Sir Rudilf Peierls ???????? ??????? ??? ?????????? ?????????????? ?????
6790tp.indd 1
4/8/09 3:15:55 PM
This page i...
357 downloads
1368 Views
13MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Sir Rudilf Peierls ???????? ??????? ??? ?????????? ?????????????? ?????
6790tp.indd 1
4/8/09 3:15:55 PM
This page intentionally left blank
Sir Rudilf Peierls Selected Private and Scientific Correspondence Vol.2
Sabine Lee University of Birmingham, UK
World Scientific NEW JERSEY . LONDON. SINGAPORE . BEIJING . SHANGHAI . HONG KONG . TAIPEI . CHENNAI
6790tp.indd 2
4/8/09 3:15:56 PM
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
SIR RUDOLF PEIERLS Selected Private and Scientific Correspondence Volume 2 Copyright © 2009 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN-13 978-981-279-706-3 ISBN-10 981-279-706-8
Printed in Singapore.
Kim - Sir Rudopf Peierls (V2).pmd
1
3/24/2009, 1:46 PM
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
v
Contents
Acknowledgements
vii
Editorial Comments
xi
6. Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
1
7. Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
284
8. 1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
437
9. 1963–1974: Oxford
679
10. 1974–1986: Retirement — Two Birds of Passage
754
11. 1986–1995: The Tree Needs to Grow New Rings
922
Bibliography
1064
Archival Sources
1065
List of Correspondence
1067
Name Index
1089
This page intentionally left blank
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
vii
Acknowledgements
In October 2004 the Institute of Theoretical Physics at Oxford was formally named the Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics. The occasion was memorable for the impressive line-up of guests who had come from all over the world for the ceremony. It was also memorable for the personal account of Rudolf Peierls’ youngest daughter, Jo Hookway, who gave an insight into life in the Peierls household and beyond. In talking about her father, she said: I feel an overwhelming sense of pride and responsibility in being here today and this is for a number of reasons. Firstly a pride in my father and all he achieved and stood for. Secondly there is the pride, coupled with responsibility, of being here representing the Peierls family. This task is also a huge one because of the size of the family — obviously I am here as part of the Peierls nuclear family. But the Peierls family is so much larger than this — its membership is worldwide and is probably of indefinable boundaries as it contains not only everyone who ever was a member of my father’s department, but also all their partners, children, grandchildren and so on. As Jo continued to explain, she may not have understood, what being a theoretical physicist meant, or what the squiggles produced by her father on backs of envelopes and on blackboards signified; but what she did know and understand was that her father, with the considerable support of his wife, was building a community of people in his department: the extended Peierls family. Volume II of the Peierls Correspondence bears witness to this very special extended family. Correspondence of work-related and personal matters intermingle, and the strong sense of camaraderie among the
April 7, 2009
viii
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
members of Peierls’ department and their families is clearly visible throughout. Most of the letters reproduced in this second volume of the Selected Correspondence of Rudolf Peierls were part of the collection that Rudolf Peierls passed on to the Contemporary Scientific Archives Centre in two instalments in the mid 1970s and mid 1990s. They were catalogued and duly deposited at the Department of Western Manuscripts of the Bodleian Library, Oxford where they are now held. I am grateful to Colin Harris and his colleagues in the Western Manuscript Department for all their support and advice, which greatly facilitated the completion of the project. Some of the letters exchanged between Rudolf Peierls and his family remain in family possession, as do many of the photos. These are reproduced here with kind permission of the Peierls family. Other material was collected from the Library of Congress (Papers of J. Robert Oppenheimer), the Pauli Archive at CERN, the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library (Bethe Papers), the Churchill Archives Centre, Cambridge (Chadwick Papers, Dirac Papers), the National Archives, Public Record Office, London, and the Niels Bohr Library of the AIP Center for History of Physics. In all these archives and many other libraries I have received valuable assistance in assembling this collection and researching the historical background of the material and the work described therein. Material authored by Rudolf and Genia Peierls is reproduced by permission of the Peierls family; letters written by James Chadwick are reproduced by kind permission of the Master and Fellows of Churchill College; letters authored by Wolfgang Pauli are reproduced with permission of the Pauli Archive, CERN; letters written by Niels Bohr are reproduced with permission of the Niels Bohr Archive, Copenhagen. Some of the letters reproduced in this volume have previously been published. This applies to some of the letters exchanged with Wolfgang Pauli,a and Niels Bohr.b a Karl von Meyenn (ed.), Wolfgang Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel mit Bohr, Einstein, Heisenberg u.a, Vol. 3: 1940–1949, Vol. 4: 1950–1956, Berlin/ Heidelberg/New York: Springer, 1993ff. b Peierls, R. E. (ed.), Niels Bohr Collected Works, Vol. 9: Nuclear Physics (1929– 1952), North-Holland: Amsterdam, 1985.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Acknowledgements
peierlsroot2
ix
Among other copyright holders who have kindly granted permission to reproduce letters in this collection are: Mrs. Rose Bethe; Prof. Jochen H. Heisenberg; Dr. I. Landau; Dr. Olga Cherneva; Frau Monika Baier; Mrs. A.F. Crampin; Prof. Gustav Born; Christian Suter; F. Anthony Placzek; the Fowler family; Mrs. Jane Gatrell; Dr. Susan K. Martin; Mrs. K.D. Baxandall; A. and J.L.J. Rosenfeld; Ida Nicolaisen and Josh Pais; Jae Riebe; Gerald E. Brown; Ursula Frisch; Ed Salpeter, Prof. Emeritus, Cornell University; the British Pugwash Group, Ilse Thorner; the family of Robert S. Aitken, Denys Wilkinson, Roger H. Stuewer, Prof. Brian Pippard. Research for this project, in particular archival work in Russia and the United States, has been supported by the British Academy and the Royal Society. The work was facilitated by a term’s research leave from the University of Birmingham and an AHRB grant which permitted the extension of this leave by a further term. My thanks go to the entire Peierls family, and in particular to Jo Hookway who has supported this project with enthusiasm, insider knowledge and much common sense. She greatly facilitated access to material which had not been archived and is still in family possession, she read and commented on parts of the book, and gave useful insights into many aspects of the Peierls family life which would have been difficult, if not impossible, to gain in any other way. Other family members offered helpful insights and constructive criticism and they provided most of the photos reproduced in this volume. When I embarked on this two-volume edition of a selection of Rudolf Peierls’ Correspondence, I had little idea about the magnitude of the enterprise. I have been living with this exciting project for over a decade. So has my family. My husband, a theoretical physicist himself, knows that he only has himself to blame for introducing me to the work of Rudolf Peierls when we were both final-year Ph.D. students at Cambridge. Our children, however, who had little choice in the matter, have been living with the project tolerantly. Without my family’s encouragement, understanding and patience, this edition would not have come to fruition. Thanks! Birmingham, 2008
Sabine Lee
This page intentionally left blank
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
xi
Editorial Comments
The introduction to volume 1a explains the background, provenance of and selection criteria for the material reproduced in the Selected Correspondence. For easy reference, below the main editorial principles followed in this volume, have been relisted. 1. The letters are listed chronologically, and, unless stated otherwise, reproduced in toto. 2. The transcription is limited to the text content, not to layout or graphic details. 3. Typos and misplaced letter sequences are corrected.b 4. The letters reproduced in this collection are held in the Bodleian Library,c the Library of Congress (Papers of J. Robert Oppenheimer), the Pauli Archive at CERN (Pauli Letters), the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library (Bethe Papers), the Churchill Archives Centre, Cambridge (Chadwick Papers, Dirac Papers), and the National Archives, Public Record Office, London. Often Rudolf Peierls and his colleagues kept carbon copies of typed letters, and therefore both original letter and carbon copy survive. Unless otherwise stated, the letters reproduced here are the originals; however, to clarify, a list in a
S. Lee, Sir Rudolf Peierls. Selected and Private Correspondence, Vol. 1, Singapore: World Scientific, 2007, pp. 1–11. b This applies in particular for correspondence in the late 1980s and 1990s. As a result of failing eyesight in later life, many of Rudolf Peierls’ word-processed letters written in those years contain a large number of typographical errors which have been corrected. c Sir Rudolf Peierls, Papers and Correspondence, 1898–1996; CSAS catalogue no 52/6/77 and NCUSACS supplementary catalogue 57/6/96.
April 7, 2009
12:11
xii
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the appendix specifies whether the text used in the edition is an original or a carbon copy. 5. Handwritten additions, where included, are identified as such. 6. Editorial additions are made in square brackets. 7. Text which was deleted in the manuscript is not transcribed. 8. The reproduced material makes no distinction between single and multiple underlining. 9. Gaps arising from punching or filing are filled and only noted in square brackets, if there are doubts. Abbreviations are only completed where necessary. 10. Illegible words are noted as [??], with [?] for one word, [??] for two words and [???] for three or more words. 11. Handwritten additions missing from the typed text of a carbon copies are noted as [...] and are identified as missing text in an editorial note. 12. Footnotes in the text are marked with asterisk and added at the end of the page on which they occur. Editorial notes appear at the bottom of the page. 13. Repeated words at the page break are transcribed as one word.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1
6.
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
“My God, what have we done?” Reportedly, these were the words of Robert Lewis, the co-pilot of Enola Grey, the B-29 that dropped the first atomic bomb on Hiroshima on 6th August 1945. The scientists who had spent the previous years developing the atomic bomb, knew about its fatal effects. Those who had witnessed the Trinity Tests, the explosion of the first atomic bomb in the New Mexican desert had been in awe. Robert Oppenheimer, the scientific head of the mission, not only remarked that scientists knew that the world would no longer be the same, he also famously commented the event with a passage from the Bhagavad Gita: “· · · now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds · · · ”. Despite the destructiveness of the weapon which had been built, despite the horror caused by its use on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and despite the deep concern over the destructive power among the scientists who had created the bomb, their scientific and technological achievements are without question. General Groves, who would later be at pains to minimise the contributions of the British contingent at Los Alamos was one of the first to congratulate James Chadwick, the head of the British Mission, on the success of the joint project.1 Most members of this British contingent at Los Alamos, who had been instrumental in the Manhattan Project at the level of research and development, returned to the UK at the end of the hostilities in the Pacific. For them the subsequent years were dominated by the key issues of resettling into peacetime academia and of dealing with the consequences of their war-time research. Most chose to return to Higher Education and help 1
Letter [380].
April 7, 2009
12:11
2
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
build or rebuild the academic landscape in the UK. While this was true to a greater or lesser extent for virtually all academics who had been involved in the war effort away from their home institutions, for those nuclear scientists who returned from the Manhattan Project, this task had qualities which differed significantly from that of their colleagues. The production effort of nuclear weapons had moved forward nuclear physics and chemistry in a way that would have been impossible without this wartime enterprise, and this in itself altered the scientists’ outlook.2 But the success of the Project also had momentous repercussions of political and psychological nature. The Manhattan Project, epitomised by the joint leadership of the military (General Leslie Groves) and the scientist (Robert Oppenheimer) had brought together politics/warfare and science in a way that had been unknown before. From now on, spheres of influence had to be determined, territory defended and scientists had to face the huge political, military and humanitarian consequences that their scientific discoveries had had and would continue to have at much closer range than ever before. It is not surprising, therefore, that after 1945 many of those leading scientists became involved in efforts to control nuclear weapons. They set up their own national scientists’ organisations such as the American Federation of Scientists in the US3 or the Committee of Atomic Scientists, later called the British Association of Atomic Scientists in the UK.4 Beyond the non-governmental realm of these organisations, scientists also became increasingly involved in consulting governments on nuclear issues, both on questions of weapons development and nuclear energy and on issues of the control of these weapons. In the UK, a further issue arose largely out of the changing nature of the Anglo-American relationship, namely how to develop one’s own nuclear programme in response to American attempts to monopolise the production of nuclear power. At Los Alamos, (and at the other research centres of the Manhattan Project) science had been truly international — within the confines of a wartime enterprise under the 2
See letters [381], [384], [386], [390–391], [394]. Letter [390]. 4 Letters [395], [413–414], [418–19]. 3
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
3
military command of General Leslie Groves. Hence, it is not possible to quantify precisely the achievements of what became known as the British mission to Los Alamos. Their number never exceeded more than about twenty-five (even counting the ‘consultants’) which was negligible in comparison with thousands of workers at Los Alamos at the peak of activities. During the war, General Groves commented that British research was ‘substantial’ and that the British scientists made an ‘invaluable’ contribution to the American project. Yet, after the war, he claimed that while the quality of the work of the British team was high, their number was far too small to have had a significant impact, a reasoning which was adopted by American policy makers who were soon to engage in a more restrictive policy of nuclear sharing. Others disagreed and argued that the British contribution to the project went far beyond what a mere head count would suggest and was out of all proportion to the team’s size. American accounts of the Los Alamos years dominated the early historiography of developments on the Hill, just as American economic and military power dominated international relations after the end of the war. Throughout the war, nuclear co-operation and/or lack of it had followed a very similar pattern to the general development of AngloAmerican relations more generally, with strategic, psychological, economic and political considerations and suspicions playing a crucial part in the formulation of policies. The British government clearly expected wartime nuclear collaboration to be continued after the end of the war. Prime Minister Attlee, in a letter to President Truman in early August 1945, proposed a ‘joint declaration of our intentions to utilise the existence of this great power not for our own ends, but as trustees for humanity in the interest of all peoples in order to promote peace and justice in the world.’5 But the Americans had rather different ideas. Some, especially in the military, intended to build on what they perceived to be a five-year technological lead by accelerating nuclear research in national (and secret) projects, while at the same time controlling uranium supplies. This would allow the Americans to accumulate a stockpile of 5
Attlee to Truman, 8.8.1945, Foreign Relations of the United States, 1945, pp. 36–7.
April 7, 2009
4
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
weapons and to extend their strategic advantage.6 Others envisaged closer co-operation with the Soviet Union (at the expense of the United Kingdom) in order to avoid a nuclear arms race.7 Others were contemplating some form of co-operation with the British (and Canadians) while expressing doubts about collaboration with the Soviet Union. The terms of the Quebec Agreements of August 1943, the AngloAmerican Declaration of Trust of June 1944 and the Hyde Park aidememoir of September 1944, had led the British to expect a continuation of nuclear collaboration ‘after the defeat of Japan unless terminated by joint agreement’.8 This was not forthcoming. Within less than a year, the approach of substantial technology and scientific transfer had been replaced by a more restrictive American policy of the Atomic Energy Act, the so-called McMahon Act, of August 1946 which prevented the transfer of information about technical processes and ‘restricted data’, such as the production of fissionable material to other nations. The correspondence between Rudolf Peierls and James Chadwick, who continued to act as technical adviser and head of the British Mission until his return to the UK in late 1946, give some indication of the underlying tension.9 Moreover, they touched on the implications of the McMahon Act for the future of British nuclear ambitions. On an immediate practical level the McMahon Act meant that the British scientists, some of whom had remained at Los Alamos beyond August 1945, were no longer allowed access to documentation and reports which they had been able to utilise without restrictions before. More significantly in the medium and long term it meant that the British were forced to (or felt forced to) develop nuclear weapons independently, because they were no longer allowed to benefit from the scientific collaboration within 6 Timothy J. Botti, The Long Wait. The Forging of the Anglo-American Nuclear Alliance, 1945–1958, New York: Greenwood Press, 1987, p. 9 7 Henry Stimson to Harry S. Truman, accompanied by a memorandum, September 11, 1945, Washington, 11.9.1945, Foreign Relations of the United States, 1945, pp. 41ff. 8 Anglo-American Declaration of Trust, 13.6.1944, www.nuclearfiles.org/ redocuments/1944/440613-anglo-amer-decl.html; Hyde Park Agreement, Foreign Relations of the United States, 1944, Vol. 2, Washington D.C., 1967, pp. 1026–28. 9 Letters [395], [402], [414], [416].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
5
the gigantic American enterprise. And indeed, a decision as taken by a handful of people without full Cabinet consultation in January 1947 to develop nuclear weapons. It was a sensitive area of public policy, and the programme was not officially communicated to the public until five years later, when the then Prime Minister Winston Churchill, in February 1952, announced plans for testing the first British-built nuclear weapons. The exchange of letters between Rudolf Peierls and G.P.Thomson indicates that fundamental and applied research in nuclear physics was continuing at British universities, and that Rudolf Peierls’ expertise was sought on these issues.10 But Peierls was also concerned about progress of the new Atomic Energy Research Establishment(AERE) at Harwell, where the Ministry of Supply had taken over an RAF airfield for the purpose of providing the infrastructure for the research and development of civil nuclear power. To direct the British effort, Air Marshal Viscount Portal of Hungerford was made Controller of Production, Atomic Energy; John Cockroft became director of the Atomic Energy Research Establishment, and Christopher Hinton, a senior ICI engineer, became the leader of the fissile material production programme.11 At that stage, no decision on nuclear weapons development had been made, but in January 1946, already, William Penney had been put in charge of Armament Research, an appointment which suggested that the British Government was seriously considering the option of an independent development of a nuclear arsenal. In June 1947 Penney was chosen to lead Britain’s nuclear weapons program, although this decision was not made public until much later. Secrecy surrounded the early stages of the project, with the press being discouraged to visit Harwell, and with public and political debates about atomic energy suppressed. As one MP put it during a parliamentary debate: ‘When an Hon. Member asks the Prime Minister about the atomic bomb, he looks at him as if he had been asked something indecent.’12 And even when one of the senior members of the AERE, the head of the Theoretical Physics Division 10
Letters [393–394], [397], [400]. See letters [402], [427]. 12 Hansard, House of Commons Debates 1948, Col. 574 (4 March 1948). 11
April 7, 2009
12:11
6
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
at Harwell, Klaus Fuchs, was arrested in early February 1950, charged with violation of the Official Secrets Act, little official comments were passed on the work carried out at Harwell. The arrest of Klaus Fuchs was a severe blow to the British scientific community as a whole, and it was a particular blow to Rudolf Peierls and his family personally.13 Klaus Fuchs, who had worked on Tube Alloys, the British atomic bomb research project, had been transferred alongside Peierls to New York and later to Los Alamos to work on the Manhattan Project. During his work on the British and AngloAmerican atomic weapons projects he supplied the Soviet Union with valuable information about those, and he continued to do so after his return to England in 1946 when he joined the AERE at Harwell. In the late 1940s, as a result of the successful deciphering of the Venona transcripts, incepted messages that had been sent between several Soviet intelligence agencies, a leak of atomic secrets to the Soviets was identified as leading to the British Mission at Los Alamos, and eventually Klaus Fuchs was isolated as the key suspect. Under interrogation from MI5, he confessed, in January 1950, to having broken the Official Secrets Act by passing on classified information to the Soviets. On the basis of this confession, he was convicted to 14 years in prison in March 1950.14 Klaus Fuchs had been a close friend of Rudolf and Genia Peierls’, he had lodged with them when he first came to Birmingham, and he had collaborated closely with Rudolf Peierls who had not only hired him into his department at Birmingham but had also been instrumental in securing his appointment at Los Alamos. Much of the correspondence in early 1950 reflects this. The letters exchanged with friends an colleagues are part of the attempt to come to terms with the personal disappointment as well as an endeavour to limit the damage done to the scientific communities in the UK and the US.15 13
Letter [493]. Fuchs was released early after serving a little more than nine years of his sentence. After his release he returned to his native East Germany where he continued his scientific career, being elected to the Academy of Science and the Communist Party central committee. Eventually he became deputy director of the Institute for Nuclear Research in Rosendorf, from where he retired in 1979. 15 Letters [495–497], item [500]. 14
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
7
The Fuchs trial was interesting in what it revealed as much as in what it concealed. Many aspects of the case were kept from the public in order to cover important political secrets. A number of people in the highest echelons of British secret intelligence had a distinct interest in ensuring that the Fuchs case would not lead to further disclosures. They and the British Government did not want details of Fuchs’ work at Harwell publicised, as he was involved in the then still secret British atomic weapons programme. In Britain, the case vanished from the public view within days of the verdict without Fuchs’ spy contacts in Britain ever being apprehended fully. British anger over Fuchs dissipated very quickly. The initial public outrage and the discussion in the press about the wisdom of accepting political and religious refugees and employing them in sensitive fields soon subsided. It never escalated into the Mccarthyism of the US, which was shaken by espionage cases in the aftermath of Fuchs’ exposure, when the Rosenbergs, Harry Gold, and the Greenglasses were exposed. One of the victims of the widespread anti-communism, often culminating in political hysteria, was Robert Oppenheimer.16 Rudolf Peierls never shied away from expressing his views in public. He did so regardless of the effect this would have on is own position. He would later support Oppenheimer openly as well as privately,17 just as he defended civil liberties in the aftermath of the Fuchs affair in his memorandum ‘Lesson of the Fuchs Case’.18 He was never secretive about his friendships with people from communist countries and of communist persuasion, he argued for the re-establishment of scientific exchange with the Soviet Union and its satellites. He rejected the idea of oppressing the voices of dissenters by arguing that this totalitarian measure would bring security at the expense of values that any democracy had to fight to retain. In the aftermath of the Fuchs arrest, Peierls’ overt expression of these views led some to question his reliability, especially in view of the fact that he had access to sensitive and secret information in connection with the UK nuclear programme.19 16
See below, pp. 442–43. See e.g. letters [597], [601]. 18 Item [500]. 19 Letter [525]. 17
April 7, 2009
12:11
8
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
However, at that time, as on many other occasions during the subsequent decades, it was recognised by people in authority that the views may have been uncomfortable at times, but at no point did they undermine the security and values of democracy in the UK, and at all times did Peierls prove loyal to the UK national interest.20 Another issue on which Rudolf Peierls expressed his views clearly and encouraged others to do likewise was the question of how to deal with defeated Germany and the German scientists in particular. The questions engaged the thoughts of many British scientists, and even more so many German-born British scientist many of whom, due to their Jewish origin, had been forced to leave Germany under National Socialism. In early 1948 Peierls circulated a memorandum,21 which was widely discussed as a string of conferences in the UK required the scientists to clarify their position with regard to the invitation of German colleagues,22 the organisation of social, non-scientific contacts, and decisions on foreign membership of learned societies, such as the Royal Society which conferred membership to distinguished foreign scientists.23 Beyond the attempts of dealing with the legacy of the weapons development, many scientists, especially in the early post-war years, were also concerned with rebuilding the international science community. The totalitarian regimes in Europe had led to a massive displacement of scientists, as had the war itself. Many who had been forced to leave their home countries in the 1930s and early 1940s, had no desire to return and were looking positions in their adopted homes, mostly in the UK and the US.24 Given the shortage of highly trained scientific staff in UK academia, many such positions could be found. Conversely, filling Chairs even at prestigious British universities often proved difficult.25 Rudolf Peierls, throughout the post-war era, received numerous offers to take up such positions, including Chairs at Oxford, Manchester and 20
See below chapter 10, pp. 756–57. Item [440]. 22 Letters [404–406]. 23 Letters [442–443], [445], [447], [458–461]. 24 See e.g. communications with G. Wick, letters [382], [385], [387]. 25 See letters [388], [390], [415]. 21
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
9
London. He considered few of these seriously, but the offer to take up the Plummer Chair at Cambridge was an offer which he thought about very thoroughly, and about which he consulted several close colleagues.26 The correspondence in this context indicates some important aspects which help to explain his loyalty to Birmingham, but also his clear ideas of what he regarded as important for a prosperous theoretical physics community in the UK:27 a balanced flexible system that provides good training and high standards without prejudicing against students outside Oxbridge. Beyond the question of securing academic leadership within the UK, there was also the issue of retaining Britain’s standing as a recognised centre of research excellence. Rudolf Peierls had come to Birmingham in 1937 as the first professor of Mathematical Physics and had set himself the task of establishing a school devoted to both first-class research and first-class teaching. The war had put the effort on hold, but as soon as Peierls returned to Birmingham, he re-engaged in the process and, virtually from scratch, he developed a school of mathematical physics, or theoretical physics as it would be called later, which was arguably the best in the country and which could compete with any in Europe and with most others globally. His correspondence during the first post-war decade gives some clues as to why he succeeded where many others failed. • Peierls regarded teaching as his main responsibility.28 While he enjoyed his research and recognised its importance as a contribution to a discipline which was undergoing exciting developments, increasingly this research was being done in collaboration with research students and younger research staff and thereby became virtually indistinguishable from teaching. • His enthusiasm for teaching and building up a viable team found expression in time and energy devoted to securing funding for young scholars and finding the best possible people to carry out the 26
Letters [383–384]. See in particular letter [384]. 28 R.E. Peierls, Bird of Passage. Recollections of a Physicist, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1985 (cited hereinafter as Peierls, Bird of Passage), pp. 249 ff. 27
April 7, 2009
12:11
10
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
increasingly complex research.29 Within a few years, he had built a reputation for his institute, of being an ideal training ground — a reputation which helped achieving both the above aims; but it also enabled Peierls to work within a group of a critical mass which would always be certain of being supplied with the best of talent from within Britain and from abroad. • Peierls’ commitment to his students and research fellows did not end with the completion of their period at Birmingham. Much thought and letter writing went into the task of securing future positions and exchange opportunities. In this, the prospects of the individual scientist was as important as the future of his own institute at Birmingham. • Collaboration with the US throughout the war and close contact with many friends and colleagues across the Atlantic, had sharpened Rudolf Peierls’ awareness of the role reversal which had occured with regard to academic physics. As early as September 1945, he expressed, in a letter to Raymond Priestley, the Vice Chancellor of Birmingham University, that ‘American universities [had] matured a great deal and contact with this country [was] now less important to them, and more important to us’.30 The consequence of this, in Peierls’ view, had to be regular academic exchanges which would allow the UK to benefit from scientific achievements of colleagues in the US. And his attempts to put Birmingham firmly on the academic map in theoretical physics meant that he was keen to secure a sizeable fraction of the exchange for this institution. • A supplementary ingredient which could not be found in any other institute was what some would later term the ‘Genia-factor’. Genia Peierls was an enthusiastic supporter of her husband’s endeavours to attract the best young scientists to Birmingham, a place which — with post-war rationing, shortage of housing and 29 30
Letters [389], [403]. Letter [381].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
11
generally meagre facilities was not the most appealing location. Her hands-on efforts which ranged from provision of short-and long-term accommodation to general advice, from organising social gatherings to job-advice for spouse and general counselling, had a significant impact on the cohesion of the growing ‘Peierls school’.31 • Peierls himself had studied in an environment which had encouraged travel and intense exchange of research ideas through students moving from research centre to research centre and of course, through scientific meetings and conferences. Convinced about the stimulation brought about by this exchange of knowledge, he organised two international conferences at Cambridge, in 1948 and 1953. These and the regular seminar programmes organinsed in the department attracted some of the leading figures of the national and international physics communities, including Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, Mott, Born, Lise Meitner, Frisch, Oppenheimer, Bethe, and many others.32 That a professor would take his teaching and administrative duties seriously was not in itself something that set Rudolf Peierls apart from many of his contemporaries. But he was quite prepared to make personal sacrifices and put departmental interest before his own. One such example was his reaction to Robert Oppenheimer’s invitation to spend the academic year 1951/2 at Princeton. The offer was very appealing, not only because of Peierls’ friendship with Oppenheimer and the prospect of a year’s research largely uninterrupted by administrative chores and teaching commitments. Princeton, at the time, was buzzing with activity in the wake of recent developments in field theory in which Peierls himself was very interested. Nevertheless, he informed Oppenheimer that he could only spend one term at the Institute, because he felt responsible for a large number of new research students and considered it necessary to take his share of administrative responsibility 31
See Genia Peierls. Reminiscences collected on the occasion of Genia Peierls’ 70th birthday, July 1978., copy in Peierls Papers, Supp. A.119. 32 See e.g. letters [445], [447], [451], [456], [474–476].
April 7, 2009
12:11
12
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
at Birmingham for the first half of the academic year in question.33 The war had interrupted some of Peierls’ research, most notably the famous Bohr-Placzek Peierls paper.34 The three scientists picked up the threads in 1945 and communicated extensively about the manuscript.35 The paper remained unpublished at the time, although the results were written up in a manuscript which several decades later was published in Bohr’s Collected Works.36 Peierls’ closest friend from his student days in Munich, Hans Bethe, had moved to Cornell in 1935. At Los Alamos, the two scientists again had the opportunity to work together closely with Hans Bethe as the Head of the Theoretical Physics Division and Rudolf Peierls in charge of the hydrodynamics group. After the end of the war, the two friends, again, parted to take up their roles as leading theoretical physicists in their respective adopted home countries, the US and the UK. Over the subsequent decades, they remained in close contact through correspondence, academic and social exchanges and, equally significantly, through establishing a network of research collaboration of their students and junior colleagues.37 Most influential among these was the recommendation of Hans Bethe to Freeman Dyson, in early 1949, to spend some time at Peierls’ institute.38 The fellowship arranged between Rudolf Peierls and Robert Oppenheimer, at the time director of the Institute of Advanced Studies at Princeton, where Dyson, the rising star of theoretical physics was based, demonstrates two points very clearly. Firstly, Peierls was excellent at spotting talent, and secondly he was flexible enough to make Birmingham an attractive option for your scholars to choose his institute despite stiff competition from 33
Letter [524]. S. Lee (ed.), Sir Rudolf Peierls. Selected Private and Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, Singapore: World Scientific, 2007 (cited hereinafter as Lee, Selected Correspondence, Vol. 1), Chapter 4, pp. 522–524. 35 Letters [392], [417], [421], [435], [444], [485–486], [490]. 36 R.E. Peierls (ed.), Niels Bohr. Collected Works, Vol. 9 Nuclear Physics (1929– 1952), Amsterdam: North Holland, 1986, pp. 505–519. 37 Letters [396], [401], [412], [424], [426], [428–430], [432], [434], [436], [438], [448], [453–455], [457], [465]. 38 Letters [468–470], [473]. 34
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
13
Cambridge, Oxford, Liverpool, Manchester, Bristol and other universities.39 Dyson was based at Birmingham, but it was agreed that he was at liberty to spend time at Princeton regularly, as long as it fitted in with departmental requirements at Birmingham.40 This resulted in Birmingham being in direct contact with the development of quantum field theory, which at the time was worked on by Schwinger, Tomonaga, Feynman and Dyson.41 Others similarly made the journey across the Atlantic, and the exchange went both ways with, among others, Byers, Lieb, Langer, Brown, Dalitz, Salpeter, Claude Bloch and Stanley Mandelstam moving between the US and Birmingham. Another example of Peierls spotting talent and being slightly unconventional in securing it for Birmingham was Gerry Brown. A native of South Dakota, Brown had studied at Wisconsin and Yale, where he obtained an M.S. and a Ph.D. His short-lived membership of the Communist Party, from which he was eventually expelled, put his academic career in the US at risk despite his outstanding doctoral work with Gregory Breit. Various enquiries to universities in England led to the by now famous three-penny folded airmail return from Rudi Peierls saying: ‘Come ahead.’42 In February 1950 Gerry Brown arrived as a political refugee from pre-McCarthy anti-communist America; in 1960 he left to take up his appointment as full professor of Theoretical Physics at Niels Bohr’s Nordic Institute for Theoretical Physics (NORDITA). While not many of Peierls’ students arrived as refugees in the same way as Gerry Brown did, many left into distinguished positions, and a significant number eventually ended up filling the Chairs of the most prestigious European, American, Asian and Australian Universities. Peierls’ correspondence throughout the 1950s demonstrates the paths of some of these talented young men and women.
39
See also letter [484]. Letters [477], [479]. 41 Letters [507–508], [510], [513–514], [518]. 42 G.E. Brown, ‘Flying with Eagles’, Annu. Rev. Part. Sci. 51, 1–22 (2002), here, p. 6. 40
April 7, 2009
14
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[380] L.R. Groves to James Chadwick Washington, 10.8.1945 Dear Sir James, I have received your nice letter of August 9 and I wish to convey through you to all members of the T.A. Directorate my sincere and heartfelt appreciation of their congratulatory message and for their own great contributions to the success of our project. Sincerely yours, L.R. Groves
[381] Rudolf Peierls to Raymond Priestley [location unspecified], 13.9.1945 (carbon copy) Dear Vice-Chancellor, As I mentioned to you the other day, I believe that the universities in this country can gain a great deal by an arrangement that will make it possible for visitors from abroad, in particular from the United States, to spend short periods ranging from one month to one year according to circumstances, at British universities. Such men could have a very welcome stimulating influence particularly in subjects in which at the moment, owing to better equipment and greater manpower, the United States are leading. In addition to the actual benefit derived from such visits, there would be the possibility that some of these men might like the life here, and might make themselves popular with their colleagues here so that they could be induced to accept permanent jobs, and thus help to alleviate the great manpower shortage that now exists among scientists of high standing. After the last war this type of exchange was largely helped by Fellowships awarded by the Rockefeller Foundation, the Guggenheim Foundation, and similar bodies, most of whom I think have ceased to award such Fellowships, or have restricted them to special subjects (Rockefeller
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
15
Fellowships are now only available to men working in medical science and allied subjects). I do not believe we can expect the Americans to provide new funds for this purpose, largely because American universities have matured a great deal and contact with this country is now less important to them, and more important to us, than in the past. I believe, therefore, that this country could try to provide funds for this purpose. This might either be done by individual universities, or by a national organisation for all universities, and the latter would probably make administration somewhat easier. In many cases such visitors could be given existing jobs, in particular Research Fellowships would appear very suitable; at a time when our own training of young scientists has been held up to a degree which will make it impossible to fill all these Fellowships immediately. In that case the Fund I am suggesting would merely have to provide travel expenses; which I believe should be on a generous scale, and shall allow senior people to come for extended periods and to bring their families; and it should also provide some subsistence allowance to take care of the fact that these people cannot bring their own furniture, and are not familiar with conditions in this country, so that they will not be able to live as economically as people who are at home here. In the long run it may be undesirable to take up existing Research Fellowships in this way, and it would then be preferable to have the central fund responsible for both travelling expenses and living costs. I believe most of my colleagues will agree that such a scheme would be of greatest importance to British universities, and I am sure that, in my own subject in particular, it would make an enormous difference. I know that there are many Americans in my subjects. However, this scheme should not start immediately but, say, in a year’s time, when we have overcome the immediate administrative difficulties which will result from converting the universities to a peace-time basis. [R.E. Peierls]
April 7, 2009
12:11
16
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[382] Gian Carlo Wick43 to Rudolf Peierls Rome, 14.9.1945 Dear Peierls, It is a long time now that I gave a friend who was coming to London your address, begging him to enquire about you. But without result. Now I venture to write to you directly, hoping to find you still in your old place. There is not much use now writing about the past years; perhaps we shall talk about our experiences one day. I sincerely hope that you and your family have gone through these hard times unhurt. I, for my part, have been in Rome most of the time. Fortunately I was not called up — except for twenty days in the summer 1943 — and I was not asked to do any war work. If I had, I hope I would have had the courage to refuse, but it would not have been pleasant! Now I am rather anxious to get back to work, after a month of rest in a small village on the hills. We have received, only now, the Physical Review.∗ Although scientific production has been slowed down by the war, still four years of Phys. Rev. make a lot of reading! It will take much work to get up to date again. You would help me a lot with a hint or two. 1) I have received from Schr¨ odinger several reprints on a new unitary theory which seems to explain a lot of things.44 I am ∗ But
not the Proceedings R.S., not the P. Cambr., nor Nature. These will be very hard to get, we are told! 43
Gian Carlo Wick (1909–1992) a native Italian studied at Turin and later worked at Leipzig and G¨ ottingen before returning to Italy, eventually working under Fermi, before becoming professor at Palermo and then Padova. 44 Throughout the war, Erwin Schr¨ odinger published a large number of papers, primarily in the Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy on a variety of subjects. Most notably, in 1943 he published E. Schr¨ odinger, ‘The General Unitary Theory of the Physical Fields’, Proc. Roy. Ir. Ac. 49A, 43–58 (1943) and in the following year E. Schr¨ odinger, ‘The Point Charge in the Unitary Field Theory’, Proc. Roy. Ir. Ac. 49A, 225–35 (1944); E. Schr¨ odinger, ‘Unitary Field Theory: Conservation Identities and Relation to Weyl and Eddington’, Proc. Roy. Ir. Ac. 49A, 237–44 (1944) and E. Schr¨ odinger, ‘The Union of the Three Fundamental Fields (Gravitation, Meson, Electromagnetism)’, Proc. Roy. Ir. Ac. 49A, 275–87 (1943).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
17
very intrigued and I would study this theory carefully if I were not engaged in a number of complicated papers on nuclear forces, strong interactions and so on. I have never bothered very much about unitary theories. What is the general opinion about this particular one? 2) Has non-linear electrodynamics made any important advance? 3) Has the theory of nuclear reactions made any important advance? I am specially interested in this, as I am writing a book with Amaldi;45 I have left aside until now the chapter on the theory of resonance phenomena and so on; I expected that the paper by you, Bohr and Placzek would oblige me to change much of what I might have written. Has the paper ever appeared? Will it ever appear? Which subjects would be especially affected by it? I should be very indebted to you, if you were so kind to answer, even very briefly, to these questions. Have you heard of Amaldi’s experiments on neutron scattering? They seem quite interesting. With kindest regards, also to Mrs. Peierls, Yours truly Gian Carlo Wick
[383] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft Washington, 13.12.1945 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, I have just received an offer of the vacant chair in Cambridge. I find it extremely difficult to make up my mind. I am tempted by the better supply of students in Cambridge, but doubtful about the chances of having contact with a strong experimental nuclear physics team in Cambridge. This depends on a number of factors, in particular on who is likely to be your successor in the Jacksonian Chair.46 45
The book does not appear to have materialised. John Cockroft had held the Jacksonian Chair since 1939 but was leaving Cambridge to become the first director of the Atomic Energy Research Establishment at Harwell in 1946. In 1947 Otto Frisch accepted the Jacksonian Chair. See letters [415] and [428]. 46
April 7, 2009
18
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
If you have any information about what is likely to happen there, or know anything more generally about the future of fundamental physics in Cambridge, I would be very grateful for your advice. I am planning to go to Washington to see Chadwick and shall probably be there on December 19 and 20. If you plan to be in Washington at the same time, do not bother to reply. Otherwise, would you be good enough to send a copy of your reply to Washington for me. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
[384] Rudolf Peierls to Raymond Priestley [location unspecified], 13.12.1945 (carbon copy) Dear Priestley: After having successfully disposed of an invitation from Oxford and one from Manchester, I have now received an offer of the Plummer Chair in Cambridge. As you can imagine, I find it somewhat harder to make up my mind on this. My personal preference is strongly on remaining in Birmingham. I have enjoyed the work in the University. I am looking forward to the collaboration with Oliphant on his new plans, and I like the Administrative machinery of a modern university which in Birmingham seems to run particularly efficiently and smoothly. I feel I should not decide on personal preference alone, but the overriding consideration ought to be the chances of success in starting a school of theoretical physics and training up a new generation which is very badly needed, and I feel my decision should be based entirely on where there are the best prospects of success in this. On this question, too, there are arguments on both sides. I believe research in theoretical physics can be successful only in close contact with experimental work and I believe I shall find much more fruitful collaboration with Oliphant’s department on the kind of fundamental problems that I would be particularly interested in than I could expect in Cambridge. I also know that in any changes of policy, both as regards
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
19
the teaching and organisation of research, I should find more support in Birmingham than the somewhat cumbersome machinery in Cambridge would make possible. The important factor on the other side of the balance is, of course, the availability of good students and the present examination and scholarship system which, particularly in mathematical subjects, canalizes the supply of first-class students to Cambridge. If this situation remains unchanged my choice, therefore lies between first-rate students in Cambridge and between a first-rate set-up with a restricted supply of students or a plentiful supply of students with a somewhat difficult set-up. This is true unless it is possible at this moment to break the vicious circle which attracts all good students to Cambridge and Oxford because of their high reputation and maintains a high reputation because they get the best students. For several reasons it might be the best psychological moment to change this now in a limited number of subjects, and it might be possible to attract to Birmingham a research team of graduate students, including some who had their undergraduate training in Cambridge. I have put down my view on this question in so much detail because I think it is only fair that you should know the position fully, and also because you may have more definite views on the chances of putting the provincial universities, and in particular Birmingham, in a better place compared to Cambridge than was possible in the past. In that case, I would greatly appreciate your advice. I would also like to make it clear that, in writing this letter, my object is not to obtain any further promises or concessions from the university. You probably know that in the case of the offer from Manchester, I wrote to Haworth in order to clear up beyond doubt a point on which I was almost satisfied, but on which a brief statement in Faculty minutes had raised some slight doubt. The reply from Haworth was very enthusiastic and gratifying and I am now satisfied that I can expect from the Faculty and from the other University authorities all the support and assistance I can reasonably expect. The one attraction of Cambridge which makes me hesitate now, the supply of first-class students, is clearly not a point for bargaining.
April 7, 2009
20
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
In replying to Cambridge, I shall try and postpone a decision until my return to England, which I expect to be approximately February 1, and I shall say that, whatever the decision, I shall not consider moving before the summer since I think the least I owe to the University of Birmingham is to return and get things running again after they have patiently put up with my absence for so long. With kind regards, Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[385] Rudolf Peierls to G.C. Wick [location unspecified], 14.12.1945 (carbon copy) Dear Wick: I have just sent you a cable asking you whether you would be prepared to consider a research job in Birmingham. By the time this letter reaches you, you may already have replied one way or another but, in any case, I am writing to give you a little more explanation than is possible in a cable. I intend to be back in Birmingham around February 1 and I shall then have a separate department of mathematical physics with a rather small staff. There is, at the moment, only one man besides me, who is interested in research,47 but I have now managed to get funds from which to create new research fellowships, and we will be able to get more good people, provided we can find them. If you would find it possible to come, I think the least we could offer you is a research fellowship at £800 p.a. which would carry no teaching duties except that you would 47 Hugh McManus had already been a research student in 1938/9. After the war, his results could not be reconstructed and he had to restart his career as a research student with work on infinite self energy. Peierls, Bird of Passage, pp. 137, 227. McManus eventually moved to Chalk River, the Canadian Atomic Energy Laboratory and later became professor of physics at Michigan State University.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
21
probably like to give a small number of lectures, say three or four a week, to senior students. The post is not a permanent one, but it is not limited to any definite period, and can be held for a number of years. The shortage of competent theoretical physicists in England is now so great that I do not have any doubt that you would find an equivalent or better job before very long. My department is in close contact with Oliphant’s department, which is expanding greatly and which I hope will be one of the centres of fundamental research. Oliphant has plans of constructing a machine for accelerating particles to energies of the order of 109 volts. He has quite a good staff including Moon. There is no specific date at which we would want you to take up your duties except, of course, that the sooner you can come the better. I have no knowledge of what difficulties we shall meet in greeting the necessary papers and permits, but I shall try to do my utmost to get this through in as short a time as possible. I should express that technically, the appointment to such a fellowship has to be made by the university authorities, but I do not anticipate any objections from them. I have heard rumours to the effect that you have been offered a job in this country and it is not for me to give you advice one way or other, but personally I would very much hope that you still can and will choose England, since I would be looking forward to collaborating with you with great pleasure. It might be useful to bear in mind that there is an extreme shortage of good people in England, and for this reason advancement to senior and individual positions is comparatively easy (there are at least three professorships vacant now). I personally find life in England particularly attractive, even with the postwar difficulties in housing, food and clothing that are likely to continue for some time, but this clearly is a personal matter. With best wishes, [R.E. Peierls]
April 7, 2009
12:11
22
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[386] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick Washington, 14.12.1945 (carbon copy) Dear Chadwick, I was trying to arrange to come to Washington to see you after your return to this country, but I find transportation conditions at the moment so difficult that it would probably mean a great loss of time. I therefore decided to abandon the idea for the present, but I could always arrange to come if you think there are important matters to be discussed. I shall, in any case, try to speak to you on the phone early next week. In any case, I am planning to leave here finally on January 10 and expect to be in the East from January 14 until my ship sails, which will probably be around January 25. I intend to spend some days in Washington during that period. Placzek will be able to tell you most of the news. I believe the most conspicuous fact since your departure is the amazing deterioration of morale in this place. There is very little work going on beyond writing up the “encyclopedia”48 and many people whose original intention had been to stay on for the summer have decided to get out. Bradbury49 is trying to rally his remaining forces and things are a little better now because, in most places, the new men have been appointed who will act as division and group leaders during the interim period. They have taken over the work in most places, and naturally pursue it more intensely than the people who are about to leave anyway. As regards the British team, Bretscher and with him French50 have still 48
After the development of the first operational nuclear weapons, the scientists of the Manhattan project wrote up the scientific developments in what became commonly known as the ‘Encyclopedia’. 49 Noris Bradbury (1909–97) replaced Robert Oppenheimer as director of the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory in 1945 and led it for 25 years until 1970. 50 Egon Bretscher (1901–1973) and Anthony P. French (1920–) both returned to England in 1946, the former to take up a post at Harwell, the latter to work at the Cavendish in Cambridge. French emigrated to the US in 1955 to join the Physics Department at the University of Carolina. In 1962 he moved to MIT.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
23
plenty of work to do and I believe are quite satisfied with their facilities. Bretscher still is quite happy to stay on until summer, except that he is somewhat worried about his relation to Cambridge since all letters from there seem to imply that he is expected there immediately. I hope you have brought some information with you that might clarify his position. Tuck has been given a free hand in doing experiments of fundamental interest and seems quite satisfied that these would keep him supplied with interesting work until June.51 Similarly, Titterton52 has plenty of work to do; the proposal to make him group leader did not materialise after all, because it turned out that Hans was prepared to stay on. He is somewhat senior to Titterton and, in addition, is likely to stay not only during the interim period but also after June and it is therefore, better for continuity for him to be in charge of the group. In this connection, I found that the letter that Hans wrote to you on the subject of Titterton’s salary was a spontaneous action of Hans on taking over the group and should, I think, be taken as a confirmation of the high value he places on Titterton’s work. Fuchs feels that when he has completed his writing he would be of more value in the development of the new Establishment53 than he could be here and is, accordingly, planning to leave some time in February. Skyrme54 has been asked to remain until June and will do so unless pressure is brought to make him return to England. 51 James L. Tuck stayed on at Los Alamos and worked with Teller on the development of thermonuclear weapons. 52 Ernest W. Titterton (1916–1990) continued work at Los Alamos until 1947, when he returned to England to become group leader in charge of nuclear emulsion and cloud chamber research at Harwell. 53 Klaus Fuchs returned to England in 1946 to become head of the Theory Division at Harwell. 54 Tony H.R. Skyrme (1922–1987) returned to a research fellowship at Birmingham after the war before moving on to M.I.T., Princeton and eventually also to Harwell as head of the nuclear physics group in 1950. In 1963 he succeeded Rudolf Peierls as Professor of Theoretical Physics at Birmingham.
April 7, 2009
12:11
24
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Frisch55 is completing his work and plans to leave approximately in February. Hughes56 seems quite happy to work in Frisch’s group and might even stay on after Frisch has left. Marshall, however, is still anxious to get back home at the earliest opportunity; I hope you have brought some information on the possibility of his returning to university work. Placzek57 will no doubt tell you himself about his plans. You will have heard about the interviews with the various prospective staff members for the Establishment. In discussing who was or was not interested in the interview, it turned out that Bretscher was quite interested in the possibility of a job in the Establishment. I encouraged him to go to the interview with the others, but he evidently decided not to go. I have not seen him since then, since I was on vacation and he went on vacation just before I returned, but I believe what was in his mind was that he was anxious to talk the situation over with you before discussing any new job more seriously. He is still away, but expected back here on December 22, and I imagine will be anxious to see you as soon as possible after that. While you were away I had offers of jobs from Oxford and Manchester, which I turned down after some reflection. I now had an offer from Cambridge and on this I find it very hard to make up my mind. I have one or two questions in that connection that I would like to ask you and I shall try to do that on the phone. You may be interested to know that the censorship here has now been lifted and, in general, security has been relaxed a great deal. For 55
Otto Frisch (1904–1979) returned to England after the war to become head of the nuclear physics group at Harwell before taking up the Jacksonian Chair at Cambridge in 1947. 56 Donald J. Hughes (1914–1960) had worked at the Metallurgical Laboratory. He was a member of the committee charged with studying the social and political implications of nuclear weapons which produced the so-called Franck Report. Hughes later became Head of the Neutron Physics Measurement Group at Brookhaven. 57 George Placzek (1905–1955) had moved from the Canadian Nuclear Research Laboratory at Chalk River, where he had been head of the theoretical physics division, to Los Alamos in 1945. A year later he transferred to General Electric Co., before joining the Institute of Advanced Studies at Princeton in 1948.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
25
example, in many cases friends or relatives have been allowed to come to the site as visitors. Are you planning to come out here again in the near future? There are plenty of people who would be very happy to see you here, although I am afraid I cannot promise much in the way of startling new developments. Yours sincerely, [R. Peierls]
[387] Rudolf Peierls to G.C. Wick [location unspecified], 18.12.1945 (carbon copy) Dear Wick: Thank you very much for your prompt reply to my cable. I was rather afraid that it might be too late, and if the reason against your being able to consider an offer is that you have already accepted the job at Notre Dame, I feel very foolish not to have thought of asking you in time. Since I wrote to you there has been a further development since I have been offered Fowler’s professorship in Cambridge. At the moment, I am very undecided as to what I should do. The offer is quite attractive, yet there are many reasons for staying in Birmingham. My point that affects my decision is what will happen to Birmingham if I leave. They will find it difficult to replace me because of the well-known shortage of theoretical physicists in England, and I feel under a strong obligation to them. If I decide to go to Cambridge, I do not think they could do better than offer the job to you. Naturally, this is a matter for the Faculty at Birmingham to decide and I can only advice them, but I believe that my advice would carry some weight. I imagine that your answer to my previous enquiry would equally apply to such an offer if made at this time. However, if you think that the offer of a full professorship might put you in a better position to try and get released from commitments
April 7, 2009
26
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
already entered into, please let me know. In any case, I would probably not leave Birmingham until next autumn and you might still be prepared to consider coming then or a little later. Please tell me frankly what your feelings in this matter are. It is, of course, quite possible that having once gone to this country, you would want to remain here, particularly since you are liable to be offered better jobs fairly soon. All this must, of course, at the moment be regarded as unofficial and confidential, but having an informal reply from you will help me greatly, both in making my own decision and in advising the Faculty at Birmingham. Quite apart from all this, there is the question whether, on your way to America, you might find it possible to visit England for a short period. Clearly, if you catch a boat from England this would be very easy. If you were proposing to get a boat directly from Italy or elsewhere, it might raise some complications with transportation and papers. However, if it can be done at all, I would be very happy to see you again and have some discussions. I am sure that we could arrange to have your expenses met. My movements are as follows: I shall leave here on January 10; can be reached after than until about January 24 through: c/o J.F.Jackson, P.O. Box 680, Benjamin Franklin Station, Washington 4, D.C. I hope to be back in England around February 1 and my address is then The University, Birmingham 15. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[388] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick Washington, 4.1.1946 Dear Chadwick, I have disobeyed your instructions to some extent and I have had a brief and very informal conversation with Bob Wilson about Cambridge. In doing so I have, of course, made it perfectly clear that this was at this
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
27
stage merely a vague idea — that as far as I knew the idea had never even yet been discussed by people concerned in Cambridge, and that I was talking to him purely on my own initiative to find out what the chances were of getting him into such a scheme. I did not, of course, expect on this very vague basis to get any definite reply, but this reaction was sufficiently favourable to make me think that there is a fair chance of his accepting and it would certainly be worthwhile, in my opinion, to pursue this proposition with all possible energy. What I discussed with him was the idea of his going to Cambridge for a limited period of a few years, and as was to be expected, this idea would appeal to him more than a permanent job, provided, of course, he would not have to spend the greater fraction of his time in just preparing future developments and designing equipment that would not materialize during his period there. At present his plans are, as you know, to go to Harvard, but he proposes first to go to Berkeley in order to design there a new cyclotron for Harvard. Clearly, if he was not going to go to Harvard for the time being, he would not be particularly interested in spending his summer on developing equipment and, for that reason, I believe that the chances of getting him would rather depend on how soon a definite approach could be made. This, of course, does not mean I am certain he would accept — one of the questions being whether he can arrange for leave of absence from Harvard or otherwise ensure that he will not spoil his position here and find himself stranded on his return. Yours sincerely, R. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
28
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[389] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr Birmingham, 21.2.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick,58 (If you will permit me to retain this form of address which is now obsolete, but which we all got to like very much). As you will see from the heading I have now returned to Birmingham, and am trying to get back to a somewhat more normal mode of life. Before leaving America, I had received a message asking whether I would go to Cambridge to take Fowler’s chair. As you can imagine, I found it hard to make up my mind on this, since Cambridge is so very attractive in many ways, and in particular because of the number and quality of students available there. After long deliberations, however, I finally decided to stay in Birmingham. My chief reason is that I like the spirit of that place, and that I think, it is most important, for any theoretical team to be in close contact with a life experimental group, and I have much more assurance of finding that here, with Oliphant and Moon close at hand. In addition, I think it would be healthier for the whole country, of the modern universities were to be strengthened and if there were subjects which are well represented in some of them, Birmingham seems a good place for this, and the present a very suitable time. This means I am now trying to build up a good research team here. I have already one or two people for a start, and there are visitors whose presence will certainly help to create the right atmosphere. One of them is Jensen, a pupil of Møller’s, who is here primarily to learn experimental physics, but who does show considerable interest also in theoretical problems. I am naturally most anxious to hear about any other promising men whom we could induce to come here, and if you hear of any such people whose plans are unsettled and who are, or might be, considering to come 58
At Los Alamos, Niels Bohr’s code name was Uncle Nick, an address which Peierls continued to use after the war.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
29
to England, I would be very grateful, if you could bear Birmingham in mind. I think it will be reasonably easy to get financial support for them, if necessary. I hope you and your family are well, and are at last being given a chance to be all together. With best wishes, Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls] [390] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick [Birmingham], 26.2.1946 Dear Chadwick, I hope you will forgive me for not writing to you until now, but you probably understood that, in addition to the first rush of business, I had the problem of deciding where to go and also where to put my family. As rumours travel, you have probably already heard that we have decided to remain in Birmingham, and I think the chief argument that finally tipped the balance was the rather attractive prospects of experimental physics in Birmingham as compared with the uncertain situation in Cambridge and the need, in general, to build up the modern universities to get a fairer share of the good students, not to the detriment of Cambridge, but to reestablish fair proportions. I also felt that the spirit of Birmingham University as a whole and the greater flexibility of the modern university will make a lot of difference. I realise, of course, that this makes things rather difficult for Cambridge, but I do not think the problem is insoluble. I have suggested to Bragg that they should consider Casimir,59 and Mott is backing me on that. An alternative would be L.H.Thomas,60 whom one might have a chance of persuading to return. 59
In 1942 Hendrik Casimir (1909–1945) had joined the Philips Research Laboratories in Eindhoven, where he remained until his retirement in 1972. 60 Llewellyn Hilleth Thomas (1903–1992) had studied at Cambridge before taking up a professorship at Ohio State University in 1929.
April 7, 2009
12:11
30
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
You may have seen that I wrote a short and rather superficial article for the Sunday Dispatch,61 at their request.∗ It is not a paper of which I approve, but the practice seems to be for everybody to write for papers indiscriminately as long as they are left free to say what they want. I was somewhat hesitant over the procedure that should be followed, since clearly there would not be time to send such an article to you for approval. I did, however, attempt to write it in such a way that I was certain it contained no unpublished information other than obvious deductions from such information and that it was not likely to upset anyone on the other side. I also had it cleared by Akers,62 who submitted it to the appropriate authorities in the Ministry of Supply. Frightened by other people’s experiences with papers, I made it a condition that they should not make any alterations without my approval. This condition was accepted and, surprisingly enough, observed. There exists now a somewhat complicated situation with the Committee of Atomic Scientists. I believe you had a letter from the organisers of the committee, which at present is sponsored by the Association of Scientific Workers.63 It consists of about twenty people whose names happened to be known to the sponsors, and at a meeting we had a few days ago, we all pressed strongly for a change in the set-up, in which the committee, in order to be able to speak for anybody, should contain at least representatives elected by the groups still existing in places where project work was being carried out. In addition it was felt widely that it would be better for such a committee to be independent of the Association of Scientific Workers, since such a connection would only antagonise ∗ Copy 61
enclosed.
Sunday Dispatch, 17.2.1946. Wallace Alan Akers (1888–1954) had been co-director of Tube Alloys during the Second World War and returned to ICI after the war as research director. 63 The National Union of Scientific Workers was founded in 1918. In 1927 it changed its name to the Association of Scientific Workers; in 1968 it amalgamated with the Association of Supervisory Staffs, Executives and Technicians to form the Association of Scientific, Technical and Managerial Staffs. 62
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
31
certain people. It is, however, not yet clear, how an independent committee could be financed, unless, like the new American Federations of Scientists, it collects members from all branches of science outside the project. On the advisability of this step on other grounds there is much controversy. I personally feel that the two activities at present attempted by the Association of Scientific Workers, namely to act as a trade union for scientists, and to express the general view of scientists as unbiased experts, do not mix and should be carried out by separate bodies. Everybody is asking now, how soon you will be back and I hope it will not be so very long now. Yours sincerely, R. Peierls
[391] James Chadwick to Rudolf Peierls [location unspecified] 6.3.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Peierls, I have just received your letter of February 26.64 I am very glad to hear that you have settled down already but cannot help but feel sorry that you have decided not to go to Cambridge. I appreciate your reasons and sympathise with them, and even share some of them, but I still regret the loss to Cambridge. I hope Bragg will consider the suggestion of Casimir seriously for this would be quite a reasonable solution of the difficulty. I had not heard about your article in the Sunday Dispatch, and I am glad to have a copy of it. I think it is very good and you have avoided most adroitly a number of pitfalls while still appearing to give some information. There has been quite a lot of publicity on this side and a good deal of sheer nonsense. The chief topic we have to avoid in 64
Letter [390].
April 7, 2009
12:11
32
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
discussion of the Navy Test is any mention of British participation.65 The point is that they do not want to have to refuse requests from other countries, which might ask to send representatives, if it were known that we were sending observers as well as taking part in the work. A second topic is the animal experiments. Here they fear pressure from the antivivisectionists, who are very active just now. A little has leaked out but the arguments have been played down by saying that the animals are nearly all rats. The preparations for the tests are most hectic. My own opinion is that there has been too much display and that it would have been better to carry out the operation quietly; also that they are attempting far too much in the way of measurements and observations. I think that much of the work is not necessary for the real purpose of the test. Some of the scientists are more active than ever in public affairs. The young Federation is doing quite well, although I do not agree with a good deal of what they say publicly. I think they have gone too far and that they have lost support by being too emphatic, but they have not yet fallen into discredit. Urey66 continues to be very vocal and I am afraid he is now losing ground. If Groves seizes his chances, he will be able to re-establish himself, after having almost lost the game. It is a very odd situation at the moment. Yours sincerely, J. Chadwick 65
The immediate post-war years were characterised by tensions in Anglo-American nuclear, defence and other relations. British hopes for ‘full and effective co-operation’, as postulated in the Quebec Agreement between the US and Great Britain in 1943, were not fulfilled in essential nuclear development matters. Technology transfer was limited to basic scientific research only. It did not apply to development, design, construction, and operation of plants per se and was in fact limited to mutually advantageous ad hoc arrangements. At that time great care was taken by the US not to raise awareness of continued British presence at Los Alamos or indeed at other venues of nuclear work. This was most evident during ‘Operation Crossroads’, a series of nuclear tests carried out on the Pacific island of Bikini in July 1946. See S.Lee, ‘Birmingham — London — Los Alamos — Hiroshima: Britain and the Atomic Bomb’, Midland History 27, 146–64 (2002). 66 Harold Clayton Urey (1883–1981), had been Director of War Research, Atomic Bomb Project, Columbia University, between 1940 and 1945; after the war he moved to the Institute of Nuclear Studies at Chicago.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
33
[392] Niels Bohr to Rudolf Peierls Copenhagen, 7.3.1946 Dear Peierls, Thank you very much for your kind letter67 which recalled so many pleasant remembrances of the time we all spent together at Los Alamos where you and your wife looked after Aage and me with so great kindness. It was a great pleasure to learn from your letter that you are now back in Birmingham and, after your great contribution to the war work, are able again to concentrate on general scientific problems and to cooperate with Oliphant and Moon. I shall certainly bear in mind your offer for a time to take up in your group a promising young physicist for whom a stay with you will be such a profitable experience. We are also here trying to reorganize our experimental as well as our theoretical work and I am myself endeavouring to complete the various investigations which I had to leave unfinished on my escape from Denmark. Among these I have an especially bad conscience about our common work with Placzek and I wonder whether there might soon be an opportunity where we could meet again to look properly into it.68 I need not say how great a pleasure it would be to us all here if you would soon be able to visit us. My own plans are somewhat unsettled, but there is the possibility that I might come to England some time in May, and as soon as I can survey my obligations I shall, of course, write to you again. With kindest regards from us all to your wife and the children, and also to common friends in Birmingham, Yours, Niels Bohr 67
Letter [389]. Georg Placzek, Niels Bohr and Rudolf Peierls had been working on a joint paper on resonance processes since the late 1930s. They published a short note in Nature with the intention of publishing a fuller exposition of the argument in a separate paper. Lee, Selected Correspondence, Vol. 1, Chapter 4. Their work had been interrupted by the war. At the conference in Copenhagen in September 1947, it was agreed that Peierls would complete and update the earlier draft of 1939–40. 68
April 7, 2009
12:11
34
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[393] G.P. Thompson to Rudolf Peierls London, 8.3.1946 Dear Peierls, I send you herewith a M.S. in the hope that you will look through it. It contains an idea on the generation of nuclear energy from deuterons. I have discussed it with Blackman69 who has helped in some of the calculations, and consulted Akers. He agrees with me that it is of sufficient importance to ask you to give an opinion, and I sincerely hope you will be able to do so. Some of the quantities concerned are uncertain, notably the crosssections. Perhaps you may know better figures than I have been able to find. The working conditions chosen are rather arbitrary, and I think it would be necessary to put up the quantities I have called X and H in order to retain a sufficient share of the products of the reaction to make the reaction self sustaining as regards temperature. What I am most concerned about, however, is not whether the reaction would or would not be self sustaining, but whether the general scheme is sound. If it is, and the balance is not too far on the wrong side, somebody will probably be able to make it work even if some of the heat produced has to be fed back as electrical energy to keep the thing going. Besides that it would be a formidable source of plutonium using very little uranium and making comparatively little demands on cooling. It would probably be cheaper than a pile and would have at least political importance. For these reasons, if the scheme is sound, Akers wants to take out some kind of patent in my name. Please let me know if you are likely to be in town any time so we can arrange a lunch, or if necessary I could come to Birmingham. Yours sincerely, G.P. Thompson 69
Moses Blackman (1908–1983), lecturer at Imperial College, London, was working with G.P. Thompson on a gas discharge apparatus for a nuclear reactor. For details see M.G. Haines, ‘Fifty Years of controlled fusion research’, Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 38, 643–56 (1996).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
35
[394] Rudolf Peierls to G.P. Thomson [Birmingham], 12.3.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Thomson, Thank you for your interesting letter and manuscript.70 I find myself in a very peculiar situation when I try to comment on this problem. The reason is that I am in possession of a great deal of information obtained on our topics by work at Los Alamos. This work concerns a part of the project which is regarded as particularly secret, and I am sure it would be felt very strongly that I ought not to pass on any information except to a very limited number of people. I had previously obtained from Sir John Anderson permission to mention similar matters to members of the Technical Committee,71 provided that they were warned to keep this information to themselves. This clearly means that I should also be able to talk freely to you about this, but if I do so it might handicap you in working along such lines with the help of further collaborators, and, for that reason, it seems to me possible that you might prefer not to receive this information from me. If you wish to carry on work utilising the information I have brought on this subject from Los Alamos and to disclose it to other members of your staff, my feeling is that it would be advisable to report this to Chadwick and get his comments as to likely reactions in America. I would like, however, now to make at least one remark, which I think I can make without drawing on this special knowledge, and that is that the beginning of your manuscript refers to heating the substance to temperatures of the order of 100,000 electron volts. It seems to me that this is the crux of the matter and that this will be extremely difficult, because, while it is true that a magnetic field will diminish the heat conductivity, it will not completely prevent the transmission of 70
Letter [393]. In the Tube Alloys project not all the information was distributed to all members of the project but rather kept within subcommittees. 71
April 7, 2009
12:11
36
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
heat unless the magnetic field were infinitely large and, for that reason, the amount of energy that will have to be fed into the system to reach or maintain this high temperature may well prove prohibitive. I find in your manuscript no estimate of the required energy input. I may have overlooked this and you may have considered this point, but it seems to me the chief difficulty. For the rest, any comments I could make are of a more detailed kind and could not be made without using this special kind of information I possess, and I do not want to do so before knowing whether this is your wish. I shall not spend much time in London during the next two weeks or so, since I am tied up with lectures very heavily, owing to the illness of a member of staff here. I shall be glad to meet you in London early in April if you think that further discussion of the matter can wait until then. If you were able to come to Birmingham I should be very glad to see you here almost any time. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls P.S. Please also regard as confidential information the fact that I know aspects of the problem that are specially secret, since it is not too hard to guess what these aspects might be.
[395] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick Birmingham, 12.3.1946 Dear Chadwick, Thank you for your letter of March 6th.72 I have since seen Bragg again and he has approached Bohr on the question of Casimir and got a very favourable answer. My impression was that Bragg was in favour of this plan and felt he would be able to carry the other electors. It is not certain, however, whether Casimir would accept, although I think the chances are fairly good.73 72 73
Letter [391]. Casimir remained at Philips Research Laboratories. See letter [390].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
37
The fact that the British observers are participating in the naval tests seems fairly widely known in this country, and in an introduction to my article the Sunday Dispatch, in fact, stated this. They said that British observers were on their way to the Pacific now. They did not get this information from me, and I did not think I could or should prevent them from printing this. In other newspapers I have seen lengthy accounts of the numbers and types of animals that are being used in the tests; I do not know, of course, whether this information is correct. My own feeling on the tests is that the first two are not likely to give much information that could not be derived from blast measurements at Trinity and observations at Hiroshima, together with some commonsense and some model experiments on the formation of tidal waves. Their main effect would seem to me to be to delay the third experiment, which, of course, is the really interesting one. You may be interested to know that an attempt is now being made to set up an Association of Atomic Scientists,74 in some way similar to the first federation formed in America.75 This started as a committee called together by the Association of Scientific Workers, whose papers, I believe, you have seen, but it has now been agreed, and I think very wisely, that it would be best to have such an organisation independent of the Association of Scientific Workers. A provisional committee has been formed of which I am a member, and it is expected that within a week or so things will have reached the stage where one can enroll members. In the meantime, the committee is taking over all the work started by the committee of the Association of Scientific Workers. We are trying to avoid some of the mistakes made by the Americans, by insisting from the outset that a proper division should be made between statements of the scientific facts and opinions held by scientists, and that on the latter type of question the association should not express 74
The Atomic Scientists’ Association was set up in 1946 primarily to educate British public opinion about nuclear matters and to make a case for international control of atomic energy 75 The Federation of American Scientists had been formed in 1945 by atomic scientists from the Manhattan Project to address a broad spectrum of national security issues of the nuclear age and to promote the humanitarian uses of science and technology.
April 7, 2009
12:11
38
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
any definite views or advocate any definite policies. Their job should primarily be to promote discussions which will help to make clear the implications of such views or policies and to make available statements of such views drawn up by individuals either inside the association or outside on their own behalf. They should, as an association, advocate views on such questions only if, after submitting proposals to all the members, they are found to be shared by all, or essentially all, the scientists in the association. We have considered the question of widening this, as the Americans have done, into an organisation including all scientists in this country, but it was felt that this would be invading territory which at present other associations such as the A.Sc.W. and the British Association regard as their own, and that it would be wiser to wait until means of working through existing organisations had been explored, without, in doing so, getting definitely labelled in any political direction, as would be the case under A.Sc.W. As soon as the necessary steps have been taken, we will, of course, send you all the literature about the new association, and even if in your present position76 you would consider it unwise to become a member of it, we will, of course, always be grateful for any advice or opinion that you care to express. I am very disappointed at the rate at which things are moving in the project in this country and at morale throughout the project. I have been trying to think out what are the main factors responsible for all this, and, while this letter is getting too long to get into details, I hope to write to you soon to explain my views on this. With best wishes, Yours sincerely, R. Peierls
76
Chadwick was still Head of the British Mission to the Manhattan Project.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
39
[396] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 14.3.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you very much for your article, which I think is admirable.77 I believe it will fit into the series without altering a single word. This completes the series, except for the article from Phil Morrison from whom I have not heard yet. As what you sent me was a carbon copy, I assume that you have sent the original to Groves’ office. They have in the past been quite good about clearing things quickly, in particular when reminded from time to time, and Mr. MacMillan in Chadwick’s office is looking after that. If, by any chance, you should not have sent your article to Groves’ office, McMillan will get in touch with you directly. I am in your debt in many ways, owing you (a) a letter, and (b) a nickel. On the latter, will you please begin to charge interest.78 In other words, I have decided to stay here, largely because the spirit of the place is more attractive than it appears to be now in Cambridge, and it is hard to predict how Cambridge will change in the near future. It is, of course, possible that a good man will succeed Cockroft, but even then the whole administrative machinery is very cumbersome and conservative. Birmingham is rather fun and I have the ambition to put Birmingham on the map and get a good team of research workers started here, which would, I think, be a healthier thing from a wider point of view than to begin concentrating everything at Cambridge. People in Cambridge were naturally disappointed and they are now trying to find an alternative solution. There are, I think, one of two possibilities which would work quite well; if they are reasonable about it, but I know that amongst others, your name is on their list and I am trying to tell them that to attempt to offer this job to you would be a waste of time and of a postage stamp. 77
Peierls helped put together a series of articles on atomic weapons as part of the Penguin News Series. Science News 6, London: Penguin, 1948. 78 Bethe and Peierls had had a bet over Peierls’ future career.
April 7, 2009
12:11
40
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Even in Birmingham, with all the help from the University, it takes, of course, time to build up. So far I have 1 (one) research student,79 with two more expected in the near future and one apparently good undergraduate finishing in the summer who might stay on. There is practically any amount of money for fellowships, so that I could get more people if I could find them. In particular I am trying to induce Skyrme to leave Los Alamos, but have not heard from him as yet. The process of settling down and getting rid of excess papers etc. is a very painful one, as no doubt you have found yourself, and it is not made easier by the fact that a week or so after my return one of our lecturers fell ill and I had to take over most of his work, which, for a month or so, involves me in about thirteen lectures a week, mostly to large classes of engineers. I do not regret this, because I always meant to try these engineer courses in order to see whether they cannot be given in a more reasonable way and it is rather fun. Anyway, there are only two more weeks of this and, on the principle of the old story with the pig and the goat, etc., I shall then find that never before in my life did I have so much free time. My one research student is now tidying up the question of the integral theory of the electro-magnetic field. As you know I was going to try this out. So far it appears that the classic side of this is perfectly straightforward and contains no snags. We are trying to apply this to some specific problem, such as the emission of radiation by an electron, to see how it works, but the real question is, of course, that of quantization and I have no confidence that this can be done.80 You will by now have received an invitation to the conference in Cambridge in July.81 It is, I think, unfortunate that the organisers are not able to pay people’s fares but only their stay in Cambridge. Even so, I very much hope that you will be able to come. It goes without saying that once you are here, and if you are not too hard pressed for time, we would count on seeing you in Birmingham. 79
Hugh McManus. See letters [385], [412]. R.E. Peierls and H. McManus, ‘Classical electrodynamics without singularities’ Proc. Roy. Soc. A 195, 323–36 (1948). 81 Between 22 and 27 July 1946, a Physical Society Conference on fundamental particles and low temperatures took place in Cambridge. 80
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
41
We are still living in a boarding house, but we have bought the tail end of the lease of quite a nice house and hope to move in on April 15th. With very best wishes to all of you, Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[397] Rudolf Peierls to G.P. Thomson [Birmingham], 26.3.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Thomson, Thank you for your letter82 which has made the position much clearer. I see that your scheme is based essentially on the assumption that the nuclei will not contribute to heat conduction at all. Granting this assumption, I believe your conclusions are correct, although I am not quite satisfied that it is altogether in order to count only collisions which give deflections of 90◦ . In this kind of problem, collisions with small deflections are very much more frequent, and I believe it would be more correct to take an average cross-section, weighing each collision with the factor 1 − cos. This is likely to result in a somewhat similar free mean path which, in your conditions, means a somewhat greater conductivity. However, since you have a considerable factor in hand, I do not believe this will essentially affect the argument. The essential point is, then, that of the contribution to the nuclei. If I understand your argument rightly, it is that you are essentially in the Knudsen case and that only a negligible fraction of the nuclei will make a collision with other nuclei before hitting the wall after once they have acquired their high temperature, and you have further assumed that any nucleus that has hit the wall will get stuck there. This will continue until the potential differential between the gas and the wall will have risen to a point where the potential energy becomes 82
Letter could not be located.
April 7, 2009
42
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
greater than kT and, from then on, no further nuclei can reach the walls. The number of nuclei needed to produce this charge is small and the energy carried away by them is, therefore, negligible. I am a little worried about this argument, for three reasons. In the first place, once you are dealing with deuterons striking a wall at high speed, it seems to me unavoidable that one should get some phenomena of secondary emission. Secondary emission of electrons, of course, is of no importance, since these will not leave the wall, but with the energies concerned I rather think it will be possible to knock off positive ions, which, of course, would break down the charge contribution, and this seems likely if the wall contains near its surface a lot of deuterons which had got stuck there previously. It might, however, be possible to make the wall of such a material that it would be very hard to dislodge any atom from its surface and that, at the same time, the deuterons would penetrate too deeply to find their way out again. Possibly some experiments could be devised to throw light on this question. The second point is the following. Supposing that the surface itself acts as a perfect trap for deuterons, then there will be a strong electric field normal to the surface and this will give to any electrons circling there in the magnetic field an average velocity component at right angles to both fields. I find, for the kind of figures that you have quoted, an average electron velocity component in the direction of 2 · 5.108 cm./sec. which means a current density of 3000 amps./cm.2 This will cause a gradient of the field of the magnitude of 4000 gauss/cm. As a result, the magnetic field gets neutralised in the centre of the tube and, therefore, also the electric field will disappear from there. This will increase the electric intensity in the outer part and hence the current density, and in this way progressively the field will be forced into a narrower shell near the wall. In the end it will mean that your temperature difference, as well as your potential difference, would have to be maintained over a very small gap comparable to the radius of the electron orbits, and this is clearly impossible. Thirdly, there is a fact that, owing to electron collisions, this gas will have a finite electric conductivity, and this is another reason why, together with the electric field, there will be a transport of electrons to the wall, since the migration of every electron to the wall requires a
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
43
deuteron to go as well to restore the potential, it seems to me that this process would continue until all the gas has been cleared up. I find it hard to say how one can escape all three of these difficulties together. But I would be very glad to have your comments on this. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[398] Rudolf Peierls to William G. Penney [Birmingham], 29.3.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Bill, I have only just heard that you are back in this country. I hope there will be an opportunity of meeting you before you disappear again, as there are a number of questions, both about the project and otherwise, that it would be nice to talk over. I have not seen you since you got your new job and, while I am sure you will make a success of this work and will enjoy it, I cannot help regretting that this means one more defection from the ranks of theoretical physicists in this country, of which, in any case, there are too few.83 I was glad to see your name on the new list of the Royal Society. I am sure that is well deserved. I do not know whether you know that I helped put together a series of articles on the atomic bomb to make up a number of the new Penguin Science News. This number will deal entirely with atomic energy.84 I have the articles all completed except for an article by Philip Morrison on “the atomic bomb as a weapon” This was promised for mid-January, 83 William Penney (1909–1991), who had been part of the British delegation at Los Alamos, had taken up the position of Chief Superintendent of Armament Research (CSAR) which put him in charge of the Armament Research Department in January 1946. 84 See letter [396], note 77.
April 7, 2009
44
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
but it is not complete yet and cannot be sent for another month. I have reported this to the publishers to find out whether they are prepared to wait so long for the article, but while I am waiting for a reply I would be glad to know whether, by any chance, you might be prepared to write such an article in a hurry. This is intended to be on a rather popular level. The other articles are about seven thousand words each on the average, but this is not a very precise limitation either way. There are other articles dealing with the chain reaction in general, with the separation of isotopes and the production of plutonium, with the properties of the atoms, electrons and neutrons, so that for this article is remains to explain in some detail the processes involved in the actual explosion, in particular the competition between the rate of reaction and the increase in volume due to the expansion and the effects. All this, of course, within the limits laid down by present security rules. I would, of course, let you have the existing articles as a basis, Penguin pay, I believe three guineas for a thousand words, but they intend to publish the series also in other languages like Spanish and Portuguese, and they may well decide to publish it in America as well and there would be additional royalties from these. I do not know whether you have heard that we are trying to get an atomic scientists’ organisation along somewhat similar lines to the American organisations, though on a smaller scale, and suited to the conditions in this country. I hope you will agree to support this. Does your business ever bring you to the Midlands? If so, I would certainly be glad to see you here, and otherwise, maybe we could meet in London. How easy is it for you to get to the centre of town? With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
45
[399] William G. Penney to Rudolf Peierls Fort Halstead, Sevenoaks, 1.4.1946 Dear Rudy, I was glad to hear from you.85 If there had not been a delay I should have returned to the States on the 23 March; my present plans are to leave about the 15th April. I should also, very much like to talk with you on several matters but unless you are coming to London in the next fortnight and have a few hours to spare when you come, it is not likely that we shall meet before my return. It would not be difficult for me to get up to London at any time, if you came. Your suggestion about an article for the Penguin Science is one which I am afraid I must refuse. To me, it is not at all clear what should be said in such an article. I am not so much worried about Security but rather about the effect that an ill-considered article might have. You may be interested to hear that it is likely that a Government White Paper will be issued on the atomic bomb damage in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This paper will be written by the team from the Ministry of Home Security which went to Japan with the Strategic Bomb Survey Group. I have seen the report which these people have prepared and it seems to me that they can usefully prepare a White Paper; they report only things which were obvious to everybody who went into the cities; in fact, they missed a great deal. I hope that you and your wife and children are all well and not finding austerity too severe. Yours sincerely, Bill
85
Letter [398].
April 7, 2009
12:11
46
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[400] G.P. Thomson to Rudolf Peierls London, 2.4.1946 Dear Peierls, Many thanks for your letter and criticisms.86 The second point you make is a very serious one and invalidates the scheme as originally proposed except for very low densities. I think, however, that there is a way out as follows. In order to get the energy in for heating purposes we had already proposed to use the toroid as a sort of wave guide and drive the electrons forward by what is virtually the pressure of radiation. They would then transfer energy to the nuclei by collisions. Now this process will create a current round the toroid which will cause a circumferential magnetic field (circumferential round the circumference of the circular section of the toroid). This magnetic field will serve to anchor the electrons instead of the solenoid field originally proposed. The velocity of the electrons corresponding to the combination of this field and the radical electric field is now in the direction of the current and in the same sense. Another way of looking at it is to say that the different current elements attract and so balance the outward radial force on the electrons. The electrons once anchored, all is as before. This case is harder to work out than the former but as far as Blackman and I can see it should work out. As regards your other objection: There is no evidence to my knowledge that fields of the order considered ∼ 10, 000 volts/cm will produce any secondary emission of positrons from metals. There might be some spluttering of neutrals due to bombardment of the walls, but this can be made very small by lining with aluminium and perhaps in other ways. I envisage holes in the walls through which deuterium would be admitted and the products of the decomposition withdrawn. The amount of gas in use will be controlled by shooting electrons into the centre to make up for those driven to the walls by collision. Some nuclei of H3 .H .H3l will reach the walls, some but 86
Letter [397].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
47
fewer H2 since these will not have the energy of disintegration to help them overcome the field. At first they may penetrate a short distance into the walls but this thin skin will soon become saturated and the nuclei will collect on the surface picking up electrons from the secondaries formed. (If there is any difficulty about this the solid walls could be shielded from the electron field by a lining of gauze say 1cm away, but I don’t believe this will be necessary.) This thin layer of gas will mix with the deuterium supply and be drawn off at some of the holes in the wall while deuterium is wasted in this way, but it could be recovered with the valuable tritium. Some of the deuterium gets ionised by collision and is drawn in to the body of the gas to an extent determined by the loss of disintegration nuclei and the balance of electrons shot in over those lost. The controls are two; — rate of shooting of electrons, supply of deuterium. I should very much like to discuss all this as it is so difficult to explain by letter. I am going to Ireland on Friday for a holiday, returning on the 24th. If you are likely to be in London before the end of April, could you let me know? If not, I think I should come to Birmingham. What day would suit you? It is most kind of you to help as you are doing. Yours very sincerely, G.P. Thomson
[401] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 8.4.1946 Dear Rudi: Thanks a lot for your letter of 3rd April.87 It is unfortunately true that I had not sent my manuscript to Washington, but I am doing this today. It had weighed on my conscience for about a week past, but I was away all the week. I am very happy to have won the nickel. I think in the long run you are going to be happier at Birmingham than at Cambridge. Still, it is a 87
Bethe almost certainly refers to letter [396] dated 14 March 1946.
April 7, 2009
12:11
48
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
pity that Cambridge has gone so much to the dogs as you indicated by your refusal. Bretscher is apparently so disgusted that he will not come back to Cambridge. I am just having a visit with Wentzel for two days. He mentioned that there were several young theorists in Zurich who took their degrees in the last two years. He wanted to send one over to Cornell with a Fellowship, which we like very much. But I thought also of your problems and thought you might be interested in getting one or two to England. Wentzel is going back to Zurich at the end of this week. You might like to write to him there as to what kind of people you would be interested in. I got the official invitation from Cambridge. It is very tempting to go, but I had promised myself to take a really long vacation this summer. So it is probably “no”, but this is certainly the most difficult invitation to refuse. I got settled here quite nicely and find some time to study mesons and nuclear forces and to do a little bit of work myself. Physics is, after all, a fascinating subject. You may have seen the report of the State Department on international control of atomic energy of which Oppie is one of the authors.88 I think it is very good. Greetings from Rose who is enjoying the comforts of civilisation and from myself to you and the family. Yours sincerely, Hans [402] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick [location unspecified], 3.5.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Chadwick, For some time I have intended to write to you my impression of the situation here as regards the project and what is wrong with it. In the 88
United States Department of State Committee on Atomic Energy, ‘Report on the International Control of Atomic Energy’, (Washington, 28.3.1946).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
49
meantime things have changed considerably through Portal89 taking office and through his establishing a new Technical Committee under his Chairmanship. This has removed at least some of the difficulties, in that there is now at least a body in which the scientists meet from time to time and through which they can be kept informed of what is going on. But I still feel far from satisfied that things are going as well as they ought to. Probably the great snag is the incredible inefficiency and red tape in the Ministry of Supply. You will have heard stories about this from other sources. Here are some examples, by way of illustration. The general experience is that it takes three months to get any payment of outstanding balance to people returning from North America. I have not been able, in spite of intense pressure, to get these matters straightened out, but in my case this is less serious than in the case of younger people like Marshall, who has not had his payment yet, or Morris, for whom it took an incredible time, although it is finally settled now. As you know, most of us had to be appointed honorary consultants in order to legalize our position in retaining reports. The writing of even the formal letters necessary for this purpose took ages, and probably would never have been done if Akers had not written such letters off his own bat, against instruction. I had, in fact, a letter from Summer telling me that it was a violation of the Official Secrets Act, if I retained any reports beyond 11th March. The letter reached me about 13th March. It was, of course, of no consequence, but similar things happen to people who are less familiar with the project and it does not actually make them keen to continue to help. The worst of all these things is, as no doubt you know, the situation at Harwell. Oliphant and I visited Harwell this week and there is practically nothing going on there. No construction work has progressed, or even started. Skinner has an uphill job fighting petty officials over petty regulations. The greatest difficulty was the arrangements for making appointments, but I understand that this is now being handled in a somewhat different way, giving Skinner more direct responsibility, and maybe things will work a little more effectively. 89
Air Marshal Viscount Portal of Hungerford (1893–1971), had been Commanderin-Chief of RAF Bomber Command and then Chief of the Air Staff and Marshal of the RAF. After the war he became Controller of Production, Atomic Energy (CPAE).
April 7, 2009
50
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Another example is that one hangar is filled with equipment from Valley. While we were there we had a visit from the former Foreman at Valley to explain the nature of some of the equipment. It turned out that a catalogue of this equipment had been sent to the Ministry of Supply but had never reached Skinner. It would evidently be desirable to dismantle some of the equipment and to take out parts that would be of value to Harwell, but they have at the moment not even a crew of people who could get hold of some screwdrivers to get to work on this. They have of course not the screwdrivers and spanners either. In addition to all this, every little job connected with living conditions there, such as the distribution of mail, leaking taps, transportation and so on, becomes a problem that needs to be fought out and takes time. I am not suggesting that any of these items is, in itself, serious. Probably by the time this letter reaches you, most of the difficulties will have been overcome somehow, and they will be fighting about something else. But all this wears out the personnel, in particular Skinner, completely and keeps their attention away from more important questions, and it illustrates the complete lack of comprehension in the official mind of what the project is about and how it ought to be tackled. Asking for reasons for this, it seems to me that the chief reason is the position of the project in the Ministry of Supply, in which it is just one of many activities and in which at every level, not only at the top, it requires the action of people who are concerned with it for only a very small fraction of their time. For every little wall that has to be built at Harwell, the Ministry of Works has to be brought in and contact with the Ministry of Works is made by the Ministry of Supply officials who have no idea about atomic energy. I understood some time ago from Longmir that in anything he does he reports to civil servants in the Ministry who are busy men and not particularly interested in atomic energy, and his recommendations reach people at a higher level merely in the form in which these civil servants choose to summarise or forward them. I believe there is hope that all these things will improve as the activities of the project grow, since it will then be possible to allocate more full-time staff to the project specifically, but it will involve a fight at each step.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
51
What I am particularly concerned about is that before the decision was taken to place this project under the Ministry of Supply it was our general impression that things would not be allowed to get to this state, but that, if the project were to come under an existing ministry it would have a special organisation set up for it which would make use of the priority and financing arrangements of the ministry and would link up also with it at a high level but within that framework would have a completely independent organisation. All the scientists concerned with the project felt strongly about this and were prepared to fight. They are in an unassailable position because without them the project cannot be carried on, and most public opinion and Parliament would react very strongly if this project had to be abandoned because the scientists felt that they were not given the working conditions that would enable them to carry on efficiently. What is needed now for this is concerted action by all scientists. The new organisation under the Ministry of Supply was, I believe, accepted by Cockroft and yourself before anyone else knew what was proposed. Since Cockroft and you are the people who primarily have to fight out all these difficulties, very clearly no-one can raise a major protest against such arrangements as long as you two feel that you can make a satisfactory job of the proposed arrangements. It was certainly no-one’s desire to make life more difficult for you than it is. What has gone wrong, I think, is that there is insufficient contact and cooperation between all the people who essentially are in agreement on the objects, and, in broad outline, what is needed to implement them, and I think that minor differences of opinion in technical or administrative matters have now been allowed to prevent concerted action in major matters. I feel sure that for the past years all the members of the Technical Committee, as well as Akers and Perrin, were in essential agreement on what had to be done, yet in talking to any of them (and I do not except myself) one would hear more criticism of the others, of their technical views, of how they handled a particular question of organisation or policy, than of essential agreement and concerted action. The result is that the enormous prestige and power which the scientists possess is, in fact, lost. The only way in which we can bring pressure to bear is by making clear that there are certain limits beyond which we are not prepared to go, and that if the government depart-
April 7, 2009
52
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ments want our collaboration they have to adhere to these limits or else they will not have us. It should not be necessary to carry things far enough to threaten resignation, or actually resign, but if things are handled in such a way that it is perfectly clear that certain steps will not be tolerated by the scientists it will have the same effect. This, of course, is a weapon that must be used very cautiously and to use it lightheartedly over minor matters would weaken our position more than not to use it at all. But I cannot help feeling, on looking at the present state of the project in this country, that things have been allowed to go too far and that if we had been in a position to get together and review the situation from time to time we would have found the point at which to dig our feet in. Things were, of course, made difficult by the dispersion of the team across the Atlantic and the unavoidable break-up of the old Technical Committee. When, in due course, you and Cockroft get back and when we can again get together around a table, these things will be easier, but it does not look as if this can be achieved very soon, meanwhile the organisation may have drifted a long way in a direction from which it is hard to retrieve it and in any case time will have been lost which, from every point of view, is most vital. I cannot offer any very constructive suggestion as to what should be done about it, except generally to stress the importance of trying to spread amongst this group, as far as possible, information on what action will be or has been taken and the reasons for which it may or may not be wise to accept such action and on people’s attitude in general. I believe it is our job now, being on the spot and in close touch with the set-up here, to keep you and Cockroft informed of what is going wrong, and it is for you and Cockroft, as the people with the best knowledge of policy and the contacts at a higher level, to give us a lead in saying how far one must compromise and at what point one should stop. A relatively minor point compared with all this, is the following. I believe there is some kind of vicious circle as regards Harwell, in that many people who will eventually go to Harwell are still in Canada because there is little for them to do here and there is a tendency for construction work at Harwell to be delayed because the urgency is not appreciated as long as the people who want to get to work are not on
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
53
the spot. I believe that if all the people who are not essentially needed in Canada, but who are merely remaining there to learn what they can while they cannot be used in Harwell, were to come back so that the place would be filled with people who were pressing for accommodation, which is about to be completed, for equipment, which theoretically was promised but has not arrived, then if there was someone waiting for each of the instruments which are on order, the job would in fact be accelerated and the result would be a saving of time, although it might appear to be an uneconomical use of the men. At the same time, as people collect there, the structure of the various teams, their plans and responsibilities, would begin to crystallize out and one would realise more clearly what is needed in the way of additional staff. It is essential that this should be done while men can still be found. I would therefore suggest that many of the people who can be spared from Canada should be brought back as soon as possible. This does not apply to all of them, since for the temperament of some people this situation I have described would have very unsatisfactory results and they might get dissatisfied with the project forever. One particular case I have in mind is Fuchs. In understand he is committed to stay in Los Alamos until June, and he is probably very useful there. I would feel strongly, however, that his commitments there should not be allowed to drag on and that, in the circumstances, he should not go to Canada after leaving Los Alamos, but should come back immediately to help settle the staff problems for his team, to discuss in broad outline the research programme and to choose the arrangements as regards machines, computers, etc. that will be required for this programme. If, when this is done, there is still nothing for him to do (this seems to me to be quite unlikely), he could still visit Canada afterwards and get some experience there. I believe, however, that from Montreal reports and from discussions with Buneman, Guggenheim, Pryce and others, he could, in fact, learn as much from a visit in Chalk River. Another case which occurred to me was Arms. I do not know what he is doing and it may be of vital importance, but if it is not, I believe that he would help accelerate matters a good deal by chasing around after equipment and helping in the layout of laboratories, workshops, etc. and that he would do this quite readily if the situation were explained
April 7, 2009
54
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
to him, even though it would mean that for a few months he would not do any scientific work. It is a relief to get all of this off my chest, and I would be very glad to hear whether you think I am misunderstanding the situation or whether you agree with my attitude. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[403] Ed Salpeter to Rudolf Peierls Santa Fe, 19.5.1946 Dear Rudy, I thank you very much for your several letters concerning the Research Fellowships at Birmingham. I have waited to obtain the opinion and advice of others before reaching my decision, which is that I should like my name to be considered as that of a candidate for a junior fellowship. I have come to this conclusion after weighing the disadvantages of (or rather my antipathy towards) living in your city against the following points — first the opportunity to participate in a more general field of fundamental research, second the probability of making contact with a wider circle of people, and third, which is perhaps the most decisive, my feeling that this would leave most open the ultimate direction of my career. These last points are chiefly in comparison with going to Harwell, as regards other possibilities I have thought it desirable not to leave things until I should return to England. I am sending a formal application to the Secretary of the Faculty of Science. Please give my best wishes to Genia and the children, and I shall look forward to seeing you all in the summer. Yours sincerely, Ed Salpeter
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
55
[404] Rudolf Peierls to Max Born [Birmingham], 12.6.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Born, Thank you for your information about Miss Walker.90 I had also encouraging reports from other people and we shall ask her for interview as soon as that can be arranged. I saw Dirac the other day and he mentioned to me the remark in your letter about Heisenberg. I do not think the matter will arise because I do not believe that Planck is being invited and I understand, in fact, that the committee organising the Conference have ruled against inviting any Germans.91 I feel one must be careful about pressing for admission of people like Heisenberg, since I believe that for the resumption of international contacts it is essential that people should be made to understand the distinction between the behaviour of people like Laue and Hahn, of whom one hears from all sides that they have kept aloof from all government activities and have resisted any temptation to ingratiate themselves with the Nazis either by collaborating or making public statements, and the others of whom this seems much less clear. For example, the chief reason for excluding Germans from the coming conference seems to have been the argument that it would cause resentment among the people from the occupied countries. I believe, in fact, that amongst the latter, in particular the Dutch, Belgian and French people, the part played by Laue and Hahn is well known and that they would not have resented their coming, whereas they would have resented it if Heisenberg or Becker or others had been asked. They would, in fact, have appreciated it if their opinion had been obtained about people who could be trusted. The whole problem is very difficult and one has, of course, to remember that Heisenberg is by far the best scientist of all the ones mentioned and in any question depending solely on scientific merit all other arguments should not count; but, in fact, in a conference of the kind 90 91
Letter could not be located. See also item [440].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
56
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
planned in Cambridge, scientific discussions will be inseparable from social gatherings and I, for one, while I would welcome an opportunity to hear Heisenberg’s ideas on scientific matters and discuss them, would feel very reluctant to have any social contact with him until we are able to take a more detached view of the past than we can do just yet. These problems are most complicated and I would be glad to know what you think. Fuchs is still in Los Alamos but is due to leave there in few days and I expect he will be back in this country early in July. I imagine he will get in touch with you as soon as he gets back. No doubt you have heard that he has accepted a job at the new Atomic Energy Research Establishment at Harwell. If you want to get hold of him urgently, a letter addressed to him c/o J.F.Jackson, P.O.Box 680, Benjamin Franklin Station, Washington, 4, D.C. will reach him until he leaves North America. I hope to see you at the Cambridge meeting in July. Will you be staying in the south between 11th and 22nd, and if so is there any chance that you could spend a day or so in Birmingham? I expect to have Rosenfeld here at that time and he would, of course, love a chance of seeing you. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[405] Max Born to Rudolf Peierls [Edinburgh] 13.6.1946 Dear Peierls, Thank you for your letter and the interesting remarks about the German physicists.92 About 2 years ago, when I was a member of the Sectional Committee for Math[ematics] of the R[oyal] S[ociety], Dirac asked me to join him in proposing Heisenberg for election as a Foreign Fellow of the R.S. After some consideration I refused and kept to this decision in 92
See letter [404].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
57
spite of Dirac’s persuasion who rightly said that Heisenberg’s discovery will be remembered when Hitler is completely forgotten. I said I would reconsider the matter after the war when we had the opportunity of knowing exactly how far H[eisenberg] has collaborated with the Nazis. Meanwhile I have heard contradictory reports. He was certainly not behaving like Laue and Hahn. But it is said he tried to obstruct the development of nuclear explosives. I do not know whether this is true. My feeling is now that these fellows have got their punishment. They are not only having a hard life and little to eat, but their conceit is badly shaken. In my letter to Dirac I wanted to show that I was prepared to reconsider the question. But if you object, and if the people of the occupied countries object I shall not move any further. Heisenberg’s new papers on relativistic quantum mechanics (Z. f. Phys. 120, pp. 53, 675, 1943)93 have impressed me rather much. They contain no solution of the difficulties, but they clear away some rubbish. I hoped that Peng’s work had removed some of the infinities,94 but I got a letter from him telling me that there is a mistake in it and just these results are wrong. My own ideas look to me quite promising but I am too old and tired to work them out alone, and I have no collaborator suited for this kind of work. I hope Fuchs may spend some holiday weeks in helping me, when he returns. I shall write to him. I shall be in the south between July 11th and 22nd, and I intend to visit my daughters, Irene in Cambridge and Gritly in Oxford. I should like [to] spend a day or two in Birmingham, if it would fit in. I shall let you know. With kind regards, Yours, M. Born
93
W. Heisenberg, ‘Die beobachtbaren Gr¨ ossen in der Theorie der Elementarteilchen. I’, Z. Phys. 120, 513–38 (1943); and W. Heisenberg, ‘Die beobachtbaren Gr¨ ossen in der Theorie der Elementarteilchen. II’, Z. Phys. 120, 673–702 (1943). 94 Huan-Wu Peng, educated at Tshingua University, was working with Heitler at the Institute of Advanced Study in Dublin. In 1944 he had published some papers jointly with Max Born. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh 62, 40, 92, 127 (1944).
April 7, 2009
12:11
58
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[406] Rudolf Peierls to Max Born [Birmingham], 14.6.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Born, Thank you for your letter.95 I am glad to know your views on this question and if you will be in the south next month I hope we shall have to opportunity to talk about this. If you were in Oxford, you might like also to discuss the question with Simon, who, I believe, has strong feelings in the matter. I have just seen Peng’s paper in the P.R.S.96 and, while it is very interesting, it seems to me that he has not given enough information to say really how the calculation should be carried out. It does justify, however, the hope that something can be done along those lines and I hope his new calculations, which you mention, will not dispose of this completely. I am not at all impressed with Heisenberg’s new scheme or Møller’s work on the same subject.97 It seems to me quite an empty scheme which is completely indefinite until one formulates the laws to which his matrix S is subjected. One might, of course, hope ultimately that the matrix S itself will be found to obey some very simple laws, but since these must contain ordinary quantum theory as a limiting case and since in the ordinary case of a collision with non-Coulomb forces the expressions for S become extremely complicated, I do not see much hope in that direction. I did hear from Dirac about your idea of linking this up with “reciprocity” and that is very interesting, but I always had grave doubts as to what would happen to the reciprocity in a many bodied problem. 95
Letter [405]. H.-W.Peng, ‘On the divergence difficulty of quantized field theories and the rigorous treatment of radiation reaction’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A186, 119–147. 97 See letter [405], note 93. 96
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
59
I would be extremely happy to see you here in July. So far I have no definite engagements during the time you mention, but no doubt there will be all sorts of meetings. As Rosenfeld will probably be staying with us, we may not be able to offer you a room, but I am sure something can be fixed up, if it would be convenient for you to stay overnight. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls] [407] Rudolf Peierls to Y.I. Frenkel [Birmingham], 20.6.1946 (carbon copy) Dear Frenkel, I have now for some months been back at my normal job at Birmingham and I am trying hard to settle down again to some more normal work. I imagine you will be in a very similar position. I do not know whether you are back in Leningrad yet, but I hope this letter will reach you anyway. Has your institute suffered very much, and have you been able to resume work there? I have seen the many papers you have published during the last years and been very interested in many of them. I expect that I myself shall try to work chiefly on field theory, meson theory and the theory of nuclei. On the latter we still have to finish some work started in Copenhagen before the war. I am at present trying to revive the idea of introducing a finite length into the theory of the electron, in order to remove the infinities, and I have found a way of doing this in classical theory without destroying Lorentz invariants, but at the expense of obtaining the field equations and the equations of motion in the form of integral equations in time. Classically, it all looks straightforward, but we have not yet succeeded in quantising the theory. I am not at all convinced that this is the right approach, but I am also not very impressed with the view of Dirac, since I do not like his reinterpretation of the negative possibilities, nor do I believe the recent theories of strong coupling. The recent attempts by Peng to prove that
April 7, 2009
12:11
60
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
all the infinities are merely due to the perturbation and that the field equations have finite solutions is very intriguing, but I do not see how this particular method of solution can be right.98 Many of these problems will, of course, be discussed at the International Conference in Cambridge in July and I very much hope that you will be able to accept the invitation to the Conference. It would be very nice to have a really good discussion of physical problems again after so many years and I believe that just now the resumption of normal contacts between scientists is of enormous importance. I am trying to build up a bigger team here, of whom some, of course, will be rather junior. With this, and through the collaboration with Oliphant’s department, who are completing the installation of a cyclotron now and are working on a machine for very much higher energies, I am looking forward to a very interesting time. My family are back in Birmingham, too. With the great housing shortage it was quite a problem to find a place to live, but in the end we were lucky and got settled quite comfortably. The children are at school again and life is now more or less back to normal. I very much hope to see you at Cambridge in July, but if you will not be there I should greatly enjoy hearing from you again about your family and friends. With very best wishes, Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[408] Y.I. Frenkel to Rudolf Peierls Leningrad, 21.6.[1946] Dear Peierls, Thank you very much for your kind invitation to the conference. I shall be very glad to attend it, if that proves possible. Among other things I would like to discuss the question of relativistic quantum theory of 98
See letters [405–406], notes 94 and 96.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
61
complex particles, which I have considered rather loosely a couple of years ago. I have transferred your letter to the Academy of Sciences and shall telegraph, if I get a positive answer to my application. I hope you are all well. Please give my kindest regards to Jenney and to our common friends. Yours sincerely, J. Frenkel
[409] Y.I. Frenkel to Rudolf Peierls Leningrad, 21.7.1946 My dear Peierls, Although I wrote you a few lines through a young physicist [??] who was expected to go to England, I am writing you again in reply to your letter of June 20th99 which I received on the next day after sending you a telegram informing that I had just seen Jenney’s parents in good health at Moscow (you probably interpreted this telegram as a preliminary reply to your letter.) After 3 1/2 dreary years spent with my family in Kazan (where I lost my mother in 1944) we came back to Leningrad, rather amazed at the possibility of returning to our pre-war relatively comfortable existence. I changed my old flat for a better one, further away from the street and was lucky to find most of our furniture and other belongings, including the books, more or less intact. At the beginning of the war it seemed unthinkable that we should ever come back to the pre-war conditions. In some respects this maybe true, (particularly in America); but in regard to our living conditions — especially those of the scientific workers in large cities — we have practically reached to pre-war status owing to a number of facilities put at our disposal by the government. This may be illustrated by the fact that a great many scientists — of all professions 99
Letter [407].
April 7, 2009
12:11
62
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
myself including are buying cars for our own private use. As a result of adverse living conditions and various troubles during the war period, I have developed a hypertonia, (i.e. abnormally high blood pressure or arterial tension), which I have to take care at present. Last year, when it was discovered, I succeeded to get rid of it after one month’s rest at a sanatorium near Moscow. I am afraid that this will take longer this time. Outside my childhood I have never [been] sick in my life, and it worried me terribly to have to follow the prescription of the physicians. With respect to r´egime etc. in fact I have not begun to follow them yet, but shall try to be a “good boy” in a sanatorium near Riga where I am going in a few days with all my family for 4 weeks. My wife is always “so-so”, since 1943 owing to an abdominal haemorage; but as a whole her health has improved since 1936 when she suffered from acute haemorages due to her trombopenia. The children are prosperous; The elder (23 years) studies physics at the polytechnical institute but is more interested in poetry (he has written and translated a number of excellent verses) and in chess; the younger will graduate his high school next year, but has not chosen any profession yet.100 I have been pretty active scientifically both at Kazan, and after my return therefrom to Leningrad. Unfortunately my activity has recently been arrested by my hypertonia and the associated headaches. As soon as I return to good health I shall set to work again. As usual I am interested in a large variety of different problems, which prevents me from digging deeply enough in a single place. I am of course very much interested in the problem of fundamental particles and field theory. I think, however, that the present dualistic treatment, in which the particles and the field are dealt with as two independent components of the whole is fundamentally wrong and that the particles must be considered as secondary entities, produced by the quantization of the field
100
Viktor Zakovlevich Frenkel (1930–1997), became a physicist and historian of science in his own right. From 1948 he studied physics and mechanics at the Leningrad Polytechnic Institute. After work for the Svetlana Works on the design and construction of electrovacuum devices he joined the theoretical department of the Ioffe Institute of Engineering Physics in 1959, to which he remained attached until his death in 1997.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
63
which is the bearer of all mechanical properties (energy, momentum, etc., there being no such thing as the kinetic energy of the particles or their mutual energy with the field). The actual realization of this monistic programme which has been initiated by Lorentz’ theory of electron is of course very difficult; a modification of Lorentz’ theory by introducing a certain length into the field equation may help to solve it. What do you think of my approach to the problem of the relativistic quantum theory of complex particles (I think I have sent you reprint thereof.),101 which I propose to treat as elementary particles with internal degrees of freedom. I have recently written another paper which may interest you on the asymmetrical splitting of heavy nuclei.102 I shall send you a reprint as soon as it will be available. One of my luckiest achievements during the recent two years is probably a theory of atmospheric electricity which I have succeeded to greatly improve quite recently. I also shall have a team of about 10 young people working with me during the next term. Most of them have been recently demobilized and require a certain induction period for beginning research work. All our common friends in Moscow (Tamm, Landau, etc.) are in good health and probably will write to you themselves. I am visiting Moscow regularly once a month, owing to my association with two research institutions there (one in geophysics, the other in molecular physics). It is a great pity that the present state of international affairs does not enable us to establish a direct contact with our colleagues and friends abroad. Let us hope that the situation will change for the better soon and that we shall be able to discuss scientific and other matters soon in a less cumbersome way than letter-writing.
