Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Neill McKee Jane T...
60 downloads
4428 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Neill McKee Jane T. Bertrand Antje Becker-Benton
SAGE Publications New Delhi l Thousand Oaks l London
Copyright © Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Center for Communication Programs, 2004 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
First published in 2004 by Sage P ublications India Pvt Ltd Publications B-42, Panchsheel Enclave New Delhi 110 017 Sage P ublications Inc Publications 2455 Teller Road Thousand Oaks, California 91320
Sage P ublications Ltd Publications 1 Oliver’s Yard, 55 City Road London EC1Y 1SP
Published by Tejeshwar Singh for Sage Publications India Pvt Ltd, typeset in 10pt BruceOldStyle BT by Star Compugraphics Private Limited, New Delhi and printed at Chaman Enterprises, New Delhi.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-P ublication Data Cataloging-in-Publication McKee, Neill. Strategic communication in the HIV/AIDS epidemic/Neill McKee, Jane T. Bertrand, Antje BeckerBenton. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. AIDS (Disease)—Prevention. 2. Health behavior. 3. Health education. 4. Communication in medicine. I. Bertrand, Jane T. II. Becker, Benton Lee, 1938–III. Title. RA643.8.M38
362.196'9792—dc22
ISBN: 0–7619–3207–0 (US–Hb) 0–7619–3208–9 (US–Pb)
2004
81–7829–324–2 (India–Hb) 81–7829–325–0 (India–Pb)
Sage P roduction T eam: Geetanjali Minhas, O.P. Bhasin and Santosh Rawat Production Team:
2004001250
Contents List of Boxes
9
List of Figures
11
List of Plates
13
Abbreviations
15
Acknowledgments
19
Chapter 1: The Challenge of Combating HIV/AIDS
23
The Complex Challenge Global Responses Strategic Communication: An Essential Ingredient Audience for this Book Organization of this Book
23 24 26 27 28
Chapter 2: Strategic Communication in the F ight Against HIV/AIDS Fight
30
The Challenge Elements of Strategic Communication A Paradigm Shift from Behavior Change to Social Change Conclusion
30 31 41 53
Chapter 3: Communication for Social and Behavioral Change
55
Advocacy to Strengthen Political Commitment Case Study: Application of the AIDS Impact Model in Cambodia Social Mobilization to Bolster the National Response Case Study: Stop AIDS, Love Life in Ghana Interventions to Strengthen Community Responses Case Study: Mobilizing Traditional Networks in Guinea Promoting a Balanced Approach to Prevention Messages: The “ABCs” of Safer Sexual Practices Case Study: Communicating Safer Sex in Zambia Communication to Reduce Stigma Case Study: Brief Examples of Disclosure and Compassion in Africa
55 63 65 73 76 85 88 99 101 107
6 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Chapter 4: R eaching Special Audiences Reaching
110
Preventing HIV Infection in Young People Case Study: Communication for Social Norm Change in Adolescent Reproductive Health in Bangladesh Focusing on Gender: Reaching Women and Girls, Men and Boys Case Study: Sara: A Role Model for African Girls as they Face HIV/AIDS Case Study: Involving Boys in Zambia: The Chikomeni Youth Camp Sex Workers: Shifting the Balance of Power Case Study: SHAKTI Project of Bangladesh Reaching Men Who Have Sex with Men Case Study: Naz Foundation Trust of India Prevention and Injecting Drug Users Case Study: IDUs in New Delhi, India Reaching Mobile Populations Case Study: The Lesedi Project Among South African Miners Case Study: Tea Parlors for Truckers in India HIV/AIDS in Conflicts and Emergency Situations Case Study: Health of Adolescent Refugees Project (HARP)
110 121
Chapter 5: Communication for Health and Social Services
183
HIV/AIDS and Services: An Overview Case Study: The Ugandan Yellow Star Program Increasing Use of Voluntary Counseling and Testing (VCT) Case Study: New Start in Zimbabwe Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission Case Study: Expansion of PMTCT in Thailand The Role of Communication in Anti-Retroviral Therapy Case Study: Going to Scale with Anti-Retroviral Therapy in Brazil Improving the Quality of Life of People Living with HIV and AIDS Case Study: The Commuter AIDS Information Project, South Africa Case Study: Orphans and Other Vulnerable Children in Malawi
183 191 193 204 206 216 217 225 228 233 235
Chapter 6: Selected Strategic Approaches
238
Using Entertainment–Education for HIV/AIDS Prevention Case Study: The BBC Entertainment–Education Program in India Peer Education Case Study: Peer Education Among Factory Workers in Thailand Case Study: Peer Educators at Mumias Sugar Company in Kenya Telephone Hotlines Case Study: The South Africa AIDS Hotline Using Information Communication Technologies (ICTs) Case Study: Setting Up an Electronic AIDS Network in South East Asia
238 248 252 259 262 263 268 271 282
122 133 135 138 147 148 156 158 163 165 171 172 174 180
Contents 7
Chapter 7: P resent and F uture Challenges for Communicators Present Future
285
Comprehensive Approaches to Prevention, Including the ABCs Addressing Stigma New Findings on STIs and HIV Biology, Culture, and Risk Risk, Behavior, and Technology Public Health and Human Rights Conclusion
285 288 290 291 294 296 299
Appendix: R esources to K eep Communication Specialists Updated Resources Keep
300
Bibliography
312
Index
333
About the Authors
350
List of Boxes 2-1 2-2 2-3 2-4 2-5
Types of Research Needed to Guide Decision-making Factors Influencing the Choice of Communication Channels P-Process (revised)—Steps in Strategic Communication Participation Analysis—Potential Actors for Advocacy and BCC Participants in Program for Female Sex Workers (FSWs), Maharashtra, India
35 39 49 50 51
3-1 3-2 3-3 3-4 3-5 3-6 3-7 3-8
HIV/AIDS Communication Planning in Maharashtra, India Ladder of Empowerment The Community Action Cycle The Journey of Hope Additional Community-Based Tools The Role of the “ABCs” in Reducing HIV Rates in Uganda Lessons from Success in Uganda and Thailand A Controversial Condom Advertisement
69 79 80 82 83 91 92 95
4-1 4-2 4-3 4-4 4-5 4-6 4-7 4-8 4-9
Examples for Entertainment–Education Elements of Successful Sexuality Education Programs Tips for Success in Working with Young People “Men Aren’t from Mars”: Unlearning Machismo in Latin America Stepping Stones Approach Causal Factors in FSWs’ Vulnerability to HIV The Sonagachi Project in Kolkata, India Reaching Truck Drivers in India Hot Spots and Risk Zones
114 119 120 126 128 139 144 166 168
5-1 5-2 5-3 5-4 5-5 5-6 5-7 5-8 5-9 5-10
The Continuum of Care in Action in India VCT in Africa The Benefits of VCT Quality of VCT Services Increasing Demand for VCT VCT in India Profits from New Start, Zimbabwe A Four-Pronged Approach to PMTCT The Importance of Infant Feeding Guidelines for PMTCT Nigeria: Excellence in PMTCT Communication Planning HIV/AIDS Workplace Interventions
185 194 195 199 202 205 207 210 214 232
10 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
6-1 6-2 6-3 6-4 6-5 6-6 6-7 6-8 6-9 6-10 6-11 6-12 6-13 6-14 6-15
Let’s Go With the Times Sara Saves Her Friend Soul City’s Impact on Domestic Violence Spin-off in West Africa: Clés de la Vie Regional E–E Using Popular Music Scriptwriting for Meena Strengthening Capacity by Training Ugandan Producers on the Job Targeted Recruitment of Peer Educators is Important The TanZam Highway Peer Educators Tips for Success in Peer Education Innovative Ways to Combine Community Level E–E with Mass Media: A Distance Learning Radio Show in Zambia CT-based AIDS Education at the Workplace Tools for Program Managers Radio Presenters Browsing the Internet for Their Audiences Tips for Success
241 242 242 244 246 247 248 253 256 259 274 277 279 281 281
List of F igures Figures 2-1 2-2 2-3 2-4
32 32 33 45
2-5 2-6
The P-Process for Strategic Communication Planning The Stages of Health Communication Steps in Developing a Behavior Change Communication Strategy Behavior Development and Behavior Change in the Social and Environment Context Pathways Communication Model for HIV/AIDS Revised P-Process
3-1 3-2
Strategic Communication Components Community Action Cycle
73 80
4-1 4-2 4-3a 4-3b 4-3c 4-3d
Model Illustrating the Interdependence of Life Skills MSM Identities in India Condom Used during Last Non-regular Sex Condom Used during Last Paid Sex Sexual Intercourse with Paid Partners Sexual Intercourse with Non-regular Partners
115 155 166 166 166 166
5-1
The HIV/AIDS Continuum of Care
185
47 48
List of Plates 2-1 Adolescent participation in Bangladesh ARH design workshop. (Credit: CCP)
52
3-1 NGOs, researchers, and media organizations developed a communication 70 plan to deal with HIV/AIDS during a week-long communication planning workshop in Maharashtra, India. (Credit: CCP) 3-2 Stop AIDS, Love Life road shows attracted large crowds and raised HIV/AIDS 74 awareness in Ghana. (Credit: CCP) 3-3 A traditional leader in Ghana takes part in the World AIDS Day procession 75 in support of the Stop AIDS, Love Life program, February 2001. (Credit: CCP) 3-4 The Journey of Hope toolkit in Ghana illustrates how behavior affects the spread 82 of HIV/AIDS. (Credit: CCP) 3-5 A comic book, Marcelline and Jojo, for Francophone Africa promotes open 108 discussion and support for PLHA. (Credit: Projet Regional Santé Familiale et Prévention du SIDA) 4-1 “Not everyone is doing it.... If your time hasn’t come, don’t have sex,” reads an HIV/AIDS poster for young people in Honduras. (Credit: Nicaragua Comision Interagencial de Salud Reproductiva) 4-2 Comic book series on Adolescent Reproductive Health in Bangladesh dealing with HIV/AIDS and many related subjects. (Credit: AV Com/BCCP) 4-3 The Sara stories provide a role model to empower African girls to deal with unwanted sexual advances. (Credit: UNICEF) 4-4 Zambian boys at a sports camp, which combines both soccer training and education in reproductive health and HIV/AIDS. (Credit: Youth Activists Organization) 4-5 Discrete, pocket-size communication materials for MSM. (Credit: Humsafar Trust, Mumbai, India)
111
123
134
136
152
14 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
5-1 Gold Circle Quality Teams in Togo, Cameroon, and Burkina Faso encourage dialogue between clients and providers: “We are here to listen to you”. (Credit: Projet Régionale Santé Familiale et Prévention du SIDA) 5-2 The first phase of Uganda’s Yellow Star program stimulated active community support and involvement. (Credit: Delivery of Improved Services for Health Project)
188
6-1 Adolescents sing and dance at a DramAidE theater performance in South Africa. (Credit: Patrick Coleman/CCP) 6-2 Detective Vijay, a TV serial drama involving HIV/AIDS in India. (Credit: BBC World Service Trust) 6-3 HIV/AIDS telephone hotline poster from Nigeria’s Youth Empowerment Foundation (YEF). (Credit: YEF, CCP) 6-4 Zambia distance education by radio. (Credit: Nikkie Ashley)
241
193
250 264
274
Abbreviations ABC AED AFRO-NETS AIDS AIM ANC APDIME APROPO ARH ARV ART AVERT AW BBC BCC BPWT CADRE CAFS CAI CARAM CBD CBOs CBT CCP CDC CDI CD-4 CHESS CIIR CIT CONNECT COPE
Abstinence, Being faithful and Condom use Academy for Educational Development African Networks for Health Research and Development Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome AIDS Impact Model Ante-Natal Clinic Assessment, Planning, Design, Implementation Monitoring, and Evaluation Apoyo a Programas de Población Adolescent Reproductive Health Anti-Retroviral Anti-Retroviral Therapy International HIV and AIDS charity based in the UK, with the aim of AVERTing HIV and AIDS worldwide All Workers British Broadcasting Corporation Behavior Change Communication Bhoruka Public Welfare Trust Centre for AIDS Development, Research and Evaluation Centre for African Family Studies Computer Assisted Instruction Coordination of Action Research on AIDS and Mobility Community-Based Distributors Community-Based Organizations Computer-Based Training Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Center for Communication Programs Center for Disease Control and Prevention Committee to Democratize Information Technology T-Helper White Blood Cells Computer-Based Health Information/Support System Catholic Institute for International Relations Crisis Intervention Teams Zimbabwe Institute of Systemic Therapy Community-based Options for Protection and Empowerment
16 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
CSW CUP DCSA DfID DHS DISH DOTS DPKO E–E FAO FBO FGC FHI FP FPAK FSW GIPA GRIDS GTZ GUD HAART HARP HCA HCP HCPs HCPS HEART HIV HSV-2 ICRW ICT IDP IDU IDUs IEC IMPACT IPC IPC/C JHU/CCP JOH KAP LSE
Commercial Sex Worker Caring Understanding Partners Daimler Chrysler in South Africa Department for International Development (UK) Demographic and Health Surveys Delivery of Improved Services for Health Directly Observed Therapy (for TB) Department of Peace Keeping Operations Entertainment–Education Food and Agriculture Organization Faith-Based Organizations Female Genital Cutting Family Health International Family Planning Family Planning Association of Kenya Female Sex Worker Greater Involvement of People with HIV or AIDS Gay-Related Immune Deficiency Syndrome German Technical Cooperation Genital Ulcer Disease Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy Health of Adolescents Refugees Project Health Care Administration Health Communication Partnership Health Care Providers (Private, public, allopathic or non-allopathic) Health Care Provider Study Helping Each Other Act Responsibly Together (Zambian HIV/AIDS prevention campaign for youth) Human Immunodeficiency Virus Herpes Simplex Virus (Type-2) International Center for Research on Women Information Communication Technology Internally Displaced People Injection Drug Use Injecting Drug Users Information–Education–Communication Implementing AIDS Prevention and Care Project, managed by FHI Interpersonal Communication Interpersonal Communication and Counseling Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Center for Communication Programs Journey of Hope Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices Life Skills Education
Abbreviations 17
MARCH MCH MDACS MOH MOPH MSACS MSM MTCT NA NAA NACO NACP NAPWA NCE NCHADS NECTOI NGO NNRTI NNVAW OI OVC PALS PATH PI PLA PLHA PMTCT PRA PRISM
PSA PSI RAP+ RH RHC RHO SARS SCI SFPS SHAKTI SMS SOMARC
Modeling and Reinforcement to Combat HIV/AIDS (Model) Maternal and Child Health Mumbai District AIDS Control Society Ministry of Health Ministry of Population and Health Maharashtra State AIDS Control Society Men who have Sex with Men Mother-to-Child Transmission Nucleoside Analogues National AIDS Authority National AIDS Control Organization National AIDS Control Program National Association of People with AIDS NAPWA Commuter Educators National Center for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs National Employment Council for Transport Operating Industry Non-Governmental Organization Non-Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors National Network on Violence Against Women Opportunistic Infection Orphans and Other Vulnerable Children Positive and Living Squad Program for Appropriate Technology in Health Protease Inhibitor Participatory Learning in Action People Living with HIV/AIDS Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission Participatory Rapid Appraisal Pour Renforcer les Interventions en Santé reproductive et MST/SIDA (or Strengthening Reproductive Health and Sexually Transmitted Diseases/AIDS Interventions Project) Public Service Announcement Population Service International Réseau Africain des Personnes avec le VIH/sida (Network of African People living with HIV/AIDS) Reproductive Health Rural Health Centre Reproductive Health Outlook Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Sara Communication Initiative Santé Familiale et Prévention du Sida (Family Health and AIDS Project) Stopping HIV/AIDS through Knowledge and Training Initiatives Project Short Message Service Social Marketing for Change Project
18 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
SRH STD STI SW TAMPEP TASO TB TBA UNAIDS UNDP UNESCO UNFPA UNHCR UNICEF USAID VCT VIPP WAGGGS WHO WST WWW YAO ZDV ZIHPCOMM
Sexual and Reproductive Health Sexually Transmitted Disease Sexually Transmitted Infections Sex Worker Transnational AIDS/SIDA Prevention among Migrant Prostitutes in Europe Project The AIDS Support Organization Tuberculosis Traditional Birth Attendants United Nations Joint Programme on HIV/AIDS United Nations Development Programme United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization United Nations Fund for Population Activities United Nations High Commission for Refugees United Nations Children’s Fund United States Agency for International Development Voluntary Counseling and Testing Visualization in Participatory Programs World Association of Girl Guides and Girl Scouts World Health Organization World Service Trust (of BBC) World Wide Web Youth Activist Organization Zidovudine Zambian Integrated Health Programme Communication and Community Partnerships
Acknowledgments Over the last 20 years, numerous organizations have been involved in different types of communication programs for HIV/AIDS prevention and care, and, more recently, a wider range of HIV/AIDS services. The authors have based this book on many of these experiences, including the past and current work at the Center for Communication Programs (CCP), Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. Supported primarily by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), CCP has been working in over 50 developing countries in the past 25 years, with an ever-increasing portfolio in HIV/AIDS within the Health Communication Partnership (HCP) and other projects. In addition, the authors have drawn on their experience in HIV/AIDS at their former organizations: Neill McKee (UNICEF and IDRC, Canada), Jane Bertrand (Tulane University School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine), and Antje Becker-Benton (GTZ, South Africa and Bushradio 89.5, Cape Town). The authors owe a debt of gratitude to a number of past and present CCP staff who drafted specific sections of text for this book, listed below in the order of appearance of the sections: Chapter 3 Social Mobilization to Bolster the National Response/ Case Study: Stop AIDS, Love Life in Ghana Interventions to Strengthen Community Responses/ Case Study: Mobilizing Traditional Networks in Guinea Promoting a Balanced Approach to Prevention Messages: The “ABCs” of Safer Sexual Practices Communication to Reduce Stigma
Chapter 4 Preventing HIV Infection in Young People
Focusing on Gender: Reaching Women and Girls, Men and Boys Sex Workers: Shifting the Balance of Power Reaching Men Who Have Sex With Men
Ian Tweedie Guillaume Bakadi Fannie Fonseca-Becker Susan Krenn Robert Ainslie Elizabeth Serlemitsos Kim Seifert Aida Olkkonen
Cheryl Lettenmaier Elizabeth Serlemitsos Jane Brown Stella Babalola Carol Sienche Lisa Cobb Lisa Cobb
20 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Prevention and Injecting Drug Users Reaching Mobile Populations HIV/AIDS in Conflicts and Emergency Situations Chapter 5 HIV/AIDS and Services: An Overview Increasing Use of Voluntary Counseling and Testing (VCT) Improving the Quality of Life of People Living with HIV or AIDS Chapter 6 Peer Education
Telephone Hotlines Using Information Communication Technologies (ICT) Appendix: R esources to K eep Communication Resources Keep Specialists Updated
Lisa Cobb Aida Olkkonen Esther Braud
Michelle Heerey Cheryl Lettenmaier Kate Stratten Kim Seifert
Jane Brown Cheryl Lettenmaier Elizabeth Serlemitsos Robert Ainslie Kate Stratten Marcela Aguilar Susan Leibtag Hugh Rigby Benjamin Lozare Jaya Nair
In addition, several CCP colleagues developed section outlines, suggested material for inclusion, or helped find relevant material: Aaron Brady, Stella Babalola, Patrick Coleman, Margaret D’Adamo, Maria Elena Figueroa, Larry Kincaid, Judy Mahacheck, Alice Payne Merritt, Andrew Plumer, Hugh Rigby, Jose Rimon, Gary Saffitz, Niranjan Singh, Amelie Sow, Youssef Tawfik, Dana Weckesser, and Kevin Zembower. The authors would like to extend a special thanks to the following staff at CCP for their help in editing and preparing the final manuscript for publication: Mark Beisser, Amanda Bowling, Kim Martin, Rita Meyer, Sujata Naik, Lavina Velasco, and Kathy Wolfe. As mentioned above, this book highlights the efforts of many other agencies and organizations working on HIV/AIDS in developing countries. We extend our thanks to the following colleagues who wrote and/or provided material for case studies: Sohail Agha, formerly PSI Jodi Ansel, Pathfinder Clement Bwalya, Youth Activists Organization, Zambia Shari Cohen, UNICEF Consultant Lisanne Brown, Horizons Program/Tulane University Stacia Burnham, ICRW Deborah Heimann, The Communication Initiative Dr. S. Jana, CARE India
Acknowledgments 21
Carol Larivee, FHI/Impact Ronnie Lovich, Save the Children O. Cam Hoeun, FHI Cambodia Hally Mahler, YouthNet Luis F. Martínez, PASMO Honduras Gordon Nyanjom, PSI Kenya Julie Pulerwitz, Horizons Program/PATH Shaleen Rakesh, Milan Project of the Naz Foundation Trust Gail Snetro, Save the Children John Stover, Policy Project/Futures Group Marco Antonio Vitoria, Brazil AIDS Program Mary Wiecynski, PSI Kenya. We are grateful to the following individuals who reviewed earlier drafts of one or more sections of the book: Lisa Howard-Grabman and Angela Brasington, Save the Children/HCP Shari Cohen, UNICEF Consultant for PMTCT Suzanne Maman, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health At the request of Sage Publications, Dr. Arvind Singhal, Presidential Research Scholar and Professor, School of Communication Studies, Ohio University, and Mahesh Mahalingam, Communication Advisor, UNAIDS, Geneva, reviewed the manuscript and gave excellent advice. John Howson, Senior Program Advisor at HCP and staff of the International HIV/ AIDS Alliance, carried out a comprehensive technical review. These inputs were tremendously valuable. Notwithstanding the extensive input from many colleagues, the authors are fully responsible for any errors or omissions. The opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the organization for which they work, nor of any other organization. Last but not least, the authors would like to thank their spouses, Elizabeth McKee, Bill Bertrand and Stanley Benton for their continued patience, personal and sometimes technical support for this project.
Chapter 1
The Challenge of Combating HIV/AIDS The Complex Challenge The AIDS epidemic, a staggering challenge by any measure, becomes more complex every year. The number of people infected with HIV climbs by 14,000 daily—12,000 adults and 2,000 children. As of December 2003, it was estimated that between 34 to 46 million people worldwide, had HIV or were living with AIDS (UNAIDS, 2003). Of the persons infected, 71 percent live in sub-Saharan Africa, the continent hardest hit by the epidemic (UNAIDS, 2002a). At present, seven sub-Saharan countries, all in southern Africa— Botswana, Lesotho, Namibia, South Africa, Swaziland, Zambia, and Zimbabwe—have an adult HIV prevalence rate of 20 percent or more, with at least one in five adults between 15 and 49 years infected. Today, more than 13 million children currently under the age of 15 years have lost one or both parents to AIDS, most in sub-Saharan Africa. By 2010, this number is expected to jump to more than 25 million (UNAIDS, UNICEF and USAID, 2002). Governments see the future of their countries blighted by the social, economic, demographic, and health impact of this disease. Health facilities—lacking equipment, supplies, and personnel—must find ways of coping with a growing number of people living with HIV and AIDS (PLHA). Many health and social service systems are near collapse under this continuously escalating burden. Yet Africa has no monopoly on the disease. China, with one-fifth of the world’s population, has detected localized epidemics in seven provinces and incipient epidemics in another nine, resulting from unsafe sale of blood plasma, a growing number of unsafe drug injections, commercial sex contacts, and an increasingly mobile population (NIC, 2002). India reported an adult prevalence rate of approximately 0.8 percent at the end of 2001 (UNAIDS, 2002a)— very low in comparison to much of Africa—but with a population of one billion, this rate translates into nearly four million PLHA. Only South Africa has more cases. At rates ranging from 1 to 6 percent, Caribbean countries have the second highest prevalence rate of any region in the world (UNAIDS, 2003); but because of a relatively small population, this region is only beginning to command more attention, internationally. Eastern Europe and Central Asia have the fastest growing regional epidemics; the number of cases skyrocketed from an estimated 5,000 in 1990 to 1.5 million at the end of 2003 (Lamptey et al., 2002; UNAIDS, 2003).
24 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
In short, although some regions, such as North Africa and the Middle East, have maintained very low prevalence rates, the HIV/AIDS epidemic continues to spread with devastating consequences around the globe. If, miraculously, we were able to eliminate all new HIV infections within a year, the number of AIDS cases would continue to increase over the next 10 to 15 years, as those already carrying the virus begin to manifest symptoms of the disease.
Global Responses During the early days of the epidemic, most international agencies, donors and governments focused their efforts on primary prevention, while non-governmental organizations (NGOs) began the first initiatives in care and support. Prevention strategies included screening blood supplies, creating awareness of HIV through the mass media, and promoting safer sexual practices. The major thrust of early programs was promoting the use of condoms. In addition, a few countries employed approaches to changing structural factors that influence behavior, such as laws and regulations (Sweat and Denison, 1995). The experience of successful countries illustrates that strong and early preventive actions can effectively reduce HIV rates. Uganda was the first African country to reduce its HIV prevalence rate. The impressive decrease in prevalence from approximately 15 percent in 1991 to 5 percent in 2001 can be traced to open and effective communication and political will to fight HIV/AIDS, as well as multi-sectoral action. This led to decreases in sexual partners, increased use of condoms, especially with non-regular partners, and, to a lesser extent, delay in sexual debut (Green et al., 2003; Hogle, 2002; Parkhurst, 2001). Thailand was the first Asian country to stem the tide of its growing HIV/AIDS epidemic. Key ingredients for achieving this were political commitment, the enforcement of condom use at nearly 100 percent in brothels and a supporting mass media campaign (Rojanapithayakorn and Hanenberg, 1996). In the chapters that follow, we analyze in depth the reasons for success in these countries, and in Senegal, Zambia, Cambodia, and Brazil, as well as in specific vulnerable groups, such as gay communities in the western countries. In contrast, we also analyze countries where little progress has been made because success in the fight against HIV/AIDS has been the exception rather than the rule. It is clearly evident that in this new millennium, we face a global emergency that is manifesting itself first and foremost in sub-Saharan Africa and increasingly in India and China. Hospitals and health centers are unable to meet the demand for treatment of opportunistic infections (OIs) and other HIV-related problems. Family members of AIDS patients devote large portions of their productive time to care giving. Communities struggle to cope with the growing number of children orphaned by AIDS. In the face of human suffering at this scale and the unprecedented need for resources to deal with the problem, the international community is beginning to direct an increasing percentage of its resources to care, support, and treatment.
The Challenge of HIV/AIDS 25
In the 1990s, voluntary counseling and testing (VCT) emerged as a bridge between prevention and care, support, and treatment. VCT services have become relatively accessible, at least in urban areas in countries such as Botswana, Brazil, South Africa, Thailand, Uganda, and Zimbabwe. VCT allows people to learn their HIV status relatively quickly and confidentially. Those who test negative may feel empowered and motivated to protect themselves against future infection. Those who find they are seropositive may be able to take steps toward living positively, such as maintaining a positive mental state, eating more nutritious foods, and seeking treatment for OIs early on. Moreover, VCT programs can provide referrals to social and medical services, as well as psychological support groups. Finally, these same programs can encourage HIV-positive individuals to avoid infecting others or to protect themselves from reinfection. Knowing one’s status also may motivate people to use anti-retroviral therapy (ART). ARV drugs—especially the more effective “triple cocktail,” which is now called highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART)—became widely available in industrialized countries in the mid-1990s where they turned the course of the epidemic for most PLHA. By following regimens strictly and testing for viral load periodically, PLHA have learned how to maintain their health. The expense of these drugs, however, made them inaccessible to most PLHA in developing countries until Brazil took the step to manufacture generic brands in-country, and, with international support, supply them free of charge to a large percentage of Brazilian PLHA (Singhal and Rogers, 2003). Indian companies have also followed suit but India is only now beginning to formulate its policy to supply such drugs to its four million PLHA. It will likely be some years before ARV drugs become widely available to the growing number of PLHA in developing countries. A promising role for ART emerged in the mid-1990s when clinical trials in Thailand and Uganda demonstrated the efficacy of using a short course of ARV drugs, together with VCT, in the prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT). It was found that mother-tochild transmission (MTCT) can be decreased by 50 percent through proper use of these drugs and improved obstetric practices (Shaffer et al., 1999). PMTCT is now becoming an integral part of the fight against HIV/AIDS in many countries. However, despite the demonstrated cost-effectiveness of PMTCT and VCT, these services remain out of the reach of the vast majority of pregnant women and new mothers, even in high-prevalence countries. Time is of the essence. Efforts made early in the growth of an epidemic have a much greater effect in reducing its scale than efforts made later in its course (R owley and Anderson, 1994). HIV experts have now defined a package of 12 essential prevention interventions and nine care and support activities that constitute the expanded response to HIV/AIDS in low- and middle-income countries (Schwartlander et al., 2001). If the international community implemented this comprehensive package of interventions on a large scale it would have great impact. Stover et al. (2002) have estimated (through mathematical modeling based on epidemiological analyses and results of intervention studies) that if such a package was implemented globally by 2005, it would be possible to reduce the number of new HIV infections by 63 percent by 2010.
26 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Strategic Communication: An Essential Ingredient In recent years, the global response to the HIV/AIDS epidemic has taken many forms. Governments have mobilized national AIDS control committees. The health sector has responded with intensified prevention activities, as well as care, treatment, and support. Ministries of education have brought HIV/AIDS prevention into the curriculum of primary and secondary schools. Ministries of information, finance, labor, women’s and community affairs, and many others have played a role in their respective sectors. New NGOs have sprung up around the world to provide health and social services for PLHA, home care for people with full-blown AIDS, and care and support for orphaned children. Since the onset of the epidemic, information and communication have played a role in this response. In many countries in the 1980s, well-intentioned health officers and other personnel with little or no experience in communication, developed messages aimed at instilling fear about HIV and AIDS. Such efforts often failed to engage the public in positive behavioral change. For instance, annual World AIDS Day, consisting of activities intended to create greater awareness of HIV/AIDS, have sometimes inadvertently stigmatized PLHA and so-called “high risk groups.” Strategic communication is a promising response to the HIV/AIDS epidemic that has been vastly underutilized to date. The systematic nature of strategic communication contrasts sharply with the ad hoc practice of designing an occasional poster or radio spot for a given cause. It combines a series of elements—extensive use of data, careful planning, stakeholder participation, creativity, high-quality programing, and linkages to other program elements and levels, among others—that stimulate positive and measurable behavior change among the intended audience. The challenges in the realm of behavior and social change remain daunting. The international HIV/AIDS community has learned a number of sobering lessons over the past two decades. Sexual behavior is often irrational, especially where alcohol and drugs are involved, which casts doubt on rational models of decision-making (Perloff, 2001). Many individuals are unwilling to acknowledge risk or to sacrifice sexual freedom (Richens et al., 2003). Even after success in behavior change, “backsliding” may occur. For example, the advent of HAART in the western world appears to have caused some in the gay community to adopt an attitude of “treatment optimism,” abandoning safer sex practices largely because HIV is no longer seen as a death sentence (Richens et al., 2003). The same may occur in developing countries as ART or HAART becomes more readily available. Experience from developing countries indicates that if we focus on individuals, rather than communities and social organization, we tend to “blame the victim” and will not have optimal impact. Cultural norms play a key role in sexual behavior, such that programs must attempt to change social norms as well as individual behavior (Airhihenbuwa and Obregon, 2000). This book argues that strategic communication, which can address both behavior and social change, is an approach that has proven highly effective in other areas of public health (e.g., family planning) and yet has been underutilized in the area of HIV/AIDS. In addition, structural and environmental factors have a powerful influence on individual behavior—a fact that has led numerous experts to propose combining interventions aimed at
The Challenge of HIV/AIDS 27
individual behavior change with those targeting structural change (Richens et al., 2003; Sweat and Denison, 1995). As discussed in detail in Chapter 3, advocacy and social mobilization are components of strategic communication that can be effectively employed to facilitate change in structural and environmental factors. Finally, this book argues that strategic communication also has an important role to play in the expanded range of services that are now integral to most national HIV/AIDS control programs: VCT, PMTCT, and care, treatment, and support for other PLHA. Within these interventions, communication should be considered an essential component for educating the public, shaping attitudes and perceptions, creating demand for services, and improving provider–client interaction. Communication strategies must be tailored to individual national settings and to the different sub-populations within each country. Experience has shown that comprehensive communication programs are needed in both low and high prevalence countries. In the early stages of an epidemic, governments and donor agencies have usually devoted most resources to targeted interventions with vulnerable groups, such as sex workers, truck drivers, and other members of the mobile workforce. However, such targeted action has often stigmatized such people and reinforced the denial of risk among the general population. Well-researched and well-designed communication programs can be used to counter this tendency and to increase public discourse on and acceptance of the threat of HIV/AIDS. Experience in Uganda and Thailand has shown that this is essential. Both low and high prevalence countries require intense focus on groups at high-risk because of their behaviors or vulnerabilities, often through interpersonal communication channels specifically directed to them (e.g., peer education among sex workers). Both require the engagement of the general public, although increased resources will be required for intensified efforts in higher prevalence countries. Moreover, in large countries such as India or China, small percentages translate into an enormous number of people infected with HIV. In China, the low sounding “0.1 percent prevalence rate” announced at the end of 2001 translates into at least one million seropositive individuals in 31 provinces (UNAIDS, 2002a; UNAIDS, 2003). Mass communication channels can complement other interventions in reaching large numbers of infected and affected people. Indeed, as countries realize the need to go to scale with HIV/AIDS interventions, strategic communication—a combination of mass media and interpersonal channels, together with both social and community mobilization—offers great promise.
Audience for this Book This book is directed to those who are working or are planning to work on some aspect of strategic communication, either in planning and/or implementing programs directly or in encouraging the incorporation of communication in specific projects. These different audiences may include: l
Communication Specialists: those responsible for designing and implementing actual communication programs in countries worldwide. This book provides an overview of
28 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
l
l l
l
state-of-the-art techniques that have been used in different settings around the globe, with specific ideas—but no “cookie-cutter” prescriptions—on approaches to achieving behavior and social change. Public Health and Social Development Specialists: those people from multiple disciplines who work alongside communicators in researching, planning, designing, implementing, and evaluating programs. Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs): those who often implement the types of activities outlined in this book, especially community-based interventions. National-Level P olicymakers and P rogram Managers Policymakers Program Managers: those responsible for implementing a national HIV/AIDS strategy, as well as local HIV/AIDS interventions. This book outlines the added value of strategic communication in addressing the full range of HIV/AIDS issues. Bilateral and International Agencies Agencies: those whose support is needed to implement large-scale communication efforts in the fight against HIV/AIDS. This book provides the rationale for investment in communication as part of the national response to HIV/AIDS, worldwide, as well as guidelines on appropriate ways of approaching the job.
Organization of this Book This book provides practical guidelines for designing strategic communication programs for HIV/AIDS and is organized as follows: Chapter 2 outlines the basic principles of strategic communication applicable to behavior and social change in general, as well as to HIV/AIDS in particular. Chapter 3 outlines the familiar roles of communication to date, which remain as important as ever: advocacy to garner political commitment and to improve policies, social mobilization to engage a broader range of sectors in the fight against HIV/AIDS, and community mobilization to promote prevention and encourage care and support of PLHA. This chapter also describes comprehensive approaches to prevention, including promotion of the “ABCs” (Abstinence and delay of sexual debut, Being faithful or reduce sexual partners, and Condom use). Finally, it discusses the use of communication in reducing stigma, a phenomenon that accompanies the HIV/AIDS epidemic, worldwide, and acts as a major obstacle to prevention, treatment, care, and support. Each of the sections of the chapter has subsections that cover the rationale for the approach, formative research questions, audiences and actors, strategic approaches, key issues to communicate, and challenges and lessons learned. Each section ends with a case study that demonstrates how the approach has been utilized in the context of a specific developing country. Chapters 4 and 5 are structured in a similar way. Chapter 4 focuses on communication programs for specific audiences. Whereas previous sections identify different audiences, this section provides more in-depth coverage of programing
The Challenge of HIV/AIDS 29
for particular subgroups within the population: young people, women/girls, men/boys, sex workers, men who have sex with men (MSM), injecting drug users (IDUs), uniformed services, mobile populations, and people living in refugee settings. Chapter 5 describes, in detail, the role of communication in support of the clinical and social services that have surfaced with the evolution of the HIV/AIDS epidemic: VCT, PMTCT, ART, services for PLHA, and care and support of orphans and other vulnerable children (OVC). Chapter 6 focuses on selected strategic communication approaches that the authors believe have shown both great potential in changing behavior and the capability to be further exploited: entertainment–education, peer education, telephone hotlines, and digital communication. Each of the sections in this chapter has subsections on rationale, formative research, audiences, strength of the approach, essential elements, challenges and lessons learned, plus a section on increasing local capacity. Case studies round off the documentation as well. Chapter 7 addresses some of the emerging challenges in combating HIV/AIDS. Finally, the Appendix provides an inventory of resources for professionals working in the area of HIV/AIDS prevention and care, in order to assist them in updating their knowledge, identifying prototype materials, networking with colleagues, and accessing formal training courses. Note: Throughout this book, we generally use the well-known acronym, “HIV/AIDS” to refer to the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) and its resulting condition—Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS). However, we have tried to use “HIV” alone, “AIDS” alone, or “HIV and AIDS” when the issue being discussed relates to the virus alone, the disease alone, or to both the virus and the disease in a different manner. Evidence has shown that many people at the community level do not understand the difference between the stages of infection and the disease, including the fact that years of relatively healthy living can lie between them. This type of misinformation exacerbates stigma against people diagnosed with HIV.
Chapter 2
Strategic Communication in the Fight Against HIV/AIDS
The Challenge Strategic communication is an approach to the design and implementation of programs that increases their impact on behavior and social change. For some, communication may conjure up the image of a glitzy mass media campaign. Indeed, such programs can be effective in capturing the attention of the intended audience and influencing individual behavior and social norms. However, the most effective programs combine the power and reach of mass media with activities that allow face-to-face interaction, such as community-based events and interpersonal communication/counseling (IPC/C). Strategic communication starts with a vision that creates optimism—to avoid HIV, live positively, show compassion—and motivates people towards adopting specific behaviors. Based on a multi-disciplinary approach, drawing on sociology, psychology, anthropology, marketing, and other disciplines, strategic communication combines the science of a data-driven, systematic process with the art of creative programing. There is no recipe that one can follow mechanically but rather a set of guidelines that inform the process. Our main purpose in writing this book is to argue that well-executed, strategic communication has been vastly underutilized in the fight against HIV/AIDS. We have learned a great deal about strategic communication from other areas of social development, family planning in particular (Piotrow and Kincaid, 2001). Yet two decades of HIV/AIDS prevention work have shown that the epidemic presents unique challenges in terms of behavior change and requires new thinking. Few countries have used this approach in mounting their national response to HIV/AIDS to date. Whereas TV spots, billboards, community rallies, schoolbased events, and countless other communication activities abound, rarely are they part of a well-coordinated, systematic effort that extends to all levels and sectors of society. In this chapter, we begin by outlining the current state-of-the-art in strategic communication for social development, including HIV/AIDS. We present the elements used in designing, implementing, and evaluating effective programs. We explain the paradigm shift that has occurred in relation to HIV/AIDS prevention, which requires us to move beyond “business
Strategic Communication 31
as usual.” We conclude the chapter with our recommendations for more effective HIV/AIDS programing, which center on three principles: 1. Target social norms as well as individual behavior. 2. Expand beyond ad hoc interventions to a coordinated social movement. 3. Bring community-level activities to scale through a linkage with mass media.
