Shock Wave and High Pressure Phenomena Series Editor-in-Chief L. Davison, USA Y. Horie, USA Founding Editor R. A. Graham, USA
Advisory Board V. E. Fortov, Russia Y. M. Gupta, USA R. R. Asay, USA G. Ben-Dor, Israel K. Takayama, Japan F. Lu, USA
Shock Wave and High Pressure Phenomena L.L. Altgilbers, M.D.J. Brown, I. Grishnaev, B.M. Novac, I.R. Smith, I. Tkach, and Y. Tkach: Magnetocumulative Generators T. Antoun, D.R. Curran, G.I. Kanel, S.V. Razorenov, and A.V. Utkin: Spall Fracture J. Asay and M. Shahinpoor (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids S.S. Batsanov: Effects of Explosion on Materials: Modification and Synthesis Under High-Pressure Shock Compression R. Cherét: Detonation of Condensed Explosives L. Davison, D. Grady, and M. Shahinpoor (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids II L. Davison and M. Shahinpoor (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids III L. Davison, Y. Horie, and M. Shahinpoor (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids IV L. Davison, Y. Horie, and T. Sekine (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids V A.N. Dremin: Toward Detonation Theory Y. Horie, L. Davison, and N.N. Thadhani (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids VI R. Graham: Solids Under High-Pressure Shock Compression J.N. Johnson and R. Cherét (Eds.): Classic Papers in Shock Compression Science V.F. Nesterenko: Dynamics of Heterogeneous Materials M. Su´ceska: Test Methods of Explosives J.A. Zukas and W.P. Walters (Eds.): Explosive Effects and Applications G.I. Kanel, S.V. Razorenov, and V.E. Fortov: Shock-Wave Phenomena and the Properties of Condensed Matter V.E. Fortov, L.V. Altshuler, R.F. Trunin, and A.I. Funtikov: High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids VII L.C. Chhabildas, L. Davison, and Y. Horie (Eds.): High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids VIII R.P. Drake: High-Energy-Density Physics D. Grady: Fragmentation of Rings and Shells M.V. Zhernokletov and B.L. Glushak (Eds.): Material Properties under Intensive Dynamic Loading G. Ben-Dor: Shock Wave Reflection Phenomena S.M. Peiris and G.J. Piermarini (Eds.): Static Compression of Energetic Materials
Suhithi M. Peiris . Gasper J. Piermarini
Static Compression of Energetic Materials With 156 Figures
ABC
Gasper J. Piermarini National Institute of Standards and Technology 100 Bureau Drive Gaithersburg, MD 20899-1070 USA E-mail:
[email protected]
Suhithi M. Peiris Defense Threat Reduction Agency 8725 Kingman Road Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-6201 USA E-mail:
[email protected]
Series Editors-in-Chief: Lee Davison ˜ Vista Road 39 Canoncito Tijeras, NM 87059, USA E-mail:
[email protected]
ISSN: 8063-7200 ISBN: 978-3-540-68146-5
Yasuyuki Horie AFRL/MNME Munitions Directorate 2306 Perimeter Road Eglin AFB, FL 32542, USA E-mail:
[email protected]
e-ISBN: 978-3-540-68151-9
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008930164 © 2008 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permissions for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover design: WMXDesign GmbH, Heidelberg, Germany Printed on acid-free paper 5 4 3 2 1 0 springer.com
Preface
This volume, belonging to the series “High-Pressure Shock Compression of Solids”, focuses on the utility of static-compression studies of energetic materials to understand shock processes such as detonation. Static compression, initially based on P. W. Bridgman’s work during the first half of the 20th century, launched into its own science in 1959 when the diamond anvil cell (DAC) was developed and subsequently utilized as a primary tool to achieve very high pressures. One motivation for this book is to document the history of the development of the DAC and its associated analytical techniques to the study of energetic materials at static high pressures. Another incentive is to present recent work utilizing the DAC in several areas relevant to understanding the behavior of energetic materials at high static pressures. In the late 1960s, three scientists at the National Bureau of Standards (NBS) in Washington, DC, S. Block, C. E. Weir, and G. J. Piermarini (the co-editor of this book), were actively involved in the development of a single crystal x-ray diffraction technique utilizing the DAC. Several papers describing the progress they were making in that area had been published, demonstrating promising results. However, one major obstacle had not been overcome, and that was the ability to measure accurate sample pressure in the DAC in a simple, routine, and rapid way. Research scientists at the Explosives Laboratory, Picatinny Arsenal, Dover NJ, were aware of the NBS work and were following its progress with great interest. In 1969, the Picatinny scientists approached the NBS group and asked if they would try the new high-pressure single-crystal x-ray diffraction technique on several inorganic azides that were of interest to them. They desired information on pressure-induced polymorphism and anisotropic compressibility of these azides, data that were unavailable at that time. The NBS scientists initial response, to say the least, was not very enthusiastic, because they pointed out that such data required a knowledge of sample pressure and also a hydrostatic pressure environment due to the desired anisotropic properties of the crystals. Both pressure and hydrostaticity were quite unreliable at that time because of the lack of exact measurement capabilities with respect to those properties. The Picatinny scientists were more optimistic than the NBS group and suggested that they undertake the study to see where it would lead. After some deliberation, the NBS group agreed to take a look at these azides, but only when they
v
vi
Preface
could fit the work into an already busy schedule. They cautioned the Picatinny scientists that it might take months before they could get meaningful results, if at all. The Picatinny scientists presented a convincing argument to study these materials. They noted that little work on explosive materials at very high pressures and also at elevated temperatures had been published because of the nature of the experimental conditions available at that time, i.e., relatively large volume presses had to be used to generate the pressures needed to obtain useful data such as compressibility, thermal stability, pressure-induced polymorphism, etc. Few contemporary experimental scientists were willing to conduct such experiments owing to the danger of the sample detonating inside the anvils of the press, jeopardizing the safety of the researchers. So it was that the NBS scientists were introduced to studying energetic materials at high pressures in a DAC. Little did they know or appreciate the farreaching consequences of their decision to study pressure effects on these azides. In 1970, the DAC was an unsophisticated piece of equipment and the technology associated with it for pressure measurement was rudimentary (known freezing pressures of the pressure-transmitting media were used to define the pressure), but nevertheless the NBS scientists were able to obtain useful data with it, and, in the case of the azides, some of the data were reported for the first time. Since then, DAC technology and the means for measuring sample pressure in the instrument (e.g., the ruby fluorescence method and now other more recently developed techniques) have dramatically progressed. The DAC has been transformed from a rather crude qualitative instrument to the sophisticated quantitative research tool that it is today, capable of routinely producing and measuring sustained static pressures in the multi-megabar range and readily adaptable to numerous scientific measurement techniques because of its optical window, miniature size, and portability. Today, the DAC is the premier instrument of choice for conducting experiments of all kinds and in all disciplines which utilize the static high pressure and temperature variables. Indeed, for static high pressure/temperature studies on energetic materials, the DAC has become a widely used indispensable tool especially for studying these very sensitive energetic materials with multiple phase transitions at small pressure/temperature changes. Common energetic materials such as ionic ammonium nitrate, ammonium perchlorate, sodium perchlorate, and the molecular solids, NM, TNT, HMX, RDX, and TATB when initiated, undergo rapid decomposition resulting in a high-pressure high-temperature shock wave or detonation. This is a complex process to accurately describe, being a combination of almostinstantaneous chemical, mechanical, and physical changes, requiring estimations of high-pressures, high-temperature thermodynamic properties, chemical kinetics, and reaction mechanisms. Fortunately, as described in this book, DACs allow the design of well-defined static experimental conditions with accurate analytical measurements, leading to a much better understanding of the behavior of energetic materials with respect to initiation, reaction, and detonation processes. The various chapters in this book will attest to this fact, because much of the experimental data represented in these chapters were obtained with the DAC. Because of its enormous popularity in the scientific community, and because many users of the DAC are unaware of its origin due to its many modifications,
Preface
vii
the history behind the invention of the DAC at NBS is presented in Chapter 1. This chapter highlights the development of the original lever-arm type DAC together with a description of four other generic types of DACs developed later. Also described are several analytical techniques – optical polarizing light microscopy, infrared absorption spectroscopy, and powder- and single-crystal x-ray diffraction – that were applied successfully for the first time to the study of energetic materials at static high pressures. In addition, Chapter 1 describes a process of invention, which illustrates a concept that unique and original research often is not planned by the organization, but originates from the scientists themselves, who must be highly qualified and motivated to do research. Planned research assumes that certain predictable results will be achieved, and therefore, funding can be justified by the institution. Unfortunately, this line of reasoning frequently produces mediocre scientific results. The quintessential message proffered in Chapter 1 is that the development of the DAC was not planned in advance; but, after its conception by the scientists themselves, the work was allowed to simply progress, until ultimately its importance was recognized and financially supported. Chapter 2 explains the utility of static high pressures to synthesize energetic materials. The ultimate intent of the research described in this chapter is to create highnitrogen or polymeric nitrogen materials. Thus, it describes the creation of singlebonded crystalline nitrogen, synthesized from N2 at P > 100 GPa and T > 2,000 K. The material has a cubic-gauche (cg-N) structure, which was determined from x-ray diffraction and Raman measurements. Chapter 3 elucidates experimental measurements of the pressure–volume equations of state of energetic materials and their phase transitions at high pressure and temperature, while Chapter 4 explains the same for binders and polymers used in the formulation of explosives. The adaptation of the DAC for x-ray diffraction experiments, Raman and Brillouin spectroscopy, and other analytical techniques is detailed. The influence of nano- to micron-scale features of binders and polymers, on the equation of state of formulated explosives is explained. Chapter 5 highlights dynamic techniques with the DAC, utilizing time-resolved spectroscopy to study complex processes of rapid mechanical, physical, and chemical changes that occur during the detonation of an energetic material. Chapter 6 discusses static experiments that allow a detailed understanding of these complex processes at the molecular level to illustrate the interplay between static and shock experiments. Chapter 7 describes molecular dynamics simulation methods and applications to energetic materials under high compression. Applications using both electronicstructure-based methods and conventional moleculardynamics methods employing empirically derived force fields are given, as well as a discussion on advantages and limitations/deficiencies of the various methods and models. Chapter 8 addresses how defects affect the initiation and detonation of energetic materials. Ab initio modeling of several energetic materials is used to elucidate the effect of electronic and spatial structure of defects and their complex involvement in initiation of the explosion process.
viii
Preface
The editors wish to acknowledge the demanding efforts of all the contributing authors to this book, and also to recognize their personal contributions to static compression and its utility in studying energetic materials. This is a dynamic and diverse field with many questions still to be investigated, leaving exciting possibilities for future work. April, 2008 Virginia, USA
Suhithi M. Peiris Gasper J. Piermarini
Contents
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v
1
Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gasper J. Piermarini
1
2
Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75 Mikhail I. Eremets, Ivan A. Trojan, Alexander G. Gavriliuk, and Sergey A. Medvedev
3
Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives . . . . . . . . 99 Suhithi M. Peiris and Jared C. Gump
4
Equations of State of Binders and Related Polymers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127 Dana M. Dattelbaum and Lewis L. Stevens
5
Reaction Kinetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 203 Suhithi M. Peiris
6
Understanding Shock-Induced Changes in Molecular Crystals . . . . . 219 Zbigniew A. Dreger
7
Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics Simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 255 Betsy M. Rice and Thomas D. Sewell
8
Modeling Defect-Induced Phenomena . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 291 Maija M. Kuklja and Sergey N. Rashkeev
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327
ix
Contributors
Dana M. Dattelbaum Dynamic and Energetic Materials Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87544, USA
[email protected] Zbigniew Dreger Institute for Shock Physics, Washington State University, PO Box 642816, Pullman, WA 99164, USA;
[email protected] Mikhail I. Eremets Max Planck Institute for Chemistry, Postfach 3060, 55020 Mainz, Germany;
[email protected] Alexander G. Gavriliuk A. V. Shubnikov Institute of Crystallography, Russian Academy of Sciences, Leninskii Pr. 59, Moscow 117333, Russia, Institute for High Pressure Physics, Russian Academy of Sciences, Troitsk, Moscow 142190, Russia Jared C. Gump Indian Head Division - Naval Surface Warfare Center, Indian Head, MD 20640, USA Maija M. Kukla Office of Integrative Activities, National Science Foundation, 4201 Wilson Boulevard, Arlington, VA 22230, USA;
[email protected] Sergey A. Medvedev Max Planck Institute for Chemistry, Postfach 3060, 55020 Mainz, Germany Suhithi M. Peiris Indian Head Division - Naval Surface Warfare Center, Indian Head, MD 20640, USA, now at: Defense Threat Reduction Agency, 8725 Kingman Road, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060, USA;
[email protected] Gasper J. Piermarini National Institute of Standards and Technology, 100 Bureau Drive, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA;
[email protected] Sergey N. Rashkeev Center for Advanced Modeling and Simulation, Idaho National Laboratory, P.O. Box 1625, Idaho Falls, ID 83415, USA Betsy M. Rice U. S. Army Research Laboratory, AMSRL-WM-BD (Bldg. 4600), Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005, USA;
[email protected] xi
xii
Contributors
Thomas D. Sewell Theoretical Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545, USA, Now at: Department of Chemistry, University of Missouri-Columbia, Columbia, MO 65211, USA Lewis L. Stevens Dynamic and Energetic Materials Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87544, USA Ivan A. Trojan Max Planck Institute for Chemistry, Postfach 3060, 55020 Mainz, Germany
Chapter 1
Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques Gasper J. Piermarini
1.1 Introduction It has often been said that scientific advances are made either in a dramatic and revolutionary way, or, as in the case of the diamond anvil cell (DAC), in a slow and evolutionary manner over a period of several years. For more than 2 decades, commencing in 1958, the DAC developed stepwise from a rather crude qualitative instrument to the sophisticated quantitative research tool it is today, capable of routinely producing sustained static pressures in the multi-megabar range and readily adaptable to numerous scientific measurement techniques because of its optical accessibility, miniature size, and portability. During the last several decades the amount and quality of research with DACs has increased enormously with new instrument modifications, new applications, and experimental results being reported in literature frequently. In fact, the DAC now has become the premier instrument of choice for conducting experiments of all kinds and in all disciplines that utilize static high pressure and temperature variables. Indeed, for static high pressure/temperature studies on energetic materials, the DAC has become a widely used indispensable tool. Never in my thoughts did I ever expect this simple, yet elegant, device to become so widely used and accepted throughout the world for conducting scientific research in many diverse disciplines. Because of its enormous popularity in the scientific community, and also because I have perceived that many scientists who use the instrument today are unaware of its origin, probably because so many different modifications of the instrument have been made and are currently in use, I think it is appropriate to narrate the history behind the invention of the DAC in the introductory chapter of this book. The DAC, as we know it today, was invented at the National Bureau of Standards (NBS), renamed the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in 1986. Its development illustrates a process of invention almost unique in the scientific research community. I believe it will be of noteworthy value to present in detail the motivations behind this invention. I will also present first simple and later S.M. Peiris, G.J. Piermarini (eds.), Static Compression of Energetic Materials, Shock Wave and High Pressure Phenomena, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2008
1
2
G.J. Piermarini
more refined experimental techniques and results permitting the reader to appreciate and assess the merits of research on energetic materials with the DAC. In the process, I will discuss four fundamental topics: (1) an in-depth history of how and why the DAC was invented; (2) descriptions of five basic generic models of the DAC and their characteristic merits and disadvantages in various research applications; (3) the development of the ruby fluorescence method at NBS to measure sample pressures in the DAC; (4) the development of pressure-transmitting media for specific applications; and (5) the development of high- and low-temperature capability. I will follow with descriptions of several innovative DAC applications, the result of research at NIST and the Naval Surface Warfare Center (NSWC, White Oak), which are especially useful in the study of energetic materials. They are: (1) optical polarizing microscopy for detecting birefringence changes in single crystals resulting from pressure-induced polymorphism and measuring phase transition pressures; (2) Fourier transform infrared absorption (FTIR) spectroscopy for detecting phase transformations and obtaining kinetic data on thermal decomposition reactions at high pressures; and (3) x-ray diffraction techniques, including single crystal, powder, and energy dispersive methods for confirming the existence of pressure-induced polymorphism and identifying the new phases crystallographically. Experimental results obtained with the aid of these techniques will be presented on the thermal decomposition kinetics, chemical reactivity, and phase behavior of RDX and nitromethane (NM).
1.2 Invention The invention of the original DAC (lever-arm type with 180◦ optical transmission window) took place in the late 1950s at the NBS in Washington, DC [1]. At that time I was a young budding scientist attached to the Constitution and Microstructure Section (Howard F. McMurdie, Section Chief), where the DAC was invented and later developed into a sophisticated scientific research instrument. My own research activity at that time was unrelated to high-pressure work. I was fulfilling my 2-year military obligation (1956–1958) in the US Army and was assigned to Aaron S. Posner’s crystallography laboratory to develop a rapid x-ray fluorescence technique for quantitative analysis of dental amalgams used by the military services. Because my office and measurement apparatus were near the high-pressure laboratory, I was able to develop close relationships with the individuals involved in the DAC’s development, so I did, indeed, witness on a daily basis the process of invention. It was not until 1961, about 2 years after the first paper describing the pioneering work on the DAC was published, that I began my own collaboration with C. E. Weir on the development of a modified (hydraulically loaded) version of the lever-arm type DAC for x-ray powder diffraction measurements [2]. As I reflect on it now, it was the coincidental meeting of four scientists, C. E. Weir, A. Van Valkenburg, E. R. Lippincott, and E. N. Bunting (Fig. 1.1), each with his own technical and scientific expertise, which provided the impetus
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
3
Fig. 1.1 The four scientists associated with the invention of the Diamond Anvil Pressure Cell at the National Bureau Standards, Washington, DC, in 1957. From the left: Charles Edward Weir, 1911– 1987; Alvin Van Valkenburg, 1913–1991; Ellis Ridgeway Lippincott, 1920–1974; Elmer Newman Bunting, 1892–1966 [NIST Archives]
necessary for the invention of the DAC. Interestingly enough, the activity leading up to the invention had not been officially defined or even recognized in its early stages. Rather, it was the innate intuition of these four scientists which permitted them to recognize a fertile area of high-pressure research, and moreover, each one knew how he could contribute to its realization. It was not planned that way, for, in the beginning, there was little or no collaboration or even interaction among these individuals. In the early to mid-1950s, Weir, a chemist by training, was assigned to the Leather Section, studying the physical properties of leather and how they affected wear. For example, he used the pressure variable to measure porosity in leather by Hg intrusion using a piston/cylinder hydraulic press [3–5]. He initiated these studies because porosity in leather was known qualitatively to affect wear. Weir conducted these experiments in an attempt to quantify that affect. Apparently Weir was so efficient and productive in performing his official tasks, that he had additional time during which he could pursue his own personal research interests, discretionary research which most of us did at NBS and still do today at NIST. In the 1950s, it was common for NBS scientists to nurture unofficial discretionary research of personal interest provided it did not interfere with performing official duties, and, furthermore, was related to them in a somewhat general way. Weir adapted his piston/cylinder press used for the leather porosity measurements to measure the compressibility of many solids, including borosilicate glasses, teflon, natural and synthetic rubbers as well as to study other phenomena such as pressure-induced polymorphism (Fig. 1.2). He published the results of his piston-displacement measurements in the archival scientific literature, some of which were industrially important and appeared in print for the first time [6–9]. As a result of his early high pressure work, Weir received the Department of Commerce Silver Medal for his outstanding accomplishments. While performing his studies, Weir developed an intense interest and appreciation for the effect of pressure on the properties and structure of materials. In fact, he expressed to the
4
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.2 Weir (left) explains to G. Piermarini the details of the encapsulation method for samples used in his early award-winning work with the hydraulic press located in the background (c.1968) [W. P. Richardson, NIST Photo Lab]
management his desire to pursue this kind of research, rather than continue his work on leather. In recognition of his accomplishments, Weir was able to continue his high-pressure work in McMurdie’s Section. In the course of discussing his results with other NBS scientists, Weir met Van Valkenburg (known as Van by his colleagues), and many discussions related to high-pressure studies took place between them. In 1958, Allen Astin, the Director of NBS, announced that several research areas in high pressure would be emphasized in current and new NBS programs. Three activities relevant to DAC were in that announcement: (1) to develop new methods and technologies to achieve high pressures, (2) to develop measurement techniques for the study of the structure and properties of materials at high pressure, and (3) to establish a pressure scale to measure them [10]. Thus, in 1959 work on the development of the DAC became an official NBS program. In the early to mid-1950s, Van, also working in McMurdie’s Section, was engaged officially in crystal synthesis by hydrothermal techniques, particularly in the re-crystallization of mica by the Morey bomb method. At that time mica was classified as a strategic material because it was universally used as an insulator in vacuum tubes. Solid state devices were not in commercial use in the mid-1950s. Van was a mineralogist by training and had an intense appreciation for the effect of pressure on the physics and chemistry of materials. Like Weir, Van had a discretionary research activity, which he pursued in his spare time. He hoped to develop a high temperature–high pressure method for the synthesis of diamond, which, incidentally, he was never able to achieve. Enthusiasm for this endeavor stemmed from the fact that a few years earlier the General Electric Company had announced
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
5
Fig. 1.3 Van Valkenburg (ca 1957) adjusting the parameters on his high-temperature furnace used for the synthesis, crystallization and reconstitution of mica [W. P. Richardson, NIST Photo Lab]
the first successful production of synthetic diamond by a high temperature–high pressure method – a technological achievement prominent on the world scientific scene at that time. Van used a piston/cylinder press in combination with a hightemperature NBS-type self-aligning tetrahedral anvil device for his diamond synthesis studies [11] (Fig. 1.3). As I recall, Weir expressed a strong desire to join Van so they could collaborate in this newly emerging area of high-pressure research. With the introduction of solid state devices, mica was no longer classified a strategic material and Van’s research project was terminated. Also, the fact that P. W. Bridgman had been awarded the Nobel Prize for his work in high-pressure physics a few years earlier may have influenced their motivation. Weir convinced McMurdie that his proposed move to join Van would be beneficial for both of them and for the section. So, in 1957 Weir and Van were working together on high-pressure phenomena in the same laboratory room. As it turned out, Bunting, also in McMurdie’s section, was working in that same large laboratory room on the second floor of the Industrial Building on the NBS site on Van Ness Street in Northwest Washington, DC (now demolished and replaced by the University of the District of Columbia) (Fig. 1.4). Bunting, Weir, and Van collaborated with Professor Lippincott, a guest scientist and consultant from the University of Maryland, on the measurement of infrared absorption spectra of
6
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.4 Bunting’s office was in the high-temperature furnace laboratory where there was also a Beckman infrared (IR) spectrophotometer that he used to study polymorphs of silica and germania in collaboration with Lippincott. Bunting is shown sitting at his desk facing the spectrophotometer located behind Van’s high-temperature furnace on the left (c.1959) [G. J. Piermarini, NBS]
inorganic materials. Lippincott’s expertise was in absorption spectroscopy, particularly in the infrared (IR) region, and they published results of their collaborative work on temperature-induced polymorphism in silica and germania [12]. As I recall, Earl Schoonover, Chief of the Mineral Products Division at the time, promoted collaborations with outside organizations such as local universities, e.g., the University of Maryland and other government agencies to assist the NBS scientific staff in developing new research areas to investigate. These circumstances placed all four scientists in the same room where they performed their own independent research work and also collaborated with Lippincott on infrared spectroscopy studies. These conditions also permitted them to interact with each other daily, exchanging ideas of common scientific interest. In the relatively free laboratory environment of the post-Sputnik era, funds for research were not lacking. In fact, I recall one high-level manager, Earl Schoonover, Chief of the Mineral Products Division, speaking to a bench scientist, “Don’t worry about where the funds are coming from, just do good science.” In this kind of environment, which is rare today, it was not long before one of these four individuals came up with the notion that a major scientific breakthrough could be achieved in the area of high-pressure research by developing a miniature high-pressure device with 180◦ optical transmission, permitting the measurement of infrared absorption spectra of materials under high pressure. This inspiration came about because of Lippincott’s spectroscopy background. During their many conversations, he frequently brought the subject up and commented that such a device would be an effective tool for probing the behavior of atomic forces in matter. He argued that unlike temperature, which cannot exceed the limits imposed by the thermal stability of the solid under study and the absolute zero of temperature, the only limitation imposed by the use of pressure is the failure or limit of the pressure-producing vessel itself. Lippincott was excited over the possibility of being able to measure and interpret the effects
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
7
of pressure on infrared spectra, something which had not been done before. If they succeeded in doing this, he said, it would be a major breakthrough in the areas of IR spectroscopy and high-pressure research. That was enough to convince all four of them. They decided to undertake the development of such a device. However, unlike prior discretionary activity, usually carried out individually, this one would be a combined effort of these four scientists and it would take over a year of their discretionary time to accomplish the goal. It is important to note that their main impetus was not the development of a pressure scale, although knowledge of the pressure was important to them, but the measurement of the infrared spectra of solids at high pressures as a means of studying interatomic forces and bonding. This spectroscopic technique placed an immediate and immense constraint on their high-pressure apparatus, for whatever they designed and fabricated had to be small enough to fit into the sample chamber of an IR unit and also had to be transparent to infrared radiation. Their first attempt to do this failed miserably. It was based on a design first published in 1957 [13], in which the principle of pressing a powder in a cylinder by inserting two opposed pistons in the cylinder and forcing them together to compress the sample between them was used. A large single-crystal diamond was employed with a cylindrical hole to contain the sample for x-ray diffraction measurements. For infrared absorption measurements, Van was able to obtain a 7 1/2 carat (1 metric carat = 200 mg) single-crystal Type II (low IR absorption properties) diamond from the Smithsonian Institution free of charge. The justification for the gratis transfer was that the rough stone would be used specifically for research purposes at the NBS and would very likely be destroyed in the process of experimentation. A cylindrical hole (0.4 mm) was bored through the diamond perpendicular to two parallel polished faces. Tight-fitting drill rods were inserted to compress the powdered sample within the cylinder. After a few excursions to elevated pressures by applying a load to the ends of the drill rods using a simple clamp device hand-made by Weir, the diamond developed radial fissures around the hole which increased with subsequent load applications as shown in Fig. 1.5. The diamond eventually split into pieces with subsequent applications of load because axial alignment of the drill rods was difficult to maintain, leading to further crack propagation and ultimate splitting. This development quickly put an end to the experiment and also any future experiments of this kind because no one or no organization was going to donate a diamond of that size again even for the benefit of scientific research. Thus, they had to come up with a fundamentally new approach. After much discussion and deliberation, they finally agreed on a very simple device suggested by Weir which made use of the principle of Bridgman-opposed anvils [14, 15]. Percy W. Bridgman, a Nobel Laureate and the father of high-pressure research, was a pioneer in the pressing of materials between two loaded flat-faced anvils (Fig. 1.6). As noted earlier, Weir had been studying the effect of pressure on leather for several years and had acquired a wealth of knowledge in the experimental techniques employed by researchers in the field. He concluded that opposed anvils, transparent to infrared radiation, would be the simplest approach, especially because they would have to make the device themselves during their spare time. All agreed to proceed in that way.
8
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.5 This photo depicts the radial cracks that develop around the bored hole through the diamond. These cracks increase in size as the load on the pistons increases ultimately leading to complete fracture of the diamond into several pieces [13]
F
Fig. 1.6 This schematic depicts the fundamental concept of Bridgman-opposed anvils. A load (F) forces two opposed anvils (usually a very hard material like WC) together with the sample squeezed in the small area between them. The load is generated usually by utilizing a hydraulic press. For a given load, the smaller the anvil area, the greater the pressure generated on the sample
OPPOSED ANVILS
SAMPLE
F
The NBS scientists also knew that diamond, because of its extreme hardness, high compressive strength, and IR transmission properties, was the obvious material to use for the anvils. For optimum IR transmission, particularly in the fingerprint region for the study of interatomic forces, they would have to obtain rare Type II diamonds or at least those possessing mainly Type II character. Most diamonds exhibit gradations between Types I and II properties [16]. Rare Type II diamonds could be used for infrared microspectroscopy studies because they could withstand the loads necessary to generate high pressures. Also, by utilizing a miniature opposed-anvil arrangement, only microgram quantities of sample are required, so a very small portable apparatus for generating load was all that was needed. But at this stage, they had no idea how or where to obtain Type II diamonds. The work was still discretionary and no supporting funds were available.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
9
McMurdie certainly would not agree to their purchase, especially if the diamonds were going to be squeezed together and very likely crushed in the process, ending up like their earlier experience with the 71/2 carat stone. Whatever they were going to do had to be done on their own initiative and without official support. Van, whose mineralogy background was critical at this stage, came up with a wonderful solution. Through his efforts, he succeeded in obtaining 1,100 brilliant-cut gem diamonds from the General Services Administration (GSA), which maintained a large accumulation of contraband diamonds confiscated by the US Customs Service from smugglers attempting to enter the country with them illegally. Unlike today, where confiscated diamonds are periodically auctioned off to the general public by the GSA, in 1957 disposing the stones by public sale was not permitted and the contraband gems accumulated in the GSA coffers and remained there indefinitely. With the assistance of McMurdie, who provided an NBS document declaring that these diamonds would be used specifically in high-pressure experiments at the NBS and would very likely be destroyed in the process of experimentation, the GSA agreed to transfer to NBS about 1,100 brilliant-cut gems, all roughly one third of a carat in weight. I do believe that without the availability of these cost-free gems, the effort to build this high-pressure instrument would have been seriously curtailed, if not entirely terminated. In any case, the venture would not have proceeded easily beyond this point without the availability of these gratis gems. Bunting and Van proceeded to measure the IR transmission and other properties of the 1,100 gems and found that only 55 of them were primarily of Type II character and suitable as anvils for IR transmission experiments [16] (Fig. 1.7, Fig. 1.8). They now had the proper diamonds, but they still had to shape them into anvils and then fabricate the mechanism for applying load to them. Both procedures had to be simple because Weir was going to use only an old South Bend♦ lathe, a drill press, a hack saw, files, an old high-speed diamond wheel obtained from surplus, and any other equipment readily available to him in his laboratory to do all this. These simple tools dictated how the instrument was going to be designed and fabricated. Thus, what was initially thought to be a great hindrance turned out, in the end, to be a great boon, because these simple fabrication tools and the constraints imposed by the infrared apparatus, determined the ultimate simplicity in the design of the device.