101
J. Frenkel, ‘On the theory of relaxation losses, connected with magnetic resonance in solid bodies’, J. Phys. (U.S.S.R.) 9, 299–304 (1945). 102 J. Frenkel, ‘Some features of the process of fission of heavy nuclei’, J. Phys. (U.S.S.R.) 10, 533–539 (1946) Frenkel had been working on the splitting of heavy nuclei for several years. See also Frenkel, J., ‘On the Splitting of Heavy Nuclei by Slow Neutrons’, Phys. Rev. 55, 987 (1939).
April 7, 2009
12:11
64
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Give my best regards to Jenny — also from my wife — and from us both to yourself. Cordially yours, J. Frenkel Will you kindly subscribe me to the “Vogue”. The expense will be covered by the Oxford Press which are just going to produce a new book of mine.103 If you get across some really interesting book (fiction) please also send us a copy (stating the price). My wife will be very grateful to you for such things.
[410] Tony Skyrme to Rudolf Peierls Santa Fe, 29.7.1946 Dear Rudy, I had better acquaint you with the arrangements that I have made for the transmission to England of the document that I have decided to submit as a dissertation at Trinity College, Cambridge. At the moment this is in the General’s Office in Washington for clearance; in the rather unlikely event that it should be completely declassified I have arranged that it shall be sent directly to Trinity. I anticipate that it will remain more or less classified; and in this case I have asked the Washington Office to transmit it to you, as a responsible person who can keep custody of it. I have informed Trinity College of this arrangement and have asked them to tell you to which authorised person(s) they would wish the document to be transmitted for examination. With regard to my leaving this country, I have applied for a passage home early in September; however, no sailing dates are yet known and I shall fit my plans to this date when I learn it. I shall leave Los Alamos at the end of this week and go to the West Coast and then up to Vancouver; 103
J. Frenkel, Kinetic Theory of Liquids, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1946.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
65
I shall arrange that any mail reaching here during August is forwarded to me. Mrs Daily has asked me to be remembered to you; with best wishes to your family, Yours sincerely, Tony Skyrme
[411] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 26.8.1946 Dear Oppy, I am writing to let you know that one of our Members of Parliament, Captain Raymond Blackburn, is expecting to be in the United States from about September 3rd to September 27th and is most anxious to see you. His contacts are arranged largely through the Atomic Scientists of Chicago. He hopes to spend the first week of his stay on the west coast and if you are in California he would, if possible, like to see you during that first week. I think you will find it worth your while talking to him. He is a young Labour M.P. who has made atomic energy his special interest and he has repeatedly pressed in Parliament for a constructive discussion and for a statement supporting the Lilienthal Report.104 He is, of course, not a scientist and his knowledge and judgement have not always been perfect, but I think it is most important that we should keep reasonable people like him as well informed as we are permitted to do. I heard from Oliphant that you were critical of the statement by the British Atomic Scientists on international control on the grounds that it recommended U.N.O. continued making bombs. This was I believe, based on press reports and in the meantime you will have seen the full text of our statement which was reprinted in the Chicago Bulletin and 104
‘A Report on the International Control of Atomic Energy’, prepared for the Secretary of State’s Committee on Atomic Energy, Washington D.C., Dept. of State Publication 2498, 16.3.1946.
April 7, 2009
12:11
66
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
you will have seen that we have tried to keep an open mind on this question. I would be very interested to know if you still disapprove. Here quite a stir has been caused by press extracts from an article by Urey in “Air Affairs” in which he is supposed to have said the United States might be forced to declare war itself “with the frank purpose of conquering the world and ruling it as desired and preventing any other sovereign nation from developing mass weapons of war.”105 This has produced a rather unfortunate effect, although I feel sure that the words must have appeared in the context that gave them a different meaning from that which they convey by themselves.∗ We have regretted very much that you could not come to Cambridge. It was quite a successful and stimulating meeting, but it would have been better if we had had your views as well. With best wishes, Yours sincerely, R. Peierls ∗ We
have now seen the full text and confirmed this. Though I still think his wording was unfortunate.
[412] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe Birmingham, 24.1.1947 Dear Hans, There are many things to write about after such a long time but for the moment I shall leave the domestic matters and write only about shop. My department has got going and we have started on quite a number of problems, although we have not as yet produced much in the way of results. I would like, in this letter, however, to tell you what we are doing, for two reasons: firstly I would be glad of your comments on any 105
See Harold C. Urey’s papers, University of San Diego, Series 1, Box 135, folder 5.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
67
of these points and, secondly, many of the problems are of such a type that I rather expect someone in America is also thinking about them. In that case it is quite likely that you may know and, while it may be quite worth while to go ahead tackling such problems in several independent ways, it would in any case be a comfort to us to know. I think I can best describe our work by listing the people who are here and what they are doing. Jahn106 is a man whose name I am sure you know. He has been here since August and in connection with his knowledge of group theory he was particularly interested in Wigner’s theory of symmetries in nuclei. His ultimate aim is to see which of Wigner’s results, in particular about the most reasonable coupling to assume, have to be modified in the light of the existence of non-central forces. No doubt this problem is also being thought about by other people, but we want to know the answers and want to learn the techniques. For the moment he is trying to alter the presentation of the Wigner theory by bringing in the explicit representation of the permutation group to see why the results appear only to depend on whether the nucleus is of the type 4, 4r + 1 etc., although for the derivation one has to use explicitly the permutation groups of a higher order. What he is trying to do is analogous to Slater’s method in the case of the atom. This, I think, would be a very useful step.107 Preston,108 a pupil of Infeld’s from Toronto, came here with an almost completed paper on the theory of alpha-decay.109 This carried the one-body-problem to a logical conclusion, fitting the 106
Hermann Arthur Jahn (1907–1979) studied under Heisenberg and van der Waerden in Leipzig, joined Peierls’ department in 1946 and later became professor of applied mathematics in Southampton. 107 See among others H.A. Jahn, and J. Hope, ‘Symmetry Properties of the Wigner 9j Symbol’, Phys. Rev. 93, 318–21 (1954). 108 Melvin A. Preston, studied at Toronto before joining Peierls’ research team in Birmingham where he completed his Ph.D.. In 1953 he returned to McMaster, where, apart from a few years at Saskatchewan, he spent the rest of his career. 109 M.A. Preston, ‘The Theory of Alpha-Radioactivity’, Phys. Rev. 71, 865–77 (1947).
April 7, 2009
12:11
68
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
phases of the wave function inside the nucleus and using an exact analytical solution, even for the case l = 0. It is doubtful whether it makes sense to carry the one-body model that far but in the course of his calculations two interesting points have come out: (1) the formula given by Gamov from the transparency barrier in the case l = 0 is completely wrong110 and based on an inaccurate evaluation of the integral, which, of course, with some trouble can be done in closed form. Apparently this wrong formula has been used ever since, e.g. by you. (2) In the one-body model, the transparency of the barrier as a function of l first increases and then decreases. This surprising result is due to the fact that if you always assume a rectangular potential barrier, but fit its eigenvalue correctly, higher l forces you, for the same total energy, to assume a deeper well (because of the effect of the centrifugal term) and therefore both the density and velocity near the edge of the nucleus increases. It is, of course, very questionable whether this feature of the one-body problem has a real meaning, but it might have and there seems some evidence that the assumption of the decay constant behaving in that way allows a somewhat better fit for the experimental data. Preston is also working on an explanation of Chang’s peculiar results on alpha fine structure assuming that the nucleus is excited by long-range Coulomb forces after passing the potential barrier.111 A simple calculation regarding the alpha-particle as a classical point charge gives a perfectly reasonable estimate for the probability. We felt, however, that this should be done more decently and we struck some snags in that calculation which have dissolved themselves now, leaving him only with somewhat nasty integrals to evaluate. We have seen now a reference to work by
110
G.A. Gamow, Constitution of Atomic Nuclei and Radioactivity, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1931, pp. 91 and 103; G.A. Gamow, ‘Zur Quantentheorie des Atomkernes’, Z. Phys. 51, 204–212 (1928). 111 W.Y. Chang, ‘A Study of Alpha-Particles from Po with a Cyclotron-Magnet Alpha-Ray Spectrograph’, Phys. Rev. 69, 60–77 (1946); W.Y. Chang, ‘Low-Energy Alpha-Particles from Radium’, Phys. Rev. 70, 632–39 (1946).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
69
Dancoff112 on the same idea but, as from this it is quite impossible to understand how Dancoff has done the calculation or what the answer is, we propose to continue. In any case, it is a fascinating problem.113 When this is finished he will tackle the question of the effect of non-central forces on proton-proton scattering. This, of course, appears only at higher l and therefore at higher energies than the p − n scattering, but it is likely that such energies will be, or in fact have been, reached. In this connection we computed for the experimentalists some curves for the angular distribution of the p − p scattering at about 13 MeV and the curves are very entertaining. They mean, in particular, that in order to sort out the contributions of s, p, etc. waves, one has to measure the scattering with quite a fine angular definition. Experiments along these lines are planned here now, but as the cyclotron is not working yet they will have to wait. Skyrme is studying the problem arising from the dispersion formula (Bethe-Placzek,114 Kapur-Peierls etc.)115 with a view to seeing what one can get out about potential scattering and the like. We have just received Wigner’s latest papers on this subject116 but do not appreciate yet to what extent they dispose of the problem. Skyrme has also given a tidier proof of the completeness of the complex eigenfunctions used in my paper with Kapur. 112
S.M. Dancoff, Metallurgical Project Report, Short Range Alphas in Natural Radioactivity. 113 Preston published his results two years later in M.A.Preston,‘The Electrostatic Interaction and Low Energy Particles in Alpha-Radioactivity’, Phys. Rev. 75, 90–99 (1949). 114 H.A. Bethe and G. Placzek, ‘Resonance Effects in Nuclear Processes’, Phys. Rev. 51, 450–89 (1937). 115 P.L. Kapur and R. Peierls, ‘The dispersion formula for nuclear reactions’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A166, (1938), 277–95. 116 Eugene P. Wigner, ‘Resonance Reactions’, Phys. Rev. 70, 606–18 (1946).
April 7, 2009
12:11
70
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Salpeter,117 an Austro-American, is tackling the problem of self-energy and has succeeded in proving that (contrary to the idea of Peng’s paper118 ) the infinities are not due to using perturbation theory, at least in the following sense: if the integrals are cut off at a certain maximum wave factor k0 and the wave equation are then solved rigorously for any k0 : then in the limit k0 = ∞ the energy tends to infinity. This proof is now complete for all one particle problems. In the relativistic one-electron problem it leads to a divergence as dk rather than k, as in Waller’s case. This, however, we have convinced ourselves, justifies no hope of a similar improvement in the Weisskopf case. The next step would be, of course, to try and generalise such a proof to Weisskopf’s case of pair theory.119 In attempting this, however, we discovered that Weisskopf’s method is wrong, since the subtraction of the infinite charge density due to the electrons in negative states is done by reference to the states in zero field comparing the two infinite sums, term by term, for the same momentum. Since, however, momentum is not gauge invariant, the whole procedure is not gauge invariant, as I have shown years ago in the Royal Society Proceedings. This makes the whole theory inconsistent, since in the ordinary quantum electro-dynamics used by Weisskopf the relation divE = 4πρ can hold at all times only if all interactions are gauge invariant. We are trying to put this right, but cannot say yet whether this will affect Weisskopf’s result.
117
Edwin E. Salpeter (1924–), a graduate from the University of Sydney, completed his Ph.D. under R. Peierls in 1948. He then moved on to Cornell, where he became professor of physics in 1957. 118 H.W. Peng, ‘On the representation of the wave function of a quantized field by means of a generating function’, Proc. Roy. Ir. Acad. 51, 113-22 (1947). 119 Weisskopf had published several papers on self-energy. See e.g. V. Weisskopf, ‘On Self Energy and the Electromagnetic Field of the Electron’, Phys. Rev. 56, 72–85 (1939). See also R.E. Marshak and V.F. Weisskopf, ‘On the Scattering of Mesons of Spin 1/2 by Atomic Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 59, 130–35 (1941). For a survey of developments in electron theory see V.Weisskopf, ‘Recent Developments in the Theory of the Electron’, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 305–15 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
71
McManus120 is still working on the field theory for finite size electron, of which you know the general idea. There were many snags in the mathematics but as far as the classical theory is concerned everything straightened itself out, with one exception: we have obtained the equation of motion of an electron without external field which, in this case is an integral equation. We can easily prove that this has a trivial solution corresponding to motion at constant velocity and also that if you add external fields you get the usual radiation terms up to the normal radiation damping, with corrections only of higher order in the frequency than the Lorentz damping. It seems very plausible that these should be the only solutions of the type of Dirac’s runaway solutions. We are still struggling, however, with a reasonable proof for this. As to the quantisation of such theory we need a brainwave but we have not yet given it up. An attempt to do this is also being made by Bleuler,121 one of Wentzel’s pupils whom I managed to get largely through your good offices and who also is tackling one or two more formal problems in the theory of quantised fields. A young research student is just starting work on an attempt to calculate internal pair creation in the case of a gamma-ray of arbitrary multipole character.122 I do not believe this has ever been done but in the case of gamma-rays of energies well above 1MeV internal pair creation should be quite well observable and experiments on the sharing of energy between electron and positron or on their relative angular distribution ought to give a convenient way of determining the order of the multipole. This, of course, can also be done with internal conservation, but as for high gammaray energy and low atomic number in the distinction between K, 120
Hugh McManus who had been a research fellow at Birmingham before the war, returned to Birmingham from his war-time assignment at Chalk River, where he had been working at the Canadian atomic energy laboratory. He continued his work as a research fellow at Birmingham until 1951 and eventually became professor of physics at Michigan University. 121 Konrad Bleuler, (1912–1992), completed his Ph.D. under Wentzel’s supervision in Zurich. 122 The student was R.A. Fatehally.
April 7, 2009
72
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
L, etc. electrons may not be easy, this alternative method seems of interest. This, in particular is a problem which one would hardly like to duplicate, so if you know of anyone else doing this I would be glad to know. Krook,123 a South African who formerly worked on astrophysics, is trying to calculate the continuous gamma-ray spectrum emitted in a proton-neutron collision when the neutron is not captured. For low energies, this will, of course, be quite a small effect although it should be observable. For high energies, it will be more likely than capture and may there help to get information about forces. What is planned at present is to calculate it for some simple type of force so as to have this available for comparison when we get experimental date. Another research student is looking into Landau’s theory of liquid helium.124 We are rather dissatisfied with that theory because, while it makes out an excellent case for the existence of what Landau calls “rotons”, he assumes that there is a lower limit to the roton spectrum from dimensional arguments, leaving out of account that there is a dimensionless number, namely the number of helium atoms, which may enter into this result. We think it should, in fact, be possible to prove that this is the case and that for a reasonable amount of helium the lowest roton level is practically zero. This, however, is not quite an easy problem. It is mathematically connected with the old problem of the rotation of nuclei, on which I am dissatisfied with the paper by Teller and Wheeler.125 Probably if one can decently solve one of the two problems one can also get the solution to the other. 123 Max Krook, had studied astrophysics at Cambridge before becoming research fellow at Birmingham. Eventually, he returned to astrophysics, becoming professor at Harvard. 124 After the discovery of superfluidity and liquid helium in 1938, Lev Landau constructed a theory of ‘quantum liquids’ at very low temperatures. His papers between 1941 and 1947 are concerned with the quantum liquids of the ‘Bose type’ such as the superfluid liquid helium (4 He). 125 E. Teller and J.A. Wheeler, ‘On the Rotation of Atomic Nucleus’, Phys. Rev. 53, 778–89 (1938).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
73
Another research student is learning all about luminescence in solids in order to assist Garlick126 (whom I believe you met at a recent meeting at Cornell) in the analysis of the rather interesting experiments he is doing here. Kynch,127 who is rather busy with teaching, is working on the non-central forces in the nucleus. There seems, in particular, a peculiar discrepancy between your result and a similar result of Schwinger and Rarita on the one hand128 and the result of Rosenfeld and Møller on the other.129 You find that in order to account for the observed quadrupole moment of deuteron one has to assume a very strong tensor force, comparable in order of magnitude to the central force. Møller and Rosenfeld start with a tensor force which, coming only from the non-static terms, is about ten times smaller, treat it with perturbation theory and get the right quadrupole moment. One would say, at first sight that this simply means the perturbation theory is not justified, but it is the same kind of perturbation theory that one uses for calculating the fine structure in the atom and there we are reasonably confident that it works. It might, in fact, be that because of the peculiar nature of the problem the perturbation theory is more trustworthy than the rigorous solution. In this connection Kynch is also exploring 126 G.F.J. Garlick was experimenting with phosphors and phosphorescence. See G.F.J. Garlick, ‘Phosphors and Phosphorescence’, Rep. Prog. Phys 12, 34–55 (1948). He later published a joint paper with Fatehally: G.F.J. Garlick and R.A. Fatehally, ‘Measurement of Particle Energies with Scintillation Counters’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1446 (1949). 127 J.G. Kynch (1915–2003) had studied theoretical physics at Imperial College, London, he joined the Birmingham department initially to take over Rudolf Peierls’ teaching, while the latter was engaged in work for the M.A.U.D. committee. His temporary appointment was extended several times and he stayed until 1952 when he accepted the Chair of Applied Mathematics at University College of Aberystwyth. In 1957 he became professor of mathematics at UMIST. 128 W. Rarita and J. Schwinger, ‘On Neutron-Proton Interaction’, Phys. Rev. 59, 436–52 (1941); W. Rarita and J. Schwinger, ‘On the Exchange Properties of NeutronProton Interaction’, Phys. Rev. 59, 556–64 (1941). 129 C. Møller and L. Rosenfeld, Kgl. Danske Vid. Math.-Fys. Med. 17, No. 8 (1940); C. Møller and L. Rosenfeld, Kgl. Danske Vid. Math.-Fys. Med. 23, No 13 (1945).
April 7, 2009
12:11
74
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the use of the Svartholm method, which treats the Schr¨ odinger equation as an integral equation in momentum space and uses iteration. It appears that this works also for tensor forces and is, in fact, quite convenient. This, I think, completed the list, except that I have not said what I am doing, but that is easy — I sit on committees and write letters. I shall be writing about other things soon. Yours sincerely, Rudi
[413] G. Placzek to Rudolf Peierls Schenectady, 7.3.1947 Dear Peierls, Many thanks for your detailed letter130 and the statement of the Council of the British Atomic Scientists, which I have read with great interest. It tends to show that, if even scientists of one nation cannot agree in the fundamentals of the matter we need not be surprised to see the politicians landed in the present hopeless mess. You are probably aware that the statement has been extensively misquoted by Mr. Gromyko in yesterday’s session of the Security Council.131 This is of course not your fault since even if it had been possible to write it from a more unified point of view, this would not have afforded protection against distortions. I hope you can get a verbatim copy of the speech, it was rather long and the papers left out the most interesting passages. I happened to listen to it on the radio and it was rather characteristic to hear Gromyko state in terms which were clearly sincere conviction that the idea of an inspector who could freely travel 130
Letter could not be located. On 5 March 1947 Soviet foreign minister Gromyko gave a speech in the U.N. Security Council denouncing American nuclear policy. See New York Times, 5.3.1947, p. 16. 131
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
75
in a “foreign” country and even fly over it, could not have been meant seriously. The Russians, of course, have by no means a monopoly on such a mentality; the recent statement by Senator Taft, warning against the danger that communists might “infiltrate” into an international control agency, is on a very similar level. Enclosed a pictorial record of yesterday’s meeting, taken from today’s New York Times. You will probably enjoy the subscript. I am afraid I cannot entirely share the Olympian detachment of your American military friend who hopes that chances of an agreement might be better once stories of successful Russian bomb manufacture begin to circulate. I am rather inclined to believe the opposite. But, unfortunately, we shall see. Clayton132 (from Chalk River) asked me for a copy of the table of the exponential integral for complex argument, so that he could forward it to you. Unfortunately I have no copy here. I believe I left one at Montreal, but whether or not this is so, they cannot find it. The rest of the copies is in Carlson’s hands133 at Los Alamos and to extricate one from there, under present circumstances, might take longer than to have the whole tables recalculated. I therefore recommended to Clayton to get in touch with Lowan, (Math. Tables Project) who might have a spare copy or could perhaps get one reproduced. I hope you will keep me informed on the result of your and Skyrme’s investigations re Wigner Dispersion formula, and gauge invariance of Weisskopf’s logarithmic divergence. Newspaper reports here inspired, in some credulous souls, the hope that Schroedinger might have discovered the laws of the universe. Mr. W.L. Lawrence was speeded into action. Jumping at the opportunity to act as a great patron saint of science, he got hold of Schroedinger’s 132
Henry H. Clayton (1906–89), English-born physicists who had studied at the University of British Columbia. In 1945 he joined the Montreal Laboratory and moved to Chalk River in 1946. In 1950 he became head of the theoretical physics branch, a position held until his retirement in 1969. 133 Bengt Carlson (1915–), Swedish-born physicist who had studied at Stockholm and Yale. He worked in Placzek’s group at Montreal from April 1943.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
76
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
manuscript, had it photostated at the Times expense, and distributed far and wide throughout the country. Of course, it turned out to be bunk. A lesson for the above mentioned souls showing that the more traditional channels of scientific information still seem to be fully adequate. With best regards to you and Genia, yours sincerely, G. Placzek
[414] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick [location unspecified], 10.3.1947 Dear Chadwick, A few days ago the “Times” had an item about the last statement by Gromyko (I believe the date of the statement was 5th March) and in reporting this the American correspondent of the “Times” added that most of Gromyko’s ammunition seems to have been supplied by the memorandum from the British Atomic Scientists’ Association.134 In view of this we are naturally anxious, first of all, to get the verbatim text of Gromyko’s speech in order to see how he quoted us and whether the quotation was a fair one. I wonder whether you could be good enough to arrange for a transcript of this speech to be sent over by air mail? The “Times” statement rather implies that the quotation has made an unfavourable impression in America, although I conclude this merely from the use “ammunition.” Any comment you could make about this would, of course, be very welcome. We had, some time ago, a letter from the Executive Officer of the American Delegation, in reply to our memorandum, in which his main criticisms were that some of the points we were pressing had already been taken care of in some of Baruch’s 134
See letter [413].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
77
statements.135 This is, therefore, a useful confirmation that there seems to have been nothing in our memorandum that came as a violent shock to the American Delegation. Yours sincerely, R. Peierls I enclose copies of both our memoranda, in case they are of use in this connection.
[415] Otto Frisch to Rudolf Peierls [location unspecified], 10.3.1947 Dear Peierls, Cockroft asked me today whether I was interested in becoming his successor in Cambridge (that is the Jacksonian Chair, isn’t it?). I was not quite unprepared for this question since Dee had been here a few weeks ago and had told me that he felt he could not accept the offer and that he thought I would get asked next. Now this is a difficult decision to take. I feel a certain amount of loyalty towards Harwell, and I also think that in a year or two it might be quite a well-equipped place. On the other hand, the emphasis will always — and perhaps increasingly — be on the engineering side and though we shall be able to [d]o some pure research we shall probably do it with a bad conscience, feeling that we are not going all out to develop atomic energy. In Cambridge this should not be so, and I should be able to put my whole heart in the job. And of course Cambridge is a much nicer place. On the other hand, again, my administrative responsibilities will be even greater than here, I suppose, and my inexperience in University teaching will be a handicap. 135
Bernard Mannes Baruch (1870–1965) was the American delegate to the United Nations Atomic Energy Commission. On 14 June 1946 he had proposed the international control of atomic energy, the so-called Baruch-Plan.
April 7, 2009
78
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I should very much like to hear what you think about it. You know the setup in Cambridge well (so well that you declined a job there!) and you might help me to understand why that chair is so hard to fill. Also, you know me fairly well. I was very glad to hear from Fuchs that Genia is home again and that everything went well. I am going to Denmark and Sweden on Tuesday, returning immediately after Easter. (Unless I decide to cancel my berth in view of the Cambridge matter). I should be very thankful for a reply before I leave, please address it c/o Meitner, Flat 2, 85 West Hill, London, S.W.15. I shall be there on Friday night and again on Monday night, and I may go to Cambridge over the weekend or part of it. Yours, O.R.F.
[416] James Chadwick to Rudolf Peierls New York, 13.3.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Peierls, I sent yesterday to Philip Moon the verbatim record of the meeting of the Security Council on March 5th. This is the only complete record which I have and it is my own file copy, so that I shall want it back. Gromyko’s use of your memorandum was just a typical example of Russian methods. You will be able to judge for yourself whether it was fair or not. The Security Council and the audience were certainly rather surprised to find Gromyko supporting the Russian views by means of quotations from a memorandum by the British Atomic Scientists’ Association. Very few of them would, at any time, realise how dishonestly Gromyko was quoting, for very few read the memorandum. It was, as you know, published in the February issue of the Chicago Bulletin, but not many people outside the American, the Russian and our Delegation read this. Some of the journalists were naturally very interested to hear Gromyko claiming support for his thesis from English sources. They
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
79
pursued that matter, and two days later both the New York Times and the Herald Tribune carried articles which I enclose. I should like to have these back. Yours sincerely, [J. Chadwick]
[417] Rudolf Peierls to George Placzek [Birmingham], 24.4.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Placzek, Thank you for your letter of 7th March and the highly amusing picture of Uncle James.136 Meanwhile we have had the full text of Gromyko’s speech and, as you say, it is a very depressing document even if it has its amusing points. If, however, one looks at the earlier statements made at one time or another by Gromyko and Molotov and the many contradictions in them. It is clear that the fact of their saying decidedly “no” today rules out as little the possibility of their saying “yes” tomorrow as vice versa. As far as the British Atomic Scientists’ Association is concerned, we feel we ought to appoint Gromyko honorary publicity manager or something for the way he has put us on the map. With one exception his quotations are quite correct, although, of course, torn from the context they give the wrong impression. I saw the articles in the New York papers that followed Gromyko’s speech by a few days in which other passages from our memorandum were quoted, in this case, of course, carefully picking those parts in which we agree with the American point of view. I do not quite share your view that the document was quite futile; it is, of course, a question whether the present situation can be remedied at all by a rational discussion in the Atomic Energy Commission of the Security Council and it is likely that if any progress is made it may depend on discussions behind the scenes and on factors that have 136
Letter [413].
April 7, 2009
12:11
80
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
nothing to do with the problem in hand, but to the extent that it was worthwhile to keep rational discussion going I do believe that we have raised points where obstacles to the acceptance of the details could be removed. Even more amusing, perhaps, are the Senate hearings about Lilienthal.137 I enjoyed particularly the picture of Groves releasing the Smyth report against his better judgement because of the bullying of scientists. On the question of tables of the complex potential integral, it will be interesting to see what ultimately comes out of the revolutions in the wheels of the machine. In practice, as you may remember, there was a blueprint of the original typescript of those tables here and that is still accessible to us. We can therefore await further developments with patience, unless in the meantime, Lowan has carried out further subtabulation. On the general dispersion formula we have not yet made much progress beyond one small point: In the Kapur-Peierls method one expands the whole wave function inside the nucleus in a series of complex eigenfunctions. As a result, one gets a potential scattering term representing the scattering from a hard sphere and alongside with it a dispersion sum which seems to converge rather slowly. Skyrme has pointed out that one could equally use an alternative procedure, namely to expand not the whole of the function but its difference from the incident plane wave. In that case the potential scattering term represents the Born approximation and, in particular, the artificially chosen nuclear radius no longer appears explicitly. For high energies of the incident neutron it seems fairly clear that in this formula the contribution from the distant terms of the dispersion sum are smaller than in the alternative case. This will certainly be proved when the energies are so high that the Born approximation becomes a useful approximation and is likely to be true even for somewhat lower energies. Once one has recognised that there is this amount of freedom in the method, a third alternative immediately suggests itself and that is to 137
On 4 February 1947 David E. Lilienthal had issued a controversial statement ‘This I Deeply Believe’, also known as the ‘Credo’. See David E. Lilienthal Papers, Volume 1, 1900–1949, Box 118–119. Princeton University Library.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
81
start by solving a one-body problem with a complex potential representing, in other words, the nucleus as a black rather than a reflecting sphere, and after subtracting the wave functions ascertained from the whole wave function expand the residue in a series as before. This means using the theory of a black nucleus as developed by Bethe as a starting point. Evidently this will lead to a formula in which the potential scattering appears explicitly as that due to a black sphere and added to it there will be again a dispersion sum. On physical grounds I suspect that this description would be the most convenient one, i.e. it would make the dispersion sum converge more rapidly than the alternatives. Of the three possibilities this third one certainly is the most complicated one mathematically and there seems no obvious way either to prove that it is a good approximation or to decide the value of the absorption coefficient which ought to be used. I would much appreciate your comments on this situation. We have not been able to get much thrill out of the recent papers by Wigner or by Weisskopf on this subject.138 I agree with your comments on the wisdom or otherwise of letting newspapers distribute scientific manuscripts, but not that the traditional channels are very adequate at the moment. Printing is deplorably slow, particularly in this country, and one has to rely largely on casual gossip and, while this is apt to make more sense than the efforts of Mr. W.L.Lawrence, it is hardly more efficient. With best wishes, [R.E. Peierls] P.S. I am working on a plan to have a small theoretical conference at Birmingham this summer, to deal with the fundamental difficulties and with elementary particles. The likely dates are July 23rd to 26th, and I hope to get some of the theoreticians in this country and a fair number 138
E.P. Wigner, ‘Resonance Reactions and Anomalous Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 70, 15–33 (1946); E.P. Wigner, ‘Resonance Reactions’, Phys. Rev. 70, 606–18 (1946); E.P. Wigner and L. Eisenbud, ‘High Angular Momenta and Long Range Interaction in Resonance Reactions’, Phys. Rev. 72, 29–41 (1947); H. Feshbach, D.C. Peaslee and V.F. Weisskopf, ‘On the Scattering and Absorption of Particles by Atomic Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 71, 145–58 (1947).
April 7, 2009
12:11
82
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
from the Continent to take part. Our funds do not make it possible to pay transatlantic fares but if, by any chance, you were intending to be on this side this summer, we would look after your board and lodgings, probably in the University hostel here, during the conference. You will get a more official notice in due course but I thought I would let you know at once that this is likely to happen. I need not say that we should be delighted to see you here.
[418] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, May 1947 Dear Oppie, I enclose particulars of an informal conference that we are hoping to hold at Birmingham this summer. If you or any of your colleagues are planning to be on this side of the Atlantic at the time (or are just waiting for a reason to make such a trip) we would be delighted to see you here. I would also be grateful to have the names of others to whom you suggest such an invitation should be sent. Yours sincerely, R. Peierls Congratulations on the new job! Hardly more restful?139
[419] Niels Bohr to Rudolf Peierls Copenhagen, 2.6.1947 Dear Peierls, I want to tell you that my plans have been somewhat changed since I wrote last. Circumstances are that under the pressure of various obligations I have recently been somewhat overstrained, and I have therefore 139
Robert Oppenheimer had resigned from his post at Berkeley to take up the directorship of the Institute of Advanced Studies in Princeton.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
83
felt it necessary to give up my journey to England and Ireland this summer and try to get some real recreation in July, such as I have not had for several years. I am sorry that I shall thus not be able to see you as I hoped, but on the other hand I am sure that the change in the plans will give us better possibilities in the near future to complete our work which had been so long postponed. I was very glad to learn that it will be possible to you to come here for a time in August or September. In the Institute we plan a little conference in the later part of September, and it would be very nice if before that time we could have some thorough discussions about the general problems. Perhaps it would be the best of you could come here in the middle of September and stay over the conference or as long as you can. With kindest regards, Yours, Uncle Nick
[420] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr [Birmingham], 5.6.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, Thank you very much for your letter. I am very sorry to hear that you have not been well, although it is hardly surprising that you should feel tired in view of the very many different things that must be making demands on your time now. I had just heard from Møller about the proposed conference and I had written to him that things are a little difficult because of the two fairly official lectures that I had promised to give on the 20th and 25th September. I probably could get out of either or both commitments, but I would have to make the necessary arrangements very soon. Alternatively, if the conference were to start before the 20th I might be able to stay for at least part of the conference and get back in time to deliver the lecture on the 20th; but then I should start fairly soon booking my passage, as I believe pressure on space in the ships and planes is going
April 7, 2009
12:11
84
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
to be very heavy. I realise of course that the precise arrangements for the conference must depend on many factors and they cannot be settled at once, but I would be very grateful to know the dates as soon as they are fixed. From what you say, it would at the moment sound best if I tried to arrive, say, about 10th September and to leave either in time to be back in London on the 19th or a little later, if the conference is later and if I can still cancel my lecture on the 20th. I need hardly say that I am looking forward intensely to this visit. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[421] Niels Bohr to Rudolf Peierls Copenhagen, 26.6.1947 Dear Peierls, I am sorry not before to have answered your kind letter of June 5th,140 but I have been somewhat doubtful what to propose as regards the best time for your visit here. Circumstances are that due to wishes of some of our American friends who could not come before, the conference here has so far been planned for the last week in September. Furthermore, Sir John Anderson is coming on an official visit to Denmark from September 11th to 18th and will be staying with us for some of the time. I hope very much that the schedule of the conference can be made to fit in with your own plans but, on account of the other commitments in September, it might perhaps be best if, instead of coming before the conference, you could manage to stay on a little longer to give us the opportunity to talk about how it stands with a possible completion of our work with Placzek.141 I take the occasion to tell you that Jacobsen is going to England for the last part of July and intends to come to Birmingham to learn 140
Letter Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr, 5.6.1947, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b203, C.32. 141 See Lee, Selected Correspondence, Vol. 1, Chapter 4.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
85
about the developments in Oliphant’s laboratory. It will also be a great pleasure for him to attend your conference, at any rate such a part of it which is not too specific mathematical. Further, one of the younger of the experimental collaborators in the Institute, Børge Madsen, who has done some beautiful work on recoil particles is going to England in July to visit various laboratories. Also Madsen intends to come to Birmingham towards the end of the months and hopes to be allowed to attend such parts of the conference as are not too far from his line. Please inform Oliphant about these visits. I need not say that it would be a great pleasure for us if he could attend your conference himself. With kindest regards from us all, Yours, Uncle Nick, P.S. Mr Madsen will arrive in London at July 2nd, where his address will be at the Society for Visiting Scientists, 5, Old Burlington Street, W.1.
[422] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr [Birmingham], 1.7.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, Thank you for your letter of 26th June.142 I would, of course, not have wanted you to alter the date of your conference to fit my particular plans and I think it will be possible for me to be present at least for part of the time. It would be somewhat difficult to cancel my lecture to the Institute of Physics on September 25th since it is a rather formal affair and since I have already given them notes on what I propose to say, which have been used by the other speakers to plan their papers, and I think I 142
Letter [421].
April 7, 2009
86
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
could not find anyone else who could take my place and say just what I would have said. I would try, however, to come across by ‘plane on the afternoon of the 25th or, if that is impossible on the morning of the 26th and so could at least take part in some of the discussions. It would then be possible also for me to stay for part of the following week since our term does not start until 7th October. I would, however, want to be back here a few days before the beginning of term. I am very glad to hear that Jacobsen and Madsen are likely to visit Birmingham and if they should find it convenient to be here at the time of our conference they will, of course, be welcome to take part in any discussions that they do not find too mathematical. Oliphant and Moon similarly are very glad to hear about these visits. It would be a help to know fairly soon when Jacobsen expects to be in Birmingham so that we can ensure that accommodation will be ready for him. I can get in touch with Madsen directly when he gets to London and find out more about his plans. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
[423] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr [Birmingham], 18.7.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, In connection with your conference in September, I wondered whether you would allow Ferretti, who as you may know, is spending a year with me, to take part in it?143 You probably know some of Ferretti’s work; 143 Bruno Ferretti who been the remaining theoretical physicist in Rome after Giancarlo Wick had emigrated to America, spent a year at Birmingham. He was working on methods for solving scattering and eigenvalue problems. See B. Ferretti and M. Krook, ‘On the Solution of Scattering and Related Problems’, Proc. Phys. 60, 481–90 (1948).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
87
I have formed an extremely high opinion of his ability and judgement from what I have seen of him and in particular he is now working on a calculation of the energy loss of mesons in their orbits inside atoms and it is conceivable that he might produce some definite result one way or another in time for the conference.144 I think we could probably arrange to get a grant for the expenses of his journey but before exploring this I wanted first to ask whether it would be all right for him to come. Several others of my collaborators would, of course, also be very interested in the discussions of the conference but I imagine that, as on previous occasions, you want to keep the conference limited to a fairly small group, and then of all the people here Ferretti would seem the most likely one to make an important contribution to the discussion. As for my own plans, I find there is unfortunately no ‘plane in the evening so that I could only travel in the morning of Friday 26th September. I shall make sure of a reservation on that ‘plane which would get me to Copenhagen by lunch time and I try to get a reservation to return towards the end of the following week. If you think these dates would not be suitable, would you let me know? With best wishes, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
144
Peierls and Ferretti had collaborated on radiation damping theory and had produced a joint paper. R.E. Peierls and B. Ferretti, ‘Radiation damping theory and the propagation of light’, Nature 160, 531–34 (1947).
April 7, 2009
12:11
88
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[424] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 28.7.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you for your letter. Our conference has just finished145 and it was a lot of fun, though no doubt it would have been more fun if you had managed to get here. We discussed a number of problems, including the one related to your note146 . My personal impression is that physically you are almost certain to be right, i.e. that the observed shift is due to self energy, but that this will not come out of the present theory and that, in particular if one applies present theory to this problem the reduction in the order of magnitude due to pair theory and that due to taking the difference between two states will not be cumulative, so that one will get at least still a logarithmic infinity in this result. One may not even get a definite result at all because, as far as I know, no formulation of pair theory exists which is consistent and Lorentz invariant beyond the first approximation. I do believe, however, that in a future theory in which one has eliminated the infinities the result for the level shift will look very much like yours. We have discussed further the paper by you and Oppenheimer147 on the Heitler theory and Ferretti has traced the trouble to the result that in the damping theory light signals do not propagate with light velocity.148 This, of course, is the effect of the reinterpretation of the theory in which one gives up the ordinary space-time description. We have all come to the conclusion that this is a fundamental feature of all 145
Peierls had organised a small theoretical conference at Birmingham which dealt with the fundamental difficulties and with elementary particles. This took place between July 23rd and 26th. See letter [417]. 146 Bethe had just submitted a note on the electromagnetic shift of energy levels which was to be published later that year. H.A. Bethe, ‘The Electromagnetic Shift of Energy Levels’, Phys, Rev. 72, 339–41 (1947). 147 Hans A. Bethe and J.R. Oppenheimer, ‘Reaction of Radiation on Electron Scattering and Heitler’s Theory of Radiation Damping’, Phys. Rev. 70, 451–58 (1946). 148 Ferretti’s results were the basis of a paper published in Nature. See letter [423], note 144.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
89
those theories in which one tries to throw out all self-energy terms and therefore one should now consider only theories involving a fundamental constant of the dimensions of a length in which only the contributions from very short waves are neglected but the others, which, as you point out, are needed, are retained. Your letter, of course, tends to strengthen this view. How about plans for next year? I think it should not be difficult, if you can get leave of absence, to find a suitable position for you for a few months. Needless to say that it would appeal to me most if that position could be found in Birmingham, but it depends somewhat on what you want. There are a number of places which, at the moment, have no decent theoretician — for instance, Dee in Glasgow has only some rather junior men and a new Chair has just been created at Liverpool which I imagine it will be hard to fill. In one or the other of these places, you would therefore be carrying out a valuable job of putting the experimentalists on the right lines. On the other hand, I take it your point in taking sabbatical leave is to get away for a time from administration and teaching duties and to sit in a place with the right atmosphere in which you could do your own research and where there would be enough younger people to pick up any spare problems you happen to scatter. From my point of view Birmingham might be the best place, though this would, of course, not exclude your meeting the people from other universities. Another alternative would be a kind of general job, sponsored, perhaps, by the Royal Society, in which you would spend periods at all the places that want to see you, but if you want to sit down and get some work done this is hardly to be recommended. Please let me know what your ideas are on this subject so that we can set the wheels turning. Another question is about the financial side of the arrangements. The new scheme of sabbatical leave that we are going to institute here provides that the full university salary continues and may be supplemented by a grant to cover travel expenses and higher cost of living. In trying to organise something here, one would have to know whether your regulations are similar, because if one of us went on study leave and got a grant by the university he was visiting, this would merely serve to reduce the cost to this home university, and naturally nobody
April 7, 2009
12:11
90
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
here would be anxious to make a grant merely to save expenses to Cornell. On the other hand, we would, of course, be anxious to make sure that you are not out of pocket as a result of the transaction. Would you want to bring your family and, if so, would they be with you or perhaps in Belfast.149 There is no doubt whatever that we can arrange for you to get the necessary status and facilities and very little doubt that we can arrange an adequate grant. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[425] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 6.8.1947 Dear Oppie, I enclose for your information a copy of letter we have sent to Nature150 which I think strengthens the argument of your paper with Hans.151 It seems to us that this objection is not confined to the specific formalism of Heitler’s, but applies equally to any theory not involving a constant of the dimension of a length which would allow a quantitative distinction between the terms which are wanted and those which are not. Yours sincerely, R. Peierls
149
Paul Ewald, Hans Bethe’s father-in-law, had settled in Belfast. See letter [423], note 144. 151 See letter [424], note 147. 150
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
91
[426] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe Birmingham, 14.8.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you for sending me a draft of your paper on the two-meson hypothesis.152 This is all very interesting as Uncle Nick would say, but I do not believe that the second kind of meson which you postulate can have anything to do at all with the Bristol photographs.153 The chief reason for this is that in the Bristol technique for any heavy meson stopping in the plate, the probability of the track of the light meson, if any, also lying within the plate is very small. In other words, for any track which they have found in which a light meson is visible there must be many others which also exist, but do not appear. This means that the heavy mesons do not represent, as you say, something like 6% of all mesons stopping in the plate, but from the latest Bristol figures something like 50%. In the light of this, the discussion on your page two is somewhat misleading. Incidentally, the photographs were not taken at 30,000 feet as you say on page two, but on top of a mountain and your guesses on page five about the dimension of the plane do not make much sense, instead there was a lot of snow around. Similarly, your footnote seventeen is hardly justified since it is very likely that there was in that case a secondary meson present but that it went out of the plane of the emulsion. Equally, of course, this may have been a light meson. 152
Hans A. Bethe and R.E. Marshak, ‘On the two-meson hypothesis’, Phys. Rev. 72, 506–509 (1947). 153 At Bristol, photographs had shown the development of light mesons from heavy heavy ones. C.M.G. Lattes, H. Muirhead, G.P.S. Occhialini and C.F. Powell, ‘Processes involving charged mesons’, Nature 159, 694–97 (1947). The results were reported, among others, at a conference at Harwell, where Powell explained the experiments in detail. See also C.M.G. Lattes, G.P.S. Occhialini and C.F. Powell, ‘Observations on the tracks of slow mesons in photographic emulsions’, Nature 160, 453–56 and 486–92 (1948). Further developments are described in S. Schweber, ‘Shelter Island, Pocono, Oldstone. The emergence of American quantum electrodynamics after the war’ Osiris 2, 265–302 (1986).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
92
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I cannot help feeling that all the facts we have at present, if they are right, cannot even be understood with the help of two kinds of mesons. I enclose a re-draft of our note to Nature which I hope is more intelligible than the first.154 Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[427] Rudolf Peierls to Klaus Fuchs [Birmingham], 27.8.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Klaus, Thank you for your note about the plant design. My chief comment is that its wording, perhaps, is too aggressive for instance in the first sentence it is a bit condescending, it might be better to say “I have only minor comments on the L.S.D. plant. While I have not checked the detailed figures, I would like to mention the following points.” This is almost what you have said, but I am trying to make it sound a little more polite. In the addition to your item three, I think most of the members of the committee will understand what is meant here by differential flow, why not say “consequently the two sections will temporarily be isolated from each other.” Incidentally, I am no longer satisfied that it is really such a vital point, we tend to think too much in terms of stationary conditions, but if the differential flow ceases for a time between the two sections, will it not simply mean that the amount of light product increases at the top of the lower section so that when exchange is resumed not much has been lost? This hardly affects your note because it is likely that the alternative place for the drum is better anyway and one ought not to accept it in the present position without checking its [e]ffect on performance. 154
See letter [423], note 144.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
93
H.S.D. item two. I do not know whether an increase of compression ratio would really be feasible, one might get too near to the un-stable region of the compressor. Would it be worthwhile to end on a more optimistic note, pointing our that it is very likely that all these problems can be solved in the time available before the H.D.S. design is to be frozen. As your note stands it sounds as if there was serious doubt whether it is possible to build such a plant at all. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[428] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 3.9.1947 Dear Rudi: Thanks very much for your many letters, scientific and otherwise. I liked your paper about Heitler’s Theory very much.155 It is certainly the most striking argument against the theory that it does not give the correct velocity of light. It ought to be possible to show this not only by indirect argument but also by direct calculation. You are probably doing this right now. I did a little more on the electro-magnetic line shift. I have done it relativistically and it is indeed finite. I do not have the numerical result because there are too many terms, each of which has to be evaluated. But the result is essentially the same as in the unrelativistic ca[l]culation. There are some interesting points in it, concerning the subtraction of the electron-magnetic mass, and also concerning the cut-off procedure for the self energy. But the main point is that it is finite and depends essentially on ψ 2 (0). Thanks for your criticism of our note on the heavy meson. I am afraid the note was written in a great hurry, and what is worse, it will 155
See letters [423], note 144.
April 7, 2009
12:11
94
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
be printed in the “Phys. Rev.” without our getting any proof.156 So the large density of mistakes will stay in. I am particularly unhappy about the mess I made concerning the altitude in which the measurements were made; as they were made on a mountain, our statement is not correct that most of the mesons are produced in the neighborhood of the measuring apparatus. You are also at least qualitatively right that there must be many heavy mesons which do not appear as such because they escape from the plate. However, I believe that quantitatively this is not quite as important as you say, because the emulsion is rather thick and amounts to about 40 ∗ percent of the range. I think some change in ionization density should be noticed in that distance. The famous Footnote 17 is of course unintelligible, but the meson in question originates in a nuclear disintegration in the plate itself, and should therefore be a heavy meson according to our theory. Since this statement was omitted in the footnote, your objection that it might be a light meson will occur to most readers, but really it cannot be. Now about the plans for the future. It was awfully nice of you to write immediately about the possibility for my possible visit. I have not yet got my leave approved but I am working on it and I hope it will be definite in about a month or so. The financial arrangements are that the University pays my regular salary but no expenses. I am losing a considerable amount in consultation fees from the General Electric Company which of course I cannot visit while I am in England. None of the money which I might get from an English University will go to Cornell. So it would be nice if I could get some sort of position; in this case I will probably come out just about even, that is I will be able to pay the travelling expenses and replace the loss of GE fees. I should like to go to a place where I am really useful and should like to give some regular lectures, as long as there is not too much of this (let us say no more than six a week). I think at the present time, with physicists so scarce, I should not completely retire to the luxury of pure research. Concerning places I want to try — first of all to make a ∗I
did not have time to look up the numbers, so this may be wrong.
156
See letter [424], note 147.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
95
deal with Mott.157 Our department here has invited Mott previously to come for a semester and would still be very anxious to have him. There is a lot of work in the solid state going on here, and I am too much out of this to give any advise. So the present plan is to ask Mott to change places with me for one semester. Please keep this to yourself for the time being, because I have not yet approached Mott, since my leave has not definitely been approved. If this does not work out, I think Liverpool would be a very attractive place. Also, now with Frisch there,158 Cambridge would be interesting. But I think I should let fate take its course and not put too many boundary conditions on this problem. Any University where there is an attractive program in experimental physics and where a theoretical physicist is needed, will be fine. I should like to stay at one place and not travel around too much. Of course I would want to see you frequently, but distances generally are not very great. The plan is to take the whole family and this might make a difficulty from the standpoint of housing. We would visit Rose’s parents during the summer and would expect to leave the children there while Rose and I go to the Continent for a few weeks. But when term begins, it would be nice to have the family happily reunited. The time would be approximately from July to the end of January. I do not know how this fits in with your terms; as I remember the fall term ends at Christmas. If the job I am going to get is just for the fall term, it might be very nice if I could spend a month with you in Birmingham. This is just to give you a vague idea, I hope it won’t make too much trouble for you to look for a suitable place. But both Rose and I are dreaming very much of this visit. We had a very nice time together in southwestern Colorado. At present, Rose’s mother is visiting us and it is really very nice. She has hardly changed at all in the nineteen years since I know her. Best regards to the family. Yours sincerely, Hans 157
Nevill Mott (1905–1996) held the Chair of Theoretical Physics at Bristol at the time. 158 Otto Frisch had accepted the Jacksonian Chair in Cambridge in 1947.
April 7, 2009
12:11
96
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[429] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 23.9.1947 Dear Rudy: One of my students, Edwin Lennox,159 is very much interested in spending a year or two in Europe. He will probably get his Ph.D. next June and would like to come over after that. He would like best to come to you if you would like to have him, and if you could give him some research position. You may remember Lennox from Los Alamos while he was in Vicky’s group. In the meantime, he has developed very well and had learned a lot of physics. When he was at Los Alamos, he had had only a very small amount of physics courses. I think he is very good; at least he shows great interest in all problems and tries to get a real understanding of everything in physics. I remember that you had some research position available when you went back to Birmingham. Would any of these be available to Lennox for next year? What would be the salary that he could get? He just encumbered himself by marrying a widow with three children; however, they get some pension from the U.S. Government and possibly some financial support from the grandfather of the children. So the situation is not as desperate as it sounds and you may consider him simply as married without any children, as far as financial needs are concerned. If it is possible for you to take Lennox, he would of course also be interested in the problems of life, especially whether there is any chance to find a place for him to live. If this looks very black, he may be better advised not to come. He would also be interested in knowing for how long your research appointments would run. Physics continues to be very exciting especially the electromagnetic shift of the energy levels and the mesons. At a conference the other day, 159
Edwin Lennox completed his Ph.D. with Hans Bethe and later took up a post at Ann Arbor before moving to the Department of Chemistry at the University of Illinois, Urbana.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
97
we admired the latest pictures from Bristol, especially the one in which a meson is produced in a star and then produces another star.160 I hope to hear from Vicky and Placzek very soon on what happened in Copenhagen. I assume you were there.161 Best regards to the family. Yours sincerely, Hans
[430] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 27.9.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you for your letter. I still do not agree with your interpretation of Powell’s experiment.162 The point is not that if the track goes at an angle to the plate it cannot be recognized as that of a meson, but that it is not detected at all. The plate is always horizontal under the microscope and if the track has a strong “dip” the focal plane will only contain one or a few grains at a time and, therefore, no recognizable track will appear. No doubt a more elaborate inspection technique would disclose such tracks, but there would be no point in trying this since all the information can be obtained by observing only the tracks which are nearly in the plane of the emulsion. In any case, the others have not been looked for, and all the dozen or so cases found at Bristol are cases in which both primary and secondary 160
Prior to the advent of large-scale accelerators in the mid 1950s, Cecil Powell and his collaborators at Bristol (Occhialini, Lattes, Camerini, Muirhead, and many others) made a number of important discoveries in the study of cosmic radiation, so much so that Louis LePrince-Ringuet referred to Bristol as ‘the big sun surrounded by little satellites’. 161 Rudolf Peierls attended the latter part of the conference organised by Niels Bohr in late September 1947. 162 Cecil Frank Powell (1903–1969), studied natural sciences at Cambridge where he gained his Ph.D. working under Wilson and Rutherford. He moved to Bristol where he eventually (1948) became Melville Wills Professor of Physics.
April 7, 2009
12:11
98
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
mesons lie in the plane of observation. Powell is going to publish his conclusions about the statistics.163 Now about your plans, I am not taking any action at present since the question of Bristol is best explored by your approaching Mott directly. Here are, however, a few points for your information; the winter term lasts in all universities from early October until Christmas. The term is, however, not an important unit for teaching; all courses are planned on the basis of a whole session and as far as I can see it would make no difference if your visit did not cover an integer number of terms. (A whole session, October to June would be different but I take it that is too long for you.) In Bristol, the teaching of Applied Mathematics is in the hands of the Mathematics Department. The theoretical physicists do not do the teaching. I do not think that Mott himself gives as many as six lectures a week. At Birmingham (and in some other places) people with our background do lecture on mechanics, hydrodynamics, electricity etc. to undergraduates including engineers, and we have now a staff of three besides myself, for this purpose. It would be hard to justify a temporary appointment for this kind of work, particularly if it is only for part of the session, so that someone else would have to finish the courses which you start. Here, at any rate, it would be much easier to build a case on the stimulating effect your presence would have on the research in both experimental and theoretical physics. I cannot speak for Bristol, but I imagine things would be rather similar. If you just swap places with Mott, your main function would be to replace him in the administration of the department and in the supervision of research. Housing is, as you know, not easy. One does, however, see from time to time furnished houses or flats at not unreasonable rents, and there are also boarding houses that might take you with the family. (Best of all close to somebody’s house where Rose could go for washing or similar activities not tolerated in a boarding house.) 163
C.M.G. Lattes, G.P.S. Occhialini and C.F. Powell, ‘Observations on the tracks of slow mesons in photographic emulsions’, Nature 160, 453–56 and 486–92 (1948).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
99
Liverpool are trying to fill a new chair in theoretical physics.164 This is likely to be filled before your visit. If they are unsuccessful and the chair is still vacant in 48–49 they would, of course, jump at the chance of having you for a short period and it would there be particularly easy to organize funds since the job exists. Failing this, I think Cambridge should also not be difficult. Next come some plans of mine. I find I shall have to attend a meeting in Washington on 14th and 15th November, though there is some talk of it being a week earlier. It comes at an awkward time from the point of view of my duties here and I do not want to stay away longer than necessary. But I might get in an extra day or two and in that case would, of course, very much like to come and see you. As we are very limited on dollars now, this would only work, if my fare from Washington to New York could be covered somehow. What are the chances of this? I could, of course, give a lecture on any subject. I shall let you know more about dates as soon as possible. Greetings to everybody. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[431] Y.I. Frenkel to Rudolf Peierls Leningrad, 7.10.1947 My dear Peierls, I am very sorry to have missed your attractive conference. I hope there will be another opportunity of meeting you either here or in England in the near future. The negative theory of the results of an inspection of the present quantum theory and the mathematical intrications to which the attempts to remove its difficulties lead, seem to indicate that these 164
The Chair was filled in 1948 by Herbert Fr¨ ohlich who remained at Liverpool until 1973.
April 7, 2009
100
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
attempts are not radical enough and that one must discard certain notions which seem inherent in the present theories and are considered as fundamental. One of these notions is the association of the particle concept to the field one. In the case of radiation this association leads to the idea of “longitudinal photons” which are assumed to the particle correlate of the electrostatic field. In the case of meson theory a similar rˆ ole is played by neutral mesons. I believe that both of these particles are non-existent while the field with which they are associated is a reality. Further, matter is unusually described in a dualistic way, as a system consisting of field and particles interacting with each other, the interaction between the particles being transmitted by the field. I think that this dualistic conception of matter must be replaced by a monistic field conception, the particles appearing as quantum effects due to the field. This programme has been outlined by Lorentz classical theory, when its development was, however, chivied by the intricacies of the problem of electron structure. Now, from the point of view of quantum theory, this problem must be considered as ficticious — just as the problem (which seems never to have been discussed) of the structure of a photon. I do not think it necessary to introduce in the fundamental equation a quantity corresponding to the classical radius of the electron. I rather believe that one must introduce a quantity corresponding to the energy of formation of an electron pair. As a matter of fact this quantity appears in Dirac’s equation as a mass of an electron. But Dirac’s equation is an equation of motion, while the fundamental equation must be an equation of the electromagnetic field, the behaviour (“motion”) of electrons and positrons following (as in Lorentz’ theory) from the laws of the conservation of electromagnetic energy-tensor. This is the programme which I think has to be realized. In the case of nucleus we have a similar situation with the additional complications, corresponding to the interaction between the two fields (nuclear and electromagnetic). The main thing is to remove the particles from the field equations, introducing them eventually as quantum effects.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
101
The publication of Soviet work in foreign languages has recently been wholly discontinued. I am afraid that this may lead to a complete loss of contact between ourselves and our foreign colleagues, unless the latter take some pains to study the elements of Russian language, which will enable them to read our papers in Russian. It is hoped that we shall be allowed to publish a yearly report on our scientific work in English. I shall be glad to help you, meanwhile, in getting our Russian journals for the libraries of the British universities, in particular the “Journal of Physical Chemistry, the Journal of Colloid Sciences, the Drolady (C.K. of the A of Sc.) All is well with us both here and in Moscow. Give my love to Genia. Natasha is sending her greetings to both of you. With kindest regards. Yours sincerely, J. Frenkel
[432] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 8.10.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you for your letter about Lennox.165 I am naturally very interested in the possibility of having him here. He must, however, realise that things are not going to be easy at all from his own point of view. Our research fellow-ships vary in seniority and salaries range from £450 a year to £700. This is subject to the usual 5% deduction for superannuation with the University adding 10%. The superannuation is optional and would not apply to anyone who was not intending remaining in academic life in this country. In addition there is a family allowance of £50 p.a. for each child of school age or below. I would, of course, have to know more about his 165
Letter [429].
April 7, 2009
102
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
progress and ability before expressing an opinion where his salary would lie within the range I have quoted, but unless he has developed in quite a spectacular way, it is hardly likely that he would find himself at the top of the grade. My present guess would, therefore, be that he might well expect £500 to £550 and more if we can make out a case. I cannot also at this moment give an assurance that there will be a vacancy for him, we are likely to have a vacancy next session for which there may also be competition, but more vacancies may arise. The terms of these fellow-ships are yearly appointments up to a total tenure of five years. This last limit is not likely to be serious since, if he wants to settle down in this country, it is quite likely that he will find a teaching job that would attract him either in Birmingham or elsewhere. He would, however, have to pay his own passage as well as that of his family, since we have no grant that could be used for this purpose. I do not know whether it would be possible to find some outside grant to help him, but I am sure that at most his own passage could be covered in this way. As regards living conditions here, the salaries I have quoted are adequate though not generous for young married men. To support three children on them would be very tough. Housing is still very short here and it is virtually impossible to rent a house or flat unless he is exceedingly lucky or unless he is allocated one of the very few houses under the control of the University for which, however, there is very strong competition. One can occasionally rent furnished accommodation, but that would be rather expensive and it may not be easy to find anything satisfactory for the size of his family. It is possible to buy houses, a small modern house is likely to cost about £1,500, of which two thirds, or with luck a little more, could be covered by a mortgage. This would have to be furnished unless he can bring furniture from America, this again is difficult and expensive. It should also be born[e] in mind that the style of dress, especially for the children, is rather different here from what it is in America, and he would, therefore, probably have to get almost completely new outfits before he came over. It looks, therefore, as if the whole project was extremely difficult unless he was able to supplement his income at least for the initial ex-
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
103
penses and during the first year quite substantially from private means. If he feels, provided things turn out the right way, he might settle in Europe for good, it may be worth going through all this trouble; if what he has in mind is a year or two on this side, it would seem too big a sacrifice. Perhaps you would discuss these facts with him and if you would let us know a little more both about his progress in research and about his other plans, I may be able to give more definite advice. The meeting to which I have to go in Washington has now definitely been fixed for 14th–16th November. I intend to leave here about the 10th and to start back on the 19th. If during that time there could be a chance of seeing you, that would, of course, be very nice. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[433] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft [Birmingham], 26.10.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, I have thought further about the recent difficulties over the release of photographs and other information. I feel strongly that this places us really in an impossible position for discussing declassification with the Americans. This may not merely involve technicalities, but we may have to support our advice by discussing reasons for our attitude. How can we do this if there is a likelihood of a government which instructs us acting on completely different ideas? I feel so strongly on this point that I have seriously considered to withdraw from the delegation unless this point can be cleared up before our departure.166 I have decided against this, since such a step by one 166
Rudolf Peierls was planning on attending a declassification conference in Washington in November 1947. See letter [430].
April 7, 2009
12:11
104
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
member of the delegation would tend to give the impression that the scientists are divided in their attitude; this might do more harm than good. Any pressure that is brought could only come from you either personally or speaking on behalf of all of us. There will, I hope, be a possibility of talking these things over at Malvern, but I thought it might help if you knew my views beforehand. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
[434] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 1.11.1947 Dear Oppie, I have to attend meetings in Washington on 14th – 16th November, and my only available transportation will get me to New York with any luck on the 6th of November. I would like to use the extra time for a few visits and I am trying to arrange to call at Princeton about November 12th. I am hoping to call at Chicago between 7th and 9th, at M.I.T. on the 19th and perhaps 11th, although I do not know whether these dates will be suitable in those two places. I shall telephone your office on arrival in New York, but if this letter reaches you in time, it would help if you would leave a message for me at La Guardia Airport where I am due to arrive by B.A.O.C. Flight 15–16a on the 6th, saying what your movements are likely to be during that week. I do not know whether you will also happen to be in Washington at the time of our meetings,167 and if so you may prefer to have a chat 167
Since the passing of the Atomic Energy Act of 1946 (McMahon Act), the declassification of atomic energy information, both basic scientific and related technical information, was regulated by this legislation. Under the terms of the McMahon Act, the so-called ‘restricted data’ (RD) which concerned the manufacture and utilization of atomic weapons, as well as the production of fissionable material, was no longer to be shared with other countries. UK scientists, however, were consulted in declassification meetings, such as the one in Washington in November 1947.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
105
there rather than in Princeton where you may be busy, but in that case I would still try to visit Princeton to see Wigner and others. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[435] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr Birmingham, 2.11.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, Here is, at last, the promised redraft of the paper.168 I was very disappointed that it took me so long to get it ready, but I struck a number of minor formal difficulties in the presentation. It also has increased somewhat in length, but I think it would be hard to say the same things in a substantially shorter paper. I am particularly sorry about the delay since, owing to difficulties with transportation, I have to leave for the United States already on 5th November, so that there is no hope of getting your comments before I leave. Your comments would reach me, if they were sent c/o British Supply Office, P.O. Box 680, Benjamin Franklin Station, Washington D.C. to get there by 15th November, or c/o Bethe at Cornell, by the 18th. This applies in particular if there are any questions you would like me to discuss with Placzek.169 Otherwise, it would, of course, be quite all right for you to make any changes you wish and send the paper off. I hope to be back here on the 21st November. 168
Here Peierls refers to the second draft of the manuscript entitled ‘On the Mechanism of Transmutations of Atomic Nuclei. II. Processes in the Continuous Energy Region of the Compound State’, reproduced in R.E. Peierls (ed.), Niels Bohr. Collected Works, Vol. 9, Amsterdam: North Holland, 1986 (cited hereinafter as Bohr. Collected Works), pp. 487–502. It was produced after agreement had been reached by Bohr, Placzek and Peierls that the latter should update the pre-war drafts of their joint paper in order to publish it. 169 Georg Placzek had moved from Los Alamos to a job with General Electric, until he secured a position at Princeton, working at the Institute for Advanced Studies with Oppenheimer.
April 7, 2009
106
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
It may help if I add a few notes on my reasons for changes which I have made. (“Old draft” here refers to the typescript dated 9.10.47, which you sent me.170 ) Section 1: This is meant to be a rough sketch, and you may like to change the wording of this. Section 2: This is substantially the old section 1, but with the discussion of the Breit-Wigner formula omitted,171 as we agreed. I have left the discussion of the phenomena at very high energies, which, I believe, helps to complete the picture. You were doubtful whether this should not be omitted. If that still is your view, it can easily be taken out without breaking the continuity of the rest. I have added on p. 3, the point that the “potential scattering” need not be exclusively elastic. Section 3: This is the new section which gives an elementary derivation of the Breit-Wigner formula. I gave a misleading picture of this in Copenhagen by stating that four principles are involved. Actually, the conservation theorem is not necessary for this purpose. Section 4: It seems more logical to discuss detailed balancing before the conservation theorem, and this required some slight changes in this section, which otherwise is just the old section 3. I have shortened somewhat the discussion of the precautions necessary in applying detailed balancing to quantum problems. It seems a satisfactory point of view that, in all cases in which the states of the 170 This refers to a typescript produced from pre-war manuscripts which were typed up to form the basis of Peierls’ attempt to redraft the paper. See R. Peierls, ‘Introduction’, Bohr. Collected Works, Vol. 9, p. 50. 171 Breit and Wigner had derived the general theory of resonance processes for a single resonance level (G. Breit and E. Wigner, ‘Capture of Slow Neutrons’, Phys. Rev. 49, 519–31 (1936).) When applied to the case where the width of the resonance level is greater than their spacing, the Breit-Wigner method gives a result that does not conform to the derivation of the cross section for the formation of the compound nucleus by the capture of a particle from the general theorem of detailed balancing. Contrary to Kalckar, Oppenheimer and Serber, who believed the Breit-Wigner formula to give the correct answer (F. Kalckar, J.R. Oppenheimer and R. Serber, ‘Note on Resonances in Transmutation of Light Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 52, 279–82 (1937)), Bohr, Peierls and Placzek argued that, in fact, the answer from the detailed balancing argument was the right one.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
107
compound nucleus can be described as definite states in the sense of the quantum mechanics formalism, the formalism automatically implies the law of detailed balancing, and it is therefore not necessary to construct an actual circular process which would violate the Second Law of thermodynamics, if detailed balancing did not hold. (It must of course always be possible to construct such a process.) Section 5: This is based on the old section 2. I have altered the mathematics slightly by retaining the complex scattering amplitude Si rather than splitting it at once into modules and phases. This seems to make it a little easier to see how the potential scattering term enters in (32). On the potential scattering term itself, it seems to me unnecessary to regard the application of (32) to the potential scattering alone as approximate (old p. 14 bottom) since the potential scattering by itself should be defined as the solution of a definite wave equation. The interference between potential and “true” scattering by itself would present no difficulty at all if the potential scattering were purely elastic. This was true in the very first draft of this part in which the potential scattering was defined in a formal way based on the Peierls-Kapur equations. In the view now taken, which I regard more satisfactory from a physical point of view, this is no longer true, but this leaves a certain amount of conjecture as regards the interference between the inelastic potential and “true” scattering. A more precise answer could, however, come only from a much more quantitative study, including a definite model for the potential scattering, and I feel we ought not to attempt this at the present stage. I have also put back the generalization to particles with spin to a later point so as to avoid introducing the quantity that is called δAJ . The reason is that in the case of spin one must consider, instead of one incident wave, a number of different waves with different spin directions, which are incoherent, and which, in general will have different phases. The cross section is then obtained by averaging. I believe therefore that an equation like (26) of the old draft could not be justified in the case of particles with spin, though, of course the inequality (35) with J in place of l will still hold. I have omitted the analogy with the scattering of light by a system of oscillators in a box. It seems to me that most readers would not be sufficiently familiar with the theory of this model to accept the state-
April 7, 2009
12:11
108
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ments about its properties as obvious, and one would hardly want to present an extensive mathematical study of the model. I have also omitted the statement at the bottom of p. 12 of the old draft that in the continuous level region the phase is always that corresponding to full resonance. It seems hard to justify this in a convincing manner. In the pre-war draft of the statement, this was justified from the Peierls-Kapur formalism,172 but it depended again on a very formal, and probably inconvenient, definition of the potential scattering. Since the statement is not needed for the conclusion, it seemed wiser to omit it. Section 6: is very short, and you may prefer to treat it as part of section 5. This can be done by just omitting the heading. With best wishes. Yours sincerely, [R. Peierls] Apologies for the typing, which is my own.
[436] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe Birmingham, 24.11.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, On my return here, I found a list of people who have been invited to write reports for the Solvay Conference,173 and I am glad to see your name. I had already promised to write a report on self-energy problems, not knowing, of course, the rapid progress that is now taking place in the United States in this field. Definitely we should try and avoid too 172
This formalism was developed in P.L. Kapur and R. Peierls, ‘The dispersion formula for nuclear reactions’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A166, 277–95 (1938). 173 The 8th Solvay Conference, the first post-war conference, took place in September 1948 in Brussels.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
109
much overlap and we ought to agree what is the best division of labour, if any. Could you let me know as soon as possible whether you are proposing to come to the conference, whether you are agreeing to write a report and what your views are about the best division. For example, I might try to summarise the account of the difficulties of the old theories including a criticism of the attempts by Dirac, Gustafson, Heitler etc., and deal with the position of theories not including perturbation. This would include your own proof that the divergence does not depend on perturbation theory. It would also include the classical theory of McManus and the general method of Feynman to the extent to which I have understood it, or shall understand it. It would leave you all those theories in which finite results can be obtained by an intelligent application of perturbation theory without modification, including your own work, the recent Princeton results, Schwinger etc. This, however, is only a tentative suggestions and any division would be all right with me provided it does not involve my writing about the Princeton results I have only heard in conversation, and Schwinger’s calculations174 which I do not know at all. With best wishes, Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
174
After Bethe had completed non-relativistic calculations about the Lamb shift and magnetic anomalies of the electron momentum, Weisskopf and Schwinger had done some relativistic calculations. See S. Schwinger, ‘On quantum electrodynamics and the magnetic moment of the electron’, Phys. Rev. 73, 416–17 (1948).
April 7, 2009
12:11
110
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[437] Rudolf Peierls to Abram Pais [Birmingham], 27.11.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Pais, Thank you for your letter and typescript175 which arrived here yesterday. I am writing at once to let you have my immediate reactions. If within the next few days I have any second thoughts or suggestions from my collaborators here, I shall send them off on the off chance that you may still be able to use them. I have not so far found any further reference to be added to your survey or any further papers to reproduce. I am also not aware of any errors in my paper. Your survey seems to me an admirable and most helpful piece of work. Of a number of comments, perhaps the most serious one refers to the discussion of the Lorentz and Abraham electrons starting on page six, and the corresponding quantum theories. To my mind the discussion involving self-stress has always appeared as a most unnecessary piece of learned complication, although I realise the part it has played in the historical development. Surely all that one must realise is (a) that a formula based on an electron with rigid charge distribution not subject to Lorentz contraction violated relativity in the most elementary way; (b) that a charge distribution which is subject to Lorentz contraction can be formulated in an invariant way as long as only motion with uniform velocity is considered, but that such a motion becomes impossible if acceleration is allowed because of the well-known fact that relativity does not permit the existence of a rigid structure capable of being accelerated. This, of course, can be traced to the fact that a charge distribution which depends uniquely on the location of its centre, involves 175
Letter could not be located. Abraham Pais had attended the Shelter Island Conference ‘on the foundations of quantum mechanics’ between 1st and 3rd June 1947. On the suggestion of Oppenheimer and Wheeler, he edited a collection of earlier papers to be published in 1948. The book itself was never published, but the preface written by Pais was published as A. Pais, Developments in the Theory of the Electron, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1948.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
111
of necessity a transmission of impulses with infinite velocity (since a change of velocity at the centre must cause instantaneously corresponding change in velocity of the distant parts of the distribution). From this statement it is clear that neither the Abraham nor the Lorentz picture can be compatible with relativity dynamics. Historically this discussion was important at a time when not only the electron problem, but also the problem of relativity dynamics were in question. Now that the principles of relativity are no longer in doubt, I see no advantage in discussing in detail the feature of schemes evidently not compatible with these principles. My own feeling would, therefore, be that the fewer equations written for these schemes, the clearer the story will become to the reader and one can, of course, refer for the mathematical details to the references you are quoting. Similarly, I do not see much advantage in classifying, as you do on page nine, the non-invariant theories according to just where they go wrong. Similarly, (unless I have misunderstood an important point) you place some weight on the fact that there is a procedure in quantum theory leading to your equations (7a’) and (7b’) which are equivalent to the classical theory which is of historical importance but which is inadmissible owing to its contradiction to relativity. Other smaller points, page ten, line fifteen, it is misleading to say that the Dirac theory leads to that of Lorentz. The Lorentz equation was meant only as an approximate one, neglecting higher terms which would be important if the frequencies of the motion became compatible to c/... In this connection it would, I think, be useful to mention the remark, due, as far as I know, to McManus here, that the Dirac theory here is equivalent to putting into the Lorentz theory a negative mechanical mass so as to make the total mass equal to the observed value and then letting the electron radius tend to zero. I found this helpful in understanding the significance of the runaway solutions. Page fourteen, footnote — “The Kramers theory mentioned previously”, I did not see the reference to which this applies. I suspect it might apply to your reference (27) which is only mentioned on the following page and which in any case is merely a private communication. If this is correct, would it be possible to give a little more detail? Otherwise, could you make it clearer which application by Kramers you had in mind? Page fourteen,
April 7, 2009
112
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
line nine, “It should be recalled” this is one of Bohr’s favourite expressions, but I think one should be a little more explicit. Page 24a, your account of the difficulties conveys the impression that the source of the trouble is the fact that the new terms contain higher powers of the field intensities. If this were the only difficulty, one might, of course, question, as Bohr has done, the validity of the derivation of such equations from correspondents. Nevertheless, it might still be possible to derive the non-linear field equations resulting from such a scheme by means of a new Hamiltonian and then apply the standard procedure of quantization. I have always thought that the real trouble was the occurrence in the equations of motion of quantities containing time derivatives of higher order or even the values of the field equations at different times. This means that the equations are no longer of Hamiltonian form and that, therefore, the standard procedure of quantization can no longer be applied. This is important because if this were the main point, it would mean that there might be a chance of getting over the difficulty by means of the Feynman method which starts from the action function directly without the use of a Hamiltonian. Evidently the equations in question could be derived from an action principle. I am not yet satisfied, however, that the Feynman method wold be applicable to such a situation. Also, of course, it does not follow that the results would be physically reasonable. Page 28, footnote, you mention a quantity λcrit of which I could not find a definition. This may be due to my hurried reading, but it would also help, if a clear statement were given somewhere what you mean by λcrit . Page 30, line 5 from bottom you refer to page 20a which is not included in my copy. As page 20 refers to my old paper, II am naturally interested to know whether I have missed there an important addition. Also, in the list of references, items 104 and 105 are omitted in my copy and I would be glad to know what these are. Reference 87 strikes me as odd, only a minority of your readers will have been present at the conference and the purpose of the reference to such a discussion is usually to show the channel through which you have learned of somebody else’s views. In quoting yourself in this way the impression is given that you merely want to ensure the priority of having made an unspecified statement at a certain time, and I am sure that is not you intention.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
113
I do not know whether it is worthwhile to include amongst the list of classical theories, say on page twelve, a reference to the integral field equations by McManus which I reported to you the other day. I still believe that from a classical point of view these are free from all objections one can raise against the proposals which you list. I have just sent to Feynman a typescript containing mathematical details to which, no doubt, you could refer if you wish. On the other hand, I appreciate that it is hopeless to attempt to be completely up-to-date if you ever want to go to press, and it may well be too late to include a reference to this theory. One last remark, if it is possible in the available time, it would, I think, be worthwhile to check the language of your survey. Some of the sentences do not read very well and I had to read some of the passages several times, before I could make out their sense. Yours sincerely R.E. Peierls
[438] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 4.12.1947 Dear Rudi, Thanks for your letter of 24th November.176 It tells me, among other things, that you arrived safely back in England which is fine. In the meantime, we also saw Fuchs whose visit was very nice. For the Solvay Conference, I would have proposed exactly the same division of labor as you. I wrote Bragg that I would talk about level shift and related problems. By this I mean the Princeton results, Schwinger’s results and any other results we might obtain in subtraction physics. I would leave everything about the free electron and the relation to classical theory to you. So in short, I agree. I[t] was very fine to have you here and we all got a lot of ideas from your visit. Unfortunately, Feynman has not yet quantized your theory 176
Letter [436].
April 7, 2009
12:11
114
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
but got sidetracked into some invariance problems. He and Lennox have shown tentatively that Pais’ method for getting a finite self-energy does not give an invariant result.177 The last two days Vicki was here, so we got still more ideas and still less work done. I will let you know if anything new develops. Greetings to everybody, especially to Genia. Yours sincerely, Hans
[439] Rudolf Peierls to Nevill Mott [Birmingham], 17.12.1947 (carbon copy) Dear Mott, In connection with the conference in Bristol that you mentioned to me, I have the impression that this would not overlap seriously with conference we might hold here on somewhat similar lines to the one last year. Ours would concentrate on fundamental theory, steering clear, as far as possible, of cosmic rays, but concentrating on the problem of self energy, pair theory and the like. We might also include nuclear reactions and in that case widen the conference to one that would include experiments as well as theory and make it a joint affair with Oliphant’s department. This will, I think, not overlap much with your plans unless the latter included some sessions devoted specifically to Powell’s work on n-p scattering, or on the D-O reactions etc. As you said your conference would start on the 20th of September, I am planning to have ours start on the 13th, but perhaps finish it well before the end of the week so as to give some time for foreign visitors who want to visit other places in between. I would 177
Hans Bethe reported the results at the Solvay Conference. H.A. Bethe, Report to the Solvay Conference, September 1948. See also R.P. Feynman, ‘Relativistic Cut-Off for Quantum Electrodynamics’, Phys. Rev. 74, 1430—1438 (1948).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
115
be glad to hear your comments on these suggestions and also whether I can assume that the date of your conference is fixed. I would also like to write to Bohr in order to make sure our plans would not interfere with anything he has in mind and in that connection would like to mention your conference. Is that in order or are your plans still confidential? R.E. Peierls
[440] Our Relations with German Scientists [date unspecified, probably early 1948] Since the war there have been few occasions for contact between British and German scientists. Gradually scientific life in Germany seems to get organised again, and with the resumption of scientific publications there are bound to be more exchanges of scientific views and, sooner or later, more opportunities for personal contacts. How will we receive our German colleagues? I have put off writing anything on the subject in the hope that what I am going to say might be said by others. I regard myself as poorly qualified to write, for two reasons: Firstly, I have not visited Germany since the war, and my knowledge of scientific life there is based on reading and on other people’s reports. Secondly, as a former German, I may be suspected of prejudice. However, the matter is important and if others will not speak I cannot remain silent. The problem of the scientists is, of course, not an isolated one, but it is linked up with the position of all the German people after the war. I shall concentrate on the scientist because that is the aspect of the problem of which I have detailed knowledge, and also because it is a particularly acute one in view of the particularly close personal relations that usually exist between scientists of all countries. Amongst scientists, as amongst other people, one finds in this country a widespread readiness to forget the past, to blame the war and the pre-war events on a few political leaders who have been (or in some
April 7, 2009
116
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
cases will be) tried before the courts and to reestablish with all our German colleagues the relations we had when we broke off. This is an attitude which deserves the greatest admiration. It is amazing that after a war which caused so much suffering in this country and which brought Britain so near to ruin, there should be so little ill feeling against the former enemies. It is almost incredible that, with food here severely rationed, pressure of public opinion should have forced the authorities to grant permission for food parcels to be sent to Germany, and that even now, the correspondence columns of the papers reflect more concern with the plight of the Germans than the opposite. All this reflects a mature and enlightened understanding of the fact that there is no sense in collective retribution, that personal hardship on individual Germans will bring no comfort to people here who suffered as a result of the war. It is good to be generous, but there is danger in indiscriminate generosity. It must be remembered that in the interest of the Germans themselves, and in the interest of the future peace of the world, the rebuilding of a sane public life in Germany is of the utmost importance. We must, therefore, consider what effect our attitude is having on German public life, and scientific life in particular. During (and before) the rise of the Nazi party to power, there were some German scholars who were active supporters of the party and who were taken in by the catch phrases and the ‘theories’ of Nazism. They were few in number. The ideas of the party were so crude that extreme passion, ignorance or stupidity were necessary to be taken in by them, and the few who fall in that category were not as a rule scholars of rank. They can safely be ignored. But there were vastly greater numbers of people who had perfectly sufficient intelligence not to be taken in. When in 1933 the Nazi “reforms” hit the German universities there were certainly a large majority of their staff who would not have themselves advanced such changes, and who, if you had asked them, would have declared themselves in favour of academic freedom. They did not like the idea of colleagues being dismissed for no other reason than that they were Liberals, Socialists or Jews. Yet, when the changes came, nearly all of them acquiesced and if they were not personally affected, continued to serve under the new system. This involved in many cases adopting the new language of
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
117
the Nazi system, taking part in ceremonies glorifying this regime and professing admiration for it. A few people would not play. Some left quickly and accepted jobs abroad, some went underground and tried to fight the regime. They soon ended up in a concentration camp or realised the hopelessness of their struggle and left the country. The number included many young people with no established reputation, or with professions in which the work cannot easily be transplanted and these often had to struggle hard to find work abroad in spite of the very generous reception many refugees found in other countries. Some stayed in their jobs with barely concealed disgust, but kept away from administrative responsibility so as to avoid becoming tools of the vicious system. They did not usually go as far as to oppose the regime outright and thus to court certain disaster, but they tried to keep their hands clean. But the majority of university teachers made their peace with the system. Certainly they regretted the excesses, though reading only German newspapers it was easy to forget such uncomfortable facts as concentration camps. They did not like to see useful members of their staff discharged for non-professional reasons and if by pleading it was possible to retain such a person they did their best. But on the whole they accepted the instructions of the authorities loyally just as, being good citizens, they had followed the laws of the previous regime. In fact, as it was considerably more dangerous to be found disloyal to the new regime, the new laws were observed more scrupulously than the old ones. Many of these men must at some time have considered the question of resigning, but as a rule they persuaded themselves that it was their duty to stay in their jobs (or to advance into the jobs vacated by the dismissals) so as to exercise a restraining influence and perhaps to protect some of their junior staff (in practice such protection was never effective for long) or at the most to save their families from hardship. There is, of course, a vast difference here, between junior people for whom resignation might have meant starvation for themselves and their dependents. Much as one admires the few who would not bend no matter what the consequences, one cannot expect everyone to be a hero. But no heroism was involved for the front-rank men, many of whom could have found
April 7, 2009
118
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
jobs abroad at once, or who (during earlier years) could have left the country with part of their savings and would never have been destitute, though resignation would have entailed serious sacrifice for them too. Few would admit that they stayed for the sake of their own comfort. This did not always mean that the money mattered; many were too keen to keep their positions because of the prestige (and sometimes because of the research facilities) attached to them. These front-rank men could have given a lead that might have been followed by many of juniors (though the risk was greater for the juniors). We have heard of the refusal of the personnel of a Dutch University to sign a loyalty declaration during the occupation. This resulted in wholesale arrests and deportations. But even the Nazi regime would have hesitated to carry on without the majority of German University teachers. Resignation of a majority might have won the universities respect and a measure of freedom. All of us who were lucky enough not to be faced with a decision of this kind will wonder how sure we are of our own courage in such a situation, and none of us can be quite sure before we have faced it in reality. Yet I refuse to believe that any authority whose justification rests on the shoddy formulations as the Nazi ideology could manage to dismiss a number of University teachers in this country with the remainder staying loyally at their jobs. The general inertia amongst the senior people set the pattern for the younger ones. The more declarations of loyalty were signed by leading people, the greater was the risk for any other man who wanted to keep out. Accordingly the courageous few who risked serious suffering felt almost greater resentment against the “good citizens” who compromised for the sake of peace and comfort, than against the few fools who were taken in, or the scoundrels who joined the party for personal gain. Now they are nearly all back in academic life. The good citizen, who is good at signing papers and getting along with the authorities, is back in the leading job and gets on excellently with the representatives of Military Government. He has now found the courage to disassociate himself from the Nazi creed. He is beginning to discover that it is much less dangerous to contradict the Military Government than to contradict the Nazis, and he is now found to hold an opinion of his own. Of the
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
119
active collaborators, some are back, too, since they have a chance of counting as “victims of Nazi persecution” if they had a row with a party official or got into a concentration camp for embezzling party funds. The decent people, who managed to keep their hands clean are back. They are much more awkward people to deal with; they think about principles and they get worried if they think the Military Government is making mistakes. They are not too easy to get along with. The real victims are back too — if they have survived. They are rarely in leading positions; they have been out of the business for too long to have administrative experience or to be up-to-date in their professional work. So they work under the good citizen whom it makes very uncomfortable to look at them or in some cases under the old party member who proved his integrity by having a row with Nazi officials. On paper they have some privileges, they do not amount to very much. In this atmosphere the education continues. Many of them are still influenced by their earlier education under the Nazi system. They are, to a varying degree, ready to accept new ideas and there is no doubt that the spirit of their teachers and professional leaders exercises a profound influence on their attitude, and thus may determine the attitude of the future professional men and administrators. Here is the place where it would be vitally important to encourage the democratic ideals, unprejudiced thought about the past as well as the future, personal integrity, and independence of opinion. On several occasions I have met Germans who throughout the war have managed both to retain their self-respect in spite of temptation and their lives in spite of persecution, and they deeply regretted that the Universities were reopened too soon. They argued that compromises were justified in the case of key administrators or technicians in industry without them the economy of the country would have deteriorated even more. If reliable people could not be found for these jobs, one had to make do with more doubtful ones. But in the Universities, the position is different. The aims they serve are long-range ones, and one has to balance the immediate effects of a shortage of professional men against the danger of allowing again the growth of a professional class whose spirit may repeat to a dangerous
April 7, 2009
120
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
extent the pattern that was a vital element in the growth of Nazism. Much better for Germany, those Germans argue, to build up a few centres staffed with people whose records are known, and who would attract in the course of time, others of similar attitude. One or two such centres do, I believe, exist, but they are overshadowed by the majority of other universities. This is the background against which we should consider our attitude to German colleagues. We much remember the prestige attached, in German eyes, to an invitation to go abroad, at a time when foreign travel is virtually impossible, the effect on morale of close personal relations with people in other countries, and above all the effect on the feelings of those few decent people who do not get the same reception. I do not, of course, for a moment wish to suggest that we should interrupt, or fail to resume, the exchange of scientific information. If a scientist, whatever his personal record, has ideas or results to contribute, it would be foolish and contrary to the principles of scholarship to take no notice of them. Equally we would wish him to be acquainted with our own results and ideas which we publish in scientific literature so as to make them openly available to all. Most of us are so accustomed to carry on technical discussion with our good friends that it seems almost impossible to distinguish one’s personal relations from the professional ones. And evidently it is much pleasanter, and more convenient, if we are able to receive our colleagues as friends. But it is certainly not impossible to draw a distinction. Those of us who had the experience between 1933 and 1939 of meeting German scientists whom they knew to be party members and in active support of the regime, will remember that it was painful but quite possible to discuss technical matters without letting one’s memory of the other person’s record be blunted. We might get some advice on this from scientists in countries occupied during the war for whom it was a common experience to meet men whom they respected professionally, but from whom they wanted to keep aloof personally and socially. It is not, of course, easy to discriminate, quite often we do not know enough about each of these men to define our attitude. It would be much more comfortable for us if this work were done by the authorities, or by the denazification tribunals. But their decisions rest on a different basis.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
121
They are concerned with questions of expediency as well as principle and (much as we may deplore the large part expedience plays in German university plans) they do not decide the problem which I have tried to formulate. The problem of deciding is not unsurmountable. About the senior men, who held positions of responsibility under the old regime, much is widely known, and more can be learned from colleagues in Holland, Belgium, Scandinavia and other countries who mostly had first-hand knowledge of this problem at a time when it was far less academic than it is now. Much less is known about the younger ones, but about them we can far better afford to be generous in case of doubt.
[441] Nevill Mott to Rudolf Peierls Bristol, [date unspecified]178 Dear Peierls, I promised Kurti to write something on Skinner’s proposals, and this led me into putting down my opinion now ab[out] control of A[tomic] E[nergy]. I hope you can read my scrawl. Would you like to have it circulated to the A.S.A.Council as a basis for discussion? Actually, I don’t think that we shall any more get agreed statements — unless we shed our left wing — if then! Also if people want to meet and discuss our policy on this, I think we should urge them to put down their views in writing first, or else say how they agree or disagree with a statement like this — purposely rather than controversial. P[lease] return for typing. N.F. Mott
178
The letter was received on 6.1.1948.
April 7, 2009
12:11
122
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[442] Nevill Mott to Rudolf Peierls Bristol, 2.2.1948 Dear Peierls, Thank you for sending me your MS.179 As you know, though I agree with your diagnosis, I do not agree with your conclusions. I do, of course, agree with what you say about the wet behaviour of German University Professors during the war. Also that I can’t imagine British Universities behaving in the same way. The question is, what to do about it? I believe your solution impossible. One cannot dig up the political past of each man whom one might invite to come here. I tried over Justi,180 to whom Simon had strong objections. I could not find anyone else in Holland or England who knew Justi (I don’t mean I wrote more than a dozen letters). What I did get was a lot of opinions, favourable as unfavourable, on Simon’s judgements in such matters. The whole thing made me rather sick. I shall not do it again. Have you read last week’s leading article in the Economist? I very much agree with it. We ought now to give the Germans full authority again over their own economic and cultural affairs. To attempt to reeducate them through Military Government will probably have the opposite effect to what we intend. Then, as regards to our scientific contacts, I think they should be based on scientific achievement, and be coupled with normal friendliness. What you ask, (though your case looks strong in this instance) is that the scientific invitations should be affected by political judgements. It seems to me simply untrue that we as a body, can choose “decent” Germans (or decent Americans, those who have stood up to the Committee of Unamerican activities???) because noone will agree on who is “decent”. Your proposal opens the door to such questions as “is he anti-nazi?’; “Is he anti-Soviet?”; “Is he pro or anti-Marshall · · · ?”, and I would not like to see this enter our scientific relations. 179
Item [440]. Eduard Justi (1904–1986), German electrochemist who had been working on fuel cells at the University of Braunschweig. He later became professor of low-temperature physics at Braunschweig (1946–74). 180
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
123
Well, like the question of whether or not we should make atomic bombs, these are emotional and ethical judgements. I don’t expect to convince you; your experience is different from mine and, of course, you’ll have different ideas on what is of first importance. Yours ever, N.F.M
[443] Rudolf Peierls to Nevill Mott [Birmingham], 6.2.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Mott, As you say,181 the problem of German scientists is one on which we shall have to agree to differ, but I would like to comment on one or two points in your letter. I quite agree, of course, and I have experienced myself, the difficulty of finding out something about the lesser known people, but the point is the importance of the cases of the prominent people whose record is known to everybody in Germany, since what matters i[s] the effect on German people. I also agree that there will never be unanimity on the merits of one particular person, but what I am asking is not that we should agree, but that each of us should form judgement, not of course about anybody’s political views but on his personal integrity which is a rather different story. If any scientists in this country had been convicted of robbing a bank or fraudulent bankruptcy, we would still listen to his lectures or read his papers, but if an occasion arose to ask him to dinner or shake his hand on a social occasion, we should want to know what we personally felt about his record. To quote a relevant example, if we will have an occasion again to meet Nunn-May, no doubt, people’s reactions will differ to what their 181
Peierls refers to letter [442].
April 7, 2009
124
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
personal relations to him should be, some will decide that their behaviour will not be influenced by his actions, others will have nothing to do with him, but this is quite apart from what we think about his political views. All of us will wish to do what we can to see that he is enabled to carry on scientific work in the most favourable circumstances. All I am asking for is the things that people in Germany did or failed to do, be considered as important as robbing a bank or violating the Official Secrets Act. There is a lot in what you say in letting Germans run their own affairs, but this would have been a lot more convincing if it had been done from the beginning. This would have led to a good deal of unpleasantness, possibly even a good deal of bloodshed, but after having intervened to restore order and to back the “respectable” people, the occupation authorities have accepted the responsibility which they cannot suddenly drop. If my article gets published, I hope this will start some correspondence including letters from people holding views like yours and the result of that will be to help people appreciate the issues and make up their minds one way or another. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[444] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr Birmingham, 6.2.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, I should probably have written before to say that I had a brief opportunity while I was in America182 to discuss the draft of our paper 182 Rudolf Peierls had been to the US for a conference, and on that occasion met George Placzek with whom he discussed the Bohr-Peierls-Placzek paper. Peierls appears to have left a copy of the draft with Placzek who commented on it and passed the revised manuscript on to Bohr, when the latter came to Princeton in May 1948. See R. Peierls, ‘Introduction’, Bohr: Collected Works, Vol. 9, p. 51.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
125
with Placzek. Placzek raised a number of small points that might want amending, but it seemed to us that all these could be taken care of by alterations of a few words, they could well wait until we knew your reaction to the main outline. It has occurred to me that one of these points might be causing you difficulty and that it might save you trouble to draw your attention to it. It concerns the derivation of the Breit-Wigner formula. The derivation which I have sketched is valid only for the part of the resonance curve for which the kinetic energy of the emerging neutron (or other particle) differs only by a small fraction from its value at resonance. It does not cover either cases in which the width of the resonance level is comparable to the kinetic energy of the neutron at resonance or the cross section for thermal neutrons (1/ν law). We tried to see whether it was easy to generalise the derivation so as to cover these cases as well, but we felt that this was not possible without spoiling the transparency of the argument, but that it was preferable, therefore, to leave the derivation as it stands and merely to make clear to which category of problem it is applicable. Since the purpose of the paper is mainly to deal with high energies, it would be quite reasonable to use an argument which is not appropriate for very low velocities. I am afraid that local arrangements made it necessary to make a decision on our plans for the summer about which I wrote to you before, and we have decided to go ahead with a conference here in the week starting 20th September.183 This will be a joint affair of the Physics and Mathematical Physics Departments. I very much hope that in doing so, we are not clashing too badly with any plans you have in mind. With very best wishes to all friends in Copenhagen, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
183
While Rudolf Peierls was at Birmingham, he co-organised two major international conferences, one in 1948 and one in 1953. See Peierls, Bird of Passage, pp. 261–2.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
126
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[445] Rudolf Peierls to Werner Heisenberg [Birmingham], 11.2.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Professor Heisenberg, I hear that you are spending some time in this country and I would be very glad if it were possible to visit Birmingham and talk to our Seminar. I have a group of about 15 people, most of whom are working on field theory and other fundamental problems and of whom all have heard a good deal of fundamental theory so that they will appreciate a talk on a rather advanced level. They would also be interested to hear about superconductivity, though they are much less familiar with the background there and one could not assume too much to be known. Our seminar normally meets on Thursday afternoons, but if necessary it would be easy to arrange a meeting on another day. In any case, you would have to spend at least one night in Birmingham and if you can manage it, it would be even better if you could stay for several days so that there would be more opportunity for full discussion of any problems you care to tell us about and also of the work we are trying to do here. I have lately thought a good deal about the problems arising from the relations of scientists here and in other countries with those in Germany, and you may be interested to see what my views are from the enclosed copy of an article that I hope to get published.184 I feel that while these problems are not easy to discuss, it is important that they be faced frankly and I hope that during your visit there would be an opportunity to have a frank talk about these things. It may well be that you will not agree with me on these matters, but that is no reason why we should not, in any case, get together over physics. Please let me know whether it would be possible for you to come and what would be a good time. The coming week would not be convenient for us, but from 24th February almost any day would be possible. If 184
Item [440].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
127
you will let me know how long you are able to stay, I can make sure accommodation is arranged for you. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[446] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls [Ithaca], 12.2.1948 Dear Rudy: Thanks for your letter of February 5.185 There seems to be quite a mess about paying the fares for the Solvay Conference.186 I saw Blackett for a few minutes and he told me he would talk to the U.S. Navy. At that time he did not seem to want any help, but if he does I shall of course stand by. Bragg wrote me recently that “he was sure they could arrange to pay for my fare.” I am not sure how much that means, but I shall wait for developments. I am sorry I will be very much in a rush around the Solvay Conference because it is in the midst of our term. Moreover, I am still planning to come over for a more leisurely visit this summer. So I would rather not visit you in connection with the Solvay Conference, unless it just happens that my return plane is delayed. It seems that our summer trip will also be made by plane so that we shall arrive quite early in June. My plans are to spend the time from then until July 15 visiting various places in England, except for about two weeks that I want to spend with my parents-in-law. That can easily be arranged at my convenience. When will it be best to come to 185 Letter Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe, 5.2.1948, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b2102, C.16. 186 The 8th Solvay Conference was to take place in October 1948. From the official photograph it appears that Bethe did not take part in the conference after all.
April 7, 2009
12:11
128
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
you and to go to other places in England? Will you have a conference during this time? This might be a great advantage to me because it would probably facilitate getting my trip paid. Skyrme187 is of course most welcome. The only boundary condition is that I will be in Columbia the first semester next year and at Cornell the second. I do not think that the Commonwealth people and Skyrme will mind this. Yours sincerely, Hans [447] Werner Heisenberg to Rudolf Peierls Cambridge, 17.2.1948 Lieber Peierls! Haben Sie vielen Dank f¨ ur Ihren Brief. Ich komme gerne nach Birmingham, und ich kann ja vor Ihrem Seminar u ¨ber das wenige sprechen, was ich von der Theorie der Elementarteilchen zu wissen glaube. Ich danke Ihnen auch sehr daf¨ ur, dass Sie mir offen Ihre Meinung u ¨ber ein schwieriges politisches Problem geschrieben haben.188 Es ist so, wie Sie vermuten: ich bin nicht mir Ihnen einverstanden. Aber die Tatsache, dass Sie mir so offen geschrieben haben, gibt mir Hoffnung, dass wir in einem Gespr¨ ach wenn auch nicht zu einer Angleichung der Standpunkte so doch zu einem Verst¨ andnis des anderen Standpunktes kommen k¨onnen. Zur Frage des Zeitpunktes: Vom 10.–12. M¨ arz bin ich bei Blackett; ich k¨ onnte am 12. nach B[irmingham] kommen und bis zum Abend des 13. bleiben. Eventuell auch 8. und 9. M¨ arz, wenn aus dem geplanten Besuch in Oxford nichts wird. W¨ urde Ihnen das passen? Also auf gutes Wiedersehen, Ihr Werner Heisenberg 187
Tony Skyrme, at the time university research fellow at Birmingham, spent the academic years 1948–50 in the United States, as research associate at M.I.T. and as a member of the Institute of Advanced Study at Princeton. 188 Peierls had sent Heisenberg a copy of his memorandum [440].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
129
[448] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 3.3.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you for your letter of 13th February.189 I have now at last my Solvay report finished and, while you will receive a copy through official channels, I thought I had better let you have one as soon as possible for your information. In most English universities term finishes about 1st July, in Birmingham in particular is finishes with the Degree Ceremony on the 3rd. Between the 24th and 29th of June are our examiners’ meetings when there is one or sometimes two meetings almost every day. I am hoping to go on a holiday about the middle of July, so that the best time to see you here would be either before 22nd June or between 30th June and about 12th July. I shall be away for three weeks and then again here from early August, though naturally, of course, during August other members of my department may be away at various times. Lastly, we shall have a conference here from the 14th to 18th September. I hope this is not too late for you. It will this time be a bigger affair covering experimental as well as theoretical problems, but we hope nevertheless to preserve the informal character of our last conference, at any rate in the theoretical meetings. You will receive an official invitation to that conference in a day or two. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
189
Refers to letter [446].
April 7, 2009
12:11
130
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[449] Robert Serber to Rudolf Peierls Berkeley, 4.3.1948 Dear Rudolph: The experimental facts about the np scattering are about as follows: Good measurements have been made, under Segre’s direction, using triple coincidence counters to detect the protons. These have been carried from 5◦ to 50◦ (perhaps 55◦ ) in the lab system. The average neutron energy is 90 Mev. The cross section in the center of mass system looks like
There is evidence from the counter work that the curve rises again on the left. However, the conclusion about the symmetry comes principally from the work of Powell, who scatters the neutrons in a hydrogen filled cloud chamber. While the statistics of the cloud chamber results are not very good yet, they are in good agreement with the counter data for cos θ > 1, and are symmetric. I didn’t quite say that this is support for strong coupling (in fact Dancoff and I are on record in the Physical Review as saying that strong coupling theories can’t account for nuclear forces).190 What I said was that the easiest way of describing what symmetrical scattering means is to say that after the collision, the neutron forgets whether it started as a neutron or as a proton. This would be natural with strong coupling; and, although weak coupling theories may be fixed up to give the same result, it would involve apparently arbitrary and accidental choices of coupling parameters. 190
R. Serber and S.M. Dancoff, ‘Strong Coupling Mesotron Theory of Nuclear Forces’, Phys. Rev. 63, 143–61 (1943).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
131
I doubt if a symmetric theory will turn out to fit the facts. At 90 Mev the Born approximation is not very bad, and although the double scattering effects are then all right, and quite visible to the naked eye, they are not big enough to do much symmetricising. This isn’t by any means conclusive — the errors in the cloud chamber work are still too big to say that the symmetry of the scattering is really established.191 I would be interested in hearing of your new method of calculating. We have fooled around with variation methods, but finally decided the easiest and quickest way was to use a partial wave analysis, and determine phase shifts by WKB approximation. The WKB method gives remarkably good wave functions, and, if better accuracy is wanted, a single iteration of the WKB solutions in the integral equation for the wave function gives a better result than we ever need. Also, it is just as easy to get the WKB solutions including tensor forces. Assuming that the scattering is symmetric, we can get a pretty good description of the facts by taking a simple Yukawa potential with a range of 1.2 × 10−13 as determined by Breit from the p − p scattering. This gives σ(0◦ )/σ(90◦ ) = 3, in agreement with experiment, and a total cross section of 0.087 barns, compared to McMillan’s 0.084 ± .003. However, if tensor forces are included, it is a real strain to get a big enough quadripole moment with such a short range force. Perhaps it is not possible at all, but we quickly found out that the tensor force would have to be so large that the calculated ratio σ(0◦ )/σ(90◦ ) = 3 would be reduced greatly. So we are now engaged in seeing if with a larger range we can fit the data. The n − p scattering has been crowded into the background at the moment. Perhaps you have already heard that Lattes and Gardner192 have found mesons made in the cyclotron. The experimental arrange191
Serber had recently published on the subject R. Serber, ‘Nuclear Reactions at High Energies’, Phys. Rev. 72, 1114–1115 (1947). Another important contribution was his paper, together with Fernbach and Taylor published in the following year; S. Fernbach, R. Serber and T.B. Taylor, ‘The Scattering of High Energy Neutrons by Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1352–55 (1949). 192 J. Burfening, Eugene Gardner and C.M.G. Lattes, ‘Positive Mesons Produced by the 184-Inch Berkeley Cyclotron’, Phys. Rev. 75, 382–87 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
132
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ment is like this:
This all takes place inside the vacuum chamber of the cyclotron, and the magnetic field focuses negative mesons on the plates. This density on the plates is about 108 what one can get in cosmic rays. Most of them are seen to end in stars, and probably all do. Their mass, determined by Hρ and range measurements on 50 tracks, is 313 ± 16. This is all the information we have at the moment, but we look forward to a busy future. Needless to say, I would be delighted to hear any ideas you may have concerning either scattering or the mesons. With best regards, Robert Serber [450] Werner Heisenberg to Rudolf Peierls Cambridge, 4.3.1948 Lieber Peierls! Leider haben sich meine Pl¨ane wieder etwas ¨andern m¨ ussen, da ich aller Wahrscheinlichkeit am Freitag, d[em] 12. abends in London sein muss. K¨ onnten Sie eventuell, wenn ich nicht nach B[irmingham] kommen kann, — etwa f¨ ur Donnerstag — nach Manchester kommen? Ich w¨ urde Sie wirklich gerne wieder sprechen. Vielleicht k¨ onnte ich auch Samstag fr¨ uh noch nach B[irmingham] fahren. Jedenfalls will ich versuchen, Sie am Mittwoch abend oder Donnerstag fr¨ uh in B[irmingham] anzurufen. Bis dahin weiss ich genau, was meine Verpflichtungen sind. Hoffentlich auf gutes Wiedersehen! Ihr W. Heisenberg
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
133
[451] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 18.3.1948 Dear Rudy: I suppose the enclosed letter to Bragg is self-explanatory.193 I should really like very much to be back in time. This of course also applies to your conference. In view of the new date for the Solvay Conference, I wonder whether your Theoretical Conference would not be more convenient in June or early July. I do not know whether that is possible. If not, could it be early in September? Otherwise the program outlined in your letter suits me very well. I intended to be in Switzerland and possibly Germany from the middle of July to the end of August which overlaps with the time you intend to be absent from Birmingham. I shall probably come to see you in the beginning of July but maybe I shall stop for a day or two in early June. Yours sincerely, Hans Thanks a lot for your Solvay report!
[452] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 23.3.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thank you for your letter.194 I am very sorry that the date of our meeting is too late for you. Unfortunately, it is impossible to change it 193
Letter Hans Bethe to W.L. Bragg, 18.3.1948 asking Bragg to take into account the American academic calendar when rescheduling the Solvay Conference. Carbon copy in Peierls Papers, Mc.Eng.misc.b202, C.16. 194 Letter [451].
