchen that it was the type of smile girls can share only when they are not too busy being “flowers of fairies or strawberries instead of something honest and worthy of respect . . . you know . . . like being people.” The honest competition that brought out their best efforts and enticed Raymond to join them in his way brought them all together as people, not as social competitors trying to outmaneuver one another but as allies. “The Lesson” • “The Lesson” is a story about a child’s first realization of the true depth of economic inequity in society. The main characters are Miss Moore, an educated black woman who has decided to take the responsibility for the education of neighborhood children upon herself, and Sylvia, the narrator, a young girl. Though it is summer, Miss Moore has organized an educational field trip. This annoys Sylvia and her friend, Sugar, but since their parents have all agreed to the trip, the children have little choice but to cooperate. The trip is actually an excursion to a high-priced department store, F. A. O. Schwartz. The children look with astonishment at a toy clown that costs $35, a paperweight that sells for $480, and a toy sailboat that is priced at $1,195. The children are discouraged by the clear signs of economic inequality. When Miss Moore asks what they have learned from this trip, only Sugar will reply with what she knows Miss Moore wants them to say: “This is not much of a democracy.” Sylvia feels betrayed but mostly because she sees that Sugar is playing up to Miss Moore, while Sylvia has been genuinely shaken by this trip. At the end, Sugar is plotting to split the money she knows Sylvia saved from the cab fare Miss Moore gave her, but Sylvia’s response as Sugar runs ahead to their favorite ice cream shop, “ain’t nobody gonna beat me at nothin’,”
Bambara, Toni Cade
77
indicates she has been shaken and is not planning to play the same old games. However, Sylvia cannot so easily slough it off. “Medley” • The most popular story from The Sea Birds Are Still Alive, “Medley” is the story of Sweet Pea and Larry, a romantic couple who go through a poignant breakup in the course of the story. Though neither of them is a musician, both are music fans, and their showers together are erotic encounters in which they improvise songs together, pretending to be playing musical instruments with each other’s body. Sweet Pea is a manicurist with her own shop, and her best customer is a gambler named Moody, who likes to keep his nails impeccable. Because he goes on a winning streak after she starts doing his nails, he offers to take her on a gambling trip as his personal manicurist, for which he pays her two thousand dollars. Sweet Pea takes the offer, though Larry objects, and when she gets back, he seems to have disappeared from her life. Nonetheless, she remembers their last night in the shower together, as they sang different tunes, keeping each other off balance, but harmonizing a medley together until the hot water ran out. Though Sweet Pea is faced with the choice of losing two thousand dollars or her boyfriend and chooses the money, the story does not attempt to say that she made the wrong choice. Rather, it is a snapshot of the impermanence of shared lives in Sweet Pea’s modern, urban environment. This transience is painful, but is also the basis for the enjoyment of life’s beauty. Thomas Cassidy Other major works anthologies: The Black Woman: An Anthology, 1970; Tales and Stories for Black Folks, 1971; Southern Exposure, 1976 (periodical; Bambara edited volume 3). novels: The Salt Eaters, 1980; Those Bones Are Not My Child, 1999. miscellaneous: “What It Is I Think I’m Doing Anyhow,” The Writer on Her Work, 1981 (Janet Sternburg, editor); Deep Sightings and Rescue Missions: Fiction, Essays, and Conversations, 1996. screenplays: The Bombing of Osage Avenue, 1986 (documentary); W. E. B. Du Bois—A Biography in Four Voices, 1995 (with Amiri Baraka, Wesley Brown, and Thulani Davis). Bibliography Alwes, Derek. “The Burden of Liberty: Choice in Toni Morrison’s Jazz and Toni Cade Bambara’s The Salt Eaters.” African American Review 30, no. 3 (Fall, 1996): 353-365. In comparing the works of Morrison and Bambara, Alwes argues that while Morrison wants readers to participate in a choice, Bambara wants them to choose to participate. Bambara’s message is that happiness is possible if people refuse to forget the past and continue to participate in the struggle. Butler-Evans, Elliott. Race, Gender, and Desire: Narrative Strategies in the Fiction of Toni Cade Bambara, Toni Morrison, Alice Walker. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1989. The first book-length study to treat Bambara’s fiction to any extent, this study uses narratology and feminism to explore Bambara’s works. Evans, Mari, ed. Black Women Writers (1950-1980): A Critical Evaluation. Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor Press/Doubleday, 1984. In the essay “Salvation Is the Issue,” Bambara says that the elements of her own work that she deems most important
78
Short Story Writers
are laughter, use of language, sense of community, and celebration. Hargrove, Nancy. “Youth in Toni Cade Bambara’s Gorilla, My Love.” In Women Writers of the Contemporary South, edited by Peggy Whitman Prenshaw. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1984. Thorough examination of an important feature of Bambara’s most successful collection of short fiction—namely, that most of the best stories center on young girls. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Bambara: “Gorilla, My Love” (vol. 3); “The Lesson” (vol. 4); “My Man Bovanne” (vol. 5); and “Raymond’s Run” (vol. 6). Vertreace, Martha M. Toni Cade Bambara. New York: Macmillan Library Reference, 1998. The first full-length work devoted to the entirety of Bambara’s career. A part of the successful Twayne series of criticism, this will be quite helpful for students interested in Bambara’s career. Williamson, Judith Barton. “Toni Cade Bambara.” In Critical Survey of Long Fiction, Revised Edition, edited by Carl Rollyson. Vol. 1. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2000. Analysis of Bambara’s longer fictional works that may offer insights into her short fiction. Willis, Susan. “Problematizing the Individual: Toni Cade Bambara’s Stories for the Revolution.” In Specifying: Black Women Writing the American Experience. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1987. Though largely centered on an analysis of The Salt Eaters, this essay also has clear and informative analysis of Bambara’s most important short fiction.
79
Russell Banks Born: Newton, Massachusetts; March 28, 1940 Principal short fiction • Searching for Survivors, 1975; The New World, 1978; Trailerpark, 1981; Success Stories, 1986; The Angel on the Roof: The Stories of Russell Banks, 2000. Other literary forms • Russell Banks has published several collections of poetry and many novels. Continental Drift (1985) was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and Affliction (1989) was nominated for both the PEN/Faulkner Award for Fiction and the Irish International Prize. His other major works include the novels Family Life (1975), Hamilton Stark (1978), The Sweet Hereafter (1991), Rule of the Bone (1995), Cloudsplitter (1998), and The Darling (2004). His poems, stories, and essays have appeared in The Boston Globe Magazine, Vanity Fair, The New York Times Book Review, Esquire, and Harper’s. Achievements • Russell Banks has been awarded a Woodrow Wilson Foundation Award, a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Fellowship, a National Endowment for the Arts grant, the Ingram Merril Award, the Fels Award, the John Dos Passos Award, the St. Lawrence Award for Fiction from St. Lawrence University and Fiction International, and the American Academy of Arts and Letters Award for work of distinction. His work has been anthologized in Prize Stories: The O. Henry Awards and The Best American Short Stories. Biography • Russell Earl Banks was born in Newton, Massachusetts, on March 28, 1940, and raised in New Hampshire. The first in his family to attend college, Banks found the atmosphere at Colgate University incompatible with his working-class background and relinquished his scholarship after eight weeks. He headed for Florida, fully intending to align himself with rebel Cuban leader Fidel Castro, but, lacking enough incentive and money, worked at odd jobs until his career path became clear. He was at various times a plumber (like his father), a shoe salesman, a department store window dresser, and an editor. In 1964 he enrolled at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and graduated Phi Beta Kappa in 1967. His sense of political and social injustice became more finely honed in this city, which is touted as the most northern of the southern states, the most dramatic incident being the disruption of an integrated party by gunwielding members of the local Ku Klux Klan. A John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship in 1976 allowed him to move to Jamaica, where he immersed himself in the culture, trying to live as a native rather than as a tourist. The experience of living in an impoverished nation helped him professionally as well as personally and gave him a broad perspective on issues of race. Married four times and the father of four grown daughters, Banks has taught at major universities, including Columbia University, Sarah Lawrence College, New York University, and Princeton University. Critic Fred Pfeil called Banks
80
Short Story Writers the most important living white male American on the official literary map, a writer we, as readers and writers, can actually learn from, whose books help and urge us to change.
Analysis • Russell Banks’s work is largely autobiographical, growing out of the chaos of his childhood: the shouting and hitting, physical and emotional abuse inflicted on the family by an alcoholic father, who abandoned them in 1953. Being forced at the age of twelve to assume the role of the man in the family and always living on the edge of poverty greatly influenced Banks’s worldview and consequently his writing. Banks’s struggle to understand the tight hold that the past has on the present and the future led him to create a world in which people come face to face with similar dilemmas. Banks’s characters struggle to get out from under, to free themselves from the tethers of race, class, and gender. He writes of working people, those who by virtue of social status are always apart, marginalized, often desperate, inarticulate, silenced by circumstances. He aims to be their voice, to give expression to their pain, their aspirations, their angsts. Their emotional makeup can be as complex as those more favored by birth or power. In an interview in The New York Times Book Review, Banks noted that part of the challenge . . . is uncovering the resiliency of that kind of life, and part is in demonstrating that even the quietest lives can be as complex and rich, as joyous, conflicted and anguished, as other seemingly more dramatic lives. Banks’s main strength, besides his graceful style, keen powers of observation, intelligence, and humanity, is his ability to write feelingly of often unlovable people. He never condescends or belittles. He does not judge. He always attempts to show, rather than tell, why characters are as they are, and it is in the telling that Banks is able to understand himself and exorcise the devils of his own past. He did not necessarily set out on self-discovery, but learned, through writing, who he was and what he thought. He grew to understand himself through understanding the elements of his past that shaped him. Banks is sometimes grouped with Raymond Carver, Richard Ford, and Andre Dubus as writers in a “Trailer-Park Fiction” genre, which, according to critic Denis M. Hennessy, examines American working-class people living their lives one step up from the lowest rung on the socioeconomic ladder and doing battle every day with the despair that comes from violence, alcohol, and self-destructive relationships. Some of Banks’s plots and themes are derivative, with heavy borrowings from Mark Twain and E. L. Doctorow, but his unique touch sets them apart. Banks is both a chronicler and a critic of contemporary society. Influenced by James Baldwin, who said that the true story about race would have to be “written from the point of view of a member of a lynch mob,” Banks attempts to elicit an understanding of the perpetrators as well as of the victims of crimes, cruelties, and injustices. He believes that understanding a situation depends on knowing how the players who created it were created themselves. His characters all search for transformation, for something that will redeem them, lift them above their present circumstances. Their searches lead them to greater desolation and very seldom to contentment. The lower echelon is forever pitted against and at the mercy of the middle class. Hennessy has called Banks’s short fiction the “testing ground of his most innovative ideas and techniques.” The major themes revolve around dishar-
Banks, Russell
81
mony, both in the family and in society, and the eternal search for the lost family. Banks admits that much of his fiction centers on “Russell Banks searching for his father. . . . I spent a great deal of my youth running away from him and obsessively returning to him.” Searching for Survivors • Banks’s first collection combines reality and fantasy, with the fourteen stories divided into three general groups: five moral and political parables, a trilogy of stories that feature Latin American revolutionary Che Guevara, and six substantially autobiographical tales set in New England. Banks’s experiments with narrative style, structure, and point of view met with mixed response. He was credited for trying but faulted for lacking a unifying thread. Critic Robert Niemi says of the parables that if the theme . . . is the modern divorce between cognition and feeling [they] stylistically enact that schism with a vengeance . . . almost all [being] solemn in tone, and written in a detached, clinically descriptive style that tends toward the cryptic. Each story ends on a note of either defeat or disillusionment. Survival is highly unlikely. The American Dream has failed. The opening tale deals with a man driving along the Henry Hudson Parkway, thinking about his childhood friend’s car, a Hudson, and about the explorer, who was set adrift in 1611 in the waters that eventually bore his name. The narrator imagines going to the shores of Hudson Bay to look for evidence of the explorer’s fate. Therein is an attempt to understand the past. Banks often deals with the Old World and the early exploration of North America, and he shows the connections between those who set out from their comfortable but unjust homelands to settle the unknown, and modern Americans who have been shunted out of their safe cocoons of fixed values and family security into the relativistic reality of the latter half of the twentieth century. In a story confirming Thomas Wolfe’s thesis that one “can’t go home again,” a young man returns from adventures with guerrilla leader Che Guevara, only to find his hometown irrevocably changed and himself so different that no one recognizes him. In another story, “With Che at Kitty Hawk,” a newly divorced woman and her two daughters visit the Wright Brothers Memorial. An almost-happy ending has the woman feeling somewhat liberated after being trapped in marriage, but that optimism is fleeting. In yet another, “Blizzard,” Banks shifts the narrator, first having him be omniscient, then having him speak through a man who is losing touch with reality, succumbing to guilt and bleak wintry surroundings. The New World • Banks’s search for a comfortable voice caused him to continue to experiment with narrative voice, switching from first- to second-person, and sometimes third-, at times unsettling readers and critics who deemed his shifts haphazard rather than intentional. Never fully at ease with an omniscient, all-knowing narrator, yet not wanting his storyteller to be a character, an integral player, and hence subject to the vagaries of plot, Banks tries to approach his writing as the telling of a story to a partner, perhaps in a darkened room while lying comfortably in bed. He wants to share his story, yet not to tell it from a position of privilege. This approach gives readers the immediacy needed for involvement in the story, but, at the same time, enough detachment on the part of the narrator to trust him.
82
Short Story Writers
Banks called his second collection, which was far more positively received, “a carefully structured gathering of ten tales that dramatize and explore the process and progress of self-transcendence, tales that . . . embrace the spiritual limits and possibilities of life in the New World.” The collection is divided into two parts: “Renunciation” and “Transformation.” The opening story, “The Custodian,” deals with a forty-three-year-old man whose father’s death finally frees him “to move to a new village . . . to drink and smoke and sing bawdy songs.” As he is now also free to marry, he, “reasoning carefully . . . conclude[s] that he would have good luck in seeking a wife if he started with women who were already married.” Fortuitously, he has many married male friends and thus begins his series of conquests. He proposes to a few likely prospects; they succumb; he changes his mind; they return to their husbands, never to know satisfaction again. In another story, “The Conversion,” a young boy is wracked by guilt at not being a good person, at engaging in excessive masturbation, always falling short of what he thought he should be. Alvin wants to change. He wants to be good, decent, and chaste. He fails miserably until one day he sees an angel in a parking lot and decides to become a preacher. His conversion, readers realize, is not so much religious as it is a hope to start anew. His new religious life starts as a dishwasher in a religious camp. Robert Niemi observes that, “much like Banks in his youth, Alvin is torn between the promise of upward mobility and loyalty to his father’s proletarian ethos.” Alvin’s father suspects him of “selling out his working-class identity by associating himself with a bourgeois profession,” reflecting Banks’s own social background in which attempts to move upward were considered a criticism of what was left behind. Historical figures are featured in some of the stories: Simón Bolívar, Jane Hogarth (wife of the eccentric painter William), Edgar Allan Poe, and others. In the Hogarth tale, “Indisposed,” the wife is sadly used by the husband, who treats her as a sexual convenience and housekeeper. She is overwhelmed by the nothingness of her existence. She is fat and self-loathing until she experiences a sickbed transformation which allows her to move beyond “pitying [her large, slow] body to understanding it.” She is then, according to Niemi, able to “inhabit her body fully and without shame, thus reclaiming herself.” Then, when her husband is caught in the upstairs bed with the young domestic helper, Jane is able to exact swift punishment and completely change the tenor of the home. Niemi observes that Banks’s history shades into fiction and fiction melds into history. [His] central theme, though, is the enduring human need to reinvent the self in order to escape or transcend the constrictions of one’s actual circumstances. This means creating a “new world” out of the imagination, just as the “discovery” of the Americas opened up vast horizons for a culturally exhausted Old World Europe. Banks believes that “the dream of a new life, the dream of starting over” is the quintessential American Dream, the ideological keystone of American civilization from its inception to the present day. Trailerpark • In this collection, perhaps his most structurally satisfying, Russell Banks takes readers into the very heart of a community of people who, while not having lowered expectations, do have less grandiose or unrealistic ambitions than those in the mainstream. They go through life earning enough to meet basic needs, never going far beyond their environs. Some work full time, some seasonally; some leave
Banks, Russell
83
for a while and then return. Most seem to find the day-to-day process of getting by nearly enough. Heartaches, anger, depression, and just plain weirdness are often eased with marijuana and alcohol. This collection’s twelve stories are interrelated because they all deal with the residents of the Granite State Trailerpark in Catamount, New Hampshire. They have little in common other than the circumstances of their housing. They are detached physically as well as emotionally, yet they do form a community with at least some common concerns. One of the residents notes that when you are “a long way from where you think you belong, you will attach yourself to people you would otherwise ignore or even dislike.” Each story deals with one of the dozen or so denizens, all of whom are “generally alone in the world.” Trailer #1 is the heartbeat of the park, where French Canadian manager Marcelle Chagnon oversees operations. She lost a child when an unscrupulous doctor found her more interesting than her illness. Bank teller Leon LaRoche lives in #2 next to Bruce Severance, in #3, a college student who is an afficionado of homegrown cannabis. Divorcée Doreen Tiede and her five-year-old daughter are in #4 next to the burned remains of #5, where Ginnie and Claudel Bing lived until Ginnie left the stove burner on. Retired army captain Dewey Knox is in #6; Noni Hubner and her mother Nancy are in #7. Merl Ring, in #8, enjoys self-imposed isolation, eagerly awaiting the blasting winters when he can set up his equipment in the middle of frozen Skitters Lake and spend months of solitary ice fishing. The former resident of #9, Tom Smith, killed himself, and the place remains empty. The only black resident, Carol Constant, sometimes shares #10 with her brother Terry. Number 11 houses Flora Pease and more than 115 guinea pigs, which threaten to overtake the trailer and the whole park. The opening story, “The Guinea Pig Lady,” introduces all the residents as they share their concerns about the situation. Most notable is the trailer and occupant not mentioned at all—#12, probably the narrator’s place. Banks’s park people have offbeat but understandable pathologies. Some are just achingly lonely. Critic Johnathan Yardley credits Banks with drawing together a “small but vibrant cast of characters, a human comedy in microcosm” made up of “utterly unconnected people [who] find themselves drawn together by the accident of living in the same place; the trailer park, grim and dreary as it may be, is a neighborhood.” Success Stories • This 1986 collection of twelve stories, six autobiographical, six parabolic, has more to do with failed attempts to change the course of lives than it does with acquisition of fame and fortune. The characters in the collection have been called “dreamers, nourished on giddy expectations, but disenfranchised by accidents of class, economy, looks or simple luck.” They think that life holds all sorts of possibilities but learn quickly that fate has not cast a favorable eye on them. Banks sets out to show that success is more elusive for the disenfranchised. Four stories revolve around Earl Painter, a young child in the story “Queen for a Day,” who writes to the host of the popular television show of the same name numerous times hoping that his mother’s plight will land her a place as a contestant. In subsequent stories, Earl attempts to come to grips with his parents and their lies and imaginings. His search for fulfillment leads him to Florida, where he experiences short-lived success. He toys with the idea of marrying into a new life but instead engages in adultery with a neighbor’s wife, learning from her husband that he is just one of her many dalliances. These stories are interspersed with ones that are either fabular or close to surreal.
84
Short Story Writers
Three deal with situations possibly slated to show a similarity between Third World exploitation and an American tendency to disenfranchise the working class. All deal with the terrible consequences of false promises of success. One story, “Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story,” shows the impermeability of the walls separating the classes. The hero, exceptionally handsome, develops an unlikely relationship with his antithesis, an alarmingly ugly barroom pickup named Sarah. His initial curiosity about lovemaking with someone so badly put together turns into a kind of commitment but not one strong enough to be made public. The contrast in their appearances proves too great for him. He is indeed superficial and acts hatefully. Years later, the truth of his love dawns on him, but Sarah is long gone, and he is left with his shame. Critic Trish Reeves notes in an interview that “the irony of finally becoming a literary success by writing about the failure of the American Dream was not lost on Banks.” He said: I still view myself in the larger world the way I did when I was an adolescent. . . . [as a member of] a working class family: powerless people who look from below up. I’m unable to escape that—how one views oneself in the larger structure is determined at an extremely early age. The great delusion is that if you only can get success then you will shift your view of yourself . . . you will become a different person. That’s the longing, for success is really not material goods, but in fact to become a whole new person. Gay Annette Zieger Other major works anthology: Brushes with Greatness: An Anthology of Chance Encounters with Greatness, 1989 (with Michael Ondaatje and David Young). novels: Family Life, 1975 (revised, 1988); Hamilton Stark, 1978; The Book of Jamaica, 1980; The Relation of My Imprisonment, 1983; Continental Drift, 1985; Affliction, 1989; The Sweet Hereafter, 1991; Rule of the Bone, 1995; Cloudsplitter, 1998; The Darling, 2004. nonfiction: The Autobiographical Eye, 1982 (David Halpern, editor); The Invisible Stranger: The Patten, Maine Photographs of Arturo Patten, 1999. poetry: Fifteen Poems, 1967 (with William Matthews and Newton Smith); 30/6, 1969; Waiting to Freeze, 1969; Snow: Meditations of a Cautious Man in Winter, 1974. Bibliography Chapman, Jeff, and Pamela S. Dean. Contemporary Authors 52 (1996). A short but information-packed study under the headings “Personal,” “Career,” “Memberships,” “Awards and Honors,” “Writings,” and “Sidelights” (containing author quotes and discussions, mostly of longer fiction but also touching on Trailerpark), followed by an invaluable list of biographical and critical sources. Contemporary Literary Criticism 37, 1986. Provides a good overview of Banks’s life up to 1985 and gives a substantial sampling of literary criticism. Contemporary Literary Criticism 72, 1992. Strong biographical overview of Banks’s life and influences, followed by critical analyses of work published between 1986 and 1991. Included is a valuable interview conducted by writer Trish Reeves that provides a good understanding of the author. Top literary critics provide illuminating commentary.
Banks, Russell
85
Haley, Vanessa. “Russell Banks’s Use of ‘The Frog King’ in ‘Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story.’” Notes on Contemporary Literature 27 (1997): 7-10. Proposes that the story from the Grimm brothers’ folktale collection is a source for Banks’s narrative. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Banks: “The Moor” (vol. 5), “Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story” (vol. 6), and “The Visitor” (vol. 8). Meanor, Patrick, ed. American Short Story Writers Since World War II. Vol. 130 in Dictionary of Literary Biography. Detroit: Gale Research, 1993. Good background material on Banks’s life and the general content of his fiction with some discussion of thematic and narrative approaches. Niemi, Robert. Russell Banks. Twayne’s United States Authors series. New York: Twayne, 1997. Comprehensive biography that includes critical analyses of all his major literary works. It is rife with charming and telling details that convey the essence of the author, but it maintains the objectivity necessary to present a fair portrait. ____________. “Russell Banks.” In American Writers: A Collection of Literary Biographies, Supplement V—Russell Banks to Charles Wright, edited by Jay Parini. New York: Scribner’s, 2000. This accessible article summarizes and updates Niemi’s book on Banks. The bibliography expands and updates the earlier one. Somerson, Wendy. “Becoming Rasta: Recentering White Masculinity in the Era of Transnationalism.” Comparatist 23 (1999): 128-140. Analyzes Rule of the Bone’s treatment of white masculinity and racial identity politics in an era when national boundaries are becoming more porous.
86
Donald Barthelme Born: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; April 7, 1931 Died: Houston, Texas; July 23, 1989 Principal short fiction • Come Back, Dr. Caligari, 1964; Unspeakable Practices, Unnatural Acts, 1968; City Life, 1970; Sadness, 1972; Amateurs, 1976; Great Days, 1979; Sixty Stories, 1981; Overnight to Many Distant Cities, 1983; Forty Stories, 1987. Other literary forms • In addition to his one hundred and fifty or so short stories, Donald Barthelme published four novels, a children’s volume that won a National Book Award, a number of film reviews and unsigned “Comment” pieces for The New Yorker, a small but interesting body of art criticism, and a handful of book reviews and literary essays, two of which deserve special notice: “After Joyce” and “Not Knowing.” Achievements • For nearly three decades, Donald Barthelme served as American literature’s most imitated and imitative yet inimitable writer. One of a small but influential group of innovative American fictionists that included maximalists John Barth, Robert Coover, and Thomas Pynchon, Barthelme evidenced an even greater affinity to the international minimalists Samuel Beckett and Jorge Luis Borges. What distinguishes Barthelme’s fiction is not only his unique “zero degree” writing style but also, thanks to his long association with the mass-circulation magazine The New Yorker, his reaching a larger and more diversified audience than most of the experimentalists, whose readership has chiefly been limited to the ranks of college professors and their students. For all the oddity of a fiction based largely upon “the odd linguistic trip, stutter, and fall” (Snow White, 1967), Barthelme may well come to be seen as the Anthony Trollope of his age. Although antirealistic in form, his fictions are in fact densely packed time capsules—not the “slices of life” of nineteenth century realists such as Émile Zola but “the thin edge of the wedge” of postmodernism’s version of Charles Dickens’s hard times and Charles Chaplin’s modern ones. For all their seeming sameness, Barthelme’s stories cover a remarkable range of styles, subjects, linguistic idioms, and historical periods (often in the same work, sometimes in the same sentence). For all their referential density, Barthelme’s stories do not attempt to reproduce mimetically external reality but instead offer a playful meditation on it (or alternately the materials for such a meditation). Such an art makes Barthelme in many respects the most representative American writer of the 1960’s and of the two decades that followed: postmodern, postmodernist, postFreudian, poststructuralist, postindustrial, even (to borrow Jerome Klinkowitz’s apt term) postcontemporary. Biography • Often praised and sometimes disparaged as one of The New Yorker writers, a narrative innovator, and a moral relativist whose only advice (John Gardner claimed) is that it is better to be disillusioned than deluded, Donald Barthelme was born in Philadelphia on April 7, 1931, and moved to Houston two years later. He grew up in Texas, attended Roman Catholic diocesan schools, and began his writing career as a journalist in Ernest Hemingway’s footsteps. His father, an architect who favored
Barthelme, Donald
87
the modernist style of Ludwig Mies Van Der Rohe and Le Corbusier, taught at the University of Houston and designed the family’s house, which became as much an object of surprise and wonder on the flat Texas landscape as his son’s oddly shaped fictions were to become on TO VIEW IMAGE, the equally flat narrative landscape of postwar American fiction. While majorPLEASE SEE ing in journalism, Barthelme wrote for PRINT EDITION the university newspaper as well as the OF THIS BOOK. Houston Post. He was drafted in 1953 and arrived in Korea on the day the truce was signed—the kind of coincidence one comes to expect in Barthelme’s stories of strange juxtapositions and incongruous couplings. After his military service, during which he also edited an Army newspaper, he returned to Houston, where he worked in the university’s public relations department (“writing poppycock for the President,” as he put it in one story), and where he founded Forum, a Bill Wittliff literary and intellectual quarterly that published early works by Walker Percy, William H. Gass, Alain Robbe-Grillet, Leslie Fiedler, and others. Barthleme published his first story in 1961, the same year that he became director of the Contemporary Arts Museum of Houston. The following year, Thomas Hess and Harold Rosenberg offered him the position of managing editor of their new arts journal, Location. The journal was short-lived (only two issues ever appeared), but Barthelme’s move to New York was not. Taking up residence in Greenwich Village, he published his first story in The New Yorker in 1963, his first collection of stories, Come Back, Dr. Caligari, in 1964, and his first novel, Snow White (among other things an updating of the Brothers Grimm fairy tale and the Walt Disney feature-length animated cartoon), in 1967. Although he left occasionally for brief periods abroad or to teach writing at Buffalo, Houston, and elsewhere, Barthelme spent the rest of his life chiefly in Greenwich Village, with his fourth wife, Marion Knox. He lived as a writer, registering and remaking the “exquisite mysterious muck” of contemporary urban American existence, as witnessed from his corner of the global (Greenwich) village. Analysis • Donald Barthelme’s fiction exhausts and ultimately defeats conventional approaches (including character, plot, setting, theme—“the enemies of the novel” as fellow writer John Hawkes once called them) and defeats, too, all attempts at generic classification. His stories are not conventional, nor are they Borgesian ficciones or Beckettian “texts for nothing.” Thematic studies of his writing have proved utterly inadequate, yet purely formalist critiques have seemed almost as unsatisfying. To approach a Barthelme story, the reader must proceed circuitously via various, indeed at times simultaneous, extraliterary forms: collage, caricature, Calder mobile, action
88
Short Story Writers
painting, jazz, atonality, the chance music of John Cage, architecture, information theory, magazine editing and layout, ventriloquism, even Legos (with all their permutational possibilities, in contrast with the High Moderns’ love of cubist jigsaw puzzles). In Barthelme’s case, comparisons with twentieth century painters and sculptors seem especially apropos: comical like Jean Dubuffet, whimsical and sad like Amedeo Modigliani, chaste like Piet Mondrian, attenuated like Alberto Giacometti, composite like Kurt Schwitters, improvisational like Jackson Pollock, fanciful like Marc Chagall and Paul Klee. Like theirs, his is an art of surfaces, dense rather than deep, textured rather than symbolic, an intersection of forces rather than a rendered meaning. Adjusting to the shift in perspective that reading Barthelme entails—and adjusting as well to Barthelme’s (like the poet John Ashbery’s) unwillingness to distinguish between foreground and background, message and noise—is difficult, sometimes impossible, and perhaps always fruitless. However attenuated and elliptical the stories may be, they commit a kind of “sensory assault” on a frequently distracted reader who experiences immediate gratification in dealing with parts but epistemological frustration in considering the stories as wholes, a frustration which mirrors that of the characters. Not surprisingly, one finds Barthelme’s characters and the fictions themselves engaged in a process of scaling back even as they and their readers yearn for that “more” to which Beckett’s figures despairingly and clownishly give voice. Entering “the complicated city” and singing their “song of great expectations,” they nevertheless—or also—discover that theirs is a world not of romantic possibilities (as in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s fiction) but of postmodern permutations, a world of words and undecidability, where “our Song of Songs is the Uncertainty Principle” and where “double-mindedness makes for mixtures.” These are stories that, like the red snow in Barthelme’s favorite and most Borgesian work, “Paraguay,” invite “contemplation” of a mystery that there is “no point solving—an ongoing low-grade mystery.” Expressed despondently, the answer to the question, “Why do I live this way?”—or why does Barthelme write this way?—is, as the character Bishop says, “Best I can do.” This, however, sums up only one side of Barthelme’s double-mindedness; the other is the pleasure, however fleeting, to be taken “in the sweet of the here and the now.” “Me and Miss Mandible” • Originally published as “The Darling Duckling at School” in 1961, “Me and Miss Mandible” is one of Barthelme’s earliest stories and one of his best. Written in the form of twenty-six journal entries (dated September 13 to December 9), the story evidences Barthelme’s genius for rendering even the most fantastic, dreamlike events in the most matter-of-fact manner possible. The thirty-five-year-old narrator, Joseph, finds himself sitting in a too-small desk in Miss Mandible’s classroom, having been declared “officially a child of eleven,” either by mistake or, more likely, as punishment for having himself made a mistake in his former life as claims adjuster (a mistake for justice but against his company’s interests). Having spent ten years “amid the debris of our civilization,” he has come “to see the world as a vast junkyard” that includes the failure of his marriage and the absurdity of his military duty. At once a biblical Joseph in a foreign land and a Swiftian Gulliver among the Lilliputians, he will spend his time observing others and especially observing the widening gap between word and world, signifier and signified, the ideals expressed in teachers’ manuals and the passions of a class of prepubescents fueled by film magazine stories about the Eddie Fisher/Debbie Reynolds/ Elizabeth Taylor love triangle. Unlike his biblical namesake, Joseph will fail at reeducation as he has
Barthelme, Donald
89
failed at marriage and other forms of social adjustment, caught by a jealous classmate making love to the freakishly named Miss Mandible. “A Shower of Gold” • The coming together of unlike possibilities and the seeming affirmation of failure (maladjustment) takes a slightly different and more varied form in “A Shower of Gold.” The former claims adjuster, Joseph, becomes the impoverished artist, Peterson, who specializes in large junk sculptures that no one buys and that even his dealer will not display. Desperate for money, he volunteers to appear on Who Am I?, the odd offspring of the game show craze on American television and of existentialism transformed into pop culture commodity. (There is also a barber who doubles as an analyst and triples as the author of four books all titled The Decision to Be.) Peterson convinces the show’s Miss Arbor that he is both interesting enough and sufficiently de trop to appear on Who Am I?, only to feel guilty about selling out for two hundred dollars. Watching the other panelists be subjected to a humiliating barrage of questions designed to expose their bad faith, Peterson, accepting his position as a minor artist, short-circuits the host’s existential script by out-absurding the absurd (his mother, he says, was a royal virgin and his father, a shower of gold). Peterson’s situation parallels Barthelme’s, or indeed any American writing at a time when, as Philip Roth pointed out in 1961, American reality had begun to outstrip the writer’s imagination, offering a steady diet of actual people and events far more fantastic than any that the writer could hope to offer. What, Roth wondered, was left for the writer to do? “A Shower of Gold” offers one possibility. “The Indian Uprising” • “The Indian Uprising” and “The Balloon” represent another possibility, in which in two quite different ways Barthelme directs the reader away from story and toward the act of interpretation itself (interpretation as story). As Brian McHale and Ron Moshe have demonstrated, “The Indian Uprising” comprises three overlapping yet divergent and even internally inconsistent narratives: an attack by Comanche on an unidentified but clearly modern American city; the narrator’s (one of the city’s defender’s) unsatisfying love life; and the conflict between modern and postmodern sensibilities manifesting itself in a variety of allusions to modernist texts, including T. S. Eliot’s The Waste Land (1922). Near the end of his poem, Eliot writes, “These fragments I have shored against my ruins.” “The Indian Uprising” presents a very different approach, transforming Eliot’s shoring up of high culture into a “barricade” that recycles Eliot and Thomas Mann along with ashtrays, doors, bottles of Fad #6 sherry, “and other items.” Behind Eliot’s poem lies the possibility of psychic, spiritual, and sociocultural wholeness implied by Eliot’s use of the “mythic method.” Behind Barthelme’s story one finds recycling rather than redemption and, instead of the mythic method, what Ronald Sukenick has called “the Mosaic Law,” or “the law of mosaics, a way of dealing with parts in the absence of wholes.” Short but beyond summary, filled with non sequiturs, ill-logic, self-doubts, and anti-explanations, “The Indian Uprising” rises against readers in their efforts to know it by reducing the story to some manageable whole. At once inviting and frustrating the reader’s interpretive maneuvers, “The Indian Uprising” follows the “plan” outlined in “Paraguay” insofar as it proves “a way of allowing a very wide range of tendencies to interact.” Attacking and defending are two operant principles at play here, but just who is attacking and what is being defended are never made clear. Sides change, shapes shift in a story in which American Westerns, the Civil Rights movement, and American in-
90
Short Story Writers
volvement in Vietnam all seem to have their parts to play, but never to the point where any one can be said to dominate the others. Small but indomitable, the story resists the linearity of an interpretive domino theory in favor of a semiotic quagmire (more evidence of Barthelme’s interest in current affairs—Vietnam, in this case—and “mysterious muck”). In “The Indian Uprising,” there is no final authority to come like the cavalry to the rescue and so no release from the anxiety evident in this and so many other Barthelme stories. Although there may be no permanent release, however, there is some temporary relief to be had in the “aesthetic excitement” of “the hard, brown, nutlike word” and in the fact that “Strings of language extend in every direction to bind the world into a rushing ribald whole.” “The Balloon” • “The Balloon” is a more compact exploration and a more relentless exploitation of interpretation as a semiotic process rather than a narrowly coded act. Covering only a few pages (or alternately an area forty-five city blocks long by up to six blocks wide), “The Balloon” is Barthelme’s American tall-tale version of the short French film The Red Balloon and an hommage to Frederick Law Olmsted (who designed New York’s Central Park) and environmental artist Cristo (one of his huge sculptural wrappings). Analogies such as these help readers situate themselves in relation to the inexplicable but unavoidable oddity of “The Balloon” in much the same way that the viewers in the story attempt to situate themselves in relation to the sudden appearance of a balloon which, even if it cannot be understood (“We had learned not to insist on meanings”), can at least be used (for graffiti, for example) and appreciated despite, or perhaps because of, its apparent uselessness. Ultimately the narrator will explain the balloon, thus adding his interpretive graffiti to its blank surface. The balloon, he says, was “a spontaneous autobiographical disclosure” occasioned by his lover’s departure; when, after twenty-two days, she returns, he deflates the balloon, folds it, and ships it to West Virginia to be stored for future use. His explanation is doubly deflating, for while the balloon’s “apparent purposelessness” may be vexing, in a world of “complex machinery,” “specialized training,” and pseudoscientific theories that make people marginal and passive, it has come to exist as the “prototype” or “rough draft” of the kind of solution to which people will increasingly turn, to what the Balloon Man calls his best balloon, the Balloon of Perhaps. Until the narrator’s closing comments, the balloon is not a scripted text but a blank page, not an object but an event, not a ready-made product, a prefab, but a performance that invites response and participation. It is a performance that the narrator’s explanation concludes, assigning both an origin (cause) and destination (result, function, use, addressee). Yet even as the explanation brings a measure of relief, it also adds a new level of anxiety insofar as the reader perceives its inadequacy and feels perhaps a twinge of guilty pleasure over having made so much of so little. In a way, however, the balloon was always doomed to extinction, for it exists in a consumer culture in which even the most remarkable objects (including “The Balloon”) quickly become all too familiar, and it exists too in a therapeutic society in thrall to the illusion of authoritative explanations. “Robert Kennedy Saved from Drowning” • Appearing only two months before the real Robert F. Kennedy’s assassination, “Robert Kennedy Saved from Drowning” explores epistemological uncertainty by exploiting the contemporary media’s and its audience’s claiming to know public figures, whether politicians or celebrities (a dis-
Barthelme, Donald
91
tinction that began to blur during the eponymous Kennedy years). The story exists at the intersection of two narrative styles. One is journalistic: twenty-four sections of what appear to be notes, each with its own subject heading and for the most part arranged in random order (the last section being a conspicuous exception) and presumably to be used in the writing of a profile or essay “about” Kennedy. The second narrative style is Kafkaesque fantasy and is evoked solely by means of the reporter’s use of journalistic shorthand, the initial “K,” which “refers” to Kennedy but alludes to the main characters of the enigmatic (and unfinished) novels Der Prozess (1925; The Trial, 1937) and Das Schloss (1926; The Castle, 1930) and ultimately to their equally enigmatic author, Franz Kafka himself. The narrator of “See the Moon?” claims that fragments are the only forms he trusts; in “Robert Kennedy Saved from Drowning,” fragments are the only forms the reader gets. The conflicting mass of seemingly raw material—quotes, impressions, even fragments of orders to waiters—saves Kennedy from drowning in a media-produced narcissistic image that turns even the most inane remarks into orphic sayings. Kennedy cannot drown; he can only float on the postmodern surface. Instead of the Kennedy image, Barthelme turns Kennedy into a series of images, the last being the most ludicrous and yet also the most revealing: Kennedy as Zorro, masked and floundering in the sea, his hat, cape, and sword safely on the beach. Saved from drowning (by the narrator), Kennedy is unmasked as a masked image, a free-floating signifier, a chameleon in superhero’s clothing who proves most revealing when most chameleon-like, offering a summary of Georges Poulet’s analysis of the eighteenth century writer Pierre Marivaux. Only here, at this third or even fourth remove, will many readers feel that they have gotten close to the “real” Kennedy: The Marivaudian being is, according to Poulet, a pastless, futureless man, born anew at every instant. The instants are points which organize themselves into a line, but what is important is the instant, not the line. The Marivaudian being has in a sense no history. Nothing follows from what has gone before. He is constantly surprised. He cannot predict his own reaction to events. He is constantly being overtaken by events. A condition of breathlessness and dazzlement surrounds him. In consequence he exists in a certain freshness which seems, if I may say so, very desirable. This freshness Poulet, quoting Marivaux, describes very well. “Views of My Father Weeping” • “Views of My Father Weeping” combines epistemological uncertainty with typically postmodern problematizing of the relationship between past and present (hinted at in the above quotation). Several days after his father has died under the wheels of an aristocrat’s carriage, the narrator sets out to investigate whether the death was accidental, as the police reported, or an example of the aristocracy’s (and the police’s) indifference to the poor. Spurred on less by a desire for truth and justice than a vague sense of filial obligation and even more by the slight possibility of financial gain, but fearful that he may be beaten for making inquiries, perhaps (like his father) even killed, the narrator-son proceeds, more hesitant than Hamlet. Hamlet had his father’s ghost appear to remind him of his duty to avenge a murder most foul. Barthelme’s story also has a ghost (of sorts), a weeping father who sits on his son’s bed acting in decidedly untragic fashion like a spoiled, sulky child whose very identity as father the son quietly questions. Complicating matters still further, this father seems to appear in a second story within “Views of My Father Weeping,” which takes place in a more contemporary and clearly, although fan-
92
Short Story Writers
tastically, American setting. These important if often blurred differences aside, the two narrators suffer from the same twin diseases that are pandemic in Barthelme’s fiction: abulia (loss of the ability to decide or act) and acedia (spiritual torpor). They certainly would benefit from a reading of a slightly later story, “A Manual for Sons,” a self-contained part of Barthelme’s second novel, The Dead Father (1975), which concludes with this advice: You must become your father, but a paler, weaker version of him. The enormities go with the job, but close study will allow you to perform the job less well than it previously has been done, thus moving toward a golden age of decency, quiet, and calmed fever. Your contribution will not be a small one, but “small” is one of the concepts that you should shoot for. . . . Fatherhood can be, if not conquered, at least “turned down” in this generation—by the combined efforts of all of us together. The extreme brevity of his densely allusive and highly elliptical stories suggests that Barthelme sides with the smallness of sons in their comic struggle with their various fathers (biological, historical, cultural). Against the authoritative word of the All Father, Barthelme offers a range of ventriloquized voices. “Here I differ from Kierkegaard,” says one of the characters in “The Leap.” “Purity of heart is not,” as Kierkegaard claimed, to will one thing; it is, rather, “to will several things, and not know which is the better, truer thing, and to worry about this forever.” Barthelme’s own double-mindedness and preference for mixtures and the guilty pleasures of the son’s uncertainty and anxiety of influence become especially apparent in his collages of verbal and visual materials in which he puts the magazine editor’s skills—layout in particular—to the fiction writer’s use in order to achieve for fiction the kind of “immediate impact” generally available only to those working in the visual arts. “At The Tolstoy Museum” • “At the Tolstoy Museum,” one of the best of these collages, literalizes, chiefly through visual means, the canonization of Leo Tolstoy as a metaphorical giant of literature, a cultural institution, an object of public veneration. Visitors to the “Tolstoy museum” must gaze at the prescribed distances and times and in the proper attitude of awe and submission. Readers of “At the Tolstoy Museum” find all the rules broken, temporal and spatial boundaries transgressed, and distances subject to a new and fantastic geometry. Against the museum as a repository of cult(ural) memorabilia, the story serves a narrative riposte in the form of a study in perspective. Barthelme whittles Tolstoy down to manageable size by exaggerating his proportions (much as he does with another dead father in his second novel): the thirty thousand photographs, the 640,086 pages of the Jubilee edition of Tolstoy’s works, the coat that measures at least twenty feet high, the head so large it has a hall of its own (closed Mondays, Barthelme parenthetically adds), even a page-long summary of one of Tolstoy’s shortest stories, “The Three Hermits.” There are also the two huge Soviet-style portraits on facing pages, identical in all but one feature: the tiny figure of Napoleon I (The Little Emperor), from Tolstoy’s Voyna i mir (1865-1869; War and Peace, 1886), playing the part of viewer/reader. Best of all is Barthelme’s rendering of The Anna-Vronsky Pavilion, devoted to the adulterous pair from Anna Karenina (1875-1877; English translation, 1886), a cutout of a nineteenth century man and woman superimposed on an early (and now adulterated) study in perspective dating from 1603. “At the Tolstoy Museum” does more than merely mix and match, cut and paste. It makes hilariously
Barthelme, Donald
93
clear the artifice of art and of what the passive consumer of culture may naively assume is both natural and eternal. “Sentence” • “Sentence” makes a similar point, but it does so by exploring the literal in a quite different way. As its title suggests, the story takes the form of a single sentence of approximately twenty-five hundred words and manages to combine the brevity, open-endedness, and formal innovation that together serve as the hallmarks of Barthelme’s idiosyncratic art. The subject of “Sentence” is the sentence itself: its progress and process. Beginning with one of Barthelme’s favorite words, “or” (“etc.” and “amid” are others), it proceeds by means of accretion and ends (if a work without any terminal punctuation can be said to end) as much an “anxious object” as any of those works of modern art to which Harold Rosenberg applied that phrase. Even as it pursues its own meandering, self-regarding, seemingly nonreferential way down the page, “Sentence” remains mindful of its reader, no less susceptible to distraction than the sentence itself and lured on by whatever promise the sentence holds out yet also feeling threatened by the sentence’s failure to play by the rules. As the narrator sums up, “Sentence” is “a man-made object, not the one we wanted of course, but still a construction of man, a structure to be treasured for its weakness, as opposed to the strength of stones.” Earlier in “Sentence,” Barthelme alludes to the Rosetta Stone that Champollion used to decipher the ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs. Barthelme’s fiction, although written in a familiar language, proves more resistant to decoding. Barthelme uses the past as he uses the present, but neither offers anything approaching an interpretive touchstone, only the raw material, the bits and bytes out of which he constructs his oddly shaped but nevertheless aesthetically crafted “archaeological slices.” “The Glass Mountain” • Built upon the cultural ruins of an ancient Norse tale entitled “The Princess and the Glass Hill,” “The Glass Mountain” resembles “Sentence” and “The Balloon” more than it does its nominal source in that it, too, is largely about one’s reading of it. “I was trying to climb the glass mountain,” the narrator declares in the first of the story’s one hundred numbered sections (most only one sentence long). Like the reader, the narrator is “new to the neighborhood,” persistent, comically methodical, and methodologically absurd; the plumber’s friends he uses to scale the glass mountain at the corner of Thirteenth Street and Eighth Avenue seem no less inappropriate than his by-the-book how-to approach drawn from medieval romance—or the reader’s efforts to climb (surmount, master) Barthelme’s seethrough metafiction by means of equally outdated reading strategies. Once atop the glass mountain the narrator finds exactly what he hoped to, “a beautiful enchanted symbol” to disenchant. Once kissed (like the frog of fairy tales), the symbol proves disenchanting in a quite different sense of the word, changed “into only a beautiful princess” whom the narrator (now himself disenchanted) hurls down in disappointment. Having staked his life on the eternal symbol of medieval romance, the narrator finds the temporary and the merely human (princess) disappointing. “The New Music” • Making a postmodern something, however small and selfconsuming, out of the existential nothing became Barthelme’s stock-in-trade, most noticeably in “Nothing: A Preliminary Account.” His art of the nearly negligible works itself out comically but almost always against a sympathetic understanding for the permanence for which the climber in “The Glass Mountain” and the characters
94
Short Story Writers
in so many of his other stories, “The New Music,” for example, yearn. A fusion of two stories published earlier the same year, one with the same title, the other entitled “Momma,” “The New Music” takes the dialogue form that Barthelme often used to new and dizzying heights of nearly musical abstraction, akin to what Philip Roth would accomplish more than a decade later in his novel, Deception (1990). The subject here is slight (even for Barthelme), as the story’s two unidentified, no-longeryoung speakers go through (or are put through) a number of routines analogous to vaudeville comedy and improvisational jazz. After a few opening bars, one speaker suggests that they go to Pool, “the city of new hope. One of those new towns. Where everyone would be happier.” They then segue into an exchange on, or consideration of, the new music done as a version of the familiar song “Momma don’ ’low.” Among the many things that Momma (now dead) did not allow was the new music. “The new music burns things together, like a welder,” or like the sculptor Peterson from “A Shower of Gold” or like Barthelme, who, along with his two speakers, understands that the new music always has been and always will be ever changing, ever ephemeral, ever new, and forever beyond Momma’s prohibitions and the reader’s explanations. Robert A. Morace Other major works children’s literature: The Slightly Irregular Fire Engine: Or, The Hithering Thithering Djinn, 1971. novels: Snow White, 1967; The Dead Father, 1975; Paradise, 1986; The King, 1990. miscellaneous: Guilty Pleasures, 1974; The Teachings of Don B.: Satires, Parodies, Fables, Illustrated Stories and Plays of Donald Barthelme, 1992 (Kim Herzinger, editor); Notknowing: The Essays and Interviews of Donald Barthelme, 1997 (Herzinger, editor). Bibliography Barthelme, Helen Moore. Donald Barthelme: The Genesis of a Cool Sound. College Station: Texas A&M University Press, 2001. The author, a senior lecturer of English at Texas A&M University, was married to Barthelme for a decade in the 1950’s and 1960’s. She traces his life from his childhood in Houston to his development as a writer. Couturier, Maurice, and Regis Durand. Donald Barthelme. London: Methuen, 1982. This brief study focuses on the performance aspect of Barthelme’s stories and considers them in relation to the multiplicity of varied responses that they elicit from readers. Readings are few in number but highly suggestive. Hudgens, Michael Thomas. Donald Barthelme, Postmodernist American Writer. Lewiston, N.Y.: Edwin Mellen Press, 2001. This volume in the series Studies in American Literature examines Barthelme’s novels The Dead Father and Snow White and his short story “Paraguay.” Includes bibliographical references and an index. Klinkowitz, Jerome. Donald Barthelme: An Exhibition. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 1991. Klinkowitz is easily the best informed and most judicious scholar and critic of contemporary American fiction in general and Barthelme in particular. Building on his Barthelme chapter in Literary Disruptions: The Making of a PostContemporary American Fiction (2d ed., 1980), he emphasizes the ways in which Barthelme reinvented narrative in the postmodern age and places Barthelme’s fiction in the larger aesthetic, cultural, and historical contexts. Perhaps the single most important study of Barthelme.
Barthelme, Donald
95
May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these twelve short stories by Barthelme: “The Balloon” (vol. 1), “Critique de la Vie Quotidienne” (vol. 2), “The Glass Mountain” (vol. 3), “The Indian Uprising” and “Lightning” (vol. 4), “Margins” (vol. 5), “Paraguay” and “See the Moon?” (vol. 6), “A Shower of Gold” and “Some of Us Had Been Threatening Our Friend Colby” (vol. 7), and “Views of My Father Weeping” and “Wrack” (vol. 8). Molesworth, Charles. Donald Barthelme’s Fiction: The Ironist Saved from Drowning. Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1982. Objecting to those who emphasize the experimental nature of Barthelme’s fiction, Molesworth views Barthelme as essentially a parodist and satirist whose ironic stance saves him from drowning in mere innovation. Patteson, Richard, ed. Critical Essays on Donald Barthelme. New York: G. K. Hall, 1992. Collection of critical essays on Barthelme from book reviews and academic journals. Provides an overview of critical reaction to Barthelme in the introduction. Essays deal with Barthelme’s use of language, his fragmentation of reality, his montage technique, and his place in the postmodernist tradition. Roe, Barbara L. Donald Barthelme: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Introduction to Barthelme’s short stories, with discussion of the major stories arranged in chronological order. Also includes several interviews with Barthelme, as well as previously published essays by other critics. Stengel, Wayne B. The Shape of Art in the Stories of Donald Barthelme. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1985. Discusses such themes as play, futility, stasis, affirmation, and education in four types of stories: identity stories, dialogue stories, social fabric stories, and art-object stories. Focuses on Barthelme’s emphasis on art in his self-reflexive stories. Waxman, Robert. “Apollo and Dionysus: Donald Barthelme’s Dance of Life.” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (Spring, 1996): 229-243. Examines how the interplay between the Apollonian search for order and the Dionysian longing for freedom from convention informs much of Barthelme’s work and is often embodied in the metaphor of music.
96
Ann Beattie Born: Washington, D.C.; September 8, 1947 Principal short fiction • Distortions, 1976; Secrets and Surprises, 1978; Jacklighting, 1981; The Burning House, 1982; Where You’ll Find Me, and Other Stories, 1986; The Best American Short Stories 1987, 1987; What Was Mine, and Other Stories, 1991; Park City: New and Selected Stories, 1998; Perfect Recall: New Stories, 2001; Follies and New Stories, 2005. Other literary forms • Although Ann Beattie’s reputation rests primarily on her short stories, particularly those that first appeared in The New Yorker, she has also written several novels. The first, Chilly Scenes of Winter (1976), appeared simultaneously with Distortions, a rare occurrence in the publishing world, especially for a first-time author. Her second novel, Falling in Place (1980), is her most ambitious and her best. In Love Always (1985), she uses an approach that is closer to that of her short stories than in either of the previous novels. The subject matter is narrower, and the characters are more distanced from the narrative voice. Picturing Will followed in 1989. Eight years later, she published My Life, Starring Dara Falcon (1997), which was scorned as her weakest novel to date. The Doctor’s House (2002) did not fare much better with the critics. In 1986 and 1987, Beattie worked on her first nonfiction project, the text to accompany a monograph containing twenty-six color plates of the paintings of Alex Katz. Achievements • The author of ten collections of short stories through 2005, Ann Beattie has been called the most imitated short-story writer in the United States, an amazing claim for a woman whose publishing career did not begin until the early 1970’s. Along with such writers as Raymond Carver, she is a premier practitioner of minimalism, the school of fiction-writing that John Barth has characterized as the “less is more” school. In 1977, she was named Briggs-Copeland Lecturer in English at Harvard, where she was apparently uncomfortable. She used a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation grant to leave Harvard and move back to Connecticut, where she had attended graduate school. In 1980, she received an award of excellence from the American Academy of Arts and Letters and a Distinguished Alumnae award from American University. In 1992, she was elected to the American Academy and Institute of Arts and Letters. Biography • Born on September 8, 1947, Ann Beattie grew up with television, rock music, and all the other accoutrements of the baby boomers. The child of a retired Health, Education, and Welfare Department administrator, Beattie took a bachelor’s degree in English at American University in 1969 and completed her master’s degree at the University of Connecticut in 1970. She began, but did not complete, work on her doctorate. In 1972 she married David Gates, a writer for Newsweek and a singer, whom she later divorced. Together they had one son. Before her appointment at Harvard, Beattie taught at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville. After living in the Connecticut suburbs and in New York City, she returned to Charlottesville and the university in 1985. She appeared as a waitress in the film version of Chilly Scenes of
Beattie, Ann
97
Winter and, after her divorce, was named one of the most eligible single women in America. In 1985, Beattie met painter Lincoln Perry, whom she later married. The couple lived for a time in Charlottesville. Later, Beattie and Perry settled in a turn-ofthe-century farmhouse in York, Maine, one of America’s oldest cities. Beattie has said that she does not go to book-publishing parties, does not know many writers, has an unlisted phone number, and shies away from writers’ colonies. Analysis • Ann Beattie has been called the spokesperson for a new lost generation, a sort of Ernest Hemingway for those who came of age during the 1960’s and 1970’s. Many of her themes and much about her style support the assertion that she, like Hemingway, voices a pervasive and universal feeling of despair and alienation, a lament for lost values and lost chances for constructive action. Yet to limit one’s understanding of Beattie’s work to this narrow interpretation is a mistake. Beattie shares much with writers such as Jane Austen, who ironically portrayed the manners and social customs of her era, and with psychological realists such as Henry James, who delved into the meanings behind the subtle nuances of character and conflict. Her primary themes are loneliness and friendship, family life, love and death, materialism, art, and, for want of a better term, the contemporary scene. Her short fiction tends to be spare and straightforward. Her vocabulary and her sentence structure are quite accessible, or minimalist, to use a more literary label. Even when the stories contain symbols, their use is most often direct and self-reflexive. Beattie’s combination of subject matter and style leads to a rather flat rendering of the world, and she is sometimes criticized for that flatness. Because her narrators usually maintain a significant distance from the stories and their characters, critics and readers sometimes assume that Beattie is advocating such remove and reserve as the most feasible posture in contemporary life. Even her most ironic characters and narrative voices, however, experience a profound longing for a different world. Despite the ennui that dominates the texture of their lives, Beattie’s characters hold on to the hope of renewal and redemption, often with great fierceness, even though the fierceness frequently suggests that these people are clutching at hope so hard that they are white-knuckling their way through life. If members of the generation about which she writes are indeed lost, they have not accepted their condition, even though they recognize it. They are still searching for the way out, for a place in which to find themselves or to be found. “Dwarf House” • “Dwarf House,” the first story in Distortions, establishes an interest in the grotesque, the bizarre, and the slightly askew that surfaces several times in this first of Beattie’s collections. The main characters of the story are James and MacDonald, brothers who struggle to find understanding and respect for each other and to deal with their possessive and intrusive mother. Because James, the older of the two, is a dwarf, Beattie immediately plays upon the collection’s title and places the story beyond the plane of realism. The irony of the story develops as the reader realizes that MacDonald’s supposedly normal life is as distorted as the life of his sibling. When MacDonald goes to visit James in the dwarf house where he lives, along with several other dwarfs and one giant, he finds himself repulsed by the foreign environment. Yet, when he gets home, he cannot face his own “normal” world without his martinis. He is as alienated and isolated at home and at work as he would be if he were a dwarf. Beattie uses the ludicrous, the exaggerated scenario of James’s life, complete with his wedding to a fellow
98
Short Story Writers
dwarf, conducted by a hippie minister and culminating in the releasing of a caged parrot, as a symbol of hope and the new freedom of married life, to bring into focus the less obvious distortions of reguTO VIEW IMAGE, lar American life. MacDonald is typical of many PLEASE SEE Beattie characters. He is relatively PRINT EDITION young—in his late twenties—and OF THIS BOOK. well educated. He works, but his work provides little challenge or stimulation. He has enough money to live as he wants, but he struggles to define what it is he does want. His wife is his equal—young, well educated, hip—but they have less than nothing to talk about. MacDonald wants to make his Sigrid Estrada brother’s life more normal—that is, get him out of the dwarf house, the one place where James has ever been happy, and back into their mother’s home, where James and MacDonald will both be miserable. MacDonald is motivated not by malice toward James but by an overdeveloped sense of guilt and responsibility toward his mother, a trait he shares with many of Beattie’s young male characters. By the story’s end, the reader cannot say who is better off: James, whose life is distorted but productive and satisfying to him, or MacDonald, who has everything a man could want but still lacks an understanding of what it is he should do with what he has. “The Lifeguard” • In “The Lifeguard,” the final story in Distortions, Beattie portrays the offbeat and grotesque elements that permeate the collection, in a sharply realistic setting where their humor and irony disappear. The impact of these elements is, then, all the more forceful for the reader’s sense of sudden dislocation. Without warning, the book becomes too real for comfort, and at the same time it continues to use shades of the unreal to make its point. “The Lifeguard” tells the story of the Warner family and their summer vacation. The mother, Toby, finds herself fantasizing about the young college student who is the lifeguard on the beach. Yet when her children Penelope and Andrew die in a boat deliberately set afire by their playmate Duncan Collins, the inappropriateness and incapacity of the lifeguard and of her infatuation are too vividly brought home to Toby. The monstrousness of Duncan Collins’s action is but another kind of distortion; there are no simple lives in a distorted world. “A Vintage Thunderbird” • If Distortions emphasizes the outward manifestations of the disordered contemporary world, Secrets and Surprises, the second collection, turns inward, as its title suggests. “A Vintage Thunderbird” features a woman who comes to New York to have an abortion against the wishes of her husband. The friends to whom she turns, Karen and Nick, have their own problems in love. By mirroring the sense of loss that follows the abortion with the sense of loss felt by Karen
Beattie, Ann
99
and Nick when she sells the vintage car of the title, Beattie addresses the connection between spiritual and emotional needs and material needs. Very few of the people in Beattie’s fiction suffer for want of material goods; almost all suffer from lack of spiritual and emotional fulfillment. The interesting aspect of this dichotomy is that the characters do not, as a rule, actively pursue material wellbeing. Their money is often inherited, as are their houses and many of their other possessions. The main character in “Shifting,” for example, inherits an old Volvo from an uncle to whom she was never very close. The money earned by these characters is almost always earned halfheartedly, without conspicuous ambition or enthusiasm. These are not yuppies who have substituted acquisition for all human emotion; they are people who, by accident of birth or circumstance, have not had to acquire material wealth; for whatever reason, wealth comes to them. What does not come is peace, satisfaction, and contentment. When a material object does provide emotional pleasure, as the Thunderbird does for Karen and Nick, Beattie’s characters tend to confuse the emotion with the symbol and to conclude, erroneously, that ridding themselves of the object will also rid them of the gnawing doubts that seem to accompany contentment and satisfaction. It is sometimes as frightening, Beattie seems to suggest, to be attached to things as to people. “The Cinderella Waltz” • In The Burning House, Beattie’s third collection, she turns to the darker, more richly textured veins of her standard subject matter to produce stories that are less humorous but more humane, less ironic but wiser than those in the earlier collections. Infidelity, divorce, love gone bad—all standard Beattie themes—are connected to parenthood and its attendant responsibilities, to homosexuality, to death, and to birth defects. The affairs and the abortions that were entered into, if not concluded, with a “me-generation” bravado suddenly collide with more traditional values and goals. Many of Beattie’s characters, both married and single, have lovers. In fact, having a lover or having had one at some time during a marriage is almost standard. In “The Cinderella Waltz,” Beattie adds a further complication to the de rigueur extramarital affair by making the husband’s lover a male. Yet, in much the same way that she makes the unusual work in a story such as “Dwarf House,” Beattie manages to make this story more about the pain and suffering of the people involved than about the nontraditional quality of the love relationship. The wife in “The Cinderella Waltz,” left to understand what has happened to her marriage and to help her young daughter to reach her own understanding, finds herself drawn into a quiet, resigned acceptance of her husband’s relationship with his lover. She laments the loss of innocence in the world, for her child and for them all, but she chooses to go forward with the two men as part of her life and the child’s. She rejects—really never even considers—the negative, destructive responses that many women would have had. “The Cinderella Waltz” ends with images of enormous fragility—glass elevators and glass slippers. Yet they are images that her characters embrace and cling to, recognizing that fragile hope is better than none. The cautious nature of such optimism is often mistaken for pessimism in Beattie’s work, but her intention is clearly as affirmative as it is tentative. “Winter: 1978” • Another story from The Burning House, “Winter: 1978,” offers a glimpse of most of Beattie’s concerns and techniques. An unusually long story for
100
Short Story Writers
Beattie, “Winter: 1978” features a selfish mother who is hosting a wake for her younger son, who has drowned in a midwinter boating accident. His death is mystifying, for there were life preservers floating easily within his reach, a fact that suggests the ultimate despair and surrender often present in Beattie’s characters. An older son blames the mother for placing too much guilt and responsibility on the dead son, but he himself has done nothing to assume some of that burden. The older son’s former wife, their child, his current girlfriend, and his best friend are all present at the wake. The best friend’s girlfriend is alone back in California, having her uterus cauterized. His former wife seems inordinately grief-stricken, until it is revealed that the dead man was her lover. During the course of the wake, which lasts several days, she becomes the lover of her former husband’s best friend. This extremely baroque and convoluted situation contains much that is ironically humorous, but it also reflects deep pain on the part of all the characters, not only the pain of having lost a loved one but also the pain of reexamining their own lives and measuring them against the idea of death. That sort of existential questioning, rarely overt but frequently suggested, contributes to the idea of a lost generation brought to life on the pages of Beattie’s fiction. Yet Beattie rarely leaves her characters in perpetual existential angst, as is the case in a Hemingway story such as “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place,” an embodiment of the existential despair and the longing for some minute, self-created order and refuge typical of the original literary lost generation. Instead, Beattie often opts for a neoRomantic, minimalist version of hope and redemption, of continued searching as opposed to acquiescence. “Winter: 1978” concludes with the absentee father, the surviving son, taking his own child upstairs for a bedtime story. The little boy, like the daughter in ”The Cinderella Waltz,” is far too wise to take comfort from the imaginary world of the story; he has been exposed to far too much of the confused adult world of his parents. On this occasion, however, he pretends to believe, and he encourages his father’s tale about the evolution of deer. According to the story, deer have such sad eyes because they were once dinosaurs and cannot escape the sadness that comes with having once been something else. This story serves as a metaphor for the melancholy cast of characters in this and Beattie’s other collections of short fiction. Almost all of her characters have a Keatsian longing to connect with a better, more sublime existence that seems to be part of their generation’s collective consciousness. Far too aware and too ironic to follow the feeling and thereby to transcend reality, they linger in their unsatisfactory lesser world and struggle to accommodate their longing to their reality. “Snow” • More than her other collections, Where You’ll Find Me displays Beattie’s awareness of her own reputation as a writer. In particular, in a story called “Snow,” she appears to write a definition of the kind of story her work has come to define. Fewer than three pages long, the story takes a single image, that of snow, and uses it not only as a symbol of the lost love the narrator is contemplating but also as a metaphor for storytelling as practiced by the author. The remembered lover has explained to the narrator at one point that “any life will seem dramatic if you omit mention of most of it.” The narrator then tells a story, actually one paragraph within this story, about her return to the place where the lovers had lived in order to be with a dying friend. She offers her story-within-a-story as an example of the way in which her lover said stories should be told.
Beattie, Ann
101
The narrator goes on to say that such efforts are futile, bare bones without a pattern to establish meaning. For her, the single image, snow in this case, does more to evoke the experience of her life with the man than does the dramatized story with the details omitted. In the story’s final paragraph, the narrator concludes that even the single image is too complex for complete comprehension. The mind itself, let alone the narratives it creates, is incapable of fully rendering human experience and emotion. The best a writer, a storyteller, can do is to present the essence of the experience in the concrete terms in which his or her consciousness has recorded it. What the reader almost inevitably receives, then, is minimal, to return to John Barth’s theory. It is equally important, however, that Barth argues that the minimal can be more than enough. The characters in this fourth collection are generally older and wiser than their predecessors. They have, as a rule, survived an enormous loss and are still hoping for a richer, more rewarding life, or at least one in which they feel less out of place and alone. “Janus” • Andrea, the real-estate agent who is the main character of “Janus,” is typical. Safely married to a husband who is interesting and financially secure, she is also successful in her career. The two of them take great pleasure in the things that they have accumulated. Yet Andrea takes most pleasure in a relatively inexpensive and quite ordinary-looking ceramic bowl, a gift from a former lover who asked her to change her life, to live with him. Although she has long since turned him down, Andrea finds herself growing increasingly obsessed with the bowl. She begins to believe that all of her career success comes from the bowl’s being precisely placed in the homes that she shows to her clients. A mystery to her, the bowl seems to be connected to the most real, the most private parts of herself. She loves the bowl as she loves nothing else. She fears for its safety. She is terrified at the thought that it might disappear. She has lost the chance that the lover represents, choosing instead stasis and comfort, remaining intransigent about honoring her previous commitments. Sometimes she goes into her living room late at night and sits alone contemplating the bowl. She thinks, “In its way, it was perfect; the world cut in half, deep and smoothly empty.” Such is the world that Beattie observes, but Beattie is, after all, an artist, not a realestate agent. All that Andrea can do is contemplate. Beattie can fill the bowl, to use a metaphor, with whatever she chooses. She can capture, again and again, the story behind the “one small flash of blue, a vanishing point on the horizon,” that Andrea can only watch disappear. Barth’s description of the impulse behind minimalism, the desire “to strip away the superfluous in order to reveal the necessary, the essential,” is a fair assessment of Beattie’s work. Yet it is equally important to recall what necessary and essential elements remain after the superfluous has been stripped away. They are love, friendship, family, children, music, and creativity. Beattie fills the bowl of her fiction with much the same fruits that other writers have used. “Windy Day at the Reservoir” • In contrast to her earlier, so-called minimalist stories, Beattie’s more recent short fictions seem to be moving more toward length and elaboration, making more use of novelistic techniques of character exploration and realistic detail. “Windy Day at the Reservoir,” the longest story in her collection What Was Mine, focuses on two people who, while house-sitting for another couple, make a number of discoveries both about the homeowners and about themselves—for exam-
102
Short Story Writers
ple, about the vacationing couple’s impending breakup because of the wife’s mastectomy and their own inability to have children. The point of view moves from the house-sitting husband, to the wife, to the mentally disabled son of the housekeeper, who walks into the reservoir and drowns. The final section focuses on the housekeeper, who provides a novelistic resolution to the two couples who have both broken up. Ending with a realistic resolution rather than a metaphoric embodiment of conflict, the story reflects Beattie’s moving away from short-story techniques to novelistic devices. “Going Home With Uccello” and “Park City” • A clear contrast between short-story and novelistic technique can be seen in the difference between two of the eight new stories in Beattie’s collection of selected stories, Park City—“Going Home with Uccello” and the title story “Park City.” In the former, a woman on a trip to Italy with her boyfriend has a realization about why he has taken her there when he flirts with a Frenchwoman about an Uccello painting. She understands that he has taken her to Italy not to persuade her to join him in London forever, but to persuade himself that he loves her so much that no other woman can come between them. The story ends in a typical Beattie ambiguity about whether the man in the story can commit himself to a relationship or whether he is continuing, as so many of Beattie’s male characters do, to look for some ineffable dream. In “Park City” the central character spends a week at a Utah ski resort during the off-season looking after her half-sister’s daughter, Nell, who is three, and her halfsister’s boyfriend’s daughter, Lyric, who is fourteen. The story is filled with dialogue among the three female characters in which it seems increasingly clear that the woman is more naïve than the precocious fourteen-year-old. In one particular encounter, the girl spins out a long invented tale to a stranger about having had breast implants. The story ends when the central character tries to get on a ski lift with the child Nell and the two almost fall off. They are saved by a man who, significantly, tells her, “the one thing you’ve got to remember next time is to request a slow start.” In the twenty-odd years that Beattie has been publishing short stories, mostly in The New Yorker, her milieu and her method have changed little, which has led some to complain that she has nothing new to say about the era she has evoked so sharply. However, Beattie has said, “My test was not did I get it right about the sixties, but is it literature. I am not a sociologist.” Jane Hill With updates by Melissa E. Barth and Charles E. May Other major works children’s literature: Goblin Tales, 1975; Spectacle, 1985. novels: Chilly Scenes of Winter, 1976; Falling in Place, 1980; Love Always, 1985; Picturing Will, 1989; Another You, 1995; My Life, Starring Dara Falcon, 1997; The Doctor’s House, 2002. nonfiction: Alex Katz, 1987. Bibliography Atwood, Margaret. “Stories from the American Front.” The New York Times Book Review, September 26, 1982, 1, 34. Discusses The Burning House as it represents the loss of the American dream for the children of the 1960’s. For Beattie, freedom
Beattie, Ann
103
equals the chance to take off, run away, split. Beattie’s stories chronicle domesticity gone awry, where there are dangers and threats lurking beneath the surface of even the most mundane event. Observes that most of the stories in this collection concern couples in the process of separating. Barth, John. “A Few Words About Minimalism.” The New York Times Book Review, December 28, 1986, 1- 2, 25. Explores Beattie’s spare style and considers her fiction as it represents a current stylistic trend in the American short story. Spends a considerable amount of space describing the origins of the contemporary minimalist movement in American short fiction. Sees this form as a nonverbal statement about theme: the spareness of life in America. Places Beattie’s work among that of other minimalists, including Raymond Carver, Bobbie Ann Mason, James Robison, Mary Robison, and Tobias Wolff. Discusses Edgar Allan Poe as an early proponent of minimalism. Says that Beattie’s fiction is clearly shaped by the events surrounding the Vietnam War. A helpful essay for gaining an understanding of Beattie as a minimalist. Beattie, Ann. “An Interview with Ann Beattie.” Interview by Steven R. Centola. Contemporary Literature 31 (Winter, 1990): 405-422. Contains a photograph of Beattie. This article is useful to the general reader, providing information about Beattie’s biography. Beattie discusses herself as a feminist writer and talks about how she goes about creating credible male protagonists. Asserts that most of her fiction centers on exploring human relationships. McKinstry, Susan Jaret. “The Speaking Silence of Ann Beattie’s Voice.” Studies in Short Fiction 24 (Spring, 1987): 111-117. Asserts that Beattie’s female speakers puzzle readers because they tell two stories at once: an open story of the objective, detailed present juxtaposed against a closed story of the subjective past, which the speaker tries hard not to tell. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these ten short stories by Beattie: “The Big-Breasted Pilgrim” and “The Burning House” (vol. 1); “The Cinderella Waltz” (vol. 2); “Imagined Scenes,” “In the White Night,” “Jacklighting,” and “Janus” (vol. 4); “Shifting” (vol. 6); “Snow” (vol. 7); and “Winter: 1978” (vol. 8). Montresor, Jaye Berman, ed. The Critical Response to Ann Beattie. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1993. Includes contemporary reaction to Beattie’s novels and collections of short stories, as well as scholarly and academic analyses of her work by various critics. Stein, Lorin. “Fiction in Review.” Yale Review 85, no. 4 (1997): 156-165. After an excellent summary of Beattie’s early fiction, the writer proceeds to analyze My Life, Starring Dara Falcon, which he thinks has been underrated by critics. Wyatt, David. “Ann Beattie.” The Southern Review 28, no. 1 (1992): 145-159. Presents evidence that in the mid-1980’s there was a marked alteration in Beattie’s fiction. Instead of withdrawing from life and its dangers, her characters chose to care about other people and to commit themselves to creativity. A perceptive and convincing analysis.
104
Saul Bellow Born: Lachine, Quebec, Canada; June 10, 1915 Died: Brookline, Massachusetts; April 5, 2005 Principal short fiction • Mosby’s Memoirs, and Other Stories, 1968; Him with His Foot in His Mouth, and Other Stories, 1984; Something to Remember Me By: Three Tales, 1991; Collected Stories, 2001. Other literary forms • Saul Bellow is known primarily for his novels, which include The Adventures of Augie March (1953), Herzog (1964), Mr. Sammler’s Planet (1970), and Ravelstein (2000). He also published plays, a book of nonfiction prose about a trip to Jerusalem, and a number of essays. Achievements • Few would deny Saul Bellow’s place in contemporary American literature. Any assessment of his contributions would have to account for his realistic yet inventive style, the rich Jewish heritage upon which he draws, the centrality of Chicago in his fictional world, the role of the intellectual, and a fundamental wit, rare in contemporary American fiction. In 1976, Bellow’s achievement was internationally recognized when he was awarded the Pulitzer Prize and the Nobel Prize in Literature. He also won the 1988 National Medal of Arts and four National Book Awards—for The Adventures of Augie March in 1954, for Herzog in 1965, for Mr. Sammler’s Planet (1970) in 1971, and for The Bellarosa Connection (1989) in 1990. In 1997, The Actual (1997) won the National Jewish Book Award, given by the Jewish Book Council. Biography • Saul Bellow was born in Canada. After spending his first nine years in the Montreal area, he moved with his family to Chicago and graduated from high school there. He spent his first two years of college at the University of Chicago and the last two at Northwestern University, graduating in 1937. That same year he began a brief interlude of graduate work in anthropology at the University of Wisconsin. A few years later he started his writing career. He also taught at the University of Chicago from 1962 to 1993, moving to Boston University thereafter. Married five times, Bellow had three sons by his first three wives. At the age of 84, he had a daughter by his fifth wife. After a long residence in Chicago, he relocated to Massachusetts in 1994. There he became a professor of literature at Boston University and became coeditor of a new literary journal, The Republic of Letters. His last novel, Ravelstein, published in 2000, may be seen as his literary farewell, as it voices his concern about the survival of the human spirit amid the luxurious entanglements of contemporary life. He died at his Brookline, Massachusetts, home in April, 2005, at the age of eighty-nine. Analysis • Saul Bellow’s stature in large measure owes something to the depths to which he plumbed the modern condition. He addressed the disorder of the modern age, with all its horror and darkness as well as its great hope. Though intensely identified with the United States, his heroes are preoccupied with dilemmas arising out of European intellectual and cultural history. Bellow’s fictional world is at once cerebral
Bellow, Saul
105
and sensual. His concern is with the interconnections between art, politics, business, personal sexual proclivities and passions, the intellectual, and the making of culture in modern times. He is heady, like German writer Thomas Mann, revealing the limitations and powers of the self. Few contemporary American writers deal with such weighty issues as masterfully as did Bellow. Bellow’s honors and reputation document but do not explain his importance, although it will be more clearly seen in the future when some of the main tendencies of American fiction of his era have been fully developed. He is important because he both preserved and enhanced qualities that are present in the great fictional works of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, yet he fully participated in the tumult and uncertainty of the modern era. Though he often opposed the © The Nobel Foundation political left and espoused “traditional” cultural positions, Bellow was not primarily a polemical writer. His main concern was not with maintaining social or cultural order but was more spiritual and philosophical in nature. In this, he differed from the group of “New York intellectuals” that centered in the 1940’s and 1950’s on the journal Partisan Review. Although Bellow was for a time friendly with members of this group he took pains to distance himself from it and to stress his essential independence of any creed or ideology, as his paramount concern was for the individual. This theme is especially prominent in his short fiction, whose smaller canvas gives heightened emphasis to Bellow’s stress on the struggle of the individual for self-definition and development against the background of the sundry obstacles the world has in store. Bellow’s characters have selves and interact with a society and a culture that Bellow created in detail after careful observation. In some of his works, especially Mr. Sammler’s Planet, Bellow’s attitude toward that society and that culture borders on scorn, but his attitude has been earned, not merely stated in response to limitations on his own sensibility. The interaction between self and society in his work occurs against the backdrop of moral ideas. This is not to say that Bellow was didactic; rather, his work is infused with his sophisticated understanding of moral, social, and intellectual issues. In addition to preserving a rich but increasingly neglected tradition, Bellow enriched that tradition. After the exuberant opening words of The Adventures of Augie March, he also added new possibilities to the prose style of American fiction. In short, his work offers some of the benefits that readers in previous centu-
106
Short Story Writers
ries sought in fiction—most notably, some ideas about how to be a person in the world—yet it also offers a technical brilliance that Bellow keeps in rein instead of letting it control his work. Mosby’s Memoirs, and Other Stories • The stories collected in Mosby’s Memoirs, and Other Stories explore characteristic Bellow themes and clearly demonstrate the writer’s moral and aesthetic vision. “Looking for Mr. Green” is set in Chicago during the Depression and recounts the efforts of a civil servant, George Grebe, to deliver relief checks to black residents of the south side. This is the stuff of social protest literature, and Bellow’s story does dramatize the suffering that was endemic at that time, but it is much more than didactic. Bellow avoids a single-minded attack on economic injustice and the resulting inartistic story by, among other things, using a number of contrasts and ironies. For example, two scenes set on the streets and in the tenements of Chicago are separated by a scene at Grebe’s office, and in that scene a philosophical discussion between Grebe and his boss, Raynor, is interrupted by a welfare mother’s tirade. The basic situation of the story is ironic, because it seems odd that anyone would have trouble delivering checks to persons who desperately need them. These persons, however, are difficult to ferret out, and their neighbors will not reveal their whereabouts because they fear that Grebe is a bill collector, process-server, or other source of trouble, and because he is white. This irony vividly illustrates the degree to which the Depression exaggerated the instinct of selfpreservation and widened the gulf between blacks and whites. Grebe’s name points out several of the contrasts in “Looking for Mr. Green.” Grebes are birds known for their elaborate courtship dances, but George Grebe is a bachelor. More important for the story, grebes live in pairs rather than in flocks and remain in their own territories, but George, because of his job, is forced into society and into territory where he is an alien, not only because he is white but also because he is the son of the last English butler in Chicago and was a professor of classics. This is not to say that he is a stranger to trouble: He “had had more than an average seasoning in hardship.” Despite his troubles, Grebe is shocked by suffering, distrust, and decrepit physical settings. Oddly enough, these conditions are for him not only a moral problem but also an epistemological one. Raynor, his supervisor, brings up this problem by asserting that “nothing looks to be real, and everything stands for something else, and that thing for another thing.” In contrast, Grebe later concludes that objects “stood for themselves by agreement, . . . and when the things collapsed the agreement became visible.” The physical setting and the social and economic structure in this story are rapidly deteriorating, if not collapsing. Grebe complicates his analysis by asking “but what about need?,” thereby suggesting that because of the Depression the agreement itself is collapsing and perhaps with it reality. Some of the persons he meets want to hasten that collapse. The welfare mother “expressed the war of flesh and blood, perhaps turned a little crazy and certainly ugly, on the place and condition,” and another person advocates an alternate agreement, a plan whereby blacks would contribute a dollar apiece every month to produce black millionaires. Grebe’s finding Mr. Green indicates that he can do something about this obscure world in which appearance and reality are mixed. Near the end of the story he asserts that it “was important that there was a real Mr. Green whom they could not keep him from reaching because he seemed to come as an emissary from hostile appearances.”
Bellow, Saul
107
“The Gonzaga Manuscripts” • “The Gonzaga Manuscripts” is a subtle story that traces changes in a young man, Clarence Feiler, and puts those changes in the context of important issues pertinent to the proper functions of literature and to its relation to everyday reality. Bellow carefully delineates the psychological state of Feiler, to whom literature makes an enormous difference, and shows the impingement upon him of Spanish society, which also was the environment of the writer about whom he cares passionately, Manuel Gonzaga. These themes are developed in the context of Feiler’s search in Madrid and Seville for the unpublished manuscripts of poems written by Gonzaga. Feiler learns finally that the poems are lost forever, buried with Gonzaga’s patron. When Feiler arrives in Spain he is a confirmed Gonzagan, and while searching for the manuscripts he immerses himself in Spanish society and even in Gonzaga’s former milieu. Bellow meticulously paints in the Spanish background by describing the cities, religious processions, political climate, and a representative group of Spaniards. As a result of his immersion Feiler begins virtually to relive Gonzaga’s poems. For example, early in the story Feiler quotes part of a poem: I used to welcome all And now I fear all. If it rained it was comforting And if it shone, comforting, But now my very weight is dreadful. The story ends thus: as “the train left the mountains, the heavens seemed to split. Rain began to fall, heavy and sudden, boiling on the wide plain. He knew what to expect from the redheaded Miss Walsh at dinner.” That is, the rain is not comforting, and he fears that Miss Walsh will continue to torment him. Feiler maintains his allegiance to Gonzaga, but there is considerable evidence in the story indicating that his allegiance is misplaced. For example, Gonzaga’s friends are unimpressive. His best friend, del Nido, is a babbling mediocrity who sees little need for more poetry, and Gonzaga’s patron has had the poems buried with her, thus denying them to the world. Another acquaintance misunderstands Feiler’s search, thinking that he is after mining stock. One of Gonzaga’s main beliefs is that one needs to take a dim view of human potential; he advocates being little more than a creature and avoiding the loss of everything by not trying to become everything. Even though Feiler himself has few aspirations besides finding the lost poems, he ends in despair. In fact, Gonzaga resembles the writers whom Bellow castigates in “Some Notes on Recent American Fiction” because of their minimal conception of human potential and their concomitant solicitousness for their own sensibility. Bellow’s essay is a defense of a view of literature that Feiler unflatteringly contrasts to Gonzaga’s. “Mosby’s Memoirs” • “Mosby’s Memoirs” was published in 1968, two years before Mr. Sammler’s Planet, and, like that novel, is a study in world weariness. Mosby is writing his memoirs in Oaxaca, Mexico, where the fecund land and the earthy existence of the people contrast to his own dryness. His mind ranges back through his life, particularly to recall two friends: Ruskin, a poet who has a theoretical bent of mind, and Lustgarden, who alternates between endlessly elaborated Marxism and piratical capitalism. At the end of the story Mosby is in a tomb that, along with his inability to get
108
Short Story Writers
enough air to breathe, suggests that he is moribund. Although Mr. Sammler’s Planet depicts a sympathetic character fending off as best he can the horrors of contemporary life, “Mosby’s Memoirs” shows the danger of rejecting one’s era. Mosby’s critique is conservative: He had worked for Hearst, had shaken Franco’s hand, had agreed with Burnham’s emphasis on managing, even to the point of admiring Nazi Germany’s skill at it. Partly because Lustgarden’s Marxism is not made to appear attractive either, Mosby’s politics are not as unattractive as his attitude toward other persons. He is intolerant and is characterized by “acid elegance, logical tightness, factual punctiliousness, and merciless laceration in debate.” Even more damaging to him is a scene at a concert in which he is described as “stone-hearted Mosby, making fun of flesh and blood, of those little humanities with their short inventories of bad and good.” His attitude is also obvious in his treatment of Lustgarden in his memoirs. Rather than using his friend’s disastrous attempts to make money as a political parable or as an occasion to demonstrate pity, Mosby plans to use them for comic relief, in the process eschewing his “factual punctiliousness” in order to make Lustgarden more laughable. Him with His Foot in His Mouth, and Other Stories • The stories brought together in Him with His Foot in His Mouth, and Other Stories can be divided into two types: The title story and What Kind of Day Did You Have? (both novella-length pieces) feature powerful, aging Jewish intellectuals trying to come to grips with the course their lives have taken and bridge the world of ideas with the sensate, real world around them. The other three stories in the volume—“Zetland: By a Character Witness,” “A Silver Dish,” and “Cousins”—are cut from the same fabric as “Looking for Mr. Green.” They vividly, almost nostalgically, evoke a past, between the wars and after, and portray the assimilation of Jews in the United States. What is impressive in all of these stories is the wide historical swath they cut; Bellow’s concern here, as elsewhere, is no less than the human condition in the twentieth century. Herschel Shawmut, the narrator of Him with His Foot in His Mouth, a man in his sixties, is a successful Jewish musicologist. His story, a sort of confession, is addressed to a “Miss Rose” whom he evidently mortally offended with an inadvertent verbal barb years ago. Shawmut confesses to other slips of the tongue as well. As he writes about all the incidents, revealing a certain pattern of personality, he attributes them simply to fate. His confession also reveals that he has been swindled by his own brother Philip, a materialist living a sumptuous bourgeois life in Texas. Philip persuades his naïve brother to hand over all of his hard-earned money (made from his musicological ventures) and form a partnership in a company rife with fraud and other illegal activities. After Philip’s untimely death, Shawmut, hounded by creditors, seeks exile. He is, in the end, living a lonely life in Canada. Through his confessions, Shawmut seems to find some kind of order and the satisfaction of having articulated the nature of his fate, for better or worse. Victor Wulpy, the older Jewish intellectual in What Kind of Day Did You Have? is a charismatic figure who sweeps a much younger Katrina Goliger, mother of two, off her feet. On the day in question, Wulpy calls Katrina to ask her to come to Buffalo and fly back to Chicago with him for a speaking engagement. Not daring to question this cultural giant, she takes off immediately, cancelling an appointment with a psychiatrist for an evaluation of her psychiatric condition in a fierce battle with her former husband for custody of her children. In the climactic scene of the story, the small Cessna plane they are in seems, in the thick of a winter storm, to be in a fatal
Bellow, Saul
109
dive toward Lake Michigan. In the face of possible death Katrina wants him to say he loves her, but he refuses. “If we don’t love each other,” she then wonders aloud, “What are we doing? How did we get here?” In the end, Wulpy makes his speaking engagement and Trina makes it home, to find her children gone. Soon they return, escorted by Krieggstein, a police officer and a suitor waiting for the passing of the Wulpy phase. “A Silver Dish” and “Cousins” • Bellow’s Jewish wit, evident in all these stories, sparkles in “A Silver Dish” and “Cousins,” both cleverly conceived. In “A Silver Dish,” a sixty-year-old Woody Selbst mourns his father’s death and recalls an incident in his youth. Woody’s mother and father had split up, leaving Woody’s upbringing in the hands of his mother and a Protestant evangelical minister. Woody’s father, “Pop,” returns one day to ask his son a favor. Would he introduce his father to a certain wealthy Protestant, Mrs. Skoglund, who had made money in the dairy business? Woody reluctantly agrees and takes his father to the woman’s home. While she and her suspicious maid leave the room to pray and decide whether or not to comply with Pop’s request for money, Pop steals a silver dish from a locked cabinet. Woody and his father get into a scuffle, and his father promises to put the dish back if Mrs. Skoglund coughs up the money. She does, but Pop, unbeknownst to his son, keeps the dish. When the dish is missed, Woody gets the blame and falls from grace in the eyes of the evangelical crowd—which is exactly the effect his father desired. In “Cousins,” the narrator, Ijah Brodsky, an international banker, tells the story of his contact with three cousins. The first, Tanky Metzger, is connected to mobs and wants Ijah to use his influence with a certain judge and gain a lighter sentence. The second cousin is Mordecai, or “Cousin Motty,” whom Ijah goes to visit in the hospital after he has been hurt in an automobile crash. Cousin Motty has letters to deliver to Ijah from another cousin, Scholem Stavis. The intellectual in the family, Stavis has ended up, however, driving a cab. All through the narrative are reminiscences, a calling up of the past, a restitching of old relationships. Ijah’s existence seems somehow to be tied to, and defined by, his connection to these cousins. The Actual • The Actual, a short, self-contained novella, has many of the traits and characteristics associated with Bellow’s earlier work. In fact, for these reasons it is an excellent introduction to Bellow’s fictional world. Yet, strikingly for a work published in its author’s eighty-second year, it also breaks new ground for Bellow. The hero of The Actual is a man named Harry Trellman, who is at the time of the action semiretired and living in Chicago. Trellman has always been perceived by those he encounters as a bit different from everybody else, standing out from the rest of the crowd. Trellman worked as a businessman in Asia and later served as an adviser to Siggy Adletsky, a tycoon and racketeer who controls a huge financial empire and who is now ninety-two years old. Adletsky finds Trellman valuable because of his wide-ranging knowledge. This is a situation often found in Bellow’s work: the alliance between the shady millionaire and the intellectual. As a teenager, Trellman had been in love with Amy Wustrin, who had eventually chosen as her second husband Trellman’s best friend in high school, Jay Wustrin. Throughout the years, Harry Trellman had kept firm to the inner image of Amy in his mind even as he went through his varied career and activities. After Jay Wustrin dies prematurely, he is buried in the cemetery plot originally reserved for Amy’s father, who had sold it to him years earlier. Now Amy wants to remove Jay’s body to the
110
Short Story Writers
burial plot of his own family so that her father, who is still alive at an advanced age, can eventually be buried there. In a limousine provided by Adletsky, Amy and Trellman disinter and rebury the body. Moved by this scene of death and renewal, Trellman confesses to Amy that he has always loved her, that he has what he terms an “actual affinity” for her (hence the title of the story). He then asks her to marry him. This declaration of love is striking as Trellman, for most of his life, has remained uncommitted and rather inscrutable, not exposing his inner secrets to others. Harry’s privacy is contrasted with the willful self-exposure of men such as Jay Wustrin, who love making a spectacle of themselves. This dichotomy between the public and private man is mirrored by the tensions in Trellman’s relationship with Adletsky, who is concerned only with money and profit-making, yet needs the intellectual-minded, knowledgeable Trellman in order to succeed; equally, Trellman becomes dependent on the financial largesse of Adletsky. Trellman stands slightly outside the world’s network of relationships yet cannot do entirely without them. In most of his fictions, Bellow’s male protagonists tend to have troubled relationships with women and are often suffering in the aftermath of divorce. The serenity of Trellman’s love for Amy stands in vivid contrast especially to earlier short fictions of Bellow’s such as What Kind of Day Did You Have? and sounds a note of romantic celebration that is basically unprecedented in Bellow’s work. John Stark With updates by Allen Hibbard, Nicholas Birns, and the Editors Other major works plays: The Wrecker, pb. 1954; The Last Analysis, pr. 1964; Under the Weather, pr. 1966 (also known as The Bellow Plays; includes Out from Under, A Wen, and Orange Soufflé). anthology: Great Jewish Short Stories, 1963 novels: Dangling Man, 1944; The Victim, 1947; The Adventures of Augie March, 1953; Seize the Day, 1956; Henderson the Rain King, 1959; Herzog, 1964; Mr. Sammler’s Planet, 1970; Humboldt’s Gift, 1975; The Dean’s December, 1982; More Die of Heartbreak, 1987; A Theft, 1989; The Bellarosa Connection, 1989; The Actual, 1997 (novella); Ravelstein, 2000; Novels, 1944-1953, 2003 (includes Dangling Man, The Victim, and The Adventures of Augie March). nonfiction: To Jerusalem and Back: A Personal Account, 1976; Conversations with Saul Bellow, 1994 (Gloria L. Cronin and Ben Siegel, editors); It All Adds Up: From the Dim Past to the Uncertain Future, 1994. Bibliography American Studies International 35 (February, 1997). A special issue on Bellow, in which a number of distinguished contributors discuss the importance of Bellow’s work as a symbol of the civilization of the United States. The issue contains tributes, critiques, and analyses of Bellow’s thought and art. Atlas, James. Bellow. New York: Random House, 2000. Full and accessible biography, written with the cooperation of its subject. Bibliography. Bellow, Saul. “Moving Quickly: An Interview with Saul Bellow.” Salmagundi (Spring/ Summer, 1995): 32-53. In this special section, Bellow discusses the relationship between authors and characters, John Updike, intellectuals, gender differences, Sigmund Freud, and kitsch versus avant-garde art.
Bellow, Saul
111
Bloom, Harold, ed. Saul Bellow. New York: Chelsea House, 1986. This volume, with an introduction by Bloom, is an omnibus of reviews and essays on Bellow. Collected here are comments on Bellow by writers such as Robert Penn Warren, Malcolm Bradbury, Tony Tanner, Richard Chase, and Cynthia Ozick. Gives the reader a good sense of early critical responses to Bellow. Boyers, Robert. “Captains of Intellect.” Salmagundi (Spring/Summer, 1995): 100108. Part of a special section on Bellow. A discussion of characters in stories from the collection Him with His Foot in His Mouth, and Other Stories as captains of intellect who pronounce authoritatively on issues of the modern. Discusses Bellow as an intellectual leader with a multifaceted perspective. Cronin, Gloria L., and L. H. Goldman, eds. Saul Bellow in the 1980’s: A Collection of Critical Essays. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press, 1989. This anthology brings together a sampling of a wave of criticism that focuses variously on Bellow’s women, his debts to Judaism, connections to theories of history, and modernism. Freedman, William. “Hanging for Pleasure and Profit: Truth as Necessary Illusion in Bellow’s Fiction.” Papers on Language and Literature 35 (Winter, 1999): 3-27. Argues that Bellow’s realism is a search for truth, not the discovery of it. Discusses how Bellow deals with the question of whether a man is isolated or a member of a human community. Contends that for Bellow the value of literature is the ceaseless search for truth in a world that promises truth but seldom provides it. The Georgia Review 49 (Spring, 1995). A special issue on Bellow in which a number of contributors discuss his life and art, his contribution to American thought and culture, and the wide range of his works. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these six short stories by Bellow: “A Father-to-Be” and “The Gonzaga Manuscripts” (vol. 3), “Leaving the Yellow House” (vol. 4), “Looking for Mr. Green” and “Mosby’s Memoirs” (vol. 5), and “A Silver Dish” (vol. 7). Pifer, Ellen. Saul Bellow Against the Grain. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1990. In a study that deals comprehensively with the writings, Pifer’s central observation is that Bellow’s heroes are divided against themselves and conduct an inner strife that dooms and paralyzes them. Their struggle, like Bellow’s, is a search for language to articulate the modern condition.
112
Ambrose Bierce Born: Horse Cave Creek, Ohio; June 24, 1842 Died: Mexico(?); January, 1914(?) Principal short fiction • Cobwebs: Being the Fables of Zambri the Parse, 1884; Tales of Soldiers and Civilians, 1891 (also known as In the Midst of Life, 1898); Can Such Things Be?, 1893; Fantastic Fables, 1899; The Cynic’s Word Book, 1906; My Favourite Murder, 1916; Ghost and Horror Stories of Ambrose Bierce, 1964; The Collected Fables of Ambrose Bierce, 2000 (S. T. Joshi, editor). Other literary forms • As a lifelong journalist and commentator, Ambrose Bierce wrote prodigiously. He was fond of vitriolic epigrams and sketches, together with miscellaneous works of literary criticism, epigrams, and both prose and verse aphorisms. His most famous work is almost certainly The Devil’s Dictionary (1906), a collection of typically ironic and cynical definitions, such as that for a bore: “A person who talks when you wish him to listen.” Many of Bierce’s nonfiction writings have been published posthumously. These include Shadows of Blue and Gray: The Civil War Writings of Ambrose Bierce (2002) and The Fall of the Republic, and Other Political Satires (2000). Bierce also published several volumes of verse during his lifetime, and a collected edition of his poetry was published in 1995. Achievements • For many years, Ambrose Bierce was labeled a misanthrope or pessimist, and his dark short stories of murder and violence were understood as the work of a man who, obsessed with the idea of death, showed himself incapable of compassion. A less moralistic and biographical reevaluation of Bierce’s work, however, reveals his intellectual fascination with the effect of the supernatural on the human imagination. Many of his morally outrageous stories are tall tales, which certainly cannot be taken at face value. Their black humor, combined with the coolly understated voices of their criminal or psychopathic narrators, reflects a society gone to seed and pokes fun at the murderous dangers of American life in the West during the Gilded Age. Biography • Ambrose Gwinett Bierce was brought up on the farm in Horse Cave Creek, Ohio, where he was born in 1842. Although information about his early life is sparse, the evidence of his stories and the fact that he quarreled with and repudiated his large family with the exception of one brother indicate an unhappy childhood and an abnormal hatred of parental figures. His only formal education consisted of one year at a military academy. He fought with the Indiana infantry in the American Civil War (1861-1865), was wounded at the battle of Kennesaw Mountain, and ended the conflict as a brevet major. After the war, he settled in California, where, following a brief stint as a watchman at the San Francisco mint, he drifted into literary work. He wrote for the San Francisco Argonaut and News Letter and published his first story, “The Haunted Valley” (1871), in the Overland Monthly. He married and, on money received as a gift from his father-in-law, traveled abroad to England in 1872, returning to California in 1876 because of bad health. Upon his return he again became associated with the Argonaut. From 1879 to 1881 he took part in the Black Hills gold rush, return-
Bierce, Ambrose
113
ing in 1881 to San Francisco, having found no success as a miner. There he began, in association with the San Francisco Wap, his famous column “The Prattler,” transferred to William Randolph Hearst’s San Francisco Examiner upon the Wap’s failure, and continued at the Examiner until 1896, when Hearst sent him to Washington as a correspondent for the New York American. Much of Bierce’s subsequently collected work appeared first in “The Prattler.” Divorced in 1904, Bierce resigned from the Hearst organization in 1909 and, in a final quixotic gesture, disappeared into Mexico in the thick of the Mexican Revolution. He was never heard from again. Analysis • Perhaps the most rewarding way to approach Ambrose Bierce’s writing is to note that it was in many respects the product of two intertwined biographical factors, inseparable for purposes of analysis. The first of these reflects Bierce’s thorny and irascible personality which made him, on the one hand, quarrel with practically everyone he ever knew, and on the other, follow romantic and often impossible causes, the last of which led to his death. The second reflects his lifelong employment as a journalist, more specifically as a writer of short columns, generally aphoristic in nature, for various newspapers. The interaction of these two often contradictory strands explains, as well as any single factor can, both the strengths and weaknesses of Bierce’s writing. Philosophically, Bierce’s work is almost completely uncompromising in its iconoclasm; his view of existence is despairing, revealing only the bitterness of life within a totally fallen world promising neither present happiness nor future redemption. This “bitterness,” which almost every critic has remarked in Bierce’s work, is not completely fortunate. It can, and in Bierce’s case often does, lead to that kind of adolescent cynicism which delights in discovering clouds in every silver lining. Too many of the insights which once seemed sterling are now fairly obviously only tinfoil. The definition of “economy” in The Devil’s Dictionary (1906) is a case in point: “Purchasing the barrel of whiskey that you do not need for the price of the cow that you cannot afford”—an arresting idea, certainly, succinctly expressed, but by no means a profound one. In fact, it is precisely the kind of item one would expect to find on the editorial page of the morning newspaper and perhaps remember long enough to repeat at the office. Indeed, this particular aphorism did first appear in a newspaper, with most of the other contents of The Devil’s Dictionary and, predictably, did not really survive the transformation into book form. The Devil’s Dictionary, like much of Bierce’s work, is now much more generally read about than actually read. “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” • At its best, however, Bierce’s cynicism is transformed into often-passionate statements of the tragedy of existence in a world in which present joys are unreal and future hopes vain, as a glance at one of Bierce’s best-known stories, “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge,” will show. This story, for all its apparent simplicity, has attracted uniform critical admiration and has been complimented not only by being extensively anthologized but also by having been made into an award-winning film. Purporting to be an incident from the American Civil War, the story opens with the execution by hanging of a Confederate civilian. His name, Peyton Farquhar, is revealed later, as is his apparent crime: He was apprehended by Union soldiers in an attempt to destroy the railroad bridge at Owl Creek, from which he is about to be hanged. The hangman’s rope breaks, however, sending Farquhar into the current below. He frees his bound hands and, by swimming, manages to escape both the fire of the Union riflemen who have been assem-
114
Short Story Writers
bled to witness the execution and, more miraculously, the fire of their cannon. Reaching shore, Farquhar sets out for home along an unfamiliar road, and after a night-long journey in a semidelirious condition arrives at his plantation some thirty miles away. His wife greets him at the entrance, but as he reaches to clasp her in his arms he suffers what is apparently a stroke and loses his senses. He has not, it develops, suffered a stroke; the last sentence of the story tells us what has really happened. The rope had not broken at all: “Peyton Farquhar was dead; his body, with a broken neck, swung gently from side to side beneath the timbers of the Owl Creek bridge.” “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” sounds, in summary, contrived. What is it, after all, more than a tired descant on the familiar theme of the dying man whose life passes before his eyes, coupled with the familiar trick of the unexpected happy ending put in negative terms? The answer, from the perspective of one who has read the story rather than its summary, is that it is much more. For one thing, the careful reader is not left totally unprepared for the final revelation; he has been alerted to the fact that something may be amiss by Bierce’s remark that Farquhar had, before his apparent death, fixed “his last thoughts upon his wife and children.” Moreover, Farquhar’s journey home is described in terms which become constantly less real. The unreality of the details of his homeward journey not only expresses Farquhar’s growing estrangement from the world of reality, his “doom,” perhaps, or—for those more at home in modern Freudianism—his “death wish,” but also subtly indicates that what seems to be happening in the story may not in fact actually be happening, at least in the real world. In any event, Bierce’s point is clear and reinforced within the story by a consistent movement in grammatical usage from the actual, “he was still sinking” (speaking of Farquhar’s fall from the bridge into the water), toward the hypothetical, such as “doubtless,” the word Bierce uses to describe Farquhar’s apparent return to his plantation. What, then, makes this story more than the predictable reverse of the typical tricky story with the illogical happy ending? The difference is to be found simply in Bierce’s uncompromisingly negative view of the world. The reader begins in a world where everyone is symbolically sentenced to death, from which his or her reprieve is only temporary, and the reader wanders with him through a field of illusions which become more attractive as they escape the confines of reality. The reader ends, reaching for a beauty and love which was sought but which was unobtainable, dead under Owl Creek Bridge. The symbolism of Owl Creek is not gratuitous: Wise old owls discover that every road leads only to death. “Chickamauga” • The master image of “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” of a delusory journey leading to an ultimately horrible and horrifying revelation is central to many of Bierce’s stories, one more of which is worth brief mention here. “Chickamauga,” not as well known as the former story, is equally chilling and equally cunning in its artistry. It tells of a nameless young boy, “aged about six years,” who with toy sword in hand wanders away from his home one day into the adjacent woods, where he successfully plays soldier until, unexpectedly frightened by a rabbit, he runs away and becomes lost. He falls asleep, and when he awakens it is nearly dusk. Still lost, his directionless night journey through the forest brings him upon a column of retreating soldiers, all horribly wounded and unable to walk, who are trying to withdraw from a battle (presumably the 1863 Battle of Chickamauga in the American Civil War, although this is never specifically stated) which has been fought in the neighborhood and of which the child, whom we later discover to be both deaf and
Bierce, Ambrose
115
mute, has been unaware. In a ghastly parody of military splendor, the child takes command of these horribly wounded soldiers and leads them on, waving his wooden sword. As the ghastly cavalcade limps forward, the wood mysteriously begins to brighten. The brightness is not the sun, however, but the light from a burning house, and when the little boy sees the blazing dwelling he deserts his troops and, fascinated by the flames, approaches the conflagration. Suddenly he recognizes the house as his own, and at its doorway he finds the corpse of his mother. Again, the magic of this story vanishes in paraphrase, in which the masterfully controlled feeling of horror almost inevitably sounds contrived, the revelation slick rather than profound. The compelling quality of “Chickamauga” is largely a function of Bierce’s style, which at once conceals and reveals what is going on. The story of a small boy who wanders off into the woods with a toy sword and who is frightened by a rabbit scarcely seems to be the kind of fictional world in which such uncompromising horrors should logically take place. Yet on a symbolic level, the story has a curiously compelling logic. The first reading of the tale leaves one with a slightly false impression of its meaning. The story does not tell us, as it seems to, and as so many fairy tales do, that it is better not to leave home and venture into the wild wood; the story’s meaning is darker than this. In the world of “Chickamauga,” safety is to be found neither at home nor abroad. By wandering away into the woods the boy perhaps escaped the fate of those who remained at home, and yet his symbolic journey has only brought him back to a world where death is everywhere supreme. To emphasize this point more strongly, in 1898 Bierce retitled the book of short stories in which both the above tales appeared In the Midst of Life. Readers are expected to complete the quotation themselves: “ . . . we are in death.” Although most of Bierce’s stories which are widely remembered today deal with military themes, many of his other stories are quite frankly supernatural. By and large these supernatural stories seem less likely to survive than his military ones, if only because Bierce has less sense for the implicit thematic structure of supernatural tales than he does for macabre stories about the military. His ghost stories are avowedly “shockers,” without the psychological depth to be found in the works of true masters of the supernatural. They do not have the profundity, for example, of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) or Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1897). Nevertheless, the best of them do have a certain compelling quality simply because of the bizarre nature of the revelation of what lies at the heart of the supernatural event which Bierce relates. “The Damned Thing” • “The Damned Thing” offers a convenient case in point. This is, quite simply, the story of a man who is hunted down and finally killed by some kind of animal, apparently a wildcat. The reader never knows precisely what kind of animal it is, however, since it has one peculiar quality: It is invisible. The story is told with the last scene first. This last scene, entitled “One Does Not Always Eat What Is on the Table,” takes place at the coroner’s inquest over the body of one Hugh Morgan, who has met a violent death. His friend, William Harker, explains how Morgan had acted inexplicably on a hunting trip, apparently falling into a fit. The coroner’s jury agrees, at least to an extent. Their ungrammatical verdict is “We, the jury, do find that the remains come to their death at the hands of a mountain lion, but some of us thinks, all the same, they had fits.” In the closing scene of the story, Morgan’s diary is introduced as explanation, and in it we read of his growing awareness that he is being stalked by some kind of invisible animal. A pseudoscientific rationale is given for this invisibility. The animal is “actinic,” at least according to Morgan. “Actinic” colors, we
116
Short Story Writers
are informed, are colors that exist at either end of the spectrum and that cannot be perceived by the human eye. We have, in other words, either an infrared or an ultraviolet mountain lion. Neither choice is particularly satisfactory, and the difficulty with our willing suspension of disbelief in the tale is indicated by precisely this: The science is bad, and yet it pretends not to be. The notion of an ultraviolet mountain lion is basically more silly than chilling, and since the story has no fiber to it other than the revelation of what the mountain lion actually consists of, we cannot take it seriously. In fact, the reader feels vaguely victimized and resentful, as though having been set up as the butt of some kind of pointless joke. Yet even in this story, relatively unsuccessful as it is, we see at work the underlying preoccupations which make some of Bierce’s other stories unforgettable. The attempt in a Bierce story is always to shock someone by removing him from a commonplace world and placing him—like the little boy in “Chickamauga”—in another world whose laws are recognizable, though strange. The logic of a Bierce story is often very like the logic of a nightmare, in which the reader is placed in the position of the dreamer. When trapped in a nightmare, the reader feels the presence of a certain inexorable logic, even though one may not, at the moment, be able to define exactly how that logic operates or of what precisely it consists. It is the feeling for the presence of this hostile and malevolent order which gives the best of Bierce’s stories their perennial fascination. James K. Folsom With updates by R. C. Lutz Other major works miscellaneous: The Collected Works of Ambrose Bierce, 1909-1912; Shadows of Blue and Gray: The Civil War Writings of Ambrose Bierce, 2002 (Brian M. Thomsen, editor). nonfiction: Nuggets and Dust Panned in California, 1873; The Fiend’s Delight, 1873; Cobwebs from an Empty Skull, 1874; The Dance of Death, 1877; The Dance of Life: An Answer to the Dance of Death, 1877 (with Mrs. J. Milton Bowers); The Devil’s Dictionary, 1906; The Shadow on the Dial, and Other Essays, 1909; Write It Right: A Little Blacklist of Literary Faults, 1909; The Letters of Ambrose Bierce, 1922; Twenty-one Letters of Ambrose Bierce, 1922; Selections from Prattle, 1936; Ambrose Bierce on Richard Realf by Wm. McDevitt, 1948; A Sole Survivor: Bits of Autobiography, 1998 (S. T. Joshi and David E. Schultz, editors); The Fall of the Republic, and Other Political Satires, 2000 (Joshi and Schultz, editors); A Much Misunderstood Man: Selected Letters of Ambrose Bierce, 2003 (Joshi and Schultz, editors). poetry: Vision of Doom, 1890; Black Beetles in Amber, 1892; How Blind Is He?, 1896; Shapes of Clay, 1903; Poems of Ambrose Bierce, 1995. translation: The Monk and the Hangman’s Daughter, 1892 (with Gustav Adolph Danziger; of Richard Voss’s novel). Bibliography Butterfield, Herbie. “‘Our Bedfellow Death’: The Short Stories of Ambrose Bierce.” In The Nineteenth Century American Short Story, edited by A. Robert Lee. Totowa, N.J.: Barnes & Noble Books, 1985. Brief, general introduction to the themes and techniques of some of Bierce’s most representative short stories. Conlogue, William. “A Haunting Memory: Ambrose Bierce and the Ravine of the Dead.” Studies in Short Fiction 28 (Winter, 1991): 21-29. Discusses Bierce’s symbolic use of the topographical feature of the ravine as a major symbol of death in five
Bierce, Ambrose
117
stories, including “Killed at Resaca,” “Coulter’s Notch,” and “The Coup de Grâce.” Shows how the ravine symbolizes the grave, the underworld, and lost love for Bierce, all derived from his Civil War memories and the death of his first love. Davidson, Cathy N. The Experimental Fictions of Ambrose Bierce: Structuring the Ineffable. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1984. Discusses how Bierce intentionally blurs distinctions between such categories as knowledge, emotion, language, and behavior. Examines how Bierce blurs distinctions between external reality and imaginative reality in many of his most important short stories. ____________, ed. Critical Essays on Ambrose Bierce. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1982. Comprehensive compilation of thirty essays and reviews of Bierce’s work, this collection is an essential tool for any serious study of Bierce. Davidson’s introduction locates the essays in relation to the ongoing process of reevaluating Bierce’s work, and her thoroughly researched bibliography contains more than eighty further critical references. Fatout, Paul. Ambrose Bierce: The Devil’s Lexicographer. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1951. Fatout’s impressive collation of painstakingly researched biographical data represents an important landmark in the scholarly study of Bierce’s life. Supplemented by illustrations and a bibliography. Gale, Robert L. An Ambrose Bierce Companion. New York: Greenwood Press, 2001. Comprehensive guide to the life and writings of the American satirist. Grenander, Mary Elizabeth. Ambrose Bierce. New York: Twayne, 1971. This volume is well researched, balanced, and readable, and it is perhaps the single most accessible study of Bierce’s work and life. Contains a valuable, annotated bibliography and a list of primary sources. Hoppenstand, Gary. “Ambrose Bierce and the Transformation of the Gothic Tale in the Nineteenth-Century American Periodical.” In Periodical Literature in Nineteenth-Century America, edited by Kenneth M. Price and Susan Belasco Smith. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1995. Examines Bierce’s relationship to the San Francisco periodicals, focusing on the influence he had in bringing the gothic tale into the twentieth century; discusses themes and conventions in “The Damned Thing” and “Moxon’s Master.” May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Bierce: “Chickamauga” (vol. 1), “The Coup de Grâce” (vol. 2), “Killed at Resaca” (vol. 4), and “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” and “One of the Missing” (vol. 5). Morris, Roy, Jr. Ambrose Bierce: Alone in Bad Company. New York: Crown, 1996. Compelling, if somewhat slight, biography of one of American’s most eccentric yet quotable authors.
118
Giovanni Boccaccio Born: Florence or Certaldo (now in Italy); June or July, 1313 Died: Certaldo (now in Italy); December 21, 1375 Principal short fiction • Decameron: O, Prencipe Galetto, 1349-1351 (The Decameron, 1620). Other literary forms • Although Giovanni Boccaccio’s greatest work is the masterfully framed collection of one hundred Italian short stories known as The Decameron, he also left a large and significant corpus of poetry. His earliest poetry, written in Naples, is in Italian and includes the Rime (c. 1330-1340; poems), which comprises more than one hundred lyrics, mostly sonnets and not all of sure attribution. These short poems are largely dedicated to the poet’s beloved Fiammetta, who is identified in some of Boccaccio’s pseudoautobiographical writings as Maria d’Aquino; supposedly, she was the illegitimate daughter of King Robert of Naples, but more probably she was the invention of the poet. Similarly, the longer poem La caccia di Diana (c. 1334; Diana’s hunt), Il filostrato (c. 1335; The Filostrato, 1873), Il filocolo (c. 1336; Labor of Love, 1566), and Teseida (1340-1341; The Book of Theseus, 1974) are all poems ostensibly inspired by Boccaccio’s ardor for Fiammetta, whose name means “little flame.” Other poems that were composed in the 1340’s also treat the formidable power of love and include the Commedia delle ninfe, entitled Il ninfale d’Ameto by fifteenth century copyists (1341-1342; the comedy of the nymphs of Florence), L’amorosa visione (1342-1343; English translation, 1986), Elegia di Madonna Fiammetta (1343-1344; Amorous Fiammetta, 1587), and Il ninfale fiesolano (1344-1346; The Nymph of Fiesole, 1597). Achievements • Giovanni Boccaccio created many literary firsts in Italian letters. He is often credited, for example, with the first Italian hunting poem (La caccia di Diana), the first Italian verse romance by a nonminstrel (The Filostrato), the first Italian prose romance (Labor of Love), and the first Italian idyll (The Nymph of Fiesole). Many scholars also regard Boccaccio as the greatest narrator Europe has produced. Such high esteem for the Tuscan author assuredly arises from his masterpiece, The Decameron, which has provided a model or source material for many notable European and English authors, from Marguerite de Navarre and Lope de Vega Carpio to Gotthold Ephraim Lessing and Alfred, Lord Tennyson. Even if Boccaccio had never composed his magnum opus, however, he would still enjoy significant acclaim in European literary history for his presumedly minor writings. For example, many consider his Amorous Fiammetta to be the first modern (that is, postclassical) psychological novel. Certainly his Il ninfale d’Ameto anticipates Renaissance bucolic literature. Contemporary medieval authors also looked to Boccaccio for inspiration. In The Filostrato, Geoffrey Chaucer found ample material for his Troilus and Criseyde (1382), and in The Book of Theseus Chaucer discovered the source for “The Knight’s Tale.” Boccaccio’s encyclopedic works in Latin resulted in his being regarded as one of the most prominent Trecento humanists. Indeed, it was as a Latin humanist, rather than as a raconteur of vernacular tales, that Boccaccio was primarily remembered during the first century following his demise.
Boccaccio, Giovanni
119
Biography • The exact place and date of the birth of Giovanni Boccaccio are not known. Until the first half of the twentieth century, it was believed that he was born in Paris of a noble Frenchwoman; scholars now regard that story as another one of the author’s fictional tales. Most likely, he was born in Florence or Certaldo, Italy, in June or July, 1313, the natural son of Boccaccio di Chellino and an unidentified Tuscan woman. His father, an agent for a powerful Florentine banking family (the Bardi), recognized Giovanni early as his son; the boy, as a result, passed both his infancy and his childhood in his father’s house. Boccaccio’s teacher in his youth was Giovanni Mazzuoli da Strada, undoubtedly an admirer Dante Alighieri, whose La divina commedia (c. 1320; The Divine Comedy, 1802) greatly influenced Boccaccio’s own writings. In his early teens, sometime between 1325 and 1328, Boccaccio was sent to Naples to learn the merchant trade and banking business as an apprentice to the Neapolitan branch of the Bardi Company. The Bardi family, as the financiers of King Robert of Anjou, exerted a powerful influence at the Angevin court in Naples. The experiences Boccaccio enjoyed with the Neapolitan aristocracy and with the breathtaking countryside and beautiful sea are reflected in many of his early poems. During his sojourn in Naples, Boccaccio also studied canon law, between 1330 or 1331 and 1334. While studying business and law, however, he anxiously sought cultural experiences to broaden his awareness of belles lettres. Largely self-taught in literary matters, he soon began to study the writings of his somewhat older contemporary, Francesco Petrarca, known as Petrarch. Later, the two men became friends and met on a number of occasions (1350 in Florence, 1351 in Padua, 1359 in Milano, 1363 in Venice, and 1368 in Padua again). Boccaccio left Naples and returned to Florence between 1340 and 1341 because of a financial crisis in the Bardi empire. Although Boccaccio rued having to leave Naples, so often associated in his imagination and writings with love and adventure and poetry, his highly bourgeois Florentine experience added an important and desirable dimension of realism to his work. Little is documented about Boccaccio’s life between 1340 and 1348, although it is known (from one of Petrarch’s letters) that he was in Ravenna between 1345 and 1346 and that he sent a letter from Forlì in 1347. He was back in Florence in 1348, where he witnessed at first hand the horrible ravages of the Black Death, or bubonic plague. Between 1349 and 1351, he gave final form to The Decameron, which takes as it mise en scène Florence and the Tuscan countryside during the plague of 1348. After his father’s death in 1349, Boccaccio assumed many more familial responsibilities and financial burdens. As his fame as an author and scholar burgeoned, his fellow Florentines began to honor him with various ambassadorial duties, starting with his 1350 assignment as ambassador to the lords of Romagna. Such posts, however, did little to alleviate the financial difficulties caused by the collapse of the Bardi Company. Boccaccio longed to return to the pleasant life he had known in Naples, but visits there in 1355 and again in 1362 and 1370 to 1371 were extremely disappointing. Between 1360 and 1362, he studied Greek, the first among the literati of his time to do so seriously; from that time until his death, his home became the center for Italian humanism. Sometime around 1361 or 1362, he left Florence to take up residence in the family home in Certaldo, where he died, on December 21, 1375, the year after the death of his friend and fellow humanist, Petrarch. Analysis • Giovanni Boccaccio’s short fiction, one hundred novelle, or tales, is collectively and contemporaneously his longest work of fiction, known as The Decameron.
120
Short Story Writers
That fact must be kept foremost in mind in any serious analysis of the tales. In other words, Boccaccio’s individual short stories are best understood when examined as part of a much larger work of fiction which has an elaborate cornice, or frame, striking symmetry, and selective and oft-repeated themes. The word decameron, Greek for “ten days,” refers to the number of days Boccaccio’s fictional characters (three young men and seven young women) dedicate to swapping tales with one another in the tranquil Tuscan countryside away from the plague-infested city of Florence. The work’s subtitle, “Prencipe Galeotto” (Prince Galahalt), refers to the panderer Galahalt, who brought Guinevere and Lancelot together, and emphasizes that Boccaccio’s book—dedicated to women—is written, not unlike many of his early poems, in the service of love. As the narration of the first day begins, three men—Panfilo (“all love”), Filostrato (“overcome by love”), and Dioneo (“the lascivious”), alluding to the love goddess Venus, daughter of Dione—come by chance one Tuesday upon seven women, who are between the ages of eighteen and twenty-eight, in the Church of Santa Maria Novella. The year is 1348, and the Black Death is the macabre background for what happens in the course of the telling of the tales. The seven women—Pampinea (“the vigorous”), Fiammetta (whose name echoes that of Boccaccio’s beloved), Filomena (“lover of song”), Emilia (“the flatterer”), Lauretta (in homage to Petrarch’s beloved Laura), Neifile (“new in love”), and Elissa (another name for Vergil’s tragic heroine Dido)—anxiously wish to remove themselves from the diseased and strife-torn city and repair to the healthful and peaceful countryside. The young men agree to accompany the ladies, and the following day (a Wednesday) the group leaves for a villa in nearby and idyllic Fiesole. Better to enjoy what is essentially a fortnight’s holiday, Pampinea suggests that they tell stories in the late afternoon when it is too hot to play or go on walks. It is decided that one of them will be chosen as king or queen for each day, and the chosen person will select a theme for the stories to be told on that day. Only Dioneo, who tells the last tale each day, has the liberty of ignoring the general theme if he so desires. They then proceed to tell ten stories per day over a two-week period, refraining from tale-telling on Fridays and Saturdays out of reverence for Christ’s crucifixion and in order to prepare properly for the Sabbath. On a Wednesday, the day following the last day of telling tales and exactly two weeks from the day the group left Florence, they return to their respective homes. The emphasis on order Library of Congress
Boccaccio, Giovanni
121
and propriety, the presentation of the countryside as a locus amoenus, the repetition of the number ten (considered a symbol of perfection in the Middle Ages), and even the total number of tales (one hundred, equal to the number of cantos in Dante’s The Divine Comedy) are all aspects of the work which contrast sharply with the disorder, impropriety, and lack of harmony which characterized Florence during the 1348 plague. The author graphically depicts, in the opening pages of the book, examples of the social chaos caused by the plethora of plague-induced deaths. The pleasant pastime of telling tales in the shade of trees and the skillful ordering of the stories serve, in other words, as an obvious antidote or salutary response to the breakdown of society which resulted from the deadly pestilence which swept Italy and much of Europe in the mid-fourteenth century. Further supporting the notion that The Decameron presents an ordered universe as an alternative to the chaos and anarchy created by the plague is Boccaccio’s insistence that his storytellers, though they may occasionally tell ribald tales, are uniformly chaste and proper in their behavior toward one another. Boccaccio’s Themes • The stories told on each of the ten days that make up The Decameron explore a predetermined subject or theme. On the first day, everyone is free to choose a topic—one is the character “Abraam giudeo” (“Abraham the Jew”). On the second day, the stories treat those, such as the subject of “Andreuccio da Perugia” (“Andreuccio of Perugia”), who realize unexpected happiness after serious misfortune. Then, on the third day, the stories discuss people who have accomplished difficult goals or who have repossessed something once lost, among which is the tale “Alibech” (“Alibech and Rustico”). The next day, the narrators tell love stories which end unhappily (see “Tancredi, Prenze di Salerno” and its English translation). On the fifth day, they tell love stories which depict misfortune but end felicitously (see “Nastagio degli Onesti” and the English translation). The stories told on the sixth day deal with the role of intelligence in helping one avoid problems—one of the most famous among these is “Cisti fornaio” (“Cisti the Baker”). On the seventh day, the stories relate tricks which wives play on husbands (see “Petronella mette un so amante in un doglio,” or “Petronella and the Barrel”), and on the eighth day, the stories recount tricks men and women play on each other, as in “Calandrino” (“Calandrino and the Heliotrope”). On the ninth day, once again everyone is free to choose a topic (one is described in “Le vasi una badessa in fretta ed al buio per trovare una sua monaca a lei accusata” and its translation, “The Abbess and the Nun”). Finally, on the tenth day, the narrators tell of men and women who have performed magnanimous deeds and acquired renown in so doing (see “Il Marchese di Saluzzo,” or “The Marchese di Saluzzo and Griselda”). In addition to the pronounced framing technique created by the introductions to the various days and by the themes themselves, there seems to be a degree of subtle thematic framing within the stories themselves from first to last. The first story of the first day, “Ser Cepparello,” tells how a most wicked man—clearly a figura diaboli, or type of the devil—deceived a friar with a false confession and came to be reputed a saint. On one hand, the tale ridicules gullible priests and credulous common folk, but on the other hand, it presents the undeniable power of human cunning. The tenth story of the tenth day recounts the story of how the Marquis of Saluzzo marries the peasant Griselda and subjects her to inhuman trials to ascertain her devotion; for example, he pretends to have their two children killed. His cruelty is ostensibly designed to test her love or respect for him; her extraordinary patience in responding
122
Short Story Writers
to his bestiality assuredly makes of her a figura Christi, or type of Christ. From the comedic devil figure of Cepparello to the tragic Christ figure of Griselda there appears to be in The Decameron a revelation of the breadth of the human condition and the wide-ranging possibilities of human experience. Nevertheless, Boccaccio explores a variation on at least one of two themes in almost all of his stories: the power of human intelligence (for good or bad) and the effect of love or human passion (for the wellbeing or detriment of those involved). At times, these themes are intermingled, as in so many of the stories of the seventh day having to do with the ingenious tricks wives play on their (usually cuckolded) spouses. Boccaccio’s Settings • Often when treating the advantages of human wit, Boccaccio provides a Florentine or Tuscan setting to his story. For example, in the sixth day, “Cisti the Baker” is set in Florence and illustrates the rise and power of the hardworking and hard-thinking merchant class Boccaccio knew so well in his hometown. Similarly, “Guido Cavalcanti,” told on the same day, has Florence as its setting and reveals the barbed wit of one of the city’s native sons. There are also tales told of Florentines who are dull-witted; examples would include the various eighth- and ninth-day stories about the simple-minded painter Calandrino, who is constantly being tricked by his supposed friends Bruno and Buffalmacco. Those who outsmart him, however, are fellow Florentines. By contrast, many of the highly adventurous tales are set in cities far away from Florence, often in exotic locations. Not surprisingly, Naples figures prominently in perhaps the most notable of the adventure tales—that is, “Andreuccio of Perugia,” the story of a provincial young man who goes to a big city (Naples) to buy horses and ends up suffering a series of misfortunes only to return home with a ruby of great value. In the tale, Naples symbolizes adventure and daring and is undoubtedly meant to recall the city of the author’s youth. Boccaccio’s Love Tales • Boccaccio’s love tales repeatedly, though not exclusively, present realistic women in place of the idealized and angelic women Dante was wont to exalt. In stories scattered throughout The Decameron, but especially in those of the third and fifth day, the physical and pleasurable union of man and woman is portrayed as the healthy and correct goal of human love. Although some interpret such unabashed celebration of humankind’s sexuality as a sure indication that The Decameron is a Renaissance work, it should be remembered that approximately 90 percent of Boccaccio’s tales derive from medieval sources. G. H. McWilliam, in the introduction to his excellent English translation of The Decameron, reviews with insight the problem of how to classify the book with regard to historical period. He points out that the harsh judgment leveled against friars and monks, whether they are philanderers or simoniacs, has numerous precedents in the literature of the Middle Ages, including Dante’s thoroughly medieval The Divine Comedy. This is not to say, however, that The Decameron does not look to the future, for it most certainly does. For one thing, when Boccaccio attacks the superstitious religious beliefs and corrupt ecclesiastical practices of his times, he does so with more severity than did his predecessors; for another, he presents the centrality of sexuality to the human condition without recourse to sermons or condemnations of the same. In both ways, he draws closer to the spirit of a new age and distances himself from the Middle Ages. His overriding purpose in the tales, however, is to illuminate the spectrum of humankind’s experiences and to point, in a world accustomed to pain and disease, a way to happiness and health. Boccaccio’s medium is always the
Boccaccio, Giovanni
123
well-worded and exquisitely framed story; his best medicine, more often than not, is laughter or the praise of life. Madison V. Sowell With updates by Victor A. Santi Other major works nonfiction: Genealogia deorum gentilium, c. 1350-1375; Trattatello in laude di Dante, 1351, 1360, 1373 (Life of Dante, 1898); Corbaccio, c. 1355 (The Corbaccio, 1975); De casibus virorum illustrium, 1355-1374 (The Fall of Princes, 1431-1438); De montibus, silvis, fontibus lacubus, fluminubus, stagnis seu paludibus, et de nominbus maris, c. 1355-1374; De mulieribus claris, c. 1361-1375 (Concerning Famous Women, 1943); Esposizioni sopra la Commedia di Dante, 1373-1374. poetry: Rime, c. 1330-1340; La caccia di Diana, c. 1334; Il filostrato, c. 1335 (The Filostrato, 1873); Il filocolo, c. 1336 (Labor of Love, 1566); Teseida, 1340-1341 (The Book of Theseus, 1974); Il ninfale d’Ameto, 1341-1342 (also known as Commedia delle ninfe); L’amorosa visione, 1342-1343 (English translation, 1986); Elegia di Madonna Fiammetta, 1343-1344 (Amorous Fiammetta, 1587, better known as The Elegy of Lady Fiammetta); Il ninfale fiesolano, 1344-1346 (The Nymph of Fiesole, 1597); Buccolicum carmen, c. 13511366 (Boccaccio’s Olympia, 1913). Bibliography Bergin, Thomas G. Boccaccio. New York: Viking Press, 1981. Excellent general introduction to Boccaccio. It begins with a historical background to Florentine life in the fourteenth century and proceeds to delineate the life of the author with emphasis on the major influences on his work. The early works are analyzed individually for their own merit and for their relationship to The Decameron. Contains lengthy but lucid discussion of The Decameron followed by notes and a useful list of works. Branca, Vittore. Boccaccio: The Man and His Works. Translated by Richard Monges. New York: New York University Press, 1976. The definitive biography of Boccaccio by an eminent scholar in the field of medieval literature. Caporello-Szykman, C. The Boccaccian Novella: The Creation and Waning of a Genre. New York: Peter Lang, 1990. Defines the novella as a form that existed only between Boccaccio and Cervantes. Discusses generic characteristics of the Decameron, Boccacio’s narrative theory, and the novella’s place within the oral tradition. Edwards, Robert R. Chaucer and Boccaccio: Antiquity and Modernity. New York: Palgrave, 2002. Examines the influence of Boccaccio on Chaucer. Forni, Pier Massimo. Adventures in Speech: Rhetoric and Narration in Boccaccio’s “Decameron.” Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1996. Examines Boccaccio’s style in his seminal work. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Hollander, Robert. Boccaccio’s Two Venuses. New York: Columbia University Press, 1977. Thorough analysis of all Boccaccio’s works except The Decameron. The author contrasts classical and Christian influences in Boccaccio’s work and concludes that, although the latter predominates in the later works, even in the earlier prose the classical Venus is tempered by the use of irony. Moe, Nelson. “Not a Love Story: Sexual Aggression, Law and Order in Decameron X 4.” Romanic Review 86 (November, 1995): 623-638. Discusses the fourth tale of
124
Short Story Writers
the tenth day as a reworking of an earlier Boccaccio treatment; examines his reformulation of the social significance of sexual transgression that is at the center of both versions of the tale. Stierle, Karlheinz. “Three Moments in the Crisis of Exemplarity: Boccaccio-Petrarch, Montaigne, and Cervantes.” Journal of the History of Ideas 59 (October, 1998): 581595. Discusses Boccaccio’s response to the exemplum as a form of narration that presumes more similarity in human behavior than diversity; analyzes Boccaccio’s turn from exemplum to novella as a shift that indicates a crisis of exemplarity. Wright, Herbert G. Boccaccio in England, from Chaucer to Tennyson. London: Athlone Press, 1957. Analysis of the influence of Boccaccio on well-known authors such as Geoffrey Chaucer, William Shakespeare, and Alfred, Lord Tennyson, with an especially lengthy and perspicacious discussion of the presence of Boccaccio in The Canterbury Tales.
125
Jorge Luis Borges Born: Buenos Aires, Argentina; August 24, 1899 Died: Geneva, Switzerland; June 14, 1986 Principal short fiction • Historia universal de la infamia, 1935 (A Universal History of Infamy, 1972); El jardín de senderos que se bifurcan, 1941; Seis problemas para don Isidro Parodi, 1942 (with Adolfo Bioy Casares, under joint pseudonym H. Bustos Domecq; Six Problems for Don Isidro Parodi, 1981); Ficciones, 1935-1944, 1944 (English translation, 1962); Dos fantasías memorables, 1946 (with Bioy Casares, under joint pseudonym Domecq); El Aleph, 1949, 1952 (translated in The Aleph, and Other Stories, 1933-1969, 1970); La muerte y la brújula, 1951; La hermana de Eloísa, 1955 (with Luisa Mercedes Levinson); Cuentos, 1958; Crónicas de Bustos Domecq, 1967 (with Bioy Casares; Chronicles of Bustos Domecq, 1976); El informe de Brodie, 1970 (Doctor Brodie’s Report, 1972); El matrero, 1970; El congreso, 1971 (The Congress, 1974); El libro de arena, 1975 (The Book of Sand, 1977); Narraciones, 1980. Other literary forms • Though most famous for his work in short fiction, Jorge Luis Borges also holds a significant place in Latino literature for his work in poetry and the essay. In fact, Borges would be considered a major writer in Latino letters for his work in these two genres (the vast majority of which was produced before the Argentine writer branched into short fiction) even had he never written a single short story. Borges’s early poetry (that for which he earned his reputation as a poet) is of the ultraist school, an avant-grade brand of poetry influenced by expressionism and Dadaism and intended by its Latino practitioners as a reaction to Latino modernism. Borges’s essays, as readers familiar with his fiction might expect, are imaginative and witty and usually deal with topics in literature or philosophy. Interestingly, because of the writer’s playful imagination, many of his essays read more like fiction than essay, while, because of his propensity both for toying with philosophical concepts and for fusing the fictitious and the real, much of his fiction reads more like essay than fiction. It seems only fitting, however, that for a writer for whom the line between fiction and reality is almost nonexistent the line between fiction and essay should be almost nonexistent as well. Achievements • It is virtually impossible to overstate the importance of Jorge Luis Borges within the context of Latino fiction, for he is, quite simply, the single most important writer of short fiction in the history of Latino literature. This is true not only because of his stories themselves, and chiefly those published in Ficciones, 1935-1944 and El Aleph, but also, just as important, because of how his stories contributed to the evolution of Latino fiction, both short and long, in the latter half of the twentieth century. Borges was the founder of Latino literature’s “new narrative,” the type of narrative practiced by the likes of Julio Cortázar, Gabriel García Márquez, Carlos Fuentes, Mario Vargas Llosa, and others. Latino fiction prior to Borges was chiefly concerned with painting a realistic and detailed picture of external Latino reality. His imaginative ficciones (or fictions) almost single-handedly changed this, teaching Latino writ-
126
Short Story Writers
ers to be creative, to use their imagination, to treat fiction as fiction, to allow the fictional world to be just that: fictional. Borges’s works also taught Latino writers to deal with universal themes and to write for an intellectual reader. Without Borges, not only would the literary world be without some superb stories, but also Latino narrative in the second half of the twentieth century would have been radically different from what it evolved to be. Biography • Jorge Luis Borges was born on August 24, 1899, in Buenos Aires, Argentina, the first of two children born to Jorge Guillermo Borges and Leonor Acevedo de Borges. (His sister, Norah, was born in 1901.) Borges’s ancestors included prominent Argentine military and historical figures on both sides of his family and an English grandmother on his father’s. “Georgie,” as Borges’s family called him, began reading very early, first in English, then in Spanish. Tutored first by his English grandmother and later by a private governess, and with access to his father’s library (which contained numerous volumes in English), young Borges devoured a wide range of writings, among them those of Robert Louis Stevenson, Rudyard Kipling, and Mark Twain, as well as works of mythology, novels of chivalry, The Thousand and One Nights (c. 1450), and Miguel de Cervantes’ Don Quixote de la Mancha (1605, 1615). Borges finally entered school at the age of nine, and at the age of thirteen he published his first story, a dramatic sketch entitled “El rey de la selva” (the king of the jungle), about his favorite animal, the tiger. Borges and his family traveled to Europe in 1914. World War I broke out while they were visiting Geneva, Switzerland, and they remained there until 1918. During his time in Geneva, Borges began to take an interest in French poetry, particularly that of Victor Hugo and Charles Baudelaire, as well as the poetry of Heinrich Heine and the German expressionists. He also began to read the works of Walt Whitman, Arthur Schopenhauer, and G. K. Chesterton, and he maintained his literary connection to his native Argentina by reading gauchesca (gaucho) poetry. In 1919 Borges and his family moved to Spain, living for various lengths of time in Barcelona, Majorca, Seville, and Madrid. While in Spain, Borges associated with a group of ultraist poets and published some poetry in an ultraist magazine. In 1921, Borges and his family returned to Buenos Aires. His return to his native city after a seven-year absence inspired him to write his first volume of poetry, entitled Fervor de Buenos Aires (fervor of Buenos Aires) and published in 1923. During this same period (in 1922), he collaborated on a “billboard review” entitled Prisma (prism) and edited the manifesto “Ultraísmo” (ultraism), published in the magazine Nosotros (us). He also helped found a short-lived magazine entitled Proa (prow). Following a second trip with his family to Europe (1923-1924), Borges continued to write poetry during the 1920’s, but he began to branch out into the essay genre as well, publishing three collections of essays during this period: Inquisiciones (inquisitions) in 1925, El tamaño de mi esperanza (the size of my hope) in 1926, and El idioma de los argentinos (the language of the Argentines) in 1928. One of his collections of poetry, Cuaderno San Martín (San Martín notebook), won for him second prize in the Municipal Literature Competition in 1929. The prize carried an award of three thousand pesos, which Borges used to buy an edition of the Encyclopœdia Britannica. Borges continued writing both poetry and essays in the 1930’s, but this decade would also bring his first (though unconventional) steps into fiction. He began contributing to the magazine Sur (south) in 1931 (through which he met his friend and
Borges, Jorge Luis
127
future literary collaborator Adolfo Bioy Casares); later, in 1933, he became the director of Crítica (criticism), a Saturday literary supplement for a Buenos Aires newspaper. As a contributor to the supplement, Borges began to rewrite stories that he took from various sources, adding his own personal TO VIEW IMAGE, touches and reworking them as he PLEASE SEE saw fit. He finally wrote, under a PRINT EDITION pen name, a wholly original piece OF THIS BOOK. entitled “Hombres de las orillas” (men from the outskirts), which appeared on September 16, 1933, in the supplement. This story and his other Crítica pieces were well received and published together in 1935 in a volume entitled Historia universal de la infamia. Borges’s foray into fiction writing continued to follow an unconventional path when in 1936 he © Washington Post, reprinted by permission of the D.C. Public Library began writing a book-review page for the magazine El Hogar (the home). Each entry carried a brief biography of the author whose work was being reviewed. Once again, Borges could not leave well enough alone. To the author’s true biographical facts, Borges began to add his own “facts,” even including apocryphal anecdotes from the author’s life and supplementing the author’s bibliography with false titles. This mix of fact and fiction, with no regard or concern for which was which, would come to be one of the trademarks of Borges’s fiction. Borges took a job as an assistant librarian in a suburban Buenos Aires library in 1937, a position whose work load and setting afforded the writer ample time and resources to read and write. In December of 1938, however, the Argentine writer suffered a near-fatal accident, slipping on a staircase and striking his head while returning to his apartment. The resulting head injury developed into septicemia, and Borges was hospitalized for more than two weeks. While still recovering in early 1939, Borges decided that he would abandon poetry and the essay (though he would later return to these genres) and dedicate his literary efforts to short fiction. Though it is somewhat unclear as to precisely why he made this decision (there are various accounts), it is speculated by some (and Borges’s own comments have supported such speculation) that he did so because after his head injury he was not sure that he could write poetry and essays of the quality for which he had been known before the accident. Short stories, for which he was virtually unknown at this point, would not allow anyone to compare an old Borges with a new, and potentially inferior, Borges. Again, this is only one suggestion as to why the Argentine writer made the decision he did; what is most important, however, is that he made it, and this decision, and the accident that seems to have caused it, would change the face of Latino fiction of the twentieth century.
128
Short Story Writers
Almost immediately, Borges began to produce a series of short stories that would make him the most important writer in Latino fiction and that would eventually make him famous. The first of these stories was “Pierre Menard, autor del Quijote” (“Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote”), which appeared in Sur in May of 1939. This story was followed in 1940 by “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” (“Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius”) and the collection El jardín de senderos que se bifurcan (the garden of forking paths) in 1941. Six stories were added to the eight collected in El jardín de senderos que se bifurcan, and a new collection, entitled Ficciones, 1935-1944, one of the most important collections of short fiction in Latino literature, appeared in 1944. Another landmark collection, El Aleph, followed in 1949. During this time, the height of his literary career up to this point, Borges, who was anti-Peronist, fell into disfavor with the government of Argentine president Juan Perón. He was dismissed from his position at the library in 1944 and appointed inspector of poultry and eggs in the municipal market. He resigned, but he did return to public service in 1955 when, following the fall of Perón, he was named the director of the National Library. Ironically, in the same year, he lost his sight, which had been declining for several years. Despite the loss of his sight, Borges continued to write (through dictation), though less than before. At the same time, his two collections of stories from the 1940’s had made him a household name among Latino literati. Worldwide recognition came in 1961, when he shared the Formentor Prize (worth ten thousand dollars) with Samuel Beckett. The fame that this award brought Borges changed his life. That fall, he traveled to the United States to lecture at the University of Texas, and between 1961 and his death in 1986, he would make numerous trips to the United States and elsewhere teaching and speaking at colleges and universities, attending literary conferences on his works, collecting literary awards, and otherwise serving as an international ambassador for Latino literature. Borges married for the first time (at the age of sixty-eight) in 1967, the same year that he accepted an invitation to teach at Harvard University as a Charles Eliot Norton lecturer. The marriage dissolved in 1970, with Borges, according to one popular anecdote, leaving the home he shared with his wife and taking only his prized Encyclopœdia Britannica with him. Perón returned to the Argentine presidency in 1973, and Borges resigned as director of the National Library. His mother died at the age of ninety-nine in 1975. Borges continued to write during the 1970’s and until his death, working in short fiction, poetry, and the essay (having returned to these last two genres in the 1950’s). The bulk of his fame, however, and particularly that specifically related to short fiction, had come from his two collections of stories from the 1940’s. He was nominated repeatedly for the Nobel Prize in Literature but never won it. In 1986, he married his companion María Kodama and shortly thereafter died of cancer of the liver on June 14, 1986, in Geneva, Switzerland. Analysis • Jorge Luis Borges may be, quite simply, the single most important writer of short fiction in the history of Latino literature. The stories he published in his collections Ficciones, 1935-1944 and El Aleph, particularly the former, not only gave Latino (and world) literature a body of remarkable stories but also opened the door to a whole new type of fiction that would be practiced by the likes of the above-mentioned Julio Cortázar, Gabriel García Márquez, Carlos Fuentes, and Mario Vargas Llosa, and that, in the hands of these writers and others like them,
Borges, Jorge Luis
129
would put Latino fiction on the world literary map in the 1960’s. Prior to Borges, and particularly between 1920 and 1940, Latino fiction, as stated previously, was concerned chiefly with painting a realistic and detailed picture of external Latino reality. Description frequently ruled over action, environment over character, and types over individuals. Social message, also, was often more important to the writer than was narrative artistry. Latino fiction after Borges (that is, after his landmark collections of stories of the 1940’s) was decidedly different in that it was no longer documentary in nature, turned its focus toward the inner workings of its fully individualized human characters, presented various interpretations of reality, expressed universal as well as regional and national themes, invited reader participation, and emphasized the importance of artistic—and frequently unconventional—presentation of the story, particularly with respect to narrative voice, language, structure (and the closely related element of time), and characterization. This “new narrative,” as it came to be called, would have been impossible without Borges’s tradition-breaking fiction. This is not to say that Borges’s stories fully embody each of the characteristics of the Latino “new narrative” listed above. Ironically, they do not. For example, Borges’s characters are often far more archetypal than individual, his presentation tends to be for the most part quite traditional, and reader participation (at least as compared to that required in the works of other “new narrativists”) is frequently not a factor. The major contributions that Borges made to Latino narrative through his stories lie, first, in his use of imagination, second, in his focus on universal themes common to all human beings, and third, in the intellectual aspect of his works. During the 1940’s, Borges, unlike most who were writing so-called Latino fiction, treated fiction as fiction. Rather than use fiction to document everyday reality, Borges used it to invent new realities, to toy with philosophical concepts, and in the process to create truly fictional worlds, governed by their own rules. He also chose to write chiefly about universal human beings rather than exclusively about Latinos. His characters are, for example, European, or Chinese, frequently of no discernible nationality, and only occasionally Latino. In most cases, even when a character’s nationality is revealed, it is of no real importance, particularly with respect to theme. Almost all Borges’s characters are important not because of the country from which they come but because they are human beings, faced not with situations and conflicts particular to their nationality but with situations and conflicts common to all human beings. Finally, unlike his predecessors and many of his contemporaries, Borges did not aim his fiction at the masses. He wrote instead, it seems, more for himself, and, by extension, for the intellectual reader. These three aspects of his fiction—treating fiction as fiction, placing universal characters in universal conflicts, and writing for a more intellectual audience—stand as the Argentine writer’s three most important contributions to Latino fiction in the latter half of the twentieth century, and to one degree or another, virtually every one of the Latino “new narrativists,” from Cortázar to García Márquez, followed Borges’s lead in these areas. Borges’s stories are more aptly called “fictions” than “stories,” for while all fit emphatically into the first category, since they contain fictitious elements, many do not fit nearly so well into a traditional definition of the second, since they read more like essays than stories. His fictions are sophisticated, compact, even mathematically precise narratives that range in type from what might be called the “traditional” short story (a rarity) to fictionalized essay (neither pure story nor pure essay but instead a
130
Short Story Writers
unique mix of the two, complete, oddly enough, with both fictitious characters and footnotes, both fictitious and factual) to detective story or spy thriller (though always with an unmistakably Borgesian touch) to fictional illustration of a philosophical concept (this last type being, perhaps, most common). Regardless of the specific category into which each story might fall, almost all, to one degree or another, touch on either what Borges viewed as the labyrinthine nature of the universe, irony (particularly with respect to human destiny), the concept of time, the hubris of those who believe they know all there is to know, or any combination of these elements. Most of Borges’s fame as a writer of fiction and virtually all of his considerable influence on Latino “new narrative” are derived from his two masterpiece collections, Ficciones, 1935-1944 and El Aleph. Of these two, the first stands out as the more important and may be the single most important collection of short fiction in the history of Latino literature. Ficciones, 1935-1944 contains fourteen stories (seventeen for editions published after 1956). Seven of the fourteen were written between 1939 and 1941 and, along with an eighth story, were originally collected in El jardín de senderos que se bifurcan (the garden of forking paths). The other six stories were added in 1944. Virtually every story in this collection has become a Latino classic, and together they reveal the variety of Borges’s themes and story types. “Death and the Compass” • “La muerte y la brújula” (“Death and the Compass”) is one of the most popular of the stories found in Ficciones, 1935-1944. In it, detective Erik Lönnrot is faced with the task of solving three apparent murders that have taken place exactly one month apart at locations that form a geographical equilateral triangle. The overly rational Lönnrot, through elaborate reasoning, divines when and where the next murder is to take place. He goes there to prevent the murder and to capture the murderer, only to find himself captured, having been lured to the scene by his archenemy, Red Scharlach, so that he, Lönnrot, can be killed. This story is a perfect example of Borges’s ability to take a standard subgenre, in this case the detective story, and give it his own personal signature, as the story is replete with Borgesian trademarks. The most prominent of these concerns irony and hubris. Following the first murder and published reports of Lönnrot’s line of investigation, Scharlach, who has sworn to kill Lönnrot, constructs the remainder of the murder scenario, knowing that Lönnrot will not rest until he deciphers the apparent patterns and then—believing he knows, by virtue of his reasoning, all there is to know—will blindly show up at the right spot at the right time for Scharlach to capture and kill him. Ironically, Lönnrot’s intelligence and his reliance (or over-reliance) on reasoning, accompanied in no small measure by his self-assurance and intellectual vanity, which blind him to any potential danger, bring him to his death. Other trademark Borgesian elements in the story include the totally non-Latino content (from characters to setting), numerous references to Jews and things Jewish (a talmudic congress, rabbis, and Cabalistic studies, to name only a few), and an intellectual content and ambience throughout not typical of the traditional detective story. (Lönnrot figures out, for example, that the four points that indicate the four apparent murders—there are really only three—correspond to the Tetragrammaton, the four Hebrew letters that make up “the ineffable name of God.”) “The Garden of Forking Paths” • “The Garden of Forking Paths” is another story from Ficciones, 1935-1944 which in the most general sense (but only in the most gen-
Borges, Jorge Luis
131
eral sense) fits comfortably into a traditional category, that of spy thriller, but like “Death and the Compass,” in Borges’s hands it is anything but a story typical of its particular subgenre. In this story, Dr. Yu Tsun (once again, a non-Latino character), a Chinese professor of English, working in England (a non-Latino setting as well) as a spy for the Germans during World War I, has been captured and now dictates his story. Yu tells of how he had needed to transmit vital information to the Germans concerning the name of the town in which the British were massing artillery in preparation for an attack. Yu’s superior, however, had been captured, thus severing Yu’s normal lines of communication. Identified as a spy and pursued by the British, Yu tells how he had selected, from the phone directory, the only man he believed could help him communicate his message, one Stephen Albert (though the reader at this point is not aware of exactly how Albert could be of help to Yu). Yu tells of how he traveled to Albert’s house, hotly pursued by a British agent. Yu had never met Albert, but Albert mistook him for someone else and invited Yu into the house. The two talked for a hour about Chinese astrologer and writer Ts’ui Pêen (who happened to be one of Yu’s ancestors) and Ts’ui’s labyrinthine book The Garden of Forking Paths (which, given its content, gives Borges’s story a story-within-a-story element) as Yu stalled for time for the British agent to catch up with him. Yu says that as the agent approached the house, Yu killed Albert and then allowed himself to be captured by the agent. The final paragraph of the story reveals that Yu had chosen to kill Albert and then be arrested so that news of the incident would appear in the newspaper. He knew that his German colleagues would read the small news item and would divine Yu’s intended message: that the British had been massing artillery near the French town of Albert—thus Yu’s reason for having chosen Stephen Albert. “The Circular Ruins” • “Las ruinas circulares” (“The Circular Ruins”) is one of a number of examples in Ficciones, 1935-1944 of Borges’s frequent practice of using a story to illustrate (or at least toy with) philosophical concepts, in this particular case, most notably, the Gnostic concept of one creator behind another creator. In this story, a mysterious man travels to an equally mysterious place with the intention of creating another person by dreaming him. The man experiences great difficulty in this at first, but eventually he is successful. The man instructs his creation and then sends him off. Before he does, however, the man erases his creation’s knowledge of how he came to be, for the man does not wish him to know that he exists only as the dream of another. Soon after the man’s creation has left, fire breaks out and surrounds the man. He prepares for death, but as the flames begin to engulf him, he cannot feel them. He realizes then that he, too, ironically, is but an illusion, not real at all but simply the dream of another. “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote” • “Pierre Menard, autor del Quijot” (“Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote”), also from Ficciones, 1935-1944, is one of Borges’s most famous stories that may be classified as a fictionalized essay, for it is clearly not a story: a fiction, yes, but a story (at least by any traditional definition of the term), no. In it, a pompous first-person narrator, a literary critic, in what is presented as an essay of literary criticism, tells of the writer Pierre Menard (fictional in the real world but completely real in Borges’s fictive universe). After considerable discussion of Menard’s bibliography (complete with titles and publication dates, all fictional but with titles of real literary journals—once again, an example of Borges’s practice of fusing the
132
Short Story Writers
fictive and the real), as well as other facts about the author, the critic discusses Menard’s attempt to compose a contemporary version of Cervantes’ Don Quixote de la Mancha. Menard accomplishes this not by writing a new Don Quixote de la Mancha but simply by copying Cervantes’ original text word for word. The critic even examines identical passages from the two versions and declares that Menard’s version, though identical to Cervantes’, is actually richer. The critic pursues the reasons and ramifications of this fact further. The result is, among other things, a tongue-in-cheek sendup of scholars and literary critics and the snobbish and often ridiculous criticism that they publish. “The South” • Finally, “El Sur” (“The South”), from Ficciones, 1935-1944 as well, is a classic Borges story that demonstrates the author’s ability to mix reality (at best a relative term in Borges’s world and in Latino “new narrative” as a whole) with fantasy and, more important, to show that the line between the two is not only very subtle but also of no real importance, for fantasy is just as much a part of the universe as socalled reality. This story, which Borges once said he considered his best, concerns Johannes Dahlmann, a librarian in Buenos Aires. Dahlmann, the reader is told, has several heroic, military ancestors, and though he himself is a city-dwelling intellectual, he prefers to identify himself with his more romantic ancestors. In that spirit, Dahlmann even maintains a family ranch in the “South” (capitalized here and roughly the Argentine equivalent, in history and image, to North America’s “Old West”). He is, however, an absentee landowner, spending all of his time in Buenos Aires, keeping the ranch only to maintain a connection, although a chiefly symbolic one, with his family’s more exciting past. Entering his apartment one night, Dahlmann accidentally runs into a doorway (an accident very similar to that which Borges suffered in 1938). The resulting head injury develops into septicemia (as was the case with Borges as well), and he is sent off to a sanatorium. Finally, he recovers well enough to travel, at his doctor’s suggestion, to his ranch in the South to convalesce. His train trip to the South is vague to him at best, as he slips in and out of sleep. Unfamiliar with the region, he disembarks one stop too early and waits in a general store for transportation. While there, he is harassed by a group of ruffians. He accepts the challenge of one among them, and as the story ends, he is about to step outside for a knife fight he knows he cannot win. If that were all there were to “The South,” the story would be interesting, perhaps, but certainly nothing spectacular, and it would probably fit fairly comfortably into the type of Latino narrative popular before Borges. There is more, however, and it is this “more” that places the story firmly within the parameters of Latino “new narrative.” The story is, in fact, the literary equivalent of an optical illusion. For those who can perceive only one angle, the story is essentially that described above. For those who can make out the other angle, however, the story is completely different. There are numerous subtle though undeniably present hints throughout the second half of the story, after Dahlmann supposedly leaves the sanatorium, that suggest that the protagonist does not step out to fight at the end of the story. In fact, he never even leaves the sanatorium at all but instead dies there. His trip to the South, his encounter with the ruffians, and his acceptance of their challenge, which will lead to certain death, are all nothing but a dream, dreamt, it seems, in the sanatorium, for death in a knife fight is the death that he, Dahlmann—the librarian who likes to identify himself with his heroic and romantic ancestors—would have preferred compared to that of the sanatorium. This added dimension as well as the rather subtle manner in
Borges, Jorge Luis
133
which it is suggested (an attentive reader is required) separates both the story and its author from the type of fiction and fiction writer that characterized Latino fiction before Borges. It is this type of added dimension that makes Borges’s fiction “new” and makes him a truly fascinating writer to read. Borges continued to write short fiction after Ficciones, 1935-1944 and El Aleph, but the stories produced during this period never approached the popularity among readers nor the acclaim among critics associated with the two earlier collections. This is attributable in part to the fact that most of the stories the Argentine writer published in the 1960’s, as well as the 1970’s and 1980’s, lack much of what makes Borges Borges. Most are decidedly more realistic, often more Argentine in focus, and in general less complex—all in all, less Borgesian and, according to critics, less impressive. Some of this, particularly the change in complexity, has been explained as attributable to the fact that because of his loss of sight, Borges turned to dictation, which made reediting and polishing more difficult. Regardless of the reason, most of Borges’s fiction after his two landmark collections of the 1940’s has been largely ignored. Keith H. Brower Other major works novel: Un modelo para la muerte, 1946 (with Adolfo Bioy Casares, under joint pseudonym B. Suárez Lynch). screenplays: “Los orilleros” y “El paraíso de los creyentes,” 1955 (with Bioy Casares); Les Autres, 1974 (with Bioy Casares and Hugo Santiago). poetry: Fervor de Buenos Aires, 1923, 1969; Luna de enfrente, 1925; Cuaderno San Martín, 1929; Poemas, 1923-1943, 1943; Poemas, 1923-1953, 1954; Obra poética, 19231958, 1958; Obra poética, 1923-1964, 1964; Seis poemas escandinavos, 1966; Siete poemas, 1967; El otro, el mismo, 1969; Elogio de la sombra, 1969 (In Praise of Darkness, 1974); El oro de los tigres, 1972 (translated in The Gold of Tigers: Selected Later Poems, 1977); La rosa profunda, 1975 (translated in The Gold of Tigers); La moneda de hierro, 1976; Historia de la noche, 1977; La cifra, 1981; Los conjurados, 1985; Selected Poems, 1999. nonfiction: Inquisiciones, 1925; El tamaño de mi esperanza, 1926; El idioma de los argentinos, 1928; Evaristo Carriego, 1930 (English translation, 1984); Figari, 1930; Discusión, 1932; Las Kennigar, 1933; Historia de la eternidad, 1936; Nueva refutación del tiempo, 1947; Aspectos de la literatura gauchesca, 1950; Antiguas literaturas germánicas, 1951 (with Delia Ingenieros; revised as Literaturas germánicas medievales, 1966, with Maria Esther Vásquez); Otras Inquisiciones, 1952 (Other Inquisitions, 1964); El “Martin Fierro,” 1953 (with Margarita Guerrero); Leopoldo Lugones, 1955 (with Betina Edelberg); Manual de zoología fantástica, 1957 (with Guerrero; The Imaginary Zoo, 1969; revised as El libro de los seres imaginarios, 1967, The Book of Imaginary Beings, 1969); La poesía gauchesca, 1960; Introducción a la literatura norteamericana, 1967 (with Esther Zemborain de Torres; An Introduction to American Literature, 1971); Prólogos, 1975; Cosmogonías, 1976; Libro de sueños, 1976; Qué es el budismo?, 1976 (with Alicia Jurado); Siete noches, 1980 (Seven Nights, 1984); Nueve ensayos dantescos, 1982; The Total Library: Non-fiction, 1922-1986, 2001 (Eliot Weinberger, editor); This Craft of Verse, 2000. miscellaneous: Obras completas, 1953-1967 (10 volumes); Antología personal, 1961 (A Personal Anthology, 1967); Labyrinths: Selected Stories, and Other Writings, 1962, 1964;
134
Short Story Writers
Nueva antología personal, 1968; Selected Poems, 1923-1967, 1972 (also includes prose); Adrogue, 1977; Obras completas en colaboración, 1979 (with others); Borges: A Reader, 1981; Atlas, 1984 (with María Kodama; English translation, 1985). translations: Orlando, 1937 (of Virginia Woolf’s novel); La metamórfosis, 1938 (of Franz Kafka’s novel Die Verwandlung); Un bárbaro en Asia, 1941 (of Henri Michaux’s travel notes); Bartleby, el escribiente, 1943 (of Herman Melville’s novella Bartleby the Scrivener); Los mejores cuentos policiales, 1943 (with Bioy Casares; of detective stories by various authors); Los mejores cuentos policiales, segunda serie, 1951 (with Bioy Casares; of detective stories by various authors); Cuentos breves y extraordinarios, 1955, 1973 (with Bioy Casares; of short stories by various authors; Extraordinary Tales, 1973); Las palmeras salvajes, 1956 (of William Faulkner’s novel The Wild Palms); Hojas de hierba, 1969 (of Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass). anthologies: Antología clásica de la literatura argentina, 1937; Antología de la literatura fantástica, 1940 (with Adolfo Bioy Casares and Silvia Ocampo); Antología poética argentina, 1941 (with Bioy Casares and Ocampo); El compadrito: Su destino, sus barrios, su música, 1945, 1968 (with Silvina Bullrich); Poesía gauchesca, 1955 (with Bioy Casares; 2 volumes); Libro del cielo y del infierno, 1960, 1975 (with Bioy Casares); Versos, 1972 (by Evaristo Carriego); Antología poética, 1982 (by Leopoldo Lugones); Antología poética, 1982 (by Franciso de Quevedo); El amigo de la muerte, 1984 (by Pedro Antonio de Alarcón). Bibliography Aizenberg, Edna, ed. Borges and His Successors. Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1990. Collection of essays by various critics on Borges’s relationship to such writers as Italo Calvino and Umberto Eco, his influence on such writers as Peter Carey and Salvador Elizondo, and his similarity to such thinkers as Michel Foucault, Paul de Man, and Jacques Derrida. Bell-Villada, Gene H. Borges and His Fiction: A Guide to His Mind and Art. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1981. Excellent introduction to Borges and his works for North American readers. In lengthy sections entitled “Borges’s Worlds,” “Borges’s Fiction,” and “Borges’s Place in Literature,” Bell-Villada provides detailed and very readable commentary concerning Borges’s background, his many stories, and his career, all the while downplaying the Argentine writer’s role as a philosopher and intellectual and emphasizing his role as a storyteller. A superb study. McMurray, George R. Jorge Luis Borges. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1980. Intended by the author as “an attempt to decipher the formal and thematic aspects of a synthetic universe that rivals reality in its almost overwhelming complexity,” namely Borges’s universe. A very good and well-organized study of Borges’s dominant themes and narrative devices, with many specific references to the Argentine author’s stories. Includes an informative introduction on Borges’s life and a conclusion that coherently brings together the diverse elements discussed in the book. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these thirteen short stories by Borges: “The Aleph” (vol. 1); “The Circular Ruins” (vol. 2); “Funes, the Memorious,” “The Garden of Forking Paths,” and “The Gospel According to Mark” (vol. 3); “The Library of Babel” (vol. 4); “The Lottery in Babylon” (vol. 5); “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote,” “The Secret Miracle,” and “The Shape of
Borges, Jorge Luis
135
the Sword” (vol. 6); and “The South,” “Theme of the Traitor and the Hero,” and “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” (vol. 7). Nuñez-Faraco, Humberto. “In Search of The Aleph: Memory, Truth, and Falsehood in Borges’s Poetics.” The Modern Language Review 92 (July, 1997): 613-629. Discusses autobiographical allusions, literary references to Dante, and cultural reality in the story “El Aleph.” Argues that Borges’s story uses cunning and deception to bring about its psychological and intellectual effect. Rodríguez Monegal, Emir. Jorge Luis Borges: A Literary Biography. New York: E. P. Dutton, 1978. This nearly definitive biography of Borges was written by one of the Argentine writer’s (and contemporary Latin American literature’s) most prominent critics. Particularly interesting for its constant blending of facts about Borges’s life and literary text by him concerning or related to the events or personalities discussed. Detailed, lengthy, and highly informative. Very useful for anyone seeking a better understanding of Borges the writer. Soud, Stephen E. “Borges the Golem-Maker: Intimations of ‘Presence’ in ‘The Circular Ruins.’” MLN 110 (September, 1995): 739-754. Argues that Borges uses the legend of the golem to establish authorial presence in the story. Argues that Borges did not seek to deconstruct literature but to re-sacralize it and to salvage the power of the logos, the Divine Word. Stabb, Martin S. Borges Revisited. Boston: Twayne, 1991. Update of Stabb’s Jorge Luis Borges, published in 1970. Though Borges’s early works, including those from the 1940’s and 1950’s, are discussed and analyzed here, emphasis is on Borges’s post1970 writings, how the “canonical” (to use Stabb’s term) Borges compares to the later Borges, and “a fresh assessment of the Argentine master’s position as a major Western literary presence.” An excellent study, particularly used in tandem with Stabb’s earlier book on Borges. Williamson, Edwin. Borges: A Life. New York: Viking Press, 2004. Drawing on interviews and extensive research, the most comprehensive and well-reviewed Borges biography. Wreen, Michael J. “Don Quixote Rides Again.” Romanic Review 86 (January, 1995): 141-163. Argues that Pierre Menard is not the new Cervantes in Borges’s story “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote,” but rather the new Quixote. Asserts that in the story Borges pokes fun at himself and that a proper interpretation of the story requires readers to understand that Menard’s Quixote is simply Cervantes’ Quixote, although Menard thinks it is a new and important work. Zubizarreta, Armando F. “‘Borges and I,’ a Narrative Sleight of Hand.” Studies in 20th Century Literature 22 (Summer, 1998): 371-381. Argues that the two characters in the sketch are involved in the implementation of vengeance. Argues that the character Borges, driven by a compulsive pattern of stealing, unsuspectingly takes over the “I” character’s grievances against him through his own writing.
136
Elizabeth Bowen Born: Dublin, Ireland; June 7, 1899 Died: London, England; February 22, 1973 Principal short fiction • Encounters, 1923; Ann Lee’s, and Other Stories, 1926; Joining Charles, 1929; The Cat Jumps, and Other Stories, 1934; Look at All Those Roses, 1941; The Demon Lover, 1945 (pb. in U.S. as Ivy Gripped the Steps, and Other Stories, 1946); The Early Stories, 1951; Stories by Elizabeth Bowen, 1959; A Day in the Dark, and Other Stories, 1965; Elizabeth Bowen’s Irish Stories, 1978; The Collected Stories of Elizabeth Bowen, 1980. Other literary forms • Elizabeth Bowen is as well known for her ten novels as she is for her short-story collections. She also wrote books of history, travel, literary essays, personal impressions, a play, and a children’s book. Achievements • Elizabeth Bowen’s career is distinguished by achievements on two separate, though related, fronts. On the one hand, she was among the best-known and accomplished British women novelists of her generation, a generation which, in the period between the wars, did much to consolidate the distinctive existence of women’s fiction. Bowen’s work in this area is noteworthy for its psychological acuity, sense of atmosphere, and impassioned fastidiousness of style. As an Anglo-Irish writer, on the other hand, she maintained more self-consciously than most of her predecessors an understanding of her class’s destiny. Themes that are prevalent throughout her work—loss of innocence, decline of fortune, impoverishment of the will—gain an additional haunting quality from her sensitivity to the Irish context. Her awareness of the apparent historical irrelevance of the Anglo-Irish also gives her short stories in particular an important cultural resonance. Biography • Elizabeth Dorothea Cole Bowen received her formal education at Downe House in Kent and at the London County Council School of Art. In 1923 she married Alan Charles Cameron and lived with him in Northampton and Old Headington, Oxford. In 1935 she and her husband moved to Regent’s Park, London, where Bowen became a member of the Bloomsbury group. During World War II she stayed in London, where she worked for the Ministry of Information and as an air-raid warden. In 1948 she was made a Commander of the British Empire. She was awarded an honorary Doctor of Letters by Trinity College, Dublin, in 1949. After the death of her husband in 1952, Bowen returned to live at Bowen’s Court in Ireland, her family estate. In 1957 she was awarded an honorary Doctor of Letters by the University of Oxford. In 1960 she sold Bowen’s Court and returned to Old Headington, Oxford. After a final trip to Ireland, Elizabeth Bowen died in London on February 22, 1973. Analysis • Elizabeth Bowen’s stories are set in the first half of the twentieth century in England and Ireland. Often the action takes place against a background of war. Taken together, her stories provide a chronicle of the social, political, and psychic life of England from the beginning of the century through World War II. Her characters are mainly drawn from the middle class, although upper- and lower-class characters
Bowen, Elizabeth
137
appear as well. Although Bowen’s protagonist is usually a woman, men also play important roles. By selecting significant detail and by utilizing mythic parallels, Bowen constructs stories whose settings, actions, and characters are simultaneously realistic and symbolic. Bowen’s characters exist in a world which has lost contact with meaning; traditional forms and ideas have lost meaning and vitality. Both identity and a sense of belonging are lost; “Who am I?” and “Where am I?” are typical questions asked by Bowen protagonists. Some characters merely go through the motions and rituals of daily life, experiencing pattern without meaning. Others have a vague consciousness that something is wrong; unfulfilled, they suffer from boredom, apathy, and confusion. Sometimes, such characters are driven to seek alternatives in their lives. “Summer Night” • In “Summer Night,” while the Major, an example of the first type of character, goes about his evening routine, shutting up the house for the night, his wife, Emma, pretending to visit friends, leaves her traditional family for an assignation with Robinson, a man she hardly knows. He represents another type: the man who adapts to meaninglessness by utilizing power amorally to manipulate and control. Emma is disillusioned in her search for vitality and love when she discovers that Robinson wants sex and nothing else. Other characters, such as Justin, are fully conscious of the situation; they know that they “don’t live” and conceive the need for a “new form” but are impotent to break through to achieve one. Although Bowen’s stories focus on those characters who seek meaning or who are in the process of breaking through, they also represent a final type—one whose thinking and feeling are unified and in harmony with existence. An example from “Summer Night” is Justin’s deaf sister, Queenie. While Robinson is left alone in his house, while Emma leans drunk and crying against a telegraph pole, and while Justin goes to mail an angry letter to Robinson, Queenie lies in bed remembering a time when she sat with a young man beside the lake below the ruin of the castle now on Robinson’s land: “While her hand brushed the ferns in the cracks of the stone seat emanations of kindness passed from him to her. The subtle deaf girl had made the transposition of this nothing or everything into an everything.” Queenie imagines: “Tonight it was Robinson who, guided by Queenie down leaf tunnels, took the place on the stone seat by the lake.” It is Queenie’s memory and imagiLibrary of Congress nation that creates, at least for
138
Short Story Writers
herself, a world of love, unrealized, but realizable, by the others. Memory recalls the lost estate of human beings, represented here by the castle, its grounds, and its garden, as well as man’s lost identity. Queenie is a queen. All human beings are rightfully queens and kings in Bowen’s fiction. Queenie’s memory reaches back to the archetypal roots of being, in harmony with life; her imagination projects this condition in the here and now and as a possibility for the future. Queenie’s thinking is the true thinking Justin calls for, thinking that breaks through to a “new form,” which is composed of archetypal truth transformed to suit the conditions of modern life. Throughout Bowen’s fiction this kind of thought takes the form of fantasy, hallucination, and dream. Bowen’s fiction itself, the expression of her imagination, also exemplifies this thinking. “Her Table Spread” • Toward the end of “Summer Night” it occurs to Justin that possibly Emma should have come to him rather than Robinson. In “Her Table Spread” Bowen brings together two characters much like Emma and Justin. Valeria Cuff, heir and owner of a castle in Ireland, situated on an estuary where English ships are allowed to anchor, invites Mr. Alban, a cynical and disillusioned young man from London, to a dinner party. These characters represent opposites which concern Bowen throughout her fiction: male and female, darkness and light, thought and feeling, physical and spiritual, rational and irrational. The separation or conflict of these opposites creates a world of war; their unification creates a world of love. Valeria’s orientation is romantic, “irrational,” and optimistic: “Her mind was made up: she was a princess.” She invites Alban to her castle, “excited” at the thought of marrying him. Alban is realistic, rational, and pessimistic: “He had failed to love. . . . He knew some spring had dried up at the root of the world.” Alban is disconcerted by Valeria’s erratic, impulsive behavior and by her apparent vulgarity. He has heard “she was abnormal—at twenty-five, of statuesque development, still detained in childhood.” Ironically, as Alban realizes “his presence must constitute an occasion,” he is “put out of” Valeria’s mind when a destroyer anchors in the estuary. Valeria believes it is the same destroyer that had anchored there the previous spring at Easter when two officers, Mr. Graves and Mr. Garrett, came ashore and were entertained by friends. Valeria’s expectation that the officers will come to dinner initially separates her from Alban. When the officers fail to arrive, she runs outside to signal them with a lantern. Old Mr. Rossiter, uncle to Mrs. Treye, Valeria’s aunt, leads Alban to the boathouse to prevent Valeria from rowing out to the destroyer. When a bat flies against Alban’s ear, he flees, and, ascending the steps back toward the castle, he hears Valeria sobbing in the dark. When he calls to her, expressing concern and sympathy, she mistakes him for Mr. Garrett. Her fantasy of love is realized as she and Alban stand together, unified in a field of light shining from the castle. Symbolic details and analogies with pagan and Christian myth universalize the meaning of the story. Alban is associated with the destroyer, with Graves and Garrett, and with their emblems, statues of Mars and Mercury. Like the destroyer, Alban is “fixed in the dark rain, by an indifferent shore.” The officers represent aspects of Alban. The name Graves suggests death; and the statue associated with Graves is Mars, god of war. Garrett is a pun on garret, which derives from a word meaning to defend or protect. Garrett’s statue is Mercury, a god associated by the Romans with peace. Alban’s link with the destroyer, with death and war, threatens the destruction of Valeria’s dreams of love and peace. The Garrett aspect of Alban, however, linked with protection and peace, offers the possibility of the realization of Valeria’s dreams.
Bowen, Elizabeth
139
Valeria is associated with two symbolic items. Among the gifts she has to offer is a leopard skin, suggesting the animal and the sensual, and a statue of Venus, goddess of love. Valeria thus offers love in both its physical and spiritual aspects. Contained in her fantasies is the expectation that love will put an end to war. She thinks: “Invasions from the water would henceforth be social, perhaps amorous,” and she imagines marrying Garrett and inviting “all the Navy up the estuary” for tea: “The Navy would be unable to tear itself away.” As Valeria attempts to signal the destroyer with the lantern, she thinks that Graves and Garrett will have to fight for her; instead, the battle takes place within Alban. The pagan symbolism in “Her Table Spread” is overlain and transformed by Christian symbolism. Valeria’s castle and its grounds, like the ruins of the castle in “Summer Night,” represent a lost Eden. Valeria is an heir and a princess; she is an incarnation of Eve seeking her rightful role and place in a paradise of love and peace. Symbolically, she calls to Adam (Alban) to reclaim his inheritance—to join her in recreating the garden. The way is expressed in Bowen’s use of the second major Christian myth. Alban must undergo the experience of Christ, the second Adam, to redeem his “fallen” self; he must reject temptation and undergo crucifixion—sacrifice his ego. The trip to the boathouse is Alban’s descent into hell. There he is tempted by Old Mr. Rossiter, the Devil. Rossiter offers Alban whiskey, which he refuses, and tempts him with Valeria: “She’s a girl you could shape. She’s got a nice income.” Alban’s rejection of this temptation, his refusal to listen to the Devil, is signified by his flight from the boathouse when a bat flies against his ear. As Alban ascends the steps, he recognizes where he is: “Hell.” This recognition is the precondition for discovering where he belongs. At this point he undergoes a symbolic crucifixion. Hearing Valeria “sobbing” in “absolute desperation,” Alban clings “to a creaking tree.” The sympathy Alban feels for Valeria signifies the death of Graves within him and the resurrection of Garrett. Valeria has also experienced crucifixion. Graves and Garrett have not arrived, and her lantern has gone out; she, too, is in hell. Humbled and in darkness, the two meet. Alban speaks with tenderness: “Quietly, my dear girl.” Valeria speaks with concern. “Don’t you remember the way?” The year before the destroyer had anchored “at Easter.” Now Valeria is present at and participates in resurrection: “Mr. Garrett has landed.” She laughs “like a princess, and magnificently justified.” Standing with Valeria in the glow of light from the castle, observed by the two female guests, Alban experiences love: “Such a strong tenderness reached him that, standing there in full manhood, he was for a moment not exiled. For the moment, without moving or speaking, he stood, in the dark, in a flame, as though all three said: ‘My darling.’” “The Demon Lover” • A world of love is achieved, if only momentarily, in “Her Table Spread.” In “The Demon Lover” Bowen creates a story of love denied or repressed, and its power transformed into the demonic. The stories complement each other. The first takes place at a castle in Ireland in the spring and recalls the previous Easter; the second is set in an abandoned London flat in autumn during the bombing of London in World War II and recalls a previous autumn during World War I. The action of “Her Table Spread” concludes with the coming of night. The protagonists of the first story are a young woman in search of love and a young man associated with war; those of the second are a forty-year-old married woman who has denied love and her fiancé of twenty years before, a solider lost in action during World War I. Both female characters are “abnormal”: Valeria of “Her Table Spread” caught
140
Short Story Writers
up in fantasy, Kathleen of “The Demon Lover” subject to hallucination. Bowen utilizes elements of the Eden myth to universalize the meaning of both stories. In “The Demon Lover” Mrs. Kathleen Drover returns to her abandoned London flat to pick up some things she had left behind when her family moved to the country to escape the bombing. In the dark flat where everything is covered with a dustlike film, she opens a door, and reflected light reveals an unstamped letter recently placed on a hall table. Since the caretaker is away and the house has been locked, there is no logical explanation for the appearance of the letter. Unnerved, Mrs. Drover takes it upstairs to her bedroom, where she reads it. The letter reminds her that today is the anniversary of the day years before when she made a promise of fidelity to a young soldier on leave from France during World War I—and that they had agreed to meet on this day “at an hour arranged.” Although her “fiancé was reported missing, presumed killed,” he has apparently survived and awaits the meeting. When Kathleen hears the church clock strike six, she becomes terrified but maintains enough control to gather the items she came for and to formulate a plan to leave the house, hire a taxi, and bring the driver back with her to pick up the bundles. Meanwhile, in the basement “a door or window was being opened by someone who chose this moment to leave the house.” This statement provides a realistic solution to the problem of the letter’s appearance, but a psychological interpretation offers an alternative conclusion. The London flat symbolizes Kathleen’s life as Mrs. Drover, and the shock of finding the letter reveals to Kathleen the meaninglessness of this life and the falseness of her identity as Mrs. Drover. By marrying Drover, Kathleen has been “unfaithful” not only to the soldier but also to herself. It is this self which emerges as a result of the “crisis”—actually the crisis of World War II—and which has unconsciously motivated Mrs. Drover’s return to the house. The fact that the letter is signed K., Kathleen’s initial, suggests that she wrote the letter, which is a sign of the reemergence of her lost self. The house represents not only Kathleen’s life as Mrs. Drover but also the repressed-Kathleen aspect of her identity. The person in the basement who leaves the house at the same moment Mrs. Drover lets herself out the front door is a projection of this repressed self, the self Mrs. Drover now unknowingly goes to face. Overlying the psychological meaning of the story are two additional levels of meaning, one allegorical, the other archetypal. The young Kathleen represents England, defended and protected by the soldier, who represents the generation of those who fought for the country during the first war. Kathleen’s loveless and meaningless marriage to Drover represents England’s betrayal of the values the war was fought to defend—a betrayal which has contributed to the creation of World War II. The letter writer asserts: “In view of the fact that nothing has changed, I shall rely upon you to keep your promise.” Because Kathleen and England have betrayed themselves, because love has failed, war continues, and both the individual and the country must suffer destructive consequences. On the archetypal level, Kathleen and the soldier are incarnations of Eve and Adam, although the soldier is an Adam transformed by war into a devil who coerces Eve to “fall,” forces her to make the “sinister truth.” The soldier’s uniform is the sign of his transformation. His true nature, his Adamic self, is covered and denied by the clothes of war. Kathleen is unable to touch the true self of the soldier, and he is unable to reach out to her. The scene takes place at night in a garden beneath a tree. Intimidated by not being kissed, Kathleen imagines “spectral glitters in the place” of the soldier’s eyes. To “verify his presence,” she puts out a hand, which he takes and
Bowen, Elizabeth
141
presses “painfully, onto one of the breast buttons of his uniform.” In this way he forces her to make a vow of fidelity—a pact with the Devil. He says, “I shall be with you . . . sooner or later. You won’t forget that. You need do nothing but wait.” Kathleen suffers the fate of Eve, feels that unnatural promise drive down between her and the rest of all humankind. When the soldier, her “fiancé,” is reported “missing, presumed killed,” she experiences “a complete dislocation from everything.” Compelled now to confront her fate, she gets into a taxi, which seems to be awaiting her. When the driver turns in the direction of her house without being told where to drive, Kathleen leans “forward to scratch at the glass panel that divided the driver’s head from her own . . . driver and passenger, not six inches between them, remained for an eternity eye to eye.” Reunited with her demon lover, Kathleen screams “freely” as the taxi accelerates “without mercy” into the “hinterland of deserted streets.” The failure of love condemns Kathleen—and by implication humankind—to insanity and damnation in the modern wasteland. In spite of the pessimistic conclusion of “The Demon Lover,” Bowen’s short fiction is ultimately affirmative. In a 1970 McCall’s essay she lamented that many people, especially the young, are “adrift, psychologically . . . homeless, lost in a void.” She expresses her desire to “do something that would arrest the drift, fill up the vacuum, convey the sense that there is, after all, SOMETHING. . . . (For I know that there is.)” Bowen’s fiction conveys the existence of this something, which some would call God, others simply the source of being. Whatever it is called, it exists within each individual and in the natural world. Its primary nature is love, expressed in acts of kindness, sympathy, understanding, and tolerance. It is the potential for unity among people and harmony with the world. This potential is mirrored in the unity and harmony of Bowen’s stories. The lyric descriptive passages, the coherence of matter and form, the intense visual images, and the emotional force of her stories demonstrate Bowen’s mastery of the short-story form. Her stories deserve to be recognized as among the best written in the twentieth century. James L. Green With updates by George O’Brien Other major works children’s literature: The Good Tiger, 1965. play: Castle Anna, pr. 1948 (with John Perry). novels: The Hotel, 1927; The Last September, 1929; Friends and Relations, 1931; To the North, 1932; The House in Paris, 1935; The Death of the Heart, 1938; The Heat of the Day, 1949; A World of Love, 1955; The Little Girls, 1964; Eva Trout, 1968. nonfiction: Bowen’s Court, 1942; Seven Winters, 1942; English Novelists, 1946; Collected Impressions, 1950; The Shelbourne: A Center of Dublin Life for More than a Century, 1951; A Time in Rome, 1960; Afterthought: Pieces About Writing, 1962; Pictures and Conversations, 1975; The Mulberry Tree: Writings of Elizabeth Bowen, 1986. Bibliography Austin, Allan E. Elizabeth Bowen. Rev. ed. New York: Twayne, 1989. Austin contends Bowen’s better stories investigate psychological states that are more unusual than those in her novels. He calls “The Demon Lover” a ghost story that builds up and culminates like an Alfred Hitchcock movie.