Transmission
2 %100
3
4
Wavelength 6 7
5
8
9 10
μ 12 14 16
B 50 A
0 5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000 1,800 1,600 1,400 1,200 1,000 Wavenumber
800
600 cm−1
Fig. 1.7 A. Infrared spectrum of typical type-II diamonds (2–4 mm thick). B. Infrared spectrum of a thin type-II diamond (1 mm thick) [20, 22]
10
G.J. Piermarini
Transmission
2 %100
3
4
5
Wavelength 6
7
8
9 10
μ 12 14 16
50
−0 5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000 1,800 1,600 1,400 1,200 1,000 800 Wavenumber
600 cm−1
Fig. 1.8 Infrared spectrum of a typical type I diamond (2–4 mm thick) [20, 22]
The actual construction of the first DAC was literally left in the hands of Weir, who had a special proclivity for design and fabrication and excelled at it. Weir preferred to do things himself and rarely involved the Shops Division, even when carrying out his official work. He often was heard to say, “I don’t have time to wait for this job to get done because it may take a week or so, and, furthermore, I will have to make a careful drawing of the object I need made to give to the Shops. I think I’ll just do it myself right now and be over with it.” And he usually did, as was the case with the DAC. Because readymade anvils had not been obtained, the Type II brilliant-cut gem stones, which had been selected by Van and Bunting, had to be modified into anvils. The simplest thing to do was to grind down the tip or culet of the brilliant-cut stone until a small flat area about 0.5 mm2 was formed. Weir did this himself on the selected type II gems by grinding down the culets on a high-speed grinding wheel impregnated with diamond grit with a home-made jig to keep the ground flat parallel to the table of the gem. Several stones, often as many as ten, were mounted in the jig simultaneously, held firmly in place with low-melting solder. This procedure permitted several anvils to be made concurrently. Although each scientist had input into the overall design of the clamping device, the final approval was left up to Weir because he was going to have to fabricate it using the equipment he had available to him. Once they all agreed on the lever-arm design, which has remained essentially the same even to today, Weir proceeded to fabricate the device by himself. He used tools only available to him in the laboratory, i.e., an old South Bend lathe with sloppy, noisy bearings as I recall, an electric drill press, a hack saw, and whatever else was handy to get the job done. Finally, after many weeks of trials and failures, the final instrument was created (Fig. 1.11). It was used successfully to demonstrate for the first time that pressure shifts and other pressure effects on the infrared absorption spectra of materials could be observed and measured [1]. The device, a crude, homemade instrument, became the prototype for all succeeding designs of the opposed diamond anvil high-pressure cell with 180◦ optical transmission, initiating a new era for high-pressure research. The design of the original instrument is shown in schematic cross section in Fig. 1.9 and Fig. 1.10.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
11
Fig. 1.9 This is a schematic diagram of the original leverarm type DAC fabricated by C. E. Weir in 1957/58. The simplicity in the design is clearly demonstrated. In operation, rotation of the screw G compresses the spring F, which transmits a force through the lever arms to E. The opposed pistons B, containing the diamond anvils A, are fixed in position in the massive block C by the entablature ring D. Thus the diamonds are squeezed together under an applied load. Note that the thickness of the block C is only 1 inch, permitting the device to be positioned in the focusing mirrors of the IR instrument as shown in Fig. 1.10 below [20, 22]
Fig. 1.10 The IR beam path is designated by the letters A through H. The pressure cell is designated by the letter D. B is a convex mirror. C and E are concave focusing mirrors. F and G are planar reflecting mirrors [20]
In what appears to be a case of simultaneous discovery, because to my knowledge neither group was aware of the other’s work until just before publication, a similar device was developed at the University of Chicago (UC) for x-ray powder diffraction measurements at high pressures [17, 18]. Like the NBS DAC, this instrument
12
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.11 This photograph shows the original instrument, homemade by C. E. Weir. On close inspection its crude fabrication is readily apparent. Because of its importance in the field of highpressure research, this instrument, small enough to fit in the palm of one’s hand and capable of producing very high pressures, is on display today in the NIST Museum at Gaithersburg, MD [NIST Archives]
Sample
Diamond Cones
X–Ray Beam
Fig. 1.12 The University of Chicago instrument was designed to replace the sample mount of a standard 2θ scan x-ray diffractometer. The entablatures for the two diamond cones were Carbaloy inserts in steel, thus precluding the possibility of 180◦ transmission
made use of two opposed diamonds in a Bridgman flat-face anvil arrangement, but the fundamental difference between the two instruments is in the direction of the incident and reflected x-ray beams. Unlike the NBS design, which has 180◦ transmission so that the x-ray beam enters one anvil and exits through the other anvil, in the UC device the x-ray beam enters and exits the same anvil as shown in the Fig. 1.12. With official NBS funding more refined pressure cells (Fig. 1.13) were built in the NBS fabrication shops specifically for IR absorption studies which were performed on many materials of interest and published in the scientific literature over the next several years [19–23]. This instrument with 180◦ optical transmission was used for infrared absorption measurements on powders squeezed between the two opposed diamond anvils. Some of the very first materials studied were NaNO3 , KNO3 , AgNO3 , ferrocene, ice, and CaCO3. . These studies demonstrated for the first time that pressuredependent shifts in the IR absorption bands could be measured, in addition to the observation of large changes in spectra as a consequence of pressure-induced phase transformations [19–22].
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
13 H
SCALE 1 INCH
SIDE VIEW
G
D F
H
FRONT VIEW I
C
B
CROSS-SECTION OF ANVIL ASSEMBLY
E
D
F
A
Fig. 1.13 A schematic view of the refined pressure cell is shown on the right. Critical components are identified as follows: A – the diamond anvils, B – the supporting steel entablatures, C – steel guiding cylinder, D – aluminum cell body, E – piston, F – steel pressure plate, G – tappet spring, H – screw knob, I – circular cavity for insertion of a resistance coil furnace. Except for the Al cell body and the diamond anvils, all other components were fabricated from a stainless steel. Two push/pull screws, 120◦ apart, located in each piston (E), provided a mechanism for tilting the keyed supporting steel entablatures (B) permitting parallel alignment of the diamond anvil faces. In a later similar design, the keyed entablature feature was removed and only one piston was fitted with these screws because alignment could be achieved by a combination of a tilt of one anvil and a rotation of the other [Courtesy of High Pressure Diamond Optics, Inc. Tucson, AZ 85719]
Van was born in Schenectady, NY in 1913, earned a B.S. degree in geology from Union College in 1936, and, 2 years later, an M.S. degree in mineralogy and petrology from the University of Colorado. During World War II, he supervised degaussing ships at the Charlestown Navy Yard in Boston, MA. He joined NBS in 1945
14
G.J. Piermarini
and left in 1964 to become a Program Director in Geochemistry at the National Science Foundation. Later he became Chief of University Relations at the Bureau of Mines until his retirement in 1980. All the while, Van continued to work with the DAC at the Geophysical Laboratory until 1980. Van continued to be associated with the DAC in the years after he departed NBS through High Pressure Diamond Optics (HPDO), a company which manufactures and sells DACs to researchers in the high-pressure community. HPDO originally was a partnership consisting of Weir, Lippincott, and Van Valkenburg, with Van being the active partner and Weir and Lippincott silent partners. Later, however, Van became the sole owner of the company. Over the years, Van provided many DAC instruments to the high-pressure community through the vehicle of HPDO. This too, had an important impact in the field of high pressure for it made the DAC readily available to many scientists who would otherwise have had to design and fabricate the instrument in their own laboratories. Many would have chosen not to do so. In retirement, Van moved to Tucson, AZ, where he continued to manufacture and sell DACs and anvils with his son Eric. Van passed away in 1991. His son Eric continues to operate HPDO [23]. Weir retired from NBS in 1970 after the development and refinement of the highpressure single-crystal x-ray diffraction technique, and moved to San Luis Obispo, CA. He was born in Washington, DC in 1911, the son of a government employee. He attended Dunbar High School, graduating at the head of his class. In 1929 he was one of four young men appointed to the US Naval Academy, Annapolis, by Oscar De Priest, representative in Congress from Chicago. However, even though he passed the mental examination, he was not accepted to the Academy because of poor vision [24]. Weir went on to study chemistry at the University of Chicago and earned a B.S. degree in 1932, an M.S. degree in physical chemistry from Howard University in 1934 and taught there until 1937, when he entered the California Institute of Technology (CalTech) to study for the Ph.D. in physics. Owing to illness he terminated his studies in 1940 and joined NBS in 1943, where he remained until his retirement after an outstanding and prolific scientific career. Weir passed away in 1987 [25]. Bunting retired from NBS in 1962 after a long and productive career (37 years) at NBS. He was born in Chicago in 1892. He was one of the few scientists during those early years that had a doctorate degree (from UC in physics, mathematics, and chemistry, granted in 1918). He passed away in 1966 [26]. Lippincott was born in Philadelphia in 1920 and attended Earlham College in Richman, IN. He earned a doctorate from Johns Hopkins University in 1947. In 1974, Lippincott passed away at an early age (54 years) from Hodgkin’s disease [27].
1.3 Introduction of the Gasket Technique In the years immediately following the pioneering work on the development of the DAC, Van made an extremely valuable contribution to DAC technology in 1962 [28, 29]. He had the clever idea of encapsulating pure liquid samples in the DAC by using a thin metal gasket (Fig. 1.14) containing a very small hole placed between the flat surfaces of the opposed anvils. The hole was filled with liquid and
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
15
DIAMOND ANVIL
INCONEL
FOIL
GASKET HOLE FOR LIQUID DIAMOND ANVIL
Fig. 1.14 This schematic diagram shows a thin metal foil (gasket) separating the two diamond anvils. The foil is typically an Inconel alloy about 2–3 mm thick, and contains a hole approximately 0.2–0.3 mm in diameter. Note that the face of the lower anvil has less area than the face of the upper anvil, permitting it to indent the foil more effectively, thereby reducing the volume of the hole and thus increasing the pressure on the confined liquid
the anvils were squeezed together while observing the liquid with the aid of a polarizing light microscope. Prior to 1962, only powders were pressed between the diamond anvils and were studied mainly by IR absorption spectroscopy and x-ray powder-diffraction methods. In his initial experiment, Van filled the cavity with water, quickly assembled the pressure cell and then applied a force to the anvils while observing the confined water in the gasket hole with the aid of a polarizing microscope. The metal foil thinned down reducing the volume of the hole and thus the confined water also, thereby increasing the pressure. At about 0.98 GPa, he found that the water crystallized to ice VI. He observed for the first time the crystallization of water at room temperature (RT) to solid ice VI. What he saw is shown in Fig. 1.15. Van was able to observe, for the first time, crystallization and polymorphism in water as the pressure was increased at room temperature [28] (Fig. 1.16). Furthermore, by employing this technique on a single crystal of calcite and using glycerine as the pressure-transmitting medium, Van was able to observe two pressure-induced polymorphic transformations in calcite when polarized light was used to illuminate the crystal [29]. The original work on calcite was done soon after the gasket technique was developed, but the results of that study were not published until 1970, long after Van had left NBS in 1964. The development of the gasket technique was very important for it permitted hydrostatic pressure environments to be achieved thereby laying the foundation for quantitative measurements at high pressures because of the reduction and even elimination of pressure gradients in some liquids. One of the early applications derived from this gasket technique was high-pressure single-crystal x-ray diffraction. In fact, it was Van’s gasket technique and his observations of the transformations in calcite in glycerine that led Weir, Stanley Block,
16
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.15 These are amorphous shapes or globules of crystalline ice VI in equilibrium with water at approximately 0.98 GPa at RT as viewed through the DAC with the aid of a polarizing light microscope. This photograph is the original one that Van took when he saw for the first time ice VI in equilibrium with water at room temperature. To my knowledge, no one had ever seen this before
Fig. 1.16 A single crystal of ice VI was grown from one of the globular crystals shown in Fig. 1.15. The procedure Van followed was to melt all but one of these faceless crystals by carefully warming the cell slightly above RT and then allowing the temperature to return to ambient. This procedure was done at approximately 0.98 GPa, the freezing pressure of ice VI at RT
and me in 1964 to begin a long collaboration, this time with NBS support, resulting in the development of the high-pressure single-crystal x-ray diffraction technique utilizing the precession camera [30]. By 1971, the DAC had undergone several stages of refinement both at NBS and other laboratories and also was adapted to other measurement techniques by several laboratories in the US and abroad. However, the DAC was still not fully appreciated by many scientists including those in the NBS management because there was no rapid, convenient, and accurate method available to measure the sample pressure. At that time pressures were generally determined by a tedious and time-consuming x-ray diffraction method measuring the volume compression of NaCl based on an equation of state. The technique often required as much as 15 h to make one pressure measurement. Thus, the DAC’s acceptance as a tool for high-pressure research was limited and was used primarily in laboratories engaged in research of geological interest where very high pressures were desired, but high accuracy at these very high pressures was not considered a serious issue at the time.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
17
1.4 Application to X-Ray Diffraction Techniques The NBS opposed-anvil DAC became the prototype for all subsequent diamond cells with 180◦ optical transmission. While the first application of the DAC was in IR spectroscopy, we proceeded to investigate the possibility of applying the instrument to x-ray powder diffraction because we were part of the Crystallography Group. At the conclusion of my military service obligation, I joined the Constitution and Microstructure Section, headed by H. F. McMurdie. A year after joining that Section, Weir and I initiated a collaboration on applying the DAC to x-ray powder diffraction. In 1962 we published a description of a hydraulically loaded miniature x-ray powder diffraction high-pressure camera along with results demonstrating the usefulness of the technique [2] (Fig. 1.18). When it became obvious that single crystals could be grown in a DAC from liquids, the possibility of performing single-crystal x-ray diffraction experiments at high pressures was obvious to us. Weir and I had published several successful x-ray diffraction studies on powders at high pressures using the hydraulic pressure cell (Fig. 1.17). It was only natural for us to extend the technique to single crystals. In 1963, Stanley Block, head of the Crystallography Group, joined us in this endeavor. As before with the original pressure cell, Weir modified a Buerger-type
Fig. 1.17 A schematic diagram of the hydraulically loaded x-ray diffraction high-pressure camera. It demonstrated for the first time that useful powder patterns could be recorded on film from samples under pressure. The number of observed d spacings was limited, but often could be indexed according to a crystal system, thus yielding volume compression data. Also pressure-induced phase transformations could be detected. Components are identified in [2]
18
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.18 Two examples of phase transitions are shown in this figure. Opposite quadrants (La and CsF) of x-ray powder diffraction films demonstrate pressure-induced phase transformations, e.g., the hexagonal structure of α-La transforms to a face-centered cubic structure (fcc); CsF transition is from a NaCl-type-to-CsCl-type structure [31, 32]. These films were taken with the instrument shown in Fig. 1.19
Fig. 1.19 This is a photograph of the crudely modified Buerger-type precession camera that Weir built to accommodate the lever-arm type DAC to determine if meaningful x-ray diffraction patterns could be obtained from a single crystal under pressure. Be metal inserts were used to support the anvils because of the metal’s relatively high transmission properties for Ag Kα radiation [33]
precession camera to accommodate a lever-arm type pressure cell fitted with beryllium (Be) metal plates to support the diamond anvils. Beryllium was used because ˚ radiation and diffracted beams of its relative transparency to Ag Kα (λ = 0.5609 A) from the crystal could penetrate it without much loss in intensity (Fig. 1.19).
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
19
Fig. 1.20 This is one of the very first precession patterns (μ = 16◦ , Pd filtered Ag radiation) obtained of the hk0 level of ice VI at RT and 0.98 GPa. The heavy diagonal streaks are from the single-crystal diamonds and the rings are from the metal gasket. The very small spots in a regular geometric pattern arise from diffraction from the single crystal of ice VI. This photograph is one of the very first ever taken of a single crystal at RT and these high pressures. A detailed analysis of this film related to the structure of ice VI can be found in [34] Fig. 1.21 This is a typical 24 h exposure using for a zero-level photograph obtained from a bromine single crystal. Bromine was used for this analysis because of its relatively intense diffraction spots as shown in the photograph [35]
Because of the encouraging x-ray data obtained for ice VI (Fig. 1.20), a complex set of absorption and polarization corrections for the Be inserts and the crystal under precession motion were evaluated and tested on a single crystal of Br2 whose structure was known (Fig. 1.21). The results of the analytical procedure showed a dramatic improvement in intensities and that a structure factor (R-Factor) as low as 9.1% was possible when these corrections were applied [35]. Utilizing these absorption corrections, the first structure determination ever done on an unknown single crystal by this DAC technique was accomplished on a high-pressure form of benzene, benzene II [36]. At a pressure of about 2.5 GPa and RT, benzene II was found to crystallize in the monoclinic system (space group P21 /c; Fig. 1.22). The
20
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.22 A single crystal of benzene II in equilibrium with liquid at about 310◦ C and 3 GPa, showing well-defined crystal morphology. This crystal was slowly grown to fill the gasket cavity by gradually reducing the temperature to RT. A crystal such as this one was used to study the structure of benzene II [36]
Table 1.1 A comparison of crystal data for benzene I and benzene II. The numbers in parentheses are standard deviations on the reported values in units of the last place, obtained from least-squares refinement from 20 experimental values of 2θ . The increase in density (ρc ) for benzene II illustrates the effect of 2.5 GPa [36] BENZENE I (21◦ C, 0.07 GPa) a = 7.17 b = 9.28 c = 6.65 Space group Pbca Z=4 ρc = 1.18 g cm−3
BENZENE II (21◦ C, 2.5 GPa) ˚ a = 5.417(5) A b = 5.376(19) c = 7.532(7) β = 110.00(8)◦ Space group p21 /c Z=2 ρc = 1.258 g cm−3
structure was solved by generating all possible molecular packing configurations and calculating structure factors, reliability factors, and packing energies for each configuration. The procedure produced a unique solution for the molecular packing of benzene II, yielding a conventional reliability index (R factor) of 7.6% based on 19 unique reflections. Later, the method was used in a similar approach to determine the crystal structure of an unknown high-pressure form of carbon tetrachloride (CCl4 -III). The space group was found to be P21 /c with four molecules per unit cell [37]. The crystal data on benzene are listed in Table 1.1 In the intervening years between 1964 and 1968 refinements to the DAC and the precession camera were made to facilitate the operation of the high-pressure single-crystal x-ray diffraction technique. A new DAC was designed and fabricated
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
21
almost entirely of Be metal except for high-strength components needed to support the required loads, e.g., the load-generating screw, the tappet spring, and the spring pressure plate [38]. Also a Buerger-type precession camera, designed to accommodate the Be DAC, was built in the NBS fabrication shop (Fig. 1.23). With this improved instrumentation crystal data on high-pressure phases of benzene, carbon disulfide, bromine, carbon tetrachloride, and potassium nitrate were obtained [39]. In these experiments, single crystals were grown at elevated pressures either from the liquid, e.g., C6 H6 -I, CS2 , CCl4 -I, CCl4 -II, CCl4 -III, or from the solid, e.g., KNO3 –III and KNO3 -IV(?). Results are shown in Table 1.2 With the publication of our successes utilizing the DAC in single-crystal x-ray diffraction at high pressures, military research laboratories such as the Explosives
Fig. 1.23 The redesigned Be DAC and precession camera are shown here mounted on an x-ray unit ready for operation Table 1.2 From single-crystal x-ray diffraction data obtained from high-pressure phases at room temperature, unit cell and space group data are listed. All unit cell dimensions are given in ˚ with estimated uncertainties of ±2 in the last decimal place given and uncertainties angstroms (A) of ±0.5◦ in angles C6 H6 I–orthorhombic, a = 7.17, b = 9.28, c = 6.65, bca, CS2 –orthorhombic, a = 6.16, b = 5.38, c = 8.53,Cmca, Br2 –orthorhombic, a = 8.54, b = 6.75, c = 8.63,Cmca, CCl4 , II–rhombohedral, a = 14.27, α = 90◦ , CCl4 , II–monoclinic, a = 22.10, b = 11.05, c = 25.0, β = 114◦ , Ca orC2/c, CCl4 , III–orthorhombic, a = 11.16, b = 14.32, c = 5.74,C2221 , KNO3 , III–rhombohedral, a = 4.31, α = 78◦ 54, KNO3 , IV(?)–orthorhombic, a = 5.58, b = 7.52, c = P21 nb or Pmnb.
22
G.J. Piermarini
Laboratory, Picatinny Arsenal, Dover, NJ, and The Army Materials Technology Laboratory, Watertown, MA asked us if we could investigate the feasibility of carrying out such studies on energetic materials because compression data as well as pressure-induced phase transformations and structures of high-pressure phases were literally nonexistent on explosive materials at that time and were highly desired. The reason for the paucity of this data was that safe experimental techniques to study the behavior of explosives at high pressures were unavailable until we introduced this new DAC technique. Until the request from military laboratories came, we had no intention of studying energetic materials in the DAC. It was only because of the interest of these military laboratories that we got involved in this activity. Scientists in those laboratories recognized before we did the usefulness of the DAC in studying explosives under pressure. They noted that because of the relatively small amount of material required for study, the danger of explosion is minimal and often even nonexistent. So, in 1969 we initiated single-crystal studies for Picatinny Arsenal to determine if we could measure the compressibility of several single-crystal azides of military interest, e.g., Pb(N3 )2 , Ba(N3 )2 , KN3 , TlN3 , and NaN3 . For these studies, the measurements had to be made in a chemically inert hydrostatic pressure environment to preserve the single-crystal character of the sample. Nonhydrostatic stresses in the pressure environment would produce cracks and other kinds of defects in the crystal, destroying its single-crystal character. In addition to the chemically inert, hydrostatic-pressure-transmitting medium requirements, the pressure on the sample had to be known accurately to obtain meaningful compression measurements. We developed a novel methodology for solving these problems simultaneously. We used accurately known RT freezing pressures of n-hexane (10395 bar) and ethanol (22210 bar) known to be chemically inert to the azide crystals studied. Figure 1.24 shows in detail the procedure followed to solve these issues [40].
Fig. 1.24 This is a single crystal of Pb (N3 )2 at approximately 2.2 GPa and RT. The matrix surrounding the crystal is chemically inert liquid ethanol in equilibrium with multiple small crystals of ethanol floating in its liquid (upper right) [40]
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
23
This condition describes the freezing pressure of ethanol at RT, which is known from previously published results of measurements made by P. W. Bridgman. The single-crystal x-ray diffraction measurements were made under these conditions utilizing the Buerger-type precession camera. The RT freezing pressures of other chemically inert liquids were similarly used to obtain data at other pressures. In this way, compression, and therefore, compressibilites of several inorganic azides were determined for the first time because previously no one was eager to compress explosives in conventional presses where relatively large volumes were required. As illustrated in Tables 1.3 and 1.4, the compressibility of α- and β-lead azide, barium azide, potassium azide, sodium azide, and thallium azide were successfully determined by single-crystal x-ray diffraction techniques for the first time in a new application of the diamond anvil pressure cell. Because single-crystal data were obtained in this study, both anisotropic and volume compressibilities were able to be determined. A pressure-induced phase transformation was discovered for the first time in thallium azide at RT at a pressure between the freezing points of chloroform (5390 bar) and n-decane (2990 bar). Pressure–temperature observations of lead azide using a polarizing microscope with the DAC were carried out to 300◦ C and about 3 GPa. No phase transition was observed. In the overall study, it was determined that radiation damage to azide crystals under high pressures was reduced significantly compared with radiation damage observed at RT. However, a great
Table 1.3 Anisotropic and volume compression of six inorganic azides determined by singlecrystal x-ray diffraction measurements in a new application of the DAC [40] Substance
Crystal system
Pb(N3 )2
Orthorhombic
Pb(N3 )2
Monoclinic
Ba(N3 )2
Monoclinic
KN3
Tetragonal
TIN3
Tetragonal
NaN3
“Monoclinc”b
Presure a(10−8 cm) b(10−8 cm) c(10−8 cm) β(deg) V (10−24 cm3 ) (bar) 1 11.31 10 395 11.08(5)a 22 210 10.83(1) 1 18.46(8) 10 395 18.01(9) 1 5.435(4) 10 395 5.395(4) 22 210 5.375(9) 1 6.0727 10 395 6.034 22 210 5.992 1 6.196(8) 2 990 6.178(8) 1 6.630(2) 10 395 6.098
16.25 16.16(3) 16.14(1) 8.909(8) 8.774(8) 4.401(1) 4.345(3) 4.316(3)
3.640(2) 3.593
6.63 6.630(5) 6.601(1) 5.093(6) 5.065(5) 9.611(4) 9.553(6) 9.47(2) 7.144 6.828 6.638 7.376(7) 7.316(7) 5.299(2) 5.288
106.2(2) 105.9(2) 99.67(8) 99.8(2) 101.2(5)
111.5(5) 106.0
1218. 1187.(5) 1154.(2) 804.4(4) 770.(4) 226.2(2) 220.2(3) 215.4(6) 263.4 248.6 238.3 283.2(6) 279.9(2) 118.9(2) 111.3
a Numbers in parentheses represent standard deviations in the last significant figure shown resulting from a least-squares fitting process. Where standard deviations are not shown, either the parameters were obtained from the literature or there was insufficient data to do a meaningful least-squares refinement. b NaN assumed monoclinic at 9 bar and the parameters listed derived on that basis. 3
24
G.J. Piermarini
Table 1.4 Compressibilities of six inorganic azides (10−4 bar−1 ) [40] Substance Pb(N3 )2 (ortho) Pb(N3 )2 (mono) Ba(N3 )2 KN3 TIN3 NaN3
−a−1 0 (Δa/ΔP)
−b−1 0 (Δb/ΔP)
1.96a 1.91 2.34 0.71 0.50 0.60 0.59 0.97b 7.69
0.53 0.30 1.51 1.22 0.97
1.32
−c−1 0 (Δc/ΔP)
−V0−1 (ΔV /ΔP)
0.20 0.57 0.58 0.65 4.25 3.17 2.17b
2.44 2.36 4.12 2.53 2.15 5.41 4.30 4.63b 6.15
a Where
two values are given, the first refers to the interval 1 bar to 10,395 bar. The second, to the interval 1 bar to 22,210 bar. One value only refers to the interval 1bar to 10,395 bar. b These values refer to the interval 1bar to 2,990 bar.
disadvantage to the method is that pressure measurement is cumbersome and timeconsuming because the cell has to be reloaded each time a different pressure point is needed for a different liquid.