Elements of Strategic Communication Although no two programs will evolve in exactly the same manner, certain common elements guide the design and implementation of any strong program. In this section, we expand on the elements outlined by Piotrow et al. (1997) and adapt them specifically to HIV/AIDS. (1) F ollow a Systematic Approach: In the early days of information–education– Follow communication (IEC) programs, well-intended communicators would often respond to a given problem by creating colorful posters or pamphlets for the intended audiences with information on the relevant topic. Absent was any analysis of the characteristics of the problem (e.g., prevalence levels), segmentation of the population most affected, existing levels of knowledge, psychosocial and economic barriers to service utilization, and other relevant factors. Over the past three decades, the field of social communication has evolved markedly, and many programs now use a systematic approach to the design and implementation of behavioral change interventions. The systematic approach refers to a sequence of steps that guide the planning and implementation of the program in which elements of design and execution are interspersed with data collection and analysis that inform decision-making. Several different models exist, but all are strikingly similar at the core. The Center for Communication Programs at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health has promoted the “P-Process” since 1982. It entails five steps: (i) analysis, (ii) strategic design, (iii) development, pretesting, and production, (iv) management, implementation, and monitoring, and (v) impact evaluation (Figure 2-1). A model from the US-based National Cancer Institute involves an iterative, four-step process (Figure 2-2). Although the graphic is different, many of the concepts are similar to Figure 2-1. Family Health International (FHI, 2002a) has proposed a more detailed, 12-step process (Figure 2-3). These three models share several common characteristics: l l l l l
a sequential ordering of actions in the design, implementation, and evaluation of the program. in-depth analysis of the situation to guide the design process. creative design of communication products, based on empirical data. constant dialogue between those designing/implementing the program and those collecting data. continuous tracking of the process and outputs for mid-course corrections and other adjustments to the program.
32 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Figure 2-1: The P -P rocess for Strategic Communication Planning P-P -Process
Source: JHU/CCP, 1997 Figure 2-2: The Stages of Health Communication
Source: National Cancer Institute, 2002
Strategic Communication 33 Figure 2-3: Steps in Developing a Behavior Change Communication Strategy
Source: Family Health International (FHI, 2002a)
(2) F ocus on the Objective: Programs have a better chance of being successful if they are Focus designed with specific results in mind. The goal of the international and national agencies working in this area is to halt the epidemic at the macro level. Most programs work toward the objectives of reducing HIV transmission, providing treatment, and providing care and support to those infected and affected by HIV/AIDS at the individual and community level. In the early days of the epidemic, communication program objectives generally reflected prevention in the form of achieving changes in knowledge, misconceptions, and practices— especially regarding condom use. Today, communication program planners and evaluators tend to be more specific about each objective, specifying the intended audience and time frame (e.g., to increase the percentage of young people age 10 to 17 years in country “X” who report they are not sexually active). In some cases, communication program planners and evaluators will also specify the magnitude of expected change in relation to existing services (e.g., to increase the number of youth who undergo VCT in city “Y” by 20 percent in a 12-month period). This approach presumes that baseline data are available.
34 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
A clear focus on the objective helps to shape the design of the communication program and the types of activities to be undertaken. Focusing on results means that programs cannot stop at the production of catchy, appealing messages or seemingly effective outreach activities. Rather, their success is judged by the extent to which they actually achieve their objectives. (3) Segment the Audience: The choice of channels relies on the principles of audience segmentation. Audience segmentation derives both from epidemiology (identifying patterns of HIV transmission) and marketing (targeting those with relevant behaviors, interests, and needs). It involves identifying subgroups of the population and tailoring communication interventions to most effectively reach these groups. In the commercial sector, market segmentation often entails socio-economic status, age, gender, and increasingly, lifestyle. In the case of HIV/AIDS, segmentation also uses these same factors (e.g., programs that target young people in low-income households). Much of segmentation relates to individuals whose behavior puts them at a higher risk of HIV transmission: MSM, IDUs and sex workers. To single them out as groups in highly visible ways as the focus of HIV prevention work, further stigmatizes them. Moreover, such an approach inadvertently can send the message to the general public that the risk of HIV/AIDS is limited to these groups rather than to particular behaviors, thus causing others to disregard messages on the dangers of the virus. What then is the solution for this dilemma? Everything we know from epidemiology argues in favor of segmentation, especially in the early stages of the epidemic when infection is limited primarily to subgroups. Interventions can be designed to use channels that reach these groups without drawing the attention of the general public. For example, La Sala program is operating in several Central American countries that provides a safe haven for sex workers. The program establishes a house for their exclusive use in the neighborhood near their work; the sex workers can drop by to have a cup of coffee, cook a meal, read a magazine, and socialize with others. La Sala also provides information, free condoms, counseling, and referrals to medical and social services. Similarly, the most effective outreach programs for MSM are those designed and implemented by members of this group, who know how best to reach others. Kippax and Race (2003) note that gay groups in developed countries have become agents in the national response to HIV/AIDS, using their knowledge of epidemiological/medical risks to adopt behaviors that confer protection. Outreach programs for IDUs must find their intended audience where they congregate—often in the streets— and communicate with them one-on-one or in groups. (4) Incorporate Theory into P rogram Design: Strategic communication must be theoryProgram based. Although the word “theory” has ponderous academic connotations, in its simplest form it explains how a program is expected to bring about the desired change and can reveal hidden assumptions. Either implicitly or explicitly, nearly all interventions are based on theory (King, 1999). One challenge in using theory in the design of HIV/AIDS programs is selecting or identifying the most appropriate one for a certain audience. We revisit the questions of behavior change theory and the paradigm shift in relation to HIV later in this chapter. (5) Use R esearch throughout the P rocess, from Design to Evaluation: Strong programs Research Process, are built on evidence-based decision-making. The types of research required in strategic
Strategic Communication 35
communication fall into the conventional categories of formative, process, and summative (Box 2-1). Not all programs will have the resources necessary to conduct research at every stage. It is nonetheless useful to recognize the full range of research and evaluation that potentially guide the design and mid-course corrections for a program, in order to decide which types of interventions will potentially be most useful and cost-effective. Box 2-1: T ypes of R esearch Needed to Guide Decision-making Types Research Formative research includes a series of quantitative and qualitative techniques used to learn more about a problem in a particular social context (Debus, 1986; Valente, 2002). Problem analysis reveals various levels of causation, as well as the manifestation and outcomes of the problem. Specifically, formative research is important for identifying the extent of the problem in a given population, or segments of the population most affected, and for finding factors that explain its occurrence, existing levels of knowledge and attitudes toward the situation, barriers to action, and related information. Formative research is conducted early in the project life cycle and guides decision-making on design and implementation. It can and should be carried out with each new element of the program, even if these are brought in later. The pretesting of communication materials and tools constitutes one type of formative research. Before finalizing a given communication material, tool, or media program, program staff test it in near-final form among members of the intended audience for comprehension, aesthetic appeal, cultural acceptability, and related factors. Also, very important is testing the acceptability of the tool by implementing it with organizations and their fieldworkers, as well as with communitylevel gatekeepers, the tertiary audience in the participation analysis for strategic communication (Box 2-4). Operational research is generally required with fieldworkers because they are the ones who must manage the materials in the field. Based on the results, the creative staff then modifies the materials before final dissemination. Although pretesting can greatly enhance the effectiveness of communication materials and tools, too often programs neglect to pretest or they do so in a hasty fashion without extracting the full benefit from the exercise. Process evaluation consists of both quantitative and qualitative research methods used to track how the program is implemented and how well it is received (Rossi et al., 1999). One common approach is to compare the activities outlined in the plan of action with those actually implemented at the field level. Process evaluation also measures the reaction of the target population to a given communication program once it has been launched, thus identifying areas in need of mid-course correction. Client satisfaction is an often-studied element of process. In short, process evaluation measures “what has been done” and “how well it has been done,” but not what changes have occurred because of it. Program monitoring is one form of process evaluation that tracks outputs, either in terms of activities completed (e.g., number of brochures produced, number of talks given) or actual service utilization (e.g., number of youths attending a given rally, number of new visits to a VCT clinic). This type of monitoring allows one to determine the extent to which the actual program conforms to the original implementation plan, and it gives some evidence of audience response in the form of attendance or clinic visits. Summative evaluation measures the extent to which a program achieves its objectives. Depending on the study design, it may also demonstrate causality (the extent to which the program under (Box 2-1 contd.)
36 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic (Box 2-1 contd.) study was responsible for the behavioral outcomes observed). Without summative evaluation, it is impossible to determine whether or not a given program has been effective. One common fault in designing programs is to assume that summative evaluation only “comes at the end.” Although the post-test or follow-up data are collected well after the program has been implemented, the evaluator(s) should decide upon the design from the outset of the program to ensure the availability of the necessary data to establish impact. Programs differ in the financial and human resources they have available and are willing to devote to these different types of research. Indeed, a common underlying tension among program designers and evaluators is that research and evaluation compete for funds with the design and implementation of a program. Yet savvy program administrators realize that the best programs result from using research to inform and improve the intervention at all stages along the process. Evaluation requires a knowledge base and skill set that would fill a separate book. We refer readers to two useful references on this subject (Bertrand and Solis, 2000; UNAIDS, 2000a) but do not attempt to address this topic in this book. Source: See citations mentioned in the box.
(6) Use Strategic P ositioning: Communicators use positioning to determine the best apPositioning: proach to motivate audiences to change or adopt a specific behavior. Positioning establishes in the minds of the audience an image of the desired behavior that helps them remember it, learn about it, act upon it, and advocate for it (Piotrow and Kincaid, 2001). As O’Sullivan et al. (2002) explain, effective positioning involves communication on a program, product or service that: l l l l
resonates with the audience, differentiates from the competition, stands out as better than the known alternatives, and provides a benefit that is worth the cost or effort.
Whereas some might consider this idea of strategic positioning—and the closely linked concept of “branding” or establishing a long-term identity—to be exclusively in the domain of commercial marketing, in fact, it can be equally applicable in social development communication. Positioning creates a memorable cue for the audience to know why they should adopt a behavior. It shapes the development of messages and the selection of channels. In addition, it ensures that messages will be consistent and that each communication effort will reinforce other activities for a cumulative effect (O’Sullivan et al., 2002; Piotrow and Kincaid, 2001). (7) Adopt the Entertainment–Education Approach: As audiences around the world gain greater viewer sophistication and have access to more media channels, health communication must be able to compete for viewer attention with high quality, entertaining programing. In response, communication specialists are turning increasingly to “entertainment–education”
Strategic Communication 37
(E–E) as a means of reaching millions with attention-grabbing messages or emotion-charged drama. E–E continues to grow in popularity, precisely because it captures the interest of the audience as it delivers socially-beneficial messages (Jacoby and Fokkens, 2001; Piotrow and de Fossard, 2003; Singhal and Rogers, 1999). Drama has more effect than many other forms of communication because it tells an engaging story, it involves the audience emotionally, and it depicts changes in characters with which the audience identifies (Kincaid, 2002). The empathic emotional response in the audience is the motivational force that induces members of the audience to reconceptualize the central problem depicted in the drama, and to resolve it in their own lives, using lessons learned. E–E not only takes advantage of “star power,” but also creates celebrities out of relatively unknown actors. In Nicaragua, the Puntos de Encuentro program created a television series Sexto Sentido on adolescent reproductive health topics that became one of the most popular TV shows in the country. Nicaragua had no well-known actors, so they recruited high school and university students. Once the show was on the air and became a hit, the actors became celebrities. When they went on tour to different cities and visited high schools to talk about the themes raised in the show, young people would swamp them with requests for autographs. People on the street would stop them and viewers would send them fan mail asking to be their friends, some proposing dates, others asking for advice because fans considered them as role models. UNFPA chose “Alejandra” (who used emergency contraception after having unprotected sex with someone she did not know) and “Angel” (the openly gay character in the show) as local celebrities to be their goodwill ambassadors. E–E is by no means limited to the mass media. It is an indispensable tool in community mobilization, where crowds congregate precisely on the hope of being entertained by streettheater troupes, a pop music group, puppeteers, or an engaging spokesperson. Whereas celebrity status is not essential for strategic communication, strong creative design is key to delivering messages with the greatest potential impact. Good scriptwriters, actors, and other creative artists sometimes resist the systematic approach used in the design of strategic communication for health and development purposes (for example, using pretesting as a basis for developing and changing scripts and characters). Yet, most will come to agree to these requirements if they are given adequate explanations for the rationale or they are involved as observers in the process (de Fossard, 1996; 1998). (8) Establish Quality Standards: To be effective, a communication program must be carefully designed and implemented. In the case of mass media, this requires the use of skilled, creative staff and good production facilities. Moreover, communication materials need to be pretested for attractiveness, comprehension, cultural acceptability, and related factors. With respect to community-based programs, personnel must be well-trained and have the appropriate interpersonal skills to interact effectively in group settings. They need to arrive when they say they will, use participatory techniques to engage the community, stay on topic, and use appropriate communication supports in a professional way. The process of achieving quality takes different forms. Few, if any, social development agencies have a staff of creative talent available for the design and production of communication
38 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
programs in multimedia formats for multiple levels. Rather, most organizations depend on one or more key staff to coordinate the creative process, including contracting with local ad agencies or recruiting the talent needed to produce specific communication products (e.g., TV spots, radio programs, printed materials, and so forth) (Greenberg et al., 1996). In terms of community-level activities, keys to quality include hiring and retaining people with excellent qualifications for IPC/C and motivation of groups through interactive methods. Additional keys to quality in the context of clinic facilities include staff who are sensitive to client needs and fears, treat clients with dignity and respect, provide accurate information, ensure confidentiality, and give hope. (9) Use Multiple, Mutually R einforcing Channels: The question of “what channel is the Reinforcing best to use” is clearly outdated. In the world of strategic communication, programmers combine different communication vehicles: mass media, community mobilization, and IPC/C. Within each category, they may employ multiple channels, such as women’s groups, church groups, sports events for youth, and others. Ideally, the different channels must send mutually reinforcing messages. Actors and actresses on TV soap operas can serve as valuable role models for specific behaviors that clinic personnel should perform in VCT. Public service announcements (PSAs) on radio can provide the same information as print materials distributed in clinics and schools. The multiple factors that influence the choice of communication channel are outlined in Box 2-2. (10) Design Client-Centered P rograms: The program should cater to the interests of the Programs: intended beneficiaries rather than to those of the people designing and implementing it. For this reason, it is essential to involve the audience in program design through formative research or other processes such as direct participation in story design. Messages and stories must resonate with the aspirations, fears, and needs of the group. Perhaps the greatest challenge lies with service delivery programs in which health care personnel are overworked and close to burnout due to the additional caseload of HIV and AIDS patients. Even in such settings, those responsible for programs must find ways of shifting toward client-centered services, which are more convenient, less time consuming, and more polite (Piotrow and Kincaid, 2001). (11) Ensure P rograms are Benefit-Oriented: HIV/AIDS communication must speak directly Programs to the needs and interests of the audience. Communicators and communication tools must stress how the behaviors they promote will directly benefit both individuals and communities, in terms of quality, convenience, affordability, or response to an important felt need. Vague appeals to “national interest” carry little weight. Rather, messages must convey to the listeners why they or their families will be better off by following a certain course of action (Piotrow and Kincaid, 2001). (12) Ensure P rograms are Service-Linked: Communication is not an isolated component Programs of a national, regional, or local program. Rather, it is a means of translating concepts from a national strategy into action at the field level. As the HIV/AIDS epidemic evolves, the range
Strategic Communication 39 Box 2-2: F actors Influencing the Choice of Communication Channels Factors Complexity of the Issue: Although IPC/C tends to be labor-intensive, it is by far the most appropriate type of communication for certain situations. For example, VCT centers devote substantial resources to pre- and post-test counseling, precisely because a confidential, one-on-one dynamic is important in this emotionally charged service. Sensitivity of the Issue: Highly sensitive issues may not lend themselves to the use of mass media. For example, Takalani Sesame in South Africa introduced an HIV-positive muppet, Kami, as part of the cast of characters (Segal et al., 2002). Via both radio and TV, Kami provides young viewers with age-appropriate knowledge of HIV/AIDS and attempts to reduce stigma toward PLHA. However, the mass media do not address the sensitive issues of child abuse in relation to HIV/ AIDS; rather, these topics form part of the curriculum for outreach activities, mediated by trained adults. Literacy: Whereas certain segments of the population may be highly literate (e.g., students participating in school programs), others may not be able to read and write—a factor that would rule out print materials with extensive text. Since levels of literacy tend to be lower in rural than urban areas, radio serves as an excellent medium for reaching such audiences in many countries. Desired R each: Programs aspiring to national coverage or even large segments of the general Reach: public often use some form of mass media. By contrast IPC/C is more appropriate when the message needs to be tailored to the individual. Prevailing Social Norms: Countries differ greatly in their openness and willingness to deal with the behaviors linked to HIV transmission. For instance, many countries still have constraints on airing condom messages, while others have overlooked existing laws and norms due to the urgency of the HIV/AIDS threat. For example, in Thailand, as part of the initiative to ensure 100 percent condom use in brothels, national mass media carried messages encouraging men to use condoms when visiting sex workers despite the fact that commercial sex work is illegal in that country (Rojanapithayakorn and Hanenberg, 1996). Media Habits and P references of the Intended Audience: Findings from formative research will Preferences indicate the extent of access that a given audience has to different media (radio ownership, TV ownership, opportunities for listening/viewing elsewhere), as well as its media habits (viewing, listening, reading). Moreover, formative research identifies preferred viewing times, favorite stations, and favorite programs. Surveys can identify memberships in different types of community activities that could serve as vehicles for behavior change communication (BCC) or ask about access to computers and Internet. Cost: The costs of different communication channels vary by type and also by country. TV production and the purchase of TV airtime are often beyond the budgets of organizations, even though TV may be cost-effective in terms of unit cost per person reached. Radio is much less expensive and may reach specific audiences (e.g., youth, residents in rural areas). Thus, cost plays a determining role in the choice of media. Source: See citations mentioned in the box.
of services expands: counseling on prevention, STI diagnosis and treatment, VCT, treatment of OIs, nutrition counseling, PMTCT, and, in a growing number of countries, appropriate use of ART or HAART. In addition, the number of other services for PLHA is growing, such
40 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
as home care, psychosocial counseling, and education programs for OVC. Communication is a primary vehicle for informing the public about these services, creating demand for them, reducing stigma, and encouraging adherence to testing and treatment. Strategic communication must link people to the services they need. By the same token, those designing communication programs must ensure that the services they promote are consistent with the services actually available to the public (Piotrow and Kincaid, 2001). (13) Incorporate P articipation and Interaction: Evidence abounds that people learn more Participation when they participate actively than when they passively absorb information. Whereas earlier theories of communication described one-way communication between sender and receiver, many programs today are developed with the involvement of the intended audience, and operate on the basis of two-way or multi-directional communication. Even where mass media are involved, the audience is encouraged to call in questions, get more information through a hotline, write letters to the station, or enter a “chat room” on an issue through the Internet. Community-based events offer greater opportunity for direct interaction and participation. Programs can also foster greater participation in the clinic-based setting by coaching clients how to interact with service providers to get answers to their questions—a “smart client” approach. (14) Consider Cost-Effectiveness: Cost-effectiveness refers to measuring costs in relation to outcomes as a means of identifying strategies that yield the best return on the financial investment. It does not imply using the lowest cost alternative, if it does not provide results. One difficulty in establishing cost-effectiveness is the dearth of rigorous research, to date, on either the cost of HIV/AIDS communication interventions or their impact in specific settings. In the absence of exact numbers, planners can, nonetheless, make rough estimates in comparing the relative return on communication through different channels. To move from cost-effectiveness as a concept to a criterion for decision-making in HIV/AIDS programing, it will be necessary for the organizations to fund such work so researchers can refine their methods for measuring cost-effectiveness in relation to communication interventions. With greater efforts in this type of research, we expect in the future to be able to more accurately respond to the question: “How can additional funds be allocated with the greatest effect to achieve and sustain healthy behavior?” The 14 elements of strategic communication programs, outlined above, describe the stateof-the-art approach that has worked very effectively in the realm of international family planning and other social development programs. Yet the urgency of the HIV/AIDS epidemic and the challenges it presents to sustained behavior change require us to further refine our approach to strategic communication as it relates to HIV/AIDS. At the heart of this refinement is a shift in paradigm, resulting from a gradual evolution in behavior change theory.
Strategic Communication 41
A Paradigm Shift from Behavior Change to Social Change Theories, refined into models and frameworks, are useful in both the design and the evaluation of communication programs. In an in-depth review of behavioral theories relevant to sexual behavior change, King (1999) identifies and describes in detail the major theories used to date. In terms of individual change, the best known theories are the health belief model, reasoned action, social learning, stages of change, and the AIDS risk reduction model. In terms of design, theories identify important variables and specify how these variables work together to produce a desired outcome (Witte, 1998). For example, the health belief model specifies that preventive health behavior is influenced by five factors: (i) perceived barriers to performing the recommended response, (ii) perceived benefits of performing the recommended response, (iii) perceived susceptibility to a health threat, (iv) perceived severity of a health threat, and (v) cues to action (Janz and Becker, 1984; Rosenstock, 1974). These constructs become the basis on which to design specific interventions that may consist of messages via mass media or interpersonal channels and skill-building exercises in community settings. In evaluating the program, researchers test the variables specified in the models to determine whether or not individuals are engaging in the desired behaviors, and if not, which variables in the model explain why they are not (Witte, 1998). For example, members of the intended audience may have increased their awareness of HIV/AIDS, believe that HIV/AIDS is a serious threat to their own health, and even believe that condoms are an effective means of protection. Yet they may not have the power or skills to be able to undertake the behaviors needed to protect themselves (e.g., negotiate condom use). Over the two decades since HIV/AIDS first emerged, theories to explain behavior and social change have evolved markedly. Early in the epidemic, many practitioners assumed that simply giving correct information about transmission and prevention would lead to behavior change. This model proved naïve. “Second generation” interventions, which continue to inform programs today, drew on psychosocial and cognitive approaches that educated individuals in practical skills to reduce their risk of infection (Kalichman and Hospers, 1997). In recent years, social scientists have come to recognize that socio-cultural factors strongly influence complex health behaviors, including sexual behavior (Kippax and Race, 2003). Beyond an individual’s own social network, there are larger structural and environmental determinants that also affect sexual behavior, such as living conditions related to one’s employment (e.g., mining camps that require men to spend substantial periods of time away from home) (Sweat and Denison, 1995). Whereas early theory work tended to focus on behavioral change at the individual level, the field has moved toward theories and models that focus on social groups/communities and on larger contextual factors. With respect to theories that take into account the larger social context, King (1999) cites the diffusion of innovations, social influence (social inoculation), social networks, and gender/ power. In addition to this arsenal of theories, several authors have emphasized the role of structural and environmental factors (Sweat and Dennison, 1995) as well as policy and economic issue (Carael et al., 1997) as determinants of behavior change. Interventions of this
42 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
type target organizations, communities, and policy (King, 1999). One widely cited example is the policy for 100 percent condom use brothels in Thailand, credited with reducing HIV incidence throughout Thailand in the early 1990s (Rojanapithayakorn and Hanenberg, 1996). During the first decade of the AIDS epidemic, western social scientists generated the majority of the theory work related to HIV/AIDS. Indeed, many researchers saw the applicability of paradigms created in relation to North America or Europe to the problem of HIV/ AIDS in developing countries. Whereas the conditions differed markedly, certain factors such as risk perception and self-efficacy seemed equally relevant to developing and developed countries. Fishbein, one of the leading behavior change theorists, argues that we do not need “new” theories of behavior and behavior change, but rather for investigators and interventionists to better understand and correctly utilize existing, empirically-supported behavioral theories in developing and evaluating behavior change interventions (Fishbein, 2000). However, others have taken a more socio-political point of view, stating that concentrating on the western, individual-oriented theories has often led us to addressing the media-rich “haves” rather than the harder-to-reach “have-nots,” inevitably increasing the gap between such segments of society. In addition, when the “have-nots” do not adopt certain behaviors, they are often blamed for the failure of a program (Figueroa et al., 2002; Robinson and Levy, 1986; Tichenor et al., 1970). “Personal and individual blame is to some extent a natural consequence of doing individual, psychological research on problems that are fundamentally social problems” (Caplan and Nelson, 1973). The HIV/AIDS epidemic has driven this need for new thinking because it usually begins with the “haves” who are mobile and who have money for multiple sexual partners or intravenous drugs. However, within a few years, it silently penetrates the much larger communities of “have-nots” who are then asked to change their behavior to confront an enemy they cannot see nor understand, an enemy that infects their bodies, as well as their social organization and coping mechanisms. While the “haves” may have the education and understanding, as well as the economic resources to seek counseling and care that leads to behavior change and even prolonging their lives with ART, the “have-nots” are not in such a position. They are blamed and stigmatized for being infected. In addition, during the past decade, numerous researchers have challenged the individuallyoriented social cognitive theories on other grounds. The first major criticism relates to the applicability of these theories to the social and cultural context of developing countries, in general, and of Africa in particular (Airhihenbuwa and Obregon, 2000). For instance, program planners have often expected members of the target audience to adopt behaviors that are inconsistent with cultural norms, with few clues of how to counter the inevitable social consequences of such bold action. “Culture” has often been viewed as a negative force or a barrier to change instead of an attribute that can work toward positive ends. Amaro (1995) has argued that most theories have focused on the individual or two-person unit, downplaying the importance of culture in influencing people’s construction of social reality and decisions regarding safer sex. A UNAIDS (1999a) publication based on consultations with communication researchers and programmers in a number of developing countries similarly concluded that most HIV
Strategic Communication 43
communication programs are shaped around theories and models that do not meet regional or local needs. The publication maintains that these theories have been used to explain HIV/ AIDS-related behavior in western countries, but relatively few have been tested or validated in developing countries, with a few notable exceptions (e.g., the diffusion of innovations work of Astatke and Serpell, 2000; Rogers, 1995). A second major source of criticism relates to the issue of intentions, which assume selfagency or self-efficacy (the ability of the individual to take control of his or her behavior) and action. Kelly et al. (2001) argue that cognitive decision theories of behavioral change do not address the contingencies that bring intentions to fruition. Particularly in the field of sexual activity, cognitive self-agency models of acting are particularly inappropriate, because the individual does not necessarily have control over actions in this arena (e.g., unfaithfulness of the partner, financial destitution, separation of families for work-related reasons). Individuals simply may not be in a position to undo the circumstances that led them to the behavior in the first place. In real life, sexual mores, gender stratification, and gender role stereotypes operate powerfully to discourage men and women from practicing safer sex (Perloff, 2001). A third criticism relates to the implied rationality in many of these theories. That is, they assume that people are rational creatures who consider the costs and benefits of alternative actions and make careful use of information available to them. However, under social pressure, in the heat of the moment, or under the influence of alcohol and drugs, good intentions may give way to the motivations of the moment. Emotions and sexual arousal may overtake the best of intentions (Perloff, 2001). As Kelly and Kalichman (1995) point out, “insufficient attention has been paid to the many psychological, relationship, cultural, affective-arousal, and situational influences that surround and form the context for human sexual behavior.” Indeed, criticism along these lines led UNAIDS to develop an alternative framework that refocuses communication interventions on the basis of five key contextual domains: government policy, socio-economic status, culture, gender relations, and spirituality (UNAIDS, 1999a). The key principles of this document are as follows: l l
l l
l
Sustainability of social change is more likely if the individuals and communities most affected own the process and content of communication. Communication for social change should empower, be horizontal (versus top-down), give a voice to the previously unheard members of the community, and be biased towards local content and ownership. Communities should be agents of their own change. Emphasis should shift from persuasion and the transmission of information from outside technical experts to dialogue, debate, and negotiation on issues that resonate with members of the community. Emphasis on outcomes should be beyond individual behavior to social norms, policies, culture, and the supporting environment.
According to Scalway (2002a), these principles are influencing the major donors and international organizations. For example, USAID, DFID, UNICEF, and a consortium of Nordic nations now have policies or strategies that emphasize the social change approach.
44 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
However, those working in HIV/AIDS face a dilemma. On the one hand, many accept the principles outlined above and recognize the importance of community-driven social change and its effectiveness in the long run. On the other, they are acutely aware, given the urgency of the epidemic, that participatory processes with communities can be labor-intensive and time-consuming. Their parliaments and boards of directors often demand to see quick results with taxpayers’ or foundations’ money. Those responsible for combating HIV/AIDS must find effective means of reaching the largest possible number of people with information and motivation that could save their lives. Our proposed approach builds on the elements of strategic communication, outlined earlier in the chapter. To effectively combat HIV and AIDS, we must develop a more inclusive process than exists in most countries today. The new thinking must respond to the critics that call for greater community empowerment, but it must also recognize the need to go to scale as quickly as possible. To this end, we propose three principles that must inform the new thinking on communication programs for HIV/AIDS: (1) T arget Social Norms as well as Individual Behavior: Much of the HIV/AIDS prevention Target work, to date, has focused on individual behavior, for instance, the ABCs. Yet many have come to realize that the “self” or individual cannot be separated from his/her social environment. Figure 2-4 captures this holistic view of individual behavior as a product of multiple, overlapping social and environmental influences (McKee et al., 2000a). This model illustrates the immediate influence of family, peers, and community on the individual or self. The series of rings beyond this immediate context of family, peers, and community describe elements that are essential to behavior change, along with factors that will condition that change. Specifically, people need accurate and timely information about HIV and AIDS and other health and development problems, shown in the next concentric circle. With such information, some individuals, groups or communities may be empowered to act. However, such people are usually those who are already motivated or empowered through education and other programs. For most people, information is not enough and they require motivation through strategic communication, such as effective counseling, entertaining radio, or TV programs. If done well, such communication will foster individual attitudinal and behavior change, as well as social norm change. However, motivation may not be enough. Few young people in the countries hardest hit by HIV/AIDS have the power to negotiate the time and conditions for having sex, including the use of condoms. They need the ability to act, shown in the fourth ring, in particular circumstances that pose a threat to their health and survival. Such skills are sometimes called psychosocial life skills or emotional and social skills such as problem-solving (in social relationships), decision-making, negotiation, critical and creative thinking, interpersonal communication, and other relationship skills such as empathy, and coping with stress and emotions. Many of these skills involve group interaction and collective efficacy. In fact, psychosocial life skills are acquired through interactive, group learning. The originators of this model emphasized life skills because they are essential elements of protection against HIV/AIDS.
Strategic Communication 45 Figure 2-4: Behavior Development and Behavior Change in the Social and Environment Context
Source: McKee et al., 2000a
In fact, the model emphasizes behavior development of both children and adolescents who have not yet begun practicing risk behaviors, as well as change for those who are already practicing them and may be able to change with the help of new skills, along with information and motivation. Finally, the outer ring of Figure 2-4 represents the overall social and environmental context consisting of macro elements that impede or accelerate behavior and social change, such as policies/legislation, services, education systems, religion, politics, economics, the physical environment, and the organizational environment. Communication specialists must take these factors into consideration in designing programs, and they must work in concert with others to bring about positive changes in relation to these macro-level factors. As shown in Figure 2-4, values—the composite expression for attitudes, beliefs, social norms, or world views—cross-cut the entire model of concentric circles and anchor individual and social behavior. In-depth research and participatory interaction with people are the means of developing an understanding of values for purposes of communication planning. The implication of the model in Figure 2-4 for strategic communication is that programs must not focus exclusively on individual change, but must aim to influence the social context
46 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
in which the individual operates. Programs must target social norms, not just individual behavior. The model also underscores a second key concept for improving the effectiveness of strategic communication programs: expanding beyond ad hoc interventions to a coordinated social movement. A more detailed model that captures the need for comprehensive programs that work at multiple levels is the “Pathways Communication Model for HIV/AIDS,” presented in Figure 2-5. This model draws on the conceptual framework for the USAID-funded Health Communication Partnership, which has a large HIV/AIDS component. The pathways model reflects the concept of mutually supportive channels of communication, aimed at different levels: the sociopolitical environment, service delivery systems, communities, families, and individuals. It also outlines the initial outcomes and behavioral outcomes that precede actual change in HIV transmission or social norms relating to the care and support for PLHA. In short, it summarizes the multiple elements that together lead to the desired long-term outcomes. (2) Expand Beyond Ad hoc Activities to a Coordinated Social Movement: The rising incidence of HIV in many African and Asian countries has intensified the commitment of numerous countries to deal with this epidemic and has jolted others to begin taking action. They recognize the urgency to act, though some feel overwhelmed by the magnitude of the challenge. The first response of many countries is to design and implement interventions to reach groups who are most vulnerable to HIV infection. However, many stop short of a plan to effectively scale up the national response through social mobilization. Figure 2-6 presents a model for strategic communication planning that builds on the PProcess (shown in Figure 2-1). This planning model may be applied to the processes of social change. The revised P-Process differs from the original in four important ways: (i) It expands on the concept of analysis by explicitly including both situation assessment, and communication and audience analysis. Situation assessment involves the collection and review of relevant epidemiological and social data. By contrast, communication analysis is an exercise to identify both the behavior and values of the audience, which is specifically geared to strategic communication initiatives. (ii) It shows the concepts of “participation” and “capability strengthening,” to be integral components of the process. (iii) It broadens the language and concept of “strategic design and development” to include an understanding of its possible application to community mobilization and IPC/C, as well as mass media. (iv) It shows that the results from the initial cycle should be fed back into the program in subsequent cycles, informing the programatic assumptions in the analysis, at any level, or the strategic design, which may have to change. Details of each step of the process are provided in Box 2-3. As is evident, the concepts of “management” of the whole process and continuous “feedback” are added here to the other cross-cutting concepts of participation and capacity strengthening. The revised P-Process is more explicit than the original in signaling the importance of mobilization for social change, which requires the involvement of many organizations, agencies
Source: Adapted from the Health Communication Partnership (2002).
Figure 2-5: P athways Communication Model for HIV/AIDS Pathways
48 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Figure 2-6: R evised P -P rocess Revised P-P -Process
Source: Health Communication Partnership, 2003b
and people at the national, state, district, and community levels. One process that forms part of the communication analysis is participation analysis that identifies the different individuals and institutions that should be involved. It consists of “segmenting” all of the social actors who may influence or want to own the direction of the program. Box 2-4 defines the different actors who may have a role to play in advocacy efforts at the national, state/provincial, and district level as well as in Behavior Change Communication (BCC) at the community level.
Strategic Communication 49 Box 2-3: P -P rocess (revised)—Steps in Strategic Communication P-P -Process (1) Analysis l
l
Situation Analysis: Severity and causes of health, social and environmental problems. Identify social, cultural and economic factors inhibiting/facilitating desired social changes. Develop problem statement. Identify formative research priorities and carry out. Audience and Communication Analysis (a) Participation Analysis National to district levels levels:: Identify partners and allies for policy change and strengthening service delivery. Community level level:: Segment primary/secondary/tertiary audiences, plus fieldworkers/change agents. (b) Social and Behavioral Analysis Individual level level:: knowledge, attitudes, skills, and behaviors. Community level level: social networks, socio-cultural norms, collective efficacy, and community dynamics, including leadership patterns. Ser vices level Services level:: availability of communication materials, capacity for interpersonal communication and counseling. Environmental level: public opinion, existence of action groups, media engagement, policies and legislations affecting interventions. (c) Communication and T raining Needs Assessment Training Media access and use of participants, capacity of media practitioners, organizational capacity of partners and allies. Resources needs.
Throughout process:
Participation: Include national, district, and community level
Capacity Strengthening: Ensure capacity from national to community level
(2) Strategic Design l l l l l
Establish communication objectives. Develop main communication approaches and positioning. Determine budget and key strategies: channel and media selection. Develop an implementation plan for key activities, include roles and responsibilities of partners and allies. Develop and monitoring and evaluation plan.
(3) Development and T esting Testing l l
Develop and test concepts, processes, messages, stories, materials. Revise and pilot test final versions and adjust, as needed.
(4) Implementation and Monitoring l l l l l
Monitoring and F eedback: Feedback: Manage and facilitate, track outputs and ensure timeliness, quality and learning processes
Produce and disseminate final materials. Conduct training of trainers and of fieldworkers/change agents. Mobilize key partners, allies, and communities to implement plan. Manage and monitor program participation and outputs. Adjust program materials, activities, procedures, as needed. (Box 2-3 contd.)
50 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic (Box 2-3 contd.) (5) Evaluation and R eplanning Replanning l Assess outcomes and impact on knowledge, attitudes, skills, behavior. l Disseminate results to partners, counterparts, stakeholders. l Determine needs for follow-up and/or extension. l Revise/redesign program processes, materials and activities. Source: Health Communication Partnership, 2003b Box 2-4: P articipation Analysis—P otential Actors for Advocacy and B CC Participation Analysis—Potential BCC Advocacy (National/State/P rovince/District) (National/State/Province/District) Partner: An institution, association, ministry, corporation, or group that serves as a resource (financial, technical, human, or material) for collaboration with the core partners in achieving the overall objectives of a designated program area, usually for the full length of the program. Ally: An institution, association, corporation, group, celebrity, spokesperson, or politician that serves as a resource (financial, technical, human, or material) for collaboration with the core partners in achieving at least one of the objectives in a designated program area, often being engaged for a specifically defined time. Gatekeeper: An authority, powerful individual, institution, or association—at the national, regional, or district level—that influences the policy or legal environment (social, cultural, religious, political, or economic) that either facilitates or inhibits behavior and social change. Gatekeepers may allow or inhibit program interventions to take place through various national, regional, or district channels. Programs may bring them on board as partners and allies through advocacy, or they may succeed in “neutralizing” them. Behavior Change Communication (Community Level) Primary Audience: Those whose behavior is the focus of the strategic communication objectives. Secondary Audience: People who directly relate to the primary audience through frequent contact and who may support or inhibit behavior change in the primary audience through their influence. The strategic communication objectives often must focus on them directly for changes to take place in the primary audience. Tertiary Audience (Community-level Gatekeepers): Local community groups, institutions, or individuals who may support or inhibit behavior and social change in a community by allowing or disallowing an intervention to take place. These people control the local social environment, communication channels and decision-making processes, and have a great influence on local social norms. Fieldworker or Agent: A natural agent of change in a community, usually representing an institution or organization that may have similar goals for behavior and social change and who may be brought on board for communication program purposes through involvement in training, planning, and implementation.
