This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
&Y2}- The mapping a—>d is a continuous homomorphism of A into C(^2). Let A be a Banach algebra with identity. A two-sided ideal radA of A is the Jacobson Radical if it is the intersection of all maximal left (right) ideals of A- Equivalently, radA = {a : a(ab) = a(ba) = {0} for all b£A}. A C*-algebra C is a Banach algebra with a conjugation operator * such that (a*)* = a,(ab)* = b* a*, (aa + fib)* = aa* +~J3b* and ||a*a|| = ||a|| 2 for all a,bEC and a, /3GC. A *-homomorphism p of a C*-algebra C is a •-homomorphism from C into C(HP), where Hp is a Hilbert space. If C has an identity e and p(e) = I, then p is unital; if kerp = {0}, p is faithful. It is obvious that p is faithful if and only if p is a *-isometric isomorphism
3
Background
from C onto p(C). Gelfand-Naimark-Segal Theorem Every abstract C*-algebra C with identity admits a faithful unital * -representation p in C(Ti.p) for a suitable Hilbert space fip, i.e., C is isometrically ^-isomorphic to a C*-algebra of operators. Furthermore, ifC is separable, then Hp can be chosen separable. von-Neumann Double Commutant Theorem Let AcC(H) be a unital C*-algebra. Then the closure of A in any of weak operator, strong operator and weak-* topologies is the double commutant A", where A" = {A'}' and A'{T) = {TeC(H) We call A'(T) commutant 1.2
:AT = TA
for all A<=A}.
ofT.
K-Theory of Banach Algebra
.Ko-group. Let A be a Banach algebra with identity, and let e and / be idempotents in A. e and / are said to be algebraic equivalent, denoted by e ~ a / , if there are x, y£A such that xy = e and yx = / ; e and / are said to be similar,denoted by e ~ / , if there is an invertible z&A such that zez"1 = / . It is obvious that e ~ a / and e ~ / are equivalent relations. Let M^A) be the set of all finite matrices over A, Proj(A) be the set of algebraic equivalent classes of idempotents in A. Set \/(A) = Proj(M'00(A)), then \J(Mn(A)) is isomorphic to \J(A). If Pi Q a r e idempotents in Proj(A), p~ s q if and only if p®r~aq®r for some rGProj(A), then "~ 3 " is called stable equivalence. KQ{A) is the Grothendieck group generated by \J{A) [B. Blackadar [1]]. The pair (G,G+) is said to be an ordered group if G is an abelian group and G+ is a subset of G satisfying i. G+ + G+CG+; ii. G+n(~G+) = {0}; iii. G+ - G+ = G. An ordered relation "<" can be defined in G by x
Let A, Ai and Ai be Banach algebras and A =
Ai®A2,
for
4
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
then
\J(A)* \J(At)® \f(A2), K0(A)cK0(A1)®K0(A2), \J(Mn(A))~ \J(A) and K0(Mn(A))~K0(A), where "~" means isomorphism. Let A and B be two Banach algebras and let a be a homomorphism from A into B. Then there is a homomorphism a* induced by a from K0(A) into K0(B). Six-Term Exact Sequence Let A be a unital Banach algebra and let J be its ideal, then we have the following standard exact sequence
and the following exact cyclic sequence Ko(J) d] ffiCA/J)
^K0(A)^K0(A/J) d[ « — f f i ( 4 ) «— Kx{J),
where K\(B) is the Ki-group of Banach algebra B.
1.3
The Basic of Complex Geometry
Let A be a manifold with a complex structure and let n be a positive integer. (E, 7r) is called a holomorphic vector bundle of rank n over A if n is a holomorphic map from E onto A such that each fibre Ex = 7r -1 (x) is isomorphic to C n (a;eA) and such that for each zo£A, there exist a neighborhood A of zQ and holomorphic functions e\{z), e2{z)^ • • • , en(z) from A to E such that e\{z), e2(z), • • • , en(z) form a basis of Ez = ir~1(z) for each zeA. The functions e\, e2, • • • ,en are said to be a holomorphic frame for E on A. The bundle is said to be trivial if A can be assigned to A. Let E and F be two holomorphic bundles over a complex manifold A. A map (p from E to F is a bundle map if
F\ is a linear transformation for every AeA. A Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle E over A is a holomorphic bundle such that each fibre E\ is an inner product space. Two Hermitian )} for z€C, then Q is called an outer function, where c is a constant and \c\ — 1. The Blaschke product is a class of inner functions with the form ([AB]) = ?( [A]) ¥>([£]) = A ^ A B and ip is an isomorphism. (iii)=>(iv). Let ip be an isomorphism from Ao(S)/radAo(S) to C. Then (ii). It follows from Gelfand Theory. (ii)=^(iii). First we consider A = A/radA. For xGradA, (iv). For arbitrary x, y, z£A, a(xyz) = {p(xyz) : ipGx(A)} = { (i). Given x,y£A,
Background
5
holomorphic vector bundles E and F over A are said to be equivalent if there exists an isometric holomorphic bundle map from E onto F. Let H be a separable complex Hilbert space and let n be a positive integer. Denote Gr(n,H), the Grassmann manifold, the set of all n- dimensional subspaces of H. For an open connected subset A of C fc , a map / : A—>G r (n,H) is said to be holomorphic if at each AoGA there is a neighborhood A of Ao and n holomorphic W-valued functions n
^i(z),e2(z),-"
>e„(z) such that f(z) = V ( e j( 2 )}-
If
/
:
^—>G r (n,K) is
3=1
a holomorphic map, then an n-dimensional Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle Ef over A and a map
Ef.=
{(x,z)eHxA:xef(z)}
and (j): Ef—>A,<j){x,z) = zeA. Given two holomorphic maps / and g : A—>Gr(n,'H), we have two vector bundles Ef and Eg over A. If there exists a unitary operator U on H such that g = Uf, then / and g are said to be unitarily equivalent. If there is an open subset A of A such that Ef\& is unitarily equivalent to •Eg I A! then Ef and Eg are said to be locally unitarily equivalent. Rigidity Theorem Let A be an open connected subset of Cfc and let f and g be holomorphic maps from A to Gr(n, TCj such that
V /(*) = V aw = HzeA zeA Then f and g are unitarily equivalent if and only if Ef and Eg are locally unitarily equivalent. 1.4
Some Results on Cowen-Douglas Operators
Let Q be a connected open subset of C, n is a positive integer, the set Bn(Q) of Cowen-Douglas Operators of index n is the set of operators T&JC(H) satisfying
(i)
Oca(r);
(ii) r a n ( z - T ) := {(z - T)x : x£H} = H for each z€fi; (iii) V/ fcer(* -T) = H\ (iv)
dimker(z — T) = n for each zefi.
6
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
It can be proved that if Qo is a nonempty open subset of fi, then Bn(£i)cBn{yio). For an operator T£Bn(fl), the mapping z\—>ker(z — T) defines a Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle of rank n. Let (ET,TT) denote the subbundle of trivial bundle QxH given by ET := {(z,x)eflxH : xeker(z-T)
and n(z,x) = z}.
Let A'(T) be the commutant of T, i.e., A'{T) := {A&C{H) : TA = AT}, then for TeS„(fi), there is a monomorphism TT from ^4'(T) into H™,E JQ) satisfying TTX = X\ker{z_T) for XeA'(T) and zeft, or r T X ( z ) = ker(z-T) '•— X(z), where -ff^(j5;T)(^) is the set of all bounded bundle endomorphisms from E? to ETTo summarize the above and Section 1.3, we can find a holomorphic frame (ei(z), • • • ,en(z)) such that n
ker(z-T)
= \/ ek(z), ZGQ for TeB„(fi).
Fix a zoSfi, denote Hi = ker(z0 - T ) , H2 = ker(z0 - T)2Qker(z0 Hm = ker(zQ - T)mQker(zQ
- T), - T)" 1 " 1 .
We have: Theorem CD1 [Cowen, M.J. and Douglas, R. (1977)] m
(i)
E ©Wfc = V ( e
fc=i
...
(*o) : l < i < « , 0
00
r«; E®-Hk = n; k=l
(Hi) {el- (zo) : l<j
—
The following theorems will often be used in the chapters hereafter. Theorem H [Herrero, D.A. (1990)] IfTeBn(Q), then ap{T*) = 0, where T* is the adjoint ofT and o~p(T*) is the point spectrum ofT*. Theorem J W 1 [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1998)] Let Te6„(fi) and let Pz be the orthogonal projection from H onto ker(z — T) for z£fl, then (I — Pz^heriz-T)1- *s similar to T.
Background
7
Theorem J W 2 [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1998)] Let TeC(H). For given numbers > 0, there exist a positive integer n and Cowen-Douglas operators {Ai}\=1, {bj}? = i +1 such that
F-(®^)©(® s*)||<£. j=i
i=i+i
Theorem J W 3 [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1998)] Given TeBi(fl), there exist compact operators K\,K2,--- ,Kn,--- with \\Ki\\ < 7^- such that T + Ki&Bi(Q) and kerTT+K,T+K, = {0},i ^ j , where TA,B is the Rosenblum operator from C(H) to C(H) given by TA,B(X) = AX — XB forXeC{H). 1.5
Strongly Irreducible Operators
Operator T is strongly irreducible if there is no nontrivial idempotent in A'(T) ([Gilfeather, F. (1972)], [Jiang, Z.J. (1979)], [Jiang, Z.J. (1981)]). Operator T is irreducible if there is no nontrivial orthogonal projection in A'(T) ([Halmos, P.R. (1968)]). It is obvious that strongly irreducibility is invariant under similarity while irreducibility is just unitarily invariant. Denote (57) and (IR) the set of all strongly irreducible operators and irreducible operators, respectively, on H. Let K{l-L) be the ideal of compact operators on H and let •K : £(H)^A(H)
:= C{H)/1C(H)
be the canonical quotient mapping, A(H) is called the Calkin algebra. The essential spectrum of operator T is ae (T) = {AsC : A—ir(T) is not invertible in A{H)} and the Predholm domain of T is pF(T) = C\ae(T). It is well known that o-e{T) = ale{T)U
aifr(T))
are(T) :=
O-T(TT{T)).
and
8
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
Operator T is a Fredholm operator if 0€PF(T). T is a semi-Fredholm operator if the range of T, ranT, is closed and either nulT := dimkerT or nulT* := dimkerT* is finite. In this case the index indT of T is defined by indT := nulT - nulT*. The Wolf spectrum aire (T) of T is given by alre(T)
:=
are(T)nale(T)
and PS-F{T) := C\oire(T) is the semi-Fredholm domain of T. The spectral picture A(T) of T consists of the compact set <7;re(T) and the index ind{T— A) on the bounded connected components of ps-F(T). Spectral picture theorem of strongly irreducible operators [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1996b)] Let T be in C(H) with connected spectrum cr(T). Then there exists a strongly irreducible operator L satisfying (i) A ( L ) = A ( T ) ; (ii) TeS(L)-; (Hi) If there is another strongly irreducible operator L\ with A(Li) = A(T), then L\ES(L)~, where S(L) is the similarity orbit of L, i.e., S(L) := {XTX-1 and S{L)~ is the norm closure
: Xe£(H)
is invertible}
ofS(L).
Spectral picture theorem of Cowen-Douglas operators [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1998)] Let T be in C(H) with connected a(T) and a(T)\p®_F(T). If pp{T) ^ 0, then there exists a Cowen-Douglas operator A&(S I) such that A(T) = A(A) and if there is another operator B&S(T)~, P°S-F(T)
:= {\£ps-F(T)na(T)
then BGS(A)~,
where
: ind(X - T) = 0}.
9
Background
Commutant theorem of strongly irreducible operators [Fang, J.S. and Jiang, C.L. (1999)] Operator T is strongly irreducible if and only if a (A) is connected for each A in A'(T). The following theorem will be used frequently in this book. Theorem CD2 [Cowen, M.J. and Douglas, R. (1977)] ator in B\(fl) is strongly irreducible.
1.6
Each oper-
Compact Perturbation of Operators
We introduce only two famous theorems on compact perturbation of operator here. Brown-Douglas-Fillmore theorem / / T\ and T2 are essentially normal operators on Ti, then a necessary and sufficient condition that T\ be unitarily equivalent to some compact perturbation of T2 is that o-e(Ti) = o-e(T2) and ind{\ — T\) ~ ind{\ — T2) for ««A^cr e (Ti). An operator T is essentially normal if T*T — TT* is compact. Voiculescu's theorem Let T£C(H) and p be a unital faithful *representation of a separable C* -subalgebra of the Calkin algebra A(H) containing the canonical images n(T) and n(I) on a separable space Ti.p. Let A •= p(w(T)) and k be a positive integer. Given e > 0, there exists KeK,(H), with \\K\\ < e, such that T -
K^T®A^^T®A^k\
where "=" means unitarily equivalent.
1.7
Similarity Orbit Theorem
Complex number A is a normal eigenvalue of T if A is an isolated point of cr(T) and the dimension of H(X,T), the range of the Riesz idempotent
10
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
corresponding to A, is finite. Denote the set of all normal eigenvalues of T by ao(T). The minimal index of A — T, AS/0s_ir(T), is defined by min-ind{\
— T) := min{nul(X — T), nul(X — T)*}.
Similarity orbit theorem Given T, Ae.C(H) satisfying (i)
Toeplitz Operator and Sobolev Space
Let D and C be the open unit disk and unit circle in the complex plane respectively, and let p, be the Lebesgue measure on C, normalized so that fi(C) = 1. If e„(z) = zn for ZGC and n = 0, ± 1 , ±2, • • •, then {e n , —oo < n < +00} is an orthonormal basis (ONB) for L2(C, p). Let H2 := span{en : n>0} and H°° = L°°(C,fi)nH2. If P is the orthogonal projection from L2(C,p) onto H2 and if ^eL 0 0 (C,p), then the Toeplitz operator T$ with symbol <j> is defined by T+f = P{cpf) for all feH2. If is a positive measurable function on C such that logcpGL1 (C', p) and if Q(z) = c-exp{fc ^^log
where k>0, c e C , with \c\ = 1 and {A.,} is a sequence of nonzero numbers 00
in D satisfying J2 (1 — l^jl) < +00.
Background
11
Factorization theorem If f&H2 and / ^ 0, then f is the product of an inner function m and an outer function Q, i.e., f = mQ. Beurling's theorem A subspace H\ of H2 is invariant under the operator Tz if and only if Hi = 4>H2 := {<j)f : f&H2} for some inner function
4>. Let Q be an analytic Cauchy domain in the complex plane and let W22(Q.) be the Sobolev space „W22 ,„,„,
f „
Tn,^
M:=[feL2(n,dm):
, x the distributional derivative of first and ] secondorderof/belongtojL2(Adm)
where dm denotes the planar Lebesque measure. For f,geWn(tt), we define (/,) = £ jDafD^g~dm,
then
)
W22(fl)
\a\<2
is a Hilbert space and a Banach algebra with identity under an equivalent norm. By Sobolev embedding theorem, f&W22(fl) implies that f£C(Q) and ll/llc(n)<M|l/llw»(n) for some M > 0. Thus a sequence of functions {fn}^Li converges to / in W22(Q) implies that / „ converges to / uniformly on Q. For f£W22(Q,), the multiplication operator Mf on W22(Q) is defined as follows Mfg = fg,
geW22(Q).
Let W(ti) := {Mf : feW22(Q)}, then W(fl) is a strictly cyclic operator algebra with strictly cyclic vector e(s,t) = 1. An operator algebra A on a Hilbert space 7i is said to be strictly cyclic if there exists a separating vector e such that Ae := {Ae : AGA}
= H.
Theorem J W 4 [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1996a)] (i) a(Mz) = aire(Mz) = H ; (it) A'(Mz) = W(fl); (Hi) Aa(Mz) = R(Q), where Aa(Mz) is the algebra generated by the rational function of Mz with poles outside fi and R(i}) is the closure in W22(Q) of all rational functions with poles outside fl.
Chapter 2
Jordan Standard Theorem and K0- Group 2.1
Generalized Eigenspace and Minimal Idempotents
Recall that a kxk Jordan block X 1 A
0"
Jk(X) = 0
1 A.
has the following properties (i) Jfc(A) is strongly irreducible on Ck, i.e., there is no nontrivial idempotent in A'(Jk(X))\ (ii) nul(X- Jfc(A)) = l,ker(X-Jk(X)y g ker(XJk{X))i+l,l<j
B = o-k
• • • a-2
= 1,2,-
, fc\
a\_
It follows from (iii) directly that (iv) A'(Jk(X))/radA'(Jk(X))~C. For j4eM n (C) and XGCT(A), ker(X — A) is called the eigenspace of A related to A. If there is a positive integer m,m < n, such that ker(X - A)m = ker(X -
A)m+1,
then ker(X — A)m is called the generalized eigenspace of A related to A. By 13
Structure
14
of Hilbert Space
Operators
elementary matrix theory, we have the following proposition. Proposition 2.1.1 Let Ae.Mn(C) and \£a(A) with nul(X - A) = 1 and let M be the generalized eigenspace of A related to X, then A\tf~Jk{X) for some k,k < n. A nonzero idempotent PGA'(T) is minimal, if for each idempotent Q&A'(T), ranQcranP implies Q = 0. Proposition 2.1.2 Let A&Mn(C) and let P be a minimal idempotent in A'(A), then there exists a number AsC, such that ^4|ranP~«^fc(A), where k = dimranP. Proof Since PEA'(T), ranP and ran(I — P) are invariant subspaces of A. {Claim 1} B :— A\ranp has a unique eigenvalue XB- Otherwise, it follows from the theory of linear algebra that P is not minimal. {Claim 2} B is strongly irreducible and UUI{XB — B) = 1. Since P is minimal, BG(SI). Using the basic theory of linear algebra and the fact that P is minimal again, we have HUI{XB — B) = 1. Thus the proposition is a conclusion of Proposition 2.1.1. Let {Afc}£=1 be all of the eigenvalues of A e M n ( C ) , the multiplicity is included, by Proposition 2.1.2 and the theory of matrix, we have the next proposition. Proposition 2.1.3 {PxiliLi such that (i)
Let A€Mn{C),
then there exist minimal idempotents
E Pxk = / c - and PXk Px3 = 0 for k ± j ; fc=i
(ii)
A\ ranP\.