April 7, 2009
12:11
134
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
now since the invitations have gone out, the accommodation has been booked (this is very short as you may imagine) and particularly as there are a number of other events in September. It begins with a[n] International Conference on Applied Mathematics and Mechanics from 6th–11th September which will overlap to a slight degree in membership with ours. There are also likely to be some business meetings involving a number of our people as well as possible foreign visitors during the later half of that same week. In the week following our conference is the Cosmic Ray Conference at Bristol which was the first one to get fixed and, in fact, our date was partly chosen to enable the overseas visitors to attend both conferences. Following that, of course, is the Solvay. I am surprised at what you say about the starting date of the American universities since last year the majority of visitors seemed to remain in Europe until the end of the Copenhagen Conference in the very last days of September. I very much hope you will be able to delay your return to take in our conference at least, if not Bristol and the Solvay. I understand the meeting sponsored by the American Emergency Committee of Atomic Scientists will now not be held in Jamaica, but in the United States. I have said that I accept in principle, but if the date remains in June I shall probably not get away in time. I would be grateful to have your views as to whether this meeting is likely to serve a useful purpose and whether it would be worth the effort to go there, particularly if it means missing important University meetings. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely [Rudi] [453] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 7.4.1948 Dear Rudy: Thanks for your letter of March 23.195 I am rather sad that the conference cannot be moved. The starting of American Universities has 195
Letter [452].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
135
always been around September 20. The trouble was only that Uncle Nick has always disregarded university schedules and chosen the dates for his Copenhagen Conference at random. Some visitors, like Vicky, were too anxious to go to the grand reopening of the Copenhagen meetings196 last year and therefore did not return in spite of the semester. (I appreciate that the Bristol meeting was the first to get fixed and I protested immediately to Powell about his date, but without success.) I have pretty much decided to go to your conference but none of the later ones. I hope that I will hear everything in Birmingham then and earlier in the summer. The meeting sponsored by the American Emergency Committee197 is not likely to serve a useful purpose. It was Szilard’s idea to have such a meeting to bring together scientists from all countries east and west of the iron curtain. Those from the east of the curtain have already refused to attend, as was to be expected. In the present situation, it is my opinion, that nothing useful can be done from the side of atomic energy or of scientists in general and that any stress on atomic energy can only deepen the international conflict. I was very much against holding this conference and this opinion is shared by other people such as Oppenheimer and Weisskopf. By the way, I resigned from the Emergency Committee, not because of the conference but because of my conviction of the futility of these endeavors at the present time. I have also heard some rumors that the Federation of American Scientists is giving up the idea of the International Conference. This seems sensible to me, but of course the Emer196
The conference had attracted a large number of physicists who spent some time in Copenhagen during the last two weeks of September 1947. Among them were Kramers, Weisskopf, Pais, Rosenfeld, Peierls, Blackett, Placzek, Wheeler, Rossi, Ferretti, Klein. See letter Wolfgang Pauli to Otto Stern, 19.8.1947, K.V. Meyenn (ed.), Wolfgang Pauli. Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel mit Bohr, Einstein, Heisenberg u.a., Vol. 3: 1940–1949, Heidelberg: Springer, 1993 (hereinafter cited as Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, with volume number), p. 471. 197 See letter [452].
April 7, 2009
12:11
136
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
gency Committee is an independent agency. Anyway, I would much rather talk physics with you than have you go to that conference. Thanks very much for the parliamentary debates of the House of Lords.198 I am of course very proud. Yours sincerely Hans
[454] Robert Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls and Mark Oliphant [Princeton], 8.4.1948 Dear Peierls and Oliphant: Thank you both for your good notes of invitation to the Birmingham Conference. I am sending in an acceptance which I only hope will correspond to reality when the time comes. I want very much to visit with you and talk over the many wonderful developments in physics, as well as other problems with which we have had a common concern in the past. You ask for other suggestions for invitees to the conference. There are two who have carried out essentially parallel and very beautiful developments in quantum electrodynamics, Julian Schwinger at Harvard and Sin-itiro Tomonaga in Japan. It would surely be a great addition to the conference if they could both come. I hope that there is nothing improper in my accepting an invitation in which it is inevitable that there be a little uncertainty as to my plans. With all warmest greetings, Robert Oppenheimer
198
Almost certainly this refers to the parliamentary debate on the perils of atomic warfare launched by the Archbishop of York, 18 February 1948, Hansard, HoL, Vol. 153, cols 1178–1213.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
137
[455] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 15.4.1948 Dear Oppie, Thank you for your letter.199 We are delighted that there is at least a chance of seeing you here, and it is, of course, quite in order to accept provisionally: we only hope you will be able to keep to it. We had already invited Schwinger. As regards Sin-itiro Tomonaga, we do not know anything about him directly, but would be very glad to have him on your recommendation, if the administrative side of it could be managed. Presumably he could not be brought here without some help from the U.S. authorities in Japan, and I imagine you know better than we do whether, and how, they can be approached. I accordingly enclose an invitation for this purpose and we would be very grateful to you if you could have it passed along the right channel, or alternatively suggest to us the right “ansatz”. With best wishes, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[456] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Serber [Birmingham], 17.4.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Bob, Thank you very much for your letter of 4th March.200 I quite agree with you that the new discoveries about artificial mesons are much more exciting than n–p scattering, still, it seems worth continuing the discussion on n–p scattering. I enclose a curve giving the results of 199 200
Letter [454]. Letter [449].
April 7, 2009
12:11
138
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
calculations by Barker201 here and a copy of a note to Nature202 explaining the calculations. The method of Ferretti and Krook which he used and which is being published in the May number of the Proceedings of the Physical Society203 goes as follows: We need to determine the logarithmic derivative at some point r = a beyond the range of the forces. Supposing we start with the right value of [. . . ]204 we will get a solution which is regular at the origin, otherwise the solution is singular at the origin. Consider the Taylor series for [. . . ]205 at a. For the general solution which is singular at the origin the radius of convergence of this Taylor series can at most be a and usually is just a. For the regular solution it is larger. If I consider, therefore, the ratio between two successive Taylor coefficients, it should converge to a much lower value if the parameter [. . . ]206 is chosen in the right way. The approximation now consists in applying this criterion not to the limit, but to a Taylor coefficient of finite order. It is found in practice that for a sensible choice of a, something like the 10th coefficient will give a very good accuracy and the determination of these coefficients is very rapid, provided the potential function is such that the required successive differentiations do not give too much trouble. The method is also applicable to tensor forces and Barker is now engaged in a discussion of this problem using something like the Schwinger theory. I am a little puzzled by your statement that at 90 Mev the Born Approximation would give only backward scattering, whereas the more likely case B of Barker’s, the forward and backward intensities for exchange forces differ only by a factor three. Qualitatively Barker’s curves are very similar to those published by Bethe, but we were reluctant to 201
See also F.C. Barker and R.E. Peierls, ‘On the Definition of the “Effective Range” of Nuclear Forces’, Phys. Rev. 75, 312–13 (1949). 202 F.C. Barker and D.G. Ravenhall, ‘Scattering of like particles at 100 MeV’, Nature 163, 20 (1949). 203 B. Ferretti and M. Krook, ‘On the Solution of Scattering and Related Problems’, Proc. Phys. Soc. 60, 481–90 (1949). 204 Missing in carbon copy. Details of the calculation found in the above paper, note 203. 205 Missing in carbon copy. 206 Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
139
use the square well, since at short wave lengths the sharp boundaries are liable to give spurious effects. However, we need not have worried apparently, since it looks as if the wave length is not as yet very short. As far as I can see from your account of the experiments, the statement that the curve is symmetrical rests entirely on the cloud chamber data, and it would seem a little premature to draw conclusions until one knows with what accuracy symmetry is really established. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[457] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 6.5.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, You may be interested in the enclosed note which we have sent to Nature. The results bear out qualitatively what you have found independently with a square well. We were afraid of a square well, since at very short wavelength the sharp edges of the well are liable to give serious interference effects. We started, of course, like most people with the idea that 100 MeV is a high energy. The results show that it isn’t, and so probably the square well is as good as anything else. It is, however, desirable that at these energies the results are insensitive to the nature of the forces, no doubt this would change at still higher energies, but even if these could be attained, they will be very much harder to interpret because of relativistic effects and the like. What is more pleasing is the rapidity with which it is possible to calculate phases by a method of Ferretti and Krook.207
207
See letter [456], note 203.
April 7, 2009
140
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
The trick is as follows: You choose a point r = 2 beyond the range of the forces and you imagine that you integrate the equations inwards from this point. In general, i.e. choosing the wrong slope, the answer will be singular at the origin and its Taylor series about a will have a radius of convergence at most equal to a. For the correct slope the radius of convergence will be larger and may even be infinite. Accordingly you can get the correct slope by imposing the condition that the Taylor series should converge as well as possible. As an approximation you make the nth term in these series as small as possible, i.e. equal to zero, and for quite reasonable n this gives a good approximation of the slope and hence to the phase. Since in this operation only successive differentiations are required, it is quite easy to go to, say n = 10 without much trouble if your potential is of a reasonably simple analytical form. The method works amazingly well and can be generalised to tensor forces. We are getting rather excited about the self-energy problem. You remember Salpeter here having a proof for the one-body problem that the self-energy is calculated exactly and without perturbation theory and was really infinite.208 In trying to generalise this to the case of hole theory, he struck some snags, however, and there seems now the possibility that the statement is not in fact true in hole theory, but that the logarithmic infinity disappears if one calculates exactly. We are very far from having proved this, but the mere possibility is, of course, very important. Another point that agitates me is the self-energy of the photon. In the ordinary way this, of course, is again infinite and one would expect with the usual tricks or, for example, with the kind of modification that McManus or Feynman are playing with,209 to make it finite. However, the rest mass of the photon is not merely finite, it must be very exactly zero, and the only way to get this in any of these theories is to assume a finite mechanical rest mass for the photon which would then exactly 208 Ed Salpeter (1924–) was completing his Ph.D. at Birmingham in 1948. After a brief period he went to Cornell to work with Hans Bethe where, apart from brief research spells elsewhere he stayed for the remainder of his career. 209 R.P.Feynman, ‘Relativistic Cut-Off for Quantum Electrodynamics’, Phys. Rev. 74, 1430–38 (1948).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
141
cancel the finite (negative) dynamic mass. This is rather interesting formally and it means, amongst other things, that perturbation theory applied to this must always give utter nonsense since you can never get a finite rest mass to rest mass zero by a small perturbation. See you in June. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[458] Max Born to Rudolf Peierls Edinburgh, 22.5.1948 Dear Peierls, There are two things I would like to have your opinion about. The first is this: I got to-day an information from the R[oyal] S[ociety] about the recommendations of names for election of Foreign Members. Apart from Cripps, and two names unknown to me, there are Browser and Pauling. But not Schr¨ odinger. Dirac and I have tried for years to bring him into the R[oyal] S[ociety] The main obstacle is the letter he wrote in Graz, in which he expressed his agreement with the Nazis (or something like that; part of it was, I think, published in “Nature”).210 On account of this silly document a group of people have prohibited his election. The formal difficulty is that he is not British; hence he cannot be an ordinary Fellow. And as he lives in Eire which is regarded as part of the British Empire, he cannot be a Foreign Member. Now the latter obstacle has been removed, as far as I know, by a special decision of the Council. When I heard that Heitler was to be elected I wrote some strong letters to members of the Sectional Committee, saying that it would be an affront to Schr[¨ odinger], if H[eitler] would be in the Society and he not. Actually I have a very high opinion of H[eitler], but still I think Schr[¨ odinger] is of a higher order of magnitude. There is hardly any paper in theoretical physics in the world where not 210
See Letter [273], note 1029 in Lee, Selected Correspondence, Vol. 1, Chapter 5.
April 7, 2009
142
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the Schr[¨ odinger] equation is used. He has actually revolutionised our science. That he was not very lucky in recent years seems to me of less importance. Planck has also not done any fundamental work after 1900. Therefore I feel rather strongly in this matter. I should like to know what you think. It is a great pity that Dirac is not here; I think I could agree with him on some drastic action. But now I do not know what to do. I am quite aware of Schr[¨ odinger]’s shortcomings and of the enmity he has accumulated through his own behaviour. But I think that all this ought not to matter in the question of election to a purely scientific society. The other point is Palestine. I am not a Zionist, not even a Jew by religion. I tried always to be as impartial as possible, on account of my ignorance of the facts. It appeared to me from the newspapers that Britain played a nasty game, arming and training the Arabs and then retiring, to leave the dirty work to the sons of the desert. But I had not proof that this is really so. To-day Manchester Guardian has a leader confirming my worst fears. I think nobody can doubt any more that this is really Bevin’s politics. I think it is almost worse than Hitler, sit still and watch quietly this second mass murder arranged by our own Government? I am a member of the Labour Party — can one stay in it? Should we — you, Polany, Goldstein, I and as many others, as we can get — not publish some protest? I shall write to Einstein for advice. But let me know what you think, or better feel, and also your wife’s opinion. From the Department I could tell you some interesting things, but I am not in the mood for it. With kind regards, Yours ever, M. Born
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
143
[459] Rudolf Peierls to Max Born [Birmingham], 24.5.1948211 (carbon copy) Dear Born, odinger, there is no doubt Thank you for your letter.212 As regards Schr¨ whatever about his merits as a scientist and surely no member of the Royal Society can have any doubt that he is much better than practically all Fellows and Foreign Members recently elected. This issue is, however, whether scientific distinction is the only factor taken into account in the election. As regards election of Fellows that is perhaps the case. The rule is, however, that he is not eligible to be a Fellow and for the election for a foreign member it is probably true that the personal record has also to be weighed. Election of a foreign member has some of the characteristics of conferring an Honorary Degree when personal factors undoubtedly play a legitimate part. I have understood the decision of the Council to mean that they take this view. On grounds of personal record I think there is a very strong case against Schr¨ odinger. The famous Graz letter is only one example, but it is bad enough. To describe it just as ,,silly” is minimising this too much. Our distress at events in Germany was so bitter just because there were so many people who failed to understand the importance of personal integrity and the disastrous effect of men with a worldwide reputation saying what they knew to be wrong for the sake of expediency. It is true that most of us would say or sign such things under strong pressure or in acute danger. We would, however, expect to pay for it and we would disassociate ourselves from such statements as soon as the danger was passed. Schr¨ odinger has never troubled to do so. About other facts my opinion is only based on hearsay, but it adds up to a consistent 211
Two drafts of letters dated 24.5.1948 exist and a further draft dated 29.5.1948, which is the one likely to have been sent. The second draft dated 24.5.1948 is reproduced here to demonstrate the development of Peierls’ thinking on the two issues about which Born had enquired. 212 Letter [458].
April 7, 2009
144
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
impression of irresponsible behaviour. At a time when scientists are in the public eye and when their word counts, there is a particularly strong duty to apply severe standards. The only case you could make out is to claim that the election of a foreign member should be based on scientific merit alone, but if this is done, it must be done consistently. Would you take the same view if Heisenberg’s name were proposed? Or in the hypothetical case that Weizs¨ acker had done work of comparable importance, would you take the same line in his case? On the other matter I agree with you in being distressed over the recent events. I also agree that it is foolish for this country not to recognize the new state. This, however, is only foolish and short-sighted. I do not believe it is particularly immoral. The moral question has been confused ever since, in a spirit of wishful thinking, promises were made to both Arabs and Jews which at least in the interpretation given to the words by each side were outright contradictory. I think it is a tragedy that this whole Palestine adventure was ever started. The numbers that can be accommodated there are pitifully small to make any difference to the wider problem and the trouble arising from it will only make more difficult the problem of settling homeless Jews elsewhere and of creating a tolerable situation for others in the places where they are now living. I believe that nationalism is always bad and Jewish nationalism is no exception. This does not diminish the distress one feels about the violence which is abundant there now and which, as always, must hit harmless people. I do not think, however, one has any right to protest in public, unless one also protested at the violence from Jewish terrorists when this was hitting harmless civilians on the other side. What one can argue about is expediency in the long run. I do not believe that your opinion or mine on this point will be particularly welcome, but I believe that political pressure from America which is undoubtedly being exerted is much more likely to change the position. If you hear from Einstein it would, of course, be interesting to know his views, but one should not follow his example which is to give his
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
145
name to any cause for which it is requested regardless of whether or not he has any knowledge of the case and thereby achieving a position where nobody takes any notice of his signature under any appeal. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[460] Rudolf Peierls to Max Born [Birmingham], 29.5.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Born, Thank you for your letter.213 I am sorry it has taken me so long to reply, but I have been away from Birmingham for several days. As regards Schr¨ odinger, there is, of course, no doubt whatever about his merits as a scientist, and surely no member of the R[oyal] S[ociety] Council can have any doubt that he is much more eminent than practically any Fellow or Foreign Member recently elected. The issue is, however, whether scientific distinction is the only factor to be taken into account in the election. As regards Fellows that is perhaps the case. Schr¨odinger, however, does not appear to be eligible as a Fellow and election of a Foreign Member is a rather different story. It is in many ways analogous to conferring an honorary degree, where the personal record is most certainly taken into account. I have understood the decision of the Royal Society to mean that this is their interpretation. On grounds of personal record I think there is a very strong case against Schr¨ odinger. The famous Graz letter is only one example, but it is bad enough. I would not pass it over by just describing it as ,,silly”. Our distress at events in Germany surely was so bitter just because there were so many people who failed to understand the seriousness of the issues, and the importance of personal integrity. If a man with a worldwide reputation says what he knows not to be true for reasons of 213
Letter [458].
April 7, 2009
146
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
expediency, it is not merely silly. Admittedly most of us would say or sign such things under strong pressure or in acute danger. But we would expect to pay for it, and in any event would presumably disassociate ourselves from what we said as soon as it was safe to do so. To my knowledge, Schr¨ odinger has never troubled to explain this letter was written under pressure. (As far as I know it was not very severe pressure at that). About other similar things I only know from hearsay, such as his retaining his name on the books of the German Legation in Dublin practically as long as such Legation existed. It all adds up to a consistent impression of irresponsibility. At a time when scientists are so much in the public eye and when their words count more than ever, standards of behaviour must be particularly severe. The only case you could make would be to claim that the election of Foreign Members should be based exclusively on scientific standing. But this would have to be applied consistently. Would you take the same view if Heisenberg’s name were proposed? Or in the hypothetical case that Weizs¨acker had done work of comparable importance, would you take the same line in his case? On the question of Palestine, I agree with you in feeling acute distress. Of course, Britain ought to recognize the new state. Their not doing so is short-sighted and foolish, but not particularly wicked. The moral question is incredibly confused and has been confused ever since promises were made both to the Zionists and to the Arabs which, at least in the sense in which each side understood them, were outright contradictory. I have no particular liking for the Arabs, but one must admit that there is considerable justification in their claims. True the Arabs are backward. In the view of the Americans, England is a backward country, too, but noone would admit that this entitles the Americans to take over the country and run it. True also the Arab population is not dense enough to work the land efficiently (at least I imagine it is true) but their refusal to allow others to come in is as justified as the refusal of the British agricultural labourers to allow foreigners to work on the land, even with the present shortage of labour. True, Palestine was a Jewish country in Biblical times; but you cannot reverse history, and hand over America to the Red Indians, or the French, or England to the Celts (if you can find enough).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
147
With all this I do not mean to say that the Arabs are right and the Zionists wrong, but merely that the question is confused and that we have here one of those situations in which each side genuinely had the conviction of being in the right, and where nobody can prove them wrong. This could, of course, have been the perfect situation for UNO to prove its worth. I believe, however, that the utter failure of UNO (which may finish it in the same sense in which Manchuria finished the League of Nations) cannot be blamed on the British Government, it is due to quite irresponsible behaviour on the part of America. I believe it is a pity that this Palestine adventure was ever started. The numbers that can be settled there are pitifully small compared to the number of displaced Jews. The trouble arising over Palestine is bound to make more difficult the problem of finding acceptance for the Jews in countries capable of taking large numbers, or creating tolerable conditions for them in the countries in which they live now. Nationalism is bad anywhere, and Jewish nationalism is no exception. All this, of course, is not the fault of the unfortunate victims who are suffering now in Palestine. Unfortunately, things have gone so far that there is bound to be suffering and violence in Palestine whatever is done. If the British Army moved in again to take over the country and restore order, the violence from terrorists on both sides would not be less severe than the present war. We tend to overestimate the scale of this war, for example a recent statement that a hundred Jews were killed in Jerusalem since the beginning of the fighting shows that the matter is serious but has hardly reached the scale of warfarer. I am sure the government are genuinely anxious to find a solution that would avoid further violence. They probably believe that to recognize the new state, and to withdraw support from the Arab state would cause perhaps fewer victims amongst the Jews but more among the Arabs. Much as our sympathy may be on the side of the Jews, can we really insist that it makes any difference whether men, women and children are killed who speak one language or another? It might make quite the wrong impression if we made public our indignation at attacks on Jewish civilians by the Arab armies, unless we have previously protested against attacks on Arab civilians by Jewish terrorists.
April 7, 2009
12:11
148
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
In the end the problem boils down to expediency, and of what would actually happen if British help to the Arab states was withdrawn. I do not believe that on this question your opinion or mine would carry much weight — or, for that matter, whether it would be based on a particularly sound knowledge of the facts. It is very sad to have to watch these things happening without taking any action, and I can understand your impatience, but I believe that in this particular situation action would not make particularly good sense, nor would it be likely to assist in getting a satisfactory solution of the problem. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[461] Leon Rosenfeld to Rudolf Peierls Manchester, 4.6.1948 Dear Peierls, I enclose the proof of the last chapters of my book containing among others a short account of Ramsay’s argument concerning Schwinger’s theory.214 I need not say that I shall be grateful for your criticism. Blackett showed me your article on the German scientists.215 As you would expect I agree entirely with your views and I think that it would be extremely useful if it could be published. I would like, however, if I were to write such an article myself, to lay perhaps more emphasis than you do on the detrimental influence of the present situation on the youth and I would specifically stress the fact that most German intellectuals are now taking an entirely passive attitude, and instead of contributing their share to the material and moral reconstruction of their country, they pin their hopes on the advantages to be gained from the conflict between the two occupying powers. I would also allude to the regrettable fact that after the liberation there hardly was any spontaneous manifestation from the part of the 214 215
Leon Rosenfeld, Nuclear Forces, Amsterdam: North-Holland Pub. Co., 1948–9. Item [440].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
149
Germans of any regret for the past and desire to do better in the future. I feel also that you should perhaps try to formulate more firmly and more concretely the conclusions of your essay, since as it is now it gives the impression that the problem is hopeless and that there is hardly anything to do about it. Perhaps after all this is true, but still we are confronted with the urgent practical problems such as whether to invite the Germans and so on, on which we have to make up our minds. There is one small point needing correction: the situation in Holland to which you allude on page 3 was a bit more complicated. The so called loyalty declaration was in itself a harmless document that could be signed and was actually signed by all state functionaries, including University teachers. But the conflict arose when the Germans tried to enlist the students for work in Germany. They tried to make the authorization to continue the study dependent on signing similar loyalty declarations. The refusal of most students to do so had nothing to do with the declaration itself, but was a clear protest against the attempts to force them to work for the benefit of the Germans. This protest led to wholesale arrests and deportations of students and also to the persecution of a small number of professors who had been prominent in supporting the students’ action. From this you may see how to modify your text at that particular place in order to avoid inaccurate statements. The cautious way in which the nazis manoeuvred with us in Holland, seems to support your opinion that “even the nazi regime would have hesitated to carry on without the majority of German University teachers”.— With best wishes, Yours sincerely, L. Rosenfeld I enclose the report on the examination for your signature.
April 7, 2009
12:11
150
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[462] Robert Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 16.8.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Peierls: Your good note of August 5th has just reached me. I shall be glad to give the introductory Thursday afternoon talk on the field theory although I have no doubt that a number of people on your list could do a better job.216 We shall probably come up to Birmingham on Monday, September 13th. Kitty will be with me, and we both look forward very much to seeing you both. Am I right in assuming that there will be some place where both she and I can stay? We plan to be with Bohr in Copenhagen the first ten days in September and if you have messages you can best reach us there. Sincerely, [Robert]
[463] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Serber Birmingham, 8.10.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Bob, In trying to remember what I had learned at the Solvay, I came across the following point: I believe you said that the curve for the n − p scattering at 90 MeV looked so symmetrical as between 0◦ –180◦ that you were led to the assumption that there is no scattering at all in the states of odd angular momentum and that you had obtained a good fit with a cental force of such a description. Now, Mr. Preston here points out, in my view correctly, that such a force would not be compatible with the saturation of nuclear forces, since for saturation you must not 216
This refers to the Birmingham Conference to take place in September 1948.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
151
have more “ordinary” force than is contained in the symmetric mixture of Kemmer.217 Of course, all this depends on there being approximate charge independent and negligible many-body forces, but it would be very important to have evidence which forces us to abandon one or the other of these assumptions. The tensor force in itself cannot save the saturation, though, of course, it may alter the nature of the central force that one derives from the Berkeley data. These points have probably occurred to you, but I would be glad to know your reaction and also in view of this it is particularly important to examine how well the symmetry of the pattern is proved from the available data. From what I remember of your slide the points at angles below 90◦ seemed to show more scatter than those above and one could, perhaps, tolerate some deviation from this symmetric pattern. No doubt, you are now examining your suggestion of a non-exchange tensor force and if this works, which I find hard to believe, it may also have some effect on the nature of the central force that you have to assume.218 Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
217 N. Kemmer, ‘The charge-dependence of nuclear forces’, Proc. Cam. Phil. Soc, 34, 354–64 (1938); N. Kemmer, ‘Quantum Theory of Einstein-Bose particles and nuclear interaction’, Proc. Roy. Soc A166, 127–153 (1938). 218 This point is addressed in S. Fernbach, R. Serber and T.B. Taylor, ‘The Scattering of High Energy Neutrons by Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1352–55 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
152
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[464] Robert Serber to Rudolf Peierls Berkeley, 4.11.1948 Dear Rudolph: I am enclosing prints of the slides I showed at the Solvay Conference.219 −Kr 1 The curve labelled II is for the potential 12 (1+Px ) e r , K = 1.2×10−13 . Curve I is for 40 Mev. For charge symmetric forces with this Yukawa potential the cross section at 180◦ would be about 40 × 10−27 , so to get a more reasonable looking curve, the results for charge symmetry with a square well of range 1.8 × 10−13 were plotted as curve IV. (With a square well one can get considerably smaller cross sections than with a smooth potential.) III was intended to be the curve for the Yukawa potential with tensor forces included. However, III is not right, according to our latest results. The trouble was that in plotting III the phase shifts for the 3 D3 +3 G3 states were taken from a Born approximation (a fact I wasn’t aware of when I last saw you). Although the phase shifts are small, the weight factors are big, and using the correct phase shifts makes a quite appreciable difference in the differential cross section. We now think that the proper curve, including tensor forces, is still quite close to II, though some checking of this conclusion is necessary. If true, the difficulties concerning tensor forces have disappeared. As to the symmetry of the scattering: the counter data indicates some asymmetry, though a rather small one, while the cloud chamber data seems to show quite appreciable asymmetry developing at small angles (if the last point can be believed). However, the curve still appears not as asymmetric as one would predict from, say, the “charge symmetric theory”. A small repulsive force in states of odd angular momentum could be invoked to account for the asymmetry, i.e. slightly more exchange than ordinary force. The argument for keeping the forces in the odd states as small as possible in that zero force gives the minimum total cross section from the calculations. 219
See also letter [463].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
153
To explain saturation, one would certainly have to give up charge independence — repulsive forces would have to appear in the like particle interactions. I don’t believe the work which has been done on p − p scattering is much help here; the limit on the amount of repulsive p wave force compatible with the observation is so sensitive to range, and, as far as I know, calculations with short-range forces haven’t been made. There are no results to report yet from our 32 Mev p − p scattering experiments. The latest result on the meson mass ratio is 1.32 ± .0 − 2, so zero mass for the third particle seems pretty certain. The geometry of the apparatus for measuring the π lifetime has been checked by running −8 (half α particles through it. The present figure is τ 1 = 0.9 +.25 −.15 × 10 2 life). With best regards, Robert Serber
[465] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls New York, 10.12.1948 Dear Rudy: Thanks for your several letters. I shall be very happy to have Salpeter220 and I have just written to Wilson about giving him an appointment. I am reasonably sure that we can give him a position as a Research Associate at a salary of $3500 to $3800. This, I think, should be adequate and will correspond approximately to his current salary plus traveling expenses to this country and back. We cannot make any separate arrangement for travel expenses. I hope Dyson will actually decide to come to you.221 He gets better every day. However, he has so many offers that he has not yet made 220
Ed Salpeter moved to Cornell after completing his Ph.D. at Birmingham. Freeman Dyson (1923– ), had studied at Cambridge between 1941 and 1943. After war service in the research division of the R.A.F., Bomber Command, he undertook research at Cambridge (1946–47) and Cornell (1947–1948) before becoming research fellow at Birmingham. 221
April 7, 2009
12:11
154
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
up his mind where to go in England. He has some excessive loyalty to Cambridge; I told him he would waste his time if he went there. I have sent your Letter to the Editor to The Physical Review.222 I knew this derivation or a rather similar one; in fact, I am planning to write a paper in which a still more general and exact relation is derived and used.223 Blatt224 has used still another derivation, but for practical purposes has used essentially your relation. Everything about the scattering of neutrons and protons by protons is getting to be exceedingly simple. Especially the complicated calculations by Breit225 are now quite unnecessary. I have also taken care of your application for membership in The Physical Society. I am enjoying my stay at Columbia.226 I find that I have much more time than usual to do some work. There is quite a lot of progress in quantum electrodynamics and the people most concerned, namely Schwinger, Feynman and Dyson, have been busy writing up their knowledge. At the moment, Rose is visiting me but without the children. Regards to all of you. Yours sincerely, Hans
222
F.C. Barker and R.E. Peierls, ‘On the Definition of the “Effective Range” of Nuclear Forces’, Phys. Rev. 75, 312–12 (1949). 223 H.A. Bethe, ‘Theory of the Effective Range on Nuclear Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 76, 38–50 (1949). 224 John M. Blatt and J. David Jackson, ‘On the Interpretation of Neutron-Proton Scattering Data by the Schwinger Variational Method’, Phys. Rev. 76, 18–37 (1949). 225 G. Breit, H.M. Thaxton and L. Eisenbud, ‘Analysis of Experiments on the Scattering of Protons by Protons’, Phys. Rev. 55, 1018–64 (1939); L.E. Hoisington, S.S. Share and G. Breit, ‘Effects of Shape of Potential Energy Wells Detectable by Experiments on Proton-Proton Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 56, 884–890 (1939), and G. Breit, L.E. Hoisington, S.S. Share and H.M. Thaxton, ‘The Approximate Equality of the Proton-Proton and Proton-Neutron Interactions for the Meson Potential’, Phys. Rev. 55, 1103 (1939). 226 Hans Bethe was visiting professor at Columbia University in the autumn of 1948.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
155
[466] Rudolf Peierls to J.R. Oppenheimer [Birmingham], 16.12.1948 (carbon copy) Dear Oppie, I am writing to ask about two problems which were mentioned in discussions here at the Solvay. The first is that you drew attention to the results by Finkelstein, according to which the lifetime of τ -mesons for the decay into [. . .]227 with the emission of one or two photons was sure to be much shorter than observed. The published paper by Finkelstein covers only some special cases.228 We have looked into this problem more generally. It is easier, of course, to survey the case of the emission of one photon. In this case it seems possible to choose the spin and parity of the two mesons and type the coupling in such a way that this process is forbidden. We are proposing also to study what happens in three cases to the emission of the two photons and to see whether there are cases in which this also can be reduced. I imagine that you may have similar calculations going and, while a certain amount of overlap does no harm, the job of listing all the possible combinations and compiling the results of such a high-order process is one that is scarcely worth duplicating. If, therefore, you think that this problem has been completely explored, or if this is being done, could you let me know? The second point also concerns work by Finkelstein; in this case the question of non-linear theories. You explained that the classical wave equation for two scalar fields, one with, the other without mass, and with a coupling term proportional to the square of the first and the first power of the second wave function has a non-singular stationary solution. We have played a bit with these equations and we have found it very hard to decide whether they have only one solution or an enumerable set. Here again the explanation involves a good deal of hard work and if 227
Missing in carbon copy. R. Finkelstein, ‘The gamma Instability of Mesons’, Phys. Rev. 72, 415–22 (1947); Oppenheimer and Finkelstein had collaborated on this work. E.g. S.T. Epstein, R.J. Finkelstein and J.R. Oppenheimer, ‘Note on Stimulated Decay of Negative Mesons’, Phys. Rev. 73, 1140–41 (1948). 228
April 7, 2009
12:11
156
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Finkelstein knows the answer to this question we would not want to do it again. According to our notes of the meeting you said that there was “at least one” non-singular solution, but our notes may not be accurate. Another point is that you mentioned the question of finding an operator representing the coordinate of the centre of this structure in the quantized equations. I have not yet succeeded in seeing the purpose of this; surely if there exists in quantum theory something corresponding to a structure of finite extent in this equation, its position can be defined in an obvious way to an accuracy given by its size and to that accuracy it must also satisfy the commutation laws with a momentum, since the momentum operator corresponds to an infinitesimal displacement of all fields together. I see no reason, however, why one should expect to have an exact coordinate operator which is defined to a better accuracy than the size. One would be in a position rather similar to that of the ordinary Dirac equation without coupling in which the existence of precise coordinate operator is rather a mathematical luxury and goes by the board as soon as one used pair theory. The direction in which it would be nice to explore such a theory is to find what one can about the existence, or otherwise, of stationary states of finite energy in the quantum equations, but this, of course, is not easy. We greatly enjoyed reading all about you in Time229 and I thought that, with some allowance for the habits of journalists, the article was excellent, except for the remarks about Einstein to which you objected. We were rather amused by the somewhat backhanded compliment to the state of European physics, though, of course, it is easy to reconstruct the remark that you presumably made which got translated in this fashion. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
229
On November 1948, TIME magazine published ‘The Eternal Apprentice’, a cover story on Robert Oppenheimer.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
157
[467] J.R. Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 30.12.1948 Dear Rudi: Thank you for your fine letter.230 It was good to hear from you and made me homesick for a long talk. Let me try to answer your questions. To the best of my knowledge, no systematic search for selection rules to lengthen the lifetime of τ -mesons has been made. Of course examples of selection rules can be found in Finkelstein’s paper;231 and Furry’s theorem gives one other examples. I must say that this last strikes me as somewhat unpromising. Surely in pursuing it one must also investigate stability with regard to electron-positron pairs. I gather that we are looking for a factor which is something like 10−9 , since certainly the characteristic decay process is not a gamma instability or an electro-positron instability. Of course, I do not have anything against pursuing this, but am only trying to explain why we have not ourselves done it. There is just one point: If one does not wish to question the materialization processes for nucleons, one may believe, as far as today’s evidence goes, that the production of the τ meson is always accompanied by the production of another particle of equal or greater mass. This does not seem too likely either; but I do not believe that there is any real evidence against it. I meant really only that we should keep open-minded about the materialization process and this might be one of the ways that we might learn about them in the not too remote future. As far as the non-linear theories, I profoundly agree with every word you write. The business of defining center of mass coordinates is a rather trivial, rather formal and quite sterile one, and in any case has been pretty well looked into both by Pryce and by Møller. Finkelstein says that there is more than one non-singular stationary solution, but whether there is an infinite number and how they are related, I do not know, and I doubt whether he does. It seems to me that the 230 231
Letter [466]. See letter [466], note 228.
April 7, 2009
12:11
158
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
essential questions, and this is being worried about a little locally, is to understand the relation between the classically coupled fields and the quantum theory; to understand this, that is, when one cannot use the principle of super-position and the theory of normal modes. I will promise to keep you informed if we get anywhere with this, and I would hope that you would let us know as things become clearer to you. One reason which may not be too good a one for my own interest in this problem is the following: One can integrate the Tomonaga equation formally as follows: ∞ mtµ ν Tν (x)η ηµ d4 x Ψ(−∞) Ψ(σ) = “eψp”i/l −∞
The essential point in all electrodynamic treatments so far is that in order to define the “exponential” one must approximate to it by a power series so that one can order the non-commuting factors properly; i.e., with the latest point to the left, etc. These difficulties of the order do not occur in a classical field theory; and if one should solve the classical problem, one would have a starting point for a perturbation theory based on the smallness of h and not of e. To date this is a program only; and I suspect that there are some deep reasons why it will not work, because a number of us have been trying without success. One piece of news which you need to know is how very very good Dyson is. He wants to return, and in fact must return, to England for the next years, but we have made a flexible arrangement with him to come back here for as many semesters as he can spare. I think he likes the arrangement and we are all delighted by it. He has gone a long way towards answering the questions about the finiteness and uniqueness of electrodynamics and has established strong presumption that in going to more complicated processes and higher order corrections nothing worse than the Lamb shift will turn up.232 The Lamb shift itself, after agonizing fluctuations, appears to be settling 232
F.J. Dyson, ‘The Electromagnetic Shift of Energy Levels’, Phys. Rev. 73, 617– 26 (1948); F.J. Dyson, ‘The Interactions of Nucleons with Meson Fields’, Phys. Rev. 73, 929–30 (1948).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
159
down to 1052 meg, a result which was not obtained by the highbrow Feynman-Schwinger-Tomonaga methods, but by much more pedestrian ones.233 There is still a real question as to the complete uniqueness of procedures; but as for the moment — things have been changing rapidly — it does not appear that this has contributed to the uncertainty of the result; and it does not appear that only rather arbitrary and odd methods of following the integrations, which have not, in fact, been used, can give a different answer. You are most kind about “Time”. I think it stank, and suffered very much for a couple of weeks until I could forget it. It would be very good to have a talk with you about many things in physics and some in politics and the atom. I hope that business will bring you to this country soon and that you will stay with us for a while. We both send you both our warmest, friendliest wishes for the New Year, Oppie
[468] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 16.1.1949 Dear Professor Peierls, I am sorry to be so slow in answering your very nice letter of November 30th.234 During this interval I have been trying to get my own mind firmly made up about what I want to do and I have now finally decided that Birmingham is the place, and I will take up your offer of a Research Fellowship. The salary will not be of crucial importance to me, to start with at any rate, and so I leave it to you to get what you can for me. More important will be the question of finding somewhere pleasant to 233
F.J. Dyson, ‘The Radiation Theories of Tomonaga, Schwinger and Feynman’, Phys. Rev. 75, 486–502 (1949). 234 Peierls had invited Freeman Dyson to join his department as a research fellow. Letter could not be located.
April 7, 2009
160
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
live, and I should be very grateful for any help or advice you can give about this; I shall be arriving in England about July 15th, and so I shall have two months to make arrangements before actually moving in. The “usual particulars” about me are: Age, 25 Degree, Cambridge B.A. (1st class) in mathematics, 1945 British subject by birth, Academic history; Research Fellow of Trinity College, 1946–49; Member of the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, 1948. If they want to know further details concerning the colour of my hair, membership of the Communist Party, etc. I will be glad to supply them. For your own information (this is a little confidential), Oppenheimer has very generously arranged for me a 5-year membership of the Institute, on the understanding that I make use of it for no more then 1 12 years between now and 1954. This means that I shall be able to come here at intervals and keep abreast with what the U.S. is doing, and it is an arrangement which would combine well with a Fellowship at Birmingham carrying no departmental responsibilities. Of course I should stay at Birmingham for the whole of the first year at least. I think it is extraordinarily thoughtful of Oppenheimer to have so anticipated my needs. I was interested in the remarks you made in your letter about physics (probably by now you have completely forgotten what you said). The problem of dealing with the hydrogen atom rigorously as a two-body system rather than as an electron in a given field has been thought about a great deal, and nobody has yet proposed a simple way of doing it; however I am convinced that it is not a fundamentally difficult matter or a gap in Schwinger’s theory. One can see quite well that the secondorder radiative corrections arise from the same kind of processes as in the Lamb-shift, only you have processes in which the proton takes part in addition to those involving the electron. The difficulty in carrying out a complete calculation seems to be due mainly to the fact that people have not yet found a decent method of treating the hydrogen atom as
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
161
a two-body problem, even without radiative corrections. This is said, with all due apologies to Breit.235 Concerning the more general questions of the validity of electrodynamics `a la Schwinger and Feynman, I hope soon to be able to send to you a long paper of mine in which these things are discussed. The paper is finished and is at the moment in the process of being mimeographed; with luck it will be published some time in the summer (the first paper appears in the Feb. 1 Physical Review).236 In the paper I have dealt with scattering problems exclusively, and shown that for them at least the theory always gives finite and sensible results. Also, we know now (Schwinger found it out) that there is no real discrepancy in the Lamb-shift calculations; everybody now agrees on 1052 as the right value, and the mistake in the old “highbrow” calculation was not a question of principle but was just a wrong neglect of terms at the lowenergy end. It seems to me now not at all likely that the bound-state problems will give worse troubles than the scattering problems, though of course the calculations will always be tougher. You will see from my paper that I do not believe in a program of making infinite self-energies finite. The reasons for this are too long to be talked about here. I agree with you in not taking seriously Feynman’s cut-off methods; he himself does not take them very seriously either. His big paper on electrodynamics will unfortunately not be appearing for some time. With many thanks for your letter, Freeman J. Dyson 235
Gregory Breit at Yale was working on related problems. In the late 1940s he published several important papers about the fine and hyperfine structure of hydrogen. G. Breit and G.E. Brown, ‘Effect of Nuclear Motion on the Fine Structure of Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev, 74, 1278–84 (1948); G. Breit and G.E. Brown, ‘The Effect of Nuclear Motion on the Hyperfine Structure of Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev, 76, 1299–1304 (1948). But Breit’s relativistic two-body interaction had limitations in that it could only be used as an expectation value. Gerry Brown, Breit’s collaborator at Yale, later tackled these limitation when he was working as a research assistant at Peierls’ institute at Birmingham. 236 F.J. Dyson, ‘The Radiation Theories of Tomonaga, Schwinger, and Feynman’, Phys. Rev. 75, 486–502 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
162
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[469] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson Birmingham, 21.1.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, I am very glad that you are coming here and I shall now set the machinery in motion to offer you an appointment. From what preliminary enquiries I have made I am now doubtful whether this will be at the top of the salary range I mentioned before, but from what you say you would not make that a condition. As I have vacancies now which I do not expect before the end of the session your appointment could run from any date you choose and if, for example, you would like to start immediately on arrival or, for example, on the 1st of September, will you let me know? It will make no difficulty if you want to visit Princeton from time to time, on the contrary, this will obviously increase your value to us. I would, of course, expect that the dates of such visits be discussed and that you would meet me if I was anxious to have you here at some specific time because I want to be away or for other reasons. Equally obviously, your salary would not continue during your absence, if during that period you are getting a full salary from another source (subject to anything special we might be able to arrange about travelling expenses). The information in your letter is quite adequate, luckily we have not reached the stage in this country where a university would consider it reasonable to ask questions about the political views of their staff. To avoid delaying this letter I shall not comment on your remarks about physics which were most interesting beyond saying that we are looking forward to seeing your paper237 from which we hope to learn a lot of things that we have not yet managed to understand. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
237
Letter [468], note 236.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
163
[470] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 25.1.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, I am writing again, this time about a number of assorted points, instead of sending you three of four letters in succession. The first point is that Dyson has now decided to come to Birmingham next session, which, of course, cheers me very much. It remains now to get the authorities here to fix his salary and I am trying to get for him a reasonably high salary which may be a little difficult in view of his age. Would you be good enough to write me a letter with a frank statement of your opinion of him; this should cover not merely his ability and promise but also his actual achievement to date, since the point at issue is the extent to which he can be regarded as of fairly senior standing. For example, it would help, if you could state what sort of job he could expect to have in an American university if he was an American, or if you were able to compare him to the general run of people holding senior jobs in this country (if this can be done without being rude). The next point is a question of physics. I don’t remember whether I have mentioned to you before some work which Swiatecki238 here has done recently trying to get to the bottom of the magic numbers, 20, 50 and 82, in nuclear structure. The occurrence of these numbers smells of the existence of “shells”, i.e. single particle states to some approximation, but there are two factors against this. (1.) that on a shell model you would have to explain why you get only the breaks at these numbers and none at the intermediate numbers which should correspond to closed shells. (2.) you cannot get a complete shell at 50 unless you omit the 2s level, whereas you cannot complete 20 unless you include it. Both these difficulties can be met in principle by observing that with increasing weight the shape of any potential well would have to change both on 238
Wladek J. Swiatecki (1918–), completed his Ph.D. under Peierls in 1949 working on nuclear structure. He later went to Copenhagen, Uppsala, and Berkeley where he spent the rest of his career.
April 7, 2009
12:11
164
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
account of the predominance of the surface effects for light nuclei and because of the increase in the Coulomb forces which tends to decrease the density near the centre as compared to the edge. In particular, the latter effect will make the sequence 2s, 3p · · · go up with increasing weight relative to 1s, 2p · · · It is, therefore, not impossible that when Y or N (= A − 2) is about 20 the 2s level should still be fairly low, whereas near Z or N = 50 it might have moved up above 3d. At the same time, this would explain why intermediate shells do not appear to be marked when two levels are just about passing each other one would not get any clear break. On this view one would be dealing with a situation analogous to the rare earths in atomic structure. The question whether the reduction in the density near the centre is big enough to do this depends on what one assumes for the compressibility of nuclear matter. There exists on this only a paper by Feenberg239 in which one of the two required parameters fixed from the observed mass defect curve, whereas the other is fixed from fishy theoretical treatment. We have been unable to rule out the possibility that the compressibility might be somewhat larger than is usually assumed and it might even be possible that heavy nuclei are almost hollow. We have thought of means of deciding this question approximately; in principle it might be done by observing nuclear radii, but this is very insensitive. One interesting possibility is to use the diffraction of electrons by nuclei using energies of 30MeV or more. Now the diffraction patterns to be observed have been calculated by Rose using the Born approximation and if one does this both for a solid and a hollow nucleus the difference is small but not altogether negligible. Now Born approximation is, of course, very poor, particularly for heavy nuclei and, while it can hardly be expected to give a long order of magnitude, it would be nice to have a better theory. I believe this is in principle contained in the work of Smith240 which you mentioned when you were here and the main object in telling you this long story (apart from getting your general comments) is to see whether Smith’s work, when complete, will cover the answer to this question, or 239
E. Feenberg, ‘Nuclear Shell Structure and Isomerism’, Phys. Rev. 75, 320–22 (1949). 240 Presumably Jack H. Smith at Cornell.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
165
if not whether his method can be used for the purpose. If you do not intend to have this done we would very much welcome a chance to see Smith’s work in advance so that we could adapt it for this purpose. My third problem arises from the planning of the 1950 volume of the Physical Society Progress Reports which you know, as you wrote an article for it in the past.241 We were wondering whether we could have an article on nuclear forces; would you be interested in writing this? The date of publication is not fixed yet, but probably the MS. would have to be received during the late summer for publication early next year. You will remember that these articles are not generously paid but serve a very useful purpose. Compared to the Review of Modern Physics they are rather less specialised and less high-brow. If you cannot do this, can you suggest someone else? Equally, of course, other suggestions about articles in the series would be welcome. Lastly, we understand that the Fulbright Scheme is coming into effect next session and that, as you probably know this will allow research students and more senior people to come and work here. We have been asked to say whether we would accept research students, which, of course, we would, if they are suitable, and what kind of more senior people we would like. This information was required at such short notice that it was impossible to find out who would be interested. I have mentioned a few names at random including Feynman and Placzek, though these are long shorts, but if you hear of anybody who might like to spend a year or so in Europe, will you let them know or get directly into touch with the Fulbright people. I have also mentioned to them that I would quite like to have someone who works on solids and/or metals to arouse some interest in this here, though of course he could not learn very much on this subject from us. Under this heading I have not mentioned any names at all, but would be grateful for suggestions. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
241
H.A. Bethe and R.E. Marshak, ‘The physics of stellar interiors and stellar evolution’, Reports on Progress in Physics 6, 1–15 (1939).
April 7, 2009
12:11
166
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[471] N. Kemmer to Rudolf Peierls Cambridge, 31.1.1949 Dear Peierls, There are two things I should like to consult you about. The first concerns the Schwinger, Tomonaga etc. stuff. I have 2 1/2 men here studying these things and now that Schwinger has published Pt 1242 there is hope that we shall eventually learn publicly all that has been done. In the meantime, however, we have played with the obvious generalisations to meson theory and though (using later work by Tomonaga) the general lines of a consistent extension to these cases are clear, we are still by no means clear about the details. I myself have unfortunately only very little time to devote to thinking about these things. So I wanted to ask you whether you have had any more recent news of progress on this front. We possess the things duplicated at Birmingham, and Vol. III 1& 2 of the Japanese Journal (Prog. Th. P.243 ) also of course the Pocorvo notes. I should be most grateful to learn of any other information. So far we cannot report any results, though the lads have done masses of exploratory paperwork. The second matter is of a different nature. Do you know Felix Adler244 who at various times was in Switzerland, Paris, Montreal and now Wisconsin? If you do, you will remember that he is an almost pathologically shy person, but has improved in recent years. At Wisconsin he has, I understand, been quite a success as a lecturer, but he doesn’t like life in the States and, partly under the influence of relatives, I believe, he wants to get over here. He realises that he doesn’t stand much of a chance to be offered an attractive post and that, although 242
Julian Schwinger, ‘Quantum Electrodynamics, I. A Covariant Formulation’, Phys. Rev. 74, 1439–61 (1948). 243 Progress in Theoretical Physics, monthly journal founded in 1946 by Hideki Yukawa and now published for the Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics and the Physical Society of Japan. 244 Felix T. Adler (1911–1979), theoretical nuclear physics who later moved to Illinois, where he was instrumental in establishing the university as a national centre for reactor science and engineering.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
167
there are quite a few poorly paid posts at small universities going one hardly would import a foreigner from Wisconsin for one of those. So his only chance would be to come here for a year or so on some grant and then look around. I was wondering what your attitude would be to having him around for a year, if possible with some financial assistance provided by some source you can tap. I think he is quite a good man when in the right atmosphere and his yield of scientific work has been small. Apart from early work under Wentzel, which wasn’t very independent there have been some things on neutron diffusion and now, I hear, on theoretical chemical lines. But he does know quite a lot. I am asking you about this mainly because Mrs Burkill to whom he is related, turned to me for advice. Don’t hesitate for a moment if you feel you must give a definite and not encouraging reply. I have just thought of another thing I wanted to mention, and that is that I expect to have a really good young man in search of a post by October so that I should be glad to hear from you if you know of anything going. Sorry to bother you. Best regards. Yours sincerely, N. Kemmer
[472] Rudolf Peierls to N. Kemmer [Birmingham], 2.2.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Kemmer, On the question of information about Schwinger theories, Schwinger has completed Part II of his paper which is being published in the Physical Review.245 He sent me a duplicated copy of this which is at 245
Julian Schwinger, ‘Quantum Electrodynamics, II. Vacuum Polarization and Self Energy’, Phys. Rev. 75, 651–79 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
168
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
present in enormous demand here. You might try to see whether he can spare you another copy of this. It is much more readable than the earlier Part II which you have. Another paper on the same subject has just been completed by Dyson in which the equivalence of Schwinger and Feynman’s method is proved and in which is also shown how to generalize the method beyond the second approximation.246 I have just received a duplicate copy of this and besides Dyson, Weisskopf has also had copies made. You might be able to get a copy from either (Dyson is now at Princeton). As regards the Japanese journal, I have had correspondence with the American Scientific Advisor in Tokyo and also directly with Tomonaga as a result of which we are just putting into effect an exchange scheme. The American Office has informed me that besides Tomonaga also Dr. Kobayasi is interested in such an exchange; I am not clear whether this is an alternative to the arrangement with Tomonaga or in addition. I expect to hear shortly from Kobayasi and I also expect to hear which British journal Tomonaga wants from us. Perhaps the best thing would be to wait until I have both these replies and I shall let you know. We are, of course, also studying the Schwinger papers intensely and perhaps in a little while it would be a good idea if one or two of the people in your team who are interested could come across for a day or so to compare notes. We would, of course, be delighted if you could join in this. I think, however, it would be best to wait another month or two when everybody will have digested things somewhat further and when we can get more out of such discussions. As regards Adler, it would, no doubt, be nice to have him around, but competition for the Research Fellowships I have available here is likely to be keen and my impression both from what I know and from what you say is that he would not be a very strong candidate. The only other type of grant I can think of is under the Fulbright Scheme which does make it possible to pay for American scientists to spend a year or so in this country. I do not know very much as yet how one goes about getting such a grant in practice and I would not commit myself at this 246
See letter [468], note 236.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
169
stage to asking Adler unless I knew whether this would spoil the chances of getting someone more senior. Meanwhile it may be possible for him or the head of his department to apply directly from the American end. Jobs at smaller universities are not always badly paid and finding a more attractive grant he could do worse than accepting a teaching or research job at a smaller university which will certainly pay a living salary, provided this is geographically within reach of bigger centres so that he can make contacts and get himself known. In this connection I heard recently that ter Haar also is interested in a job in this country.247 He is, of course, much more senior and he would give up a full professorship at Purdue to come here so that he would obviously not consider a very junior job. If you hear of any vacancy you might like to bear this in mind. As regards your other bright young man, could you tell me more about him, particularly whether he would be suitable for a D.S.I.R. Maintenance Award or a Senior Research Award or, of course, a University Research Fellowship. It is a bit early yet to consider the final staffing for next session, but I would like to consider him as a possibility. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[473] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 2.2.1949 Dear Rudy: I think the enclosed letter on Dyson is strong enough but the strange thing is that it is all true and sincere. He is really incredibly good. Concerning your calculations on nuclear structure, I just have on my desk 2 papers, one by Nordheim248 and the other by Feenberg,249 about 247
Dirk ter Haar eventually took up a post as Reader at Oxford University in 1956. L.W.Nordheim, ‘On Spins, Moments, and Shells in Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1894–1901 (1949). 249 Eug`ene Feenberg had published a paper on nuclear shell structure in early 1949 248
April 7, 2009
170
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the same subject. Feenberg especially uses a model similar to yours in which he takes into account that the nucleus may be something like a hollow shell. Having just returned to Cornell I have not had time yet to find out about the recent calculations of Jack Smith. I think he has calculated the effect of the distribution of protons on the nucleus and came to the conclusion that the effect is hardly observable if the distribution is that assumed by Feenberg in previous papers. However, if the nucleus were actually a hollow shell, this should be observable in electron diffraction. Nobody as yet has experimented on this but this will probably soon be done. The Berkeley synchrotron is going and ours is beginning to go, and electron diffraction is one of the points on our program. I will write more about this when I have checked with Smith. Concerning the Physical Society progress reports, I should like to think it over a little more. At the moment I would rather say no, because I still have a good deal of writing to do for the books of Segre250 and Schein251 on nuclear physics and cosmic rays respectively. I will ask Phil Morrison if he wants to do it; he would do it very well. Weisskopf may be another possibility. Concerning exchange students, I had a very good boy at Columbia by the name of Slotnick252 who would like to go to Europe next year. His first choice is Pauli, but he is also very much interested in coming to you. Possibly he will want to divide his time between Birmingham and Zurich. He will write you directly. I am writing to Eyges253 about possible jobs for next year for him. (see letter [470], note 239.) and had submitted another paper on nuclear shell structure to be published later in 1949. E. Feenberg and K.C. Hammack, ‘Nuclear Shell Structure’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1877–93 (1949). A few weeks after Bethe’s letter to Peierls, Feenberg, Hammack and Nordheim submitted a joint note on the same theme. E. Feenberg, K.C. Hammack and L.W. Nordheim, ‘Note on Proposed Schemes for Nuclear Shell Models’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1968–69 (1949). 250 Emilio Segr`e (ed.), Experimental Nuclear Physics, New York: Wiley, 1953. 251 D.J.X. Montgomery (ed.), Cosmic Ray Physics: based on lectures given by Marcel Schein at Princeton University, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1949. 252 Murray Slotnick, in fact went to Princeton in 1950, before moving to the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. 253 Leonard Eyles went to Berkeley, M.I.T. before joining the Air Force Cambridge Research Laboratory in Massachusetts.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
171
I had a rather fruitful semester at Columbia and will soon send you a paper on the effective range of nuclear forces.254 I am also sending you a copy of the first paper by Dyson which will soon appear in print.255 With best regards to you and the family, Yours sincerely, Hans
[474] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 14.2.1949 Lieber Herr Peierls! Ich habe mich soeben entschlossen, eine freundliche Einladung des “Faculty Board of Mathematics” in Cambridge anzunehmen und dort die sogenannte “Rouse Ball lecture” zu halten.256 Da der Term dort am 11. M¨ arz schließt, habe ich vorgeschlagen, die letzte Woche dieses Terms als Zeit der Vorlesung zu w¨ahlen. (Meine Korrespondenz l¨ auft mit dem Sekret¨ ar der Faculty Board Dr.A.J.Ward, Emmanuel College, Cambridge). Das Thema der Vorlesung ist “Physical and mathematical aspects of recent developments in quantum electrodynamics”. Vor etwa 2 Wochen habe ich einen langen Brief an Schwinger geschickt.257 Leider habe ich nur eine begrenzte Zahl von Kopien zur Verf¨ ugung, hatte aber Ma258 (zur Zeit in Dublin) gebeten, Ihnen eine Kopie zukommen zu lassen. Wenn Sie sie noch nicht erhalten haben, wird sie sicher bald zu Ihnen gelangen. 254 H.A. Bethe, ‘Theory of the Effective Range in Nuclear Scattering’, Phys. Rev., 76, 38–50 (1949). 255 See letter [468], note 236. 256 These were lectures about new developments in quantum field theory, which took place between 8 and 19 March 1949. 257 Letter W. Pauli to Julian Schwinger, 24.1.1949, Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, III, pp 609–19. 258 Shih-Tsun Ma, Chinese physicist who was working with Walter Heitler at the Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies.
April 7, 2009
12:11
172
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Es handelt sich mir darum, versteckte Annahmen, die in Schwingers “Beweisen” implizit enthalten sind, an’s Tageslicht zu bringen. Das gilt nicht nur f¨ ur die Fragen der Polarisation des Vakuums, sondern auch f¨ ur das interessantere Problem der Korrektur des magnetischen Momentes des Elektrons. Die in meinem Brief an Schwinger zum Schluß erw¨ahnte Rechnungen von Villars259 sind inzwischen im wesentlichen alfte von Schwingers “Part fertig geworden,260 auch haben wir die erste H¨ 261 ∗ uhrten Rechnungen u ¨ber das III” inzwischen erhalten. Die dort angef¨ magnetische Moment des Elektrons sind formal richtig, ich betrachte sie aber als definierende Regel, wie die betreffenden bedingt konvergenten Integrale auszuwerten seien und nicht als hypothesenfreie Beweise. Dies kann ich auf Grund von Villars Rechnungen n¨ aher begr¨ unden. Ich bin jetzt an einem Punkt angelangt, wo ich gerne mit anderen u ¨ber diese Fragen diskutieren m¨ ochte. Denn ich verstehe zwar die Mathematik, bin aber von der Physik darin nicht befriedigt. Die ,,Regulatoren” k¨ onnen dem Wesen der Sache nach nur eine provisorische Formulierung sein. Ist Herr Salpeter noch bei Ihnen? Was haben Sie sonst f¨ ur Leute in Ihrer Gruppe? Ich w¨ urde eigentlich gerne noch einige Tage l¨ anger in England bleiben und auch andere Orte als Cambridge sehen. Da ich an die Konferenzen in Birmingham so oft abgesagt habe, k¨ onnte ich diesmal kommen. Es liegt mir aber nichts an popul¨ aren Vorlesungen, sondern mehr an “technical talks” in Seminaren u ¨ber theoretische Physik. Ist Rosenfeld an solchen Fragen interessiert?262 ∗ Dagegen
habe ich von ihm noch keine Antwort auf meinen Brief. It seems that he thinks it over. 259 Felix Villars (1921–2002), studied physics and mathematics at the ETH where he completed his Ph.D. in 1946, before working as Pauli’s assistant between 1946–49. He became research associate and later lecturer and professor at the MIT where he stayed until his retirement. 260 W. Pauli and F. Villars, ‘On the invariant regularization in relativistic quantum theory’, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 434–44 (1949); F. Villars, ‘On the energy-momentum tensor of the electron’, Phys. Rev. 72, 122–28, (1950). 261 This refers to the draft of J. Schwinger, ‘Quantum Electrodynamics III. The electromagnetic properties of the electron-radiative corrections to scattering’, Phys. Rev. 76, 790–817 (1949). 262 Rosenfeld spent the academic year 1949/50 at Peierls’ institute in Birmingham.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
173
Vielleicht k¨ onnen Sie die Nachricht meines Kommens nach England auch sonst dort verbreiten und sich u ¨ber Daten mit Dr. Ward in Cambridge verst¨ andigen. (Vor dem 7. oder 8. M¨ arz kann ich nicht nach England kommen, habe aber Zeit hinterher.) Viele Gr¨ uße Ihr W. Pauli
[475] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli [Birmingham], 17.2.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli, Thank you for your letter. If after your visit to Cambridge you could manage to spend a week or so in Birmingham this would suit us both very well indeed. We would not expect you to give any lectures to a big audience but we would get most out of your visit if you could give us one talk (or more) in our Seminar and for the rest just discuss things informally. Besides myself, Salpeter is very interested in the Schwinger theory and has studied it extensively, also a Pole, Rzewuski,263 (a friend of Rayski) who is working now on the coupling between nucleons and the meson field a` la Schwinger. McManus is also very interested in field theory,264 though he has as yet spent less time with the Schwinger technique and there are three or four others who know enough about the problems to ask intelligent questions. The period from 11th–19th March is quite free as far as I know, except that we are arranging for Dirac to come over on the 17th to give a talk in our Seminar. However, it would add to the attraction to have both you and Dirac here at the same time and there is no reason why our Seminar should not meet several times during the same 263
Jan Rzewuski had come to Birmingham on a fellowship of the Polish government and returned to Gdansk where he continued to teach physics. 264 See letter [396], note 80.
April 7, 2009
12:11
174
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
week. Our term does not end until the 19th and I, therefore, shall have to give a few lectures but not enough to interfere seriously with our discussions. If your time is limited and you want to spend only a few days in Birmingham, I think it would be better if you came during the early part of the week, since Dirac’s talk will be about monopoles and presumably this is not what you want to discuss in the first place.265 We can take care of your fare from Cambridge and back to Cambridge or London and we can pay your hotel expenses while you are in Birmingham, but apart from this I am afraid we cannot offer you a fee for your lectures. I am writing to Ward in Cambridge so that he can keep us informed about the dates of your visit there. A copy of your letter to Schwinger has arrived here a few days ago from Heitler; we have not yet, of course, digested it completely, but I tend to agree with you that this represents a considerable advance in our understanding of the mathematical structure of the theory, but leaves it physically in an unsatisfactory state. One interesting question would be to see the relation between your method and Dyson’s treatment of the higher approximations.266 In particular, one would like to know whether in the treatment of higher order treatments each order has again to be treated by using appropriate “regulators” or whether the same trick will do for all orders. I suppose you have seen Dyson’s paper, if not we could probably lend you a copy. I think it would be very important to let Dyson see your note if that has not yet been done. As you know he is now at Princeton. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
265
Pauli had initially been very doubtful about magnetic monopoles (P.A.M. Dirac, ‘The theory of magnetic monopoles’, Phys. Rev. 74, 817–30 (1948)), but after discussing the idea in detail with Dirac at the Solvay Congress in 1948, he revised his views. See letter Wolfgang Pauli to Arnold Sommerfeld, 1.2.1949, Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, III, p. 624. 266 F.J. Dyson, ‘The radiation theories of Tomonaga, Schwinger and Feynman’, Phys. Rev. 75, 486–502 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
175
[476] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Zurich, 23.2.1949 Lieber Herr Peierls, ur Vielen Dank f¨ ur Ihren Brief vom 17.267 Zeit und Bedingungen f¨ meinen Besuch in Birmingham passen mir ausgezeichnet so wie Sie es vorschlagen. (Inzwischen habe ich von Kramers auch eine Einladung nach Holland erhalten. Ich soll ab 21. M¨ arz dort sein, werde also von Birmingham nach Leiden fahren.) Die Vorlesung in Cambridge ist am 10. M¨ arz, ich rechne also damit, etwa vom 14. bis 19. M¨ arz in Birmingham zu sein. Daß ich auf diese Weise einen Vortrag von Dirac u ¨ber die Monopole h¨ oren werde, ist mir auch ganz recht. Diese Theorie von Dirac hat eine gewisse Sch¨ onheit in sich und es ist m¨ oglich, daß die Monopole tats¨ achlich in der Natur existieren. Wenn man sie aber ernst nimmt, ¨ber sie wissen als was in Diracs Arbeit steht. m¨ ußte man viel mehr u 1) Was ist ihre Masse? 2) Wie beeinflußen sie die Kernkr¨afte? Diracs Theorie kann richtig sein, aber sie ist zu arm an Aussagen. Da alle Theorien u ¨ber die magnetischen Momente von Photon und Neutron falsche Resultate geben, k¨ onnte man wohl auf den Gedanken verfallen, die Neutronen als aus zwei Diracschen Monopolen zusammengesetzt zu denken. Ich m¨ochte gerne von Ihnen wissen, ob in Birmingham Kopien von Schwingers “Part II” und der ersten H¨ alfte von “Part III” available onnte ich n¨ amlich meine Exemplare Herrn Villars sind.268 (Wenn ja, k¨ hier lassen, der sie gut brauchen kann.) I have a copy of Dyson’s paper269 here and also a letter of his in which he announced a second paper, which, however, has not yet arrived. I also made an arrangement that a copy of my letter to Schwinger should 267
See letter [475]. J. Schwinger, ‘Quantum Electrodynamics II. Vacuum polarization and selfenergy’, Phys. Rev. 75, 651–79 (1949) and J. Schwinger, ‘Quantum Electrodynamics III. The electromagnetic properties of the electron-radiative corrections to scattering’, Phys. Rev. 76, 790–817 (1949). 269 See letter [475], note 266. 268
April 7, 2009
176
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
be sent to Princeton. Dyson seems to be a good man, his letter was in some respect enlightening for me. We shall talk more about it. Schwinger’s deep silence is continuing. Meanwhile my best regards. Yours sincerely, W. Pauli
[477] Rudolf Peierls to J.R. Oppenheimer Birmingham, 7.3.1949 Dear Oppie, I wrote to you before that we were looking a little more quantitatively into the lifetime of the τ -meson following the process discussed by Finkelstein. This has not been completed and as you predicted the result is quite independent of the type of particle and the type of interaction. What we had been looking for was not so much a selection rule which, as you say, would not alter things as it would be broken in the next approximation, but rather a factor depending in a different way on the various dimensionless mass rations which occur. I enclose a copy of a paper on this subject which is still in the draft stage and may still need some editing. Since the whole problem goes back to a suggestion you made here, I would be glad to know if you had any objections to being quoted on this and also whether you have, in the meantime, made this point in any other publication to which reference should be made. Yours sincerely, R.E.P I am just getting Dyson’s appointment here confirmed. There will of course be no difficulty in the way of his coming to Princeton whenever it suits him and you and I am very glad of this further link with the Institute.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
177
[478] Robert Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls [Princeton], 16.3.1949 Dear Rudi, Thank you for your good letter and for sending Van Wyk’s paper,270 which I was glad to get, and with the results of which I have no quarrel. There is not yet in published form a discussion of this question on my part, but in the records of the Solvay Congress, there is to be, I think, a brief summary of my views on the alternatives, in which the connection of this difficulty with the materialisation process is raised, and the possibility of other coupling schemes briefly indicated. I do not know whether it is worth referring to this document, which is not yet out and which may never be widely available. In the meantime, our thoughts have not matured much. Powell’s wonderful picture, of course, raises the possibility of τ → 3ω, where the lifetime, barring some mystical selection rule, should be even shorter than for gamma rays. If one assumes that τ → 2ω+µ is made impossible by the conservation laws, then it appears that the lifetime of τ → ω + 2µ may well be of the [r]ight order of magnitude to fit observation. This point is in fact being explored by Sheila Power.271 We will let you know when and if we have anything that looks as though it had any connection with the real world. We sent you Dyson’s second paper272 and also, I believe, some long works of Case273 on the nucleon-meson problem. It is turning out to be a very tough thing to digest these developments of the last two years and maintain any sort of perspective, the more so because at the moment one can neither get any sensible results with the mesons, nor devise 270
Presumably C.B. van Wyk, ‘On the Decay of the τ -Mesons’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A62, 697–709 (1949). 271 S. Power, ‘Decay of a Heavy tau-Meson into Three Lighter Mesons’, Phys. Rev. 76, 865–66 (1949). 272 F.J. Dyson, ‘The Interaction of Nucleons with Meson Fields’, Phys. Rev. 73, 929–30 (1948). 273 K.M. Case, ‘On Nucleon Moments and the Neutron-Electron Interaction’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1–13 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
178
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
methods sufficiently powerful to justify expecting them. It would be good to have a chance to talk again, and I hope that one or another pretext will bring us together in one or another country before very long. I have high hopes that on the matter of our more effective collaboration the situation will begin to clear long. Kitty joins me in sending the warmest greetings to you and Genia. We think of you often with great gratitude for the wonderful time in Birmingham. Robert Oppenheimer
[479] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 31.3.1949 Dear Professor Peierls, Thank you very much for your last letter.274 The salary you are mentioning is really astonishingly generous, as also is your anxiety not to tie me down to Birmingham. I enclose herewith the particulars you wanted for the Royal Society; I am very much obliged to you for undertaking yourself to handle the details of applying for the Royal Society grant. The Institute has not made me a specific travelling allowance for my expenses on future visits here, but the funds it provides are so ample as to cover all such expenses very comfortably. So you need not bother about that. I will now briefly reply to the physical half of your letter. Incidentally, I have spent the last month, and shall spend the next, travelling around from place to place and giving talks and consuming excessive quantities of food and liquor. While this sort of life is good for acquiring general knowledge about what is going on in physics, it is certainly not conducive to serious thinking. For this reason my thoughts have not progressed substantially beyond the stage at which they were when 274
Letter could not be located.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
179
I wrote the S-matrix paper.275 I believe I am not likely to be smitten with any new ideas until I have taken a long and complete holiday, which will not be until the midsummer at the earliest. I am glad you have had a talk with Pauli, who seems to be the one member of the “old gang” who takes the trouble to thoroughly understand the new methods. We are all very pleased with his regulators;276 especially the programme of using regulators harmonizes very well with the programme of systematic segregation of renormalisations outlined in my S-matrix paper. The regulators just make it clearer why the rules of procedure I have proposed are sensible, and vice versa. To demonstrate the equivalence of my rules with Pauli’s it is only necessary to show that all the convergent operators, which appear in my method as the physically real effects after separation from the renormalisation, actually tend to zero with increasing electron rest-mass. That this is so seems to follow just from dimensional arguments; since the real effects always begin by being proportional to the particle momenta to some positive power, they must also have some positive power of the electron mass in the denominator. However, I have not yet tried to make a rigorous argument out of this. You will see, if you read the last section of the S-matrix paper, where the physical meaning of the theory is discussed, that I differ very much from your view of these matters. Of course, one is here arguing about things which are matters more of taste than of judgement, and either or both of us may turn out to be completely wrong. However, I will here summarise my point of view for your consideration. I regard the method of regulators as a method of making predictions of electrodynamics mathematically precise. As such it introduces into the theory a few additional physical hypotheses which were left vague in the old electrodynamics but these new hypotheses do not assert any physical significance for the method of regulators itself. In other words, 275 F.J. Dyson, ‘The S-Matrix in Quantum Electrodynamics’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1736– 55 (1949). The paper was published in June 1949 but had been submitted in February 1949. 276 See W. Pauli and F.Villars, ‘On the Invariant Regularization on Relativistic Quantum Mechanics’, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 434–44 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
180
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the physics of the method is to be found in the formulae which are obtained after going to the limit and letting all additional masses tend to infinity, and not at any earlier stage. The hope which is expressed in the last section of the S-matrix paper and which I believe is a promising hope, is that electrodynamics can now be put into a consistent and divergence-free shape by a purely mathematical reformulation, without any additions to its physical content. The method of regulators is a rather modest step in this direction. I certainly envisage the necessity later on of making alterations in electrodynamics of a more fundamental and physical kind. But I think the nature of such alterations cannot be guessed at, for example, by proposing to take seriously the formulae which arise in the method of regulators before passing to the limit of infinite auxiliary masses, you are making such a guess. I am less ambitious and confine myself to squeezing all I can out of the existing theory. Again with many thanks, Freeman Dyson
[480] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer [Birmingham], 13.4.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Oppie, Things have changed a little as regards the calculation of van Wyk,277 about which I wrote to you before. We had not noticed before that the list of cases he had covered in his paper did not contain the case in which both mesons have zero spin. In this case the emission of one photon is forbidden by conservation of angular momentum. The next process one would think of is then the emission of a positron-electron pair which might give an intensity only 137 times smaller. We have not studied this process but this is also forbidden if the two mesons have opposite parity, i.e. if one is scalar and the other pseudoscalar. In that 277
See letter [478], note 270.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
181
case the most likely allowed process is the emission of two photons. This has now also been calculated by von Wyk taking only the “g” coupling terms, i.e. coupling terms without derivatives. The result is: [. . . ]278 which would not seem to contradict any known evidence. I suspect that taking f type coupling instead, the result would only differ by a small numerical factor, but this must be confirmed. Admittedly this is a somewhat artificial explanation because it would give a [. . . ]279 -meson the same status as an isomeric nucleus, but it might exist in nature for some reason that isomeric nuclei are found. It might well be true that in principle mesons are possible with all sorts of different masses and spins and that they all have very short lifetimes and are, therefore, never seen except the [. . . ]280 which is metastable and therefore just visible. Until we have evidence about the spin and parity of these mesons we should therefore bear in mind this rather simple possibility which does not require a drastic breakdown of current theory. Von Wyk’s paper has not been sent off for publication as yet, and he has amended his calculations accordingly. I would be interested in your reaction to this development. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[481] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson [Birmingham], 22.4.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, Thank you very much for your letter.281 In the meantime I had a chance to digest your second paper282 a little more and I think I now 278
Missing in carbon copy. Missing in carbon copy. 280 Missing in carbon copy. 281 Letter [479]. 282 Ibid., note 275. 279
April 7, 2009
182
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
understand its ideas, though, of course, I have not yet mastered every detail of technique. I think, as Bohr would say, “we agree much more than we think”. You have shown in your paper that as long as the expansion in powers of the coupling constant is justified, one can find the prescription which will make the coefficient of any power unambiguous and finite. The new point which I had not appreciated when I last wrote was that only two or three divergent intervals recur and that everything is unique once one has made up one’s mind what value to attribute to them. Up to this point, of course, there can be no possible controversy. However, the penalty for using an arbitrary prescription imposed after constructing the fundamental equations is that the procedure is not convincing as regards consistency with a different approach. If one could calculate the whole thing from a theory which would give only finite answers either by introducing a fundamental length or by using auxiliary masses of the Pauli type, one would at each stage get a definite answer and could then go to the limit of the point charge or of infinite auxiliary masses. I have little doubt that by proceeding in this limit your prescription for identifying and discarding self-energy terms would justify itself and that the questionable divergent integrals would in all orders take the values that you require. However, what is doubtful is the part played by the series expansion in this procedure. One may, I think, learn a little from the analogy with the classical case. The nonsense one gets in the Dirac equation with runaway solutions is directly due to the fact that this theory assumes the infinite positive self-energy to be offset by an infinite negative mechanical rest mass. At high acceleration the field lags behind and hence the negative mechanical energy provides an unlimited store for further acceleration. If the use of a cut-off in the Weisskopf theory of the self energy is any guide, it is likely that in a finite theory the self-energy will again be positive, though, of course, only varying as a logarithm of the cut-off energy. If you then proceed to the limit of zero radius you will reach a point at which the mechanical mass changes sign. Now in the classical theory the mischief brough[t] by this is not apparent if you only look at solutions which are power series in the electric charge and trouble arises from the appearance of new solutions which cannot be so expanded. In the quantum theory it
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
183
is likely that the corresponding trouble, if it arises will take the form that no solution corresponds to a convergent series. Whether or not this difficulty arises in your cases is not easy to say and there are two separate questions: (a) whether the series obtained with your existing method converges. This would seem rather likely. (b) the other question is whether a theory in which a self-energy is made finite would converge for all values of the self-energy so that one could go to the limits. If (a) is all right but (b) is not, in other words if the elimination of the self energy and the limit of zero radius are not interchangeable, one could begin to have doubts whether your theory would be logically consistent with a treatment of the case where one deals with the case of discrete levels. It is perhaps not quite fair to attack you on this point because you admit yourself that you have not covered the case of stationary states, but my point is that if one can succeed in rendering your prescription as plausible from a physical point of view, one would gain increased confidence that it must hang together with a reasonable treatment of stationary states. If it is regarded merely as a mathematical procedure justified by its consistency and by its results, one is, of course, left with the job of proving the consistency fully for all conceivable combination of cases. I was also rather interested in your discussion of observability and I very much like the tendency to say that because one cannot detach particles from their fields, the range of possible observations is rather more limited. This fits on to what Landau and I tried to do many years ago283 but did not do right. However, I think this must be studied very much more deeply because from the way you put it one does not get a clear distribution what the limits of observation are and what physical factors in them are responsible for the limitation. You will have an amusing controversy on your hands as soon as Bohr reads that section of your paper because Bohr is very sensitive to anything being said on this subject that he does not fully approve. The controversy, however, will be both entertaining and instructive. 283
R.E. Peierls and L. Landau, ‘Erweiterung des Unbestimmtheitsprinzips f¨ ur die relativistische Quantentheorie’, Z. Phys. 69, 56–69 (1930).
April 7, 2009
184
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I always feel that there is something inconsistent in the whole present approach because we take as a starting point the wave equation, i.e. the relation between energy momentum and spin, for free particles which is about the only thing we must be sure of. However, when one proceeds with the theory it turns out that the wave equations we have written are not really the equations for real particles, but they are the equations for ficticious particles uncoupled from the surrounding field about which we ought not to postulate anything. One could, of course, start differently by postulating in the first place that the wave equations for one real electron or one real photon should be simple and in that way would make the variables used by Schwinger after the first transformation the real basis of the theory. However, in these variables the equations, of course, are not linear but contain coupling terms of any arbitrary order giving direct matrix elements for processes in which an arbitrary number of particles are created, provided you have at least two to start with. Obviously it is hopeless to expect that each of these treatments of arbitrary order should be derived from the new physical principles, but it might be possible that there exists some common functional form for all these terms taken together which could be justified by reference to general principles. If this could be done one would have a basic formulation in which the “bare” particle never enters and in which accordingly the question of self-energy never arises. This would, I think, be very close to the spirit of your treatment but would differ from it by the fact that the self-energy is not ever written down and then eliminated. But whether such a treatment is possible I have no idea. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
185
[482] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli [Birmingham], 10.6.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli, Following our discussions here284 we have thought more about some of the problems arising from regularization and some more quantitative work has been done by Rzewuski. I think you might be interested to know the position we have reached at present, particularly since Rzewuski is going back to Poland now and for some time our own further progress here will not be rapid. The first things that Rzewuski tried was to see whether in place of using particles of integer spin one could obtain your regularization also if the auxiliary particles were Fermi particles of higher spin. It seems somehow more satisfactory to couple electrons with other Fermi particles, though, of course, in regularizing such things as the electron self-energy one has to use “auxiliary photons” and one would like those to be Bose particles. Rzewuski has limited himself to auxiliary electrons of three-halves and he has looked at the problem of vacuum polarisation.285 In this case, it turns out, however, that the terms which give the same singularity as that for spin one-half, also have the same sign and therefore cancellation is impossible. Moreover, one obtains singularities of higher order because of the occurrence of higher derivatives in the commutation laws and these cannot be cancelled unless perhaps one introduces particles of still higher spin, but at this point we give up. The situation, however, is still worse in which it is a condition on the Schwinger formalism that the local interaction Hamiltonian should 284
Wolfgang Pauli had visited Birmingham in March 1949. See letters Peierls to Pauli, 17.2.1949, Pauli to Peierls, 23.2.1949 in Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, III, pp. 631–2 and 638–39. 285 J. Rzewuski, ‘Some cut-off methods for the electron self-energy’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A62, 386–91 (1949). He later took up this work in a joint paper with Rayski. J. Rayski and J. Rzewuski, ‘On a system of fields free of divergences of the mass renormalization type’, Acta Physica Polonica 10, 159–72 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
186
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
have the property that its value at two points on the same space-like surface should commute. Schwinger discusses this condition for his case and he claims that it is all right, but as far as we can see the proof involves the same kind of doubtful treatment of products of singular functions which you have criticised. This difficulty does not arise in Schwinger’s case, if the electro-magnetic potentials are not quantized. In the case of spin three-halves this further goes wrong, already for a given external field and therefore one cannot really draw any conclusion at all, but this difficulty in itself seems to me to offer a ray of hope. It has been shown by Tomonaga that a similar difficulty arises in the case of meson fields or in other cases where the interaction Hamiltonian contains derivatives of the field variables and Tomonaga has succeeded in adding a term to the interaction which restores the Lorentz invariance as well as the commutability. One might try to do the same for the general Schwinger case and the extra terms would then have to be as ambiguous as the term Schwinger uses, but in such a way that the total expression becomes unambiguous and therefore for its evaluation one can use any reasonable representation of the D-function. We have not yet seen, however, how to start looking for the right kind of term. In case of spin one-half one can write the commutator between different local Hamiltonians including field quantization and if one takes only the vacuum expectation value, which certainly ought to vanish, it actually becomes somewhat identical with your K[· · · ]286 , but with the function [· · · ]287 x − x replaced by D[· · · ]288 (x − x ). One other point that we notice and which shows how sloppy the Schwinger mathematics can be arises from the zero-point energy. In equation 1.46 of Schwinger’s second paper289 he claims, for example, that the vacuum expectation value of the energy density of the electromagnetic field is zero. This, however, is also equal to the expectation value of E 2 + H 2 and it is rather a tall order to be asked to believe that this can be zero. Of course, the zero-point energy can always be 286
Missing in carbon copy. Missing in carbon copy. 288 Missing in carbon copy. 289 Letter [476], note 268. 287
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
187
subtracted in an invariant way and will not give trouble, but to claim that a calculation of this quantity can give zero shows how dangerous the Schwinger methods are. This makes us feel that a decent solution of the difficulties which you have pointed out in connection with vacuum polarization is really essential even at the very beginning and even the basic equations of the theory hang in the air until this problem has been faced. I would be very interested in your reactions to these various points. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [483] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 10.7.1949 Lieber Herr Peierls! Ich beantworte erst heute Ihren Brief vom 10. Juni,290 da ich hierzu noch einige Resultate abwarten wollte. Zu den von Ihnen aufgeworfenen Fragen wollte ich folgendes sagen: 1. Ich weiß jetzt, daß alle Zweideutigkeiten betreffend Kommutatoren von physikalischen Gr¨oßen (Viererstrom, Dichte der Wechselwirkungsenergie) in Punkten mit raumartiger Verbindungslinie fortfallen in einer Mixtur aus “wirklichen” geladenen Elektronen und geladenen Spin 0-Bosonen, wenn die Bedingunen erf¨ ullt sind 2 Ci Mi = 0 Ci = 0, (Dies ist demnach gen¨ ugend f¨ ur Eichinvarianz der Resultate.) mit ur alle Spin 1/2-, Ci = −1/2 f¨ ur den speziellen Werten Ci = 1 f¨ ∗ alle Spin 0-Teilchen. ∗ Dieses
Resultat stammt (f¨ ur die erste N¨ aherung in e2 /c unabh¨ angig von Rayski und Jost [Jost und Rayski (1949)], von Uhlenbeck und Pais [Pais und Uhlenbeck (1949)] und von Umezawam Yukawa und Yamada [(1948)](nach brieflicher Mitteilung von Tomonaga). 290
Letter [482].
April 7, 2009
12:11
188
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Dieser “realistische” Standpunkt d¨ urfte auch gen¨ ugend sein, um die Nullpunktsenergie zu kompensieren, da diese ja negativ ist f¨ ur Elektron-Positronpaare.∗∗ (Man soll Kompensation der Nullpunktsenergie-dichte in allen Raum-Zeitpunkten verlangen. ∂ 2 ∆(1) Es handelt sich um Ausdr¨ ucke der Form i Ci ( ∂xµ ∂xν )x<0 mit verschiedenen Massen.) Ich weiß allerdings nicht auswendig, ob auch hier die Zahlenwerte Ci = 1 f¨ ur Spin 1/2, Ci = −1/2 f¨ ur Spin 0 die richtigen sind, aber ich vermute das. Dieser “realistische” Standpunkt versagt f¨ ur die 2. Aber: Selbstladung. Diese (logarithmisch unendliche) Konstante hat dasselbe Vorzeichen f¨ ur Spin 1/2 und Spin 0-Teilchen (aus physikalischen Gr¨ unden vermute ich dasselbe f¨ ur alle Teilchen) und eine Kompensation ist unm¨ oglich. Dieser Sachverhalt macht mir die gr¨ oßte Sorge (siehe jedoch unten sub 5). (Jost nennt die Selbstladung den ‘top-nonsense’ der jetzigen Theorie.) 3. Was Teilchen mit h¨ oherem Spin betrifft, so habe ich bisher immer vermutet, daß f¨ ur geladene Teilchen mit h¨ oherem Spin im a¨ußeren (nicht quantisierten) elektromagnetischen Feld die Komponenten des Viererstromes in Punkten mit raum-artiger Verbindungslinie wirklich nicht kommutieren werden (und nicht nur zweideutig sind). (Wissen Sie etwas bestimmtes dar¨ uber?) Ich war deshalb geneigt, geladene Teilchen mit Spin > 1 auszuschließen (seit etwa 1940). Einer meiner Sch¨ uler hat mich darauf aufmerksam gemacht, daß dieser Schluß nicht zwingend sei, da eine Mischung geladener Teilchen mit h¨ oheren ganz- und halbzahligen Spins existieren k¨ onnte, f¨ ur welche der Vakuums-Erwartungswert des Kommutators der Totalstromkomponenten in Punkten mit raumartiger Verbindungslinie wirklich Null ist. Vielleicht werden wir das hier noch weiter untersuchen. ∗∗ Das
ist eine alte Idee von Pais und Bohr (1946).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
189
4. Ein Schwede in Lund namens K¨ all´en, der jetzt in Z¨ urich ist, hat das von Ihnen bei meinem Besuch in Birmingham angeregte Problem der h¨ oheren N¨ aherungen (d.h. nicht linear im ¨außeren Feld) der Vakuumpolarisation mit großem Erfolg behandelt. (Dabei wurde zun¨ achst das elektromagnetische Feld nicht quantisiert.) F¨ ur Elektronen kam dabei heraus, daß die Divergenzen in den sukzessiven N¨aherungen imachsth¨ oheren N¨ aherung ist mer schw¨acher werden. In der n¨ dann nur noch eine (die Eichinvarianzst¨ orende) logarithmische Divergenz vorhanden, die mit Ci = 0 formal weggeht und alle folgenden N¨ aherungen (von e6 angefangen) konvergieren von selbst. Nun rechnet K¨all´en dasselbe auch noch f¨ ur Bosonen (Spin 0). Ich vermute, daß die oben beschriebene Mixtur — bis auf die unendliche Selbstladung! — in allen N¨ aherungen konvergiert.291 5. Dabei blieb, wie gesagt, das elektromagnetische Feld unquantisiert. Das andere Problem, wo man sich umgekehrt auf ur aber die die im a¨ußeren Feld lineare N¨aherung beschr¨ankt, daf¨ von der Quantisierung des elektromagnetischen Strahlungsfeldes herr¨ uhrenden Korrekturen in h¨ oherer N¨ aherung berechnet, wird hier von den beiden Polen Rayski und Weyssenhof behandelt.292 (Rayski ist eben nach Hause gefahren, aber Weyssenhof — der bessere Physiker von den beiden, der auch sehr eifrig ist — bleibt noch bis Herbst hier.) Bei diesem Problem gibt es nat¨ urlich etliche Korrekturen zur Selbstladung. Ich bin sehr neugierig, welches Vorzeichen diese Korrekturen in n¨ achst h¨ oherer N¨aherung haben werden und hoffe, daß es negativ sein wird. Es schwebt mir n¨ amlich — als letzter Ausweg beim Selbstladungsproblem — etwas vage eine Art Bestimmung von e2 /c aus der Bedingung des Verschwindens der Selbstladung vor. Nat¨aurlich ist es dann sehr unsch¨ on, daß man nach Potenzen 291
G. K¨ all´en, ‘Higher approximations in the external field for the problem of vacuum polarization’, Helv. Phys. Acta 22, 637–654 (1949). 292 See J. Rayski, ‘Polarization of the vacuum’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1961 (1949).
April 7, 2009
190
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
von e2 /c entwickelt, {Das denke ich mir aber nur als Ersatz f¨ ur 2 die Behandlung einer strengen Gleichung f (e /c, m1 , m2 , · · · ) = 0 wobei man eben f (.) nach der Variablen e2 /c entwickelt.} Zun¨ achst muß man nat¨ urlich sehen, ob auch die Terme n¨ achster ur die Selbstladung bei Elektronen und bei N¨aherung in e2 /c f¨ geladenen Bosonen kompatibel sein sollen. (Nat¨ urlich werden auch die zur Kompensation bei der Selbstenergie der geladenen Teilchen ben¨ otigten neutralen skalaren Hilfsfelder mit m = 0 in dieser N¨aherung Beitr¨ age zur Selbstladung geben.) Es w¨ urde mich interessieren, nun Ihre Kritik zu meinem momentanen Standpunkt zu h¨ oren. Es ist merkw¨ urdig, daß ich aus Ihrer Kritik immer sehr viel mehr lernen kann als aus Ihren eigenen Arbeiten (oder Arbeiten Ihrer Sch¨ uler). Meine allgemeine Idee ist die, daß die in beliebig kleinen Raum-Zeitgebieten definierbaren physikalischen Gr¨ oßen (TotalEnergie-Impulsdichte, Total-Vierer-Strom) keine Spezifizierung der Massen und Spins der beteiligten Teilchen erlauben d¨ urfen (siehe oben sub 1 des u ¨ber die Nullpunktsenergie Gesagte). Mit vielen Gr¨ ußen and Sie selbst und Ihre Familie (how is the baby?) Stets Ihr W. Pauli P.S. 1) Der Inder Vachaspati muß sich erst an die europ¨ aische Umgebung gew¨ohnen und hat vorl¨ aufig noch nichts geleistet. Er soll, finde ich, vorl¨ aufig ruhig hier bleiben und so weit deutsch lernen, daß er Vorlesungen h¨ oren kann, statt schon wieder den Ort zu wechseln. Sollte er bis Herbst noch immer nichts verstanden haben, so m¨ ußte man ihn dann heimschicken, aber ich habe die Hoffnung f¨ ur ihn noch nicht aufgegeben. 2) Ein Sch¨ uler von Schwinger hat mir einen langen, aber keineswegs inhaltsreichen Brief betreffend meiner Kontroverse mit seinem verehrten Lehrer geschrieben. Die Diplomatie dabei besteht darin, daß Schwinger ihm zwar gestattet hat, mir zu schreiben, sich aber geweigert hat, den
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
191
Brief seines Sch¨ ulers selbst zu lesen!— Inhaltlich konnte ich nichts anderes aus der langen Rede entnehmen als daß Schwinger eine Art Offenbarung (auf irgendeinem Berg Sinai) gehabt hat: Und der Herr sprach: (1) ur x − 0, tue aber nicht so f¨ ur ∂x∂ ν ∂ (4) (x) ,,Setze immer ∂∆ ∂xν = 0 f¨ trotz gleicher Symmetrieeigenschaften.”— Was Schwinger bei der Nullpunktsenergie macht (im Gegensatz zu meinem Kompensationsversuch) ist nat¨ urlich ganz a¨hnlich. [484] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 27.7.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, It looks almost as if I have not written to you since your letter of 7th February.293 Meanwhile your letter about Dyson has done just what I wanted it to do, namely not merely persuaded the university to offer him a good job, but also got the Royal Society to appoint him to a Warren Fellowship which has advantages. He has been here already for two days and it will make all the difference to the department to have him here next year. I assume that you have not done any more about the Physical Society Progress Reports and that is just as well, because with all the experiments going on now it is likely that a report written now would be obsolete before it appeared (the volume now in preparation will not come out before July 1950). Things may have settled down a little more in a year’s time. The closing date for manuscripts for the following volume is going to be about September 1950 and it is much too early to talk about an article for that volume. However, I need hardly say that if you actually have started to write an article and if you are prepared to let us have it by September, everybody will be delighted to see it go in to the forthcoming volume. 293
Letter Hans Bethe Ms.Eng.misc.b.202, C16.
to
Rudolf
Peierls,
7.2.1949,
Peierls
Papers,
April 7, 2009
12:11
192
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
On the question of nuclear structure it seems indeed that Feenberg and Swiatecki here have been thinking along very similar lines, but for some time, Swiatecki has been working on a decent derivation of the surface tensions of a nucleus which is essential for the question under discussion and he had discovered that nothing said on this subject in the literature is any good. He has now developed a generalization of the Thomas-Fermi method which is suitable to treat potential gradients and, while the numerical work is not complete as yet, he seems to be able to derive a fairly good value for the surface term in the semiempirical formula and one can then have some confidence in applying the methods to internal density gradients. I have not heard anything from Slotnick,294 but I had some correspondence with Gerald Brown of Yale 295 who makes a very good impression and who is coming here probably with a Fulbright Grant. He was coming in October, but he has to finish some job for Breit and will not be free before January. The last session has not been very productive, largely, though not entirely, because we were always trying to catch up with the work on field theory by Schwinger, Feynman and Dyson etc. We are now preparing for a determined attack on discussing meson theory by the new techniques without the use of perturbation theory; most of what has been said in the literature seems just to be perturbation theory run riot. Dyson told us the sad story of your car; I hope it is making a good recovery and that in spite of it you are by now all reunited. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
294
Murray Slotnick, at the time at Columbia University then moved on to Princeton postdoctoral fellow. 295 Gerry Brown had worked with Gregory Breit at Yale. He joined the Birmingham group in 1950.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
193
[485] Niels Bohr to Rudolf Peierls Copenhagen, 22.8.1949 Dear Peierls, It has been a pleasure to me that it has now been arranged that Lindhard296 will be with you next year. I am sure that it will be a great experience to him and I also hope that it will mean a still closer cooperation between our groups. As a small beginning I reckon that Lindhard’s stay with you will be helpful in completing our old work with Placzek. In the last weeks I have gone through the old manuscripts with Lindhard and discussed with him the latest progress as regards nuclear constitution and in particular the success of the method of considering the binding energy of the nucleons separately in the nuclear field. I realize that one sometimes has taken the drop model too literally, and to clear my thoughts, I have written down a few tentative comments297 of which I shall be very glad to hear your opinion. They do not contain much new, but I feel that the development gives a simple basis for the treatment of the problems of nuclear reactions and removes doubts as regards the conclusions to be drawn from dispersion theory and detailed balancing. As soon as I get time, I will try to incorporate such views in our old manuscript and will, if not before, give it to Lindhard when he leaves. This summer I have been busy with the preparation of a series of lectures on general topics, which I shall deliver at Edinburgh in the autumn 298 and have also worked with Rosenfeld on the completion of our work on the measurability of field and charge quantities.299 It has come out that the situation is just as required by Schwinger’s formalism, and that it is simpler than assumed by Heisenberg in that respect that charge fluctuations are well defined in sharply limited space-time 296
Jens Lindhard (1922–), student of Niels Bohr’s, later professor of theoretical physics University of Aarhus. 297 Manuscript ‘Tentative Comments on Atomic and Nuclear Constitution’, (1949), reproduced in Bohr. Collected Works, Vol. 9, pp. 523–55. 298 See letters [486], [490]. 299 N. Bohr and L. Rosenfeld, ‘Field and Charge Measurements in Quantum Electrodynamics’, Phys. Rev. 78, 794–98, (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
194
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
extensions, just like field fluctuations. Also, this work I hope to complete in the autumn months. As you may understand it will be quite a busy time for me and, if it is not too inconvenient to you, I should be glad if Lindhard could stay here and leave for Edinburgh in the middle of October or in any case till the end of September. With kindest regards and best wishes to your family and yourself from us all, Uncle Nick
[486] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr Birmingham, 26.8.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, Thanks you for your letter.300 It will be all right for Lindhard to come here in the middle of October. I gather from Born that your lectures in Edinburgh will have longish intervals between them and this makes me wonder whether there might be a chance of you spending a little while in Birmingham while you are in this country. It would, of course, give us the greatest pleasure, if that were possible and we would be able to look after your expenses arising from such a visit. However, you need not decide this now.301 I have read your note with great interest,302 but I am afraid I do not agree with some of the points. If I understand correctly the argument on the second page, you deduce from the large indeterminacy of position that it is possible to describe the motion of each particle as if it were moving in a smooth field of force. I do not believe that this conclusion is correct. At least if one assumes the forces between the nucleons to be of the type usually assumed (i.e. two-body forces, partly of exchange character, and compatible with the properties of light nuclei) 300
Letter [485]. Bohr did go to Birmingham and Peierls also met him in Edinburgh during the summer. See letter [490]. 302 See letter [485], note 299. 301
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
195
then the attempt to find the best potential to represent the motion has been carried out by Euler303 for a nuclear force obeying a Gaussian law and by Huby304 for the “meson potential”. Both have calculated the higher approximations which take into account the correlations between individual nucleons and find that these higher terms are by no means small and severely alter the magnitude of the total binding energy. This tends to prove that, while the potential energy of the particle does not depend much on its position relative to the centre of the whole nucleus, it does depend decisively on the position relative to the neighbouring nucleons. It is in the nature of exchange forces that this kind of correlation becomes particularly strong since each nucleon tends to be coupled strongly with only three others. Now in the last few months we have seen evidence that properties of nuclei could be described very well by means of a “shell model” which would seem to contradict the conclusion about the importance of correlations. Supposing that this evidence is really conclusive, it would mean either that the nuclear forces are not of the kind which are now generally accepted, or that there exists some other way of describing the motion in which correlations are not neglected and in which nevertheless, the energy values can be put in correspondence with the shell model. I think it is important to face this difficulty and to recognize that with at least the usual assumptions about nuclear forces the uncertainty in the position is not sufficient to make the shell model a good approximation. For the same reason I am not very happy about the view you take at the end of the second page, in which the capture of a particle into the nucleus proceeds first by way of a stationary state in a smooth potential. In a formal way one can, of course, always consider such states with limited life-time due to the possibility of exchange of energy between the nucleons. I should expect, however, that in the energy region corresponding to the capture of a neutron of few MeV, the life303
¨ H. Euler, ‘Uber die Art der Wechselwirkung in den schweren Atomkernen’, Z. Phys. 105 (1937), 553–75. 304 R. Huby, ‘Investigations on the Binding Energy of Heavy Nuclei’, Proc. Roy. Soc. London A62, 62–71 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
196
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
time of such a state would be so short that it would not be very helpful in describing nuclear processes. However, at much higher excitations energies it may well be that such states would help to understand the maxima and minima in the excitation curves found, for example by Pollard and his collaborators at Yale.305 Kindest regards, from all of us and also to Mrs. Bohr, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[487] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 16.10.1949 Dear Oppie, I am afraid I vanished from Princeton without trace, and without saying again how much I enjoyed the day; I was very conscious of having come at a time when you could have used a day’s quiet much better than any visitor, and if I had known before that I could afford a few days in U.S. after the conference, I would have suggested coming later. The Chalk River Conference turned out to be much more fruitful than I expected, and we had an opportunity of saying what ought to be done next and why.306 Whether this will get us anywhere, I do not know, of course, but the discussion was at least interesting. I have been very much intrigued by your idea that the nuclear forces (apart from tensor interactions) might, in fact be contact forces, and that the “effective range” might, in fact, be due to damping. There is in this, a mathematical problem, whether damping effect of the kind we know now can result in a finite range, while not, at the same time, also contributing to the p−, d−, · · · scattering about as much as a “real” 305
E.C. Pollard (1906–1996), had studied at Cambridge under Chadwick. In 1933 he joined the Yale faculty and later became the first professor of biophysics there. In the late 1940s he worked on exchange forces and he carried out experiments involving the deuteron bombardment of various elements. 306 Peierls had attended a declassification conference at Chalk River. While on the other side of the Atlantic, he had spent a day at Princeton.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
197
potential of the same effective range. No doubt you will be pursuing this further; I am trying to look into this for my own satisfaction, but I would be very glad to know if you reach a definite conclusion. I would have written before, but on my return we discovered that our last baby has achondroplasia, which means she is one of those dwarfs with normal bodies and very short arms and legs. We were naturally in great distress, but it makes it a little easier to know that she is likely to reach 4 or 4 12 ft. and that people of this type are usually very happy and well-adjusted. We are now trying to find some adult people with this condition, so as to learn better the sort of life for which to educate her; but the condition is quite rare. Dyson has been here for a week or so; he makes a great difference to the place. With many thanks again and greetings to Kitty. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[488] Rudolf Peierls to Raymond Priestley [Birmingham], 9.11.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Vice-Chancellor, I believe that the next meeting of the Senate Executive Committee will have before it again the proposal concerning the method of deciding promotions at the efficiency bar. As no doubt you know, this was discussed by the Faculty of Science Executive in a long and heated debate ending in a close vote in favour of the proposal that the discussion be limited to Professors. I do not wish to be disloyal to my colleagues in raising again a question on which I voted with the minority, but I have very strong doubts whether the decision was constitutionally possible. The presently accepted constitution of the Faculty of Science provides clearly that questions of salary are to be decided by Faculty Executive which includes the Chairman of Faculty Boards. I do not believe this constitution can
April 7, 2009
198
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
be altered by one of the bodies of which Faculty consists, though, of course, Senate can over-rule it. The responsibility, therefore, rests with Senate and is not settled by the decision of Faculty Executive. Turning now from the legal form to the substance of the programme, it seems to me a retrograde step to exclude non-professorial members of staff from such discussions. For some years we have had in the Faculty of Science the Chairmen of two Boards present and I have never seen any signs of embarrassment resulting from their presence or any contribution from them which was not as constructive or as responsible as from Professors. I believe we have a lot to gain from the presence of men who, while they cannot repeat outside the meeting the arguments that were used, will be able to assure their colleagues that each problem was discussed fairly and on the basis of available facts and without personal prejudice. One hears stories of cases in the past where members of nonprofessorial staff behaved irresponsibly. I think we must recognise that whatever may have been the quality of our staff twenty years ago we would have failed badly in our duty if this was possible now and in any event if such people were appointed Chairmen of Faculty Boards or in other ways members of Faculty. In the particular case of the Faculty of Science the proposed constitutional change would make a very illogical position since it would leave promotion to Grade I, the withholding in exceptional cases of routine increments, the temporary re-appointment of members of staff beyond retiring age and similar matters involving delicate personal matters, in the hands of the full Faculty Executive with the sole exception of the increase at the efficiency bar. The only logical step to take if this is passed would be to exclude the Chairman of the Boards also from the discussion of all thee matters, leaving them in practice merely to present the report of their Boards and depart. This would completely wreck the spirit of the present experiment in the Faculty and give offence to the non-professorial staff. I hope Senate Executive will bear these points in mind when making their decision. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
199
[489] Ed Salpeter to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 4.12.1949 Dear Peierls, A. Physics (i) “Rochester Star”. You’ve probably heard of Brodt and Peter’s famous star by now, but just in case you haven’t, here it is: In a star with 18 heavy-fragment prongs (Ag or Br nucleus), 23 minimumionisn. particles were emitted in a cone making ∼ 2.5◦ (total projected angular spread) with forward direction and 33 at larger angles. In 1/4 ” radiation length of glass & emulsion 15 to 20 more charged p[articles] were produced in this forward cone. (These are presumably e+ − e0 pairs created by the γ-rays given off by the decay of the neutral mesons. ∴ most probable number of neutral mesons ∼ 20). Av[erage] energy of these neutral mesons estimated (from spread of the pairs, I think?!) to be 10BeV each. The conclusion is (a) Must be multiple production in a single act (at least the forward cone), (b) evidence for neutral mesons and either (c) Meson production in C.G. systems is isotropic, but only fraction of energy converted into mesons or (d) Most of energy converted, but mesons produced in cone (∼ π/10) around the direction of each of the nucleons. (ii) Electron Sprays: Exp[erimen]ts of Oppenheimer & Ney307 (Phys. Rev. 76, 1418 (1949)) have been separated and confirmed: Up to 50 particles of mass < 10me and kinetic energies not much greater than their rest mass (since almost all absorbed in one radiation length of Pb without starting showers) have been observed. According to one report these sprays have been so frequent, that every second primary at 100.000ft must create one!! Noone here has an explanation as yet (if the exp[eriments] are really correct). 307
F. Oppenheimer and E.P. Ney, ‘Wide Angle Sprays of Minimum Ionization Particles’, Phys. Rev. 76 1418–1419 (1949).
April 7, 2009
200
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
(iii) I don’t know of any spectacular results I can report on but here are some topics on which people are working: (a) Multiple meson production (Princeton Inst. Rochester). Attempts to modernise the 1949 paper of Lewis, Oppenheimer and Wouthuysen308 and rescue what can be secured of it. Interest (mainly scepticism) in Heisenberg’s view (Z.P. 126, 569, (1949)309 that mesonic interaction at high energies is so strong that methods like L.O. & W’s (which assume “statistical independence” of meson emission) are entirely unjustified. (b) Investigations for all types of meson interactions which nucleon-mesonic field interactions, give finite results with massand charge renormalisation alone — which can be rescued by a finite number of additional renormalisations (i.e. adding infinite quadruple moment coupling terms in original Hamiltonian etc. ) (Princeton Inst., Cornell, etc.) (c) Difficulties of finite cut-offs (Pais & Uhlenbeck, Feynman310 ): With finite order diff[erential] equations on P[ais] & U[hlenbeck]]s theory (equiv[alent] to discrete values of masses of auxiliary “photons” on F[eynman’s] theory) the theories seem to be mathematically self-consistent but lead to predictions which are physical nonsense (emission of negative-energy auxiliary particles, etc.) On F[eynman’s] theory of continuous distribution of auxiliary masses it seems possible to make prob[abilities] of emission of these negative energy p[artic]les zero. (F[eynman]’s dodge is to calculate the excitation of a far-away atom, say, by means of these auxiliary p[artic]les — instead of calculating their emission pr[obability] in the orthodox way — so that he adds amplitudes and not pr[obabilities] and the contributions of the different masses cancel.) But in this case the theory is self-inconsistent, e.g. the
308 H. W. Lewis, J. R. Oppenheimer, and S. A. Wouthuysen, ‘The Multiple Production of Mesons’, Phys. Rev. 73, 127–140 (1948). 309 ¨ W. Heisenberg, ‘Uber die Entstehung von Mesonen in Vielfachprozessen’, Z. Phys. 126, 569–82 (1949). 310 See A. Pais and G.E, Uhlenbeck ‘On Field Theories with Non-Localized Action’, Phys. Rev. 79, 145–65 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
201
life-time of an excited atomic state (imaginary part of Lampshift) does not tally with emission pr[obability] of real photons (as calculated by the effect of a far-away atom). On P[ais] and U[hlenbeck]’s theory with infinite number of orders the positrons is more obscure, but seems to be similar. B: Gossip: Believe it or not, I have tracked Tony Skyrme down to earth! In fact I spent Thanksgiving with the Skyrmes. They live in one of the Institute Housing Project apartments, own a car (ancient, but sturdy); still have their English accents without any trace of contamination and generally maintain a little oasis of England. Tony seems to prefer the Institute to MIT and is working on some rather abstract topics of field theory. The Princeton Institute seems to have more Theoreticians this year than ever before — the only ones who haven’t arrived yet are Jost & Pauli (and they’re probably here now). There have been a few changes at Cornell — the only other addition to the Theor. Dept. is Fritz Rohrlich311 , an Austro-Israelien (ex-Jerusalem, ex-Harvard, exPrinceton). I haven’t seen very much of the Bethes or Wilsons yet, so I can’t report any news there, but they seem to be fine and send their regards. I am sharing an apartment with Darcy Walker at the moment (and have managed to fill it with junk). I have little to report about myself except that I, quite inexplicably, have lost my giant appetite on arrival in this country and eat no more than an average American (in my present form I just can’t touch Bethe). With best regards to you, the Peierls household and the Dept. Ed Salpeter P.S. I am enclosing a cheque for phone calls, etc. which I owe the Dept.