142
Short Story Writers
Bloom, Harold, ed. Elizabeth Bowen: Modern Critical Views. New York: Chelsea House, 1987. Collection of eleven essays, surveying the range of Bowen criticism. Excerpts from the main book-length critical works on Bowen are included. The volume also contains some comparatively inaccessible articles on Bowen’s short fiction, and essays on her work by the poets Mona Van Duyn and Alfred Corn. Supplemented by an extensive bibliography. Craig, Patricia. Elizabeth Bowen. Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England: Penguin Books, 1986. Short biographical study. Indebted to Victoria Glendinning’s work, though drawing on later research, particularly on Bowen’s Irish connections. The work also contains perceptive readings of Bowen’s stories and novels. Includes a useful chronology. Hoogland, Renée C. Elizabeth Bowen: A Reputation in Writing. New York: New York University Press, 1994. Another good source. From the series The Cutting Edge: Lesbian Life and Literature. Jarrett, Mary. “Ambiguous Ghosts: The Short Stories of Elizabeth Bowen.” Journal of the Short Story in English, no. 8 (Spring, 1987): 71-79. A discussion of the themes of alienation, imprisonment, loss of identity, and the conflict of fiction and reality in Bowen’s stories, focusing primarily on the so-called ghost stories. Lassner, Phyllis. Elizabeth Bowen: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1991. Introduction to Bowen’s short fiction focusing on its unique characteristics. Deals with the basic conflicts in the stories between the present and the past, often embodied in female ghosts and ancestral homes. Interprets many of her stories in terms of women’s struggle with a patriarchal society that stands in the way of their pursuit of a creative life. Includes essays on short fiction by Bowen and discussions of her stories by William Trevor and Eudora Welty. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Bowen: “The Demon Lover” (vol. 2); “The Happy Autumn Fields” and “Her Table Spread” (vol. 3); “Ivy Gripped the Steps” (vol. 4); “Mysterious Kôr” (vol. 5); “A Queer Heart” (vol. 6); and “Summer Night” and “Tears, Idle Tears” (vol. 7). Partridge, A. C. “Language and Identity in the Shorter Fiction of Elizabeth Bowen.” In Irish Writers and Society at Large, edited by Masaru Sekine. Totowa, N.J.: Barnes & Noble Books, 1985. Overview of Bowen’s short stories that focuses on her impressionism, her economy, and her Jamesian approach to narrative. Illustrates that style is Bowen’s overriding preoccupation. Rubens, Robert. “Elizabeth Bowen: A Woman of Wisdom.” Contemporary Review 268 (June, 1996): 304-307. Examines the complex style of Bowen’s work as a reflection of her personality and background; discusses her romanticism and her rejection of the dehumanization of the twentieth century. Walshe, Eibhear, ed. Elizabeth Bowen Remembered. Dublin: Four Courts Press, 1998. Brief biography that includes helpful bibliographical references.
143
Kay Boyle Born: St. Paul, Minnesota; February 19, 1902 Died: Mill Valley, California; December 27, 1992 Principal short fiction • Short Stories, 1929; Wedding Day, and Other Stories, 1930; The First Lover, and Other Stories, 1933; The White Horses of Vienna, and Other Stories, 1936; The Crazy Hunter, and Other Stories, 1940; Thirty Stories, 1946; The Smoking Mountain: Stories of Postwar Germany, 1951; Nothing Ever Breaks Except the Heart, 1966; Fifty Stories, 1980; Life Being the Best, and Other Stories, 1988. Other literary forms • In addition to her short stories, Kay Boyle published several novels, volumes of poetry, children’s books, essay collections, and a book of memoirs. Breaking the Silence: Why a Mother Tells Her Son About the Nazi Era (1962) is her personal account, written for adolescents, of Europe during the Nazi regime. Boyle also ghostwrote, translated, and edited many other books. Hundreds of her stories, poems, and articles have appeared in periodicals ranging from the “little magazines” published in Paris in the 1920’s to The Saturday Evening Post and The New Yorker, for which she was a correspondent from 1946 to 1953. Achievements • Both prolific and versatile, Kay Boyle has been respected during her long career for her exquisite technical style and her ardent political activism. She was very much a part of the expatriate group of writers living in Paris in the 1920’s, and her work appeared in the avant-garde magazines alongside that of James Joyce, Gertrude Stein, Ernest Hemingway, and others. Her work is in many ways typical of the period, stylistically terse, carefully crafted, displaying keen psychological insight through the use of stream of consciousness and complex interior monologues. That her work was highly regarded is evidenced by her many awards: two John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowships; O. Henry Awards in both 1935 and 1961; an honorary doctorate from Columbia College, Chicago; and membership in the National Institute of Arts and Letters. She taught at San Francisco State University and Eastern Washington University. Biography • Born into an affluent family in St. Paul, Minnesota, in 1902, Kay Boyle moved and traveled frequently and extensively with her family during her childhood. After studying architecture for two years in Cincinnati, Boyle married Robert Brault, whose family never accepted her or the marriage. What was to have been a summer trip to France in 1923 became an eighteen-year expatriation, during which Boyle continued to write poetry and fiction. Boyle left her husband to live with editor Ernest Walsh until his death from tuberculosis in 1926. Boyle later returned to Brault with Walsh’s child. They divorced in 1932, when she married Laurence Vail, a fellow American expatriate. After her marriage to Vail also ended in divorce, Boyle married Joseph von Franckenstein, an Austrian baron who had been forced out of his homeland during the Nazi invasion. She lived much of the time in Europe and was a correspondent for The New Yorker. She returned to the United States in 1953; Franckenstein died in 1963. Boyle taught at San Francisco State University from 1963 to 1979 and
144
Short Story Writers at Eastern Washington University in 1982. Her arrest and imprisonment following an anti-Vietnam War demonstration is the basis of her novel The Underground Woman (1975). She would remain actively involved in movements protesting social injustices and violations of human rights.
Analysis • In a 1963 article Kay Boyle defines what she saw as the role of the serious writer: to be “the spokesman for those who remain inarticulate . . . an aeolian harp whose sensitive strings respond to the whispers of the concerned people of his time.” The short-story writer, she believed, is “a moralist in the highest sense of the word”; the role of the shortstory writer has always been “to speak briefly and clearly of the Library of Congress dignity and integrity of [the] individual.” Perhaps it is through this definition that the reader may distinguish the central threads that run through the variegated fabric of Boyle’s fiction and bind it into a single piece. During the 1920’s, when the young expatriate artists she knew in Paris were struggling to cast off the yokes of literary convention, Boyle championed the bold and experimental in language, and her own early stories are intensely individual explorations of private experiences. Yet when the pressures of the social world came to bear so heavily on private lives in the twentieth century that they could not be ignored, Boyle began to expand the scope of her vision and vibrate to the note of the new times to affirm on a broader scale the same basic values—the “dignity and integrity” of the individual. Beginning in the 1930’s, her subject matter encompassed the rise of Nazism, the French resistance, the Allied occupation of postwar Germany, and the civil rights and anti-Vietnam War movements in the United States, yet she never lost sight of the individual dramas acted out against these panoramic backdrops. In the same article Boyle also quotes Albert Camus’s statement that “a man’s work is nothing but a long journey to recover through the detours of art, the two or three simple and great images which first gained access to his heart.” In Boyle’s journey of more than fifty years, a few central themes remained constant: a belief in the absolute essentiality of love to human well-being—whether on a personal or a global level; an awareness of the many obstacles to its attainment; and a tragic sense of loss when it fails and the gulfs between human beings stand unbridged. “Wedding Day” • “Wedding Day,” the title story of her first widely circulated volume of short stories, published in 1930, is typical of her early works. It is an intense explo-
Boyle, Kay
145
ration of a unique private experience written in an experimental style. The action is primarily psychological, and outward events are described as they reflect states of consciousness. Yet it is representative of Boyle’s best work for decades to come, both in its central concern with the failure of love and in its bold use of language. “The red carpet that was to spurt like a hemorrhage from pillar to post was stacked in the corner,” the story begins. From the first sentence the reader senses that things are out of joint. The wedding cake is ignored as it is carried into the pantry “with its beard lying white as hoarfrost on its bosom.” “This was the last lunch,” Boyle writes, and the brother and sister “came in with their buttonholes drooping with violets and sat sadly down, sat down to eat.” To the funereal atmosphere of this wedding day, Boyle injects tension and bitterness. The son and mother argue as to whether the daughter will be given the family’s prized copper saucepans, and he mocks the decorum his mother cherishes when he commands her not to cry, pointing his finger directly at her nose “so that when she looked at him with dignity her eyes wavered and crossed” and “she sat looking proudly at him, erect as a needle staring through its one open eye.” As the mother and son bicker over who wanted the wedding in the first place, the bride-to-be is conspicuously silent. Finally, as the son snatches away each slice of roast beef his mother carves until she whimpers her fear of getting none herself, he and his sister burst into laughter. He tosses his napkin over the chandelier, and she follows him out of the room, leaving their mother alone “praying that this occasion at least pass off with dignity, with her heart not in her mouth but beating away in peace in its own bosom.” With the tension between children and mother clearly delineated and the exclusive camaraderie between brother and sister suggested, Boyle shifts both mood and scene and describes in almost incantatory prose the pair’s idyllic jaunt through the spring afternoon in the hours remaining before the wedding: The sun was an imposition, an imposition, for they were another race stamping an easy trail through the wilderness of Paris, possessed of the same people, but of themselves like another race. No one else could by lifting of the head only be starting life over again, and it was a wonder the whole city of Paris did not hold its breath for them, for if anyone could have begun a new race, it was these two. The incestuous overtones are strong. “It isn’t too late yet, you know,” the brother repeatedly insists as they stride through the streets, take a train into the bois, and row to the middle of a pond. “Over them was the sky set like a tomb,” and as tears flow down their cheeks, the slow rain begins to fall. There is perfect correspondence between landscape and emotion, external objects mirroring the characters’ internal states. The rain underscores the pair’s frustration and despair as they realize the intensity of their love and the impossibility of its fulfillment: Everywhere, everywhere there were other countries to go to. And how were they to get from the boat with the chains that were on them, how uproot the willowing trees from their hearts, how strike the irons of spring that shackled them? What shame and shame that scorched a burning pathway to their dressing rooms! Their hearts were mourning for every Paris night and its half-hours before lunch when two straws crossed on the round table top on the marble anywhere meant I had a drink here and went on. The inevitable wedding itself forms the final segment of the story, and the lyrical spell binding the pair is broken the instant they set foot in the house again to find
146
Short Story Writers
their mother “tying white satin bows under the chins of the potted plants.” The boy kicks down the hall the silver tray that will collect the guests’ calling cards, and his mother is wearily certain “that this outburst presaged a thousand mishaps that were yet to come.” The irony of the story lies not only in the reversal of expectations the title may have aroused in the reader but also in the discrepancy between different characters’ perceptions of the same situation. The self-pitying matron worries only about the thousand little mishaps possible when a major disaster—the wedding itself—is imminent; but the guests arrive “in peace” and the brother delivers his sister to the altar. Boyle captures magnificently the enormous gulf between the placid surface appearance and the tumultuous inner reality of the situation as she takes the reader inside the bride’s consciousness: This was the end, the end, they thought. She turned her face to her brother and suddenly their hearts fled together and sobbed like ringdoves in their bosoms. This was the end, the end, the end, this was the end. Down the room their feet fled in various ways, seeking an escape. To the edge of the carpet fled her feet, returned and followed reluctantly upon her brother’s heels. Every piped note of the organ insisted that she go on. It isn’t too late, he said. Too late, too late. The ring was given, the book was closed. The desolate, the barren sky continued to fling down dripping handfuls of fresh rain. The mindless repetition of the phrase “the end” and the blind panic of the bride’s imaginary flight have an intense psychological authenticity, and the recurrence of the brother’s phrase “It isn’t too late” and its perversion in “Too late, too late,” along with the continuing rain, are evidence of the skill with which Boyle has woven motifs into the fabric of her story. “Wedding Day” ends with dancing, but in an ironic counterpoint to the flight she had imagined at the altar, the bride’s feet “were fleeing in a hundred ways throughout the rooms, fluttering from the punch bowl to her bedroom and back again.” Through repetition and transformation of the image, Boyle underscores the fact that her path is now circumscribed. While the brother, limbered by the punch, dances about scattering calling cards, the mother, “in triumph on the arm of the General, danced lightly by” rejoicing that “no glass had yet been broken.” “What a real success, what a real success,” is her only thought as her feet float “over the oriental prayer rugs, through the Persian forests of hemp, away and away” in another absurdly circumscribed “escape” that is yet another mockery of the escape to “other countries” that the pair had dreamed of that afternoon on the lake. Ironies and incongruities are hallmarks of Kay Boyle’s fiction. For Boyle, reality depends on perception, and the fact that different perceptions of the same situation result in disparate and often conflicting “realities” creates a disturbing world in which individuals badly in need of contact and connection collide and bounce off one another like atoms. In “Wedding Day” Boyle juxtaposes a real loss of love with the surface gaiety of a wedding that celebrates no love at all, but which the mother terms “a real success.” She exposes the painful isolation of each individual and the tragedy that the only remedy—a bonding through love—is so often thwarted or destroyed. The barriers to love are many, both natural and man-made. In some of Boyle’s stories those who would love are severed by death. Sometimes, as in the case of the brother and sister in “Wedding Day,” love’s fulfillment is simply made impossible by the facts of life in this imperfect world, and although readers can mourn for what has
Boyle, Kay
147
been lost, they can hardly argue about the obstacle itself—the incest taboo is nearly universal. Yet in many of her works Boyle presents a more assailable villain. In “Wedding Day” she treats unsympathetically the mother, who stands for all the petty proprieties that so often separate people. Boyle finds many barriers to human contact to be as arbitrary and immoral as the social conventions which cause Huck Finn’s “conscience” to torment him as he helps his friend Jim to escape slavery, and in her fiction she quietly unleashes her fury against them. An obstacle she attacks repeatedly is a narrow-mindedness which blinds individuals to the inherent dignity and integrity of others, an egotism which in the plural becomes bigotry and chauvinism. “The White Horses of Vienna” • While Boyle and her family were living in Austria in the 1930’s, she was an eyewitness as the social world began to impose itself on private lives, and she began to widen the scope of her artistic vision; yet her “political” stories have as their central concern the ways in which external events affect the individual. In one of her best-known stories, “The White Horses of Vienna,” which won the O. Henry Award for best story of 1935, Boyle exposes the artificial barricades to human understanding and connection. The story explores the relationship between a Tyrolean doctor, who has injured his leg coming down the mountain after lighting a swastika fire in rebellion against the current government, and Dr. Heine, the young assistant sent from Vienna to take over his patients while he recovers. The Tyrolean doctor and his wife see immediately that Dr. Heine is a Jew. The Tyrolean doctor is a clean-living, respected man. He had been a prisoner of war in Siberia and had studied abroad, but the many places in which he had been “had never left an evil mark.” Boyle writes: “His face was as strong as rock, but it had seen so much of suffering that it had the look of being scarred, it seemed to be split in two, with one side of it given to resolve and the other to compassion.” In his personal dealings it is the compassionate side that dominates. When his wife asks in a desperate whisper what they will do with “him,” the Tyrolean doctor replies simply that they will send for his bag at the station and give him some Apfelsaft if he is thirsty. “It’s harder on him than us,” he tells her. Neither has the wife’s own humanity been extinguished entirely by institutionalized bigotry, for when Dr. Heine’s coat catches fire from a sterilizing lamp on the table, she wraps a piece of rug around him immediately and holds him tightly to smother the flames. Almost instinctively, she offers to try patching the burned-out place, but then she suddenly bites her lip and stands back “as if she had remembered the evil thing that stood between them.” The situation of the Tyrolean doctor, described as a “great, golden, wounded bird,” is counterpointed in a story Dr. Heine tells at dinner one evening about the famous Lipizzaner horses of the Spanish Riding School in Vienna, still royal, “without any royalty left to bow their heads to, still shouldering into the arena with spirits a man would give his soul for, bending their knees in homage to the empty, canopied loge where royalty no longer sat.” He tells of a particular horse that the government, badly in need of money, had sold to an Indian maharaja. When the time had come for the horse to be taken away, a wound was discovered cut in his leg. After it had healed and it was again time for the horse to leave, another wound was found on its other leg. Finally the horse’s blood was so poisoned that it had to be destroyed. No one knew who had caused the wounds until the horse’s devoted little groom committed suicide that same day. When the after-dinner conversation is interrupted by the knocking of Heimwehr troops at the door, “men brought in from other parts of the country, billeted there to subdue the native people,” the identification between the
148
Short Story Writers
doctor and the steed is underscored. He cannot guide the troops up the mountain in search of those who have lit that evening’s swastika fires because of his wounded leg. Dr. Heine is relieved that the rest of the evening will be spent with family and friends watching one of the Tyrolean doctor’s locally renowned marionette shows. After staring out the window at the burning swastikas, the “marvelously living flowers of fire springing out of the arid darkness,” the “inexplicable signals given from one mountain to another in some secret gathering of power that cast him and his people out, forever out upon the waters of despair,” Dr. Heine turns back, suddenly angry, and proclaims that the whole country is being ruined by politics, that it is impossible to have friends or even casual conversations on any other basis these days. “You’re much wiser to make your puppets, Herr Doktor,” he says. Even the marionette show is political. The characters are a clown who explains he is carrying artificial flowers because he is on his way to his own funeral and wants them to be fresh when he gets there, and a handsome grasshopper, “a great, gleaming beauty” who prances about the stage with delicacy and wit to the music of Mozart. “It’s really marvellous! He’s as graceful as the white horses at Vienna, Herr Doktor,” Dr. Heine calls out in delight. As the conversation continues between the clown, called “Chancellor,” and the grasshopper addressed as “The Leader,” Dr. Heine is not laughing so loudly. The Chancellor has a “ludicrous faith in the power of the Church” to support him; the Leader proclaims that the cities are full of churches, but “the country is full of God.” The Leader speaks with “a wild and stirring power that sent the cold of wonder up and down one’s spine,” and he seems “ready to waltz away at any moment with the power of stallion life that was leaping in his limbs.” As the Chancellor proclaims, “I believe in the independence of the individual,” he promptly trips over his own sword and falls flat among the daisies. At the story’s conclusion, Dr. Heine is standing alone on the cold mountainside, longing to be “indoors, with the warmth of his own people, and the intellect speaking.” When he sees “a small necklace of men coming to him” up the mountain, the lights they bear “coming like little beacons of hope carried to him,” Dr. Heine thinks, Come to me . . . come to me. I am a young man alone on a mountain. I am a young man alone, as my race is alone, lost here amongst them all. Yet ironically, what Dr. Heine views as “beacons of hope” are carried by the Heimwehr troops, the Tyrolean doctor’s enemies. As in “Wedding Day,” Boyle presents a single situation and plays off the characters’ reactions to it against one another to illustrate the gaps between individuals and the relativity of truth and reality in the world. Because his personal loyalties transcend his politics, Dr. Heine rushes to warn the family of the Heimwehr’s approach. When the troops arrive they announce that the Austrian chancellor, Dollfuss, had been assassinated in Vienna that afternoon. They have come to arrest the doctor, whose rebel sympathies are known. “Ah, politics, politics again!” cries Dr. Heine, wringing his hands “like a woman about to cry.” He runs outdoors and takes the doctor’s hand as he is being carried away on a stretcher, asking what he can do to help. “You can throw me peaches and chocolate from the street,” replies the Tyrolean doctor, smiling, “his cheeks scarred with the marks of laughter in the light from the hurricane lamps that the men were carrying down.” His wife is not a good shot, he adds, and he missed all the oranges she had thrown him after the February slaughter. At this image of the Tyrolean doctor caged like an animal but still noble, with his spirit still unbroken, Dr. Heine is left “thinking in anguish of the snow-white horses, the Lipizzaners, the relics of pride, the still unbroken
Boyle, Kay
149
vestiges of beauty bending their knees to the empty loge of royalty where there was no royalty any more.” In “The White Horses of Vienna,” Boyle expresses hope, if not faith, that even in the face of divisive social forces, the basic connections of compassion between individuals might survive. In a work that is a testament to her humanity, she presents the Tyrolean doctor’s plight with such sensitivity that readers, like the Jewish assistant, are forced to view with understanding and empathy this proud man’s search for a cause that will redeem the dignity and honor of his wounded people while at the same time abhorring the cause itself. Boyle sees and presents in all its human complexity what at first glance seems a black-and-white political issue. Boyle, however, was no Pollyanna. As the social conflict that motivates this story snowballed into world war and mass genocide, she saw with a cold, realistic eye how little survived of the goodwill among human beings she had hoped for. In many of her stories written in the 1940’s and up to her death, she examined unflinchingly and sometimes bitterly the individual tragedies played out in the shadow of the global one. “Winter Night” • In “Winter Night,” published in 1946, she draws a delicate portrait of a little girl named Felicia and a woman sent by a “sitting parent” agency to spend the evening with her in a New York apartment. The woman, in her strange accent, tells Felicia that today is an anniversary, that three years ago that night she had begun to care for another little girl who also studied ballet and whose mother, like Felicia’s, had had to go away. The difference was that the other girl’s mother had been sent away on a train car in which there were no seats, and she never came back, but she was able to write a short letter on a smuggled scrap of paper and slip it through the cracks on the floor of the moving train in the hope that some kind stranger would send it to its destination. The woman can only comfort herself with the thought that “They must be quietly asleep somewhere, and not crying all night because they are hungry and because they are cold.” “There is a time of apprehension which begins with the beginning of darkness, and to which only the speech of love can lend security,” the story begins, as Boyle describes the dying light of a January afternoon in New York City. Felicia and the “sitting parent,” both left alone, have found that security in each other. When, after midnight, Felicia’s mother tiptoes in the front door, slipping the three blue foxskins from her shoulder and dropping the velvet bag on a chair, she hears only the sound of breathing in the dark living room, and no one speaks to her in greeting as she crosses to the bedroom: “And then, as startling as a slap across her delicately tinted face, she saw the woman lying sleeping on the divan, and Felicia, in her school dress still, asleep within the woman’s arms.” The story is not baldly didactic, but Boyle is moralizing. By juxtaposing the cases of the two little girls left alone by their mothers and cared for by a stranger, she shows that the failure of love is a tragic loss on an individual as well as on a global scale. Again, personal concerns merge with political and social ones, and readers find the failure of love on any level to be the fundamental tragedy of life. Some of the stories Boyle wrote about the war and its aftermath were less subtle, “artistic” explorations of individual struggles than they were frankly moralistic adventure stories written for commercial magazines, and they were more popular with the public than with the critics. Yet one of her finest works was also a product of her war experiences. The Smoking Mountain: Stories of Postwar Germany (1951) consists of eleven stories, several originally published by The New Yorker, which had employed
150
Short Story Writers
Boyle as a correspondent for the express purpose of sending “fiction out of Germany.” It is prefaced by a seventy-seven-page nonfiction account of a de-Nazification trial Boyle witnessed in Frankfurt in 1948, which reveals her immense skill as a reporter as well. The book presents a painful vision. Any hope that a renewed understanding among peoples might result from the catastrophic “lesson” of the war is dashed, for the point of many of the stories and certainly of the introduction is how little difference the war has made in the fundamental attitudes of the defeated but silently defiant Germans who can still say of 1943 and 1944—“the years when the gas chambers burned the brightest. . . .Those were the good years for everyone.” In 1929, Boyle, with poet Hart Crane, Vail, and others, signed Eugene Jolas’s manifesto, “Revolution of the Word,” condemning literary pretentiousness and outdated literary conventions. The goal, then, was to make literature at once fresh and experimental and at the same time accessible to the reader. Boyle would remain politically involved and productive as a writer, publishing collections of poetry, short stories, and essays in the 1980’s. She would continue in her work to test the individual against events of historical significance, such as the threat of Nazism or the war in Vietnam. Although critics have accused her later works of selling out to popular taste, and her style of losing its innovative edge, Boyle remained steadfast in defining her artistic purpose as a moral responsibility to defend the integrity of the individual and human rights. To do so, Boyle argued, she must be accessible to the public. Sandra Whipple Spanier With updates by Lou Thompson Other major works children’s literature: The Youngest Camel, 1939, 1959; Pinky, the Cat Who Liked to Sleep, 1966; Pinky in Persia, 1968. anthologies: 365 Days, 1936 (with others); The Autobiography of Emanuel Carnevali, 1967; Enough of Dying! An Anthology of Peace Writings, 1972 (with Justine van Gundy). novels: Process, wr. c. 1925, pb. 2001 (Sandra Spanier, editor); Plagued by the Nightingale, 1931; Year Before Last, 1932; Gentlemen, I Address You Privately, 1933; My Next Bride, 1934; Death of a Man, 1936; Monday Night, 1938; Primer for Combat, 1942; Avalanche, 1944; A Frenchman Must Die, 1946; 1939, 1948; His Human Majesty, 1949; The Seagull on the Step, 1955; Three Short Novels, 1958; Generation Without Farewell, 1960; The Underground Woman, 1975. nonfiction: Breaking the Silence: Why a Mother Tells Her Son About the Nazi Era, 1962; Being Geniuses Together, 1920-1930, 1968 (with Robert McAlmon); The Long Walk at San Francisco State, and Other Essays, 1970; Words That Must Somehow Be Said: The Selected Essays of Kay Boyle, 1927-1984, 1985. poetry: A Glad Day, 1938; American Citizen Naturalized in Leadville, Colorado, 1944; Collected Poems, 1962; Testament for My Students, and Other Poems, 1970; This Is Not a Letter, and Other Poems, 1985; Collected Poems of Kay Boyle, 1991. Bibliography Bell, Elizabeth S. Kay Boyle: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Excellent introduction to Boyle’s short stories. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Carpenter, Richard C. “Kay Boyle.” English Journal 42 (November, 1953): 425-430.
Boyle, Kay
151
This essay provides a helpful and general look at Boyle’s early novels and short fiction. ____________. “Kay Boyle: The Figure in the Carpet.” Critique: Studies in Modern Fiction 7 (Winter, 1964-1965): 65-78. Carpenter rejects the common complaint that Boyle is a mere “stylist,” discussing her thematic depth, particularly in “The Bridegroom’s Body” and “The Crazy Hunter.” Elkins, Marilyn, ed. Critical Essays on Kay Boyle. New York: G. K. Hall, 1997. Collection of reviews and critical essays on Boyle’s work by various critics, reviewers, and commentators. Hollenberg, Donna. “Abortion, Identity Formation, and the Expatriate Woman Writer: H. D. and Kay Boyle in the Twenties.” Twentieth Century Literature 40 (Winter, 1994): 499-517. Discusses the theme of self-loss through the roles of marriage and motherhood in Boyle’s early works. Shows how expatriation allowed some psychic space to explore the effect of gender roles on her aspirations. Discusses the effect of inadequate maternal role models her identity as an artist. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Boyle: “Astronomer’s Wife” (vol. 1), “Summer Evening” (vol. 7), and “The White Horses of Vienna” and “Winter Night” (vol. 8). Mellen, Joan. Kay Boyle: Author of Herself. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1994. Drawing on personal conversations with Boyle and her family, Mellen discusses the autobiographical nature of Boyle’s writing and lays bare much of Boyle’s own mythologizing of her life in her autobiographical writing. Porter, Katherine Anne. “Kay Boyle: Example to the Young.” In The Critic as Artist: Essays on Books, 1920-1970, edited by Gilbert A. Harrison. New York: Liveright, 1972. This essay examines Boyle as she fits in the literary movement of her time. Focuses on some of her stories, as well as on the novel Plagued by the Nightingale. Spanier, Sandra Whipple. Kay Boyle: Artist and Activist. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1986. Heavily annotated, thorough, and the first critical biography and major work on Boyle. Supplemented by select but extensive primary and secondary bibliographies. Illustrated. Twentieth-Century Literature 34 (Fall, 1988). A special issue on Kay Boyle, with personal reminiscences by Malcolm Cowley, Jessica Mitford, Howard Nemerov, and Studs Terkel, among others. Also contains several critical essays on Boyle’s work.
152
T. Coraghessan Boyle Born: Peekskill, New York; December 2, 1948 Principal short fiction • Descent of Man, 1979; Greasy Lake, and Other Stories, 1985; If the River Was Whiskey, 1989; Without a Hero, 1994; T. C. Boyle Stories: The Collected Stories of T. Coraghessan Boyle, 1998; After the Plague: Stories, 2001; Tooth and Claw, 2005; The Human Fly, and Other Stories, 2005. Other literary forms • T. Coraghessan Boyle is primarily a writer of prose fiction who has divided his energy roughly equally between short stories and novels. His novels explore many of the same subjects and themes as his short fiction and have received both popular attention and critical praise. He published his first novel, Water Music, in 1981, followed by two more during the 1980’s, four during the 1990’s, and three during the first years of the twenty-first century: Drop City (2003), The Inner Circle (2004), and Talk Talke (2006). His 1993 novel, The Road to Wellville, was made into a motion picture in 1994. Achievements • T. Coraghessan Boyle received a National Endowment for the Arts Fellowship in 1977. Descent of Man, his first collection of stories, won the St. Lawrence Award for Short Fiction. His novel Water Music (1981) received the Aga Khan Award, and another novel, World’s End (1987), was awarded the PEN/Faulkner Award for Fiction. Boyle also received O. Henry Awards for “Sinking House” (1988), “The Ape Lady in Retirement” (1989), “The Underground Gardens” (1999), “The Love of My Life” (2001), and “Swept Away” (2003). T. C. Boyle Stories: The Collected Stories of T. Coraghessan Boyle (1998) won the Bernard Malamud Prize in Short Fiction from the PEN/Faulkner Foundation. In 2003, he was a National Book Award finalist for Drop City. In 2004, “Tooth and Claw” was a Best American Stories selection. Biography • Born into a lower-middle-class family in Peekskill, New York, in 1948, Thomas John Boyle was a rebellious youth who performed in a rock-and-roll band, committed acts of vandalism, and drank heavily. He did not get along with his father, a school-bus driver who died of alcoholism at the age of fifty-four, in 1972. Boyle’s mother, a secretary, was also an alcoholic and died of liver failure. Assuming the name T. Coraghessan Boyle at the State University of New York at Potsdam, he studied saxophone and clarinet until he realized that he lacked the necessary discipline for music. He then drifted into literature. After college, to avoid military service during the Vietnam War, he taught English for two years at his alma mater, Lakeland High School, in Shrub Oak, New York, while indulging in heroin on weekends. In 1972, Boyle entered the creative writing program at the University of Iowa, where he studied under Vance Bourjaily, John Cheever, and John Irving, earning a doctorate in 1977, with a short-story collection, later published as Descent of Man, serving as his dissertation. Such academic achievement is ironic for someone placed in a class for slow learners in the second grade. Boyle became a teacher at the University of Southern California, where he founded an undergraduate creative writing program, and settled in Woodland Hills with his wife, Karen Kvashay, and their chil-
Boyle, T. Coraghessan
153
dren, Kerrie, Milo, and Spencer. One of the most public and flamboyant writers of his time, Boyle delighted in performing public and recorded readings. Analysis • During a time when the majority of serious American writers have been concerned with the minutiae of everyday life, T. Coraghessan Boyle has stood out by exploring a wide range of subjects, locales, periods, and strata of society. Distinctive as a stylist, storyteller, and satirist, Boyle enthusiastically encompasses numerous literary conventions into his fiction, turning them into something fresh and often humorous. He examines both the detritus and the silliness of the world, exulting in its absurdities. Boyle’s short fiction is most notaCourtesy, Allen and Unwin ble for its extraordinary range of subjects, which include a chimpanzee who has translated works by Charles Darwin, Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche, and Noam Chomsky into Yerkish; the final performance of blues musician Robert Johnson; the importation of starlings into the United States; an attempt to improve the public image of the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini; and a statue of the Virgin Mary that re-creates a man’s sins for all the world to see. Boyle’s stories delve into such topics as violence, sexuality, paranoia, guilt, and the clichés of popular culture. Although some of his stories are realistic, most exaggerate the world’s absurdities for comic effect. His tone is predominantly satirical but rarely angry. “Bloodfall” • “Bloodfall” depicts the effects of an apparently endless rainfall of blood on seven young adults who live together. Although they smoke marijuana, burn incense, and listen to thunderously loud rock and roll, they are not hippies but well-to-do materialists who use electric toothbrushes and drive BMWs. They sleep together in a bed that they appropriately think of as “the nest,” since they have attempted to withdraw from the often disconcerting realities of the outside world, seeking comfortable refuge in their home. The inexplicable rain of blood cuts them off completely from the rest of the world by knocking out their telephone and television. They cannot drive to get food since they cannot see through a blood-smeared windshield. Their response to this terrifying situation is to ignore it: “Isabelle said it would be better if we all went to bed. She expressed a hope that after a long nap things would somehow come to their senses.” The blood begins to stain everything about their antiseptic existence: their white clothing when they venture outside, their white carpet when the flood begins to seep under their door. They are confident that the bloodfall will stop, since logic demands that it will, and it does. Since such an event is illogical to begin with, however,
154
Short Story Writers
“Bloodfall” ends with the start of a new downpour, this time consisting of “heavy, feculent, and wet” fecal matter. Boyle often satirizes modern human beings’ feeble efforts to protect themselves from outside forces, as in “Peace of Mind,” an attack on home security systems, but the image of the blood invading the white world of these smug materialists is his strongest statement on this theme. Boyle’s vividly contrasting images of red and white and his telling accumulation of the trite details of the lives of contemporary American consumers contribute to the story’s effectiveness. As throughout his fiction, Boyle borrows from the conventions of popular culture, in this case horror fiction and films, to create a compelling vision of modern alienation. “The Big Garage” • “The Big Garage” is a frightening but comic horror story. When the Audi belonging to B. breaks down, a tow truck mysteriously appears and takes it to Tegeler’s Big Garage, an enormous service center in the middle of nowhere. Because it is late at night and no mechanics are available, B. is forced to sleep on a cot in a storage closet where other customers are also waiting for their vehicles to be repaired. B. discovers that he must go through a complicated maze to the appointment office and fill out a seven-page application for an appointment to have his car serviced. Fed up with this nonsense, B. confronts a team of German mechanics who taunt him and throw him down a chute into the car wash, where he is washed and waxed. After trying and failing to escape by hitchhiking, B. gives in and goes across the street to Tegeler’s Big Lot, where the owner of the Big Garage sells his broken customers Tegelers, his own inferior make. B. is caught up in a bureaucratic nightmare out of a Franz Kafka novel, such as Der Prozess (1925; The Trial, 1937). Boyle takes a familiar situation and exaggerates it to show how everyday life can become an impersonal, nerve-racking, humiliating experience. He makes a serious statement about alienation and the often vicious insensitivity of a consumer culture while also having fun through slapstick and literary parody. “The Overcoat II” • Boyle combines homage to a favorite work of literature with political satire in “The Overcoat II,” an updating of Nikolai Gogol’s “Shinel” (1839; in The Overcoat, and Other Stories, 1923) to the Moscow of the 1980’s. Akaky Akakievich Bashmachkin, a devoted clerk in the Soviet bureaucracy, has no interests outside his work, no time for anything but waiting in endless queues for scarce goods. Yet the only blemish on his party-line life is the cheap, tattered overcoat he has bought because a central department store clerk, attacking the quality of Soviet-made products, tried to sell him a black-market overcoat. Akaky is ridiculed by his unpatriotic coworkers because he appears to use the coat to give himself the aura of a Marxist saint. Old Studniuk, one of the fourteen residents who share his apartment, tells Akaky he must use the black market to get everything he can: “There ain’t no comrade commissioner going to come round and give it to you.” Akaky sells his television set and exhausts his savings to spend three months’ salary on a camel’s hair overcoat with a fox collar. His fellow clerks are impressed, and one, Mishkin, invites Akaky to his home. After leaving Mishkin’s house, where he had one of the best times of his life, he is beaten and his coat stolen. The police recover the coat but keep it and fine Akaky for receiving stolen goods. Feeling betrayed by all he has believed in, Akaky develops pneumonia, dies, and is soon forgotten. The police inspector who has interrogated him wears the coat proudly.
Boyle, T. Coraghessan
155
Like “Ike and Nina,” in which President Dwight D. Eisenhower and Premier Nikita S. Khrushchev’s wife have an affair in 1959, “The Overcoat II” satirizes Soviet life. Gogol’s Akaky dies from the despair of losing his beloved coat, Boyle’s from losing his belief in the Soviet system, something even more irreplaceable. Gogol ends his story with Akaky’s ghost seeking revenge against those who have wronged him, Boyle’s with an enemy profiting from the clerk’s naïve belief in a system that exploits him. The happiness that Akaky experiences at Mishkin’s party must be short-lived, for in Boyle’s paranoid universe, some unexpected, uncontrollable force is out to get the individual. Only those as cynical as the society in which they live can survive. “Two Ships” • The uncontrollable force confronting the protagonist of “Two Ships” is his childhood best friend. The teenage Jack and Casper are rebels together, assaulting symbols of wealth and religion. They run away from home, but Jack gives up two weeks before Casper. During this experience, Jack recognizes the streak of madness in his friend and is both repelled by and attracted to it: “He was serious, he was committed, his was the rapture of saints and martyrs, both feet over the line.” Casper’s passion leads him to convert fervently to Marxism. When he is drafted during the Vietnam War, he deserts the Army. Jack does not see Casper for several years after he goes into the Army, but he receives several packages containing lengthy, incoherent poems expressing Casper’s political views. Jack then goes to law school, marries, and settles down. After he receives a telephone call from Casper asking him to stick up for his friend, Jack tells an agent at the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) that Casper is “seriously impaired.” Following eleven months in a mental institution, Casper returns to his hometown, and Jack is frightened. Casper finally visits him but terrifies Jack even further by saying little. Jack begins packing. More than guilt about betraying his friend to the FBI, Jack experiences shame over how their lives have diverged: “I’d become what we’d reacted against together, what he’d devoted his mad, misguided life to subverting.” Jack is disturbed by Casper’s reminding him how he has failed himself through his willingness to play society’s game by its rules, his becoming a corporate attorney who defends polluters, his lack of passion for and commitment to anything but his family, and his failure to accept any responsibility for the state of the world. “Two Ships” effectively blends such major Boyle subjects as paranoia, friendship, and betrayal. His characters are constantly betraying one another and themselves. “The Hector Quesadilla Story” • Although generally satirical and often condemnatory, Boyle’s fiction is not always cynical and unforgiving. “The Hector Quesadilla Story,” one of the best baseball stories ever written, demonstrates the possibility of getting a chance to overcome failure. The title character plays for the Los Angeles Dodgers but only pinch-hits, because he is too old, too fat, and too slow to perform well in the field. (Boyle has loosely based this character on Manny Mota, the legendary pinch hitter for the Dodgers in the 1970’s.) A grandfather whose official baseball age is several years short of actuality, Hector lives only to eat the spicy Mexican food that he passionately loves and to play the game that he loves even more. He keeps telling his wife he will play one more season but secretly has no intention of quitting. Meanwhile, he waits patiently at the end of the bench to prove himself again, to come alive in the only way he knows how. Hector is convinced that something special will happen during a game with the
156
Short Story Writers
Atlanta Braves, whom the Dodgers are battling for first place, because it falls on his birthday. With the score tied in the ninth inning, he is denied his “moment of catharsis,” his chance to win the game. As the contest drags on into extra innings, the manager refuses to let him bat because the Dodgers have run out of players and Hector would have to play in the field if the score remained tied. With his team trailing by one run in the bottom of the thirty-first inning in the longest game in major league history, Hector finally gets his chance but is foolishly thrown out trying to stretch a double into a triple. When the next batter hits a home run, Hector is forced to pitch for the first time because no one else is available. All seems lost when the Braves score four runs off him in the next inning, but Hector redeems himself with a bases-loaded home run to tie the score once again. The game then “goes on forever.” “The Hector Quesadilla Story” works on two levels. On one, it is about the most magical quality of baseball: “How can he get old?” Hector asks himself. “The grass is always green, the lights always shining, no clocks or periods or halves or quarters, no punch-in and punch-out: this is the game that never ends.” Without the restraints of time seen in such games as football and basketball, a baseball game could theoretically last forever. On the second level, the story deals with how the individual feels the limitations that time imposes upon him and how he fights against them. Hector tries to ignore what his body, his family, and common sense tell him. Because a baseball game can go on forever, so can he. He appropriates the magic of the game for himself: “it’s a game of infinite surprises.” Boyle makes baseball a metaphor for life itself. “Sorry Fugu” • The tone of most of Boyle’s stories is primarily comic, and in one of the best, “Sorry Fugu,” he also displays the gentler side of his satire. Albert D’Angelo, owner and chef of D’Angelo’s, wants his new restaurant to be both good and successful. He wants it to meet the challenge of Willa Frank, the restaurant critic who always gives negative reviews, even to those places that Albert reveres. He fears and longs for the day when she and her companion, known only as “the Palate,” will enter his establishment. Luckily, Albert knows when the great moment has arrived, since one of his employees knows Willa and her boyfriend, Jock McNamee. Unfortunately, she has come on one of those nights when all goes wrong, and Albert knows he has failed on the first of her three visits. They arrive the second time with an older couple. Albert is prepared this time, only to see each of them pass the dishes to Jock, who is not interested in any of them. Albert understands what to do on the third visit after his employee tells him that what Jock really likes is the “shanty Irish” food his mother used to make. Albert then ignores what the couple orders and serves the Palate peas, boiled potatoes, a slab of cheap, overcooked meat, and catsup. When the outraged Willa charges into the kitchen, Albert seduces her with squid rings in aioli sauce, lobster tortellini, taglierini alla pizzaiola, Russian coulibiac of salmon, and fugu, a Japanese blowfish. Willa confesses that she relies on Jock’s crude judgment, since at least he is consistent in disliking everything, and that she is afraid to risk a positive review. Although other American writers of Boyle’s generation fill their fiction with brand names and trendy antiques as a means of delineating their characters, Boyle uses food to explore their social status and individuality. What is most important about “Sorry Fugu,” however, is its depiction of the roles of the critic and the artist. Boyle satirizes the superficiality of many critics through Willa’s uncertainty about her tastes and dishonesty in relying on Jock’s lack of taste. Albert is an artist in the
Boyle, T. Coraghessan
157
care he takes in creating his dishes: “Albert put his soul into each dish, arranged and garnished the plates with all the patient care and shimmering inspiration of a Toulouse-Lautrec bent over a canvas.” Boyle takes the same care as a stylist, as when Albert contemplates Willa’s name: “It was a bony name, scant and lean, stripped of sensuality, the antithesis of the round, full-bodied Leonora. It spoke of a knotty Puritan toughness, a denying of the flesh, no compromise in the face of temptation.” Since Boyle has said in interviews that he wants to be both popular and critically praised, Albert appears to be a self-portrait of an artist who needs to be judged by the highest standards. Without a Hero • Boyle continued his eclectic exploration of the absurdities of the world in his short-story collection Without a Hero. “Filthy with Things” tells the humorous yet oddly disturbing story of a married couple suffocating in a world of suburban materialism that has advanced so far beyond their control that they must hire an organizing specialist to kick them out of their own house and take possession of their belongings. As the narrator watches the workers sort through and catalog everything he owns, he feels “as if he doesn’t exist, as if he’s already become an irrelevance in the face of the terrible weight of his possessions,” or, more broadly, of a late twentieth century American culture in which materiality often defines the person. One of the most prominent of Boyle’s many recurring obsessions is his interest in the influence that animals have on human behavior, and vice versa. The narrator of “Carnal Knowledge” gets involved with a group of animal-rights activists when he falls in love with Alena, a militant vegetarian whose crippled dog urinates on him at the beach. After quitting his job to take part in antifur demonstrations in Beverly Hills, the narrator is coerced into taking part in a plot to “liberate” thousands of turkeys from a poultry farm a few weeks before Thanksgiving. The raid does more harm than good, however, when large numbers of turkeys wander onto a fog-enshrouded freeway and cause a truck to jackknife. After being spurned by Alena, who travels north with another man to defend grizzly bears, the protagonist drives by the accident scene, where the road is “coated in feathers, turkey feathers” and where there is “a red pulp ground into the surface of road.” He promptly returns to eating the Big Macs that he has been subconsciously craving for days. Beneath the humor of such stories lies a message to which Boyle often returns: The universe is an ambiguous, unpredictable place, and each person must find his or her own solitary way to negotiate its absurdities. T. C. Boyle Stories • T. C. Boyle Stories: The Collected Stories of T. Coraghessan Boyle is a 691-page volume which includes all the tales from the author’s previous short-story collections, plus four stories previously unpublished in book form and three previously unpublished anywhere, an impressive sixty-eight over a twenty-five-year period. Although reading a complete collection of an author’s work often means plowing through the mediocre to get to the good (and this book is no exception), one benefit is the opportunity to see the development of the writer over time. In Boyle’s case, there is a clear tendency for early stories to be driven more by premise than by character. In stories such as “Bloodfall,” characterization tends to be subordinate to the idea. In subsequent stories, Boyle began demonstrating a willingness to invest more time and effort into exploring the multiple dimensions of his characters, and by the 1980’s, a clear preference for dwelling on the subtleties of the human condition had emerged.
158
Short Story Writers
In the midst of this development, several common threads tie most, if not all, of Boyle’s stories together, most notably his use of humor of all types—parody, slapstick, satire, wit, and irony—and his dedication to keen observation rendered through bold, colorful language. This latter quality, which seems to be missing from a large portion of contemporary American fiction, is a clear reflection of Boyle’s belief that it is possible for fiction to possess the same vitality as rock-and-roll music. Michael Adams With updates by Douglas Long and the Editors Other major works anthology: Doubletakes: Pairs of Contemporary Short Stories, 2003. novels: Water Music, 1981; Budding Prospects: A Pastoral, 1984; World’s End, 1987; East Is East, 1990; The Road to Wellville, 1993; The Tortilla Curtain, 1995; Riven Rock, 1998; A Friend of the Earth, 2000; Drop City, 2003; The Inner Circle, 2004; Talk Talke, 2006. Bibliography Boyle, T. Coraghessan. “A Punk’s Past Recaptured.” Interview by Anthony DeCurtis. Rolling Stone, January 14, 1988, 54-57. In his most revealing interview, Boyle talks about his drug use, the importance of understanding history, and the autobiographical element in his fiction. He expresses the desire to be like Kurt Vonnegut, in showing that literature can be both serious and entertaining, and like John Updike, in constantly changing his approach to fiction and improving as an artist. ____________. “Rolling Boyle.” Interview by Tad Friend. The New York Times Magazine, December 9, 1990, 50, 64, 66, 68. Boyle portrays himself as a missionary for literature who promotes himself to ensure that he is read. He comments on the new maturity and reality in some of his fiction but admits that the absurd and bizarre are more natural for him. Boyle also expresses pessimism about the future of the human race. Chase, Brennan. “Like, Chill!” Los Angeles 38 (April, 1993): 80-82. A biographical sketch, focusing on Boyle’s successful literary career and celebrity status in Hollywood. Boyle maintains that he is an academic whose purpose is to write. Hume, Kathryn. American Dream, American Nightmare: Fiction Since 1960. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2000. Boyle’s work is discussed in an extensive study of the tension between utopian and dystopian tendencies in late twentieth century American fiction. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Boyle: “Greasy Lake” and “The Hector Quesadilla Story” (vol. 3), “If the River Was Whiskey” (vol. 4), and “The Overcoat II” (vol. 6). Pope, Dan. “A Different Kind of Post-Modernism.” Gettysburg Review 3 (Autumn, 1990): 658-669. A discussion of Boyle’s collection If the River Was Whiskey, along with a collection of short fiction by Rick DeMarinis and Paul West, as typifying the work of a new generation of writers who look beyond “the age of innocent realism.” Shelden, Michael. “T. Coraghessan Boyle: The Art of Fiction CLXI.” Paris Review 155 (Summer, 2000): 100-126. General appreciation of Boyle’s writings.
Boyle, T. Coraghessan
159
Spencer, Russ. “The Jester Who Hath No King.” Book, December, 1998-January, 1999, 38-43. Day-in-the-life type feature based on a visit to Boyle’s home, with Boyle— described as “the Bacchus of American letters”—assessing his career and personal philosophies following the publication of Riven Rock and T. C. Boyle Stories. Vaid, Krishna Baldev. “Franz Kafka Writes to T. Coraghessan Boyle.” Michigan Quarterly Review 35 (Summer, 1996): 533-549. As if writing a letter from Franz Kafka, Vaid discusses the work of Boyle, investigates the similarity between the two writers, and argues that the reader could grow as tired of Kafka’s logic as of Boyle’s broad panoramas.
160
Ray Bradbur y Born: Waukegan, Illinois; August 22, 1920 Principal short fiction • Dark Carnival, 1947; The Martian Chronicles, 1950; The Illustrated Man, 1951; The Golden Apples of the Sun, 1953; The October Country, 1955; A Medicine for Melancholy, 1959; Twice Twenty-two, 1959; The Machineries of Joy, 1964; Autumn People, 1965; Vintage Bradbury, 1965; Tomorrow Midnight, 1966; I Sing the Body Electric!, 1969; Long After Midnight, 1976; “The Last Circus,” and “The Electrocution,” 1980; The Stories of Ray Bradbury, 1980; Dinosaur Tales, 1983; A Memory of Murder, 1984; The Toynbee Convector, 1988; Quicker than the Eye, 1996; Driving Blind, 1997; One More for the Road: A New Short Story Collection, 2002; Bradbury Stories: One Hundred of His Most Celebrated Tales, 2003; The Best of Ray Bradbury: The Graphic Novel, 2003; The Cat’s Pajamas, 2004. Other literary forms • Although Ray Bradbury has described himself as essentially a short-story writer, his contributions to a wide variety of other genres have been substantial. Indeed, he has intentionally sought to compose successfully in virtually every literary form. His best-known novels are Fahrenheit 451 (1953), Dandelion Wine (1957), and Something Wicked This Way Comes (1962), the last being his personal favorite from among all his works. After publishing Green Shadows, White Whale in 1992, Bradbury concentrated mostly on shorter forms. However, after reaching the age of eighty, he returned to the longer form with From the Dust Returned: A Family Remembrance in 2001, Let’s All Kill Constance in 2003, and Farewell Summer in 2006. Among Bradbury’s screenplays, the most successful have been Moby Dick (1956), written in collaboration with filmmaker John Huston, and Icarus Montgolfier Wright (1961) with George C. Johnson, which was nominated for an Academy Award. Bradbury had his stage plays produced in Los Angeles and New York City, and several of them have been published, representative samples of which are The Anthem Sprinters and Other Antics (1963) and The Pedestrian (1966). He also wrote many plays for radio and television. Some of the most important of the several volumes of poetry that he published were collected in The Complete Poems of Ray Bradbury (1982). Five more volumes of poems followed later, including I Live By the Invisible: New and Selected Poems (2002). Bradbury has also written books for children and adolescents, including Ahmed and the Oblivion Machines: A Fable (1998); compiled anthologies of fantasy and science-fiction stories, such as The Circus of Dr. Lao, and Other Improbable Stories (1956); and published nonfiction works dealing with his interests in creativity and the future, such as Yestermorrow: Obvious Answers to Impossible Futures (1991) and Bradbury Speaks: Too Soon from the Cave, Too Far from the Stars (2005). Achievements • Despite the fact that Bradbury was once named the best-known American science-fiction writer in a poll, his actual literary accomplishments are based on work whose vast variety and deeply humanistic themes transcend science fiction as it is commonly understood. His many stories, from gothic horror to social criticism, from playful fantasies to nostalgic accounts of midwestern American life, have been anthologized in several hundred collections, in English as well as many
Bradbury, Ray
161
foreign languages, and several of the stories that he published early in his career now occupy a distinguished niche in twentieth century American literature. Some of his early tales were recognized with O. Henry Prizes in 1947 and 1948, and in 1949 he TO VIEW IMAGE, was voted Best Author by the National Fantasy Fan Federation. PLEASE SEE Bradbury’s “Sun and Shadow” PRINT EDITION won the Benjamin Franklin MagOF THIS BOOK. azine Award as the best story of 1953-1954, and in 1954 he received a National Institute of Arts and Letters Award in Literature. His novel Fahrenheit 451 won a gold medal from the Commonwealth Club of California, and his book Switch on the Night (1955) was honored with a Boy’s Club of America Junior Book Award in 1956. He received the Mrs. Ann Radcliffe Award of the Count Thomas Victor Dracula Society in 1965 and 1971, the Writers’ Guild of America West Valentine Davies Award in 1974, and the World Fantasy Award for Life Achievement in 1977. Whittier College gave him an honorary doctor of literature degree in 1979. PEN, an international writers’ organization of poets, playwrights, editors, essayists, and novelists, gave Bradbury its Body of Work Award in 1985. In 1988 Bradbury won the Nebula Award, and in 1995 he was named Los Angeles Citizen of the Year. In 2002, he was honored with a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame, and in 2004, he received the National Medal of the Arts. Biography • Ray Douglas Bradbury often makes use of his own life in his writings, and he insisted that he had total recall of the myriad experiences of his life through his photographic—some would say eidetic—memory: He stated that he always had vivid recollections of the day of his birth, August 22, 1920, in Waukegan, Illinois. Leonard Spaulding Bradbury, his father, was a lineman with the Bureau of Power and Light (his distant ancestor Mary Bradbury was among those tried for witchcraft in Salem, Massachusetts); Esther Marie (née Moberg) Bradbury, his mother, had emigrated from Sweden to the United States when she was very young. A child with an exceptionally lively imagination, Ray Bradbury amused himself with his fantasies but experienced anguish from his nightmares. His mother took him to his first film, The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1923), when he was three years old, and he was both frightened and entranced by Lon Chaney’s performance. This experience originated his lifelong love affair with motion pictures, and he wrote that he could remember the scenes and plots of all the films that he ever saw. As he grew up, Bradbury passed through a series of passions that included cir-
162
Short Story Writers
cuses, dinosaurs, and Mars (the latter via the writings of Edgar Rice Burroughs). Neva Bradbury, an aunt, assisted his maturation as a person and writer by introducing him to the joys of fairy tales, L. Frank Baum’s Oz books, live theater, and the stories of Edgar Allan Poe. In Bradbury’s own view, the most important event in his childhood occurred in 1932 when a carnival came to town. He attended the performance of a magician, Mr. Electrico, whose spellbinding act involved electrifying himself to such an extent that sparks jumped between his teeth and every white hair on his head stood erect. Bradbury and the magician became friends, and their walks and talks along the Lake Michigan shore behind the carnival so energized his imagination that he began to compose stories for several hours a day. One of his first efforts was a sequel to a Martian novel of Burroughs. During the Depression, Bradbury’s father had difficulty finding work, and in 1932 the family moved to Arizona, where they had previously spent some time in the mid1920’s. Still in search of steady work, his father moved the family to Los Angeles, which was where Ray Bradbury attended high school and which became his permanent home. His formal education ended with his graduation from Los Angeles High School, but his education as a writer continued through his extensive reading and his participation in theater groups (one of which was sponsored by the actor Laraine Day). To support his writing, he worked as a newsboy in downtown Los Angeles for several years. During World War II, Bradbury’s poor eyesight prevented him from serving in the Army, but this disappointment gave him the freedom to pursue his career as a writer, and he began to publish his stories in such pulp magazines as Weird Tales and Hugo Gernsback’s Amazing Stories. The high quality of Bradbury’s stories was quickly recognized, and he was able to get his new stories published in such mass-circulation magazines as Collier’s, The Saturday Evening Post, Harper’s Magazine, and Mademoiselle. Because of his success as a writer, he had the financial security to marry Marguerite Susan McClure in 1947 (they had met when she, a book clerk, had waited on him). The marriage produced four daughters. By the early 1950’s, Bradbury, now recognized as an accomplished science-fiction and fantasy writer, began his involvement with Hollywood through an original screenplay that would eventually be released as It Came from Outer Space (1952). During the mid-1950’s, he traveled to Ireland in connection with a screenplay of Moby Dick that he wrote with John Huston (he later drew on his experiences with the Irish for several stories and plays that took his work in a new direction). Upon his return to the United States, Bradbury composed a large number of television scripts for such shows as Alfred Hitchcock Presents, Suspense, and The Twilight Zone. During the late 1950’s and early 1960’s, Bradbury moved away from science fiction, and his stories and novels increasingly focused on humanistic themes and his midwestern childhood. During the late 1960’s and throughout the 1970’s and 1980’s, Bradbury’s output of short and long fiction decreased, and his ideas found outlets in such literary forms as poems, plays, and essays. He also participated in a number of projects, such as “A Journey Through United States History,” the exhibit that occupied the upper floor of the United States Pavilion for the New York World’s Fair in 1964. Because of this display’s success, the Walt Disney organization hired him to help develop the exhibit Spaceship Earth for the Epcot Center at Disney World in Florida. He continued to diversify his activities during the 1980’s by collaborating on projects to turn his novel Fahrenheit 451 into an opera and his novel Dandelion Wine into a musical. During the late 1980’s and early 1990’s, he returned to some of the
Bradbury, Ray
163
subjects and themes that had earlier established his reputation with the publication of short-story collections The Toynbee Convector, Quicker than the Eye, and Driving Blind, and the novels A Graveyard for Lunatics: Another Tale of Two Cities (1990) and Green Shadows, White Whale (1992). Analysis • Ray Bradbury once said that he had not so much thought his way through life as he had done things and discovered what those things meant and who he was after the doing. This metamorphosis of experience under the aegis of memory also characterizes many of his stories, which are often transmogrifications of his personal experiences. He therefore used his stories as ways of hiding and finding himself, a self whose constant changes interested, amused, and sometimes frightened him. He believed that human beings are composed of time, and in many of his science-fiction stories, a frequent theme is the dialectic between the past and the future. For example, in several of his Martian stories, the invaders of the Red Planet have to come to terms with their transformation into Martians, since survival in an alien world necessitates the invader’s union with the invaded. Aggression and submission might represent the initial dialectic, but survival or death becomes the most determinative. Even in stories where Bradbur y’s characters and settings seem ordinar y, this theme of metamorphosis is nevertheless present, because these stories often show ordinar y people being transformed by extraordinar y, sometimes bizarre situations. Sometimes Bradbur y’s purpose is to point out the enlightening power of the abnormal; sometimes he wants to reveal the limitations of the ever yday and ordinar y. His best works are often wrenching indictments of the dangers of unrestrained scientific and technical progress, though his work also encourages the hope that humanity will deal creatively with the new worlds it seems driven to make. His characters are changed by their experiences, particularly when they encounter great evil beneath the surface of seemingly normal life, but in other stories Bradbur y gives the reader a window through which to see the positive meaning of life (these stories, usually sentimental, are life-affirming, permitting readers to believe that human dreams can be fulfilled). By helping readers to imagine the unimaginable, he helps them to think about the unthinkable. He speaks of his tales as “idea fiction,” and he prefers to call himself a Magical Realist. He casts magic spells through his poetic words and highly imaginative visions, and because of this aura of enchantment, some critics have seen his chief subject as childhood or the child hidden in the adult unconscious. A danger exists, however, in treating Bradbury as a writer of fantasy suitable only for adolescents. This may be true for some of his works, but many of his stories exhibit emotional depths and logical complexities that call for a sophisticated dialectic between the adult and his buried childhood. The difference between fantasy and reality is not strongly developed in the child, whose experience of the world is minimal. Bradbury often plays with this tension between fantasy and reality in dealing with his principal themes—the power of the past, the freedom of the present, and the temptations and traps of the future. In the world of Bradbury’s stories, fantasy becomes essential for a person existing in an increasingly technological era or with experiences that, like an iceberg, are nine-tenths buried below the surface. In these cases, the abilities to fantasize various alternatives or futures, and to choose the best among them, become necessary for survival. Because of Bradbury’s woefully inadequate knowledge of science and the lack of verisimilitude in the technological gadgetry of his science-fiction stories, many afi-
164
Short Story Writers
cionados of the genre do not consider him a genuine science-fiction writer. He agrees. His science-fiction settings are backgrounds for characters with social, religious, and moral dilemmas. Like fellow science-fiction writer Isaac Asimov, Bradbury believes that science fiction’s value lies in helping human beings to visualize and solve future problems before they actually occur, but unlike Asimov, he has a deep suspicion of the machine and a great faith in the human heart’s capacity to perceive, do good, and create beauty. Because of this attitude, many critics view Bradbury as essentially a romantic. Since F. L. Lucas once counted 11,396 definitions of “romanticism,” however, perhaps Bradbury’s brand of romanticism should be more fully articulated. He has expressed an attraction for spontaneity of thought and action, and he actively cultivates his own unconscious. He believes deeply in the power of the imagination, and he accepts Blaise Pascal’s sentiment that the heart has reasons about which the reason knows nothing. In making an assessment of Bradbury’s contribution to modern American literature, one must come to terms with the role he played in popularizing science fiction and making it critically respectable. Bradbury himself once stated that, for him, science fiction is “the most important literature in the history of the world,” since it tells the story of “civilization birthing itself.” He has also said that he considers himself not a science-fiction writer but an “idea writer,” someone who loves ideas and enjoys playing with them. Many of his science-fiction critics would concur in this characterization, since they have had problems categorizing this man who knows so little about science as a traditional science-fiction writer. When asked whether the Mariner mission’s revelations about the inhospitability of Mars to humankind had invalidated his stories about the planet, Bradbury responded that these discoveries in no way affected them, because he had been composing poetic myths, not scientific forecasts. In addition to their lack of scientific verisimilitude, his stories have other weaknesses. Few of his characters are memorable, and most are simply vehicles for his ideas. He has said frankly that he devises characters to personify his ideas and that all of his characters—youths, astronauts, and grotesques—are, in some way, variations on himself. Other critics have noticed failures in Bradbury’s imaginative powers, particularly in his later stories. The settings and images that seemed fresh when first used in the early stories became stale as they continued to be used in the later ones. Thomas M. Disch complained that Bradbury’s sentimental attachments to his past themes “have made him nearly oblivious to new data from any source.” Despite these criticisms, Bradbury’s stories possess great strengths. If his characters are made negligible by the burden of the ideas that they are forced to carry, these same ideas can open readers to his enchanting sense of wonder. These readers can be inspired by his enthusiasm for new experiences and new worlds. They may also be uplifted by the underlying optimism present even in his most pessimistic work and come to share his belief that human beings will overcome materialism, avarice, and obsession with power to achieve the expansion of what is best in the human spirit that has been his principal theme. Dark Carnival • Many of these characteristics, along with Bradbury’s penchant for the grotesque and macabre, can be seen in his first collection of stories, Dark Carnival. August Derleth, a Wisconsin writer who had established Arkham House to publish stories of fantasy and horror for a limited audience, had read Bradbury’s stories in the pulp magazine Weird Tales, recognized their quality, and suggested that
Bradbury, Ray
165
Bradbury collect them in a book. Dark Carnival was very successful with its specialized market, and its three thousand copies were quickly sold and soon become collectors’ items. The book’s title was aptly chosen, since the stories often deal with the dark and strange. Several stories make use, although in highly altered forms, of emotions and events in Bradbury’s own life. For example, “The Small Assassin” depicts an infant, terrified at finding himself in a hostile world, taking revenge on his parents. Bradbury uses this metamorphosis of a supposedly innocent newborn into an assassin to explore some of the feelings he had as a very young child. Death is a motif that appears often in these tales, but unlike Poe, whom he admired, Bradbury uses the morbid not for its macabre fascination, as Poe did, but to shift readers onto a different level from which they can see reality in a new and enlightening way. In most of these tales, more happens in the imaginations of Bradbury’s characters than happens in their lives. He has the ability to reach down into the labyrinthine unconscious of his characters and pull out odd desires, strange dreams, and horrendous fears. For example, in “The Next in Line,” a story that grew out of his own experience on a trip to Guanajuato, northwest of Mexico City, a young American wife is simultaneously frightened and fascinated by the rows of propped-up mummified bodies in a Guanajuato catacomb. After her traumatic ordeal, she finds herself increasingly immobilized by her alienation from the death-haunted Mexican society and by her fear that her own body is a potential mummy. Another stor y, “Skeleton,” has a similar theme. A man is obsessed by the horrible bones that he carries within him, but when a strange creature crawls down his throat and consumes the bones that were the source of his obsession, he is transformed into a human jellyfish. These and other fantasies and horrors ser ve as exorcisms through which the devils of one’s unconscious are expelled. The best of these stories leave the reader cleansed and transformed, with an expanded consciousness and control of the fears that can make people prisoners of their own hidden emotions. The Martian Chronicles • Some critics see the twenty-six stories collected in The Martian Chronicles as the beginning of the most prolific and productive phase of Bradbury’s career. Like Dark Carnival, this collection resulted from the suggestion of an editor, but in this case Bradbury added passages to link together his stories about Mars. These bridge passages help to interrelate the stories, but they do not make them into a unified novel. This places The Martian Chronicles into a peculiar literary category—less than a novel but more than a collection of short stories. Despite difficulties in categorizing this book, it is commonly recognized as Bradbury’s most outstanding work. When it was first published, it was widely reviewed and read by people who did not ordinarily read science fiction. The poet Christopher Isherwood, for example, praised the book for its poetic language and its penetrating analysis of human beings forced to function on the frontier of an alien world. Within twenty years of its publication, The Martian Chronicles sold more than three million copies and was translated into more than thirty languages. The Martian Chronicles is not totally unrelated to Dark Carnival, since Bradbury’s Mars is a fantasy world, a creation not of a highly trained scientific imagination but of a mythmaker and an explorer of the unconscious. Within the time frame of 1999 to 2026, Bradbury orders his stories to give the reader a sense of the coherent evolution of the settling of Mars by Earthlings. The early stories deal with the difficulties the
166
Short Story Writers
emigrants from Earth have in establishing successful colonies on Mars. The fifteen stories of the middle section explore the rise and fall of these colonies. The stories in the final section are concerned with the possible renovation of the human race on Mars after an annihilative nuclear war on Earth. In several of the stories in The Martian Chronicles, Bradbury is once again fascinated by the subject of death. Earthlings who make the mistake of trying to duplicate Earth’s culture on Mars meet difficulties and death. This theme is particularly clear in “The Third Expedition,” a story that was originally titled “Mars Is Heaven” and that deeply impressed the critic and writer Jorge Luis Borges. In “The Third Expedition,” Captain John Black and his crew constitute a third attempt by Earthlings to create a successful settlement on Mars, this time in a town that bears a striking resemblance to traditional midwestern American towns of the 1920’s. It turns out that the Martians have deceived the Earthlings by using telepathic powers to manufacture this counterfeit town in their receptive imaginations. Captain Black and his crew have such a deep desire to believe in what they think they see that they delude themselves into seeing what the Martians want them to see. This mass hypnosis produced by the Martians capitalizes on the crew’s self-delusion and on its members’ need to re-create their past. When each Earthling is securely locked within what he believes is his home, he is murdered by the Martians. Trapped by their past and unable to resist, they are destroyed. Illusion and reality, time and identity, change and stability are the themes that intertwine in Bradbury’s treatment of this story (one can understand why Borges liked it so much, since his own work dwells on the theme of the Other as an inextricable element in one’s own identity). The Illustrated Man • Soon after The Martian Chronicles appeared, Bradbury published another book of interlinked stories, The Illustrated Man. Most of its eighteen stories had been published in various magazines between 1947 and 1951, but some had been written specifically for this book. The framing device, which is neither as consistent nor as unifying as the bridge passages in The Martian Chronicles, derives from tattoos that completely cover the skin of a running character. The tattoos, however, do not grow out of the personality of this character, as would be expected for a real tattooed man whose likes and dislikes would be represented in the permanent images he chooses to decorate his body. Instead, each tattoo embodies a Bradburian idea that comes alive in a particular story. The otherwise unrelated stories fall into several categories—tales of robots and space travel as well as stories of Mexicans and Martians. Four of the stories are set on Bradbury’s Mars, and two of these are closely related to The Martian Chronicles. Some of the stories have themes related to those initially developed in Dark Carnival. For example, like “The Small Assassin,” “The Veldt” concerns the revenge of children against their parents, this time in a futuristic setting. The children, who are obsessed with a room-filling television device that can depict scenes with three-dimensional realism, choose to watch an African veldt inhabited by lions gorging themselves on carcasses. The parents, who try to get their children to control their television addiction, end up as food for the lions. In this story, Bradbury makes use of a favorite theme—the blurred distinction between illusion and reality. Other stories in The Illustrated Man are animated by such social concerns as racism and with ethical and religious dilemmas derived from modern science and technology. For example, “The Fire Balloons” focuses on a religious missionary’s discovery that the only surviving Martians have metamorphosed from human forms to floating balls of blue flame
Bradbury, Ray
167
(reminiscent of the fire balloons in Earth’s Fourth of July celebrations). After undergoing this transformation, these Martian flames are no longer capable of sin. Bradbury implies that a new planet means a new theology, the Fall is reversible, and a state of innocence can be regained. The Golden Apples of the Sun • Bradbury’s fourth collection, The Golden Apples of the Sun, used neither linking passages nor a frame narrative to interrelate the twenty-two stories. Instead, this book initiated the Bradburian potpourri of stories that would characterize most of his later collections: nostalgic, satiric, and humorous stories whose settings could be Mars, Mexico, or the Midwest and whose genre could be fantasy, science fiction, crime, or horror. He would use this variety of approach, setting, and genre to cast a revelatory light on aspects of modern life that conventional fiction was avoiding. Although the critical reception of The Golden Apples of the Sun was largely favorable, some critics found several of the stories disappointing and noted a falling-off from the high level of quality of The Martian Chronicles and The Illustrated Man. Despite the divided opinions, general agreement existed on the success of several of the stories, for example, “Sun and Shadow,” which was set in Mexico and which won both praise and awards. Another story, “The Fog Horn,” became the basis of a film, The Beast from Twenty Thousand Fathoms (1953). It is about a lonely dinosaur which is attracted by the sound of a foghorn, interpreting it as the mating call of a potential companion (he dies of a broken heart when he swims to shore and discovers his error). The story “A Sound of Thunder” develops a favorite Bradburian theme of the profound effect of the past on the future. It depicts what happens when a time traveler steps on a butterfly in the past and inadvertently changes the future (this will remind modern readers of the “butterfly effect” in chaos theory, in which the beating of a butterfly’s wings in a Brazilian rain forest may cause a tornado in Kansas via a long chain of cause and effect). The October Country • The October Country, a collection that has as its core the stories of Dark Carnival along with four new stories, appeared appropriately in October of 1955. Bradbury described the country of the title as a place “whose people are autumn people, thinking only autumn thoughts” and whose steps “at night on the empty walks sound like rain.” In the light of the earlier success of Dark Carnival, it is surprising that several critics were not as kind to this collection as they had been to Bradbury’s earlier ones. For example, Carlos Baker, Ernest Hemingway’s biographer, predicted in his review that the only route that Bradbury’s writings could follow if he continued in the direction that he had chosen was down. Some critics did see him trying, in this and later collections, to develop new subjects, themes, and approaches. For them, his imagination was still nimble, his mind adventurous, and his heart sensitive. They also noticed his increased emphasis on social issues and his desire to treat the joyous side of human nature. For most critics, however, Bradbury’s later collections of stories were repetitive mixes of ideas, themes, and treatments that he had used many times before. A Medicine for Melancholy • The problems sensed by Bradbury’s critics can be seen in the collection of twenty-two stories titled A Medicine for Melancholy. In addition to the expected stories of fantasy and science fiction, A Medicine for Melancholy includes tales from the lives of the Irish, Mexicans, and Mexican Americans. The title story explores the awakening womanhood of an eighteenth century London girl who is
168
Short Story Writers
cured of melancholia by the visit of what she interprets as Saint Bosco but who is in reality a dustman. Two of the stories in this collection, “Icarus Montgolfier Wright” and “In a Season of Calm Weather,” led to films, and others, “A Fever Dream” for example, are reminiscent of films. In “A Fever Dream,” aliens invade Earth not externally but by taking over the minds and hearts of their Earth victims (the film analogue is the 1956 The Invasion of the Body Snatchers). Derivative, too, seems the story “All Summer in a Day,” about a group of children on cloud-enshrouded Venus who get to see the sun only once every seven years (the analogue here is Isaac Asimov’s classic story “Nightfall”). The Machineries of Joy • During the 1960’s and 1970’s, Bradbury’s career entered a new phase characterized by a decreasing output of short stories and novels and an increasing output of plays and poetry. When he did bring out short-story collections, the majority of critics saw little suggesting artistic growth, though a minority actually preferred his new stories, interpreting them as examples of a mature writer whose stories had acquired humanity, depth, and polish. These latter critics are also the ones who were not attracted to his tales about corpses, vampires, and cemeteries and who preferred his new optimism and his emphasis on civil rights, religion, and morality. Many of the stories in The Machineries of Joy provide good examples of these new tendencies. There are still stories characteristic of the old Bradbury—a sciencefiction tale in which the explorers of a new planet find themselves possessed by a resident intelligence, and a horror story in which raising giant mushrooms gets out of hand. Many of the stories, however, contain the epiphanic appearance of human warmth in unexpected situations. For example, in “Almost the End of the World,” when sunspots destroy television reception, a world addicted to this opiate of the mind and heart is forced to rediscover the forgotten joys of interpersonal communication. I Sing the Body Electric! • Bradbury’s next collection, I Sing the Body Electric! also met with a mixed critical response. Academic critics and readers who had formed their taste for Bradbury on his early works found this potpourri of seventeen stories pretentious and a decline from his best science-fiction, fantasy, and horror stories. Some stories are slight—indeed, little more than anecdotes: In “The Women,” for example, a man experiences the sea as a woman and his wife as her rival. On the other hand, some critics found Bradbury’s new stories enthralling and insightful, with the unexpected—a robot Abraham Lincoln, Ernest Hemingway’s spirit, and an automated Martian city—confronting the reader at every turn of the page. The stories of I Sing the Body Electric! certainly contain some of Bradbury’s favorite themes—the dialectic between past and future, reality and illusion. For example, the title story concerns a robot grandmother ideally programmed to meet the needs of the children of a recently motherless family. This electrical grandmother embodies the past (she has all the sentiment humans conventionally associate with this figure) and the future (she is a rechargeable AC-DC Mark V model and can never die). Another story that deals with the presentness of the past is “Night Call, Collect.” In this tale, an old man alone on a deserted Mars receives a telephone call from himself when he was much younger (he has forgotten that he devised this plan many years earlier in order to assuage the loneliness of his old age). His young self battles with his old self, and as the old man dies, past, present, and future commingle in an odd but somehow enlightening amalgam.
Bradbury, Ray
169
Long After Midnight • Long After Midnight contains twenty-two stories, several of which had been written in the late 1940’s and early 1950’s but never previously anthologized. Some critics found the new stories aimless, uninspired, and selfindulgent, but others thought that many of them were poignant, sensitive, and touching. These latter critics thought that several of these stories represented Bradbury’s new grasp of the power of love to overcome evil and to make permanent valued moments from the past. A few of the stories broke new ground in terms of subject matter: “The Better Part of Wisdom” is a compassionate and restrained treatment of homosexuality, and “Have I Got a Chocolate Bar for You!” deals gracefully with a relationship between a priest and a penitent. The Stories of Ray Bradbury • In 1980, Bradbury selected one hundred stories from three decades of his work in The Stories of Ray Bradbury. Many reviewers treated this book’s publication as an opportunity to analyze Bradbury’s lifetime achievement as a short-story writer. Some found much to praise, comparing his body of work to Edgar Allan Poe’s, O. Henry’s, and Guy de Maupassant’s. Thomas M. Disch, however, in an influential essay in The New York Times Book Review, denigrated Bradbury’s stories as “schmaltzy” and “more often meretricious than not.” Unlike those critics who praised Bradbury’s early work and saw a decline in the quality of his later stories, Disch stated that early and late are “meaningless distinctions” in Bradbury’s output. He criticized Bradbury condescendingly as a child manqué, attributing his success to the fact that “like Peter Pan, he won’t grow up.” The Toynbee Convector • To those who thought that Bradbury was using The Stories of Ray Bradbury to bid farewell to the form that had been his home for most of his life as a writer, another collection, The Toynbee Convector, showed that they were mistaken. As with his other late collections, this, too, contained the familiar blend of science fiction and gothic horror as well as sentimental tales of Ireland and Middle America, but it broke little new ground. Quicker than the Eye • Most of the twenty-one stories in Quicker than the Eye are loaded with symbols and metaphors about look-alikes, death, doors that open to the unknown, revelations from the unconscious mind, and psychic connections to the past and future. Magicians always fascinated Bradbury. They pretend to do something, the audience blinks, and “quicker than the eye, silks fall out of a hat.” Bradbury performs magic with words, and stories “fall out” of his imagination. In “Quicker than the Eye,” the narrator and his wife watch a magician saw a woman in half and make her disappear. Men in the audience laugh. Then, Miss Quick, a pickpocket, nimbly removes wallets and other personal items from ten unsuspecting male volunteers. Miss Quick particularly humiliates one volunteer, who looks exactly like the narrator, by stripping him “quicker than the eye.” The angry narrator identifies with his “double’s” vulnerability, but his wife laughs. Several stories have themes of revenge and death. In “The Electrocution,” carnival worker Johnny straps Electra in the Death Chair, blindfolds her, and pulls the switch. Blue flames shoot from her body, and, with a sword, she touches and “connects” with a fascinated youth in the crowd. After Electra and her lover meet secretly, Johnny, in a jealous rage, beats him up. The next time he “electrocutes” Electra, he turns up the voltage and says, “You’re dead!” She replies, “Yes, I am.” Some doors that open to the unknown are better left closed. The title “Dorian in
170
Short Story Writers
Excelsus” is wordplay on the liturgical phrase Gloria in excelsis and refers to Oscar Wilde’s The Picture of Dorian Gray (1890 serial, 1891 expanded). A handsome youth invites the aging, dissipated narrator to become a Friend of Dorian at a spa. Behind golden doors, the narrator discovers how Friends of Dorian shed age and become physically beautiful. To regain youth, he must wrestle in Dorian’s gym with hundreds of lustful men. Dorian is a “gelatinous, undulant jellyfish, the sponge of men’s depravity and guilt, a pustule, bacteria, priapic jelly.” He lives by breathing the sweaty stench of human passion and sin. The horrified narrator refuses Dorian’s offer and scratches him with a fingernail. Dorian screams as noxious gases escape, and he and his Friends die. Psychic connections to the past and future are recurring themes in Quicker than the Eye. The title character in “That Woman on the Lawn” awakens a teenage boy with her crying. Her picture is in his family album. He directs her to an address down the street, and they agree to meet in three years; he is her future baby. Robert J. Paradowski With updates by Martha E. Rhynes Other major works children’s literature: Switch on the Night, 1955; R Is for Rocket, 1962; S Is for Space, 1966; The Halloween Tree, 1972; Fever Dream, 1987; Ahmed and the Oblivion Machines: A Fable, 1998. plays: The Anthem Sprinters and Other Antics, pb. 1963; The World of Ray Bradbury: Three Fables of the Future, pr. 1964; The Day It Rained Forever, pb. 1966; The Pedestrian, pb. 1966; Dandelion Wine, pr. 1967 (adaptation of his novel); Madrigals for the Space Age, pb. 1972; The Wonderful Ice Cream Suit, and Other Plays, pb. 1972; Pillar of Fire, and Other Plays for Today, Tomorrow, and Beyond Tomorrow, pb. 1975; That Ghost, That Bride of Time: Excerpts from a Play-in-Progress, pb. 1976; The Martian Chronicles, pr. 1977; Fahrenheit 451, pr. 1979 (musical); A Device Out of Time, pb. 1986; On Stage: A Chrestomathy of His Plays, pb. 1991. anthologies: Timeless Stories for Today and Tomorrow, 1952; The Circus of Dr. Lao, and Other Improbable Stories, 1956. novels: Fahrenheit 451, 1953; Dandelion Wine, 1957; Something Wicked This Way Comes, 1962; Death Is a Lonely Business, 1985; A Graveyard for Lunatics: Another Tale of Two Cities, 1990; Green Shadows, White Whale, 1992; From the Dust Returned: A Family Remembrance, 2001; Let’s All Kill Constance, 2003; Farewell Summer, 2006. nonfiction: Teacher’s Guide to Science Fiction, 1968 (with Lewy Olfson); “Zen and the Art of Writing” and “The Joy of Writing”: Two Essays, 1973; Mars and the Mind of Man, 1973; The Mummies of Guanajuato, 1978; The Art of the Playboy, 1985; Zen in the Art of Writing: Essays on Creativity, 1989; Yestermorrow: Obvious Answers to Impossible Futures, 1991; Bradbury Speaks: Too Soon from the Cave, Too Far from the Stars, 2005. poetry: Old Ahab’s Friend, and Friend to Noah, Speaks His Piece: A Celebration, 1971; When Elephants Last in the Dooryard Bloomed: Celebrations for Almost Any Day in the Year, 1973; Where Robot Mice and Robot Men Run Round in Robot Towns: New Poems, Both Light and Dark, 1977; The Bike Repairman, 1978; Twin Hieroglyphs That Swim the River Dust, 1978; The Aqueduct, 1979; The Haunted Computer and the Android Pope, 1981; The Complete Poems of Ray Bradbury, 1982; Forever and the Earth, 1984; Death Has Lost Its Charm for Me, 1987; Dogs Think That Every Day Is Christmas, 1997; With Cat for Comforter, 1997 (with Loise Max); I Live By the Invisible: New and Selected Poems, 2002.
Bradbury, Ray
171
screenplays: It Came from Outer Space, 1952 (with David Schwartz); Moby Dick, 1956 (with John Huston); Icarus Montgolfier Wright, 1961 (with George C. Johnson); The Picasso Summer, 1969 (with Ed Weinberger). Bibliography Bloom, Harold, ed. Ray Bradbury. New York: Chelsea House, 2001. Critical essays cover the major themes in Bradbury’s works, looking at, among other topics, his Martian stories, his participation in the gothic tradition, the role of children in his work, and his use of myth. Badbury, Ray. “The Ray Bradbury Chronicles.” Interview by J. Stephen Bolhafner. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, December 1, 1996. Interview with Bradbury on the occasion of the publication of his collection of short stories Quicker than the Eye. Bradbury reminisces about the beginnings of his career, talks about getting over his fear of flying, and discusses The Martian Chronicles as fantasy, mythology, and Magical Realism. ____________. “Sci-fi for Your D: Drive.” Newsweek 126 (November 13, 1995): 89. In this interview-story, Bradbury discusses why he is putting his most widely acclaimed short-story collection, The Martian Chronicles, on CD-ROM. Bradbury also discusses the role of imagination in technology, the space program, and his favorite literary figures. Eller, Jonathan R., and William F. Touponce. Ray Bradbury: The Life of Fiction. Kent, Ohio: Kent State University Press, 2004. First full biography of Bradbury. Greenberg, Martin Henry, and Joseph D. Olander, eds. Ray Bradbury. New York: Taplinger, 1980. This anthology of Bradbury criticism is part of the Writers of the Twenty-first Century series. Some of the articles defend Bradbury against the charge that he is not really a science-fiction writer but an opponent of science and technology; other articles defend him against the charge that he is mawkish. Includes an extensive Bradbury bibliography compiled by Marshall B. Tymn and an index. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Bradbury: “The April Witch” (vol. 1), “I See You Never” (vol. 4), “There Will Come Soft Rains” (vol. 7), and “The Veldt” (vol. 8). Mogen, David. Ray Bradbury. Boston: Twayne, 1986. This brief introduction to Bradbury’s career centers on analyses of the literary influences that shaped the development of his style and the themes whose successful embodiment in his short stories and novels shaped his reputation. The detailed notes at the end of the book contain many useful references. Bibliography and index. Reid, Robin Ann. Ray Bradbury: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 2000. Part of the publisher’s series of reference books on popular contemporary writers for students, this volume provides detailed plot summaries and analyses of Bradbury’s fictional works, along with character portraits, a biography of Bradbury and an extensive bibliography. Touponce, William F. Naming the Unnameable: Ray Bradbury and the Fantastic After Freud. Mercer Island, Wash.: Starmont House, 1997. Touponce finds the psychoanalytic ideas of Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung helpful in plumbing the effectiveness of much of Bradbury’s work (though in a letter to the author, Bradbury himself denies any direct influence, since he has “read little Freud or Jung”).
172
Short Story Writers
Nevertheless, Touponce believes that Bradbury has written stories of a modern consciousness that often forgets its debt to the unconscious. Weist, Jerry, and Donn Albright. Bradbury, an Illustrated Life: A Journey to Far Metaphor. New York: William Morrow, 2002. “Visual biography” of Bradbury made up mostly of images from pulps, films, television, and other mass media that both influenced Bradbury and have been influenced by him. An innovative approach to understanding a writer who transcends the printed page. Weller, Sam. The Bradbury Chronicles. New York: William Morrow, 2005. This authorized biography, was written with access to Bradbury and his personal papers and correspondence. Not a critical work, but rather an admiring portrait of the writer.
173
Morley Callaghan Born: Toronto, Ontario, Canada; February 22, 1903 Died: Toronto, Ontario, Canada; August 25, 1990 Principal short fiction • A Native Argosy, 1929; Now That April’s Here, and Other Stories, 1936; Morley Callaghan’s Stories, 1959; The Lost and Found Stories of Morley Callaghan, 1985. Other literary forms • Although Morley Callaghan was a masterful short-story writer, he also won recognition for his many novels, the most highly regarded being Such Is My Beloved (1934), More Joy in Heaven (1937), The Loved and the Lost (1951), and Close to the Sun Again (1977). He is also the author of a novella (No Man’s Meat), a children’s book (Luke Baldwin’s Vow, 1948), and three plays (To Tell the Truth, pr. 1949; Turn Home Again, pr. 1940; and Season of the Witch, pb. 1976). He recorded some of his stories for children, and others, such as Luke Baldwin’s Vow, have been filmed. Starting his career as a journalist, Callaghan contributed articles and essays to newspapers and journals throughout his life. His nonfiction works include the text for a book of John de Visser’s photographs, entitled Winter (1974), and That Summer in Paris: Memories of Tangled Friendships with Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and Some Others (1963), an entertaining account of the heady days in Paris in 1929, when he socialized with Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, James Joyce, and other writers. Throughout his life, Callaghan continued to make significant contributions to Canadian cultural life as a book reviewer and essayist as well as a novelist. Achievements • During the 1920’s, Morley Callaghan’s stories impressed Ernest Hemingway, who introduced them to Ezra Pound. Pound subsequently printed them in his magazine, The Exile. The stories also impressed F. Scott Fitzgerald, who presented them to Maxwell Perkins, his editor at Scribner’s. Perkins later published Callaghan’s stories as well as some of his novels. Although considered a highly promising writer in the 1920’s and 1930’s, Callaghan neither developed a large audience nor achieved the type of reputation that his works warrant. Edmund Wilson commented that Callaghan was “perhaps the most unjustly neglected novelist in the Englishspeaking world.” Even so, Callaghan was the recipient of several awards: Canada’s Governor General’s Literary Award (1951), the Gold Medal of the Royal Society of Canada (1958), the Lorne Pierce Medal (1960), the Canada Council Molson Prize (1970), the Royal Bank of Canada Award (1970), and the Companion of the Order of Canada (1982). He was also nominated for a Nobel Prize. His fiction is praised for its direct, unornamented prose, though later criticism has suggested that hiswriting is wooden, with technical weaknesses. His fiction is also valued for its sympathetic portrayal of ordinary people and for its honest treatment of the problems of contemporary life. Callaghan’s lifelong exploration of the conflict between spirituality and human weakness and alienation has illuminated the best of his writing. Callaghan held a doctorate in literature from the University of Western Ontario (1965), a law degree from the University of Toronto (1966), and a doctorate in litera-
174
Short Story Writers ture from the University of Windsor (1973). In 1989, the city of Toronto awarded him a Lifetime Achievement Award.
Biography • Born in Toronto, Canada, on September 22, 1903, Edward TO VIEW IMAGE, Morley Callaghan was reared by Roman Catholic parents of Irish descent. PLEASE SEE He grew up interested in sports, espePRINT EDITION cially boxing and baseball, but at a OF THIS BOOK. young age he also displayed a talent for writing, selling at the age of seventeen his first article, a description of Yonge and Alberta streets in Toronto, to the Star Weekly for twelve dollars. In 1921, he entered St. Michael’s College of the University of Toronto, and during the summers and part-time during the school year, he was a reporter for the Toronto Daily Star, the same newspaper that employed Ernest Hemingway, who encouraged John Martin him in his attempts at fiction writing. Callaghan received his bachelor’s degree in 1925, and enrolled in Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto. He continued to write short stories, mailing them to Hemingway, who was then in Paris. Some of these stories, through Hemingway’s assistance, appeared in various magazines, such as This Quarter, Transition, and The Exile. In 1928, the year that Callaghan finished law school and was admitted to the Ontario bar, Maxwell Perkins, of Scribner’s, published several of his stories in Scribner’s Magazine and agreed to print his first novel, Strange Fugitive (1928), as well as a collection of short stories, A Native Argosy. Forsaking law, Callaghan decided to be a writer. After marrying Loretto Florence Dee in 1929, he traveled to Paris, where he met with Hemingway and became acquainted with F. Scott Fitzgerald and James Joyce. He later recorded this volatile period in That Summer in Paris. Leaving Paris in the autumn, Callaghan returned to Toronto, which became his home except for occasional stays in Pennsylvania and New York, where he socialized with Sherwood Anderson, Thomas Wolfe, James T. Farrell, Sinclair Lewis, and other writers. During this early period, from 1928 to 1937, he published a novel or a collection of short stories almost yearly. From 1937 to 1948, he neglected his fiction and devoted his time to radio programming and writing essays. It has been suggested that the events of that time—the rise of Nazism, the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939), the purges of Joseph Stalin, and World War II—contributed to his lack of interest in fiction. In 1948, he resumed writing novels and short stories, which appeared regularly in leading magazines. In his later years he devoted his energy to novels and nonfiction works. He also gained public recognition and respect in Canada as a radio broadcast personality and commentator on Canadian cultural life. Callaghan died on August 25, 1990, in Toronto.
Callaghan, Morley
175
Analysis • Over his long career, Morley Callaghan published more than one hundred short stories, in such magazines as The New Yorker, Scribner’s Magazine, and numerous other magazines. Many of these have been collected in his four volumes of short stories. Although there are variations and exceptions, Callaghan’s stories generally have recognizable characteristics. Foremost of these is the style: Most noticeably in the early works, Callaghan employs short declarative sentences, colloquial dialogue, and plain, unadorned language. As he remarked in That Summer in Paris, he attempts to “tell the truth cleanly.” This sparse, economical, straightforward style has been compared with Hemingway’s. Perhaps Callaghan was influenced by Hemingway (he admired and respected the older author), but it is likely that Callaghan’s work on a newspaper shaped his writing, just as Hemingway’s style was honed by his years of reporting. Like a journalist, Callaghan presented the events in his stories objectively, neither condemning nor praising his character. By precisely recording his observations, Callaghan allows his readers to form their own judgments. He strives “to strip the language, and make the style, the method, all the psychological ramifications, the ambience of the relationships, all the one thing, so the reader couldn’t make separations. Cézanne’s apples. The appleness of the apples. Yet just apples.” In other words, he endeavored to capture the essence of the moment. Although Callaghan’s stories are often set in Canada, he should not be classified as a regional writer. His appeal ranges beyond the borders of his country. The themes he treats are universal and are not limited to Canadian issues; in fact, he has been criticized for not addressing Canadian problems more forcefully. Many of his stories examine human relationships, and they therefore revolve around psychological issues rather than physical actions. They depict the ordinary person and his or her desire for happiness. This desire is often frustrated by environmental forces such as unemployment and injustice and by internal drives such as fear and sex. In the early stories, the characters, inarticulate and of less than normal intelligence, are on the edge of society: the poor, the disabled, the criminal, and the insane. The characters in Callaghan’s later stories are more likely to be educated, but they still struggle in their quest for a better life. All Callaghan’s characters reflect his concerns as a Roman Catholic, and a certain pessimism underlies their portrayals. Rarely in Callaghan’s characters are innate spirituality and nobility of character allowed to triumph over the more ignoble of human instincts and behavior. In 1928, Scribner’s published Callaghan’s first novel, Strange Fugitive, and followed this a year later with A Native Argosy, a collection of short fiction containing fourteen stories and two novellas. These stories are some of the most naturalistic produced by Callaghan, and the characters, themes, and style resemble that found in work by other naturalistic writers, such as Stephen Crane, Theodore Dreiser, and Frank Norris. Influenced by Charles Darwin, Karl Marx, and Sigmund Freud, these authors applied the principles of scientific determinism to their fiction. Humans are viewed as animals trapped in a constant struggle to survive. They are limited by forces that are beyond their control and even beyond their understanding. Callaghan, like the other naturalistic writers, presents the material in an objective and documentary manner, eschewing moral judgments and optimistic endings. “A Country Passion” • “A Country Passion,” originally printed in Transition, portrays an inarticulate character who is ultimately destroyed by a combination of his in-
176
Short Story Writers
stincts and society’s strictures. Jim Cline loves Ettie Corley, a mentally disabled girl twenty-nine years his junior, who will soon be sent to an asylum. He wants to marry the sixteen-year-old girl, but the minister forbids it because Jim has been in jail, as the reader learns later, for stealing chickens and for fighting. Although unable to marry, Jim nevertheless “had come to an agreement with her any way,” and now he faces a charge of seduction which carries a life sentence. Jim’s interest in Ettie is more than sexual. Out of concern for her, Jim has bought coal and food for Ettie’s family in the winter and clothes for her. She needs him; as the minister comments, “she’s had the worst home in town and something should have been done about it long ago.” Nevertheless, the culture will not accept their union. After being arrested, Jim escapes from jail, harboring the vague notion that “if he could get out he could explain his idea to everybody and get people behind him,” his problem would be solved. Unable to concentrate, he cannot formulate his idea. He is caught and will presumably spend the rest of his life in jail, while Ettie will spend hers in an institution. Though Jim and Ettie struggle to attain happiness, they cannot overcome the forces that oppose them. The depressing outcome is relieved partly by their achieving, even for a brief moment, a sharing of their affection. “Amuck in the Bush” • The naturalistic tone is found throughout the collection. In “Amuck in the Bush,” Gus Rapp is portrayed as an animal, controlled by his instincts. Fired from his lumberyard job, he seeks revenge by attacking the boss’s wife and fiveyear-old daughter. The attack is savage, and only because of his own awkwardness does he not kill them. After the attack, he appears as a mute and uncomprehending animal as he crashes through the forest. Eventually, he is drawn back to the town, where he is captured and roped to a lamppost. “A Wedding Dress” and “An Escapade” • Many of the characters in A Native Argosy are dissatisfied and troubled by vague, unarticulated desires. In “A Wedding Dress,” Lena Schwartz has waited fifteen years to marry. Finally, when her fiancé has a good job, the wedding is scheduled. She longs for a dress that will show her to her advantage and make her desirable to her future husband. Unaware of her own actions, she steals an expensive dress from a store. Regretting the deed, she nevertheless tries on the fancy but ill-fitting dress. Still wearing it, she is arrested. Her fiancé bails her out and takes her into his custody. In “An Escapade,” a middle-aged woman is lonely and repressed. Because of the titillating gossip of her bridge-club friends, Rose Carew misses the service at her Catholic church in order to attend another service being held in a theater. During the service, she is sexually attracted to the man next to her. She does not, however, recognize the emotion; she only knows that she is uncomfortable. She hurriedly leaves, goes to her Catholic church, and prays until she recovers her equanimity. Both of these characters yearn for a change in their lives, but they cannot articulate their desires and are unable to initiate actions that might bring about the desired results. “A Predicament” • Throughout Callaghan’s work appear stories that contain characters, settings, and conflicts that are familiar to Catholics. In “A Predicament,” a young priest hearing confessions must deal with a drunk who has wandered into the confessional booth. The man, thinking that he is on a streetcar, waits for his stop. The priest, ignoring him, hears confessions from the other booth, but it soon becomes apparent that the man will not go away and will probably cause a disturbance. The
Callaghan, Morley
177
priest, young and somewhat insecure, is afraid of any embarrassment. To resolve the issue, the priest slips into the role of a streetcar conductor and announces to the man, “Step lively there; this is King and Young. Do you want to go past your stop?” The drunk quietly leaves. The priest is at first satisfied with his solution, but then his dishonesty bothers him. Earlier, he had chided a woman for telling lies, instructing her that lies lead to worse sins. Unsure of his position, he thinks that he should seek the bishop’s advice but then decides to wait until he can consider his actions more closely. Thus, he postpones what might be a soul-searching encounter. Callaghan, gently and with humor, has shown that priests are no strangers to human weaknesses. In His Own Country • In A Native Argosy, Callaghan included two novellas. One of these, In His Own Country, presents a man who attempts to find a synthesis between religion and science. Although Bill Lawson dreams of becoming a latter-day St. Thomas Aquinas, he is unsuited for the project because of his overwhelming ignorance. Indeed, the task throws him into a catatonic state. Flora, his wife, is concerned first with the income that the project might generate, then with his neglect of her, and finally with his well-being: He does not eat, shave, or take care of his clothes. She longs for the days when they would enjoy the evenings together. Eventually, he quits his job because the small hypocrisies associated with newspaper work taint him, or so he reasons, and render him unsuitable for his grand task. He grows increasingly bewildered as he tries to summarize what is known about geology, chemistry, and the other sciences. At one point, he argues that he can reduce all life to a simple chemical formula. He even converts to Catholicism in order to understand religion better. Finally, returning from a long walk, he discovers his wife with an old beau and dashes out of the house. Flora searches for him, but failing to find him, she retreats to her father’s farm, a three-hour walk from town. Later, Bill is found incoherent on a bench. At first not expected to live, he is force-fed by his mother, and eventually Flora returns to care for him. The town treats Bill as a marvel and admires him for the philosophical thoughts they assume that he is thinking. The ending is ambiguous. Is Bill a prophet, a saint, or a madman? Flora as the point-of-view character is well chosen. Limited in intelligence, she makes no attempt to comprehend Bill’s thoughts, which ultimately drive him to insanity. The sparse, economical prose style matches the limited perceptions of Flora. Bill and Flora belong to the roster of marginal characters in A Native Argosy who lack control over their own lives. Now That April’s Here, and Other Stories • Callaghan’s second collection of short stories, Now That April’s Here, and Other Stories, contains thirty-five stories that were published in magazines from 1929 to 1935. This later work shows the influence of Christian humanism, a belief in a Christian interpretation of the world coupled with a focus on humans’ happiness and an emphasis on the realization of their potential. In 1933, Callaghan spent many hours with Jacques Maritain, the French theologican and philosopher, who was then a visiting scholar at the University of Toronto. Maritain is credited with developing Christian existential thought as a response to Jean-Paul Sartre’s essentially atheistic existentialism. His influence led Callaghan to moderate the strongly pessimistic tone of his fiction. Less naturalistic in tone than the earlier tales, these stories present characters who, while they still cannot greatly alter the courses of their lives, can occasionally achieve a measure of peace, contentment, and dignity. Unlike the inarticulate char-
178
Short Story Writers
acters of the previous volume, these later characters are more intelligent. Matching this change in the characterization, Callaghan’s style is more complex; the sentences are longer and of greater variety as opposed to the pared-down style of the earlier volume. Yet while the style is more mature and the stories more optimistic, there is less variety than in the earlier volume. The stories presented in this collection for the most part follow a set pattern. The equilibrium of the opening is interrupted by a crisis; after the crisis is met, an equilibrium is again established, but some insight is achieved, all within the span of a few hours. “The Blue Kimono” • Many of the selections in Now That April’s Here, and Other Stories depict the struggles of young lovers to overcome the effects of the Depression. In “The Blue Kimono,” George and his wife, Marthe, had come to the city for better opportunities, but since they have arrived in the city, their situation has worsened. Frustrated, George blames his wife for his unemployment. One night, he awakens and discovers Marthe tending their son. The woman is frightened, but George is too frustrated to notice his wife’s concern; all he sees is her tattered blue kimono. He had bought it when they were first married, and now it seems to mock his attempts to secure a job. Gradually, his wife communicates her fears to him; the boy’s symptoms resemble those of infantile paralysis. Immediately, the husband forgets his problems and tries to entertain the little boy. When the boy finally responds to the aspirin, the couple, who have weathered the crisis, are drawn closer. The wife thinks that she can mend the kimono so that it would not appear so ragged. Through their love for each other and for their son, the two have, for a moment, eliminated the tension caused by their poverty. In “The Blue Kimono” as in “A Wedding Dress,” Callaghan uses clothing symbolically. These items suggest a happier moment and reveal the discrepancy between the characters’ dreams and the reality that makes those dreams unattainable. “A Sick Call” • In this story Callaghan utilizes a situation that is familiar to Catholics. In “A Sick Call,” Father Macdowell, an elderly priest, who is often chosen to hear confessions because nothing shocks him, is called to the bedside of a sick woman. Even though she has left the Church, she, afraid of dying, wants to be absolved of her sins. Her husband, John, however, who rejects all religion, opposes the priest’s visit. John is afraid that she will draw close to the Church and thereby reject him, thus destroying the love they share. Yet the priest’s advanced age, his gentleness, and his selective deafness secure for him a place at the side of the woman’s bed. In order to hear her confession, Father Macdowell requests that John leave, but John refuses. Father Macdowell seemingly accepts defeat and in preparation for departing asks the husband for a glass of water. As John complies, the priest quickly hears the woman’s confession and grants absolution. John, returning as the priest is making the sign of the Cross, knows that he has been tricked. The priest leaves with a sense of satisfaction, yet gradually he grows concerned that he came between the wife and her husband. The priest recognizes John’s love for her and remarks on the beauty of such strong love, but then he dismisses it, calling it pagan. He begins to doubt his convictions, however, and allows that perhaps the pagan love is valid. In “A Sick Call,” Callaghan has again presented a priest with human failings; Father Macdowell relies on subterfuge in order to hear a confession. Yet the story is more than a character study of a priest; it is a discussion of what is sacred, and the answer is left ambiguous. Callaghan implies that sacredness is not the sole property of religion.
Callaghan, Morley
179
Morley Callaghan’s Stories • After a ten-year hiatus in writing fiction, Callaghan resumed writing novels and short stories in the late 1940’s. In 1959, he published his third collection of short stories, Morley Callaghan’s Stories. For this, he selected his favorite stories from 1926 to 1953. Twelve had appeared earlier in A Native Argosy, thirty-two in Now That April’s Here, and Other Stories; the remaining thirteen, previously uncollected, had been written between 1936 and 1953. Callaghan in the prologue writes of the stories, “These are the ones that touch times and moods and people I like to remember now. Looking back on them I can see that I have been concerned with the problems of many kinds of people but I have neglected the very, very rich.” These stories, as well as those in the other collections, show a sympathy for beleaguered ordinary human beings and an understanding of their problems. “The Cheat’s Remorse” • In “The Cheat’s Remorse” (reprinted in the 1938 edition of Edward O’Brien’s Best Short Stories), Callaghan focuses on people who have been adversely affected by the Depression. Phil, out of work, is drinking coffee in a diner. Although he has a possibility of a job, he needs a clean shirt before he can go for the interview. Yet his shirts are at the laundry, and he lacks the money to get them. At the diner, he notices a wealthy drunk drop a dollar when he pays the bill for a sandwich he did not even eat. Phil waits until the man leaves. As he stoops to pick up the money, however, a young woman places her foot on it. She, too, has been waiting for the drunk to leave, and she, too, needs the money. Phil offers to flip a coin to resolve the issue. The woman loses. Having used his trick coin, Phil cheated her. Yet immediately he regrets it, tries to give her the dollar, and even confesses his guilt, but she refuses. She argues perceptively that a single dollar could not begin to alleviate her problems but it might make some difference to him. He feels so bad that at the conclusion he is eyeing a tavern, planning to assuage his guilt with alcohol. The characters are affected by economic forces over which they have little or no control. Thus the story has some affinities with the earlier naturalistic tales from A Native Argosy. In “The Cheat’s Remorse,” both the best and the worst are depicted. Phil, selfishly, willingly cheats the woman, but the woman, ignoring her need, offers to help Phil. So even though she is affected by the same forces, she maintains her humanity and dignity. “A Cap for Steve” • Callaghan effectively wrote stories from the point of view of characters who are limited in intelligence, and he was just as effectively able to employ a child’s point of view. In “A Cap for Steve,” Steve, a painfully shy young boy, is obsessed with baseball. His father belittles the sport, however, not realizing that baseball is Steve’s only pleasure. Grudgingly, his father takes him to a baseball game during which Steve acquires the cap of one of the star players. The cap changes Steve into a leader. Yet he loses the cap and becomes despondent. Later he discovers another boy, a lawyer’s son, wearing his cap, and he and his father call on the boy’s father. The difference between the two families is apparent immediately. Steve’s family is barely surviving, while the other boy’s is wealthy. Since the lawyer’s son bought the cap from another, the lawyer offers to sell it to Steve for the price he paid, five dollars. Even though five dollars represents a sacrifice for Steve and his father, they agree. Then the lawyer offers to buy back the cap because his son values it. At twenty dollars, Steve’s father agrees. Stunned, Steve will not walk with his father on the return home. Steve’s father realizes that he does not know his son and resolves to be more of a father. The boy accepts his father’s apology and is willing to forget the cap as “the price
180
Short Story Writers
[he] was willing to pay to be able to count on his father’s admiration and approval.” Although the story is set in the Depression and illustrates class differences, the focus is on the father-and-son relationship. The father does not accept his son until he comes close to losing his love, but the boy is willing to forgive his father’s indifference for the chance at a closer relationship. The emphasis is on the love that can survive under adverse conditions. The Lost and Found Stories of Morley Callaghan • In 1985, Callaghan published a fourth volume of collected stories, The Lost and Found Stories of Morley Callaghan. The twenty-six stories in this volume were originally published in leading magazines in the 1930’s, 1940’s, and 1950’s. During the preparation of Morley Callaghan’s Stories, they had been overlooked, and in 1984, they were “found.” The stories are similar in tone, style, and theme to the work that appears in the other collections. In Callaghan, the inarticulate and the forgotten—the rural and urban poor, the insane, and the mentally weak—have found a voice. Throughout his career, in a straightforward narrative style, he told their story. Although Callaghan might not have received the recognition he deserves, he nevertheless should be studied. As one reviewer has written, Callaghan “sits across the path of Canadian literature like an old Labrador, you’re not sure how to approach him, but you can’t ignore him.” Barbara Wiedemann With updates by Jill Rollins Other major works children’s literature: Luke Baldwin’s Vow, 1948. plays: Turn Home Again, pr. 1940 (also known as Going Home); To Tell the Truth, pr. 1949; Season of the Witch, pb. 1976. novels: Strange Fugitive, 1928; It’s Never Over, 1930; No Man’s Meat, 1931 (novella); A Broken Journey, 1932; Such Is My Beloved, 1934; They Shall Inherit the Earth, 1935; More Joy in Heaven, 1937; The Varsity Story, 1948; The Loved and the Lost, 1951; The Many Coloured Coat, 1960; A Passion in Rome, 1961; A Fine and Private Place, 1975; Season of the Witch, 1976; Close to the Sun Again, 1977; “No Man’s Meat,” and “The Enchanted Pimp,” 1978; A Time for Judas, 1983; Our Lady of the Snows, 1985; A Wild Old Man on the Road, 1988. nonfiction: That Summer in Paris: Memories of Tangled Friendships with Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and Some Others, 1963; Winter, 1974. Bibliography Boire, Gary A. Morley Callaghan: Literary Anarchist. Toronto: ECW Press, 1994. Very good biography of Callaghan. Includes bibliographical references. Cude, Wilfred. “Morley Callaghan’s Practical Monsters: Downhill from Where and When?” In Modern Times. Vol. 3 in The Canadian Novel, edited by John Moss. Toronto: NC Press, 1982. This florid essay treats the darker side of Callaghan’s vision through a discussion of characterization in several of his short stories and in some of his novels. Gadpaille, Michelle. The Canadian Short Story. Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1988. Includes a brief discussion of Callaghan’s short-story writing career, commenting on his working-class characters, the simplicity of his style, and his contribution to the development of the modern Canadian short story.
Callaghan, Morley
181
Kendle, Judith. “Morley Callaghan: An Annotated Bibliography.” In The Annotated Bibliography of Canada’s Major Authors, edited by Robert Lecker and Jack David. Vol. 5. Toronto: ECW Press, 1984. Contains the most exhaustive listing of primary sources and secondary sources for Callaghan’s work up to 1984 that a student is likely to need. The categories cover the spectrum from books and articles to interviews to audiovisual material. A helpful “Index to Critics Listed in the Bibliography” is also included. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Callaghan: “All the Years of Her Life” and “A Cap for Steve” (vol. 1), “The Faithful Wife” (vol. 3), “Now That April’s Here” (vol. 5), and “A Sick Call” (vol. 7). Morley, Patricia. Morley Callaghan. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1978. This study considers Callaghan’s fiction to the mid-1970’s, including thorough, useful analysis of his short fiction. Stuewe, Paul. “The Case of Morley Callaghan.” In Clearing the Ground: English-Canadian Fiction After “Survival.” Toronto: Proper Tales Press, 1984. In this chapter, Stuewe takes Callaghan to task for sloppy writing and his critics to task for concentrating on Callaghan’s thematic concerns to the exclusion of his technical flaws. Stuewe’s own writing and tone are lively and incisive. Tracey, Grant. “One Great Way to Read Short Stories: Studying Character Deflection in Morley Callaghan’s ‘All the Years of Her Life.’” In Short Stories in the Classroom, edited by Carole L. Hamilton and Peter Kratzke. Urbana, Ill.: National Council of Teachers of English, 1999. Analysis of the story through the perspective of how events affect and change a single character. Woodcock, George. “Possessing the Land: Notes on Canadian Fiction.” In The Canadian Imagination: Dimensions of a Literary Culture, edited by David Staines. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1977. Callaghan’s fiction is discussed in the context of Canadian fiction and its development and direction since the nineteenth century. The student is provided with a valuable overview that underscores the significance of Callaghan’s contribution to Canadian literature.
182
Truman Capote Born: New Orleans, Louisiana; September 30, 1924 Died: Los Angeles, California; August 25, 1984 Principal short fiction • A Tree of Night, and Other Stories, 1949; Breakfast at Tiffany’s: A Short Novel and Three Stories, 1958; One Christmas, 1983; I Remember Grandpa: A Story, 1986; The Complete Collected Stories of Truman Capote, 2004. Other literary forms • In addition to stories and short novels, Truman Capote wrote travel sketches and various kinds of nonfiction, much of which has been collected, along with some of Capote’s short stories and novellas, in A Capote Reader (1987). The volume Local Color (1950), on the other hand, is a collection solely of travel essays. Capote also did some screenwriting, including critically well-received scripts for Beat the Devil (1954) and The Innocents (1961), an adaptation of the Henry James story The Turn of the Screw (1898), and an adaptation of Breakfast at Tiffany’s, which became a well-known film in 1961. In Cold Blood (1966), probably his most famous work, is a “nonfiction novel,” a documented re-creation of the murder of a family in Kansas. The novel was both a critical and a popular success, and the television film version won an Emmy Award in 1967. Capote’s last work, another nonfiction novel, Answered Prayers: The Unfinished Novel (1986), set off a social scandal with its gossipy revelations. Capote finished his writing career in ignominy. In 2004, the handwritten manuscript of a novel that Capote had composed when he was only nineteen turned up in a Sotheby’s auction. The following year, that book was published as Summer Crossing. The brief story is about a young woman left on her own in a Manhattan penthouse, as the rest of her family are traveling abroad. Though immature and often confused, the book shows many signs of Capote’s later strengths as a writer. Achievements • The best of Truman Capote’s writing is regarded as elegant prose, noted for its lucidity, although at its worst it became an example of vain excess and gossip. Yet Capote was one of the United States’ leading post-World War II writers. He pioneered the genre of the “nonfiction novel” with In Cold Blood and gained renown for his short stories and novellas. His story “Miriam” won the O. Henry Memorial Award in 1943, and “Shut a Final Door” won the same prize in 1946. Although much of his work has been both critically and popularly praised, Capote was rarely formally recognized during his writing career. Biography • Because his parents were divorced when he was four years old, Truman Capote was reared by aunts and cousins in a small town in Alabama. At the age of seventeen, he moved to New York City and worked his way up from mailroom clerk to feature writer for The New Yorker. Capote’s early promise seemed fulfilled with the success of In Cold Blood, and he spent many years traveling around the world as a celebrated author. He became the pet celebrity for a number of high-society women, most notably Barbara “Babe” Paley and Lee Bouvier Radziwill, sister of Jacqueline Kennedy
Capote, Truman Onassis. His charmed life seemed to fade, however, under the pressure of trying to produce another successful novel. During the 1970’s and early 1980’s, Capote’s health was ruined by alcoholism and drug dependency. The downslide began in 1975, however, when Esquire magazine published Capote’s story “La Côte Basque: 1965.” The story was a thinly veiled exposé of the scandals of the rich and famous, and its targets did not appreciate the publicity. Capote’s friends immediately ostracized him, and he became persona non grata in many of the places he had previously frequented. Depressed by the reaction that his story generated, Capote became reclusive. His work deteriorated even more, and he did not produce anything to rival his earlier writing before he died at the home of his longtime friend Joanne Carson in 1984.
183
Library of Congress
Analysis • Truman Capote’s stories are best known for their mysterious, dreamlike occurrences. As his protagonists try to go about their ordinary business, they meet with unexpected obstacles—usually in the form of haunting, enigmatic strangers. Corresponding to some childhood memory or to someone the protagonist once knew, these people take on huge proportions and cause major changes in the character’s life. The central figures of these stories are usually people who have left their hometowns, who travel, or who live alone, for they seem most vulnerable to chance encounters. Their isolation gives them the time, and their loneliness gives them the motivation to see these experiences through to their conclusions—and often with great risk. Capote was a careful craftsman. His words are meticulously chosen for their evocative power, and, at their best, they create highly charged images and symbols. His descriptions of the seasons or weather further heighten the effects he wants to create. Snow, rain, dusk, and sunlight serve to separate the particular setting from a larger landscape, thus reinforcing the self-reflexive nature of his stories. Attics, kitchens, one-room walk-ups, and isolated apartments are typical settings that also provide sequestered settings. The atmosphere, location, characters, and events present a touching but often chilling and ominous beauty. The combination of reality and dream also produces an eerie beauty. “A Tree of Night” • In “A Tree of Night,” one of his finest stories, Kay is a young, attractive student returning to college after the funeral of an uncle. It is late on a winter night, bare and icy, when she boards the train from the deserted platform. Taking the only available seat, she sits opposite an odd-looking couple. The woman is in her
184
Short Story Writers
fifties, with a huge head and a dwarfish body, while the man is mute, with marblelike eyes and an expressionless face. Although Kay is initially polite, she hopes to be left alone, but the woman wants company and conversation. Kay tries to remain distant, but the woman and man are persistent and aggressive. Without any warning, the man reaches toward Kay and strokes her cheek. Her reaction is immediate but confused: She is repelled by the boldness of the gesture while, at the same time, she is touched by the delicacy. From this point on, Kay seems to view the man and woman as harbingers of danger. Capote’s style remains realistic and his tone objective, but the couple behave as though they are part of Kay’s nightmare. The woman talks endlessly, always wanting a response from her listener. She forces Kay to drink liquor with her and even grabs her wrist. As in a nightmare, Kay wants to scream and awaken the other passengers, but no sounds come out. Trying to escape from the woman’s irritating voice, Kay has a reverie as she stares into the void face of the man, and suddenly his face and her uncle’s dead face blend. She sees, or imagines that she sees, a shared secret and a stillness. This association of the stranger with someone from her past is deadly, preparing the reader for the end of the story. By degrees, the man assumes control over Kay. He takes from his pocket a peach seed and fondles it gently. The woman insists that he only wants Kay to purchase it as a good-luck charm, but Kay is frightened, interpreting his action as some kind of warning. Trying to avoid the man, she leaves her seat for the observation platform and fresh air, but soon she senses someone beside her and knows that it must be the man. Now, without the distracting annoyance of the woman, Kay understands why she finds him so threatening. Unable to speak or to hear, he is like her uncle, dead, and the dead can haunt. She further recognizes him as a figure from her childhood dreams, the boogeyman, the “wizard-man,” the mysterious personage that could bring alive “terrors that once, long ago, had hovered above her like haunted limbs on a tree of night.” Kay’s submission is unquestionable, but precisely what she submits to is left ambiguous. Together, she and the man return to their seats, and she gives him money for the peach seed. Then the woman takes possession of Kay’s whole purse and, although Kay wants to shout, she does not. Finally the woman takes Kay’s raincoat and pulls it “like a shroud” over her head. No longer struggling, Kay sinks into a strange passivity. “A Tree of Night” raises many questions but provides few answers. The characters are realistically presented, but eccentric, to say the least. Kay is not wholly convincing, yet is still three-dimensional. It is rather the events themselves that appear unlikely and nightmarish, but since Capote delights in paradox, his story cannot be classified as either pure dream or simple reality. Why does Kay not protest? To what extent do she and the mute actually communicate? Is the submission of the young girl carefully planned by the couple? Are the two travelers real passengers who want to do her harm, or can they be projections from Kay’s psyche? Or are they merely two unique strangers to whom Kay attributes much more power than they really have? These ambiguities are the source of both the story’s weaknesses and its strengths; they enrich the encounter and abstract it, but they also leave the reader feeling baffled. Nevertheless, Capote seems to imply that human beings are extremely vulnerable to destructive instincts. Perhaps beginning with a memory or fear from deep within the psyche, one projects it and expands it until it acquires a frightening degree of reality. In fact, it may become a deadly kind of reality. Kay essentially wills herself first into isolation from other passengers and finally into submission. She returns
Capote, Truman
185
from the observation platform accompanied by the stranger. She chooses neither to change her seat nor to scream. Eventually, she chooses not to struggle. Human beings are delicate creatures, and the power of the “wizard-man” is enough to cause Kay to sink into nightmarish and unnecessary helplessness. “Master Misery” • The mysterious realm of dream can invade the workaday world and then consume it. This is precisely what happens in “Master Misery” when Sylvia leaves her hometown of Easton to stay with married friends who live in New York City. Soon she becomes frustrated with her daily routine and her “namby-pamby, bootsytotsy” friends. Hoping to earn money to find her own apartment, Sylvia overhears a conversation in the Automat. As unlikely as it sounds, a certain Mr. Revercomb purchases dreams. Intrigued, Sylvia visits his Fifth Avenue brownstone and discovers that Mr. Revercomb does indeed purchase dreams for cash. As she continues to visit his office, events take an unfortunate turn. The more Sylvia sees him, the more he seems eccentric, even unnatural. One time as she whispers her dream, Mr. Revercomb bends forward to brush her ear with his lips, apparently in a sexual approach. Sylvia becomes so obsessed with selling her dreams that everything else in her life loses significance. She cuts off communication with her married friends, quits her office job, and rents a dingy studio apartment. Her only friend is Oreilly, a former clown whom she meets in Mr. Revercomb’s waiting room. They have much in common, for Oreilly used to sell his dreams also, but now Mr. Revercomb has no use for them. Although he spends most of his time drunk, Oreilly has the foresight to warn his new companion against the man he calls the Master of Misery, who is so adept at convincing people that parting with a dream is worth five dollars. He explains to Sylvia that she must not lose her independence or her private world of memory and dream, and he compares Mr. Revercomb with the demon of childhood nightmare, the ominous figure who haunted the trees, chimneys, attics, and graveyards of makebelieve. Like the mute in “A Tree of Night,” Revercomb is “a thief and a threat,” for after he appropriates one’s dreams, it is a short passage to one’s subconscious and one’s soul. Sylvia’s life contracts to unhappy proportions. She moves from Revercomb’s waiting room back to Oreilly, her waiting companion, who commiserates with her shrinking self before consuming the liquor she buys with her dream-money. He does, however, advise her to ask Revercomb for her dreams back, provided that she gradually returns the money over a period of time. Sylvia agrees, for her life has become miserable and isolated, but this is a Faustian story, and what was spent cannot be retrieved. Revercomb informs Sylvia that under no circumstances would he return what she has sold and, besides, he has already used them up. Walking home in the falling snow, Sylvia acknowledges that she is no longer her own master and has no individuality; soon she will not have even Oreilly, who will go his own way. Thinking she used Revercomb, it turns out that he has used her, and now they are inseparable—until he discards her as he did Oreilly. The story concludes as Sylvia overhears footsteps following behind. There are two boys, who have followed her from the park and continue to do so. Sylvia is frightened, but like Kay in “A Tree of Night,” she becomes passive and submissive, for there is “nothing left to steal.” As in much of Capote’s short fiction, the individual tacitly gives a stranger enormous power. Once Sylvia abdicates full responsibility for herself and enters Revercomb’s world, she becomes vulnerable and he becomes omniscient. Gradually
186
Short Story Writers
she is emptied of friends, an orderly routine, ambition, desire, and, finally, of selfpossession. The reader can never be sure who Revercomb is or what he does with dreams, but Sylvia, not the Master of Misery, is the focus of interest. She allows him to create her misery, leaving her with no one, not even her former self. Capote’s early work especially makes use of the gothic tradition, but because the details remain realistic and controlled, the mysterious elements are subtle and therefore even more insidious. The “wizard-man” is Capote’s archetype—the mute in “A Tree of Night,” Mr. Revercomb in “Master Misery,” the young girl in “Miriam,” Mr. Destronelli in “The Headless Hawk.” This figure transforms the actual world of the protagonist, usually in undesirable and irreversible ways. Whether the encounter with this stranger is a final retreat into narcissism or a submission to a purely external presence may not be clarified, but the fragility of the human psyche is all too clear. Miriam Fuchs With updates by Jo-Ellen Lipman Boon and the Editors Other major works plays: The Grass Harp: A Play, pr., pb. 1952 (adaptation of his novel); House of Flowers, pr. 1954 (with Harold Arlen). novels: Summer Crossing, wr. 1943, pb. 2005; Other Voices, Other Rooms, 1948; The Grass Harp, 1951; A Christmas Memory, 1956 (serial); In Cold Blood, 1966; The Thanksgiving Visitor, 1967 (serial); Answered Prayers: The Unfinished Novel, 1986. miscellaneous: Selected Writings, 1963; Trilogy: An Experiment in Multimedia, 1969 (with Eleanor Perry and Frank Perry); Music for Chameleons, 1980; A Capote Reader, 1987; Too Brief a Treat: The Letters of Truman Capote, 2004 (edited by Gerald Clarke). nonfiction: Local Color, 1950; The Muses Are Heard, 1956; Observations, 1959 (with Richard Avedon); The Dogs Bark: Public People and Private Places, 1973. screenplays: Beat the Devil, 1954 (with John Huston); The Innocents, 1961. Bibliography Brinnin, John Malcolm. Truman Capote: Dear Heart, Old Buddy. Rev. ed. New York: Delacorte Press, 1986. Chronicles Capote’s life from before the success of In Cold Blood to his ruin from alcoholism and drugs. Most useful is the insight into the literary circles in which Capote moved. Includes an index. Clarke, Gerald. Capote: A Biography. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1988. Arguably the definitive biographical work on Capote, this lengthy text covers all the ups and downs of his career. Contains copious references and an index. Garson, Helen S. Truman Capote: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Divided into three sections: a critical analysis of the short fiction, an exploration of Capote’s biography and his “inventing a self,” and a selection of essays by Capote’s most important critics. Also includes a chronology and bibliography. Grobel, Lawrence. Conversations with Capote. New York: New American Library, 1985. This biography uses interview material to flesh out its information. Grobel covers Capote’s life from childhood to his fall from society’s grace and his subsequent death. In chapter 4, entitled “Writing,” Capote discusses his writing career and the authors who he believed had the greatest influence on him. Includes a brief primary bibliography that lists films that Capote scripted and an index. Hardwick, Elizabeth. “Tru Confessions.” The New York Review of Books 45 (January 15, 1998): 4-5. Discusses George Plimpton’s recording the remarks of those who came
Capote, Truman
187
into contact with Capote’s journey to literary fame; notes that Plimpton arranges these voices to produce the effect of the unrehearsed, companionable exchange at a cocktail party; argues that the method and result suit their subject, given that Capote, when not writing, was partying, forever receiving and producing banter. Inge, M. Thomas, ed. Truman Capote: Conversations. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1987. This book is a collection of interviews with Capote done by interviewers who range from Gloria Steinem to George Plimpton to Capote himself, in a section called “Self-Portrait.” The index allows the reader to find specific references to individual short stories. Long, Robert Emmet. “Truman Capote.” In Critical Survey of Long Fiction, Revised Edition, edited by Carl Rollyson. Vol. 2. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2000. Analysis of Capote’s longer fictional works that may offer insights into his short fiction. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these six short stories by Capote: “Children on Their Birthdays” and “A Christmas Memory” (vol. 2); “The Headless Hawk” (vol. 3); “Miriam” and “My Side of the Matter” (vol. 5); and “A Tree of Night” (vol. 7). Plimpton, George. Truman Capote: In Which Various Friends, Enemies, Acquaintances, and Detractors Recall His Turbulent Career. New York: Doubleday, 1997. This biography based on interviews provides dramatic, primary information, but it also must be checked against the more reliable biography by Gerald Clarke. Includes biographies of contributors and a chronology. Windham, Donald. Lost Friendships: A Memoir of Truman Capote, Tennessee Williams, and Others. New York: William Morrow, 1987. A friend of the major literary lights of the 1950’s and 1960’s, as well as a novelist himself, Windham dedicates the first half of Lost Friendships to his relationship with Capote and its subsequent decline. No reference material is included.
188
Raymond Car ver Born: Clatskanie, Oregon; May 25, 1938 Died: Port Angeles, Washington; August 2, 1988 Principal short fiction • Put Yourself in My Shoes, 1974; Will You Please Be Quiet, Please?, 1976; Furious Seasons, and Other Stories, 1977; What We Talk About When We Talk About Love, 1981; Cathedral, 1983; Elephant, and Other Stories, 1988; Where I’m Calling From, 1988; Short Cuts: Selected Stories, 1993. Other literary forms • Raymond Carver distinguished himself as a short-story writer and poet, and he wrote in both forms until his death. His poetry has been published in the following collections: Near Klamath (1968), Winter Insomnia (1970), At Night the Salmon Move (1976), Two Poems (1982), Fires: Essays, Poems, Stories (1983), If It Please You (1984), This Water (1985), Where Water Comes Together with Other Water (1985), Ultramarine (1986), and A New Path to the Waterfall (1989). Achievements • Raymond Carver’s greatest achievement was overcoming his economically and culturally disadvantaged background to become an author of world renown. He made the short story a workable literary form; since Carver, short-story collections have again become a marketable commodity in the book trade. Both as a model and as a teacher, he had such an influence on younger fiction writers that author Jay McInerney could truthfully say (alluding to a famous statement that Fyodor Dostoevski made about Nikolai Gogol) that there is hardly a single American shortstory writer younger than Carver who did not “come out of Carver’s overcoat.” With only a bachelor’s degree and mediocre grades, Carver was invited to teach at distinguished universities and became a professor of English at Syracuse University in 1980. He received many honors during his lifetime, including a Strauss Living Award, which guaranteed him an annual stipend of thirty-five thousand dollars and enabled him to devote all his time to writing during the last years of his life. Just before his death, he received a doctorate of letters from the University of Hartford. Biography • Raymond Carver grew up in a sparsely populated corner of the Pacific Northwest. This rustic environment had an indelible effect upon his character and writing. Like Ernest Hemingway, one of the writers who influenced him, he loved the purity and freedom of the American wilderness, and he also respected the simplicity, honesty, and directness of the men and women who earned meager and precarious livelihoods in that primitive setting. He married young and had two children to support by the time he was twenty. He had wanted to be a writer from the time he was in the third grade, but the responsibilities of parenthood made it extremely difficult for him to find time to write. His limited education forced him to take menial jobs for which he was temperamentally unsuited. He was unable to consider tackling anything as ambitious as a full-length novel, so he spent his odd free hours writing short stories and poetry. He managed to get some of his work published in little magazines, but these publications paid little or nothing for his work, so he was haunted by financial problems for much of his life.
Carver, Raymond
189
One of the most important influences in Carver’s life was John Gardner (1933-1982), who taught creative writing at California State University at Chico and said, “You cannot be a great writer unless you feel greatly.” The idealistic Gardner introduced his students to the literary magazines TO VIEW IMAGE, that represented the cutting edge in contemporary American fiction and PLEASE SEE poetry, and he urged them to write PRINT EDITION honestly about what they knew, as OF THIS BOOK. opposed to turning out formula fiction in an attempt to make money. This is exactly what Carver did, and, ironically, he found that the hardships and distractions that were preventing him from writing were the very things that provided him with material to write about. This may account for the characteristic stoical humor to be found in many of his sto© Marion Ettlinger ries. Another profound influence in his life was alcohol. One of Carver’s distinguishing traits as a writer is his astonishing candor, and anyone who reads a dozen of his short stories will get a good idea of what his life was like for nearly two decades. His drinking caused serious domestic and financial problems, which led to feelings of guilt and more drinking. Amazingly, his strong constitution and unwavering motivation enabled him to continue producing stories and poems. With the publication of What We Talk About When We Talk About Love in 1981, Carver achieved critical and popular fame. His financial problems were ameliorated because he was receiving valuable grants and teaching assignments and was also selling his work to high-paying, slick magazines such as Esquire, Harper’s Bazaar, Playgirl, and The New Yorker. Collections of his short stories sold well. He was earning money teaching creative writing courses and appearing as a featured attraction at many workshops and seminars. By the late 1970’s, Carver had separated from his first wife and was living with the poet and teacher Tess Gallagher. She helped him cope with his drinking problem and provided a much-needed stabilizing influence. Carver, always a heavy cigarette smoker, died of lung cancer in 1988. By that time, his works had been published all over the world in more than twenty languages. Analysis • Nearly everything written about Raymond Carver begins with two observations: He is a minimalist, and he writes about working-class people. Even when the critic is sympathetic, this dual categorization tends to stigmatize Carver as a minor artist writing little stories about little people. Although it is true that most of Carver’s characters belong to the working class, their problems are universal. Carver writes about divorce, infidelity, spiritual alienation, alcoholism, bankruptcy, rootlessness,
190
Short Story Writers
and existential dread; none of these afflictions is peculiar to the working class, and in fact, all were once more common to members of the higher social classes. Carver was a minimalist by preference and by necessity. His lifelong experience had been with working-class people. It would have been inappropriate to write about simple people in an ornate style, and, furthermore, his limited education would have made it impossible for him to do so effectively. The spare, objective style that he admired in some of Hemingway’s short stories, such as “The Killers” and “Hills Like White Elephants,” was perfectly suited to Carver’s needs. The advantage and appeal of minimalism in literature is that it draws readers into the story by forcing them to conceptualize missing details. One drawback is that it allows insecure writers to imply that they know more than they know and mean more than they are actually saying. This was true of the early stories that Carver collected in Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? A good example of Carver’s strengths and weaknesses is a short story in that volume titled “Fat.” “Fat” • As the title suggests, “Fat” is about a fat man. It is little more than a character sketch; nothing happens in the story. Throughout his career, Carver based stories and poems on people or incidents that he observed or scraps of conversation that he overheard; these things seemed to serve as living metaphors or symbols with broader implications. Carver frames his story by setting it in a restaurant and by describing the fat man from the point of view of a waitress. She says that she has never seen such a fat person in her life and is somewhat awestruck by his appearance, by his gracious manners, and by the amount of food that he can consume at one sitting. After she goes home at night, she is still thinking about him. She says that she herself feels “terrifically fat”; she feels depressed, and finally ends by saying, “My life is going to change. I feel it.” The reader can feel it too but might be hard pressed to say what “it” is. The story leaves a strong impression but an ambiguous one. No two readers would agree on what the story means, if anything. It demonstrates Carver’s talent for characterization through dialogue and action, which was his greatest asset. Both the waitress and her fat customer come alive as people, partially through the deliberate contrast between them. His treatment of the humble, kindly waitress demonstrates his sensitivity to the feelings of women. His former wife, Maryann Carver, said of him, “Ray loved and understood women, and women loved him.” “Fat” also shows Carver’s unique sense of humor, which was another trait that set him apart from other writers. Carver was so constituted that he could not help seeing the humorous side of the tragic or the grotesque. His early, experimental short stories most closely resemble the early short stories of William Saroyan reprinted in The Daring Young Man on the Flying Trapeze, and Other Stories (1934) and subsequent collections of his stories that appeared in the 1930’s. Saroyan is perhaps best remembered for his novel The Human Comedy (1943), and it might be said that the human comedy was Carver’s theme and thesis throughout his career. Like the early stories of Saroyan, Carver’s stories are the tentative vignettes of a novice who knows very well that he wants to be a writer but still does not know exactly what he wants to say. “Neighbors” • Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? includes the tragicomic “Neighbors,” the first of Carver’s stories to appear in a slick magazine with a large circulation. Gordon Lish, editor of the men’s magazine Esquire, recognized Carver’s talent early but did not immediately accept any of his submissions. Lish’s welcome encourage-
Carver, Raymond
191
ment, painful rejections, and eventual acceptance represented major influences in Carver’s career. “Neighbors” deals with ordinary people but has a surrealistic humor, which was to become a Carver trademark. Bill and Arlene Miller, a couple in their thirties, have agreed to feed their neighbors’ cat and water the plants while they are away. The Stones’ apartment holds a mysterious fascination, and they both find excuses to enter it more often than necessary. Bill helps himself to the Chivas Regal, eats food out of their refrigerator, and goes through their closets and dresser drawers. He tries on some of Jim Stone’s clothes and lies on their bed masturbating. Then he goes so far as to try on Harriet Stone’s brassiere and panties and then a skirt and blouse. Bill’s wife also disappears into the neighbors’ apartment on her own mysterious errands. They fantasize that they have assumed the identities of their neighbors, whom they regard as happier people leading fuller lives. The shared guilty adventure arouses both Bill and Arlene sexually, and they have better lovemaking than they have experienced in a long while. Then disaster strikes: Arlene discovers that she has inadvertently locked the Stones’ key inside the apartment. The cat may starve; the plants may wither; the Stones may find evidence that they have been rummaging through their possessions. The story ends with the frightened Millers clinging to each other outside their lost garden of Eden. This early story displays some of Carver’s strengths: his sense of humor, his powers of description, and his ability to characterize people through what they do and say. It also has the two main qualities that editors look for: timeliness and universality. It is therefore easy to understand why Lish bought this piece after rejecting so many others. “Neighbors” portrays the alienated condition of many contemporary Americans of all social classes. “Neighbors,” however, has certain characteristics that have allowed hostile critics to damn Carver’s stories as “vignettes,” “anecdotes,” “sketches,” and “slices-of-life.” For one thing, readers realize that the terror they briefly share with the Millers is unnecessary: They can go to the building manager for a passkey or call a locksmith. It is hard to understand how two people who are so bold about violating their neighbors’ apartment should suddenly feel so helpless in the face of an everyday mishap. The point of the story is blunted by the unsatisfactory ending. What We Talk About When We Talk About Love • The publication of the collection titled What We Talk About When We Talk About Love made Carver famous. These short, rather ambiguous stories also got him permanently saddled with the term “minimalist.” Carver never accepted that label and claimed that he did not even understand what it meant. He had a healthy mistrust of critics who attempted to categorize writers with such epithets: It was as if he sensed their antagonism and felt that they themselves were trying to “minimize” him as an author. A friend of Carver said that he thought a minimalist was a “taker-out” rather than a “putter-in.” In that sense, Carver was a minimalist. It was his practice to go over and over his stories trying to delete all superfluous words and even superfluous punctuation marks. He said that he knew he was finished with a story when he found himself putting back punctuation marks that he had previously deleted. It would be more accurate to call Carver a perfectionist than a minimalist. “Why Don’t You Dance?” • One of the best short stories reprinted in What We Talk About When We Talk About Love is “Why Don’t You Dance?” It is one of the most repre-
192
Short Story Writers
sentative, the most “Carveresque” of all Carver’s short stories. A man who is never given a name has placed all of his furniture and personal possessions outside on the front lawn and has whimsically arranged them as if they were still indoors. He has run an extension cord from the house and hooked up lamps, a television, and a record player. He is sitting outside drinking whiskey, totally indifferent to the amazement and curiosity of his neighbors. One feels as if the worst is over for him: He is the survivor of some great catastrophe, like a marooned sailor who has managed to salvage some flotsam and jetsam. A young couple, referred to throughout the story as “the boy” and “the girl,” drive by and assume that the man is holding a yard sale. They stop and inquire about prices. The man offers them drinks. The boy and girl get into a party spirit. They put old records on the turntable and start dancing in the driveway. The man is eager to get rid of his possessions and accepts whatever they are willing to offer. He even makes them presents of things that they do not really want. Weeks later, the girl is still talking about the man, but she cannot find the words to express what she really feels about the incident. Perhaps she and her young friends will understand the incident much better after they have worked and worried and bickered and moved from one place to another for ten or twenty years. “Why Don’t You Dance?” is a humorous treatment of a serious subject, in characteristic Carver fashion. The man’s tragedy is never spelled out, but the reader can piece the story together quite easily from the clues. Evidently there has been a divorce or separation. Evidently there were financial problems, which are so often associated with divorce, and the man has been evicted. Judging from the fact that he is doing so much drinking, alcoholism is either the cause or the effect of his other problems. The man has given up all hope and now sees hope only in other people, represented by this young couple just starting out in life and trying to collect a few pieces of furniture for their rented apartment. Divorce, infidelity, domestic strife, financial worry, bankruptcy, alcoholism, rootlessness, consumerism as a substitute for intimacy, and disillusionment with the American Dream are common themes throughout Carver’s stories. The symbol of a man sitting outside on his front lawn drinking whiskey, with all of his worldly possessions placed around him but soon to be scattered to the four winds, is a striking symbol of modern human beings. It is easy to acquire possessions but nearly impossible to keep a real home. Carver did not actually witness such an event but had a similar episode described to him by a friend and eventually used it in this story. A glance at the titles of some of Carver’s stories shows his penchant for finding in his mundane environment external symbols of subjective states: “Fat,” “Gazebo,” “Vitamins,” “Feathers,” “Cathedral,” “Boxes,” “Menudo.” The same tendency is even more striking in the titles of his poems, for example, “The Car,” “Jean’s TV,” “NyQuil,” “My Dad’s Wallet,” “The Phone Booth,” “Heels.” In his famous essay “The Philosophy of Composition,” Edgar Allan Poe wrote that he wanted an image that would be “emblematical of Mournful and Never-ending Remembrance,” so he created his famous raven perched on the bust of Pallas Athena and croaking the refrain “nevermore.” To highlight the difference in Carver’s method, Carver might have seen a real raven perched on a real statue, and it would have suggested mournful and never-ending remembrance. This kind of “reverse symbolism” seems characteristic of modern American minimalists in general, and Carver’s influence on their movement is paramount.
Carver, Raymond
193
Poe states that he originally thought of using a parrot in his famous poem but rejected that notion because it did not seem sufficiently poetic and might have produced a comical effect; if Carver had been faced with such a choice, he probably would have chosen the parrot. What distinguishes Carver from most minimalists is a sense of humor that is impervious to catastrophe: Like the man on the front lawn, Carver had been so far down that everyplace else looked better. He would have concurred heartily with William Shakespeare’s often-quoted lines in As You Like It (pr. c. 1599-1600): Sweet are the uses of adversity, Which, like a toad, ugly and venomous, Wears yet a precious jewel in his head On a different level, “Why Don’t You Dance?” reflects Carver’s maturation as a person and an author. The responsibilities of parenthood as well as the experience of teaching young students were bringing home to him the fact that his personal problems could hold instructional utility for others. As a teacher of creative writing, placed more and more in the limelight, interacting with writers, editors, professors, and interviewers, he was being forced to formulate his own artistic credo. The older man in the story sees himself in his young yard-sale customers and wants to help them along in life; this is evidently a reflection of the author’s own attitude. Consequently, the story itself is not merely an autobiographical protest or lament like some of Carver’s earlier works but is designed to deliver a message—perhaps a warning—for the profit of others. The melancholy wisdom of Carver’s protagonist reflects Carver’s own mellowing as he began to appreciate the universally tragic nature of human existence. “Where I’m Calling From” • “Where I’m Calling From” is a great American short story. It originally appeared in the prestigious The New Yorker, was reprinted in the collection titled Cathedral, and appears once again as the title story in the best and most comprehensive collection of Carver’s stories, Where I’m Calling From. The story is narrated by an alcoholic staying at a “drying-out facility,” an unpretentious boardinghouse where plain meals are served family style and there is nothing to do but read, watch television, or talk. The bucolic atmosphere is strongly reminiscent of the training-camp scenes in one of Hemingway’s most brilliant short stories, “Fifty Grand.” The narrator in Carver’s story tells about his drinking problems and interweaves his own biography with that of a friend he has made at the drying-out facility, a man he refers to as J. P. The only thing unusual about their stories is that J. P. is a chimney sweep and is married to a chimney sweep. Both J. P. and the narrator ruined their marriages through their compulsive drinking and are now terrified that they will be unable to control their craving once they get out of the facility. They have made vows of abstinence often enough before and have not kept them. They have dried out before and gone right back to the bottle. Carver manages to convey all the feelings of guilt, remorse, terror, and helplessness experienced by people who are in the ultimate stages of alcoholism. It is noteworthy that, whereas his alcoholic protagonists of earlier stories were often isolated individuals, the protagonist-narrator of “Where I’m Calling From” not only is actively seeking help but also is surrounded by others with the same problem. This feature indicates that Carver had come to realize that the way to give his stories the point or
194
Short Story Writers
meaning that they had previously often lacked was to suggest the existence of largescale social problems of which his characters are victims. He had made what author Joan Didion called “the quantum leap” of realizing that his personal problems were actually social problems. The curse of alcoholism affects all social classes; even people who never touch a drop of alcohol can have their lives ruined by it. “The Bridle” • “The Bridle” first appeared in The New Yorker and was reprinted in Cathedral. It is an example of Carver’s mature period, a highly artistic story fraught with social significance. The story is told from the point of view of one of Carver’s faux-naïf narrators. Readers immediately feel that they know this good-natured soul, a woman named Marge who manages an apartment building in Arizona and “does hair” as a sideline. She tells about one of the many families who stayed a short while and then moved on as tumbleweeds being blown across the desert. Although Car ver typically writes about Northern California and the Pacific Northwest, this part of Arizona is also “Car ver Countr y,” a world of freeways, fast-food restaurants, Laundromats, mindless television entertainment, and transient living accommodations, a homogenized world of strangers with minimum-wage jobs and tabloid mentalities. Mr. Holits pays the rent in cash every month, suggesting that he recently went bankrupt and has neither a bank account nor credit cards. Carver, like minimalists in general, loves such subtle clues. Mrs. Holits confides to Marge that they had owned a farm in Minnesota. Her husband, who “knows everything there is about horses,” still keeps one of his bridles, evidently symbolizing his hope that he may escape from “Carver Country.” Mrs. Holits proves more adaptable: She gets a job as a waitress, a favorite occupation among Carver characters. Her husband, however, cannot adjust to the service industry jobs, which are all that are available to a man his age with his limited experience. He handles the money, the two boys are his sons by a former marriage, and he has been accustomed to making the decisions, yet he finds that his wife is taking over the family leadership in this brave new postindustrial world. Like many other Carver male characters, Holits becomes a heavy drinker. He eventually injures himself while trying to show off his strength at the swimming pool. One day the Holitses, with their young sons, pack and drive off down the long, straight highway without a word of explanation. When Marge trudges upstairs to clean the empty apartment, she finds that Holits has left his bridle behind. The naïve narrator does not understand the significance of the bridle, but the reader feels its poignancy as a symbol. The bridle is one of those useless objects that everyone carts around and is reluctant to part with because it represents a memory, a hope, or a dream. It is an especially appropriate symbol because it is so utterly out of place in one of those two-story, frame-stucco, look-alike apartment buildings that disfigure the landscape and are the dominant features of “Carver Country.” Gigantic economic forces beyond the comprehension of the narrator have driven this farm family from their home and turned them into the modern equivalent of the Joad family in John Steinbeck’s classic novel The Grapes of Wrath (1939). There is, however, a big difference between Carver and Steinbeck. Steinbeck believed in and prescribed the panacea of socialism; Carver has no prescriptions to offer. He seems to have no faith either in politicians or in preachers. His characters are more likely to go to church to play bingo than to say prayers or sing hymns. Like many of his contemporary minimalists, he seems to have gone beyond alienation, beyond existentialism, beyond despair. God is dead; so what else is new?
Carver, Raymond
195
Carver’s working-class characters are far more complicated than Steinbeck’s Joad family. Americans have become more sophisticated as a result of the influence of radio, motion pictures, television, the Internet, more abundant educational opportunities, improved automobiles and highways, cheap air transportation, alcohol and drugs, more leisure time, and the fact that their work is less enervating because of the proliferation of labor-saving machinery. Many Americans have also lost their religious faith, their work ethic, their class consciousness, their family loyalty, their integrity, and their dreams. Steinbeck saw it happening and showed how the Joad family was splitting apart after being uprooted from the soil; Carver’s people are the Joad family a half-century down the road. Oddly enough, Carver’s mature stories do not seem nihilistic or despairing because they contain the redeeming qualities of humor, compassion, and honesty. “Boxes” • Where I’m Calling From is the most useful volume of Carver’s short stories because it contains some of the best stories that had been printed in earlier books plus a generous selection of his later and best efforts. One of the new stories reprinted in Where I’m Calling From is “Boxes,” which first appeared in The New Yorker. When Carver’s stories began to be regularly accepted by The New Yorker, it was an indication that he had found the style of self-expression that he had been searching for since the beginning of his career. It was also a sign that his themes were evoking sympathetic chords in the hearts and minds of The New Yorkers’ middle and upper-class readership, the people at whom that magazine’s sophisticated advertisements for diamonds, furs, highrise condominiums, and luxury vacation cruises are aimed. “Boxes” is written in Carver’s characteristic tragicomic tone. It is a story in which the faux-naïf narrator, a favorite with Carver, complains about the eccentric behavior of his widowed mother who, for one specious reason or another, is always changing her place of residence. She moves so frequently that she usually seems to have the bulk of her worldly possessions packed in boxes scattered about on the floor. One of her complaints is about the attitude of her landlord, whom she calls “King Larry.” Larry Hadlock is a widower and a relatively affluent property owner. It is evident through Carver’s unerring dialogue that what she is really bitter about is Larry’s indifference to her own fading charms. In the end, she returns to California but telephones to complain about the traffic, the faulty air-conditioning unit in her apartment, and the indifference of management. Her son vaguely understands that what his mother really wants, though she may not realize it herself, is love and a real home and that she can never have these things again in her lifetime no matter where she moves. What makes the story significant is its universality: It reflects the macrocosm in a microcosm. In “Boxes,” the problem touched on is not only the rootlessness and anonymity of modern life but also the plight of millions of aging people, who are considered by some to be useless in their old age and a burden to their children. It was typical of Carver to find a metaphor for this important social phenomenon in a bunch of cardboard boxes. Carver uses working-class people as his models, but he is not writing solely about the working class. It is simply the fact that all Americans can see themselves in his little, inarticulate, bewildered characters that makes Carver an important writer in the dominant tradition of American realism, a worthy successor to Mark Twain, Stephen Crane, Sherwood Anderson, Theodore Dreiser, Willa Cather, John Steinbeck, and William Faulkner, all of whom wrote about humble people. Someday it may be gener-
196
Short Story Writers
ally appreciated that, despite the odds against him and despite the antipathy of certain mandarins, Raymond Carver managed to become the most important American fiction writer in the second half of the twentieth century. Bill Delaney Other major works anthology: American Short Story Masterpieces, 1987 (with Tom Jenks). miscellaneous: Fires: Essays, Poems, Stories, 1983; No Heroics, Please: Uncollected Writings, 1991 (revised and expanded as Call If You Need Me: The Uncollected Fiction and Other Prose, 2001). poetry: Near Klamath, 1968; Winter Insomnia, 1970; At Night the Salmon Move, 1976; Two Poems, 1982; If It Please You, 1984; This Water, 1985; Where Water Comes Together with Other Water, 1985; Ultramarine, 1986; A New Path to the Waterfall, 1989; All of Us: The Collected Poems, 1996. screenplay: Dostoevsky, 1985. Bibliography Bugeja, Michael. “Tarnish and Silver: An Analysis of Carver’s Cathedral.” South Dakota Review 24, no. 3 (1986): 73-87. Discusses the revision of an early Carver story, “The Bath,” which was reprinted in Cathedral as “A Small Good Thing.” The changes made throughout the story, and especially the somewhat more positive resolution, reflect Carver’s evolution as a writer. Campbell, Ewing. Raymond Carver: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Introduction to Carver’s stories that focuses on such issues as myth and archetype, otherness, and the grotesque. Discusses the difference between “early” and “late” versions of the same story, such as “So Much Water Close to Home” and “The Bath” and “A Small Good Thing.” Includes Carver’s own comments on his writing as well as articles by other critics who challenge the label of minimalist for Carver. Carver, Raymond. “A Storyteller’s Shoptalk.” The New York Times Book Review, February 15, 1981, 9. In this interesting article, Carver describes his artistic credo, evaluates the work of some of his contemporaries, and offers excellent advice to aspiring young writers. The article reveals his perfectionism and dedication to his craft. Gentry, Marshall Bruce, and William L. Stull, eds. Conversations with Raymond Carver. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1990. Wide-ranging collection of interviews covering Carver’s career from the early 1980’s until just before his death. Halpert, Sam. Raymond Carver: An Oral Biography. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1995. Expanded edition of a collection of conversations originally published in 1991 as When We Talk About Raymond Carver. Includes contributions from Carver’s first wife, his daughter, an early writing instructor, and some of his lifetime friends. ____________, ed. When We Talk About Raymond Carver. Layton, Utah: Gibbs Smith, 1991. Collection of transcripts of interviews with ten writers who knew Carver on a personal basis, including a fascinating interview with Carver’s first wife, Maryann, who provides a fresh perspective on the incidents on which many of Carver’s stories were based. Kesset, Kirk. The Stories of Raymond Carver. Athens: Ohio University Press, 1995. Intelligent discussion of Carver’s stories, focusing on Carver’s development of his own moral center.
Carver, Raymond
197
May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these nine short stories by Carver: “Careful” and “Cathedral” (vol. 1); “Errand” (vol. 2); “Neighbors” (vol. 5); “A Small, Good Thing” and “So Much Water So Close to Home” (vol. 7); and “What We Talk About When We Talk About Love,” “Why Don’t You Dance?,” and “Will You Please Be Quiet, Please?” (vol. 8). Nesset, Kirk. The Stories of Raymond Carver: A Critical Study. Athens: Ohio University Press, 1995. The first book-length study of Carver’s work, Nesset calls the book “a preliminary exploration.” Includes an extensive bibliography. Powell, Jon. “The Stories of Raymond Carver: The Menace of Perpetual Uncertainty.” Studies in Short Fiction 31 (Fall, 1994): 647-656. Discusses the sense of menace Carver creates by leaving out or only providing clues to central aspects of his stories. Argues that this technique forces both the characters and the readers to try to understand the clues. Runyon, Randolph Paul. Reading Raymond Carver. Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press, 1992. Analyzes Carver’s stories as “intratextual” and argues that they should be read in relationship to one another. Claims that in Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? and Cathedral each story is linked to the immediately preceding story and the one after it. Scofield, Martin. “Story and History in Raymond Carver.” Critique 40 (Spring, 1999): 266-280. Shows how three late Carver stories—“Intimacy,” “Blackbird Pie,” and “Elephant”—embody a new experimental technique for integrating fiction and autobiographical or historical events.
198
Willa Cather Born: Back Creek Valley, near Gore, Virginia; December 7, 1873 Died: New York, New York; April 24, 1947 Principal short fiction • The Troll Garden, 1905; “Paul’s Case,” 1905; Youth and the Bright Medusa, 1920; Obscure Destinies, 1932; The Old Beauty and Others, 1948; Willa Cather’s Collected Short Fiction: 1892-1912, 1965; Uncle Valentine, and Other Stories: Willa Cather’s Collected Short Fiction, 1915-1929, 1973. Other literary forms • Willa Cather is best known as a novelist, but she wrote prolifically in other forms, especially as a young woman; she had been publishing short stories for more than twenty years before she published her first novel. Although her fame rests largely on her twelve novels and a few short stories, she has a collection of poetry, several collections of essays, and hundreds of newspaper columns and magazine pieces to her credit. Only one of her books, A Lost Lady (1923), was filmed in Hollywood; after that one experience, Cather would not allow any of her work to be filmed again. Achievements • Willa Cather was one of America’s first modern writers to make the prairie immigrant experience an important and continuing subject for high-quality fiction. Although her setting is often the American western frontier, she masterfully locates the universal through the specific, and her literary reputation transcends the limitations of regional or gender affiliation. In her exploration of the human spirit, Cather characteristically defends artistic values in an increasingly materialistic world, and she is known for her graceful rendering of place and character. Praised in the 1920’s as one of the most successful novelists of her time, Cather was sometimes criticized in the next decade for neglecting contemporary social issues. Later, however, and especially since her death, she was recognized as a great artist and one of the most important American writers of the twentieth century. In 1923, she was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for the novel One of Ours (1922). She also received the Howells Medal for fiction from the Academy of the National Institute of Arts and Letters in 1930, the Prix Fémina Américain for Shadows on the Rock (1931) in 1933, and the gold medal from the National Institute of Arts and Letters in 1944. With time, interest in Cather’s fiction continued to increase, rather than diminish, and she enjoys appreciative audiences abroad as well as in her own country. Biography • Willa Sibert Cather moved with her family from Virginia to Nebraska when she was only nine years old, a move that was to influence her mind and art throughout her life. As a student at the University of Nebraska, she wrote for various college magazines; she also became a regular contributor to the Nebraska State Journal, publishing book, theater, and concert reviews, as well as commentary on the passing scene. Even after she moved to Pittsburgh to take an editorial job, she continued to send columns home to the Nebraska State Journal. Later she also began contributing to the Lincoln Courier. She taught English in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (an experience that became the source for one of her most famous short stories, “Paul’s Case”), and
Cather, Willa
199
then moved to New York to take a position with McClure’s Magazine. After the publication of her first novel, Alexander’s Bridge, in 1912, she left McClure’s Magazine, financially able to devote her full time to her creative work. Over the next three decades, she published successfully and to critical acclaim. Analysis • Willa Cather was always conscious of a double urge in herself, toward art and toward the land. As long as her parents were living, she found herself torn between the western prairie and the cultural centers of the East and Europe. That basic polarity appears again and again in her stories, some of which deal with the artist’s struggle against debilitating influences, and some with both the pleasant and the difficult aspects of the prairie experience. Perhaps only in her work did Cather achieve a comfortable reconciliation of these polarities, by making the prairie experience the subject of her art. All of Cather’s work is consistently value-centered. She believed in characters who are good, artists who are true to their callings, people who can appreciate and use what is valuable from the past, and individuals who have a special relationship with the land. Her chief agony lay in what she saw as a general sellout to materialism—in the realm of art, in the prairie and desert, in the small town, in the city. The struggle of the artist to maintain integrity against an unsympathetic environment and the forces of an exploitative materialism is explored in three stories that are particularly important in the Cather canon. Two of them, “The Sculptor’s Funeral” and “Paul’s Case,” have been widely anthologized and are well known. The third, “Uncle Valentine,” is an important later story. “The Sculptor’s Funeral” • “The Sculptor’s Funeral” is about the return in death of a world-renowned sculptor to the pinched little prairie town from which he somehow miraculously sprang. Harvey Merrick’s body arrives by train in the dead of winter, accompanied by one of his former students. There to meet the coffin are several prominent townsmen, among them a brusque, red-bearded lawyer named Jim Laird. Only he can appreciate the magnitude of Harvey Merrick’s achievement. The watchers around the body chuckle and snort over poor Harvey’s uselessness as a farmhand, over his inability to “make it” in the only things that count for them—money-making ventures in Sand City. Jim Laird, in a storm of self-hatred for having become the scheming lawyer these harpies wanted him to be, enters the room and blasts them mercilessly. He reminds the town elders of the young men they have ruined by drumming “nothing but money and knavery into their ears from the time they wore knickerbockers.” They hated Harvey, Laird says, because he left them and rose above them, achieving in a world they were not fit to enter. He reminds them that Harvey “wouldn’t have given one sunset over your marshes” for all of their material properties and possessions. Laird is too drunk the next day to attend the funeral, and it is learned that he dies some years later from a cold he caught while “driving across the Colorado mountains to defend one of Phelps’s sons who had got into trouble there by cutting government timber.” Harvey Merrick is not the tragic figure of the story, for he, thanks to a timid father who sensed something special about this one son, managed to escape destruction. He became the artist he was destined to be, in spite of his unlikely beginnings. The money-grubbing first citizens of Sand City can wag their tongues feebly over his corpse, but they cannot touch him or detract from his accomplishment. If there is a tragic element in the story, it is the life of Jim Laird. Like Harvey, he went away
200
Short Story Writers to school full of idealistic fire; like Harvey, he wanted to be a great man and make the hometown people proud of him. Instead, he says, “I came back here to practice, and I found you didn’t in the least want me to be a great man. You wanted me to be a shrewd lawyer.” He became that shrewd lawyer and lost his soul in the process. The dead artist, imposing and serene in his coffin, serves as a perfect foil for Jim Laird, and the story stands as one of Cather’s most powerful treatments of the conflict between artistic ideals and materialistic value systems.
“Paul’s Case” • “Paul’s Case” presents a somewhat different view of that conflict. Paul, a high school youngster, is not a practicing artist, but he has an artistic temperament. He loves to hang around art Edward Steichen/Courtesy, George Bush galleries and concert halls and thePresidential Library and Museum aters, talking with the performers and basking in their reflected glory. It is glitter, excitement, and escape from the dripping taps in his home on Pittsburgh’s Cordelia Street that Paul craves. A hopeless “case,” Paul is finally taken out of high school by his widowed father because his mind is never on his studies. Forced from his usher’s job at the concert hall and forbidden to associate with the actors at the theater, he loses the only things he had lived for and cared about. When he is denied those vital outlets for his aesthetic needs and sent to do dull work for a dull company, he carries out a desperate plan. One evening, instead of depositing his firm’s receipts in the bank, he catches a train for New York. With swift determination, he buys elegant clothes and installs himself in a luxurious hotel suite, there to live for a few brief days the life he had always felt himself suited for. Those days are lovely and perfect, but the inevitable reckoning draws near: He learns from a newspaper that his father is en route to New York to retrieve him. Very deliberately Paul plots his course, even buying carnations for his buttonhole. Traveling to the outskirts of town, he walks to an embankment above the Pennsylvania tracks. There he carefully buries the carnations in the snow, and when the appropriate moment comes, he leaps into the path of an oncoming train. A sensitive youngster with limited opportunity, Paul is not an artist in the usual sense. His distinction is that he responds to art, almost any art, with an unusual fervor. To him, anything associated with the world of art is beautiful and inspiring, while anything associated with lower-middle-class America is ugly and common. He is wrong about both worlds. With eyes only for the artificial surface glitter that spangles the world of art, he never sees the realities of hard work and struggle that define the
Cather, Willa
201
life of every artist. Clearly, Cordelia Street is not as bad as Paul imagines it to be; it is, in fact, a moderately nice neighborhood where working people live and rear their families. Cordelia Street, however, has inadvertently taught him that money is the answer to all desires, that it can buy all the trappings that grace the world of art. Cordelia Street’s legendary heroes are the Kings of Wall Street. In spite of his blindness, Paul captures the reader’s sympathies because he feels trapped in an aesthetic wasteland to which he cannot and will not return; the reader realizes at the end that perhaps Paul’s only escape lies in his final choice. The Waldorf, after all, provided temporary breathing space at best. His only real home is, as Cather tells us, in the “immense design of things.” “Uncle Valentine” • Valentine Ramsay, the title character in “Uncle Valentine,” is like Paul in many ways: He is sensitive, charming, flighty, unpredictable, temperamental, and intolerant of commonness. Unlike Paul, however, Valentine is a true artist, a gifted composer; it is not the artificial shell of art that he values, but the very heart of it. After several years abroad, he decides to return to Greenacre, his family home in the lush Pennsylvania countryside. He feels that perhaps at Greenacre he can shut out the world and find the peace he needs to write music. Ramsay and the neighbors next door, with whom he shares a special affection, both artistic and social, have a magnificent year together, a “golden year.” They roam the fields and woods, they share music, and they increase in aesthetic understanding. Casting a tragic shadow over this happy group, however, is the figure of Valentine’s uncle, who haunts the premises like a grieving ghost. A child prodigy, he had left home to pursue his art, but for reasons never disclosed, he gave up his music and returned, burying himself in the ashes of his ruined life. As a young man, Valentine had made a bad marriage to a rich woman whose materialistic coarseness became a constant affront to him; her very presence beside him in a concert hall was enough to shatter his nerves and obliterate the music he came to hear. Valentine has escaped from her, but she is destined to destroy his peace once again. He and his neighbors discover that she has purchased the large piece of property next to theirs, the property they had loved and tramped through for endless days. She intends to move in soon, bringing her fortune, her brash assertiveness, and Valentine’s only son. She, along with the encroaching factory smoke downriver, spells the end of the blessed life the little group of art fanciers has known at Greenacre. Valentine is forced to flee again, and the reader learns that he is killed while crossing a street in France. Cather’s message is clear. The important things in life—art and the sharing of its pleasures, friendships, a feeling for land and place, a reverence for the past—are too often destroyed in the name of progress. When economic concerns are given top priority, whether on the prairie or in Pennsylvania, the human spirit suffers. Happily, in a much-loved story called “Neighbor Rosicky,” Cather affirms that material temptations can be successfully resisted. Valentine is defeated, but Rosicky and his values prevail. “Neighbor Rosicky” • Anton Rosicky, recognizable as another rendering of Ántonia’s husband in Cather’s best-known novel, My Ántonia (1918), has instinctively established a value system that puts life and the land above every narrow-minded material concern. For example, when his entire corn crop is destroyed in the searing heat one July day, he organizes a little picnic so that the family can enjoy the few things they
202
Short Story Writers
have left. Instead of despairing with his neighbors, Rosicky plays with his children. It is no surprise that he and his wife, Mary, agree without discussion as to what things they can let go. They refuse to skim the cream off their milk and sell it for butter because Mary would “rather put some colour into my children’s faces than put money into the bank.” Doctor Ed, who detects serious heart trouble in Rosicky, observes that “people as generous and warm-hearted and affectionate as the Rosickys never got ahead much; maybe you couldn’t enjoy your life and put it into the bank, too.” “Neighbor Rosicky” is one of Cather’s finest tributes to life on the Nebraska prairie, to a value system that grows out of human caring and love for the land. Rosicky had lived in cities for many years, had known hard times and good times there, but it occurred to him one lonely day in the city that he had to get to the land. He realized that “the trouble with big cities” was that “they built you in from the earth itself, cemented you away from any contact with the ground,” so he made his decision and went West. The only thing that disturbs his sleep now is the discontentment of his oldest son. Rudolph is married to a town girl, Polly, and he wants to leave the farm and seek work in the city. Rosicky understands Rudolph’s restlessness and Polly’s lonesomeness and looks for every opportunity to help the young couple find some recreation time in town. In spite of his efforts, however, Polly continues to dislike farm life and to find the Rosickys strange and “foreign.” Then one day Rosicky suffers a heart attack near Rudolph’s place. No one is there to care for him but Polly, and that day something lovely happens between the two of them: She has a revelation of his goodness that is “like an awakening to her.” His warm brown hand somehow brings “her to herself,” teaches her more about life than she has ever known before, offers her “some direct and untranslatable message.” With this revelation comes the assurance that at last all will be well with Rudolph and Polly. They will remain on the land and Rosicky’s spirit will abide with them, for Polly has caught the old man’s vision. It is fitting that Rosicky’s death a few months later is calmly accepted as a natural thing, and that he is buried in the earth he loved. That way there will be no strangeness, no jarring separation. Rosicky is Cather’s embodiment of all that is finest in the human character. He had been a city man, a lover of opera and the other cultural advantages of city life, but he found his peace in the simple life of a Nebraska farm. By contrast, Harvey Merrick, the sculptor, had been a country boy, a lover of the prairie landscape, but he found his peace in the art capitals of the world. Nevertheless, Merrick and Rosicky would have understood each other perfectly. One’s talent lay in molding clay, the other’s in molding lives. Cather is sometimes accused of nostalgia, of denying the present and yearning for the past. What seems clear in her work, however, is not that she wants to live in the past but that she deplores a total rejection of the values of the past. She fears a materialistic takeover of the human heart, or a shriveled view of human life. She is convinced that the desire for money and the things money can buy corrupts character, cheapens life, destroys the landscape, and enervates art. In her exploration of the conflicts engendered by a destructive materialism, in her celebration of art and the land, Willa Cather’s devotion to an enduring system that spans time and space to embrace the good, the beautiful, and the true is made evident. Marilyn Arnold With updates by Jean C. Fulton
Cather, Willa
203
Other major works novels: Alexander’s Bridge, 1912; O Pioneers!, 1913; The Song of the Lark, 1915; My Ántonia, 1918; One of Ours, 1922; A Lost Lady, 1923; The Professor’s House, 1925; My Mortal Enemy, 1926; Death Comes for the Archbishop, 1927; Shadows on the Rock, 1931; Lucy Gayheart, 1935; Sapphira and the Slave Girl, 1940. miscellaneous: Writings from Willa Cather’s Campus Years, 1950. nonfiction: Not Under Forty, 1936; Willa Cather on Writing, 1949; Willa Cather in Europe, 1956; The Kingdom of Art: Willa Cather’s First Principles and Critical Statements, 18931896, 1966; The World and the Parish: Willa Cather’s Articles and Reviews, 1893-1902, 1970 (2 volumes). poetry: April Twilights, 1903. Bibliography Arnold, Marilyn. Willa Cather’s Short Fiction. Athens: Ohio University Press, 1984. In this indexed volume, Arnold discusses all Cather’s known short fiction chronologically. The detailed investigations will be helpful both for readers new to Cather’s stories and those who are more familiar with them. Discussions of stories which have received little critical attention are especially useful. Includes a selected bibliography. Gerber, Philip L. Willa Cather. Rev. ed. New York: Twayne, 1995. In this revised edition, Gerber focuses more on Cather’s short fiction than in the first edition, as well as on the resurgence of criticism of her work. Discusses the major themes of the experience of the artist and life in rural Nebraska in major Cather short stories. Harris, Jeane. “Aspects of Athene in Willa Cather’s Short Fiction.” Studies in Short Fiction 28 (Spring, 1991): 177-182. Discusses Cather’s conflict between her gender and her inherited male aesthetic principles and how this is reflected in some of her early short stories by “manly” female characters modeled after the Greek goddess Athene. Maintains that Cather’s androgynous female characters represent her dissatisfaction with traditional notions of femininity and masculinity. Lindermann, Marilee. The Cambridge Companion to Willa Cather. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2005. Thirteen essays examining Cather’s most noted novels and short stories. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Cather: “Coming, Aphrodite” (vol. 2); “Neighbor Rosicky” (vol. 5); “Paul’s Case” (vol. 6); and “The Sculptor’s Funeral” (vol. 6). Meyering, Sheryl L. A Reader’s Guide to the Short Stories of Willa Cather. New York: G. K. Hall, 1994. Discusses individual Cather stories, focusing on publishing history, circumstances of composition, sources, influence, relationship to other Cather works, and interpretations and criticism. Deals with her debt to Henry James, the influence of her sexual orientation on her fiction, and the influence of Sarah Orne Jewett. Murphy, John J., ed. Critical Essays on Willa Cather. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1984. Among the thirty-five essays in this substantial collection are reprinted reviews and articles by Eudora Welty, Katherine Anne Porter, Leon Edel, Blanche H. Gelfant, and Bernice Slote. It also includes original essays by David Stouck, James Leslie Woodress, Paul Cameau, and John J. Murphy. The introduction offers a history of Cather scholarship.
204
Short Story Writers
Robinson, Phyllis C. Willa: The Life of Willa Cather. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1983. Popular biography, with good material on Cather’s family and friends. It contains some biographical analyses of Cather’s major works. Skaggs, Merrill Maguire, ed. Willa Cather’s New York: New Essays on Cather in the City. Madison, N.J.: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 2001. Collection of twenty essays focusing on Cather’s urban fiction and her work for McClure’s. Wasserman, Loretta. Willa Cather: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1991. Focuses on selected short stories that the author feels are the most challenging and lend themselves to different critical approaches. Includes interviews with Cather, one of Cather’s essays on the craft of writing, samples of current criticism, a chronology, and a select bibliography.