~Jmfc(Afc), where rrik =
dimranP\k;
n
(Hi) A = Y, +A\ranP^ • 2.2
Similarity Invariant of Matrix
Jordan standard theorem Let A£Mn(C), sum of finitely many Jordan blocks, i.e., i
A~Q)Jmk(Xk). k=i
then A is similar to a direct
Jordan Standard
Theorem and
Ko-Group
15
By Propositions 2.1.2, 2.1.3 and Jordan standard theorem, the similarity of two nxn matrices A and B depends completely on their eigenvalues and generalized eigenspaces. A quantity (or quantities) or property (or properties) V is similarity invariant if operator A has V and A~B imply B has V. For a subset 11 of C(H), similarity invariant (or invariants) V is completely similarity invariant if AGTZ, then A~B if and only if BE.% and A and B have same V. One of our aims is to find or determine complete similarity invariants of operators. But if H is an infinite dimensional separable Hilbert space, it is very difficult to obtain complete similarity invariant of operators in £(7i). As a matter of fact, some operators in £(Ji) even have no eigenvalues. To provide a new idea for finding of the similarity invariants of Hilbert space operators, we interpret the Jordan standard theorem in the view point of i^o-theory. The propositions below are from [Blanckdar, B. (1986)] and [Aupetit, B. (1991)]. Proposition 2.2.1 K0(Mn(C))^Z and V(M n (C))^N, where N {0,1, 2, • • • } andZ = {0, ± 1 , ±2, • • • }.
=
Proposition 2.2.2 Let A be a unital Banach algebra and let P be an idempotent in A and R&adA. If P + R is still an idempotent in A, then there exists an invertible element XGA such that X{P + R)X_1 = P. We know that A'{Jk(X))/radA'{Jk{X))=C for each Jordan block Jfc(A). If P is an idempotent in A'(Jk(ty), it follows from the structure of A'(Jk(X)) that P = ICk + R, where R is a lower triangular idempotent. Thus P~A'{Jk(\))Ic>< by Proposition 2.2.2. From Proposition 2.2.1 and the definition of .RVgroup, we have the following proposition. Proposition 2.2.3 Lemma 2.2.4
\J{A'{Jk{X)))^N
Let A\, A2€(SI)
and
K0(A'{Jk(X)))=Z.
satisfying i = 1,2,
then at least one of the following is true (i) AX~A2; (ii) If X,Ye£{H) with AXX = XA2 and YAx =• A2Y, then XYeradA'(Ai) and YXGradA'(A2). Proof If A\ is not similar to A2 and AXX = XA2, YA\ = A2Y. Thus AXXY
= XA2Y
= XYAX
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
16
and XYtA'iAi). If XY&radA'iAx), then XY = A + R for some AeC,A ^ 0 and R&radA'{Ai), since ^'(A^/racM'(;4i)5=!C. Therefore XY is invertible. Similarly, YX is invertible. This implies that X and Y" are both invertible, i.e., Ai~A2. The contradiction indicates that XYGradA'{A\). Similarly, YX&adA'{A2). i
Lemma 2.2.5
Let A£(Mn(C)),
then A'{A)/radA'(A)^
*£
Mki(C),
i=l
where k\ + k2 H Proof
\-ki—n.
By Proposition 2.1.3 and Proposition 2.1.2, we have m
A~^®Jfci(Ai). i=l
For simplicity we prove the lemma for m = 2 and consider the following two cases. {Case 1} k\ = k2 and Ai = A2, therefore Jfc^Ai) = Jk2{^2)- A simple computation indicates that 0"
Oil
A'(A) = <
a2
An A12 A21 A22
Oil
012 Oil.
Oik
from which we have
radA'(A) = <
Ru -R12
0 a 0
0
Ri
>.
R21 R22
/?••• a 0 Thus A'(A)/radA'(A)^M2{C). {Case 2} fci ^ k2 or Ai ^ A2. If k\ ^ k2, without loss of generality we assume that k\ > k2. By Lemma 2.2.4, if XGkerTj ( hJ (A } and YekerTj .. w .. ., then XY&adA'(JkM),YX&adA'{Jk2(\2)).
Jordan Standard Theorem and KQ-Group
17
Set J =
Xn X±2 X21 X22
XneradA'(JkM), X22eradA'(Jk2(X2)),
X12X21&adA'(Jkl^i)) X21X12£radA'(Jk2(\2))
It is easily seen that J is a two sided ideal of A'(A).
}•
We claim that
Xu - A X\2 X2\ X22 — A is invertible for each A 7^ 0 and Xu X2i
Xi2 &J. X22
In fact, observing that 1 0 -(Xn-A)-1!
Xu — A XX2 X2\ X22 — A
X\\ — A X\2 0 (X22-A)-X12(X11-A)-1X2i. where Xl2(Xlx
- \yxX2X&adA\J^{\2)). (X22 — A) - X\2{Xii
is invertible. Therefore
Thus — X)~
X2\
X\\ — A X12 is invertible. X21 X22 — A
The claim above indicates that CF{X) — {0} for each X&J.
Thus
J = radA'(A) and A'(A)/radA'(A)^C®C. This complete the proof. 1
Theorem
2.2.6
Let
AeMn(C)
and
i4~E®4W(ni).
i/ien V(-^'(^))=N ( Z ) and K0(A'(A))^Z«\ where Jki{Xi)(ni) orthogonal direct sum of rii copies of Jki{Xi).
denotes the
18
Structure of Hilbert Space
Proof
By Lemma 2.2.5, A'(A)/radA'(A)S*
Operators
£ ©M„,(C). By Proposition i=l
2.2.2 and Proposition 2.2.3 we have
i
\ / { E ®^(C)}SN("
\/(A'(A))= \j{A'{A)/radA'(A)}^
2=1
and K0(A'(A))=iZ^. Theorem 2.2.6 is another form of Jordan standard theorem. The following result gives the complete similarity invariant for matrices in terms of ifo-grc-up. m
Theorem 2.2.7
Let A,BeMn{C)
and A = £ © 4 ? i=i
and Aki is not similar to Akj for i ^ j . Then A~B exists an isomorphism h such that
with
Akie{SI)
if and only if there
h(K0(A'(A®B)))^ZW and h[IA,(A@B)} = 2niei + 2n2e2 + ••• + 2nkek, where 0 ^ n i £ N , i = 1, 2, • • • , k, {e,}^ =1 are the generators of the semigroup N ' m ' of Z^"1' and IA'(A®B) is the identity of A'(A®B). m
Proof
If A~B,
,„
then A®B~ £ ®A£ni).
.
The "necessary" part follows
i=l
from Theorem 2.2.6. Proof of "Sufficient" part.
Since
BGM„(C),
B ~ £ ®Bk
>
where
j=l
Bkj£(SI), and
Bkj + Bkj, if j rf, f.
It follows from
h[lA'(A
h(K0(A'(A®B)))^Z^ + 2nkek
that I = m. By Lemma 2.2.4, for each i?fc. there exists an Ak. such that Bkj~Aki and m^ = n s . This implies that A~B. 2.3
Remark
Theorem 2.2.6 and Theorem 2.2.7 are different forms of Jordan standard theorem and can be obtained in different ways. Lemma 2.2.4 is due to [Cao, Y., Fang, J.S. and Jiang, C.L.(2002)].
Chapter 3
Approximate Jordan Theorem of Operators
In the operator theory of finite dimensional space, or in matrix theory, Jordan canonical theorem is one of the core contents. The Jordan theorem gives the complete similarity invariant of matrices. But in the infinite dimensional Hilbert space case, it is very difficult to find complete similarity invariant for operators. We can only give an approximate Jordan theorem, or obtain complete similarity invariant for some special class of operators. In this chapter, we give some different kinds of approximate Jordan theorems considering strongly irreducible operators as the replacement of Jordan blocks in matrix theory.
3.1
Sum of Strongly Irreducible Operators
[Radjaval, H. and Rosenthal, P. (1973)] proved that every operator in C(Ti.) is a sum of two irreducible operators. In this section, we will prove the following result. Theorem 3.1.1 Every bounded linear operator on H. is a sum of two strongly irreducible operators. In order to prove the theorem, we need the following lemmas. Lemma 3.1.2 Assume that Te£(H) with indT = —1 and min-indT = 0. If B\ and B2 are two left inverses ofT and eo is a unit vector in (ranT)-1, then there exists an f£H such that B\ — B2 + /<8>eo. Proof Set f =(B1B2)e0 and A = B1-B2/<8>e0. Since indT = - 1 and since min-indT = 0, ranT is closed and dim^anT)1= 1. Thus for each XGH, there is a number a€C and x\€H such that x = ae^ + Tx\. 19
20
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Since BiT = B2T = I, Ax = a{Bi - B2)e0 + B{Txi - B2Txx - a = af + X1-X1af- < Txi,e0 > f = 0.
eo -
(f®e0)Tx!
Thus, A = 0 and B\ = B2 + f®e0. Lemma be a unit ThenTB Proof and y€7i
3.1.3 Let TGC(H) with indT = — 1 and min-indT = 0. Let eo vector in (ranT)1- and B be a left inverse of T with Beg = 0. = 1 -e0®e0. Set A = TB + e0(g>eo — / . Since for each XGH there exist a e C such that x = aeo + Ty,
Ax = aTBeo + TBTy + a(e 0 ®eo)e 0 4- (e 0 ®e 0 )Tj/ — ae0 — Ty = 0 + Ty + ae0 + 0-ae0-Ty = 0. Thus A = 0 and TB = I - e0
Given T, eo and B as that in Lemma 3.1.3.
If
thenTe(SI).
P r o o f If there is a nontrivial idempotent PGA'(T), kerT* is an invariant subspace of P*. Since indT = —1 and min-indT = 0, dimkerT* = 1. Therefore, P*eo = Aeo and A = 0 or A = 1. Assume that A = 0 (otherwise consider I — P), then P =
0 0
Q IranP'
kerP ranP*
and
T=
T i T12
0 T2
kerP ranP*.
Set
x=
IkerP
Q
0
IranP'
kerP ranP* ' p =
X-'-PX
0
0
0
IranP*
kerP ranP*
and f = X-1TX =
T: 0 0 T2
kerP ranP*.
Note that P* = P , PeA'(f),indf = - 1 and min-indf = 0. Thus Ti and T2 are injective with closed ranges and indT\ + indT2 = indT = — 1. Assume that e 0 = ei + e2, where eiGkerP and e2€ranP*. Since P*eo = 0 and e 0 ^ 0,ei ^ 0 and Q*ei = - e 2 . Since Tj*ei + T^ex + T2*e2 = 0, Ti*ei = 0. Thus indTi = - 1 and indT2 = 0. This implies that T2 is
Approximate
21
Jordan Theorem of Operators
invertible and T\ is left invertible. Suppose that B2 is the inverse of T 2 and B\ is a left inverse of Ti satisfying kerB\ = (ranTi)1-. Thus Biei = 0. Set Bt 0 0 B2
B =
kerP ranP* '
then B is a left inverse of f and BP = PB. Set B = X ^ R X " , then B is also a left inverse of T. It follows from T*ei = T,*ei = 0 that jrhi is a unit vector in (ranT)1-. By Lemma 3.1.2, there exists a vector / such that J5 = B + /®ijU|. From-BX^eo = X ^ B e o = 0,Xe o = e 0 + Q e 2 + e 2 and BXeo = 0, we have: 0 = 6(ei + Qe2 + c 2 ) = 5 i e i + 5 i Q e 2 + 5 2 e 2 + < e2, ^
> / + < Qe 2 , p ^ > /
= 5! Qe2 + £ 2e2 + | | e 1 | | / - g | r / . If e 2 ^ 0, it follows from BiQe2±B2e2 Thus /:
ei 2
|e2|| -||e1||2
and B2e2 7^ 0 that BiQe2+B2e2
BxQe2 +
ei
Ml 2 -INI 2
^ 0.
B2e2
and D
1
" 1
"r
B
BiQe20ei
l l « . „ l | 2 _ n „ , 112
I|e2|r-||ei|| j?2£2®ei
IMP-IK
n
<J
52
kerP ranP*
Moreover, herP - $$•
+ Qe2®el - < 2 | a ^ e i ® e i
0
TB =
(3.1.1) e?<»ei e2<»
i-ranP*
By Lemma 3.1.3, TB = I — eo®eo = I — ei®ei — e\
e\ - e2
Therefore,
TB
-e 2 ®ei *
kerP ranP*
(3.1.2)
Structure
22
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Compare (3.1.1) with (3.1.2) we have
INI 2 - INI 2 = 1. Since || e i || 2 + ||e 2 || 2 = ||e 0 || 2 = 1, ||e 2 || = 0 and e 2 = 0. Thus, Pe0 = Pex = 0. Therefore, T{PB - BP) = P(TB) -
(TB)P
= P(I - e 0 ®e 0 ) - (/ - e 0 <8e 0 )P = - ( P e 0 ) ® e 0 + e 0 ®P*e 0 = 0.
But T is injective, thus PB - BP = 0, i.e., PB = BP. This contradicts B&(SI). Therefore TG(SI) and the proof of the proposition is now complete. Lemma 3.1.5 Let A, S&C(H), \\A\\ < \ and let S be the froward unilateral shift. Then for each A G C with |A| < | , S + A — A is a Fredholm operator and ind(S + A - A) = - 1 , min-ind(S + A - X) = 0. Proof
Note that for each x£H, \\(S + A-
X)x\\>\\Sx\\ - \\Ax\\ - | A | H > ( 1 - piDllzll.
Thus S + A — A is bounded below, ran(S + A — A) is closed and dimker(S + A - A) = 0,min-ind(S + A-
X) = 0.
On the other hand, it follows from | | ( ^ - A)5*|| < 1 that I + (A - X)S* is invertible. Therefore, ind{S + A - A) = ind[S + {A-
X)S*S]
= ind[(I + (A - X)S*)S] = ind[I +{A-
X)S*} + indS
= 0 + (-l) = - l .
Approximate
23
Jordan Theorem of Operators
Thus S + A — A is a Fredholm operator. Lemma 3.1.6
Assume that Te£(H),
X0eC,ind(T
- A0) = - 1 and
min-ind(T — Ao) = 0. Then T~T\ran(T_\0). Proof Define X : H —> ran(T - A0) by Xx = (T - A0)x for x€H. Since ran(T — Ao) is closed and T — Ao is injective, X is invertible. Note that T\ran{T-x0)Xx
= T(T - X0)x = (T-
\0)Tx
=
XTx,
thus T\ran(T-\o)X
=
XT,
i.e., T\ran(T-\0)~T.
Lemma 3.1.7 Given matrix representation
AGC(H)
A =
that admits the following lower triangular
"Ao a2\ 0 a32 0
0
eo ei e2
(3.1.3)
with respect to the ONB {efc}£L0. 7/||A|| < | , then (S + A)*e#i(fi), where S is the unilateral shift. Proof Since ||A|| < \ and |A0| < \, ind(S + A - A) = - 1 and min-ind(S + A - A) = 0 for |A| < - . Thus (S + A - A)* is surjective and nul(S + A - A)* = 1. In particular, ker(S + A-
A0)* = {ae0 : aGC}.
Therefore ran(S + A - A0) = \J{ek : fc>l} := Hx. Set T = (S + A)\Hl. Lemma 3.1.6, S + A~T. Thus r a n ( T - A ) * = Hi
By
24
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
and nul{T - A)* = 1 for all AGfi := {A : |A| < i } . Clearly, T* admits a strict upper triangular matrix representation with respect to {ek}^Li- Thus \J{kerT*k,k>l}
= Hi.
This implies that T*eBi(ft). Thus (S + 4)*eSi(fi). Lemma 3.1.8 Given matrix representation
that admits the following upper triangular
BGC(H)
0
eo
&22
ei e2
0 0
B = 0
with respect the ONB {ek}f=0. If \\B\\ < 1, then S + BG(SI), the unilateral shift. Proof Since \\BS*\\ < 1, (I + BS*) is invertible. Set A = S*(l +
where S is
BS*)-\
Thus A - A = S*(I + BS*)-1^ - \{I + BS*)S) for |A| < \\I + BS*\\-\ Note that (/ — X(I + BS*)S) is invertible. Therefore, A — A is surjective and nul(A — A) = 1. Since A admits a strict upper triangular matrix representation with respect to the ONB {efc}£L0, \J{kerAk,k>l} = H. 1 Denote D, = { A G C : |A| < (1 + HSU)- }, then AeB^Q.) and AG(SI). Because of A{S + B) = A(I + BS*)S = I, A is a left inverse of S + B and Ae0 = A(e0 + BS*e0) = A(I + BS*)e0 = S*(I + BS*)-1(I
+ BS*)e0
= S*e0 = 0. It is easy to see that eo£[ran(S + B)}1-. By Proposition 3.1.4, S +
Be(SI).
Approximate
Lemma 3.1.9 representation
25
Jordan Theorem of Operators
Let BEC(?{)
admit the following upper triangular matrix
b13
0 bu
B
&22 ^23
•••
eo
*
ei
0
with respect the ONB {ek}kL0- If\\B\\ < a S C satisfying
then there exist
JQ,
(ii) \\B\\ < I and B admits the following matrix 0 0
0
•••
and
representation
eo
^22 &23 ' • '
B =
BGC(H)
ei e2 ;
&33
0
(Hi) S + B + ae0®e0~S + B and S + B + ae0®eo£(SI), where S is the unilateral shift. Proof Denote H 0 = {Ae0 : AeC}, Hi = V{e™ : n > l } . Then S =
0 0 ei
Ho Hi
and
0e0®/ 0 B±
B
Ho Hi
under the decomposition of the space H = Ho ©Hi. Note that Si is unitarily equivalent to S, i.e., Si=S. Set g = Si(IHl
+ SiB*i)~lf
J2(-±)nSi(SiB*i)nf.