Participants in the advocacy program are often an audience for advocacy themselves. Once persuaded to become partners or allies, they are natural advocates for the cause. Some may
Strategic Communication 51
be “gatekeepers” who need to be convinced in order to communicate to the general population (e.g., media gatekeepers) or to a specific group of people such as youth in school (e.g., education authorities). This type of concerted advocacy can lead to the involvement of a wide range of operational partners and shorter-term allies in a multi-sector response—“social mobilization” for HIV/AIDS prevention, care, and destigmatization. Box 2-5 provides an example of a participation analysis in relation to female sex workers (FSWs) that proved useful in planning a large-scale communication program in the state of Maharashtra, India. It presents part of the results of a planning process for an integrated HIV/AIDS communication plan in that state. Stakeholders in the planning process included service providers, government personnel, and NGOs who worked directly with various groups— youth, sex workers, truckers, IDUs, MSM, and representatives from those groups. The “sex worker group” analyzed the HIV/AIDS situation in the state and drew on its own knowledge of the issues to complete this participation analysis. Box 2-5: P articipants in P rogram for F emale Sex W orkers (FSWs), Maharashtra, India Participants Program Female Workers Advocacy (State or District Level)
Behavior Change Communication (Community Level)
Partners (Operational)
MSACS, MDACS, Avert, Women’s Commission, Local NGOs, Ministry of Health/ Home Affairs, NACO, donors, Organization of SW, Mahila Aarthik Vikas Organization
Primary Audience
Bar girls, non-brothel-based FSWs, brothel-based FSWs, regular partners
Allies (Event or Function-specific)
Condom manufacturers, Chalak Malak Sanstha Organization, lawyers associations, childcare organizations, local press/ media, vocational training institutions, folk artists, Truckers Federation
Secondary Audience
“Madams”, clients (general public), pimps, petrol pump owners/employees, beauty parlors owners/employees
Gatekeepers
Police dept., local health authorities, women activist groups, hotel/bar/lodge associations, political parties
Tertiary Audience (Community Gatekeepers)
“Fixed” taxi drivers, lodge owners, mobile vendors, local police, Yuvak Organization, religious leaders, local elected members
Fieldworkers Peer educators, outreach workers/volunteers, health or Agents care providers, counselors Source: Health Communication Partnership, 2003c
52 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Participation may go beyond articulating detailed plans. Participants may also be involved in the formulation of materials, including their messages and stories. For instance, in an HIV/AIDS program for young people, adolescents can be involved in formulating radio and TV programs, dramas, or stories for comic books alongside researchers, writers, artists, programmers, and media gatekeepers (see Plate 2-1). They can become part of the process of articulating objectives and designing stories and characters—in other words, full partners in the process much before the usual step of pretesting. This is the “paradigm shift” that can happen when a participation analysis is carried out before the design process begins.
Plate 2-1: Adolescent participation in Bangladesh ARH design workshop. (Credit: CCP)
In summary, participation analysis provides an inventory of potential partners in a societywide movement to combat HIV/AIDS. Although the job of bringing together these partners may fall to the national or state AIDS control program, often communicators can play a key role in recruiting these groups to participate in the national response. Chapter 3 discusses social mobilization in more detail.
Strategic Communication 53
(3) Bring Community-Level Activities to Scale through a Linkage with Mass Media: Community mobilization is a natural part of social mobilization. However, communities must be involved in this national movement as partners, not as targets of a campaign. Experience to date has shown several ways of enlisting communities as partners in the fight against HIV/AIDS, which is elaborated on in greater detail in Chapter 3. Programs should use an expansive definition of “communities”: (i) communities defined by residential proximity, (ii) groups brought together by common interests or beliefs, such as religious communities, and (iii) communities of vulnerable groups, such as FSWs, MSM, and IDUs. As the response to the HIV/AIDS epidemic evolves—especially in the areas of testing, treatment, care and support—community initiatives take on renewed importance. Yet a major shortcoming of programs, to date, has been the disconnect between community initiatives, on the one hand, and mass media efforts on the other. Often, different organizations develop community-based and mass media interventions as two parallel but separate programs. This approach wastes much of the potential synergy to be gained from coordinating programs for these two levels. Another problem is the plethora of overlapping projects, tools, and processes to garner the participation of different communities in development efforts, which can lead to confusion and a waste of resources. A mechanism for coordination and synchronization of efforts is absent. As the epidemic continues to spread unabated in many countries, HIV/AIDS programs must go to scale. Pilot projects have proven useful in testing certain approaches, but we must identify ways of expanding their benefits to a larger portion of those in need. The mass media have a powerful reach and have proven to be effective in breaking the silence around HIV/AIDS—an essential first step to action at the individual, community, and policy levels. Still creating links between the HIV/AIDS communication via the mass media and community-based initiatives helps to deliver far greater impact. A number of programs are beginning to move in this direction. For example, the MARCH model, championed by CDC, links E–E programming through mass media with communitylevel initiatives (Galavotti et al., 2001). Similarly, a number of the programs with technical input from Johns Hopkins’ Center for Communication Programs join the mass media elements, often including E–E, with community-level work. For example, the Stop AIDS, Love Life program in Ghana demonstrates the power of linking mass media programming with community-level interventions as part of a coordinated, multi-sectoral movement to combat HIV/AIDS (see Chapters 3 and 4 for case studies of Stop AIDS, Love Life and other programs that link mass media and community elements).
Conclusion Strategic communication offers a powerful set of tools for designing, implementing, and evaluating programs. It provides guidance for both communication related to HIV/AIDS prevention, as well as treatment, testing, care, and support. Communication is not a set of
54 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
isolated activities or something that a group of specialists do separately from others working on HIV/AIDS initiatives. Rather, it is the process for converting the national HIV/AIDS strategy into tangible interventions that effect people’s lives. In this chapter, we outlined the elements of strategic communication and a paradigm shift in its theoretical reference and framework. This provides structure to the design of communication programs and underscores the ideas presented in the remainder of this book. We have learned an enormous amount about communication during the first two decades of the HIV/AIDS epidemic, yet the epidemic continues to spread. In the absence of a vaccine or a cure, behavior change represents one of the very few means of stemming the epidemic. We must apply the most effective tools we have to this job, and strategic communication provides a valuable framework for the next generation of HIV/AIDS programs.
Chapter 3
Communication for Social and Behavioral Change Strategic communication provides powerful approaches for reaching national policymakers, local government officials, traditional and religious leaders, community leaders, and members of the general public to influence social norms and individual behavior. This chapter expands on the discussion begun in Chapter 2 regarding the need for advocacy, social and community mobilization, and BCC in the following sections: l l l l l
Advocacy to strengthen political commitment Social mobilization to bolster the national response Interventions to strengthen community responses Promoting the ABCs for safer sexual practices Communication to reduce stigma
Advocacy to Strengthen Political Commitment Rationale Uganda has had the most dramatic decline in HIV infection rates in the world. HIV prevalence peaked at around 15 percent in 1991 and declined to 5 percent as of 2001 (Hogle, 2002). President Museveni of Uganda has been given much of the credit for this success. He demonstrated an early and relentless resolve to fight HIV/AIDS, igniting the forces of Ugandan society—including all levels of government, NGOs, community-based and faith-based organizations, and other elements of civil society—to take on the fight (Green, 2001). Some have said Uganda was successful due to the natural course of the epidemic and people started to act based on a fear response to seeing friends and relatives dying. However, to counter this argument, the same has not happened in other high-prevalence countries and there have been some successes even in a few low-prevalence countries. For instance, Senegal has been recognized as another success story, albeit in a different way, as the infection rate only reached 1.1 percent in 1990 and has declined since 1997 to 0.5 percent at the end of 2001 (UNAIDS, 2002a). The fact that Senegal is a more
56 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
conservative and religious society with nearly universal male circumcision and was attacked by HIV-2, rather than the more virulent HIV-1, may have contributed to its success. However, it is evident that behavior change did not come about in Senegal due to a fear response. Rather, as in Uganda, political and religious leadership supported AIDS prevention efforts boldly and at a relatively early stage (Green et al., 2003). Thailand and Cambodia (see Cambodia case study) demonstrated a similar resolve. In Thailand, the government strongly backed a 100 percent condom campaign in commercial sex facilities, which helped to trim new infections from a high of 140,000 during 1991 to 30,000 during 2001 (UNAIDS, 2000b). The record to date shows that where political, religious, and social leaders do not fully and openly back efforts to stem the spread of HIV early, their constituents remain in denial and the virus continues to spread unabated. India is a case in point where some government officials “proclaimed that AIDS was a foreign disease, and that the epidemic could never spread in a family-centered society” such as theirs (Singhal and Rogers, 2003). By the end of 2002, India had a prevalence rate of at least 0.8 percent with 3.82 to 4.58 million PLHA (UNAIDS, 2002a; UNAIDS, 2003). However, even in India some bold leaders have taken a stance on HIV/AIDS. Most recently the Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh, a south Indian state of 76 million people with a growing HIV prevalence, has championed the cause in the fight against HIV/AIDS by breaking the silence and asking for concerted action by state personnel and partners. Leaders demonstrate political commitment by using their power and influence for a cause. Advocacy has been the major strategy to gain needed political commitment where it is absent or weak. Advocacy is a component of strategic communication that is too often ignored. Its dictionary definition is “verbal argument or support for a cause or policy,” such as that which is done by a lawyer in a courtroom. In international development work, it has been defined more comprehensively: Advocacy is a continuous and adaptive process of gathering, organizing, and formulating information into argument to be communicated through various interpersonal and media channels with a view to raising resources or gaining political and social leadership acceptance and commitment for a development program, thereby preparing a society for its acceptance (McKee et al., 2000b). Through advocacy, we attempt to influence a nation, state, or district to strengthen the fight against HIV/AIDS through changes in resource allocations, or policies and laws such as the provision of family life or life skills education in schools, the reduction of school fees for orphans, budgetary provision for adequate HIV testing services, condom availability in government health centers, the legal age of sexual consent and of marriage, and laws on discrimination against PLHA. In addition, advocacy can be employed to hasten the development of national policies on HIV and AIDS prevention, care, support and mitigation that help to create an enabling environment for all strategic interventions. However, action against HIV/AIDS need not await the finalization of policy. Consider the difference between Ethiopia and Uganda. The Government of Ethiopia began to develop a national AIDS policy in 1988, but the country remained rather inactive in fighting the
Communication for Change 57
epidemic for many years. The Government of Uganda did not begin such policy formulation until 1996, after years of concerted action and considerable success. Both governments approved their policies by the end of the decade (Stover and Johnston, 1999).
Formative Research The participation analysis described in the previous chapter, feeds into advocacy planning. In addition, answers to the following questions are needed to develop an effective HIV/AIDS advocacy program or campaign: l l l l l l l l l
What is the HIV prevalence and incidence, as well as main causal factors? What are the communication barriers? What is the level of denial by leadership and the causes for this? What are the present dispositions/attitudes/opinions of key leaders on HIV and AIDS? Do they share information with their constituencies? What has been the experience with political and other leadership support in comparable countries, provinces, regions, or districts? What is the level of stigma attached to having HIV and AIDS? Which policies, laws, and regulations either enable or create a barrier to an effective response to HIV and AIDS? What changes or additional policies or laws are needed? Which are the most effective channels or means of reaching key leaders? What is the projected effectiveness of various communication interventions, including how they can support a multi-sector response? What are the effects of decentralization on a possible response?
Audiences and Actors As discussed in the section on participation analysis in Chapter 2, the audiences for advocacy can be many and varied: l l l l l
the president or head of state, prime minister, cabinet, parliamentarians, key public servants, respected statesmen or stateswomen, religious and traditional community leaders, social and business leaders, women’s leaders, NGO leaders, and celebrities who may have a positive effect on public opinion.
These people should be identified at every level where change is needed—national, provincial/ regional, district, and sub-district. Advocacy efforts target these individuals in an effort to bring them on board to support HIV/AIDS programs whenever possible. Even better, they may become effective advocates for the cause. In other words, the original audiences may
58 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
become the actors. In some cases, however, important gatekeepers may feel they cannot enter into the debate personally and may opt to be silent on issues, but not block the needed changes.
Strategic Approaches Who carries out advocacy? Often advocacy begins with public interest groups and NGOs that see the need for change in policy or laws within a given society. Sometimes it is these individual efforts that pay off. Very often these activities are fragmented and ad hoc. By using participatory methods and involving key government and civil society partners, national, state, or district advocacy plans for changes in policies and resource allocation can become part of an overall communication planning exercise. These individual groups may later wish to engage lobby groups or public relations firms that have experience in moving the public agenda through negotiation and persuasion or by positioning issues effectively through public events and the media. Strategic approaches to gaining political commitment for a sustained effort in the fight against HIV/AIDS will vary by country and context. In some countries, political leadership may be ready to become more committed to the fight against HIV/AIDS, but religious leaders may remain an obstacle. In this case, it may be difficult to foster change. To help “break the silence,” one solution is to locate and educate one potentially powerful “positive deviant” in the religious community who can plant the seeds of change. However, the political leadership in a country might be too conservative or too preoccupied with other issues, such that the only possibility is to start with changing public opinion—the opinion of the leadership’s key constituencies—in order to build pressure for change. Another strategic approach is to influence leadership opinion through a pilot project such as a community-based response in which the leaders not only see the problems, but also witness how a community is dealing with them in a positive and productive way. This gives the politician something to embrace and endorse publicly. Specific Strategies for Advocacy Targeted Interpersonal Communication: This strategy, also known as “lobbying,” is among the most cost-effective. Leaders are often influenced more by such interpersonal means than by any other. However, if the president of a country is a key object of advocacy, it is necessary to carefully identify the individual(s) who may influence him or her. Should it be a respected elder statesman? Or should it be a business leader, a media celebrity, or PLHA? Analysis and planning are required to determine this. In addition, advocates or lobbyists must know what they want to achieve through such interactions. “An advocate should never go into a meeting designed to increase political commitment for HIV/AIDS policies and programs without being able to respond to the question, ‘What do you want me to do?’” (The Policy Project, 2000a).
Communication for Change 59
Simple P rint T ools: Simple, well-designed print materials can be effective in reinforcing Print Tools: the main points one wants to make, including actions the leader can take. One of the most effective materials are pocket-sized, colorful, spiral-bound cue cards containing key points in bullet form with easily understood graphics. Leaders need accessible information. The object is to advocate with them so that they in turn become advocates for HIV/AIDS prevention and care. If top leaders are well-respected, they will have a great deal of influence on the public statements and actions of their subordinates who can further influence the public at large. Presentations on the Impact of AIDS: One means of getting the attention of political and social leaders is to demonstrate the effect HIV/AIDS has on the overall demographic, macroeconomic, and social development trends in the country. A politician’s own survival depends on the improvement in such trends, especially in democratic countries. When confronted with clear projections, based on good data, leaders may be persuaded to put their weight behind a cause. One example of such a tool is the AIDS Impact Model (AIM) of the Policy Project (see Cambodia case study). AIM has been used in a wide variety of countries and settings, such as in Kenya, where hundreds of presentations have been made to different levels of society, from the President to district development committees. In Kenya, AIM presentations contributed to an increase in political will to act after a long-held silence (The Policy Project, 2000b). Briefing and T raining of Members of P rint and Electronic P ress: This strategy, sometimes Training Print Press: called “media advocacy,” may be effective in broadening political and social leadership support, especially in more democratically inclined systems. Leaders know that media have a large role in shaping public opinion. Well-informed media channels—such as newspapers, radio and television news, and public opinion programs—can influence leaders by providing them with new facts and opinions, as well as conveying the perception that their constituents may also be well-informed on these same facts. For example, one of the main problems that journalists still face when reporting on HIV/AIDS is convincing their editors, who are often not sensitized on the issues of appropriate ways to handle stories. Moreover, newsrooms in many countries are often dominated by men who see HIV/AIDS as a “soft issue” (AWMC and UNDP, 2001). Journalist training can have a major effect on mass media and advocacy regarding the ethics of AIDS reporting, as well as curbing the use of vocabulary that invites stigma. Training should include editors in their role as gatekeepers for HIV/AIDS stories and HIV/AIDS NGOs, which need to learn how to collaborate better with the press (AWMC and UNDP, 2001). In training media personnel on HIV and AIDS, it is important to present technical information in a clear and concise way with well-formulated curricula, well-designed hand outs, reference papers, and sources of further information. Journalists may view very glossy, expensive-looking materials as “propaganda” and reject these outright. In addition to the complex technical issues involved with a retrovirus and its attack on the body’s immune system, journalists must deal with many social issues: values, biases, prejudices, myths, and
60 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
misconceptions. They must have the freedom to discuss all the issues in an open, nondirective manner. In some cases, the trainers will need expert opinion and almost irrefutable evidence. However, those organizing the training of journalists must be prepared to deal with strong opinions based on political perspectives rather than science, such as the debate that raged in South Africa that poverty (not HIV) causes AIDS. Good facilitation skills are needed to keep the training or orientation session “on track” if such issues arise. Training of journalists should not be restricted to technical or medical issues. Journalists are in a position to rapidly propagate myths and traditional biases, such as the belief in some countries that women are to blame for the spread of HIV or that having sex with a virgin is a cure for AIDS. In addition to dispelling such myths, journalists need to know that one of the fundamental causes of the spread of HIV/AIDS through heterosexual behavior is gender inequity. Therefore, gender sensitization and training may be just as important or more important than teaching about the medical and health issues involved in HIV transmission. Likewise, training on issues of human sexuality may be needed to counteract prejudices against MSM and sex workers. It is important to involve gender and sexuality experts and to include the participation of both men and women in training sessions. Without such training, journalists may propagate gender stereotypes and myths about the role of women or minority groups in spreading HIV, thereby hindering rather than facilitating social change. Holding P ublic Events: Public events—including conferences, workshops, and meetings to Public discuss policy issues or research findings—have been somewhat overused in HIV/AIDS programs. If events are well-designed, they provide an occasion for political and social leaders to confirm or reaffirm their commitment to the fight against HIV and AIDS. Leaders know that people want to hear their position on issues. Strategic use of events includes the strategic choice of the right venue and audience and proper briefing of leaders on issues beforehand. For example, it would be counterproductive if the audience were to berate a leader publicly or if the press were to scorn him or her for a position taken. Such incidents can weaken political commitment to the fight against HIV and AIDS. By contrast, a newsworthy, wellinformed, and well-orchestrated press conference can serve to broaden advocacy to lower level leadership, as well as the general public. Working with PLHA for Change: Engaging PLHA as spokespeople for HIV/AIDS programs and involving them in the planning of interventions may be one of most effective strategies for “breaking the silence” and dealing with stigma, as well as increasing political will for policy change and an enabling environment. It is particularly fortuitous when such spokespersons are well-respected individuals who no one would have expected to have HIV or AIDS. When President Museveni first opened public discourse in Uganda, Philly Bongoley Lutaya, a Ugandan musician based in Sweden, declared publicly that he was HIV-positive and returned to Uganda in 1989 to speak out widely about the disease before he died (KyenkyaIsabirye, 1990). His advocacy work benefited the people of Uganda and gave the impetus for setting up the AIDS Information Centre, which now provides VCT services to a large number of people. His name is memorialized in programs even today. Magic Johnson, the famous American basketball star, is another person who helped to set the public agenda and destigmatize PLHA. He remains alive and healthy today, largely because of HAART and the steps he has taken both mentally and physically to protect his health. Using mass media
Communication for Change 61
channels to communicate messages of such popular personalities helps spread the word that HIV and AIDS can be dealt with in a positive and open manner. However, it is not necessary that spokespeople always be celebrities. Nkosi Johnson, an 11-year-old South African boy, had a great influence on public opinion by stepping up to the podium to break the silence in South Africa before he died of AIDS (Singhal and Rogers, 2003). In Ghana, the Stop AIDS, Love Life program created radio and TV spots and materials with an HIV-positive laborer named Douglas Sem, who was the first to speak out about his status in an open way. His openness led to greater political commitment and began to reduce stigma (Tweedie et al., 2002). Putting politicians and religious leaders on the same stage as PLHA can send a powerful signal to lower-level political, religious, and community leaders, as well as to the public at large. Leaders may be spurred into action through the personal experience of knowing someone who is living positively with HIV/AIDS or someone who has died.
Key Issues to Communicate In advocacy, issues or key messages to communicate may be many and varied. This will depend largely on the answers to the formative research questions mentioned above. In countries where the epidemic is not advanced, leaders may be motivated by the following messages: l l l l l l
Act before it is too late, before the virus spreads to the general population and takes its toll on our culture, society, and economic life. Recognize the costs and opportunity costs of different targeted interventions and their linkages to existing services or the need for new services. Expect a positive effect from such actions, based on socio-economic projections (see Cambodia case study) and the cost of long-term inaction. Take action that makes a difference, including influencing others. Address “risk behaviors” and not “risk groups,” avoiding the stigmatization of the population most infected. Use a balanced “ABC” approach.
In countries where the epidemic is advancing to the general population, additional issues to communicate may include the following: l l l l l
It is essential to “breaking the silence” on many social taboos and open up communication on the issues. A collaborative, multi-sectoral response is imperative; we are all in this together. Health and social services need to expand their capacities and meet the challenge. Religious leaders must motivate their congregations to action or they will soon be out of a job. Compassion for PLHA is essential and PLHA must be involved in all aspects of the national response.
62 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Challenges and Lessons Learned HIV and AIDS pose a tremendous challenge for the building of political commitment due to a tendency to blame various minority groups that have little political clout, such as sex workers or MSM, groups that some national or religious leaders may denounce publicly. The invisibility of the epidemic in its early stages, and the complexity of behavior and epidemiological factors involved, sometimes allow the national resolve to be sidetracked into fruitless debates such as the one on where AIDS originated. When such resistance exists, effective advocacy for political commitment may require a great deal of analysis, preparation, and planning before it is implemented. Advocacy efforts must stay current with policy shifts and progress in programs. Instead of just calling for access to ARV drug treatment for all infected, some activists have shifted the advocacy strategy to include calls for improving the infrastructure, coordination, and collaboration of existing health care services (ICASO, 2002). In fact, this shift represents a return to earlier attempts by NGOs in the mid- to late-1990s that called for the strengthening of infrastructure and essential drugs for PLHA (AIDS Consortium, 1998). Leaders’ voices are needed at many stages. “Breaking the silence” is only a first step. New political commitment may be needed for adequate STI treatment or VCT services, condom supplies, needle exchange programs, or in-school education programs. Each of these programs implies a whole set of behavioral and social issues and may ignite differences of opinion grounded in value differences. Each may require a different approach. Programs should generally avoid focusing on the negative. For instance, religious leaders as a group have often been castigated by donors, UN agencies, and NGOs as the main barrier to increasing political and societal will. However, in spite of the lack of visible support to HIV/AIDS prevention, many religious leaders have led the way in care and support responses. There is often no recognition of the fact they often feel caught between what is expected of them in their vocational roles and the reality they face in their own lives as members of a vulnerable community. It is only in the last few years that they are being courted and are now seen as part of the solution (Howson, 2003). Finally, advocacy efforts need to be monitored and evaluated. If a particular strategy is not proving successful, there is no sense in continuing in that direction. Monitoring and measuring success in advocacy may be done through simple indicators, such as the increase or decrease in positive, negative and neutral newspaper articles on HIV and AIDS over a period of time (The Policy Project, 2000c). Another tool, used at the international level in over 40 countries, to date, is the AIDS Program Effort Index (Stover et al., 2000). This composite indicator measures a range of factors, including political support, the legal and regulatory environment, human rights, policy formulation, organization, prevention and care programs, and evaluation efforts. The results from this index serve to motivate political and social leaders to action. When a given country scores low compared to others, its leaders may feel the pressure to do better by the time of the next “report card.”
Communication for Change 63
Case Study: Application of the AIDS Impact Model in Cambodia Background: In Cambodia in 1995, a survey of sex workers revealed that 38 percent were HIV-positive; by 1997, the overall adult prevalence rate had reached an estimated 3.2 percent (Singhal and Rogers, 2003). By the end of 2001, nearly 80 percent of sex workers were consistently using condoms with customers (Singhal and Rogers, 2003), and the overall prevalence rate dropped to 2.7 percent (UNAIDS, 2002a). How did this happen? An analysis of Cambodia’s efforts to fight HIV/AIDS indicates that advocacy played a key role in gaining political support. One of the advocacy interventions implemented to sustain the momentum in Cambodia involved the AIDS Impact Model (AIM) of the POLICY Project. AIM can be used to gain support for a new national plan, to push for the creation of an HIV/AIDS coordinating council, or to increase funding for prevention and care. It consists of a computerized information tool that analyzes, develops, and presents information about the current status of the epidemic and makes projections of AIDS cases and deaths, as well as the future impact on health, social, and economic well-being. AIM incorporates proven interventions that reduce HIV transmission, reduce stigma, and improve the lives of those infected or affected. The presenter can change the assumptions during the presentation (e.g., “suppose we doubled the number of pregnant women in PMTCT services”) to show the impact of such changes on the course of the epidemic. The program also shows how the implementation of various prevention strategies will impact positively on these macro-level factors. Several versions of AIM can be prepared for different audiences, depending on their technical grasp of the subject and their preferences for different types of program planning and resource mobilization. AIM can generate computer presentations, color slides, or overhead transparencies ready for use. However, the presenter needs good presentation skills to use these tools effectively as well as technical skills to manipulate the computer program. Twenty or more presenters can be trained at one time in order to rapidly deploy the program at provincial, district, and lower levels, as required. Audiences and Strategy: In Cambodia, the National AIDS Authority (NAA) was established to lead a multi-sectoral strategic response; the United Nations Country Theme Group on HIV/AIDS (chaired by UNFPA) began to assist in developing an HIV/AIDS advocacy strategy. The need arose to “translate” data already gathered on the extent of the epidemic into laymen’s terms and advance Cambodia’s national AIDS policy agenda by mobilizing commitment and resources across all levels of the public and private sector. Based on that need, UNFPA funded the Futures Group to assist Cambodian organizations to implement an advocacy initiative to increase understanding and support for the AIDS program and to accelerate resource mobilization for HIV/AIDS prevention, treatment, care, campaigns to eliminate stigma and discrimination, and community support programs at national and local levels. The development and application of the AIM presentation in Cambodia triggered a process of building collaborative political commitment and active involvement in HIV/AIDS issues. The major steps in this process were: (i) forming an interdisciplinary team to implement the activity, (ii) collecting data and research information, (iii) selecting key audiences and priority
64 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
messages to communicate, (iv) drafting and reviewing an information booklet and presentation, (v) training presenters, (vi) developing a detailed dissemination plan, and (vii) conducting presentations for a wide range of organizations at the national and provincial levels. In addition to forging strong collaboration between NCHADS (the National Center for HIV/ AIDS, Dermatology and STDs within the Ministry of Health) and NAA, this process fostered active debate about priority policy issues and the dissemination of key messages, encouraging input from a wide range of stakeholders, many of whom had never worked together before. These stakeholders included health and non-health ministry representatives working at national, provincial, and district levels, as well as donors, NGOs, PLHA, and the private sector. As Dr. Mean Chhi Vun, Director of NCHADS, stated, “AIM as an advocacy tool helps us all work from a common page and deliver common messages while expanding the national response to AIDS.” The final booklet and presentation includes information on the current status of the epidemic; projections about its future course; estimates of socio-economic impact; proven interventions for prevention, care, support, treatment, the reduction of stigma and discrimination; and the roles of leaders at every level of society. R esults: NCHADS and NAA have used the AIM booklet and presentation to engage policymakers at the national and regional levels in policy dialogue about the response to AIDS. The AIM booklet has been disseminated to all line ministries and provinces. The advocacy effort also included a series of workshops to train presenters in “AIM in Cambodia” in order to build advocacy capacity at both the national level (among members of the NAA Technical Board) and also at the provincial level (among multi-sectoral Provincial AIDS Committee presenters). Working from a master dissemination plan, these presenters continue to deliver AIM presentations with careful preparation and technical support by NCHADS and the Futures Group. This approach has strengthened ownership of the project at all levels and throughout many different sectors, as well as the capacity to adapt and disseminate AIM to specific target audiences in order to achieve specific advocacy goals. A rudimentary monitoring and evaluation system will help to inform achievement of advocacy goals at each level. Lessons Learned: Future applications will continue to build sustainable, in-country, crosssectoral capacity for data collection, modeling, and analysis of HIV/AIDS issues and impacts; measuring and building political commitment; and increasing multi-sectoral, multi-level collaboration during national HIV/AIDS strategic planning. Dissemination of AIM messages will utilize the inherent organizational structure—from national to district—existing in each sector. Persons trained in impact analysis, presentation, and advocacy skills will be able to apply these to future work in operations research, socio-economic surveys, evaluation designs, and advocacy programs; so contributing to a multi-sectoral response to HIV/AIDS in Cambodia for years to come. Source: Stover and Begala, 2002
Communication for Change 65
Social Mobilization to Bolster the National Response Rationale Through advocacy, we garner political commitment for the fight against HIV/AIDS, and this commitment, hopefully, sparks concrete social action. Historically, the first response in many countries has been to set up control programs in ministries of health, treating the epidemic as a health matter. However, it has become apparent that HIV/AIDS affects all aspects of human life and requires a multi-sectoral response. Once more, it was Uganda that took the lead in establishing the Uganda AIDS Commission in 1992 under the Office of the President with membership from different organizations, including PLHA. The late Bishop Misaeri Kauma, Church of Uganda, first chaired the Commission and the chairmanship has remained in the hands of the church, with the Minister of Health as a co-chair. This arrangement sent a signal that action on HIV/AIDS in Uganda is a multi-sectoral responsibility. It is everybody’s business. Besides addressing individual behavior, HIV/AIDS has to be tackled at the social, environmental, and structural levels (Oussama et al., 1995; Sweat and Denison, 1995). Building a multi-sectoral response entails the involvement of all levels of government, NGOs and Community-Based Organizations (CBOs), faith-based organizations, foundations, service clubs, the private sector (including retail and manufacturing), the informal sector, and financial services. It also means collaboration between public sectors that are often vertically organized: health, nutrition, agriculture and fisheries, education, social services, law, sports, media, culture, children and youth, gender, media, communications and transportation, uniformed services, and others. This is not to say that each and every member of these categories, levels, and sectors must work together from the start. Inter-sectoral collaboration is not the norm in most countries. Networking and coalition-building takes time (for a variety of multi-sectoral country profiles, see Mani, 2002; PVO-USAID, 2002). Countries that are successful in igniting a social movement for HIV/AIDS prevention and care have a much greater chance of success in defeating the virus. The process of establishing such a movement is called “social mobilization.” This term has been defined and understood in various ways. The definition most aligned with the thinking in this section, however, is as follows: Social mobilization is a process of bringing together all feasible and practical intersectoral social partners and allies to determine felt-need and raise awareness of and demand for a particular development objective. It involves enlisting the participation of such actors, including institutions, groups, networks and communities, in identifying, raising, and managing human and material resources, thereby increasing and strengthening self-reliance and sustainability of achievements (McKee et al., 2000b). As defined above, “community mobilization” (described in greater detail in the next section) may be a part of an overall social mobilization process. However, individual communities or
66 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
clusters of communities may also be mobilized by internal dynamics and processes, or through the help of civil society organizations, in the absence of overall societal mobilization. In fact, international community development experts and NGOs have created a plethora of projects, tools and processes to garner the participation of communities in development efforts, including HIV/AIDS prevention and care. In contrast, we have paid less attention to the processes of social mobilization at the national, regional/state, district, and local levels. This gap has been apparent in the response to HIV and AIDS in many countries.
Formative Research The process of social mobilization requires a good deal of preparation. In many ways, this research is an extension of the participation analysis and formative research required for advocacy: l
l
l
l
Who are the major players (potential partners, allies and gatekeepers) at the national, regional/provincial, municipal, district, and sub-district levels? This listing will include governmental and non-governmental individuals and organizations, including associations, social, and religious groups. It will also include an analysis of their present involvement in HIV/AIDS and their interest and potential in the issues and intervention areas. What are the capacities and capacity gaps of major players? What capacity-building interventions are needed (e.g., training on elements of strategic communication: advocacy and BCC, including interpersonal communication, community mobilization, and uses of mass media? What are the most appropriate forms of partnerships and organizational structure, methods, and processes to ensure participatory planning and sustained coordination/ collaboration? What human and monetary resources are needed by various partners to carry out effective plans?
Audiences and Actors As many partners and allies are required as is feasible and practical for a national social mobilization program. Some of those who are brought on board through advocacy become the advocators for action among a wider group spanning multiple levels. This inter-sectoral collaborative action may include government ministries concerned with the following: l l l l l
Health and nutrition Agriculture and fisheries Social services Children, youth and gender Education and sports
Communication for Change 67 l l l
Media and culture Transportation and telecommunications Local government, law, and uniformed services
It also may include all levels of government: l l l l
President’s or prime minister’s office Parliamentarians/legislators National, regional/state, provincial and district/municipal administrations Bilateral donors and UN agencies
In addition, it may involve civil society organizations such as: l l l l l l l
NGOs, community-based organizations (CBOs) Faith-based organizations Traditional government structures Professional associations and networks Media associations and networks Universities Service clubs and the private sector
Strategic Approaches It is possible to carry out strategic communication programs without attempting to create a social movement for an issue, but such efforts are less likely to be effective and sustainable. While a comprehensive, inter-sectoral approach will involve actions at many levels by a large number of partners, here we are mainly concerned with those strategies that draw on the expertise of communicators. Use Leaders as Advocates: Those political, social, and religious leaders who are targeted for advocacy and become clearly committed can now be used as advocates for the social mobilization process. This can be done through interpersonal contact with parliamentarians or business leaders, through rallies, or the mass media. For example, in Ghana, the paramount chief and other tribal chiefs agreed to participate in a campaign on prevention that was broadcast nationwide on radio and television (see Ghana case study). Because political, traditional, and social leaders hold an important place in society, they have the power to motivate others and their voices will be heard. However, before they speak, they need to be well-briefed on key issues. HIV and AIDS are very complex subjects and often judgments people make about the epidemic can be strongly value-laden, thereby alienating possible partners as well as the primary and secondary audiences. Development of National Coordination Body for Communication: The national or state AIDS commission or control program normally develops coordination mechanisms for the various actions to be taken, at least at their levels. This group may work with the UN Theme
68 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Group or Expanded Theme Group. UNAIDS normally facilitates such bodies and national governments, major donors, and civil society constitute the membership. It is essential to have a sub-committee or other group within this framework that coordinates communication inputs for the national response and whose members have good knowledge of and leadership on HIV/AIDS. The group also needs to coordinate messages through mass media and other channels, such as schools and health services. The alternative is chaos, or at the very least, a waste of resources and potential clash of messages, thereby adding confusion. Development of a National L ogo: This strategy, also known as “branding,” involves the Logo: development of a symbol with which all players can identify. It could be an overall symbol for all actions taken in the fight against HIV/AIDS. Or it could be a few different symbols for various purposes, such as primary prevention, care and support, or youth-focused programs. However, it is important to avoid cluttering the environment, including the mass media, with too many logos. Also, programs must develop this type of symbol through a participatory process, both with partners who are expected to use it and through focus group discussions with intended audiences. The symbol must make sense to them, as well as be self-explanatory and motivating. Involving a steering committee of partners in the logo development process will avoid rejection by key players, but all members need to recognize the importance of formative research in developing the logo. Participatory Planning W orkshops: An essential ingredient of social mobilization is Workshops: participatory planning events. Too often the concept of “participation” is left to the community level for which we design processes and tools to foster increased community participation in programs. Whereas community participation is seen as desirable, very often the organizational structures inside governments and NGOs that work with communities remain nonparticipatory, rigid, and non-collaborative. Each organization may want communities to participate in its own vision and program; a situation that can result in undesirable competition, a waste of resources, and confusion. Participatory methods have proven effective in developing national, provincial/regional, and district-level plans (McKee, 1992; McKee et al., 2000c; Ng’weshemi et al., 1997), because they have the power to bring the ideas of many key players together in a creative manner. Such techniques can include mapping the present programs of all organizations and demonstrating how they fit into the national response. It is also necessary to identify gaps, research needs, new strategies, resource needs, and coordination mechanisms. Such planning exercises not only eliminate redundancy, but they can also strengthen the overall program by providing linkages between organizations and individuals that would not otherwise exist. In addition, an effective participatory planning experience may increase the motivation of the actors involved. The launch of social mobilization activities can catalyze individuals and organizations to action. Such events, often involving high-level leadership and media coverage, provide an ideal opportunity for all partners to make public their commitment to action on HIV/AIDS. Implementation occurs in phases, including “pulses” for renewing energy as new interventions such as VCT and PMTCT are launched. Use of a Common Communication and T raining T ool: Experience indicates that the Training Tool: development and use of the same communication and training tools by a large number of
Communication for Change 69
partners can be highly effective in social mobilization. Such items may include videotapes, facilitation manuals involving games and exercises, and other participatory processes to facilitate behavior change and behavior development (such as Journey of Hope, described later in the chapter). Very often, organizations want to develop their own tools “from scratch.” Doing so not only wastes resources, but it may also destroy collaboration and create confusion. The development of common tools requires key partners to be involved in the needs assessment and formative research that reveals the perceptions of potential users, as well as operations research on how the tools are actually used by various clients and user groups. Program planners should guard against having too many tools, especially tools developed in a vacuum without the involvement of possible end-users. If a group wants to adapt tools that already exist, the process can be collaborative as well. Capacity-Building: Training communication partners on strategic communication is an essential strategy for reinforcing social mobilization. Communication planning is required down to the district and community level, and the key actors will need skills in directing research, formulating plans, developing and pretesting materials, implementing interventions, and monitoring and evaluation. In addition, key partners need training on participatory planning and training methods so that the levels of participation will not decrease from the national level to the community. Finally, those trained need to be supported through networking, information updates, web-based and electronic linkages, if possible, and through technical assistance when needed.
Key Issues to Communicate Social mobilization is a set of processes that usually follow from advocacy and strengthen BCC. As such, it is not possible to separate out key issues to be communicated. However, those who advocate for such processes would emphasize the need for collaboration, participatory planning processes, an overall intervention plan, and capacity building to carry it out at all levels. One important issue to communicate and address is the need to map out the interventions, roles, and responsibilities of different organizations, both government and civil society, so they reinforce and complement each other so as to avoid overlap that can lead to a waste of resources, chaos, and confusion. Box 3-1: HIV/AIDS Communication Planning in Maharashtra, India In Maharashtra, where the HIV incidence is rapidly rising and coordinated action has been absent, representatives of all key state agencies, NGOs, researchers, and media organizations participated in a one-week planning workshop in late 2002 to develop an integrated statewide communication plan for prevention, care and support, and reduction of stigma. The participatory planning process involved the use of Visualization in Participatory Programs (VIPP), a planning and training methodology that has had considerable success as a social mobilization tool for various social programs in a number of developing countries (McKee et al., 2000c) (See Plate 3-1). Source: See citations mentioned in the box.
70 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Plate 3-1: NGOs, researchers, and media organizations developed a communication plan to deal with HIV/ AIDS during a week-long communication planning workshop in Maharashtra, India. (Credit: CCP) Source: Health Communication Partnership, 2003c
Challenges and Lessons Learned Weak P olitical Support: Social mobilization has the greatest chance for success when the Political head of state, president, prime minister, or chief minister is actively engaged. If such leaders are not favorably disposed, it may be necessary to find a strong substitute such as the first lady or a retired statesman, or stateswoman. Weak or nonexistent leadership in the fight against HIV/AIDS is a serious but not insurmountable challenge to social mobilization. However, under such conditions, it becomes more difficult to galvanize partners into action, secure the necessary funds, get commitment from donors, and devolve the program to lower levels.