205
Geoffrey Chaucer Born: London(?), England; c. 1343 Died: London, England; October 25(?), 1400 Principal short fiction • Book of the Duchess, c. 1370; Romaunt of the Rose, c. 1370 (translation, possibly not by Chaucer); House of Fame, 1372-1380; The Legend of St. Cecilia, 1372-1380 (later used as “The Second Nun’s Tale”); Tragedies of Fortune, 1372-1380 (later used as “The Monk’s Tale”); Anelida and Arcite, c. 1380; Palamon and Ersyte, 13801386 (later used as “The Knight’s Tale”); Parlement of Foules, 1380; The Legend of Good Women, 1380-1386; Troilus and Criseyde, 1382; The Canterbury Tales, 1387-1400. Other literary forms • In addition to the works listed above, Geoffrey Chaucer composed Boece (c. 1380), a translation of Boethius’s The Consolation of Philosophy (523), which Boethius wrote while in prison. Chaucer also wrote an astrological study, A Treatise on the Astrolabe (1387-1392), and a miscellaneous volume entitled Works (1957). Achievements • Geoffrey Chaucer is generally agreed to be the most important writer in English literature before William Shakespeare. Recognized internationally in his own time as the greatest of English poets and dubbed “the father of English poetry” by John Dryden as early as 1700, his central position in the development of English literature and even of the English language is perhaps more secure today than it has ever been. One of the keys to Chaucer’s continued critical success is the scope and diversity of his work, which extends from romance to tragedy, from sermon to dream vision, from pious saints’ lives to bawdy fabliaux. Readers from every century have found something new in Chaucer and learned something about themselves. Biography • Household records seem to indicate that as a boy, Geoffrey Chaucer served as a page for the countess of Ulster, wife of Edward III’s son Lionel, Duke of Clarence. Chaucer undoubtedly learned French and Latin as a youth, to which languages he later added Italian. Well versed in both science and pseudoscience, Chaucer was familiar with physics, medicine, astronomy, and alchemy. Spending most of his life in government service, he made many trips abroad on diplomatic missions and served at home in such important capacities as comptroller of customs for the Port of London, justice of the peace for the county of Kent, and clerk of the King’s Works, a position that made him responsible for the maintenance of certain public structures. He married Philippa de Roet, probably in 1367, and he may have had two daughters and two sons, although there is speculation concerning the paternity of some of those children believed to have been Chaucer’s. Since Chaucer’s career was his service to the monarchy, his poetry was evidently an avocation which did not afford him a living. Analysis • Geoffrey Chaucer’s best-known works are Troilus and Criseyde and the unfinished The Canterbury Tales, with the Book of the Duchess, the Hous of Fame, the Parlement of Foules, and The Legend of Good Women positioned in the second rank. In addition to these works and to Boece (c. 1380; translation of Boethius’s The Consolation of
206
Short Story Writers
Philosophy, c. 523-524) and the Romaunt of the Rose, there exist a number of shorter and lesser-known poems, some of which merit brief attention. These lesser-known poems demonstrate Chaucer’s abilities in diverse but typically medieval forms. Perhaps the earliest extant example of Chaucer’s work is “An ABC to the Virgin”; this poem, primarily a translation from a thirteenth century French source, is a traditional series of prayers in praise of Mary, the stanzas of which are arranged in alphabetical order according to the first letter of each stanza. Another traditional form Chaucer used is the “complaint,” or formal lament. “A Complaint to His Lady” is significant in literary history as the first appearance in English of Dante’s terza rima, and “The Complaint unto Pity” is one of the earliest examples of rime royal; this latter poem contains an unusual analogy which represents the personified Pity as being buried in a heart. “The Complaint of Mars” illustrates Chaucer’s individuality in treating traditional themes and conventions; although the poem purports to be a Valentine poem, and akin to an aubade, its ironic examination of love’s intrinsic variability seems to make it an anti-Valentine poem. Chaucer similarly plays with theme and form in To Rosemounde, a ballade in which the conventions of courtly love are exaggerated to the point of grotesquerie; the narrator says, for example, that he is as immersed in love as a fish smothered in pickle sauce. Finally, Chaucer’s poem “Gentilesse” is worthy of note for its presentation of a theme, developed in “The Wife of Bath’s Tale” and in “The Clerk’s Tale,” which posits that “gentilesse” depends not on inheritance or social position but on character. In sum, these poems, for most of which dates of composition cannot be assigned, represent a variety of themes and forms with which Chaucer may have been experimenting; they indicate not only his solid grounding in poetic conventions but also his innovative spirit in using new forms and ideas and in treating old forms and ideas in new ways. Book of the Duchess • Of those poems in the second rank, the Book of the Duchess was probably the earliest written and is believed to have been composed as a consolation or commemoration of the death of Blanche, Duchess of Lancaster and wife of John of Gaunt, with whom Chaucer was associated. The poem uses the technique of the dream vision and the device of the fictional narrator as two means of objectifying the subject matter, of presenting the consolation at a remove from the narrator and in the person of the bereaved knight himself. The poem thus seems to imply that true consolation can come only from within; the narrator’s human sympathy and nature’s reassurance can assist in the necessary process of acceptance of and recovery from the loss of a loved one, but that movement from the stasis of deprivation to the action of catharsis and healing can occur only within the mourner’s own breast. The poem is told by a lovesick narrator who battles his insomnia by reading the story of Ceyx and Alcyone. Finally falling asleep, he dreams that he awakens in the morning to the sounds of the hunt and, following a dog, comes upon a distinguished young knight dressed in black who laments his lost love. In response to the dreamer’s naïve and persistent questions, the knight is eventually prodded into telling of his loss; he describes his lady in love-filled superlatives, reveals that her outer beauty was symbolic of her inner nobility, and acknowledges the great happiness they enjoyed in their mutual love. At the end of this lengthy discourse, when the narrator inquires as to the lady’s whereabouts, the knight states simply that she is dead, to which the narrator replies, “Be God, hyt ys routhe!” The poem thus blends the mythological world, the natural world, and the realm of human sympathy to create a context within which the mourner can come to accept
Chaucer, Geoffrey
207
his loss. The dreamer’s lovesickness causes him to have a natural affinity with the knight, and, by posing as stupid, naïve, and slowwitted, the dreamer obliges the knight to speak and to admit his loss, a reality he must acknowledge if he is to move beyond the paralysis caused by his grief to a position where he is accessible to the consolation that can restore him. This restoration is in part accomplished by the dreamer’s “naïve” questions, which encourage the knight to remember the joys he experienced with his lady and the love that they shared. The knight is then able to be consoled and comforted by the corrective and curative powers of his own memories. The poem thus offers a psychoLibrary of Congress logically realistic and sophisticated presentation of the grief process, a process in which the dreamer-narrator plays a crucial role, since it is the dreamer who, through his seemingly obtuse questioning, propels the knight out of the stasis to which his grief has made him succumb; the cathartic act of speaking to the dreamer about his lost love renders the knight open to the healing powers available in human sympathy and the natural world. The poem, even as it is elegiac in its tribute to the lost lover, is in the genre of the consolatio as it records the knight’s conversion from unconsolable grief to quiet acceptance and assuagement. In establishing the persona of the apparently naïve and bumbling narrator, Chaucer initiates a tradition which not only has come to be recognized as typical of his works but also has been used repeatedly throughout literature. Probably the earliest English writer to use such a narrative device, Chaucer thereby discovered the rich possibilities for structural irony implicit in the distance between the author and his naïve narrator. Hous of Fame • In contrast to the well-executed whole that is the Book of the Duchess, the Hous of Fame, believed to have been composed between 1372 and 1380, is an unfinished work; its true nature and Chaucer’s intent in the poem continue to elude critics. Beyond the problems posed by any unfinished work is the question of this particular poem’s unity, since the connections between the three parts of the poem which Chaucer actually finished are tenuous. In the first book of the poem, the narrator dreams of the Temple of Venus, where he learns of Dido and Aeneas. The second book, detailing the narrator’s journey, in the talons of a golden eagle, to the House of Fame, and the contrast between the eagle’s chatty friendliness and volubility and the obviously terrified narrator’s monosyllabic responses as they swoop through the air, provides much amusement. The third book, describing the House of Fame and its presiding goddess, demonstrates the total irrationality of fame, which
208
Short Story Writers
the goddess awards according to caprice rather than merit. After visiting the House of Rumor, the narrator notices everyone running to see a man of great authority, at which point the poem breaks off. Critical opinion differs considerably as to the poem’s meaning. Some believe it attempts to assess the worth of fame or perhaps even the life of the poet, in view of the mutability of human existence; others believe the poem intends to consider the validity of recorded history as opposed to true experience; yet other critics believe the poem attempts to ascertain the nature of poetry and its relationship to love. Although scholars have certainly not as yet settled on the poem’s meaning, there is agreement that the flight of the eagle and the narrator in book 2 is one of literature’s most finely comic passages. Beyond this, it is perhaps wisest to view the poem as an experiment with various themes which even Chaucer himself was apparently disinterested in unifying. Parlement of Foules • In contrast to the Hous of Fame, the Parlement of Foules, composed around 1380, is a finely crafted and complete work in which Chaucer combines several popular conventions, such as the dream vision, the parliament of beasts, and the demande d’amour to demonstrate three particular manifestations of love: divine love, erotic love, and procreative love, or natural love. The fictional narrator is here a person who lacks love, who knows of it only through books, and whose very dreams even prove emotionally unsatisfying. The narrator recounts his reading of Scipio Africanus the Younger, who dreamed that his ancestor came to him, told him of divine justice and the life hereafter, and urged him to work to the common profit. Having learned of the nature of divine love, the narrator dreams that Scipio comes to him as he sleeps to take him to a park where there are two gardens, one the garden of Venus and the other the garden of Nature. The garden of Venus is clearly the place of erotic or carnal love; it is located away from the sun and consequently is dark, and it has an illicit and corrupt atmosphere. In addition to such figures as Cupid, Lust, Courtesy, and Jealousy, the narrator sees Venus herself, reclining half-naked in an atmosphere that is close and oppressive. In contrast, the garden of Nature is in sunlight; it is Valentine’s Day, and the birds have congregated to choose their mates. In addition to the natural surroundings, the presence of Nature herself, presiding over the debate, helps to create an atmosphere of fertility and creativity. The choice of mates is, however, impeded by a quarrel among three male eagles who love a formel. Each eagle has a different claim to press: The first asserts that he has loved her long in silence, the second stresses the length of his devotion, and the third emphasizes his devotion’s intensity, pointing out that it is the quality rather than the length of love that matters. Since the lower orders of birds cannot choose mates until the eagles have settled their quarrel, the lesser birds enter the debate, aligning themselves variously either for or against the issues of courtly love which are involved. When the various birds’ contributions deteriorate into invective without any positive result, Nature intervenes to settle the matter, but the formel insists upon making her own choice in her own time, that is, at the end of a year. The other birds, their mates chosen, sing a joyful song which ends the dream vision. When the narrator awakes he continues to read, hoping to dream better. The poem, then, presents love in its divine, erotic, and procreative forms. Although the narrator sees these various manifestations of love, he is unable to experience them since all are unavailable to him. He is, in some ways, thus akin to the eagles and in contrast to the lower orders of birds who obviously fare well, since at the end
Chaucer, Geoffrey
209
of the parliament they are paired with their mates and blissfully depart. The eagles and the formel, however, because of the formel’s need to deliberate upon and choose among her courtly lovers, are in a kind of emotional limbo for a year; in effect, they are all denied for a relatively long period love’s natural expression. Thus, even as the system of courtliness raises and ennobles love, the system also provides an impediment to the ultimate realization of love in mating. Although there seems to be a movement in the debate from the artificiality of courtly love to the naturalness of pairing off, this movement does not affect the eagles, who remain constrained, in large part because of their commitment to the courtly code. The poem examines, then, not merely the various faces of love but the nature of courtly love in particular and its seemingly undesirable effects upon its adherents. The Legend of Good Women • Like the Hous of Fame, the The Legend of Good Women is unfinished; although the poem was intended to contain a prologue and a series of nineteen or twenty stories telling of true women and false men, the extant material consists of two versions of the prologue and only nine legends. The poem purports to be a penance for the poet’s offenses against the God of Love in writing of the false Criseyde and in translating the antifeminine Romaunt of the Rose. In the prologues, Chaucer uses the techniques of the dream vision and the court of love to establish a context for his series of tales, which are much akin to saints’ lives. In fact, the poem seems to parody the idea of a religion of love; the poet, although he worships the daisy as the God of Love’s symbol, commits by his work heresy against the deity and must therefore repent and do penance by writing of women who were saints and martyrs in love’s service. The two prologues differ in the degree to which they use Christian conventions to describe the conduct of love; the “G” prologue, believed to be later than the “F” prologue, has lessened the strength of the analogy to Christian worship. The legends, however, are very much in the hagiographic tradition, even to the extent of canonizing women not customarily regarded as “good,” such as Cleopatra and Medea. Evidently wearying of his task, however, Chaucer did not complete the poem, perhaps because of the boredom inherent in the limited perspective. Troilus and Criseyde • Of Chaucer’s completed work, Troilus and Criseyde is without question his supreme accomplishment. Justly considered by many to be the first psychological novel, the poem places against the epic background of the Trojan War the tragedy and the romance of Troilus, son of Priam, and Criseyde, daughter of Calchas the soothsayer. Entwined with their lives is that of Pandarus, friend of Troilus and uncle of Criseyde, who brings the lovers together and who, in consequence, earns lasting disapprobation as the first panderer. In analyzing the conjunction of these three characters’ lives, the poem considers the relationship of the individual to the society in which the individual lives and examines the extent to which events in one’s life are influenced by external circumstances and by internal character. At a deeper level, the poem assesses the ultimate worth of human life, human love, and human values. Yet the poem does not permit reductive or simplistic interpretation; its many thematic strands and its ambiguities of characterization and narrative voice combine to present a multidimensional poem which defies definitive analysis. The poem’s thematic complexity depends upon a relatively simple plot. When callow Troilus is stricken with love for Criseyde, he follows all the courtly rules: He suffers physically, loves her from a distance, and rises to great heights of heroism on the
210
Short Story Writers
battlefield so as to be worthy of her. When Troilus admits to Pandarus that his misery can only be cured by Criseyde’s love, Pandarus is only too happy to exercise his influence over his niece. By means of a subtle mix of avuncular affection, psychological manipulation, and veiled threats, Pandarus leads Criseyde to fall in love with Troilus. The climax of Pandarus’s machinations occurs when he arranges for Troilus and Criseyde to consummate their love affair, ostensibly against the stated will of Criseyde and in spite of Troilus’s extremely enfeebled condition. Until this point the poem, reflecting largely the conventions of fabliau, has been in the control of Pandarus; he generates the action and manipulates the characters much as a rather bawdy and perhaps slightly prurient stage manager. With the love scene, however, the poem’s form shifts from that of fabliau to that of romance; Pandarus becomes a minor figure, and the love between Troilus and Criseyde achieves much greater spiritual significance than either had anticipated. Although the tenets of courtly love demand that the lovers keep their affair secret, they enjoy for three years a satisfying and enriching relationship which serves greatly to ennoble Troilus; the poem’s shape then shifts again, this time from romance to tragedy. Calchas, having foreseen the Trojan defeat and having therefore defected to the Greeks, requests that a captured Trojan be exchanged for his daughter. The distraught lovers discover that the constraints placed upon them by their commitments to various standards and codes of behavior combine with the constraints imposed upon them by society to preclude their preventing the exchange, but Criseyde promises within ten days to steal away from the Greek camp and return to Troilus. Once in the Greek camp, however, Criseyde finds it difficult to escape; moreover, believing that the Greek Diomede has fallen in love with her, she decides to remain in the Greek encampment until the grief-stricken Troilus eventually has to admit that she has, indeed, betrayed him. At the end of the poem, having been killed by Achilles, Troilus gazes from the eighth sphere upon the fullness of the universe and laughs at those mortals who indulge in earthly endeavor. In his bitter wisdom he condemns all things of the earth, particularly earthly love, which is so inadequate in comparison with heavenly love. This section of the poem, erroneously called by some “the epilogue,” has been viewed as Chaucer’s retraction of his poem and a nullification of what has gone before. Chaucer’s poetic vision, however, is much more complex than this interpretation supposes; throughout the poem he has been preparing the reader to accept several paradoxes. One is that even as human beings must celebrate and strive for secular love, which is the nearest thing they have to divine love, they must nevertheless and simultaneously concentrate on the hereafter, since secular love and human connections are, indeed, vastly inferior to divine love. A second paradox is that humans should affirm the worth of human life and human values while at the same time recognizing their mutability and their inferiority to Christian values. The poem also presents courtly love as a paradox since, on one hand, it is the system that inspires Troilus to strive for and achieve a vastly ennobled character even though, on the other, the system is proven unworthy of his devotion. Criseyde is similarly paradoxical in that the narrator portrays her as deserving of Troilus’s love, even though she proves faithless to him. These paradoxes are presented against a classical background which contributes to the poet’s juxtaposition of several oppositions. The world of the classical epic provides the setting for a medieval courtly romance so that, although the characters exist in a pagan environment, they are viewed from the Christian medieval perspective
Chaucer, Geoffrey
211
which informs the poem. The poem’s epic setting and its romance form, then, like its pagan plot and its Christian point of view, seem thus to be temporally misaligned; this misalignment does not, however, lead to dissonance but instead contributes to the poem’s thematic ambiguity. The characters also contribute significantly to the poem’s ambiguity. Criseyde, particularly, resists classification and categorization. The ambivalent narrator encourages the reader to see Criseyde in a variety of contradictory postures: as a victim, but also as a survivor, one who takes the main chance; as a weak and socially vulnerable person, but also as a woman who is self-confident and strong; as an idealistic and romantic lover, but also as a careful pragmatist; as a greatly self-deceived character, but also as a self-aware character who at times admits painful truths about herself. Also ambiguous, but to a lesser degree, is Pandarus, whose characterization vacillates between that of the icily unsentimental cynic and that of the sensitive human being who bemoans his failures to achieve happiness in love and who worries about what history will do to his reputation. He seems to see courtly love as a game and to disbelieve in the total melding of two lives, but he betrays his own sentimentality when he indicates that he longs to find such love for himself. Although his mentor seems not to take courtly love seriously, to Troilus it is the center of his life, his very reality. His virtue lies in large part in his absolute commitment to courtly ideals and to Criseyde. The solidity of that commitment, however, prevents Troilus from taking any active steps to stop the exchange, since such action would reveal their love affair, soil Criseyde’s reputation, and violate the courtly love code. In this sense, Troilus is trapped by his own nobility and by his idealism, so that his course of action is restrained not only by external forces but also by his own character. In fact, the poem seems to show that both Troilus and Criseyde are ultimately responsible for what happens to them; the role of fate in their lives is relatively insignificant because their very characters are their fate. As Troilus is governed by his dedication to heroic and courtly ideals, Criseyde is governed by the fact that she is “slydynge of corage.” It is her nature to take the easiest way, and because of her nature she is untrue to Troilus. From the poet’s point of view, however, Criseyde’s faithlessness does not invalidate for Troilus the experience of her love. Because of his own limited perspective, Troilus is himself unable to assess the worth of his life, his love affair, and the values to which he subscribed; the parameters of his vision permit him to see only the inadequacy and imperfection of earthly experience in comparison with the experience of the divine. The poet’s perspective, however, is the one that informs the poem, and that perspective is broader, clearer, and more complex, capable of encompassing the poem’s various paradoxes and oppositions. In consequence, even though Troilus at the end discounts his earthly experience, the poem has proven its worth to an incontrovertible degree; human life, even though inferior to the afterlife, nevertheless affords the opportunity for experiences which, paradoxically, can transcend their earthly limitations. Ultimately, then, the poem affirms the worth of human life, human love, and human idealism. The Canterbury Tales • Although Chaucer never completed The Canterbury Tales, it is his most important work and the one for which he is best known. In its conceptual richness, in its grace and precision of execution, and in its broad presentation of humanity, The Canterbury Tales is unequaled. The poem occupied Chaucer for the last
212
Short Story Writers
one and a half decades of his life, although several of the stories date from an earlier period; it was not until sometime in the middle 1380’s, when he conceived the idea of using a framing device within which his stories could be placed, that the work began to assume shape. That shape is the form of a springtime pilgrimage to Canterbury to see the shrine of Thomas à Becket. The fictional party consists of some thirty pilgrims, along with the narrator and the host from the Tabard Inn; each pilgrim was to tell two stories en route to Canterbury and two on the return trip, making an approximate total of 120 tales. There are extant, however, only the prologue and twenty-four tales, not all of which are completed; moreover, the sources of these extant tales (more than eighty manuscript fragments) contain considerable textual variations and arrange the tales in many differing orders. Thus, it is impossible for critics to determine the order which Chaucer envisioned for the tales. The notion of using the pilgrimage as a framing device was a stroke of narrative brilliance, since the device provides infinite possibilities for dramatic action while it simultaneously unifies a collection of widely disparate stories. In response to the host’s request for stories of “mirth” or “doctryne,” the pilgrims present an eclectic collection of tales, including romances, fabliaux, beast-fables, saints’ lives, tragedies, sermons, and exempla. The frame of the pilgrimage also permits the poet to represent a cross section of society, since the members of the party range across the social spectrum from the aristocratic knight to the bourgeois guild members to the honest plowman. Moreover, since the tales are connected by passages of dialogue among the pilgrims as they ride along on their journey, the pilgrimage frame also permits the characters of the storytellers to be developed and additional dramatic action to occur from the pilgrims’ interaction. These “links” between the tales thus serve to define a constant fictional world, the pilgrimage, which is in juxtaposition to and seemingly in control of the multiple fictional worlds created in the tales themselves; the fictional world of the pilgrims on their pilgrimage thereby acquires a heightened degree of verisimilitude, especially because the pilgrims’ interchanges with one another often help to place them at various recognizable points on the road to Canterbury. The pilgrimage frame also permits the creation of an exquisitely ironic tension between the fictional narrator and the poet himself. The narrator is Chaucer’s usual persona, naïve, rather thick-witted, and easily and wrongly impressed by outward show. This narrator’s gullible responses to the various pilgrims are contrasted to the attitude of the poet himself; such use of the fictional narrator permits the poet not only to present two points of view on any and all action but also to play upon the tension deriving from the collision of those two perspectives. The device of the pilgrimage frame, in sum, allows the poet virtually unlimited freedom in regard to form, content, and tone. The context of the pilgrimage is established in the poem’s prologue, which begins by indicating that concerns both sacred and secular prompt people to go on pilgrimage. Those people are described in a formal series of portraits which reveals that the group is truly composed of “sondry folk” and is a veritable cross section of medieval society. Yet the skill of the poet is evident in the fact that even as the pilgrims are “types”—that is, they are representative of a body of others like themselves—they are also individuals who are distinguished not simply by the realistic details describing their external appearances but more crucially by the sharply searching analysis that penetrates their external façades to expose the actualities of character that lie beneath.
Chaucer, Geoffrey
213
“The Knight’s Tale” • The tales begin with a group that has come to be seen as Chaucer’s variations on the theme of the love-triangle and which consists of “The Knight’s Tale,” “The Miller’s Tale,” and “The Reeve’s Tale.” Like Troilus and Criseyde, “The Knight’s Tale” superimposes a romance against the background of the classical world as it tells of Palamon and Arcite, knights of Thebes who are captured by Theseus during his battle with Creon and sentenced to life imprisonment in Athens. While imprisoned they fall in love with Emily, over whom they quarrel; since Palamon, who saw and loved her first, thought she was a goddess, Arcite, who saw her second but who loved her as a woman, insists that his is the better claim. Several years later, Arcite having been freed and Palamon having escaped from prison, the knights meet and again quarrel, agreeing to settle the matter with a duel. When Theseus comes upon them he stops the duel and decrees that they must instead meet a year later with their troops to decide the matter in a tournament. For this tournament Theseus erects a magnificent stadium with temples to Venus, Mars, and Diana. When the stadium is completed and the time for the tournament has arrived, the three members of the love-triangle pray for the assistance of their particular gods: Palamon asks Venus for Emily or for death; Arcite asks Mars for victory; and Emily asks Diana to permit her to remain a virgin or, failing that, to be wedded to the one who most loves her. These various petitions cause a quarrel between Venus and Mars which Saturn resolves by announcing that Palamon shall have his lady even though Mars assists Arcite to victory. Arcite, in consequence, wins the tournament, but in the midst of his victory parade, his horse rears, and he is mortally injured. From his deathbed Arcite summons both Palamon and Emily and commends them to each other, but they continue to grieve during the next several years. Finally, Theseus summons Palamon and Emily to him and tells them that since grief should end and life go on, they are to marry and thus make joy from sorrows. The poem’s plot, then, concerns the resolution of the love-triangle typical of romance. This plot, however, is in the service of a more serious conflict, that between order and chaos. Theseus serves as the civilizing instrument, the means by which order is imposed on the anarchy of human passion. In actuality, by assuming control over the hostility between Palamon and Arcite, Theseus reshapes their primitive emotional conflict into a clearly defined ritual; by distancing it as well in time and space, Theseus forces that conflict into a shape and an expression that is socially acceptable and which poses no threat to the culture’s peaceful continuance. Theseus thus makes order and art out of raw emotion and violent instincts. “The Miller’s Tale” • The love conflict which in “The Knight’s Tale” serves to develop this cosmic theme is in “The Miller’s Tale” acted out on the smaller scale and in the more limited space of the sheerly natural world and thus serves no such serious or noble end. Again there is a triangle, but the romantic discord among the aristocratic Palamon, Arcite, and Emily becomes in “The Miller’s Tale” the bawdy comedy of the fabliau as it arises from the interaction of the young clerk Nicholas and the effeminate dandy Absolon, both of whom desire Alison, the young wife of John, an old and jealous carpenter. At the same time that the amorous Absolon serenades her nightly and sends her gifts in an effort to win her, Alison agrees to give her love to Nicholas as soon as he can create the opportunity. In fact, however, no elaborate stratagem is needed to make possible the encounter Alison and Nicholas both desire. Since Alison’s husband is away all day working, and since Nicholas, as a student who boards with the couple, is at home with Alison all day, there really are no obstacles pre-
214
Short Story Writers
venting the lovers from acting on their passions immediately. Alison’s insistence, then, that Nicholas devise a plan whereby they can give rein to their passions, reflects an important stylistic and thematic connection between the tale and “The Knight’s Tale.” In “The Knight’s Tale,” Theseus controls the passions of Palamon and Arcite by postponing their encounter and dictating its arena; the distancing in time and space results in a civilized, restrained expression of their passions. In “The Miller’s Tale,” by contrast, the distancing Alison demands parodies the conventions of romance and courtly love. This distance in actuality simply ennobles base instincts, for Alison and Nicholas inhabit not a courtly world but a natural one, and their intellectual, spiritual, and romantic pretensions constitute only a thin veneer covering their healthy animalism. By using distance as a means of ennobling base instincts, “The Miller’s Tale” parodies not only the world and the theme of “The Knight’s Tale” but also its poetic treatment. Nicholas’s seduction plan plays upon both the strengths and the weaknesses of the carpenter’s character. Telling John that another flood is coming, Nicholas convinces the carpenter that he must hang three barrels from the rafters in which Nicholas, John, and Alison can remain until the waters rise; then they will cut themselves free to float away. The carpenter’s pretensions to spiritual and theological superiority cause him to accept this prophecy unquestioningly, but at the same time his genuine love for his wife causes his first reaction to be fear for her life. When all three on the appointed night have ostensibly entered their barrels, Nicholas and Alison sneak down to spend a night in amorous play. At this point the plot is entered by Absolon, who comes to Alison’s window to serenade her; pleading for a kiss, he finds himself presented with Alison’s backside. Bent then on avenging his misdirected kiss, he brings a hot colter and asks for another kiss; presented this time with the backside of Nicholas, Absolon smacks it smartly with the red-hot colter, causing Nicholas to cry out “Water!” which in turn causes the carpenter to cut the rope on his barrel and crash to the ground, injuring both his person and his dignity. Whereas in “The Knight’s Tale” the three major characters ultimately obtain what they desire most—Arcite, victory; Palamon, Emily; and Emily, the man who loves her most—“The Miller’s Tale” reverses this idea; John, the jealous carpenter, is cuckolded and humiliated in front of the entire town, the fastidious Absolon has kissed Alison’s “nether ye,” and Nicholas has lost a hand’s-breadth of skin from his backside. Only Alison remains unscathed, but then, she must spend her life being married to John. The poem thus parodies the romance tradition, the idealistic notion that civilized or courtly processes can elevate and ennoble fundamental human passions. Even as it transfers various themes, mechanisms, and perspectives from “The Knight’s Tale,” “The Miller’s Tale” transforms these and reflects them negatively. The generic differences between the two poems, however, demand that content and tone differ. “The Knight’s Tale,” combining epic and romance, deals seriously with serious considerations, whereas “The Miller’s Tale,” by virtue of its being a fabliau, has as one of its purposes the humorous depiction of human shortcomings. “The Reeve’s Tale” • “The Knight’s Tale” and “The Miller’s Tale” are different tales that have structural similarities; “The Reeve’s Tale,” which completes the poem’s first thematic grouping, shares with “The Miller’s Tale” the fabliau form, but the two differ considerably in tone. The Reeve’s story results from his outrage at the Miller’s story, which has belittled carpenters; in angry retaliation the Reeve relates the popu-
Chaucer, Geoffrey
215
lar fabliau concerning the two students who, cheated by a dishonest miller, exact revenge by sleeping with both his wife and his daughter. The plot, which hangs in part upon the device of the misplaced cradle, has as its end the unsophisticated students’ triumph over the social-climbing miller. The tone of “The Reeve’s Tale,” therefore, is bitter and vindictive, told, the Reeve acknowledges, solely to repay the Miller. Chaucer uses the romance and the fabliau, the two forms with which he begins his series of tales, again and again in the course of the poem. Other romances are the unfinished “The Squire’s Tale,” which has an Asian setting; “The Man of Law’s Tale,” which blends romance and a saint’s life in the story of the unfortunate Constance; and “The Wife of Bath’s Tale,” “The Clerk’s Tale,” and “The Franklin’s Tale,” which will be discussed together as “the marriage group.” The genre of the fabliau is also further represented in “The Shipman’s Tale” of the debt repaid by the adulterous monk to his lender’s wife, and in “The Friar’s Tale” and “The Summoner’s Tale,” stories that are attacks on each other’s professions and which are told to be mutually insulting. Chaucer’s Use of Saints’ Lives • Another popular genre Chaucer employs in his collection is that of the saints’ lives, a type used in “The Second Nun’s Tale” of St. Cecilia and in “The Prioress’s Tale” of the martyred Christian boy slain by Jews. Although both tales conventionally concern “miracles of the Virgin,” the tale of the Prioress is of particular interest because of the nature of the storyteller. Although she is supposed to be a spiritual being, a guardian of other spiritual beings, she is described in the same manner as the heroine of a courtly romance; moreover, although her description points to sensitivity and charity, her moral sensibility is clearly faulty. She worries over a little mouse but tells a violent tale of religious intolerance. Moreover, the ironies implicit in the engraving on her brooch—“Amor vincit omnia”—are extensive, as are the ironies deriving from the conflicting perspectives of the narrator, who naïvely admires her for all the wrong reasons, and the poet, who clearly sees her as possessed of many shortcomings. “The Nun’s Priest’s Tale” • Another popular genre in the Middle Ages was the beast-fable, a form that Chaucer uses brilliantly in “The Nun’s Priest’s Tale.” The story concerns Chauntecleer and Pertelote, a cock and hen owned by a poor widow. When Chauntecleer one night dreams of a fox, he and Pertelote have an extended discussion on the validity of dreams. Believing that dreams are caused by bile or overeating, Pertelote advises the use of a laxative; Chauntecleer, however, holding a different opinion, tells a story wherein a dream is proven prophetic. At this point the fox appears, whom the Nun’s Priest likens to such other traitors as Simon and Judas Iscariot. Even as he insists that his antifeminine statements are not his own but the cock’s, the Nun’s Priest clearly believes that woman’s counsel often brings misfortune and points with relish to the fox’s sudden appearance as proof of this belief. The encounter between the fox and the cock reveals the weaknesses of both. Relying hugely on flattery, the fox persuades Chauntecleer to relax his guard, close his eyes, and stretch his neck, providing the perfect opportunity to seize Chauntecleer and race off. As the widow and her household set chase, Chauntecleer advises the fox to tell the pursuers to turn back because he will soon be eating Chauntecleer in spite of them; when the fox opens his mouth to do this, Chauntecleer escapes. Although the fox tries to persuade Chauntecleer to come down out of the tree, Chauntecleer wisely declares that he will not again be fooled by flattery
216
Short Story Writers
and that no one should prosper who closes his eyes when he should watch. The fox, as one might expect, disagrees, declaring that no one should prosper who talks when he should hold his peace. The poem thus uses the beast-fable’s technique of personifying animals to the end of revealing human truths; it also uses the conventions and the rhetoric of epic and courtly romance to talk about the lives of chickens, thus creating a parody of the epic form and a burlesque of the courtly attitude. The poem is also, to a degree, homiletic in treating the dangers inherent in succumbing to flattery; each character suffers as a result of this weakness, the cock by having foolishly permitted himself to be captured, and the fox by having gullibly permitted himself to be hoodwinked by one pretending affinity. “The Wife of Bath’s Tale” • Having begun the discussion of The Canterbury Tales with an analysis of the group of tales concerned with the love-triangle, it seems fitting to end the discussion with an analysis of those tales referred to as “the marriage group.” “The Wife of Bath’s Tale,” “The Clerk’s Tale,” “The Merchant’s Tale,” and “The Franklin’s Tale” bring to that group several perspectives on women and the relation between the sexes. The Wife of Bath, in complete opposition to the traditional view of women, presents one extreme point of view that advocates sensuality and female authority. An excellent example of what she advocates, the wife is strong and lusty and insists on dominance in her marriages. In her lengthy prologue to her story she takes issue with patristic doctrine concerning chastity and female inferiority and uses scriptural allusions to buttress her opinions. Her prologue thus provides a defense of women and of sensuality. The Wife of Bath’s tale, an exemplum illustrating the argument contained in her prologue, concerns a knight who must, in order to save his life, find out what women desire most. Despairing over his inability to get a consensus of opinion, he one day comes upon a “loathly lady” who offers to give him the answer if he in turn will do what she requests. Gratefully agreeing, he learns that women most want “sovereynetee” and “maistrie” over their husbands; he is less pleased, however, to learn that her request is that he marry her. Having kept his promise, the knight on their wedding night is understandably distant from his new wife; when pressed for an explanation, he notes that she is ugly, old, and lowly born. She in turn explains that nobility comes not from wealth or birth, that poverty is virtuous, and that her age and ugliness ensure her chastity. She gives the knight a choice: He can have her ugly and old but faithful, or young and pretty but untrue. The knight chooses, however, to transfer this decision and consequently the control of the marriage to her, whereupon she announces that she will be not only young and pretty but also faithful, thus illustrating the good that comes when women are in control. “The Clerk’s Tale” • The Wife’s tale, and the wife herself, with her heretical opinions concerning marriage and sexual relations, outrage the Clerk, who tells a tale to counter the Wife’s; his tale reinforces the doctrine that male dominance on earth conforms to the order of the divine hierarchy. His story treats the patient Griselda, who promises her husband, Walter, to do everything he wishes and never to complain or in any way indicate disagreement. When a daughter is born to them, Walter, who is an Italian marquis, tells Griselda that since the people are complaining about her low birth, he must have the child killed, to which Griselda meekly agrees; Walter, however, sends the child secretly to a relative to be reared. When a son is born, Walter
Chaucer, Geoffrey
217
again does the same thing, again to test her obedience, and again Griselda is perfectly submissive. Twelve years later Walter secretly sends for the two children and tells Griselda that since he is divorcing her in order to marry someone else, she must return to her father. Moreover, he insists that she return to her father just as she had left him, that is, naked, since Walter had provided her with clothes. Griselda, with great dignity, requests at least a shift as recompense for the virginity which she had brought to him but which she cannot take away with her. When asked later to come and make arrangements for Walter’s new bride, Griselda cheerfully complies, although she does, at this point, give some indication of the great price she has paid for her obedience and her faithfulness to her vow; she asks Walter not to torment his new wife as he tormented her, the bride-to-be having been tenderly reared and therefore not so well able to withstand such adversity. Walter, finally satisfied as to Griselda’s steadfastness, restores her as his wife and reunites her with her children. The Clerk concludes by noting that it is hard to find women like Griselda nowadays. The tale is one with which critics have long grappled, since it presents seemingly insurmountable interpretive problems. The story can hardly be taken as realistic, even though the Clerk, through his efforts to give Walter psychological motivation, attempts to provide verisimilitude. Although the poem may be intended as allegory, to illustrate that one must be content in adversity, it seems also to have a tropological level of meaning, to illustrate the proper attitude for wives. The narrator’s own uncertainty as to whether he tells a tale of real people, a saint’s life, or an allegory, contributes to the difficulty one has in assessing the poem’s nature and purpose. It is obvious, though, that the Clerk’s intended corrective to “The Wife of Bath’s Tale” is perfectly accomplished through his tale of the impossibly patient Griselda. “The Merchant’s Tale” • At the end of his tale the Clerk appears to switch directions; he advises that no husband should try what Walter did, and that furthermore wives should be fierce to their husbands, should provoke their jealousy, and should make them weep and wail. The Merchant picks up this notion and echoes the line in the first sentence of his own remarks, which are intended to counter the Clerk’s presentation of the saintly wife. The Merchant’s own unhappy marriage experience adds a painfully personal coloration to his tale of the old husband and the young wife. The Merchant’s story of May, Januarie, and the pear tree is well known in the history of the fabliau. Immediately after wedding the sixty-year-old Januarie, whose lovemaking she considers not “worth a bene,” May meets and falls in love with Damian, who loves her in return. When Januarie becomes temporarily blind, the lovers plot to consummate their love in the pear tree above Januarie’s head. Pluto and Proserpina, debating how men and women betray each other, decide to restore Januarie’s sight but to give May a facile tongue. Consequently, when Januarie’s sight returns and he sees May and Damian making love in the pear tree, May explains that her struggling in a tree with a man was an effort to restore his sight, which is obviously as yet imperfect. Placated, Januarie accepts her explanation, and they are reconciled. The three tales thus present varying views of woman as lascivious termagant, as obedient saint, and as clever deceiver; marriage, accordingly, is seen as a struggle for power and freedom between combatants who are natural adversaries. It remains for Chaucer in “The Franklin’s Tale” to attempt a more balanced view, to try to achieve a reconciliation of the oppositions posed in the tales of the Wife of Bath, the Clerk, and the Merchant.
218
Short Story Writers
“The Franklin’s Tale” • “The Franklin’s Tale” is a particular kind of romance called a Breton lai, which conventionally is concentrated, imaginative, and exaggeratedly romantic. Although the tale is interesting in its depiction of an integrity which rests upon absolute commitment to the pledged word, the intricacies of the poem’s moral issues are ultimately resolved, in a rather disappointing fashion, by something akin to a deus ex machina. The tale, nevertheless, has been seen traditionally to function as the reconciliation of the marriage group because of the more balanced relationship portrayed between Arveragus, a knight, and Dorigen, his wife. The couple agree that he will show no sovereignty except for that semblance of it which may be necessary for his dignity, and that their effort will be for freedom, harmony, and mutual respect in marriage, rather than for mastery. In this regard, they represent an ideal example of marriage which is totally antithetical to those of the preceding marriage tales; in Dorigen and Arveragus, Chaucer seems to be exploring the possibility that chivalric ideals and middle-class virtues can be compatible in marriage. Whether the poet really believes this is possible, however, is placed in question by the tale’s romance form and by its contrived ending. While Arveragus is away on knightly endeavors, Dorigen mourns and grieves, worrying particularly about the black rocks that make the coastline hazardous. When Aurelius, who has loved her long, pleads for her attentions, she explains that she will never be unfaithful to her husband but adds, in jest, that if he will remove the rocks she will love him. Two years after Arveragus has come home, Aurelius, made ill by his long-frustrated passion, finds a magician who, for a large fee, creates the illusion that the rocks have vanished. Asked then to fulfill her end of the bargain, the horrified Dorigen contemplates suicide to avoid this dishonor, but her miserably unhappy husband, declaring that “Trouthe is the hyeste thyng that man may kepe,” sends Dorigen to fulfill her promise. Pitying them, Aurelius releases her from her promise and is in turn released from his debt by the magician; the tale ends by asking who was the most generous. Although Dorigen and Arveragus have a marriage based on respect, honesty, and love, and although they share a moral sensibility and agree on the importance of honor to them individually and to their marriage, the artificial resolution of the plot by totally unexpected elements—the decisions of both Aurelius and the magician not to press their just claims—would seem to suggest that the poet himself dared not treat in a realistic fashion the unpleasant and probably disastrous results of the plot which he had created. In effect, he established an ideal marriage situation, set up a test of that marriage’s strength, but then decided not to go through with the test. In placing his attempted solution of the marriage problem in the form of a Breton lai, in failing to pursue to the end the ver y questions he himself raises, and in providing a typical romance ending, the poet seems to indicate that any real solution to the problems pertaining to women and to marriage are not going to be so easily attained. The Canterbur y Tales, then, represents one of the earliest collections of short stories of almost ever y conceivable type. In addition to being a generic compendium, the poem is also a compendium of characters, since the pilgrims who tell the stories and the people who inhabit the stories together constitute the widest possible representation of character types. In framing his collection of tales with the pilgrimage, Chaucer permitted himself an eclecticism in form, content, and treatment which was unprecedented in English literature. There are those who would eagerly affirm that the grace of vision which permeates The Canterbur y
Chaucer, Geoffrey
219
Tales makes the work not only one which was unprecedented but also one which has not since been equaled. Evelyn Newlyn With updates by William Nelles Other major works miscellaneous: Works, 1957 (second edition; F. N. Robinson, editor). nonfiction: Boece, c. 1380 (translation of Boethius’ The Consolation of Philosophy); A Treatise on the Astrolabe, 1387-1392. Bibliography Borroff, Marie. Traditions and Renewals: Chaucer, the Gawain-Poet, and Beyond. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 2003. Collection of essays that provide a fresh and different analysis of Chaucer’s work. Brewer, Derek. A New Introduction to Chaucer. New York: Longman, 1998. Written by an expert in the field, this volume provides ample biographical and historical material for anyone who is unfamiliar with Chaucer’s life and work. Includes a thorough bibliography and index. Brown, Peter, ed. A Companion to Chaucer. Malden, Mass.: Blackwell, 2000. Part of the Blackwell Companions to Literature and Culture series, offers broad and detailed essays by scholars of Chaucer and his era. Condren, Edward I. Chaucer and the Energy of Creation: The Design and the Organization of “The Canterbury Tales.” Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 1999. Examines the motives behind Chaucer’s layout of the stories. Gittes, Katherine S. Framing the Canterbury Tales: Chaucer and the Medieval Frame Narrative Tradition. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1991. Analyzes the influence of the Asian frame narrative tradition on The Canterbury Tales; argues that what was once taken for incompleteness is the result of the influence of Eastern modes of narrative structure. Narkiss, Doron. “The Fox, the Cock, and the Priest: Chaucer’s Escape from Fable.” The Chaucer Review 32 (1997): 46-63. Examines Chaucer’s reworking of Aesop’s fable in “The Nun’s Priest’s Tale.” Argues that Chaucer moves the fable away from the realm of learning and wisdom to mockery and a way of reading that in “The Nun’s Priest’s Tale” fable is extended by characterization and action. Claims that Chaucer’s use of the fable suggests doubling, repetition, and substitutions. Percival, Florence. Chaucer’s Legendary Good Women. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998. Suitable for introductory students yet containing challenging insights for scholars. Percival attempts to provide a comprehensive interpretation of the puzzling Legend of Good Women without ignoring any of the contradictory views that it contains about women. Rossignol, Rosalyn. Chaucer A to Z: The Essential Reference to His Life and Works. New York: Facts on File, 1999. Indispensable guide for the student of Chaucer. West, Richard. Chaucer 1340-1400: The Life and Times of the First English Poet. New York: Carroll & Graf, 2000. Discussion of the history surrounding Chaucer’s achievements and the events of his life. Chapters take up such matters as the Black Death’s impact on the anti-Semitism evident in “The Prioress’s Tale” and the impact of the great English Peasants’ Revolt of 1381 on Chaucer’s worldview.
220
John Cheever Born: Quincy, Massachusetts; May 27, 1912 Died: Ossining, New York; June 18, 1982 Principal short fiction • The Way Some People Live, 1943; The Enormous Radio, and Other Stories, 1953; “The Country Husband,” 1954; The Housebreaker of Shady Hill, and Other Stories, 1958; Some People, Places, and Things That Will Not Appear in My Next Novel, 1961; The Brigadier and the Golf Widow, 1964; The World of Apples, 1973; The Stories of John Cheever, 1978; Thirteen Uncollected Stories, 1994. Other literary forms • Believing that “fiction is our most intimate and acute means of communication, at a profound level, about our deepest apprehensions and intuitions on the meaning of life and death,” John Cheever devoted himself to the writing of stories and novels. Although he kept voluminous journals, he wrote only a handful of essays and even fewer reviews, and only one television screenplay, The Shady Hill Kidnapping, which aired January 12, 1982, on the Public Broadcasting Service. A number of Cheever’s works have also been adapted by other writers, including several early short stories such as “The Town House” (play, 1948), “The Swimmer” (film, 1968), “Goodbye, My Brother” as Children (play, 1976), and “O Youth and Beauty,” “The Five-Forty-Eight,” and “The Sorrows of Gin” (teleplays, 1979). Benjamin Cheever has edited selections of his father’s correspondence, The Letters of John Cheever (1988), and journals, The Journals of John Cheever (1991). Achievements • A major twentieth century novelist, John Cheever has achieved even greater fame as a short-story writer. He published his first story, “Expelled,” in The New Republic when he was only eighteen. Reviewers of his first collection, The Way Some People Live, judged Cheever to be a promising young writer. Numerous awards and honors followed: two John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation grants (1951, 1961), a Benjamin Franklin award for “The Five-Forty-Eight” (1955), an O. Henry Award for “The Country Husband” (1956), election to the National Institute of Arts and Letters in 1957, elevation to the American Academy in 1973, a National Book Award in 1958 for The Wapshot Chronicle (1957), the Howells Medal in 1965 for The Wapshot Scandal (1964), cover stories in Time (1964) and Newsweek (1977), the Edward MacDowell Medal in 1979, a Pulitzer Prize and a National Book Critics Circle award (both in 1978), an American Book Award (1979) for The Stories of John Cheever, and the National Medal for Literature (1982). Cheever’s achievements, however, cannot be measured only in terms of the awards and honors that he has received (including the honorary doctorate bestowed on this high school dropout), for his most significant accomplishment was to create, with the publication of The Stories of John Cheever, a resurgence of interest in, and a new respect for, the short story on the part of public and publishers alike. Biography • The loss of his father’s job in 1930, followed by the loss of the family home and the strained marital situation caused, John Cheever believed, by his mother’s growing financial and emotional dependence, all had a lifelong effect on
Cheever, John
221
Cheever. When he was expelled from Thayer Academy at the age of seventeen, Cheever was already committed to a writing career. His career, however, would do little to assuage his sense of emotional and economic insecurity. Although he liked to claim that “fiction is not crypto-autobiography,” from the beginning, his stories were drawn from his personal experiences. They have even followed him geographically: from New England, to New York City, through his military service, to the suburbs (first Scarborough, then Ossining), with side trips to Italy (1956-1957), the Soviet Union (on three government-sponsored trips), and Sing Sing prison, where he taught writing (1971-1972). The stories have, more importantly, followed Cheever over hazardous emotional terrain, transforming personal obsessions into published fictions: alcoholism, bisexuality, self-doubts, strained marital relations, and the sense of “otherness.” The stories also evidence the longing for stability and home that manifested itself in three of the most enduring relationships of his fifty-year career: with the Yaddo writers’ colony in Saratoga Springs, New York (beginning in 1934); with The New Yorker (which began publishing his work in 1935); and with his wife Mary Winternitz Cheever (whom he met in 1939 and married two years later, and with whom he bickered over the next forty years). Cheever did not become free of his various fears and dependencies—including his nearly suicidal addiction to alcohol—until the mid-1970’s. After undergoing treatment for alcoholism at Smithers Rehabilitation Center, he transformed what might well have become his darkest novel into his most affirmative. Falconer (1977) was both a critical and a commercial success. Like its main character, Cheever seemed for the first time in his life free, willing at least to begin talking about the private life that he had so successfully guarded, even mythified before, when he had played the part of country squire. The triumph was, however, short-lived. After two neurological seizures in 1980, a kidney operation and the discovery of cancer in 1981, and, shortly after the publication of his fifth novel, the aptly and perhaps whimsically titled Oh What a Paradise It Seems (1982), he died on June 18, 1982. Analysis • John Cheever has been called both “the Chekhov of the exurbs” and “Ovid in Ossining”—which suggests both the variety and the complexity of the man and his fiction. Accused by some of being a literary lightweight—a writer merely of short stories and an apologist for middle-class life—he has been more often, and more justly, praised as a master chronicler of a way of life that he both celebrates and satirizes in stories that seem at once conventional and innovative, realistic and fantastic. His stories read effortlessly, yet their seeming simplicity masks a complexity that deserves and repays close attention. The line “The light from the cottage, shining into the fog, gave the illusion of substance, and it seems as if I might stumble on a beam of light,” for example, only appears simple and straightforward. It begins with a conventional image, light penetrating darkness, thus illuminating the way to truth, but the next five words undermine the “illusion” first by calling attention to it, then by paradoxically literalizing the metaphor, making this substantive light a stumbling block rather than a source of spiritual or philosophical truth. “A Miscellany of Characters That Will Not Appear in My Next Novel” • Nothing in Cheever’s fiction of stark contrasts—light and dark, male and female, city and country—ever exists independent of its opposite. His stories proceed incrementally and contrapuntally, at times in curiously indirect ways. In “A Miscellany of Characters That Will Not Appear in My Next Novel,” for example, Cheever’s narrator
222
Short Story Writers
banishes seven kinds of characters and situations from his fiction, including alcoholics, homosexuals, and “scornful descriptions of American landscapes.” However, not only did his next novel, as well as much of the rest of his fiction, include all three, but also the very act of listing them in this “miscellany” confirms their power, giving TO VIEW IMAGE, them a prominence that far outPLEASE SEE weighs their hypothetical banishPRINT EDITION ment from any later work. This play of voices and positions within OF THIS BOOK. individual works also exists between stories. The same narrative situations will appear in various Cheever stories, handled comically in some, tragically in others. In effect, the stories offer a series of brilliant variations on a number of basic, almost obsessive themes, of which the most general and the most re© Nancy Crampton current as well as the most important is the essential conflict between his characters’ spiritual longings and social and psychological (especially sexual) nature. “What I wanted to do,” one of his narrator-protagonists says, is “to grant my dreams, in so incoherent a world, their legitimacy,” “to celebrate,” as another claims, “a world that lies spread out around us like a bewildering and stupendous dream.” Their longings are tempered not only by the incoherence of their world but also by a doubt concerning whether what they long for actually exists or is rather only an illusion conjured out of nothing more substantial than their own ardent hopes for something or some place or someone other than who, what, and where they currently are. Even when expressed in the most ludicrous terms possible, the characters’ longings seem just as profound as they are ridiculous, as in the case of “Artemis the Honest Well Digger” searching “for a girl as pure and fresh as the girl on the oleomargarine package.” The line seems both to affirm and to qualify the yearning of a character who may confuse kitsch with Kant, advertising copy with lyrical longings, but who nevertheless seems as much a holy fool as a deluded consumer. Whether treated comically or tragically, Cheever’s characters share a number of traits. Most are male, married, and white-collar workers. All—despite their Sutton Place apartments or, more often, comfortable homes in affluent Westchester communities—feel confused, dispossessed, lost; they all seem to be what the characters in Cheever’s Italian stories actually are: expatriates and exiles. Physical ailments are rare, emotional ones epidemic. Instead of disease, there is the “dis-ease” of “spiritual nomadism.” They are as restless as any of Cheever’s most wayward plots and in need of “building a bridge” between the events of their lives as well as between those lives and their longings.
Cheever, John
223
Trapped in routines as restricting as any prison cell and often in marriages that seem little more than sexual battlefields, where even the hair curlers appear “bellicose,” Cheever’s characters appear poised between escaping into the past in a futile effort to repeat what they believe they have lost and aspiring to a lyrical future that can be affirmed, even “sung,” though never quite attained. Even the latter can be dangerous. “Dominated by anticipation” (a number of Cheever’s characters hope excessively), they are locked in a state of perpetual adolescence, unwilling to grow up, take responsibility, and face death in any form. Although their world may lie spread out like a bewildering and stupendous dream, they find it nevertheless confining, inhospitable, even haunted by fears of emotional and economic insecurity and a sense of personal inadequacy and inconsequentiality, their sole inheritance, it seems, from the many fathers who figure so prominently in the stories, often by virtue of their absence from the lives of their now-middle-aged sons. Adrift in an incoherent world and alone in the midst of suburbs zoned for felicity, they suffer frequent blows to their already fragile sense of self-esteem, seeing through yet wanting the protection of the veneer of social decorum and ceremoniousness that is the outward and visible sign of American middle-class aspiration and which Cheever’s characters do not so much court as covet. “The Enormous Radio” • The thinness of the veneer of social decorum is especially apparent in “The Enormous Radio,” a work that shows little trace of the Ernest Hemingway style that marks many of Cheever’s earlier stories. The story begins realistically enough. Jim and Irene Westcott, in their mid-thirties, are an average couple in all respects but one: their above-average interest in classical music (and, one assumes, in the harmony and decorum that such music represents). When their old radio breaks down, Jim generously buys an expensive new one to which Irene takes an instant dislike. Like their interest in music, which they indulge as if a secret but harmless vice, this small disruption in their harmonious married life seems a minor affair, at least at first. The radio, however, appearing “like an aggressive intruder,” shedding a “malevolent green light,” and possessing a “mistaken sensitivity to discord,” soon becomes a divisive, even diabolical presence, but the evil in this story, as in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown,” to which it has often been compared, comes from within the characters, not from without (the radio). When the radio begins to broadcast the Westcotts’ neighbors’ quarrels, lusts, fears, and crimes, Irene becomes dismayed, perversely entertained, and finally apprehensive; if she can eavesdrop on her neighbors’ most intimate conversations, she thinks that perhaps they can listen in on hers. Hearing their tales of woe, she demands that her husband affirm their happiness. Far from easing her apprehensiveness, his words only exacerbate it as he first voices his own previously well-guarded frustrations over money, job prospects, and growing old, and as he eventually exposes his wife’s own evil nature. As frustration explodes into accusation, the illusion of marital happiness that the Westcotts had so carefully cultivated shatters. As with so many Cheever stories, “The Enormous Radio” has its origin in biographical fact: While writing in the basement of a Sutton Place apartment house, Cheever would hear the elevator going up and down and would imagine that the wires could carry his neighbors’ conversations down to him. “Goodbye, My Brother” • “Goodbye, My Brother” derives from another and far more pervasive biographical fact, Cheever’s relationship with his elder brother, Fred, the father figure to whom he developed too close an attachment. Fred turned
224
Short Story Writers
to business and for a time supported Cheever’s writing but, like Cheever, eventually became an alcoholic. Beginning with “The Brothers” and culminating in the fratricide in Falconer, relations between brothers figure nearly as prominently in Cheever’s fiction as those between spouses. Just as stories such as “The Enormous Radio” are not simply about marital spats, “Goodbye, My Brother” is not just about sibling rivalry. Just as the relationship between Irene and the malevolent radio is actually about a condition within the marriage and more especially within Irene herself, the external relationship between the story’s narrator and his brother Lawrence is actually about the narrator’s own Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde personality—in psychological terms, a matter of split personality and projection. Lawrence’s narrator objectifies Lawrence’s own frustrations, self-loathing, and fears. Lawrence and the narrator are two of the Pommeroys who have gathered on Laud’s Head in August for their annual family vacation. Like his sister, just back after her divorce, and their widowed mother, who drinks too much while trying to keep up the family’s upper-crust pretensions, the narrator needs these few weeks of respite from the grind of his dead-end teaching job. Together they swim, play cards and tennis, drink, and go to costume dances, where in an almost Jungian freak of chance, all the men come dressed as football players and all the women as brides, as eloquent a statement of the sadness of their blighted but still aspiring lives as one can imagine. Lawrence partakes in none of it. A lawyer moving from one city and job to another, he is the only family member with prospects and the only one unable to enjoy or even tolerate the illusion of happiness that the family seeks to maintain. He is also the only one willing, indeed eager, to detect the flaws and fakery in the Pommeroys’ summer home, its protective sea wall, and its equally protective forms of play. Gloomy and morose as well as critical, Lawrence is, to borrow the title of another Cheever story, the worm in the Pommeroy apple. He is the messenger bearing the bad news, whom the narrator nearly kills with a blow to the head as the two walk along the beach. He strikes not only to free himself from his brother’s morbid presence but also to extirpate the Lawrence side of his own divided self: Cain and Abel, murderer and good Samaritan. Once Lawrence and his sickly looking wife and daughter leave, the narrator turns to the purifying water and the triumphant vision of his mythically named wife and sister, Helen and Diana, rising naked from the sea. The story closes on a lyrically charged note that seems both to affirm all that the Pommeroys have sought and, by virtue of the degree of lyrical intensity, to accentuate the gap between that vision and Lawrence’s more factual and pessimistic point of view. “O Youth and Beauty” • “O Youth and Beauty” makes explicit what virtually all Cheever’s stories imply, the end of youth’s promise, of that hopeful vision that the ending of “Goodbye, My Brother” sought to affirm. Thus it seems ironically apt that “O Youth and Beauty” should begin with a long (two-hundred-word) Whitmanesque sentence, which, in addition to setting the scene and establishing the narrative situation, subtly evokes that Transcendental vision that Walt Whitman both espoused and, in his distinctive poetic style, sought to embody. Beginning “At the tag end of nearly every long, large Saturday night party in the suburb of Shady Hill,” it proceeds through a series of long anaphoric subordinate clauses beginning with the word “when” and ending with “then Trace Bearden would begin to chide Cash Bentley about his age and thinning hair.” The reader is thus introduced to what, for the partygoers, has already become something of a suburban ritual: the perfectly named
Cheever, John
225
Cash Bentley’s hurdling of the furniture as a way of warding off death and reliving the athletic triumphs of the youth that he refuses to relinquish. When Cash, now forty, breaks his leg, the intimations of mortality begin to multiply in his morbid mind. Although he may run his race alone, and although the Lawrentian gloominess that comes in the wake of the accident may make him increasingly isolated from his neighbors and friends, Cash is not at all unique, and his fears are extreme but nevertheless representative of a fear that pervades the entire community and that evidences itself in his wife’s trying to appear younger and slimmer than she is and her “cutting out of the current copy of Life those scenes of mayhem, disaster, and violent death that she felt might corrupt her children.” It is rather ironic that a moment later she should accidentally kill her husband in their own living room with the starter’s pistol, as he attempts to recapture the past glories of all those other late Saturday night races against time and self in an attempt always, already doomed, to recapture the past glories of his days as a young track star. The track is in fact an apt symbol for Cash’s circular life, in which, instead of progress, one finds only the horror of Nietzschean eternal recurrence. “The Five-Forty-Eight” • Upon first reading, “The Five-Forty-Eight” seems to have little in common with the blackly humorous “O Youth and Beauty.” A disturbed woman, Miss Dent, follows Blake, whose secretary she had been for three weeks and whose lover she was for one night, some six months earlier. She trails him from his office building to his commuter train. Threatening to shoot him, she gets off at his stop and forces him to kneel and rub his face in the dirt for having seduced and abandoned her. One of Cheever’s least likable characters, Blake gets what he deserves. Having chosen Miss Dent as he has chosen his other women (including, it seems, his wife) “for their lack of self-esteem,” he not only had her fired the day after they made love but also took the afternoon off. Miss Dent fares considerably better, for in choosing not to kill Blake she discovers “some kindness, some saneness” in herself that she believes she can put to use. Blake too undergoes a change insofar as he experiences regret for the first time and comes to understand his own vulnerability, which he has heretofore managed to safeguard by means of his “protective” routines and scrupulous observance of Shady Hill’s sumptuary laws. Whether these changes will be lasting remains unclear; he is last seen picking himself up, cleaning himself off, and walking home, alone. “The Housebreaker of Shady Hill” • “The Five-Forty-Eight” is quite literally one of Cheever’s darkest stories; only the dimmest of lights and the faintest of hopes shine at its end. Although it too ends at night, “The Housebreaker of Shady Hill” is one of Cheever’s brightest and most cheerful works, full of the spiritual phototropism so important in Falconer, the novel that Newsweek hailed as “Cheever’s Triumph.” The housebreaker is thirty-six-year-old Johnny Hake, kindly and comical, who suddenly finds himself out of work, at risk of losing his house, his circle of friends, and the last shreds of his self-esteem. Desperate for cash, he steals nine hundred dollars from a neighbor, a theft that transforms his vision of the world. Suddenly, he begins to see evil everywhere and evidence that everyone can see him for what he now is. The “moral bottom” drops out of his world but in decidedly comic fashion: Even a birthday gift from his children—an extension ladder—becomes an acknowledgment of his wrongdoing (and nearly cause for divorce). Chance, however, saves Johnny. Walking to his next victim’s house, he feels a few drops of rain fall on his head and
226
Short Story Writers
awakens from his ludicrous nightmare, his vision of the world restored. Opting for life’s simple pleasures (he is after all still unemployed), he returns home and has a pleasant dream in which he is seventeen years old. Johnny cannot get his youth back, but he does get his job back (and he does return the money he has stolen). The happy endings proliferate as the story slips the yoke of realism and romps in the magical realm of pure fairy tale, where, as Cheever puts it far more sardonically in his third novel, Bullet Park (1969), everything is “wonderful wonderful wonderful wonderful.” “The Country Husband” • Comic exaggeration and hyperbolically happy endings characterize many of the stories of the late 1950’s and early 1960’s. In “The Housebreaker of Shady Hill,” it is losing his job that starts Johnny Hake on his comical crime spree; in “The Country Husband,” it is nearly losing his life that sends Francis Weed on an ever more absurdly comical quest for love and understanding. Weed has his brush with death when his plane is forced to make an emergency landing in a field outside Philadelphia. The danger over, his vulnerability (like Blake’s) and mortality (like Cash Bentley’s) established, the real damage begins when Weed can find no one to lend a sympathetic ear—not his friend, Trace Bearden, on the commuter train, not even his wife, Julia (too busy putting dinner on the table), or his children (the youngest are fighting and the oldest is reading True Romance). With his very own True Adventure still untold, Weed goes outside, where he hears a neighbor playing “Moonlight Sonata,” rubato, “like an outpouring of tearful petulance, lonesomeness, and self-pity—of everything it was Beethoven’s greatness not to know,” and everything it will now be Weed’s comic misfortune to experience as he embarks upon his own True Romance with the rather unromantically named Anne Murchison, his children’s new teenage babysitter. Playing the part of a lovesick adolescent, the middle-aged Weed acts out his midlife crisis and in doing so jeopardizes his family’s social standing and his marriage. The consequences are potentially serious, as are the various characters’ fears and troubles (Anne’s alcoholic father, Julia’s “natural fear of chaos and loneliness,” which leads to her obsessive partygoing). What is humorous is Cheever’s handling of these fears in a story in which solecisms are slapstick, downfalls are pratfalls, and pariahs turn out to be weeds in Cheever’s suburban Garden of Eden. When Francis finally decides to overcome his Emersonian self-reliance, to confide in and seek the help of a psychiatrist (who will do what neither friends nor family have thus far been willing to do—that is, listen), the first words Weed tearfully blurts out are, “I’m in love, Dr. Harzog.” Since “The Country Husband” is a comedy, Weed is cured of his “dis-ease” and able to channel his desires into more socially acceptable ways (conjugal love and, humorously enough, woodworking). The story ends with a typically Cheeveresque affirmation of Fitzgerald-like romantic possibilities, no less apparent in Shady Hill than in The Great Gatsby’s (1925) West Egg. It is an affirmation, however, tempered once again by the tenuousness of the characters’ situation in a “village that hangs, morally and economically, from a thread.” “The Death of Justina” • The thread will break—although still comically—in “The Death of Justina.” Here, the focus is double, on the parallel plights of the authorial narrator, a fiction writer, and the protagonist-narrator of the story that he writes (like “The Housebreaker of Shady Hill,” in oral style), also a writer (of advertising copy). Briefly stated, their shared predicament is this: how (for the one) to write about and
Cheever, John
227
(for the other) to live in a world that seems to grow increasingly chaotic and preposterous. As the authorial narrator explains, “Fiction is art and art is the triumph over chaos (no less) and we can accomplish this only by the most vigilant exercise of choice, but in a world that changes more swiftly than we can perceive there is always the danger that our powers of selection will be mistaken and that the vision we serve will come to nothing.” The authorial narrator then offers a man named Moses’ account of the death of his wife’s cousin Justina as “one example of chaos.” Ordered by his doctor to stop smoking and drinking and by his boss to write copy for a product called Elixircol (something of a cross between Geritol and the Fountain of Youth), Moses suddenly finds himself at a complete loss when he tries to arrange for Justina’s funeral, for Justina has died in his house, and his house is an area of Proxmire Manor not zoned for death. No doctor will issue a death certificate, and the mayor refuses to sign an exemption until a quorum of the village council is available, but when Moses threatens to bury Justina in his yard, the mayor relents. Victorious but still shaken, Moses that night has a strange dream set in a vast supermarket where the shoppers stock their carts with unlabeled, shapeless packages, which are then, much to their shame, torn open at the checkout counters by brutish men who first ridicule the selections and then push the shoppers out the doors into what sounds much like Dante’s inferno. The scene is amusing but, like the ludicrously comical scenes in Franz Kafka’s works, also unsettling. The story does not affirm the shoppers any more than it does the village council that drew up the zoning laws, but it does understand what compels them even as it sympathetically satirizes the inadequacy of their means. As Moses points out, “How can a people who do not mean to understand death hope to understand love, and who will sound the alarm?” “The Brigadier and the Golf Widow” • “The Brigadier and the Golf Widow” makes a similar point in a similar way. Here too, the authorial narrator is perplexed, wondering what the nineteenth century writers Charles Dickens, Anton Chekhov, Nikolai Gogol, and William Makepeace Thackeray would have made of a fallout shelter (bizarrely decorated and disguised with gnomes, plaster ducks, and a birdbath). He also understands, however, that fallout shelters are as much a part of his midtwentieth century landscape as are trees and shrubbery. The shelter in question belongs to Charlie Pastern, the country club general who spends his time calling loudly for nuclear attacks on any and all of his nation’s enemies. His world begins to unravel when, by chance, he begins an affair with a neighbor whose own fears and insecurity lead her first to promiscuity and then to demanding the key to the Pasterns’ shelter (a key that the local bishop also covets). Apparently the last words of “The Death of Justina,” taken verbatim from the Twenty-third Psalm, about walking through the shadow of the valley of death and fearing no evil, no longer apply. For all the good cheer, hearty advice, biblical quotations, comical predicaments, and lyrical affirmations, there lies at the center of Cheever’s fiction the fear of insufficiency and inadequacy—of shelters that will not protect, marriages that will not endure, jobs that will be lost, threads that will not hold. “The Swimmer” • The fact that the thread does not hold in “The Swimmer,” Cheever’s most painstakingly crafted and horrific work, is especially odd, for the story begins as comedy, a lighthearted satire, involving a group of suburban couples sitting around the Westerhazys’ pool on a beautiful midsummer Sunday afternoon
228
Short Story Writers
talking about what and how much they drank the night before. Suddenly Neddy Merrill, yet another of Cheever’s middle-aged but youthfully named protagonists, decides to swim home pool to pool. More than a prank, it is for him a celebration of the fineness of the day, a voyage of discovery, a testament to life’s romantic possibilities. Neddy’s swim will cover eight miles, sixteen pools, in only ten pages (as printed in The Stories of John Cheever). Although he encounters some delays and obstacles—drinks graciously offered and politely, even ceremoniously, drunk, a thorny hedge to be gotten over, gravel underfoot—Neddy completes nearly half the journey in only two pages (pages 3-4; pages 1-2 are purely preparatory). The story and its reader move as confidently and rapidly as Neddy, but then there are a few interruptions: a brief rain shower that forces Neddy to seek shelter, a dry pool at one house, and a for-sale sign inexplicably posted at another. Midway through both journey and story, the point of view suddenly and briefly veers away from Neddy, who now looks pitifully exposed and foolishly stranded as he attempts to cross a divided highway. His strength and confidence ebbing, he seems unprepared for whatever lies ahead yet unable to turn back. Like the reader, he is unsure when his little joke turned so deadly serious. At the one public pool on his itinerary, he is assaulted by crowds, shrill sounds, and harsh odors. After being very nearly stalled for two pages, the pace quickens ever so slightly but only to leave Neddy still weaker and more disoriented. Each “breach in the succession” exposes Neddy’s inability to bridge the widening gap between his vision of the world and his actual place in it. He is painfully rebuffed by those he had previously been powerful enough to mistreat—a former mistress, a socially inferior couple whose invitations he and his wife routinely discarded. The apparent cause of Neddy’s downfall begins to become clear to the reader only as it begins to become clear to Neddy—a sudden and major financial reversal—but Neddy’s situation cannot be attributed to merely economic factors, nor is it susceptible to purely rational analysis. Somewhere along Neddy’s and the reader’s way, everything has changed: The passing of hours becomes the passage of whole seasons, perhaps even years, as realism gives way to fantasy, humor to horror as the swimmer sees his whole life pass before him in a sea of repressed memories. Somehow Neddy has woken into his own worst dream. Looking into his empty house, he comes face to face with the insecurity that nearly all Cheever’s characters fear and the inadequacy that they all feel. The stories (and novels) that Cheever wrote during the last two decades of his life grew increasingly and innovatively disparate in structure. “The Jewels of the Cabots,” for example, or “The President of the Argentine” matches the intensifying disunity of the author’s personal life. Against this narrative waywardness, however, Cheever continued to offer and even to extend an affirmation of the world and his protagonists’ place in it in a lyrically charged prose at once serene and expansive (“The World of Apples,” Falconer). In other words, he continued to do during these last two decades what he had been doing so well for the previous three: writing a fiction of celebration and incoherence. Robert A. Morace Other major works novels: The Wapshot Chronicle, 1957; The Wapshot Scandal, 1964; Bullet Park, 1969; Falconer, 1977; Oh, What a Paradise It Seems, 1982.
Cheever, John
229
nonfiction: The Letters of John Cheever, 1988 (Benjamin Cheever, editor); The Journals of John Cheever, 1991; Glad Tidings, a Friendship in Letters: The Correspondence of John Cheever and John D. Weaver, 1945-1982, 1993. teleplay: The Shady Hill Kidnapping, 1982. Bibliography Bosha, Francis J., ed. The Critical Response to John Cheever. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1994. Collection of reviews and critical essays on Cheever’s novels and shortstory collections by various commentators and critics. Cheever, Susan. Home Before Dark. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1984. This memoir by Cheever’s daughter is especially important for fleshing out his troubled early years and providing an insider’s look at his marital and other personal difficulties (alcoholism, illnesses, sexual desires). Suffers from lack of documentation and indexing. More valuable as a synthesis of previously published material than as a daughter’s intimate revelations. Collins, Robert G., ed. Critical Essays on John Cheever. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1982. Reprints an excellent sampling of reviews, interviews, and early criticism (including many dubbed “new” that are in fact only slightly reworked older pieces). Of the truly new items, three deserve special mention: Collins’s biocritical introduction, Dennis Coale’s bibliographical supplement, and particularly Samuel Coale’s “Cheever and Hawthorne: The American Romancer’s Art,” arguably one of the most important critical essays on Cheever. Dessner, Lawrence Jay. “Gender and Structure in John Cheever’s ‘The Country Husband.’” Studies in Short Fiction 31 (Winter, 1994): 57-68. Argues that the story is structured as a comedy with a farcical narrow escape and a tension between the domestic and the wild; contends the plot pattern dissolves pain into laughter. Donaldson, Scott. John Cheever: A Biography. New York: Random House, 1988. Scrupulously researched, interestingly written, and judiciously argued, Donaldson’s biography presents Cheever as both author and private man. Donaldson fleshes out most of the previously unknown areas in Cheever’s biography and dispels many of the biographical myths that Cheever himself encouraged. The account is sympathetic yet objective. Hipkiss, Robert. “‘The Country Husband’: A Model Cheever Achievement.” Studies in Short Fiction 27 (Fall, 1990): 577-585. Analyzes the story as a prose poem filled with imagery of war, myth, music, and nature. Argues that the elaborate image pattern makes one realize how rooted in the American value system the protagonist’s final fate really is. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these ten short stories by Cheever: “The Angel of the Bridge” and “The Brigadier and the Golf Widow” (vol. 1); “The Country Husband” and “The Enormous Radio” (vol. 2); “The FiveForty-Eight” and “Goodbye, My Brother” (vol. 3); “The Housebreaker of Shady Hill” (vol. 4); “Metamorphoses” (vol. 5); “The Swimmer” (vol. 7); and “The World of Apples” (vol. 8). Meanor, Patrick. John Cheever Revisited. New York: Twayne, 1995. The first book-length study of Cheever to make use of his journals and letters published in the late 1980’s and early 1990’s. Focuses on how Cheever created a mythopoeic world in his novels and stories. Includes two chapters on his short stories, with detailed
230
Short Story Writers
analyses of stories in The Enormous Radio, and Other Stories and The Brigadier and the Golf Widow. O’Hara, James E. John Cheever: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1989. In addition to reprinting five important reviews and critical essays and providing a detailed chronology and annotated selected bibliography, this volume offers a 120page analysis of Cheever as a writer of short stories that goes well beyond the introductory level. O’Hara’s discussion of the early unanthologized stories is especially noteworthy. Waldeland, Lynne. John Cheever. Boston: Twayne, 1979. This volume in Twayne’s United States Authors series is introductory in nature. Although it lacks the thematic coherence of other works, it has great breadth and evidences an awareness of previous critical commentary.
231
Anton Chekhov Born: Taganrog, Russia; January 29, 1860 Died: Badenweiler, Germany; July 15, 1904 Principal short fiction • Skazki Melpomeny, 1884; Pystrye rasskazy, 1886; Nevinnye rechi, 1887; V sumerkakh, 1887; Rasskazy, 1888; The Tales of Tchehov, 1916-1922 (13 volumes); The Undiscovered Chekhov: Forty-three New Stories, 1999 (revised and expanded, 2001). Other literary forms • Anton Chekhov’s literary reputation rests as much on his drama as on his stories and sketches, despite the fact that he was a far more prolific writer of fiction, having written only seventeen plays but almost six hundred stories. Chayka (1896, rev. 1898; The Seagull, 1909), Dyadya Vanya (1897; Uncle Vanya, 1914), Tri sestry (1901; The Three Sisters, 1920), and Vishnyovy sad (1904; The Cherry Orchard, 1908), Chekhov’s chief dramatic works, are universally considered classics of modern theater. Chekhov was also an indefatigable correspondent, and his letters, along with his diaries and notebooks, form an important segment of his writing. He also wrote numerous journal articles and one long work, Ostrov Sakhalin (serialized in 1893 and 1894), a scholarly exposé of an island penal colony that Chekhov visited in 1890. Achievements • In his lifetime, Anton Chekhov gained considerable critical acclaim. In 1888, he won the Pushkin Prize for his fiction, and in 1900, he was selected to honorary membership in the Russian Academy of Sciences for both his fiction and his drama. Chekhov’s fiction departs from the formulaic, heavily plotted story to mirror Russian life authentically, concentrating on characters in very ordinary circumstances that often seem devoid of conflict. A realist, Chekhov treads a fine line between detachment and a whimsical but sympathetic concern for his subjects. In his mature work, he is perhaps the most genial of Russian masters, compassionate and forgiving, seldom strident or doctrinaire. Equally important, that mature work reflects very careful artistry, worthy of study for its technique alone. Biography • Anton Pavlovich Chekhov, the third of six Chekhov children, was born on January 29, 1860, in Taganrog, a provincial city in southern Russia. His father, Pavel Egorovich Chekhov, son of a serf, ran a meager grocery store, which young Anton often tended in his neglectful father’s absence. A religious fanatic and stern disciplinarian, Pavel gave his children frequent beatings and forced them to spend long hours in various devotional activities. For Anton, who did not share his father’s zeal, it was a depressing, gloomy childhood. Although the family was poor and Pavel’s marginal business was slowly failing, Anton was able to get some schooling, first at a Greek parochial school, then at the boys’ gymnasium, or high school. In 1875, after a bout with acute peritonitis, young Chekhov decided to become a physician. His future brightened when, in 1876, his father, trying to evade his creditors, secretly moved the family to Moscow, leaving Anton to finish school. In 1879, Anton moved to Moscow, entered the medical school of the University of
232
Short Story Writers
Moscow, and almost immediately began publishing stories in various magazines and newspapers. A very prolific apprentice, by 1884, when he graduated from medical school, he had published his first collection of short fiction. By 1886, Chekhov had begun his long association and friendship with A. S. Suvorin, the owner of an influential conservative newspaper to which Chekhov contributed dozens of pieces. Recognized as a significant new author, Chekhov devoted more time to writing and less and less to his medical practice, which, in time, he would abandon altogether. Chekhov’s greatly improved finances allowed him to buy a better Moscow house and gave him time to travel, which he freLibrary of Congress quently did, despite ill health. In 1887, he journeyed to the Don Steppe, and two years later crossed Asia to visit the Russian penal colony on Sakhalin Island. The next year he traveled to Europe with Suvorin. In 1892, Chekhov purchased Melikhovo, an estate outside Moscow. It became a gathering place for family, relatives, and associates. There, too, Chekhov practiced medicine, more as a human service to poor villagers than as a necessary source of income. In 1896, Chekhov had his first theatrical success with The Seagull, although the reaction of the opening-night audience greatly distressed the author. Suffering from tuberculosis, by the mid-1890’s he began coughing up blood, and in 1897 he had to be hospitalized. In 1898, Chekhov began his propitious association with the newly formed Moscow Art Theater and its great director, Konstantin Stanislavski. He also met Olga Leonardovna Knipper, a young actor. Despite his ill health and his frequent sojourns to Yalta, they carried on a love affair and were married in 1901. The last six years of Chekhov’s life, from 1898 to 1904, brought him as much recognition as a dramatist as his earlier career had brought him as a writer of fiction. Uncle Vanya, The Three Sisters, and The Cherry Orchard, his last significant work, were all major successes. In 1904, in one last attempt to stay the course of his disease, Chekhov and his wife went to Germany, where, at Badenweiler, he died on July 15. Analysis • Anton Chekhov published his earliest stories and sketches in various popular magazines under pseudonyms, the most often used being “Antosha Chekhonte.” As that pen name hints, he was at first an unassuming and relatively compliant “hack,” willing to dash off careless pieces fashioned for the popular reader. Most are light, topical studies of social types, often running fewer than a thousand words. Many are mere sketches or extended jokes, often banal or cynical. Some are farces, built on car-
Chekhov, Anton
233
icatures. Others are brief parodies of popular genres, including the romantic novel. Few display much originality in subject. Still, in their technique, economy of expression, and themes, the early pieces prefigure some of Chekhov’s most mature work. In them, Chekhov experimented with point of view and most particularly the use of irony as a fictional device. He also established his preference for an almost scientific objectivity in his depiction of character and events, an insistence that, in the course of his career, he would have to defend against his detractors. Chekhov’s penchant for irony is exemplified in his very first published story, “Pis’mo k uchenomu sosedu” (“A Letter to a Learned Neighbor”), which appeared in 1880. The letter writer, Vladimirovich, is a pompous, officious oaf who makes pretentious statements about science and knowledge with inane blunders in syntax, spelling, and diction, inadvertently revealing his boorish stupidity while trying to ingratiate himself with his erudite neighbor. As does this sketch, many of Chekhov’s first pieces lampoon types found in Russian society, favorite satirical targets being functionaries in the czarist bureaucracy and their obsequious regard for their superiors. One sketch, “Smert’ chinovnika” (“The Death of a Government Clerk”), deals with a civil servant named Chervyakov who accidentally sneezes on a general and is mortified because he is unable to obtain the man’s pardon. After repeated rebukes, he resigns himself to defeat, lies down, and dies. His sense of self-worth is so intricately bound up in his subservient role that, unpardoned, he has no reason to continue living. In another story, “Khameleon” (“The Chameleon”), Ochumelov, a police officer, vacillates between placing blame on a dog or the man whom the dog has bitten until it can be confirmed that the dog does or does not belong to a certain General Zhigalov. When it turns out that the dog belongs to the general’s brother, the officer swears that he will get even with the dog’s victim. Like so many other characters in Chekhov’s fiction, Ochumelov is a bully to his subordinates but an officious toady to his betters. Other stories, not built on irony or a momentous event in the central character’s life, are virtually plotless fragments. Some chronicle the numbing effects of living by social codes and mores rather than from authentic inner convictions, while others record human expectations frustrated by a sobering and often grim reality. In several stories, Chekhov deals with childhood innocence encountering or narrowly evading an adult world that is sordid, deceitful, or perverse. For example, in “V more” (“At Sea”), a man decides to provide a sex education for his son by having him observe a newly married couple and a third man through a bulkhead peephole. Presumably to satisfy his own puerile interest, the father peeps first and is so mortified by what he sees that he does not allow his son to look at all. Sometimes severely restricted by magazine requirements, Chekhov learned to be direct and sparse in statement. Many of his early stories have little or no exposition at all. The main character’s lineage, elaborate details of setting, authorial incursions—all disappear for economy’s sake. In his precipitous openings, Chekhov often identifies a character by name, identifies his class or profession, and states his emotional condition, all in a single sentence. Others open with a snippet of conversation that has presumably been in progress for some time. When he does set a scene with description, Chekhov does so with quick, deft, impressionistic strokes, with only the barest of details. Chekhov also learned the value of symbols as guides to inner character. In “Melyuzga,” a pathetic clerk named Nevyrazimov is trying to write a flattering Easter
234
Short Story Writers
letter to his superior, whom, in reality, he despises. Hoping for a raise, this miserable underling must grovel, which contributes to his self-loathing and self-pity. As he tries to form the ingratiating words, he spies a cockroach and takes pity on the insect because he deems its miserable existence worse than his own. After considering his own options, however, and growing more despondent, when he again spies the roach he squashes it with his palm, then burns it, an act which, as the last line divulges, makes him feel better. The destruction of the roach is a symbolic act. It seems gratuitous and pointless, but it reveals the dehumanizing effect that chinopochitanie, or “rank reverence,” has on the clerk. In destroying the roach, Nevyrazimov is able to displace some of the self-loathing that accompanies his self-pity. His misery abates because he is able, for a moment, to play the bully. Despite the limitations that popular writing imposed, between 1880 and 1885 there is an advance in Chekhov’s work, born, perhaps, from a growing tolerance and sympathy for his fellow human beings. He gradually turned away from short, acrid farces toward more relaxed, psychologically probing studies of his characters and their ubiquitous misery and infrequent joy. In “Unter Prishibeev” (“Sergeant Prishibeev”), Chekhov again develops a character who is unable to adjust to change because his role in life has been too rigid and narrow. A subservient army bully, he is unable to mend his ways when returned to civilian life and torments his fellow townspeople through spying, intimidation, and physical abuse. His harsh discipline, sanctioned in the military, only lands him in jail, to his total astonishment. By 1886, Chekhov had begun to receive encouragement from the Russian literati, notably Dmitrí Grigorovich, who, in an important unsolicited letter, warned Chekhov not to waste his talents on potboilers. The impact on Chekhov was momentous, for he had received the recognition that he desired. Thereafter, he worked to perfect his craft, to master the literature nastroenija, or “literature of mood,” works in which a single, dominant mood is evoked and action is relatively insignificant. This does not mean that all Chekhov’s stories are plotless or lack conflict. “Khoristka” (“The Chorus Girl”), for example, is a dramatic piece in method akin to the author’s curtain-raising farces based on confrontation and ironic turns. The singer, confronted by the wife of one of her admirers, an embezzler, gives the wife all of her valuables to redeem the philanderer’s reputation. His wife’s willingness to humble herself before a chorus girl regenerates the man’s love and admiration for his spouse. He cruelly snubs the chorus girl and, in rank ingratitude, leaves her alone in abject misery. Other stories using an ironic twist leave the principal character’s fate to the reader’s imagination. “Noch’ pered sudom” (“The Night Before the Trial”) is an example. The protagonist, who narrates the story, makes a ludicrous blunder. On the eve of his trial for bigamy, he poses as a doctor and writes a bogus prescription for a woman. He also accepts payment from her husband, only to discover at the start of his trial that the husband is his prosecutor. The story goes no further than the man’s brief speculation on his approaching fate. In yet another, more involved story, “Nishchii” (“The Beggar”), a lawyer, Skvortsov, is approached by a drunken and deceitful but resourceful beggar, Lushkov, whom he unmercifully scolds as a liar and a wastrel. He then sets Lushkov to work chopping wood, challenging him to earn his way through honest, hard work. Before long, Skvortsov persuades himself that he has the role of Lushkov’s redeemer and manages to find him enough work doing odd jobs to earn a meager livelihood. Eventually, growing respectable and independent, Lushkov obtains decent work in a no-
Chekhov, Anton
235
tary’s office. Two years later, encountering Skvortsov outside a theater, Lushkov confides that it was indeed at Skvortsov’s house that he was saved—not, however, by Skvortsov’s scolding but by Skvortsov’s cook, Olga, who took pity on Lushkov and always chopped the wood for him. It was Olga’s nobility that prompted the beggar’s reformation, not the pompous moral rectitude of the lawyer. In 1887, when Chekhov took the time to visit the Don Steppe, he was established as one of Russia’s premier writers of fiction. With the accolades, there almost inevitably came some negative criticism. A few of his contemporaries argued that Chekhov seemed to lack a social conscience, that he remained too detached and indifferent to humanity in a time of great unrest and need for reform. Chekhov never believed that his art should serve a bald polemical purpose, but he was sensitive to the unjust critical opinion that he lacked strong personal convictions. In much of his mature writing, Chekhov worked to dispel that misguided accusation. For a time Chekhov came under the spell of Leo Tolstoy, his great contemporary, not so much for that moralist’s religious fervor but for his doctrine of nonresistance to evil. That idea is fundamental to “The Meeting.” In this tale, which in tone is similar to the didactic Russian folktales, a thief steals money from a peasant, who had collected it for refurbishing a church. The thief, baffled by the peasant’s failure to resist, gradually repents and returns the money. “The Steppe” • In 1888, Chekhov wrote and published “Step’” (“The Steppe”), inspired by his journey across the Don Steppe. The story, consisting of eight chapters, approaches the novella in scope and reflects the author’s interest in trying a longer work, which Grigorovich had advised him to do. In method, the piece is similar to picaresque tales, in which episodes are like beads, linked only by a common string—the voyage or quest. The main characters are a merchant, Kuznichov, his nine-year-old nephew, Egorushka, and a priest, Father Christopher, who set out to cross the steppe in a cart. The adults travel on business, to market wool, while Egorushka is off to school. The monotony of their journey is relieved by tidbits of conversation and brief encounters with secondary characters in unrelated episodes. Diversion for young Egorushka is provided by various denizens of the steppe. These minor characters, though delineated but briefly, are both picturesque and lifelike. Some of the characters spin a particular tale of woe. For example, there is Solomon, brother to Moses, the Jewish owner of a posting house. Solomon, disgusted with human greed, has burned his patrimony and now wallows in self-destructive misery. Another miserable figure is Pantelei, an old peasant whose life has offered nothing but arduous work. He has nearly frozen to death several times on the beautiful but desolate steppe. Dymov, the cunning, mean-spirited peasant, is another wretch devoid of either grace or hope. The story involves a realistic counterpart to the romantic quest, for the merchant and the priest, joined by the charming Countess Dranitskaya, seek the almost legendary figure, Varlamov. Thus, in a quiet, subdued way, the work has an epic cast to it. Its unity depends on imagery and thematic centrality of the impressions of Egorushka, whose youthful illusions play off against the sordid reality of the adult world. The journey to the school becomes for Egorushka a rite of passage, a familiar Chekhovian motif. At the end of the story, about to enter a strange house, the boy finally breaks into tears, feeling cut off from his past and apprehensive about his future. “The Steppe” marks a tremendous advance over Chekhov’s earliest works. Its im-
236
Short Story Writers
pressionistic description of the landscape is often poetic, and though, like most of Chekhov’s fiction, the work is open plotted, it is structurally tight and very compelling. The work’s hypnotic attraction comes from its sparse, lyrical simplicity and timeless theme. It is the first of the author’s flawless pieces. “A Boring Story” • Another long work, “Skuchnaia istoriia” (“A Boring Story”), shifts Chekhov’s character focus away from a youth first encountering misery in the world to an old man, Nikolai Stepanovich, who, near the end of life, finally begins to realize its stupefying emptiness. The professor is the narrator, although, when the story starts, it is presented in the third rather than the first person. It soon becomes apparent, however, that the voice is the professor’s own. The story is actually a diary, unfolding in the present tense. The reader learns that although Stepanovich enjoys an illustrious reputation in public, of which he is extremely proud, in private he is dull and emotionally handicapped. Having devoted his life to teaching medicine, the value of which he never questions, the professor has sacrificed love, compassion, and friendship. He has gradually alienated himself from family, colleagues, and students, as is shown by his repeated failures to relate to them in other than superficial, mechanical ways. He admits his inability to communicate to his wife or daughter, and although he claims to love his ward, Katya, whom his wife and daughter hate, even she finally realizes that he is an emotional cripple and deserts him to run off with another professor who has aroused some jealousy in Nikolai. The professor, his life dedicated to academe, has become insensitive to such things as his daughter Liza’s chagrin over her shabby coat or her feelings for Gnekker, her suitor, who, the professor suspects, is a fraud. Unable to understand his family’s blindness to Gnekker, whom he perceives as a scavenging crab, Nikolai sets out to prove his assumption. He goes to Kharkov to investigate Gnekker’s background and confirms his suspicions, only to discover that he is too late. In his absence, Liza and Gnekker have married. Bordering on the tragic, “A Boring Story” presents a character who is unable to express what he feels. He confesses his dull nature, but, though honest with himself, he can confide in no one. Detached, he is able to penetrate the illusions of others, but his approach to life is so abstract and general as to hinder meaningful interpersonal relationships. Near the end of life, he is wiser but spiritually paralyzed by his conviction that he knows very little of human worth. One notes in “A Boring Story” Chekhov’s fascination with the fact that conversation may not ensure communication, and his treatment of that reality becomes a signatory motif in Chekhov’s later works, including his plays. Characters talk but do not listen, remaining in their own illusory worlds, which mere words will not let them share with others. “The Duel” • “Duel” (“The Duel”), a long story, is representative of Chekhov’s most mature work. Its focal concern is with self-deception and rationalization for one’s failures. It pits two men against each other. The one, Laevsky, is a spineless, listless, and disillusioned intellectual who has miserably failed in life. The other, Von Koren, is an active, self-righteous zoologist who comes to despise the other man as a parasite. In his early conversations with his friend Dr. Samoilenko, Laevsky reveals his tendency to place blame on civilization for human failings, a notion espoused by JeanJacques Rousseau and a host of other romantic thinkers. The doctor, whose mundane, pragmatic values simply deflect Laevsky’s lament, cannot understand his
Chekhov, Anton
237
friend’s ennui and disenchantment with his mistress, Nadezhda Feydorovna. Laevsky perceives himself as a Hamlet figure, one who has been betrayed by Nadezhda, for whom he feels an increasing revulsion, which he masks with hypocritical sweetness. He envisions himself as being caught without purpose, vaguely believing that an escape to St. Petersburg without Nadezhda would provide a panacea for all of his ills. Laevsky’s antagonist, Von Koren, is next introduced. Von Koren is a brash, outspoken, vain man who believes that Laevsky is worthy only of drowning. He finds Laevsky depraved and genetically dangerous because he has remarkable success with women and might father more of his parasitical type. During their encounters, Von Koren is aggressive and takes every chance to bait Laevsky, who is afraid of him. Laevsky’s situation deteriorates when Nadezhda’s husband dies, and she, guilt ridden, looks to him to save her. Laevsky wants only to escape, however, and he runs off to Samoilenko, begging the doctor for a loan so he might flee to St. Petersburg. After confessing his depravity, he swears that he will send for Nadezhda after he arrives in St. Petersburg, but in reality he has no intention of doing so. Caught up in his own web of lies and half-truths, Laevsky must deal with those of Nadezhda, who is carrying on affairs with two other men and who has her own deceitful plans of escape. Convinced that Samoilenko has betrayed him through gossiping about him, Laevsky starts an argument with him in the presence of Von Koren, who supports the doctor. The heated exchange ends with a challenge to a duel, gleefully accepted by Von Koren. The night before the duel, Laevsky is extremely frightened. He is petrified by the prospect of imminent death, and his lies and deceit weigh upon him heavily. He passes through a spiritual crisis paralleled by a storm that finally subsides at dawn, just as Laevsky sets out for the dueling grounds. The duel turns into a comic incident. The duelists are not sure of protocol, and before they even start they seem inept. As it turns out, Laevsky nobly discharges his pistol into the air, and Von Koren, intent on killing his opponent, only manages to graze his neck. The duel has a propitious effect on both men. Laevsky and Nadezhda are reconciled, and he gives up his foolish romantic illusions and begins to live a responsible life. He is also reconciled to Von Koren, who, in a departing confession, admits that a scientific view of things cannot account for all life’s uncertainties. There is, at the end, a momentary meeting of the two men’s minds. “The Duel” is representative of a group of quasi-polemical pieces that Chekhov wrote between 1889 and 1896, including “Gusev” (“Gusev”), “Palata No. 6” (“Ward Number Six”), and “Moia zhizn” (“My Life”). All have parallel conflicts in which antagonists are spokespersons for opposing ideologies, neither of which is capable of providing humankind with a definitive epistemology or sufficient guide to living. “Rothschild’s Fiddle” • Other mature stories from the same period deal with the eroding effect of materialism on the human spirit. “Skripka Rotshil’da” (“Rothschild’s Fiddle”) is a prime example. In this work, Yakov Ivanov, nicknamed Bronze, a poor undertaker, is the protagonist. Yakov, who takes pride in his work, also plays the fiddle and thereby supplements his income from coffin-making. For a time, Yakov plays at weddings with a Jewish orchestra, whose members, inexplicably, he comes to hate, especially Rothschild, a flutist who seems determined to play even the lightest of pieces plaintively. Because of his belligerent behavior, after a time the Jews hire Yakov only in emergencies. Never in a good temper, Yakov is obsessed with his financial losses and his bad luck. Tormented by these matters at night, he can find some respite only by striking a solitary string on his fiddle.
238
Short Story Writers
When his wife, Marfa, becomes ill, Yakov’s main concern is what her death will cost him. She, in contrast, dies untroubled, finding in death a welcome release from the wretchedness that has been her lot married to Yakov. In her delirium, she does recall their child, who had died fifty years earlier, and a brief period of joy under a willow tree by the river, but Yakov can remember none of these things. Only when she is buried does Yakov experience depression, realizing that their marriage had been loveless. Sometime later Yakov accidentally comes upon and recognizes the willow tree of which Marfa had spoken. He rests there, beset by visions and a sense of a wasted past, regretting his indifference to his wife and his cruelty to the Jew, Rothschild. Shortly after this epiphany, he grows sick and prepares to die. Waiting, he plays his fiddle mournfully, growing troubled by not being able to take his fiddle with him to the grave. At his final confession, he tells the priest to give the fiddle to Rothschild, in his first and only generous act. Ironically, the fiddle for Rothschild becomes a means of improving his material well-being. As “Rothschild’s Fiddle” illustrates, Chekhov continued his efforts to fathom the impoverished spirit of his fellow man, often with a sympathetic, kindly regard. Most of his last stories are written in that vein. Near the end of the 1890’s, Chekhov gave increasing attention to his plays, which, combined with his ill health, reduced his fictional output. Still, between 1895 and his last fictional piece, “Nevesta” (“The Bride”), published in 1902, he wrote some pieces that rank among his masterpieces. As in “Rothschild’s Fiddle,” Chekhov’s concern with conflicting ideologies gives way to more fundamental questions about human beings’ ability to transcend their own nature. He examines characters who suffer desperate unhappiness, anxiety, isolation, and despair, experienced mainly through the characters’ inability either to give or to accept love. He also, however, concerns himself with its antithesis, the suffocating potential of too much love, which is the thematic focus of “Dushechka” (“The Darling”). “The Darling” • In this story, Olenka, the protagonist, is a woman who seems to have no character apart from her marital and maternal roles. She is otherwise a cipher who, between husbands, can only mourn, expressing her grief in folk laments. She has no important opinions of her own, only banal concerns with petty annoyances such as insects and hot weather. She comes to life only when she fulfills her role as wife and companion to her husband, whose opinions and business jargon she adopts as her own, which, to her third husband, is a source of great annoyance. Ironically, alive and radiant in love, Olenka seems to suck the life out of those whom she adores. For example, her love seems to cause the demise of her first husband, Kukin, a wretched, self-pitying theater manager. Only in the case of her last love, that for her foster son, Sasha, in her maternal role, does Olenka develop opinions of her own. Her love, however, ever suffocating, instills rebellion in the boy and will clearly lead to Olenka’s downfall. “The Bride” • By implication, the comic, almost sardonic depiction of Olenka argues a case for the emancipation of women, a concern to which Chekhov returns in “Nevesta” (“The Bride”). This story deals with a young woman, Nadya, who attempts to find an identity independent of roles prescribed by traditional mores and the oppressive influence of her mother, Nina, and her grandmother. Nadya, at the age of twenty-three, is something of a dreamer. As the story begins,
Chekhov, Anton
239
she is vaguely discontent with her impending marriage to Andrew, son to a local canon of the same name. Her rebellion against her growing unhappiness is encouraged by Sasha, a distant relative who becomes her sympathetic confidant. He constantly advises Nadya to flee, to get an education and free herself from the dull, idle, and stultifying existence that the provincial town promises. When Andrew takes Nadya on a tour of their future house, she is repulsed by his vision of their life together, finding him stupid and unimaginative. She confides in her mother, who offers no help at all, claiming that it is ordinary for young ladies to get cold feet as weddings draw near. Nadya then asks Sasha for help, which, with a ruse, he provides. He takes Nadya with him to Moscow and sends her on to St. Petersburg, where she begins her studies. After some months, Nadya, very homesick, visits Sasha in Moscow. It is clear to her that Sasha, ill with tuberculosis, is now dying. She returns to her home to deal with her past but finds the atmosphere no less oppressive than before, except that her mother and grandmother now seem more pathetic than domineering. After a telegram comes announcing Sasha’s death, she leaves again for St. Petersburg, resolved to find a new life severed completely from her old. As well as any story, “The Bride” illustrates why Chekhov is seen as the chronicler of twilight Russia, a period of stagnation when the intelligentsia seemed powerless to effect reform and the leviathan bureaucracy and outmoded traditions benumbed the people and robbed the more sensitive of spirit and hope. Although the contemporary reader of Chekhov’s fiction might find that pervasive, heavy atmosphere difficult to fathom, particularly in a comic perspective, no one can doubt Chekhov’s mastery of mood. With Guy de Maupassant in France, Chekhov is rightly credited with mastering the form, mood, and style of the type of short fiction that would be favored by serious English-language writers from Virginia Woolf and James Joyce onward. His impact on modern fiction is pervasive. John W. Fiero Other major works plays: Platonov, wr. 1878-1881, pb. 1923 (English translation, 1930); Ivanov, pr., pb. 1887 (revised, pr. 1889; English translation, 1912); Medved, pr., pb. 1888 (A Bear, 1909); Leshy, pr. 1889 (The Wood Demon, 1925); Predlozheniye, pb. 1889, pr. 1890 (A Marriage Proposal, 1914); Svadba, pb. 1889, pr. 1890 (The Wedding, 1916); Yubiley, pb. 1892 (The Jubilee, 1916); Chayka, pr. 1896 (revised pr. 1898, pb. 1904; The Seagull, 1909); Dyadya Vanya, pb. 1897, pr. 1899 (based on his play The Wood Demon; Uncle Vanya, 1914); Tri sestry, pr., pb. 1901 (revised pb. 1904; The Three Sisters, 1920); Vishnyovy sad, pr., pb. 1904 (The Cherry Orchard, 1908); The Plays of Chekhov, pb. 19231924 (2 volumes); Nine Plays, pb. 1959; The Complete Plays, pb. 2006 (Laurence Senelick, editor). miscellaneous: The Works of Anton Chekhov, 1929; Polnoye sobraniye sochineniy i pisem A. P. Chekhova, 1944-1951 (20 volumes); The Portable Chekhov, 1947; The Oxford Chekhov, 1964-1980 (9 volumes). nonfiction: Ostrov Sakhalin, 1893-1894; Letters on the Short Story, the Drama, and Other Literary Topics, 1924; The Selected Letters of Anton Chekhov, 1955.
240
Short Story Writers
Bibliography Bartlett, Rosamund Chekhov: Scenes from a Life. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2006. This biography takes a look not only at Chekhov’s life but also at the geography and history of the Russian empire. Bloom, Harold, ed. Anton Chekhov. Philadelphia: Chelsea House, 1999. Volume in the series Modern Critical Views. Includes bibliographical references, an index, and an introduction by Bloom. Clyman, Toby, ed. A Chekhov Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1985. Collection of critical essays, especially commissioned for this volume, on all aspects of Chekhov’s life, art, and career. Some of the most important critics of Chekhov’s work are represented here in essays on his major themes, his dramatic technique, his narrative technique, and his influence on modern drama and on the modern short story. Flath, Carol A. “The Limits to the Flesh: Searching for the Soul in Chekhov’s ‘A Boring Story.’” Slavic and East European Journal 41 (Summer, 1997): 271-286. Argues that “A Boring Story” affirms the value of art and offers comfort against the harshness of the truth about ordinary life and death. Gottlieb, Vera, and Paul Allain, eds. The Cambridge Companion to Chekhov. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2000. Guide to the life and works of Chekhov. Johnson, Ronald J. Anton Chekhov: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1993. Introduction to Chekhov’s short stories, from his earliest journalistic sketches and ephemera to his influential stories “Gooseberries” and “Lady with a Dog.” Discusses Chekhov’s objective narrative stance, his social conscience, and his belief in the freedom of the individual. Includes excerpts from Chekhov’s letters in which he talks about his fiction, as well as comments by other critics who discuss Chekhov’s attitude toward religion and sexuality. Lantz, K. A. Anton Chekhov: A Reference Guide to Literature. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1985. Lantz offers an indispensable tool for the researcher. The work provides a brief biography, a checklist of Chekhov’s published works with both English and Russian titles, chronologically arranged, and a very useful annotated bibliography of criticism through 1983. Malcolm, Janet. Reading Chekhov: A Critical Journey. New York: Random House, 2001. With Cheklov as a guide, Malcolm draws on her observations as a tourist/journalist to compose a melancholy portrait of post-Soviet Russia. Malcolm weaves her encounters with contemporary Russians with biographical and critical analyses of Chekhov and his writings. Martin, David W. “Chekhov and the Modern Short Story in English.” Neophilologus 71 (1987): 129-143. Martin surveys Chekhov’s influence on various English-language writers, including Katherine Mansfield, Virginia Woolf, James Joyce, Sherwood Anderson, and Frank O’Connor. He compares selected works by Chekhov with pieces by those he has influenced and discusses those Chekhovian traits and practices revealed therein. He credits Chekhov with showing how effete or banal characters or circumstances can be enlivened with the dynamics of style. The article is a good departure point for further comparative study. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eighteen short stories by Chekhov: “The Bet,” “The Bishop,” and “The Chemist’s Wife” (vol. 1); “The Darling,” “The Duel,” “Easter Eve,” and “Enemies” (vol. 2); “Gooseberries”
Chekhov, Anton
241
and “Gusev” (vol. 3); “The Kiss” and “The Lady with the Dog” (vol. 4); “The Man in a Case” and “Misery” (vol. 5); “Rothschild’s Fiddle” (vol. 6); “The Steppe: The Story of a Journey” and “A Trifling Occurrence” (vol. 7); and “Vanka” and “Ward No. 6” (vol. 8). Prose, Francine. “Learning from Chekhov.” Western Humanities Review 41 (1987): 114. Prose’s article is an appreciative eulogy on the staying power of Chekhov’s stories as models for writers. She notes that while Chekhov broke many established rules, his stress on objectivity and writing without judgment is of fundamental importance. The piece would be of most help to creative writers.
242
Charles Waddell Chesnutt Born: Cleveland, Ohio; June 20, 1858 Died: Cleveland, Ohio; November 15, 1932 Principal short fiction • The Conjure Woman, 1899; The Wife of His Youth, and Other Stories of the Color Line, 1899. Other literary forms • Charles Waddell Chesnutt achieved his literary reputation and stature as a short-story writer. His scholarly bent and indelible concern for human conditions in American society, however, occasionally moved him to experiment in other literary forms. Based on his study of race relations in the American South, he wrote the novel The Marrow of Tradition (1901). The Colonel’s Dream followed in 1905. As a result of the critical acclaim for these novels and for his first, The House Behind the Cedars (1900), Chesnutt became known not only as a short-story writer but also as a first-rate novelist. However, most of his novels were not published until long after he died. These include Mandy Oxendine, written in 1897 and first publishied in 1997; A Business Career, written in 1898 and published in 2005; Evelyn’s Husband, written in 1903 and published in 2005; and The Quarry, written in 1928 and published in 1999. In 1885, Chesnutt published several poems in The Cleveland Voice. The acceptance of his essay “What Is a White Man?” by the Independent in May of 1889 began his career as an essayist. Illustrating his diverse talent still further and becoming an impassioned voice for human justice, he wrote essays for a major portion of his life. Collections of his essays were published in 1999 and 2001, and a volume of his letters appeared in 2002. Chesnutt also demonstrated his skill as a biographer when he prepared The Life of Frederick Douglass (1899) for the Beacon biography series. Achievements • One of Chesnutt’s most significant achievements was his own education. Self-taught in the higher principles of algebra, the intricate details of history, the linguistic dicta of Latin, and the tenets of natural philosophy, he crowned this series of intellectual achievements by passing the Ohio bar examination after teaching himself law for two years. A man of outstanding social reputation, Chesnutt received an invitation to Mark Twain’s seventieth birthday party, an invitation “extended to about one hundred and fifty of America’s most distinguished writers of imaginative literature.” The party was held on December 5, 1905, at Delmonico’s restaurant in New York City. Chesnutt’s greatest public honor was being chosen as the recipient of the Joel E. Springarn Medal, an award annually bestowed on an American citizen of African descent for distinguished service. Biography • Charles Waddell Chesnutt was born in Cleveland, Ohio, on June 20, 1858. He attended Cleveland public schools and the Howard School in Fayetteville, North Carolina. Having distinguished himself academically early in his schooling, Chesnutt was taken into the tutelage of two established educators, Robert Harris of the Howard School and his brother, Cicero Harris, of Charlotte, North Carolina. He later succeeded Cicero Harris as principal of the school in Charlotte in 1877 and
Chesnutt, Charles Waddell
243
followed this venture with an appointment to the Normal School in Fayetteville to train teachers for colored schools. On June 6, 1878, Chesnutt married Susan Perry. Shortly after his marriage, he began his training as a stenographer. Even at this time, however, his interest in writing competed for his energies. He spent his spare time writing essays, poems, short stories, and sketches. His public writing career began in December of 1885 with the printing of the story “Uncle Peter’s House” in the Cleveland News and Herald. After several years passed “The Goophered Grapevine” was accepted by The Atlantic Monthly and published in 1888. Continuing his dual career as a man of letters and a businessman/attorney for more than a decade after his reception as a literary artist, Chesnutt decided, on September 30, 1899, to devote himself full-time to his literary career. From Cleveland Public Library that moment on he enjoyed a full and productive career as a man of letters. At the beginning of the twentieth century, Chesnutt became more politically active as a spokesman for racial justice. He toured the South and its educational institutions such as Tuskegee Institute and Atlanta University. He joined forces with black leaders such as Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois. In May of 1909, he became a member of the National Negro Committee, which later became the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP). The last two decades of Chesnutt’s life were less active because his health began to fail him in 1919. He was, however, elected to the Cleveland Chamber of Commerce in 1912. Chesnutt continued to write until his death on November 15, 1932. Analysis • The short fiction of Charles Waddell Chesnutt embraces traditions characteristic of both formal and folk art. Indeed, the elements of Chesnutt’s narrative technique evolved in a fashion that conspicuously parallels the historical shaping of the formal short story itself. The typical Chesnutt narrative, like the classic short story, assumes its heritage from a rich oral tradition immersed in folkways, mannerisms, and beliefs. Holding true to the historical development of the short story as an artistic form, his early imaginative narratives were episodic in nature. The next stage of development in Chesnutt’s short fiction was a parody of the fable form with a folkloric variation. Having become proficient at telling a story with a unified effect, Chesnutt achieved the symbolic resonance characteristic of the Romantic tale, yet his awareness of the plight of his people urged him toward an increasingly realistic depiction of
244
Short Story Writers
social conditions. As a mature writer, Chesnutt achieved depth of characterization, distinguishable thematic features, and a rare skillfulness in creation of mood, while a shrewdly moralizing tone allowed him to achieve his dual goal as artist and social activist. “The Goophered Grapevine” • Chesnutt’s journal stories constituted the first phase of his writing career, but when The Atlantic Monthly published “The Goophered Grapevine” in 1888, the serious aspects of his artistic skill became apparent. “The Goophered Grapevine” belongs to a tradition in Chesnutt’s writings which captures the fable form with a folkloric variation. These stories also unfold with a didactic strain which matures significantly in Chesnutt’s later writings. To understand clearly the series of stories in The Conjure Woman, of which “The Goophered Grapevine” is one, the reader must comprehend the allegorical features in the principal narrative situation and the thematic intent of the mythic incidents from African American lore. The Conjure Woman contains narratives revealed through the accounts of a northern white person’s rendition of the tales of Uncle Julius, a former slave. This storytelling device lays the foundation for Chesnutt’s sociological commentary. The real and perceived voices represent the perspectives he wishes to expose, those of the white capitalist and the impoverished, disadvantaged African American. The primary persona is that of the capitalist, while the perceived voice is that of the struggling poor. Chesnutt skillfully melds the two perspectives. Chesnutt’s two volumes of short stories contain pieces that are unified in theme, tone, and mood. Each volume also contains a piece that might be considered the lead story. In The Conjure Woman, the preeminent story is “The Goophered Grapevine.” This story embodies the overriding thematic intent of the narratives in this collection. Chesnutt points out the foibles of the capitalistic quest in the post-Civil War South, a venture pursued at the expense of the newly freed African American slave. He illustrates this point in “The Goophered Grapevine” by skillfully intertwining Aunt Peggy’s gains as a result of her conjurations and Henry’s destruction as a result of man’s inhumanity to man. Chesnutt discloses his ultimate point when the plantation owner, McAdoo, is deceived by a Yankee horticulturist and his grape vineyard becomes totally unproductive. Running episodes, such as Aunt Peggy’s conjurations to keep the field hands from consuming the grape crop and the seasonal benefit McAdoo gains from selling Henry, serve to illustrate the interplay between a monied white capitalist and his less privileged black human resources. McAdoo used Aunt Peggy to deny his field laborers any benefit from the land they worked, and he sold Henry every spring to increase his cash flow and prepare for the next gardening season. The central metaphor in “The Goophered Grapevine” is the bewitched vineyard. To illustrate and condemn man’s inhumanity to man, Chesnutt contrasts the black conjure woman’s protection of the grape vineyard with the white Yankee’s destruction of it. McAdoo’s exploitation of Henry serves to justify McAdoo’s ultimate ruin. Through allegory, Chesnutt is able to draw attention to the immorality of capitalistic gain through a sacrifice of basic humanity to other people. “Po’ Sandy” • Following the theme of inhumanity established in “The Goophered Grapevine,” “Po’ Sandy” highlights the abuse of a former slave laborer. Accordingly, a situation with a folkloric variation is used to convey this message. Sandy, Master
Chesnutt, Charles Waddell
245
Marabo’s field hand, is shifted from relative to relative at various points during the year to perform various duties. During the course of these transactions, he is separated from his second common-law wife, Tenie. (His first wife has been sent to work at a distant plantation.) Tenie is a conjurer. She transforms Sandy into a tree, and she changes him back to his original state periodically so that they can be together. With Sandy’s apparent disappearance, Master Marabo decides to send Tenie away to nurse his ailing daughter-in-law. There is therefore no one left to watch Sandy, the tree. The dehumanizing effects of industrialization creep into the story line at this point. The “tree” is to be used as lumber for a kitchen at the Marabo home. Tenie returns just in time to try to stop this transformation at the lumber mill, but she is deemed “mad.” Sandy’s spirit thereafter haunts the Marabo kitchen, and no one wants to work there. The complaints are so extensive that the kitchen is dismantled and the lumber donated toward the building of a school. This structure is then haunted, too. The point is that industrialization and economic gain diminish essential human concerns and can lead to destruction. The destruction of Sandy’s marital relationships in order to increase his usefulness as a field worker justifies this defiant spirit. In his depiction of Sandy as a tree, Chesnutt illustrates an enslaved spirit desperately seeking freedom. “The Conjurer’s Revenge” • “The Conjurer’s Revenge,” also contained in The Conjure Woman, illustrates Chesnutt’s mastery of the exemplum. The allegory in this work conveys a strong message, and Chesnutt’s evolving skill in characterization becomes apparent. The characters’ actions, rather than the situation, contain the didactic message of the story. Some qualities of the fable unfold as the various dimensions of characters are portrayed. Consequently, “The Conjurer’s Revenge” is a good example of Chesnutt’s short imaginative sketch. These qualities are also most characteristic of Chesnutt’s early short fiction. “The Conjurer’s Revenge” begins when Primus, a field hand, discovers the conjure man’s hog alone in a bush one evening. Concerned for the hog and not knowing to whom the animal belongs, Primus carries it to the plantation where he works. Unfortunately, the conjurer identifies Primus as a thief and transforms Primus into a mule. Chesnutt uses this transformation to reveal Primus’s personality. As a mule, Primus displays jealousy when other men show attraction to his woman, Sally. The mule’s reaction is one of shocking violence in instances when Sally is approached by other men. The mule has a tremendous appetite for food and drink, an apparent compensation for his unhappiness. Laying the foundation for his exemplum, Chesnutt brings these human foibles to the forefront and illustrates the consequences of even the mildest appearance of dishonesty. The conjurer’s character is also developed more fully as the story progresses. After attending a religious revival, he becomes ill, confesses his act of vengeance, and repents. During the conjurer’s metamorphosis, Chesnutt captures the remorse, grief, and forgiveness in this character. He also reveals the benefits of human compassion and concern for other human beings. A hardened heart undergoes reform and develops an ability to demonstrate sensitivity. Nevertheless, the conjurer suffers the consequences of his evil deed: He is mistakenly given poison by a companion, and he dies before he completely restores Primus’s human features, a deed he undertakes after repenting. The conjurer dies prematurely, and Primus lives with a clubfoot for the rest of his life.
246
Short Story Writers
Features of Chesnutt’s more mature writing emerge in the series of narratives that make up The Wife of His Youth, and Other Stories of the Color Line. The stories in this collection center on the identity crisis experienced by African Americans, portraying their true human qualities in the face of the grotesque distortions wrought by racism. In order to achieve his goal, Chesnutt abandons his earlier imaginative posture and embraces realism as a means to unfold his message. The dimensions of his characters are therefore appropriately self-revealing. The characters respond to the stresses and pressures in their external environment with genuine emotion; Mr. Ryder in “The Wife of His Youth” is no exception. “The Wife of His Youth” • “The Wife of His Youth” follows the structural pattern that appears to typify the narratives in the collection. This pattern evolves in three phases: crisis, character response, and resolution. The crisis in “The Wife of His Youth” is Mr. Ryder’s attempt to reconcile his new and old ways of life. He has moved North from a southern plantation and entered black middle-class society. Adapting to the customs, traditions, and mores of this stratum of society is a stressful challenge for Mr. Ryder. Tensions exist between his old life and his new life. He fears being unable to appear as if he belongs to this “blue vein” society and exposing his lowly background. This probable eventuality is his constant preoccupation. The “blue veins” were primarily lighter-skinned blacks who were better educated and more advantaged than their darker counterparts. Relishing their perceived superiority, they segregated themselves from their brothers and sisters. It is within this web of social clamoring and essential self-denial that Mr. Ryder finds himself. The inherent contradictions of this lifestyle present a crisis for him, although a resolution is attained during the course of the narrative. Mr. Ryder’s efforts to fit into this society are thwarted when his slave wife appears at his doorstep on the day before a major social event that he has planned. He is about to introduce the Blue Vein Society to a widow, Mrs. Dixon, upon whom he has set his affections. The appearance of Liza Jane, his slave wife, forces Mr. Ryder to confront his new life. This situation also allows Chesnutt to assume his typically moralizing tone. Mr. Ryder moves from self-denial to self-pride as he decides to present Liza Jane to his society friends instead of Mrs. Dixon. The narrative ends on a note of personal triumph for Mr. Ryder as he proudly introduces the wife of his youth to society. “The Passing of Grandison” • Chesnutt does not totally relinquish his allegiance to the use of myth in The Wife of His Youth, and Other Stories of the Color Line. The myth of the ascent journey, or the quest for freedom, is evident in several stories in the collection, among them “The Passing of Grandison” and “Wellington’s Wives.” Following the structured pattern of crisis, character response, and resolution, “The Passing of Grandison” is a commentary on the newly emerging moral values of the postbellum South. Colonel Owens, a plantation owner, has a son, Dick, who is in love with a belle named Charity Lomax. Charity’s human values reflect the principles of human equality and freedom, and the challenge that she presents to Dick Owens becomes the crisis of the narrative. Dick is scheduled to take a trip North, and his father insists on his being escorted by one of the servants. Grandison is selected to accompany his young master. Charity Lomax challenges Dick to find a way to entice Grandison to remain in the North and receive his well-deserved liberation. Charity’s request conflicts with the values held by Dick and Grandison. Dick believes that slave/master relationships are essential to
Chesnutt, Charles Waddell
247
the survival of the South. Grandison holds that servants should be unequivocally loyal to their masters. In spite of Dick’s attempts to connect Grandison unobtrusively with the abolitionist movement in the North, the former slave remains loyal to Dick. Grandison’s steadfastness perplexes Dick because his proposed marriage to Charity is at risk if he does not succeed in freeing Grandison. After a series of faulty attempts, Dick succeeds in losing Grandison. Dick then returns home alone and triumphant. Grandison ultimately returns to the plantation. He had previously proven himself so trustworthy that goodwill toward him is restored. To make the characterization of Grandison realistic, however, Chesnutt must have him pursue his freedom. In a surprise ending typical of Chesnutt, Grandison plans the escape of all of his relatives who remain on the plantation. They succeed, and in the last scene of the narrative, Colonel Owens spots them from a distance on a boat journeying to a new destination. “The Passing of Grandison” successfully achieves the social and artistic goals of The Wife of His Youth, and Other Stories of the Color Line. Chesnutt creates characters with convincing human qualities and captures their responses to the stresses and pressures of their environment. While so doing, he advocates the quest for human freedom. “Uncle Wellington’s Wives” • “Uncle Wellington’s Wives” contains several of the thematic dimensions mentioned above. The story concerns the self-identity of the African American and the freedom quest. Wellington Braboy, a light-skinned “mulatto” is determined to move North and seek his freedom. His crisis is the result of a lack of resources, primarily financial, to achieve his goal. Braboy is portrayed as having a distorted view of loyalty and commitment. He justifies stealing money from his slave wife’s life savings by saying that, as her husband, he is entitled to the money. On the other hand, he denies his responsibility to his slave wife once he reaches the North. In order to marry a white woman he denies the legality of a slave marriage. Chesnutt takes Braboy on a journey of purgation and catharsis as he moves toward resolution. After being subjected to much ridicule and humiliation as a result of his mixed marriage, Braboy must honestly confront himself and come to terms with his true identity. Abandoned by his wife for her former white husband, Braboy returns to the South. This journey is also a symbolic return to himself; his temporary escape from himself has failed. Milly, Braboy’s first wife, does not deny her love for him, in spite of his previous actions. Milly receives and accepts him with a forgiving spirit. Chesnutt capitalizes on the contrast between Braboy’s African and Anglo wives. The African wife loves him unconditionally because she has the capacity to know and understand him, regardless of his foibles. Braboy’s Anglo wife was frustrated by what she considered to be irreparable inadequacies in his character and abandoned him. “Cicely’s Dream” • In his character development, Chesnutt repeatedly sought to dispel some of the stereotypical thinking about African Americans. An example of his success in this effort is found in “Cicely’s Dream,” set in the period of Reconstruction. Cicely Green is depicted as a young woman of considerable ambition. Like most African Americans, she has had very little education and is apparently limited in her capacity to achieve. She does have, however, many dreams. Cicely’s crisis begins when she discovers a wounded man on her way home one
248
Short Story Writers
day. The man is delirious and has no recollection of who he is. Cicely and her grandmother care for the man until his physical health is restored, but he is still mentally distraught. The tenderness and sensitivity displayed by Cicely keep the stranger reasonably content. Over a period of time, they become close and eventually pledge their love to each other. Chesnutt portrays a caring, giving relationship between the two lovers, one which is not complicated by any caste system which would destroy love through separation of the lovers. This relationship, therefore, provides a poignant contrast to the relationships among blacks during the days of slavery, and Chesnutt thereby exposes an unexplored dimension of the African American. Typically, however, there is a surprise ending: Martha Chandler, an African American teacher, enters the picture. She teaches Cicely and other black youths for one school term. During the final program of the term, the teacher reveals her story of lost love. Her lover had been killed in the Civil War. Cicely’s lover’s memory is jolted by the teacher’s story, and he proves to be the teacher’s long-lost love. The happy reunion is a celebration of purely committed love. Again, Chesnutt examines qualities in African Americans which had largely been ignored. He emphasizes the innate humanity of the African American in a natural and realistic way, combining great artistic skill with a forceful moral vision. Patricia A. R. Williams With updates by Earl Paulus Murphy Other major works novels: Mandy Oxendine, wr. 1897, pb. 1997; A Business Career, wr. 1898, pb. 2005 (Matthew Wilson and Marjan van Schaik, editors); The House Behind the Cedars, 1900; The Marrow of Tradition, 1901; Evelyn’s Husband, wr. 1903, pb. 2005 (Matthew Wilson and Marjan van Schaik, editors); The Colonel’s Dream, 1905; Paul Marchand, F.M.C., wr. 1921, pb. 1998; The Quarry, wr. 1928, pb. 1999. nonfiction: The Life of Frederick Douglass, 1899; The Journals of Charles W. Chesnutt, 1993; “To Be an Author”: The Letters of Charles W. Chesnutt, 1889-1905, 1997; Charles W. Chesnutt: Essays and Speeches, 1999; Selected Writings, 2001 (SallyAnn H. Ferguson, editor); An Exemplary Citizen: Letters of Charles W. Chesnutt, 1906-1932, 2002. Bibliography Delma, P. Jay. “The Mask as Theme and Structure: Charles W. Chesnutt’s ‘The Sheriff’s Children’ and ‘The Passing of Grandison.’” American Literature 51 (1979): 364375. Argues that the story exploits the theme of the mask: the need to hide one’s true personality and racial identity from self and others. Delma argues that because Chesnutt uses the mask theme, the story is not a run-of-the-mill treatment of the long-lost-son plot. Duncan, Charles. The Absent Man: The Narrative Craft of Charles W. Chesnutt. Athens: Ohio University Press, 1998. This informative volume includes bibliographical references and an index. Filetti, Jean. “The Goophered Grapevine.” Explicator 48 (Spring, 1990): 201-203. Discusses the use of master-slave relationships within the context of storytelling and explains how Chesnutt’s “The Goophered Grapevine” relates to this tradition. Indicates that one of Chesnutt’s concerns was inhumanity among people, but the story is told from a humorous perspective with the newly freed slave outwitting the white capitalist.
Chesnutt, Charles Waddell
249
McElrath, Joseph R., Jr., ed. Critical Essays on Charles W. Chesnutt. New York: G. K. Hall, 1999. Includes bibliographical references and an index. McFatter, Susan. “From Revenge to Resolution: The (R)evolution of Female Characters in Chesnutt’s Fiction.” CLA Journal 42(December, 1998): 194-211. Discusses female revenge in Chesnutt’s fiction. Argues that his women use intelligence and instinct for survival to manipulate their repressive environments. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by Chesnutt: “The Goophered Grapevine” (vol. 3), “The Passing of Grandison” and “The Sheriff’s Children” (vol. 6), and “The Wife of His Youth” (vol. 8). Render, Sylvia. The Short Fiction of Charles Chesnutt. Washington, D.C.: Howard University Press, 1974. Discusses the collected short fiction of Chesnutt and indicates that it came out of the storytelling tradition of African Americans and was written within the conventions of local humor that were popular at the time. Sollers, Werner. “Thematics Today.” In Thematics Reconsidered: Essays in Honor of Horst S. Daemmrich, edited by Frank Trommler. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1995. Detailed discussion of the themes in “The Wife of His Youth.” Argues that contemporary thematic readings that stress race and gender are less likely to identify other themes such as marriage, fidelity, and age difference. Suggests that Chesnutt’s special way of treating the race and age themes needs more attention. Wonham, Henry B. Charles W. Chesnutt: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1998. Includes bibliographical references and an index.
250
G. K. Chesterton Born: London, England; May 29, 1874 Died: Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, England; June 14, 1936 Principal short fiction • The Tremendous Adventures of Major Brown, 1903; The Club of Queer Trades, 1905; The Perishing of the Pendragons, 1914; The Man Who Knew Too Much, and Other Stories, 1922; Tales of the Long Bow, 1925; Stories, 1928; The Sword of Wood, 1928; The Moderate Murder and the Honest Quack, 1929; The Poet and the Lunatics: Episodes in the Life of Gabriel Gale, 1929; Four Faultless Felons, 1930; The Ecstatic Thief, 1930; The Paradoxes of Mr. Pond, 1936; The Vampire of the Village, 1947. Other literary forms • One of the most prolific and versatile writers of his time, G. K. Chesterton published books in almost every genre. From 1901 until his death in 1936, he worked as a journalist in London. He was a prolific essayist and literary critic, and his 1909 book on his close friend George Bernard Shaw is still held in the highest esteem. He wrote several volumes of poetry, foremost of which was his 1911 The Ballad of the White Horse. After his conversion to Roman Catholicism in 1922, he became a fervent but tactful apologist for his new faith. His 1925 book The Everlasting Man and his 1933 study on Saint Thomas Aquinas reveal the depth of his insights into the essential beliefs of Catholicism. His Autobiography was published posthumously in late 1936. Chesterton published more than a dozen novels during his lifetime, ranging from The Napoleon of Notting Hill in 1904 to The Scandal of Father Brown in 1935. His The Vampire of the Village was published eleven years after his death, in 1947. In 2001, Basil Howe: A Story of Young Love, a novel he had written in 1894, when he was only twenty, was published for the first time. Achievements • Chesterton was a man of letters in the finest sense of the term. He expressed effectively and eloquently his ideas on a wide variety of literary, social, and religious topics. He was a master of paradox and always encouraged his readers to reflect on the subtle differences between appearance and reality. Reading his wellcrafted short stories is a stimulating aesthetic experience because he makes readers think about the moral implications of what they are reading. Although his critical writings on literature and religion reveal the depth of his intellect, Chesterton’s major achievement was in the field of detective fiction. Between 1911 and 1935, he published five volumes of short stories in which his amateur sleuth is a Catholic priest named Father Brown. Unlike such famous fictional detectives as Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes and Edgar Allan Poe’s Auguste Dupin, Father Brown relied not on deductive reasoning but rather on intuition in order to solve perplexing crimes. Father Brown made judicious use of his theological training in order to recognize the specious reasoning of criminals and to lead them to confess their guilt. His Father Brown stories explored moral and theological topics not previously treated in detective fiction. Biography • Gilbert Keith Chesterton was born on May 29, 1874, in London. He was the second of three children born to Edward and Marie Louise Chesterton. Edward
Chesterton, G. K.
251
Chesterton was a real estate agent. Gilbert’s older sister, Beatrice, died at the age of eight, in 1877, and two years later his brother, Cecil, was born. Everything seems to indicate that Edward and Marie Louise were loving parents. In 1982, Gilbert graduated from St. Paul’s School in London. For the next three years, he studied at London’s Slade Art School, but he finally realized that he would never develop into a truly creative artist. From 1895 until 1900, he worked for a publishing firm. From 1901 until his death, in 1936, he served as a journalist and editor for various London newspapers and magazines. In 1901, he married Frances Blogg. Gilbert and Frances had no children. Theirs was a good marriage, each helping the other. Frances survived her husband by two years. During the first decade of the twentieth century, Chesterton met the writers Hilaire Belloc and Shaw, who became his lifelong friends. Although Belloc and Shaw seemed to have little in common because Belloc was an apologist for Catholicism and Shaw was an agnostic, Chesterton liked them both very much. Several times, Belloc organized lively but good-natured debates in which Shaw and Chesterton discussed religion and politics. Throughout his adult life, Chesterton supported the Liberal Party in Great Britain, but gradually he became disillusioned with the leadership of the Liberal prime minister David Lloyd George. After the coalition government run by Lloyd George fell apart in 1922, Chesterton lost much interest in politics. During the last fourteen years of his life, his major interests were literature and religion. Before World War I began, Chesterton was already a well-known English writer, but he had not yet explored profound philosophical and religious themes. Two unexpected events forced Chesterton to think about his mortality and the reasons for his existence. In late 1914, he fell into a coma, which lasted four months. The cause of this coma was never fully explained to the public. After his recovery, he was a changed man. His view of the world became very serious. Then, less than one month after the end of World War I, Chesterton suffered a terrible personal loss when his only brother, Cecil, died from nephritis in a military hospital in France. After’s Cecil’s death, Chesterton felt a void in his life. His friend Father John O’Connor, who was the apparent inspiration for Father Brown, spoke to him at length about Catholicism, and Chesterton became a Catholic on July 30, 1922. Four years later, his wife, Frances, joined him in the Catholic Church. The last decade of his life was a very productive period. He continued to write his Father Brown stories, but he also found much pleasure in writing and giving speeches on religious topics. Although firmly convinced that Catholicism was essential for his own spiritual growth and salvation, he was always tolerant and respectful of friends such as H. G. Wells and Shaw, who did not share his religious beliefs. Soon after he had completed his Autobiography in early 1936, he developed serious heart problems. He died at his home in Beaconsfield, England, on June 14, 1936, at the age of sixty-two. Analysis • Before he began writing his Father Brown stories, G. K. Chesterton had already published one book of detective fiction. In The Man Who Was Thursday, Chesterton created a detective named Gabriel Syme, who infiltrates an anarchist group in which each of the seven members is named for a different day of the week. Syme replaces the man who had been Thursday. At first, this group seems strange to Syme because he does not understand what the anarchists wish to accomplish. This paradox is resolved when Chesterton explains that all seven “anarchists” are, in fact, detectives assigned separately to investigate this nonexistent threat to society. Although The Man Who Was Thursday does demonstrate Chesterton’s ability to think
252
Short Story Writers
clearly in order to resolve a problem, the solution to this paradox is so preposterous that many readers have wondered why Chesterton wrote this book, whose ending is so odd. It is hardly credible that all seven members of a secret organization could be police officers. Critics have not been sure how they should interpret this work. Chesterton’s own brother, Cecil, thought that it expressed an excessively optimistic view of the world, but other reviewers criticized The Man Who Was Thursday for its pessimism. In his Father Brown stories, this problem of perspective does not exist because it is the levelheaded Father Library of Congress Brown who always explains the true significance of scenes and events that had mystified readers and other characters as well. The other characters, be they detectives, criminals, suspects, or acquaintances of the victim, always come to the conclusion that Father Brown has correctly solved the case. “The Secret of Father Brown” • In his 1927 short story “The Secret of Father Brown,” Chesterton describes the two basic premises of his detective. First, Father Brown is very suspicious of any suspect who ues specious reasoning or expresses insincere religious beliefs. Father Brown senses intuitively that a character who reasons incorrectly might well be a criminal. Second, Father Brown strives to “get inside” the mind of “the murderer” so completely that he is “thinking his thoughts, wrestling with his passions.” Father Brown needs to understand what drives the guilty party to commit a specific crime before he can determine who the criminal is and how the crime was committed. Most critics believe that the best Father Brown stories are those that were published in Chesterton’s 1911 volume The Innocence of Father Brown. Although his later Father Brown stories should not be neglected, his very early stories are ingenious and have remained popular with generations of readers. Several stories in The Innocence of Father Brown illustrate nicely how Father Brown intuitively and correctly solves crimes. “The Blue Cross” • In “The Blue Cross,” Aristide Valentin (the head of the Paris police) is sent to London to arrest a notorious thief named Flambeau, who is a master of disguises. Valentin knows that Flambeau is well over six feet tall, but he does not know how Flambeau is dressed. As Valentin is walking through London, his attraction is suddenly drawn to two Catholic priests. One is short and the other is tall. The short priest acts strangely so that he would attract attention. He deliberately throws soup on a wall in a restaurant, upsets the apples outside of a grocery store, and breaks a window in another restaurant. This odd behavior disturbs the merchants, who consequently ask police officers to follow the priests, who are walking toward the Hamp-
Chesterton, G. K.
253
stead Heath. Readers soon learn that the short priest wants to be followed for his own protection. Just as the tall priest, who is, in fact, Flambeau, orders Father Brown, the short priest, to turn over a sapphire cross that he was carrying to a church in Hampstead, Father Brown tells him that “two strong policemen” and Valentin are waiting behind a tree in order to arrest Flambeau. The astonished Flambeau asks Father Brown how he knew that he was not a real priest. Readers learn that Father Brown’s suspicion began when, earlier in the story, the tall priest affirmed that only “modern infidels appeal to reason,” whereas true Catholics have no use for it. Father Brown tells Flambeau: “You attacked reason. It’s bad theology.” His intuition told him that his tall companion could not have been a priest, and he was right. Father Brown is not merely an amateur detective. He is above all a priest whose primary responsibility is to serve as a spiritual guide to upright people and sinners alike. Although he brought about Flambeau’s arrest, Flambeau soon turned away from a life of crime. After his release from prison, he became a private detective, and his closest friend became Father Brown. This transformation can be attributed only to the religious teaching that Flambeau received from his spiritual mentor, Father Brown. “The Eye of Apollo” • The tenth story in The Innocence of Father Brown is entitled “The Eye of Apollo.” At the beginning of this short story, Flambeau has just opened his detective agency in a new building located near Westminster Abbey. The other tenants in the building are a religious charlatan named Kalon, who claims to be “the New Priest of Apollo,” and two sisters, who are typists. Flambeau and Father Brown instinctively distrust Kalon, who has installed a huge eye of Apollo outside his office. Pauline Stacey, the elder of the two sisters, is attracted to Kalon, whom Joan Stacey dislikes intensely. One afternoon, Pauline falls down an elevator shaft and dies. Flambeau concludes hastily that this was an accident, but Father Brown wants to examine her death more thoroughly. He and Flambeau decide to talk with Kalon before the police officers arrive. Kalon presents the preposterous argument that his “religion” favors life, whereas Christianity is concerned only with death. Father Brown becomes more and more convinced that Kalon is a murderer. To the astonishment of Flambeau, Father Brown proves that Pauline “was murdered while she was alone.” Pauline was blind, and Kalon knew it. As Kalon was waiting in the elevator, he called Pauline, but suddenly he moved the elevator, and the blind Pauline fell into the open shaft. Flambeau wonders, however, why Kalon killed her. Readers learn that Pauline had told Kalon that she was going to change her will and leave her fortune of five hundred thousand pounds to him. Kalon did not realize, however, that her pen had run out of ink before she could finish writing her will. When he first hears Kalon speak, Father Brown knows instantly that this hypocrite is a criminal. At the end of the story, he tells Flambeau: “I tell you I knew he [Kalon] had done it even before I knew what he had done.” Once again Father Brown’s intuition is perfectly correct. “The Secret Garden” • Father Brown has the special ability to recognize the true meaning of seemingly insignificant clues, which other characters see but overlook. In The Innocence of Father Brown, there are two other stories, “The Secret Garden” and “The Hammer of God,” that illustrate the effectiveness of Father Brown’s powers of intuition and that also contain rather unexpected endings. Just as they are in “The Blue Cross,” Valentin and Father Brown are major characters in “The Secret Garden.” As the head of the Paris police, Valentin has been so successful in arresting
254
Short Story Writers
criminals that many men whom he sent to prison have threatened to kill him as soon as they regain their freedom. For his own protection, Valentin has very high walls built around his garden, with the only access to it being through his house. His servants guard the entrance to his house at all times. One evening, Valentin holds a reception, which is attended by Father Brown, a medical doctor, an American philanthropist named Julius Brayne, Commandant O’Brien from the French Foreign Legion, Lord and Lady Galloway, and their adult daughter Lady Margaret. Father Brown learns that Valentin is especially suspicious of all organized religions, especially Catholicism, and Julius Brayne likes to contribute huge sums of money to various religions. During the party, a body with a severed head is found in the garden. All the guests are mystified because the head found next to the body does not belong to any of Valentin’s servants or to any of the guests. After much reflection on this apparent paradox, Father Brown proves that the head and the body belong to different men. The body was that of Julius Brayne, and the head belonged to a murderer named Louis Becker, whom the French police had guillotined earlier that day in the presence of Valentin, who had obtained permission to bring Becker’s head back to his house. Valentin killed Brayne because of a rumor that Brayne was about to become a Catholic and donate millions to his new church. His hatred for Christianity drove Valentin mad. Father Brown explains calmly that Valentin “would do anything, anything, to break what he calls the superstition of the Cross. He has fought for it and starved for it, and now he has murdered for it.” Valentin’s butler Ivan could not accept this explanation, but as they all went to question Valentin in his study, they found him “dead in his chair.” He had committed suicide by taking an overdose of pills. The ending of this short story is surprising because readers of detective fiction do not suspect that a police commissioner can also be a murderer. “The Hammer of God” • In “The Hammer of God,” readers are surprised to learn from Father Brown that the murderer is not a violent madman but rather a very respected member of the community. The Reverend Wilfred Bohun could no longer stand the scandalous behavior of his alcoholic brother Norman, who blasphemed God and humiliated the Reverend Bohun in the eyes of his parishioners. Chesterton states that Wilfred and Norman Bohun belong to an old noble family whose descendants are now mostly “drunkards and dandy degenerates.” Rumor has it that there has been “a whisper of insanity” in the Bohun family. Although Father Brown empathizes with the Reverend Bohun, he nevertheless believes that he should express Christian charity toward his brother. When the body of Norman Bohun is found outside his brother’s church, Father Brown begins to examine the case. Father Brown finally comes to the conclusion that the Reverend Bohun killed his brother by dropping a hammer on him from the church tower. The murderer tried to frame the village idiot because he knew that the courts would never hold an idiot responsible for murder. At the end of this story, the Reverend Bohun and Father Brown have a long conversation, and Father Brown dissuades the Reverend Bohun from committing suicide because “that door leads to hell.” He persuades him instead to confess his sin to God and admit his guilt to the police. In prison, the Reverend Bohun, like Flambeau, may find salvation. In both “The Blue Cross” and “The Hammer of God,” Father Brown hates the crime but loves the sinner. Readers are left with the definite impression that Father Brown is absolutely essential for the spiritual growth and eventual salvation of Flambeau and the Reverend Bohun.
Chesterton, G. K.
255
Several critics have remarked that the character of Father Brown did not change much in the four volumes of detective fiction that Chesterton wrote after The Innocence of Father Brown. This stability represents, however, strength and not weakness. It would have been inappropriate for a member of the clergy to have stopped caring about the spiritual life of others. Father Brown knows that evil exists in the world, but he also believes that even sinners and murderers can be reformed in this life and saved in the next. Father Brown is a fascinating fictional detective who uses his own religious beliefs in order to solve crimes and express profound insights into the dignity of every person. Edmund J. Campion With updates by the Editors Other major works plays: Magic: A Fantastic Comedy, pr. 1913; The Judgment of Dr. Johnson, pb. 1927; The Surprise, pb. 1952. anthologies: Thackeray, 1909; Samuel Johnson, 1911 (with Alice Meynell); Essays by Divers Hands, 1926. novels: Basil Howe: A Story of Young Love, wr. 1894, pb. 2001; The Napoleon of Notting Hill, 1904; The Man Who Was Thursday: A Nightmare, 1908; The Ball and the Cross, 1909; The Innocence of Father Brown, 1911; Manalive, 1912; The Flying Inn, 1914; The Wisdom of Father Brown, 1914; The Incredulity of Father Brown, 1926; The Return of Don Quixote, 1926; The Secret of Father Brown, 1927; The Floating Admiral, 1931 (with others); The Scandal of Father Brown, 1935; The Vampire of the Village, 1947. miscellaneous: Stories, Essays, and Poems, 1935; The Coloured Lands, 1938; The Collected Works of G. K. Chesterton, 1986-1999 (35 volumes); The Truest Fairy Tale: An Anthology of the Religious Writings of G. K. Chesteron, 2007 (Kevin L. Morris, editor). nonfiction: The Defendant, 1901; Robert Louis Stevenson, 1902 (with W. Robertson Nicoll); Thomas Carlyle, 1902; Twelve Types, 1902 (revised as Varied Types, 1903, and also known as Simplicity and Tolstoy); Charles Dickens, 1903 (with F. G. Kitton); Leo Tolstoy, 1903 (with G. H. Perris and Edward Garnett); Robert Browning, 1903; Tennyson, 1903 (with Richard Garnett); Thackeray, 1903 (with Lewis Melville); G. F. Watts, 1904; Heretics, 1905; Charles Dickens: A Critical Study, 1906; All Things Considered, 1908; Orthodoxy, 1908; George Bernard Shaw, 1909 (revised edition, 1935); Tremendous Trifles, 1909; Alarms and Discursions, 1910; The Ultimate Lie, 1910; What’s Wrong with the World, 1910; William Blake, 1910; A Defence of Nonsense, and Other Essays, 1911; Appreciations and Criticisms of the Works of Charles Dickens, 1911; The Future of Religion: Mr. G. K. Chesterton’s Reply to Mr. Bernard Shaw, 1911; A Miscellany of Men, 1912; The Conversion of an Anarchist, 1912; The Victorian Age in Literature, 1913; Thoughts from Chesterton, 1913; London, 1914 (with Alvin Langdon Coburn); Prussian Versus Belgian Culture, 1914; The Barbarism of Berlin, 1914; Letters to an Old Garibaldian, 1915; The Crimes of England, 1915; The SoCalled Belgian Bargain, 1915; A Shilling for My Thoughts, 1916; Divorce Versus Democracy, 1916; Temperance and the Great Alliance, 1916; A Short History of England, 1917; Lord Kitchener, 1917; Utopia of Usurers, and Other Essays, 1917; How to Help Annexation, 1918; Charles Dickens Fifty Years After, 1920; Irish Impressions, 1920; The New Jerusalem, 1920; The Superstition of Divorce, 1920; The Uses of Diversity, 1920; Eugenics and Other Evils, 1922; What I Saw in America, 1922; Fancies Versus Fads, 1923; St. Francis of Assisi, 1923; The End of the Roman Road: A Pageant of Wayfarers, 1924; The Superstitions of the Sceptic, 1924; The Everlasting Man, 1925; William Cobbett, 1925; A Gleaming Cohort, Being from
256
Short Story Writers
the Words of G. K. Chesterton, 1926; The Catholic Church and Conversion, 1926; The Outline of Sanity, 1926; Culture and the Coming Peril, 1927; Robert Louis Stevenson, 1927; Social Reform Versus Birth Control, 1927; Do We Agree? A Debate, 1928 (with George Bernard Shaw); Generally Speaking, 1928 (essays); G. K. C. as M. C., Being a Collection of Thirtyseven Introductions, 1929; The Thing, 1929; At the Sign of the World’s End, 1930; Come to Think of It, 1930; The Resurrection of Rome, 1930; The Turkey and the Turk, 1930; All Is Grist, 1931; Is There a Return to Religion?, 1931 (with E. Haldeman-Julius); Chaucer, 1932; Christendom in Dublin, 1932; Sidelights on New London and Newer York, and Other Essays, 1932; All I Survey, 1933; G. K. Chesterton, 1933 (also known as Running After One’s Hat, and Other Whimsies); St. Thomas Aquinas, 1933; Avowals and Denials, 1934; Explaining the English, 1935; The Well and the Shallows, 1935; As I Was Saying, 1936; Autobiography, 1936; The Man Who Was Chesterton, 1937; The End of the Armistice, 1940; The Common Man, 1950; The Glass Walking-Stick, and Other Essays from the “Illustrated London News,” 1905-1936, 1955; Lunacy and Letters, 1958; Where All Roads Lead, 1961; The Man Who Was Orthodox: A Selection from the Uncollected Writings of G. K. Chesterton, 1963; The Spice of Life, and Other Essays, 1964; Chesterton on Shakespeare, 1971. poetry: Greybeards at Play: Literature and Art for Old Gentlemen—Rhymes and Sketches, 1900; The Wild Knight, and Other Poems, 1900 (revised, 1914); The Ballad of the White Horse, 1911; A Poem, 1915; Poems, 1915; Wine, Water, and Song, 1915; Old King Cole, 1920; The Ballad of St. Barbara, and Other Verses, 1922; Poems, 1925; The Queen of Seven Swords, 1926; Gloria in Profundis, 1927; Ubi Ecclesia, 1929; The Grave of Arthur, 1930. Bibliography Clipper, Lawrence J. G. K. Chesterton. New York: Twayne, 1974. In this useful introduction to the works of Chesterton, Clipper does a fine job of describing the recurring themes in Chesterton’s fictional and nonfictional writings. He analyzes very well Chesterton’s poetry and literary criticism. Contains an excellent annotated bibliography. Conlon, D. J., ed. Chesterton: A Half Century of Views. New York: Oxford University Press, 1987. Contains numerous short essays on Chesterton published during the first fifty years after his death. The wide diversity of positive critical reactions shows that not only his popular fiction but also his writings on literature and religion continue to fascinate readers. Crowe, Marian E. “G. K. Chesterton and the Orthodox Romance of Pride and Prejudice.” Renascence 49 (Spring, 1997): 209-221. Argues that Chesterton used the word “romance” to refer to three different concepts: erotic love, adventure stories, and orthodox faith. Fagerberg, David W. The Size of Chesterton’s Catholicism. Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1998. Analyzes Chesterton’s apologetic works for the Catholic Church. Horst, Mark. “Sin, Psychopathology, and Father Brown.” The Christian Century 104 (January 21, 1987): 46-47. Compares Chesterton’s detective Father Brown to Will Graham, a character in Michael Mann’s film Manhunt. Argues that although both sleuths use introspection to pursue criminals, when Father Brown looks within himself, he sees sin, a universal reality, whereas when Will Graham looks within, he sees psychopathology, an aberration. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by
Chesterton, G. K.
257
Chesterton: “The Blue Cross” (vol. 1), “The Hammer of God” (vol. 3), and “The Invisible Man” (vol. 4). Pearce, Joseph. Wisdom and Innocence: A Life of G. K. Chesterton. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1996. Scholarly and well-written biography of Chesterton. Contains many quotes from his works and good analysis of them, as well as useful data on his family and friends. Schwartz, Adam. “G. K. C.’s Methodical Madness: Sanity and Social Control in Chesterton.” Renascence 49 (Fall, 1996): 23-40. Part of a special issue on G. K. Chesterton. Argues that his view shifts from focus on mental condition of an individual to the way societies define sanity and make “insanity” a means of bourgeois class control. Tadie, Andrew A., and Michael H. Macdonald, eds. Permanent Things: Toward the Recovery of a More Human Scale at the End of the Twentieth Century. Grand Rapids, Mich.: William B. Eerdmans, 1995. This volume includes a fairly thorough discussion of Chesterton’s writing, along with works of T. S. Eliot and C. S. Lewis, looking primarily at its ethical and religious components. Wills, Garry. Chesterton. New York: Doubleday, 2001. This biography is a revised edition of Chesterton, Man and Mask (1961).
258
Kate Chopin Born: St. Louis, Missouri; February 8, 1851 Died: St. Louis, Missouri; August 22, 1904 Principal short fiction • Bayou Folk, 1894; A Night in Acadie, 1897. Other literary forms • In addition to the short stories which brought her some fame as a writer during her own lifetime, Kate Chopin published two novels, At Fault (1890) and The Awakening (1899), the latter of which was either ignored or condemned because of its theme of adultery and frank depiction of a woman’s sexual urges. Chopin also wrote a few reviews and casual essays and a number of undistinguished poems. Achievements • Kate Chopin’s short stories, published in contemporary popular magazines, won her fame as a local colorist with a good ear for dialect and as a writer concerned with women’s issues (sexuality, equality, independence). After the publication of The Awakening in 1899, however, her popularity waned, in part because of the furor over the open treatment of adultery and sex in the novel. She wrote few stories after 1900, and her work was largely neglected until the rediscovery of The Awakening by feminist critics. Criticism of that novel and new biographies have spurred a new interest in her Creole short stories, which have been analyzed in detail in terms of their regionalism and their treatment of gender. Influenced by Guy de Maupassant, she herself did not exert any literary influence on later short-story writers, at least not until after the rediscovery of The Awakening. Biography • Kate Chopin was born Katherine O’Flaherty in St. Louis, Missouri, in 1851. Her mother’s family was Creole, descended from French settlers, and her father, a successful merchant, was an Irish immigrant. She was educated at the Academy of the Sacred Heart in St. Louis beginning in 1860, five years after her father’s accidental death, and graduated in 1868. In 1870, she married Oscar Chopin, who took her to live in Louisiana, first in New Orleans and later in Natchitoches Parish, the setting for many of her stories. In 1882, Oscar died of swamp fever; Kate Chopin managed her husband’s properties for a year and in 1884 returned to St. Louis. The next year her mother died, and in 1888 Chopin began writing out of a need for personal expression and to help support her family financially. Her stories appeared regularly in popular periodicals, and she published a novel, At Fault, in 1890. Bayou Folk, a collection of stories and sketches, appeared in 1894, the year her widely anthologized “The Story of an Hour” was written. A Night in Acadie followed, and she was identified as one of four outstanding literary figures in St. Louis by the Star-Times. Her celebrated novel, The Awakening, received hostile reviews that upset her, though reports about the book being banned were greatly exaggerated. She did, however, write relatively little after this controversy and died five years later in St. Louis, where she was attending the world’s fair. Analysis • Until the 1970’s, Kate Chopin was known best literarily, if at all, as a “local colorist,” primarily for her tales of life in New Orleans and rural Louisiana. Chopin
Chopin, Kate
259
manages in these stories (about twothirds of her total output) to bring to life subtly the settings and personalities of her characters, usually Creoles (descendants of the original French settlers of Louisiana) or Cajuns (or Acadians, the French colonists who were exiled to Louisiana following the British conquest of Nova Scotia). What makes Chopin especially important for modern readers, however, is her insight into human characters and relationships in the context of their societies whether Creole, Cajun, or Anglo-Saxon—and into the social, emotional, and sexual roles of women within those societies. Chopin’s desire and hope for female independence can be seen in two of her earliest stories, “Wiser Than a God” and “A Point at Issue!” (both 1889). In the first story, the heroine Paula Von Stoltz Missouri Historical Society rejects an offer of marriage in order to begin a successful career as a concert pianist because music is the true sole passion of her life; it is an act that anticipates the actions of Edna Pontellier in The Awakening. In the second story, Eleanor Gail and Charles Faraday enter into a marriage based on reason and equality and pursue their individual careers in separate places. This arrangement works very well for some time, but finally each of the two succumbs to jealousy; in spite of this blemish in their relationship, Chopin’s humorous tone manages to poke fun at traditional attitudes toward marriage as well. “The Story of an Hour” • This questioning though humorous attitude is strongly evident in one of Chopin’s most anthologized and best-known tales, “The Story of an Hour” (1894). Mrs. Mallard, a woman suffering from a heart condition, is told that her husband has been killed in a train accident. She is at first deeply sorrowful but soon realizes that even though she had loved and will mourn her husband, his death has set her free: “There would be no powerful will bending hers in that blind persistence with which men and women believe they have a right to impose a private will upon a fellow-creature.” As Mrs. Mallard descends the stairs, however, the front door is opened by her husband, who had never been on the train. This time her heart gives out, and the cause ironically is given by the doctors as “the joy that kills.” “La Belle Zoraïde” • It is in her Louisiana stories, however, that Chopin’s sympathy for female and indeed human longings emerges most fully, subtly blended with a distinct and evocative sense of locale and folkways. “La Belle Zoraïde” (1893) is presented in the form of a folktale being told by a black servant, Manna-Loulou, to her mistress, Madame Delisle (these two characters also are central to the story “A Lady of Bayou St. John,” 1893). The tale itself is the story of a black slave, Zoraïde, who is forbidden by her mistress to marry another slave with whom she has fallen in love because his skin is too black and her mistress intends her for another, more “gentle-
260
Short Story Writers
manly” servant. In spite of this, and although the slave she loves is sold away, she bears his child and refuses marriage to the other slave. Her mistress falsely tells Zoraïde that her child has been born dead, and the slave descends into madness. Even when her real daughter is finally brought back to her, Zoraïde rejects her, preferring to cling to the bundle of rags that she has fashioned as a surrogate baby. From then on, She was never known again as la belle Zoraïde, but ever after as Zoraïde la folle, whom no one ever wanted to marry. . . . She lived to be an old woman, whom some people pitied and others laughed at—always clasping her bundle of rags—her ‘piti.’ The indirect narration of this story prevents it from slipping into the melodramatic or the maudlin. Chopin’s ending, presenting the conversation of Manna-Loulou and Madame Delisle in the Creole dialect, pointedly avoids a concluding moral judgment, an avoidance typical of Chopin’s stories. Instead, readers are brought back to the frame for the tale and concentrated upon the charm of the Creole dialect even while they retain pity and sympathy for Zoraïde. “Désirée’s Baby” • In spite of their southern locale, Chopin’s stories rarely deal with racial relations between whites and blacks. One important exception is “Désirée’s Baby” (1892). Désirée Valmondé, who was originally a foundling, marries Armand Aubigny, a plantation owner who is proud of his aristocratic heritage but very much in love with Désirée. He is at first delighted when she bears him a son, but soon begins to grow cold and distant. Désirée, puzzled at first, soon realizes with horror that her child has Negro blood. Armand, whose love for Désirée has been killed by “the unconscious injury she had brought upon his home and his name,” turns her out of the house, and she disappears with her child into the bayou, never to be seen again. Later, in a surprise ending reminiscent of Maupassant, Armand is having all reminders of Désirée burned when he discovers a letter from his mother to his father which reveals that his mother had had Negro blood. In this story one sees the continuation of Chopin’s most central theme, the evil that follows when one human being gains power over another and attempts to make that person conform to preset standards or expectations. As suggested earlier, Chopin finds that power of one person over another is often manifested in the institution of marriage. Yet, as even her earliest stories suggest, she does not always find that marriage necessarily requires that a wife be dominated by her husband, and she demonstrates that both men and women are capable of emotional and spiritual growth. “Athénaïse” • The possibility for growth is perhaps best seen in the story “Athénaïse” (1895). Athénaïse, an emotionally immature young woman, has married the planter Cazeau, but has found that she is not ready for marriage. She runs back to her family, explaining that she does not hate Cazeau himself: It’s jus’ being married that I detes’ an’ despise. . . . I can’t stan’ to live with a man; to have him always there; his coats and pantaloons hanging in my room; his ugly bare feet—washing them in my tub, befo’ my very eyes, ugh! When Cazeau arrives to bring her back, however, she finds that she has to go with him. As the couple rides home, they pass an oak tree which Cazeau recalls was where
Chopin, Kate
261
his father had once apprehended a runaway slave: “The whole impression was for some reason hideous, and to dispel it Cazeau spurred his horse to a swift gallop.” Despite Cazeau’s attempt to make up and live with Athénaïse at least as friends, she remains bitter and unhappy and finally runs away again, aided by her romantic and rather foolish brother Montéclin. Cazeau, a sensitive and proud man, refuses to go after her again as though she too were a runaway slave: “For the companionship of no woman on earth would he again undergo the humiliating sensation of baseness that had overtaken him in passing the old oak-tree in the fallow meadow.” Athénaïse takes refuge in a boarding house in New Orleans where she becomes friendly with Mr. Gouvernail, a newspaper editor. Gouvernail hopes to make Athénaïse his lover, but he refrains from forcing himself on her: “When the time came that she wanted him . . . he felt he would have a right to her. So long as she did not want him, he had no right to her,—no more than her husband had.” Gouvernail, though, never gets his chance; Athénaïse has previously been described as someone who does not yet know her own mind, and such knowledge will not come through rational analysis but “as the song to the bird, the perfume and color to the flower.” This knowledge does come to her when she discovers that she is pregnant. As she thinks of Cazeau, “the first purely sensuous tremor of her life swept over her. . . . Her whole passionate nature was aroused as if by a miracle.” Thus, Athénaïse returns to reconciliation and happiness with her husband. Chopin’s story illustrates that happiness in a relationship can come only with maturity and with mutual respect. Cazeau realizes that he cannot force his wife to love him, and Athénaïse finally knows what she wants when she awakens to an awareness of her own sexuality. If Cazeau has to learn to restrain himself, though, Mr. Gouvernail learns the need to take more initiative as well; not having declared his love for Athénaïse, he suffers when she goes back home. The tone of the entire story is subtly balanced between poignancy and humor, allowing one to see the characters’ flaws while remaining sympathetic with each of them. The importance of physical passion and of sexual self-awareness which can be found in “Athénaïse” can also be found in many of Chopin’s stories and is one of the characteristics that make her writing so far ahead of its time. It is this theme that, as the title suggests, is central to her novel The Awakening and which was partly responsible for the scandal which that novel provoked. Chopin’s insistence not merely on the fact of women’s sexual desires but also on the propriety and healthiness of those desires in some ways anticipates the writings of D. H. Lawrence, but without Lawrence’s insistence on the importance of male dominance. “The Storm” • Sexual fulfillment outside of marriage without moral judgments can be found in “The Storm,” written in 1898, just before The Awakening, but not published until 1969. The story concerns four characters from an earlier tale, “At the ’Cadian Ball” (1892). In that earlier story, a young woman, Clarisse, rides out in the night to the ’Cadian Ball to declare her love for the planter Alcée Laballière. Alcée is at the ball with an old girlfriend of his, Calixta, a woman of Spanish descent. Clarisse claims Alcée, and Calixta agrees to marry Bobinôt, a man who has been in love with her for some time. “The Storm” is set several years later. Calixta and Bobinôt have had a child, and Alcée and Clarisse have been happily married. One day, while Bobinôt and his son are out on an errand, a huge storm breaks out. Alcée takes refuge at Calixta’s house, and the old passion between the two is rekindled; as the storm breaks about them in
262
Short Story Writers
mounting intensity, the two make love, Calixta’s body “knowing for the first time its birthright.” Although the storm mirrors the physical passion of the couple, neither it nor the passion itself is destructive. Where one would expect some retribution for this infidelity in a story, the results are only beneficial: Calixta, physically fulfilled, happily welcomes back her returning husband and son; Alcée writes to Clarisse, off visiting relatives, that he does not need her back right away; and Clarisse, enjoying “the first free breath since her marriage,” is content to stay where she is for the time. Chopin’s ending seems audacious: “So the storm passed and every one was happy.” Although written about a century ago, Chopin’s stories seem very modern in many ways. Her concern with women’s place in society and in marriage, her refusal to mix guilt with sexuality, and her narrative stance of sympathetic detachment make her as relevant to modern readers as her marked ability to convey character and setting simply yet completely. In the little more than a decade in which she produced most of her work, her command of her art grew ever stronger, as did her willingness to deal with controversial subjects. It is unfortunate that this career was cut so short by the reaction to The Awakening and her early death; but it is fortunate that Chopin left the writing that she did and that it has been preserved. Donald F. Larsson With updates by Thomas L. Erskine Other major works novels: At Fault, 1890; The Awakening, 1899. miscellaneous: The Complete Works of Kate Chopin, 1969 (2 volumes; Per Seyersted, editor). nonfiction: Kate Chopin’s Private Papers, 1998. Bibliography Bonner, Thomas, Jr. The Kate Chopin Companion. New York: Greenwood Press, 1988. Guide, arranged alphabetically, to the more than nine hundred characters and over two hundred places that affected the course of Chopin’s stories. Also includes a selection of her translations of pieces by Guy de Maupassant and one by Adrien Vely. Contains interesting period maps and a useful bibliographical essay. Boren, Lynda S., and Sara de Saussure Davis, eds. Kate Chopin Reconsidered: Beyond the Bayou. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1992. Although most of these essays focus on The Awakening, several discuss such stories as “Charlie,” “After the Winter,” and “At Cheniere Caminada.” Other essays compare Chopin with playwright Henrik Ibsen in terms of domestic confinement and discuss her work from a Marxist point of view. Brown, Pearl L. “Awakened Men in Kate Chopin’s Creole Stories.” ATQ, n.s. 13, no. 1 (March, 1999). Argues that in Chopin’s Creole stories, in intimate moments women discover inner selves buried beneath socially imposed ones and men discover subjective selves buried beneath public personas. Erickson, Jon. “Fairytale Features in Kate Chopin’s ‘Désirée’s Baby’: A Case Study in Genre Cross-Reference.” In Modes of Narrative, edited by Reingard M. Nischik and Barbara Korte. Würzburg: Königshausen and Neumann, 1990. Shows how Chopin’s story conflicts with the expectations set up by the fairy-tale genre on which it is based; for example, the prince turns out to be the villain. Argues that the ending
Chopin, Kate
263
of the story is justified, for in the fairy tale the mystery of origin must be solved and the villain must be punished. Koloski, Bernard. Kate Chopin: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1996. Discusses Chopin’s short stories in the context of her bilingual and bicultural imagination; provides readings of her most important stories, examines her three volumes of stories, and comments on her children’s stories. Also includes excerpts from Chopin’s literary criticism and brief discussions by other critics of her most familiar stories. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Chopin: “La Belle Zoraïde” (vol. 1), “Désirée’s Baby” (vol. 2), “Madame Célestin’s Divorce” (vol. 5), and “The Storm” and “The Story of an Hour” (vol. 7). Petry, Alice Hall, ed. Critical Essays on Kate Chopin. New York: G. K. Hall, 1996. Comprehensive collection of essays on Chopin. This volume reprints early evaluations of the author’s life and works as well as more modern scholarly analyses. In addition to a substantial introduction by the editor, it also includes seven original essays by such notable scholars as Linda Wagner-Martin and Heather Kirk Thomas. Seyersted, Per. Kate Chopin: A Critical Biography. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1980. Seyersted’s biography, besides providing invaluable information about the New Orleans of the 1870’s, examines Chopin’s life, views, and work. Provides lengthy discussions not only of The Awakening but also of her many short stories. Seyersted sees her as a transitional literary figure, a link between George Sand and Simone de Beauvoir. Toth, Emily. Kate Chopin. New York: William Morrow, 1990. Toth’s thoroughly documented, exhaustive work is the definitive Chopin biography. She covers not only Chopin’s life but also her literary works and discusses many of the short stories in considerable detail. Toth updates Per Seyersted’s bibliography of Chopin’s work, supplies a helpful chronology of her life, and discusses the alleged banning of The Awakening. The starting point for Chopin research. ____________. Unveiling Kate Chopin. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1999. Using newly discovered manuscripts, letters, and diaries of Chopin, Toth examines the source of Chopin’s ambition and passion for her art, arguing that she worked much harder at her craft than previously thought.
264
Sandra Cisneros Born: Chicago, Illinois; December 20, 1954 Principal short fiction • The House on Mango Street, 1984; Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories, 1991. Other literary forms • Sandra Cisneros is known for her poetry as well as her short fiction. She has published several collections of poems, including Bad Boys (1980), My Wicked, Wicked Ways (1987), and Loose Woman (1994); much of her poetry remains uncollected and unpublished, according to the author’s wishes. She has also published a series of essays explaining her own creative processes as a writer in The Americas Review. In addition, she published Hairs = Pelitos (1984), a children’s book illustrated by Terry Ybanez which expands on the chapter “Hairs” in The House on Mango Street. In 2002, Cisneros published her second novel, Caramelo, which is about a multigeneration Mexican American family making a pilgrimage from Chicago to Mexico City. Achievements • Together with authors such as Ana Castillo, Denise Chávez, and Alma Villanueva, Sandra Cisneros is one of the literary voices that emerged in the 1980’s and was responsible for securing for Chicana fiction a place in mainstream American literature. Her collection of short stories Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories was the first work by and about Chicanas—Mexican American women—to receive a contract with a major publishing house (Random House). Cisneros was awarded the Before Columbus American Book Award and the PEN Center West Award for her first collection of short fiction, The House on Mango Street. She is a twotime recipient of a National Endowment for the Arts Fellowship for Creative Writers for her poetry and fiction. In 1985, Cisneros received a Dobie-Paisano Fellowship. She was granted a MacArthur Fellowship in 1995. Biography • Sandra Cisneros was born in 1954 into a working-class family in Chicago, Illinois. With a Mexican American mother, a Mexican father, and six brothers, she described her circumstances as being similar to having seven fathers. Because of close familial and cultural ties with Mexico, the Cisneros family moved back and forth between a series of cramped apartments in Chicago and the paternal grandmother’s home in Mexico City. The concept of home or the lack of one would later weigh heavily in Cisneros’s writing. The combination of an uprooted lifestyle and an everchanging circle of friends, schools, and neighborhoods, as well as the isolation that resulted from her brothers’ unwillingness to let a girl join in their play, led Cisneros to turn inward to a life of books. That time spent alone allowed an observant, creative voice to take root in the author. Cisneros considered her career as a professional writer to have begun in 1974— the year in which she enrolled in a writing class as a junior at Loyola University of Chicago, where she would later receive her bachelor of arts degree in English. It was her tenure at the University of Iowa’s Writers’ Workshop, from which she took a master of fine arts degree, however, that proved an invaluable aid in the formation of her own
Cisneros, Sandra
265
literary voice. During a discussion of Gaston Bachelard’s La Bétique de l’espace (1957; The Poetics of Space, 1964), in which her classmates spoke of the house as a literary symbol complete with attics, stairways, and cellars of imagination and childhood, Cisneros realized that her experience was different from that of her college classmates. Her background was that of a multiethnic, working-class neighborhood complete with drunken bums, families sleeping on crowded floors, and rats. She ceased trying to make her style fit that of the perfect, white, and mostly male image that was foreign to her and, instead, undertook writing about that to which her classmates could not relate but was familiar to her. Cisneros has used her education to foster change within the Chicano community. She taught high school dropouts for three years in a Chicano barrio. She has also worked as an administrative assistant at Loyola University, where she was involved in the recruitment of minority and disadvantaged students. In 1984, she was the literature director of the Guadalupe Cultural Arts Center of San Antonio, the city which she made her home. Cisneros served as writer-in-residence at the Michael Karolyi Artists Foundation in Vence, France, the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, the University of California at Irvine, and the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque. Analysis • Sandra Cisneros said that she writes about the memories that will not let her sleep at night—about the stories that are waiting to be told. Drawing on the memories of her childhood and her cultural identity—the run-down, crowded apartment, the double-edged sword of being American yet not being considered American, the sight of women in her community closed in behind apartment windows—Cisneros’s fiction avoids any romantic clichés of life in the barrio. Despite the sobering themes upon which Cisneros touches—poverty, sexism, and racism—she tells her stories with a voice that is at the same time strong, playful, and deceptively simple. Cisneros’s distinctive style is marked by the grace with which Spanish words and phrases are woven into her stories. Central to her stories is a preoccupation with the house, the community, and the condition of women. Her images are vivid and lyrical. She acknowledges that she was influenced in style by the mix of poetry and fiction in Jorge Luis Borges’s El hacedor (1960; Dreamtigers, 1964). Indeed, while Cisneros herself classifies her fiction as stories that read like poems, critics have not reached an agreement, labeling her works The House on Mango Street and Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories alternatively as novels, short-story collections, series of vignettes, and prose poems. The House on Mango Street • The series of sketches in The House on Mango Street offers a bittersweet view of life in a Chicago barrio. Readers follow the young adolescent narrator Esperanza—whose name (as explained in the story “My Name”) means “hope” in Spanish and also implies too many letters, sadness, and waiting—as she makes the discoveries associated with maturing. She introduces the reader to her neighbors and her neighborhood, making them as familiar to the reader as they are to her. In the title story, Esperanza explains how her family came to live on Mango Street. The family had hoped that the house on Mango Street would be like the ones they had always dreamed of—with real stairs and several bathrooms and a great big yard with trees and grass. Esperanza sadly explains, however, that their house does not fulfill this wish at all. She is ashamed of her red brick house, as she has been of all of her family’s previous dwellings. She succinctly describes the embarrassment that she experienced when the family was living on Loomis and she had to show her apartment to a nun from
266
Short Story Writers
TO VIEW IMAGE, PLEASE SEE PRINT EDITION OF THIS BOOK.
her school. She pointed to the family’s third-floor flat, located above a boarded-up laundry, and suffered the blow of the nun’s disbelieving response, “there?” From that moment, Esperanza knew that she had to have a house—one that she could show with pride to people as if it were a reflection of herself. She was sure the family would have such a house soon. Yet the house on Mango Street is not that house.
“Bums in the Attic” • Because Esperanza remarks that she wants a house “all my own. With my porch and my pillow, my pretty purple petunias. My books and my stories,” Cisneros has been read as creating a grasping and selfish protagonist. Yet the section titled “Bums in the Attic” dispels this notion of untoward individualism. In this sketch—which resembles one of Cisneros’s favorite children’s stories, Virginia Lee Burton’s The Little House (1978), in which the owners of a © Rubén Guzmán house on a country hill promise the house never to sell it—Esperanza speculates about the grand home on a hill that she will have someday. As much as she wants to leave Mango Street, however, she stresses that even in her country home she will not forget from where she came. She will not make her house a secured palace that locks out the world; she will instead offer her attic to the homeless so that they too will have a home. “Those Who Don’t” • In “Those Who Don’t,” the young Esperanza discusses in a matter-of-fact tone the concept of being the “other” in society. She knows that people who happen into her neighborhood think that her community is dangerous, but she knows her neighbors by name and knows their backgrounds. Among her Latino friends she feels safe. Yet Esperanza can understand the stranger’s apprehension, for when she and her family venture out of the security of their neighborhood, their bodies get tense and their eyes look straight ahead. “Alicia Who Sees Mice” • Cisneros’s concern for the place women hold in Latino society is evident in the powerful story “Alicia Who Sees Mice.” Alicia, Esperanza’s friend, must rise early every morning “with the tortilla star” and the mice in the kitchen to make her father’s lunch-box tortillas. Alicia’s mother has died, and, Esperanza remarks, young Alicia has inherited her mother’s duty as the family caregiver along with her “rolling pin and sleepiness.” Alicia has dreams of escaping this life of confinement and sacrifice, however, with a university education. She studies
Cisneros, Sandra
267
hard all night with the mice that her father says do not exist. With its precise imagery, “Alicia Who Sees Mice” is at once a criticism of patriarchal oppression of women and a beacon for those women who would struggle to break away from that oppression. “Minerva Writes Poems” • The theme of education and writing as a means whereby women can escape from the barrio is also found in “Minerva Writes Poems.” Minerva is only a bit older than Esperanza, “but already she has two kids and a husband who left . . . and keeps leaving.” Minerva’s husband reappears sporadically, but their reunion usually ends in violence and abuse. Minerva cries every day over her bad situation and writes poems at night. In an act of artistic and sisterly solidarity, she and Esperanza read their poems to each other, yet at this point, Esperanza feels helpless, unable to stop the beatings. In her reply, “There is nothing I can do,” there is a sense that Esperanza is inciting Minerva to take action for herself as well as implying that society itself must change its attitudes. “Edna’s Ruthie” • This sisterly support for fulfillment through learning is echoed in “Edna’s Ruthie.” The title character is a talented but damaged woman who returns to her mother’s home when she can no longer care for herself. Her own fondness for books—for hearing and telling a good story—inspires Esperanza in her own creative endeavors. Ruthie is moved to tears by Esperanza’s recitation of children’s stories, a response that conveys to the young girl the power of the word. “Red Clowns” • Esperanza’s passage into adulthood is not without setbacks. In “Red Clowns,” she goes to the amusement park with her friend Sally. When the sexually precocious Sally abandons Esperanza to slip away with a boy, Esperanza is molested and possibly raped by an older boy who tells her, “I love you Spanish girl, I love you.” She is angry and sad and confused over the loss of her innocence. She cannot understand why everyone told her that sex would be so wonderful when, in fact, she found nothing pleasant about the perpetrator’s dirty fingernails and sour breath. She wants to forget that degrading experience; she does not want to speak its horror. She yells at her friend Sally for leaving her, but she also directs her anger at a society that is partner to such an awful lie. “The Three Sisters” • The fundamental conflict that besets Esperanza is resolved in “The Three Sisters.” Although Esperanza has repeatedly voiced her desire to escape the barrio and its double bind of racism and sexism which snares many women, she nevertheless loves her community and cannot come to terms with deserting it. Then three wise, eccentric, and decidedly feminist sisters settle the issue. Young Esperanza is strong, talented, and destined to “go very far,” they tell her. Their encouraging words sanction her flight, yet the sisters remind her as well of the need for loyalty: When you leave you must remember to come back for the others. A circle, understand? You will always be Esperanza. You will always be Mango Street. You can’t erase what you know. You can’t forget who you are. Young Esperanza can finally look to a life beyond the confines of her repressive environment. Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories • Likewise, Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories offers a glimpse into the lives of Chicanas who must confront daily the triple
268
Short Story Writers
bind of not being considered Mexican, not being considered American, and not being male. Cisneros said that while the pieces of Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories function individually, there is a single, unifying thread of vision and experience that runs throughout the collection of twenty-two narratives. Although the names of the narrators change with each work, each narrator retains a strong, determined, rebellious voice. “Eleven” • In “Eleven,” eleven-year-old Rachel’s birthday prompts her to consider what it means to grow older. The wisdom of her eleven years has taught her that the years “underneath” the birthday, like the rings inside a tree trunk, make one a certain age. When people want to cry, she reasons, it is the part of them that is three that brings on tears; when they are scared, it is the part in them that is five that registers fear. For this reason, Rachel explains, she was not able to act eleven years old today in school when her teacher wrongly accused her of forgetting an ugly red sweater that had been in the coatroom for a month. All the years were welling up inside her, preventing Rachel from telling everyone that it was not her sweater. Instead, she was silent. She tries to be happy and remember that today she is eleven and that her mother will have a cake for her when she goes home. The part of Rachel that is three, however, comes out in front of the class instead. She wishes she were anything but eleven. “One Holy Night” • The narrator of the chilling “One Holy Night” is an adolescent girl who sells fruits and vegetables from her grandmother’s pushcart. She meets a wanderer named Chaq who tells her that he is a descendant of a long line of Mayan kings. Intrigued by his story, the young woman begins to follow Chaq to his little room behind an automobile garage after she has sold each day’s produce. Chaq spins mystic tales of the past and future greatness of his family’s lineage as he entices the girl into her first sexual experience. She returns home to her grandmother and uncle a changed woman, barely able to contain her excitement. The young woman’s secret, however, is soon discovered: She is pregnant. The family, in total disgrace, attempts to locate Chaq, who has since left town. Her uncle writes a letter in hope of finding the man who could correct his niece’s ruined life. A response arrives from Chaq’s sister. She explains that her brother’s name is actually Chato, which means “fat-face”; he is thirty-seven, not at all Mayan, and not at all royal. The girl’s family sends her to Mexico to give birth and to avoid disgrace. It is later learned that Chato has been captured and charged with the deaths of eleven women. The girl appears unfazed by the news, however, and continues to plan her dreams of children. She becomes indifferent to love. “Never Marry a Mexican” • The title “Never Marry a Mexican” sums up the advice that the protagonist Clemencia was told as a young girl by her Chicana mother who regretted marrying a Mexican. Her mother’s words ultimately consign Clemencia to cultural and social marginality. Clemencia scorns the working-class Latino men in her life and refuses to consider any of them as potential husbands. However, ironically, the white men whom she favors follow the same advice her mother has instilled in her: They will become sexually involved with a Chicana, but they will not marry outside of their own race. Caught uncomfortably between cultures, Clemencia attempts to make the most of her difficult status. She prides herself on remaining unattached, a seductress who beds white, married men while their wives are in the throes of childbirth. Yet her pain
Cisneros, Sandra
269
and loneliness are palpable. She nurses affection for one white married lover for eighteen years, eventually gaining revenge on him by entering into a sexual relationship with his son. For Clemencia, the unhealthy relationship yields and yet perverts what she ostensibly disavows: marriage and motherhood. Sexual intercourse with the young man, she believes, links her to his father and mother’s marital relations, of which he is the product, and her lover’s relative youth allows her to “mother” him. “Woman Hollering Creek” • The collection’s title story is one of its strongest. It is a story of Cleófilas, a woman reared in a small town in Mexico not far from the Texas border. Cleófilas dreams of the romance and passion of the soap operas that she watches at her girlfriend’s house. She believes her fantasy is realized when she meets Juan Pedro, a Texan who wants to marry her right away, “without a long engagement since he can’t take off too much time from work.” Cleófilas is whisked away across the border to Seguin, Texas, a town like so many others, with nothing of interest to walk to, “built so that you have to depend on husbands.” Life on “the other side” is, at first, a blessing for Cleófilas. Texas is the land of Laundromats and dream homes. Running behind their new house is a creek that all call Woman Hollering. Cleófilas wonders if the odd name is connected to tales of La Llorona, the tragic mythical figure known to wail after drowning her children. Her enthusiasm for her new life ends quickly, however, with a slap to her face by Juan Pedro. That slap will start a long line of abuse and cause Cleófilas to think flatly, “This is the man I have waited my whole life for.” Although she had always promised herself that she would not allow any man to hit her, Cleófilas, isolated at home, not allowed to correspond with her family, hindered by not knowing English, and afraid of Juan Pedro’s rage, stays with him. When she begins to suspect that Juan Pedro is unfaithful, she thinks about returning to her native town but fears disgrace and does not act. Cleófilas had always thought that her life would be like a soap opera, “only now the episodes got sadder and sadder. And there were no commercials in between for comic relief.” She becomes pregnant with their second child but is almost too afraid to ask Juan Pedro to take her to the clinic for prenatal care. Once at the clinic, Cleófilas breaks down and tells her plight to a sympathetic doctor who arranges a ride for her and her son to the bus station in San Antonio. The morning of their escape, Cleófilas is tense and frightened. As they pass over Woman Hollering Creek in a pickup truck, their spirited female driver lets out a Tarzan-like yell that startles her two passengers. On her way back to her father’s home, Cleófilas catches a glimpse of what it is to be an autonomous woman. Mary F. Yudin With updates by Theresa Kanoza and the Editors Other major works children’s literature: Hairs = Pelitos, 1984. novel: Caramelo, 2002. miscellaneous: Vintage Cisneros, 2004. poetry: Bad Boys, 1980; The Rodrigo Poems, 1985; My Wicked, Wicked Ways, 1987; Loose Woman, 1994. Bibliography Brady, Mary Pat. “The Contrapuntal Geographies of Woman Hollering Creek, and Other
270
Short Story Writers
Stories.” American Literature 71 (March, 1999): 117-150. Shows how Cisneros’s narrative techniques challenge various spatial representations and lay bare hidden stories. Claims that Cisneros explores the various subtleties of violence of changing spatial relations. Cisneros, Sandra. “On the Solitary Fate of Being Mexican, Female, Wicked, and Thirty-three: An Interview with Writer Sandra Cisneros.” Interview by Pilar E. Rodríguez Aranda. The Americas Review 18, no. 1 (1990): 64-80. In an enlightening interview, Cisneros discusses her identity as a Chicana, her development as a writer, and her use of poetry and modern myth in her fiction. The interview focuses on the collections My Wicked, Wicked Ways and The House on Mango Street. ____________. “Sandra Cisneros: Conveying the Riches of the Latin American Culture Is the Author’s Literary Goal.” Interview by Jim Sagel. Publishers Weekly 238 (March 29, 1991): 74-75. In this informative interview, Cisneros speaks about the influence that her childhood had on her writing. The interview touches upon the personal side of the writer and includes a brief description of the genesis of the collection Woman Hollering Creek, and Other Stories. Griffin, Susan E. “Resistance and Reinvention in Sandra Cisneros’ Woman Hollering Creek.” In Ethnicity and the American Short Story, edited by Julie Brown. New York: Garland, 1997. Discusses the role that Mexican popular culture and traditional Mexican narratives play in limiting women’s sense of identity. Focuses primarily on the negative effects of popular romances in Mexico and televised soap operas. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Cisneros: “Geraldo No Last Name” (vol. 3), “One Holy Night” (vol. 5), and “Woman Hollering Creek” (vol. 8). Mullen, Harryette. “‘A Silence Between Us Like a Language’: The Untranslatability of Experience in Sandra Cisneros’s Woman Hollering Creek.” MELUS 21 (Summer, 1996): 3-20. Argues that Spanish as a code comprehensible to an inside group and as a repressed language subordinate to English are central issues in Woman Hollering Creek. Sanborn, Geoffrey. “Keeping Her Distance: Cisneros, Dickinson, and the Politics of Private Enjoyment.” Publications of the Modern Language Association 116, no. 5 (2001): 1334-1348. Analyzes Cisneros’s use of a poem by Emily Dickinson in The House on Mango Street as a means of evoking the pleasures of withdrawal from faceto-face sociality. Thompson, Jeff. “’What Is Called Heaven?’ Identity in Sandra Cisneros’s Woman Hollering Creek.” Studies in Short Fiction 31 (Summer, 1994): 415-424. States that the overall theme of the stories is the vulnerability of the female narrators. The vignettes should be read as symptomatic of a social structure that allows little cultural movement and little possibility for the creation of an identity outside the boundaries of the barrio. Wyatt, Jean. “On Not Being La Malinche: Border Negotiations of Gender in Sandra Cisneros’s ‘Never Marry a Mexican’ and ‘Woman Hollering Creek.’” Tulsa Studies in Women’s Literature 14 (Fall, 1995): 243-271. Discusses how the stories describe the difficulties of living on the border between Anglo-American and Mexican cultures and how the female protagonists of the stories struggle with sexuality and motherhood as icons that limit their identity.