= 71=0
Then 5-Lei and
n*n< f > r 111/1 = ! ! %
10
i=0
Since / = B*e0, ||/||<||fl*|| < ^ . Therefore || 5 || < §. Let a = - < ei,g >, n | a | < | | / | | < £,i.e. a satisfies (i). Set B =
"0 0 Ho 0 Bi + e i O g Hi
26
Structure of Hilberi Space
Operators
i.e., B = B - e 0 ® / + eiC Then \B\\ = \\Bx+e&g\\<\\B\\
+
\\g\\
and "0 0 B =
0 •••" eo
&22 ^23 • ' •
ei
.0 i.e., B satisfies (ii). Set X =
0 J Wl
i.e., X = I + eo®g. It is obvious that X is invertible and X Note that X-1(S
x
= I — eoi
+ B + ae0®e0)X
eoQs>e0 — e0<x> 0 IWl
ae 0 ®e 0
e0®/
eoQjeo e 0 ®g 0 IWl
a e 0 ® e 0 - (e 0 ®9)(e 1 <8>e 0 ) e 0 ® / - (eo®g)(Si + Bx) ei<8»eo 5i+Bi
0
a e 0 ® e 0 - < ei,g > (e 0 ®e 0 ) e 0 ® / - e 0 ®(5i + B\)*g ei®e 0 Si + B\
eo®e 0 e 0 ® g 0 /Wl .
0 0 ei<8>e0 S i + £?i
/Wl J
eo®eo e 0 ®g
L 0
/ Hl J
0 0 ei®e 0 ei®g + Si + Bx = S + B, i.e., S + B + a e 0 ® e 0 ~ 5 + B. By Lemma 3.1.8, S + Be(SI). S +B +
ae0®e0£(SI).
Therefore,
Approximate
Jordan Theorem of Operators
27
The following lemma is due to [Jiang, C.L. and Wu, P.Y. (1998)]. Lemma 3.1.10 For given TeC(H), there exist ONB { e f c } ^ 0 and A,B£C(H) satisfying (i) T = A + B; (ii) A admits a strict lower triangular matrix representation with respect to {efc}£L0; (Hi) B admits an upper triangular matrix representation with respect to {ek}%0. We are now in a position to prove Theorem 3.1.1. Proof of Theorem 3.1.1 By Lemma 3.1.9, we can find ONB {efc}£L0 and A\, B\ &£(H) such that T = A\ -f B\, A\ is strict lower triangular and B\ is upper triangular with respect to {efc}^ :1 . Denote b =< Bieo,eo >, then b is the upper left entry of the upper triangular matrix of Bi. Set Ai = A\ + 6eo®e0, Bi = B\ - be0®e0 and r = B3 rB2. 10(||A 2 || + ||B 2 || + 1)
Then || — -S3 j| < 375 a n d —B3 admits the following matrix representation 0 * *
eo ei e2
-B3 0
with respect to {efc}£L0. By Lemma 3.1.9, there is an aGC with |a| < § such that S — B3 + aeo®eo£(SI), where S is the unilateral shift. Denote Ti
1
(S - Bi + ae0
then TiG(57). Let A3 = rAi + aeo®eo and AQ = rb + a, then ||^4.i||
28
Structure of Hilbert Space
|Ao|<|r-6| + H < i By Lemma 3.1.7, S + A3G{SI).
+
Operators
i
Define T2 = ±(S +A3), then
T2G(SI)
and
Ti+T2 = ±(B3 - S - ae0®e0 + S + A3) = ^{rB2 - aeo<8>e0 + rA2 + ae 0 ®e 0 ) = B2 + A2 = B\— 6e0®e0 + A\ + 6eo®e0 = A1 + B1 = T.
Theorem 3.1.1 indicates that every bounded linear operator acting on an infinite dimensional, separable Hilbert space can be expressed as a sum of two strongly irreducible operators. In the proof, we used the strongly irreducibility of Cowen-Douglas operators of index 1 frequently. As a matter of fact, in finite dimensional Hilbert space we have the following theorem. T h e o r e m 3.1.11 Every operator on a finite dimensional Hilbert space is a sum of two strongly irreducible operators. Proof Let T e £ ( C n ) and A = T - (£)trT, where trT is the trace of T, i.e., the sum of diagonal elements in the matrix representation with respect to some ONB. If rankA
'Oa 0 ••• 0" 0 aO • • • 0 A^ 0
0 0 0
Approximate
29
Jordan Theorem of Operators
Let b = ( ^ ) t r T , c ^ 0 and c ^ a, then b a — c 0 ... b a — c ...
6c 0 ••• 0 6 c ••• 0 T=
o o
+ b c b
0
b a—c b
0
Since Ti~T2~J n (6)€(SI), T is the sum of two (57) operators. If rank A > 1, by the matrix theory, we have 0 a 12 • • • a l n _ i a-21 0 a 2n fln-n &nl
0 a
ai„
a„_i„
n 2 • • • O-nn-l
0 ai2 aJ3 • • • 0 a 23 • • •
0
aln a2„
0 021
0 0
+ 0 a„_i„ 0
a-n-n
O-n-12
•
O-nl
On2
•
•
0 ^ n n -- i 0
where a^ ^ 0(i ^ j) [Choi, M.D., Lausee, C. and Radjavi, H. (1981)]. It is easily seen that T is the sum of two (SI) operators.
3.2
Approximate Jordan Decomposition Theorem
If cr(T) is disconnected for T£L(7i), by Riesz decomposition theorem T£(SI), and by upper semi-continuity of spectrum, there exists an e > 0 such that T + Ag(SI) for all AeC(H) with \\A\\ < e. If a(T) is connected, we have the following theorem stated in section 1.5. Spectral picture theorem of (SI) operators Given T€JC(H) with connected spectrum <J(T), there exists a (SI) operator L satisfying (i) A(L) = A(T); (ii) TeS(L)-; (Hi) If there is another Lj6(57) such that A(Li) = A(T), then LIG5(L)".
30
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
By the above spectral picture theorem, we get the following theorem. First approximate Jordan decomposition theorem [Jiang, C.L. and W a n g , Z. Y. (1996b)] Let T&C(H), then there exists A&C(H) such that A is the direct sum of at most infinitely many (SI) operators and satisfying (i)
TGS(A)-;
(ii) IfB€£(H)
andBeS(T)-,
then
BGS(A)~.
The interested reader is referred to [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1998)] for the proof of the theorem. In general, we call this theorem the unique decomposition theorem with respect to similarity orbit. In 1988, D.A. Herrero raised the following conjecture in personal communication: Every operator with connected spectrum is a small compact perturbation of (SI) operator. Or precisely, given T€C(H) with connected a(T) and given an e > 0, there exists a compact operator K with \^K\\ < e such that T + Ke(SI). Following theorem confirms Herrero's conjecture. T h e o r e m 3.2.1 Let T&C(H) (or T&Bn(9)) with connected a(T). given e > 0, there is a compact operator K, \\K\\ < e, such that T + Ke(SI)
(orT +
Then
KeBn(n)n(SI)).
We will prove the theorem only in the Bn(Cl) operator case. Reader is referred to [Ji, Y.Q. and Jiang, C.L. (2002)], for the general case, which is a little more complex. Before we begin our proof, we need the following lemmas. Lemma 3.2.2[Fialkow, L.A. (1981)] ing are equivalent: (i) ar(A)nat(B) = 0; (ii) TA,B is surjective; (Hi) ranTA,B contains IC(H).
Let A, B^C(H),
then the follow-
Lemma 3.2.3 [Herrero, D.A. and Jiang, C.L. (1990)] Let A,BeC(H). Assume that H = \J{ker(X - B)k : Aer,fc>l} for a certain subset T of the point spectrum o~p(B) of B, and ap(A)r\T — 0, then T A,B is infective. Let 0 be a non-empty open connected subset of C such that (Q)° = Q, where (Q)° denotes the interior of the closure Q of Q. Given zo&Q, there exists a probability measure /z supported by T := d£l, the boundary of Q, satisfying f(zo) = fr fd^i for every function / analytic on fi [Herrero,
Approximate
Jordan Theorem of Operators
31
D.A. (1990)]. Let M(T) = "multiplication by A" on L 2 (T,/i). The subspace H2(T) of L2(T,fj,), spanned by the functions analytic on Q, is obviously invariant under M(T), i.e.,
M(r) =
# 2 (r) M+(T) Z 2 2 o M_(r) L ( i » e # ( r y
Lemma 3.2.4[Herrero, D . A . (1990)] Let M{T),M+{T) and M _ ( r ) 6e as above, then (i) M(T) is normal and both M+(F) and M-(T) are essentially normal; (ii) a{M{T)) = o-e{M{T))=
a ( M + ( r ) ) = a ( M _ ( r ) ) = fi; *nd(A - M+(T)) = -nul(X - M+(T)) = -nul{\ - M+(T))* = - 1 for all \€il; (Hi) If Q is simply connected, then \\Z\\<m^ ', where m denotes the planar Lebesgue measure. It is obvious that M + ( r ) * € # i ( £ r ) and M-(T)eBi(Q),
where Q* := {A :
Aeft}. An operator is quasitriangular if ind(\ — T)>0 for all A€/9 s _ir(T). The Weyle spectrum aw{T) of TeC{H) is defined by aw{T) := D M ? 1 + # ) •' K&K(H)}. It is well known that aw(T) := {AGC : A - T is not a Fredholm operator of index 0}. L e m m a 3.2.5[Herrero, D . A . (1990)] Suppose that T£C(H) is quasitriangular and a(T) = aw(T). Let T = {A„}^L1Ccr(T) satisfy that each clopen subset of o~(T) intersects the closure ofT. Given e > 0, there exist a compact operator K, \\K\\ < e, and an ONB { e ^ } ) ^ such that *
~ai
T+K
02
ei e2
.0 where the set {a-i}^ll = T and card{j : aj = ai} = oo for each i. Lemma 3.2.6[Herrero, D.A. (1990)] Given T£C{H), nonempty subset rco"; r e (T) and e > 0, there exists a compact operator K, \\K\\ < e, such that
T +K=
0 AJ H2'
32
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
where N is a diagonal operator of uniformly infinite multiplicity with o-(N)=T,a(A)
= a(T),alre(A)
=
alre(T)
and ind{A - A) = ind(T - A) for each A£p s _ir(T). Lemma 3.2.7
Suppose that j, _
T i T12
~ [O T2
n2
satisfies the following conditions:
(i) (ii)
T2eBn(n)n(SI);
nul{T\ — Afc) =.n, k = 1, 2, • • • and \J{ker(Xk - Ti) : k = 1,2, •••} = Hi; (in) Bk := Pfcer(Ti-Afc)'?i2|fce7-(T-Afc) is injective, where Pfcer(Ti-Afc)* *« t/ie orthogonal projection from H onto ker(Ti — Afc)*. Then Te£ n (ft)n(SJ). Proof {Claim} fcer(T - Afc) = ker{Tx - Xk). Assume that Ti - Afc T12 0 T2 - Afc for xGHi and y£H2, then (Ti - Afc)x + T i 2 y = 0 and (T2 - Afc)y = 0. Since Pfcer(T 1 -A t )*(Tl - Afc) = 0,
Pfcer(Ti-Afc)*Ti22/ = 0. Since Pfcer(Ti-Afc)*Ti2 is injective, y = 0. This implies that ker(T - Xk) = ker(T\ - Xk)
Approximate
Jordan Theorem of Operators
33
and \/{&er(r-Afe):*>l}=Wi. Since cr 0 (Ti)nfi = {^fc}fcLi> there exists connected open subset fiiCnnp(Ti). Since T 2 eS„(fi),\f{ker{T 2 -\) : Aefti} = W2. Furthermore, \/{ker(T
- A) : Xe{Xk}^=1UQi}
= Hi®H2.
Thus Te£ n (ft). Now we will prove that TG(SI). Assume that PGA'(T) is an idempotent. Since ker(T — Xk) = ker(T\ — Xk), k = 1,2, • • • , Hi is an invariant subspace of P, i.e., P =
PiPn 0 P2
Hi H2
Since T2&{SI), P 2 = SI-^2,S = 0 or 1. Without loss of generality, we can assume that 5 = 0, i.e., P2 = 0. Thus ranPcHi. Note that PS-A'(T) and T€Bn(fl). If P ^ 0, then T'|ranp6^ r n (0) for some m, l < m < n . Since T| ranP = Ti\ • a n P i Tii =
Ti\ranp£Bm(Q),
It is easy to see that ranP is an invariant subspace of T\. Therefore, Ti =
0 T^
ranP HiQranP'
By the condition (ii) of the lemma, Ti — A is invertible for AGfi\{Afc}^=1. Thus we can find an invertible XGC(H),
x=
^ 1 1 -X"l2 _X2i X22.
ranP HiQranP
such that Xn X\2 'Tn - A £ 0 2"22 ~ X 2 i X22_
' ^.
7o" 0/
Simple computations indicate that Xu(Tu — A) = I Thus Tn — A is invertible. This contradicts Tn&Bm(n). Therefore Px = P2 = 0 and TG(SI).
34
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Lemma 3.2.8[Ji, Y.Q., Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1996)] Suppose that B is essentially normal and B(=Bn(Cl). Then for given e > 0, there exists a compact operator K with \\K\\ < e, such that T + K£Bn(Cl)C\(SI). Lemma 3.2.9[Herrero, D.A. (1987)] Suppose that R&C(7i) and satisfies the following conditions: (i) o~(R) and o~w(R) are connected and contain a connected open set Cl; (ii) ind{\ - R)>0 for all \€ps-F(R); (Hi) PS-F(R)DQ
and ind(X — R) = n for all AGH.
Then given e > 0, there exists a compact operator K, \\K\\ < e, such that R-KeBn(fl). Lemma 3.2.10[Herrero, D.A. (1984)] LetT€C(H) be quasitriangular operator and \£ae(T). If o~w{T) is connected, then given e > 0 and natural number m, there is a compact operator K, \\K\\ < e, such that nulT^ — km, k>\, and \J{kerT^ : k>l} = H, where Te = T + K - A. Lemma 3.2.11 Let T&C{H) be quasitriangular operator and let Cl be a connected component of ps_F(T) such that crw{T)L)Cl is connected. Given e > 0 and natural number n, there exist a sequence {^k}k^=i of complex numbers in Cl and a compact operator K with ||K|| < e, such that {Afc}2L1C
*
A2
T + K^
cn C"
0
where pflF{T) := {\£ps-F{T) : ind{\ - T) = 0}. Proof Note that dClCo-ire(T). We choose a dense subset {/ifc}^ of dCl. Then each clopen subset of o-w{T) intersects {pk}%K'=i- By Lemma 3.2.5, there exists a compact C\, ||Ci|| < §, such that
\J{ker{T + d - pky : j>l, k>l} = H and dim \J{ker(T
+ Cx - pk)j : j > l } = oo
for all k>l. Without loss of generality, we can assume that ap{T* + Cl) = 0. Since ClCP^F(T)
= p%(T
+ C1),
Approximate
35
Jordan Theorem of Operators
nncr(T + C 1 ) = 0 . Denote
M1=\J{ker(T
+
C1-fi1)j:j>l},
then M. is an invariant subspace of T + Cx and dimM.\ = oo. Let
iwr + dju,,, then /UiGcre(Ti) and cr(Ti) = aw{Ti) is connected. If dim\f
{ker(T + Ci - fnY : i = 1,2,-•• , j > l } e A 1 i < oo,
then fcer(T+ for all j>l.
d-Hi)'CM
Denote
Mk = yikeriT+d-fii)'
: l
{ker{T + Cx-fnY
where k>l,j>l. Without loss of generality, we can assume that dimMk
:
l
= oo. Thus
T+ d 0 Since \J{ker(Tk — Hk)j '• j>l} = Mk, crw(Tk) = cr(Tfc) is connected and Cp(Tk*)c{Jik}- Thus Tk is a triangular, /ifeG
*" (J-k
Tk + Kk
cn C"
cn>
fc = l , 2 , - .
0 Since {/Ujtj^iCcftl,
we can choose pairwise distinct numbers {A (fc)
.
j
fc>l, j > l } in ft such that \fXk — A^KJ| < -^
for all j and fc. Thus there
36
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
is a compact operator Kk with \\Kk\\ < pr such that iW
C"
c
\(2)
Ak = Tk + Kk + Kk*
i< 3 >
C"i ^ = 1>2, •••
Furthermore, there is a compact operator C2,11C21 i < § satisfying •
'J4I
Mi M2 M3'
T + Cx + Co = 0
where C 2 = ^ ©(-Kk + ^fc)- Set if = C\ + C 2 , then K is compact and fc=i i ( * >J : J>1,/s>l} as {^k}kLi- ^ i s n o t ; difficult to see H^ll < e. Rearrange {A^that K and {Afcj^j satisfy all the requirements of the lemma.
Now we are in a position to prove Theorem 3.2.1. Proof of Theorem 3.2.1 For T&B n (fi), assume that dQ.Caire(T) (otherwise, replace Q with the component of PS-F(Q) containing fi). Denote $ = (Q)° and T = d$. Then rccr, r e (T). By Lemma 3.2.6 and Lemma 3.2.9, we can find a compact operator K\, \\Ki\\ < | such that T +
K^
Tx * 0 iV W2:
where Ti€# n (fi), N is a diagonal operator of uniformly infinite multiplicity and CT(JV) = T. Let M(T) be given as in Lemma 3.2.4, then M(T)^ = n
0
M(T) is normal and
0 M + (T) M{T)
(n)
0 It is clear that a(M(T)W)
0
Z
fc=i fc=i
= T.
0 M_(r) fc=i
Approximate
Jordan Theorem of Operators
37
By Voiculescu theorem [Voiculescu, D. (1976)] there exists a compact operator Fx such that \\Fi\\ < § and N + F^MIT)^. Thus Ti T + Ki+
K2^
*
*
o 0M+(r)
Jz
k=l
0
k=l
0 M_(T)
0
fc=i
where K2 is compact, K2 = 0©i<2 and H-ft^H < f • Set
o ©M+(r) fc=l
It is obvious that a(Bi) = CT(T), Q C p ^ B i ) and ind(Bx - A) > 0 for all A in cr(Si)npir(-Bi)\f2. Therefore B\ is quasitriangular, fi is a connected component of pp{B\) and Q,r)aw(Bi) = cr(T) is connected. By Lemma 3.2.11 we can find a sequence {Afc}^ °f pairwise distinct complex numbers in Q and a compact operator E, \\E\\ < JQ such that {Afe}^=1Ccr0(yl1) and C"
Ai
c
Ai = B + E^
Summarizing the arguments above, we can find a compact operator if3, ||#31| < y| such that A\ T + Kt + K2 + K3*
Denote B2
=
0 M_(r).
*
n3
n
0
©M_(T)
fc=i
Note that B 2 is essentially normal and
k=i
B2€Bn{$)cBn(£l)
[Cowen, M.J. and Douglas, R. (1977)]. By Lemma 3.2.9,
we can find a compact operator F2, \\F21| < ^ such that A2 = B2 +
F2eBn(n)n(Sl).