1.5 The Ruby Fluorescence Pressure Measurement Technique By 1971, the DAC had undergone several stages of refinement and had been adapted to other measurement techniques by NBS and other laboratories in the United States. It was used primarily for x-ray powder diffraction studies, optical polarizing microscopy, and IR absorption spectroscopy. At that time single-crystal x-ray measurements were not of interest because of the difficulty in measuring the sample pressure as discussed in our compression of azides measurements. As a consequence of this limitation, the DAC was not fully appreciated by many research scientists because there was no convenient and rapid method available for measuring the sample pressure. Pressures, determined by calculating force per unit area, were inaccurate and associated uncertainties imprecise because of the unknown distribution of force over the gasket and sample areas. This situation persisted for several years. Until 1971, pressures were either calculated (force per unit area) or measured from compression data (utilizing an equation of state, e.g., NaCl) obtained by x-ray powder diffraction measurements. But the former procedure, as already stated, was very inaccurate, and the latter was tedious and time-consuming, often requiring as many as 15 h of exposure time to produce a measurable diffraction pattern on film for one pressure determination. Thus, acceptance of the DAC by the scientific community as a tool in high-pressure research was somewhat limited. It was used in laboratories engaged in research of geological interest where very high pressures simulating the earth’s interior were desired, while a knowledge of the pressure was not yet of primary importance.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
25
In 1971, however, the situation changed dramatically. Stanley Block and I (Weir had retired from NBS and had moved to San Luis Obispo, CA in 1970) were under constant prodding by the management to develop a better method for measuring pressures in the DAC. The problem was discussed in the NBS cafeteria one day among John (Jack) B. Wachtman Jr., Chief of the Inorganic Materials Division, Stanley Block, Chief of the Crystallography Section, and Professor Dean Barnett, a Guest Scientist at NBS on sabbatical leave from Brigham Young University (BYU). (Dean had worked with large presses in his research at BYU and wanted to learn how to use the DAC.) While having lunch together, their conversation turned to the problem of measuring pressure in the DAC. During the conversation, Wachtman asked a pivotal question, “Have you considered fluorescence spectroscopy?” Among the many possible techniques we had already tested over the years, all were found to be unsuitable. However, we had never considered fluorescence spectroscopy, so they replied they would look into it. Encouraged by this meeting, Stanley Block, Dean Barnett, Richard Forman, and I undertook to measure the pressure-dependence of several fluorescing materials thought to be good candidates for a pressure sensor [41, 42]. Some of the materials investigated happened to be lying on the shelves in Forman’s spectroscopy laboratory, while others were provided by H. S. Parker and W. S. Brower of the Solid State Chemistry Section. Those materials included Al2 O3 (ruby), YAlO3 , YAG, MgO, and a few others. In our investigation, some were found to have observable pressure dependences, but ruby exhibited by far the most promising results as revealed in Table 1.5. The main fluorescence lines in ruby (the R1 and R2 doublet) were intense and sharp and both lines shifted appreciably toward the red end of the spectrum with increasing pressure indicating that ruby would be a sensitive pressure sensor compared to the other materials studied. With ruby in a gasketed DAC, pressures could be detected in situ using only a very small ruby crystal (only 1% of the available volume is needed because of ruby’s high R-lines fluorescent intensity). Furthermore, because ruby is chemically quite inert to most substances, including liquids, it is almost an ideal material for an internal pressure sensor and, after accurate calibration, would be useful as a secondary pressure standard. Moreover, the chemical inertness of the ruby makes it likely that experiments on many substances at temperatures above 200◦ C will not destroy the usefulness of this measurement technique. The very small ruby crystal can be present in the sample chamber to detect pressures without interfering with any other specimen under investigation in the chamber, including the pressure-transmitting liquid itself. From the significance of these observations, it became apparent that the pressure dependence of ruby needed to be calibrated immediately. In 1972, a preliminary calibration of the ruby R-lines pressure dependencies (Fig. 1.25) was accomplished by using the method employed previously for the measurement of the azide compressibilities, i.e., the freezing pressures of liquids, as described in Table 1.6 [41]. This tentative result, showing linearity in the R1 and R2 pressure shifts, was very promising. In 1974 a more precise calibration was done at NBS utilizing an x-ray powder diffraction method to measure the compression of NaCl and relating this to
8753
Pair line Singlet R-line Singlet R2 -Z2 linef Multiplet
YAlO3 (2.5% Cr)
MgO (Cr unknown)
YAlO3 (Nd unknown)
7320
6887 6878
strong
weak
strong
medium
strong
very strong
Relative Intensity
0.090 0.010
−0.13
0.093
0.105
0.076
0.068
dλ /dPb ˚ (A/kbar)
0.35
0.84
0.31
0.70
0.36
d λ /dPb ˚ (A/kbar)
20
10
21
8
10
7.5
Linewidthc ˚ (A)
0.22
0.92
0.39
0.53
0.28
0.01
Background Ratiod
b These
of dopant is designated as a weight percent values were measured and are recorded here for comparison purposes only and are not reported as accurate measurements of the derivatives with respect to pressure and temperature. We consider the values to be accurate to approximately 10% c Linewidths indicated are those measured with the apparatus described herein. They represent full width at half-maximum values (FWHM) d Ratio of background intensity near the peak to intensity of the peak above the background. In MgO and the Nd-doped YAlO samples’ the background may be 3 due to poor crystal quality and/or other impurities e Yttrium Aluminum Garnet f As designated in M. J. Weber and T. E. Varitimos, J. Appl. Phys. 42, 4996 (1971)
a Amount
6992
R-lines Doublet
YAGe (0.38% Cr2 O3 )
7228 7251
R-lines Doublet
YAlO3 (0.2% Cr)
6928 6942
Wavelength ˚ λ (A)
R-lines Doublet
Line Designation and Description
Ruby, Al2 O3 (0.5% Cr)
Materiala
Table 1.5 Comparison of various fluorescing crystalline materials for potential use in a DAC
26 G.J. Piermarini
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
27
A −15
R1
Wave number shift (cm-1)
−10
−5
SLOPE = -0.77 ± 0.03 CM-1 kbar-1 0 −20
B −15
R2
−10
−5
SLOPE = -0.84 ± 0.03 CM-1 kbar-1 0
0
5
10
15
20
25
Pressue (kbar)
Fig. 1.25 Pressure-dependencies of the ruby R1 and R2 fluorescence lines determined from the pressure points listed in Table 1.6. These pressures are approximate because the temperature at which the measurement was made was not measured or controlled
Table 1.6 Freezing pressure points
a
Substance
Transitiona
Transition pressure (kbar)
CCl4 CCl4 H2 O H2 O n-C7 H16 n-C2 H5 Br
L-I III − IVb L-VI VI-VII L-I L-I
1.3 40 9.6 22.3 11.4 18.3
L refers to the liquid state and the Roman numerals designate solid phases. The III–IV transition point of CCL4 was excluded from the calculation because of the nonhydrostatic character of the medium surrounding the ruby crystal [41].
b
28
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.26 The pressure dependence at 25◦ C of the ruby R1 fluorescence line at 6,942 ˚ as a function of wavelength A ˚ and also wave number (A) or frequency (cm−1 ). Values for pressures are based on the Decker equation of state for NaCl. The dependence is linear to 195 kbar following the equation PNaCl = 2.746(Δλ ), where P is in kbar and Δλ ˚ The uncertainty in the in A. slope, dp/dλ in terms of a 95% confidence interval ˚ −1 . is 2.746 ± 0.014 kbar A Including the reported uncertainty associated with the Decker EOS for NaCl, the value of the slope is 2.740 ± ˚ −1 within a 95% 0.016 kbar A confidence interval [43]
the measured shift in the wavelength of the ruby R1 line under the same conditions (Fig. 1.26). The corresponding pressure was calculated from the compression data utilizing an established equation of state for NaCl (the Decker EOS) [43].
1.6 Hydrostatic Pressure-Transmitting Media One ramification of the ruby fluorescence method of pressure measurement is the very useful property of line broadening of the R1 , R2 doublet peak, resulting from the initiation of inhomogeneous stresses in the pressure-transmitting medium surrounding the ruby as shown in Fig. 1.27. Because knowledge of the nature of the pressurized environment surrounding a sample under study is extremely important, the phenomenon was studied further to corroborate the assumption that the broadening was due to inhomogeneous stresses [44]. Other liquids, known to have hydrostatic pressure limits from earlier-published press experiments, were studied by the ruby fluorescence method, e.g., isopropyl alcohol, 1:1 pentane:isopentane, and ethanol, the results of which are shown in Fig. 1.28. Included are observations on 4:1 methanol:ethanol. The results were quite interesting. First, they demonstrated that under increasing hydrostatic pressures, the R-lines sharpen significantly until a pressure is reached where an abrupt discontinuity occurs and line broadening sets in severely. The discontinuities occurred at pressures in agreement with published hydrostatic limits, corroborating our initial assumption that line broadening was the result of non-uniform stresses. Second, our measurements on 4:1 methanol:ethanol,
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
29
120 A
100
Relative Intensity
B 80
C
60
40
20
0 14300
14340 14380 14420 Wavenumber, cm−1
14460
Fig. 1.27 Luminescence spectra from a crystal of ruby (0.05% Cr by wt) in a gasketed DAC. A is at ambient pressure; B, at 2.23 GPa (mixture of ices VI and VII); C, in a nonhydrostatic environment at about 4 GPa (mixture of CCl4 III and IV) illustrating a line broadening affect [41]
Fig. 1.28 Line-broadening effects due to the onset of nonhydrostatic stresses on the ruby crystal relative to the 1atmosphere line-width. The line-width decreases continuously until the discontinuity points, P1 , P2 , P3 , and P4 , which indicate the pressures at which the ruby senses nonhydrostatic stresses in a given pressure-transmitting medium. For example, the discontinuity in 4:1 methanol: ethanol occurs at P4 , about 104 kbar, for methanol, P3 at about 70 kbar, etc. [44]
30
G.J. Piermarini
carried out for the first time on that liquid mixture, produced a discontinuity (and thus a hydrostatic limit) at a pressure far beyond any known liquid or liquid mixture at that time. To advance our knowledge on this phenomenon, and to further support our argument that line broadening of the ruby R-lines is the result of the onset of nonhydrostaticity, another experiment was devised. Fine particles of crystalline ruby chips were dispersed throughout two solids, AgCl and NaCl (both commonly used as pressure-transmitting media in press experiments), water, and 4:1 methanol:ethanol (to corroborate our own ruby fluorescence experiments), were pressed in a gasketed DAC. A unique system of diaphragms and fine slits built into our microscope permitted us to measure fluorescence spectra from isolated small areas along the gasket diameter. Position sensitive sampling of the R1 ruby lines revealed the pressure distribution in the compressed media [44]. Ruby R-line broadening data such as that shown in Fig. 1.28 is extremely important because it permits one to readily assess the critical property of hydrostaticity in liquids that are used as pressure-transmitting media. Confirmation of the hydrostatic limit of liquids and powders is shown in Fig. 1.29. To illustrate, the 4:1 ethanol:methanol mixture begins to show nonhomogeneity in the stress at a pressure of about 10 GPa, in agreement with the result shown in Fig. 1.28. Our interpretation of the discontinuity in the line broadening graphs in Fig. 1.28, i.e., the onset of nonhydrostaticity in the medium, initially was not fully appreciated by some skeptical scientists. To satisfy the skeptics, we provided additional experimental evidence to support our argument. We developed a simple Stokes Falling Ball method to measure the pressure-dependence of viscosity of liquids [45]. The DAC was mounted on an optical goniometer modified to permit viewing the sam-
Fig. 1.29 Position sensitive line broadening measurements in some commonly used pressuretransmitting media. Note that the 4:1 methanol:ethanol mixture begins to show nonuniform stresses above 10 GPa [44]
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
31
Fig. 1.30 A view of the viscosity apparatus, showing the mounted DAC (A), the optical goniometer (B), the horizontal low-power microscope (C) and attached TV camera (D)
ple in the DAC with a stationary horizontal microscope attached to the goniometer (Fig. 1.30). The translational motions of the goniometer positioned the sample on the optic axis of the microscope and the rotational feature inverted the sample on a horizontal axis while maintaining optical alignment (Fig. 1.31). A TV camera and recording instrument were incorporated in the design to permit observations of the ball position over long periods of time. At very high viscosities, for example, observations were made over a period of weeks. In a practical sense, one significant result of this work is the independent confirmation of the glass transition pressure in 4:1 methanol:ethanol mixture at 10.4 GPa (Fig. 1.32). However, in a more general sense, I think it would be a useful endeavor to explore the use of this method to measure the pressure dependence of explosive liquids, an area of study which has received little attention in the past. As deficiencies in the ungasketed method such as the large parabolic gradient in pressure, the relatively small volume of sample (a thin layer between the anvil flats) became more appreciated from the line broadening studies, use of a metal gasket became almost universal. As illustrated above in Fig. 1.29, if the gasket confines a powder, pressure gradients are reduced considerably from the case where no gasket is used, but, when the powder is in a liquid pressure-transmitting medium, gradients in pressure are nonexistent until the liquid reaches its freezing pressure or the viscosity of the liquid approaches the glass transition pressure (Fig. 1.33). Thus, it was quickly recognized that if liquids could be confined under pressure in a DAC, then other materials in the form of powders and single crystals could be included and the liquid would act as a hydrostatic pressure-transmitting medium as long as it remained a fluid. Not only did this improve existing x-ray powder diffraction studies by providing a well-characterized pressure environment, but, as we saw earlier, it
32
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.31 A view of Dow-Corning 200 fluid in the gasket of a DAC, a solid Ni sphere about 0.033 mm in diameter, a very small chip of ruby located at the bottom of the calibrated superimposed scale in the eyepiece of the microscope. The smallest graduation on the scale for the particular optics used is 0.0095 mm. Later, a ruby sphere was used both as the falling ball and the pressure sensor, eliminating fluid flow interference between two objects in the liquid [45]
also led to single-crystal x-ray diffraction under high pressure, a revolutionary development in high-pressure techniques. To facilitate pressure measurements an optical fluorescence system for rapid routine pressure measurement was developed at NBS in 1973, which permitted pressures to be measured in the DAC with an accuracy and speed hitherto unachieved [42]. The precision of the measurement with that instrumentation with the ruby in a hydrostatic environment is 0.05 GPa. The NBS system, shown in schematic detail in Fig. 1.34, includes an optical polarizing microscope for visual observation of the sample which is also displayed continuously on a color video monitor. In addition to the sample image, the calculated pressures (both FWHM and model values), the measured temperature, the measured and calculated model R-line spectra and the differences between them, and also the time and date are displayed next to the image of the sample on the monitor every 3 s or at longer intervals when greater precision in the pressure measurement is desired. All of this information can be recorded on
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
33
Fig. 1.32 Viscosity as a function of pressure of 4:1 mixture by volume of methanol:ethanol at room temperature corrected for an infinite parallel wall effect. The dashed lines are extrapolations to the glass transition (10−13 poise) at about 10.4 GPa (determined by the ruby method) and to the viscosity of pure methanol at 1 atmosphere (6 × 10−3 poise) [45]
video tape as a record of the experiment and can be referred to at a future time with all the relevant information. A photograph of the apparatus is shown in Fig. 1.35. By 1974, DAC technology had advanced to a high degree of sophistication. With the development of the rapid, accurate, routine, and convenient ruby fluorescence method of pressure measurement at NIST, the problem of pressure calibration and measurement, a major obstacle to the widespread use of the DAC, was removed. As a result, the DAC experienced an unprecedented expansion in its use and acceptance by the high-pressure community as a tool for physical and chemical investigations at high pressure. The ruby fluorescence pressure scale was subsequently extended by various scientists, in 1978 to 1 Mbar, and in 1986 to 5.5 Mbar. No longer was the diamond cell simply a qualitative or semiquantitative instrument, but it became a serious quantitative research tool for carrying out high-pressure studies. Today it is the instrument of choice as a research tool for high-pressure research. Our successes with these two instruments, the lever-arm and hydraulically loaded pressure cells, motivated other research laboratories in the United States and also in other parts of the world, particularly in Japan and Germany, to initiate research programs using
34
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.33 Pressure distribution in an ungasketed sample of powdered NaCl intimately mixed with fine powdered ruby crystals (approximately 10% of ruby by volume) in the diamond anvil cell at two different applied loads (V > VI > VII). The mixture itself through friction acts as its own seal as the sample thins out under load. Because the coordinate scale factors are identical for Figs. 1.29 and 1.33, a comparison between the two figures illustrates clearly that even for a small area within the sample, pressure gradients in the ungasketed system exceed greatly the gradients in gasketed systems [44]
these devices. The following paragraph describes some of those instruments that were developed. For the purposes of this presentation, I will discuss briefly several well-known pressure cells, each of which has strengths in particular areas of application for which they were specifically designed, and also weaknesses in other areas of application. I do not intend to go into great detail discussing the operation of these instruments. In this connection, the reader is referred to reference [46], for an outstanding review of DACs, discussed in great detail and completeness. The most important component of a DAC is the Bridgman-opposed anvil arrangement of the diamonds, which permits the generation of high pressures on anything placed between them. This opposed-anvil arrangement is a fundamental characteristic of all DACs regardless of their overall mechanical design. The other essential components serve to (1) align the anvils so that their faces are parallel and their areas coaxial, and (2) generate forces on the anvils sufficient to produce the desired pressures on something placed between their faces. Several designs have arisen to fulfill the requirements of (1) and (2), and also to meet specific experimental conditions. Variations in the mechanical design of the DAC have arisen from different ways of generating the applied force and of aligning the diamonds to make them parallel and on axis.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
35
Fig. 1.34 A detailed description of this figure is inappropriate for the purposes of this presentation. Only a brief explanation is given here. A focused He-Cd laser beam is directed via EPI illumination onto the ruby crystal in the pressure cell. The resulting fluorescent emission is directed to the echelle grating and wavelength analyzed to determine its shift relative to the wavelength at atmospheric pressure. The pressure is then calculated and displayed on the monitor utilizing computer programs. A complete description of the system is given in reference [42]
1.7 Some Basic Types of DACs One such instrument is the NBS cell developed in our laboratory in 1975 and still used quite widely today [47]. Some history behind its development is appropriate to give here because it demonstrates how advances in DAC technology were made in
36
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.35 This photograph shows the microscope, mounted DAC, echelle grating, video camera, computer with monitor and television with sample image and relevant data displayed on the screen [42]
those early years. In our early experiments with DACs before 1975, we learned to appreciate how critical it was to achieve and maintain good anvil alignment, because many diamonds were destroyed in the process of testing new mechanical alignment designs. Fortunately for us, we had an abundant supply of diamonds (provided gratis by the US Customs Service, as noted earlier in this chapter), and, although diamond failures were common in those days because of primitive DAC designs, we were not overly concerned about this. Initially, to support and align the anvils we used ordinary steel plates. One plate could be translated and rotated and then fixed in position by three lateral screws 120◦ apart. The other plate could be tilted with two screws 180◦ apart. A combination of tilt, rotation, and translation provided the necessary parameters for making the anvil faces parallel and axially aligned. To achieve the latter, one anvil face was intentionally made larger in area than the other. The weakest part of this design was the tilting mechanism, which failed under high loads often resulting in destruction of the diamond, even though, at that time, we had only a rough estimate of the pressure that was reached at the point of failure. The other weakness was the relatively soft metal (unhardened) used to fabricate the plates. We noted that under high loads the table of the diamond indented the seat supporting the anvil, usually unevenly, which contributed to misalignment of the faces. We were literally working in the dark as far as understanding the details of the improvements that were being made was concerned. In this connection, I cannot overstate the importance of our having developed the ruby fluorescence pressure-measurement technique, because, with that new capability, we began to understand in-depth the problems we faced and the solutions that were needed to correct them. For example,
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
37
with the ability to measure pressure, we were able to determine the maximum pressure achieved before a particular design under study failed. With such information, we proceeded to redesign the alignment and force generation components of the cell in a stepwise fashion. Learning from our earlier failures, we ultimately developed the ball and socket alignment arrangement and force-generating mechanism shown in the diagram below. In this design, the principle employed to generate force is a spring-loaded leverarm assembly, where the applied force is produced by the simple rotation of a large screw, which compresses Belleville spring washers, each having a capacity of 272 kgf when fully compressed to the flat position. The spring-lever-arm arrangement generates a uniform and continuously varying force as the screw is rotated, a feature that has proved, in practice, to be highly desirable because it eliminates distortions in the anvil assembly and also undesired large changes in pressure. Use of Belleville spring washers has also proved to be highly useful because they can be stacked either in series, in parallel, or in combinations of both, to alter sensitivity and load characteristics as preferred. It is specifically control of these characteristics which are desired because they can be tailored to the peculiarities of the sample under investigation. The applied load, magnified by 2 through the lever-arm system, is transmitted to the pressure plate which bears against the extended piston containing one of the diamond anvils. The opposing anvil is fixed in its position and acts as an entablature for the piston anvil. The fixed anvil or entablature is supported by a translating diamond mount plate, which permits the two anvil faces to be aligned axially along the direction of the load. The piston anvil is supported in a tilting diamond mount hemisphere and permits parallel adjustment of the opposing faces. With these simple adjustment features, anvil alignment can be accomplished with ease and precision and is also permanently maintained. Both diamond mount supports contain conical cutouts which permit 180◦ optical access and can be modified to accommodate the particular requirements of the measurement of interest. A loose-fitting removable bifilar-type resistance coil heater sheathed in Inconel alloy and electrically insulated with MgO powder is conveniently inserted in a cavity surrounding the anvil-piston assembly for heating as shown in Fig. 1.36. In effect the sample is located at the center of an externally heated coiled resistance furnace. For low temperatures, the furnace can be replaced with a cooling coil for the passage of liquid nitrogen or other lower-temperature coolants. Personally, I favor the spring-loaded lever-arm design over others as a matter of convenience, static heating with resistance coil heaters and ease in loading with gasketed samples. However, I note, that regardless of the mechanism employed for generating the force, the criteria for producing very high pressures remain the same: (1) the ability to align the anvil faces accurately and (2) maintaining this alignment rigidly under the loads necessary to produce high pressures. The alignment arrangement consists of a hardened (RWC 60) diamond mount plate, which can be translated with the aid of three screws (120◦ apart) to position the anvils axially. The other anvil is mounted in a similarly hardened steel hemisphere that can be tilted with three screws (120◦ apart) to make the opposing anvil faces parallel as indicated by the disappearance of interference fringes in the gap between the assembled anvil faces. In 1975, we were
38
G.J. Piermarini Translating Diamond Mount Plate
Diamond Anvils Belleville Spring Washers
Tilting Diamond Mount Hemisphere
Adjusting Screws
Removable Heater
Incomel Alloy 718
Extended Plston Pressure Plate
Pressure Plate Bearing Scale:
1 cm
Fig. 1.36 The NIST diamond anvil cell with temperature capability [47]. This cut-away cross section shows the essential components of the NIST DAC including the anvil support alignment design, lever-arm assembly and spring washer loading system. For high-temperature experiments the entire cell, except for the spring washers, is fabricated from Inconel 718, a high-temperature high-strength superalloy which permits sample temperatures as high as 1,073 K to be maintained routinely [58]
able to achieve the highest pressures ever measured by the ruby method (in excess of 60 GPa) in a DAC. Indeed, the famous 19th century physicist, William Thomson (better known to us as Lord Kelvin) had great insight when he commented about the importance of being able to measure a quantity to increase our knowledge and understanding of that quantity. Seventeen years before the founding of NBS, Lord Kelvin, in one of his many lectures [48], said: When you can measure what you are speaking about, and express it in numbers, you know something about it; but when you cannot measure it, when you cannot express it in numbers, your knowledge is of a meager and unsatisfactory kind: it may be the beginning of knowledge, but you have scarcely, in your thoughts, advanced to the stage of science.
Because of the amazing success of that work, increasing numbers of scientists became interested in learning how to use a DAC especially because one could now routinely measure the pressure on a sample in the cell using an internal pressure sensor (Fig. 1.37). In that paper [47], I stated that I would be pleased to provide working drawings of the instrument upon request. Soon after the publication of that work, P. W. Bell of the Geophysical Laboratory in Washington, DC visited me along with his machinist to obtain the drawings, and also to get my opinion on what I thought would improve the performance of the instrument based on my experience using it. If I were to fabricate another cell, I said I would make the piston and cylinder much longer to improve and maintain alignment at loads higher than I had attained in our present experiments. I thought that was the weakest part of our design. In
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
39
Fig. 1.37 Transition pressures for various materials used as fixed-points on the Fixed Point Pressure Scale (FPPS). The graph compares FPPS with the ruby-NaCl scale. The points identified with 1961 refer to the original FPPS; those identified with 1970 refer 1970 revised scale [47]
1977, Mao and Bell came out with the DAC design shown below with the astonishing announcement of having successfully attained the unprecedented pressures of over a megabar [49]. It took just 2 years to go from 60 GPa to over 100 GPa, an accomplishment creating quite a stir in the high-pressure community, particularly for geophysicists, who were interested in studying phenomena occurring in the interior of the earth. In addition, studies with the ultrahigh-pressure DAC resulted in a revision of the fixed-point pressure scale commonly used to calibrate large presses at that time. The values of the calibration points based on the ruby pressure scale were lowered by a factor of 2 in the range above 15 GPa as illustrated in the graph below. Like the NIST cell, the Mao-Bell DAC uses a Belleville spring-loaded lever-arm mechanism for generating the force, but is considerably larger and operates in an inverted configuration (Fig. 1.38). For stable anvil alignment, this cell uses a long 60–70 mm detachable piston/cylinder assembly. Anvil alignment involves translating and tilting two hardened half-cylinder rockers. Basically a scaled-up version of the NIST DAC, this cell facilitates the generation of very large forces to produce pressures in the megabar range originally intended for the study of materials of geological interest. During the past several years, cells of this type have continued to break records in achieving the highest static pressures in the laboratory. It has also been used extensively to study the condensed noble gases as well as other gases, which are loaded in a large cryostat at low temperatures. However, its relatively
40
G.J. Piermarini Tungstan carbide half–cylinders Diamond anivils
Cylinder Piston
Gasket
Fulcrum
Main body
Thrust block
Lever Drive screw
Fig. 1.38 The Mao-Bell diamond anvil cell
large size makes it inconvenient to adapt to measurement techniques where limited space is available. Another type of DAC designed for x-ray powder diffraction studies is the Bassett cell [50]. The force-generating mechanism in this cell consists of a driving nut in a threaded stainless steel cylinder with relatively massive walls to provide strength and rigidity. The anvil assembly consists of a stationary anvil whose support is threaded from one end of the cylinder and a movable anvil in a sliding piston arrangement is driven from the opposite end of the cylinder as shown in Fig. 1.39. Rotation of the driving nut advances the piston pushing it against the stationary entablature. Anvil alignment is achieved with two half-cylinder rocker anvil supports whose axes are rotated by 90◦ in the plane normal to the load direction. Forces generated by this mechanism tend to be discontinuous and in relatively large steps rather than continuous, as is the case provided by spring washers, because the pitch of the thread determines the magnitude of the load generated for a given fraction of a rotation. In cells of this kind, the thread pitch is necessarily small in order to sustain the large forces needed to produce high pressures particularly because there is no mechanical magnification factor as in the case of the lever-arm system. Another disadvantage with this design is in the inconvenience of providing static heating capability using a resistance coil furnace. This cell has been used extensively for high-pressure x-ray powder diffraction studies and with laser heating of samples to very high temperatures for phase diagram studies. Pressures as high as 40 GPa have been reported with samples in the ungasketed configuration using 0.3 mm anvil flats. The Holzapfel cell [51] is a design based on a knee-action mechanism. Two parallel-threaded rods, which connect the two larger levers shown in Fig. 1.40, are synchronously rotated with a special gear-set wrench pulling the lower ends of the
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
41
Fig. 1.39 Cross-section drawing of the Bassett cell showing the hemi-cylinder hardened rocker supports for anvil alignment and the very simple force-generating mechanism of a driving nut pushing against a movable piston in a guiding cylinder
Fig. 1.40 Cross-section of the Holzapfel DAC. The thrust for the piston is generated by moving the opposed knee-type lever arms closer together when the threads are advanced synchronously without distortion. A tilting hemispherical diamond mount and a translating plate are used to align the diamonds similar to the NIST design
levers together. A force is exerted on the moving piston, which generates the pressure. This knee mechanism results in a large force multiplication factor, which permits pressures in the 50 GPa range to be reached. This cell uses the NIST mechanism of a tilting hemisphere and a translation plate for anvil alignment. The cell has been adapted for x-ray powder and single-crystal diffraction, Raman, Brillouin, and other optical studies at high pressure. The special geometry of the knee mechanism including the levers and threaded rods require precision-machined components which
42
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.41 Miniature Merrill-Bassett cell designed originally for single-crystal x-ray diffraction studies, but now used for other kinds of experiments also, consists of Be anvil support plates for high radiation transmission. Thrust is applied by tightening three symmetrically positioned pulling screws. Maintaining anvil alignment may be an issue if the screws are not rotated at the same rate
must all fit together with great accuracy, otherwise the thrust will not act strictly parallel to the cylindrical axis of the instrument and problems may arise in maintaining alignment under applied loads. The Merrill-Bassett DAC is the simplest of all designs [52] (Fig.1.41). Three screws pull two platens together. When tightened synchronously with a special gearset wrench, diamond alignment is maintained and pressures are generated. Of all the DACs, this device is the most compact, rendering it useful for single-crystal x-ray diffraction measurements because it can be mounted directly on the circle of an automated x-ray goniometer without additional supporting mechanisms. For this application Be supports are required for the diamond anvils because they are relatively transparent to x-rays and provide a wide-angle window for the incident x-ray beam and also for the diffracted beams. Unlike steel, however, Be is relatively weak and limits the support it can provide to reach very high pressures. Another problem is the lack of positive guidance for the diamond anvils to help maintain alignment. Because of these disadvantages, pressures in excess of 15 GPa are rarely reached with this DAC. Today, the sample is generally prepared in the gasketed configuration. Metal gaskets, in addition to prolonging the life of the anvils and extending their pressure
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
43
range, permit the sample to be encapsulated in a fluid pressure-transmitting medium, thus providing a truly hydrostatic environment for the sample. The hydrostatic (zero shear stress) state is highly desirable because it eliminates the presence of shear stresses of unknown magnitude which often lead to serious difficulties in the interpretation of the desired measurement. Thus, the maintenance of the hydrostatic environment is a prime consideration for achieving error-free results in any highpressure experiment. In most of the earlier work with the DAC, sample pressures were estimated from the applied load. Such estimates yielded an average pressure over the sample in the ungasketed case, but are even less reliable using a gasketed sample, because the gasket absorbs an unknown amount of the load. Losses in load due to friction both in the sample and in the instrument were also unknown. The lack of a rapid reliable pressure measurement procedure seriously hampered research using the DAC, because one could not prescribe and then produce a desired pressure condition and thus could not give meaningful in situ direction to an experimental study.
1.8 Optical Polarizing Microscopy Optical polarizing microscopy coupled with a DAC is a very simple technique (Fig. 1.42), yet its power as a research tool is awesome. The DAC can be mounted on a rigid supporting base to prevent detectable motion under magnification as the pressure screw is rotated as shown in the schematic diagram below. To demonstrate the power of this simple technique the four photos below (Fig. 1.43) illustrate the ZnS transition at 15 GPa and room temperature in a
POLARIZING MICROSCOPE
THERMOCOUPLE HOLE
COIL FURNACE
Fig. 1.42 A simple schematic diagram of the optical polarizing microscope technique with the DAC
DIAMOND CELL
BRASS SUPPORT
44
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.43 Pressure-induced transition in zinc sulfide at about 15 GPa to an opaque semimetal
methanol:ethanol:water mixture (16:3:1 by volume, respectively) in a gasketed DAC as viewed through the polarizing microscope [53, 54]. The clear triangularshaped crystal in the photo on the left is ZnS and the irregular-shaped crystal above it is the ruby pressure sensor. The range of pressures for these four photos is 14.9 GPa on the left to 15.1 GPa on the right. The transition to a semimetal can be arrested as it progresses and is very sharp and an excellent fixed point for a pressure scale. The transition can be detected by electrical resistance measurements because it involves a sharp decrease in electrical resistance to an opaque semimetal.