311
Fritz Rohrlich (1921–) who had previously been at Harvard, joined the Institute of Advanced Studies in 1949; he later went to the University of Iowa (1953–1963) and Syracuse University (1963–1991).
April 7, 2009
12:11
202
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[490] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr Birmingham, 7.12.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, I have made provisional arrangements to fly to Copenhagen on the morning of 2nd January (there is no suitable plane on the 1st) and if this arrangement is still convenient to you I shall arrive at Copenhagen about 3.30 p.m. I shall be needed again in Birmingham on the 9th January and will probably have to leave on the 8th. It may help if I put down a few points that I did not have time to explain adequately either here or at Edinburgh.312 It seems to me that the contents of the paper as at present drafted are largely, if not entirely, independent of the model one makes of the nucleus, though the values one would tend to guess for the various constants occuring in the equations do, of course, depend very much on the model. In the past there has been a tendency to confuse these matters, i.e. to identify the model that you first proposed of the nucleus, with the mathematical formalism developed to investigate this model, which, however, is far more general. For this reason I entirely agree that it would be desirable in the introduction to explain this and to say also that one should now have an open mind about the model and that the experimental facts about “magic numbers” and the success of the theory of Jensen313 and Goeppert-Meyer314 are vital pieces of evidence. However, the question of what exactly one must conclude from these things is, to my mind, essentially unsolved. In earlier correspondence I insisted that it was not correct to regard each particle as moving in the average field of the others, if our present view about these forces were anything like correct. This, however, does not prove that one cannot 312
Bohr had given a series of lectures at Edinburgh, and on this occasion, he had met Peierls and visited him in Birmingham. See letter [486]. 313 O. Haxel, J.H.D. Jensen and H.E. Suess, ‘On the Magic Numbers in Nuclear Structure’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1766 (1949). 314 Maria G. Mayer, ‘On Closed Shells in Nuclei. II’, Phys. Rev. 75, 1969-70, (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
203
get a shell structure out of the present forces. It might be possible, at least in the case of a single nucleon outside a closed shell, to find a picture describing it as a particle moving in a suitable field of force which would, however, not be the average potential of the others. The situation is reminiscent of that in field theory, where one gets large errors (and indeed infinities) if one regards the disturbance caused by the electron in the field as small. We are now learning how to take into account the disturbance which inevitably accompanies an electron and in some sense this is the meaning of “renormalization”. One might hope in the nucleus equally to think of the momentum of a nucleon in an otherwise saturated nuclear fluid, taking into account the disturbance it will locally cause in it, and this might lead to a reasonable one-body picture. I am, therefore, not sure that there is enough evidence on which you say we must abandon our present picture of the forces, but equally it is not certain that we can retain this picture and, while I am most anxious to discuss these problems with you and see what progress one can make, I feel that for the present paper it would be wiser to admit the existence of unsolved problems than to attempt a complete answer in this context. Yours very sincerely, R.E. Peierls We greatly enjoyed your brief visit. I am looking forward to the days in Copenhagen, but please say quite frankly, whether this is still convenient. If you would rather leave it until you pass through this country, this would be very nice for me, too.
April 7, 2009
12:11
204
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[491] Rudolf Peierls to James Chadwick [Birmingham], 8.12.1949 (carbon copy) Dear Chadwick, I believe I have not yet written to thank you for your second letter on the problem of Oliphant’s successor.315 For various complicated reasons our Committee did not, in fact, meet until this week and I was glad to be able to put your views before them. We have not made very much progress yet beyond ruling out a number of names on the grounds either that they were no[t] suitable or that it was known that they would not accept. We have, in particular, ascertained that Dee could not be persuaded to change his mind. We are now left with the following names as possibilities: (1) Moon; I have explained the position as regards him already. (2) Devons316 ; this was one of the names you mentioned and it was also mentioned by Cockroft. The Committee felt that before ruling out Devons as a candidate for the Poynting Chair, they would want to be quite clear about his merits. They might face the possibility of offering him the appointment in preference of Moon if there was a really strong case for doing so. This means judging his merits as a physicists as regards past performance and future promise and his suitability from the point of view of administration and teaching. I gather that his reputation is of being somewhat intolerant with people and of expecting too much from students, but I do not know how seriously one ought to take this. I would expect, personally, that to appoint Devons would mean loosing Moon and apart from my personal regret at such a step one would want 315
Mark Oliphant was planning to take up an appointment as first director of the Australian National University Research School of Physical Sciences in Canberra in 1950. 316 Samuel Devons (1914–), had studied at Cambridge where, after war work as senior scientific officer for the Air Ministry, he became a lecturer after the war. He later became Professor of Physics at Imperial College (1950–1955), before taking up an appointment as Langworthy Professor of Physics at Manchester. He later became Professor of Physics at Columbia University (1966–1984).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
205
to be sure that in the end we are gaining by the transaction. (3) Powell; this name has not previously been mentioned, partly because we always took it for granted that the appointment should bear some relation to the operation of the big machines. However, it may be possible to delegate the day-to-day supervision of the machines to some of the first-rate people who are now with Oliphant on this job, subject, of course, to a supervision on policy and overall responsibility in the hands of one or both of the Professors. On the experiments done on the machines as opposed to their operation, one would feel that the proton synchroton should, in fact, come into very close contact with Powell’s work. I believe it may be that Powell would, in fact, prefer, if he accepted at all, to hold the second chair, but it might still be the correct course to offer him the more senior job and let him choose. I am sorry to trouble you again over this, but you will appreciate that this is a most difficult problem for us and it would be most helpful if you could let us have your comments on these three possibilities. We have not yet considered the problem seriously of who would be appointed to the Second Chair, if Moon were to be Poynting Professor, but (unless Powell would be interested in that position) an interesting suggestion would be Pontecorvo, but this is by no means clear and need not be settled at this stage. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [492] Rudolf Peierls to Ed Salpeter [Birmingham], 26.1.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Salpeter, Thank you very much for your long and most welcome letter and the various bits of information in it. I have no particular comments on them, except that I have now understood why the results of Pais317 seem to 317
Abram Pais was working on field theories with non-localised action. See letters Peierls-Pais, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b212, C.230.
April 7, 2009
12:11
206
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
be rather different from ours, in particular, Irving’s.318 The answer is that the work of Pais is based on the theory by Bopp319 which leads to equations for a free electron in which the integral goes over the past but not the future motion. Such theories are not equivalent to McManus’s form of the equation.320 They arise only if the field allows a photon of finite mass as well as zero mass and I believe it follows from Pais’s arguments that to get the self energy finite, one must then assume negative energy densities for these auxiliary masses. McManus’s theory leads to integrals going over past and future and can always been arranged so as to give a finite energy but Irving has demonstrated the danger of runaway solutions. We have not yet found a form function which avoids this and it may well not exist. Whether an oscillatory runaway solution in the classical theory is necessarily fatal is, of course, another question. We have made no progress about quantisation. Rumour has it that Feynman can quantize equations having only a Lagrangian and not a Hamiltonian. I wonder whether this rumour is correct, or whether he can do this perhaps only for the Wheeler-Feynman formalism which is special in the sense that one has started from a differential theory of two fields and then eliminated one of the fields. Other current work: we are having a beautiful course of lectures from Dyson which, amongst other things, help to show how little field theory we knew before, but a few people are now beginning to learn how to use it. Of these Dalitz has completed his calculation on the corrections to angular distribution of pairs ejected by a 0-0 nuclear transition as in oxygen. The correction is several percent but it varies rather slowly with angle and it is not easy to observe experimentally. It is of the wrong sign as well as too small for explaining results which Devons appeared to find, which, however, in any case, were still uncertain. Ravenhall found the problem about complex eigenvalues in Feynman theory too vague and in view of what your letter says in this context I see 318
J. Irving, ‘Applications of the Peierls-McManus Classical Finite Electron’, Proc. Phys. Soc. London A62, 780–790 (1949). 319 F. Bopp, ‘Eine lineare Theorie des Elektrons’, Ann. Phys. 38, 345–84 (1940). 320 See letter [396], note 80.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
207
now that the problem is much deeper than I had thought. He has just completed a calculation of the production of pairs by electrons which had never been done decently and which is of interest in connection with the Bristol experiments.321 He is now going on to look at the problem of bound states in field theory. Gunther got here finally after waiting two months for his British visa and is still living mostly on air and he is now waiting for his money from Poland. He is making rather heavy weather of the derivation of the Breit terms from field theory (so far only the order e2 , nothing to do with Lamb shift etc.). He is tying to do it by means of a 4n dimensional configuration space. I thought at first that this would lead to unsurmountable trouble. He has convinced me that it can be done but not yet that there is an advantage in doing it. Moorhouse has shelved field theory for the time being and has worked out the theory of scattering neutrons by ferromagnetism. It appears that one can give a very direct and instructive interpretation to such experiments which will not teach us much about neutrons, but may throw light on models of ferromagnetism. Barker has sent his paper on the Schwinger model off for publication322 and is now worrying about nuclear models, investigating, in particular, a two-particle problem which may give a lead to estimating the extent to which the existence of shells may be compatible with the general Bohr picture. Wroe has turned over to cosmology and the origin of the elements. It now looks as if the general idea of Teller and Meyer323 can be rescued assuming that the universe was at one time so small that it was completely filled with matter and nuclear density and low temperature and then expanded. This leads to condensation more or less as in the cloud chamber and the rest proceeds as in Teller’s picture. There are, 321
R.H. Dalitz, and D.G. Ravenhall, ‘On the Tomonaga method for intermediate coupling in meson field theory’, Phil. Mag. 42, 7 (1951). 322 F.C. Barker, ‘Schwinger Potential in Nuclear Forces’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A63, 898–909 (1950). 323 Maria G. Mayer and E. Teller, ‘On the Origins of the Elements’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1226–31 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
208
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
of course, very many complications to be allowed for and one cannot yet be sure of the answer.324 Butler extended Wroe’s work on the three-body problem and set out a programme of carrying out the necessary integrations numerically. This is not prohibitive but too long for Butler to do himself and we have shelved this until we can find a suitable computer. Lindhard, whom you don’t know, has settled down very well in the department. He is interested in the degree of ionization of nuclear fragments and in nuclear models. I am also working with him and van Wieringen on an old problem in the theory of metals in which, after fifteen years, we have now made one step forward, but seem to be unable to take the remaining step necessary to get an answer. The synchrotron is getting along well but, of course, it is much too early to make any predictions. The cyclotron is now behaving well at a D voltage, somewhat below the design figure and hence giving a beam that does not quite get to the edge. It has now been decided to reduce the magnetic field a little and thus to get certainty of a particle beam at a slightly lower voltage rather than hopes of a hypothetical beam at the design energy. You are not the only ex-member of the department who writes letters. Several people heard from Skyrme and we had a letter from Rzewuski saying that he got married recently. Gardner is settling down at Harwell but largely is continuing the kind of problem he was working on here. I forgot to mention Swiatecki. He is still engaged in mopping up operations resulting from his work on nuclear surface tension.325 We are at last getting round to issuing a list of papers of which reprints are available. I do not know whether your reprints will be sent out from Cornell, but if you like us to put your papers on the list could you let me know more or less by return as I would like to get the list out within the next week or two. In that event you should either mail 324
The results were later published as R.E. Peierls, K.S. Singwi and D. Wroe, ‘The Polyneutron Theory of the Origin of the Elements’, Phys. Rev. 87, 46–50 (1952). 325 See W.J. Swiatecki, ‘Density distribution inside nuclei and nuclear shell structure’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A63, 1208–18 (1950); and W.J. Swiatecki, ‘Nuclear Compressibility and Fission’, Phys. Rev. 83, 178–9 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
209
us a supply of reprints or else we should send you from time to time a list of names of people who have asked for your papers. If I do not hear from you I shall assume that you wish to stand on your own feet in this matter. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [493] Genia Peierls to Klaus Fuchs Birmingham, [date unspecified]326 (carbon copy) Dear Klaus, Rudi just came home from London, and I am writing to you in front of our sitting room fire, where we so often talked about so many things. This is a hard letter to write, perhaps even a harder one to read, but you know me well enough not to expect me to mince my words. I am taking it all much easier than everybody else, because my Russian childhood and youth taught me not to trust anybody and to expect anyone and everyone to be a communist agent. Twenty years of freedom in England softened me somewhat, and I learned to like and trust people, or at any rate some of them. But early attitudes are deeper and after the first half hour I feel I can take it. I certainly did trust you. Even more, I considered you the most decent man I knew. I do that even now. This is the reason why I am writing to you. I understand that you have now changed you views and want the best of our civilisation to go on. The best is trust in human beings, friendship, this bit of freedom and fresh air which is still lingering here and there in the world and makes life worth living, and bringing up children a joy. Your actions have tremendously endangered just these things. And this in two ways: one is directly and as was your intention, and one cannot do much about that now. But one can and one must do something about the other. 326
The letter was probably written on the 4th of February 1950, the day that Rudolf Peierls visited Klaus Fuchs in prison.
April 7, 2009
210
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Do you realize what will be the effect of your trial on scientists here and in America? Specially in America where many of them are in difficulty already? Do you realize that they will be suspected not only by officials but by their own friends, because if you could why not they? For your “cause” you did not have to be on such warm personal relations with them, to play with their children and laugh and drink and talk. You are such a quiet man that you could have kept yourself much more aloof. You were enjoying the best of the world you were trying to destroy. It was not honest. In a way I am glad that you failed in this, because [???] you the value of humanity, of warmth of freedom, what did you do to them, Klaus? Not only that their faith in decency and humanity is shaken, but for years to come they will be suspected to be involved in this with you. Perhaps you did not think about it at the time, but you must think now. [???] to say who were your real connections. It is awfully hard, perhaps the hardest thing of all to do. But you went all the way in one direction, don’t stop half way now. You are not soft, and not one for an easy way out. You are a mathematician. This problem has no rigorous solution. Try to find the best approximation. Rudi told me that you don’t want to give the impression that you want to ease your own position. Klaus, don’t be a child. This is the schoolboy code of honour. Impressions don’t matter. You personally do not matter. The issues are too important for that, and you know it, otherwise you would have taken the only easy way out for you personally — to take your life. Thank you for not doing that. You could not leave all this terrible mess for others to sort out. This is your job, Klaus. And you know you never shirked. No even the washing up!! Oh Klaus, my tears are washing away the ink. I was so very fond of you, and I so much wanted you to be happy, and now you never will be. I still think that you are an honest man, it means that you do what you think right, whatever the cost. Do the right thing. Try and save as much as you can of this decent and warm and tolerant, this free community of international science which gave you so much these last ten years.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
211
This letter is just a sea of ink, I am asking Rudi to copy it. Would you like me to come to see you? You are now going through the hardest time a man can go through, you have burned your god. God help you! [Genia]
[494] G.I. Taylor327 to Rudolf Peierls Cambridge, 5.2.1950 Dear Peierls, Like everyone I have come across who knows Fuchs I was shocked and astounded when I heard what has happened. I cannot imagine that our police would have acted unless they had overwhelming evidence because they must have understood how terribly bad their action would be for Anglo-American co-operation and even then I cannot understand why they did not get Fuchs to resign quietly. Then the thing is quite outside anything I could imagine. It is just impossible to imagine anyone person acting as the police allege Fuchs did. But Frisch suggested to me the only possibility that I have heard that has any chance of being conceivable. He tells me that Fuchs came over from Nazi Germany early as a refugee and that he was interned at the beginning of the war and was in a group that was so badly treated that there was in fact an enquiry into the matter. Frisch suggested Fuchs might have an insane resentment and has for years been stiring up a punishment which has now been let loose. If this is indeed the case, it is indeed an extraordinary case for resentment against bad individuals has been turned into a desire to punish all people who have since treated him extremely kindly. People like Cockroft & you and me for instance, as well as the whole body of the scientific workers. Of course one looks 327
Geoffrey Ingram Taylor, (1986–1975), studied mathematics and physics at Trinity College, Cambridge, where he became a fellow, lecturer and later professor of physics. Member of the British mission at Los Alamos.
April 7, 2009
212
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
against all reason that a mistake has been made, but I feel that’s the least probable of the possibilities. I write to you because you know F[uchs] better than I do + you may have some light to shed on the psychological aspects of the question. Don’t answer if you feel you can’t. I wrote because I feel I am one of a small group who have been dealt a shattering blow and that some comfort may come from a feeling of solidarity with other members of that group. Yours sincerely, G.I. Taylor
[495] Klaus Fuchs to Genia Peierls London, 6.2.[1950] Dear Genia, It was wonderful of Rudi to visit me on Saturday, although I could not do anything to cheer him up. On the contrary. It is up to you. Do you mind if I talk of other things? Sometime I shall try and describe to you what went on in my mind. But you will have to be very patient. I have been sitting here for an hour, trying to think what to write next, when your letter arrived. I have told myself almost every word you say, but it is good that you should say it again. I know what I have done to them and this is why I am here. You ask: Perhaps you did not think about it at the time. Genia, I didn’t, and this is the greatest horror I had to face when I looked at myself. You don’t know what I had done to my own mind; and I thought I knew what I was doing. And there was this simple thing, obvious to the simplest decent creature, and I didn’t think of it. I had used my god to make myself into this, and that was the point where it finally crashed down. Controlled schizophrenia is the nearest description I can give to it; but I didn’t control the control; it controlled me. I know that it is my job to try and clear up the mess I made. I am afraid I did shirk it at first, and that made the mess even worse. They gave me a much easier way out. I could have left Harwell to go to a
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
213
university a free man, free from everything, free from friends, with no faith left to start a new life. I could even have stayed at Harwell if I had admitted just one little thing and had stayed quiet about everything else. I bungled the “take your life” stage; yes I went through that too, before the arrest. The elaborate precautions taken after my arrest, I am glad to say, were quite unnecessary, though a trifle inconvenient. I was only afraid they would discover the safety pins which held my pants together. In that case my appearance in court the following morning might have been somewhat undignified. I suppose you would almost enjoy the kind of things I am learning about here. All these people [are] in their way kind and decent. Even the chap who apparently made prison his home by occasional excursions to pick up a few hundred pounds and have a few riotous weeks on them. He grew quite sympathetic when I admitted that I hadn’t made any money out of it. Nothing could shake him from the belief that I had been double-crossed. Many many thanks for your letter. Funny that women see such thin[g]s so much clearer than men. And that they are so much kinder by saying hard words straight out. Klaus Sorry I have not got anybody to type this out for me. I hope you can read it. And don’t worry if you can’t see the tears, I have learned to cry again. And to love again. K[laus]
[496] Rudolf Peierls to G.I. Taylor Birmingham, 7.2.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Taylor, Your letter reached me only now, as it went to an old address, owing to an error in the Royal Society Year Book.
April 7, 2009
214
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I very much appreciate your writing to me at once, and I entirely agree with all you say about the consequences this is likely to have. You can imagine that this came as an even greater shock to us than to anybody else, after ten years of the closest personal and scientific association with Fuchs. At the present moment I cannot say very much for reasons that you will appreciate, but I can say that I do not think the picture Frisch has given you is at all likely to be accurate. One must still keep an open mind, as long as the facts are not clear, and they are certainly not clear to me. But assuming the facts to be as alleged, the only explanation is that for him his political views took, as these particular views do so often, the form of almost religious convictions and psychologically the situation would be rather like that of a Jesuit, who may feel free to act against the ordinary standards of morality in a higher cause. I also have reason to think that, always the facts are as alleged — which I do not yet accept — he must have gone through a process of development in which he abandoned these views but after the date of what is said to have happened. I felt I should tell you this at once because, while it would not for a moment excuse the action, it would at least raise it to a somewhat higher level than the kind of personal grudge that you speak of. However, I have put all this in such a conditional form for a definite reason, and I can yet see a possibility of an explanation which would be less distressing. This may be wishful thinking, and I cannot know until I have more of the evidence than I can obtain at the present. If this should be true, it would become clear quite soon, and meanwhile one has to be patient. Your sincerely, R.E. Peierls On re-reading the last paragraph, I find it sounds more definitive than I intended. It is a very long shot.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
215
[497] Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr [Birmingham], 14.2.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Uncle Nick, I feel I should write to you about Fuchs, though I have really very little to say that you do not know already. This has come as a distressing blow to very many people and I am sure that it must also have caused you terrible distress. I do not know whether from the American papers it was possible to sort out fact from imagination, but you will have seen a report of the Police Court Proceedings last week in which statements by Fuchs himself were described. If one takes these statements as genuine, and it is very hard to believe anything else, he has lived all these years hiding his real allegiance, yet at the same time acquiring a genuine and almost passionate interest for his job and building up personal relationships and friendships which were kept quite separate from his secret contacts. One can believe that a man should hold political views of such strong, almost religious, conviction that he should let them override all other considerations, but it is incredible that, at the same time, a man who had never thought for himself and who was always ready to go to enormous lengths in the interest of others, should allow himself to become so attached to the people and to allow other people to become so attached to him without seeing what he was doing to them. According to the statements quoted in court, this was really what broke him in the end, and because it was the trust and confidence shown him by his friends which convinced him in the end that there was something wrong with the cause, but it was, of course, then too late to undo the damage. The whole picture is so unbelievable that we continue to ask ourselves whether he has really done all the things to which he is reported to have confessed, or whether some, or all of them, are perhaps hallucinations created by a very great mental strain. It is impossible for us to judge this because the answer depends, of course, on what other evidence exists besides his own statements and quite properly the authorities will not tell us whether such evidence exists and how strong
April 7, 2009
216
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
it is, but until then I know I shall continue to regard this at least as a possibility. There is no doubt that this whole case will have disastrous effects, quite apart from personal relations on the political atmosphere and the positions of scientists both here and particularly in America. It is, of course, quite illogical if all security clearance and investigations have missed such a case to seek a remedy in submitting people to further checks and clearances. Nevertheless this will, of course, be done. We are beginning to wonder whether the real lesson is not that it is impossible to maintain secrecy in a project involving so many people without creating the atmosphere of a totalitarian country in which everybody is ready to suspect his best friend of being an informer. Russia has found how to stop leakages very effectively. If this is the only effective solution do we want to go that way ourselves or should we not say that at that price security is not worth having. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[498] Rudolf Peierls to E.C. Bullard328 [Birmingham], 15.4.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Bullard, As you may know, I had some correspondence with Womersley329 about the possibility of employing a first-rate man who is graduating this summer and there is a point of principle arising from this which I would like to put before you. 328 Edward Crisp Bullard (1907–1980), studied physics at Cambridge under Blackett, and later turned to geophysics. In 1949 he became director of the National Physical Laboratory, Teddington Middx. 329 John R. Womersley (1907–1958), Superintendent of the Mathematics Division of the National Physical Laboratory.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
217
It emerges that the only thing this man could do would be to apply to the Civil Service Commission for the general entry to the Scientific Civil Service though he could state a preference for the N[ational] P[hysical] L[aboratory] but I gather from Womersley that it is not possible to conduct direct negotiations about the type of work he might be taken in for. I have often felt from previous experience that the centralised method of recruiting for scientific work was bad. It is, of course, modelled on the procedure invented for the administrative class where presumably a man decides in the first place that he wants to become a Civil Servant and does not mind very much, even though he may have some preference, whether he collects taxes or issues building permits. In the case of scientists I find the best people are usually those who have some concrete ideas as to what they would like to do although they may later change their ideas, and I have never come across a case which makes it as obvious as the present one to what extent the present system discourages applications from such people. In writing to you I do not want in the least to press the particular case since the man was somewhat doubtful about it anyway. I had offered him a place as a research student and he is quite keen to stay on except that his age gives him some reason not to prolong his training excessively. I was making enquiries about possible jobs mainly to help him make up his mind whether he wants to stay on here and it is likely that he may stay on anyway. I thought, however, that the particulars of this case might interest you and in case your views about the Civil Service recruiting are similar to mine it might provide useful ammunition. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
218
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[499] Egon Orowan to Rudolf Peierls Cambridge, Mass., 20.4.1950 Dear Peierlses, You would not believe how often, in certain situations, the question occurs to me: How would you expect me to behave in this (mess, quandary, tight spot, problem, and the rest of Roget’s). I am afraid, however, just at the moment, there is no real problem on the table for you; so this is just a sign that I am thinking of you not only when strictly utilitarian reasons demand it. Also, I should like to thank you for sending me to Weisskopf; he was very useful indeed. He said: 1) he would not go from MIT to Princeton if he were offered an equivalent job; 2) Cambridge Mass. is far better than Princeton; 3) apart from Bethe and Wigner, he could not tell the name of another physicist whose salary exceeds 10,000. This is his own salary, too. With the MIT, the main problem is merely to discover the snags and the flies in the ointment. So far, the whole place appears so improbably nice that it seems to me the less good spots are reserved for later discovery. As a university and research place, it seems Paradise after Cambridge – Eng. The people are incredibly nice; partly it is the attitude of the couple before the marriage ceremony which cools down when they leave the church. The surroundings are pretty, one can recognise it even now when the trees hardly begin to bud. As you see, therefore, there is a definite recession with Canberra and Princeton. However, I have not arrived at the zero line yet, and I have duly sent to Hugh S. Taylor a project he asked from me about the new group for applied physics of solids (or materials engineering) that they want to set up at Princeton. Having penetrated into the skin of American life, it seems to me far more attractive than it appeared from the distance. Of course, this place is a bit highbrow and too full of intelligentsia as far as I am concerned, but I can easily learn a few words like repression, existentialism etc. to fit into the picture. I hope you are well; since you are very busy, I do not suggest that perhaps once one of you might take pity of a poor exile to the extent of a few lines.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
219
Between this line and the previous one I had a visitor belonging to the wire-pulling class who broached pointedly the question of the Harvard metallurgy department which they want to re-open when they find somebody to put in. At the same time, he was so positive that you cannot live in the U.S. a life better than a dog’s with less than 20,2000 or 30,000 p.a., that I am beginning to think Canberra is better. With the kindest regards to you all, Yours ever, E. Orowan
[500] Memorandum Rudolf Peierls The Lesson of the Fuchs Case [Birmingham, around March 1950] To all those who were associated with Dr. Fuchs during his work on the atomic energy project the disclosures at his trial have caused great distress. One could wish nothing less than to go on talking about this, particularly in public. However, the case will do such serious harm and there seems to be so much contradiction and confusion about it that I feel it necessary to write up the picture as I see it. The main point will be the conclusions to draw (or not to draw) and I shall describe the past events only as far as they have a bearing on this. For me the story starts in 1941 when a small team was then working on atomic energy in this country. I was mainly responsible for theoretical physics and more help was needed on this side. Most people of suitable ability were then already on high priority work but when I heard that Fuchs was available I knew he was a man of the right scientific qualifications. I knew he had left Germany because of his opposition to the Nazis and I respected him for this. I knew of his connection with left-wing student organisations in Germany since at that time the communist controlled organisations were the only ones putting up any active opposition. It was natural for a young man who wanted to fight the Nazis to work with any available allies, as indeed this country did later during the war.
April 7, 2009
220
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Approval for his appointment had, of course, to be given by the authorities. I do not know what their methods of investigations were, and what was disclosed, but I assumed that they had to weigh the value of his help (at a time of great shortage of scientific manpower) against any risk of his having retained from his early contacts in Germany (8 years earlier) a loyalty to a party that owed allegiance to a foreign power. During all these years we saw much of him. Shy and retiring at first he made many friends and in many conversations politics was, of course, a frequent topic. His views seemed perhaps a little to the left of ours, but he seemed to share the attitude to Communism — and to any kind of dictatorship — of most of his friends. I remember an occasion when he talked to a young man who was in sympathy with communism and in the argument Fuchs was very scornful of the other’s dogmatic views. When I heard of his arrest I regarded it as quite incredible that anyone should have hidden his real beliefs so well. Looking back it seems that at first he shared in the life of his colleagues and pretended to share their views and attitude only in order to hide his own convictions. But gradually he must have come to believe what was at first only pretence. There must have been a time when he shared one attitude with his colleagues and friends and another with the agents to whom he then still transmitted information, and when he was himself in doubt which of the two was conviction and which was pretence. I do not want to enter into speculations about the state of his mind during all this time. Some have described it as an abnormal case of a split personality, others tend to regard it as a superb piece of acting, but either way it is certainly quite exceptional. In the past his close friends were mostly amongst people who shared his extreme views. Of course, the case for the democratic way of life must have been made to him also by many people who felt a genuine conviction for it, but apparently this had not converted him. The years spent here and in America on the project brought him more and closer association with new friends, and it is one of the most unusual features of his case that a man who was not selfish should, in spite of his position, allow these close associations to form on false pretences. But as a result there was something new that grew on him. Nobody ever argued the case because nobody knew that he needed convincing, but he discovered
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
221
that implicitly all shared principles which gave him a strength that his ideals were losing. From his point of view this is perhaps the most tragic: that he does not now even have the satisfaction of suffering for a cause in which he believes. But it contains a slight piece of comfort: the story has shown up a weakness in the defence of democratic countries beca[u]se the atmosphere of mutual confidence that is so essential a part of our life, makes this kind of betrayal harder to guard against. Yet, it also shows the strength of our system which in time won over such a strong supporter of a different ideology, though, in his case, only too late. Our problem must be how to reduce the risk of further cases of this kind, while yet preserving those features that make us so sure (and that ultimately convinced Fuchs) that we are right. How, then, can we avoid further leakages: As an ordinary mortal I do not presume to know the methods of the security services but broadly speaking they can work in three ways; by “counter-espionage”, i.e. by infiltrating into the espionage organisation which they are trying to frustrate, by “clearance”, i.e. by investigating the background of people employed or to be employed on secret work and by “supervision” of the conduct of the men on the job. The first is obviously a good method if practicable, but one would not imagine it to be a complete safeguard in itself. “Clearance” investigations are, of course, employed in connection with secret work. In the case of Fuchs, they would have had to probe very deeply to disclose his continued adherence to the communist cause and that would have required a depth of human insight that is very hard to achieve. Anything that could be done to raise the level of knowledge in this way would, of course, be most valuable. But, in any case, such investigations would presumably have shown that he had been a member of a left-wing organisation in his youth. Should we now exclude others of whom this is found? Fuchs was German born; should one now all be suspicious of foreign born people? Fuchs was a scientist; should one mistrust all scientists? Should one mistrust all men with the initial F? The Fuchs case came as such a shock to the public that I would not blame anyone for advocating all these measures, except perhaps the last one. But we must not be under the illusion that they would bring
April 7, 2009
12:11
222
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
safety. They would not even have prevented the case of Nunn May.330 But they would have lost the country a great deal of ability. I believe that it is fair to say that if from the atomic energy teams in England and in America one would have excluded all foreign born scientists as well as those who in their youth had held extreme political views of one kind or another, the leakage of atomic energy would have been prevented by the fact that there would have been no atomic secrets. The work could not have continued effectively under such restrictions. This may sound an immodest statement for me, as a foreign born scientists, to make. But a glance at the names in the Smyth Report331 which summarises atomic energy work in America will make my point obvious. I am not saying that one should take no notice of the background of the people to whom one entrusts secrets. As long as there are any secrets (and all this story increases our longing for a state of the world in which they would not be necessary) it is important to judge who can be trusted with them, but one cannot insist that the precautions should be such that they would necessarily detect a second Fuchs. We are not likely to find a second person who can for years maintain the impression of being a politically inactive but generally liberal and reasonable person. But if there should be further cases of the same kind of psychology (or of equally perfect acting) they may well be people who had never openly professed communism. Should one then rely more on supervision? The difficulty in the large number of scientists and others on secret work. To “shadow” a person day and night takes more than one investigator. Where would one find the necessary number of intelligent investigators and how does one check their reliability? Probably this method had its best chance in the atomic bomb work in Los Alamos, New Mexico, which was located at the remote spot largely just in order to reduce the risk of leakage. While
330
Alan Nunn May (1911–2003) had worked at the Chalk River Plant of the Manhattan Project. In 1946 he was sentenced to 10 years; hard labour for spying for passing information on the Manhattan Project in to the Soviet Union. 331 Henry De Wolf Smyth, The Official Report on the Development of the Atomic Bomb Under the Auspices of the United States Government, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1945.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
223
the gates of this “atom city” were not actually locked, travelling by its members was discouraged and few ever travelled beyond the immediate neighbourhood. We always assumed that on our rare trips we would be watched by the efficient army security services and that this applied particularly to those employed by the British rather than the American authorities. Yet one of the charges against Fuchs relates to February 1945, a time when he was working at Los Alamos and presumably just absent to attend some meeting or collect some technical information elsewhere. If his secret rendez-vous could pass unnoticed in these circumstances the prospects of generally keeping all people under supervision does not look promising. If one considers these problems objectively, one sees that as long as there are large projects employing thousands of people we cannot have absolute assurance against leakage except in one way. The governments of totalitarian countries presumably find it easy to keep their secrets, and by adopting their methods we might succeed, too. If we build up an iron curtain preventing travel across the border, except in rare cases, if we suspect people who are talking to a foreigner, if we give the police the right to act on suspicion and, above all, if we build up a state of affairs in which everyone suspects his best friends of being police informers (and half of them probably are) then our military secrets might be safe, but at what price? If this were really necessary, we would lose most of the assets of democracy including even the pleasure of convincing a man like Fuchs in the end that we are right and he was wrong — because there would not be much difference. Nobody has yet proposed such drastic measures, but the insistence that one now hears frequently on security measures without specifying them exactly and the very understandable desire for certainty that there will be no further such cases, may logically lead us in that direction. Must we then choose between helplessly tolerating all foreign agents and becoming a police state? Fortunately things are not as black as that. Of course the authorities will continue to find out what they can about the people entrusted with important secrets and they will make the job of any future Fuchs or Nunn May as difficult as they can; they
April 7, 2009
224
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
will not pretend that they are infallible. A good general knows he is bound to lose a battle occasionally. The details of all military equipment such as tanks and aeroplanes have always been considered as important secrets. Nevertheless, no country ever succeeds to hide their main features indefinitely, but this does not even out the assets. The country with the better technical skill, the greater ability for research and design and the greater industrial potential will still be better off because no leakage can replace the value of the right skill and knowledge of the man actually on the job. The question of the importance of atomic weapons for the future safety of this country and of the United States is a controversial one which I do not want to raise here but accepting their importance more can be gained by assuming a positive need through efficient development work and good planning than by a frustrating attempt to seal up hermetically all possible channels by which others may get to know things which, after all, they might discover for themselves. One fallacy that would be particularly dangerous in this context is to extend the principle of clearance to cover not merely the employment of men to be entrusted with secret work but to a wide variety of cases which it is argued that people with extreme political views might abuse their position for seditious propaganda. This is dangerous because it would lead to political discrimination and to a restriction of the freedom of expression. It is clear that in certain circumstances the spreading of extreme political opinions might be a danger, but the difference is that propaganda is something that cannot be pursued in secret. If people misuse their position to advocate their own views, this can easily be known and they can be dealt with on the basis of their actions. There is no need to suspect them in advance. In the cases where the job is concerned with non-political matters, in particular, technical information, anybody engaged in political propaganda would, in fact, not be carrying out his duties properly and could be dealt with on that basis. In jobs concerned with the discussion of such problems as international relations of political theory or practice, it is most desirable that all views should be heard and that people should be in a position to make up their minds on a full knowledge of all arguments. This means that it is, in fact, undesirable that people should be prevented from expressing
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
225
any views however extreme or unpopular, provided one takes care to balance their views by having others available who would speak for the other side. This has always been the tradition of this country and it is important that the danger of disloyal acts which, as the Fuchs case has reminded us, is serious and should not be confused with the danger of extremist propaganda which at the present time is negligible and, in any case, must be fought by argument and not by prohibition.
[501] D.H. Wilkinson to Rudolf Peierls Cambridge, 12.5.1950 Dear Professor, I hoped to see you at the A.S.A. Council Meeting last Saturday, but I hope you will not mind being written to instead. I have been doing a series of measurements on the photo-disintegration of the deuteron at various gamma-ray energies between 6 and 18 MeV, and there is one point which I would be pleased if you would clear up. It is whether or not the state of polarisation of the gamma-rays, linear, elliptical, or anything else, has any influence on the photo-disintegration or whether it depends solely on the gamma ray energy when the deuterons are randomly oriented. I pass the gamma-rays which are derived from nuclear reactions and may be very strongly polarized, through an ionisation chamber containing ordinary deuterium gas and observe the total number of disintegrations they produce and also, effectively, the angular distribution of the photo-protons I(Θ) in the Θ co-ordinate only. Now does the number of disintegrations or I(Θ) depend on the state of polarisation? It seems instinctively obvious to me that it should not, but I do not know how to write it out properly. People who do calculations never mention this problem, so it is probably pretty trivial, but on the other hand, nobody is prepared to give me a whole-hearted yes or no answer. As you did the early calculations on this problem you can probably tell me straight away, and I would be very grateful, if you would. I measure the gamma-rays through matter and measuring the amount
April 7, 2009
12:11
226
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
of ionization they produce, and I presume that here again there is no influence of the state of polarisation? I would also be pleased if you would let me know your views on the reliability of recent calculations such as those of Bethe and Longmire.332 What I am most concerned about is the validity of the fundamental formula derived from perturbation theory. Is this effectively exact or are unknown approximations involved? If this formula is exact then the rest follows automatically, and one may use the formula of Bethe and Longmire for determining the effective triplet range. But are there any troubles back in the fundamentals which people never remark on nowadays? If one uses my values of the photo-disintegration cross section one derives a value for the triplet effective range almost the same as the “new” value of 1.71 derived from the liquid mirror slow neutron scattering, though the photodisintegration results are not so accurate as the others. The results so far are: E(MeV) 6.11 8.45 12.4 17.6
σ(1028 ) cm2 21.5 18.6 10.0 8.5
± ± ± ±
1.2 1.5 1.2 1.2
I hope you do not mind these questions, but I would like to be sure about the straight forwardness of the interpretation of the experiments, and that I need not worry about complications of multipolarity and so on. Yours sincerely, D.H. Wilkinson
332
H.A. Bethe, ‘Theory of the Effective Range in Nuclear Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 76, 38–50 (1949); H.A. Bethe and Conrad Longmire, ‘The Effective Range of Nuclear Forces II. Photo-Disintegration of the Deuteron’, Phys. Rev. 77, 647–54 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
227
[502] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft [Birmingham], 15.5.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, If Pryce does go to Princeton next year I shall certainly do my best to help with the running of the theoretical division at Harwell.333 My main difficulty in this, as you will realise, is going to be one of time and I would suggest that a little later it would be good to plan out in what way this would least interfere with running my department here. I assume that I can count on assistance with such matters as petrol supply where the use of a car makes it possible to fit in visits to the Establishment with less dislocation. As regards the question of fees, I can not really pretend that this extra work would be carried on without loss of efficiency in the performance of my duties to the university and it may well be a reasonable suggestion that part or the whole of any further fee should be passed on to the university. The whole arrangement is, of course, subject to approval by the university but before consulting them it would be better to know precisely how we are going to arrange my visits. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
333
Maurice Pryce had helped run the theoretical division at Harwell after the arrest of Klaus Fuchs.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
228
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[503] Rudolf Peierls to D.H. Wilkinson [Birmingham], 18.5.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Wilkinson, Thank you for your letter.334 The question of the polarization of the gamma rays will depend on the symmetry of the source from which they are obtained in relation to the direction of observation. For instance, if your gamma rays go in the forward direction as seen by the bombarding beam then the problem has complete axial symmetry and therefore gamma rays will be unpolarised. Of course, each individual photon will have a polarization correlated with the direction of the fragments and your disintegration but since the direction of these fragments is statistically symmetrical about the direction of the beam, this will make no difference. One must remember in this connection that there is no physical difference in the gamma ray beam according to whether you produce an unpolarized beam by superimposing waves of linear polarization in different directions or waves of opposite circular polarization or intermediate elliptic cases, as long only as one averages over all possible orientations. Therefore, in this case of forward emission of the gamma rays it follows rigorously that polarization is unimportant. Now, in general, you will be working at different angles and then there may be a greater likelihood of gamma rays being polarized in a direction at right angles to the plane formed by your bombarding beam and the line of travel of the gamma ray then in that plane and vice versa. Even in that case, however, your method of observation would not be sensitive to polarization since you only measure the angle between the proton and the gamma ray and any effect of polarization must disappear if you imagine your chamber rotated about the line of the gamma ray and the results averaged. This clearly would not make any change to your set-up. 334
Letter [501].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
229
It is an interesting question whether one could conduct the experiment in such a way as to distinguish protons forming the same angle with the gamma ray but orientated differently with respect to the plane of symmetry set up by bombarding beam and gamma ray. If the gamma ray were polarized, one would then expect a strong correlation of the protons with that direction. At low energies this correlation would be something like a cos2 distribution for the electric dipole effect. At the energies you mention the magnetic effect will be quite negligible but there may be contributions from higher multipoles and things are then a little more complicated, but this will only make the correlation stronger. All this, of course, depends on how strongly the gamma rays are polarized and this depends on the reaction in which they are emitted. To take an example, if the reaction is such that bombarding a nucleus with no spin the proton comes in with angular moment 1 and the final state of the nucleus is again without spin, then the angular momentum has to be taken over by the emitted gamma ray which for observation at right angles would give complete polarization. This is an extreme case and unlikely to be realised in practice. Another simple case about which a simple statement is possible is that in which the protons arrive with angular momentum zero. This is usually the most important case at low bombarding energies unless it is forbidden by selection rules. In that case, the proton entering the nucleus has no memory of the direction from which it came and as a result the gamma rays are rigorously unpolarized. If you can tell us a little more about the reactions you are using I could probably say in what cases there is a chance of observing polarization and in some cases such observations might, in fact, throw a new light on the mechanism of the reaction. The principle of the argument is very similar to the coincidence measurements made, for example, by Martin Deutsch at M.I.T.335 or discussed in the recent paper by Gard-
335
Martin Deutsch and his collaborators at MIT had published various papers on disintegration schemes of radioactive substances throughout the 1940s and into the 1950s, using coincidence methods.
April 7, 2009
12:11
230
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ner in the Physical Society (LXII, 763, 1949).336 The difference is only that here one takes as one datum the direction of the bombarding particle rather than that of another particle emitted in the interaction. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[504] Niels Bohr to Rudolf Peierls Copenhagen, 25.5.1950 Dear Peierls, I thank you for your kind letter of May 16th337 and hasten to answer that Mr. Barker shall be most welcome indeed to work with our group for the next academic year. I was very interested in what you wrote about his abilities and about his work. We are also here just now occupied with the problems of nuclear reactions on such lines and expect in a few weeks a visit of Dr. Hill from U.S.A. who has worked with Wheeler and me on fission problems, and I hope with him soon to complete a paper just on the relationship between the drop model and an individual particle model in such respects.338 In Paris you probably have heard that considerable progress has recently been made in the relationship between nuclear shape and nucleon binding. This gives not only a far-reaching quantitative account of the quadrupole moments of nuclei, but implies also a coupling between the excitation of individual nucleons and the oscillations of the whole nucleus which offers a general understanding of the properties of the formation of the compound state on nuclear reactions. Our old work with Placzek has also been much on my mind, but both Placzek and I were so pre-occupied in Princeton with other work 336
J.W. Gardner, ‘Directional Correlation between Successive Internal-Conversion Electrons’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A62, 763–79 (1949). 337 Rudolf Peierls to Niels Bohr, 16.5.1950, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b203, C.33 338 The results were published by Hill and Wheeler in D.L. Hill and J.A. Wheeler, ‘Nuclear Constitution and Interpretation of the Fission Phenomena’, Phys. Rev. 89, 1102–1121 (1953).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
231
and interests that we only had a few discussions about this paper, which I hope we all can complete as soon as I have got the work with Wheeler and Hill off my hands. It has been a great pleasure to learn that Lindhard has had such a good time in Manchester, and I look forward to see him soon again and to go to work in the charge of fission fragments, about which Lassen’s experiments339 have given such interesting results. Would you kindly greet Lindhard from me and say that I shall be glad to learn about his plans. I have not written myself to him because I found so much to do in the first weeks after my return from Princeton. I cannot close this letter without remembering the very noble and moving letter you sent to me to Princeton about the tragic case which has brought some much anxiety into wide circles.340 We are certainly not living in a pleasant world, but in spite of all I keep up the hope that we shall see better times before it is too late. With the kindest regards from my wife and me to the whole family and your self. Yours ever, Uncle Nick
[505] Rudolf Peierls to Raymond Priestley [Birmingham], 13.6.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Vice-Chancellor, Sir John Cockroft, the Director of the Atomic Energy Research Establishment of the Ministry of Supply, has asked me to give them some help 339 N.O. Lassen was working on the ionisation of fission fragments, and he had recently completed some experiments which were published in N.O. Lassen, ‘Total Charges of Fission Fragments in Gaseous and Solid Media’, Phys. Rev. 79, 1016–17 (1950). 340 Letter [497].
April 7, 2009
12:11
232
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
during the next academic year with the supervision of their Theoretical Physics Division.341 The position is that they have so far been unable to find a successor to Dr. Fuchs, and there is no prospect of a suitable man being man being found in the near future. At present Professor Pryce of Oxford is directing the work of the division in a part-time capacity but he has arranged to spend the next academic year at Princeton and Cockroft is asking me to take his place. I am not looking forward to this further commitment with much pleasure since it will be extremely hard to do this and at the same time do justice to my own research team, but I do not see how in such circumstances such a request can be refused. I am, therefore, writing to ask you to bring the matter before the Council for their approval. I understand that Pryce was spending half-a-day a week at Harwell for this purpose. I expect that I shall probably go there for one day from time to time on the average probably twice in three weeks. This depends a little on how much of the business can be done by Harwell people coming to see me here. I expect also to spend a little more time there during the vacations. In the correspondence the question of a fee has also been raised; you may remember that I am now a Consultant for the Ministry of Supply. Until recently this meant that I was receiving a fee of £ 300 p.a. but recently when I completed my term of office on their Technical Committee, this was reduced to £ 200. Cockroft now says that if I take on the extra work they should pay an increased fee and, while the exact amount has not been fixed, a figure of £ 500 p.a. has been mentioned. My own feeling in this matter is that I could not really accept such a large payment for spare time work since I cannot fairly claim that this is a commitment I can carry in addition to my full university duties. I feel, therefore, that, while the Ministry of Supply ought of course to pay for what they get, I should return at least part of the increased fee to the university. If we can see any way to minimise the harmful effect to my department of the extra weight I have to carry, for example, by 341
See letter [502].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
233
temporary staff to relieve some of my other duties, this might well be regarded as first charge on the money obtained in this way, though I do not see clearly at the moment any arrangement that would really help to give me more free time. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [506] Rudolf Peierls to Manchester Guardian Birmingham], 17.6.1950 (carbon copy) LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Professor Bohr’s letter Sir. — Your leading article today about Professor Niels Bohr’s letter to the United Nations makes disappointing reading for those who respect your paper highly for its liberal tradition.342 By all means let us, as you suggest, keep our feet on the ground, but also let us try to keep our head out of the sand. Professor Bohr tried to show us some hope in an imaginative approach towards restoring openness in the field of international relations, particularly in scientific matters. He was trying to show the value in itself of even a small step in that direction. If I read his letter right he did not say specifically how far such a first step should go, and he certainly did not imply that the United States should forthwith publish complete blueprints of their atomic energy installations, but he talks of an “offer · · · of immediate measures towards openness on a mutual basis.” No progress in international relations is possible which does not involve mutual concessions, but Bohr was stressing the advantage to be gained by reversing the present trend of increasing the height of barriers on all sides. Maybe, as you suggest, such an offer would not meet with any response, but then nothing would be lost, and a great deal gained, by the fact that the offer had been made. 342
On 9th June 1950, Niels Bohr had sent an open letter to the United Nations, arguing for rational peaceful atomic policies. See www.galilean-library/bohr.html.
April 7, 2009
12:11
234
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
You describe the United States’ “atomic mysteries” as her trump card. If this were correct, the security of the Western Nations would look very sad indeed. The Fuchs case gave proof again, if proof was needed, that in democratic countries it is impossible to keep large projects secret for long. We must guard against the danger, which is becoming evident today, of drifting more and more away from that personal freedom and freedom of knowledge which is so important a part of our way of life. We all know that an efficient way of keeping secrets is to curtail freedom of expression, freedom of movement, and the free flow of information, but this leads us surely towards the loss of what we value most in our democratic institutions as we understand them. The real trump card of the United States lies in her resources, her industrial potential, and her scientific and technical staff of high quality and enterprise. They are of little value in the end, as the example of German scientific effort has shown, unless they will, if need be, pull their weight inspired by the enthusiasm for their system of government and by confidence in their method of government. From this point of view a genuine effort in this direction suggested by Bohr would add to the moral strength of the countries that value personal freedom. The danger of losing any part of the moral strength by related or not fully consistent attempts to protect secret information is likely to be far greater than the danger of the possible loss of some secrets that, for all we know, may already be compromised. R.E. Peierls [507] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson [Birmingham], 19.6.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, Here is some assorted information; There has been some delay in writing up Ravenhall’s note about pair creation343 but this is now practically 343
G.E. Brown and D.G. Ravenhall, ‘On the Interaction of Two Electrons’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A208, 552–59 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
235
ready. I have asked Kolsrud344 to look into the effect of screening on the partition of energy between positron and electron in gamma ray pair creation (King’s anomaly); Brown is looking after that and they are also keeping in touch with Ravenhall so this should be all right. Dalitz has found that in his calculation on O16 he has omitted a term which does not influence the answer greatly but might in principle be observable since it leads to a relatively large anomaly at small angles. The reason for the error was that in the double integration of the Feynman type he had not noticed that a pole crosses the real axis in the course of the integration so that caution is needed. He is now anxious to make sure that there are no other similar troubles and this will delay the completion of his paper a little. He has, however, solved the other difficulty in the discussion of the ordinary Born approximation to Coulomb scattering and this is now perfectly reasonable and intelligible as far as it has been carried and it is not worth going further. My own paper is still held up while I search for a more satisfactory derivation which is not messed up by the presence of non-commuting factors. One can always carry out the proof for Lagrangians of the usual type but the result is so obviously of more general validity that it seems a pity to prove it in such a restrictive way. Brown has helped a good deal with sorting this out but in the last week or two examinations have been a major nuisance; thank God these are over. Gunther is leaving in a few days and neither of his papers is ready for publication.345 His derivation of the Breit terms seems now all right in principle but it has to be explained better and it really has not made much progress in the last few months. He also gave us a Seminar about his use of configuration space. Without pair theory this now looks all right but there are still some proofs missing for statements which are probably correct. He comes periodically to say that everything is wrong 344
Marius Kolsrud, later Institute for Theoretical Physics, Oslo. Marian G¨ unther later published a paper in two parts. M. G¨ unther, ‘The Relativistic Configuration Space Formulation of the Multi-Electron Problem’, Phys. Rev. 88, 1411–21 (1952); and M. G¨ unther, ‘The Relativistic Configuration Space Formulation of the Multi-Electron Problem. II’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1347–57 (1954). 345
April 7, 2009
236
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
because, for example, an integral which ought to vanish does not do so and in this particular case it turned out that he had merely shown that the integrand did not vanish identically as he had thought. As regards the use of this method, with pair theory everything is in a complete mess because he had carefully assumed that the S+ function (summing over positive energy states only) vanishes outside the light cone, which, of course, is not true. This means one needs a new idea and whether it can be done at all is now doubtful. Schonland has now evaluated the Scott and Snyder formula346 for the case in hand instead of improving the 7% discrepancy it increases it to about 20%. This may be due to some misunderstanding about density and composition of the emulsion and we are checking up on this now, because I cannot believe that the Williams formula which the Bristol people have used, can differ that much more from the correct result. But if it is confirmed, I would begin to suspect the method of Snyder and Scott.347 You will now have seen the letter by Bohr which I was not allowed to talk about before. As I expected it has not made a strong impression because it was not easy for the newspapers, with the best intentions, to sum it up clearly in the space they have. In particular the Manchester Guardian had a leader which was very unreasonable and I have just sent them a furious letter on the subject.348 Cockroft, whom I saw the other day, seemed quite shaken by your decision to go to Cornell. He seemed worried for one thing that your reply might be taken to indicate that you would have given a different answer if you had, in fact, been offered a job which involved the full responsibility of running the division, whereas he had made the sug346 H.S. Snyder and W.T. Scott, ‘Multiple Scattering of Fast Charged Particles’, Phys. Rev. 76, 220–25 (1949); H.S. Snyder and W.T. Scott, ‘On Scattering Induced Curvature for Fast Charged Particles’, Phys. Rev. 78, 223–30 (1950). 347 In his paper D.S. Schonland, ‘On the Utilization of Multiple Scattering Measurements’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 640–56 (1952), Schonland used the method of Scott and Snyder after Corson had confirmed that it was in agreement with experiment. Dale R. Corson, ‘Multiple Scattering of Fast Electrons on Nuclear Emulsions’, Phys. Rev. 80, 303–304 (1950). 348 Letter [506].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
237
gestion of being free to do your own work mainly to make the thing more attractive to you. I told him that it was not my impression that you would have taken the job either way but I feel you ought to know about this. He asked me whether, in general, we could improve our p[ro]spects of keeping young theoreticians in the country if there were more research Professorships. My reply to that was that I thought in your case this would not help because even if the job with the status of the Cornell job was created somewhere in this country you were likely still to prefer Cornell and that otherwise I did not know of people who have yet reached the stage where they would expect to get a Research Fellowship, though this may well arise in a few years time. If I have misrepresented your position on this I would be interested to know even if it is now too late to do anything about it. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[508] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 24.6.1950 Dear Professor Peierls, Tomorrow I am leaving Princeton for Ann Arbor, and so I think I may send you a report on what I have learned here. I was lucky in arriving here just before a large number of people left. Tomonaga says he has spent a profitable year here, not working very hard but enjoying his leisure and the relief from running a department and finding problems for numerous graduate students. The first months he spent in an attempt to combine his variational method of describing radiation fields (as he uses it in his papers on meson theory where the nucleons are treated as non-relativistic finite sources) with the covariant formulation of electrodynamics. He found this did not work out, he got into great complications of detail and could not see his way through, and so he never wrote the work up and finally abandoned it. Since then he has worked on the problem of describing the behaviour of a
April 7, 2009
12:11
238
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
degenerate gas of Fermi particles with strong interactions. (It seems that everybody has to have a rest from field theory occasionally!) He has found a method like that of Bloch spin-waves which describes the state of the gas as a superposition of sound-waves which behave like simple harmonic oscillators on Bose particles. The method is however worked out for the one-dimensional case. Also it is restricted to longrange interactions and may not be at all applicable to nuclear material. He says the relation of the particles to the sound waves is very similar to that of neutrinos to photons in the neutrino theory of light. For this reason the three-dimensional case is not to be handled by any simple extension of the one-dimensional case. He has written a paper on the one-dimensional model349 which is now being mimeographed and you shall receive a copy of it. Jost and Luttinger, also exhausted with field theory, have been amusing themselves about the Ising lattice problem.350 They have only succeeded in convincing themselves that the 3-dimensional case is too difficult for them. Jost now intends to go back and work some more on field theory, and he has some ideas which are good though nebulous. Case has written with Pais a very good paper on the analysis of the P − P and N − P scattering experiments in terms of the spin-orbit coupling potential.351 He seems to think the evidence for some such a coupling is now really convincing. I am sending you also copies of this paper. It seems that now Harwell can make a valuable contribution by doing some accurate measurements of the scattering, especially the P − P scattering at 150 MEV. I hope you can bring this to their notice. In particular the Case-Pais potential predicts a P − P scattering at 90◦ which is roughly constant from 150 MEV to 350 MEV at 4 millibarns per steradian. 349
S. Tomonaga, ‘Remarks on Bloch’s Method of Sound Waves applied to ManyFermion Problems’, Prog. Theor. Phys. 5, 544–69 (1950). 350 They had just submitted, together with M. Slotnick, a paper on pair production by photons. R. Jost, J.M. Luttinger and M. Slotnick, ‘Distribution of Recoil Nucleus in Pair Production by Photons’, Phys. Rev. 80, 189–96 (1950). 351 K.M. Case and A. Pais, ‘On Spin-Orbit Interactions and Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 80, 203–11 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
239
Yang has been continuing to play with the calculation of the SMatrix in the Heisenberg representation. Nothing very useful has come out of this. Placzek said the reports of his death had been partly exaggerated. He is, in fact, walking around and working, and seems in as a good a state as last year. They are staying here through the summer and living quietly because they are afraid his kidney may give more trouble, but at present it is behaving well. Placzek has been working all this year with a young Dutchman called Nijboer352 on the details of the interference phenomena in neutron scattering, even a lot of numerical work has been done. He and Else send you and the family all their best wishes. Skyrme you shall soon see and he will tell you what he has been doing. Karplus and Neumann carried through the calculation of the scattering of light by light and found it much more unpleasant than they had believed possible. It seems the results are of no possible value except as a warning to others who may want to calculate such things.353 Karplus gave me a report on the doings of Schwinger. He was working until 4 months ago on an attempt to formulate the whole of electrodynamics and carry through the renormalizations without expressions in α. Then Kroll found a simple mistake at the beginning of the whole work and so he gave it up in disgust. Since then he has become interested in making a rigorous formulation of the Feynman description of field theories using “sum over histories”. He has apparently translated the Feynman ideas into his own language and made them work both for Bose and Fermi fields. I have not seen the details of this. But I gather it departs rather radically from the Feynman method as Feynman uses it. Schwinger uses a method in which the fields are already quantized 352
The result of their work was published as G. Placzek, B.R.A. Nijboar and L.V. Hove, ‘Effect of Short Wavelength Interference on Neutron Scattering by Dense Systems of Heavy Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 82, 392–403 (1951). 353 Karplus and Neumann had just submitted their result which was published as Robert Karplus and Maurice Neumann, ‘Non-Linear Interactions between Electromagnetic Fields’, Phys. Rev. 80, 380–385 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
240
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
before the sum over histories is written down, and I do not know what use he then can make of the sum over histories.354 Schwinger will lecture on this work during the summer at Brookhaven. So I will hear about it first hand from Karplus later on. I think this is all I have to report on physics. You will be not surprised to learn that this year the Princeton group has been suffering from a feeling of frustration, just as some of us have at Birmingham. Indeed, there has been very little serious work done, and none of outstanding importance. Driving force has been entirely lacking. Oh, I forgot. I also talked with Van Hove.355 He has been thinking about the connection between classical and quantum mechanics and the foundations of quantum theory. He has clarified these questions quite a lot. But of course it is an abstract mathematical piece of work, and I do not know if it will have any practical consequences. Roughly he says in the classical theory define the Hilbert Space H of all squareintegrable functions of the position and momentum variables. The scalar product F G is just F Gdpdq. Now since by Liouville’s theorem dpdq is invariant under contact transformations, every contact transformation under pq is associated with a linear unitary transformation of H. Also, to every classical function K(p, q) corresponds an infinitesimal classical contact transformation in H, i.e. a Hermitian operator K in H. The correspondence classical function K ↔ Hermitian operator K is 1–1. Now the process of quantization is a projection of H on to a Hilbert 354
Schwinger’s work led to a sequence of publications throughout the early 1950s. J. Schwinger, ‘The Theory of Quantized Fields. I’, Phys. Rev. 82, 914–27 (1951), J. Schwinger, ‘The Theory of Quantized Fields. II’, Phys. Rev. 91, 713–28 (1953), J. Schwinger, ‘The Theory of Quantized Fields. III’, Phys. Rev. 91, 728–40 (1953), J. Schwinger, ‘The Theory of Quantized Fields. IV’, Phys. Rev. 92, 1283–99 (1953), J. Schwinger, ‘The Theory of Quantized Fields. V’, Phys. Rev. 93, 615–28 (1954) and J. Schwinger, ‘The Theory of Quantized Fields. VI’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1362–84 (1954). 355 L´eon van Hove (1924–1990), studied mathematics and physics at Brussels and received his Ph.D. in 1946. After three years of research at Brussels he went to Princeton and Brookhaven before becoming professor of theoretical physics at Utrecht in 1954. He later worked as leader of the theory division at CERN and at the MaxPlanck Institute for Physics and Astrophysics, before becoming Research Director General at Cern in 1976 (1976-80).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
241
space of functions of fewer variables (e.g. q or lg instead of p and q), i.e. onto a linear subspace of H. Van Hove is about so show: (i) that this process of projection is connected in a direct way with the “averaging over histories” of the Feynman method. And so he thinks he can make the Feynman method mathematically watertight. (ii) that the full space H divides in a natural way into a kind of direct product of two subspaces, either of which can be chosen as the subspace onto which to project. And in each subspace there is a set of coordinates and momenta. I do not understand all the details of this. But I thought you might like to know about it. I hope he will write is up before long. My best wishes to all the students of Birmingham. For the attention of Dalitz and/or Salam. Nobody here seems to have seriously tackled the question of whether a consistent renormalization theory can be made with a λφ4 term. They all thought Matthews had proved it could be done, and so they left it at that. Now for my personal news: I have now understood why it is that in the Lamb shift calculation one has to use a contact transformation of the form t ∞ −2 n 1 t − P (H(x1 ), · · · , H(xn ))dx1 · · · dxn S(t) = c n! −∞ −∞ n=o with the order of integration as written, in order to get an operator which really is unitary when you throw away all the finite oscillating terms at −∞. The proof of this is not difficult. At the same time this clears up completely the appearance of the Z 1/2 factors in the Smatrix, by a straight-forward physical argument. So the Karplus-Kroll argument to which you objected is now unnecessary. That is all I have done since leaving Birmingham. I will write it down and send you a copy some time.
April 7, 2009
12:11
242
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I look forward to hearing your news and seeing your quantization paper.356 But of course I do not expect you write at this length! This is intended to be a news-letter and you have full permission to circulate it if you think it is worth it. Yours Freeman Dyson
[509] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 27.7.1950 Dear Oppie, You may remember that we chatted last Autumn about our problem here of finding another Professor of Physics. In the course of this conversation you mentioned the name of Panofski357 as a man who might possibly be interested in such a position, and who would be very suitable. As you have probably heard, since then Oliphant has in fact departed and Philip Moon has been appointed to succeed him as Head of Department. We must now appoint a professor to succeed Moon. Moon himself is interested more in nuclear physics proper than in building machines, and it would therefore be useful to have another man who could play a strong part in the supervision of the cyclotron, which is now operating satisfactorily, and in helping to complete the synchrotron. However, at the same time we are trying to appoint another man of the senior staff whose specific duty would be the supervision of the machines, and there are prospects of finding a suitable man in this way. It is therefore not a necessary condition that the new professor should be machine-minded, but we have to consider the two appointments as part of the same problem. 356
See letter [507]. W.K.H. Panofsky (1919–), studied at Princeton and obtained his Ph.D. from CalTech in 1942; after wartime nuclear work, he moved to Berkeley before taking up a professorship at Stanford in 1951 where he remained for the rest of his academic career. 357
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
243
I am now writing to see whether it still looks to you as if Panofski might still be a candidate for our job, and if so, whether you would be kind enough to let me have a few words about him which I could pass on to our committee, or if you prefer, would give me one or two names of people who could give well-informed opinion about Panofski. To put this matter into proper perspective I ought to say that we are still at the stage where we are making enquiries fairly widely, and it is therefore too early to say with whom Panofski would be competing if he were interested in the job. I have an idea that a letter which I wrote to you last October never reached its destination.358 If it didn’t you must have thought me very discourteous for fading out without saying a word about the enjoyable time I spent with you at a time when you probably had many more things on your mind. I also wrote in that letter the story about our smallest child which we had just discovered. We have now had almost a year to get used to the idea and, like so many other things, once one finds out enough about the trouble it is not as bad as it seemed at first sight. Higginbotham has told me about your views and advice as regards the proposed conference between American and British scientists. Your remarks will be most useful, and their spirit is very close to what we had hoped would be the line taken by the meeting. I have no illusions about many concrete results to be expected from such a meeting, but I still think it would be worthwhile, and Uncle Nick’s open letter359 would provide some useful material. I only wish it could have been written in such a way that more than the select few could understand it. But then, of course, it would not be Bohr! Yours sincerely, R.E.P.
358 359
Letter [487]. See letter [507], note 348.
April 7, 2009
12:11
244
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[510] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Ann Arbor, 3.8.1950 Dear Professor Peierls, In answer to your letter of 19 June.360 (i) If the Williams approximation and the Snyder-Scott method differ by 20% I would certainly trust the latter rather than the former. But probably this trouble has been cleared up by now. I wish we had put more effort into these calculations while I was in Birmingham; looking back on the past year this seems to be my main mistake, I was always dividing my time between five or six problems and never sat down and concentrated upon one thing long enough to finish it. I hope you and Schoenland will now be able to do something with it. (ii) We had a colloquium talk the other day from Chandrasekhar361 on the multiple scattering of light in the atmosphere. Everyone agreed that this was a work of art, a masterpiece. He has solved exactly the integral equation for scattering in a plane atmosphere, including the direction and degree of polarization. And everything comes out in precise agreement with observation. I felt after this that if we had attacked our multiple scattering problem with the same determination we should long ago have reached an exact solution. Certainly our problem is not nearly so formidable. (iii) My course of lectures is now over and the notes will be mimeographed in a few days. They contain my new ideas so far as they have yet developed, which is not far. (iv) About my letter to Cockroft. I said “It is clear that I am too young to be given a position of real responsibility and working primarily on pure science, it is best that I go to Cornell where I 360
Letter [507]. Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar (1910–1995), nephew of C.V. Raman, studied in Lahore and Cambridge before joining the faculty of the University of Chicago where he stayed for the remainder of his academic career. 361
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
245
can work best.” He seems to have interpreted this to mean that I was sorry he had not offered me a job as Head of Division. Actually, I meant two things. (a) I had already told him when I was at Harwell before the Cornell job had arisen, that if I came to Harwell I would come to work on atomic energy and not to do pure science. Therefore I naturally expected that he would have taken this into account in making me this offer. (b) It was my own estimate of the situation that I was too young for a position of real responsibility. I still think this is true. Now he has written to me again, as you know, with the offer of the position of Head of Division. I wrote back saying that I would like to talk with Bethe before making a final decision but that the answer would almost certainly be No. I am becoming more and more convinced that I am right in not accepting the job. But if you have any criticisms to make, or advice to offer, I shall naturally be glad to listen to you. Concerning the question of keeping young men in England, I have nothing to say. Certainly the only thing that would keep me in England would be either (a) a clear and urgent call of patriotic duty, or (b) if Cornell should get involved in political squabbles of the kind they are enjoying this year in Berkeley. I do not think that more Research Professorships would really help in this respect. I agree with what you have said about this in your letter. (v) I am not yet married but am rapidly approaching that condition. So if all goes well I will be needing an apartment for 3 in Birmingham next January.362 It is, however, still uncertain whether Verena’s College can find a replacement for next academic year. If they can’t get one, she will be rather obliged to go on teaching there. Yours sincerely, Freeman Dyson 362
Freeman Dyson married Verena Esther Huber in 1950. daughter.
She already had a
April 7, 2009
12:11
246
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[511] Robert Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls [Princeton], 6.9.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Rudi, It has been many weeks since your good letter has been here.363 I have been away on New Mexico and I hope that my delay in writing will have caused you no trouble. Let me turn first to your departmental question. I still think that Panofski would be a magnificent choice. I am somewhat less confident that he could be lured away from Berkeley. I believe, though it may be a breach of confidence to write this, that he has been offered positions both at Harvard and at Columbia and has turned them down. I think he is quite attached to life in California. However, at the present moment, due to a variety of serious difficulties which have turned up at the University, this may be an auspicious time and I would encourage you to move quickly, if this is the direction in which you want to move. You ask who would write recommendations for Panofski. I should think that Macmillan and Rabi would both do very well on that. If you want a detailed appreciation from a theoretical side, probably Serber knows his work in greatest detail. I don’t know of anyone in this country who combines better than he does the appreciation of the problems of highenergy accelerators with a real understanding of the physics that can be done with them. I hope very much that the conferences to take place this month will be successful, both the conference at Harwell364 and your own undertaking.365 You know how much I would have wished to be there, but it did not seem like the proper moment for me to leave my modest duties here. I cannot, of course, hold very high hopes for the outcome of even the most earnest collective effort with regard to the problems of peace and atomic control; but I hope very much that I shall learn if possible 363
Letter [509]. In September 1950, a nuclear physics conference was taking place at Harwell. 365 Peierls was organising a second international conference at Birmingham in September 1950. 364
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
247
from you as well as from Placzek and Higginbotham what the views were. It would be good if Bohr came himself. You must be sad that Dyson has deserted you.366 He will have one year here, I guess, and then go to Cornell. Matthews367 has just arrived and I have not yet had a chance to talk with him. There has been nothing in physics which seems to me to constitute a real theoretical advance, as far as the work that has been going on in this country. It would be good to be able to talk of problems in physics with you. Both Kitty and I were deeply touched by your few words about your youngest child. We send Genia and you our love and our warmest good wishes. [Robert]
[512] Rudolf Peierls to Philip Moon [Birmingham], 19.9.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Philip, I hope that, in spite of the winterly weather, you are managing to get a good holiday and in particular you are getting a little bit of the rest you must badly need. I am now writing first of all to say that I have now a reply from Oppie which I enclose.368 You have probably heard about the trouble at Berkeley369 and perhaps it is not inconceivable then even a firstrate man might get fed up and might want to leave in the present 366 In 1951, Freeman Dyson accepted a professorship at Cornell, before, in 1953, rejoining the Institute of Advanced Study at Princeton as professor of physics. 367 P.T. Matthews was lecturer of theoretical physics at Birmingham between 1952 and 1957. He then joined Abdus Salam at Imperial College London and later became Vice Chancellor of Bath University. 368 Letter [511]. 369 The University of Berkeley operated what was known as the ‘speaker ban’, which allowed the university authorities of censor public speaking on campus. The censorship was largely, though not exclusively, directed against communists.
April 7, 2009
248
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
circumstances. The way in which Panofski’s work was referred to at the Oxford Conference does make one feel that if you could get him it would be a marvellous acquisition, both from the point of view of machines and of nuclear physics. On the other hand, of course, this would be bound to cause further delay. Since we talked at Oxford I have heard further rumours repeating the suggestion that Blackett made to you and indicating that Cockroft also seems to be thinking in that direction. I do not really believe seriously that this idea will be pressed and if it comes before the Nuclear Physics Committee of which, no doubt, you will be made a member, I think we shall have an ally in Chadwick. It does mean, however, that one should think out the problems and the future programme rather carefully so that we have the right answers available at the right time, but all this we can discuss when you are back. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[513] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 23.9.1950 Dear Professor Peierls, I am now installed at the Institute, having acquired a house on the Institute Housing estate. With luck I shall soon start again to do some work. I am sending you by ordinary mail a copy of some notes made by Goldberger for a lecture course on the latest Schwinger theory. These notes are very confused and difficult to read, but I believe they contain a lot of good ideas and one ought to take trouble to understand them. I think now, after 3 readings I understand them at any rate better than Goldberger does. In this new theory Schwinger does three things which I consider of first-class importance.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
249
(i) He translates the Feynman Lagrangian formalism with “integration over histories” into a rigorous and conventional language. And he makes it work also for Fermi-style fields. Thus the full strength of the Feynman method is now available in a more practical and convenient form. (ii) He has a simple and convincing explanation of the connection between spin and statistics, quite different from either Pauli’s or Feynman’s more complicated arguments. (iii) He has a way of treating electrodynamics which does not treat the four potentials as dynamical variables, and thus avoids all trouble with supplementary conditions. You have to search carefully to find how (i) is hidden in the notes. Of course, the name of Feynman is never mentioned. Only I happen to know from other sources (as is also obvious when you see what Schwinger’s method actually is) that Schwinger started the whole thing from the idea of making Feynman’s method intelligible to himself. As a consequence of (i), Schwinger is able to derive from the classical Lagrangian function simultaneously the equations of motion and the commutation-relations of a quantum field theory. I believe also your form of the commutation-relations will come out of this method in a natural way. Probably Schwinger will not avoid the difficulties you have found when the Lagrangian is not quadratic in the fields. I hope you will look into this.370 With the Schwinger notes is a paper by Placzek which may interest somebody at Birmingham. My own work has not progressed any further since we left Ann Arbor. I am held up by some mathematical difficulties which may not be easy to overcome. I do not think the whole method is so very valuable and important that it is worth while to present it to the world in a unfinished state. So I am letting it sleep for a few weeks while I think about other things. 370
Peierls was working on the commutation laws of relativistic field theory.
April 7, 2009
12:11
250
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
We have had some stimulating talks with Prof. Laurent Schwartz371 from Nancy. Probably you have heard of his ideas. He is a mathematician with a new kind of function-theory which is much better adapted to physical applications than the old kind. For example it deals with ∆-functions. So he has in fact made mathematically honest a lot of doubtful manipulations of field theory. He has not, of course, thrown any light on the main problems, real divergences and such. But he is a man with a good understanding and a lot of interest in these problems, and so he says he will look carefully and try to understand the mathematical situation lying underneath the “renormalization” theories. I hope he may do something worth while. In any case we shall continue to correspond with him. The Institute is just now waking up from its summer slumbers. There is no further news of general interest to report. My family is in very good state. Oppy was very pleased when I told him about your new commutation method. We just heard that my wife Verena is free from her job in Baltimore. They were able at the last moment to find a replacement. This is very good news. Now we shall definitely be able to come to England together about Dec. 23. We shall spend some days with my family in London and then move into something in Birmingham (I hope) in time for the start of term in January. Now of course I ought to be getting busy finding a home before the very last moment. Perhaps you would be kind enough to let me know what you think I ought to do about this. E.g. is it sensible to write at once to the University housing office? Or to put advertisements in the paper? I do not want in any way to saddle you with the responsibility of getting us housed. Verena is also interested in getting some part-time or occasional work in connection with the university. I do not know at all what possibilities 371
Laurent Schwartz (1915–2002), studied at Paris and Strasbourg where he obtained his Ph.D. in 1943. In 1945 he became professor at Nancy, before moving to Paris in 1953 where he taught in different institutions until his retirement in 1983.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
251
exist in this direction. She thinks she is in danger of getting very lazy, if she only has a house and a husband and a child to look after, and no regular job. Another question that arises is that of Katrin’s school. Here she goes to the township school, which is a good school and free, but of course she does not learn much. She is now 5 1/2, will be 6 next April. What school do you recommend us to go to in Birmingham? And should we start negotiating early to be sure of a place? All these questions of course need not be answered, if you think it is all right to wait until Christmas before dealing with them. In that case we shall be glad to deal with them ourselves in person. All best wishes to your family too. Thanking you very much for your letters, and for any information you may be able to give us. Yours sincerely, Freeman Dyson
[514] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson [Birmingham], 25.9.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, I have a very bad conscience for leaving your two long and interesting letters372 unanswered and even more for failing to send you my personal best wishes to your marriage. On the latter point I have at least the consolation that you will have taken the long letter from Genia as speaking on all our behalf and there was really nothing I could add to what she had already said. We are now all looking forward to meeting your wife and her daughter when you get them over. We hope it will not be too bad a shock to be transferred suddenly into the middle of an English winter. If you will let us know approximately when to expect you we shall look around for a flat which will at least mitigate the worst hardships. 372
Letters [510], [513].
April 7, 2009
12:11
252
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
About the correspondence with Cockroft, it was not my intention to persuade you to change your mind but merely to report to you what had been said to make sure I was not creating further confusion.373 I have now come to the conclusion that the best I can do to counteract the drift of young theoreticians away from this country is to try and create a visiting Professorship somewhere, I would hope Birmingham, which one could use to invite here for one year at a time the people who on the whole want to remain in America. I think there are good prospects of achieving this. If you have any ideas about people who might be interested in such an offer a little later on I would be glad to know. Now about physics. My progress in completing the proof of my method of quantization has been very slow and this, in fact, is the main reason why I have delayed writing to you. I always hoped I could send you the complete answer. At present the position is as follows: the method is consistent only if one can prove the inversion theorem. I have got a very transparent proof of this in the classical case, but on trying to extend this to non-commuting factors I have discovered that it is not, in fact, true as generally as I thought. That is to say keeping the order of the factors unaltered the retarded and advanced solutions which should be equal differ in fact by a commutator. This commutator vanishes by virtue of the commutation laws themselves, but this means one can only prove the consistency of the whole scheme and one cannot first establish the identity and then base the commutation laws on it. In this situation it would look more reasonable to think of a proof of the kind you have given, but I am reluctant to rely on this for two reasons. (a) because one then needs the Hamiltonian formalism to prove the consistency of my scheme and one then loses its main attraction, namely that one does not have to formulate a Hamiltonian to start with. (b) it is then necessary to prove the equality of the extra term in the Lagrange function and in the Hamiltonian to first order, even when this term contains derivatives or momenta. This follows, of course, if one uses your trick regarding the infinitesimal factor as a new dynamical variable, but I find it very
373
See letter [507].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
253
hard to see how this procedure can be justified. I have got some ideas of how to get around this difficulty but they are still very nebulous. Here many things are going well. Ravenhall’s work is finished, probably just in time to get this thesis in and the result is that the Breit terms are not correct to the order to which they claim to be correct when applied to the ground states of the helium atom. We are not yet sure of the exact magnitude of the difference but it seems certainly large enough to explain the observed discrepancy. Brown has shown how to do the same thing in configuration space and everybody now agrees about the result. Just now Brown has discovered an even more exciting use to be made of this new correction term but I dare not write about this yet since it is only two days old and needs confirmation.374 Butler’s work has come out very well too and he has now shown how one can use the result of the d − p reaction to identify the spins and parities of nuclear levels.375 In particular in the case of [. . . ]376 this leads to a result different from what everybody had assumed. No doubt Pais will have told you about all this. We also had some interesting talks with Ferretti. He has a new way of deriving the wave function renormalization terms that arise in your expansion of the S-Matrix. This is probably identical in content with what you have done recently, but it is put in a way which, to my mind, makes it[s] significance particularly clear. He has also got some nice results about how exactly the expansion in powers of the coupling constant breaks down when there are discrete states and he has derived an equation which formally at least contains the answer to this, so it remains to be seen whether it can be turned into a practical method. Schonland is still working on the scattering problem. On the point I mentioned to you last, it turned out as one could expect that there is no substantial agreement between the older theory of Williams and the
374 See G.E. Brown and D.G. Ravenhall, ‘On the interaction of two electrons’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A208, 252–59 (1951). 375 S.T. Butler, ‘On Angular Distributions from (d, p) and (d, n) Nuclear Reactions’, Phys. Rev. 80, 1095–96 (1950). 376 Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
254
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
formula by Snyder and Scott.377 The confusion has arisen because the Bristol people had evaluated the Williams theory in a manner which we still do not understand, but there is now still a disagreement in the constant of the scattering formula, not only between experiment and theory but also between the different experiments. Moreover, according to the Bristol experiments, the constant for protons seems to vary with proton energy. We are now looking to see whether there is any chance that the method used for evaluation, including the cut-off, could be reasonable for this. Dalitz has written up his work on [. . . ]378 for his theses and is now preparing it for publication.379 He also has some interesting results on Born-approximation (I don’t quite remember whether you knew already about these when you left; if so, I must apologise for the repetition). First of all in the formula for the scattering of electrons by nuclei he discovered that all results published as power series in Z were wrong except the paper by McKinlay and Feshbach380 which came to our notice only recently. Dalitz has found a mistake in each of the previous papers and obtained the correct formula which agrees with McKinlay and Feshbach and with Mott’s exact formula if correctly expanded.381 The point where most people went wrong arises from the presence of both virtual and real intermediate states in second order Born approximation and he finds that all this business can be made much more transparent if one uses Feynman notation. He has also looked at the ordinary non-relativistic Coulomb scattering where it is usually believed that although first order terms give the correct answer, the second order terms do not vanish but, in fact, diverge. To this a lot of philosophi377
See letter [507], note 346. Missing in carbon copy. 379 R.H. Dalitz, ‘On higher Born approximation in potential scattering’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A206, 509–520 (1951); R.H. Dalitz, ‘On radiative corrections to the angular correlation in internal pair creation’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A206, 521–538 (1951). 380 William A. McKinley, Jr. and Herman Feshbach, ‘The Coulomb Scattering of Relativistic Electrons by Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 74, 1759–63 (1948). 381 N. Mott, ‘The scattering of fast electrons by atomic nuclei’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A124, 425–43 (1929); N. Mott, ‘The polarisation of electrons by double scattering’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A135, 429–58 (1932). 378
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
255
cal discussion has been attached, but Dalitz finds that the statement is quite wrong, again because the role of real and virtual states was not properly understood. He will get rid of both these papers soon and then hopes to start on the problem you suggested, though he realises that by now someone else may already be well on the way. Field has nearly finished his problem and the answer seems to be identical with your result obtained by low-brow methods but he is at present checking this before making a final statement. Kolsrud is looking into the discrepancies in pair production. You remember that the Bristol people found disagreement as regards the energy distribution between positrons and electrons and there are other experiments reporting disagreements as regards the angular distribution. We are now satisfied that screening cannot be responsible for either of these and we propose to look at the effect of Born approximation but this is, of course, a long job. I think this is most of the progress as far as will interest you. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[515] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft [Birmingham], 16.10.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, Thank you for your letter about Luffman.382 I shall make a point on my next visit to talk to Luffman about this. Your question, however, prompts me to tell you the position of solid state work at Harwell. It seems to me that it is almost impossible to get any useful work done by having members of the present staff learn about solid state theory however good they may be. The trouble is that solid state theory is not 382
Letter could not be located.
April 7, 2009
12:11
256
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
a very rigorous discipline but a complicated mess of different methods which work in some cases and do not in others and to say that anything sensible one must not only know the literature, but also have a sound judgement as to what statements in the published literature one should or should not believe. It takes many years for even the best men to reach that stage. I am all in favour of allowing some suitable people to read about the subject because they will then be suitable to work under the direction of a more experienced man if and when you find one, but they will not be very much use as long as they are on their own even with such help they can get from part-time consultants such as Mott and myself. I spent some time talking to T.M. Fry and my conclusion was that it would be well worthwhile to make every effort to get such a more senior man on the theoretical side, even though he probably will not do everything that Fry hopes can be done. Fry seems to be somewhat optimistic about the reliability of calculations from first principles and of giving absolute interpretations to miscellaneous measurements. Solid state theory will always remain a semi-empirical science and the best that can be done is to discuss the experiments intelligently in the light of responsible theoretical speculations. This may mean that once an expert in that field has acquainted himself fully with the position there may be enough work to occupy all his time, but the answer to that should be to give him some freedom to branch out in more academic problems. The main thing is to have someone who is there all the time and who would have to give first priority to whatever can be done on the problems of relevance to the work in hand. When I last talked to you on this subject I mentioned the name of H.R.Paneth.383 He is now here on my staff and, while I am very glad to have him and expect him to be very useful here, I do not think I should recommend him for a job at Harwell where, for several reasons, I feel he would not fit in too well. This, of course, may change but for the present I am pretty sure he should be counted out. There are two men at present at Cambridge who deserve serious consideration: they are Dingle and 383
Heinz Rudolph Paneth (1926–2004), later known as Henry Post, son of pioneering radiochemist Friedrich A. Paneth, had worked at Montreal in Halban’s group.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
257
Sondheimer. Of the two Dingle384 is probably in the long run th[e] better man and more used to contact with experimental work. At the present he is still a little wild in the sense that he might quite happily investigate an effect which is 104 times too small to matter for the problem until someone else points that out to him. It is very doubtful, in any case, whether he could be persuaded to leave Cambridge. Sondheimer’s strength is perhaps more on the side of the more formal mathematical theory, but he is very good, and he has a varied experience. You probably know that he has just returned to a fellowship at Trinity after spending a year at M.I.T.385 Before that he also spent a year with Mott at Bristol who also speaks very highly of him. He is of German origin and I know that his appointment might therefore cause some shaking of heads, but he has just got married and that usually means that he might be more liable to succumb to temptations of a job at Harwell. I have not, of course, asked him and I may be wrong about this. I do not know him well, and you should not accept my opinion about him without support from other people, in particular, Mott and perhaps Sch¨ onberg. It is suggested that after Mott’s return from America he should meet me at Harwell to discuss the solid state problems and probably a decision would be left until after that, but it might be useful to think about the possibilities in the meantime. Otherwise, as far as I can see now, the main need of the theoretical division would seem to be to explore what theoretical work is required for the general programme of a long-range point of view. As regards pile and reactor programme, this would seem to be well in hand, though, of course, I would like to discuss the work in detail with Davison, Rennie, etc.. More exploration is needed in connection with fundamental nuclear physics and the cyclotron work and there Skyrme is making a good start. 384
R.B. Dingle had come from Bristol to Cambridge and worked, among others, with D. Shoenberg. He moved on to the University of Western Australia, before becoming professor of physics at St. Andrews University. 385 While working with Nevill Mott at Bristol and at M.I.T. Sondheimer had been working questions of conductivity in metals. His most recent publication dealt with this issue. E.H.Sondheimer, ‘The Influence of a Transverse Magnetic Field on the Conductivity in Thin Metallic Films’, Phys. Rev. 80, 401–406 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
258
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
The question must be answered whether the division should do something in parallel with Risley on the isotope plant and I believe some people should also think about the programme on which G.P. Thomson and Thoneman are working.386 I hope to see you next week in London or later, but I though[t] it might save time to put some of these points on paper. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls] [516] Claude Bloch387 to Rudolf Peierls Copenhagen, 26.10.1950 Dear Professor Peierls, Please find enclosed a reprint of a paper on a variation principle in nonlocal field theory. It is, of course, all unquantized, except for the free fields, where the quantization is rather trivial. As regards the quantization when the interactions are taken into account, I think that a method similar to that recently developed by Yang and Feldmann,388 and by K¨ allen,389 can be used. I would be extremely interested in learning your opinion about this procedure. The equations of non-local field theory can be written by means of local field functions only, if one introduces a smearing function. Thus, the interaction term in the Lagrangian reads g dx dx dx F (x , x , x )ψ t (x )u(x )ψ(x ), 386
For details on the work of the different divisions working on nuclear energy see R. Carruthers, ‘The Beginning of Fusion at Harwell’, Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 30, 1993–2001 (1988). 387 Claude Bloch (1923–1971), studied at Paris and received his doctorate in 1946. He continued to do research at Copenhagen (1948–51) and CalTech (1952–53), before joining the Commissariat ` a l’´energie atomique where he eventually became director of the physics division. 388 C.N. Yang and D. Feldman, ‘The S-Matrix in the Heisenberg Representation’, Phys. Rev. 79, 972–78 (1950). 389 G. K¨ allen, ‘Formal integration of the equations of quantum theory in the Heisenberg representation’, Arkiv Fysik 2, 371–410 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
259
in the case of a charged spinor field interacting with a neutral scalar field. The field equations deduced from the variation principle are ∂ + M ψ(x) = g dx dx F (x , x , x )u(x )ψ(x ), γ ∂x (1) 2 t ( − m )u(x) = y dx dx F (x , x , x )ψ (x )u(x ). Assume now for a moment that the right hand side of the equations (1) are known functions, the solution of the linear differential equations thus obtained is the sum of the free field and of a particular solution of the non-homogeneous equations. The latter can be expressed by means of a Green function. This gives ψ(x) = ψ m˙ (x)+g dx dx dx S+ (x−x )F (x , x , x )u(x )ψ)x ), (2) m ˙ + u(x) = u (x)+g dx dx dx D+ (x−x )F (x , x , x )ψ (x )u(x ). Here, S+ and D+ are the usual retarded Green functions, ψ m˙ and um˙ are the incoming fields, which are equal to ψ and u for x4 → −∞. (The latter statement is true only under suitable restrictions). The equations (2) are integral equations equivalent to the system (1). A similar system (2’) can be obtained by means of the advanced Green functions. It will contain the outgoing fields ψ out and uout . Clearly, (2) and (2’) define the outgoing fields as functions of the incoming fields (which may be arbitrary), or conversely. Quantization can be introduced by postulating for the incoming fields (or the outgoing fields) the normal commutation relations of the fields. Clearly, this is consistent with the field equations, which can be used to deduce the commutation relations of the other field functions. It can be shown that the outgoing fields satisfy also the normal free field commutation relations. Hence, there is a unitary matrix such that ψ out (x) = S −1 ψ m˙ (x)S,
uout (x) = S −1 um˙ (x)S,
which can be taken as the S-matrix of the system.
(3)
April 7, 2009
12:11
260
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Assuming that expansions in powers of g can be used, it is possible to obtain a formal extension for the n-th term in the expansion of the outgoing fields as functions of the incoming fields. In the conventional case, in which F (x , x , x ) = δ(x − x )δ(x − x ), it is possible, of course to go one step further, and to obtain Dyson’s expression for the n-th term of the expansion of S. In the more general case, however, I have not been able to deduce an explicit expression of S, and this makes the calculations of transition probabilities more difficult than in the normal theory. In fact I do not yet know whether convergent and reasonable results can be obtained for a proper choice of the smearing function F . At any rate, the general scheme seems to be very suitable for theories containing smearing functions, still, due to the lack of causality in the strict sense, the Hamiltonian formalism or the Schr¨odinger equation do not seem to be very natural approaches. I would be very grateful, if you could spare some time and let me know your opinion on the subject. Yours very sincerely, C. Bloch P.S. After the 30th of this month, my address will be: Claude Bloch, 10 Boulevard Barb`es, Paris (18e ).
[517] Rudolf Peierls to Claude Bloch [Birmingham], 1.11.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Dr. Bloch, Thank you very much for your letter390 and the reprint of your paper. Since I saw you in Paris we have made an effort to understand the physical meaning of the non-localised theory of Yukawa, but, while we see the consistency of the mathematics, I am afraid we have been quite 390
Letter [516].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
261
unable to see what it all means and, in fact, my feeling was [that] there is not even a theory but just some equations. We shall read your paper and hope this will help us to understand this a little better. In your letter you write equations which seem to me to be very similar to those of McManus, except that you have a smearing function depending on three points in space instead of two. This is an important point, because one would like to have such a function in order to make certain self-energy terms finite. However, we always believed that one would get into trouble with gauge invariance if in a product such as [. . . ]391 one took the two functions at different points in space. We are, in fact, playing with equations for a quantized theory which are identical with the ones you set out except for the difference in the smearing function, and we believe now even that we can justify them from some general principle that leads to quantized equations directly from an action principle without formulating a Hamiltonian. There are still, however, some mathematical difficulties which are holding us up. These difficulties concern the general principle and not the results. We are fairly clear now what the results will be and they will be just that not all the infinities are removed by this method, but as I said this has very much to do with the question of whether you have a smearing function depending on two or three coordinates. I hope soon to have the answer to the problem about the general principle and if I get that written up, I will send you a copy of it. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
391
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
262
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[518] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 8.11.1950 Dear Professor Peierls, I am sending you a copy of some work of Schwinger, and I enclose a copy of a letter to Bethe with some remarks392 which you might find helpful, among a lot of irrelevant material. Thank you very much for your letter to Verena which she is answering separately. Also I was glad to get news from Dalitz and Ravenhall. Please will you thank them. It will amuse you to see that once again Schwinger has been directly anticipated by Nambdu393 in a paper in Prog. Theoret. Phys. Vol. 5, part 1 published 6 months ago. But of course Schwinger has done a much better job than Nambu with the new method. Yours Freeman Dyson
[519] Verena Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 8.11.1950 Dear Professor Peierls, Thank you very much indeed for your kind letter discussing the possibilities of jobs for me. I am very sorry we are bothering you with such questions. But since we are so far away and since I should like to start working as soon as possible after arriving in Birmingham we are bound to do this. First of all you might like to know something about my education: Elementary and high school in Athens, Greece, where 392
Letter Freeman Dyson to Hans Bethe, 8.11.1950, Peierls Papers, MS.Eng.misc.b202, C.17. 393 Y. Nambu, ‘The use of proper time in quantum electrodynamics’, Progr. Theor. Phys. 5, 83–94 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
263
I graduated with the “reichsdeutsche Abitur” in 1940. From 1940 to 1947 regular studies at the University of Zurich. My main subject was mathematics, the first minor subject as usual physics, the second minor subject chemistry. I went through some chemistry and physics labs, and also through examinations in these fields as well as theoretical physics. I also heard some lectures in Astronomy and some of more general contents, my hobby at the time was logistics. In 1947 I made the PH.D. in mathematics with a thesis on group theory “supervised” by Speiser. Ever since then I was interested in research in abstract group theory, but I have never succeeded in doing anything worth publishing. In 1949–50 I was an instructor of mathematics at Goucher College in Baltimore. There I taught trigonometry, analytic geometry, calculus and advanced calculus. I am looking forward to having a job again, mainly because I find it healthy and satisfactory to do some honest, solid and definite more or less useful work. Furthermore I should like to be able to contribute to the financial support of our household, especially since we shall try to get a maid. From all the possibilities you mention the most appealing seems to me applied research. I think I would be adaptable enough for such a job. Surely I would not spare any efforts to do it well. I am not afraid of the dull part of it. I would like to learn something about the back ground and the meaning of such a work and this would make it interesting. As to teaching: I rather liked Goucher. But I understand that I would not be likely to find a place with the same advantages: small department, easy schedule, College level, and so forth. However, I still consider this as a possibility if nothing else could be found. As to languages, I know quite a few, but none of them really thoroughly: English, German, French, some Greek, Italian, little Spanish. On the whole I am looking forward to doing some work I have never done. Of course I wish to find a work which I start on the basis of what I have learnt, and through which I can learn some more about physics or mathematics. I am very much looking forward to our trip to England, and to meeting you and your family.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
264
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Again very many thanks and best regards also to Mrs Peierls. Sincerely yours, Verena Dyson P.S. In view of the short time left to us I shall be glad if you will accept definitely in my name any job which you think suitable, giving priority to applied research, second choice school teaching. If possible, a fulltime job would be fine.
[520] Rudolf Peierls to J. Rzewuski [Birmingham], 8.12.1950 (carbon copy) Dear Rzewuski, I have an extremely bad conscience because I know that I never wrote a reply to your long letter some time ago, both to send you our best wishes on your marriage which by now must be quite a well-established institution and to thank you for the very interesting paper by yourself and Rayski.394 In fact, in a way this paper was the reason for the delay because I thought I would write when I have had a chance to read this paper and make some intelligent comments, but life was particularly hectic at that time and I never got down to it properly. Meanwhile I have received your very interesting paper about the result of the McManus theory. We had, in fact, intended to do just the same thing and you have beaten us to it. As soon as we saw that this was a possibility of carrying the work out we also guessed what the answer would be and, in particular, that it would not remove all the infinities. I would have said that even the self energy of an electron would not come out finite, and as far as I have been able to understand your calculations that is also your result. The difference lies merely in 394
See letter [482], note 285.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
265
the question of terminology what exactly what one means by the self energy and what names one gives to other similarities. One reason why we were slow over this was that we always wanted to see whether the theory applied in this manner could be part of a consistent formalism and I had just succeeded in seeing a way how one could formulate the commutation laws in a way which was derived directly from the Lagrangian and did not need the definition of a Hamiltonian. If this method is applied to the McManus theory or for that matter to any other theory in which one can expand in powers of the coupling constant, then the results must lead to just what you have done, but by my more general method it should be possible to see whether the commutation laws which one obtains in this way are consistent and satisfactory and therefore whether the operators defined by this series really exist or whether one gets into contradictions. I have struck some trouble with developing this method further and, in particular, with proving what conditions must be satisfied for consistency, but I hope it will not take long to straighten this out and I shall then send you an account of the whole thing. The department continues to flourish: we now have a fair number of people interested in field theory who have learnt the modern techniques from Dyson when he was here last year and we are just expecting Dyson here for the remainder of the present session. He seems to have developed a new theory by means of which one can also treat bound states and therefore make a decent approach to the problem of nuclear forces. We have made one slight step towards the treatment of bound states by applying field theory to the problem of interaction of two electrons, for example in the helium atom. This has been done so far only to the accuracy of the Breit terms: already the next step beyond that looks very complicated, but it is very interesting to find that already in this order there is a correction to the Breit terms which vanishes for free electrons (i.e. for the Møller problem) but which is important in helium and which, in fact, seems to remove the discrepancy between the present theoretical values and the experiment. This is mainly Ravenhall’s work and he is now trying to generalise the method and apply it to other problems.
April 7, 2009
266
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I also enclose a circular which I have sent to all former members of the department. If by any chance you have a picture which you could let us have for the purpose if would be very much appreciated. I hope to hear from you again about your further progress. All the old members of the department send their best wishes. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[521] Robert Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 12.2.1951 Dear Rudi: Of all the many things of which we might write, it has come my time to write of the pleasantest. That is to ask whether in fact you wish to come to the Institute next year. I earnestly hope that your answer will be affirmative. We would be glad to have you for the whole academic year or for either of your terms. The formal terms will run from the first of October until just before Christmas, and from mid-January to about the first of April. We always hope that our members stay beyond the formal terms. You will know so much about what sort of place this is from your many friends here that I need not burden this letter with anything more than an assurance of our hope that you will come and a cordial welcome if you do. It would be helpful for us to know when your plans are clear, whether Genia will come with you and whether you will be able to bring your family, and what sort of a grant we might make to make your visit possible. None of this is urgent; but when the time comes, you must let us try to make your visit as agreeable and fruitful as possible. With every warm good wish to you both, Robert Kitty sends you both her love. R.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
267
[522] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 19.2.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Rudy: Thanks for your letter recommending Noyes. I would like to hear more about your trip to India395 if you have more time to collect your thoughts. Of course I constantly feel that I owe you a long letter about science but there always seems to be too much else in the way. This letter is to announce the visit of our family to Europe this summer, Uncle Joe permitting. If you are there and are willing to have us, we would like to visit you. As usual in our family we follow Napoleon’s principles and travel separately. Rose and the children are planning to go by boat and to get to England about June 1. They would like to come to you some time in early June, and they would like to stay for about a week, if you can accomodate them. I could imagine with the increased family, that space is limited even in your house. I am planning to come by plane about the middle of June and to spend about two weeks in England. One of these I would like to travel around and spend the other week with you. Again if this fits in with your plans. After that I was planning to go to Uncle Nick’s conference396 which I believe is about July 4 to 10. After that I would like to join the family in Germany. Please write me what your plans are and how you are fixed up for accomodation. We would all like to see you and to replace by a personal visit what is lacking in correspondence. With best regards, [Hans] 395
Between 14 and 22 December 1950, an international theoretical physics conference on elementary particles had been held at the newly-opened Tata Institute of Fundamental Research. Rudolf Peierls attended the conference and spent some time afterwards visiting, among others, Raman’s institute at Bangalore. 396 The conference took place between 6 and 10 July 1951, see Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/1, p. 339.
April 7, 2009
12:11
268
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[523] Rudolf Peierls Hans Bethe Birmingham, 28.2.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, I am delighted to hear of your impending visit. It will be great fun to have Rose and the children with us and I am sure we can manage to squeeze them into the house somehow. In fact, Genia is planning to take the children to the seaside for a week or two during June and if should so happen that Rose’s visit should fall in that period she might like to join Genia and the small children at a seaside holiday and the best, of course, would be if this were either at the beginning or at the end of that period so that Rose could also have at least a few days at Birmingham. As regards your own visit, you will, of course, also be most welcome at any time. I am also due to go to the conference in Copenhagen, and our plan is to take the car across via Ostend and to drive up to Copenhagen. I understand that the conference was to start on the 6th. We would probably be able to leave only on the morning of the 1st and cross on the 2nd. It looks possible that we should reach Copenhagen on the evening of the 5th. What would you think about joining us in the trip? I would, of course, hope that this would not curtail the length of your stay in Birmingham since all the other people here, including Dyson, would certainly like to talk to you. However, all these plans are subject to confirmation; it may still be that Genia might prefer to take her holiday elsewhere and I would in that case, go directly to Copenhagen by boat or by plane. Scientifically the most important result of the Bombay conference for me was that the Bristol people produced convincing evidence in favour of multiple as opposed to plural production of mesons.397 The point is that for plural production you would expect that for a greater number of mesons there should either be also a larger number of reasonably 397
See Report of the international conference on elementary particles, Bombay: Commercial Print Press, 1951.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
269
fast protons (“grey tracks”) or else if the energy should be completely dissipated a greater energy in the star formed by low energy tracks. They have looked for correlation of either kind and they are completely absent. On the average, for example, the energy in the star increases only by 55 MeV per meson produced and this is clearly not enough. I also learnt there for the first time about Fermi’s theory of meson production which is very attractive and simple as everything else that Fermi does. Whether it is right is another matter and I think particularly that his explanation of the angular distribution is rather fishy. Of course there was much more to India than physics, but to do justice to the many impressions there would take a pretty long letter and I shall leave it until we meet, I hope in June. Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[524] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 10.3.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Oppie, I owe you a reply to your very kind invitation to visit Princeton next Session. I did not write at once because I wanted first to explore the possibilities. May I say first of all how much I appreciate the invitation. I have considered my arrangements for next year and have come to the conclusion that I could not possibly get away for the first term. There are many reasons for this, one is that there will again be a fair number of new research students joining our group and while I have some promising young men on the staff I do not think I have yet reached the stage, where I can leave them to decide on the programme of the new men. Another reason is that our Professor of Pure Mathematics G.N.Watson, is retiring and there will be a new Professor of Mathematics starting next Session. Since the two departments are jointly concerned with the teaching of Mathematics students, I feel I should
April 7, 2009
270
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
be here to take my share of the responsibility at the beginning of the Session. However, it seems feasible for me to come for your second term which practically coincides with our Spring term, by that time the new men should have settled down and there is not much administrative work in the undergraduate teaching at that time. If, therefore, the international situation has not deteriorated in a drastic way it looks to me as if I shall be able to accept your invitation for the second term with delight. As regards the financial side it is almost certain that the University will grant me leave of absence with pay except that they might deduct any fees that have to be paid to lecturers that have to do my teaching while I am away, and as far as I can foresee other sources of income would continue also, with the possible exception of some fees for consulting work. I would not expect to bring my family to Princeton, but possibly Genia might join me for a few weeks, during my stay. You generously asked me what payment would be necessary to make the visit possible and this puts me into a difficulty; broadly speaking my commitments here, would probably use up my normal income so that what would be required would be the cost of my stay in the United States. I shall of course apply to the Fulbright Scheme for a grant to cover my passage and I assume that this will be granted, however, I have no knowledge of the present cost of living in the United States in general and in Princeton in particular, and I feel that you can probably judge this better than I can and I would therefore be grateful if you could fix whatever sum seems to you appropriate. I am looking forward with great pleasure to the opportunity of spending a term at the Institute and to a chance of refreshing my very inadequate knowledge of modern ideas. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
271
[525] Rudolf Peierls to Viscount Portal of Hungerford [Birmingham], 9.4.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Lord Portal, On thinking over our recent conversation I feel I would like to send you my comments in writing, both because this will allow me to add one or two remarks that did not occur to me on the spot, and because this will make it possible for you, if you see fit, to pass the letter on to the people who raised the matter in the first place.398 There are several different ideas that may have been in the minds of the security people when they drew attention to the position, and I shall comment on some of them though they may not all be relevant. The most obvious question is whether the reported accusations throw any doubt on my reliability. On this I cannot comment usefully, but I was very gratified to know, both from your direct assurance, and from the fact that you raised the matter with me, that you regard the answer to this question as satisfactory. There may have been doubt whether I was aware of the possible affiliations of the two men, and if I was not, whether I might inadvertently disclose to them any confidential information. If such a warning was intended, I am grateful for it, but would like to say that I did know of Prof. P. that he held extreme and rather dogmatic, political views; while I did not have the same impression of Dr. B. I would have hesitated to rely on his disgression anyway. But the main point is that whatever I thought of these people, I know enough about my obligations, and about the importance of the information I have access to, I would not dream of passing confidential information to these people any 398
As a result of Klaus Fuchs’ arrest, many British scientists were facing criticism over their links with Eastern European colleagues. In Peierls’ case, the allegations were particularly frequent, because of his personal contacts to Russia and his close links with Klaus Fuchs. In this case, Peierls was accused of having close contacts to two Birmingham colleagues, referred to here as Prof. P and Dr. B, both of whom were said to have communist affiliations.