Thus there is a compact operator K4, \\K^\\ < ^ such that T + Kx + K2 + K3 + X 4 = [ ^ U
A 12
.
A2
38
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
According to Lemma 3.2.7, it is sufficient for us to find a compact operator E12 such that ||£ 1 2 || < fi and Pfcer(A!-Afc)*(^12 + •£;i2)Uer(A1-Afc) is injective. Since {Xk}k^L1Cap(A1)nPF(A2) and nul(A\ — Xk) — n,
X\
cn
G\2
C"
A2
"Gi * " 1-0
0 G2
Woo
Jno where Xi G\2 G13 • • X2 G23 • •
Gi
C" C"
A3 '•
and G 2 = A » - Since A2eBn(Q),ker(A2
- Xk) = ker(Gx - Xk) and
Ax Ex E2 G = 0 Gi * L 0 0 G2
©C"
fc=l
00
©C"
fc=l
We need only to find a compact operator i*3, H-F3JI < <^, such that Pker(A-\k)*(El
+ ii3)Uer(G1-AJ,)
Approximate
39
Jordan Theorem of Operators
is injective. Since \k£0o(Ai)
for k>l,A\
has the following expression:
"Ho
Ax = A3 C23 C13
C"
A2 C12
c cn
Ai
Thus Afc £ a(Aoo) for all &>1. Under the above decomposition,
*
*
*
£1 = E31 E32 E33 • • •
:
*
E21 E22 E23 • • •
:
*
En
:
*
E12 E13 • • •
where E^ is an operator from one n-dimensional space to another for i, j>l. It is obvious that we can choose F n with \\Fn\\ < | such that En + Fu is invertible. Inductively, we can choose Fjj with \\Fjj\\ < ^ such that Ej+ij+i + WjX~1Vj + Fj+i:j+i is invertible, where Wi = (Gj,j+i> Gj-i,j+i, • • • . Gitj+i, Ej+iti, • • • ,
-\? cj,j-i Xj-i Xj — Xj
' ••
c
j,i
" • Cj-1,1
Ai
Ej,i
Ej+ij),
Aw + Au
Ej-iti
En + Fn A2 Xj
40
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
and
Ej-i,j+i
Vj =
Fi,j+i
Set
F2 =
0
F33
'•
0
:
F22
Fn
then F2 is compact and j|JF211 < -§ils From the construction we can see PkeriAt-x^'iEi + Fi)\ker(A2-\k) injective for all k>l. Therefore the proof of the theorem is now complete. Definition 3.2.12 A sequence {Pj : l<j
n-
Definition 3.2.13 Let TeC(H) and V = {Pj : l<j
Approximate
Jordan Theorem of Operators
41
the orthogonal sum of at most countably many (57) operators. Definition 3.2.14 Let Vx = {Pj • l<j
ranQv(j))
such that 5UP{||Xj||,||X-1||,l
= TranQ^u)Xj,
l<j
In Chapter 4, we will show that V\ and Vi are similar about T if and only if there exists an invertible operator X&A'(T) such that {XPjX-1
: l<j
= {Qj :
l<j
Definition 3.2.15 Suppose that T has strongly irreducible decomposition. T is said to have a unique strongly irreducible decomposition up to similarity if any two of the (SI) decomposition of T are similar. The Jordan canonical theorem in finite dimensional space means essentially that each nxn matrix has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. For operators in £(H), it is very difficult to obtain a "Jordan canonical theorem". In Chapter 5 of this monograph we will prove the following theorem. Theorem FJ Every Cow en-Douglas operator has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. Using Theorem FJ, we obtain the following two approximate Jordan canonical theorems. Theorem 3.2.16 Given T&C(H) and e > 0, there exists Ae£(H) such that A has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity and \\T — A\\ < e. Theorem 3.2.17 Let TGJC-(H) be quasitriangular. Assume that cr(T) consists of finitely many components and each component intersects pp(T).
42
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Given e > 0 there exists a compact operator K with \\K\\ < e such that T + K has a unique strongly irreducible decomposition up to similarity. Theorem 3.2.16 can be proved by using of Theorem JW2 in Chapter 1 and Theorem FJ, and Theorem 3.2.17 can be proved by Theorem 3.2.1 and Lemma 3.2.4. 3.3
Open Problems
1. Given TGC(H) and e > 0, does there exist a compact operator K with \\K\\ < e such that T + K has unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity? 2. Is every operator in C(H) the sum of two Cowen-Douglas operators of index 1? 3. Given TGC(H) and e > 0, does there exist an integer p, l
CP(H) = {KeK{H)
:^A£ <
oo,\ n £a p (K*K)±}
n=l
and
3.4
Remark
The concept of unique strongly irreducible decomposition up to similarity appeared first in [Jiang, C.L. and Wang, Z.Y. (1998)]. Theorem 3.1.1 is given by [Yue, H. (2002)]. Before that, [Jiang, C.L. and Wu, P.Y. (1998)] proved that each operator in £(H) is the sum of three (SI) operators, and each triangular or compact operator is the sum of two (SI) operators. Theorem 3.1.11 is given by [Jiang, C.L. and Wu, P.Y. (1998)]. Theorem 3.2.1 is due to [Ji, Y.Q. and Jiang, C.L. (2002)]. Theorem 3.2.16 and Theorem 3.2.17 are both proved by [Jiang, C.L.(l) ].
Chapter 4
Unitary Invariant and Similarity Invariant of Operators In this chapter % always denotes a complex, separable infinite dimensional Hilbert space. One of the basic problems in operator theory is to determine when two operators A and B in C(H) are unitarily equivalent or similar. In infinite dimensional Hilbert space, this problem has no general solution. What we can do is to find the answer for some special classes of operators. A quantity (quantities) or a property (properties) P is unitary (or similarity) invariant (invariants) if A has P and A=B(A~B) implies that B has P. For example, reducibility and strong reducibility are unitary invariants while strong reducibility is only the similarity invariant. For a subset R of C(H), unitary (similarity) invariant (invariants) P is completely unitary (or similarity) invariant (or invariants) if AGR, then A=B (or A~B) if and only if BGR and A and B have same P. From this point of view, one of the basic problem in operator theory mentioned above is to determine the completely unitary or similarity invariants. We have seen in Chapter 2 that eigenvalues and generalized eigenspaces are completely similarity invariants of nxn matrices. [Conway, J.B. (1990)] showed that two *-cyclic normal (or subnormal) operators A and B in £(H) are similar if and only if the scalar-valued spectral measures induced by them a equivalent, while they are unitary equivalent if and only if they are similar. Here, an operator A is normal if A* A — AA*, and A is subnormal if there exist a normal operator JV and an invariant subspace M. of N such that N\M = A. For two injective unilateral weighted shifts, the boundedness of the ratios of the products of their weights is the completely similarity invariant [Shields, A.L. (1974)]. There have already been a lot of results on the similarity invariants of operators, especially that of non-adjoint operators, which can be found in, for example, [Herrero, D.A. (1987)], [Herrero, D.A. (1990)], [Conway, J.B. (1990)].
43
44
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
In this chapter, we will discuss further the unitary invariants and similarity invariants of non-self-adjoint operators.
4.1
Unitary Invariants of Operators
We begin with a famous theorem. Schur theorem Each nxn matrix X is unitary equivalent to the orthogonal direct sum of irreducible matrices. For T££(H), let W*(T) denote the von-Neumann algebra generated by T. By von-Neumann double commutant theorem we can easily prove the equivalence of the following conditions. (i) T is irreducible; (ii) A'(W*(T))=I; (hi) W*(T) = C(H). The following proposition tells us that the Schur Theorem can not be generalized to C{Ji). Proposition 4.1.1 Let Ne£(H) be a self-adjoint operator with crp(N) = 0, then N is not orthogonal direct sum of irreducible operators. Furthermore, N is not the topological direct sum of (SI) operators. i
Proof
For the first part of the proposition, if N = Yl
(BNi,l
i=i
where NiG(RI), then Ni is self-adjoint and the the dimension of the space Hi, on which Ni acts, is just 1. Thus o~p(N) ^ 0. It is a contradiction. For the second part of the proposition, if PGA'(N) is a nontrivial idempotent, then by the spectral theorem of self-adjoint operators, there exists a orthogonal projection P' such that ranP = ranP' and P'GA'(N) [Putnam I.[l]]. If N is the topological direct sum of sum (SI) operators, then by the fact stated above, we can find an orthogonal projection P'GA'(N) and N\ranP' is irreducible. By the argument used in the first part we conclude that crp(N) j= 0. It is also a contradiction. Although it is not every operator to be the direct sum of irreducible operators, we have the following proposition. Proposition 4.1.2 Every operator T&C(7i) is the direct integral of irreducible operators. Proof In fact this is a corollary of Theorem 3.6 of [Azoff, E.A., Fong, C.K. and Gilfeather., F. (1976)]. The weakly closed algebra A(T), generated by
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
45
T and / , can be expressed as / A ®A\d[j,(\), where A is a separable metric space, fi is a regular a-finite Borel measure on A and A\ is a weakly closed irreducible operator algebra for almost all AsA. Recall that an operator algebra is irreducible if it has no nontrivial reducing subspace. Therefore, we have T=
/ ® T A ^ ( A ) , T A e A , A e A a.e..
./A
Thus A(T)cfA®A(Tx)diJ,(\)cfA®Axd[i(\) = A(T). This implies that A{T\) = A\ for almost all AeA. Thus the irreducibility of ,4 A implies that T\£(RI). Therefore T = fA®T\dn(\) is the asserted irreducible integral decomposition of T. For C*-algebra A and natural number n, let M„(A) denote the set of all nxn matrices with entries in A. The following theorem gives the number of reducing subspaces of an operator. Theorem 4.1.3 The number of reducing subspaces of any operator Te£(W) is either finite or uncountably infinite. The former case occurs if and only ifT is the direct sum of finitely many irreducible operators, i.e., T = Ti©T2© • • • ®Tn, and Ti,Tj are not unitarily equivalent ifi^j. In this case, the number of reducing subspace is 2™. Theorem 4.1.3 has a similar pattern but in a different context with the following result of [Ong, S.C. (1987)]. Theorem Ong Given T € £ ( C n ) , the number of invariant subspaces ofT is either finite or uncountably infinite. The former case occurs if and only if T has a cyclic vector. To prove Theorem 4.1.3, we need four lemmas. The first is a structure theorem for two orthogonal projections, and has been quoted in many literatures before. The reader is referred to [Halmos, P.R. (1968)]. Lemma 4.1.4 Given two orthogonal projections P and Qg£(W), there is a unitary operator U such that /i0 ®h®h®0®0 0 0
U*PU and U*QU =
A B
B ©/2©0©/ 4 ©0 h-B
46
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
under the decomposition of the space H = Hi®H2®H3®Hi®Hs, where is a positive contraction and B = [A(Ii — A)] 2. We may assume that 0 < A<^Ii and A is unique up to unitary equivalence. Using Lemma 4.1.4, we can prove the next lemma.
J4G£(WI)
L e m m a 4.1.5 IfTGC(H) has countably many reducing subspaces, then A'(W*(T)) is abelian. Proof Let P , Q&A'(W*(T)) be two orthogonal projections represented as in Lemma 4.1.4. Since PT — TP and QT = TQ, a simple computation 5
indicates that T = T\@T2® ^ ©T, under the decomposition of the space i=3 5
and T\A = AT\. For each complex number A, denote M\ = {\BX®X®Q®Q®Q :
XeHi}.
It is easily seen that M\ is a reducing subspace of T, and if Hi ^ {0}, then Mx ± My
(A ^ A').
Since T has only countably many reducing subspace, Hi = {0}. Thus P = / 2 ©/ 3 ®o©0 and Q = /2©0©/ 4 ©0. This implies that PQ = QP. Since von-Neumann algebra A'(W*(T)) generated by the projections in it, A'(W*(T)) is abelian.
is
Recall that a projection p in a C*-algebra is minimal if there is no projection q other than 0 and p such that pq = q. L e m m a 4.1.6 Let PeA'(W*(T)) and only ifT\ranpG(RI).
be a projection, then P is minimal if
The proof of this lemma is an easy consequence of the definition of minimal projection. L e m m a 4.1.7 Let A, BGC(H)C\(TZT), then A and B are unitarily equivalent if and only if there exists a nonzero operator X such that XA = BX and XA* = B*X.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
47
Proof If XA = BX and XA* = B*X for some nonzero X, then kerX and ranX are reducing subspaces of A and B. If kerX ^ {0}, by the irreducibility of A kerX = Ti., i.e., X = 0, a contradiction. Thus kerX — {0}. Similarly, we can conclude that ranX = "H, i.e., X has a dense range. Let X = UP be the polar decomposition of X, where U is unitary and P = (X*X)2>0. Since X*X,4 = X * £ X = AX*X, PA = AP. Therefore UAP = UP A = XA = BX = BUP. Since P is also range dense, UA = BU. Thus A=B. We are now in a position to prove Theorem 4.1.3. Proof of Theorem 4.1.3 Assume that T has countably infinite many reducing subspaces. By Lemma 4.1.5, A'(W*(T)) is abelian. Thus A'(W*(T)) is generated by some Hermitian operator A [Radjaval, H. and Rosenthal, P. (1973)]. Note that cr(A) can not be finite. Otherwise, n
A = Y^ ®*Ji i=l
and n
W*(A) =
{J2®aiIi:ai€C}. »=i
This implies that W*(A) = A'(W*(T)) contains only finitely many projections, and contradicts the assumption. Thus a{A) can be decomposed into countably infinitely many pairwise disjoint Borel subsetslcrj}?^, each of which has a strictly positive spectral measure. Since a (A) has uncountably many different decompositions, so is the spectral projections of A. Therefore, there are uncountably many orthogonal projections in W*(A) = A'(W*(T)). This is also a contradiction. Thus the number of reducing subspaces of T can not be countably infinite. Now we assume that T has finitely many reducing subspaces. By Lemma 4.1.6 A'(W*{T)) is abelian. Let Pi,--- , P n be minimal projections in
48
Structure
A'(W*(T)).
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Since PP,- = P , P , it is not difficult to prove that PiPj = 0 n
n
for i ^ j , and ^ P* = /. Let T — S 0 ^ 1=1
under the decomposition
2=1
n
H = Yl ®ranPi, where T{ = T\ranPi- By Lemma 4.1.7, Ti£(RI).
We are
i=l
now to prove that T is not unitarily equivalent to Tj for i ^ j . Otherwise, if Ti=Tj, there is a unitary operator £/ such that UTi = TjU, where l < i < j
and Tj is not
i=l
unitarily equivalent to Tj for i ^ j . Let P = {Py}"., = i be orthogonal projections commuting with T. Then PyTj = TiPij for all l
p y T/ = P ^ T ; = (TjPjy =
(P,^)*
= T ; P ^ = i-p,-.
Since T, and Tj are irreducible and not unitarily equivalent for i 7^ j , by Lemma 4.1.7, Py = 0 and so Pji = 0. Thus Pjj is an orthogonal projection commuting with T,, which implies that Pa = 0 or I-nt (i = 1,2, ••• , n). Therefore T has only 2™ reducing subspaces. In the following, we will characterize the decomposibility of an operator into direct sum of irreducible operators in terms of C*-algebra language. For TG£(H) and an integer n, l
operators (i.e., T = ^ © T ;
(
•)
is the direct sum of irreducible
, l<Tii
i=l
wise not unitary equivalent) if and only if A'(W*(T))
is ^-isomorphic to
n
^2 ©M n i (C). Moreover, the (RI)-decomposition
ofT is unique in the sense
i=l m
.
of unitary equivalent. Precisely, if T = Yl ©^fc
.
is another direct sum
fc=i
of irreducible operators {Sk}™=1, which are pairwise not unitary equivalent, then n = m and there exist a permutation n of {1,2, • • • ,n) and a unitary operator U in A'(W*(T)) such that n, = rnw^ and UTi = Sn^U,i =
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
49
1,2,--- ,n. Note that [Takesaki, M. (1979)] showed that every finite dimensional C*-algebra is *-isomorphic to the direct sum of finitely many full matrix algebras. Thus we have the following corollary. Corollary 4.1.9 T is the direct sum of finitely irreducible operators if and only ifdimA'(W*(T)) < oo. To prove Theorem 4.1.8, we need the following lemma. Lemma 4.1.10 If T is irreducible on H and X££(H) satisfying XT = TX and XT* = T*X, then X = dl for some deC. Proof Since X*X commutes with T, T commutes with any spectral projection P of X*X. Since T&{RI),P = 0 or P = I. Thus a{X*X) is a singleton {a} and X*X = al. On the other hand, it follows from XT = TX and XT* = T*X that kerX is a reducing subspace of T. Since T€(RI),kerX = {0} or H. Similarly, ranX = H or ranX~ = {0}. This implies that X = 0 or X is injective with dense range. Thus
where U is unitary. If a ^ 0, then UT = TU and UT* = T*U. Repeating the arguments above, we have U = /3I or X = dl, where d = \/a/3. Thus, the proof is complete. Proof of Theorem 4.1.8
Let T = £ ®T}ni)
satisfy the conditions of
i=l
the theorem. For any X€A'(W*(T)),
by Lemma 4.1.10,
n
X =
J^(BXi,Xi€A'(W*(T^)). i=l
Let
then
YjkzA'(W(Tt)). By Lemma 4.1.10, Yjk = ^)kh, where 7j is the identity on Wj.Thus
Structure
50
of Hilbert Space
Operators
n
It is obvious that the mapping J n ^ ®[^}fc-^]?fc=i
defines a *-
i=l
isomorphism from A'(W*(T))
onto £) ©M n i (C).
Conversely, if 4> is a ^-isomorphism from A'(W*(T))
onto A
:=
n
X)©M n j (C) and let Etj denote the element 0® • • • ®etj® • • •ffiOin A, i=l
where e^ is an riiXTii matrix whose (i,j)-entry is 1 and the others are 0. Then 4>~l(Eij)£A'(W*(T)) are pairwise orthogonal minimal projections with £>_1(.EV,) = ln- Obviously, by Lemma 4.1.7, ^{E^H is one of •J
the reducing subspaces of T with Ta :=
TU-HEii)nZ{BI)
and
T = £©!;,. Since Eij^Eik
for all (j, k), Tij^Tik
and T ^ £
®TJni).
»=i m
.