1.9 High P–T Properties of Explosives and Propellants The thermophysical and thermochemical properties of energetic materials at elevated pressures are of interest because many of these compounds are extensively used as propellants and explosives. During detonation, the shock wave produced by these materials may reach 50 GPa and temperatures up to 5,500 K, resulting in polymorphic transformations and the initiation of chemical reactions, including thermal decomposition [55]. Therefore, it is important to understand the reactions involving chemical decomposition in these materials, including their pressure dependence. Given the complexity of the reactions and the observed temperature dependencies in many nitramine explosives and monopropellants such as RDX (1,3,5trinitrohexahydro-1,3,5-triazine), HNIW (hexanitrohexaaza-isowurtzitane), HMX (octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine), ADN (ammonium dinitramide), PNA (p-nitroaniline), and NM (nitromethane), an understanding of the pressure effect is necessary for accurate modeling of combustion and explosive behavior. Parameters in the Arrhenius equation, characterizing the reaction rate, such as activation energy, usually are derived from ambient pressure studies and subsequently extrapolated to the detonation regime. Published results [56–58], indicate that these ambient pressure kinetic parameters are not applicable to the high-pressure regime. Generally, investigations of the reaction kinetics were experimentally performed by thermo-gravimetric or differential scanning calorimetry. However, in such studies different results are obtained when the experiments are carried out in either a confined or unconfined state. The discrepancies are thought to be due either to the autocatalytic or pressure-dependent nature of the reaction mechanism. Consequently, applicable high-pressure data is critically needed to increase our understanding of
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
45
the reaction mechanism under detonation conditions, which can improve the accuracy of the mathematical modeling procedures. A combination of DAC techniques, all utilizing the ruby fluorescence method of pressure measurement, can be used to measure the kinetics of decomposition reactions. These include: (1) Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy for the kinetic measurements, (2) energy dispersive x-ray powder diffraction (EDXD) for crystallographic identification of the observed polymorphic forms and also compression measurements, (3) optical polarizing light microscopy (OPLM) for delineating the stability fields in the equilibrium pressure–temperature phase diagram, as well as for confirming observed phase transitions, and (4) Raman scattering (RS) for measuring the pressure dependence of the shifts in the vibrational modes. To demonstrate the power of the DAC in studying energetic materials as a function of static pressure and temperature, I have selected two examples from the literature, RDX (1,3,5trinitrohexahydro-1,3,5-triazine) [59] and nitromethane [60,61], which represent the pioneering work done in this area at NIST. I describe how these four experimental techniques were used to obtain data on polymorphism (phase diagrams), chemical reactivity, and rates of thermal decomposition, including reaction mechanisms and Arrhenius activation energies and volumes. References giving similar information and experimental results on the P–T phase diagrams, thermal decomposition reactions, the nitramine compounds, HMX, HNIW, ADN, and PNA and other energetic materials such as ammonium perchlorate (AP) and pentaerythritrol (PETN), can be found in references [62–68]. Also, a comprehensive review relevant to this area of study, including experimental, theoretical, and computational methods characterizing decomposition, combustion, and detonation of energetic materials, is recommended [69].
1.9.1 P–T Equilibrium Phase Diagrams for RDX and NM 1.9.1.1 RDX In the original study characterizing the equilibrium P–T phase diagram of RDX for the first time, OPLM observations of single crystals in a hydrostatic environment were used to identify three solid polymorphs, α, β, and γ [59] (Fig. 1.44). Two solid polymorphs, known from earlier work [70,71], were originally named I and II, but, following universally accepted phase equilibria convention, we renamed them α- and β-RDX in the present study. The α–γ phase boundary was easily detected by observing with the aid of OPLM discontinuous changes in birefringence in α-phase single crystals. The transition, independent of temperature, is rapid, reversible and involves no breakup of the single crystal as long as the pressure-transmitting environment is hydrostatic. The in situ energy dispersive x-ray results give a small volume decrease of about 1.6% and are in agreement with published data for γ-RDX [72].
46
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.44 The equilibrium phase diagram of RDX as a function of pressure and temperature as determined with the aid of a DAC [72]
Above about 488 K, a new solid phase, β, exists and is the phase in equilibrium with liquid. Unlike the γ-phase, the β-phase cannot be detected by visual observation under OPLM, but was deduced from changes in both IR and x-ray patterns. (Energy dispersive x-ray diffraction measurements of RDX powders in the same hydrostatic environment confirmed the structural changes associated with the three different polymorphs, even though the β-phase has not been identified crystallographically. Also, observed changes in the FTIR spectra obtained for the three solid phases provided additional confirmation for the phase transitions.) When γ-phase is brought back to RT and nearly to atmospheric pressure, it reverts to the α-phase. Thus, the β-phase remains metastable to almost atmospheric pressure, where it rapidly reverts to α-phase. The liquidus, as expected, increases linearly to 7.0 GPa. The increased scatter in the data points of the liquidus is a reflection of the decrease in accuracy of the ruby fluorescence measurements at higher temperatures. The scatter in the data points at lower temperatures, e.g., RT, is due to sample strain arising from the shear stresses produced in the Fluoroinert liquid used as a chemically inert pressuretransmitting medium. The glass transition in Fluoroinert is about 4.2 GPa at RT and shear stresses produced in the medium at these pressures will affect the transition pressure in RDX. At higher temperatures, the viscosity of Fluoroinert decreases significantly and shear stress plays almost no role in initiating the α–γ transition, resulting in less scatter in the data points. It is known that RDX has one metastable conformer, β-RDX, in addition to the room temperature stable orthorhombic form, α RDX (space group Pbca). The structure of the α-phase has been determined by single-crystal neutron diffraction, but the β-form has not been solved unequivocally, because of the difficulty in
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
47
growing and preserving quality single crystals suitable for analysis. The highpressure phase is in the same crystal system (orthorhombic) as the ambient α-RDX, but a definite structure was not reported. Gamma RDX was identified earlier from volume compression data derived from x-ray diffraction measurements, although it was never assigned a label or name. The volume compression data showed a 1.6% decrease in volume near 4.0 GPa indicating a first-order phase transition. No change in the orthorhombic-type unit cell was found. The pressure dependences of the orthorhombic lattice parameters decrease monotonically with increasing pressure. However, near 4 GPa both a and c continue to decrease, but b abruptly increases resulting in a small decrease in volume of about 1.6%. Above about 488 K, a new solid phase, β, exists which, at higher temperatures, is the phase in equilibrium with liquid. As was noted earlier, β-phase has not been identified crystallographically. It also cannot be detected by visual observation under polarized light, unlike the γ–phase [72] (Fig. 1.45). The infrared spectra of α and γ-RDX indicate that their molecular structures must be similar, because only slight changes between the two spectra are observed (Fig. 1.48). The γ-to-β transformation, however, results in a significant change in the molecular spectra of the two phases (Fig. 1.46). In particular, the bands at ≈1, 060 cm−1 and at ≈1, 400 cm−1 that are observed in the α and γ phases are not seen in the β-phase. The 1, 060 cm−1 bands have been assigned to cyclic vibrations coupled to deformations of the NO2 groups through the C–N–N bond angle. The 1, 400 cm−1 bond results from a CH2 wagging motion. In addition, two prominent
Fig. 1.45 Crystallographic d-spacings for three phases of RDX (α, β, and γ) as a function of pressure at room temperature. For α-RDX, the normal orthorhombic pattern is shown at 2.6 GPa (). At 4.5 and 5.1 GPa, another orthorhombic pattern is shown (♦, for γ phase) and the circles (◦) indicate “d” spacings for the β phase at 5.6 and 6.7 GPa [72]
48
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.46 Infrared Spectra for α-, β-, and γ-RDX in the CH stretching frequency range. These spectra are shown to illustrate the significant differences among the three phases of RDX, making them easily distinguishable [72]
bands are observed in α-phase in the CH stretching region, ≈3, 100 cm−1 . However, in the β-phase at least five bands are observed in this region. A detailed assignment of the vibrational spectra for α-RDX and its isotopes has been reported. A detailed analysis of the vibrational spectra of β-RDX found in the present study is not available at present because it requires additional isotopic study and structural information. However, the crystal structure of γ-RDX was investigated recently utilizing a DAC by FTIR spectroscopy and powder x-ray diffraction measurements followed by Rietveld refinements of the structure [72]. Although γ- and α-phases were found to belong to the same space group, Pbca, as was noted earlier, they exhibited a different crystal packing, attributable to rotations and translations of molecules. While the molecular structures of the α- and γ-phases have the same conformation, the N–NO2 torsion angles changed slightly (Fig. 1.47). It is of interest to note that infrared spectra reported for a metastable RDX phase obtained by the evaporation of a thymol-RDX solution [72], appear to be very similar to the spectra obtained here for the β-phase under different conditions of P and T. Because of the great similarity in these IR spectra, it seems reasonable to assume that the two phases are the same, indicating that the stability field of this metastable phase is now established.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
49
Fig. 1.47 Infrared absorbance spectra of α- and γ-RDX at 1.4 and 4.1 GPa, respectively, both at RT. Because the two spectra are very similar, their molecular structures are assumed to be also similar [72]
Fig. 1.48 Infrared absorbance spectra of α- and β-RDX at 2.4 GPa and 508 K. In the wavenumber range measured, significant differences are indicated
50
G.J. Piermarini
1.9.1.2 NM Similar measurements by the same experimental techniques have been published for nitromethane, the simplest of the aliphatic nitro compounds. The melting point [60] (Fig. 1.49), and more recently several solid phases including a partial phase diagram [73] (Fig. 1.50), have been reported. Also, thermal decomposition parameters and kinetics of decomposition have been determined [74–79].
Fig. 1.49 Equilibrium melting point of nitromethane as a function of P and T. The data points were fitted to the logarithmic function shown in the figure. Above 1.54 GPa and 433 K, the curve was not defined because rapid thermal decomposition occurs [60]
300
CII
Temperature (⬚C)
CI 200
100 SII
SIII
SIV
SI
Fig. 1.50 The P–T phase diagram for nitromethane taken from [73]
SV
0 0
5
10
15
20
Pressure (GPa)
25
30
35
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
51
To again illustrate the power of the OPLM method in conjunction with a DAC, the pressure dependence of the melting point of nitromethane is discussed because utilizing this method permitted delineation of the equilibrium solid–liquid phase boundary to the high-pressure regime for the first time. The two-phase condition, crystal and liquid, can be maintained in a gasketed DAC as a function of T by a corresponding appropriate change in P, thereby ensuring that the measurements are truly at equilibrium conditions. In this manner, the equilibrium phase boundary between any solid and its liquid can be defined over a desired P-T range. In the case of nitromethane, the P-T range present study extends to 1.54 GPa and 433 K, at which point thermal decomposition initiates. Decomposition is readily observed by a darkening of both the liquid and the crystal, ultimately producing a brown solid residue, liquid, and gases, similar to what is shown in Fig. 1.52 for the decomposition products of RDX. Upon release of P, only the solid residue remains in the gasket and it can be retrieved and analyzed by mass spectrometry to determine its chemical constituents. Using the logarithmic function in Fig. 1.49, which describes the melting point of nitromethane at 298 K, the calculated freezing pressure is 0.40 GPa. The liquid phase is easily superpressed to about 2 GPa, where the metastable liquid rapidly crystallizes to a polycrystalline phase, the same phase (orthorhombic, space group, P21 21 21 ) that crystallizes at low temperatures and 1 atmosphere [60]. Other studies on polymorphism in nitromethane have been published, in which a solid–solid transition corresponding to the locking of the methyl group rotation was reported [74]. More recent work discloses three new solid phases, called III, IV, and V, discovered by Raman scattering measurements in the P–T range of 0–35 GPa and 293–623 K [72]. Their stability fields in the P–T phase diagram were defined by breaks or discontinuities in observed shifts in different Raman modes as a function of P and T. Four solid–solid transitions and two irreversible transformations were determined in that study (Fig. 1.50). The I–II transition at 293 K is at (3.0 ± 0.2) GPa, detected by breaks or discontinuities in line-widths in the observed Raman modes. The I–II transition was reported earlier at 3.5 GPa and ambient T [55]. The II–III transition, independent of T, is at (7.5±0.5) GPa at ambient T. It was detected by the appearance of new Raman bands and changes in peak line-widths. The transition is probably first order and thought to be the result of an increase in the number of molecules per cell. The III–IV transition is at (13.2 ± 1.0) GPa at ambient T. It was also detected by breaks or discontinuities in the slope of the different Raman modes with pressure. This transition is P- and T-dependent. The IV–V transition, at (25 ± 1) GPa and ambient T, was not studied at higher T because it transforms at about 328 K. The transformation of nitromethane to the CI compound is irreversible and slow. Because its Raman peak could not be distinguishable from ground, the authors concluded that CI is amorphous. Similarly, the CI–CII is irreversible, but more rapid than the nitromethane–CI transition. CII did not give a Raman signal. This work is an example of identifying phases and delineating phase boundaries to establish the P–T phase diagram based on the measurement of the more intense vibrational modes of solid phases of nitromethane up to 35 GPa and 623 K. The specific behavior of nitromethane under these conditions is unusual as well as interesting for such a basic compound, often considered as
52
G.J. Piermarini
a model for energetic nitro compounds. What is needed now is to study nitromethane and its various polymorphs by other experimental measurement techniques in combination with the DAC to detect and confirm the existence of these phases and chemical reactions and to carry out detailed analyses of the results obtained to further our understanding of the behavior of this very fundamental energetic compound.
1.9.2 Pressure Dependence of Thermal Decomposition Rates In the pressure regime above 1 GPa, few published methods are currently available for kinetic measurements particularly for decomposition reactions of energetic materials where micro volume samples are necessary for the safety of the investigators. The following narrative describes FTIR absorption experiments to obtain relevant kinetic data for thermal decomposition reactions of two important materials, RDX and nitromethane, as a function of pressure and temperature. Through a combination of the measured pressure effects on the thermal decomposition kinetics, and, in the case of NM, the identification of decomposition products, possible reaction mechanisms are proposed for the thermal decomposition process in NM at high pressures. The chemical reactivity and phase stability of RDX and NM at high pressures and elevated temperatures were characterized in equilibrium P–T phase diagrams. Innovative advances in the measurement of the pressure dependence of decomposition rates of propellants and explosives were made at NIST during the 1980s. The experiments, utilizing time-resolved FTIR technology, were seminal in nature because such measurements had never been made before at high pressures. Because this area of study has not received much attention in the energetic materials community, I shall discuss this subject in detail in the hope that I can rekindle some interest in it. In 1984, a Fourier transform infrared microscopic method for measuring kinetic effects and thermal decomposition rates for energetic materials at high temperatures and high pressures in combination with a DAC with heating capability was developed at NIST, in collaboration with the Naval Surface Warfare Center at White Oak, MD. Because commercial IR microscopes were unavailable at that time, an FTIR spectrometer modified with an on-axis Cassegrain-type beam condenser was employed. The experimental configuration for the DAC coupled to the Cassegrain-type focusing system is shown in Fig. 1.51. With this system, time-dependent FTIR absorption spectra were obtained for the first time on RDX at high pressures and high temperatures [58]. This Cassegrain optical system with the mounted DAC was small enough to fit directly on an XYZ positioning device located in the sample chamber of the IR instrument [58]. The sample in the DAC could be positioned readily at the focal point of the optical system to achieve maximum IR throughput. Fortunately, infrared microscopes are available today and can be used in combination with a DAC, so that these measurements are much easier to carry out.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
53
Fig. 1.51 Schematic diagram of Cassegrain optics used with the DAC [58]
Fig. 1.52 Left: Thin film starting sample of RDX at 2 GPa; Center: RDX at 0.9 GPa and RT after decomposition was initiated at 4 GPa and 516 K. A brownish liquid is present with dispersed gaseous bubbles. Right: P lowered from 0.9 GPa to ambient P and T. Brown residue plus liquid remains in the gasket [58]
For an FTIR experiment, a sample of RDX in a gasketed DAC at an average pressure of 2 GPa and at ambient temperature is shown in Fig. 1.52. To prepare this sample, RDX powder was packed into a Pt-Rh gasket (≈ 0.457 mm diameter and 150 μm thick) along with two small ruby chips (one located near the center of the sample and the other at the far left center). The ruby chips, two small dark regions in a homogeneous field, act as pressure sensors. In this sample configuration, the pressure is quite nonhydrostatic as indicated by line broadening of the R-lines. Consequently, a large uncertainty is associated with the overall sample pressure. This large uncertainty can be reduced appreciably by including a thin film of powdered NaCl in the sample configuration. This is done by first compressing powdered NaCl between the ungasketed anvils to form a thin film (0.25 μm in thickness) and then assembling the gasket containing the powdered sample to be studied as was done in our earlier experiments. The presence of NaCl reduces the inhomogeneity in the stresses significantly, but does not entirely eliminate it. The decomposed products are also shown in Fig. 1.52.
54
G.J. Piermarini
1.9.2.1 RDX Thermal decomposition in RDX has been determined in α and β phases only (Figs. 1.53 and 1.54). No decomposition in γ phase has been reported in the pressure–temperature regime, 1.4 < GPa > 6.9 and 478 < K > 508, because it always transforms to the β-phase before decomposition initiates.
Fig. 1.53 Thermal decomposition of α-RDX. A series of six time-dependent infrared absorption spectra of α-RDX taken at 4.4 GPa and 515 K in a DAC. The sample thickness is approximately 15 μm [58]
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
55
The measured thermal decomposition rate for α-RDX increases with increasing pressure between 1.4 and 2.4 GPa. On the other hand, β-RDX decomposes with a very different pressure dependence. Like that observed for β-HMX [62], the rate decreases with increasing pressure and decomposition products are more complex with some solid residue present after pressure reduction to 1 atmosphere. Decomposition in β-RDX takes place at temperatures well below the melting point (Fig. 1.56). At 488 K and 5 GPa, for example, decomposition at a very slow rate was observed which increases as the temperature is increased. The products of decomposition were found to exhibit interesting behavior and require further discussion. After decomposition at 4 GPa and 516 K, the pressure cell containing decomposed β-RDX was cooled to room temperature and the pressure measured 0.9 GPa indicating a large decrease in pressure. Both solid and liquid are observed whose IR spectra indicate the presence of H2 O, CO2 , and N2 O chemical species. As the pressure is lowered, gases evolve from the liquid at a pressure of about 0.3 GPa. At atmospheric pressure, the remaining solid residue gave no measurable IR absorption indicating the IR active materials escaped as gases as the pressure seal was broken. At present the solid residue is unidentified. Decomposition rates can be estimated because the concentration of RDX remaining in the DAC is proportional to the measured absorbance. The fraction decomposed can be obtained by taking ratios of peak RDX absorbencies with time, normalized to absorbency at t = 0 (Fig. 1.55). For decomposition at a given P and T, the ratios are combined to give an average value, which when subtracted from unity, yields α, a term proportional to the mole fraction of decomposed RDX. Then, α can be plotted as a function of time for the various pressures and temperatures studied. It is interesting to note that at constant temperature, increasing pressure increases the rate of thermal decomposition for α-RDX, but decreases the rate for β-RDX, indicating that two different chemical mechanisms or rate-controlling steps are involved for the two distinct structures. One would assume that the α-RDX decomposition mechanism is at least bimolecular in nature with a negative volume of activation, while the β-RDX decomposition mechanism would be unimolecular with a positive volume of activation [59]. Many kinetic expressions, derived for determining rate constants, k, from α–time curves for thermal decomposition reactions in the solid state, have been reviewed extensively [79] (Fig. 1.57). For previously reported kinetic measurements on RDX, the Prout-Tompkins rate equation, ln[α/(1 − α)] = kt + C was used to derive the overall rate constant for thermal decomposition. This equation represents an autocatalytic, branching chain-type reaction giving sigmoid-type α–time curves. Another rate equation which linearizes α–time curves is –ln(1 – α)=kt + C, which represents a diffusion limited reaction [55] (Fig. 1.58). Both equations are oversimplifications of complex rate expressions involving rate constants for nucleation, growth, and termination of reactions in a single solid. Even though the true physical meaning may be unknown, these equations do permit one to obtain mathematical expressions for extracting the rate constant for a given measured reaction. If one assumes an accurate measure of the rate constant, despite the above caveat, for the overall decomposition reaction for α-RDX, one can determine a meaningful
56
G.J. Piermarini
RELATIVE ABSORBANCE
Fig. 1.54 IR absorbance spectra of α-RDX. Top: decomposition products at 2.4 GPa and 503 K. Bottom: decomposition products after the pressure was lowered to atmospheric and the temperature to ambient. Under these conditions, the decomposition products appear to be few and uncomplicated as shown in the FTIR pattern in Fig. 1.54. The products appear to be mainly H2 O, CO2 , and N2 O in the form of liquids, which all transform to gases when the pressure is lowered to approximately 1.2 GPa 100 PEAK A PEAK B PEAK C
75 50 25 0
0
4
8 12 16 TIME SETS (80 SEC/SET)
20
Fig. 1.55 Absorbance vs. time plots of three RDX absorption peaks labeled A, B, and C in Fig. 1.53. These curves have been normalized to an absorbance of 100 at time zero, prior to thermal decomposition at 515 K and 4.4 GPa [58]
dependence of k on pressure and temperature (Figs. 1.59 and 1.60). From the total differential of the natural logarithm of k, it can be shown that the partial derivatives are equal to (d ln k/d(1/T ))P = −ΔH ∗ /R
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
57
Fig. 1.56 Pressure dependence of the decomposition temperature of RDX indicated by the onset of a decrease in intensity of an infrared absorption peak. Experimental evidence suggests that the melting of RDX is coincident with thermal decomposition [58]
Fig. 1.57 Typical α-time curves for α-RDX thermal decomposition at 508 K at the pressures indicated. α is the fraction of RDX decomposed. Owing to slight changes in the pressure as the decomposition reaction proceeds, the curves show large scatter in the data points. The curves, however, can be identified with the initial and intermediate stages of a sigmoid or s-shaped type curve typical of decomposition reactions. The shape of these curves are related to physical and chemical mechanisms involved in the decomposition reaction [59]
and
(d ln k/dP)T = −ΔV ∗ /RT
where ΔH ∗ and ΔV ∗ are the experimental enthalpy and volume of activation, respectively [58, 59, 62]. For more complex multiple-step reaction mechanisms ΔH ∗ and
58
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.58 Linearization of the α-time curves for α-RDX thermal decomposition at 2.1 GPa and the temperatures indicated using a diffusion limited model for the reaction mechanism. It should be noted that at higher pressures, the Prout-Tompkin expression gave good linearization, suggesting a change to an autocatalytic-type decomposition mechanism [59]
Fig. 1.59 Temperature dependence of the rate constant, k, of α-RDX thermal decomposition for the pressures indicated. The slope is proportional to the activation energy, ΔH ∗ . Because the lines have almost equal slopes, ΔH ∗ appears to be independent of pressure and has a positive average value of approximately 51 kcal/mol
ΔV ∗ are weighted means of the processes with the rate-controlling step providing the main contribution. In the pressure and temperature range studied in this work, it appears that within the experimental error of the measurements, ΔH ∗ is independent of pressure and
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
59
Fig. 1.60 Pressure dependence of the rate constant, k, of α-RDX thermal decomposition for the temperatures indicated. The slope is proportional to the activation volume, ΔV ∗ . Because the lines have almost equal slopes, ΔV ∗ appears to be independent of pressure and has a negative average value of approximately −5.6 cm3/mol
ΔV ∗ is independent of temperature. Having a knowledge of the rate constant, k, ΔH ∗ , and ΔV ∗ , the rate constant can be expressed in thermodynamic terms by use of transition state theory, ∗ k = (KT/h)e−ΔG /RT and
k = (KT/h) e−ΔS
∗ /RT −ΔH ∗ /RT
permitting evaluation of ΔG∗ and ΔS∗ , the free energy and entropy of the activated state. The importance of these measurements for energetic materials can be emphasized by pointing out the effect of pressure on the Arrhenius chemical-kinetic parameters, often used to model explosions. The Arrhenius activation energy, E Arr , ∗ and the internal energy of activation, E , have been the volume of activation, Vact act related to the reaction rate, k: E Arr = (R d ln k)/d(1/T ) and
∗ E Arr = Eact +Vact [P − T (dP/dT )].
Thus, at very high pressures, the term, [P – T (dP/dT )], can play a dominant role in the decomposition of energetic materials [59].
1.9.2.2 Nitromethane The chemical reactivity of NM as a function of pressure and temperature was observed optically with the aid of a polarizing light microscope [60, 61]. The instru-
60
G.J. Piermarini
3.4
3.6
mentation permitting these observations is described in detail earlier in this chapter. Above 1.54 GPa and 433 K, thermal decomposition initiates and is readily observed by darkening of the liquid and crystal producing ultimately brown solid residue, liquid, and gases. Upon release of pressure, only the solid residue remains, which has been analyzed by mass spectrometry in order to determine its chemical constituents. The major products of decomposition up to 7 GPa are ammonia, formic acid or its salt and water. The residue was originally reported to be the oxalate salt based on the similarity of the IR absorption spectra, but that result had never been confirmed (Fig. 1.61). Pressure tends to increase the chemical reactivity of NM as well as the rate of thermal decomposition. It was observed, quite accidentally, that a pressure-induced
NITACHETHANE
2.6
2.8
0 SEC
530 SEC
2.4
RELATIVE ABSORBANCE
3.0
3.2
5 GPA, 403k
2.0
2.2
1461 SEC
1.6
1.8
4454 SEC
1200
1100
1000 900 HAVENUMBERS
800
700
Fig. 1.61 Infrared absorbance spectra of NM at 5.0 GPa and 403 K for several times during thermal decomposition. Only the two peaks shown here at 1,100 and 925 cm−1 , due solely to vibrational frequencies of modes in crystalline NM, were used in the analysis of the data. Time t = 0 indicates when the sample of NM reached decomposition temperature. The spectrum at 4,454 s shows no NM bands and only those from the decomposition products
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
61
spontaneous explosion of single crystals of NM at room temperature can occur. Further study revealed that single crystals grown from the liquid with the 111 and either the 001 or the 100 crystal faces perpendicular to the applied load direction in the DAC, if pressed rapidly to over 3 GPa, explode instantaneously accompanied by an audible snapping sound [60]. The normally transparent sample becomes opaque instantly. Visual examination of the residue revealed a dark brown solid, which was stable when heated to over 300◦ C. Subsequent x-ray analysis showed the material to be amorphous. Mass spectral analysis of the residue was inconclusive because no well-defined spectra were observed. The fact that most of the sample is recovered as solid residue after the explosion and is stable to over 300◦ C suggests that the material may be amorphous carbon. This stress-induced explosion occurs only in protonated NM because similar attempts on the deuterated form did not result in explosion [60]. Shock experiments on oriented pentaerythritol (PETN) crystals have shown similar type behavior. In this case, it was suggested that the sensitivity of shock pressures to crystal orientation is the result of the availability of slip planes or system of planes in the crystal to absorb the shock, thereby increasing the threshold to explosion [60]. A similar explanation may be applicable to the NM crystals as well. The deuteration effect must play a role in the initiation chemistry. An isotope effect has been observed previously in the sensitivity of HMX and RDX to shock and thermal conditions [60]. Previously reported time-to-explosion measurements on NM up to 5 GPa indicate that pressure decreases the time required to achieve an explosion [80]. As a result of this behavior, pressure is expected to have a similar effect on the thermal decomposition rate in NM. Kinetic measurements, similar to those described above for RDX, were made on NM over the ranges 2.0 ≤ GPa ≥ 7.1 and 393 ≤ K ≥ 453 with the following results. As was the case for RDX, the α vs. t curves can be identified with the initial and intermediate stages of a sigmoid (s-shaped) type curve characteristic of thermal decomposition of a single solid in an autocatalytic-type reaction (Fig. 1.62). With increasing temperature the s-character diminishes to where the curve is almost linear at 423 K. A plot of ln [α/ (1 − α)] vs. t gives linear dependence which supports a decomposition mechanism consistent with nuclei formation with branching interference. The slopes of these lines give typical Arrhenius temperature behavior with the overall rate increasing with temperature. Linear fits of ln [α/(1 − α)] vs. time for data obtained at 2.0 GPa for the decomposition temperatures indicated that the overall decomposition rate increases with increasing temperature, typical of Arrhenius behavior. This type of dependence was found for the thermal decomposition of HMX in an earlier work [62], where the results were more consistent than in the case of NM. Unlike the HMX case, NM undergoes significant changes in its decomposition mechanism because the α vs. time curves change above 413 K. Moreover, at pressures greater than 5 GPa, a third change in the reaction mechanism is indicated by a further change in the shape of the α vs. time curves. Because only two absorbance bands with large signalto-noise error were used to calculate the NM concentration term, α, and because multiple reaction mechanisms appear to overlap in the P–T regime studied, only a qualitative analysis of the data was possible in that work. What is certain is that the
62
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.62 α vs. time sigmoid-type curves obtained for the pressures and temperatures indicated. α is the fraction of decomposed NM at time, t, during thermal decomposition. Curves are logarithmic fits to the data points
decomposition rate in NM was found to increase with increasing pressure, but the overall trend in the data was inconsistent. However, there are some qualitative observations that can be made on the basis of reaction times at the various P–T conditions measured and these are as follows: 1. To 5 GPa at least two different reaction mechanisms are involved in the decomposition and both have a positive pressure dependence on the overall rate of decomposition. 2. Mechanism (1) is dominant below 4 GPa and T ≤ 130◦ C. 3. Mechanism (2) operates at all measured temperatures at 5 GPa and at T ≥ 140◦ C at 4 GPa. 4. The mechanism crossover temperature appears to be 140◦ C. At T ≤ 140◦ C at 2 GPa mechanism (1) is operative, but at T ≥ 140◦ C either mechanism (2) or a mixture of both are operative. 5. Mechanism (1) is linearly dependent in ln [α/ (1 – α)] vs. time, similar to that found earlier for β-HMX [62], while mechanism (2) is linear in ln (1 – α) vs. time similar to that reported for RDX [58,59]. The type of predominant chemical mechanism of the decomposition reaction determines the mathematical functionality of α with respect to time [60]. The fact that two different time dependencies were reported indicates the presence of two separate and distinct kinetic processes. It is known that the aci or enol form of NM can play an important role in the thermal decomposition of NM by acting as a catalyst [60,61]. The results obtained for NM cannot rule out the possibility of this form affecting the observed kinetic data. 6. Finally, a third mechanism is reported to operate at pressures greater than 5 GPa.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
63
These results illustrate the complexity of the NM thermal decomposition reaction. More than one kinetic mechanism and/or catalytic effect may be present. However, the results show definitely a positive pressure enhancement of the reaction rate. As described in reference [62], from the expression: d ln k = ΔH ∗ /RT 2 dT − ΔV ∗ /RTdP, for small increases in pressure with all other terms being equal, only a negative ΔV ∗ will cause increases in ln k. Therefore, the thermal decomposition rate of NM must have a negative volume of activation in the P–T regime studied in these experiments. This result directly implies that the NM decomposition reaction in the solid state is at least bimolecular in character, contradicting published mass spectra studies of molecular reactions in the gas phase [60], where the reaction was reported to be unimolecular. This disagreement is not surprising because different decomposition mechanisms can be expected between the crystalline and gaseous phases of NM. The intermolecular collision probability, for example, is much higher in the condensed phase.