Communication for Change 71
Sustaining Commitment: Once people and organizations become active, it may be difficult to sustain a high level of commitment and coordination. Many different national and donor interests come into play, as well as differing perspectives on crucial issues such as culture and human rights. Coordinators require excellent facilitation skills to keep all partners involved. Sometimes people are chosen for coordination roles based on their reputation in a technical area, and they may lack the ability to facilitate group processes or motivate a coalition to grow while remaining faithful to program objectives. Ensuring F ull P articipation by all P artners: In planning processes involving different Full Participation Partners: organizations, the positions and programs of a few partners often dominate. Those in charge should actively work to avoid this kind of “seminar culture.” Participatory planning requires true participatory processes run by professional facilitators who can balance the inputs and experience of many organizations and individuals in a neutral way, and allow the group to answer a set of questions in a progressive manner. This approach is crucial to securing a widely held sense of ownership in plans. Very often people in authority (or people who think they should be in authority) are impatient with such activities and will attempt to disrupt or “hijack” the process. Experienced facilitators can deal with such behavior if the leadership agrees upon their role in advance. An even greater challenge is that encouraging participation will tend to open up many vocal debates. For instance, debates may erupt on the question of the balance between prevention and care and treatment, including the provision of drugs as a human right for PLHA. The best solution is to have a national plan of action with policies that anticipate and address such issues. Without such planned coordination, conflict, chaos, and a waste of resources may ensue. Ensuring Community P articipation: Over-planning at the national to district levels may Participation: inhibit community incentive. The success of Uganda’s efforts was largely due to the philosophy of “letting many flowers grow”—that is, letting local actions flourish. With the devolution of power and responsibility, people can be motivated to act. At the same time, it is useful for those at the central level to map ongoing programs or interventions throughout the country to avoid duplication, conflicts between organizations, and wasting resources. Dealing with “Burnout”: The epidemic affects many of the key players in the national response on a personal basis daily. They may be HIV-positive themselves, fear that they are, or they may have family members or close friends who are sick or have died. Some may have the extra social and economic responsibility for guardianship of orphans. These realities may affect their energy levels and the timeliness of their inputs. However, the visible involvement of PLHA in all aspects of the program may be a motivational factor for all those affected. Monitoring R esults: Most monitoring and evaluation efforts involve interventions that Results: focus on the individual as the unit of measurement. Very little monitoring or evaluation research exists on social mobilization processes, including measurement of effects on the environmental and social structural changes required for positive and sustained behavior
72 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
change (Kelly and Parker, 2001). For instance, some of the process indicators for social mobilization include the existence of plans and the degree to which they are followed, the number of organized and complementary partners involved, evaluation of their specific programs, and the degree to which roles and responsibilities are clearly understood by the various actors in the process. Evaluators face an important challenge in measuring environmental or structural factors, as well as the effect of social mobilization on these factors. Beyond Social Mobilization: Finally, advocacy and social mobilization are necessary but not sufficient components for achieving social and individual change. A strong program of BCC, including behavioral development for children and adolescents, is required for meeting program objectives. One definition for BCC has been given as follows: Behavior Change Communication is a research-based, consultative process of addressing knowledge, attitudes, and practices through identifying, analyzing, and segmenting audiences and participants in programs and by providing them with relevant information and motivation through well-defined strategies, using an appropriate mix of interpersonal, group and mass-media channels, including participatory methods. (Adapted from McKee et al., 2000b) Figure 3-1 conceptualizes the relationship between these various components of strategic communication. All of these components of strategic communication should be strongly linked to services. The planning continuum arrow on the three principal components of strategic communication indicates that there is no automatic starting point. Rather, it depends on the issue. Leadership may be ready for advocacy on one issue in HIV/AIDS programs but not another. Sometimes it may be more fruitful to forego direct advocacy for the time being and concentrate on building a network for a process of social mobilization, selecting a set of partners who can put pressure on leadership. Alternatively, in the absence of political support, communication programmers may start by building demand in the population through broadscale BCC and thereby foster a gradual change in the perception of leadership on the issues, if they are allowed to do so. This book focuses largely on this outer circle of BCC through the strategic approaches of mass media, interpersonal communication, and community mobilization. However, the concepts of advocacy and social mobilization will re-emerge in various examples, for without these broad-based complementary strategies, strategic communication will often be incomplete or unsuccessful.
Communication for Change 73 Figure 3-1: Strategic Communication Components
Source: McKee et al., 2000b
Case Study: Stop AIDS, Love Life in Ghana The Stop AIDS, Love Life program illustrates how the concepts of Advocacy, Social Mobilization and BCC fit together. Background/R ationale: During the last quarter of 1999, a confluence of events in Ghana Background/Rationale: galvanized the national response to HIV/AIDS at a level not previously achieved in the country. The National AIDS Control Programme and its partners had labored diligently for many years in the areas of policy development, situation and response analyses, and development of a national strategic framework, thus laying a strong foundation for action. This foundation was necessary, but not sufficient, in catalyzing a national response. All too often, excellent policies and elegant strategies never get implemented. But in this case, a series of events that occurred in a three-month period triggered action. Since then, Ghana’s national response has steadily grown stronger.
74 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Plate 3-2: Stop AIDS, L ove Life road shows attracted large crowds and raised HIV/AIDS awareness in Ghana. (Credit: CCP)
Audience and Strategy: The key audience for advocacy was the President and the Cabinet. A combination of advocacy interventions at these most senior levels and the introduction of a major BCC program provided the catalyst to strengthen the national response. A variety of organizations, coordinated by the National AIDS Control Programme, contributed in varying capacities, drawing on their relative strengths and expertise. Process: In October 1999, a high-level delegation of the International Partnership Against AIDS in Africa, organized by UNAIDS and led by Dr. Miriam Were of UNFPA, went to Ghana on an advocacy mission. As part of a full schedule of activities and meetings, Dr. Were talked with the Minister for Communications for hours. This personal lobbying activity convinced the Minister that he and his ministry needed to be actively engaged in the national response against HIV/AIDS. Shortly thereafter, the Ghana Social Marketing Foundation and Johns Hopkins’ Center for Communication Programs briefed the Minister on the forthcoming Stop AIDS, Love Life program, funded by USAID, to elicit his support and patronage. The Minister was instrumental in garnering the support of the President and First Lady, raising the profile of the initiative to the national level. The First Lady subsequently launched Stop AIDS, Love Life in February 2000. The Minister for Communications also mobilized the resources of his Ministry in support of the program, including 20 mobile cinema vans that toured the nation, reaching millions of people with messages on HIV/AIDS.
Communication for Change 75
Because the program started at the top, it was easier to obtain the highest levels of support and participation in subsequent phases, injecting “pulses” of activities to renew the energy and motivation needed to adapt the key messages. This high-level participation and support came from government officials, traditional leaders, and religious leaders. The King of the Ashanti, who is the President of the National House of Chiefs, and other paramount chiefs participated in a phase of the campaign that featured them speaking frankly about HIV/ AIDS issues. This most traditional and senior-level support, which was broadcast frequently on television and radio, was instrumental in mobilizing other chiefs and “queen mothers” to take up the issue in their own communities.
Plate 3-3: A traditional leader in Ghana takes part in the W orld AIDS Day procession in support of the World Stop AIDS, L ove Life program, F ebruary 2001. February (Credit: CCP)
The Vice President launched the next phase of the campaign, dubbed Journey of Hope. The Journey of Hope (Box 3-4) is a participatory, life skills toolkit designed to enhance community responses to HIV and AIDS. Many organizations throughout the nation incorporated the Journey of Hope into their own programs, using their own resources to support it. Many of the most senior religious leaders in the nation, among both Christian and Muslim faiths, committed themselves and their institutions to the third phase of the campaign, which focuses on compassion and destigmatizing PLHA. These religious leaders appear frequently on radio and TV spots, stimulating their congregations to follow their lead.
76 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Lessons Learned: The involvement of various agencies was critical to the success of this approach. Compelling advocacy activities created the initial will and energy for social mobilization from ministry to community levels. Subsequently, the BCC program provided the way to direct this commitment towards specific behavior. It is doubtful if one component in the absence of the other would have resulted in the strengthening of the national response as it has occurred in Ghana in recent years. Sources: Tweedie et al., 1997; 1998; and 2002
Interventions to Strengthen Community Responses People are resisting changes and innovations in their lives for a variety of reasons. They typically resist changes not clearly understood; changes they or their representatives had no part in bringing about; changes that threaten their vested interest and security; changes advocated by those they do not like or trust; and changes that do not fit into the cultural values of the community. (Nix, 1977 as cited in Bracht and Kingsbury, 1990)
Rationale In high prevalence countries, communities are currently taking the brunt of the epidemic. Sustained denial, stigma, and discrimination against PLHA prevent communities from normalizing the disease and integrating it into shared problem-solving strategies (Busza, 2001). Meanwhile, the burden of caring for terminally ill adults and children is taking an unprecedented toll on families, eroding community coping capacities and traditional social safety nets. BCC strategies often aim at the individual and operate at the national level. However, addressing prevention, reducing stigma, and mitigating the effects of HIV and AIDS at local levels requires community-based approaches. “Community mobilization,” the most common term for such approaches, can be defined as follows: Community mobilization is a capacity-building process through which community individuals, groups, or organizations plan, carry out, and evaluate activities on a participatory and sustained basis to improve their health and other needs, either on their own initiative or stimulated by others (Howard-Grabman and Snetro, 2003). Some guiding principles of community mobilization processes are engaging people in problem-solving activities which are relevant to their immediate needs and realities; tapping
Communication for Change 77
local knowledge information and expertise, thereby building people’s confidence in themselves; and helping to create local ownership for the process and its outcomes. In Uganda, falling HIV prevalence rates have been attributed in large part to a multitude of local responses. There has been a good deal of discussion recently, about replicating the Uganda experience elsewhere, and this has led to high expectations for such approaches. Critics respond that very often anecdotal evidence is all that is available to verify the value of such approaches; few community-based responses have been sufficiently documented or evaluated to determine their true impact (ICASA HDN Key Correspondent Team, 2001). Some say Uganda may be a special case since it was emerging out of years of civil war at the time when HIV/AIDS hit the country, making nation building and fighting AIDS inter related. In other countries, one might argue, rather than stimulating a multitude of local responses, there may be a need to “scale up” such responses and pilot projects if one expects to truly be effective in the fight against HIV and AIDS (De Jong, 2001). Despite these challenges, community mobilization methods have become a crucial component of communication programming in the response to HIV/AIDS, largely because of a renewed recognition of the close interaction between individual sexual behaviors and community norms (Airhihenbuwa and Obregon, 2000; Piotrow et al., 1997). Social and cultural norms, to an unknown extent, mediate individual sexual behaviors. Successful communication models and strategies recognize and incorporate contextual or environmental factors involved in HIV/AIDS, sexual and reproductive health, and sexuality. Strategic communication should be designed to trigger community dialogue, which in turn can develop into collective action (Figueroa et al., 2002). At the community level, communication interventions need to be innovative and collaborative in order to galvanize community efforts and bring them to scale.
Formative Research Some key questions for formative research are as follows: l l l l l l l l
What community norms prevail concerning HIV/AIDS, STIs, and adolescent and adult sexuality among community members? What community channels exist and can be tapped for a communication intervention? What communication channel access, preferences, and habits do community members have? What social networks exist and how do they work? Who are the official and unofficial opinion leaders? What are the previous experiences with community mobilization projects? What are the health and social service structures, needs, and priorities in the community? What collaboration has there been between HIV/AIDS programs and health service structures at the local and district levels, and what is the potential for further collaboration?
78 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic l l
What needs exist regarding care for orphans and other vulnerable children? What indigenous care service systems exist in the community and how can they be strengthened?
Audiences and Actors The concept of “community” as both the audience and actor in community mobilization processes can be defined in various ways: l
l l
Geographical Community: A group of people living in or coming from a defined geographical area, sharing basic values, and organizational structures (Robertson and Minkler, 1994). Common Interest Community: Groups of people linked in a network by common values and interests, such as women’s groups, youth groups, and faith-based groups. Common Identity Community: Groups of people reinforced through their means of livelihood or common practices such as business leaders, truckers, sex workers, MSM, or IDUs.
Communities are rarely homogenous groups of people but rather are composed of various subgroups holding different interests, beliefs, and practices. They are not necessarily harmonious entities that can be easily facilitated to undertake collective action. Very often they contain elements and factions that are in conflict with one another over control of resources and socio-political processes for various historical or present reasons.
Strategic Approaches The approaches taken in community-based responses to HIV and AIDS can differ in the degree to which communities have control over the design of programing and implementation of activities (Cleland, 1996). On the Ladder of Empowerment (See Box 3-2), the degree of participation can range from Information to Community Control. Whereas the first categories of information and consultation or “community outreach” are considered important first steps that involve the community to a limited degree, the latter two processes are clearly identified with true community mobilization and participation methods. Available program resources and duration of the project often determine which approach is realistic and possible. However, most development specialists concur that the higher the degree of community participation and ownership, the greater the program’s effectiveness and sustainability. In recent years, many community-based projects in high-prevalence countries have undergone a change in focus. NGOs and CBOs have shifted from their initial focus on prevention
Communication for Change 79 Box 3-2: L adder of Empowerment Ladder Low
Information Consultation
Medium
Delegation
Partnership
High
Community Control
Information about existing program decisions is given and explained, but no channels for feedback are provided. Views are sought before decision-making; community members are asked to advise on or revise a preset program through focus groups, attitude surveys, neighborhood meetings or pretesting, but program planners judge the legitimacy or feasibility of the advice. Local leaders have the opportunity to influence decision-making by a local committee that has a mandate to represent the community (e.g., review board) and guarantee the accountability of the program. Shared authority on planning, decision-making, and implementation of responsibilities (e.g., through joint planning and implementation committees, as equal stakeholders). Authority of the community to develop, manage, and implement programs of their choice—perhaps within a framework of grants, advice, and support provided by the resource holder.
Source: Adapted from Wilcox, 1994
to a combination of prevention and care activities (International HIV/AIDS Alliance, 1998; Kippax and Race, 2003). This change has increased these organizations’ need for technical support, capacity-building, and strategic partnerships to effectively facilitate community processes such as the one outlined in Box 3-3. As is evident from Box 3-3, programing for prevention, care, and support at the community level must go beyond “surface” activities such as information dissemination and condom distribution to exploit the full potential of communities. A comprehensive approach to community actions against HIV and AIDS should be employed and should ideally combine the following strategies (adapted from International HIV/AIDS Alliance, 1999): Advocacy for Community-Based P rojects: Advocacy to garner support for communityProjects: based HIV/AIDS interventions involves community action to influence local and national level policies, laws, resource allocation, and management systems through a variety of methods. This can include lobbying, supporting sympathetic candidates, rallying, and demonstrating. In Ghana and Guinea, for example, a series of meetings between small NGOs, community groups, traditional leaders, and healers helped to mobilize leaders to support and speak out on HIV/AIDS prevention strategies. Print materials as the “take-home” medium can be used by participants to reinforce key actions to be taken following the events (Bakadi, 2002; Tweedie et al., 2002). Participatory Assessments: Participatory assessments of community needs, assets, and aspirations are the foundation of appropriate and effective community-based programing.
80 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Box 3-3: Community Action Cycle Save the Children (USA), an organization that has done extensive community mobilization for HIV/AIDS and other health areas recommends the following steps or “Action Cycle”: l l l l l l l
Prepare to mobilize. Organize the community for action. Explore the health issues and set priorities. Plan together. Act together. Evaluate together. Prepare to scale-up.
Source: Howard-Grabman and Snetro, 2003 Figure 3-2: Community Action Cycle
Participatory Rapid Appraisal (PRA), Participatory Learning in Action (PLA), and related methodologies employ techniques such as community mapping, body mapping, Venn diagrams, ranking, and scoring. These techniques are used to assist with situation analyses and to tap community expertise, formulate priorities, and motivate collective action. The community is fully involved in data collection, analysis, and documentation of the effects of health and development problems in their lives, and this activity plays a special role in the mobilization process. Participatory assessments may lead to the development of unexpected community priorities. Interventions may have to include such priorities, integrating them with HIV/AIDS prevention and care activities where they best fit. For instance, an assessment in Burkina Faso showed that low literacy and poverty are urgent problems that influenced vulnerability to HIV. Literacy training and micro-credit projects were developed in response, integrating
Communication for Change 81
discussion groups on sexual and reproductive health, including HIV/AIDS, into such activities (International HIV/AIDS Alliance, 1998). However, if the program cannot respond to community-defined priorities in this way because of donor-set conditions, it is important to be open and transparent with the community about the possibilities at the beginning of the programing process. ools for Action: NGOs and CBOs need proven but simple Communication Channels and T Tools and flexible methods and tools for action. Their focus should be on increasing the dialogue about HIV/AIDS in the community, linking people to health and community services and encouraging such services to become proactive. A good example of a tool for triggering dialogue and action is the Fleet of Hope in Tanzania (FHI, 1997), which Johns Hopkins’ CCP recently adapted for use in Ghana under the name Journey of Hope (Box 3-4). Ideally, program planners will be able to use ready-made materials, but they will need to arrive at that decision based on participatory assessments. Moreover, they often need to adapt such materials to a specific context. Other Community-Level Media and Activities There are many tools available for community-level processes (Box 3-5). In addition, a number of communication activities and channels may be useful, depending on past experience and budget allocation for such interventions: l
l l
l
Interpersonal Communication (IPC) and Group Communication: These are, of course, the most widely used and easiest channels to organize. However, the quality of IPC and group communication processes depends on good training in IPC and group facilitation methods. Too often it is assumed that anyone can be a communicator, but the community may resist poorly trained, unskilled mobilizers. Peer Education: This is a commonly used approach that is documented in detail in Chapter 6. A specific example is also given in the Guinea case study that follows. Community-Based Entertainment–Education (E–E) (E–E): E–E strategies work well at the community level through channels such as theater, sports, and music events. However, such strategies also require special training of community-level agents in HIV/AIDS issues to avoid giving incomplete or contradictory messages, reinforcing gender stereotypes, or stigmatizing certain groups. E–E methods are most effective when coordinated with other community-based program components. Community R adio: Local mass media, such as community radio stations, may be Radio: effective but they rarely have the personnel and technical capacity to continuously develop informed HIV/AIDS programing without a good deal of assistance. Preproduced documentaries, drama, and regular newsletters on HIV/AIDS issues may provide valuable content. Program presenters and disk jockeys are in dire need of HIV education and guidelines for ethical reporting on HIV and AIDS in order to avoid transmitting misinformation and inadvertently increasing stigma. There is a need, for instance, for ethical guidelines for including PLHA volunteers and spokespeople in radio and other community-based communication programs.
82 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Box 3-4: The Journey of Hope One of the models for action developed in Ghana as part of the Stop AIDS, Love Life campaign is the Journey of Hope (JOH). JOH is a practical and participatory life skills tool that engages communities and individuals in meaningful interaction on HIV and AIDS in ways that are culturally acceptable. JOH helps to establish the link between an individual’s goals in life (represented as “future islands”) and current HIV prevention behaviors. It allows all to participate in an entertaining activity that not only delivers a clear message, but also builds supportive social networks in communities. Moreover, it provides a framework within which to discuss issues of sexuality and HIV/ AIDS in non-judgmental ways. Participants in the JOH try to walk across sticks of wood on the ground, each representing a different prevention strategy (ABC—Abstinence, Be faithful, or use Condoms); if they fail to stay the course, they risk falling into the surrounding water full of crocodiles (HIV). This exercise reinforces the point that it is tricky but possible to remain safe from HIV/AIDS, while moving towards “future islands.” JOH has gained acceptance and use by a wide spectrum of groups in Ghana, including religious groups, schools, NGOs, government employees, youth groups, and others. The local team initially produced over 2,000 kits and trained numerous NGOs and community groups in their use. Subsequently these groups have incorporated JOH into their peer motivation activities throughout Ghana. Based on qualitative assessments, JOH shows promise as an effective tool for behavioral change. The demand for JOH kits continues to increase. Source: Tweedie et al., 2002
Plate 3-4: The Journey of Hope toolkit in Ghana illustrates how behavior affects the spread of HIV/AIDS. (Credit: CCP)
Communication for Change 83 l
L ocal Materials: Evidence suggests that creative, well-designed local materials in local languages can influence attitudes and behaviors of community members. Support materials, such as caps and bags carrying a locally designed logo, are usually popular incentives for local action. One participatory way of developing appropriate health promotion materials and activities at the local level is known as “Action Media” (Parker, 1997). This workshop-based methodology combines educational and reflective elements with games, role-plays, condom distribution and media development.
Box 3-5: Additional Community-Based T ools Tools l
l
l l
For participatory development of programs: Berengere De Negri et al., 1998. Empowering Communities: Participatory Techniques for Community-Based Program Development. Vol. 1 (2), Trainer’s Manual (Participant’s Handbook). Nairobi: CAFS in collaboration with JHU/CCP and AED. For situation assessments, partnership-building, guiding participatory workshops, and other capacity-building tools: HIV/AIDS NGO/CBO Support Toolkit: A CD-ROM and website at http://www.aidsalliance.org/ngosupport/. For community media in Southern Africa: Health-e, Soul City: HIV/AIDS. A Resource for Journalists. Brochure accessible at www.health-e.org.za. For community mobilization: Howard-Grabman, L.H. and Gail Snetro, 2003: How to Mobilize Communities for Health and Social Change. Health Communication Partnership.
Source: See citations mentioned in the box.
Other R elated P rogram Strategies Related Program NGO/CB O Capacity Strengthening: NGOs and CBOs need a diverse range of skills and NGO/CBO resources to respond effectively to HIV/AIDS. Since their planning and implementation capacity is often limited, successful community health communication approaches must build NGO and CBO capacities in both organizational and technical areas. Organizational capacity includes developing realistic strategies, detailed action plans, and budgets, as well as finding the most effective partners for implementation. There is a need for strengthening technical capacities to plan and design communication strategies that are tailored for the circumstances of a particular community or communities. NGOs and CBOs can also benefit enormously from technical support that helps them incorporate education and communication on sexual and reproductive health, sex and sexuality, gender, and HIV/AIDS stigma into all aspects of their own organizational policies and programs (International HIV/AIDS Alliance, 1998). Clear guidelines are needed on how to involve people infected and affected by HIV and AIDS at all stages, to approach gender inequalities as a source of vulnerability to HIV infection, and to monitor and document programs. Building Strategic and Multi-Sectoral P artnerships: Partnership-building through particiPartnerships: patory planning by community groups (e.g., churches, private sector, schools) and external organizations (government agencies or donors) fosters collective action, maximizes use of resources, and builds consensus around strategic communication goals.
84 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
In some countries, “local response networks” have been formed. These carry out the function of identifying and training community facilitators at different levels and developing coalitions among governments and NGOs or CBOs. Governments and NGOs provide resources for community groups and assist in developing action plans, including communication programs or campaign designs, through participatory, multi-sectoral workshops (UNAIDS, 2002a). In some countries, partnerships exist between local AIDS Action Committees and district health administrations that manage networks of health services. Such partnerships can greatly facilitate health care access, resource allocation, and coordination of community communication activities (Ng’weshemi et al., 1997). Multi-sectoral collaboration (e.g., education, community development, and planning) is crucial from the start to help build a sustainable program structure. However, in many countries such networks and structures do not yet exist.
Key Issues to Communicate l l l l
l l l l
Disseminate correct information, especially at the community level, about HIV/AIDS, its prevention, care, and consequences (such as OVC). Correct misinformation about transmission and concepts that stigmatize. Emphasize compassion and solidarity. Involve interested traditional and faith-based leaders to develop appropriate ways to address stigma and prevention (abstinence/delay, reduction of partners/faithfulness, and condom use). Address gender norms and harmful traditional practices. Determine the feasibility of messages focusing on sexual violence and intergenerational and transactional sex. Promote home-based care methods and successful community-based strategies for OVC. Promote VCT, STI treatment, and the treatment of opportunistic infections and develop ways to support adherence to ART, if available.
Challenges and Lessons Learned Limited Community Capacity: It is not enough to help communities assess their needs and draw up action plans. Organizational capacity-strengthening and sustained assistance in the implementation phase are crucial. Donors may overestimate community capacity. Implementers need to recognize the technical and strategic limitations that may exist at the community level and design programs accordingly—or invest a good deal more in capacitybuilding. It is difficult to find good community mobilizers and facilitators. Selection criteria are often lacking or not properly applied, and potential candidates often need considerable training in participatory processes and skills building.
Communication for Change 85
Community Demand: Communities should be selected on the basis of local demand for interventions if projects are to be effective and sustainable. Designing a “demand-driven” distribution system (e.g., for communication materials) can maximize the likelihood that materials will be used. Scaling Up: Scaling up the reach of community-based programs is a tremendous need and challenge to programmers, given the rapid spread of the epidemic. Critics have argued that small pilot programs with no chance of replication are unproductive (De Jong, 2001). Others have argued that program planners should replicate processes that help communities identify appropriate, local solutions. At the same time, communities may benefit from sharing their experiences with others (Howard-Grabman and Snetro, 2003). Programmers need to make sure that they only promote and scale up “best practices” that have been demonstrated as effective through careful evaluation. Otherwise, we may perpetuate a cycle of trial and error. Mass Media as a Complement: Using mass media for the wider dissemination of local solutions is an effective way of sharing lessons learned, acknowledging a successful community solution, and affecting social norms at the same time. Mass media can disseminate successful community efforts to other communities. Successful, local processes and lessons can even be incorporated into national strategy planning by governments, NGOs, and the private sector. Harmful Community Norms: Responses to the epidemic must address not only community problems, but also norms and values that shape relationships between people, such as gender relations and traditions manifested in early marriage, polygamy, or treatment of widows, creating vulnerability to HIV.
Case Study: Mobilizing Traditional Networks in Guinea Background: Guinea’s national HIV seroprevalence is 2.8 percent (USAID, 2001). However, in urban areas rates are as high as 42 percent among FSWs and between 5 percent to 7 percent among other vulnerable population groups such as miners, truckers, and the military. Guinea is nearing a transition stage where the epidemic could easily make its way into the general population. Even though rural areas appear to have much lower rates, this could change if concerted action is not taken. The situation has been exacerbated by unstable political circumstances in neighboring countries. Refugees from Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Cote d’Ivoire move in and out of Guinea and there are numerous military camps in the region (USAID, 2001). As in other areas of conflict in Africa, these conditions have the potential to increase the HIV prevalence rate exponentially. However, Guinea, especially in rural areas, remains a very traditional Muslim society where sexuality cannot be discussed in public and sex education was totally absent until
86 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
recently. In 2000, the Prism Project was launched in Siguiri district to protect young Guineans against HIV/AIDS. An assessment revealed a high number of traditional social networks that have an effect on sexual health. Seres are peer groups of female friends based on age cohorts (e.g., 15 to 19 years, 20 to 24 years, 25 to 30 years, and so forth). Membership in Seres starts at age six and lasts a lifetime. Seres are relatively formal, holding weekly or monthly meetings with an agenda. Seres provide tangible help to members during weddings, childbirths, and deaths; they undertake community activities. The more than 70 registered Seres meet regularly to respond to members’ needs and to undertake community activities. In the District Development Committee, which includes a health committee, traditional and public leaders meet and share political influence. The committee is composed of educated, community stakeholders, such as political leaders, doctors, lawyers, pharmacists, teachers, and two or three representatives from Seres. Audience and Approach: The PRISM Project combined an adolescent HIV/AIDS prevention campaign using peer leaders with a community mobilization approach. Working in partnership with the traditional social structures and networks, the project defined community leaders and parents as secondary audiences who influence the youth in their decision-making. In January 2001, project personnel met with the District Development Committee to share available data regarding the prevalence of HIV in the district capital. This, and many more follow-up visits were part of an advocacy process to prompt community action. The committee soon decided to dedicate the year 2001 to HIV. With one Seres taking the lead, all traditional and appointed leaders as well as local NGO representatives discussed the effects of HIV/AIDS on the district and the need for appropriate action. Videos and theater were shown to the public during a traditional holiday to raise people’s awareness about HIV and increase their likelihood of adopting prevention behaviors. In order to directly reach urban and rural youth of varying literacy levels, the project used local peer educators. The peer educators were trained to do outreach work and to talk to clients coming to their businesses. “Standing Youth” were identified by the community and worked in association with the health center. They reached peers by being invited to give talks to Seres. “Sitting Youth” were young hairdressers and tailors who were trained to reach their peers by displaying and distributing educational material and to stimulate discussion around HIV and AIDS issues in their workplaces by doing condom demonstrations and referring clients to the local health center (Bakadi, 2002). In 2002, a quasi-experimental study was conducted, using a post-test only design with a treatment and comparison area to evaluate impact of the project’s activities among a representative sample of youth (500 males and 500 females 16–24 years-of-age in the treatment area, 100 in the comparison area). Fonseca-Becker et al. (2003) reported the following results: l
All Sere leaders requested and received an orientation on STD/HIV and prevention skills and behaviors. All participants committed themselves to share what they learned with their Sere colleagues.
Communication for Change 87 l
l
l
l
l
Evaluation results show significantly higher exposure to campaign activities for males (83 percent) than for females (63 percent). Data further indicate that in the intervention area, about 30 percent of young men and 21 percent of young women make use of peer educators (hairdressers and tailors) when they want to discuss sexuality issues. The campaign was well-balanced with the promotion of two key behaviors including abstinence and condom use. Abstinence was positioned as the first choice and approximately half of the youth (exposed to the campaign) in the intervention group reported they had decided to abstain from sexual activity. The demand created by promotional events led to the sale of 20,000 condoms. Research showed that respondents in the intervention area were significantly more likely to know where to get condoms than in the control area (86 percent and 57 percent respectively), and among those sexually active, nearly 50 percent of the male respondents in the intervention area reported using a condom at their last sexual encounter, as compared to only 24 percent in the control area. The majority of young men in the intervention area perceived their community members (including religious and community leaders, health workers, parents, and members of Sere) to be more open to discuss youth sexuality issues than before the intervention. Young women also reported significantly more openness in their community for discussing youth sexuality issues in the intervention area as compared to the control area. Anecdotal evidence also indicates that parents prefer their children to go to the peer educators because they know their children will get important information which they themselves often feel uncomfortable discussing.
Lessons Learned l l
l l
l
l
Meaningful, locally collected data can prompt action. People will act only when they feel that HIV/AIDS is a concern to them and their community. Dialogue is the key. Meeting and talking to people in the community helps to assess how they perceive the HIV/AIDS epidemic and their readiness to take action. This process allows the identification of other resource people who extend the network of actors. Using groups such as the Seres involved tapping into a very powerful, local network for message dissemination. Reinforcing people’s skills is very important. Creating a coalition is only the first step. This needs to be followed by providing technical and psychosocial life skills training to the community members involved in prevention activities. In traditional societies, such as that of Upper Guinea where young women are less exposed to activities outside of their homes, special efforts must be made to better reach women in a culturally appropriate manner. Information on HIV is sometimes more acceptable and accessible for community members if presented within the context of STIs.
88 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic l
Coalition-building at the local and district levels is a very effective way to motivate people to share resources. However, the challenge remains on how to sustain such a coalition.
Source: Bakadi, 2002; Fonseca-Becker et al., 2003
Promoting a Balanced Approach to Prevention Messages: The “ABCs” of Safer Sexual Practices Rationale When the HIV/AIDS epidemic emerged in developing countries in the mid-1980s, many of those involved in the early prevention efforts believed that condoms would be the most effective means to curb the spread of HIV. Thus, much of prevention messages and programs focused on “C,” condoms, rather than “A,” abstinence, or “B,” being faithful to one’s partner or reducing the number of one’s sexual partners. Starting in the 1970s, several organizations working at the international level developed and refined strategies for the social marketing of condoms in connection with international family planning programs. US-based social marketing firms such as Population Services International (PSI) had programs in a few developing countries in the early 1980s, and by the end of the decade, they had expanded condom social marketing to sub-Saharan Africa. Similarly, SOMARC, managed by the Futures Group, operated in an additional seven sub-Saharan countries. These organizations took bold action in publicizing the risk of HIV/AIDS and in educating the public on the role of condoms in its prevention. The publicity surrounding social marketing helped to break the silence, especially in countries where governments had yet to develop their own strategies. Brand names such as “Prudence” and “Protector” became household words, and condomrelated paraphernalia (T-shirts, windshield decorations, baseball caps) was a familiar sight in countries with a social marketing program. Condom sales figures experienced dramatic increases in almost all countries where social marketing programs were implemented. In fact, there has been good progress in increasing condom sales in many countries in the last decade. For instance, condom sales in India have increased by 13 percent per year since the 1970s (Bentley et al., 1998). Other countries record similar success in condom distribution, including sales: Uganda—4 million in 1996 to 120 million in 2001 (Kirungi, 2001) and South Africa—6 million in 1994 to 198 million in 1999 (Myer et al., 2001). Part of the reason for this success was the perceived efficacy and low cost of condoms. The public health community was successful in promoting products or services that offered low-cost solutions, such as packets of oral rehydration salts or contraceptive pills. When HIV emerged, condom promotion seemed to be, potentially, the most cost-effective means of stopping its spread from a public health standpoint.
Communication for Change 89
Another reason for this concentration on “C” was the collective inexperience in promoting other options such as abstinence and partner reduction. “A” and “B” do not figure prominently as part of family planning programs aimed at couples assumed to be mutually monogamous and condom use seemed simple to explain as a means of preventing transmission. Few countries developed communication programs that were explicitly aimed at influencing social norms or presenting “A” or “B” in a positive light. This lesser focus on “A” and “B” in contrast to “C” may also reflect a widespread belief about the futility of promoting behaviors that require foregoing sexual gratification. However, recent analysis has indicated that although condoms may have played a significant role in reducing HIV infection in highly vulnerable populations—such as sex workers and their clients and MSM—they have had little impact on HIV rates in the general population in high prevalence countries. Married couples or regular partners seldom use them. In fact, HIV seroprevalence has continued to rise along with the sale of condoms in countries such as Kenya, South Africa, Botswana, and Cameroon (AIDSMARK, 2002). In spite of sales such as those mentioned, one reason sometimes given for this apparent failure of condoms to make an impact is supply. It has been calculated that in Africa, over the last decade, only 4.6 male condoms per year were available for every man between 15 to 59 years (Shelton and Johnson, 2001). This number would cover only a tiny fraction of sexual encounters. One reason sometimes cited for the lack of demand for condoms is the continuing controversy over their reliability. Religious groups continue to spread information that they may break or tear and are not foolproof, either for contraceptive purposes or for protection against HIV or STIs. In a comprehensive review of the effectiveness of condoms, Hearst and Chen (2003) have summed up their findings as follows: A good, simple answer may be to say that condoms appear to be about 90 percent effective when used consistently and properly. With perfect use, effectiveness may be even higher, though not 100 percent. With inconsistent or improper use, condom effectiveness is certainly lower. These results should come as no great surprise, as they closely match data on the effectiveness of condoms for preventing pregnancy (Weller and Davis, 2002). Although there is some evidence that condoms might occasionally be permeable to virus-size particles (Ahmed et al., 2001), the vast majority of condom failures result not from leakage through latex but from “flow” factors, such as breakage, slippage, or improper use (NIAID, 2001). There is no reason to expect that the frequency of use should differ when condoms are used to prevent HIV infection or pregnancy. Another study analyzed survey data from six African countries and concluded that the main reason for low use of condoms is demand; people say they trust their partner and therefore see no need for condoms or dislike using them. Researchers concluded that most people do not identify lack of availability and cost as barriers to condom use (Longfield et al., 2001). In fact, there has been little success in convincing people to use condoms in the context of a steady relationship—married, or otherwise. For instance, in Nigeria, where 65 million condoms were distributed in 1999, only 2 percent of sexually active respondents reported that they always used a condom with their spouse or other steady partner in the past two months, compared to 33 percent for boyfriends and girlfriends and 67 percent for casual
90 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
partners (Van Rossem et al., 2001). For many people, condoms have become associated with sexual activity outside of marriage, and in many countries religious groups have discouraged or condemned their use, not only for HIV protection but, in the case of the Catholic Church, for family planning purposes. In fact, condom use even remains relatively low (17 and 33 percent) in discordant couples (when only one partner in marriage or a steady relationship is HIV-positive) due to factors such as the desire for intimacy, gender inequity, and desire to have children in spite of HIV (Hearst and Chen, 2003). In recent years, more and more evidence has emerged about the need for a balanced approach to prevention messages. For example, an in-depth review of what happened in Uganda concluded that “A” and “B” have been more important than “C” in achieving success, although all three factors may now be responsible for sustaining those achievements (Box 3-6). There is evidence that the positive trends in Uganda are also taking place in at least a few other African countries. For instance, in the Bukoba district of Tanzania, HIV incidence declined from 4.8 percent per year in 1987–89 to 0.6 percent per year in 1993–96 (Stoneburner and Low-Beer, 2002). Also, in Lusaka, Zambia, HIV prevalence among 15 to19year-old pregnant women fell from about 30 percent to about 15 percent between 1993 and 1998 (Fylkesnes et al., 2000; US Census Bureau, 2001). Condom use also increased, but only slightly. The apparent decline in HIV appears to have more to do with reductions in casual partners than with increased condom use (Bloom et al., 2000; Grulich and Kaldor, 2002). Similar population-based studies in 1996 and 1999 show that the proportion of men and women in Zambia in all age groups reporting sex with casual partners fell substantially (Agha, 2002). Data from different countries demonstrate the value of maintaining this balanced approach to prevention. No country seems to have succeeded in reducing and maintaining the reduction of HIV/AIDS incidence and prevalence based on only one of the ABCs. For example, data from Thailand on the widely touted “100 percent condom campaign” indicate that in addition to increased condom use, Thai men also reduced their number of visits to brothels, a fact less often reported (Hogle, 2002). In fact, there may be more similarities than differences between Uganda and Thailand, as pointed out in Box 3-7. What about the prevention experience in relatively lower-prevalence countries? The Dominican Republic, with an estimated HIV prevalence of only 1 percent (UNAIDS, 2002a), has been cited as a major success story for the social marketing of condoms. However, it appears primary sexual behavior changed. Green and Conde (2000) found that 79 percent of respondents in a national survey reported they had changed their behavior due to the fear of AIDS. The majority (52 percent) of these claimed they had become monogamous or reduced their numbers of sexual partners, 15 percent reported use of condoms, 14 percent cited having sexual relations only with people they knew, 9 percent reported avoiding commercial sex, 2 percent claimed they had become abstinent, and 3 percent had not yet begun to have sexual relations. However, there is no simple answer to the question of what works best. In Senegal, the HIV prevalence rate never rose above 1.1 percent and was reported to be 0.5 percent at the end of 2001 (UNAIDS, 2002a). Although conservative cultural norms of relying on “A” and “B” are often cited as contributing to this achievement, in fact Senegal has taken a very aggressive and comprehensive approach to fighting HIV/AIDS. Senegal reports large increases
Communication for Change 91 Box 3-6: The R ole of the ““AB AB Cs” in R educing HIV R ates in Uganda Role ABCs” Reducing Rates An objective review of the data indicates that the major declines in HIV incidence in Uganda clearly preceded the incorporation of large-scale condom promotion into AIDS control efforts. Condom social marketing did not get off the ground on any large scale until the mid-1990s, after the major decline in HIV incidence. By 1995, only 6 percent of Ugandan women and 16 percent of Ugandan men had ever used a condom, with consistent condom use being much lower. Ugandans now report much higher rates of condom use, particularly with casual partners. This may be helping to keep incidence rates down since the late 1990s but cannot be given major credit for the larger fall in incidence that took place before then. So what did cause HIV incidence rates to fall in Uganda in the late 1980s and early 1990s? The available evidence suggests that the main cause was a substantial change in sexual behavior, particularly a reduction in non-regular partnerships. For example, in 1995, only about 12 percent of Ugandan males and 5 percent of Ugandan females between 15 and 19 years-old reported having sex with a non-regular partner in the past 12 months. This compares with about 50 percent and 30 percent, respectively, in neighboring countries. Other age groups showed similar differences in comparison to neighboring countries. In contrast, population-based surveys in Uganda in 1989 found that the proportion of adults reporting casual sex in the past 12 months more closely matched the higher levels that continue to be reported in neighboring countries. Whether as a result of individual rational decision-making or through a more complex process of redefining community norms of behavior, Ugandans seem to have reduced their level of sexual risk behavior from what was once a level typical of their region to what is now a much lower level. Comparisons with neighboring countries suggest that changes in numbers and types of partners have much more to do with the decline in HIV incidence in Uganda than do rates of condom use, which were lower in Uganda than in neighboring countries in the mid-1990s. Simulation models confirm the decline in HIV incidence observed in Uganda to be consistent with what would be predicted from a roughly 50 percent decrease in casual partnerships. This does not mean that condoms had no role in the Ugandan success story. Although overall rates of condom use were comparatively low at the time that incidence rates were declining, even low levels of condom use in the general population can still make a difference if condom use is higher among subgroups of the population at highest risk. This may apply in Uganda, where condom use in commercial sex is very high. Also, condom use may have been higher among the young than among adults in general and thus may have contributed to the decreased HIV incidence observed in that age group. Furthermore, the public debate about condoms that took place in Uganda in the early 1990s may have contributed to the general level of awareness and communication about AIDS and thereby contributed to the process of risk reduction even before large numbers of condoms were used. Source: Hearst and Chen, 2003
in condom sales and distribution: 800,000 in 1988 to 7 million in 1997 (Meda et al., 1999). In addition to this free distribution, 3.6 million socially-marketed condoms were sold through 2,200 sales points in 2001 (USAID, 2002a). As early as 1969, registered sex workers in this Muslim country underwent mandatory quarterly health check-ups and received treatments for STIs. Officials have kept close watch on the safety of the blood supply. Condoms have also played a significant role as they are distributed free of charge to sex workers, patients with STIs, youth, and those employed in the uniformed services.