In order to prove the uniqueness, let T = X) ©S^.
.
be another ex-
pression of T, where {Sk}™^ are pairwise not unitary equivalent and m
.
H — ^2 ®L(™k • Let Pki be the orthogonal projection from H onto the fc=i
Z-th subspace of £j,
> then F ^ =
n
.4 := £ ® M n i ( C ) , and Y,Fki = ^ Since T | r a n p u e ( i ? / ) , P H is minimi fc,i mal. Thus Fki is minimal in A and there exists an integer n, such that Fki€Mni(C) with rankFu = 1. Therefore X).FM = 7 ni and so mk = rii. I
Prom ^.Fjfez = / , we can conclude that m — n. The remainder of the theorem can be proved directly from the *-isomorphism 4>. Next we will consider when two operators have isomorphic reducing subspaces lattices. [Conway, J.B. and Gillespie, T.A. (1985)] solved this problem in the case of normal operators. Using their result, we can characterize isomorphism of the reducing subspace lattices of two operators if they can be expressed as direct sums of irreducible operators.
Unitary Invariant
Proposition 4.1.11
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
51
Let
j=i
anc?
* = £«*£" fc=l
where Aj,Bk&(RI), {Aj} and {Bk} are pairwise not unitarily equivalent, l
morphic to RedB, then n — m and there is a permutation 7r of {1, 2, • • • , n} such that rij = ^ ( j ) [Conway, J.B. and Gillespie, T.A. (1985)]. This proves the necessity part. The sufficiency is obvious. Proposition 4.1.13 IfT^ is a direct sum of irreducible operators, then so is T. Proof Without loss of generality, we assume that n t=i
{Tj}™=1 is a sequence of irreducible operators, which are pairwise unitarily inequivalent. Then there are pairwise orthogonal projections Pj,j =
Structure
52
of Hilbert Space
Operators
1,2, • • • , n, each of which commutes with T^
and J2Pj
=
sucn
!•>
tnat
r^fc^Irani3,,i = 1,2, • • • , k are pairwise unitarily inequivalent. By Lemma 4.1.7, Pj = 2_^ ®Qij, where Qij£A'(T>
) , {Qij} are pairwise orthogonal, Y^®Qij
=
^
anc
^
j
Tt \ranQij, j = 1,2, • • • , A; are pairwise unitarily equivalent. Therefore we need only to prove that if A^^B^, l
\ranQ-
Proof Set W = U\ranp- Then W is a unitary operator from ranP onto ranQ and satisfies W(T\ranP) = (T\ranQ)W. Lemma 4.1.16 Let TeC(H)
and
\J(A'(W*{T)))^N{fl]®(N+u{<^}){k2\ 0
Proof
Assume that T| ran f> is irreducible and [P] = J2 ©aje,, where a* is
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
53
an integer, CKOJJ < oo. If there are at least two nonzero a^s, say a\, a? ^ 0. Then / = a.\e\ and g = J2 ®aiei
a
re nonzero elements in
\J(A'(W*(T))).
i=1
Thus there exist a natural number m and mutual orthogonal projections Q and RGA'(W*(T^)), such that [Q] = f and [R] = g. Set S = Q + R, then /
[5] = [Q] + [R} = f + g = J2 ^id
= [P].
Therefore S is unitarily equivalent to P © 0 ( m - 1 ) in A'(W*(T^m^)), denotes the zero operator on H. By Lemma 4.1.15, r
r(rn)]
-t
'\ranS
where 0
„ /^> /T>(m)j
= J-
^
"ranP©0("-!)
T\ranP€(RI).
This contradicts the fact that T\ranp€(SI). Thus [P] = a»ei. Similarly, we can prove a* = 1. Conversely, assume that [P] = ei and T\ranp is reducible. Then there are nonzero projections Q^GA'CW^T^)) such that QR = 0 and P =
<2 + P. Let
[Q] = 5 3 ®aiei i=l
and
[P] = 53©ftei, i=l
where 0
and
©(a, + &>)<*
Structure
54
of Hilbert Space
Operators
for all i>2. Therefore ax = 0 and j3x = 0 and on = # = 0 for i>2. This implies that [Q] = 0 or [R] = 0. A contradiction. Therefore T\ranp£(RI)Lemma 4.1.17 Let AGC(H) be a direct sum of irreducible operators and B&C{K) have no reducing subspace on which B is irreducible. If there exists an operator X such that XA = BX, XA* = B*X, then X = 0. oo
Proof
Without loss of generality, we assume that A = £ ®An with n=l oo
respect to H = £ ©W„, where Ane(RI).
Then X* = [X{, X | , • • • ]*. Now
n=l
we prove X\ = 0. In fact, from XA — BX and XA* = 5 * X , we have XXB = AtXi and XXB* = A*X. Thus {X^^Ai = Ai(XiX{) and ( X i X j * ) ^ = A\(XiX{). Since ^ is irreducible, by Lemma 4.1.10 XXX{ = XIHl for some AeC. If A ^ 0. Let U = \~lXi. Then UU* = IHl and Q := U*U is a projection in C{K.) with Q-B = BQ. Set p = IHl®0,
Q = 0©Q,
then p, ge£(Wi © £ ) • Set p' = pffiO, ?' = q®0, where
Set C = J 4 I © B . We claim that p' and g' are unitarily equivalent in A'{W*(C^)). To prove this, we define v=^QU^££(H1+JC). It is easy to see that v is a partial isometry, vv* = p and v*v = q. Then the assertion follows from the Proposition 5.2.12 of [Wegge-Olsen, N.E. (1993)]. By Lemma 4.1.15, C^\ranp^C^\ranql. But C^\ranp, = A^RI). Thus C
\ranq'=B\ranQe(RI),
which contradicts our assumption on B. Hence X\ = 0. By the same arguments we can prove that Xn = 0 for n > 2 . Thus X = 0. Proof of Theorem 4.1.14 The necessity follows from the analysis above. We only prove the sufficiency. Assume that \/{A'(W*{T)))^l)@{N+U{oo}Yk2\
0
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
55
of Operators
Let P be a projection in Mk(A'(W*(T))) = A'{W*{T^)) such that [P] is a free generator of \/(A'{W*(T))). By Lemma 4.1.16, T^\ranPe(RI) (here we embed A'(W*(T)) into Mk(A'(W*(T))) with the embedding \A 0] map A>-» ). Using Zorn's lemma, we can find a maximal family in A'(W*(T^)) of pairwise orthogonal projections {Pj}n=l, l
will prove that Q = 7^fc', the identity operator on H^. Otherwise, set 7\ := T^\ranQ,T2 := ^ (fc) | r <m(/«-Q)- Since is a projection in .4'(W*(T( fe ))), T\ is a direct sum of irreducible operators and T
Thus
V(^'(W/*(T(fc))))^V(-4'(iy*(:ri)))®\/(-4'(W'*(T2))) (Isomorphism Theorem). Let R be a projection in A'(W*(T2 )) for which [i?] is a free generator of \J(A'(W*(T2))). By Lemma 4.1.16, T^m)\ranRe(RI). By the similar argument above, we find a nonzero projection Q iGA' (W* (T2 )) such that T3 := T2 |ranQi is the direct sum of irreducible operators and T4 := T;j; | r an(j-Qi) n a s n o reducing subspace .M with T4|^€(i?7). Using Lemma 4.1.17 again, we have A'(W*(T^m)))
=
A'(W*(T3))®A'(W*(T4)).
Thus Q\ commutes with every operator in A'(W*(T2 )) and QiGA'(W*(T2 )) by von-Neumann double commutant theorem. Therefore Q = S(m\ where S is a nonzero projection in W*(T2), and rp
<7-t( m )|
jrn |
\(m)
Since T3 is the direct sum of irreducible operators, so is T2\TanS by Proposition 4.1.13. This contradicts the assumption on T2. Thus Q = 1^ and T(fc) is a direct sum of irreducible operators. By Proposition 4.1.13, T is also a direct sum of irreducible operators.
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
56
By Theorem 4.1.14 and its proof, we have the following theorem. Theorem 4.1.18
Let A,B£C(H). i
,
operators, i.e., A = J2 (BA),
n
If A is the direct sum of irreducible
,
, 1 < / < O O , l
i=l
are not similar if and only if there exists an isometric isomorphism (j) such that (j>{\J{M{W*{A®B))))
= N^ fcl) ©(N + U{oo})( fc2 \
Q
i
and (f)(1) = 2^2,riiei, where {e,} are the generators
of\J(A'{W*(A))).
i=l
Note that for A£C(H), if A is a direct sum of infinitely many irreducible operators, then KQ(A'(W*(A))) = 0. Thus, in this case, i^o-group can not describe the unitary equivalent relation between operators. But we have the following theorem. Theorem 4.1.19
Let A,Be£.(7i).
Assume that A is the direct sum of i
,
,
finitely many irreducible operators: A = ^Z ©Aj™ , 1
oo, i = 1, 2, • • • ,1. Then A=B if and only if there exists an isometric isomorphism <j> such that cj>(K0(A!(W*(A®B))))
= N^}
and <j>(I) = 2 ^ n^ei, where {e,} are the generators of
Ko(A'(W*(A))).
i=i
Note that for A€Bn(Q.). Since A is a direct sum of finitely many irreducible operators, we can get the following theorem by Theorem 4.1.19. Theorem 4.1.20 Let A,B£Bn(fl), then the following statement hold. (i) A has a unique (SI) decomposition up to unitary equivalence. k
(ii) IfA=
J2®A\ni>,Aie{RI)
and{Ai}ki=l
are pairwise unitarily in-
2=1
equivalent. Then A=B if and only if there exists an isomorphic map
=
^Ylniei'
where {e;} are the generators of
Unitary Invariant
4.2
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
57
Strongly Irreducible Decomposition of Operators and Similarity Invariant: K0-Group
It is more convenient in terms of i^o-group to describe the unitary invariant of operators which are direct sum of irreducible operators. The proof of it depends strongly on the tools of C*-algebra theory. We give, in terms of semigroup theory, a necessary and sufficient condition to that an operator can be expressed as a direct sum of irreducible operators. In this section, we first prove the following theorem. Theorem 4.2.1
Given Te£(H),
the following are equivalent: n
(i)
T is similar to ^2 ®A\
under the decomposition of the space
»=i k
.
H=J2 ®KT
.
, where
kn
,i
< oo, Ai£(SI),
Ai^Aj
for i ^ j and each T(n>
i=l
has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity; (ii)
\J(A'(T))= N(k>, and this isomorphism 4> sends [I]—miei + n 2 e 2 H
h n^,
where {ej}f=1 are the generators of N^ and N = {0,1,2, • • • }, n, ^ 0. From Theorem 4.2.1, we obtain the following corollary. Corollary 4.2.2 Let T i , T 2 e ( 5 / ) , T = Ti®T2. If \f(A'(T))*N, then Ti~T 2 . Moreover, if T^ has a unique (SI) decomposition for all natural numbers up to similarity, then Ti~T 2 if and only if Ko(A'(T))=Z, where Z := {0, ± 1 , ±2, • • • }. Before we prove Theorem 4.2.1, the following lemmas are needed. Lemma 4.2.3 Given A, BGC(H). Assume that ip is an isomorphism from A'(A) onto A'(B). {Pi}^ i is an (SI) decomposition of A if and only if {y>(P;)}"=1 is an (SI) decomposition of B. In particular, if A~B, then A!(A)^A!(B). Proof Since
J2 tp(Pi) = I- We need only to show that B\v^Pi)H£(SI),
i = 1,2, • • • , n.
Otherwise, there exist two nonzero idempotents Qi and Q2&A'(B) such that Q2Q1 = Q1Q2 = 0 and Qi + Q2 =
Structure
58
of Hilbert Space
Operators
If A~B, there exists an invertible operator X such that XAX 1 = B. Define Tt-^XTX'1 for all T^A'(A). This mapping is an isomorphism from A'(A) onto A'(B). Lemma 4.2.4 Let Te£(H) and Pi,P2£A'(T) be idempotents. If Pi~A'(T)P2> then T | P 1 - H ~ T | P 2 7 ^ , where ~A'(T) means similarity in A'(T). Proof Since Pi~A'(T)P2, there is an invertible operator X£A'(T) such that XPiX-1 = P2. Thus XranPi = ranP2, Xran(I - Pi) = ran(I - P 2 ). Set X\ = X\ranp1, Then X = X\+X2,
X2 =
X\ran(i_pxy
the topological sum of X\ and X2, and
XiCGLiCiPtH,
P2H)),
- P{)H, (I -
X2GGL(C((I
P2)H)),
where GL(A) is the set of invertible elements in the algebra A. Note that
T=
Ti 0 0 T2
PiH (I-Pi)H
where Tx = T\PlH,T2 = T\{l_Pl)H,T[ A simple calculation shows that T[ 0 0 Ti
Xx 0 0 X2
T[ 0
p2n
on
{1-P2W
= T\P2H and T2' = T\(I_P2)n.
Xx 0 0 X2
Ti 0 0 T2
ThatisT|PlW~T|p2>i. Lemma 4.2.5 Let TeC(H) and let {Pi}?=1 and {Qi}?=1 be two (SI) decompositions ofT. If there exist Xi&GL(C(PiH,QiH)) such that Xi(T\PiH)X-1=T\Qin,i
=
l,2,.-
then X = X!+X2+
Proof
•••
+XneGL(A'(T)).
Since
H = ranP\+ranP2-\
\-ranPn = ranQ\+ranQ2+
• • • +ranQn,
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Ti
pxn
Invariant
of Operators
QlH
T{
;
J
-n
where Tt = T\PiH,T[ is invertible. Lemma 4.2.6
PxH
= T\QiH,i
59
0
Ti
•>
QiH
= 1,2, • • • ,n. Clearly, XT = TX and X
Let \ - * l i ' ' ' ) * m > * 771+1•>' ' ' i -* n /
and •,Qn} 6e two spectral families in A'(T), where TGC(H). If there are X,YGA'(T) and a permutation n of Sn = {1,2, • • • , n) satisfying (i) XPiX'1 =Qi,l. Moreover, {Pr'} is exactly a rearrangement o / { P r } " = m + 1 . Proof Given Qr,m < r
^ r, such that
XYQrY^X^^Qj,. By (ii), YQjxY~l
= PJ2 for some j 2 . If m < J2
If
1<72<TI,
it is obvious that j i ^ j 2 . Otherwise, Qh = Y~lPhY
= Y~lPhY
= Qr,
which contradicts m < r
60
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
Similarly, j 3 g {31,32}- If m < j3
=
^/r2^ir2^T2 •
Without loss of generality, we may assume that Si>S2- If s\ > S2, then ^r2
Note that Z~2Zri
ZriQnZri
ZT2 = Qr2^\Qm+li
' ' • ,Qn}-
= X F - • - X F (X appears j S l — j S 2 times). Set R = YXY- • -XY,
where X appears j S l — j S 2 — 1 times. By the procedure of the choice, we have RQrxR-1e{Pi,P2, • • • ,Pm}. Thus XRQriR-1X-1e{Q1,Q2,--But XRQriR~
X~
=
Z~2 ZriQriZ~i
,Qm}ZT2
= <2r26{Qm+l> • • • ,Qn}-
A
contradiction. Thus s x = S2- But if s\ = s 2 l we can easily prove that Qrx = Qr2, which is also a contradiction. This completes the proof of our Claim and the lemma. By the similar argument of Lemma 4.2.6, we can prove the following result. L e m m a 4.2.7 Letre£(H) i-'l)'*' I M H I I ' "
and let j P-m.k-i — 1) ' ' ' i-• mjt; •• mfc + 1) ' " '
i*nf
and i V l ) ' * ' i V m n ' " i V m i b _ i - l ) " ' j Wmk > Wmk+li " " " j VnJ
be two spectral families in A'{T).
If there exist
X1,X2,---,Xk:YeGL(A'(T)) and a permutation IT of sn such that XiPjX~l
— Qj,mi
+ l<j<mi+i,
i = 0,1, • • • , k - 1, mi = 0
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
61
and Y~1PjY = Q-K(J), l < j < « - Then forVr,mk < r
such that
= T\QiH, l
(ii) there exist a Y&GL(A'(T))
and a permutation ir of Sn such that
Y~~ PtY = <2„-(,),
then given Qr, r£(m + 1, • • • , n), we can find r'G{m + 1, • • • , n} and Zr€GL(QrH,Pr
r(T\Qrn)Zr
=T\piH-
Furthermore, if r\ ^ r2, then r{ ^ r'2. Proof Given r£{m + l,--- ,n}, by (ii) of the lemma there exists an operator Pj1€{Pi}?=1 such that YQrY~x = Pj1. If m < ji
62
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Let {-Pi}£Lx and {Qi}^ be two (57) decomposition of T\PH, and let {Pi}" = T O + 1 be an (SI) decomposition of T\^_P^n. Then {Pi •• l
l
are two (57) decomposition of T. By the uniqueness of the decomposition, we can find an operator YGGL(A'(T)) such that {YPiY-1}
= {Ql,.--
,Qm,Pm+u...
,P„}.
By Lemma 4.2.6, we can find Zi&GL(C(QiH,PiH)) of Sn, such that Zi{T\QiH)Z^ Set Z r = I\pkn,k>m
= T\p^n,
and a permutation TT
l
+ 1 a n d Z = Zi-i
i-Zn. By Lemma 4.2.5,
ZGGL(^'(T)) and Z P W e G L ( ^ ' ( r ) | p W ) . Note that (Z|PW)Qi(Z|p„)-1 = PT(i),l<»<m. The proof of the lemma is complete. Lemma 4.2.10 Let TG£(H). IfT has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. If P and Q are two idempotents in A'(T), then the following are equivalent: (i) P~A>(T)Q; (ii)
T\PH~T\QH-
Proof (i)=^(ii) is a consequence of Lemma 4.2.4. (ii)=Ki). By Lemma 4.2.9, T\pH,T\QH,T\{I_P)n and T\{I_Q)n all have a unique (57) decomposition up to similarity. Since T\PK~T\Q-H, there exists an operator X £GL(C(PH, QH)) such that X(T\pU)X~
=T\QH.