1.9.3 Chemical Mechanism of NM Decomposition Previously reported time-to-explosion measurements on NM up to 5 GPa show that pressure decreases the time to explosion [80]. Therefore, pressure can be expected to have a similar effect on the thermal decomposition rate. If that assumption is correct, then the model for the decomposition reaction mechanism should be at least bimolecular. Considerable work has been reported on the possible chemical reaction pathways for both pyrolysis and detonation processes in NM [60,72]. Most of these proposed mechanisms are based upon a unimolecular process. As far as can be determined, only this work and one other show experimentally that the reaction under pressure results from a bimolecular process, although the reported results were derived from the effect of pressure on time-to-explosion measurements [72]. Based on theoretical electronic orbital calculations, a bimolecular process has been proposed as follows:
H 3C
O
+
N
H3C
N
H O
O
O
H C
N • •
H
H
C H
N H
O
H
H H
O
H • • O •• > C
••>
O
N
O
+
H
O
C H
O
(1.1)
N O
64
G.J. Piermarini
The quantum mechanical calculations show this to be a three-center reaction complex, where, under high pressure, the potential surface contacts result in a simultaneous motion of atoms, indicated by the arrows in the chemical equation, to form the resultant products. The nitrosomethane rapidly reacts to form HCN and finally NH3 and HCOOH as follows: H
H H
C H
N
C
O
N
O
H
HCN
+
HOH
(1.2)
H
At elevated P and T, HCN rapidly hydrolyzes: HCN + 2HOH → NH3 + HCOOH.
(1.3)
The remaining product from reaction (1) rapidly decomposes (reaction 4 not illustrated) into the following possible gaseous compounds: H2 O, N2 O, CO2 , CO, NO, H2 , and solid C. Reaction (1) is rate controlling with a calculated activation energy of 32.5 kcal mol−1 . Reactions (2), (3), and (4) are relatively fast compared with reaction (1). Reactions (3) and (4) provide the pathways for the production of NH3 , HCOOH, and H2 O via chemical reaction with HCN which is known to be a major pyrolysis product of NM [60, 72]. These studies confirm the presence of NH3 , HCOOH, and H2 O along with volatile gases as the major products of thermal decomposition of NM under high pressures. This proposed reaction scheme for NM decomposition at elevated pressures suggests a strong intermolecular interaction of NM in the condensed phase. If this is indeed the case, then it is important to investigate the effect of pressure on the vibrational bands in NM and to analyze the observed shifts in light of intermolecular coupling between the –NO2 and H3 C– groups of interacting molecules. The results from that study support the bimolecular nature of the mechanism for the thermal decomposition of NM under pressure [60, 72].
1.9.4 Compressibility of Explosive Liquids In the remaining part of this chapter, I discuss two articles appearing in the scientific literature related to energetic materials studies at static high pressures, demonstrating novel applications of the DAC not discussed previously. Where applicable, I suggest new areas to investigate to further advance our scientific knowledge, particularly with respect to energetic liquids where little high-pressure work has been done.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
65
Fig. 1.63 A schematic diagram of the volume measurement apparatus, making use of a strain-gage technique to measure sample volume [81]
One innovative technique [81] I want to mention is a novel method for determining the compressibility of explosive liquids, a measurement that has challenged experimentalists for many years (particularly in the very high-pressure regime) because it requires a determination of the volume pressure dependence of the liquid. The method utilizes a lever-arm type DAC, which incorporates a strain-gage transducer system to measure the thickness of a regular shaped liquid sample as it is compressed in a hydrostatic environment. As shown in Fig. 1.63, the strain-gage transducer functions as an electronic caliper to measure changes in the thickness of the sample (gasket thickness) as it is compressed. Planimeter measurements on enlarged photomicrographs of the gasket hole determine area changes. The ruby technique provides the pressure measurement. Thus, the technique permits direct volume change measurements in the DAC by monitoring the gasket hole area and its thickness. Accuracies of 1% or better were reported (Fig. 1.64). Volume measurements on explosive liquids and liquids in general cannot be determined with desired accuracy by x-ray methods appropriate for powders and single crystals. Thus, this unique method has the potential to provide experimental PVT data on liquids for developing equation of state models (Fig. 1.65). This strain-gage transducer method represents an unusual application of the DAC, which has direct relevance to the study of energetic liquids, an area having received little attention because of the complexity involved in measuring volume compression of liquids at very high pressures. This technique, although difficult to carry out, provides a means of obtaining PVT data so essential for developing equation of state models for explosive liquids. In this connection, I refer to a recent publication concerning classical MD simulations of nitromethane (NM) under high compression and high-temperature conditions [82]. In that article theoretical results,
66
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.64 Compressibility data from five samples of n-heptane at 298 K are shown compared to literature values [82]. The agreement is quite satisfactory with a mean square error for a single observation of ±0.013 and for the average of all observations was ±0.003 [81]
Fig. 1.65 For the measurements at 373 K the results are similar to those obtained at room temperature. A mean square error for a single observation was calculated to be ±0.016 and for the average of all observations was ±0.004 [81]
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
67
e.g., thermodynamic functions were compared with experimental compressibility data (density) on NM that were published in 1973, almost 35 years earlier when the accuracy of the pressure scale then in use was not well-characterized. (There was considerable uncertainty in the accuracy of the fixed-point pressure scale used ubiquitously prior to the introduction of the ruby scale.) In 1975, the fixed-point scale was reduced by a factor of 2 in the range above 15 GPa [47]. For some thermodynamic functions, e.g., shock velocity and particle velocity, the classical MD simulation was found to be close to the experimental results. However, the calculated Hugoniot pressure was too high in the high-pressure range, even when other simulation models were applied. There appears to be a deficiency of compressibility data in the scientific literature, not only for explosive liquids, but for liquids in general, probably because of the great difficulty in performing such experiments. While this strain-gage device is, indeed, not easy to use, there is definitely a need to provide more accurate compression data on explosive liquids. The rewards are great for someone adept enough with a DAC (and there are many such individuals now, worldwide) to accomplish such measurements. To illustrate the usefulness of this technique, I refer to a paper reporting the effects of pressure on the vibrational spectra of liquid NM which uses data on the effect of pressure on the specific volume of NM at temperatures of 298 and 373 K [61] (Fig. 1.66). The strain-gage transducer system described above was used
Fig. 1.66 Pressure dependence of the specific volume of NM at 298 and 373 K [61]. The uncertainty associated with the specific volume measurement is ±0.015 cm3 g−1 and with pressure is ±0.025 GPa. The curves were drawn through the center of each data point. At 298 K, the specific volume of NM appears linear with pressure to about 0.4 GPa. At higher pressures, where the superpressed liquid exists, the curve bends rapidly, becoming almost flat due to increasing repulsive forces at those higher densities
68
G.J. Piermarini
Fig. 1.67 Equilibrium pressure/temperature phase diagrams for H2 O and D2 O illustrating the superpressed state of liquid and its behavior as a function of P and T [85]
to obtain the compression data required to compare the observed frequencies of the NO2 stretching modes to the calculated frequency shifts due to intermolecular coupling. To make this comparison it was necessary to estimate from specific volume data the decrease in the intermolecular distance with pressure between interacting pairs of molecules. Another interesting and unique modification is the development of a dynamic diamond anvil cell (dDAC) which permits measurements of pressure/time-dependent phase transformation pathways [83] (Fig. 1.67). The fundamental design of the dDAC consists of a traditional DAC with integrated electromechanical piezoactuators to control the load on the sample. Because of the known anomalous superpressed nature of H2 O and D2 O in the stability regions of phases VI and VII [84, 85], the dDAC instrument was demonstrated on H2 O by observing timeresolved pressure-induced crystallizations of ice VI and ice VII. The authors of this article were able to evaluate the interfacial free energy and were also able to determine that the value for supercompressed water (SW/iceVII) is less than that for (SW/iceVI), indicating that the local order of the supercompressed phase is more similar to crystalline iceVII than crystalline ice VI. This result is consistent with recent studies suggesting that the local order in high density water is bcc-like as in iceVII. The ramifications of this technique when applied to explosive liquids deserve more attention by the energetic materials community. One area to explore further, for example, is the superpressed state of NM. At 298 K, NM freezes to a crystalline solid at 0.40 GPa [61]. The structure of this high-pressure phase is the same as the phase that crystallizes at low temperature and 1 atmosphere (orthorhombic space group P21 21 21 ) [73, 74, 86]. It is also known, however, that liquid NM easily superpresses at RT with the metastable liquid existing to about 2 GPa, where it rapidly
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
69
crystallizes to a polycrystalline phase at 298 K [61]. The metastable liquid exists over a considerable range of pressure (1.6 GPa) before it crystallizes, where it could be studied by various techniques to learn more about this superpressed state. Furthermore, at elevated temperatures, the superpressed state of NM liquid would exist even at higher pressures, a typical behavior of the superpressed liquid state, in general. The two phase diagrams shown above illustrate the anomalous behavior of H2 O and D2 O, i.e., the metastable extension of the liquid–VII phase boundary into the stability field of solid phase VI. Note that at higher temperatures the superpressed liquid exists at higher pressures for both H2 O and D2 O. To determine these phase diagrams polarizing light microscopy was used in conjunction with a DAC equipped with a miniature resistance coil-heating element. The ruby technique was used to measure pressure. This is yet another example of the power of OPLM in determining phase transitions, phase stability fields and phase diagrams. A wealth of valuable scientific knowledge concerning the superpressed state of nitromethane could be obtained by this experimental method of study. Finally, much to my surprise, my recent literature search on α-2,4,6 trinitrotoluene (TNT), which has a low melting point of 80.1◦ C (probably existing as a stable liquid over a significant range of pressure and temperature before decomposition), yielded little information on the P/T equilibrium phase diagram of that important explosive. This compound, in my opinion, would be an ideal candidate for investigation by OPLM in a DAC. Such an investigation could lead to a wealth of knowledge concerning the behavior of TNT both in the solid and liquid states, providing motivation to further study the material by other measurement techniques, e.g., x-ray diffraction, IR and Raman spectroscopy, etc.
1.10 Summary I have attempted to give the reader an overview of the various DAC technologies that were developed in the early period of its growth soon after its invention at the NIST/NBS laboratory and to stress the seminal nature of the advances made, as many of them have been refined by others and are still in use today. In summary, besides the invention of the DAC itself (including high and low temperature capability), other applications to IR spectroscopy, x-ray diffraction (both to powder and single-crystal studies), polarizing light microscopy, Raman spectroscopy, FTIR spectroscopy (including time-dependent studies), were all developments at the NIST/NBS laboratory. Ancillary technologies, including the discovery of hydrostatic pressure-transmitting media, the simple Stokes falling ball methodology for the measurement of viscosity in liquids, and, of course, the all important development of the ruby fluorescence method of pressure measurement, so essential to the success of the of DAC as a quantitative scientific tool, were also seminal advances made at the NIST/NBS laboratory. All of these techniques were discussed in the preceding pages of this chapter. Certainly numerous improvements over these early
70
G.J. Piermarini
methods have been made during the past decades and a discussion of these improvements would be impractical to include in this chapter simply because there are too many of them currently practiced in high-pressure research. All of these methods, in conjunction with a DAC, have proved to be exceedingly useful in the study of energetic materials (as well as in many other research areas), with the result that numerous advances have been made in our scientific understanding of these vital materials. Acknowledgments The author wishes to thank Alan D. Mighell, NIST Research Associate, for his careful and thorough reading of the manuscript and also for his persistent encouragement in writing this chapter. The author also wishes to acknowledge the Ceramics Division of NIST for providing me with a Research Associateship under the sponsorship of Winnie Wong-Ng to support the preparation of this book.
Notes
Certain companies, commercial equipment, instruments, or materials are identified in this document. Such identification neither implies recommendation or endorsement by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, nor does it imply that the products identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose.
˚ throughout the text and in some of the tables The use of “bar”, “poise,” and “angstrom (A)” follow the common practice of workers in the field at the time the research was performed. For the uninitiated, I note that 1 bar = 105 N/m2 (or 105 pascal) = 106 dyn/cm2 = 1.0197 kgf/cm2 . The international standard (SI) unit of pressure is the pascal, or newton per square meter. The SI unit for viscosity is the pascal second (Pa·s), where 1 poise = 0.1 Pa·s. The SI unit for wavelength is ˚ = 0.1 nm. nanometer (nm), where 1 A
References 1. C. E. Weir, E. R. Lippincott, A. Van Valkenburg, E. N. Bunting, (1959) Infrared studies in the 1-micron to 15-micron region to 30,000 atmospheres. J Res Nat Bur Stand, Sect A 63(1), 55–62. 2. G. J. Piermarini, C. E. Weir, (1962) A diamond cell for x-ray diffraction studies at high pressures. J Res Nat Bur Stand, Sect A 66, 325–331. 3. C. E. Weir, (1945) Compression of sole leather. J Res Nat Bur Stand 35(4), 257–271. 4. C. E. Weir, (1948) Effect of temperature on the volume of leather and collagen in water. J Res Nat Bur Stand 41(4), 279–285. 5. C. E. Weir, (1950) High-pressure apparatus for compressibility studies and its application to measurements on leather and collagen. J Res Nat Bur Stand 45(6), 468–476. 6. C. E. Weir, (1954a) Compressibilites of crystalline and glassy modifications of selenium and glucose. J Res Nat Bur Stand 52(5), 247–249. 7. C. E. Weir, (1954b) Temperature dependence of compression of linear high polymers at high pressures. J Res Nat Bur Stand 53(4), 245–252. 8. C. E. Weir, L. Shartsis, (1955) Compressibility of binary alkali borate and silicate glasses at high pressures. J Am Ceram Soc 38(9), 299–306.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
71
9. C. E. Weir, J. D. Hoffman, (1955) Compressibilities of long-chain normal hydrocarbons. J Res Nat Bur Stand 55(6), 307–310. 10. L. H. Adams (Consultant to the Director) (1958) Survey of current high pressure research program at National Bureau of Standards and recommendations regarding future needs in this area. Revised November 19, 1958, NARA RG, Astin File, Box 15. 11. R. A. Paquin, E. Gregory (1963) Modification and calibration of a tetrahedral anvil apparatus, in Giardini AA and Lloyd EC (eds) High pressure measurement. Butterworths, Washington, DC, pp 274–285. 12. E. R. Lippincott, A. Van Valkenburg, C. E. Weir, E. N. Bunting, (1958) Infrared studies on polymorphs of silicon dioxide and germanium dioxide. J Res Nat Bur Stand 61(1), 61–70. 13. J. C. Jamieson, (1957) Introductory studies of high-pressure polymorphism to 24,000 bars by x-ray diffraction with some comments on calcite II. J Geol 65, 334–343. 14. P. W. Bridgman, (1952) The resistance of 72 elements, alloys and compounds to 100,000 kg/cm2 . Proc Am Acad Arts Sci 81, 167–251. 15. P. W. Bridgman, I. Simon, (1953) Effects of very high pressures on glass. J Appl Phys 24, 405–413. 16. E. N. Bunting, A. Van Valkenburg, (1958) Some properties of diamond. Am Mineral 43, 102–106. 17. J. C. Jamieson, A. W. Lawson, N. D. Nachtrieb, (1959) New device for obtaining x-ray diffraction patterns from substances exposed to high pressure. Rev Sci Instrum 30(11), 1016–1019. 18. J. C. Jamieson, A. W. Lawson (1962) Debye-Scherrer x-ray techniques for very high pressure studies in Wentorf RH (ed) Modern very high pressure techniques. Butterworths, Washington, DC, pp 70–91. 19. E. R. Lippincott, C. E. Weir, A. Van Valkenburg, (1960) Infrared studies of dense forms of ice. J Chem Phys 32(2), 612–614. 20. E. R. Lippincott, C. E. Weir, A. Van Valkenburg, E. N. Bunting, (1960) Studies of infrared absorption spectra of solids at high pressures. Spectrochim Acta 16, 58–73. 21. G. J. Piermarini, C. E. Weir, (1962) High-pressure transition in RbF. J Chem Phys 37(8), 1887–1888. 22. C. E. Weir, A. Van Valkenburg, E. R. Lippincott (1962) Optical studies at high pressures using diamond anvils in R. H. Wentorf (ed) Modern very high pressure techniques. Butterworths, Washington, DC, pp 51–69. 23. Alvin Van Valkenburg Biographical File. Archives Collection, Information Services Division. National Institute of Standards and Technology. Gaithersburg, MD. 24. R.J. Schneller Jr (2005) Breaking the color barrier: The U.S. naval academy’s first black midshipman and the struggle for racial equality, New York University Press, New York, pp 65–67. 25. Charles Edward Weir Biographical File. Archives Collection, Information Services Division. National Institute of Standards and Technology. Gaithersburg, MD. 26. Elmer Newman Bunting Biographical File. Archives Collection, Information Services Division. National Institute of Standards and Technology. Gaithersburg, MD. 27. Obituary of Ellis Ridgeway Lippincott. The Washington Post, December 28, 1974. 28. A. Van Valkenburg A (1963) High-pressure microscopy, in Giardini AA, Lloyd EC (eds) High pressure measurement. Butterworths, Washington, DC, pp 87–94. 29. A. Van Valkenburg, (1970) High pressure optics. Appl Opt 9(1), 1–4. 30. S. Block, C. E. Weir, G. J. Piermarini, (1965) High-pressure single-crystal studies of ice VI. Science 148, 947–948. 31. G. J. Piermarini, C. E. Weir, (1964) Allotropy in some rare earth metals at high pressures. Science 144, (3614) 69–71. 32. C. E. Weir, G. J. Piermarini, (1964) Lattice parameters and lattice energies of high- pressure polymorphs of some alkali halides. J Res Nat Bur Stand, Sect A 68(1), 105–111. 33. C. Weir, G. Piermarini, S. Block, (1965) Single-crystal x-ray diffraction at high pressures. J Res Nat Bur Stand, Sect C 69(4), 275–281. 34. S. Block, C. E. Weir, G. J. Piermarini, (1965) High-pressure single crystal studies of ice VI. Science 148(3672), 947–948.
72
G.J. Piermarini
35. A. Santoro, C. E. Weir, S. Block, G. J. Piermarini, (1968) Absorption corrections in complex cases. Application to single crystal diffraction studies at high pressure. J Appl Crystallogr 1, 101–107. 36. G. J. Piermarini, A. D. Mighell, C. E. Weir, S. Block, (1969) Crystal structure of benzene II at 25 kbar. Science 165, 1250–1255. 37. G. J. Piermarini, A. B. Braun, (1973) Crystal and molecular structure of CCl4 -III: A high pressure polymorph at 10 kbar. J Chem Phys 58(5), 1974–1982. 38. C. E. Weir, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, (1969) Instrumentation for single crystal x-ray diffraction at high pressures. Rev Sci Instrum 40(9), 1133–1136. 39. C. E. Weir, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, (1969) Crystallography of some high-pressure forms of C6 H6 , CS2 , Br2 , CCl4 , and KNO3 . J Chem Phys 50(5), 2089–2093. 40. C. E. Weir, S. Block, G. J. Piermarini, (1970) Compressibility of inorganic azides. J Chem Phys 53(11), 4265–4269. 41. R. A. Forman, G. J. Piermarini, J. D. Barnett, S. Block, (1972) Pressure measurement made by the utilization of ruby sharp-line luminescence. Science 176, 284–285. 42. J. D. Barnett, S. Block, G. J. Piermarini, (1973) Optical fluorescence system for quantitative pressure measurement in the diamond-anvil cell. Rev Sci Instrum 44(1), 1–9. 43. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, J. D. Barnett, R. A. Forman, (1975) Calibration of the pressure dependence of the R1 ruby fluorescence line to 195 kbar. J Appl Phys 46, 2774–2780. 44. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, J. D. Barnett, (1973) Hydrostatic limits in liquids and solids to 100 kbar. J Appl Phys 44, 5377–5382. 45. G. J. Piermarini, R. A. Forman, S. Block, (1978) Viscosity measurements in the diamond anvil pressure cell. Rev Sci Instrum 49, 1061–1066. 46. M. I. Eremets (1996) Chapter 3, The diamond anvil cell. in High pressure experimental methods, Oxford University Press, New York, pp 49–92. 47. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, (1975) Ultrahigh pressure diamond-anvil cell and several semiconductor phase transition pressures in relation to the fixed point pressure scale. Rev Sci Instrum 46, 973–979. 48. W. Thomson (1891) Lecture to the Institution of Civil Engineers, May 3, 1883, Popular Lectures and Addresses by Sir William Thomson (London/New York, Macmillan) vol. 1, p 80. 49. H. K. Mao, P. M. Bell, (1978) High pressure physics: Sustained static generation of 1.36 to 1.72 Megabars. Science 200, 1145–1147. 50. W. A. Bassett, T. Takahashi, P. W. Stook, (1967) X-ray diffraction and optical observations on crystalline solids up to 300 kbar. Rev Sci Instrum 38, 37–42. 51. G. Huber, K. Syassen, W. B. Holzapfel, (1977) Pressure dependence of 4f levels in euopium pentaphosphate up to 400 kbars. Phys Rev B 15, 5123–5128. 52. L. Merrill, W. A. Bassett, (1974) Miniature diamond anvil pressure cell for single crystal x-ray diffraction studies. Rev Sci Instrum 45, 290–294. 53. S. Block, G. Piermarini, (1976) The diamond cell stimulates high-pressure research. Phys Today 29(9), 44–55. 54. I. Fujishiro, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, R. G. Munro (1982) Viscosities and glass transition pressures in the methanol-ethanol-water system, in C. M. Backman, T. Johannisson, L. Tegner (eds) High pressure in research and industry. 8th AIRAPT Conference Proceedings, Arkitektkopia. Uppsala, Sweden, Vol. II, pp 608–611. 55. Y. B. Zel’dovich, Y.P. Raiser (1966) Physics of Shockwaves and High Temperature Hydrodynamic Phenomena, Academic Press, New York. 56. R. D. Bardo, T. N. Hall, M. J. Kamlet, (1982) Energies and volumes of activation for condensed detonating explosives. J Chem Phys 77(11), 5858–5859. 57. R. D. Bardo, T. N. Hall, M. J. Kamlet, (1979) Volumes of activation in the shock initiation of explosives. Combust Flame 35(3), 259–265. 58. P. J. Miller, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, (1984) An FT-IR microscopic method for kinetic measurements at high temperatures and high pressures. Appl Spectrosc 38, 680–686. 59. P. J. Miller, S. Block, G. J. Piermarini, (1991) Effects of pressure on the thermal decomposition kinetics, chemical reactivity and phase behavior of RDX. Combust Flame 83, 174–184.
1 Diamond Anvil Cell Techniques
73
60. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, P. J. Miller, (1989) Effects of pressure on the thermal decomposition kinetics and chemical reactivity of nitromethane. J Phys Chem 93, 457–462. 61. P. J. Miller, S. Block, G. J. Piermarini, (1989) Effects of pressure on the vibrational spectra of liquid nitromethane. J Phys Chem 93, 462–466. 62. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, P. J. Miller, (1987) Effects of pressure and temperature on the thermal decomposition rate and reaction mechanism of β-Octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7tetrazocine. J Phys Chem 91(14), 3872–3878. 63. T. P. Russell, P. J. Miller, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block (1993) Pressure/temperature/reaction phase diagrams for several nitramine compounds, in L. H. Liebenberg, R. W. Armstrong, J. J. Gilman (eds) Structure and properties of energetic materials. Materials Research Society Symposium Proceedings, Pittsburgh, PA, pp 199–213. 64. T. P. Russell, P. J. Miller, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, (1992) High-pressure phase transition in γ-hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane. J Phys Chem 96(13), 5509–5512. 65. T. P. Russell, P. J. Miller, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, (1993) Pressure/temperature phase diagram of Hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane. J Phys Chem 97(9), 1993–1997. 66. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, R. Damavarapu, S. Iyer, (1991) 1,4-Dinitrocubane and cubane under high pressure. Propellants Explos Pytotech 16, 188–193. 67. T. P. Russell, G. J. Piermarini, P. J. Miller, (1997) Pressure/temperature and reaction phase diagram for dinitro azetidinium dinitramide. J Phys Chem B 101, 3566–3570. 68. T. P. Russell, G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, P. J. Miller, (1996) Pressure, temperature reaction phase diagram for ammonium dinitramide. J Phys Chem 100, 3248–3251. 69. R. W. Shaw, T. B. Brill, D. L. Thompson (2005) In Overviews of recent research on energetic materials, Advanced Series in Physical Chemistry, World Publishing, Singapore, Vol. 16. 70. W. C. McCrone, (1950) RDX (Cyclotrimethylenetrinitramine). Anal Chem 22(7), 954–955. 71. R. J. Karpowicz, S. T. Sergio, T. B. Brill, (1983) Beta-polymorph of hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitros-triazine. A Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy study of an energetic material. Ind Eng Chem Prod Res Dev 22(2), 363–365. 72. G. J. Piermarini, S. Block, P. J. Miller (1990) Effects of pressure on the thermal decomposition rates, chemical reactivity, and phase behavior of HMX, RDX and nitromethane, in Bulusu SN (ed) Chemistry and physics of energetic materials. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 391–412. 73. S. Courtecuisse, F. Cansell, D. Fabre, J. P. Petitet (1995) A Raman spectroscopic study of nitromethane up to 350◦ C and 35 GPa. J Phys IV (Paris) 5, C4–359–363. 74. D. T. Cromer, R. R. Ryan, D. Schiferl, (1985) The structure of nitromethane at pressures of 0.3 to 6.0 GPa. J Phys Chem 89, 2315–2318. 75. J. W. Brasch, (1980) Irreversible reaction of nitromethane at elevated pressure and temperature. J Phys Chem 84, 2084–2085. 76. R. Ouillon, J. P. Pinan-Lacarr´e, P. Ranson, (2002) Low-temperature Raman spectra of nitromethane single crystals. Lattice dynamics and Davydov splittings. J Chem Phys 116, (11) 4611–4625. 77. J. P. Pinan-Lacarre, R. Ouillon, B. Canny, P. Pruzan, P. Ranson, (2003) Pressure effect at room temperature on the low-energy Raman spectra of nitromethane-h(3) and –d(3) up to 45 GPa. J Raman Spectrosc 34, 819–825. 78. S. F. Rice, M. F. Foltz, (1991) Very high pressure combustion: Reaction propagation rates of nitromethane within a diamond anvil cell. Combust Flame 87(2), 109–122. 79. W. E. Brown, D. Dollimore, A. K. Galwey (1980) Reactions in the Solid State in C. H. Bamford, C. H. F. Tipper (eds) Comprehensive Chemical Kinetics, Vol 22, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Chap. 3, pp 0–340. 80. E. L. Lee, R. H. Sanborn, H. D. Stromberg (1970) Thermal decomposition of high explosives at static pressures to 50 Kbar. Proc 5th Symp (Int) Detonation, pp 331–337. 81. J. W. Brasch, (1980) Techniques for compressibility measurements on explosive materials using an opposed diamond-anvsil optical cell. Rev Sci Instrum 51, 1358–1362.82. Bridgman PW (1932) Volume-temperature-pressure relations for several non-volatile liquids. Proc Am Acad Arts Sci 67, 1–27. 82. H. Liu, J. Zhao, G. Ji, Z. Gong, D. Wei, (2006) Compressibility of liquid nitromethane in the high-pressure regime. Phys B 382, 334–339.
74
G.J. Piermarini
83. G. W. Lee, W. J. Evans, C. S. Yoo, (2006) Crystallization of water in a dynamic diamond-anvil cell: Evidence for ice VII-like local order in supercompressed water. Phys Rev B 74, (134112) 1–6. 84. K. Yamamoto, (1980) Supercooling of the coexisting state of Ice VII and water within Ice VI region observed in diamond-anvil pressure cells. Jpn J Appl Phys 19(10), 1841–1845. 85. G. J. Piermarini, R. G. Munro, S. Block(1984) Metastability in the H2 O and D2 O systems at high pressure. Mat Res Soc Symp Proc, vol 22, Elsevier Science, pp 25–28. 86. S. F. Trevino, E. Prince, C. R. Hubbard (1980) Refinement of the structure of solid nitromethane. J Chem Phys 73(6), 2996–3000.
Chapter 2
Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material Mikhail I. Eremets, Ivan A. Trojan, Alexander G. Gavriliuk, and Sergey A. Medvedev
2.1 Introduction Pure nitrogen can be considered as a material with optimized storage of chemical energy because of the huge difference in energy between triply bonded di-nitrogen and singly bonded nitrogen. N ≡ N bond is one of the strongest chemical bonds known, containing 4.94 eV atom−1 while the N–N bond is much weaker with −0.83 eV atom−1 [1]. Therefore when transforming from singly bonded nitrogen to diatomic triply bonded molecular nitrogen, a large amount of energy should be released: about 2.3 eV atom−1 . Or, in other words, this chemical energy can be ideally stored by transforming a triple bond into three single bonds. Thus, nitrogen may form a high-energy density material with energy content higher than that of any known nonnuclear material. The greatest utility of fully single-bonded nitrogen would be as high explosives. Here, a tenfold improvement in detonation pressure over HMX (one the more powerful high explosives) seems possible [2]. A chemical approach for synthesis of nitrogen-energetic materials is creating large all-nitrogen molecules or clusters bound by single (N–N) or single and double (N = N) bonds. Calculations predict different polynitrogen molecules or clusters [3] such as, for instance, N4 , N8 , N20 , or even nitrogen fullerene N60 (see for review Refs [3–5]) with high-energy-storage capacity. However, none of them has yet been synthesized with exception of N4 (TdN4 ) [6], albeit with a very short lifetime of ∼1 μs [6]. Synthesis of compounds having several nitrogen atoms consecutively is difficult because the single bond in nitrogen is relatively weak. It has been achieved only in compounds with other atoms. For instance, HN3 and other azides with linearN3 radical have been synthesized by Curtius in 1890 [7]. Only recently N5 + was synthesized by Christe and coworkers [8]. On the basis of the N3 − and N5 + species nearly all nitrogen compounds were synthesized by attaching these radicals to a central atom of Te, B, and P such as N5 P(N3 )6 , N5 B(N3 )4 , Te(N3 )4 , and others (see for review Refs [2, 9–11]).