92 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Box 3-7: Lessons from Success in Uganda and Thailand The experiences of Thailand and Uganda have many differences. In particular, condoms appear to have played a more central role in the success of AIDS prevention efforts in Thailand than in Uganda. These represent differences of degree and circumstances rather than a fundamental difference in approach. In fact, the Thai and Ugandan experiences are more similar than dissimilar. Both countries responded to the AIDS epidemic quickly and decisively. In both, the AIDS control programs had leadership from the highest levels. Both were multi-sectoral and achieved a broad public consensus of support. Both avoided stigmatization and included important aspects of care for the HIV-infected. Both the Thai and Ugandan efforts were endogenous responses to a locally perceived threat. Both countries benefited from international public health and scientific collaboration, and international donors played essential roles in program financing; yet in both cases, the impetus behind prevention efforts was local. While efforts in Thailand emphasized condom use, particularly in commercial sex, they did not emphasize partner reduction. Moreover, Thais responded with a substantial reduction in their number of partners, particularly in the context of commercial sex. While efforts in Uganda emphasized partner reduction, they did not discourage condom use. In fact, condom use has recently reached high levels in the general population of Uganda and has probably been high for much longer in commercial sex. The public promotion and debate regarding condoms ended up encouraging not only condom use but also decreased numbers of partners in both countries. The difference in emphasis between condoms and partner reduction probably had more to do with differences in local epidemiology, particularly differences in the prominence of commercial sex in HIV transmission, than with underlying differences in philosophy. In both cases, the result was a response to the HIV epidemic that seemed to work better than a cookbook approach based on generic international recommendations. A Thai-style program emphasizing condom use in commercial sex and prevention for injecting drug users would not have worked in Uganda, where these are not the main factors driving the epidemic. A Ugandan-style program emphasizing partner reduction for the general population probably would not have worked well in Thailand. In both cases, what did work was a determined, multi-sectoral effort enlisting broad public support and responding to local realities. Source: Hearst and Chen, 2003
It is evident that to successfully combat the HIV/AIDS pandemic, countries need broader “ABC” approaches tailored to local needs. Such approaches can attract a greater number of organizations to join the cause, including those that might reject direct involvement in condom promotion, such as faith-based organizations.
Formative Research The following questions form the basis of formative research needed to design and launch a communication program for the ABCs: l
What is the profile of the intended audience? What is their age, gender, socio-economic status, and interests?
Communication for Change 93 l l
l l l l l l l l l
What knowledge and attitudes do they have related to HIV transmission and prevention, including perception of risk of HIV/AIDS? What are their predominant sexual behaviors? (e.g., average age of sexual debut, number of sexual partners, sexual activity outside of marriage/steady relationships, polygamy, and sexual practices/sexual orientation.) What are their present levels of condom use? Other contraceptive use? What social norms most influence the group and their communities regarding sexuality and STIs, including HIV/AIDS? What misconceptions and myths do they have with regard to HIV and AIDS? What is their ability to delay sexual debut, maintain abstinence, or negotiate condom use? What level of “self-efficacy” do they report and what skills do they exhibit? What communication channels do they prefer? What are their media habits? What is the level of access to supplies and services, including condom supplies, VCT, and STI services? Are there particular segments of society that will reject condom promotion, even within a balanced ABC approach? How will they be included in the program? Is it possible to communicate separate A, B, C messages to different audiences? (e.g., delay of sexual debut or continued abstinence for those who are unmarried and/or not yet sexually active, secondary or periodic abstinence or use condoms for those who are sexually active)
Audiences and Actors While there are many audiences and actors relevant to increasing safer sex practices, the following are among the most critical when considering ABC programing for the general population: Young P eople: Youth can be segmented into subgroups that enable programmers to respond People: more directly to their particular needs. Usually, programs segment young audiences into 10 to 14 year-olds and 15 to 19 year-olds. The definition of young people reaches up to 24 years of age or beyond in some countries, and each age group may have particular needs, perceptions, beliefs, and values. Men and W omen of R eproductive Age: All men and women of reproductive age face inWomen Reproductive creasing risk of HIV/AIDS, especially in high-prevalence countries or those in transition. The combined effect of physiological susceptibility and gender imbalances in marital or long-term relationships leaves women particularly vulnerable to HIV infection. In many societies, men indulge in multiple sexual partnerships, patronize commercial sex workers, or partake in bisexual activity, putting their spouses or regular partners at great risk. Influential Individuals and Societal Groups: Civil society organizations, religious, political or traditional leaders, and other influentials are critical secondary or tertiary audiences and potential actors. First, through their platform and constituencies, they can make an issue
94 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
public and promote open dialogue. Second, these influentials can directly promote individual risk reduction behaviors such as fidelity, condom use, or partner reduction among their constituencies.
Strategic Approaches The key to the successful promotion of the ABCs is to present a balanced set of options and to encourage use of the option that best fits individual lifestyles and needs. Although all three options are available, specific segments of the general population are likely to opt for one over the others, and communication programs need to position the ABC options accordingly. The following strategies and channels are useful in a holistic, integrated communication plan for the ABCs of prevention. We expand on many of them in much more depth elsewhere in this book. l
l
l l l
Interpersonal Communication and Counseling: Interpersonal communication and counseling by health, social, and educational service providers are key strategies for communication on the ABCs. TV and R adio: Many innovative strategies can be used in the form of entertaining Radio: TV and radio spots, drama, and other creative formats for the dissemination of ABC messages. The program should be branded with a well-researched logo that will provide high visibility and identification. Peer Education: This approach constitutes a potentially powerful and frequently used channel (see Chapter 6). Hotlines and Information T echnologies: Telephone hotlines and Internet technology Technologies: are fast becoming the cutting edge of prevention and care programs (see Chapter 6). Group and L ocal Media: Facilitation of “ABC” choices through life skills sessions Local can be linked with the overall program through mass media (See Journey of Hope, Box 3-4).
Key Issues to Communicate However, the challenge for communicators is not just choosing channels. The challenge lies in the complex issues that surround arriving at an effective and acceptable formula for communicating a combination of ABC messages through different channels. Because of the power and reach of the mass media, communicators have been criticized for promoting early sex and sex outside of marriage. In Zambia, TV spots promoting the use of condoms among male youth were deemed acceptable by media gatekeepers but one showing young, unmarried females having condoms handy derailed the whole HEART Campaign (see Zambia case study) for an entire year. In Kenya, one particular TV spot within a condom social marketing program “raised a ruckus” and had to be withdrawn, as documented in Box 3-8.
Communication for Change 95 Box 3-8: A Controversial Condom Advertisement A “racy” television ad for socially marketed condoms made Kenyan “adults fume and adolescents squirm,” according to the Associated Press. In the ad, two young women who appear to be teenagers are waiting at a train station on a sunny day. A handsome young man walks in from the heat to a water faucet and pours water on his head and chest, taking off his shirt. The two women stare, licking their lips; one drops her plastic water bottle, which cracks and starts leaking. The young man walks over, takes a condom from his pocket, and puts it on the water bottle, stopping the leak. The television spot was well made and conveyed a high level of sexual energy. This advertisement created a great deal of controversy. Opponents claimed that it encouraged promiscuity among young people. Proponents countered that it encouraged condom use among atrisk young people and demonstrated, among other things, that condoms are strong and waterproof. Neither side could base their opinion on any objective data as to whether the advertisement did or did not encourage sexual activity among young people. Sources: Aetna InteliHealth, 2002; Hearst and Chen, 2003
“A” for Abstinence: Abstinence is particularly appropriate for adolescents who should recognize it as the surest means of avoiding HIV/AIDS and protecting their own future plans. In fact, it has been suggested that “D” for delay should be added to “ABC menu.” Delay of sexual debut is central to the promotion of abstinence, and a number of countries have developed communication programs that encourage adolescents to wait. Evidence suggests that in Uganda the medium age of sexual debut among both men and women increased by approximately one year between 1989 and 2000 (Bessinger et al., 2002). The proportion of young people of ages 15 to 19 years reporting that they never had sex rose in Uganda between 1989 and 1995: from 31 percent to 56 percent for males and 26 percent to 46 percent for females (World Bank, 1999). Adolescents often experience conflicting emotions about sexual debut, including sexual relations before marriage. On the one hand, many feel tremendous social pressures from their peers to engage in sex: to “be a man,” to “be cool,” to please a boyfriend/girlfriend, to give and receive affection, to get favors and gifts. Many experience the strong biological drive that accompanies adolescence, which may lead them to want to experiment and experience the pleasure that sex brings. On the other hand, many young people recognize that in today’s world, their best protection is to delay or avoid sex during their adolescent years. Religious teaching, family values, desire for educational advancement, and related factors may encourage them to abstain from sex. Research conducted in Zambia revealed that youth, and young girls in particular, wanted to have concrete messages that provide them with reasons to abstain or return to abstinence (see Zambia case study). Equipping young people with the information and particularly the life skills they need to negotiate and maintain a positive approach to reproductive health is essential in the fight against HIV and AIDS. The benefits of this approach will not only help prevent HIV transmission among young people today; it will also help establish appropriate behavioral patterns as this cohort moves into adulthood. The primary audience for messages about abstinence is the adolescent who is not yet sexually active. However, programs can also encourage those who have had sexual relations
96 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
to return to abstinence or delay relations for a substantial period. This option is also available to individuals whose partners are stationed elsewhere for long periods of time, although this group has not been a primary audience for abstinence promotion, to date. Finally, some PLHA may opt to discontinue having sexual relations, but such issues are better addressed in programs directed specifically to them. artner: Being faithful to one known and trusted partner or “B” for Being F aithful to One P Faithful Partner: at least reducing the number of sexual partners are usually messages aimed at unmarried but sexually active individuals and to married or common-law couples. It should be clear that you should know your and your partner’s HIV status and/or use condoms consistently if you have sexual relationships with an HIV-positive person or with more than one known and trusted partner. In other words, reducing sexual partnerships alone may not be an effective HIV-prevention strategy. One problem with young people is the often short-lived nature of their sexual relationships, followed closely by new ones. Thus, being faithful to the current partner may not provide protection if either partner practices “serial monogamy,” a series of short relationships, faithful while they last. In such situations, “B” is not foolproof for a number of reasons: the “one partner” may be infected unbeknownst to the other or the current “faithfulness” may have followed multiple sexual relationships by one or both of the partners. So having fewer sexual partners reduces but does not eliminate the risk of infection. Although “B” has been less utilized than “A” or “C,” it is an important part of the “ABC trilogy.” Evidence from Uganda suggests that partner-reduction has been one of the factors in the decline of HIV prevalence (Box 3-6). As in the case of abstinence, communication programs must address social norms related to these practices. It is important to provide positive role models that face such dilemmas and experience the positive consequences of making the right decision. Both mass media and community-level interventions, particularly those using an entertainment–education format, can be effective in communicating the changing norms of a society on this issue. “C ” for Condom Use: The audience for condom promotion potentially includes all individuals “C” who are sexually active. However, experience in many countries indicates that young people and men having sex outside of marriage, including with sex workers, are most receptive to condom use. As discussed, social marketing programs created widespread awareness of condoms and their role in the protection of HIV/AIDS throughout the developing world. Condoms, whether brand specific or generic, are now readily available in most developing countries in health centers, pharmacies, and neighborhood kiosks, as well as places such as truck stops, motels, bars, and discos, where they are often positioned with casual sexual activity or at least sex outside of marriage. Specialized types of condom promotion include dual protection and dual-method use. Dual protection refers to the benefit of the condom in protecting against both pregnancy and STI/HIV/AIDS. This benefit of condoms may be particularly attractive to young people who need both types of protection, and because they have sex on a sporadic basis (they may not feel the need to be on birth control or more continuous contraception). Dual-method use, by contrast, involves the use of condoms to prevent STI/HIV/AIDS and the use of another contraceptive to prevent pregnancy. To date, dual-method use is relatively rare, for the
Communication for Change 97
reasons that married couples tend to dislike condom use, as noted, and using two methods requires additional initiative and expense.
Challenges and Lessons Learned The Non-R ational Nature of Sexual Behavior: Sex and sexual transmission of HIV take Non-Rational place in a domain of very complex and emotional behaviors that affect people’s risk perception: feelings of love are equated with trust and often overpower personal caution and responsibility. Sexual encounters may be mistaken for expressions of love. Discussing sex or condom use may be taboo. Mainstream portrayals of romantic love in the media send out contradictory and counterproductive messages of purity, submission, and love as uncontrollable passion and intoxication, and they avoid the issue of responsible protection (Ndabamenye, 2000). As Perloff (2001) notes, good intentions may fall by the wayside in the presence of strong sexual drive or desire for emotional fulfillment, especially if alcohol or drugs are involved. Alcohol and drugs also have a very negative effect on the correct and consistent use of condoms. Stigma A ttached to Condom Use: Ironically, the use of condoms—one of the most effective Attached means of preventing HIV transmission—carries a certain stigma that deters individuals from using them. Asking one’s partner to use a condom implies that the partner, or the asker, has had other partners and may have an STI, including HIV. Condom negotiation can ruin the romantic nature of the encounter or worse yet, lead to violence against the woman who requested it. Again, communication can play an important role in increasing the social acceptability of condoms and influencing social norms around their use. An amusing TV spot in Ghana portrays an amorous couple who move hastily toward their love-hut, but the action stops short when the man says he does not want to use a condom. They emerge from their hut engaged in loud bickering. The man, realizing his only hope to complete his lovemaking, relents and returns, agreeing to use a condom. Promoting AB CT ogether: There is a good deal of debate on whether “C” should be promoted ABC Together: in the same campaign or program as “B,” and especially with “A,” including delay of sexual debut by young people. In many countries, political and religious leaders have taken public positions against the widespread promotion of condoms, calling instead for a focus on abstinence for the unmarried and fidelity within marriage. In some countries different groups have arrived at a compromise, such as eliminating the word “condom” from public service announcements or referring audiences to other organizations that distribute condoms. A Note of Caution in the Use of AB C Messaging: We offer a word of caution about sendABC ing the message that condom use is advisable only if abstinence and faithfulness fail, because this message can be misleading or even dangerous. For example, women who are being faithful to an unfaithful husband need to be advised to use condoms, while sexually active young couples cannot rely on each other’s ideas of “serial monogamy.” They need to go for HIV testing before having unprotected sex. In a second example, condoms should be used by sero-discordant couples (i.e., where one is HIV negative and the other positive).
98 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
On the positive side, it should be noted that in Thailand, the national HIV/AIDS program promoted condoms widely and visibly on the mass media but did not discourage men from visiting commercial sex facilities. In spite of this, the percentage of men visiting these establishments fell dramatically (Stoneburner and Low-Beer, 2002). A similar result was demonstrated in Brazil, where condom promotion directed at male port workers was not only instrumental in increasing condom use, but also decreased the reported percentage of men having casual partners (Hearst et al., 1999). However, in spite of these findings, surprisingly little is known about why the above positive results were obtained or the overall effects of different approaches to condom promotion on sexual risk behavior. According to Hearst and Chen, Research studies and program evaluations that examine the effect of condom promotion strategies usually focus on condom use as their outcome. Seldom do they measure numbers and types of partners with sufficient rigor to determine to what extent a particular condom promotion strategy influences other aspects of sexual risk. The possibility that interventions presenting casual sex with a condom as socially acceptable, enjoyable, and safe might increase sexual risk cannot be discounted. In high-risk groups that are already engaging in such behaviors, it is appropriate that the main consideration is to find the approach that best promotes condom use. But priorities might be different for people not currently practicing high-risk behaviors because the balance of risk versus benefit may be different, with greater potential to do harm (Hearst and Chen, 2003). HIV/AIDS prevention programs should pay more attention to interactions between ABC strategies. These interactions are often positive but might also, at times, be negative. Prevention programs should try to maximize the positive interactions and minimize the negative ones. Too often, different prevention strategies are viewed as competing alternatives rather than examining how they might complement and reinforce each other. At the very least, different approaches should carefully avoid undercutting each other (Hearst and Chen, 2003). However, there is evidence that when communication programs are carefully planned and researched, the ABC messages can be promoted independently to different audiences without having a negative spillover effect. This has been demonstrated in Zambia, where A and C were successfully promoted within the same mass communication campaign (See Zambia case study).
Communication for Change 99
Case Study: Communicating Safer Sex in Zambia Background: The Zambia Sexual Behavior Survey (C.S.O., Zambia, 1998) reported that 37 percent of boys and 27 percent of girls have already had sex by the age of 15. By age 19, only 16 percent of youth in Zambia reported they “have never had sex.” Surveys in high-density urban areas indicated that by the age of 19 years, the majority of sexually active females had been pregnant at least once. Condom use was inconsistent and the majority of youth (84 percent) reported not using a condom the last time they had sex. Studies in Zambia show that the HIV prevalence for women 15–19 years old is 6.6 percent and for men of the same age 1.9 percent, the difference largely attributed to young women’s physical susceptibility to HIV and the cultural norm of girls having sexual relations with older men. Although government and NGOs had previously implemented awareness campaigns for young people, these efforts had led to only minor changes in youth behavior. Project Strategy: Against this background, the HEART—Helping Each Other Act Responsibly Together—campaign was born. HEART was designed specifically for young people of ages 13–19 years. The overall objective of the program was to promote healthy sexual behaviors among young people by reinforcing existing “safer” behaviors and changing behaviors that are “unsafe.” One key to the success of this intervention was the leadership youth provide in setting the agenda. Recognizing that youth know youth culture best, young people were asked to serve on the campaign design team, to participate on a Youth Advisory Group, to articulate specific campaign objectives, to review message concepts and execution, and to conduct focus groups and in-depth interviews related to the campaign. The specific campaign objectives included: l l l l l
Promoting continued abstinence among those already abstaining, Making abstinence “hip, cool, the in-thing,” Increasing consistency of condom use among sexually active youth, Positioning condoms among sexually active youth as a cool part of their sexual lives, and Making youth understand that even a person who looks healthy can be infected with HIV.
Campaign materials included TV spots, mainly for urban youth, and radio spots, largely for rural youth, which focused on abstinence and consistent use of condoms. Complementing the electronic media were a variety of other materials including posters, car stickers, messages on buses and exercise books, a CD with a wide selection of songs, and three musical videos with the key messages. A key campaign message “You can’t tell by looking,” stressed that one cannot tell a person has HIV by that person’s appearance. Some of the media spots dealt with abstinence, such as: l
Choices, where abstinent boys reminded their peers why they choose to be abstinent.
100 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic l
“When He Says...”, where boys spoke a series of lines to which girls replied “no to sex” and maintained their “virgin power/virgin pride.”
The campaign was evaluated through a quasi-experimental, pre- and post-test design. The evaluation’s results demonstrate that “both abstinence and condoms can be promoted in a youth campaign, and with positive results in achieving both types of targeted behavior change. This is an important finding because those who favor abstinence promotion sometimes argue that promotion of this along with condoms (A and C) sends a mixed message. Or that condom promotion undermines the abstinence or delay of debut message, therefore it may make more sense to promote one or the other, but not both at the same time.” (Hearst and Chen, 2003). Some of the more notable findings are as follows: l
l l
l
l
l l
The HEART campaign reached over 50 percent of the intended audience; 71 percent of urban and 37 percent of rural youth saw one or more of the spots. Young women, both urban and rural, were as likely as young men to have seen some or all of the spots. Comprehension of the messages was good. Between 60 percent and 90 percent of viewers spontaneously identified the correct message of any given spot. The evaluation found that 75 percent of males and 68 percent of females who were exposed to the campaign began talking with others about AIDS, abstinence, and using condoms as a result of the campaign. Among women who are sexually experienced, 82 percent of campaign viewers, contrasted with 69 percent at baseline and 64 percent of impact survey non-viewers, reported they feel confident that they have “the ability to say no to unwanted sex.” Using logistic regression and holding the independent variables age, educational attainment, urban/rural residence and sex, constant, data show that viewers were 1.68 times more likely to report primary or secondary abstinence than non-viewers. There was a dose effect: the more health communication spots a respondent recalled, the greater the likelihood that the respondent was abstinent. Among both men and women, the perceived efficacy to use condoms was positively and significantly correlated with viewership. Logistic regression analysis found that viewers were 1.91 times more likely to have ever used a condom and 1.63 times more likely to report condom use during their last sexual encounter, when contrasted with non-viewers (holding sex, age, residence, and education constant). Older, better educated respondents were more likely than others to use condoms. Interestingly, women were more likely to report condom use than men when background characteristics were held constant.
The evaluators recommended that the program should: l
Continue to support and encourage abstinence or “return to abstinence” as a viable alternative.
Communication for Change 101 l l
Convey the idea that abstinence is a social norm among young people. Portray consistent condom use as a social norm.
The report noted that “fear of HIV infection” was the main reason given for abstaining from sex. Those who were abstaining, who had not been exposed to the campaign, were more likely to cite “not having a partner or the opportunity for sex.” The report points out that young people in areas of high HIV prevalence will respond positively to delay/abstinence messages by choosing or maintaining such behavior. Source: Hearst and Chen, 2003; Underwood et al., 2001
Communication to Reduce Stigma Rationale Stigma is a recurrent theme throughout this book because of the devastating role it plays in the lives of PLHA and the barrier it presents to prevention. Stigma results from the devaluation of individuals or groups of people who are perceived to be HIV-positive or living with AIDS (whether or not they manifest symptoms of AIDS). Stigma leads to acts of discrimination, which occur when “a distinction is made against a person that results in his or her being treated unfairly and unjustly on the basis of their belonging, or being perceived to belong, to a particular group” (UNAIDS, 2002a). Perceived stigma can have powerful psychological consequences for the victim, leading to depression and feelings of lack of self worth, which further impacts on the health status of PLHA (UNAIDS, 2002b). Stigma and discrimination can be manifested at different levels and in different contexts: policy and legal, institutional (schools, health care facilities, workplace), community, family, and individual. For example, being HIV-positive or simply coming from a high prevalence country can result in limitations on international travel and migration or mandatory HIV testing. Children of infected parents have been excluded from collective activities and expelled from school. Stigma is a consequence of the association people make between HIV/AIDS and pre-existing prejudices, shame, blame, and fear related to sexuality, gender, race/ethnicity, and class. HIV/AIDS is associated with sexually transmitted diseases, homosexuality, promiscuity, prostitution, and sexual “deviance” or assumptions about “African sexuality,” as well as drug use and poverty (Kidd and Clay, 2003; Parker et al., 2002). A woman’s decision not to breastfeed in a high prevalence country may raise suspicions of her being HIV-positive. These suspicions can lead to breaches of confidentiality at her health care clinic and stigmatizing gossip in the community and family. Stigma has resulted in
102 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
people being denied food or care, evicted from their homes or workplaces, and violently attacked and murdered (Parker et al., 2002). Fears of contagion, disease, and dying are compounded by misinformation about how HIV is transmitted and what it means to live with HIV and AIDS. People, however, often seem largely unaware that their attitudes, language, and actions are stigmatizing. In fact, care and support for PLHA often coexists with stigmatizing attitudes and acts of discrimination in the same community (ICRW Research Update, 2002). Fear of stigmatization prevents PLHA from disclosing their status, protecting their sexual partners, asking friends or family for support, and making long-term plans for their dependents. Various scare messages such as “AIDS kills,” as well as stereotypes associated with PLHA, have clearly contributed to the perception that AIDS only affects “others,” especially those who are already marginalized, such as sex workers and MSM. People may not be willing to get tested or disclose their status from fear of being associated with such groups. Stigma limits the effectiveness of prevention efforts. Because of the stigma attached to HIV and AIDS, people may deny that they are at risk, avoid getting tested, and may also avoid protective behaviors or discussion of HIV/AIDS altogether. Those who learn they are HIVpositive may continue former risky behaviors or reject healthy behaviors to avoid arousing suspicion. Stigma has also led political leaders in many countries to deny that HIV and AIDS are problems that need urgent action (UNAIDS, 2002b). Stigma negatively affects the seeking of care and support. Expecting negative repercussions, PLHA may avoid seeking care from health care professionals or social workers until symptoms become severe. In fact, stigma has been exhibited frequently by providers at health care facilities where people go to get tested or to receive care and support. Negative perceptions of PLHA shape provider and caregiver behavior. Blaming the patient for his/her illness can lead to less than adequate care or even denial of care and breaches of confidentiality. Unless care providers are thoroughly trained in how to empathetically deal with PLHA, they may inadvertently or directly stigmatize the latter, even though they may have better knowledge than most people on how HIV does and does not spread. Stigma and discrimination have tremendous costs. HIV infections increase as people avoid prevention behaviors and getting tested. Health care costs grow because of the difficulties of treating opportunistic infections at advanced stages. Workplaces lose valuable employees. Individuals and families struggle to cope with the illness on their own. Because stigma is rooted in social attitudes and cultural beliefs, the issue is difficult to tackle. However, if we do not address the stigmatization of PLHA, any effort to fight HIV/AIDS will have limited results.
Formative Research Key research questions are as follows: l
Do people freely talk about HIV and AIDS (at home, at church, in the store, at work)?
Communication for Change 103 l
l l l l l l l l l l
Do people have accurate knowledge about HIV and AIDS transmission and care, especially about the lack of transmission through casual contact such as shaking hands? What are people’s images of HIV and AIDS and the language used to discuss it in the mass media? Is HIV/AIDS associated with particular groups or particular behaviors? Are there reports of discrimination in the community, workplace, and health care setting? What are the experiences of PLHA? Are they afraid to disclose their status to family and friends? What are people’s attitudes about condom use and HIV testing? What are various opinion leaders (including religious leaders) saying about HIV/ AIDS and who is at risk? What policies and laws exist with regard to HIV and AIDS discrimination? What policies and laws presently exist that protect or discriminate against PLHA? How have educational institutions dealt with PLHA and their children? Do support networks exist for PLHA? Are PLHA involved in HIV/AIDS prevention and care activities? Do programs already exist to promote acceptance and support for PLHA and how successful have they been?
Audiences HIV/AIDS-related stigma exists in varying degrees throughout the world. Because it stems from and reinforces pre-existing attitudes and discrimination within the social fabric of different societies, stigma reduction strategies should target many different subgroups within a given population, in addition to the general public. Groups that play an especially significant role in influencing stigma include: l l l l l l
Policymakers and opinion leaders (including traditional/social leaders, political leaders, business leaders, religious leaders) Health care workers PLHA and their families and friends PLHA’s caretakers in the community and home Media workers and journalists International and local NGOs, CBOs, and FBOs involved in HIV/AIDS work
Strategic Approach Because the intensity and focus of HIV/AIDS-related stigma and discrimination differ by country, it is difficult to suggest a standardized strategy to address stigma. Strategies must
104 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
be carefully tailored to respond to the local environment at a particular time. For example, in countries where HIV prevalence is low or where the disease is not highly visible, communication efforts on stigma need to first focus on high-risk behaviors of highly vulnerable groups and prevention efforts that address these. However, in areas where the HIV/AIDS epidemic is more widespread, the program also needs to focus on stigma as it relates to care and support in the general population (e.g., confidentiality in getting tested before marriage, using a replacement for breastfeeding, protection of orphans). Similarly, no one intervention will effectively eliminate stigma. Rather, a combination of the strategies, such as those that follow, may be needed. Advocacy: Advocacy is needed to create and enforce laws and policies that support PLHA and punish discrimination. For example, the Thai Business Coalition on AIDS advocates with employers about the benefits of nondiscriminatory workplace policies and facilitates presentations and workshops about HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS, 1997a). As a result, HIV-positive employees have reported increased acceptance and support, and staff members have become more willing to volunteer in organizations working to address HIV/AIDS. In India, the Lawyers Collective HIV/AIDS Unit works to influence HIV/AIDS legislation, informs PLHA and organizations addressing HIV/AIDS about appropriate legislation, and directly takes up cases of discrimination in the courts (Lawyers Collective HIV/AIDS Unit, 2002). Interpersonal and Group Communication: Because stigma is usually based on ignorance and fear, it is important that communication interventions create dialogue and individual contact between PLHA and uninfected people. Program planners must also give careful attention to the design of messages, correcting misconceptions about HIV transmission, so that they do not inadvertently contribute to HIV/AIDS-related stigma. For example, a focus on “risk groups” rather than “risk behaviors” reinforces stigma. PLHA involvement in the design and implementation of communication interventions has been shown to reduce PLHA’s own fear of stigmatization (Horizons, 2002a). Communication interventions can target specific audiences to reduce stigma. In Tanzania, a school-based program involving HIV/AIDS education, including small group discussions and role-plays, resulted in a significant improvement in attitudes toward PLHA (Klepp et al., 1997). When agricultural workers in Zimbabwe learned about HIV/AIDS through peer education and workshops, they became more open in discussions about HIV, indicating reduced stigma (Kerry and Margie, 1996). Research on care, stigma, and discrimination against PLHA can also serve as an effective means to creating dialogue about stigma. In India, discussions with staff from three hospitals on the results of baseline research on stigma towards PLHA led to increased interest and action to reduce stigma, including the development of PLHA-friendly “gold standards” for hospital programs and staff (Horizons, 2002b). Mass Media: Mass media, if inappropriately used, can actually increase stigma. For instance, if vulnerable groups such as sex workers are portrayed as the main HIV transmitters, they will be further stigmatized. Conversely, mass media can help to foster a more supportive environment regarding HIV/AIDS prevention and PLHA. Mass media channels, when viewed as credible sources of information, have the advantage of reaching vast audiences. Effective messages delivered through mass media channels can support and reinforce interventions
Communication for Change 105
conducted at the community level. For example, in India a documentary film describing the life of a PLHA was produced and broadcast nationally (Venkataraman et al., 1996). Focus group discussions revealed that exposure to the film increased acceptance and reduced stigma, and volunteers and organizations became more willing to work with PLHA. Training: To foster healthier, more positive attitudes about PLHA, training interventions are needed for a variety of important and influential audiences including health care workers and other caregivers, opinion leaders, media workers, and journalists. For example, UNAIDS worked with the Rotary Club of Dhaka, Bangladesh, to organize a workshop on HIV/AIDS for media professionals (Rotary International, 2002). Training efforts must go beyond knowledge. Training should address the attitudes, interpersonal communication, and counseling skills of health workers and caregivers. Historically, training for health workers has focused on HIV/AIDS knowledge and specific technical skills, with less emphasis on the importance of positive provider attitudes. Even in the UK, research found that an alarming 46 percent of PLHA surveyed reported discrimination from health care providers (Power et al., 2002). As regards frontline providers of information and care to people concerned about HIV/AIDS, providers’ judgmental attitudes can inhibit people from asking questions and seeking service, and can reinforce stigmatizing behavior in general. In Cambodia, training teams visited caregivers, demonstrating treatments involving close contact and touch, and reinforced the message that PLHA do not need to be feared (Sarath, 1999). In Uganda, the Islamic Medical Association trained over 8,000 religious leaders. An evaluation concluded that the support of official Islam for care of PLHA is a strong counterweight to stigmatization (UNAIDS, 1998a). Involving PLHA: The involvement of PLHA in designing communication and training interventions is paramount. PLHA can give the disease and its consequences a human face, increasing the immediacy of the illness to others. PLHA involvement allows PLHA to redefine their illness, reconstruct their identities, and develop tools to reduce stigma. For example, The AIDS Support Organization (TASO) in Uganda provides counseling and medical care to PLHA and their families and organizes groups where they can discuss issues they are facing (Kaleeba et al., 1997). Participants report that the program helps them realize that they are not alone. Those PLHA who are affiliated have high rates of disclosure of their HIV status, indicating reduced stigma. A multi-country study of PLHA involvement in communitybased organizations (in Burkina Faso, India, Ecuador, and Zambia) showed similar results; PLHA demonstrated reduced fear of stigmatization and feelings of powerlessness (Horizons, 2002a).
Key Issues to Communicate l l l
Emphasize that everyone is at risk, not just those identified as vulnerable groups. Focus on risk behavior, not risk groups. Provide indepth information on all aspects of HIV and AIDS (e.g., how HIV is transmitted, the difference between HIV and AIDS) (Nyblade, 2003).
106 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic l l l l l
Create awareness on stigma (i.e., language, attitudes, behavior) and how it is harmful (Nyblade, 2003). Invite NGOs and health workers involved in HIV/AIDS work to examine their own attitudes and behavior (Nyblade, 2003). Include asymptomatic PLHA in prevention efforts and visual communication to demonstrate that “You can’t tell by looking.” Communicate that PLHA can lead long, positive, and healthy lives if they have a number of care and support options. Emphasize human rights and compassion such as: – – – – –
“I am not my disease.” “My friend with AIDS is first my friend.” “AIDS does not discriminate, why do you?” “Fight AIDS, not people with AIDS.” “Take a look, stigma kills.”
Challenges and Lessons Learned The lack of in-depth knowledge and dialogue on HIV and AIDS allows “correct knowledge” to coexist with irrational fear of casual transmission and stigmatizing attitudes (ICRW Research Update, 2002). Attitudes toward certain groups such as sex workers, IDUs, and MSM may be deep-rooted and difficult to change. Stigma is difficult to measure as it is fed by a range of prejudices, attitudes, and behaviors (UNAIDS, 2000b). Reducing stigma may mean talking openly and frankly about sexuality and what communities sometimes define as socially unacceptable behavior. Until recently, relatively few interventions to reduce HIV/AIDS stigma in developing countries had been conducted, rigorously evaluated, and published (Brown et al., 2001a). However, a growing number of countries are now focusing directly on stigma. Lessons learned, to date, include the following: l l l l
l
No one strategy can effectively eliminate stigma—a combination of approaches is crucial. Stigma messages need to be integrated into the overall behavior change strategy. All HIV/AIDS messages need to be carefully formulated so as not to reinforce stigma. Few national-level stigma interventions have been conducted. Greater emphasis needs to be placed on comprehensive programs that use the context of prevention, care, and support to address stigma. Indirect, as well as direct ways to address stigma can work well (Busza, 1999). Personalizing or putting a face on the disease makes the greatest impact on stigma.
Communication for Change 107
Case Study: Brief Examples of Disclosure and Compassion in Africa One of the strongest strategies to address stigma around HIV and AIDS is to humanize the face of AIDS through public testimonies of PLHA. The following projects used mass media to tell stories of the courage and strength required when confronting HIV infection and living openly with HIV and AIDS.
South Africa: “The Living Openly” Project AIDS is seldom associated with openness but this project has given insight into the lives of PLHA who chose to help “normalize” the disease through public disclosures of their status. The project was born in 1999, reflecting on the often harsh and stereotyped portrayals of PLHA in the South African media, which used pictures of people who were ill, in bed, emaciated, and downcast. Instead, the Beyond Awareness Campaign of the Ministry of Health developed a photographic exhibition, a book, and a documentary video, tracing the uniquely different experiences of 31 South Africans who tell their stories about the process of living openly with HIV and AIDS. The participants were drawn from a variety of contexts and represent a wide age range: from 11-year-old Nkosi Johnson to Jan de Groot who was 73 years old. A qualitative evaluation of the intervention showed that it had valuable psychosocial benefits for the PLHA participants in that it gave them useful information and made them feel empowered. The public response, especially to the photo exhibition, demonstrated that people identified with the project participants and felt that their stereotypes about PLHA had been challenged. The video has been shown on prime-time TV. However, the evaluation was not able to capture the impact of this broader exposure (Beyond Awareness Campaign, 2000a and 2000b).
West Africa: “Living Positively—Vivre Positivement” The West African Santé Familiale et Prévention du Sida (SFPS) program developed a similar video in 2002. This 42-minute video, produced by Burkina Faso filmmaker Fanta Nacro, presents the testimonies of West African PLHA who describe their need to love and be loved, their desire to have children, and how they were eventually accepted by their families and communities. Additionally, a 32-page color comic book, “Marcelline et Jojo: Un combat pour la vie” tells the story of Jojo—a young student who has just learned about his HIV-positive status. Through Jojo’s trials and tribulations the reader learns about nutrition, the treatment of opportunistic infections, and the need to join a support group. The South African Storyteller Group helped develop the comic, which was modeled after an earlier version called “Eating with Hope.”
108 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Plate 3-5: A Comic Book, Marcelline and Jojo rancophone A frica promotes open discussion and Jojo,, for F Francophone Africa support for PLHA. (Credit: Projet Regional Sante Familiale et Prevention du SIDA)
Both the objectives and content of the comic book and film were developed through a participatory workshop that brought together PLHA and their organizations, health providers, program managers, cartoonists, and filmmakers from Burkina Faso, the Ivory Coast, Mali, Senegal, and Togo. Both products are a result of the collaboration between SFPS, Johns Hopkins’ CCP, UNAIDS and RAP+, the Francophone Association of People Living with HIV and AIDS (JHU/CCP 2002a).