Thus if {Px,P2, • • • ,Pm} is an (57) decomposition of T\PH, then (XP1X-\XP2X-1,--^PmX-1} is an (57) decomposition of T\QH. Assume that {P m +i, • • • , Pn} and {Qm+i, • • • , Qn} are (57) decomposition of T|(/_p) W and T | ( / _ Q ) ^ respectively. Then {Pj}™=1 and {XPiX~l
: \
l
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
63
are two (SI) decompositions of T. By the uniqueness of the decomposition, there exists an operator YeGL(A'(T)) such that {YPiY~l}f=1 is a 1 rearrangement of {XPjX" : l
and r[ = r'2 if and only if n = r%. Set Z = Zi+ • • • +ZneGL(A'(T)).
Since ZPZ"" 1 = Q, by Lemma 4.2.5,
P~A'{T)QLemma 4.2.11 Let T££(H) and let P and Q be idempotents in A'(T). IfT\pn is not similar to T\Q-H, then P©0W<» is not similar to <5©0W(n> in A' (T^n+1^) for each natural number n. Proof If there is an XeGL(A'(T(-n+1'>)) satisfying X(P®OnM)X^
= Q®0Hin)
for some nGN, then by Lemma 4.2.4, T(n+1)
l(Peo w ( „,)«(»+» ~ T ( n + 1 ) |(Q e o K(n) )W(»+D •
But we have r( +1)
"
l(p©o w ( „ ) )w("+ 1 )- r |pw
and T(n+1)
\{Q®On{n))H<-"-+V-T\Q-H-
Therefore
T\PK~T\Q-H-
A contradiction.
Lemma 4.2.12 Given Te£(H). IfT^n) has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity for each natural number n, then for two idempotents P, Q in A'(T), P~A>{T)Q if and only if [P] = [Q] in \/(A'(T)). Proof The "if" part is obvious. Assume that [P] = [Q], then there is a natural number k such that P©0W(io~_4,(T(k+i))<3(B0H(fc). By Lemma 4.2.4, P~A'(T)Q-
T\P-H~T\Q-H-
By Lemma 4.2.10 we conclude that
64
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Proof of Theorem 4.2.1 (i)=S-(ii). Let P be the orthogonal projection from H onto Hi, and let E be an idempotent in A'(T^). Since T<") has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity, by Lemma 4.2.9 T^\E-H(„) and T(n}\,I_g)-H(n) have unique (SI) decompositions up to similarity. If {Qi, ••• , Qa} is an (SI) decomposition of T^\EnM and {Qa+i, ••• , Qb) is an (SI) decomposition of T^\^I_E-)H(n), then {Qi, • • • ,Qb} is an (SI) decomposition of T K Since {P 1 ( n n i ) ,.-- ,Pfc(rmfc)} is also an (SI) decomposition of T^n\ by the uniqueness of the decomposition, there is an XeGL(A'(T^)) such that XQjX-1 Since E = Qi + Q2 + • • • + Qa, XEX'1
= Pt. = X P}mi) • Define a mapping
\J(A'(T)) -> N
then by Lemma 4.2.12, F~E~
E P ^
k
in Moo(A'(T)). U F~ E P ( m i ) in
i=l
i=l
Moo(^'(T)), then h([F]) = h([E}) and F ~ E . Thus /i is one to one. For a &-tuple (mi, • • • , mfc) of nonnegative integers, we can find ma number n i i such that mi
E
pr} to
i=l
(mi, • • • , mfc) and is onto. Thus
\J(A'(T))^N^\ By the construction of h, we know that h([I]) = (n\, • • • , n^). (ii)=*-(i). Suppose that V(-^'( T '))=N (fc) a n d h is the isomorphism. Then there exist a natural number r and k idempotents Qi,--- ,Qk in A'(T^) satisfying h([Qi]) = eu\
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
65
fc fc
Assume that h([P}) = £
A e
* i = £ A;/i([<3i]), A^eN. Set w = r J2 <**,
i=l
i=l
find a natural number n > w such that fc t ,, P©o w( „-i)~ i4 , {r ( n ) ) ] T QlA,)©o " -w- ( n - « 0 .
1=1
By Lemma 4.2.4, T< n >|,p« „ W W r~ -T W |. n . „_„)«(») l(P©o M(
- (Ai, (E Q l ' ®°„(«-»))w(n)
Thus (E
Note that i.e.,
T|P-H€(S7),
Q^i^n^i
thus only one Aj equals 1 and the others are zero, h([P}) = e*
for some i. (b). For arbitrary idempotents P and Q in „4'(T<">), if h([P]) = h([Q]), then T\PH~T\Qn. Repeating the arguments in (a), we get (b). Let {Pi, Pi, • • • , Pm} be a spectral projections of T and assume that fc P
K[ i\) = J2XiJeJ^iJ^N.7=1
Then m i=i
m
k
i=i j=i
fc ra fc fc fc
From h(I) — Y2 n^e*, we have J ] J3 ^»j — 12 n»- Thus m < J^ m. This i=l
i=l j=l
*=1
i=l
implies that the number of elements in each set of spectral projections of T is finite and T is the direct sum of only finitely number of (SI) operators. Furthermore, let {P 1 ; P2, • • • ,Pi} be an (SI) decomposition of T, then fc
E j2 ^-
h(j2iPi}) = H[i]) = i=l
i=l
n
66
Structure of Hilbert Space
k
By (a), t = ^2 ni
aQ
Operators
d for each i, l
i=l
Pil,---,Pinie{P1,P2,-.-,Pt} such that h([Pil]) = -- = h([Pitli]) = ei. By (b), T\PijU~T\pikH,
l<j,k
Denote A, = T\Pi.H, l<j
»=i
Assume that {P{, P2,-- • i P's) ls another (SI) decomposition of T. Then k
repeating the above arguments, we have r = J2ni
an
d f° r
eacn
h l
there are n, idempotents in {P[, P^ • • • , P^} such that ft maps each of them k
to <*. By (b), if h{[Pi\) = h([P$),l
£ ni: then T\Ptn~T\p.n.
By
j=i
Lemma 4.2.5, T has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. The proof of the theorem now is complete. Proof of Corollary 4.2.2 Note that if T W has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity, then by Theorem 4.2.1 Ti~T2 if and only if \J(A'(TX®T2))^N. Therefore, if Ti~T2, then KQ(A'(T1®T2))^Z, since \J(A'(T1®T2))^N. Conversely, if K0(A'(Ti®T2))^Z, by Theorem 3.2.1, V(-4'(Ti©T 2 ))SN( fc \fc<2. Since K0(A'(T1eT2))^Z, V M ' ( T i © ? 2 ) ) = N . Thus Ti~T 2 . This completes the proof of the corollary. The following proposition tells us that besides normal operators, a class of analytic Toeplitz operators whose unitary invariant and similarity invariant are same. In fact, we have stronger result. Proposition 4.2.13 Let ipi and tp2 be two univalent analytic on the unit disk D. Then the following are equivalent: (ii) kerTTvl<Tie2 # {0} and kerrTv2tTvl Proof (i)=>(ii) is obvious. oo
(ii)=>(i).
functions
¥= {0}.
Assume that ifi(z) = £} AJz J ',zeZ?,i = 1,2. Since ?, is j=0
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
univalent, X\ ^ 0 for i = 1,2. If there are X, Y£C(H2)
67
such that
Denote fli = <^i(D),J72 = ^(D). Clearly, fii and Q2 are simply connected and T^eB^flt^T^eBiiQ^). If fi2 ^ fi2, by Lemma 4.2.3 kerrTipi)Tv2
= kerrT^Tify
= {0},
this contradicts our assumption. Thus we may assume that Q.i = Q2 = ^ and o^T^) = cr(TV£,2) = fi. Without loss of generality, we assume that Oefi and v?i(0) = 0, (^2(20) = 0,zo£D. Then there exists a Mobius transformation X:£>->£>
satisfying x (0) = z0. Thus y 2 (x(0)) = 0. This implies that TVtM*TV2UW). Therefore we may assume that ^2(0) = 0. Note that T*VT*2 have the following matrix representations with respect to the ONB {1,2, z2, z3, • • • }: 0 X1 A 2 A 3 • • • 0
A; A 2
••.
0 X1 A 2 A 3 0 Af Al
rp#
0 A?
0 Ai '••
.0
.0
Prom T*XY* = Y*T*2, computation indicates 2/11 2/12 2/13 • '
y* __
2/22 2/23 • '
A2 n-1 and t/nn = [-n"] 2/ii, A
n
2,3,
i
0
We claim that | ^ | < 1 . Otherwise, since Y* is bounded, y n = 0 and ynn = 0 for n = 2,3, • • • . Similarly, j/y = 0 for i, j>l. This contradicts Y* j^0. Similarly, | j t | < l . Thus |Aj| = |A?| = A. Denote 6/j = a^ff-f-
and f/j = diag(l,e
>,e^idj
• ).*' = !. 2-
Structure
68
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Obviously Uj is unitary. Denote 0 A *" 0 A
R^UjT^U^
0 '••
'
0
Since UjT*U* = e~ie'T*, RjSA'(T*),j = 1,2. Thus, there exists a function gjGH00 such that Rj = T*.. Since T*.^T*.,gj(D) =
= 0,^(0) = A > 0 , j = 1,2.
It follows from Riemann mapping theorem that gi = gi and therefore •L
In the following we will compute the i^o-groups of some Banach algebras in terms of Theorem 4.2.1. Theorem 4.2.14 K0(H°°)^Z, V(#°°)=N. Proof Consider the analytic Toeplitz operator Tz. It is well known that
A'(TZ)^H°°. By Theorem 4.2.1, we need only to show that T = TJ has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity for each natural number n. Since T*£Bn(D), there are only finitely number of elements in each spectral family of T*. Thus we need only to prove that if P is a minimal idempotent in A' (T), then T\P(H2)M~TZ. Note that T is an isometric isomorphism and P(H2)^ is an invariant subspace of T, it follows from the famous von-Neumann-Wold theorem T\P^H2^)—TZ. This completes the proof of the theorem. Corollary 4.2.15 K0(H°°(n))^Z and V(#°°(fi))=N, where ft is a nonempty bounded simply connected domain. Proof Since ft is nonempty bounded and simply connected, there exists a univalent analytic function
n
T
N(fc) and
\/M'(5Z® ^))»=i
Ko(A'(J2®T^-zik)i=i
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
69
Furthermore, T — ^ ®TVi has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. Proof
£ ®(H2)n*. Thus it follows
By Proposition 4.2.13, A'(Y, ®TVi)^ i=i
j=i
from the isomorphism of if-groups and Theorem 4.2.14 that
VCA'(E ®^j)- £
© V((#2))K)=N(fc)
and n i=l
To summarize the facts discussed above we have the following corollary. Corollary 4.2.17 Let
(Hi) 4.3
lVl=llfi2;
K0(A!(TVl®TV2))^Z.
(SI) Decompositions of Some Classes of Operators
Using Lemma 2.2.4 and Theorem 4.2.1, we get the following theorem. Theorem 4.3.1 Let Ai,A2,---
, Ak€(SI)n£(H)
A'(Ai)/radA'(Ai)^C,
satisfying
i = 1,2, • • • , k.
Then the following statements hold: (i) Ai~Aj if and only if K0(A'(Ai®Aj))=Z; (ii) LetT = J2 ®A
^ j , then
i=l
\J(A'(T))^N(-k\K0(A'(T))^Z{kl Furthermore, T has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. A unilateral weighted shift T on Hilbert space Ti. is an operator that maps each vector in some ONB {e„}^L0 into a scalar multiple of the next
70
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
vector, i.e., Ten =
anen+i,aneC
for all n. If an ^ 0 for all n, T is injective. Lemma 4.3.2 Let A££(H) be an injective unilateral weighted shift and power bounded, i.e., ||A n ||<M < oo for a constant M > 0 and all n>l. Then there is an injective unilateral weighted shift B with ||J3||<1 such that A~B. Proof Suppose that
A =
0 0 ai 0 a2 0
eo ei e2*
0 It is well known that A is unitarily equivalent to the unilateral weighted shift with weighted sequence {|a n |}. Thus we can assume that a „ > 0 for all n. If an
If Y\ aj>l for all k>ni, then set mi = oo. Otherwise, set j=ni k
mi = min{k>ni
: 1 [ ctj < 1}, j=n1
then mi < oo and ami < 1. If mi < oo, consider the set {k > mi : a^ > 1}. If it is empty, let n^ = oo. Otherwise let ri2 = min{k > mi : a^ > 1}. If k
Y[ Oj>l for all k>ri2, set m
J2 ctj < 1}. Similarly, we define finitely many or countably many rij's and mi's inductively satisfying (1) m0 = 0 < ni < mi < n2 < m2 < • • • < rik < mk < rifc+i < • • • (the last one is oo if the sequence is finite); (2)oy
(3) [ ] ai if nk<j<mk,k i=nk
= 1,2, ••• ;
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
(4) atj
Invariant
of Operators
71
= 1,2,
Define 0<j < n\
fl ai nk<j < mk
Xj
mk<j Denote M = sup{\\Ak\\ Xe£(H) by
: k>l},
< nk+1.
then l<Xj<M,j
OO
OO
3=0
j=0
= 1,2,---. Define
for all J2 oijejCH. It is easily seen that X is invertible. Set B =
X~1AX,
j=o
then B is still an injective unilateral weighted shift. If the weighted sequence of B is {bj}^1, then bj — Note that 0 < bj = <x,
j = nk, k>l, since m fc _i
bj = (\\
ai)~1aj{
xJ1&jXj-i,J>l= Xnk-i if j-i
\[ at) = 1 if
nk < j < mk,k>l. If j = mfc, fc>l, X j - i > l , Oij < 1, thus 0 < bj =
l-ajX-lx
IfTO*< j < rafc,fc>l,0
lim
pn(A).
sot n~+oo
(4) For each h£H°°, ||ft(i4)||<||h||oo, where ||,
H°
is the norm of h in
72
Proof
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Denote R = H{oo) and A
0
{I-A*A)i
0 / 0
T =
Ho
n2-
0
where Hi = H,i = 1,2, • • • . Clearly, T*T = IR, thus T is an isometry. Since 'A* (I-A*
A)*
0 / 0 I
0 T* =
Wo
0
and since {ker(A*)k
: k>l} = H0,H0c\J{ker(T*)k 0
0 " eo
«i 0
A =
: k>l}. If
ei
a2 0
e2
For xfc = 0©0 © • • • © 0 © efc©0© • • • € # , obviously (T*)fc+2a:fc = 0 for all Ar>0. Hence HiC\/{ker(T*)k : k>l}. Similarly, Hjc\J{ker{T*)k : k>l} for all j>0. Therefore T is a pure isometry and for each heH°°,h(T) is well-defined,
ii^cmi = iwioo and there is a sequence {p n }^Li of polynomials such that h(T)=SOT-
lim p„(T). n—>oo
Let Po be the orthogonal projection from i? onto Ho. Define
$(h) = PoHT)\no. Then it is not difficult to see that $ is a homomorphism from H°° to .4'(A) satisfying (l)-(4). Lemma 4.3.4 Lei A be a power bounded injective unilateral shift with o~e{A) = {z : \z\ = 1}, then given T£A'(A), there exists an h£H°° such that T = h(A).
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
73
Proof By Lemma 4.3.2 and Lemma 4.3.3, h(A) is well-defined for each h£H°°. Since 0^ae(A) and kerA — {0}, there exists an injective unilateral weighted shift B such that A*B = I. Since ae(A) = {z : \z\ = 1}, ae(B) = {z : \z\ = 1}. Since B has no eigenvalue and is not invertible, o~(B) = {z : |,z|
For |A| < 1, denote f\ = J2 XnBneo,
then
71=0
A* f\ = A/A and < eo,f\ >= 1. It is obvious that /^ is a vector-valued analytic function for X&D. Given TGA'(A), define /i(A)=
power bounded injective unilateral weighted shift and ae(A/r) = {z : \z\ = 1}. By Theorem 4.3.6, \J (A'{A))*?N, K0(A'(A))^Z and A™ has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity for each natural number n. Example 4.3.8 Let T be an injective unilateral weighted shift with decreasing weight sequence {wn}^=1 and lim wn = 0. A simple compu-
74
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
tation shows that A'(T)/radA'(T)^C. By Theorem 4.3.1, \/(A'(T))^N, KQ{A'(T))=7i and T^"' has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity for each natural number n. In the following we will discuss the class of bilateral weighted shift. An operator AGC(H) is called a bilateral weighted shift if there is an ONB {e n }^L_ 00 of the space H and a sequence { a „ } ^ = _ 0 0 of complex numbers such that Aen = anen+i. If an ^ 0 for all n, then A is injective. It is wellknown that A is unitarily equivalent to the bilateral weighted shift with weight sequence {|«n|}^L_oo- ^n w h a t follows we always assume A is an injective bilateral weighted shift with (real) monotone weight sequence and A is not invertible. Denote
0
ax 0
e2
a0
ei
0
eo
a-i
A = 0
a_ 2 0
Q!_3
e_i e-2 e-3
0
S R 0 T
\fiej : j > 0 } = H+ \Z{ej :j<0} = H--
We assume that a,j>aj+\ > 0 and
lim an = 1. Since A is not invertible,
lim an = 0. n—* + oo
For polynomial p(.z) = £) OjZJ', denote j=0
PW = Then MT^WpW^
p(S) i? p 0 p(T)
and |b(S)||<|W|oo- Let Q and P* be the orthogonal
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
75
projections from H onto H- and , respectively,
V w := \A A e * : A e C >' k =°- ± 1 > ± 2 ' • • • • Note that when /c>0, &—1
71
A;-Rp = ^ Q j P f c ^ Q = j=0
E
(otj J J
fc<j
ai)ek®ek-j.
i=k—j
Thus t.
1
„
L.
1
fa
^
\\pkRPh<{ n «o( E «?)*<( n «onpii2<(n aoiHioo, i= —1
j=fc+l
i= —1
i= — \
where ||Pfc7?p||2 is the Hilbert-Schmidt norm of PkRp, \\p\U is the norm of p in H2(dD). Therefore, +oo
P P II 2 < E n*wi2< E( fc=0
n ai)iipn- < +°°-
+oo fc—1
fc=0
i=-l
are
If {pn}n°=i uniformly bounded in H°° and converges to some h£H°° uniformly in every closed subset of D, then {pn(S)}^=i and {pn(T)}n°=1 converge to h(S) and h(T), respectively, in strong operator topology, and {Rp^n^i converges to some operator Rh in the Hilbert-Schmidt norm. Thus for each h£H°°, we get an operator 'h(S) Rh ' 0 h{T)\ ' denoted by h{A). more,
Obviously, H/i^U^U/iH^ and h(A)eA'(A).