S.M. Peiris, G.J. Piermarini (eds.), Static Compression of Energetic Materials, Shock Wave and High Pressure Phenomena, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2008
75
76
M.I. Eremets et al.
Presented here is an ultimate case of pure single-bonded nitrogen which can be synthesized at high pressures and temperatures from common triply bonded molecular nitrogen. At high pressures molecules of nitrogen approach each other and start interacting so strongly that intramolecular interaction becomes comparable with intermolecular interaction, and therefore di-nitrogen molecules can dissociate to atomic nitrogen. Atoms of nitrogen with three directed covalent bonds can further create a three-dimensional network popularly termed polymeric nitrogen. Such transformations have been predicted long time ago [12, 13] to happen at high pressures of ≈50 GPa, but it was found experimentally at much high pressures of ∼200 GPa [14] at low temperatures, and then at a slightly lower pressures of 150 GPa and room temperature [15]. This apparently nonmolecular nitrogen has a disordered network of single- and double-bonded atoms as follows from calculations [16, 17]. Next important step in the preparation of polymeric nitrogen was the theoretical prediction of single-bonded crystalline nitrogen where each nitrogen atom is connected with three other with single bonds [18]. It has a cubic symmetry structure but with an unusual arrangement of atoms: the cubic gauche structure (referred to as cg-N or CG) of the I21 3 space group. This structure was recently fully confirmed experimentally [19–22]. Theoretical calculations also agree that the cg-N structure is the most stable among possible proposed single-bonded nitrogen networks [23–29]. This polymeric nitrogen is a unique material. First of all, it has very high accumulated energy: about 1.2–1.5 eV atom−1 releases during the transformation from cg-N to N2 [16–18, 30]. This is 5.5 times higher (energy/mass ratio) when compared to the powerful explosive hexogen [17]. At the same time cg-N is similar to diamond in terms of values of lattice parameters and low compressibility. Thus it could be a hard (or superhard) material with ultimate high-energy capacitance. Importantly, polymeric nitrogen is predicted to be metastable at ambient pressure [18], and an amorphous polymeric nitrogen indeed has been recovered to ambient pressure at low temperatures [14]. Cg-N was proved experimentally to be metastable at least down to 25 GPa. This chapter describes the synthesis and properties of polymeric nitrogen in more detail, and also discusses other polymeric structures which are predicted to be competitive with the cg-N phase in some pressure range [23, 25–28, 31–33]. Finally we mention attempts to decrease the pressure of polymerization by using precursors different from pure nitrogen. Instead of compressing diatomic nitrogen, molecular N3 − anions in the lattice of NaN3 were examined [34,35]. The N3 − anion is a straight chain of three nitrogen atoms linked essentially with double bonds. It can be considered as a molecule which is more weakly bonded than the diatomic triple-bonded nitrogen. Therefore, it could be expected that the N3 − molecules will create polymeric single-covalent bond networks easier than diatomic nitrogen. New structures that are distinct from linear N3 − -ion-based molecular phases were found near ambient pressure after laser heating [34]. In Ref. [35] the photolytic decomposition of sodium azide under UV pulse irradiation was studied. The resultant product, speculated to be N7 − , was found to be unstable at room pressure and temperature.
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
77
2.2 Polymeric Nitrogen In this section we will present our results on synthesis and properties of polymeric single-bonded nitrogen. When nitrogen atoms are connected with single bonds into a polymeric network it could be a high-energy density material (HEDM). Moreover, polymeric nitrogen should be environmentally clean because the final product of the transformation is nitrogen. This polymeric nitrogen material could also be an ideal rocket fuel or propellant. A way to create an atomic solid with a single-bonded crystalline structure is application of high pressures, as predicted in 1985 by McMahan and LeSar [12]. Simple cubic or distorted sc structures similar to other group-V elements were calculated. This transformation is expected to accompany with a large drop of volume and considerable hysteresis. This new material can be called “polymeric nitrogen”: the starting dimer is the molecular nitrogen while the final product is a crystal built with single covalent bonds. We note here that nitrogen behaves uniquely under pressure. If we compare it with other molecular solids such as H2 , O2 , I2 , and others [36], they are double-covalent bonded and at high pressure transform to metals while nitrogen first transforms to an insulating covalent crystal. Nitrogen also is different from other elements of group V. For instance, the stable form of phosphorus at ambient pressure is a P4 molecule where atoms are connected to each other by single bonds. The reason of this difference is simple: atoms of phosphorous are significantly larger than nitrogen atoms and therefore longer single bonds are preferable. At high pressure nitrogen also does not follow the sequence of phase transformations typical for group-V elements. Mailhiot et al. [18] found that nitrogen behaves uniquely under pressure: molecular nitrogen transforms into a lattice of single-bonded atoms with cubic gauche structure (cg-N). This unusual structure naturally follows from the directed covalent bonds: the dihedral angle in a N–N single bond energetically prefers a gauche conformation [18] as can be seen, for instance, in the molecule of hydrazine. As a result this structure theoretically is much more preferable (Fig. 2.1): it has significantly lower (0.86 eV atom−1 ) total energy than previously considered phases. This has been confirmed in numerous calculations [17, 23–28, 30, 32, 37–44]. Mailhiot et al. [18] calculated the volume, bulk modulus, and other properties of cg-N. This transformation should happen at ≈50 GPa and be accompanied with a dramatic drop of volume (∼20%) and complete change of the phonon spectrum. The cg-N phase was predicted to be metastable at ambient pressure. All this gave clear information for experimental proof. However, the experiments that followed did not reveal any transition in this pressure range while a darkening [45] and nearly opaque state [46] has been observed at the highest pressures up to 180 GPa [46]. Transformation to nonmolecular nitrogen finally came with the dramatic disappearance of the molecular vibron [14] at 190 GPa at low temperatures from transparent to an opaque phase. The same transition was also seen in measurements at room and elevated temperatures [15, 47, 48]. It was found that this transformation has a huge hysteresis [14]. Therefore, the value of equilibrium pressure is about 100 GPa [14] – much lower than the pressure of direct transformation, and closer
78
M.I. Eremets et al.
Fig. 2.1 Polymeric phases of nitrogen. Total energy per atom calculated for the threefoldcoordinated arsenic (A7), black-phosphorus (BP), and cubic gauche (cg) phases of nitrogen, and for a twofold-coordinated chainlike (ch) phase of nitrogen, as a function of atomic volume (after Mailhiot et al. [18])
to the theoretical [18] calculations. Moreover, the hysteresis was so large that it allowed the nonmolecular nitrogen to be recovered at low temperatures [14]. Though the nonmolecular nitrogen has properties close to those predicted for the polymeric nitrogen [18], the material was a narrow-gap semiconductor [14, 16, 47], which is in contradiction to the predicted dielectric cg-N. First-principle simulations elucidated the structure of the opaque phase: an amorphous or disordered network of single- and double-bonded nitrogen atoms [16, 17] as shown in Fig. 2.2a. However, there is no direct experimental evidence that the nonmolecular phase creates a polymeric network. Available optical data only indicate the amorphous nature for this material [14, 16, 47]. This can be seen, for instance, from Fig. 2.2b where only very broad bands are present in the Raman spectrum. Next decisive step towards polymeric nitrogen was done with laser heating of molecular nitrogen above 100 GPa [19]. Here a direct transformation of molecular nitrogen to a new transparent phase, which turned out to be the long sought after polymeric nitrogen was found. Polymeric nitrogen was synthesized at T > 2,000 K at P > 110 GPa. These record parameters were achieved from a novel arrangement of the diamond anvil cell (Fig. 2.3). First, a gasket compacted from powdered cubic boron nitride (cBN) mixed with epoxy was used [49]. This gasket is 1.5–2 times thicker (8–10 μm at 60 GPa) than typical hard gasket materials such as Re or W at the same pressure. This allows larger sample volumes. Also, this increases the gap between the boron laser radiation absorber (that heats the sample) and the anvils (Fig. 2.3), a precondition to achieving very high temperatures at megabar pressures. Second, the cell was specifically designed for use in with challenging x-ray diffraction measurements. X-ray diffraction measurements of a nitrogen sample (which is a light element and a weak scatterer) at pressures up to 170 GPa were performed
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
79
220 GPa 170 GPa 165 GPa
N2 phonons
a
b
Raman intensity
Intensity (arb. units)
488 nm laser line excitation
Ratio Ramanto-luminescence 50-80
N2 vibrons
1000 2000 3000 Raman shift (cm−1)
c
0
2000
4000
Raman shift (cm−1)
Fig. 2.2 Amorphous polymeric nitrogen. (a) Structure of low-coordinated (Z = 3–4) nitrogen at ambient pressure at 100 K produced by simulations showing atom positions and bonds between them (from Ref. [16]). (b) Raman spectra of nitrogen at megabar pressures at 300 K taken through diamond anvils having a negligible own luminescence as can be seen from (c) where Raman spectra from 15 anvils are presented which perfectly coincide: only first- and second-order Raman peaks from diamond are in the spectra
at the ID9 beam line at ESRF [50]. The cBN gasket is extremely advantageous in x-ray diffraction studies: it produces only a few weak peaks comparable with nitrogen in intensity. Also, boron as an absorber of the 1.064 μm laser radiation was used (Fig. 2.3a). Importantly, boron is a very weak scatterer of x-rays and a signal produced by a 1 μm thick plate does not interfere with the diffraction pattern from the nitrogen sample. Moreover, the weak diffraction peaks from boron are uniformly distributed over a wide spectrum without strong peaks [51]. The boron plate was formed by pressing nanoparticles of amorphous boron of 99.99% purity. Boron is initially a semiconductor and transforms to a poor metal at megabar pressures [49]. It is a good absorber of the 1.06 mm laser radiation, however it violently reacts with nitrogen at T > 1,800 K and pressures <15 GPa [52]. At megabar pressures this reaction is nearly suppressed. We observed small color changes at the center of the boron plate at the highest temperatures that are likely due to formation of cBN, as evident from well-recognized peaks of cBN in the diffraction pattern (Fig. 2.3). However, the thin boron/cBN plate remained opaque, and heating was very stable to the highest temperatures allowing reliable temperature measurements [53]. Note, that at pressure below ∼50 GPa reaction of boron with nitrogen becomes marked. Heating to high temperature released stress inside the sample, resulted in sharp x-ray diffraction peaks (Fig. 2.3), and dramatically increased the accuracy of the measurements. For pressure measurements ruby luminescence was used [54]. For that a micrometer-sized piece of ruby was placed at the edge of the gasket hole. To study the possible reaction of ruby with nitrogen, ruby was omitted in another experiment, yielding the same result. The pressure in this experiment was determined from the sharp high-frequency edge of the diamond anvil [55]. The diamond anvil cell of original construction was described elsewhere [56]. Nitrogen gas compressed to 2,500 bars was loaded at room temperature. Very low-luminescence synthetic
80
M.I. Eremets et al.
Fig. 2.3 X-ray diffraction measurements of nitrogen after heating to 2,600 K at 140 GPa. (a) A cross section of the sample arrangement. The heating ∼1 μm-thick boron plate (absorber of laser radiation; black) rests on cBN pieces that thermally insulate the plate from the bottom anvil. The sample squeezed between the anvils is surrounded by the cBN/epoxy gasket followed by the metallic (Re) supporting ring. The culet of diamond anvil is of diameter 90 μm. X-ray diffraction was ˚ wavelength focused to a spot of diammeasured with a monochromatic X-ray beam with 0.4168 A eter ∼5 μm. (b) X-ray patterns taken across the culet of diamond anvil to distinguish between the input from the gasket and the different phases of the sample. Spectra taken from the most heated part (±5 μm) were attributed to the new phase of nitrogen. At the gasket only pure cBN patterns are present. At the edge of the nitrogen sample (r = −15 μm) there is a significant input from the molecular phase at the 10◦ –14◦ range. The black and grey vertical lines indicated calculated positions of reflections corresponding to cg-N and cBN, respectively
diamonds (Fig. 2.2) with flats of diameter 95 μm beveled at 10◦ to 380 μm culet and 60–90 μm flats were used in other runs. Raman spectra before and after heating
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
81
were recorded with a single grating monochromator, notch-filters, cooled CCD and argon and Ti-sapphire lasers at the 458–800 nm spectral range. In a typical run, the pressure was increased up to 140 GPa at 300 K until the sample started to darken. At this pressure, the sample was heated in steps with intermediate recordings of Raman spectra at room temperature. After the first heating to 980 K, the transformation accelerated. The sample darkened further, but it remained in the molecular state – the vibrons in the Raman spectra of nitrogen did not change. The high-frequency edge from the diamond anvils sharpened, indicating uniform pressure distribution, which dropped to 120 GPa. No further changes were observed after heating up to 1,400 K. After heating to 1,700 K, the sample further darkened and the intensity of the vibron of nitrogen significantly decreased. At 1,980 K, the vibron peaks became indistinguishable from the background, all wide bands in the low-frequency part of spectrum disappeared, and luminescence measured from the nitrogen sample significantly increased. A ring around the absorber appeared, likely due to melting of the sample. Instead of further darkening, unexpectedly, the sample became transparent (the absorber plate became clearly visible in reflected light). After successive heating up to 2,500 and 2,600 K, the transparent colorless part spread out over a larger area and could be seen in transmitted light. The nitrogen at the edge of the gasket hole was not heated to the high temperatures and remained dark. The pressure in the center of the sample reduced to 115 GPa. Thus, a dramatic transition happened at 115 GPa at temperatures above ∼2,000 K. X-ray diffraction patterns were accumulated from different parts of the sample across the culet in order to distinguish between the contribution from the gasket and the different phases of the sample (Fig. 2.3). In the center of the sample there are up to five reflections of the new phase of nitrogen and two reflections from cBN. These reflections are clearly different: the nitrogen rings are spotty while the cBN ring is not. In addition, the intensity of the cBN peaks varies from point to point of the scan, and at some places the reflections almost disappear. We fitted the measured x-ray diffraction spectra by the cubic gauche structure of nitrogen (cg-N) and cBN. cg-N has the following parameters: space group I21 3, ˚ sites 8a, x = 0.067. We tried also to fit the spectra to different proa0 = 3.4542 A, posed polymeric structures [12,13,17,25,37] as well as boron from the absorber [51] instead of the cg-N structure, but without satisfactory results. The cg-N structure is schematically shown in Fig. 2.4. All nitrogen atoms are threefold coordinated and bond-lengths are the same for all pairs of bonded atoms. At a pressure of 115 GPa ˚ and the angle between bonds is 108.87◦ . We also dethe bond length is 1.346 A termined the cg-N structure upon decreasing pressure down to 42 GPa (Fig. 2.4c). We fitted the experimental points measured in the 42–134 GPa range with BirchMurnaghan equation of states (EOS) extrapolated to zero pressure with the follow˚ [3]. The cg-N ing parameters: bulk modulus B0 = 298 GPa, B = 4.0,V0 = 6.592 A is a stiff solid as follows from the high value of B0 which is characteristic for strong covalent solids (B0 = 365 GPa for cBN [57]). The bulk modulus determined from different types of EOSs lies in the range of 300–340 GPa. The determined value of ˚ [3] predicted in Ref. [18]. atomic volume V0 is close to 6.67 A
82
M.I. Eremets et al.
Fig. 2.4 Cubic gauche (cg-N) structure. Each atom of nitrogen is connected to three neighbors with three single covalent bonds. (a) The primitive cell, (b) an extended structure of the polymeric nitrogen. (c) The EOS of cg-N structure. Extrapolation of this EOS to zero pressure gives a volume ˚ [3] – in excellent agreement with theoretical predictions of 6.67 A ˚ of cg-N structure about 6.6 A [3] (Ref. [18])
Fig. 2.5 Diffraction from cg-N synthesized at 110 GPa in diamond anvil cell with laser heating. (a) Diffraction peaks from two experiments. Grey lines relates to the arrangement with boron absorber heated to 2,000 K and rhenium gasket. Black lines: CVD diamond plate heated to 2,500 K, gasket was prepared from cBN powder mixed with small amount epoxy. Numbers and rods are indexes and position of reflections calculated according to the cubic gauche structure. The peaks are obtained by integration of spots at diffraction pattern shown in (b) for the case of a cell with side-input for x-ray beam and combination of boron heater and Re gasket
The cg-N structure has been further confirmed in many experiments [20–22]. For instance, more x-ray reflections were obtained to check cg-N structure [58]. For that a diamond anvil cell, which allows collection of diffraction at higher angles has been built. It has an additional side-input at 15◦ to the axes of the cell. If the x-ray goes through this window the diffraction rays can be observed up to 35◦ . An example of the x-ray diffraction for this side-input geometry is shown in Fig. 2.5. Thus two new 321 and 330 reflections of cg-N structure were found. In other experiments with this geometry but with different arrangement of the gasket and the heater 402
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
83
and 332 reflections in addition were obtained. Altogether nine reflections from the sample were collected. These reflections were observed also because instead of a fine powder of cg-N larger crystallites were grown which can give strong reflections at large angles. For that, the synthesis temperature was kept as low as possible at a given pressure, and the heating time was increased to minutes. Thus conditions of equilibrium growth were approached. An absorber of the laser radiation gives an additional complication for analysis and interpretation of the experiment. Therefore, cg-N also has been attempted to synthesize with laser heating but without any absorber. Nitrogen at pressures above ∼130 GPa significantly absorbs itself and it was successfully heated directly with YAG laser radiation resulting x-ray diffraction and Raman spectra of cg-N [20–22]. To summarize, we found the cg-structure which was considered theoretically as the most energetically favorable single-bonded structure [17, 23–28, 30, 32, 37–44] and originally proposed by Mailhiot et al. [18]. This is a new allotrope of nitrogen where all atoms are connected with single covalent bonds. To our knowledge, this unusual cubic phase has not been observed previously in any element.
cg-N
110 GPa
40000
Wavenumber (cm-1)
Raman intensity, arb. units
1600
´10
1200
800 0
a
800
1000
1200
Raman shift, cm-1
b
0
50
100
150
Pressure (GPa)
Fig. 2.6 Raman scattering from the cubic gauche polymeric nitrogen. (a) Raman spectrum from a large sample of cg-N at 120 GPa. A small intensity doublet at 963 cm−1 has been magnified for clarity. (b) Pressure dependence of Raman modes of the cg-N phase. Points are taken from different experiments. Lines are theoretical calculations [24]. The shadow area indicates width of Raman band from the stressed diamond anvils which covers the high-energy Raman lines of cg-N
84
M.I. Eremets et al.
2.2.1 Raman Spectra of cg-N Transformation to cg-N phase was accompanied with a dramatic change of vibration spectra: after disappearing of the molecular vibron a new Raman peak in the cg-N phase was observed (Fig. 2.6). This is a fingerprint of transformation. The new peak is easily detected and it is strong in some samples. The position of this peak and its pressure dependence well follows calculations for cg-N phase [39] (Fig. 2.6). However, puzzlingly only one peak was observed in all experiments while four peaks are expected from the symmetry I21 3 of cg-structure. Only recently this problem has been resolved. From theoretical side, intensities of Raman peaks along with their positions have been calculated in Ref. [24] and it was found that only one peak dominates, others should be much weaker. Experimentally this was confirmed by obtaining a strong Raman signal from a large sample. It was grown in a diamond cell with anvil culets of the toroidal shape [22] (Fig. 2.7). This shape dramatically
250
40 μm
200
Intensity
cg-N 150
2000 K
100
second heating 1200 K 1400 K 1300 K
50
Molecular phase 297 K
0 6
a
8
10
12
14
2Θ (λ=0.3344 A)
16
18
b
Fig. 2.7 X-ray diffraction measurements of nitrogen at 140 GPa measured in situ at different temperatures. (a) The X-ray Diffraction spectra were obtained by integrating the CCD image patterns (shown at (b)) and extracting the background. Star indicates the cBN peak. X-ray beam with ˚ wavelength was focused to a spot of diameter ≈ 5 μm and collimated by a 20 μm pinhole. 0.3344 A The radiation from the YAG laser was focused in the same place. Toroidal profile of diamond anvil culets is shown in inset (a)
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
85
increases the high-pressure volume and allows large samples to be obtained and consequently to have intensive x-ray diffraction (Fig. 2.7) and Raman spectra (Fig. 2.6). Thus we were able to analyze the Raman spectrum of cg-N in detail and to find one more additional weak split peak (Fig. 2.6). Its position as well as the intensities (which are ∼100 times smaller than that of the dominated Raman peak) coincides well with the calculations [24, 39]. The remaining two weak peaks owing to cg-N structure [24, 39] can be hidden under the strong background of the Raman band from the stressed diamond anvils (the dashed area at Fig. 2.6).
2.2.2 Control Experiments In the experiments performed at high temperatures T > 2,000 K, reaction of hot nitrogen with heater or surrounding gasket or diamonds is not excluded. Therefore, we had done numerous checking experiments to insure that the observed Raman and xray diffraction signals belong to cg-N, not to a product of interaction of nitrogen with gasket, absorber, or diamond. Different combinations of absorber and gasket materials (boron–cBN, boron–rhenium, -TiN–rhenium, beryllium–cBN, hBN–rhenium) results in the same x-ray diffraction pattern and Raman spectrum manifesting synthesis of cg-N. The following two arrangements are mostly evident: (a) absorber made of CVD (diamond grown by chemical vapor deposition) diamond plate and cBN/epoxy gasket, and (b) boron absorber and Re gasket. In both cases we obtained only x-ray reflections corresponding to the cg-N structure. This means that the observed diffraction pattern does not relate to compounds of nitrogen with rhenium or boron. Reaction with carbon is also excluded because the CVD plate heater apparently does not react with nitrogen at temperatures of up to 2,500 K: diffraction from the heated polycrystalline CVD plate presents only diamond rings which have same intensity as the unheated plate. We also did not observe any Raman peaks in the range of 200–3,500 cm−1 except of the cg-N peak at ≈830 cm−1 and the vibron of a small intensity – a reminder of incomplete transformation of molecular nitrogen. Reaction with diamond anvils is also excluded for the following reason. We know that molecular nitrogen nearly completely transforms at the new phase (the molecular vibron disappeared). The thickness of the nitrogen sample in our experiments was ∼5 μm. This means that diamond anvils should be etched at >1 μm in depth to create a hypothetical carbonitride compound. We did not see any changes at the surface of the anvils after the experiments while submicroscopic changes can be easily seen with the interference microscope. Indeed, in rare cases occasionally we damaged the diamond surface with sharply focused laser radiation but these spots were visually easy to identify. In addition, Raman spectra from the damaged areas revealed peaks related to carbonitrides but not the cg-N peak. Finally, diamonds are warmed to less than 100◦ during laser heating, as we measured with a Pt thermometer (Pt foil touched to an anvil). Therefore, reaction of nitrogen with diamonds is unlikely.
86
M.I. Eremets et al.
2.3 Transformation from Molecular to Polymeric Nitrogen In this section we will discuss details of transformation of molecular to polymeric nitrogen. First, we estimate a minimum pressure of the phase transformation. For that, we heated a sample of nitrogen at successively increasing pressures. At 20 GPa and 800 K and at 60 GPa and 2,500 K no changes in the Raman spectra were observed. At 82 GPa we saw no significant changes in the Raman spectra below 2,400 K. After heating at this temperature, a peak at 2,392 cm−1 from a new molecular nitrogen phase was observed below the main vibron line of molecular nitrogen at 2,410 cm−1 , indicating reduced bond order of the N–N bond and charge redistribution due to enhanced interaction between molecules [41]. At 95 GPa, this phase disappeared after heating to 1,500 K and only the previously known molecular phase was observed after heating up to 2,590 K. After increasing pressure to 110 GPa, the sample behaved similar to other experiments on synthesis of cg-N (as shown, for instance, in Fig. 2.3). Luminescence strongly increases at temperatures above 800 K (Fig. 2.8). This is apparently due to accumulation of defects in the crystalline lattice. After heating to higher temperature of 1,520 K luminescence decreases but nitrogen obviously remains in the molecular form – intensity of the vibron remains the same
110 GPa
Before heating
25 mm
N2 vibron
Intensity, arb. units
a)
800 K
cg-N
1520 K
Red phase
300 K 1990 K 1000
b)
After 2200 K
c)
2000
3000
Raman shift, cm−1
Fig. 2.8 Laser heating of molecular nitrogen at 110 GPa. (a) View of the sample through diamond anvils. Nitrogen is contained in a hole in rhenium gasket where a 1 μm thick boron plate black is placed as an absorber of heating radiation of YAG laser. Nitrogen is over the plate and seen as transparent at the left corner of the hole of the Re gasket which surrounds the sample. (b) After laser heating up to 1,990 K nitrogen transforms to cg-N which can be seen around the boron absorber as yellow or colorless substance. A transient red phase is at periphery of the heated area. Nitrogen remained in molecular form in the unheated corner of the sample at the left. (c) Raman spectra of nitrogen measured at room temperature after heating to the mentioned temperatures. In result of heating to 1,990 K vibron disappeared and a peak corresponding to cg-N phase appeared
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
87
and no other peaks appear. Drastic spontaneous transformation happens at heating to ∼2, 000 K: nitrogen transforms to a nonmolecular form (the vibron disappears) and a cg-N single-bonded nitrogen forms with a characteristic Raman peak at 820 cm−1 . During laser heating at the transformation, the temperature drops for several hundred degrees so that additional power is needed to maintain the temperature. Upon the transformation, pressure significantly drops on 5–20 GPa (depending on particular arrangement of the sample in the chamber) indicating a significant reduction of the volume of the sample. The phases of the transformation can be seen in Fig. 2.8. The cg-N looks colorless or yellow over the boron absorber and at its edge. A transient high luminescence amorphous phase is formed at the colder part of sample. It is red and is well separated from the cg-N phase. The colorless molecular nitrogen remains unchanged in the unheated part of the sample. In many other experiments we observed that nitrogen remains in molecular form at pressures lower than 110 GPa, even being heated to 3,000 K. At higher pressures, the needed temperature is lower: for instance, at 140 GPa cg-N can be created at T ∼1,400 K. For further clarification of transformation of molecular to polymeric nitrogen the starting structure - knowledge of the crystal structure of molecular nitrogen is required. However, it is available only below approximately 50 GPa where the diatomic solid nitrogen exhibits a rich phase diagram [59, 60]. At higher pressures of ∼60 GPa at room temperature, Raman and infrared absorption data indicate a transformation from the ε -N2 rhombohedral (R3c) [61–63] to a ζ -N2 phase [60, 64, 65]. This phase persists in the molecular state up to further transformation to the nonmolecular state at 150–180 GPa. The crystal structure of ζ -N2 has not yet been firmly determined. It was proposed as R3c [65, 66], but later it was found that this structure is not consistent with Raman and IR data performed at low temperatures [60, 64]. A low-symmetry (orthorhombic or monoclinic) structure with two sites for atoms was proposed [64]. In x-ray studies of nitrogen up to 65 GPa at room temperature, Jephcoat et al. [67] observed a transition at ∼60 GPa, but the signal was weak and the pressure was not high enough to separate the new phase and determine its structure. New molecular phases have also been synthesized at high pressures and temperatures (70–90 GPa and 600–1,000 K); although x-ray diffraction data are sufficient to identify them as new phases, the crystal structures have not yet been determined [48]. We performed extensive x-ray diffraction measurements of molecular nitrogen up to 170 GPa and tried to identify the structure of ζ -N2 phase. A majority of the diffraction patterns of the molecular phases were collected at the Advanced Photon Source (APS, HPCAT at Sector 16), while the cg-N-phase and some patterns of molecular nitrogen were collected at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF, beamlines ID-9 and ID30). In all cases, we used an x-ray beam focused down to a spot of ∼5 μm, and angle dispersive diffraction techniques [19]. Diffraction patterns of nitrogen in the 60–150 GPa pressure range are shown in Fig. 2.9. At 60 GPa, several diffraction peaks of the previous ε -phase widen. At 69 GPa, these peaks are split but new peaks do not appear, which suggests that the ε -N2 → ζ -N2 transformation is not accompanied by a large lattice distortion. Above
88
M.I. Eremets et al.