Ghana: Reach Out, Show Compassion Stop AIDS, Love Life is a joint effort of the Ghana Ministries of Information and Health, the Ghana Social Marketing Foundation, and JHU/CCP, with support from USAID. In 2000, the program created radio and TV spots featuring one of the first Ghanaians, Kuasi, who disclosed his HIV-positive status in public. Kuasi died shortly after the production of the TV spots and his father and aunt agreed to talk on camera about his courage and their compassion for him. The family’s openness led to greater political commitment to reduce stigma in Ghana. The second phase of the Stop AIDS, Love Life national communication program is called Reach Out, Show Compassion. One of the key barriers for community and faith-based organizations to get involved in AIDS activities is the stigma that HIV and AIDS are associated
Communication for Change 109
with immorality. Many even deny that people amongst them may be infected. Compassion is a key to de-stigmatization and one of the central tenets of humanitarian and faith-based groups. The campaign’s goal is therefore to cultivate attitudes of compassion, hope, and support among Christian and Muslim leaders toward Ghanaians living with HIV/AIDS. Using (i) advocacy activities with the church hierarchy, (ii) training and activity packages for clergy, imams and lay leaders, and (iii) mass media to approach congregations, the program is already increasing the number of faith-based religious groups engaged in HIV/AIDS issues. Training programs for 900 clergy, imams, and other religious leaders were held throughout Ghana. Television and radio spots were produced and aired, featuring openly positive PLHA as part of their congregation or preachers quoting passages from the Bible or Koran where compassionate behavior is demonstrated. A multitude of print materials, such as posters, brochures, stickers, billboards, and T-shirts support the campaign. People living with HIV/AIDS need more than medical support; they need emotional and spiritual support and they need to live in caring communities. This will slow the spread of HIV because people would not be so likely to hide their status if they could expect more compassion. Sources: Beyond Awareness Campaign, 2000a, 2000b; JHU/CCP, 2002b; Tweedie et al., 2002
Chapter 4
R eaching Special Audiences Preventing HIV Infection in Young People Rationale The previous chapter contained many references to and examples of young people because they represent a large percentage of the general population in the developing world. However, they also represent a special audience with special needs when it comes to program formulation and design. Young people present the greatest hope, yet the largest challenge, in curbing the HIV/AIDS pandemic. If all young people were to reach their 25th birthday free of HIV and AIDS, the number of PLHA would be halved. Unfortunately, because of their social, emotional, and physical immaturity, and because societies often make it difficult for them to learn about sexuality and HIV/AIDS, young people are especially vulnerable. There are a number of overlapping and confusing terms used for young people. A “child” is defined by the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child as anyone below 18 years of age. “Youth” is a term sometimes used to denote “young people,” but it has different connotations in various countries, including organizational membership in youth associations and youth wings of political parties for up to 35 or 40 years of age. “Adolescence” usually means people between 10 and 19 years of age, and “teenagers” refers to those between 13 and 19 years. For the purposes of this discussion, we use the term “young people,” which is defined as people between the ages of 10 and 24 years of age and includes “early adolescence” (10 to 14 years), middle adolescence (15 to 19 years), and young adults (20 to 24 years) (JamesTraore, 2001). The majority of research and programming has concentrated on the 15 to 24year age range. However, in order for young people to develop healthy behaviors that protect them against HIV and AIDS, programs need to address early adolescent and even preadolescent age groups. Most young people around the world become sexually active between the ages of 10 and 20 years (Greene et al., 2002). Of the estimated 40 million people living with HIV or AIDS at the end of 2001, approximately 11.8 million were between 15 and 24 years of age. About half of all new infections occur in young people between the ages of 15 and 24 years, amounting to 6,000 young people being infected per day around the world (UNAIDS, 2002a). As young people reach puberty, they are caught between two worlds—childhood and adulthood. Adolescence is a time of change and adjustment. At this time, girls and boys learn to
Reaching Special Audiences 111
Plate 4-1: “Not everyone is doing it…. If your time hasn’t come, don’t have sex,” reads an HIV/AIDS poster for young people in Honduras. (Credit: Nicaragua Comision Interagencial de Salud Reproductiva)
behave as adults and to deal with new physical sensations and emotions. Hormonal changes cause swings in emotions, confusion, and strong sexual urges. Often young people want to experience sex and the feeling of being loved by someone without considering the risks involved. They are sexually, emotionally, and socially inexperienced, and are often denied the information, guidance, skills, and services they need to protect themselves. Young people often do not believe that they are vulnerable to HIV and other threats to their health and survival. They more readily put themselves at risk of contracting HIV than do adults (UNAIDS, 1999b). Although many know about HIV and how to prevent it, and may even think their friends are at risk, they often believe that they, themselves, are unlikely to be infected (Maswanya et al., 1999). Young people often define the trustworthiness of a prospective partner by the opinions of family and friends and his or her ability to fulfill emotional and physical needs, rather than trying to learn about a partner’s sexual history. The very nature of adolescent relationships increases their risk of HIV infection. In some countries, young people may enter a series of short-term sexual relationships. Because they are faithful to their current partners, they do not consider themselves at risk of HIV infection and rarely use condoms. They assume that partners are HIV-negative until suspected otherwise and when trust within the partnership is broken, they often terminate the relationship and look for another intimate partner immediately, rather than adopting risk-reducing methods such as using condoms (Longfield et al., 2002) or abstaining. In surveyed countries in Africa, the percentage of unmarried girls between 15 and 19 years of age, who used condoms
112 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
during their most recent sexual encounter ranged from 2 percent to 18 percent. Reasons for non-use of condoms included poor access, expense, and personal barriers such as shyness about buying condoms and difficulty discussing use with partners (Kiragu, 2001). On the other hand, others believe there is nothing they can do to prevent infection and are powerless and fatalistic about HIV. Unfortunately, it is often difficult for adults to communicate with and influence young people who are exploring their own independence. Peers’ opinions and actions usually carry more weight in influencing young people’s behavior than those of their parents and elders in the community. Their friends become important sources of acceptance and self-esteem and such peer pressure propels young people into risk-taking behavior such as unprotected sex, alcohol, and drug use, as well as violence. Young people are also heavily influenced by advertising and media images that typically idealize sexuality—often without protection. The risk of infection is compounded by poverty, lack of education, and unemployment, especially for young women because of their low status in society. Demographic and health survey data indicate that girls who complete some secondary education are more likely than those who do not, to delay the onset of sex and to use contraceptive methods, including condoms. Yet, in most parts of the developing world, few women attend secondary school. In poor communities, many young women enter sexual relationships with older men (who are more likely to be HIV-positive) in exchange for gifts, school marks or fees, clothing or food, or other transactions they believe will increase their status among peers (Luke and Kurz, 2002; PRB, 2001). In sexual relationships of this sort, young women have little power to demand condom use. In some countries in Africa, many young women have two types of boyfriends—those who can help support their material needs and those with whom they are emotionally or romantically involved.
Formative Research The formative research questions for a program for young people include the following: l l l l
l l
What channels of communication do different categories of young people access most? What media or channels would influence them most on sexual and reproductive health matters? How do parents, family, and community relate to young people on such matters? What are the opinions of community gatekeepers on these matters? What has been the experience with sex education or family life education in the school system? What level of investment over what period of time would be required to make this effective? What are the attitudes of health providers on delivering STI services, VCT, sexuality and pregnancy counseling, and related services to young, unmarried people? What other community-based channels such as youth associations and clubs could be tapped to link with other communication strategies?
Reaching Special Audiences 113
Strategic Approaches Young people constitute a diverse audience that can be segmented in a number of ways: l l l l l l l l
age marital status education and present schooling status socio-economic status ethnic/cultural background urban or rural residence sexual activity—active and inactive sexual preference
The strategic approach that will work best depends on the audience segment a program intends to reach. Each of these audience segments will require different approaches and channels. Programs for young people are most effective when they employ a tiered approach, reaching more than one segment, each with its own tailored strategy. Strategic communication approaches for young people include: Entertainment–Education: Music and music videos, educational videos, sports, television and radio programs, and community-based entertainment channels are particularly popular with young people. They make excellent vehicles for HIV/AIDS prevention programs through use of drama, public service announcements, variety shows, and quiz and game shows. Throughout the world, young people are the largest consumers of such entertainment formats. Many programs have tapped into this popularity to reach young people with HIV/AIDS information and motivation to adopt healthy behaviors and avoid risk. Entertainment– Education can also be used to direct young people to services. For example, a long-running radio program for young people in Kampala, Uganda, is responsible for growing numbers of clients attending the Naguru Teenage Centre for RH services and VCT testing (Juma et al., 2001) (See Chapter 6 for a more complete discussion of Entertainment–Education techniques). Youth Newspapers, Magazines, and R adio Magazines: In many countries, the HIV/AIDS Radio pandemic has led to the production and distribution of special newspapers or magazines aimed at young people. For example, Straight Talk, a Ugandan organization for young people, produces monthly newsletters and weekly radio programs on safer sex, reproductive health issues, and life skills education. Newsletters are distributed to thousands of primary and secondary schools in the country, and these enjoy a wide readership among young people and their teachers. Thousands of young people have now formed Straight Talk clubs where they discuss issues in the newsletters and listen to the radio programs together. In Tanzania, a commercial magazine called Femina addresses reproductive health issues through a mixture of articles, some on general interest issues and news, and youth-focused advertising. The idea is to attract young readers to consider issues and protection from HIV through a vehicle that they would love to read for entertainment purposes.
114 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Box 4-1: Examples for Entertainment–Education Ghana: “Speak Easy” Youth Radio: The award-winning youth radio magazine show, “Speak Easy,”— aired weekly in 1999 on the most popular FM station in Accra. Developed by Ghana Social Marketing Foundation and Johns Hopkins’ CCP, the one-hour show combined a serial radio drama with a live discussion by a youth audience in the studio. A call-in line motivated participation directly from the listening audience. A major objective was to open dialogue and discussion among youth on reproductive health issues, especially HIV and AIDS. Themes such as parent–child communication and peer pressure were most popular among young people. Many callers expressed the desire that the drama be made into a TV show, which was done the following year. Launched in 2001, “Things We Do for Love” is a TV serial drama in Ghana for young people that addresses the pressures and problems of adolescence (e.g., HIV and AIDS, teen pregnancy, condom use, and rape). After every six episodes, a discussion segment with a live audience allows viewers to ask questions and make contributions.
Hotlines and Computer Counseling: In a number of places, organizations have established telephone hotlines or “helplines” with telephone counselors who have been trained to talk to young people about sex and reproductive health topics. Computerized counseling systems allow young people to explore the issues using a completely anonymous question–answer system. However, such systems are less immediate and personal than live counselors and cannot deal well with young people in crisis situations. Peer Education: Many strategies involve training and supervising peer educators. These young people are trained to discuss sexual and reproductive health topics with their peers, including advocacy for safer and more responsible sexual behavior. Most young people trust trained peer educators because they feel such counselors have greater empathy and can “speak their own language.” Life Skills Approaches In and Out of School: Schools are an ideal place to reach large numbers of young people with reproductive health education, whether during school hours or through school clubs as extracurricular or community-based activities. Such programs should begin as early as possible in primary school before children have begun to drop out. In many countries, ministries of education have integrated family life education or life skills education into primary and secondary school curricula. In recent years, the life skills approach has become more popular because of teachers’ and parents’ resistance to teaching curricula labeled “sex,” “family life,” or “reproductive health” education (UNICEF-UNAIDS-WHO, 2001). Life skills are described in various ways but one definition involves the classification in Figure 4-1. Such approaches require pre-service or in-service training for teachers on both the content and methodology, which must be interactive and participatory rather than informational and didactic. In other words, teachers must become interactive communicators. It is not easy to transform a traditional teacher into a life skills facilitator. To be most effective, life skills training should involve the students’ parents and community so that skills introduced in the classroom are supported and reinforced at home (Carnegie and Weisen, 2000; Horizons, 2001a; UNICEF, 2002a; USAID, 2002b).
Reaching Special Audiences 115 Figure 4-1: Model Illustrating the Interdependence of Life Skills
Source: Carnegie and Birrell Weisen, 2000
Life skills approaches can also be delivered through youth clubs, either with adult facilitators or through peer education. Life skills approaches can also be the basis of the design of media initiatives that rely on a synergistic combination of mass media and group processes at the community level (see Bangladesh ARH case study and case study on Sara Communication Initiative). Parent–Child Communication: Research in the United States has shown that children who maintain good relationships and communicate freely with their parents are less likely to engage in high-risk practices such as alcohol abuse, drug use, and early sex. Some programs in developing countries are beginning to work with parents to encourage them to take responsibility for educating their adolescents about sex and reproductive health in an effective, sympathetic manner. For example, the Delivery of Improved Services for Health project in Uganda developed a newsletter and radio programs for parents about how to discuss sexual and reproductive health issues with their children, and it directed parents to church groups that had parent education classes (Lewicky et al., 1998; Palmer, 2002). However, in many cultures, usually older siblings, aunts, and uncles, rather than parents, educate children on sexual issues. Programmers should be guided by formative research on this matter to find the right mentor for such education. In addition to communication channels and methods, there are a number of systems interventions that should be well-linked to strategic communication interventions.
116 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Adolescent-friendly Services: Whenever possible, communication programs should be linked to adolescent-friendly health and social services. There are different models of adolescentfriendly health services: stand-alone youth clinics, separate services and spaces for young people within regular health facilities that are offered at any time, or regular reproductive health services offered to young people on specific days of the week or hours of the day. Often these health services attract young people with recreational activities, indoor games, or video shows. Health workers receive training to provide information and services that are relevant to young people in a friendly manner without judgment or condemnation. In many countries, family planning associations are establishing adolescent-friendly services by training their service providers or hiring younger nurses and midwives. Clinics offer contraception including condoms, antenatal care services, STI treatment, VCT, and overall sexual and reproductive health counseling, including abortion and post-abortion counseling where legal. Youth Clubs and Centers: A number of community-based programs have established youth clubs or drop-in centers where young people can meet and interact. These places are considered to be relatively safe and supportive environments. Usually, such centers attract clientele with indoor and outdoor games, video shows, and other activities. The theory behind such centers is that they provide activities that are socially stimulating. They foster the development of positive relationships with peers, but recreational time is supervised, thus reducing the chances of casual and unsafe sex, as well as other risk behaviors, such as smoking, alcohol consumption, and substance abuse. Often such centers also organize training in life skills and livelihood skills. Some provide condoms or other reproductive health services. In Malawi, Africare has worked with communities in several districts to establish drop-in centers. Young people who use the centers have established clubs and drama groups that entertain and educate the surrounding communities on a variety of health issues, including HIV/AIDS prevention. Sometimes schools or communities start anti-AIDS clubs as extracurricular activities such as Sara life skills clubs (see Sara case study) or Straight Talk clubs in Uganda. A countrywide association such as Boy or Girl Scouts or Guides may take the lead. Income Generation and V ocational Skills T raining: A number of programs for young Vocational Training: people involve training in vocational skills or establishing income generation activities. In theory, these activities reduce the likelihood that young women will have transactional sex. Also, earning a living and being employed helps build self-esteem and greater confidence to resist peer pressure to engage in risky practices. Such activities do not constitute a communication approach per se, but may be incorporated in some of the approaches mentioned here.
Key Issues to Communicate The following are some key objectives that communication programs for young people may seek to achieve:
Reaching Special Audiences 117 l l l l l l l l l l l l l
Motivate young people to delay sexual debut as long as possible by resisting peer pressure or other influences to begin sexual activity early. Educate youngsters that loss of virginity does not mean it is impossible to abstain again. Encourage young people to abstain from multiple sexual relationships. Make condom use valued and expected in any sexual relationship. Increase the perception of their personal risk of HIV/AIDS and the ability to talk to others about sexual issues. Build the confidence of parents (or other trusted adults) and children to discuss sexual issues with one another. Encourage young people to make personal risk-reduction plans and to stick to them. Facilitate life skill competencies and communicate using role models that demonstrate these. Educate young people that HIV can infect anyone and that one cannot tell who is infected by the way they look. Encourage young people to continue schooling as long as possible. Inform them that STIs facilitate the transmission of HIV. Encourage young people to access friendly health services, including STI counseling and treatment, VCT, and condoms. Encourage young people to access friendly social and recreation services and to partake in sports.
Challenges and Lessons Learned Segmentation: Young people are not a homogeneous group. It is impossible to find one effective medium to reach all, even in a particular culture. Their differences can be determined by age, rate of physical and emotional development, levels of literacy, and relationship to family, peers, and mentors, among others. Their ambitions and other motivations also differ greatly, so it is impossible to address all young people with the same strategic approach. Mass Media: Mass media can play a critical role in BCC programs for young people. Around the world, access to radio, television, films, and videos is growing rapidly. Most surveys of TV/video viewership indicate that 15 to 20-year-olds watch these in the greatest numbers. These media are very influential. For example, young people across the African continent watch the videos of various rap musicians and, subsequently, emulate their behaviors and dress. Such media can be harnessed for positive social change and may be the single best and most economical way to influence large numbers of young people. On the other hand, more and more young people are exposed to a brand of international youth culture in the form of music, with explicit sexual lyrics, and music videos that often suggest that casual sexual activity is a worldwide norm. With satellite television, cables, and dishes, it has become more difficult to segment young audiences for different programs and messages. When condom promotion is designed to reach those already sexually active, often through a popular youth personality or star, those who are not yet sexually active may
118 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
receive the message that premarital sex is the social norm for those who are “cool.” This fact requires youth programmers to rethink their program formats and messages to ensure that they deliver prevention (e.g., “ABC”) messages in a balanced way. This is possible to do, as has been shown in the Zambian case study at the end of Chapter 3. Questions About Negative Effects: As noted, some fear that educating young people on sexual issues, even in a balanced way, will have negative outcomes. However, it has been shown that properly designed reproductive health education programs do not lead young people to have casual sex. Magnani and Karim (2002) identified 41 studies of such programs around the world. They found that more than half of these programs were school-based, though others were community-based or worked through the mass media, workplace, or health facilities. Almost all resulted in improved knowledge and attitudes, and many produced an increase in contraceptive use. Fewer programs had a demonstrable impact on either sexual initiation or number of sexual partners. For each of these two outcomes, only seven programs showed a significant impact. However, the researchers found that where there were results, they were always in the direction of reduced sexual risk-taking. Children will receive sex education from one source or another. They are bombarded by negative adult behavior models through cinema, television, and advertisements, and “silence and evasiveness are just as powerful teachers as discussion of the facts” (McNab, 1981). Going to Scale with P eer Education and Life Skills: Face-to-face interventions such as Peer peer education programs (see Chapter 6) and life skills programs are potentially effective among those reached, but they are costly and difficult to develop, manage, and maintain at a large scale. With HIV/AIDS prevalence reaching the magnitude it has in many regions, interventions need to be scaled up. Achieving high quality face-to-face interventions at a large scale requires tremendous human and financial resources that normally are beyond the means of any individual program. Small-scale efforts that are not sustained or integrated into the system risk having little or no effect (Kinsman et al., 1999). School-based programs have strong potential. When teachers are trained and used as role models, they can effectively reach large numbers of young people. They can also serve as effective catalysts for change. However, teachers who engage in risky sexual behavior with their students put programs in jeopardy. Such teachers can no longer be viewed as credible authorities, nor can they command the respect of their students and the communities they serve. Participation of Y oung P eople: Programs should focus on the participation of young people Young People: in design and implementation. Young people usually understand what their needs are and how they should be addressed. They can motivate their peers more effectively than anyone else. By knowing what will have optimal impact, youth-led NGOs can catalyze young people in all areas, personally and programmatically. Young people can also advocate for youthcentered programs in government and other institutions. In order to make such programs even more successful, young people need to strengthen their skills in management, budgeting, finance, and report writing. Young people are generally eager to learn such things. Youth-led efforts can translate into better youth-focused programing in both NGO and government channels and should be promoted (Golombek, 2002).
Reaching Special Audiences 119 Box 4-2: Elements of Successful Sexuality Education P rograms Programs Content l l l l
Give clear, consistent messages based on accurate information. Focus on reducing sexual behaviors that lead to unintended pregnancies and STIs/HIV. Be specific to age and culture. Have a theoretical framework proven to affect behavior.
Program Design l l l
Include methods that involve students, are skill-based, and address social pressures. Conduct sessions that are of sufficient length. Motivate and train teachers to participate.
Source: Adapted from Kirby, 2001
Youth-F riendly Health Services: The need for youth-friendly services is evident. However, outh-Friendly currently, these services are not widely available and more advocacy is needed for them. Programs require special emphasis to ensure they have clear and consistent messages and that there are relevant links to referral services, where appropriate. Rural areas are often hard to reach, but with a combination of personnel trained in providing youth-friendly health services, quality materials, and effective use of the mass media, young people will have access to the information and services they need to reduce their risk of HIV infection. Faith-Based Initiatives: In many countries, churches or other faith-based institutions serve as a meeting place for young people. Faith-based leaders and organizations need to be involved as much as possible. Providing religious leaders with statistics and case examples can be useful in convincing them of the need for sexual and reproductive health education and that such information does not lead to promiscuity, as noted. Faith-based groups can incorporate messages about risk reduction into the work of youth groups. It has been demonstrated that adolescents who have spiritual beliefs are less likely to initiate early sexual intercourse (WHO, 2001). In Uganda, adolescent girls have used their chosen label of being “born again” as protection from undesired male advances (Wimberley, 1994). Involving PLHA: PLHA can play a critical role in protecting the lives of young people. It is important for young people to appreciate that the risk of HIV infection is real. It has been documented that young people who are involved in providing care and support for PLHA are less likely to engage in risky behavior and less likely to stigmatize PLHA (Horizons, 2001a). R ole Models and Mentors: Young people need adults to model good behavior and to talk to them about values, relationships, and sexuality. They need adults with whom they can talk: people who are knowledgeable and confident and able to answer questions. These adults should see the potential in young people, not just the problems. We can find such adults in many places—at school, at church, in the workplace, at home, and in their extended family. These adults strive to understand young people and the realities they live in, and not preach to them. They should see young people as the hope for the future with great potential.
120 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Capacity-building of Y oung P eople: In the process of developing and implementing programs Young People: for young people, their capacity should be built through involvement in programs. They can develop skills in areas such as strategic thinking, management, planning, budgeting, and financial accountability. With such skills, they can further develop in many areas. Those involved in peer education gain specific skills in communication, knowledge in sexual and reproductive health, as well as overall adolescent health and development. When these young people move on to other occupations, they carry these skills and this knowledge with them. Adult members of the communities that support programs for young people also gain personally. Parents, teachers, religious leaders, and service providers gain skills in communication, as well as critical knowledge that they can use to reduce their own risk of HIV infection. Many of these adults become role models for young people and they can continue these informal relationships throughout their lives. Linkage to Y outh Livelihood: The needs of young people are diverse. Often what appears to Youth be a health problem is rooted in something deeper. While many young people are motivated to participate in programs and adopt healthier behaviors, they may be prevented from doing so because of economic or social factors. For example, a young person may want to be a volunteer peer educator, but may have family pressure to bring in an income. Young people often face strong social pressure: for boys the pressure to appear to “be a man” and for girls the pressure to be seen as “trendy” and to have nice things such as cosmetics, clothes, or a cell phone. Some just cannot see that life holds anything more for them than these immediate pleasures that are available in exchange for sex. Others, even more desperate, are forced to engage in risky sexual behavior for their own and their families’ survival. Linkage with livelihood programs can take place in different ways. For instance, health communicators and educators can deliver HIV/AIDS education to livelihood programs or act as counselors and referral points for AIDS-affected youth. It is not necessary or desirable for every organization to become involved in livelihood skills development, for this requires special expertise (In Focus, 2001). 4-3: T ips for Success in W orking with Y oung P eople Tips Working Young People l l l
l l
Start programs with as young an age group as possible, phasing in issues in an age-appropriate and culturally acceptable manner. Know the percentage of young people who have early sexual activity and the extent of their knowledge on sexuality, sexual and reproductive health, SRH, and HIV/AIDS. Segment your audience, be clear about the communication objectives for each segment, and where best to reach them. A well-designed, balanced approach to prevention messaging (e.g., the prevention “ABCs”) is required. Programs need to promote condom use in a targeted way to those who are sexually active. Involve young people in all aspects of the program from planning, through implementation, monitoring, and evaluation. Involve young people more deeply in accurately assessing their own personal risk of HIV infection. Message-based approaches are very limited. Behavior change is much easier to bring about when people make their own decisions, based on their own analysis. Skill-based approaches reinforce such development. (Box 4-3 contd.)
Reaching Special Audiences 121 (Box 4-3 contd.) l l l l l l
Strengthen peer group systems by age and gender. Involve parents and community gatekeepers in the process as early as possible. Involve media, religious, educational, and health service gatekeepers in the process, at an appropriate stage. Integrate issues of gender equity and de-stigmatization into prevention and care programs for young people. Ensure that prevention messages are linked to accessible services, including counseling, information, and health services. Advocate for more and better services for young people. Create better opportunities to reach young people through diverse channels: schools, clinics, churches, youth centers, and the mass media.
Case Study: Communication for Social Norm Change in Adolescent Reproductive Health in Bangladesh Background: In 1999, a coalition of partners called the “Adolescent Reproductive Health Working Group,” with technical support from Focus on Young Adults, the Bangladesh Center for Communication Programs and Johns Hopkins’ CCP, began an innovative communication program, funded by USAID and, more recently, UNICEF. Adolescents from ages 10 to 19 years constitute 25 percent of the population of Bangladesh’s 130 million people. In Bangladesh, society gives little recognition to the fact that adolescence is a unique period of life. Neither the public health nor the education system fully address adolescents’ problems, such as early marriage, early pregnancy; maternal morbidity, mortality, and malnutrition; STI/HIV transmission; and, increasingly, sexual abuse and substance use. Most adolescents face anxiety and mental stress from the time of changes in puberty because such subjects are normally taboo, even between parent and child. This program illustrates a holistic approach to keeping HIV infection low in a very low prevalence country. The rate of infection among IDUs is 4 percent, while among FSWs it remains less than 0.5 percent, and HIV is not measurable in the general population, but there is growing evidence of increasing STI rates and other reproductive health problems among adolescents. Audiences and Strategy: Following a detailed baseline study, the project team designed and implemented a comprehensive communication package consisting of question–answer booklets based on what adolescents said they wanted to know. The four booklets cover (i) physical and emotional changes in puberty, (ii) sexual attraction, delay, and conception, (iii) preventing risks such as teenage pregnancy, early marriage, and STIs/HIV, and (iv) marriage and family health. Accompanying the booklets are a set of entertaining videos that were produced through participatory, life skills workshops with adolescents. The videos reflect the adolescents’ own thoughts, feelings, and solutions to their problems, as well as comments from parents and
122 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
service providers. Comic animation and songs by teenagers on the themes make the videos lively and engaging. A third part of the package is life skills manuals that guide facilitators through participatory processes with adolescents. The programmatic tools are branded as the “Know Yourself” communication toolkit and are tied to radio and television magazine shows and a comic book series. Adolescent producers and spokespersons produce the TV and radio components that show adolescents searching for and finding solutions to their problems through field interviews, success stories, drama, song and video/audio clips, and panel discussions with experts. A comic book series is also being produced with a great deal of adolescent input through story-writing workshops and formative research. Comic books serve as an alternative media for communicating sensitive issues in an entertaining and culturally acceptable way. The unique feature of this well-researched communication package is that various government, NGO, and UN partners have adopted it as a common toolkit for social mobilization on adolescent reproductive health issues. The strategy recognizes that adolescents need information, need to be motivated to act, and require psychosocial skills, such as critical thinking and negotiation, to develop positive behavioral outcomes. They also need an enabling environment to foster and sustain positive change. Likewise, those parents and community members become a part of the enabling environment. The Working Group decided that rather than wait for policy change and the establishment of services, it would follow a demand-driven approach through strategic communication, thereby gradually influencing social norms concerning adolescent reproductive health, as well as policy on health and educational service delivery. Source: Health Communication Partnership, 2003d
Focusing on Gender: Reaching Women and Girls, Men and Boys Rationale Of the estimated 40 million people living with HIV/AIDS at the end of 2001, men and women accounted for 18.5 million each, while 3 million children were infected (UNAIDS, 2002a). However, in sub-Saharan Africa, there were an estimated 15 million women compared to 11 million men living with the disease. Why are there such differences and how does gender relate to acquiring HIV? One of the fundamental causes of HIV/AIDS is gender inequity, especially within contexts of poverty and income disparity (Long and Ankrah, 1996; SIDA, 1998). In most countries where the HIV/AIDS epidemic rages, women and girls are especially vulnerable. As of December 2001, among 15 to 24-year-olds in sub-Saharan Africa, twice as many females (5.7 million) as males (2.8 million) were living with HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS, 2001a). In Eastern and Southern Africa, young women between 15 to 24 years of age are up to six times
Reaching Special Audiences 123
Plate 4-2: Comic book series on Adolescent R eproductive Health in Bangladesh dealing with HIV/AIDS Reproductive and many related subjects. (Credit: AV Com/BCCP)
more likely to be infected than adolescent males of the same age group (UNAIDS, 2000d). In general, females are infected in their teens and early twenties, whereas males reach similar levels in their mid-twenties to mid-thirties. One reason given for earlier infection in females is that the female reproductive tract is more vulnerable to HIV than that of males (Watstein and Laurich, 1991), so it is easier for men to infect women than vice versa. Second, in parts of sub-Saharan Africa and Asia, teenage girls usually have sex with or marry older males, rather than their own age mates. Third, gender disparity exists in many parts of the developing world in terms of access to education (especially retention in higher-level education), health, and other social service facilities. But above all, girls and women in these regions are much more vulnerable to HIV due to socio-cultural conditioning beginning at an early age. In many parts of Africa and Asia, girls have fewer opportunities than do boys in almost all endeavors. Traditionally, their primary role is seen to be future child-bearers and nurturers. At an early age, girls often learn to take subservient roles and, as they grow older, they lack basic psychosocial skills such as the ability to communicate assertively, to think critically and creatively, to make decisions and negotiate, to solve problems in social relationships, to resist pressure, and to cope with emotions and conflict (Carnegie and Weisen, 2000). The gender-based socialization of boys and girls continues to create power dynamics in sexual relationships that put women at a disadvantage (Population Council, 2001). Girls
124 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
usually enter relationships with the opposite sex as unequal partners. As such, they are often unable to negotiate safe sex or to avoid sexual abuse and exploitation. They also have less access to condoms, even if they are available, and are therefore likely to leave decisions about their use to their male partners. Girls in Africa, looking for ways out of poverty, or more precisely, a means of paying their school fees, acquiring clothes, jewelry and makeup, or to travel, are often courted by older men or “sugar daddies” who give such gifts in exchange for sex. Such “transactional sex” is very common in many countries and is a prime reason for the spread of HIV to young women. In parts of Africa and Asia, some men falsely believe that having sex with a virgin or younger “clean” girl can act as a cure for HIV/AIDS. Many young girls have been infected as a result of such misinformed and desperate searches for a cure. Globally, violence against women is an important factor in HIV transmission (WHO, 2000a), including physical violence from intimate partners and harmful traditional practices such as female genital cutting (Morison et al., 2001), forced or coercive sex, forced prostitution, and trafficking. In a study in India, for example, men who had experienced extramarital sex were 6.2 times more likely to abuse their wives than men who were faithful (Martin et al., 1999). In a sample of 122 young men in South Africa, 19 reported having participated in gang rape. In South Asia, deep-rooted gender discrimination, lack of female education, poverty, and lack of opportunities in rural areas are manifested in the trafficking of young girls into prostitution in cities or neighboring countries. The trafficking of Nepali girls has been a special focus of investigation. Rates of HIV infection among young sex workers in urban areas range from 17 percent in Nepal (UNAIDS, 2000d) to as high as 72 percent in Mumbai, India (Salunke et al., 1998). Trafficked girls and women are victims of a social system that puts little value on their lives. If they attempt to return to their home communities, they often face extreme stigmatization and discrimination. However, married women in apparently stable relationships are also in great danger in many parts of the world because their husbands are the clients of sex workers or have other semi-permanent sexual relationships. Some cultures consider this behavior to be the norm. For instance, in parts of Southern Africa, men with livestock have long migrated between their summer and winter pastures and jobs, setting up house with a different wife in each location. Overall economic development and the building of good roads in the second half of the twentieth century made such mobile lifestyles even more possible and exacerbated the transmission of HIV in the 1980s and 1990s. In many parts of the world, mobile men such as truck drivers or sailors may have one known family but a number of semi-permanent relationships with women on their regular routes. With HIV/AIDS, such extramarital relationships put wives in danger. Gender issues need to be addressed in HIV/AIDS care and support programs. Women and girls usually play the main family role in caring for the sick, including those who have AIDS-related infections and illnesses. This situation further reduces their opportunities for education and development. Communicators should affect the lives of girls and women in a positive manner by analyzing and working towards changes in both the socially-prescribed gender division of labor and unequal power relationships between men and women. However, it is not possible to change the situation for girls and women without reaching boys and men. “Part of the effort to curb the AIDS epidemic must include challenging
Reaching Special Audiences 125
negative beliefs and behaviors, including the way men view risk and how boys are socialized to become men. Men are expected to be strong, robust, and virile—but these very expectations may translate into behaviors that can endanger both men and their partners” (Piot, 2000). Men face pressures from society to live up to long-standing gender roles. Cultures the world over tend to associate manhood with physical strength and aggressive behavior, bravery, psychological strength and suppression of sympathetic emotions, risk-taking, adventure, and independence. Men are influenced by social pressures that encourage them to prove their sexual prowess, and they may believe that real men take risks, do not wear condoms, nor get sick (Panos, 1998). Men, worldwide, tend to have more sex partners, including extramarital partners, than women, thereby increasing their own and their partners’ risk of contracting HIV. They are also more likely to purchase sex and to initiate violence with their sexual partners (Scalway, 2002b; UNAIDS/Panos, 2001). They generally have more power in sexual relations and decide when, how often, and where sex should take place, as well as whether or not a condom will be used. Young men, in particular, run increasingly high risks of HIV infection, as their age of sexual debut is decreasing in many countries (Scalway, 2002b). The secrecy, stigma, and shame associated with HIV that often discourage men from learning about their HIV status further exacerbate this situation. Although men usually know more about STIs and how to protect themselves from AIDS than women (United Nations, 2002), they are, in general, less likely than women to seek medical attention when they are ill, which may also prevent them from knowing if they are infected (Piot, 2000). Men also suffer from their “machismo.” The gender-defined roles and dominating behaviors expected of them in many societies may block their potential to develop into mature human beings. This leads them to occupations in which they may not be satisfied or which put them at risk. They may feel psychological pressure to succeed and fulfill family expectations, sometimes also resulting in violence against women, often exacerbated by alcohol or drug abuse. Their “machismo” concept also may be a factor in producing large families, which they then find difficult to support, or in having multiple sexual partners, putting both them and their spouses at risk. Programs to tackle “machismo” (see Box 4-4) are few and far between or have been poorly evaluated.
Formative Research Many of the formative research questions in Chapter 3 will apply, since men, women, boys, and girls constitute the general population. However, a gender-based analysis requires that we ask a specific set of questions. The following list is by no means exhaustive but indicates what could be included: l
What differential attitudes and practices are manifested in the affected communities regarding the way boys and girls are brought up and treated in the home (e.g., gender-based decisions on involvement in domestic work and caring for siblings and the ill)?
126 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Box 4-4: “Men Aren’t from Mars”: Unlearning Machismo in L atin America Latin The Catholic Institute for International Relations (CIIR) promotes equality between men and women throughout its programs. Its key aims are to increase women’s participation, particularly in strategic civil and political leadership positions; promote greater awareness about women’s human rights among men and women; and ensure that the priorities and activities of partner organizations reflect greater knowledge about both the causes of and need to reduce gender violence, with a particular focus on masculinity. An example of this work is a popular education project in Latin America that aims to help reduce violence against women by prompting changes in men’s attitudes and behavior. The program consists of a series of workshops run by trainers in the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Haiti, Honduras, and Peru. The project’s aim is that partners, daughters, girlfriends, mothers, and sisters of the men taking part should become less subject to violent or manipulative behavior. The initiative has the following components: l
l
l
Training on Gender iolence: Using a popular education methodology, Gender,, Masculinity Masculinity,, and V Violence: men take part in a series of workshops on gender, masculinity, and violence designed not only to increase their knowledge of the issues but also to challenge and change attitudes and behavior. Training of T rainers: This training equips participants with the tools to duplicate the Trainers: workshop with other men and thus increase the project’s impact. Development workers are also encouraged to form local groups to replicate the methodology and continue the dialogue in their communities. A workbook, El Significado de Ser Hombre, has been produced to support this process. Information Campaign: Through the workshops, links are cultivated with a wide range of local organizations and efforts are made to inform women’s organizations about related events.
Interregional and cross-regional learning are crucial to this project, and networks in which the partner organizations and CIIR are involved are important in disseminating experiences. Source: CIIR, n.d.
l l l l
l l l
What are the school enrollment, retention, and completion rates for boys and girls? If there are differences, why is this so? Is there any difference in health and social services access between males and females? If so, why? What is the average age of marriage for men and women, and if there is a substantial gap, what are the reasons? To what extent are females involved in choices regarding their own future, such as education and occupation, family planning methods, the decision to get married, and choice of husband? What is the age of sexual debut? Is intergenerational sex practiced? To what degree? Is there trafficking and other forms of violence against women, and if so, what factors reinforce this kind of behavior?
Reaching Special Audiences 127 l l l l
l l
What are the typical power dynamics in both premarital and marital relationships and what are the reasons for this? How do these dynamics affect sexual behavior? Do women control any component of the family income and does this affect sexual power dynamics? How mobile are men compared to women, and how does this affect their sexual behavior? How do men perceive themselves and their gender-determined roles and how does this affect their potential? Is there a “machismo” culture and how are the lives of men affected by this? Are there positive role models in the community or society that can be used to communicate equity in male–female relationships? What are the channels for reaching men and women? Are they separate or the same and how can they be tapped effectively?