Further-
(/ii + h2){A) = hi(A) + h2(A), hxh2{A) = fti(i4)fea(4) for all
h1,h2£H°°.
Theorem 4.3.9 A'(A)/radA'(A^H00, where A is an injective bilateral weighted shift with decreasing weight sequence {oin}t^-oo' ^m an = 1 n—> — oo
and A is not invertible. Proof By the analysis above, we need only to show that for each XeA'(A), there exists an h£H°° such that X = h(A) + Q, where
76
Structure of Hilbert Space
QGradA'(A).
Operators
Assume that
Xn
-Xio
-X^l-1 -X^l-2
^oi
-Xoo
Xo-1
Xo-2
ei
eo
X = X_i_i X_i_2
X_21 X_20
e-i e-2
A"_2-l -X"-2-2
For each integer k, denote Ak(X) = (£ijXzj)i,j, where e^ 1 i—j =k . That is, Afc(X) is the operator, which reserves the fc-th 0 i-jj£k diagonal in the matrix representation of X and let the other entries be zero. It is obvious that X commutes with A if and only if A commutes with every Ak(X). Moreover, computations indicate that Ao(X) = xool, ^k(X)A^ commutes with A and A0(Ak(X)A^) = Ak(X)A^ for k < 0. Thus there is a constant a such that Ak{X)A^ = al. If a ^ 0, we have
{a~lAk{X)A\k^l)A
= A{a~1^k(X)A^-1)
= I.
This contradicts that A is not invertible. Therefore a = 0 and Afc(X) = 0 for all k < 0. Thus
X =
Xi X 2 0 X3
and X commutes with T. A simple computation shows that Xi X2 eradA'{A). 0 0 Since ae{T) = {z : \z\ = 1}U{0} and ||T|| = 1, we can find heH°° and QeradA'(A) such that X2 = h(T) + Q by Lemma 4.3.4. This completes the proof of the theorem. Theorem 4.3.10 Let AECCH) be an injective bilateral weighted shift with monotone weight sequence. If A is not invertible, then \f(A'(A))^,
K0(A'(A))^Z
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
77
and A^n> has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity for each natural number n. Given two power bounded injective unilateral weighted shifts A~{ak}'j?Li and B~{/3fc}^=1, by the arguments used in the proofs of Lemma 4.3.3 and Proposition 4.2.13, we have the following proposition. Proposition 4.3.11 A~B {0}.
if and only if kerTA B ¥" {0} and kerrg A ¥"
Note, if A is not similar to B, then kerTA,B = {0} or kerrs,A Assume that kerTA,B = {0}. Define
= {0}.
B 0
.° A It follows from kerTA,B = {0} that A'(T) = {
TB
TBA
0
TA
:TBeA'(B),TAeA'(A)
By Proposition 4.3.5, A'(T)/radA'(T)^H00®Hco. lowing proposition.
and
TBA&kerTB,A}.
Thus we have the fol-
Proposition 4.3.12 Let A, BeA'(T) be two power bounded injective unilateral weighted shifts, then the following are equivalent: (i) A~B if and only if A'(A®B)/radA'(A®B)^M2(H°°); (ii) A is not similar to B if and only if A'(A®B)/radA'(A®B)^H°°®H'x; (Hi) A~B if and only if K0(A'(A®B))^Z; (iv) A is not similar to B if and only if KQ(A'(A®B))=Z®Z. Let S be the unilateral shift on H2 given by Sf = zf(z), feH2. Let 9GH°° be a nonconstant inner function and Pg denote the projection of H2 onto H(6) = H2eOH2. The Jordan block S(9) is defined by S(9) = PBS\H(6) [Bercovici, H. (1988)]. In the following, we will prove that for the singular inner function 9 with S(6)e(SI),S(6)(-n^ has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. Applying this result we get that V^ has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity. Theorem 4.3.13 Let 9GH°° be a singular inner function such that S(9)£(SI), then for each n>l,S(9)^ has a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity.
78
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Proof Applying the six-term exact sequence of if-theory [cf. [Taylor, J. (1975)]] and the short exact sequence of Banach algebra O-^0H°°
- U H°° -^
Hoo/0H°°
— • 0,
we obtain the following exact sequence of groups Q^K0(H°°)
- ^ Ko(H°°/0H00)
-£+ KiiOH00)
-±> Ki[H°°),
(4.3.1)
where 7r* (resp. i») is the induced homomorphism of -K (resp. i) on KQ{H°°) (resp. Ki(9H°°)) and d is the connected homomorphism. It is proved [Tolokommokov, V. (1993)] that Bar((9H°°)+) = 1, where Bar((0H°°)+)=min{n:(alr--
,am+1)T<=Lgm+1((0H°°)+)
such that (aj + b\, a m +i, • • • , am + bmam+i )TeL<7m((0tf°°)+) for some {6 i }^ 1 c(6'ii' 0 0 ) + ,V m>n}, and n
Lgn((0H°°)+)
: aie(0Hoo)+,
= {(ai,---,anf
(i = 1,2, • • • , n ) , ^ a ^ = 1 2=1
T
+
for some (&!,••• ,bn) ,bi£(6H°°) (i = 1,2,-•• , n ) } . From this i(0H°°)+ is an isomorphism [Wang, Z.Y. and Xue, Y.F. (2000)]. Thus for any a£Ki(9H°°) with n(a) = 0 in Ki(H°°), there is an / = 0g + leGLrd&H00)-*-) for some geH°° such that [a] == [/] in Ki(0H°°) and i»([/]) = 0 in ^ ( t f 0 0 ) . Thus we can find heH°° such that f = eh so that e ' W = TT(/) = 1. Noting that A'(S(0))S*H°°/0H°° and since 00 S(9)G(SI), we have that H^/OH contains no non-zero idempotent. Therefore ir(h) = 2km for some integer k [Taylor, J. (1975)] and hence he(eH°°)+. So / = eh£(6H°°)+. This means that d = 0 by (4.3.1). Finally, we conclude from (4.3.1) and [Wang, Z.Y. and Xue, Y.F. (2000)] that Ko(H°°/9H00) = {n[l] : n e Z } . Let P be a nontrivial idempotent in A'(S{0)W) = Mn(A'(S(0))). Since g
ueHco}^H°°/9H°°,
and k with l < f c < n - 1 such that P =
Xdiag(Ik,Q)X-1.
Unitary Invariant
Set Ti = X\
diag(ikfi)H<-n)
and Similarity
an
d T2 — X T1T2 =
Invariant
1
\PH(n).
of Operators
79
It is easy to verify that
IpHW
and ^2^1 =
Idiag(Ik,0)HM
and T a S ( 6 l ) < n W . o r i = diafl(S(0)
and
s(e)^\PiHin)e(Si)(i
= i,2,---,m).
By the above arguments, S(9)^\P.H(n)£(SI) operator Xi€GLi(A'{S(6))) such that Pi = Xidiag{IH2,0)Xr1, m
implies that there exists an
(i = 1,2, • • • , m).
m
Thus n[/# a ] = [ £ P.] = £ [ # ] = m[IH2] in 7f o (,4'(S(0)))=Z. Since [J*,] i=l
i=l
is the only generator of Ko(A'(S(6))), we get that n = m. Therefore we can choose YieGLi(A'(S{0)^)) such that Pi = Yidiag(0,0,---
, 0 , 7 ^ , 0 , •• • . O ) ^ " 1 = YieiYr\
(i = 1,2,- • • ,n).
n
Set V = J ] PiYi. Then it is easy to check that FeGL 1 (^'(5(0)(" ) )) with F - 1 = £) y . " 1 ^ and y - ^ - y = e*. That is 5(0)
finite (SI) decomposition up to similarity.
80
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Let V be the Volterra operator on H = L2([0,1]) denned by
Vf(t)= [
Jo
f(s)dsjen,te[0,i}.
Then ||V|| = ^,a(V) = {0} and A'(V) is the weak closure of the algebra generated by IH and V. Put Tv = (IH - V){IH + V)'1. Then A'(TV) = A'{Tv) and Ty is unitarily equivalent to 5(e) by [Bercovici, H. (1987)] and hence A'(V)^H°°/eH°°, where e(z) = exp(^). Corollary 4.3.14 Ve(SI) and 0 n > has a unique finite (SI) decomposition up to similarity for each n>\. Proof We have supp(e) = {1} and every nontrivial divisor of e has the form et(z) = Aezp(*f±i),0 < t < 1, |A| = l,zeD. Take zn = 1
, n = 1,2, ••• . n Then lim e t (z„) = lim (e/e t )(z„) = 0, i.e., ( e t , e / e t ) T £ Lg2(H^). n—»oo
So
n—>oo
5(e) G (57), since it is not difficult to see that S(9) 0 (57) if and only if there exists a nonconstant division B\ of 0 such that (6i,6/9i)T£Lg2(H(-00^). Now suppose that {P^^dA'(V^) is an idempotents, PjP, = 0(i ^ j ) m
and ^ Pi= I. Let Q be an idempotent in .4'(Ty |p.W(„)). Then gPiG^'(2v n ) ) = ^ ' ( ^ ( n ) ) is an idempotent and moreover Q^A'(V^\PiH(n)). Thus lA™)|p.-H(„)€(57) ) means that Q = 0 or Pu i.e., T^" | Pi H(«)e(57), so that {Pi}^ is an (57) decomposition spectral family of Ty . By Theorem 4.3.13, n = m and there is YzGLi(A'(V^)) such that P< = YeiY~l,(i = 1,2,--- ,n). The corollary follows.
4.4
The Commutant of Cowen-Douglas Operators
As indicated in Theorem JW2 of Chapter 1, Cowen-Douglas operators have very rich contents, including many of hypernormal operators and subnormal operators. In order to characterize the similarity invariant of CowenDouglas operators, we will discuss the commutant of Cowen-Douglas operators in this section, which is the preparation for characterizing the similarity invariant of Cowen-Douglas operators in Chapter 6.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
81
In this section, we always assume that TeS n (fi), thus V ker(T — z) = H, where H is a complex, separable, infinite dimensional Hilbert space. Note that B1(Q,)c(SI) and for every TeBi(fi) we can easily prove the following result. Proposition CD [Cowen, M.J. and Douglas, R. (1977)] A'(T) isomorphic to a subalgebra of H°°(Q).
is
Proposition CD indicates that if Tei3i(f)), then A'(T) is commutative. In the finite dimensional space C", J n ( A ) s £ ( C n ) , and A'(Jn{X)) is commutative. For Volterra operator V, A'(V) is also commutative. In Section 4.5, we will see that for multiplication operator Mf on the Sobolev disk algebra, MjeBi(D) if and only if A'(Mf) is commutative. In Chapter 5, we will show that the set of strongly irreducible operators, whose commutant is commutative, is dense in the set of all Cowen-Douglas operators in the norm topology. Example 4.4.1
Let Xk = \ and Wk = Xk + J-i 0WX 0 0 W2 T =
Afc 1 0 Afc
Define
C2 C2 °° 2 C2<E£(J>C l
Proposition 4.4.2 Suppose that TG.C(T(.) where H = 8 C 2 . Then (i) Te(SI); (ii) A'{T) is not commutative; (Hi) A'(T)/radA'(T) is commutative. Proof (i) Suppose that PGA'(T), then P i i A2P13 • • • P22
P23 • • P33 ••
c 22 c C2
is given in Example 4-4-1>
(cf. [Jiang, C.L. and Li, J.X. (2000)])
0 and Pfc+i fc+1 = Ek 1PuEk for all k > 1, where Ek = W1W2- • -Wk. Compu-
82
Structure
1 fe+i fc! 2(fc-l)!
tation indicates that Ek = [_
Then Pk+lk+l=Ek
0
Operators
an
. Assume that P n
h
a 12
0-21 0,22
fc!
PnEk an
0
of Hilbert Space
A;!
\_ fc+i fc! 2(fc-l)!
a12
0-21 0,22
a
n - <»2i2^\y. k l
(an - a 2 2 ) # I J T * ! + °ia ~ a
^2U^vk]
0.21 „ fc(fc+l) Oil ~ Q21 2
+ 0,22 fc2(fc+l)2 4
/ \k(k+l) . Q ( a n - a22j V 2 + 12 ~ a 2 1 fc(fc+l) . «21 + «22 2
A21
«2I(2^I)T)2(^)2
Since k(k + 1) —> oo as k —> oo, a,2i = 0 and a n = 022It is easy to see that if P 2 = P , then P = 0 or 7, i.e., Te(SI). (ii)
° *
Denote ^4Q =
00
Since WkA0 = A0Wk for all k>l,
A := diag(i4 0 , A), • • • )zA'(T).
Denote B02
10 00
Set B fcfc+2 = Ek-1B02W3Wi-
fc!_M^i)fc,
-Bfcfc+2 =
0
jfc!
10 00
1 3-4-5
(fc+2)
/•I i(*+B)-fc (fc+2) "" 3-4-5 (fc+2)
0
0
fc(fc+5)
(fc+l)(fc+2)
2(fc+l)(fc+2)
0
0
3+4+5+--- + (fc+2) 3-4-5 (fc+2)
0 U
3-4-5
• -Wk+2 for fc>l. Then
1 3-4-5
(fc+2)
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
83
of Operators
Thus ||5fcfc+2|| < 2 for all k>l and
B:=
00Bo2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 B13 0 0 0 • • • 0 0 0 0 5 2 4 0 0 • • €C(H).
Computation implies B£A'(T). But since A0B02 ^ therefore A'(T) is not commutative. (iii) Suppose that BGA'(A), then Bu
BQ2AO,AB
^ BA, and
B\2 5 i 3 • • • B22 B23 • • •
5 =
B33 • • •
0 Similar to the proof of (ii), we have
Bij =
Let
0 4
{ek}kLi be an ONB of H = ®C^ 'OWi
such that
0
0 0 W2 0 ••• 0 0
respect to {efc}^=1, where Wk =
0 W 3 ' •.
*1
We may rearrangement {ek}kxL1 denoted by {fk}kx'=i such that 4-
"yli_S" 0 Ai W 2 '
84
Structure of Hilbert Space
oo
Operators
oo
where Hi = V {f2k},H2 = V {/2/t-i} and A;=l
fc=l
0 10
h h /ka ' A l
00±
Ai =
000
=
0 1 0 ••• 00± 0
/3
000
/5"
1
/l
S72fc-i = /2it-2 and 5 / i = 0. Note that Bij
0 b£
Thus 5 i B12 0 52
5
W2'
Without loss of generality, we may assume that Hi —H^- Then H H'
Ax S 0 Ai
A:
where S us an injective back shift with power sequence {1}. By former argument, we have B1B12
B =
0
where Bi&A'(Ai),i = 1,2. Suppose that B,TeA'(A). B =
•Bi B12 0
B2
,
V
BGA'(A),
Then
ft
£2
T=
TiT 1 2 " H 0 T2 H
Furthermore, BT - T B it follows that A'(Ai) commutative.
0*" H 00 -;H'
is commutative. It shows that A'(A)/radA'(A)
is
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
85
In the chapter 6, we will show that the class of operators C := {TeCH)D(SI) : A'{T)/radA'(T) is commutative} is dense in (57) operators in norm topology. Therefore we have the following conjecture. Conjecture
Given TeC(H)n(SI),
A'{T)/radA'(T)
is commutative.
If Te6 n (fi)n(S7), we can give a confirmative answer to the conjecture. Theorem 4.4.3 Let AGBn(Q.)n(SI), then there exists a natural number m, 0 < m
Let
TGBn(n),AeA'{T) and A(z) := A| f c e r ( T _ z ). If a(A(z)) is disconnected at zo£Q, then there exists a positive number 6 such that cr(A(z)) is disconnected in each point in D(zo, 5) := {z : \z — ZQ\ < 5}. Thus we can find a positive number s such that a(A(z))r\D(\(zo),s) = \(ZQ),Z&D(ZO,5), where A(zo) is an eigenvalue of A(ZQ). Set P(z)=
{A{z)-X)-1dX.
f dD(\(z0),e)
P(z) is said to be a holomorphic idempotent defined on D(\(zo), e) induced by A'(T). If each holomorphic idempotent P(z) induced by A'(T) satisfies dimker(T\
v
r a n (P( 0 ) _ Z o ) )
< n,
then n is called the minimal index of T or we say that T has the minimal index n. Example 4.4.5 IfTGBi(Q),
the minimal index ofT is 1.
Example 4.4.6 Assume that f(t) = z(z~ | ) , then Tj£B2(Q)n{SI),OeQ. 2 is not the minimal index ofTi. But there is a connected open set fii such thatT^B^VLx).
86
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Example 4.4.7 For the analytic Toeplitz operator Tzi, T*2€B2(D). ple computation shows that T*2 has no minimal index.
A sim-
By the definition, we have the following proposition. Proposition 4.4.8 Given A£Bn(Q,), n is the minimal index of A if and only if there is no B£Bm(Q),m < n, such that BGA'(A). According to the literature of [Cowen, M.J. and Douglas, R. (1977)] (Chapter 3), we have the following proposition. Proposition 4.4.9 T£Bn(Q)r\(SI), there is a natural number m,0 < m
A2 =
(A*\ni)
Then Ai
A12
Hi
0 A2 By Lemma 1.2 of [Herrero, D.A. (1990)], erp(A*) = 0. Thus dimH{ Since A — z is right invertible for zefl, let B =
Bi
B12
Hi
0
B2
Hi
= oo.
be a right inverse of A — z, i.e., (A - z)B
~A\-z 0 ~IHI
.°
.4l2 'B1B12 A2-z_ 0 B2 0 " IH
±.
Thus (A2 — z)B2 = Iftj-, and Ai — z is right invertible for zef2. It is not difficult to prove that B2&Bi{Q) for some I < n. Let ir be the canonical mapping from £(H) to £(H)/JC(H), where £(H)/fC(H) is the
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
87
Calkin algebra. Then we have n(B)n(A
- z) =
ir(I W l )
0
0
7T(/ W x)
This implies that ran(A\ — z) is closed. Denote (ei(?/),••• ,ek(y)) holomorphic frame of ranP(y), then for l<j
=
= (\{y) -
\J ranP(y),ran(Ai
the
z)ej(y).
— z) = H\ for each zG<&.
Thus
Let m = n — I, the proof of the theorem is complete.