271
Walter Van Tilburg Clark Born: East Orland, Maine; August 3, 1909 Died: Reno, Nevada; November 10, 1971 Principal short fiction • The Watchful Gods, and Other Stories, 1950. Other literary forms • In addition to his short stories, Walter Van Tilburg Clark wrote three novels—The Ox-Bow Incident (1940), The City of Trembling Leaves (1945), and The Track of the Cat (1949). The first and last of these were made into motion pictures. Tim Hazard (1951) is the enlarged version of The City of Trembling Leaves. Clark also produced an early book of poems, Ten Women in Gale’s House and Shorter Poems (1932). Achievements • Although Walter Van Tilburg Clark is known primarily for his novels, his one volume of stories, as well as his uncollected short stories, have established him as a fine writer of short stories. In fact, his “The Wind and the Snow of Winter” received the O. Henry Award in 1945. In their Western settings, their ambiguous depiction of the American Dream, their concern about personal identity and oneness with nature, and their essentially tragic vision, the short stories are of a piece with his three novels. Unlike some “Western” writers, Clark used his landscape as both subject and backdrop for his own philosophical themes. Less concerned with characters—one story virtually omits them, concentrating instead on animals as “characters”—than with ideas, Clark used his characters, many of whom seem stereotypical, to embody and actualize his notions about the possibility of defining self and position in the cosmos. Biography • Walter Van Tilburg Clark was born on August 3, 1909, in East Orland, Maine, the first child of Walter Ernest and Euphemia Abrams Clark. In 1917, his father, a distinguished economics professor, became president of the University of Nevada at Reno. Therefore, the family had to move when Clark was only eight. In Reno, Clark attended public schools and later received his bachelor’s and master’s degrees in English from the University of Nevada. Clark married Barbara Morse in 1933, and they became the parents of two children, Barbara Ann and Robert Morse. The couple settled in Cazenovia, New York, where Clark began a career in high school and college teaching as well as creative writing. In the next several years, Clark continued writing and taught at several schools, including the University of Montana, Reed College, and the University of Nevada, where he resigned after protesting the autocratic tendencies of the administration. He eventually returned there, however, to teach creative writing. Clark was also director of creative writing at San Francisco State College from 1956 to 1962. He died of cancer on November 10, 1971, at the age of sixty-two. Analysis • Walter Van Tilburg Clark once wrote that the primary impulse of the arts has been religious and ritualistic—with the central hope of “propitiating or enlisting Nature, the Gods, God, or whatever name one wishes to give the encompassing and still mysterious whole.” Certainly Clark’s fiction attests to such a view. In a world in which thought is often confused and fragmented, he advocates for humanity a stance of intellectual honesty, an acceptance of instinctive values, and a belief in love. The
272
Short Story Writers
key is human experience. As Max Westbrook so aptly put it in his study of Clark, “Clark’s literary credo, then, is based on the capacity of the unconscious mind to discover and to give shape to objective knowledge about the human experience.” “The Buck in the Hills” • “The Buck in the Hills” may be Clark’s clearest reflection in his stories of the literary credo mentioned above. Writing more or less in the terse, almost brittle, style of Ernest Hemingway, Clark opens the story with vividly descriptive passages of mountain scenery. The narrator, whose name the reader never learns, has returned to this setting after five years. It is really more than a return for him; it is a pilgrimage to a sacred place. Like Hemingway’s heroes, he feels a deep need to replenish his spirit, to reattach himself to things solid and lasting. The clear sky, the strong mountains, and the cold wind all serve as a natural backdrop for the spiritual ritual of his pilgrimage. As he climbs toward the peak of a mountain, he recalls with pleasure an earlier climb with a dark girl “who knew all the flowers, and who, when I bet her she couldn’t find more than thirty kinds, found more than fifty.” On that day, as on this, the narrator felt a clear sense of the majesty of the mountains and the “big arch of the world we looked at,” and he recalls spending two hours another time watching a hawk, “feeling myself lift magnificently when he swooped up toward me on the current up the col, and then balanced and turned above.” When he returns to his campsite by a shallow snow-water lake, he swims, naked, and as he floats in this cleansing ritual, looking up at the first stars showing above the ridge, he sings out “an operatic sounding something.” At this point, just when his spiritual rejuvenation is nearly complete, the ritual is broken by the appearance of Tom Williams, one of the two men whom he had accompanied on this trip to the mountains. The plan had been for Williams and the other man, Chet McKenny, to spend a few days hunting, leaving the narrator alone. As he watches Williams approach, the narrator unhappily expects to see McKenny also, a man he dislikes not because of his stupidity but because of something deeper than that. Williams, however, is alone. After a while Williams tells the narrator of the experience he has just had with McKenny, whom he calls a “first-rate bastard.” During their hunt McKenny had purposely shot a deer in the leg so that he could herd it back to their camp rather than carry it. When they arrived at the camp, he slit the deer’s throat, saying, “I never take more than one shot.” Sickened by this brutal act, Williams drove off in his car, leaving McKenny to get out of the mountains as best he could. After Williams’s story, both men agree that McKenny deserves to be left behind for what he did. In another cleansing ritual, they both take a swim, becoming cheerful later as they sit by their fire drinking beer. The next morning, however, it is snowing, and as they silently head back down the mountain, the narrator feels that there is “something listening behind each tree and rock we passed, and something waiting among the taller trees down slope, blue through the falling snow. They wouldn’t stop us, but they didn’t like us either. The snow was their ally.” Thus there are two contrasting moods in “The Buck in the Hills”: that of harmony and that of dissonance. At the beginning of the story, the narrator has succeeded after five years in reestablishing a right relationship with nature and thus with himself, but at the end, this relationship has been destroyed by the cruel actions of McKenny. The narrator’s ritual of acceptance of the primordial in human beings has been overshadowed by McKenny’s ritual of acceptance that human beings are somehow above nature. Ernest Hemingway’s belief that morality is what one feels good after is in one
Clark, Walter Van Tilburg
273
sense reversed here to the idea that immorality is what one feels bad after; certainly the narrator and Williams, on their way down the mountain, feel bad. Human beings and nature in a right relationship is not a mere romantic notion to Clark. It is reality—indeed, perhaps humankinds only reality. “The Portable Phonograph” • In “The Portable Phonograph” Clark ventures, if not into science fiction, at least into a kind of speculative fiction as he sets his story in a world of the future, one marked by the “toothed impress of great tanks” and the “scars of gigantic bombs.” It seems a world devoid of human existence; the only visible life is a flock of wild geese flying south to escape the cold of winter. Above the frozen creek in a cave dug into the bank, however, there is human Library of Congress life: four men—survivors of some undescribed Armageddon—huddle before a smoldering peat fire in an image of primitive existence. Clark provides little background of these four almost grotesque men. One, the reader learns, is a doctor, probably of philosophy rather than of medicine. One is a young musician, quite ill with a cough. The other two are middle-aged. All are obviously intelligent. The cave belongs to the doctor, whose name is Jenkins, and he has invited the others to hear him read from one of his four books—the Bible, Moby Dick, The Divine Comedy, and the works of William Shakespeare. In selfish satisfaction he explains that when he saw what was happening to the world, “I told myself, ‘It is the end. I cannot take much; I will take these.’” His justification is his love for the books and his belief that they represent the “soul of what was good in us here.” When Jenkins finishes his reading from The Tempest, the others wait expectantly, and the former finally says grudgingly, “You wish to hear the phonograph.” This is obviously the moment for which they have been waiting. Jenkins tenderly and almost lovingly brings out his portable phonograph and places it on the dirt-packed floor where the firelight will fall on it. He comments that he has been using thorns as needles, but that in deference to the musician, he will use one of the three steel needles that he has left. Since Jenkins will play only one record a week, there is some discussion as to what they will hear. The musician selects a Claude Debussy nocturne, and as Jenkins places the record on the phonograph, the others all rise to their knees “in an attitude of worship.” As the piercing and singularly sweet sounds of the nocturne flood the cave, the men are captivated. In all but the musician there occur “sequences of tragically heightened recollection”; the musician, clenching the fingers of one hand over his teeth, hears only the music. At the conclusion of the piece, the three guests leave—the musician by himself, the other two together. Jenkins peers anxiously after
274
Short Story Writers
them, waiting. When he hears the cough of the musician some distance off, he drops his canvas door and hurries to hide his phonograph in a deep hole in the cave wall. Sealing up the hole, he prays and then gets under the covers of his grass bed, feeling with his hand the “comfortable piece of lead pipe.” Structurally a very simple story, “The Portable Phonograph” is rich in its implications. In a devastated world four men represent what Jenkins refers to as “the doddering remnant of a race of mechanical fools.” The books that he has saved symbolize the beauty of humanity’s artistic creativity as opposed to the destructiveness of its mechanical creativity. Again, Clark portrays two sides of human nature, that which aspires to the heights of human spiritual and moral vision and that which drives humankind on to its own destruction. The cruel and bitter irony is that essentially humankind imagination is at once its glory and its undoing. As the men kneel in expectation before the mechanical wonder of the phonograph, they worship it as a symbol of human ingenuity. The music that comes from the record provides for at least three of the men a temporary escape from their grim reality. Thus, humanity’s drive for mechanical accomplishment—the same drive that has destroyed a world—now has also preserved the beauty of its musical accomplishment. This may well be what the musician understands as he lets his head “fall back in agony” while listening to the music. Human beings are forever blessed to create and doomed to destroy. That is why the piece of lead pipe is such a protective comfort to Jenkins as he closes “his smoke-smarting eyes.” In order to protect what is left of art, he must rely on the very methods that have brought about its demise. “The Indian Well” • In his excellent novel The Track of the Cat, Clark takes the reader into the realm of human unconscious as Curt Bridges, the protagonist, is driven to his own death while tracking both a real and an imagined cougar. In the short story “The Indian Well,” set in the desert in 1940, Jim Suttler also seeks to kill a cougar, and although the mythological and psychological implications are not developed as fully as they are in the novel, the story is still powerful in its total effect. In what must be one of the best word pictures of the desert and the creatures that inhabit it, Clark devotes a half-dozen pages to the stark drama of life and death that takes place around a desert well; rattlesnakes, road runners, jackrabbits, hawks, lizards, coyotes, and a cow and her calf all play parts. The story’s only character is Jim Suttler, a grizzled old prospector who, with his mule Jenny, still seeks gold in abandoned and long-forgotten mines. Suttler is a man well-attuned to life in the desert wilderness. Armed with a rifle, an old six-shooter, and primitive mining tools, he is not merely a stereotyped prospector; his red beard and shoulder-length red hair might lead some to see in him a resemblance to Christ, but Suttler is unlike Christ in several ways. Early in the story, Suttler and Jenny arrive at Indian Well. The history of Indian Well is recorded on the walls of the rundown cabin nearby; names and dates go back to the previous century. All had used the well, and all had given vent to some expression, ranging from “God guide us” to “Giv it back to the injuns” to a more familiar libel: “Fifty miles from water, a hundred miles from wood, a million miles from God, and three feet from hell.” Before Suttler leaves, he too will leave a message. Finding some traces of gold in an abandoned mine near the well, Suttler decides to stay for a while to see if he can make it pay off. It is a comfortable time, and both he and Jenny regain some of the weight lost during their recent travels. Two events, however, change the idyllic mood of their stay. The first occurs when Suttler kills a range
Clark, Walter Van Tilburg
275
calf that, along with its mother, has strayed close to the well. Although he has some qualms about killing the calf, Suttler, enjoying the sensation of Providence, soon puts them out of his mind. Next, a cougar kills Jenny. This event inflames Suttler with the desire for revenge—even if “it takes a year”—so throughout the winter he sits up nights waiting for the cat to return. When he eventually kills it, he skins it and, uncovering Jenny’s grave, places the skin over her carcass. His revenge complete, he cleanses himself at the well and leaves as a “starved but revived and volatile spirit.” Thus, one more passerby has contributed to the history of Indian Well, and the life around the well goes on. The basic element in “The Indian Well” is the ironic contrast between the beginning and the ending of the story, just as it is in “The Buck in the Hills.” When they come upon Indian Well, Suttler and Jenny enter into a natural world that has its own ordered life and death, and they blend easily into it. Suttler appears to be a man at one with nature, yet at the end of the story, the death that he has inflicted upon the cougar stands as something apart from the ordered world of the well. It is a death that was motivated by the desire for revenge, a very human emotion. The reader might be suspicious when Suttler kills the calf, but he justifies such a killing on the basis of the meat that the calf provides. Killing the cougar, on the other hand, cannot be justified in any external way. The deep satisfaction that it brings to Suttler stands in opposition to any right relationship between human beings and nature; it is solely a part of Suttler’s inner self. When the deed is done, Suttler can blend back into the natural world around him. For that one winter, however, as he lies in wait for the cougar, he exhibits humankind’s all-too-common flaw of putting itself above the natural world. Still, because he knows what he has done and, moreover, accepts it, he is able once more to establish his relationship with the cosmic forces. “Hook” • In a very real sense, this establishing of a relationship with the cosmic forces is the goal of many of Clark’s characters. Caught in the ambiguities of good and evil, of morality and immorality, they struggle to maintain a faith in humanity and to bring moral law into accordance with natural law, for only in that way can human beings be saved from their own destructive tendencies. Some critics, such as Chester Eisinger, see Clark as being rather pessimistic regarding the success of such a human attempt at unity and attribute to him a desire to retreat from other human beings. If this view is correct, then perhaps the story “Hook” is the best expression of what Clark wants to say. The main character in this story is a hawk which fulfills itself in flight, in battle, and in sex, until it is killed by a dog. The hawk’s life is a cycle of instinct, and it can easily enough be seen as an antihuman symbol. If Eisinger’s view is wrong however, then it is possible to see Clark as a writer who seeks not a retreat from other human beings but an explanation of humanity. For, like the hawks that appear so often in Clark’s stories, human beings are also a part of nature and because he is, it is possible to see his task as one of defining himself in the context of the natural order of things. Whatever the outcome, Clark’s characters do make the attempt. Wilton Eckley With updates by Thomas L. Erskine Other major works novels: The Ox-Bow Incident, 1940; The City of Trembling Leaves, 1945; The Track of the Cat, 1949; Tim Hazard, 1951.
276
Short Story Writers
nonfiction: The Journals of Alfred Doten, 1849-1903, 1973 (3 volumes). poetry: Ten Women in Gale’s House and Shorter Poems, 1932. Bibliography Court, Franklin E. “Clark’s ‘The Wind and the Snow of Winter’ and Celtic Oisin.” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (Spring, 1996): 219-228. Examines the mythic pattern of Clark’s most famous story against the background of the Celtic legend of wandering Oisin. Eisinger, Chester E. Fiction of the Forties. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963. Eisinger regards Clark’s short stories as similar in theme (search for identity, desire to merge with nature, and rejection by nature) to the novels. Although several short stories are mentioned in passing, Eisinger includes lengthy analyses of “The Buck in the Hills,” “Hook,” and “The Watchful Gods.” Kich, Martin. Western American Novelists. Vol. 1. New York: Garland, 1995. After a brief account of Clark’s career, Kich provides an extensive, annotated bibliography, providing detailed commentary on reviews of virtually every significant prose fiction. Kich also annotates reference works with entries on Clark and books with chapters on his fiction. Laird, Charlton, ed. Walter Van Tilburg Clark: Critiques. Reno: University of Nevada Press, 1983. Collection of eighteen pieces, some by Clark himself, on Clark’s life, his major published work, and his literary craftsmanship. The book is most valuable for the essays on “The Watchful Gods” and “The Pretender,” essays that portray Clark as a reviser/craftsman, and for the autobiographical information and the detailed chronology provided by his son. Lee, L. L. Walter Van Tilburg Clark. Boise, Ida.: Boise State College Press, 1973. Lee devotes a separate chapter to the short stories, which he believes repeat the themes of the novels but with greater clarity and insight. “The Portable Phonograph” and “The Watchful Gods” are discussed in some detail. Supplemented by a helpful bibliography. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Clark: “Hook” (vol. 3), “The Portable Phonograph” (vol. 6), and “The Wind and the Snow of Winter” (vol. 8). Ronald, Ann. “Walter Van Tilburg Clark’s Brave Bird, ‘Hook.’” Studies in Short Fiction 25 (Fall, 1988): 433-439. Discusses the complex irony of the story, arguing that critics have wrongfully ignored it as a simple fable or animal tale for children. Westbrook, Max. Walter Van Tilburg Clark. New York: Twayne, 1969. Westbrook’s book remains the best overall assessment of Clark’s literary work; in addition to a chronology of Clark’s life, a biographical chapter, and a select bibliography, Westbrook includes a chapter on Clark’s novella, The Watchful Gods, and Other Stories, and several paragraph-length discussions of Clark’s best short stories. ____________. “Walter Van Tilburg Clark and the American Dream.” In A Literary History of the American West, edited by J. Golden Taylor. Fort Worth: Texas Christian University Press, 1987. Westbrook blends biography with criticism as he analyzes Clark’s fiction and defines Clark’s place in literary history. Using characters from stories and novels, Westbrook depicts the Clark “hero” as an idealistic dreamer incapable of practical action. As a result, the American dream, or its nightmarish counterpart, becomes a real concern for Clark.
277
Arthur C. Clarke Born: Minehead, Somerset, England; December 16, 1917 Principal short fiction • Expedition to Earth, 1953; Reach for Tomorrow, 1956; Tales from the White Hart, 1957; The Other Side of the Sky, 1958; Tales of Ten Worlds, 1962; The Nine Billion Names of God, 1967; Of Time and Stars: The Worlds of Arthur C. Clarke, 1972; The Wind from the Sun, 1972; The Best of Arthur C. Clarke, 1937-1971, 1973; The Sentinel: Masterworks of Science Fiction and Fantasy, 1983; Dilemmas: The Secret, 1989; Tales from Planet Earth, 1989; More than One Universe: The Collected Stories of Arthur C. Clarke, 1991; The Collected Stories of Arthur C. Clarke, 2000. Other literary forms • Arthur C. Clarke is best known for novels that chronicle nearfuture space and sea exploration or suggest transcendence of human form and limitations. He published an autobiographical novel based on his experience with radar in World War II, and he adapted several of his stories for film: 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) for Stanley Kubrick, 2010: Odyssey Two (1982), and Cradle (1988). In 1997, he published 3001: The Final Odyssey. Among his most important and best-known novels are Against the Fall of Night, 1953 (revised as The City and the Stars, 1956), Childhood’s End (1953), Rendezvous with Rama (1973), Imperial Earth (1975), and The Fountains of Paradise (1979). Since the early 1990’s, he has written most of his novels in collaboration with other authors, most notably Gentry Lee and Stephen Baxter. These later novels include The Garden of Rama (1991), The Light of Other Days (2000), Time’s Eye (2004), and Sunstorm (2005). Throughout his career, Clarke contributed numerous articles on science and speculation, edited various scientific and science-fiction magazines, and wrote more than twenty books of nonfiction, including By Space Possessed (1993) and The Snows of Olympus: A Garden of Mars (1994). In 2003, Clarke published From Narnia to a Space Odyssey: The War of Ideas Between Arthur C. Clarke and C. S. Lewis. Clarke recorded some of his fictional works, lectured widely on science, the sea, and futuristic technology, and authored a television series, Arthur C. Clarke’s World of Strange Powers. His writing has appeared in popular magazines under the pseudonyms E. G. O’Brien and Charles Willis. Achievements • Arthur C. Clarke has received numerous awards. The most representative include Hugo Awards for science fiction in 1956, 1974, and 1980; UNESCO’s Kalinga Prize in 1961, for science writing; the Stuart Ballantine Gold Medal in 1963, for originating the concept of communications satellites; an Academy Award nomination in 1969 for best screenplay; Nebula Awards for science fiction in 1972, 1973, and 1980; a GALAXY Award for science fiction in 1979; and the Centennial Medal in 1984, for scientific achievements. Other distinguished honors include the prestigious Grand Master Award from the Science Fiction Writers of America in 1986, the Charles A. Lindbergh Award in 1987, and his election to the Society of Satellite Professions Hall of Fame in 1987 and to the Aerospace Hall of Fame in 1988. In 1989 Clarke became a Commander of the British Empire, and he received a knighthood for “services to literature” in 1998.
278
Short Story Writers
Biography • Reared in the country, Arthur Charles Clarke worked as a government auditor (1936-1941) in London, where he became active in the British Interplanetary Society (eventually becoming chairman, 1946-1947, 1950-1952). A Royal Air Force instructor in the infant technology of radar during World TO VIEW IMAGE, War II, he published the first specuPLEASE SEE lations on “stationary” communications satellites in 1945. After earnPRINT EDITION ing his bachelor’s degree in physics OF THIS BOOK. and mathematics at King’s College, London (1948), he became assistant editor of Science Abstracts (19491951) before turning to full-time writing. Introduced in 1953 to scuba diving, he moved to what was then Ceylon in 1956 and remained there for many years. Clarke married Marilyn Mayfield in 1954, but they were divorced in 1964. Clarke has more than five hundred works attributed to him. He is © Washington Post, reprinted by permission of the D.C. Public Library known as one of the most influential writers in the science-fiction field, as well as a visionary seer on scientific speculation. Clarke was the first, for example, to propose the idea of communications satellites, in his article “Extraterrestrial Relays” in 1945. He is a mathematician and physicist as well as a novelist and commentator. His talent for peering into the future has involved him in advising governments on communication and on the human use of space. Clarke popularized his belief in the total exploration of space and the sea. He became chancellor of the University of Moratuwa in Sri Lanka and was founder of the Arthur C. Clarke Center for Advanced Technology. Analysis • Exposed in his childhood to both the pulp magazines of Hugo Gernsback and the English literary tradition of fantasy and science fiction, Arthur C. Clarke sometimes forges an uneasy alliance between the two in his own stories. The matter-offact description of the marvelous of H. G. Wells, the poetic evocation of unknown places of Lord Dunsany, and the immense vistas of space and time of the philosopher Olaf Stapledon lie cheek-by-jowl with artificial suspense devices, awkward sentimentality, schoolboy silliness, and melodramatic manipulation of such hoary motifs as the “stranded astronaut” or the “end of the world” in his less distinguished fiction. At its best, however, Clarke’s work shows glimpses of humanity’s rise to interplanetary civilization or evokes the wonder, in suitably subdued tones, of confrontations with extraterrestrial intelligences. Clarke’s 1967 collection of his “favorites” represents many facets of his career, from the raconteur of tall tales and ghost stories to the fantasist, the sentimentalist,
Clarke, Arthur C.
279
the realist, and the poet of wonder. Most of his best and best-known stories are included, from the haunting rite of passage of a young lunar exile getting his first glimpse of the unapproachably radioactive world of his ancestors (“‘If I Forget Thee, Oh Earth . . . ,’”) to such “alien fables” of technological complacency as “Superiority” and “Before Eden.” “Rescue Party” • Among them, “Rescue Party,” his second professionally published story, looks forward to other tales of human progress and alien contact, but it is unusual in its strong story line and alien viewpoint. Although it makes one of his rare claims for human superiority, a fetish of Astounding Science Fiction editor John W. Campbell, Jr., the story’s humor, style, and forecasts are vintage Clarke. “Who was to blame?,” it opens, setting the context of a paternalistic “Galactic Federation,” sending a ship to rescue a few hundred survivors from Earth before its sun turns into a nova. With a million years between visits, the federation had been taken by surprise by humankind’s rise to civilization in two-fifths of that time, signaled by radio waves detected two hundred light years away. With little more than four hours to go, the ship arrives at a deserted planet, sends out two search parties, and barely escapes the cataclysm, burning out its “main generators” in the effort. Directing its course to the receiving point of a communications array on Earth, the mile-long spaceship, now needing rescue itself, approaches rendezvous with an unexpected fleet of ships from the planet. Unprecedented in size, this fleet of “primitive” rockets demonstrates an acceleration of human technological development so astonishing that the captain, the tentacled Alveron, whose ancient people are “Lords of the Universe,” teasingly suggests the vast federation beware of these upstarts. This “little joke” is followed by the narrator’s quiet punch line: “Twenty years afterward, the remark didn’t seem funny.” Humor of situation is evident throughout the story, from the concept of “administering” a galaxy to the discovery of the humans’ “handicap” of bipedalism from an abandoned portrait of a city alderman. The incongruity of the rescuers’ need for rescue is mirrored by the precision that allows the aliens an unflappable split-second escape but brings them there in the first place too late and with too little to do anything useful, then finds them baffled by relatively primitive communications devices and an automatic subway. Although the story creaks in places—contemporary theory says the sun cannot become a nova, vacuum tubes are outmoded, helicopters never did become the wave of the future—those details can be sacrificed for the sake of the fable. The primary forecasts of space travel and posturban civilization should not be discounted, at the risk of being as naïve and complacent as the aliens, without even their limited security in their own superiority. More commonly, Clarke sees alien technology as older and better than humans’, as in two stories in which 2001: A Space Odyssey is rooted. In “Encounter at Dawn,” ancient astronauts “in the last days of the Empire” give tools to primitives a hundred thousand years before Babylon. “The Sentinel” • Even more understated, “The Sentinel” is allegedly told by an eyewitness who begins by directing the reader to locate on the Moon the Mare Crisium (Sea of Crises), where the discovery took place. Part of a large 1996 expedition, he recalls fixing breakfast when a glint of light in the mountains caught his eye; staring through a telescope so fascinated him that he burned the sausages. From such homey touches, he led the climb to “Wilson’s Folly,” a plateau artificially leveled for a
280
Short Story Writers
twelve-foot crystal pyramid “machine.” Its force field gave way, after twenty years of frustrated investigation, to an atomic assault which reduced the mystery to fragments. The rest of the story is speculation, successive stages of Wilson’s inferences. Not a relic of lunar civilization, the artifact, half the age of Earth, was left by visitors: Wilson imagines it saying “I’m a stranger here myself.” After its destruction, he “guesses” it must have been a beacon; interrupting its signal has triggered a “fire alarm.” Lacking explicit alien intent, the pyramid emblemizes the unknown. Although such a potentially multivalent symbol invites other interpretations, Wilson’s is supported by 2001, in which a rectangular slab under the lunar surface signals after being exposed to sunlight. The final savage attack on the pyramid also seems significant to the narrator, although the pyramid might have been programmed to selfdestruct. The quasi-religious awe, tinged with fear as well as positive expectation, with which Wilson awaits the aliens’ return has echoes elsewhere in Clarke. This story, moreover, with its judgment of space travel as a first step toward an incalculable destiny, many readers see as an article of faith in a grand design of a creator god. Such a pattern may lie beneath some of his work, but Clarke has also taken pains to discourage conventional religious interpretations. “The Nine Billion Names of God” • Clarke’s work is dotted with attacks on religious or “mystical” belief and behavior, with one exception: the Scottish-born head of worldwide Buddhism in The Deep Range (1957), whose opposition to butchering whales is based partly on the conviction that aliens may judge humankind on its behavior toward its fellow creatures. Certainly the surprise ending of “The Nine Billion Names of God” is no proof of Clarke’s sharing the faith of his Tibetan lamas. Although the story attacks the complacency of Western computer technicians whose efficiency speeds up the counting of all of God’s names, the ending (“Overhead, without any fuss, the stars were going out”) is that of a joke or a ghost story. “The Star” • Rather than simply trivializing God, Clarke’s award-winning short story “The Star” makes God destructive and merciless. A Jesuit astrophysicist, slightly defensive about being both a cleric and a scientist, the narrator is at the point of quiet desperation. Beginning “It is three thousand light-years to the Vatican,” he finds no solace in the crucifix near his computer or the engraving of Loyola, whose order is not all that will end when an expedition makes public its findings. In a retrospective narration that distances the action, the narrator recounts a ship’s approach to the inappropriately named “Phoenix” Nebula, the debris of a supernova that destroyed an interplanetary civilization. Different from Wells’s story of the same name, this cataclysm did not spare a people and let them find a sense of community. From their remains in a vault on the star’s most distant planet, the crew finds evidence that this “disturbingly human” civilization was at its peak when it died. The narrator’s colleagues see no room in nature for God’s wrath or mercy, and the narrator denies his own right to judge God. He is troubled, however, by the date of the disruption; given its direction and distance, this must have been the “Star of Bethlehem,” hanging low in the East before sunrise. Explicitly rejecting keeping the information secret or tampering with the data, he is troubled in his faith because he cannot refuse (or refute) the findings of science. A masterpiece of compression, poetic in style, somber in tone, and totally devoid of action and dialogue (not even the two lines of “The Sentinel”), “The Star” does
Clarke, Arthur C.
281
not even state its conclusion. The narrator must either conclude that his colleagues are right or accept a God who would destroy this culture to impress a few humans. “A Meeting with Medusa” • Considerably at variance with these and most of Clarke’s short fiction is “A Meeting with Medusa.” Appearing four years after his retrospective collection, it is one of his longest stories not given book length, and a sharp improvement over most of his work in the 1960’s. Allusive and subtly patterned, both a character study and a tale of adventure, it continues Clarke’s interest in “first contact” and alien landscapes, but it also fictionalizes J. D. Bernal’s suggestion in The World, the Flesh, and the Devil (1929) that space exploration is the proper province of a human mind in a posthuman body. All but destroyed when a mismanaged robot camera platform sent his dirigible, the Queen Elizabeth IV, down in flames, Howard Falcon is restored to life as a cyborg, the physical form of which is not revealed until the last of eight chapters. Seven years later, stronger and more durable, he argues successfully to be sent on an expedition into the atmosphere of Jupiter. After an additional three years, the actual adventure takes place. Almost a part of the “raft,” Kon-Tiki, supported by a hot hydrogen balloon (with emergency ram-jet and rocket motors), the wingless Falcon is nevertheless at a disadvantage when it comes to making contact with native life forms. Expecting at most a kind of plankton, he comes upon creatures whose nearest Earth analogues, in miniature, are varieties of sea life. Manta rays a hundred yards across seem docile browsers of floating wax mountains until their natural enemies appear. Radio-sensitive jellyfish over a mile wide, they repel attacking mantas with electrical discharges that also function for communications. A dirigible pilot once again, Falcon has neither their maneuverability nor their familiarity with local conditions. Wryly amused at his ambassadorial role, he is understandably reluctant to obey the “Prime Directive” requiring him to avoid attacking intelligent creatures, at the cost of his own life if need be. When tentacles descend around the Kon-Tiki, he descends still lower; when the “Medusa” begins to “pat” his craft tentatively with a single tentacle, he cuts loose with his auxiliary engines. The Great Red Spot, blizzards of wax, atmospheric maelstroms, and various other features of the “world of the gods” can wait until another time. A hero who has reignited humankind’s imagination, Falcon is slipping away from identity with the human race, one now discovers, along with the reader’s first glimpse of his undercarriage, hydraulic lifts, balloon tires, and seven foot height, if not of his “leathery mask” (now seen in a different light). Like the panicky “superchimp” on the Queen Elizabeth whose face he used to see in dreams, he is “between two worlds,” the biological and the mechanical. He represents at its extreme the “cosmic loneliness” of Clarke’s heroes. Falcon is at the center of the story, although the predominant interest may be more in what he sees than in what he does. Jupiter is the “hero,” at least of the middle sections of the story, in which Clarke combines his undersea experience and astrophysical theory to draw plausible inferences about an unlikely place for “life as we know it.” Although he is not an adequate “ambassador” to the Jovians—who could be?—because he is not quite human, Falcon is the best possible explorer. A “new breed,” he is for some purposes “more than human,” although one’s bias toward the “handicap” of bipedalism may blind one to it. He is also one more piece of evidence that the “transcendence” of human limitations widespread in Clarke’s fiction may be
282
Short Story Writers
at best a mixed blessing. Suspenseful yet satiric, adventuresome yet calmly paced, “A Meeting with Medusa,” in its poetic evocation of first contact and its sophisticated variations on transcendence and the “stranded astronaut,” is a culmination of the shorter fiction that came before it. “The Hammer of God” • Several years elapsed before Clarke agreed to write another short story, “The Hammer of God,” for Time magazine’s special issue Beyond the Year 2000, published in the fall of 1992. In this tale, Clarke wryly combines paradoxes to shape his whimsical yet ironic version of efforts to deflect an asteroid’s possible collision with Earth. Clarke combines extreme religious polarities; ancient mythological deities; futuristic technological, political, and economic achievements; and a cast characterized by their opposing actions and reactions: an eccentric politician, a sentimental captain, a very logical computer, an asteroid, and religious saboteurs. Facts about two previous asteroids serve to punctuate and divide the story into three parts. The first cataclysm sixty-five million years ago brought destruction to dinosaurs, plants, and other animals. In contrast, the second, in 1972, cut through Earth’s atmosphere for two minutes, causing no damage. The third asteroid enters the solar system in 2212. Named Kali after the Hindu goddess of death and destruction, this traveler is the menace facing Captain Robert Singh, commander of the ship Goliath; his central computer, David; and his one-hundred-person team, Operation ATLAS. The captain’s team wants to move a small chunk of the asteroid into a new path away from Earth. Clarke envisions sophisticated technological and scientific advances. A neuralinput cap, the “portable Brainman,” fitting directly over a bald skull, allows the century-old Captain Singh to relive an experience from twenty years ago with his young son, Toby. The oil age ends with the advent of successful cold fusion. With lens-corrective laser shaping, eyeglasses are abolished, choices of skin coloring allow individuals to vary skin color as frequently as they change clothing, and scientific data from a radio beacon/measuring rod anchored within Kali supply David with facts to report on what the actual probability of impact would be. Logical thinking is not characteristic for the captain of the Goliath. He focuses on whether his future friendships will be on Mars or the moon and speculates about how he can arrange that all the many decades of his life will be on Mars. His mind is not on ship business. Conversely, David’s logical thoughts provide an alternative solution to the loss of hydrogen the ship experiences. With the remainder of the ship’s own propellant, originally reserved to rendezvous with Titan, Goliath itself can push Kali into a new course that will bypass Earth. Unfortunately, no one explores Kali further before accepting David’s maneuver. This asteroid has a fatal hidden feature, a weak outer crust. When Goliath pushes with all its force against Kali, it breaks through this crust and is stuck. Despite all attempts to reverse and pull free, the effort is useless. Using the remainder of its fuel, the ship makes one final push on Kali, strong enough to slightly alter the asteroid’s path and to permanently lock them into the asteroid’s surface. Contrary to the ancient Hindu goddess Kali’s almost endless blood sacrifices, this Kali’s destructive sacrifices as she cuts through Earth’s atmosphere for two minutes are trivial—only the ship’s crew, ten thousand lives, and one trillion dollars in damages. With skilled understatement, numerous paradoxes, and wry humor, Clarke again demonstrates in “The Hammer of God” his ability to craft an entertaining tale about Earth’s potential
Clarke, Arthur C.
283
collision with a stray asteroid from outer space. As a poet of the infinite, whose fables judge humanity from an “alien” point of view, Clarke stands alone. David N. Samuelson With updates by Terry Theodore and the Editors Other major works children’s literature: Islands in the Sky, 1952; Dolphin Island, 1963. novels: Prelude to Space, 1951; The Sands of Mars, 1951; Against the Fall of Night, 1953 (revised as The City and the Stars, 1956); Childhood’s End, 1953; Earthlight, 1955; The Deep Range, 1957; Across the Sea of Stars, 1959; A Fall of Moondust, 1961; From the Ocean, from the Stars, 1962; Glide Path, 1963; Prelude to Mars, 1965; “The Lion of Comarre,” and “Against the Fall of Night,” 1968; 2001: A Space Odyssey, 1968; Rendezvous with Rama, 1973; Imperial Earth, 1975; The Fountains of Paradise, 1979; 2010: Odyssey Two, 1982; The Songs of Distant Earth, 1986; 2061: Odyssey Three, 1987; Cradle, 1988 (with Gentry Lee); Rama II, 1989 (with Lee); Beyond the Fall of Night, 1990 (with Gregory Benford); The Ghost from the Grand Banks, 1990; The Garden of Rama, 1991 (with Lee); Rama Revealed, 1993 (with Lee); The Hammer of God, 1993; Richter 10, 1996 (with Mike McQuay); 3001: The Final Odyssey, 1997; The Trigger, 1999 (with Michael Kube-McDowell); The Light of Other Days, 2000 (with Stephen Baxter); Time’s Eye, 2004 (with Baxter); Sunstorm, 2005 (with Baxter). nonfiction: Interplanetary Flight, 1950; The Exploration of Space, 1951 (revised, 1959); Going into Space, 1954; The Exploration of the Moon, 1954; The Coast of Coral, 1956; The Making of a Moon, 1957; The Reefs of Taprobane, 1957; Voice Across the Sea, 1958; The Challenge of the Spaceship, 1959; The Challenge of the Sea, 1960; The First Five Fathoms, 1960; Indian Ocean Adventure, 1961 (with Mike Wilson); Profiles of the Future, 1962; Indian Ocean Treasure, 1964 (with Wilson); Man and Space, 1964 (with others); The Treasure of the Great Reef, 1964; Voices from the Sky, 1965; The Promise of Space, 1968; First on the Moon, 1970 (with others); Into Space, 1971 (with Robert Silverberg); Beyond Jupiter, 1972 (with Chesley Bonestall); Report on Planet Three, 1972; The Lost Worlds of 2001, 1972; The View from Serendip, 1977 (autobiographical); 1984: Spring, a Choice of Futures, 1984; The Odyssey File, 1985 (with Peter Hyams); Arthur C. Clarke’s July 20, 2019: Life in the Twenty-first Century, 1986; Astounding Days: A Science Fictional Autobiography, 1989; How the World Was One: Beyond the Global Village, 1992; By Space Possessed, 1993; The Snows of Olympus: A Garden on Mars, 1994; Greetings, Carbon-Based Bipeds! Collected Essays, 1934-1998, 1999; From Narnia to a Space Odyssey: The War of Ideas Between Arthur C. Clarke and C. S. Lewis, 2003 (Ryder W. Miller, editor). poetry: The Fantastic Muse, 1992. Bibliography Clarke, Arthur C. Astounding Days: A Science-Fictional Autobiography. New York: Bantam Books, 1989. Although this volume is not really an autobiography, Clarke offers a brief memoir of his youth. He explains how writers and editors of Astounding magazine (later named Analog) first aroused his interest in science fiction and discusses his work on rocketry and radar. ____________. “An Odyssey of Sorts.” Interview by Frederick V. Guterl. Discover 18 (May, 1997): 68-69. In this interview, Clarke discusses, among other subjects, the cold-fusion energy revolution and the evidence for life on Mars.
284
Short Story Writers
Dauer, Susan Jaye “The Star.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 7. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Analysis of “The Star” with sections on themes and meaning and style and technique. Also includes a detailed synopsis of the story. McAleer, Neil. Arthur C. Clarke: The Authorized Biography. Chicago: Contemporary Books, 1992. Definitive account of Clarke’s career, written with Clarke’s cooperation. Meisenheimer, Donald K., Jr. “Machining the Man: From Neurasthenia to Psychasthenia in SF and the Genre Western.” Science-Fiction Studies 24 (November, 1997): 441-458. Argues that although Clarke works within the tradition of Wellsian science fiction, he also makes heavy use of the genre-Western established by Owen Wister and Frederic Remington. Olander, Joseph D., and Martin Harry Greenberg, eds. Arthur C. Clarke. New York: Taplinger, 1977. This collection of nine essays on Clarke examines his individual works and his science-fiction writings in general. The editors state that Clarke is a hard science-fiction author whose commitment is to the universe. Provides a good source of textual criticism. Supplemented by a select bibliography and a biographical note. Rabkin, Eric S. Arthur C. Clarke. San Bernardino, Calif.: Borgo Press, 1980. Good short introduction to Clarke’s important science-fiction work, with brief descriptions. Robkin has high praise for Clarke and considers him one of the best in the science-fiction genre. Complemented by a bio-critical introduction, an annotated bibliography, and a chronology. Reid, Robin Anne. Arthur C. Clarke. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1997. General introduction to Clarke’s life and work, with a chapter on each of his nine novels. Slusser, George Edgar. The Space Odysseys of Arthur C. Clarke. San Bernardino, Calif.: Borgo Press, 1978. Brief but provocative commentary on Clarke’s fiction. Virginia, Mary E. “The Sentinel.” In Masterplots II: Short Story Series, edited by Charles E. May. Rev. ed. Vol. 6. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Student-friendly analysis of “The Sentinel” that covers the story’s themes and style and includes a detailed synopsis.
285
Joseph Conrad Born: Near Berdyczów, Podolia, Poland (now Berdychiv, Ukraine); December 3, 1857 Died: Oswalds, Bishopsbourne, England; August 3, 1924 Principal short fiction • Tales of Unrest, 1898; Youth: A Narrative, and Two Other Stories, 1902; Typhoon, and Other Stories, 1903; A Set of Six, 1908; ’Twixt Land and Sea, Tales, 1912; Within the Tides, 1915; Tales of Hearsay, 1925; The Sisters, 1928; The Complete Short Stories of Joseph Conrad, 1933. Other literary forms • Joseph Conrad is best known for his powerful and psychologically penetrating novels, which, like his shorter fiction, are often set in exotic locales, frequently the Far East, at sea, or a combination of the two, as with his most famous novel, Lord Jim: A Tale (1900). Even when using a more conventional setting, such as London in The Secret Agent: A Simple Tale (1907), or Geneva, Switzerland, in Under Western Eyes (1911), Conrad maintains a sense of otherness because his characters live in a moral shadow world of revolutionaries and adventures. In addition to three plays based on his stories, Conrad produced three volumes of autobiographical writings, which, however, often conceal more than they explain about his varied and often dramatic personal life. Following his death, several edited collections of Conrad’s correspondence were published, and these letters offer some insight into his fiction. Achievements • Joseph Conrad is one of the outstanding writers in English literature and, because of his background and achievements, occupies a unique position. To a great degree, Conrad was the creator of the psychological story and modern spy novel. Because of his genius and insight, Conrad transformed the typical setting of the adventure romance—the mysterious Far East, the shadowy underworld of the secret agent—into an acceptable setting for the serious writer and greatly expanded the range of English literature. Conrad avoided direct narrative, presenting his plots as a tale told by someone who either recounted the events from memory or passed along a story heard from someone else. The narrator in a Conrad story also gives events obliquely, partially revealing them, speculating on their cause and possible meaning, and then adding new and often essential information, so that the reader must participate in interpreting the unfolding story. Conrad used this method because he believed that it accurately reflected the manner in which people understand actions in real life but also employed it because of his characters, who cannot be understood quickly, for they are not simple persons. Complicated and often contradictory figures, their actions, like their personalities, must be apprehended gradually and from different angles. A writer who did not learn English until his twenties, Conrad brought a sense of newness and scrupulous care to the language. He uses an extensive vocabulary, particularly in his descriptive passages of settings, internal as well as external. His style produces in the reader the moral and psychological equivalent to the emotions and inner
286
Short Story Writers struggles felt by the characters. These qualities of plot, character, and style were recognized by the noted American critic H. L. Mencken when he wrote about Conrad that “[t]here was something almost suggesting the vastness of a natural phenomenon. He transcended all the rules.”
Biography • Joseph Conrad had one of the most unusual lives of any major writer in English literature. He was born in Berdyczów, Poland, on December 3, 1857, and was christened Jósef Teodor Konrad Nat-cz Korzeniowski. His father, Apollo Korzeniowski, was a Polish intellectual and writer whose works included original verse and translations of William Shakespeare. Apollo Korzeniowski was also a fervent Polish patriot, and his activities against Russian repression (Poland was at that time part of the Russian EmLibrary of Congress pire) caused his arrest and exile in 1861. Apollo Korzeniowski, along with his wife, Ewelina Bobrowska, and his young son, Jósef, was sent to Vologda, a dismal town northeast of Moscow. The climate was severe, and living conditions were harsh. Ewelina died in April, 1865, when young Jósef was only seven years old. A few years later, after Apollo had been released from exile because of ill health, he too died, and at the age of eleven, Jósef was placed in the care of his maternal uncle, a kindly man who provided for his education and supported him with funds for many years. Because of these memories and his own intense patriotism, Jósef found life in occupied Poland unbearable, and, when doctors recommended a seaside environment for his own frail health, he left for Marseilles, France, in October, 1874. In Marseilles, he lived on funds from his uncle and engaged in a shadowy enterprise to smuggle weapons to royalist rebels in Spain. In 1877, Jósef and some companions bought a ship for that purpose, but their plot was betrayed, and their vessel, the Tremolino, was deliberately run aground to avoid capture. In the spring of the following year, having lost all of his money gambling at Monte Carlo, Jósef attempted suicide. The wound was minor, and within a month he was able to sign aboard his first English ship, the Mavis. On April 24, 1878, Jósef Korzeniowski, soon known as Joseph Conrad, became an English sailor; he would remain one for the next seventeen years, serving on eighteen different vessels but commanding only one, the Otago, in 1888. During his voyages, Conrad traveled to the settings for his stories. In 1883, he was second mate onboard the Palestine, which caught fire and later sank, leaving the crew
Conrad, Joseph
287
to survive in open boats until they reached land. In 1890, Conrad was in the Belgian Congo as part of a trading company, but within a year he left, his health seriously weakened by malaria and his psychological and moral sense severely shaken by the ruthless, amoral exploitation of the natives by Europeans who were avid for ivory. By this time, Conrad had concluded that his seafaring career was unsuccessful, and he had already started work, in 1889, on his first novel, Almayer’s Folly (1895), and achieved English citizenship in 1886. In January, 1894, Conrad ended his naval career, determined to become a writer. Almayer’s Folly gained favorable critical notice, primarily for its exotic setting and characters. Conrad’s next work, An Outcast of the Islands (1896), seemed to mark him as a talented but perhaps limited author of exotic romances. With the appearance of The Nigger of the “Narcissus” (1898), however, the literary world was forced to take note of a new and strikingly original talent. Having dedicated himself to writing, Conrad settled at Pent Farm, in Kent, with his wife, Jessie George, whom he married on March 24, 1896. The Conrads had two sons, Alfred Borys, born in 1898, and John Alexander, born in 1906. As an author, Conrad was critically acknowledged but was not very popular for many years. Even such powerful novels as Lord Jim: A Tale or Nostromo: A Tale of the Seaboard (1904) or Under Western Eyes, which have since been recognized as classics, had relatively modest sales. To supplement his income, Conrad wrote shorter fiction for popular magazines; these stories were collected in eight volumes during Conrad’s lifetime. In 1913 came his first truly popular work, Chance. Having achieved financial stability, Conrad moved in 1919 to Oswalds, near Canterbury, where he spent the remaining years of his life. He was offered, but declined, a knighthood in 1924. That same year, after long bouts of frequent bad health, he died of a heart attack on August 3. He was buried at Canterbury. Analysis • Throughout his career, Joseph Conrad returned to a constellation of central themes that were expressed through the actions of his characters and, more important, through those characters’ reactions to events around them. These themes can best be considered when they are grouped into two generally opposing categories. A sense of personal, moral heroism and honor is contrasted to betrayal and guilt. Typically, a Conradian character will discover, in the crucible of a dangerous situation, that he does or does not live up to the inner standards he has hoped to maintain. This realization may not come immediately, and often the true meanings of a character’s actions are revealed only long afterward, through a retelling of his story. The second grouping contrasts illusion with reality. Illusion is often a belief in “progress” or some grand political scheme. It is unmasked by reality, which, in Conrad, almost inevitably assumes the form and tone of pessimistic irony. Through the device of a narrator recounting the story, the truth gradually emerges, revealing the tragic difference between what characters believe themselves and the world to be, and what they actually are. “An Outpost of Progress” • The division between these two groupings is present even in Conrad’s early story “An Outpost of Progress.” Like many of his fictions, it is set in the tropics, specifically a desolate ivory trading station in the isolated reaches of the Congo. Two hapless Europeans, Kayerts and Carlier, arrive at the station, filled with dreams of riches and slogans of civilization. They quickly disintegrate, their original illusions giving way to true madness. Kayerts shoots his companion, then hangs himself from a cross in the station’s unkempt graveyard. The out-
288
Short Story Writers
post of progress has been overrun by the forces of savagery. The story is fiercely ironic. Kayerts and Carlier are caricatures, the first fat, the second thin, both incredibly stupid. “Incapable of independent thought,” as Conrad describes them, they are lost without society to dictate their thoughts and actions. Although they loudly repeat the hollow slogans of progress, the two white men are obviously greatly inferior to their native helper, who watches their decay with dark satisfaction. Using simple, unsympathetic characters and a violent, even melodramatic plot, Conrad presents his themes in the starkest possible fashion. “The Lagoon” • In the story “The Lagoon,” written at almost the same time as “An Outpost of Progress,” Conrad handles the conflict between betrayal and guilt, on one hand, and guilt versus honor and heroism, on the other, with more subtlety. An unnamed white man spends the night in the house of Arsat, a young Malay, who is tending his dying wife. During the long tropical night, Arsat tells his friend the story of how he and his brother had fled with the woman from their local chief. The three had been pursued and, at the moment of their escape, Arsat’s brother had fallen behind and cried out for help. Arsat had not responded, however, fleeing instead to safety with his lover. Now, when she is dead, he speaks of returning for revenge. In a moment of crisis Arsat made a decision, and for years he has suffered the moral consequences of that action. Although Conrad refrains from judging his character, Arsat clearly believes that he has failed; his only hope is to perform some heroic action, such as seeking vengeance, that will restore his earlier sense of himself as an honorable, loyal person and brother. Implicit in the story, however, is the sense that Arsat cannot undo the past and that his hopes are only illusions. This sense is reinforced powerfully by Conrad’s extensive descriptions of the Malaysian jungle, which seems to overwhelm the characters, rendering them incapable of action while mocking their vain hopes. “Youth” • “Youth,” Conrad’s first indisputable masterpiece among his shorter fictions, introduces his famous narrator Marlow. In the story, Marlow, forty-two when he tells his tale, recounts events that happened twenty years before when he sailed on the Judea, laden with a cargo of coal for Bangkok. An ill-fated ship, the Judea is beset by an endless, almost comical series of calamities that climaxes when the coal catches fire and explodes, leaving the crew to reach land in open boats. The events are drawn largely from Conrad’s own experiences as mate on the Palestine in 1881. The contrasts between heroism and cowardice, between reality and illusion run throughout the story, but Conrad blends them in a fashion that reveals that the distinctions between them are not as simple as might be supposed. As Marlow recognizes, his earlier self was full of the illusions of youth, yet it was those very illusions that sustained him and allowed him to achieve the standards by which he wished to live and act. In that sense, illusion made heroism possible. Such a situation is obviously ironic, and throughout his story Marlow comments frequently on the tangled relationship between romanticism and practicality, illusion and reality. Unlike other Conrad tales, however, “Youth” does not treat this division with pessimism but with optimism, no doubt because it is a story of youth and because Marlow, for whatever reason, did uphold his personal standards of integrity and moral courage. Heart of Darkness • Heart of Darkness, perhaps Conrad’s most famous work, is a novella based on his experience as mate on the riverboat Roi des Belges in the Congo dur-
Conrad, Joseph
289
ing 1890. In this story, Conrad once again uses Marlow as his main character and narrator, and the events are a literal and symbolic journey by Marlow into that “immense heart of darkness” that is both the African jungle and the human soul. A powerful, searing work, Heart of Darkness is one of the first masterpieces of symbolism in English literature and Conrad’s most acutely penetrating psychological study. The story itself is relatively simple. Marlow signs on with a Belgian company that exports ivory from the Congo; employed as a mate on the company’s steamboat, he sails upriver to meet the renowned Kurtz, a trader who has become legendary for the success of his efforts and the force of his character. Marlow has heard, however, that Kurtz is more than an ivory trader and that he has evolved into a powerful force of civilization and progress. When Marlow arrives at Kurtz’s station, he finds instead that the man has reverted to savagery, becoming a dreaded, almost supernatural figure to the natives. The site is ringed with posts decorated with human skulls, and Kurtz’s presence casts an evil shadow over the African jungle. Marlow carries the sick, delirious Kurtz back down the river, but the man dies during the journey as the riverboat narrowly escapes an ambush by the terrified and outraged natives. The impact of Heart of Darkness comes from the nearly devastating effects of what Marlow sees and experiences. A naïve young man in the earlier “Youth,” Marlow is still relatively innocent at the start of Heart of Darkness. By the end of the story, that innocence has been forever shattered, a loss shared by the attentive reader. The world of the story grows increasingly corrupted and corrupting. The adventures Marlow undergoes become stranger, and the characters whom he meets are increasingly odd, starting with the greedy traders whom Marlow ironically describes as “pilgrims,” to an eccentric Russian who wanders in dress clothes through the jungle, to Kurtz himself, that figure of ultimate madness. The native Africans, whether cruelly abused workers, actually slaves, of the trading company or savages in awe of Kurtz, retain a sort of primeval dignity, but they, too, are beyond Marlow’s experience and initial comprehension. The Congo of Heart of Darkness is a strange and terrifying world, a place where the normal order of civilized life has become not only inverted but also perverted. To render this complex and disturbing moral vision, Conrad uses an intricate framing structure for his narrative. The story opens with Marlow and four friends talking about their experiences. One of the listeners, who is never named, in turn conveys to the reader the story told by Marlow. This story-within-a-story shuttles back and forth, as Marlow recounts part of his tale, then comments upon it, and then often makes an additional reflection upon his own observations. In a sense, by retelling the events, Marlow comes to understand them, a process that is shared by the reader. Instead of interrupting the flow of the story, Marlow’s remarks become an essential part of the plot, and often the reader does not fully understand what has happened until Marlow’s explanations reveal the extent and significance of the action. Heart of Darkness gains immensely through Conrad’s use of symbolism, because much of the meaning of the story is too terrifying and bleak to be expressed in plain prose; the inhumanity and savagery of the European exploiters, Kurtz in particular, are expressed more powerfully through a symbolic, rather than overt, presentation. Throughout the narrative, clusters of images occur at significant points to underscore the meaning of events as Marlow comes to understand them. Opposites are frequent: Brightness is contrasted with gloom, the lush growth of the jungle is juxtaposed to the sterility of the white traders, and the luxuriant, even alarming life of the wild is always connected with death and decomposition. Running throughout the
290
Short Story Writers
story are images and metaphors of madness, especially the insanity caused by isolation. The dominant symbol for the entire work is found in its title and final words: All creation is a vast “heart of darkness.” Since its publication, Heart of Darkness has been recognized as a masterpiece of English literature, and readers have responded to the work on several different levels. An attack on imperialism, a parable of moral and ethical growth and decline, a psychological study—Heart of Darkness is all these things and something more. “Typhoon” • With the writing of “Typhoon,” Conrad suspended his customary moral and psychological complexities to present a fairly straightforward sea story. The Nan-Shan, a vessel filled with Chinese workers returning home from Malaysia, runs headlong into a ferocious typhoon. As the crew struggles above decks to save the ship, an equally dangerous furor erupts below, as the sea’s violent motions scatter the passengers’ baggage, mixing their hard-earned silver coins in total confusion. The Chinese begin a desperate combat among themselves, each man intent upon regaining his own money. Captain MacWhirr and his first mate, Jukes, must battle these two storms, either of which could wreck the ship. Captain MacWhirr and Jukes are total opposites. MacWhirr is a stolid, perhaps stupid man, so devoid of imagination that he experiences little self-doubt and few terrors. Even the looming typhoon does not frighten him, since he has never experienced such a storm and cannot comprehend its dangers. Jukes, on the other hand, is a more typical Conradian character, sensitive, anxious to prove worthy of his own inner moral code, and acutely conscious of the dangers that the sea can pose. As with so many other figures in Conrad’s fictions, Jukes seems to believe in a sense that these dangers are somehow meant for him personally, as a trial of his own character. MacWhirr suffers from no such beliefs, since they are beyond his comprehension. With the onset of the typhoon, the seeming limitations of Captain MacWhirr become strengths, while Jukes’s supposedly higher qualities might, if left unchecked, paralyze him at the critical moment. Ironically, MacWhirr is Jukes’s salvation. Since the Captain lacks the imagination to realize that he should be afraid, he is therefore not afraid and continues in his plodding but effective fashion. Jukes, in order to live up to his moral code, has no choice but to follow, acting more bravely and coolly than his inner doubts might otherwise allow. Together, the two men lead the crew in heroic efforts that save the Nan-Shan. The only complexity that Conrad employs in “Typhoon” is in his narrative structure. The story shifts from third person to passages of letters from Captain MacWhirr, Jukes, and the ship’s engineer to their families. This second layer is overlain by a third, in which the letters are read, sometimes with commentary, by the families in England. Through this method, Conrad allows the major characters to present the story as they experience and perceive it and adds a further contrast between the men who actually endure the storm and those who only read about it, and so cannot fully grasp its strength and danger. “The Duel” • “The Duel,” sometimes titled “The Duellists,” is the story of two officers in Napoleon Bonaparte’s army, who wage their own private war for sixteen years, while about them all Europe is plunged into a larger, much more deadly combat. Conrad was an avid student of the Napoleonic period, and he based his story on an actual rivalry. More than the story of two men, “The Duel” is Conrad’s reflections upon the Napoleonic age.
Conrad, Joseph
291
The two progatonists are Feraud from Gascony in southern France—a region noted for its hot-blooded, impetuous natives—and D’Hubert, a Picard, with the reserved nature characteristic of that northern region. Through an accidental incident, the two become engaged in an affair of honor that can be settled only by a duel. Once begun, the duel is protracted to farcical lengths, extending from Paris to Moscow, from the time of Napoleon’s greatest triumphs to his final defeat at Waterloo. Finally, D’Hubert falls in love and marries, finding life more worthwhile than this questionable affair of honor. In the final encounter, he emerges victorious and spares Feraud’s life on the promise that the combat will now, finally, end. The tale is briskly and even comically rendered, with Conrad’s typical ironies in this case turned positive. The darker aspects of his vision are reserved for his wider view of the Napoleonic age: What might be seen as humorous when only two men are involved becomes tragic almost beyond comprehension when entire nations are the duelists. Feraud and D’Hubert fight only each other in their affair, while Napoleon engaged all the countries of Europe. At the end of that wider struggle, Conrad implies, there was no happy resolution, only the desolation that follows the exhausted silence of the battlefield. This bleaker vision, however, is not allowed to overwhelm the essentially humorous basis of the story. The title of the work may contain a clue to one of its themes, the typical Conrad subject of the “double,” the other person who is so like the hero yet somehow different. During the interminable encounters, D’Hubert comes to believe that he is linked, in some mysterious and unbreakable fashion, to Feraud. They are “secret sharers,” in one sense literally so, because they cannot reveal that their duel began over a trivial misunderstanding and was prolonged out of fear of embarrassment. They are also “secret sharers” in a wider sense, because their lives have fullest meaning only when joined together. In this way, the “duellists” are indeed “dual,” and their relationship is not only one of combat but also, in fact, one of union. “Gaspar Ruiz” • “Gaspar Ruiz” was based upon actual events in the Chilean revolution against Spain of the 1830’s. The title character, an immensely strong but rather simpleminded peasant, joins the army of the rebels. Captured during battle, he is forced to join the Loyalist army and is then once again made a prisoner, this time by his former comrades. Condemned as a traitor, Gaspar Ruiz escapes and is sheltered by a Loyalist family whose daughter, Erminia, he later marries. A series of misadventures leads Gaspar to become a general in the Loyalist army, although his political sense is almost nonexistent and he wishes, as much as he can comprehend the matter, to be a Chilean patriot. When Erminia and her daughter are captured by the rebels and held in a mountain fort, Gaspar has a cannon strapped to his huge back so it can batter open the gate and free them. The desperate tactic works, but Gaspar is mortally wounded, and Erminia kills herself, dying with her husband. The story is told in typical Conrad fashion—that is, long after the events have occurred and by two different narrators. One of them is General Santierra, who, as a lieutenant in the rebel army, knew Gaspar Ruiz and is now the guardian of Gaspar’s grown daughter. The second narrator, who opens the story in the third person but who is revealed, at the close, to be a guest of General Santierra, answers questions that Santierra raises. This narrator explains that revolutions are a distillation of human experience and that they bring some human beings to fame who otherwise would be resigned to oblivion. In revolutions, genuine social ideals, such as freedom or equality, may be passionately held in the abstract but are ferociously violated in ac-
292
Short Story Writers
tuality, just as Gaspar Ruiz, a true if bewildered patriot, was condemned and made a traitor by circumstances and false accusations. In a sense, the unnamed guest is reinforcing a constant Conrad theme, the difference between reality and illusion. “The Secret Sharer” • Probably Conrad’s most famous short story, “The Secret Sharer” is a deceptively simple tale that carries such deep, perhaps unfathomable moral and psychological undertones that since its publication readers and critics have remained puzzled and fascinated by its elusive, evocative power. In the story, a young captain, new to his first command, is startled to discover a naked man swimming by his ship’s side. Once aboard, the swimmer, named Leggatt, confesses that he is fleeing from his own ship, the Sephora, because he murdered a fellow sailor. The act was justified, as the young captain quickly realizes, for the Sephora was in danger of foundering during a violent storm, and the murdered man, by failing to obey Leggatt’s orders, had placed the ship and its crew in immediate danger. Now, however, Leggatt is a hunted man. The captain hides Leggatt in his own cabin, keeping him safely out of sight until he can sail his ship close enough to an island to allow Leggatt to escape. By pledging and then keeping his word to the mysterious Leggatt, the young captain upholds his own moral code, even though it runs counter to conventional law and morality. In doing so, he proves that he is capable of living up to that “ideal conception of one’s personality every man sets up for himself secretly.” The fact that morality is established and maintained secretly—in this case, literally so—is a Conradian irony and a central paradox of this tale. Adding to the reader’s bewilderment is the fact that the young captain’s “ideal conception” is nowhere presented explicitly. The reader is able to see the captain’s code in action and perhaps assess its consequences but must deduce from these tantalizing clues what must constitute the standards that the young officer so earnestly desires to uphold. The captain’s code is indeed a puzzling one, for not only does it require him to be faithful to a murderer, but also it causes him to risk his own ship. To give Leggatt the best possible chance to swim to safety, the captain steers dangerously close to shore, risking running aground or perhaps breaking up on the shoals. Naturally, he cannot tell his crew why he orders this difficult, dangerous maneuver, so another secret is layered upon those already present. When the captain is successful in his plan, for the first time he feels a sense of unity and closeness with his vessel, a mystical—and again, secret—bond. The meanings of “The Secret Sharer” are hidden in its deceptively straightforward narrative. The work is full of ambiguity and possible double meanings, all presented in brisk, even prosaic fashion. Even the title is multiple: Since Leggatt is unknown to anyone but the captain, his presence is indeed a secret, but he and the young commander also share common secrets, both Leggatt’s presence and the “ideal conception of one’s personality,” which seems to be their joint moral code. Since these meanings are complementary, rather than contradictory, they add to the resonance of the story. Other touches add to the story’s depth. The young captain and Leggatt are so similar that they seem to be doubles, and Conrad obviously intends this identification to be as much moral as physical. Both men feel themselves to be outcasts, Leggatt actually so, because of his crime; the captain, psychologically, because of his newness to the ship and its crew. In one sense, Leggatt can be seen as an alter ego of the narrator, perhaps even a projection of his darker, maybe criminal, side. It may even be possi-
Conrad, Joseph
293
ble, as some critics have suggested, that Leggatt does not actually exist but is only a figment of the young captain’s imagination. Such an unusual, even implausible interpretation indicates the perplexity that “The Secret Sharer” elicits in readers and underscores why this story, so famous in itself, is also emblematic of all Conrad’s fiction. Under the guise of a simple sea tale, he has gathered the themes that constantly flowed through his works: the ideal sense of self that must be tested and proved under difficult situations; the conflict between loyalty and betrayal, reality and illusion; and, above all, the innate need for human beings to preserve, even in trying circumstances and against conventional pressures, a moral code whose only reward is a secret that may, perhaps, never be shared. Michael Witkoski Other major works plays: One Day More: A Play in One Act, pr. 1905; The Secret Agent: A Drama in Four Acts, pb. 1921; Laughing Anne: A Play, pb. 1923. novels: Almayer’s Folly, 1895; An Outcast of the Islands, 1896; The Children of the Sea: A Tale of the Forecastle, 1897 (republished as The Nigger of the “Narcissus”: A Tale of the Sea, 1898); Heart of Darkness, 1899 (serial), 1902 (book); Lord Jim, 1900; The Inheritors, 1901 (with Ford Madox Ford); Romance, 1903 (with Ford); Nostromo, 1904; The Secret Agent, 1907; The Nature of a Crime, 1909 (serial), 1924 (book; with Ford); Under Western Eyes, 1911; Chance, 1913; Victory, 1915; The Shadow-Line, 1917; The Arrow of Gold, 1919; The Rescue, 1920; The Rover, 1923; Suspense, 1925 (incomplete). nonfiction: The Mirror of the Sea, 1906; Some Reminiscences, 1912 (pb. in U.S. as A Personal Record); Notes on Life and Letters, 1921; Joseph Conrad’s Diary of His Journey Up the Valley of the Congo in 1890, 1926; Last Essays, 1926; Joseph Conrad: Life and Letters, 1927 (Gérard Jean-Aubry, editor); Joseph Conrad’s Letters to His Wife, 1927; Conrad to a Friend, 1928 (Richard Curle, editor); Letters from Joseph Conrad, 1895-1924, 1928 (Edward Garnett, editor); Lettres françaises de Joseph Conrad, 1929 (Jean-Aubry, editor); Letters of Joseph Conrad to Marguerite Doradowska, 1940 (John A. Gee and Paul J. Sturm, editors); The Collected Letters of Joseph Conrad, 1983-2005 (7 volumes; Frederick R. Karl and Laurence Davies, editors). Bibliography Billy, Ted. A Wilderness of Words: Closure and Disclosure in Conrad’s Short Fiction. Lubbock: Texas Tech University Press, 1997. In this study of Conrad’s linguistic skepticism, Billy emphasizes endings in Conrad’s short fiction and how they either harmonize or clash with other narrative elements in nineteen of Conrad’s short novels and tales. Argues that Conrad presents knowledge of the world as fundamentally illusory. Graver, Lawrence. Conrad’s Short Fiction. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1969. This study of Conrad’s stories is grouped chronologically and displays the linkages between the shorter fictions and individual stories, and between them as a group and the novels. Since it covers the lesser-known stories as well as the more famous ones, it is essential for placing Conrad’s development of themes and styles within a larger artistic context. Karl, Frederick R. Joseph Conrad: The Three Lives. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1979. This book is, and will remain, the definitive Conrad biography, elucidating as it does Conrad’s life in Poland, on the seas, and in England. The well-
294
Short Story Writers
documented study is also replete with generously thorough analyses of Conrad’s major works, as well as of his artistic development and political orientation. Karl tends at times to be stiltedly (and quite needlessly) insistent upon where and how his views differ from those of other interpreters of Conrad’s life and work. ____________. A Reader’s Guide to Joseph Conrad. Rev. ed. Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press, 1997. Good handbook for students. Provides bibliographical references and an index. Lewis, Pericles. “‘His Sympathies Were in the Right Place’: Heart of Darkness and the Discourse of National Character.” Nineteenth-Century Literature 53 (September, 1998): 211-244. Shows how Conrad contributed to modernist literary technique by structuring conflict between the “ethical” and the “sociological” in Marlow’s decision to align himself with Kurtz over the Company. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Conrad: “Amy Foster” (vol. 1), “Il Conde” and “The Lagoon” (vol. 4), “An Outpost of Progress” and “The Secret Sharer” (vol. 6), “The Tale” (vol. 7), and “Typhoon” and “Youth” (vol. 8). Meyers, Jeffrey. Joseph Conrad: A Bibliography. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1991. Briskly moving, no-nonsense biography that surveys the key points and themes of the major works. Very good at placing Conrad within the social and intellectual milieu of his day and offering good insights from other literary figures, such as Ford Madox Ford, who significantly influenced Conrad’s literary career. Najder, Zdzislaw. Joseph Conrad: A Chronicle. Translated by Halina Carroll-Najder. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1983. Thorough and sympathetic biography of Conrad written by a countryman. The volume stresses the influence of Conrad’s Polish heritage on his personality and art. Najder draws many telling and intriguing parallels between Conrad’s life and his writing. Orr, Leonard, and Ted Billy, eds. A Joseph Conrad Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1999. Good manual, complete with bibliographical references and an index. Stape, J. H. The Cambridge Companion to Joseph Conrad. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1996. In this collection of essays on most of Conrad’s major work by different critics, the most helpful for a study of his short fiction are the essays “Conradian Narrative” by Jakob Lothe, which surveys Conrad’s narrative techniques and conventions, and “The Short Fiction” by Gail Fraser, which discusses Conrad’s experimentation with short narrative. Swisher, Clarice, ed. Readings on Joseph Conrad. San Diego, Calif.: Greenhaven Press, 1998. Contains essays by J. B. Priestley, Robert Penn Warren, and Richard Adams about many of Conrad’s works.
295
Robert Coover Born: Charles City, Iowa; February 4, 1932 Principal short fiction • Pricksongs and Descants, 1969; The Water Pourer, 1972 (a deleted chapter from The Origin of the Brunists); Charlie in the House of Rue, 1980; The Convention, 1981; In Bed One Night and Other Brief Encounters, 1983; Aesop’s Forest, 1986; A Night at the Movies: Or, You Must Remember This, 1987; The Grand Hotels (of Joseph Cornell), 2002 (vignettes); A Child Again, 2005. Other literary forms • Besides the above-mentioned collections of short fiction and novellas and many uncollected short stories, Robert Coover’s production includes the novels The Origin of the Brunists (1966), The Universal Baseball Association, Inc., J. Henry Waugh, Prop. (1968), The Public Burning (1977), Gerald’s Party (1985), Pinocchio in Venice (1991), John’s Wife (1996), Ghost Town (1998), and The Adventures of Lucky Pierre: Directors’ Cut (2002); a collection of plays entitled A Theological Position (1972), which contains The Kid, Love Scene, Rip Awake, and the title play; the screenplay After Lazarus (1980); a play, Bridge Hound (1981); several poems, reviews, and translations published in journals; a screenplay/novella Hair o’ the Chine ; the film On a Confrontation in Iowa City (1969); and theater adaptations of “The Babysitter” and Spanking the Maid. Coover has also published a few essays on authors he admires, such as Samuel Beckett (“The Last Quixote,” in New American Review, 1970) and Gabriel García Márquez (“The Master’s Voice,” in New American Review, 1977). Achievements • Robert Coover is one of the authors regularly mentioned in relation to that slippery term “postmodernism.” As a result of the iconoclastic and experimental nature of his fiction, Coover’s work does not enjoy a widespread audience; his reputation among academics, however, is well established, and the reviews of his works have been consistently positive. Although in the beginning of his career he had to resort to teaching in order to support his family, he soon began to gain recognition, receiving several prizes and fellowships: a William Faulkner Award for Best First Novel (1966), a Rockefeller Foundation grant (1969), two John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowships (1971, 1974), an Academy of Arts and Letters award (1975), a National Book Award nomination for The Public Burning, a National Endowment for the Humanities Award (1985), a Rea Award (1987) for A Night at the Movies, a Rhode Island Governor’s Arts Award (1988), and Deutscher Akademischer Austauschdienst Fellowship (1990). The publisher Alfred A. Knopf’s rejection of The Public Burning after initial acceptance brought some fame to Coover. Since the novel deals with the trials of Ethel and Julius Rosenberg and presents former president Richard M. Nixon as its central narrator, the publisher thought it would be too controversial. Eventually, The Public Burning was published by Viking Press and became a Book-of-the-Month Club selection. Critical studies about Coover started in the late 1970’s. Still, in spite of the critical acclaim and the considerable amount of scholarship about his work, Coover’s work remains relatively unknown to the public, and some of his early novels are now out of print.
296
Short Story Writers
Biography • Robert Lowell Coover was born in Charles City, Iowa. His family soon moved to Indiana and then to Herrin, Illinois. His father managed the local newspaper, the Herrin Daily Journal, which prompted Coover’s interest in journalism. His college education began at Southern Illinois University (1949-1951), but he transferred to Indiana University, where he received a bachelor’s degree in Slavic studies in 1953. After graduation, Coover was drafted and joined the United States Naval Reserve. While in Spain, he met Maria del Pilar Sans-Mallafré, who became his wife on June 13, 1959. During these years, his interest in fiction began. His first published story, “Blackdamp,” was the seed of his first novel, The Origin of the Brunists. He received a master’s degree from the University of Chicago in 1965. During the following years, Coover and his family alternated stays in Europe with periods in the United States. The several awards he received during the 1970’s made him financially secure and allowed him to continue writing. Coover has held appointments at Bard College, the University of Iowa, Columbia University, Princeton University, the Virginia Military Institute, and he has been a distinguished professor at Brown University since 1979. He has also been writer-inresidence at Wisconsin State University. In spite of a large amount of time spent abroad (in Europe and in South America) and his outspoken need to take distance from his own country, Coover’s production is very “American,” since he often bases his fiction on American events, persons, and national myths. Coover often manipulates historical events for artistic purposes, but he has a solid knowledge of the facts. During the late 1980’s, Coover began teaching writing on computers. With the rise of the World Wide Web in the 1990’s, he made significant progress in the use of hyperfiction. Hyperfiction, also referred to as hypertext fiction, tree fiction, nonlinear fiction, or electronic fiction, is fiction written with the capabilities of hypertext. Hyperfiction is truly nonlinear since it cannot be represented on a printed page. The reader takes an active role in hyperfiction, choosing which links to click on and which paths to follow. Thus, the narrative may be very different from one reading to the next, depending on the choices made by the reader. Readers can follow different characters, or points of view, or skip back and forth between different time zones. By clicking on an interesting name, place, event, or idea, the reader can be taken to a new page connected to that name, place, event, or idea. Coover reads, writes, and reviews hyperfiction. He teaches hyperfiction workshops at Brown University. The Hypertext Hotel is a collaborative hyperfiction that grew out of Coover’s workshops. During the 1990’s, students, authors, and scholars have added to the fictional hotel text. Coover developed a course at Brown that introduces students to the possibilities of hyperfiction. He also been known to encourage the use of hyperfiction and the software that makes it possible. Coover is the author of the now classic “The End of the Book,” an article in which he explains hyperfiction and his general optimism that it will someday replace books. Analysis • Robert Coover’s central concern is the human being’s need for fiction. Because of the complexity of human existence, people are constantly inventing patterns that give them an illusion of order in a chaotic world. For Coover, any effort to explain the world involves some kind of fiction-making process. History, religion, culture, and scientific explanations are fictional at their core; they are invented narratives through which human beings try to explain the world to themselves. The prob-
Coover, Robert lem, Coover would say, is that people tend to forget the fictional nature of the fictional systems they create and become trapped by them, making dogmas out of the fictions. The artist’s function, then, is to reexamine these fictions, tear them down, and offer new perspectives on the same material, in order to make the reader aware of the arbitrariness of the construct. Coover’s fiction often has been labeled “metafiction”—that is, fiction about fiction—and indeed most of his works are comments on previously existing fictional constructs. If in his longer works he examines the bigger metaphoric narratives such as religion, history, or politics (that one of the theorists of postmodernism, Jean-François Lyotard, has called “metanarratives”), in his shorter works Coover turns to smaller constructs, usually literary fictions. In the prologue to the “Seven Exemplary Fictions” contained in Pricksongs and Descants, Coover addresses Miguel de Cervantes as follows:
297
National Archives
But, don Miguel, the optimism, the innocence, the aura of possibility you experienced have been largely drained away, and the universe is closing in on us again. Like you, we, too, seem to be standing at the end of one age and on the threshold of another. Just as Cervantes stood at the end of a tradition and managed to open a door for a new type of fiction, modern authors confront a changing world in need of new fictional forms that can reflect this world’s nature better. Just as Cervantes tried to stress the difference between romance and the real world through the mishaps of Don Quixote, Coover wants to stress the fictionality and arbitrariness of some fictions that hold a tight grip on the reader’s consciousness. Like Cervantes, Coover wants to free readers from an uncritical acceptance of untrue or oversimplified ideas that limit and falsify their outlook on life. Fictions, Coover and Cervantes would say, are not there to provide an escape by creating fantasies for the reader. When they do so, Coover continues writing in his prologue, the artist “must conduct the reader to the real, away from mystification to clarification, away from magic to maturity, away from mystery to revelations.” This quotation, coming from an author whose work is usually considered “difficult,” might seem somehow odd. How does Coover’s fiction clarify, or what does it reveal? His work often presents constantly metamorphosing worlds, which mimic the state of constant change in the real world. Just as the world is continuously changing, Coover’s fictions also refuse to present stable, easily describable characters or scenarios. Coover also calls attention to the fictionality of fiction by focusing on the process
298
Short Story Writers
and the means of creation rather than on the product. As he states in the prologue, the novelist turns to the familiar material and “defamiliarizes” it in order to liberate readers’ imagination from arbitrary constraints and in order to make them reevaluate their reactions to those constraints. These are the main strategies of Coover’s two collections of stories, Pricksongs and Descants and A Night at the Movies. Pricksongs and Descants • The title of the first collection refers to musical terms, variations played against a basic line (the basic line of the familiar narrative). As one character in one of the stories says, however, they are also “death-c— and prick-songs,” which prepares the reader for the sometimes shocking motifs of death and sex scattered throughout the stories. In Pricksongs and Descants, Coover turns to the familiar material of folktales and biblical stories. Using this material offers him the possibility of manipulating the reader’s expectations. One of the ways in which Coover forces the reader to look at familiar stories from new perspectives is by retelling them from an unfamiliar point of view. For example, the story “The Brother” is Coover’s version of the biblical flood told from the point of view of Noah’s brother, who, after helping Noah to build the ark, is left to drown. “J’s Marriage” describes how Joseph tries to come to terms with his marriage to the Virgin Mary and his alternating moods of amazement, frustration, and desperation. Some of the stories of the same collection are based on traditional folktales: “The Door” evokes “Little Red Riding Hood,” “The Gingerbread House,” reminds one of “Hanzel and Gretel,” “The Milkmaid of Samaniego” is based on the Spanish folktale of the same title; and Hair o’ the Chine, a novella, mocks the tale of the “Three Little Pigs and the Wolf.” Coover subverts, however, the original narratives by stressing the cruelty and the motifs of sex, violence, and death underlying most folktales. Revealing the darker side of familiar stories is in fact one of Coover’s recurrent techniques. In other stories of Pricksongs and Descants, Coover experiments with the formal aspects of fiction-making. He reminds the reader of the artificiality of fiction by presenting stories that are repertoires of narrative possibilities. Often, Coover juxtaposes several different beginnings, or potential stories, but leaves them undeveloped. He interweaves the different story lines, some of which are complementary and some of which might be contradictory, as is the case in “Quenby and Ola, Swede and Carl” and in “The Magic Poker.” In the “Sentient Lens” section and in “Klee’s Dead,” Coover explores the possibilities and the limitations of the narrational voice: In the first set of stories, Coover denies the possibility of an objective narrative voice by portraying a camera that constantly interferes with the events of the story; in “Klee’s Dead,” the supposedly “omniscient” narrator is unable to explain the reasons for Paul Klee’s suicide. In most of the stories of Pricksongs and Descants, the figures are types described with a flaunted lack of depth of characterization, which prevents the reader from identifying with them in any possible way. This contributes to the critical distance that Coover thinks it is necessary to maintain toward fiction. As critic Cristina Bacchilega says in her article about Coover’s use of the Märchen (folktales) in this collection, while “the Märchen is symbolic of development, of a passage from immaturity to maturity, Coover’s fictions present rather static characters . . . the only dynamic process allowed is in the reader’s new awareness of the world as a construct of fictions.” The function of the artist in contemporary society is one of Coover’s recurring concerns, which surfaces in “Panel Game,” “Romance of Thin Man and Fat Lady,” and “The Hat Act,” all of which portray cruel and insatiable audiences who, in
Coover, Robert
299
their thirst for entertainment, do not hesitate to exterminate the artists if their performance does not stand up to their expectations. A Night at the Movies • In A Night at the Movies, Coover probes the nature of filmic fictions, which present a greater danger of being taken for “real” because of the immediacy of filmic images. Coover approaches film from three perspectives. In the stories “Shootout at Gentry’s Junction,” “Charlie in the House of Rue,” “Gilda’s Dream,” and “You Must Remember This,” Coover demythologizes specific films and offers his own version of the story, usually baring the ideology of the original version. In “After Lazarus” and “Inside the Frame,” he explores the conventions through which these fictions create an illusion of an independent world on the screen. In “The Phantom of the Movie Palace” and “Intermission,” he challenges the ontological status of reality and film by making the characters cross the boundaries that separate these two realms. “Shootout at Gentry’s Junction” is a parody of the ideology and of the form of the Western film High Noon (1952). Coover parodies the narrative line and the easy identification of good and evil typical of most Westerns. The film celebrates the code of honor and personal integrity typical of the Western hero; abandoned by everybody, the sheriff of the film, played by Gary Cooper, has to fight alone with the villain and his gang. In the story, however, the protagonist is a fastidious, neurotic sheriff who is obsessed with fulfilling the role imposed on him. The villain is Don Pedro, the Mexican bandit, whose major talent is expressing himself by expelling intestinal gas. As in the film, the narrative progresses toward the confrontation of the villain and the sheriff. The tight structure of the film, however, is disrupted in the story by giving both characters a different kind of discourse. The sheriff’s discourse has a traditional narrative line. It is narrated in the past tense and refers to formulas taken directly from the visual tradition of the Western. The Mexican’s discourse is in the present tense and in broken English, influenced by Spanish. Furthermore, Coover makes the Mexican ubiquitous. Readers never really know where he is—he seems everywhere at the same time, raping the schoolmarm at the local school, cheating at cards in the saloon, and burning papers at the sheriff’s office. After shooting the sheriff, the Mexican sets the town on fire and rides into the sunset. The irreverence of Coover’s version of Casablanca (1942) is even greater. Casablanca has become the epitome of the romantic melodrama, drawing like the Western upon codes of honor and heroic behavior. In “You Must Remember This,” Coover gives his version of what might have happened between frames. Quite literally, Rick and Ilsa fall between frames and make furious love several times. The love story becomes a pornographic movie. The disruption of the moral code of the film creates an avalanche of disruptions in other categories: Rick and Ilsa begin to sense that their senses of time and place are fading, and their identities become increasingly diffused. At the end of the story, the characters melt into nothingness after several desperate attempts to return to the mythic movie. Other stories in the collection A Night at the Movies aim at exposing the artificiality of the technical conventions of film. Written in the form of a screenplay, “After Lazarus” parodies the notion of the camera as the ultimately objective narrator. In the story, the camera “hesitates,” “pauses,” “follows back at a discreet distance,” and rapidly moves back when frightened. “Inside the Frame” refers in its very title to filmrelated terms. If films construct a narrative through the sum of frames that all have a reason and a function in the global construct of the story, this story presents several
300
Short Story Writers
possible beginnings of stories in one single frame. In “Inside the Frame,” the reader gets glimpses of what could be potential stories: a woman stepping off a bus, an Indian with a knife between his teeth, a man praying at a grave, a singing couple, a sleepwalker. There is no development, no explanation of the images. “Lap Dissolves” is a literary imitation of the film technique. The story fades from one film-related situation to the next, with the words giving the cues to the transformation of the scenario. Coover disrupts the ontological boundaries between “reality” and fiction by making the protagonists of “The Phantom of the Movie Palace” and “Intermission” move between them. The mad projectionist of the first story lives in an abandoned movie palace and plays with the reels of film, constructing films by cutting and pasting images of other films. Somehow, his experiments go awry, and he becomes trapped in the fictions he has been creating. The girl of “Intermission” enters a film-related fantasy when the film in the story ends and she steps into the lobby of the movie theater to buy a snack. Outside the theater, she is thrown into a series of situations directly drawn from Hollywood films: She moves from a car race with gangsters, to a tent with Rudolph Valentino, to the sea surrounded by sharks. In what is supposed to be “reality,” she becomes a dynamic individual, but back in the cinema she returns to the passivity that Hollywood fictions seem to invite. Briar Rose • In Briar Rose, a novella and a retelling of the fable of Sleeping Beauty, Coover travels deeply into the dreams of the sleeping princess and into the forest of briars and brambles that plague the prince as he tries to rescue her. The story centers on the powers of the human imagination and escalates to an erotic pace as sex and storytelling fuse together. As the prince fights his way to the princess’s bed chamber to awaken her from a deathly enchanted sleep, Coover involves the reader by dangling numerous interpretative possibilities just below the surface of this brief narrative. Coover’s genius is displayed in his use of words, drifting back and forth between reality and dreams. His speculations about what makes a prince forge through the briars and what a princess dreams about while magically asleep for one hundred years are thought-provoking, mysterious, compelling, and at times hilarious. As the tale unwinds, Coover exposes the masculine desire to prey on female beauty. In addition, he leads the reader to contemplate the necessity that women resist male yearnings that are projected onto them. The tale is a bit dull in places and lacks a definite ending with some culminating metaphor, but Coover constructs an intriguing story that is well known, turned in on itself, and explored to reveal different levels of human consciousness. In his major collections of stories, Coover elaborates on his fundamental concern, namely the necessity for the individual to distinguish between reality and fiction and to be liberated from dogmatic thinking. In order to do so, Coover emphasizes the self-reflexive, antirealistic elements of his fiction. The result is original, highly engaging, and energetic stories that probe human beings’ relationships to the myths that shape their lives. Carlota Larrea With updates by Alvin K. Benson
Coover, Robert
301
Other major works plays: A Theological Position, pb. 1972; Love Scene, pb. 1972; Rip Awake, pr. 1972; The Kid, pr., pb. 1972; Bridge Hound, pr. 1981. novels: The Origin of the Brunists, 1966; The Universal Baseball Association, Inc., J. Henry Waugh, Prop., 1968; Whatever Happened to Gloomy Gus of the Chicago Bears?, 1975 (expanded, 1987); The Public Burning, 1977; Hair o’ the Chine, 1979 (novella/screenplay); A Political Fable, 1980 (novella); Spanking the Maid, 1981 (novella); Gerald’s Party, 1985; Pinocchio in Venice, 1991; Briar Rose, 1996 (novella); John’s Wife, 1996; Ghost Town, 1998; The Adventures of Lucky Pierre: Directors’ Cut, 2002. screenplays: On a Confrontation in Iowa City, 1969; After Lazarus, 1980. Bibliography Coover, Robert. “Interview.” Short Story, n.s. 1 (Fall, 1993): 89-94. Coover comments on the difference between the short story and the novel, the writing of Pricksongs and Descants, his use of sexuality in his fiction, his iconoclastic streak, postmodernism, and his use of the short story to test narrative forms. ____________. Interview by Amanda Smith. Publishers Weekly 230 (December 26, 1986): 44-45. Coover discusses the motivations that lie behind his experimental fiction; states he believes that the artist finds his metaphors for the world in the most vulnerable areas of human outreach; he insists that he is in pursuit of the mainstream. What many people consider experimental, Coover argues, is actually traditional in the sense that it has gone back to old forms to find its new form. Evenson, Brian K. Understanding Robert Coover. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2003. Evenson explains the particularly dense style of Coover’s metafiction (his writing about writing) in a comprehensive survey that is part of the Understanding Contemporary American Literature series. Evenson guides readers through Coover’s postmodern fiction, which deals with myth- and storymaking and their power to shape collective, community action, which often turns violent. Gordon, Lois. Robert Coover: The Universal Fictionmaking Process. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1983. Like Richard Andersen’s book, this volume provides a friendly introduction and overview of Coover’s work, placing him in the context of metafictional or postmodernist literature. Notes, select bibliography, and index. Kennedy, Thomas E. Robert Coover: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Kennedy’s study shows Coover’s use of myth, fantasy, love, soap opera, slapstick comedy, parable, and daydream on the level of the short story, which he displays with extraordinary effect in his novels as well. Contains interviews with Coover and glosses on many of his critics. Maltby, Paul. Dissident Postmodernists: Barthelme, Coover, Pynchon. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1991. Comparative look at these three writers and their fictions. Includes a bibliography and an index. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Coover: “The Babysitter” and “The Brother” (vol. 1), and “A Pedestrian Accident” (vol. 6).
302
Short Story Writers
“The Pleasures of the (Hyper)text.” The New Yorker 70 (June/July, 1994): 43-44. Discusses Coover’s Hypertext Hotel, the United States’ first online writing space dedicated to the computer-generated mode of literature known as hypertext; describes Coover’s writing class at Brown University and its use of hypertext. Pughe, Thomas. Comic Sense: Reading Robert Coover, Stanley Elkin, Philip Roth. Boston: Birkhäuser Verlag, 1994. Analyzes the humor in the writers’ books. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Scholes, Robert. “Metafiction.” The Iowa Review 1, no. 3 (Fall, 1970): 100-115. Initially theoretical, then descriptive, this article discusses four major metafictional writers: Coover, William H. Gass, Donald Barthelme, and John Barth. Scholes categorizes the different types of metafictional writing and classifies Coover’s Pricksongs and Descants as “structural” metafiction, since it is concerned with the order of fiction rather than with the conditions of being.
303
A. E. Coppard Born: Folkestone, Kent, England; January 4, 1878 Died: London, England; January 13, 1957 Principal short fiction • Adam and Eve and Pinch Me, 1921; Clorinda Walks in Heaven, 1922; The Black Dog, 1923; Fishmonger’s Fiddle, 1925; The Field of Mustard, 1926; Count Stephan, 1928; Silver Circus, 1928; The Gollan, 1929; The Higgler, 1930; The Man from Kilsheelan, 1930; Easter Day, 1931; Nixey’s Harlequin, 1931; The Hundredth Story of A. E. Coppard, 1931; Crotty Shinkwin, and the Beauty Spot, 1932; Dunky Fitlow, 1933; Ring the Bells of Heaven, 1933; Emergency Exit, 1934; Polly Oliver, 1935; Ninepenny Flute, 1937; These Hopes of Heaven, 1937; Tapster’s Tapestry, 1938; You Never Know, Do You?, 1939; Ugly Anna, and Other Tales, 1944; Fearful Pleasures, 1946; Selected Tales from His Twelve Volumes Published Between the Wars, 1946; The Dark-Eyed Lady: Fourteen Tales, 1947; The Collected Tales of A. E. Coppard, 1948; Lucy in Her Pink Jacket, 1954; Simple Day, 1978. Other literary forms • A. E. Coppard published three slender volumes of poetry, Hips and Haws (1922), Pelagea, and Other Poems (1926), and Cherry Ripe (1935), and two collections, Yokohama Garland (1926) and Collected Poems (1928). In 1957, he published his autobiography, It’s Me, O Lord! Achievements • Though not widely known among general readers, Coppard has experienced a resurgence of popularity as a result of the adaptation of several of his stories for Masterpiece Theatre on public television. For both his mastery of the short-story form and his sensitive portrayal of English rural life, Coppard is an important figure in the development of the short story as a serious literary form. From a background of poverty and with no formal education, Coppard advanced through a number of clerical and accounting jobs in Oxford, reading and associating with the students there. Becoming increasingly active in political activities and writing for journals, Coppard eventually decided to write professionally. During the 1920’s and 1930’s, he was considered one of the foremost short-story writers in England. Coppard’s stories are frequently compared to those of Anton Chekhov and Thomas Hardy, whose influence Coppard acknowledged, and also to those of his contemporaries H. E. Bates and D. H. Lawrence. Although his poetry has not generated much acclaim, Coppard’s prose is eloquently lyrical, its evocation of mood and emotion particularly noteworthy. Biography • Alfred Edgar Coppard’s remarkable life contributed to his early success. To such an influential editor-writer as Ford Madox Ford, he was a rustic wise man or gypsy, a character out of one of his own dark country stories. Coppard was born into poverty and attended only four years of elementary school in Brighton. His father was a tailor, his mother a housemaid; when his father died young, Coppard had to help the family survive by taking a series of menial jobs. At the age of twenty-one, he became a clerk in an engineering firm in Brighton, where he remained for seven years, advancing to cashier. As a teenager and young man he walked the English countryside, absorbing its landscapes and the language of country folk he met in roadside taverns, a favorite setting for many of his later tales. He was a fine athlete and even supplemented his income as a successful professional sprinter. He married in 1906
304
Short Story Writers
and a year later took a better position as an accountant for an ironworks in Oxford, a position he held for twelve years. During his years in Oxford Coppard read, often in the Bodleian, associated with students, heard and sometimes met such luminaries as Vachel Lindsay, Aldous Huxley, and William Butler Yeats, and, finally, began to write. He also became involved in Socialist politics and joined the Women’s Social and Political Union. Finally, in 1919, having published seven or eight tales in journals such as the Manchester Guardian and a few poems in journals such as The Egoist (edited by T. S. Eliot), he decided to leave his position at the foundry and become a professional writer. On April 1, 1919, at the age of forty-one, he moved to a small cottage outside Oxford at Shepherd’s Pit, where he lived alone in the woods, becoming aware of “the ignoring docility of the earth” and, finally, publishing his first collection of tales on the second anniversary (Adam and Eve and Pinch Me, 1921) of his new career. His first book was well received and thrust him into prominence as one of the leading English short-story writers. Over the next thirty years his production of tales, poems, and reviews was steady and of high quality. A second marriage, to Winifred May de Kok in 1931, endured, but his reputation as a short-story writer began to wane in the mid1930’s; his last collection of tales (1954) was not even reviewed by the Times Literary Supplement. The Collected Tales, however, was a clear success, and the autobiography he completed on the eve of his fatal illness in 1957 is a delight. Analysis • The unique quality of A. E. Coppard’s short fiction derives from his powers as a lyrical writer, his sympathetic understanding of the rural, lower-class folk who organically inhabit the English countryside so memorably evoked in his tales, and his “uncanny perception,” as Frank O’Connor remarked, “of a woman’s secretiveness and mystery.” Coppard’s earliest reviewers and critics emphasized the poetic quality of his tales. The title story from The Field of Mustard is one of the great stories in English, and it suggests the full range of Coppard’s creative genius, including his lyric portrayal of the English countryside and its folk, especially its women, whose language and life-consciousness seem wedded to the landscape. “The Field of Mustard” • Like other lyric short stories, “The Field of Mustard” is nearly plotless. It opens with the suggestion that everything has already happened to the main characters, “three sere disvirgined women from Pollock’s Cross.” What remains for Coppard is to evoke the quality of these lives and the countryside of which they are a part; the tale proceeds as a kind of lyric meditation on life and death in nature. The women have come to “the Black Wood” in order to gather “dead branches” from the living trees, and on their way home, two of them, Dinah Lock and Rose Olliver, become involved in an intimate conversation that reveals the hopelessness of their lives. Rose, wishing she had children but knowing she never will, cannot understand why Dinah is not happy with her four children. Dinah complains that “a family’s a torment. I never wanted mine.” Dinah’s “corpulence dispossessed her of tragedy,” and perhaps because she has had the burden as well as the fulfillment of motherhood, she expressed the bitterness of life in what serves almost as a refrain: “Oh God, cradle and grave is all for we.” They are old but their hearts are young, and the truth of Dinah’s complaint, “that’s the cussedness of nature, it makes a mock of you,” is reflected in the world around them: The depleted women are associated with the mustard field and the “sour scent rising faintly from its yellow blooms.” Against this natural order, Dinah and Rose wish that “this world was all a garden”; but “the
Coppard, A. E.
305
wind blew strongly athwart the yellow field, and the odour of mustard rushed upon the brooding women.” As Dinah and Rose continue their conversation, they complain of their feeble husbands and discover a mutual loss: Each had been a lover of Rufus Blackthorn, a local gamekeeper. He was “a pretty man,” “handsome,” “black as coal and bold as a fox”; and although “he was good to women,” he was “a perfect devil,” “deep as the sea.” Gradually Coppard’s pattern of imagery reveals the source of these women’s loss to be the very wellspring of life—their love and sexual vitality. The suggestion is explicit in their lover’s name, “Blackthorn,” who had brought them most in life yet left them now with “old grief or new rancour.” This grim reality is suggested earlier when the women meet an old man in the Black Wood; he shows them a timepiece given him by “a noble Christian man,” but is met only with Dinah’s profane taunt, “Ah! I suppose he slept wid Jesus?” Outraged, the old man calls Dinah “a great fat thing,” shouts an obscenity, and leaving them, puts “his fingers to his nose.” Dinah’s bitter mockery of Christian love gradually merges with the sour scent of mustard and surfaces transformed in Rose’s recollection of how Blackthorn once joked of having slept with a dead man. These women, gathered in “the Black Wood” to collect dead wood from the living trees, have in effect slept with death. The yellow mustard blooms quiver in the wind, yet they are sour. The same “wind hustled the two women close together,” and they touch; but, bereft of their sexual vitality, they are left only with Dinah’s earlier observation that “it’s such a mercy to have a friend at all” and her repeated appeal, “I like you, Rose, I wish you was a man.” The tale ends with the women “quiet and voiceless,” in fading light they came to their homes. But how windy, dispossessed, and ravaged roved the darkening world! Clouds were borne frantically across the heavens, as if in a rout of battle, and the lovely earth seemed to sigh in grief at some calamity all unknown to men. Coppard’s lyric tales celebrate the oral tradition. His stories are often tales of tales being told, perhaps in a country tavern (as in “Alas, Poor Bollington!”). In some tales an oral narrator addresses the reader directly, and in others the rural settings, the characters, and the events—often of love ending in violence—draw obviously upon the materials of traditional folk ballads. Coppard himself loved to sing ballads and Elizabethan folk songs, and the main characters in these stories are sometimes singers, or their tales are “balladed about.” In many tales, Coppard used rhythmic language, poetically inverted constructions, and repeated expressions that function as refrains in ballads. The most explicit example of a tale intended to resound with balladic qualities is “A Broadsheet Ballad,” a tale of two laborers waiting in a tavern for the rain to pass. They begin to talk of a local murder trial, and one is moved by the thought of a hanging: “Hanging’s a dreadful thing,” he exclaims; and at length, with “almost a sigh,” he repeats. “Hanging’s a dreadful thing.” His sigh serves as the tale’s refrain and causes his fellow to tell within the tale a longer tale of a love triangle that ended in a murder and an unjust hanging. Finally, the sigh-refrain and the strange narration coalesce in the laborer’s language: Ah, when things make a turn against you it’s as certain as twelve o’clock, when they take a turn; you get no more chance than a rabbit from a weasel. It’s like dropping your matches into a stream, you needn’t waste the bending of your back to pick them out—they’re no good on, they’ll never strike again.
306
Short Story Writers
Coppard’s lyric mode is perfectly suited to his grand theme: the darkness of love, its fleeting loveliness and almost inevitable entanglements and treacheries. He writes of triangles, entrapping circumstances, and betrayals in which, as often as not, a lover betrays himself or herself out of foolishness, timidity, or blind adherence to custom. Some of his best tales, like “Dusky Ruth” and “The Higgler,” dwell on the mysterious elusiveness of love, often as this involves an alluring but ungraspable woman. Men and women are drawn together by circumstances and deep undercurrents of unarticulated feeling but are separated before they consummate their love. “The Higgler” • Because of its portrayal of unconsummated love, its treatment of the rural poor, and its poetic atmosphere that arises from the countryside itself, “The Higgler” (the first story in The Collected Tales) is fully characteristic of Coppard’s best work. It is not simply a tale of unconsummated love, for its main character comes to absorb and reflect the eternal forces of conflict in nature. For Coppard this involves more than man’s economic struggle to wrest his living from nature; it involves man’s conflict with man in war, his conflict with his lover, his conflict with himself, and ultimately, with his own life source, the mother. Harvey Witlow is the higgler, a man whose business it is to travel the countryside in a horse-drawn wagon, buying produce from small farms. The story opens with the higgler making his way across Shag Moor, a desolate place where “solitude . . . now . . . shivered and looked sinister.” Witlow is shrewd and crafty, “but the season was backward, eggs were scarce, trade was bad”; and he stands to lose the meager business he has struggled to establish for himself since returning from the war, as well as his opportunity to marry. “That’s what war does for you,” he says. “I was better off working for farmers; much; but it’s no good chattering about it, it’s the trick of life; when you get so far, then you can go and order your funeral.” After this dismal beginning, Witlow is presented with an unexpected opportunity to improve his life in every way; but he is destined to outwit himself, as his name suggests, and to know more fully the “trick of life.” As the tale develops, then, the reader watches him miss his opportunity and resume his descent into general desolation. Witlow’s chance comes when he stops at the farm of a Mrs. Sadgrove. Here the higgler finds plenty of produce as well as the intriguing possibility of a relationship with Mrs. Sadgrove’s daughter, Mary, another of Coppard’s alluring, secretive women. Mary’s quiet beauty attracts Witlow, but he imagines her to be too “well-up” and “highly cultivated” for him. She shows no interest in him, so he is unprepared when, after several trips to the farm and an invitation to dinner, Mrs. Sadgrove tells him of her poor health and her desire that he should wed Mary and take over the farm. The higgler leaves bewildered. Here is his life’s opportunity: The farm is prosperous, and he is far more attracted to Mary than to Sophy, the poor girl he eventually marries; besides, Mary will inherit five hundred pounds on her twenty-fifth birthday. It is simply too good to believe, and after consulting with his mother about his opportunity, Witlow grows increasingly suspicious. The reader has already been told that “mothers are inscrutable beings to their sons, always”; and Witlow is confused by his mother’s enthusiasm over his opportunity. Even the natural world somehow conspires to frighten him: “Autumn was advancing, and the apples were down, the bracken dying, the furze out of bloom, and the farm on the moor looked more and more lonely. . . .” So Witlow begins to avoid the Sadgrove farm and suddenly marries Sophy. Within months, his “affairs had again taken a rude turn. Marriage, alas, was not all it might
Coppard, A. E.
307
be; his wife and his mother quarrelled unendingly,” and his business fails badly. His only chance seems to be to return to the Sadgrove farm, where he might obtain a loan; but he does so reluctantly, for he knows Mrs. Sadgrove to be a hard woman. She exploits her help and “was reputed to be a ‘grinder’”; and he has betrayed her confidence. In an increasingly dark atmosphere of loss, Witlow returns across Shag Moor to the Sadgrove farm, where Mary meets him with the news of her mother’s death that day. Now a prolonged, eerie, and utterly powerful scene develops as the higgler agrees to help Mary prepare her mother’s body, which lies alone upstairs in a state of rigor mortis. He sends Mary away and confronts the dead mother, whose stiff outstretched arm had been impossible for Mary to manage. Moments later, in their intimacy near the dead mother, Witlow blurts out, “Did you know as she once asked me to marry you?” Finally Mary reveals that her mother actually opposed the marriage: “The girl bowed her head, lovely in her grief and modesty. ‘She was against it, but I made her ask you. . . . I was fond of you—then.’” To his distress and confusion, Mary insists that he leave at once, and he drives “away in deep darkness, the wind howling, his thoughts strange and bitter.” “Arabesque: The Mouse” • Coppard’s vision of life caught in a struggle against itself, of the violence in nature and its mockery of morality, of the deceit among humans and of humans’ denial of their true nature—all this is marvelously represented in one of his first and finest tales, “Arabesque: The Mouse.” It is a psychological horror story of a middle-aged man who sits alone one night reading Russian novels until he thinks he is mad. He is an idealist who was obsessed by the incompatibilities of property and virtue, justice and sin. He looks at a “print by Utamaro of a suckling child caressing its mother’s breasts” and his mind drifts to recall his own mother and then a brief experience with a lover. These recollections merge in a compelling pattern of images that unite finally, and horribly, with an actual experience this night with a mouse. As a child horrified by the sight of some dead larks that had been intended for supper, he sought comfort from his mother and found her sitting by the fire with her bodice open, “squeezing her breasts; long thin streams of milk spurted into the fire with a little plunging noise.” Telling him that she was weaning his little sister, she draws him to her breast and presses his face “against the delicate warmth of her bosom.” She allows him to do it; “so he discovered the throb of the heart in his mother’s breast. Wonderful it was for him to experience it, although she could not explain it to him.” They feel his own beat, and his mother assures him his heart is “good if it beats truly. Let it always beat truly, Filip.” The child kisses “her bosom in his ecstasy and whisper[s] soothingly: ‘Little mother! little mother.’” The boy forgets the horror of the dead larks bundled by their feet, but the next day his mother is run over by a heavy cart, and before she dies her mutilated hands are amputated. For years the image of his mother’s bleeding stumps of arms had haunted his dreams. Into his mind, however, now floats the recollection of an experience with a lovely country girl he had met and accompanied home. It was “dark, dark . . . , the night an obsidian net”; finally in their intimacy she had unbuttoned his coat, and with her hands on his breast asked, “Oh, how your heart beats! Does it beat truly?” In a “little fury of love” he cried “Little mother, little mother!” and confused the girl. At that moment footsteps and the clack of a bolt cause them to part forever. The sound of the bolt hurls him into the present, where, frightened, he opens his cupboard to find a mouse sitting on its haunches before a snapped trap. “Its head was bowed, but its beadlike eyes were full of brightness, and it sat blinking, it did not
308
Short Story Writers
flee.” Then to his horror he sees that the trap had caught only the feet, “and the thing crouched there holding out its two bleeding stumps humanly, too stricken to stir.” He throws the mouse from his window into the darkness, then sits stunned, “limp with pity too deep for tears” before running down into the street in a vain search for the “little philosopher.” Later he drops the tiny feet into the fire, resets the trap, and carefully replaces it. “Arabesque: The Mouse” is a masterwork of interwoven imagery whose unity is caught in such details as the mother’s heartbeat, the mother’s milk streaming with a plunging noise into the fire, the mouse’s eyes, and the “obsidian net” of night. Coppard’s characters are sometimes shattered by such thoughts and experiences, but the author never lost his own sense of the natural magnificence and fleeting loveliness in life. It is true that many of his late tales pursue in a more thoughtful and comic manner the natural and psychological forces in life that were simply, but organically and poetically, present in such earlier tales as “The Higgler”; that is, in some of his later stories the reader can too easily see him playing with thoughts about Alfred Adler, Sigmund Freud, and, repeatedly, Charles Darwin (whose prose he admired). Yet the last tale (the title story) of his final volume is one of his best. “Lucy in Her Pink Jacket” is almost a hymn to nature, a song of acceptance in which lovers meet accidentally in a magnificent mountain setting. Their lovemaking is beautiful, natural, and relaxed, and they accept the web of circumstances causing them to part. Coppard’s description of his last parting character might serve as his reader’s image of himself: “Stepping out into the bright eager morning it was not long before [he] was whistling softly as he went his way, a sort of thoughtful, plaintive, museful air.” Bert Bender With updates by Lou Thompson Other major works children’s literature: Pink Furniture, 1930. nonfiction: Rummy: That Noble Game Expounded, 1933; It’s Me, O Lord!, 1957. poetry: Hips and Haws, 1922; Pelagea, and Other Poems, 1926; Yokohama Garland, 1926; Collected Poems, 1928; Cherry Ripe, 1935. Bibliography Allen, Walter. The Short Story in English. New York: Oxford University Press, 1981. Includes a brief analysis of Coppard’s “The Higgler,” suggesting that the story is as unpredictable as life itself, with nothing seemingly arranged or contrived by Coppard. Bates, H. E. “Katherine Mansfield and A. E. Coppard.” In The Modern Short Story: A Critical Survey. London: Evensford Productions, 1972. Coppard’s contemporary and fellow author of short stories discusses Coppard’s role in the development of the modern English short story. Bates discerns an unfortunate influence of Henry James on Coppard’s work, which is remarkable in its Elizabethan lyricism and its homage to the oral tradition. Includes an index. Beachcroft, T. O. The Modest Art: A Survey of the Short Story in English. New York: Oxford University Press, 1968. Discusses Coppard’s two basic generic veins—the highly fantastic in such stories as “Adam and Eve and Pinch Me,” and the naturalistic in stories such as “The Higgler” and “The Water Cress Girl.” Cowley, Malcolm. “Book Reviews: Adam and Eve and Pinch Me.” The Dial 71, no. 1 (July,
Coppard, A. E.
309
1921): 93-95. Describes Coppard’s careful workmanship, his skillful narration, and his artful blend of fantasy and realism. Cowley notes Coppard’s emotional unity, his insight into characters, his animated landscapes, and his role in keeping the short-story form vital. Ginden, James. “A. E. Coppard and H. E. Bates.” In The English Short Story, 1880-1945: A Critical History, edited by Joseph M. Flora. Boston: Twayne, 1985. Compares Coppard’s and H. E. Bates’s treatment of rural life as well as their dedication to the short story as distinguished from other literary forms. Although both authors employed the techniques of the modern short story, Ginden does not consider them “modernists,” arguing that their work lacks the reliance on symbol or metaphor and instead stresses anecdote and description. Kalasky, Drew, ed. Short Story Criticism: Excerpts from Criticism of the Works of Short Fiction Writers. Vol. 21. Detroit: Gale Research, 1996. Thoughtful collection of criticism of works by Coppard, Jean Rhys, William Sansom, William Saroyan, Giovanni Verga, and others. Lessing, Doris. Introduction to Selected Stories by A. E. Coppard. London: Jonathan Cape, 1972. Lessing attributes the general appeal of Coppard’s fiction to his exceptional talent for storytelling. Coppard was an expert craftsman, but it is the authentic growth of characters and events that involves the reader. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Coppard: “Adam and Eve and Pinch Me” and “Arabesque—The Mouse” (vol. 1), “The Field of Mustard” and “The Higgler” (vol. 3), and “The Third Prize” (vol. 7). O’Connor, Frank. The Lonely Voice: A Study of the Short Story. New York: World, 1962. O’Connor examines Coppard’s themes of poverty, personal freedom, and women in the context of other modern short fiction by Irish, English, American, and Russian writers. The two great English storytellers, according to O’Connor, are Coppard and D. H. Lawrence. Though both authors had working-class backgrounds, Coppard is a more deliberate, self-conscious artist, and he betrays feelings of social inadequacy. Schwartz, Jacob. The Writings of Alfred Edward Coppard: A Bibliography. 1931. Reprint. Folcroft, Pa.: Folcroft Library Editions, 1975. Features a biography by Schwartz and a foreword and notes by Coppard.
310
Julio Cortázar Born: Brussels, Belgium; August 26, 1914 Died: Paris, France; February 12, 1984 Principal short fiction • Bestiario, 1951; Final del juego, 1956; Las armas secretas, 1959; Historias de cronopios y de famas, 1962 (Cronopios and Famas, 1969); End of the Game, and Other Stories, 1963 (also as Blow-Up, and Other Stories, 1967); Todos los fuegos el fuego, 1966 (All Fires the Fire, and Other Stories, 1973); “Octaedro,” 1974 (included in A Change of Light, and Other Stories, 1980); “Alguien que anda por ahí y otros relatos,” 1977 (included in A Change of Light, and Other Stories, 1980); Un tal Lucas, 1979 (A Certain Lucas, 1984); Queremos tanto a Glenda y otros relatos, 1980 (We Love Glenda So Much, and Other Stories, 1983); Deshoras, 1982. Other literary forms • Julio Cortázar’s literary career, which lasted almost forty years, includes—besides his short stories—novels, plays, poetry, translations, and essays of literary criticism. In his essay on short fiction entitled “Algunos aspectos del cuento” (“Some Aspects of the Short Story”), Cortázar studies the varying role of the reader with regard to different literary forms. Cortázar’s first book, Presencia (1938), was a collection of poetry that he published under the pseudonym Julio Denís. He translated authors as diverse as Louisa May Alcott and Edgar Allan Poe into Spanish and considered French Symbolist poetry to be of enormous influence on his prose writing. He experimented with a form of collage in his later works of short fiction. Achievements • An antirealist, Cortázar is often grouped with Gabriel García Márquez as one of the foremost proponents of the Magical Realism movement and, during his lifetime, one of the most articulate spokespersons on the subject of Latin American fiction. Although Cortázar is most admired for his short stories (his short story “Las babas del diablo” was made into a classic film in 1966 called Blow-Up by director Michelangelo Antonioni), it was the publication of the novel Rayuela (1963; Hopscotch, 1966) that placed the author among the twentieth century’s greatest writers. The Times Literary Supplement called Hopscotch the “first great novel of Spanish America.” Biography • Julio Cortázar was born in Brussels, Belgium, in 1914, during the German occupation. His Argentine parents were stationed there while his father was on the staff of a commercial mission. Cortázar’s antecedents came from the Basque region of Spain, as well as France and Germany, and they had settled in Argentina. When Cortázar was four years old, his parents returned to Argentina, where he would grow up in Banfield, a suburb of Buenos Aires. His father abandoned the family, and he was reared by his mother and an aunt. Cortázar attended the Escuela Norman Mariano Acosta in Buenos Aires and earned a degree as a public-school teacher in 1932. In 1937, he accepted a high school teaching post and shortly thereafter published Presencia, a collection of poems, under the pseudonym Julio Denís. In 1940, he published an essay on Arthur Rimbaud, under the same pseudonym, and began to teach a class on the French Sym-
Cortázar, Julio
311
bolist movement at the University of Cuyo in Mendoza. In 1946, Jorge Luis Borges, at that time the editor of the literary journal Anales de Buenos Aires, published “Casa tomada” (“House Taken Over”)—the first work that Julio Cortázar penned under his own name. A writer with outspoken political beliefs, Cortázar was defiantly anti-Peronist. He was arrested and as a result was forced to relinquish his academic career in Argentina. Instead, however, he became a translator and, in 1951, went to Paris, where he soon established permanent residency. Much of his best short fiction, including “Bestiary” and “End of the Game,” was published in the 1950’s and reveals his experience as an expatriate—a Latin American living in Paris. In Paris, Cortázar got a job as a translator for UNESCO, which he kept for the rest of his life despite his international success as an author. In 1953, he married Aurora Bernandez, with whom he translated Poe’s prose works into Spanish, while they lived briefly in Rome. In 1963, he published Hopscotch and, after a visit to Cuba, became a powerful figure on both the literary and the political scenes. His audience grew wider during the 1960’s and 1970’s with the translation of Rayuela into dozens of languages and the appearance of the film Blow-Up. He also traveled extensively to such diverse places as Chile, New York, and Oklahoma to attend conferences, receive awards, and participate in political tribunals. In 1981, he finally became a French citizen. He died in Paris in February, 1984, of leukemia and heart disease. He is buried in the Montparnasse cemetery in Paris. Analysis • Influenced by the European movements of nineteenth century Symbolism and twentieth century Surrealism, Julio Cortázar combines symbols, dreams, and the fantastic with what seems to be an ordinary, realistic situation in order to expose a different kind of reality that exists in the innermost heart and mind of modern human beings. Like Edgar Allan Poe, Cortázar is fascinated by terror. He uses human beings’ worst nightmares to explore which fears control them and how phobias and dreams coexist with seemingly rational thought. Using symbols and metaphors for subconscious obsessions, Cortázar’s short fictions, unlike those of the Surrealists, are carefully constructed. His journey into the irrational is not a free-flowing adventure; rather, it is a study of a particular corner of the mind that is common to all people. “Bestiary” • “Bestiary,” an early story published in 1951, contains many of the elements of poesy and mystery that are characteristic of the nineteenth century Symbolists so admired by Cortázar. The story is told by a child whose scope of understanding and point of view are limited, thereby leaving certain details vague and confusing. Isabel is sent to the country for the summer to stay in a home inhabited by another child, Nino, and three adults: Luis, Nino’s father; Rema, who may or may not be Nino’s mother, Luis’ wife or sister, Nino’s sister, or the housekeeper; and the Kid, who is not a kid but Luis’ brother. The information given about the family is not specific in those terms, but it is quite specific in Isabel’s feelings about each person. The overwhelming oddity about this summer home is that a tiger is allowed to roam freely about the house and grounds. The people are advised as to the location of the tiger each day, and they go about their business as usual by simply avoiding the room or part of the fields in which the tiger happens to be. Life seems to be filled with very typical activities: Luis works in his study; the children gather an ant collection; and Rema supervises meals. Isabel is especially fond
312
Short Story Writers
of Rema but not of the Kid. Events are relayed that expose Isabel’s true feelings about the Kid and the kind of person she believes him to be. He is surly at the dinner table. Once, after Nino has hit a ball through the window leading to the Kid’s room, the Kid hits Nino; the most disturbing moment, however, is a scene between Rema and the Kid during which Isabel acts as a voyeur, revealing some sort of sexual abuse on the part of the Kid toward Rema. Because of Isabel’s admiration for Rema, she decides to take revenge on the Kid. The culmination of the story is that Isabel lies to the family about the whereabouts of the tiger, sending the Kid into the room where the animal is. Screams are heard, and it is clear that the Kid has been mauled to death. Isabel notices that Rema squeezes her hand with what the child believes to be gratiLibrary of Congress tude. Many critics have speculated about the meaning of the tiger. Cortázar, in true Symbolist fashion, has himself said that the reader receives a richer experience if no specific symbol is attributed to the animal in this story. As in the works of Poe, constant tension and terror pervade the work, and the tiger’s meaning becomes a relative one—a personal nightmare for each character and each reader. “Letter to a Young Lady in Paris” • “Letter to a Young Lady in Paris” begins on a charming note. It is a letter from a young man to his girlfriend, who is visiting Paris. She has asked him to move into her apartment, and, through very delicate language, he tries to convince her that he would disrupt her very orderly and truly elegant apartment. He succumbs to her wishes, however, and moves his belongings, but on the way up in the elevator he begins to feel sick. Panic ensues when he vomits a bunny rabbit, and, while living in the apartment, each wave of anxiety produces another. Soon, he is sequestering ten bunny rabbits in an armoire. The rabbits sleep in the daytime and are awakened at night; he manages to keep his secret from his girlfriend’s nosy maid. The nocturnal insomnia and the constant production of bunny rabbits drive him to jump out the window along with the last one regurgitated. The charming letter is really a suicide note, and the seemingly eccentric but sweet story becomes a horrific account of phobia and insanity. “Axolotl” • Cortázar seems particularly fascinated with the unusual placement of animals in these stories. In “Bestiary” and “Letter to a Young Lady in Paris,” animals
Cortázar, Julio
313
take over the lives of people. In another short story, “Axolotl,” the man who visits the aquarium every day to see the axolotl swim becomes the axolotl. The narrative point of view switches back and forth between the man and the sea creature, telling the story from both points of view, but since there is no regular pattern or warning when the point of view changes, it is often difficult to determine inside whose skin readers are. The nightmare of being trapped inside the body of a beast is the human’s experience, and the panic of being abandoned by the man is the axolotl’s final cry. The only hope, as noted by the axolotl, is the creation of art where the writer can become another and communicate on behalf of all creatures—expressing the feelings of all creatures so that none may feel the terror of isolation and imprisonment. “All Fires the Fire” • The shifting of narrative point of view as well as the alternation of time and place is a technique that Cortázar developed during his career as an author. A later story, “All Fires the Fire,” revolves around two unhappy love triangles. One takes place in modern times and one during a gladiator fight in an ancient coliseum. Again, Cortázar uses animals to provide a menacing tone to what seem to be ordinary failures in romance. In both cases, raging blazes burn the lovers to death. No clear delineation is made when the story shifts scenes. The reader begins to sense these changes as the story unfolds; the scenes are different, but the tension never desists. The author creates deliberate ambiguity so that the reader, who is being intentionally confused by the author, nevertheless receives signals at the same time. Like the Symbolist writers whom he admired, Cortázar, in “All Fires the Fire,” understands the power of the suggestive image and insists that readers use their own senses to feel the intensity of hate, lust, and love in both triangles. Through smell, sound, and sight, the reader gets two complete and distinct pictures that have similar endings. Like the Surrealist writers who unraveled the varying layers of the mind, Cortázar here projects two events that occur at two different times in two different places yet at the same moment in the reader’s consciousness. “Blow-Up” • Through fractured narration, Cortázar is able to examine how the mind can appropriate different personalities and points of view in this story, which he first published as “Las babas del diablo.” The games of the mind are a constant theme in the works of Cortázar, and it is for that reason that a journey into his fictive world is an opportunity to explore the relationship between what seems to be real and what seems to be illogical. Cortázar confounds the reader’s system of beliefs with his manipulation of discourse. He begins the story “Blow-Up,” for example, by stating: “It’ll never be known how this has to be told, in the first person or in the second, using the third person plural or continually inventing modes that will serve for nothing.” He continues by telling readers how he writes—by typewriter—making them absolutely aware of the fact that they are going to enter the world of fiction. Although “Blow-Up” begins on this self-conscious trial, which seems to draw an obvious distinction between art and life, its actual theme is the interchangeability of the two. The narrator introduces the reader to the story’s hero, a French-Chilean photographer named Robert Michel, and then becomes him. The story is narrated alternatively in first-person “I” and third-person “he” and becomes a collage of identities. Out for a stroll on a pleasant November day, the photographer happens by chance upon a scene that disturbs him. Chance is an essential component of the world of
314
Short Story Writers
magic, the fantastic and the illogical in Cortázar’s short fiction. Chance rearranges preexisting order and creates a new future, past, and present for Cortázar’s characters. The photographer/narrator witnesses a brief moment between a young man, a woman, and an older man sitting in a car—another love triangle with menacing undertones—and creates a history of what might have brought all three to the quai near the Seine. After the particular episode, he creates a future for them of what might happen to each of them afterward. Later, when he himself reflects on the episode, he studies his photographs as if the moments were frozen in time. Strangely, the more he studies his enlargements the more his memory alters. Because he creates a fiction about each of the people involved, the photo and his involvement in their little dramas become fiction as well, and he is not at all certain of what he has witnessed. The whole episode develops into a dream, a game of the mind. The photographs that he had taken, which were supposed to reproduce reality with exactitude, become a collage of suggestions. Magnified, the photographs reveal even less about what he thought had occurred. The photographer believes that his camera is empowered with precision and with accuracy; he discovers, however, that the artwork has a life of its own that is constantly re-creating itself. The search for truth in art is the pervading theme in Julio Cortázar’s short fiction. He attempts to break with realist attitudes to force the reader to look beyond that which is ordinary and comfortable in order to explore the realms that seem, on the surface, incomprehensible and fearful. Cortázar believes that as human beings, people must recognize the inexplicable as just that and must admit that they do not have control over everything. The characters in “Bestiary” do not have control over the tiger. The young man in “Letter to a Young Lady in Paris” does not have control over the rabbits that he regurgitates. “All Fires the Fire” depicts the characters involved in passionate love triangles whose emotions are out of control. Finally, in “Blow-Up,” the artist’s work has a life of its own. It was the Symbolist movement that gave Cortázar his stylistic signature and the Surrealists who divulged the irrational to later artists. Cortázar combined his appreciation for both movements and consolidated them with his own voice to create exciting and challenging short fiction. Susan Nayel Other major works novels: Los premios, 1960 (The Winners, 1965); Rayuela, 1963 (Hopscotch, 1966); 62: Modelo para armar, 1968 (62: A Model Kit, 1972); Libro de Manuel, 1973 (A Manual for Manuel, 1978); El examen, wr. 1950, pb. 1986 (Final Exam., 2000) miscellaneous: La vuelta al día en ochenta mundos, 1967 (Around the Day in Eighty Worlds, 1986); Último round, 1969; Divertimiento, 1986. nonfiction: Buenos Aires Buenos Aires, 1968 (English translation, 1968); Último round, 1969; Viaje alrededor de una mesa, 1970; Prosa del observatorio, 1972 (with Antonio Galvez); Fantomas contra los vampiros multinacionales: Una utopía realizable, 1975; Literatura en la revolución y revolución en la literatura, 1976 (with Mario Vargas Llosa and Oscar Collazos); Paris: The Essence of Image, 1981; Los autonautas de la cosmopista, 1983; Nicaragua tan violentamente dulce, 1983 (Nicaraguan Sketches, 1989); Cartas, 2000 (3 volumes). poetry: Presencia, 1938 (as Julio Denís); Los reyes, 1949; Pameos y meopas, 1971; Salvo el crepúsculo, 1984.
Cortázar, Julio
315
translations: Robinson Crusoe, 1945 (of Daniel Defoe’s novel); El inmoralista, 1947 (of André Gide’s L’Immoraliste); El hombre que sabía demasiado, c. 1948-1951 (of G. K. Chesterton’s The Man Who Knew Too Much); Vida y Cartas de John Keats, c. 1948-1951 (of Lord Houghton’s Life and Letters of John Keats); Filosofía de la risa y del llanto, 1950 (of Alfred Stern’s Philosophie du rire et des pleurs); La filosofía de Sartre y el psicoanálisis existentialista, 1951 (of Stern’s Sartre, His Philosophy and Psychoanalysis). Bibliography Alazraki, Jaime, and Ivan Ivask, eds. The Final Island. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1978. Collection of essays, including two by Cortázar himself, about the role of magic or the marvelous as it works alongside what appears to be realism in Cortázar’s fiction. Contains a chronology and an extensive bibliography that offers data on Cortázar’s publications in several languages. Alonso, Carlos J., ed. Julio Cortázar: New Readings. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998. Part of the Cambridge Studies in Latin American and Iberian Literature series. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Garfield, Evelyn Picon. Julio Cortázar. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1975. Garfield begins and ends her study with personal interviews that she obtained with Cortázar at his home in Provence, France. She studies the neurotic obsession of the characters in Cortázar’s fiction and offers firsthand commentary by Cortázar on his methods of writing and his own experiences that helped create his work. Cortázar’s philosophies, his preferences, and even his own personal nightmares are expounded upon, illuminating much of the symbolism found in his work. Chronology, analysis, complete bibliography, and index. Guibert, Rita. Seven Voices: Seven Latin American Writers Talk to Rita Guibert. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1973. Includes an important interview with Cortázar, who discusses both his politics (his strenuous objection to U.S. interference in Latin America) and many of his fictional works. Hernandez del Castillo, Ana. Keats, Poe, and the Shaping of Cortázar’s Mythopoesis. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, 1981. Studies the influence of John Keats and Edgar Allan Poe on the work of Cortázar. The author states that of these two poets, whose works Cortázar translated, Poe had the greater influence on Cortázar. Studies the role of the archetypes in mythology and psychology and how they have been used in the works of all three writers. Contains an excellent index, which includes references that had an enormous impact on trends in the twentieth century. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these seven short stories by Cortázar: “Apocalypse at Solentiname,” “Axolotl,” and “Blow-Up” (vol. 1); “End of the Game” (vol. 2); “Instructions for John Howell” and “The Island at Noon” (vol. 4); and “The Southern Thruway” (vol. 7). Peavler, Terry J. Julio Cortázar. Boston: Twayne, 1990. Peavler divides Cortázar’s short fiction into four categories—the fantastic, the mysterious, the psychological, and the realistic—in order to show how Cortázar used these genres as games to study discourse. Includes a chronology and a through bibliography. Stavans, Ilan. Julio Cortázar: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1996. See especially the chapters on the influence of Jorge Luis Borges on Cortázar’s fiction, his use of the fantastic, and his reliance on popular culture. Stavans also has a sec-
316
Short Story Writers
tion on Cortázar’s role as writer and his interpretation of developments in Latin American literature. Includes chronology and bibliography. Sugano, Marian Zwerling. “Beyond What Meets the Eye: The Photographic Analogy in Cortázar’s Short Stories.” Style 27 (Fall, 1993): 332-351. Summarizes and critiques Cortazar’s analogy between the short story and photography in his essays, “Some Aspects of the Short Story” and “On the Short Story and Its Environs”; explains how Cortázar dramatizes the analogy in “Blow-Up” and “Apocalypse at Solentiname.” Yovanovich, Gordana. Julio Cortázar’s Character Mosaic: Reading the Longer Fiction. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1991. Three chapters focus on Cortázar’s four major novels and his fluctuating presentations of character as narrators, symbols, and other figures of language. Includes notes and bibliography.
317
Stephen Crane Born: Newark, New Jersey; November 1, 1871 Died: Badenweiler, Germany; June 5, 1900 Principal short fiction • The Little Regiment and Other Episodes of the American Civil War, 1896; The Open Boat, and Other Tales of Adventure, 1898; The Monster, and Other Stories, 1899; Whilomville Stories, 1900; Wounds in the Rain: War Stories, 1900; Last Words, 1902. Other literary forms • Stephen Crane began his brief writing life as a journalist, and he continued writing for newspapers, notably as a war correspondent, throughout his career, sometimes basing his short stories on events that he had first narrated in press reports. He also wrote raw-edged, realistic novels in which he employed journalistic techniques, most significantly in Maggie: A Girl of the Streets (1893) and The Red Badge of Courage: An Episode of the American Civil War (1895). By contrast, he composed wry, evocative, often cryptic poems, published in The Black Riders and Other Lines (1895) and War Is Kind (1899), that seemed to reveal the philosophy behind the world created in his fiction. Achievements • Stephen Crane’s fiction has proved hard to classify—not, however, because he defies categorization but because he worked in two nearly incompatible literary styles at once, while being a groundbreaker in both. On one hand, he founded the American branch of literary naturalism (this style had originated in France) in his early novels. These works emphasized the sordid aspects of modern life, noted the overpowering shaping influence of environment on human destiny, and scandalously discounted the importance of morality as an effective factor touching on his characters’ behavior. In this style, he was followed by writers such as Theodore Dreiser and Frank Norris. On the other hand, in these same early novels he developed a descriptive style that made him a founder of American impressionism. Although the naturalist component of his writing stressed how subjectivity was dominated by social forces, the impressionist component, through coloristic effects and vivid metaphors, stressed the heightened perceptions of individual characters from whose perspectives the story was presented. The man closest to Crane in his own time in developing this impressionist style was Joseph Conrad, though, it will be recognized, this method of drawing from a character’s viewpoint became a central tool of twentieth century literature and was prominently employed by authors such as William Faulkner, Virginia Woolf, and Henry James. Crane took the unusual tack of both playing up his characters’ points of view in presenting the world and downplaying the characters’ abilities to influence that world. Although this combination of strategies could be made to work satisfactorily, later authors who have taken Crane’s path have tended to develop only one of these strands. Moreover, many critics have found Crane’s dual emphases to be jarring and incompletely thought through, particularly in his novels. In fact, many have believed that it is only in his short stories that he seemed thoroughly to blend the two manners.
318
Short Story Writers
Biography • To some degree, Stephen Crane’s life followed a perverse pattern. He was acclaimed for the authenticity of his writings about events that he had never experienced and then spent the remainder of his few years experiencing the events that he had described in prose—often with disastrous consequences. Born on November 1, 1871, in Newark, New Jersey, Crane was the last child in the large family of a Methodist minister, Jonathan Townley Crane. The family moved frequently from parish to parish and, in 1878, came to Port Jervis, New York, in forested Sullivan County, where Crane would set most of his early stories. Two years later, his father died, and his mother had to begin struggling to support the family, doing church work and writing for religious publications. Crane determined to be a writer early in his life, and though he attended a few semesters at Lafayette College and then Syracuse University, his real interest in his college years was in soaking up the atmosphere of New York City lowlife and writing freelance articles for newspapers. In 1892, he completed his first novel, Maggie: A Girl of the Streets, the story of a young girl driven into streetwalking by a Bowery Romeo. This first novel was so shocking in tone and full of obscenity (in those days, this meant that it contained words such as “hell”) that it was rejected by respectable publishers. Borrowing money, Crane printed the book himself, and though it went unread and unsold, it garnered the appreciation of two of the outstanding literary figures of the day, Hamlin Garland and William Dean Howells. Crane’s next book, The Red Badge of Courage, a novel about the Civil War (18611865), brought him universal acclaim and celebrity status. In the year of the book’s publication, however, as if living out his fiction, he defended an unjustly accused prostitute against the corrupt New York City police, just as he had defended the poor prostitute Maggie in prose, and found undeserved blight attached to his name. From then on, life would be made difficult for him in New York City by the angered police force. Crane more or less abandoned New York at this point, easily enough since the authority of his army novel had placed him in much demand as a war correspondent. Going to Florida to wait for a ship to Cuba, where a rebellion against the Spanish colonialists was taking place, Crane met Cora Taylor, the madame of a house of ill repute who was to become his common-law wife. The ill-fated ship that he eventually boarded sank, and Crane barely escaped with his life, though, on the positive side, he produced from the experience what many consider his greatest short story, “The Open Boat.” As if to show that he could describe real wars as well as he could imagine them, he began shuttling from battle to battle as a reporter, first going to the Greco-Turkish War and then back to view the Spanish-American War, ruining his health in the process. Between wars, he stayed in the manorial Brede Place in England, where he became acquainted with a number of other expatriates who lived in the area, including Joseph Conrad, Harold Frederic, and Henry James. Crane’s problems with the police and the irregularity of his liaison with Cora Taylor—she could not get a divorce from her long-estranged husband—would have made it difficult for Crane to live in his homeland, so in 1899, he settled at the manor for good. Sick and beset with financial woes brought on by extravagant living and an openhanded generosity to visitors, he wrote feverishly but unavailingly to clear his debts. He died the next year from tuberculosis, after having traveled to the Continent to seek a cure.
Crane, Stephen Analysis • Perhaps because his writing career was so short, critics have devoted much space to Stephen Crane’s slight, decidedly apprentice series of sketches collectively entitled The Sullivan County Tales. One trait that the sketches do have in their favor is that they contain all the facets of style and theme that Crane was to utilize as his writing developed. The reader finds the overbearing power of the environment, the vivid descriptions, the premise that these descriptions reflect the heightened consciousness of a character or characters, and the idea that this very heightening involves a distortion of perception that needs to be overcome for the characters’ adequate adjustment to, and comprehension of, reality. Also of significance is that these stories are generally concerned with the actions of four campers and hence reflect not only on individual psychology but also on the psychology of group dynamics. This was also to become a focus of Crane’s writing.
319
Library of Congress
“Four Men in a Cave” • In one of the better pieces from this series, “Four Men in a Cave,” a quartet of campers decides to explore a cave in order to have something to brag about when they return to the city. Their scarcely concealed fears about the expedition are rendered by Crane’s enlivening of stalactites that jab down at them and stalagmites that shoot up at them from crevices. At the end of their path, they find a hermit who invites them to a game of poker, but their fear-stoked imaginations visualize the gamester as a ghoul or Aztec priest. Only later after escaping the cave, in a comic denouement, do they learn of the cave dweller’s true identity, that of a mad farmer who took to solitude when he lost his land and wife through gambling. By this time, there seems to be little to brag about, since what has happened has exposed their cowardice and credulity. The story provides an early example of the rough-and-ready combination of impressionist subjectivity, in how the descriptions in the piece are tinged by the campers’ fears, and naturalist objectivity, in how the overwhelming environment of the cave, for part of the story, controls the men’s action while dwarfing them. Further, the piece indicates the way, as Crane sees it, emotions can be constructed collectively, as when each camper tells the others how he has misidentified the hermit, adding to the growing hysteria. “An Experiment in Misery” • In 1894, Crane published a maturer story, “An Experiment in Misery,” in which he transposed the narrative of a cave journey into a serious study of urban social conditions. In the originally printed version of the piece, two
320
Short Story Writers
middle-class men observe tramps and speculate about their motives and feelings. On impulse, the younger man decides to dress as a tramp in order to penetrate their secrets. (Such a tactic, of disguising oneself to uncover hidden areas of society, was a common practice of crusading reporters at that time.) In the later, revised version of this story, the one that is more commonly known, Crane removed the beginning and ending that reveal the protagonist to be slumming; yet, though his social origins are obscured, the story still concerns a neophyte who knows nothing of the life of the underclass and who is being initiated into the ways of the Bowery slums. The high point of the tale, corresponding to the cave exploration, is the hero’s entrance into an evil-smelling flophouse. He has trouble sleeping in the noisome room, for his keyed-up fancy sees morbid, highly romanticized symbols everywhere. He understands the shriek of a nightmare-tossed sleeper as a metaphoric protest of the downtrodden. Awakening the next morning, the protagonist barely remarks on the stench, and this seems to indicate that, merely through familiarity, some of the falsely romantic pictures that he has entertained about the life of the city’s poorest have begun to rub off. Exactly what positive things he has learned and of what value such learning will be to him are never clear and, indeed, as Crane grew, while his stories still turned on the loss of illusions, they began to lose the dogmatic assurance that such a change is necessarily for the good. The last scene of the sketch, though, does make a more definite point, this one about the nature of groups. The hero has begun to associate with a fellow tramp called the assassin and now, after his initiatory night, seems both adjusted to his new station and accepted by the tramp world, at least insofar as the assassin is willing to regale him with his life story. By abandoning his preconceptions about poverty, the protagonist has quite seamlessly fitted himself into the alien milieu, yet this joining of one community has a negative side effect of distancing him from another. The last tableau has the assassin and the hero lounging on park benches as the morning rushhour crowd streams by them. Here, soon after the hero has had the comfortable feeling of being accepted in one society, he has the poignant realization that, as a bum, he no longer belongs to the larger American working world. There is even a sly hint, given by the fact that the youth begins employing the same grandiose, romanticized terms in depicting his separation from the business world that he had earlier used to depict the flophouse, that he has embarked on a new course of building delusions. In other words, his loss of illusions about the reality of tramp life has been counteracted (as if a vacuum needed to be filled) by the imbibing of a new set of illusions about the vast gulf between the classes. Each community one may join seems to have its own supply of false perspectives. “The Open Boat” • In 1897, after his near death at sea, Crane produced what most name his greatest short story and what some even rank as his supreme achievement, placing it above his novels. This is “The Open Boat.” Again there are four men. They are in a small boat, a dinghy, escapees from a sunken vessel, desperately trying to row to shore in heavy seas. The famed first sentence establishes both the parameters of the fictional world and a new chastening of Crane’s style. It reads, “None of them knew the color of the sky.” Literally, they are too intent on staying afloat to notice the heavens; figuratively, in this godless universe the men cannot look to the sky for help but must rely on their own muscles and wits, which, against the elements, are little enough. Furthermore,
Crane, Stephen
321
the opening’s very dismissal of color descriptions, given that much of Crane’s earlier work, such as The Red Badge of Courage, depends heavily on color imagery, can be seen as the author’s pledge to restrain some of the flashiness of his style. This restraint is evident not only in a more tempered use of language here but also in the nature of the protagonists’ delusions. In works such as the slum experiment, the romanticized preconceptions that determine the protagonist’s viewpoint can be seen as trivial products of a shallow culture—that is, as marginal concerns—whereas in the sea story, the men’s illusions are necessities of life. The men in the boat want to believe that they must survive, since they have been fighting so hard. If they do not believe this, how can they continue rowing? The point is put wrenchingly at one moment when the men refuse to accept that they will drown, as it seems they will, in the breakers near the shore. Such illusions (about the meaningfulness of valor and effort) obviously have more universal relevance than others with which Crane has dealt, and that is why the story strikes so deep; the illusions also, ingeniously, tie in with readers’ expectations. As much as readers begin to identify with the four men (and they are sympathetically portrayed), they will want them to survive and thus will be on the verge of agreeing to their illusions. Thus, Crane engineers a remarkable and subtle interlocking of readers’ and characters’ beliefs. Furthermore, the functionality of the possibly delusive beliefs of the struggling men—that is, the fact that they need to believe that they will make it ashore to keep up the arduous fight for life—helps Crane to a fuller, more positive view of human community. The men in the cave were merely partners in error, but these toilers share a belief system that sustains them in their mutually supportive labor, which the characters themselves recognize as “a subtle brotherhood of men.” The men’s shared recognition of the supportive structure of human groups gives weight to the story’s last phrase, which says, of the three survivors who have reached land, “and they felt that they could then be interpreters.” The story, written in the third person, is given largely from the viewpoint of one of the four, a newspaper correspondent. This is not evident at once, however, since the narrative begins by simply objectively reporting the details of the men’s struggle to stay afloat and reproducing their laconic comments. In this way, the group is put first, and only later, when the correspondent’s thoughts are revealed, does the reader learn of his centrality as the story begins to be slightly colored by his position. What the focus on his consciousness reveals, aiding Crane in deepening his presentation, is how the subtle brotherhood is felt individually. After rowing near to the shore but not being able to attract anyone’s attention, the crew settle down for a night at sea. While whoever is rowing stays awake, the others sleep like the dead they may soon become, and at this point, the story dwells more intently on the correspondent’s outlook as he takes his turn at the oars. The newspaperman reconsiders the beliefs that have been keeping them afloat, seeing the weakness in them and accepting, now that he is alone, the possibility of an ironic death— that is, one coming in sight of shore after their courageous struggle. Yet his existential angst, an acknowledgment that there is no special heavenly providence, neither stops him from his muscle-torturing rowing nor diminishes his revived illusions on the morrow, when they again all breast the waves together. If this line of reasoning shows him mentally divorcing himself from the collective ideology, another night thought implies that, in another direction, he is gaining a deeper sense of solidarity. He remembers a verse that he had learned in school about a legionnaire dying far from home with only a comrade to share his last moments.
322
Short Story Writers
The correspondent had thought little of the poem, both because he had never been in extremis (and so saw little to the pathos of the case) and, as Crane notes, had formerly looked cynically at his fellows (and so had found unpalatable or unbelievable the care of one soldier for another). A day’s experience in the dinghy has made him keenly aware of the two aspects of experience that he had overlooked or undervalued, and thus has given him a clear understanding of the networks (those of democratic brotherhood) and circumstances (a no-holds-barred fight against an indifferent universe) that underlie the human social world. This understanding can be applied in many ways, not only toward a grasp of group interaction but also toward an interpretation of honest art. Still, the most telling incident of his lonely watch is not so much any of his thoughts as an action. The boat, the correspondent finds, has become the magnet to a huge shark. Achingly, he wishes that one of his fellow sailors were awake to share his fidgety vigil; yet, he resists any impulse he has to rouse them or even to question aloud whether any of them is conscious for fear that he should waken a sleeper. Even if alone he cannot continue with the group illusion, he can, though alone, effortlessly maintain the group’s implicit morality, which holds that each should uncomplainingly shoulder as much of the burden as possible, while never revealing irritation or fear. Much later, the newspaperman learns that another of the four, the captain, was awake and aware of the predator’s presence during what had been taken to be the correspondent’s moment of isolated anguish. The hidden coexistent alertness of the captain suggests the ongoing mutuality of the group that undergirds even seemingly isolated times of subjectivity. To bring this story in line with the last one mentioned, it is worth noting that the small group in the boat is contrasted to a group on shore just as, in “An Experiment in Misery,” the hoboes were contrasted to the society of the gainfully employed. When the rowers are near the coast on the first day, they vainly hope to attract the ministering attentions of people on land. They do attract their attention, but the people, tourists from a hotel, merrily wave at them, thinking that the men in the dinghy are fishermen. The heedlessness, inanity, and seeming stupidity of the group on shore compare unfavorably with the hard-won, brave alertness of the boatmen, pointing to the fact that the small group’s ethical solidarity is not of a type with the weaker unity found in the larger society. The men’s deep harmony rather—beautiful as it is—is something that can be found only in pockets. The depicting of the community on the land foreshadows elements of Crane’s later, darker pictures of community, as in “The Blue Hotel,” where what sustains a group is not a life-enhancing though flimsy hope but a tacitly accepted lie. “The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky” • In the year that he wrote “The Open Boat” and the next year, Crane was to compose three other brilliant stories, two of which dealt with myths of the Old West. Both these Western tales were written in his mature, unadorned style, and both continued his focus on the belief systems of communities. What is new to them is a greater flexibility in the handling of plot. Previously, he had simply followed his characters through a continuous chronological sequence from start to finish; now, however, he began shifting between differently located character groups and jumping around in time. In “The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky,” the action begins on a train moving through Texas, carrying Yellow Sky’s sheriff, Jack Potter, and his new wife back to town. Potter is apprehensive about his reception, since he has married out of town in a whirlwind
Crane, Stephen
323
courtship and none of the townspeople knows of his new status. The scene shifts to the interior of a Yellow Sky saloon, where the gathered, barricaded patrons have other things to be apprehensive about than Potter’s marriage. Scratchy Wilson, the local ruffian, has gotten drunk and is shooting in the main street, while, as the bar’s occupants admit, the only man able to cow him is the absent sheriff. Scratchy Wilson himself, as the reader learns in another scene shift, not aware of Potter’s trip, is truculently looking for the sheriff so that they can engage in a showdown. In truth, the reader, knowing of Potter’s imminence, will probably share Wilson’s expectation of a gun battle, which is not an unreasonable forecast of the plot’s unfolding. Yet, this expectation is founded on a deeper belief, that the West will always be an uncivilized place of outlaws and pistols. A chagrined Scratchy recognizes that this belief is invalid and that an era has passed when he finds that the sheriff has taken a wife. After meeting the couple, he holsters his guns and stalks off toward the horizon. “The Blue Hotel” • A tragic variation on similar themes of violence and community beliefs appears in “The Blue Hotel,” a story that a few critics rank in importance above “The Open Boat.” The tale concerns a fatalistic traveler, the Swede, who stops for the night in a hotel in Nebraska. (This protagonist’s name will be picked up by Ernest Hemingway, a Crane admirer, for an equally fatalistic character in his short-story masterpiece “The Killers.”) Through the Swede’s conversation with the hotel owner, Scully, and other stoppers, it appears that, based perhaps on an immersion in dime novels, the Swede thinks that this town—or, for that matter, any town in the West—is a hotbed of bloodshed and mayhem. After his fears seem to be allayed by the officious owner, who assures him that he is mistaken, the Swede overreacts by becoming boisterous and familiar. This mood of his eventually dissipates when, involved in a game of cards, he accuses the owner’s son of cheating. The upshot is that the pair engage in a fistfight, which the Swede wins. He is now triumphant but can no longer find any welcome at the hotel; so he wanders off to a nearby saloon, in which his even more high-strung and aggressive demonstrations lead to his death at the hands of an icy but violent gambler he had been prodding to drink with him. At this point, the story seems a grim meditation on the truth or falsity of myths. What seemed to be the manifestly absurd belief of the Swede has been proven partially true by his own death. Yet, it appears this truth would never have been exposed except for the Swede’s own pushy production of the proper circumstances for Western violence to emerge. There is, however, another turn of the cards. A final scene is described in which, months later, two of the hotel’s card players, witnesses of the dispute between the Swede and Scully’s son, discuss events of that fateful evening. One of them, the easterner, claims that the whole group collected at the hotel that night is responsible for what led to the death since they all knew that the owner’s son was cheating but did not back up the Swede when he accused the youth. In one way, this final episode indicates that perhaps the Swede’s suspicions were accurate in yet another sense; the whole town is made up, metaphorically, of killers in that the community is willing to sacrifice an outsider to maintain its own dubious harmony. From this angle, though, this Western town’s particular violence merely crystallizes and externalizes any hypocritical town’s underlying psychic economy. (Crane depicted this economy more explicitly in his novella The Monster.) In another way— and here the increasing complexity of Crane’s thought on community is evident— even after the final episode, it still appears that the Swede’s murder has some justification.
324
Short Story Writers
There are two points to be made in this connection. For one, throughout the story, Crane represents the frailty of human existence as it is established on the prairies in the depths of winter. The story begins by underlining the presumptuousness of Scully’s hotel’s bright blue color, not so much as it may be an affront to the other, staider buildings in town, but in its assertiveness against the grimness of the white wastes of nature surrounding and swamping the little burg. The insignificance of human beings measured against the universe is explicitly stated by Crane in an oftquoted passage. He speaks of humans clinging to a “whirling, fire-smitten, icelocked, disease-stricken, space-lost bulb.” He goes on to say that the “conceit of man” in striving to prevail in such conditions is “the very engine of life.” It is true that they all killed the Swede in some sense, but the fragility of the human community, it may be surmised, demands that its members all practice respect and forbearance toward one another so that a common front can be presented against uncaring nature. If anyone consistently violates this unwritten code, as the Swede does, he must be eliminated for group self-preservation. It is significant in this light that the Swede, who demands a grudge match with the owner’s son, would take the men away from the large, redhot stove (symbol of the warmth of peaceful intercourse and home comfort) outside to fight in subzero weather. To restate this, for his own egotistical purposes, the Swede would drag everyone into a much greater exposure to a harsh environment than life in the community, were it running harmoniously, would ever make necessary. The second point to be made is that Crane’s portrait of the gambler, which interrupts the narrative at a high point and which, thus, seems at first sight a cumbersome miscalculation by the author, allows the reader a fuller understanding of the place of an outsider in this Western society. If readers were given only the Swede’s treatment to go by, they would be forced to conclude that, whatever the necessity of the visitor’s expulsion, this town has little tolerance for aberrant personalities. Yet, such a position has to be modified after Crane’s presentation of the gambler, whose disreputable calling excludes him from the city’s better social functions but whose behavior in other areas—he bows to the restrictions put on him with good grace and is a charitable family man who will not prey on the better citizens—conforms enough to standards to allow him to be generally accepted. Intervening at this point, Crane’s portrayal of this second (relative) outsider is used to indicate that the community will permit in its midst a character who has not followed all of its rules, provided such a character does not, as the Swede does, insistently and continuously breach the accepted norms. All this taken together does not, certainly, excuse a murder. What it does show is that Crane’s understanding of how a community sustains itself has expanded beyond the understanding that he had at the time of the sea story. He indicates that the guiding principle of mutual support found in the dinghy has remained operative, even in a far less threatened situation, while adding that violations of this principle can lead to less happy consequences than might have been foreseen in the earlier story. “Death and the Child” • Finally, in “Death and the Child,” Crane produced an excellent story about war, the topic which had been both the most consistent and the least successful subject of his short pieces. The intertwined themes of the effect of illusions and the ways that an individual can be integrated into, or excluded from, a community, the most important themes of Crane’s work, are again central. In this piece, the character who nurses illusions is Peza, a journalist who has decided to join the Greek side during the Greco-Turkish War, motivated by unrealistic ideas about
Crane, Stephen
325
the glories of classical Greece and the adventure of fighting. Once he reaches the battle lines, however, he finds it impossible to join the other combatants. He is displeased by the nonchalance of the troops, who refuse to strike heroic poses, but what actually ends up turning him away from solidarity is his realization that to become part of the group he must accept not only a largely humdrum life but also the possibility of a prosaic death. In other words, it is not coming down to earth with the common men that ultimately scares him but the understanding that he may have to come down under the earth (into a grave) with them. The story exhibits what had become the traits of Crane’s mature style. He writes with a terse, crisp, subdued prose that is occasionally shot through with startling or picturesque imagery, this imagery being the residue of his initial, more flowery style. Crane also exhibits a mastery of plotting. This is brought out by the careful joining of Peza’s emotional states to his gyrations around the battle camp as well as by the story’s final encounter, where Peza comes upon an abandoned child, who, too young to comprehend war, still has a clearer view of reality than the distraught journalist. This skill at plotting is not something that Crane possessed from the beginning, which brings up a last point. It might be said that there is a chronological distinction between Crane’s interests and his method of narration. Although his thematic concerns remained constant throughout his writing career, as he grew older his attention to how a community was created and sustained grew in weight. His ability to construct complex plots is one that he picked up during the course of his creative life. There are authors who advance little after their first books, but in Crane’s case, it can definitely be said that there was a promise for the future that his short life never redeemed. James Feast Other major works plays: The Blood of the Martyr, wr. 1898?, pb. 1940; The Ghost, pr. 1899 (with Henry James; fragment). novels: Maggie: A Girl of the Streets, 1893; The Red Badge of Courage: An Episode of the American Civil War, 1895; George’s Mother, 1896; The Third Violet, 1897; The Monster, 1898 (serial), 1899 (novella; pb. in The Monster, and Other Stories); Active Service, 1899; The O’Ruddy: A Romance, 1903 (with Robert Barr). nonfiction: The Great Battles of the World, 1901; The War Dispatches of Stephen Crane, 1964. poetry: The Black Riders and Other Lines, 1895; A Souvenir and a Medley, 1896; War Is Kind, 1899; The University Press of Virginia Edition of the Works of Stephen Crane, 1970 (volume 10). Bibliography Benfey, Christopher E. G. The Double Life of Stephen Crane. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1992. Narrative of Crane’s life and literary work that argues that the writer attempted to live the life his works portrayed. Includes bibliography and index. Berryman, John. Stephen Crane: A Critical Biography. Cooper Square Press, 2001. Reissue of the first major biography of the author, first published in 1950. Still valuable for its detail and insight. Colvert, James B. Stephen Crane. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1984. This biography, aimed specifically at the nonspecialist, is highly readable and is en-
326
Short Story Writers
hanced by numerous illustrations. Its bibliography is limited but well selected. The author’s research is impeccable. ____________. “Stephen Crane and Postmodern Theory.” American Literary Realism 28 (Fall, 1995): 4-22. A survey of postmodern approaches to Crane’s fiction. Summarizes the basic premises of postmodern interpretation, examining how these premises have been applied to such Crane stories as “The Open Boat,” “The Upturned Face,” and “Maggie”; balances such interpretive strategies against critics who affirm more traditional, humanistic approaches. Halliburton, David. The Color of the Sky: A Study of Stephen Crane. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1989. Though somewhat thematically disorganized, the author’s philosophical grounding and ability to look at Crane’s works from unusual angles make for many provocative readings. In his discussion of “The Blue Hotel,” for example, he finds much more aggression directed against the Swede than may at first appear, coming not only from seemingly benign characters but also from the layout of the town. Notes, index. Knapp, Bettina L. Stephen Crane. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1987. Succinct introduction to Crane’s life and career, with a separate chapter on his biography, several chapters on his fiction, and an extensive discussion of two poetry collections, The Black Riders and Other Lines and War Is Kind. Includes a detailed chronology, a bibliography of primary and secondary sources, and an index. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Crane: “The Blue Hotel” and “The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky” (vol. 1), “Death and the Child” and “An Episode of War” (vol. 2), “An Experiment in Misery” (vol. 3), “The Monster” and “The Open Boat” (vol. 5), and “The Upturned Face” (vol. 8). Metress, Christopher. “From Indifference to Anxiety: Knowledge and the Reader in ‘The Open Boat.’” Studies in Short Fiction 28 (Winter, 1991): 47-53. Shows how the structure of “The Open Boat” (made up of four key moments) creates an epistemological dilemma for readers, moving them from a position of indifference to a state of epistemological anxiety. By suggesting that the survivors have become interpreters, Crane implies that one must get rid of indifference to the difficulty of gaining knowledge and embrace the inevitable anxiety of that failure. Robertson, Michael. Stephen Crane: Journalism and the Making of Modern American Literature. New York: Columbia University Press, 1997. Argues that Crane’s success inspired later journalists to think of their work as preparatory for writing fiction; claims the blurring of fact and fiction in newspapers during Crane’s life suited his own narrative experiments. Wertheim, Stanley. A Stephen Crane Encyclopedia. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1997. Very thorough volume of Crane information. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Wolford, Chester L., Jr. Stephen Crane: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1989. This overly brief but useful look at Crane’s short fiction provides Wolford’s sensitive readings as well as commentary on the major points that have been raised in critical discussions of the Crane pieces. In describing “The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky,” for example, Wolford explains his view of how the story fits into the archetypical patterns of the passing of the West narratives, while also exploring why other critics have seen Crane’s story as a simple parody.
327
Walter de la Mare Born: Charlton, Kent, England; April 25, 1873 Died: Twickenham, Middlesex, England; June 22, 1956 Principal short fiction • Story and Rhyme: A Selection, 1921; The Riddle, and Other Stories, 1923; Ding Dong Bell, 1924; Broomsticks, and Other Tales, 1925; Miss Jemima, 1925; Readings, 1925-1926 (2 volumes); The Connoisseur, and Other Tales, 1926; Old Joe, 1927; Told Again: Traditional Tales, 1927; On the Edge, 1930; Seven Short Stories, 1931; The Lord Fish, 1933; The Nap, and Other Stories, 1936; The Wind Blows Over, 1936; Animal Stories, 1939; The Picnic, 1941; The Best Stories of Walter de la Mare, 1942; The Old Lion, and Other Stories, 1942; The Magic Jacket, and Other Stories, 1943; The Scarecrow, and Other Stories, 1945; The Dutch Cheese, and Other Stories, 1946; Collected Stories for Children, 1947; A Beginning, and Other Stories, 1955; Ghost Stories, 1956; Short Stories, 1927-1956, 2001 (Giles de la Mare, editor). Other literary forms • In addition to his numerous volumes of short fiction, Walter de la Mare published poetry, novels, anthologies of various kinds, collections of essays, one play, and scores of essays, reviews, and articles published separately. In the United States, de la Mare is better known as a children’s writer than he is for the other genres in which he worked. Achievements • Walter de la Mare’s remarkable literary career spans more than five decades. The English novelist, poet, dramatist, short-story writer, critic, essayist, and anthropologist is best known today as a writer infused with a Romantic imagination. He has often been compared to William Blake and Thomas Hardy because of similarities in thematic development of mortality and visionary illumination. Often labeled as an escapist because of his retreat from reality, de la Mare touches on dreams, fantasy worlds, emotional states, and transcendent pursuits. Best known in the United States for his children’s literature, he has produced numerous volumes of prose and verse in the genre. All his work is suffused by a childlike quality of imagination. De la Mare’s writings have still not received the attention they deserve. He lived a quiet, uneventful life, always reluctant to impart information about himself. Throughout his life de la Mare wrote poetry. It is this work that represents his truest and most lasting literary achievement. In 1948, de la Mare received the Companion of Honour and in 1953, the Order of Merit. During the next three years he also received honorary degrees from five colleges, including Oxford and Cambridge. Biography • Walter de la Mare was born on April 25, 1873, in Charlton, Kent, the son of well-to-do parents, James Edward de la Mare and Lucy Sophia Browning de la Mare. In her book Walter de la Mare (1966), Doris Ross McCrosson said that de la Mare’s life “was singularly and refreshingly uneventful.” De la Mare was educated at St. Paul’s Cathedral Choir School in London, where he was the founder and editor of the school magazine, The Choristers’ Journal. In 1890, at the age of seventeen, de la Mare began working as a bookkeeper at the Anglo-American Oil Company in London, a position he held for almost twenty years. While working as a bookkeeper, de la Mare began
328
Short Story Writers writing stories, essays, and poetry, many of which were published in various magazines. For a while, de la Mare wrote under the pseudonym “Walter Ramal.” Soon after the publication of his first books, he was granted a civil list pension by the British government amounting to one hundred pounds a year. Thereafter, he devoted himself entirely to literature and writing. De la Mare died at home on June 22, 1956, at the age of eighty-three. He is buried at St. Paul’s Cathedral.
Analysis • Walter de la Mare’s stories take the form both of wish fulfillment and nightmare projections. Believing that the everyday world of mundane experience is a veil hiding a “real” world, de la Mare used dream forms as a means of piercing the veil as well as a means of suggesting that between dream and reality looms, as de la Mare said, “no impassable Library of Congress abyss.” Because of their hallucinatory character, dreams merge with states of madness, travel to mysterious realms, childhood visions. The surfaces of de la Mare’s stories belie an underlying reality; rendering the texture of everyday experience with exquisite detail, he built his surfaces with such lucidity that a reader is often surprised to find a horror beneath that which is apparently placid or a joy beneath that which is apparently mundane. “The Riddle” • “The Riddle” starts like a fairy tale with such lightness and grace that one might expect a “happy ever after” ending. Soon, however, it becomes apparent that the quavering voice of the grandmother betokens something more than age, and the gifts she presents to her seven grandchildren become something more than sugar plums. Although it is never made explicit, one may assume that the grandchildren have come to live with their grandmother because of the death of their parents. The aged woman says to the children,“bring me smiling faces that call back to my mind my own son Harry.” The children are told they may come in the presence of their grandmother twice a day—in the morning and in the evening. The rest of the time they have the run of the house with the exception of the large spare bedroom where there stands in a corner an old oak chest, older than the aged woman’s own grandmother. The chest represents death. It is later revealed to be decorated as a coffin, and it attracts the children one by one. Harry is first. Opening the chest, he finds something strangely seductive that reminds him of his mother, so he climbs in and the lid miraculously closes. When the other children tell their grandmother of Harry’s dis-
De la Mare, Walter
329
appearance, she responds, “Then he must be gone away for a time. . . . But remember, all of you, do not meddle with the oak chest.” Now it becomes apparent that the grandmother, herself so close to death that she seems more feeble every day, is also to be identified with the oak chest and that rather than a good fairy dispensing sugarplums she is a wicked witch seducing the children to their death. Ann is the last child to be called to the chest, and she walks as if in a dream and as if she were being guided by the hand. One paragraph more ends the story. With the children all gone, the grandmother enters the spare room, but her eyesight is too dim for her to see, and her mind is a tangled skein of memories which include memories of little children. “The Orgy” • “The Orgy: An Idyll” seems an entirely different kind of story. Rather than being set in a house with myriad rooms suggesting something of the gothic, “The Orgy” is set mainly in a large and elegant department store in London; rather than beginning with a “once upon a time” element, it opens on a bright May morning, crisp, brisk, scintillating. Details of the great packed street down which Philip walks leave readers no doubt that here is the world of their own experience. Before the action is ended, however, it becomes clear that the story is an extravaganza. Philip is engaged in a buying orgy, charging everything that strikes his fancy to the account of his uncle who has just disinherited him, and the orgy is a fanciful idyll of the wish fulfillment variety. Philip’s desire for revenge projected into bright, hallucinatory images is carried into action in exactly the way the uncle will understand—to the tune of “a couple of hundred thousand pounds,” a considerable amount of money in 1931, the year the story was published. “In the Forest” • “In the Forest” is a brilliant exercise in point of view restricted to the mind of a small boy in such a way that the childlike behavior and lack of perception characteristic of the very young take on the aura of nightmare. At no time does de la Mare vary the focus; no words are used that a child could not know; no insight is offered that a child could not understand. Although the child occasionally feels a twinge of guilt because he has not obeyed his mother, he is completely impervious to the horror of the action going on around him. The story opens when the boy’s father is leaving to go to war. The boy is half asleep and is moving in and out of consciousness. It is the advent of the fall of the year, and a storm has brought down leaves that are still green from the trees. Although the leaves are still green, it is getting cold. The boy asks his father to bring him a gun back from the war and notices without comment that his father, instead of leaving immediately, keeps coming back to say good-bye. Unaware of the anguish being suffered by his father and mother, the boy asks his mother if she is glad his father is going to the war. The mother does not answer, but the boy’s simple statement makes the point. “But she was crying over the baby, so I went out into the forest till dinner.” Later the boy chops wood, an activity that causes him to be hot and excited, and then he brings the logs into the house. The wind is roaring as if it is angry, more leaves are falling, and the weather is cold and misty. The boy finds his mother asleep with the baby in her arms, and the baby, too, is asleep, although, as the boy notices, the baby scarcely seems to be breathing. The boy falls asleep by the warm hearth and stays there all night. In the morning he rushes out, glad that his father is gone, because now he can do just as he pleases. Visiting the snares, he finds a young rabbit caught by one leg and, imitating his father, kills the hare with a crack on the neck and
330
Short Story Writers
carries it to the house by the hind legs. Later he wonders how “they would carry back” his father’s body “if he was killed in the war.” Because the baby is crying, the boy chooses to spend his days in the forest until one day when he tells his mother he is going to “bring her some fish for dinner!” The dialogue that follows is the first that occurs in the story. The mother tells the boy that the baby is very ill and tries to get him to touch and hold his baby brother, asking: “Do you love it?” The boy shakes his head and persists: “I think I should like to go fishing mother . . . and I promise you shall have the biggest I catch.” Then, denying the mother’s plea that he go for the doctor, the boy runs out saying, “It’s only crying.” The boy catches no fish and believes the fish would not bite because he has been wicked, so he goes home, and now for the first time he hears cannons on the other side of the forest. When he gets home, he finds his mother angry, calling him a coward, and the baby dead. The next day he consents to his mother’s request that he go for the sexton, but as he is on his way he hears a rifle sound and “a scream like a rabbit,” and he is frightened and runs home. Since his mother has already called him a coward, however, he lies to her, telling her the sexton was gone. Now the mother decides she must take the dead baby to the graveyard herself, and once again she addresses her son: “Won’t you kiss your little brother, Robbie?” Alone, the boy eats more than he should and builds the fire up so high that its noise drowns out any outside noises. Alone, he believes he is in a dream “that would never come to an end.” He does not cry, but he feels angry at being left alone, and he is afraid. He also feels guilty about the amount of food he has consumed. He fears his mother’s return and yet longs for her, feeling that he loves her and is sorry for his wickedness. The next thing he knows, it is broad daylight. His mother has still not returned, but he hears a groan at the doorway. It is his father with a “small hole” at the back of his shoulder; dark, thick blood covers the withered leaves on which he lies. The boy tries to give his father water and tells him about the baby, “but he didn’t show that he could hear anything.” Then the boy hears his mother coming back and runs out to tell her “that it was father.” The story ends as abruptly as it begins, but the point of view so neatly restricted and the image patterns masterfully arranged create the tenor and vehicle of an Everyman’s Freudian nightmare. The subtly stated but powerfully conveyed theme delineates an Oedipal pattern that raises the story from an isolated and factual experience to an overwhelming and communal dream having mythic proportions. “An Ideal Craftsman” • “An Ideal Craftsman” is just as powerful. Although the story makes use of a young boy as protagonist, point of view is different from that found in “In the Forest.” This time de la Mare allows an omniscient narrator to move in and out of the consciousness of the two major characters. Once again, however, a horror is present, foreshadowed from the beginning of the story; once again the aura of dream is cast over the entire story; and once again death, this time murder, is the focal point of the story. For a short-story writer of such consummate skill, de la Mare has attracted almost no critical attention, and what books have been written about him concentrate more on his other writings than on his pieces of short fiction. This lack of attention is a great pity. In her book Walter de la Mare, McCrosson devotes only one chapter of some twenty pages to de la Mare’s short-story craft, but her summary of his achievement is accurate:
De la Mare, Walter
331
His preoccupation with good and evil puts him on a level with [Nathaniel] Hawthorne and [Joseph] Conrad; his mastery of suspense and terror is equal to [Edger Allen] Poe’s; the subtlety of his characterizations occasionally rivals [Henry] James’s. And the range of his portrayals is impressive: children, old maids, the demented, old idealists and young pessimists, artists, business men, dandys, young women in love—all of whom share in the mysterious and sometimes maddening business called living. Mary Rohrberger With updates by Terry Theodore Other major works play: Crossings: A Fairy Play, pr. 1919. anthologies: Come Hither, 1923; The Shakespeare Songs, 1929; Christina Rossetti’s Poems, 1930; Desert Islands and Robinson Crusoe, 1930; Stories from the Bible, 1930; Early One Morning in the Spring, 1935; Animal Stories, 1939; Behold, This Dreamer!, 1939; Love, 1943. novels: Henry Brocken, 1904; The Return, 1910; The Three Mulla-Mulgars, 1910 (reprinted as The Three Royal Monkeys: Or, The Three Mulla-Mulgars, 1935); Memoirs of a Midget, 1921; At First Sight: A Novel, 1928. nonfiction: Rupert Brooke and the Intellectual Imagination, 1919; The Printing of Poetry, 1931; Lewis Carroll, 1932; Poetry in Prose, 1936; Pleasures and Speculations, 1940; Chardin, J.B.S. 1699-1779, 1948; Private View, 1953. poetry: Songs of Childhood, 1902; Poems, 1906; A Child’s Day: A Book of Rhymes, 1912; The Listeners, and Other Poems, 1912; Peacock Pie: A Book of Rhymes, 1913; The Sunken Garden, and Other Poems, 1917; Motley, and Other Poems, 1918; Flora: A Book of Drawings, 1919; Poems 1901 to 1918, 1920; Story and Rhyme, 1921; The Veil, and Other Poems, 1921; Down-Adown-Derry: A Book of Fairy Poems, 1922; Thus Her Tale, 1923; A Ballad of Christmas, 1924; Stuff and Nonsense and So On, 1927; Self to Self, 1928; The Snowdrop, 1929; News, 1930; Poems for Children, 1930; Lucy, 1931; Old Rhymes and New, 1932; The Fleeting, and Other Poems, 1933; Poems, 1919 to 1934, 1935; This Year, Next Year, 1937; Memory, and Other Poems, 1938; Haunted, 1939; Bells and Grass, 1941; Collected Poems, 1941; Collected Rhymes and Verses, 1944; The Burning-Glass, and Other Poems, 1945; The Traveller, 1946; Rhymes and Verses: Collected Poems for Young People, 1947; Inward Companion, 1950; Winged Chariot, 1951; O Lovely England, and Other Poems, 1953; The Complete Poems, 1969. Bibliography Allen, Walter. The Short Story in English. New York: Oxford University Press, 1981. Argues that, as a short-story writer, de la Mare closely resembles Henry James in his supernatural stories, for his stories are rooted in mundane reality. Beetz, Kirk H. “Walter de la Mare.” In Critical Survey of Long Fiction, Revised Edition, edited by Carl Rollyson. Vol. 2. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2000. Analysis of de la Mare’s longer fictional works that may offer insights into his short fiction. Benntinck, Anne. Romantic Imagery in the Works of Walter de la Mare. Lewiston, N.Y.: Edwin Mellen Press, 2001. Devotes one chapter apiece to each of seven major Romantic themes or leitmotifs in de la Mare’s poetry. Includes bibliography, index of works, general index. Manwaring, Randle. “Memories of Walter de la Mare.” Contemporary Review 264 (March, 1994): 148-152. A reminiscence of a longtime acquaintance of de la Mare
332
Short Story Writers
that comments on his style and his influence. Reflects de la Mare’s childish delight in simple things that is so often reflected in his stories. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these four short stories by de la Mare: “A Recluse,” “A Revenant,” and “Seaton’s Aunt” (vol. 6); and “The Trumpet” (vol. 7). Perkins, David. “Craftsmen of the Beautiful and the Agreeable.” In A History of Modern Poetry. Vol. 1. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1976. Perkins emphasizes de la Mare’s complicated relationship to the Romantics. Like them, he often wrote about the world as a dream. He was aware of the conventional nature of Romantic poetry, and often the poems are about conventions. Unlike certain Romantics, he does not portray evil as sublime. He is a master at interrogative conversation and anticipates the modernist stress on the accents of daily speech. Sisson, C. H. English Poetry, 1900-1950. Manchester, England: Carcanet Press, 1981. Sisson mentions that de la Mare was the last of the Romantics. His poetry combines Romantic themes with the more personal themes of twentieth century verse. It is characterized by purity of language and hushed, intimate accents, and it succeeds in capturing the intimate rhythms of speech. De la Mare was at his best in a limited range of subjects. His finest work pictures life on the edge of a dream. Wagenknecht, Edward. Seven Masters of Supernatural Fiction. New York: Greenwood Press, 1991. See the chapter on Walter de la Mare, which includes a brief biographical sketch and discusses his fiction in the context of the English literary tradition. Wagenknecht deals with both the short and the long fiction, providing a succinct overview of de la Mare’s body of work in prose. Whistler, Theresa. Imagination of the Heart: The Life of Walter de la Mare. London: Duckworth, 1993. Good biography of de la Mare. Includes bibliographical references and an index.
333
Isak Dinesen Born: Rungsted, Denmark; April 17, 1885 Died: Rungsted, Denmark; September 7, 1962 Principal short fiction • Seven Gothic Tales, 1934; Vinter-Eventyr, 1942 (Winter’s Tales, 1942); Sidste Fortœllinger, 1957 (Last Tales, 1957); Skœbne-Anekdoter, 1958 (Anecdotes of Destiny, 1958); Ehrengard, 1963; Efterladte Fortœllinger, 1975 (Carnival: Entertainments and Posthumous Tales, 1977). Other literary forms • In addition to her numerous tales and stories, Isak Dinesen wrote many letters and essays. She is particularly well known, however, for her narrative Den afrikanske Farm (1937; Out of Africa, 1937), which tells of her years in Kenya (a sequel was published in 1960). After her death, two volumes of letters, written while in Africa, were published, as were her essays. Achievements • Isak Dinesen has a special position in modern literature in that she is a major author in two languages. Although a native of Denmark, she wrote in both English and Danish, creating her tales as original works in both tongues. Popular with the critics as well as the general public, she was appointed an honorary member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters in 1957 and was repeatedly mentioned as a candidate for the Nobel Prize in Literature. Her initial success came in the English-speaking world. With time, however, she became successful also at home, where her magnetic personality and storytelling gifts gradually captivated the public. Aided by the medium of radio, she became a veritable cultural institution in Denmark. Since her death, her critical reputation has steadily grown both at home and abroad, and she has come to be considered a modern master of short fiction. Biography • Isak Dinesen’s life may be divided into three parts, namely her childhood and youth, her time in Africa, and her years as a recognized writer. Her parents came from very different social backgrounds. From her father, Wilhelm Dinesen, a landed proprietor, she inherited a love of adventure, nature, and storytelling. Her mother, in contrast, came from a bourgeois family of merchants and attempted to foster a sense of duty, obligation, and guilt in her three daughters. Karen Christenze (Isak is a pseudonym that she assumed at the beginning of her writing career) was her father’s favorite daughter and thereby was able to avoid some of her mother’s puritanical manacles. At the age of ten, however, her father’s suicide turned her youth into a period of mostly joyless desperation. Early she began writing stories and short plays, for which she had been prepared by an unsystematic private education. She also studied art and traveled abroad with her mother, sisters, and aunt. The second period in Dinesen’s life began in 1914, when she married her first cousin, the Baron Bror Blixen-Finecke, and with him settled down to manage a coffee plantation outside Nairobi, in British East Africa. Her husband infected her with syphilis and proved himself a poor manager of the plantation; the couple was separated in 1921 and divorced four years later. Living in Kenya as the manager of a different, and larger, coffee farm, Dinesen cultivated a friendship with Denys Finch
334
Short Story Writers
Hatton, whom she had met in 1918. A confirmed bachelor, Finch Hatton had no desire to marry Dinesen, which grieved her. Dinesen’s African life came to an end in 1931, when the coffee farm had to be sold and Finch Hatton died in the crash of his private plane. Dinesen returned to Denmark in a state of abject poverty. Supported by her family and inspired by the success of a few stories, which years earlier had been published under the pen name Osceola, she set out to create a new life for herself as a writer. Other stories, written during her African sojourn, existed in draft form, and some of these gradually became perfected and included in Seven Gothic Tales, the Englishlanguage edition of which became both a critical and a popular success. Her autobiographical narrative Out of Africa established her as a major presence on the literary scene both in Denmark and in the English-language world, and subsequent books were also enthusiastically received. An indication of Dinesen’s popularity in the United States is the fact that five of her titles were chosen as Book-of-the-Month Club selections. Living at her birthplace, Rungsted, north of Copenhagen, Denmark, she gathered her admirers around her and tended her literary reputation. During most of her adult life, Dinesen was plagued by illness, which was exacerbated by much strenuous travel abroad and the entertainment of numerous guests at home. After a particularly taxing summer, she died at her home on September 7, 1962. Analysis • Isak Dinesen reacted against the psychological and social realism of contemporary Danish literature and looked back to the Romantic storytellers for inspiration. Like them, she preferred the longer, drawn-out tale to the short story proper, and authorial narration, often with overtly present narrators, is a hallmark of her narratives. Her chosen form therefore often struck her contemporaries as old-fashioned. This was also the case with her thematic concerns, for her stories take place mostly in the century between 1770 and 1870 and express the ethos of a bygone age. She speaks in favor of such aristocratic values as duty, honor, and justice, but she also rejects the Christian dualistic worldview and questions the role of religion and the place of women in contemporary bourgeois society. Above all, however, the role of art in human life constitutes a central theme of her authorship. Through art, a unified vision is possible, and such a monistic perception of reality is, for Dinesen, a primary source of meaning in general and of comfort in difficult times. “The Monkey” • “Aben” (“The Monkey”), a long story from Seven Gothic Tales, is a good example of Dinesen’s “gothic” or fantastic narratives that also exhibits many of her thematic concerns. Its setting is a noble milieu in northern Germany in the 1830’s; its theme is the nature of love. Boris, a young lieutenant in the Prussian Royal Guards, has become involved in a homosexual scandal in the capital and is seeking the aid of his maiden aunt, Cathinka, the Prioress of Cloister Seven, a convent for spinsters of noble blood. In order to escape dishonor and almost certain death, Boris has resolved to marry, thus hoping to lay to rest the rumors of his homosexual involvement with other members of his regiment. His aunt, who is well acquainted with the various noble families of the land, is being asked to select a suitable mate for him. The fantastic element of the story is found in the relationship between the Prioress and her little gray monkey, to which she has a mysterious bond and with which she, from time to time and in accordance with traditional Scandinavian folk belief in shape-shifting, exchanges her identity. The monkey is connected with the idea of
Dinesen, Isak
335
love through the love goddess of an ancient Baltic people, the Wends. The goddess looks like a beautiful woman from the front and like a monkey from the back. Through this image, Dinesen argues against the Judeo-Christian distinction between the heteroerotic, which is acceptable to society, and the homoerotic, which is not. Speaking in favor of a monistic outlook on human sexuality, Dinesen, through the similarity between the Wendish love-goddess and the Janus face, problematizes the distinction between normal and abnormal sexuality. The text actually foregrounds the question of how it can be determined which side is the front and which is the back of the goddess, and the implied answer is that no such determination can be made Library of Congress on objective grounds. There is, nevertheless, a recognition on Dinesen’s part that people have to live up to the expectations of their society if they are to get along in life. Boris has certain duties to his family, and, despite his sexual difference from the norm, he is obligated to repress his desires and to force himself to marry. The Prioress, who at this time and in a mysterious way is possessed by aspects of her monkey’s personality, chooses as his bride the only daughter of a neighbor, a tall and strong young woman named Athena, whom Boris has known since childhood. Her father welcomes Boris as a suitor and says that he would delight in seeing the young man’s features in the faces of his grandchildren. Athena rejects him, however, and states unequivocally that she will never marry; she will not, in other words, yield to her duty to her family. There is a strong implication in the text that Athena is as troubled by her gender role as Boris is by his. Athena’s rejection infuriates the Prioress, who arranges a supper of seduction during which Athena gets drunk. As the girl goes to her room, the Prioress gives Boris an aphrodisiac to help him complete his conquest, and he struggles with Athena, who knocks out two of his teeth. Boris interprets this as a symbolic castration and feels that he has been freed from his obligation to have a normal conjugal relationship with her, should they get married. She has won his battle with traditional sexuality for him, and he therefore triumphantly kisses her with his bloody mouth. The significance of this perverted and ironic image of defloration is not lost on Athena, who, in horror and disgust, loses consciousness. Boris does not touch her further. The next morning, Athena is told by the Prioress that she is now most likely pregnant and that her only hope of avoiding dishonor is to marry Boris. Together, they then watch as the Prioress, who all along has been in the grip of the personality of the monkey, reasserts her own true self through an intense struggle with the little ani-
336
Short Story Writers
mal. This astonishing event affects Athena deeply, and she resigns herself to marrying Boris, with the proviso, however, that she is to have dominion in their relationship. Athena’s and Boris’s union is thus marked by the backside of the love goddess in several ways. Erotically, they are misfits in that they both look on heterosexuality with revulsion. Psychologically and emotionally, their union is a result of a power struggle, touched by the fantastic, rather than a consequence of the usual process of falling in love. Morally, their marriage represents a surrender to the expectations of their families, but it is unlikely that they will do their real duty and have children. Socially, their marriage will also be out of the ordinary, because, in opposition to the patriarchal norm of their time and place, the wife will rule the roost with the consent of her husband. Dinesen thus problematizes one of the fundamental oppositions of human life, namely that between male and female, and offers a critique of both sex roles and Christian dualism. “The Young Man with the Carnation” • Although the stories in Seven Gothic Tales touch on the fantastic and frequently present challenges to the readers those of Winter’s Tales are more traditional, and therefore also more accessible, narratives. Written during the German occupation of Denmark, they are tales for difficult times, in which the possibility of reconciliation and restoration is held dear. “Den unge mand med nelliken” (“The Young Man with the Carnation”), which introduces the English-language edition of the collection, is a powerful expression of Dinesen’s theory of art. Its protagonist, Charlie Despard, is a young English writer who, while born and reared in circumstances of great poverty, has transmuted the pain of his childhood experiences into his first novel, with which he has had tremendous success. Because of his newfound reputation as a writer, he has been able to marry a beautiful young woman from a family of means, and outwardly he has every reason to be happy, which indeed, for a time, he has been. As Dinesen indicates through his name, however, he is now in despair, for he has found that art has failed him. He has nothing more to say as a writer, while at the same time he feels that life holds no joys for him. His is not simply a bad case of writer’s block, though, but a case of someone who, because of his erstwhile happiness, has lost his ability to create. The story tells about how Charlie comes to terms with his situation and regains his creativity. While traveling on the Continent, Charlie and his wife have been separated for a few days but have planned to meet at a hotel in Amsterdam. Charlie arrives last and goes to his wife’s room, where he finds her asleep with her door unlocked. Shortly after his arrival, someone else tries to open the door, and, when Charlie gets out of bed to investigate, he finds a young man who, wearing a carnation, is obviously on his way to a rendezvous. Charlie’s first reaction is envy, for he believes the young man to have found the happiness which he, himself, is lacking. He then experiences a shock at his wife’s infidelity, feels sorry for himself, writes her a brief note, and leaves in search of that happiness which he sensed in the face of the young man with the carnation. During the next few hours, his mind is in turmoil, and he walks along the waterfront, contemplating his situation. He is then found by some sailors who believe him to be thinking of suicide and who therefore invite him to come with them to a tavern. The men spend the night telling one another stories, and Charlie’s tales indicate that he now suffers from no loss of creativity; the experience of the night has given him the pain which is needed by the artist. His regained creativity gives him the strength to face his wife, and he returns to the hotel only to find that he, the previous night,
Dinesen, Isak
337
had entered the wrong room. Dinesen’s imagery shows that Charlie the fiction writer interprets his experience as a kind of resurrection, which is followed by a dialogue with God. Charlie is told by God that he had been created in order to write and that it is God who wants him to tell his stories and who therefore gave him the pain of the previous evening. He is promised, however, that God will not measure out any more distress to him than what is needed for his art. Charlie accepts the idea that pain is a necessary condition of creativity and realizes that it is the young man with the carnation who is to be pitied, rather than himself. Dinesen’s theory of art is thus basically a romantic one, in which the joys of life are viewed as inferior to art and therefore fundamentally incompatible with creative endeavor. The artist is required to sacrifice normal human happiness for the privilege of being able to commune with the divine, which is the essence of artistic creation. “Sorrow-Acre” • Another significant aspect of “The Young Man with the Carnation” is the concept of duty, which manifests itself as Charlie’s obligation to God to be a writer of stories. In “Sorg-agre” (“Sorrow-Acre”), the next story in Winter’s Tales, duty is a central motif that contributes much to the story’s theme. “Sorrow-Acre” tells about a young Dane named Adam who has spent several years in England, but who, at the beginning of the story, has just returned home to his ancestral estate only to find himself in conflict with his uncle, the ruler of the manor. Adam represents the beginnings of a new social order and serves as the embodiment of the ideas of the French Revolution (1789), while his uncle advocates a traditional, aristocratic view of life. The three intertwined plots of the story are played out against the backdrop of life on this semifeudal Danish country estate in the late eighteenth century. The first plot concerns the uncle’s dealings with Anne-Marie, the mother of a young man who has been accused of a crime. There is little proof in the case, and the uncle admits that he has no basis for making a judgment about the man’s guilt or innocence. When Anne-Marie begs for the freedom of her son, however, he offers her a bargain: If she can cut a certain rye field in the course of one day, her son will receive his freedom. The outward drama of the story concerns Anne-Marie’s superhuman attempt at harvesting the field, which is normally three days’ work for a man. She succeeds but at the end dies from exhaustion. The second plot line concerns the relationship between Adam and his uncle. Adam finds his uncle’s action barbarous and threatens to leave because of his sense of outrage. The uncle defends himself by referring to the divine principle of arbitrary power, saying that because he is essentially like a god in his relationship to his serflike farm workers, his actions should not be questioned. Although the drama in the rye field may seem like a tragedy to most mortals, the unresolved question of the young man’s innocence or guilt adds a divinely comic flavor to Anne-Marie’s attempt to buy his freedom. A nobleman may approach the divine by accepting and appreciating the comic aspects of human life. The uncle would himself, he says, like nothing better than to be in a position where he might be able to buy himself a son at the cost of his own life, thus ensuring the succession of the family line. He has lost his only son and has recently, in his rather advanced age, married the young lady who was intended to be his son’s bride. The third strand of the plot involves the relationship between Adam and his uncle’s young wife. It is very much against Adam’s interests that his uncle should receive an heir, for if the uncle were to die childless, Adam would inherit the estate. It has been prophesied by a gypsy, however, that Adam’s posterity is to possess the estate,
338
Short Story Writers
and it is becoming clear to Adam that he has a duty to the family to give his uncle a legal heir. The young wife’s attitude toward Adam would clearly facilitate such an unspoken arrangement. All the main characters in this tale thus exemplify the principle of duty, particularly as it concerns the continuation of a family line. Adam recognizes that he has been brought back to Denmark by fate and that he must play his part in the drama of his family. He is reconciled to his uncle, who begs him to stay; the uncle surely knows that Adam is essential to the success of his project. The uncle’s young wife knows that she has been brought into the family expressly for the purpose of providing an heir. Anne-Marie, whose death is a powerful reminder of a person’s duty to his or her descendants, sets a powerful example of commitment to one’s family. “The Sailor-Boy’s Tale” • Dinesen sees a connection between duty and the concept of justice, for it is a paramount duty of human beings to strive to be just. Her idea of justice is clearly expressed in “Skibsdrængens fortælling” (“The Sailor-Boy’s Tale”), a rather simple story that is also found in Winter’s Tales. Like “The Monkey,” “The Sailor-Boy’s Tale” presupposes that the reader is familiar with folk beliefs related to shape-shifting, the idea that a human being may temporarily take on the form of an animal. The story tells about a young sailor boy named Simon, who, during a storm in the Mediterranean, climbs the mainmast of his ship to free a peregrine falcon that has become caught in the rigging. Before Simon sets it free, the falcon pecks his thumb sufficiently hard to draw blood, and Simon retaliates by hitting it on the head. This incident proves to be significant to Dinesen’s portrait of justice and its operation. Two years later, Simon’s ship has come to the herring markets in the town of Bodø in northern Norway, where Simon meets and falls in love with a young girl named Nora. One evening, when he is on his way to a meeting with the girl, he runs into an overly friendly Russian sailor, whose behavior has homosexual overtones. Simon, who does not want to be late for his meeting with the girl, stabs and kills the Russian, after which he is pursued by the dead man’s shipmates. While he is hiding in the crowd at a dance, an old pagan Lapp woman named Sunniva shows up, says that Simon is her son, and tells him to come home with her. Sunniva wipes off his bloody knife on her skirt and, while hiding Simon when the Russian sailors come looking for him, cuts her thumb to explain the presence of blood. She then arranges for safe passage for him back to his ship, at which point she reveals that she is the falcon that Simon released during the storm in the Mediterranean. She has rescued him both because she likes him and because of her sense of justice, for he deserves to be paid back for helping her. To completely settle her accounts with him, she then boxes his ear in return for his blow to her head while she was in the shape of the falcon. Sunniva also explains to Simon that she admires his devotion to the girl Nora and that the female residents of the earth hold together. Referring to men as their sons, she indicates that the world is really run by women, who are bound together with a matriarchal compact. Sunniva’s pagan matriarchy gestures at Dinesen’s questioning of both traditional sex roles and the Christian religion. “The Heroine” • Dinesen’s rather gentle critique of Christianity in “The Sailor-Boy’s Tale” becomes relentlessly satirical in “Heloise” (“The Heroine”), in which she casts a woman stripper in the role of the Christian savior. A young Englishman named Frederick Lamond, together with a company of French travelers, is caught in a Ger-
Dinesen, Isak
339
man border town at the time of the Franco-Prussian war. A student of religious philosophy, Frederick is at the time writing a treatise on the doctrine of the Atonement. When the German army marches into town, he and the other stranded travelers are accused of espionage. A famous messianic prophecy from the Book of Isaiah, which is quoted in Frederick’s manuscript, is read as a code by the Germans and forms the main proof of their accusation. One of the travelers is a woman named Heloise, whose rare beauty greatly impresses one of the German officers. Realizing that the accusation of espionage may not have much merit, he offers the travelers a bargain: If Heloise will appear before him in the nude, they will be permitted to continue to France; otherwise, they will be shot. Heloise turns to the company and leaves the decision in their hands, and they all vote to refuse the German’s demand. The officer, who respects the courage of both Heloise and her companions, then decides to let them go after all, and he apologizes to Heloise, whom he terms a heroine, by sending her a big bouquet of roses. Six years later, Frederick is in Paris to attend some lectures in his field. Entertained by a friend, he is taken to a music hall, where the most beautiful woman in Paris is appearing nude in a show. It turns out that the woman is Heloise, whom Frederick still remembers well. They meet and reminisce after the show, and Heloise explains what in her opinion was at stake in the dramatic incident six years earlier. It was not only the lives of the travelers, she says, which hung in the balance but also their ability to live with their consciences. It would have cost her very little to comply with the German’s demand; for her, it would have been a professional matter, not one of conscience. The other travelers, however, would have never gotten over it if Heloise were to have bought their freedom at the cost of exposing her body. Frederick now understands that her heroism did not consist in standing up to the German officer’s demands but in looking after the welfare of her companions’ souls. Heloise, who through the imagery in the story has been carefully presented as a kind of Christ-figure, now appears, to both Frederick and the reader, as a full-blown savior. Portraying a stripper as someone who saves people from guilt constitutes a truly ironic comment on traditional Christian religion. Casting a woman in such a position undercuts the traditional conception of women’s roles as well. “The Heroine,” through its overt questioning of central religious and social norms, therefore becomes one of Dinesen’s most radical stories. “Babette’s Feast” • Heloise’s parting comment to Frederick is that she wishes that he might have seen her perform six years earlier, when her beauty was at its fullest. Heloise has the temperament of an artist in that art, in her case the beauty of her body, gives meaning to her life. A similar commitment is held by the title character in “Babettes gæstebud” (“Babette’s Feast”) from Anecdotes of Destiny, who, like Heloise, is French. Babette is a famous Parisian chef who had to flee her country at the time of the Paris Commune. She finds her way to a small Norwegian fishing village, where she, for the next fourteen years, lives as a maid in the home of two spinsters. These two sisters are the daughters of a minister who founded a pietistic religious society and who, because of his asceticism, rejected his daughters’ suitors. Years after his death, his daughters live solely for their father’s memory and religious ideals. Babette regularly plays the French lottery and chances to win ten thousand francs, which she wishes to spend on a French dinner at the centenary of the minister’s birth. The various foreign dishes are disconcerting to the guests, who are all members of the minister’s sect; only one of them, the former suitor of one of the daugh-
340
Short Story Writers
ters, is able to appreciate Babette’s culinary artistry. When, at the end of the dinner, the two sisters learn that the utterly exhausted Babette has spent all her money on the project, they cannot understand her motivation, but Babette states that she has done it for her own sake: She is an artist who craves excellence in her field of endeavor. Like Babette, Dinesen placed high demands on herself. She felt a strong sense of duty and loyalty to the artist within her, thus her tales are exquisitely crafted but not numerous. She relentlessly pursued her unitary vision, subtly criticizing those aspects of life that went against the grain of her thought, such as the dualism of received religion and traditional sex roles. Through her authorship she prepared a literary feast that continues to be enjoyed by numerous readers. Jan Sjåvik Other major works novels: Gengœldelsens Veje, 1944 (as Pierre Andrézel; The Angelic Avengers, 1946). nonfiction: Den afrikanske Farm, 1937 (Out of Africa, 1937); Skygger paa Grœsset, 1960 (Shadows on the Grass, 1960); Essays, 1965; Breve fra Afrika, 1914-1931, 1978 (Letters from Africa, 1914-1931, 1981); Daguerreotypes, and Other Essays, 1979; Samlede Essays, 1985. Bibliography Aiken, Susan Hardy. Isak Dinesen and the Engendering of Narrative. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990. Offers thoughtful critical interpretation of Dinesen’s works. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Bassoff, Bruce. “Babette Can Cook: Life and Art in Three Stories by Isak Dinesen.” Studies in Short Fiction 27 (Summer, 1990): 385-389. Discusses the plot elements of desire for transcendence, a fall caused by confrontation with the real world, and new knowledge or resignation in “The Ring,” “The Diver,” and “Babette’s Feast.” Bjørnvig, Thorkild. The Pact: My Friendship with Isak Dinesen. Translated by Ingvar Schousboe and William Jay Smith. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1983. This short book offers Bjørnvig’s account of his friendship with Dinesen, from their first meeting in 1948 to their definitive parting in 1954. Written by an accomplished poet, the volume is interesting in its own right as well as for the insight into Dinesen which it provides. Donelson, Linda. Out of Isak Dinesen in Africa: The Untold Story. Iowa City, Iowa: Coulsong List, 1995. Good, updated biography of Dinesen. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Henriksen, Aage. “The Empty Space Between Art and Church.” In Out of Denmark, edited by Bodil Warmberg. Copenhagen: Danish Cultural Institute, 1985. Henriksen asserts that the underlying principle of all Dinesen’s tales is the discovery that reality is transformed into a dream. Contends that Dinesen’s stories are based on the complicated nature of human love. Juhl, Marianne, and Bo Hakon Jørgensen. Diana’s Revenge: Two Lines in Isak Dinesen’s Authorship. Translated from the Danish by Anne Born. Odense, Denmark: Odense University Press, 1985. This volume contains two sophisticated scholarly and critical essays of considerable length. Juhl’s contribution, “Sex and Consciousness,” is informed by feminist theory. Jørgensen, in “The Ways of Art,” discusses the relationship between Dinesen’s sensuality and her art. Their book, which includes a
Dinesen, Isak
341
good bibliography, is particularly strong in its discussion of Dinesen’s use of classical symbols. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Dinesen: “Babette’s Feast,” “The Blank Page,” and “The Cardinal’s First Tale” (vol. 1); “The Deluge at Norderney” (vol. 2); “The Monkey” (vol. 5); “The Sailor-Boy’s Tale” (vol. 6); and “Sorrow-Acre” and “The Supper at Elsinore” (vol. 7). Mullins, Maire. “Home, Community, and the Gift That Gives in Isak Dinesen’s ‘Babette’s Feast.’” Women’s Studies 23 (1994): 217-228. Argues that the meal Babette prepares is not a gift but a demonstration of her own aesthetic powers. Argues that Babette subverts the phallo-logocentric society in which she finds herself and transforms home and community through her presence. Rashkin, Esther. “A Recipe for Mourning: Isak Dinesen’s ‘Babette’s Feast.’” Style 29 (Fall, 1995): 356-374. Claims the story is a psychoanalytic reflection on the process involved in overcoming an inability to mourn, for which it writes a recipe for transcendence of that inability through the preparation and consumption of food. Stambaugh, Sara. The Witch and the Goddess in the Stories of Isak Dinesen: A Feminist Reading. Ann Arbor, Mich.: UMI Research Press, 1988. Stambaugh offers a feministinspired examination of the portraits of women that are found in Dinesen’s texts. The strength of her brief study is the recognition of the centrality of gender for an understanding of Dinesen’s work; its weakness is its lack of theoretical sophistication. The book has a complete scholarly apparatus.