Strategic Approaches A key challenge is to work in and with cultures that often send both positive and negative gender-related message to boys and girls from an early age. Strategic communication is instrumental in changing girls’ self-awareness and skills to delay sexual debut, abstain, or use condoms. Likewise, communication has a strong role to play in shaping the behavior of boys towards girls, starting at an early age; or in involving mature men in becoming more caring and understanding in their roles as boyfriends, husbands, and fathers. Programs should also address the longer-term goal of persuading men and women to reassess traditional concepts of masculinity and femininity and the prescribed roles that accelerate the spread of HIV. In addition, advocacy and communication can also be instrumental in trying to advance new gender policies and overall social norms. However, to be realistic, such changes will take time, and communication alone cannot address deep seated gender inequity. Effective HIV/AIDS communication may involve the use of a number of channels. The choice of channels needs to be informed by appropriate formative research, including a thorough review of the access of females and males to each channel and the channel’s appropriateness for delivering reproductive health information. Mass Media: The media play a significant role in shaping and influencing social norms, including gender roles and perspectives. Not only do men make decisions that affect their families’ lives, but their decisions dominate the workplace and political and social arenas. Their thoughts and words on these matters are carried to people through the mass media. Men, especially heads of state, as well as leaders in the religious community and the private sector, need to be encouraged to speak out and lead by example. Likewise, women leaders can play an important role, such as the First Ladies of Africa who recently formed a movement against HIV/AIDS. Radio, TV, and newspapers can cover events to which they lend their prestige and power. Mass media reflect images of masculinity that many young men imitate. HIV/AIDS prevention programs use media effectively when they disseminate images and story lines of men
128 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
who treat women and girls with respect. Media also provide HIV/AIDS prevention information on which both males and females can act and share with friends. Radio can greatly increase young people’s information-seeking behavior, as found in the Kenya Youth Variety Show (Odallo, 1997). This radio call-in program, the first of its kind in Kenya, attracted an audience of more than 3.3 million adolescents, making it a major source of information and referrals to clinics. The program provided an opportunity to impart information and positive role models. Peer Education: People are influenced by those who have the most in common with them, especially people of the same age and sex. Peer educators provide information in schools, bars, sports groups, religious groups, and community gathering places. They are often selected by fellow peers and must be equipped with knowledge and interpersonal communication skills related to HIV/AIDS prevention, violence reduction, and sexuality. Peer education programs have been found to reduce the incidence of HIV by reducing risk-taking behavior among young people and the educators themselves (Kiragu, 2001). Participatory articipatory,, Community-based Methods: Community-based programs use a variety of participatory learning approaches, including local theater and song, videos, and other external communication tools. Gender analysis should influence the methods to be used (See example in Box 4-5). Box 4-5: Stepping Stones Approach The Stepping Stones Approach, used by over 2,000 organizations in 104 countries, was first developed in Uganda in the mid-1990s. It recognizes that the widespread “ABC” approach often fails to take into account that gender power relations are the main factor in such decisions. Girls and women seldom have the life skills needed to bring about real and sustainable behavior change. Stepping Stones training aims to improve relations between men and women, young and old, and to increase the likelihood of changes in attitudes and behavior, especially those that directly concern HIV/ AIDS prevention and care. The program involves a community-based, peer group approach, and uses learning methods such as drawing, mime, role-play, drama, and song. The methods are not literacy-dependent, and they enable community members to discover new ways of thinking and feeling, to look at problems through a “gender lens,” and to find solutions for them together. In some programs, as many as 18 community sessions are held in one week, involving men, women, boys, and girls. These sessions include developing cooperation and communication skills; exploring facts and feelings about relationships, HIV and AIDS, and safer sex; understanding what influences people to behave in the way they do; and exploring how to practice and sustain behavior change. This approach depends on the recruitment and training of male and female facilitators with experience in the use of participatory methods, gender analysis and concepts, HIV/AIDS/STI prevention and care, the ability to deal with interpersonal conflict, and to counsel individuals when required. The process also requires a good deal of community “buy in,” usually through convincing male decision-makers to become involved and let others participate. Source: Save the Children, 2002a
School-based Channels: In-school adolescents constitute a captive, easy-to-reach audience for behavior programs. The extent to which schools are an appropriate and cost-effective
Reaching Special Audiences 129
avenue for imparting HIV/AIDS education for boys and girls depends on many factors such as the degree of support from the school system, parents and community; the strength of the syllabus; and the quality of teachers. However, developing and maintaining such systems in resource-poor environments has proven difficult. Successful in-school programs are founded on a thorough gender analysis and have as one of their main objectives, positive modeling of gender relationships beginning at an early age. Countries such as Canada, Sweden, and France, which have comprehensive curricula covering a wide range of topics and options for safe sexual behavior, have the lowest teenage pregnancy and STI rates amongst young people (UNAIDS, 2002a). R ole Modeling through Sports Channels: Young men observe, respect, and often emulate the behavior of their favorite sports heroes who can serve as role models. The Caring Understanding Partners (CUP) Program (JHU/CCP, 2002c; JHU/CCP/CECAFA, 1999) involves the training of soccer players and coaches to serve as spokespersons for health topics, including HIV/AIDS. Fans and communities, in turn, receive messages that motivate them to learn more about how to protect themselves and their families against HIV/AIDS. This comes from sports heroes who speak on topics such as the advantages of delaying or abstaining from sex, or why it is really smart to use condoms consistently. The strategy is based on the idea that high-profile, male athletes can help break through barriers encountered in reaching men and encourage them to seek help for health problems, take stock of their own risk behaviors, and share responsibility on reproductive health matters, including the use of condoms. Research has found that when adolescent boys find positive role models, they are less violent, more respectful of girls and women, and more likely to take responsibility for contraception as they become sexually active (Barket and Loewenstein, 1996). Some would argue that sports activities not only enhance physical fitness and life skills, they also keep young men away from risky situations and allow them to “develop and express their masculinity” in healthy ways that are not harmful (UNAIDS/Panos, 2001). Similar strategies have also been attempted in girls’ recreation activities, such as girl guides and girls’ involvement in sports. However, rigorous evaluations have not been carried out on the use of sports channels for behavior change in HIV/AIDS-related behavior. The usually male-dominated “macho” sports events may not always be the best venue through which to communicate messages that will truly lead to behavior change. However, a more comprehensive, community-based approach to sports strategies can be taken (See Zambia case study). Communicating through Health Services: As discussed in detail in Chapter 5, health clinics, especially family planning and ANCs, can provide a channel for reaching women and adolescent girls with HIV-related information and counseling. For example, in response to the increasing rate of HIV infection among Brazilian women in the 1990s, the Sociedade Civil Bem-estar Familiar do Brasil decided to integrate HIV/STI diagnosis and prevention into their family planning services. Thousands of women have benefited from these services and have had the opportunity to practice discussing sexual issues with their partners (UNAIDS, 1998b). However, men usually consider birth control and ANC services to be women’s business that seldom requires their attention, unless there are costs to be paid. More settings are needed to provide effective sexual health and HIV/AIDS-related services
130 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
for men, including adolescents. Both WHO and USAID surveys have found that services for adolescent males are scarce and under-funded, with only a small minority of programs working with them (Scalway, 2002a). Men need reliable reproductive health education and services that offer access to counseling about HIV/AIDS, as well as life events and decision-making. Men also need diagnosis and treatment services. A more holistic approach to sexual and reproductive health care for men will enhance their well-being, equip them to make responsible decisions, result in lower levels of STIs and unintended childbearing, and allow them to become better fathers. “Thus, what is increasingly seen as good for men in their own right should turn out to be just as good for women—to the benefit of men and women as individuals, couples, families, and society as a whole” (Alan Guttmacher Institute, 2002). Existing clinics and health centers can be adapted to create male-friendly spaces, counseling and services (UNAIDS/Panos, 2001). Similarly, VCT and PMTCT programs have found that men need to be involved in care and support services, so that they will not be indifferent or act as barriers, preventing their partners from participating in such programs.
Key Issues to Communicate Gender analysis should form the basis for decisions on issues and messages to be communicated. From a gender perspective, key issues include the following: l
Communicate Gender Equity Clearly: Messages should be constructed with an understanding of the differences between sex and gender—the biological and the social. “Sex” refers to biological differences between men and women or to sexual acts between people. “Gender,” on the other hand, concerns socially constructed roles, qualities, and behaviors expected from men and women, and boys and girls in different cultures. Gender roles are learned and influenced by education, economics, and social status, among others. While an individual’s sex usually does not change, gender roles are socially determined and can evolve over time. HIV/AIDS communication can be used to challenge those gender roles that are harmful to the overall development of people and put them at greater risk of HIV infection. For instance, the socially-defined role for African girls involves the completion of a great deal of housework and minding of siblings, so much so that they are often forced to drop out of school. Keeping girls in school, as long as schools are safe from “sugar daddies,” has been shown as a protective strategy against HIV infection, both because of the protection of the social and physical environment they are in, and the knowledge and skills they learn. Therefore, communicating on a more equitable division of household chores is indirectly linked to HIV prevention.
l
Communicate Sensitively that P ower Imbalances in R elationships increase HIV Power Relationships Risks: A central theme in the construction and expression of gender and sexuality is power. It affects individual autonomy, sense of self, the experience of sex, and the opportunities open to women and men. Communication messages and themes need
Reaching Special Audiences 131
to address the power imbalances in relationships and the consequences of these imbalances. They should encourage mutual respect between men and women, boys and girls. Communication should focus on men who show how they care for their partner and families by not bringing HIV into the household. Messages can emphasize that a man’s self-worth is strengthened by actively caring for his partner’s and children’s well-being. Some specific “gender equitable” qualities include men who: – – – – –
are respectful in their relationships with women and do not seek sexual conquest, but rather equality and intimacy, seek to be involved fathers who actively care for their children, assume equal responsibility for reproductive health issues, are not violent towards women, and advise their male friends to be responsible as well.
l
Enhance Self -efficacy through R ole Models: Equally, communication programs Self-efficacy Role can show women and girls who stand up to men. Such women demonstrate skills of refusal and self-efficacy, choosing to determine their own future. However, images of women as strident and overbearing may inadvertently cause the audience to reject the message. Careful research on the characters and issues to be included in the programing will help to increase acceptability among members of the intended audience.
l
Identify and F eature “P ositive Deviants” in P rograms: Promote and learn more Feature “Positive Programs: about “positive deviants,” those men, women, boys, and girls who demonstrate positive gender values and who practice delay of sexual debut, abstinence, faithfulness, and safe sexual behaviors that prevent the spread of HIV (See Sara case study).
l
Promote Dialogue: Open dialogue among community members constitutes a powerful strategy that facilitates a focus on sexuality, gender, and AIDS as steps toward protective behavior against HIV infection (Calderon, 1997). Dialogue among policymakers is especially key, because they may be good advocates for behavioral change and social responsibility (Alan Guttmacher Institute, 2002). Advocacy is required on the need to review national legal frameworks so that they are more responsive to gender aspects of the HIV/AIDS epidemic (UNFPA, 2000).
l
Involve P arents: Communication programs should encourage children to initiate Parents: dialogue with their parents about issues related to sexuality and HIV prevention, as well as help parents educate their children about sexuality, responsibility, and HIV.
Challenges and Lessons Learned Starting at an Early Age: There is strong rationale to reach boys and girls at an early age, before they are sexually active, and to continue to involve them. Behavioral research specific to particular culture contexts should drive the themes and messages. However, it is often challenging to deliver appropriate communication on sexual matters to very young people.
132 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Cultural or religious gatekeepers may derail the program unless they are involved from the beginning. Also, programs cannot assume that young people, once engaged in a program, do not need to be re-engaged. Experience suggests that interventions should be staged by age but have flexible limits. Gender Analysis: All communication on HIV/AIDS prevention and care should benefit from a gender analysis. However, very often only lip service is paid to gender issues in program planning. Gupta (2000) distinguishes gender-neutral approaches “that do no harm” (such as “be faithful” messages), gender-sensitive approaches (which meet the different needs of men and women), transformative approaches (e.g., fostering constructive approaches for men), and approaches that empower women or men (e.g., in improving their access to skills building, services, and technologies). The examples given in this chapter may be helpful in understanding how gender can and should be integrated into various strategies. Access: It is not easy to effectively reach women and girls and empower them to participate more actively in decisions concerning their sexuality. Barriers include cultural factors that inhibit the access of young people, especially women, to reproductive health information and limit their capability to make reproductive health decisions. There is also gender-based disparity in access to the mass media. In some societies, women and girls are not encouraged to go outside their homes without their husband or a male relative. In others, the decision to seek health care must first be sanctioned by a male relative. Gatekeepers: In most societies there are “gatekeepers” in the family whose blessing and involvement are necessary for women’s involvement in any intervention. They may be men or older women, such as grandmothers, who continue to reinforce male-dominated values. For cultural reasons, community gatekeepers may not be willing to support interventions that they perceive to undermine traditional gender roles and relationships. In this regard, it is helpful to start with non-threatening issues on which there is consensus and ready community support before gradually moving on to more controversial topics. A project that sought to promote spousal communication about reproductive health in Guinea was successful in eliciting the support of Islamic religious leaders and increasing social support for family planning because its initial advocacy activities centered around child health and other nonthreatening themes (Blake and Babalola, 2002). L ong-term Commitment: Sexual behavior, influenced and defined by deeply ingrained and sometimes harmful cultural beliefs about masculinity and femininity, plays a large role in the spread of HIV. Programs must enable men to “examine and challenge old harmful concepts of masculinity and create a new definition of what it means to be a man in this new millennium”(The Hunger Project, 2001). The challenge lies in the fact that these beliefs are rooted in traditions that have been reinforced over generations and cannot be dismantled overnight, nor should they necessarily be. Programmers who undertake a close examination will recognize and respect certain healthy gender differences, while at the same time work to influence those that are not constructive and currently facilitate the spread of HIV. Since empowering people to participate more actively in decisions concerning their sexuality often involves changing social norms, achieving measurable impact may take considerable time and resources. Objectives need to be realistic. While norms do not change overnight, with
Reaching Special Audiences 133
persistence, programs can achieve significant changes in knowledge, attitudes, and, eventually, practices. Project implementers may want to adopt a phased approach, first focusing on advocacy through opinion leaders and later focusing on individual knowledge and attitudes as well as on group and social norms.
Case Study: Sara: A Role Model for African Girls as they Face HIV/AIDS UNICEF’s Sara Communication Initiative (SCI) is primarily aimed at delaying the age of sexual debut for African girls and empowering them to deal with the sexual advances from boys and men, including “sugar daddies” and other forms of sexual abuse. The SCI involved extensive formative research and production of an expanding set of communication tools, including animated videos, comic books with users’ guides, posters, and a radio series. Program planners conceptualized, researched, and implemented these tools in 12 Eastern and Southern African countries between 1995 and 2000 and are now expanding to new countries such as Ghana and Nigeria. The Sara stories involve a range of factors determining the positive behavioral development of African adolescents aged 10 to 19 years and address the need for a supportive role by boys, parents, and communities. The creators believed that the stories had to be informative, while motivating people to change. They also had to address the ability or skills of girls to act, while recognizing environmental factors that may facilitate or impede positive change. The creators of Sara recognized that boys and parents should not be left out since any proposed changes in girls’ lives would have to be supported by them. Therefore, the research process and the creation of Sara stories involved boys and adult community members. Various male and female characters of different ages serve as protagonists or antagonists for the cause of girls’ rights. The modeling of positive gender relations, starting at an early age, was especially important. So Sara’s friend, Juma, Sara’s father, and her younger brother all play key, positive roles in her life. To date, these widely disseminated stories have covered a range of topics: staying in school, avoiding sexual abuse and exploitation by truck drivers and “sugar daddies,” avoiding female genital cutting, avoiding teenage pregnancy, breaking the silence on HIV/AIDS, supporting orphans and PLHA, and protecting children from child labor and sexual exploitation in cities and in civil conflict settings. The Sara videos and radio series have reached millions of people in broadcasts throughout Africa. However, the use of Sara print materials in formal and non-formal educational settings is just as important, if not more important for full behavior development of adolescents. It was recognized that training through group processes, including interactive learning methods, is usually required to develop psychosocial life skills for appropriate behavioral responses to risk situations.
134 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Plate 4-3: The Sara stories provide a role model to empower A frican girls to deal with unwanted sexual African advances. (Credit: UNICEF)
Program activities include: l l l l l l l l l l l l l
National training workshops on the use of Sara materials Development of local Sara materials Formation of core Sara groups for dissemination and utilization Wide use of Sara materials by government partners and NGOs Training of facilitators for effective utilization Establishment of Sara clubs and/or peer educator programs Distribution of Sara materials to schools Broadcast of Sara videos on national television networks Rebroadcast of the Sara radio series on national stations Local language translations of materials Screening of Sara videos to its audiences through video outreach systems Training of local artists and writers Sara advocacy festivals
An independent mid-term evaluation (Russon, 2000) completed during 1999–2000 showed that a high percentage of girls and boys in areas where full programming had been implemented recognized the Sara character. Girls reported the positive influence of Sara in delaying sexual debut and abstaining or avoiding situations with potential for sexual abuse and exploitation. Qualitative research with girls in life skills programs in Uganda and Kenya demonstrated how they used Sara as a role model for protecting themselves from sexual abuse as well as how boys were attracted and motivated by the Sara figure. The SCI demonstrated that engaging cartoon characters, when well researched and programed, can engender discussion in communities and help shift individual behaviors and
Reaching Special Audiences 135
community norms. Evidence from Uganda, a country that has experienced a decline in the incidence of HIV, points to the importance of delaying sexual debut among adolescents. This was central in Sara stories, as were messages to boost self-esteem among young girls and encourage avoidance of sexual exploitation. Sara is being adopted by many user groups in the fight against HIV/AIDS in Africa. Her added value is that she appeals to all age groups and triggers discussion between generations. The SCI encompasses a set of communication tools that have a strong research base and are applicable across many cultures. In addition, the commercialization of Sara materials through an educational publisher (www.mml.co.za) bodes well for future sustainability. Sara stands side-by-side with African girls to address the inequality they face by virtue of their gender. Source: McKee et al., 2003
Case Study: Involving Boys in Zambia: The Chikomeni Youth Camp Background: The Youth Activist Organization (YAO) approach in prevention of HIV/AIDS is tailored to youth in rural areas where there is a dearth of reproductive health information. Trainers teach boys football (soccer) strategies and moves and parallelly impart knowledge, skills, “strategies and moves” in sexual and reproductive health (SRH). Goal and Objectives: The overall goal of the project is to increase male participation in reproductive health/family planning and child health issues in the family. Specific objectives are: l l l
To increase young men’s knowledge about reproductive health, HIV/AIDS, and family planning. To promote safer sex and improve young men’s skills in using condoms. To equip young men with life skills such as decision-making, goal setting, and selfesteem.
Audience: The primary audience of the project is boys aged 14 to 24 years, both in and out of school from rural and peri-urban communities. Each camp works with 50 boys over a period of seven days. As a secondary audience, the project targets participants’ parents, girls aged 12 to 24 years, and the community associations. The football camp at Chikomeni Rural Health Centre (RHC) catchment area presents an instructive case. This area has a population of nearly 11,000 people who live in villages as far as 20 kilometers away from the health centre. In October 2000, YAO conducted the first
136 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Plate 4-4: Zambian boys at a sports camp, which combines both soccer training and education in reproductive health and HIV/AIDS. (Credit: Youth Activists Organization, Zambia)
Youth Sexual and Reproductive Health Football Camp for approximately 50 boys during a one-week period. Major project activities consisted of the following: Youth R eproductive Health/HIV/AIDS and F ootball T raining Reproductive Football Training raining: These sessions, central to the strategy, were targeted at 50 boys aged 14–24 years. In addition to football skills, peer educators and coaches trained the boys in sexual reproductive health, including HIV/AIDS and STIs (modes of transmission and prevention including abstinence, condom use, being faithful to one partner, and masturbation); hygiene; relationships/gender equity; negotiation and decision-making skills; and community responsibility. Football T rainers’ Orientation Session: At least five men from the community were selected Trainers’ to assist the coach with the football training. Through three-day sessions, the project staff oriented the five coaches in SRH, HIV/AIDS, and family planning. They also taught them how to link reproductive health messages to football. For example, in a football match, players have to protect themselves by using shoe and shin guards. Similarly, in the game of life, one needs to play safe by using condoms, and to acquire the skill to use them correctly. Fathers’ and Mothers’ Orientation Sessions: Other sessions were also aimed at reaching the participants’ fathers and mothers and other men and women in the community. The
Reaching Special Audiences 137
main objective was to provide information to them on their role in the family. The focus was on adolescent reproductive health, communication about these issues within the family and the community, and the role that men can play. Couples/Community Health Session: On the fourth day, the project invited mothers, fathers, neighborhood health committees, women’s associations, and other community members to a session on community health. This meeting provided a platform to identify common health concerns in the community, using participatory games. The group then prescribed their own solution for the identified problems. Community Mobile Video Shows: Shows were held in the evenings. These combined reproductive health and HIV/AIDS information with social awareness drama and movies, along with discussion. Dancing competitions before the movie encouraged participation of the audience. Winners received promotional materials such as posters, makeup bags, or T-shirts. R esults: As a result of the Youth Camp, the community now accepts the fact that the “inheritance of widows,” the tradition that requires a man to marry the widow of his dead brother, is no longer an acceptable practice given the prevalence of HIV/AIDS in Zambia. The records of community-based distributors (CBDs) in the area demonstrated an increase in condom use. The Chairman of the Health Centre Committee at Chikomeni RHC indicated that the camp was popular with parents and youth alike, as attested by the numerous requests for a similar camp for girls. The camp introduced the young men and the community to the importance of discussing SRH issues and taught them that SRH education is vital to protect the well-being of individuals, families and communities. Parents in the community, both men and women, reported that attending the SRH sessions helped them clear a lot of misconceptions on family planning and HIV/AIDS. The Clinical Officer at the Health Centre, Boniface Hamusonde, reported as anecdotal evidence: l l l l
an increase in community participation, greater youth involvement in community affairs, an increased demand for Voluntary Counseling and Testing (VCT), especially among engaged couples, and a heightened awareness among community members regarding the transmission and prevention of HIV/AIDS.
YAO’s overall aim is that, in the long run, participants in such camps will grow into responsible adults, able to use available resources and to make informed choices. Source: YAO/JHU/CCP, 2002
138 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Sex Workers: Shifting the Balance of Power Rationale It is often said that sex work is one of the oldest and most widespread professions in the world, yet it is perhaps the least understood. Sometimes called “prostitution,” the term is not used here because of its judgmental overtones that can obscure the underlying structural factors (Synergy, 2002). It involves female, male, or “transgendered” persons who receive money or goods in exchange for sexual services. Although these categories of sex workers may have factors in common in terms of causes and consequences, for the purposes of analysis and strategic thinking, this section deals mainly, but not exclusively, with female sex workers (FSWs). Further discussion on male and “transgender” sex workers follows in the next section. FSWs are predominantly younger women and girls who trade sex for money. Sometimes transactional sex for favors or gifts is equated with sex work. However, those who are involved usually do not consider themselves sex workers, and usually society does not consider them so until such activities become their primary source of economic sustenance. In HIV surveillance worldwide, HIV prevalence among sex workers is substantially higher than among the general population; in some places, over 80 percent of FSWs have tested positive for HIV (Ghys et al., 2002). In high prevalence areas, sex workers are particularly vulnerable to HIV infection due to their multiple sexual partners, frequency of sexual acts, often low access to condoms and/or use of condoms, and difficulties they experience in negotiating condom use with clients. In the past, many interventions have focused on individual FSWs, unconsciously perpetuating the notion of them as “vectors” of HIV, placing little emphasis on the role clients play in HIV transmission and prevention and further stigmatizing FSWs themselves. Less attention has been paid to other factors that may be determinants of sex work: poverty, trafficking, debt bondage, and factors that put such women at even greater risk, such as violence, drugs, and alcohol use. Careful analysis of HIV risk in FSWs indicates that causes are complex and multi-layered. A simplified representation of these causes appears in Box 4-6. The long experience in programs for FSWs indicates that addressing immediate causes alone, such as the provision of condoms, information on HIV/AIDS, and skills to negotiate condom use, is necessary but not sufficient to affect change. There have been increasing calls for programs that address multiple levels of HIV risk causation, a more structural approach to the problem (Sweat and Denison, 1995; UNAIDS, 2002a, 2002c). Box 4-6 demonstrates that at the most basic or structural level are the laws and policies regarding sex work. This is perhaps the most difficult to address since sex work remains illegal in all but a handful of countries today. It is most difficult to advocate for or communicate on the informational, social, health, and economic rights of people who are considered by society to be outside the law, whether they operate from the street, brothels, hotels, bars, or their own homes.
Reaching Special Audiences 139 Box 4-6: Causal F actors in FSWs’ V ulnerability to HIV Factors Vulnerability Causal Level
Factors
Immediate
l l l
Underlying
l l l l l
Basic or Structural
l l l l l l l
Limited information, skills, negotiating power Lack of consistent condom supplies Control by clients, pimps, madams, brothel owners, and regular partners Poor access to educational, prevention, and care services Stigmatization and marginalization Alcohol and drug abuse Violence and intimidation/bondage Sexual exploitation and trafficking Income differential and mobility of client populations Economic vested interests to maintain the status quo Cultural and/or traditional beliefs and practices Gender inequity—educational, social, occupational Poverty and limited economic opportunity Lack of political will to change the situation Laws and policies regarding sex worker practices
Source: Adapted from UNAIDS, 2002c
Another basic or structural cause is lack of political will. In very few societies will political figures side with marginalized groups such as sex workers since such actions will seldom help gain popularity or votes. Another basic cause is gender inequity. UNAIDS reports: Although their rights and economic independence are often limited (in some instances severely), women frequently bear the major burden of family obligations. In addition to having limited access to employment, women in many societies have fewer prospects of financial support outside of marriage other than sex work. On the other hand, when bride payments or dowries change hands, young women may come to realize that they are being treated as a commodity. Sex work may offer them more control of their sexuality than their society affords to either married or marriageable women, and using that sexuality for their own profit may seem a viable alternative to marriage (UNAIDS, 2002c). However, sex work is usually more profitable for the traffickers and others who control the trade. Program planners must consider these audiences, among others, when designing an intervention: pimps, madams or brothel owners, and regular partners. The pattern of interaction is often complex. Sex workers also develop sexual relationships with pimps or other men as surrogate “husbands” or regular partners who provide emotional support in exchange for free sex. The power and the role of these players can vary considerably and must be addressed in the design of any intervention. Clients of FSWs may be adolescent boys, single men, or married men with families. Studies of the prevalence and spread of HIV have found that the rate of HIV among sex workers is
140 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
highest in places where the clients are very mobile, such as truck stops and port cities. The danger of unprotected, paid sex that exists in many places is more frequent amongst professions that compel men to be away from their families and communities for extended periods of time. For instance, miners isolated in camps for months at a time often seek out sex workers, as do sailors arriving in port after weeks at sea. Other groups of men who use sex workers frequently are men in the armed services, including the military and the police. The cultural values and traditional beliefs of clients are a basic factor that increases vulnerability as well. For instance, as noted in the previous section, the “machismo” culture of men may motivate them towards accessing FSWs. Young men are often encouraged to have their first sexual experience with an older woman—usually a FSW (UNAIDS, 2002c). Traditional beliefs also increase risk. For instance, the false belief that having sex with a young girl is a cure for syphilis has also emerged as a cure for HIV in both Africa and Asia—a belief that has increased the demand for very young sex workers and put them at great risk (UNAIDS, 2002c). This brief analysis of complex and varied patterns of human behaviors, with various causal levels, clearly demonstrates that programs for FSWs require program approaches that are holistic or integrated, addressing immediate, underlying, and structural or environmental factors. Extensive formative research is needed to determine the “shape and size” of interventions and how communication can play a strong role.
Formative Research Formative research questions for FSWs include the following: l l l l l l l
l l l l
Is sex work regular or occasional? Is sex work legal or illegal and what other laws and policies protect sex workers or make them more vulnerable (e.g., rape or violence in sex work)? What is the nature of the settings where contacts are made with clients (brothels, streets, hotels, bars, massage parlors, cinemas, or other locations)? Who are the clients and how often do they avail services? What is their average number of clients per day? What are the various prices charged by different types of FSWs in different locations and what are their working conditions? What is the socio-economic and educational status of all those involved in commercial sex (e.g., FSWs, pimps, clients, regular partners) and what are the main occupations of clients? What is the rate of regular condom use with these various players? What is the history and current level of STIs? Injecting drug use? What knowledge, myths, and misconceptions do FSWs and their sexual partners have about SRH, condoms, and related subjects? What psychosocial and technical skills do FSWs have, for instance in negotiating and using condoms?
Reaching Special Audiences 141 l l
What are the social and culture factors that motivate men to use commercial sex? What level of stigma is associated with sex workers and with accessing their services? (Adapted from UNAIDS, 2002c)
These questions are far from exhaustive. However, they represent a good starting point in the process of developing the foundation of an effective program.
Strategic Approaches As noted, experience has shown that communication strategies must be grounded in a more holistic program approach that addresses some of the structural and underlying factors that contribute to HIV transmission in sex work. Each of the strategies listed must be tailored to take into account the diverse ways in which sex work is practiced worldwide. Communication Approaches Various communication strategies can be used and linked to the structural approaches. These are: Advocacy for Changes in L aws and P olicies: Advocacy can be carried out with health, Laws Policies: social service, and legal authorities, largely through interpersonal contact, lobbying and negotiation, or through presentations at workshops and seminars. The object is to foster changes in the policies and laws that discriminate against sex workers, drive them underground, and increase their own as well as their clients’ risks. It is unlikely that laws and policies will change easily. However, sometimes authorities will agree to “look the other way” and avoid applying laws or policies that they realize do more harm than good. For instance, in Andhra Pradesh, India, after exposure to the issues, the Chief Minister authorized the release of a letter to all police authorities that measures their performance on the basis of the arrest of traffickers and pimps, not FSWs who are usually victimized, in spite of the fact that sex work remains illegal in India. Interpersonal Communication and Counseling: Health professionals and others can be trained in interpersonal communication (IPC) and counseling for sex workers, including issues of stigma and discrimination. In addition, health professionals should counsel male patients on sexual practices, including paid sex. However, IPC and counseling on such subjects is no easy matter. Many health workers bring their own biases and judgmental attitudes about commercial sex. Training programs must be in-depth and need to include on-the-job monitoring and supervision following training. Communication Aids: Flip charts, both informational or in the form of stories, with audiocassettes sometimes, are used to support IPC and make it more effective. These can be produced in a larger format, for group facilitation on the issues, or smaller, for interaction with one to three people. Other communication aids, such as small booklets, music cassettes, T-shirts, stickers, banners, and related items can be used to reinforce IPC and group methods
142 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
and to popularize programs within the locale. It is essential that literacy levels of FSWs be known before producing print materials designed for them. Anatomical models of the penis can be useful for demonstrating correct condom use and other educational purposes. Community-based Media: Entertainment–Education strategies, such as community theater, have proven very popular in program settings, both for FSWs and their clients. Scripting should be thoroughly pretested and there should be minimum variations from the final script. Quality assurance in message delivery is essential. Dramatic stories and messages should be “processed” by the audience with the help of trained facilitators so that messages are made clear to everyone. Peer Education: The reason for using peers instead of health professionals to deliver prevention messages is that peers are often able to gain trust and have credibility that outsiders lack. FSW peers, some of whom are still practicing sex workers, will usually be less judgmental of sexual behavior and life choices than health professionals. Peer educators can impart knowledge and skills to other sex workers on correct condom use, ways to negotiate the use of condoms, and strategies for coping with violence and stigma. They can also distribute condoms and communication materials, as well as provide referrals to services. They can work on the street, in bars, clubs, brothels, hotels, or drop-in centers. Peer educators can also reach clients in the places they buy sex or in the workplace (e.g., military barracks, mining camps, truck rest stops). Mass Media: Mass media is less frequently used in the case of HIV prevention and care in sex work because of the high probability that wide public exposure may further blame and stigmatize FSWs. However, with careful scripting and formative research, TV and radio programs, drama, and other forms of entertainment can educate audiences about the situation of FSWs and the causal determinants of their profession. This may help to decrease stigma and discrimination, as well as open up discussion. However, care must be taken not to simply shift blame and stigmatize other groups such as truck drivers. It is imperative to address causes at various levels, rather than to focus on particular groups as “core transmitters.” Linkages to Services Interventions that change the normative or regulatory conditions of sex work are known as environmental and structural interventions. They may require substantial advocacy to gain support and communication in their implementation. Examples are given here: Distribution and Marketing of Condoms: Sex workers require condoms to be readily available in large quantities. Different programs have provided condoms to sex workers and clients in various ways, including handing them out for free and selling them at reduced prices. Examples cited earlier are those of Thailand and the Dominican Republic, which mandated 100 percent condom use in brothels. These interventions did not require sex workers alone to insist on condom use. They placed much of the responsibility on those with power, the brothel owners (Sakondhavat et al., 1997). One innovative solution to maintaining a constant supply of condoms for sex workers is social marketing, which makes these available at many sources.
Reaching Special Audiences 143
In fact, sex workers can sell condoms to fellow workers, providing them with additional income. Groups of sex workers have been able to negotiate lower prices for bulk purchases of condoms and then market these among sex workers and clients. Some programs have used the profits for literacy training, health care, or subsidizing condoms for sex workers who are unable to afford them (UNAIDS, 2000c). Health Services and Drop-in Centers: FSWs and their clients need regular SRH services, cervical screenings and treatment, STI treatment, VCT, access to condoms and other contraceptive methods, and maternal and child health services, as well as regular health services. Often they do not use services because they are made to feel stigmatized and ashamed when accessing these. Establishing special sites where sex workers can access such services can help diminish this reluctance. Alternatively, services such as those for STI diagnosis and treatment may be “franchised”—that is, training can be provided to regular medical practitioners for a standard protocol of services that are inspected and then “branded” and monitored to provide an identity for the marketing of these services. In addition, a safe, comfortable space for sex workers to gather can serve as a venue for providing education, support, and services. Drop-in centers can be the focal point for the implementation of many prevention and care strategies. Outreach: Sex workers may not feel comfortable accessing services such as condom provision and HIV prevention counseling in a clinical setting, as they may feel that facilities serving the general public would not welcome them. If this is the case, it is important to offer services where sex workers gather and are likely to feel most comfortable. Peer educators are often involved in outreach work. Community-Based: Sex workers are seldom viewed as a community in themselves. They are often controlled by others and have little power to organize for their rights. However, experience has shown that if they are organized and facilitated to analyze their own situations, they are able to develop their own code of practices (Sangram, n.d.). They have the capacity to demand their rights to protection through consistent condom use by clients, a decent livelihood, health and social services, security, and even care for their children (See Sonagachi Project, Box 4-7).
Key Issues to Communicate As indicated, communication interventions must be integrated with service delivery approaches. Simply delivering messages to sex workers will have little impact. Therefore, the following suggestions for key issues to communicate should be seen in that light. Emphasize HIV Infection Risk: FSWs and clients both carry a high risk of contracting HIV. Messages should communicate real levels of risk, as well as how to lower risk. Messages that are overly laden with fear will likely be rejected by those who “live on the edge.” For instance, a woman who has been subjected to discrimination, violence, and mistreatment or a truck driver who spends long hours on insecure roads may not see the intangible, distant death threat of an incurable disease as something to fear.
144 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic Box 4-7: The Sonagachi P roject in K olkata, India Project Kolkata, Sonagachi, the “golden tree,” is the oldest and largest red-light district in Kolkata, West Bengal, India, and is home to a community-run sex worker project. It started in 1992 as a health promotion project to inform sex workers about AIDS, provide STI services, and promote condom use. The project has now evolved into a multifaceted community project to create an enabling environment for sex workers to act on their own behalf. One key event was the establishment of a sex worker union, which advocates for the decriminalization of prostitution, workers’ rights, and entitlement to negotiate working conditions. The basic approach of the Sonagachi Project is respect for sex workers and recognition of their profession, as well as reliance on their understanding and capacity. Based on a philosophy of empowering sex workers, the project has multiple components that contribute to its success: peer education, brothel-based STI clinics, and an AIDS awareness group using music, dance, and street theater. In terms of results, consistent condom use has increased from 1 percent in 1992 to 50 percent in 2002, prevalence of syphilis has dropped from 25 percent to 11 percent, and HIV prevalence is currently around 5 percent. This level is very low compared to the 51 percent prevalence among their colleagues in Mumbai (Bombay) in Maharashtra, India. The project also includes a school for sex workers’ children, a loan co-op, and peer-led literacy classes. The main reason for the success of the project is the reconfiguration of power balances between sex workers and their clients since the women belong to a union that sets the rules of sexual interaction, including obligatory condom use. The project has expanded to reach an estimated 60,000 sex workers in the State of West Bengal and plans are in place to reach even more. Source: Horizons, 2002c; Jana, 2002; Jana et al., 1999; UNAIDS, 2000c
Communicate Correct Condom Use: Condoms must be used correctly and consistently to be effective. Messages should incorporate the issue of expiration date and how to store, use, and dispose of condoms correctly. It is important to emphasize that condoms are a tool for “safer” sex rather than “safe” sex (See Challenges and Lessons Learned). Strengthen Condom Negotiation Skills: Sex workers may fear that insisting on condom use will result in violence or loss of income. Strategies to negotiate effectively for condom use that build sex workers’ confidence and self-efficacy should be included in communication programs. However, as has been shown in Thailand’s 100 percent condom program and the West Bengal example (see Box 4-7), when structural changes take place, the power of laws and policies rather than the skills of one person support such negotiation. This approach is much more effective. Emphasize the Need for P rotection with R egular P artners: Sex workers who use condoms Protection Regular Partners: for commercial sex often choose not to use them for sexual relations with pimps, regular partners, or “husbands” who give them protection and emotional support in exchange for free sex. Programs should encourage FSWs to protect themselves in all types of relationships and to realize that they are not likely to be the exclusive sexual partner of such men. However, this is not easy to communicate since the power balance in these relationships usually does not favor FSWs. Promote VCT and STI T reatment: Diagnosis and treatment for STIs and VCT for HIV, Treatment: while helpful in preventing the transmission of HIV, may not be a personal priority for
Reaching Special Audiences 145
FSWs for a variety of reasons. Helping them see the personal benefits of diagnosis and treatment of STIs and VCT can increase their motivation to act. However, attitudes of health professionals with regard to sex workers also need to be addressed (Wojcicki and Malala, 2001). Formative research will help program planners understand the stigma involved and what will be most motivating to a particular community. For instance, older FSWs very often have children and may be concerned with their future. Using this as a motivational factor may be effective.
Challenges and Lessons Learned The challenges in prevention, care, and support in the area of sex work are many: Condom Effectiveness: Even if condoms are used consistently, a good estimate of their effectiveness is 90 percent. Therefore, in regions of high HIV prevalence, consistent condom use might increase the average time until infection for a full-time FSW from 6 months to 60 months—small consolation for such women (Hearst and Chen, 2003). There is some evidence that FSWs in Thailand are becoming infected in spite of the 100 percent condom program in brothels (Kilmarx et al., 1999). It is difficult for communicators to address such information when it is circulated. However, for the time being, in commercial sex work there is no alternative prevention method except non-penetrative sex and masturbation. Even though the female condom has shown high acceptance among FSWs, for example in Zimbabwe, the main obstacle to its use was the client’s mistrust of unfamiliar methods (Ray et al., 2001). In the future, microbicides may be an additional protection if they come into the market and if FSWs can afford them. Some sex workers also use female condoms to reduce their risk of HIV infection. Acceptance: Groups from outside the sex worker community who attempt to implement interventions may find that gaining access and trust is one of the biggest challenges faced. Due to the discrimination sex workers have faced, they may be distrustful of outsiders offering help or solutions. Stigma and Discrimination: Dealing with stigma and discrimination in the context of marginalized and often criminalized professions is difficult. Stigma and discrimination impact a sex worker’s ability to negotiate safe sex practices, seek medical care, and access social services. Sex workers are sometimes seen as “core transmitters” in the early stage of an epidemic. Such language can isolate them, push them “underground,” and make them difficult to reach. In fact, studies have shown that sex workers are among those most likely to respond positively to HIV and STD prevention programs, for example, by increasing their use of condoms with clients (UNAIDS, 2002c). Stigma and discrimination against sex workers reinforce violence by clients, pimps, and sometimes the police. Violence against sex workers is a serious impediment not only to their human rights but also to HIV prevention, since levels of violence influence condom use. About 49 percent of Bangladeshi sex workers reported, for example, being raped by the police and 68 percent by thugs/pimps (Jenkins et al., 2002).