Nitrogen, T = 295 K 78 GPa 74 68 62 52 42 31 20 GPa 6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
2Q (deg, l=0.41009 A) Fig. 2.9 X-ray diffraction spectra of molecular nitrogen taken at different pressures
80 GPa, diffraction patterns demonstrate only one phase which does not change up to 150 GPa, with the exception of the appearance of an amorphous halo above 100 GPa and some redistribution of the intensity. We analyzed the diffraction pattern of the ζ -phase obtained at 80 GPa. We tried the hexagonal indexing to verify the R3c structure. The structure was found not to be a rhombohedral structure; only hexagonal indices fit the data, verifying that the ζ -phase does not have the R3c structure. To identify this low-symmetry structure, the best indexing was found with an orthorhombic unit cell. Three space groups: P2221 , P21 21 2, and P21 21 21 satisfied the diffraction spectra. The P2221 group has been selected because of its proximity to the space group I21 3 (cg-N structure). However, its comparison with the cg-N structure may not be valid because a gradual martensitic transformation between these structures is unlikely. Such transition requires very high pressures, which is where the equations of state (EOS) of ζ -N2 and cg-N would intersect (Fig. 2.10). Instead, the final transition to the cg-N structure is accompanied by a drastic change in volume, approximately 22% at 110 GPa (Fig. 2.10). Note, that at this pressure, the atomic volume of the molecular phase (ζ -N2 ) approaches that for cg-N at zero pressure (Fig. 2.10). The P2221 group structure is under debate [68] and further efforts on determination of apparently low-symmetry structure of ζ -N2 are needed. Molecular–polymeric transformation in nitrogen remarkably resembles phase transformations in carbon and boron nitride in terms of compressibility and volume change (Fig. 2.10). There may also be similarities in the microscopic mechanisms of these transformations in nitrogen and carbon (and BN). Transitions between the carbon and BN phases are reconstructive diffusion-type phase transformations where
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
160
89
z-N2 ® cg-N at 2000K
140
P (GPa)
120 100
z-N2
cg-N
80 60
e-N2
40 20
Diamond
Graphite hBN
cBN 0 4
5
6
7 Vat
8
9
10
11
(Å3)
Fig. 2.10 Pressure–volume equation of state (EOS) of nitrogen. Our experimental data for ε -N2 are shown with open circles. Grey circles are data from Ref. 61. At P > 60 GPa ε -phase transforms to ζ -phase which remains stable at pressures up to P > 150 GPa, where upon it transitions to a nonmolecular phase with an amorphous-like structure. η -N2 can be directly transformed to the cubic gauche structure (cg-N) with laser heating above 2,000 K at P > 110 GPa (Ref. [20]). The EOS of this phase has been measured with increasing pressure up to 134 GPa, and then on releasing pressure down to 42 GPa where the sample escaped the cell. Extrapolation of this EOS to zero ˚ [3] in excellent agreement with theoretical pressure gives a volume of cg-N structure about 6.6 A ˚ [3] (Ref. [18]). The EOSs for carbon [71, 72] graphite and diamond) and predictions of 6.67 A BN [73, 74] are also presented to show the proximity of these covalent bonded materials with nitrogen
growth of a new phase can be accompanied by the fragmentation of the parent crystal and the creation of a disordered amorphous layer between crystallites, as has been reported for the hBN ↔ cBN transitions [69]. Similarly, it has been proposed recently that such transformations can occur through virtual melting along interfaces in the material [70]. This general picture of fragmentation of phases and creation of amorphous material is consistent with the disordered state of the nonmolecular nitrogen. To check, if transformation from molecular to cg-N goes through an amorphous phase, or a transient phase [41] we performed for the first time x-ray diffraction in situ with laser heating. This experiment requires a combination of two complex techniques: x-ray diffraction measurements from light elements like nitrogen, and laser heating at megabar pressures. We performed measurements at 13 ID beam line at ˚ wavelength was collimated to APS (Chicago). An intensive x-ray beam of 0.3344 A ≈5 μm spot. This beam produced a luminescence in the sample, therefore, the beam can be visualized with a sensitive CCD camera. This helped us to combine precisely the x-ray and laser-heating beams. The YAG laser beam was focused to a larger spot
90
M.I. Eremets et al.
than the x-ray beam to diameter of ≈10 μm, and therefore diffraction has been collected from nearly uniformly heated area. Temperature was determined by recording the spectrum of thermal radiation and fitting it with the Planck radiation function. An important experimental improvement is the already mentioned toroidal shape of diamond anvil culet (Fig. 2.7). This allowed us to increase thickness of the sample to ≈14–15 μm (with flat anvils it is ≈3–5 μm) and thus dramatically increase x-ray scattering and decrease accumulation time of a nitrogen sample to seconds. As squeezed to pressure about 140 GPa, the nitrogen sample becomes partly dark, and no Raman signal could be detected from the dark sample, indicating the transition to the amorphous nonmolecular phase in agreement with previous studies [14, 15, 47] However, the area in the center of the sample remained in molecular state as inferred by Raman spectra typical for molecular ζ -N2 phase. The x-ray diffraction pattern obtained from this part of sample can also be attributed to the molecular ζ -phase while no diffraction peaks were observed in diffraction pattern from the dark region of the amorphous sample. As the sample was heated above 1,000 K, the intensity of diffraction lines of ζ -phase gradually decreases (Fig. 2.7) indicating the decrease of the amount of this phase. No new diffraction lines indicating the transformation to a new crystalline phase could be detected in the diffraction pattern. With temperature increase, the molecular ζ -phase transforms to the amorphous state. At T ∼ 1,450 K the diffraction lines of ζ -phase disappears completely. This transformation to the amorphous phase is irreversible – the diffraction pattern of the sample quenched to the room temperature does not reveal reflections from ζ -phase. This amorphous phase is nonmolecular as inferred by the absence of vibron lines in the Raman spectra of the quenched sample. In the subsequent heating of this part of the sample containing the amorphous material the well-defined diffraction pattern of newly formed cg-N appeared as the sample was heated above 1,300 K. The amount of the cg-phase was growing with further temperature increase up to a highest temperature of about 2,000 K. No changes of diffraction pattern were observed as the sample was cooled down to room temperature. The same sequence of transformations (molecular→amorphous→cg-nitrogen [cgN]) was reproducibly observed at continuous increases in temperature of unheated parts of the sample with laser. In this manner nearly the whole sample was entirely transformed to the cg-phase revealing a very pronounced diffraction pattern (Fig. 2.7). Our data evidence that at high pressure–high temperatures molecular nitrogen transforms to the atomic cg-N through an amorphous state. This transformation between solid molecular and cg-nitrogen occurs with continuous increase of temperature at the same pressure; therefore, this is a solid-state transformation without melting. The amorphous state is likely a polymeric network of single-bonded and double-bonded nitrogen atoms as follows from calculations [16, 17]. An amorphous state intermediate between phases is typical for diffusion-type phase transformations. It has been clearly observed in transformations with large change of volume to such as graphite-diamond (ΔV ≈ 26%) [71–73] and hexagonal BN – cBN (ΔV ≈ 24%) transformations [73, 74]. The molecular–cg-N transitions is also diffusion-type first-order transition between very different structures with a large drop of volume (ΔV ≈ 22%).
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
91
2.3.1 Metastability of Polymeric Nitrogen and its Recovery
Energy (eV / atom)
2.0 1.5 0.9 eV
1.0
N2
cg-N
0.5 0.0
0.5
1.0
cubic gauche --- molecular nitrogen
a)
Total energy per cel (two atoms), eV
Another aspect of transitions with large change of lattices and volume is a large hysteresis of the phase transformation and metastability – once formed, a high-pressure phase can be recovered to ambient pressure (a well-known example is diamond). From an energetic point of view a reason of metastabilty is a large kinetic barrier separating high- and low-pressure phases. For carbon, the energetic barrier at zero pressure between graphite and diamond is Δ E ≈0.33 eV atom−1 (Fig. 2.11) and 0.38 eVpair−1 for BN [73–75] while the energy difference between diamond and hexagonal graphite is nearly zero [73]. Therefore, diamond (which has slightly higher energy) separated by the large barrier from graphite is practically as stable as graphite. In difference with cBN or diamond, nitrogen in polymeric state has much higher energy than in the ground state (molecular nitrogen): this difference is ∼1.2–1.3 eV atom−1 . However, to transform from cg-N to molecular nitrogen a barrier of ∼0.9 eV [18] should be overcome (Fig. 2.11). The activation energy EA = 0.63 eV is also characteristic for the amorphous polymeric nitrogen (which has a short-range with predominantly threefold coordinated atoms) as calculated in Ref. [16]. These large barriers suggest that the highly energetic cg-N and the amorphous polymeric nitrogen might be metastable even at zero pressure [18, 39]. More careful consideration includes surface. Unsaturated bonds which are intrinsic defects on the surface of cg-N crystal significantly decrease the barrier [16] down to ∼0.1 eV [29]. Still this is a high barrier which implies that cg-N might be stable at ambient pressure at least at low temperatures. Note, that the broken bonds at the
−310.4 −310.8 Diamond
−311.2
0.33 eV
10
b)
Graphite
12
14
16
Cell volume, A3
18
c)
Fig. 2.11 Energy barriers separated a metastable phases from a ground state. (a) Calculated total energy per atom as a function of the reaction coordinate for cg → β ‘-O2 transformation, where β ‘-O2 designates a distorted two-layer variant of the β -O2 molecular structure. This is approximately zero pressure path, with the starting atomic volumes equal to the equilibrium values for ˚ 3 atom) and the final volume the equilibrium value for β -O2 molecular the cg-N phase (6.67A 3 −1 ˚ atom ) The zero of energy corresponds to the diatomic β -O2 structure (from Ref. [18]). (19.67A (b) Graphite-diamond relation. Total energy per cell (two atoms), as functions of the cell volume for the hydrostatic pressure path. In (a) the solid curve is for the graphite and the dashed curve is for the diamond (from Ref. [73]). (c) A typical example of the rhenium gasket broken by the cg-N sample escaped from the cell at 70 GPa in direction shown by the arrow
92
M.I. Eremets et al.
surface which are the nuclei of instability can be saturated by hydrogen atoms [29]. This is similar as in the case of amorphous polymeric nitrogen [16]. The above estimation suggest possibility of recovering of polymeric nitrogen. However, this turned out to be a difficult experimental problem: typically the sample escapes from the diamond anvil cell at pressures of 70–100 GPa by rupturing the gasket. This is a typical occurrence, and obviously this is due to the inherent weakening of the gasket at decreasing pressure [56]: at releasing, load edges of diamond culet elastically recover and do not support the plastically deformed thin gasket anymore. A novel technique must be developed for repetitive recovery of the sample at ambient pressure. Nevertheless, after a number of efforts amorphous nonmolecular nitrogen once has been recovered to ambient pressure at temperatures below 100 K [14]. Cg-N has not been recovered yet – it also escapes at the same pressures at our numerous attempts with different configurations of the gasket and the anvils. At present pressure down to 42 GPa has been achieved occasionally due to a sudden drop of pressure from 115 GPa because of failure of one of the anvils. The sample of cg-N nevertheless survived but partly transformed to molecular nitrogen. At this pressure and 300 K it was apparently unstable – it had transformed to molecular nitrogen (cg-N Raman peak disappeared) under approximately 40 min of focused laser radiation of wavelength of 488 nm and power of W = 10 mW. This behavior is similar to nonmolecular amorphous nitrogen which transformed back to molecular form at P < 50 GPa at 300 K [14]. This indicates that most likely both forms of nonmolecualr nitrogen are polymeric nitrogen in disordered or single-crystalline forms. This also means that cg-N will be likely recovered to ambient pressure similar to the amorphous nitrogen.
2.3.2 Perspectives of Synthesis of New Forms Polymeric Nitrogen Starting from prediction of polymeric nitrogen [12, 18] theoretical calculations give insight to its properties and stimulated experiment. Recent calculations become more and more precise and can predict amazingly well structures of high-pressure phases. In our experience, we found nearly exact prediction of high-pressure phases in silane [76, 77], see also Ref. [23]. In this respect theoretical exploration of the new polymeric nitrogen structure [16, 23–31, 33, 37, 38, 42–44] is very promising and can guide direction of experimental search. These calculations agree that cg-N structure is the most stable. Besides, many other structures were found which are close in energy to cg-N, for instance, another three-dimensional polymeric structure related to cubic gauche (Fig. 2.7) and less stable by only 49 meVatom−1 [23]. Systematic search of new metastable allotropes of nitrogen has been done by Zahariev et al. [28]. They considered Peierls-like distortions of a reference structure which was taken simple cubic structure (SC) which is to be the natural high-pressure reference structure for group 15 elements. They found many structures with total energy close to cg-N, which clearly has the lowest enthalpy. Two structures were discovered to be mechanically stable at zero pressure. Notably, all the previously considered simple single-bonded phases of polymeric nitrogen (BP, A7, and LB)
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
93
with the exception of cg-N, were found to be mechanically unstable at all pressures considered. There is a number of works, predicting new nonmolecular phases compatible to cg-N in the low-pressure region. Chaired web (CW) structure was found which is thermodynamically more stable than the cubic gauche (cg-N) phase at the ambient pressure: the enthalpy favors CW over CG by approximately 20 meV [31]. The temperature-dependent free-energy and zero-point energy corrections favor cg-N over CW by 54 meV. With the rise in temperature there is a crossover of the two free-energy dependences around 200 K. At ambient temperature the new CW phase is thermodynamically more stable than the cg-N. Metastability of the CW phase was demonstrated by both phonon calculations, and first-principles molecular dynamics simulations. The CW phase is an insulator at low pressure with a calculated band gap of ∼5 eV. Alemany and Martins [37] also predicted a phase which has lower enthalpy than cg-N at P < 15 GPa. It has a zigzag chainlike arrangement is thus partially polymeric and each atom has a coordination number of two. This phase is metastable at zero pressure and is metallic. Mattson et al. [25] found a very similar and also metallic chain structure but with the different packing which leads to a significantly lower energy (∼0.18 eVatom−1 ) [25] making it very close in energy (but slightly higher) to cg-N. A new structure with the zigzag chains in the new phase connected by two atoms with double bonds has been proposed in Ref. [44], but it has higher energy than other chain phases. Stability of cg-N in the limit of high pressures was studied by Alemnay and Martins [37]. They found that at P > 200 GPa BP, an orthorhombic distortion of sc is more stable than CG. Experimentally all these predicted nonmolecular phases were not yet confirmed. Theoretical calculations gave further insight of unique properties of cg-N. This is a wide energy gap dielectric: the band gap is 4.13 eV at zero pressure and 3.89 eV at 240 GPa [27], and 5.2 eV at 150 GPa in Ref. [38]. The generalized gradient approximation (GGA) calculation of the band gap at 240 GPa is in good agreement with previous work [37] while Monte Carlo calculations [32] give band gap 8.1 eV. Chen et al. [42] found the unique constant-gap behavior (Eg = 4.2 eV under pressures 40 and 130 GPa, and it decreases at lower and higher pressures. The Eg ∼ 4 eV at megabar pressures well correlates with our observations of the colorless transparent phase. Further detailed calculations of compressibility, lattice dynamics [24], dielectric constants ε ∝ = 4.44, ε 0 = 4.81 at P0 of cg-N and their pressure dependence have been done in Ref. [41]. Chen et al. [42] raised attention to an interesting possibility that cg-N can be also a superhard material. The distance between nitrogen atoms in the cg-N at am˚ [19] – significantly shorter than that for diamond (1.54 A). ˚ bient pressure is 1.466 A The high strength of cg-N is also indicated by its high bulk modulus: 260–340 GPa [18, 19, 21, 27, 38, 44, 50]. On the other hand, strength of cg-N could be weaker in comparison with diamond because there are only three bonds for each atom for nitrogen instead of four bonds for diamond. Chen et al. [42] calculated the hardness of cg-N as ≈83 GPa which is less than diamond (100–130 GPa) but higher than other known superhard materials: (c − BC2 N (76 GPa) and cBN (63 GPa)).
94
M.I. Eremets et al.
2.4 Conclusions It is shown here that pure nitrogen can exist in polymeric forms where atoms connect each other by single covalent bonds. At room or lower temperatures nitrogen transforms to an amorphous polymeric form at 150–200 GPa. Under laser heating at T ∼ 2,000 K and P > 110 GPa nitrogen has been synthesized in a single-bonded crystalline form. It has unusual cubic gauche structure (cg-N) with space group I21 3. In the cg-N structure all-nitrogen atoms are threefold coordinated and bondlengths are the same for all pairs of bonded atoms. The experimentally determined structure is in perfect agreement with the theoretical prediction. Polymeric nitrogen can be metastable at ambient pressure as has been confirmed experimentally for the amorphous phase. The metastable polymeric nitrogen is predicted to be the most powerful high-density energy, because of a uniquely large difference in energy between single-bonded and triple-bonded atoms. In particular, it was calculated that polymeric nitrogen can produce detonation pressure ten times higher than that for HMX. Interestingly, cg-N is also predicted to be a superhard material second after diamond. It is also shown here that high nitrogen materials can be prepared at lower pressure utilizing starting materials other than pure nitrogen. The challenge remains the recovery of such new high-energy density high-nitrogen or pure-nitrogen materials down at ambient pressures and temperatures.
References 1. Huheey, J. E., Keiter, E. A. & Keiter, R. L. Inorganic Chemistry: Principles of Structure and Reactivity (Harper Collins, New York, 1993). − 2. Christe, K. O. Recent Advances in the Chemistry of N+ 5 , N5 and High-Oxygen Compounds. Propel, Explosiv. Pyrotech. 32, 194–204 (2007). 3. Samartzis, P. C. & Wodtke, A. M. All-nitrogen chemistry: how far are we from N60 ? Int. Rev. Phys. Chem. 25 527–552 (2006). 4. Rice, B. M., Byrd, E. F. C. & Mattson, W. D. Computational aspects of nitrogen-rich HEM. High Ener Density Mater. Struct. Bond. 125, 153–194 (2007). 5. Barlett, R. J. Exploading the mysteries of nitrogen. Chemi. Indus. 140–143 (2000). 6. Cacase, F., Petris, G. d. & Troiani, A. Experimental detection of tetranitrogen. Science 295, 480–481 (2002). 7. Curtius, T. Berichte. Deutsch. Chem. Gesellschaft 23, 3023–3033 (1890). 8. Christe, K. O., Wilson, W. W., Sheehy, J. A. & Boatz, J. A. N+ 5 : A novel homolepic polynitrogen ion as a high energy density material. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 38, 2002–2009 (1999). 9. Klapotke, T. M. in High Energy Density Materials (ed. Klapotke, T. M.), pp. 85–121 (Springer, Heidelberg, 2007). 10. Knapp, C. & Passmore, J. On the Way to “Solid Nitrogen” at Normal Temperature and Pressure? Binary Azides of Heavier Group 15 and 16 elements. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 43, 2–4 (2004). 11. Glukhovtsev, M. N., Jiao, H. & Schleyer, P. v. R. Besides N2 , what is the most stable molecule composed only of nitrogen atoms? Inorg. Chem. 35, 7124–7133 (1996). 12. McMahan, A. K. & LeSar, R. Pressure dissociation of solid nitrogen under 1 Mbar. Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 1929–1932 (1985).
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
95
13. Martin, R. M. & Needs, R. Theoretical study of the molecular-to-nonmolecular transformation of nitrogen at high pressures. Phys. Rev. B 34, 5082–5092 (1986). 14. Eremets, M. I., Hemley, R. J., Mao, H. K. & Gregoryanz, E. Semiconducting non-molecular nitrogen up to 240 GPa and its low pressure stability. Nature 411, 170–174 (2001). 15. Goncharov, A. F., Gregoryanz, E., Mao, H. K., Liu, Z. & Hhemley, R. J. Optical evidence for nonmolecular phase of nitrogen above 150 GPa. Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 1262–65 (2000). 16. Nordlund, K., Krasheninnikov, A., Juslin, N., Nord, J. & Albe, K. Structure and stability of non-molecular nitrogen at ambient pressure. Europ. Lett. 65, 400–406 (2004). 17. Mattson, W. D. PhD thesis (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2003). 18. Mailhiot, C., Yang, L. H. & McMahan, A. K. Polymeric nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 46, 14419– 14435 (1992). 19. Eremets, M. I., Gavriliuk, A. G., Trojan, I. A., Dzivenko, D. A. & Boehler, R. Single-bonded cubic form of nitrogen. Nature Mater. 3, 558–563 (2004). 20. Gregoryanz, E. et al. High P-T transformations of nitrogen to 170 GPa. J. Chem. Phys. 126, 184505 (2007). 21. Lipp, M. J. et al. Transformation of molecular nitrogen to nonmolecular phases at megabar pressures by direct laser heating. Phys. Rev. B 76, 014113 (2007). 22. Trojan, I. A., Eremets, M. I., Medvedev, S. A., Gavriliuk, A. G. & Prakapenka, V. B. Transformation of molecular to polymeric nitrogen at high pressures and temperatures. In situ X-ray diffraction studies. Appl. Phys. Lett., to be published (2008). 23. Oganov, A. R. & Glass, C. W. Crystal structure prediction using ab initio evolutionary techniques: Principles and applications. J. Chem. Phys. 124, 244704 (2006). 24. Caracas, R. Raman spectra and lattice dynamics of cubic gauche nitrogen. J. Chem. Phys. 127, 144510 (2007). 25. Mattson, W. D., Sanchez-Portal, D., Chiesa, S. & Martin, R. M. Prediction of new phases of nitrogen at high pressure from first-principles simulations. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 125501–125504 (2004). 26. Zahariev, F., Hu, A., Hooper, J., Zhang, F. & Woo, T. Layered single-bonded nonmolecular phase of nitrogen from first-principles simulation. Phys. Rev. B 72, 214108 (2005). 27. Yu, H. L. et al. First-principles calculations of the single-bonded cubic phase of nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 73, 012101 (2006). 28. Zahariev, F., Dudiy, S. V., Hooper, J., Zhang, F. & Woo, T. K. Systematic method to new phases of polymeric nitrogen under high-pressure. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 155503–1555034 (2006). 29. Zhang, T., Zhang, S., Chen, Q. & Peng, L.-M. Metastability of single-bonded cubic-gauche structure of N under ambient pressure. Phys. Rev. B 73, 094105–094107 (2006). 30. Uddin, J., Barone, V. N. & Scuceria, G. E. Energy storage capacity of polymeric nitrogen. Molecul. Phys. 104, 745–749 (2006). 31. Zahariev, F., Hooper, J., Alavi, S., Zhang, F. & Woo, T. K. Low-pressure metastable phase of single-bonded polymeric nitrogen from a helical structure motif and first-principles calculations. Phys. Rev. B 75, 140101 (2007). 32. Mitas, L. & Martin, R. M. Quantum Monte Carlo of nitrogen: atom, dimer, atomic, and molecular solids. Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2438–2441 (1994). 33. Lewis, S. P. & Cohen, M. L. High-pressure atomic phases of solid nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 46, 11117–11120 (1992). 34. Eremets, M. I. et al. Polymerization of nitrogen in sodium azide. J. Chem. Phys. 120, 10618– 10618 (2004). 35. Peiris, S. M. & Russell, T. P. Photolysis of Compressed Sodium Azide (NaN3 ) as a synthetic pathway to nitrogen materials. J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 944–947 (2003). 36. Hemley, R. J. Effects of high pressure on molecules. Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 51, 763–800 (2000). 37. Alemany, M. M. G. & Martins, J. L. Density-functional study of nonmolecular phases of nitrogen: metastable phase at low pressure. Phys. Rev. B. 024110 68, 024110 (2003). 38. Zhao, J. First-principles study of atomic nitrogen solid with cubic gauche structure. Phys. Lett. A 360, 645–648 (2007).
96
M.I. Eremets et al.
39. Barbee, T. W. & III. Metastability of atomic phases of nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 48, 9327–9330 (1993). 40. Yakub, E. S. Diatomic fluids at high pressures and temperatures: a non-empirical approach. Physica B 265, 31–38 (1999). 41. Caracas, R. & Hemley, R. J. New structures of dense nitrogen: pathways to the polymeric phase. Chem. Phys. Lett. 442, 65–70 (2007). 42. Chen, X. Q., Fu, C. L. & Podloucky, R. Superhard Dense Nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 77, 064103 (2008). 43. Ross, M. & Rogers, F. Polymerization, shock cooling, and the high-pressure phase diagram of nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 74, 024103 (2006). 44. Wang, X. L. et al. Prediction of a new layered phase of nitrogen from first-principles simulations. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter. 19, 425226–425229 (2007). 45. Reichlin, R., Schiferl, D., Martin, S., Vanderborgh, C. & Mills, R. L. Optical studies of nitrogen to 130 GPa. Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 1464–1467 (1985). 46. Bell, P. M., Mao, H. K. & Hemley, R. J. Observations of solid H2 , D2 , N2 at pressures around 1.5 megabar at 25◦ C. Physica B 139–140, 16–20 (1986). 47. Gregoryanz, E., Goncharov, A. F., Hemley, R. J. & Mao, H. K. High-pressure amorphous nitrogen. Phys. Rev. B 64, 052103 (2001). 48. Gregoryanz, E. et al. Raman, infrared, and x-ray evidence for new phases of nitrogen at high pressures and temperatures. Phys. Rev. B 66, 224108–5 (2002). 49. Eremets, M. I., Struzhkin, V. V., Mao, H. K. & Hemley, R. J. Superconductivity in boron. Science 293, 272–274 (2001). 50. Eremets, M. I., Gavriliuk, A. G., Trojan, I. A., Dzivenko, D. A. & Boehler, R. in ESRF Highlights 2004 (ed. Admans, G.), pp. 37–38 (Imprimerie du Pont de Claix, Grenoble, 2005). 51. Sanz, D. N., Loubeyre, P. & Mezouar, M. Equation of state and pressure induced amorphization of β-boron from X-ray measurements up to 100 GPa. Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 245501 (2002). 52. Yoo, C. S., Akella, J., Cynn, H. & Nicol, M. Direct elementary reactions of boron and nitrogen at high pressures and temperatures. Phys. Rev. B 56, 140–146 (1997). 53. Boehler, R., Bargen, N. v. & Chopelas, A. Melting, thermal expansion, and phase transitions of iron at high pressures. J. Geophys. Res. B 95, 21731–21736 (1990). 54. Mao, H. K., Xu, J. & Bell, P. M. Calibration of the ruby pressure gauge to 800 kbar under quasihydrostatic conditions. J. Geophys. Res. 91, 4673–4676 (1986). 55. Eremets, M. I. Megabar high-pressure cells for Raman measurements. J. Raman Spectr. 34, 515–518 (2003). 56. Eremets, M. I. High Pressures Experimental Methods (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1996). 57. Knittle, E., Wentzcovitch, R. M., Jeanloz, R. & Cohen, M. L. Experimental and theoretical equation of state of cubic boron nitride. Nature 337, 349–352 (1989). 58. Eremets, M. I., Gavriliuk, A. G. & Trojan, I. A. Single-crystalline polymeric nitrogen. Appl. Phys. Lett. 90, 171904 (2007). 59. Manzhelii, V. G. & Freiman, Y. A. (eds.) Physics of Cryocrystals (American Institute of Physics, College Park, MD, 1997). 60. Bini, R., Ulivi, L., Kreutz, J. & Jodl, H. J. High-pressure phases of solid nitrogen by Raman and infrared spectroscopy. J. Chem. Phys. 112, 8522–8529 (2000). 61. Mills, R. L., Olinger, B. & Cromer, D. T. Structures and phase diagrams of N2 and CO to 13 GPa by x-ray diffraction. J. Chem. Phys. 84, 2837–2845 (1986). 62. Olijnyk, H. High pressure x-ray diffraction studies on solid N2 up to 43.9 GPa. J. Chem. Phys. 93, 8968–8972 (1990). 63. Hanfland, M., Lorenzen, M., Wassilew-Reul, C. & Zontone, F. Structures of molecular nitrogen at high pressure. Rev. High Pressure Sci. Technol. 7, 787–789 (1998). 64. Goncharov, A. F., Gregoryanz, E., Mao, H.-K. & Hemley, R. J. Vibrational dynamics of solid molecular nitrogen to megabar pressures. Low Temper. Phys. 27, 866–869 (2001). 65. Schiferl, D., Buchsbaum, S. & Mills, R. L. Phase transitions in nitrogen observed by Raman spectroscopy from 0.4 to 27.4 GPa at 15 K. J. Phys. Chem. 89, 2324–2330 (1985).
2 Synthesis of High-Nitrogen Energetic Material
97
66. LeSar, R. Improved electron-gas model calculations of solid N2 to 10 GPa. J. Chem. Phys. 81, 5104–5108 (1984). 67. Jephcoat, A. P., Hemley, R. J., Mao, H. K. & Cox, D. E. Pressure-induced structural transitions in solid nitrogen. Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 33, 522 (1988). 68. Gregoryanz, E. et al. On the epsilon-zeta transition of nitrogen. J. Chem. Phys. 124, 116102 (2006). 69. M. I. Eremets et al. Disordered state in first-order phase transitions: Hexagonal-to-cubic and cubic-to-hexagonal transitions in boron nitride. Phys. Rev. B 57, 5655–5660 (1998). 70. Levitas, V. I., Henson, B. F., Smilowitz, L. B. & Asay, B. W. Solid-solid phase transformation via virtual melting significantly below the melting temperature. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 2357021-4 (2004). 71. Hanfland, M., Beister, H. & Syassen, K. Graphite under pressure: equation of state and firstorder Raman modes. Phys. Rev. B 39, 12598–12603 (1989). 72. Occelli, F., Loubeyre, P. & LeToullec, R. Properties of diamond under hydrostatic pressures up to 140 GPa. Nature Materials 2, 151–154 (2003). 73. Furthmueller, J., Hafner, J. & Kresse, G. Ab initio calculation of the structural and electronic properties of carbon and boron nitride using ultrasoft pseudopotentials. Phys. Rev. B 50, 15606–15622 (1994). 74. Albe, K. Theoretical study of boron nitride modifications at hydrostatic pressures. Phys. Rev. B 55, 6203–6210 (1997). 75. Fahy, S., Louie, S. G. & Cohen, M. L. Pseudopotential total-energy study of the transition from rhombohedral graphite to diamond. Phys. Rev. B 34, 1191–1199 (1986). 76. Eremets, M. I., Trojan, I. A., Medvedev, S. A., Tse, J. S. & Yao, Y. Superconductivity in hydrogen dominant materials: silane. Science 319, 1506–1509 (2008). 77. Pickard, C. J. & Needs, R. J. High-pressure phases of silane. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 045504 (2006).