April 7, 2009
272
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
more than to my many other friends who may be safe, but who are not connected to the project. Or perhaps there may have been concern that the political thoughts of these acquaintances might sow dangerous seeds in my mind. If a warning against this danger was intended, I am grateful for it, but I am not afraid of this danger. I have lived in many countries and discussed politics and principles with many different types of people. As a result I have developed my own views and principles, and I hold these with conviction. They are not easily shaken by propaganda. In fact, I believe it to be one of the greatest advantages of the democratic way of life, and a great source of strength, that we hold our beliefs from free choice, and after mature consideration of the alternatives, and not because dangerous ideas have been kept from us. There might also have been a suggestion (though I would like to stress that nothing in your very fair and reasonable explanation would support this inference) that my contacts with the two men in question was liable to be misconstrued, and that it would be better to disassociate myself from them. If there was any such suggestion, I would like to make it clear that I see no cause whatever to alter my personal relations with people. Almost anything one does can, in suitable circumstances, be open to misinterpretation; this is a risk one cannot escape. To these remarks I would like to add a comment of a different kind. The points you raised worry me because, on the face of it, the implication seems to be that of a very low standard of efficiency in the security services. It is quite correct that Professor P. is an old friend of mine, though I have not, in fact, seen him for at least eight months (outside university senate meetings, &c). But my association with Dr. B. is much more tenuous than that. He stayed at our house when he first came here in 1939 as a very poor refugee. About 18 months ago when their child was born, my wife tried to help and advise them on their domestic difficulties. As a result of differences in outlook which became apparent then, the two ladies have not seen each other since then. My own contacts with B. do not go beyond exchanging, on rare occasions, a few words about some topical news item. I mention these thoroughly unimportant facts only because they tend to show that the information available to the security services is
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
273
somewhat obsolete and not terribly significant. I would have thought there were a great many facts about me that could be made to look much worse. I would naturally assume that these were known, and regarded as innocuous, but I am now beginning to wonder whether perhaps they have not yet been reported? Is it known, for example, that, when we were in Cambridge, we were on friendly terms with D.P. Wooster,399 and spent a summer holiday with him and his family in 1937? Or that my wife is on very friendly terms with Mrs Betty Waddington at Cambridge, whom she has known well since about 1934, and whose views since then have shifted so far to the left that I believe she is now a member of the communist party? My wife still visits her every time she is in Cambridge, and when we go to Cambridge together I usually do as well. Is it known that I am acquainted with Prof. P.Y. Chau of Peking, from the days when we were both research student[s], and that, when he recently visited Birmingham as a member of the official “goodwill” mission on behalf of the Chinese government, he spent an evening at our house? Is it known that, when in 1949 we arranged an exchange visit which brought a Belgian girl to our house for a few weeks, and my son later to her house in Brussels, she turned out to be the daughter of the General Secretary (or similar high official) of the Belgian Communist Party? Is it known that I am well-acquainted with Dr. Gremlin in the Physics Department here, whose name appeared on the letterhead of the committee organising the Sheffield “Peace” congress? It is true that my social contacts with the Gremlins are not very frequent, but rather more so than with Dr. B. Is it known that I was greatly disappointed when the proposal to get Professor C.F. Powell of Bristol for our physics chair fell through, in spite of his reputation as a left-winger? Is it known that I had recently in my department two Polish scientists who came with scholarships awarded by the Polish government,400 399
Peter Wooster, a Cambridge crystallographer, and his wife Nora held pronounced left-wing views. 400 Jerzy Rayski and Jan Rzewuski.
April 7, 2009
274
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
and that we were on friendly terms with both of them, one even staying in our house for a few nights? I suppose it is known that my brother, like myself, has a Russianborn wife (this is pure coincidence); but is it known that, before she married him in about 1930, she was a secretary in the Russian Trade Delegation in Berlin? On the other hand, is it known that my wife is the cousin of Kannegiesser, a counter-revolutionary who assassinated Uritzky, who was then the head of the Russian secret police? With the same, very rare surname, she was never allowed to forget this connection. Is it known that her family was banished from Leningrad in 1935, partly because of this old connection, and partly no doubt because of her marriage to a foreigner. They have not dared communicate with her for several years, and we do not know whether they are still alive. I hope you will appreciate that this letter is not written in a spirit of complaint. I appreciate the great importance of security checks, and I have great sympathy for the difficulty in the way of such investigations, in particular in the case of intellectuals who rarely present a case without complications. But with so many facts in my case that could be open to unfavourable interpretation, if the attention of the experts is caught by just the two men in question, one naturally wonders whether they have missed many of the other facts, or whether they have a rather curious sense of proportion. Thank you once again for the frankness and courtesy with which you talked to me about all this. Yours sincerely, [R. Peierls]
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
275
[526] Rudolf Peierls to Herbert Fr¨ ohlich401 [Birmingham], 26.4.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Fr¨ ohlich, Thank you for your letter.402 May I say first of all how pleased I was that your election to the Royal Society has come through at last.403 About the other problem, I was meaning to write to you as soon as I knew you were back.404 The point is the following: in your treatment of the interaction of electrons with the lattice you are in fact writing down a one body problem, but because of the Pauli principle this results in terms which are essentially two-electron terms when you [. . . ]405 a statistical problem. We have set ourselves the problem, first of all of finding out what those terms look like if one writes down the equation for two electrons and also to see whether there are any other two-electron terms. We have already found the following facts: firstly if one transforms your terms into coordinate space they have the peculiar property that they do not seem to depend on the distance between the two electrons. In other words if your two electrons are represented by wave brackets, which are known to be 10 cm apart, the interaction term would be equally strong, as if they were close together; secondly there are terms which come only in the two electron problem and the most important of these can be described as one electron emitting a phonon and the other absorbing it. These, however, are not diagonal terms and if one restricts oneself exactly to first-order perturbation theory they are of no importance, however, one should not be pedantic about first-order 401
Herbert Fr¨ ohlich (1905–1991), studied in Munich where he obtained his Ph.D. under Sommerfeld in 1930. He left Germany in 1933, initially working in Leningrad with Joffe, before emigrating to England to work with Mott in Bristol. In 1948 he accepted a Chair at Liverpool where he remained until his retirement in 1973. 402 Letter could not be located. 403 Herbert Fr¨ ohlich was elected fellow of the Royal Society on 15 March 1951. 404 Herbert Fr¨ ohlich had been on leave at Purdue University, Indiana. 405 Word missing in text.
April 7, 2009
12:11
276
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
theory since one is dealing practically with a continuous spectrum, so that one has to consider cases in which the electron[s] have exchanged quite small amounts of energy. I believe now that if one takes such terms into account they should remove the apparent discrepancy and in that respect it is satisfactory that the discrepancy is important particularly for large volumes of metal when of course it is also particularly important not to regard the energy levels as far apart. At present we do not claim that the result w[ould] necessarily make any difference to the application of the theory, but I am fairly certain that an exploration of these problems will help one to understand what goes on. I am fairly confident that by our methods it will be possible to solve the two-electron problem with some simplifications but without assuming perturbation theory, but it remains to be seen whether this will throw sufficient light on the many body problem so as to be independent of perturbation theory for the physically important case. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[527] H. Fr¨ ohlich to Rudolf Peierls Liverpool, 1.5.1951 Dear Peierls, Many thanks for your letter and congratulations.406 I was very interested to see that you have ideas which might lead to an interaction which also depends on the coordinates in ordinary space. I felt that in a better approximation than I have used this should be expected. My reasons were as follows: Consider classically the interaction of two sources of a field. When the sources are at rest then the interaction no doubt depends on their distances only. When they move, velocity dependent terms have to be introduced which become increasingly important when the velocity of the sources approach the critical velocity of the field (velocity of sound 406
Letter [526].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
277
or light). In my case the velocity of the particles is large compared with the velocity of sound. The velocity dependent terms would therefore be expected to be very important. But nevertheless there should be some dependence on the distance in the approximation in which one does not neglect s/v entirely. I realise, of course, that this is merely an intuitive argument and not at all compelling. I am very glad to see therefore that you have better reasons to expect such a term. You may be interested, in this connection, that I have seen Wentzel and he appears to feel satisfied now that the main ideas of the theory are correct. I agree with him, of course, that one ought to find improved methods. The great difficulty in this case is that metal theory is essentially based on the hypothesis of free electrons (modified by periodic potentials only). The question then arises at what point exactly should one make this hypothesis. One might, for instance, make it for a Fermi distribution at absolute zero with any number of free vibrations excited. In this case, one would be concerned with the difference of the properties of other distributions from the f0 distribution only. I should like to have your opinion, if possible, on a further point concerning Bardeen’s interpretation of the magnetic properties. His argument is essentially based on his belief that in the case of very small effective mass the Landau-Peierls formula breaks down in such a way that homogeneous fields are not possible. I think however that his argument is wrong. The L-P formula can be derived from a calculation of the change in the energy of an electron gas due to the presence of a vector potential A; and the result can be written as 1/2|χ0 |(curl A)2 . Here, strictly speaking, A is a self=consistent vector potential and very nearly curl A = b and = H, for otherwise one would obtain the wrong Lorentz forces. In general the above energy is still to be corrected because it contains, twice, the terms due to the magnetic interaction. This interaction does, of course, depend on the macroscopic shape of the specimen. The simplest way of dealing with it is to consider the
April 7, 2009
12:11
278
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
case of a slab between poles of a permanent magnet, in which case the interaction is negligible. One then finds, immediately, that χ0 is not the susceptibility χ but rather χ = µχ0 or |χ| = |χ0 |/(1+4π|χ0 |) < 1/4π so that the contradiction which Bardeen believes to derive (negative µ) never arises. Yours sincerely, H. Fr¨ ohlich
[528] Rudolf Peierls to Raymond Priestley [Birmingham], 22.5.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Vice-Chancellor, I have discussed with Prof. Garner407 the question of an appointment in my department which raises a point of principle on which your opinion would be very welcome. The vacancy arises with the resignation of Mr. H.McManus, who was a lecturer in Grade II, his present salary being £650. His appointment was only a temporary one, the reason being that I knew he wanted a change and was going to leave as soon as he could find a satisfactory job elsewhere, but the job is definitely part of my establishment. I would now like to recommend for appointment Dr. R.H.Dalitz, who is at present a research fellow, his salary being £550 p.a. I have no doubt that Dr. Dalitz is a most suitable person for the job, but the question is what his salary should be. Dalitz is now 26. He graduated with 1st Class Honours in Mathematics at Melbourne in 1944, and with 1st Class Honours in Physics in 1945. He spent a short time doing research there, which led to two C.S.I.R. Reports on hydro-dynamic problems, and was then awarded a research scholarship that took him to Cambridge. He spent the two 407
Frederic Horace Garner (1893–1964), Professor of Chemical Engineering at Birmingham University, 1942–1960.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
279
years 1946–48 in Cambridge and the following session in Bristol, and came here as a research fellow in 1949. He completed last summer a thesis which got him the Cambridge Ph.D., and this work led to two papers which have been accepted by the Royal Society and will appear shortly. He is one of the best research men in my department, very mature for his age and is at the moment completely responsible for one graduate student and takes a great share in helping and advising others. In addition, under our customary arrangement by which research fellows also help in undergraduate teaching, he has for the last two years been giving all the lectures that we normally give as part of Honours Physics Course IV. These are the hardest courses in my department, because a lot of information has to be conveyed in a very short period of lectures to people not familiar with mathematical techniques, and Dalitz has acquitted himself very well; in fact, I understand from the physicists that of the five lecturers who have given these courses recently, Dalitz is the only one who has made a real success of this job. Dalitz himself is somewhat reluctant to take on a teaching job instead of continuing in his present research fellowship, and I can see that from his point of view to take on the extra teaching duties would be a sacrifice. I still hope to be able to persuade him to accept this if we can make it worth his while. It would not be reasonable, in any case, to ask him to take on extra duties without an increase in salary, and I feel therefore, we could in any case not offer him less than £600 p.a. I would very much like, however, to be able to offer him £650. This is still saving, since McManus, if he had stayed, would presumably have been entitled to £700 next year. In this connection it is relevant that a year ago I replaced a lecturer Grade II who was then leaving by an appointment in Grade III, so that the balance of seniority on my staff would not be unreasonable. The question of principle that arises is therefore solely concerned with Dr. Dalitz’s age. Incidentally, Dr. Dalitz is married and has two children. He is, of course, entitled to family allowance both as a research fellow and as a lecturer. I have discussed this problem also with Professor Moon, who knows Dalitz and knows in particular of the teaching work he has done. He is prepared to support the recommendation for £650 as an exceptional case.
April 7, 2009
280
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I believe Garner is going to talk to you about this case at the next opportunity, but the purpose of this letter is to put all the facts before you to save time. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[529] Robert Oppenheimer to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 27.8.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Rudi: I was very glad to get your letter of August 24th. Just three days ago I was in the office of the Science Advisor of the State Department listening to the many tales about visas in general and in particular, and I am concerned that nothing should interfere with your planned stay at the Institute.408 Your status here is that of a Member, analogous to a fellow supported by a foundation. The formal purpose of your coming is to enable you to pursue your own studies; the Institute makes and can make no formal demands whatsoever on your time. You are thus fully eligible to come on a Visitor’s visa, and I am attaching a formal statement indicating that we have been designated by the Department of State as a sponsor of the Exchange Visitor Program. The grant that we make to you is not a salary; and whatever great tangible or intangible benefits we derive from your being here, our grant and your coming are in no way conditioned by their realization. Quite recently, I have been told that you are coming next month with an official passport; and it has not been clear to me that it would be wise or even possible for you to use this for the extended visit next Spring. The Department of State 408 Rudolf Peierls, during the McCarthy era, on several occasions, had problems with obtaining the necessary visa for the United States. After problems in obtaining a visa for attending the nuclear physics conference in Chicago in October 1951, again his attempts to get the travel documents necessary to embark on his visit to Princeton in 1952 met with delays, but were approved eventually.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
281
is aware of our great interest in having you and our desire that nothing delay or interfere with your visit, and you must let us know if there are any ways in which we can help in bringing this about. My present plans are to attend the Chicago conference. But since I have kept almost no plans in the last months, I do not know with assurance that I will actually be there. I do very much hope to see you, both in connection with the basic problems which will be taken up in Chicago and in connection with the always important question of effective collaboration between our two countries. I hope you will arrange, in connection with this visit, to spend a little time in Princeton and to stay with us if at all possible. Allison has asked that I tell you of my willingness to join the discussion on meson theories at which you will be a chairman. You know, I expect, that I have no great clarifying light to shed; but you know me well enough to know that I am always willing to join in a discussion. With every warm good wishes from both of us to both of you, [Oppie] [530] Rudolf Peierls to Claude Bloch [Birmingham], 13.12.1951 (carbon copy) Dear Bloch, In Copenhagen you mentioned to me the very nice idea that an oper¯ 1 )ψ(x2 ) could be made gauge-invariant if one ator like F (x1 − x2 )ψ(x expressed ψ(x2 ) by the Taylor series and replaced in it the derivative by the gauge invariant operator, so that formally the expression becomes ∂
ie
¯ 1 )ex1 −x2 )( ∂xµ − e Aµ ) ψ(x1 ) F (x1 , −x2 )ψ(x
(1)
We have taken to the study of such theories again and I would therefore be glad to know whether you have published your suggestion and whether you would allow me to refer to is in a talk I have promised to give to the American Physical Society in New York in February. The following results may interest you. (perhaps you have already obtained them yourself):
April 7, 2009
12:11
282
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
1. The above expression can be evaluated explicitly and is essentially identical with ie
¯ 1 )e F (x1 , X2 )ψ(x
x
2 x1
Aµ dxµ
ψ(x2 )
where the integral in the exponent is to be taken over the straight line joining the (four-dimensional) points x1 and x2 . 2. It is nevertheless not possible to assume a Lagrangian of the form x ¯ 1 )γµ eie x12 Aν dxν ψ(x2 ) dx41 dx42 dx43 F (x1 x2 x3 )Aµ (x3 )ψ(x Le+Lf + (2) where Le and Lf are the usual free-electron and free field functions, since this leads to gauge invariant functions only if ∂jµ =0 ∂xµ
(3)
where jµ (x3 ) is the factor of Aµ (x3 ) in the action principle (2). 3. One does, however, obtain a consistent scheme for the action principle: x ¯ 1 )G(x1 , x2 )eie x12 A˜µ dxµ ψ(x2 )d4 x1 d4 x2 ψ(x (4) Lf +
where G(x1 x2 ) =
∂ γµ − im F (x1 − x2 ) ∂xµ
(5)
and F is an invariant form factor of the usual kind. A˜µ is a “smeared” potential ˜ (6) Aµ (x1 ) = Ø(x1 − x2 )Aµ (x2 )d4 x2 This second “smearing” process may not in fact, be necessary. It is easy to see that (4) reduces to the usual theory if F and Ø are taken as δ functions.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Resettling at Birmingham: Postwar Physics in the UK
peierlsroot2
283
We are rather attracted by the equation (4) and are proposing to investigate it further. I shall be in Princeton for the Spring Term, leaving this country on 4 January, so unless you reply before Christmas could you write to the Institute for Advanced Studies at Princeton? With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
284
7.
Birmingham:
A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
The 1950s were the most vibrant period in the history of Birmingham’s theoretical physics department. When Gerry Brown commented on his forced exit from the American academic circuit in 1950, he commented that with the benefit of hindsight his seeming ill fortune turned out to be great luck as he was ‘settled in the most stimulating theoretical group in the world.’409 That ‘Prof’, as Peierls was known and addressed as affectionately by many of his junior colleagues, was the core around which this active research community congregated, is evident in the extensive correspondence between him and other members of the department between January and April 1952, when he spent a term at the Institute of Advanced Study at Princeton. With Freeman Dyson’s arrival at Birmingham in the autumn of 1949, quantum electrodynamics arrived at Peierls’ institute, as Dyson at first lectured about the Feynman/Schwinger/Dyson results and later about new formulations of the old theory. Princeton was one of the nerve centres of the new developments. At the time, apart from its director Robert Oppenheimer, the other permanent staff members at Princeton were C.N. Yang, Abraham Pais, and Peierls’ old friend George Placzek. And in addition the departments of physics and mathematics with Eugene Wigner, Arthur Wightman, Menahem Max Schiffer and David Feller, and many transients at the Institute410 helped to create a stimulating research environment. As Sam Schweber recalls, during his time at Princeton, between 1949 and 1952, most of the presentations 409
G.E. Brown, ‘Fly with Eagles’, Ann. Rev. Nucl. & Part. Sci. 51, 1–22 (2001), here p. 7. 410 At the time among those transients were Francis Low, Murray Gell-Mann, L´eon Van Hove, Frank Yang, Bryce de Witt and Robert Karplus.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
285
at the Institute were at the frontiers of quantum field theory and in particular quantum electrodynamics (QED).411 QED, the theory of interactions of charged particles with the electromagnetic fields, describes mathematically interactions of light with matter, and also interactions of charged particles with one another. Following on from the Dirac Equations which represented motion and spin of electrons in a way that incorporated both the quantum theory and the theory of special relativity, Feynman, Schwinger, Tomonaga and Dyson further refined the idea and developed it more fully. Their theories rest on the idea that charged particles such as electrons or positrons interact by absorbing and emitting photons, particles of light that transmit electromagnetic forces. These photons are virtual, as their existence violates the conservation of energy and momentum. The interaction of two charged particles occurs in a series of processes of increasing complexity. In the early 1950s, the new developments in quantum mechanics had not been applied to two-electron interactions or to higher-order interactions between electron and proton in hydrogen. In 1951, Hans Bethe and Ed Salpeter at Cornell had developed an equation for these bound-state problems, and Gerry Brown also worked on a formulation of a perturbation theory for these problems.412 The letters exchanged between Gerry Brown and Rudolf Peierls, mostly dealt with the comparison of the work which Salpeter and Bethe had just published and Gerry Brown’s own progress.413 Schwinger, Feynman and Dyson had demonstrated how to eliminate infinities in the theory, and the kind of perturbation calculations, especially in the two-body systems of hydrogen and positronium which Salpeter and Brown were engaged in, also occupied many other physicists, including Robert Karplus, Norman Kroll and Francis Low. They were technically complex, but conceptually less exciting.414 411
Interview of Arne Hessenbruch with Sam Schweber, 27.8.2001. http:// hrst.mit.edu/hrs/materials/public/schweber interview.htm. 412 G.E. Brown, ‘Bound-State Perturbation Theory in Four-Dimensional Momentum Representations’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A215, 371–85 (1952). 413 See letters [532], [535–536], [538], [540], [543], [545–47], [549–50], [553–54], [557–58]. 414 See letters [535], [538], [540], [550], [554–55], [557].
April 7, 2009
12:11
286
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
More conceptually significant were some other theoretical considerations tackled at Birmingham (and elsewhere), after the techniques and formalisms of the new QED approach had been mastered. Some of the letters sent between Birmingham and various American universities, pointed to the new avenues which were being explored in the wake of these field theoretical developments. Among those were problems arising from Rayleigh Scattering, and the calculation of the Lamb-Shift in heavy atoms. Philip Moon, at the time professor of experimental physics at Birmingham, had been scattering γ-rays coherently off complex nuclei, both intermediate and heavy. John Woodward, assistant lecturer at Peierls’ department, and Gerry Brown developed a theory which was to explain some the phenomena encountered by Moon. Woodward had been using Thomas-Fermi-approximations for the purpose, but it became clear that rather than treating the electrons closest to the nucleus as a Fermi gas, their replacement by their relativistic Dirac wave functions, might be more promising. Brown had used such relativistic electrons in his doctoral work with Gregory Breit.415 Their work, which received a lot of input from ‘Prof’, is discussed extensively in the correspondence.416 W. Franz in the 1930s had worked out the form factor for Rayleigh scattering, the cross section to lowest order in an expansion in Zα.417 Brown, however, worked out that the next term of higher order in Zα was larger than Franz’s calculations suggested for higher γ-ray energies, which went against scientists’ preconceptions that with an increase in the incident energy the expansion in Zα should converge more rapidly.
415
Brown had published four papers while working on his Ph.D. with Breit at Yale. G. Breit and G.E. Brown, ‘Effect on Nuclear Motion on the Fine Structure of Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev.74, 1278–84 (1948); G. Breit, G.E. Brown and G.B. Arfken, ‘The Effect on Nuclear Motion on the Hyperfine Structure of Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1299–1304 (1949); G.E. Brown and G.B. Arfken, ‘Effects of the Proton Radius on Nuclear Motion Correction for the Hyperfine Structure of Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1305–1306 (1949); and G. Breit and G.E. Brown, ‘Perturbation Methods for Dirac Radial Equations’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1307–1310 (1949). 416 See letters [532], [536], [538], [546], [554]. 417 W. Franz, ‘Rayleighsche Streuung harter Strahlung an schweren Atomen’, Z. Phys. 98, 314–20 (1935). See letter [540].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
287
Peierls later commented that this was ‘almost a classical case of a theoretical surprise’, when he described the problem in his Surprises in Theoretical Physics, a collection of physical problems where plausible expectations are not borne out by careful analysis.418 In fact, this ‘surprise’ presented Peierls with a good opportunity to reinforce collaboration with his close friend Hans Bethe. Having briefly met him at the Rochester Conference early in January 1952, he visited him at Cornell later in the month, among others to discuss the Brown/Woodward work.419 Bethe had calculated the Rayleigh scattering in impulse approximations in order to explain experimental results which Bob Wilson at Cornell had obtained.420 The discussions with him and also with Joseph Levinger who had an interest in the problem, were fruitful and encouraged by regular feedback from ‘Prof’, Brown and Woodward drafted a paper which explained why the main contributions to Rayleigh Scattering came from closer to the nucleus as (∆x)2 became larger.421 Another quantum field theoretical problem tackled by Peierls concerned the development of a non-localised theory, a theory spaced out in time as well as in space. Translating the equations, which worked satisfactorily in the classical framework, into quantum theory required the introduction of quantum rules which did not exclude ‘non-local theories’. Peierls and his Swiss post-doc Max Chr´etien investigated the problem and discussed it in detail with Claude Bloch, Wolfgang Pauli and J. Valatin.422 As the correspondence indicates, their progress led to the publication of two joint papers on these non-local theories.423 418
R.E. Peierls, Surprises in Theoretical Physics, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1970. 419 Letter [538]. 420 R.R. Wilson, ‘Scattering of 1.33 MeV Gamma Rays by an Electric Field’, Phys. Rev. 90, 720–21 (1953). 421 G.E. Brown and J.B. Woodward, ‘Coherent Scattering of Gamma Rays by Bound Electrons’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 977–80 (1952). 422 See letters [533–34], [537], [542], [548, 551, 556, 561, 563–64, 566–70, 573, 584–89, 591–92]. 423 M. Chr´etien and R.E. Peierls, ‘Properties of Form Factors in Non-Local Theories’, Nuovo Cimento 10, 668–76 (1953); M. Chr´etien and R.E. Peierls, ‘A study of gaugeinvariant non-local interactions’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A223, 468–81 (1954).
April 7, 2009
12:11
288
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
If Peierls had been concerned about the effect of his temporary absence on the well-being of the department, his worries would have been dispelled by the comment of Gerry Brown about two months into the former’s absence: ‘I’m not anxious for you to get back from the States’, he writes, ‘because the information you’ve been passing on has been a tremendous spur in getting a lot of things cleared up’.424 Most other letters which Peierls exchanged with colleagues at Birmingham and elsewhere concerned these and other questions of quantum field theory. But the Princeton-Birmingham correspondence also reflects the second leg on which Peierls’ department stood, namely the training of undergraduate and graduate students. His younger colleagues had stood in for lectures, and while Peierls left them the freedom to design and alter the lectures freely, he was approached for and happily gave advice on methodology and examinations.425 More importantly he continued to oversee the progress of more advanced students (Sheila Brenner, John Radcliffe, P.G. Harper,) by communicating with them directly and through their temporary advisers, Gerry Brown, Dick Dalitz, or George Kynch to ensure that they would not be disadvantaged by his decision to pursue more actively his own research at Princeton. Peierls’ communications with Dick Dalitz demonstrate that ‘Prof’ was keen for his junior colleagues to participate actively on the international research scene, as he advised and encouraged Dalitz to consider spending some time in the US,426 while balancing the needs of the individual staff member with the smooth running of the department. For Peierls, his stay at Princeton did not only allow him to participate in stimulating exchange at the cutting edge of his discipline; it also provided him with uninterrupted time to think and calculate, which was exactly what was needed to complete the project which he was working on himself. He was looking for a new expression of some of the basic rules of quantum mechanics, namely the formulation of commutation laws of relativistic field theory. Heisenberg and Pauli had formulated a consistent formulism for quantum field theory more than twenty years 424
Letter [554]. See particularly letters exchanged with Gerry Brown. 426 Letters [539], [541]. 425
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
289
earlier.427 However, they had used the Hamiltonian form of the field equations to construct pairs of canonically conjugate variables, and as the Hamiltonian form of the equation was linked to a choice of the time axis, the Lorentz-invariance of the formulation was not evident. Alternative approaches based on ‘interaction representation’, such as those formulated by Tomonaga428 , Schwinger429 and De Wet430 had similar limitations, and Peierls attempted to formulate a general rule for obtaining commutators for any two points in space and time. In March 1952, Peierls reported about his progress to Dirac with whom he had written a paper on Lorentz invariance in quantum theory a decade earlier.431 The previous two months of concentrated work had led to the construction of Poisson Brackets, related to the action principle but not requiring the introduction of canonical variables.432 This permitted the laws for forming the commutators of canonical theory as well as the anticommutators of Fermi-Dirac particles to be stated in a covariant way.433 However, while the commutation laws could be applied to theories in which there was no Hamiltonian, there was not guarantee that it was anti-commutative, i.e. that the identity [a,b] = −[b,a] was satisfied. When the paper was published later in 1952, Wolfgang Pauli queried a number of important details, which led to a lengthy exchange of views. Pauli had become interested in non-local field theories during discussions at Copenhagen in June 1952, and after his return from a trip to
427
W. Heisenberg and W. Pauli, ‘Zur Quantenmechanik der Wellenfelder’, Z. Phys. 56, 1–61 (1929); W. Heisenberg and W. Pauli, ‘Zur Quantenmechanik der Wellenfelder II’, Z. Phys. 59, 168–90 (1930). 428 S. Tomonaga, ‘On a relativistically Invariant Formulation of the Quantum Theory of Wave Fields’, Progr. Theor. Phys. 1, 27ff. (1946). 429 J. Schwinger, ‘Quantum Electrodynamics. I. A Covariant Formulation’, Phys. Rev. 74, 1439–61. 430 J.S. de Wet, ‘The interaction representation in the quantum theory of fields’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A201, 284–96 (1950). 431 R.E. Peierls, P.A.M. Dirac and M.H.L. Pryce, ‘On Lorentz invariance in the quantum theory’, Proc. Cambr. Phil. Soc. 38, 193–200 (1942). 432 Letters [552], [555]. 433 R.E. Peierls, ‘The commutation laws of relativistic field theory’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A214, 143–57 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
290
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
India434 he took up the problem more energetically, which is evident in his correspondence with Peierls as well as with Møller and Bloch.435 By January 1953, Peierls could send a proof of the Jacobi Identity, which Pauli has been urging him to provide, 436 but Pauli remained sceptical. In March 1953, in a presentation at the Turin Conference on non-local theories,437 he was very pessimistic about the theory, and on his return from Turin he wrote to Peierls. ‘For me it looks like a cemetery for the lorentzinvariant formfactor theory in its present form.’438
434
Letters [584–589]. See Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/1. 436 Letter [584]. 437 W. Pauli, ‘On the Hamiltonian structure of Non-Local Field Theories’, Nouvo Cimento 10, 648 (1953). 438 Letter [591]. 435
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
291
[531] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Princeton], 14.1.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, I saw Dyson at the Rochester conference last week.439 To my great surprise he seems to have lost interest in his programme for treating divergence, and partly he seems to feel that all that can be done with his technique could be done more simply with the Bethe-Salpeter equation. I tried to question him a little about his reaction to Salam-Matthews440 but he just did not know anything about their calculation. He did, however, agree that to do a one-particle problem properly in his scheme, one would have to solve first the vacuum problem and then the vacuum plus one particle, and where necessary, subtract the two. Of all this, I think the most important is the remark that a solution to the same problem is contained in the Bethe-Salpeter equation. If that is true it would probably not be wise to invest much further effort in the Dyson (or ex-Dyson) programme. However, I think we would need a better understanding of the B.S. equation before we could be sure. I hope to find out more about this and shall, of course, let you know. There was a lot of interest at Rochester. The conference notes are supposed to be written up within a week (authors Noyes and Messiah441 ) and a copy will be sent to Birmingham, so I need not go into detail, but I shall try to bring out a few important points. I shall include where relevant what I learnt at Bristol, since I never had a chance to tell you properly about that. Firstly about π and π o mesons. The most interesting results are by Anderson (Chicago) and Steinberger (Columbia) about scattering by 439
Second Annual Rochester Conference on Meson Physics 11.–12.1.1952. Abdus Salam and P.T. Matthews had published a paper which discussed the extension of Dyson’s proof of finiteness after renormalization of matrix elements for scattering processes to certain meson interactions. See P.T. Matthews and Abdus Salam, ‘The Renormalization of Meson Theories’, Rev. Mod. Phys. 23, 311–14 (1951). 441 A.M.L. Messiah and H.P. Noyes, ‘Proceedings of the Rochester Conference on Meson Physics, January 11–12, 1952’, Rochester University Technical Report, (1952). 440
April 7, 2009
12:11
292
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
hydrogen. It is confirmed that the cross section rises with energy, the total cross section going from about 21 millibarns at 89 MeV to 60 mb at 217 MeV for negative mesons, and from 20 mb at 56 MeV (50 at 82) to 152 at 135 Mev for π + . The puzzling feature is that the scattering of positives is larger and rises more steeply with energy.442 In the case of π − gamma rays were found, which indicate a (π−, π 0 ) reaction. By measuring at 90◦ the cross section for pure scattering at 112 MeV was estimated to be σ(π − , π − ) ∼ 13mb, while σ(π − , π 0 )25mb. In the same circumstances the (π − , π + ) cross section is near 100. Fermi points out that these three cross sections are not far from the ratio 1:2:9, which could be interpreted according to the following picture. Assume the forces to be charge symmetric. Then the total isotopic spin is a good quantum number in this reaction. A nucleon having isotopic spin 1 1 2 , and a meson 1, we are then dealing with states of total T = 2 or 3/2. In the collision of a positive meson with a proton we have in fact a pure state 3/2, in the other case a mixture. Now suppose that the interaction is strong only for T = 3/2 and negligible for 12 . Then one would have to resolve the state of H + π − into states of given T , and the state of T = 3/2 then should have a cross section as large as in the positive case. The scattered wave is then again resolved into positive and neutral mesons. The answer to this is, of course, unique and gives just 1:2:9. Next one asks why the interaction is so strongly dependent on isotopic spin and a suggestion is that there might exist isobaric states, as in the strong-coupling theory, except that, if the coupling is not strong, they would be rather wide. The phenomenon would therefore be a kind of broad resonance with a T = 3/2 virtual level of the system. The experiments show, in fact, that the negative cross section flattens off near 200 MeV, and with enough imagination one can in fact see it going 442
H.L. Anderson, E. Fermi, E.A. Long, R. Martin and D.E. Nagle, ‘Total Cross Section of Negative Pions in Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev. 85, 934–35 (1952), H.L. Anderson, E. Fermi, A. Lundby, D.E. Nagle and G.B. Yodh, ‘Ordinary and Exchange Scattering of Negative Pions by Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev. 85, 935–36 (1952), H.L. Anderson, E. Fermi, E.A. Long, R. Martin and D.E. Nagle, ‘Total Cross Section of Positive Pions in Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev. 85, 936 (1952), C. Chedster, P. Isaacs, A. Sachs and J. Steinberger, ‘Total Cross Sections of pi-Mesons and Several Other Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 82, 958–59 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
293
down again. This maximum is not, however, a very direct indication of a resonance level, since one assumes anyway that the interaction is mainly in p states (in order to get the rapid rise with energy) and if one had no other waves contributing, a p state gives, of course, first a rise and then a fall because of the 12πχ2 limit. Brueckner reported some calculation fitting the resonance formula of the Breit-Wigner type, and obtained an energy and a width from it (resonance energy 137 MeV in centre of mass system) but I do not believe it means much. Because these facts support the concept of an isobaric state, Wentzel dug out the old strong-coupling theories again and he is trying to apply them, but I do not think one could do that. Now about heavier animals. It is clear there exists neutral V which decays into a proton and a negative particle which probably is a π − . It is now fairly probable, but not yet certain, that there is no other particle and that the energy release is in the neighbourhood of 75 MeV. The actual number 75 comes from Leighton443 at Cal Tech who has a very good set-up for getting lots of particles and measuring them accurately. However, according to the Manchester group, there exists in addition a second type of V particle, called V20 in Manchester, and v at the Rochester Conference, which is supposed to decay into two charged mesons. Leighton disagrees with this now strongly, but claims instead a second group of particles, which also gives a homogeneous value for the energy release if interpreted as decaying into a proton and a π − . Leighton would probably interpret the cases where the positive was seen to be light, as involving a negative proton. This second group has a reaction charge of 34 MeV, and in this group it is only the negatives (i.e. mesons) which are ever seen to be slow, which is very hard to understand. There is therefore doubt whether the lighter V (or v) exists. On the other hand, the Bristol people now find plenty of Kρ . In very energetic showers which are mainly two-nucleon collisions (seen in the plate as having few or no low-energy nucleons) they seem to be generated as frequently as πρ . 443
R.B. Leighton, S.Dean Wanlass and William L. Alford, ‘On the Decay of Neutral V -Particles’, Phys. Rev. 83, 843–85 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
294
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Also the existence of τ has become more certain. There are now six cases known in photographic plates, and Cal Tech have two cloud chamber pictures of a triple decay into similar particles in flight. Oppenheimer stressed the difficulty of explaining the comparatively long life of all three particles together with their copious production and Pais has an approach to systematise this. He supposes that particles in families, one family being the nucleon, which he calls N0 , the heavier V -particle which he calls N1 , and there might be more. This evidently goes with the picture of isobaric states, except that N1 must be at a much higher energy, and live much longer, than the level mentioned before. The second family is firstly the π, which for this purpose he calls π0 (regardless of charge) and the controversial v, which becomes π1 . Again there are presumably other members of this family. Now Pais postulates that all strong interactions, which must in general be of the form (Ni , Nj , Nk ) are limited by the requirement that i + j + k be even. This includes for the case (0,0,0) the ordinary Yukawa interaction, the case (0,1,1) which leads to the simultaneous production of V and v in the same collision, and (1,1,0) which produces a virtual transition of a neutral [..] into two V ’s and hence leads to the usual [..] decay.444 If only such interactions are permitted, then V and v are stable. One can now add a much weaker coupling which comes in the case when i+j+k is odd. For this the g2 /hc would have to be about 10−11 .445 The attractive feature of this scheme is that no complicated calculation is needed to show that the lifetimes can really be made long enough to any order of approximation, since the restriction on the matrix ele[m]ents that has been imposed has a group property and higher orders cannot bring any surprises. Still, of course, it is building a very large structure of ideas on a few uncertain facts! With kindest regards, Yours [R.E. Peierls]
444 445
Missing in carbon copy. A. Pais, ‘Some Remarks on V -Particles’, Phys. Rev. 86, 663–72 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
295
[532] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 14.1.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Jerry, I have just arrived here at the Institute, and so my holiday is really beginning. I have obviously not yet been able to do anything about your various errands. I also have not yet finished reading your paper,446 but I gather that Salpeter is interested in rather similar problems.447 I am therefore sending your MS to him, which I hope is o.k. with you, but I shall tell him to be ready to send it back to you at short notice if you want it back. Otherwise it will come back to me and I shall then send it on with any comments I have about editing &c. I also hope to send the hydrodynamics paper.448 On the boat I played a little more with the non-local equations, particularly from the point of view of defining anything without the series expansion. This main point is that I now think one should first look at the case of electrons in an external field, without bringing in the quantized field. In such a case one cannot, of course, talk about self-energy, but one can discuss vacuum polarization (and hence photon self-energy) and it is not a trivial case. In this case, the wave equation is still linear in the ψ ’s and the nature of the general solution of the inhomogeneous equations that we need for the commutators is quite straightforward. In particular, the commutators themselves will not depend on the wave function, and the usual interpretation of ψ, ψ as emission and absorption 446
G.E. Brown, ‘Bound-State Perturbation Theory in Four-Dimensional Momentum Representation’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A215, 371–85 (1952). 447 After the progress of Schwinger, Feynman, Tomonaga and Dyson on quantum electrodynamics, one of the research foci was that of two-electron interactions or higher-order interactions between electron and proton in hydrogen. Ed Salpeter and Hans Bethe had applied Feynman’s S-matrix formalism to the bound-state problem for two interacting Fermi-Dirac particles. See E.E. Salpeter and H.A. Bethe, ‘A Relativistic Equation for Bound-State Problems’, Phys. Rev. 84, 1232–42 (1951). 448 Gerry Brown was lecturing the hydrodynamics course for which the examination paper had to be prepared.
April 7, 2009
12:11
296
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
operators is still correct. The problem of finding a basic set of operators which are simultaneously measurable now reduces to an ordinary, non-unitary transformation, whose properties I have not yet completely sorted out. It seems to me that one should not tackle the case of a quantized field before this similar problem is clear, and perhaps too optimistically, that if we have solved the simpler problem we ought to see a way to get at the bigger one. I saw Bethe at Rochester, and shall probably be at Cornell on Jan. 30. He was interested in the present state of Woodward’s work449 and your argument that the first-order terms should be larger than the zeroorder ones for hard gamma-rays. He pointed out that, apart from the factors brought in by the matrix elements, the first-order terms contain an energy denominator, which goes through zero. The singularity arising from this is, of course, not serious, but since this means the term will be sometimes positive and sometimes negative, the result may still come out fairly small. I have looked at it again, and it does not look very plausible. But one cannot be sure until the integration has been done. They have not done much more about this problem, except to notice that the imaginary term in the scattered amplitude (which arises from the possibility of photoeffect, and, in the forward direction [· · · ]450 is important. If you and Chr´etien451 know anymore about non-local equations before Jan 31., or Woodward about scattering before Jan. 30. let me know.452 449
John Woodward, studied mathematical physics at Birmingham and obtained his Ph.D. under Peierls. He became assistant lecturer, and was working on the theory of scattering γ-rays. 450 Line cut off in carbon copy of the letter. 451 Max Chr´etien, postdoctoral research visitor at Birmingham who eventually moved from physics into computer sciences. He was associate professor for computer science at Brandeis University. 452 Brown and Woodward later published the results as G.E. Brown and J.B. Woodward, ‘Coherent Scattering of Gamma Rays by Bound Electrons’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 977–80 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
297
I enclose a letter, mainly for Dalitz, which however will interest you, too. I shall write to Sheila Brenner453 in a day or so, I would like to take another look at the programme for the summer school before replying. Keep you powder dry and the hydrodynamics wet. Yours, [R. Peierls]
[533] Claude Bloch to Rudolf Peierls Pasadena, 18.1.1952 Dear Professor Peierls, I thank you very much for your interesting letter.454 I am very sorry that it was delayed a long time in Paris, so that my answer comes very late. About the formula involving ie
e
x
2 x1
Aµ dxµ
,
(1)
I should perhaps mention to you that a similar expression has already been given by Sachs (Phys. Rev. 74, 433)455 in connection with the phenomenological theory of exchange currents in nuclei, which is indeed a very similar problem. An obvious remark, is that this expression is not unique. In fact, a gauge invariant expression is obtained if the integral is taken along any arbitrary path going from x1 to x2 . More generally, one could take the average of (1) over a set of paths chosen in such a way that the whole expression has the required invariance properties. A great similarity with Feynman’s integrals over the paths appears then, specially as the integral in the exponent of (1) is the action integral of a charge e going from x1 to x2 along the considered path. 453 Sheila Brenner (1930–2002), studied at Birmingham and obtained her Ph.D. under Peierls. She later taught at Swansea, Royal Holloway and Liverpool. 454 Letter [530]. 455 R.G. Sachs, ‘Phenomenological Theory of Exchange Currents in Nuclei’, Phys. Rev. 74, 433-441 (1948).
April 7, 2009
298
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
This, of course, is nothing more than playing with the equation and there is no doubt that the interaction you are considering is the most natural of this type. It seems very attractive, and I would be very interested in knowing about the development of the theory. I quite agree that form functions of three points cannot be introduced in electrodynamics. When I mentioned to you such a possibility, I was thinking of a meson-nucleon interaction such as (2) g dx1 dx2 dx3 F (x1 x2 x3 )ψ + (x1 )u(x2 )ψ(x3 ). This type of interaction is the only one I have studied so far. I have not published anything as yet on non-localized interactions, but I have just finished a manuscript about this problem. I hope to be able to send you a copy of the manuscript in a week or two. It is concerned with the general formulation of the problem taking as particular example the interaction (2). An investigation of the convergence of the self energies to all orders is made. It turns out that whereas convergence at the second-order is easily secured, divergences reappear at higher order unless it is specified, in particular, that the Fourier transform of the form function should have only time-like components. As this requirement does not seem to be in contradiction with any other requirement, everything is all right. Besides I made a detailed investigation of the conditions under which the non-localizability remains limited to small domains. It is very simple, but I think it was useful to do it. I also show by a general argument that the commutation rules are consistent with the field equations. A further check of this fundamental requirement is given by the actual calculation to all orders of the commutation relations of the outgoing fields in functions of the incoming fields. Altogether, I think it is proven that the theory rests on sound basis. I have not yet made any calculation of cross section, correction to the magnetic moment of the nucleons due to the exchange current coming from (1), etc... I have heard rumours that during your stay in this country you would spend some time at Cal. Tech. I hope it is true. With many thanks for your interest in my work. Yours, very sincerely, Claude Bloch
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
299
P.S. Please do not mention my suggestion of replacing a non-localized interaction by a Taylor series; a) it is a very old trick, which can be traced back to Wheeler’s velocity dependent potentials b) it is an extremely bad idea since the factor (1) can be found very simply as follows: Consider a gauge transformation Aµ = Aµ (x) +
∂∆ , ∂xµ
ψ(x) = ψ(x)e−ie∆ ,
ψ + (x) = ψ + (x)eie∆ , (3)
where a bar has been put below the transformed quantities. The transformation law of the expression we are interested in is ψ + (x1 )ψ(x2 ) = ψ + (x1 )ψ(x2 )eie(∆(x1 )−∆(x2 )) . We have
∆(x1 ) − ∆(x2 ) = − C
∂∆ = ∂xµ
(4)
C
(Aµ − Aµ )dxµ ,
(5)
where C is any path going from x1 to x2 . Substitution of (5) into (4) gives ψ + (x1 )eie C Aµ dxµ ψ(x2 ), which is the gauge invariance equation we want.
[534] Rudolf Peierls to Claude Bloch [Princeton], 21.1.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Bloch, Thank you very much for your letter.456 I found also that the expression involving the line integral of the vector potential had been used by Sachs.457 This is, however, a rather different matter from its particular use in a non-local theory. I also think that your derivation from the 456 457
Letter [533]. Letter [533], note 455.
April 7, 2009
12:11
300
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Taylor series is useful in showing that the expression is a natural one. The identity of ∂ e(x2 −x1 )( ∂x −ieA) ψ(x1 ) with ee
2 1
Adx
ψ(x2 )
can, of course, be demonstrated without using a series expansion, merely ∂ − ei A). by finding the eigenfunctions of the operator ( ∂x I have studied further the equations one gets from using in electromagnetic theory the action principle I gave in my last letter, and have not so far found any objections to it. Dr. Chr´etien in Birmingham is now working out the solutions of these equations by expanding in powers of the coupling constant. The results, which I do not have as yet, should be very similar to yours for the meson case, except that the occurrence of the line integrals causes some slight mathematical complications. I am surprised to hear that you find still some divergence with a general form function. I was always afraid of using a form function which has a different behaviour inside and outside the light cone since I did not feel sure that this would preserve the causal character of the theory, but from what you say you seem to have covered this point. In fact, just as your letter arrived, I was engaged in looking again at the requirement for (large-scale) causality so I shall expect your manuscript with gre[a]t interest. My main interest at the moment is to formulate the theory in such a manner that the definitions are independent of the expansion in powers of the coupling constant. I had derived, some time ago, commutation laws which were derived directly from the Lagrangian and could be used in a non-Hamiltonian theory, only it is not easy to prove that they are consistent, i.e. that they have solutions. I can now do this for a very special case, namely the equations for quantized electrons in an external (i.e. unquantized) field. This is a very easy case, but not quite trivial, since one can discuss such problems as vacuum polarization. In this case one can understand the general behaviour of the equations quite well. I can also get explicit solutions for the case of a uniform (but not necessarily weak) magnetic field, provided I use for my form factor a function whose Fourier transform is a simple exponential. This
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
301
function is probably not admissible because it rises instead of falling for time-like momentum vectors, but for the particular problem in hand it gives no trouble, and its behaviour should be fairly typical. About your remark that the integral in the exponent need not be taken over a straight path: If one is to specify a particular path, the only definition that is Lorentz invariant is the straight line. One could mix terms with different paths, and even integrate over all paths in the Feynman way, as you suggest, but I feel this would be useful only if one could use it to see some new connections between different parts of the theory. Within the framework of the kind of equations I am using it would just seem an unnecessary complication. How long are you staying at Pasadena? Are you likely to be in the East at all? If you should be in this neighbourhood before the middle of April, I very much hope we can arrange to meet. I do not think I shall be able to get to California during this visit. What are your plans for the next year? Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[535] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 23.1.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, I have not yet sent off your paper to Salpeter, as I said I was going to do, because I wanted some more time to read it myself, and in particular to discuss it with Low,458 which proved most interesting. I am sending it off now and this is to report to you about a number of point[s]. The most interesting point is that Low has a suggestion to understand why your terms cancel approximately in the end. He says that while for the purpose in hand one has to allow for the motion of the 458
See letter [532].
April 7, 2009
12:11
302
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
proton, the proton velocity will be small in all the important terms. The most rational way of proceeding would therefore be to go over to the second-order equation for the proton (I mean second order in the momentum) which can be approximated by the non-relativist Schr¨ odinger wave function for the proton. In this form one can see that the A2 term will be important. This term evidently is not a spin term and will have no low-order effect on hyperfine structure. Now if one proceeds as you do from the linear equation, there are terms involving the exchange of a transverse photon, which will contribute, when i[n]terated, to the A2 term mentioned above, and it is plausible that those will be in the leading correction terms for the hyperfine structure is not surprising. Other points on your paper: I think it is important that you should state quite clearly what kind of calculation you assume preceded the formulation of your correction terms. In other words what is the wave equation from which you obtained the function defining your matrix element. One can visualize two different alternatives: (a) you solve exactly the two-body equation in which the interaction is the even (++) part of the Coulomb interaction which, for example, is used in your paper which Ravenhall.459 Then this should be supplemented by terms representing the creation of virtual pairs, and you have to satisfy not only yourself, but also the reader, that the contributions such terms make to the hyperstructure, for example through their commutators with transverse interactions, are of a higher order than you need. (b) You solve exactly the two-body equation in which the odd parts of the potential have been retained. This is possible since the equation in this case does not blow up. Starting from an electron and a proton in a bound state, conservation of energy and momentum prevents either of them going off into a state of negative energy. You must then carry out the usual re-interpretation of positron theory. Based on the solutions of the two-body equation this has never been done, and it may not be easy. In any case, this reinterpretation as it stands does not contain such effects as the action on the electron of the vacuum polarization produced by the proton. I do not think it is likely that these terms 459
G.E. Brown and D.G. Ravenhall, ‘On the interaction of two electrons’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A208, 252–59 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
303
will have a large effect on what you calculate but the worry is that in this procedure (b) it is not clear how one should formulate such effects, and therefore it is not clear that this procedure can be reduced to the same basic equation as the usual approach to field theory where one re-interprets the negative-energy states first and then proceeds to solve the equations. This remark also applies to the problem of a single electron in a Coulomb field of high Z, where in your other paper460 you propose doing the re-interpretation after solving the Dirac equation with field, and the point may therefore have some bearing on what Sheila Brenner is doing. On p. 3 of your MS you refer to the approximation as taking intermediate states as free, and state that the error caused by this will be of higher order in [· · · ]461 . Later on you explain that the reason for this is that the relevant intermediate states have momenta of the order mc. This is probably right, but I would have to do a considerable amount of thinking before I could satisfy myself that this was so, and you should be a little more explicit. A trivial remark: on p. 5a you refer to transient effects arising from the switching of the interaction and say that they are “neglected anyway in the usual theory.” This is a poor way of stating a good case. Is not the point that the switching is only a mathematical trick, and that one should imagine going to the limit of switching so slowly that there are no transients. If there were any terms due to the transient included in your answer, they would, in fact, be wrong. This is no doubt what you mean, but it should also be what you say. Equally trivially: Also on p. 5a you write the matrix element for graph IIIc II ) (−i∆E2II T )2 + (−i∆E4c If I have succeeded in understanding what you are talking about, there should be a factor T on the second bracket. I mention this only in case there is something very deep which I have missed. 460
G.E. Brown, ‘Electron-Electron Interaction in Heavy Atoms’, Phil. Mag. 43, 467–71 (1952). 461 Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
304
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
On p. 3a you refer to the mesonic part of the proton moment, which of course you do not treat, and express the hope that to first order it would still act as a point-dipole. This is reasonable or otherwise according to what you mean by first order. One can visualize this term as representing a current density spread over a distance h/µc, and the correction will come in for any electron wave components corresponding to momenta of order c. This is quite apart from terms involving a spin reversal of the proton, in which of course virtual mesons may play a much more direct part (your remark sounds as if you had effects of this second kind in mind). Lastly, on p. 5c, in connection with the discussion of your equation (7), you explain that wherever there is a γi γi1 this should really be understood to be the transverse part, but that the effect [· · · ]462 a factor 2/3. Now here you do not give an argument, but ask the reader to take your word for it, since you have worked it out, but Low points out that this is rather surprising, since you are dealing with a product of four matrices. These refer to two different photons, and one can see that it might be plausible to average over the direction of the two photons independently (Though neither Low nor I have looked into this.) But if so, surely each of the averages would contribute a factor of 2/3, and one would expect the overall 4/9. Alternatively, if the photon cannot be treated as independent, one would be most surprised if the result were as simple as just a factor 2/3. So on this point some little explanation might be useful. As regards the general technique of applying Feynman methods to stationary states, I hear that Kroll463 gave a talk here last term, in which he explained this, and the idea is no doubt equivalent to yours, though I have not heard any detail. I do not know whether this is being published (I hope to find out) but in any case this is not an argument against publishing your version. Now about non-local theory. I have played mainly with the case of a non-quantized electromagnetic field. Then the wave equation for the 462
Line missing in carbon copy. Norman M. Kroll, at the time fellow at the Institute of Advanced Studies, later became professor of physics at the University of California, San Diego. 463
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
305
electron is still linear, and one should evidently expand the quantized electron wave function in terms of the unquantized non-local wave equation in the field. I have tried to obtain these solutions, and the only case I can do exactly is that of a homogeneous magnetic field which need not be weak. I can solve it only if I assume that Fourier transform of 2 2 the form factor to be a simple exponential, i.e. eλ(E −p ) . This has the mathematical advantage that it factorises between energy and momentum, and in that case the integral equation can be transformed into a differential equation. This form factor has, of course, the disadvantage that it increases with energy, and is therefore probably inadmissible, but in the special problem this does not seem to give any trouble. The solutions come out to be oscillator functions as in the differential theory, but the scale factors contain the constants in different combinations. The equation blows up when the field gets stronger than 2λc/e. I have not yet understood the physical reason for this. In the course of construction (sic) the commutators for this case, I have seen that one can do a bit of general theory for the case of an external field. The argument goes as follows. The wave equation is /)f (x1 − x2 )]α(x1 x2 )ψ(r2 ) = 0 d4 x2 [(m + k where f is the invariant form function, k is understood to be a differentiating operator acting on f only, and α(x1 x2 ) is an abbreviation for 2 e−ie/c 1 Adx Now I consider all solutions of this equation, with any value of the mass (real or imaginary). Then is it clear from the usual arguments that d4 x1 d4 x2 u ¯jt (x1 )[k /f (x1 − x2 )]a(x1 x2 )uis (x2 ) = 0 (mi − mj ) where i, j specifies t[w]o masses, and s, t, each a state (stationary or otherwise) for masses i or j. Hence in the sense of this four-dimensional integral operation, the states of different mass are orthogonal. It would therefore be nice to specify the states of any given mass in such a manner as to make them also orthogonal and normalized in the same senses, i.e.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
306
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
to have d4 x1 d4 x2 u ¯jt (x1 )[k /f (x1 − x2 )]α(x1 , x2 )uis (x2 ) = δ(mi − mj )δst If this is done, one can express the D functions which appear in the commutators explicitly: ψ(x )
2 = Dψ(x ¯ )
1
i,s
1 u ¯is (x1 )uis (x2 ) m − mi
Here the summation over i is in effect an integration over the mass, the fact that we require the retarded solution means that in this integration one should go above or below the pole according to whether the state s has a positive or negative energy (how one formulates this for a time-dependent energy field in which there are no stationary states is at the moment not clear). Now in the commutator one wants the difference between the retarded and advanced solution, and since these differ merely by how one passes the singularity, this leaves just the residue. The result is therefore (factors not guaranteed) ¯ 1 )ψ(x2 )]+ = [ψ(x
¯ us (x1 )us (x2 )
s
where the summation is now taken for a constant mass (the correct mass) and where, with the above normalization, the factor is +1 or −1, according to whether s refers to positive or negative energy. I have now looked at this in the particular case of no field, where one can compare this normalization with the usual one. It turns out that the normalization condition, if the wave functions are u = a · eipr−iEt amounts to a ¯·a=
m |E|
Since for a free-particle state a ¯a = ma∗ a/E, the requirement is that a∗ a = , where has the same meaning as before. Therefore, for posi-
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
307
tive energy, the prescription reduces to the conventional normalization. For negative energies it becomes impossible, since a∗ a cannot be negative. Hence one must alter the normalization condition by the inclusion of [..]464 on the right, which then means that [..]465 goes out of the commutation rule. The need for this factor in the normalization is deplorable since it complicates life. I am now trying to see what happens when one carries out the re-interpretation leading to positron theory, and whether this will not give a reasonable scheme without [..]466 in it. But I have not got far with this. I shall now send off your paper to Salpeter, and ask him to send it back to you as soon as possible. Low also asks whether you have, or can easily get, the fine structure of positronium, apart from any annihilation terms, to order compared to the magnitude of the fine structure. The reason is that he and Ward467 are trying to find a method of taking into account annihilation terms to the same order, and in order to state the results as observable predictions one needs the order terms as well. Nobody here believes in the Dyson progamme as a realistic scheme. Low thinks, in fact, that the Bethe-Salpeter equation is equivalent in that one can use [it] for everything that the Dyson scheme would do, and in particular that the elimination of the infinities is easy. He claims that in writing the paper with Gell Mann468 he saw quite clearly what one should do about the infinities, but that it was too obvious to write it down. He thinks, however, that the Bethe-Salpeter equation also is terrible to handle and is looking for better methods.
464
Missing in carbon copy. Missing in carbon copy. 466 Missing in carbon copy. 467 John Clive Ward (1924–2000), studied at Oxford and completed his Ph.D. under Maurice Pryce. He researched at Princeton, Bell Labs, Adelaide, Aldermaston, University of Maryland, University of Miami, Carnegie Institute of Technology, John Hopkins University and Victoria University, Wellington, before settling as professor of physics at Macquarie University in Sydney. 468 Murray Gell-Mann and Francis Low, ‘Bound States in Quantum Field Theory’, Phys. Rev. 84, 350-354 (1951). 465
April 7, 2009
308
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I have a preprint from Salpeter in which he also treats the corrections to hyperfine structure. I have not studied it yet, but I shall ask him to send you a copy if he has not already done so.469 I had a reply from Claude Bloch to my letter about non-local theories.470 He is working on very similar lines, but he is interested in the meson field and therefore not troubled by gauge invariance, and he always uses the series expansion (philosophy of Yang-Feldman)471 and therefore is not troubled about generalized commutation laws. He claims that to second order one gets finite results, but that in higher order there still appear infinities, unless one makes a special choice of the form factor, one possible choice being that in which the Fourier transform of f vanishes for all time-like momentum vectors. This surprises me, but I have seen no details. He has promised to send a manuscript in a week or two. It would be interesting to see if this corresponds to anything Chr´etien has found. Bloch also writes that he has written out clearly the condition in which such a non-local theory is compatible with macroscopic causality, i.e. does not contain actions transmitted into the past over measurable times. He does not say what these conditions are, but he does not sound as if they were stringent. Greetings to everybody, Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls] [536] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham], 25.1.195[2] Dear Prof, First of all, I might say, there is nothing of importance for me to report which will affect either your Cornell discussions or your smeared out talk. I’m enclosing this just to let you know how things are coming. 469 E.E. Salpeter and W.A. Newcomb, ‘Mass Corrections to Hyperfine Structure’, Phys. Rev. 87, 150 (1952). 470 Letter [533]. 471 C.N. Yang and D. Feldman, ‘The S-Matrix in the Heisenberg Representation’, Phys. Rev. 79, 972–978 (1950)
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
309
First of all I’d like to ask you to expedite the sending of Salpeter’s MS on this fine and HFS of hydrogen472 in case it has not been sent. This note of mine on electron-electron interaction in heavy atoms has been accepted by Phil. Mag. and I’m sending you a carbon copy today of the MS.473 The calculation of this latter business — the electron-electron interaction in heavy atoms — is proceeding well. Sheila has it calculated for the k shell and there it raises the energy of the two K electrons by .906Zα2 mc2 I’m checking thru the calculation rather carefully and the numerical factor may be wrong, but I am quite sure that the whole business can be done analytically and that her method is more or less all right. As soon as I have it checked, I’ll have her send it on to you. Woodward’s scattering of γ-rays has not made any important progress that I am aware of, but he has been properly exhorted to write to you in case it has. The hydrodynamics lectures are going quite easily now. They are fairly enjoyable, but are taking up a good bit of time. My own research is not particularly glowing, mainly because I have been putting in some time trying to organise Sheila, who is working pretty hard, but quite inaccurately, albeit cleverly with respect to methods, etc. I think that she’ll get over the inaccuracies if she learns to write things down properly. I have managed to keep up with vacuo-polarisation things well enough to talk to Chr´etien intelligently, perhaps. All in all, things are percolating quite well about the department. Edmond’s lectures have improved no end, although he still needs a little wind taken out of his sails; Dalitz nuclear theory lectures are superb as far as organisation etc. go and are attended by what looks to be 30 or 40 people. Sincerely, Gerry 472
Salpeter, E.E., ‘Mass Corrections to the Fine Structure of Hydrogen-Like Atoms’, Phys. Rev. 87, 328-43 (1952) 473 G.E. Brown, ‘Electron-electron Interaction in Heavy Atoms’, Phil. Mag. 43, 467–71 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
310
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[537] Rudolf Peierls to Chr´ etien [Princeton, date unspecified]474 (carbon copy) Dear Chr´etien Thank you very much for your long screed. I have not finished digesting it but it does not overlap at all with anything I have been doing, so I am not in a position to check it. It is depressing that the results look so complicated, but that was to be expected. The most urgent job now seems to me to find methods to discover whether they are finite or not. In view of the results claimed by Bloch, one might even have to go to higher order, but I would feel that this should not be attempted before we have thoroughly understood the results as they are now. In the meantime we shall get a copy of Bloch’s calculations, and can examine his claim that the higher orders may diverge. If you try to discuss the magnitude of the quantities occurring in your formulae, it will be important to be clear about the properties in the form function, and I have recently learnt a little more about this. I shall summarise the position here both because it may be of help to you, and also in the hope that you will check it. Consider the function F in coordinate space. It was proved by McManus that if one takes its Fourier transform to be an even function of k2 (four-dimensional) then F is an odd function of R2 .475 It therefore follows that the following moments vanish: 2 F dR , R4 F dR2 , · · · where R2 , of course, always goes from [−∞] to [+∞].476 Now consider the case where a field is disturbed by a small source restricted to a small region near the origin. One then wants to make sure that the effect of this at a distant point on the light cone is small, both in order 474
February 1952. See letter [396], note 80. 476 Missing ∞ in carbon copy. 475
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
311
to avoid trouble with macroscopic causality, and in order to ensure that the theory goes to the correct limit when r0 tends to zero. Then the integral F (R2 )f (x )d4 x where f represents the source can, for a point x near the light cone, but not close to the source, be approximated as 1 R2 1 3 2 F (R2 ) d r dR f r , t − r − r + 2 t 2t Actually this expression is correct only to order R2 , but this does not affect the argument. Now we expand f in a Taylor series with respect to time, and integrate over R2 . The result obviously give a number of successive derivatives of f , multiplied by the moment of F . The first non-vanishing term of F is odd, is R2 F dR2 . Now this is dimensionally a pure number, and therefore independent of r. If it does not vanish it will therefore remain finite in the limit and give corrections to the usual local theory. We must therefore require that it vanishes. Then the next non-vanishing term contains the 6th exponent. R6 F dR2 which is dimensionally r 4 . The integral multiplying this will be proportional to t−4 , where t, of course, is the time difference between the action of the source and its direct effect on the field. This presumably falls off sufficiently rapidly to avoid observable troubles and it certainly behaves all right as r0 [→] 0.477 One may still ask whether it is always legitimate to use the Taylor series for the source function. Obviously, if the source function behaves irregularly, there will be trouble. However, in our theory, one will not expect any physical quantity to vary steeply within a distance small compared to r0 because of the smoothing effects built into the theory. Since the Taylor series is used only over a distance of r02 /t where t by definition is large compared to r0 this would seem to be all right. The next question is whether the vanishing of the second moment is compatible with the requirements that the Fourier transform of F should 477
Missing → in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
312
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
be positive for all values of k2 . This had me rather worried, because the day before my New York talk I suddenly felt doubts about this compatibility. At first I thought it was all right, because the paper by McManus478 contains some functions for which g is obviously positive, and some for which the second Moment of F obviously vanishes. But then I saw that he had given the one only in momentum state, the other only in coordinate space, so the compatibility was not proved. I now think it is all right, but it should be checked. For this one needs an explicit formula for conversion, and the easiest procedure seems as follows. We wait to find F as a space-like argument. Since, for even g we already know that F is odd, this is sufficient. We then put t = 0 without loss of generality. Writing next the Fourier transform explicitly, and integrating first over the direction of the space part of k, and then over the magnitude of the space-part, keeping the resultant constant (which has to be done separately for time-like and space-like k) one obtains: (common factors not guaranteed)
∞ 4π 2 ∂ 2 2 Re sdsg(e )K0 (sr) + (ds)d(is)g(−s )K0 (isr) F = r ∂r 0 C where Re means real part of, and K0 is essentially a Hankel function: (2)
K0 (x) = 0iH0 (−ix) I believe this result is essentially given in the McManus thesis, but not in the published paper. It is now clear that the expression can be written as a contour integral
4π ∂ 2 Re zdzg(z )K0 (zr) r ∂r Cx where the contour C goes from a real infinite z down to the positive real axis to the origin and up the positive imaginary axis to +i. This encloses exactly the quadrant in which K tends to zero for infinite argument, except just along the imaginary axis where it oscillates. This oscillatory behaviour is of course of the kind that occurs always in a 478
See letter [396], note 80.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
313
Fourier transform and can be dealt with in the usual way. It is evident that this is equivalent to shifting the contour off the imaginary axis by a small angle, and therefore we are allowed to move the whole contour off to infinity, provided g is an analytic function. The result can therefore be expressed simply in terms of the [. . . ]479 poles of g in the first quadrant, and the corresponding residues 4. 1 For example the function g = const. k4 +a 4 which is quoted by McManus has only one pole in the relevant quadrant, and its Fourier transform can immediately be written down in terms of a derivative of K0 . Now consider the integral r 2 F dr 2 . Since the integrand is even it is sufficient to integrate over positive values of r 2 . After some algebra and using the differential equations for K, this can be written as 36π 2 Re i
pj j
zj
I have also used the fact that for x = 0, xK0 (x) has the value 2/π. Hence, the integrand vanishes if pj /zj is real. This is correct if one arranges that g should be an even function and should be real for both real and imaginary values of z. For example, McManus’ function const/(z 4 + a4 ) can be seen to satisfy this condition. Since I started writing this letter, I have found another argument, which is much simpler. Consider a source f as before, and the result of folding it with F , say f . Then from the expression given on the first page of this letter it is clear that, if the integral in question did not vanish, f would near the light cone have regions in which it is as large as const/r 2 . The distance from the light cone where the values occur is independent of r, since the function will clearly decrease only if I get away from any light cone crossing the region where f is appreciable. Hence, if I consider the integral
479
Missing in carbon copy.
|f |2 r 2 d3 rdt
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
314
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
over all space and time, it ought to diverge. I have inserted the modular sign in order not to discuss reality conditions, in fact [. . . ]480 will usually be real. Now, if the Fourier transform if f is [. . . ]481 then the Fourier transform of [. . . ]482 f is [. . . ]483 g. With this, the above integral can be written as 3 ∂ 2 3 2 484 485 2 )|2 d d k ∂kn |g(k /[. . .] n=1
Now g is always less than 1, so the above integral is less than its value with the factor g omitted, which is however, just the corresponding integral fir the function f instead of f [. . . ]486 which therefore is finite of the source function vanishes sufficiently rapidly outside a limited region. This argument pleases me from the point of view of ensuring that there will be no trouble with causality, but I am not sure whether it really proves that the integral of R2 F vanishes, since for suitable form function the argument could be extended to arbitrarily high powers and it is obvious that not all the moments of F are going to vanish. While I am writing this, I have had a look, and it seems to me that all the moments will vanish, so the effect along the light cone will in fact fall off exponentially, if the source function does. This is merely due to the fact that all the integrals differ from each other by containing a higher moment of the K0 for real argument, which is always finite and real, and multiplied by a power of zj4 [. . . ]487 which is a real factor if the poles lie on the diagonal, as in McManus case. If they do not lie there the[y] must lie symmetrically to the diagonal with conjugate residues, in order to make g real, and the same will happen again. I better close this letter before I make any more discoveries. However, you may find some of these arguments useful in trying to see what 480
Missing Missing 482 Missing 483 Missing 484 Missing 485 Missing 486 Missing 487 Missing 481
in in in in in in in in
carbon carbon carbon carbon carbon carbon carbon carbon
copy. copy. copy. copy. copy. copy. copy. copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
315
is finite and what is not, and I suggest you make try the McManus function as an illustration, of the behaviour of k−4 is not strong enough to make your integral converge, you can take the difference between two such functions with different parameters, which can be made to be[h]ave as k−8 which should surely be enough. I am very glad to know that you will be in Birmingham next year. I don’t know anything further yet about the chances of a University Fellowship. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls] [538] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 3.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, Your letter to Cornell488 was beautifully timed, it was handed to me as I entered Bethe’s office, and I believe it had just arrived. I had some talks with Salpeter about your calculation. He has posted it back to you, and he has also sent off a pre-print of his paper.489 The following points arise from a comparison of results: (a) The main term in the fine structure correction is almost the same, but there is a discrepancy of a factor 2. This may be a slip [in] the algebra in either paper, it may have some connection with the question of allowing for the transversality by a factor 2/3 (see my previous letter490 ) and it might even be that he has included terms which you have left out, though this does not seem likely at this point. (b) Your result gives only the log term, but not the numbers added to the log. These come from a careful integration over non-relativistic momenta, and he assumes that you realize that they should be there but have not bothered to work 488
Letter [536]. See letters [534–35]. 490 Letter [535]. 489
April 7, 2009
12:11
316
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
them out. (c) He gets non-negligible contributions from other diagrams, involving a cross-over of a longitudinal and a transverse photon. This again is related to a query I raised in my last letter. Deutsch491 has now measured the fine structure of positronium to a better accuracy than available theories, and it is therefore interesting to improve the calculation. A lot of people are trying this. I believe you know of the thesis by Ferrel (not sure this spelling is right) who worked at Princeton University with Wightman and is now at G¨ ottingen.492 He claims to have done the whole thing, but I heard a third-hand rumour that his calculation is not right. Low here is also starting a calculation together with Ward and Stern (an ex-Schwingerite here). Ravenhall was originally reluctant to start on positronium because he believed Radcliffe was doing it, and by now feels there are altogether too many people doing it. I am afraid I cannot remember who are the others, but there are several. The next item will interest you and Woodward. I talked at Cornell with Bethe and Levinger on the gamma-ray scattering.493 Bethe now believes that your argument is correct, though of course one cannot be sure until the factors have been estimated. Levinger was rather perturbed by this, since he had put a lot of effort into the calculation of the zero-order term. (See his abstract at the NY meeting, which should have arrived by now.) However, he was mainly concerned with the case where the change of momentum of the photon is less than mc. He then finds that the correction to the usual form factor is of the order q/mc where q is the momentum transfer. Now it looks as if the correction that Woodward is calculating does not give a useful answer in itself, but it is not wasted since it should merely be supplemented by the first order term. He asked whether we would have any objections to his calculating 491
Martin Deutsch (1917–2002), studied at M.I.T and received his Ph.D. in 1941, and later joined the Manhattan Project. After the war he returned to M.I.T. where he spent the remainder of his career. In 1951, he measured and confirmed the existence of positronium. 492 Richard Ferrell summarized the findings of the doctoral thesis in a letter in Phys. Rev.. Richard.A.Ferrell, ‘The Positronium Fine Structure’, Phys. Rev. 84, 858–59 (1951). 493 See letter [531].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
317
the first-order term for that case, and I told him that this would not really overlap with what Woodward is doing, since this is at the moment mainly concerned with the case of large q, but that he should keep us informed about his progress. I also promised we would let him know about any results we get. He is now at Louisiana State. I feel incapable of listing all the odd bits of information which I came across though I am writing to the appropriate people about some of them. I also cannot list the many people who were asking about you and send you their best wishes, but I remember amongst them Blair, Arfken and Pollard. Breit was in an amazingly tolerant mood and after Salpeter’s talk merely asked what was the difference between Ed’s equation and his earlier one. Salpeter suppressed the desire to say that the difference was that his formula was right, and merely explained which kind of graphs gave additional terms in his calculation. So everything was very peaceful. Possible new members for the Birmingham department for next year include Jack Davidson494 from Washington University, St. Louis, Segall495 from Illinois, a man called Stuart, who accosted me in New York and who is from somewhere in the East, and a man from Manitoba. Also Brueckner has expressed a desire to spend a year in England and this is to be encouraged, but it will probably not work out for next year. We counted together 12 ex-members of the department now on this continent (without Singwi) of these 9 were present at the New York meeting. I am sorry the hydrodynamics course takes so much of your time, but you have been warned. Still, as long as you enjoy it, it will soon be over. I do not understand what you say about Sheila Brenner’s result. Unless there is a typing error, the result you quote is a number times ZRydberg which is the order of the ordinary non-relativistic Coulomb 494
John P. Davidson, at the time at Washington University, later moved to Rio de Janeiro, New York, and eventually to the University of Kansas, where he remained for the rest of his career. 495 Benjamin Segall, at the time at the University of Illinois, later moved to the Radiation Laboratory at Berkeley, to the General Electric Research Laboratory, Schenectady, New York and eventually to the Department of Physics at Case Western Reserve University Cleveland, Ohio.
April 7, 2009
12:11
318
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
interaction between the two electrons, which surely must have been calculated before. The next term presumably is two orders higher in (Z) and would correspond to the usual Breit correction. Only a term in (Z) would be new. This would be very small unless Z was very large, and then, presumably, one should not use a series at all. Or did you mean that the calculation has been done for a particular Z which makes the analytical expression you quote somewhat misleading. In that case, what was the Z? I enclose some notes on things concerning mainly other people though you will also want to see them and vice versa. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls] Krook496 got your radio all right, but he claims it does not work.
[539] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Princeton], 4.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, I would like to add a few more comments to the points I made in my last letter to you.497 First, I have had some more talks with Low here, who asserts that it is completely obvious that the renormalization of the Bethe-Salpeter equation is no more complicated than the renormalization of S-Matrix theory, in fact he says he knew this when he wrote the paper with Gell-Mann,498 but the point was so obvious that it was not worth writing down. I have not yet had the chance of having this out with him in detail, but from the amount of work he has done with the equation and his general soundness I would bet that he is right. I there496
Max Krook, South African born research fellow at Birmingham who later became professor at Harvard. 497 Letter [531]. 498 Letter [535], note 468.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
319
fore suggest that you and Radcliffe drop the work on the Dyson-method and turn to the BS equation instead. Furthermore it seems to me that the arguments about isobaric states of both isotopic and ordinary spin 1/2 playing a part in meson scattering tend to remove the evidence against pseudoscalar coupling. Whatever the coupling, such a state contributes only to p scattering, and the strong rise of the cross section with energy is therefore an immediate consequence. There should, of course, also be contributions from the s wave, which do not have resonance character, but which will matter at low energy, but the experiments are not accurate enough to exclude these. When Dyson was here recently, he pointed out that the existence of an isobaric state did not necessarily mean that the coupling was very strong (though it does mean, of course, that one must not use Born approximation). He points out that the parameter which has to be large to justify the usual “strong coupling” approximation contains both the coupling constant and the radius of the source which has to be introduced in such a theory. If the source radius is the nuclear Compton wave length, then one can have “strong coupling” with a reasonably small coupling constant, for which for example the expansion of the kernel in the Bethe-Salpeter equation might still be reasonable. I do not claim to have understood this quite clearly, but quote it as it will interest you in a general way. On the question of the scattering of neutrons or protons by a deuteron, I had not previously realized that the objection by Kohn499 is valid only for the doublet S state, but neither for the quartet S state nor for any states of higher angular momentum of the whole system, since for these the triton presumably has no bound states. It would therefore seem perfectly possible to use the iteration method for those other states. This is not without interest because (a) Christian tells me that one can make a phase shift analysis, which determines the separate 499
W. Kohn (1923–) had completed his Ph.D. at Harvard in 1948 working with Schwinger and Van Vleck; between 1950 and 1969 he worked at Carnegie Mellon University before taking up a post at the University of California at San Diego. In 1979 he became Founding Director of the Institute of Theoretical Physics at Santa Barbara.
April 7, 2009
12:11
320
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
phases from the experiments except for an ambiguity, by which either a small doublet S and a large quartet S phase or vice versa will do. (b) there is hope that Skyrme will get an answer by this method, but this will be easiest for the doublet S state, and a method to do the other would therefore combine well with his. Lastly I think you will be interested that Brueckner,500 who is now at Illinois has expressed an interest in coming to Birmingham, and mentioned the idea of an exchange. It is probably too late to organise anything for ne[x]t session, but the session after might be a possibility. It is not clear whether it would not be more useful if he came on a Fulbright or some such grant, but the idea of an exchange would not be without interest. By all accounts Illinois seems to be a very lively place. However, this is all still very vague. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[540] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 6.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, About your calculation. I do always keep carbon copies of any typed letters. I hope you do the same, because I shall refer to points in your last letter. But I do not have a copy of your screed, which is on its way back (to you[)], so if you have occasion to write about it you better refresh my memory. About the Salpeter-Low letter the phrase taking into account the proton recoil meant just the obvious thing, namely keeping the kinetic energy of the proton in the energy denominators, and is obvious in calculating any effect proportional to l/M . However, he had in that paper a curious canonical transformation which appeared to simplify 500
Keith A. Brueckner, at the time at Indiana University, Bloomington, later went to Pennsylvania, before taking up an appointment at the University of California, San Diego in 1959.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
321
the problem which Low now believes actually obscures some points. In particular, there is a term of which he believed it did nothing but change the mass to the reduced mass. This is true for the ground state but for the excited states which come into second order calculations it does other things. His reasons for thinking that this is important is that in the paper he gets a logarithmic term which he thinks is not real, since it has no analogue in the corresponding calculation for positronium which he is doing now by a simpler method. All this is not very clear to me but it may help to explain why you were in difficulty. The argument about cancelation before integration is nice and would have saved you a lot of work, if one had seen it earlier. I have now understood what kind of zero-order function you assume is used, but I still think a little more explanation is needed for publication than is given in your note. I do not mean you should say how one actually obtains them, but what equation (in abstract terms) they are supposed to be the solution of and to what approximation. The omitted terms are therefore commutators between longitudinal and transverse effects involving also states of negative energy, and that agrees with Low’s comments (and presumably also with Salpeter’s). However, Low is convinced that those terms are not small, and in your last para. but one on p. 3 of your letter you seem to admit that this is possible. As to method “b”, I used the argument about conservation of energy and momentum only to satisfy myself that a finite solution to the two-body problem omitting radiative corrections does exist. The possible final states into which it might disintegrate are, of course, asy[m]ptotically free-particle states of positive or negative energy, and hence the use of conservation laws does not imply that one is using any approximation for the bound state itself. The trouble seems to be that the excited states of this system always will lead to a coupling of positive and negative-energy states, and since one needs a complete set of solutions for carrying our the re-interpretation of pair theory this may get one into difficulties. About the factor 2/3, I find your argument still hard to follow. However, Low had another way of looking at this, and we checked the factors together. We came to the conclusion that the factor 2/3 is all right for the fine structure, but not the h.f.s. Since you have not
April 7, 2009
12:11
322
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
calculated the latter, except for the cancellation, which is not affected by the numerical factor, this is not serious, but it is interesting merely from a formal point of view. About the mesonic part of the proton moment I know exactly what you meant, but it would be better not to use the expression “first order”, since everybody will understand this to mean something else. Salpeter’s paper was sent to you by first-class surface mail well over a week ago, so it should arrive before long. Your screed went off ditto on 30th Jan. About Sheila Brenner’s work. This is very nice, and it is nice to see that all the nasty integrations can be carried out. I think it would be good to publish a short note about this (not too short but shorter than what she sent me). I do not think that the photoeffect is necessarily the best way of getting an experimental check. In principle, the X-ray line corresponding to the transition of the electron from the L to the K shell is very accurately known. The question here is whether all other corrections like screening can be estimated with sufficient accuracy for the L shell. What about the K-absorption edge? I tried to explain this business to Low and suddenly could not remember your argument for saying that for the purpose one should take the l-[??] term instead of [. . . ]. This is in your note that is being published.501 If you could spare a copy or proof of this, it would help. On a point of mathematical technique, I firmly believe that it is always easier, even in bound state problems not to specify the special representation of the Dirac matrices. That one can solve the hydrogen problem conveniently without has been shown in a German paper by Franz.502 He always treats his wave functions as square 4 × 4 matrices, so that in effect he obtains the solutions for at least two states together (and even then his matrix has to degenerate so that two rows vanish.) This seems to be an unnecessary complication. Should I return Miss Brenner’s note? I am just about to give a seminar about the non-local theory. I have several new quite wild ideas, but I shall write about them later. 501
Letter [536], note 473. W. Franz, ‘Rayleighsche Streuung harter Strahlung an schweren Atomen’, Z. Phys. 98, 314–20 (1935). 502
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
323
There is quite a race on about positronium. It seems that the results of Ferrel are not right, and now Low and Ward here are trying to beat Karplus & Co. to it.503 Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls] [541] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Princeton], 7.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, Thank you for your letter, which crossed with my last one to you. I do not believe one should find observable anomalies of scattering of π mesons by protons due to the actual or virtual formation of V particles. Even if we assume that the (V) decay is just onto a proton and a π one can get the cross section of the inverse reaction by detailed balancing from the life time. The lifetime is, in natural units so long that the cross section will come out extremely small. This means also that any resonance scattering will give a very narrow peak (the width is of the order of 10−5 ev) which not only would not show up in the existing experiments but is probably quite unobservable in practice. I did not mention that the people working with Schein in Chicago504 reported at Rochester an attempt to find the production of V particles by the passage of π mesons from the cyclotron through matter. Amongst hundreds of tracks in their photographic plates they had a few which could possibly be interpreted in that way, but the evidence is extremely messy, and they do not claim to have established anything. If this effect were confirmed it would, of course, prove that the V s are not produced together with another particle as Pais suggests.505 I also asked Dyson what use the BS equation would be for a one body problem and he replied that such things as the magnetic moment of the 503
See above letter [537]. Marcel Schein (1902–1960), studied in Zurich where he obtained his Ph.D. and habilitation. He later emigrated to the US and became professor at Chicago. 505 See A. Pais, ‘Some Remarks on the V -Particles’, Phys. Rev. 86, 663–72 (1952). 504
April 7, 2009
12:11
324
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
nucleon could probably be done by a slightly modified form of S-Matrix theory, which would still represent an expansion of g2 only. (After all this is how Schwinger did the anomalous moment of the electron). This expansion may not be good, of course, but such expansions are used anyway in the case of the Dyson programme, and in the BS equation. Dyson therefore believes that the specific need for this theory arises only in bound-state problems, and that for those the BS equation is better. About positronium see my remarks in the enclosed letter to Brown.506 I was under the impression that Radcliffe had got tired of it and was dropping it. If he continues he faces heavy competition, though he may have a head start. I suggest he might write me a brief note about what exactly he is trying to do and how far he has got, so that I could then find out how this progress compares with that of the people here. If he is not ahead of them, but is using a different method it might well be worth continuing, since one is bound to learn something from it. I am not surprised by your remark that you have not got much research work done, you are certainly carrying an extremely heavy load this term. I certainly think it would pay to write a short note on your re[s]ults about the polarization effects in a cascade. I am not clear whether this question arose as a result of questions of experimentalists (Harwell? Halban?) who are planning to do some measurements on it. In that case, of course, it would be courteous to consult them before you decide to publish your comments. The other question about p + P = D + π should, I think, not be covered in the same note, particularly since you have already discussed the general principles common to both in a separate note. There may be a case for waiting with this second one until one can quote some rough numbers, but this depends on whether there is a prospect of someone being available to do the calculation in a reasonable time. In this connection, I should perhaps mention that I have left Harper in a rather unsatisfactory stage of his work.507 I have made a number of suggestions, and perhaps he has enough to do. But if he is stranded, he might prefer to do a simple calculation on a 506
Letter [540]. P.G. Harper, graduate student working on conduction electrons in uniform magnetic fields. After completion of his studies in Birmingham he joined the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization in Sydney. 507
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
325
scattering problem rather than do nothing, even though it is quite far from his main field of interest, which is the electron theory of metals. I do not know of any conference for 1952, except a summer meeting of the Physical [Society] and the Institute of Physics at Glasgow. This is not planned as an International Conference, and will probably be only a two-or three-day affair. Moon is likely to know the latest position about this. I am glad to know your reaction about spending a period abroad. You will have seen my reference to Brueckner in my last letter. I am now wondering whether it is too late to do anything for next session, but the difficulties are (a) all present proposals are still so vague that it will be some time before anything can be decided, and, for example if one thinks of a direct exchange, the co-operation of a number of authorities would be required. (b) You would not apply for a visa before the scheme was decided and confirmed at least in outline and this will make it rather late. It would not be very pleasant to be in a situation where you will not know until the last minute whether the visa will come through in time or not. (c) It would add one more change in the department, and things might be a bit chaotic next session. However, none of these arguments is absolutely decisive and if, for example you would have very strong feelings that next session would be much better than the year after we could have a shot at it. I think Redmond would be a valuable addition to the team. I have written to him to say so and have also sent a recommendation to the Fulbright people in London. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls] [542] Rudolf Peierls to M. Chr´ etien [Princeton], 7.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Chr´etien, I have now had time to look through your notes more carefully. I have not checked the numerical factors and signs, but I find general expressions of much the same form.
April 7, 2009
12:11
326
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Two important points, however: Why do you call const/const - p2 the McManus transform. This function is not given in the paper by McManus, perhaps it occurs in his thesis. I would think it highly undesirable to choose a function with poles in it. This is likely to make the result ambiguous, and, for the reasons given in my last letter, one ought to have a function whose derivatives are bounded. The function which McManus discusses a good deal is a4 /(a4 + p4 ) and this is entirely satisfactory. The Fourier transform is found in my last letter. not yet understood whether the occurrence of integrals like iqI2 have 4 e d q arises from the specific form function you have chosen, but I am surprised that anything so unpleasant should come in. If it recurs with a better form factor, I would try to alter the order of integration, and see if one cannot get rid of the ambiguity that way. I gave a seminar on these things yesterday, but did not finish and will continue next week. In the meantime I shall see whether I find a simple reason for believing that answers should be finite or not. Also, at the seminar Wigner raised the question whether our Lagrangian was Hermitian (or rather, in the first place, whether it is real treating wave functions and potentials as c-numbers). I could not answer this offhand, but I do not expect any trouble from this, in the worst case we may have to define the Lagrangian as the real part of what we wrote before. I hope also to get clear about this point by next week. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls] [543] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham], [date unspecified]508 Dear Prof, I’m sending immediately a few notes concerning your comments, in the same order as the l[e]tter, so that if you have a carbon copy handy, it will be easy to follow this. On second thought, I’ll make this more or less complete in itself since I’m sure that you have not kept a CC. 508
The letter was written in early February 1952.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
327
It seems to me that Low’s comment on the A2 term and the reason for no spin-spin term occurring is very reasonable. I’ve been thinking about this ever since I read his letter to the Phys. Rev. with Salpeter,509 and I understand it better from your comments. (Incidentally, Low and Salpeter take into account proton-recoil in corrections to the hfs arising from the exchange of one transverse photon. Could you please discover what he means by this statement what proton recoil means here? I’m very anxious to find him out what he calculated. I tried to find out through writing him, but I confess that I’m still mystified, although he gave a clear exposition of everything else.) One can make a similar mathematical argument within the formalism of the MS. In the two terms describing balancing. That means to say, one can see immediately, that the coefficients of the spinor terms are equal for any given photon momentum k, and consequently that the equality of the two terms and hence the lack of spin-spin interaction is assured even before integration over k. One has the dominant terms (i)
/γ j ) (γ i 2k (p + k)2 + m2
γ1i 2k /γ1j (p1 − k)2 + m21
from
/γ i ) (γ j 2k (p + k)2 + m2
γ i 2k /γ j (pl1 + k)2 + m21
from
and (ii)
the numerators in (i) are things like ip / + ik− m, ip /1 − 2k− m; and in l / − m parts go three γi (ii) things like ip / + 2k− m, ip /1 + ik− m but the ip etc. to operate on the wf and are negligible aside from common factors 1/k2 , 509
1 & etc. (k − ∆P )2
F. E. Low and E. E. Salpeter, ‘On the Hyperfine Structure of Hydrogen and Deuterium’, Phys. Rev. 83, 478 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
328
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
which he will then integrate over k. Now, choosing p to be the electron momentum, one sees that the denominator involving proton momenta p1 , p1 give factors which are equal and opposite in sign in the two cases. Since photon energies of order mc2 (to be discussed later) are involved, one can call the proton momentum sensibly equal to the fourth component and this iM , where M is the rest mass. Further, all k’s are to be disregarded in this particular denominator unless they combine somehow with M . Hence, the denominator (p1 − k)2 + M12 becomes equal approximately to −|k0 |M1 and it is clear that the second denominator is equal to just the negative of this. Hence one has for the sum of the[ir] two terms: +
1 1 {(γ i 2k /γ j + γ j 2k /γ i }(γ i k /γ j ) 2 2 (p + k) + m |k /0 |M1
(1)
As explained in the MS, only the 4th component of k in the numerator will bring in velocity-independent spinor terms, since otherwise one has the product of three velocity-dependent spinors. Hence, one has sensibly: −
1 1 [γ4 (γ i γ j + γ j γ i )][γ4 (γ i γ j )] (p + k)2 + m2 M1
(1)
However, the argument is rather messy. It seems to amount to the same thing as Low’s argument. In fact, in considering things from the point of view of a time-ordered theory, one has split a non-spin-dependent term into two spin-dependent terms. You are, of course, quite right that I should state a bit more explicitly what kind of a calculation I assume to precede the formulation of these correction terms. I think that within the framework of this MS one should point out only, however, that it is possible to separate the exchange of two transverse photons from other effects, and to formulate the whole problem possibly in another note in which one could concentrate on the main points involved. The approach used here is that of
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
329
Brown and Ravenhall.510 Only (++) parts of the wave functions are allowed. (For convenience, ++ is taken in terms of free electron and free proton functions, although I should think it would be possible to choose hydrogen-like functions). The interference of the “unlike parts” of the Coulomb potential with the transverse interaction do indeed contribute m Ry to both fine and HFS, or order α of the main effect, in order α3 M but the coefficient is so small as to make the correction to the hfs about 10% that of the recent Karplus-et-all-, Schwinger-et-all correction511 The important terms are — in the non-covariant perturbation theory which I used — such things as
a) Electron-positron pair with electron in state I is formed with the emission of a transverse quantum b) Through the “unlike” part of the e2 /r interaction, the pair annihilates and the proton is scattered. c) The proton absorbs the transverse quantum returning to initial state. 510
See letter [535], note 459. Robert Karplus, Abraham Klein, and Julian Schwinger, ‘Electrodynamic Displacement of Atomic Energy Levels’, Phys. Rev. 84, 597–98 (1951); Robert Karplus and Abraham Klein, ‘Electrodynamic Displacement of Atomic Energy Levels. I. Hyperfine Structure’, Phys. Rev. 85, 972–84 (1952); Karplus and Schwinger were doing further work which was published in subsequent months. Robert Karplus, Abraham Klein, and Julian Schwinger, ‘Electrodynamic Displacement of Atomic Energy Levels. II. Lamb Shift’, Phys. Rev. 86, 288–301 (1952); Robert Karplus and Abraham Klein, ‘Electrodynamic Corrections to the Fine Structure of Positronium’, Phys. Rev. 86, 257 (1952); Robert Karplus and Abraham Klein, ‘Electrodynamic Displacement of Atomic Energy Levels. III. The Hyperfine Structure of Positronium’, Phys. Rev. 87, 848–58 (1952). 511
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
330
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
This possibility is forbidden to the vacuum plus proton because of the presence of the electron in state I. Hence it represents an interference with the vacuum self-energy of the proton in the negative energy electron field. The energy correction looks like (being careful to use pair theory):
∆E =
= = .! (forbidden)
2
αi ∗ ψ e ψ I ψ )(ψ ∗ √ C(ψp∗ √αωi ψp )(ψpos p r12 el p el ω ψpos )
(Ep − Ep − ω)(−Eel − Epos − ω)
ψpos creates a positron in an arbitrary state. ∗ creates an electron in state I. ψel The mathematics involved in calculating these terms is easy but tedious and I’ve been trying to think out a way of doing it a bit more schmelegantly. These corrections should, of course, appear automatically in any sort of treatment using the Bethe-Salpeter equation, which presumably handles pairs correctly. To summarize the above: One does the e2 interaction as Ravenhall and I did it, then corrects the terms involving the exchange of one photon for the effects described in the paragraph above; this I have not done in the MS because these latter effects come from one transverse photon; then calculates the effects of the exchange of two transverse photons as I did in the MS. In this latter calculation, the cancellation of the spin-spin interaction terms is insensitive to the choice of zeroorder wave function, but the spinorless operator for the fine structure — calculated in the momentum representation in the MS should be inserted between the correct wave functions containing only positive energy components. (The actual value of the fine structure correction will be determined by the value of the hydrogen wave function at a distance of order h/mc from the origin, if relativistic corrections are brought in. The cutting out of the negative energy components of the wave function will change this value slightly, and I should really make a decent calculation of this rather than rough estimates, so I’ll get after it). I think, however, that it is clear that one can separate the various effects unambiguously and evaluate only the exchange of two traverse photons as an effect-in-itself. (Wirkung-in-sich-selbst)
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
331
One of my main worries these days is a procedure like (b) that you mention for handling a two-body problem. I should prefer, however, to think the problem out, beginning from bound state solutions rather than falling back on the fact that energy and momentum of electron and proton cannot be conserved in this special case. Of course, one should demonstrate that for the case of weak coupling, perturbation theory gives the same answer as the above. However, I’d rather save these worries for later. In heavy atoms, even, I don’t see yet how to take vacuum polarization correctly into account, and this is still the problem of one particle in an external potential! That binding in intermediate states is of order higher than the main effect is best seen by considering graphs like
where one inserts a Coulomb scattering - - - - - - -. I don’t claim to have evaluated this effect, but I’ve gotten the coefficients of the leading terms, I don’t know of any convincing way of showing that the important intermediate states are of energy order mc2 except by breaking up the large number of terms represented by each graph and evaluating them co-variantly. I’ve looked at lots of terms this way. Also, all order of magnitude estimates, when compared with the final answer, turn out to be consistent with this assumption. I’ll look at this from the A2 point of view. Thanks for the comment about switching on the potential as a mathematical device. Also, I did drop a T. With respect to the mesonic part of the proton moment, I meant only that I didn’t treat it. By first order treatment of it, I meant the usual treatment of Fermi, Breit etc. where they multiply the e2 contribution to the hfs calculated using the Dirac part of the moment by a factor 2.6? to take account of the mesonic part of the moment.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
332
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
The factor 2/3 coming from employing γ i γ1i −
γ · k γ1 · k 2
k
instead of γ i γ1j
is easy to explain. First, a few comments: The two photons are horribly unindependent in the sense that they must have, to within order α, opposite momenta. Let’s assume that the “A2 argument” is right and that I understand it. Then one has, as far as the numerators of the matrix elements are concerned, something like / + ik / − m)γi ]el [Aj Ai δij ]P [γj (ip The polarizations of the two photons appear to be the same. If the polarization of the first photon is limited to the plane ⊥ to the propagation axis, then the polarization of the second photon will automatically be also ⊥ to its propagation axis. Now, in [ ]el the dominant term is [γj iγ4 K4 γi ]el and hence all directions are equally favourable here. Consequently have two thirds of what we had before. Within the framework of the MS, one can put the argument: Because of the detailed equality of the coefficients of the spinor terms, explained on page 1, for the crossed and uncrossed exchange of the two photons, one can combine these two terms before integrating over k. The sum of the expressions on p.2. goes over into: |K| 1 γ4 γ41 {(γi γj )(γi γj )(1) + (γj γi )(γi γj )(1) 2 2 (p + k) + m M1 1 − 2 [(γi γ · k )(γi γ · k )1 + ( γ · k γi )((γi γ · k )1 k
+( γ · k γj )( γ · k γj )(1) + (γj γ · k )( γ · k γj )(1) ] 2 + 4 ( γ · k )( γ · k )(1) ( γ · k )( γ · k )(1) }; k and { } = 4
using the commutation properties of the γ’s. At the time I wrote the draft of the MS, I had a more formal business in mind, but the above is perhaps more convincing, because it is simpler. Now, to pass on to other matters. I’m looking forward most expectantly to the pre-print from Salpeter. With reference to Low’s question,
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
333
the fine structure of positronium can be gotten to order α of the main effect along the lines in the MS if one makes the corrections coming from the “unlike” parts of e1/r12 mentioned above. The arguments of the MS would need a bit of tidying up since at one point I use the fact that m/M is a small quantity. This doesn’t seem to be necessary, but it gave a bit more convincing proof at this point. Thanks to Low for the reprints which I received today. I’ve been reading your comments on smearing with great interest. I like the idea of throwing the job of forming on orthogonal set on to the mass mi . It seems to me that using positron theory, your troubles with [. . . ]512 are eliminated. But I’d rather wait to write more on this until the weekend since I have my Wed. lectures to prepare. Probably you’re already way ahead of me on this anyway. I haven’t looked through the hydro exam yet, but will get around to it over the weekend.513 Thanks a lot for taking so much trouble with my MS. Sincerely, Gerry
[544] Rudolf Peierls to M. Chr´ etien [Princeton], 14.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Chr´etien I have sweated the last week or so over the question whether the vacuum polarization to order e2 is finite. By a procedure similar to yours I obtain the following expression: jν (k) = Bµν aµ (k) 512 513
Missing in carbon copy. See letter [538].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
334
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
with 2
Bµν = −4e
0
1
4s
dσ
2pµ pν + δµν (k · p − kν pµ ) 1 δµν d p g(p) p 2 + m2 4
· g(p − sk)g(p − σk) − (1 − s)pµ gν (p − sk)g(p − σk) − (1 − σ)(pν u − kν )g(p − sk)gµ (p − σk)
− (1 − s)(1 − σ)(p(k) − k)gν (p − sk)gµ (p − σk)
1 · δ((p − k)2 + m2 ) − [pµ gν (p + (s · σ)k) 2 + pν gµ (p + (s − σ)k)]δ(p2 + m2 )
I have taken real coordinates, with the summation convention in the form aµµ = a11 + a22 + a33 − a44 ,
δµν = 1,
µ = ν = 1, 2, 3,
δ44 = −1
which is similar to Feynman’s except for a sign, g is the Fourier transform of the form function (your [..]514 except for a factor) in such units that in the point theory g = 1. gν stands for δg/∂pν . a(k) is of course a Fourier component of the external field, and the condition k.a = 0 has been used, which accounts in part for the unsymmetric appearance of the result. Now at first I did not dare put k = 0 directly in the above, since then the pole of the 1(p2 m2 ) comes on top of the singularity of the delta function. I have, however, now seen that, since the pole is to be taken as principal value, this is not serious. Then if one puts k = 0, one can perform a partial integration which finally leaves the expression in a form in which it all depends on g (−m2 ) where g is the derivative with respect to p2 . Now the argument −m2 is, of course, just the value which matters in the limit of long wavelength, and it would appear reasonable to choose the function in such a way that it is symmetric about this point (instead of about 0 as we usually assumed). Then the term independent 514
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
335
of k2 seems to disappear fairly unambiguously. (the reasoning would not apply in the local limit, since the integration by parts then leaves an indefinite residue at infinity.) I am not yet very happy about the whole argument, because the evaluation still looks a little arbitrary, so that one might still get different answers by working in a different way. It is certainly disappointing that the theory is not yet convergent in an absolute sense. The reason is, of course, that divergence in the nongauge invariant term which I have discussed, comes from an integration over the immediate neighbourhood of the hyperbolic surface p2 +m2 = 0 and in this neighbourhood the g factors do not help convergence. It may be that things would be much clearer and less ambiguous if written in coordinate space, but they are then just too damn complicated. However, the next step is to get the term proportional to k [..]515 which represents charge renormalization. Of this we must expect that it be unambiguous and finite, otherwise the theory is no use. I shall have a look at this now, and hope you will do the same, and at the same time I shall continue thinking about the general problem of quantising such a theory without using a series expansion. So far I have not made much sense of this, beyond the remark that it can be done in principle for an unquantized field. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
[545] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham], 18.2.1952516 Dear Prof, I’m just getting off a short note to tell you that I found — actually before the arrival of Salpeter’s MS — the place where the calculations differed. Remember the factor 2 I found wrong in Feynman’s work? It 515 516
Missing in carbon copy. Misdated 1951.
April 7, 2009
336
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
is a very dangerous thing to do and Dalitz checked it for me and showed me where it came right. I had previously had Radcliffe and Field check it, but they made the same mistake as I. This part of the problem is in almost complete agreement, then. Salpeter seems to have integrated the resultant expression a bit more carefully, but this could be done equally easily here. One thing that I like in his work is that one can see whether things come from negative energy states or positive. On the whole, for two-body problems, his method is undoubtedly far more powerful than mine. However, I think that I understand his work far better for having gone through the calculation and also in electrons interacting with external fields etc. there is some advantage in seeing how Feynman theory can be applied for calculating bound state corrections. In the interference of Coulomb terms and transverse photons, I haven’t yet collected up my coefficients for the fine structure, but they are much like Salpeter’s result for this. My graphs, however, give an α correction to the HFS and Salpeter claims that the first correction to come in is of order αm/M . I’ve not thought thru the business properly yet, so I may very well be in error. But this I will look at. I now understand how one handles low energy effects where binding has to be taken into account — one doesn’t in this formalism. I’ve been worrying about how to evaluate them, but it seems to me that one just has to go back to the NR treatment and do things like the NR part of the Lamb Shift. At any rate, I have enough to do to keep busy until you get back. I think that there is no use in worrying about publication of the MS until I understand better the interference of Coulomb and transverse parts, and all in all it would be best to wait till you got back. I wonder, however, if you would have any objection to having Miss Sparkes type a tentative copy, which I can form from your comments and Salpeter’s, in the case that she has time, since several people (Ferrell, Breit, etc.) have asked me for copies of the MS and they have been very decent in keeping me informed of what they are doing and thinking about similar things. If anything is finally published from this work, it will take a long time until it gets to the proper stage. I wonder how Breit’s bearing up under it. The Salpeter business is really schmelegant. A number of problems come to mind.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
337
Incidentally, Salpeter says that Kroll et all, Karplus et all, Baranger are all writing things to publish.517 Yours, Gerry
[546] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 19.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, Thank you for your letter of 15th Feb.518 I have no useful comments on your points (a) or (b). As regards (c) I do not object to using transformations involving free propagators as intermediate states. Only one has to be careful, because one can get caught out. It is always all right if you can satisfy yourself that in a space-time representation the propagators only act for short enough time (or alternatively that the main weight comes from states of very high energy). But the higher the order of the terms, the harder it will be to see through this. Even then, of course, one can get caught out, as Woodward’s problem shows, but this, I think, is a very special situation because one is calculating a very small effect, and one really has a position where both the zero-order and the first-order terms are extremely small, only as it happens the zero-order one is even smaller than the other. In this connection we had a nice talk from Wick about the “impulse approximation” used in treating the collision of mesons with deuterons &c, where the usual procedure is to take the n − p interaction into account exactly in the ground state wave function but neglects it in all the propagators. This can be shown to be the first step of a rigorous expansion (though its convergence is not proved) and the reason for 517
See N.M. Kroll and F. Pollock, ‘Relative Corrections to the Hyperfine Structure and the Fine Structure Constant’, Phys. Rev. 84, 876–88 (1952); M. Baranger, ‘Relativistic Corrections to the Lamb Shift’, Phys. Rev. 85, 1064 (1952). 518 Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls, 15.2.1952, Peierls Papers, Supp., C.51.