342
Fyodor Dostoevski Born: Moscow, Russia; November 11, 1821 Died: St. Petersburg, Russia; February 9, 1881 Principal short fiction • Sochineniya, 1860 (2 volumes); Polnoye sobraniye sochineniy, 1865-1870 (4 volumes); Povesti i rasskazy, 1882; The Gambler, and Other Stories, 1914; A Christmas Tree and a Wedding, and an Honest Thief, 1917; White Nights, and Other Stories, 1918; An Honest Thief, and Other Stories, 1919; The Short Novels of Dostoevsky, 1945. Other literary forms • In addition to short fiction, Fyodor Dostoevski wrote novels, nonfiction, criticism, and Yevgeniya Grande (1844), a translation of Honoré de Balzac’s novel Eugénie Grandet (1833). In his own time, Dostoevski was exceptionally influential, especially through Dnevnik pisatelya (1876-1877, 1800-1881; The Diary of a Writer, 1949), a series of miscellaneous writings that he published occasionally in St. Petersburg. Dostoevski also wrote a series of essays on Russian literature, some feuilletons, and the well-known travelogue “Zimniye zametki o letnikh vpechatleniyakh” (1863; “Winter Notes on Summer Impressions,” 1955). His most famous contribution in his own time was his speech in Alexander Pushkin’s honor, given on the occasion of the dedication of a monument to Pushkin in 1880. Achievements • In the world literature of the nineteenth century, Fyodor Dostoevski has few rivals. Some of his characters have penetrated literary consciousness and produced a new generation in the works of prominent twentieth century authors such as Jean-Paul Sartre and Jorge Luis Borges. He initiated psychological realism, inspiring both Friedrich Nietzsche and Sigmund Freud. His novels are read in translation in twenty-six languages. Dostoevski was originally suppressed in the Soviet Union, only to reemerge as even more influential in the second half of the twentieth century, finding a whole new generation of admirers in his transformed homeland. Even though his style is markedly nineteenth century, Dostoevski still seems quite modern even in the twenty-first century. Biography • Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevski was born on November 11, 1821, in a small Moscow public hospital, where his father, Dr. Mikhail Andreevich Dostoevski, worked. He was the second son to the doctor and Marya Fyodorovna (née Nechaeva). One year after his mother’s death, in 1837, Fyodor enrolled in the St. Petersburg Academy for Military Engineers. He completed his studies at the academy even after his father had died of a stroke in 1839, thanks to the inheritance of the Dostoevski estate. Like so many writers’ attempts, Dostoevski’s first foray into the literary world was through translation—in his case, of Balzac’s Eugénie Grandet, appearing in print in 1844. His first original work was a novel in letters, Bednye lyudi (1846; Poor Folk, 1887), which met with immediate success, creating quite a literary sensation even before its publication. The great critic Vissarion Belinsky hailed it with such enthusiasm that the novice writer was propelled into early fame. Dostoevski followed this initial success with Dvoynik (1846; The Double, 1917). It
Dostoevski, Fyodor
343
was met more coolly, was considered an artistic failure, and was generally unpopular. The failure of The Double, as seen in the twenty-first century, is quite ironic, since it contains many of the thematic occupations that eventually made Dostoevski famous. His next novel, Netochka Nezvanova (1849; English translation, 1920), was fated never to be completed. Most novels then appeared in journals and were serialized; this was the case with all Dostoevski’s novels. After the first three installments of Netochka Nezvanova appeared in 1849, Dostoevski was arrested for participating in a secret anticzarist society, the Petrashevsky Circle. He and thirty-two of his associates were arrested, imprisoned for eight months, and sentenced to death. At precisely the moment that his comrades were facing the firing squad, the sentence was commuted to hard labor. Dostoevski spent four years in hard labor at Omsk, followed by three years of exile from the capital. Dostoevski married Marya Isaeva in 1857, while still in Siberia. He was beginning to suffer from epilepsy, however, and she was also sickly. They returned to St. Petersburg in 1859, and shortly thereafter his works began again to appear in print. Life, however, did not return to normal. In 1864, his brother died, leaving him a second family to support. His wife, too, died the same year. Strapped financially, Dostoevski accepted an advance payment, agreeing to deliver a novel to a publisher that same year—or else forfeit the profits from all his subsequent works. He succeeded in completing Igrok (1866; The Gambler, 1887), satisfying this publisher thanks to his stenographer, Anna Snitkina, whom he married in 1867. They left Russia for a few years, returning in 1871. The novels that he wrote while abroad established him as an important writer but not as a popular or successful one. In fact, during his life, he met with very little recognition. The one shining exception to this neglect came at the dedication of a monument to Pushkin, in 1880. Thousands of people greeted his speech enthusiastically. He died only a few months later, in 1881, when an even larger crowd attended his funeral. Analysis • Fyodor Dostoevski’s works fall into two periods that coincide with the time before his imprisonment and following it. The seven-year hiatus in his creative output between 1849 and 1857 corresponds to the four years that he spent in prison and the three subsequent years during which he was banished in Siberia. The first period produced primarily shorter novels and short stories, many of which have never been translated into English; the latter period is represented more by the great novels, the epithet denoting both significance and size, as well as by Dnevnik pisatelya, 1876-1877, 1880-1881 (2 volumes, partial translation as Pages from the Journal of an Author, 1916; complete translation as The Diary of a Writer, 1949), which also contains several new short stories. In Dostoevski’s works, complex structures are created that introduce fundamentally antipodal constructs and that produce, among other effects, a mythologization of the antagonistic elements. Thus, the city, often the St. Petersburg of Dostoevski’s present, contrasts with the countryside. The squalor of poverty permeates St. Petersburg with sounds and smells in Dickensian realistic fashion, as opposed to the quaint, provincial quiet of the country. Usually, problems or actual troublemakers come from the city, or, if one leaves the provinces for the city, one may become “infected” with urban discontent and return to plague the countryside. In another prevalent dichotomy, the “man of the forties” (that is, the optimistic believer in the Enlightenment) often clashes with the “man of the sixties” (that is, the atheistic or nihilistic revolutionary). This conflict often is positioned generationally, and it is seldom clear
344
Short Story Writers
whether the representative of either generation should prevail. Often throughout Dostoevski’s works, men of a higher social class, although not necessarily a very high class, interact most significantly with women who are socially inferior, usually powerless or “compromised.” The relationship takes on many different attitudes in the various works, but, in almost every case, the woman turns out to be of greater virtue or higher moral and spiritual constitution than the man who, nevertheless, from his privileged position in society, usually fares better than the woman. Perhaps most important of all the themes in his work is the belief in God versus atheism. If there is no God, many of Dostoevski’s characters Library of Congress realize, then either every human being is a God or every human being is nothing at all. This conflict can, and sometimes does, take place within a single person as well as between two characters. Atheism usually appears in its most extreme state—that is, in the belief that, since there is no God, the human being must be God. Although Dostoevski’s proponents of atheism are strong-willed, disciplined, and morbidly dedicated, in Dostoevski’s world they need to accept the existence of God as their only chance for peace or, in the final analysis, for existing in the world at all. Although free will is interpreted by these radical proponents as the ability to become gods, the submission to the will of the divine God is the only means toward happiness. Those who fail to redeem themselves through God either perish or are subject to enormous spiritual and psychological torment. Such conflict forms the crux of more than one novel in Dostoevski’s latter period, and it will be the treatment of this element in Dostoevski’s work that will earn for him recognition as the founder of existentialism in literature. Ironically from the point of view of Dostoevski’s beliefs, it is his existential writings rather than his metaphysical ones that constitute his most profound influence on world literature in the twentieth century. Most of Dostoevski’s short stories are simpler works than the novels, both in terms of the psychology of the characters and in terms of structure. “White Nights” • One of his best-known short stories, “Belye nochi” (“White Nights”), is subtitled “A Sentimental Story from the Diary of a Dreamer.” The unnamed protagonist of this work meets a young woman, Nastenka, by chance one evening along the embankment. When they have the opportunity to speak to each other, they find that they have much in common: Neither of them is able to enjoy a life of his or her own, and both of them, because of varying circumstances, are confined to their own abodes, occupied most of the time in daydreaming. Nastenka is physically restrained by her grandmother by being pinned to her skirt; the male protagonist is confined by his abject poverty and the inertia of unsociability to his quarters, with the
Dostoevski, Fyodor
345
green wallpaper and the spiderwebs. At the end of the story, Nastenka, nevertheless, is able to escape her fate thanks to the offices of the young boarder, who has taken pity on her, but she has had to wait an entire year; it is precisely at the end of this year that she meets the protagonist, whom, she claims, she would certainly love, and does in fact love, but as she truly still loves the other, she must relinquish. Nastenka leaves, imploring the protagonist not to blame her, knowing that he cannot blame her because he loves her. The protagonist feels that, somehow, this “moment” that they have shared is enough love to sustain him for a lifetime of dreaming. This story, unusual in the works of Dostoevski, does not involve the motif of the abused young woman, and the rejected young man seems quite content with his fate. Unlike most of Dostoevski’s women, Nastenka has succeeded in meeting an honorable man who seemingly keeps his word, making her a singular female in the works of Dostoevski. “A Christmas Tree and a Wedding” • More in keeping with Dostoevski’s image of the abused, victimized woman is the young girl in “Elka i svad’ba” (“A Christmas Tree and a Wedding”). The first-person narrator relates how he notices the indecent attention of a “great man” of society toward an eleven-year-old girl playing with dolls, who has been promised a huge dowry during one family’s Christmas party. The “great man” is interested only in the fabulous dowry and bides his time. Five years later, the narrator notices a wedding taking place in the church and focuses on the face of the very young bride, “pale and melancholy,” her eyes perhaps even red from “recent weeping” and her look of “childish innocence,” where could be detected “something indescribably naive . . . mutely begging for mercy.” He recognizes the young girl of a few years before and also the “great man,” who is now the groom. The narrator concludes that it was a “good stroke of business.” In this story, the theme of the helpless woman completely at the mercy of rapacious, evil men plays a major role, and the fate of the young girl in “A Christmas Tree and a Wedding,” for all her money, bodes much worse than that of the impoverished Nastenka. “The Dream of a Ridiculous Man” • Perhaps Dostoevski’s best-known short story, “Son smeshnogo cheloveha” (“The Dream of a Ridiculous Man”) presents more of the most typical Dostoevskian philosophy of any short story. In it, a petty clerk who has realized that he has no reason to live believes that he should commit suicide to put an end to his ridiculous existence. Just when he decides to do so, a young girl accosts him and seemingly tries to engage his assistance. He pushes her aside, but his action causes him great shame, and he feels deep pity for the young girl. The experience of these two emotions causes him to postpone his suicide, if only for a few hours. Meanwhile, he falls asleep, and in his dream he shoots himself. Then, after he is dead and buried, he is transported to an Earth-like planet inhabited by people who only love. Unfortunately, he corrupts the entire population, causing wars, antipathies, and alienation. Upon awakening, the man feels that he has undergone a revelation and must preach his new religion, trying to convince people that it is possible to live in harmony together and to love sincerely people other than oneself. In “The Dream of a Ridiculous Man,” many themes from Dostoevski’s mature novels appear: whether one is a zero or a human, whether there is an afterlife, suffering as the only condition for the possibility of love, and suicide as a means of investing significance to human action, as well as many more. It is in the great novels that the complex world wherein the actions of all Dostoevski’s creations take place, including the short works. To read a short story without a fundamental background in
346
Short Story Writers
other seminal works—for example Zapiski iz podpolya (1864; Notes from the Underground, 1918)—would very likely lead to a trap that could trivialize what are, by themselves, minor works such as the short stories. If, however, the short stories are contextualized within the entire works of Dostoevski over both his major periods, they form several interesting transitional points between many of his philosophical designs. The young girls, usually victimized by poverty and evil men, seem to be an outgrowth of an early novel, Poor Folk, and a continuing motif throughout the later period. Here, an orphan serf girl is pressured into a marriage that will doubtless cause her endless degradation and possibly physical harm. The paradoxical “spiteful man” of Notes from the Underground is the model of the “little clerk” who, nevertheless, has been influenced by German romantic philosophy and against logical positivism. His voice and “spite” reverberate almost palpably in the short stories as well as in the great novels. The theme of life as suffering and love or compassion as life’s greatest suffering is developed throughout the great novels, which, when used as a backdrop for the short works, provides a glimpse into the motivations of many of the protagonists. Dostoevski’s short stories clearly have a place of their own in Russian literature. Together, they form a miniature portrait of the most compelling people in Dostoevski’s world. Reading them, along with the longer works, gives the discriminating reader an insight into one of the most powerful and intricate minds of the nineteenth century. Christine Tomei Other major works novels: Bednye lyudi, 1846 (Poor Folk, 1887); Dvoynik, 1846 (The Double, 1917); Netochka Nezvanova, 1849 (English translation, 1920); Unizhennye i oskorblyonnye, 1861 (Injury and Insult, 1886; also known as The Insulted and Injured); Zapiski iz myortvogo doma, 1861-1862 (Buried Alive: Or, Ten Years of Penal Servitude in Siberia, 1881; better known as The House of the Dead); Zapiski iz podpolya, 1864 (Letters from the Underworld, 1913; better known as Notes from the Underground); Igrok, 1866 (The Gambler, 1887); Prestupleniye i nakazaniye, 1866 (Crime and Punishment, 1886); Idiot, 1868 (The Idiot, 1887); Vechny muzh, 1870 (The Permanent Husband, 1888; also known as The Eternal Husband); Besy, 1871-1872 (The Possessed, 1913; also known as The Devils); Podrostok, 1875 (A Raw Youth, 1916); Bratya Karamazovy, 1879-1880 (The Brothers Karamazov, 1912); The Novels, 1912 (12 volumes). miscellaneous: Polnoe sobranie sochinenii v tridtsati tomakh, 1972-1990 (30 volumes). nonfiction: “Zimniye zametki o letnikh vpechatleniyakh,” 1863 (“Winter Notes on Summer Impressions,” 1955); Dnevnik pisatelya, 1876-1887, 1880-1881 (2 volumes; partial translation Pages from the Journal of an Author, 1916; complete translation The Diary of a Writer, 1949); Pisma, 1928-1959 (4 volumes); Iz arkhiva F. M. Dostoyevskogo: “Idiot,” 1931 (The Notebooks for “The Idiot,” 1967); Iz arkhiva F. M. Dostoyevskogo: “Prestupleniye i nakazaniye,” 1931 (The Notebooks for “Crime and Punishment,” 1967); F. M. Dostoyevsky: Materialy i issledovaniya, 1935 (The Notebooks for “The Brothers Karamazov,” 1971); Zapisnyye tetradi F. M. Dostoyevskogo, 1935 (The Notebooks for “The Possessed,” 1968); Dostoevsky’s Occasional Writings, 1963; F. M. Dostoyevsky v rabote nad romanom “Podrostok,” 1965 (The Notebooks for “A Raw Youth,” 1969); Neizdannyy Dostoyevsky: Zapisnyye knizhki i tetradi 1860-1881, 1971 (3 volumes; The Unpublished Dostoevsky: Diaries and Notebooks, 1860-1881, 1973-1976); F. M. Dostoyevsky ob iskusstve, 1973; Selected Letters of Fyodor Dostoyevsky, 1987.
Dostoevski, Fyodor
347
translation: Yevgeniya Grande, 1844 (of Honoré de Balzac’s novel Eugénie Grandet). Bibliography Adelman, Gary. Retelling Dostoyesvky: Literary Responses and Other Observations. Lewisburg, Pa.: Bucknell University Press, 2001. Study of the possible influence of Dostoevski on a number of authors from Joseph Conrad to Frank Herbert. Bloom, Harold, ed. Fyodor Dostoevsky. New York: Chelsea House, 1989. Essays on all of Dostoevski’s major novels as well as on his treatment of heroes and nihilism. Includes introduction, chronology, and bibliography. Frank, Joseph. Dostoevsky: The Seeds of Revolt, 1821-1849. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1976. The first volume of Frank’s monumental five-volume biography, the best available source on Dostoevski’s life and art in English. Includes an appendix on neurologist Sigmund Freud’s case history of Dostoevsky. ____________. Dostoevsky: The Years of Ordeal, 1850-1859. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1983. Reiterates Frank’s effort to subordinate the writer’s private life in favor of tracing his connection to the social-cultural history of his time. ____________. Dostoevsky: The Stir of Liberation, 1860-1865. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1986. Continues Frank’s study. ____________. Dostoevsky: The Miraculous Years, 1865-1871. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1995. The fourth volume in Frank’s series on the life and works of Dostoevksi. Includes an extended discussion of Dostoeski’s novella The Gambler from an ethnic-psychological perspective as a commentary on the Russian national character and an extended discussion of the classical construction of the novella The Eternal Husband, which Frank sees as Dostoeski’s most perfect shorter work. ____________. Dostoevsky: The Mantle of the Prophet. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2002. Volume 5, concluding Frank’s biography. Jackson, Robert Louis, ed. Dialogues with Dostoevsky: The Overwhelming Questions. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1993. Chapters on the writer’s relationships with Ivan Turgenev, Leo Tolstoy, Anton Chekhov, Maxim Gorky, Nikolai Gogol, William Shakespeare, and Friedrich Nietzsche. Kjetsaa, Geir. Fyodor Dostoevsky: A Writer’s Life. Translated by Siri Hustvedt and David McDuff. New York: Viking Press, 1987. Thorough and compelling work on Dostoevski’s life that seeks to shed light on the creation of Dostoevski’s fiction, citing letters and notes as artistic points of departure for Dostoevski. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these seven short stories by Dostoevski: “Bobok” (vol. 1), “The Crocodile” and “The Dream of a Ridiculous Man” (vol. 2), “An Honest Thief” (vol. 3), “A Nasty Story” (vol. 5), “The Peasant Marey” (vol. 6), and “White Nights” (vol. 8). Straus, Nina Pelikan. Dostoevsky and the Woman Question: Rereadings at the End of a Century. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Although, like most books on Dostoevski, this study centers on the novels, it is helpful in understanding his work generally; it argues that Dostoevski’s compulsion to depict men’s cruelties to women is a constitutive part of his vision and his metaphysics. Claims that Dostoevski attacks masculine notions of autonomy and that his works evolve toward “the death of the patriarchy.”
348
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Born: Edinburgh, Scotland; May 22, 1859 Died: Crowborough, East Sussex, England; July 7, 1930 Principal short fiction • Mysteries and Adventures, 1889 (also as The Gully of Bluemansdyke, and Other Stories); The Captain of Polestar, and Other Tales, 1890; The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, 1892; My Friend the Murderer, and Other Mysteries and Adventures, 1893; Round the Red Lamp: Being Fact and Fancies of Medical Life, 1894; The Great Keinplatz Experiment, and Other Stories, 1894; The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes, 1894; The Exploits of Brigadier Gerard, 1896; The Man from Archangel, and Other Stories, 1898; The Green Flag, and Other Stories of War and Sport, 1900; The Adventures of Gerard, 1903; The Return of Sherlock Holmes, 1905; Round the Fire Stories, 1908; One Crowded Hour, 1911; The Last Galley: Impressions and Tales, 1911; His Last Bow, 1917; Danger!, and Other Stories, 1918; Tales of Terror and Mystery, 1922 (also as The Black Doctor, and Other Tales of Terror and Mystery); Tales of the Ring and Camp, 1922 (also as The Croxley Master, and Other Tales of the Ring and Camp); Tales of Twilight and the Unseen, 1922 (also as The Great Keinplatz Experiment, and Other Tales of Twilight and the Unseen); Three of Them, 1923; Last of the Legions, and Other Tales of Long Ago, 1925; The Dealings of Captain Sharkey, and Other Tales of Pirates, 1925; The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes, 1927; The Maracot Deep, and Other Stories, 1929; The Final Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, 1981 (revised and expanded 2001); Uncollected Stories: The Unknown Conan Doyle, 1982. Other literary forms • Arthur Conan Doyle’s more than one hundred published works include novels, autobiography, political treatises, plays adapted from his fiction, and works on spiritualism as well as his short stories, for which he is best known. His character Sherlock Holmes has been the subject of innumerable films, plays, and radio scripts and has become the archetype of the conventional detective hero. Achievements • Although Doyle was not the first to write short stories featuring a detective with great analytical powers, and while he acknowledged his debt to such writers as Edgar Allan Poe and Émile Gaboriau, who had written tales of intelligent amateur detectives solving crimes through logical deduction, in Sherlock Holmes, Doyle created a character who has entered the popular imagination like no other. Sherlock Holmes is perhaps the most famous and popular character in detective fiction, if not in all modern fiction. Doyle’s stories were a strong influence on writers such as Ellery Queen, Agatha Christie, John Dickson Carr, and the many others who create tightly constructed puzzles for their detectives to solve with clearly and closely reasoned analysis. Societies such as the Baker Street Irregulars have sprung up around the world to study Doyle’s stories, and the name of Sherlock Holmes has become synonymous with deduction, while “Elementary, my dear Watson” is a catchphrase even among those who have never read the stories. Biography • Arthur Conan Doyle was born in Scotland of devout Irish Catholic parents and educated by the Jesuits in England and Austria. He graduated from the medical school at the University of Edinburgh and first went to sea as a ship’s surgeon on a
Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan
349
whaler to the Arctic, later on a West African passenger liner. He opened an office in Southsea, England, and because of a dearth of patients, began writing to fill his leisure time and to supplement his income. He had previously published a few short stories anonymously, and in 1887 completed A Study in Scarlet, a novelette in which Sherlock Holmes, as the central character, appears for the first time. Urged on by his American editor, he wrote The Sign of Four (1890; also pb. as The Sign of the Four) and a series of Sherlock Holmes stories which appeared in the Strand Magazine. The popularity of Holmes enabled Doyle to give up the practice of medicine, but since the author desired to be known as a historical romancer, the character was “killed off” in a struggle with his archenemy, Professor Moriarty, in the story “The Final Problem.” Ten years later, yielding Courtesy, University of Texas at Austin to pressure from his publishers and the public, he resurrected Holmes, first in The Hound of the Baskervilles (1901-1902, serial; 1902, book) and later in another series of Holmes short stories. Doyle was knighted in 1902 for his political service and principally for his publications defending the conduct of the British in the South African (Boer) War. Having left Roman Catholicism, he turned to spiritualism and devoted the rest of his life to psychic research and propagandizing his beliefs. Analysis • In spite of his desire to be acknowledged as a writer of “serious” literature, Arthur Conan Doyle is destined to be remembered as the creator of a fictional character who has taken on a life separate from the literary works in which he appears. Sherlock Holmes, as the prototype of almost all fictional detectives, has become a legend not only to his devotees but also to those who have not even read the works in which he appears, the detective being immortalized by reputation and through the media of movies, television, and radio. Doyle claimed that the character of Sherlock Holmes was based on his memories of Dr. Joseph Bell, a teacher of anatomy at the University of Edinburgh, whose diagnostic skills he had admired as a student of medicine. Bell, however, disclaimed the honor and suggested that Doyle himself possessed the analytical acumen that more closely resembled the skills of Sherlock Holmes. Regardless of the disclaimers and acknowledgments, there is little doubt that Doyle owed a large debt to Edgar Allan Poe and other predecessors in detective fiction, such as Émile Gaboriau and François-Eugène Vidocq. Doyle records that he was familiar with Mémoires (1828-1829; Memoirs of Vidocq, Principal Agent of the French Police, 1828-1829) and had read
350
Short Story Writers
Gaboriau’s Monsieur Lecoq (1880). It is the influence of Poe, however, that is most in evidence in the character of Holmes and in many of his plots. Poe’s character of C. Auguste Dupin bears remarkable similarities to the Sherlock Holmes character. Both Holmes and Dupin, for example, are eccentrics; both are amateurs in the detective field; both have little regard for the official police; and both enter into investigations, not because of any overwhelming desire to bring a culprit to justice but out of the interest that the case generates and the challenge to their analytical minds. In addition, both have faithful companions who serve as the chroniclers of the exploits of their respective detective friends. Although Dupin’s companion remains anonymous and the reader is unable to draw any conclusions about his personality, Dr. Watson, in contrast, takes on an identity (although always in a secondary role) of his own. The reader shares with Watson his astonishment at Holmes’s abilities. In effect, Watson becomes a stand-in for the reader by asking the questions that need to be asked for a complete understanding of the situation. Generally, the Sherlock Holmes stories follow a similar pattern: There is usually a scene at the Baker Street residence, at which time a visitor appears and tells his or her story. After Holmes makes some preliminary observations and speculates upon a possible solution to the puzzle, Holmes and Watson visit the scene of the crime. Holmes then solves the mystery and explains to Watson how he arrived at the solution. “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” follows this formula, and it is apparent that Poe’s “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” had a direct influence on this “locked room” mystery. The murder, the locked room, and the animal killer are all variations on the ingredients in the first case in which C. Auguste Dupin appears. Even the reference to the orangutan on the grounds of the Manor House would appear to be an allusion to the murderer in Poe’s story. The gothic romance influence is also apparent in this adventure of Sherlock Holmes: There is the mysterious atmosphere and the strange, looming manor house; and there is the endangered woman threatened by a male force. Changing the murderer from the ape of Poe’s story to a serpent in Doyle’s story suggests at least symbolically the metaphysical (or supernatural) struggle between the forces of good and evil. Typically, this story as well as all the Holmes stories ends with the solution to the mystery. Sherlock Holmes acknowledges that, by driving the snake back into the room where Dr. Roylott, the murderer, is waiting, he is indirectly responsible for his death; yet he matter-of-factly states that it is not likely to weigh heavily on his conscience. The mystery has been solved; that has been the detective’s only interest in the case. Because of this single-minded interest on the part of the detective, what happens to the criminal after discovery is no longer relevant. If the criminal is to stand trial, the story ends with the arrest and no more is heard of him. There are no trials, no dramatic courtroom scenes, and no reports of executions or prison sentences which had been popular in earlier detective stories and which were to regain immense popularity in the future. Although the solution to the “ingenious puzzle” is the prime concern for the detective and certainly of interest to the reader, it is Sherlock Holmes’s character with his multifaceted personality and his limitations which makes Doyle’s stories about the detective’s adventures so re-readable. Holmes, for example, is an accomplished musician, a composer as well as an instrumentalist; he is an expert in chemical research and has educated himself to be an authority on blood stains; he is the author of innumerable monographs on such esoteric subjects as different types of tobacco, bicycle tire impressions, and types of perfume; and he is an exceptional pugilist.
Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan
351
Sherlock Holmes’s limitations, however, are what make him so attractive to the reader. He is sometimes frighteningly ignorant; for example, after Dr. Watson has explained the Copernican system to him, he responds: “Now that I know it. . . . I shall do my best to forget it”; he considers this information trivial, since it is not useful, and he feels that retaining it will crowd practical knowledge out of his mind. Holmes can also make erroneous judgments, and, perhaps most appealing of all, he can fail as a detective. It is this capacity for the detective to fail or to be outwitted that is perhaps Doyle’s most significant contribution to the detective-fiction genre. Whereas Holmes’s predecessors such as Lecoq and Dupin are presented as unerring in their conclusions and infallible in solving their cases, Doyle’s hero demonstrates his fallibility early in his career. “A Scandal in Bohemia” • It is in the first of the Sherlock Holmes short stories, “A Scandal in Bohemia,” without doubt Doyle’s version of Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Purloined Letter,” that this very human fallibility is revealed. Both stories deal with the need to recover items that are being used to blackmail a person of royal heritage. In both cases, attempts to find the items have failed and the detectives are called on for assistance; and, in both stories, a ruse is used to discover the whereabouts of the incriminating items. Although the debt to Poe is large in this story, “A Scandal in Bohemia” also displays some significant departures that establish the work as Doyle’s own, artistically. The scenes in the streets of London are conveyed with convincing detail to capture effectively “the spirit of the place” of Victorian England. The characters in Poe’s Dupin stories are lightly drawn, and the central interest for these tales is not in the people but in what happens to them. Although the characters in Poe’s stories talk about matters that are relevant only to the mystery at hand, the direct opposite is true in Doyle’s story. The people in the Holmes story are interesting and full of dramatic movement, and Holmes’s conversations with Watson and the others are filled with comments which are not related to the case. In addition, Doyle introduces the device of disguises in “A Scandal in Bohemia.” The king of Bohemia, wearing a small face mask to hide his identity, visits Holmes in his lodgings; his disguise, however, is immediately penetrated by the detective. Sherlock Holmes also assumes a disguise in the story that is so convincing and successful that even his close friend Dr. Watson is unable to recognize him. It is the skill of Irene Adler, Holmes’s antagonist in the story, in assuming another identity that leads to the detective’s being foiled. Holmes’s failure in this story, however, in no way detracts from him. On the contrary, this failure and his others (such as in “The Yellow Face”) serve to make him only more convincing and more three-dimensional as a human being than the always successful C. Auguste Dupin. Holmes loses no status through his errors; instead, he gains in the light of his past and future successes. “The Red-Headed League” • Although there will always be disagreement among Sherlock Holmes aficionados about which of the many short stories is best, there is broad agreement that one of the best-constructed stories by Arthur Conan Doyle is the second short story in the first series, “The Red-Headed League.” Doyle himself ranked the story very high when he was queried, and the Victorian reading public’s response attested to its popularity. This story also introduces one of the recurring themes of the short stories: that of the doppelgänger, or double. The dual nature of the world and of personalities is developed in parallel manners throughout the un-
352
Short Story Writers
raveling of the mystery of Jabez Wilson’s involvement with the Red-Headed League. The contemplative side of Holmes is repeatedly contrasted with his energized side, just as the orderliness of Victorian England is seen in stark relief against “the half that is evil.” Repeatedly, when there is a lull in the chase or a mystery has been solved, Sherlock Holmes retreats to his contemplative side to forget at least temporarily “the miserable weather and the still more miserable ways of our fellowmen.” “The Red-Headed League” follows the traditional formula of a Sherlock Holmes story. Holmes is visited at his flat by Jabez Wilson, who relates his problem. Wilson, the owner of a small pawnshop, has been working for the Red-Headed League for eight weeks, until abruptly and under mysterious circumstances, the league has been dissolved. He qualified for the position because of his red hair, and his only duties were to remain in a room and copy the Encyclopædia Britannica. He has been able to perform these chores because his assistant, Vincent Spaulding, was willing to work in the pawnshop for half-wages. He has come to Sherlock Holmes because he does not want to lose such a position without a struggle. Holmes and Watson visit the pawnshop, and Spaulding is recognized by the detective as being in reality John Clay, a master criminal and murderer. The detective is able to infer from the circumstances that the opposite of what is expected is true. He concludes that it is not the presence of Jabez Wilson in the room performing a meaningless “intellectual” task for the league that is important; rather, it is his absence from the pawnshop that gives his alter ego assistant the opportunity to perform the “physical” task of tunneling from the cellar into the nearby bank. Setting a trap, Holmes, Watson, and the police are able to capture Clay and his confederates in their criminal act. The double theme of the story is also reinforced in Jabez Wilson’s account of the applicants lining up to apply for the position with the Red-Headed League. He describes the crowd lining up on the stair; those in anticipation of employment ascending the stairs with hope; those who have been rejected descending in despair, forming a “double” stream. John Clay, Holmes’s antagonist in this story, is the first in a long line of adversaries of the detective who serve in effect as doppelgängers of the sleuth. Clay has an aristocratic background and possesses royal blood. Holmes also has illustrious ancestors, being descended from country squires, and his grandmother is described as being “the sister of Vernet, the French artist.” Clay is well educated and urbane, characteristics Holmes repeatedly shows throughout his adventures. Clay is described as being “cunning” in mind as well as skillful in his fingers, again a reflection of the detective’s characteristics. Clay is also gracious in his defeat and expresses admiration for the ingenuity displayed by the victorious Holmes. He is truly a worthy adversary for the detective and the direct mirror image of Holmes. “The Final Problem” • Other great master criminals and, in effect, doubles for the great detective are Colonel Sebastian Moran of “The Adventure of the Empty House,” Van Bork of “His Last Bow,” and, the most famous of them all, Professor Moriarty, who is described in “The Final Problem” as the “Napoleon of crime” and the “organizer of half that is evil and of nearly all that is undetected in this great city.” In essence, “The Final Problem” is a departure from the formula that characterizes the previous twenty-two Holmesian short stories, basically because Doyle intended that this would be the final work in which his detective would appear. Tiring of his creation and motivated by the desire to pursue his other literary interests, he has Watson record the demise of his friend. The story has no ingenious puzzle for the de-
Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan
353
tective to unravel but instead is a detailed account of Sherlock Holmes’s confrontation with his nemesis. For years, Holmes, who could “see deeply into the manifold wickedness of the human heart” and who could “leave his body at will and place himself into the mind and soul” of others, had been unable to penetrate the veil that shrouded the power “which for ever stands in the way of the law, and throws its shield over the wrongdoer.” In this manner, Doyle almost casually proposes a conspiracy theme in this story which, in the hands of other writers, becomes one of the overriding characteristics of the detective fiction and thriller genres. It is the character of Professor Moriarty, however, which commands the interest of the reader, particularly when seen as a reflection of Holmes. Professor Moriarty’s career, like Holmes’s, “has been an extraordinary one. He is a man of good birth and excellent education, endowed by Nature with a phenomenal mathematical faculty. At the age of twenty-one he wrote a treatise upon the Binomial Theorem, which has had a European vogue.” When the Professor visits Holmes at his flat, his physical appearance is described as “extremely tall and thin, his forehead domes out in a white curve, and his two eyes are deeply sunken in his head. He is clean shaven, pale, and ascetic looking.” To Holmes, his appearance is quite familiar, even though he has never met the man before. It is entirely likely that Holmes’s immediate recognition is intended to suggest that the detective, for the first time in his life, is viewing in the flesh the side of his nature that his great intellect has refused to allow him to acknowledge. Even though Dr. Watson had made special efforts to characterize Holmes as being almost totally devoid of emotion in his previous chronicles of Holmes’s adventures, there are many instances in which there are outbursts of extreme feelings on the part of the detective. Holmes fluctuates between ennui and expressions of delight. He is often impulsive and compassionate. He is patient and deferential to his female clients. He is moved to indignation and intends to exact a form of revenge in “The Five Orange Pips.” In this story, “The Final Problem,” he shows a level of nervousness and caution which is almost akin to fear in response to the threat that the malevolent genius Moriarty poses toward his person. Professor Moriarty is too much like himself for the detective to remain scientifically detached. There is no doubt that Holmes is totally conscious of the significance of the parallels that exist between the two when the Professor states: It has been a duel between you and me, Mr. Holmes. You hope to place me in the dock. I tell you that I will never stand in the dock. You hope to beat me. I tell you that you will never beat me. If you are clever enough to bring destruction upon me, rest assured that I shall do as much to you. Holmes, with Watson, flees this enemy whom he acknowledges as “being quite on the same intellectual plane” as himself. Then, at Reichenbach Falls, he is almost inevitably forced to come face-to-face once again with his other self. Sidney Paget, the illustrator of many of the original publications in the Strand Magazine, depicts the struggle between Holmes and Moriarty just before their dual plunge into the chasm as being entwined together. Thus, the culmination of Holmes’s illustrious career, as originally intended by Doyle, was brought about in an entirely satisfactory symbolic and literary manner. Holmes, who could idly concede, “I have always had an idea that I could have made a highly efficient criminal,” and “Burglary was always an alternative profession had I
354
Short Story Writers
cared to adopt it,” had resisted those impulses. In “The Final Problem” he could say: “In over a thousand cases I am not aware that I have ever used my powers upon the wrong side.” The detective, however, was keenly aware throughout this story that “if he could be assured that society was freed from Professor Moriarty he would cheerfully bring his own career to a conclusion.” With the death of Moriarty, he achieves that end. Although “London is the sweeter for [my] presence,” the destruction of the other side of his nature in Professor Moriarty makes it all the more so. The death of Sherlock Holmes along with his nemesis is comparable to self-destruction. “The Adventure of the Empty House” • When Doyle “killed off” his detective hero, he was in no way prepared for the public reaction that followed. He resisted almost continuous pressure from his publishers and the public until 1902, when he finally relented and resurrected Holmes in The Hound of the Baskervilles and later in the story “The Adventure of the Empty House.” In this story, a lieutenant of Professor Moriarty, Colonel Sebastian Moran, is the culprit and functions as the alter ego for Holmes. One of the more subtle acknowledgments of the double theme in this story is the use by Holmes of a wax model of himself to mislead his adversaries. Similar to “The Final Problem,” the story of the return of Sherlock Holmes does not follow the usual formula for the previous works, but the rest in the series adheres rather closely. When the stories are read in sequence, however, one can understand why the mere presence of the detective, however contrived his survival, would be cause for rejoicing by his followers. Even a lapse of more than ten years since his last appearance (three years within the stories) has in no way diminished his skill or intellectual capacity. Sherlock Holmes remains all that he was before his showdown with Professor Moriarty. The dialogue between the characters is as crisp as ever; the scenes are portrayed as vividly as before; the careful construction of the plots and the unraveling of the mysteries are as provocative as ever; and the imagination of the author is very much in evidence. There is evidence, however, of Doyle’s reluctance to take his hero as seriously as he had before. “The Adventure of the Dancing Men” • The story “The Adventure of the Dancing Men,” for example, is extremely contrived, almost totally dependent on cartoons as a cipher, and the reader is left with a feeling of dissatisfaction. The stories in the first series after the “death” of Sherlock Holmes are nevertheless of generally high quality and possess many memorable scenes which remain after the mysteries have been solved. Later Holmes Stories • There is agreement that the quality of the Sherlock Holmes stories published in the two collections His Last Bow and The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes is significantly diminished. Published in 1917 and 1927 respectively, the books demonstrate that Doyle was tired of his detective, as the works were written casually and almost impatiently. The onset of World War I in the title story of His Last Bow is pointed out by Jacques Barzun as being “perhaps symbolic of the end of a world of gaslight and order in which Holmes and Watson could function so predictably.” The stories in The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes, published only a few years before Doyle’s death, possess some fine moments, but there is a singular failure on the part of the author to re-create the vividness of the Victorian world that had lifted the previous series of short stories out of the ordinary and enabled the reader to accept and admire so readily the reasoning powers of Sherlock Holmes.
Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan
355
Despite the uneven quality of these works, it is a tribute to Doyle’s ability that Sherlock Holmes remains a memorable character. Although Watson informs the reader that Holmes’s knowledge of formal philosophy is nil, he is a philosopher in his own way. Holmes has probed the most abstract of understandings—ranging from the motivation of humans to the nature of the universe—from the study of the physical world. He possesses a peculiar morality akin to the John Stuart Mill variety: Evil is doing harm to others. When he seeks justice, he almost inevitably finds it; justice in the social and structured sense. Holmes has little regard for the laws of human beings; he recognizes that they do not always serve the purposes of justice, so at times he rises above them and often ignores them. For him, the distinction between right and wrong is absolute and beyond debate. It was Doyle’s skill in infusing such depth into his character that makes Holmes greater than Dupin and Lecoq. Robert W. Millett With updates by Karen M. Cleveland Marwick Other major works plays: Foreign Policy, pr. 1893; Jane Annie: Or, The Good Conduct Prize, pr., pb. 1893 (with J. M. Barrie); Waterloo, pr. 1894 (also as A Story of Waterloo); Halves, pr. 1899; Sherlock Holmes, pr. 1899 (with William Gillette); A Duet, pb. 1903; Brigadier Gerard, pr. 1906; The Fires of Fate, pr. 1909; The House of Temperley, pr. 1909; The Pot of Caviare, pr. 1910; The Speckled Band, pr. 1910; The Crown Diamond, pr. 1921; Exile: A Drama of Christmas Eve, pb. 1925; It’s Time Something Happened, pb. 1925. edited texts: Dreamland and Ghostland, 1886; D. D. Home: His Life and Mission, 1921 (by Mrs. Douglas Home); The Spiritualist’s Reader, 1924. novels: A Study in Scarlet, 1887 (serial; 1888, book); The Mystery of Cloomber, 1888; Micah Clarke, 1889; The Firm of Girdlestone, 1889; The Sign of Four, 1890 (first pb. as The Sign of the Four); Beyond the City, 1891; The Doings of Raffles Haw, 1891; The White Company, 1891; The Great Shadow, 1892; The Refugees, 1893; The Parasite, 1894; The Stark Munro Letters, 1895; The Surgeon of Gaster Fell, 1895; Rodney Stone, 1896; The Tragedy of the Koroska, 1897 (also as A Desert Drama); Uncle Bernac, 1897; A Duet, with an Occasional Chorus, 1899 (revised 1910); The Hound of the Baskervilles, 1901-1902 (serial), 1902 (book); Sir Nigel, 1905-1906 (serial), 1906 (book); The Lost World, 1912; The Poison Belt, 1913; The Valley of Fear, 1914-1915 (serial), 1915 (book); The Land of Mist, 1926. miscellaneous: The Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Reader, 2002. nonfiction: The Great Boer War, 1900; The War in South Africa: Its Causes and Conduct, 1902; The Case of Mr. George Edalji, 1907; Through the Magic Door, 1907; The Crime of the Congo, 1909; The Case of Oscar Slater, 1912; Great Britain and the Next War, 1914; In Quest of Truth, Being a Correspondence Between Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Captain H. Stansbury, 1914; To Arms!, 1914; The German War: Some Sidelights and Reflections, 1915; Western Wanderings, 1915; A Visit to Three Fronts, 1916; The British Campaign in France and Flanders, 1916-1919 (6 volumes); The Origin and Outbreak of the War, 1916; A Petition to the Prime Minister on Behalf of Roger Casement, 1916(?); The New Revelation, 1918; The Vital Message, 1919; A Debate on Spiritualism, 1920 (with Joseph McCabe); Our Reply to the Cleric, 1920; Spiritualism and Rationalism, 1920; Fairies Photographed, 1921; The Evidence for Fairies, 1921; The Wanderings of a Spiritualist, 1921; The Case for Spirit Photography, 1922 (with others); The Coming of the Fairies, 1922; Our American Adventure, 1923; Memories and Adventures, 1924; Our Second American Adventure, 1924; Psychic Experiences, 1925; The Early Christian Church and Modern Spiritualism, 1925; The History of
356
Short Story Writers
Spiritualism, 1926 (2 volumes); Pheneas Speaks: Direct Spirit Communications, 1927; A Word of Warning, 1928; What Does Spiritualism Actually Teach and Stand For?, 1928; An Open Letter to Those of My Generation, 1929; Our African Winter, 1929; The Roman Catholic Church: A Rejoinder, 1929; The Edge of the Unknown, 1930; Arthur Conan Doyle on Sherlock Holmes, 1981; Essays on Photography, 1982; Letters to the Press, 1984. poetry: Songs of Action, 1898; Songs of the Road, 1911; The Guards Came Through, and Other Poems, 1919; The Poems: Collected Edition, 1922. translation: The Mystery of Joan of Arc, 1924 (Léon Denis). Bibliography Akinson, Michael. The Secret Marriage of Sherlock Holmes and Other Eccentric Readings. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1996. Attempts to read Holmes’s stories in the manner in which Holmes himself might read them. “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” is read in terms of the philosophy of Kundalini yoga; “A Scandal in Bohemia” is read in terms of its use of traditional romance motifs and its debt to Edgar Allan Poe; Jungian psychology is used to read A Study in Scarlet; and Derridian deconstruction is used to read “The Adventure of the Copper Breeches.” Barsham, Diana. Arthur Conan Doyle and the Meaning of Masculinity. Burlington, Vt.: Ashgate, 2000. Discussion of masculinity according to Doyle, delving into all Doyle’s writings, including his war correspondence and travel writings. Green, Richard Lancelyn. A Bibliography of A. Conan Doyle. New York: Oxford University Press, 1983. Provides a massive bibliography of all that Doyle wrote, including obscure short pieces. Illustrated and containing a seventy-five-page index, this book includes a list of more than one hundred books of biographical, bibliographical, and critical interest for the study of Doyle. Hall, Jasmine Yong. “Ordering the Sensational: Sherlock Holmes and the Female Gothic.” Studies in Short Fiction 28 (Summer, 1991): 295-304. Examines how gothic elements and female clients in a number of stories, including the well-known “The Speckled Band,” establish the rational detective as a powerful, patriarchal hero. Argues that Holmes controls his female clients as much as the gothic villains in Doyle’s stories. Hodgson, John A., ed. Sherlock Holmes: The Major Stories with Contemporary Critical Essays. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Includes nine essays on Holmes, from a variety of critical perspectives, including feminist, deconstruction, and discourse analysis approaches. Jaffee, Jacqueline A. Arthur Conan Doyle. Boston: Twayne, 1987. Jaffee’s solid work combines biography and a critical discussion of Doyle’s stories and novels. Contains three chapters on the Sherlock Holmes stories, which closely examine the tales. Supplemented by an index, a bibliography of Doyle’s work, and an annotated bibliography. Jann, Rosemary. The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes: Detecting Social Order. New York: Twayne, 1995. Part of Twayne’s Masterwork Series, this slim volume is divided into two parts, the first of which places the great detective in a literary and historical context, followed by Jann’s own reading of Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlockian approach to detective fiction. In addition to a selected bibliography, Jann’s book includes a brief chronology of Doyle’s life and work. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by
Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan
357
Doyle: “The Adventure of the Dancing Men” and “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” (vol. 1), “The Greek Interpreter” (vol. 3), and “The Red-Headed League” and “A Scandal in and Bohemia” (vol. 6). Orel, Harold, ed. Critical Essays on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. New York: G. K. Hall, 1992. Including both evaluations by Doyle’s contemporaries and later scholarship—some of it commissioned specifically for inclusion in this collection—Critical Essays is divided into three sections: “Sherlock Holmes,” “Other Writings,” and “Spiritualism.” Harold Orel opens the collections with a lengthy and comprehensive essay, which is followed by a clever and classic meditation by Dorothy L. Sayers on “Dr. Watson’s Christian Name.” Also included are pieces by such literary lights as George Bernard Shaw, Max Beerbohm, and Heywood Broun. Stashower, Daniel. Teller of Tales: The Life of Arthur Conan Doyle. New York: Henry Holt, 1999. Excellent biography of Doyle. Focuses less on the Holmes novels and more on the historical novels, personal crusades, and spiritualism.
358
Andre Dubus Born: Lake Charles, Louisiana; August 11, 1936 Died: Haverhill, Massachusetts; February 24, 1999 Principal short fiction • Separate Flights, 1975; Adultery and Other Choices, 1977; Finding a Girl in America, 1980; The Times Are Never So Bad, 1983; The Last Worthless Evening, 1986; Selected Stories, 1988; Dancing After Hours: Stories, 1996; In the Bedroom: Seven Stories, 2002. Other literary forms • Although Andre Dubus wrote an early novel, The Lieutenant (1967), which is highly regarded by some critics and readers, and a short novel, Voices from the Moon (1984), which has been printed separately, his most important contributions to literature are his shorter works. Besides his fiction, Dubus wrote two wellreceived books of autobiographical essays. Achievements • Andre Dubus’s literary career is notable in the way it stands outside the shifting fashions of the American literary scene. During the 1960’s and 1970’s, when the “postmodernism” of Donald Barthelme, John Barth, and Thomas Pynchon was creating a highly self-conscious, self-reflective literature that often used its own craft to explore itself, Dubus remained a committed realist, at his best when he used his craft to explore the lives of his characters. During the period when the so-called minimalist stories of writers such as Raymond Carver, Bobbie Ann Mason, and Lorrie Moore came into literary prominence, Dubus remained what might be called a “maximalist” writer, who seemed most at home in the form of the long story, or novella. In a period of shifting male and female definitions, Dubus wrote often about the waywardness of people who continue to define themselves by concepts of masculinity and femininity that the world around them no longer values. Not least of all, in an age of secular values, Dubus often looks to the Sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church to find deep values. Biography • Andre Dubus was born in Lake Charles, Louisiana, on August 11, 1936, and attended the Christian Brothers Catholic School in Lafayette from 1944 until 1954, after which he enrolled in McNeese State University in Lake Charles. Upon graduating from college in 1958 with a bachelor’s degree in English and journalism, he married Patricia Lowe and entered the Marine Corps with a commission as lieutenant. Over the next five years, four of the couple’s children were born (Suzanne in 1958, Andre III in 1959, Jeb in 1960, and Nicole in 1963), and he was to rise to the rank of captain. In 1963, he published his first story, “The Intruder,” in The Sewanee Review and resigned his officer’s commission to enter the master of fine arts program at the University of Iowa, the much respected Writers’ Workshop program. Upon receiving his degree in 1965, he taught for one year as a lecturer at Nicholls State University in Louisiana, before accepting a position at Bradford College in Massachusetts in 1966, where he was to teach for the next fourteen years, until his retirement in 1984. Dubus was married and divorced three times, and the pain of these broken mar-
Dubus, Andre
359
riages provided a source for much of his fiction. His first marriage, to Lowe in 1958, ended in divorce in 1970. His second marriage, to Tommie Gail Cotter in 1975, ended in divorce in 1977. His third marriage, to Peggy Rambach, also a writer, in 1979, produced two daughters, Cadence, born in 1982, and Madeline, born in 1987, but ended when his wife left in November, 1987, in the midst of family strain stemming from a 1986 automobile accident, which also cost Dubus a leg. Many of Dubus’s stories have been selected for the annual The Best American Short Stories and Prize Stories: The O. Henry Awards series. Among his national honors, he received a National Endowment for the Arts grant in 1985 and a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship in 1986. Both of these honors came after his retirement from teaching in 1984. His plans to use the monetary freedom provided by these grants to spend more time writing were violently interrupted by an accident in which he had stopped to assist two distressed motorists, only to become the victim of another car. The pain of recovering from this accident, in which he saved a life but lost a leg, is chronicled in the title essay of his collection of essays Broken Vessels. On February 24, 1999, Dubus died in Haverhill, Massachusetts. Analysis • Among American story writers of the twentieth century, the one to whom Andre Dubus is most often compared is Flannery O’Connor. Although Dubus’s works are not generally marked by the wry, ironic wit that permeates O’Connor’s work, both writers are marked by what Thomas E. Kennedy, among others, has called an “existential Christian” sensibility. “If They Knew Yvonne” • An early Dubus story, “If They Knew Yvonne,” first published in The North American Review in 1969 and collected both in Separate Flights and Selected Stories, displays this sensibility clearly. This story traces the development of a teenager, Harry Dugal, growing into manhood and caught between two powerful forces: his emerging sexuality and his need for the absolution and Communion provided by the Roman Catholic Church. Taught by the fathers at the Christian Brothers School to regard masturbation as “self-abuse” and a mortal sin, Harry, as he discovers his own inability to resist the urge to masturbate, goes to confession at every opportunity to confess his sins. Disgusted at his own weakness and at the sexual weakness that he discovers in his family around him, including his parents, whose store of condoms he discovers, and his sister Janet, who gets married while two months pregnant, the young Harry even considers emasculating himself at one point. At the age of nineteen, however, he has his first sexual encounter with a woman his own age, Yvonne Millet, and discovers a type of sexuality that does not disgust him. When Yvonne implores him, “Love me, Harry, love me,” he begins to perceive that this type of love is not the squalid lust that he had been warned to guard against but something else, something he is not sure the Catholic fathers at his school knew anything about. The story ends shortly after he has drifted apart from Yvonne and goes to confession again. After Harry has confessed his sexual affair, the priest quotes a line from St. John, in which Christ prays, “I do not pray that You take them out of the world but that You keep them from evil,” a quote that delineates the story’s Christian existentialist theme. Harry begins to understand that the higher good depends not on remaining pure and safe from the world but on being a responsible, conscientious member of the world. In his full-length study, Andre Dubus: A Study of the Short Fiction, Thomas Kennedy points out that almost half of Dubus’s first fifty stories deal with violent themes or
360
Short Story Writers
subjects, but he further points out that violence is only secondary to the central theme, a symptom of the greater condition of “human isolation and disconnection in . . . modern America.” This is not to say that Dubus in any way excuses violence, but rather that understanding how violence grows out of an acceptance of superficial values is an important source for his fiction. “The Pretty Girl” • Dubus’s novella “The Pretty Girl,” collected in both The Times Are Never So Bad and Selected Stories, is one of his best extended examinations of this type of violence. One of the two point-of-view characters is Raymond Yarborough, who is presented as a wildly exploding tinderbox of violence. When the reader meets him, he is divorced from the other main character, Polly Comeau, but still obsessed by her. The reader learns early that Raymond has already raped her, though he considers that he was only “taking back my wife for a while.” Before long, he beats up and severely injures a man whom he knows she has slept with and lights a fire around the house where Polly is staying, not to destroy anything but to terrorize her. If Raymond is in many ways the antagonist in the story, he is also the most interesting character, and his former wife Polly is not presented in particularly sympathetic terms. A waitress by trade, Polly is in many ways best described in the terms of the story’s title as a twenty-six-year-old “pretty girl” who has used her beauty to avoid fashioning an adult identity and instead has tended to drift from one sexual affair to another, even during the course of her marriage, without much sense of responsibility or consequences. Polly is a loner almost as much as Raymond is. She shares a house with a male acquaintance but has no close friends either male or female. Her relationships with women tend to be competitive, and her friendships with men tend to be brief, quickly sacrificed to her love affairs. She is significantly alone when Raymond breaks into her house at the end of the story to confront her about why she left him and what she really wants. Though he is unarmed, Polly, who has been ill and alone for several days, uses a gun she bought for protection to kill him when he begins to take off his clothes. Both main characters are carefully constructed to be unlikable, though only Raymond is presented as truly repugnant. The success of the story is that it compels the reader nevertheless to want to understand each of them and to appreciate each character’s struggle, while not inviting the reader to forget or overlook their immature self-obsession or moral rootlessness. “Finding a Girl in America” • A number of Dubus’s stories deal with recurring characters. Two stories of the three that deal with Hank Allison, a middle-aged, philandering college professor, show Dubus’s art at both its best and its worst. “Finding a Girl in America” shows both the character Hank Allison and the writer Andre Dubus at their worst. In it, Hank is presented as a divorced college professor who has been having affairs with his female students. As the story opens, he has learned that a former lover had an abortion and feels cheated because he believes that had the baby been born, it would have filled the void left in his life by his daughter growing up; the point of view of the woman who would have had a baby she did not want fathered by a man she did not love is not seriously considered. The attention to detail, which in other stories creates a convincing illusion of reality, in this story seems tedious and self-indulgent. Dubus’s insistence on finding moral frameworks to understand his characters, a tendency that in many stories uplifts his art, in this story misleads him.
Dubus, Andre
361
Hank’s life is so self-indulgent that it is hard for a reader to take him half as seriously as he takes himself. “Adultery” • The earlier story, “Adultery,” is by contrast one of the finest examples of Dubus’s art. To be sure, Hank Allison is the same self-centered, self-justifying man that the reader meets in the later story (as well as in “We Don’t Live Here Anymore”). “Adultery,” however, is carefully constructed to consider not only marital fidelity but also spiritual fidelity. The main characters are Hank Allison, his wife Edith, and Father Joe Ritchie, a Catholic priest dying of cancer who renounces his vows and has an affair with Edith. The story also investigates the lives of a number of other men and women whom Hank and Edith choose as lovers. It is Hank who initially brings adultery into his and Edith’s marriage, but when she discovers it, he immediately consents to her right to have extramarital affairs as well. The affairs they both have take their toll especially on Edith and make a sham of their marriage. The irony of the title—and the element that raises this story to the finest level of American fiction—is that Edith’s adultery with a dying Catholic priest is not viewed by her or Father Ritchie as true adultery; the true adultery for her is staying in a marriage based on hypocrisy. Similarly, although this affair compromises Joe Ritchie in more ways than one, he and Edith both understand that their relationship is spiritually as well as personally the right thing to do; what worries Joe Ritchie most is that Edith might remain married to Hank, and he is relieved when she comes to him while he is dying to say that she is divorcing Hank. By deciding to divorce Hank, Edith upholds at least the idea of marital fidelity. Moreover, she realizes that her affair with Joe Ritchie has provided her with a new center for her life and that she would be unfaithful to herself and the belief in marriage to remain with Hank any longer. “A Father’s Story” • “A Father’s Story,” which was chosen by John Updike for the annual The Best American Short Stories in 1984, is in some respects Dubus’s most important story. Smaller in scale than stories such as “The Fat Girl” or “Separate Flights,” which each compress the story of several years into a few pages, “A Father’s Story” focuses on a crucial incident in the life of Luke Ripley and his daughter Jennifer. Like many of Dubus’s characters, Luke seems in many ways to be a version of the author, but in this case, a version that has achieved a deceptive veneer of simplicity. The opening line of the story, “My name is Luke Ripley and here is what I call my life,” seems to present the voice of a direct, straightforward man. The life that Luke tells the reader about is one filled with a variety of contradictions: He is a devout Catholic but divorced; he attends Mass regularly but does not always listen; he enjoys talking to his priest but casually, preferably over a few beers, and what they discuss is mostly small talk; he is a self-described lazy man who dislikes waking up early but does so each morning to pray, not because he feels obligated to do so but because he knows he has the choice not to do so. Luke Ripley is a man who lives with contradictions and accepts them. As such, when his daughter comes to him, frantically telling him that she hit a man with a car, he reacts almost instinctively. Rather than call the police or an ambulance, he drives to the scene of the accident to verify that the young man is in fact dead. When he knows that there is nothing that can be done to help the young man, he drives home and puts his daughter to bed, then takes her car out and runs it into a tree in front of the church to cover up the dent she had already created. The story
362
Short Story Writers
ends with Luke recalling to the reader how he justifies himself to his God each morning, saying, “You never had a daughter and, if You had, You could not have borne her passion. . . . I love her more than I love truth.” God replies, “Then you love in weakness,” to which Luke responds, “As You love me.” The power of “A Father’s Story” is that it captures perfectly the opposites that Dubus’s fiction is constantly exploring. Luke Ripley’s love for his daughter is both his strength and his weakness. Similarly, his love for his daughter moves him to deceive, even as his religion demands confession; and when he finds himself unable to confess his sin of covering up his daughter’s crime, the story itself, it is clear, is his substitute for the confession that he cannot make to a priest. Like many of Dubus’s stories, “A Father’s Story” shows a person caught between the confusing, ambiguous demands of his human heart and the by-no-means-clear demands of a religion in which he believes but which speaks of an absolute he can only partially understand. Thomas Cassidy With updates by Charles E. May Other major works novels: The Lieutenant, 1967; Voices from the Moon, 1984; We Don’t Live Here Anymore, 1984. nonfiction: Broken Vessels, 1991; Meditations from a Movable Chair: Essays, 1998. Bibliography Breslin, John B. “Playing Out of the Patterns of Sin and Grace: The Catholic Imagination of Andre Dubus.” Commonweal 115 (December 2, 1988): 652-656. An interesting analysis of the Catholic themes in Dubus’s literature, written for a lay audience. Breslin focuses particularly on Dubus’s trilogy of stories dealing with Hank Allison (“We Don’t Live Here Anymore,” “Adultery,” and “Finding a Girl in America”), and “A Father’s Story.” Cocchiarale, Michael. “The Complicated Catholicism of Andre Dubus.” In Songs of the New South: Writing Contemporary Louisiana, edited by Suzanne D. Green and Lisa Abney. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 2001. Discusses Dubus’s writing in the context of Catholicism and its role in the complex morality of his characters. Dubus, Andre. “An Interview with Andre Dubus.” Interview by David Yandell Todd. Yale Review 86 (July, 1998): 89-110. Dubus candidly discusses his decision to become a writer and the relationship between his life, his stories, and the authors who have most influenced him. He also considers what motivates his characters, creates their conflicts, and provides them with spiritual and moral significance. Feeney, Joseph J. “Poised for Fame: Andre Dubus at Fifty.” America 155 (November 15, 1986): 296-299. Using the occasion of Dubus’s fiftieth birthday, the author provides a general introduction to the man, his writing, and his major themes. Written for an audience he assumes to be generally unfamiliar with Dubus’s fiction, this article presents the major themes of Dubus’s fiction without exploring them in depth. Ferriss, Lucy. “Andre Dubus: ‘Never Truly Members.’” In Southern Writers at Century’s End, edited by Jeffery J. Folks and James A. Perkins. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1997. Discusses several short stories with a focus on Dubus’s concerns with Roman Catholic sexual politics, particularly in the context of his women characters and his connection with the literary tradition of the South.
Dubus, Andre
363
Kennedy, Thomas E. Andre Dubus: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1988. The first full-length study of Dubus’s fiction to be published, this volume is by far the most helpful work for someone interested in Dubus and his fiction. Kennedy groups Dubus’s stories together by their thematic content and analyzes them in separate chapters, which are each devoted to one theme. Also included are other critical evaluations, two interviews with Dubus, an extensive bibliography of primary and secondary sources, and a helpfully designed index. If there is a flaw, it is that Kennedy sometimes seems too devoted to Dubus’s work to accurately evaluate its occasional shortcomings. Lesser, Ellen. “True Confession: Andre Dubus Talks Straight.” Review of Selected Stories. Village Voice 37 (January 17, 1989): 56. Lesser claims that “Dubus writes stories like a pilot pushing the envelope—continually testing fiction’s effective limits.” She praises his fiction for its deliberate unfashionableness and for its unsimplified Catholic sensibility. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Dubus: “The Curse” and “Dancing After Hours” (vol. 2), “A Father’s Story” and “The Fat Girl” (vol. 3), and “Killings” (vol. 4). Miner, Madone. “Jumping from One Heart to Another: How Andre Dubus Writes About Women.” Critique 39 (Fall, 1997): 18-31. Discusses three stories—“Anna,” “Leslie in California,” and “Rose”—in terms of Dubus’s ability to write empathetically from a woman’s perspective, to speak with a woman’s voice about women’s experience, while still retaining his “maleness.” Rowe, Anne E. “Andre Dubus.” In Contemporary Fiction Writers of the South, edited by Joseph M. Flora and Robert Bain. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1993. General introduction to such Dubus themes as the passage from childhood to the adult world, failed friendships and marriages, and the individual’s search for a meaningful center. Also includes an analytical survey of criticism of Dubus’s fiction. Yarbrough, Steve. “Andre Dubus: From Detached Incident to Compressed Novel.” Critique: Studies in Modern Fiction 28 (Fall, 1986); 19-27. Argues that Dubus’s short stories can be categorized in three different ways, of which the largest category is the compressed novel, which follows the course of characters’ lives for several years. This article focuses on a number of short stories, including “The Doctor,” “The Dark Men,” “Townies,” “In My Life,” “Separate Flights,” and “The Fat Girl.”
364
Stuart Dybek Born: Chicago, Illinois; April 10, 1942 Principal short fiction • Childhood and Other Neighborhoods, 1980; The Coast of Chicago, 1990; The Story of Mist, 1993; I Sailed with Magellan, 2003 (novellas). Other literary forms • Stuart Dybek is known principally for his short fiction. He has also published three volumes of poetry: Brass Knuckles (1979), Kiddie Corner (1981), and Streets in Their Own Ink (2004). His only play, Orchids, was produced in 1990, and his short story “Death of a Right Fielder” was adapted to television in 1991. Achievements • Editors have chosen many of Stuart Dybek’s stories for inclusion in anthologies. He won a Special Citation from the Ernest Hemingway Foundation as well as awards from the Cliff Dwellers Arts Foundation, Friends of American Writers, the Whiting Foundation, and the Society of Midland Authors. In addition, he received a Nelson Algren Award, several O. Henry Awards, and the Church and the Artist Literary Competition Award. Dybek has been the recipient of a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship and the National Endowment for the Arts grant. Biography • Stuart Dybek was born on April 10, 1942, in Chicago, the son of Stanley and Adeline Sala Dybek. He grew up in a working-class, ethnic neighborhood, a milieu that figures prominently in his writing. After graduating from a Roman Catholic high school, he enrolled at Loyola University, but he interrupted his education to work in the Civil Rights and antiwar movements of the early 1960’s. He earned a bachelor’s degree from Loyola in 1964 and a master’s degree in 1968. He married Caren Bassett in 1966. After working as a case worker with the Cook County Department of Public Aid, teaching in a Chicago-area elementary school, and teaching high school on the island of St. Thomas as a VISTA volunteer, Dybek returned to school. He earned an master of fine arts degree from the prestigious University of Iowa Writers’ Workshop in 1973. In 1974, he began teaching English and creative writing at Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo, Michigan. He served as a visiting professor at Princeton University in 1990 and began teaching in the Warren Wilson M.F.A. program for writers in 1985. Dybek’s first book-length publication was his collection of poetry and prose poems, Brass Knuckles. His first collection of short stories, Childhood and Other Neighborhoods, published in 1980, was well received by the critics. Likewise, his second collection, The Coast of Chicago (1990), received considerable critical praise. Beginning the mid-1970’s, Dybek published a steady stream of stories in such important journals as Ploughshares and TriQuarterly and such popular magazines as The New Yorker and The Atlantic Monthly. Analysis • Chicago has a long tradition of producing fine writers who use the city as their literary landscape. Gwendolyn Brooks, Carl Sandburg, Upton Sinclair, and The-
Dybek, Stuart
365
odore Dreiser, among others, belong to this tradition. Stuart Dybek, while drawing heavily on the city for his settings, characters, and images, departs from the tradition with his dreamlike portrayal of life in a postmodern world. Some critics have identified his work with Magical Realism and have suggested a connection with Jorge Luis Borges and Italo Calvino. Dybek himself reports that after he wrote some of the early stories included in Childhood and Other Neighborhoods he began to read the works of Franz Kafka and Gabriel García Márquez. In addition to exploring the intersection between dreams and reality, Dybek has pioneered the genre sometimes known as “sudden” or “flash” fiction. These stories are sometimes also called “short short” stories; sudden fiction can be just a few paragraphs long, and such stories are never longer than three pages. Consequently, readers of sudden fiction often find themselves in the middle of a situation well under way, a situation that will end but not conclude. Some of the prose poems in Dybek’s poetry collection Brass Knuckles could fall into this category. The Coast of Chicago also includes several very short stories. Many of Dybek’s stories draw on his experiences growing up in a Polish-Latino neighborhood on the South Side of Chicago. His characters often have Polish surnames, attend Catholic churches, and carry with them the culture and mythology of Eastern Europe. Even when his stories are not overtly about the immigrant experience, their settings are rich with ethnic sounds, aromas, and sights. Churches frequently appear in the center of the landscape. Dybek often places his characters in moments of transformation. Frequently this takes the form of a coming-of-age story, especially in Childhood and Other Neighborhoods. In a 1997 interview with Mike Nickel and Adrian Smith, Dybek says that he is always “looking for some door in the story that opens on another world.” For some characters, this can be the world of adulthood; for others, it can be an entry into the world of magic or death. The entry into a different world can be a transformative moment for his characters, as well as for his readers. Childhood and Other Neighborhoods • The eleven stories of the collection are about coming of age. With his title, Dybek deliberately suggests that there is both a time and a space to childhood; that is, he sees childhood in the same way one would see a neighborhood, as a place where interconnected people live out their lives, bounded by streets, houses, ethnicity, and religion. The main characters in this collection are generally young people, often second- or third-generation Poles making their homes in Chicago. Dybek himself identifies the subject of the collection as “perception,” reminding his readers that children perceive the world in ways that are different from the ways adults do. For many of the characters in this book, their moment of transformation comes when they leave the familiar streets of their own neighborhood and venture out into the world at large. Sometimes these adventures end tragically, sometimes humorously. Often the world outside the neighborhood is a world infused with magic or horror. The opening story of Childhood and Other Neighborhoods, “The Palatski Man” is about a young girl, Mary, and her older brother John. The story opens on Palm Sunday and continues to use religious iconography and imagery throughout. At the center of the story stands the nameless Palatski Man, a vendor who dresses in white and sells taffy apples and palatski, a confection of wafers and honey. There is a strangeness to this treat; Mary has never seen palatski sold anywhere else. For Mary, eating the palatski reminds her of Holy Communion, an image that recurs later in the story.
366
Short Story Writers
John and his friend Ray Cruz are fascinated by the Ragmen, who traverse their neighborhood collecting rags. John tells Mary about following a Ragman for a long way and discovering the place where all the Ragmen live. Ray and John are discovered by the Ragmen and become separated. Later, when John calls Ray’s home, Ray denies that the adventure ever happened, and John is unable to locate the Ragmen’s camp again. Later, John and Mary follow the Palatski Man and find themselves once again at the Ragmen’s camp. In a mystical, frightening ceremony, the young people partake of a kind of Eucharist consisting of taffy apple syrup and palatski, which tastes surprisingly bitter. That night, Mary discovers that John has not eaten his portion. The story closes strangely with a scene that could be a real event, a vision, or a dream. The Palatski Man comes for Mary, and she knows that she must go with him. Dybek reports that he wrote this story while listening to the music of Polish composer Zoltán Kodály. The music suggested the strange, Eastern European images. There are also undercurrents of the Persephone myth, and readers should remember that this myth was a subject of a poem in Dybek’s Brass Knuckles. In Greek mythology, Persephone eats pomegranate seeds offered her by Hades, the ruler of the underworld. As a result, she is bound to stay with him for six months of the year. Likewise, Mary’s ingestion of the minute wafer given to her by the Palatski Man makes possible the final scene. The Coast of Chicago • The Coast of Chicago contains both longer stories and very short stories, intertwined and interconnected by theme and image. Some reviewers suggest that the very short stories are lyrical in nature and may be autobiographical. Again, Chicago provides the setting for the stories, and again, Dybek has said that he listened to music, jazz this time, as he wrote the stories. Many of the stories in the collection have a dreamlike, legendary quality to them. Art and music figure in many of the stories. For example, “Nighthawks,” itself a minicollection of tales within the larger collection, uses Edward Hopper’s painting by the same name as its starting point. Likewise, “Chopin in Winter” draws on the music of the Polish composer. In all, the stories are often elegiac, somber, nearly hallucinatory. Again, Dybek seems most interested in showing the reader the way characters and settings change, often subtly, often before the reader’s very eyes. “Ant” • Appearing in the Winter, 1997-1998, issue of Ploughshares, “Ant” is a sample of Dybek’s very short fiction and an example of the blend of fantasy and realism characteristic of many of his stories. In addition, the story features entry into another world and then back into the ordinary one. The story opens with Martin lying on a blanket under a tree with his lover. When an ant begins to drag him by his toe, Martin remembers stories read to him when he was a boy by his Uncle Wayne. His uncle, a veteran of an unnamed war, acted out the stories after reading them to Martin. The most memorable for Martin was “Lonigan and the Ants.” His uncle, who had pretended that he was an ant and Martin was Lonigan, had begun to pursue him. All that saved the frightened Martin from the mad pursuit by his uncle was the reminder that Lonigan does not die, and the ants do not win; the “authority of the story” is enough to change his uncle’s actions. Dybek seems to be playing with the boundaries of storytelling here. In the larger story, he exerts authority over his own story and writes a version in which one ant does win. Eventually, an ant works its way up Martin’s back, grabs hold of his belt, lifts him off the ground, and carries him away. Diane Andrews Henningfeld
Dybek, Stuart
367
Other major works play: Orchids, pr. 1990. poetry: Brass Knuckles, 1979; Kiddie Corner, 1981; Streets in Their Own Ink, 2004. Bibliography Cook, Bruce. “Walks on the Southwest Side.” Washington Post Book World (January 13, 1980): 1-2. Places Dybek in the tradition of the Chicago writers, including Nelson Algren, Gwendolyn Brooks, and Saul Bellow, in a review of Childhood and Other Neighborhoods. Dybek, Stuart. “An Interview with Stuart Dybek.” Interview by Mike Nickel and Adrian Smith. Chicago Review 43 (Winter, 1997): 87-101. A revealing interview in which Dybek reflects on what it means to be a “Chicago writer,” his ethnic background and how it influences his writing, and his ideas about form and writing. ____________. “Thread.” Harper’s 297 (September, 1998): 34-37. A brief memoir by Dybek recalling his Catholic upbringing and his first Holy Communion. Gladsky, Thomas S. “From Ethnicity to Multiculturalism: The Fiction of Stuart Dybek.” MELUS 20 (Summer, 1995): 105-118. Offers a brief history of Polish immigration to the United States followed by a consideration of Polish American writers before turning to an examination of Stuart Dybek in this context. Connects ethnicity and memory and discusses the role of Catholicism in Dybek’s prose. Kakutani, Michiko. “Lyrical Loss and Desolation of Misfits in Chicago.” The New York Times Book Review (April 20, 1990): C31. Draws a parallel between The Coast of Chicago and Sherwood Anderson’s Winesburg, Ohio (1919), noting similarities in characters, lyricism, and “emotional forcefulness.” Lee, Don. “About Stuart Dybek.” Ploughshares 24 (Spring, 1998): 192-198. A profile of Dybek and his subject matter. Provides biographical information as well as considering Dybek’s contribution to the “short short” genre of short stories. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Dybek: “Bijou” and “Blight” (vol. 1), and “Pet Milk” (vol. 6). Shapard, Robert, and James Thomas, eds. Sudden Fiction: American Short-Short Stories. Salt Lake City: Gibbs M. Smith, 1986. The classic collection of the “short short” story. Includes Dybek’s short short “Sunday at the Zoo” as well as an afterword by Dybek on the genre. Ward, Robert. “A Review of Childhood and Other Neighborhoods.” Northwest Review 18 (Fall, 1980): 149-157. Weber, Katharine. “Windy City Dreaming.” The New York Times Book Review, May 20, 1990, 30. Reviews The Coast of Chicago, connecting memory, dreaming, and the dreamlike nature of Dybek’s stories.
368
Ralph Ellison Born: Oklahoma City, Oklahoma; March 1, 1914 Died: New York, New York; April 16, 1994 Principal short fiction • Flying Home, and Other Stories, 1996. Other literary forms • Invisible Man, Ralph Ellison’s 1952 novel, is one of the most important American novels of the twentieth century. Ellison also published two wellreceived collections of essays, Shadow and Act (1964) and Going to the Territory (1986), which were combined into one volume in The Collected Essays of Ralph Ellison (1995). In 1999, a posthumous edition of his long-awaited second novel was published as Juneteenth: A Novel. Achievements • Though he won a Rosenwald grant in 1945 on the strength of his short fiction, and though two of his short stories, “Flying Home” and “King of the Bingo Game,” are among the most commonly anthologized short stories in twentieth century American literature, Ralph Ellison is best known for his 1952 novel Invisible Man, which won the National Book Award and the Russwurm Award. In 1975 he was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Letters, which in 1955 awarded him a Prix de Rome Fellowship. He received the French Chevalier de l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres in 1970 and the National Medal of Arts in 1985. In 1984 he was awarded the Langston Hughes medallion by City College in New York for his contributions to arts and letters. Biography • Ralph Waldo Ellison was born March 1, 1914, in Oklahoma City to Ida and Lewis Alfred Ellison, who had moved out of the South in search of a more progressive place to live. An ambitious student, he distinguished himself locally and was rewarded with a scholarship to attend the Tuskegee Institute, in part because the local white population did not want Ellison, an African American, to integrate the white colleges in Oklahoma. Unable to afford the fare to Alabama, he rode a freight train to Tuskegee, in which he enrolled in 1933. A voracious reader in college, he pursued interests in literature, history, and folklore. At the end of his junior year, Ellison, like the narrator of Invisible Man, was refused financial aid and so traveled to New York City, where he hoped to make enough money to finish his studies. While in New York, he met another African American author, Richard Wright, who encouraged Ellison’s literary ambitions, and instead of returning to Tuskegee, he began to contribute short stories and essays to various literary journals and anthologies. From 1938 to 1944, he worked with the Federal Writers Project, and in 1945, he was a awarded a Rosenwald grant to write a novel. The result was Invisible Man (1952), a landmark work in African American fiction that won for its author numerous honorary degrees, literary awards, and worldwide fame. Though Ellison would publish two well-received collections of essays, Shadow and Act and Going to the Territory, he would never follow up his first novel with a second in his lifetime. He began writing his next novel around 1958, and over the years he was to publish numerous excerpts from it as a work-in-progress. A fire at his Plainsfield,
Ellison, Ralph
369
Massachusetts, summer home destroyed much of the manuscript in 1967, causing him to have to painstakingly reconstruct it. Though he was to work on this project for the rest of his life, he never found a final form for the novel with which he felt comfortable, and it remained unfinished when he died of a heart attack in 1994. His literary executor, John F. Callahan, published his short fiction in one volume as Flying Home, and Other Stories in 1996 and a selfcontained portion of his final novel as Juneteenth in 1999. Analysis • Because most of Ralph Ellison’s short fiction was written before his career as a novelist began, his short stories are often analyzed biographically, as the training ground for the novelist he was to become. This is not entirely unjustified beNational Archives cause a biographical overview of his literary output reveals that he tried out the voices, techniques, and ideas that he was to present so boldly in Invisible Man and almost completely abandoned the form after his success as a novelist, devoting himself to his essays and to his never-to-be-completed second novel. It is true that in his two most accomplished stories, “The King of the Bingo Game” and “Flying Home,” he develops themes of the chaos of the modern world and the affliction of racial conflict that would later be combined and expanded in his famous novel. On the other hand, his earlier stories show him working out many of the same ideas from different perspectives. Although the voice that informs his most accomplished work is a mature voice that is uniquely Ellison’s own, the voices in his other stories show more clearly the influences of Ernest Hemingway, Richard Wright, and James Joyce. In relating his short fiction to his overall work, Edith Schor in Visible Ellison: A Study of Ralph Ellison’s Fiction (1993) aptly observed that Ellison’s short stories provided experimental laboratories for testing the translation of the forms and experiences of African American life into literature. In evaluating the stories themselves, however, Robert Bone best summarized their lasting value when he observed in “Ralph Ellison and the Uses of Imagination” (1966) that Ellison’s short stories are about “adventurers” testing “the fixed boundaries of southern life.” Flying Home, and Other Stories • Flying Home, and Other Stories is a posthumous collection of stories edited by Ralph Ellison’s literary executor, John F. Callahan, which brings together in one volume all of the principal short fiction Ellison wrote (excepting pieces that were published as excerpts of his novels). Callahan arranged the stories according to the age of the main characters, thereby highlighting the stories’
370
Short Story Writers
thematic unity regarding the growth of young persons’ ideologies, which might not otherwise be evident. The collection opens with “A Party Down by the Square,” a story told in an intentionally flat style by a young man from Cincinnati who visits his uncle in Alabama and witnesses a lynching on a stormy night. Confused by the cyclone that moves through the town, an airplane pilot mistakes the fire of the lynching for an airport flare and flies too low through the town, knocking loose a wire and electrocuting a white woman. Undaunted, the crowd continues with the lynching and the anonymous narrator watches a nameless black man being burned, marveling at the victim’s resiliency but showing no moral awareness of the horror of the act. Four of the stories in the collection focus on two young friends, Buster and Riley, as they explore their world and their friendship. The first story, “Mister Toussan,” finds them making up imaginary exploits for Haitian liberator Toussaint L’Ouverture, a name they have heard but with which they have only vague associations and upon which they hang various fantasies. Similarly, “Afternoon” and “That I Had Wings” find the boys involved in imaginative games to stave off boredom. “A Coupla Scalped Indians” focuses on Riley, who has just been “scalped” (circumcised) at the age of eleven, having a sexually charged encounter with old Aunt Mack, an eccentric healer Riley sees naked in her shack as he is making his way home from a carnival. “All was real,” Riley tells the reader after leaving her shack, in wonderment about his discovery of the encroaching adult reality. “Hymie’s Bull” and “I Did Not Learn Their Names” are stories about riding freight trains, and together with “The Black Ball” and “A Hard Time Keeping Up,” they are about young men finding their way in a world that can be violent and harsh but that can also contain friendship and tenderness in unexpected places. The importance of learning to discern the tenderness amid the harshness of the world becomes the central theme of two of the most important stories in the collection, “In a Strange Land” and “Flying Home.” “King of the Bingo Game,” by contrast, is a story about a young man trying to make his way in a world that offers little in the way of tenderness and much in the way of danger. Though “Flying Home” and “King of the Bingo Game” are the most significant stories in this collection, the collection offers a startling group of works, each of which is a semiprecious jewel and which, when taken together, mark the growth of the author’s artistry. “King of the Bingo Game” • One of Ellison’s most durable statements about the harsh chaos of the modern world can be found in “King of the Bingo Game.” The main character is an unnamed black North Carolina man living in Harlem, who has wandered into a cinema in the hope of winning the door prize that might pay for a doctor for his wife. By playing his own and several discarded Bingo cards simultaneously, he manages to win the bingo portion of the game, which gives him the opportunity to spin the bingo wheel. While on stage, he spins the bingo wheel by pressing a button but is then unable to take the chance of letting the button go. Only double zero will win the jackpot of $36.90, and he realizes that so long as he keeps the wheel spinning, he has not lost, so he refuses to let the wheel stop. The wheel takes on the symbolic importance of a mandala, a wheel of life, something the main character realizes when he exclaims, “This is God!” Because he has taken much too long to let go of the button, security guards try to take it from him and knock him out in an altercation. The wheel stops at double zero, but as he fades into unconsciousness, he realizes that he will not get the prize he sought. Though this story is among Ellison’s
Ellison, Ralph
371
harsher fictions, it is also one of his most poetic presentations of the unfeeling chaos of the modern world. “In a Strange Country” • Though not as artistically satisfying as the longer “Flying Home,” “In a Strange Country” tells a similar tale of self-discovery through the acceptance of a previously despised group identity. Parker is an intelligent black merchant seaman who lands in Wales during World War II only to be promptly attacked by a group of American soldiers simply for being a black man. A group of Welshmen, led by Mr. Catti, rescues him but not before his eye is injured and begins to swell. Over several drafts of ale, Catti learns that Parker is a music enthusiast and takes him to a singing club. There, Parker is swept up in the emotions of the songs about Welsh national pride but reminds himself that he is from Harlem, not Wales. He feels at first alienated and then deeply connected to the men around him, who, he believes, see his humanity much more clearly than do his fellow Americans who are white. As the evening is ending, the band begins to play “The Star-Spangled Banner” in his honor, and he finds himself singing along with deep feeling. On one hand, the “strange country” of the title is Wales, but on a deeper level, it is the part of himself that is opened up by the bonding of common humanity he shares with these Welshmen and which, for the first time in his life, disallows any easy cynicism. “Flying Home” • Ralph Ellison’s longest short story, “Flying Home,” is also his most richly satisfying accomplishment in the form. At the center of the story is Todd, a young black man whose lifelong dream of becoming a pilot crashes along with his plane when he flies into a buzzard on a training flight. Jefferson, an old black man who comes to Todd’s rescue after the crash, tells him the buzzards are called “jim crows” locally, setting up an important level of symbolism about what has really caused Todd’s crash. In fact, Todd has been training with the Tuskegee Airmen, a group of black World War II pilots who trained at the famed Tuskegee Institute but were only reluctantly deployed for combat missions. For Todd, this crash landing on a routine flight almost certainly means he will never get another chance to fly and, in his mind, will become the common black man he considers Jefferson to be, the worst fate he can imagine for himself. Despite the younger man’s hostility, Jefferson distracts the injured Todd by telling him a story about dying, going to heaven, and flying around so fast as to cause “a storm and a couple of lynchings down here in Macon County.” In his storywithin-a-story, Jefferson is stripped of his wings for flying too fast and is sent down to earth with a parachute and a map of Alabama. Todd, seeing only that this story has been twisted to mirror his own situation, snaps, “Why are you making fun of me?”— which, in fact, the old man is not doing. A feverish dream into which Todd drifts reveals not only the depth of his lifelong desire to fly but also the power of his grandmother’s admonition: Young man, young man Yo arm’s too short To box with God. To Todd, becoming a pilot means taking a position higher than the majority white culture wants to allow black men of his time to occupy; it is the equivalent of box-
372
Short Story Writers
ing with God in his mind. To have failed as a pilot means not only to have made a mistake but also to have let his entire race down, something he cannot allow to happen. So when Dabney Graves, the racist landowner on whose property Todd has crashed, arrives at the site, Todd snaps at the man and places his own life in danger. Jefferson, though, saves him by intervening and telling Graves that the Army told Todd never to abandon his ship. Graves’s temper is assuaged, and Jefferson and a young boy are allowed to take Todd to safety in a stretcher. The final image is of Todd watching a buzzard flying against the sun, glowing like a bird of flaming gold. This image suggests that though Todd will never fly again, his spirit will rise up like a phoenix from the ashes of his defeat, a victory made possible by the current of goodwill he can now allow himself to feel for Jefferson. Todd will begin to learn to love himself for who he is by loving others for who they are. Thomas Cassidy Other major works novels: Invisible Man, 1952; Juneteenth, 1999 (John F. Callahan, editor). nonfiction: Shadow and Act, 1964; The Writer’s Experience, 1964 (with Karl Shapiro); Going to the Territory, 1986; Conversations with Ralph Ellison, 1995 (Maryemma Graham and Amritjit Singh, editors); The Collected Essays of Ralph Ellison, 1995 (John F. Callahan, editor); Trading Twelves: The Selected Letters of Ralph Ellison and Albert Murray, 2000; Living with Music: Ralph Ellison’s Jazz Writings, 2001 (Robert O’Meally, editor). Bibliography Benston, Kimberly, ed. Speaking for You: The Vision of Ralph Ellison. Washington, D.C.: Howard University Press, 1987. Useful resource of responses to Ellison’s fiction and essays. Also includes an extensive bibliography of his writings. Bloom, Harold, ed. Modern Critical Views: Ralph Ellison. New York: Chelsea House, 1986. Though this widely available collection of essays focuses mainly on Invisible Man, it provides insights from which any reader of Ralph Ellison may profit, and Berndt Ostendor’s essay, “Anthropology, Modernism, and Jazz,” offers much to the reader of “Flying Home.” Bone, Robert. “Ralph Ellison and the Uses of Imagination.” Triquarterly 6 (1966): 3954. An important essay on the uses of transcendentalism and jazz in Ellison’s fiction and of his writing’s importance to the Civil Rights movement and black culture in general. Busby, Mark. Ralph Ellison. Boston: Twayne, 1991. Excellent introduction to Ellison’s life and work. Callahan, John F. Introduction to Flying Home, and Other Stories, by Ralph Ellison. Edited by John F. Callahan. New York: Random House, 1996. Callahan’s introduction to this collection of fiction is essential reading for anyone interested in Ellison’s fiction, not only for the literary insights it provides but also for the basic editorial information about how these stories were selected and edited. Jackson, Lawrence. Ralph Ellison: Emergence of Genius. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 2001. The first book-length study of Ellison’s life. A good background source for the novelist’s early life and career. Jackson, however, ends his study in 1953, shortly after the publication of Invisible Man.
Ellison, Ralph
373
May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Ellison: “Battle Royal” (vol. 1), “Flying Home” (vol. 3), and “King of the Bingo Game” (vol. 4). Schor, Edith. Visible Ellison: A Study of Ralph Ellison’s Fiction. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1993. Published a year before Ellison’s death, this is an excellent fulllength study of the fiction that was generally available at the time, including his short fiction, which had not yet been collected in book form. This is probably the best place for the serious scholar of Ralph Ellison to begin. Skerret, Joseph. “Ralph Ellison and the Example of Richard Wright.” Studies in Short Fiction 15 (Spring, 1978): 145-153. An examination of the influence of Richard Wright on Ralph Ellison’s short fiction. Watts, Jerry Gafio. Heroism and the Black Intellectual: Ralph Ellison, Politics, and AfroAmerican Intellectual Life. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1994. Chapters explore critic Harold Cruse’s influential interpretation of black intellectuals, the biographical background to Invisible Man, the relationship between the novel and black music, and the responsibilities of the black writer. Includes notes and a bibliography.
374
Louise Erdrich Born: Little Falls, Minnesota; June 7, 1954 Principal short fiction • “The Red Convertible,” 1981; “Scales,” 1982; “The World’s Greatest Fisherman,” 1982; “American Horse,” 1983; “Destiny,” 1985; “Saint Marie,” 1985; “Fleur,” 1987; “Snares,” 1987; “Matchimanito,” 1988; The Best American Short Stories 1993, 1993. Other literary forms • Louise Erdrich is probably best known for her novels, which include Love Medicine (1984), The Beet Queen (1986), The Antelope Wife (1998), The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse (2001), The Master Butchers Singing Club (2003), Four Souls (2004), and The Painted Drum (2005). She is also the author of several collections of poetry, including Original Fire: Selected and New Poems (2003), and a number of children’s books, including The Range Eternal (2002) and The Game of Silence (2004). In 1995, she published her first nonfiction book, a personal memoir of her daughter’s birth, The Blue Jay’s Dance: A Birth Year (1995). Books and Islands in Ojibwe Country followed in 2003. Achievements • Several of Louise Erdrich’s stories have appeared in the annual The Best American Short Stories and Prize Stories: The O. Henry Awards series. She received a Nelson Algren Fiction Award as well as a National Endowment for the Arts Fellowship in 1982, the Pushcart Prize and the National Magazine Award for Fiction in 1983, a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship in 1985, and a Western Literary Association Award in 1992. Her Love Medicine received the Virginia McCormack Scully Prize, the National Book Critics Circle Award, the Los Angeles Times award for best novel, the Sue Kaufman Prize, and the American Book Award and was named one of the best eleven books of 1985 by The New York Times Book Review. Biography • Karen Louise Erdrich was born in Little Falls, Minnesota, on June 7, 1954, the first of seven children of a German father and Chippewa mother. A member of the first coeducational class at Dartmouth College in 1972, she received her bachelor’s degree in 1976. While teaching expository and creative writing on a fellowship at Johns Hopkins University, she earned a master’s degree from The Johns Hopkins Writing Program in 1979. In 1980 she was a textbook writer for the Charles Merrill Company, and a year later, she became a visiting fellow at Dartmouth. On October 10, 1981, she married the writer Michael Dorris. In 1981, Erdrich published her first short story, “The Red Convertible,” in Mississippi Valley Review. Over the next two years, she published such award-winning stories as “The World’s Greatest Fisherman” and “Scales.” In 1984, she published her first collection of poetry, Jacklight, as well as her first novel, Love Medicine. In 1991, she coauthored The Crown of Columbus with her husband. In 1981, Erdrich became writer-in-residence at Dartmouth’s Native American Studies Program. She and Dorris later moved to Minneapolis and separated after fifteen years of marriage. During the divorce proceedings, Dorris committed suicide, on April 11, 1997. Although Erdrich has said that the success of her work was due in
Erdrich, Louise
375
great part to the collaboration of her husband, she continued to be productive as a writer, especially in the long-fiction form. Between 1998 and 2005, she published five novels. Analysis • Just as fiction in general has opened up to a diverse ethnic spectrum of writers, so too has short fiction, and Louise Erdrich’s stories stand as excellent examples of contemporary Native American literature. Like Leslie Marmon Silko, Linda Hogan, and Paula Gunn Allen, Erdrich has taken a place as one of the prominent female Native American authors of short fiction. Even among American Indian stories, Erdrich’s stand out for their multiethnic nature. Erdrich’s stories include not only Native American characters but also characters of German, Swedish, and other European descent. Likewise, many of the stories’ themes are not specifically Native American themes. Indeed, the themes of Erdrich’s stories range from the effects of war on families and personal identity to loss of heritage and family and personal relationships. Stylistically, Erdrich’s stories reveal many similarities to the stories of writers she has said had significant influence on her. The distinct sense of place, of character, and of history that colors the works of Toni Morrison, William Faulkner, and Italo Calvino is similarly prominent in Erdrich’s stories. She has said of Calvino that “the magic in his work is something that has been an influence,” which is clear especially in stories like “Fleur” and “Snares.” As Faulkner does with Yoknapatawpha County, Erdrich creates a world of the Chippewa reservation and the town of Argus, in which and around which nearly all of her stories occur. Many of her characters are employed repeatedly in her stories. Minor characters in one story may be the central characters in another or relatives of characters in one story are featured in later stories. Thus, most of Erdrich’s stories connect to create a fictional world, which appears as true as the real world. Erdrich has said that “the story starts to take over if it is good.” Her stories fulfill this criterion, capturing readers’ imagination and carrying them along on an intense mental ride. Her stories truly “touch some universals” that embrace readers of all ages, cultures, and beliefs. “The Red Convertible” • “The Red Convertible” is Erdrich’s first published story. Like many of her stories, this tale of two brothers later became a chapter in the novel Love Medicine. On the surface, the story appears to be merely a simple tale of two brothers and the car they share. Lyman Lamartine, a young Indian man with a “touch” for money, and his brother Henry save enough money to buy a used, red Oldsmobile convertible. Lyman tells the story, describing the early adventures he and his brother shared in the car. However, as the story progresses, it becomes clear that much more than the car is important in this story. Lyman describes how Henry changed when he returned home from the Vietnam War. While the family tries to help the deeply depressed Henry, Lyman tricks his brother into fixing up the car that he damaged. Although Henry does improve, even the car cannot save him, as he commits suicide in the end. In this story, the red convertible represents the freedom and innocence of youth, yet once those things are lost due to war in Henry’s case and due to the altered Henry in Lyman’s case, they cannot be regained; they must be let go. Although the story unfolds mainly on the reservation, part of its success is that the topic itself (the loss of innocence, the effects of war) is universal, which allows any reader to understand and be intrigued by the tale.
376
Short Story Writers
“Saint Marie” • Like many of Erdrich’s stories, “Saint Marie” also became a chapter in Love Medicine. “Saint Marie” is the story of a young Indian girl, who goes to the Roman Catholic convent near the reservation so she might prove she is better than the other heathen Indians. MaTO VIEW IMAGE, rie tries very hard to keep Satan out PLEASE SEE of her life, yet one of the nuns, Sister Leopolda, believes Marie to be comPRINT EDITION pletely under the devil’s control. LeoOF THIS BOOK. polda proceeds to torture Marie to the point of stabbing her with a fork in order to expunge the evil. Yet to cover her madness, Leopolda lies to the other nuns, telling them that Marie must be touched by God as she has the signs of the stigmata on her hand; Marie must be a saint. However, Marie uses her knowledge of the truth of what happened to intimidate and humble Leopolda. Once Michael Dorris again, this is a story about loss of innocence, about the psychological effects of a traumatic event in a young person’s life. Similarly, Marie’s struggle with her beliefs and Leopolda’s madness are not necessarily specific to Native Americans, so many readers can access the story and enjoy it. “Destiny” • A story which later became part of The Beet Queen, “Destiny” describes Celestine Duval’s visit to see her granddaughter’s Christmas play. Wallacette, Celestine’s granddaughter, is a large, strong, impulsive girl, who intimidates the other children in her school and town. The destiny of the title is Wallacette’s destiny to be strong and independent, just like her grandmother. Celestine adores Wallacette, though she does not get along with Wallacette’s parents very well. In particular, there is bad blood between Celestine and her daughter-in-law, whose gelatin molds with vegetables in them are a source of great disgust for Celestine. The story turns comic when Wallacette hits a little boy she likes when he does not cooperate in the play, and it ends on a humorous note as Celestine reveals that the secret dish she had taken to the play with her daughter-in-law’s name on it was a gelatin mold with nuts and bolts in it. This story is very entertaining and universal in its depictions of family struggles and the pains of growing up. The psychological element still exists in this story, but some of the intense emotional pains are absent, which allows a humorous tone to come through. “Fleur” • “Fleur” presents the story of one woman’s multiple drowning experiences and her influence on the people around her. Told from the point of view of Pauline Puyat, this story later became a chapter in Tracks (1988). Pauline describes how Fleur Pillager drowned several times, and every man who rescued her ended up either
Erdrich, Louise
377
crazy or dead. Pauline believes that Fleur has special magic powers, and she tells the story of the time Fleur left the reservation and went to the town of Argus. After beating a group of men at cards for a number of weeks, Fleur is attacked by the men in a smokehouse. Pauline stands by and watches the event, doing nothing to help Fleur. However, Fleur has her revenge when, in the midst of a storm that came from nowhere and touched nothing that Fleur valued, the men become locked in a meat freezer. Pauline believes that Fleur called up the storm. Although the story is about Fleur, it is also about Pauline. Pauline voices her own feelings and thoughts throughout the story, revealing the guilt she feels for not helping Fleur as well as the envy she feels toward this strong woman. Fleur is an enigma to Pauline, but she is also what Pauline seems to want to be in this story. “Matchimanito” • Though it was published after “Fleur,” “Matchimanito” is the story of how Fleur came to be the last living member of her family and what happened to her when she came back to the reservation from Argus. An old man, Nanapush, tells how he found Fleur amid her dead family and took her away to recover from the “spotted sickness.” This story reveals that Fleur is different from everyone else from the beginning. She is quiet yet powerful. Upon returning from Argus, she lives alone in a cabin next to Matchimanito, the lake, which fuels rumors about her relationship with the lake monster, Mishepeshu. However, Fleur soon attracts a young man, Eli Kashpaw, and they live as husband and wife by the lake. Fleur becomes pregnant, and her pregnancy sparks more rumors, as the child’s paternity is questioned. The birth of the child is difficult, and though many people believe that Fleur and her baby are dead, both live to prove them wrong. This is a powerful story because it demonstrates the strength of Fleur, the mixing of the old Indian ways with the new ones, the interaction of the community and individuals, and the history of both one person and a people. This story is particularly successful in its ability to show all of these things without force-feeding them to the reader. Keri L. Overall With updates by the Editors Other major works children’s literature: Grandmother’s Pigeon, 1996 (illustrated by Jim LaMarche); The Birchbark House, 1999; The Range Eternal, 2002; The Game of Silence, 2004. novels: Love Medicine, 1984 (revised and expanded, 1993); The Beet Queen, 1986; Tracks, 1988; The Crown of Columbus, 1991 (with Michael Dorris); The Bingo Palace, 1994; Tales of Burning Love, 1996; The Antelope Wife, 1998; The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse, 2001; The Master Butchers Singing Club, 2003; Four Souls, 2004; The Painted Drum, 2005. nonfiction: The Blue Jay’s Dance: A Birth Year, 1995; Books and Islands in Ojibwe Country, 2003. poetry: Jacklight, 1984; Baptism of Desire, 1989; Original Fire: Selected and New Poems, 2003. Bibliography Chavkin, Allan, ed. The Chippewa Landscape of Louise Erdrich. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 1998. Collects original essays focusing on Erdrich’s writings that
378
Short Story Writers
are rooted in the Chippewa experience. Premier scholars of Native American literature investigate narrative structure, signs of ethnicity, the notions of luck and chance in Erdrich’s narrative cosmology, and her use of comedy in exploring American Indians’ tragic past. Davis, Rocío G. “Identity in Community in Ethnic Short Story Cycles: Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club, Louise Erdrich’s Love Medicine, Gloria Naylor’s The Women of Brewster Place.” In Ethnicity and the American Short Story, edited by Julia Brown. New York: Garland, 1997. Discusses how Erdrich’s Love Medicine is in fact a cycle of short stories. Suggests that each chapter is a story with a different narrator, but the narrators’ voices combine to present a communal protagonist. An interesting concept and a useful way of understanding the stories as they stand on their own. Erdrich, Louise. Conversations with Louise Erdrich and Michael Dorris. Edited by Allan Chavkin and Nancy Feyl Chavkin. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1994. This is a collection of twenty-five interviews with the couple and includes an interview with Joseph Bruchac. Ferguson, Suzanne. “The Short Stories of Louise Erdrich’s Novels.” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (1996): 541-555. An excellent discussion of four short stories—“Saint Marie,” “Scales,” “Fleur,” and “Snares”—and how they were modified when they became chapters in the novels. Ferguson also argues that alone the short stories should be read differently than when they are presented as chapters in a novel. This is a good article for clarifying the differences between the short stories and their counterpart chapters in the novels. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Erdrich: “The Beet Queen” (vol. 1), “Fleur” (vol. 3), “The Leap” (vol. 4), and “The Red Convertible” and “Saint Marie” (vol. 6). Rebein, Robert. Hicks, Tribes, and Dirty Realists: American Fiction After Postmodernism. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 2001. Study asserting that gritty realism has gained ascendancy over metafiction in American writing. Examines the works of Dorothy Allison, Annie Proux, Thomas McGuane, Cormac McCarthy, Larry McMurtry, and Louise Erdrich. Smith, Jeanne Rosier. Writing Tricksters: Mythic Gambols in American Ethnic Literature. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1997. Thorough examination of ethnic trickster figures as they appear in the work of Erdrich, Maxine Hong Kingston, and Toni Morrison. Chapter 3 explores the trickster characteristics of Old Nanapush, Gerry Nanapush, Lipsha Morrissey, Fleur Pillager, and others. Stookey, Lorena Laura. Louise Erdrich: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1999. Good study of Erdrich’s works. Includes bibliographical references and an index.
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
MAGILL’S C H O I C E
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
Volume 2 William Faulkner — R. K. Narayan 379 – 758
edited by
Charles E. May California State University, Long Beach
SALEM PRESS, INC. Pasadena, California
Hackensack, New Jersey
Cover photo: Shawn Gearhart/©iStockphoto.com
Copyright © 1993, 1997, 2008, by Salem Press, Inc. All rights in this book are reserved. No part of this work may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the copyright owner except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information address the publisher, Salem Press, Inc., P.O. Box 50062, Pasadena, California 91115. Some essays in these volumes originally appeared in Critical Survey of Short Fiction, Second Revised Edition, 2001. New material has been added. ∞ The paper used in these volumes conforms to the American National Standard for Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, Z39.48-1992 (R1997). Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Short story writers / edited by Charles E. May. — Rev. ed. v. cm. — (Magill’s choice) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-58765-389-6 (set : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-58765-390-2 (vol. 1 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-58765-391-9 (vol. 2 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-58765-392-6 (vol. 3 : alk. paper) 1. Short story. 2. Short stories—Bio-bibliography—Dictionaries. 3. Novelists—Biography—Dictionaries. I. May, Charles E. (Charles Edward), 1941PN3373.S398 2008 809.3’1—dc22 2007032789
First printing
printed in canada
Contents – Volume 2 Contents
Complete List of Contents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxv Faulkner, William . Fitzgerald, F. Scott Flaubert, Gustave . Forster, E. M. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
379 388 397 407
Gallant, Mavis . . . . . . . García Márquez, Gabriel . Garland, Hamlin . . . . . Gogol, Nikolai . . . . . . Gordimer, Nadine . . . . Greene, Graham . . . . . Grimm Brothers . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
413 420 428 435 444 453 461
Harte, Bret . . . . . . Hawthorne, Nathaniel Hemingway, Ernest . . Hempel, Amy . . . . . Henry, O. . . . . . . . Hughes, Langston . . Hurston, Zora Neale .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
469 475 486 495 499 505 512
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
Irving, Washington . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 519 Jackson, Shirley . . . . James, Henry . . . . . Jewett, Sarah Orne . . Jhabvala, Ruth Prawer Joyce, James . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
526 533 543 550 555
Kafka, Franz . . . . . Kincaid, Jamaica . . Kingsolver, Barbara . Kipling, Rudyard . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
565 576 583 588
Lardner, Ring . . . Lavin, Mary . . . . Lawrence, D. H.. . Le Guin, Ursula K. Lessing, Doris . . . London, Jack . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
598 603 611 621 628 636
. . . . . .
xxiii
Short Story Writers
McCullers, Carson . . . Malamud, Bernard . . . Mann, Thomas . . . . . Mansfield, Katherine . . Mason, Bobbie Ann . . Maugham, W. Somerset Maupassant, Guy de . . Melville, Herman . . . . Mérimée, Prosper. . . . Mishima, Yukio . . . . . Mukherjee, Bharati . . . Munro, Alice . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
641 649 659 670 680 687 695 704 712 717 723 734
Nabokov, Vladimir . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 743 Narayan, R. K.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 752
xxiv
Complete List of Contents Complete List of Contents
Volume 1 Achebe, Chinua, 1 Adams, Alice, 7 Aiken, Conrad, 13 Alexie, Sherman, 20 Allende, Isabel, 24 Andersen, Hans Christian, 28 Anderson, Sherwood, 35 Angelou, Maya, 43 Atwood, Margaret, 48 Babel, Isaac, 58 Baldwin, James, 66 Bambara, Toni Cade, 73 Banks, Russell, 79 Barthelme, Donald, 86 Beattie, Ann, 96 Bellow, Saul, 104 Bierce, Ambrose, 112 Boccaccio, Giovanni, 118 Borges, Jorge Luis, 125 Bowen, Elizabeth, 136 Boyle, Kay, 143 Boyle, T. Coraghessan, 152 Bradbury, Ray, 160 Callaghan, Morley, 173 Capote, Truman, 182
Carver, Raymond, 188 Cather, Willa, 198 Chaucer, Geoffrey, 205 Cheever, John, 220 Chekhov, Anton, 231 Chesnutt, Charles Waddell, 242 Chesterton, G. K., 250 Chopin, Kate, 258 Cisneros, Sandra, 264 Clark, Walter Van Tilburg, 271 Clarke, Arthur C., 277 Conrad, Joseph, 285 Coover, Robert, 295 Coppard, A. E., 303 Cortázar, Julio, 310 Crane, Stephen, 317 De la Mare, Walter, 327 Dinesen, Isak, 333 Dostoevski, Fyodor, 342 Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan, 348 Dubus, Andre, 358 Dybek, Stuart, 364 Ellison, Ralph, 368 Erdrich, Louise, 374
Volume 2 Faulkner, William, 379 Fitzgerald, F. Scott, 388 Flaubert, Gustave, 397 Forster, E. M., 407 Gallant, Mavis, 413 García Márquez, Gabriel, 420 Garland, Hamlin, 428 Gogol, Nikolai, 435 Gordimer, Nadine, 444 Greene, Graham, 453 Grimm Brothers, 461
Harte, Bret, 469 Hawthorne, Nathaniel, 475 Hemingway, Ernest, 486 Hempel, Amy, 495 Henry, O., 499 Hughes, Langston, 505 Hurston, Zora Neale, 512 Irving, Washington, 519 Jackson, Shirley, 526 James, Henry, 533 xxv
Short Story Writers Jewett, Sarah Orne, 543 Jhabvala, Ruth Prawer, 550 Joyce, James, 555 Kafka, Franz, 565 Kincaid, Jamaica, 576 Kingsolver, Barbara, 583 Kipling, Rudyard, 588 Lardner, Ring, 598 Lavin, Mary, 603 Lawrence, D. H., 611 Le Guin, Ursula K., 621 Lessing, Doris, 628 London, Jack, 636
McCullers, Carson, 641 Malamud, Bernard, 649 Mann, Thomas, 659 Mansfield, Katherine, 670 Mason, Bobbie Ann, 680 Maugham, W. Somerset, 687 Maupassant, Guy de, 695 Melville, Herman, 704 Mérimée, Prosper, 712 Mishima, Yukio, 717 Mukherjee, Bharati, 723 Munro, Alice, 734 Nabokov, Vladimir, 743 Narayan, R. K., 752
Volume 3 Oates, Joyce Carol, 759 O’Brien, Edna, 770 O’Connor, Flannery, 778 O’Connor, Frank, 788 O’Faoláin, Seán, 796 O’Flaherty, Liam, 803 Olsen, Tillie, 810 Ozick, Cynthia, 816 Paley, Grace, 823 Parker, Dorothy, 830 Perelman, S. J., 835 Petry, Ann, 841 Pirandello, Luigi, 850 Poe, Edgar Allan, 857 Porter, Katherine Anne, 867 Powers, J. F., 876 Pritchett, V. S., 881 Proulx, E. Annie, 891 Purdy, James, 896 Saki, 905 Salinger, J. D., 910 Saroyan, William, 919 Sillitoe, Alan, 925 Singer, Isaac Bashevis, 931 Spark, Muriel, 941 Steinbeck, John, 948 Stevenson, Robert Louis, 954
Tan, Amy, 961 Taylor, Peter, 966 Thomas, Dylan, 973 Thurber, James, 981 Tolstoy, Leo, 987 Trevor, William, 998 Turgenev, Ivan, 1006 Twain, Mark, 1015 Tyler, Anne, 1022 Updike, John, 1029 Viramontes, Helena María, 1042 Vonnegut, Kurt, 1047 Walker, Alice, 1056 Warren, Robert Penn, 1066 Welty, Eudora, 1073 Wharton, Edith, 1083 Williams, Joy, 1090 Williams, Tennessee, 1095 Williams, William Carlos, 1103 Wolff, Tobias, 1109 Woolf, Virginia, 1116 Wright, Richard, 1123 Terms and Techniques, 1129 Time Line, 1140 Index, 1147 xxvi
Short Story Writers Revised Edition
379
William Faulkner Born: New Albany, Mississippi; September 25, 1897 Died: Byhalia, Mississippi; July 6, 1962 Principal short fiction • These Thirteen, 1931; Doctor Martino, and Other Stories, 1934; The Portable Faulkner, 1946, 1967; Knight’s Gambit, 1949; Collected Short Stories of William Faulkner, 1950; Big Woods, 1955; Three Famous Short Novels, 1958; Uncollected Stories of William Faulkner, 1979. Other literary forms • William Faulkner published nearly twenty novels, two collections of poetry, and a novel-drama, as well as essays, newspaper articles, and illustrated stories. His early work has been collected and his University of Virginia lectures transcribed. As a screenwriter in Hollywood, he was listed in the credits of such films as The Big Sleep (1946), To Have and Have Not (1944), and Land of the Pharaohs (1955). Achievements • William Faulkner is best known for his novels, particularly The Sound and the Fury (1929), Absalom, Absalom! (1936), and As I Lay Dying (1930), all of which have been translated widely. A Fable (1954) and The Reivers (1962) won Pulitzer Prizes, and A Fable and the Collected Short Stories won National Book Awards. Faulkner received the Nobel Prize in Literature for 1949. Film versions have been made of several of his works: Sanctuary (1961), Intruder in the Dust (1949), The Sound and the Fury (1959), The Reivers (1969), and Pylon (1957; or Tarnished Angels). Others (Requiem for a Nun, 1951, and “Barn Burning”) have been filmed for television. Such attention attests to the fact that Faulkner has been one of the most influential writers in the twentieth century—both in the United States, where his work suggested to an enormous generation of southern writers the valuable literary materials that could be derived from their own region, and in Europe, particularly in France. He has had a later, but also profound, effect on Latin American fiction, most noticeably in the work of Colombian writer Gabriel García Márquez, who seeks, as Faulkner did, to create a fictive history of a region and a people. Faulkner’s work has also been well received in Japan, which he visited as a cultural ambassador in 1955. Biography • William Faulkner spent most of his life in Mississippi, although as a young man he went briefly to Paris and lived for a time in New Orleans, where he knew Sherwood Anderson. He trained for the Royal Air Force in Canada during World War I, but the war was over before he saw action. He attended the University of Mississippi in Oxford for a year, where he published poems and reviews in a campus periodical; and after dropping out, he worked for a time in the university post office. He married Estelle Oldham, and they had a daughter, Jill. Except for periodic and often unhappy stays in Hollywood to work on screenplays—in order to support a large number of dependents—Faulkner lived and wrote in Oxford, where he had available to him in the town and surrounding countryside the prototypes for the characters that inhabit his major works. During the late 1950’s, he accepted a position as a writer-inresidence at the University of Virginia and traveled to Japan on behalf of the U.S.
380
Short Story Writers
Department of State. Although his literary reputation waned in the 1940’s, when virtually all of his earlier works were out of print, Faulkner’s stature as a writer grew after 1946, when The Portable Faulkner was published by Malcom Cowley, and especially after 1950, when he accepted the Nobel Prize, when his collected stories were published, and when his novels began to be reprinted. Faulkner drove himself harder physically as he grew older, and he was troubled throughout his life with alcohol binges, into which he would often fall after completing a book. These factors contributed to his death in 1962. Analysis • William Faulkner has been credited with having the imagination to see, before other serious writers saw, the tremendous potential for drama, pathos, and sophisticated humor in the history and people of the South. In using this material and, in the process, suggesting to others how it might be used, he has also been credited with sparking the Southern Renaissance of literary achievement that produced much of the United States’ best literature in the twentieth century. In chronicling the tragedy of southern history, he delineated a vision tempered by his historical perspective that has freed the region from the popular conception of its character as possessing a universal gentility and a pervasive aristocracy, and he portrayed realistically a population often idealized and caricatured in songs, movies, and pulp fiction. In undercutting the false idealizations, Faulkner often distorted the stereotypes and rendered them somewhat grotesque in the interest of bringing them to three-dimensional life; and he attempted to show in the political and social presumptions of the South the portent of its almost inevitable destruction—first through war and then through an insidious new social order based on commercial pragmatism and shortsighted lust for progress. In this sense, the New South is shown to have much in common with mainstream America. Faulkner’s themes are often conveyed in an elaborate baroque style noted for its long, difficult sentences that challenge the reader to discern the speaker, the time, and even the subject of the narrative. Faulkner makes considerable use of stream-ofconsciousness interior monologues, and his frequent meshings of time reinforce his conviction that the past and present are intricately interwoven in the human psyche. “A Rose for Emily” • “A Rose for Emily,” frequently anthologized and analyzed, is probably Faulkner’s best-known story. Because of its elements of mystery, suspense, and the macabre, it has enjoyed a popular appeal. That Emily Grierson, an aging southern belle, murders the lover who spurned her and sleeps beside his decaying body for a number of years is only the most sensational aspect of the story. What is more interesting to the serious reader of Faulkner is the interplay between Emily Grierson and the two generations of townspeople who attempt to cope with her— one the old guard and the other a new generation with “modern ideas.” The opening paragraphs of the story inform the reader that when Miss Emily died, the whole town turned out for her funeral. She was a “fallen monument . . . a tradition, a duty and a care; a sort of hereditary obligation upon the town.” The townspeople, who are by the time of Emily’s death mostly of a generation younger than her own, have never been able to incorporate her into their community. For them, as well as for their fathers, she has stood as an embodiment of an older ideal of southern womanhood—even though in her later years she has grown obese, bloated, and pale as dough. The older generation, under the mayoralty of Colonel Sartoris (“who fathered the edict that no Negro woman should appear on the streets without
Faulkner, William
381
an apron”), has relieved Miss Emily of her taxes and has sent its children to take her china-painting classes “in the same spirit that they were sent to church on Sunday with a twenty-fivecent piece for the collection plate.” The new generation, however, is not pleased with the accommodations its fathers made with Miss Emily; it tries to impose taxes upon her and it no longer sends its children to take her lessons. Miss Emily has been encouraged in her ways by the old guard, however; she refuses to pay the town’s taxes, telling the representatives of the new generation to “see Colonel Sartoris,” who has been dead for ten years. The town is unable to handle Emily; it labels her “insane” and likewise comes to see her as the ghost of a feminine ideal out of the past. She becomes a recluse, living alone in her house with her black servant; and in her claim to privilege and impunity, she stands as a re© The Nobel Foundation minder to the town of the values— and sins—of its fathers, which are visited upon the third generation. It is tempting to think of Miss Emily as merely a decadent and perverse relic of the South’s antebellum past; indeed, this is how the story has often been read. Such a neat interpretation, however, would seem to be defeated by the time element in the story. Emily lives in a house spiraled and cupolaed in the architectural style of the 1870’s, on a once-elegant street that has been altered by industry and commercial development. Although the rickety town fathers of the Civil War era (1861-1865) come to her funeral dressed in their dusty uniforms and even believe that she was of their own generation and that they had danced with her when she was a young woman, clearly Emily is not of that generation; she is of the postwar South. She has not lingered as a relic from a warped racist culture; she has instead been created by defeated members of that culture who have continued to yearn after a world they have lost, a world that might well have existed largely in their imaginations, but a concept so persistent that the newer generation, for all its modern ideas, is powerless to control it. The reader is told that the town had long thought of Emily and her dead father “as a tableau, Miss Emily a slender figure in white in the background, her father a spraddled silhouette in the foreground, his back to her and clutching a horsewhip, the two of them framed by the backflung front door.” It is clear that the newer generation of the twentieth century has adopted certain popular ideas about the Old South. This “tableau” could serve as the dust jacket for any number of romantic novels set in the plantation days. Thus, the two generations are complicit in ignoring the real Emily and creating
382
Short Story Writers
and maintaining the myth of Emily as an exemplum of southern womanhood from a lost age, just as the town aldermen—“three graybeards and one younger man, a member of the rising generation“—have conspired to cover up Emily’s horrible crime. When the smell of the corpse of Emily’s decaying lover, Homer Barron, had become so strong that it could no longer be ignored by the town, the aldermen had scattered lime around Emily’s house secretly at night, although they knew she had recently purchased arsenic from the druggist and that Barron had disappeared; and when the smell went away, so did the town’s concern about the matter. The old guard cannot bear, and does not wish, to accept the grim essence of the dream it has spun; the new generation, under the influence of the old, grudgingly accepts its burden of the past, but then wrenches it into a romantic shape that obscures the “fat woman in black” (overindulgent, moribund) that is Emily Grierson. The story, then, is a comment on the postbellum South, which inherited the monstrous code of values, glossed over by fine words about honor and glory, that characterized the slave era; that postbellum South learns to ignore the unsavory elements of its past by ignoring Emily the recluse and murderess and by valorizing the romantic “tableau.” This is, however, a complex matter. The new generation—a generation excluded from the nominal code of honor, valor, and decorum that the old Confederates believed to have sustained them and excluded from the benefits that were to be gained from the slave system of the “glorious” Old South—sees the Griersons as “high and mighty,” as holding themselves “a little too high for what they really were.” The new generation, pragmatic and small-minded, for the most part, has inherited a landscape sullied by cotton gins and garages. Miss Emily Grierson, as a privileged person and as a reminder of what the older generation forfeited in its defeat, is a goad in the minds of the uncharitable newer generation, which, when she does not marry, is “vindicated.” When it hears the rumor that she has inherited nothing but the decaying house from her father, it is glad: “At last they could pity Miss Emily.” Miss Emily out of sight, destitute, “insane,” and deprived too of the lost legacy of the Old South can be re-created as a fictional heroine in white, part of the backdrop against which the popularized hero, her father, stands with his horsewhip—a faceless silhouette, cruel and powerful, an “ancestor” who can be claimed by the dispossessed generation as its own. The incestuous image of the father and daughter suggests the corrupt nature of the New South, which, along with the corrupt nature of the Old South, is a favorite Faulknerian concern. Granted, the “tableau” on the face of it appears to be the cover of a romantic novel, and in that sense it seems to be merely a popular rendering of history; but it is the townspeople who arrange father and daughter in the lurid scene. It is the men of the new generation who black out the distinguishing features of Emily’s dead father in their creation of the tableau, leaving a dark masculine space (more, one would guess, in the shape of foreman Homer Barron than of Mr. Grierson) into which they can dream themselves, as masters of a glorious age, as potent heroes for whom the wispy heroine wanes in the background. The newer generation has the “modern ideas” bred of the necessity of surviving in the defeated, industrialized South; but in its attitudes toward Emily Grierson, it reveals the extent to which the old decadent values of the fathers have been passed along. The narrator of the story, one of the townspeople himself, has proved unreliable. Although it is true that Emily seems to be “a tradition, a duty, a care, . . . an hereditary obligation,” a relic of the past miraculously sprung into being in spite of the disparity between her time and the historical time with which she is associated, the narrator only
Faulkner, William
383
inadvertently reveals the truth of the matter: that both generations of the town are guilty of the desires and misplaced values that not only allow Miss Emily the murderess to come into being but also lead them to cover her crime and enshrine her in a tableau into which they, in their basest longings, can insert themselves. There is an incestuousness to all of this, an unhealthy interbreeding of values that allows each generation to perform despicable acts in the process of maintaining its ideas of what it would like to be. It is true that Emily is a “fallen monument”; but what the narrator fails to spell out explicitly is that the monument has been erected not only by the historical grandeur of her family, but also by the dispossessed generations that interpret her to their own ends. The monument is toppled by death, not by an ethical evolution in the town. The narrator is redeemed to some extent by “his” pity for Emily and by the recognition that the town, by driving her into mad isolation, has treated her badly. As for Emily herself, she would seem to represent the worst elements of her neighbors, carried to their extreme conclusions. As the antebellum masters of the slaves presumed an all-powerfulness that allowed them to believe that they could own people, so does Miss Emily presume. Alive, Homer Barron—the outsider, the Yankee, a curious vitality in the pallid town—is outside Miss Emily’s control. Dead, however, she can own him, can dress his corpse like a groom, can sleep beside him perhaps every night at least until her hair turns gray. As the new generation can blind itself to unpleasant truths about its history and itself, so can Emily become lost in delusion: Her father, dead for three days, is proclaimed not dead and she refuses to bury him; Homer’s corpse is a “groom” (and, perhaps in some further depraved vision, connected with the dead father). Emily represents not only the decadence of Colonel Sartoris’s racist era but also the decadence of the “modern” generation’s use of that era. Thus “A Rose for Emily,” often dismissed as Faulkner’s ghost story, proves to be a clear expression of a recurring motif in Faulkner’s works: the complexity of the connections between the present and the past. “The Bear” • These connections are explored in a less sensational manner in “The Bear.” This story, which Faulkner also made the centerpiece of his novel Go Down, Moses, is another of the most anthologized, most studied pieces of Faulkner’s short fiction. Composed of five sections (although often only four are printed in anthology versions, the long and complex fourth section being omitted), “The Bear” covers the history of Isaac (Ike) McCaslin, heir to the land and to the shame of his slave-owner grandfather, L. P. C. McCaslin, who committed incest with his illegitimate daughter, thereby driving her mother to suicide. After discovering this horrifying ghost in old plantation ledgers, Ike feels bound to repudiate the inheritance that has descended to him from his grandfather—even though the repudiation costs him his wife and any hope of progeny—in an attempt to expiate his inherited guilt and to gain a measure of freedom from the vicious materialism that brought the slavery system into being. Thus he allows his patrimony to pass to his cousin McCaslin Edmonds, who plays devil’s advocate in Ike’s attempt to understand the South and his own place in it, the tragedy of the blacks and of his own class, and the significance of what he possesses without inheriting: an instinctual knowledge of nature and an infallible sense of what is just. “The Bear” may be seen as a hunting story, part of the Big Woods collection that includes “The Bear Hunt” and “Race at Morning.” As a hunting story it is concerned with Ike’s maturing, with his pilgrimage year after year to the hunting grounds where he and a group of adult hunters stalk the ancient bear, Old Ben, an enduring symbol
384
Short Story Writers
of nature. Ike’s guide and teacher is Sam Fathers, an aging Native American who still holds a sure instinct for the truths to be found in nature, and under whose tutelage Ike comes to form a system of values that later will lead him to renounce his inheritance. From Sam, Ike acquires a sense of nature’s terms and of humanity’s need to meet her on her own terms—of the necessity of according dignity to the force of nature and to all creatures through whom it courses. To meet the embodiment of that force in Old Ben, Ike must leave behind the instruments of civilization: the gun, the compass, the watch. Eventually Ike is able to track down Old Ben with regularity, but even when he encounters the bear and is armed, he refuses to shoot it. It would seem that the proof of nature’s endurance, represented in the bear, is of paramount concern to Ike. When Old Ben is finally killed and Sam Fathers dies, the ritual of the hunt is over for Ike. Yet two years later, he returns to the woods and sees in its organic and deathless elements, which have incorporated the remains of Old Ben and Sam Fathers, a proof of nature’s dualistic power to absorb death and bring forth new life from it. This force is at the same time awesome and terrifying, and it must be revered and confronted if humanity is to live meaningfully. Even as Ike makes this last pilgrimage, however, a lumber company hacks away at the forest and a train cuts through the wilderness, underscoring the idea of the damage a materialistic civilization can do to even the most powerful aspects of nature. Faulkner shows an era of United States history passing—an era of abundance and of human appreciation of what nature requires from humanity in their mutual interest. When “The Bear” is examined from the point of view of the intricate fourth section, it goes beyond being merely a hunting story to comment profoundly on the passing age and that which is replacing it. The scene shifts from the vast wilderness of nature to the intense confines of Ike McCaslin’s consciousness, which struggles to find a way to atone for the sins of his ancestors and of his class. The entanglement of past and present here is more complex than it is in “A Rose for Emily,” for Ike must face the knowledge that bloods mingled in the past—black and white, slave and owner—have flowed in grossly inequitable courses to the present, as reflected in the sufferings of his mixed-blood relatives. Therefore, he renounces his patrimony, he sets out to redress old wrongs with his black relatives, and he seeks to give full recognition to the brotherhood he shares with these relatives by recognizing the strengths they contribute to his family and to southern society—the virtues of “pity and tolerance and forbearance and fidelity and love of children.” In contrast to the self-serving generation of postbellum townspeople in “A Rose for Emily,” Ike—also of that era—is a man of conscience. This is not to suggest, however, that Ike is particularly “modern” in his ideas; rather he has modeled himself on older examples of integrity, not only Sam Fathers but also his father and his uncle, who had turned over their own inherited house to their slaves and built a humbler cabin for themselves. In Ike’s own case, the personal sacrifices to integrity and conscience have been enormous—his wife’s love; his hope of a son to carry on his mission; living alone and ultimately uncertain that his sacrifice will bear fruit beyond his limited scope to influence events. Nevertheless, Faulkner illustrates through his invention of Ike McCaslin the extent to which idealism can flourish, even when constantly challenged by the grimmest vestiges of past evils. “Barn Burning” • “Barn Burning” is an inversion of “The Bear” in that its protagonist, ten-year-old Sarty Snopes, is seeking the world that Ike McCaslin wishes to repudiate. Not of the landed class, but the son of a tenant farmer who is always on the
Faulkner, William
385
move because arson is his means of creating justice, Sarty associates the landed gentry with a “peace and dignity” and a civilized justice that is the direct opposite of the “fear and terror, grief and despair” that characterizes his life with his father, Ab Snopes. Ab uses fire as a weapon against the ruling class that he sees as the shaper of his economic fate, and he exhorts Sarty to be true to the blood ties which Ab sees as the only protection for his kind against the forces of an exploitative aristocracy. Sarty, however, rejects the “old blood” that he has not chosen for what seems to him a higher concept of fairness, and he longs to be free of his family and the turmoil it generates in his life. For Sarty, Major DeSpain is the antithesis of Ab. DeSpain owns the farm on which Ab has most recently contracted to work. To Sarty, DeSpain and his columned house, as big as a courthouse, represent not what Ab sees, the sweat of black and white people to produce someone else’s wealth, but the peace and dignity for which Sarty yearns and a system of justice that operates on principles of law rather than on personal revenge. Sarty’s view is based on a naïve trust in civilization that blinds his inexperienced eyes to the inescapable connections between wealth and the mechanism of civilization. Ab provokes a confrontation with DeSpain by deliberately tracking horse manure on an expensive rug. A series of moves and countermoves by Ab and DeSpain brings the pair to the point where, although DeSpain cannot begin to recover his loss from Ab, the local court nevertheless rules that Ab must take responsibility, within his means, for his act. This is enough to satisfy Ab yet again that the social system only works in behalf of the rich, and he sets out that night to redress this wrong by burning DeSpain’s barn. Sarty cannot bear to allow this injustice, and so he is torn between real loyalty to his family and commitment to an ideal of justice. Specifically, he must decide whether to support his father’s crime through silence or to betray the familial bond and warn DeSpain. Sarty chooses the ideal, warns DeSpain even as the barn begins to burn, and then flees the scene, unsure whether the shots he hears wound any of his family. Having made his choice, Sarty must set out alone to forge his own life. “Barn Burning” offers a helpful picture of how Faulkner sees the economics of the postbellum South, where the poor whites remain the underclass rivals of black sharecroppers. Faulkner shows in other works how a new social order eventually evolved in which the descendants of Ab Snopes slip into the defeated, genteel society like silent bacteria and take over its commerce, coming finally to own the mansions that had previously belonged to the DeSpains and Compsons and Sartorises. Again and again Faulkner reiterates that it was the corrupt systems of slavery and of the plantation that ultimately ensured the fall of the Old South. Yet his view of Snopeses—violent, relentless, insidious men and inert, cowlike women, who by their numbers and crafty pragmatism will wrench the land and the wealth from the depleted gentility—is hardly positive. In fact, “Barn Burning” is singular in that it is perhaps the only example of Faulkner’s fiction in which the Snopeses are depicted sympathetically without first being made to appear ridiculous. As is often the case, Faulkner is extremely sensitive to the young boy caught in a painful rite of passage—as true for Sarty Snopes as it is for Ike McCaslin, Lucius Priest, Chick Mallison, and others not of the threatening Snopes clan. Moreover, “Barn Burning” makes an interesting case for Ab Snopes as the pitiable creation of the landed aristocracy, who seeks dignity and integrity for himself, although his only chance of achieving either would seem to lie in the democratic element of fire as the one defense available to all, regardless of social class. In this story,
386
Short Story Writers
Ab is placed in the company of Wash Jones, Joe Christmas, and other members of the underclass that Faulkner views with sympathy and whose portrayals are in themselves indictments of the civilization that has forced them to desperate means. Although none of these examples quite suggests the very humorous ends to which Faulkner often turns his southern materials, it should be remembered that he was highly aware of the potential for comedy in all the situations described here and that even such delicate matters as the tensions between the races and the revolution in the social order are, in Faulkner’s hands, as frequently the catalysts of tall tales and satire as they are of his most somber and lyrical prose. It is true that “A Rose for Emily” hints at a typically Faulknerian humor in that a whole town is turned on its end by the bizarre behavior of one of its citizens; but the grotesque nature of Miss Emily’s secret smothers the promise of comedy in the story. Those seeking to experience Faulkner’s comic voice are better served by reading such stories as “Shingles for the Lord,” “Mule in the Yard,” and “Spotted Horses.” In any case, whatever the mode Faulkner adopted in creating his Yoknapatawpha County and thereby re-creating the South, he produced a stunning body of work, and in both matter and style, his works have had an equally stunning impact on modern letters. Constance Pierce With updates by Terry Heller Other major works novels: Soldiers’ Pay, 1926; Mosquitoes, 1927; Sartoris, 1929; The Sound and the Fury, 1929; As I Lay Dying, 1930; Sanctuary, 1931; Light in August, 1932; Pylon, 1935; Absalom, Absalom!, 1936; The Unvanquished, 1938; The Wild Palms, 1939; The Hamlet, 1940; Go Down, Moses, 1942; The Bear, 1942 (novella); Intruder in the Dust, 1948; Requiem for a Nun, 1951; A Fable, 1954; The Town, 1957; The Mansion, 1959; The Reivers, 1962; The Wishing Tree, 1964 (fairy tale); Flags in the Dust, 1973 (original version of Sartoris); Mayday, 1976 (fable). miscellaneous: The Faulkner Reader, 1954; William Faulkner: Early Prose and Poetry, 1962. nonfiction: New Orleans Sketches, 1958; Faulkner in the University, 1959; Faulkner at West Point, 1964; Essays, Speeches and Public Letters, 1965; The Faulkner-Cowley File: Letters and Memories, 1944-1962, 1966 (Malcolm Cowley, editor); Lion in the Garden, 1968; Selected Letters, 1977. poetry: The Marble Faun, 1924; A Green Bough, 1933. screenplays: Today We Live, 1933; To Have and Have Not, 1945; The Big Sleep, 1946; Faulkner’s MGM Screenplays, 1982. Bibliography Fargnoli, A. Nicholas, and Michael Golay. William Faulkner A to Z: The Essential Reference to His Life and Work. New York: Facts on File, 2001. Encyclopedic reference work covering Faulkner’s life and writings, with entries on individual short stories, characters, and much more. Ferguson, James. Faulkner’s Short Fiction. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1991. Attempt to redress the critical neglect of Faulkner’s short fiction. Discusses Faulkner’s poetic and narrative impulses, his themes of loss of innocence, failure to love, loneliness, and isolation; comments on his manipulation of time and
Faulkner, William
387
point of view and how his stories relate to his novels. Ford, Marilyn Claire. “Narrative Legerdemain: Evoking Sarty’s Future in ‘Barn Burning.’” The Mississippi Quarterly 51 (Summer, 1998): 527-540. In this special issue on Faulkner, Ford argues that Faulkner experiments with the doubling of perspective in “Barn Burning” in which the omniscient narrator fuses with the protagonist to create a story with multiple narrative layers. Gray, Richard. The Life of William Faulkner: A Critical Biography. Oxford, England: Blackwell, 1994. A noted Faulkner scholar, Gray closely integrates the life and work. Part 1 suggests a method of approaching Faulkner’s life, part 2 concentrates on his apprentice years, part 3 explains his discovery of Yoknapatawpha and the transformation of his region into his fiction, part 4 deals with his treatment of past and present, part 5 addresses his exploration of place, and part 6 analyzes his final novels, reflecting on his creation of Yoknapatawpha. Includes family trees, chronology, notes, and a bibliography. Inge, M. Thomas, ed. Conversations with William Faulkner. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1999. Part of the Literary Conversations series, this volume gives insight into Faulkner the person. Includes bibliographical references and index. Jones, Diane Brown. A Reader’s Guide to the Short Stories of William Faulkner. New York: G. K. Hall, 1994. Discusses more than thirty of Faulkner’s stories in terms of publishing history, circumstances of composition, sources/influence, and relationship to other Faulkner works; includes interpretations of the stories and summarizes and critiques previous criticism. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Faulkner: “Barn Burning” (vol. 1), “Delta Autumn” and “Dry September” (vol. 2), “Red Leaves” and “A Rose for Emily” (vol. 6), “Spotted Horses” and “That Evening Sun” (vol. 7), and “Wash” (vol. 8). Minter, David. William Faulkner: His Life and Work. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1980. Shorter and less detailed than Joseph Blotner’s biography, this volume gives more attention to exploring connections between Faulkner’s life and his works. The Mississippi Quarterly 50 (Summer, 1997). A special issue on Faulkner, including articles that discuss displaced meaning, dispossessed sons, the wilderness and consciousness, and subjectivity in Go Down, Moses. Singal, Daniel J. William Faulkner: The Making of a Modernist. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1997. Study of the thought and art of Faulkner, charting the development of his ideas from their source in his reading to their embodiment in his writing. Depicts two Faulkners: the country gentleman and the intellectual man of letters. Wagner-Martin, Linda. New Essays on “Go Down, Moses.” New York: Cambridge University Press, 1996. After an introduction that summarizes contemporary reception and critical analysis of Go Down, Moses, Wagner-Martin collects essays that approach the work from the perspective of race, environment, gender, and ideology.
388
F. Scott Fitzgerald Born: St. Paul, Minnesota; September 24, 1896 Died: Hollywood, California; December 21, 1940 Principal short fiction • Flappers and Philosophers, 1920; Tales of the Jazz Age, 1922; All the Sad Young Men, 1926; Taps at Reveille, 1935; The Stories of F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1951; Babylon Revisited, and Other Stories, 1960; The Pat Hobby Stories, 1962; The Apprentice Fiction of F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1907-1917, 1965; The Basil and Josephine Stories, 1973; Bits of Paradise, 1974; The Price Was High: The Last Uncollected Stories of F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1979; Before Gatsby: The First Twenty-Six Stories, 2001 (Matthew J. Bruccoli, editor). Other literary forms • Four novels, four short-story collections, and a play make up the nine F. Scott Fitzgerald books published in his lifetime. They were issued in uniform editions by Scribner’s with a British edition of each. His short stories were widely anthologized in the 1920’s and 1930’s in collections such as The Best Short Stories of 1922, Cream of the Jug, and The Best Short Stories of 1931. The Vegetable: Or, From President to Postman (1923) was produced at the Apollo Theatre in Atlantic City, and, while Fitzgerald was under contract to MGM, he collaborated on such screenplays as Three Comrades, Infidelity, Madame Curie, and Gone with the Wind. There have been numerous posthumous collections of his letters, essays, notebooks, stories, and novels; and since his death there have been various stage and screen adaptations of his work, including film versions of The Great Gatsby (1925) and Tender Is the Night (1934). Achievements • F. Scott Fitzgerald, considered “the poet laureate of the Jazz Age,” is best remembered for his portrayal of the “flapper” of the 1920’s, a young woman who demonstrated scorn for conventional dress and behavior. Fitzgerald’s fiction focuses on young, wealthy, dissolute men and women of the 1920’s. His stories written for popular magazines such as the Saturday Evening Post and, later, Esquire were very much in demand. Fitzgerald’s literary reputation, however, is chiefly based on the artistry of stories such as “Babylon Revisited” and “The Rich Boy,” as well as the novel The Great Gatsby. In this important novel, Fitzgerald uses rich imagery and symbolism to portray lives of the careless, restless rich during the 1920’s and to depict Jay Gatsby as the personification of the American Dream, the self-made man whose quest for riches is also a futile quest for the love of the shallow, spoiled Daisy. Biography • F. Scott Fitzgerald was educated at St. Paul Academy and at the Newman School in Hackensack, New Jersey. While attending Princeton University he wrote for the Princeton Tiger and Nassau Literary Magazine. He left Princeton without a degree, joined the Army, and was stationed near Montgomery, Alabama, where he met Zelda Sayre. In 1920, they were married in New York City before moving to Westport, Connecticut. Their only child, Frances Scott Fitzgerald, was born in 1921. During the mid1920’s the Fitzgeralds traveled extensively between the United States and Europe, meeting Ernest Hemingway in Paris in 1925. The decade of the 1930’s was a bleak one for the Fitzgeralds; Zelda had several emotional breakdowns and Scott sank into alcoholism. They lived variously in Montgomery and on the Turnbull estate outside
Fitzgerald, F. Scott
389
Baltimore. Fitzgerald went to Hollywood for the second time in 1931. After that they lived for a time in Asheville, North Carolina, where Zelda was hospitalized and where Fitzgerald wrote the Crackup essays for Esquire. In 1937, Fitzgerald met Hollywood columnist Sheila Graham while he was living in Hollywood and writing under contract to MGM. Although he remained married to Zelda, he fell in love with Graham and lived with her through his remaining years. He began writing The Last Tycoon in 1939 and died, before it was completed, on December 21, 1940, at the age of forty-four. Analysis • F. Scott Fitzgerald was a professional writer who was also a literary artist. In practical terms this meant that he had to support himself by writing short stories for popular magazines in order to get sufficient income, according to him, to write decent books. Indeed, most of the money that FitzLibrary of Congress gerald earned by writing before he went to Hollywood in 1937 was earned by selling stories to magazines. In his twenty-year career as a writer, he published 164 magazine stories; other stories were never published. All but eight of the stories that originally appeared in magazines became available in hardcover editions. As one would expect of a body of 164 stories written in a twenty-year period mainly for popular consumption, the quality of the stories is uneven. At the bottom of this collection are at least a dozen stories, most of them written for Esquire during the last years of his life, which have few redeeming qualities; at the top of the list are at least a dozen stories which rank among the best of American short stories. One should not, however, be led to believe that these, as well as the hundred or more “potboilers” in the middle, do not serve a useful role in his development as an artist. Fitzgerald in the 1920’s was considered the best writer of quality magazine fiction in America, and his stories brought the highest prices paid by slick magazines; the Saturday Evening Post, for example, paid him four thousand dollars per story even during the Depression. The noted wit Dorothy Parker commented that Fitzgerald could write a bad story, but that he could not write badly. Thus each story, no matter how weak, has the recognizable Fitzgerald touch—that sparkling prose which Fitzgerald called “the something extra” that most popular short stories lacked. Fitzgerald also learned at the beginning of his career that he could use the popular magazines as a workshop for his novels, experimenting in them with themes and techniques which he would
390
Short Story Writers
later incorporate into his novels. An understanding of a Fitzgerald story should take into account this workshop function of the story as well as its artistic merits. Fitzgerald’s career as a writer of magazine fiction breaks logically into three periods: 1919-1924, years during which he shopped around for markets and published stories in most of the important periodicals of the times; 1925-1933, the central period characterized by a close association with the Saturday Evening Post—a relationship which almost precluded his publication of stories in other magazines; and 19341940, a period beginning with the publication of his first Esquire story and continuing through a subsequent relationship with that magazine which lasted until his death. During the first of these periods, Fitzgerald published thirty-two stories in ten different commercial magazines, two novels (This Side of Paradise, 1920, and The Beautiful and Damned, 1922), two short-story collections (Flappers and Philosophers and Tales of the Jazz Age), and one book-length play (The Vegetable). In the second period, during which The Great Gatsby and a third short-story collection (All the Sad Young Men) appeared, he enjoyed the popular reputation he had built with readers of the Saturday Evening Post and published forty-seven of the fifty-eight stories which appeared during this nine-year period in that magazine; the remaining eleven stories were scattered throughout five different magazines. In the final period, Fitzgerald lost the large Saturday Evening Post audience and gained the Esquire audience, which was smaller and quite different. Of the forty-four Fitzgerald stories to appear between 1934 and his death, twenty-eight appeared in Esquire. In addition to Tender Is the Night, which was completed and delivered before Fitzgerald’s relationship with Esquire began, Fitzgerald published his final short-story collection (Taps at Reveille); he also drafted The Last Tycoon (1941) during the Esquire years. Twelve stories, nine of which have appeared in Esquire, have been published since his death. An obvious conclusion may be drawn about Fitzgerald’s professional career: He was at his best artistically in the years of his greatest popularity. During the composition of The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald’s commercial fiction was in such demand that large magazines such as the Saturday Evening Post, Hearst’s, and Metropolitan competed for it. Tender Is the Night was written during the time when Fitzgerald’s popularity with slick magazine readers was at its all-time high point; for example, in 1929 and 1930, important years in the composition of Tender Is the Night, he published fifteen stories in the Saturday Evening Post. In sharp contrast to the 1925-1933 stories, which are characteristically of an even, high quality, and many of which are closely related to two novels of this period, the stories of the Esquire years are, in general, undistinguished. In addition, with minor exceptions, the stories written in this final period have little relation to Fitzgerald’s last “serious” work, The Last Tycoon. The Esquire years thus constitute a low point from both a popular and an artistic standpoint. They are years during which he lost the knack of pleasing the large American reading public and at the same time produced a comparatively small amount of good artwork. In the first two years of Fitzgerald’s storywriting, his sensitivity to audience tastes was naïve. “May Day” and “The Diamond as Big as the Ritz,” not only the two best stories from these years but also two of the best stories in the Fitzgerald canon, were written for sale to mass-circulation magazines. Both, however, were too cynical about American values to be acceptable to a large, middle-American audience. By 1922 and the publication of “Winter Dreams” in Metropolitan, Fitzgerald had learned how to tailor his stories for slick magazine readers while at the same time using them to experiment with serious subjects and themes that he would later use in longer works.
Fitzgerald, F. Scott
391
“Winter Dreams” • Viewed in association with The Great Gatsby, “Winter Dreams” provides an excellent illustration of Fitzgerald’s method of using his stories as a proving ground for his novels. In a letter to Maxwell Perkins, Fitzgerald describes “Winter Dreams” as a “sort of 1st draft of the Gatsby idea,” and indeed, it contains sufficient similarities of theme and character to be called a miniature of The Great Gatsby. Parallels between Dexter Green and Jay Gatsby are striking: Both men have made a total commitment to a dream, and both of their dreams are hollow. Dexter falls in love with wealthy Judy Jones and devotes his life to making the money that will allow him to enter her social circle; his idealization of her is closely akin to Gatsby’s feelings for Daisy Buchanan. Gatsby’s idealized conception of Daisy is the motivating force that underlies his compulsion to become successful, just as Dexter’s conception of Judy Jones drives him to amass a fortune by the time he is twenty-five. The theme of commitment to an idealized dream that is the core of “Winter Dreams” and The Great Gatsby, and the similarities between the two men point up the close relationship between the story and the novel. Because “Winter Dreams” appeared three years before The Great Gatsby, its importance in the gestation of the novel cannot be overemphasized. Important differences in Fitzgerald’s methods of constructing short stories and novels emerge from these closely related works. Much of the effectiveness of The Great Gatsby lies in the mystery of Gatsby’s background, while no such mystery surrounds the early life of Dexter Green. In “Winter Dreams,” Dexter’s disillusionment with Judy occurs suddenly; when he learns that she is no longer pretty, the “dream was gone. Something had taken it from him . . . the moonlit veranda, and gingham on the golf links and the dry sun and the gold color of her neck’s soft down. . . . Why these things were no longer in the world!” Because his enchantment could be shattered so quickly, Dexter’s commitment to Judy is not of the magnitude of Gatsby’s commitment to Daisy. Gatsby’s disenchantment could only occur gradually. When he is finally able to see Daisy, “the colossal significance of the green light . . . vanished forever,” but his “count of enchanted objects” had only diminished by one. Even toward the end of the novel, there is no way of knowing that Gatsby is completely disenchanted with Daisy. Nick says that “perhaps he no longer cared.” The “perhaps” leaves open possibilities of interpretation that are closed at the end of “Winter Dreams.” Although Dexter can cry at the loss of a dream, Gatsby dies, leaving the reader to guess whether or not he still held on to any fragment of his dreams about Daisy. The expansiveness of the novel obviously allowed Fitzgerald to make Gatsby and his dream believable while he could maintain the mystery of Gatsby’s past and the origins of his dream. Fitzgerald could not do this as well with Dexter in “Winter Dreams.” The point is that in writing “Winter Dreams” Fitzgerald was giving shape to his ideas about Jay Gatsby, and, after creating the story, he could better see the advantages of maintaining the sense of mystery that made Gatsby a more memorable character than his counterpart in “Winter Dreams.” “The Rich Boy” • Like “Winter Dreams,” “The Rich Boy,” published a year after The Great Gatsby, clearly illustrates the workshop function that the stories served. The story’s rich boy, Anson Hunter, falls in love with the beautiful and rich Paula Legendre, but he always finds some reason for not marrying her, although he maintains that his love for her never stops. Anson, the bachelor, ironically becomes an unofficial counselor to couples with martial difficulties and, in his role as protector of the family name, puts an end to an affair that his aunt is having. Paula marries an-
392
Short Story Writers
other man, divorces him, and, when Anson encounters her late in the story, he finds her happily remarried and pregnant. Paula, whose revered place has been jeopardized by her pregnancy, finally dies in childbirth, symbolically taking with her Anson’s youth. He goes on a cruise, disillusioned that his only real love is gone. Yet he is still willing to flirt with any woman on the ship who will affirm the feeling of superiority about himself that he cherishes in his heart. In “The Rich Boy,” then, Fitzgerald uses many of the themes—among them, lost youth and disillusionment in marriage—that he had covered in previous stories; in addition, he uses devices such as the narrator-observer point of view that had been successful in The Great Gatsby, and he pulls from the novel subjects such as the idealization of a woman who finally loses her suitor’s reverence. “The Rich Boy” also blends, along with the themes he had dealt with before, new topics that he would later distill and treat singly in another story, just as he first deals explicitly with the rich-are-different idea in “The Rich Boy” and later focuses his narrative specifically on that idea in “Six of One.” Finally, particularly in the use of the theme of bad marriages in “The Rich Boy,” there are foreshadowings of Tender Is the Night and the stories which cluster around it. “Babylon Revisited” • The best of these Tender Is the Night cluster stories is “Babylon Revisited,” which earned Fitzgerald his top Saturday Evening Post price of four thousand dollars and which is generally acclaimed as his finest story. “Babylon Revisited” represents a high point in Fitzgerald’s career as a short-story writer: It is an artistically superior story which earned a high price from a commercial magazine. In the story’s main character, Charlie Wales, Fitzgerald creates one whose future, in spite of his heroic struggle, is prescribed by his imprudent past, a past filled with heavy drinking and irresponsibility. He is destined to be haunted by reminders of his early life, embodied by Lorraine and Duncan, drinking friends from the past; to be judged for them by Marion, his dead wife’s sister who, like Charlie’s conscience personified, is disgusted by his past and demands punishment; and to be denied, for his penance, any right to fill the emptiness of his life with his daughter Honoria, who is in Marion’s custody and who is the only really meaningful thing left. Fitzgerald fashions Charlie as a sensitive channel through which the reader can simultaneously view both Paris as it existed for expatriate wanderers before the Depression and the now-dimmed Paris to which Charlie returns. The contrast is masterfully handled in that the course of Charlie’s emotional life closely parallels the changing mood of the city—a movement from a kind of unreal euphoria to a mood of loss and melancholy. The contrast at once heightens the reader’s sense of Charlie’s loneliness in a ghost town of bad memories and foreshadows his empty-handed return to Prague, his present home. All of Charlie’s present misery has resulted, in Fitzgerald’s precise summary, from his “selling short” in the boom—an allusion to the loss of his dead wife Helen. Charlie, however, refuses to be driven back to alcohol, even in the face of being denied his daughter Honoria. Although he might easily have done so, Fitzgerald avoids drawing the reader into a sentimental trap of identification with Charlie’s plight, the responsibility for and consequences of which must finally be borne only by Charlie. As he later did in Dick Diver’s case in Tender Is the Night, Fitzgerald has shown in “Babylon Revisited” how one man works his way into an existence with nada at the core; how he manages to dissipate, “to make nothing out of something,” and thus prescribe for himself a future without direction. It is also in the creation of this mood of Charlie’s isolation
Fitzgerald, F. Scott
393
that the artistic brilliance of the story, as well as its kinship to Tender Is the Night, lies. The popular thrust of “Babylon Revisited” is a dual one in which Fitzgerald plays on what were likely to be ambivalent feelings of popular readers toward Charlie. On one hand, he is pictured first as an expatriate about whose resolution to remain abroad American audiences may have been skeptical. On the other, Charlie appears to have reformed and obviously loves his daughter. Marion, by contrast, is depicted as a shrew, and the reader is left to choose, therefore, between the punishment of a life sentence of loneliness for a penitent wrongdoer and the granting of his complete freedom and forgiveness rendered against the better judgment of the unsympathetic Marion. Fitzgerald guarantees that the reader will become emotionally involved by centering the story around the highly emotional relationship between a father and his daughter. Because Charlie is, in fact, guilty, to let him go free would be to let wrongdoing go unpunished—the strictest kind of violation of the Puritan ethic. To deprive Charlie of Honoria, however, would be to side with the unlikable Marion. Fitzgerald, then, resolves the conflict in the only satisfactory way—by proposing a compromise. Although Marion keeps Honoria for the moment, Charlie may be paroled, may come back and try again, at any time in the future. The story, therefore, is successful on three major counts: It served as a workshop in which Fitzgerald shaped the mood of Tender Is the Night; it entertained with the struggle against unfair odds of a well-intentioned father for the affection of his daughter; and it succeeded on the mythic level, suggested in the title, as a story in which all ingredients conspire to lead to Charlie’s exile—an isolation from the city that has fallen in the absence of a now-reformed sinner, carrying with it not only the bad but also the good which Charlie has come to salvage. Esquire Stories • About four years after the publication of “Babylon Revisited,” Fitzgerald had lost the knack of writing Saturday Evening Post stories, and he began writing shorter pieces, many of which are sketches rather than stories, for Esquire. Esquire, however, was not a suitable medium to serve a workshop function as the Saturday Evening Post had been. On the one hand, it did not pay enough to sustain Fitzgerald through the composition of a novel; even if it had, it is difficult to imagine how Fitzgerald would have experimented in the framework of short Esquire pieces with the complex relationships that he was concurrently developing in The Last Tycoon. Moreover, there is the question of the suitability of Fitzgerald’s The Last Tycoon material, regardless of how he treated it, for Esquire: The Monroe Stahr-Kathleen relationship in The Last Tycoon, for example, and certainly also the Cecelia-Stahr relationship, would have been as out of place in Esquire as the Esquire story of a ten-year binge, “The Lost Decade,” would have been in the Saturday Evening Post. In short, Esquire was ill-suited to Fitzgerald’s need for a profitable workshop for The Last Tycoon, and it is difficult to read the Esquire pieces, particularly the Pat Hobby stories about a pathetic movie scriptwriter, without realizing that every hour Fitzgerald spent on them could have been better spent completing The Last Tycoon. From a practical standpoint, it is fair to say that the small sums of income for which Fitzgerald worked in writing the Esquire stories may have interfered with the completion of his last novel, whereas the high prices Fitzgerald earned from the Saturday Evening Post between 1925 and 1933 provided the financial climate that made it possible for him to complete Tender Is the Night. Indeed, if the Esquire stories in general and the Pat Hobby stories in particular, close as they were in terms of composition to The Last Tycoon, marked the distance
394
Short Story Writers
Fitzgerald had come in resolving the professional writer-literary artist dichotomy with which he had been confronted for twenty years, any study of the function of the stories in Fitzgerald’s overall career would end on a bleak note. Two stories, “Discard” and “Last Kiss,” neither of which was published in Fitzgerald’s lifetime, indicate, however, that he was attempting to re-create the climate of free exchange between his stories and novels characteristic especially of the composition period of Tender Is the Night. “Last Kiss” provides a good commentary on this attempt. When the story appeared in 1949, the editors remarked in a headnote that the story contained “the seed” that grew into The Last Tycoon. The claim is too extravagant for the story in that it implies the sort of relationship between the story and the novel that exists between “Winter Dreams” and The Great Gatsby, a relationship that simply does not exist in the case of “Last Kiss” and The Last Tycoon. There are, however, interesting parallels. “Last Kiss” • Fitzgerald created in “Last Kiss” counterparts both to Monroe Stahr and Kathleen in The Last Tycoon. Jim Leonard, a thirty-five-year-old film producer in “Last Kiss,” is similar to Stahr in that he possesses the same kind of power: When the budding starlet, Pamela Knighton, meets Leonard, her agent’s voice tells her: “This is somebody.” In fact, on the Hollywood success ladder he is, in Fitzgerald’s words, “on top,” although, like Stahr, he does not flaunt this fact. Although Pamela is fundamentally different from Kathleen in her self-centered coldness, they also share a resemblance to “pink and silver frost” and an uncertainty about Americans. Kathleen is no aspiring actor, but her past life, like Pamela’s, has an aura of mystery about it. Moreover, the present lives of both are complicated by binding entanglements: Pamela’s to Chauncey Ward, and Kathleen’s to the nameless man she finally marries. There are other parallels: The first important encounter between Leonard and Pamela, for example, closely resembles the ballroom scene during which Stahr becomes enchanted by Kathleen’s beauty. In fact, the nature of Leonard’s attraction to Pamela is similar to that of Stahr’s to Kathleen; although there is no Minna Davis lurking in Leonard’s past as there is in Stahr’s, he is drawn to Pamela by the kind of romantic, mysterious force which had finally, apart from her resemblance to Minna, drawn Stahr to Kathleen. Moreover, both attachments end abruptly with the same sort of finality: Pamela dies leaving Jim with only film fragments to remember her by, and Kathleen leaves Stahr when she marries “the American.” The possibility that these parallels were the seeds of The Last Tycoon is small. The important point, however, is that “Last Kiss” is a popular treatment of the primary material that Fitzgerald would work with in the novel: Jim’s sentimental return to the drugstore where he had once seen Pamela and his nostalgic remembrance of their last kiss earmark the story for a popular audience which, no doubt, Fitzgerald hoped would help pay his bills during the composition of the novel. Fitzgerald was unable to sell the story, probably because none of the characters generates strong emotion. It is sufficiently clear from “Last Kiss,” however, that Fitzgerald was regaining his sense of audience. In the process of demonstrating how well he understood Hollywood, the story also captured much of the glitter that is associated with it in the popular mind. In order to rebuild the kind of popular magazine workshop that he had had for Tender Is the Night, it remained for him to subordinate his understanding of Hollywood to the task of re-creating its surface. If he had continued in the direction of “Last Kiss,” he would perhaps have done this and thus returned to the kind of climate which had in the past proven to be most favorable for his serious novel work—one in which he
Fitzgerald, F. Scott
395
wrote handfuls of stories for popular magazines while the novel was taking shape. It is also possible that he might have used such stories to make The Last Tycoon something more than a great fragment. Regarding the role of the stories in Fitzgerald’s career, one can finally state that they functioned as providers of financial incentive, as proving grounds for his ideas, as workshops for his craft, and as dictators of his popular reputation. The problem for the serious student of Fitzgerald’s works is whether one should examine the popular professional writer who produced some 164 stories for mass consumption or limit one’s examination of Fitzgerald to his acclaimed works of art, such as “Babylon Revisited,” “The Rich Boy,” The Great Gatsby, and Tender Is the Night. To do one to the exclusion of the other is to present not only a fragmented picture of Fitzgerald’s literary output but also a distorted one. Just as the stories complement the novels, so do the novels make the stories more meaningful, and the financial and emotional climate from which they all came illuminates the nature of their interdependence. Bryant Mangum With updates by Mary Ellen Pitts Other major works play: The Vegetable: Or, From President to Postman, pb. 1923. novels: This Side of Paradise, 1920; The Beautiful and Damned, 1922; The Great Gatsby, 1925; Tender Is the Night, 1934; The Last Tycoon, 1941. miscellaneous: Afternoon of an Author: A Selection of Uncollected Stories and Essays, 1958; F. Scott Fitzgerald: The Princeton Years, Selected Writings, 1914-1920, 1996 (Chip Deffaa, editor). nonfiction: The Crack-Up, 1945; The Letters of F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1963; Letters to His Daughter, 1965; Thoughtbook of Francis Scott Fitzgerald, 1965; Dear Scott/Dear Max: The Fitzgerald-Perkins Correspondence, 1971; As Ever, Scott Fitzgerald, 1972; F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Ledger, 1972; The Notebooks of F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1978; A Life in Letters, 1994 (Matthew J. Bruccoli, editor); F. Scott Fitzgerald on Authorship, 1996; Dear Scott, Dearest Zelda: The Love Letters of F. Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald, 2002 (Jackson R. Bryer and Cathy W. Barks, editors). Bibliography Bruccoli, Matthew J. Some Sort of Epic Grandeur. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1981. In this outstanding biography, a major Fitzgerald scholar argues that Fitzgerald’s divided spirit, not his lifestyle, distracted him from writing. Bruccoli believes that Fitzgerald both loved and hated the privileged class that was the subject of his fiction. Eble, Kenneth. F. Scott Fitzgerald. Rev. ed. Boston: Twayne, 1977. A clearly written critical biography, this book traces Fitzgerald’s development from youth through a “Final Assessment,” which surveys scholarship on Fitzgerald’s texts. Gale, Robert L. An F. Scott Fitzgerald Encyclopedia. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1998. Provides everything students should know about Fitzgerald’s life and works. Indispensable. Hook, Andrew. F. Scott Fitzgerald: A Literary Life. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2002. Part of the Literary Lives series. Concise rather than thorough, but with some interesting details.
396
Short Story Writers
Jefferson, Margo. “Still Timely, Yet a Writer of His Time.” The New York Times, December 17, 1996, p. C17. A brief biography of Fitzgerald on the occasion of his centennial year; calls him one of those rare artists with a cultural radar system that is constantly picking up sensations, responses, and fresh thoughts. Kuehl, John. F. Scott Fitzgerald: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1991. Part 1 discusses Fitzgerald’s major stories and story collections, part 2 studies his critical opinions, and part 3 includes selections from Fitzgerald critics. Includes chronology and bibliography. Mangum, Bryant. A Fortune Yet: Money in the Art of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Short Stories. New York: Garland, 1991. Discusses all of Fitzgerald’s stories, both those in collections and those uncollected, focusing on their relationship to his novels and their role as a proving ground for his ideas. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these eight short stories by Fitzgerald: “Absolution” and “Babylon Revisited” (vol. 1), “Crazy Sunday” and “The Diamond as Big as the Ritz” (vol. 2), “The Freshest Boy” (vol. 3), “May Day” (vol. 5), “The Rich Boy” (vol. 6), and “Winter Dreams” (vol. 8). Meyers, Jeffrey. Scott Fitzgerald: A Biography. New York: HarperCollins, 1994. In this biography, which makes use of previously unknown materials about Fitzgerald’s life, Meyers discusses how such writers as Edgar Allan Poe, Ernest Hemingway, and Joseph Conrad influenced Fitzgerald’s fiction. Petry, Alice Hall. Fitzgerald’s Craft of Short Fiction. Ann Arbor, Mich.: UMI Research Press, 1989. Study of Fitzgerald’s short stories in relationship to his novels, American society, and his personal life. Summarizes and critiques critical reception to his short-story collections and discusses his relationship with his editor Max Perkins; analyzes all the major stories and a number of minor ones. Tate, Mary Jo. F. Scott Fitzgerald A to Z: The Essential Reference to His Life and Work. New York: Facts on File, 1998. Comprehensive study of the man and his works. Provides bibliographical references and an index.
397
Gustave Flaubert Born: Rouen, France; December 12, 1821 Died: Croisset, France; May 8, 1880 Principal short fiction • Novembre, wr. c. 1840, pb. 1885 (November, 1932); Trois Contes, 1877 (Three Tales, 1903). Other literary forms • Gustave Flaubert is best known for his novels Madame Bovary (1857; English translation, 1886) and L’Éducation sentimentale (1869; A Sentimental Education, 1898), which offer a realistic view of life in his native Normandy and, in the latter somewhat autobiographical novel, in Paris. He also wrote narratives of his travels to the Pyrenees and Corsica in 1840 (1927), to Italy in 1845, and to Egypt and the Middle East in 1849-1851 (Notes de voyage, 1910). Much of the exotic material gleaned on these trips helped inspire La Tentation de Saint Antoine (1874; The Temptation of Saint Anthony, 1895) and Salammbô (1862; English translation, 1886), novels in which he fictionalized figures from history. Achievements • Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary may be regarded as the great French novel, but upon its publication, in 1857, it was attacked for its immorality, and a famous lawsuit attempted to suppress it. In a sense, Emma Bovary differs little from many heroines of earlier novels, who engaged in enough amorous adventures to attract avid readers but whose eventual punishment served to uphold a moral perspective sufficient to keep the books socially respectable. What is new in Madame Bovary, as in Flaubert’s other realist work, lies in the author’s style. His detailed documentation of the society in which Emma lived emphasized the hypocrisy endemic in that society. Careful control of physical description delineates the personalities of the various characters and creates a style that has strongly influenced subsequent writers. Flaubert’s realistic compositions form only one aspect of his literary production. His other works, closer to the romantic tradition of the historical novel, testify to his depth and versatility. Biography • Gustave Flaubert was the second of three surviving children of a provincial doctor. Although it was Gustave’s older brother, Achille, who would succeed their father in his medical practice, young Gustave accompanied his father even into the dissecting room, where he gained a knowledge of anatomy and a habit of close observation that would contribute to his future literary style. Unlike Emma’s husband, the inept country doctor Charles Bovary, Achille-Cléophas Flaubert was a respected professional. Even after his father’s death, Flaubert wrote to his mother from Egypt of his pleasure at meeting during his travels a man who knew and respected his father’s reputation. Flaubert began the study of law but discontinued in part because of his poor health. Epileptic, he had infrequent seizures, but despite his robust appearance, his friends and family sought to protect him from excess strain. Flaubert’s only sustained professional activity was as an author. Although he lacked other employment, he felt no particular pressure to rush his works into publication. During the years 1835
398
Short Story Writers
to 1840, he composed a number of short pieces of prose, some fictitious and some personal memoirs, yet he published little. Most of these juvenilia were collected for publication only after his death. During 1843-1845, Flaubert composed the first version of his autobiographical novel, A Sentimental Education, which would finally be published in a considerably revised version in 1869. The story that it tells of young Frédéric Moreau and his frustrated love for an older, married woman parallels Flaubert’s own passion for the wife of Maurice Schlésinger, a financially successful bourgeois who provided a vehicle for the criticism of a materialistic society. Flaubert’s hesitation to publish increased in 1849 after reading the manuscript of The Temptation of Saint Library of Congress Anthony to his friends Maxima Du Camp and Louis Bouilhet, who harshly criticized it. In October, 1849, Flaubert and Du Camp set out together on a trip to Egypt and the Mediterranean coast as far as Constantinople. During the early part of this journey, Flaubert suffered from considerable depression, which he related to the poor reception of his book and doubts about his literary future. These doubts seem ironic in retrospect, given that in the fall of 1851 he was to begin writing Madame Bovary. Despite a lengthy relationship with Louise Colet, Flaubert never married. His numerous affairs may have been somewhat compromised after his tour of the Orient, however, in that he returned home suffering from syphilis. The publication of Madame Bovary in 1857 brought Flaubert both fame and notoriety because of the accusation of its immorality. During the remaining years of his life, Flaubert divided his time between his residence in Paris and his country house in Normandy. He also occasionally traveled to North Africa, the setting of his novel Salammbô published in 1862, and to Germany and England. In 1877, three years before his death, he published what are now his best-known short stories, in Three Tales. Analysis • Gustave Flaubert’s Three Tales, published during the year 1877, when he was fifty-six years old, reflects the variety of styles of his literary production as a whole. “Un Cœur simple” (“A Simple Heart”) employs the Norman realism of Madame Bovary. “La Légende de Saint Julien l’hospitalier” (“The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler”) reflects the preoccupation with exotic locales and the history of the early Christians evident in The Temptation of Saint Anthony and Flaubert’s travel narratives. “Hérodias” retains this exotic context while focusing on a singular heroine from the past, as Flaubert had done in Salammbô.
Flaubert, Gustave
399
These three texts, Flaubert’s only short fiction to be widely read, provide the usual choices for modern readers seeking an introduction to his work. Flaubert wrote them in a spontaneous burst of activity between September, 1875, and February, 1877, as if he were capping his career with a demonstration piece of his various styles. “A Simple Heart” • “A Simple Heart,” the life story of the good-hearted servant Félicité, draws its material from Flaubert’s own life. In 1825, a servant, Julie, joined the Flaubert household and may have provided a model for the character of Félicité. Critics have further suggested comparisons between Félicité and the old woman Catherine Leroux, who, in the Comices agricoles scene of Madame Bovary (part 2, chapter 8), is awarded “for fifty-four years of service on the same farm, a silver medal— valued at twenty-five francs.” Twenty-five francs may at that time have represented a fairly impressive sum but was nevertheless a mediocre value to place on fifty-four years of service. Flaubert, echoing his habit of undercutting both characters and social conventions with a final, damning detail, ends the official statement addressed to Catherine Leroux on this materialistic note. In “A Simple Heart,” as in Madame Bovary, the materialism of Norman society appears in the form of a continual preoccupation with money. Yet in both works, this harsh theme contrasts with a persistent romanticism linked to the vain hopes of the various characters. Cupidity in the form of jealousy appears in the very first sentence of “A Simple Heart”: “For half a century, the bourgeois women of Pont-l’Évëque envied Madame Aubain because of her servant, Félicité.” The motivations of characters throughout the story revolve around money, often to the disadvantage of trusting Félicité. Some figures appear prejudged, as society would have classified them economically, from their very first mention in the text. Thus, Madame Aubain’s uncle, an impoverished aristocrat who visits early in the second section of the story, “always arrived at lunch time, with a horrid poodle whose paws spread dirt on all the furniture.” Even the characters dearest to Félicité do not hesitate to hurt her when money is involved. When Félicité befriends Nastasie Barette, who does exploit her by accepting numerous presents, Madame Aubain cuts off this opportunity for friendship by decreeing their prompt return from Trouville to Pont-l’Évëque. Even Félicité’s beloved nephew, Victor, imposes on her generosity, although he does bring back to her gifts from his travels. His sudden departure on a voyage to the United States throws Félicité into despair, augmented by Madame Aubain’s insensitive incomprehension of her suffering when she learns of Victor’s death. Throughout, characters are defined, usually in a negative manner, by the objects that surround them, objects that often appear in themselves hostile. The initial description of Madame Aubain’s house in Pont-l’Évëque tells the reader that “it had interior differences of level that made people trip,” and the family members appear through the presentation of their rooms, where the “two children’s beds without mattresses” and the attic room of Félicité testify to the subordinate status of children and servants. Yet appearances can be deceiving, still with a bias toward the negative. Because of her harsh life and limited diet, Félicité “at the age of twenty-five appeared to be forty years old.” The considerable catalog of objects in these defining descriptions parallels Flaubert’s technique in Madame Bovary and echoes much of the realistic style of Honoré de Balzac, whose death in 1850 had appeared to Flaubert as a great loss.