146 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Addressing stigma and discrimination is a necessary step toward enabling sex workers to protect their own health and the health of their communities. Coercion, V iolence, and T rafficking: Coerced sex work in the form of debt bondage, trafViolence, Trafficking: ficking, or sex work of very young girls is a growing problem worldwide, and presents additional challenges to HIV prevention. Women coerced or forced into sex work have even less power to negotiate safe sex than sex workers who make a choice to enter the profession. Once forced into sex work, usually far from home, many of these women do not have the option of going back, as they may have been traded into sex work by impoverished family members and will most likely face rejection by friends and family if they return (Beyrer, 2001). A few specific lessons learned are as follows: l
l
l
l
l l l l
l
There are still gaps in our knowledge of many aspects of sex work and many assumptions made about sex workers that are not necessarily true (Wojcicki and Malala, 2001). For example: assumptions about why people sell sex and to whom; that all sex work involves penetration; and to what extent, given other choices, women (and men) who sell sex would choose another occupation (Gysels et al., 2002). The active involvement of sex workers in program design and implementation is an essential component of successful interventions, not only to gain access to sex worker communities and to gain their trust, but also to fully understand the needs, beliefs, and behaviors of sex workers and clients—a prerequisite for effective project planning. Facilitating the formation of coalitions, collectives, and advocacy groups composed of sex workers can be a step toward sustainability and increased capacity. Groups of sex workers who gain skills and are empowered to take steps to identify and address their own needs can form organizations that, with training and capacity strengthening, can eventually implement projects independently or in partnership with others. It is important to recognize the stigmatization and abuse of human rights that sex workers face, and to address these issues through project design and implementation. UNAIDS has stated that “one of the clearest public health lessons emerging from the HIV pandemic is that protecting the human rights of sex workers is one of the best ways to protect the rest of society from HIV” (UNAIDS, 2000c). Police and local authorities should also be involved in program design with sex workers. Programs should design interventions for brothel owners or pimps and clients, as well as sex workers. Health and social service staff must maintain non-judgmental attitudes toward sex workers and include stigma-reduction strategies in the intervention. Those who stand to gain financially from sex work (e.g., madams and brothel owners) should be made aware that they have an interest in preventing HIV. Programs can build interest and capacity among these people as well. Paying attention to them will ensure that sex workers are not further disempowered. Stakeholders among groups of sex work clients such as heads of military institutions, trucking firms, and mine owners are valuable partners in HIV prevention activities and can gain the skills to implement their own projects to protect their employees.
Reaching Special Audiences 147
Case Study: SHAKTI Project of Bangladesh Background: In Bangladesh, there is a traditional system of collective societies of FSWs living together in brothels with some recognition and protection, as well as health services (Khan and Arefeen, 1992). However, this system has begun to break down in a number of urban locations, and an estimated 100,000 FSWs sell sex to clients in hotels, lodges, and on the streets (Bloem, 1999). In Bangladesh society, women in general, and sex workers in particular, face gender-based violence such as acid attacks and rape due to their low status and lack of power. Bangladesh has a low HIV prevalence among female sex workers, remaining only at 0.5 percent for the past three years (DGHS, 2003). This scenario presents an enormous opportunity for keeping HIV prevalence and incidence low. The SHAKTI project in Bangladesh addresses HIV prevention among two of the most stigmatized and vulnerable communities: sex workers and IDUs. SHAKTI, which means “power” in Bangla and stands for “Stopping HIV/AIDS through Knowledge and Training Initiatives,” aims to increase sex workers’ use of condoms and to provide access to quality STI treatment services in order to prevent HIV infection. The project works with both street-based and brothel-based sex workers, as well as brothel owners and other stakeholders. SHAKTI is implemented by CARE International, with funding from DFID in partnership with the Marie Stopes Clinic Society to provide STI services, and with local NGOs and groups of sex workers to facilitate implementation. Audiences and Strategy: SHAKTI uses a peer education strategy to deliver HIV prevention messages and provide affordable condoms to sex workers. Over 170 volunteer peer educators and 55 paid outreach workers have provided IEC services to their fellow sex workers on the streets and in brothels. SHAKTI also provides sex workers a comfortable place to gather; drop-in centers offer sex workers a place to bathe and rest, access HIV prevention information and condoms, receive literacy training, and get medical services. The drop-in centers serve as a hub for SHAKTI’s prevention activities with sex workers. In order to ensure that sex workers always have a supply of condoms available, SHAKTI peer educators have become condom providers as well. SHAKTI is able to buy condoms in bulk, and the peer educators sell them to their peers at a slight profit. Part of these profits are put back into a fund for the neediest sex workers. R esults esults: The SHAKTI project has been evaluated using biannual surveys among sex workers as well as monitoring data. Brothel-based surveys have shown a clear increase in the percentage of sex acts protected by condom use: from less than 20 percent in 1996 to more than 75 percent in 1999. Protected sex with regular partners also increased, as did knowledge of the value of condom use (from 36 percent to 87 percent) in the same period (UNAIDS, 2000c). Lessons Learned: The SHAKTI project shows that it is vital to address sex workers’ needs beyond their need for STI services and condoms. Providing services like bathing facilities and literacy training offers opportunities for further HIV communication while meeting sex workers’ most pressing needs.
148 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Involving sex workers in each step of design and implementation offers the opportunity for sustainability and ownership of the project by sex workers. The effectiveness of the sex worker-managed condom marketing scheme is a testament to the importance of audience participation strategies and primary audience involvement. Source: Bloem, 1999; UNAIDS, 2000c
Reaching Men Who Have Sex With Men Rationale HIV/AIDS first caught the wide attention of public health officials and the public at large in the early 1980s when it became known as the “gay disease” or Gay-Related Immune Deficiency Syndrome (GRIDS). At first it was thought only to be transmitted between men who have sex with men (MSM)—mainly through unprotected anal sex. This is because most cases were self-identified gay men. In fact, “patient zero” was later identified to be a gay Air Canada flight attendant who directly infected 26 of the 39 other men first identified to have HIV (Klovdahl, 1985). The scientific evidence on the dangers of the disease that was gathered by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in Atlanta was largely ignored by US government officials. The reasons for this were conflicting budget priorities, bureaucratic inertia, and anti-gay stigma and homophobia (the fear and hatred of homosexuals), which also inhibited political will to do anything about the outbreak. Similarly, the media were reluctant to cover it (Singhal and Rogers, 2003). It was at this time that President Reagan’s “moral majority” movement was first taking root in the American political scene, bringing with it a neoconservatism linked to a Christian fundamentalism that does not recognize the rights of homosexuals. It was only when it was discovered that HIV could be transmitted heterosexually, and probably had been so transmitted in the 1970s or earlier, that more attention and resources were added to the fight against the virus. Meanwhile, gay men in the US, western Europe, and Australia experienced the death of unimaginable numbers of loved ones, friends, and members of their communities. They formed coalitions for advocacy and actions for HIV/AIDS prevention, care, support, and treatment, as well as the human rights of PLHA. Experience in San Francisco, where gay men could live openly, demonstrated how a community could organize from within to control the spread of HIV and mitigate the effects of AIDS. This positive example was replicated elsewhere, and by the early 1990s, the rate of new HIV infections dropped dramatically among MSM in the US (CDC, 2001a). As noted, gay men themselves pioneered many of the early HIV prevention interventions and later on played important roles in the development of prevention policy, thus demonstrating the power of peer-led and community-based interventions against HIV/AIDS (Kippax
Reaching Special Audiences 149
and Race, 2003). This development may have lent support to reinvigorating the gay rights movement that had been strong in the 1960s. In some countries it may have led to advocacy and increased recognition of the view that gay couples often live in stable relationships and have the right to be treated in the same way as heterosexual married couples, and also the right to rear children. However, this is not to say that all problems are solved for gay men in the West. There is growing evidence that today many younger gay men in North America and Europe, who were not part of the movement in the 1980s and 1990s, see HIV as a concern of the older generation and do not follow the protective measures needed for preventing HIV infection (Catania et al., 1998; CDC, 2000; Imrie et al., 1999). In addition, many African-American MSM do not self-identify as “gay” to avoid stigma from their own communities and families. Consequently, some members of these groups have tended to avoid prevention behaviors, with a resulting steep rise in the rate of HIV infection recently (CDC, 2001b). The experience of African-American MSM is similar to the experience of MSM in much of the non-western world where interventions for MSM do not receive the same attention. In sub-Saharan Africa, the epidemic is perceived to be exclusively driven by heterosexual transmission. Also in Mexico and Central and South America, where the early cases were only reported among homosexual men, the rapid shift to heterosexual transmission patterns has directed attention away from prevention and care interventions for MSM (Aggleton et al., 1999). Stigma against homosexuality still pervades many of these societies, and in many developing countries, including sub-Saharan Africa, homophobia often leads men to hide their sexual preferences to prevent being shunned by friends, family, and society. Usually, religious bodies and codes reinforce such stigma (UNAIDS, 1998c). The stigma against homosexuality causes some men to marry women to conform to social norms. In fact, in many parts of the world, MSM may not identify with any of the usual categories such as “gay,” “homosexual,” or “bisexual” (MAP Network, 2001) (See Figure 4-2). In India, it has also been reported that married truck drivers on the road with adolescent boy helpers sometimes engage in anal sex with them when FSWs are not available or when funds are low. In fact, providing such services to truckers is often a gateway for young, roadside cleaners and vendors to become helpers and eventually drivers themselves (Astana and Oostvogels, 2001). Evidence from Bangladesh indicates that the society-imposed separation of boys from girls leads to a significant amount of same-sex activity between adolescent boys, usually experimental and often regarded as “play” rather than sex. Such behavior is not usually based on sexual preference or a “gay” identity. In one study in Dhaka, nearly nine out of 10 respondents between 5–18 years of age reported that their first sexual experience in adolescence was with same-sex older relatives, friends, or neighbors, indicating sexual abuse by older boys and adults. There is also considerable evidence of adolescent boys’ involvement in transactional sex with older boys and men (Kabir, 2002). It is evident that the identities and behaviors of MSM around the world are many and varied and that interventions that prescribe easy answers, developed outside of the communities of MSM, will usually not be accepted and will most likely fail. In addition, in some countries, sex work and IDU (which are independent risk factors for HIV transmission) are prevalent among MSM, and these factors serve to compound the risk involved, even more for
150 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
those who do not feel comfortable having a gay or other identity (Rietmeijer et al., 1998). In-depth formative research is required, with the full involvement of MSM themselves, in order to determine the direction and focus of programs.
Formative Research A review of the formative research questions in Chapter 3 for the “prevention messaging” (“ABCs”) and “stigma” sections would reveal certain common issues that should also be taken up here. In addition, specific questions for the development of programs for and with MSM in various communities or geographic areas may be as follows: l
l l
l l l l l l l l l l l l l
What various identities and occupations do MSM have in the community or area of intervention? How do they perceive themselves? As communities or cohesive groups or as individuals? What are their educational attainment levels and literacy rates, socio-economic status, as well as other factors that may influence how programs will need to be developed? What are the general patterns of MSM relationships (e.g., Is it common for MSM couples to have an agreement that sex with others may be allowed under certain circumstances? Is the use of condoms part of that agreement)? What is the pattern of sexual partner change in the various categories of MSM within a given time? What are the predominant MSM sexual behaviors and where do they occur? Where do MSM normally congregate—in specific cities or elsewhere? Is there a significant pattern of sex work amongst MSM? What rates of STIs and IDU prevail and in which MSM groups? Where do they or could they access sexual health services, condoms, and VCT? Is MSM behavior illegal and, if so, how is it dealt with by the police and legal authorities? How open is the society towards MSM? Can they live openly? What attitudes do the police and judges, health and social workers have towards MSM? Are there any opportunities for policy change and if so, who are the gatekeepers and who might influence them? What is the attitude of the media and general public towards MSM? Which are the most likely channels to reach and work with MSM? What groups exist for MSM interventions or are open to work with them?
This list of questions is by no means exhaustive. In fact, MSM are often best placed to identify the most appropriate questions to ask in a given community. These are only suggestions to be expanded on and further refined in a particular program together with MSM networks.
Reaching Special Audiences 151
Strategic Approaches Like other vulnerable groups, MSM need comprehensive, sensitive, culturally-appropriate interventions to prevent HIV transmission and to provide care, treatment, and support for PLHA. Developing programs with them involves a process of working with and through social networks and providing interventions where MSM are most likely to be receptive. MSM themselves are normally the main actors in developing such programs. The following strategies have been found to be helpful in the design of interventions and in planning programs. Communication Strategies Advocacy: Sensitizing the police and legal authorities, health and social service provision managers, and the media about the realities and vulnerabilities of MSM is a challenging task since the behavior being discussed is often illegal or forbidden. However, such advocacy can take place through interpersonal contact, targeted presentations in seminars, and private meetings. Simple fact sheets may be useful to leave behind. Mass media can be used in societies that have already reached a level of acceptance but should be avoided if it is likely to increase stigma. IPC/C: In order to facilitate behavior change that reduces the risk of HIV, MSM need interpersonal communication and counseling (IPC/C) services. Health professionals and social service providers should be prepared to counsel MSM clients on safer sex behavior, STI treatment, and VCT. In many countries, health providers are not comfortable discussing these issues with MSM, as they believe the latter’s behavior is wrong or immoral. Such stigma may prevent MSM from revealing their sexual preferences or identity, thereby reducing the chances that they will receive the information and counseling they require. Health professionals can be trained in counseling techniques with MSM to help the latter overcome stigma. Counseling is important, not only in making decisions about condom use and sexual behavior, but also in addressing other HIV risk factors associated with some MSM, such as drug use and commercial sex work. Peer Education: Peer educators play a critical role in MSM communication programs. Peer education involves the knowledge and skills of people with great empathy and can be used to access often hard to reach MSM. Peers are often able to gain trust and establish credibility that outsiders lack. They are usually less judgmental than non-peers and can be used to educate other MSM on correct condom use, to distribute condoms and lubricants, and to refer their clients to other services when required. These activities can be undertaken in a facilitybased setting or in less formal places. Many countries have gay bars and clubs that can possibly be used as intervention sites for informal, peer-led education. In countries where MSM behavior is very repressed, private parties may be an appropriate channel for communication activities. Social settings are good venues for creative and sometimes explicit educational activities such as games and contests (e.g., contests with prizes for successfully demonstrating condom use on a penis model).
152 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Provision of Communication Materials: MSM need accurate information about HIV in order to protect themselves and their partners. Programs can provide MSM with the tools to prevent HIV through information and communication materials. Many MSM do not know enough about HIV to take precautionary measures or believe it is only a “western disease,” a disease of IDUs, or a disease of “gay” men with whom they may not identify. In societies where MSM are stigmatized, pocket-size materials that are less visible can be produced. These can be put into a cartoon format to make them humorous and appealing.
Plate 4-5: Discrete, pocket-size communication materials for MSM. (Credit: Humsafar Trust, Mumbai, India)
Hotlines: Telephone hotlines can provide quality STI and HIV information and counseling, as well as referrals. Counselors must also be trained in counseling on issues of sexuality and sexual identity for men who are questioning or struggling with their sexual preferences. Hotlines are very important for those who wish to remain anonymous. Internet: The Internet can be a tool for people to meet and socialize. It has been used as a social networking tool, particularly among MSM in developed countries or in places where the Internet is widely accessible. MSM use the Internet to meet partners and “chat” on-line, and it can also be used to convey HIV prevention information and locations for services. In many societies, MSM have above average educational achievements and so such channels are not unrealistic. Mass Media: As with FSWs, mass media may be used to address stigma against MSM. However, a great deal of research and careful design are required to produce effective programs
Reaching Special Audiences 153
that do not further stigmatize them. In Nicaragua, the program Sexto Sentido had a gang character, “Angel,” who portrayed the difficulties that gays face in a very sympathetic manner. Despite conservative social norms, this character was instrumental in creating new insights into gay issues for the general public. Linkage to Services Drop-in Centers and Outreach: Since they are often highly stigmatized, MSM may not feel comfortable accessing services in a clinical setting or may not realize they are at risk and should seek services. Many MSM groups and intervention projects have provided a safe, comfortable space for MSM to obtain information, support, counseling, condoms and lubricants, and even clinical services. Drop-in centers should be established in a location convenient to MSM and should be open during the hours that are most appropriate to their needs. An NGO for MSM in Mumbai, The Humsafar Trust, provides such a safe space for MSM, counseling services, peer education programs, a hotline service and condom supplies. Working from this center, outreach workers can offer communication materials, condoms, counseling, and referrals in bars, homes, parks, gyms or on streets. In order to address the other factors that may make MSM vulnerable to HIV, programs should provide referrals to appropriate, friendly services, such as drug addiction treatment, STI and VCT services, general health care, and employment counseling.
Key Issues to Communicate There are some basic issues to convey to all categories or identities of MSM. However, the social and contextual factors in which MSM find themselves will determine the manner in which these issues can be communicated, as well as what other issues should be included. These may include, for instance, how to avoid exploitation and violence in situations that may endanger personal security, and how to avoid being arrested in societies where homosexuality remains illegal. Such issues must be developed in context. R einforce that HIV is not V isible: One cannot tell if a sexual partner has HIV unless the Visible: partner has been tested. If people do not know the status of their partner (whether male or female, commercial or not, steady or casual), they should use condoms. Promote the AB Cs: While similar prevention messages (abstain, be faithful to an uninfected ABCs: partner or reduce the number of casual partners, and use condoms for anal or oral intercourse) are applicable, MSM in the West are also familiar with a concept called “negotiated safety.” This relatively safe practice allows for discarding condoms among known seronegative partners who negotiate and agree only to have sex using condoms outside their relationship (Kippax and Race, 2003). Communicate Clearly that all Unprotected P enetrative Sex is Risky: Some men may Penetrative believe anal sex is less risky than vaginal sex, when in fact the risks are greater. MSM need
154 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
to know the risks associated with anal sex and the importance of using condoms. It is especially important to reinforce the message that a condom needs to be applied before penetration and to address the myth that early and non-rough penetration poses no risk (Calzavara et al., 2002; Hoff et al., 2002). Clear Up Misconceptions about Oral Sex: Penis to mouth sex also involves some risk, especially if there is transmission of body fluids through cuts and lesions. It is advisable for the “active” participant not to ejaculate in the mouth. Condoms can also be used as a protective barrier. Promote Non-penetrative Methods: There are many non-penetrative ways to enjoy sex, including mutual masturbation and “thigh sex,” and these should be encouraged to reduce risk. Condoms Must be Used Correctly and Consistently: People should be made aware that condoms may break when an oil-based lubricant is used. MSM also need to know that condoms must be used with both male and female partners, for commercial and non-commercial sex, and with steady and casual partners. When one gets used to using them and when lubricated properly, they can prolong orgasms and increase pleasure. Alcohol and Drug Use: These factors increase the chances of HIV transmission, either in relation to sexual behavior, or in the case of IDU, directly.
Challenges and Lessons Learned HIV/AIDS programs with and by MSM were the first to be established. However, there are still many challenges to overcome in such interventions: Stigma and Homophobia: These may be the greatest challenges facing communication efforts aimed at HIV prevention among MSM. Stigma influences not only how others treat MSM, but how men, including young men, view themselves and their needs as well. If they are uncomfortable accepting their sexual preferences or behavior, they may avoid protective messages. The way a particular society views and treats MSM also affects the care and services MSM can receive. If it is not socially acceptable to discuss MSM, and if MSM are viewed as aberrant or immoral, initiatives to prevent transmission of HIV in MSM are less likely to be developed. MSM Identities May Be Complex: Reaching MSM who do not self-identify as MSM is another challenge. An excellent example to demonstrate how programs must be formulated on local realities comes from India. The Humsafar Trust has described the complexity of MSM identities (see Figure 4-2). The concept of MSM includes hijras, or eunuchs, who are part of societies that once had social, ceremonial, and occupational functions in courts and rich households. They continue today in various societies or forms including sex work. “Straight” men sometimes seek out hijras because they are considered more sexually skilled than women but are feminine in
Reaching Special Audiences 155 Figure 4-2: MSM Identities in India
Source: Humsafar Trust, Mumbai, 2002
manner and dress. In this example, neither the hijra, nor the man who engages in sex with the hijra, would consider himself an MSM. Other MSM identities include transsexuals, those who identify themselves as bisexuals, and those who are behaviorally bisexuals, and a large number of separate occupational identities that may be available for commercial sex, such as film extras, gym boys, hotel boys, bar boys, and masseurs (malishwala). Truckers and their helpers, taxi drivers, and migrant workers may be involved in MSM behavior as well. On the other hand, only a very small percentage of MSM think of themselves as “gay,” and gay identity may either be “kothi” or “panthi,” those who are “receptive” and those who are “active” in penetrative anal sex (Astana and Oostvogels, 2001; FHI, 2000a; Kavi, 2002). Behavioral Disinhibition: In the West, ART has given PLHA new life and new hope. The possibility of life-sustaining treatments has also given rise to a sense of “treatment optimism” accompanied by complacency about HIV and its prevention. Many young MSM in the US and western Europe now believe that HIV is a condition that can be managed, if not totally cured, and they are taking fewer measures to protect against HIV than the older generation. This trend is known as “behavior disinhibition.” Such factors, along with a sense of fatigue over constant vigilance in prevention, have led to a new rise in HIV transmission among MSM in the West (Katz et al., 2002; Kellogg et al., 1999). In fact, there are examples in the US and Europe of young MSM wanting to belong to HIV-positive groups where they receive more attention, social and health services, and gain a sense of “belonging” to a community.
156 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
In fact, a recent documentary film called The Gift picked up the topic and created controversies at prestigious film festivals across Europe, the US, and Australia. The film offers the unique perspective of a small subculture of HIV-negative men in the western gay male community who actively seek to become or are completely indifferent about becoming HIV-positive (Dream Out Loud Productions, 2003). In order to overcome this trend, new strategies and approaches are needed to help MSM understand that HIV is still very much present, there is still no cure, and, above all, that the use of ARV drugs, taken over the long term, provides less than a positive picture in terms of quality of life. In countries where antiretrovirals will soon become available, the challenge remains to ensure that MSM do not perceive them as a cure. Peer Education: This is an effective tool for communicating HIV prevention messages to MSM. However, programs must select peer educators carefully and train and support them adequately. The quality of the peer education intervention will determine its success. It must be done in the right situations and contexts, which can be identified by formative research. Adjusting Strategy: Programs can benefit from midstream adjustment to accommodate local situations. Because local MSM communities differ and established strategies and messages are not always transferable between cultures, it is important to monitor progress and results during project implementation and make adjustments to strategy as needed. Gaining P artnerships: NGOs and social groups addressing IDUs, sex workers, youth, or Partnerships: other vulnerable groups should be encouraged to integrate MSM issues into their work, thereby expanding the partnerships of intervention programs. Best P ractices: Lessons learned from the region or country in which a program is implemented Practices: can help shape program design and avoid mistakes. But western interventions that have worked well in Europe and Australia may not work as well in Asia, for example. So regionally focused materials and case studies will be most helpful.
Case Study: Naz Foundation Trust of India Background: India is a country with an HIV paradox: comparatively low HIV prevalence but high HIV burden. Because India has a population of one billion people, even a low HIV prevalence represents millions of PLHA. UNAIDS estimated that at the end of 2002, India had 3.82 and 4.58 million people living with HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS, 2003). Heterosexual transmission is thought to be responsible for the majority of infections but in certain areas, such as in the Northeastern states and in inner cities, IDU is an important factor. As the epidemic worsens, MSM communities have become increasingly vulnerable.
Reaching Special Audiences 157
Audiences and Strategy: The Naz Foundation Trust was established in 1994 to address issues of sexual health, HIV/AIDS, and STIs among MSM, women, truck drivers, and PLHA. The MSM program focuses on encouraging responsible sexual behavior among MSM in a non-judgmental, positive way. The Naz Foundation’s MSM program emphasizes increasing knowledge about HIV, including modes of transmission, risk-reduction strategies, and means of accessing treatment. These prevention efforts are implemented through a number of intervention strategies, including: l
l
l l
Community outreach: nine outreach sites staffed by eight outreach officers disseminate information, discuss sexual behavior and other issues, demonstrate condom use, and provide referrals. STI referrals: Naz operates STI clinics for people at risk of HIV and STIs, and MSM are encouraged to attend. For those who do not wish to be identified as MSM by entering an STI clinic for MSM, referrals to MSM-friendly physicians are provided. Social groups and meetings: three different support and social groups meet regularly, each intended for a specific sexual self-identification. Counseling: telephone hotline and in-person counseling exists to address issues of concern amongst MSM.
R esults: The MSM interventions implemented by Naz have been evaluated using monitoring data and a survey. These data show a number of positive results. The percentage of men who use condoms “all the time” increased from 11 percent to 43 percent, the percentage of men who visited an STI clinic rose from 24 percent to 56 percent, and use of condoms by male sex workers rose from 20 percent to 43 percent. In addition, safe sex practices increased while the practice of unsafe behaviors decreased: for example, the percentage of men who had receptive penetrative sex fell from 54 percent to 34 percent, while the use of lubricants and mutual masturbation increased. Lessons Learned: Although the men served by the Naz project were all “MSM,” Naz recognized that their various self-identifications required tailored interventions to reach them effectively. Careful audience analysis and formative research are an essential part of understanding audience composition and needs. Reaching the female partners of MSM is important for the prevention of HIV. The Naz Foundation found that gaining access to the female partners of their clients was not easy, and they continue to try to look for ways to reach this audience. Source: Rakesh, 2002; UNAIDS, 2000e
158 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Prevention and Injecting Drug Users Rationale The sharing of contaminated needles through injection drug use (IDU) is one of the primary behaviors most responsible for HIV transmission in many countries. The drug of choice varies across populations. In Manipur, India, for example, the drug is heroin while in Kolkata it is buprenorphine. In Ukraine, it is a homemade brew made from poppy heads called “poppy straw.” In addition to needle sharing, which can also be responsible for other infections such as hepatitis C, various studies have found injecting drug users (IDUs) to be disproportionately involved in the sex industry or to engage in high-risk sexual activity (UNAIDS, 2001b). IDU contributes to an increased incidence of MTCT among females or female partners of IDUs. It also contributes to increased transmission through other sexual contact between IDUs and non-injectors (UNAIDS, 2001b). Such behaviors create a gateway or “bridge” for HIV to enter non-injecting populations. In Latin America, Eastern Europe, Russia, and the New Independent States, nascent epidemics are fueled, in large part, by IDU. The New Independent States have the steepest HIV infection curve in the world, and 80 percent of these infections are due to IDU (ICAD, 2001; IHRD, 2001). In many countries in Asia, including China, Malaysia, and Vietnam, IDU is the primary route of HIV transmission as well (Reid and Costigan, 2002). However, in sub-Saharan Africa, the continent most affected by HIV, IDU is not a major route of transmission. With a comprehensive prevention and harm-reduction strategy, including BCC, it is still possible to reduce HIV prevalence among IDUs in these countries and to prevent the bridging of HIV into the general, non-injecting population through effective, targeted interventions. However, IDUs are hard to reach since their activities are illegal and they can be arrested, prosecuted, jailed, or executed for their use, depending on the country they live in. Moreover, in Asia, Europe, and Eurasia, the majority of IDUs are married, which means that issues around sexual transmission need to be addressed (UNAIDS, 2001b). Therefore, the sexual partners and spouses of IDU form important sub-audiences. Another group at particularly high risk for HIV infection are prisoners. In most countries, strict policies that do not allow the distribution of condoms and clean needles in most prisons heighten the risk of HIV transmission among incarcerated IDUs and other prisoners. (UNAIDS, 1997b)
Formative Research Some of the questions that need to be answered are as follows: l l
What types of drugs are being used and what are their effects on people? Is drug use illegal and, if so, what are the law enforcement policies (e.g., how are various drug users, including IDUs, prosecuted and punished)?
Reaching Special Audiences 159 l l l l l l l
What are the socio-economic profiles and living conditions of IDUs? What kind of language do they use to describe their practices? Do they see themselves at risk of contracting HIV? What knowledge do they have about this? Do people routinely trade sex for drugs? Who injects and with whom? What services exist for IDUs? Is there a needle exchange program? Is drug detox/ treatment available? What are the likely paths of transmission from IDUs to the general public (e.g., sexual partners, including long-term partners, casual partners, and sex workers)?
Strategic Approaches Based on international experience, many organizations working with IDUs try to prevent further infection and promote behavior change through harm reduction at various levels (UNAIDS, 2001b). Harm reduction aims to minimize the personal and social harm of IDU, but not to eliminate drug use. While the eradication of addictive drug use is desirable, in the long run, harm reduction emphasizes the risk of HIV infection. It is a public health approach that focuses on intermediate steps of promoting the use of sterile injection equipment, drug treatment, or substitution programs, rather than disciplinary and penalizing strategies (FHI, 2001). The strategies described below are focused on the role of strategic communication and will help IDUs avoid reusing and sharing contaminated injecting equipment; will encourage them to protect themselves and their sexual partners from sexually transmitted HIV; and will help them gain access to services and treatment to mitigate the harm of IDU. Communication Strategies Advocacy and Social Mobilization: Advocacy and social mobilization strategies, such as broad coalition building, direct lobbying, community consultation, and involvement of IDUs in grassroot mobilization activities have been shown to be effective (Small, 2002). They may be used, for instance, in trying to establish harm-reduction measures such as syringe exchange and methadone maintenance, which have been shown to be quite effective in reducing HIV transmission. However, opposition to implementing these programs persists in many countries (Des Jarlais et al., 2002). The same is usually true for the resistance to distributing condoms in prison. Promotion of Sterile Injection Equipment: Information materials promoting the use of sterile equipment can educate IDUs about ways to inject more safely and how to reduce the risk of sexual transmission though condom use and VCT. Materials should be developed with the help of networks of IDUs, where possible, and can be distributed at health services during peer outreach sessions and at IDU meeting places.
160 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Peer Education: Peers can be very effective at carrying prevention messages to IDUs. Peers may be recovering IDUs or stable IDUs who are able to communicate prevention messages and concepts to their friends, contacts, partners, and community (Vuong et al., 2002). The reason for using peers instead of health professionals is that peers are often able to gain trust and have credibility that outsiders lack. Peers are also more likely to be non-judgmental of injecting behavior than health professionals. Projects can involve peer educators in the distribution of communication materials, condoms, and bleach kits; the provision of referrals to further services; counseling for behavior change and drug treatment; syringe exchange programs; and outreach. Life Skills T raining: One of the best ways to prevent HIV infection is to ensure that young Training: people do not begin to inject drugs at all. In many settings, young people are at risk due to lack of skills, lack of opportunities, boredom, and the presence of drugs in their communities. A communication intervention can best address a young person’s need for the skills it takes to remain drug-free, such as interpersonal skills and thinking skills. Through a life skills training strategy, youth can develop these skills to improve their ability to make choices to protect their health and their future. Life skills training includes interpersonal skills (including partner communication and negotiation), thinking skills (including decision-making and problem solving), and coping skills (including coping with emotions, stress management, and self-esteem). Links to Services R eferral to Health and Social Services: Providing IDUs and their partners with referrals to health and social services can help them maintain their health, prevent HIV, and treat their addictions. They have a constellation of health concerns such as STIs, TB, hepatitis, and abscesses. Programs should make referrals to health care providers who are sensitive to the unique needs of IDUs. These health needs are not always a priority to IDUs, however. Immediate issues like housing, acute poverty, and addiction are often more pressing. Meeting these needs, where possible, will allow individuals to address long-term survival strategies. For this reason, interventions intended for IDUs should develop strong links to social services that are equipped to address these social needs. Outreach: Taking interventions to IDUs rather than expecting them to seek out services is a way to increase the reach of programs. IDUs are often uncomfortable utilizing facilitybased services for many reasons, including criminalization and discrimination, inconvenient hours or locations, cost, and a lack of interest in the services being offered. Reaching into the community and offering services by trained street workers at times and in places that are convenient for IDUs is a potentially more effective approach. Outreach can take the form of offering services in parks, on certain streets, in homes, or during non-working hours. Condom provision, HIV/AIDS communication materials and activities, counseling, needle exchange, and STI services can all be offered through outreach. Partners and family members of IDUs should be addressed as well.
Reaching Special Audiences 161
Needle Exchange: Exchanging clean needles for used, possibly infected ones decreases HIV transmission among IDUs. Studies show that needle exchange does not increase injecting drug behavior (Hagan et al., 2000). Needle exchange can be part of a larger approach to HIV prevention, sometimes referred to as harm reduction. Harm reduction seeks to change the conditions associated with drug use that are responsible for the spread of HIV in the IDU community (Hilton et al., 2001). Needle exchange is a strategy to provide clean injecting equipment to those who need it, and as such, it is a clinical service. Needle exchange is also a means of reaching some of the hardest to reach IDUs with communication strategies like counseling and referral to further services such as VCT, STI treatment, and drug treatment. Needle exchange programs should follow the principles discussed in relation to “outreach” in the previous section. In particular, needle exchange should be provided in places and at times convenient to IDUs. Mobile vans, stationary sites, pharmacies, and 24-hour automated dispensing machines form part of needle exchange strategies. However, providing clean needles to IDUs is illegal in many countries. Thus, the development and implementation of a needle exchange program should be done, if possible, in cooperation with local authorities, police, and communities. Dispensing bleach and information on how to properly clean injecting equipment is another strategy for harm-reduction that should be included in interventions for IDU. Programs can work in conjunction with a needle exchange program or as part of an intervention that does not include needle exchange.
Key Issues to Communicate Programs directed to IDUs must overcome distrust. Using peer educators and involving IDUs in the development of messages and materials is crucial with this audience. l
l l l l l l
l
Create awareness among the general public about transmission through IDU and the role played by stigma and discrimination against IDUs in creating barriers to service access. Train health service providers to be sensitive counselors in service provision for IDUs. Explain the dangers of needle sharing and discourage it as risky behavior. Remind IDUs to disinfect needles before use and show them how to do this. Discuss sexual risk-taking under the influence of drugs. Promote condom use and other safer sex measures, including the reduction of sexual partners. Promote the various services available to IDUs (VCT, needle exchange, detox, counseling, street workers, peer educators) and encourage IDUs to use these services (including how to access them). Promote HIV/AIDS support groups and positive living.
162 Strategic Communication in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic
Challenges and Lessons Learned Legal Issues: Injecting drug use is illegal in most countries of the world. The fact that the intended audiences for interventions are usually criminalized and marginalized makes reaching them challenging. It is difficult to reach out to IDUs and gain trust in order to carry out prevention and harm-reduction interventions, research, and evaluation. IDU networks exist in many western countries, and now increasingly in Asia and Eastern Europe too. Programmers should closely collaborate with these networks. Needle Exchange P rograms: One of the most effective methods of preventing HIV infection Programs: among IDUs is needle exchange, according to most research. However, this type of program remains illegal in many countries of the world. Even in places where needle exchange is legal, funding agencies often do not consider needle exchange a part of their mandate. Further research, education, and lobbying around this issue is needed. An interim solution is linking projects that may not be able to directly provide needle exchange with a needle exchange service provided by another organization in the same region. Stigma and Discrimination: Stigma and discrimination towards IDUs can prevent the effective implementation of programs to prevent HIV infection. Some people believe that IDUs have brought the infection upon themselves and do not deserve to be helped. This attitude can affect the care doctors provide IDU patients, the way police and communities treat them, and the programs that organizations are permitted to implement. Specific lessons learned include the following: Preventing a General Epidemic: Preventing the spread of HIV among IDUs through sexual contact can help contain an epidemic and prevent outbreak into the general public. Interventions designed for IDUs should include strategies and messages concerning safe sexual behavior with long-term partners, casual sexual partners, sex workers, or IDUs engaged in sex work. Sex work is intrinsically connected to injecting drug use, both because people often trade sex for drugs, and because sex workers often inject drugs. Promoting condom use and providing condoms for all IDUs is essential, but it is particularly important to reach men and women who participate in sex work, either as workers or clients. For IDUs, purchasing condoms is likely to be secondary to purchasing drugs, so programs should consider the benefits and drawbacks (e.g., lack of sustainability) of providing free condoms as part of their strategy. IDU interventions that promote faithfulness to one partner or reduction in number of sexual partners are important for the prevention of HIV transmission. Studies show that decreasing the numbers of partners is effective in decreasing HIV prevalence, and that IDUs will decrease their number of sexual partners in response to programs designed to achieve partner reduction (Chitwood et al., 1990). In Asia and the New Independent States, the regions of the world hardest hit by HIV among IDUs, the majority of IDUs are married. The high rate of marriage acts as a platform for discussing “being faithful” in the context of marriage and caring for the health of one’s partner.
Reaching Special Audiences 163
Involving IDUs: Working in partnership with members of the IDU community and seeking input and guidance from the community will greatly enhance the effectiveness of the projects. Because people who inject drugs may face stigma and legal action, it is essential to gain their trust and use their knowledge. Services and Communication Linkages: Clinical services and counseling services for IDUs should be provided together, as far as possible from the same service delivery site and by the same providers, such as peer educators, outreach workers, and health professionals. Program staff must ensure that adequate clinical services are available to support IDUs’ efforts to make the difficult behavior changes that are the goal of counseling and other communication interventions. Community-based groups and NGOs with a history of working with IDUs often have the ability to provide the communication element of IDU interventions and provide referrals to clinical services or offer them on-site. These groups may be in a better position to weave together the communication and clinical elements of the intervention than medical facilities or providers. L ocal R esources: Local NGOs with experience working with IDUs are a valuable resource Resources: for project design and implementation. Groups that already have a history of working well with IDUs are in a good position to help implement HIV prevention activities, and their experience and relationships can be invaluable in tailoring projects to local conditions and needs. Fulfilling Other Needs: HIV prevention is not always the top priority for someone who is injecting drugs; the need for drugs, food, shelter, and other health services may take precedence. For this reason, meeting these needs, or providing referrals to other services that will, is often a necessary part of an intervention designed to reach IDUs with HIV prevention messages. With basic survival needs met, IDUs can look at long-term survival and HIV prevention. Building on Successes: When designing communication interventions for IDUs, program planners should become familiar with what has been implemented in the past and build on proven approaches. There are good peer education and harm-reduction “how-to” manuals available, that contain case studies and examples from all over the world. The UNAIDS website (www.unaids.org) is a good resource for accessing this information.
Case Study: IDUs in New Delhi, India Background: In some cities in India, HIV prevalence among IDUs is as high as 85 percent, whereas the infection rate among the general public is still under 1 percent. This variance makes prevention work with IDUs essential, not only to protect individuals who inject drugs, but also to prevent the virus from seepin