April 7, 2009
12:11
338
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
expecting it to work is just again that the propagators are required only over short time intervals. A paper by Wick and Chew on the subject is being published.519 As for positronium, Low’s calculation seems to be quite under control, and his answer agrees with what Karplus gets by a different method. Karplus is coming here next week, and it will presumably all get sorted out then. I’m rather disturbed by what you report about Radcliffe’s progress. I’m writing to him separately, and I hope this will endorse what you are telling him. I agree with you about Woodward’s problem that the non-relativistic approach to the first-order terms should give very nearly the right answer, but it is still desirable to discuss the more accurate expression and show that the rest is indeed negligible. I think it would be a good idea if he, or you and he jointly, were to publish the remark that one cannot neglect first-order terms, and also give the result by the simple method, leaving for a later paper the more pedantic treatment. This is desirable because the point is likely to be quoted by Levinger (and was referred to in his New York talk) so it is important to have it on record in a tidy manner. Would you discuss this with Woodward?520 I did not mean to suggest that there was anything fundamental in not using specific representations of the Dirac matrices. Certainly where a calculation has been done, and is not too laborious there is no sense in going back and doing it another way. My remark was intended merely to point out that the other approach often simplifies life and should be borne in mind as a possibility, either for making a calculation more convenient, or for making it easier to write up. I do not quite understand why you think it is important to treat the 2s state. For the K-absorption edge one wants to have the energy difference between the atom with and without the K electron, and in the K − L emission line one presumably is concerned with the transition 1s − 2p. But in either case it is, of course, important to discuss what 519
Geoffrey F. Chew and Gian Carlo Wick, ‘The Impulse Approximation’, Phys. Rev. 85, 636–642 (1952). 520 See letter [532], note 452.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
339
happens to the rest of the electrons, if the K-electron is removed, or transferred to the L-shell. With the question of the comparison between your term and the Breit term I meant primarily the point that, if one uses product wave functions they are identical. This follows in a straightforward manner by an integration by parts. Probably this fact is know, but it would be useful to have a reference. Even though you have already returned the proofs it may not be too late to add a footnote, or a note at the end, containing a brief reference to this point (even the bare statement about the equivalence without derivation, would be helpful) and if you like a reference to Breit. It is worth asking the editor whether this would be possible without inconvenience. It may well be that the type has not yet been broken into pages, or if it has, that there is room at the end for a note, I feel pretty sure that it would not have gone to press yet. Another point made by Low is that in the logarithmic terms of the finite structure which you derive in your calculation the leading terms come entirely from transitions in which two pairs are created. To that order the same result should therefore be obtainable from the A2 terms in the non-relativistic equation for both particles. These presumably give a logarithmic divergence at the upper end, and this should be cut off at mc. This should give your logarithm in a simple manner. If after you see the students’ work you think there is a reasonable chance of some of them doing your question, go ahead with it.521 There is no great harm done even if one question is too hard, it just limits their choice a little. We have actually one question fewer than last year, so if you can think of another nice question that is fine, but otherwise let it go. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
521
This refers to an examination paper drafted by Gerry Brown for his hydrodynamics course.
April 7, 2009
12:11
340
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[547] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 23.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, I see no reason why you should not have a report of your calculations typed out, even it they are not ready yet for publication.522 If there is any clash between this and other typing jobs, this is for Kynch to settle.523 If it can be done, you should consider whether it would not be worthwhile duplicating it. One always needs more copies than one thinks, and also it is much easier to get the formulae in and correct typing errors. But it does mean somewhat more work and expense. I had also a letter from Breit in which he pointed out that he had previously published a formula equivalent to yours. I replied politely that it was not quite the same thing, since in his case it came from an equation (6) which has no solutions, and which should be understood to be applied in some sense to the positive parts only. In general one expects corrections from the negative or pair production parts which are left out, and in your other paper it is evident that indeed there are such corrections. So it is a new result that in this particular problem there aren’t (except for vacuum polarization terms, which ought to exist, already in the case of a a single electron near a heavy nucleus. Have you considered how important these should be in relation to the corrections Sheila Brenner is working on?) I agreed with Breit, however, that you ought to quote him, and told him I had suggested you should try and get the reference inserted. If that failed, we would have to consider what we could do about it (presumably nothing). I spent some time trying to understand the proof about my general commutation laws which you gave me just when I left. I have come to the conclusion that it does not wash. The point is that you assume that 522
See Gerry Brown’s request in letter [545]. George Kynch, who had been lecturer of mathematical physics since 1941, had taken over administrative duties for the department while Rudolf Peierls was on leave in Princeton. 523
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
341
both the original and the modified problem have a Lagrangian and a Hamiltonian which are linked by the usual relation H = pq˙ − L However, this is correct only apart from the order of factors, since in the general case p will not commute with q. ˙ On the other hand you make use of the Taylor expansion ˙ + ∂L δ + · · · L(φ, φ˙ + δ) = L(φ, φ) ∂ φ˙ This again in general gets the factors in the wrong order, since with noncommuting variables one has to form the Taylor series by inserting the [. . . ]524 in every product in the place where a factor has been removed by differentiation. As your equations stand they are therefore wrong by two commutators, and the job is to prove that these two errors just cancel. Disregarding the order of factors I have known for a long time how to get the result. One can try to restrict the theorem to such cases (limiting both the nature of the original Lagrangian and the operator A whose commutator is desired) that the difficulty does not arise. But this means discussing an awful lot of specific cases in order to make sure one does not rule out any case of practical interest. I am just making another attempt to write up this stuff, and I am still stuck at the same point. I have invented a few more tricks, but they are all not strong enough. I have here a set of lecture notes by Dyson on field theory (given at Cornell). These were on sale, and after seeing them I wanted to get a second copy for the department, but I was too late. Actually, most people here missed the bus. So you will have to wait for these until I get back. I expect to find a queue all lined up for them! Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls] 524
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
342
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[548] M. Chr´ etien to Rudolf Peierls Birmingham, 24.2.1952 Dear Professor Peierls, Many thanks for your many letters. I progressed very much along the same lines, although with less success. 2 First to your question, why call a2a+p2 a Macmanus-form function. I’m afraid I have no other excuse for this than temporal mental blackout. I used it only for two days or so, unfortunately just at the time when I sent my letter. 4 I had already calculated the Fourier transform of a4a+p4 when I got √ 4π K1 (ia2 t2 − r 2 ), your letter. The result was f (r, t) = −2i(2π)−3 √ta2 −r 2 which I think is identical with yours. Now to the vacuum current. After evaluating the traces I get (In the formula I quoted last time the sign of Lµν was wrong): (2π)3 Bµν (p) 1 2 [g(ps−q)g(pσ−q)δµν ds dσ d4 q = −4e g(q) +g(ps−q)(1−σ)gν (pσ−q)+(1−s)gµ ·(1−σ)gν ]δ((q−p)2 +m2 ) g(ps−q)g(pσ−q) [pµ q ν −2q µ q ν −δµν (pq)] q µ (p2 −2(pq)) δ(ps−q)(1−σ)gν (pσ−q) 1 + µ ν 2 g(p) q (p −2(pq)) g(ps−q)(1−σ)g (pσ−q) (p2 −2(pq)) (1−s)gµ (ps−q)(1−σ)gν (pσ−q) 1 δ((q−p)2 +m2 ) 2 −4e ds dσ d4 q · [q µ gν (q+(σ−s)p) · 2 2 q +m 2 +q ν gµ (q+(σ−s)p)+(s−σ)gµν (q+(σ−s)p)]δ(q 2 +m2 ) If I use ((q − p)2 + m2 )δ((q − p)2 + m2 ) = D I get your result, apart from the sign of the last bracket and the absence of its last term,∗ which you ∗ The
one with gµν =
∂ ∂ ∂qµ ∂qν g(q
+ (σ − s)p).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
343
may have omitted by mistake or some other reasons. Now you see (i.e. I believe you see) that putting p = 0 gives Bµν (0) = 0. Unfortunately, I have no believe in the validity of my formula for p = 0. I have to confess the following sins, which you will have noticed already: In the calculation of ψ1 (k) I used the wave equation to reduce /−k /s) + m)ψ0 (r − k) to ik! / (l − s)ψ0 (r − k) in the current one ψ1 ∼ · · · (i(r 1 ψ1 (k) Taking vacuum expectation values gives a gets terms like ir!/ +m /+ factor δ(p − k) and putting p equal to 0 gives ir!/ 1+m ψ1 (0) = ir!/ 1+m (ir! m)ψ1 (0) = ψ1 (0) If one uses the wave equation first and puts then p equal to 0 one gets 0 instead. Thus I recalculated jµ (0) from the beginning and got the result 3
(2π) Bµν (0) =
g(q)δµν
2g2 1− 2 q + m2
1 ν µ µ ν − (g (q) · q + g (q)q ) 2
× δ(q 2 + m2 ) This is different from the result I obtain by putting p to zero in your formula by the factor 12 in front of the second term, but it does not seem to give a vanishing Bµν (0) neither. Finally, I couldn’t understand, why or how you get the above Bµν to be proportional to g(−m2 ). I transformed the second term by part[ial] int[egration], thus getting rid of the derivatives of g, replaced δ /(q 2 ) + m2 by −δ(q 2 + m2 )/q 2 + m2 and so got, using rather clean methods π (2π)3 Bµν (0) = −2 m2 δµν g(−m2 ) 2 From your formula I get a factor 3 instead of 2. I’m pretty sure you’ll find some snags in my above considerations. After the last few days’ hunt for the wrong signs and other mistakes in my notes I feel rather dim and so would be very grateful for any sort of hints, kicks and suggestions. Once more many thanks and the best wishes, M. Chr´etien
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
344
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[549] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham], 27.2.1952 Dear Prof, Thanks for the letter of 19th February.525 Since I want to keep you informed of what I’m doing, I’m writing in considerable detail, but am sending a CC to Salpeter so the effort will not be wasted in case you are not interested. a) I took the Fourier transform of this term coming from two transverse photons: and found the interaction to be 3 1 i m Ry −imr12 −imr ) − 2 me + 4πδ(r12 ) − 3 (1 − e M π mc r12 r12 where the real part gives energy corrections. (The imaginary part doesn’t give simply transition probabilities, but also hangovers from the second order Hamiltonian.) It is easy to evaluate the effect on the energy in hydrogen in which case one obtains 1s: −4.54 Mc. 2s: −0.46 Mc.
p states: of order α or less
The latter figure is precisely what E2 S526 gets from adding up the log contribution from the case where the intermediate states consist of states with both particles in negative energies, and another term where only the electron goes to a negative energy state. The final two terms on the RHS of (1) always cancel so that one is left only with the 1 Q.P. : 3 (1 − e−imr ) r12 this is equally well 2 525 526
Letter [546]. E.E. Salpeter.
sin2 (mr/2) 3 r12
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
345
b) I checked the calculation that Ravenhall and I made for the effect of pair production of the fine structure:
and got an answer twice as large as what E2 S would have gotten if he had evaluated his term for this case. (I don’t like this factor 4 in the denominator of a projection operator.) He doesn’t actually evaluate this, but evaluates the difference between this term and the term one would get evaluating the corresponding Breit term. (negative energy states instead of pair production.) Now in the way things were done in Breit, Brown and Arfken,527 the Dirac function was inserted for the electron. Hence no corrections of order m/M were taken into account in evaluating the fine structure, and one should simply add the m/M corrections from pair production to our results. (The non m/M -dependent corrections will be the same any way one looks at it.) In the end, I get the same answer as E2 S to add on to B2 A. I’m checking this carefully, however. c) The simplest way to handle the retardation of the Coulomb potential seems to be to go back to the old fashioned perturbation theory as done by Ferrell and Salpeter. I’m checking their work carefully and am trying to put things into a neat form. I can’t find in E2 S’s work any terms from
Coulomb transverse 527
G. Breit, G.E. Brown and G.B. Arfken, ‘The Effect of Nuclear Motion on the Hyperfine Structure of Hydrogen’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1299–1304 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
346
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
these seem to me to come in this order. I’m almost sure that they do not in his work, because one can get all of his results [. . . ]528 from non-relativistic functions for the case when one +rp hat on is exchanged and no reference is made to the possibility of pair production. (This latter seems to be important for HFS). This ought to complete the FS of hydrogen to this order, and I’ll have all factors collected before you get back. d) Simultaneously I’m carrying through the calculation of FS and HFS corrections in positronium, which are not much different except that in a) positrons go down to negative energy states and b) etc. The connection of this perturbation scheme with the BS eqn. is no[w] fairly obvious to me: the perturbation scheme is simply a development in powers of the coupling constant of the BS eqn. (Or better, a development in terms of the part of the Hamiltonian assumed to be small). To date I have not had to know the fourth components of the two particles any more accurately than their rest-mass energy; if one wishes to know the fourth components more precisely, it seems desirable to go back to the BS eqn, altho this too can be done (from my point of view) a bit more visually and therefore it is perhaps easier to write things down, altho that is a matter of taste. I consider it an advantage not to work in the CM system and to use Feynman’s integration tricks; after one is more or less accustomed to them it ought to go easier — I don’t know. Yours sincerely, Gerry [550] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 28.2.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, I spent a useful day at Columbia yesterday, and met Kroll. He told me that Karplus & Co had also worked out the correction to the hydrogen 528
Missing in manuscript.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
347
hfs, treating both the Dirac and the anomalous moment as if they were given by Dirac theory. The correction factor is 1+
m 3α m log π M M
The best experimental determination of 137 from the hfs, without the correction is now 137.03652 I don’t remember the exact limit of error, but I would guess it is about 100 unites of the last quoted digit, or perhaps somewhat less. The best determination from the fine structure, which is done with P states and therefore does not involve any correction, except for the Schwinger moment correction, (which, of course, is allowed for), is 137.0348 ± 0.0015 We discussed the question how one should allow for the hfs corrections. If one imagines these worked out from a non-relativistic equation, one should get them almost right, since that equation is correct to first order in 1/M , and will therefore merely leave the argument of the log uncertain. Now such an equation, which would describe the meson part of the moment through a Pauli term, should be right except for the uncertainty of the log, and also except for structure effects which, however, are likely to be even smaller than the uncertainty of the log. Tomorrow, Karplus is coming here to talk about positronium, and I hope to learn a lot, though whether I can transmit what I have learnt is the next question. I have now understood a lot more about commutation laws. Concerning the question whether the Lagrangian L + λA and the Hamiltonian H −λA are always equivalent, the position is as follows. In order to avoid complications about the construction of the unmodified ordered Lagrangian and Hamiltonian, I have restricted myself to the case in which L is quadratic in the first time derivatives, the quadratic term having constant coefficients. There may also be a linear term, whose coefficients may be arbitrary functions of the wave functions: 1 i 1 L = Cαβ φ˙ α φ˙ β + (fα φα + φα fα ) + (gα φ˙α − φ˙α gα ) − V 2 2 2
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
348
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
where f, g, and V are functions of the φ. I have not written here the dependence on the space coordinates, but this gives no complication. I can then prove the modified Hamiltonian and Lagrangian are equivalent to first order, if the modifying term is either one of the φ or one of the φ˙ or, of course, any linear combination. This is enough to derive my form of the commutator between φα (x, t) and φσ (x , t ), but not for a more general function. To construct the expression for a more general A, it ˙ 529 (i) is still true without further is also correct (i) for Aφ (ii) for Aφ[..] restriction. (ii) is, however, not true, unless the f and g are further restricted. If f and g happen to be linear in the φ this is certainly sufficient. f may be quadratic in the φ, provided there are certain symmetry properties, which mean essentially that fα is the derivative of a cubic function of the φ with respect to φα . I don’t believe one can make the g quadratic and still have the equation right independently of the f . It is likely however, that one can have a more general case in which there are certain relations between the f and the g, but this is still too complicated for me. That this is not idle fussing can be seen by taking, in a problem of one degree of freedom, the Lagrangian 1 1 ˙ 3 ) − V (q) L = q˙2 + (q 3 q˙ + qq 2 2 Then the theorem in question is not true if A contains a term q˙3 or higher. Hence both your and Dyson’s proof would seem to be a bogus. In the actual cases of physical interest the f are never more than quadratic (e.g. interaction of charged scalar or pseudoscalar mesons with the electromagnetic field) but I am not quite clear how generally they satisfy the required identities. The charged meson case contains both f and g terms, and therefore is not transparent. I have, however, written everything out for that case, and it seems to be all right. There is just a hope one might save the general theorem nevertheless if in the case of cubic f , for example, there are several ways of writing the Hamiltonian which all give the same unmodified equations of motion, but different modified ones, and the theorem might then hold for one 529
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
349
of these form[s]. But I doubt it. This is quite academic, provided the theorem does hold in the cases that occur in practice. (Also academic is the question whether the breakdown of this theorem necessarily means a breakdown in my general expression for the commutator, but I suspect it does.) In all this, I have referred only to Boson fields. In Fermion fields, where the Lagrangian is linear in the first time derivatives, everything is much easier, and there are, as far as I can see, no restrictive conditions. I also believe that, once I have straightened out the Boson case, the case of mixed fields, will give no trouble. However, these limitations show that one will have to learn a good deal more before one can be confident that the method will apply without trouble to non-Hamiltonian systems. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
[551] Rudolf Peierls to M. Chr´ etien [Princeton], 1.3.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Chr´etien Thank you for your letter with a lot of useful formulae. I am glad we agree more or less on the result of the calculation for finite p (your notation). You may well be right about the sign of the last part, I had checked mine, but I am never sure about signs. The reason for omitting the term in the second derivative of g was the following: you can interchange s and σ, the effect of which is to change the sign of p in the argument of g. At the time you may also change the sign of q, which is a variable of integration, and by then you have reversed the whole argument, its second derivative is also even, so the function has not changed. However, the s-[. . . ]530 factor outside has changed sign. It is, I think quite legitimate to use the properties of the δ-function 530
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
350
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
to reduce your expression to mine, as long as p = 0, since then the denominator does not vanish (or vanishes only in special cases, which do not contribute very much) but as you say one must be very careful in the limit p = 0 In stating that the answer involves g (−m2 ) I had also been careless about this, and had also used your identity δ (x) = −δ(x)/x. As my coefficients were then, one could then cancel everything but a term pr gρ δ(p + m2 ) = 2pr pν g (p2 )δ(p2 + m2 ). If you use Lorentz invariance, you can argue that this product vanishes if µ = ν and that the integrals involving squares of the components are equal. Then the integral can be expressed in terms of p2 g (p2 )(p2 − m2 ). However, I checked the coefficient in this derivation again in order to explain it to you, and I cannot make it come out the same way. I must have made an algebraic error. It does not matter anyway, because I no longer believe the identity, see below. I have checked that with your signs and coefficients one gets in the same way something proportional to g(−m2 ). However, I do not understand how you can get a finite answer from this. If one integrates over the time component of q first and thereby eliminates the [..]531 function, one gets apart from factors d3 θ/ Q2 − m2 where Q is the space part of q, and I do not see how this can come to anything but infinity. The “rather clean methods” by which you did this were presumably something like field theory, but this means attributing a finite value to a divergent integral by a convention, and if we can possibly help it this is to be avoided, because we are going to all this trouble just in order not to have to use recipes for divergent integrals. We cannot help some of this, because any four-dimensional Fourier transform of an invariant function is in some sense divergent, since an integration over each hyperboloid gives infinity, so one must not do this integration first. But I still hope we need not use conventions on other places. At any rate the Fourier transform if done the wrong way gives merely an indefinite answer not simply plus infinity. In any case, 531
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
351
something must be wrong, since any expression which depends only on g(−m2 ) must be identical with the corresponding result in the local theory and there one knows that a reasonable convention can make the vacuum polarisation zero or infinity, but never finite. Now about the identity δ1 (x) = −δ(x)/x. One can get this in two ways (perhaps more). One would be to take the correct identity xδ(x)+ δ(x) = 0 and divide by x, but that is not very convincing. The way I did it was to say δ(x) can be written as
1 1 1 − δ(x) = 2πi x + i x − i →0 because if this is multiplied by any function which is analytic near x = 0, and integrated, the integral reduces to the integral of 1/x times the other factor over an infinitesimal countour around the origin. On the other hand, the principal value of 1/x can be defined as
1 1 1 + 2 x + i x − i →0 Hence, 1 δ(x) = x 4πi
1 x + i
=
2
1 + x − i
→0
1 1 1 1 ∂ − = − g (x) 4π ∂x x + i x − i 2
I just notice that my identity is not the same as yours, but differs by a factor 12 . However, we really have no business to take the t[w]o infinitesimal imaginary parts equal. One should really use a small in representing the [. . . ]532 function and say δ in representing the principal part. In that case the answer will depend on the order in which they go to zero, and by putting in an arbitrary ratio between them one can get almost anything. 532
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
352
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
There is also a more physical reasoning why one should not put p = 0 before carrying out the integration. Take as an example an expression like g(q − ps). Since g only depends on the square of the four vector, the argument is q 2 + sp2 − 2spq. Since this term is multiplied by a delta function of (p − q)2 m2 , the argument of g can be reduced to −m2 +2(−s)pq−(1−s2 )p2 . The last term is unimportant, but the second shows that as one integrates over q, the argument of g will increase indefinitely as q increases in certain directions, for any finite p, however small. On the other hand, if we put p = 0 the argument of p remains constant. The difference would be unimportant if the integral converged well, so that only small values of q contributed anyway, but since it does not, the point may be of decisive importance. It will certainly help to reduce the integral, so far I have only looked at single terms, but there it seemed that even this effect was not sufficient to give divergence, since the integration over the component of q at right angles to p was sufficient to give divergence, unless the integration over the component parallel to q, taken by itself, were to vanish. This certainly is not true if one treats each term separately, but there might be hidden cancelations. I was proposing to work out the integral for finite p with a specific function g. The McManus function is very suitable, since the number of its poles is small, so that one could use contour integration. But the discussion of the contours at large distance will give some trouble, and also in this kind of work one has to be sure of one’s signs, and so far I have not felt capable of doing this. Would you feel like having a look at it? If all this fails, one may still be able to argue that the non-gaugeinvariant part should be eliminated by regularization. This could be interpreted as a “realistic” regularization, since meson fields will give a similar term of opposite sign (cf. Feldman, Phys. Rev. 76, 1369, (1949)).533 This would then allow us to calculate the next term, the charge renormalization, which now certainly ought to be finite, since for this term realistic renormalizarion does not help. But I cannot pretend that this thought makes me very happy. Another approach is to say that, since the theory is gauge invariant, the B term must vanish if it is finite. It might be possible to see that it 533
David Feldmann, ‘On Realistic Field Theories and the Polarization of the Vacuum’, Phys. Rev. 76, 1369–1375 (1949).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
353
cannot be infinite, by looking at the expression in coordinate space. At first this seems difficult, because one knows little about the properties of g−1 in coordinate space. But here again the McManus function provides a useful illustration, since its inverse is a differential operator. Using this, I thought at one time I could convince myself that the expression could not diverge, but I am no longer sure of this, since one has to worry about all sorts of cases, for example that in which the singularities of the two S functions lie on each other’s light cone &c. If you can see through this mess, it would be quite sufficient to know that the term is not infinite. Yours sincerely, [Rudolf Peierls]
[552] Rudolf Peierls to P.A.M. Dirac [Princeton], 3.3.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Dirac, I am afraid I have not carried the investigations of the generalized commutation laws as far as I should have mainly because I was most interested in the question how one could apply these to non-Hamiltonian formalism. I am still held up by some aspects of this problem though there exists a[t] least one case of a non-Hamiltonian theory where everything seems to go through all right. I have however just recently resumed the study of the validity of these relations in theories where the canonical scheme applies, and I can make the following statements: 1. In classical theory, where one need not consider the order of the factors, the expression Dab − ba (in the notation of my Bombay lecture) defined a generalized [. . . ]534 Poisson bracket which can generally be proved to coincide with the ordinary P.B. when the quantities a and b refer to the same time. D
534
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
354
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
2. In a non-standard case (in your terminology) these generalized P.B. are still unambiguously defined. I have not yet given any general proof that they are equivalent to the canonical ones since I find the several existing method[s] for treating this case in general rather hard to follow. I have, however, looked specifically at the case of the electromagnetic field, and at the case of vector mesons, without coupling, and shown that the equivalence holds. The same is still true in quantum theory, since the uncoupled equations are linear and the question of the order of factors does not arise. 3. In the case of quantum theory and non-linear equations, my commutators are derived from an ordered Lagrangian, whereas the canonical scheme starts from an ordered Hamiltonian. For the comparison one must therefore have a method of constructing an ordered H and ordered L which give the same equations of motion. This cannot be done in all generality, but one can do it for a Lagrangian of the form . . . . . . d3 rCαβ ψα ψβ +fα ψα + ψα fα + i(gα ψα − ψα gα ) − V where Cαβ are constants (I have so far assumed a non-vanishing determinant, and thus restricted myself to the standard case again) fα gα and V may depend in any manner on the field variables [..]535 but not on their time derivatives. If I then form Dab − Dab where a and b are functions of the field variables at times t1 and t2 respectively, I can still prove equivalence with the canonical P.B. in the limit t1 = t2 (i) if a is one of the ψα or its time derivative (ii) for an arbitrary a provided that the fα and gα satisfy certain identities which need further clarification, but which seem to hold in all cases that occur in practice. For instance, it is sufficient that the f and g are linear in the ψ. This still excludes, for instance, the case of mesons interacting with an electromagnetic field. But I have looked at the case of a charged scalar meson field coupled to the electromagnetic field, and the 535
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
355
identities are still all right. I can construct cases (with apparently no physical importance) in which the identities break down, but the only means that an auxiliary theorem I have used in the proof fails, and the general expression for the commutator might still be all right. In any case (i) is sufficient to obtain the commutators between the field variables themselves. As you see, I have no clear proof, yet that covers vector mesons coupled to other fields, but I think it is most unlikely that any special complications will turn up. I think it is the most attractive feature of these commutation laws that they seem to work so universally, without specifying the nature of the theory in any way. For example, in vacuum electrodynamics, one can use them to derive directly the commutators between the field strength at any two points in space-time, without ever defining a vector potential. But of course one still needs the vector potential to describe the interaction with matter (I have some vague ideas how one might eliminate the vector potential there, too, from the definitions and work with field strengths alone, but it is not yet clear whether this will work.) I am spending a most useful and enjoyable term at the Institute, many people here ask about you frequently and send their greetings to all of you. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[553] Rudolf Peierls to Gerry Brown [Princeton], 3.3.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Gerry, I shall try to report on Karplus’s talk. The main impression was that an incredible amount of virtuosity was not only used in this calculation,
April 7, 2009
12:11
356
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
but was really required to get over some of the snags. The mathematical technique used was that from a paper by Schwinger in the Proc. Nat. Acad.536 which is apparently more or less equivalent to BetheSalpeter. This is not very important. The main difficulty was that, in order to avoid difficulties we know only too well, one has to separate longitudinal and transverse photons. This makes the calculation non-covariant. Now one term in this calculation contains an infra-red divergence, which should be cancelled against another coming from a charge-renormalization graph. This, of course, diverges at high energies, and the subtraction of both divergences should be done co-variantly to be sure one gets a reasonable answer. The trick how this is done is not to notice that the wave function which appears in the questionable term, and which is the solution of the non-co-variant equation with longitudinal interaction only can be replaced by one in which transverse effects are allowed for as well and which to the required order is covariant. This is done by adding in corrections which really come from other graphs. The wave function is constructed by applying an integral operator to the non-relativistic wave function. This creates small correction terms everywhere, and larger corrections near the origin. One then juggles the expression around, subtracting suitable things which are easy to evaluate until one is left with something that matters only at short distances. This is only one of many tricks, but it seemed the most impressive one. You probably won’t understand much of this exposition, I am not sure I do. The result is interesting by the absence of any logarithm, Oppenheimer felt sure that was due to the peculiar cancellation one always gets in positronium, because the g-factors of the two particles are opposite and equal, but Karplus was not at all sure whether he agreed with this. He gave a list of contributions from the various terms, expressed in φ2 (0): units of 2πα m2
536
J.Schwinger, ‘On the Green’s Functions of Quantized Fields: I’, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci US 37, 452–455 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
357
1 σ1 σ2 3 (vac. polarisation) & vice versa (vertex) the second being an iteration of a first − order graph (Pirenne) (This is the second − order affect of the above)
0 1σ σ1 σ2 3π −
3α 1 σ1 σ2 2π 3
s2 /2 −
8 α s2 · 9π 2 α s2 −1 (1−log 2) 2 π
* 1
+1α−
Total splitting The bracket is 1 − 0.0052.
7 3
4α s2 π 2
1−
41 3 α + log 2 21 7 π
I don’t know whether you know how Deutsch’s experiment is done. He measures the Zeeman effect, which is strictly second-order, because of the cancellation of the g factors. In the formula for the second-effect everything is known except the splitting in the denominator. (one can see that all other levels are too far away to give any important contribution.) Deutsch derives a splitting of (2.032 ± 0.003) × 105 Megacycles. He did not, however, allow for the Schwinger correction to the magnetic moment, and if this is done the splitting becomes 2.037. Karplus gets 2.034, which agrees within the experimental error. In presenting his calculations, he had at one stage a formula [..]537 which he claimed to give the total correction to the hydrogen hfs, if one 537
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
358
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
puts the proton mass in. This is evidently the result I got from Kroll and quoted in my last letter, only there it was not clear which way the correction went (or what was being corrected, whereas the formula seems clear. In the positronium case this simply gives one of many terms. If the implication in your last letter (of Feb. 27)538 which has just arrived, is that you can calculate the positronium case by less formidable means, good luck to you. I am very interested in your account of what you are doing — I cannot follow all of it, partly because I am really not up to date, and partly because of the liberal sprinkling of expressions like ,,this term” &c. which I usually find hard to hitch to anything. However, I hope this remark and the lack of any more constructive response won’t discourage you from continuing to let me know what you are doing. Best wishes, [Rudolf Peierls]
[554] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham], 10.3.1952 Dear Prof, Thanks very much for your account of Karplus’s seminar.539 It helps things a lot. May I say first of all that I haven’t gotten as yet where the I[nfrared] catastrophes come in — that is, in the calculation of the Lamb-shift terms, and I can well believe what you have to say about them, but I think that they can be handled in a fairly straightforward manner following some of Dyson’s ideas on the subject which he gave while here. I would be very grateful if you would check with someone on the sign of Karplus’s correction to the hydrogen HFS. By taking the next 538 539
Letter [549]. Letter [553].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
359
term in m/M in my exchange of two transverse photons, I get just the same term except that mine has a plus sign where his has a minus sign. (Mine would make the triplet state lie higher than the singlet still more). If my answer is wrong, then I think it is because I’ve omitted other effects, since the whole process of getting this next term involves a simple expansion of an already integrated term and the first term in this expansion agrees with Salpeter. This is just the order where, from Low’s argument, corrections to the HFS should first come in. ((m/M )2 α3 Ry). You will be surprised to receive in not too long a time, a rather weighty contribution from me — a cyclostyled copy of this draft. I’ve added lots of things so that the fine structure in hydrogen is corrected to the order that Salpeter does it, and am now putting in some calculations on positronium and will add a few comments on helium. The whole things is getting quite long, and if the cost runs too high in putting it out, I’ll share it with the dept., but we can talk about that when you get back here. I’ve also been putting in some comments on the use of my method as an expansion of the BS equation, since I think that the expansion is done in a much nicer form here than in Salpeter’s MS. I’m still not happy in any of the above about the terms where the unlike parts of the Coulomb potential and one transverse photon interfere. But I’m putting off consideration of that until I get the above stuff in shape and then during vacation, will really get after this interference term. It seems to me that this term[s] should contribute to the HFS. Kynch thought that the hydro question that I added was too easy,540 so we decided to tack onto it as ii: (ii) Under what condition can a velocity potential or a stream function or both be used to describe the motion of a fluid? I’ve discussed this briefly in class and it seems to me that it takes some thinking. It is the only question on “philosophy” on the exam. At any rate, there is still time for me to take the whole thing out, if you disagree with the question. Sheila’s work is not going too well at present since she is looking into a lot of questions in screening and since most people around here 540 This refers to hydrodynamics examination paper for a course Gerry Brown was teaching.
April 7, 2009
12:11
360
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
— except myself — have been pretty pessimistic about being able to estimate other screening from outer electrons, etc. to this accuracy. It seems to me that one important thing which has already been done is that we understand how much of the inner screening comes from magnetic and how much from Coulomb effects. But she has enough to do until you get back. Your letter made me more anxious than ever for Radcliffe to jump into this Positronium Lamb-shift. I don’t think things are so tough that he can’t get something out of it. As soon as lectures are over next week, I’ll get together with Woodward and we’ll probably get something on the γ-rays written up. Probably one can even get a sensible answer out of the problem if what’shis-name has done a calculation of the zero-order-term. I’m not at all anxious for you to get back from the States because the information you’ve been passing on has been a tremendous spur in getting a lot of things cleared up esp. about interpretation etc. and I find your letters much more intelligible than you think from your comments. I’m getting off the stats exam to you the end of this week. I think that there still is plenty of time — the questions are pretty straightforward to formulate. Sincerely, Gerry [555] Rudolf Peierls to P.A.M. Dirac [Princeton], 12.3.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Dirac, I should correct a statement I made in my last letter to you,541 before it leads to confusion. Under (3), when I talk about the case of quantized fields I said that the identities which ensure the validity of my general commutation laws for any two operators a and b were still valid in the 541
Letter [552].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
361
case of charged mesons interaction with the electromagnetic field. This turned out to be incorrect, owing to an algebraic error. In fact, the identities are not satisfied in this case, and this not only invalidates the auxiliary theorem used in the proof, but the general expression for the commutator does not hold. The position is therefore the following. My method leads to the construction of a generalized Poisson Bracket [. . . ]542 a,b. The identity [..]543 where the square bracket denotes the commutator, is always valid if a is one of the field variables, or its time derivative, or any linear combination of these. b may be anything. The rule is generally valid, including the order of factors, for any a for a restricted class of theories, but these do not cover all the cases of physical interest. However, once one knows the commutators between the field amplitudes and their time derivatives, the rest can be built up in the usual way, so that I do not believe this limitation seriously limits the usefulness of the relation. I have nearly completed my paper on this subject and shall send you a copy when it has been typed.544 Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls] [556] Claude Bloch to Rudolf Peierls Pasadena, 14.3.1952 Dear Professor Peierls, I thank you very much for your letter.545 I looked again into the question of the microscopic non-localizability. I do not think that the Fourier transform of the form function need be analytic. I suppose you get the condition of analyticity from the requirement that the form function F 542
Missing in carbon copy. Missing in carbon copy. 544 R.E. Peierls, ‘The commutation laws of relativistic field theory’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A214, 143–57 (1952). 545 Letter Rudolf Peierls to Claude Bloch, 26.2.1952, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b203, C.26. 543
April 7, 2009
12:11
362
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
considered as a function of s = (x − x )2 should fall off very rapidly as s becomes large. If one assumes an exponential decrease it turns out that the Fourier transform has to be analytic, but I think that this requirement is too strong. In fact I assume only a decrease as an inverse power of s. From any criterium I could think of this seems sufficient. Moreover, I think that the contributions of the neighbourhood of the light cannot in the best of the cases fall off faster than an inverse power of the three-dimensional distance. It seems then natural to assume the same law on the other direction. If one accepts this assumption, it turns out that the Fourier transform has to have a finite number of continuous and absolutely integrable derivatives. It is then possible to have timelike components only in the Fourier transform, provided the function matches smoothly at zero. As regard convergence, one would expect that the part of momentum space defined by the condition that all momentum vectors occuring in a self-energy integral [. . . ] have a finite four-dimensional length should be finite. This is all right for the following term
For this one, however:
the situation is not so nice. The vectors 1 and 2 have bounded components, but 3 and 4 have bounded components only if 2 is a time-like vector. This is why I make the assumption that the form function should have a Fourier transform with time-like components only. I must say that I am not very fond of this assumption. It makes many virtual transitions impossible, and I am afraid that it will lead to some unreasonable consequence. The fact, however, remains that, at least for interaction of the type ψ + uψ, the form function is unable to cut off all integrals at large momenta. There may, of course, be a less drastic way out of this
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
363
difficulty. I wonder if the same thing happens with the interactions you are considering. I thank you very much for your advice concerning next year, and particularly for proposing a stay in Birmingham. I would, in fact, be very interested in spending some time there when I go back to Europe, and I hope this possibility will still be open by then. With kindest regards, Yours very sincerely. C. Bloch
[557] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham] 18.3.1952 Dear Prof., I thought I would write you a short note describing the general state of affairs. First of all, I didn’t mean the comment about your being interested in the details of my letters two weeks or so ago the way that you understood it. In this particular letter I mentioned a number of details and referred to work of Salpeter’s which I didn’t think that you had looked into in this much details; consequently I didn’t want you to waste time trying to follow something which might have been inadequately explained.546 For those particular details it might have taken a prohibitive amount of work to show where everything came from and since some of the comments were not very carefully thought thru, it didn’t seem to be worthwhile to explain them. (& some of them were meant for Salpeter.) The end of this week I’m sending you off a copy of my screed which is now micrographed. I wrote up only the part thru hydrogen with some notes telling how to apply these particular calculations to positronium since the change-over is trivial — mostly it just means setting M equal 546
Letter Gerry Brown to Rudolf Ms.Eng.misc.b.204, C.51 and letter [554].
Peierls,
7.3.1952
Peierls
Papers,
April 7, 2009
364
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
to m, in the formluae already calculated. Now there are many parts of the screed which are not too well thought through, and on the whole it is not too consistent. However, the work was fairly involved and I wanted to get it together before the Easter vacations so that I wouldn’t be bothered with details over the vac and can really think thru some of the points concerned. I still get the opposite sign to Karplus in the HFS. On the whole I check Salpeter, except for a factor 2 which is in an insignificant term. I think there is no doubt that the method is correct, and I discussed the similarity of it to the BS method — which gives the same expression in every case I’ve looked up so far – and have managed to straighten up some sloppy points about “end-effects” of the Coulomb potential on a somewhat ununderstandable way to be sure, but it is clear to me how they should be handled, and I’ll accept criticism gratefully on the exposition. With all of these apologies, I’m sending the work on to you and will send it so that it will almost certainly get there before you have to leave in case you want some light reading on the boat. I want to get back much more on this other work of smearing things when you come back, but during your absence seemed a good time to clear up a number of points concerned with this perturbation theory, which seems to me a pretty powerful method as far as pure formalism is concerned — the perturbation procedure of Salpeter is pretty messy altho his handling of the equation and pairs, etc. is really beautiful. The hydro has really been enjoyable. I messed up a couple of lectures at the beginning of the term or rather middle (wave motion of all things) and gave one ill-chosen problem sheet, but the last few weeks have been going very smoothly and I think that my lectures have been quite reasonable. I haven’t been stumbling in class much at all — not once for two or three weeks now. I like the students — most of them — very much. I’ve covered just up thru viscosity, but no sound, turbulence, shock waves, etc. One reason that everything has gone so well this term is that I’ve been in wonderful health — not even the trace of a cold thus far — and I feel quite happy about the lectures now altho it was a bit of a strain to begin with. I’ll be very happy for you to get back with respect to Sheila’s problem, which is coming out at the sides now. One trouble is that I’m
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
365
the only optimistic person w[ith] r[espect] t[o] it and she’s getting a somewhat defeatist attitude. There are some rather complicated articles by Bertha Swirles547 (Mrs. J.)548 on much the same thing and they look pretty horrible. (1936)549 Still, I think that with a little sense as to where to look one can really begin to understand a bit about the dynamics of screening. Also, Radcliffe is not progressing too fast. I try to imbue him with optimism, too — in fact I spend a lot of my time doing just that about the dept. now — but he hasn’t understood a lot of things about bound states in Lamb shift yet. Gerry
[558] Gerry Brown to Rudolf Peierls [Birmingham] 25.3.1952 Dear Prof., Last week I sent off a mimeographed copy of my screed to you. I’m afraid it does not fit your economy requirements, but on the whole the costs didn’t run very high and I’ll be glad to pay part of it. About the only factor in a longer screed is the paper – postage is negligible when sent by printed matter rates. I discovered in messing around today that the factor for the HFS is probably not right because I made a slip in a factor calculating the effect of interference with the longitudinal part of the interaction (retardation of Coulomb potential.) All in all, I’m trying to straighten up several points concerning the HFS which is considerably smaller than the FS and contains a number of troublesome terms. I wanted to get everything 547
Bertha Swirles (1903–99), studied at Girton College, Cambridge and G¨ ottingen; received her Ph.D. from Cambridge in 1929; later she taught at Manchester, Bristol, Imperial and Cambridge. 548 In 1940, Bertha Swirles had married Harold Jeffreys. 549 Bertha Swirles, ‘The Relativistic Interaction of Two Electrons in the SelfConsistent Field Method’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A157, 680 (1936).
April 7, 2009
12:11
366
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I now know or think put together in a form where I could communicate with people intelligently and on the whole most of the screed is ok. In especial, I’m trying to square away this whole business of interference between unlike parts of the potential and transverse photons. I think this may contribute to the HFS in the order Karplus calculated and this may be a difference between his and my calculations. I think I now know how to do this, tho. When you have mimeographed copies of the commutation laws, could you please send a copy to Dr. P.R. Zilsel550 Physical Dept. U of Conn. Storrs, Conn.? My friend Aadne Ore 551 is coming thru the department for a week late in May or early in June and I wrote him to see if he would talk on positron affinities, etc. He has done some exceedingly nice variational calculations of the Hylleras type. Woodward and I will be sending you a draft copy of a letter or something on γ-rays. The writing of this followed very much the RavenhallBrown pattern,552 except that John kept his temper. He objected very much to my anthropomorphisms and I to his formalities. But you can arbitrate. It isn’t very long. I don’t know whether you’re aware of the fact, or not (or whether we are perhaps not aware of some publications) but there seems to be no reasonable theory — even statistical — on screening in atoms and the work boils down pretty much to that described in Sommerfeld’s book, where he interjects a screening coefficient which is determined more or less empirically. As I see it, our job is to get an idea of how this screening constant is constituted, since by definition it is the difference between the theoretical term value in an unscreened field and the experimental term value. Thus, I’m not so sure one wants to separate off screening. 550
P.R. Zilsel was among Gregory Breit’s students at Yale at the same time as Gerry Brown was working with Breit. 551 Aadene Ore (1916–1980) was another one of Gerry Brown’s friends at Yale. He later worked at Chicago, Bergen and Oslo, increasingly working on physical chemistry. 552 See letter [507], note 343.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
367
Our terms give more or less a dynamic description (I mean they include magnetic effects) of screening. It is nice to know how much of it comes from magnetic effects etc. The present aim is to calculate the interaction of a 1s electron with the 1s, 2s and perhaps 2p shell in detail (or at least to get an answer for the interaction with the electrons concerned, and a relativistic answer.) Then to take care of the outer screening by some sort of statistical theory or something. This may be all wet — you don’t seem to be thinking this way. Anyway, we can have a good hash when you come back. I don’t think that Sheila will have wasted much time over it. Thus far only the 1s − 1s interaction has been calculated. Unfortunately I think that almost all effects will go the same way with Z so that there can’t be much separating off. About the only personal news is that — on your wife’s recommendation — I decided, or rather we, to get married in June. Also your wife wrote you a long letter yesterday and put a shilling stamp on it, but forgot to mark “Airmail” so that, if you receive no letters for a bit, this is the reason why. Yours, Gerry
[559] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 26.3.1952 Dear Peierls, Thank you very much for your letter and MS. First I must say, I did not know you were coming here Monday and Tuesday of next week. In fact, Bob Wilson553 asked me if there were any special time when I would be away from Ithaca because he was expecting you to come here and would arrange it so that you should come while I was here. I told him, any 553
Robert Wilson (1914–2000), had studied at Berkeley where he obtained his Ph.D. in 1940. After research at Princeton he joined the Manhattan Project. After the war he went to Harvard before, in 1947 joining Cornell University. In 1967 he assumed the directorship of the National Accelerator Laboratory.
April 7, 2009
12:11
368
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
time would suit me, except March 31 to April 3 inclusive when I shall be giving talks in Toronto. I hope you can arrange to be here some time outside these days. I am sorry this confusion has arisen. If you want to stay longer in Cornell there is no reason why you should not stay with us. Anyway, I want to see you and you should consider yourself invited for any time you chose. I hope you will have met Verena while she is in Princeton. Then you may already have straightened out your plans directly with her. She is unfortunately still very sick and exhausted, she has not been at all in good health since we came to Ithaca. I hope this week in Princeton may have done her some good. Next thing I have to say is thank you very much for getting me the F.R.S.554 This means a lot to me especially to my parents and I feel greatly indebted to you for it. Now, to answer your letter itself. I read the paper carefully555 and found it most illuminating. I am glad you have finally written this work up in an adequate way. Many things in it are new and exciting, especially Sec. 6 and the Appendix. I agree that my proof of the equivalence of your Equations 3.4 and 3.3 is “phoney”. It rested on the idea that λ itself could be considered as an additional field-variable with a canonical momentum which vanished identically. This argument seems to work all right for classical dynamics, but I never explored the complications that can arise with non-commuting quantities in the quantum case. I am sorry if I misled you and held up your work by making excessive claims for it. I feel, and have always felt, that it is very doubtful if any clear meaning can be attached to a quantized theory with a term like q˙3 in the Lagrangian. Your example shows just in what way the difficulties begin to show up in a case like this. For example take your equation (A.17a) p = q˙ + q 3 + 3λq˙2 δ(t − t ) 554
(A17.a)
Freeman Dyson had been elected Royal Society Fellow on 20th March 1952. Peierls’ paper on commutation laws of relativistic field theory. See letter [555], note 544. 555
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
369
which you use to deduce the discontinuity of q at t = t DA (q)t1 + 0) = −3q˙2
(A18)
Now if q is discontinuous at the time t1 , the value of q˙ there is in fact infinite or indeterminate. So we have to argue that the infinite term in q˙ is multiplied by λ and so gives no contribution to A.18 in the lowest order of λ. That is, we neglect the term ∞ × λ because λ is small! a procedure painfully familiar to us in quantum electrodynamics. But here I think one should be able to do better and take proper account of all the terms. I have not any clear opinions on the relation of these things to the Feynman quantisation method. I think it is in general the case that the Feynman method will be meaningful only when terms like q˙3 are absent from the Lagrangian, but I am not sure of this. Thus your examples might tell us something about the Feynman method and its limitations. Have you read an obscure paper of Schwinger Proceedings of the National Academy of sciences 37, 452, July 1951?556 Here he writes down an equation (8)
δ δL(x) = i
δ1
dx [L(x)δ L(x ) + − δL(x) δ L(x ) ]
δ2
which is in his notations almost the same as your commutation rule. However he does everything only formally and never stops to explain what anything means. I think his method will run up against just the same difficulties as yours if one applies it to Lagrangians other than the simplest (He concerns himself only with electrodynamics of particles of spin 0, 12 and 1). Looking forward to seeing you here. With many thanks, Freeman Dyson
556
See letter [553], note 536.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
370
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[560] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Princeton], 2.4.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, Thank you very much for your letter.557 I spent the last few days at Cornell, and found that Butler also thinks now he can get his results in a simpler way. From your rather brief description it looks as if the two methods are very similar, if not identical. One should make sure, however, that the one characteristic feature of Butler’s calculation, namely the occurence of a linear combination of the Bessel function and its derivative comes out correctly. Butler apparently can get this if he applies dispersion theory to the interaction of the neutron wave with the nucleus. I do not agree, however, that the protons are unpolarized. Consider, for example, the ground state of oxygen 17. This is a D state, and its spin is probably 5/2. This means that the neutron in the d wave can be absorbed only if its spin is parallel to its orbit. There is therefore strong correlation between neutron spin and orbit. On the other hand the proton spin is strongly correlated with the neutron spin, and there is a (rather complicated) correlation between the proton and neutron orbits. I feel unable to say, without calculation, how strong a proton polarization this will produce, and it may well be possible to see from general arguments that i[t] should be small, but I do not think this is obvious, or is established by the argument you give. Butler also has an approximation method of allowing for the Coulomb field, but I am not yet convinced that it is right. Thank you for your remarks about the final year students. In general it is not our job to disqualify potential research students completely. Of course, if it is obvious that a man is incapable of doing research it is not in his interests to make him apply, or to make him spend a year on trying to get somewhere, but in case of doubt we should not stop him. 557
Letter R.H. Dalitz Misc.Eng.misc.b205, C.75.
to
Rudolf
Peierls,
19.3.1952,
Peierls
Papers,
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
371
However, we have to put the names in an order of merit list. This is important because the number of DSIR grants is usually limited, and for this purpose the question is who shows the greatest promise on the basis of available knowledge. This list of merit can be revised after the examination; anyone who does very badly in the exam will usually have to go down in the list unless there are special circumstances. But normally the examination will not change our opinion much. I would guess that this year we can expect about three grants. My present impression is that the order should be: 1. Miss Brenner, 2. Marshall, 3. Wade, 4. Beasley. There is also a physicist, Thomas, who may want to come to us, I am not yet clear whether he would be on our quota. It would be very useful to have your comments on this order. It is particularly hard to compare Miss Brenner with the others, because she has already done a year’s research (or nearly) but it does not matter particularly, unless [s]he should go down to third place or worse, which does not seem likely to me. Yours sincerely, [R.E. Peierls]
[561] Rudolf Peierls to Claude Bloch [Princeton] 13.4.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Bloch, I have left your letter of 14 March for a long time without reply.558 This was partly in the hope that your promised typescript would materialize. You are quite right in saying that the condition on the form function with I stated in my last letter was too severe. We have restricted ourselves to functions of that kind, which, in fact have the property that “non-causal”effects along the light cone decrease exponentially with the time difference, but it is true that this is not strictly necessary. I had 558
Letter [556].
April 7, 2009
372
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
in mind largely the electromagnetic case where the Fourier transform of the form function must be unity for zero argument in order to ensure that the ordinary equations hold for long waves, and in that case it could vanish for space-like argument only if it were discontinuous, which would not do. However, it is not safe to generalize from this to our case. I have not made much progress with the apparent non-gauge invariant term. I was interested to see from your letter that the diagram which gives you the trouble in fourth order is, in fact, what in the electro-magnetic case would be a vacuum polarisation part, and this made me wonder whether my trouble and yours might be related. However, I would have to learn more about your calculations to be sure of this. It would also be very interesting to know whether the divergence you find is in the sense of the integral being mathematically ambiguous, or whether it can be expressed as an integral over a quantity of constant sign, so that it must definitely be regarded as infinite. I hope that when I get back to Birmingham in ten days time I shall join forces with Chr´etien, who has been doing the detailed calculation for my case, and that we shall soon have an answer. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[562] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer Birmingham, 2.5.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Robert, I saw to-day the people from Bristol who wanted to raise the problem of “zeta” mesons and can therefore clear up the mystery about what these particles are supposed to be. This term refers to cases which have been found in which two mesons are emitted from a start at an angle very much smaller than it is likely statistically and with nearly the same momentum. The Bristol people tend to interpret this as the emission of a short lived particle which then decays into two mesons with a reaction energy of a few MeV. You will probably have seen the note which
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
373
Brueckner and Watson wrote about this559 pointing out that very similar features can be o[b]tained if there is an attractive force between mesons which would influence the probability of their being emitted with small momentum difference. There is, of course, only a quantitative difference between these two descriptions and the experimental data are as yet insufficient to decide whether one is dealing with a sharply defined energy or with a broad resonance factor as Brueckner and Watson suggest. In any case it seems very likely that the phenomena itself is real. While I am writing may I thank you once more for letting me take the “refresher course” at the institute which helped me to catch up with other people’s ideas as well as sorting out my own and also for the extremely generous arrangements, which made everything so easy. With kindest regards, also to Kitty, Rudi
[563] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Zollikon-Z¨ urich, 14.8.1952 Lieber Herr Peierls. Ich habe mit einigem Interesse Ihre Arbeiten u ¨ ber die Definition der Poisson-Klammern gelesen. (1. Die im Bombay-Report560 , 2. das type-written Manuskript von Princeton561 — ich komme eben aus Les Houches zur¨ uck,562 wo ich u[nter] a[nderem] auch mit Rosenfeld diskutiert und diese Arbeiten ein 2. Mal wiedergelesen habe.) 559 Keith A Brueckner and Kenneth A. Watson, ‘Possibility of Obtaining Experimental Information Concerning the Meson-Meson Interaction’, Phys. Rev. 87, 621–22 (1952). 560 R. Peierls, ‘Commutation laws in relativistic field theory’, International Conference on elementary particles (1951). 561 R. Peierls, ‘The Commutation laws of the relativistic field theory’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A214, 143–57 (1952). 562 ´ ´ e de Wolfgang Pauli had lectured at the third summer school at the Ecole d’Et´ Physique Th´eoretique at Les Houches. See Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/1, p. 693.
April 7, 2009
12:11
374
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Seit der Konferenz in Kopenhagen im Juni563 habe ich mich etwas ausf¨ uhrlicher mit den Formfaktortheorien (siehe Peierls-McManus,564 Møller-Kristensen,565 Cl. Bloch566 ) besch¨aftigt. In dieser Verbindung, besonders im Hinblick auf die M¨ oglichkeit, Ihren Formalismus auf die Theorien a` la Møller-Kristensen (=M.-Kr.) anzuwenden, habe ich zun¨ achst einige Fragen, die sich — unabh¨ angig von der Lorentzinvarianz der Theorie — auf alle Theorien mit Translationsinvarianz beziehen. 1. Sie sprechen in Ihrer Arbeit etwas leichtfertig von “nichtEs l¨ aßt sich jedoch leicht Hamiltonschen Theorien”.567 zeigen, daß alle translations-invarianten Theorien exakte Energieussen. Die gegenteiliImpulsintegrale Pµ (µ = 1, 2, 3, 4) besitzen m¨ gen Behauptungen von Møller-Kristensen sowie von Cl. Bloch sind unrichtig. Im Falle der reell-skalaren Mesontheorie, elektrischneutrale Mesonen in Wechselwirkung mit Formfaktor F (x − x , x − x ) mit Nukleonen (Spinorfeld), habe ich diese Integrale leicht streng ausrechnen k¨ onnen und habe sie k¨ urzlich Møller geschrieben. Davon gibt es noch ein ebenfalls in der Zeit exakt konstantes “Ladungs”-Integral Q der Nukleonen (entsprechend ¯ −iα mit konstanter Phase α). der Eichgruppe ψ → ψeiα , ψ¯ → ψe
563
Between 3 and 17 June 1952 the Council of Representatives of European States for Planning of an International Laboratory oversaw a conference in Copenhagen which was concerned with the recently founded laboraroty later known as CERN. 564 R. Peierls and H. McManus, ‘Electrodynamics without point singularities’, Phys. Rev. 70, 795 (1946); see also letter [396], referring to McManus’ work; H. McManus, ‘Classical electrodynamics without singularities’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A195, 323–36 (1948) 565 P. Kristensen and Ch. Møller, ‘On a convergent meson theory’, in International Physics Conference, 50–51 (1952); P. Kristensen and Ch. Møller, ‘Convergent SMatrix formalism with correspondence to ordinary quantum mechanics’, Phys. Rev. 85, 928–29 (1952). 566 Cl. Bloch, ‘On field theories with non-localized interaction’, Kgl.Danske Vid.Selsk. 27, No 8, 1–55 (1952). 567 R. Peierls, ‘The commutation laws of the relativistic field theory’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A214, 143–57 (1952); here pp. 153f.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
375
Die Relationen (f = beliebige Feldgr¨ oße) −
∂f = i[Pµ , f ], [Q, ψ] = −ψ, [Q, ψ ∗ ] = ψ ∗ ∂xµ [Pµ , Pν ] = [Pµ , Q] = 0 [Q, u] = 0, ↓ reelles Mesonfeld
m¨ ussen aus gruppentheoretischen Gr¨ unden exakt gelten. (N.B. Ich konnte zeigen, daß dies mit Ihrer Definition der Klammersymbole im Einklang ist. Siehe unten.) Was Sie mit “nichtHamiltonschen Theorien” meinen, wird dem p.t. Leser nicht erkl¨art. Man kann und soll unter Umst¨ anden allerdings quantisierte (oder klassische) Feldtheorien in nicht kanonischen Variablen schreiben, die Bezeichnung “nicht-Hamiltonsche Theorie” scheint mir aber deswegen allein nicht angebracht. 2. Die einzige Voraussetzung f¨ ur die Anwendbarkeit Ihres Formalismus scheint mir die zu sein, daß die Mannigfaltigkeit der L¨ osungen dieselbe ist wie f¨ ur Kopplungskonstante Null (freie Teilchen). Im ¯ x), ψ(x), u(x ), ∂u(x) im Sinne Falle M.-Kr. bedeutet das, daß ψ( ∂t der klassischen Theorie auf einen Schnitt t = const. als Anfangszustand willk¨ urlich vorgegeben werden k¨ onnen∗ und die weitere zeitliche Entwicklung eindeutig definieren. Es soll also nicht so etwas wie “run-away solutions” geben. Pais-Uhlenbeck haben ja gezeigt, daßdies erf¨ ullt ist, wenn der Formfaktor keine Null2 urde stellen bzw. Pole hat. (z.B. e−α ). (Im gegenteiligen Fall w¨ ich lieber sagen, daß der Anfangszustand im Sinne der Theorie ungen¨ ugend charakterisiert war als daß “die Feldgleichungen unvollst¨andig sind”.) W¨ are dies nicht so, so m¨ ußten M.-Kr. und Cl. Bloch mit ihrer St¨ orungstheorie sowieso einpacken (der letztere Autor schw¨ atzt Unsinn u ¨ber diesen Punkt in einer in Pasadena verfaßten Arbeit, von der er mir ein Manuskript geschickt hat).568 ∗ D.
h. es sollen keine supplementary conditions f¨ ur diese Gr¨ oßen bestehen. 568
Bloch had spent some time in Pasadena in 1952/3. The manuscript to which Pauli refers was not published.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
376
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
¯ ψ, u, ∂u auf einen Schnitt t = const. den AnDaraus, daß ψ, ∂t fangszustand bestimmen, folgt nat¨ urlich gar nicht, daß sie kanonische Variable sind: Nat¨ urlich sind sie es nicht, und weder Q noch P (Impuls, entsprechend µ = 1, 2, 3) haben die Normalform (beide bekommen Zusatzterme proportional zur Kopplungskonstante, die in der lokalen Theorie verschwinden). 3. Nun betrifft eine erste Frage die G¨ ultigkeit Ihres Lemmas ret B − Dav B = −Dret A + Dav A [A, B] = −[B, A] oder DA A B B Ihr Beweis, der explizite kanonische Variable verwendet, scheint mir nicht ad¨ aquat. Selbst wenn man f¨ ur A, B die Feldgr¨ oßen selbst einsetzt, geben sie keinen von der Hamiltonischen Form der Gleichungen unabh¨ angigen Beweis, der die Allgemeinheit der G¨ ultigkeit des Satzes in Erscheinung treten l¨ aßt. Ich m¨ochte Sie deshalb fragen, was Sie dar¨ uber wissen (bevor ich anfange, mich selber damit zu plagen). Dazu noch einige Bemerkungen zu Ihren Methoden. Insofern die Differenzen der gestrichenen und der ungestrichenen Feldgr¨ oßen nur in der ersten Ordnung Ihres Parameters λ ben¨ otigt werden, verwendet Ihre Methode die sogenannten “Equations de variation” (Pointcar´e).∗∗ Den DA B entspricht, im ¯ Falle, daß B eine Feldgr¨ oße selbst ist (wie u, ∂u ∂t , ψ, ψ wie bei M.-Kr.), das δx1 · · · δxk der Punktmechanik (siehe Whit— Sie haben aber die “Variationsgleichuntaker, 1.c.)569 gen” durch Anbringen der Inhomogenit¨ at (Quelle) bereichert und das ist vielleicht eine gute Idee. (Nat¨ urlich kann man das∗∗∗ (N.B. Die Differenz der selbe in der Punktmechanik machen.) ∗∗
Vgl. Whittaker, Analytical Dynamics, Chap. X, §112. d Es w¨are den Gleichungen f¨ ur dt δxr (Whittaker, p. 285) als ∂A ugen. Dann gibt es wieder eine avancierte Zusatzterm ∂xr hinzuzuf¨ und eine retardierte L¨ osung. ∗∗∗
569
E.T. Whittaker, Analytische Mechanik der starren K¨ orper, (Berlin: Springer, 1924), 287f.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
377
retardierten und der avancierten L¨ osungen der inhomogenen Variationsgleichung gen¨ ugt nat¨ urlich der gew¨ ohnlichen homogenen Variationsgleichung. Deshalb verh¨ alt sich diese Differenz auch so sch¨on stetig.) Ob homogen oder inhomogen, jedenfalls sind oßen wie die Variationsgleichungen linear in den DA f (f Feldgr¨ ¯ ψ, ψ, u etc.) und das sollte wohl erm¨ oglichen, Reziprozit¨ atss¨atze u ¨ber selbstadjungierte lineare Differentialgleichungen anzuwenden und so zu Ihrem Satz {A, B} = -{B, A} zu gelangen. Ich habe das aber noch nicht durchgef¨ uhrt. Dagegen habe ich f¨ ur B = Pµ die Df · Pµ ausgerechnet und u r t < t1 fand, daß sie brav die Spr¨ unge bei t = t1 machen und f¨ bzw. t > t1 Null sind, obwohl die (nicht kanonischen) Feldgr¨ oßen selbst viel komplizierter sind. Die Relationen f¨ ur [Pµ , f ] kommen ganz richtig heraus. 4. Ich habe absichtlich die Analogien zur Punktmechanik mit endlich vielen Freiheitsgraden hervorgehoben, weil ich nun auf den Begriff “Integralinvarianz” lossteuern m¨ochte (Whittaker, §§113). An Stelle von “Integralinvariante” (bzw. invariante Differentialform 1. und 2. Grades) (M1 δx1 + · · · + Mn δxn ) der Punktmechanik tritt im Falle kanonischer Feldvariablen p(x, t), q(x, t) {Mρ (p(x), q(x))δpρ (x) + Nρ (p(x), q(x))δqρ (x)}d3 x ρ
mit einer endlichen ρ (die auch nur aus einem einzigen Term bestehen kann) und einem Integral u ¨ber den 3-dimensionalen Raum (an Stelle der Summe u ¨ber die δxr ). Das der Integralinvariante der Punktmechanik w¨ are nunmehr u ¨ber den Funktionsraum zu erstrecken, was immer Schwierigkeiten macht (es sei denn, daß man ein Kristallgitter mit nach oben abgeschnittener endlicher Zahl von Eigenschwingungen statt des wirklichen Raumes einf¨ uhrt). Aber man
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
378
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
kann ja von einer zeitlich konstanten Differentialform sprechen, z.B. Mρ (x), Nρ (x) mit
δJ , δJ δpρ (x) δqρ (x)
identifizieren, worin J
↓ ↓ Variantionsableitung
ein Integral ist. Z.B. kann man f¨ ur J das Impulsintegral P = ∂qρ 3 x) ∂x) nehmen. Dann kann man auch zu invarianten ρ d xpρ ( ¨bergehen. (Das u ¨ber Bilinearformen† in den δ (bzw. Ihren Dt) u den Funktionsraum ist vermeidbar.) 5. Ganz unabh¨ angig von Ihrem Formalismus war ich zu dem Schluß gekommen, daß das Existenztheorem von Lie-K¨ onigs, wonach die zeitlich-konstante Bilinearform sich immer auf die kanonische Normalform bringen l¨ aßt, es also kanonische Variable geben muß, sobald es Poisson-klammern gibt, auch f¨ ur Feldtheorien g¨ ultig sein sollte. Einen strengen Beweis daf¨ ur habe ich allerdings noch nicht gefunden, aber ich bin bereit zu wetten, daß es z.B. in der M.-Kr. Formfaktortheorie kanonische Feldvariablen geben muß: Diese w¨aren dadurch charakterisiert, daß die Impuls- und Ladungsintegrale in den neuen Variablen wieder die Normalform Pk =
∂ϕ ∂ν ϕ + pν ∂xµ ∂x ∗
3
d x,
Q=
ϕ∗ ϕd3 x
(Im Ausdruck dieser Variablen durch die urspr¨ unglichen k¨ onnen letztere zu verschiedenen Zeiten eingehen.)
annehmen, daß f¨ ur ϕ∗ , ϕ, pν , ν die kanonischen Kommutatoren richtig sind und daß f¨ ur Kopplungskonstante 0 diese Variablen ¨bergehen. In der ersten N¨ aherung der stetig in ψ ∗ , ψ, pu , u u St¨ orungstheorie habe ich das in der Tat verifizieren k¨ onnen (linear in der Kupplungskonstante). † N.B.
Die Koeffizienten der Kovariante ist die reziproke Matrix zu den Poisson-Klammern.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
379
Ich m¨ochte also wissen: den Zusammenhang Ihrer Definition der Poisson-Klammern†† mit dem Begriff “bilineare Kovariante” (bzw. die Verallgemeinerung dieses Zusammenhanges f¨ ur Systeme mit ∞-vielen Freiheitsgraden wie es die Felder sind). Meine das Theorem von Lie-K¨onigs verallgemeinernde Vermutung ist, daß immer wenn Ihr Formalismus anwendbar ist, die Theorie sich auch auf die Hamiltonsche-kanonische Form bringen l¨ aßt (auch dann, wenn Formfaktoren vorhanden sind).— Nat¨ urlich kann die explizite Durchf¨ uhrung schwierig und auch unn¨ otig sein! Das ist alles reine Mathematik, also Vorfragen, die u ¨brigens nicht direkt mit der Lorentzinvarianz zu tun haben. Die letztere wird f¨ ur lorentz-invariante Formfaktoren typische Konvergenzprobleme verursachen, wohl auch dann, wenn der Formfaktor wie bei M.-Kr. von drei (statt bisher nur zwei) Punkten abh¨ angt. Auch bin ich sonst aus physikalischen Gr¨ unden eher ziemlich skeptisch gegen¨ uber den Formfaktortheorien. Was ist Ihre Ansicht? (N.B. Die Eichgruppe der Elektrodynamik wird unm¨ oglich!) Viele Gr¨ uße Ihr W. Pauli †† Mit
Hilfe der inhomogenen “Variationsgleichungen”.
[564] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Zollikon-Z¨ urich, 14.8.1952 (draft) Nicht abgeschickt weil unfertig! Lieber Herr Peierls! Ich schicke Ihnen noch einen Nachtrag, um an einem einfachen (rein klassischen — alles sind c-Zahlen) Beispiel aus der Punktmechanik klar zu machen, was ich meine. Ich betrachte 3 Massenpunkte mit den Koogen. Das ordinaten q1 , q2 , q3 , die sich auf einer Geraden bewegen m¨ Bewegungsgesetz folgte aus einer (in bezug auf die Zeit translationsinvarianten) Lagrangefunktion, die einen Integraloperator enthalten
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
380
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
m¨oge. (Oszillator und Wand einf¨ uhren, um Dn zu beschr¨anken):
Ldt −
−g
ein Born Potential
↓ m [ (q˙12 + q˙22 + q˙32 ) − V (q) ]dt 2
dt1 dt2 dt3 F (t1 , t2 , t3 )ϕ[q1 (t1 ), q2 (t2 ), q3 (t3 )].
F h¨ angt nur von den zwei Differenzen t1 − t2 , t3 − t1 ab und ist eine (reelle) Funktion, die f¨ ur F (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) = F (−τ1 , −τ2 , −τ3 ) (Spiegelinvarianz; z.B. eine Gauss-Funktion). u r t = t0 Von ϕ und g setze ich nur voraus, daß qi (t), q˙i (t) f¨ willk¨ urlich vorgegeben werden k¨ onnen und eindeutig den weiteren Verlauf in Zukunft und Vergangenheit bestimmen sollen.∗ Die Bewegungsgleichungen lauten ∂V ∂ϕ[q1 (t1 ), q2 (t2 ), q3 (t3 )] +g dt2 dt3 F (0, t2 −t, t3 −t) =0 m¨ q1 (t)+ ∂q1 ∂q1 {N.B. F (t1 , t2 , t3 ) ≡ F (0, t2 − t, t3 − t)} und entsprechend f¨ ur q2 , q3 . Ihre inhomogenen Variationsgleichungen bei einer Quelle f¨ ur qj kann man schreiben ∂2V (j) + g dt1 dt2 dt3 F (τ1 , τ2 , τ3 )δ(t − tk ) md¨ qk (t) + ∂qk ∂qr ·
∂2ϕ dqρ(j) (tρ ) = δkj δ(t − ti ). ∂q ∂q r k ρ
(A)
Ihre Vorschrift ist nun die: man suche erst die retardierten L¨ osungen (j) j ur t → −∞, dann die avancierten L¨ osungen δqk → 0 f¨ ur δqk → 0 f¨ t → +∞ und setze (I)
[qk (tk ), qj (tj )] = δq
(j) k ret
−δq
(j) k av
Nun kommt alles darauf an, direkt einzusehen, daß die rechte Seite bei Vertauschung von (j, tj ) mit (k, tk ) antisymmetrisch ist. ∗ Ein
Beispiel ist q gleich dem Produkt q1 (t1 )q2 (t2 )q3 (t3 ).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
381
Ich habe das bis jetzt noch nicht so gesehen, aber auch nicht das Gegenteil. K¨ onnen Sie es zeigen? (N.B. Wenn ich dieses Beispiel verstanden habe, kann ich ohne weiteres dasselbe auch f¨ ur eine Feldtheorie mit Formfaktor wie die von M[øller]-Kr[istensen].) Was meine eigenen Behauptungen u ¨ber ein solches System betrifft, so sind sie folgende: 1. Es existiert ein Energieintegral m H = (q˙12 + q˙22 + q˙32 ) + v(q) 2 ∂ϕ[q1 (t1 ) · · · q3 (t3 )] . q˙k (tk ) +g E(t1 −t3 , t2 −t, t3 −t)dt1 dt2 dt3 ∂[qk (tk )] k
Man muß nun E gem¨aß der Gleichung bestimmen 3 ∂ ∂ E(τ1 , τ2 , τ3 ) [F (τ2 −τ1 , τ3 −τ1 )δ(τk )] = ∂τk ∂τk k=1 k
↓ h¨ angt wirklich von 3 Variablen ab
oder mit τ2 = τ1 + ρ, τ3 = τ1 + σ, τ1 ≡ τ ∂ ∂δ(τ ) + [F (ρ, 0)(δ(ρ + τ ) · · · δ(τ ))] F (ρ, 0) ∂τ ∂ρ ∂ ∂ E(τ, τ + ρ, τ + σ), + [F (ρ, 0)(δ(σ + τ ) − δ(τ ))] = ∂σ ∂τ 1 ∂ [F (ρ, σ)((r+τ )−(τ ))] also E(τ, τ +ρ, τ +σ) = F (ρ, σ)δ(τ )+ 2 ∂ρ 1 ∂ [F (ρ, σ)((σ + τ ) − (τ ))]. + 2 ∂σ Man sieht, daß bei festem ρ, σ (bei dieser Wahl der additiven Konstante in E) f¨ ur τ → +∞ und f¨ ur τ → −∞E → 0 gilt. ußten die Poisson-Klammern 2. Aus q˙k = [H, qk ], q¨k = [H, q˙k ], · · · m¨ im Prinzip folgen und sobald nur im Prinzip (f¨ ur irgendein t) qk (t) ucken l¨ aßt (etwa durch Potenzsich durch qr (t0 ) und q˙r (t0 ) ausdr¨ reihen in g, muß diese Theorie als ,,Hamiltontheorie” betrachtet werden und kanonische Variable sollen existieren.
April 7, 2009
12:11
382
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Also die Hauptsache ist mir der Beweis f¨ ur die Antisymmetrie der rechten Seite von (I) in k und j. Inzwischen werde ich weiter dar¨ uber nachdenken. Nochmals viele Gr¨ uße Ihr W. Pauli
[565] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft [Birmingham], 14.8.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, As you probably know there has been some correspondence recently about the question of this country’s participation in the European nuclear physics scheme. I had not previously written to you about this, because my impression was, after the conference at Buckland House,570 that most people there held very similar views. However, as I have in the past been rather sceptical about the scheme. I ought perhaps to say what I feel about it now and from what conversations I had with others, I believe that my views are fairly representative of those held in the universities now. I had been doubtful about the prospect of this scheme previously because I was afraid it might divert attention from the possibility of a scheme providing travel grants to move physicists around as between different European countries, which would have been very much cheaper and easier and of very great value. I also felt that it would probably be better for this country not to be a direct participant in such a scheme, since according to the early plans the new laboratory was to have machines only comparable to those already under construction in this country, and in that situation it would have been better for the 570
Informal Conference held on 7 June 1952 at Buckland House near Harwell to discuss ‘High Energy accelerators for Nuclear Physics’. See report written by M. Snowdon, 7.6.1952; carbon copy in Chadwick Papers, CHADI, 26/2.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
383
limited effort and scientific manpower available here to be concentrated on the jobs to which we were already committed. I also felt that there was some doubt whether with arrangements started on the government committee level the administration of the scheme would get into the right hands and whether it would not be tied up in red tape. Now it is clear that the scheme is going ahead and my first objection is therefore no longer relevant. From the point of view of this country the situation is entirely changed if, as is now proposed, the laboratory will go for a machine considerably more ambitious than what is planned in this country. If it were possible to go for a really high energy this would make a large difference, not only to the prestige of European physics, but also to the prospects of retaining in the future the chance of training some really first rate physicists, who would be attracted to the subject and stimulated by the prospect of being in the front rank of the development of the fundamental side of the subject. It is still a question whether on abstract considerations it would be possible and desirable for such a bigger machine to be built independently in this country, but I think everybody is agreed that if Great Britain were now to announce a plan to go ahead independently with such a scheme it would have politically most unfortunate results, even if it were economically possible. One could, of course, return to this possibility if it should turn out that the discussions for international co-operation on this project were to break down. As regards my last difficulty I am still not completely satisfied that in the end the set-up will be one in which the technical and scientific problems can be pursued without undue bureaucratic difficulties, but there seems a good chance that if this country were to come in, the prestige of our representatives would be such that they could take a decisive part in helping to develop the organisation and then things might go well. For this reason it seems to me very important that the question about our participation should be settled as soon as possible and that if we are going to come in at all, which I hope we shall, it should be done at a very early stage. The expense of joining in during the present preparatory stage, which is all that would have to be definitely promised at the present, surely is not a serious obstacle.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
384
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
At the Buckland conference it sounded as if decisions on this matter were being taken (or not taken) by committees in which the representation of modern nuclear physics was extremely limited. Presumably you know how this has developed in the meantime and perhaps is set up is now more satisfactory, but if physicists in the universities can do anything to make their views heard, I am quite sure that many of us would be prepared to state our views in whatever form and place was unlikely to be most effective. I must apologise for writing such a long letter on things that I must assume that you are well aware of and if as I hope you can tell me that these points are being taken account of in the responsible quarters, I shall be quite satisfied with that. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [566] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Zollikon-Z¨ urich, 16.8.1952 (draft) Nicht abgeschickt weil unfertig! Lieber Herr Peierls! Das beiliegend vorgerechnete Beispiel aus der Punktmechanik l¨aßt alles im Detail hervervortreten, was ich in meinem letzten Brief nur in allgemeinen Worten ausgef¨ uhrt habe. Es ergibt sich daran anschließend eine mir wesentliche Frage betref¨ fend die Anwendbarkeit Ihres Formalismus. Ubertr¨ agt man diesen w¨ortlich, so hat man statt der Gl[eichung] (2) der beiliegenden Noten die inhomogen Variationsgleichungen ∂2V (j) ( )t δql (t) + g dt1 · · · dtk F (t1 · · · tk ) mδ q¨k + ∂qk ∂ql l
· δ(t − tk )
l
∂2ϕ δql (tl ) = λδjk δ(t − tj ) ∂[qk (tk )]∂[ql (tl )]
(2, Peierls)
zu bilden. Diese haben eine retardierte L¨ osung δ(j) qkret (t), die mitsamt ihrer Ableitung nach der Zeit f¨ ur t → −∞ verschwindet und eine
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
385
avancierte L¨osung, die (ebenso ihre zeitliche Ableitung) f¨ ur t → +∞ verschwindet. Dann hat man ihre Differenz zu bilden δ(j) q ≡ δ(j) q ret ∼ δ(j) q av k
k
k
die eine (besondere) L¨osung der homogenen Variationsgleichungen ist. osungen h¨ atte man nun die Poisson-Klammern anzusetzen: F¨ ur diese L¨ [qk (tk ), qj (tj )] = δ(j) qk . Leider kann ich nun aber nicht einsehen, daß die rechte Seite bei Vertauschung von (k, tk ) mit (j, tj ) das Vorzeichen ¨andert, wie das Ihr “Lemma” behauptet. Bei kanonischen Variablen stimmt das ur die Gleichungen, wie sie da stehen — schon, aber allgemein — f¨ halte ich es nicht f¨ ur richtig. (Ich sehe aber keine allgemeine Beziehung osungen qk (t) bei zwischen δqlret und δqlav , da die nicht variierten L¨ Umkehr der Zeit kein einfaches Verhalten zu zeigen brauchen.) Auch ist der Passus Ihrer Arbeit, wo “die L¨ osungen” der urspr¨ unglichen Gleichungen mit denen der inhomogenen Gleichungen durch eine kanonische Transformation verbunden werden sollen, etwas unklar geschrieben. Nat¨ urlich kann man Gr¨ oßen mit denselben Vertauschungs-Relationen durch eine S-Transformation verbinden, aber dazu muss man schon wissen, was die VertauschungsRelationen sind. Im vorliegenden Fall sehe ich keine einfache Beziehung zwischen den Vertauschungs-Relationen der homogenen und der inhomogenen Gleichungen. Bitte schreiben Sie mir also, ob f¨ ur die Gleichungen “(2, Peierls)” Ihr Antisymmetriesatz f¨ ur die Differenz der retardierten und avancierten L¨ osung gilt. Sollte das nicht der Fall sein (was ich vermute), so w¨ urde Ihr Formalismus f¨ ur mich wesentlich an Interesse verlieren, und ich w¨ urde dann lieber brav bei den homogenen Variationsgleichungen bleiben (die ja auch alles Gew¨ unschte schon enthalten) wie in den beiliegenden 571 Notizen. Viele herzliche Gr¨ uße Ihr W. Pauli 571
Enclosed with the letter were notes about ‘Punktmechanik mit “nichtmomentanen” Bewegungsgleichungen’. See Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/1, 705–707.
April 7, 2009
12:11
386
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[567] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli [Birmingham], 20.8.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Professor Pauli, Thank you very much for your two long and interesting letters.572 In the question of defining non-Hamiltonian systems I meant really nothing deep, but I wanted to know how one should handle the quantum mechanics of non-local equations (non-local meaning simply equations containing form functions). I took it for granted, perhaps too easily, that for those equations one could not practically imply the canonical formalism and that one would not be able to do anything with them without having a new technique. The method which I have worked out is, of course, very far from being a usable one, but it gives at least some hope in that direction. However, I agree with you that one should specify more carefully in what way such systems differ from the canonical scheme, (if at all). Turning now to the example, which is worked out in your note,573 and discussed in your second letter.574 I think I can assert that this is the case to which classically my method is applicable. This, as far as I can see, follows directly from section 6 of my Princeton paper,575 which is entitled “Non-Hamiltonian Theories”, as you point out without sufficient justification, but which does carry through the proof of the anti-symmetry of the Poisson bracket without the use of canonical variables. I tried to-day to write out this proof for the specific system contained in your note, but it would cover several pages of algebra and contain nothing that is not evident from the few equations in my paper, so I think you will really find those more satisfactory, but if you have any trouble in following the argument or any objection to its validity, I would be glad to give more detail. 572
Letters [563], [566]. Note accompanying letter [563]. 574 Letter [566]. 575 See letter [563], note 561. 573
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
387
Further in the same letter you raise an objection to the argument used in section three of my paper, but this section was intended merely to prove that in cases where canonical variables exist the definitions of the Poisson bracket, which I have given, are correct, and for this case, the canonical transformation (3.7) does, in fact, explicitly provide the transformation from the original to the modified solutions of the system and its existence is therefore established. As I tried to make clear in the paper, there remains still an essential gap in the justification of the general commutation law, the argument of section 3 is valid only for canonical systems and that of section 6 is valid only classically, that is to say regardless of the order of factors. I cannot therefore assert that I can quantize a non-local theory, except for a somewhat trivial case, to which I want to come back later. Given what you say one might think of approaching the problem of quantization by your method, which essentially depends on expressing the solutions of the field equations in terms of the values of variables at any one time, but the trouble is that the expressions one then obtains will no doubt algebraically be very complicated and the question of the ordering of factors will arise, if one chooses the wrong ordering of factors, one will presumably get a theory which is not Lorentz invariant and since the whole procedure of solving in terms of the quantities at one time destroys the covariance of the description, it will be hard to make the right choice. Of course, the question of quantization does not really arise, if one is prepared to expand in powers of the coupling constant, since one then needs only two commutators between the free particle quantities (Yang-Feldman).576 But I would like to get somewhat beyond this power series, which may after all be divergent and I would like at least to be able to make some general statements about a theory without series expansion, even though one might not be able to obtain any particular solution without expanding. In this way I rather differ from Møller and Kristensen and incidentally I never believed their statement that there was not an energy and charge operator in such a theory that is completely conserved. 576 C.N. Yang and D. Feldman, ‘The S-Matrix in the Heisenberg Representation’, Phys. Rev. 79, 972–78 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
388
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Turning now to some points in your first letter. I agree that the only condition for the validity of my formulae classically is that the introduction of the coupling should not produce new degrees of freedom, but as I have stressed before, this does not dispose of the problem of quantization. You ask my views about the value of non-local theories in general. This is somewhat linked up with the question whether in the existing field theory one can divorce the renormalization from the series expansion and whether one can write finite equations (however complicated and implicit) which are rigorous, and which one then can solve, if necessary, by means of an expansion. If this is possible, then I would doubt whether one really needs non-local equations, that is to say whether one would ever have to put a form factor into the basic postulate. However, it seems to me certain that the equations which one would then obtain after eliminating the infinities would in themselves contain integral operations, so that the experience of handling such equations would not be wasted. On the other hand it [is] also possible that such finite equations which contain all the physical results of the existing theory may not exist and that the only way to get finite equations without series expansion is to leave out some part of the integrations, which, in any case, refers to energy regions about which we know nothing and in which new things like the production of as yet unknown particles will change things. In other words I would like to be able to write down that part of the present theory about which we can really be sure, and I would like to do so in a finite, consistent, and Lorentz and gauge invariant form. This brings me to another point. You say that the use of form factors destroys the gauge invariance, but this is not necessarily true. That such integral expressions can be made gauge invariant, was pointed out by C. Bloch,577 though he put it in a rather complicated form. It is true ¯ 2 ) is not gauge invariant, but one can replace ¯ 1 )ψ(x that the product ψ(x it by ¯ 1 )eie ψ(x 577
x
2 x1
Aµ δxµ
ψ(x2 ),
(1)
Cl. Bloch, ‘On field theories with non-localised interactions’, Kgl. Danske Vid. Selsk. 27/8, 1–55 (1952), here p. 46.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
389
where the integral goes over the straight line (in four dimensions) from x1 to x2 . Evidently (1) is gauge invariant. Its occurrence in the action principle does not give any new trouble that is not already present in any form factor theory. If one wants to use a series expansion, the only change is some slight algebraic complication, and the occurrence of higher powers of A in the action principle which have to be taken together with the higher order approximations for the lower powers. We have been playing for some time with an action principle of this kind that has attractive features, and which looks as follows: L=i
4
4
¯ 1) d x1 d x2 ψ(x
∂ ie x2 Adx γµ + M F (x1 − x2 ) e x1 ψ(x2 ) ∂xµ
+ hermition conjugate + Lf .
(2)
Signs and numerical factors are not guaranteed, units are such that h = c = 1, F is a form factor (depending on one distance only). The brackets are meant to indicate that the differentiation acts only on F , not on the other factors, Lf is the action of the electromagnetic field by itself. The other term contains both the Lagrangian of free particles and coupling. The equations derived from (2) have the property that (a) in the absence of a field they admit only the solution of the free-electron Diracequation, (b) in the limit in which the spread of the form factor goes to zero it reduces to the usual local theory. We have tried to apply this to some simple cases, using a power series in e, in particular we have looked at the vacuum polarization. The result is that the non-gauge invariant term is still divergent. I am fairly sure that the next term, i.e. the charge renormalization will be finite, but it is of course messy to try to define this term in the presence of the divergent leading term. The reason for this trouble lies mathematically in the fact that, considering the effect of a potential with wave vector k one is left with a four-dimensional integration over a momentum p, which is restricted to be a real-electron momentum, i.e. p2 = m2 . The integrand contains
April 7, 2009
390
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the four-dimensional Fourier transform g of the form factor in the form g(p − sk) and for other similar arguments. Here, s is an auxiliary variable which runs from 0 to 1, and arises from the line integral in (2). If g is to be invariant, it will depend only on the square of its argument, i.e. on p2 + s2 k2 − 2spk
(3)
In the integration over p, p2 remains constant, and the k is, of course, given and finite. If k is space-like, as for a static potential, then pk is zero in a two-dimensional section of the three-dimensional integration. In that section the form factor therefore does not reduce the integrand, and so it can reduce the order of the divergence only by one, which is not enough. Now (2) is not the most general action principle of this type, and we are at present studying the most general case. However, I am not very hopeful, because the integrand can only be reduced by a more general function of the three invariants, of which (3) is a linear combination. Since, in the two-dimensional section of the integration, all three of these variables are finite, it does not look as if this can help to remove the divergence. The same is true in the theory of Møller and Kristensen, their contrary assertion is due to the fact that they work out the vacuum polarization only for external fields satisfying the free-meson equation, and hence have a time-like k. In that case, the situation is quite different, and pk is always large if any component of p is large (provided p2 = m2 ) This means the self-energy of a meson will in their theory diverge when k is space-[like] which will happen in virtual states. I believe this to be connected with Bloch’s statement that he tends to get divergences in fourth order. From some remarks in your letter it seems to me that you will not be surprised about this trouble. This may well force one to abandon the non-local theories. We are discussing the following means of avoiding this conclusion:
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
391
1. The divergence may just be the fault of the method of calculation, and there may be a reasonable way of looking at the answer which makes it evident that the non-gauge invariant term is zero. There are such cases in four-dimensional Fourier transforms, and one can write the most harmless expressions in a way which makes them appear divergent. But I am not very hopeful in this direction. 2. One may simply prescribe a method which preserves group invariance, and therefore make this term vanish, but this would remove the main point of a non-local theory. 3. One might expect this term to be cancelled by a “relativistic” renormalization, since the contributions to this term from different kinds of fields do have different signs. This does not make me very happy either. 4.578 The divergence may have something to do with the power series in e, and if one were to obtain the rigorous solutions of the equations this might be equivalent to a prescribed order of integration, which would remove the difficulty. This seems to me at the moment the most promising line, but it makes things very difficult mathematically. Rather surprisingly it is possible to get the rigorous solutions (2) for the case of an external homogeneous magnetic field, without specifying the shape of the form factor, and I am playing with these at the moment. Unfortunately it seems that the infinite extent of such a field introduces some new ambiguities (similar to those in the diamagnetism of free electrons) and I have therefore not been able as yet to calculate the induced current. Apart from these difficulties, I have been interested in the action principle (2) as an exercise in quantization. I have no idea what to do with the general class of interacting quantized fields. But at least in the very modest case of a classical vector potential everything goes through all right. One then has the simplification that the action principle is bilinear in the field variables, so that the Poisson brackets are c-numbers. 578
In the manuscript the numbering is inconsistent and the number 3 is used twice.
April 7, 2009
392
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
One can then carry through the quantization in a covariant manner and finds that the wave function can be expanded in terms of c-number solutions which minimize (2), with coefficients which can be given the usual interpretation of emission and absorption operators. However, each of these refers to the whole space-time picture and it appears rather arbitrary to relate them to any specific time. I admit that to quantize such a simple case is not much of an achievement, but it is at least one case where the non-local theory works. If you are interested I could send you details of how this goes through quite covariantly. In such a gauge invariant theory there is, of course, no difficulty defining a current density, since this is simply the functional derivative of the action principle with respect to the vector potential. Hence also the expression for the total charge is unambiguous. I think one should define the energy momentum tensor in the corresponding way, namely by writing the action principle in terms of curvilinear coordinates and then differentiating with respect to the gik . This can be done for any of these non-local theories. By integrating over space, one can then define the expression for the total energy, which is presumably the same thing as the Hamiltonian. But I am not sure what one does with it. (It is, of course, exactly constant in time, not merely on the average). It would be interesting to know how this definition of the energy is related to yours. Just one more point: It seems to be possible, by treating an expression like (1) as a density matrix, and finding the equations for it, to get a formulation of the theory in which only the electromagnetic field appears, but not the vector potential. There no question of gauge invariance arises, and there cannot possibly [be] any gauge-invariant term in the polarization. I have not got very far with this, however, because of some mathematical troubles. Any comments on all this would be most welcome. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
393
[568] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 29.8.1952 Lieber Herr Peierls, Vielen Dank f¨ ur Ihren Brief vom 20.579 Meine Bemerkungen dazu haben zum Teil provisorischen Charakter. 1. Ihren Beweis von section 6 habe ich nun genau durch¨ uberlegt und sehe kein Hindernis mehr, ihn auf das von mir diskutierte Beispiel anzuwenden. Darin sind wir also einig. Es sind aber noch einige Fragen zur¨ uckgeblieben, auf die ich noch keine Antwort weiß. (j) osung (0 f¨ ur t → −∞) mit Sei DRet qk (t) die retardierte L¨ der Inhomogenit¨ at −λδkj δ(t − tj ) in der Variationsgleichung.1 (j) Dav qk (t) die avancierte L¨ osung (0 f¨ ur t → +∞) mit der(j) (j) (j) selben Inhomogenit¨ at und δk (t) ∼ = DRet qk − DAv qk diese osung der homogenen Variationsgleichung. Wodurch spezielle L¨ (j) ∼ δ(j) (tj ) charakterisiert? sind die Anfangswerte limt→t δ (t) = j
k
k
Bei kanonischen Variablen ist die Antwort so einfach, aber im allgemeinen Fall bin ich bisher nicht durchgekommen. Hier muß die mir noch fehlende Br¨ ucke von Ihrer Methode zu meinen Ausdr¨ ucken f¨ ur die bilineare Kovariante sein.2.1 Die Schwierigkeit h¨ angt nat¨ urlich damit zusammen, daß das “Anfangswertproblem” in den nicht-lokalen Theorien nicht explizit l¨ osbar ist und man hier, wie Sie es ganz richtig r¨ ugen — noch 1 In
den Index k kann auch die Raumkoordinate mit einbezogen werden, die Zeit schreibe ich aber extra. 2.1 Das Lemma von der Antisymmetrie der nach Ihnen definierten Poisson-klammern ist u ¨brigens a¨quivalent mit der Behauptung, daß die aus den beiden oben angef¨ uhrten L¨ osungen der inhomogenen (i)
(i)
Variat[ions]-Gl[eichungen] gebildete Kovariante D(DRet qk , DAv qk ) die nicht zeitleer konstant ist sowohl f¨ ur t → +∞ als auch f¨ ur t → −∞ verschwindet. 579
Letter [567].
April 7, 2009
12:11
394
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ganz in den Potenzreihen nach der Kopplungskonstante gefangen ist.2.2 Die Schwierigkeiten wegen der Reihenfolge von Faktoren ¨ beim Ubergang von der c-Zahltheorie zu der q-Zahltheorie im nichtlokalen Fall halte ich f¨ ur objektiv und tats¨ achlich vorhanden. (N.B. Bei Møller-Kristensen ist ein nicht ganz unwichtiger Fehler gemacht hinsichtlich dieser Reihenfolge in Ihrem Ausdruck ∂t0 f¨ ur ∂xµνν .) 2. Der Vorschlag von Cl. Bloch von einer Wechselwirkungsenergie die x µ ¯ 1 )eie x12 Aµ dx f (x2 ) Ψ(x ↓ gerade Linie
enth¨ alt, war mir wohl bekannt, ich habe ihn aber (vielleicht zu Unrecht) bisher nicht ernst genommen. Zun¨ achst hatte ich ein wenig Angst wegen der Identit¨ at zwischen den Feldgleichungen, die aus der Divergenzgle∂j ichung ∂xµµ = 0 entspringen. Diese Gleichungen folgen ja in der lokalen Theorie auf zweierlei Weise aus den Feldgleichungen a) aus den Maxwell’schen b) aus den Dirac’schen (b[e]z[iehungs]w[eise] bei Spin 0 aus den Klein-Jordanschen Gleichungen) f¨ ur das Materienfeld. Eine solche echte Identit¨ at wird auch in der nicht-lokalen Theorie bestehen bleiben, damit die Felder nicht u ¨berbestimmt sind. Nat¨ urlich kommt alles darauf an, daß der Stromvektor Jµ (x) richtig definiert wird. Herr Cl. Bloch dr¨ uckt sich um diese Frage, da er die Aµ nur als a¨ußeres Feld einf¨ uhrt. Es fragt sich, ob bei der Definition des Stromvektors als Funktionalableitung des Wirkungs-integrals nach dem das Potential (S. 6 Ihres Briefes) diese Identit¨ at richtig 2.2 Bei
den Renormalisations-theorien hat Herr G. K¨allen hier in Z¨ urich einen ersten Versuch gemacht, von diesen Potentzreihen wegzukommen. Seine Arbeit ist gerade in den Helv. Phys. Acta erschienen580 Ihre Meinung w¨ urde mich interessieren. 580
G. K¨ allen, ‘On the definition of the renormalization constants in quamtum electrodynamics’, Helv.Phys.Acta 25, 417–34 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
395
herauskommt. Im Moment scheint es mir allerdings, daß das der Fall sein muß (wenigstens in der c-Zahltheorie) als Folge der Eichgruppe f¨ ur die Lagrange-funktion und die Feldgleichungen. Aber ich m¨ochte ganz sicher sein. Der zweite Einwand betrifft das m¨ogliche Auftreten neuer Divergenzen aus eie Aµ dxµ bei Quantisierung des elektromagnetischen Feldes. Wie ist es mit dem gew¨ohnlichen Vakuumerwartungswert eines solchen Operators? Entwickelt man die Exponetialfunktion in eine Potenzreihe, so treten doch voraussichtlich schreckliche Divergenzen (`a la Nullpunktsenergie) auf?† Das scheint mir immer noch so h¨aßlich, daß ich den Cl. Bloch’schen Vorschlag recht ungern mag. 3. Vakuum-polarisation Dies ist mir eigentlich noch wichtiger als die anderen unter 2) erw¨ahnten Punkte. In der Møller-Kristensen Theorie ist die Sachlage doch noch ein wenig anders als Sie es in Ihrem Brief schildern. Is ist richtig, daß M[øller]-K[ristensen] pl¨ otzlich sagen, der †† ¨brigens anzunehmen, daß das Vektor k sei zeitartig (ohne u außere Feld die kr¨ ¨ aftefreie Wellengleichung erf¨ ullt — es kann also nur “reine Dummheit” sein.) Aber im Z¨ ahler der Formel von M[øller]-K[ristensen] steht ein Faktor (p.k); das ist sehr bedeutungsvoll und d¨ urfte f¨ ur die Konvergenz der M[øller]-K[ristensen] Formeln f¨ ur die Vakuum-pol[arisation] im Falle raumartiger k wohl gen¨ ugen. Es fragt sich nun, ob das nur am skalaren Charakter des exponentiellen Meson-Feldes von M[øller]-K[ristensen] liegt, oder vielleicht doch allgemein ist. Haben Sie sorgf¨ altig nachgesehen, ob bei ur Ihrem Wirkungsprinzip (2) nicht am Ende auch der Ausdruck f¨ die Vakuumpolarisation f¨ ur (p.k) = 0 von selbst verschwindet? (Das d¨ urfte f¨ ur die Konvergenz gen¨ ugen). † Sie
sollten das ja wissen auf Grund Ihrer Untersuchungen u ¨ber das Wirkungsprinzip (vgl. p. 3 Ihres Biefes). †† Ich verwende die Bezeichnung Ihres Briefes. M[øller]-K[ristensen] haben L statt Ihres P , p statt Ihres k.
April 7, 2009
12:11
396
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Die Antwort auf diese letzte Frage interessiert mich besonders und vielleicht wird es sogar letzten Endes hiervon abh¨ angen, ob ich die lorentzinvarianten Form-faktoren ernst nehme. Denn von solchen besonderen Gl¨ ucksf¨ allen abgesehen, ist Cl. Bloch’s Argument, daß in h¨ oheren N¨ aherungen doch Divergenzen auftreten werden — entgegen dem Optimismus von M[øller]-K[ristensen] — ganz richtig. Diese diskutieren sehr stark die Ausdr¨ ucke unter dem Schutze der Voraussetzung, daß alle auftretenden Impulsvektoren bestimmten (nicht verschwindenden Massen) entsprechen. Nochmals vielen Dank f¨ ur Ihren Brief und herzliche Gr¨ uße Ihr W. Pauli
[569] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 30.8.1952 Dear Peierls! I have one more question regarding the section 6 of your Princetonpaper:581 In order to prove the possibility of your definition of Poisson brackets one has still to show that the Jacoby identity [A[B, C]] + [B[C, A]] + [C[A, B]] ≡ 0
(I)
holds for your definition of [A,B].582 I am satisfied, if you prove it for the classical case, moreover it is sufficient to prove it for field quantities φα , φβ , φγ themselves. — Of course I believe that it will be all right, but it is your business to give the proof (the Jacobian-identity being fundamental). Besides it, one needs the proof, that for all F s not explicitly depending on time one has ∂F = [F, H] ∂t 581
(II)
See letter [563], note 561. See W. Pauli, ‘On the Hamiltonian structure of non-local field theories’, Nuovo Cimento 10, 648–67 (1953), here p. 656. 582
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
397
But the latter was always trivial in the examples which I considered one has only to compute dH dt if the solution of the inhomogeneous variationalequation are inserted (see my last letter).583 So the missing point in your section 6 is just the Jacobi-identity. Please let me know about it. If this is completed, the Lie-K¨ onigstheorem asserts the existence of canonical variables for a finite number of degrees of freedom (But I think one can venture its generalisation to a system with an infinite number of degrees of freedom.) This theorem is simply circumstance that in an arbitrary space without metrics, one can always transform a covariant antisymmetric tensor field Jρσ (x), which fulfills Jρσ ≡ −Jσρ
∂Jτ ρ ∂Jστ ∂Jρσ + + =0 τ ∂x ∂xσ ∂xρ
[expresses the Jacobi-identity δ1 J(δ2 , δ3 ) + δ2 J(δ3 , δ1 ) + δ3 J(δ1 , δ2 ) = 0∗ for 1 J(δ1 , δ2 ) ≡ Jρσ (δ1 xρ δ2 xσ − δ2 xρ δ1 xσ )] 2 to its normal form 0 −1 1 0 0 −1 1 0 .. . (with some trivial modification if the determinant Det ||Jρσ || would be identically zero). ∂φρ σ One can, of course, if one wishes, put Jρσ = ∂φ ∂xρ − ∂xσ and then use the theorem of Pfaff, that φρ (x)dxρ can be transformed into x1 dx2 + x3 dx4 + · · · x2n−1 dx2n (+ possibly dx2n+1 which does not occur, σ α σ follows for α Jρα [x , x ] = δρ from the Jacobi identity for ρ σ [x , x ]. It also follows from (II) that J(δ1 , δ2 ) is constant in time (“bilinear covariant”). (∗) It
583
Letter [568].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
398
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
if Det ||Jρσ || = 0). If you give a prove of the Jacobi-identity you have practically(∗∗) proved that all classical systems, which you considered in section 6 are Hamiltonian systems. Regarding troubles with orders of factors in the quantized systems, they will actually exist for arbitrary Lagrangian’s and I believe that the formalism can work only for particular Lagrangians. Best wishes, Yours W. Pauli (∗∗) Apart
from the epsilontic questions like treatment of space coordinates [...] as an index α etc.
[570] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli Les Houches, 1.9.1952 (carbon copy) Lieber Herr Pauli! Ihr Brief vom 29/8.584 erreichte mich in Birmingham gerade vor der Abreise in die Ferien, der n¨achste wurde mir nach Paris nachgeschickt. Ich bin jetzt auf einer Rundreise zur Riviera und vielleicht Spanien, und daher nur mit Verz¨ ogerungen erreichbar. 2 ¨ Uber die Eigenschaften des Ausdruckes ei 1 ADS habe ich im Falle quantisierter Aµ noch nichts bewiesen. Ich habe keine Angst vor der mu Identit¨ at ∂j ∂xµ ≡ 0, da diese doch automatisch aus der Definition folgt (sobald L eichinvariant ist) und unabh¨ angig von jµ (x) = δAδL µ (x) der Reihenfolge von Faktoren. ¨ Uber Vakuumsfluktuationen eines solchen nichtlinearen Ausdruckes weiß ich auch noch nichts, aber ich glaube, das kommt sp¨ ater. Man muß nat¨ urlich nur verlangen, daß die Fluktuationen von beobachtbaren Gr¨ oßen sind. 584
Letter [568].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
399
¨ Uber den anscheinend divergenten Ausdruck der Vakuumpolarisation versuchen wir noch immer, uns zu u ¨berzeugen, daß er wirklich verschwindet. Man kann schon Rechenvorschriften geben, mit denen die Integration Null ergibt. Aber das gen¨ ugt nicht. Es k¨ onnte sein, daß man eine eindeutige Vorschrift bekommt, wenn man (im Prinzip) die Gleichungen f¨ ur endliches e l¨ ost und dann entwickelt. Ich glaube, ich werde die Jacobi-Identit¨ at beweisen k¨onnen — im wesentlichen unter Benutzung eines Variationsprinzipes L + λA + µB und seiner L¨osungen bis zur zweiten Ordnung in λµ. Aber das muß warten, bis ich wieder zu Hause bin. Mit herzlichen Gr¨ ußen Ihr [R. Peierls] [571] Ed Salpeter to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 15.9.1952 Dear Rudi, We have been playing with J. Irving’s tritone and Alpha-p[artic]le wave f[unctio]ns585 and I want your advice on the following: We took the latest experimental values for the triplet and singlet ranges of the 2body potential and plugged it into John’s formulae (Phil. Mag., XLII, 338 (1951)),586 adjusted the well depths (separately for H3 & H4 ) (away from the ex[ponential] values in such a way as to get the correct binding energy out of Jock’s formulae. For H4 this required no faking of the experimental well depth for Yukawa and a 15% increase of depth for the exponential shape. We then calculated the quantity I am really after r 2 , where r is the distance of a nucleon from the total center of mass. We got r 2 ∼ 0.7 × 10−26 cm2 for Yukawa and 1.2 × 10−26 cm2 for exponential. 585
John Irving, ‘The Binding Energy of the α-Particle’, Phys. Rev. 87, 519–20 (1952). 586 John Irving, ‘Binding energies of three and four-particle nuclei’, Phil. Mag. 42, 338–50 (1951).
April 7, 2009
12:11
400
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I’d like to know whether your guess would be that r 2 really depends so strongly on potential shape or whether you think that the method merely is inaccurate? The only news I have are rumours of some (14) “T-tracks” which Salant found at Brookhaven.587 A heavily ionizing, probably doubly charged part[icle] comes to rest and emits two minimum ionisation tracks, extremely straight, in exactly opposite directions. They were found in high altitude balloon flights (one flight), were very common in this one flight, but have never been seen before or after. ??? The Brookhaven Cosmotron is dismantled at the moment and they are getting it ready for systematic experiments in a few months time. As Oliphant probably told you, there is a possibility of my going to Canberra at the beginning of 1954. I haven’t made any decisions yet, but if I should decide to go, I would very much like to spend a few months at the end of 1953 (say October — or September — until X-mas in Birmingham before going Down Under. I am wondering what you think the chances might be for financial support for such a term’s stay at Edgbaston? Greetings to all Ed. [572] Rudolf Peierls to Ed Salpeter [Birmingham], 20.10.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Ed, I am sorry that the usual post-vacation rush has prevented me so far from thinking about your question and therefore from answering your letter. I would say that on general principles one would not expect variation methods to give good wave functions, even though they give good energy values, in fact, their very advantage lies in that they give a good energy value from a moderately bad function. I would therefore not be in the 587
M. Blau and E.O. Salant, ‘T -Tracks in Nuclear Emulsions’, Phys. Rev. 88, 954–55 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
401
least surprised if the mean square radius, which after all is sensitive to the wave function, in particular to its asymptotic part, were sensitive to the assumptions. It is often stated of Irving’s wave function that it is arranged to have the right asymptotic behaviour. This, however, applied only to the functional nature of the tail, but neither to the coefficient in the exponent, nor to the amplitude factor outside. Incidentally some later work by Irving, now in course of publication, indicates that even for the energy values his function is not quite as good as appeared at first, he seems to have had some luck with the cases to which it was first applied. Now about looking at the same integrals for the wave function of Svartholm,588 where the first iterated function should be very much better, this at any rate has the right asymptotic form with the correct exponent, whatever else may be wrong with it. Now about your plans. I need hardly say that I would be delighted at any prospect of your visiting this department and that I shall do anything in my power to secure a reasonable grant for the purpose. About the only kind of grant I can count on are our ordinary Research Fellowships. It may well be that one of these will be vacant at the beginning of next session and I think there would be no trouble in persuading the University to appoint you for one term. The maximum rate provided for these is at the rate of £700 p.a. I don’t know whether you would regard this as a satisfactory order of magnitude, but I shall also see what can be done in other ways. Please let me know how your plans develop and in particular about the probability p of your being able to come here as a function of time t. We have this year again a particularly attractive and lively group, and about the only trouble at the moment is that we have so many postgraduate lectures, working parties and discussion groups that one has to keep a time table to prevent them clashing. With kindest regards to everybody, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls 588
N.V. Svartholm, The Binding Energy of the Lightest Atomic Nuclei, Stockhom: Lund, 1945.