400
Short Story Writers
Thus, the detailed menu of the lunch at the Liébard farm recalls the even more expansive description in Emma Bovary’s view of the dinner at the château, and Virginie, after her death, survives in memory in her clothes—reminiscent of the wedding bouquet of Charles’s previous wife that greets Emma upon her arrival at the house at Tostes—clothes that Madame Aubain could bring herself to inspect only when “moths flew out of the wardrobe.” The central documentation, however, must be that of Félicité’s own room. Flaubert makes a significant decision to withhold this description until the very end of the story. The mention of Félicité’s room in the opening pages tells the reader only that it was in the attic and had a view over the fields. There is no description of the interior. By the time it is revealed, the room contains the debris of Félicité’s life and “had the appearance both of a chapel and a bazaar, as it contained so many religious objects and varied things.” The separation of the religious objects here from the others underlines their dual role. Religion, as will be seen, held great importance for Félicité, but the objects that represent her devotion share with the others in her room echoes of deterioration and loss. Further, the distinction blurs between religious and secular: “On the dresser, covered with a cloth like an altar, was a box made of seashells that Victor had given her.” She retains with religious veneration objects linked to her memories. Negative emphasis within the realistic catalog again parallels Madame Bovary. The determining events of Félicité’s unhappy memories grow from the same avaricious society that surrounded Emma. The one man she loved, Théodore, abandoned her to marry “a very rich old woman,” an action analogous both to Charles Bovary’s first, arranged marriage to Héloïse and to Paul’s later marriage in “A Simple Heart” to the daughter of a man who could help his career. Victor’s death, attributed to poor medical treatment of his case of yellow fever, recalls Charles Bovary’s unfortunate failure in the operation on Justin, and the heirs who pillage Madame Aubain’s house parallel the actions of Emma’s creditors. The most obvious negative emphases, however, result from a series of exclusions. The bad can be defined most easily by contrast with the good. Often, this ranking comes from the arbitrary expectations of society, expectations that Flaubert documented in his Dictionnaire des idées reçues (1910, 1913; Dictionary of Accepted Ideas, 1954). Thus, Charles Bovary bought for Emma “a second-hand vehicle that, once equipped with new lanterns and pierced leather mud flaps, almost resembled a tilbury,” and at the beach at Trouville, Virginie “went swimming in a shirt, for lack of a bathing costume; and her maid dressed her in a customs-inspection cabin that served for the bathers.” Things, not allowed to be as they naturally exist, are described as “almost” something more prestigious. Those moments of high prestige in which the characters participate, however, disappear from the text. At Virginie’s funeral, for example, readers see the preparation of the body for the burial but not the more uplifting religious ceremony. Flaubert states simply, “after mass, it took three quarters of an hour to get to the cemetery.” Similarly, though romance dominates Emma Bovary’s life, Flaubert never shows her at the moment of central significance when she is a bride in church. Again, he emphasizes distance to be traversed: “The town hall being at half a league from the farm, they went there on foot, and came back in the same manner, once the ceremony was over at the church.” The last phrase, added almost as an afterthought, effectively deemphasizes what could have been the most positive moment of Emma’s life. One may certainly argue that liturgy, with its set patterns, need not
Flaubert, Gustave
401
be described in detail to be understood. Still, as Alphonse Daudet so aptly demonstrated in “Les Trois Messes basses,” the personal circumstances woven into each liturgy make it a unique event. This must hold especially true for both weddings and funerals. Although the drama of liturgical moments disappears from Flaubert’s texts, a current of romanticism persists throughout “A Simple Heart.” Linked in part to the religious element in the story, this romanticism includes references both to traditional romantic themes and to other passages in which Flaubert appears to parody such themes. This again echoes Madame Bovary and Flaubert’s dual feelings concerning romantic passion. Emma Bovary’s emotional confusion clearly derives from the false ideas of love, which she had taken from sentimental novels. Immediately after her marriage, she “sought to know exactly what people meant in real life by the words felicity, passion and intoxication that had appeared so beautiful to her in books.” Flaubert’s use of the word félicité in this description of Emma’s disappointment anticipates the irony in the choice of the word as the name for his heroine in “A Simple Heart.” Félicité does occasionally achieve joy but only despite the numerous forces working against her happiness. Religion provides the central solace of Félicité’s life. At the beginning of the story, she rises at dawn to attend Mass and falls asleep each night with her rosary in her hand. She derives a dual joy from attending catechism classes with Virginie. She admires the beauty of the stained-glass windows, much as Emma Bovary “rather than following the mass looked at the holy pictures framed in azure in her book,” and thus Félicité gains a rudimentary religious education, such training “having been neglected in her youth.” The repeated images in the church of the Holy Spirit in the form of a bird prepare for Félicité’s vision at the end of the story. Along with religion, a romantic joy in external nature touches Félicité. In a way that underlines her solitude, however, these fleeting moments of happiness come to Félicité only with the rare experience of love. Flaubert tells the reader very early that Félicité “had had, like anyone else, her tale of love,” thus deemphasizing this formative experience. Still, during her interlude with Théodore, they were surrounded by the beauty of nature: “The wind was soft; the stars shone,” but as Emma could not regain the luxury of the ball at the château, Félicité only rarely returns to the joys of nature. One other such interlude does occur when she accompanies the Aubain family to the countryside. This enjoyment coincides with the fulfillment that Félicité feels in taking care of Paul and Virginie when they are children, but even here there is a sense of deterioration from a better state of things past. The house they visit “was all that remained of a vacation house, now disappeared.” Consistent with the romantic pathetic fallacy identifying elements of nature with the emotional condition of the protagonist, nature remains pleasant in “A Simple Heart” while Félicité is relatively happy. Later, as she worries about Victor, who has gone to sea, she focuses on violent storms and finally learns that, “as in a memory of engravings in a geography book, he was eaten by savages, trapped in a forest by monkeys, or dying on a deserted beach.” Like Emma, she takes her imaginings from an overly literal application of material from books. As Flaubert cites these tales of savages and monkeys, modern elements of romantic travel literature, he draws on a rich source of contemporary allusion. Elsewhere, the names of Paul and Virginie he chooses for Madame Aubain’s children recall the novel Paul et Virginie (1788), by Jacques-Henri Bernadin de Saint-Pierre, the exotic setting of which provided a model of preromantic nature description. Later, the ap-
402
Short Story Writers
pearance of the de Larsonnière family with their black servant and their parrot continued this current of exotic allusion. Flaubert’s critique of romanticism leads him to use a degree of exaggeration that approaches parody. When their uncle gives the children a geography book with engravings, “they represented different scenes of the world, cannibals with feathers on their heads, a monkey carrying off a young girl, bedouins in the desert, a whale being harpooned. . . .” These dramatic choices may have been typical of geography books of the time, but in Flaubert’s description of Virginie after her death, the choices are entirely his own. He begins with a conventional tableau, where Virginie’s pale face contrasted with a black crucifix echoes the contrast of light and darkness dear to the Romantics. As Félicité remains “for two nights” near the body, however, the description, drawn from Flaubert’s realistic medical observations, inclines toward the grotesque. Grotesque exaggeration linked to the theme of death culminates in the story of Félicité’s parrot. She had become so attached to the bird, the last voice audible to her as she became progressively deaf, that she had it stuffed after its death. Its place among the religious objects in her room reinforced an association: “In church she always contemplated the Holy Spirit and observed that he somewhat resembled the parrot.” The bird, however, badly preserved, deteriorated. At the end, when Félicité’s friend brought the parrot to her to kiss, “worms were devouring it.” Félicité does not see the deterioration of the parrot. Her eyes as well as her ears are failing. The brief fifth and final section of the story brings the reader at last to the perspective of Félicité herself, who, thanks to the very narrowness of her perceptions, achieves the happiness promised in her name. Earlier references have slighted Félicité’s intelligence and alluded to her lack of education, but what she does not know may protect her. The fifth section opens with the line “The grass sent the odor of summer,” appealing to one sense that Félicité retains and bringing back to her the sense of joy in nature. A religious procession is about to pass by the house, and readers see it through Félicité’s imagination. The holy sacrament is displayed on an altar containing many objects representative of life in the local area, including the stuffed parrot, Loulou. This accumulation of mismatched objects, however, no longer conveys the lack of aesthetic sense that it might have represented earlier. It has become a “mound of bright colors” amid which “Loulou, hidden under some roses, showed only a blue forehead, like a piece of lapis.” Properly selected and arranged, even the realistic debris of village life can present a form of beauty. At the end, Félicité is vindicated in that her “simple heart” had led her to make instinctive choices that protect what beauty there was in her world. The complex style of “A Simple Heart” derives from the tension between its realistic and romantic elements. A similar contrast in “La Légende de Saint Julien l’Hospitalier” (“The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler”), however, produces a much simpler narrative, where quantities of relatively generic images replace the nuances of the objects in Félicité’s surroundings. “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler” • “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler” conveys the life of its protagonist from birth to death, neatly divided into three parts: the growing violence of the young man, who fears that he will fulfill a prophecy that he will kill his parents, a period of flight that ends with Julien unwittingly killing his parents when they come to seek him, and his final repentance and salvation. The story, set in a vaguely described medieval Europe, contains numerous exotic
Flaubert, Gustave
403
elements that link it to Flaubert’s The Temptation of Saint Anthony. Although Antoine spends the greater part of his story doing penance and resisting temptations, however, Julien’s violent years dominate a story with only a brief phase of penitence. The fairy-tale opening of “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler”—“Julien’s father and mother lived in a chateau, in the middle of a wood, on the slope of a hill”—contrasts with the more theatrical style with extensive dialogue that dominates The Temptation of Saint Anthony. Exotic elements proliferate in “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler” from the very first description, where the family’s castle contains armaments of foreign origins, to the Asian merchants and pilgrims from the Holy Land who describe their journeys and to the diverse adversaries whom Julien faces during his extensive travels as a soldier. The analogy with the story of Oedipus, similarly destined to kill his father, adds a foreign element, but description in “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler” lacks the details and contrasts of the Norman scene. When Julien kills animals while hunting and later finds himself surrounded by beasts intent on avenging his excessive savagery, the catalog of creatures retains the artistic sense of animals highlighted in a tapestry: “A marten slipped quickly between his legs, a panther bounded over his shoulder, a serpent wound around an ash tree.” Except for the stag that speaks to Julien to warn him of his fate, the animals and other objects Julien encounters remain generic, devoid of descriptive detail. Similarly, the pathetic fallacy linking landscape to emotion disappears in this text. When, in the second part, Julien marries and attempts to lead a settled life, the sky over his château “was always blue.” Even in the emotional hunting scene that reawakens his savagery and leads to the death of his parents, readers see him surrounded by natural beauty: “The shadows of trees spread out across the moss. Sometimes the moon dappled the clearings.” Occasionally, description does serve, as elsewhere in Flaubert’s work, to define the mood of characters. As Julien grows more ferocious in hunting, he returns home one night “covered with blood and dirt, with thorns in his hair and smelling like savage beasts.” Flaubert, however, continues here, “He became like the beasts.” The symbolism is more explicit and heavy-handed than in Flaubert’s more realistic texts. A night lamp “in the form of a dove” symbolizes his parents’ care for Julien but with a more simplistic suggestion than that in Félicité’s vision of the Holy Spirit. If the characters are not seen as motivated by the objects that surround them, a strong theme of fate provides an alternate controlling force. When Julien’s thirst for blood is first aroused and he begins to kill birds with stones, “the wall being broken at that place, a piece of stone happened to be under his fingers. He turned his arm and the stone knocked down the bird.” The stone, not Julien, is responsible, and later, when Julien attempts to repent, violent dreams come unbidden to renew his desire to kill. Fate finds its voice in the prophecies governing Julien’s life. At his birth, a beggar, “a Bohemian with plaited beard, silver rings on his arms, and blazing eyes,” warns Julien’s father of the violence to come, much as the beggar in Madame Bovary foreshadows Emma’s death. At the end of the story, the leprous traveler whom Julien rescues flashes the same blazing eyes just before Julien is carried off to heaven. This salvation, ordained by Christ, responds to another kind of external—this time divine—manipulation.
404
Short Story Writers
“Hérodias” • Just as Julien’s story follows what has been preordained, “Hérodias” must not depart from the set sequence of events from the biblical story. This time, Flaubert narrates not the entire life of his protagonist but the events of a single day. During the first two parts of the story, a delegation arrives from Rome and, while searching Herod’s cellars for treasures, finds the imprisoned John the Baptist, called here Iaokanann, who rails against Herod’s incestuous marriage. The third part narrates the banquet where Salomé’s dance earns Iaokanann’s death. Again, Flaubert uses a considerable amount of description, much of it derived from his own visit to the shores of the Dead Sea, but the view remains that of the camera, avoiding detailed analysis of the characters’ emotions. Readers first see Herod on a terrace with a panoramic view of the surrounding country. The descriptive catalog of the terrain and Herod’s embattled position parallel the situation at the beginning of Salammbô. Later, an enumeration of armaments in Herod’s cellars recalls the similar listing in “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler,” but very little of this relates to character exposition. Only the menacing “hot wind with the odor of sulfer” that blows as Hérodias, Herod’s wife, arrives hints at the personal confrontations to come. Even when, at the end of the first part, Herod’s view of a beautiful young girl on another terrace foreshadows Hérodias’s manipulation of him, the portrait of the girl herself has the impersonality of an Asian painting. A principal animation of “Hérodias” comes from recurrent animal imagery. Iaokanann appears in prison, covered with animal skins, “in the depths of his lair.” He screams that he will cry out “like a bear, like a wild ass” and forces Hérodias finally to “roar” like a lion. Contrasting with this animal imagery, however, Salomé’s dance appears mechanical. In a parallel scene in Salammbô, the heroine dances with a python “placing the middle of its body around the back of her neck,” but Salomé, instructed by her mother, remains externally controlled “like a flower shaken by a storm.” Almost inevitably Iaokanann is beheaded. The story ends as two Christians carry the head away toward Galilee: “Since it was very heavy, they took turns carrying it.” This final realistic touch parallels the closing of “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler,” where Flaubert adds, “There is the story of Saint Julien l’Hospitalier approximately as one finds it on the church window in my country.” Each story, exoticism notwithstanding, ends grounded by a realistic touch. Flaubert’s instinctive return to realism reflects the importance of the documentary style, founded on his detailed observation of Norman life, through which he orchestrated objects to reflect the psychological composition of his characters. A comparison of “A Simple Heart” with Flaubert’s more exotic short stories reveals a shift in the latter toward a formal objectivity. Animals like those of a tapestry and the image of a girl portrayed as if in a painting distance themselves from the emotional content of the story. Flaubert’s realistic manner bridges this distance. In “A Simple Heart,” as in Madame Bovary, he develops a complexity that relies on the careful selection of objects to define both the feelings of his characters and the societal forces that often conflict with them. This conflict, closely tied to the clash of romantic and realistic elements, provides the basic tension that gives life to Flaubert’s work. Dorothy M. Betz
Flaubert, Gustave
405
Other major works plays: Le Château des cœurs, wr. 1863, pr. 1874 (with Louis Bouilhet; The Castle of Hearts, 1904); Le Candidat, pr., pb. 1874 (The Candidate, 1904). novels: La Première Éducation sentimentale, wr. 1843-1845, pb. 1963 (The First Sentimental Education, 1972); Madame Bovary, 1857 (English translation, 1886); Salammbô, 1862 (English translation, 1886); L’Éducation sentimentale, 1869 (A Sentimental Education, 1898); La Tentation de Saint Antoine, 1874 (The Temptation of Saint Anthony, 1895); Bouvard et Pécuchet, 1881 (Bouvard and Pécuchet, 1896). miscellaneous: The Complete Works, 1904 (10 volumes); Œuvres complètes, 19101933 (22 volumes). nonfiction: Par les champs et par les grèves, 1885 (with Maxime Du Camp; Over Strand and Field, 1904); Correspondance, 1830-1880, 1887-1893; Dictionnaire des idées reçues, 1910, 1913 (Dictionary of Accepted Ideas, 1954); Notes de voyage, 1910; Correspondance, 1981 (Alphonse Jacobs, editor; Flaubert-Sand: The Correspondence of Gustave Flaubert and George Sand, 1993); Gustave Flaubert-Alfred Le Poittevin, Gustave-FlaubertMaxine Du Camp: Correspondances, 2000 (Yvan Leclerc, editor). Bibliography Addison, Claire. Where Flaubert Lies. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1996. Detailed study of Flaubert’s life and art, focusing on the relationship between his personal life, historical context, and his fiction. Bloom, Harold, ed. Gustave Flaubert. New York: Chelsea House, 1989. This collection of fourteen essays with an introduction by Bloom covers multiple aspects of Flaubert’s life and work. Jane Robertson writes on the structure of “Hérodias,” noting the relative difficulty of the work. Shoshana Felman’s essay on “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler” stresses legendary and symbolic elements in the story. Contains a chronology of Flaubert’s life, a bibliography, and an index. Brown, Frederick. Flaubert: A Biography. Boston: Little, Brown, 2006. This penetrating study of Flaubert in nineteenth century Paris paints a lively portrait of the man and his time. Cronk, Nicholas. “Reading Un Cœur Simple: The Pleasure of the Intertext.” NineteenthCentury French Studies 24 (Fall/Winter, 1995/1996): 154-161. Discusses the story’s allusion to eighteenth century works from the Rousseauesque tradition of sentiment and the Voltairean tradition of satire. Claims that Flaubert appropriates a character of Bernardin de Saint-Pierre’s as a model for Félicité. Greenbaum, Andrea. “Flaubert’s Un Cœur Simple.” The Explicator (Summer, 1995): 208-211. Discusses the satire in Flaubert’s story, particularly its mockery of religious devotion by means of the parrot, the story’s satirical centerpiece. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Flaubert: “Hérodias” (vol. 3); “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler” (vol. 4); and “A Simple Heart” (vol. 7). Nadeau, Maurice. The Greatness of Flaubert. Translated by Barbara Bray. New York: Library Press, 1972. This biographical work devotes chapter 16 to the Three Tales, stressing how these works evolved from ideas that Flaubert had accumulated during his previous writing. Sources considered are largely biographical, and the chapter details the immediate context in which the three stories were written. Supplemented by a chronology and a bibliography.
406
Short Story Writers
Porter, Laurence M., ed. Critical Essays on Gustave Flaubert. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1986. This collection of sixteen essays includes work by a number of authorities in the field. Two studies treat the Three Tales: Raymonde Debray-Genette studies “Narrative Figures of Speech” in “A Simple Heart” in a structural analysis that still insists on the importance of illusion, and Benjamin F. Bart examines “Humanity and Animality” in “The Legend of St. Julian, Hospitaler.” Bibliography, index. Stipa, Ingrid. “Desire, Repetition, and the Imaginary in Flaubert’s Un Cœ ur Simple.” Studies in Short Fiction 31 (Fall, 1994): 617-626. Argues that although Flaubert maintains an ironic perspective in the story, a pattern of repetitions of imagery makes the transformation of the parrot into a sacred symbol acceptable to the reader, a tactic that protects the protagonist from being the victim of the irony. Unwin, Timothy, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Flaubert. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004. Replete with tools for further research, this is an excellent aid to any study of Flaubert’s life and work. Wall, Geoffrey. Flaubert: A Life. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2002. Critically acclaimed narrative biography that gives Lottman and Troyat a run for the standard. Offers plenty of fresh detail and a great read.
407
E. M. Forster Born: London, England; January 1, 1879 Died: Coventry, England; June 7, 1970 Principal short fiction • The Celestial Omnibus, and Other Stories, 1911; The Eternal Moment, and Other Stories, 1928; The Collected Tales of E. M. Forster, 1947; The Life to Come, and Other Stories, 1972; Arctic Summer, and Other Fiction, 1980. Other literary forms • E. M. Forster wrote six novels, one of which (Maurice, 1971) was published posthumously because of its homosexual theme. He also wrote travel books, essays, reviews, criticism, biography, and some poetry. Together with Eric Crozier he wrote the libretto for the four-act opera Billy Budd (1951), adapted from Herman Melville’s famous work. Achievements • As a novelist of rare distinction and one of the great literary figures of the twentieth century, E. M. Forster enjoyed international recognition and received many literary awards and honors. In 1921, as private secretary to the maharajah of Dewas State Senior, he was awarded the Sir Tukojirao Gold Medal. The publication of A Passage to India (1924) brought him much acclaim, including the Femina Vie Heureuse Prize and the James Tait Black Memorial Prize in 1925. In 1927, he was elected Fellow of King’s College, Cambridge, and he delivered Clark Lectures at Trinity College. In 1937, the Royal Society of Literature honored him with the Benson Medal. In 1945, he was made Honorary Fellow, King’s College, where he remained until his death in 1970. In 1953, he was received by Queen Elizabeth II as a Companion of Honor. Between 1947 and 1958, several universities, including Cambridge, conferred on him the honorary degree of doctor of laws. In 1961, the Royal Society of Literature named him a Companion of Literature. He attained the greatest recognition when, on his ninetieth birthday, on January 1, 1969, he was appointed to the Order of Merit by Queen Elizabeth. Biography • Edward Morgan Forster was born in London on January 1, 1879. He was the great-grandson of Henry Thornton, a prominent member of the Evangelical Clapham Sect and a member of Parliament. His father, an architect, died early, and he was brought up by his mother and his great-aunt, Marianne Thornton (whose biography he published in 1956). He received his early education at Tonbridge School, but he did not like the public school atmosphere. His bitter criticism of the English public school system appears in his portrayal of Sawston School in his first two novels, Where Angels Fear to Tread (1905) and The Longest Journey (1907). From Tonbridge, Forster went on to the University of Cambridge—thanks to the rich inheritance left by Marianne Thornton, who died when he was eight—where he came under the influence of Goldworthy Lowes Dickinson (whose biography he wrote in 1934) and quickly began to blossom as a scholar, writer, and humanist. After graduating from King’s College, Forster traveled, with his mother, to Italy and Greece in 1901. His first short story, “Albergo Empedocle,” was published in 1903. Between 1903 and 1910, he published four novels, nine short stories, and other,
408
Short Story Writers
nonfictional items. His travels to Greece and Italy led to his representation of life in those countries as being less repressive than life in England. During World War I, he served as a volunteer with the Red Cross in Alexandria, Egypt. His stay there resulted in Alexandria: A History and a Guide (1922) and Pharos and Pharillon (1923). His two visits to India, the first in 1912 in company of Goldworthy Lowes Dickinson and the second in 1921 as private secretary to the maharajah of Dewas State Senior, provided him material for his masterpiece novel A Passage to India (1924) as well as The Hill of Devi (1953). With A Passage to India, Forster’s reputation was established as a major English novelist of the twentieth century. He made a third visit to India in 1945 to attend a conference of Indian writers at Jaipur. He then wrote, “If Indians had not spoken English my own life would have been infinitely poorer.” He visited the United States in 1947 to address the Symposium on Music Criticism at Harvard and again in 1949 to address the American Academy of Arts and Letters. Though Forster stopped publishing fiction after 1924, he continued to produce significant nonfiction writing to the end. In a statement at the beginning of B. J. Kirkpatrick’s A Bibliography of E. M. Forster (1965), Forster said: “The longer one lives the less one feels to have done, and I am both surprised and glad to discover from this bibliography that I have written so much.” He died on June 7, 1970, at the age of ninety-one. Throughout his life he kept his faith in liberal humanism, in the sanctity of personal relationships, and, above all, in individualism. His charismatic personality and his personal warmth have led many people to believe that the man was greater than his books. Analysis • All of Forster’s best-known and most anthologized stories appeared first in two collections, The Celestial Omnibus and The Eternal Moment. The words “celestial” and “eternal” are especially significant because a typical E. M. Forster story features a protagonist who is allowed a vision of a better life, sometimes momentarily only. Qualifications for experiencing this epiphany include a questioning mind, an active imagination, and a dissatisfaction with conventional attitudes. The transformation resulting from the experience comes about through some kind of magic that transports him through time—backward or forward—or through space—to Mt. Olympus or to heaven. Whether or not his life is permanently changed, the transformed character can never be the same again after a glimpse of the Elysian Fields, and he is henceforth suspect to contemporary mortals. Forster termed his short stories “fantasies,” and when the discerning reader can determine the point at which the real and the fantastic intersect, he will locate the epiphany, at the same time flexing his own underused imaginative muscles. Perhaps “The Machine Stops,” a science-fiction tale about a world managed by a computerlike Machine that warns men to “beware of first-hand ideas,” was at the time of its writing (1909) the most fantastic of Forster’s short fiction, but its portrayal of radio, television, and telephones with simultaneous vision seems to have been simply farsighted. Forster frequently uses a narrator who is so insensitive that he ironically enhances the perception of the reader. In “Other Kingdom,” for example, when Mr. Inskip finds it “right” to repeat Miss Beaumont’s conversation about a “great dream” to his employer, the reader correctly places the tutor on the side of unimaginative human, rather than in the lineup of Dryads to which the young lady will repair. When the narrator of “The Story of a Panic” boasts that he “can tell a story without exaggerating” and then unfolds a tale about a boy who obviously is visited by Pan and who finally
Forster, E. M.
409
bounds away to join the goat-god, the readers know that they must themselves inform the gaps of information. When the same narrator attributes the death of the waiter Gennaro to the fact that “the miserable Italians have no stamina. Something had gone wrong inside him,” the reader observes the disparity between the two statements and rightly concludes that Gennaro’s death has a supernatural cause—that he had been subjected to the same “panic” as had Eustace, and that only the latter had passed the test. In Aspects of the Novel (1927), Forster suggests that fiction will play a part in the ultimate success of civilization through promotion of human sympathy, reconciliation, and understanding. In each of the short stories the protagonist gets a fingerhold on the universal secret, but he sometimes loses his grip, usually through the action of someone too blind, materialistic, or enslaved by time to comprehend the significance of the moment. If, as Forster himself declares, the emphasis of plot lies in causality, he allows the reader an important participation, because the causes of transformation are never explicit, and the more mundane characters are so little changed by the miraculous events taking place around them that they are not puzzled or even aware that they occur. “The Eternal Moment” • In “The Eternal Moment,” the stiffly insensitive Colonel Leyland, Miss Raby’s friend and traveling companion, is just such a character. Although Miss Raby is determined to accept the responsibility for the commercialization of the mountain resort Vorta engendered by her novel, Colonel Leyland can understand her feelings no more readily than can Feo, the uneducated waiter who is the immediate object of Miss Raby’s search. Although Miss Raby ostensibly has returned to the village to see how it has been affected by tourism since she made it famous, she also is drawn to the spot because it was the scene of the one romantic, although brief, interlude of her life. For twenty years she has recalled a declaration of passionate love for her by a young Italian guide whose advances she had rejected. This memory has sustained her because of its reality and beauty. She finds the once rustic village overgrown with luxury hotels, in one of which Feo, her dream-lover, is the stout, greasy, middle-aged, hypocritical concierge. Miss Raby, whose instincts have warned her that the progress of civilization is not necessarily good, sees that “the passage of a large number of people” has corrupted not only the village and its values, but also Feo. Observing that “pastoral virtues” and “family affection” have disappeared with the onslaught of touristry, she accosts the embarrassed peasant who had once offered her flowers. In a scene that is the quintessence of a human failure to communicate, Feo believes that she is attempting to ruin him, while she is actually appealing to him to help the old woman who owns the only hotel untouched by modernity. Colonel Leyland, who cannot bear the thought, much less the reality, of such intimate contact with a member of the lower class, gives up his idea of marrying Miss Raby. The rich novelist, whose entire life has been enriched by the “eternal moment” when she briefly and in imagination only had spanned class barriers, asks Feo if she can adopt one of his children. Rebuffed, she will live alone, able perhaps to blot out reality and relive the happiness that the memory of the “eternal moment” has brought her. Another misunderstood protagonist is Eustace, the fourteen-year-old English boy considered a misfit by the group of tourists with whom he is seeing Italy. Listless and pampered, bad-tempered and repellent, Eustace dislikes walking, cannot swim, and
410
Short Story Writers
appears most to enjoy lounging. Forced to go to a picnic, the boy carves from wood a whistle, which when blown evokes a “catspaw” of wind that frightens all of the other tourists into running. When they return to their picnic site in search of Eustace, they find him lying on his back, a green lizard darting from his cuff. For the first time on the trip the boy smiles and is polite. The footprints of goats are discerned nearby as Eustace races around “like a real boy.” A dazed hare sits on his arm, and he kisses an old woman as he presents her with flowers. The adults, in trying to forget the encounter, are cruel to Eustace and to Gennaro, a young, natural, ignorant Italian fishing lad, who is a “stop-gap” waiter at the inn, and who clearly understands the boy’s experience. As Eustace and Gennaro attempt to flee to freedom from human responsibility, the waiter is killed, the victim of a society which in its lack of understanding had attempted to imprison Eustace, oblivious to his miraculous change, or at least to its significance. He has turned into an elfin sprite of the woods, to which he escapes forever, leaving behind him Forster’s customary complement of complacent, nonplussed tourists. “Other Kingdom” • No Pan, but a Dryad, is Evelyn Beaumont of “Other Kingdom.” Mr. Inskip, who narrates the tale, has been hired as a tutor of the classics by handsome, prosperous, and pompous Harcourt Worters. Inskip’s charges are Worters’s fiancé, Miss Evelyn Beaumont, and his ward, Jack Ford. When Worters announces that he has purchased a nearby copse called “Other Kingdom” as a wedding gift for Evelyn, she dances her gleeful acceptance in imitation of a beech tree. On a celebratory picnic Evelyn asks Jack to stand in a position that will hide the house from her view. She is dismayed to learn that Worters plans to build a high fence around her copse and to add an asphalt path and a bridge. Evelyn values the fact that boys and girls have been coming for years from the village to carve their initials on the trees, and she notes that Worters finds blood on his hands when he attempts to repeat the romantic ritual. Upon hearing that Worters has obtained Other Kingdom by taking advantage of a widow, she realizes that he is a selfish person who views her as one of his possessions to be enjoyed. Broken in spirit, she apparently agrees to his plan of fencing in the copse, but she dances away “from society and life” to be united with other wood nymphs and likely with Ford, who knows intuitively that she is a free spirit that can never be possessed. “The Road from Colonus” • Although Eustace in “Story of a Panic” is a Pan-figure, Evelyn a Dryad, and Harcourt Worters a prototype of Midas, Mr. Lucas of “The Road from Colonus” is associated with Oedipus. The tale’s title is reminiscent of Sophocles’ play, and Ethel, Mr. Lucas’s daughter, represents Antigone. As do Miss Raby, Eustace, and Evelyn Beaumont, Mr. Lucas enters into a special union with nature and humankind. Riding ahead of his daughter and her friends, he finds the “real Greece” when he spies a little inn surrounded by a grove of plane trees and a little stream that bubbles out of a great hollow tree. As he enters this natural shrine, he for the first time sees meaning to his existence, and he longs to stay in this peaceful spot. The other tourists, however, have schedules and appointments to adhere to, and they forcibly carry Mr. Lucas away from the scene of his revelation. That night the plane tree crashes to kill all occupants of the inn, and Mr. Lucas spends his remaining days fussing about his neighbors and the noises of civilization, especially those made by the running water in the drains and reminiscent of the pleasant, musical gurgles of the little stream in Greece.
Forster, E. M.
411
“The Celestial Omnibus” • More fortunate than Mr. Lucas is the boy who rides “The Celestial Omnibus” from an alley where an old, faded sign points the way “To Heaven.” After the driver, Sir Thomas Browne, delivers the boy across a great gulf on a magnificent rainbow to the accompaniment of music, and back home to his nursery, the boy’s parents refuse to believe his tale. Mr. Bons, a family friend, attempts to prove the boy is lying by offering to make a repeat journey with him. On this trip the driver is Dante. Even though Mr. Bons is finally convinced that the boy has actually met Achilles and Tom Jones, he wants to go home. When Mr. Bons crawls out of the omnibus shrieking, “I see London,” he falls and is seen no more. His body is discovered “in a shockingly mutilated condition,” and the newspaper reports that “foul play is suspected.” The boy is crowned with fresh leaves as the dolphins awaken to celebrate with him the world of imagination. Mr. Bons, when accosted with this world, rejected it so violently that he suffered physical pain. In all of these “fantasies,” a gulf separates reality from illusion, and the latter is clearly to be preferred. If one must inhabit the real world, one can bear its existence and even love its inhabitants if that person is one of the fortunate few receptive to a special kind of vision. Sue L. Kimball With updates by Chaman L. Sahni Other major works play: Billy Budd, pb. 1951 (with Eric Crozier; libretto). novels: Where Angels Fear to Tread, 1905; The Longest Journey, 1907; A Room with a View, 1908; Howards End, 1910; Maurice, wr. 1913, pb. 1971; A Passage to India, 1924. miscellaneous: The Abinger Edition of E. M. Forster, 1972-1998 (17 volumes; Oliver Stallybrass, editor). nonfiction: Alexandria: A History and a Guide, 1922; Pharos and Pharillon, 1923; Aspects of the Novel, 1927; Goldsworthy Lowes Dickinson, 1934; Abinger Harvest—A Miscellany, 1936; Virginia Woolf, 1942; Development of English Prose Between 1918 and 1939, 1945; Two Cheers for Democracy, 1951; The Hill of Devi, 1953; Marianne Thornton: A Domestic Biography, 1797-1887, 1956; Commonplace Book, 1978; Selected Letters of E. M. Forster, 1983-1985 (2 volumes; Mary Lago and P. N. Furbank, editors); The Feminine Note in Literaturem 2001. Bibliography Beauman, Nicola. E. M. Forster: A Biography. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1994. In this biography devoted primarily to the first forty-five years of Forster’s life, when he was developing as a fiction writer, Beauman discusses the origins of Forster’s fictional themes in his family background and claims that his most successful years as a writer were also his unhappiest as a person due to his sexual repression and his conflicts over his homosexuality. Caporaletti, Silvana. “Science as Nightmare: ‘The Machine Stops’ by E. M. Forster.” Utopian Studies 8 (1997): 32-47. Discusses the dystopian theme in the story; claims the story denounces materialism and conformism imposed by rigid social conventions that repress diversity, spontaneity, and creativity. ____________. “The Thematization of Time in E. M. Forster’s ‘The Eternal Moment’ and Joyce’s ‘The Dead.’” Twentieth Century Literature 43 (Winter, 1997): 406-419. Discusses how the two stories are influenced by Henri Bergson’s dual concept of
412
Short Story Writers
time as sequential and psychological. Argues that most of the characters in the stories reflect the contrast between these two modes of time. Gardner, Philip, ed. E. M. Forster: The Critical Heritage. New York: Routledge, 1997. Critical essays on Forster’s works. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Iago, Mary. E. M. Forster: A Literary Life. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1995. Succinct study of Forster’s novels and work for the British Broadcasting Corporation. Helpful notes. McDowell, Frederick P. W. E. M. Forster. Rev. ed. Boston: Twayne, 1982. Brilliant, wellbalanced, and compendious overview of Forster’s life, times, career, work, and achievement. This book contains a useful chronology, a select bibliography, and an index. It also offers a concise and perceptive analysis of Forster’s short stories. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Forster: “The Celestial Omnibus” (vol. 1), and “The Other Side of the Hedge” and “The Road from Colonus” (vol. 6). Rapport, Nigel. The Prose and the Passion: Anthropology, Literature, and the Writing of E. M. Forster. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Provides excellent interpretation and criticism of Forster’s literary works. Seabury, Marcia Bundy. “Images of a Networked Society: E. M. Forster’s ‘The Machine Stops.’” Studies in Short Fiction 34 (Winter, 1997): 61-71. Discusses the story as a vision of the computer revolution. Examines interrelations between technology and religious thinking in the story; explores what happens to people when they spend much of their time connected to computer networks. Stone, Wilfred. The Cave and the Mountain: A Study of E. M. Forster. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1966. Well-researched and scholarly book. Contains a vast amount of useful information about Forster’s background, career, esthetics, and work. Includes a detailed and illuminating chapter on the short stories. Using psychological and Jungian approaches, Stone offers insightful and masterly critiques of Forster’s fiction. Supplemented by notes and a comprehensive index.
413
Mavis Gallant Born: Montreal, Quebec, Canada; August 11, 1922 Principal short fiction • The Other Paris, 1956; My Heart Is Broken: Eight Stories and a Short Novel, 1964 (pb. in England as An Unmarried Man’s Summer, 1965); The Pegnitz Junction: A Novella and Five Short Stories, 1973; The End of the World, and Other Stories, 1974; From the Fifteenth District: A Novella and Eight Short Stories, 1979; Home Truths: Selected Canadian Stories, 1981; Overhead in a Balloon, 1985; In Transit, 1988; Across the Bridge, 1993; The Moslem Wife, and Other Stories, 1994; The Collected Stories of Mavis Gallant, 1996; Paris Stories, 2002; Varieties of Exile: Stories, 2005. Other literary forms • A journalist and essayist as well as a writer of fiction, Mavis Gallant has chronicled various social and historical events, such as the case of Gabrielle Russier, a young high school teacher in Marseille, who was driven to suicide by persecution for having become romantically involved with one of her students. Paris Notebooks: Essays and Reviews (1986) is a collection of essays in which Gallant offers observations relating to her many years spent in France, scrutinizing French culture and life in general. Her accounts of the student revolt of 1968 are particularly riveting. In addition, Gallant wrote The War Brides (1978), a collection of biographical articles, and the play What Is to Be Done? (pr. 1982), a drama about two young women who idealize communism. Her essays, articles, and reviews have appeared regularly in The New Yorker, The New York Times Book Review, The New Republic, The New York Review of Books, and The Times Literary Supplement. Achievements • Mavis Gallant’s stature as a writer of short fiction is unassailable. The elegant simplicity of her pieces is an unchanging trait of her work and was in fact recognized in her first published piece, “Madeleine’s Birthday,” for which The New Yorker paid six hundred dollars in 1951. In 1981, Gallant was awarded Canada’s Governor-General’s Literary Award for fiction for Home Truths. Other awards include the Canadian Fiction Prize (1978), Officer of the Order of Canada (1981), and honorary doctorates from the University of Saint Anne, Nova Scotia (1984), York University (1984), the University of Western Canada (1990), Queen’s University (1992), University of Montreal (1995), and Birnap’s University (1995). She has also received the Canada-Australia Literary Prize (1985) and the Canadian Council Molson Prize for the Arts (1997). Biography • Born in Montreal in 1922, Mavis Gallant (née Mavis de Trafford Young), an only child, was placed in a Roman Catholic convent school at the age of four. She attended seventeen schools: Catholic schools in Montreal, Protestant ones in Ontario, as well as various boarding schools in the United States. After the death of her father, Gallant lived with her legal guardians in New York, a psychiatrist and his wife. At the age of eighteen, Gallant returned to Montreal. After a short time working for the National Film Board of Canada in Ottawa during the winter of 1943-1944, Gallant accepted a position as reporter with the Montreal Standard, which she left in 1950. In 1951, Gallant be-
414
Short Story Writers
TO VIEW IMAGE, PLEASE SEE PRINT EDITION OF THIS BOOK.
gan contributing short-fiction stories to The New Yorker. During the early 1950’s, she moved to Europe, living in London, Rome, and Madrid, before settling in Paris in the early 1960’s. It was through her travels and experiences in France, Italy, Austria, and Spain that she observed the fabric of diverse societies. During the initial years of her life in Europe, Gallant lived precariously from her writings, ultimately becoming an accomplished author, depicting loners, expatriates, and crumbling social structures. Gallant settled in Paris, working on a history of the renowned Dreyfus affair in addition to her work in fiction. Gallant settled in Paris, occasionally traveling to Canada, the United States, and England.
Analysis • The often somber tone of Mavis Gallant’s work is strengthened by the combination of acute lucidness and understated stylistic © Allison Harris richness. Gallant is a remarkable observer. She succeeds in creating worlds that are both familiar and foreign, appealing yet uninviting. Her mastery in the restrained use of language and in her incomparable narrative powers make her undeniably one of the world’s greatest fiction writers. “The Other Paris” • The title story of Mavis Gallant’s first collection strikes the pitch to which the others that follow it are tuned. Most of these stories are about young Americans in Europe just entering into marriage, uncertain about what they should feel, unsure of their roles, and unable to find appropriate models around them for the behavior that they think is expected of them. The young protagonists in the stories grope through their ambivalences, looking for guidance in others who seem more sure of themselves, or clutching written words from some absent sibling—advice recorded in a letter, or written down by themselves about appropriate responses to their present situation. In the other stories in which a parent is present, the other parent, usually ill or divorced, is absent, and the rules of conduct become equally tenuous because of that absence. The European stories are set in the early 1950’s, when the devastations of World War II are still being felt. Refugee figures haunt the fringes. “The Other Paris” refers to the romantic illusions generated by films about that city which Carol feels she is missing. She is about to be married to Howard Mitchell, with whom she works in an American government agency, and with whom she is not yet in love. She keeps remembering her college lectures on the subject to reassure
Gallant, Mavis
415
herself. Common interests and similar economic and religious backgrounds were what mattered. “The illusion of love was a blight imposed by the film industry, and almost entirely responsible for the high rate of divorce.” Carol waits expectantly for the appropriate emotions to follow the mutuality of their backgrounds: Their fathers are both attorneys, Protestants, and from the same social class. In Carol’s mind, the discovery of that mysterious “other Paris” is linked with the discovery of love. She believes the Parisians know a secret, “and if she spoke to the right person or opened the right door or turned down an unexpected street, the city would reveal itself and she would fall in love.” She tries all the typical tourist things, such as listening to carols at the Place Vendôme, but everything has been commercialized. Newsreel cameras and broadcast equipment spoil the atmosphere she seeks. Plastic mistletoe with “cheap tinsel” is tied to the street lamps. Odile, Howard’s secretary, invites her to a private concert. Excitedly Carol thinks that she has finally gained entrance into the aristocratic secrets that are hidden from foreigners. Instead of the elegant drawing room she had anticipated, it is an “ordinary, shabby theatre” on an obscure street, nearly empty except for a few of the violinist’s relatives. Odile is thin, dark, seldom smiles, and often sounds sarcastic because of her poor English. She is involved with Felix, pale, ill, hungry, and without papers, who sells things on the black market. He is twenty-one, she is more than thirty years old, and Carol finds the gap in their ages distasteful. They have no common interests, no mitigating mutual circumstances; yet, one night in Felix’s dark, cluttered room, she discovers that they love each other. The thought makes her ill. In that dusty slum, with revulsion, she discovers that, at last, she has “opened the right door, turned down the right street, glimpsed the vision.” On this paradox, that the sordid reality reveals the romantic illusion, the story closes with a time shift to the future in which Carol is telling how she met and married Howard in Paris and making it “sound romantic and interesting,” believing it as it had never been at all. “Autumn Day” • “Autumn Day” is another initiation story of a nineteen-year-old, Cissy, who follows her Army husband to Salzburg. She has a list of instructions: “Go for walks. Meet Army wives. Avoid people on farm.” She attributes her unhappiness, her failure to feel like a wife, to the fact that they have no home. They are boarding in a farmhouse from which she takes dutiful long walks under the lowering Salzburg skies, gray with impending snow. An American singer practices a new setting of the poem “Herbsttag” (“Autumn Day”), whose most haunting line, which the narrator feels had something to do with her, is “who does not yet have a home, will never have one.” She feels that the poet had understood her; it was exactly the life she was leading, going for lonely walks. She slides a note under the singer’s door, asking if they might meet. After a complicated day she returns to the farmhouse to find the singer had invited her to lunch and had returned to America. Walt, her bewildered husband, finds her crying. He tries, timidly, to console her by insisting that they “will be all right” when they get their own apartment. She wonders if her present mood is indeed temporary or whether their entire marriage will be like this. It is in depicting these border states of consciousness that Gallant excels. Her portraits of girls who are trying to become women without having internalized a strong role model to emulate are moving because the portrayal of their inner sense of being lost is augmented by the setting; it is externalized into the girls’ awareness of being foreigners alone in a strange country. The psychic territory has been projected outward into an alien land. Both Cissy and her friend Carol have heard music which they
416
Short Story Writers
feel contains some secret knowledge that can help them understand their feeling of having been somehow left out, excluded from a love they would like to feel. Both accommodate themselves to lives that are less than the songs promised they might be. “Autumn Day” closes with Cissy’s ritually repeating the magic formula, like an incantation, like a figure in a fairy tale casting a spell over her own anxiety, “We’ll be all right, we’ll be all right, we’ll be all right.” “Poor Franzi” • “Poor Franzi” is also set in Salzburg and in the same wavering space. The young American Elizabeth is engaged to the grandson Franzi of Baroness Ebendorf, an Austrian aristocrat, who dies in the course of the story. Because Franzi refuses to go to the funeral, Elizabeth feels obligated to attend. A party of American tourists serves as choric voices. They insinuate that the young Austrian has become engaged to the American girl simply to escape from the country. They gossip about his failure to visit the old woman in her last illness, his refusal to pay for the funeral, and his having burned her will. Her landlady, “out of helplessness and decency,” had arranged for the last rites, which she could ill afford, a peasant paying homage to a noble line. Elizabeth’s nearsightedness is a physical correlative of her failure to see her fiancé’s faults, which are obvious to everyone else. “Blind as a bat!” the other Americans mutter as she walks straight past them. She gazes at the edge of the horizon, but her myopia prevents her from distinguishing whether she is seeing clouds or mountains. She sees Franzi in this same suffused haze. Instead of the cynicism and selfishness his behavior so clearly outlines, there is a fuzzy aura blurred by her feeling of having to be protective of his great grief. Poor thing, he is all alone now; he must never suffer again. The soft shapes, “shifting and elusive,” which better eyes than hers saw as the jutting rocks of the Salzburg mountains, become an emblem of her emotional condition. The story closes on this ambiguous haze: “What will happen to me if I marry him? she wondered; and what would become of Franzi if she were to leave him?” The Collected Stories of Mavis Gallant • This anthology contains fifty-two stories that originally appeared in The New Yorker magazine. Gallant has divided her anthology into nine sections: thirty-five stories, with settings chronologically arranged between 1930 and 1990; five autobiographical stories with Linnet Muir, a young Canadian girl, as the main character; four about the Canadian Carette Sisters; four focused on Edouard, a Frenchman and his two “wives”; and four featuring Henri Grippes, a French “hack” writer and charlatan. In the introduction, Gallant says she gets her ideas for stories through imaginary flashes. She compares the process to looking at a snapshot. Then she begins by developing a unique character with a name, age, nationality, profession, voice and accent, family history, destination, personality quirks, secrets, ambitions, and attitudes toward love, money, religion. Next, she writes scenes between her characters with dialogue and develops a plot that is “entire but unreadable.” She says that revision takes her a long time; it is a “slow transformation from image to story.” The stories are written in a powerful and fluent style with precise details. Many have settings during and after World War II in Canada, France, and Germany, when people’s lives are in a state of flux. Gallant’s settings and characters are reproduced like filmed images, complete with background noise and dialogue. However, her extraordinary ability to get inside her characters’ minds provides ironic contrast
Gallant, Mavis
417
between external events and their fragmented thoughts and confused emotions. Typically, her main characters are rootless young women trapped by the past in an existential world, lonely, isolated, and uncertain of the direction their lives should take. Secondary characters often include neglected, love-starved children, surrounded by insensitive adults. “The Moslem Wife” • The title of this story does not refer to a North African setting or to the Islamic religion. It refers to the role of Muslim women, who traditionally submit to the domination of fathers and husbands. These women have great responsibility for the management of their homes and the well-being of their families. Most have limited contact with the outside world. Gallant compares the Muslim wife’s lifestyle to that of Netta Asher, an inexperienced young English girl, whose family ties and cultural roots have been severed by death and circumstance. Netta’s dying father provides for her future by signing a one-hundred-year lease on his resort hotel in southern France and marrying her to Jack, a philandering cousin. Thus, locked into her role as owner/manager of the hotel, Netta leads a confined life, while Jack enjoys much freedom. On the eve of Adolf Hitler’s European conquest, Jack goes on holiday to England and does not return until World War II is over. Meanwhile, Netta takes care of Jack’s temperamental mother and survives deprivation and the presence of Italian and German soldiers billeted at the hotel. Miserable and lonely, Netta longs to escape her “prison.” However, when Jack, the perpetual adolescent, returns, Netta, still dependent on his masculine charm, remains locked into her role as “The Moslem Wife.” “Across the Bridge” • “Across the Bridge” is a lighthearted initiation story, set in Paris in the 1950’s. It gives insight into postwar French families and their attempt to reestablish social classes and tradition. American teenagers, who enjoy considerable freedom to select their own love interests without parental involvement, will consider this story old-fashioned and foreign. However, ethnicity, religious background, and economic and social status are realistic factors that continue to influence a person’s selection of a mate. After much negotiation, teenage Sylvie Castelli’s parents arrange her marriage to Arnaud Pons, a quiet, unromantic young man. The Italian/French Castellis have a modest fortune, but the Pons family has an old and respected name. On a bridge en route to having wedding invitations printed, Sylvie confesses to her mother that she is in love with Bruno, a boy she met at the park. Her doting parents allow her to break her engagement to Arnaud, and Mr. Castelli contacts Bruno’s wealthy parents, who deny their son’s interest in Sylvie and humiliate the Castellis. Eventually, Sylvie “crosses the bridge” from romantic, adolescent dreams to realistic maturity and on her own, without parental involvement, selects Arnaud as her fiancé. The question of whether pragmatic considerations offset romantic ideals and physical attraction remains unanswered as Sylvie and Arnaud begin their new relationship. “The Doctor” • The Linnet Muir stories are fictionalized, coming-of-age memoirs based on Gallant’s own experiences as a member of a dysfunctional family. Biographical data confirms much, but not all, of the content of the stories. During her childhood, Gallant, like Linnet, observed her parents’ unhappy marriage. In “The Doctor” a precocious Linnet recalls the sterile and bewildering relationship between her parents, Charlotte and Angus Muir, and their eccentric friends, Mrs. Erskine and Dr.
418
Short Story Writers
Chauchard, Linnet’s pediatrician, who is treating her for a lung disease from which she recovers. After Gallant’s father’s untimely death, her mother placed her in a series of boarding schools and left her care and education to strangers. In her late teens, Gallant, like Linnet, attempted a reconciliation with her mother that failed. “In Youth Is Pleasure,” an ironic title because of somber events in the story, eighteen-year-old Linnet asserts her independence, breaks off an unhappy relationship with her mother, and returns to Montreal from New York. There, she discovers family secrets: that her father suffered from tuberculosis of the bone and committed suicide and that her mother ran off with a lover. Gallant became a successful journalist in Canada, an experience she considered boring, but one that sharpened her writing skills and techniques of observation. After selling her first short story, she left Canada and moved to France, where she hoped to establish new roots and become a successful writer. Similarly, in the story “Between Zero and One,” Linnet works at a boring government job surrounded by men who are either too old or disabled to serve in the army during World War II. At first they resent Linnet, but later accept her. When Mrs. Ireland, an outspoken feminist, arrives, dynamics in the office change. After looking at a graph of statistics, Linnet becomes more assertive. She discovers that what occurs during a person’s lifegraph “Between Zero and One” determines the future. Ruth Rosenberg With updates by Kenneth W. Meadwell and Martha E. Rhynes Other major works play: What Is to Be Done, pr. 1982. novels: Green Water, Green Sky, 1959; Its Image on the Mirror, 1964 (novella); A Fairly Good Time, 1970. nonfiction: The Affair of Gabrielle Russier, 1971; The War Brides, 1978; Paris Notebooks: Essays and Reviews, 1986. Bibliography Besner, Neil. The Light of Imagination: Mavis Gallant’s Fiction. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 1988. Extremely thorough analysis of Gallant’s fiction from The Other Paris to Overhead in a Balloon. Includes a biographical review as well as a useful critical bibliography. Clement, Lesley D. Learning to Look: A Visual Response to Mavis Gallant’s Fiction. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2000. This “visual” study of Gallant’s work analyzes her descriptive powers, which generally take priority over plot per se. Cote, Nicole, Peter Sabor, and Robert H. Jerry, eds. Varieties of Exile: New Essays on Mavis Gallant. New York: Peter Lang, 2003. Collection of essays on a range of topics, chiefly focusing on Gallant’s view of Canada from her self-imposed Parisian “exile” as well as her depiction of other types of exile—literal, figurative, and psychological—in her work. Dobozy, Tamas. “‘Designed Anarchy’ in Mavis Gallant’s The Moslem Wife, and Other Stories.” Canadian Literature, no. 158 (Autumn, 1998): 65-88. Discusses an anarchic aesthetic in the collection in which the stories challenge the impulse to create a master narrative and instead allow a variety of competing narratives that prevent a unified vision.
Gallant, Mavis
419
Hatch, Ronald. “Mavis Gallant.” In Canadian Writers Since 1960: First Series. Vol. 53 in Dictionary of Literary Biography, edited by W. H. New. Detroit: Gale Research, 1986. Thorough general introduction to Gallant’s fiction up to, and including, Home Truths. Supplemented by a bibliography of interviews and studies. Jewison, Don. “Speaking of Mirrors: Imagery and Narration in Two Novellas by Mavis Gallant.” Studies in Canadian Literature 10, nos. 1, 2 (1985): 94-109. A study of Green Water, Green Sky and Its Image on the Mirror. Focuses on the importance of mirrors from the perspective of imagery as well as of narration. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these nine short stories by Gallant: “Acceptance of Their Ways” and “Across the Bridge” (vol. 1); “Dédé” (vol. 2); “Going Ashore” (vol. 3); “The Ice Wagon Going Down the Street,” “Jorinda and Jorindel,” and “Lena” (vol. 4); “The Other Paris” (vol. 6); and “Speck’s Idea” (vol. 7). Schaub, Danielle. Mavis Gallant. New York: Twayne, 1998. Book-length discussion of Gallant’s fiction focusing on the relationship between thematic tensions and narrative devices. Argues that Gallant’s irony, stylistic devices, atmosphere, and structure create a tension that reflects the disconnectedness of her characters. Features chapters on Gallant’s major short-story collections from The Other Paris to Across the Bridge. Schenk, Leslie. “Celebrating Mavis Gallant.” World Literature Today 72 (Winter, 1998): 18-26. In this interview, Gallant discusses the short story as a genre, the extent to which her stories are biographical or autobiographical, and her relationship to contemporary France. She also discusses some of her stories, including “Across the Bridge.” Simmons, Diane. “Remittance Men: Exile and Identity in the Short Stories of Mavis Gallant.” In Canadian Women: Writing Fiction, edited by Mickey Pearlman. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1993. Discusses characters in a number of Gallant’s short stories who, suffering some early loss, are adrift and, by choosing to live abroad, are acting out their inner sense of exile.
420
Gabriel García Márquez Born: Aracataca, Colombia; March 6, 1928 Principal short fiction • Los funerales de la Mamá Grande, 1962 (Big Mama’s Funeral, stories included in No One Writes to the Colonel, and Other Stories, 1968); Isabel viendo llover en Macondo, 1967 (Monologue of Isabel Watching It Rain in Macondo, 1972); No One Writes to the Colonel, and Other Stories, 1968; Relato de un náufrago, 1970 (The Story of a Shipwrecked Sailor: Who Drifted on a Liferaft for Ten Days Without Food or Water, Was Proclaimed a National Hero, Kissed by Beauty Queens, Made Rich Through Publicity, and Then Spurned by the Government and Forgotten for All Time, 1986); El negro que hizo esperar a los ángeles, 1972; La increíble y triste historia de la Cándida Eréndira y de su abuela desalmada, 1972 (Innocent Eréndira, and Other Stories, 1978); Leaf Storm, and Other Stories, 1972; Ojos de perro azul, 1972; Todos los cuentos de Gabriel García Márquez, 1975 (Collected Stories, 1984); Collected Novellas (1990); Crónica de una muerte anunciada, 1981 (Chronicle of a Death Foretold, 1982); Doce cuentos peregrinos, 1992 (Strange Pilgrims: Twelve Stories, 1993). Other literary forms • Besides his short fiction, including short stories and novellas, Gabriel García Márquez’s fictional work includes full-length novels, such as his masterpiece and best-known novel, Cien años de soledad (1967; One Hundred Years of Solitude, 1970). Among his other novels are El amor en los tiempos del cólera (1985; Love in the Time of Cholera, 1988), El general en su laberinto (1989; The General in His Labyrinth, 1990), Del amor y otros demonios (1994; Of Love and Other Demons, 1995), and Memoria de mis putas tristes (2004; Memories of My Melancholy Whores (2005). During García Márquez’s long career as a journalist, he has written numerous articles, essays, and reports on a variety of topics, particularly relating to Latin American life and politics. He has published more than twenty volumes of nonfiction writings, most of which have not been translated into English. Among his translated nonfiction works are Noticia de un secuestro (1996; News of a Kidnapping, 1997), an account of the nefarious activities of drug lord Pablo Escobar in 1990, and Vivir para contarla (2002; Living to Tell the Tale, 2003), the first part of a projected three-volume autobiography. Achievements • In 1967, Gabriel García Márquez’s highly acclaimed novel One Hundred Years of Solitude appeared and was immediately recognized by critics as a masterpiece of fiction. As a work of high literary quality, this novel was unusual in that it also enjoyed tremendous popular success both in Latin America and in translation throughout the world. This work made García Márquez a major figure—perhaps the major figure—of contemporary Latin American literature. García Márquez’s work has been praised for bringing literary fiction back into contact with real life in all of its richness. His combination of realism and fantasy known as Magical Realism (realismo mágico) sets the stage for a full spectrum of Latin American characters. His stories focus on basic human concerns, and characters or incidents from one work are often integrated into others, if only with a passing reference.
García Márquez, Gabriel
421
García Márquez won the Colombian Association of Writers and Artists Award in 1954, for the story “Un dia despues del sabado.” The novel Cien años de soledad (One Hundred Years of Solitude) garnered the French Prix de Meilleur Livre Étranger, the Italian Chianciano Award, and the Venezuelan Rómulo Gallego Prize. Awarding him the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1982, the Nobel committee compared the breadth and quality of his work to that of such great writers as William Faulkner and Honoré de Balzac. In 1988 García Márquez won the Los Angeles Times Book Award, for El amor en los tiempos del cólera (1985; Love in the Time of Cholera, 1988). Biography • Gabriel García Márquez was born in Aracataca, a town near the Atlantic coast of Colombia, on March © The Nobel Foundation 6, 1928. His parents, Luisa Santiaga and Gabriel Eligio Márquez, sent him to live with his maternal grandparents for the first eight years of his life. He attended school in Barranquilla and Zipaquirá and went on to law studies at the Universidad Nacional in Bogotá. García Márquez’s first short story was published in 1947 in the Bogotá newspaper El Espectador. The literary editor praised the work, and in the next five years several more short fictions were also published. When his studies were interrupted by political violence in 1948, García Márquez transferred to the Universidad de Cartagena, but he never received his degree. Instead, he began his career as a journalist, writing for El Universal. He soon had a daily column and became friends with the writers and artists of the “Barranquilla group.” In 1950, he moved to Barranquilla and in 1954 to Bogotá, continuing his work as a journalist. During this time, he also published Leaf Storm, and Other Stories and received a prize from the Association of Artists and Writers of Bogotá. In 1955, he was sent to Geneva, Switzerland, as a European correspondent. When El Espectador was closed down in January, 1956, García Márquez spent a period of poverty in Paris, working on La mala hora (1962; In Evil Hour, 1979) and writing some freelance articles. In the summer of 1957, he traveled through Eastern Europe before moving to Caracas, Venezuela, as a journalist. With the prospect of a steady job, he married Mercedes Barcha in March, 1958. Interested since his university days in leftist causes, García Márquez worked for the Cuban news agency Prensa Latina in Bogotá after Fidel Castro came to power in 1959, then in Havana, Cuba, and later New York. After leaving the agency, he moved to Mexico City, where he worked as a journalist and screenwriter with Carlos Fuentes during the period 1961-1967. In 1962, In Evil Hour was published and won the Esso Literary Prize in Colombia. That same year, a collection of stories, Los funerales de la
422
Short Story Writers
Mamá Grande, also appeared. Then, in a spurt of creative energy, García Márquez spent eighteen months of continuous work to produce his best-selling novel One Hundred Years of Solitude, which won book prizes in Italy and France in 1969. In order to be able to write in peace after the tremendous success of this book, he moved to Barcelona, Spain, where he met Peruvian author Mario Vargas Llosa. In 1972, he won both the Rómulo Gallego Prize in Venezuela and the Neustadt International Prize for Literature. The money from both prizes was donated to political causes. García Márquez left Barcelona in 1975 and returned to Mexico. That same year, El otoño del patriarca (1975; The Autumn of the Patriarch, 1975), about the life of a Latin American dictator, was published, and in 1981, his Chronicle of a Death Foretold appeared. His news magazine, Alternativa, founded in 1974 in Bogotá to present opposing political views, folded in 1980, but García Márquez continued his activism by writing a weekly column for Hispanic newspapers and magazines. His Nobel Prize speech in 1982 made a strong statement about conditions in Latin America yet sounded the note of hope in the face of oppression. García Márquez continued his literary production after receiving the Nobel Prize, publishing, among other works, El general en su laberinto in 1989 (The General in His Labyrinth, 1990), based on the life of South American revolutionary leader Simón Bolívar. He also continued his political work, appearing at conferences with, variously, Colombian, Venezuelan, Mexican, and U.S. presidents discussing such issues as civil war and drug trafficking. In 1999 he fell ill in Bogotá, in one of his seven houses, and was diagnosed with cancer. Analysis • Gabriel García Márquez’s fiction is characterized by a thread of common themes, events, and characters that seem to link his work together into one multifaceted portrayal of the experiences of Latin American life. From the influences of his early childhood, when he learned from his grandmother how to tell the most fantastic stories in a matter-of-fact tone, to his later observations of the oppression and cruelties of politics, García Márquez captures the everyday life of the amazing people of coastal Colombia, with its Caribbean flavor, as well as the occasional resident of the highlands of Bogotá. He has an eye for the details of daily life mixed with humor and an attitude of acceptance and wonder. His characters experience the magic and joy of life and face the suffering of solitude and isolation but always with an innate dignity. García Márquez’s vision touches real life with its local attitudes and values, and in the process it also reveals a criticism of politics, the Church, and U.S. imperialism, as they contribute to the Latin American experience. García Márquez’s body of work portrays a complete reality breaking out of conventional bounds. Characters from one story regularly show up or are mentioned in another, while his complex mix of fantasy and reality reveals a consummate storyteller capable of bringing to his work the magic of his non-European world. His impact as a writer lies in the fact that although his work describes the Latin American experience of life, it also goes beyond to reveal a universal human experience. Ojos de perro azul • García Márquez’s earliest stories have a bizarre, almost surreal, tone, reminiscent of Franz Kafka. Collected in Ojos de perro azul, these stories represent an experimental phase of García Márquez’s development as a writer. They exemplify his new, or strange, realism, extending the reality of life into and beyond the experience of death. “La tercera resignación” (“The Third Resignation”), for example, deals with the thoughts and fears of a young man in his coffin. “Nabo, el negro que
García Márquez, Gabriel
423
hizo esperar a los ángeles” (“Nabo, the Black Man Who Made the Angels Wait”) tells of a man who is locked in a stable because he goes insane after being kicked in the head by a horse. In “Isabel viendo llover en Macondo” (“Monologue of Isabel Watching It Rain in Macondo”), published the same year as his first novella, Leaf Storm, García Márquez captures the atmosphere of a tropical storm through the eyes of his protagonist. Here, the world of Macondo, used in Leaf Storm as well and made world-famous in One Hundred Years of Solitude, is presented amid the suffocating oppressiveness of tropical weather. Here as later, nature itself is often a palpable force in the fiction of García Márquez—often exaggerated and overwhelming in order to reflect the reality of Latin American geography and the natural forces within it. The repetition underscores the monotony of the continuing deluge, and the theme of solitude is reflected in the imagery as well as in the personal relationship of Isabel and Martin: “The sky was a gray, jellyish substance that flapped its wings a hand away from our heads.” No One Writes to the Colonel • After demonstrating his ability to capture the tropical atmosphere, García Márquez shows himself capable of capturing a portrait in words with his well-structured novella No One Writes to the Colonel. The central character is a dignified man with a deep sense of honor who has been promised a military pension. Every Friday, he goes to the post office to wait for mail that never comes, and then he claims that he really was not expecting anything anyway. He is a patient man, resigned to eternal waiting and hope when there is no reason to expect that hope to be fulfilled. “For nearly sixty years—since the end of the last civil war—the colonel had done nothing else but wait. October was one of the few things which arrived.” His other hope is his rooster, which belonged to his son, who was executed for handing out subversive literature, but since he is too poor to feed the rooster, some townspeople work out an arrangement to provide food until after the big fight. The political background is introduced subtly as the story opens with the funeral of the first person to die of natural causes in this town for a long time. Violence, censorship, and political repression are a given, as is the pervasive poverty. The colonel continues passing out the literature in his son’s place and waiting for his pension. His dignity sustains him in the face of starvation. The dialogues between the colonel and his practical wife of many years are woven through the novella and reach a climax at the very end of the story. She presses him to sell the rooster, asking plaintively and persistently what they will eat: It had taken the colonel seventy-five years—the seventy-five years of his life, minute by minute—to reach this moment. He felt pure, explicit, invincible at the moment when he replied: “S—!” Los funerales de la Mamá Grande • The image of dignity is developed again in the first story of Los funerales de la Mamá Grande, entitled “La siesta del martes” (“Tuesday Siesta”) and also set in Macondo. Said to be García Márquez’s favorite, it tells of a woman and her young daughter who arrive by train in the stifling heat at siesta time. The woman asks the priest to be allowed to visit her son in the cemetery. The young man was shot for being a thief, but she proudly claims him as her own with quiet selfcontrol: “I told him never to steal anything that anyone needed to eat, and he minded me.”
424
Short Story Writers
The title story, “Los funerales de la Mamá Grande” (“Big Mama’s Funeral”), still set in Macondo, breaks the tone of the other stories into a technique of hyperbole, which García Márquez later used in One Hundred Years of Solitude to good effect. The opening sentence sets the tone: This is, for all the world’s unbelievers, the true account of Big Mama, absolute sovereign of the Kingdom of Macondo, who lived for ninety-two years, and died in the odor of sanctity one Tuesday last September, and whose funeral was attended by the Pope. The panorama and parody of the story mention Mama’s power and property in highsounding phrases, many from journalism. The pageantry is grandiose to the point of the absurd for this powerful individual, a prototype of the patriarch who appears in García Márquez’s later work. She is a legend and local “saint,” who seemed to the local people to be immortal; her death comes as a complete surprise. The story criticizes the manipulation of power but also skillfully satirizes the organized display or public show that eulogizes the holders of power with pomp and empty words. The story ends when the garbage men come and sweep up on the next day. Innocent Eréndira, and Other Stories • Fantastic elements characterize the collection entitled Innocent Eréndira, and Other Stories. Two of the stories, “Un señor muy viejo con unas alas enormes” (“A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings”) and “El ahogado más hermoso del mundo” (“The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World”), have adult figures who are like toys with which children, and other adults, can play. With the second story, García Márquez also tries a technique of shifting narrators and point of view to be used later in the novel The Autumn of the Patriarch. A political satire is the basis for another story, “Muerte constante más allá del amor” (“Death Constant Beyond Love”). The situation that forms the basis for the satire is also incorporated into the longer “Innocent Eréndira.” Geographically, in this collection García Márquez has moved inland to the barren landscape on the edge of the Guajiro desert. Here, he sets a type of folktale with an exploited granddaughter, a green-blooded monster of a grandmother, and a rescuing hero named Ulises. Combining myth, allegory, and references from other works, García Márquez weaves a story in which “the wind of her misfortune” determines the life of the extraordinarily passive Eréndira. Treated as a slave and a prostitute by her grandmother, Eréndira persuades Ulises to kill the evil woman—who turns out to be amazingly hard to kill. Throughout the story, García Márquez demonstrates the ability to report the most monstrous things in a matter-of-fact tone. Some critics have pointed out that the exaggeration that seems inherent in many of his tales may have its roots in the extraordinary events and stories that are commonplace in his Latin American world. Chronicle of a Death Foretold • In the novella Chronicle of a Death Foretold, García Márquez blends his experience in journalism with his mastery of technique to tell a story based on an actual event that took place in 1955 in Sucre, where he lived at the time. Using records and witness testimony, he unfolds his story on the lines of a detective story. The incident is based on the revenge taken by Angela Vicario’s brothers on their friend Santiago Nasar, who supposedly took Angela’s virginity (although some doubt is cast on this allegation). The story is pieced together as the townspeople offer their memories of what happened, along with excuses for not having
García Márquez, Gabriel
425
warned the victim. Tension builds as the reader knows the final outcome but not how or why it will occur. The use of dreams (ironically, Nasar’s mother is an interpreter of dreams), the feeling of fatalism, and submission to the code of honor, all of which form a part of this society’s attitudes, play a central role in the novella, as do García Márquez’s use of vision and foreshadowing. Although the basis for the story is a journalistic report of a murder, the actual writing captures the themes of love and death as well as the complex interplay of human emotions and motives in a balanced and poetic account, which reveals García Márquez’s skill as a writer. Strange Pilgrims • Strange Pilgrims picks up the Magical Realism of the earlier short stories, orchestrating twelve works written between 1976 and 1982 so that seven stories, having to do with the death-force of life, are followed by five stories which evoke the vitality of death. The opening story portrays a septuagenarian ex-president whose imminent death proves to be illusory; the seventh story portrays a septuagenarian woman, to whom the approach of death proves to be illusory. In both stories, dying is detailed as a form of intensified living. The second and sixth stories deal with the supernatural, one through a corpse that does not putrefy and the other through a haunted bedroom, and both include Italian settings. The third and fifth stories carry fairy-tale variations: a sleeping beauty who, unkissed, awakes of her own volition, and a lady in distress who, imprisoned in a madhouse, transcends her incarceration. In the fourth story, the umbilicus of the seven, a woman, whose life consists of dreaming, awakens from her dreams only through death. The concluding five stories present, first, two stories of murder—between which is a story of suicide—and two stories dealing with strange fatalities. In one, the wave function of light drowns persons without diving gear; in the other, an apparently negligible rose-thorn prick on a young bride’s ring fingertip inexorably causes her death. Susan L. Piepke With updates by Roy Arthur Swanson Other major works novels: La hojarasca, 1955 (novella; translated as Leaf Storm in Leaf Storm, and Other Stories, 1972); El coronel no tiene quien le escriba, 1961 (novella; No One Writes to the Colonel, 1968); La mala hora, 1962 (revised 1966; In Evil Hour, 1979); Cien años de soledad, 1967 (One Hundred Years of Solitude, 1970); El otoño del patriarca, 1975 (The Autumn of the Patriarch, 1975); El amor en los tiempos del cólera, 1985 (Love in the Time of Cholera, 1988); El general en su laberinto, 1989 (The General in His Labyrinth, 1990); Collected Novellas, 1990; Del amor y otros demonios, 1994 (Of Love and Other Demons, 1995); Memoria de mis putas tristes, 2004 (Memories of My Melancholy Whores, 2005). nonfiction: La novela en América Latina: Diálogo, 1968 (with Mario Vargas Llosa); Cuando era feliz e indocumentado, 1973; Chile, el golpe y los gringos, 1974; Crónicas y reportajes, 1976; Operación Carlota, 1977; De viaje por los países socialistas, 1978; Periodismo militante, 1978; Obra periodística, 1981-1999 (5 volumes; includes Textos costeños, 1981; Entre cachacos, 1982; De Europa y América, 1955-1960, 1983; Por la libre, 1974-1995, 1999; Notas de prensa, 1961-1984, 1999); El olor de la guayaba: Conversaciones con Plinio Apuleyo Mendoza, 1982 (The Fragrance of the Guava: Plinio Apuleyo Mendoza in Conversation with Gabriel García Márquez, 1983; also known as The Smell of Guava, 1984); La aventura de Miguel Littín, clandestino en Chile, 1986 (Clandestine in Chile: The Adventures of Miguel Littín, 1987); Noticia de un secuestro, 1996 (News of a Kidnapping,
426
Short Story Writers
1997); Por un país al alcance de los niños, 1996 (For the Sake of a Country Within Reach of the Children, 1998); Vivir para contarla, 2002 (Living to Tell the Tale, 2003). Bibliography Bell, Michael. Gabriel García Márquez: Solitude and Solidarity. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1993. This book explores García Márquez’s works from a number of different perspectives, ranging from comparative literary criticism to political and social critiques. Aso included are commentaries on García Márquez’s styles, including journalism and Magical Realism. Bell-Villada, Gene H. García Márquez: The Man and His Work. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1990. Includes biographical information on García Márquez, analyses of his major works, an index, and a bibliography. Bloom, Harold, ed. Gabriel García Márquez. New York: Chelsea House, 1989. Essays by eighteen critics, with an introduction by Bloom, on the fiction of García Márquez. Includes two studies of Chronicle of a Death Foretold, estimates of the influences of Kafka and Faulkner, analyses of narrative stylistics, and inquiries into the author’s types of realism. Byk, John. “From Fact to Fiction: Gabriel García Márquez and the Short Story.” MidAmerican Review 6 (1986): 111-116. Discusses the development of García Márquez’s short fiction from his early imitations of Kafka to his more successful experiments with Magical Realism. Gerlach, John. “The Logic of Wings: García Márquez, Todorov, and the Endless Resources of Fantasy.” In Bridges to Fantasy, edited by George E. Slusser, Eric S. Rabkin, and Robert Scholes. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1982. Argues that the point of view of “A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings” makes readers sympathize with the old man by establishing his superiority over the villagers. González, Nelly Sfeir de. Bibliographic Guide to Gabriel García Márquez, 1986-1992. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1994. Annotated bibliography that includes works by García Márquez, criticism and sources for him, and an index of audio and visual materials related to the author and his works. McMurray, George R., ed. Critical Essays on Gabriel García Márquez. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1987. Collection of book reviews, articles, and essays covering the full range of García Márquez’s fictional work. Very useful for an introduction to specific novels and collections of short stories. Also includes an introductory overview by the editor and an index. McNerney, Kathleen. Understanding Gabriel García Márquez. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1989. Overview addressed to students and nonacademic readers. After an introduction on Colombia and a brief biography, the five core chapters explain his works in depth. Chapters 1 through 3 discuss three novels, chapter 4 focuses on his short novels and stories, and chapter 5 reviews the role of journalism in his work. Includes a select, annotated bibliography of critical works and an index. McGuirk, Bernard, and Richard Cardwell, eds. Gabriel García Márquez: New Readings. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1987. Collection of twelve essays in English by different authors reflecting a variety of critical approaches and covering García Márquez’s major novels as well as a selection of his early fiction: No One Writes to the Colonel, Innocent Eréndira, and Chronicle of a Death Foretold. Also includes a translation of García Márquez’s Nobel address and a select bibliography.
García Márquez, Gabriel
427
Oberhelman, Harley D. Gabriel Gárcia Márquez: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1991. Argues that García Márquez’s short fiction is almost as important as his novels. Suggests that his stories have the same narrative pattern as his novels. Includes five interviews with García Márquez and essays by four critics. Solanet, Mariana. García Márquez for Beginners. New York: Writers and Readers, 2001. Part of the “Beginners” series of brief introductions to major writers and their works. Very basic, but a good starting point.
428
Hamlin Garland Born: West Salem, Wisconsin; September 14, 1860 Died: Hollywood, California; March 4, 1940 Principal short fiction • Main-Travelled Roads: Six Mississippi Valley Stories, 1891; Prairie Folks, 1893; Wayside Courtships, 1897; Other Main-Travelled Roads, 1910; They of the High Trails, 1916; The Book of the American Indian, 1923. Other literary forms • Hamlin Garland’s more than fifty published works include nearly every literary type—novels, biography, autobiography, essays, dramas, and poems. His best and most memorable novels are Rose of Dutcher’s Coolly (1895), similar in plot to the later Theodore Dreiser novel Sister Carrie (1900), and Boy Life on the Prairie (1899), chronicling the social history of Garland’s boyhood. One book of essays, Crumbling Idols (1894), presents his theory of realism (“veritism”). His autobiographical quartet, A Son of the Middle Border (1917), A Daughter of the Middle Border (1921), Trail-Makers of the Middle Border (1926), and Back-Trailers from the Middle Border (1928), recounts the story of his family. A Daughter of the Middle Border won the Pulitzer Prize for 1922. These books contain episodes that are treated in greater detail in some of his short stories. Achievements • Hamlin Garland’s work stands at an important transition point leading from Romanticism to realism, playing a role in ushering in the new literary trend. His best works are important for their depiction of a segment of society seldom delineated by other writers and for the relationship they show between literature and its socioeconomic environment. He used American themes—rather than Americanized European themes—and commonplace characters and incidents that turned the American writer away from his colonial complex, even away from the New England tradition of letters. His realism emancipated the American Midwest and West and the American farmer particularly from the romanticized conception that kept their story from being told before. Like Walt Whitman, Garland wanted writers to tell about life as they knew it and witnessed it. His realism foreshadowed the work of young writers such as Stephen Crane, E. W. Howe, and Harold Frederic. His naturalistic inclination, apparent in his belief that environment is crucial in shaping men’s lives, preceded the naturalistic writing of Crane, Frank Norris, and Dreiser. Aside from their value as literature, Garland’s best stories are a comprehensive record of an otherwise relatively unreported era of American social history. Much read in his prime, he enjoyed considerable popularity even while antagonizing, with his merciless word pictures, the very people about whom he wrote. Garland was awarded honorary degrees from the University of Wisconsin, the University of Southern California, Northwestern University, and Beloit College. In 1918, he was elected to the board of directors of the American Academy of Arts and Letters. He won the Pulitzer Prize for Biography and Autobiography in 1922. Biography • Of Scotch-Irish descent, Hannibal Hamlin Garland moved with his family from Wisconsin, where he was born in West Salem on September 14, 1860, to an
Garland, Hamlin
429
Iowa farm while still a child. Years spent on the farm made him seek escape through a career in oratory. To this end, he attended Cedar Valley Seminary, from which he graduated in 1881. He held a land claim in North Dakota for a year but mortgaged it for the chance to go East and enroll in Boston University. He succeeded in getting to Boston but was unable to attend the university; however, he embarked on a selfdirected program of reading in the holdings of the Boston Public Library. While in Boston, he began writing, his first attempts being lectures, then stories and books. It was around this time also that he joined the Anti-Poverty Society and became an active reformer. He read Henry George and embraced the Single Tax theory as a solution to some of the many contemporary social problems. Donald Pizer, along with many scholars, divides Garland’s career into three general phases: a period of political and social reform activity that coincides with his most memorable fiction set in the Middle West (1884-1895); a period of popular romance-writing in which his settings shifted from the Midwest to the Rocky Mountains (1896-1916); and a period of increasing political and social conservatism, during which he wrote his major autobiographical works (1917-1940). In 1899, Garland married Zulime Taft, and they became parents of daughters born in 1904 and 1907. His list of acquaintances and friends grew to include such literary figures as William Dean Howells, Eugene Field, Joseph Kirkland, Edward Eggleston, Frank Norris, Stephen Crane, George Bernard Shaw, and Rudyard Kipling. Garland lived the last years of his life in Hollywood, where he could be near his married daughter. In these later years, he turned more seriously to a lifelong fascination with the occult, producing two books on the subject. He died of cerebral hemorrhage in Hollywood on March 4, 1940. Analysis • Hamlin Garland’s most enduring short stories are those dealing with the Middle Border (the prairie lands of Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Nebraska, and the Dakotas). Collected for the most part in four books, they touch on nearly every subject of everyday life, from birth through youth, adulthood, courtship, and marriage, to death. They deal with the unromantic life of harassed generations on the farms and in the small towns of the prairie. Garland’s belief that an author must write of “what is” with an eye toward “what is to be” causes him alternately to describe, prophesy, suggest, and demand. Although often subtle in his approach, he is sometimes, when championing the cause of the farmer, more the reformer than the artist. Social protest is the single most recurrent theme in his work. “A Stopover at Tyre” and “Before the Low Green Door” show with some skill the unrelenting drudgery of the farmer’s life. “Under the Lion’s Paw” • “Under the Lion’s Paw,” Garland’s most anthologized story, is his most powerful statement of protest. In it, one man, Tim Haskins, like thousands of struggling farmers, is exploited by another man, representative of scores of other land speculators. Haskins, through months of arduous labor, pushing his own and his wife’s energies to their limits, has managed to make the dilapidated farm he is renting a productive place of which he can be proud. He has begun to feel confident that he can buy the farm and make a success of it. The owner, however, has taken note of the many physical improvements Haskins has made and recognizes its increased value. Thus, when Haskins talks to the owner about buying the place, he is astonished to learn that the purchase price has doubled and the rent has been increased. Haskins is “under the lion’s paw,” caught in untenable circumstances that
430
Short Story Writers
will hurt him no matter what he does. If he gives up the farm, as his angry indignation dictates, he will lose all the money and time he has invested in the farm’s improvements. If he buys, he will be under a heavy mortgage that could be foreclosed at any time. If he continues to rent at the higher fee, all his work will almost literally be for the owner’s benefit, not for himself and his family. The personally satisfying alternative of simply striking the man dead is wildly considered by Haskins momentarily until the thought of the repercussions to his family brings him to his senses, and he agrees to buy on the owner’s terms. The situation in itself is cruel. Garland clearly shows that it is even worse when one realizes that the exploitation of Haskins is only one of thousands of similar cases. “Lucretia Burns” • “Lucretia Burns,” another social protest story, is longer and has more action and a more complex major character than the similar “Before the Low Green Door.” Although some of its impact is diminished by its tiresome discussions on reform and by its weak denouement, Garland has created in Lucretia an unforgettable character who makes the story praiseworthy. Lucretia is a strong personality who had “never been handsome, even in her days of early childhood, and now she was middle-aged, distorted with work and childbearing, and looking faded and worn.” Her face is “a pitifully worn, almost tragic face—long, thin, sallow, holloweyed. The mouth had long since lost the power to shape itself into a kiss.” She has reached a point of desperation that calls for some kind of action: confrontation (with her husband), capitulation, or a mental breakdown. She chooses to renounce her soul-killing existence and operate on a level of bare subsistence, with no more struggling to “get ahead” or do what is expected. When the spirit of rebellion overcomes her, she simply gives in to her chronic weariness and refuses to do more than feed her children and the husband for whom she no longer cares. For a successful conclusion to this powerful indictment against the farm wife’s hopeless life, Garland had several choices. Unfortunately, he chose the ineffectual ending in which a dainty, young, idealistic schoolteacher persuades Lucretia to give life another try. The reader, having seen Lucretia’s determination to stop the drudgery in her life forever, is dissatisfied, knowing it would have taken a great deal more than a sympathetic stranger to convince Lucretia that her life was worth enduring. This kind of lapse is not Garland’s only flaw. Occasionally, he leads on his readers, telling them what they should think about a character. In “A Sociable at Dudleys,” for example, he describes the county bully: “No lizard Library of Congress revelled in the mud more hideously
Garland, Hamlin
431
than he. . . . His tongue dropped poison.” Garland apparently abhorred the “vileness of the bully’s whole life and thought.” Moreover, in most of the stories, one can tell the heroes from the villains by the Aryan features and Scottish names of the former and the dark, alien looks of the latter. His heroes are further categorized into two prevailing physical types: Either they are tall, imposing, strong, even powerful and handsome (Tim Haskins is an older, more worn version of this type) or they are stocky, sturdy, ambitious, cheerful, and optimistic counterparts of the young Hamlin Garland as he described himself in A Son of the Middle Border. Will Hannan of “A Branch Road” falls into this category. “A Branch Road” • “A Branch Road” develops another favorite theme of Garland— a romantic one in which boy meets girl; misunderstanding separates them; and then adversity reunites them. Although this plot is well-worn today, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. the reading public still liked it, and Garland occasionally catered to the larger reading public. “A Branch Road” is long enough for the author to develop character, setting, and plot in a more leisurely, less personal manner than in some of his other stories on the same theme, such as “A Day of Grace,” “A Sociable at Dudleys,” and “William Bacon’s Man.” In “A Branch Road,” young Will Hannan and Agnes Dingman have fallen in love. Will is ecstatic when he goes to the Dingman farm to help with the threshing, secure in his belief that she cares as much for him as he for her. Once at the farm, however, listening to the other men, both young and older, making casual, joking comments about Agnes’s prettiness and her attraction to most of the young swains in the county, Will becomes apprehensive that they will notice her obvious preference for him and make light of his deep private feelings. To prevent this, he repays her smiling attentions to him with curt words and an aloof manner. Agnes is hurt and confused by this, not understanding his masculine pride and sensitivity to ridicule. She responds by keeping up a light-hearted demeanor by smiling and talking to the other men, who are delighted, a response that makes Will rage inwardly. The day is a disaster for Will, but because he is to take Agnes to the fair in a few days, he is confident that he will be able then to set things right. On the morning of the day of the fair, however, the hopeful lover sets out early but promptly loses a wheel from his buggy, requiring several hours of delay for repair. By the time he gets to Agnes’s house, she has gone to the fair with Will’s rival, Ed Kinney. Will is so enraged by this turn of events that he cannot think. Dominated by his pride and jealous passion, blaming her and considering no alternatives, he leaves the county, heading West, without a word of farewell or explanation to Agnes. Seven years later he returns to find Agnes married to Ed Kinney, mother of a baby, daughter-in-law to two pestering old people, and distressingly old before her time. Will manages to speak privately to her and learns how he and she had misunderstood each other’s actions on that day long ago. He finds she had indeed loved him. He accepts that it is his fault her life is now so unhappy, that she is so abused and worn. In defiance of custom and morality, he persuades her to leave her husband and go away with him. They flee, taking her baby with them. In outline, this is the familiar melodrama of the villain triumphing over the fair maiden while the hero is away; then, just in time, the hero returns to rescue the heroine from the villain’s clutches. Actually, however, Garland avoids melodrama and even refrains from haranguing against farm drudgery. He avoids the weak denouement and chooses instead a rather radical solution to the problem: The
432
Short Story Writers
abduction of a wife and baby by another man was a daring ending to an American 1890’s plot. Yet Garland makes the justice of the action acceptable. Will Hannan, a very sensitive young man living among people who seem coarse and crude, is propelled through the story by strong, understandable emotions: love, pride, anger, fear of humiliation, remorse, pity, and guilt. Love causes the anger that creates the confusion in his relationship with Agnes. Pride and fear of humiliation drive him away from her. Remorse pursues him all the time he is away and is largely responsible for his return. Pity and guilt make him steal Agnes away from the life to which he feels he has condemned her. Many of Garland’s other stories do not have the emotional motivation of characters that “A Branch Road” has (in all fairness, most are not as long); nor are Garland’s characters generally as complex. He seems less concerned with probing a personality’s reaction to a situation than with describing the consequences of an act. The theme of the return of the native to his Middle Border home is used in several stories, among them “Up the Coolly,” “Mrs. Ripley’s Trip,” and “Among the Corn Rows.” “The Return of a Private” • Less pessimistic and tragic and more sentimental than these is “The Return of a Private,” an elaboration of Garland’s father’s return from the Civil War (1861-1865) as told in the first chapter of A Son of the Middle Border. The story describes the sadness which old war comrades feel as they go their separate ways home. It describes the stirring emotions which the returning soldier feels as he nears his home and sees familiar landmarks; when he first catches sight of the homestead; when he sees his nearly disbelieving wife and the children who hardly remember him. They are tender scenes, but Garland the artist cannot contain Garland the reformer, who reminds the reader of the futility facing the soldier, disabled physically from war-connected fever and ague and handicapped financially by the heavy mortgage on his farm. The soldier’s homecoming is shown as one tiny, bright moment in what has been and will continue to be an endless cycle of dullness and hardship. Garland obviously empathizes with the character and shows the homecoming as a sweet, loving time, but, as with so many of his stories, “The Return of a Private” is overcast with gloom. Garland’s stories show the ugly and the beautiful, the tragic with the humorous, the just with the unjust. He tries always to show the true, reporting the speech and dress of the people accurately, describing their homes and their work honestly. Truth, however, is not all that he seeks; he wants significance as well. To this end, his stories show the effects of farm drudgery on the men and women, of the ignorant practices of evangelists, of the thwarted ambitions of the youth because of circumstances beyond their control. Garland does not always suppress his reformer’s instincts, and so in some stories he offers solutions. In his best stories, however, he simply shows the injustice and moves the reader, by his skillful handling of details, to wish to take action. Although his stories are often bitter and depressing, there is a hopefulness and optimism in Garland that compels him to bring them to a comparatively happy ending. In his best stories, he does for the Middle Border what Mary E. Wilkins Freeman does for New England, brings the common people into rich relation with the reader and shows movingly the plights of the less fortunate among them, especially women. Jane L. Ball With updates by Terry Heller
Garland, Hamlin
433
Other major works play: Under the Wheel: A Modern Play in Six Scenes, pb. 1890. novels: A Little Norsk, 1892; A Member of the Third House, 1892; A Spoil of Office, 1892; Jason Edwards: An Average Man, 1892; Rose of Dutcher’s Coolly, 1895; The Spirit of Sweetwater, 1898 (reissued as Witch’s Gold, 1906); Boy Life on the Prairie, 1899; The Eagle’s Heart, 1900; Her Mountain Lover, 1901; The Captain of the Gray-Horse Troop, 1902; Hesper, 1903; The Light of the Star, 1904; The Tyranny of the Dark, 1905; Money Magic, 1907 (reissued as Mart Haney’s Mate, 1922); The Long Trail, 1907; The Moccasin Ranch, 1909; Cavanagh, Forest Ranger, 1910; Victor Ollnee’s Discipline, 1911; The Forester’s Daughter, 1914. nonfiction: Crumbling Idols: Twelve Essays on Art, 1894; Ulysses S. Grant: His Life and Character, 1898; Out-of-Door Americans, 1901; A Son of the Middle Border, 1917; A Daughter of the Middle Border, 1921; Trail-Makers of the Middle Border, 1926; The Westward March of American Settlement, 1927; Back-Trailers from the Middle Border, 1928; Roadside Meetings, 1930; Companions on the Trail: A Literary Chronicle, 1931; My Friendly Contemporaries: A Literary Log, 1932; Afternoon Neighbors, 1934; Joys of the Trail, 1935; Forty Years of Psychic Research: A Plain Narrative of Fact, 1936. poetry: Prairie Songs, 1893. Bibliography Garland, Hamlin. Selected Letters of Hamlin Garland. Edited by Keith Newlin and Joseph B. McCullough. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1998. The volume’s introduction serves as a good entry into Hamlin’s biography. Joseph, Philip. “Landed and Literary: Hamlin Garland, Sarah Orne Jewett, and the Production of Regional Literatures.” Studies in American Fiction 26 (Autumn, 1998): 147-170. Compares some of Garland’s early stories with the stories in Jewett’s Country of the Pointed Firs to examine ideological conflict within literary regionalism. Argues that while Garland’s support for social reform leads him to challenge some of the conventions of late nineteenth century realism, Jewett does not see class differences as a hindrance to U.S. destiny. McCullough, Joseph. Hamlin Garland. Boston: Twayne, 1978. This study follows Garland through his literary career, dividing it into phases, with major attention to the first phase of his reform activities and the midwestern stories. A primary bibliography and a select, annotated secondary bibliography are included. Martin, Quentin E. “Hamlin Garland’s ‘The Return of a Private’ and ‘Under the Lion’s Paw’ and the Monopoly of Money in Post-Civil War America.” American Literary Realism 29 (Fall, 1996): 62-77. Discusses how Garland made money and power the central features in his two stories; discusses the connection between the stories and the financial system of Gilded Age America in the 1890’s. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these three short stories by Garland: “Mrs. Ripley’s Trip” (vol. 5), “The Return of a Private” (vol. 6), and “Under the Lion’s Paw” (vol. 8). Nagel, James, ed. Critical Essays on Hamlin Garland. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1982. Nagel’s introduction surveys the critical responses to Garland’s work. This volume is especially rich in reviews of Garland’s books, and it also includes twenty-six biographical and critical essays.
434
Short Story Writers
Newlin, Keith. “Melodramatist of the Middle Border: Hamlin Garland’s Early Work Reconsidered.” Studies in American Fiction 21 (Autumn, 1993): 153-169. Discusses Garland’s development of a dramatic method to express the privation of the Middle Border; argues that he was torn between his admiration for the universal truths of melodrama and his realization that melodrama was limited in its realistic presentation of life. ____________, ed. Hamlin Garland: A Bibliography, with a Checklist of Unpublished Letters. Troy, N.Y.: Whitston, 1998. Basically a primary bibliography, with one section listing articles that addressed Garland extensively. The introduction surveys the availability of primary and secondary sources. Newlin includes a chronology and title index. Silet, Charles. Henry Blake Fuller and Hamlin Garland: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1977. This volume contains a comprehensive annotated guide to writing about Garland through 1975. For information about scholarly writing on Garland after 1975, see American Literary Scholarship: An Annual. Silet, Charles, Robert Welch, and Richard Boudreau, eds. The Critical Reception of Hamlin Garland, 1891-1978. Troy, N.Y.: Whitston, 1985. This illustrated volume contains thirty-three essays that illustrate the development of Garland’s literary reputation from 1891 to 1978. The introduction emphasizes the difficulty critics have had trying to determine the quality of Garland’s art.
435
Nikolai Gogol Born: Sorochintsy, Ukraine, Russian Empire (now in Ukraine); March 31, 1809 Died: Moscow, Russia; March 4, 1852 Principal short fiction • Vechera na khutore bliz Dikanki, vol. 1, 1831, vol. 2, 1832 (Evenings on a Farm Near Dikanka, 1926); Arabeski, 1835 (Arabesques, 1982); Mirgorod, 1835 (English translation, 1928). Other literary forms • Nikolai Gogol established his reputation on his remarkable short stories, but he is often better known in the West for his play Revizor (pr., pb. 1836; The Inspector General, 1890) and for the first part of his novel Myortvye dushi (1842; Dead Souls, 1887). Still the subject of much debate and criticism, his Vybrannye mesta iz perepiski s druzyami (1847; Selected Passages from Correspondence with Friends, 1969) represents a range from literary criticism to tendentious and presumptuous evaluation of Russia as seen from abroad. Achievements • In Russian literature of both the nineteenth and the twentieth centuries, it is impossible to overstate the importance of Nikolai Gogol as an innovator in style and subject matter. He created a great and enduring art form composed of the manners of petty officials, small landowners, and the fantastic and all-too-real people who inhabit the three worlds that he describes: the Ukraine, St. Petersburg, and the Russian heartland. Outside Russia, his influence can be detected most noticeably in Franz Kafka’s Die Verwandlung (1915; The Metamorphosis, 1936), which centers on a conceit not unlike Nikolai Gogol’s hapless titular councillor in Gogol’s “Nos” (“The Nose”). Inside Russia, Fyodor Dostoevski is reputed to have begun the saying that “we all came from under Gogol’s ‘Overcoat,’” meaning that Gogol’s stories originated the themes, social and spiritual anguish, and other literary preoccupations of the rest of Russian literature. Biography • Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol was born in the Ukraine on March 31, 1809, to a Ukrainian landowner, Vasily Afanasievich Gogol-Yanovsky, and his young wife, Mariya Ivanovna. Vasily Afanasievich wrote plays in Ukrainian and sponsored artistic evenings at his home. Nikolai would write almost nothing in Ukrainian throughout his life. On his father’s estate, Nikolai would absorb the manner and, significantly, the pace of provincial life, which would flavor his works from his early stories through Dead Souls. At school and later in the Gymnasium, Nikolai remained something of a loner. He participated in activities, especially in drama performances, where he is said to have excelled. His classmates called him “the mysterious dwarf,” though, for his predilection to aloofness and his unassuming stature. Gogol’s first work, Hans Kuechelgarten (1829), which he published at his own expense, was received so poorly that he bought all the unsold copies, burned them, and never wrote in verse again. He fled the country (in what was to become a characteristic retreat) and took refuge in Germany for several weeks. When he returned,
436
Short Story Writers
he occupied a minor post in the civil service in St. Petersburg and began writing the stories that would begin to appear in 1831 and subsequently make him famous. His first collection of stories, Evenings on a Farm Near Dikanka, met with great critical and popular acclaim and set the stage for the series of successes that his later stories were to have. In 1836, however, his play The Inspector General premiered, was produced most outlandishly in Gogol’s mind, and created a minor scandal. Although this initial reaction was reversed and, through the intercession of the czar himself, the play was to continue its run, Gogol was nevertheless mortified at the antagLibrary of Congress onism that he had aroused in the spectators. He again left the country, only this time—with the exception of two rather short trips back to Russia— forever. Gogol’s last and most enduring works, “Shinel” (“The Overcoat”) and Dead Souls, were thus written abroad. The irony of the profound resonance that his writing enjoyed at home was not lost on him. He began to doubt his ability to convey the “truth” to the Russians from such a distance and began to search for artistic inspiration. His self-doubt gave birth to his last literary production, Selected Passages from Correspondence with Friends. This product of his doubt was met with indignation and even anger in Russia. Vissarion Belinsky wrote his famous letter excoriating Gogol for his “fantastic book” and for writing from his “beautiful distance.” Had Gogol forgotten the misery of Russia, its serfdom and servility, its “tartar” censorship, its totalitarian clout? Belinsky believed that the public was justified in its censure of this work; the public has the right to expect more from literature. Gogol spent the last six years of his life fighting depression and artistic barrenness, trying to reach the “truth” in the second part of Dead Souls. However, he failed to finish this work and, shortly before his death, burned what he had written. Physically ill, spiritually empty, emotionally depleted, he died in pain in Moscow on March 4, 1852. Analysis • Nikolai Gogol combines the consummate stylist with the innocent spectator, flourishes and flounces with pure human emotion, naturalism with delicate sensitivity. He bridges the period between Romanticism and realism in Russian literature. He captures the “real” against the background of the imagined and, in the estimation of at least one critic, the surreal. Frequently, the supernatural or some confounding coincidence plays a major role in his works. His heroes of the “little man” variety imprinted the most profound impression on his readers and critics alike. These petty clerks, all socially dysfunctional in some major respect, nevertheless
Gogol, Nikolai
437
explore the great depth of the human soul and exhibit certain personality traits characteristic of the greatest heroes in literature. Gogol focuses his major creative occupation on the manners of his characters; his creative energy is nowhere more apparent than in the “mannerizing” in which he describes and characterizes. His genius does not dwell in philosophical dialogues, allegory, or involved interior monologue as do the realist novels of the latter half of the century. Nor does he engender his heroes with abandon and ennui, as do his near contemporaries Alexander Pushkin and Mikhail Lermontov. The depth of his psychological portraiture and the sweep of his romantic apostrophes, however, remain powerful and fascinating. In his plays, speech is swept aside from its characteristic place in the foreground; the dramatic foreground is given over to the manner or mannerisms of the characters. The actions literally speak louder than words. The social satire, deeply embedded in the manners of the characters, unfolds without special machinations and with few unnatural speech acts, such as asides. It is a tribute to Gogol’s skill that his characters do not necessarily become superficial or unidimensional as a result but are imbued with certain attributes that display a wide range of human passion, particularly human dignity and the cognizance of the injustices created in social stratification. One of Gogol’s favored narrative devices can be called the chatty narrator. This narrator, seemingly prolix and sometimes random, will supply the reader with most of the information that will ever be revealed about a character. In a typical passage, the reader will encounter a character who might say something utterly commonplace such as: “I won’t have coffee today, Praskovia Osipovna, instead I will take some hot bread with onions.” The character says little that can be used to describe himself. The reader’s attention, however, is then directed to the information supplied by the narrator: “Actually, Ivan Yakovlevich would have liked to take both, but he knew it was utterly impossible to ask for two things at the same time since Praskovia Osipovna greatly disliked such whims.” Thus Ivan Yakovlevich is described by his manners—he speaks to his wife in a formal tone that relates very little information to the reader— but the narrator, in his chatty, nosy fashion reveals much about this individual and describes Ivan’s wife, his subordinate position at home, and his struggle for dignity within this relationship at the same time. Thus, from a seeming excess of information, the reader becomes familiar with a character who might otherwise remain nondescript. Gogol’s narratives abound in descriptions, and these tend to be humorous. Many times, humor is created by the device of metonymy, whereby a part stands for the whole. Thus, women become “slender waists” and seem so light that one fears that they will float away, and men are mustaches of various colors, according to their rank. Another humorous effect might be created by the chatty narrator’s remark about some individual in a very unfavorable light. This information that he, for some reason, knows in regard to the character informs the reader’s opinion of that character and often lends either a humorous or a pathetic tone to his or her person. Also humorous is the effect created through realized metaphors, another favorite technique of Gogol. Thus, instead of “he ate like a pig,” the person is actually transformed into a pig with all the attributes of a perfect pig, at least temporarily. In general, Gogol’s works abound with descriptions packed with colors, similes, and wayward characterizations by his narrator or actors. Gogol’s works fall roughly into three categories, which in turn correspond approximately to three different periods in his creative life. The first period is repre-
438
Short Story Writers
sented solely by short stories that exhibit lush local color from the Ukraine and Gogol’s own mixing of devils and simple folk. Seven of the eight stories from the collection Evenings on a Farm Near Dikanka, which appeared in 1831 (with the second part following in 1832), belong in this category, as well as the stories in Mirgorod, first published in 1835. The second major period of Gogol’s literary life features works either centered on a locus in the imperial center of Russia, St. Petersburg itself, or surrounding the bureaucrats and petty officials ubiquitous in the provinces of the empire. This period stretches roughly from 1835 to 1842 and includes the short stories “Nevsky Prospekti” (“Nevsky Prospect”), “Zapiski sumasshedshego” (“The Diary of a Madman”), “The Overcoat,” “The Nose,” the play The Inspector General, and the novel Dead Souls. The short story “Portret” (“The Portrait”), although definitely a product of this period, is singular for its strong echoes of the devil tales in the early period. The last period can claim only one published work, Selected Passages from Correspondence with Friends, and is typically interpreted as a reversal in Gogol’s creative development. If the analyst, however, can keep in mind Gogol’s rather fanatic attachment to his artistic life as a devotional to God, then perhaps this otherwise unexplainable curve in his creative evolution might seem more understandable. The two volumes of Evenings on a Farm Near Dikanka contain eight stories. However atypical they were to become in terms of setting and subject matter, these tales of the Ukraine, with various elements of the supernatural adding terror, exhibit many of the qualities found in the mature writer of the second period. They are magical and engaging, heroic and base, simply enjoyable to read and quite poignant. “A May Night” • An excellent example of these tales is “Mayskaya Noch: Ili, utoplennitsa” (“A May Night: Or, The Drowned Maiden”). The plot is a simple love story in which the lovers are not allowed to wed because of the objection of the man’s father. The seeming simplicity, however, is overwhelmed by acts of Satan, witches, and rusalki. (In folk belief, rusalki are female suicides who endlessly inhabit the watery depths of ponds, tempting men and often causing their deaths.) When the antics of Ukrainian Cossack youths do not by themselves bring the matter to resolution, the rusalka puts a letter into the young man’s hand, which secures for him his marriage. The characters are depicted in ways highly reminiscent of the oral folktales. Levko, the hero, sings to his beloved to come out of her house. He speaks of his “brighteyed beauty,” her “little white hands,” and her “fair little face.” All these figures of speech are fixed epithets common in folklore. He promises to protect her from detection—“I will cover you with my jacket, wrap my sash around you, or hide you in my arms—and no one will see us,”—forfending the possible intrusion three ways. Likewise, he promises to protect her from any cold—“I’ll press you warmer to my heart, I’ll warm you with my kisses, I’ll put my cap over your little white feet”— that is, a threefold protection. The reinforcement of images in threes is also quite common in folklore. Thus, clearly, Gogol is invoking folklore in his artistic works. Nevertheless, there are hints of the mature Gogol in the landscape descriptions. Even the intervention of the supernatural to produce, in this case, the successful outcome of the story belongs to the second period as well as to the first. “Ivan Fyodorovich Shponka and His Aunt” • One story, in retrospect, however, stands out clearly from the others. “Ivan Fyodorovich Shpon’ka i ego tetushka”
Gogol, Nikolai
439
(“Ivan Fyodorovich Shponka and His Aunt”) certainly presages the later works that will come to be regarded as Gogol’s most characteristic. Set in the Ukraine, the story begins with an elaborate frame involving the following: The original storyteller of the tale wrote the story entirely and gave it to the narrator (for reasons that are not explained), but the narrator’s wife later used the paper to wrap her pies, so the end of the story was unfortunately lost. Readers are assured, however, that should they desire, they may contact the original storyteller, who still lives in that village and who will certainly oblige in sharing the ending. There are many details in this frame alone that are very typical of the mature Gogol. First, the narrator does not take responsibility for the story—that is, that it is left unfinished; the abrupt end is presented as something over which he has no control. Second, the woman is the undoing of the man, although, in this case, the undoing is caused by her stupidity (she is illiterate) and not by an inherent evil. Moreover, the narrator could have rectified the situation himself, but, seemingly, he was fated to forget to ask the storyteller for another copy of the ending. Most of all, the story in the frame abounds with chatty, seemingly irrelevant details that serve to characterize the narrator, his wife, and the storyteller but that, ultimately, motivate the plot and occasion the sometimes precipitous changes in the course of the narrative. The motifs described above reappear in forms both changed and unchanged throughout Gogol’s work. A woman will appear in many guises in three of the four stories in Mirgorod. In “Taras Bulba,” a long story with the color and force of an epic, a Polish beauty causes the son, Andrei, to defect to the enemy. Later, the traitor will be murdered by his father’s own hands, described in the father’s own words as a “vile dog.” “Viy” • In another story from this collection, “Viy,” a young student, Khoma Brut, meets an old woman on his way home on vacation. When he stays for the night in her barn, she comes after him with outstretched arms. Khoma tries to avoid her three different ways, but she persists and, to his amazement, he loses the use of his arms and legs. The old woman turns out to be a witch who wickedly torments and then rides on the back of the young philosopher. Remembering some exorcisms, however, he renders her harmless and, in fact, exchanges places with her, now riding on her back. Khoma makes an incredible trek in this fashion until she falls in a faint. Now, watching her prone form, he is amazed to find not a witch or an old woman but a fair young maiden. Khoma races off, making it all the way to Kiev, but is called back to watch over her corpse for three nights, which was the last request of the dying maiden. During the third night, he is overcome by the supernatural devil, Viy, who emanates from the dead woman and thus brings his own doom. “The Tale of How Ivan Ivanovich Quarreled with Ivan Nikiforovich” • This tale revolves around the motif of the evil woman, although almost imperceptibly. Here, it is a “stupid” woman who sets out the gun while cleaning the house, which causes Ivan Ivanovich to envy this possession of his neighbor Ivan Nikiforovich. This seemingly insignificant act is the very act that causes an ensuing argument and that in turn builds into a lasting enmity between the former friends and then lasts in the courts for a decade. In Russia, this story is often invoked when people quarrel over imagined improprieties or insignificant trifles.
440
Short Story Writers
“Nevsky Prospect” • In Arabesques, the two most famous stories, “Nevsky Prospect” and “The Diary of a Madman,” similarly feature the demonic power of women over men. “Nevsky Prospect” indeed centers on this “demonic” nature of women. Two tales are told, one of the “sensitive young man,” the artist Piskarev, and the other of a rather older, down-to-earth lieutenant named Pirogov. The artist, perhaps fooled by the falling darkness, is stunned by the dazzling beauty of a woman walking by on Nevsky Prospect, a main avenue in St. Petersburg. At the same moment, Pirogov notices and blindly takes off after a blond woman, “convinced that no beauty could resist him.” Piskarev, almost overwhelmed at his own audacity, meekly follows his beauty to her “home,” only to find out that she is, indeed, a prostitute. This development soon becomes the undoing of the poor artist as he falls into daytime and nighttime dreaming in a vain attempt to rescue his former exalted vision and save her image from the reality of her vile lifestyle. He takes to opium and, finally emboldened, decides on the desperate act of proposing marriage to her. When she rebuffs him, he goes mad and takes his own life. Pirogov, on the other hand, for all of his selfconfidence and experience, fares only slightly better after following his blond beauty home—to her husband. He blindly but cunningly continues his pursuit of her, only to end up being humiliated and physically abused. Indignant, he sets out to put his case before the court, but, somehow, after eating a little and spending some time rather pleasantly, he becomes diverted and seemingly forgets the whole thing. The narrator then closes the story with the admonition not to trust Nevsky Prospect, since nothing is as it seems, especially not the ladies. “The Diary of a Madman” • “The Diary of a Madman” appears to be the personal journal of Popryshchin, whose name sounds very much like “pimple.” The story is written as a series of entries with the chronology becoming entirely skewed at the end in accordance with the degree of dementia within the protagonist. The appearance of Popryshchin, the poor government clerk, marks the introduction of a new incarnation of the meek Shponkin type who will populate many of Gogol’s works thereafter and enter the world of Russian literature as a prototype for many writers, notably Dostoevski. Popryshchin, a rather older, undistinguished man, adores the director’s daughter but recognizes that pursuing her is useless. Moreover, he sees that his infatuation for her will be his doom: “Dear God, I’m a goner, completely lost!” Virtually at the same moment that he admits his futile position, his attention is drawn to the thin voice of Madgie, the young lady’s dog, who is speaking to Fido. This rather fantastic conversation is centered on the letter that poor Fido seemingly never received from Madgie. Popryshchin’s delusions continue to build up, with him even reading the canine correspondence. It is actually through Madgie’s letters that Popryshchin learns of the young lady’s love for, and engagement to, a handsome young chamberlain. Moreover, Popryshchin finds the young man’s description unflattering. The sentence, “Sophie always laughs at him,” becomes the crowning blow to his sanity. Shortly thereafter he goes mad, imagining himself to be the king of Spain. He is committed to Spain, more accurately, to a mental hospital, where he is constantly tormented. The pathos of the “little man” is palpable, conveyed through the evocation of a beautiful image—a troika coming to fly to him and rescue him—juxtaposed to the hateful attendants dousing him repeatedly with cold water. “The Overcoat” • Another “little man” follows closely in Popryshchin’s footsteps. In “The Overcoat,” Akaky Akakievich, whose humorous name is a reminder of fecal
Gogol, Nikolai
441
matter (kaka), represents such a meek and orderly person that he can perform only one duty: copying papers. This duty he discharges perfectly and with great pleasure, sometimes so much so that he occasionally brings the document home and, in his spare time, copies it again. Akaky Akakievich lives in St. Petersburg, victim of almost unimaginable poverty with barely enough means to keep himself alive. It was, indeed, a terrible day when he could no longer persuade his tailor to have his overcoat remade; he would have to buy a new one. The physical privations that were necessitated by this desperate position are reminiscent of saintly asceticism. However, Akaky begins to sublimate his anguish and dreams of the great overcoat as though of a wife. With the mention of the word “wife,” the reader who is accustomed to Gogol might immediately suspect the potential danger of this coat, since women in Gogol’s fiction are almost always the undoing of a man. True to form, after withstanding all the hardships, enduring all the misgivings and new sensations, Akaky wears the new coat only once before he is mugged and the coat stolen from him. Dazed and exposed in the cold of St. Petersburg, he musters the courage to petition a “Person of Consequence” who dismisses him pompously. Akaky then falls into a fever from which he will not emerge alive. The tale, however, takes on a fantastic ending. Akaky comes back from the dead, intimidates and robs the Person of Consequence of his overcoat, and then, apparently satisfied, leaves the scene forever. “The Nose” • The supernatural revenge makes “The Overcoat” quite singular in Gogol’s work. The fantastic element, however, appears again in another story of the same period, “The Nose.” A barber, Ivan Yakovlevich, takes a roll for breakfast and finds, much to his alarm, a human nose in it, and he recognizes the nose as that of the Collegiate Assessor Kovalyov. Ivan Yakovlevich tries to rid himself of the nose. Meanwhile, its erstwhile owner wakes up to find a completely smooth area where his nose and incipient pimple had been the previous evening. He sets out on foot with the empty spot concealed by a handkerchief, only to witness his own former nose walking about freely, moreover in the uniform of a civil councillor—that is, a higher-ranking individual than Kovalyov himself. He accosts the nose very deferentially, but the nose claims to be an independent individual and not part of Kovalyov at all. In desperation, he sets out for the police department but, thinking better of it, decides to place an advertisement in the local newspaper. There, the clerk, thinking about it, decides against publishing such an advertisement to avoid potential scandals for the paper. Luckily for Kovalyov, the nose is returned to him by a police officer, but to his horror, it will not stick to his face. Then, as absurdly as the story began, it ends. Kovalyov wakes up with the nose back in its former place, goes to Ivan Yakovlevich and has a shave (the barber now not touching the olfactory organ), and it is as though nothing happened. Many of Gogol’s characters have penetrated into everyday Russian speech. If someone works hard at a brainless job, he is called an “Akaky Akakievich,” for example, an attestation how well the writer created a type of Russian “little man” who, however uncreative, still captures the hearts and alliances of readers. There is something real about these absurd, impossible characters, something in their unidimensionality that transcends their locus and becomes universal. Gogol, while embroidering in highly ornate circumlocution, directly touches the wellspring of humanity in even the lowliest, most unattractive character. In his descriptions, there are simultaneously resonances of slapstick humor and the depths of human misery and social injustice.
442
Short Story Writers
Gogol left quite an imprint on the course of Russian literature. Very few subsequent writers will produce anything that does not at all reverberate the Gogolian legacy. Even in the twentieth century, writers incorporate his artistic ideas or emulate his style to a degree. Christine Tomei Other major works plays: Vladimir tretey stepeni, wr. 1832, pb. 1842; Zhenit’ba, wr. 1835, pr., pb. 1842 (Marriage: A Quite Incredible Incident, 1926); Revizor, pr., pb. 1836 (The Inspector General, 1890); Utro delovogo cheloveka, pb. 1836, pr. 1871 (revision of Vladimir tretey stepeni; An Official’s Morning, 1926); Igroki, pb. 1842, pr. 1843 (The Gamblers, 1926); Lakeyskaya, pb. 1842, pr. 1863 (revision of Vladimir tretey stepeni; The Servants’ Hall, 1926); Otryvok, pb. 1842, pr. 1860 (revision of Vladimir tretey stepeni; A Fragment, 1926); Tyazhba, pb. 1842, pr. 1844 (revision of Vladimir tretey stepeni; The Lawsuit, 1926); The Government Inspector, and Other Plays, pb. 1926. novels: Myortvye dushi, part 1, 1842, part 2, 1855 (Dead Souls, 1887); Taras Bulba, 1842 (revision of his 1835 short story; English translation, 1886). miscellaneous: The Collected Works, 1922-1927 (6 volumes); Polnoe sobranie sochinenii, 1940-1952 (14 volumes); The Collected Tales and Plays of Nikolai Gogol, 1964. nonfiction: Vybrannye mesta iz perepiski s druzyami, 1847 (Selected Passages from Correspondence with Friends, 1969); Letters of Nikolai Gogol, 1967. poetry: Hanz Kuechelgarten, 1829. Bibliography Fanger, Donald L. The Creation of Nikolai Gogol. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1979. Fanger presses deeply into the background material and includes in his purview works both published and unpublished, in his effort to reveal the genius of Gogol’s creative power. This book is worthwhile in many respects, particularly for the wealth of details about Gogol’s life and milieu. Includes twenty-eight pages of notes and an index. Fusso, Susanne, and Priscilla Meyer, eds. Essays on Gogol: Logos and the Russian Word. Evanston, Ill.: Northwestern University Press, 1992. Collection of essays on Gogol from a conference at Wesleyan University. Bibliography and index. Hart, Pierre R. “Narrative Oscillation in Gogol’s ‘Nevsky Prospect.’” Studies in Short Fiction 31 (Fall, 1994): 639-645. Argues that the story is a commentary on the author’s development of strategies to deal with reality; discusses the urban scene in the story, suggesting that the city forces the protagonist into a final defensive position. Karlinsky, Simon. The Sexual Labyrinth of Nikolai Gogol. 1976. Reprint. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992. Look at Gogol’s literature and his relations with men. Contains annotated bibliography of Gogol’s works in English. Index. Luckyj, George Stephen Nestor. The Anguish of Mykola Hohol a.k.a. Nikolai Gogol. Toronto: Canadian Scholars’ Press, 1998. Explores Gogol’s life and how it affected his work. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Maguire, Robert A. Exploring Gogol. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1994. The most comprehensive study in English of Gogol’s entire writing career. Incorporates a chronology, detailed notes, and an extensive bibliography.
Gogol, Nikolai
443
____________, ed. Gogol from the Twentieth Century: Eleven Essays. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1974. This collection of essays, with a lengthy introduction by the editor and translator, represents some of the most famous and influential opinions on Gogol in the twentieth century. Some of the most problematic aspects of Gogol’s stylistics, thematics, and other compositional elements are addressed and well elucidated. Bibliography, index. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of these five short stories by Gogol: “The Diary of a Madman” (vol. 2), “The Nose” and “Old-World Landowners” (vol. 5), “The Overcoat” (vol. 6), and “Viy” (vol. 8). Rancour-Laferriere, David. Out from Under Gogol’s “Overcoat”: A Psychoanalytic Study. Ann Arbor, Mich.: Ardis, 1982. This specialized study proves very exciting to the reader of Gogol. Much of the discussion focuses on the particular usage of words by Gogol. Even students with no command of Russian will find the explication understandable since the examples are clear and self-defining. Much of the discussion consists of very modern literary-analytical technique and may prove of good use to the reader. Contains a bibliography that includes many background works. Tosi, Alessandra. “Andrei Kropotov’s ‘Istoriia o Smurom Kaftane’: A Thematic Source for Gogol’s ‘Shinel’?” The Slavonic and East European Review 76 (October, 1998): 601-613. Compares Gogol’s “The Overcoat” with Kropotov’s earlier story; in both stories a trivial garment takes on significance for the main characters and ultimately causes their ruin. Discusses the similarity in the twists in the plots; suggests that Kropotov’s story may have been source for Gogol’s.
444
Nadine Gordimer Born: Springs, Transvaal, South Africa; November 20, 1923 Principal short fiction • Face to Face: Short Stories, 1949; The Soft Voice of the Serpent, and Other Stories, 1952; Six Feet of the Country, 1956; Friday’s Footprint, and Other Stories, 1960; Not for Publication, and Other Stories, 1965; Livingstone’s Companions: Stories, 1971; Selected Stories, 1975; A Soldier’s Embrace, 1980; Something out There, 1984; Reflections of South Africa, 1986; Crimes of Conscience, 1991; Jump, and Other Stories, 1991; Why Haven’t You Written? Selected Stories, 1950-1972, 1992; Loot, and Other Stories, 2003; Beethoven Was One-Sixteenth Black, and Other Stories, 2007. Other literary forms • Nadine Gordimer is well known for several of her novels, including A World of Strangers (1958), The Conservationist (1974), Burger’s Daughter (1979), and The House Gun (1998), as well as the acclaimed My Son’s Story (1990). She has also published extensively in nonfiction and has made notable contributions to South African scholarship with such books as Lifetimes Under Apartheid (1986; with David Goldblatt) and Living in Hope and History: Notes from Our Century (1999). Her other publications have included volumes essays; two edited works on the literature of her homeland, South African Writing Today (1967) and Telling Tales (2004); and several teleplays. Achievements • As a courageous chronicler of life in South Africa, particularly through her short fiction, Nadine Gordimer is known throughout the world. She published her first collection of short stories in 1949 and has continued to publish books into the twenty-first century. One of her latest collections, Beethoven Was One-Sixteenth Black, and Other Stories (2007), contains a diverse mix of stories, ranging from a tale about a former anti-apartheid activist trying to understand his own racial identity to a fantasy about a parrot with an embarrassing habit of reproducing the voices and intimate conversations of people whom it overhears. Gordimer received the W. H. Smith and Son Prize in 1971 for Friday’s Footprint, and Other Stories. Two years later she won the James Tait Black Memorial Prize for A Guest of Honour (1970). The next year, The Conservationist shared with Stanley Middleton’s Holiday (1974) the prestigious Booker Prize. Gordimer was also a recipient of France’s Grand Aigle d’Or, and in 1991 she won what many consider the ultimate literary honor—the Nobel Prize in Literature. An opponent of all forms of discrimination, Gordimer rejected candidacy for the Orange Prize in 1998 because the award was restricted to female writers. She has been the vice president of PEN International and an executive member of the Congress of South African Writers. Her other honors have included the Modern Literature Association Award and the Bennett Award in the United States and the Chevalier de l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres in France. Her short fiction has been published in such magazines as The New Yorker. One American reviewer summed up Gordimer’s importance in literature, writing: “Gordimer is in the great mainstream of the short story—Maupassant, Chekhov, Turgenev, James, Hemingway, Porter.” Most of Gordimer’s fiction has been pub-
Gordimer, Nadine
445
lished in paperback form, enabling a greater number of readers and critics to recognize and enjoy her work. Biography • Nadine Gordimer grew up a rebel. Both her parents were immigrants to South Africa; her mother was English, her father an eastern European Jew. In Springs, the gold-mining town near Johannesburg in which she spent her early years, Gordimer frequently played hooky from her convent school. When she did attend, she would sometimes walk out. She found it difficult to tolerate all the pressures for conformity. In the white, middle-class South African environment in which Gordimer grew up, a girl could aspire only to marry and rear a family. After leaving school and then working at clerical jobs for a few years, girls would © The Nobel Foundation eventually be singled out as prospective wives by young men from families much like their own. From there, within months the girls would actualize the greatest dreams of young womanhood: They would have their engagement parties, linen showers, and wedding ceremonies, and they would bear their first children. None of these dreams would be served by the girls’ education; books, in perhaps leading their minds astray, would interfere with the years of the girls’ preparation for the mold. At an early age, however, Gordimer did not fit the mold—she was an avid reader. By nine, she was already writing, and at the age of fourteen she won a writing prize. Her favorite authors were Anton Chekhov, W. Somerset Maugham, Guy de Maupassant, D. H. Lawrence, and the Americans Katherine Anne Porter, O. Henry, and Eudora Welty. As Gordimer became a young woman, she became increasingly interested in politics and the plight of black South Africans. She did not, however, launch her writing career as a way to bring change. A male friend was an important influence on Gordimer. He told her that she was too ignorant and too accepting of society’s values. Gordimer has written, “It was through him, too, that I roused myself sufficiently to insist on going to the university.” Since she was twenty-two at the time and still being supported by her father, her family did not appreciate her desire to attend the university. Gordimer commuted to Johannesburg to attend the University of Witwatersrand. While at the university, she met Uys Krige, an Afrikaans poet who had shunned his privileged Afrikaner heritage, lived in France and Spain, and served with the International Brigade in the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939). He, too, was a profound influence on her. She had been “a bolter,” as she put it, at school; she was in the process of bolting from her family and class and the culture of white South Africa, and Krige gave her a final push. She would be committed to honesty alone. She began to send
446
Short Story Writers
stories to publications in England and the United States. They were well received, and she began to build her reputation as a short-story writer and novelist. She published her first collection of stories, Face to Face, in 1949. During the 1950’s, Gordimer married her first husband, Reinhold Cassirer, a German Jew who had fled Berlin. They had a son, Hugo, with whom Gordimer would collaborate during the mid-1990’s on a documentary about Berlin and Johannesburg. A second marriage later produced another child. During the mid-1980’s Gordimer turned to a new medium. She wrote teleplays of four of her stories–Praise, Oral History, Country Lovers, and A Chip of Glass Ruby (all 1985); she also participated in the production of other teleplays. Taken together, the films present a compelling vision of Gordimer’s South Africa. A filmed interview of Gordimer by Joachim Braun often accompanies the showing of her films. In this interview, Gordimer had many interesting things to say about both her work and the tragic state of her country. Always passionate about politics, Gordimer was a member of the African National Congress during the 1990’s and an enthusiastic supporter of South Africa’s peaceful transition to full democracy. She continued writing and publishing prolifically into the twenty-first century and published her fifteenth collection of short stories, Beethoven Was One-Sixteenth Black, and Other Stories, in 2007, at the age of eighty-four. Analysis • Nadine Gordimer is a distinguished novelist and short-story writer. About Selected Stories, drawn from her earlier volumes of stories, a reviewer said that the stories “are marked by the courage of moral vision and the beauty of artistic complexity. Gordimer examines, with passionate precision, the intricacies both of individual lives and of the wide-ranging political and historical forces that contain them.” About the stories in A Soldier’s Embrace, a reviewer wrote, “Their themes are universal: love and change, political transition, family, memory, madness and infidelity, to name a few. . . . What makes Nadine Gordimer such a valuable—and increasingly valued— novelist and short-story writer is her ability to meet the demands of her political conscience without becoming a propagandist and the challenges of her literary commitment without becoming a disengaged esthete.” Over the course of her career, three of her books were banned in South Africa. It would be easy for Gordimer to declare self-exile. Unlike James Joyce, however, she chose not to abandon the inhospitable country of her birth, accepting the obligation of citizenship to help make her country better. She did this by practicing her art, for it is an art that enables her diverse compatriots to understand better themselves and one another. The settings and characters in Gordimer’s stories cut across the whole spectrum of South African life. She writes about black village life and black urban experiences. She writes about the Afrikaans-speaking whites, English-speaking whites, Indians, and others. Her protagonists are as likely to be male as female, and reviewers have commented on her uncanny ability to make her male characters fully realized. In The House Gun, Gordimer ponders the deeply personal question of whether parents can even trust their own child not to commit murder. With amazing range and knowledge, she reveals the intricacies of individual lives and of the historical and political forces that shape them. Reading one of Gordimer’s stories is always exciting, because one does not know what will have caught her interest—urban or rural blacks, urban or rural Afrikaners, leisured or working or revolutionary whites, an African or a European setting. It is a
Gordimer, Nadine
447
great surprise, for example, to discover a story in the form of a letter from a dead Prague father to the son who predeceased him. It is a made-up letter in which Hermann Kafka tells off ungrateful, congenitally unhappy Franz. As she has demonstrated again and again during more than thirty years of writing, Gordimer does not restrict her focus to people and scenes that are the most familiar. One marvels in reading “A City of the Dead, a City of the Living,” for example, at what the author, a well-off white woman, knows of black-township life, at the total credibility of characters Samson Moreke and his wife, Nanike. Gordimer’s knowledge and credibility are characteristic of all of her short fiction. “A City of the Dead, a City of the Living,” “Sins of the Third Age,” and “Blinder” could easily be included among the twenty best short stories of the twentieth century. “Is There Nowhere Else Where We Can Meet?” • Among Gordimer’s most gripping stories are those in which blacks and whites are at cross-purposes. “Is There Nowhere Else Where We Can Meet?” from The Soft Voice of the Serpent, and Other Stories is one of the simplest and best of this group. On a country road, a young white woman’s handbag is torn from her by a passing local, whose bedraggled condition had evoked the woman’s pity. The day is very cold, yet he is shoeless and dressed in rags. When she attains safety and has brought her fear under control, she decides not to seek aid or inform the police. “What did I fight for” she thinks. “Why didn’t I give him the money and let him go? His red eyes, and the smell and those cracks in his feet, fissures, erosion.” “Six Feet of the Country” • The title piece of Gordimer’s 1956 collection, Six Feet of the Country, is another exceptional story. A young black laborer walks from Rhodesia to find work in South Africa, where he has family who are employed on a weekend farm of a white Johannesburg couple. When he arrives at the farm, the illegal immigrant becomes ill and dies. There ensues a prolonged entanglement with the authorities, who insist on having the body so that it can be examined and the bureaucratic requirement for a statement of the cause of death can be fulfilled. With great reluctance, the family surrenders the body. When at last the casket is returned to the farm for burial, they discover that the body in it is that of a stranger. In the course of spinning out a plot about the fate of a corpse, Gordimer provides great insight into the lives of the farm laborers, the proprietors, and the police official, and she also reveals the relative inability of the laborers to deal with illness and the bureaucracy. “A Chip of Glass Ruby” • “A Chip of Glass Ruby,” in Not for Publication, and Other Stories, is about an Indian family in the Transvaal. The wife and mother is loving and unassuming and a very competent manager of a household that includes nine children. To the chagrin of her husband, Bamjee, she is also a political activist. It makes no sense to him that she takes grave risks for blacks, who are regarded as lower even than Indians. During the course of the story, she is arrested and imprisoned and participates in a prison hunger strike. Bamjee, a poor, small-time fruit and vegetable dealer, cannot understand any of this: He asks, “‘What for?’ Again and again: ‘What for?’” His birthday comes, and he himself does not even remember. The eldest daughter brings word from her mother, in the prison, however, that his birthday must not be forgotten. Bamjee is moved and begins to have a glimmer of understanding of the wonderful woman who is his wife. As the daughter explains: “It’s because she always remembers; remembers everything—people without somewhere to live, hungry kids, boys who can’t get educated—remembers all the time. That’s how Ma is.”
448
Short Story Writers
“The Intruder” • “The Intruder,” which appears in Livingstone’s Companions, focuses on the decadence of an upper-class man of English descent. After shedding his last wife, hard-drinking, stay-out-late James Seago takes up with the beautiful teenage daughter of Mrs. Clegg, a woman of his age who affects a bohemian morality. Seago refers to the daughter, Marie, whom he uses sexually and enjoys having in his lap as he drinks, as his teenage doll, his marmoset, his rabbit. Because he has financial problems, Seago is plausibly able to postpone committing himself to her in marriage. Once they are married, Seago’s irresponsible life of nightly partying does not change. Having married his pet, however, he must live with her, and so they set up housekeeping in an unpleasant flat. Marie becomes pregnant. The arrival of a child will force changes in Seago’s way of life: For one thing, they will have to find living quarters more suitable for a child; for another, his wife-pet will have to give her primary attention to the child, not him. Arriving home early one morning after a night of partying, they fall into bed exhausted. A few hours later, Marie awakens hungry. She wanders out of the bedroom and finds the rest of the flat a wreck. All the kitchen staples have been spilled or thrown about; toothpaste is smeared about the bathroom. In the living room, on one of the sofa cushions, is “a slime of contraceptive jelly with haircombings—hers.” Gordimer only hints at the perpetrator. It seems more than likely, though, that it is James Seago, who again is rebelling at the prospect of being forced into a responsible mode of life. “Abroad” • In “Abroad,” the main character is an Afrikaner. Manie Swemmer is a likable, middle-aged widower who has worked hard his entire life at construction and with cars. His grown sons have moved to neighboring black-run Zambia, known as Northern Rhodesia while still a British colony. Manie decides to take the train up to Zambia and visit his sons. Arriving in Lusaka, the capital, Manie is met by his younger son, Willie. Having expected to stay with Willie, Manie is surprised to learn that Willie does not have quarters of his own but is staying at a friend’s, where there is no room for his father. To his dismay, Manie learns that all the local hotels are booked. The irrepressible Manie, though, manages to talk the manager of the Regent into placing him in a room that already has been rented as a single. The problem is that it is rented to an Indian, although an educated Indian. Although Manie has been given a key to the room and has placed his belongings inside, when he returns later, the Indian, from the inside, has bolted the door and locked out the Afrikaner. Manie then is offered a bed in a room intended for black guests. The blacks have not yet arrived, and Manie uses the door bolt to lock them out. “Abroad” is a beautiful story about a well-meaning Afrikaner who is excited by the racial mixing of the new nation and who wants to stretch himself to his liberal limit. His feelings toward blacks, though, are still conditioned by his South African base, where all blacks are automatically regarded as inferior. “I’ve only just got here, give me a bit of time,” Manie tells the desk clerk. “You can’t expect to put me in with a native, right away, first thing.” “A Soldier’s Embrace” • Upon gaining its independence from Portugal in 1975, Mozambique became another black-ruled neighbor of South Africa. “A Soldier’s Embrace,” the title story of Gordimer’s 1980 collection, is about the changeover, the exultation, and the disillusionment of a liberal white couple. The story begins with a brilliant scene of the celebration of the victory of the guerrillas who have been fighting the colonial power. Swept up by the street crowd, the woman finds herself embraced by two soldiers, one a white peasant youth, the other a black guerrilla. She
Gordimer, Nadine
449
puts an arm around each and kisses each on the cheek. Under the new regime, one is certain, a human being will be a human being; all groups will be treated equally. Although many whites take flight to Europe, the woman and her husband, a lawyer, are eager to participate in building the new nation. Weeks and months pass, however, and, despite the friends the lawyer has among highly placed blacks, the government does not ask the lawyer for his services. There is an atmosphere of hostility toward whites. There is looting and violence. When a friend in nearby Rhodesia, soon to be Zimbabwe, offers the lawyer a position in that country, with reluctance and relief he and his wife pack and go. The couple have wanted the country in which they have spent their adult years to be black-run; when that comes about, they find that there is no role for them. Something Out There • In the novella that provides the title for Gordimer’s volume of short fiction Something Out There, a race war looms but has not yet erupted. Acts of violence are taking place; any one of them might well precipitate such a war. In the novella, the “something out there” is a baboon. Gordimer’s intention is to suggest that the response of white South Africans to the baboon corresponds to the irrational way they have been responding to the carefully planned symbolic acts of violence by guerrillas. Those acts of violence are handwriting on the wall announcing the coming of race war, which still could be prevented if the writing were read intelligently. All that the whites want, however, is to be left alone. They want the animal “to be confined in its appropriate place, that’s all, zoo or even circus.” They want South African blacks to be confined to their appropriate places—locations and townships, black homelands, villages in the bush. As the baboon is “canny about where it was possible somehow to exist off the pickings of plenty,” so, too, is the South African black majority, before the cataclysm, somehow able to exist off pickings of white wealth. That wealth will not be shared, only protected, “while charity does not move those who have everything to spare, fear will”—the fear of the baboon, the fear of the guerrilla. What is the fate of the baboon? It is finally shot and slowly bleeds to death from its wounds. The implication is clear: A similar fate awaits the guerrillas. Gordimer’s prime minister speaks: “This government will not stand by and see the peace of mind of its peoples destroyed. . . . We shall not hesitate to strike with all our might at those who harbour terrorists. . . .” The four guerrillas who are the novella’s human protagonists, in counterpoint to the movements of the baboon, succeed in blowing up a power station; three escape and it is made clear that they will carry out further attacks. The meaning in this plot—though not in all Gordimer plots on this subject—is that a ruthless government will be a match for those attempting to destroy it. The fact that the white population is greatly outnumbered makes no difference. They have the education, the technology, the will to defend to the death what they have. Racial justice is an idea with which only a few whites—the man and woman on the power-station mission—are concerned. Protecting privilege and property is what most whites care most about. They cannot understand the few who act from disinterested motives. A minor character in “Something Out There” is a decent white police sergeant. He is totally mystified by the white guerrillas whom he interrogates: “There’s something wrong with all these people who become enemies of their own country. . . . They’re enemies because they can’t enjoy their lives the way a normal white person in South Africa does.”
450
Short Story Writers
One of the black guerrillas is dispassionate, determined, fearless Vusi, whose life is dedicated to bringing about black majority rule. Vusi says. “They can’t stop us because we can’t stop. Never. Every time, when I’m waiting, I know I’m coming nearer.” A Vusi, however, is rare. “At the Rendezvous of Victory,” another story in this volume, looks ahead to the ultimate black victory. It is about the man who served as commander in chief of the liberation army, known as General Giant. As a warrior, he was invaluable; as a cabinet minister after victory, he is a great burden to his prime minister. He led his people to victory and freedom; in freedom, his chief interest is women. “A City of the Dead, a City of the Living” • In “A City of the Dead, a City of the Living,” a young black man who has committed illegal acts for his people’s liberation and who is on the run from the police is given shelter by a township family. With their small house already overcrowded, the family is inconvenienced, but the husband knows his duty. His wife, nursing her fifth child, does not like the idea of taking in a stranger, but the man is pleasant and helpful, and she softens. She softens and begins to feel attracted to him. Frightened, she goes to the police to inform on him, thus betraying the cause of her people’s liberation. “Sins of the Third Age” • “Sins of the Third Age,” surprisingly, is not a political story. It is about a couple who survived World War II as displaced persons. Nothing remained of their pasts. They met and in a strange country began to build their lives together. Gordimer is wonderfully evocative as she suggests the passing of years and the deepening of their love. The wife’s job as an interpreter takes her on frequent trips, many times to Rome and Milan. On one of her trips, she gets the idea that they should buy a home in Italy for their retirement, near a Piedmontese village. He retires first and goes to Italy to prepare the house. After several months, he appears suddenly and announces, “I’ve met somebody.” His affair eventually ends, but the betrayal destroys the vitality of the marriage. To have done otherwise than to take her husband for granted would have been betrayal on her part. She trusted, and she loses. “Blinder” • “Blinder” is still another fine story in the 1984 volume. It is about an aging servant woman’s loss of her lover, a man who was the main consolation of her life. Ephraim’s first loyalty, however, was to his wife and children in his home village; the wife got his earnings, and after his death, her children get his bicycle. When Ephraim suddenly dies, Rose’s white family expected her to increase her drinking, to go on a “blinder.” Instead, she plays hostess to Ephraim’s wife, who has come to the city to see about a pension. “The Defeated” • “The Defeated” was originally published in the collection Why Haven’t You Written? Selected Stories, 1950-1972 and was reprinted in 1993. It is a firstperson narrative concerning a European Jewish family that runs a concession store for black South Africans in a forbidden, filthy part of town. The narrator, a young girl, befriends Miriam Saiyetovitz, whose immigrant parents work long hours selling goods to indecisive customers. The shop they live above is across from an eating establishment teeming with the smells of slaughtered animals. Mrs. Saiyetovitz, “ugly, with the blunt ugliness of a toad; the ugliness not entirely at home in any element— as if the earth were the wrong place, too heavy and magnetic for a creature already blunt,” and her dull husband devote their lives to giving their daughter everything
Gordimer, Nadine
451
they possibly can. When Miriam describes all the birthday gifts her friend received, her mother assures her they will throw her a huge party. As the two girls grow up together and it comes time for university, Miriam’s parents labor to send her to a good college. Miriam grows further apart from them, moving into the upper classes as she attends pool parties and eventually marries a doctor. Ultimately, she abandons the two people who made her comfortable life possible. When the narrator, now a grown woman, goes to visit Mr. and Mrs. Saiyetovitz, she learns that they hardly see their daughter or her baby son at all. In “The Defeated,” Gordimer conjures up an evocative variety of discordant but powerful moments: the sweaty smell of the black Africans mingling with the odor of bloodied meat, the toadlike mother juxtaposed with her blossoming daughter, the quietly rage-filled father who takes terrible advantage of his status as a white man to humiliate his black customers. Also noticeable is the contrast between the narrator’s relatively benign home life and the concession area where black South Africans are forced to shop among the refuse. “The Defeated” deftly envelops in its fold class differences, the burgeoning of female sexuality, and the tragedy of wasted lives, both of immigrants and of dispossessed indigenous peoples. Gordimer does not openly judge Miriam, but it is clear through the telling of her growing alienation that Miriam is only one of the upwardly mobile Afrikaners whose sights are set on material gain and not on remaining true to those who sacrificed happiness for them. Paul Marx With updates by Carol Bishop Other major works novels: The Lying Days, 1953; A World of Strangers, 1958; Occasion for Loving, 1963; The Late Bourgeois World, 1966; A Guest of Honour, 1970; The Conservationist, 1974; Burger’s Daughter, 1979; July’s People, 1981; A Sport of Nature, 1987; My Son’s Story, 1990; None to Accompany Me, 1994; The House Gun, 1998; The Pickup, 2001; Get a Life, 2005. teleplays: A Chip of Glass Ruby, 1985; Country Lovers, 1985; Oral History, 1985; Praise, 1985. nonfiction: On the Mines, 1973 (with David Goldblatt); The Black Interpreters: Notes on African Writing, 1973; Lifetimes Under Apartheid, 1986 (with Goldblatt); The Essential Gesture: Writing, Politics, and Places, 1988 (Stephen Clingman, editor); Conversations with Nadine Gordimer, 1990 (Nancy Topping Bazin and Marilyn Dallman Seymour, editors); Three in a Bed: Fiction, Morals, and Politics, 1991; Writing and Being, 1995; A Writing Life: Celebrating Nadine Gordimer, 1999 (Andries Walter Oliphant, editor); Living in Hope and History: Note from Our Century, 1999. anthologies: South African Writing Today, 1967 (with Lionel Abrahams); Telling Tales, 2004. Bibliography Bazin, Nancy Topping, and Marilyn Dallman Seymour, eds. Conversations with Nadine Gordimer. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1990. The scope of this volume renders it invaluable. It reveals some of Gordimer’s insights and attitudes toward her works and their origins, in conversations spanning thirty years. Supplemented by an index and a bibliography. Driver, Dorothy, Ann Dry, Craig MacKenzie, and John Read, comps. Nadine Gordimer: A Bibliography of Primary and Secondary Sources, 1937-1992. London: Hans Zell,
452
Short Story Writers
1994. More than three thousand entries listed chronologically. Each critical book or article entry indicates which Gordimer works are covered. Includes a chronology of Gordimer’s career to 1993. Several helpful indexes. Ettin, Andre Vogel. Betrayals of the Body Politic: The Literary Commitments of Nadine Gordimer. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1995. Ettin examines all Gordimer’s genres of writing and discovers the recurring themes: betrayal, politics of family, concept of homeland, ethnicity, and feminism. Head, Dominic. Nadine Gordimer. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1994. Head interprets Gordimer’s first ten novels. Indexed. Select bibliography of works by and about Gordimer. Chronology of Gordimer’s career and major South African political events to 1991. King, Bruce, ed. The Later Fiction of Nadine Gordimer. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1993. The introduction, surveying the variety in Gordimer’s novels from The Late Bourgeois World to My Son’s Story, is followed by five general essays dealing thematically or stylistically with multiple novels, seven essays dealing with one or two novels in depth, and three essays dealing with short stories. Indexed. Notes on contributors. Lazar, Karen. “Feminism as ‘Piffling’? Ambiguities in Nadine Gordimer’s Short Stories.” In The Later Fiction of Nadine Gordimer, edited by Bruce King. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1993. Examines a number of Gordimer’s short stories in terms of her changing attitudes toward women’s oppression and feminism, ranging from her early view that many women’s issues are “piffling” to views that reveal Gordimer’s politicization on the question of gender. Lomberg, Alan R. “Once More into the Burrows: Nadine Gordimer’s Later Short Fiction.” In The Later Fiction of Nadine Gordimer, edited by Bruce King. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1993. Analysis of how Gordimer continues to examine concerns raised in early stories in her later ones. After discussing how two early stories are developed into a later novella, Lomberg analyzes other stories that Gordimer has written again and again, particularly those that treat love affairs. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of nine short stories by Gordimer: “Another Part of the Sky” (vol. 1); “The Defeated” (vol. 2); “Livingstone’s Companions” (vol. 4); “Open House” (vol. 5); and “Something Out There,” “The Smell of Death and Flowers,” “A Soldier’s Embrace,” “Town and Country Lovers,” and “The Train from Rhodesia” (vol. 7). Smith, Rowland, ed. Critical Essays on Nadine Gordimer. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1990. Excellent selection of essays on Gordimer’s works. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Temple-Thurston, Barbara. Nadine Gordimer Revisited. New York: Twayne, 1999. Part of Twayne’s World Authors series, this is a good updated study of the author and her works. Bibliographical references and an index are provided. Trump, Martin. “The Short Fiction of Nadine Gordimer.” Research in African Literatures 17 (Spring, 1986): 341-369. Argues that in her best stories Gordimer describes the hardships of South Africans, particularly women, who suffer social inequality; summarizes a number of stories that illustrate this focus.
453
Graham Greene Born: Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, England; October 2, 1904 Died: Vevey, Switzerland; April 3, 1991 Principal short fiction • The Basement Room, and Other Stories, 1935; The Bear Fell Free, 1935; Twenty-four Stories, 1939 (with James Laver and Sylvia Townsend Warner); Nineteen Stories, 1947 (revised 1954; as Twenty-one Stories); A Visit to Morin, 1959; A Sense of Reality, 1963; May We Borrow Your Husband?, and Other Comedies of the Sexual Life, 1967; Collected Stories, 1972; How Father Quixote Became a Monsignor, 1980. Other literary forms • Graham Greene published twenty-six novels including the posthumously issued No Man’s Land (2004). His other novels include The Power and the Glory (1940; reissued as The Labyrinthine Ways), The Heart of the Matter (1948), Brighton Rock (1938), The End of the Affair (1951), and The Human Factor (1978). In addition to his many novels and short-story collections, Greene published five plays; three collections of poetry of which the last two, After Two Years (1949) and For Christmas (1950), were privately printed; travel books, including two centering on Africa; several books of literary essays and film criticism; a biography, Lord Rochester’s Monkey: Being the Life of John Wilmot, Second Earl of Rochester (1974); and two autobiographical works, A Sort of Life (1971) and Ways of Escape (1980). In addition, Greene published journals, book reviews, and four children’s books. Achievements • Although the Nobel Prize eluded Graham Greene, he remains one of the most important novelists of the twentieth century. With more screen adaptations than any other modern author, translations into twenty-seven different languages, and book sales exceeding twenty million dollars, Greene enjoyed a combination of critical success and popular acclaim not seen by a British author since the time of Charles Dickens. In 1984, Great Britain made Greene a Companion of Literature, and in 1986, a member of the elite Order of Merit. France bestowed on Greene one of its highest honors, naming him a Commander of Arts and Letters. In addition, Greene’s most famous novels–The Power and the Glory, The End of the Affair, and The Heart of the Matter—have been acknowledged as literary masterpieces. Combining the outer world of political intrigue and the inner world of the human psyche, Greene’s world is one of faith and doubt, honor and betrayal, love and hate. Both the depth and breadth of Greene’s work make him one of Britain’s most prolific and enduring writers. Biography • Educated at Berkhamsted School and Balliol College, Oxford, Graham Greene served in the Foreign Office, London, from 1941 to 1944. He married Vivien Dayrell-Browning in 1927 and had two children. He was a staff member of the London Times from 1926 to 1930, and he served as movie critic (1937-1940) and literary editor (1940-1941) of The Spectator. He also served as director for Eyre and Spottiswoode, publishers (1944-1948), and for The Bodley Head, publishers (1958-1968). The recipient of numerous awards, Greene received the Hawthornden Prize for The Labyrinthine Ways in 1941; the Black Memorial Prize for The Heart of the Matter in 1949; the
454
Short Story Writers
TO VIEW IMAGE, PLEASE SEE PRINT EDITION OF THIS BOOK.
Shakespeare Prize, Hamburg, 1968; and the Thomas More Medal, 1973. Other awards of distinction include a D.Litt. from the University of Cambridge in 1962, a D.Litt. from Edinburgh University, 1967, Honorary Fellow at Balliol College (Oxford) in 1963, Companion of Honor in 1966, and Chevalier of the French Legion of Honor in 1969. With fifty-four books to his credit, Greene remained a productive writer throughout his life. His last publication was in 1988, but he was said to be working on a new book at the time of his death on April 3, 1991. Greene spent his last years in Antibes, France, and died in Vevey, Switzerland.
© Amanda Saunders
Analysis • “Goodness has only once found a perfect incarnation in a human body and never will again, but evil can always find a home there. Human nature is not black and white but black and grey.” So said Graham Greene in his essay “The Lost Childhood,” and the statement as well as any defines the worldview manifested in his fiction. The “perfect incarnation” is Jesus Christ, and it is against this backdrop of the divine-made-human that Greene draws and measures all the actions of his stories. Whether the stories are explicitly religious in theme, such as “The Hint of an Explanation,” or not, or whether Greene chooses to view humanity in a tragic or comic light, the basic vision is the same: human nature steeped in evil and struggling with the fundamental problems of egotism, love and hate, responsibility, innocence and guilt. As a result of this vision, the central action in Greene’s fictional world is invariably betrayal—the Judas complex—betrayal of one’s fellow human beings, of one’s self, or of one’s God. For Greene’s heroes and heroines there is no escape; they fall by virtue of their very humanity. Yet their flawed humanity is not presented and then judged from the standpoint of any simplistic orthodoxy. As a thinker and as a fiction writer Greene was a master of paradox, creating a world of moral and theological mystery in which ignobility and failure may often be the road to salvation. Indeed, in Greene’s world the worst sin is a presumed innocence which masks a corrosive egotism that effectively cuts human beings off from their fellow creatures and from God. “The Hint of an Explanation” • Greene’s paradoxical treatment of his major themes within a theological perspective is best evident in “The Hint of an Explanation.” The story develops in the form of a conversation between the narrator, an agnostic, and another passenger, a Roman Catholic, while the two are riding on a train in England. Although he confesses to have occasionally had intuitions of the existence of God, the agnostic is intellectually revolted by the whole notion of “such a God who can so abandon his creatures to the enormities of Free Will . . . ‘When you think of what God—if there is a God—allows. It’s not merely the physical agonies, but think of the corruption, even of children.’” The question posed by the agnostic is the mystery of
Greene, Graham
455
evil—why an omniscient God permits it. In response, the Catholic reminds him that the limitations of human understanding make a full answer impossible for human beings. Nevertheless, he insists, there are “hints” of an explanation, hints caught by men when they are involved in events that do not turn out as they were intended— “by human actors I mean, or by the thing behind the human actors.” The suggested “thing” behind the human actors is Satan, and it is the Catholic traveler’s conviction of Satan’s ultimate impotence and defeat, derived paradoxically from an experience of evil in his own childhood, that provides the underpinning for his own belief in divine providence. As a child, the Catholic son of a Midland bank manager was tempted by the town freethinker to steal a consecrated Host while serving Mass and deliver it to him. The tempter, a baker named Blacker, is corruption incarnate; he both entices the boy by letting him play with an electric train and promising to give it to him, and at the same time threatens to bleed him with a razor if the boy will not do his bidding. The boy is conscious of the eternal consequences his actions will have: “Murder is sufficiently trivial to have its appropriate punishment, but for this act the mind boggled at the thought of any retribution at all.” Still, driven by fear of Blacker, he steals the communion wafer—the Body of Christ—and prepares to deliver it to the baker. Nevertheless, when Blacker appears that evening under the boy’s bedroom window to collect the Host, his diabolical purposes are defeated when the boy abruptly swallows the communion wafer rather than deliver it into the hands of the Enemy. As he now recalls this episode from his childhood for the agnostic stranger, the Catholic sees in it a “hint” of the manner in which the mystery of the divine will operates, for that episode was the “odd beginning” of a life that eventually led him to become a priest. Looking back on it now, he sees in his struggle with Blacker nothing less than the struggle between God and Satan for the human soul, and the inevitable defeat of “that Thing,” doomed to hopelessness and unhappiness. Although the story is clear in its religious theme, any danger of its being merely a tract disguised as fiction is skillfully circumvented both by the paradoxical quality of Greene’s thought and by his technical skill as a writer. For one thing, Greene undercuts the threat of dogmatic rigidity by creating enormous compassion for the malevolent figure of Blacker, imprisoned in his own misery, at the same time leaving the door open for his eventual redemption through defeat. Moreover, much of this compassion derives from the reader’s awareness that, as a human being, Blacker is as much the victim of satanic forces working through him as he is agent of his own fate. Greene sustains a delicate dramatic balance between man’s free will and responsibility on the one hand, and on the other, the suggestion or “hint” of supernatural forces at work in human affairs. Greene leaves the reader with a sense of the ineffable mystery of reality, and even the rather hackneyed and mechanical surprise ending of the story—the discovery in the last paragraph that the Catholic is indeed a priest—is consistent with the dramatic logic of the story. “The Hint of an Explanation” bears many of the trademarks that made Greene one of the most important and widely read artists of the twentieth century, earning him both popularity and high critical esteem. His technical skill and sheer virtuosity as a storyteller stemmed equally from his mastery of the high formalist tradition of Henry James and Joseph Conrad and from the conventions of the melodramatic thriller, with its roots in classical, Renaissance, and Jacobean drama. Mastery of the themes and devices of the thriller—love and betrayal, intrigue, unexpected plot turns, the use of the hunt or chase, danger and violence—gave him a firm founda-
456
Short Story Writers
tion upon which to base his subtle explorations of the spiritual condition of human beings in the twentieth century. In short, one of his most important contributions to the short story lies in the way in which he took the conventional form of popular fiction and infused it with a dimension of mystery that often penetrates to the deepest theological levels of experience. Although occasionally the action in Greene’s stories may seem contrived, it is contrivance brought off with great dynamism—the energy and unpredictability of life’s happenstances—and not the sealed, airless contrivance wrought by the aesthetic purists (whom Greene denounced), those modern fiction writers who have elevated artistic form to an absolute. Although the social milieu of Greene’s fiction is most often the commonplace world of modern England and Europe, it is his ability to infuse this landscape with the sense of mystery that gives the stories their imaginative power and depth. Often the most fertile ground for imagination is childhood, and this may well account for the fact that, as in “The Hint of an Explanation,” Greene frequently makes childhood the locus of action for his themes of innocence, egotism, and betrayal. Yet his depiction of childhood is not a sentimentalized, romantic portraiture of innocence betrayed by a hostile world. Greene focuses on childhood because he finds in children a sense of reality which is keener and more alive, a sharper moral imagination, and a more vivid awareness of the personal consequences of their choices as they struggle with the demands of love and hate, loyalty and betrayal. In an essay on James, Greene remarked that “to render the highest justice to corruption you must retain your innocence: you have to be conscious all the time within yourself of treachery to something valuable.” Greene’s fictional children, still unjaded by maturity, feel the potential for treachery both within themselves and surrounding them. Greene was able to make this complex childhood world palpable and render it with great psychological fidelity, perhaps seen best in one of his finest stories, “The Basement Room.” “The Basement Room” • Betrayal and the spiritually fatal consequences of choosing a specious innocence over the unalterable fact of the fallen state are the driving forces in “The Basement Room.” Phillip Lane, a seven-year-old upper-class boy, develops a strong bond of friendship with Baines, the family butler, while his parents are gone on a fortnight’s holiday. With Baines, whom he sees as a “buccaneer” and man-of-the-world, Philip feels that he has begun “to live,” and indeed he is initiated into a complex world of love and hate, deceit, the demands of friendship, and eventually betrayal. For Baines and Phillip have a common enemy: Mrs. Baines, a bitter shrew who bullies both her husband and young Phillip. During a day’s outing with Baines, Phillip also meets the butler’s mistress, Emmy, whom Baines introduces as his “niece.” When Mrs. Baines is called away suddenly because of family illness, Baines, in a holiday mood, brings Emmy home for the night, convinced that Phillip will loyally keep his secret. “Life,” however, so complex and confusing in its demands, is too much for young Phillip. The suspicious Mrs. Baines returns unexpectedly during the night and terrifies him, demanding to know where “they” are. Too frightened to answer, Phillip manages to reach the bedroom door in time to see the enraged Mrs. Baines attacking her husband in the upstairs hallway, and in the ensuing struggle she topples over the bannister and is killed. Phillip runs frightened from the house, while the butler quickly removes her body to the foot of the stairs of their basement apartment to make it appear that she has accidentally fallen there. Phillip wanders aimlessly in the streets, waiting for someone to lift the burden of responsibility from him, for “life”
Greene, Graham
457
has now become intolerable. “He loved Baines, but Baines had involved him in secrets, in fears he didn’t understand. That was what happened when you loved—you got involved; and Phillip extricated himself from life, from love, from Baines.” So when he is returned home by the police, Phillip betrays Baines, blurting out the facts that condemn the butler. The effect of Phillip’s betrayal—choosing an egotistic “innocence” over the ambiguous responsibilities of love in a fallen world—is disastrous to his own spiritual growth. At the end of the story, Greene skillfully shifts the scene forward to Phillip’s own deathbed where, having “never faced it [life] again in sixty years . . . ,” he agonizingly relives the moment of his betrayal, murmuring the policeman’s question to Baines (“Who is she? Who is she?”) as he sinks into death. Greene’s point is clear: Phillip’s spiritual development stopped at the age of seven when he refused the consequences of his love for Baines. Instead of the reality of being a fallen, yet free and mature, creature, he chose egotism and the illusion of innocence. The innocence Phillip elects, however, is not a true childlike quality. On the contrary, the childhood Phillip loses is exactly that keen awareness of the potentialities for love and treachery, of the power of evil and the vital sense of mystery inspiring terror and awe which constitutes for Greene the real human condition. We are reminded of Greene’s quoting from Æ’s poem “Germinal”: “In the lost childhood of Judas, Christ was betrayed.” “The Destructors” • Greene’s depiction of the lost childhood theme in “The Basement Room” is devastating and terrible, but he can also present the same theme in a manner which is devastatingly funny. Such is the case in “The Destructors,” in which the callous youngster Trevor leads a gang of neighborhood boys in the systematic dismantling of the house of Mr. Thomas—“Old Misery” as the children call him—a retired builder and decorator. Because his own father was once an architect, Trevor fully understands the value of Old Misery’s house; indeed, it is an elegant, twohundred-year-old structure built by Sir Christopher Wren, which embodies the refinements of tradition. In fact, Old Misery’s house is an emblem of civilization itself, the whole legacy of humane values and order and design passed from generation to generation, still imposing even though it stands amid the ruins of bombed-out postwar London. Fully conscious of its historical and cultural significance, Trevor diabolically mobilizes the gang of youths to bring the house down, working from the inside “like worms, don’t you see, in an apple.” Trevor ingratiates himself with Old Misery by asking to tour the inside of the house and then, learning that the owner will be away for a weekend holiday, sets his plan of destruction in motion. Working floor by floor, the gang wrecks everything— furniture, china and ornamental bric-a-brac, doors, personal mementos, porcelain fixtures, the winding staircase, and parquet floors; even Old Misery’s hidden cache of pound notes is burned up. The evil inspired by Trevor goes beyond simple thievery; it is destruction for its own sake, a satanic love of chaos. When Trevor’s minion Blackie asks him if he hates Old Misery, the leader replies coldly that “There’d be no fun if I hated him. . . . ‘All this love and hate,’ he said, ‘it’s soft, it’s hooey. There’s only things, Blackie. . . .”’ In Trevor’s remark Greene has touched the nerve of a fundamental side of the modern consciousness, its brutal amorality and contempt for the past. Greene’s inventive genius manages to make “The Destructors” humorous, although terrifyingly so. Trevor’s plan to destroy the house is endangered when Old Misery returns prematurely from his holiday, but Trevor is up to the challenge and
458
Short Story Writers
instantly contrives a plot to trap the aged owner in his own outdoor privy. Locked in by the gang for the night, Old Misery can only sit helplessly and wonder what the faint sounds of hammering and scraping mean. The next morning a driver arrives to remove his lorry from the parking lot next door, and as he pulls away, unaware of the rope tying his truck to the foundation beams, Old Misery’s house comes down in a heap of rubble. The driver manages to free Old Misery from the privy, but he cannot restrain himself from laughing at the scene of devastation. “‘How dare you laugh,’ Mr. Thomas said, ‘It was my house. My house.’” The driver can only reply, chuckling, “I’m sorry. I can’t help it, Mr. Thomas. There’s nothing personal, but you got to admit it’s funny.” “The Destructors” represents Greene at his best in presenting his vision of human perversity and folly in a comic vein. The depiction of Trevor’s unmitigated evil is frightening, but it is finely balanced by the humor of the final scene; and in the lorry driver’s laughter and the absurdly pathetic character of Old Misery the reader finds a basic affirmation of the common values of human existence which, paradoxically, triumph over the cold diabolism of young Trevor. It is he who is the ultimate loser. Knowing the world only as “things,” he himself has become a thing—T. the destructor—and he cannot respond either with love or hate to the life around him. Greene’s stories, with their remarkable craftsmanship, exercise a powerful fascination on the reader. Even at their most melodramatic, his stories unfailingly create a plausible sense of reality because they touch the full range of human experience: petty foibles, corruption, deceit, love, responsibility, hope, and despair. Whether Greene’s emphasis is tragic or comic, or a wry mingling of both, the reader is again and again confronted in the stories with the fundamental mystery of existence on earth, making them at once rich, entertaining, and profound. John F. Desmond With updates by Karen Priest Other major works children’s literature: The Little Train, 1946; The Little Fire Engine, 1950 (also known as The Little Red Fire Engine, 1952); The Little Horse Bus, 1952; The Little Steam Roller: A Story of Mystery and Detection, 1953. plays: The Heart of the Matter, pr. 1950 (with Basil Dean; adaptation of his novel); The Living Room, pr., pb. 1953; The Potting Shed, pr., pb. 1957; The Complaisant Lover, pr., pb. 1959; Carving a Statue, pr., pb. 1964; The Return of A. J. Raffles: An Edwardian Comedy in Three Acts Based Somewhat Loosely on E. W. Hornung’s Characters in “The Amateur Cracksman,” pr., pb. 1975; For Whom the Bell Chimes, pr. 1980, pb. 1983; Yes and No, pr. 1980, pb. 1983; The Collected Plays of Graham Greene, pb. 1985. anthologies: The Old School: Essays by Divers Hands, 1934; The Best of Saki, 1950; The Spy’s Bedside Book: An Anthology, 1957 (with Hugh Greene); The Bodley Head Ford Madox Ford, 1962, 1963 (4 volumes); An Impossible Woman: The Memories of Dottoressa Moor of Capri, 1975. novels: The Man Within, 1929; The Name of Action, 1930; Rumour at Nightfall, 1931; Stamboul Train: An Entertainment, 1932 (pb. in U.S. as Orient Express: An Entertainment, 1933); It’s a Battlefield, 1934; England Made Me, 1935; A Gun for Sale: An Entertainment, 1936 (pb. in U.S. as This Gun for Hire: An Entertainment); Brighton Rock, 1938; The Confidential Agent, 1939; The Power and the Glory, 1940 (reissued as The Labyrinthine Ways); The Ministry of Fear: An Entertainment, 1943; The Heart of the Matter, 1948; The Third
Greene, Graham
459
Man: An Entertainment, 1950; The Third Man and The Fallen Idol, 1950; The End of the Affair, 1951; Loser Takes All: An Entertainment, 1955; The Quiet American, 1955; Our Man in Havana: An Entertainment, 1958; A Burnt-Out Case, 1961; The Comedians, 1966; Travels with My Aunt, 1969; The Honorary Consul, 1973; The Human Factor, 1978; Dr. Fischer of Geneva: Or, The Bomb Party, 1980; Monsignor Quixote, 1982; The Tenth Man, 1985; The Captain and the Enemy, 1988; No Man’s Land, 2004. miscellaneous: The Portable Graham Greene, 1973 (Philip Stout Ford, editor). nonfiction: Journey Without Maps: A Travel Book, 1936; The Lawless Roads: A Mexican Journal, 1939 (reissued as Another Mexico); British Dramatists, 1942; Why Do I Write? An Exchange of Views Between Elizabeth Bowen, Graham Greene, and V. S. Pritchett, 1948; The Lost Childhood, and Other Essays, 1951; Essais Catholiques, 1953 (Marcelle Sibon, translator); In Search of a Character: Two African Journals, 1961; The Revenge: An Autobiographical Fragment, 1963; Victorian Detective Fiction, 1966; Collected Essays, 1969; A Sort of Life, 1971; The Pleasure Dome: The Collected Film Criticism, 1935-40, of Graham Greene, 1972 (John Russell-Taylor, editor; pb. in U.S. as The Pleasure-Dome: Graham Greene on Film, Collected Film Criticism, 1935-1940); Lord Rochester’s Monkey: Being the Life of John Wilmot, Second Earl of Rochester, 1974; Ways of Escape, 1980; J’accuse: The Dark Side of Nice, 1982; Getting to Know the General: The Story of an Involvement, 1984. poetry: Babbling April: Poems, 1925; After Two Years, 1949; For Christmas, 1950. radio play: The Great Jowett, 1939. screenplays: Twenty-one Days, 1937; The New Britain, 1940; Brighton Rock, 1947 (adaptation of his novel; with Terence Rattigan); The Fallen Idol, 1948 (adaptation of his novel; with Lesley Storm and William Templeton); The Third Man, 1949 (adaptation of his novel; with Carol Reed); The Stranger’s Hand, 1954 (with Guy Elmes and Giorgino Bassani); Loser Takes All, 1956 (adaptation of his novel); Saint Joan, 1957 (adaptation of George Bernard Shaw’s play); Our Man in Havana, 1959 (adaptation of his novel); The Comedians, 1967 (adaptation of his novel). teleplay: Alas, Poor Maling, 1975. Bibliography Bayley, John. “Graham Greene: The Short Stories.” In Graham Greene: A Reevaluation. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1990. Basing his comments on his analysis of “The Hint of an Explanation,” Bayley argues that many Greene stories have a hidden subject in a sense that none of his novels does. Claims that by means of almost invisible contrasts and incongruities, the story leads the reader both away from and toward its central revelation. De Vitis, A. A. Graham Greene. Rev. ed. Boston: Twayne, 1986. Most interesting in this volume are an overview of critical opinion about Greene, a chronology, and a chapter on the short stories. Supplemented by a thorough primary bibliography and an annotated bibliography of secondary sources. Kelly, Richard. Graham Greene. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1984. General introduction to Greene and his work. The chapter on the short stories discusses “The Destructors,” “The Hint of an Explanation,” and “The Basement Room” as the best of Greene’s stories. ____________. Graham Greene: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1992. Discusses the influence of Henry James, Guy de Maupassant, and W. Somerset Maugham on Greene’s stories, but also discusses how the stories reflect Greene’s own personal demons. Includes an interview with Greene, his introduction to his Collected Stories, and three previously published essays by other critics.
460
Short Story Writers
May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of six short stories by Greene: “Across the Bridge,” “The Basement Room,” and “Cheap in August” (vol. 1); “The Destructors” and “A Drive in the Country” (vol. 2); and “The Hint of an Explanation” (vol. 3). Meyers, Jeffrey, ed. Graham Greene: A Revaluation. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1990. These essays by eight scholars offer critical analyses of Greene’s accomplishments, in the shadow of his death. Miller, R. H. Understanding Graham Greene. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1990. Guide to all of Greene’s writing. The style is concise yet informative and evaluative, but the author runs too quickly through the canon. Bibliography and index. O’Prey, Paul. A Reader’s Guide to Graham Greene. New York: Thames and Hudson, 1988. Critical overview of Greene’s fiction. The excellent introduction familiarizes the reader with Greene’s major themes. Supplemented by a complete primary bibliography and a brief list of critical works. Sherry, Norman. The Life of Graham Greene. 2 vols. New York: Viking Press, 1989-1995. The first two parts of what is certainly the most comprehensive, most authoritative account of Greene’s life yet published, written with complete access to his papers and the full cooperation of family, friends, and the novelist himself. Includes a generous collection of photographs, a bibliography, and an index. Smith, Grahame. The Achievement of Graham Greene. Sussex, England: Harvester Press, 1986. Includes an excellent introduction, with an overview of themes and biographical data. Contains chapters on “Fiction and Belief” and “Fiction and Politics,” as well as sections titled “The Man of Letters” and “Greene and Cinema.” Augmented by a select bibliography.
461
Brothers Grimm Jacob Grimm Born: Hanau, near Kassel, Hesse-Kassel (now in Germany); January 4, 1785 Died: Berlin, Prussia (now in Germany); September 20, 1863
Wilhelm Grimm Born: Hanau, near Kassel, Hesse-Kassel (now in Germany); February 24, 1786 Died: Berlin, Prussia (now in Germany); December 16, 1859 Principal short fiction • Kinder-und Hausmärchen, 1812, 1815 (revised 1819-1822; German Popular Stories, 1823-1826; 2 volumes; better known as Grimm’s Fairy Tales). Other literary forms • The Brothers Grimm published important studies of German tales and mythology, as well as philological works recognized for their importance to the study of the German language. Achievements • The tales collected and edited by the Brothers Grimm are the defining instances of Märchen, a term only approximately translated by “fairy tale.” At a time when the changes wrought by the Industrial Revolution threatened to make the traditions of oral storytelling disappear, Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm were able to preserve these tales in written form. Now, in the Anglo-Saxon world at least, the tales recounted by the Brothers Grimm are more familiar than any stories except those of the Bible. The literary influence of the collection has been considerable: It has shaped much of subsequent children’s literature and has inspired a great many sophisticated fictions, particularly among the German Romantics, the English Victorians, and the so-called Fabulators of the mid-twentieth century. Most important, however, has been the direct human influence of the tales. The collection epitomizes the psychological wisdom of generations of storytellers, and the tales themselves provide for nearly every child in the West a first map of the territory of the imagination. Biography • Both of the Brothers Grimm devoted their lives to literary and philological scholarship. Following in their father’s footsteps, they studied law at Marburg, but, under the influence of Johann Gottfried Herder and Clemens Brentano, they turned from the law, and between 1806 and 1826, first at Marburg and later at the library of the Elector in Kassel, they collaborated in the study of folklore, producing not only the Märchen but also Deutsche Sagen (1816-1818; German Legends, 1981), on local historical legends and other works. In 1830, they left Kassel to become librarians and later professors at Göttingen. After a decade of largely independent work, the two collaborated again on a monumental lexicon of the German language, the Deutsches Wörterbuch (1854). The project was begun in 1838, was carried to Berlin when the brothers were appointed professors at the university in 1841, and was completed only in 1961—Wilhelm had died working on the letter D, Jacob at F. Wilhelm Carl Grimm was in his own right an editor of medieval texts who did im-
462
Short Story Writers
portant work on runes and Germanic legend. Jacob Ludwig Carl Grimm was one of the greatest scholars in the history of a nation of scholars. His Deutsche Mythologie (1835; Teutonic Mythology, 1880-1888), attempted to establish a theoretical base for the Märchen collected earlier, viewing them as the detritus of a German mythology suppressed by Christianity. In thus laying the groundwork for all further speculation on the origins of folklore and myth, he has come to be acknowledged as the founder of the scientific study of folklore. At the same time, he is the uncontested founder of the systematic study of the German language and indeed of historical linguistics itself; this assessment is based on the strength of his work that begins with the formulation of Grimm’s law in Deutsche Grammatik (1819-1837) and culminates in the Deutsches Wörtebuch. Analysis • Grimm’s Fairy Tales came into being in the context of German Romanticism, particularly with its renewed interest in the medieval past. Just as European society was becoming urban, industrial, and literate, a growing nationalism turned attention to folk culture. The Brothers Grimm first began collecting songs and stories for the poet Clemens Brentano and his brother-in-law Achim von Arnim, who had themselves collaborated on an influential collection of folksongs, Des Knaben Wunderhorn (1805, 1808; the boy’s wonderhorn), still familiar from Gustav Mahler’s many settings of its songs. The Grimms drew on oral as well as printed sources, interviewing both peasant storytellers and middle-class urban informants. The resulting collection of some two hundred stories preserved a substantial body of folklore, fortuitously, at the very moment when its milieu was being irreparably destroyed by the modernization of nineteenth century Europe. Translated into at least seventy languages, Grimm’s Fairy Tales stands as the model for every subsequent collection of folklore, however much more sophisticated in theory or method. The brothers’ own notes and commentaries on the tales, included in the second edition, form the basis of the science of folklore. One source of the appeal of these tales is their complex chemistry of both art and artlessness. The Grimms did not think of themselves as authors of short fiction but as what would now be considered anthropologists. They set for themselves the task of contriving, from many different versions of any tale, an account that achieved artistic integrity without sacrificing folkloric quality. This meant sometimes restoring details that seemed to have been dropped or distorted in the course of oral tradition, or deleting what seemed purely literary invention. Many decisions were arbitrary since this was, after all, the beginning of a discipline, and the Grimms sometimes changed their minds, as differences between the first and second editions make clear. They were guided on the whole, however, by an aim of reconstructing prototypes which they assumed to be oral. Thus, in each tale they were responding to two different challenges. First, they attempted to preserve and even enhance the atmosphere of performance through traditional rhetorical devices such as repetition of songs and narrative formulas in which the audience would share and through the general circumstantial quality characteristic of every spellbinding teller. At the same time, their versions were meant to be definitive and fixed in print, a medium with aesthetic demands of its own that had to be met. “Six Soldiers of Fortune” • As a result, within the Grimm style, which is instantly recognizable as a matter of motif, several substyles of narrative are apparent. There are some tales that strike the reader as archetypal for their transparency of struc-
Grimm Brothers
463
ture. “Six Soldiers of Fortune,” for example, assembles a group of soldiers, each with a unique preternatural power, makes use of, and so in a sense exhausts, each power in a deadly contest for the hand of a princess, and then dismisses the group with a treasure to divide. Perhaps most lucid of all is the haunting “The Fisherman and His Wife”; this tale combines heightening ambitions and lowering weather against the measured rhythm of wishes demanded and granted, all strung on the thread of a summoning spell sung six times to the generous fish, an enchanted prince who disturbingly remains enchanted throughout the tale, until in the end everything is as Library of Congress it was. In this tale, no wish is offered at first, until the wife, knowing with the logic of fairy tale that enchanted fish grant wishes, sends her husband back. After wishing herself from hovel to cottage to castle, however, her third wish is for a change not of station but of identity. She wishes to be king, and this moves beyond the rule of three to the inordinate and outlandish: emperor, pope, ruler of the sun and moon, things she cannot be. “The Lady and the Lion” • Other tales seem authentic not for their clarity but for a sense of free-ranging invention in loose, barely articulated forms. “The Lady and the Lion” is a prime example of a tale that seems ready to go anywhere a teller is inclined to take it. It relies heavily on familiar but heterogeneous motifs, and so while it fascinates readers from moment to moment (especially if heard rather than read) with an almost Asian opulence of invention, it seems in the end unmotivated. “Godfather Death” • The tension between the commitment to transcribe tales as told and the need to devise viable written artifacts can best be exemplified by contrasting two stories. In “Godfather Death,” a man seeking a godfather for his thirteenth child rejects God himself and the Devil but accepts Death because he “makes all equal.” When the boy is grown, Death gives him an herb that restores life, with these instructions: “If I stand by the head of the sick-bed, administer this herb and the man will recover; but if I stand at the foot, the man is mine, and you must say that nothing can save him.” The boy becomes a famous healer. Once when the King is sick, with Death at his feet, the boy risks using the herb to save him, but Death pardons him with a warning. Later, however, the King’s daughter is in the same situation, and for love of her the doctor again overrules Death. Death seizes him with an icy hand and leads him to a cave where thousands of candles are burning, some very large, some mere stubs. “Show me the light of my life,” says the doctor, and he finds it guttering. He begs his godfather to replace it, and the story ends like this:
464
Short Story Writers
Death behaved as if he were going to fulfill his wish, and took hold of a tall new candle, but as he desired to revenge himself, he purposely made a mistake in fixing it, and the little piece fell down and was extinguished. The physician too fell on the ground; now he himself was in the hands of Death. “The Wonderful Glass” • Grimm’s Fairy Tales preserves another version of this story, “The Wonderful Glass,” which is, from the point of view of a written tale, almost incoherent. It is less carefully composed than “Godfather Death”: Only one stranger appears, the child is merely “another child,” and the gift of healing is given oddly not to the child but to his father; in fact the child plays no role at all. The father never misuses the gift but one day decides to visit the godfather. Five steps lead to the house. On the first a mop and a broom are quarreling, on the next he finds a “number of dead fingers,” on the next a heap of human heads give him directions, on the next a fish is frying itself in a pan. At the top the doctor peeks through the keyhole and sees the godfather with a set of horns on his head. When he enters the house, the godfather hides under the bedclothes. When he says, “I saw you through the keyhole with a pair of horns on your head,” the godfather shouts, “That is not true,” in such a terrible voice that the doctor runs away and is never heard of again. “The Wonderful Glass” is hardly worth preserving except as a transcript of a clumsy horror story. The immense superiority of “Godfather Death” may suggest how the Grimms’ decision to proceed by artful selection among versions rather than by wholesale recasting in another mode produced masterpieces. Again and again their editorial tact added formal power to the visual interest and psychological depth of the inherited stories. “Rapunzel” • “Rapunzel,” for example, begins like many of the Märchen (“Snow White,” “Sleeping Beauty,” “The Almond Tree”), with a couple who wish for a child. A small window in their house overlooks a witch’s garden, and one night the husband climbs over the high wall to steal some “rapunze,” a salad green. He is soon caught by the witch, however, and to save his life he promises to amend the theft by giving her his child when it is born. It was pregnancy that made his wife crave rapunze; the unborn child thus causes the theft and by a rough justice replaces the thing stolen. The witch takes her at birth, names her Rapunzel, and walls her up, even more securely than the plant she replaces, in a tower accessible only by a high window. This generates the central image of the tale: the long-haired nubile girl imprisoned in the tower. Like the husband, the Prince (potential husband of the next generation) climbs over the wall to steal the witch’s Rapunze(l), and he, too, is eventually caught by the possessive witch. Learning of the Prince’s visits, she banishes Rapunzel to a wasteland, first cutting off her hair, which will be used to lure the Prince to a confrontation. He escapes, but in his terror falls on thorns that blind him. After years of wandering, he hears Rapunzel’s voice again, they embrace, and her tears restore his sight. “Rapunzel” is usually read as a story of maturation, with Rapunzel as the central figure, but she is a passive character throughout, an instrument in the relations of others. It is at least equally a tale of possessiveness and longing. The parents desire a child; in the wife’s craving for greens the reader sees the child at once gained and lost. Like the parents (although more like Rumpelstiltskin) the witch desires a child, and the Prince’s longing is obvious—it is the chief character trait of princes throughout the Märchen. The remarkable dearth of magic is related to these themes. In spite of the presence of the witch, the only magic is the healing tears of love. In other versions the witch’s magic harms the prince; here it is mysteriously not her doing, but
Grimm Brothers
465
ironic coincidence. The pathos of that reticence is owed to the Brothers Grimm; their instinct for invoking folk style is apparent in the repeated motifs but above all in their inspired invention of the phrase, “Rapunzel, Rapunzel, let down your hair,” which sounds, even when the reader knows better, like the archaic root of the whole story. Thus, the Grimms reconciled the values of folklore with what were recognized as the requirements of short fiction, but they were scrupulously aware that the versions they contrived were only moments seized out of the continuing tradition of telling and retelling. The proper habitation of the Märchen is in the mouths of storytellers. Form, the proportion of parts, and even readers’ sympathies are always being accommodated to new audiences in new circumstances. As early as 1893, Marian Cox could study 345 variants of “Cinderella” alone. Grimm’s Fairy Tales, then, were folktales accommodated to print: more symmetrical, more compressed, as a rule spatially rather than linearly conceived, and with formal rhythms replacing the lost rhythm of speech. The brothers’ devotion to their originals or to the sources behind their originals, however, is apparent. As the example of “Rapunzel” suggests, their versions are much less stylized than other literary versions; the reader never feels the presence of an author as in those printed versions that antedate the Grimms, such as Charles Perrault and Giambattista Basile. They would never say, as Perrault does, that Sleeping Beauty was beautiful even though she dressed like someone’s grandmother in clothes out of fashion for a century. Thanks to the Grimms, the Märchen have survived in a new kind of world, but the process of accommodation continues. One of the measures of how thoroughly these tales have been internalized in the West is the shock every reader feels on first reading the Grimms’ own account of tales so profoundly familiar. This is not how they are remembered, and the difference frankly reveals how tastes have changed in the intervening years. Through several generations of editors, and especially of parents, the Märchen have become more magical, much more romantic, and decidedly less violent than the Grimms’ own versions. Magic is a most important variable. Although there is plenty of it in the tales, modern readers will find the Grimms often unexpectedly discreet in the use of magic. “The Little Farmer” • There is even at least one plainly antimagical story, “The Little Farmer,” in which the protagonist defeats a whole town because the people are gullible about magic (eventually they are all drowned when, after the farmer tells them he collected a fine flock of sheep under water, they see fleecy clouds reflected on the surface as confirmation of his story and jump in). There is much use of gratuitous magic, not only for ornament but also, in particular, to establish a tone of fantasy at the start of a story. The beginning of “Sleeping Beauty” offers an extreme example: A frog jumps out of the water, prophesies that the queen will soon bear a daughter, and disappears never to be mentioned again. Indeed, supernatural helpers put in abrupt appearances throughout the tales. “Snow White” • Often in reading Grimm’s Fairy Tales, however, the reader finds coincidence or rationalization where memory led him to expect magic. Thus, in “Snow White,” although the wicked queen has her magic mirror, much that could be magic is more nearly pharmacology. Even the revival of Snow White is not, as Walt Disney and memory would have it, by the magic of a kiss from Prince Charming, but like this: The dwarfs gave the coffin to the Prince, who had his servants carry it away.