Chapter 3
Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives Suhithi M. Peiris and Jared C. Gump
3.1 Introduction Energetic materials, being the collective name for explosives, propellants, pyrotechnics, and other flash-bang materials, span a wide range of composite chemical formulations. Most militarily used energetics are solids composed of particles of the pure energetic material held together by a binder. Commonly used binders include various oils, waxes, and polymers or plasticizers, and the composite is melt cast, cured, or pressed to achieve the necessary mechanical properties (gels, putties, sheets, solid blocks, etc.) of the final energetic material. Mining, demolition, and other industries use liquid energetics that are similarly composed of an actual energetic material or oxidizer together with a fuel, that is to be mixed and poured for detonation. Pure energetic materials that are commonly used are nitroglycerine, ammonium nitrate, ammonium or sodium perchlorate, trinitrotoluene (TNT), HMX, RDX, and TATB. All of them are molecular materials or molecular ions that when initiated or insulted undergoes rapid decomposition with excessive liberation of heat resulting in the formation of stable final products. When the final products are gases, and they are rapidly produced, the sudden pressure increase creates a shock wave. When decomposition is so rapid that the reaction moves through the explosive faster than the speed of sound in the unreacted explosive, the material is said to detonate. Typically, energetic materials that undergo detonation are known as high explosives (HEs) and energetic materials that burn rapidly or deflagrate are known as low explosives and/or propellants. The singular character of energetic molecules is that they are very easily initiated, even just by friction caused when twisting of the container cap to open the container. That is, these materials are so sensitive to perturbation that their reaction or decomposition is easily started. This certainly implies that the molecule is inherently unstable or strained at ambient pressure and temperature, or that its heat of formation is very low in comparison to the formation of other phases or products from the same chemical composition. In the case of high explosives, positive values for the heat of S.M. Peiris, G.J. Piermarini (eds.), Static Compression of Energetic Materials, Shock Wave and High Pressure Phenomena, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2008
99
100
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump
formation is not unknown, perhaps explaining the multiple meta-stable crystalline structures or polymorphs discovered at ambient pressure and temperature. Consequently, the phase diagrams of HEs and their high pressure, high-temperature phase transitions are often very complex. The decomposition reaction or detonation of such high explosives is also complex, being a combination of almost instantaneous chemical, mechanical, and physical changes. It is convenient to approximate or envision detonation in the following sequential steps. When an explosive is initiated (subjected to a stimulus such as a shock wave or an insult such as friction) energy is transferred to the material causing mechanical deformation and heating. The hot and compressed material proceeds to produce chemically excited species and initial bond breaking (considered reaction initiation) takes place. The chemistry of these materials is such that once reaction is initiated, sequences of chemical reactions follow at supersonic speed. This results in the supersonic liberation of chemical energy and production of gaseous reaction products. These product gases support or push a propagating shock wave resulting in pressure–volume work. The utility of a weapon rises from this pressure–volume work known as the continuum response of the explosive, and it is highly advantageous to design this response to address the specific effect desired from a weapon. The final effect or result of a detonation, being based on such complex phenomena as described in the previous paragraph, is not easy to predict. Yet the design of efficient mission-specific weapons and the limitations of conducting large-scale tests makes the prediction, simulation, and modeling of explosives essential. Such simulations and models in order to make accurate predictions must incorporate sufficient understanding of the complex detonation process. Realistic estimations of high-pressure, high-temperature thermodynamic properties, chemical kinetics, and reaction mechanism are necessary to accurately describe an explosive’s response. Unfortunately, the rapidly changing high-pressure, high-temperature, thermodynamic properties and chemical reactions result in non-equilibrium temperature, pressure, and volume conditions. Therefore, well-defined experiments with accurate measurements of thermodynamic parameters and chemical concentrations are extremely challenging. Extrapolations made from ambient-pressure, ambienttemperature data are unreliable and lead to large uncertainties in models of explosive phenomenon. Subsequently, over the past 2 decades, experimental methods that approach the shock pressure and temperature of detonating explosives while still allowing time (static conditions) for detailed study, have been devised. Such experimental methods and data are described in Chapters 3–5, and 6 of this book. This particular chapter, Chapter 3, focuses on the equations of state (EOS) and phase stability of unreacted solid explosives at static high pressure and temperature. Experimental data described herein obtained mostly by using x-ray diffraction methods, highlight the isothermal compressibility of explosives and elaborate on the lattice structure of the material. Experiments that investigate phase stability using vibrational spectroscopies such at Raman and IR are also described. The dependence of both the EOS and the phase stability on pressure-transmitting media and quasi-hydrostatic to non-hydrostatic compression are discussed. The various meta-stable structures of energetics and the phase transitions that arise from heating
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
101
or compression are presented together with multiple phase transitions to phases that could also be meta-stable. Further, the effect of the rate of pressure or temperature increase on phase transition pressure and temperature, is also included in the later part of this chapter.
3.2 Equations of State 3.2.1 Background An “equation of state” relates the thermodynamic states of matter such as pressure (P), volume (V), and temperature (T). In static-pressure studies, the temperature is often held constant and isothermal EOS are obtained. There are several approaches to deriving EOS. Most approaches use the classical thermodynamic definitions of pressure and temperature. ∂U ∂U and T = P=− ∂V S ∂S v Where U is the total internal energy or equilibrium potential energy. The interpretation or derivation of U is usually based on the material whose EOS is to be described. Early theoretical work was based on perfect gases that followed ideal gas relationships. Subsequent attempts are more selectively based on potential energy of finite hard spheres, of harmonic vibrations. The more sophisticated quantum-mechanical potentials account for attractive and repulsive forces, non-spherical distribution of electrons and even hydrogen bonding between molecules. These methods and potentials are well described in Chapters 7 and 8 of this book. Limiting EOS to isothermal conditions where only mechanical work is performed allows another classical expression for pressure, using the Helmholtz free energy, F: ∂F P=− ∂V T This definition is found useful because when considering elasticity and compression of solids, mechanical work can be expressed in terms of deformation or strain under force. Such an expression for finite, elastic, and isothermal strain was first derived by Murnaghan, and later expanded by Birch [1]. This derivation assumes that there is always a “state of zero strain” for any temperature at which the solid exists. This assumption limits the application of this EOS to “unstrained” crystals as opposed to strained or meta-stable crystalline phases, as, interestingly, most of the HEs might be. However, at least these EOS are not dependent on the many assumptions about electronic interactions, anharmonicities, and binding energies, required for first-principle quantum-mechanical EOS.
102
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump
In the Birch-Murnaghan (BM) isothermal finite-strain derivations, F is assumed to depend only on the strain components in different directions of an elastic crystalline system. (That is, the Helmholtz free energy is considered the Strain energy, and thermal expansion is not considered as strain.) When strains are small (in the order of 10%) strain components can be defined by a Lagrangian scheme based on initial unstrained coordinates. However, an Eulerian scheme, where the coordinates of the strained state are thought to be independent of the initial unstrained state, was found to be more useful for higher compression [1]. The derivation defines negative Eulerian strain, or positive compression, f as: V −2/3 1 −1 f= 2 V0 where V is the volume at some pressure and V0 is the volume at zero pressure. Then strain energy (or Helmholtz free energy, F) resulting from hydrostatic compression is represented as a Taylor series in f : 9 2 F = V0 K0 f 2 + a f 3 + b f 4 + . . . 2 3 Differentiating gives the Pressure (P): P = 3K0 (1 + 2 f )5/2 ( f + a f 2 + b f 3 + c f 4 + . . .) where K0 is the zero-pressure isothermal bulk modulus (the inverse of compressibility). Evaluating this equation with then known compressibility data, the values of a, b, and c, etc. were limited [1, 2] to give: P = 3K0 (1 + 2 f )5/2 3 3 143 3 × f + (K0 − 4) f 2 + K0 K0 + K0 (K0 − 7) + f −... 2 2 9 where K0 , K0 are the first and second pressure derivatives of the zero-pressure isothermal bulk modulus [2]. This BM EOS formalism has been widely used for understanding the behavior of minerals and materials in the interior of the earth. Experimentally obtained P– V data are “fitted” to the formalism to yield the bulk modulus and its derivatives. These parameters are then used to extrapolate the EOS to higher pressures. As many orders of the series as necessary are used to fit P–V data. Using up to the third-order (equation shown below) is common practice. The application of a value of 4 to K0 in the third-order equation, results in essentially the second-order equation.
2
7 5
V −3 V −3 V −3 3 3 P = K0 − −1 1 + K0 − 4 2 V0 V0 4 V0
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
103
Several other derivations of EOS are well known, including one named the “universal equation of state” derived by Vinet et al. [3]. Here internal energy is expressed in terms of the Wigner-Seitz radius scaled by a scaling factor, to yield: P=
3K0 (1 − X) { 3 (K −1)(1−X)} where X = e 2 0 X2
V V0
1 3
V V0
1 3
Jeanloz has shown that this EOS is an algebraic approximation of the BirchMurnaghan EOS within the range 3 < K0 < 6 [4]. Since most of the isothermal EOS data on high explosives use the Birch-Murnaghan EOS, and since it can be shown to be an approximation to other EOS formalisms as well, this chapter will focus on the use of the Birch-Murnaghan EOS.
3.2.2 Method Typical experiments consist of loading diamond anvil cells with the sample and a pressure-transmitting medium. Samples are loaded into holes drilled into metal gaskets that are a couple hundred microns thick. The holes are in the order of tens to hundreds of microns in diameter, so the total amount of sample necessary for each experiment is very small. Samples of explosives, being commercially produced for military use, are usually not 99.99% pure like other high-purity chemicals bought from chemical manufacturers. Typical military standard production of RDX (hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitrotriazine) could include up to 7% HMX (octahydro-l,3,5,7tetranitrotetrazocine) [5]. Similarly HMX samples could include RDX. With materials like CL-20 (HNIW, hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane, 2,4,6,8,10,12-hexanitro 2,4,6,8,10,12-hexaaza tetracyclo [5,5,0,05,9 ,03,11 ]dodecane), which has multiple solid-state phases (or crystal structures) that are meta-stable at ambient P–T, samples may consist of mixed phases. More recently, less-sensitive forms of these materials have also been prepared, and structural differences in the conventional material versus the insensitive material are still under investigation [6]. Therefore, it is now necessary to describe the origin and purity of the particular samples used to obtain experimental data when publishing equations of state or similar results. To utilize powder x-ray diffraction methods, the samples must be finely ground. Grinding these friction- and electrostatic-sensitive materials can be dangerous. Grinding should be limited to very small sample quantities such a 0.1 mg, and precautions, such as static-discharge grounding or wetting down of the working surface, should be taken. Depending on the pressure-measuring technique employed, ruby dust, or other material is often loaded with the sample [7, 8]. Adding pressure-transmitting media to the gasket hole to create hydrostatic or at least quasihydrostatic conditions may be complicated by the typical liquid organics used (such as ethanol and/or methanol) reacting with the organic sample material. Therefore, either non-reacting noble gas pressure media should be used, or inorganics such as FX-75 or Dow-Corning 200 fluid can be employed [9].
104
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump
Explosives, being sensitive to various stimuli, are decomposed or reacted when subjected to certain wavelengths of radiation. Energy-dispersive x-ray (EDX) diffraction using white radiation most often causes sample decomposition. In addition, crystal structures of explosives are of low symmetry and the diffraction resolution obtained from EDX in 2θ or d-space is insufficient to yield good structural fits. Therefore, single-wavelength angle-dispersive diffraction becomes the method of choice. Diamond anvil cell samples being extremely small, synchrotron radiation is necessary for obtaining diffraction patterns in minutes instead of hours. Usually, samples are loaded, pressed to a known or measured pressure (P), and then exposed to x-rays to obtain diffraction patterns. Often, commercial software packages are used to analyze diffraction patterns and assign miller indices. Such software also calculates unit cell parameters and unit cell volumes (V). It is important to retain the errors associated with the unit cell parameters to propagate errors in the unit cell volumes obtained. These volume errors together with errors associated with the measurement of pressure should be used in the equation of state fits. When utilizing the Birch-Murnaghan EOS formalism, the fit should be weighted with the reciprocal of the error in each pressure measurement and the thermodynamic parameters from the “best” weighted fit should be published. Unfortunately, because of the percentages of error and scatter in the P–V points, not weighting the fit and not employing the best fit can result in various fitted lines that all seem to be “good” fits but yield widely disparate EOS. In our studies, high temperatures were achieved by using a hydrothermal diamond anvil cell (HDAC), developed by Bassett et al. [10]. Temperature was monitored by thermocouples placed near the culet tip of each diamond. To determine pressure for our high-temperature measurements, a ruby fluorescence measurement was taken after the addition of pressure-transmitting fluid while the cell was still at ambient temperature, to determine initial sample pressure [7, 8]. The sample was then heated to the target temperature. A new ruby fluorescence measurement was taken to determine the position of the ruby peaks at the target temperature. This target-temperature ruby peak position was then used to calculate peak shifts as the sample was compressed at the target temperature. Final pressure was obtained by adding the pressure increase at the target temperature to the initial pressure created by the addition of the pressure medium. This method ensures that pressure and temperature dependence of the ruby lines are treated independently, and the pressures reported here do not include thermal pressure created when heating.
3.2.3 Data The earliest EOS from ambient-temperature static compression of explosives was obtained by the group of Bart Olinger and Howard Cady at Los Alamos National Lab. Their method for evaluating the bulk modulus and its pressure derivative from their static-pressure P–V data involved using the Hugoniot relations to obtain pseudo-particle (u p ) and pseudo-shock (us ) velocities.
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
105
PV 0 us = 1 − VV0 up =
V PV0 1 − V0
Then, fitting the u p , us data to the linear relationship us = cT + sT u p where cT is the bulk isothermal sound speed which relates to the bulk modulus and sT relates to the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus. cT = K0V0 sT =
(K0 + 1) 4
Their initial publication of such data for the two most popular explosives RDX and HMX appears in the Proceedings of a Commissariat a l’Energie Atomique conference in Paris, France [11]. During their compression of α RDX (the polymorph stable at ambient pressure and temperature) they observed a phase transition at about 4 GPa to a phase with similar orthorhombic symmetry. Therefore, they report the bulk modulus of α RDX obtained from data up to 4.4 GPa, to be 13 GPa with a pressure derivative of 6.6. Subsequently, Yoo and Cynn also compressed α RDX [12]. They obtained a bulk modulus of 13.9 GPa with a pressure derivative of 5.8 GPa. They also obtained unit cell volumes for the higher-pressure phase (γ) up to 12 GPa, by assuming an orthorhombic symmetry for this phase. Figure 3.1 shows both Yoo and Cynn’s data and Olinger et al.’s data. Olinger’s data is within experimental error of Yoo and Cynn’s data. There are three solid lines in the plot, which are; third-order fit of the Birch-Murnaghan EOS to the data from the α-phase, the data from the γ-phase, and the combined data obtained by Yoo and Cynn. In this case, when assuming that the γ-phase is of orthorhombic symmetry, the transition volume change is found to be 1.5–1.6% [11, 12]. Assuming this volume change to be negligible, a single EOS can be fitted as shown in Fig. 3.1. Yoo and Cynn report a bulk modulus of 13.0 GPa with a pressure derivative of 6.3 for the data from both phases. Olinger et al.’s original work also included the compression of β HMX, the polymorph of HMX stable at ambient pressure and temperature. Using the Hugoniot relationships, they obtained an isothermal bulk modulus of 13.5 GPa with a pressure derivative of 9.4 for the β-phase of HMX, compressed in a pressure medium of 4:1 methanol:ethanol solution. Yoo and Cynn also published an ambient-temperature EOS for β HMX, compressed in Ar, which is such a soft solid in this pressure region that it retains near hydrostatic conditions [12, 13]. They used the third-order Birch-Murnaghan EOS formalism to fit their data. For hydrostatic compression below 27 GPa, they obtained a isothermal bulk modulus of 12.4 GPa with a pressure derivative of 10.4.
106
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump 1.00
0.95 α
V/V0
0.90
0.85 γ
0.80
0.75
0.70 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
P (GPa) Fig. 3.1 Isotherms of RDX to 12 GPa from Ref. [12]. The solid circles are Yoo and Cynn’s data and the open circles are Olinger et al.’s data. The vertical dashed line at about 4 GPa indicates the phase transition from α to γ. The solid lines represent fitted third-order Birch-Murnaghan EOS
These two sets of data from Olinger et al. and Yoo and Cynn were analyzed by Menikoff and Sewell [14]. They fit the data of Olinger et al. with a third-order Birch-Murnaghan (BM) EOS to compare it to Yoo and Cynn’s data using the same fitting technique. This fit is shown in Fig. 3.2 as a dotted line. They obtained a bulk modulus of 10.6 ± 1.7 GPa with a pressure derivative of 18.1 ± 13.4. Further, they used Yoo and Cynn’a data to just 12 GPa, in an attempt to compare fits from the same data domain. That fit yielded a bulk modulus of 16.0 ± 2.5 with a pressure derivative of 7.3 ± 1.4. They concluded that using a BM EOS to fit such P–V data requires more data points at lower pressures [14]. We obtained more than 30 — P–V data points up to 5.5 GPa using hexane as a pressure medium [15]. Our bulk modulus, obtained from fitting a third-order BM EOS, is considerably higher, at 21.0 ± 1.0 GPa with a pressure derivative of 7.5 ± 0.9. Considering these three sets of data on HMX, indications are that it is not necessarily the fitting form that gives such widely disparate results for HMX. It is possibly the HMX itself, in that, the compression of HMX is hugely influenced by non-hydrostatic pressure. Our pressure medium of hexane freezes at 1 GPa [16], thereby introducing non-hydrostatic conditions and shear stresses in the samples from that pressure. Olinger’s pressure medium also stiffens sufficiently above 4 GPa to demonstrate stiffer HMX compression above 4 GPa. Whereas both the stiffness and shear strength of the Ar pressure medium used by Yoo and Cynn remains much lower than that of HMX, thereby providing the most hydrostatic compression conditions of these three studies. The bulk moduli obtained from the less hydrostatically
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
107
520
Volume (Angstroms3)
500
Gump/Peiris Yoo/Cynn Olinger
480
460
440
420
400
0
2
4 6 8 Pressure (GPa)
10
12
Fig. 3.2 The three sets of data on β HMX described in the legend are from Refs. [11, 13, 15], respectively. The solid curve is a third-order BM EOS fit to our data [15], the dotted curve is a third-order BM EOS fit to Olinger et al.’s data [14], and th e dashed curve is a third-order BM EOS fit to Yoo and Cynn’s data to 27 GPa [13]
compressed studies indicate that the non-hydrostatic pressure felt by HMX stiffens its lattice. Yoo and Cynn speculate that this trend, where increased hydrostaticity results is higher bulk moduli, is due to chemical reactions occurring in the absence of hydrostatic conditions [13]. If chemical reactions were occurring in our samples at such pressures as 5 or 6 GPa, they are reversible because our samples decompressed from 5 or 6 GPa do return to the β structure [15]. Clearly, this behavior where non-hydrostatic stress stiffens the β HMX lattice bares further investigation. The ambient-pressure volumes (V0 ) we obtained from samples at room temperature, 100◦ C, and 140◦ C were plotted as a function of temperature [15]. Volume thermal expansion was calculated assuming linearity in the V, T relationship. The slope of the V vs. T plot was determined by a linear least-squares fit. Thermal expansion (α) was then calculated by dividing the slope by the ambient-pressure volumes because α = (1/V )(V /T )P . The average volume thermal expansion obtained from our data in this temperature range at ambient pressure is: 0.00027 K−1 [15]. An older publication by Hermann et al. [17] reports a volume thermal expansion of 0.00013 K−1 and a newer proceedings article by Saw [18] shows the same parameter to be 0.00020 K−1 . It is possible that the thermal expansion of HMX is very sensitive to the amount of impurities within the lattice (such as RDX inclusions) explaining this wide range of figures obtained for thermal expansion of β HMX. However, neither Refs. [17] or [18] discuss the purity of their samples.
108
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump
Table 3.1 Isothermal EOS parameters at ambient temperature Material α RDX in Meth:Eth α RDX in Ar β HMX in Meth:Eth β HMX in Ar β HMX in Hexane β HMX in Hexane at 100◦ C β HMX in Hexane at 140◦ C TATB in Meth:Eth TATB in Meth:Eth (to 8 GPa) TATB in Meth:Eth (to 14 GPa) PETN in Meth:Eth PETN in Ar AP in Meth:Eth AP in FC-75 or NaCl εL-20 in Dow-Corning 200 fluid εL-20 in Dow-Corning 200 fluid at 75◦ C γ CL-20 (to 0.9 GPa with no pressure medium)
Bulk modulus Pressure derivative Reference (GPa) of bulk modulus 13 13.9 13.5 12.4 21.0 ± 1.0 14.1 ± 0.82 13.5 ± 0.56 16.2 ± 2.0 13.4 ± 0.8 16.9 ± 1.0 8.70 12.3 20.3 ± 0.5 12.7 ± 0.7 13.6 ± 2.0 11.0 ± 1.3 18.9 ± 0.5
6.6 5.8 9.4 10.4 7.5 ± 0.9 11.6 ± 1.41 9.0 ± 0.85 5.9 ± 1.4 12.8 ± 1.1 8.2 ± 0.7 9.9 8.2 4 11.0 ± 1.6 11.7 ± 3.2 14.0 ± 2.7 4
[11] [12] [11] [12, 13] [15] [15] [15] [19] [20] [20] [19] [12] [25] [26] [30] [30] [30]
Isothermal equations of state at ambient temperature have also been obtained for other energetic materials, as listed in Table 3.1. Another explosive, that is also the most insensitive of those in use today, is triaminotrinitrobenzene (TATB). The isothermal compression of TATB to 7 GPa was also initially reported by Olinger and Cady [19]. They used the methanol:ethanol solution as a pressure medium, and measured pressure using NaF included in the sample and its EOS. Very recently, another group, headed by Dattlebaum, has done x-ray diffraction analysis of the TATB structure under high pressure [20]. They also used a 4:1 ethanol:methanol mixture as a pressure medium and obtained data to 14 GPa. Both data sets are shown in Fig. 3.3. The variation in Dattlebaum’s data in comparison to Olinger and Cady’s data above 2 GPa, may be attributed to the analysis of the x-ray patterns used to calculate unit cell volumes. TATB crystallizes in a unit cell with triclinic unit symmetry. Therefore, a minimum of six peaks from a cross section of different h, k, and l lattice plane configurations are necessary to obtain a good unit cell volume. Unfortunately, Olinger and Cady could only see four peaks above 3 GPa pressure, and assumed that the a, b axis compression is uniform to reduce the parameters necessary to obtain a unit cell volume from a triclinic cell. Dattlebaum’s data shows this assumption to be too lenient. Though Dattlebaum too had one problem, in that they could not observe l reflections together with all the other hk planes from the same samples. Therefore, they used peak positions from different samples (set to the same pressure) to obtain triclinic unit cell volumes. These volumes are experimentally more reliable, because no assumptions about the compression of the unit cell was made.
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
109
12 Olinger Dattelbaum
Pressure (GPa)
10 8 6 4 2 0 0.80
0.85
0.90 V/Vo
0.95
1.00
Fig. 3.3 TATB compression with third-order BM EOS fits (with no reciprocal-of-error weighting) to data from Refs. [19] and [20]. The solid line includes all the data in Ref. [19], the short-dashed line includes data to 8 GPa in Ref. [20], and the long-dashed line includes all the data in Ref. [20]
Fitting a third-order BM EOS to data from Ref. [19], results in a bulk modulus of 16.2 ± 2.0 GPa and a pressure derivative of 5.9 ± 1.4. This fit is shown in Fig. 3.3. Dattelbaum’s data from Ref. [20] is fitted from ambient pressure both up to 8 GPa and up to 14 GPa. Previous experiments have reported a cusp in the EOS at 8 GPa [20]. However, the data included here does not show an obvious volume change considering the possible error bars for each of the P and V values. To 8 GPa, the third-order BM EOS fit gives a bulk modulus of 13.4 ± 0.8 GPa with a pressure derivative of 12.8±1.1. To 14 GPa, the third-order BM EOS fit gives a bulk modulus of 16.9 ± 1.0 GPa with a pressure derivative of 8.2 ± 0.7. Interestingly, the later two fits with such widely disparate EOS parameters also highlight the vagaries of fitting P–V data to the BM EOS formalism. This problem is less pronounced if each data point is weighted by the reciprocal value of the error in P, as further discussed in the Discussion section of this chapter. PETN (pentaerythritol tetranitrate) a less utilized explosive, was also initially studied under static pressure by the group of Olinger, et al. [21]. They later published a correction to their pressure measurements which depended on the compression of NaF, as available at the time [19]. Yoo and Cynn’s report in 1998 also included the isothermal compression of PETN in Ar at room temperature to 15 GPa [12]. They compared their data to the EOS obtained from shock compression of PETN single crystals, as shown in Fig. 3.4. Their third-order BM EOS fit resulted in a bulk modulus of 12.3 GPa with a pressure derivative of 8.2. Yoo and Cynn used an orthorhombic space group P21 21 to analyze their diffraction data as published in 1947 [22], while more accurate determinations claim a tetragonal space group
110
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump
Fig. 3.4 Static compression data (solid circles) together with shock compression data (open circles) of PETN from [12]. The solid line is a third-order BM EOS fit to the static data and the dashed line from the Shock Hugoniot of PETN
P421 c [23]. More recent experiments confirm the tetragonal symmetry stable to 6 GPa, interestingly, converting to an orthorhombic symmetry (similar to the 1947 structural analysis) above that pressure [24–26]. Ammonium perchlorate (AP) is also widely used in explosive formulations, particularly as an oxidizer. There are many, sometimes contradictory, reports of phase transitions of AP at various pressures. The first high-pressure study on AP was reported by Bridgeman who observed a cusp-like maximum at 3.1 GPa, attributed to a phase transition at that pressure [27]. The change in volume due to this transition was reported to be too small to quantify. Later, ambient-temperature x-ray diffraction measurements with isothermal compression in 4:1 ethanol:methanol mixtures were recorded up to 5.0 GPa [28]. They report the ambient-temperature transition to occur above 3.57 GPa with the new phase seen at 4.70 GPa. Our study of the compression of AP using x-ray diffraction, Raman and IR spectroscopy, illuminated subtle changes different from those reported till then [29]. Compressing AP in different pressure media such as NaCl and FC-75, we saw new diffraction peaks starting from 0.9 GPa and above, with a complete phase change occurring at around 3.0 GPa. Fitting the orthorhombic ambient-pressure unit cell to diffraction patterns up to 3 GPa, results in a third-order BM EOS with a K0 of 12.7 ± 0.7 GPa and K0 of 11.0 ± 1.6. The data and fits are shown in Fig. 3.5. Fitting the six data points below 4.7 GPa from Ref. [28] to a second-order BM EOS gives a bulk modulus of 20.3 ± 0.5 GPa with the pressure derivative held constant at 4.0.
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
400
111
AP Data from [29] BM EOS fit to [29] Sandstrom's Data [28]
Volume (Å3)
390
380
370
360
350
0
1
2
3
4
Pressure (GPa)
Fig. 3.5 Static compression of AP from [29] with the third-order BM EOS fitted to 3 GPa because of a phase transition observed above that pressure. Also included are data from [28] where the phase transition was observed above 3.57 GPa
Hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane (HNIW or CL-20), a relatively recently synthesized material that is not commonly used (mostly for economic reasons), has four known polymorphs that have been found to be stable at ambient conditions. These polymorphs are labeled α, β, γ, and ε, and of these, the ε- and γ-phases have been extensively studied at static high pressure from the early 1990s. However, no isothermal compression data were published until 2006, when we reported the compression of ε CL-20 in Dow-Corning 200 fluid (0.01 cm2 s−1 kinematic viscosity) to 5.6 GPa, both at ambient temperature and 75◦ C [30]. The third-order BM EOS fit to the data yields an ambient-temperature isothermal bulk modulus of 13.6 GPa ± 2.0 with a pressure derivative of 11.7±3.2 for the ε-polymorph. Compressing the γ-polymorph at ambient temperature results in a phase transition at about 0.7 GPa [31]. Since the γ-polymorph only existed for such a small pressure range samples were loaded without the pressure medium, to obtain P–V data of the γ-phase to 0.9 GPa [30]. The third-order BM EOS fit to these non-hydrostatic, ambient-temperature data yields a bulk modulus of 18.5 ± 2.6 GPa with a pressure derivative of 5.4 ± 7.9. The high error in the pressure derivative value is primarily due to the very small pressure range of the data set. Fitting the data with a fixed value of 4 for the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus, (which reduces the BM EOS to second order), results in a bulk modulus of 18.9 ± 0.5 GPa. The data and EOS are shown in Fig. 3.6.
S.M. Peiris, J.C. Gump
Volume (Angstroms3)
112
1500
epsilon phase amb. T
1450
epsilon phase 75⬚C gamma phase amb. T
1400 1350 1300
1250 1200
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Pressure (GPa)
Fig. 3.6 Compression of the ε-polymorph of CL-20 in Dow-Corning Fluid 200, at ambient temperature and 75◦ C. The γ -phase of CL-20 is only stable to 0.9 GPa, and its compression had to be obtained without a pressure medium
Figure 3.6 also shows the compression of ε CL-20 at 75◦ C. Thermal expansion of ε CL-20 at ambient pressure, from ambient temperature (of about 27◦ C) to 75◦ C is 0.00014 ± 0.00002 K−1 . However, when compressed at 75◦ C, the expansion of the unit cell becomes negligible, and the compression curves at both temperatures merge at around 1 GPa. A third-order BM EOS fit to the 75◦ C ε-data yields an ambientpressure isothermal bulk modulus of 11.0 ± 1.3 GPa with a pressure derivative of 14.0 ± 2.7. The third-order BM EOS for ε CL-20 at room temperature and 75◦ C are equal to within the error associated with each curve, indicating the merged compression curves and that heating to 75◦ C does not change the compressibility of ε CL-20.
3.3 High-Pressure Phases 3.3.1 Background Most solid high explosives have positive Heats of Formation. This results in very fast chemical reactions which usually start with a small insult (such as a shock or laser pulse or other radiation) and persist with supersonic liberation of chemical energy, culminating in the production of stable gaseous reaction products. The positive heats
3 Equations of State and High-Pressure Phases of Explosives
113
of formation also imply that the ambient-pressure, ambient-temperature solid-state structure is itself meta-stable; resulting in multiple meta-stable crystal structures at ambient pressure and temperature or various polymorphic forms. Therefore, heating or compression of these crystals also results in multiple phase transitions and crystalline phases that are often meta-stable over long but finite timescales. Further complication is added by the rate-dependent nature of phase transitions. For instance, fast heating may result in a phase transition at a lower temperature than if the sample were heated slowly. Or slow decompression may result in retention of a high-pressure phase, while fast decompression results in a phase transition to the ambient-pressure stable structure. In DAC studies, the presence of shear stresses may also affect compression and the pressure at which phase transitions are observed. Therefore, as concluded in the previous section, it is important to minimize the effect of shear stress dependence on compression and phase-transition pressure by using pressure media that are much softer at all pressures than the explosives being studied. The most definitive methods for solid structural analysis being neutron and x-ray diffraction, and explosives being organic solids with molecules composed of C, H, O, and N in each lattice site, structural analysis of these materials become nontrivial. In addition, most of the solid-state structures have low-crystal symmetries such as monoclinic or triclinic, requiring high-resolution diffraction methods to resolve multiple peaks occurring in close 2θ or d-space. All these factors, together with the small samples in DACs, and the cone restrictions impo