April 7, 2009
12:11
402
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[573] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 30.10.1952 Dear Peierls! I am writing to you just a few lines in a hurry before my departure to India on Nov[ember] 4.589 I thank you still for your letter from your vacation.590 Meanwhile I did not continue any work in the formfactor theory, but I may well resume it in Bombay. I would be, therefore, very grateful, if you could write to me at Tata Institute in Bombay, if you made some progress with your own work in this field, particularly with the proof of the Jacobi identity, which you sketched in your last letter.591 With best regards Sincerely yours W. Pauli
[574] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Aitken [Birmingham], 26.11.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Vice-Chancellor. I am writing to make the points about housing that I mentioned to you the other day. I believe that some other Universities are doing more than we are in suitable cases. For example my opposite numbers in the Universities 589
Pauli was planning to spend the winter semester 1952/3 at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research in Bombay. He had to cut short his commitment in India due to an illness of his wife and returned in Zurich in January 1953. See letter Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls, 12.1.1953, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b212, C.237. 590 Letter [570]. 591 Pauli continued to work in this problem and gave a paper in Turin in March 1953 at a meeting on Non-Local Field Theories, which was later published as ‘On the Hamiltonian structure of non-local field theories’, Nuovo Cimento 10 648–67 (1953).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
403
of Oxford and Manchester are living in houses which their universities are renting to them. In the case of Manchester this is a Professor who came over from the Continent and who probably otherwise would not have been able to come. Both these people moved into their houses a few years ago. I have no direct knowledge of anything like that having been done recently. From one other provincial University I understand that they control about 30 flats which are rented to members of staff, probably at some slight loss to the University. In that University also a good deal of help is being given to new people with finding houses. This included, for example, a University car which took a prospective new professor to see various suitable houses. Apart from the question of acquiring more property it seems to me that the flats at present occupied by members of staff would serve their purpose more adequately if the tenants were given to understand that they were expected to make way for new comers as soon as they can reasonably find more permanent accommodation. Even without imposing any fixed time limit I believe that an occasional reminder would make some of these flats available more frequently than is the case now. In addition I would suggest that some machinery be set up by which the University would enquire about the housing needs and other problems of new staff, particularly in difficult cases, such as men with large families and low salaries, or in the case of staff coming directly from abroad. In most cases they are now receiving help from colleagues in the same or related departments, but now and again this fails because the closest colleagues of a new member of staff may themselves be new comers or may be less knowledgeable in problems of real estate than in the academic subjects. From my own experience in advising new comers I know that a little local knowledge may save the new comer a great deal of time and may help to save him from serious mistakes. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
404
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[575] Ed Salpeter to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 10.12.1952 Dear Rudi, Thanks for your comments on Irving’s variational wave functions.592 I haven’t yet done any more about the problem. I’m afraid I have another question: One of our graduate students, Stan Cohen, has started (as a Ph.D. thesis) to calculate all the corrections, except the Lamb Shift, to the binding energy of a K-electron in a very heavy atom (say, U). I have just heard a rumour that one of your students (Shirley Brenner I believe) is doing — or has done — the same or a similar problem. If that’s true I would be very interested in details so that we can try to reduce duplication to a minium. My future plans are now somewhat more definite than before: I had almost decided to take the Chair at Canberra, but was rather worried about committing myself to a more or less permanent job of responsibility. In the meantime it has turned out that Dyson is going to the Princeton Institute on a permanent basis next September and so I got the chance of staying at Cornell on an Associate Professorship. To cut a long story short we decided to stay at Cornell but to go to Canberra for about a year either next September or sometime in 1954. All this doesn’t necessarily mean that we’ll live out our lives sitting on the fleshpots of America, but I think we’ll stay at Cornell at least for a number of years. We still would like very much to come to B’ham for a while in the not too distant future. Coming for a term or year would be nicest but I couldn’t get another leave of absence very soon after my leave for going to Canberra. Another possibility would be coming for a summer sometime (for which I don’t need a leave of absence). An earlier possibility would be to come for just a month or so on our way to or from Australia, but I don’t know whether I could arrange that yet (and the extra fare might be a bit steep for such a short stay). An added complication is that Mika is expecting a baby in June 1953 — but I hope something can be arranged in spite of these complications. With best regards to all from Mika & Ed Salpeter 592
Letter [572].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
405
P.S. E.A. Power of University College is thinking of coming to the States for a year. There might possibly be some Research Associateship at Cornell. I’m wondering whether you know him, if so we would be interested in your opinion of him.
[576] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft [Birmingham], 12.12.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, The Birmingham Post this morning had a front line item reporting that Flowers was about to be appointed as the Chief Theoretical Physicist at A.E.R.E., as usual they forgot the word ‘theoretical’ half-way through and also in the headline, which makes him the Chief Physicist at Harwell and some other parts of the report are equally silly. They quote as their source the New York Times and the New York Herald Tribune. The item is somewhat embarrassing for me because they also quote me in a statement about Flowers,593 which came about because their reporter rang me to say they understood a report from the Ministry of Supply was about to be released and they wanted to collect background information, but they would hold it until the release was authorized by the Ministry. I warned the man specifically that I could not confirm the story and that I advised him not to accept it as true, but I thought it was in order to tell him what I thought of Flowers. I am reporting this to you to point out that things like that seem to be happening frequently, because information seems to reach the newspapers long before a decision has been formally confirmed and even longer before it is released to the press. The situation seems to me very bad for the relations between the Ministry and the Press, to put everybody into embarrassing situations and to result in the Press printing 593
Brian Hilton Flower, who had completed his Ph.D. at Birminham, became head of the theoretical division at AERE, holding this post until 1958.
April 7, 2009
12:11
406
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
stories in a distorted way (when the official release comes it is then stale news and they do not bother to give the correct information). I know, of course, perfectly well that these matters are not controlled from Harwell, but I thought I would draw your attention to this in case you are able to pass it on to the appropriate quarters in the Ministry for a more reasonable procedure. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[577] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 15.12.1952 Dear Rudy: I have the feeling that I have owed you a letter for quite a while. In particular, you asked me about an International Conference in Birmingham594 next fall. You may have decided about this long ago. If you haven’t I want to point out the existence of an International Conference in Japan in September 1953,595 which you probably have been invited to. I don’t know whether you want to go, but in any case, a considerable number of people possibly will go, and it may therefore not be a good idea to run a competition.∗ I probably shall not go, but I have not decided yet. An additional reason for writing you is that a very good graduate student of mine Stanley Cohen, wants very much to go to England after he finishes his Ph.D. He has applied for a Fulbright but it is of course not clear whether he will get it. If he gets it, he would like to come ∗ This
letter was held up by a secretarial confusion. In the meantime I have learnt that the conference is going to take place, and in July, so there won’t be any interference. 594
Rudolf Peierls was organising the second of two international conferences in Birmingham for the autumn of 1953. 595 International Conference on Theoretical Physics, Kyoto and Tokyo, September 1953.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
407
to you. Some time ago you told me that you might have fellowships or positions of your own available for good Ph.D.’s from Cornell. This one I can recommend wholeheartedly. What are the possibilities for him at Birmingham? Naturally, his going there would be dependent on your reaction to the other letter enclosed with this one, but supposing you were at Birmingham he would be very anxious to come. There is another question connected with the same man. He is working on a good and accurate theory of the energy levels of electrons in heavy atoms. After he had gone quite a way in this calculation, we heard a rumour that a student of yours was working on the same subject. I think this is not necessarily undesirable because a lot has to be done on this problem and two different people may find different approaches to it. However, I think you should know that this is going on and maybe the two people concerned should exchange their wisdom. We are making considerable progress on the scattering of mesons by nucleons. It is a straightforward application of pseudo-scalar coupling. The approximation made is that we consider only processes in which one additional meson is produced in the field, or a nucleon pair, or both. We hope this is a good approximation but we have no proof for that. Apart from this approximation the problem is treated exactly, using a method similar to Tamm and Dancoff.596 We can reproduce the essential features of the phase shifts of the important partial waves as measured by Fermi, et al. The only major discrepancy is for the S state of isotopic spin 1/2. We are only at the beginning of these calculations, so that much of it can still be wrong, and we have neither quantitative results nor a consistent theory. But it is very interesting and exciting. Hoping to hear from you soon, Yours sincerely, Hans Merry Xmas!
596
I. Tamm, ‘Relativistic interaction of elementary particles’, J. Phys. (USSR) 9, 449–60 (1945); S.M. Dancoff, ‘Non-Adiabatic Meson Theory of Nuclear Forces’, Phys. Rev. 78, 382–85 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
408
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[578] Hans Bethe to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 15.12.1952 Dear Rudy: This is to ask you whether it would be possible for you to come here to Cornell as a Visiting Professor for one year, namely the academic year 1953–54. Unfortunately, we are losing Dyson to the Institute of Advanced Studies. During his first year here, he had the feeling that he did not work very effectively; others did not. Particularly, during the summer he accepted some work which did not satisfy him. This fall he is working with very great efficiency on the scattering of mesons by nucleons; in fact we are all working with him.597 However, before this creative period started, he had come to the conclusion that a University with all its graduate students, examinations and other diversions would not permit him to devote his full energy to his work. He therefore asked Oppenheimer whether the standing invitation he had to the Institute could be converted into a permanent appointment. Oppie of course took up this suggestions most eagerly and made him an offer which also financially exceeds anything that Cornell University can match. We are very sorry to lose him, but find it impossible to prevent it. We have offered Ed Salpeter an Associate Professorship to take Dyson’s place at least as far as the teaching is concerned. Ed has accepted this position in preference to the Chair of Theoretical Physics at Canberra. However, he wants to visit Australia for one year and, for personal reasons, he would prefer this to be the first year of his appointment, that is the next academic year. Oliphant has already offered him to come to Canberra for one year as he wants to, but the exact time has not been settled yet. Salpeter has written to him, asking whether next year will be alright. Cornell University has agreed to give him a leave during his first year [if] he can make his arrangement with Oliphant. 597
See letter [577]. A joint paper was published in 1954. F.J. Dyson, M. Ross, E.E. Salpeter, S.S. Schweber, M.K. Sundaresan, W.M. Visscher, and H.A. Bethe, ‘MesonNucleon Scattering in the Tamm-Dancoff Approximation’, Phys. Rev. 95, 1644–58 (1954).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
409
This leaves us minus a professor of theoretical physics for this coming year. At the same time, it gives us an opportunity which especially Wilson and I have been seeking for quite a while. We have wanted for a long time to invite you to come here for a considerable period. The University has agreed to my approaching you on this matter. We can offer you for the academic year a salary of $10,000. The University starts on September 21, 1953 and ends on June 8, 1954. I do not know, of course, whether you can get away from Birmingham for this length of time. However, I thought that perhaps it could be arranged if you started this long ahead of time. If you could come, all of us would be delighted. I am sure you would want to bring your family, and I am sure that suitable living quarters could be found. You would have to teach presumably one course each semester, 3 hours a week. You could choose among the set of courses ranging from three courses in classical physics through a year-course in quantum mechanics to some more advanced courses like nuclear theory. The other courses will be given by Morrison598 and myself. As you know, there is a lot of experimental work going on in the Nuclear Laboratory and I am sure you will find the contact with this work interesting. You may have heard that Wilson is building a new synchrotron which is to give 1 to 1.5 Bev with a small amount of iron. We hope this will be working next summer so that the coming academic year may be a particularly interesting time. In addition, we are doing a lot of theoretical work and we hope, with Dyson’s help to bring meson theory into a shape such that it can actually be applied to the calculation of specific processes. This also ought to be in full swing by next fall. There are always a considerable number of young men who have taken their Ph.D.’s at other Universities and who come here with some kind of fellowship. This year we have three such people from the United States, plus a man from Turkey. In addition, we have three or four Research Associates who are paid by the Laboratory. There is a con598
Philip Morrison (1915–2005), obtained his Ph.D. from Berkeley in 1940. After his wartime work on the Manhattan Project, he worked at San Francisco State University, University of Illinois, Cornell University and M.I.T.
April 7, 2009
410
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
siderable number of graduate students, some of whom are doing their theses in theoretical physics. Altogether, this makes quite a stimulating group. The group is usually quite international; for next year we expect to have a Frenchman, an Egyptian and presumably one or two Englishmen, and possibly an Austrian or a Japanese. I hope very much that all this will sound attractive enough for you to consider coming here. If you decide to do so, you would make us very happy. Especially I would like very much the idea of repeating the times of Manchester, 1933. Please let me know what you think of it. Yours sincerely, Hans [579] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe [Birmingham], 16.12.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, I am writing once again about a further possible link in the chain between Birmingham and Cornell. This time it is about R.D. Dalitz, who will be writing to you saying that he is applying for a Commonwealth Fund Grant and asking whether you are prepared to have him if he gets the award and also what the possibilities are of a Research Fellowship, or similar post at Cornell. As regards the first part of the question I shall eat my hat if you do not say that you will be glad to have him, but as regards the second part you might like to know more about him. Firstly you met Dalitz when you were here last and I think we had some quite lengthy discussions with him, but I do not know how much detail you remember. Then he is, of course, also well known to Dyson and you should be able to find out what Dyson thinks of him. As far as my own view goes I have an enormous respect for Dalitz. He is good at field theory, for example when he worried about the internal pair creation in the Oxygen 16 decay, the papers by Feynman were quite new, and when he found that those would be useful for him he learnt the drill in a month or two and produced a reasonable answer. He knows
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
411
a lot about nuclear physics, for example both the shell model experts here like Flowers, and the experimentalists, made a habit of consulting him frequently, much to their benefit, but somewhat to the detriment of Dalitz’s own research output. He is good in talking to experimentalists and has constructive ideas, for example he realised that the pairs found at Bristol close to the stars represented the decay of a neutral meson into one pair and one photon, calculated this to show it gives the right magnitude and showed how this can be used to estimate the life-time. He volunteered last year to give a course on nuclear reactions, which was new to him then and he gave a first rate course on this. As part of this he produced the elementary derivation of the Butler formula, which was noticed independently by several other people.599 It never occurred to him to write this up as a paper, this was just part of giving a good course of lectures. There was later some interest in the polarization of the protons, which on the Butler approximation is zero, and this came out more easily from Dalitz’s technique than any other and only then was I able to persuade him to write a paper on the subject. This year he is giving us a similar post-graduate course on meson physics, both for experimentalists and our own group. I had thought of giving this course myself to avoid overloading Dalitz, but he was keen on doing it and I am now glad that I let him, because he is doing a much better job that I could I have done.600 He is also a first rate undergraduate teacher, though this will concern you less and one of his functions is to give our somewhat crazy courses in the Physical School, which as you may remember involves doing Maxwell’s theory in twelve lectures and wave mechanics in another twelve. The Physics Department have pressed me hard to keep Dalitz on this particular assignment, unless I can do it myself, because nobody else has done it so well. He is also running our Seminar and since he has taken it over I am for the first time in the position of not having to worry about it, but just to ask who will be talking next week. 599 See letter R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls, 19.3.1952, Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b205, C.75. 600 Dalitz later published research arising from his work on the τ -meson. R.H. Dalitz, ‘The Decay of the τ -Meson’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A66, 710–13 (1953).
April 7, 2009
12:11
412
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
With all these activities and his sense of duty it is not surprising that he has not published as much as he might have, even though his output is quite creditable. Another reason for this is that he has set his heart on meson theory, where it is much harder to publish papers than, for example, on nuclei, where he could have got out a lot more. He has also very high standards and will not undertake a calculation by sloppy methods, perhaps he is even a bit too critical in this respect. One of the objects of trying to spend some time at Cornell would be just the hope of getting a more concrete programme in that direction. He has made himself so useful here that I am not at all happy at the thought of being without him, but of course it [. . . ]601
[580] Rudolf Peierls to Ed Salpeter Birmingham, 18.12.1952 (carbon copy) Dear Ed, Thank you for your very interesting letter.602 On the first point you will have had the letter from Brown who explains in detail what we have done about it and I think the conclusion is that this is well in hand and is hardly worth pursuing further (it turns out in the end to be so simple that it would in any case not be the subject of a Ph.D. thesis) unless, of course, one either wants to get a still higher accuracy, which would be very difficult or else wants to put more efforts into dotting all the i’s and crossing all the t’s. We are quite happy about the approximations that Miss Brenner has made, with the possible exception of an estimate of certain second order corrections, which we are discussing at the moment. What pleases us particularly is that I have invented a trick which should reduce the problem of calculating the Lamb Shift corrections 601 602
Last page missing from manuscript. Letter [575].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
413
for this case to quite manageable proportions. This arose because we wanted to see whether one could use electronic computing equipment for this purpose, but it now looks as if it might in fact be quite manageable to do it here and hardly worth putting on a machine. If this is successful, it would at the same time also give the answer to the problem of the scattering of gamma-rays by a heavy element in which we are still interested. However, this idea is only about a week old, and we evidently have to sort it out further. As regards your own plans, you will of course always be welcome here for a week, or a month, or a year, though in the latter case of course it depends on what we can do in the way of funds. I suppose I should now wait until you tell me a little more definitely when you are going to Australia. We have just sent out invitations for a conference to be held here in July along lines similar to the 1948 conference, but devoted to nuclear physics as such. We cannot pay fares for this, but it might be an excuse to get your fare paid by someone else. However, it does not sound as if, from your own domestic point of view, June would be a particularly good time. As regards Power,603 I do not know him well personally, I do know that both Gunn and Massey think very highly of him, but you will no doubt get their opinions directly. My only direct contact with him was that I interviewed him for a job at Harwell, for which we would have taken him, if he had not preferred to go to University College, and I was his examiner for the Ph.D. which at Glasgow involves no oral examination, so I only had to read his thesis. This was quite a good piece of work, though to my taste rather too strongly based on perturbation theory and coming out with rather strong statements for pseudo vector and against pseudo scalar coupling, however, that is not much evidence either way. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls 603
E.A. Power from University College London was contemplating embarking on research in the United States.
April 7, 2009
12:11
414
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[581] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 26.12.1952 Dear Peierls, Thank you very much for your letter.604 I feel I owe you and your wife several letters. It is very good of Genia especially to continue taking so much interest in us. We all send our warmest good wishes for the new year to you and the whole department. I hope you had as merry a Christmas as we had. Probably you will some time run into Perkins who was here for the Rochester Conference, and he will tell you in some detail what went on there, if you do not get this information already from the proceedings which this time will be printed and given a wide distribution.605 It was a good and enjoyable conference, not so much because of any specific new development, but because of a general atmosphere of progress and optimism. Now to answer your questions about our meson-nucleon scattering calculations. We have not renormalized anything, and we have not instigated the order of magnitude of the many terms which we have omitted from our calculations entirely. On the contrary, our aim has been simply to take all those terms in the exact field theory which in the Dancoff approximation remain finite and unambiguous, and forget the rest for the time being.606 Specifically, we have thrown away the terms describing the proton self-energy (also the vacuum self-energy) and the meson self-energy. It is fairly clear how these terms will be handled in a more accurate calculation, by carrying out the usual renormalization in a covariant way before going to the Dancoff approximation, but we have not seriously attempted to do this. We have not done the P1/21/2 and the S1/2 state at all. 604
Letter could not be located. Proceedings of the Third Rochester Conference on High Energy Physics, New York: Interscience Publishers, 1953. 606 F.J. Dyson, ‘The Use of the Tamm-Dancoff Method in Field Theory’, Phys. Rev. 90, 994 (1953). 605
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
415
Our justification for all this is that we have finite equations which we can go ahead and solve, which contain in a qualitatively correct way the theoretical relativistic properties of the meson and nucleon, and which seem to give a good qualitative understanding of many features of the experimental results. The important thing is that, by actually solving these equations, we have learned a great many elementary facts about the consequences of any similar set of equations. So it is now much easier to see what will be the consequences of including in the interaction some of the many terms which we have neglected. So far our main numerical efforts have been concentrated on the P3/2 3/2 state which is the only one with strong attractive forces. Hans Bethe has derived for this the formula (quoting from memory) tan δ [tan δ]Born approx.
=
340 − E 200 − E
E= kinetic energy of meson in c. of mass system in MeV. This is at 2 2 a coupling constant G 4π = 14. Making G a little smaller will put the 607 resonance at a higher energy. I will be very glad to hear what you think of all this. All good wishes, Freeman Dyson I am sorry there is no chance of coming to the conference in July. I am teaching Summer School in Berkeley this summer.
607
See also F.J. Dyson, ‘Mass Renormalization with the Tamm-Dancoff Method’, Phys. Rev. 91, 421–22 (1953).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
416
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[582] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe Birmingham, 5.1.1953 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, Thanks you for your letter of 15th December, which arrived a day or two ago and for your invitation.608 This is most tempting indeed, I would love to stay at Cornell for some time and even more to have a chance of working with you again at leisure. However, I do not think it can be done. My group here still ha[s] such a rapid turn over that I am a very important element in its continuity. If I went away for a year I would probably have to start from scratch when I returned. In any case it would not be fair on the other members of staff here, who would have to deputize for me and whose chances of getting some research done would suffer the most because they would loose my help and because they would have to do my work instead. It would also be unreasonable to leave just when the synchrotron in the Physics Department here is nearing completion (it might in fact be working) so that the experimentalists are at last beginning to think about mesons rather than about engineering problems. On the more formal side I could not expect to get study leave from the university so soon after spending a term at Princeton. I could presumably get leave of absence without pay, provided I could assure the university that the work of the department could continue satisfactorily, but I am not sure this would work financially. However, the major difficulty is that I feel I can’t leave the other people here in the lurch. This is particularly acute next year when presumably Dalitz will not be here, because his presence made a lot of difference during my absence in Princeton. I certainly would not want to bring any pressure on him to postpone his departure since I think he needs a change of scenery. With all this, much as I felt tempted by the invitation, I think I must not accept. 608
Letters [577–78].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
417
Of course the situation may change with time and if the possibility of such an invitation might arise again some time later I would be very happy to look at it again. If at the present you are likely to be somewhat shorthanded I think you might find my suggestion of having Dalitz with you quite useful. He would certainly be quite willing to do some teaching and to help look after research students and the like, provided this is not on such a scale as to prevent his doing physics himself. I think you would also find that he is a very good person to discuss things with. Once more many thanks and kindest regards, Yours sincerely, [Rudi]
[583] Rudolf Peierls to Hans Bethe Birmingham, 5.1.1953 (carbon copy) Dear Hans, In reply to your letter about Stanley Cohen,609 I would of course be very glad to have him if he can get a Fulbright grant. Does he want, at this stage, a formal letter saying so? On the question of a local grant, this is not quite to easy, our Fellowships here are limited in number and I do not know how many vacancies I will have next year, if any, since the plans of one of two people who are holding such Fellowships at the present are not yet decided. I also expect some fairly strong applicants and therefore one would have to make out a fairly good case for Cohen, if he were to have any chance. From what you say it seems as if he has not published anything yet and while this does not rule him out, it would certainly need a very firm supporting statement from you. When the time comes to advertize our Fellowships, which is likely to be in two or three months, I shall let you know and perhaps you would then be good enough to tell me your opinion about him explicitly. 609
Letter [577].
April 7, 2009
12:11
418
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
As regards his problem, we had already heard about this from Salpeter and Gerry Brown, who is looking after this work, and has sent a summary to Salpeter. The numbers of course are still changing a little, because one or two corrections of interest have turned up, at the same time our confidence in the terms already worked out is increasing and the really surprising part of the situation is how simple it all is in the end. However, this work is concerned only with the K-absorption edge and we are not at present proposing to look at other energy levels. The main outstanding uncertainly in the K-absorption edge is the contribution of Lamb-shift terms and we think we have got a method which will make the numerical computation of this term possible and will at the same time give the results for the scattering of gamma rays in the K-shell of a heavy element, which I believe are still of interest. I am now in touch with Hartree to see if this problem can be done on the Cambridge machine. Yours sincrerely, [Rudi]
[584] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli Birmingham, 20.1.1953 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli! Thank you for your letter.610 I am very sorry to hear that your wife was ill in India, I hope she has completely recovered and I also hope that you had some chance of seeing something of India. I had not written to you since I had not found the proof for the Jacobi identities. I knew that the proof had to be quite simple, but I somehow could not see it. However, I have got it now, and I enclose a rough draft of it. I would like to consider this a little longer because the argument is very abstract 610
Letter Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls, 12.1.1953, Peierls Papers, Supp., C.238.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
419
and one has to watch out that one knows what the symbols mean, but I am reasonably convinced that it is in order. I would be glad to know what you think. Otherwise on the subject of non-local theories our main progress has been to find a method by means of which one can regard the action principle which contains an infinite time integration, as the limiting case of a modified action principle extending over a finite time interval only. At least for the case of non-interacting fields we can write this in such a form that the finite action principle has reasonable solutions and one can in fact prove that they are the complete set of solutions, so that one avoids the ambiguity of the mathematics, which previously troubled me, but I cannot say how this will work with interacting fields. We are also in the process of writing up a paper on the results we have so far obtained.611 This still leaves a number of difficulties unsolved, but we have discussed the equations so often and with so many people that it seems more satisfactory to put down in writing what we know. Yours sincerely R.E. Peierls Appendix Proof of the Jacobi Identity If the bracket symbols defined in the previous paper612 can be identified as the Poisson brackets, they must satisfy the identity {A, {B, C}} + {B, {C, A, }} + {C, {A, B}} = 0
(1)
In the present note I want to verify that this is indeed a consequence of the definitions in a classical theory, i.e. apart from the order of factors. It is sufficient to prove (1) for the case in which A, B, C are the field amplitudes themselves. 611
R. Peierls, ‘The Commutation laws of relativistic field theory’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A 214, 143–57 (1952). 612 Refers to the draft paper on commutation laws.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
420
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I use the notation of section 6 of the previous paper, i.e. a symbol φα represents the value of a field amplitude at some given space time point. The action integral L is assumed to be a function of all these φα and a sum α stands for the integration over space-time as well as the summation over components and over the different kinds of field. I shall further shorten notation by writing Lα for ∂L/∂φα , and Dαβ φ for Dφαβ . Then (1) requires that −
α γ
−
−
γ β
α
α β Dγ
− Dβ
−
D D
D
D
D
β α
γ β
D
+Dγ Dαβ − Dγ
α
β γ Dα
γ
D
D
+Dβ Dγα − Dβ
−
D D
γ β
D D
Dα Dβγ − Dα
β α
α γ
(2)
= 0.
The field equations are Lµ = 0
(3)
D
and νµ as well as Dµν satisfy the equation, (using the summation convention): (4a) Lσλ Dβλ + δσγ = 0 D
Lσλ
λ β
+ δσγ = 0.
(4b)
Now the definition of the operator D acting on any function of the field variables is ∂f (5) Dµ f = Dµν ∂φν and to generate a term of the type occuring in (2) we apply this rule to f = Dβλ : ∂ Dλ . (6) Dµ Dβλ = Dµν ∂φν β Now, for this purpose Dβλ is defined as that solution of (4a) for which Dβλ → 0,
tλ − tβ → −α.
(7)
We may therefore regard (4a) as an identity, and may differentiate it with respect to any φ, say φν : Lσλν Dβλ
+ Lσλ
∂Dβλ ∂φν
= 0.
(8)
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
421
Multiply by Dµν : ∂ Dλ = 0. ∂φν β
To solve this equation for the quantity (6) multiply by D
σ γ
+ Lσλ
D
Lσλν Dµν Dβλ
σ ν γ Dµ
∂ Dλ = 0. ∂φν β
(9) D
Lσλν Dµν Dβλ + Lσλ Dµν
σ γ:
(10)
But from (4b) remembering that Lσλ is a second derivative, so that Lσλ = Lλσ
Lσλ
σ γ
= −δλγ
(12)
∂ Dλ = Lσλν Dµν Dβλ γ σ ∂φν β D
Dµν
D
we have
(11)
(13)
inserting in (6) and using the identity D
Dσγ =
σ γ
(14)
{paper 1, equation (6.8)}, we have Dα Dβγ = Lσλν Dαν Dβλ Dσγ .
(15)
D
Note. It would appear arbitrary that we used σγ as a factor obtaining (10) and that we might have used Dγσ instead, since we would obtain the corresponding reduction by means of (4a) instead of (4b). However, we would then have obtained, instead of (15) the expression Lσλν Dαν Dβλ Dγσ ,
(16)
where α, β, γ are summation variables. Now the factor Lσλν is of a limited range, i.e. it gives a large contribution only if tσ tλ tn u are not very different. This, however, does not prevent all of them being very large and positive, and the other factors do not decrease as tσ ∼ tλ ∼ tσ → +α The expression (16) therefore contains an integral
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
422
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
which is likely to diverge. This objection does not apply to (15) since the factor Dσγ will decrease as {cf(7)} tγ − tσ → ∞ (15) gives us the first term of (2) and with an obvious interchange of suffixes also the first term of the second and third line. The last term on each line is obtained by reversing the time order, i.e. interchanging upper and lower suffixes in the D functions of (15). For the second term on the first line we proceed in the same way, but with Dβλ replaced by λβ in (6). Therefore we obtain: D
D
Dα
γ β
= Lσλν Dαν Dλβ Dσγ .
(17)
In this case the alternative calculation analogous to (16) is also meaningful and we find also D
Dα
γ β
= Lσλν Dαν Dλβ Dγσ .
(18)
For the third term we again reverse the order of time compared to (17) or (18), and for other lines we interchange αβγ cyclically. Thus we find for (2), using only the relations (15) and (17): Lσλν {Dαν Dβλ Dσγ − Dαν Dλβ Dσγ − Dνα Dβλ Dγσ + Dνα Dλβ Dγσ +Dβν Dλγ Dσα − Dβν Dλγ Dσα − Dνβ Dγλ Dασ − Dνβ Dγλ Dασ +Dγν Dαλ Dσβ − Dγν Dλα Dσβ − +Dνγ Dαλ Dβσ + Dνγ Dλα Dβσ }.
(19)
Here the suffixes σλ, ν may be interchanged in the bracket, since the factor outside is a third derivative, and therefore symmetric. It is then evident that the terms in (19) are opposite and equal in pairs. This establishes the Jacobi identity.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
423
[585] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 23.1.1953 Dear Peierls! I have just received your letter with your proof of the Jacobi-identity which I read with great interest.613 There is indeed a peculiarity contained in it, which should explicitly be emphasized: In the equation Dµ f = Dµν
∂f ∂φν
(5)
∂f is only unambiguously defined, if a given function of the the symbol ∂φ ν φν regardless whether or not the φν satisfy the field equations Lµ = 0 ∂f (3).∗ If, on the other hand, f is only defined for solutions of Lµ = 0, ∂φ ν µ µ is only defined apart from an additional term +Lµν Λ (Λ Lagrangian multiplier). This would give rise, on the right side of (5), to the additional term (see (4a)!)
Dµν Lαν Λα = −δαµ Λα = −Λµ which is entirely arbitrary. It was therefore not obvious for me a priori whether it is possible to define unambiguously the quantity Dµ Dβλ [see equation (6)], which enters the Jacobi-identity (2). It is, after all, a certain trick, to use the “variational equations” Lσλ Dβλ + δσβ = 0
(4a)
independent of the validity of the field equations Lµ = 0 for the fields which enter Lσλ and Dβλ : One proceeds to define second variations of ∗I
assume of course that L given as function(al) of the φν before the field equations were derived at all. 613
Letter [584].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
424
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the variational equations in cases, where the varied “orbit” does not fulfill the “equations of motion”. ∂D λ
In this way, one reaches a definition of ∂φνβ [equation (8)], assuming L (hence Lσλν ) to be known (defined) also for fields, which do not satisfy Lµ = 0. All this I do not consider at all to be an objection. On the contrary it is necessary to use a definition of Dα Dγβ in order to give to the Jacobi-identity a meaning. As the definition (8) — which leads to (15) — is consistent, it is reasonable to apply it. But, independent of the Jacobi-identity, it seems to me important to emphasize, that according to your formalism ∂f /∂φν has only an unambiguous meaning if f is defined as a function of the φ’s, even if the latter do not satisfy Lµ = 0. My wife is much better now. In India we saw the temples of the island of Elephanta and in Ellora, Ajanta and Aurangabad. But we did not see Agra, Madras and Mysore, what was planned, due to the illness of my wife. Hope to get your paper soon. I intend to tell what I know myself in Turin in March.614 All good wishes Yours W. Pauli [586] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 24.1.1953 (1st letter) supplement to my letter from yesterday Dear Peierls! I just saw, that the ambiguity in the definitions of cancels in the final result. Consider the Poisson-Bracket [f, φn u] = (Dµν − Dµν ) 614
See letter [573], note 291.
∂f . ∂φν
∂f ∂φν
and of Dµν ∂φ∂ ν Dβλ
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
425
∂f The arbitrary additional term in ∂φ is equal Λα Lαν but Λα · Lαν (Dµν − ν ν µ ) = 0 The Poisson Bracket [f, φν ] is therefore well defined, even if f is only defined for φ’s satisfying Lα = 0. — The reason is, of course, that (Dµν − νµ ) satisfies the homogeneous variational equations, in contrast to Dm uν and m uν separately. In the same way, the equation
D
D
D
D
γ ν µ )Dβ
+ Lσλ (Dµν −
D
Lσλν (Dµν −
ν µ)
∂ Dλ = 0 ∂φν β
in entirely unambiguous, in contrast to your equation (9). And so is D
γ α )Dβ
= Lσλν (Dαν −
D
(Dα −
γ λ ν α )Dβ Dσ .
But this would mean to write the 3d term −Dνα Dβλ Dσγ instead of −Dνα Dσλ Dγσ as you wish to do. I write therefore µλ Lσλν Dµν Dβλ + Lσλ Dµ Dβλ = Lσλ Λβ
↓ arbitrary Lagrangian multiplier
D
Lσλν
ν λ µ Dβ
+ Lσλ
D
and
λ µ Dβ
D
Multiply the first equation with use σ γ Lσλ = δγλ ,
σ γ
= Lσλ Λµλ. β
↓ same multiplier
(A)
(B)
the second with Dγσ and subtract, Dγσ Lσλ = δγλ ,
D
One gets D
Lσλν (Dαν Dβλ Dσγ − Dνα Dβλ Dγσ ) = (Dα −
γ α )Dβ .
This is your first minus your third term, a difference which is certainly unambiguous. It is anyway a certain arbitrariness to use the equation (A), (B) separately with the same multiplier Λµλ β . Hence a certain ambiguity, overcome only by a suitable definition, is still in your proof, if you try to avoid the form −Dνα Dβλ Dσγ of the third term.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
426
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
In the moment, I think, that your attempts to define uniquely ∂ Dλ ∂φν β
and
D
Dµν
ν µ
∂ Dλ ∂φν β
separately, not only their difference, needs a further study. Yours W. Pauli [587] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 24.1.1953 [2nd letter] Dear Peierls! I hope that this is now my last addendum: I do not see any difficulty any longer with the proof of the Jacobi-identity, if this proof is arranged only slightly differently. Dβλ can be considered as only defined for such fields which are solutions of Lµ = 0. Instead of differentiating Lσλ Dβλ + δσδ = 0
(4a)
with respect to φν I propose to replace φν by φν + λµ (Dµν − Dµν ) which is still a solution of Lµ = 0. Defining ∂ (Dµ − Dµ )Dβλ ≡ − µ Dβλ ∂λ µ and differentiating (4a) with respect to λ one gets then Lσλν (Dµν − Dµν )Dβλ + Lσλ (Dµ − Dµ )Dβλ = 0 instead of your (9). Multiplying with Dγσ and proceeding as you one gets (Dα − Dα )Dβγ = Lσλν (Dαν Dβλ Dσγ − Dνα Dβλ Dσγ ) instead of (15).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
427
(There is no convergence difficulty as there is always at least one of the J indices σλν below and at least one above.) Changing in the last relation the time order and adding one gets for the Jacoby-identity (2) the form (slightly differently from your (19)). In the second and third term Dγσ and Dσγ are transposed compared with your (19) Lσλν {Dαν Dβλ Dσγ − Dαν Dλβ Dγσ − Dνα Dβλ Dσγ − Dνα Dλβ Dγσ ) + Dβν Dγλ Dσα − Dβν Dλγ Dασ − Dνβ Dγλ Dσα − Dνβ Dλγ Dασ + Dγν Dαλ Dσβ − Dγν Dλα Dβσ − Dνγ Dαλ Dβσ + Dνγ Dλα Dβσ } which of course cancels also due to the symmetry of Lσλν . I think that settles this case now. One shall not define and use more than it is really necessary; nobody needs to know what Dβλ is for fields with Lµ = 0! Yours sincerely, W. Pauli
[588] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli Birmingham, 13.2.1953 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli! Thank you for your dramatic sequence of letters615 which were very interesting. I must say that on considering my proof further I see no objection at all in regarding the first order D-quantities as defined even for fields which do not satisfy the field equations. If they don’t then they cannot be real fields and the variation equations for D do not have the meaning of proper variation equations, but they are still perfectly valid mathematical relations and if we find it convenient to use them in intermediate steps, why not? Of course, your method of proceeding is in order, too, and it is largely a matter of taste which one prefers. 615
Letters [585–87].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
428
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
I am now really interested in where we go from here. One questions to which you seem to know the answer, but on which I am not quite clear is: having now established the Jacoby identities, how much of the standard theory using Poisson brackets, is at our disposal and how can we prove it? Of course a much more interesting question is what do we do about the real case where the order of the factors matters? I have an invitation from Wataghin616 to lecture in Turin while you are there.617 I accepted with preasure in principle and wrote about dates, but meanwhile I have had a very bad bout of flu and am still in bed, so I am not quite sure that I shall be able to travel. But it would be nice to be able to discuss some of these problems directly. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [589] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls [Z¨ urich], 17.2.1953 Dear Peierls! Many thanks for your letter.618 If you regard the first order quantities as defined even for fields, which do not satisfy the field equations, it is arbitrary to start either with Lσλ Dβλ + δσβ = 0 as you so — or with
λ Lσλ Dβλ + δσβ + Λσβ = 0.
↓ arbitrary
616
Gleb Wataghin (1899–1986) Russian-Italian physicist who had worked in S˜ ao Paulo from 1934 until his return to Turin where he built a centre of theoretical physics after the war. 617 Peierls had agreed to lecture at the Turin conference on non-local field theories which took place between 9 and 14 March 2004. 618 Letter [588].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
429
I do not see any reason to exclude the latter equation, which, however, gives something different than the former, if differentiated with respect to φν . I thought it worth while to check, that this ambiguity has no influence on the result. I wrote down everything I know on energy-integrals, Poisson brackets etc. as a pre-publication manuscript, from which you will receive a copy very soon.619 I may publish it after the Turin lectures, after I shall know the reaction of you and some others. The draw back is the solution for the “initial-value-problem” for which I do not see yet any other possibility than the development in power series of the coupling constant. I hope very much, that you will be able to travel to Turin and that your flu will be over in time. I proposed to Wataghin for my stay there March 8 till 15. Hoping to see you soon yours sincerely, W. Pauli
[590] Ed Salpeter to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 23.2.1953 Dear Rudi, I should apologize for not having answered your last letter620 and the invitation to the B[irming]ham Conference sooner. My main excuse is that I wanted to hear from Oliphant about our visit to Canberra before I wrote you. Since M.L.O. has been acting only as a sink but not a source for correspondence I’m writing anyway: I would of course love to be able to come to the July Conference, but Mika’s scheduled multiplication this summer unfortunately makes this impossible. As you can see from the above paragraph my Australian 619
Prepublication manuscript of his Turin lecture, later published as W. Pauli, ‘On the Hamiltonian structure of non local field theories’, Nuovo Cimento 10, 648–67 (1953). 620 Letter [580].
April 7, 2009
12:11
430
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
plans are still awfully vague. I think there is still a possibility that we might go to Canberra for a year in September but it’s getting a bit late. In any case I think there probably wouldn’t be time for us to go via England this summer. But if we should go to Australia in Sept. 1953 we might be able to return via England, may be early July 1954. I presume you won’t know for quite a while yet what your movements in Summer 1954 might be? In any case I’ll let you know when I know if, when and how we’re going to Australia. You mentioned in your last letter that you had hopes of calculating the Lamb Shift in heavy elements. If you have any preprints or something of that sort yet, we’d be very interested. I believe Julian Mack at Wisconsin621 is busy getting X-ray levels in heavy elements even more accurately than so far. So we thought it might be worthwhile for Stan Cohen to see how accurately he can calculate everything, except the Lamb Shift. At the moment, his idea is to calculate only K − L shell energy differences (exptg. this is probably still more reliable than ionization potentials). The difficulties in his calculations would then be somewhat different from Miss Brenner’s, but if you have any preprints of her work, we’d be very grateful. There are some moves afoot to reprint Dyson’s Electrodynamics Notes (which are out of print at the moment), so if any of your students need some, we might have some again in a month or two. Greetings to All, Ed
621
Julian Ellis Mack (1903–1966), had obtained his Ph.D. from the University of Michigan in 1927; after research at the Universities of Michigan and Minnesota, he moved to Wisconsin where he eventually became professor of physics.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
431
[591] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 17.3.1953 Dear Peierls! As soon as I came back, I found here a letter of Møller and Kristensen about the convergence questions, though — it seems to me — with a very negative result.622 They say “As regards the question of convergence we now agree with the general statement of Claude Bloch that, in order to be sure to obtain convergence to any power in g, one has to choose a form factor in momentum space G(l(1) l(3) ),∗ which vanishes whenever one of the (1) (3) (1) (3) vectors lµ , lµ or lµ + lµ is space-like.” They show that the matrix-elements between two states a, b of the operators occuring in the field-equations are for instance of the form β Iab = G(Pµ2 , Kµ2 , Pµ Kµ )fab (p(a) + p(b) , P, K) · d4 K where
1 (3) (l − l(1) ) 2 and show that this is in general divergent unless G vanishes for all (1) (3) space-like P ’s. (For space-like lµ or lµ other matrix elements give analogous results.) (fab in general does not vanish for large values of any components of K.) They add, that their calculations of last summer, which gave convergence on fourth order were formally correct, but only valid for very particular values of the length’s λ (occuring in their special form factor) and that they think now that this has no significance and adjoin Bloch’s result. ∗ Defined
P = l(1) + l(3) mK =
by F (x , x , x ) = (2π)−8 l(3) )x } · dl(1) dl(3) . 622
(1)
(3)
G(l(1) , l(3) )·exp i{lx +lx −(l(1) +
Letter Ch. Møller and P. Kristensen to Wolfgang Pauli, 12.3.1953, Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/2, pp. 68–71.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
432
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
But if one passes with such form factors — they continue — to λ → 0 (k·k) ) in momentum space in one gets additional factors χ(k) = 12 (1 − |(k·k)| the Green-functions, which then in the x-space satisfy equations 1 1 1 ( − m2 )D(x − x ) = δ(x − x ) − 3 2 π [xx]2 They finally make the remark: “It is not obvious that the non-localised character of this function could be reconciled with causality requirements even for large space-time intervals. We would be very glad for comments on this point.” I am personally certain that these formfactors of the Bloch-type which make the theory convergent will give rise to a macroscopically wrong time order of processes (acausality). If I remember correctly you said already the same in Turin and I would be glad if you could write to me soon your opinion on this point. I hope to finish my paper this week. All good wishes Yours W. Pauli For me it looks like a cemetery for the lorentzinvariant formfactor theory in its present form. Do you have any idea how to proceed?
[592] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli Birmingham, 23.3.1953 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli! Thank you for your letter.623 I am very glad to know the discrepancy between Møller and Bloch has been cleared up. This agrees with conclusions we had reached here, namely Chr´etien looked at the meson self-energy for a space-like wave vector and saw 623
Letter [591].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
433
that in that case not only Møller’s proof breaks down that the answer is finite, but one can actually see that the answer diverges. Since these terms will also appear in the second-order nucleon self-energy it is not surprising that there must be trouble. I do not, however, agree that the requirement of zero form factor for space-like argument in momentum space leads to all the trouble which Møller indicates. I believe that this happens only if one chooses the particular form of the form factor which Møller wants to have, for which there is no strong reason. Whether one may work with a form factor which is restricted in this way depends on other questions. For example if one takes the electromagnetic case and uses the old McManus theory624 in which the form factor just appears in the form ¯ )γµ ψ(x )d4 x Aµ (x) = 4π F (x − x )ψ(x with the wave functions taken at the same point, then correspondence with the classical equations for slowly varying fields requires that the form factor be normalized to unity for zero momentum. If this is coupled with the condition that it vanishes for space-like argument, one obviously ends up with a discontinuous function and this will give the kind of trouble which Møller reports. On the other hand in the form of the equations which I discussed in Turin,625 the correspondence with the usual theory for long waves merely requires that the form is normalized to 1, when the argument is time like and equal to m2 . This is obviously compatible with the form factor vanishing for space-like argument and it is possible at the same time to have any number of derivatives of the form factor in momentum space bounded (but not all derivatives) so that I think such a form factor would have reasonable properties, but it is not of course clear that in our form of the theory one would wish it to vanish for space-like argument at all. 624
See letter [396], note 80. These correspond with Peierls’ contribution to the Kyoto-conference published as R. Peierls, ‘Field theories with non-local interactions’, Kyoto-Tokyo-Konferenz, 24–39 (1953). 625
April 7, 2009
434
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Now in any case in the Møller-Kristensen theory I do not see that there is any normalization condition, since there is no classical limit for a meson field about which any knowledge exists. I do not therefore think that one can jump to the conclusion that any choice of the form factor is prohibited, though I admit that a form factor which vanishes for space-like arguments sounds somewhat unreasonable and one would have to see what other trouble could arise from such a choice. I enclose a copy of a letter to Wataghin from which you will see that we are proposing to send a short paper on the properties of the form factors, which I think would be useful in connection with your paper.626 I shall of course send you a copy of is as soon as it is ready. Yours sincerely R.E. Peierls (handwritten comment by Pauli: This, however, does not settle yet the question of the time order of processes (causality) of macroscopic distances. I shall come back to it. Hope to hear from you again. Best regards, W. Pauli.)
[593] Rudolf Peierls to Nevill Mott Birmingham, 9.12.1953 (carbon copy) Dear Mott, Congratulations on your appointment.627 I had not heard about it yet, but I am exceedingly glad for Cambridge. How soon will you be moving? On the particular question of Scott. This is a most difficult situation. You know him personally and I need not therefore stress how attractive, intelligent and generally educated a person he is. 626 Chr´etien and Peierls were about to publish their results in M. Chr´etien and R. Peierls, ‘Properties of form factors in non-local theories’, Nuovo Cimento 10, 668–76 (1953). 627 Nevill Mott had been appointed Cavendish Professor of Physics, an appointment he took up in 1954 and held until 1971.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
Birmingham: A ‘Most Stimulating Theoretical Group’
peierlsroot2
435
About his research. He was always interested in nuclear theory and before he took up his present post, he had a rather nice idea about explaining unsymmetric fission. I do not believe in fact that his explanation of this is right, but it was an interesting possibility, which had independently been suggested by Lise Meitner and he had followed it much further. However, since his appointment to his present job in which his particular assignment is to deal with nuclear theory, he does not seem to have got very much done. I saw one paper of his in which he tried to establish some semi-empirical rule in the shell model, but it was neither very convincing or constructive and I don’t think he has pursued it. I cannot remember whether this paper ever got published. Shortly after this he seems to have dropped nuclear physics and taken up some finer points in atomic theory. What he has done about these problems seems quite competent, though not exciting. What has embarrassed me particularly is that at least two research students whom Scott was supposed to supervise on problems of nuclear theory, have come to the conclusion that they did not get very much help from him and have moved to Birmingham. One of these really blossomed out and has since done some first rate work. The other one has just moved, but he has been put by Scott on some spectroscopic problem, which he solved alright, but was not very interested in and he seems greatly relieved now to be confronted with some proper nuclear problems. I do not think it would be fair to blame Scott completely for this situation, since, as you probably know the whole set up in Cambridge is not very satisfactory for theoretical research students. People seem scattered all over the place, there is no proper team work and I known of people spending years in Cambridge without ever discovering that they may have interests in common. But I had hoped that Scott might collect a few young people and get them interested in nuclear problems and this does not seem to have happened. Another thing that is evidently badly needed in Cambridge is to talk with the experimentalists about the interpretation of their work and the planning of new experiments. I have the impression that Scott has not been very much help in this respect, but no doubt you can find this out more directly.
April 7, 2009
12:11
436
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
As you see therefore I cannot give a very favourable opinion. I would like to stress that there might well be things that I have missed. For example he may well have had contacts in Cambridge with other people and that such contacts have led on or may lead to important and useful suggestions without actually publishing any papers on them. But merely I have not so far come across any evidence of this. There arises of course the important question of principle. To what extent one should over short periods make tenure of academic appointments dependent on the success of a man’s research work, but I am quite sure you are yourself well aware of this side of the problems. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls * 1 2 α s − 1 (1 − log 2) + 1α 2 π −
Total splitting
7 3
4α s2 π 2
1−
41 3 α + log 2 21 7 π
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
437
8.
1954–1963:
Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
When Rudolf Peierls took up his Chair in Mathematical Physics at Birmingham, there was no theoretical physics to speak of. When he returned to his position from the US at the beginning of 1946, what little had been achieved in the pre-war years, had been put on hold between 1939 and 1945, and Peierls had to start virtually from scratch with his endeavour to create a viable centre of theoretical physics. By early 1954, his department had been firmly established on the international research and teaching landscape. After two international conferences in 1948 and 1953, after several years of successfully attracting some of the best research students and fellows, and after successful international exchanges both of ‘Prof’ himself and some of his staff, Birmingham’s reputation had risen to a point where the recruitment of excellent staff and students caused fewer headaches than in many other places.628 Among the young researchers joining Peierls’ department in the mid-1950s were Sam Edwards, who had completed his doctorate under Julian Schwinger at Princeton with work on the structure of the electron; Nina Byers, who came to Birmingham from Chicago, and the young South African Stanley Mandelstam. If it had been Peierls’ sabbatical at Princeton and the PrincetonBirmingham arrangements over Dyson’s research position, which had guaranteed an excellent flow of information between Birmingham and the US in the early 1950s, later in the decade regular visits abroad of Peierls’ junior colleagues and exchanges arranged for advanced students and fellows facilitated a continuation of the information transfer in both directions. 628
In contrast, some universities in England and the US were struggling with recruitment and funding. See letters [599], [610].
April 7, 2009
12:11
438
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Dick Dalitz, who had joined Peierls’ group in 1949, and who had already made a name for himself in particle physics, spent two years in the US, mainly at Cornell and briefly at Brookhaven and Princeton; his correspondence with ‘Prof’ demonstrates both the intensity of the latter’s involvement in his junior colleagues’ research work and research environments, as well as his interest in the success of their exchange visits. Dalitz had been working on various aspects of decay processes of the τ -meson629 and had hoped to make further progress in this field at Cornell in 1953/4. But with Ed Salpeter on leave, he found the environment less conducive to progress than he had anticipated.630 However, despite this disappointment, it is evident that the opportunities arising from the presence of the 1 BeV synchrotron at Cornell and the possibilities of visits to other research centres in the US such as Brookhaven and Princeton proved beneficial for Dalitz;631 but occasionally it required Prof’s advice to steer in the most effective directions and to make the most of the opportunities which presented themselves.632 The Birmingham department itself was seen as an exceptional training ground for young scientists well beyond the United Kingdom. This is evident in the success of students and research fellows in securing interesting research and teaching positions throughout Europe and globally. 629
R.H. Dalitz, ‘On an Alternative Decay Process for the Neutral τ − Meson’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A64, 667–69 (1951); R.H. Dalitz, ‘On Polarized Particle Beams’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 175–78 (1952); R.H. Dalitz, ‘Some Features of the Deuteron Stripping Process’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 28–32 (1951); and R.H. Dalitz, ‘The Decay of the τ -Meson’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A66, 710–13 (1953). 630 Letters [594], [598]. 631 Letters [596], [602]. See also publications resulting from his research in the US: R.H. Dalitz, ‘Decay of τ Mesons of Known Charge’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1046–51 (1954); R.H. Dalitz, ‘Isotopic Spin Changes in τ and θ Decay’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A69, 527–40 (1954); R.H. Dalitz, ‘Isotopic Spin Changes in τ and θ Decay’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A69, 527–40 (1954); R.H. Dalitz, ‘Radiative τ -Meson Decay’, Phys. Rev. 99, 915–20 (1955); R.H. Dalitz and F.J. Dyson, ‘Renormalization in the New TammDancoff Theory of Meson-Nucleon Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 99, 301–314 (1955); R.H. Dalitz, ‘The Sachs Exchange Moment’, Phys. Rev. 95, 799–800 (1954); R.H. Dalitz, ‘Charge Independence in Light Hyperfragments’, Phys. Rev. 99, 1475–77 (1955); M.H. Kalos and R.H. Dalitz, ‘Pion-Nucleon Scattering Calculations in the TammDancoff Theory’, Phys. Rev. 100, 1515–22 (1955). 632 Letters [595], [598].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
439
Felix Bloch, on assuming the directorship at CERN, enquired about potential recruits for his establishment.633 Peierls’ reply gives a clear indication of the high calibre of some of his junior colleagues, Valatin, Feldman, Edwards, Swiatecki.634 Many of those who came to Birmingham as students, graduates or research fellows in the 1950s later filled lectureships and professorships around the globe: Dyson, Dalitz, Edwards, Brown, Byers, Flowers, Mandelstam, Bell, Matthews, Wilkinson, Lieb, Langer to name but a few. As a junior colleague commented in 1958 on what was generally known as the ‘sales campaign’ among students and staff in Birmingham, it was one of the impressive features of Peierls’ leadership that he took an interest and played an active part in ensuring the success of his young colleagues.635 The rising numbers of staff and students and their exceptionally high standard caused some logistic and administrative problems, too. As accommodation within the physics department was notoriously limited, huts had to be employed to deal with the shortage of space,636 and on one occasion, Peierls had to ask for permission to add a trailer in order to overcome the departmental space crisis.637 Even greater was the problem of finding recognition for the excellent research done in his department within the university. In an environment where promotion was often determined by long service and academic excellence was not necessarily seen as sufficient for rising through the ranks of the academic hierarchy, it was difficult to retain staff who were potentially attractive recruits to other universities. Two particularly pressing cases were Gerry Brown and Dick Dalitz. Both had joined the theoretical physics department around the same time, in 1949/50 and both, within a few years, had established themselves in their research fields internationally due to excellent research work. Similarly, both, in different ways, had contributed immensely to the departmental life of Peierls’ group, in teaching undergraduates, graduates and in 633
Letter Letter 635 Letter 636 Letter 637 Letter 634
[603]. [604]. [657]. [684]. [622].
April 7, 2009
12:11
440
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
taking on important administrative duties. With Peierls’ recommendation, Dalitz was promoted to a senior lectureship, but promotion to a professorship, which Peierls had hoped to secure shortly afterwards, came too late to convince Dalitz to remain at Birmingham, and he chose to move to a more attractive position in Chicago. A similar case arose when Paul Matthews negotiated a readership position with Imperial College, while his promotion to senior lecturer was still pending at Birmingham. In the case of Gerry Brown, Peierls hoped to be able to avoid a similar scenario of losing an excellent member of staff largely because of the cumbersome administrative setup within the university. Brown had been put forward for promotion for senior lectureship in 1957, but had lost out to the then more senior colleague, Paul Matthews. By 1958, Brown’s international standing had increased to such a level that Peierls took the unusual step of putting him forward for promotion to a professorship, although promotion to senior lecturer level had not been finalised at that point.638 His initial enquiry to the dean of the faculty was met with some scepticism and the vice-chancellor replied indicating that Brown’s age (he was 31 at the time) and the fact that he was only a lecturer, would make the conferment of the title of professor difficult, as would the fact that if ‘such a dramatic promotion were made the door would be opened to an embarrassing number of claims on behalf of other lecturers and readers in the university.’639 The reason given by the Vice Chancellor caused some consternation with Peierls, and he attempted to push Brown’s case further, not only by dismissing these arguments, but also by pointing to Brown’s academic brilliance, the more enlightened attitude of institutions such as the ETH Zurich, Harwell and other well-respected research establishments which did not consider young age as an obstacle to high achievement (and had fared very well in not doing so), and by indicating the likely effect of a lack of recognition of academic excellence on Birmingham University in particular and the UK in general.640 638
Letter [647]. Letter [649]. 640 Letter [650]. 639
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
441
More than two months after the initial enquiry, Brown finally received confirmation of his promotion, not to professor or reader but to senior lecturer at the bottom of the scale641 which caused some indignation. However, later in the year, the university took the decision to promote him to reader, a step which made him ‘quite happy on the relative scale’,642 but which still meant that by moving away from Birmingham, Brown was likely to improve his position. And indeed, little over a year later he accepted a full professorship at NORDITA.643 Among the young researchers who joined the theoretical physics group in 1956 was Nina Byers, an American student who had completed her Ph.D. at Chicago under Wentzel. Even Pauli despite his notorious scepticism about female theoretical physicists had described her as a ‘very clever girl’.644 She was another ‘political refugee’ from the US who had been offered a position at Washington, but objected to signing the required loyalty oath. Peierls, himself married to a female physicist and political refugee, had no objections to taking Nina Byers on, provided she compared favourably with other applicants for the fellowship on offer. His judgement proved right, because not only did she become a valuable member of his group during her two years at Birmingham; she later moved on to Stanford and UCLA where she eventually became professor of physics. Vivid contacts to colleagues abroad and regular international travel made ‘Prof’ more aware than many of his colleagues that standing still in a fast-moving discipline such as physics, was tantamount to lagging behind. As he wrote self-critically to Freeman Dyson, what he had brought back from his trip to the Rochester Conference in 1954 was ‘the knowledge that we have been out of touch with what goes on in several important fields and we must try to catch up. This is in part because we have not read enough and in part because we have not kept up the correspondence with other people sufficiently.’645 641
Letter Letter 643 Letter 644 Letter 645 Letter 642
[656]. [660]. [674]. [646]. [606].
April 7, 2009
12:11
442
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
He exchanged views with some of his British colleagues, who — like him — felt that the UK was losing ground to other countries, in particular to the US,646 and he took advice from his Birmingham colleagues who were spending time in the US647 as well as colleagues who had chosen the United States as their work base, such as Freeman Dyson. In his correspondence with Dyson in particular, Peierls tried to gauge what the most promising steps would be to stop the brain drain to the US and indeed, how to encourage American scientists to consider working in the UK.648 But his concern was not only with the more advanced students. Peierls also devoted time to the consideration of undergraduate teaching in its different facets. As external examiner to several other institutions and through correspondence with his own department’s external examiners,649 Peierls developed an acute sense of which teaching set ups were successful, and which courses produced the best understanding among students of his discipline and also what research facilities were needed to guarantee the scientific progress necessary to back up university teaching. He was happy to discuss his own experiences with other colleagues,650 and he was equally keen to make the scientists’ voice heard among the political decision makers, as his letter to Selwyn Lloyd at the Treasury demonstrated. In this he lobbied for better government funding of science in general and the National Institute for Research in Nuclear Science in particular.651 If Rudolf Peierls felt strongly on an issue, he was prepared to make his views known irrespective of whether this would cause difficulties for himself. One such example was the political rat-race that his friend Robert Oppenheimer found himself facing in the 1950s. In 1953, Oppenheimer had been suspended from the General Advisory Committee of the Atomic Energy Commission, which he had chaired since 1947, as 646
See letters [612], [618]. Letter [613]. 648 Letters [559], [581]. 649 See Peierls Papers, Ms.Eng.misc.b199, B.17, B.20. 650 See e.g. letter [641]. 651 Letter [692]. See also letter [618] to Cockcroft about university research facilities. 647
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
443
concerns had been expressed about his loyalty and reliability, and his security clearance had been withdrawn. Oppenheimer appealed against this decision, and between April and June 1954 hearings were held to determine whether his clearance should be restored. The commission decided against a restoration. However, Oppenheimer continued to speak out on nuclear physics issues, and although he was never officially rehabilitated, in 1963 he received the Enrico Fermi Award, a U.S. government presidential award honouring scientists of international stature for their life-time achievement in the development, use, or production of energy. This served as a measure of reconciliation for what many perceived to be a grave injustice done to Oppenheimer. Peierls tirelessly spoke out in support of Robert Oppenheimer, and his letters to ‘Oppie’ are evidence of the deeply-felt indignation at the attacks launched against his friend. Being well aware of the reluctance of many to speak up for what is right and reject what is wrong, he expressed his hope that ‘[your] many friends in America will have the wisdom and the courage to give you active support’.652 Peierls himself had his share of ‘security troubles’.653 His contacts to left-wing colleagues, his friendship with people of communist persuasion, his marriage to a Russian, his close friendship with Klaus Fuchs, all led to him being viewed with a degree of suspicion by many. When he applied for a visa to attend a conference in the US, his application met with a long delay, as did his paperwork in connection with his sabbatical at Princeton in early 1952.654 In 1957 Peierls, who at the time was acting as a consultant for the AERE at Harwell, had his security clearance revoked at the request of the American authorities. Disappointed with the action of the Harwell authorities over this matter, Peierls resigned from his consultancy. Even before this episode, Peierls had been challenged by William Penney, then on the board of the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority, about his contact to Russian colleagues and in particular his intention of participating in a conference in Moscow. In a letter in 1956, Peierls expressed his conviction of the sacrosanctity of 652
Letter [597]. See Peierls, Bird of Passage, chapter 14. 654 Letter [529]. See also Peierls, Bird of Passage, p. 322. 653
April 7, 2009
12:11
444
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the ‘freedom of scientific enquiry, the freedom of exchange of scientific information, and of objective discussion with any scientist, regardless of person, nationality, or position as long as these do not interfere with his approach to scientific fact or argument’, a principle which was subject only to ‘the overriding requirement of national security.’655 As Peierls had already made clear in his memorandum on the lessons of the Fuchs case,656 he felt strongly that the victory of the liberal democratic system could only be achieved by open competition with other regimes and political systems. In his view, it was essential not to risk personal freedom in an endeavour to silence non-democratic voices, be they communist or in other ways totalitarian. In 1956, Peierls did attend an international conference in Moscow. There had been many signs that after Stalin’s death in 1953 and with the ascension of Khrushchev in the mid 1950s, contacts between Russian and Western scientists were promoted officially in the Soviet Union. Landau had been permitted to contribute to the Festschrift on the occasion of Bohr’s 70th birthday, Russian scientists were no longer prevented from publishing in English-language journals, and some were allowed to participate in Western conferences.657 Peierls welcomed the opportunity presented by the Moscow conference to re-engage in dialogue with Russian science658 and this gave him also the chance to renew his contacts with many old friends, above all with Lev Landau.659 The more liberal flow of information from Russia brought the West into contact with Landau’s work, and his views on renormalized quantum electrodynamics was discussed widely among Peierls and some of his colleagues. Peierls engaged in an exchange with his old teacher allen, Pauli,660 who himself had discussed the topic with Gunnar K¨ Werner Heisenberg, Vicki Weisskopf.661 655
Letter [628]. Item [500]. 657 See Letter Wolfgang Pauli to Oskar Klein, 1.3.1955, Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/III, p. 131. 658 International Conference on High Energy Physics in Moscow between 14 and 22 May 1956. 659 Letters [624], [640]. 660 Letters [614–616]. 661 See correspondence between Pauli, K¨ allen, Heisenberg, Weisskopf in Pauli, 656
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
445
The contacts with Landau facilitated the first English edition of Landau’s and Lifshitz’ seminal Course of Theoretical Physics, a set of textbooks which had only been available in Russian and which was to become one of the standard works of teaching and reference for generations of physics to come.662 Peierls clearly appreciated the fact that the restrictions to scientific exchange with Russian colleagues and friends were slowly lifted, and he attempted to encourage an appreciation in the west of the work done by Russian physicists. He asked Niels Bohr to use his reputation and standing in Russia to help Lev Landau travel to the West,663 and it was doubtless on his recommendation that Birmingham University invited him to accept an honorary degree in 1958.664 In 1961, Rudolf Peierls was interviewed by a journalist in preparation of a profile to be published in the New Scientist. On reading the draft, Genia Peierls decided to write her own profile and sent it on to the journalist in question. The honest and insightful letter gives an accurate description of ‘Prof’, and many of the characteristics have since become common currency among those interested in the history of 20th century theoretical physics. Most significantly of all, perhaps, was Genia’s differentiation of scientists as either golfer or tennis player. The former, with Dirac being the stereotypical example, work by themselves without partners, collaborators or many students; the latter, and among those Genia named her husband, needed a partner to bounce ideas off and push each other to better performance.665 By the 1960s, Peierls’ impact through teaching and collaboration with younger colleagues outweighed the contributions he made independently. Also, his focus was shifting to political work and publications
Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, vol. IV/III, May–August 1955. See also letter Pauli to Abrikosov, Khalatnikov, and Pomeranchuk, Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, vol. IV/III, pp. 322–29. 662 Lev Landau and E.M. Lifshitz had written a series of textbooks on theoretical physics, the English translation of which was subsequently published by Pergamon Press. L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz, Course of Theoretical Physics, 10 vols., Oxford: Pergamon Press. 663 Letter [680]. 664 Letter [653]. 665 Letter [684].
April 7, 2009
446
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
in the area of arms control. And, as some of the letters in this chapters show, he was also beginning to get involved in putting on record the history of nuclear weapons, a story that had been written largely by Americans in a political context which had no interest per se in explaining the role of British scientists in the efforts to develop the atom bomb. Margaret Gowing, an economic historian who had worked under Keith Hancock on the civil history of the second world war, a mammoth 27-volume project, became historian and archivist to the UKAEA and researched the history of Britain and Atomic Energy, which led to a two-volume publication putting Britain’s research and development of nuclear energy into its political national and international context.666 Rudolf Peierls was happy to assist with her research, and the exchanges between the two in connection with Gowing’s work on Britain’s development of atomic energy667 was the beginning of a fruitful collaboration which later, on Gowing’s appointment to the Chair of history of science at Oxford, would continue with joint work on the history of quantum physics.668 Throughout the post-war decades, Peierls had been approached, on many occasions, about taking up chairs in other universities, both in Britain and abroad. Genia Peierls, in her profile of ‘Prof’ explained some of the reasons for his commitment to Birmingham; he rejected offers, among others, from Cambridge, Manchester, Oxford, London and Edinburgh, because he felt committed to Birmingham University, he largely liked the administrative set-up and he appreciated the research environment in his own department. In the early 1960s, however, after lengthy negotiations with Oxford University, he decided to take up the Wykeham Chair of Physics in succession of Willis Lamb. This step provided a two-folded challenge: a challenge for Peierls himself to create an equally successful school at Oxford with its more cumbersome structures, and a challenge for the Birmingham department under Peierls’ 666 M. Gowing, Britain and Atomic Energy. 1939–1945, London: Macmillan, 1964; M. Gowing, Independence and Deterrence. Britain and Atomic Energy. 1945–1952, London: Macmillan, 1974. 667 Letters [687], [702]. 668 See chapters 9 and 10.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
447
successor Tony Skyrme to keep up its high standing and international profile. Neither Peierls at Oxford nor Skyrme at Birmingham, despite some positive developments, were entirely successful in their endeavours.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
448
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[594] R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 1.1.1954 Dear Professor Peierls, Many thanks for your interesting letter. It is good to hear that things are working out so well this year. Your developments on the SF function sound very interesting and I should very much appreciate a preprint if these become available. I have heard of some studies of the SF function over here which may be of interest to you if you have not already heard more than I — for example Lee (Columbia) has recently obtained an explicit expression for SF in neutral scalar (fixed source) meson theory669 with the result SF (t) = e+imt e−g
2
d3 keiωt /ω 3
m the observed mass
It is interesting that this SF may be expanded in powers of g2 for all values of g2 . The power series expansion of SF (E) clearly has branch points at E − m = µ, 2µ, 3µ · · · as it should, but I have not yet seen whether it has any other singularities. I have also heard that Kallen, starting from some very general properties which the vacuum should have in any satisfactory theory, has concluded that the most general form allowable for SF in electrodynamics is ∞ ∞ 1 F (M )dM G(M )dM + + SF (p) = \p − m p p m M − ie − \ m M − ie + \ This seems very reasonable, though I do not understand the significance of the last term. I have not seen the work myself but have heard about it fourth hand. I am looking forward to the Rochester conference three weeks hence — we are hoping that the rumour that you are being flown over to attend this conference has a very solid foundation.670 669
T.D. Lee and D. Pines, ‘Interaction of Nonrelativistic Particle with a Scalar Field with Application to Slow Electrons in Polar Crystal’, Phys. Rev. 92, 883–89 (1953). 670 High Energy Nuclear Physics Proceedings of the Fourth Annual Rochester Conference, 25–27 January 1954, Rochester: University of Rochester Press, 1954.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
449
The attendance at the Chicago meeting was not very large but there were many interesting people there. I was particularly interested in the widespread and deep scepticism that exists in the U.S.A. concerning γ5 meson theory. Outside Cornell there appears to be relatively little work and no belief on this particular case — far more typical seem to be the semi-phenomenological fixed source studies of the type made by Chew and collaborators.671 People seem to be very impressed by the existence of heavy mesons and their possible bearing on all problems in meson physics — especially now that the π − + P → V0 + θ ◦ seems so well established at Brookhaven, although the cross section for this process seems to be relatively small. However, there even seems to be considerable interest in developing unitary field theories as a result.
One specific result reported at Chicago which may be of interest in Birmingham was an energy spectrum for pions emitted at 32◦ Lab from 2.3 Bev protons on Be (Lindenbaum & Yuan)672 — I have sketched it 671
Geoffrey F. Chew, Department of Physics, Illinois. See e.g. G.F. Chew, ‘Renormalization of Meson Theory with a Fixed Extended Source’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1748–54 (1954); G.F. Chew, ‘Method of Approximation fort the Meson-Nucleon Problem when the Interaction is Fixed and Extended’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1755–59 (1954); G.F. Chew, ‘Improved Calculation of the P -Wave Pion-Nucleon Scattering Phase Shifts in the Cut-Off Theory’, Phys. Rev. 95, 285–86 (1954). 672 Luke C.L. Yuan and S.J. Lindenbaum, ‘Energy Spectrum of Negative Pions Produced in Beryllium by 2.3-Bev Protons’, Phys. Rev. 93, 1431–32 (1954).
April 7, 2009
12:11
450
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
on the reverse side. This was compared with rough calculation using Fermi’s statistical theory and it was concluded that the low-energy peak was probably due to 3π production.∗ There has been a certain amount of interest lately in general statements which may be made on the basis of field theory for threshold matrix elements, in the limit when the meson mass approaches zero. You have probably seen the Kroll & Rudermann discussion for photoproduction673 (and which points out very neatly that Brueckner’s pair suppression argument does not hold for one case which can be rigorously calculated, namely the scattering of light by protons in the Thomson limit).674 Fubini675 spent a few hours in Princeton last week and reports that Goldberger says that for zero energy and µ/M = 0, he can obtain the scattering matrix for positive pions on protons exactly in the γs theory (!) — he says that the result indicates that the “effective coupling constant” for this case is 0.6 rather than 10. I understand a preprint will be available in a week or so.676 It is of course very doubtful whether these theories are even approximately similar to the physical situation where µ/M = 1/6, because of the terms of type µ/M (log µ/M )n which occur in a power series expansion at least — besides in this approximation the zero energy scattering is isotopic spin independent which is certainly not the case experimentally. ∗ However,
Shutt677 has no cloud chamber evidence for 3π production in N-P collisions. Shutt finds nature 2π/π production i.e. (π − , π o ) + (π + , π − )/(π − ) to be 94+26/32 (Neutrons ∼ 1.75 BeV.) 673
Norman M. Kroll and Malvin A. Rudermann, ‘A Theorem on Photomeson Production near Threshold and the Suppression of Pairs in Pseudoscalar Meson Theory’, Phys. Rev. 93, 233–38 (1954). 674 K.A. Brueckner, M. Gell-Mann and M. Goldberger, ‘On the Damping of Virtual Nucleon-Pair Formation in Pseudoscalar Meson Theory’, Phys. Rev. 90, 476–78 (1953). 675 Sergio Fubini (1928–2005), taught at the Universities of Padua, Turin and at M.I.T. Between 1971 and 1980 he served as a member of the CERN directorate. 676 S. Deser, W.E. Thirring and M.L. Goldberger, ‘Low-Energy Limits and Renormalization in Meson Theory’, Phys. Rev. 94, 711–23 (1954). 677 Ralph Shutt (1913–2001), particle scientist at the Brookhaven National Laboratory from 1947 until 1993.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
451
I believe the Dyson lecture notes have now been sent on to Birmingham. If there are any difficulties about paying for these I could easily pay for them (at any rate next month, certainly) and have the recipients repay me in sterling. The payment for the copies is not urgent. You asked me to let you know about my plans for next Session about this time. We still feel very new here, and a second term in the U.S.A. would be of far greater value to me than this first year here. This would also ease the problem of saving the funds to pay for our transportation here and back across the Atlantic. Hence I would be grateful if you could explore the possibility of extending my leave of absence for a second Session. I am still unclear what I shall be doing next year and I would appreciate any comments you may care to make on the possibilities. I have not yet asked Bethe concerning positions here next year (in fact I have not seen him for some weeks, partly because he went down with the cold, but I believe he will be back from Los Angeles within a fortnight now) but it is my impression that it is expected that I shall be here next year. The only question then arising is whether it would be wiser for me to move on and extend my contact with American physicists — this of course depends on many unpredictable factors. It seems clear that Cornell has reached an all-time low this year — next year must be an improvement (incidentally it was touch and go whether even Bethe was here this session — he was very seriously considering a permanent post at the Institute). The fact that it seems to take us a long time to settle in a new place provides an argument for staying in Cornell, though we have to seek new housing next June in any case. I am supervising several graduate students at present, and owing to the lack of senior people, about half my time is spent also discussing problems with the younger research people — this consolidates what I already know but is a slow way of learning. On the other hand I have been offered a position in Chicago for next year — Gellmann and Goldberger are both very stimulating; I have not yet gone into details concerning this offer, Chicago is not a pleasant place and housing a family is difficult according to those here who have recently come from there. The Institute is another possibility — I had recently felt that I wanted to get myself established in some line of research before going there, but perhaps I am too sensitive about this. A quite attractive
April 7, 2009
12:11
452
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
offer from Messel678 has also suggested the possibility of spending a year in Australia — I imagine though that he will be wanting to settle his permanent staff and would prefer to look further rather than have a transient occupy the position just for a year. One thing I plan to do is to enquire from Bethe as to the possibilities of working elsewhere during the summer months — Brookhaven is one possibility which comes to mind and which is essentially appropriate for many reasons. Had you heard that several examples of K-meson decay have now been observed which may be interpreted as the alternative mode of decay of the τ -meson? Rochester has two examples of star K π µ e; In both cases the π energy is between 13 and 14 Mev. Barrett from Syracuse was down here the other day and looking over his events, I noticed that he also has a similar event, giving a 4 Mev meson.679 Have you looked at the data on heavy meson capture stars — one interesting feature is that in the three cases in which a π-meson is ejected, it has energy in the region 25–30 Mev, I had wondered if this would come from a V0 -formed with low kinetic energy in the capture process, trapped in the capturing nucleus and later decaying — I find this extremely plausible now that Brookhaven had established the pro duction process π − + P V0 + θ 0 . Though it is not what I am here for, I would like to work a little on this capture process — unfortunately I have not yet been able to interest any of the graduate students in the problem. With very good wishes to all in the department, and best wishes to your family for the New Year, Yours sincerely, R.H. Dalitz
678 679
Harry Messel (1922–), Professor of Physics, University of Sydney, 1952–1987. P. Barrett, ‘K-Meson and Hyperon Decays’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1328–30 (1954).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
453
[595] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Birmingham], 11.1.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, Thank you very much for your long and interesting letter.680 As regards the physics it is very amusing how parallel are the thoughts of people in different places. The result of Lee which you quote is part of the equations contained in the note by Edwards an myself, which is just finished.681 We are sending a preprint off to you to-day. In the course of these discussions we have also formed the conjecture that what [. . . ]682 should look like and this agrees entirely with what Kallen says according to you. I think everybody would be agreed now that one should incorporate heavier particles into a complete description, but I still feel that if any equations containing only nucleons and ions can be useful at all they should have pseudo-scalar coupling and at any rate it pays to learn more about the mathematical techniques that are required to solve this case, because it seems most unlikely that the modifications of the theory brought in by heavier mesons would eliminate any of the present difficulties. Other progress from here. Davison has done a rather nice piece of work showing how to turn the Feynman ‘sum over histories’ into a respectable mathematical operation.683 Radicati and I are trying to demolish Gell-Mann’s hypothesis that particles of spin 12 can have isotopic spin, but I am not yet sure whether this can be done.684 680
Letter [594]. S.F. Edwards and R.E. Peierls, ‘Field equations in functional form’, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A224, 24–33 (1954). 682 Missing in carbon copy. 683 Davison had used orthogonal function expansion in the representation of Feynman path integrals. B. Davison, ‘On Feynman’s “Integral over All Paths”’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A225, 252–63 (1954). 684 M. Gell-Mann, ‘Isotopic Spin and New Unstable Particles’, Phys. Rev. 92, 833–34 (1953). 681
April 7, 2009
454
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Turning now to personal problems. I am very sorry to hear that Cornell has been so unsatisfactory. I am sorry because I feel in a large manner responsible for your choice, but there seemed to have been quite a number of unpredictable factors in operation. As regards the question of where to go next year I feel rather reluctant to express a firm opinion. Firstly because what advice I gave before seems to have been in the wrong direction and also because by now you have much more up to date information about conditions in the various places than I have. Cornell has of course the advantage that there is no removal problem, as you say, and life is likely to brighten up a bit with the return of Salpeter, however it all depends on how much time Bethe is going to spend at Cornell and the only way to find this out is to ask him. I think it would probably pay to discuss the whole problem very frankly with Bethe. He will not mind being told that you are not entirely happy at Cornell and why. I have a feeling that you are unduly intimidated by Princeton. As regards the physics there, you know of course Dyson and you can make up your mind yourself how much you could get out of working with him. I do not know who else is there or will be there next year. The great advantage of the Institute of course is that they are so used to having people there temporarily they have regular housing under their control and from the practical point of view there is probably less trouble involved in moving to Princeton than almost anywhere else (perhaps even less than finding a new place in Cornell). Against that the disadvantage of Princeton is the absence of experiments and this is rather a pity because one of the things you like doing and do so very well is to talk with experimentalists. From this point of view the question depends a great deal on the future of experimental work at Cornell. I imagine now they are at the machine building stage again, but the question is where are they likely to be next year. From this point of view there are great attractions in Chicago and Chicago probably combines to a rare degree contact with first rate experimental work and theoretical groups with first rate initiative, but against that of course there is the housing problem. To some extent this is a financial problem. If they pay you well enough it might not be
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
455
so bad, also there might be some lucky chance, for example to get the house of someone who has gone off for a year on a Fulbright grant or something. (It need not of course be a physicist). Another place which would give you experimental information straight from the horse’s mouth is of course Brookhaven, but I have no idea what sort of jobs they have available and whether any of them would be open to people who are not U.S. Citizens. While I say this I just remember that Yang is there now for a year unless he is actually sitting at Brookhaven with a grant from the Princeton Institute, this would seem to answer my question. However, you would be largely on your own as regards abstract theory, as far as I know, unless Yang remains there. On the whole, if the job exists, I cannot help feeling that this might be the most attractive possibility. Perhaps it may seem to you that this puts you more or less into the same position as you were at Bristol, but this was many years ago and I think now it would be very much easier for you. I am afraid this is not much in the way of definite advice, but I really know too little about the factors which are involved. On the formal side I shall now transmit to the Faculty your request for a further year’s leave of absence. I think we agreed originally that this would be easy only if it was your intention to return to Birmingham at the end of that year. I do not think this should be understood as a firm promise, nobody would want to hold you to it if there were any radically new developments, but I think the Faculty would like to know what your present intention was in this respect. Perhaps you would make this explicit when you write next. I think I understand the position, but as I may be asked questions about it it might be just as well to have it explicitly. I see I have not commented on the possibility of going to Sydney. I must confess that after meeting Blatt685 who paid us a short visit just after you left, I feel most doubtful about the pleasures of that depart685
John Blatt (1921–1990), studied in Cincinnati and obtained Ph.D.s from Cornell and Princeton. After working at M.I.T. and the University of Illinois, he moved to Sydney in 1953, before becoming foundation Professor of Applied Mathematics at the University of New South Wales (1959–84).
April 7, 2009
456
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ment. Not only at Birmingham, but in all the places which Blatt visited in this country he seems to have left a trail of dropped bricks and raised eyebrows, if you will forgive a somewhat questionable metaphor. His plans seem to center largely around an enormous electronic computer. I would imagine that next year they will be largely interested in completing the arrangements for this and planning work that can be put on such a computer. Nevertheless it would of course be a reasonable way of getting to Australia for a year for which I know there are arguments. I imagine that facilities for doing work there will be good, and that there might be good students. No doubt George will by next year have started some good cosmic ray work. Only I have the feeling that on the purely theoretical side you might feel rather cut off. I should think it highly likely that Messel would not mind at all having you for a year, only how much he would be willing to contribute to your fare both ways is of course another question. Other local news that might interest you. Radicati has been elected to a Chair in Naples, and will be leaving about Easter. Redmond and None got married a few days ago. Clementel from Italy will probably join us at Easter. I shall not get to Rochester because for some reason the Navy is not willing to give me a space on a Naval Transport Aircraft. Transportation has been offered to Moon, but for domestic reasons it is almost certain that he will not be able to go. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
457
[596] R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 9.2.1954 Dear Professor Peierls, Many thanks for your very helpful letter686 and especially for the papers which you sent. Your airletter also arrived this morning — I am sorry that I had delayed so long in replying. I am still somewhat unclear about my plans for next year — I have not formally promised to stay on here, but Bethe certainly expects this and I should find it a little difficult to tell him if it turns out that I decide to spend next year elsewhere. You may have heard from Redmond that there appears to be a great shortage of funds at Cornell for next year, very few of those theoretical people now here will be able to stay on next year — at present it appears that only Salpeter, myself and Kalos687 will be employed by the Lab., though it is possible that some people may come with outside support (this is not so common here of course). If I stay on I would plan to travel about as much as possible. This seems a good place to mention recent progress on the Cornell strong focusing 1 Bev. synchrotron. Last week the electrons were accelerated to 1400 turns, the limit of the frequency modulated acceleration. (there is a story behind this — in the original design a mistake was made and late in the construction it was realized that the machine was not even in the stability region — this was roughly and hurriedly corrected and construction went on. More detailed calculations then predicted that the machine was square on a resonance “— then we knew we were safe”, said Wilson!! and he seems to have been right.) The high power resonator necessary for the fixed frequency acceleration which now takes over is in process of being installed and hopes are running very high — of course the particles still have a long way to go. 1.5 Bev is the aim — even assuming all goes well, there may still be quite some delay in getting results as these energies will need somewhat different techniques. 686
Letter [595]. Malvin H. Kalos had studied at Illinois where he received his Ph.D. in 1952. He later moved his research focus to computational many-body physics, Monte-Carlo simulations and parallel processing. 687
April 7, 2009
12:11
458
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
However, the cosmic ray group has been getting some experience with a hydrogen diffusion chamber which will be used in preliminary work with the synchrotron. Perhaps I should go on with a little more physics. The Rochester Conference was very interesting and well organised. Nucleon-nucleon polarisation expts. were the largest single topic — there seems to be general agreement that pp polarization is large (Oxley, at 220 Mev, finds 22 = 4% maximum pol. for pp, whilst for pd, the max. pol. is 45 = 11%!?) — dependence on angle was plotted by Harwell, and by Chicago (330 Mev. — this definitely needs F -waves interfering with the P ). In the np collisions (200–300 Mev) polarization of order 5% were reported at 45◦ c.m. angle. There was some controversy as to whether the large nucleon-nucleus polarisations were due to elastic scattering or to quasi-nucleon scattering. Brookhaven reported that for neutrons between 1.0 and 2.0 Bev. incident on a hydrogen chamber, they found 24 P P− , 30 P P− O and 95 P N+− events, but no triple production. Yang said to me that meson production for 1 Bev neutrons on Be9 is only down by a factor 5 on the results for 2 Bev− at 1 Bev. The maximum intensity both for π + and π − is at 300 Mev/c in Lab. (for 32◦ Lab. angle), the π + /π − ratio is about 8 at this maximum, in c.m. system the spectrum is close to the 2π shape, though the peak is at the slightly lower energy (c.m. kinetic energy ∼ 80 Mev.) Piccioni has now done direct measurements of total cross sections for π ± P scattering at 800 Mev. and feels sure that there is really a resonance in the T = 1/2 scattering at about this energy. Bethe feels that he understands the meson-nucleon phase shifts now, and in particular all the previous mistakes, and that he now has the only permissable set which gives a α33 resonance at 194 Mev. The corresponding Yang solution has a large α31 which reaches 180◦ at this energy, the Yang α33 also being 90 here. Fermi did not feel so sure, he has seen the data change too frequently. The main theoretical contribution was that of Goldberger — I suspect you will have his paper by now.688 Wich discussed the poles of 688
Marvin Goldberger had worked on renormalization in meson theory. See S. Dreser, W.E. Thirring and M. Goldberger, ‘Low-Energy Limits and Renormalization in Meson Theory’, Phys. Rev. 94, 711–23 (1954); See also M.L. Goldberger,
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
459
the Feynman amplitude in the po plane following the kinds of arguments given by Gellmann – Low and by Kallen, and showed that these are such as to allow one to transfer to the imaginary axis and discuss the Bethe–Salpeter equation in a positive definite metric — this seems fine for the eigenvalue problem.
Serber689 gave a very stimulating talk at the N.Y. meeting on the interpretation of high energy experiments. Collins690 sa[i]d in his talk that Brookhaven now operates at 2.8 Bev. with 5 × 109 particles per pulse — I was interested to note that they do experiments with beams of scattered neutrons as far as 40◦ off the internal beam. I appreciate that it is necessary for us to consider our plans for the next few years. I should mention that Bethe has raised with us the possibility of our making a more permanent stay in this country, he believes that the procedure for this is not so difficult now. We feel that we are not able to make a rational decision about this at this stage, especially as we had things planned for a return to Birmingham. We do not feel unhappy about a return to Birmingham and no matter how ‘Causality Conditions and Dispersion Relations. I. Boson Fields’, Phys. Rev. 99, 979–85 (1955). 689 Robert Serber (1909–1997), studied at the University of Wisconsin where he obtained his Ph.D. in 1934; he worked at Berkeley, Illinois and became professor of physics at Columbia in 1951 where he remained for the remainder of his academic career. 690 George B. Collins, Brookhaven National Laboratory.
April 7, 2009
12:11
460
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
things may develop, it seems to us that our proper course is to return to Birmingham in September 1955. This is definitely our present intention. I shall be seeing the Institute for myself next week as I will be giving a talk there on the τ -meson. Pais has asked me about spending next year there, but I do not feel much inclined towards this at the present. It is easy to rationalize our inertia now that there is a strong possibility of a 1 Bev beam shortly. In any case there are of course quite a few very good experimenters here who are in close touch with work going on elsewhere and with whom it is good to discuss the real world. Silvermann or Martin for example, or Creisen or Cocconi in the cosmic ray group. I have written up some further remarks on the τ -meson decay analysis, with a more general viewpoint and which I think people at Rochester would find more convincing — on the present data (11 events!) it is rather plausible that the τ meson should have odd parity and even spin, so that 2π-decay could not compete — the experimental points just happen to lie in the regions which are unfavoured if 2π decay is allowed so that the small number of events does carry fair weight. Perhaps there are a triplet (τ + , τ o , τ − ) and a singlet θ o , forming a close mass doublet ?τ o and θ o then being distinct. Thompson has found a large number of θ o (about 15), but only one charged τ and two anomalous θ o (which might be τ o ). Very speculative!691 Otherwise I am still working on the T = 1/2 scattering and am beginning to understand the problem, which is really to carry out a renormalisation outside the framework of perturbation theory. None of the proposals published face up to this problem and Levy’s renormalisation doesn’t even give a finite result! A further complication is that in order to make any calculation practicable in my opinion, one needs to separate angular momenta first and work covariantly. However, in new Tamm-Dancoff, the terms have structure closely paralleling the covariant theory and maybe one will be able to make renormalisation which will convince other people besides myself.692 691
R.H. Dalitz, ‘Decay of tau Mesons of Known Charge’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1046–51 (1954). See also R.H. Dalitz, ‘Radiative tau-Meson Decay’, Phys. Rev. 99, 915–20 (1955). 692 See M.H. Kalos and R.H. Dalitz, ‘Pion-Scattering Calculations in the TammDancoff Theory’, Phys. Rev. 100, 1515–22 (1955).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
461
Concerning Sydney it seems very odd to me for the physics dept.’s major project to be the construction of a large computer. Though it is nice to have one available, the department’s theoretical research may well have its direction determined by the necessity of justifying the computer which is not very healthy nor particularly interesting. I have turned down the possibility, though Valda was very much attracted (all fares paid! £A1800, 3 lectures per week, Sydney climate!). Blatt seems to have an extraordinarily high reputation in this country. It is good to hear that there are so many applicants for next session! I am sorry to hear that Blin Stoyle cannot stay longer — if Gerry were to relinquish his Fellowship, would this not make difficulties for him on my return — or is he now reaching the limit anyway? We were all unhappy that you were not able to come to Rochester — it was a very stupid business! With all good wishes from both of us to yourself and Mrs Peierls, Yours sincerely, R.H. Dalitz [597] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Oppenheimer [location unspecified], 16.4.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Robert, May I add this letter to the many that you must be receiving just now, expressing indignation at the attack on you which has just been made public.693 Of all the fantastic charges the one that shocked us most is the claim (if our press reports are correct) that to have defended by legitimate methods, views on such an immensely complex question as hydrogen bomb policy which differed from the one that ultimately prevailed, must be regarded as evidence of improper motives. In a 693
In 1953, Robert Oppenheimer was suspended as Chair of the General Advisory Committee to the Atomic Energy Commission as an alleged security risk and he had his security clearance taken away, in part due to criticism from Edward Teller. In October 1954, he was unanimously re-elected director of the Institute of Advanced Study. In 1963, Oppenheimer was awarded the Enrico Fermi Award which was widely seen as a gesture of political rehabilitation.
April 7, 2009
462
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
communist or Nazi state one expects as a matter of routine, the holders of minority views to be regarded, and treated, as traitors, but if this happens elsewhere it makes us despondent about the prospects of survival of free society. But one may still be optimistic about the ultimate outcome. May I remind you of the remark that cheered you when we met last, that no situation will ever again be as hopeless as things were here in the summer of 1940. From an objective point of view, our best hope lies in the fact that this time the attack is directed against someone who is held in respect and confidence so universally by all who know him, so widely that his vocal supporters range over a field that includes Einstein and Groves, whose tangible contributions are so well known and remembered, and above all who understands the real issues so well and knows how to put his views into words. I hope that your many friends in America will have the wisdom and the courage to give you active support. For us abroad it is frustrating to know that in this battle over alleged national issues, action which we could take would be of the most doubtful value; it seems we cannot do more than assure you how strongly our feelings are on your side, and that you know without being told. Yet, ultimately your battle is also ours. We are now eagerly awaiting the next round before the investigating committee. I wish I could feel confident that this will be able to operate in sufficiently calm and dispassionate atmosphere to produce a just and fair report. In any case, a great deal of dust is going to be raised before this can happen. I feel that this letter is really quite unnecessary, because whenever we talked about anything from field theory to human affairs, you have known what I wanted to say long before I finished saying it. All I have written you could have said better for me, but I just had to write. We saw with pleasure that your name is on the programme for the Glasgow conference. Do you still plan to be there? Genia joins me in sending good wishes to both of you. Yours sincerely [R.E. Peierls]
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
463
[598] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Birmingham], 29.4.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, Thank you for your letter.694 First of all as regards Weinberg. I have now written to him that we shall be ready to take him, I am sorry this has taken so long. We were very sorry to hear of your various trials and tribulations, and I very much hope that things will now run smoothly for you for a while. I am also sorry that the team at Cornell this year seems less congenial to you than it would have been in many other years. These are the statistical fluctuations that are hard to predict. You probably have heard some reports about activities of our department here. The enormous crowd is beginning to show some signs of reasonable integration. We have animated discussions on field theory which started with thoughts about Feldman’s results.695 This seems to give a clear indication of what the analytical form of a correct SF prime should be like and this we feel is going to be very helpful in developing a better approach to it. Then Edwards and I got on to approaching this in the sense of the Schwinger equation (in which the mass operator contains a functional derivatives with respect to the meson field). One can take this quite seriously as a differential equation in functional space and solve it formally. The answer is expressed then as an integral over functional space, which looks very much like a Feynman sum over histories. We have at least learnt a good deal from the relation, though of course in itself it does not get much nearer to a practical solution. However, Edwards found that in a one-dimensional model (corresponding to particles which can have energies but no momentum) one can solve the problem exactly and obtain in fact a result corresponding without ideas 694
Letter [596]. G. Feldman, ‘Modified propagators in field theory (with applications to the anomalous magnetic moment of the nucleon)’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A223, 112–29 (1954). 695
April 7, 2009
12:11
464
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
of what its analytical form should be. This simple case could probably have been solved in other ways as well, but it is nice that it comes out in this way and it is also a good model on which to try out various approximations to see the kind of thing one is leaving out and how important it is. We also had some lectures by Skyrme, who it turns out has done something along very similar lines. In fact he derived some years ago, independently, the Schwinger equation with a mass operator though his notation was somewhat different. He now has a variation principle in which the unknown function is the propagator, as a function of the co-ordinates, and of an arbitrary meson field. His idea is then to put a suitable trial functions in and this seems very sensible, only I am not yet sure that he is able to guess trial functions which have any reasonable hope of success. Thank you for your information about the Dyson lecture notes. We made this known here, with the result that I think 15 members of the department want copies. Three of them have written individually and Matthews wrote a letter to the Secretary giving the remaining names. I don’t know what is the normal arrangement about paying for these, I think all the individual applicants could get permission through the bank to send the money, but if the copies will not be sent or reserved until the money arrives they miss the bus. Would you check up on this point and if necessary ask Bethe to advance the required amount for all of us. I imagine he would be willing to do so. We continue animated discussions with the physicists about meson physics and there is quite a good spirit. It is, however, a little depressing that it looks as if the synchrotron energy here is just about equal to the threshold for V production and that also for double [. . . ]696 production, one is still so close to the threshold that on arguments of Seitz space alone the yield should be very small. Beyond careful measurements of collisions between protons and mesons, and of course meson production, there seem to be very few fundamental experiments which can be done here. 696
Missing in carbon copy.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
465
Brown and Scheila Brenner have completed a machine run on high energy electron scattering, with various shapes of nuclear density distributions, but their evaluation still seems to require a lot of hard work. It looks as if the results are going to be much more sensible than would appear from the first crude Born approximation results reported by Hofstadter.697 Mott asked the other day whether one should have an article in the Advances in Physics on meson theory. I told him that you might possibly be prepared to say something about the more phenomenological aspects, which you have discussed so carefully and which I believe are not dealt with fully in the existing articles by Gunn and Moorhouse.698 He is writing to you to see if he can persuade you to do it. With kindest regards from everybody, R.E. Peierls
[599] R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls Ithaca, 28.5.1954 Dear Professor Peierls, It seems a very long time since I wrote you last. I have been rather busy lately with a review article for Frisch which has taken me very much longer than I would have ever believed possible.699 How is the 697
R. Hofstadter, H.R. Fechter and J.A. McIntyre, ‘High-Energy Scattering and Nuclear Structure Determinations’, Phys. Rev. 92, 978–87 (1953); R. Hofstadter, B. Hahn, A.W. Knudsen, and J.A. McIntyre, ‘High-Energy Scattering and Nuclear Structure Determinations. II’, Phys. Rev. 95, 512–15 (1954). 698 John Currie Gunn and Gordon Moorhouse had been working on aspects of meson theory. See e.g. J.C. Gunn, E.A. Power and B. Touschek, ‘The Production of π-Mesons in Proton-Proton Collisions’, Phys. Rev. 81, 277–78 (1951); R.G. Moorhouse, ‘Pair Creation in Intermediate Coupling Theory’, Phys. Rev. 89, 958–65 (1953); R.G. Moorhouse, ‘Scattering of Neutrons by Ferromagnetic Crystals’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A64, 207–208 and 1097–1107, (1951). 699 R.H. Dalitz, ‘K-Mesons and Hyperons their strong and weak interactions’, Reports on Progress in Physics 20, 163–303 (1957).
April 7, 2009
12:11
466
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
publication of your book coming along? I have been looking out for its advertisement but have been surprised not to find any yet. I have settled some of my plans for next Session. First I made an attempt to get a job for the Summer at Brookhaven – however only US citizens may be employed by Brookhaven. However Bethe suggested that I should go work there on my present salary as a representative of Cornell. I felt that this would imply an obligation toward Cornell for the coming Session, but I accepted this as I hoped the visit to Brookhaven would be very beneficial to me, Brookhaven being the major centre for theoretical physics in U.S.A. during the summer months. Therefore I did not apply to the Institute, but to confound me I received an invitation from Oppenheimer. I talked this over with Bethe, who suggested that I might consider going there just for a term, perhaps returning to Cornell for the summer. So I have arranged to stay in Cornell for the Fall and then to go on to the Institute for the Spring. For the Summer of 55 I will try to find a Summer job in California — I have had several offers for the year there, but Summer jobs don’t seem so easy to find; still I am hopeful. From my experience during the year I should say that research positions still seem fairly plentiful, but that permanent positions seem rather scarce (though it may be necessary to hunt for these, and this, of course, I have not done — but none of those here who were looking for permanent jobs really found suitable ones). Term is practically at an end this week, and many people are now leaving — Bethe leaves tomorrow. My own plans are not in a healthy state at the moment. We have to give up our house next Tuesday, and we planned to leave Ithaca then. However, yesterday I learned that my clearance has not yet come through and that I can’t go on to Brookhaven until that comes through, if ever — I had understood that Brookhaven clearance was the merest formality. Life is so complicated. Since I last wrote I have attended the Washington Meeting700 and I am enclosing a few notes from talks by Wick and Cutkosky701 — they 700
28.–30.4.1955: Washington Meeting of the American Physical Society. Copy of notes about ‘Solutions of co-variant two-particle equations’ by Wick and Cutkosky and notes by Peaslee enclosed with the letter. See also G.C. Wick, 701
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
467
have not made any progress with the Bethe-Salpeter equation for two spinor particles with ν = 0, which Goldstein considered and which appears to have no solutions — they believe this is an exceptional energy value (E = 0) and this is easy to believe. There was a great deal of talk about an event observed at Princeton, a heavy meson decay in which a product of π o -meson decays directly into two electron pairs — the evidence being fairly convincing. The π o → γ + e+ + e− decay is very commonplace these days — in fact I was told that a good check on absolute measurements of π o production processes is provided by counting the number of these pairs when the production is inside a diffusion chamber. I also enclose a few notes about some work by Peaslee on meson production in nucleon-nucleon collisions. He uses the obvious models for these energies, in which meson production results from isobar excitation, or alternatively the enhancement of the final state meson-nucleon interaction due to the resonance in the (33) state is taken into account, and he is then able to make some statements about the π + , π o , π − rations to be expected. He has some interesting comments to make concerning the possible role of higher isobars T = 5/2, 7/2 · · · , which the strong coupling theory predicts and which would not be effective in meson-nucleon scattering — these higher isobars may be important in 3π production etc. The present model can only explain why double production is enhanced above the statistical model, but similar mechanisms of excitation of higher isobars may modify the statistical model for higher multiplication also. How does it look for next Session in Birmingham? It was very encouraging to hear that you had a great flood of applications. Do you think this is just a temporary fluctuation — I had had the impression that money for research was becoming fairly scarce in Europe, has the situation changed? Certainly your problem is not one that exists over here — in fact the inflow of graduate students seems to have fallen by ‘Properties of the Bethe-Salpeter Wave Functions’, Phys. Rev. 96, 1124–34 (1954); R.E. Cutkosky, ‘Solutions of the Bethe-Salpeter Equation’, Phys. Rev. 96, 1135–41 (1954); and G.C. Wick and R.E. Cutkosky, ‘Spectrum of a Bethe-Salpeter Equation’, Phys. Rev. 101, 1830–31 (1956).
April 7, 2009
468
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
a factor of two in the last few years and the Physics Dept. is becoming rather worried, especially since they depend very much on the younger graduate students for the undergraduate lab teaching. Also I was wondering whether any of the people coming were likely to be interested in renting our house — there [is] some faint possibility that Woodward and some others may take it over, but I should be glad to write to any others who may possibly be interested. At present I am writing up some work on a program for the calculation of T = 1/2 phases or meson-nucleon scattering which was finished up when Dyson visited Cornell for a week some time back — you have probably seen the abstract which I sent to Brum.702 The work uncovers more problems than it solves and I have no great hopes that it will lead to any accord with experiment. In the absence of better proposals it does seem worthwhile to see what phases the scheme leads to and Kalos and I have permission to use the AEC UNIVAC at NYU for this problem. Kalos is an experienced computer and I am hoping not to spend too much time on this program, although it would be a good opportunity to learn what can be done with these big machines and how. Our scheme does enable a practicable calculation of a renormalised vertex and self energy without power series expansion, but making the TammDancoff approximation, and this is not without interest. I was hoping to get onto more physical problems again when I got close to the date at Brookhaven. Bethe’s book is still expanding and has reached about 800 pages703 — it has quite extensive sections on Field Theory, and goes on to explain practically every important type of meson process in detail, even strange particles · · · de Hoffmann feels like the sorcerer’s apprentice. Weinberg has now definitely accepted the Fulbright studentship in Copenhagen — I expect he has written to you about this some time back. 702 R.H. Dalitz and F.J. Dyson, ‘Renormalization in the New Tamm-Dancoff Theory of Meson Nucleon Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 99, 301–14 (1955). 703 H.A. Bethe, F. De Hoffmann, S.S. Schweber, Mesons and Fields, Vol. 1. Fields, Evanston: Row, Peterson & Co., 1955; H.A. Bethe and F. De Hoffmann, Mesons and Fields, Vol. 2. Mesons, Evanston: Row, Peterson & Co., 1955.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
469
The family has been enjoying life very well here in the Spring — our country house has been extremely pleasant. With good wishes to you all in Birmingham Yours sincerely, R.H. Dalitz [600] Rudolf Peierls to Robert S. Aitken704 [Birmingham], 12.8.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Dr. Aitken, You said some time ago that you would be willing, during your visit to North America, to handle some items of business for the University departments. I am writing to explain to you one matter concerning my department, not with the object of asking you to raise it, but because I think it is conceivable that you may be asked about it by the Vice Chancellor of Toronto and in that event it would be better that you knew the circumstances. It concerns Dr. B. Davison, a fairly senior person now a guest in my department, for whom a post is being created in the Physics Department at Toronto. I suggest that you save yourself some trouble of reading the rest of this letter now until a question is asked about it. Mr. Davison is a senior member of the staff at Harwell and has spent the present session here on paid leave (we would say study leave). He is anxious to return to Canada, where he spent several years during the war on atomic energy, largely for personal reasons (his wife was educated in Canada and has her family there). Watson, the professor of physics at Toronto knows Davison well from the war-time work and is anxious to get him there. Davison is a person of outstanding ability with an exceptionally wide knowledge of both pure and applied mathematics and the sort of person 704
Robert Stevenson Aitken (1901–1997), Vice Chancellor of the University of Birmingham (1953–1968).