466
Short Story Writers
Now it happened that as they were going along they stumbled over a bush, and with the shaking a bit of the poisoned apple flew out of her throat. It was not long before she opened her eyes, threw open the cover of the coffin, and sat up, alive and well. “Oh dear, where am I?,” cried she. The King’s son answered, full of joy, “you are near me. . . . Come with me to my father’s castle and you shall be my bride.” And Snow White was kind, and went with him. An earlier generation of commentators would have woven from bush and fruit a myth of fall and redemption, but at least as interesting is the calculated avoidance of overt magic even in resurrection. The blinding of the Prince in “Rapunzel” is treated with similar ambiguity. Violence • Apart from the treatment of magic, the most unexpected feature of the Grimms’ tales is their violence. The stories are full of treachery, mutilation, cannibalism, and over and over again the visual and visceral impact of the sight of red blood against pale skin, white snow, black wood, or stone. This is most shocking in the wellknown stories. When Snow White’s stepmother cannot resist coming to the wedding to see if the girl really is “a thousand times more fair,” she finds that “they had ready red-hot iron shoes, in which she had to dance until she fell down dead.” The ending of “Cinderella” is similar, although it is better integrated with the shape of the story. The two stepsisters cut off parts of their feet to fit into the tiny slipper, but as each in turn passes the grave of Cinderella’s true mother, which is marked by a hazel tree grown from a twig she asked as a gift from her father and watered with her tears, two birds perched in the tree, her helpers earlier, make known the mutilations so that at last Cinderella can put on the shoe that was made for her. As a result, she marries the Prince, and the tale ends with the same birds pecking out the eyes of the stepsisters. Violence in Grimm’s Fairy Tales nearly always has a human origin. The reader grows accustomed to witches, stepmothers, and evil elder siblings, but the overwhelming sense of the world here is optimistic. The stories regularly assert a harmony between humans and nature, often seen as more reliable than human harmony: The birds will help when other people will not. By their plotting, the stories also project a harmony in time. In the end, the good live happily ever after, while for the evil there are dire and, to most modern readers, disproportionate punishments. The harmonious close of a Grimm tale is grounded on a faith in justice. Indeed, several of the tales have this as their theme: No crime can remain hidden; truth will come to light. Behind this is a sense of divine Providence, for beneath all the magic the milieu of these tales is thoroughly Christian. There is hardly a trace of the tragic weight of Germanic myth in even the most harrowing of the Märchen. “The Singing Bone” • Consider “The Singing Bone”: Through the clear water of a river, a herdsman sees on the sandy bottom a bone as white as snow. He retrieves it to make a mouthpiece for his horn, and at once it begins to sing its own story, “I killed the wild boar, and my brother slew me,/ Then gained the Princess by pretending it was he.” The marvel is brought to the King, the victim’s skeleton is found, the wicked brother is ordered drowned, and the bones are “laid to rest in a beautiful grave.” This is quite brutal, even in summary, but the formal symmetries of the violence here reinforce the demonstration of justice. If a modern reader tends to worry about the bereft Princess and is less than satisfied with a beautiful grave, it may be that he has lost
Grimm Brothers
467
faith in any ultimate distribution of justice. That may be the chief reason that so much of the violence of the Grimms’ tales is now suppressed in the telling. The Grimms’ theory of folklore as the doctrine of a mythology is now discredited, but they were right to sense the tremendous resonance of these tales in the imagination. More recently, psychological approaches from Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung down to Bruno Bettelheim have pointed to the archetypal force of these stories. This force is not the Grimms’ creation; it is a wisdom concentrated through a long process of transmission. What the Grimm brothers contributed was an array of formal devices learned in the context of literate fiction—devices that increased the strength and resilience of the tales in the period when their survival was most threatened. Along with the form of the stories, what the Grimms’ retelling often particularly enhanced were the visual images. The traditional tales were full of images of seminal power from which much of the psychological impact emanated. In stories meant to be heard, however, the visual imagination is free, and images can be invoked by a word or two. Consciously or not, the Brothers Grimm realized that in the act of reading, the visual imagination is engaged, so images must be sharpened and developed in order to act on a preoccupied eye. As a result, Grimm’s Fairy Tales is crowded with images of emblematic power such as the gingerbread house, the palace of sleepers, Snow White in her glass coffin, and Little Red Riding Hood and the bedded wolf. These images have attracted the finest illustrators (and animators) of every intervening generation to join with storytellers in transmitting a body of tales that speaks to readers, it seems, in the native language of the imagination. Laurence A. Breiner Other major works nonfiction: Deutsche Sagen, 1816-1818 (German Legends, 1981; 2 volumes); Deutsche Grammatik, 1819-1837 (by Jacob Grimm alone); Über deutsche Runen, 1821 (by Wilhelm Grimm alone); Die deutsche Heldensage, 1829 (by Wilhelm Grimm alone); Deutsche Mythologie, 1835-1837 (4 volumes; by Jacob Grimm alone; Teutonic Mythology, 1880-1888); Geschichte der deutschen Sprache, 1848 (by Jacob Grimm alone); Deutsches Wörterbuch, 1852-1862 (3 volumes). Bibliography Bettelheim, Bruno. The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales. New York: Random House, 1976. Bettelheim’s book discusses the major motifs and themes of fairy tales from a Freudian psychological perspective, focusing on their meanings for the growing child. He discusses many of the tales collected by the Brothers Grimm and in part 2 examines in detail eight of the stories still popular today. He includes a useful bibliography, though many of the books listed are in German, and an index. Grimm, Jacob, and Wilhelm Grimm. The Complete Fairy Tales of the Brothers Grimm. Edited and translated by Jack Zipes. New York: Bantam Press, 1992. This is perhaps the best of the many translations in English. The introduction is informative, and data are also given on the informants the Grimm brothers used in their research. Also included are thirty-two tales that the Grimms dropped from earlier editions, as well as eight variants showing how the Grimms edited and re-created tales as they were compiling their collection.
468
Short Story Writers
Haase, Donald, ed. The Reception of Grimms’ Fairy Tales: Responses, Reactions, Revisions. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1993. Valuable essays on public and critical opinions of the Grimms’ tales. Kamenetsky, Christa. The Brothers Grimm and Their Critics: Folktales and the Quest for Meaning. Athens: Ohio University Press, 1992. Surveys the Grimms’ lives, theories and practices, critical appraisals of their folktales, and extensive bibliographical resources. Michaelis-Jena, Ruth. The Brothers Grimm. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1970. Michaelis-Jena has written a thorough biography of Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, and she includes a chapter called “The ‘Nursery and Household Tales’ and Their Influence,” which provides information on early reactions to the collection and its translations, noting that the tales spurred an interest in collection of other national folktales. Contains an index and bibliography. Murphy, G. Ronald. The Owl, the Raven, and the Dove: The Religious Meaning of the Grimms’ Magic Fairy Tales. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. Examines the religious aspects of the tales. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Paradiz, Valerie. Clever Maids: The Secret History of the Grimm Fairy Tales. New York: Basic Books 2005. Examination of the source of the Grimm brothers’ collection of fairy tales, specifically; Paradiz argues that many of the tales were contributed not by peasants from the German countryside but rather by educated and aristocratic German women. Tatar, Maria. The Hard Facts of the Grimms’ Fairy Tales. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1987. Tatar provides close readings of many of the tales, mostly from a psychological perspective, though the book is aimed at a more scholarly audience than Bettelheim’s. She examines typical motifs and situations and attempts to bring in the perspectives of folklorists, cultural anthropologists, and literary critics, as well as that of the psychologists. Notes, index. Zipes, Jack. The Brothers Grimm: From Enchanted Forests to the Modern World. New York: Routledge, 1988. Zipes’s book arose out of talks he gave at various conferences. The work is quite scholarly, and many of the chapters examine the effects of the tales on modern society and place them in a sociohistorical context. Supplemented by notes, a good bibliography, and an index.
469
Bret Harte Born: Albany, New York; August 25, 1836 Died: Camberley, Surrey, England; May 5, 1902 Principal short fiction • Condensed Novels, 1867; The Lost Galleon, and Other Tales, 1867; The Luck of Roaring Camp, and Other Sketches, 1870; Stories of the Sierras, 1872; Mrs. Skaggs’s Husbands, 1873; Tales of the Argonauts, 1875; Thankful Blossom, 1877; Drift from Two Shores, 1878; The Story of a Mine, 1878; The Twins of Table Mountain, 1879; Flip and Found at Blazing Star, 1882; In the Carquinez Woods, 1883; Maruja, 1885; A Millionaire of Rough-and-Ready, 1887; The Crusade of the Excelsior, 1887; A Phyllis of the Sierras, 1888; Cressy, 1889; The Heritage of Dedlow Marsh, 1889; A Waif of the Plains, 1890; A First Family of Tasajara, 1891; Sally Dows, 1893; A Protégée of Jack Hamlin’s, 1894; The Bell-Ringer of Angel’s, 1894; In a Hollow of the Hills, 1895; Barker’s Luck, and Other Stories, 1896; Three Partners, 1897; Stories in Light and Shadow, 1898; Tales of Trail and Town, 1898; Mr. Jack Hamlin’s Meditation, 1899; Condensed Novels: Second Series, 1902; Trent’s Trust, 1903; The Story of Enriquez, 1924. Other literary forms • Bret Harte attempted practically every form of belles lettres common in the nineteenth century. He wrote several collections of poems, almost entirely forgotten in the years since his death. Indeed, his poetic reputation to modern readers depends completely on the success of one poem, his comic verse masterpiece “Plain Language from Truthful James,” more commonly known as “The Heathen Chinee,” published in 1870. He wrote and edited newspaper material, essays, the novel Gabriel Conroy (1876), and some excellent satirical work, notably his Condensed Novels; and he collaborated with Mark Twain on a play, Ah Sin (1877), based on his poem “The Heathen Chinee.” Achievements • Bret Harte’s influence on “local color” fiction, especially the literature of the American West, was profound but not totally fortunate. He was one of the earliest writers, and certainly the most influential one, to set stories on the mining frontier that evolved from the California gold rush of 1849. His interest in the Western story and his success in transforming his raw material into popular fiction led many subsequent writers to explore American Western themes that they might otherwise have dismissed as unworthy of serious notice. Harte’s stories, however, focusing on colorful characters that he deemed worthy of treatment for their own sake, tend to undervalue plot and setting, and his contrived plots and sentimental treatment of character gave subsequent Western fiction an escapist, juvenile bent, which it took a long time to outgrow. Biography • Born in Albany, New York, as Francis Brett Harte (he would later drop the “Francis” and change the spelling of his middle name to Bret), Harte went to California in 1854, where for a while he lived many of the lives he was later to re-create imaginatively in the biographies of his fictional characters. Among other occupations, he worked an unsuccessful mining claim on the Stanislaus River; he may have been a guard for the Wells Fargo stagecoach lines; and he was employed in various
470
Short Story Writers
capacities at the San Francisco mint before drifting into journalism. He was associated with the founding (1864) of C. H. Webb’s journal the Californian, in which some of his own early work was published. Subsequently he became editor of the Overland Monthly (1868-1870), in which many of his most famous works first saw print. Notable among these are the short story “The Luck of Roaring Camp” and the comic poem “Plain Language from Truthful James,” which led to an offer from The Atlantic Monthly of a ten-thousand-dollar yearly contract, annually renewable, for exclusive rights to his material. On the strength of this contract Harte moved to Boston, but the contract was never renewed after the first year. Indeed, Harte’s later work never came up to the standard of his earlier, and although he was a tireless writer his production rapidly degenerated into hack work. He moved to Europe, serving for a brief time as American consul in Krefeld, Germany, and in Glasgow, Scotland, before finally settling in London, where he lived the rest of his life. He was happy in London, where people viewed his work more charitably than in the United States and where he was respected as an authentic voice of “the ’49.” Analysis • In any discussion of Bret Harte, one must begin by making a clear distinction between importance and quality, that is, between the influence of an author’s work and its intrinsic value. That Harte was an extremely important writer, no one will deny. Almost entire credit should be given to him for the refinement of the gold fields of California into rich literary ore. More than a mere poet of “the ’49,” he firmly established many of the stock character types of later Western fiction: the gentleman gambler, the tarnished lady, the simple though often lovably cantankerous prospector, all invariably possessed of hearts of gold. These prototypes, so beloved of later Western writers both of fiction and film, seemed to spring, like rustic Athenas, full-grown from his fertile brain. Yet with all his admitted importance there have been doubts from the very beginning about the intrinsic quality of his work. After publication of The Luck of Roaring Camp, and Other Sketches and the overwhelming success of his famous comic poem “Plain Language from Truthful James” in the same year, the set of brilliant tomorrows confidently predicted for him developed instead into rediscovery only of a series of remembered yesterdays. What, the critic should initially ask, is the reason behind Harte’s meteoric rise and his equally precipitous fall? Perhaps a partial answer may be found by examination of a term often applied to Harte’s work: It is, critics are fond of saying, “Dickensian.” There is much truth to this critical commonplace, for the influence of Charles Dickens is everywhere to be found in Harte’s writing, from the often brilliantly visualized characters, through the sentimental description, to the too-commonly contrived plot. Perhaps the first of these influences is the most important, for, like Dickens, when Harte is mentioned one immediately thinks of memorable characters rather than memorable stories. What would Dickens be without his Bob Cratchit, Mister Micawber, and Little Nell? Similarly, what would Harte be without his gambler John Oakhurst or his lovable but eccentric lawyer, Colonel Starbottle? The answer to these rhetorical questions, however, conceals a major limitation in Harte’s literary artistry which the often too-facile comparison to Dickens easily overlooks. For in Dickens’s case, in addition to the characters mentioned above, equally powerful negative or evil ones may be added who are completely lacking in Harte’s own work. Where are the Gradgrinds and Fagins and Uriah Heeps in Harte’s writing? The answer, to the detriment of Harte’s stories, is that they are nowhere to be found. The result, equally unfortunate, is that Harte’s stories lack almost completely any tragic vision of the world or of human
Harte, Bret
471
beings’ place in it. Misfortune in Harte’s stories is uniformly pathetic rather than tragic, and the unfortunate result is that too often these stories settle for a “good cry” on the part of the reader rather than attempting any analysis of humanity’s destiny or its place in an unknown and often hostile universe. “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” • A brief glance at one of Harte’s bestknown stories, “The Outcasts of Poker Flat,” may serve at once to indicate both the strengths and the limitations of his work. This story tells of the fortunes of four “outcasts” from the California gold camp of Poker Flat, who have been escorted to the city limits by a vigilance committee, operating in the flush of civic pride, and told never to return on peril of their lives. The Library of Congress four outcasts are Mr. John Oakhurst, a professional gambler; “the Duchess” and “Mother Shipton,” two prostitutes; and “Uncle Billy,” a “confirmed drunkard,” suspected as well of the more serious crime of robbing sluices. The four outcasts hope to find shelter in the neighboring settlement of Sandy Bar, a long day’s journey away over a steep mountain range; but at noon the saddle-weary Duchess calls a halt to the expedition, saying she will “go no further.” Accordingly, the party goes into camp, despite Oakhurst’s pointing out that they are only half way to Sandy Bar and that they have neither equipment nor provisions. They do, however, have liquor, and the present joys of alcohol soon replace the will to proceed toward Sandy Bar where, in all fairness to the outcasts, their reception may not be overwhelmingly enthusiastic. Oakhurst does not drink, but out of a feeling of loyalty stays with his companions. Some time later during the afternoon, the party is joined by two refugees from Sandy Bar, Tom Simson and his betrothed, Piney Woods. They have eloped from Sandy Bar because of the objections of Piney’s father to their forthcoming marriage and are planning to be wed in Poker Flat. It transpires that Simson, referred to throughout the story as “the Innocent,” had once lost to Oakhurst his “entire fortune—amounting to some forty dollars”—and that after the game was over Oakhurst had taken the young man aside and given him his money back, saying simply “you’re a good little man, but you can’t gamble worth a cent. Don’t try it over again.” This had made a friend-for-life of the Innocent and also serves to show that Poker Flat’s view of Oakhurst as a monster of iniquity is not to be taken totally at face value. Since it is now too late to travel on, both the outcasts and the young lovers decide to encamp in a ruined house near the trail. During the night Uncle Billy abandons the group, taking all the animals with him. It also begins to snow. The party, predictably, is snowed in, although the situation
472
Short Story Writers
does not appear too grave since the extra provisions which the Innocent has brought with him and which Uncle Billy did not take in his departure are enough, with careful husbandry, to last the party for ten days. All begin to make the cabin habitable, and they spend the first few days listening to the accordion the Innocent has brought and to a paraphrase of the Iliad which the Innocent has recently read and with which, much to Oakhurst’s delight, he regales the company. The situation, however, deteriorates. Another snowstorm totally isolates the camp, although the castaways are able to see, far below them, the smoke of Poker Flat. On the tenth day, Mother Shipton, “once the strongest of the party,” who had mysteriously been growing weaker, dies. Her serious decline, it turns out, is a result of the fact that she had not eaten any of her carefully husbanded rations, which she had selflessly saved for her companions. Oakhurst then makes a pair of snowshoes out of a pack saddle and gives them to the Innocent, whom he sends off to Poker Flat in a last attempt to bring aid. If the Innocent reaches Poker Flat within two days, Oakhurst says, all will be well. He follows the Innocent part way on his journey toward Poker Flat, but does not return. Meanwhile, back at the camp, the situation goes from bad to worse. Only the Duchess and Piney are left, and—although they discover and are properly grateful for the pile of wood which Oakhurst has secretly gathered and left for them—the rigors of a cruel world prove too strong. They die of starvation in the snow, and a rescue party arriving too late is properly edified by their moral courage—and, the reader trusts, properly chastened by recognition of Poker Flat’s own despicable conduct. Oakhurst, we discover at the end of the story, in the best tradition of noblesse oblige, has committed suicide. The story concludes with a rehearsal of his epitaph, written by himself on a deuce of clubs and pinned to a pine tree with a bowie knife: “Beneath this tree lies the body of John Oakhurst, who struck a streak of bad luck on the 23d of November 1850, and handed in his checks on the 7th of December, 1850.” It is pointless to pretend that “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” does not have a certain power; indeed, the evidence of its continuing popularity, as shown through inclusion in countless anthologies of every persuasion, clearly indicates that the story is not a totally negligible effort. Yet after thoughtful readers have finished the story, they are conscious of a certain dissatisfaction. The question to be asked is, “Why?” The obvious answer seems to be that the story has little new to say. In European literature, prostitutes with hearts of gold were scarcely novel figures by the 1860’s; furthermore, the fact that holier-than-thou individuals, who are likely not only to cast the first stone but also to be sorry when it hits, can scarcely have been new to any reasonably perceptive reader. What Harte no doubt intended was to evoke an emotion on the part of the reader, an emotion of sorrow and pity for the poor victims of the social ingratitude (one hates to say injustice) of Poker Flat. The argument, from one perspective, is the oldest in the world—the tiresome tu quoque statement that the holier-than-thou are little better than the lowlier-than-them. Yet this easy answer will not entirely work. As has been pointed out many times, considered purely from the perspective of “ideas,” most literature is commonplace. Perhaps a better question is to ask how Harte approached his parable and whether his fictional method works. To this the answer must be “No,” for if readers consider the story carefully, they must agree that it simply is not successful, even in its own terms. They have, as Harte’s friend and sometime collaborator Mark Twain would have said, been “sold.” Let us examine the story closely. A group of outcasts is sent up a long day’s journey
Harte, Bret
473
to another place. They stop only halfway—that is, half a day’s journey—there. The place they left, in fact, is clearly visible behind them. Four in number, they are joined by two others; when Uncle Billy deserts, their number is five. Harte tells us that with careful management they have ten days’ food, even though they have no animals. (What Uncle Billy could possibly have wanted with the seven animals he stole, particularly since he had no provisions to put on them, is never clarified, nor is the bothersome detail of how he could have managed the theft in the first place, considering he had to remove them single-handedly from under the noses of his companions, one of whom, John Oakhurst, is, Harte specifically tells us, “a light sleeper.” The animals do not simply wander off; Harte calls our attention to the fact that they had been “tethered.” Uncle Billy must therefore have released them on purpose.) In any event, the unfortunate castaways survive on meager rations for a week until Oakhurst suddenly remembers how to make snowshoes. Why he could not remember this skill on the second day or perhaps the third, is never clarified, but no matter. The reason is obvious, at least from Harte’s point of view of the logic of the story. It is necessary for Harte to place his characters in a situation of romantic peril in order that their sterling qualities be thrown into high relief; to place his characters in extremis, however, Harte totally sacrifices whatever logic the story may have in its own terms. When Uncle Billy leaves, then, the group discovers that it has sufficient supplies for ten days—that is, fifty man days’ worth of food. Mother Shipton eats none of hers, dying of starvation at the end of a week. This means that the party now has some twenty-two man days of food left, with at the most only three people to eat it, since Mother Shipton is already dead and Oakhurst is about to commit suicide. This is, according to the data Harte has previously given, easily a week’s rations. Why, then, do the two surviving ladies die of starvation before the rescue party arrives some four days later? The answer has nothing to do with the story, which is designed, rather, for the moral Harte wishes to impale upon it. For in his single-minded pursuit of the commonplace notion that appearances may be deceiving and that there is a spark of goodness in all of us, Harte has totally sacrificed all fictional probabilities. Any potential tragic effect the story might presumably possess evaporates in the pale warmth of sentimental nostalgia. This inability to allow his stories to speak for themselves is Harte’s besetting fictional weakness. Rather than allowing his tales to develop their own meaning, he obsessively applies a meaning to them, a meaning which, in far too many cases, cheapens the fictional material at his disposal. Perhaps the fault is that Harte, in his relentless search for this new California literary ore, did not really know where to find it. The mother lode consistently escaped him, and whatever flakes his search discovered were too often small and heavily alloyed. James K. Folsom With updates by John W. Fiero Other major works plays: Two Men of Sandy Bar, pr. 1876; Ah Sin, pr. 1877 (with Mark Twain); Sue, pr. 1896 (with T. Edgar Pemberton). novels: Gabriel Conroy, 1876. miscellaneous: The Luck of Roaring Camp, and Other Writings, 2001. nonfiction: Selected Letters of Bret Harte, 1997 (Gary Scharnhorst, editor).
474
Short Story Writers
poetry: “Plain Language from Truthful James,” 1870 (also known as “The Heathen Chinee”); East and West Poems, 1871; Poems, 1871; Poetical Works, 1880; Poetical Works of Bret Harte, 1896; Some Later Verses, 1898. Bibliography Barnett, Linda D. Bret Harte: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1980. With a brief introduction outlining the historical directions of Harte scholarship and criticism, this work provides a good annotated bibliography and checklist through 1977. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Harte: “The Luck of Roaring Camp” (vol. 5), “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” (vol. 6), and “Tennessee’s Partner” (vol. 7). Morrow, Patrick. Bret Harte. Boise, Ida.: Boise State College Press, 1972. This brief but excellent study analyzes Harte’s major work in both literature and criticism. Although concise, it is a very helpful introduction. Supplemented by a select bibliography. Nissen, Axel. Bret Harte: Prince and Pauper. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 2000. This scholarly biography provides a new assessment of the life and achievements of the writer. O’Connor, Richard. Bret Harte: A Biography. Boston: Little, Brown, 1966. Lively, anecdotal, and gossipy account limited to Harte’s life, this work is not critical in focus. It does list Harte’s best-known literary characters. Scharnhorst, Gary. Bret Harte. New York: Twayne, 1992. Critical biography of Harte, providing analyses of stories from four different periods of his life, fully informed by critical reception of Harte’s work. An afterword summarizes Harte’s critical reputation. ____________. Bret Harte: A Bibliography. Lanham, Md.: Scarecrow Press, 1995. Excellent tool for the student of Harte. ____________. Bret Harte: Opening the American Literary West. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2000. Study of the writer/editor and his struggle to make the West part of the wider American culture. ____________. “Mark Twain, Bret Harte, and the Literary Construction of San Francisco.” In San Francisco in Fiction: Essays in a Regional Literature, edited by David Fine and Paul Skenazy. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1995. Discusses Harte’s acceptance of the eastern canon’s taste in such stories as “The Idyl of Red Gulch” and his romanticized depiction of San Francisco as a rough-and-tumble boomtown in several late stories. Stevens, J. David. “‘She War a Woman’: Family Roles, Gender, and Sexuality in Bret Harte’s Western Fiction.” American Literature 69 (September, 1997): 571-593. A discussion of gender in Harte’s Western fiction; argues that what critics have labeled sentimental excess in Harte’s fiction is in fact his method of exploring certain hegemonic cultural paradigms taken for granted in other Western narratives; discusses stories that deal with the structure of the family and how they critique gender roles.
475
Nathaniel Hawthorne Born: Salem, Massachusetts; July 4, 1804 Died: Plymouth, New Hampshire; May 19, 1864 Principal short fiction • Twice-Told Tales, 1837 (expanded 1842); Mosses from an Old Manse, 1846; The Snow-Image, and Other Twice-Told Tales, 1851. Other literary forms • Nathaniel Hawthorne is a major American novelist whose early Fanshawe: A Tale (1828) did not lead immediately to further long fiction. After a period largely given to tales and sketches, he published his classic study of moral prejudice in colonial New England, The Scarlet Letter (1850). In the next decade, three more novels—he preferred to call them romances—followed: The House of the Seven Gables (1851), The Blithedale Romance (1852), and The Marble Faun (1860). He wrote books for children, including A Wonder-Book for Boys and Girls (1852), and travel sketches of England, Our Old Home (1863). His posthumously published notebooks and letters are also important. Achievements • This seminal figure in American fiction combined narrative skill and artistic integrity as no previous American writer had done. A dozen of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short stories remain anthology favorites, and few modern American students fail to become familiar with The Scarlet Letter. Hawthorne’s influence on subsequent American writers, especially on his younger American friend Herman Melville, and on Henry James, William Faulkner, and Robert Lowell, has been enormous. Although he wrote comparatively little literary theory, his prefaces to his novels, preeminently the one to The House of the Seven Gables, and scattered observations within his fiction reflect a pioneering concern with his craft. Biography • It is fitting that Nathaniel Hawthorne’s birth in 1804 came on the Fourth of July, for, if American writers of his youth were attempting a literary declaration of independence to complement the successful political one of 1776, Hawthorne’s fiction of the 1830’s, along with Edgar Allan Poe’s poetry and fiction and Ralph Waldo Emerson’s essays and lectures of the same decade, rank as the fruition of that ambition. Undoubtedly his hometown of Salem, Massachusetts, exerted a powerful shaping influence on his work, even though his sea-captain father died when Nathaniel, the second of three children, was only four and even though Nathaniel did not evince much interest in the sea. No one could grow up in Salem without a strong sense of the past, especially a boy one of whose ancestors, John Hathorne (as the family name was then spelled), had served as a judge in the infamous witchcraft trials of 1695. In 1813, confined to home by a foot injury for two years, young Nathaniel formed the habit of reading for hours at a stretch. On graduating from Bowdoin College in 1825, where he was a classmate of Franklin Pierce, the future president, and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, the future poet, the bookish Hawthorne returned to Salem and began a decade of intensive reading and writing. He published a novel,
476
Short Story Writers
Fanshawe: A Tale (later repudiated), in 1828 and began to compose the short stories that eventually brought him into prominence. The first collection of these, TwiceTold Tales, appeared in 1837. In 1838, he became engaged to Sophia Peabody, of Salem, and the following year was appointed to a position in the Boston Custom House, but he left in 1841 to join the infant Brook Farm community in West Roxbury, Massachusetts. As a rather solitary man with no prior practical experience of farming, he did not thrive there and left before the end of the year. Marrying in 1842, the couple settled at the Old Manse in Concord. Although he befriended Henry David Thoreau, Hawthorne found the Concord Transcendentalists generally pretentious and boring. During the administration of James K. Polk, he left Concord for another customhouse appointment, this time back in Salem. From this period comes his second short-story collection, Mosses from an Old Manse. Moving thereafter to Lenox in the Berkshires, Hawthorne met the younger writer Herman Melville and produced, in a few weeks in 1850, The Scarlet Letter, which was the first of his successful novels; The House of the Seven Gables and another collection of short fiction, The Snow-Image, and Other Twice-Told Tales, followed the next year. Back in Concord at “The Wayside” in 1852, he wrote a campaign biography for his friend Pierce, which resulted in Hawthorne’s appointment as U.S. consul in Liverpool, England. That same year he also wrote the novel The Blithedale Romance, based loosely on his Brook Farm experience. In England, Hawthorne kept an extensive journal from which he later fashioned Our Old Home. Resigning his office in 1857, Hawthorne traveled with his family on the Continent; in Florence, he began his last novel, published in 1860 as The Marble Faun. By the time he returned to Concord, his health was failing, and although he worked at several more novels, he did not get far into any of them. In 1864, he set forth on a trip with Pierce but died in Plymouth, New Hampshire, on May 19. Analysis • Nathaniel Hawthorne’s reading in American colonial history confirmed his basically ambivalent attitude toward the American past, particularly the form that Puritanism took in the New England colonies. Especially interested in the intensity of the Puritan-Cavalier rivalry, the Puritan inclination to credit manifestations of the supernatural such as witchcraft, and the psychology of the struggle for liberation from English rule, Hawthorne explored these themes in some of his earliest stories. As they did for his Puritan ancestors, sin and guilt preoccupied Hawthorne, who, in his move from Salem to Concord, encountered what he considered the facile dismissal of the problem of evil by the Concord intellectuals. He developed a deeply ambivalent moral attitude that colored the situations and characters of his fiction. In the early masterpiece “My Kinsman, Major Molineux,” Hawthorne’s concern with the coming of age of the United States blends with the maturation of a lad on the verge of manhood. Introduced to the complexities of evil, characters such as Robin of this story and the title character of “Young Goodman Brown” have great difficulty summoning the spiritual strength to resist dark temptations. Often, Hawthorne’s characters cannot throw off the burden of a vague and irrational but weighty burden of guilt. Frequently, his young protagonists exhibit a cold, unresponsive attitude toward a loving fiancé or wife and can find no spiritual sustenance to redeem the situation. Brown, Parson Hooper of “The Minister’s Black Veil,” and Reuben Bourne of “Roger Malvin’s Burial” are examples of such guilt-ridden and essentially faithless men.
Hawthorne, Nathaniel
477
Another prevalent type of protagonist rejects love to become a detached observer, such as the husband of “Wakefield,” who for no apparent reason deserts his wife and spends years living nearby in disguise. In the stories of his middle and later periods, these detached characters are usually scientists or artists. The former include misguided idealists such as Aylmer of “The Birthmark” and the scientist Rappaccini in “Rappaccini’s Daughter,” who experiments remorselessly on female family members in search of some elusive abstract perfection. Hawthorne’s artists, while less dangerous, tend also to exclude themselves from warm and loving relationships. At their most deplorable, Hawthorne’s isolated, detached characters become, like Ethan Brand in the story of the same name and Library of Congress Roger Chillingworth of The Scarlet Letter, violators of the human heart, unreclaimable souls whose estrangement from normal human relationships yields them little in compensation, either material or spiritual. Characteristically, Hawthorne builds his stories on a quest or journey, often into the woods or wilderness but always into an unknown region, the protagonist emerging enlightened or merely chastened but invariably sadder, with any success a bitterly ironical one, such as Aylmer’s removal of his wife’s birthmark, which kills his patient. The stories are pervasively and often brilliantly symbolic, and Hawthorne’s symbolic imagination encompasses varieties ranging from more or less clear-cut allegory to elusive multiple symbolic patterns whose significance critics debate endlessly. A century and a half after their composition, Hawthorne’s artistry and moral imagination, even in some of his seriously flawed stories, continue to engage readers and critics. Two of Hawthorne’s most enduringly popular stories—“Roger Malvin’s Burial” and “My Kinsman, Major Molineux”—appeared initially in the 1831 edition of a literary annual called The Token but remained uncollected until long afterward. Both seem to have been intended for a book, Provincial Tales, that never materialized, and both begin with paragraphs explicitly linking the narratives to historical events. “Roger Malvin’s Burial” • “Roger Malvin’s Burial” is set in the aftermath of a 1725 confrontation with Native Americans called Lovell’s Fight. Roger is a mortally wounded soldier; Reuben Bourne, his less seriously injured companion, must decide whether to stay with his older friend on the desolate frontier or make his way back to his company before he becomes too weak to travel. Urged to the latter course by
478
Short Story Writers
Roger, his prospective father-in-law, Reuben makes the older man as comfortable as he can at the base of a huge rock near an oak sapling, promises to return as soon as he can, and staggers away. Eventually, he is discovered by a search party and taken home to be ministered to by Dorcas, his fiancé. After several days of semiconsciousness, Reuben recovers sufficiently to answer questions. Although he believes he has done the right thing, he cannot bring himself to contradict Dorcas’s assumption that he had buried her father, and he is undeservedly lionized for his heroic fidelity. Eighteen years later, this unhappy and uncommunicative husband takes Dorcas and their fifteen-year-old son Cyrus to the frontier, presumably to resettle but really to “bury” Roger and expiate his own guilt. On the anniversary of the day Reuben had left Roger, Dorcas and Cyrus are led to the rock and the now blasted oak tree, a fatal gunshot is fired, and in a chillingly ambiguous way Reuben relieves himself of his “curse.” This pattern of irrational guilt and ambivalent quest would be repeated in other stories, using New England historical incidents and pervasive symbols such as the rock and oak of “Roger Malvin’s Burial.” “My Kinsman, Major Molineux” • “My Kinsman, Major Molineux” is justly considered one of Hawthorne’s greatest stories. The historical introduction here serves to establish the setting as a time of bitter resentment toward Massachusetts colonial governors. The location is left deliberately vague, except that Robin, the young protagonist, must arrive by ferry in a town where he hopes to meet his kinsman, a colonial official. Robin has come from the country with an idea of getting a boost toward a career from Major Molineux. The town is tense and lurid when he enters at nightfall, and the people act strangely. In particular, whenever Robin mentions the name of his kinsman, he is rebuffed. Although frequently described as “shrewd,” Robin seems naive and baffled by the events of this disquieting evening. Eventually, he is treated to the nightmarish spectacle of the public humiliation of his kinsman, though it appears that Major Molineux is the more or less innocent victim of colonial vindictiveness toward the authority of the Crown. At the climax, Robin finds himself unaccountably laughing with the townspeople at Molineux’s disgrace. By the end of the evening, Robin, convinced that nothing remains for him to do but to return home, is counseled by the only civil person he meets to wait a few days before leaving, “as you are a shrewd youth, you may rise in the world without the help of your kinsman, Major Molineux.” At one level, this is clearly a rites-of-passage story. Robin has reached the point of initiation into an adult world whose deviousness and obliquity he has hardly begun to suspect, but one in which he can hope to prosper only through his own efforts. The conclusion strongly implies that he cannot go home again, or that if he does, life will never be the same. As the stranger suggests, he may well be obliged to stay and adjust to the new world that he has discovered. The historical setting proclaims “My Kinsman, Major Molineux” an imaginative account of the colonial struggle toward the challenges and perils of an independence for which the people are largely unprepared. The ferry ride, reminiscent of the underworld adventures of epic heroes such as Odysseus and Aeneas—and perhaps more pointedly yet, the Dante of the Inferno— leads to a hellish region from which newcomers cannot normally expect to return. The multiplicity of interpretations that this story has provoked attests to its richness and complexity. Several of Hawthorne’s best stories first appeared in 1835. One of these, “Wakefield,” has been criticized as slight and undeveloped, but it remains intriguing. It
Hawthorne, Nathaniel
479
poses in its final paragraph an exacting problem: “Amid the seeming confusion of our mysterious world, individuals are so nicely adjusted to a system, and systems to one another and to a whole, that, by stepping aside for a moment, a man exposes himself to a fearful risk of losing his place forever.” Wakefield “steps aside” by leaving his wife for no apparent reason and secretly taking up residence in the next street. The setting of this story, unusual for Hawthorne, is London, and the couple have been married for ten years. Wakefield seems to be an embryonic version of the ruthless experimenter of several later stories, but here his action is more of a joke than an experiment. He is “intellectual, but not actively so”; he lacks imagination; and he has “a cold but not depraved nor wandering heart.” When he leaves, he promises to be back in three or four days, but he stays away for twenty years. He adopts a disguise, regularly walks by his old home and peers in, and even passes his wife in the street. Wakefield has a purpose that he cannot define, but the author describes his motive merely as “morbid vanity.” He will frighten his wife and will find out how much he really matters. He does not matter that much, however, for his wife settles into the routine of her “widowhood.” Finally, passing his old home in a rain shower, he suddenly decides to enter, and at this point the story ends, leaving unanswered the question of whether he has lost his place forever. “The Minister’s Black Veil” • Of the many Hawthorne stories that point toward his masterpiece in the novel The Scarlet Letter, “The Minister’s Black Veil” boasts the character most akin to Arthur Dimmesdale of the novel. Like Dimmesdale, Parson Hooper has a secret. He appears one morning at a Milford meeting house (a reference to “Governor Belcher” appears to place the story in Massachusetts in the 1730’s or early 1740’s) with his face shrouded by a black veil, which he never thereafter removes. Unlike Dimmesdale, he thus flaunts his secret while concealing it. The whole story revolves around the veil and its meaning. His sermon, unusually energetic for this mild minister, is “secret sin.” That afternoon, Hooper conducts a funeral service for a young woman, and Hawthorne hints darkly that Hooper’s sin may have involved her. In the evening, at a third service, Hooper’s veil casts gloom over a wedding ceremony. The congregation speculates endlessly but inclines to avoid the minister. One person who does not avoid him is a young woman named Elizabeth, who is engaged to Hooper. Elizabeth unavailingly begs him to explain or remove the veil and then breaks their engagement. In the years that follow, the lonely minister exerts a strange power over his flock. Dying sinners always insist on his visiting them and never expire before he reaches them, although his presence makes them shudder. Finally, Hooper himself sickens, and Elizabeth reappears to nurse him. On his death bed, he questions the aversion of his onlookers and insists that he sees a similar veil over each of their faces. He then expires and is buried with the veil still over his face. A question more important than the nature of Hooper’s transgression concerns his increase in ministerial efficacy. Is Hooper’s veiled state a kind of extended stage trick? (In death a smile lingers on his face.) Is it advantageous to be ministered to by a “mind diseased?” Is Hooper’s effectiveness an implicit condemnation of his and his congregation’s religion? Such questions Hawthorne’s story almost inevitably raises and almost equally inevitably does not presume to answer directly. “The May-Pole of Merrymount” • “The May-Pole of Merrymount” is simple in plot but complex in theme. One midsummer’s eve, very early in the colonial life of the
480
Short Story Writers
Massachusetts settlement at Mount Wollaston, or Merry Mount, a reenactment of ancient Maypole rites accompanies the wedding of an attractive young couple, Edith and Edgar. Into the scene storms a belligerent group of Puritans under John Endicott, who hacks down the Maypole, arrests the principals, including the flowerdecked priest and the bridal couple, and threatens punishment to all, though Edith’s and Edgar’s will be light if they can accommodate themselves to the severe Puritan life hereafter. Hawthorne uses history but does not follow it strictly. The historical Endicott’s main motive in attacking Merry Mount was to stop its denizens from furnishing firepower and firewater—that is, guns and liquor—to Native Americans. The real Merry Mounters were not so frivolous, nor the Puritans necessarily so austere as Hawthorne depicts them. His artistic purpose required the sharp contrast of two ways of life among early Massachusetts settlers, neither of which he is willing to endorse. The young couple are caught between the self-indulgence of their own community and the “dismal wretches” who invade their ceremony. Like many of Hawthorne’s characters, Edith and Edgar emerge into adulthood in an environment replete with bewildering moral conflicts. It is possible to see the conflict here as one between “English” and “American” values, the Americans being the sober seekers of a new, more disciplined, presumably more godly order than the one they chose to leave behind; the conflict can also be seen as one between a form of religion receptive to “pagan” excesses and a strict, fiercely intolerant one; yet another way of seeing it is as one between hedonists and sadists—for the pleasure principle completely dominates Hawthorne’s Merry Mount, while the Puritans promise branding, chopping of ears, and, instead of a Maypole, a whipping post for the miscreants. The resolution of the story echoes John Milton’s description of Adam and Eve leaving Eden at the end of Paradise Lost (1667), but Hawthorne has Endicott throw a wreath of roses from the Maypole over the heads of the departing newlyweds, “a deed of prophecy,” which signifies the end of the “systematic gayety” of Merry Mount, which also symbolizes the “purest and best of their early joys” that must sustain them in the strict Puritan regimen that lies ahead. “Young Goodman Brown” • “Young Goodman Brown,” first appearing in print in 1835, is set in Salem at the end of the seventeenth century—the era of the witchcraft trials. Again, the names of some minor characters are historical, but Brown and his wife, Faith, whom the young protagonist leaves one night to go into the woods, are among his most allegorical. In its outline the allegory is transparent: When a “good man” abandons his faith, he can expect to go to the devil. Hawthorne complicates his story by weaving into it all sorts of subtleties and ambiguities. Brown’s guide in the woods is simultaneously fatherlike and devilish. He encounters a series of presumably upright townspeople, including eventually Faith herself, gathering for a ceremony of devil-worship. At the climactic moment, Brown urges Faith to “look up to heaven, and resist the wicked one.” The next thing he knows, he is alone in the forest, all his companions having fled—or all having been part of a dream. Brown returns home in the morning, his life radically altered. He can no longer trust his neighbors, he shrinks from his wife, and he lives out his years a scowling, muttering misanthrope. As in “The May-Pole of Merrymount,” Hawthorne’s motive in evoking an episode of New England history is not primarily historical: No one proceeds against witches; there is no allusion to Judge John Hathorne. Rather, the setting creates an atmo-
Hawthorne, Nathaniel
481
sphere of guilt, suspicion, and unstable moral imagination. Breathing this atmosphere, Brown falls victim not to injustice or religious intolerance but to himself. In a sense it does not matter whether Brown fell asleep in the woods and dreamed the Black Sabbath. Regardless of whether he has lost faith, he has manifestly lost hope. His apparent capacity to resist evil in the midst of a particularly unholy temptation dispels his own guilt no more than the guilt he, and seemingly only he, detects in others. “Young Goodman Brown” is a masterful fictive presentation of the despairing soul. All the preceding stories had been published by the time Hawthorne turned thirty-one. For about three more years, stories continued to flow, although most of those from the late 1830’s are not among his best. He broke a subsequent dry spell with a series of stories first published in 1843 and 1844, many of which were later collected in Mosses from an Old Manse in 1846. Most notable of these later stories are “The Birthmark,” “The Artist of the Beautiful,” and “Rappaccini’s Daughter.” “The Birthmark” • In these later efforts, the artist-scientist appears frequently. Aylmer of “The Birthmark” becomes obsessed by the one flaw in his beautiful wife, Georgiana, a birthmark on her left cheek that had not previously bothered her or her prior lovers. To Aylmer, however, it is a “symbol of imperfection,” and he undertakes its removal. Hawthorne foreshadows the result in many ways, not the least by Georgiana’s observation that her brilliant husband’s “most splendid successes were almost invariably failures.” She submits to the operation nevertheless, and he succeeds at removing the mark but fails to preserve her life, intertwined somehow with it. Aylmer equates science with religion; words such as “miracle,” “votaries,” “mysteries,” and “holy” abound. He is also an artist who, far from subjecting Georgiana to a smoky laboratory, fashions an apartment with beautiful curtains and perfumed lamps of his creation for her to inhabit during the experiment. Neither hero nor villain, Aylmer is a gifted man incapable of accepting moral limitations and therefore unable to accept his wife as the best that life could offer him. The artist appears in various guises in Hawthorne’s later stories and novels. He may be a wood-carver as in “Drowne’s Wooden Image,” a poet like Coverdale of The Blithedale Romance, a painter like Kenyon of The Marble Faun, or, as in “The Artist of the Beautiful,” a watchmaker with the ambition “to put the very spirit of beauty into form.” Owen Warland is also a peripheral figure, not yet alienated from society like many twentieth century artists real and fictional but regarded as quaint and ineffectual by his companions. Like Aylmer, he attempts to improve on nature, his creation being a mechanical butterfly of rare and fragile beauty. Owen appears fragile himself, but it is part of Hawthorne’s strategy to reveal his inner toughness. He can contemplate the destruction of his butterfly by a child with equanimity, for the artifact itself is only the “symbol” of the reality of art. Owen suffers in living among less sensitive and spiritual beings and in patiently enduring their unenlightened patronization, but he finds security in his capacity for beauty. “Rappaccini’s Daughter” • “Rappaccini’s Daughter” has three familiar Hawthorne characters. His young initiate this time is an Italian university student named Giovanni Guasconti, whose lodgings in Padua overlook a spectacular garden, the pride and joy of a scientific experimenter, Dr. Rappaccini, whose human subject is his daughter Beatrice. A scientific rival, professor Baglioni, warns Giovanni that Rappaccini much
482
Short Story Writers
prefers science to humankind, but the young man falls in love with Beatrice and thus comes within Rappaccini’s orbit. This scientist is more sinister than Aylmer and exerts his power over Beatrice more pervasively than does Aylmer over Georgiana. Beatrice’s very life is bound up with the powerful poison with which he grows the exotic flowers in his garden. Giovanni, who has himself imbibed the poison, tries to counter its effect on Beatrice by offering her a medicine obtained from Baglioni, but its effect on her, whose whole life has depended on the poison, is fatal. This story and its four main characters have generated a bewildering variety of interpretations. One reason for the critical quarrels is a subtle shift in point of view late in the story. For most of the way, the reader is with Giovanni and knows what Giovanni knows, but about four-fifths of the way, an omniscient narrator begins to comment on the limitations of his perceptions, the truth being deeper than he can plumb. This double perspective creates difficulties in gauging his character and that of the other three principals. Hawthorne’s allegorical propensities also complicate one’s understanding of the story. For example, Beatrice can be seen as an Eve, an already corrupted temptress in the garden; as a Dantean, who guides her lover through what is for him, initially at least, Paradise; and as the Pomona of Ovid’s tale of Vertumnus, the vegetarian god who wins her love and takes her away. (There is a statue of Vertumnus in Rappaccini’s garden.) Obviously, Beatrice is not consistently any of these figures, but each of them leads to further allegorizing. Perhaps the ultimate explanation of the interpretive difficulties arising from “Rappaccini’s Daughter” is the author’s profound ambivalence. In this fictional world, good and evil, beauty and deformity, are inextricably intermingled. Is Baglioni, for example, wise counselor or jealous rival, the protector of Giovanni or the vindictive agent of Beatrice’s destruction? He fulfills these roles and others. In this story he conjoins with three other familiar Hawthorne types, the young initiate into life’s malignities, the trusting victim of a detached manipulator, and the insensitive violator of his victim’s integrity. Nearly every conceivable critical method has been applied to “Rappaccini’s Daughter”; ultimately each reader must make up his or her own mind about its primary significance. After these three stories of the mid-1840’s, all viewed incidentally as landmarks of science fiction by historians of that genre, Hawthorne, back in Salem and busy with his customhouse duties, wrote little for several years. Before turning his attention to long fiction in 1850, however, he completed a few more short stories in the late 1840’s, the most important of which is “Ethan Brand.” “Ethan Brand” • Like several of his best stories, this one occupies the time from nightfall to the following dawn, but unlike “Young Goodman Brown” and “My Kinsman, Major Molineux” it has a contemporary setting. Bartram is a lime burner attending his fire on Mount Greylock in northwestern Massachusetts with his son Joe, when a man appears, a former lime burner who long ago decided to devote his life to searching for the Unpardonable Sin, which, by cultivating his intellect at the expense of his moral sense, he found in his own heart. All this he explains to the unimaginative and uncomprehending Bartram. The sensitive son fears the glint in the stranger’s eye, and even Bartram cringes at Ethan Brand’s sinister laugh. Since Brand has passed into local folklore, Bartram dispatches Joe to inform the villagers that he is back, and soon a contingent of neighbors comes on the scene. When Brand demonstrates his abrogation of human brotherhood, they retire, and Brand offers to
Hawthorne, Nathaniel
483
watch Bartram’s fire so that the latter and his son can retire for the night to their nearby hut. When Bartram and Joe awake in the morning, they find Brand gone, but a look into the fire reveals his skeleton burned to lime, his hardened heart also burnt but distinctly outlined. What was the sin? Hawthorne subtitled this story “A Chapter from an Abortive Romance.” No fragments of such a romance have ever turned up, although the story alludes briefly to past relationships between Brand and some of the villagers, including an “Esther” on whom Brand had performed a “psychological experiment, and wasted, absorbed, and perhaps annihilated her soul, in the process.” Hawthorne seems to have intended no specifying of this or any other of Brand’s activities but succeeded in delineating a character who represents the ultimate development—at least in his short fiction—of the coldly intellectual seeker who has denied his heart, exploited others in relentless quasi-scientific experimentation, and isolated himself from humanity. Hawthorne would depict such characters in more detail in his novels but never one who acknowledged his sin so completely and regarded suicide as the only act remaining to him. At one time, Hawthorne’s short stories were viewed mainly as preliminaries to the novels to which he turned shortly after publishing “Ethan Brand” in January of 1850, but he is now recognized as a master of the short story. Unlike all other major American writers of his time, he devoted his creative energies almost exclusively to fiction. Only Edgar Allan Poe, who began to publish his fiction shortly after Hawthorne’s early stories appeared, approaches his position as the United States’ first artist of short fiction. If Poe excelled at the psychology of terror, Hawthorne prevailed at the psychology of guilt. Both brilliantly characterized the isolated or alienated individual, but only Hawthorne regularly enriched the cultural significance of his stories by locating these characters within the context of an American past and thus contributing imaginatively to his readers’ sense of that past. Robert P. Ellis Other major works children’s literature: Grandfather’s Chair, 1841; Biographical Stories for Children, 1842; True Stories from History and Biography, 1851; A Wonder-Book for Boys and Girls, 1852; Tanglewood Tales for Boys and Girls, 1853. edited text: Peter Parley’s Universal History, 1837. novels: Fanshawe: A Tale, 1828; The Scarlet Letter, 1850; The House of the Seven Gables, 1851; The Blithedale Romance, 1852; The Marble Faun, 1860; Septimius Felton, 1872 (fragment); The Dolliver Romance, 1876 (fragment); Doctor Grimshawe’s Secret, 1883 (fragment); The Ancestral Footstep, 1883 (fragment). miscellaneous: Complete Works, 1850-1882 (13 volumes); The Complete Writings of Nathaniel Hawthorne, 1900 (22 volumes); The Centenary Edition of the Works of Nathaniel Hawthorne, 1962-1997 (23 volumes). nonfiction: Life of Franklin Pierce, 1852; Our Old Home, 1863; The American Notebooks, 1941; The French and Italian Notebooks, 1980; Letters of Nathaniel Hawthorne, 19841987 (4 volumes); Selected Letters of Nathaniel Hawthorne, 2002 (Joel Myerson, editor). Bibliography Bunge, Nancy. Nathaniel Hawthorne: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1993. Discusses Hawthorne’s major short stories in three categories: isolation and
484
Short Story Writers
community, artists and scientists, and perspective, humility, and joy. Includes excerpts from Hawthorne’s journals, letters, and prefaces; also includes excerpts on Hawthorne from Herman Melville, Edgar Allan Poe, Henry James, and several contemporary critics. Keil, James C. “Hawthorne’s ‘Young Goodman Brown’: Early Nineteenth-Century and Puritan Constructions of Gender.” The New England Quarterly 69 (March, 1996): 33-55. Argues that Hawthorne places his story in the seventeenth century to explore the nexus of past and present in the attitudes of New Englanders toward theology, morality, and sexuality. Points out that clear boundaries between male and female, public and private, and work and home were thresholds across which nineteenth century Americans often passed. Kelsey, Angela M. “Mrs. Wakefield’s Gaze: Femininity and Dominance in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s ‘Wakefield.’” ATQ, n.s. 8 (March, 1994): 17-31. In this feminist reading of Hawthorne’s story, Kelsey argues that Mrs. Wakefield finds ways to escape and exceed the economy of the male gaze, first by appropriating the look for herself, then by refusing to die, and finally by denying her husband her gaze. Mackenzie, Manfred. “Hawthorne’s ‘Roger Malvin’s Burial’: A Postcolonial Reading.” New Literary History 27 (Summer, 1996): 459-472. Argues that the story is postcolonial fiction in which Hawthorne writes the emerging American nation and recalls European colonial culture; claims that Hawthorne rehearses the colonialist past in order to concentrate and effectively “expel” its inherent violence. McKee, Kathryn B. “‘A Small Heap of Glittering Fragments’: Hawthorne’s Discontent with the Short Story Form.” ATQ, n.s. 8 (June, 1994): 137-147. Claims that Hawthorne’s “Artist of the Beautiful” and “Downe’s Wooden Image” are examples of his dissatisfaction with the short story as a form; argues that the fragile articles at the center of the tales mirror the limitations Hawthorne saw in the short-story genre. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of eleven short stories by Hawthorne: “The Ambitious Guest,” “The Artist of the Beautiful,” and “The Birthmark” (vol. 1); “Dr. Heidegger’s Experiment” (vol. 2); “Ethan Brand: A Chapter from an Abortive Romance” (vol. 3); “The Minister’s Black Veil” and “My Kinsman, Major Molineux” (vol. 5); “Rappaccini’s Daughter” and “Roger Malvin’s Burial” (vol. 6); and “Wakefield” and “Young Goodman Brown” (vol. 8). Newman, Lea Bertani Vozar. A Reader’s Guide to the Short Stories of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1979. For each of fifty-four stories, this valuable guide furnishes a chapter with four sections: publication history; circumstances of composition, sources, and influences; relationship with other Hawthorne works; and interpretations and criticism. The discussions are arranged alphabetically by title and keyed to a bibliography of more than five hundred secondary sources. Scharnhorst, Gary. The Critical Response to Hawthorne’s “The Scarlet Letter.” New York: Greenwood Press, 1992. Includes chapters on the novel’s background and composition history, on the contemporary American reception, on the early British reception, on the growth of Hawthorne’s reputation after his death, on modern criticism, and on The Scarlet Letter on stage and screen.
Hawthorne, Nathaniel
485
Swope, Richard. “Approaching the Threshold(s) in Postmodern Detective Fiction: Hawthorne’s ‘Wakefield’ and Other Missing Persons.” Critique 39 (Spring, 1998): 207-227. Discusses “Wakefield” as a literary ancestor of “metaphysical” detective fiction, a postmodern genre that combines fiction with literary theory. “Wakefield” raises many of the questions about language, subjectivity, and urban spaces that surround postmodernism. Von Frank, Albert J., ed. Critical Essays on Hawthorne’s Short Stories. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1991. Divided into nineteenth and twentieth century commentary, with a section of new essays, an introduction, and a chronology of the tales. Wineapple, Brenda. Hawthorne: A Life. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2003. Analysis of Hawthorne’s often contradictory life that proposes that many of Hawthorne’s stories are autobiographical.
486
Ernest Hemingway Born: Oak Park, Illinois; July 21, 1899 Died: Ketchum, Idaho; July 2, 1961 Principal short fiction • Three Stories and Ten Poems, 1923; In Our Time, 1924, 1925; Men Without Women, 1927; Winner Take Nothing, 1933; The Fifth Column and the First Forty-nine Stories, 1938; The Snows of Kilimanjaro, and Other Stories, 1961; The Nick Adams Stories, 1972; The Complete Stories of Ernest Hemingway, 1987. Other literary forms • During the four decades in which Ernest Hemingway worked at his craft, he published seven novels, a collection of fictional sketches, and two nonfiction accounts of his experiences in Spain and in Africa; he also edited a collection of war stories and produced a considerable number of magazine and newspaper articles. The latter have been collected in posthumous editions. Manuscripts of two unfinished novels, a series of personal reminiscences, and a longer version of a bullfighting chronicle have been edited and published posthumously as well. In 1981, Hemingway’s first biographer, Carlos Baker, brought out an edition of the writer’s correspondence. Achievements • After spending a decade in relative obscurity, Ernest Hemingway finally became a best-selling author with the appearance of A Farewell to Arms in 1929. His long association with the publishing firm Charles Scribner’s Sons, where the legendary Max Perkins was his editor for more than two decades, assured him wide publicity and a large audience. His passion for high adventure and his escapades as a womanizer made him as famous for his lifestyle as for his literary accomplishments. For Whom the Bell Tolls (1940) was selected to receive the Pulitzer Prize in 1940, but the award was vetoed. In 1952, the Pulitzer committee did give its annual prize to The Old Man and the Sea (1952). Two years later, Hemingway was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature. Even more significant than these personal awards has been the influence that Hemingway has exerted on American letters. His spare style has become a model for authors, especially short-story writers. Further, Hemingway has received significant critical attention, though not all of it laudatory. His tough, macho attitude toward life and his treatment of women have been the subjects of hostile reviews by feminist critics during the 1970’s and 1980’s. Biography • Ernest Hemingway was born in Oak Park, Illinois, a Chicago suburb, in 1899, the second child of Clarence (Ed) and Grace Hemingway’s six children. Growing up in a doctor’s house, under the domination of a forceful mother, would provide Ernest grist for his literary mill in years to come. The family’s frequent trips to northern Michigan would also figure in his development as a writer, providing him a locale for numerous stories and an appreciation for wild terrain. After graduating from high school, Hemingway left Chicago to take a job on the Kansas City Star. Shortly after the United States entered World War I, he quit his job and went to Italy as a Red Cross volunteer. There, he was wounded while
Hemingway, Ernest
487
assisting Italian soldiers. He spent several weeks in a Milan hospital, where he met Agnes von Kurowsky, who would serve as a model for Catherine Barkeley in A Farewell to Arms. Hemingway returned to the U.S. in 1919 and began writing stories— none of which sold. In 1920, he met Hadley Richardson, whom he married the following year. They returned to Europe late in 1921, and for the next decade, Hemingway spent his time in Paris or in other locales on the Continent, sharpening his skills as a short-story writer. Two collections of his work were published by literary presses. The many expatriates who he met in Paris served as models for his first fulllength novel, The Sun Also Rises, which appeared to favorable reviews in 1926. In the same year, he and Hadley separated, and Hemingway © The Nobel Foundation pursued his relationship with Pauline Pfeiffer, whom he married in 1927. In 1928, Hemingway began the novel that would establish his reputation, A Farewell to Arms. Published in 1929, it sold quite well and freed the novelist to pursue other interests for several years. Though he had his residence in Key West, Florida, during the 1930’s, he spent considerable time in Spain studying the art of bullfighting and took Pauline on a big-game safari in Africa. Out of these experiences came Death in the Afternoon (1932) and The Green Hills of Africa (1935); neither received the acclaim that the earlier novels had enjoyed. In 1937, Hemingway managed to secure a position as a reporter to cover the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939). While in Spain, he spent most of his time with Martha Gellhorn, a young writer whom he had met the previous year in Florida. They were married in 1939 after Hemingway divorced Pauline. The Spanish Civil War furnished him materials for a major novel, For Whom the Bell Tolls, and a play, The Fifth Column (1938), which had a brief run on Broadway. After the outbreak of World War II, Hemingway found a way to be with the American troops, joining his third wife as a war correspondent in Europe. His relationship with Gellhorn deteriorated as the war progressed, and by 1945, they had agreed to divorce. Hemingway made Mary Welsh his fourth wife in 1946, after courting her for two years. The two spent Hemingway’s remaining years together in Cuba or in various retreats in the United States and in Europe. During the years following World War II, Hemingway started several major projects, but few came to fruition. A notable exception was The Old Man and the Sea, which ran in Life magazine, sold millions in hardback, and became a motion picture. Growing bouts of depression became harder and harder to fight off, however, and in 1961, Hemingway finally committed suicide while staying at his second home, in Ketchum, Idaho.
488
Short Story Writers
Analysis • Any study of Ernest Hemingway’s short stories must begin with a discussion of style. Reacting against the overblown, rhetorical, and often bombastic narrative techniques of his predecessors, Hemingway spent considerable time as a young man working to perfect the spare form of narration, dialogue, and description that became the hallmark of his fiction. Nowhere does he achieve greater mastery of his medium than in his short stories. He expressed his belief and described his own method in a passage in Death in the Afternoon: “If a writer of prose knows enough about what he is writing about he may omit things that he knows and the reader, if the writer is writing truly enough, will have a feeling of those things as strongly as though the writer has stated them.” Following this dictum, Hemingway constructed stories that sometimes make readers feel as if they are unseen auditors at some closet drama, or silent observers at intimate moments in the lives of characters struggling with important, although often private, issues. “Hills Like White Elephants” • The technique is readily apparent in “Hills Like White Elephants.” Set in Spain during the hot summer, the story contains little overt action. Hemingway sketches the background deftly in a single opening paragraph of half a dozen sentences, each of which provides vital information that establishes a physical setting and a symbolic backdrop for the tale. On one side of the little junction station, there are fertile fields; on the other, a barren landscape. Only three characters appear: a man identified as an American, a girl, and a woman who serves them in the little café at which they have stopped to wait for the train that passes through the unnamed town on the route from Barcelona to Madrid. The entire story consists of a single scene in which the man and the girl sit in the café, drink various alcoholic beverages, and converse. Much of the dialogue seems little more than small talk, but there is an underlying sense of tension from the very first exchange between the man and the girl after they order their beer. The girl mentions that the hills in the distance “look like white elephants,” to which her companion replies, “I’ve never seen one.” She immediately responds, “No, you wouldn’t have,” and he fires back, “I might have. . . . Just because you say I wouldn’t have doesn’t prove anything.” The harshness of their responses contrasts with the inconsequential nature of the subject of their discussion, suggesting that the relationship between them is somehow strained but that neither wishes to discuss openly the real issue over which they are at odds. For nearly half the story, the two try to make conversation that will ease the tension, but their remarks serve only to heighten it. The man finally mentions, in an almost offhand way, the subject that is really on his mind: He wants the woman to have an abortion. “It’s really an awfully simple operation,” he tells her. “It’s just to let the air in. . . . it’s all perfectly natural.” The woman, who sits silent through his pleading, finally replies, “Then what will we do afterward?” The man repeatedly assures her that things will be fine if she agrees only to terminate her pregnancy, since in his view the baby will destroy the lifestyle to which they have become accustomed. The woman is wiser; she knows that their relationship has already been poisoned forever and that her pregnancy is not the sole cause. Theirs has been a peripatetic, rootless life, as barren in some ways as the countryside in which they now find themselves. This summary of the story, like summaries of so many of Hemingway’s stories, is inevitably an artificial construct that does not convey the sense of significance that readers get from discovering the larger issues lurking beneath the surface of the dialogue and description. This story is about choice, a vital choice for the woman, who
Hemingway, Ernest
489
must face the dilemma of either acquiescing to the man’s wishes and undergoing what is for her more than a routine operation or risking the loss of a man for whom she has had some genuine feelings of love. Ultimately, either through his insistence or through her own realization that she must try to salvage their relationship even though she senses it will be futile to do so, she agrees to his demands. Her closing remark, on which the story ends, carries with it the strong note of cynicism that pervades the entire story: “I feel fine,” she tells the man as they wait for the train’s imminent arrival. In addition to his distinctive style, Hemingway has made his mark in the literary world through the creation of a special kind of hero. The “Hemingway hero,” as this figure has come to be known, is usually a man scarred by some traumatic experience—war, violence, a love affair gone bad. Often a physical maiming serves as a symbolic reminder of the psychological dysfunction that characterizes these figures. Despite having received a bad deal from the world, the Hemingway hero perseveres in his search for a good life, creating his own meaning out of the chaos of existence— the hallmark of existential heroes in both American and continental literature. These heroes do what is right without expecting reward, either in this life or in the next. “In Another Country” • Two fine examples of Hemingway heroes appear in the story “In Another Country.” The tale is set in Italy during World War I. A young American officer is recuperating at an Italian hospital, where he mingles with Italian soldiers who have seen considerably more action than he has seen. The extent of their physical injuries mirrors the psychological scars that the war has inflicted on them. One of them, a major who had been a champion fencer before the war, diligently undergoes therapy on a machine designed to restore his withered hand. He is hard on the young American for entertaining thoughts that full recovery for any of them is possible, yet he insists that they all go through the motions—not only with their therapy but also with other activities as well. He demands that the young man learn Italian correctly, for example, arguing that one must follow the rules in life, even when they seem meaningless. Clearly bitter over his fate, he nevertheless keeps up his treatment, until an even more ironic blow strikes him: His young wife contracts pneumonia, and while he is going through the motions to recover the use of a hand damaged beyond restoration, she lies dying. His anger at the cruelty of her impending senseless death drives him to lash out at the institution of marriage; when she dies, however, he breaks down in tears and abandons his therapy. The young American, witness to the Italian’s great love, comes to understand how nothing of value can last in this world. The lesson is bitter, but it is one that Hemingway heroes must learn if they are to go on living in a world where the only certainties are chance and chaos. The young American in “In Another Country” is similar to the main figure in Hemingway’s stories, Nick Adams. Seen often as an alter ego for the writer himself, Nick appears in almost twenty stories, and from them readers can piece together his history. A youth who spends time in Michigan and who has many of his ideals shattered by his participation in World War I, Nick develops the characteristics of the Hemingway hero: He becomes convinced of the world’s essential callousness, yet he steels himself against its cruelties by observing the rituals that give his own life meaning. Hence, in “Big Two-Hearted River,” Nick uses the activities associated with fishing as a kind of therapy to recover from the trauma of war.
490
Short Story Writers
“The Killers” • One of the most anthologized of the Nick Adams stories is “The Killers.” In this tale, Nick is a young man, still quite naïve and still given to romanticizing events in his life. Two Chicago gunmen arrive at the small diner where Nick is eating. They bully the waiter, bind and gag Nick and the cook, and wait impatiently for a boxer named Ole Andresen, a frequent patron of the diner, so that they can kill him. When Andresen fails to come to dinner, the gangsters finally leave. Knowing that they will seek out Andresen, Nick runs to the boxer’s boarding house to warn him. Surprisingly, Andresen refuses to run away; he is content to wait for whatever fate brings him. Nick cannot understand how anyone can accept his lot with such resignation. The lesson for him—and for Hemingway’s readers—is that there comes a point when it is impossible to keep moving on, to keep effecting changes by running away. All people must stand and meet the destiny allotted to them, no matter how bitter and unfair that may seem. “Soldier’s Home” • Like Nick Adams and the young American in “In Another Country,” the hero of “Soldier’s Home” has been scarred by his experience in World War I and has discovered upon his return to his hometown that he cannot find a sympathetic audience for his complaints. The people who did not go to war have already formed their opinions of what happened “over there” and have spent their patriotic energies feting the first groups of returning servicemen. Krebs, the protagonist of the tale, had remained in Germany with the occupation forces for a year beyond the declaration of the armistice. He is greeted with suspicion by his fellow townspeople; they cannot understand why he has waited so long to come home. When he tries to tell people what the war was actually like for him, he is rebuffed. He finds that only when he invents tales of heroism do people pay attention to him. Krebs has slipped into a continual state of ennui; no suggestion for action, either from family or friends, strikes him as worthwhile. In this sense, he fails to fulfill the role of typical Hemingway heroes, most of whom go on doggedly with their lives, all the while knowing that their efforts are doomed to failure. The overriding atmosphere of this story is one of pessimism, almost defeatism without hint of defiance—a rather unusual stance for Hemingway. Two of Hemingway’s greatest short stories are set in Africa, a land to which the author traveled on safari in 1933-1934. Often anthologized and frequently the subject of critical discussion, both “The Snows of Kilimanjaro” and “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” detail relationships between weak men and strong women, displaying Hemingway’s hostility toward women who seem to prey upon men, sapping their creativity and in some cases emasculating them. “The Snows of Kilimanjaro” • “The Snows of Kilimanjaro” tells the story of a writer who is no longer able to practice his craft. Harry, the protagonist, has lost his ability to write well, having chosen to live a life of adventure and luxury. When the story opens, Harry is lying on a cot in the African plains, dying of the gangrene that he contracted by failing to take routine care of a scratch. Much of the story is given over to dialogue between Harry and his wife (presumably his second or third wife), a rich woman on whom he depends now for his livelihood; the tension in their marriage is seen by Harry at times as the cause of his inability to produce the kind of work that had once made him the darling of critics and the public. As Harry sees it, “He had destroyed his talent by not using it, by betrayals of himself and what he believed in.” In his imagination, he writes fragments of the wonderful tales that he wishes
Hemingway, Ernest
491
to tell; these are presented in italic passages interspersed throughout the story. Though the wife holds out hope that she will be able to get Harry back to a hospital, the writer knows that he is condemned to die of his wound—itself a trivial cut, but in this case fatal because of the circumstances in which Harry finds himself. The physical landscape mirrors Harry’s failed aspirations. He is dying on the plains in sight of Africa’s highest mountain; he can see the summit, but he knows he will never reach it. Similarly, the gangrenous wound and the resultant decay parallels the decay of the writer who fails to use his talents. Both the striving for some imaginary heights and the senseless destruction of the hero are highlighted in the short epigraph that begins the story. In it, Hemingway notes the presence of a leopard carcass, frozen near the summit of Kilimanjaro. “No one has explained,” Hemingway writes, “what the leopard was seeking at that altitude.” No one can really explain, either, why men such as Harry strive to be good writers, nor can anyone explain why some succeed while others are blocked from achieving their goals. Hemingway portrays the wife in this story with only a modicum of sympathy. She seems concerned about her husband, but only because she entertains some romantic notion that believing strongly in something will make it so; she is convinced that she can save her husband despite clear evidence that he is beyond hope. Harry calls her names and blames her for his failure, and though he realizes in the moments before he dies that she is not actually the cause of his failure—“when he went to her [to marry her] he was already over”—she never achieves a level of dignity that merits the reader’s sympathy. “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” • The story that critics often cite as Hemingway’s finest is also set in Africa. “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” details the relationship of Francis and Margot Macomber, wealthy Americans on an extended hunt with their professional guide, Robert Wilson. Told nonchronologically, the story reveals Francis’s initial cowardice in the face of danger, his eventual triumph over his fear, and his untimely death at the moment when he is able to display his courage. It would be hard to characterize Francis Macomber as a Hemingway hero. In fact, he is quite the opposite. He has money, but he possesses none of the qualities that Hemingway considers admirable in a man. Francis is dominated psychologically by his wife, and much of what he does is aimed at proving his manhood to her. Their African safari is but another effort on his part to display his worthiness for her continued affection. Unfortunately, Francis is a coward. The story opens with a scene that displays the strain that he is under, having just displayed his inability to stand up to danger. Through conversation among the three principal characters, the reader is able to infer that Francis had failed to complete a kill on a lion he had wounded. When he had gone into the bush to finish off the animal, the lion had charged, and Francis had run away; Wilson had been forced to kill the animal. Margot had observed his behavior, and she is now openly disdainful of her husband. She even plays up to Wilson right in front of Francis. As a final insult, after the Macombers retire to their tent for the evening, Margot slips out and goes to Wilson’s tent to spend the night with him. The following day, Francis has a chance to redeem himself. He and Wilson go out to hunt again; this time the quarry is buffalo. Margot remains in the vehicle once more, and the incident with the lion is repeated: Macomber wounds a bull, which slumps off deep into the brush, and he must go in after the beast to finish the job that
492
Short Story Writers
he started. This time, when the bull charges, Francis holds his ground and fires at the animal, but the beast keeps on coming at him. Almost immediately, Margot fires from the car, but she hits her husband rather than the buffalo. Francis is killed instantly. Margot Macomber is a classic Hemingway woman—the kind for which Hemingway has been criticized severely in the years since feminist critics have gained influence in American literary studies. She is physically attractive, though she is reaching the age at which her beauty is starting to fade. She is portrayed as being almost desperate to find some kind of security and is willing to use her sexual wiles to obtain it. She is cruel toward Francis when he shows himself a coward: She rejects physical contact with him and openly fawns over Wilson, though she taunts him, too, about his rather callous attitude toward killing. When Wilson mentions that hunting from a car (which he had done with the Macombers earlier) is a violation of the sport hunting laws and doing so could cost him his license, Margot leaps on the opportunity to suggest that she will use this information to blackmail him at some later time. Unlike the Macombers, Wilson, Hemingway’s white hunter, possesses several of the qualities that the author admires. He is good at his job. He understands people like Francis and Margot, and he has little respect for either of them because they are essentially fakes. He makes his living by taking advantage of the desires of people like them to dabble in life’s more dangerous experiences. Having confronted danger almost every day, Wilson has become accustomed to living with his fears. He has even developed a certain callousness toward hunting and especially toward people who go on safaris. The behavior of the Macombers does not shock him. On the contrary, he is prepared for Margot’s gesture of infidelity; he carries a double cot with him so he can accommodate wives like her who find their husbands despicable and the white hunter irresistible. Though Wilson is not admirable, in his self-awareness he achieves a certain esteem that is clearly missing in either of the Macombers. The major critical question that dominates discussion of this story is: Did Margot kill her husband intentionally, or is Francis’s death an accident? This is not idle speculation, for the answer at which one arrives determines the interpretation of the story’s central theme. If Francis’s death is indeed accidental, one can argue that Hemingway is making an ironic statement about the nature of self-fulfillment. At the moment that Francis achieves his greatest personal triumph, his life is ended. The fates simply destroy the possibility of his taking control of his life now that he has displayed himself capable of facing danger. Few details in the story, however, suggest that Francis should be considered a real hero. He may appear heroic at the instant of his death, but nothing he does before he faces the buffalo makes him worthy of emulation, and little that follows his death indicates that he has won new respect or lasting remembrance. Wilson does remind Margot that, had he lived, Francis would have had the courage to leave his wife. One must remember, though, that Wilson is the person who accuses Margot of murdering her husband, and he is searching to attach a motive to Margot’s actions. If one assumes that Margot shoots her husband intentionally, the ending of the story prompts a different interpretation. Francis is a type of the man struggling to break free of the bond that strong women have placed on weak men—and, by extension perhaps, on all men. This harsh antifeminist viewpoint is supported by Hemingway’s portrayal of Margot as a classic femme fatale, valued for her beauty and grasping for security in a world where men ostensibly are dominant but where in reality women use their sexuality to gain and maintain control. Francis’s killing of the buf-
Hemingway, Ernest
493
falo is symbolic of his ability to destroy the barriers that are keeping him from breaking free of his wife; when she realizes what the event means, Margot takes immediate action to prevent her husband from carrying through on his triumph. However, Hemingway never lets the reader see into the mind of Margot Macomber (though he does share the inner thoughts of Francis, Wilson, and even the lion), so it is impossible to settle on a definitive reading of the wife’s motivation and hence of the story itself. As so often happens in real life, readers are left to draw conclusions for themselves from the events which they witness. A key scene in “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” may serve as a key to understanding Hemingway’s philosophy of life. After Macomber has wounded the lion, he and Wilson have a lengthy discussion about the necessity of going after the animal to kill it. “Why not leave him there?” Macomber asks. “It isn’t done,” Wilson replies; “But,” the professional hunter continues, “you don’t have to have anything to do with it [the final kill].” Wilson seems to be speaking for Hemingway here. Once something is started, it must be completed. Society depends on that dictum. This is more profound than it may seem at first. As anyone who has read Hemingway’s The Green Hills of Africa knows, the author sees the safari as a metaphor for life itself. The activities on the safari are self-generated: No one is forced to undertake anything on the hunt, but once one agrees to participate, one has an obligation to carry through according to the rules of the game. Wilson, who sees himself in terms of his profession, must finish the kill even if his dilettante employer refuses to do so. One’s duty, Hemingway says in Death in the Afternoon, is what one decides to do. Men and women are free to choose their destiny, knowing their struggle will always end in death; doing well that which they choose to do is what makes people heroic. Laurence W. Mazzeno Other major works novels: The Sun Also Rises, 1926; The Torrents of Spring, 1926; A Farewell to Arms, 1929; To Have and Have Not, 1937; For Whom the Bell Tolls, 1940; Across the River and into the Trees, 1950; The Old Man and the Sea, 1952; Islands in the Stream, 1970; The Garden of Eden, 1986; True at First Light, 1999. drama: Today Is Friday, pb. 1926; The Fifth Column, pb. 1938. nonfiction: Death in the Afternoon, 1932; Green Hills of Africa, 1935; A Moveable Feast, 1964; By-Line: Ernest Hemingway, Selected Articles and Dispatches of Four Decades, 1967; Ernest Hemingway: Selected Letters, 1917-1961, 1981; Dateline, Toronto: The Complete “Toronto Star” Dispatches, 1920-1924, 1985; The Dangerous Summer, 1985; Ernest Hemingway on Writing, 1999 (Larry W. Phillips, editor); Hemingway on Fishing, 2000 (Nick Lyons, editor); Hemingway on Hunting, 2001 (Sean Hemingway, editor); Hemingway on War, 2003 (Sean Hemingway, editor); Dear Papa, Dear Hotch: The Correspondence of Ernest Hemingway and A. E. Hotchner, 2005 (Albert J. DeFazio, III, editor); Hemingway and the Mechanisms of Change: Statements, Public Letters, Introductions, Forewords, Prefaces, Blurbs, Reviews, and Endorsements, 2006 (Matthew J. Bruccoli, editor). Bibliography Benson, Jackson J., ed. New Critical Approaches to the Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 1990. Section 1 covers critical approaches to Hemingway’s most important long fiction; section 2 concentrates on story techniques and themes; section 3 focuses on critical interpretations of the most impor-
494
Short Story Writers
tant stories; section 4 provides an overview of Hemingway criticism; section 5 contains a comprehensive checklist of Hemingway short fiction criticism from 1975 to 1989. Bloom, Harold, ed. Ernest Hemingway. Broomall, Pa.: Chelsea House, 2000. Includes articles by a variety of critics who treat topics such as Hemingway’s style, unifying devices, and visual techniques. Burgess, Anthony. Ernest Hemingway. New York: Thames and Hudson, 1999. Originally published in 1978 as Ernest Hemingway and His World, an insightful appreciation of Hemingway by one of Great Britain’s leading writers. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Dubus, Andre. “A Hemingway Story.” The Kenyon Review, n.s. 19 (Spring, 1997): 141147. Dubus, a respected short-story writer himself, discusses Hemingway’s “In Another Country.” States that, whereas he once thought the story was about the futility of cures, since becoming disabled he has come to understand that it is about healing. Lamb, Robert Paul. “The Love Song of Harold Krebs: Form, Argument, and Meaning in Hemingway’s ‘Soldier’s Home.’” The Hemingway Review 14 (Spring, 1995): 18-36. Claims that the story concerns both war trauma and a conflict between mother and son. Discusses the structure of the story; argues that by ignoring the story’s form, one misses the manner of Hemingway’s narrative argument and the considerable art that underlies it. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of fifteen short stories by Hemingway: “After the Storm,” “An Alpine Idyll,” “The Battler,” “Big Two-Hearted River,” and “A Canary for One” (vol. 1); “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place” (vol. 2); “Hills Like White Elephants” (vol. 3); “In Another Country,” “Indian Camp,” and “The Killers” (vol. 4); “My Old Man” (vol. 5); “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” (vol. 6); and “The Snows of Kilimanjaro,” “Soldier’s Home,” and “The Three-Day Blow” (vol. 7). Nolan, Charles J., Jr. “Hemingway’s Complicated Enquiry in Men Without Women.” Studies in Short Fiction 32 (Spring, 1995): 217-222. Examines the theme of homosexuality in “A Simple Enquiry” from Hemingway’s Men Without Women. Argues that the characters in the story are enigmatic, revealing their complexity only after one has looked carefully at what they do and say. Reynolds, Michael. The Young Hemingway. New York: Blackwell, 1986. ____________. Hemingway: The Paris Years. New York: Blackwell, 1989. ____________. Hemingway: The American Homecoming. New York: W. W. Norton, 1992. ____________. Hemingway: The 1930’s. New York: W. W. Norton, 1997. ____________. Hemingway: The Final Years. New York: W. W. Norton, 1999. These five volumes by Michael Reynolds come as close to being a definitive study of the life and work of Hemingway as anything yet published. Monumental in scope and exhaustive in detail. Wagner-Martin, Linda, ed. Hemingway: Seven Decades of Criticism. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press, 1998. Collection of essays ranging from Gertrude Stein’s 1923 review of Hemingway’s stories to recent responses to The Garden of Eden. Includes essays on “Indian Camp,” “Hills Like White Elephants,” and In Our Time as self-begetting fiction.
495
Amy Hempel Born: Chicago, Illinois; December 14, 1951 Principal short fiction • Reasons to Live, 1985; At the Gates of the Animal Kingdom, 1990; Tumble Home: A Novella and Short Stories, 1997; The Dog of the Marriage, 2005; The Collected Stories of Amy Hempel, 2006. Other literary forms • Primarily a short-story writer, Amy Hempel has published comparatively little in othe genres. During the mid-1980’s, she was a contributing editor to Vanity Fair. She also edited Unleashed: Poems by Writers’ Dogs in 1995. Achievements • Amy Hempel’s stories have appeared in leading American journals and have been widely anthologized in publications such as The Best American Short Stories and The Best of the Missouri Review, 1978-1990 (“Today Will Be a Quiet Day” appeared in both), The Pushcart Prize, The Norton Anthology of Short Fiction (1978), and New American Short Stories: The Writers Select Their Own Favorites (1987). Biography • Amy Hempel was born in Chicago, the eldest of three children (she has two younger brothers). Her family moved to Denver when she was in the third grade, and when she was in high school they moved to San Francisco. Her mother committed suicide when Hempel was eighteen, and at about the same time, Hempel was involved in two serious auto accidents. She spent a number of years in California and studied at both Whittier College and San Francisco State University, and she held a variety of jobs in her twenties. She attended the Bread Loaf Writers’ Conference in Vermont for a while but started writing in earnest when she studied with author Gordon Lish in a fiction workshop at Columbia University in 1982. (Lish arranged for her first collection of stories to be published in 1985.) After settling in New York City with her husband, Hempel worked as an editor and contributor to several periodicals and taught and lectured at a number of writing programs and workshops. Analysis • Amy Hempel is one of the original short-story writers upon whom the term “minimalist” was conferred but, as several critics have noted, “miniaturist” may be a more accurate term. Some of her stories are very short (including the one-sentence “Housewife,” which appears in Tumble Home). Even in her longer stories the style is compressed and economical in the extreme, the action limited, and the characters constantly making cryptic, ironic comments to one another. In an interview, Hempel said: A lot of times what’s not reported in your work is more important than what actually appears on the page. Frequently the emotional focus of the story is some underlying event that may not be described or even referred to in the story. Her stories demonstrate this minimalist philosophy again and again. Hempel’s stories often revolve around sadness, loss, and survival: Characters are in hospitals or in recovery or in trouble. However, even in these stories of crisis, Hempel is distinguished by her humor; characters, even children, always have clever things to say to one another, and their conversations are full of metaphors, parables, and symbolic
496
Short Story Writers
lessons. Hempel’s stories often feature dogs, other animals, and best girlfriends, thus often bordering on sentimentality. What saves the stories from falling into that easier literary condition, if anything, is their sardonic wit. “In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson Is Buried” • “In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson Is Buried” is probably Hempel’s best-known work. Originally published in Tri-Quarterly, it has been reprinted in The Editors’ Choice: New American Stories (1985) as well as in the popular Norton Anthology of Short Fiction, and it is quintessentially Hempel. The situation is dire: The narrator is visiting a friend in the hospital whom she has avoided visiting for two months; the friend is dying, and both women are in denial. Their conversation is filled with popular trivia, jokes, and funny stories—but many of these hint at the situation (like the narrator’s fear of flying). After an earthquake, the narrator relates, a teacher got her sixth-grade students to shout, “Bad earth!” at the broken playground. She asks her friend, “Did you know when they taught the first chimp to talk, it lied?” In the end, the friend dies, although the narrator cannot express the thought and says euphemistically, “On the morning she was moved to the cemetery, the one where Al Jolson is buried.” In the last image of the story, the narrator describes what happened when the signing chimp had a baby and it died: “her wrinkled hands moving with animal grace, forming again and again the words: Baby, come hug, Baby, come hug, fluent now in the language of grief.” Only the narrator is inarticulate in that language, but the sublimation of her feelings makes the story a powerful emotional experience for readers. As is often the case in reading Amy Hempel, less is surely more. “Today Will Be a Quiet Day” • This short story was also published in Hempel’s first collection, Reasons to Live, and was later included in The Best American Short Stories, The Pushcart Prize XI, and The Best of the Missouri Review: Fiction, 1978-1990, the journal where it first appeared. The story describes a father in San Francisco taking his son and daughter out for the day. The father drives north across the Golden Gate Bridge; the three eat lunch in Petaluma, and then the daughter drives them home by a different route. Little happens, in other words, and the story is filled with their conversation, joke-telling, and jousting—like the title, an inscription the son once imagined on his tombstone. The father has taken them out for the day because He wanted to know how they were, is all. Just—how were they. . . . You think you’re safe, the father thought, but it’s thinking you’re invisible because you closed your eyes. A friend of the boy has recently killed himself, readers learn, and the father wants to make sure his own kids are okay. The imagery of the story underlines the question of the difference between appearance and reality: The restaurant where they have lunch still looks like the gas station it originally was; the daughter discovers that the dog she thought was taken to live on a ranch has been put to sleep. At the end of the story, all three are in sleeping bags in the master bedroom of their house. Has the mother died recently? Are the parents divorced? Something hidden has given a tension to the simple events of the story. As they fall asleep, the father asks if they want the good news or bad news first and then says he lied, that there is no bad news. For a little while longer, perhaps, he is going to be able to protect his two teenagers from the dangers of the world, but this protective posture, as Hempel intimates to readers, is precarious.
Hempel, Amy
497
“The Harvest” • “The Harvest” was originally published in The Quarterly and collected in At the Gates of the Animal Kingdom, Hempel’s second collection of stories, and it is the best example of her metafictional style, a style which has occasionally appeared in her fiction. The story is narrated by a young woman who has been in an auto accident: She and her date were headed for dinner in his car when they were hit, and in the accident the narrator almost lost her leg—or did she? In the second half of the story, she starts to unravel her narrative, and to describe the things she left out of the story, made up, or exaggerated—the marital status of the man, the seriousness of her injuries—and by the end, readers question what, if anything, took place. A psychiatrist tells the girl that victims of trauma often have difficulties distinguishing fiction from reality, and the insight underlines what Hempel is doing in “The Harvest”: telling a story that becomes a narrative about making up a story—or about storytelling itself. “The Most Girl Part of You” • This story was first published in Vanity Fair and was subsequently reprinted in New American Short Stories and in At the Gates of the Animal Kingdom, and it displays the basic Hempel style. A teenage narrator tells of her relationship with her friend, “Big Guy,” whose mother hung herself eight days earlier. Although the surface conversation is, as usual, full of jokes, clearly there is something deeper going on. Big Guy sews the girl’s name into the skin of his hand, sucks ice to try to crack his teeth, and cuts the insect bites on her body with a razor. When Big Guy starts to make love to her after a dance, the girl claims she is “ready to start to truly be alive,” but readers sense something else—his instability, her insecurity, and her obvious pity for his tragedy. The title of the story comes from a film she was forced to watch at school years earlier, The Most Girl Part of You, and her own mother has apparently encouraged her sexual initiation. To readers, that introduction to adult sexuality seems wrong. Like the iceberg Ernest Hemingway used to describe a story’s hidden content, a large part of this story’s cryptic meaning may lie beneath the tense fictional surface. Tumble Home: A Novella and Short Stories • This collection contains seven stories and the title novella, an eighty-page letter the narrator is writing to an artist she may or may not have met, describing her life inside a mental hospital. Little happens, and readers learn more about the narrator’s friends in the institution—Karen, Warren, and Chatty—than about the narrator’s own life. There is hardly anything remarkable in their conversations except the wit and sardonic humor of Hempel’s elliptical, firstperson style. The other stories in the collection—several of them just a few pages long—reflect typical Hempel concerns. “Sportsman,” probably the strongest story here, for example, describes the breakup of Jack and Alex. Jack drives east from California to stay with his friends Vicki and her husband, “the doctor,” who live on Long Island. Vicki arranges for Jack to see Trina, a psychic, but then Alex calls from California to say that her mother has suffered a stroke. The story ends with Jack and Trina headed into New York City on a date, but the resolution of the relationships here is far from certain. As usual, appearances can be deceiving. The city looks pretty good, Jack comments; “Give it a minute,” the psychic responds. Like Raymond Carver, Hempel often tells deceptively simple stories about contemporary characters in deeper trouble than they realize. David Peck
498
Short Story Writers
Other major works anthology: Unleashed: Poems by Writers’ Dogs, 1995 (with Jim Shepard). Bibliography Aldridge, John W. Talents and Technicians: Literary Chic and the New Assembly-Line Fiction. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1992. In a chapter that considers Carver, Ann Beattie, and Frederick Barthelme, Aldridge accuses Hempel of “chronic minimalist constipation” and claims that behind her stories, several of which he analyzes, “there seems to be nothing but a chilly emotional void generated by either an incapacity to feel or a determination to express no feeling if one is there.” Ballantyne, Sheila. “Rancho Libido, and Other Hot Spots.” Review of Reasons to Live, by Amy Hempel. The New York Times Book Review, April 28, 1985, p. 9. Laudatory review that offers useful insights on minimalism and Hempel’s treatment of California’s culture. Blythe, Will, ed. Why I Write: Thoughts on the Craft of Fiction. Boston: Little, Brown, 1998. As one of twenty-six contributors to this collection, Hempel suggests some of the reasons that she creates her short fiction. Hallett, Cynthia J. “Minimalism and the Short Story.” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (1996): 487-495. In an essay that uses Hempel, Raymond Carver, and Ernest Hemingway as primary examples, Hallett attempts to lay down a theoretical foundation for minimalist fiction. Hemple, Amy. Interview by Suzan Sherman. BOMB, Spring, 1997, 67-70. In this wideranging interview, Hempel talks about her background as a writer, the origins of many of her stories, and her theories about reading and writing short fiction. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Hempel: “Going” (vol. 3), “In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson Is Buried” (vol. 4), and “Today Will Be a Quiet Day” (vol. 7). Towers, Robert. “Don’t Expect Too Much of Men.” Review of At the Gates of the Animal Kingdom, by Amy Hempel. The New York Times, March 11, 1990, sec. 7, p. 11. Contains helpful remarks on Hempel as a miniaturist.
499
O. Henr y Born: Greensboro, North Carolina; September 11, 1862 Died: New York, New York; June 5, 1910 Principal short fiction • Cabbages and Kings, 1904; The Four Million, 1906; Heart of the West, 1907; The Trimmed Lamp, 1907; The Gentle Grafter, 1908; The Voice of the City, 1908; Options, 1909; Roads of Destiny, 1909; Let Me Feel Your Pulse, 1910; Strictly Business, 1910; The Two Women, 1910; Whirligigs, 1910; Sixes and Sevens, 1911; Rolling Stones, 1912; Waifs and Strays, 1917; Postscripts, 1923; O. Henry Encore, 1936; Tales of O. Henry, 1969; The Voice of the City, and Other Stories: A Selection, 1991; The Best of O. Henry, 1992; Collected Stories: Revised and Expanded, 1993; Selected Stories, 1993; The Best Short Stories of O. Henry, 1994; One Hundred Selected Stories, 1995. Other literary forms • Although almost all of O. Henry’s literary output is in the short-story form, he contributed verse and anecdotes to Rolling Stone, the humorous weekly magazine which he founded and edited in 1894. He also experimented with playwriting, collaborating on a musical comedy based on “He Also Serves,” with two other gentlemen; the play was staged once, in mid-1909. He also prepared a play based on “The World and the Door.” Achievements • A widely read and published writer, O. Henry wrote short stories that influenced not only the development of magazine fiction as a popular form but also the evolution of modern narrative. Indeed, even very diverse European and South American writers adopt the devices O. Henry perfected. This phenomenon is no accident: His short stories have been widely reprinted and translated, especially in Russia and France, and have been adapted for radio, stage, and television performances. O. Henry was, however, especially popular in the United States. Extremely humorous, clever, and entertaining, he also managed to capture all that was recognizably and uniquely American—the variegated language, attitudes, spirit, geographical locations, social environments, and, most important, the inclination to identify with the downtrodden, the underdog. O. Henry’s contribution to American letters was so obvious that a long-lived literary prize—the annual O. Henry Memorial Award for Prize Stories—was established in 1918 by the New York Society of Arts and Sciences. Biography • Receiving little formal education, O. Henry, pseudonym of William Sydney Porter, found themes and plots for his short stories in his early jobs as pharmacist, ranch hand, draftsman, and bank teller. After being arrested for embezzlement in 1894, he fled to Honduras, where much of the material for Cabbages and Kings was acquired. He returned to Texas in 1897 to be with his dying wife and was convicted and sent to prison one year later. During his imprisonment he began to achieve national prominence for his stories and subsequently continued his writing career in New York. He signed contracts with the Sunday World and Munsey’s for weekly stories drawn from his own experiences in the city. In 1907, he married his childhood sweetheart; three years later he died, finally succumbing to alcohol-induced cirrhosis of the liver and diabetes.
500
Short Story Writers
Analysis • O. Henry’s widely varied background provided not only plots for his tales but also characters drawn from all walks of life. Ham in “The Hiding of Black Chief,” Caesar in “A Municipal Report,” and Lizzie in “The Guilty Party” are only isolated examples of O. Henry’s proficiency in creating a vivid sense of the texture of language for the reader by reproducing native dialect, be it Western, southern, or even “New Yorkese.” This linguistic sensitivity contributes to O. Henry’s versatility as a local colorist, as does his literary self-education. Echoes of Charles Dickens appear in “Elsie in New York,” allusions to Greek and Roman mythology in “Hygeia at the Solito” and “The Reformation of Calliope,” and parodic references to Arthur Conan Doyle in “The Library of Congress Adventure of Shamrock Jolnes.” O. Henry’s popularity stems not only from his depiction of commonplace events and human responses but also from the surprise endings of his “well-made” plots. Talented as an ironist, he both comments upon and sympathizes with the ranch hands, bank clerks, and shop girls whose sorrows and foibles he re-creates. Although much of his humor redounds from his likely use of puns and literary allusions, much might be called the humor of recognition—the rueful grin that occurs when a reader sees his or her own petty flaws mirrored in a character and predicts the almost inevitable downfall. The downfall, however, is often given the comic turn which made O. Henry famous. Kid Brady in “Vanity and Some Sables,” for example, would rather go to jail for the theft of furs than tell his girlfriend that her “Russian sables” cost $21.50 in a bargain basement; Maida, the shop girl in “The Purple Dress” who “starves eight months to bring a purple dress and a holiday together,” gives up her carefully garnered money to save a spendthrift friend from eviction. Molly sacrifices her furs—and her vanity—to prove Kid’s honesty, and Maida is outdone by her tailor in generosity so that she gets both her dress and the marriageable head clerk: These are the twist endings that turn minor personal tragedies into comic triumphs. “The Gift of the Magi” • Possibly one of the most anthologized of O. Henry’s stories is “The Gift of the Magi,” a tale about the redeeming power of love. The protagonists, a couple named James and Della Young, struggle to live on a small salary. By Christmas Eve, Della’s thrift has gained her only $1.87 for her husband’s gift, which she had hoped would be “something fine and rare and sterling.” She decides to sell one of the family “treasures”—her long, beautiful chestnut hair—to buy a platinum chain for her husband’s prized possession, his watch. The first reversal is that he has
Henry, O.
501
bought her a set of pure tortoiseshell combs with which to adorn her long hair; the second, that he has sold his watch to do so. In this story about the true spirit of gift-giving, both the family treasures and the protagonists take on Old Testamentary significance. Della’s hair, the reader is told, puts the queen of Sheba’s wealth to shame; Jim’s watch rivals all of Solomon’s gold. Both unselfishly sacrifice their most precious possession for the other, thereby ushering in a new dispensation on Christmas Eve. Even more, these “two foolish children” acquire allegorical value in their act of giving insofar as they replicate the giving of the three wise men: “Of all who give and receive gifts, such as they are the wisest,” O. Henry tells us: “They are the magi.” In O. Henry’s version, then, the “Gift of the Magi” turns out not to be gold, frankincense, or myrrh, not even hair-combs or a watch chain, but rather, selfless love. “Past One at Rooney’s” • This love is what O. Henry posits as a cure for such social ills as the almost inevitable gang fights and prostitution he portrays in his New York stories. In “Past One at Rooney’s,” a tale introduced as a modern retelling of William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet (c. 1595-1596), a gangster, hiding from the police, falls in love with a prostitute. They lie about their occupations for the sake of the other: Eddie MacManus pretends to be the son of a Wall Street broker, while Fanny claims to be a factory girl. When a policeman recognizes MacManus, however, she gives up her new identity to prevent the arrest. Pulling her night’s money out of her garter, she throws it at the policeman and announces that MacManus is her procurer. Once they are allowed to leave, MacManus confesses that he really is wanted by the police but intends to reform; and seeing that she still loves him, saves her (as she had “saved” him by sacrificing her hoped-for respectability) through marriage. Such stories of the “golden-hearted prostitute” are plentiful in the O. Henry canon and in themselves provide another clue to O. Henry’s popularity—his emphasis on the remnant of human compassion in the most cynical of characters. Roads of Destiny • O. Henry is interested as well in what might be called the moment of choice: the decision to act, speak, or dress in a way which seems to determine the whole course of a life. The title story of the volume Roads of Destiny, a story allegorical in nature, suggests that the choice is not so much among different fates as among different versions of the same fate. Environment, in short, determines character, unless some modicum of self-sacrificing love as in “The Gift of the Magi” intervenes. More concretely, O. Henry saw poverty and exploitation as the twin evils of urban life. Often cited for his sympathetic portrayal of the underpaid store clerk who struggles to survive, he is, as well, a biting critic of those who perpetuate an inhumane system to satisfy personal greed or lust. “An Unfinished Story,” for example, castigates an aging lady-killer who is “a connoisseur in starvation. He could look at a shop-girl and tell you to an hour how long it had been since she had eaten anything more nourishing than marshmallows and tea.” Piggy, with whom O. Henry himself ruefully identified, preyed on shop girls by offering them invitations to dinner. The working girl might thus keep her conscience and starve, or sell herself and eat: This was her condition as well as her choice. “The Trimmed Lamp” • Where a choice need not be made through hunger alone is the middle moral ground on which many of O. Henry’s stories take place. “The Trimmed Lamp,” the titular story of another volume, suggests two opposing ways to
502
Short Story Writers
deal with an exploitative economic system. Nancy, a country girl content to work for small wages in a department store, mimics not only the quietly elegant dress but also the manners of her wealthy customers, while her friend Lou, a highly paid laundry presser, spends most of her money on expensive, conspicuous clothing. Nancy exploits the system by educating herself in the best it has to offer; Lou works for the system and profits monetarily. In the long run Nancy’s education teaches her the difference between purchased quality, such as the clothes Lou wears, and intrinsic quality, which cannot be bought. She refuses an offer of marriage from a millionaire because he is a liar: As O. Henry writes, “the dollar-mark grew blurred in her mind’s eye, and shaped itself into . . . such words as ‘truth’ and ‘honor’ and now and then just ‘kindness.’” Lou, in contrast, becomes the mistress of a wealthy man, leaving her quiet, serious fiancé to Nancy. The final vignette, a plainly clothed but vibrantly happy Nancy trying to comfort her sobbing, fashionably dressed friend, illustrates the divergence between their two philosophies. Although neither can escape completely from the economic system, Nancy refuses to measure human worth in monetary terms; instead, she adopts the same set of values posited in “The Gift of the Magi.” “The Ransom of Red Chief” • Many of the stories O. Henry writes are quite outside the moral framework that is suggested in “The Trimmed Lamp.” Like others written about the “gentle grafters” who populated the nether side of his world, the story of “The Ransom of Red Chief” is of the “biter bit” variety. O. Henry’s humorous focus on the problems that two kidnappers have with their charge—a redhaired version of Tom Sawyer with the same unflagging energy for mischief—deflects the moral question about the criminal action. Johnny enjoys his adventure; he styles himself Red Chief and tries to scalp one of his captors at daybreak, then rides him to the stockade to “rescue” settlers, feeds him oats, and worries him with questions about why holes are empty. His father’s reply to a demand for ransom shows that he understands who is in captivity; he offers to take his son back for a sum of $250. The Gentle Grafter • Similarly, the exploits recounted in The Gentle Grafter are modern tall tales, the heroes at times acquiring a mythological aura, at times appearing to be no different from the average man on the street. Grafting, in short, is an occupation which carries the same code of responsibilities as any legitimate business, as is made clear in “Shearing the Wolf.” When two con men, Jeff Peters and Andy Tucker, discover that the leading hardware merchant in town intends to frustrate someone else’s scheme to sell forged money, they agree that they cannot “stand still and see a man who has built up a business by his own efforts and brains and risk be robbed by an unscrupulous trickster.” The twist is that the “trickster” is the merchant and the “businessman” is the forger. In a number of respects, then, O. Henry contributed immeasurably to the development of the American short story. To be sure, many of his works are considered ephemeral today, primarily because they first appeared as magazine fiction; but a careful perusal reveals that behind the humor lies the mirror of the social reformer. In the characters and situations one notices common human problems of the beginning of the twentieth century; in the humor one notices the attempt to deal with apparently insurmountable social problems. With his clever plot reversals, O. Henry does more than create a new story form; he keeps the reader alive to the connota-
Henry, O.
503
tions of language and aware that in a world dominated by an unfair economic system, human kindness may be the answer. Patricia Marks With updates by Terri Frongia Other major works play: Lo, pr. 1909 (with Franklin P. Adams). miscellaneous: Rolling Stones, 1912; O. Henryana, 1920. nonfiction: Letters to Lithopolis, 1922; The Second Edition of Letters to Lithopolis from O. Henry to Mabel Wagnalls, 1999 (with Mabel Wagnalls). Bibliography Arnett, Ethel Stephens. O. Henry from Polecat Creek. Greensboro, N.C.: Piedmont Press, 1963. Described by Porter’s cousin as a delightful and authentic story of O. Henry’s boyhood and youth, this entertaining biography of the early years goes far in illuminating the character-shaping environment and experiences of both Porter and his fiction. Supplemented by illustrations, notes, a bibliography, and an index. Current-Garcia, Eugene. O. Henry: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1993. Introduction to O. Henry’s stories, largely drawn from Current-Garcia’s earlier Twayne volume. Focuses on O. Henry’s frequent themes, his romanticism, and his narrative techniques, such as his use of the tall-tale convention. Includes critical excerpts from discussions of O. Henry by other critics. Eichenbaum, Boris. O. Henry and the Theory of the Short Story. Translated by I. R. Titunik. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1968. Originally published in Russia in 1925, this study reflects both the Russian interest in O. Henry as a serious writer and the brand of criticism known as Russian Formalism. Because Formalism was more concerned with technical achievement than thematic profundity, O. Henry, who was a technical master, is a perfect candidate for the exercise of this kind of analysis. Evans, Walter. “‘A Municipal Report’: O. Henry and Postmodernism.” Tennessee Studies in Literature 26 (1981): 101-116. Recognizing modern criticism’s either trite interpretation or complete indifference to O. Henry’s work, through the fiction of postmodernists like Vladimir Nabokov, John Barth, Robert Coover, and William Gass, Evans embarks on a radical revisioning of Porter’s literary contributions. Gallegly, Joseph. From Alamo Plaza to Jack Harris’s Saloon: O. Henry and the Southwest He Knew. The Hague: Mouton, 1970. By investigating contemporary photographs, literature, popular pursuits, news items, and personalities—both real and fictional—from the contemporary scene of the author, Gallegly provides significant insight into the southwestern stories. Langford, Gerald. Alias O. Henry: A Biography of William Sidney Porter. New York: Macmillan, 1957. Well-documented biography that considers in detail Porter’s marriages and the evidence used in his embezzlement trial. The foreword provides a brief but penetrating overview of O. Henry’s critical reputation (including overseas) and his place within the context of American literature. Supplemented by illustrations, an appendix about Rolling Stones, notes, and an index. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena,
504
Short Story Writers
Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of five short stories by O. Henry: “The Furnished Room” and “The Gift of the Magi” (vol. 3), “Mammon and the Archer” and “A Municipal Report” (vol. 5), and “The Ransom of Red Chief” (vol. 6). Monteiro, George. “Hemingway, O. Henry, and the Surprise Ending.” Prairie Schooner 47, no. 4 (1973-1974): 296-302. In rehabilitating O. Henry and his most famous technique, Monteiro makes comparisons with Hemingway’s own—but very different—use of the same device. This significant difference Monteiro ascribes to Hemingway’s essentially uneasy reception of Porter’s work and to the two authors’ divergent outlooks on life. Stuart, David. O. Henry: A Biography of William Sydney Porter. Chelsea, Mich.: Scarborough House, 1990. Good, updated volume on O. Henry. Includes bibliographical references. Watson, Bruce. “If His Life Were a Short Story, Who’d Ever Believe It?” Smithsonian 27 (January, 1997): 92-102. Biography strewn with anecdotes and some literary criticism. Includes photographs.
505
Langston Hughes Born: Joplin, Missouri; February 1, 1902 Died: New York, New York; May 22, 1967 Principal short fiction • The Ways of White Folks, 1934; Simple Speaks His Mind, 1950; Laughing to Keep from Crying, 1952; Simple Takes a Wife, 1953; Simple Stakes a Claim, 1957; The Best of Simple, 1961; Something in Common, and Other Stories, 1963; Simple’s Uncle Sam, 1965; The Return of Simple, 1994; Short Stories, 1996. Other literary forms • Although perhaps best known for his poetry, Langston Hughes explored almost every literary genre. His prose fiction includes novels, humorous books, historical, biographical, autobiographical, and cultural works, translations, lyrics, librettos, plays, and scripts. His total output includes more than seventy volumes, as well as numerous articles, poems, and stories, most which which were published in book form for the first time in the sixteen-volume Collected Works of Langston Hughes (2001-2004). Achievements • Langston Hughes has been acknowledged both before and after his death as the most influential African American writer in the English-speaking world. As a leader of the Harlem Renaissance, he not only wrote in a variety of genres but also edited and encouraged the literary, dramatic, and musical productions of other people of color. Recognition came during his lifetime as early as 1925, when he won the Poetry Prize given by Opportunity magazine and the Spingarn prizes of Crisis magazine for both poetry and essay writing. His novel Not Without Laughter (1930) won the Harmon Gold Medal in 1931. That year he received his first Rosenwald Fellowship, an award repeated in 1941. The John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship in 1935, the National Academy of Arts and Letters Award for Literature in 1946, and the Ainsfield-Wolf Award in 1953 continued to keep him in the forefront of the literary community, particularly in New York, throughout his life. His alma mater, Lincoln University, awarded him an honorary doctorate in 1943, and he received others from Howard University and Case Western Reserve University in 1963 and 1964, respectively. Biography • James Mercer Langston Hughes came from an educated family whose energies were spent primarily in entrepreneurial efforts to combat poverty and institutionalized racism in order to survive. His life repeats a well-known pattern of early twentieth century African American families: a resourceful mother who rented out their home to boarders, a father who had to leave home to find work, a grandmother who cared for him during his early years, and a stepfather. He grew up in the Midwest—Kansas, Illinois, and Ohio—and participated in athletics as well as in literary activities in high school. Graduating from Central High School in Lincoln, Illinois, in 1920, Hughes attended Columbia University before shipping out on liners bound for Africa and Holland. He also traveled extensively in Europe before returning to the United States in 1925. Then, in 1929, he received a bachelor’s degree from Lincoln University, Penn-
506
Short Story Writers
sylvania. Hughes at first subsisted with the help of patrons, but gradually began to earn a living on the proceeds from his writings and his poetry readings. Although mainly basing himself in Harlem, New York City, Hughes continued to travel extensively. He won numerous prizes, grants, and fellowships for his literary achievements before his death in 1967. Analysis • Langston Hughes records in The Big Sea: An Autobiography (1940) his feelings upon first seeing Africa: “when I saw the dust-green hills in the sunlight, something took hold of me inside. My Africa, Motherland of the Negro peoples! And me a Negro! The real thing!” The trip to Africa confirmed what he already knew—that the subject matter of his writings would reflect his desire “to write seriously and as well as I knew how about the Negro people.” Most of Hughes’s short stories concern themselves with black people presented from many different perspectives and in both tragic and comic dimensions. Even when a white is the protagonist of a story, as in “Little Dog,” the gentle black man to whom Miss Briggs is attracted is given special focus. Hughes, however, is not racist in his presentation. People, regardless of their racial background, are people first participating in a common humanity before they are individuals distorted by prejudice based on ignorance, by fear, or by social conditions which create a spiritual and psychological malaise, sometimes crippling in its effect. “Little Dog” • “Little Dog” tells the story of a white and gaunt middle-aged woman, head bookkeeper of a coal and coke firm for twenty-one years, who, because of her own sense of prudence, responsibility, and concern, sublimates her own desires to care for her mother, and then, after her mother’s death, is left alone and lonely. Although she keeps busy, is comfortably situated, and does not think too much of what she may be missing, she occasionally wonders why she knows no one whom she can appreciate as a friend. One day she inexplicably stops the taxicab in which she is riding in front of a pet shop featuring in its window “fuzzy little white dogs,” and she purchases for herself a puppy at a very steep price. She arranges with the janitor of her apartment building, “a tow-headed young Swede,” to provide food for her dog, which she names Flips, and soon her life revolves around activities centering on Flips. One day the janitor does not show up to feed the dog; several days pass until Miss Briggs decides she needs to go down to the basement to search out the janitor. With her dog by her side, she knocks at a door behind which she hears sounds of “happy laughter, and kids squalling, and people moving.” The door is opened by a small black boy and soon Miss Briggs discovers that the “tall broad-shouldered Negro” standing amid the children is the new janitor. The image patterns and juxtapositions in the story now begin to form meaningful patterns. The white woman, living “upstairs” with the “fuzzy white dog,” is contrasted with the black man and his “pretty little brown-black” children who live “downstairs.” The gentle and kind black man begins to service Miss Briggs’s needs, bringing more food than is good for the dog because he believes the woman desires it and because he is being paid for it; Miss Briggs, however, never tells him that meat every few days is sufficient. Soon Miss Briggs finds herself hurrying home, never realizing that it is no longer the dog but rather the nightly visits of the janitor that compel her to hurry. One evening her words inadvertently reveal her subconscious needs. The black janitor has just left after delivering Flips’s food and she can hear him humming as he returns to his family. Suddenly Miss Briggs says to Flips: “Oh, Flips . . . I’m so hungry.”
Hughes, Langston Now, although she never consciously knows why, Miss Briggs decides she needs to move; “she could not bear to have this janitor come upstairs with a package of bones for Flips again. . . . Let him stay in the basement, where he belonged.” The accumulation of references to bones, meat, and services provides for the reader, if not for Miss Briggs, a moment of epiphany: “He almost keeps me broke buying bones,” Miss Briggs says to the tall and broadshouldered black janitor. “True,” the janitor answers her. The sustenance the black man provides for the dog is no sustenance for the gaunt and bony woman, nor is the dog, like children, sufficient to keep memory of the departed alive. Miss Briggs moves and shortly is completely forgotten by the people in the neighborhood in which she had lived.
507
Library of Congress
“Thank You M’am” • If Miss Briggs seems a portrait of a woman dead before she is buried, Mrs. Luella Bates Washington Jones of “Thank You M’am” is a picture of middle-aged woman still vital and vigorous, although she, too, lives alone; and although it appears she has no children of her own, she is still potent, giving new life to a young black boy who attempts to mug her. The child is no match for the woman, who is identified with her purse so large “that it had everything in it but a hammer and nails.” She drags him home with her, sees that he washes, and shares with him her frugal meal. Her presence is so overpowering that the boy is more fearful of trying to get away than of staying, but she breaks down his resistance when she speaks to him of common problems. “I was young once and I wanted things I could not get.” The boy waits expecting the “but” to follow. The woman anticipates: “You thought I was going to say, but I didn’t snatch people’s pocketbooks. Well, I wasn’t going to say that. . . . I have done things, too, which I would not tell you, son. . . . Everybody’s got something in common.” The woman’s actions, however, tell the boy more than her words do, and at the end of the story the boy is unable to use words, although his lips try to phrase more than “Thank you M’am.” “Professor” • One of Hughes’s most frequently praised stories is “Professor.” Focused through the point of view of its protagonist, Dr. T. Walton Brown (T for Tom, Uncle Tom?), the story examines how a black professor of sociology “bows” and “bobs” like a puppet on a string to members of the wealthy white establishment, doing only those things of which they approve, saying what they want to hear, although at times he knows the lies diminish him.
508
Short Story Writers
Bitterly ironic in tone, the story begins with the juxtaposition of Brown in dinner dress against the lobby of a run-down segregated hotel and Brown cared for by a white chauffeur who tucks the professor carefully into the luxury of a limousine to carry him through the black ghetto to a private house as large as a hotel. Brown’s posture and attire are carefully contrasted with the “two or three ash-colored children” who run across the street in front of the limousine, “their skinny legs and poor clothes plain in the glare of the headlights.” So also are the streets and buildings contrasted—“the Negro streets”: “pig’s knuckle joints, pawnshops, beer parlors—and houses of vice, no doubt—save that these latter, at least, did not hang out their signs” with the “wide lawns and fine homes that lined the beautiful well-lighted boulevard where white people lived.” Brown has bought entry into the white establishment by prostituting himself, by accepting the degradation of the constant diminishing of his selfhood and his negritude. He listens to his white counterpart say: “Why, at our city college here we’ve been conducting some fine interracial experiments. I have had some colored ministers and high school teachers visit my classes. We found them most intelligent.” Although at times Brown is moved to make slight and subtle protest, in the end he agrees with the biased white people, saying “You are right.” Brown’s behavior is dictated by his desire for the money the white people offer him as long as he conforms to their expectation. Money will buy Brown prestige, will enable his college to survive, and will further his career. Money will also “take his family to South America in the summer where for three months they wouldn’t feel like Negroes.” Thus, he dances to the “tune of Jim Crow education,” diminishing both himself and his race. Although carefully constructed, the story offers no subtleties beyond the ironies present; image patterns are at a minimum, complex symbolism nonexistent. Characterization, too, is sparse. The reader learns only enough about the professor to make his behavior immediately credible, but a traditional plot line moves with careful pacing to climax and pointed resolution, and the theme overshadows technique. “Fine Accommodations” • Similar in theme and technique to “Professor” is “Fine Accommodations.” In this story, a young black porter learns that the Dr. Jenkins, booked into sleeping car accommodations, is not the leader of his race and “fine man” the naïve porter expects but rather another Uncle Tom who keeps on “being a big man” by “bowing to Southern white customs,” by helping to keep poor black people just where they have always been “all the time—poor and black.” At the end of the story, the porter makes the point of the story: “The last Negro passenger I had in that drawing room was a pimp from Birmingham. Now I got a professor. I guess both of them have to have ways of paying for such fine accommodations.” “Big Meeting” • From the perspective of complexity, subtlety, and power, “Big Meeting” is a considerably better story. Told in the first person by a young black boy who with a companion is observing a church revival meeting held in the woods, the story recounts the boy’s moment of epiphany when he realizes, if only subconsciously, that as a cynical observer rather than a participant in the ritual he is more akin to the white folks gathered to watch than to his own people. Making use of dialect and gospel songs, Hughes builds the story to a powerful sermon where the preacher recounts the betrayal of Christ to the accompaniment of echoing refrains and then moves the sermon to the cadences of poetry:
Hughes, Langston
509
They brought four long nails And put one in the palm of His left hand. The hammer said . . . Bam! They put one in the palm of His right hand. The hammer said . . . Bam! They put one through His left foot . . . Bam! And one through His right foot . . . Bam! . . . “Don’t drive it!” a woman screamed. “Don’t drive them nails! For Christ’s sake! Oh! Don’t drive ’em!” In the woods observing the action, the narrator and his companion are near enough to a car full of white people to overhear what they are saying as they comment in ways showing their biases, limitations, and prejudices. As the narrator hears these comments, he begins to respond, but not enough to cause him to identify with the participants in the service. Rather, both he and his companion seem more concerned with the behavior of their mothers who are taking part in the church rituals. At the climax of the story, the narrator hears his mother’s voice: “Were you there when they crucified my Lord?/ Were you there when they nailed Him to the tree?” At the same time as the mother cries out the questions, the preacher opens his arms wide against the white canvas tent, and his body reflects a crosslike shadow. As the mother asks the question again, the white people in the car suddenly drive away creating a swirl of dust, and the narrator cries after them, “Don’t go. . . . They’re about to call for sinners. . . . Don’t go!” The boy’s cry to the white people reflects his understanding of the parallel setup between the white people and the betrayers of Christ. Hughes goes further than this, however, and provides in the last sentence of the story an epiphanic moment: “I didn’t realize I was crying until I tasted my tears in my mouth.” The epiphany projects a revelation dimly understood by the narrator but clearly present—that as bad as the white people’s behavior seemed, his own rejection of his people and heritage was worse. Mary Rohrberger With updates by Emma Coburn Norris Other major works children’s literature: Popo and Fijina: Children of Haiti, 1932 (story; with Arna Bontemps); The First Book of Negroes, 1952; The First Book of Rhythms, 1954; The First Book of Jazz, 1955; The First Book of the West Indies, 1955; The First Book of Africa, 1960. plays: Little Ham, pr. 1935; Mulatto, pb. 1935; Troubled Island, pr. 1935 (opera libretto); Don’t You Want to Be Free?, pb. 1938; Freedom’s Plow, pb. 1943; Street Scene, pr., pb. 1947 (lyrics; music by Kurt Weill and Elmer Rice); Simply Heavenly, pr. 1957 (opera libretto); Black Nativity, pr. 1961; Five Plays, pb. 1963 (Walter Smalley, editor); Tambourines to Glory, pr., pb. 1963; Jerico-Jim Crow, pr. 1964; The Prodigal Son, pr. 1965. anthologies: The Poetry of the Negro, 1746-1949, 1949 (with Arna Bontemps); The Book of Negro Folklore, 1959 (with Bontemps); New Negro Poets: U.S.A., 1964; The Book of Negro Humor, 1966; The Best Short Stories by Negro Writers: An Anthology from 1899 to the Present, 1967. novels: Not Without Laughter, 1930; Tambourines to Glory, 1958.
510
Short Story Writers
miscellaneous: The Langston Hughes Reader, 1958; The Collected Works of Langston Hughes, 2001-2004 (16 volumes). nonfiction: The Big Sea: An Autobiography, 1940; Famous American Negroes, 1954; Famous Negro Music Makers, 1955; The Sweet Flypaper of Life, 1955 (photographs by Roy De Carava); A Pictorial History of the Negro in America, 1956 (with Milton Meltzer); I Wonder as I Wander: An Autobiographical Journey, 1956; Famous Negro Heroes of America, 1958; Fight for Freedom: The Story of the NAACP, 1962; Black Magic: A Pictorial History of the Negro in American Entertainment, 1967 (with Meltzer); Black Misery, 1969 (illustrations by Arouni); Arna Bontemps—Langston Hughes Letters, 1980; Remember Me to Harlem: The Letters of Langston Hughes and Carl Van Vechten, 1925-1964, 2001 (Emily Bernard, editor). poetry: The Weary Blues, 1926; Fine Clothes to the Jew, 1927; Dear Lovely Death, 1931; The Negro Mother, 1931; Scottsboro Limited: Four Poems and a Play in Verse, 1932; The Dream Keeper, and Other Poems, 1932; A New Song, 1938; Shakespeare in Harlem, 1942; Jim Crow’s Last Stand, 1943; Lament for Dark Peoples, 1944; Fields of Wonder, 1947; One Way Ticket, 1949; Montage of a Dream Deferred, 1951; Selected Poems of Langston Hughes, 1959; Ask Your Mama: Or, Twelve Moods for Jazz, 1961; The Panther and the Lash: Or, Poems of Our Times, 1967; The Poems, 1921-1940, 2001 (volume 1 of The Collected Works of Langston Hughes; Dolan Hubbard, editor); The Poems, 1941-1950, 2001 (volume 2 of The Collected Works of Langston Hughes; Hubbard, editor); The Poems, 1951-1967, 2001 (volume 3 of The Collected Works of Langston Hughes; Hubbard, editor). screenplay: Way Down South, 1939 (with Clarence Muse). translations: Masters of the Dew, 1947 (of Jacques Roumain; with Mercer Cook); Cuba Libre, 1948 (of Nicolás Guillén; with Ben Carruthers); Gypsy Ballads, 1951 (of Federico García Lorca); Selected Poems of Gabriela Mistral, 1957. Bibliography Bloom, Harold, ed. Langston Hughes. New York: Chelsea House, 1989. Useful collection of some of the best literary criticism of Hughes’s works, with several articles on his poetry, but these reprinted essays do not have notes and Bloom’s introduction is perfunctory. Supplemented by a useful bibliography and an index. Borden, Anne. “Heroic ‘Hussies’ and ‘Brilliant Queers’ Genderracial Resistance in the Works of Langston Hughes.” African American Review 28 (Fall, 1994): 333-345. Discusses Hughes’s focus on the interrelationship between gender and racial issues, as well as his treatment of gender issues within the black community—particularly the ways in which gender affects the struggle to maintain community in racist society. Dickinson, Donald C. A Bio-Bibliography of Langston Hughes, 1902-1967. 2d ed. Hamden, Conn.: Archon Books, 1972. With its preface by Arna Bontemps, a major scholar and critic of the Harlem Renaissance and a contemporary of Hughes, the reader has both older and updated assessments of Hughes’s achievement. Part 1 is the biography, which incorporates information throughout Hughes’s life; part 2 includes all of his work through 1965, except short newspaper articles, song lyrics, and phonographic records. Even a glance at the bibliography gives an indication of the range of Hughes’s imaginative achievement. Harper, Donna Sullivan. Not So Simple: The “Simple” Stories by Langston Hughes. Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1995. Good analysis of Hughes’s tales that includes useful bibliographical references and an index. Hokanson, Robert O’Brien. “Jazzing It Up: The Be-bop Modernism of Langston
Hughes, Langston
511
Hughes.” Mosaic 31 (December, 1998): 61-82. Examines how Hughes uses be-bop jazz to challenge both the boundaries between music and poetry and the distinctions between popular and high culture; argues that Hughes’s work constitutes a distinctively “popular” modernism that uses jazz to ground its poetic experimentation in the vernacular tradition of African American culture. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Hughes: “Gospel Singers” (vol. 3); “On the Road” (vol. 5); and “Thank You, M’am” (vol. 7). Leach, Laurie F. Langston Hughes: A Biography. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 2004. Overview of Hughes’s life and development as a playwright, poet, and journalist. Ostrom, Hans. Langston Hughes: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1993. Includes critical analyses of Hughes’s short fiction; excerpts from his essays and speeches on his life, racial issues, and writings; and remarks from critics on his works. Contains a life chronology and selected bibliography. Rampersad, Arnold. The Life of Langston Hughes. 2 vols. New York: Oxford University Press, 1986-1988. This major critical biography illustrates not only the triumphs but also the struggles of the man and the writer. The importance of Hughes in the Harlem Renaissance and his symbolic significance in the developing artistic and imaginative consciousness of African American writers come alive in concrete examples. Schwarz, A. B. Christa. Gay Voices of the Harlem Renaissance. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2003. Schwarz examines the work of four leading writers from the Harlem Renaissance—Countée Cullen, Langston Hughes, Claude McKay, and Richard Bruce Nugent—and their sexually nonconformist or gay literary voices. Trotman, C. James, ed. Langston Hughes: The Man, His Art, and His Continuing Influence. New York: Garland, 1995. Fine collection of essays dealing with such topics as the Harlem Renaissance, “Race, Culture, and Gender,” and Hughes’s continuing influence on poetry, fiction, and drama.
512
Zora Neale Hurston Born: Eatonville, Florida; January 7, 1891 Died: Fort Pierce, Florida; January 28, 1960 Principal short fiction • Spunk: The Selected Short Stories of Zora Neale Hurston, 1985; The Complete Stories, 1995. Other literary forms • Though best known for her novels, especially Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937), Zora Neale Hurston wrote in most major genres during her forty-year career. In addition to two posthumously published collections of her short stories, she wrote a few early poems, several short plays, folklore collections, essays, reportage, and an autobiography. Three of her plays were published during the 1920’s and 1930’s, and a fourth, Polk County, that she published in 1944, was produced in 2002. Her four novels include Jonah’s Gourd Vine (1934), Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937), Moses, Man of the Mountain (1939), and Seraph on the Suwanee (1948). Posthumously published collections of her nonfiction writings include Go Gator and Muddy the Water: Writings (1999), Every Tongue Got to Confess: Negro Foktales from the Gulf States (2001), and Zora Neale Hurston: A Life in Letters (2002). Achievements • Zora Neale Hurston is best known as a major contributor to the Harlem Renaissance literature of the 1920’s. Not only was she a major contributor, but also she did much to characterize the style and temperament of the period; indeed, she is often referred to as the most colorful figure of the Harlem Renaissance. Though the short stories and short plays that she generated during the 1920’s are fine works in their own right, they are nevertheless apprentice works when compared to her most productive period, the 1930’s. During the 1930’s, Hurston produced three novels, all telling examples of her creative genius, as well as two collections of folklore, the fruits of her training in anthropology and her many years of fieldwork. It is Hurston’s interest in preserving the culture of the black South that remains among her most valuable contributions. Not only did she collect and preserve folklore outright, but also she used folklore, native drama, and the black idiom and dialect in most of her fiction. Although Hurston’s popularity declined during the 1940’s and 1950’s, and although she died in relative obscurity in 1960, scholars and critics sparked a Hurston revival during the mid-1970’s. Hurston’s popularity has never been greater, as her works are considered mainstays in any number of canons, among them African American literature, folklore, southern literature, feminist studies, and anthropology. Biography • Zora Neale Hurston was born in 1891 in the all-black town of Eatonville, Florida, near Orlando. She was the youngest daughter and the seventh of eight children born to John and Lucy Hurston. Her father was a minister and local government official who wrote many of Eatonville’s laws upon its incorporation and served several terms as mayor. Her mother was a homemaker who cared not only for her children but also for an extended family that included, at various times, her own mother and her brother Jim. By all accounts, Hurston’s childhood was happy, almost idyllic, free
Hurston, Zora Neale
513
from the poverty and racism that characterized much of the black experience in the South. Indeed, this wholesome upbringing informed much of Hurston’s later work and earned for her the designation as an early black cultural nationalist. Whatever idyllic aspects Hurston’s childhood possessed were shattered when Hurston was about nine. The death of Hurston’s beloved mother, who encouraged the young Zora to “jump at the sun,” precipitated a change. This was followed by her father’s remarriage to a woman who had no interest in the children and the subsequent dismantling of the relative happiness of the Hurston household. The next several years of Hurston’s life found her much displaced, living variously with older siblings and receiving only sporadic schooling. Although exact dates are difficult to place in Hurston’s early chronology because she frequently lied about her age, various sources reveal that Hurston joined a Gilbert and Sullivan traveling show when she was about fourteen as a wardrobe maid to one of the show’s stars. Hurston worked for this show for several years, traveling throughout the South, sometimes without pay. It was with this show, however, that Hurston’s talents as raconteur were first noticed, as she often entertained the company with stories, anecdotes, and tales from the black South, told with their own humor, mimicry, and dialect. Hurston left her job with the Gilbert and Sullivan show in Baltimore, and, out of an intense desire to complete her education, she enrolled in the high school department of the Morgan Academy (now Morgan State University) in that city, completing the high school program in 1919. From Morgan, Hurston entered Howard University, at that time known as “the Negro Harvard,” in Washington, D.C. At Howard, Hurston soon came to the attention of Alain Locke, adviser to the Howard Literary Society and later a principal critic of the New Negro movement. Locke invited Hurston to join the literary society, and she soon began publishing in Stylus, the Howard University literary magazine. Her first published short story, “John Redding Goes to Sea,” appeared in Stylus in 1921. Hurston’s talent soon came to the attention of Charles S. Johnson, founder and editor of the National Urban League’s magazine Opportunity, which held annual contests for young writers. Johnson encouraged Hurston to submit her works to Opportunity, which she did; “Drenched in Light” appeared in December, 1924, and “Spunk” in June, 1925. Both “Spunk” and a short play, “Color Struck,” were second-place prizewinners in their respective divisions in Opportunity’s 1925 contest, and another short story, “Black Death,” won honorable mention. Hurston traveled to New York to attend the 1925 contest awards banquet and found herself in the midst of the Harlem Renaissance, the great outpouring of artistic expression revolving around Harlem. She became an active member of the Harlem literati and soon became the Harlem Renaissance’s most colorful figure. In the fall of 1925, Hurston entered Barnard, the women’s college of Columbia University, on a scholarship arranged by Annie Nathan Meyer. There, she studied anthropology under Franz Boas and received her degree in 1928. Beginning in 1927, Hurston traveled throughout the South, collecting folklore, first under the sponsorship of the Association for the Study of Negro Life and History, and later through various fellowships, including a Guggenheim, and the private sponsorship of Charlotte Osgood Mason, a wealthy white patron of Harlem Renaissance writers including Langston Hughes and Alain Locke. In 1930, Hurston and Hughes collaborated on a black folk play, Mule Bone, an undertaking that severed the personal and professional relationship between Hurston
514
Short Story Writers
and Hughes; the break was never mended and kept the play from being published in its entirety until 1991, long after the deaths of both authors. The dispute, precipitated by the question of principal authorship, while certainly unfortunate, nevertheless illustrates the fiercely independent temperament that Hurston maintained throughout her lifetime. Though the 1930’s got off to a rough start with the controversy with Hughes, the decade proved to be Hurston’s most productive. She published her first novel, Jonah’s Gourd Vine, in 1934, followed in rapid succession by the folklore collection Mules and Men in 1935; another novel, the now classic Their Eyes Were Watching God in 1937; another folklore collection, Tell My Horse, in 1938; Library of Congress and another novel, Moses, Man of the Mountain, in 1939. In addition, Hurston wrote several short stories and several essays, notably those on black culture, published in Nancy Cunard’s massive collection, Negro, in 1934. In 1942, Hurston published her autobiography, Dust Tracks on a Road. Although the book won the Saturday Review’s Ainsfield-Wolf Award for race relations, it proved to be the last significant work of Hurston’s career, although she did publish another novel, Seraph on the Suwanee, in 1948. There are several reasons for the decline in Hurston’s popularity, the most important among them being that her folk-based literature did not fit into protest literature, the dominant literary trend of the 1940’s, coupled with Hurston’s growing conservatism. Further, in September, 1948, shortly before the publication of Seraph on the Suwanee, Hurston was falsely charged with seducing a minor, but before the charges could be dismissed as unfounded, the black press, in particular the Baltimore Afro-American, had spread the story to its readers and had severely, almost irreparably, damaged Hurston’s reputation. Disillusioned and outraged at her treatment by the court and the black press, Hurston moved back to the South, where she lived for the remainder of her life. The 1950’s was a tragic decade for Hurston. Her career was stagnant, and although she kept writing, she received rejection after rejection. She did, however, do some reporting for the Pittsburgh Courier, a black paper with a national circulation; published several essays; and accepted several speaking engagements. She supported herself with occasional work, including substitute teaching and writing freelance articles for various papers. Toward the end of the 1950’s, Hurston’s health became increasingly fragile. She suffered from overweight, hypertension, poor diet, gallbladder trouble, ulcers, and
Hurston, Zora Neale
515
various stomach ailments. In 1959, she suffered a stroke, and in October of that year was placed in the Saint Lucie County welfare home, where, alone and penniless, she died on January 28, 1960. She was buried by subscription a week later in Fort Pierce’s segregated cemetery, the Garden of the Heavenly Rest. Analysis • The bulk of Zora Neale Hurston’s short fiction is set in her native Florida, as are most of her novels. Even when the setting is not Florida, however, the stories are informed by the life, habits, beliefs, and idioms of the people whom Hurston knew so well, the inhabitants of Eatonville primarily. One criticism often leveled at Hurston was that she frequently masqueraded folklore as fiction, or, in other cases, imposed folklore on the fictive narrative. Whatever the merits of such criticism may be, Hurston’s short stories abound with an energy and zest for life that Hurston considered instructive for her readers. “John Redding Goes to Sea” • Hurston’s first published short story is entitled “John Redding Goes to Sea.” It was published in the May, 1921, issue of the Stylus, the literary magazine of Howard University, and was reprinted in the January, 1926, issue of Opportunity. Although the story is obviously the work of a novice writer, with its highly contrived plot, excessive sentimentality, and shallow characterizations, its strengths are many, strengths upon which Hurston would continue to draw and develop throughout her career. The plot is a simple one: Young John Redding, the titular character, wants to leave his hometown to see and explore parts and things unknown. Several circumstances conspire, however, to keep him from realizing his dream. First, John’s mother, the pitifully possessive, obsessive, and superstitious Matty Redding, is determined not to let John pursue his ambitions; in fact, she pleads illness and threatens to disown him if he leaves. Second, John’s marriage to Stella Kanty seems to tie him permanently to his surroundings, as his new wife joins forces with his mother to discourage John’s desire to travel. Further, his mother’s tantrums keep John from even joining the Navy when that opportunity comes his way. Later, when John is killed in a tempest while working with a crew to build a bridge on the St. John’s River, his father forbids his body to be retrieved from the river as it floats toward the ocean. At last, John will get his wish to travel and see the world, although in death. If the plot seems overdone and the sentimentality overwhelming, “John Redding Goes to Sea” does provide the reader with the first of many glimpses of life among black Floridians—their habits, superstitions, strengths, and shortcomings. For example, one of the more telling aspects of the story is that Matty believes that her son was cursed with “travel dust” at his birth; thus, John’s desire to travel is Matty’s punishment for having married his father away from a rival suitor. Hurston suspends judgment on Matty’s beliefs; rather, she shows that these and other beliefs are integral parts of the life of the folk. Another strength that is easily discernible in Hurston’s first short story is her detailed rendering of setting. Hurston has a keen eye for detail, and nowhere is this more evident than in her descriptions of the lushness of Florida. This adeptness is especially present in “John Redding Goes to Sea” and in most of Hurston’s other work as well. By far the most important aspect of “John Redding Goes to Sea” is its theme that people must be free to develop and pursue their own dreams, which is a recurring theme in the Hurston canon. John Redding is deprived of self-expression and
516
Short Story Writers
self-determination because the wishes and interpretations of others are imposed upon him. Hurston clearly has no sympathy with those who would deprive another of freedom and independence; indeed, she would adamantly oppose all such restrictive efforts throughout her career as a writer and folklorist. “Spunk” • Another early short story that treats a variation of this theme is “Spunk,” published in the June, 1925, issue of Opportunity. The central character, Spunk Banks, has the spunk to live his life as he chooses, which includes taking another man’s wife and parading openly around town with her. Although Hurston passes no moral judgment on Banks, she makes it clear that she appreciates and admires his brassiness and his will to live his life according to his own terms. When the story opens, Spunk Banks and Lena Kanty are openly flaunting their affair in front of the Eatonville townspeople, including Lena’s husband, Joe Kanty. The other town residents make fun of Joe’s weakness, his refusal to confront Spunk Banks. Later, when Joe desperately attacks Spunk with a razor, Spunk shoots and kills him. Spunk is tried and acquitted but is killed in a work-related accident, cut to death by a circle saw. Again, superstition plays an important role here, for Spunk claims that he has been haunted by Joe Kanty’s ghost. In fact, Spunk is convinced that Joe’s ghost pushed him into the circle saw, and at least one other townsman agrees. As is customary in Hurston’s stories, however, she makes no judgment of the rightness or wrongness of such beliefs but points out that these beliefs are very much a part of the cultural milieu of Eatonville. “Sweat” • Another early Eatonville story is “Sweat,” published in 1926 in the only issue of the ill-fated literary magazine Fire!, founded by Hurston, Hughes, and Wallace Thurman. “Sweat” shows Hurston’s power as a fiction writer and as a master of the short-story form. Again, the story line is a simple one. Delia Jones is a hardworking, temperate Christian woman being tormented by her arrogant, mean-spirited, and cruel husband of fifteen years, Sykes Jones, who has become tired of her and desires a new wife. Rather than simply leaving her, though, he wants to drive her away by making her life miserable. At stake is the house for which Delia’s “sweat” has paid: Sykes wants it for his new mistress, but Delia refuses to leave the fruit of her labor. Sykes uses both physical and mental cruelty to antagonize Delia, the most farreaching of which is Delia’s intense fear of snakes. When Delia’s fear of the caged rattlesnake that Sykes places outside her back door subsides, Sykes places the rattlesnake in the dirty clothes hamper, hoping that it will bite and kill Delia. In an ironic twist, however, Delia escapes, and the rattlesnake bites Sykes as he fumbles for a match in the dark house. Delia listens and watches as Sykes dies a painful, agonizing death. Although “Sweat” makes use of the same superstitious beliefs as Hurston’s other stories, a more complex characterization and an elaborate system of symbols are central to the story’s development. In Delia, for example, readers are presented with an essentially good Christian woman who is capable of great compassion and long suffering and who discovers the capacity to hate as intensely as she loves; in Sykes, readers are shown unadulterated evil reduced to one at once pitiful and horrible in his suffering. In addition, the Christian symbolism, including the snake and the beast of burden, adds considerable interest and texture to the story. It is this texture that
Hurston, Zora Neale
517
makes “Sweat” Hurston’s most rewarding work of short fiction, for it shows her at her best as literary artist and cultural articulator. “The Gilded Six-Bits” • Although Hurston turned to the longer narrative as the preferred genre during the 1930’s, she continued writing short stories throughout the remainder of her career. One such story is “The Gilded Six-Bits,” published in 1933, which also examines relationships between men and women. In this story, the marriage bed of a happy couple, Joe and Missie May Banks, is defiled by a city slicker, Otis D. Slemmons. Missie May has been attracted by Slemmons’s gold money, which she desires to get for her husband. The gold pieces, however, turn out to be goldplated. Hurston’s message is nearly cliché—“all that glitters is not gold”—but she goes a step further to establish the idea that true love transcends all things. Joe and Missie May are reconciled at the end of the story. Last Stories • Hurston’s last stories are fables that seem to have only comic value but do, however, advance serious thoughts, such as the ridiculousness of the idea of race purity in “Cock Robin, Beale Street” or the equal ridiculousness of the idea that the North was better for blacks, in “Story in Harlem Slang.” Although these stories are not artistic achievements, they do provide interesting aspects of the Hurston canon. In many ways, Hurston’s short stories are apprentice works to her novels. In these stories, she introduced most of the themes, character types, settings, techniques, and concerns upon which she later elaborated during her most productive and artistic period, the 1930’s. This observation, however, does not suggest that her short stories are inferior works. On the contrary, much of the best of Hurston can be found in these early stories. Warren J. Carson With updates by the Editors Other major works plays: Color Struck, pb. 1926; The First One, pb. 1927; Mule Bone, pb. 1931 (with Langston Hughes); Polk County, pb. 1944, pr. 2002. novels: Jonah’s Gourd Vine, 1934; Their Eyes Were Watching God, 1937; Moses, Man of the Mountain, 1939; Seraph on the Suwanee, 1948. miscellaneous: I Love Myself When I Am Laughing . . . and Then Again When I Am Looking Mean and Impressive: A Zora Neale Hurston Reader, 1979. nonfiction: Mules and Men, 1935; Tell My Horse, 1938; Dust Tracks on a Road, 1942; The Sanctified Church, 1981; Folklore, Memoirs, and Other Writings, 1995; Go Gator and Muddy the Water: Writings, 1999 (Pamela Bordelon, editor); Every Tongue Got to Confess: Negro Foktales from the Gulf States, 2001; Zora Neale Hurston: A Life in Letters, 2002 (Carla Kaplan, editor). Bibliography Bloom, Harold, ed. Zora Neale Hurston. New York: Chelsea House, 1986. From the series Modern Critical Views. An excellent collection of criticism of Hurston’s work and life. Includes early commentary by Franz Boas and Langston Hughes, as well as later studies. Chinn, Nancy, and Elizabeth E. Dunn. “‘The Ring of Singing Metal on Wood’: Zora Neale Hurston’s Artistry in ‘The Gilded Six-Bits.’” The Mississippi Quarterly 49
518
Short Story Writers
(Fall, 1996): 775-790. Discusses how Hurston uses setting, ritual, dialect, and the nature of human relationships in the story; argues that the story provides a solution to the problem of reconciling her rural Florida childhood with her liberal arts education and training. Cooper, Jan. “Zora Neale Hurston Was Always a Southerner Too.” In The Female Tradition in Southern Literature, edited by Carol S. Manning. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1993. Examines the hitherto neglected role that Hurston played in the Southern Renaissance between 1920 and 1950. Argues that Hurston’s fiction is informed by a modern southern agrarian sense of community. Suggests that the Southern Renaissance was a transracial, cross-cultural product of the South. Cronin, Gloria L., ed. Critical Essays on Zora Neale Hurston. New York: G. K. Hall, 1998. Useful collection of essays by various scholars that includes bibliographical references and an index. Donlon, Jocelyn Hazelwood. “Porches: Stories: Power: Spatial and Racial Intersections in Faulkner and Hurston.” Journal of American Culture 19 (Winter, 1996): 95110. Comments on the role of the porch in Faulkner and Hurston’s fiction as a transitional space between the public and the private where the individual can negotiate an identity through telling stories. Hill, Lynda Marion. Social Rituals and the Verbal Art of Zora Neale Hurston. Washington, D.C.: Howard University Press, 1996. Chapters on Hurston’s treatment of everyday life, science and humanism, folklore, and color, race, and class. Hill also considers dramatic reenactments of Hurston’s writing. Includes notes, bibliography, and an appendix on “characteristics of Negro expression.” Hurston, Lucy Anne. Speak, So You Can Speak Again: The Life of Zora Neale Hurston. New York: Doubleday, 2004. Brief biography written by Hurston’s niece. Most notable for the inclusion of rare photographs, writings and other multimedia personal artifacts. Also contains an audio CD of Hurston reading and singing. Lyons, Mary E. Sorrow’s Kitchen: The Life and Folklore of Zora Neale Hurston. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1990. Perhaps the only straightforward biography of Hurston, written with the younger reader in mind. Especially useful for those who need a primer on Hurston’s background in all-black Eatonville. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of four short stories by Hurston: “Drenched in Light” (vol. 2), “The Gilded Six-Bits” (vol. 3), and “Spunk” and “Sweat” (vol. 7). Newsom, Adele S. Zora Neale Hurston: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1987. Catalog of Hurston criticism spanning the years 1931-1986, arranged chronologically with annotations. This source is an invaluable aid to serious scholars of Hurston. Also contains an introduction to the criticism on Hurston. An especially useful resource for all inquiries. West, Margaret Genevieve. Zora Neale Hurston and American Literary Culture. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 2005. Chronicle of Hurston’s literary career and a look at why her writing did not gain popularity until long after her death.
519
Washington Ir ving Born: New York, New York; April 3, 1783 Died: Tarrytown, New York; November 28, 1859 Principal short fiction • The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent., 1819-1820; Bracebridge Hall, 1822; Tales of a Traveller, 1824; The Alhambra, 1832; Legends of the Conquest of Spain, 1835; The Complete Tales of Washington Irving, 1975, 1998 (Charles Neider, editor). Other literary forms • Washington Irving distinguished himself in a variety of genres. His finest and most typical book, The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent., blends essay, sketch, history, travel, humor, and short story; his first best-seller was a satire, A History of New York (1809); he coauthored a successful play, Charles the Second: Or, The Merry Monarch (1824); but he devoted the latter and most prolific part of his career to books of travel and especially of history. Achievements • Washington Irving was America’s first internationally recognized author. Although he achieved national attention with his satiric A History of New York, his fame abroad was made with The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. Irving was a prolific writer throughout his life, from his first collaborations with his brother William and friend James Kirke Paulding, to his many biographies of well-known historical figures, including George Washington. Among his most successful works were his collections of sketches and tales, a distinction then made between realistic and imaginative types of fiction. His sketches often make use of historical sources, while the tales usually derive from traditional folktales. His best-known stories, “Rip Van Winkle” and “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,” although largely copied from German folktales, still maintain an originality through their American settings and Irving’s own gently humorous style. Biography • The eleventh and last child of a successful merchant, Washington Irving, somewhat frail and indulged as he was growing up, was the favorite child of his Anglican mother and Presbyterian minister father. As a young man, Irving studied law in the office of Josiah Ogden Hoffman, to whose daughter he was attracted, and enjoyed the social and cultural advantages of New York City as something of a gentlemanplayboy. At this time, he dabbled in satirical writing in serial publications. He gained a certain amount of cosmopolitan sophistication with a tour of Europe in 1804-1806, during which time he kept a journal. Irving was admitted to the New York bar at the age of twenty-three and nominally began to work as a lawyer on Wall Street, although he practiced little. Instead, he wrote serial essays with his brother and James Kirke Paulding for a periodical they called Salmagundi, modeled on Joseph Addison’s Spectator, “to instruct the young, reform the old, correct the town, and castigate the age.” This amounted to making light fun of fashion and social mores in high society, although occasionally they made jabs at Thomas Jefferson’s “logocratic” democracy. “Diedrich Knickerbocker’s” A History of New York followed in 1809; originally in-
520
Short Story Writers
tended as a parody of a pretentious New York guidebook, it had become instead a comic history of the Dutch in New York. When Matilda Hoffman died in the same year, Irving, distraught, stopped writing for a time. He moved in 1811 to Washington, D.C., to lobby for the Irving brothers’ importing firm. Still affected by Matilda’s death, he drifted into several different occupations, lost the brothers’ firm to bankruptcy, yet benefited from his literary contacts to the point where he began to pursue writing with renewed effort. By the time he published The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. in 1819, he was on his way to supporting himself through his writing. In order to find original materials for his sketches, he made various trips through Europe and Library of Congress America, including a ministry to Spain; he returned to New York finally in 1832. His long absence, reminiscent of Rip Van Winkle’s, provided him with a new perspective on the United States, whose western frontier was beginning to open; he packed again, this time for the West, and wrote many of his books out of the experience. He finally returned home to the Hudson, ensconced in family and friends, where he died in 1859. Analysis • Washington Irving’s masterpiece, The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent., has a historical importance few American books can match. No previous American book achieved a really significant popular and critical success in England, the only arena of opinion which then mattered; but Irving demonstrated that an American could write not only well but also brilliantly even by British standards. In fact, throughout the century English as well as American schoolboys studied Irving’s book as a model of graceful prose. Irving had achieved some popularity in his own country well before the British triumphs. In 1807-1808, Irving, his brother William, and James Kirke Paulding collaborated on the independently published periodical series, Salmagundi. Since the project was a true collaboration, scholars are in doubt as to precisely who deserves credit for precisely what, but two pieces deserve particular notice. “Sketches from Nature” sentimentally sketches two old bachelors, one of whom restores the spirits of the other by leading him through scenes reminiscent of their youth. “The Little Man in Black” is supposedly a traditional story passed through generations of a single family. Irving here introduces another old bachelor, who wanders into the village a stranger to all and sets up housekeeping in a decrepit house rumored to be haunted. First ostracized by the adults, then tormented by the local children, ultimately he dies by
Irving, Washington
521
starvation, in his last moments forgiving all, a true but misunderstood Christian. Both pieces display Irving’s graceful style, his prevalent sentimentality, and his wholehearted commitment to charming, pleasing, and entertaining his audience. Both feature an old bachelor stereotype which he inherited from the Addisonian tradition and continued to exploit in later works. The pieces differ in their formal focus, however, and aptly illustrate the two poles of Irving’s fictional nature. The second shows his fondness for the tale tradition: He cites a source in family folklore; the narrative hangs on striking incident; and he flavors the atmosphere with a suggestion of the supernatural. The first features virtues of the periodical essay: evocation of character divorced from dramatic incident; a style dominated by smoothness (Edgar Allan Poe’s term was “repose”) and by descriptions strong on concrete detail; and an essentially realistic atmosphere. Irving’s unique genius led him to combine the best of both traditions in his finest fiction and thereby to create the modern short story in America. Irving’s early career coincided with the rise of Romanticism, and the movement strongly influenced his greatest book, The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. Here he capitalized on the element which strongly marks his most successful stories: imagination. Consistently, Irving’s most successful characters, and stories, are those which most successfully exploit the imagination. “The Spectre Bridegroom” • In “The Spectre Bridegroom,” the title character triumphs not through strength, physical skills, or intelligence, but rather through manipulating the imaginations of those who would oppose his aims. The story’s first section humorously describes a bellicose old widower, the Baron Von Landshort, who has gathered a vast audience, consisting mostly of poor relatives properly cognizant of his high status, to celebrate his only daughter’s marriage to a young count whom none of them has ever seen. In the story’s second part, the reader learns that as the count and his friend Herman Von Starkenfaust journey to the castle, they are beset by bandits; the outlaws mortally wound the count who, with his last breath, begs Von Starkenfaust to relay his excuses to the wedding party. The story’s third part returns to the castle where the long-delayed wedding party finally welcomes a pale, melancholy young man. The silent stranger hears the garrulous Baron speak on, among other matters, his family’s longstanding feud with the Von Starkenfaust family; meanwhile the young man wins the daughter’s heart. He shortly leaves, declaring he must be buried at the cathedral. The next night the daughter’s two guardian aunts tell ghost stories until they are terrified by spying the Spectre Bridegroom outside the window; the daughter sleeps apart from her aunts for three nights, encouraging their fears the while, and finally absconds. When she returns with her husband, Von Starkenfaust, who had pretended to be the Spectre, they both are reconciled with the Baron and live happily ever after. By becoming in one sense artists themselves, Herman and his bride both manipulate the imaginations of the Baron, the aunts, and the entire wedding party to make their courtship and elopement possible; here, happily, the dupees lose nothing and share the ultimate happiness of the dupers. There are at least three dimensions to “The Spectre Bridegroom”: As it is read, one can imaginatively identify with the duped family and believe the Spectre genuine, or alternately identify with the young couple innocently manipulating their elders. A third dimension enters when the reader recalls the personality of the frame’s Swiss tale-teller, occasionally interrupting himself with “a roguish leer and a sly joke for the buxom
522
Short Story Writers
kitchen maid” and himself responsible (it is surely not the modest and proper Geoffrey Crayon or Washington Irving) for the suggestive antlers above the prospective bridegroom’s head at the feast. “Rip Van Winkle” • The narrative perspectives informing Irving’s single greatest achievement, “Rip Van Winkle,” radiate even greater complexities. At the simplest level the core experience is that of Rip himself, a good-natured idler married to a termagant who drives him from the house with her temper. While hunting in the woods, Rip pauses to assist a curious little man hefting a keg; in a natural amphitheater he discovers dwarfish sailors in archaic dress playing at ninepins. Rip drinks, falls asleep, and awakens the next morning alone on the mountainside. In a subtle, profound, and eerily effective sequence, Irving details Rip’s progressive disorientation and complete loss of identity. The disintegration begins mildly enough—Rip notices the decayed gun (a thief’s substitute he thinks), his dog’s absence, some stiffness in his own body—each clue is emotionally more significant than the last, but each may be easily explained. Rip next notices changes in nature—a dry gully has become a raging stream, a ravine has been closed by a rockslide; these are more dramatic alterations, but still explainable after a long night’s sleep. Upon entering the village, he discovers no one but strangers and all in strange dress; he finds his house has decayed, his wife and children have disappeared; buildings have changed as well as the political situation and even the very manner and behavior of the people. In a terrible climax, when Irving for once declines to mute the genuine horror, Rip profoundly questions his own identity. When he desperately asks if anyone knows poor Rip Van Winkle, fingers point to another ragged idler at the fringe, the very image of Rip himself as he had ascended the mountain. Even Poe or Franz Kafka never painted a loss of identity more absolute, more profound, more credible, more terrible. After a moment of horror, Irving’s sentimental good humor immediately reasserts itself. Rip’s now-adult daughter appears and recognizes him; the ragged idler turns out to be his son, Rip, Jr. Rip himself hesitates for a moment, but, upon learning that his wife has died “but a short time since,” declares his identity and commences reintegrating himself in the community, eventually to become an honored patriarch, renowned for recounting his marvelous experience. Thus is the nature of the core narrative, which is almost all most people ever read. The reader values the story for its profound mythic reverberations; after all, throughout Western civilization Irving’s Rip has become an archetype of time lost. The reader may also appreciate Irving’s amoral toying with lifestyles, and although the Yankee/Benjamin Franklin lifestyle Rip’s wife advocates and which leads to her death (she bursts a blood vessel while haggling) fails to trap Rip, he triumphs by championing the relatively unambitious, self-indulgent lifestyle Irving identifies with the Dutch. Still, many people feel tempted to reject the piece as a simplistic fairy tale dependent on supernatural machinery for its appeal and effect. This is a mistake. Those who read the full story as Irving wrote it will discover, in the headnote, that Irving chose to relate the story not from the point of view of an omniscient narrator but from that of Diedrich Knickerbocker, the dunderheaded comic persona to whom years earlier he had ascribed the burlesque A History of New York. The presence of such a narrator—and Irving went to some trouble to introduce him—authorizes the reader to reject the supernatural elements and believe, as Irving tells us many of
Irving, Washington
523
Rip’s auditors believed, that in actuality Rip simply tired of his wife, ran away for twenty years, and concocted a cock-and-bull story to justify his absence. Looking closer, the reader discovers copious hints that this is precisely what happened: Rip’s reluctance to become Rip again until he is sure his wife is dead; the fact that when his neighbors hear the story they “wink at each other and put their tongues in their cheeks”; the fact that, until he finally established a satisfactory version of the events, he was observed “to vary on some points every time he told it.” In the concluding footnote, even dim Diedrich Knickerbocker acknowledges the story’s doubtfulness but provides as evidence of its truth the fact that he has heard even stranger supernatural stories of the Catskills, and that to authenticate his story Rip signed a certificate in the presence of a justice of the peace. “The story, therefore, is beyond the possibility of doubt.” Irving clearly intends to convince his closest readers that Rip, like the couple in “The Spectre Bridegroom,” triumphed over circumstances by a creative manipulation of imagination. “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” • In “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” our source is again Diedrich Knickerbocker, and again, creatively manipulating the imaginations of others proves the key to success. The pleasant little Dutch community of Sleepy Hollow has imported a tall, grotesquely lanky Yankee as schoolmaster, Ichabod Crane. Although he is prey to the schoolboys’ endless pranks, he himself ravenously and endlessly preys on the foodstuffs of the boys’ parents. Ichabod finally determines to set his cap for the pretty daughter of a wealthy farmer, but Brom Bones, the handsome, Herculean local hero, has likewise determined to court the girl. The climax comes when the principals gather with the entire community at a dance, feast, and “quilting frolic” held at Katrina Van Tassel’s home. Brom fills the timorous and credulous Ichabod full of tales of a horrible specter, ghost of a Hessian soldier beheaded by a cannonball, who inhabits the region through which Ichabod must ride that night to return home. As he makes his lonely journey back, Ichabod encounters the dark figure who carries his head under his arm rather than on his neck and who runs him a frightful race to a bridge. At the climax the figure hurls his head and strikes Ichabod, who disappears, never to be seen in the village again. Brom marries Katrina, and years later the locals discover that Ichabod turned lawyer, politician, newspaperman, and finally became a “justice of the Ten Pound Court.” Again it is the character who creatively manipulates the imagination who carries the day; the manipulatee wins only the consolation prize. Again the Dutch spirit triumphs over the Yankee. In this story there is something quite new, however; for the first time in American literature there is, in the characterization of Brom Bones, the figure of the frontiersman so important to American literature and American popular culture: physically imposing, self-confident, rough and ready, untutored but endowed with great natural virtues, gifted with a rude sense of chivalry, at home on the fringes of civilization, and incorporating in his own being the finer virtues of both the wilderness and the settlements. Ir ving here brilliantly anticipated both the essence of southwestern humor and of James Fenimore Cooper’s seminal Westerns. Irving wrote a great many other stories, including several romantic tales set in Spain, most of them flawed by superficiality and sentimentality; he also produced a number of gothic stories, some of which are still read with pleasure, among them “The Adventure of the German Student” and “The Devil and Tom Walker.” Irving,
524
Short Story Writers
however, reached his highest point in his first published short story, “Rip Van Winkle.” He never equaled it in any subsequent story—but then, only a tiny handful of writers ever have. Walter Evans With updates by Ann A. Merrill Other major works miscellaneous: The Complete Works of Washington Irving, 1969-1989 (30 volumes). play: Charles the Second: Or, The Merry Monarch, pb. 1824 (with John Howard Payne). nonfiction: A History of New York, 1809; Biography of James Lawrence, 1813; A History of the Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus, 1828; A Chronicle of the Conquest of Granada, 1829; Voyages and Discoveries of the Companions of Columbus, 1831; A Tour of the Prairies, 1835; Astoria, 1836; The Adventures of Captain Bonneville, 1837; The Life of Oliver Goldsmith, 1849; The Life of George Washington, 1855-1859 (5 volumes). Bibliography Aderman, Ralph M., ed. Critical Essays on Washington Irving. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1990. Collection of essays on Irving, from both the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Includes discussions of Irving’s art and literary debts, the relationship of his stories to his culture, and his generic heritage. Hiller, Alice. “‘An Avenue to Some Degree of Profit and Reputation’: The Sketch Book as Washington Irving’s Entree and Undoing.” Journal of American Studies 31 (August, 1997): 275-293. Claims that some of Irving’s personal correspondence reveals that The Sketch Book may have been pitched deliberately at the British market, resulting in a paralysis of Irving’s powers of writing. McFarland, Philip. Sojourners. New York: Atheneum, 1979. Although not a conventional biography, this study of Washington Irving’s life situates the writer in his various geographic, historic, and literary contexts. McFarland explores in detail the life of Irving, interweaving his biography with those of other important Americans of the time, among them Aaron Burr, the abolitionist John Brown, and John J. Astor. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of four short stories by Irving: “Adventure of the German Student” (vol. 1), “The Devil and Tom Walker” (vol. 2), “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” (vol. 4), and “Rip Van Winkle” (vol. 6). Murray, Laura J. “The Aesthetic of Dispossession: Washington Irving and Ideologies of (De)colonization in the Early Republic.” American Literary History 8 (Summer, 1996): 205-231. Argues that Euro-Americans cultivated their sense of vulnerability with respect to Great Britain and in so doing rhetorically excused themselves from their colonizing role with regard to Native Americans. Myers, Andrew B., ed. A Century of Commentary on the Works of Washington Irving. Tarrytown, N.Y.: Sleepy Hollow Restorations, 1976. This collection, divided into four chronologically ordered sections, offers writings on Washington Irving. Part 1 includes essays by contemporaries of Irving, such as William Cullen Bryant and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow; part 2 covers evaluations from the beginning of the nineteenth century. Early twentieth century scholars of American literature,
Irving, Washington
525
such as Fred Lewis Pattee, Vernon Louis Parrington, and Van Wyck Brooks, are represented in part 3, and part 4 covers the period 1945 to 1975. The collection gives an excellent overview of the development of Irving criticism and provides a point of departure for further investigations. Piacentino, Ed. “‘Sleepy Hollow’ Comes South: Washington Irving’s Influence on Old Southwestern Humor.” The Southern Literary Journal 30 (Fall, 1997): 27-42. Examines how nineteenth century southern backwoods humorists adapted Washington Irving’s “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” to a southern setting; discusses a number of works with clear parallels to Irving’s story. Plummer, Laura, and Michael Nelson. “‘Girls Can Take Care of Themselves’: Gender and Storytelling in Washington Irving’s ‘The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.’” Studies in Short Fiction 30 (Spring, 1993): 175-184. Argues that Sleepy Hollow is femalecentered; the tales that circulate in the region focus on emasculated, headless spirits and serve to drive out masculine interlopers like Ichabod and thus preserve the old Dutch domesticity based on wives’ tales. Rubin-Dorsky, Jeffrey. Adrift in the Old World: The Psychological Pilgrimage of Washington Irving. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988. In this study of Irving’s short fiction, Rubin-Dorsky sets out to establish Irving’s Americanness, thus reversing a critical tradition that marked him as primarily imitative of British prose style. By placing Irving within his historical context, Rubin-Dorsky underscores Irving’s central position in early American letters. Tuttleton, James W., ed. Washington Irving: The Critical Reaction. New York: AMS Press, 1993. Essays of critical interpretation of Irving’s works. Williams, Stanley T. The Life of Washington Irving. 2 vols. New York: Oxford University Press, 1935. This thorough biography provides a wealth of biographical and literary detail about Irving. Volume 1 is most useful for those interested in Irving’s short fiction, as it covers his life and his work up to The Alhambra.
526
Shirley Jackson Born: San Francisco, California; December 14, 1916 Died: North Bennington, Vermont; August 8, 1965 Principal short fiction • The Lottery: Or, The Adventures of James Harris, 1949 (also pb. as The Lottery, and Other Stories); Just an Ordinary Day, 1996 (Laurence Jackson Hyman and Sarah Hyman Stewart, editors); Shirley Jackson Collected Stories, 2001. Other literary forms • Shirley Jackson’s dozen published books include novels, humorous fictionalized autobiographies, and children’s books. Many of her stories, essays, and public speeches remain uncollected. Several works have been adapted to other media: “The Lottery” for television, We Have Always Lived in the Castle (1962) for stage, and The Bird’s Nest (1954) and The Haunting of Hill House (1959) for the cinema. Achievements • Shirley Jackson is probably best known for her short story “The Lottery,” which was first published in the June 26, 1948, edition of The New Yorker. As with the majority of her works, both short stories and novels, “The Lottery” explores the darker side of the human psyche, often in a manner disturbing to the reader. In addition to using ordinary settings for extraordinary occurrences, Jackson often injects an element of the supernatural. This is seen, for example, in the story “The Visit” and in the novel The Haunting of Hill House. In addition, Jackson has published Life Among the Savages (1953), a highly humorous account of her home life. In 1961, Jackson received the Edgar Allan Poe Award for her story “Louisa, Please.” She was awarded the Syracuse University Arents Pioneer Medal for Outstanding Achievement in 1965. In 2001, Peterson Publishing brought out a new edition of her best short fiction in its Great Author series. Biography • Shirley Jackson was born in California on December 14, 1919, and moved with her family to New York when she was sixteen. After an unsuccessful year at the University of Rochester, Jackson enrolled, at the age of twenty, in the University of Syracuse. This was to be the beginning of an independent life for the author, as she would finally be away from the dominating presence of her mother. At Syracuse, Jackson met Stanley Edgar Hyman, the man she would marry in 1940. Hyman achieved fame in his own right as a teacher, writer, and critic. The marriage between Jackson and Hyman was tumultuous in many ways but provided a stabilizing factor for Jackson. Her literary production increased markedly after the marriage and the birth of their four children. Jackson’s own phobias, however, kept creeping into this successful, if odd, relationship. She was an agoraphobic and a depressive. Part of the latter affliction was contributed to by her asthma and arthritis, as well as Hyman’s extramarital affair in the early 1960’s. In addition, Jackson had never really been a social person—she was much too individualistic to fit into any of the polite social molds. In 1963, Jackson began to turn around psychologically. Her husband made a new commitment to the marriage, and an enlightened psychiatrist began to help her work with the agoraphobia. Her writing continued to be an outlet for her. Although Jackson re-
Jackson, Shirley
527
covered emotionally, she never recovered physically. She was obese and a chain smoker. She died on August 8, 1965, at the age of forty-eight. Analysis • Shirley Jackson’s stories seem to center on a single concern: Almost every story is about a protagonist’s discovering or failing to discover or successfully ignoring an alternate way of perceiving a set of circumstances or the world. Jackson seems especially interested in how characters order their worlds and how they perceive themselves in the world. Often, a change in a character’s perspective leads to anxiety, terror, neurosis, or even a loss of identity. Although it is tempting to say that her main theme is the difference between appearance and reality, such a statement is misleading, for she seems to see reality as Herman Melville’s Ishmael comes to see it, as a mirror of the perceiving soul. It is rarely clear that her characters discover or lose their grasp of reality; rather, they form ideas of reality that are more or less moral and more or less functional. For Jackson, reality is so complex and mysterious that one inevitably only orders part of it. A character may then discover parts that contradict a chosen order or that attract one away from the apparent order, but one can never affirm the absolute superiority of one ordering to another. In this respect, Jackson’s fictional world resembles those of Stephen Crane and Ernest Hemingway. Perhaps the major differences between her fiction and theirs is that her protagonists are predominantly women; she explores some peculiarly feminine aspects of the problem of ideas of order. Jackson’s middle-class American women seem especially vulnerable to losing the security of a settled worldview. Their culture provides them with idealistic dream visions of what their lives should be, and they have a peculiar leisure for contemplation and conversation imposed upon them by their dependent roles. Men in her stories seem so busy providing that they rarely look at and think about the order of things. Her career women are more like these men. In “Elizabeth” and “The Villager,” the protagonists succeed, albeit precariously, in preserving ideas of themselves and their worlds despite the contradictory facts that seem increasingly to intrude. In these two stories, one sees a sort of emotional cannibalism in the protagonists as they attempt to preserve belief in an order that reality seems no longer disposed to sustain. Several stories show a woman’s loss of an ordering dream. These divide into stories about women who experience the terror of loss of identity and those who may find a liberating and superior order in what would ordinarily be called infantile fantasy. Among those who lose a dream are the protagonists of “The Little House” and “The Renegade.” In “The Little House,” a woman’s first possession of her own small country house is ruined by the terrifying insinuations of her new neighbors; they leave her alone on her first night after relating to her their fears that the previous owner was murdered and that the murderer will return. In “The Renegade,” a mother discovers an unsuspected cruelty in her neighbors and even in her children when her dog is accused of killing chickens. Although Jackson’s humorous autobiographical stories are of a different order, the often anthologized “Charles” tells of a mother’s discovery that the nemesis of the kindergarten whose antics her son reports each day is not the mythical Charles, but her own son, Laurie. Perhaps the most successful escape into fantasy is Mrs. Montague’s in “The Island.” All her physical needs are provided by a wealthy but absent son and the constant attendance of Miss Oakes. Mrs. Montague lives in her dream of a tropical paradise, virtually untouched by her actual world. This escape is judged by the ironic frame of Miss Oakes’s relative poverty and her inevitable envy, suffering, spite, and ugliness; she has no chance of such an escape herself. Some movements into fantasy
528
Short Story Writers
are terrifying or at least ambiguous. In “The Beautiful Stranger,” Margaret resolves a tension in her marriage by perceiving the man who returns from a business trip as a stranger, not her husband. By the end of the story, this fantasy has led to her losing herself, unable to find her home when she returns from a shopping trip. A similar but more ambiguous situation develops in “The Tooth,” in which a woman escapes into a vision of an island to evade the pain of an aching tooth. Many of Jackson’s protagonists conceive of an island paradise as an ideal order when their control of the immediate is threatened. Some ideas of order remain impenetrable. In “Louisa, Please,” a variation on Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Wakefield,” a runaway daughter returns home after a long absence to discover that her family has built a life around her loss and will not be convinced of her return. In “Flower Garden” and “After You, My Dear Alphonse,” protagonists find themselves unable to change or to abandon racist ideas because the ideas are too strong or because of community pressure. “The Visit” • A closer look at three especially interesting stories reveals more about Jackson’s themes and gives some indication of her technical proficiency. In “The Visit,” Margaret comes to visit a school friend, Carla Rhodes, for the summer. The beautiful Rhodes estate includes a dream house with numerous fantastic rooms. The house seems not quite real; nearly every room is covered with tapestries depicting the house in different hours and seasons, and there is a mysterious tower of which no one speaks. For Margaret, the house and the family are ideal, especially when Carla’s brother, Paul, arrives with his friend, the Captain. This idyll lasts until the evening of Paul’s departure, when Margaret discovers that Paul has been a hallucination or a ghost, for the Captain is Carla’s brother and no one else has seen Paul. This revelation clarifies several mysteries that have developed, especially that of Margaret’s strange visit to the tower. Paul has told Margaret that an old aunt often secludes herself in the tower. When Margaret pays her a visit, she undergoes a not really frightening but certainly haunting experience with old Aunt Margaret. At the end of the story, the reader must conclude Aunt Margaret to be an apparition, that she is probably the Margaret who died for love and whose picture in mosaic appears on the floor of one room. Young Margaret has lost a phantom lover as old Margaret lost her Paul. Young Margaret realizes this at the same time that she is made aware of time’s effect on the house: the age and weakness of the Rhodeses, the bitter darkness of their true son, and the physical decay of the buildings. Furthermore, she begins to doubt her own place and identity as she wonders if her visit to the house will ever end. The home of her dreaming now threatens to become an imprisoning nightmare. In retrospect, the device by which Jackson encourages the reader to share Margaret’s hallucination or haunting may seem contrived. This choice, however, seems effective because the more fully the reader shares Margaret’s perceptions and the more subdued (without being absent) are the disturbing elements, the more fully will the reader share the shock of her awakening into nightmare. Also technically effective are the apparent connections with Poe’s “The Fall of the House of Usher.” Most important among these is the succession of mirror images: multiple pictures of the house, between the house and Mrs. Rhodes, among members of the family, between the two Margarets, and between the decline of the family and of the house. These connections seem deliberately chosen in part to emphasize the contrasts between Margaret and Poe’s narrator. Because Margaret’s response to the house is so positive, the shock of her discovery is greater by contrast. Furthermore, when she dis-
Jackson, Shirley
529
covers this house to be like what one knows the House of Usher to be, one sees the analogy between her terror at imprisonment and that of Poe’s narrator when he sees a universe unnaturally lit by a blood red moon, yet another image of the coffin lit from within. Margaret actually enters one of the dream worlds promised American girls. Under its spell, she overlooks its flaws and forgets about time, but when the Captain breaks the spell, pointing out signs of decay, Paul departs and Margaret becomes acutely aware of time as her nightmare begins. “Pillar of Salt” • Time is often the destroyer of feminine ideals in Jackson’s stories because they seem to depend on a suspension of time. In “Pillar of Salt,” another Margaret loses her secure world. A trip to New York City with her husband forces a new perspective on her which produces her anxiety and, finally, paranoia. It remains unclear, however, whether her paranoia is illness or a healthy reaction to an inimical environment. The couple’s first week in the city is idyllic, and the fast pace is a pleasant change from New Hampshire. At a party at the end of the first week, however, Margaret begins to feel isolated, unnoticed among strangers who behave in strange ways. She learns there is a fire in the building but is unable to persuade anyone else to leave. The fire turns out to be two buildings away, but she is the only one to heed the warning and flee the building. She comes to see this nightmarish experience as symbolic of her experience in New York and perhaps of her life as a whole. She begins to notice new details about the city: dirt, decay, speed, stifling crowds. She feels increasingly isolated and insignificant. Of this life she thinks, “She knew she was afraid to say it truly, afraid to face the knowledge that it was a voluntary neck-breaking speed, a deliberate whirling faster and faster to end in destruction.” Even her friends’ Long Island beach cottage shows the spreading blight; there they find a severed human leg on the sand. Margaret comes to believe that her former order was illusory. Upon returning to the city, she begins to hallucinate, to see the destruction of the city in fast motion. Windows crumble. Her bed shakes. Driven from her apartment, she finds herself unable to return, paralyzed in a fast-moving, anonymous crowd on the wrong side of a mechanical and murderous river of traffic. Margaret comes to see herself in a modern Sodom, paralyzed not because she has disobeyed God, but because she has seen in prophetic vision the truth about the city: It is no home for human beings but rather is impersonally intent upon destruction. The allusion of the title and her critique of city life verify her perception; however, those who do not share her vision remain capable of functioning. As in “The Visit,” the internal view of Margaret encourages a close identification between reader and character which makes judgment difficult until the reader can step back; but stepping back from “Pillar of Salt” plunges the reader deeper into mystery. In both stories, the protagonist moves from dream to nightmare, but in “Pillar of Salt,” the reader is much less certain that the move is to a better or more accurate view of reality. “The Lottery” • Shirley Jackson’s reputation rests primarily upon her most anthologized story, “The Lottery.” Her lecture on this story (printed in Come Along with Me) suggests that her creation of a normal setting convinced many readers that the story was largely factual. In fact, the central problem of the story seems to be to reconcile the portrait of typical small-town life in which the characters seem just like the reader with the horrifying ritualistic killing these people carry
530
Short Story Writers
out. Here, apparently incompatible ideas of order are thrust upon the reader for resolution, perhaps in order tocomplicate the reader’s conceptions. “The Lottery” develops by slowly raising the level of tension in the semipastoral setting until a series of carefully arranged revelations brings about a dramatic and shocking reversal. The villagers gather at mid-morning on a late June day for an annual event, the lottery, around which a great deal of excitement centers. Jackson supplies details which arouse reader curiosity: Nearly all towns have a similar lottery; it is as old as the town; it has an elaborate ritual form which has decayed over time; every adult male must participate; some believe the orders of nature and of civilization depend on carrying it out correctly. The family of the man who draws the marked lot must draw again to determine the final winner. The tension built out of reader curiosity and the town’s moods reverses toward the sinister when the “winner’s” wife reveals that she does not want to win. Once this reversal is complete, the story moves rapidly to reveal the true nature of the lottery, to choose a victim for annual sacrifice by stoning. Jackson heightens the horror of this apparently unaccountable act with carefully chosen and placed details. Several commentators have attempted to explain the story through reconstructing the meaning of the ritual and through carefully examining the symbols. Helen Nebeker sees the story as an allegory of “man trapped in a web spun from his own need to explain and control the incomprehensible universe around him, a need no longer answered by the web of old traditions.” These attempts to move beyond the simple thriller seem justified by the details Jackson provides about the lottery. This ritual seems clearly to be a tradition of prehistoric origin, once believed essential for the welfare of the community. Even though its purpose has become obscure and its practice muddled, it continues to unify and sustain the community. Critics tend to underemphasize the apparent health and vitality of the community, perhaps feeling that this ritual essentially undercuts that impression. It is important to notice that one function of the lottery is to change the relationship between community and victim. The victim is chosen at random, killed without malice or significant protest, and lost without apparent grief. This story may be what Richard Eastman has called an open parable, a fable which applies at several levels or in several contexts. “The Lottery” creates an emotional effect of horror at the idea that perhaps in human civilization, the welfare of the many depends often on the suffering of the few: the victim race, the exploited nation, the scapegoat, the poor, the stereotyped sex, the drafted soldier. In these cases, instead of a ritual, other aspects of the social order separate oppressor and victim, yet the genuine order and happiness of the majority seems to depend on the destruction of others. In this respect, “The Lottery” resembles many stories of oppression, such as Franz Kafka’s “The Bucket Rider” and some stories by Richard Wright; its purpose may be to jar readers into thinking about ways in which their lives victimize others. Jackson places the reader of “The Lottery,” which lacks a protagonist, in a position similar to that of the protagonists of “The Visit” and “Pillar of Salt.” The story moves from a relatively secure agrarian worldview to an event which fantastically complicates that view. Here, as in most of her stories, Jackson emphasizes the complexity of reality. Nature and human nature seem unaccountable mixtures of the creative and destructive. Her best people are in search of ways to live in this reality without fear and cruelty. Terry Heller With updates by Victoria E. McLure
Jackson, Shirley
531
Other major works children’s literature: Nine Magic Wishes, 1963; Famous Sally, 1966. play: The Bad Children, pb. 1958. novels: The Road Through the Wall, 1948 (also pb. as The Other Side of the Street); Hangsaman, 1951; The Bird’s Nest, 1954 (also pb. as Lizzie); The Sundial, 1958; The Haunting of Hill House, 1959; We Have Always Lived in the Castle, 1962. miscellaneous: Come Along with Me: Part of a Novel, Sixteen Stories, and Three Lectures, 1968 (Stanley Edgar Hyman, editor). nonfiction: Life Among the Savages, 1953; The Witchcraft of Salem Village, 1956; Raising Demons, 1957. Bibliography Hall, Wylie. Shirley Jackson: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1993. Introduction to Jackson’s stories, with comments by Jackson herself, and a few short, previously published, critical articles by others. Discusses Jackson’s interest in the occult, her fascination with dream situations, her focus on children, and her most famous story, “The Lottery.” Hattenhauer, Darryl. Shirley Jackson’s American Gothic. New York: State University of New York Press, 2003. Strong argument for Jackson’s modernity. Analyzes her use of the supernatural as metaphor and illuminates the influences of Jackson’s substance abuse, marital strife, and political leanings on her work. Kittredge, Mary. “The Other Side of Magic: A Few Remarks About Shirley Jackson.” In Discovering Modern Horror Fiction, edited by Darrell Schweitzer. Mercer Island, Wash.: Starmont House, 1985. Useful study of the use of magic and the supernatural in Jackson’s works. The author draws interesting comparisons between Jackson’s fiction and nonfiction works. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Jackson: “Charles” (vol. 1); and “The Lottery” and “One Ordinary Day, with Peanuts” (vol. 5). Murphy, Bernice M., ed. Shirley Jackson: Essays on the Literary Legacy. Jefferson, N.C.: McFarland, 2005. Collection of essays that reveals Jackson’s better and lesser known works. Oppenheimer, Judy. Private Demons: The Life of Shirley Jackson. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1988. This volume is the first extensive biography of Jackson. It is finely detailed and provides the reader an excellent view of this author. Oppenheimer interviewed close to seventy persons for this book, including Jackson’s family members, friends, and neighbors. Contains numerous photographs. Parks, John G. “‘The Possibility of Evil’: A Key to Shirley Jackson’s Fiction.” Studies in Short Fiction 15, no. 3 (Summer, 1978): 320-323. This useful article concentrates on Jackson’s short stories. Parks draws useful comparisons with authors such as Flannery O’Connor and Nathaniel Hawthorne. Rubinsein, Roberta. “House Mothers and Haunted Daughters: Shirley Jackson and Female Gothic.” Tulsa Studies in Women’s Literature 15 (Fall, 1996): 309-331. Explains how Jackson’s fiction demonstrates her increasingly gothic representation of the bonds between mothers and daughters; discusses this theme in a number of Jackson’s stories.
532
Short Story Writers
Schaub, Danielle. “Shirley Jackson’s Use of Symbols in ‘The Lottery.’” Journal of the Short Story in English 14 (Spring, 1990): 79-86. Discusses how Jackson distracts the reader’s attention into thinking the story is a fable or fairy tale; discusses the symbolic use of setting, atmosphere, numbers, names, and objects in the story. Stark, Jack. “Shirley Jackson’s ‘The Lottery.’” In Censored Books, edited by Nicholas Karolider, Lee Burgess, and John M. Kean. Lanham, Md.: Scarecrow Press, 1993. Discusses some of the reasons for the story’s being censored in schools and some of the values of teaching the story to teenagers; argues that it encourages reflection on some of the issues teens need to understand to become good citizens. Yarmove, Jay A. “Shirley Jackson’s ‘The Lottery.’” The Explicator 52 (Summer, 1994): 242-245. Discusses the importance of setting, historical time, and irony of character names in the allegorical meaning of the story. Compares the ending of the story to the ending of Hardy’s Tess of the D’Urbervilles.