April 7, 2009
470
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
who can make a helpful and practical suggestion on almost any difficult problem that is put to him. During the last year for example he has helped us make progress in a very highbrow and abstract field that until then was completely unknown to him. I would before now have tried to find ways and means of keeping him here, if it were not for his firm wish to go to Canada, and also the difficulty of creating a post of sufficiently high standing to be comparable with his status of Civil Servant. There are some special circumstances which are in fact a large measure the reason why he will not return to Harwell. This is because he was born and educated in Russia, though he is by birth a British subject. His grandfather emigrated to Russia and his father kept his British nationality. Dr. Davison left Russia in 1938 when faced with the choice of leaving or giving up his nationality. But his parents are still there. About a year ago the authorities felt worried about having a person with his background employed in as sensitive a field as atomic energy, not because anyone had any doubt in his loyalty or discretion, but because the record looks odd on paper and because there is at least the hypothetical possibility of his being exposed to blackmail through the fate of his parents. About that time when he did move to Birmingham the case received some publicity in the press, though these stories presented the picture quite fairly in not carrying any implication of his being regarded as unreliable in any sense. This publicity had been foreseen and before we agreed to his coming here I discussed the matter with Professor Humphreys, who also consulted the Pro-Vice Chancellor, who agreed that the possibility of press comment was no reason why we should not be glad to have him here, in fact I think it is correct that the publicity was in no sense adverse to the University. As far as possible questions in Toronto are concerned, the only things that are likely to matter are firstly that everyone who knows Davison here has the highest possible opinion of him as a scientist and secondly that as far as we know nobody has ever raised any doubts as to his integrity and that the interest of the press in his move to Birmingham was without embarrassment to us and extremely short lived. All these factors are of course well known to Professor Watson in Toronto, and the only reason why you might be asked about it would be to confirm that these impressions correspond to the views held by his colleagues in Birmingham.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
471
I hope you will have a pleasant and not too strenuous trip. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [601] Rudolf Peierls Robert Oppenheimer [Birmingham], 8.10.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Robert, A fair time has passed and a great many words have been uttered since I last wrote to you to comment on the fantastic situation in which you have been placed.705 There was little to say then that was not immediately obvious, the same still applies. The immediate occasion for this letter is that we had recently a news item saying that it is now confirmed you would continue at your position in the Institute. This is gratifying but it makes me sad to think that we have reached a state of affairs where we cannot even take this statement as a matter of course, but have to receive it with gratification. I also have now had an opportunity to read all the many pages that have been covered with print over this business and my main reaction is to feel: If I should ever have the misfortune to have my biography laid open, dissected and discussed in this kind of manner I would feel proud to come out of it with so good an account of everything I did and with so little cause for regret. This remark, too, comes under the heading of the perfectly obvious, but nevertheless it may need saying. The reaction is rather different to the testimony of some of our colleagues. Let us hope that the whole nightmare may now be forgotten, or at least put aside. I have some hope of attending the next Rochester Conference, though some of the paperwork may again go wrong as it did last year, but if I do, I very much hope to see you there. With kindest regards to you and Kitty, Yours sincerely, [Rudi] 705
See letter [597].
April 7, 2009
12:11
472
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[602] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Birmingham], 12.10.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, It lies heavily on my conscience that I have not yet replied to at least two of your interesting and welcome letters.706 We were very interested both in your general impressions of life in American Universities and of your trip across the country and also in the useful bits of information about physics. You probably know in a general way what is going on here. Radicati left in the Spring to take up a Chair at Naples. Blin-Stoyle returned to Oxford. He completed some rather nice work about the effect on interconfigurational mixing on magnetic moments and other phenomena. The latest paper on this by him and Perks707 (whom I believe you only know as an undergraduate) has just got published by the Physical Society. This effect seems to provide amongst other things an explanation for the anomalous magnetic moment of Bi209 . He also wrote a very nice and simple paper on hydrodynamics, giving the correct answer for the definition of rotons, on which a lot of nonsense had been published previously.708 We had hoped that this would be of some help in discussing the question of morticity in the motion of nuclear matter and we are still thinking about this, but have not got a definite answer. Redmond completed some rather nice work on intermediate coupling and has now gone off to a job at Columbia.709 This leaves us very sadly depleted on the nuclear theory side, but we are trying to build this up again, mainly with younger people and I am also getting a research fellow for one year from Japan, a man called Yoshida, who knows a lot about group theory. One of the nicer things that has come 706
Letters [596], [599]. R.J. Blin-Stoyle and M.A. Perks, ‘The Deviations of Nuclear Magnetic Moments from the Schmidt Lines’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A67, 885–94 (1954). 708 R.J. Blin-Stoyle, ‘Spin-orbit coupling and the density distribution in heavy nuclei’, Phil. Mag. 46, 973–81 (1955). 709 P.J. Redmond, ‘An explicit formula for the calculation of fractional parentage coefficients’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A222, 84–93 (1954). 707
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
473
out of nuclear theory is the work by Bowcock,710 who has been here for a year and is staying on, about the stripping process. The point is that in order to calculate the reduced width of the reaction from the observed differential cross sections, one can eliminate the correction, which was pointed out by Messiah and Horowitz.711 I always believed that they were right in so far as they showed that the total cross section in a d,p reaction was sensitive to the interaction of the proton with a nucleus, but I do not think it is safe to rely on their calculations to make the correction. Bowcock has now worked out a technique of getting this cross section reliably from the observed curve, without using any details of mechanism and this seems to be working nicely. On the solid state side Harper left in the summer for a C.S.I.R. job in Sydney, and Marshall whose work on antiferromagnetism came out very nicely, has now gone to Harwell. This leaves only two people on solid state to prevent this side from dying out. Sheila Brenner wrote a thesis on [..]712 -mesic atoms, mainly showing how one could link in a simple way the position of the energy levels with the information about the nuclear charge distribution. She has now gone off to a temporary teaching post at Swansea. The field theory group continues to be even more active than before and the general trend is more and more towards methods using functional integration. In this respect Edwards has continued with simple problems which can be solved accurately and has just completed a paper dealing with the scalar charged case without recoil, by a method which is accurate both in the limits of weak and strong coupling and reasonably good in the intermediate case. It looks as if he will be able to handle the case with recoil by essentially the same method. Matthews and Salam have done some more joint work in the summer, which in particular shows what happens in the functional integration method if one includes the closed loops (i.e. vacuum polarization effects), which
710
J.E. Bowcock, Department of Mathematics, University of Birmingham. J. Horowitz and A.M.L. Messiah, ‘The Mechanism of Stripping Reactions’, Phys. Rev. 92, 1326–27 (1953). 712 Missing in carbon copy. 711
April 7, 2009
12:11
474
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
were left out in the paper by Edwards and myself.713 The result is very simple because one simply has to replace in the numerator of our expression the propagator for a single nucleon in a given external field, by the corresponding Fredholm resolvent, i.e. to multiply the integrand by the Fredholm determinant and the same determinant has also to be added in the integrand of the normalizing factor in the numerator. This result is very reminiscent of the result of Matthews and Salam for an external field,714 and in the latter case one obtains a convergent series whenever the Fredholm series is conv[erg]ent, even though the Born approximation might be divergent. This was the basis of the somewhat optimistic remark which I made in a letter to Bethe and which has evidently reached you. We are now, however, not quite clear what really follows from this, because although one is dealing with a convergent series in the integrand, the functional integration over all possible meson fields makes each term diverge if one integrates each term separately. These infinities are just the ordinary vacuum infinities, which have to be cancelled out, but if one does cancel them out, a few of the general theorems about Fredhol[m] theory remain and so we don’t know very much at the moment. Nevertheless I have the impression that the new form of the result should be powerful in opening up new possibilities, but we have not seen them yet. Valatin has completed his work on writing counter terms in the field equations which have a definite meaning without reference to the power series, but he was troubled in doing this by the fact that infinities remain in the basic commutation laws and therefore in the definition of a state. He is therefore now working on a definition of a state which makes no explicit reference to a space like surface and he has got some formal results so far which tried together with different methods used by different people and which looks promising. Feldmann has been getting on very well, in particular in helping the experimentalists sort things out and he, Matthews and I have given talks on various occasions trying to sell some of the ideas of the present theory to the experimental 713
Letter [595], note 681. P.T. Matthews and Abdus Salam, ‘Propagators in quantized fields’, Nuovo Cimento 2, 120–34 (1955). 714
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
475
group. This has gone down so well that it has encouraged us to try as an experiment to put on in December a meeting of the Physical Society, which will consist of lectures taking two days, setting out the ideas of field theory for experimentalists and non-specialist theoreticians. We have also got Salam to help with this and we hope that it will all work. The synchrotron continues to work well as an accelerator, but progress with defining beams and getting clean conditions for experiments is still rather slow. The cyclotron has just been rebuilt, it was out of action for several months, but is now starting to work again, this time we hope it is a better engineering job. It was interesting to note from one of your letters that it is not easy to get good research students. We are under just as big a pressure as ever and I had great difficulty in keeping the number down to the same as last year, i.e. 27. In fact for a transition period of a few weeks we are one over. I have already five names down for consideration for next year and it looks as if we shall be in the same trouble again. You will have heard about the Glasgow Conference. It was on the whole quite instructive, but it was a pity that so many papers had been put on that in most sessions there was literally not a single minute for discussion. Your house is now inhabited by the four bachelors and while I have not had an occasion yet to inspect it, it looks as if it ought to survive the experience well and still be quite inhabitable by the time you come back. As things have turned out the time of your move to Princeton is probably fairly well chosen, because by then people should have had time to recover from all this fantastic loyalty Board business,715 which must have been quite upsetting and disturbing. With kindest regards, also to your wife, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
715
See letters [597], [601].
April 7, 2009
476
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[603] Felix Bloch to Rudolf Peierls Geneva, 22.10.1954 Dear Peierls, You may have heard that I have recently taken on a position as the director of CERN and you may have further heard that I am planning to have some physics done here on completion of the machines. One of the important activities in this respect is of course the theory, and although the center of the CERN theory group remains in Copenhagen for a few more years, there will be also a nucleus of condensation here in Geneva. At the present moment we have Bernard here who came on the recommendation of Møller and works on the problems of meson production. We also have succeeded to have Abragam visiting us on a half-time basis and I am very happy that in this manner we have at least made a start. The only trouble is that I am anything but an expert in high-energy physics and that even if I were one I would have very little time for acting as such. Consequently, d’Espagnat feels a bit lonely here, and I should like very much to find another man of his approximate age (32 years), experienced and interested to join us here very soon. The reason for writing this letter to you is to ask you whether you could propose somebody whom you consider suitable and likely to come within the next few months. While it would be preferable for the reasons mentioned above, to have a high energy theoretician, we would certainly also consider a man working in another field, provided that he is good, that his interests are not too narrow and that he is otherwise a nice person. I should be most grateful to you, if you would give some thought to this matter and either recommend to us possibilities or tell us who else might be a good source of information. Thanking you very much in advance for your answer to this letter. I am, with best regards, your F. Bloch
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
477
[604] Rudolf Peierls to Felix Bloch [Birmingham], 30.10.1954 (carbon copy) Dear Bloch, Thank you very much for your letter. I am very glad to know that you have taken up your new duties at Geneva and I only hope that the amount of time you will have to spend battling with red tape will not prevent you from thinking about more interesting problems. If in the course of your business you should visit this country, please don’t forget to come and see us at Birmingham. As to the question of a suitable theoretician for your staff, I do not feel I have from your letter as yet a very clear picture of the kind of man who would be required. Probably the best thing therefore is if I mention a few names which come to my mind and describe their qualifications briefly and perhaps you would let me have your reaction to them. 1) J.G.Valatin. Born and educated in Hungary. Now stateless. Age 36. He worked in Hungary mainly on molecular spectra, then spent some years in Paris when he got interested in field theory. Spent about two years in Copenhagen and has been, for the last two years, a research fellow in my department. He is very mature and has an excellent and very wide knowledge of theoretical physics. His work on field theory has at first tended to be somewhat formal, but he is now thinking on some of the really important questions, in particular how to get up the renormalization process, so as to get away from series expansion and he has made some very interesting progress. He takes a very active part in our discussions. He has not had very close contact with the experimental high energy work here but I think he would do this well and his experience on the molecular spectroscopy where he did work very closely with experimentalists should be valuable. I can perhaps express my opinion of his judgment best by saying that whenever I get a paper on any part of theoretical physics to referee on which noone else here is obviously an expert and I want a second opinion, I ask Valatin to look at it for me.
April 7, 2009
478
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
2) W.J.Swiatecki. Polish born, but was in this country during and after the war. Finished school here and got his university education here. He is a British subject. He took a Ph.D. in this department with a very good paper on nuclear problems, in particular on the nuclear surface energy. Then went for three years to Copenhagen, where he had a very bright idea about explaining the asymmetry of fission, but spent rather too long on difficult calculations with which he was trying to prove that his mechanism would work. He has now been for a year in Uppsala, partly working with Waller and partly helping the cyclotron people with the design and interpretation of experiments. Particularly the work on polarization. This is high energy work in a sense, but of course the energies they have available there are not high enough to make mesons and he has I believe no experience of meson work. However, I believe he would take to that very easily. He has a wife and two children. As far as I know it was his intention to complete the present year at Uppsala and then to leave Sweden and settle down somewhere else. I cannot of course say what would be his reaction to an invitation to Geneva. He is aged about 29. He undoubtedly is a man of first rate ability and a very good person to discuss with. He should by now have plenty of experience of talking with experimentalists. 3) G. Feldman, a Canadian. Aged 26. Took his Bachelor’s and Master’s degrees in Toronto and then did a Ph.D. here with a paper on field theory, which has proved quite important and instructive. For the last year he has held an assignment here which requires him to work together with the people on the synchrotron team, getting for them all available data on meson theory and discuss the actual or possible experiments in the light of theoretical knowledge. This involves also explaining the ideas and results of the theories in language suitable for experimentalists and he has proved extremely suitable for this particular assignment. While he was doing this, he also continued theoretical work on field theory and as a very active member of our field theory group. Particularly for a man of his age he is exceptionally good and with him more than with anyone else I would particularly hope that you would fail to persuade him to go, because we would miss him very much. Not because he is necessarily so much
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
479
better than the others here, but because he seems to well suited to his particular function here, that he would be hard to replace. His type of approach is perhaps characterized by his latest publication which is a letter to Physical Review716 pointing out that in attempting to produce anti-protons one should with an accelerator of the Berkeley type not look at the proton-proton collisions, but one should make mesons in protonproton collisions and then let the mesons collide with other protons, since in this way the threshold for nuclear pair production is lower. This of course is not a major piece of work, but it is a point he happened to notice which others seem to have missed. 4) S.F. Edwards. A graduate of Cambridge, who spent a year at Harvard with Schwinger, then a year at the Institute at Princeton and has now been here for a year on a fellowship. He is extremely productive in ideas on field theory and he has developed since he came here some powerful methods of solving simplified problems exactly, which up till then I would have regarded as completely insoluble. I wrote a joint paper with him recently717 which sta[r]ted off the development and he has gone very much further since then. I put his name forward with some hesitation, not because of any doubt as to his quality. He is undoubtedly one of the most promising young men I have here at the moment, but he is so full of ideas and so fast in his work that it is very important for him to be in a large group where his ideas can be subject to discussion and it might not be in his interest therefore to join a Laboratory with fewer theoreticians at this present time. 5) Ravenhall, whom you evidentally know from Stanford. I have a high opinion of him, though he does not seem to have got very much done since he went to America and I do not quite know why. By now you probably know more about him than I do. I don’t know what his plans are, but I heard a rumour that he was considering returning to Europe. I would be interested in your reaction to these various possibilities. I should of course add that I did not think it reasonable to sound out any 716 717
G. Feldman, ‘Antiproton Production’, Phys.Rev. 95, 1697 (1954). See letter [595], note 681.
April 7, 2009
480
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
of these people at this stage and have therefore no means of knowing which of them if any would be interested in the post. With kindest regards Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[605] Nicholas Kemmer to Rudolf Peierls Edinburgh, 13.1.1955 Dear Peierls, I have long felt that a letter to you was overdue, but I must confess that the immediate impulse to write arises from the invitation that I am now sending to you. However, first let me say a few words about what has been going on here. I cannot report much scientifically, but in other ways things seem to be getting going quite nicely, now. We are moving from our cramped quarters, that you are I am sure acquainted with, into a separate building, across the road, which will contain two lecture rooms, a library, separate offices for each member of staff and a number of quite roomy research rooms which will take from one to three students each. The building is an old one and is being thoroughly reconstructed internally at the moment. Our present guess is that we might be in it next October. We shall be quite full even when we start. The present staff consists of Schlapp, Nisbet, Pursey and the secretary, and we have five people doing research. Two are beginners. We have Nataf from Paris as an I.C.I. Fellow, Higgs, formerly of King’s College London (just starting), who wants to learn field theory, having previously done theoretical chemistry, and also just starting, Dedijer from Yugoslavia who, among other things, has been one of their representatives in CERN but now wants a year of peace to brush up his theoretical physics. There are also some possibles for next year. We have managed to get a promise of the periodicals library independent of Feather’s (on the book side, our library has been excellent since Born’s time).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
481
I, myself, am carrying on with the electrodynamics text-took that I am doing jointly with Lyttleton. As regards field theory, I have not really kept abreast of the latest developments at all well, though now I have the new stimulus to start in the presence of Higgs and in the fact that Salam has insisted in making me co-author of a paper he has just written, to which I contributed a very small amount in very early discussions.718 We shall be sending out preprints very shortly, if you have not already seen the MS. from Salam. I feel all this is quite a good start, but there is one big problem that we are now concerned with and that is giving us a lot of thought — it is the question of a desirable syllabus for an Honours course of mathematical physics. We are just in the process of having a separate “Honours school” of math. physics recognized by the University. There is not much difficulty about the advanced courses (the actual Honours school) for these have existed in a very good form since Born’s time. But the initial stages of the curriculum which have to serve the Ordinary degree students as well, are causing us quite a big headache. At present our first year is taught elementary statics and dynamics only, and none of the lecturers are really satisfied with the course, though they find it hard to decide how to improve matters in view of the poor mathematical equipment of some of the students. I have a feeling that we could learn a lot from your experience and that the time has come to seek your advice. This is one of the reasons why not only I but Schlapp and the others, would be very pleased to see you here sometime. I am glad, however that I can offer you a small further inducement to come, and I might say that the first excuse is really unnecessary for me to extend to you this invitation. It is to give one of our Ritchie Lectures. I know that you have already given one of these, but to refresh your memory, let me say that these are Guest Lectures of a quasi-popular character. The audience consists of staff and students of Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and perhaps some Philosophy. It is usually held on a Friday at 5.15 [p].m. and the choice of subject is left completely to the lecturer. We can offer you £15 for expenses. Of course Feather joins me in this invitation. 718
N. Kemmer and Abdus Salam, ‘On the relativistic equation for scattering’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A230, 266–71 (1955).
April 7, 2009
12:11
482
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
You are quite free to choose your own subject though I might just make two suggestions: Firstly, I have hitherto kept away from anything on field theory or nuclear theory, reserving such talks for a time when there were a few more people assembled here, therefore if you think of anything sufficiently generally intelligible in either of these lines, it would be grand. But I should tell you that I have also recently written to Weisskopf with a similar invitation. I do not know whether he can manage to come, but if he does, it would be as well if the topics did not overlap too much. The two dates that would suit us best would be Friday, February 4th and Friday March 4th. We could possibly shift things if you could come some other week instead, and we are not absolutely tied to Fridays. I am sorry if the first date gives you such short notice, but I am mentioning it just in case I hear from Weisskopf that he has chosen the same. If you would be kind enough to come, we would be very pleased to put you up at our home and of course we should like you to make your stay as long as possible. With best regards from my family and the department, Yours sincerely, N. Kemmer [606] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson [Birmingham], 17.2.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, Thank you very much for your letter.719 Your letter to Goudsmit720 does sum up the facts quite well. In the meantime I have also drafted a letter 719
Letter could not be located. Samuel Abraham Goudsmit (1902–1978), studied physics at Leiden and Amsterdam and received his Ph.D. from Leiden in 1927. He took up a faculty position at the University of Michigan, subsequently worked at M.I.T. and later was Chief of Scientific Intelligence of the Alsos Mission to investigate the German atomic bomb project. After a short period at Northwestern University (1946–48) he became Senior Scientist at Brookhaven (1948–70) and served as managing editor and later editorin-chief of the American Physical Society, founding, in 1958, its Physical Review Letters. 720
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
483
to Goudsmit which is just waiting for Salam’s approval before it is sent off, but I imagine he agrees.721 In this I explain that we now accept the statement that the main result of the paper is implicit in Feynman’s papers, though I still maintain that it is very hard to recognize and the result is also obtained in the Russian paper which you mentioned to me, but there it is derived in a rather round about way through the Schwinger equation. I still believe the Matthews-Salam paper is still worth publishing,722 but since some redrafting will be necessary to acknowledge the connection with earlier papers and to emphasize what is really new there would be a good deal of delay involved in having the amended version referred again and we are therefore proposing to withdraw the paper from the Physical Review and have it published in this country. I still believe that it should be published somewhere and I am strengthened in this both by the fact that the recent paper by Klein723 using functional methods still juggles around with the most complicated Schwingeresque formalism and still misses the simplicity of the whole matter and also by a remark in one of Feynman’s earlier papers in which he says that nobody has ever worked out how to do the integration over spinor fields and that this ought to be done. As to the usefulness of the functional approach, it seems to me that Feynman’s recent work on the ‘polaron’ has again demonstrated its power and the remarks which Feynman made at Rochester724 also show that a good deal can be learnt that way.725 Edwards and I have talked a bit about that latter problem and are by no means convinced that Feynman’s answers are reasonable. The doubts are based on the question what region is of the greatest importance if one thinks that it is most important to represent things correctly in the immediate neigh721
The controversy refers to a paper of P.T. Matthews and Abdus Salam the result of which Dyson claimed were already implicit in Feynman’s work. 722 See Letter [602], note 714. 723 Abraham Klein, ‘New Tamm-Dancoff Formalism’, Phys. Rev. 95, 1676–82 (1954). 724 Fifth annual Rochester Conference on High Energy Physics, 31.1.–2.2.1955. 725 R.P. Feynman, ‘Slow Electrons in a Polar Crystal’, Phys. Rev. 97, 660–65 (1955).
April 7, 2009
12:11
484
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
bourhood of the nucleon, where [..] 726 tends to become very large. It looks as if the corrections are much less than Feynman claims. However, Feynman may still be right in placing more weight on the behaviour of [..]727 over somewhat larger volumes. I have no doubt at all that by sorting out these problems one can learn much more about the nature of the physical problem, though not necessarily solve it. Apart from this my belief in the functional method is very largely based on the success of Edwards finding sensible approximations. I would be very interested to know what you think of his paper on the charged scalar case, which exists in preprint form.728 This is still an academic case for which other methods work equally well, but he is now working on an extension of the same method to the correct pseudoscalar case with recoil and this looks very promising, at any rate I am sure that not all the possibilities of the method have been explored.729 I believe that the further formal development of this method is justified only when one knows it can be used, but already when there seems some hope that it may be simpler (I think it would be fair to say that some of your papers also represent formal developments of techniques that have not as yet proved themselves.) I do not see why you feel so apologetic about disagreeing. Physics would be a poor business if one was not allowed to disagree, particularly when this does not concern facts, but the outlook for the future. If I am optimistic about the functional method it is only in the sense of the definition that an optimist is a person who thinks the future is uncertain. I hope you have by now got over the ’flu. I have been spared it this time. I got back just in time to find my wife in bed with the children just recovered. One thing I have brought back from Rochester is the knowledge that we have been out of touch with what goes on in several important fields 726
Missing in carbon copy. Missing in carbon copy. 728 S.F. Edwards, ‘The nucleon Green function in charged meson theory’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A228, 411–24 (1955). 729 S.F. Edwards, ‘The Nucleon Green Function in Pseudoscalar Meson Theory. I’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A232, 371–76 (1955). 727
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
485
and we must try to catch up. This is in part because we have not read enough and in part because we have not kept up the correspondence with other people sufficiently. As you will have noticed I am a very bad correspondent, but we always appreciate very much hearing in particular from you what you think about the way things are going. I also share your impression of Lehmann. I am glad he is clear about the significance of their paper. From reading the abstract one gets the impression that they claim far too much of it, but certainly it is an interesting beginning.730 With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[607] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Birmingham], 28.2.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, I am writing to bring you up to date on some possible developments which I have also discussed with other members of the department and which if they came off would concern you. I mentioned to you that last year I had been asked to move to Imperial College and shortly after my return this suggestion was again raised. Some of the practical factors had changed in the course of the year and I considered the question quite seriously. However, I have now again come to the conclusion that I do not want to go. Simultaneously with this, however, I was also asked in a quite preliminary way what would be my reaction to an invitation to go to Oxford. This is still quite vague, since the suggestion did not come from their selection committee and it is by no means certain that they would in fact ask me. At 730
H. Lehman, K. Symanyik, and W. Zimmerman, ‘Zur Formulierung quantisierter Feldtheorien’, Nuovo Cimento 1, 205–25 (1955).
April 7, 2009
486
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
first sight my reaction to Oxford was rather negative, but it has been changing gradually. The main cause being that I think I tended to overestimate the difficulties and disadvantages of Oxford at first and also, particularly as a result of the study of the London proposition, I now feel more strongly that there is every prospect of the school here surviving my departure and from a national point of view if we succeed in having two good schools, one here and one in Oxford, this would of course be an improvement. Admittedly, nuclear physics is not exciting, but it is largely compensated by the proximity of Harwell, which is not a negligible factor. As I already told you I have been thinking of who would be likely to succeed me here and, in my opinion, you would be the best choice. Clearly this is not for me to decide and in fact it is a rule in the University that a professor who is resigning or retiring does not take part in the selection of his successor, except that people may ask for his views. What I say about this is therefore hypothetical in three ways: it is not sure I shall be asked to go to Oxford, it is not sure that I should accept if I was, (depending largely on whether they would be able and willing to meet various requirements I would have) and it would then not be certain what action would be taken by Birmingham. I do know, however, that the most senior members of the department while they would not like the idea of my going would, if I did go, be quite happy about the prospect of working with you and I am also satisfied that for the foreseeable future there would remain a good supply of more junior research people here, though not necessarily equalling the present numbers (I think it would be preferable for the beginning to cut down the numbers to something like half of the present size) and this is just about what I would guess would happen. I am telling you all this because it is obviously of interest and also to give you an opportunity of commenting if you like. You would not of course be committing yourself by anything you say at this stage, but when we talked on the same subject at Rochester it seemed such a hypothetical possibility that I did not particularly invite you to define your reactions. If for example your reaction was that you would not wish to take on the responsibility of running a department, this would be a factor I would like to know. As you know the department is in quite good
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
487
shape and runs easily. You could rely on getting every cooperation both inside the department and the University. If you felt that in any case you would not want to settle for a long period in this country, this would be something else of interest and in that case I would be rather interested to know whether an appointment where to run a department would make it more or less likely that you would be willing to stay here. It would also be interesting to know whether in the event of my remaining here the appointment to a research professorship in the department would be more likely to attract you than either of the alternatives. (I am not yet certain what would be the prospects of getting such an appointment made, it looks as if this could not in any event be done for next session if I stay here, but it might be possible in the near future.) I might mention also that if I were to leave and you did not wish to take over, or the selection committee did not choose you, the next name that comes to mind would be Flowers. There may well be others, but no very obvious other possibility suggests itself. I would very much appreciate hearing your first reaction to this fairly soon. It is all preliminary and should not commit you and it will not have any direct effect on my decision (if a decision is called for), but it always helps in thinking about the future to know what your general reaction to such ideas looks like. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[608] R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 17.3.1955 Dear Professor Peierls, Thank you for your letter. I am very anxious to know how your thoughts and plans are developing and I will try to give you some indication of my position by discussing briefly the merits of the various possibilities. My views on these possibilities are by no means settled, as I believe you will understand.
April 7, 2009
12:11
488
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
It will certainly be unfortunate for Birmingham if you decide to go to Oxford (if Oxford will not meet your conditions, they will be very foolish) — but I have little doubt that there you would have a greater and more direct influence on the state of physics in England than is possible at Birmingham. More promising research students should be available in greater numbers and these will be people one might expect to have more reason to stay in England. But, of course, I am very much out of touch with the way the department has been developing recently. I would consider seriously the possibility of running a department at Birmingham and I am not unwilling to contemplate a lengthy stay in England. However I am inclined to think that there would be rather little to hold the present senior people to Birmingham after your departure, and that better-paid positions in more attractive localities would soon draw them away. It is probable that the only research students available would be the few coming up through the undergraduate school, for outside students are generally attracted only by very well-known names. The health of the department would be strongly coupled with the success of the synchrotron group — if things turned out well, one could hope to build up a school with high energy physics as the main field of interest. I do not have a good picture of their rate of progress at present, but it is my impression that real experiments are still a long way off; which is rather disappointing. I expect that there would be a good deal of support from the cyclotron group, which would be very stimulating and helpful. It is not clear to me how wise it would be for me to take on such a proposition at the present time. My main fear would be that the administrative work and the effort of trying to stimulate other people would leave me with little energy and peace of mind to participate personally in much of the research work. Perhaps this is an unduly pessimistic view. I am also very much worried about the general health of physics in England; particularly by the lack of active experimental work and by continuing outflow of capable and active experimenters — I understand that A.P. French is leaving Cambridge for the States731 shortly 731
A.P. French took up an appointment at the University of South Carolina, Columbia.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
489
and also R.N. Wilson of Oxford732 and that D. Walker is returning to New Zealand, all good men leaving at a time when there is such a great shortage. Do these people leave because there are insufficient senior positions available? Perhaps this is just a particularly bad period for England; there has been much wasted time and effort in the abandoned machine programmes at Cambridge and Harwell and the previous machine building projects have not been outstandingly successful except for the Liverpool machine (which certainly stands in a very favourable position at present). It is indeed very much of a question whether it makes sense for a meson-physicist to work in England at the present time!∗ If you decide against leaving Birmingham, then I anticipate that I will be returning to Birmingham as we have discussed previously — a senior position such as you suggest would certainly be acceptable. Presumably this would be argued on the basis of the needs of the synchrotron group, and it would certainly be my intention to work in this direction, as you will, of course, realize. Incidentally, I have been meaning to ask whether there is anybody likely to replace Feldman next year. The Canberra position will presumably be filled during this year, and, if I ever intend to return to Australia, this would be the time to consider doing so. The group will be quite well-supported, sabbatical leave is on a quite liberal basis, and it is envisaged that the theoretical group would consist of about six or seven post-doctoral people together with four of five research students. Unfortunately very little stimulus can be expected from the machine project within the next five years, and the low energy nuclear physics is on a rather limited scale. Also there is no undergraduate school from which students would naturally flow; the larger universities have their own theoretical groups. However I think ∗ Perhaps
this is rather too severe — it is largely a matter of one’s connections with the experimental groups, and they may really be quite good. 732
Richard Wilson took up a post at Harvard University.
April 7, 2009
12:11
490
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
that, although it may not be easy to achieve much significant work in physics there, at least in the beginning, one could play a useful role in stimulating interest in the more rapidly growing regions of physics and activity in more significant experimental work. It is not an unattractive position, on the whole, but the situation seems somewhat unpredictable to me. I believe that I must apply for the position, although I may withdraw my application or, if the position is offered to me, I may not accept in the end — at least I would not find myself regretting later that I did not apply. Lastly, you may have heard that four positions are being made available at the University of Chicago in lieu of a replacement for Fermi.733 Senior positions have been offered to Wick and Steinberger, I believe, and one of the junior positions is being offered to me. The details of the offer have not reached me; the offer has been approved by the University but will not be made formally until approved by the senior theoretician to be appointed, presumably Wick. Owing to the uncertainties raised by your letter, I did not discourage the offer out of hand. It is rather tempting, of course — I have much to learn in physics and I am well aware that one’s development is very much a reaction to the stimuli and influences which act on one — these would undoubtedly be very beneficial at Chicago. The Institute has a good atmosphere, lecturing loads are quite nominal and one would have no reason for not getting along well with the research. It would certainly not be much of a life for the family, however — I must remark, incidentally, that I have no wish to spend my life in the States, but one could argue that several years further experience in such a position now may make me more effective in England eventually, through my wider experience and wider contacts in the States, than would be the case should I return at the present time. Perhaps this is just sophistry? But this possibility deserves consideration — perhaps it may be feasible to have the offer put off for a year. I am very much confused by the existence of the new alternative, and not least by the fact that people to whom I have mentioned this matter have taken it for granted that I would accept! 733
Enrico Fermi, who had been professor of physics at the Institute of Nuclear Studies in Chicago since 1946, had died in 1954.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
491
I regret that in writing to you I am still confused in my assessment of these paths to the future — it is not easy to visualize where each of them would lead, and it is not even completely clear where I would desire them to lead. However, I am hoping that these remarks will suffice to give you some idea of my attitudes toward the various possibilities. With all good wishes, Yours sincerely, R.H. Dalitz
[609] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 31.3.1955 Dear Peierls, Your point is well taken.734 However, I still stand by the statements I made in the review of Edward’s paper. The point he made is that if G(φ) ∼ C0 + C2 g2 + C4 g4 + · · · is the Green’s function of the Fermi particle in a fixed c-number φ, then the Green function with quantized φ goes like Gq ∼ c0 + c2 (1!) + c4 (2!) + c6 (3!) + · · · The remark is quite general and applies with or without vacuum polarization, and this I considered the main contribution of the paper. Then he said in particular, if we use a cut-off theory without vac. pol. the Fredholm solution gives a G(φ) with a finite radius of convergence and therefore Gq is divergent. Now in the letter he says, for a cut-off theory with var. pol. the G(φ) will be convergent. It is not clear to me whether he also states that in this case he had proved that the G(φ) converges rapidly enough so 734
See letter [606].
April 7, 2009
12:11
492
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
that Gq is also convergent; I assume this to be the case for a sufficiently smooth φ. I do not consider that this result destroys the force of his earlier argument, because I assume that the G(φ) will in any case behave badly for sufficiently rapidly varying φ. In other words, the convergence of G(φ) is certainly not uniform in φ. His general result, that Gq is more divergent than the worst possible G(φ), is likely to be useful for a proof of divergence of Gq also with vacuum polarization. I hope I have made this argument as clear as it is to me, which is not saying much. Thank you also for your long letter of February. I got Edwards’ paper on the charge scalar theory735 and have looked at it only superficially. It seems to have some clever tricks, but I must study it much harder before I understand it properly. In general I think the test of such a method will only come when he puts in the recoil. Last week we had Chew736 here and he gave a 2 1/2 hour talk about his equations for the meson scattering. The most interesting new development is that it is proved that these equations can be mathematically deduced from only the following assumptions. (1) Unitarity of the S-Matrix (2) Causality (analytic property of the S-Matrix) (3) Goldberger symmetry between emission and absorption of mesons (4) Absence of recoil and nucleon-pair effects (5) Neglect of 2-meson states 735 S.F. Edwards, ‘The nucleon Green function in pseudoscalar meson theory. I.’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A232, 371–76 (1955). 736 Geoffrey Chew had written several papers on different aspects of meson scattering. See G.F. Chew, ‘Pion-nucleon scattering when coupling is weak and extended’, Phys. Rev. 89, 591–93 (1953); G.F. Chew, ‘Renormalization of Meson Theory with a Fixed Extended Source’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1748–54 (1954); G.F. Chew, ‘Method of Approximation for the Meson Theory with Experiment’, Phys. Rev. 94, 1755–59 (1954): G.F. Chew, ‘Comparison of the Cut-off Meson Theory with Experiment’, Phys. Rev. 96, 1669–75 (1954).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
493
So in some sense this Chew model is the most general possible within the limits of the fixed-source problem. I am at present just working over the details to try and understand it better. In particular I do not consider I understand it until I see where the factors 29 , 79 etc. come from. As you can see, I did not go to Moscow.737 The reasons were complicated and not very creditable to me. The immigration people in Washington told me that they would not penalize me for going to a meeting in Moscow if it were purely scientific. But if any kind of political propaganda were attached to it, they would be forced by the McCarran Act738 to exclude me from the U.S. unless I could prove that I had no part in such propaganda. They said also that it would be practically impossible for me to establish such proof, and a declaration beforehand of my good intentions would not help. I was sorry to find that my idealism was not strong enough to make me want to fight this through. The recent remarks of Pontecorvo also did not help.739 Yours ever, Freeman Dyson
737
31.3.–7.4.1955: All Union Conference on Quantum electrodynamics in Moscow. The International Security Act of 1950, sometimes referred to as McCarran Act, allowed for the expulsion or deportation of people considered ‘dangerous to public safety’, in particular communists or communist sympathisers. 739 Bruno Pontecorvo (1913–93), had been working under Fermi in Rome and with the Joliots in Paris; he fled to Spain and later to the US and eventually moved to Canada where he worked on cosmic rays, neutrinos and the decay of muons. In 1948, after obtaining British citizenship, he joined the British atomic project and became professor at Liverpool. In 1950, he voluntarily moved to the USSR he continued to work in nuclear research in Dubna. In 1955, he consented, for the first time after his move to the Soviet Union, to appear in public, at a press conference where he explained why he chose to leave the West and work in the USSR. 738
April 7, 2009
12:11
494
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[610] Rudolf Peierls to R.H. Dalitz [Birmingham], 4.4.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Dalitz, I have put off replying to your long and interesting letter in the expectation that things would develop a little and I could write less conditionally.740 This has now happened. Oxford have not invited me (presumably because they knew that I would ask for more than they could afford) and so at any rate for the present there will be no change here. On the other hand, the recommendation for your promotion to Grade I is well on its way and while it has not yet passed through all the stages I do not expect any complication. Of the various possibilities which you mention in your letter I am greatly disturbed by your invitation to Chicago, which must have a lot of attraction for you. I still hope of course that you will not decide to go there, but I must not try to disguise this hope as advice. However, I am glad to know that life in Chicago does not look perfect from your point of view. I assume of course that in any event you will be here next year. I cannot imagine that if you were interested in Chicago they would not be willing to wait for you for a year, since the post does not seem to involve any special duties which call for continuity. May I now comment in turn on the various points which you make in your letter. Some of them have been made less relevant by the fact that I am unlikely to leave, but they are of general interest in any case. Firstly I am not by any means sure that we are less well placed here than Oxford as regards the supply of students. Oxford does not have a very high prestige for science in general and in particular for mathematics, which is still the undergraduate course through which most of our entrants come. This was brought home to me particularly a few weeks ago when I interviewed a prospective student who on the advice of his school had put Birmingham as his first choice, Liverpool 740
Letter [608].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
495
second and Oxford third, and he explained that he would not have put Oxford down at all except for the fact that he was short of some subject (I have forgotten whether it was Applied Mathematics or Physics) and that Oxford might take him even if the other Universities did not. This is perhaps an extreme case, but I still believe that we can maintain an undergraduate school containing a fair number of bright people and the main difficulty is the question of selection. We are still experimenting with our admissions procedure, but I think we shall get it to a point where we shall not miss many promising people. There certainly is no sign of our running out of research students. In fact on the contrary I have had this year to turn down more applicants for postgraduate places in the department (some as research students, some as post-doctoral research grants) than ever. It is true that a fair proportion of these always come from abroad, but it seems to me right that we should continue to have a proportion of such people because their presence gives us more variety and has a useful influence on local students. It may in fact be worth while to run over the present composition of the department, particularly concerning the people you do not yourself know. Of the people you know Matthews, Woodward, Field, Brown, Edwards, Valatin are still here and are remaining here as far as I know. They make a really powerful team. Feldman is going to Princeton and presumably will not return to this country, however, we cannot grumble as we have had certainly much help from him.741 Candlin, whom you do not know, but who is very good is going to the Institute with a Commonwealth Fund Fellowship and must return.742 I do not think he is likely to settle in America. Of the more junior people a Canadian, Schaefer, who is quite good and working with Brown on the numerical treatment of radiation corrections for heavy elements, will stay if he can get a grant.743 A bright young South African, Mandelstam, is staying 741 Gordon Feldman moved to Princeton, and later worked at the University of Wisconsin before becoming professor of physics at John Hopkins University. 742 D.J. Candlin, after his time at Princeton, returned to the UK. Later his interests moved towards computing and he became lecturer at Edinburgh. 743 Glen Schaefer (–1986), stayed on at Birmingham. He eventually published,
April 7, 2009
496
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
on as a research student. He is very bright and quite likely to stay on in this country, if there is a job for him since physics in South Africa is not very attractive.744 Finally as regards field theory there is a young American, Lieb, who will be here for another year.745 Then we have a South Korean and a Greek, who are nice people, but not first rate. Two of our own graduates in their second year of research (one on solid state and one on nuclear theory), both of whom seem very promising. Two of last year’s graduates who are in their first year of research, both on relativistic electron theory. One rather promising and the other more average. Two French men, both more interested in nuclear problems. One will be returning to Paris in the summer, the other will continue for another year. Finally there is Miss Dee, a Cambridge graduate who has started here on nuclear problems and is likely to continue and a Japanese research Fellow, Yoshida, who will stay another year if we can renew his Fellowship. This list omits a few people who are leaving this summer and therefore don’t concern you directly. Expected newcomers include Nicholson from Australia, who should be here within the next few days and who wants to do field theory on a Canberra Fellowship; one of our own graduates (the present final year is exceptionally small and except for this man exceptionally poor); there are two very promising Fulbright Fellows, one starting research and the other one with a Doctor’s degree; one Canadian, Vogt,746 now with Wigner, who seems very bright but whose fellowship is not as
among others, a joint paper with Gerry Brown and J.S. Langer, G.E. Brown, J.S. Langer and G.W. Schaefer, ‘Lamb Shift of a Tightly Bound Electron’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A251, 92–104 (1959). 744 Stanley Mandelstam (1928–) had studied at Witwatersrand and Cambridge and obtained his Ph.D. from Birmingham in 1956. He went on to do research at Birmingham, Columbia, and Berkeley where he eventually became professor of physics in 1963. 745 Elliott H. Lieb (1932–) studied at M.I.T. and Birmingham where he obtained his Ph.D. in 1956. He took on posts in Kyoto, Illinois, Cornell, at IBM, in Sierra Leone, Yeshiva University Northwestern University and M.I.T. before becoming professor of physics at Princeton in 1975. 746 Erich Vogt (1929–), later professor at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver and director of TRIUMF, Canada’s National Laboratory for Particle and Nuclear Physics.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
497
yet assured; one Italian and one other Japanese, both interested in nuclei; one Frenchman from Joliot’s group; one very promising man from Oxford, and possibly Felix Adler from Carnegie Tech, on a year’s sabbatical leave.747 This is all we shall have room for, but I have turned down a great number of applicants some of whom looked quite promising, though I have not in fact refused any serious application from this country. You are quite right that progress with the synchrotron experiments is slow, largely because we now know that the energy region available here is not one for new discovery, but one for precise experiments and that of course always takes time. Progress is, however, continuous and we are in the satisfactory position of being evidently useful to the physicists in keeping them informed and in discussing hypothetical experiments. What you say about experimental physics is quite true and is worrying everybody. We begin to feel that the lack of equipment is only one of many reasons and that perhaps the absence of a systematic training of the younger people in modern physics, including those parts not studied locally, has a lot to do with it, and in almost every University now measures are being discussed of remedying this. In particular Mott is proposing to start postgraduate courses and he hopes that Bethe, who will be there next year, will play a large part not only in giving such course, but in organizing a suitable scheme. Nevertheless there are still good people around and the standards and the spirit of the groups, particularly at Harwell and at Liverpool, are very high. My own feeling is that for theoretical work it is not absolutely necessary to be close to a group contributing to the latest discoveries, what is absolutely essential is to be in close contact with experimentalists who are alive and up to date and who can digest for us new experimental information that becomes available. This we have got in a large measure at Birmingham and if we do not have more of it it is very largely our own fault. In educating the experimentalists here and in maintaining contact with them Feldman has been very useful. There is no immediate pro747
Felix T. Adler, (1911—79) staff member at General Atomic (1956–58), consultant at Los Alamos National Laboratory (1961–78), he served as professor of physics and nuclear engineering at the University of Illinois, Urbana between 1958 and 1979.
April 7, 2009
498
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
posal to replace him. It would not be difficult to get the same kind of grant again, but I have no suitable candidate. However, I do not think this is serious because our group is now generally in much closer contact with the Physics Department than used to be the case (there are for example weekly meetings on high energy physics which are attended usually by three or four of our people) and I expect of course also that your return will help matters in this respect. Our group is still weakest in the nuclear theory side where at the moment we are down to quite junior people, except for myself and except for the Japanese, Yoshida, who however still has difficulties with the language and therefore cannot yet pull his full weight. I find it difficult to keep myself up to date sufficiently to guide people in the right direction, or even for example to work out a programme for our nuclear physics discussion meetings, which for that reason have lagged behind. I expect of the newcomers next year some will be able to help and of course your presence here will help further even though I imagine you will not want to work on nuclear theory yourself. Incidentally I have omitted to mention another useful fact, namely that we have an arrangement by which we can pay Salam’s expenses during any periods he can spend in Birmingham, during the Cambridge vacation. We regard this as an attractive arrangement and I am almost sure it will continue indefinitely. The most interesting progress here recently is work by Edwards whose use of functional methods is approaching more closely to the possibility of a realistic solution for the full pseudo-scalar case with recoil. However, of course there are many difficulties and one can’t be sure until one actually has a solution which still looks a fair way off. With all best wishes, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
499
[611] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson [Birmingham], 7.4.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, Thank you for your letter.748 I think we would all agree at once with your remark that even allowing for vacuum polarization Edwards has not proved that anything converges. What seemed to me so instructive was that in the absence of vacuum polarization one can prove, or better one can make it plausible by very simple reasoning that the series diverges even if one uses the cut-off and therefore removes infinities. Now this situation is changed by the vacuum polarization term so that the basis for this proof collapses and I would take this as an indication that the vacuum part has profound influence on the structure of the theory and one should not believe any conclusions derived from an approach which ignores it. This of course agrees so far with what Feynman said at Rochester, except that Feynman’s analysis always necessarily puts the vacuum correction in to the exponent, which would seem at sight a slightly dangerous procedure, since any zeros of the Fredholm determinant, if they are anywhere near the relevant region, would produce logarithmic singularities in the exponent which would give quite an erroneous impression of the difficulty. By the way, I should have mentioned in my last letter that the Matthews-Salam paper apparently is going to appear in the Physical Review after all.749 Our letter withdrawing it crossed with a note from Goudsmit saying it was being published, but changes have been made which stress more clearly the relations of the contents to the results of Feynman and other people. About the method of Edwards it is certainly true that their ultimate value cannot be judged until the whole thing has been done. However, since he wrote the note which you have he has added a number of very important further steps and there is in fact an outline of a full 748 749
Letter [609]. Letter [606], notes 723–24.
April 7, 2009
12:11
500
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
treatment of the charged pseudo-scalar case with recoil. Of course it is only approximate and one has to find out how great the errors are, however, the nature of the theory is again such that it is exact in the case of weak coupling and that it is extremely good if not rigorous in the case of strong coupling (rather like the method used in Feynman’s paper on polarons. The calculations also have not been carried out completely and these get exceedingly complicated. It is in part a question of what features of the propagator one wants to look at. The exact solution for the propagator would in any way really contain the whole of physics almost everything that can happen as a virtual process which will leave its trace in the propagator, but there are some ideas about how to proceed. One satisfactory feature is that there is no problem about renormalization at all stages the different terms just split off cleanly and there is never an ambiguity. I think it is a pity you did not get to Moscow and particularly that in the end nobody from the West seems to have gone (possibly Kallen has gone but I have not yet heard), so at the moment it is the West which blocks international contact of scientists, certainly a most unsatisfactory situation.750 However, I am sure everybody will understand that in your case the risk of serious complication was extremely heavy and I think really everyone else in your position would have done just the same thing. I must say I don’t quite see why Feynman did not have the courage to go because it would in his case at most have resulted in some unpleasant publicity. I tried my best to persuade Salam to go and he almost went. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
750
See letter [609].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
501
[612] Rudolf Peierls to Nevill Mott [Birmingham], 18.4.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Mott, I am again late with my replies to various letters of yours on rather long term questions and I am trying to catch up with arrears. This is about your letter of 10th February751 in which you raise the general questions of how to improve physics in this country. I found, like Salam, that the Rochester Conference showed up a lot of things which are common ground in America and less well known here, but this did not depress me quite as much as Salam, because I have had this kind of experience many times before and know that there are compensations. However, it is quite true that physics in this country is behind that in America and not merely because of a lack of big machines. I do not know of any simple remedy. It is very largely a question of spirit and of ways of thinking, rather than of specific organizational measures which would be easy to take. For example it is I think generally true that we tend in this country to know less than we thought about what goes on in detail in other laboratories. This is a question of time only for the senior people, who are reluctant to go away for a day when it is not absolutely necessary. For younger people to spend a day occasionally at another university is not a serious problem and even the question of expenses is not serious. Many such visits are possible without being away overnight and fares are not all that large. Very often people also can arrange to stay the night with friends. The real trouble I think is that it just does not occur to people to do this except in special circumstances. Perhaps they do not know the right place to go to or with whom to talk. This in part is remedied by senior people and in this respect I think occasional meetings, smaller than the big international conferences, to which only a few of the research students can get admission, but large enough to bring together people from different Universities. It would not be possible to 751
Letter could not be located.
April 7, 2009
12:11
502
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
cover in such meetings all the interesting topics, but they could serve to establish contacts, which people could follow up on their own. However, a much more serious problems seems to lie with experimental physics. There is somehow a lack of leadership. There do not seem to be enough people who are really excited about the problems of high energy physics and who think of these problems on their own merits without necessarily linking them to an immediately practicable experiment. Perhaps it is not reasonable to this kind of interest to have survived or developed during the years when there was no chance of such experiments being done in this country. Perhaps it is a question of education and perhaps we are really short of leaders of the right type or perhaps we have failed to spot them and put them in the right positions. I think it is likely that all these answers are true to some extent and no quick remedy is evident. I should certainly be glad to talk more with you about these problems, although you will have seen from the above that my idea on the subject are far from being clear or definite. I shall next be in Cambridge on 25th May, when Ziman752 has asked me to talk to their Wednesday colloquium. I shall have to come up the night before and if you happen to be free on the evening of Tuesday, 24th May I shall be very glad to see you then. It may also be that I can stay up for the following night, but this is not clear yet. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[613] R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls Princeton, 18.4.1955 Dear Professor Peierls, I was very surprised to hear that nothing came out of your interest in the Oxford position (which suggests a sad lack of imagination at Oxford) — 752
John Michael Ziman (1925–2005), studied at Hamilton and Oxford where he obtained his Ph.D. After research in Cambridge he moved to Bristol where his research interest shifted from pure science to philosophy of science.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
503
my previous letter took it very much for granted that you would leave and should be understood thus. Thank you for your detailed letter. I certainly have no reason to expect that there will ever be a shortage of research students as long as you are there. I agree that it is very healthy to have research students from abroad, and it is also very interesting and pleasant for all concerned — my only point was that the possibility of a number of healthy and active schools of theoretical physics will depend on having suitable people stay in the country, and I am only sorry that more of the people who do stay have not been associated with a closely-knit and practical-minded school such as Birmingham. I am inclined to think that the disadvantages for a theoretical physicist working remote from active experiment depend a good deal on the nature of his work — if he seeks to account for low energy pion phenomena in terms of a meson theory, for example, the disadvantage is not very great. But if he has a direct interest in the phenomena themselves, he needs to know early what types of observations are becoming possible, how the current data is behaving — what it is interesting to discuss depends a good deal on what is experimentally feasible (although Wick — and experience — have taught me the principle “what is impossible today is still worth discussing now, for it will be done within two years”). Even if preprint communication were efficient, (word-of-mouth is more the rule here), the phenomena have been thoroughly discussed by the experts on the spot before preprints go out. (Of course the Rochester Conference and the APS meetings are particularly helpful in this matter). However, there are always things which have been overlooked, and there are obvious advantages in being able to stand at a distance, especially for one who is not particularly quick-witted. I did not wish to stress this point unduly. I am a bit surprised now to look back at the heavy concentration of field theory at Birmingham. I have wondered to what extent this can be correlated with the level of experimental activity in England, but I expect it is really just a fluctuation. The organisation of academic physics on the States has greatly impressed me. In the best places, the graduate student training is very effective and to the point; the students have a practical grasp of quan-
April 7, 2009
12:11
504
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
tum theory and its applications to many fields of current interest, which has often surprised (and embarrassed) me — in comparison English students seem one-dimensional in their interests (in physics). At first I was surprised at the fewness (low density!) of theoreticians here, but it is certainly right to encourage students to do experimental work with such facilities available here. I would very much like many English experimenters to see the courses which it is considered proper for a graduate student in experiment to attend here! The separation between graduate and undergraduate work seems very convenient for the senior people, also there are now so many research institutes and special laboratories, whose people have at most a few graduate courses to give, this tendency seems to be on the increase as machine projects are becoming too large for a University department to manage. I should mention here that I had a call from Chicago a few days ago — they are anxious to fill this position and have no authority to hold over the offer, so I turned it down. Another offer a year hence may, however, be possible. Incidentally, Wick decided not to go, and Gell-Mann left for CalTech. I was not asking for advice on Canberra,753 but I would infer that you also think it rather unattractive. I feel that one should perhaps look to the future — Australia is growing rapidly and is actively interested in atomic energy development, ten years hence (say) such a position may have more to offer than any position that may be available to me in England. Also it offers complete freedom for research (although in some isolation) which is an unusual attraction. However, it is always hard to start from scratch, and there are special difficulties in this case; one cannot hope for ideal conditions and there is a challenge to see what one can do. But it is rather likely that I would not be acceptable for the position — however, if it were offered to me, it would not be easy to turn down. I am rather sorry that it is coming up at this time. I must say that I have little feeling now for the degree of isolation which would be involved in working in Canberra. I was very interested indeed to hear how things stand in Birmingham at present.
753
See letter [608].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
505
I do not have much news of physics at the moment — people here seem rather remote from one another and there have been few visitors — but what little I have is enclosed separately. With all good wishes, Yours sincerely, R.H. Dalitz
[614] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 6.5.1955 Are you — or some other from Birmingham — going to the conference in Pisa?754 I am not sure yet whether or not I shall go.755 Dear Peierls! I would like to write to you now my present views on renormalized quantum electrodynamics. Although everything is still conjecture, at least it turned out recently that Landau has the same conjectures as I. The papers in question all appear in “Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR”, Autoren: L.D. Landau, A.A. Abrikosov and J.M. Khalatnikov.756 754
Between 12 and 18 June 1955 an international conference on elementary particles took place in Pisa. Pauli only decided to attend when it became clear that the conference would attract participation of many eminent colleagues from all over the world. See Pauli Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel, IV/3, pp. 232–4; see also Il Nouvo Cimento. Supplemento (1955) which published the most important papers of the conference. 755 Handwritten addition at the top of the letter. 756 L.D. Landau, A.A. Abrikosov and I.M. Khalatnikov, ‘On the removal of infinities in quantum electrodynamics’, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR 95, 497–500 (1954); L.D. Landau, A.A. Abrikosov and I.M. Khalatnikov, ‘An asymptotic expression for the electron Green function in quantum electrodynamics’, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR 95, 773–76 (1954); L.D. Landau, A.A. Abrikosov and I.M. Khalatnikov, ‘An asymptotic expression for the photon Green function in quantum electrodynamics’, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR 95, 1117–1120 (1954); L.D. Landau, A.A. Abrikosov and I.M. Khalatnikov, ‘The electron mass in quantum electrodynamics’, Doklady
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
506
1. 2. 3. 4.
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
l.c. l.c. l.c. l.c.
95 95 95 96
(3), (4), (6), (2),
497, 1954 773, 1954 1177, 1954 261, 1954
Do you have this periodical in England and can you understand sufficiently Russian to read these papers? K¨ all´en, who was recently in 757 and had discussions there with the groups of Landau and Moscow of Tamm brought these papers to Copenhagen and they are going to have them translated there by the theoretical CERN division. I did not see these papers myself, but I read Landau’s summarizing article (for the Bohr festival book) “The quantum theory of fields”,758 where the four mentioned papers are also quoted. I don’t think that anything is really proved by Landau and his collaborators, and K¨ all´en also has this impression. Nevertheless, I am ready not “to bet”. Landau came to his ideas quite independent of Lee’s model (which he did not know at all). (I was influenced by it, but not by it alone.) Not the conjecture. Let e be the physical, e0 the mathematical electrical charge, and let us first introduce a cut-off in momentum space at a finite momentum P destroying this the Lorentz-invariance of the theory. This I held essential in order that the renormalized qu[antum] el[ectro]dyn[amics] is at all defined. Write then e20 , (1) e2 = 1 + e20 F (P, e20 ) Akademii Nauk SSSR 95, 497–500 (1955). English-language versions of these papers can be found in D. ter Haar, (ed), Collected Papers of L.D. Landau, Oxford, 1965, papers 78–81. 757 Gunnar K¨ all´en had been the only Western representative at the All Union Conference 1955 in Moscow, where he reported on the mathematical structures of the Lee-model renormalized fields. In Moscow, he had discussions with Landau and his Russian colleagues, and he returned to Copenhagen with copies of the above mentioned articles which he had translated into English for use by Western colleagues. See letter K¨ all´en to Pauli, 19.4.1955, Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel IV/2, p. 201. 758 L.D. Landau, ‘The quantum theory of fields’, in W. Pauli (ed.), Niels Bohr and the development of physics, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1955, pp. 52–69.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
507
consider only real e0 ’s. Then it is proved that e2 /e20 < 1 or F > 0. Conjecture (both of Landau and mine): There is a lower bound for F whatever the real value of e0 may be F > µ(P ) > 0 and for large P the order of magnitude of µ(P) will be log P/m: µ(P ) ∼ log P/m
for large
P
From this conjecture it follows e2 <
1 . µ(P )
Mathematically it follows for the limit P → ∞, e2 → 0. Or, the other 1 it follows way round, for the physical value∗ e2 = 137 µ(P ) < 137, which blocks the possibility to pass to the limit P → ∞. If the conjecture in question is true, renormalized quantum electrodynamics would never be a consistent lorentzinvariant theory, a negative statement in which I now firmly believe (so does Landau). On the other hand one would still understand well that renormalized quantum electrodynamics is a good approximation to the physical reality, as the cutting-off momentum P is very large of the order of magnitude ∼ m(exp)137. (Landau made an interesting attempt to connect this cutting off boundary with gravitational forces.) It seems to me very important that more efforts should be made by the experts of field-quantization and of renormalization to prove or disprove this conjecture. I am not myself such an expert but I have talked with and written to someone, however until now their methods to attack the problem do not seem to me really satisfactory. ∗ Units
= c = 1, m = electron-restmass.
April 7, 2009
12:11
508
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
One question is: can F (P, e21 ) (for a finite P) in the denominator of (1) be developed in a power series in e21 ? (This would certainly be better than to develop e2 itself in such a power series, as is known for some time already.) Thirring759 — the expert, which is locally nearest to me (Berne) — has certain doubts about it: he is afraid, that even for a finite P power series of F might have the convergence radius zero. But this may be a bit overpessimistic. I rather believe that for finite P the power series of F exists and even has the convergence radius infinite. Only two terms of this power series are known at present (see: Jost and Luttinger, Helvetica Physica Acta 23, 201, 1950,760 which paper is also quoted by Landau) and both are positive. Jost already then guessed (and still believes in it now), that all coefficients of this power series will turn out to be positive (at least for sufficiently large P ). In this case one would of course have a lower bound for F in the hand (provided that the power series for F actually converges everywhere). I am sorry, this is all what I know about the problem of the range of consistency of the renormalized quantum electrodynamics at present. Dyson and the G¨ ottinger “Feldverein” for a while recommended a kind of “Vogel Strauß politics”, namely not to cut off and not to talk of e21 at all and only to use e2 . But this seems to me completely silly. Every statement of e2 can be translated into one of e21 and vice versa and if our conjecture is true the use of an e2 larger than µ(P ) would correspond to a non-real e1 -values (or to no e1 values at all) and will certainly give rise to pathologies (the details of which seem to me of no great interest). It seems to me urgent to find a direct and efficient method to verify or falsify our conjecture which concerns the use of a finite cut-off. 759
Walter Thirring (1927–), obtained his Ph.D. from Vienna in 1949. After research at Dublin, Glasgow, G¨ ottingen, Zurich, Bern, Princeton, M.I.T. and visiting professorships at M.I.T. and Washington, he became professor of physics at Bern, before taking up a professorship at Vienna in 1959. 760 R. Jost and J.M. Luttinger, ‘Vakuumpolarisation und e4 -Ladungsrenormalisation f¨ ur Elektronen’, Helv. Phys. Acta 23, 201–214 (1950).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
509
I am thanking Dr. Edwards very much for sending his letter to Metzer761 and his manuscripts.762 It will take some time until we have studied it thoroughly. It seems to me, that insufficient attention has [been] given his papers to the renormalization of the coupling constant which I held to be decisive in all examples. All good wishes, Yours W. Pauli
[615] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli [Birmingham], 9.5.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli! Thank you very much for your interesting letter.763 We had reprints of the four Landau papers and have spent a fair time studying them. As a result we believe on the whole that Landau is right, but his arguments in a typical Landau fashion tend to accept certain steps as plausible and certainly do not represent a rigorous proof. I certainly like your conjecture and I always felt very strongly that the fact that renormalization works in the frame work of the series expansion does not prove that the theory without cut-off makes sense. The possibility that such things may happen, was brought home to me particularly by playing with non-local classical theories. (I agree of course with your point that classical models can be quite misleading.) But in a paper by Irving764 which was done here, it was shown that if 761
Kurt Metzer, English physicist who spent some time at Zurich with Pauli. See Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel IV/2, p. 869. 762 S.F. Edwards, ‘A Note on the divergence of the perturbation method in field theory’, Phil. Mag. 45, 758–61, (1954). 763 Letter [614]. 764 J. Irving, ‘The effect of the tensor force on the binding energy of the alpha particle’, Proc. Roy. Soc.A 66, 17–27 (1953); J. Irving and D.S. Schonland, ‘Energy of the ground state of Li6 ’ , Phys.Rev. 97, 446–450 (1955).
April 7, 2009
12:11
510
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
one takes the McManus-type non-local equations seriously765 then while the series expansion looks alright and allows one after renormalization to go in each term to the limit, the physical results for the scattering of light of very high frequency depend not on the renormalized, but on the bare mass and therefore becomes nonsense when the cut-off momentum exceeds a certain value. I want to regard this merely as an illustration of what may happen. The classical theory is certainly no proof that it will happen. Edwards has come to conclusions766 which are very similar to yours and Landau’s except that he has looked more at mass than charge normalization and he can derive from very general arguments plausible results about the behaviour of the propagator for very high momentum, which in the case considered by Landau, agree exactly with Landau’s results and which would support your qualitative conjecture, i.e. the idea that one is not allowed to go to the limit in a fairly general type of theory. We agree of course that in Edward’s approach much remains to be done about renormalization. The reason why this has been omitted is in part because this is very difficult, but there is another point. One cannot, of course, talk about renormalization without reference to a specific procedure for solving the equation. I believe a good deal of confusion has been caused by people starting from renormalization in the frame-work of series expansion and then jumping to the conclusion that the results have a meaning which is unrelated to the series. Now the experience with the type of method Edwards is trying has always been that whenever some simplified theory or some part of the whole theory is amenable to a mathematical solution, then at least the mass renormalization defines itself and there is no doubt about what should be done. For this reason it seemed more profitable to concentrate on a method of solution rather than worry about renormalization If it is true that one must not go to the limit then of course we are forced back into theories of the non-local type. I am not too pleased with 765
See letter [396], note 80. S.F. Edwards, ‘A note on the divergence of the perturbation method in field theory’, Phil. Mag. 45, 758–61 (1954). 766
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
511
our previous attempts to handle non-local theories, but I have a feeling that one would get further with the following point of view: There are several possible ways of describing non-local equations, one is to use generalized Poisson brackets which I have tried to define, but then one is in difficulty with proving consistency and also it is not at all clear how one is to solve such equations, other than in perturbation theory. Another is to use the Yang-Feldman formalism767 as for example Møller and Kristensen have done,768 but then there is trouble, firstly about defining a theory other than through a series expansion and also one is troubled by the question whether the ‘Bloch theorem’ is valid, a point on which the Japanese have thrown considerable doubt. Finally one can start from the Feynman integration over paths, which can immediately be applied to any non-local theory derived from an action principle, but the doubt in that case is whether the S-Matrix resulting from the theory is unitary. I do not believe any proof for the unitarity of Feynman’s S-Matrix has been given, except by showing its equivalence with the Hamiltonian formalism where this exists. Now if one believes that the equations one is handling are the final ones they must be unitary. If one understands by the non-local theory simply that part of physics of which at the present time we have reasonable knowledge, omitting regions where new fields or new particles (or possibly, as Landau says, even gravitation) may be of importance, then the theory need not be unitary. In any theory from which possible virtual processes have been eliminated, one does not get a unitary S-Matrix. However, then there is still a requirement, namely that the total probability of all calculable processes should be less than one and never greater than one, since the lack of unitary rules results from throwing away things that may not happen. I see no clear way of deciding whether Feynman’s equations with any given non-local action satisfy such an inequality or how one is to restrict the actual principle to make them satisfy it. But certainly if one gives up the need for exact unitarity, one acquires more freedom and things might work better. 767
C.N. Yang and David Feldman, ‘The S-Matrix in the Heisenberg Representation’, Phys. Rev. 79, 972–78 (1950). 768 P. Kristensen and C. Møller, Mat-fys. Medd. 27, 7 (1952).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
512
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
It seems therefore that as on some previous occasions our conjectures are rather similar, if perhaps for different reasons. Unfortunately I shall not be able to come to the Pisa Conference, because it happens at a time when we are busy with examinations, but Edwards is certainly going and probably Matthews, Feldmann and Valatin from here as well. I think you might find it interesting to talk to these people. If you cannot get to Pisa, perhaps it would be a good idea to see whether Edwards could visit Z¨ urich on his way back. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[616] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 3.6.1955 Dear Peierls, I have still to thank you for your letter of May 9th.769 Apart from reproduction of your well-known McManus complex it contained very important information. 1) That the Landau papers have been studied in Birmingham and that “on the whole you believe that Landau is right.” (I never doubted the “typical Landau fashion” of his arguments.) 2) That you like my conjecture. That for larger energies for all (however complicated) processes the Born approximation with the bare mass and charge holds, is the content of a general conjecture of K¨ all´en’s which is proved for particular processes only. I do not believe that in order to prove my conjecture, it is necessary to prove K¨allen’s conjecture generally. (N.B. In the Leemodel the latter is true.) — I think charge renormalization is well defined, independently of any power series development. Your inequality for the total probability seems to me hopeless to prove in a theory with non-unitary S-matrix. 769
Letter [615].
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
513
Although I know some interesting models for renormalization of quantized fields besides the Lee-modell, no decisive progress has been made in the problem to prove or disprove mine and Landau’s conjecture in quantum electrodynamics. I have now decided to go to the Pisa conference and I am looking forward to see there Edwards and the other people from Birmingham, which you mentioned. His majesty Julian I Schwinger will be there, too. I thank you very much for your book on quantum theory of solids.770 I give now a lecture on problems of quantum statistics, where I am also discussing in detail the theory of the de Haas-van Alphen effect (just in order to learn it). I had used already the copy of your book in the library at this occasion before your dedicated copy has arrived.771 While I found physics always discussed fine in your book, I also found that you thankfully followed my traces as a teacher by introducing many errors of signs. In order to diminish my greater depth in this respect I am enclosing a page with a list of errors in the formula of your book in connection with the de Haas-van Alphen effect. I am looking forward to read the other chapters of your book. Yours sincerely W. Pauli [617] R.H. Dalitz to Rudolf Peierls Brookhaven, 4.8.1955 Dear Professor Peierls, I am writing this letter mainly to clarify my impressions of a long discussion which we had with T.D. Lee today on a bold synthesis he has suggested, which may have some elements of truth. I hope it may have some interest for you also. First a little background. Lifetime measurements for Kµ2 and Kπ2 by counter method are under way at Berkeley. I will not give details of 770
R.E. Peierls, The Quantum Theory of Solids, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1955. Rudolf Peierls had dedicated the copy ‘To Professor Pauli who introduced me to the subject of solid-state theory, with compliments R.E. Peierls. Mai 1955.’ 771
April 7, 2009
12:11
514
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
the method as it is quite similar to that used by the Princeton group and by Hyams at Manchester.772 With 82 Kµ2 and 25 Kπ2 counted (the delay time for the standard origin being measured), Alvarez believes that these lifetimes cannot differ by more than 40%. The τ -lifetime has been measured again by exploding emulsion stacks at two distances from the source, with a result 1.0 × 10−8 sec (±30%). Also the joint, Kπ2 lifetime has been deduced from the decays-in-flight observed along K-tracks coming into the emulsion — this is also 1.0 × 10−8 sec with a similar error. On the other hand, decay statistics of the τ -meson make it very unlikely that the τ could decay to 2π and be identified with the θ-meson. So, Lee’s starting point is that the τ and the θ should be different but with the same “apparent lifeline”, and essentially the same mass (the K + , τ + mass difference is now < 3m3 according to Berkeley). Also there is a desire to link the Kµ2 , Kµ3 Ke3 decay nodes to the explanation of beta decay. Now what kind of intermediate meson could account for beta decay, which is S+T coupling in about equal proportion? To obtain tensor coupling a vector meson is needed — to agree with the shape of > allowed spectra, it must be heavy (∼ 1000 me ); three requirements have been long known. Lee suggests that this should be the θ-meson, a (1-) meson can readily give 2π decay. From µ-decay and beta decay, then gµν gP N and gev is not very far different.
772
Bernard Hyams, at the time at Manchester University, joined CERN in 1957, where he remained until 1990.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
515
µν and to ev PN , to µν through Now θ + can decay to 2π through + through gev (this latter is something of a difficulty since θ → e+ +v has not been observed with certainty but possibly gev is somewhat less than the other links, this is not clear). But these decays are all fast taking the various g’s from beta decay etc. with lifetimes close to 10−14 sec. How then to account for the observed Kπ2 lifetime? Lee suggests that τ of (0-) and that the θ mass is a little less than the τ mass, say ∼ /me . Then
τ →θ+γ
(1)
is allowed, with probability lifetime depending on the mass difference
= mτ − mθ and the τ -meson radius. Lee supposes that this lifetime is 10−8 sec and that the tracking ratio τ → 3π/τ → θ + γ is 1/10 (the observed τ + /K + ratio). You will then see that the observed K + lifetimes are all governed by the lifetime (1), so that the “apparent lifetime” for Kπ2 , etc. is actually the τ lifetime. It is now supposed further that the θ particle does not appear directly in associated production. If it did, say π − + p → Λ◦ + θ o ,
(2)
and charge independence is assumed, π + + N → Λ◦ + θ + should go but θ + → π + + π o quite quickly (∼ 10−14 sec) and one fouls seem to have π + + βn → Λ◦ + π + + π o
(3)
is unassociated production. (However I do not believe that situation (3) has really been examined experimentally yet.) So Lee supposes, instead of (2) that (4) π − + p → Λ◦ + τ o and that τ o → θ o + γ could explain the appearance of θ o . Note that the mass difference mτ o − mθo may be quite different from Λ above so the τ o , τ + lifetime can be completely different — the observed “θ o lifetime” of 2 × 10−10 sec. would then really be the τ o lifetime and the
April 7, 2009
516
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
τ o → 3π decay mode would no longer be able to compete with this (∼ 10−3 branching ratio). Many things still lie outside this scheme — the π − µ decay cannot go through S or T coupling, i.e. through a (1-) θ-meson. The Kµ3 and Ke3 decays do not appear naturally — if the neutral particle is a γ then they will be too slow and if it is a π, additional couplings are needed (e.g. a weak τ + → θ + + π o which then → π o + µ+ + ν). Alvarez is making an attempt to detect a ∼ 12 Mev photon in coincidence with the Kµ2 decay, but this has obvious difficulties. But this gives a picture so different from anything that has been suggested before but which brings together at least in a rough way, some very different aspects of our problems, that it certainly merits a good deal of thought. I might say that Lee does not find it satisfying or anywhere near a final picture, but hopes that some elements of it may be useful. The prospect of a τ − θ pair with masses and lifetimes so close certainly suggests a situation whose solution may seem rather strange to us! Life in very enjoyable here, although the humid heat is sometimes not easy to bear. Valda and the children are all very brown and enjoy being able to visit the ocean beach very frequently. The cosmotron has been running rather spasmodically. There was a maintenance shutdown, a failure in the fuse across the magnet circuit meant another 10day break and now there is a good deal of work on the machine concerned with the external beam project. I hope the problem of beam extraction is being pushed very rigorously at Birmingham — it seems the only hope for the synchrotron to make any really significant contribution. Our departure now seems very near, and I have a great deal to do before the end of the summer — the weather, the seminar activities and the many interesting visitors all make steady writing a difficult proposition! With good wishes to all, R.H. Dalitz
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
517
[618] Rudolf Peierls to John Cockroft [Birmingham], 9.9.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Cockroft, I am writing about the question of the plans for a large accelerator. First of all I must apologise for failing to reply to Schonland’s letter at the right time. I misread the letter and was under the impression that replies were only expected later. However, if I had written at that time I would have advocated the high intensity machine at 2–3 GeV, in line with the conclusions reached at your meeting. Since then I think the case against the 12 GeV machine has been strengthened by the news of the Russian project, since it is most unlikely that the energy interval from 10–12 GeV will be critical, and one would surely expect that if for five years most of the interesting work will have been done up to 10 GeV, which can conveniently be carried out with a low intensity machine. I admit the force of Powell’s argument as regards negative K particles, but while this indicates some limitations of the work in the 2–3 Gev region, it does not in the light of the Russian programme justify the 12 GeV project. In addition I do not think one can be at all sure that in five years and later the interest will centre on negative K particles, but I think one can be sure that high intensity beams, which permit more accurate and more detailed measurements, for example of angular distributions of resonance curves and of secondary reactions will always justify themselves in any energy region. It is quite likely that new and exciting things will be found at the higher energies. It is probably true that at any time the most interesting physics will be done in the highest available energies, but clearly one cannot hope to reach, in a reasonable time, the maximum available energies, and it is just impracticable for this country to compete with the CERN and Brookhaven projects. Looking further ahead, no doubt in the distant future the questions will arise whether one can exceed the 25 MeV figure which looks like the practical limit at the present time. This will call for new ideas
April 7, 2009
518
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
in accelerator design and the experience in thinking about the present high intensity 3 GeV machine, one is as likely, as by another method, to collect new ideas. Whether even with the most brilliant ideas one can hit on a design for energies above 25 GeV which would be within the means of the U.K. is of course doubtful, but it would be satisfactory if this country could contribute some new ideas which would allow such energies to be reached by some international project. I would also like to comment on Powell’s remark about the location of the machine. There is no doubt whatever that the new machine is too big to belong to any individual University and I see the strength of the case for it being placed at Harwell. Even if it were anywhere else it would necessarily have to be available to members of all universities and would have to be operated under some central authority. Any such arrangement raises serious difficulties which I think must be faced. It is of vital importance for this country that there should be a satisfactory arrangement for attracting to fundamental experimental physics a sufficient number of men of the highest ability, and of giving them the best possible training. The traditional method of ensuring this is to have good equipment at the universities, so as to attract to the Universities staff of high calibre who can keep in touch with the undergraduate teaching, and who can themselves keep alive by being active in research. We expect the same people to supervise research students and to bring up these research students in a university atmosphere, where they can keep in touch with other branches of the subject and with other subjects. If the equipment necessary for work in the front line of physics is available only outside the Universities we will run the danger that the staff will have their main interest away from their normal laboratories and will come to regard the Universities as places to do their routine undergraduate teaching. Equally, the research students (or junior staff equivalent in status to research students) may spend most of their time at the accelerator station and we may lose the important and stimulating effect of their presence in the Universities and also the effect of the University atmosphere on their continued general education. In as much as they may regard high energy physics as the only interesting branch of the subject, they may see a post at this accelerator station as the only
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
519
worth while career and may not be attracted by a teaching post, which would allow them openly to do their main work during short periods away from their base, and as a result the present danger of losing good young men to permanent posts in the United States would obviously be enhanced. I do not believe there is any simple way out and in particular I do not believe that the idea of attaching the machine to a particular University would either be possible or would represent a satisfactory solution to the difficulties, but the conclusion to be drawn is that in the near future very serious thought should be given to this situation and that we should try to think of all possible ways to mitigate the disadvantages. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[619] Freeman Dyson to Rudolf Peierls Berkeley, 11.9.1955 Dear Peierls, I said I would write again at the end of the summer, and as I am leaving here to-morrow I will do it now. I am glad to see your book is out,773 though I have not yet managed to get hold of a copy of it. Actually, no definitive “results” have come out of the big machine so far. When I went round asking people how it is going, they all said “Oh in another month or two we will have something.” The bottleneck with could chamber and plate experiments is of course the scanning. The one experiment which has been completed since the Pisa conference is a counter experiment to measure the lifetimes of Kµ2 , Kπ2 and τ . This works in the following way. 773
See letter [616], note 770.
April 7, 2009
520
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
ABCDEF are scintillation counters. X is 3/4 inch copper absorber, Y is 14 inch absorber-radiator. (A − F ) means a particle stopping in A. If in addition we have (B + D − C − E) it is a Kµ2 (B − D − C + E) or (C + E − B + D) it is a Kπ2 (B + C − D − E) it is a τ . The Kµ2 will include some Kµ3 and Ke3 but these are known from the plate experiments to be only a few per cent of Kµ2 , so they are ignored. The delay between A and BCDE is measured for each event of interest. The results are Kµ2 lifetime (1 ± 0.3) × 10−8 sec. (1 ± 0.3) Kπ2 τ (0 ± 0.5) However, they say one should not believe the shorter τ -lifetime because the τ events are contaminated with protons which make the stars in A, ˇ and the Cerenkov selector is only 99% efficient against protons. They hope to overcome this trouble in the next run. This seems to be a good experiment and it opens up a whole field of counter experiments which one can now do with K-particles. But the main hopes of the radiation Lab. are being put into bubble chambers.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
521
You probably heard that they are designing a liquid–hydrogen bubblechamber 50×50×20 inches, which is to give precise information about all the hyperon-K-particle interactions with good statistics. A big program is being planned to scan the pictures and put the results onto Hollerith cards on a mass production basis, so that really big quantities of data can be effectively used: All this will take 2–3 years to put into operation, but it seems very sensible. Apart from the Bevatron, the most interesting experiments have been the triple-scattering experiments done with the 350 MeV cyclotron. These probably were mostly already reported at Pisa, but they are continuing to get new results. They have now enough to analyse the P − P scattering into phase shifts with SPDF waves (9 independent phase angles) using the same method as they used for π-P scattering. There are at the moment 3 possible solutions. All this is only at one energy, and if it can be done at more energy values (which is difficult) one will really learn something about the P − P interaction. I myself have worked this summer mainly on cleaning up the theory of spin waves. I considered only the simplest and most ideal case of a lattice of fixed spins with the nearest-neighbour exchange interaction J
(Si ˙ Sj ). nn
It turns out that there is a lot of interesting mathematics in this. The problem of course is to deal decently with the fact that spin waves interfere with each other not more than 2S reversed spins can sit on the same atom. I succeeded in understanding this. The problem arose because there are two published calculations of the spontaneous magnetization of such a lattice, which disagree. One by Kramers and Opechowski774 gave 3
1 − c1 θ 2 + c2 θ 2 − · · · 774
¨ W. Opechowski, ‘Uber die Temperaturabh¨ angigkeit der Magnetisierung eines Ferromagnetikums bei tiefen Temperaturen’, Physica 4, 715–22 (1937); H.A. Kramers, Commun.Kamerlingh Onnes Lab. Univ. Leiden 22, Suppl. 83 (1936).
April 7, 2009
12:11
522
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
where θ = (kT /J). The other by Schafroth775 gave 3
7
1 − c1 θ 2 + c2 θ 4 − · · · These are supposed to be low-temperature approximations, good when θ 1. 5 In fact they are both wrong. The third term is of order θ 2 when S = 12 . Aside from the practical applications of this work (which is rather negligible) I found it interesting as a kind of object-lesson showing how a non-linear field theory might behave. We have here a theory containing precisely one dimensionless parameter θ = kT /J. All the thermodynamic functions of the system can be calculated as powerseries expansions in θ, and one feels then that the theory is essentially complete. But there are obviously physical effects proportional to e−J/kT = e−1/θ which become dominant at high temperatures, which give zero contribution to every term of the power-series. So the powerseries are in no sense a complete solution of the problem. If you translate this into quantum electrodynamics and replace θ by α, the moral is obvious. This letter is getting so long I had better bring it to an end quick. Were you at Geneva? I would be glad to hear what you thought of this affair.776 I hope you had a good summer and some respectable holiday. Verena and I succeeded in getting for a few days into the high mountains, which are just wonderful. Verena also turns out to be an excellent walker and scrambler. Our children are in good shape too, and we are enjoying them more and more. George astonished us at the age of 2 y. 1 month by telling his left and right with 100% accuracy. But he has now forgotten it again. All good wishes to the family. Yours ever, Freeman Dyson 775
M.R. Schafroth, ‘Self-Consistent Spin-Wave Theory for the Ferromagnetic Exchange Problem’, Proc. Phys. Soc. A67, 33–38 (1954). 776 In August 1955, at the Geneva Conference on the Peaceful Uses of Atomic Energy, Soviet scientists had the opportunity, for the first time since the war, to demonstrate their progress in nuclear physics. The conference marked the beginning of the reconstruction of scientific East-West dialogue.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
523
[620] Rudolf Peierls to Freeman Dyson [location unspecified], 14.9.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Dyson, Thank you very much for your long and interesting letter.777 I have recently been so poor a correspondent that I might for once answer for return. I am very interested in what you say about spin wave theory because we have recently been interested in this ourselves. A very good student of mine, Marshall (I have forgotten whether you overlapped at all, but I don’t believe so) has done some very nice work on this. In particular debunking the conventional spin wave theory which replaces the spin matrices by some phoney boson creation and annihilation operators. He also showed that the answer of Schafroth was wrong, though he is not proposing to publish this, and we have always suspected the T 2 term in the expansion, but had not yet got round to doing something about the problem. Marshall’s main effort has been on the problem of antiferromagnetism, where the position is much more difficult since one does not even have any simple approximation for the state of lowest energy. He has a nice variational approach to this problem, which indicates that in the anti-ferromagnetic case the energy of the lowest ordered and the lowest disordered state are so close together that in any given model one would have to calculate extremely accurately to be sure which is which, and in addition the answer is likely to be very sensitive to secondary effects (such as interaction between other than nearest neighbours, etc). The result, while disappointing from the point of view of a clean theory, fits in quite reasonably with the experimental situation. His papers are being published in the Royal Society,778 but if you are interested I can see if he has a copy to spare. I have always known the importance in physics of the function −1 e x . It occurs in a wide class of problems in statistical mechanics in 777
Letter [619]. W. Marshall, ‘The structure of magneto-hydrodynamic stock waves’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A233, 367–76 (1955). 778
April 7, 2009
12:11
524
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
describing the difference between a very close and discrete spectrum at high temperature, and the classical continuous spectrum. The anomalous diamagnetism at low temperatures is an important example. I therefore agree enthusiastically when you say one must be prepared for such things happening in field theory, though of course this does not prove that they do happen. We have been talking a good deal about Pauli’s worries on the meaning of a renormalized theory in which the ‘bare’ coupling constant is imaginary. They are really two quite separate questions. The first is whether it is established that in the ordinary theory the bare constants really do come out imaginary, or in other words whether there is an upper limit to the observed coupling constant or charge for an arbitrary real bare constant. Pauli’s belief in this comes mainly from the Lee model, which of course proves nothing. Landau is also very confident, but we are not altogether convinced of his reasoning. On this point there is an interesting new paper by Taylor in Cambridge779 inspired mainly by your review of the Landau paper.780 He has obtained the same result from the equations of Gell-Mann, and this probably is a valid proof, but we are still digesting some steps in his reasoning. Assuming this is so there remains the question whether it is a disaster that one has to start from an unreasonable ‘bare’ theory. If the situation is similar to that in the series expansion, then the bare constants never appear in any physical answer and it should therefore not matter what they are, but I agree intuitively with Pauli that if one works with such a theory there should be some disaster somewhere. Pauli is so sure of this that when questioned at Pisa he refused even to discuss the question, but if disasters happen one ought to be able to say just what kind of disaster will occur and exactly where it will mess up the theory. Apart from this we have tried to understand the now fashionable low energy approximations. Matthews and Feldman have succeeded in 779
J.C. Taylor, ‘Self-Energy Effects on Meson-Nucleon Scattering According to the Tamm-Dancoff Method’, Phys. Rev. 98, 201 (1955). See also J.C. Taylor, ‘The form of the divergencies in quantum electrodynamics’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A234, 296–300 (1956). 780 ¨ F.J. Dyson and H.Uberall, ‘Anisotropy of Bremsstrahlung and Pair Production in Single Crystals’, Phys. Rev. 99, 604–605 (1955).
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
525
simplifying the arguments on this a good deal, but of this you will hear shortly from Feldman, who is on his way to the Institute.781 I am particularly interested to understand to what extent these results depend on the model, and to what extent they are purely phenomenological. I believe we are in danger of making the same error that was made for a long time in the nuclear two-body problem, where we now know that owing to the effective range approximation we are dealing with results dependent only on two parameters, and that therefore any kind of interaction with two parameters (and not too unreasonable in certain ways) will agree with the experiments. There the situation was confused for many years by people working with specific models, and taking any agreement they found as a confirmation of the model. We have also put a considerable effort into understanding the philosophy of Brueckner’s treatment of the many body problem, and I gather from Bethe and Weisskopf that noone in America outside Brueckner’s group has taken his approach at all seriously. Our impression so far is that for the idealised case of an infinitely large nucleus calculating only volume effects, his approximation looks good; we have gone through all the steps of his rather long and somewhat confusing reasoning and are reasonable happy about all but one on which there remains some confusion. Of course one wrong step is sufficient to wreck the answer, but since all other arguments turned out to be right, we are still hopeful. On the other hand I do not think much of his attempts to treat surface effects let alone the problem of a small finite nucleus. We hope to put some more effort into analysing these Brueckner methods still further. Yes, I did get to Geneva. At first rather reluctantly and at short notice, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. It was great fun to watch the reopening of channels in international scientific communication. I found it a great advantage there to be able to talk Russian, and to know some of the Russians personally. Their performance on accelerators is staggering. By now you will probably have heard about this. They not only have the famous 650 MeV synchro-cyclotron, which employs an extraction method similar to the Liverpool one, but even better, giving an extraction efficiency of 5%, but they also have completed, though 781
G. Feldman and P.T. Matthews, ‘No-Recoil Approximations to Charged Scalar Meson Scattering’, Phys. Rev. 103, 1870–73 (1956).
April 7, 2009
526
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
not yet in operation, a 10 BeV proton synchrotron of the Bevatron type, very lavish in space and rather conservative in design. The experiments with the 650 MeV cyclotron and with Veksler’s electron-synchrotron (of I believe 250 MeV) seem very good and accurate, but I have heard of nothing exciting. It is interesting that their planning of the experiments does not seem to have been guided by as close a contact with theory, as has been the case in Chicago. Another interesting illustration of your Bethe book review. In other words they did not have Fermi there. For example they have measured their scattering of charged mesons, but as far as I know have not observed the charge exchange effect and therefore could not make a complete analysis. Their cosmic ray work is in bad shape; they had essentially two groups of which one produced the phoney mesons of which you have heard, and the other one was too busy debunking them that they omitted the chance of looking for new particles themselves. Their theoretical team seems good. The only theoretician in Geneva was Markov, who is a very nice person, though what he is doing himself on non-local theory is not exciting, but he talked a bit about the attitude of the Landau and Tamm groups. Landau is very gloomy about the prospects of renormalization theory and present field theory in general, whereas Tamm’s people are busy doing rough calculations by TammDancoff method and the like. The most important thing is that contacts should now be very easy. It is clear that Russians will in future be able to come to conferences, that they will invite people (I have a firm promise of an invitation to Moscow as soon as possible), they will now start again to publish foreign language abstracts with their papers, and evidently also the bar on publishing papers in foreign language periodicals has been lifted. We told them about the present practice about sending out preprints, and they will consider doing the same. It will obviously be useful to include them in the distribution of future preprint. Where one does not know addresses they can always be sent care of the Academy of Sciences. The spirit at the Geneva conference was best summed up by a remark which one of the Russians is supposed to have made to an American colleague ‘You know we are so glad that we have been told to be nice and charming to you’.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
527
We had a very successful holiday in Dorset. For once the weather in this country was better than anywhere else. I never wrote to say how much we enjoyed the visit of your parents the other day. I was highly amused by your father remarking at the end that he had been very surprised to find how young I was. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[621] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli [Birmingham], 16.9.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli, There exists a scheme by which the British Council (a government organization which promotes cultural interchanges with other countries) can invite foreign scientists to visit Universities in this country. I have just heard that, at our request, they have given approval for an invitation to be sent to you. I understand that a similar request has been made by the University of Manchester and I believe that Manchester are to send you an official invitation to come to this country sometime during the academic year 1955–56 and to spend some time in Manchester and in Birmingham. I am writing for the moment only to say how pleased we are that this invitation is being sent and to hope that you will find it possible to accept. As far as Birmingham is concerned I believe any time during the academic year would be suitable, except the Easter vacation (end of March to end of April), when I myself maybe away, and of course the longer you can stay the more we shall be pleased. Before you decide on dates it would be best to wait for the letter from Manchester. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
528
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[622] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Aitken [location unspecified], 20.9.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Dr. Aitken, I am writing to let you know about a new difficulty I have met as regards accommodation for my people and the proposed solution. I have been trying very hard to limit the membership of my department for the new academic year to remain within the available space. This involves always some guess work since some people do not know until the last minute about their grants, and I was fairly pleased when the number turned out to be only one more than I had really room for. We can usually manage to squeeze in an extra one, particularly since one man is leaving at Christmas. However, since then I had a request from another American, who was going to Copenhagen for a year, but now would like to come here for a term first. His qualifications are so good and he would be so useful to us that I was most reluctant to turn him down. To exceed our number by two would really be rather difficult, but a reasonable solution would seem to be to borrow a small trailer belonging to the Physics department, which is not at the moment in use and which just makes an office for two people. I have discussed this with the physicists and it would seem possible to put this up in a suitable position near my hut, where it either will join two trailers already in use, or else will be fairly well hidden from view. I know you do not like these trailers about the place, but in this particular case it would only mar a corner of the University already not conspicuous for its beauty and would help us out of an otherwise very difficult situation. I hope you will not object to this too strongly. [Rudolf Peierls]
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
529
[623] Rudolf Peierls to Robert Aitken [Birmingham], 21.10.1955 Dear Dr. Aitken, I have now had time to consider your proposals for the Arts Faculty.782 While this may from the overall University point of view turn out to be the best solution, I have little doubt that from the point of view of University House it would have great disadvantages. If the furniture and equipment moved to the new hall were to remain there, this would handicap the planning of the new hall, which one would like to see done from scratch without being hampered by existing furniture. etc. If it were ultimately to return to the present University House, the two moves in short succession would mean a great strain on the staff and particularly on the warden, and I visualize that particularly to get the building into shape after a few years’ use for another purpose by the Arts Faculty would be rather troublesome. The Warden has put an enormous effort into making limits resources go very far, and a good deal of work has been done by her personally and by voluntary effort of the staff. It would be hard to ask for that to be done again. To get the place into shape again one would probably have to spend a great deal of money and this raises the question whether with the same amount of money one could not find easier solutions. An obvious suggestion would be if the new building at Wyddrington could be obtained in time to use that for the Arts Faculty. Distance would be a disadvantage, but I don’t see anything unsurmountable in that. Second-hand buses are surprisingly cheap and it would not cost very much to run a shuttle service between this place and the Library, as well as any other sites in the district which might have to be brought into use. After all the present institute of Education is not located very closely either to Edgbaston or Edmund Street and there must be a great deal of traffic between these places which somehow or other manages to get along. 782
Letter Robert Aitken Ms.Eng.misc.b.198, B.10.
to
Rudolf
Peierls,
24.10.1955,
Peierls Papers,
April 7, 2009
530
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
Presumably some thought has been given to other large houses in the neighbourhood which are available, or may become available in time. I believe there is one large house belonging to the University now being converted into flats and possibly this could be held for the purpose temporarily until the Arts Faculty Building is available. I have also heard of a large house in Somerset Road, with ten bedrooms, which is not on the market for the remainder of its lease (I believe twenty years) and which would not cost very much to acquire. You mention in you letter the question of huts for lecture rooms. As you know I believe that huts make very bad rooms for large classes. Some of the Arts classes are as large as 200 and I have never seen a satisfactory hut used as a lecture room for so large a class. Possibly such large classes could be accommodated in existing departmental lecture theatres (e.g. Physics or Engineering), if the times could be fitted in. I believe these rooms are not heavily used in the afternoons and perhaps the Arts Faculty could make it possible to have large lectures in the afternoon, or else the science departments here could share in some of the inconvenience. For smaller classes huts might be adequate, or possibly large rooms in houses we acquire might be suitable. The move of the Arts Faculty will of course also bring problems for the Refectory and Union. Here I imagine University House could make an important contribution. Since at present no lunches are served at University House, one could imagine, given the necessary additional facilities and staff to use the kitchen and dining room to serve several meals to undergraduates, probably in two or three sittings. This would probably not cope with all the Arts students, but I would imagine that if in addition the Refectory and the Union accepted such additional numbers as they could manage, one might not be too far out. Finally I feel that before placing too great a hardship either on members of the Arts Faculty or on other parts of the University, one should be very clear of the argument for moving as soon as possible. There may be technical reasons why we cannot continue to use Edmund Street. I imagine another point would be that this will increase the urgency of a case for getting the Arts building complete. As regards this last point we would probably also have an unassailable case if we
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
531
should show that it had in fact proved impracticable to move the Arts Faculty, and that therefore we had the beautiful new Library building and were not able to use it. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls [624] Rudolf Peierls to Lev Landau [Birmingham], 8.11.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Landau, Thank you very much for your letter.783 I am interested to hear that you are arranging for a translation of the Quantum Theory of Solids.784 Since this was published I have noticed one or two minor errors and misprints. Perhaps when you know the date of the translation going to press you could let me know so that I could send you an up to date list of corrections. I am also sending you a copy of another book, the Laws of Nature, which may amuse you.785 It is a more popular book written without any mathematics. We were very interested in seeing the papers by yourself and your collaborators about quantum field theory, in which you show that with point interactions the real charge was zero, if the bare charge is to be real.786 The hardest point in this seems to be the question whether the perturbation theory, which has been used in deriving this result remains valid in the limit. The point is of course dealt with in one of the papers by Pomeranchuk,787 but we are still trying to understand this paper in detail. 783
Letter could not be located. See letter [616], note 770. The book, published by Peierls in 1953, appeared in Russian translation in 1956. 785 R.E. Peierls, The Laws of Nature, London: Geo.Allen & Unwin, 1955. 786 See letter [625]. 787 Iu.Ia. Pomeranchuk, ‘Zero Equality of renormalized charge in quantum electrodynamics’, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR 103, 1005–1009 (1955). 784
April 7, 2009
12:11
532
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
It would, I think be most useful if there were an opportunity to discuss these and other unresolved questions of modern theory at greater length than is possible at a large conference and I am now trying for an invitation to one (or more) theoretical physicists from the U.S.S.R. to visit our department for several weeks. Needless to say we would be particularly glad, if you were able to accept such an invitation and we could arrange the time almost entirely according to your convenience. However, if you do not expect to be able to accept in the near future we would be glad to ask instead one of the other senior theoreticians, and in the choice of names would be glad of your advice. This of course would not exclude the possibility of my visiting Moscow, which you mention in your letter. With kindest regards, Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
[625] Wolfgang Pauli to Rudolf Peierls Z¨ urich, 25.11.1955 Lieber Herr Peierls, Leider kann ich im Fr¨ uhjahr doch nicht nach England kommen, da ich mich nun entschlossen habe von Januar bis etwa Mitte April (Beginn des Sommersemester in Z¨ urich) wieder zu Besuch ans Institute in Princeton 788 Das wird Sie sicherlich entt¨ auschen, aber aufgeschoben ist zu gehen. nicht aufgehoben. Im u ¨brigen ist die Feldquantisierung (trotz Landau, arts gekommen und Pomeranchuk789 und Taylor)790 nicht wirklich vorw¨ alle interessanten mathematischen Fragen (¨ uber die ich Kopenhagen 788
See letter [621]. After the death of Pauli’s father the latter was not tied to Zurich in the same way as before and could contemplate longer visits abroad, as his planned trip to Princeton. 789 L.D. Landau and I.J. Pommeranchuk, ‘On the point interactions in quantum electrodynamics’, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR 102, 489–92 (1955). 790 See letter [620], note 779.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
533
viel mit K¨all´en und Lehmann diskutiert habe), sind so unentschieden wie je. Nun noch eine Frage betreffend meinen jetzigen Assistent Dr. A. Thellung: Kann er im n¨ achsten Fr¨ uhjahr (nicht vor dem 1. April 1956) zu Ihnen nach Birmingham kommen? Ich war mit ihm sehr zufrieden und er hat eine l¨ angere Arbeit u ¨ber Quantisierung der Hydrodynamik ¨brigens fertiggestellt, die er nun zusammenschreibt.791 Dabei hat sich u gezeigt, dass die Resultate st¨arker von der Art des Abschneidens, d.h. hier von der atomistischen Konstitution der Fl¨ ussigkeit anh¨ angen als man zun¨achst erwartet hatte. Von Zeit zu Zeit ist bei meinen Assistenten ein Wechsel n¨otig, bei Thellung w¨ are vielleicht auch ein Wechsel des Arbeitsgebietes empfehlenswert und er selbst w¨ urde gerne zu Ihnen gehen.792 Was die Finanzierung von Thellungs Auslandsaufenthalt betrifft, so w¨ urde ich im Falle einer positiven Antwort von Ihnen versuchen, ihm ein Schweizer Forschungsstipendium zu verschaffen, welches etwa Fr. 500.- bis Fr. 600.- pro Monat betragen w¨ urde. Da mir das etwas knapp zu sein scheint, m¨ochte ich Sie gerne fragen, ob er aus irgend welchen Fonds bei Ihnen noch etwas dazu verdienen k¨ onnte. Mit freundlichen Gr¨ ussen Ihr W. Pauli
791 A. Thellung, ‘On the energy spectrum in quantum electrodynamics and the theory of He II’, Helv. Phys. Acta 29, 103–27 (1956). 792 Thellung spent two years between March 1956 and April 1958 in Birmingham, first as research fellow and then as part-time lecturer, before he returned to Zurich to take up an appointment as professor of physics.
April 7, 2009
12:11
534
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[626] Rudolf Peierls to S.C. Redshaw [Birmingham], 30.11.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Redshaw,793 I promised to let you have a note about the case for further for Dr. Dalitz. You will remember that Dalitz was promoted to Grade I as from the beginning of this session, and that on the last round of meetings he was given the title of Reader, on the basis of very enthusiastic reports from three referees which you read out at the Board meeting. I feel that this still does not give him an adequate status corresponding to his merit. He is certainly by far the best man in my subject in this country, who does not yet hold a chair, and he compares very favourably with many who do. His approach to his work is a very personal characteristic combining an easy command of all the modern mathematical techniques with very good practical judgement, and a sense of the important. He is extremely critical and has very high standards. If in any problem of modern physics his opinion differed from everybody else’s, including my own, I would bet that in the end he would be proved right. In addition the part of the subject which he has chosen for his own work at the present time is concerned with high energy phenomena and new unstable particles, which is the present frontline of physics, and is of the greatest importance, if only because very large amounts of money are being invested in using machines producing particles for such work, as the synchrotron in the physics department here, and the cyclotron at Liverpool, and more such machines are being planned. There is nobody else at all in this country whose knowledge and understanding of these problems can compare in the least with that of Dalitz, and who is capable of leadership. Since his return he has already has a profound influence over the planning of work in this department. We have put several research 793
S.C. Redshaw, professor of civil engineering at the University of Birmingham and dean of the faculty of science.
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
peierlsroot2
535
students on problems which he raised, and he is taking the responsibility for the planning of their work. It will probably soon be necessary to add to this group by taking further students off the problems we had previously put them on, because the new work is of great importance. In addition to this he is an extremely good judge of experimental work and good in discussing the plans for experiments the interpretation of their results with the people engaged in such work, and he is a brilliant lecturer. Before he went to America two years ago he was not known to very many people in this country, and therefore the most enthusiastic support for his recent promotion came from America. Since his return he has visited several Universities in this country, and I gather has greatly impressed everybody on the[s]e occasions. I am sure that I could now ask any physicist in any of the leading laboratories for his opinion about Dalitz and get an opinion at least as favourable as my own. There is no doubt that as regards ability, achievement, personality, Dalitz is of professorial calibre. This in itself would not necessarily make out a case for creating a personal Chair for him here, because it might be argued that a man of such a standing is not needed in the department and that he should therefore be released to go to the next Chair which is offered. However, it would be better for him if for a time he did not have to carry administrative responsibility and to worry about the organisation of undergraduate teaching, or the building up of a department. He is perfectly capable of doing the[s]e things but it would be better if for a few more years he could devote himself mainly to research, in which he can give a more unique service. But also from the point of view of the department a case can be made out. I think it is fair to say that this department is now the leading school of the subject in the country. It contains thirty people doing research, and places for research training are greatly in demand, both by applicants from within this country and by people from overseas. We have every year to turn down many good applications and even so our numbers are rising. Although I have some excellent senior people on my staff, even so I still carry too much responsibility personally for various aspects of our work, and as a result some aspects of it tend to become neglected. This applies in particular to the more experimental and phenomenological
April 7, 2009
536
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
aspects of high energy physics, which is Dalitz’ special field. I am now bringing myself up to date by attending Dalitz’ lectures. I feel we have a strong case for strengthening our department by retaining for some years our best and most experienced man in an appropriate capacity. The situation is aggravated by the fact that Dalitz is very much in demand. He has an invitation to join the staff of the Brookhaven Laboratory in Long Island as the senior theoretician on the high energy side. This is a very attractive appointment because Brookhaven is one of the two laboratories in the world now leading in this kind of research. He must decide on this offer by about January. In addition he is being short listed for a new post as Head of the Theoretical section of the new European Nuclear Research Laboratory in Geneva, and he is being offered a vacant post at Liverpool, which if Dalitz is interested would I believe be turned into a research Chair. There are many other attractive posts he could have if he wanted them. I want to make it clear that the existence of these competing offers is not the basis of my case, but they do make it more urgent. Apart from these offers there would be more time to consider the proposal, but unless something is done soon we are very likely to lose him, and particularly if he were lost to the United States I would regard this as a disaster from the national point of view. The progress of physics in this country is in danger by losing too many good people to America. To some extent this is unavoidable because of the attractive facilities available there, and the more rapid pace of progress in research. But it would be a misfortune, if, in addition we lost people by being too slow in recognizing their value, and giving them adequate status. We tend to give too much weight to age and seniority. Dalitz is now about the same age as I was when I took up my chair here. His standing in physics, his ability and his general reputation are quite comparable with mine at that time, as for the future I am confident that he will do more than I have done. I hope you will do what you can to help me in this problem. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
April 7, 2009
12:11
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
1954–1963: Spreading the Seeds of the Birmingham Group
537
[627] Rudolf Peierls to Wolfgang Pauli [Birmingham], 1.12.1955 (carbon copy) Dear Pauli! Thank you for your letter.794 I am sorry you will not be able to visit us in the spring, but I hope you will come later. I have little doubt that the British Council would be glad to sponsor an invitation also in another year. We shall certainly be glad to have Thellung here. I see at the moment no possibility of finding here a grant which would add to his income, but a sum of 500–600 swiss francs a month sounds quite adequate. The cost of living here is much less than in Switzerland. I do not of course know whether he has any special requirements. If he is married or if he is the sort of man who cannot live without a motorcar, then it might be a little difficult, but a lot of people here manage to live on considerably less. I would of course be glad to know later when he is proposing to come and roughly how long he intends to stay. The conclusions which you mention about the problem of quantum hydrodynamics sound very similar to those reached in a recent paper by Kuper and Allock795 in Liverpool. I suppose you know of their work. If you will be in America in the beginning of April I hope you will find it possible to come to the conference in Rochester (3rd to 7th April).796 These conferences are usually very good. Yours sincerely, R.E. Peierls
794
Letter [625]. G.R. Allock and C.G. Kuper, ‘“Rotons” in quantum hydrodynamics’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A231, 226–43 (1955). 796 Between 3 and 7 April 1955 the sixth Rochester Conference took place. The meeting, for the first time since the war, also included three Russian scientists. 795
April 7, 2009
12:11
538
World Scientific Book - 9in x 6in
peierlsroot2
rudolf peierls
[628] Rudolf Peierls to William Penney [location unspecified], 6.3.1956 (carbon copy) Dear Bill, On the subject of your phone call this morning I think that I should write you a note explaining what is in my mind, so that you can consider my point of view before we meet on Monday.797 Let me say, first of all, that I very much appreciate your call and the frank and courteous way in which you put the position to me. I want to ensure you that I have given the problem a great deal of thought, and do not take it lightly. It would distress me very much if I were to cause any difficulty or embarrassment to you and your colleagues in the Authority, but to my mind an important principle is involved on the other side, and this is what I want to explain. I regard our position in the cold war not merely a matter of national loyalty. We have in the west some important principles in which we believe very deeply. We tend to be a little ashamed to talk about them, but in the end most of us are willing to go to a lot of trouble about them and risk a lot for their sake. Very important amongst these is the freedom of scientific enquiry, the freedom of exchange of scientific information, and of objective discussion with any scientist, regardless of person, nationality, or position as long as these do not interfere with his approach to scientific fact or argument. This principle must, of course, be subject to the overriding requirement of national security. We have learnt to accept these limitations, and have succeeded in defining in a workable way the fields in which research may still be free because it only serves the long-term aims of searching for the fundamental laws, from those fields which at present have to remain restricted. Amongst the many things for which we blame the Russian system is their fear of free and open discussion, their arbitrary restriction of 797
Rudolf Peierls wanted to attend the International Conference on High Energy Physics in Moscow between 14 and 22 M