533
Henr y James Born: New York, New York; April 15, 1843 Died: London, England; February 28, 1916 Principal short fiction • A Passionate Pilgrim, 1875; The Madonna of the Future, 1879; The Siege of London, 1883; Tales of Three Cities, 1884; The Author of Beltraffio, 1885; The Aspern Papers, 1888; The Lesson of the Master, 1892; The Private Life, Lord Beaupre, The Visits, 1893; The Real Thing, 1893; Terminations, 1895; Embarrassments, 1896; The Two Magics: The Turn of the Screw and Covering End, 1898; The Soft Side, 1900; The Better Sort, 1903; The Novels and Tales of Henry James, 1907-1909 (24 volumes); The Finer Grain, 1910; A Landscape Painter, 1919; Travelling Companions, 1919; Master Eustace, 1920; Stories of Writers and Other Artists, 1944; Henry James: Selected Short Stories, 1950; Henry James: Eight Tales from the Major Phase, 1958; The Complete Tales of Henry James, 1962-1965 (12 volumes; Leon Edel, editor); The Figure in the Carpet, and Other Stories, 1986; The Jolly Corner, and Other Tales, 1990; The Uncollected Henry James: Newly Discovered Stories, 2004. Other literary forms • Henry James was a prolific writer who, from 1875 until his death, published at least one book every year. In addition to his considerable output of short fiction, he wrote novels, dramas, biographies, autobiographies, reviews, travelogues, art and literary criticism, literary theory, and letters. His most notable novels include Daisy Miller (1878), The Europeans (1878), The Portrait of a Lady (1880-1881), Washington Square (1880), The Bostonians (1885-1886), The Tragic Muse (1889-1890), The Turn of the Screw (1898), The Wings of the Dove (1902), and The Ambassadors (1903). James was a pioneer in the criticism and theory of fiction. Much of his criticism appears in Leon Edel and Mark Wilson’s edition of Henry James: Literary Criticism (1984). James’s creative method and the sources of many of his works are documented in The Complete Notebooks of Henry James (1987). Achievements • Henry James contributed to the development of the modernist novel, invented cryptic tales that border on the postmodern, and laid the groundwork for the contemporary theory of narrative. He completed twenty novels (two uncompleted novels were published posthumously). He also wrote 112 short stories, 7 travel books, 3 autobiographies, numerous plays, 2 critical biographies, and voluminous works of criticism. James brought the American novel to its fruition and gave it an international flavor. He transformed the novel of physical adventure to one of psychological intrigue. His character studies are probing and intense. His precise use of limited point of view invites the reader to become actively engaged in interpreting events and ferreting out meaning. His works also achieve a masterful blend of summarized action and dramatic scenes. In his short fiction, he created the forerunners of the modern antiheroes and invented metafictional stories about the nature of art and writing. Also, his critical works and many prefaces have given modern critics a vocabulary for discussing character and point of view. James edited a deluxe edition of his complete works, received honorary degrees from Harvard University and the University of Oxford, and was awarded the Order of Merit from King George V. His works have influenced Joseph Conrad, James Joyce, Virginia Woolf, and Graham Greene.
534
Short Story Writers
Biography • Henry James’s career is usually divided into four periods: his formative years, his apprenticeship, his middle years, and his major phase. James was descended from Irish Protestants. His grandfather, a poor immigrant, lived out the American Dream and died one of the wealthiest men in the United States. James’s father, Henry James, Sr., renounced the Calvinistic work ethic and indulged in the mysticism of Emanuel Swedenborg and the socialism of Charles Fourier. Through most of his youth, James was shuttled back and forth between Europe and the United States, thus gaining an international perspective on art and life. He learned French and received a European education through a variety of tutors and schools. As a young man, he was exposed to the greatest museums and art galleries in the world. His eye for painting aided him in creating a painterly quality in his work. In 1858, his family moved to Newport, Rhode Island, which was to become the scene of some of his early works of fiction. In 1862, he went to Harvard University to study law but attended James Russell Lowell’s lectures and decided to pursue a literary career. In 1864, he published his first short story and continued to write stories and criticism for the rest of his life. In 1869, he spent a year abroad. With the death of his favorite cousin, Minnie, in 1870, he believed that his youth had come to an end. James entered his apprentice years between 1865 and 1882. During these years, he published his first collection of short fiction, A Passionate Pilgrim, and his first significant novel, Roderick Hudson (1876). He achieved popular success with Daisy Miller and went on to write The American (1876-1877), Washington Square (1880), and The Portrait of a Lady (1880-1881). These works dealt with the international theme and explored the problems of American innocence exposed to the corrupting influence of European society. During the 1880’s, James began to take up some of the themes of the naturalists. With The Bostonians (1885-1886) and The Princess Casamassima (1885-1886), James began to treat the issues of social reformers. These novels, along with The Tragic Muse (1889-1890), were not successful. Between 1890 and 1895, James attempted to establish his reputation as a dramatist, but he was unable to please theater audiences, and his play Guy Domville (1894) was booed. In 1897, James settled down in Lamb House in Sussex, and by 1900 he had entered his major phase and had written three richly textured novels: The Wings of the Dove (1902), The Ambassadors (1903), and The Golden Bowl (1904). He died in 1916 in London and was buried in the United States. Analysis • Henry James believed that an author must be granted his donnée, or central idea, and then be judged on the execution of his material. James’s stories are about members of high society. The characters do not engage in dramatic actions but spend much of their time in cryptic conversations, which slowly reveal the intense psychological strain under which they are laboring. James’s narrators are often confused individuals trying to puzzle out and evaluate themselves and the people around them. Romance is frequently at the center of James’s tales, but his lovers have difficulty coming to terms with their own feelings, and often love goes unrecognized and unfulfilled. Marriage is often rejected by his characters, and when it does appear, it is often the scene of heartaches and hidden resentments. Death and dying are also a part of James’s stories. Even though he focuses on the death of women and children, he avoids both the macabre and the sentimental. His stories can be divided into three categories: international romances, tales about writers and artists, and introspective narratives about wasted lives.
James, Henry
535
James has not been given the same recognition for his short fiction that Nathaniel Hawthorne and Edgar Allan Poe have received; yet James devoted much of his literary life to the creation of short fiction and made many attempts to master the form. Several times in his life he expressed the desire to give up writing novels and to devote himself solely to creating short fiction. For half a century, James employed himself in the writing of 112 pieces of short fiction, beginning with “A Tragedy of Error” in 1864 and ending with “The Round of Visits” in 1910. He began writing stories ten years before he published his first novel, and over his lifetime, his stories appeared in thirty-five different periodicals on both sides of the Atlantic. James called his short fiction “tales,” and he divided his tales into Library of Congress types. The anecdote, which focuses on one character and one incident, is a brief, compact, and highly distilled story comparable to a sonnet. The longer nouvelle, which often ran between twenty thousand and forty-five thousand words, allowed James greater development in his short fiction, not for multiplying incidents but for probing the depths of a character’s experience. James expanded his stories because he wanted to explore the richness of human experience that lies hidden behind the surface of everyday life. James’s major tales can be divided into three periods: His early stories focus on the international theme; during his middle years, his stories center on writers and artists; and his final stories focus on older characters who have gone through life but never really lived. James’s international stories focus on taking characters with set expectations and placing them in foreign environments. Daisy Miller is one of James’s early novelettes and deals with a young American girl who finds herself out of place in a European environment. Daisy Miller • In Daisy Miller, young Frederick Winterbourne, an American living in Europe, becomes fascinated with the garrulous Daisy Miller, who is vacationing on the Continent. The free-spirited Daisy amiably flirts with Winterbourne. Although he is attracted to her, he is aware that she and her negligent mother are the source of gossip among European Americans, who are scandalized by the forward ways of the unchaperoned young American. After seeing Daisy in Vevey, he again meets her in Rome, where she is frequently seen with Giovanelli, who is thought to be an Italian adventurer. Ostracized by her American compatriots, she continues to be seen with Giovanelli and risks her life by spending a moonlit night with him at the Colosseum,
536
Short Story Writers
where she contracts malaria and dies. The puzzled Winterbourne attends her funeral and realizes that she is innocent. In Daisy Miller, James explores the dilemma of an innocent American woman who flouts the social codes of European society. More than that, however, he explores the mind of Winterbourne, a Europeanized American who tries to figure out whether Daisy is naïve or reckless. Like other Jamesean heroes, Winterbourne cannot commit himself to a woman with whom he is falling in love. Finding her attractive but shallow, he is compelled to lecture her on mores, and when he sees her at the Colosseum, he “cuts her dead.” Unable to break Winterbourne’s stiffness, she sends him a message from her deathbed, noting that she was fond of him. Convinced that he has been unjust to her, Winterbourne escapes into his studies and becomes entangled with a foreign woman. James’s heroine, like Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, represents American innocence. Both have found themselves in a world order that puts them at risk, and both are sacrificed by those who should have helped them. In addition to introducing the international theme, Daisy Miller introduces two Jamesean types: the sacrificed woman and the egotist who rejects her love. Though James later rejected his subtitle A Study, the novelette Daisy Miller is a study of the complexity of human relationships. The enigmatic but vivacious Daisy is sacrificed at the Colosseum like the early Christians, while the reticent and regretful lover experiences a sense of loss as he retreats from the world of spontaneity and life. “The Aspern Papers” • In “The Aspern Papers,” James takes the international theme beyond the romance and weaves a darker and more complex tale. In order to obtain the letters of the American poet Jeffrey Aspern, an unnamed American editor takes up residence with Aspern’s former mistress Juliana Bordereau and is willing to make love to her middle-aged niece, Miss Tita. He pays exorbitant rent for a room in their Venetian hideaway and spends lavishly to create a garden in their courtyard. Feeling that he is inspired by the mystic presence of Aspern and willing to take any measure to obtain the letters, he breaks into Juliana’s drawer and is caught. He retreats, and the dying Juliana hides the papers in her mattress. After Juliana dies, Miss Tita offers to give him the papers if he will marry her. He rejects her proposal only to reconsider it too late, after Miss Tita has burned the papers. The unnamed narrator goes by an alias. Later, he reveals his name to Miss Tita but not to the reader. He is one version of the unidentifiable American hero who either shuffles names like James Fenimore Cooper’s Leatherstocking or assumes various identities like Melville’s heroes. He is a man without an identity, a parasite living on the reputation of a famous writer. He is also a typical American monomaniacal quester, fixed on an obsessive quest and willing to sacrifice all in pursuit of it. The narrator sees himself as part of a grandiose scheme; the garden that he plants becomes the symbol of a lost Eden. In Miss Tita, James again sets up woman as a sacrificial victim. Like other Jamesean heroes (and heroes from American literature in general), the narrator rejects marriage. Also, in his quest for knowledge, he is willing to sacrifice the private lives of Juliana and Aspern. “The Real Thing” • In his next set of stories, which focus on artists and writers, James explores the relationship between life and art, and the conflict between the artist’s public and private life. In “The Real Thing,” James tells the story of an unnamed artist who hires two highly polished aristocrats forced to earn their living as
James, Henry
537
models. Major Monarch and his wife contrast with the artist’s other models, Miss Churm, a feisty cockney, and Oronte, a low-life Italian. The artist discovers that his lower-class models can transform themselves into aristocrats, whereas the real aristocrats present either a static or a distorted picture of reality. An old friend tells him to get rid of the aristocrats because they are ruining his work and jeopardizing his career. The artist, however, respects and sympathizes with their plight but eventually has to dismiss them. In “The Real Thing,” James explores not only the relationship between art and life but also the human dilemma of an artist faced with the conflict of saving his career or upholding his responsibility to two people with whom he sympathizes. The story is built on a series of finely balanced contrasts. The Monarchs are pure aristocrats. The artist thinks that they have come to sit for a portrait, but they have come to be hired as models. The Monarchs are aristocrats, yet they cannot model aristocrats, whereas Miss Churm and Oronte are commoners who can easily transform themselves into gentry. Ironically, the Englishwoman models for Italian types, while the Italian model does Englishmen. The servant-class models start out waiting on the Monarchs, but later the Monarchs wait on the servants. Thus, class distinctions are reversed. The artist wants to paint artistic portraits for which the aristocratic Monarchs are suitable, yet he devotes himself to commercial illustrations, using a working woman who can impersonate an empress. The aristocrats display themselves like slaves at an auction, whereas the servants do their job without auditioning. The lower-class models are professionals; the aristocrats are amateurs. The artist friend is supposedly a good judge of models, but he is a second-rate painter. The greatest irony of all is that people who have no sense of self can become transformed into commercial art, while people holding on to their identity, their own clothes, and their own manners become too photographic, too typical, and too much the real thing. Although the artist must rid himself of the two aristocrats, his experience with them has moved him more deeply than his work with the professional models. The story is a gem of balance and contrast that transforms an aesthetic dilemma into an ethical one and explores the relationship of art to life, servant to master, self to role, portraiture to illustration, and commercial art to lived experience. “The Real Thing” is an often-anthologized story and a perfect illustration of James’s craft in the anecdote or traditional short story. “The Figure in the Carpet” • The theme of the relationship between art and life is broadened in James’s stories about writers. During his middle period, James created a series of stories in which a young would-be writer or critic surveys the life and work of a master writer. In “The Figure in the Carpet,” a story about an eccentric writer who has gained significant critical attention, James probes the nature of criticism itself. An unidentified critic trying to gain a name for himself is called upon to review The Middle, the latest novel of the famous author Hugh Vereker, because the lead critic, George Corvick, has to meet his fiancé, Gwendolen Erme. The narrator writes a glowing review of Vereker’s work, then attends a party in hope of seeing the great author. When a socialite presents Vereker with the narrator’s review, he calls it “the usual twaddle.” Vereker later apologizes to the critic but says that critics often misunderstand the obvious meaning, which stands out in his novels like a figure in a carpet. The critic probes Vereker for clues, but the author says that the clues run throughout his entire work. After searching for the secret meaning in Vereker’s work, the critic gives up the quest as a hoax. His fellow critic Corvick, however, uses the quest for the
538
Short Story Writers
narrative secret as an excuse to work more closely with his fiancé, Gwendolen. Frustrated in their efforts, Corvick leaves the country. While away, he writes Gwendolen that he has figured out the secret, and he and Gwendolen get married. When Corvick dies, Gwendolen will not reveal the secret to the narrator, who is even willing to marry her to obtain it. Gwendolen does marry a mediocre critic, Drayton Deane. After the deaths of Gwendolen, Vereker, and Vereker’s wife, the narrator tries to obtain the secret from Deane, who knows nothing about it. In “The Figure in the Carpet,” James again turns to the monomanical unnamed narrator on a quest for secret knowledge hidden in a text. Like the narrator of “The Aspern Papers,” the critic is willing to marry a woman to gain greater knowledge about an author’s work. James said that the story was about misunderstood authors and the need for more analytical criticism. Yet the story sets up typical Jamesean paradoxes. Is Vereker being honest or is “the figure” merely a hoax on critics? Does Corvick really know the secret or is he using his knowledge to win Gwendolen? What is the puzzling connection between interpreting a work and exploring the intimate relationships between men and women? Why do the many so-called possessors of the secret die? This story has been cited as a model for the critical act by many modern critics. Its metafictional qualities and its strange mixture of love and death with the act of interpretation give it a distinctly postmodern quality. The stories written in James’s later years take on a mystical tone. The artist is replaced by a sensitive individual who has alienated himself from the world. The characters are few and often focus on only two people. The characters remain obsessive, but now they are in pursuit of that part of themselves that haunts them. The Jamesean love story is played out into old age, with the woman as a patient bystander, a reflector of the man’s battle with himself. The image of the hunt found in Cooper, Melville, and Ernest Hemingway is now symbolic of an internal quest for the terrors hidden within the self. The artists, who in earlier stories sought to gain a second chance or find a next time, now become egocentric gentlemen facing the life that they could have had. The venture into the wilderness becomes a metaphor for the descent into the unconscious. “The Altar of the Dead” • In “The Altar of the Dead,” George Stransom constantly memorializes the death of his bride, Mary Antrim, who died of a fever after their wedding day. Like a character from a Poe short story, he maintains an obsessive devotion to his dead love and is chained to the observance of the anniversary of his wife’s death. While remembering his wife, he meets his friend Paul Creston and Paul’s second wife. In a strange way, James returns to the international theme by making Creston’s new wife an American who has married for money. Stransom meditates on Creston’s first wife and idealizes her in her death. Later the same day, Stransom learns of the death of his boyhood friend, Acton Hague, a man who betrayed Stransom in some undisclosed manner. Hague becomes the only dead friend that Stransom rejects, as Stransom becomes more and more absorbed with the dead and creates an altar of candles to them. A mysterious woman becomes a fellow mourner at Stransom’s shrine. It takes him months to learn her name and years to find out her address. He finally comes to her apartment after the death of her aunt, only to find that her room is a personal shrine to Acton Hague, who rejected the woman. Since Stransom cannot light a candle for Hague, the relationship ends. The loss of the woman casts a shadow over his daily devotions at his altar. Dismayed, he has a vision of his dead wife, Mary, smiling at him from heaven. Just then, the mysterious woman
James, Henry
539
returns to him as he dies in her arms. The last candle on the altar is lit not only for Acton Hague but also for Stransom. Stransom has left the world of the living and has become obsessed with the dead. He forms a distant relationship with a fellow mourner, but she is only a part of his isolated world. Her feelings are never considered. Instead of forming a meaningful relationship, he continues to withdraw from human love. Stransom, like other heroes in James’s later tales, becomes an example of James’s reticent lover, a man who has rejected life and embraced death. The death of Stransom in the woman’s arms unites the love and death theme predominant in the later tales. “The Beast in the Jungle” • “The Beast in the Jungle” is a powerful story about one man’s quest for his illusive identity. John Marcher meets May Bartram when they are both in their thirties. Ten years earlier, Marcher revealed to her that he was singled out for a terrible fate. When Marcher recalls that he told her about his premonition, they form a relationship, and May begins to wait with him. Blindly, he rules out love as the strange fate that awaits him and forms a friendship with May, taking her to operas, giving her gifts, and spending hours talking about his fate. As the years pass, he becomes skeptical that the “beast” will ever come. He feels reluctant to take May along with him on a “tiger hunt.” Finally, May becomes ill. She knows his fate but will not tell him because she wants to make him a man like any other. He realizes that he might save her, but he is too preoccupied with his own destiny to become involved with her. She eventually tells him that his fate has already passed him by and that he never recognized it. When she dies, he contemplates that her death might be the terrible fate, but he rules out this premise. Marcher, an outsider at May’s funeral, eventually goes abroad only to return to the grave of his friend to see another mourner stricken with grief. Suddenly, the beast leaps out at Marcher, as he realizes that he has failed to love and has been unable to feel deeply about anything. He has been an empty man who has watched his life from the outside but has failed to live it. Marcher, like Stransom, is held prisoner to an obsession that removes him from the world of human relationships. He cannot give himself to another, so he must await his fate. James called the story a negative adventure. Indeed, Marcher’s trek into the wilderness is his own confrontation with his unconscious fears. In his monomaniacal obsession, he sacrifices May, who becomes dedicated to waiting for him to discover his fate, while he prides himself on his disinterestedness. In “The Beast in the Jungle,” as in other James stories, the woman becomes useful to the man as a siphon for his own obsessions. Marcher fails to recognize and accept love and wastes his life by projecting all his endeavors onto a nebulous future. He is so wrapped up in his own ego that he fails to believe that the death of a lifelong friend is a terrible fate. In the end, he is brought into the world of the dead. Like Stransom, he has lived outside the present and now has only a lost past on which to look back. Like Winterbourne at the funeral of Daisy Miller, he begins to realize what the woman has meant to him. The cemetery where he stands is compared to a garden, which can be seen as an Eden, where Marcher realizes his own ignorance and comes to a painful awareness of his loss of paradise. The cemetery is also called a wilderness, a wilderness that will take him beyond the settled life and into the terrible recesses of his own heart. Marcher is a version of the American future-oriented pioneer unattached to family and loved ones, an Emersonian hero caught in the void of his own solipsistic world. He also becomes one of the first modern antiheroes, inauthentic men who live outside themselves, men to whom nothing really happens.
540
Short Story Writers
“The Jolly Corner” • Stransom becomes absorbed in the past, in the world of the dead, and he neglects to establish a relationship with the woman who mourns with him. Marcher becomes involved in a vacuous destiny, unable to see the love that surrounds him. In “The Jolly Corner,” Spencer Brydon, another alienated man who rejects the present, pursues his obsession with a past that might have been. Having lived abroad, Brydon returns to New York after a thirty-three-year absence only to find that the world has changed around him. James again explores what happens to an individual who finds himself in an alien culture. When Brydon comes to settle some property that he owns in the United States, he begins to wonder about his talents as a businessman and contemplates the kind of man he might have been had he stayed in the United States. He eventually develops a morbid obsession with his alter ego, the other self that he might have been. One night, Brydon enters the empty house called the Jolly Corner in search of his doppelgänger. When he finally comes face to face with it, he faints at the monstrous sight. Upon recovery, he finds himself in the lap of Alice Staverton, who reassures him that she does not find his shadow self so horrible. In the end, he rejoices that he has gained knowledge about himself. Spencer Brydon’s return to the United States plays an ironic twist on James’s international theme, as a Europeanized American returns to a United States that he feels alienated from and then conjures up an American self that horrifies him. Like Marcher, Brydon finds himself on a hunt stalking his secret self, his fate that might have been. Again, James uses the image of the hunt to symbolize an internal journey into the subconscious mind. As the doors of life’s options open and close around Brydon in the haunted house of his lost youth, the monster leaps out at him as it did at Marcher. Both men, like Stransom, collapse upon the women they have neglected. Alice Staverton is the woman who waited and shared his destiny, the way that May Bartram did Marcher’s. She not only knew his double but also accepted it. The use of the double figure was popular in romantic and gothic literature, but in “The Jolly Corner,” James gave a deeper psychological and philosophical undertone to the motif. In his last group of stories, James used the mystery adventure format to probe the inner psyche of his characters and to examine characters obsessed with living life outside the present. James brought a greater psychological realism to the genre of short fiction, expanded its length in order to encompass an in-depth range of inner experiences, transformed the mystery story into metafictional narratives that have a distinctly postmodern quality, and reshaped the quest motif of American literature into existential probings about authenticating one’s identity. Paul Rosefeldt Other major works plays: Daisy Miller, pb. 1883 (adaptation of his novel); The American, pr. 1891, pb. 1949 (adaptation of his novel); Guy Domville, pb. 1894, privately; pr. 1895, pb. 1949; The Reprobate, pb. 1894, pr. 1919; Theatricals: Tenants and Disengaged, pb. 1894; Theatricals, Second Series: The Album and The Reprobate, pb. 1895; The High Bid, pr. 1908, pb. 1949; The Other House, wr. 1909, pb. 1949; The Outcry, wr. 1909, pr. 1917, pb. 1949; The Saloon, pr. 1911, pb. 1949 (one act); The Complete Plays of Henry James, pb. 1949 (Leon Edel, editor). novels: Roderick Hudson, 1876; The American, 1876-1877; An International Episode, 1878-1879 (novella); Daisy Miller, 1878; The Europeans, 1878; Confidence, 1879-1880;
James, Henry
541
The Portrait of a Lady, 1880-1881; Washington Square, 1880; The Bostonians, 1885-1886; The Princess Casamassima, 1885-1886; The Reverberator, 1888; The Tragic Muse, 18891890; The Awkward Age, 1897-1899; The Spoils of Poynton, 1897; What Maisie Knew, 1897; In the Cage, 1898; The Turn of the Screw, 1898; The Sacred Fount, 1901; The Wings of the Dove, 1902; The Ambassadors, 1903; The Golden Bowl, 1904; The Outcry, 1911; The Ivory Tower, 1917; The Sense of the Past, 1917. nonfiction: Transatlantic Sketches, 1875; French Poets and Novelists, 1878; Hawthorne, 1879; Portraits of Places, 1883; A Little Tour in France, 1884; The Art of Fiction, 1884; Partial Portraits, 1888; Essays in London, 1893; William Wetmore Story and His Friends, 1903; English Hours, 1905; The American Scene, 1907; Views and Reviews, 1908; Italian Hours, 1909; A Small Boy and Others, 1913 (memoirs); Notes of a Son and Brother, 1914 (memoirs); Notes on Novelists, 1914; The Middle Years, 1917; The Art of the Novel: Critical Prefaces, 1934 (R. P. Blackmur, editor); The Notebooks of Henry James, 1947 (F. O. Matthiessen and Kenneth B. Murdock, editors); The Scenic Art, 1948 (Allan Wade, editor); Henry James Letters, 1974-1984 (5 volumes; Leon Edel, editor); Henry James: Literary Criticism, 1984; The Art of Criticism: Henry James on the Theory and Practice of Fiction, 1986; The Complete Notebooks of Henry James, 1987; Dear Munificent Friends: Henry James’s Letters to Four Women, 1999 (Susan E. Gunter, editor); Henry James on Culture: Collected Essays on Politics and the American Social Scene, 1999 (Pierre A. Walker, editor); Dearly Beloved Friends: Henry James’s Letters to Younger Men, 2001 (Susan E. Gunter and Steven H. Jobe, editors). Bibliography Bell, Millicent. “‘The Pupil’ and the Unmentionable Subject.” Raritan 16 (Winter, 1997): 50-63. Claims the story is about that which was once considered almost unmentionable by the genteel: money. James focuses on the extinct code of manners and taste by which refined persons were not supposed to talk much about money. Dewey, Joseph, and Brooke Horvath, eds. “The Finer Thread, the Tighter Weave”: Essays on the Short Fiction of Henry James. West Lafayette, Ind.: Purdue University Press, 2001. Critical study. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Flannery, Denis. Henry James: A Certain Illusion. Burlington, Vt.: Ashgate, 2000. Analysis of illusion in the works of James. Bibliography and index. Gage, Richard P. Order and Design: Henry James Titled Story Sequences. New York: Peter Lang, 1988. Gage examines James’s published short-story collections, such as Terminations, Embarrassments, and The Soft Side, in order to show how James collected his stories around a central theme. Focusing on the interrelatedness of James’s works, Gage shows how James’s stories can be divided into organized units based upon a holistic design. Hocks, Richard A. Henry James: A Study of the Short Fiction. Boston: Twayne, 1990. Hocks’s book is a good introduction to James’s short fiction. The book divides James’s stories into three periods: the early social realism, the middle tales dealing with psychological and moral issues, and the later works of poetic expressionism. Detailed analyses of the major works are provided, along with selections of James’s writings on short fiction and a collection of critical articles on selected works. Horne, Philip. “Henry James and the Economy of the Short Story.” In Modernist Writers and the Marketplace, edited by Ian Willison, Warwick Gould, and Warren Chernaik. London: Macmillan, 1996. Discusses some of the commercial and social constraints and opportunities that affected James’s writing of short fiction in the last half of his career.
542
Short Story Writers
Lustig, T. J. Henry James and the Ghostly. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1994. Discusses James’s ghost stories and the significance of the “ghostly” for James’s work generally. Among the best-known James stories discussed are “The Jolly Corner” and “The Turn of the Screw.” Lustig devotes a third of this study to “The Turn of the Screw,” which he argues is a story about reading. Martin, W. R., and Warren U. Ober. Henry James’s Apprenticeship: The Tales, 1864-1882. Toronto: P. D. Meany Publishers, 1994. Analysis of the stories James wrote in the first fifteen years of his career, suggesting how the vision he was creating in those stories prepared for the writing of his first masterpiece, The Portrait of a Lady. Discusses the sources of his basic theme of the victimized innocent. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of twelve short stories by James: “The Altar of the Dead” and “The Beast in the Jungle” (vol. 1); “Europe,” “The Figure in the Carpet,” and “The Great Good Place” (vol. 3); “In the Cage,” “The Lesson of the Master,” and “The Jolly Corner” (vol. 4); “The Middle Years” (vol. 5); “The Pupil” and “The Real Thing” (vol. 6); and “The Tree of Knowledge” (vol. 7). Rawlings, Peter. “A Kodak Refraction of Henry James’s ‘The Real Thing.’” Journal of American Studies 32 (December, 1998): 447-462. Discusses “The Real Thing” and its treatment of issues of representation and reproduction as an allegory in which the tyrannical forces of the real and the vulgar, unless subjected to the processes of selection and idealization, can be all-vanquishing. Wagenknecht, Edward. The Tales of Henry James. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1984. The book contains brief analyses of fifty-five of James’s major tales as well as thumbnail sketches of other stories. It provides a good reference work for someone looking for short summaries and critical bibliographies (found in the footnotes) but lacks detailed criticism of individual works as well as historical perspective.
543
Sarah Orne Jewett Born: South Berwick, Maine; September 3, 1849 Died: South Berwick, Maine; June 24, 1909 Principal short fiction • Old Friends and New, 1879; Country By-Ways, 1881; The Mate of the Daylight, and Friends Ashore, 1884; A White Heron, and Other Stories, 1886; The King of Folly Island and Other People, 1888; Strangers and Wayfarers, 1890; Tales of New England, 1890; A Native of Wimby, 1893; The Life of Nancy, 1895; The Queen’s Twin, 1899; Stories and Tales, 1910; The Uncollected Short Stories of Sarah Orne Jewett, 1971. Other literary forms • Sarah Orne Jewett wrote four novels, and she published popular books for children, including Play Days (1878) and Betty Leicester (1890). Her main work of nonfiction was a history, The Story of the Normans (1887). Achievements • Sarah Orne Jewett is best known as a local colorist who captured with fidelity the life of coastal Maine in the late nineteenth century in sensitive and moving portraits, mainly of women’s lives. Except for The Country of the Pointed Firs, widely considered her masterpiece, Jewett’s long fiction is thought less successful than her short stories. During her lifetime, she was considered one of the best shortstory writers in America. Most of her stories appeared first in popular magazines such as The Atlantic, under the editorship of William Dean Howells, and Harper’s. American literary historian F. O. Matthiessen said in his 1929 study of Jewett that she and Emily Dickinson were the two best women writers America had produced. Willa Cather offered Jewett similar praise and credited her with positively changing the direction of her literary career in a brief but rich acquaintance near the end of Jewett’s life. Biography • Sarah Orne Jewett spent most of her life in South Berwick on the Maine coast, where she was born on September 3, 1849. Daughter of a country doctor, she aspired to medicine herself, but moved toward writing because of early ill health (which led her father to take her on his calls, for fresh air), the special literary education encouraged by her family, and her discovery as a teenager of her “little postage stamp of soil” in reading Harriet Beecher Stowe’s The Pearl of Orr’s Island (1862). Her father, especially, encouraged her to develop her keen powers of observation, and her grandfathers stimulated her interest in storytelling. After the death of her father in 1878, she began a lifelong friendship with Annie Fields that brought her into contact with leading writers in America and Europe, such as Henry James and George Eliot. Jewett and Fields traveled together in Europe, the Caribbean, and the United States, and after the death of Mr. Fields, they lived together for extended periods. Jewett began writing and publishing at the age of nineteen. During her career she developed and maintained the purpose of helping her readers to understand and love the ordinary people of her native Maine, and later she told stories about other misunderstood people such as the Irish and southern whites. In her career, she produced more than twenty volumes of fiction for children and adults, history, prose sketches, and poetry. Her short stories show rapidly increasing subtlety and power. Her early books were well received, but beginning with The Mate of the Daylight,
544
Short Story Writers
and Friends Ashore, reviewers routinely praised her collections highly. It was not unusual for reviewers to be puzzled by how much they liked Jewett’s stories. A frequent response was that the stories seemed to lack plot and action and yet at the same time they were absorbing and charming. Late TO VIEW IMAGE, twentieth century critics, notably PLEASE SEE feminist critics, have suggested that PRINT EDITION Jewett was developing a kind of storyOF THIS BOOK. telling in opposition to the popular melodramas with their fast-paced romance or adventure plots. Jewett’s stories came more and more to focus on intimate relations of friendship, especially between older women, but eventually in one way or another between all kinds of people. By the time Jewett wrote her masterpiece, the novella The Country of the Pointed Firs, she had fully develJames Notman oped a form of narration that pointed toward the James Joyce of Dubliners (1914). This novella, and a number of her best stories such as “Miss Tempy’s Watchers” and “The Queen’s Twin,” would set up a problem of tact, of how to overcome barriers to communion between two or more people, and then through a subtle process of preparation would make overcoming these barriers possible. The story would end with an epiphany that involved communion between at least two people. Though she wrote a variety of other kinds of stories in her career, this type of development was probably her major accomplishment, and it achieved its fullest realization in The Country of the Pointed Firs. A tragic carriage accident on her birthday in 1902 left her in such pain that she gave up fiction writing and devoted herself to her friends. In the fall of 1908, she met Willa Cather, to whom she wrote several letters that inspired Cather to write about Nebraska. Cather recognized Jewett’s help by dedicating to Jewett her first Nebraska novel, O Pioneers! (1913). Jewett died at her South Berwick home on June 24, 1909. Analysis • When a young reader wrote to Sarah Orne Jewett in 1899 to express admiration of her stories for girls, Jewett encouraged her to continue reading: You will always have the happiness of finding friendships in books, and it grows pleasanter and pleasanter as one grows older. And then the people in books are apt to make us understand ‘real’ people better, and to know why they do things, and so we learn sympathy and patience and enthusiasm for those we live with, and can try to help them in what they are doing, instead of being half suspicious and finding fault. Here Jewett states one of the central aims of her fiction, to help people learn the arts of friendship. Chief among these arts is tact, which Jewett defines in The Country of the
Jewett, Sarah Orne
545
Pointed Firs as a perfect self-forgetfulness that allows one to enter reverently and sympathetically the sacred realms of the inner lives of others. In her stories, learning tact is often a major element, and those who are successful are often rewarded with epiphanies—moments of visionary union with individuals or with nature—or with communion—the feeling of oneness with another person that for Jewett is the ultimate joy of friendship. “A White Heron” • “A White Heron,” which first appeared in A White Heron, is often considered Jewett’s best story, perhaps because it goes so well with such American classics as Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter (1850), Herman Melville’s Moby Dick (1851), and William Faulkner’s “The Bear” (1942). With these works, the story shares a central, complex symbol in the white heron and the major American theme of a character’s complex relationship with the landscape and society. As a story about a young person choosing between society and nature as the proper spiritual guide for a particular time in her life, however, “A White Heron” is atypical for Jewett. One main feature that marks the story as Jewett’s, however, is that the main character, Sylvia, learns a kind of tact during her adventure in the woods, a tact that grows out of an epiphany and that leads to the promise of continuing communion with nature that the story implies will help this somewhat weak and solitary child grow into a strong adult. Sylvia, a young girl rescued by her grandmother, Mrs. Tilley, from the overstimulation and overcrowding of her city family, meets a young ornithologist, who fascinates her and promises her ten dollars if she will tell him where he can find the white heron he has long sought for his collection. Childishly tempted by this magnificent sum and her desire to please the hunter, who knows so much of nature yet kills the birds, she determines to climb at dawn a landmark pine from which she might see the heron leave its nest. She succeeds in this quest, but finds she cannot tell her secret to the hunter. The story ends with the assertion that she could have loved the hunter as “a dog loves” and with a prayer to the woodlands and summer to compensate her loss with “gifts and graces.” Interesting problems in technique and tone occur when Sylvia climbs the pine. The narrative tone shifts in highly noticeable ways. As she begins her walk to the tree before dawn, the narrator expresses personal anxiety that “the great wave of human interest which flooded for the first time this dull little life should sweep away the satisfactions of an existence heart to heart with nature and the dumb life of the forest.” This statement seems to accentuate an intimacy between reader and narrator; it states the position the narrative rhetoric has implied from the beginning and, in effect, asks if the reader shares this anxiety. From this point until Sylvia reaches the top of the tree, the narrator gradually merges with Sylvia’s internal consciousness. During the climb, Jewett builds on this intimacy with Sylvia. Both narrator and reader are aware of sharing in detail Sylvia’s subjective impressions of her climb and of her view, and this merging of the subjectivities of the story (character, narrator, and reader) extends beyond the persons to objects as the narrator unites with the tree and imagines its sympathy for the climber. The merging extends further yet when Sylvia, the reader, and the narrator see with lyric clarity the sea, the sun, and two hawks that, taken together, make all three observers feel as if they could fly out over the world. Being atop the tallest landmark pine, “a great mainmast to the voyaging earth,” one is, in a way, soaring in the cosmos as the hawks soar in the air. At this point of clarity and union, the narrative tone shifts again. The narrator
546
Short Story Writers
speaks directly to Sylvia, commanding her to look at the point where the heron will rise. The vision of the heron rising from a dead hemlock, flying by the pine, and settling on a nearby bough is a kind of colloquy of narrator and character and, if the technique works as it seems to intend, of the reader, too. This shift in “place” involves a shift in time to the present tense that continues through Sylvia’s absorption of the secret and her descent from the tree. It seems clear that the intent of these shifts is to transcend time and space, to unite narrator, reader, character, and the visible scene which is “all the world.” This is virtually the same technical device which is the central organizing device of Walt Whitman’s “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry,” and the intent of that device seems similar as well. The reader is to feel a mystical, “transcendental” union with the cosmos that assures one of its life and one’s participation in that life. A purpose of this union is to make justifiable and understandable Sylvia’s choice not to give the heron’s life away because they have “watched the sea and the morning together.” The narrator’s final prayer makes sense when it is addressed to transcendental nature on behalf of the girl who has rejected superfluous commodity in favor of Spirit, the final gift of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s nature in his essay, “Nature.” Though this story is atypical of Jewett insofar as it offers a fairly clear transcendental view of nature and so presents a moment of communion with the nonhuman, it is characteristic of Jewett in that by subtly drawing reader and narrator into the epiphany, the story creates a moment of human communion. “The Only Rose” • More typical of Jewett’s best work is “The Only Rose,” which was first published in The Atlantic in January, 1894, and was then collected in The Life of Nancy. This story is organized by three related epiphanies, each centering on the rose, and each involving a blooming. In the first “miracle of the rose,” Mrs. Bickford and Miss Pendexter are hypnotized into communion by contemplating the new bloom on Mrs. Bickford’s poor bush. In this epiphany, Miss Pendexter enters into spiritual sympathy with Mrs. Bickford, realizing that her silence this time is unusual, resulting not from having nothing to say, but from “an overburdening sense of the inexpressible.” They go on to share the most intimate conversation of their relationship. The blooming flower leads to a blooming in their friendship. It also leads, however, to Mrs. Bickford’s dilemma: On which of her three dead husbands’ graves should she place this single rose? Her need to answer this question points to a deeper need to escape from her comparatively isolated and ineffectual life by shifting from an ethic of obligation to an ethic of love. Her heart has been frozen since her first husband’s death, and it is long past time now for it to thaw and bloom again. Miss Pendexter understands something of this and tactfully leaves Mrs. Bickford to work it out for herself. The second miracle of the rose occurs almost at the end of the story, when John confesses his love for Lizzie to his Aunt Bickford as he drives her to the graveyard. The symbolic rose of young and passionate love moves him to speak, even though he is unsure of the propriety of speaking up to the wealthy aunt from whom he hopes to receive an inheritance. His story of young love and hope, however, takes Mrs. Bickford out of herself, and she forgets her troubles in sharing his joy. As a result, he blooms, blushing a “fine scarlet.” The final miracle is that while she is taking the flowers to the graves, she realizes which of her husbands should have the rose. At the same time that John is taking the rose for his Lizzie, Mrs. Bickford is giving it in her heart to Albert, the first husband, whom she loved so passionately in her youth. Her realization of this event makes her
Jewett, Sarah Orne
547
blush “like a girl” and laugh in self-forgetfulness before the graveyard as she remembers that the first flower Albert gave her was just such a rose. In the overall movement of the story, Mrs. Bickford is lifted out of herself and prepared for a richer and deeper communion with her friends and relatives. The single rose blossom seems mysteriously to impose an obligation upon her, but probably it really awakens the ancient spring of love within her that was perhaps covered over by grief at losing Albert so young and by the difficult life that followed his loss. When she finally struggles free of the weight of the intervening years, she recovers her hidden capacity for friendship and joy, for forgetting herself and joining in the happiness of others. She has epiphanies, rediscovers tact, and begins again to experience communion. “Martha’s Lady” • “Martha’s Lady” first appeared in The Atlantic in October, 1897, and was then collected in The Queen’s Twin. This story illustrates Jewett’s mature control over her technique and material. She represents a kind of sainthood without falling into the syrupy sentimentality of popular melodrama. Into a community beginning to show the effects of a Puritan formalism comes Helena Vernon, a young city woman who is unselfconsciously affectionate and beautiful and, therefore, a pleasure to please. She delights her maiden cousin, Harriet Pyne, charms the local minister, who gives her a copy of his Sermons on the Seriousness of Life, and transforms Martha, Harriet’s new and awkward servant girl. In fact, Helena transforms to some extent everyone she meets in the village of Ashford, taking some of the starch out of their stiff and narrow way of life. After Helena leaves to marry, prosper, and suffer in Europe, Martha carries her memory constantly in her heart: “To lose out of sight the friend whom one has loved and lived to please is to lose joy out of life. But if love is true, there comes presently a higher joy of pleasing the ideal, that is to say, the perfect friend.” This is the ideal of sainthood that the narrative voice asks the reader to admire. Thanks largely to Martha’s living this ideal of always behaving so as to please Helena, she and Harriet live a happy life together for forty years. Helena returns to visit, worn, but with the same youthful spirit, and to reward with a kiss what she recognizes as Martha’s perfect memory of the services Helena enjoyed as a girl. This recognition acknowledges Martha’s faithfulness to her ideal and creates that moment of communion that is the ultimate reward for such faithfulness. What prevents this story from dissolving into mush? Nearly all the special features of Jewett’s technical facility are necessary. She avoids overelaboration. It is not difficult for an alert reader to notice the parallel to the Christ story type; a liberating figure enters a legalistic society to inspire love in a group of followers, which results in an apotheosis after her departure. The disciple remains true to the ideal until the liberator comes again to claim the disciple. Jewett could have forced this analogy on the reader, but she does not. Only a few details subtly suggest the analogy—character names, calling Martha a saint, and her relics—but these need not compel the reader in this direction, which, in fact, adds only a little to the story’s power. Although avoiding overelaboration, Jewett also avoids internal views. On the whole, the story is made of narrative summary and brief dramatic scenes. Emotion is revealed through action and speech; this technical choice produces less intensity of feeling than, for example, the intimate internal view of Sylvia in “The White Heron.” The result is a matter-of-factness of tone that keeps Martha’s sainthood of a piece with the ordinary world of Ashford. This choice is supported by nearly every other
548
Short Story Writers
technical choice of the story—the attention to detail of setting, the gentle but pointed humor directed against religious formalism, and the emergence of Martha from the background of the story. Jewett’s intention seems to be on the one hand to prevent the reader from emoting in excess of the worth of the object, but on the other to feel strongly and warmly the true goodness of Martha’s faithfulness to love. Another purpose of this narrative approach is to demonstrate tact. In “A White Heron,” both Sylvia and the reader enter the quest for the heron with mixed motives, but the nature of the journey—its difficulties, its joys, the absorption it requires— tends to purify motives and to prepare the spirit for epiphany. Sylvia’s vision from atop the pine culminates in communion with the wild bird, a vision she has earned and that she may repeat if she realizes its value. Jewett’s light touch, her own tact in dealing with such delicate subjects, is one of her leading characteristics, and it flowers magnificently in the fiction of the last ten years of her writing career. Although the stories discussed above illustrate Jewett’s most powerful and moving storytelling, they do not illustrate so fully another of the main characteristics of her stories—humor. Humor is often present in her stories and can be found in more abundance than might be expected in “The Only Rose” and “Martha’s Lady.” She also wrote a number of funny stories that discriminating readers such as Cather would not hesitate to compare with the work of Mark Twain. “The Guests of Mrs. Timms,” though more similar to the stories of Jane Austen than Twain, is a popular story of the humorous ironies that result when a socially ambitious widow calls on another widow of higher status without announcing her visit in advance. Among her best humorous stories are “Law Lane,” “All My Sad Captains,” “A Winter Courtship,” and “The Quest of Mr. Teaby,” but there are many others that are a delight to read. Terry Heller Other major works children’s literature: Play Days: A Book of Stories for Children, 1878; The Story of the Normans, 1887; Betty Leicester: A Story for Girls, 1890. novels: Deephaven, 1877 (linked sketches); A Country Doctor, 1884; A Marsh Island, 1885; The Country of the Pointed Firs, 1896; The Tory Lover, 1901. nonfiction: Letters of Sarah Orne Jewett, 1911 (Annie Fields, editor); Sarah Orne Jewett Letters, 1956 (Richard Cary, editor). poetry: Verses: Printed for Her Friends, 1916. Bibliography Auten, Janet Gebhart. “‘Nothing Much Happens in This Story’: Teaching Sarah Orne Jewett’s ‘A White Heron.’” In Short Stories in the Classroom, edited by Carole L. Hamilton and Peter Kratzke. Urbana, Ill.: National Council of Teachers of English, 1999. Recounts several experiences in teaching the story to high school students, making suggestions about the value of the story to exploring conflicts of interest and expanding the canon. Cary, Richard, ed. Appreciation of Sarah Orne Jewett: Twenty-nine Interpretive Essays. Waterville, Maine: Colby College Press, 1973. This book collects a good cross section of the major writing on Jewett from 1885 until 1972. Contains biographical sketches, extended reviews, examinations of her technique, interpretations of some individual works, and evaluations of her career.
Jewett, Sarah Orne
549
Donovan, Josephine. Sarah Orne Jewett. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1980. This critical study includes a chronology and an examination of Jewett’s literary career, following the development of her major themes through her works. Donovan is especially interested in Jewett’s feminist themes. She provides primary and secondary bibliographies. Graham, Margaret Baker. “Visions of Time in The Country of the Pointed Firs.” Studies in Short Fiction 32 (Winter, 1995): 29-37. Discusses the concept of time in Jewett’s book from Julia Kristeva’s feminist perspective; argues that Jewett presents masculine, linear time and feminine, cyclical time, yet transcends both to achieve monumental time. Contends the narrator of the stories transcends the notion of superficial change and sees that the mythical and the historical are the same. Matthiessen, F. O. Sarah Orne Jewett. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1929. This short biographical study may be the most readily available in libraries. Matthiessen surveys Jewett’s life without going into great detail. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of five short stories by Jewett: “The Courting of Sister Wisby” (vol. 2), “Miss Tempy’s Watchers” and “A Native of Winby” (vol. 5), “The Town Poor” (vol. 7), and “A White Heron” (vol. 8). Mobley, Marilyn Sanders. Folk Roots and Mythic Wings in Sarah Orne Jewett and Toni Morrison. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1991. Critical study that asserts the importance of myth and folklore in the work of two women of different races and generations who draw on the cultural roots of their people. Nagel, Gwen L., ed. Critical Essays on Sarah Orne Jewett. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1984. This collection includes sixteen contemporary reviews of Jewett’s books, reprints of eight critical essays from 1955 to 1983, and eight original essays. These deal with biography as well as interpretation. The introduction surveys the history of critical writing on Jewett. Nagel, Gwen L., and James Nagel. Sarah Orne Jewett: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1978. Introduced with a survey of criticism on Jewett, this reference guide lists and annotates writing about Jewett from 1873 to 1976. It is invaluable as a source for secondary writing and for forming impressions of how Jewett’s reputation has developed. For discussions of criticism since 1976, see American Literary Scholarship: An Annual. Silverthorne, Elizabeth. Sarah Orne Jewett: A Writer’s Life. Woodstock, N.Y.: Overlook Press, 1993. Silverthorne describes the increasing interest in Jewett’s treatment of women, ecology, and regional life. Silverthorne had access to letters and manuscripts unavailable to previous biographers, and she takes full advantage of Jewett scholarship.
550
Ruth Prawer Jhabvala Born: Cologne, Germany; May 7, 1927 Principal short fiction • Like Birds, Like Fishes, and Other Stories, 1963; A Stronger Climate: Nine Stories, 1968; An Experience of India, 1971; How I Became a Holy Mother, and Other Stories, 1976; Out of India: Selected Stories, 1986; East into Upper East: Plain Tales from New York and New Delhi, 1998. Other literary forms • Ruth Prawer Jhabvala is the author of several novels, ranging from To Whom She Will in 1955 (pb. in U.S. as Amrita) to My Nine Lives: Chapters of a Possible Past in 2004. Her 1975 novel Heat and Dust won a Booker McConnell Prize and a National Book League award. In screenplay form, that work won an award from the British Academy of Film and Television Arts. Her screenplay adaptation of E. M. Forster’s A Room with a View (1908) won a Writers Guild of America Award in 1986 and an Academy Award in 1987. Jhabvala’s screenplay Mr. and Mrs. Bridge (1990) received a New York Film Critics Circle Award. In 1993, her screenplay adaptation of Forster’s Howards End (1910) was nominated for an Academy Award. She also adapted Henry James’s novel The Golden Bowl (1904) to the screen in 2000 and Diane Johnson’s novel Le Divorce (1997) in 2003. Achievements • In addition to the many awards she has won for her fiction, Ruth Prawer Jhabvala received a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship in 1976 and a Neil Gunn International Fellowship in 1979. She was a MacArthur Foundation fellow from 1986 to 1989. Biography • Ruth Prawer was born in Cologne, Germany, on May 7, 1927, the second child of Marcus Prawer, a Polish-Jewish lawyer, and Eleanora Cohn. The family left Germany in 1939. Most of their relatives perished in World War II. In England, Prawer was educated at a grammar school and at Queen Mary College, London University. In 1951, she received her master’s degree in English literature; her thesis was on the eighteenth century short story. Soon afterward, she married Cyrus S. H. Jhabvala, an Indian Parsi, who had studied architecture at the university. They settled in New Delhi, India, where, with her husband’s encouragement, she began producing fiction. Shortly after the birth of their first daughter, Jhabvala completed a novel, To Whom She Will (1955). In 1957, her stories began appearing in The New Yorker. In 1961, film producers James Ivory and Ismail Merchant asked Jhabvala to write a screenplay of her novel The Householder (1960). Thus began a collaboration that produced some of the most admired films of the twentieth century. In 1975, Jhabvala moved to New York City but continued to maintain a close relationship with her husband. Analysis • Ruth Prawer Jhabvala’s lack of ties to any one place may account for her objectivity as a writer. However, her detachment does not prevent her from empathizing with her characters, nor does her rootlessness make her less conscious of the im-
Jhabvala, Ruth Prawer
551
portance of place. Jhabvala’s experiences may have made her more capable of understanding how feelings of isolation affect individuals, whether they are Indian women, restricted by too many traditions, or Manhattanites, burdened by too many options. Jhabvala’s early stories reflect the delight that, in her story “Myself in India,” she describes as a Westerner’s initial reaction to India. Like Jane Austen, to whom she has been compared by critics, Jhabvala here emphasizes the comic elements in family life, though she does satirize self-deception, snobbery, or pretentiousness. In these lighthearted stories, Jhabvala’s characters emerge from their adventures relatively unscathed. For example, the narrator of “My First Marriage,” from Like Birds, Like Fishes and Other Stories, regards her seduction and abandonment as incidents that merely make her more interesting. During the 1970’s, Jhabvala’s short fiction became more pessimistic. Some of her characters seek to escape from the world by following spiritual leaders, as does the protagonist in the title story of An Experience of India; others, like the minister in “Rose Petals,” from the same collection, have hopes of improving society; still others, such as the minister’s wife, dedicate their lives to amusing themselves. Whether they reside in New Delhi or New York, the characters in East into Upper East live with the same uncertainties. Although these later stories often end unresolved, one can find satisfaction in their artistic perfection. “The Old Lady” • “The Old Lady,” from Like Birds, Like Fishes, and Other Stories, is typical of Jhabvala’s early works. Its plot is minimal: The author simply records a few hours of ordinary life in a prosperous Indian family. Besides the servants, the household includes the old lady, her daughter Leila, her son Bobo, and Leila’s daughter Munni. Leila’s estranged husband Krishna and her older brother Satish, a lawyer, appear for lunch. The household is filled with tension. Leila finds her husband irritating and is annoyed with her mother, her brother, and her daughter for being so fond of him. During their lunch together, Leila embarrasses the inoffensive Krishna and quarrels with Bobo and Satish. Afterward, she criticizes her mother for being too oldfashioned to understand divorce. However, to Satish’s annoyance, nothing is decided. The protagonist recognizes this atmosphere as the one that prevailed when her husband was still living. Then she, too, was unhappy; now, however, she has learned from a guru how to distance herself from the emotional turmoil around her. There is a wonderful comic irony in the fact that though her offspring think themselves so much cleverer than their mother, she alone has found the secret of happiness. “A Course of English Studies” • One of the recurring subjects of Jhabvala’s short fiction is the conflict between East and West. In the early story “A Course of English Studies” from An Experience of India, an encounter between East and West is shown as essentially comic. Both of the major characters are worthy targets of satire, the silly Indian girl Nalini, who comes to a British university in order to have a literary love affair, and Dr. Norman Greaves, the weak-willed English teacher whom Nalini chooses as her lover. The story is told from Nalini’s perspective, and though it is told in a third-person narrative, the style reflects her breathless enthusiasm. Although Nalini has no common sense, she is a brilliant tactician, and as she is unhampered by principles and incapable of feeling shame or embarrassment, Greaves does not stand a chance against her. Nalini thoroughly enjoys the affair; it is Greaves who lives in ap-
552
Short Story Writers
prehension. After Nalini pays a visit to his wife and begins planning to take him back to India with her, Greaves terminates the relationship. Nalini recovers rapidly. Convinced that the English poets were wrong about their countrymen’s capacity for passion, she decides that she should return to India alone. In other stories, Jhabvala shows cross-cultural adventures as dangerous and potentially tragic, but the lovers in “A Course of English Studies” end up no worse for their affair, though probably no wiser. “How I Became a Holy Mother” • The title story from the collection How I Became a Holy Mother, and Other Stories focuses on a phenomenon which the author finds puzzling, the migrations of Westerners to India in search of spiritual enlightenment. The story is told in the first person by Katie, who at the age of twenty-three tires of her life in London and heads for India. Katie settles down in an ashram, which is relatively clean, has a picturesque setting, and is headed by an energetic but undemanding master. Katie enjoys conversing with the master and with the best looking of his Indian disciples, Vishwa, who eventually becomes her lover. However, she sees right through the master’s chief sponsor, the rich, tyrannical “Countess,” who plans to take Vishwa to the West with her. Determined not to lose him, Katie lets the Countess discover them making love. The master solves the problem by suggesting that they go on tour together, with Vishwa cast as the Guru and Katie as a Holy Mother. The story is particularly interesting because, unlike so many of Jhabvala’s spiritual pilgrims, this protagonist does not allow herself to be overwhelmed by India. Though Jhabvala has said that one can resist India only by escaping from it, here she suggests that common sense may be one’s best defense. “Fidelity” • Although it is set in Manhattan, “Fidelity,” from East into Upper East, is much like such stories of one-sided devotion as “Bombay” and “On Bail,” from Out of India, and the poignant “Expiation,” one of the New Delhi stories in East into Upper East. In “Fidelity,” Sophie loves her self-centered, habitually unfaithful husband, Dave, so much that she will not tell him she has a terminal illness for fear of causing him pain. Sophie knows how easily Dave is driven to tears. She also knows that he is having trouble with the young girl for whom he left her. However, as Dave admits to his sister, he has more than his mistress to worry about. If he does not come up with a significant amount of money, he will be sent to prison for fraud, as happened once before. After his nephew Michael has paved the way for him, Dave appears at Sophie’s bedside. Although he pretends concern about her health, Dave is much too focused on himself to notice that she is dying. However, Sophie has decided that the easiest way to give Dave the money he needs is to die as soon as possible. While he holds her, she prepares to take the pills that will end her life, and though Dave has no idea what is really happening, as usual, he prepares to shed his convenient tears. “Fidelity” demonstrates Jhabvala’s power to reveal the very souls of her characters without intruding into the narrative. Rosemary M. Canfield Reisman Other major works novels: To Whom She Will, 1955 (pb. in U.S. as Amrita, 1956); The Nature of Passion, 1956; Esmond in India, 1958; The Householder, 1960; Get Ready for Battle, 1962; A Backward Place, 1965; A New Dominion, 1972 (pb. in U.S. as Travelers, 1973); Heat and Dust,
Jhabvala, Ruth Prawer
553
1975; In Search of Love and Beauty, 1983; Three Continents, 1987; Poet and Dancer, 1993; Shards of Memory, 1995; My Nine Lives: Chapters of a Possible Past, 2004. screenplays: The Householder, 1963; Shakespeare Wallah, 1965 (with James Ivory); The Guru, 1968; Bombay Talkie, 1970; Autobiography of a Princess, 1975 (with Ivory and John Swope); Roseland, 1977; Hullabaloo over Georgie and Bonnie’s Pictures, 1978; The Europeans, 1979 (with Ivory); Quartet, 1981 (with Ivory); The Courtesans of Bombay, 1982; Heat and Dust, 1983 (based on her novel); The Bostonians, 1984 (with Ivory; based on Henry James’s novel); A Room with a View, 1986 (based on E. M. Forster’s novel); Maurice, 1987 (based on Forster’s novel); Madame Sousatzka, 1988 (with John Schlesinger); Mr. and Mrs. Bridge, 1990 (based on Evan S. Connell, Jr.’s novels); Howards End, 1992 (based on Forster’s novel); The Remains of the Day, 1993 (based on Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel); Jefferson in Paris, 1995; Surviving Picasso, 1996; A Soldier’s Daughter Never Cries, 1998 (based on Kaylie Jones’s novel); The Golden Bowl, 2000 (based on James’s novel); Le Divorce, 2003 (with James Ivory; based on Diane Johnson’s novel). teleplays: The Place of Peace, 1975; Jane Austen in Manhattan, 1980; The Wandering Company, 1985. Bibliography Chakravarti, Aruna. Ruth Prawer Jhabvala: A Study in Empathy and Exile. Delhi, India: B. R. Publishing, 1998. Discusses other European authors who have written about India, and Jhabvala’s role as expatriate. Useful for scholars and students approaching Jhabvala for the first time. Includes bibliographical references and an index. Crane, Ralph J. Ruth Prawer Jhabvala. New York: Twayne, 1992. In a chapter entitled “Sufferers, Seekers, and the Beast That Moves: The Short Stories,” Jhabvala’s first five volumes of short fiction are discussed. Crane maintains that the differences among Jhabvala’s stories reflect her own ambivalence toward India. Includes biographical chapter, chronology, notes, and bibliography. ____________, ed. Passages to Ruth Prawer Jhabvala. New Delhi, India: Sterling, 1991. Only one of the essays in this volume deals specifically with short stories. However, much of what is said about theme in the analyses of the novels is applicable to the short fiction as well. Godden, Rumer. “A Cool Eye in a Parched Landscape.” The New York Times Book Review, May 25, 1986, 1, 20. Points out stories in Out of India that exemplify the internal struggle that Jhabvala discusses in “Myself in India.” Gray, Paul. “Tributes of Empathy and Grace.” Time 127 (May 12, 1986): 90. In Out of India, women repeatedly sacrifice themselves for undeserving men. However, Jhabvala’s Western women choose to immerse themselves in India, while her Indian women have fewer options. Jhabvala, Ruth Prawer. “The Artistry of Ruth Prawer Jhabvala.” Interview by Bernard Weinraub. New York Times Magazine, September 11, 1983, 64. An important interview/profile, in which Jhabvala explains why she left India for New York City. ____________. “Introduction: Myself in India.” In Out of India: Selected Stories. New York: William Morrow, 1986. Jhabvala defines the “cycle” of reactions to India which all Westerners seem to experience. Essential reading. Mason, Deborah. “Passage to America.” The New York Times Book Review, November 29, 1998, 20, 22-23. The stories in East into Upper East prove once again that Jhabvala is
554
Short Story Writers
a “spellbinding urban fabulist,” whose rootless characters escape from reality in various ways. “The Temptress” is the only story of true redemption. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Jhabvala: “The Englishwoman” (vol. 2), “In a Great Man’s House” (vol. 4), and “The Man with the Dog” (vol. 5). Sucher, Laurie. The Fiction of Ruth Prawer Jhabvala: The Politics of Passion. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1989. Utilizes four novels and nine short stories to prove that Jhabvala’s detachment masks her real romanticism, as seen in her interest in feminine sexual politics. Includes bibliography. Urstad, Tone Sundt. “Protecting One’s Inner Self: Ruth Prawer Jhabvala’s ‘Rose Petals.’” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (Winter, 1996): 43-49. “Rose Petals” exemplifies what Jhabvala has stated about how different people react to India’s overwhelming social problems. An excellent starting point for the study of Jhabvala’s short fiction.
555
James Joyce Born: Dublin, Ireland; February 2, 1882 Died: Zurich, Switzerland; January 13, 1941 Principal short fiction • Dubliners, 1914. Other literary forms • James Joyce’s name is synonymous with twentieth century fiction, a revolution to which he devoted himself with remarkable single-mindedness. The results are to be found in three extremely influential works of fiction–A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man (1914-1915, serial; 1916, book), Ulysses (1922), and Finnegans Wake (1939). Though his work in other genres is of much less significance, Joyce also wrote two books of poetry, as well as one play. His youthful critical essays, crucial to an understanding of his artistic origins, were collected posthumously and edited by Richard Ellmann and Ellsworth Mason as The Critical Writings of James Joyce (1959). The raw material for A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, edited by Theodore Spencer, was also published posthumously as Stephen Hero (1944). Achievements • James Joyce is acknowledged by many as the twentieth century’s greatest prose artist and is also, arguably, that century’s most famous author. Despite his small output and the increasing difficulty of his works, Joyce’s name stands as a monument to commitment and artistic integrity. Since the end of World War II, there has hardly been a novelist in the West who has not felt Joyce’s influence. Continuing interest in his complex mind and work is sustained by a vast array of academic commentators. The reasons for Joyce’s eminence are not hard to find. Each of his works, beginning with the short stories of Dubliners, is notable for its startling originality of language and conception. His fiction, moreover, placed his native city, Dublin, indelibly on the map of the world’s culture. His life, a continual struggle against ill health, exile, and the almost total neglect of publishers, has come to be perceived as an eloquent expression of self-determination in an age of totalitarian conformity. Biography • James Augustine Joyce was born on February 2, 1882, the eldest child of John Stanislaus and Mary Jane (May) Murray Joyce. The family was typical of the growing ranks of the Irish Catholic middle class of the day, socially confident, politically optimistic, though less than well established economically. During Joyce’s early years, however, the family remained in comfortable circumstances, and at the age of six, Joyce was enrolled in Clongowes Wood College, an elite Jesuit boarding school outside Dublin. After two years at Clongowes, Joyce’s education was interrupted because of a decline in family fortunes, the result in large part of John Joyce’s improvidence. In 1893, Joyce began to attend Belvedere College, another Jesuit school, in Dublin, where, in addition to undergoing a thorough exposure to the narrow Roman Catholicism of the day, he won a number of academic prizes. In 1898, Joyce entered University College, Dublin, from which he graduated in 1902. Throughout the 1890’s, the Joyce family continued to experience hard times.
556
Short Story Writers
Their setbacks had a parallel in the reversal of Ireland’s political fortunes during the same period. In 1891, Charles Stewart Parnell, the disgraced leader of the Irish cause, died. This event was the occasion of Joyce’s first-known literary work, an accusatory poem directed against the foremost of Parnell’s lieutenants, who had turned against him, entitled “Et tu, Healy.” The 1890’s also saw the rise of a literary and intellectual movement in Ireland. By the time Joyce had begun his undergraduate career, this movement was sufficiently evolved to be criticized, a task that Joyce took upon himself, most notably in a pamphlet entitled “The Day of the Rabblement.” While at college, Joyce also distinguished himself by other literary essays, mostnotably with an article on Henrik Ibsen—an important early influence—which appeared in the prestiLibrary of Congress gious Fortnightly Review. In 1902, Joyce left Ireland for Paris, intending to study medicine in order to secure an income to support his writing. This unsuccessful trip was abruptly curtailed by news of his mother’s terminal illness. After her death in 1903, Joyce spent an unproductive year in Dublin, relieved only by writing poems and the initial versions of some of the Dubliners stories and by meeting Nora Barnacle, his wife-to-be. With her, he left Ireland in 1904, remaining abroad, with a few brief exceptions, for the rest of his life. Joyce and his wife began life in Pula, then a backwater in the Austro-Hungarian Empire, later known as the town of Pulj in Yugoslavia. Most of their lives before World War I, however, were spent in Trieste. There, their two children were born, Giorgio in 1905 and Lucia two years later. Joyce earned an uncertain and reluctant living teaching English as a foreign language and worked on the stories of Dubliners and A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. A number of prospective publishers deemed the stories to be too scandalous to issue, and Dubliners languished in limbo until 1914. That year was to prove decisive to Joyce’s development as a writer. Through the good offices of the Irish poet William Butler Yeats, the American poet Ezra Pound contacted Joyce and arranged for A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man to be serialized. In that year, also, Joyce started his most celebrated work, Ulysses, and moved with his family to Zurich, where they lived for the duration of the war. Briefly returning to Trieste in 1919, the family moved to Paris, where Ulysses was published in 1922. Beset by ill health and by the mental illness of his daughter, though immune from financial difficulties through the generosity of a patron, Harriet Shaw Weaver, Joyce remained in Paris working on his opaque masterpiece, Finnegans Wake, until World
Joyce, James
557
War II obliged him to resettle in Zurich. There, Joyce died of complications arising from perforated ulcers on January 13, 1941. Analysis • In August, 1904, James Joyce wrote to his friend C. P. Curran: “I am writing a series of epicleti. . . . I call the series Dubliners to betray the soul of that hemiplegia or paralysis which many consider a city.” This note announces, in effect, a transformation of the short story as a form. The note’s pretentious jargon reveals the attitude of the young Joyce’s artistic demeanor. In addition, it calls attention to some of the main technical and thematic characteristics of a volume that had to wait a further ten years for a publisher to consider it acceptable. There is still some scholarly debate over the term “epicleti,” whose etymology remains obscure. It is clear, however, that Joyce’s use of the term shows him to be in pursuit of an aesthetic method. This self-conscious search for a method reveals Joyce as a preeminently twentieth century modernist author. As with his eminent contemporaries and advocates T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound, to write was to articulate a theory of writing. Moreover, the search was successfully concluded, as the closing chapter of A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man records. It culminated in the “epiphany,” which means “showing forth” and which describes not only Joyce’s method but also his objectives in using one. Joyce used the term “epiphany” to describe some of his own early artistic efforts in prose. These sketches sometimes resemble prose poems, calibrating moments of intense perception and emotional heightening. At other times, they take the form of life studies of banal moments in everyday life. The overall intention is one of unmasking hidden states, whether of the exalted or humdrum variety. In both instances, the pieces are marked by a fastidious language, which clearly anticipates the “style of scrupulous meanness” in which Joyce said Dubliners is written. Dubliners • Artistic theory is not the only novelty of Dubliners. Joyce’s note to Curran also draws attention to his subject matter. From a strictly historical point of view, Joyce’s characterization of his birthplace is to some extent misleading. The stories of Dubliners tend to overlook those factors that distinguished the city in Joyce’s time. The impact and significance of the establishment in Dublin of Ireland’s national theater, the Abbey, for example, which opened in 1904, may be lost on non-Irish readers of Joyce’s stories. In general, Joyce is at pains to belittle the various attempts at cultural self-renewal, which were a marked feature of Dublin life in the early years of the twentieth century, as the satire of the story “A Mother” shows—although in “The Dead” this satirical attitude is significantly modified. Joyce also fails to provide a cross section of the city’s social composition, there being no stories featuring the upper echelon. The city was not quite the paraplegic of Joyce’s diagnostic imagination. The stories’ emphasis is on what Joyce asserts to be typical of his city. This democratic vision of his brings to the reader’s notice a range of marginalized citizens. These include children, the alienated, the helpless and hopeless, and particularly women—Dubliners has a feminist undercurrent, all the more noteworthy because of its time. These citizens, often known merely by a single name, represent the social, cultural, and moral cost of living in a city that was less a capital than one of the British Empire’s provincial administrative centers. The fact that their humdrum and unpromising lives should be subjected to the artistic and intellectual powers that Joyce possessed is significant on a number of counts. From the standpoint of literary history, Dubliners combines the two prevailing literary modes of Joyce’s day. In a refine-
558
Short Story Writers
ment of an approach pioneered by the great French novelist Gustave Flaubert, Joyce subjects material that had hitherto been the artistic property of the naturalists to the aesthetic commitments of the Symbolists. One way of describing the function of the epiphany is to note its author’s organization of commonplaces in such a manner that they ultimately yield possibilities of meaning greater than their culturally preconditioned, or factual, appearances admit. From the point of view of Irish literary history, the stories of Dubliners eloquently, though untypically, participate in the overall effort of the Irish Literary Revival to address national realities. The careful delineation of lost lives, which characterizes most of Dubliners, is a unique contribution to the spirit of the critique, which informs much of the stories’ Irish cultural context. It is not surprising to learn that they were considered too controversial to publish with impunity, or that, by virtue of being so, they confirmed their author’s belief that they constituted “a chapter in the moral history of my country.” A further notable feature of the book is that, unlike many collections of short stories, particularly those of that period, Dubliners is a collection of stories that, however limited in range, is disparate while at the same time functioning as a coherent whole. Its coherence is not merely a matter of Joycean cunning, whereby the collection’s opening story is entitled “The Sisters” and centers on a death, while the final story is called “The Dead” and takes place at a party hosted by sisters. The history of the book’s composition, to which must be added a recognition of the complications brought about by publishers’ lack of commitment, precludes any such facile observation, since “The Dead” was conceived and written after Joyce’s initial version of Dubliners had been completed and submitted for publication. Two other stories were added to the original dozen, “Two Gallants” and “A Little Cloud.” Rather more subtly, the collection achieves coherence by numerous overlapping means. These include the integrity of its style, its thematic consistency, the largely uniform character of its dramatis personae, and its use of a major device in the overall scheme of Joyce’s aesthetic, repetition and variation. In addition, Joyce himself had an integrated vision of the work’s coherence, one whereby the whole would be seen to be greater than the sum of the parts. This view holds good particularly when applied to the twelve stories of the initial Dubliners, where it describes a mode of symmetrical organization as well as a principle of thematic development, so that a case can readily be made for the work as a whole comprising a “moral history.” According to Joyce, Dubliners may be divided into four consecutive sections. The first of these consists of the three opening stories, “The Sisters,” “An Encounter,” and “Araby.” These are followed by a sequence of stories dealing with adolescence, “The Boarding House,” “After the Race,” and “Eveline.” Three stories of mature life come next, “Clay,” “Counterparts,” and “A Painful Case.” Finally the volume closes with a trio of stories devoted to public life, “Ivy Day in the Committee Room,” “A Mother,” and “Grace.” Although the symmetry of this quartet of trios is disrupted by the introduction of further stories, two of the new additions, both written in 1906, enlarge rather than negate their respective categories. The range of the stories of adolescence is considerably broadened by the addition of “Two Gallants.” Similarly, the motifs of entrapment and disillusion, typical of the stories of mature life, are further adumbrated in the history of Chandler, the protagonist of “A Little Cloud.” In “The Dead,” written in 1907, Joyce’s artistry as a writer of short fiction is seen to best advantage. In addition, this story crystallizes and elevates to a higher plane of intellection and feeling
Joyce, James
559
many of the themes of Dubliners, the result being what is generally acknowledged to be one of the finest short stories in the English language. The titles of the stories of Dubliners offer a clue to the nature of their contents. Such titles as “An Encounter,” “A Painful Case,” “Counterparts,” “A Mother,” and “The Dead”—to take some of the most obvious cases in point—seem deliberately to offer little or nothing to the reader, neither a sense of expectation nor a sense of anything particularly distinctive within the material, even though Joyce insisted to his publishers that presenting his fellow citizens to the world at large had undoubted novelty value. Yet the very anonymity of many of the titles points with precision to both their character and their method. The stories’ protagonists are for the most part colorless, unpromising, defeated, and lacking in interiority. For the most part, they are unaware of these facts about their personalities and conditions, and the stories evolve somewhat remorselessly to a point where these hapless characters are on the threshold of recognizing, or deliberately overlooking, their morally abject lives. The fact, therefore, that the stories’ titles frequently evoke generic types or states is a pointer to one of their prominent attributes. The stories that do not conform to this general rule have titles that are extremely localized and opaque in a different sense. Few readers will know automatically that the ivy day referred to in “Ivy Day in the Committee Room” refers to the custom of commemorating the Irish political leader Charles Stewart Parnell, or that “Araby,” in addition to its generic connotations, refers to an actual bazaar that was held in Dublin in mid-May, 1894. This obscure fact makes the story’s protagonist the same age as Joyce was when the bazaar was held. The sense of comparative anonymity and insignificance suggested by the titles is replicated in the case of the protagonists, a large number of whom are either anonymous or known by a single name, as though they had not yet succeeded in attaining the measure of identity required to merit being fully named. The very title Dubliners is clearly generic, and Joyce, approaching his material from such a standpoint, reveals his interest in the typical, the representative, and the norm. In this sense, Joyce shows his deep sense of the short-story form, with its traditional emphasis on the delineation of representative characters in representative contexts. Such an interest is amplified with great deftness and versatility in the language of the stories, which frequently draws on official, generic codes of utterance. Gabriel’s speech on hospitality in “The Dead” is an important example of one such code, particularly when contrasted with the highly wrought meditation that closes the story. The sermon that concludes “Grace” is another, despite being rendered in the narrative mode known as free indirect style for satirical purposes. A third example is the mimicry of the newspaper report of police evidence in “A Painful Case.” The collection as a whole is saturated by formal and informal exploitation of the characters’ various modes of utterance from which a sense of their cultural orientation and impoverishment may be extrapolated. As with all Joyce’s works, the latently satirical manipulation of cliché is a crucial feature of Dubliners. In addition, by virtue of the author’s uncanny ear not merely for the demotic but for the quality of consciousness that such utterances reveal, the stories possess a convincing patina of objectivity, as though it is the restless but unobtrusive activity of their language that produces their effects, rather than anything as unrefined as the author’s direction and intentions. Thus, the doctrine of the artist’s impersonality, which has numerous important implications for modernist aesthetics and which Joyce, possibly following the example of Gustave Flaubert, invokes in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, is utilized in Dubliners to telling effect.
560
Short Story Writers
It is in the matter of the stories’ presumed objectivity that Dubliners fell afoul of the publishing industry of the day. Joyce freely availed himself of the civic furniture of his native city, including by name actual business premises—pubs and hotels, notably— as well as churches and other well-known amenities and distinctive features of the social life of his birthplace. By so doing, he not only went further in his pursuit of documentary verisimilitude than the vast majority of even naturalistic writers of Joyce’s generation but also revealed a conception of language—or of what happens to language once it is written—which, in its mature development in Ulysses and Finnegans Wake, provided a complex, integrated code of cultural semiotics. Joyce’s use of placenames, the names of businesses, and most notoriously the names of English royalty, shows his understanding that a name is a word, not a supposedly photographic facsimile of the entity it denotes. Dubliners is replete with names chosen with a sensitivity to their artistic and cultural resonance as well as to their geographical precision. For example, the North Wall, Eveline’s terminus in the story that bears her name, is both correct in a documentary sense and thematically appropriate. A subtler instance is Mr. Duffy’s residence at Chapelizod, a short distance outside Dublin. Not only does the choice of residence underline Duffy’s standoffish nature, but also the name of where he lives is a corruption of Chapel Iseult. This name invokes the legend of the lovers Tristan and Iseult, of whose tragic love Duffy’s affair is a banal but nevertheless heartfelt shadow. Use of the legend is an anticipation of the method in Ulysses, where the heroic stuff of epic forms an ironic but by no means belittling counterpoint to the trial of twentieth century human beings. Neither of Joyce’s English and Irish publishers was very interested in the longterm consequences or subtle immediacies of Joyce’s art. Both feared that his use of actual names would lead them into serious legal difficulties, which would be compounded by what was considered a use of blasphemous language and an impersonation of the thoughts of Edward, Prince of Wales, in “Ivy Day in the Committee Room,” Joyce’s favorite story in the collection. Joyce, against his better judgment, toned down the impersonation and made a number of other minor adjustments, while basically upholding his right of documentary representation in the service of artistic integrity and objectivity. The most conclusive evidence for the stories’ objectivity, however, is provided by their use of the epiphany. Much critical ink has been consumed in attempting to explicate this device. Undoubtedly it is a key concept not only in the appreciation of the art of Joyce’s short stories but also in the comprehension of the form’s development under the influence of Dubliners. At the same time, the reader who does not possess a firm grasp of the concept may still read Dubliners with satisfaction, insight, and sympathy. The epiphany makes its presence felt, typically, at the conclusion of a Dubliners story. It is here that the reader is likely to experience a certain amount of distancing from the action, which cannot be accounted for merely by the foreignness of the characters and their locale. These, in themselves, do not inhibit either the forward movement of the narrative or that movement’s potential for significance. At the point when that potential might well be expected to be realized, however, it may strike the reader as being deferred or repressed. This discovery is intended to alert the reader that the narrative technique of a Dubliners story only superficially conforms to the introduction-developmentdenouement model of story organization. Early critics of the work, indeed, complained that for the most part, through their lack of dramatic issue or intriguing theme, the stories were no more than sketches, not seeing that what Joyce was inter-
Joyce, James
561
ested in was as much manner as matter, and that only a minimalist approach of the kind he used would grace with art the marginal conditions of his characters and articulate, in a mode that did not violate the impoverished spirit of his paralyzed raw material, its worthiness and the value of bringing it to the reader’s attention. Concern for the reader’s attention is therefore critical, since so much of what Joyce was writing about had already been effectively written off socially, culturally, politically, and spiritually. The comprehensive nature of this silencing is spelled out in the collection’s opening story, “The Sisters.” The strain placed on the reader’s attention by the typical conclusion of the stories is Joyce’s method of expressing his concern that the material’s impact not be diminished by meeting the preconditioned expectations of how its conflicts might be resolved. Rather than have the story reach a conclusion, with its connotations of finality and mastery, Joyce ends the story, breaks off the action before all its implications and ramifications have been extrapolated. He thereby extends to the reader an invitation, which may also be a duty, to draw out the inferences of this act of narrative termination. The development of inferences is the means whereby the story achieves the statement of itself, an achievement that describes the epiphany in action. In order to participate in the activity of revelation that the term “epiphany” connotes, the reader will note that not only does a Dubliners story conventionally, if loosely, observe the Aristotelian unities of time, place, and action, but also that unity is achieved by the tissue of correspondences, insinuations, nuances, echoes, and general interplay that exists among the various phases of a given story’s action and the language. The introduction of the train at the end of “A Painful Case” is an obvious example of Joyce’s cunning and tacit strategies. One of the outcomes of these effects is to offset any purely deterministic sense of plot. The compulsiveness and irreversibility of action, on a sense of which plot tends to be based, is offset, modified, or at the very least has its crudely dramatic character diminished by Joyce’s effects. As a result, the reader is placed in a position of assembling what the story’s fabric of data signifies. It is the reader, typically, rather than the protagonist, who recognizes the epiphanic moment, the moment at which the tendencies of the action become undeniably clear. At this moment, the reader attains the point of maximum perspective. It is a moment of closure but of reinvestment, of withdrawal and of sympathy, of estrangement and acceptance. Its result is to make the reader morally complicit with the material, since were it not for the epiphany’s appeal to the reader the material’s significance, or rather its ability to signify, would be moot. The empowered reader becomes the type of citizen whom the representative protagonist of a Dubliners story cannot be. The stories represent a mastery over material and circumstances with which the reader is called upon to identify, but which the characters cannot embody. Although it is possible to consider the stories of Dubliners from many different artistic, cultural, and moral perspectives, the theme of independence or the lack of it is the one that seems most central to Joyce’s concerns. His preoccupation with the paralyzed condition of his native city may be described as an awareness of how little the spirit of independence moved there. The numerous implications of this lack are addressed in story after story. The typical trajectory of the story is the optimistic going out, the counterpart of which is the disillusioned return. In even such a simple story as “An Encounter,” the youngster’s naïve dream of adventure and access to the adult world is both realized and made unrecognizable and unacceptable by the form it takes. Encounters with worldly others, such as the flirtatious couples at the bazaar at
562
Short Story Writers
the end of “Araby,” or Frank in “Eveline,” the sophisticated foreigners in “After the Race,” or Ignatius Gallaher in “A Little Cloud,” all leave the protagonists reduced and defeated. The world is a more complex and demanding environment than their dreams of fulfillment might have led them to believe. The self withdraws, pained that the world is not a reflection of its needs. As in “Two Gallants,” when the world can be manipulated to serve the ego, the process is crude, exploitative, and morally despicable. “Ivy Day in the Committee Room” • Some of the most far-reaching implications of the independence theme may be seen in “Ivy Day in the Committee Room.” There, the heirs of a dramatically successful political movement for a constitutional form of Irish independence are depicted as bemused, opportunistic, devoted to rhetoric rather than action, stagnant in thought and deed. Their conspicuous lack of will is matched by their inconsistency of thought. Yet, while satire is a pronounced feature of the story, Joyce also makes clear that the characters cannot be merely scorned. The poem that affects them is certainly not a fine piece of writing, as the story’s closing comment would have readers believe. On the contrary, it is a heartfelt performance, genuine in its feeling and authentic in its response. The negative elements of these characters’ lives and the bleak outlook for the productive commissioning of their human potential become, in Joyce’s view, as compelling a set of realities as the triumph of the will or worldly fulfillment. “The Dead” • This view receives its most comprehensive expression in “The Dead,” making the story, for that reason alone, the crowning achievement of Dubliners. From the playful malapropism of its opening sentence to its resonant closing periods, this story provides, in scale, thematic variety, psychological interest, and narrative tempo, a complete and enriched survey of Joyce’s artistic and moral commitments at the close of the first phase of his writing career. Whereas previously, the collection’s stories were representations of a quality, or poverty, of consciousness to which the characters were unable to relate, in “The Dead” Gabriel achieves an awareness of his particular consciousness. The moment of recognition, the epiphany, in which Gabriel realizes what his wife’s story of lost love says about his own emotional adequacy, is not an experience whose meaning the reader infers. It is a meaning whose articulation by Gabriel the reader overhears. Unlike many of the other stories, however, “The Dead” does not end on this note of recognition. Gabriel, for all that “The Dead” has shown him having difficulty in being self-possessed and autonomous, acknowledges the force and significance of Gretta’s revelation. He relates to those limitations in himself, which the story of Michael Furey underlines. In doing so, he attains a degree of sympathy, honesty, and freely chosen solidarity with the finite, mortal nature of human reality, his mind enlarging as its sense of defeat becomes a central and constraining fact of life. The balance achieved in “The Dead” between subjective need and objective fact, between romance and reality, between self-deception and self-awareness gives the story its poise and potency and makes it a persuasive recapitulation of the other Dubliners stories’ concerns. It is by the conclusive means of “The Dead” that Joyce’s Dubliners identifies itself with the critique of humanism, which was a fundamental component of the revolution in the arts at the beginning of the twentieth century. The invisibility of the author’s personality, the tonal and stylistic restraint with which the stories are told, and the aesthetic subtlety of the epiphany add up to rather more than simply a revolution
Joyce, James
563
in short fiction. They also, by their nature, draw attention to the force of the negative as a reality in the lives of the characters, a reality that Joyce, by refusing to overlook it, helped place on the agenda of twentieth century consciousness. George O’Brien Other major works play: Exiles, pb. 1918. novels: A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, 1914-1915, serial (1916, book); Ulysses, 1922; Finnegans Wake, 1939; Stephen Hero, 1944 (edited by Theodore Spencer). nonfiction: Letters of James Joyce, 1957-1966 (3 volumes); The Critical Writings of James Joyce, 1959; Selected Letters of James Joyce, 1975 (Richard Ellmann, editor); The James Joyce Archives, 1977-1979 (64 volumes); On Ibsen, 1999; Occasional, Critical, and Political Writing, 2000. poetry: Chamber Music, 1907; Pomes Penyeach, 1927; “Ecce Puer,” 1932; Collected Poems, 1936. Bibliography Alter, Robert. Canon and Creativity: Modern Writing and the Authority of Scripture. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 2000. Lucid argument for the complex influence that the Bible has exerted on three important and diverse authors: Franz Kafka, Hayyim Hahman Bialik, and James Joyce. Benstock, Bernard. Narrative Con/Texts in “Dubliners.” Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1994. Includes analyses of narrative principles, symbolic systems, theological contexts, and a variety of themes and techniques in Dubliners. Blades, John. How to Study James Joyce. Houndmills, England: Macmillan, 1996. Excellent study guide for students of Joyce. Includes bibliographical references, outlines, and syllabi. Bosinelli, Rosa M. Bollettieri, and Harold F. Mosher, Jr., eds. ReJoycing: New Readings of “Dubliners.” Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1998. Fourteen new essays on Dubliners that argue Joyce questioned literary, cultural, and political developments of his time. The essays examine themes, style, intertexuality, politics, linguistics, and gender conflicts in Joyce’s stories. Brunsdale, Mitzi M. James Joyce: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1993. General introduction to Joyce’s stories, focusing on the five most familiar stories from Dubliners. Also includes excerpts from Joyce’s own nonfiction criticism and from other critics. Fargnoli, Nicholas, and Michael P. Gillespie. James Joyce A to Z: The Essential Reference to the Life and Work. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995. Dictionary-type reference book with approximately eight hundred entries on characters, concepts, locales, terminology, and critics of Joyce. Jones, Ellen Carol, and Morris Beja, eds. Twenty-first Joyce. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 2004. This useful reference work collects 13 scholarly essays written by Joyce experts. Part of the Florida James Joyce Series. Leonard, Garry M. Reading “Dubliners” Again: A Lacanian Perspective. Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press, 1993. Using Lacan’s Freudian approach to language’s role in creating our experience of reality, Leonard examines the stories in Dubliners, urging readers to explore their kinship with the moral paralysis of the characters.
564
Short Story Writers
May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of twelve short stories by Joyce: “Araby” and “The Boarding House” (vol. 1); “Clay,” “Counterparts,” and “The Dead” (vol. 2); “Eveline” and “Grace” (vol. 3); “Ivy Day in the Committee Room” and “A Little Cloud” (vol. 4); “A Painful Case” (vol. 6); “The Sisters” (vol. 7); and “Two Gallants” (vol. 8). Schwarz, Daniel R., ed. “The Dead” by James Joyce. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Casebook of essays on “The Dead,” from such critical perspectives as readerresponse theory, new historicism, feminism, deconstruction, and psychoanalysis. Studies in Short Fiction 32 (Summer, 1995). A collection of sixteen new essays on Dubliners, along with eleven reviews of new books on Joyce. Includes general essays on techniques and themes of Dubliners as well as analyses of “Araby,” “The Sisters,” “Grace,” “The Dead,” and discussions comparing Joyce’s stories with those of William Trevor and Edna O’Brien. Theall, Donald F. James Joyce’s Techno-Poetics. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997. Representative of a new wing of Joyce studies, Theall’s work examines Joyce as a progenitor of today’s cyberculture. Includes bibliography and index.
565
Franz Kafka Born: Prague, Bohemia, Austro-Hungarian Empire (now in Czech Republic); July 3, 1883 Died: Kierling, Klosterneuburg, near Vienna, Austria; June 3, 1924 Principal short fiction • Betrachtung, 1913 (Meditation, 1948); Das Urteil, 1913, 1916 (The Sentence, 1928; also as The Judgment, 1945); Die Verwandlung, 1915 (novella; The Metamorphosis, 1936); Ein Landarzt: Kleine Erzählungen, 1919 (The Country Doctor: A Collection of Fourteen Short Stories, 1945); “In der Strafkolonie,” 1919 (“In the Penal Colony,” 1941); Ein Hungerkünstler: Vier Geschichten, 1924 (A Hunger Artist, 1948); Beim Bau der Chinesischen Mauer: Ungedruckte Erzählungen und Prosa aus dem Nachlass, 1931 (The Great Wall of China, and Other Pieces, 1933); Erzählungen, 1946 (The Complete Stories, 1971); The Penal Colony: Stories and Short Pieces, 1948; Selected Short Stories, 1952. Other literary forms • Franz Kafka did not attempt to write drama or poetry. His métier was prose. He was a perfectionist who apparently intended only a portion of what he had written for publication. Much of his reputation rests on his three posthumously published novels: Der Prozess (1925; The Trial, 1937), Das Schloss (1926; The Castle, 1930), and Amerika (1927; America, 1938). Those three novels and several volumes of Kafka’s short stories were prepared for publication by the executor of his literary estate, Max Brod, who took great liberties in rearranging Kafka’s often chaotic manuscripts. During the 1990’s, better trained scholars reedited Kafka’s original manuscripts and made new translations that superseded the editions that had been in print for more than sixty years. Kafka also wrote voluminously in other categories of prose that bear the same distinctive style as his creative work. His diaries and letters contain many comments that aid in the understanding of his stories, and his meticulous legal reports are exemplary professional documents. Achievements • Every year, more secondary literature is published about Franz Kafka than about almost any other author except William Shakespeare. This attests the extraordinary power and alluringly enigmatic content of his works. Although his inimitable prose style describes everything as if it were self-evident, he invariably introduces elements of the fantastic and surreal and portrays the demise of his characters as almost inevitable. His works are imbued with a sense of horror as isolated characters struggle futilely against malign forces that they do not understand. Kafka unintentionally became the voice of the age. Coming after the philosophers Martin Heidegger and Edmund Husserl, and being contemporary with the founder of psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud, he captured the existential angst of the generation. As a result of the Industrial Revolution, the father no longer worked from the home but dominated the family from a distance. The figure of authority was a stranger. Biography • Franz Kafka’s literary achievements are all the more remarkable when one considers that he lived to be only forty, was increasingly ill with tuberculosis dur-
566
Short Story Writers
ing the last seven years of his life, and up until two years before his death held a full-time position as a lawyer. Although his lifestyle was in keeping with that of his mother’s bachelor brothers, one of whom was a country doctor, Kafka and his father were very different in TO VIEW IMAGE, personality. The efforts of the robust, self-confident, and sometimes PLEASE SEE abusive businessman to rear a frail, PRINT EDITION insecure, and sensitive son led to OF THIS BOOK. a constant state of friction between the two. Unlike his younger sisters, who married and established families of their own, Kafka lived mainly with his parents, attempting always to relate to the father who could not understand him. Kafka’s parents had a strong marriage but did not have much time for their children, who were cared for by household help. During the day, the parents worked together in their store. In the evening, the two of them played cards. Kafka did well in school, contrary to his fears, and received a good education, especially in Latin, from dedicated teachers. In 1901, Kafka entered the German University in Prague and obtained his doctorate in law in 1906. He resigned from his first position, stating as his reason that he was upset by the cursing and swearing, even though it had not been directed at him. Through the intercession of a friend, he then obtained a position with the Workers’ Accident Insurance Institute and remained with the firm from 1908 to 1922, when his declining health necessitated an early retirement. His work was appreciated, and he received many benefits from the firm. Kafka was never without friends, and he had a good sense of humor—something that could be emphasized more in the interpretation of his works. He liked to read his stories aloud and sometimes broke down in uncontrollable laughter over the plots that he had invented. Marriage was something that Kafka both desired and feared. He was engaged twice to Felice Bauer, a woman who lived in another city. He had met her briefly through a friend and soon afterward initiated an epistolary relationship. This became a pattern that he repeated with two other women, always being reluctant to be with them in person. Only in the last year of his life did he overcome his inhibitions enough to live for a few months with a woman half his age, Dora Dymant. Dymant did not realize the value of Kafka’s literar y works and at his request burned many manuscripts. Kafka also stipulated in his will that his friend and exec-
Kafka, Franz
567
utor, the author Max Brod, was to burn ever ything not published during Kafka’s lifetime. It was an ambivalent request, because Brod had said he would never do so. Although Jewish, Kafka was relatively unaffected by anti-Semitism. The gravestone for him and his parents is in the Strasnice Cemetery in Prague. His three sisters were later killed in concentration camps. Analysis • Franz Kafka’s stories are not about love or success. They do not leave the reader feeling comfortable. Writing was, for him, a necessity. On August 6, 1914, Kafka wrote in his diary: “My talent for portraying my dreamlike inner life has thrust all other matters into the background; my life has dwindled dreadfully, nor will it cease to dwindle. Nothing else will ever satisfy me.” The meaning of the images from his dreamlike inner life was not always clear to him at the time of writing. Sometimes he realized only several years later what he may have subconsciously meant. Toward the end of his life, he decided that psychoanalysis was a waste of time and abandoned that approach in retrospective reading. Critics may not be of the same opinion. “The Metamorphosis” • The opening sentence of “The Metamorphosis” is one of the most famous in modern fiction: “As Gregor Samsa awoke one morning from uneasy dreams he found himself transformed in his bed into a gigantic insect.” In the story’s first section, Gregor accepts his fantastic transformation matter-of-factly, perhaps wishing to bury its causes in his subconscious mind. Instead of worrying about the mystery of his metamorphosis, he worries about the nature and security of his position as traveling salesperson for a firm whose severity he detests. In the second section, Gregor’s isolation and alienation intensify. Readers learn about his relations, past and present, with his family; they have been characterized by concealment, mistrust, and exploitation on the father’s part. Gregor’s mother is gentle, selfless, weak, and shallow; in the story’s development she becomes increasingly her husband’s appendage. His sister Grete is his favorite; however, although she ministers to his new animal needs, she fails him emotionally. In the third section, Gregor, defeated, yields up all hope of returning to the human community. His parents and sister shut him out, as his miserable existence slopes resignedly toward death. Gregor’s metamorphosis accomplishes several of his aims: First, it frees him from his hated job with an odious employer by disabling him from working; second, it relieves him of the requirement to make an agonizing choice between his filial duty to his parents—particularly his father—and his desperate yearning to emancipate himself from such obligations and dependence. It thus enables him to “bug out” of his loathsome constraints yet do so on a level of conscious innocence, with Gregor merely a victim of an uncontrollable calamity. Moreover, Gregor’s fantasies include aggressive and retaliatory action against the oppressive firm. He accomplishes this by terrorizing the pitiless, arrogant office manager, who tells him, “I am speaking here in the name of your parents and of your chief.” On the conscious level, Gregor pursues the clerk to appease him and secure his advocacy for Gregor’s cause at the office; subconsciously, his threatening appearance and apparently hostile gestures humiliate his hated superiors. Gregor’s change also expresses his sense of guilt at having betrayed his work and his parents, at having broken the familial circle. It is a treacherous appeasement of this guilt complex, inviting his isolation, punishment, and death. His loss of human
568
Short Story Writers
speech prevents him from communicating his humanity. His enormous size, though an insect (he is at least two feet wide), his ugly features, and his malodorous stench invite fear and revulsion. Yet his pacific temperament and lack of claws, teeth, or wings make him far more vulnerable than when his body was human. His metamorphosis therefore gives him the worst of both worlds: He is offensive in appearance but defenseless in fact, exposed to the merciless attack of anyone—such as his furious father—ready to exploit his vulnerability. “The Metamorphosis,” then, can be seen as a punishment fantasy with Gregor Samsa feeling triply guilty of having displaced his father as leading breadwinner for the family, for his hatred of his job, and resentment of his family’s expectations of him. He turns himself into a detestable insect, thereby both rebelling against the authority of his firm and father and punishing himself for this rebellion by seeking estrangement, rejection, and death. Insofar as Gregor’s physical manifestation constitutes a translation of the interior self to the external world, “The Metamorphosis” is a stellar achievement of expressionism. “The Judgment” • Kafka wrote “Das Urteil” (“The Judgment”) in one sitting through the night of September 22-23, 1912. It was an eminently satisfying experience, the only one of his works that he said came out of him like a birth. When he sat down to write, he had intended to depict a war scene. Then, the story took its own direction, and when he finished, early in the morning, he was not sure what it meant. He knew only that it was good. In the course of “The Judgment,” the main character, Georg Bendemann, experiences a complete reversal in his plans. At the outset, he announces his engagement to Frieda Brandenfeld. At the end, he commits suicide. The transition from good news to bad and the descent from normalcy into apparent madness are subtly accomplished. With hindsight, one can see that warning signs are held up all the way. Yet none of these signs is in itself shocking enough to alienate the reader. Only their cumulative effect is overwhelming. Kafka’s stories wield their powerful influence over the reader’s mood by always remaining plausible. While never losing the semblance of logical reportage, Kafka creates scenes of horror, which both spring from and give rise to psychological suffering. Anything resembling such scenes has come to be called “Kafkaesque.” Kafka writes metaphorically, letting characters, actions, and objects represent emotional and psychological states. Thus, the works are understood best not as narrative advancing a plot but in terms of the protagonist’s attempts to transcend absurdity, depersonalization, and alienation. There is a strong autobiographical element in all the stories. Most critics equate Georg Bendemann with Kafka, and Georg’s father with Kafka’s father. The issue to be dealt with, then, is why the father would violently oppose the son’s engagement to a woman from a well-to-do family. To accept that, one has to subscribe to an inverse standard. Kate Flores interprets this aspect of “The Judgment” in an anthropological way, explaining that for precivilized man it was an act of insubordination to supplant the dominant male. Certainly, “The Judgment” does contain elements of a primal struggle. Also consistent with this reading is the father’s tenacious hold on Georg’s watch chain, as if to halt the inexorable advance of time and the aging process. There is also the fact that Kafka’s father did indeed deride one of his engagements, although at a much later date than when “The Judgment” was written. Kafka’s stories support many interpretations. It is important, when reading “The
Kafka, Franz
569
Judgment,” that one not concentrate on the apparent polarity of father and son to the exclusion of the curious figure of the friend in Russia, to whom the first third of the story is devoted. In fact, preposterous though it may seem, the most comprehensive reading results from considering all three male figures—the friend in Russia, Georg Bendemann, and his father—to be different aspects of the same person, namely Kafka. It is significant that only one name is provided. The friend in Russia immediately becomes associated with writing, because Georg has been writing to him for years. This association is reinforced when the father, surprisingly, also claims to have been writing to the friend. After Georg has brought up the matter of an engagement on three separate occasions, the friend in Russia responds by showing some interest, but as with his emotionless reaction to the death of Georg’s mother, the friend’s interest in human affairs seems perfunctory. He has few social contacts, has let his business slide, and seems to be in a general state of ill health and decline. His life has dwindled dreadfully. This identifies him with Kafka the writer. Georg Bendemann’s business seems to have been operating in inverse proportion to that of his friend in Russia. It is thriving, and he has recently become engaged. The thriving business and the engagement go hand in hand in “The Judgment.” Both are traditionally recognized outward signs of success. Kafka, at the time of writing “The Judgment,” was already a successful lawyer, well established in his firm and becoming interested in Felice Bauer, who seems to be represented in the story by her close namesake, Frieda Brandenfeld. Frieda makes a remark to Georg that, on the surface, is very puzzling. She tells him that since he has friends such as the one in Russia, he should never have gotten engaged. This is the warning sign that either Frieda or the friend in Russia will have to go. The application to Kafka’s life seems clear: Either Felice or the writing will have to go. The most interesting and complex of the three male figures is the father. While appearing to oppose Georg, the older man can, in this case, actually be relied on to say what Georg wants to hear. Faced with the irreconcilable conflict between loyalty to his longtime friend in Russia and loyalty to his new fiancé, Georg finds himself inexplicably going to his father’s room, where he has not been for some time. The sunlight is blocked by a wall, the father is surrounded by ancient newspapers, and the window is shut. It is a trip into the dark and the past, which is sealed off from the outside world. The father represents the subconscious. He is also the progenitor, and he is still, despite some deceptive signs of senility, the figure of authority. The father’s first remark, which points beyond the frame of the surface story, is his question of whether Georg really has a friend in St. Petersburg. What the father really seems to be asking is whether the friend can continue to be called a friend when he has been so neglected. Georg at this point is still inclined to decide in favor of Frieda and an outwardly successful life, so he endeavors to quell the troubling reference to his friend by carrying his father from the dark out into the light and then covering him up, thereby forcibly suppressing the question of the friend. Contrary to Georg’s intent, this results in the father’s exploding into action. In an extraordinarily dramatic scene, he hurls off the blankets, leaps to his feet, and, standing upright on the bed and kicking, denounces Georg’s plans for marriage and accuses him of playing the false friend all these years. Georg realizes that he should be on his guard against attack but then forgets again and stands defenseless before his father.
570
Short Story Writers
The father’s second remark that seems rather incredible in terms of the surface story is that the friend in Russia has not been betrayed after all, because he, the father, has also been writing to him all along and representing him. Suppressed talents are only strengthened in the subconscious. The father now unquestionably has the upper hand and pronounces his judgment over Georg: He was an innocent child, but he has been a devilish human being. Presumably, it was during childhood that Georg cultivated the friend now in Russia. As an adult, getting ever more into business and thoughts of marriage, Georg has been devilish by denying his true self, the writer. The father finishes by sentencing Georg to death by drowning. To drown is to be plunged into the creative element. Georg confirms the validity of his father’s verdict by carrying out the sentence. It is important for the reader to remember that as the father crashes on the bed exhausted, the subconscious having asserted itself, and as Georg lets himself fall from the bridge, effectively ending the business career and the engagement, it is the formerly faded and foreign true self, the writer, who remains. Thus, what seems on first reading to be a horror story of insanity and suicide is actually not a disaster at all but an exercise in self-preservation. No sooner had Kafka become romantically involved with Felice than he had worked out subconsciously how detrimental such a relationship would be to his career as a writer. With such personal material, it is no wonder the writer in Kafka felt inspired to finish “The Judgment” in one sitting. Ironically, his conscious mind was at that point still so far behind the insights of the subconscious that he dedicated the story to none other than Felice Bauer. The subtitle of Heinz Politzer’s book on Kafka, Parable and Paradox, evokes the elusive nature of Kafka’s story lines, which are charged with opposing forces seeking synthesis. Although most of the stories are grim, the reader cannot help but be amused at the outrageous, at times burlesque turns of events. Only the bleak and disquieting desperation of the characters contradicts the humor inherent in their situations. Also, many of the stories end with the main character dead or reduced to a state of utter hopelessness. Many of the longer stories, such as “The Judgment,” are so complex that they can be confusing. Kafka’s shorter stories, consisting of only a paragraph or a page or two, sometimes leave a more lasting impression, because they each center on one main event. “Give It Up!” • Politzer begins his study with a lengthy discussion of a 124-word commentary that Kafka wrote late in 1922. In the commentary, which has become known as “Give It Up!,” a traveler heading for the train station early one morning becomes disconcerted when he checks his watch against a clock tower and thinks that he must be late. In his haste, he becomes uncertain of the way and has to ask a police officer. The officer repeats the question, then tells the man to give up and turns away from him. The police officer’s reply is both hilarious and profoundly unsettling. It is hilarious because it is completely out of line with what a police officer would say. It is unsettling because it lifts the story out of the mundane into a world where not only time but also, apparently, place have lost their relevance and it is impossible to determine one’s way. The issue has become existential. “Before the Law” • Kafka innately distrusted figures of authority and frequently portrayed them maliciously misleading and abusing those who came under their power. The 1922 commentary is simply a lighter variation on the theme that Kafka stated unforgettably in 1914 in his parable “Vor dem Gesetz” (“Before the Law”).
Kafka, Franz
571
This moving and perfect piece of writing was later incorporated into chapter 19 of Kafka’s novel Der Prozess (1925; The Trial, 1937). In the two-page parable, a man from the countr y seeks access to the law. He is told by the doorkeeper that he may not enter at the moment but possibly later. The man is deterred from entering without permission by the doorkeeper’s telling him that this is only the first of many doors that are guarded by increasingly powerful doorkeepers. The man spends the rest of his life there waiting for admittance and gives away everything he owns in unsuccessful attempts to bribe the doorkeeper. Finally, in his dying hour, he asks why no one else has come to that door, only to hear the doorkeeper say: “This door was intended only for you. I am now going to shut it.” The parable is not enlightening. By the time the man finds out that he should go through the door after all, it is shut in his face. The story seems, rather, to be a comment on the human condition as Kafka experienced it in early twentieth century Europe. The rise of science and industry had displaced but could not replace religion, with the result that human beings could no longer find their way. The human institutions, the apparent absolutes represented by the law, prove to be fallible, imperfect, and unreliable. Nothing now can fill the human need for direction in life. Reality has become fragmented and disjunctive. “Before the Law” is particularly poignant because the reader cannot help but believe that, before the law, human beings are all people from the country, simple, helpless creatures who have lost their way. “The Bucket Rider” • The way out of this impossible situation is brilliantly described with humor and sadness in Kafka’s three-page story “Der Kübelreiter” (“The Bucket Rider”), written during a coal shortage in the winter of 1916. The main character has no coal, and it is bitterly cold. He also has no money but goes to the coal dealer anyway, to ask for only a shovelful. To show how desperate he is, he rides there on his empty coal bucket, sailing through the air and calling down from high above the dealer’s house. The dealer is deeply moved by the voice of an old customer, but it is his wife who goes to the street to investigate. Once she finds that the bucket rider cannot pay immediately, she claims to see no one and waves him away with her apron. The bucket is too light to offer any resistance. The rider ascends “into the regions of the ice mountains” and is “lost for ever.” This story contains the delightful, dreamlike element of the fantastic that is a source of great beauty in Kafka’s works. The moment the main character decides to ride on his bucket, which occurs at the beginning of the second paragraph, he is lifted out of everyday reality, in which he would surely have frozen to death. Kafka shows, once again, that it is useless to plead with others, especially those who have some authority. Rather than send his main character on an empty bucket back to his freezing room, Kafka has the bucket whisk him away into the ice mountains, never to return. Coal and indeed all mundane concerns cease to be a problem as the bucket rider leaves behind the human habitat. Thwarted by everyday pettiness, he has moved instead into a timeless mental space that seems infinitely more interesting. In “The Bucket Rider,” Kafka represents that space with the image of distant ice mountains. In his fifty-second aphorism, he writes a literal description of that saving space: “There is only a spiritual world; what we call the physical world is the evil in the spiritual one, and what we call evil is only a necessary moment in our endless development.” The bucket rider has transcended the evil phase.
572
Short Story Writers
“A Country Doctor” • The winter of 1916 was one of Kafka’s most prolific periods and one in which he seemed especially visually oriented and inclined toward the fantastic. His seven-page masterpiece “Ein Landarzt” (“A Country Doctor”) is one of his most involved works. It contains all Kafka’s main themes and the salient features of his style. As in “The Bucket Rider,” the setting of “A Country Doctor” is an icy winter, and the mood is one of confused, melancholy desperation. The situation is hopeless, and the doctor sees no way out of it. Unlike “The Bucket Rider,” which has only one main event, “A Country Doctor” is a richly textured work. The most rewarding interpretive approach is that employed here in examining “The Judgment.” There are three main male characters: the country doctor, the groom, and the sick boy. They seem to represent different aspects of the same person, and the story, once again, seems to be autobiographical. The country doctor is an older man who has been working for a long time in his profession, and he is disillusioned. The local people, while placing many demands on him, do nothing to help him. Not one of the neighbors would lend him a horse in an emergency. In keeping with the spirit of the age, the people have lost their faith in religion and look instead to science and medicine to perform the miracles, backing up the doctor’s efforts with choral chanting as if he were a medicine man. He is the only one sadly aware of the limitations of his profession but plays out the charade in a resigned fashion, eventually lying outright to the boy by minimizing the severity of his fatal wound. Kafka was a professional as well, a lawyer who in 1916 had already worked nine years after articling. Although he was a dedicated and valued member of his firm, he regarded his work as a necessary evil, as his means of earning a living so that he could write in his spare time. He was not disillusioned with law, but neither did he harbor any cherished illusions about his distinguished profession. He believed that, as it did to the man from the country in “Before the Law,” law was wearing him out. Readers will equate the country doctor with Kafka the lawyer. In order of appearance, the second male character in “A Country Doctor” is the groom. That he belongs to the country doctor or is part of him is evidenced by the servant girl’s remark, “You never know what you’re going to find in your own house.” Certainly, the groom represents a source not tapped in a long time—so long, in fact, that the country doctor is surprised when the man emerges from the abandoned pigsty. By association with the steaming horses, by the birthlike nature of their emergence, and by his rape of Rose, the groom stands for vitality, sensuality, and sex. He is also associated with savagery and filth. At the time of writing “A Country Doctor,” Kafka had broken off his first engagement to Felice Bauer and had had several short-lived affairs. He was attracted to women but still believed that marriage and his work as a writer were mutually exclusive. His belief that marriage was not for him was based also on his perception of the sexual act as something terrible. Just as the groom represents a repressed aspect of the country doctor, who had all but ignored Rose, so, too, he represents the sexual fulfillment that Kafka decided again and again to sacrifice in order to continue his writing. Readers will equate the groom with Kafka the lover. The groom and the two horses emerge from the pigsty together, then go off in different directions. While the groom was pursuing Rose, the unearthly horses transported the country doctor to the sick boy. Perhaps the boy was only to be reached by supernatural means. There is a fairy-tale quality to the ten-mile journey. It took only
Kafka, Franz
573
a moment, and the blinding snow was gone, replaced by clear moonlight. The nature of the journey is significant for the reader’s interpretation of the boy. Kafka has placed him in the spiritual world. Whereas the country doctor is only one of many, as stressed by the indefinite article in the title, the boy is unique. His father, family, and the villagers have no understanding of the boy’s condition. Clearly, the boy is having a hard time of it in these surroundings. Even the doctor feels ill “in the narrow confines of the old man’s thoughts.” Disheartened, the boy at first wants to die. So does the doctor. Once the doctor becomes aware of the unique nature of the boy’s great wound, however, which is both attractive and repulsive, rose-colored and worm-eaten, the boy decides that he wants to live. By then, though, it is too late. The blossom in his side is destroying him. Like the friend in Russia in “The Judgment,” the boy in “A Country Doctor” appears sickly but turns out to be of supreme importance. Kafka was not physically strong. In 1916, his tuberculosis had not yet been diagnosed, but he suffered from stomach problems. He lived with his parents, who were concerned that the long hours he spent writing were ruining his health. It is therefore fitting that those characters in his stories who represent Kafka the writer appear to be sickly. Readers will equate the boy with Kafka the writer. Like the surface level of “The Judgment,” the surface level of “A Country Doctor” reads like a tragedy of unequaled proportions. Unable to help the boy, the country doctor finds himself also unable to get home, for the trip away from the boy is as slow as the trip to him was fast. “Exposed to the frost of this most unhappy of ages,” the doctor realizes that, as a result of this trip, he has not only sacrificed his servant girl but also lost his flourishing practice to his successor. What this translates into, though, is a triumph. Kafka the writer has subjugated Kafka the lawyer and Kafka the lover. The famous, peremptorily fatalistic last line of the story reveals its double meaning. “A false alarm on the night bell once answered—it cannot be made good, not ever.” Once Kafka accepted his gift as a writer, he could never abandon that link with the spiritual world. Kafka’s works show, simultaneously and paradoxically, not only the existential angst inherent in the human condition but also a way out of that hopeless state. If the various characters are considered as elements of a personality seeking integration, the stories end not bleakly but on a transcendent note. Kafka’s refuge was in his writing, in the spiritual world, and in laughter. Jean M. Snook With updates by Gerhard Brand and the Editors Other major works novels: Der Prozess, 1925 (The Trial, 1937); Das Schloss, 1926 (The Castle, 1930); Amerika, 1927 (America, 1938; better known as Amerika, 1946). miscellaneous: Hochzeitsvorbereitungen auf dem Lande und andere Prosa aus dem Nachlass, 1953 (Dearest Father: Stories and Other Writings, 1954; also known as Wedding Preparations in the Country, and Other Posthumous Prose Writings, 1954). nonfiction: Brief an den Vater, wr. 1919, pb. 1952 (Letter to His Father, 1954); The Diaries of Franz Kafka, 1948-1949; Tagebücher, 1910-1923, 1951; Briefe an Milena, 1952 (Letters to Milena, 1953); Briefe, 1902-1924, 1958; Briefe an Felice, 1967 (Letters to Felice, 1974); Briefe an Ottla und die Familie, 1974 (Letters to Ottla and the Family, 1982).
574
Short Story Writers
Bibliography Ben-Ephraim, Gavriel. “Making and Breaking Meaning: Deconstruction, Four-Level Allegory, and The Metamorphosis.” The Midwest Quarterly 35 (Summer, 1994): 450467. Argues that Kafka’s ability to combine oppositions without resolving them enables him to simultaneously build and dismantle an allegorical ladder ascending the four levels of traditional interpretation. Bloom, Harold, ed. Franz Kafka. New York: Chelsea House, 1986. Collection of essays, on Kafka himself and on themes that pervade his works, by distinguished scholars. Includes essays on the short stories “Up in the Gallery,” “A Country Doctor,” “Der Bau” (“The Burrow”), and “Die Verwandlung” (“The Metamorphosis”). Contains an excellent index that itemizes specific aspects of the works. Corngold, Stanley. Franz Kafka: The Necessity of Form. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1988. Chapter 3 (43 pages) contains what is very likely the definitive analysis of “The Metamorphosis.” Also includes excellent analysis of “The Judgment,” in chapters 2 and 7, discussions of form and critical method, and comparisons with other authors. Corngold also wrote a critical bibliography of “The Metamorphosis” in The Commentator’s Despair (1973). Flores, Angel, ed. The Problem of “The Judgement”: Eleven Approaches to Kafka’s Story. New York: Gordian Press, 1976. English translation, followed by a valuable collection of essays on the short story that Kafka considered his best. Harmut Binder reveals a surprising number of background sources in literature and legend. Kate Flores writes a convincing analysis based on the nature of human fatherhood. Walter Sokel provides an extensive interpretation. Very worthwhile. Hayman, Ronald. K: A Biography of Kafka. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1981. More than a biography, this study contains many helpful discussions of the literary works, showing how they arose in response to specific situations and linking them with contemporary passages from Kafka’s diary and letters. A moving portrayal particularly of Kafka’s last days, when his steps toward liberation coincided tragically with the final stages of tuberculosis. Heinemann, Richard. “Kafka’s Oath of Service: ‘Der Bau’ and the Dialectic of Bureaucratic Mind.” PMLA 111 (March, 1996): 256-270. Analyzes “Der Bau,” as a literary representation of what Kafka called the bureaucratic mind, which reflects both the acceptance of authority as a foundation for attachment to a community and the paralysis of a restlessly critical consciousness that makes impossible any reconciliation between self and other. Jofen, Jean. The Jewish Mysticism of Kafka. New York: Peter Lang, 1987. Detailed, learned examination of Kafka’s connections to Jewish writers, including Y. L. Peretz, Martin Buber, Morris Rosenfeld, and other Yiddish authors. Contains notes but no bibliography. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of ten short stories by Kafka: “The Burrow” (vol. 1); “A Country Doctor” (vol. 2); “The Great Wall of China” (vol. 3); “A Hunger Artist,” “The Hunter Gracchus,” “In the Penal Colony,” “Jackals and Arabs,” and “Josephine the Singer; Or, The Mouse Folk” (vol. 4); “The Metamorphosis” (vol. 5); and “A Report to an Academy” (vol. 6). Oz, Amos. “A Log in a Freshet: On the Beginning of Kafka’s ‘A Country Doctor.’” Partisan Review 66 (Spring, 1999): 211-217. Argues that the story is not a story of crime and punishment, nor is it a fable about making the wrong decision. The feelings of
Kafka, Franz
575
guilt the doctor experiences are not the result of any action. Under the terms of Kafka’s contract, the doctor is guilty a priori, convicted from the start, despite his innocence. Reiner, Stach. Kafka: The Decisive Years. Orlando, Fla.: Harcourt, 2005. First published in Germany in 2002, this stellar work serves as the first of a projected three-volume Kafka biography. Inclues photos, thorough notes, bibliography, and several indexes. Speirs, Ronald, and Beatrice Sandberg. Franz Kafka. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1997. Chapters on “a writer’s life” and on the novels and short stories. Provides detailed notes and extensive bibliography.
576
Jamaica Kincaid Born: Saint Johns, Antigua; May 25, 1949 Principal short fiction • At the Bottom of the River, 1983. Other literary forms • In addition to her short stories, Jamaica Kincaid has written the novels Annie John (1985), Lucy (1990), The Autobiography of My Mother (1996), and Mr. Potter (2002). Her nonfiction writings include a book-length essay concerning her native island Antigua, A Small Place (1988) and Among Flowers: A Walk in the Himalaya (2005). She has also written a children’s book, Annie, Gwen, Lilly, Pam, and Tulip (1986) and has edited several anthologies, including The Best American Essays 1995 (1995), My Favorite Plant: Writers and Gardeners on the Plants They Love (1998), and The Best American Travel Writing 2005 (2005). Achievements • Jamaica Kincaid’s short-story collection At the Bottom of the River received the Morton Dauwen Zabel Award from the American Academy of Arts and Letters in 1983. Her novel Annie John was one of three finalists for the international Ritz Paris Hemingway Award in 1985. Her short story “Xuela” was included in The Best American Short Stories 1995; “In Roseau” was included in The Best American Short Stories 1996. Biography • Born in 1949, Jamaica Kincaid, then Elaine Potter Richardson, lived with her homemaker mother and carpenter father on Antigua, a small West Indian island measuring nine by twelve miles. The family was impoverished: Their house had no running water or electricity. The young girl’s chores included drawing water from a community faucet and registering with the public works so that the “night soil men” would dispose of the family’s waste. Even so, her childhood was idyllic. She was surrounded by the extraordinary beauty of the island, was accepted by her community, and was loved and protected by her mother. When Kincaid was nine, however, her mother gave birth to the first of three more children—all boys. At that point, the closeness that Kincaid had enjoyed was at first disturbed and then destroyed. She credits the lies that she began to tell her mother as the catalyst for her fiction writing: “I wasn’t really lying. I was protecting my privacy or protecting a feeling I had about something. But lying is the beginning of fiction. It was the beginning of my writing life.” Also at this time, she began to comprehend the insidious impact of colonialism. (Antigua was a British colony until 1967, and only in 1981 did it receive full independence.) The Antiguans’ docile acceptance of their inferior status enraged her. Thus the serenity she had known as a child was displaced by loneliness and anger. In 1966, Kincaid, seeking to disassociate herself from her mother, left Antigua not to return for nineteen years and then only after she was a naturalized citizen of the United States and an established writer. Arriving in Scarsdale, New York, the seventeen-year-old Kincaid worked as a live-in baby-sitter. She did not open her mother’s letters, and when, after a few months, she took an au pair position in New York City, she did not send her mother her new address. For the next three years, she cared for the four young girls of Michael Arlen, a writer for The New Yorker and a future col-
Kincaid, Jamaica
577
league when she herself would become a staff writer for the magazine. Her childhood and early New York experiences are fictionalized in At the Bottom of the River, Annie John, and Lucy. During her first few years in New York, she wanted to continue TO VIEW IMAGE, her education at a university but PLEASE SEE found her Antiguan schooling to PRINT EDITION be inferior; instead, she first studied for a high school diploma, OF THIS BOOK. took a few photography courses at a community college, and then attended Franconia College in New Hampshire on scholarship, leaving after a year because, although only in her twenties, she felt too old. After jobs as a secretary and receptionist, she wrote for a teen magazine. In 1973, she changed Sigrid Estrada her name to Jamaica Kincaid, perhaps suggesting that she had achieved her own identity. Associating with New York writers and artists, she met George Trow (Lucy is dedicated to him), who wrote “Talk of the Town” for The New Yorker. She collaborated on a few columns, and eventually one of her pieces was accepted by editor William Shawn, who was known for encouraging fledgling writers. In 1978, the magazine published her first short story, “Girl.” Soon after, she married Allen Shawn, the editor’s son. In 1983, her first collection, At the Bottom of the River, was published to generally favorable reviews, as was her subsequent work, which has earned for her a devoted following. She continued to write short stories, usually published in The New Yorker, and give lectures and readings. She and Allen Shawn, a composer and professor at Bennington College, along with their two children—Annie, named after her mother, and Harold—settled in Bennington, Vermont. In addition to being a writer, Kincaid developed a passion for gardening, a subject on which she wrote for The New Yorker. She also published a collection of her gardening writings, My Favorite Plant, in 1998. Analysis • Jamaica Kincaid is noted for her lyrical use of language. Her short stories and novels have a hypnotic, poetic quality that results from her utilization of rhythm and repetition. Her images, drawn from her West Indian childhood, recall Antigua, with its tropical climate, Caribbean food, local customs, and folklore laced with superstitions. Many of her stories move easily from realism to surrealistic fantasy, as would a Caribbean folktale. She is also praised for her exploration of the strong but ambiguous bond between mother and daughter and her portrayal of the transformation of a girl into a woman. Thus her work touches upon the loss of innocence that comes when one moves out of the Eden that is childhood. These are the features that are found not only in her short fiction but also in her novels, the chapters of which The New Yorker originally published as short stories, and in Annie, Gwen, Lilly, Pam, and Tu-
578
Short Story Writers
lip, a children’s book that was part of a project designed by the Whitney Museum of American Art, the original publisher, who sought to bring together contemporary authors and artists for a series of limited editions aimed primarily at collectors. Kincaid’s concern with racism, colonialism, class divisions, and sexism is rooted in her history: “I never give up thinking about the way I came into the world, how my ancestors came from Africa to the West Indies as slaves. I just could never forget it. Or forgive it.” She does not hesitate to tackle these issues in her writing. In her nonfictional A Small Place, she directs the force of her language toward an examination of her native island of Antigua, presenting the beauty as well as the racism and corruption rooted in its colonial past. In her fiction, these same issues are not slighted; for example, Annie John and Lucy address various forms of oppression and exploitation. Jamaica Kincaid’s short stories, strongly autobiographical, are often set in the West Indies or incorporate images from the islands and include many events from her youth and young adulthood. In general, her stories chronicle the coming of age of a young girl. Because the mother-daughter relationship is central to the process, Kincaid often examines the powerful bond between them, a bond that the child must eventually weaken, if not break, in order to create her own identity. Kincaid has been accurately called “the poet of girlhood and place.” “Girl” • The first of the ten stories in At the Bottom of the River is the often-praised and quoted “Girl.” Barely two pages in length, the story outlines the future life of a young girl growing up on a small Caribbean island. The voice heard belongs to the girl’s mother as she instructs her daughter in the duties that a woman is expected to fulfill in a culture with limited opportunities for girls. Twice the girl interrupts to offer a feeble protest, but her mother persists. The girl is told how to wash, iron, and mend clothes; how to cook fritters and pepper pot; how to grow okra; and how to set the table—in short, everything that will enable her to care for a future husband. She is told how to smile, how to love a man, and how to get rid of an unborn baby should it be necessary. Most important, however, her mother warns her about losing her reputation because then the girl (and this is unsaid) loses her value as a potential wife. Almost as a refrain, the mother cautions, “On Sundays try to walk like a lady and not like the slut you are so bent on becoming” or “This is how to behave in the presence of men who don’t know you very well, and this way they won’t recognize immediately the slut I have warned you against becoming.” On the island, the girl’s most important asset is her virginity. The language is a prime example of Kincaid’s ability to work a hypnotic spell. The story consists of a series of variations on particular instruction: “This is how to sew on a button; this is how to make a buttonhole for the button you have just sewed on; this is how to hem a dress when you see the hem coming down and so to prevent yourself from looking like the slut I know you are so bent on becoming.” The rhythm and repetition create a lyric poetic quality that is present to some degree in all Kincaid’s fiction. Her prose demands to be read out loud. “Girl” suggests the child’s future life on the island, but several stories in the collection re-create the atmosphere of her present existence. The story “In the Night” recounts her daily experiences. Thus, details such as crickets or flowers that would be important to her are recorded, often in the form of lists or catalogs: “The hibiscus flowers, the flamboyant flowers, the bachelor’s buttons, the irises, the marigolds, the whiteheadbush flowers, lilies, the flowers on the daggerbush,” continuing for a full paragraph. Here cataloging, a familiar feature of Kincaid’s prose, represents a
Kincaid, Jamaica
579
child’s attempt to impose an order on her surroundings. The young narrator does not question her world but only reports what she observes. Thus witchcraft exists side by side with more mundane activities: “Someone is making a basket, someone is making a girl a dress or a boy a shirt . . . someone is sprinkling a colorless powder outside a closed door so that someone else’s child will be stillborn.” This melding of the commonplace with the supernatural occurs frequently in Kincaid’s fiction. The narrator’s troubles, such as wetting the bed, are those of a child and are easily resolved by her mother. Her plans for the future, marrying a woman who will tell her stories, also are typical of a child. This is an idyllic world before the fall from innocence, a world in which everything is ordered, listed, and cataloged. Nothing is threatening, since the all-powerful mother protects and shields. “Holidays” • In several other stories, including “Wingless” and “Holidays,” the girl is again shown to be occupied by the usually pleasant sensations of living: walking barefoot, scratching her scalp, or stretching, but sometimes, as illustrated in “Holidays,” experiencing pain: “spraining a finger while trying to catch a cricket ball; straining a finger while trying to catch a softball; stepping on dry brambles while walking on the newly cut hayfields.” The trauma, however, is clearly limited to physical sensations. When the child thinks of the future, the images are those of wishful thinking, similar to daydreams. This tranquil state of youth, however, is only temporary, as “Wingless” implies. The narrator, wingless, is still in the “pupa stage.” “The Letter from Home” • In “The Letter from Home,” the narrator’s growing awareness makes it impossible for her to maintain the comforting simplicity of her child’s world. Questions about life and death intrude: “Is the Heaven to be above? Is the Hell below?” These inquiries, however, are set aside in favor of the present physical reality—a cat scratching a chair or a car breaking down. Even love and conception are reduced to the simplest terms: “There was a bed, it held sleep; there was movement, it was quick, there was a being.” She is not ready to confront the idea of death, so when death beckons, she “turned and rowed away.” “What I Have Been Doing Lately” • Just as the philosophical questions about life and death disrupt the bliss of childhood, so does the journey toward selfhood, which Kincaid symbolically represents as a journey over rough or impassable terrain or water. In “What I Have Been Doing Lately,” the obstacle is water: “I walked for I don’t know how long before I came to a big body of water. I wanted to get across it but I couldn’t swim. I wanted to get across it but it would take me years to build a boat. . . . I didn’t know how long to build a bridge.” Because the journey is difficult, as any passage to adulthood would be, the narrator is hesitant, afraid of finding the world not beautiful, afraid of missing her parents, so she goes back to bed: She is not ready yet. Soon, however, she will not have the option of retreating and waiting. “My Mother” • The journey toward selfhood necessitates a separation from the mother, as is suggested in the story “My Mother.” The protection that was vital during childhood becomes stifling in adolescence: “Placing her arms around me, she drew my head closer and closer to her bosom, until finally I suffocated.” Furthermore, the girl’s feelings are ambiguous. Realizing that she has hurt her mother, she cries, but then she utilizes those tears to create a pond, “thick and black and poisonous,” to form a barrier over which they “watched each other carefully.” The all-protecting
580
Short Story Writers
mother of the earlier stories transforms herself into a mythic monster and thus threatens the emerging selfhood of the daughter. The daughter, however, also grows “invincible” like her mother, and she, too, metamorphoses into a similar beast. Strong as the daughter has become, however, she can never vanquish her mother: “I had grown big, but my mother was bigger, and that would always be so.” Only after the daughter completes her own journey toward selfhood is her mother no longer a threat: “As we walked along, our steps became one, and as we talked, our voices became one voice, and we were in complete union in every way. What peace came over me then, for I could not see where she left off and I began, or where I left off and she began.” “At the Bottom of the River” • The concluding and title story is also the longest in the collection, at about twenty pages. “At the Bottom of the River” suggests answers to the questions raised in the other stories. Again, Kincaid employs the symbol of a journey through forbidding terrain to suggest traveling through life. What is the purpose of the journey, for what does one ultimately face but death? One man, overwhelmed, does nothing. Another discovers meaning in his family, his work, and the beauty of a sunrise, but still he struggles and “feels the futility.” How can one live with the paralyzing knowledge that “dead lay everything that had lived and dead also lay everything that would live. All had had or would have its season. And what should it matter that its season lasted five billion years or five minutes?” One possible response is suggested in the life of “a small creature” that lives in the moment, aware only of the sensation of grass underfoot or of the sting of a honeybee. The narrator, who at first knew only the love of her mother, suffers from its necessary withdrawal. Adrift, she embarks on a symbolic journey in which she submerges herself in a river-fed sea. Discovering a solution at the bottom of the river, she emerges with a commitment to the present. Death, because it is natural, cannot be destroyed, but the joys derived from the commonplace—books, chairs, fruit—can provide meaning, and she “grow[s] solid and complete.” “Xuela” • Kincaid’s story “Xuela” became the first chapter of her novel The Autobiography of My Mother (1996). Like many of her other stories, it is set against a rich description of the botany and geography of tropical Dominica, and it continues Kincaid’s meditation on the theme of mothers and daughters. Xuela, the daughter who shares her mother’s name, also shares with many Kincaid women an anger at the mother who has rejected her and a fury at the world which little understands—and little cares—about her needs. In the story’s first sentence, the reader learns that Xuela’s mother died in giving her birth, and the rest of the story is the record of the first seven years of Xuela’s life. Her father places the infant in the care of Eunice, his laundrywoman and visits her every two weeks when he delivers the dirty clothes he cares for as little as he cares for his baby daughter either physically or emotionally, oblivious as he is to his laundrywoman’s lack of affection for her foster child. The child, however, knows very well that her foster mother has no use for her, and she grows ever more bitter and withdrawn. When she breaks Eunice’s treasured china plate, she cannot bring herself to utter the words “I’m sorry.” Like the turtles she captures and carelessly kills, Xuela has withdrawn into a shell which threatens to destroy her with enforced isolation. At that point her father sends Xuela to school. The few other students are all boys;
Kincaid, Jamaica
581
like their teacher they are “of the African people” and unable to respond to the powerful element of Carib Indian in Xuela’s ancestry. The teacher wears her own African heritage like a penance and is quick to label Xuela’s intelligence as a sign of her innate evil. When the child is found writing letters to her father, he removes her from the school and takes her to live with him and his new wife, another woman who has no love for the child. Like her insensitive teacher, her father’s power as a jailer seems to suggest the destructive powers of colonialism, another Kincaid theme. Through all these trials, the child is sustained by a vision of her mother, who appears to her in sleep. In the dream, she sees her true mother descending a ladder to her, but always the dream fades before she can see more than her mother’s heels and the hem of her robe. Frustrating as it is, the dream also comes to represent the presence of the only person outside herself that Xuela can identify with unreserved love. The story’s themes of the mother who, from the child’s point of view, has willfully withdrawn her love joins with the theme of the child’s wakening to the use of sexuality to replace her lost mother’s love, linking this story to the rest of Kincaid’s work. Kincaid’s stories are praised for their strong images, poetic language, and challenging themes, and they are criticized for their lack of plot and sometimes obscure symbolism. Any reader, however, who, without reservations, enters Kincaid’s fictive world will be well rewarded. Barbara Wiedemann With updates by Ann D. Garbett and the Editors Other major works children’s literature: Annie, Gwen, Lilly, Pam, and Tulip, 1986 (with illustrations by Eric Fischl). anthologies: The Best American Essays 1995, 1995; My Favorite Plant: Writers and Gardeners on the Plants They Love, 1998; The Best American Travel Writing 2005, 2005. novels: Annie John, 1985; Lucy, 1990; The Autobiography of My Mother, 1996; Mr. Potter, 2002. nonfiction: A Small Place, 1988; My Brother, 1997; My Garden (Book), 1999; Talk Stories, 2001; Among Flowers: A Walk in the Himalaya, 2005. Bibliography Bloom, Harold, ed. Jamaica Kincaid. Philadelphia: Chelsea House, 1998. Collection of individually authored chapters on Kincaid, this critical study includes bibliographical references and an index. Bouson, J. Brooks. Jamaica Kincaid: Writing Memory, Writing Back to the Mother. Albany: State University of New York Press, 2005. Examination of Kincaid’s life, including her relationship with her mother, her homeland of Antigua, and her conflicting relations with her father and brother. De Abruna, Laura Nielsen. “Jamaica Kincaid’s Writing and the Maternal-Colonial Matrix.” In Caribbean Women Writers, edited by Mary Condé and Thorunn Lonsdale. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1999. Discusses Kincaid’s presentation of women’s experience, her use of postmodern narrative strategies, and her focus on the absence of the once-affirming mother or mother country that causes dislocation and alienation. Ellsberg, Peggy. “Rage Laced with Lyricism.” Review of A Small Place. Commonweal 115
582
Short Story Writers
(November 4, 1988): 602-604. In her review of A Small Place, with references to At the Bottom of the River and Annie John, Ellsberg justifies the anger that is present in A Small Place, anger that is occasioned by exploitation. Emery, Mary Lou. “Refiguring the Postcolonial Imagination: Tropes of Visuality in Writing by Rhys, Kincaid, and Cliff.” Tulsa Studies in Women’s Literature 16 (Fall, 1997): 259-280. Emery uses one of Jean Rhys’s novels to illustrate a dialectical relationship between the European means of visualization and image-making in postcolonial literatures as something not just of the eye. Argues that the use of the rhetorical trope of ekphrasis (an artistic hybrid) reflects the cultural hybrid nature of postcolonial literature. Ferguson, Moira. Jamaica Kincaid: Where the Land Meets the Body. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1994. Includes bibliographical references and an index. ____________. “A Lot of Memory: An Interview with Jamaica Kincaid.” The Kenyon Review, n.s. 16 (Winter, 1994): 163-188. Kincaid discusses the inspiration for her writing and the reasons she wrote her first book in an experimental style; describes the influence of the English tradition on fiction in the Caribbean; comments on the nature of colonial conquest as a theme she explores through the metaphor of gardening. MacDonald-Smythe, Antonia. Making Homes in the West Indies: Constructions of Subjectivity in the Writings of Michelle Cliff and Jamaica Kincaid. New York: Garland, 2001. Focuses on these two Caribbean women writers. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Kincaid: “At the Bottom of the River” (vol. 1), “Girl” (vol. 3), and “My Mother” (vol. 5). Paravisini-Gerbert, Lizabeth. Jamaica Kincaid: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1999. Two biographical chapters are followed by penetrating analyses of At the Bottom of the River, Annie John, Lucy, and The Autobiography of My Mother. Simmons, Diane. Jamaica Kincaid. New York: Twayne, 1994. Lucid critical overview of Kincaid’s life and work. A good introduction to her work for nonspecialist readers.
583
Barbara Kingsolver Born: Annapolis, Maryland; April 8, 1955 Principal short fiction • Homeland, and Other Stories, 1989. Other literary forms • Barbara Kingsolver is known primarily for her long fiction, which includes The Bean Trees (1988), Animal Dreams (1990), Pigs in Heaven (1993), The Poisonwood Bible (1998), and Prodigal Summer (2000). She has also written travel articles, book reviews, essays, and poetry. Her nonfiction work Holding the Line: Women in the Great Arizona Mine Strike of 1983 (1989) compellingly presents the plight of miners in southern Arizona’s copper mining company towns. Her other nonfiction books include High Tide in Tucson: Essays from Now or Never (1995), Last Stand: America’s Virgin Lands (2002), and Small Wonder (2002). Kingsolver’s only published volume of poetry is Another America (1992, 1998). The form in which verses are presented in that collection invites awareness of diverse perspectives, with Kingsolver’s poetry and its Spanish translations printed on facing pages. A selection of her essays in High Tide in Tucson: Essays from Now or Never (1995) offers thoughts on parenting, home ownership, cultural habits, travel, and writing. Her observations on the natural order of things, from child rearing to exploring a volcanic crater in Hawaii, range from self-deprecatingly humorous to awe-inspired. All celebrate one’s connection to and citizenship of the world. Achievements • Kingsolver has received many awards for her writing. In 1986 the Arizona Press Club gave her its feature-writing award. She received American Library Association awards in 1989 for The Bean Trees and in 1990 for Homeland. The Edward Abbey Ecofiction Award (1990) for Animal Dreams and the prestigious PEN Western Fiction Award (1991) added to her reputation. In 1993 and 1994 she received the Los Angeles Book Award and Mountain and Plains Booksellers Association Award for Pigs in Heaven. She also received an Enoch Pratt Library Youth Book Award for The Bean Trees. Her other awards include the Enoch Pratt Library Lifetime Achievement Medal in 2005; the 2002 International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award for Prodigal Summer; an award for the Best American Science and Nature Writing in 2001; a National Humanities Medal in 2000; the 1999 Patterson Fiction Prize; a New York Times Ten Best Books selection for The Poisonwood Bible in 1998; a citation of accomplishment from the United Nations National Council of Women in 1989. In 1995, De Pauw University conferred an honorary doctorate on her. She spent two semesters as a visiting writer at Emory and Henry College. True to her activist principles, she is the founder of the Bellwether Prize, given in support of literature of social change. Biography • Born in Annapolis, Maryland, on April 8, 1955, Barbara Kingsolver spent most of her childhood in eastern Kentucky’s rural Nicholas County and began writing before beginning high school. She studied biology at DePauw University in Indiana and graduated magna cum laude in 1977. While working for a master’s degree in science at the University of Arizona, she took a creative writing class. Between her stints as a student, she lived for a time in Greece and France. After completing her
584
Short Story Writers
master’s degree, she did science writing for the University of Arizona and began to write feature articles, which appeared in such national publications as Smithsonian, Harper’s, and The New York Times. After marrying Joseph Hoffman in 1985, she wrote The Bean Trees during insomniac interludes she experienced while pregnant with her daughter Camille. She later divorced Hoffman and married Steven Hopp, with whom she settled in Tucson, Arizona. Kingsolver has been a political activist all of her adult life. Analysis • Barbara Kingsolver’s short stories are notable for their clear-eyed, sometimes ironic, and always empathic look at the daily lives of ordinary people. Her narrators are mostly female or compassionate omniscient voices telling stories of homecomings, intergenerational misunderstandings, and mundane events such as scheduling errands or getting to know one’s neighbors. She pays close attention to the tensions that control events like Thanksgiving dinners and accurately captures the dynamics of husband and wife and of mother and daughter. In her stories, characters struggle to understand who they are in the context of family history and their present circumstances. The epiphanies of Kingsolver’s women are small but searingly personal. They range from deciding not to have a child to a sudden understanding of a mother’s point of view. In a News Hour online interview with David Gergen, editorat-large for U.S. News and World Report, Kingsolver explained her fascination with the quotidian episodes in families’ and couples’ lives: We need new stories. We need stories that can help us construct, reconstruct the value of . . . solidarity, of not . . . the lone solo flier, but the family, the community, the value of working together. Kingsolver’s short fiction is not minimalist. She belongs to generations of storytellers who create settings rich in sensual and situational detail. Her characters are clearly situated and her stories have a satisfying beginning, middle, and end as do the stories of nineteenth century writers such as Sarah Orne Jewett and Mary E. Wilkins Freeman. She is also distinctly contemporary because her characters reach an episode’s end when they achieve some insight or understanding of their condition. They do not, however, find sentimental or easy answers. Each story concludes with characters more able to cope with the literal and emotional landscapes of their lives. Like poet and essayist Adrienne Rich, Kingsolver embraces the political. She believes art should reflect the world she sees daily, so she writes, for example, about the plight of mine workers in the American Southwest and the displacement of American Indians. College professors, aging hippies, and small-town eccentrics all wrestle with bigotry and stereotyping as they move through their lives. Kingsolver’s characters avoid the cynicism of many contemporary fictional voices, seeking instead a synthesis that will see them through or the moral vision that will allow them to rise above prejudices they cannot control. She combines the narrative structure of nineteenth century realists with the frank look at life espoused by John Steinbeck, one of her inspirations. Kingsolver’s characters offer an alternative to ironic, angry characters. They struggle with the inequities of American life without losing their ability to maintain human connection. Kingsolver creates characters who confront life without relinquishing hope. Her vision is distinctive and welcome. Homeland, and Other Stories • Barbara Kingsolver’s collection is divided between stories in which the difficulties of small-town life are controlled by the fears and sensibil-
Kingsolver, Barbara
585
ities of people wedded to the status quo and those in which the clash between alternative lifestyles and the ordinary routines of existence is prominent. With one exception, the narrators are women or feature omniscient narrators, whose voices elucidate women’s lives and points TO VIEW IMAGE, of view. The stories frequently have PLEASE SEE a postmodern view of time, jumpPRINT EDITION ing nonchronologically from one episode or memory to the next, the OF THIS BOOK. changes marked by spaces in the text as well as by narrated events. Kingsolver interestingly blurs the line between character and narrator by interspersing narrative passages with snippets of dialogue. Often the narrator’s contributions could just as easily be spoken by the main character; this shared quality underlines the universal relevance of private stories. Kingsolver’s stories, built around family routines, usually emphasize a thoughtful female character grappling with a problem. These range from spending quality time with a child (“Quality Time”), facing the need to break off a love affair (“Stone Dreams”), coping with suffering the failure of a long-standing relationship (“Blueprints”), and fighting economic and social injustice (“Why I Am a Danger to the Public”) to deciding whether or not to have a child (“Covered Bridges”). Another theme is how one comes to terms with one’s past. “Survival Zone” and “Extinctions” have dual tensions: The eternal city/country dilemma surfaces differently in each story, and each considers the opportunities for a life in the larger world as opposed to a well-known existence. “Rose-Johnny” tackles the divisive and meanspirited effects of racial prejudice in a small southern town. A young girl, curious and kindhearted, tells the story, which highlights the socially sanctioned cruelty of adults. Kingsolver’s characters realize the beginnings of personal solutions or they relate histories that reveal insights won after the scrutiny of their pasts. Either way, readers know life always goes on in its complicated and demanding way. Survival is mandatory; understanding possible. “Homeland” • The title story of Kingsolver’s collection Homeland, and Other Stories retrospectively tells the tale of an aging Cherokee grandmother’s last days. Gloria St. Clair, Great Mam’s granddaughter, a grown woman with her own grown children, narrates a family history that begins with the Cherokee Trail of Tears. Great Mam’s band had eluded relocation by hiding and was finally allowed to settle where they chose. Still, they called the refugee years “The Time When We Were Not.” Gloria’s reference initiates the reader into history as a personal experience. A reminiscence of the family’s trip back to Great Mam’s birthplace, the Hiwassee Valley in Tennessee, follows. Gloria’s father, a coal miner just back to work after a season of wildcat strikes,
586
Short Story Writers
decides this trip is necessary for his mother, who is in her waning days; he plans it despite his wife’s skepticism. Great Mam and Gloria’s special relationship evolves along with the story. During lazy afternoons or quiet evenings in the dark, Great Mam tells Gloria stories of the animals “as if they were relatives [her] parents had neglected to tell [her] about.” The trip, with the three children bumping along in the back of a pickup truck, as well as the fact that they slept three to a bed, reveals the family’s economic situation. Gloria’s mother represents a third dynamic, the social status quo; she is thankful God spared her children a “Cherokee nose.” Mrs. Murray rises above the common-law, racially mixed marriage of her husband’s parents. Gloria balances between her mother and her love for the soft-spoken woman, who tells her how the world began and calls her Waterbug. She fatalistically laments her lack of attention to stories she now knows were rare treasures. The trip fails, the home of a once-proud people houses a troop of sideshow Indians in Cherokee Park. Great Mam does not get out of the truck but remarks to Gloria, “I’ve never been here before.” Great Mam’s death is unremarkable, personal, and poignant for Gloria and a troublesome irritation for her mother—the three of them a perfect metaphor for the pain of America’s position on “the Indian question.” “Islands on the Moon” • Annemarie and her mother Magda are intimate antagonists because Annemarie thinks her mother “doesn’t seem mid-forties, she seems like Grandma Moses in moonstone earrings.” Annemarie has been alienated from her mother, an aging hippie with wild hair, since her father’s death, and her aggravation only increases when Magda turns up pregnant at the same time that she does. As it turns out, Annemarie is not presently married and is contemplating remarrying her first husband. Her own son, Kevin, is moving steadily beyond her reach. Magda breaks her practice of keeping her distance because she wants Annemarie to accompany her when she has amniocentesis, a test to which she would not have agreed had her doctor not threatened to drop her as a patient if she refused. On the way to the clinic, the two have an automobile accident and are rushed to the hospital. The shock of the accident and their time side by side in the hospital free a torrent of resentments from Annemarie. Her persistence prompts Magda to say, “I never knew what you expected from me, Annemarie. I never could be the mother you wanted.” When Annemarie makes the ultimate accusation, that Magda does not miss her husband, Magda recounts her husband’s obsessive attempts to try to think of all the things she would need to remember to do after he was gone. Stunned, Annemarie understands her error. “How could I not ever have known that, that it wrecked your life, too?” she asks her mother. At the story’s end, Annemarie reaches over to touch her unborn sister, establishing a tenuous bond which now has a chance to flourish. Karen L. Arnold With updates by the Editors Other major works anthology: The Best American Short Stories, 2001, 2001. novels: The Bean Trees, 1988; Animal Dreams, 1990; Pigs in Heaven, 1993; The Poisonwood Bible, 1998; Prodigal Summer, 2000. nonfiction: Holding the Line: Women in the Great Arizona Mine Strike of 1983, 1989;
Kingsolver, Barbara
587
High Tide in Tucson: Essays from Now or Never, 1995; Last Stand: America’s Virgin Lands, 2002 (photographs by Annie Griffiths Belt); Small Wonder, 2002. poetry: Another America/Otra America, 1992. Bibliography DeMarr, Mary Jean. Barbara Kingsolver: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1999. Good overview of Kingsolver’s work, emphasizing her ecofeminism. Draper, James P. “Barbara Kingsolver.” In Contemporary Literary Criticism: Yearbook 1993. Vol. 81. Detroit: Gale Research, 1994. Collection of critical views of Kingsolver’s work. Epstein, Robin. “Barbara Kingsolver.” Progressive 60 (February, 1996): 33-38. An informative interview with Kingsolver; Kingsolver believes that most readers do not think that her writing is overly political; she feels that she has a responsibility to discuss her beliefs with the public. Fleischner, Jennifer, ed. A Reader’s Guide to the Fiction of Barbara Kingsolver: “The Bean Trees,” “Homeland, and Other Stories,” “Animal Dreams,” “Pigs in Heaven.” New York: Harper Perennial, 1994. Good resource for the student new to Kingsolver’s work. Gaard, Greta. “Living Connections with Animals and Nature.” In Eco-Feminism: Women, Animals, Nature, edited by Greta Gaard. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1993. Discusses the implications of a personal/political commitment to the natural world. Kingsolver, Barbara. Interview by Lisa See. Publishers Weekly 237 (August 31, 1990): 46. Kingsolver discusses her early literary influences and her research and writing methods. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of three short stories by Kingsolver: “Homeland” (vol. 3), “Islands on the Moon” (vol. 4), and “RoseJohnny” (vol. 6). Pence, Amy. “Barbara Kingsolver.” Poets and Writers 21, no. 4 (July/August, 1993): 1421. Pence looks at Kingsolver’s writing and her commitments to political activism and family. Ross, Jean W. “CA Interview.” In Contemporary Authors. Vol. 134, edited by Susan M. Trotsky. Detroit: Gale Research, 1992. Brief biographical and professional information sections are followed by an interview covering Kingsolver’s writing methods, the sources of some of her characters, the importance of her background, and some of her nonfiction writing. Ryan, Maureen. “Barbara Kingsolver’s Lowfat Fiction.” Journal of American Culture 18, no. 4 (Winter, 1995): 77-123. Ryan compares Kingsolver’s first three novels with her first short-story collection.
588
Rudyard Kipling Born: Bombay, India; December 30, 1865 Died: Hampstead, London, England; January 18, 1936 Principal short fiction • Quartette, 1885 (with John Lockwood Kipling, Alice Macdonald Kipling, and Alice Kipling); In Black and White, 1888; Plain Tales from the Hills, 1888; Soldiers Three: A Collection of Stories, 1888; The Phantom ’Rickshaw, and Other Tales, 1888; The Story of the Gadsbys, 1888; Under the Deodars, 1888; Wee Willie Winkie, and Other Child Stories, 1888; The City of Dreadful Night, and Other Places, 1890; The Courting of Dinah Shadd, and Other Stories, 1890; Life’s Handicap, 1891; Mine Own People, 1891; Many Inventions, 1893; The Jungle Book, 1894; The Second Jungle Book, 1895; Soldier Tales, 1896; The Day’s Work, 1898; Stalky and Co., 1899; Just So Stories, 1902; Traffics and Discoveries, 1904; Puck of Pook’s Hill, 1906; Actions and Reactions, 1909; Rewards and Fairies, 1910; A Diversity of Creatures, 1917; Land and Sea Tales for Scouts and Guides, 1923; Debits and Credits, 1926; Thy Servant a Dog, 1930; Limits and Renewals, 1932; Collected Dog Stories, 1934. Other literary forms • Rudyard Kipling’s literary career began in journalism, but his prose sketches and verse brought him early fame. He wrote several novels, most lastingly Kim (1901), and he also wrote works of history, including a study of his son’s military regiment from World War I. In his lifetime as well as posthumously, however, his fame depended upon his poetry and short stories, both of which he wrote for adult audiences and for children. Kipling’s autobiography, Something of Myself: For My Friends Known and Unknown (1937), was published after his death. Achievements • By his early twenties, Rudyard Kipling had become one of the bestknown writers in the English language. His first poems and stories were written and published in India, but his popularity quickly spread throughout the Englishspeaking world and beyond. Although he published several novels, the short-story form proved to be his most successful métier. Drawing upon his experiences in India, many of his early stories featured the adventures of ordinary soldiers, junior officers, and civil officials, and his use of dialect was a recognized feature of his literary technique. Awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1907, he also received honorary degrees from many universities. Kipling wrote extensively about the benefits of the United Kingdom’s paramount position in the world, and over time his public persona was perceived to be that of a political reactionary. Although some of his finest short stories were written in the last two decades of his life, by that time, to many of his contemporaries, he had become yesterday’s man, irrevocably associated with political imperialism, a dying creed even before his death in 1936. After his death, however, his stories received much critical study and acclaim, and Kipling is considered to be one of the major practitioners of the short-story art ever to write in English. Biography • Joseph Rudyard Kipling was born in Bombay, India, in 1865. His father, John Lockwood Kipling, was an artist and teacher. His mother, Alice Macdonald
Kipling, Rudyard
589
Kipling, was from a family of exceptional sisters. One married the Pre-Raphaelite painter, Sir Edward Coley Burne-Jones, and another was the mother of Stanley Baldwin, the British prime minister in the years between the two world wars. As was customary at the time, Rudyard and his younger sister remained in England when their parents returned to India, and Kipling dramatized his misery at being left behind in his later writings. He attended a second-rank private school that prepared middle-class boys for careers in the military; small, not athletic, and forced to wear glasses, Kipling was not an outstanding or popular student, but his literary interests proved a defense and a consolation. The university was not an option for him, primarily for financial reasons, and he returned to India, where his parents had found a position for him on an English-language newspaper. Kipling was fascinated by India. Often unable to sleep, he spent his nights wandering the streets. He had written some poetry as a schoolboy and continued to do so, while also composing newspaper sketches featuring his Anglo-Indian environment. By the end of the 1880’s, he had already published several volumes of short stories and poems. No British writer since Charles Dickens had become so well known, and Kipling was only in his mid-twenties. His works were often satiric, and some readers believed that he cast aspersions upon the British army and imperial authorities in India, but the opposite was closer to Kipling’s own feelings. He doubted that the English at home understood the sacrifices that the average soldier, the young officer, and the district commissioners were making to preserve Great Britain’s prosperity and security. Kipling left India in 1889 and established himself in London, where he became acquainted with the major literary figures of the day, including Thomas Hardy and Henry James. In 1890, he published his first novel, The Light That Failed. With the American Wolcott Balestier, Kipling, in spite of his previous unwillingness to attach himself to any literary partnership, wrote a second novel, The Naulahka: A Story of East and West (1892). Kipling’s relationship with Balestier was very close, and, after the latter’s death, he married Balestier’s sister, Caroline (Carrie), in 1892. Kipling subsequently settled in Vermont, near his wife’s family. Although residing there for four years before returning to England, Kipling never admired the United States and had difficulty with Carrie’s family. Kipling’s fame reached its pinnacle in the years before the South African (Boer) War broke out in 1899. His portrayal of the Empire struck a chord in the British psyche during the 1890’s; a changing political climate, however, began to make Kipling’s public posture as an imperialist less acceptable. Still, he continued to write, both for children and for adults. In 1902, he purchased Bateman’s, a country house in Sussex, which remained his home for the rest of his life. Long a frustrated man of action and a Francophile from his schoolboy years, he vehemently opposed Germany during World War I. His only son was killed in action in 1915. Kipling’s health had begun to decline, his marriage was less than fulfilling, and although he received much formal praise, his later stories were not widely read. He died in 1936 and was buried in Westminster Abbey, more a recognition for his earlier than his later career. Only after his death was it possible to separate the public man—imperialist and antiliberal—from the literary artist whose best stories have continued to survive. Analysis • Many of Rudyard Kipling’s earliest short stories are set in the India of his early childhood years in Bombay and his newspaper days in Lahore. The intervening
590
Short Story Writers
years at school in England had perhaps increased his sensitivity to the exotic Indian locale and British imperial presence. Kipling was a voracious reader of English, French, and American writers, trained by his newspaper experience in the virtues of conciseness and detail. His art arrived almost fully revealed in his earliest works. Kipling focused, however, not on the glories and conquests of empire but on the lives—work and activities, passions and emotions—of ordinary people responding to what were often extraordinary or inexplicable events. Love, especially doomed love, terror and the macabre, revenge and its consequences—these were the elements upon which his stories turned, even later when the settings were often English. His fame or notoriety was almost instantaneous, in part because of the locations and subject matter of the stories, because of his use of dialect in re-creating the voices of his nonestablishment characters, and because Kipling’s early writings appeared at a time when England and Western civilization as a whole were caught up in imperial dreams and rivalries. A number of his stories pivot around the relations between men and women. Kipling has been called a misogynist, and often his characters, particularly those in the military, blame women for their own and others’ misfortunes. Most of his stories employ a male voice, and many critics agree that Kipling’s women are not often fully realized, particularly in his early years. The isolation of British soldiers and officials in India could itself explain these portrayals. There were boundaries in that esoteric environment—sexual, social, racial—that were violated only at a cost, but in Kipling’s stories they are crossed because his characters choose to do so or cannot help themselves. “Beyond the Pale” • In “Beyond the Pale,” Christopher Trejago seduces and is seduced by a fifteen-year-old Hindu widow, Bisea, before misunderstanding and jealousy cause the lovers to terminate the relationship. Later, Trejago returns to their place of rendezvous only to discover that Bisea’s hands have been cut off at the wrists; at the instant of his discovery, he is attacked by a sharp object that injures his groin. One of Kipling’s shortest stories, it exhibits several of his continuing concerns. Love, passion, even understanding are often doomed, whether between man and woman or between British and Indians, while horror and unexpected shock can occur at any time and have lasting effects; revenge is a human quality. Stylistically, the story is rich in the descriptive detail of the dead-end alley where Bisea and Trejago first met but is enigmatic in explaining how the affair became known, leading to Bisea’s maiming. The story does not end with the assault on Trejago. As often with Kipling, there is a coda. Trejago is forced to carry on, with a slight limp and the remembrance of horror leading to sleepless nights. “Love-o’-Women” • Dangerous boundaries and illicit relationships also feature in his “Love-o’-Women,” the story of Larry Tighe, a gentleman who had enlisted as a common soldier, a gentleman-ranker who stepped down out of his proper world. Kipling often used the technique of a story-within-a-story, told by a narrator who may or may not be telling the total truth but whose own personality and perception are as important as the plot itself, accomplished most notably in “Mrs. Bathurst.” Here, in “Love-o’-Women,” the tale opens with Sergeant Raines shooting one of his own men, Corporal Mackie, who had seduced Mrs. Raines. After Raines’s trial, several soldiers ruminate on the dead Mackie’s fate. One of them, Terrence Mulvaney, comments that Mackie is the lucky one: He died quickly. He then tells the story of Tighe,
Kipling, Rudyard whoc laimed the nickname of Loveo’-Women and made a career in the military of seducing daughters and wives, governesses and maids. When Tighe attempts to commit suicide by exposing his body to enemy fire during a battle, Mulvaney saves him and learns that Tighe deeply regrets what he has done, including his treatment and loss of his only real love, a woman named Egypt who turned to prostitution. Dying of syphilis, Tighe collapses in Egypt’s arms; she then shoots herself. Kipling did not necessarily believe in justice in the world, and, although reared a Christian, he was not orthodox in his religious beliefs but believed that there was a mortality for which one must answer. In “Love-o’-Women,” sin required confession, contrition, and penance.
591
Library of Congress
“The Phantom ’Rickshaw” • Ghosts or phantoms also often played a role in Kipling’s stories. In “The Phantom ’Rickshaw,” Jack Pansay, an English official in India, begins a shipboard flirtation with a married woman, Mrs. Keith-Wessington, while returning from England. The affair continues in India, but Pansay grows tired of her, becoming engaged to someone else. Mrs. Wessington refuses to accept the termination of the romance and subsequently dies after losing control of her rickshaw while attempting to renew the affair. Soon, as a ghostly presence, she and her rickshaw begin to appear to Pansay, and feeling that his rejection had killed her, he himself sinks into decline. Although his doctor believes that his illness is merely the result of overwork, Pansay believes otherwise: His death is the payment required for his treatment of Mrs. Wessington. “The Wish House” • From the beginning of his literary career, Kipling was considered to be a master in the use of dialect. Mulvaney’s telling of Tighe’s tale was rendered in an Irish dialect. In Kipling’s Indian stories, Mulvaney’s Irish was joined by characters speaking London Cockney, Yorkshire in northern England, and others. In many of his later stories, Kipling incorporated various English dialects, such as the Sussex dialect spoken by Grace Ashcroft and Liz Fettley in “The Wish House.” He generally used dialect when portraying the speech of persons from the undereducated classes or foreigners—persons different from his middle-class readers—and his treatment is often successful, even though some critics have claimed that his dialect re-creations were not entirely accurate. It has also been argued that, at times, the use of dialect gets in the way of the reading and understanding of the story itself, although this is more true of his early stories than his later ones. In “The Wish House,” Grace Ashcroft goes to an abandoned house, inhabited by
592
Short Story Writers
wraiths, where it was possible to take on the pain of some loved one; for her, it was her former lover. Like the blind woman in “They,” however, she is driven by a love that is ultimately a selfish one: She is willing to accept his pain as hers not only because she loved him but also because she hopes that he will never marry and find happiness with anyone else. “The Brushwood Boy” • On occasion, Kipling attempted to create the speaking style of the middle or upper classes. Here the use of words and phrases can be disconcerting to the reader, particularly after the diction and slang of an era has become dated. In “The Brushwood Boy,” George Cottar, the perfect public-school graduate and heroic young officer, resorts to “By Jove” on a regular basis. Possibly accurate then, it is artificial and stereotyped to a later generation. The same might be said about Kipling’s attempts to re-create the voices of children: Sometimes they are successful, sometimes not. If dialogue and dialect can deepen and extend the meaning and quality of a story, they can also date a story and detract from it. During the 1890’s, after his marriage to Carrie and the birth of his three children, Kipling, although continuing to write short stories and novels for an adult audience, also turned his hand to works for children. Kipling had an empathetic feeling for children; some critics suggest that he never entirely outgrew his own childhood, with its traumas and rewards. The Jungle Book was published in 1894 and The Second Jungle Book the following year. The series of stories of the baby Mowgli reared by wolves in the jungle is perhaps the most enduring of Kipling’s many short-story collections. Several generations of children read about Father and Mother Wolf, the tiger Shere Khan, the sleepy bear Baloo, the panther Bagheera, and Kaa, the python. In later decades, other children came to know them through the Walt Disney cartoon feature, but there is a quality in the Kipling stories that did not translate fully to the screen. Like authors of other animal stories, Kipling anthropomorphized his creatures, and they exhibit recognizable human characteristics, but his jungle contains a quality of danger, of menace, which was not replicated in the Disney production. “The King’s Ankus” • Kipling’s City of the Cold Lair in “The King’s Ankus,” inhabited only by the evil White Cobra, places the reader in a dark, dangerous, and claustrophobic building, a house of fear and death. A continuing motif in the stories involves references to the Law of the Jungle—Charles Darwin’s survival of the fittest—an ideology very prominent in the imperialist years of the late nineteenth century. The villainous Shere Khan, Mowgli’s rival who is always eager to put Mowgli to death, belonged to that jungle world, while the Monkey-People as portrayed in “Kaa’s Hunting” and human beings, driven from their village in “Letting in the Jungle,” did not. Both species did not properly follow the law; both were cowardly, vindictive, thoughtless, greedy, and irrational. Just So Stories • The Just So Stories were published in 1902. These were composed for an audience younger and more innocent than the readers of The Jungle Book stories. The teller of the tales, or fables, addresses his hearer as “O My Best Beloved,” who was Kipling’s eldest child, Josephine, who died at the age of six, in 1899. The Just So Stories appeal on two levels. First, they purport to answer some of the eternal questions of childhood such as “How the Camel Got His Hump” and “How the Leopard Got His Spots.” In so doing, Kipling’s genius for specific details captivates the reader. From “How the Whale Got His Throat” comes the following:
Kipling, Rudyard
593
If you swim to latitude Fifty North, longitude Forty West (that is magic), you will find sitting on a raft, in the middle of the sea, with nothing on but a pair of blue canvas breeches, a pair of suspenders (you must not forget the suspenders, Best Beloved), and a jack-knife, one shipwrecked Mariner. Second, the settings of the tales enchant with their exotic locale, such as the Howling Desert of the camel, the High Veldt of the leopard, and “the banks of the turbid Amazon” in those High and Far-Off Times. Puck of Pook’s Hill • The fourth collection of Kipling’s children’s stories was Puck of Pook’s Hill, published in 1906. Now ensconced in the English countryside at Bateman’s, Kipling turned to the history of England. Puck, “the oldest Old Thing in England,” appears to two young children, Dan and Una, and through the use of magic conjures up for them various past eras from pre-Roman times onward. The nationalistic bias of the tales is not heavy-handed, and generally the narrative and the conversations of the characters are appropriate for children, while Puck’s world, if not Puck himself, is more familiar and less exotic than Kipling’s earlier children’s books. Among re-created practical Romans, patriotic Saxons, and archetypal peasants, the most evocative tale is “Dymchurch Flit,” recited by the narrator in a Sussex dialect. In the aftermath of Henry VIII’s Protestant Reformation, England’s fairies (“pharisees”) wished to flee from the land, and a peasant woman gives her two disabled sons through a “pure love-loan” to ferry them to the Continent. At the end of each conjuring of the past, however, Puck causes the children to forget him and his creations; he and his magic belong in the stories, not in so-called real life. Although Puck uses magic, the stories themselves are more realistic, being grounded in history, than either the fables of The Jungle Book, The Second Jungle Book, or Just So Stories. “Mrs. Bathurst” • One of Kipling’s most successful short stories was “Mrs. Bathurst,” published in 1904 and set in South Africa. On one level, the story is told through an unidentified first-person narrator. He and his friend Inspector Hooper, a railway investigator who had just returned from surveying railway equipment in the interior, are passing time drinking beer on a hot day. Hooper has something in his pocket for which he occasionally reaches but never quite removes. They are shortly joined by Pycroft, a sailor, and Sergeant Pritchard, whom the narrator knows but Hooper does not. Pycroft and Pritchard begin to reminisce about sailors whom they have known: Boy Niven who led them astray in the forests of British Columbia supposedly searching for his uncle’s farm, Spit-Kit Jones who married “the cocoanutwoman,” and Moon, who had “showed signs o’bein’ a Mormonastic beggar” and who deserted after sixteen years of service. The talk then turns to “V,” who had disappeared just recently while up-country, only eighteen months before his pension. “V” was also known as Click because of his false teeth, which did not quite fit. Hooper is interested in what Pycroft and Pritchard have to say about “V” and asks them if “V” has any tattoos. Pritchard takes umbrage, believing that Inspector Hooper is seeking information in order to arrest his friend “V.” Apologies are made, and then Hooper asks to hear more about “Vickery,” though until that moment only “V” had been used in the discussion. The narrator asks why Vickery ran away, and Pycroft, through a smile, lets it be known that there was a woman involved. Mrs. Bathurst, a widow, owned a hotel in New Zealand frequented by sailors and others. Asked to describe her, Pycroft an-
594
Short Story Writers
swered that “‘Tisn’t beauty, so to speak, nor good talk necessarily. It’s just It.” Pycroft has now become the primary narrator, and Vickery and Mrs. Bathurst are filtered through his memories and perceptions. According to Pycroft, Mrs. Bathurst had “It,” and Vickery was captivated although he did not let that be known to Pycroft at the time. Last December, as Pycroft tells the story, while on liberty in Cape Town, he ran into Vickery who, visibly disturbed, demanded that Pycroft accompany him to a biograph or cinematograph. This early motion picture—a recent novelty—featured scenes from England. Sitting in the front row, Vickery and Pycroft watched various London views appear on the “magic-lantern sheet.” The scene shifted to London’s Paddington Station, and among the passengers who came down the platform in the direction of the camera was Mrs. Bathurst, who “looked out straight at us with that blindish look. . . . She walked on and on till she melted out of the picture—like a shadow jumpin’ over a candle.” At Vickery’s urging, Pycroft accompanies him for five consecutive evenings to the cinematograph. On one occasion, Vickery agitatedly claims that Mrs. Bathurst is looking for him. Then, under obscure circumstances, Vickery is assigned upcountry, and before he leaves he tells Pycroft that the motion picture of Mrs. Bathurst would appear again in a town where he would be able to see her once more. Vickery also abruptly informs Pycroft that he is not a murderer, for his wife had died during childbirth after Vickery had shipped out. Confused, Pycroft asked for the rest of the story but was not enlightened: “‘The rest,’ ‘e says, ‘is silence,’” borrowing from Hamlet (c. 1600-1601). Pycroft heard no more from Vickery. At this point Hooper again reaches into his pocket and makes a reference to false teeth being acceptable evidence in a court of law. He then tells of his recent experience in the interior. Told to watch for a couple of tramps, Hooper recites how he could see them from a long way off, one standing and one sitting. They were dead. There’d been a bit of a thunderstorm in the teak, you see, and they were both stone dead and black as charcoal. That’s what they really were, you see—charcoal. They fell to bits when we tried to shift ‘em. The man who was standin’ up had the false teeth. I saw ‘em shinin’ against the black. . . . Both burned to charcoal. Again, Hooper reaches to his pocket, and again he does not bring forth anything. Although no other evidence appears, Pritchard for one seems to assume that the other body, unidentified by Hooper, is Mrs. Bathurst. Pycroft concludes that he for one is glad that Vickery is dead, wishing only to drink the last of the beer. Throughout the story, Mrs. Bathurst is perceived through a series of images, as seen and related by Pycroft and Pritchard, who had known her in New Zealand, as told by Vickery to Pycroft, as she appears flickering on the motion-picture screen and as the unidentified narrator recites these varying images to the reader. If one theme in “Mrs. Bathurst” is the difficulty of perceiving the reality behind the images, another is the compulsive and destructive power of love. This was not a new aspect in Kipling’s work, but perhaps never before had the woman, and even the man, Vickery, been quite so filtered from the reader through the various narrators and now including her image on the screen. Vickery’s death apparently resulted because of his experience with Mrs. Bathurst. What was that experience? Was he escaping from her or seeking her out? Was he guilty of something? Apparently he was not guilty of murdering his wife. Had love or its consequences driven him mad? One critic has pointed out the element of “synchronicity,” or the significant coincidence as an element in “Mrs. Bathurst.” Many twentieth century writers, from James Joyce to Anthony
Kipling, Rudyard
595
Powell, have employed this device. In “Mrs. Bathurst,” the most notable example was the coincidence of Vickery and then Pycroft discovering Mrs. Bathurst on the motion-picture screen. The story is of seemingly disjointed events, like individual scenes in a motion picture. Combined, they may have a coherence, but what that coherence is, or means, remains obscure, merely flickering images. Readers have puzzled over “Mrs. Bathurst” ever since the story first appeared. “They” • Several of Kipling’s later stories continue to develop his earlier themes. In 1904, Kipling wrote “They.” A ghost story, or perhaps a fantasy, its setting is a beautiful, isolated country house in England inhabited by a young blind woman who, through her sheer need, has been able to bring back the spirits of dead children and thus to transcend the grave, the ultimate barrier. Like Mrs. Bathurst and other of Kipling’s female characters, the blind woman has a power that profoundly affects the world around her. “Mary Postgate” • “Mary Postgate,” a powerful story of repression and revenge, portrays a middle-aged spinster and companion who passively accepts the abuse of the young boy of the house, Wyndham Fowler. He treated her shabbily for years, throwing things at her, calling her names such as “Posty” and “Packhead,” and belittling her abilities. Then, while in training as a pilot in World War I, Wynn is accidentally killed. Postgate has long repressed and denied any feelings and does so again when his death is announced; her only regret is that he died before he had the chance to “kill somebody.” While she is in town getting paraffin to burn Wynn’s effects, a building collapses, killing a young girl; although the local doctor tells her that the crash occurred from natural causes, she refuses to accept it, convinced that the Germans have bombed the house. Returning home to light the fire, she comes across an injured pilot in the garden and, assuming that he is German, refuses to summon a doctor, electing instead to watch him die. In choosing the pilot’s death, Postgate not only is having her revenge for the death of Wynn and the girl killed supposedly at the hands of the hated German enemy but also is gaining her personal revenge for the hollowness of her own life. The pilot in the garden might well be German, but for Mary it makes no difference: It could be anyone. As he dies and as the fire consumes Wynn’s effects, Mary experiences a rush of ecstasy comparable to a sexual release. “Mary Postgate” is a deeply felt exploration of a damaged human psyche. “Dayspring Mishandled” • “Dayspring Mishandled” is one of Kipling’s last and finest stories. It, too, is a story of revenge, but revenge ultimately not taken. It tells of two writers, Manallace and Castorley, cynically writing for pulp publication: “If you save people thinking you can do anything with ‘em.” After they quarrel, Castorley decides to write real literature and becomes a pseudoexpert on Geoffrey Chaucer; Manallace, who does have literary abilities, chooses not to pursue his talent and continues the easy path. Over an unspecified insult by Castorley to a woman for whom Manallace has been caring—typically in Kipling, much is left unsaid—Manallace vows revenge, creating a fake Chaucerian manuscript that Castorley publicly proclaims as legitimate, thus earning a knighthood. Manallace plans to reveal the fake, perhaps to the press, perhaps to Castorley himself to drive him insane, but he delays his plan as Castorley’s health begins to fail and as he is put under the care of a doctor, Gleeag, who Manallace later suspects is poisoning Castorley. Lady Castorley urges Manallace to help Castorley assemble his collected works for publication and implies
596
Short Story Writers
that she knows about the forgery; Manallace believes that she is having an affair with Gleeag, the doctor, and that she wants knowledge of the fake Chaucer manuscript to come out in hopes that the shock will kill her husband. On his deathbed, Castorley confesses his fears to Manallace: The manuscript was “too good,” and his wife has reminded him that “a man could do anything with anyone if he saved him the trouble of thinking,” which is exactly what Manallace has done with Castorley by allowinghim to validate the fake without really thinking. Castorley dies of what Gleeag, Lady Castorley’s paramour, said was “Malignant kidney-disease—generalized at the end.” Like most of Kipling’s best stories, “Dayspring Mishandled” explores the recurring themes of passion and revenge, the failure of human nature, the confusion in relationships, frustrated ambition, and the inability to see clearly, even in the understanding of oneself. It is rich in allusions and references that remain unexplained and are left for the reader to explore. Kipling’s most popular stories were the product of his early life, but some of his greatest stories—too often ignored for a time— were written toward the end. Eugene S. Larson Other major works novels: The Light That Failed, 1890; The Naulahka: A Story of East and West, 1892 (with Wolcott Balestier); Captains Courageous: A Story of the Grand Banks, 1897; Kim, 1901. miscellaneous: The Sussex Edition of the Complete Works in Prose and Verse of Rudyard Kipling, 1937-1939 (35 volumes). nonfiction: American Notes, 1891; Beast and Man in India, 1891; Letters of Marque, 1891; The Smith Administration, 1891; A Fleet in Being: Notes of Two Trips with the Channel Squadron, 1898; From Sea to Sea, 1899; Letters to the Family, 1908; The New Army in Training, 1914; France at War, 1915; The Fringes of the Fleet, 1915; Sea Warfare, 1916; Letters of Travel, 1892-1913, 1920; The Irish Guards in the Great War, 1923; A Book of Words, 1928; Something of Myself: For My Friends Known and Unknown, 1937; Uncollected Prose, 1938 (2 volumes); Rudyard Kipling to Rider Haggard: The Record of a Friendship, 1965 (Morton N. Cohen, editor); The Letters of Rudyard Kipling, 1990-2004 (6 volumes; Thomas Penney, editor); Writings on Writing, 1996 (Sandra Kemp, editor); Kipling’s America: Travel Letters, 1889-1895, 2003 (D. H. Stewart, editor). poetry: Schoolboy Lyrics, 1881; Echoes, 1884 (with Alice Kipling); Departmental Ditties, 1886; Barrack-Room Ballads, and Other Verses, 1892; The Seven Seas, 1896; An Almanac of Twelve Sports, 1898; Recessional, and Other Poems, 1899; The Five Nations, 1903; Collected Verse, 1907; A History of England, 1911 (with C. R. L. Fletcher); Songs from Books, 1912; Sea Warfare, 1916; Twenty Poems, 1918; Rudyard Kipling’s Verse, 1885-1918, 1919; The Years Between, 1919; Q. Horatii Flacci Carminum Librer Quintus, 1920 (with Charles L. Graves, A. D. Godley, A. B. Ramsay, and R. A. Knox); Songs for Youth, 1924; Sea and Sussex from Rudyard Kipling’s Verse, 1926; Rudyard Kipling’s Verse, 1886-1926, 1927; Songs of the Sea, 1927; Poems, 1886-1929, 1929; Selected Poems, 1931; Rudyard Kipling’s Verse, 1885-1932, 1933; Rudyard Kipling’s Verse, 1940 (definitive edition). Bibliography Adams, Jad. Kipling. London: Haus Books, 2005. This biography reveals Kipling’s inspiration for his poetry and portrays sides of his character that are rarely seen.
Kipling, Rudyard
597
Battles, Pau. “‘The Mark of the Beast’: Rudyard Kipling’s Apocalyptic Vision of Empire.” Studies in Short Fiction 33 (Summer, 1996): 333-344. A reading of Kipling’s story as his most powerful critique of the Empire; argues that “The Mark of the Beast” is an allegory of the relationship between the colonizer and the colonized. Bauer, Helen Pike. Rudyard Kipling: A Study of the Short Fiction. New York: Twayne, 1994. Discusses the themes of isolation, work, the Empire, childhood, the supernatural, and art in Kipling’s short stories. Includes Kipling’s comments on writing and excerpts from a formalist and a postcolonial analysis of Kipling. Coates, John. The Days’s Work: Kipling and the Idea of Sacrifice. Madison, N.J.: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1997. Explores one of Kipling’s favorite themes. Daniel, Anne Margaret. “Kipling’s Use of Verse and Prose in ‘Baa Baa, Black Sheep.’” Studies in English Literature 1500-1900 37 (Autumn, 1997): 857-875. Argues that the story relies on a literary self-consciousness to bring under artistic control the possible untruths and chaos of memory; claims that Kipling’s use of both prose and poetry creates a comfortable connection with his audience. Dillingham, William B. Rudyard Kipling: Hell and Heroism. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005. This biography offers a close look at some of Kipling’s most noted works while exploring the complexities of his personality. Gilmour, David. The Long Recessional: The Imperial Life of Rudyard Kipling. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2002. Interesting account of Kipling’s life and his complex and changing views of the British Empire, written with an awareness of the rise of terrorism emanating from the postcolonial developing world. Mallett, Phillip, ed. Kipling Considered. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1989. This collection contains essays on Plain Tales from the Hills, Stalky and Co., Kipling and Conrad, and “Mrs. Bathurst.” The most helpful for readers interested in Kipling’s short stories is Clare Hanson’s discussion of the meaning of form in Kipling’s short stories; Hanson establishes a theoretical framework for the short story as a genre and discusses Kipling’s “Mary Postgate” to illustrate her concepts. May, Charles E., ed. Masterplots II: Short Story Series, Revised Edition. 8 vols. Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Designed for student use, this reference set contains articles providing detailed plot summaries and analyses of eight short stories by Kipling: “The Gardener” (vol. 3); “Lispeth” (vol. 4); “The Man Who Would Be King” (vol. 5); “The Strange Ride of Morrowbie Jukes,” “They,” and “Thrown Away” (vol. 7); and “Wireless” and “The Wish House” (vol. 8). Orel, Harold, ed. Critical Essays on Rudyard Kipling. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1990. Sections on Kipling’s poetry, his writing on India, his work as a mature artist, his unfinished memoir, and his controversial reputation. Introduced by a distinguished critic. No bibliography. Ricketts, Harry. Rudyard Kipling: A Life. New York: Carroll & Graf, 2000. In a detailed and lively account of Kipling’s life, Ricketts also analyzes the literary works that emerged from that popular but controversial career.
598
Ring Lardner Born: Niles, Michigan; March 6, 1885 Died: East Hampton, New York; September 25, 1933 Principal short fiction • Bib Ballads, 1915; Gullible’s Travels, 1917; Treat ‘em Rough, 1918; Own Your Own Home, 1919; The Real Dope, 1919; How to Write Short Stories, 1924; The Love Nest, and Other Stories, 1926; Round Up: The Stories of Ring Lardner, 1929; Lose with a Smile, 1933; Ring Around the Bases: The Complete Baseball Stories of Ring Lardner, 1992 (Matthew J. Bruccoli, editor). Other literary forms • Ring Lardner is known chiefly as a short-story writer, but in his own time was better known as a sportswriter, columnist, and humorist. He also wrote two novel-length works, You Know Me Al (1915) and The Big Town (1921), and he tried his hand at writing musical comedies, June Moon (1929; in collaboration with George S. Kaufman) being his only successful one. Most of Lardner’s nonfictional prose remains uncollected, although a few works have appeared in book form, including an early piece about the return of the Chicago White Sox from a worldwide tour, a book of verse about successful business and professional men (Regular Fellows I Have Met, 1919), three humorous essays, “The Young Immigrunts,” “Symptoms of Being Thirty-five,” and “Say It with Oil,” and a burlesque autobiography, The Story of a Wonder Man (1927). Achievements • Ring Lardner added significantly to a tradition dating back at least as far as Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (1884). Using first-person monologue (usually humorous, always steeped in colloquialisms, occasionally in the form of correspondence), Lardner allowed his characters to reveal themselves, warts and all. As such, the superficiality and insincerity of his narrators is starkly contrasted with the often harsh truths they unintentionally reveal. This allowed Lardner to illustrate some of the less edifying aspects of American society and human nature in general. He also captured the spoken language (and slang) of ordinary people, rendering it as an art form unto itself. Thus, in addition to their entertainment value, Lardner’s stories provide a telling picture of American manners and morals during the first third or so of the twentieth century. Finally, Lardner was a pioneer in the fruitful marriage between the game of baseball and American letters, laying the foundation for later works by prominent authors such as Mark Harris (Bang the Drum Slowly, 1956), W. P. Kinsella (Shoeless Joe, 1982, filmed as Field