Lemma 4.4.11 [[C owen, M.J. and Douglas, R. (1977)] Let f : ri—+Gr(n,H) be a holomorphic curve, where fi is a connected open set. Let Ef be a vector bundle defined on fi and let ri(z),--- ,rn(z)) be the holomorphic frame of Ef. If ri(zo),-- • ,rn(zo) form an ONB of f(z0), then there exists a holomorphic frame rj", • • • ,7^. of Ef, defined on some open set A containing ZQ, such that ri(zo) =n{zQ),i
= 1,2, ••• ,n
and < ^k)(zo),rj(zo)
>= 0, l
1,2, • • • .
Proof of Theorem 4.4.3 Without loss of generality, we assume that n is the minimal index of A and D c O . If there is a B£A'(A) such that a(B(0)) = {Ai, A2}, Ai =^ A2, then since B(z) is holomorphic for z€.Q, there exists an £ > 0 such that <x(B(z)) = {X1(z),\2(z)},zeD(0,e)
= {z : \z\ < e},X1{z) ? X2(z),Xi(0)
and A2(0) = A2. Since B(z) is holomorphic on Q, we can find an £1 > 0 such that D(Xue1)na(B(z))=D(X1,e1)na(B(z))
= {Ai(z)}
D(X2,e1)n
= {X2(z)}.
and = D(X2,e1)n<j(B(z))
= Ai
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Set P(z)=
(B(z)-\y1dX,zeD(0,e1).
J SD(Ai,ei)
Then I-P{z)=
{B(z)~\)-1d\,zeD{0,ei).
f dD(X2,El)
Denote M =
\J
ranP(z). By Proposition 4.4.10, we may assume that
«e£»(0,ei)
Ai := A\M&Bk{Cl). Denote A2 = {A*\Mi.)*,Bl Me{LatA)n(LatB) and A =
Ai A12 0 A2
=
B\M,B2
=
M M x. B
(B*\Mx)*.
Bi B\2 0 B2
Note that
M
where LatA denotes the lattice of invariant subspaces of A. Let {e\(z), • • • ,ek(z)} be a holomorphic frame of {ek+i(z), • •• ,en(z)} be a holomorphic frame of E2 = {(x, z) : x€(I - P(z))ker(A
- z),
ZGD(0,
EA1
and
e)},
then {ei(z),--- , ek(z), ek+i{z), • • • ,en(z)} is a holomorphic frame of EA-I on£(0,e). Since AB = BA,B\A\ = A\B\. By Proposition 4.4.10 it follows from Ai€6fc(fi) that A2£Bn-k{Sl). Denote Hi = kerA,H2
= kerA2GkerA,
• • • ,Hm = kerAmekerAm'1,-
By Theorem CD in Section 1.4, we have Wi©W2® • • • ®Hm = V k 0 ^ 0 )
:
!<*<», 0 < j < m - 1},
and 0 Al2 A13 • • 0 A 2 3• •
0 '•
Bn B\2 B\z H2
B22
B
B23
B-33
n2
••.
Unitary Invariant and Similarity Invariant of Operators
Denote A = kerA1,L2 = kerA\ekerAi,• • ,Cm = kerAfekerAm~1,-• • . By Theorem CD again, Cii ®Cm = V R 0 ^ 0 ) : l
Bn
0 A12 A13 0 A'23 A, =
C2
0
B'33
0 Since
B12 B13 B22 B23
0 Therefore
BGA'(A),B1€A'(A1).
Bk+i,k+i~Bk,k
and B'k+i,k+i~B'kk,
k= 1,2,-•• .
Since B'n =- B l\/{ei(0),-,e f c (0)},
°{B'n)
= {Ai} and
= 1,2,
Set B'w •••
B'lm
£1
{B\)m =
B'mm_ r
. ° then
a ( ( S ! ) m ) = {Ai}. Since Bu = B| f c e r^ff(5ii) = {Ai,A a }. Thus a(5 fcfc ) = {Ai,A2},fc = l , 2 , - - Set B\\
• ••
B\m
Bm — v
-^mm _
Hm
A
c3-
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
90
then a(Sm)
=
{Xl,X2}.
Define Pm =
(Bm - A)-xdA
f M>(Al,£l)
and Pm = Pm®0 £ ®Uk • k>m.
Then Pm is an idempotent and PmAm 0 A12
•• •
o
= AmPm,
Air,
where
Hi
••
"lm-1
o Denote Af = \J{ranPm
fc>m
Tim
: m = 0,1,2, • • • } , then N&{LatA)C\{LatB)
and
JW{0}. OO
{Claim 1} Af = M = V f o C O . - " ,e n (z) : z€D(0,ei)} = V AnSince V { e P ( 0 ) : l
- l } c V / R ^ C 0 ) : 0
- 1},
A © • • • ©AnCfti© • • • ©W m , A © • • • ®Cm£LatB and Cx@---®Cm£LatBm. Note that fcer(S! - A)n = ker{Bx ~ Ai)* = kerAx = \/{ei(0), • • • , efc(0)}. A simple computation indicates that dimker(Bm
- \i)mn
= mk.
For each x£C\® • • • ©An, we have (Bm - Ax) m "x = ((ST) m - X^x
= 0.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
- Xi)mn
=
91
This implies that A © • • • ®£mCker(Bm
ranPm.
Since dim{Ci® • • • ®£m) = mk, C\® • • • ®Cm = ranPm Denote K = \J{ek+l{z),---
and M = M..
,e„(z):ze£)(0,e1)},
then JCe{LatA)r\(LatB). Define Qm=
f J SD(A 2 ,ei)
(Bm - A)-^A and Qm = Qm®0
E
k>m
@7ik.
Similarly, we can get K. = \J{ranQm : m = 1,2, • • • }. Since {e\(z),- • • ,ek{z),ek+i(z), • • • ,en(z)} is a holomorphic frame of EA, we can obtain an ONB of kerA by Gram-Schmidt orthogonalization. Without loss of generality, we may assume that {ei(0),--- ,e fc (0),e fe +i(0),--- ,e n (0)} is the ONB of kerA. Since \\(z) ^ \2(z),z£D(0,ei), by Lemma 4.4.11, Theorem JW 1 in Chapter 1 and the argument of Claim 1, we have the following Claim 2. {Claim 2} There are two subspaces E\ and E\ of Wj, i = 1,2, • • • , satisfying (i) Hi = E[+Ei,E\C\Ei1 = {0}(ii)
0
Bn
W2 W3'
B\2
Bis
B22 B23
B =
B.33
n2 w3'
Structure of Hilbert Space
92
Operators
where "11 "12
Aij —
0
a\\
Bij =
0 4
{Claim 3 } K + M = H and K,C\M = {0}. By Claim 2, we can assume that V{ e j
(0) : l ^ J < n } = 'Hm+i- Set Bn
0 A 1 2 0 ••• Wi 0 A23 • • •
X(d)
0
0
Wl
B22
0
n2 Hz-
0 "-.
B33
then ,4(d)€#„.(fii), where OeftiCft. Since AB = BA, A{d)B{d) = B{d)A{d). Since a(Bn)
= {Ai,A 2 } and since Sfc+1:fc+1~Bfc,fc, a(B(d)) = {X1,X2}
and (B(d) - Ai)*(5(d) - A 2 )"- fc = 0. Set P =
(B(d) — X)~1dX. Then P i s an idempotent. To complete
J 3£>(AI,EI)
the proof of Claim 3, we need the following Claim 4. {Claim 4 } r a n P = M. Set > n
•••
0
: , Pm(d) =
Bm(d) 0
•Bn
and Pm(d) = P m (d)®0 £
Hm &-yik.
J
(Bm(d) - X)^dX
aD(All£l)
Then {P m (^)}m=i
are
uniformly bounded.
fc>m
By Banach-Alaoglu Theorem, Pm{d) converge to P in weak operator topology. It is easy to see that ranPl{d)=ranP1
= {ei(0),--- ,e fc (0)}.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
93
Note that \/{ef(p) : l<j
- z)cker(A
- z)
and dimker(A — z) = n < +oo, (B(z) - f{z))nker{A
- z) = 0, zGQ..
Since B(z) = Ax{z)A2{z) - A2{z)Al(z), f{z) = 0. Thus B(z)nker(A-z) = 0. It follows from \J{ker(A - z) : zefl} = H that Bn = 0. Therefore BEradA'(A) and the proof of second part of Theorem 4.4.3 is now complete. By Theorem 4.4.3 and its arguments, we have the following corollary. Corollary 4.4.12
Let AeBn(Q,)n(SI), radA'{A) = {BeA'(A)
then :Bn=0}.
Corollary 4.4.13 Let AeBn(£l), then AG(SI) if and only if A'(A)/r adA'(A) is isomorphic to a subalgebra of H°°. Proof Since H°° contains no nontrivial idempotent, A'(A)/r adA'(A) has no nontrivial idempotent, thus nor does A'(A). This proves the sufficiency. The necessity follows from Theorem 4.4.3.
94
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
By Factorization Theorem / = \Q f° r e a c n function f£H°°, where x is an inner function and Q is an outer function. If \ is a finite Blaschke product, then by the knowledge of Toeplitz operator Tf£Bn(Q). Thus we have the following corollary. Corollary 4.4.14 Let feH°°. If there is a XQ&D such that inner part °f f — /(-^o) is a finite Blaschke product, then Tf^(SI) if and only if A'(Tf)^H°°. Proof We first prove that if Tfe(SI), then radA'(Tf) = {0}. Without loss of generality, we assume that / = \Qi where x is a Blaschke product of order n and Q is a outer function. It follows from [Cowen, C.C. (1978)], that A'{Tf)cA'(Tx). But Tx^n). Thus A'(Tx)^Mn(A'{Tz)). Since radMn(A'(Tz)) radA'(Tf) By Corollary 4.4.13, A'(Tf) A'{Tf)^H°°. 4.5
= {0}, = {0}.
is commutative.
Since
H°°
The Sobolev Disk Algebra
Let Q be an analytic Cauchy domain in the complex plane and let W22(Q) denote the Sobolev space W22(ti) = {f&L2(Q,,dm) : the distributional partial derivatives of first and second order of / belong to L2(Cl,dm)}, where dm denotes the planar Lebesque measure. For f,g€W22(Q,), we define
IDafD^dm,
7
then W 22 (fi) is a Hilbert space and a Banach algebra with identity under an equivalent norm. By Soblov embedding theorem, f&W22(Q) implies that feC(Ti) and ||/|| C m)<M||/||n/22 ( n) for some M. For f£W22(Cl), the multiplication operator Mf on W22(fl) is denned as Mfg = fg,
geW22(n).
Let
W(n) := {Mf : f£W22(Q)},
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
95
then W(Q.) is a strictly cyclic operator algebra with strictly cyclic vector e(s,t) = 1. It has been proved that a(Mz) = aire{Mz) = Q. and A'(MZ) = W(Q). Let Aa(Mz) be the algebra generated by the rational functions of Mz with poles outside Q and R(Q) := Aa(Mz)e. Since W(Q) is strictly cyclic, there exist positive numbers N and K such that for each / G W / 2 2 ( 0 ) ,
N\\f\\w>Hn)<\\Mf\\
k*Z0(Mf(n)) =
f(zQ)=
for some kZo€R(Q), and kZo£ker(Mz(Q.) — z0)*; (Hi) A'(MZ(Q)) = Aa(Mz{Q)) = {M/(fl) : feR(Q)}, where M,(fi) := Mf\mn). Therefore A'(MZ(U)) is strictly cyclic and Mz(£l) is rational strictly cyclic. Proof (i) If 20 £ Q, then
(*o -
z^eRiCl),
M(*o-*)-i = (ZQ - M , ) " 1
and M ( ^_ x ) -i(fi) = ( z 0 - M , ( f i ) ) - 1 . Therefore, a(Mz(Cl))(Zil. Assume that z0 6 (T and for all g£R(£l), the function (z0 - Mz(Q,))g = (zo - ^)s(z) vanishes at z0. Thus zo - M 2 (fi) is not onto and a{Mz(Q))cCl. Let z 0 efi, then for /ei?(fi) there exist a number (5 > 0 and a function h analytic in T such that
f(z)-f(z0)
=
(z-z0)h(z),zeY,
96
Structure of Hilbert Space
where T := {zeC : \z - z0\ < 6}cTcCl.
Operators
Denote
1
A
E := Q. - - F = n - {zeC : |z - z 0 | < - } and define
«.)-{*<*> /(z)(z-z )
-1
0
-*e£
Then f(z) — /(zo) = (z — zo)<7(z) for all zefi and g is analytic in fi. Note that f Qf 9 y \9\2dm<—J |(z-Zo)0(z)|2dm<-^||/-/o||2y22(f1), i.e.,
[ / (
^
/ ( 2
°
) ]
= /'(*) = g(z) + (z-
z0)g'(z)eL\E).
We have (z - z 0 )s'(*)€L 2 (£;). Thus jf \g'{z)\2dm< 1 ^ |(z - z 0 ) 5 '(z)| 2 dm< J ^ l / - / o | | U ( n ) That is g'eL2(E).
Since
a 2 [ / ( z ) - / ( z 0 ) ] _ o „ , , ,_ , „ - 2,
2 5 ' + (z - z 0 ) f l "eL (£),
ds2 we have (z — zo)g"&L2{E) and
^|5"W| 2 rfm<|||/-/ 0 || 2 v 2 2 ( n ) . Therefore, 5 e W 2 2 ( £ ) . For k = 0,1,2 and z e f r = {zeC : |z - z 0 | < §<J}, by Cauchy formula,
I^WI-ISi/K^*1^!*1"01«esr 2
Therefore, (?,(?', 5 "eZ, (§r) and # e W 2 2 ( § r ) , Since geW22(E) at the same time, we have g£W22(Q,). It follows from / ( z ) = /(ZQ)+(Z—zo)g(z) that the
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
97
of Operators
codimension of ran(Mz(tt) - ZQ) is 1. It is obvious that ker(Mz(Q) — ZQ) = {0}, thus z0Gps-F(Mz(n)), ps-F(Mz(n)) = fi and ind(Mz(Q) - zQ) = - 1 . (ii) and (hi). Denote A := {M/(fl) : feR(Q.)}. It is easy to see that A is a commutative algebra with identity closed in weak operator topology and Ae = R(fl), that is A is strictly cyclic. By [Lambert, A (1971)], the adjoint space A* = {g* : there exists a function g£R(Q) such that g"(Mf{Sl))=<Mf{Sl)e,g>}. Thus, for homomorphism k*0 : k*ZQ{Mf(Q)) = f(zo),f£R(Cl), kZa£R(il) such that
there exists a
K0(Mf(n)) = f(z0) =< Mf{Q)e,kZ0 >=< f,kZ0 > . On the other hand, if p : A —> C is a homomorphism, then p(M,(n)) = z 0 G f f ( M / ( n ) ) = n . For a rational function r{z) with poles outside fi, p(r(Mz(Q))) = r(zo). Since {r(M 0 (fi))} is dense in A, p(Mz(Q)) = f(z0) for each /G.R(fi). Let s€fl(n), then < g,(Mz(n) - z0)*kZo >=< (z - z0)g,kZo >= 0. Therefore, kzoeker(Mz(tt) - z0)*. Assume that T€.A'{Mz(Q)), then for z0ett,
Mz(n)*T*kZ0 = T*Mz(nykZ0 = ztr*kzo. Since nul(Mz(Q)
— ZQ>)* = 1, there is a complex number t(zo) such that T*kZ0
=t(z^)kZ0.
Thus ( r / ) ( z ) = < Tf,kz
> = < /,T*/e z > = t(z)f(z),
Because t(z) = (Te)(z)eR(Sl),T
f£R(Q),
ZGQ.
= Mt(il). This proved that
A'(MZ(Q)) = A =
Aa(Mz(Q)).
Proposition 4.5.2 Let Vi be a bounded simply connected Cauchy domain, then the set of polynomials is dense in R(£l). Proof Given a positive number e and an f&R(Q), let r(z) be a rational function with poles outside fl such that ||/ —7i|iy22(fi) < £• For this r, there
98
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
is a bounded Cauchy domain fii such that QiDfiiDfiiDfi and the poles of r(z) are outside fii. By Mergelyan theorem, there exist polynomials pn such that pn converge to p uniformly on fii. If follows from Cauchy formula that p'n—>r' and p'^—>r" uniformly on fi. In conclusion, pn^>r in W22(Q,) and there is an integer N such that ||pjv — ^||iy22(n) < £ - Therefore, WPN - f\\w™(si) < 2e. Because of the special definition of the inner product in Sobolov space for general fi, it is very difficult to discuss the properties of the space R(fl) and the multiplication operators further. But if we choose a better fl, many results can be obtained. When fi = D, the unit disc, we call R(D) Sobolev disk algebra. For simplicity of symbols, in what follows we will denote Mf(D), the multiplication operator with symbol f&R(D), by Mf. Proposition 4.5.3 (i) Hilbert space R(D) has an ONB {e n }^L 0 , where e
n
=
Hnz
i Pn
[(3n<'-7r i +2n+l)7r] 2 > n
=
°> *> 2 > ' ' ' !
(ii) R(D) is a functional Hilbert space, the reproducing kernel of which oo
is given by k(u,v) = J2 / ^ u " ^ n - For zoSfi, n=0
K = f>^)*n; (Hi) If f(z) = Yl fnzn
is analytic in D, then fsR(D)
if and only if
n=0
E-"=o l/n3
2 Hn
If fGR(D),
then Sn = J2 fkzk
< +oo.
converge to f uniformly in D;
fc=o
(iv) Mz is an essentially normal unilateral weighted shift, Mzen ,n = 0,1,2, ••• , and \\MZ\\ = (v) Assume that f(z) 52fnzneR{D), then
Qn^n+l)
®n —
/o Mf =
0
/iff f° h%f\% /3
/33
j2
03
/98. 15'
eo ei
/o Jl
03
e j0
2.
e3
=
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
99
Proof (i) Computation shows that zn = (s + it)n,n = 0,1,2,-•• ,is n2+2i an orthogonal system and ||z n || 2 = (,a»*-n*+2n+i)* ^B y p r o p o s i t i o n 4 5 2 , n+1
{e„}£°=0 forms an ONB of R(D). (ii) For z0£D,\f{z0)\<\\f\\cl5<M\\f\\w*2{D) for each f&R{D). R(D) is a functional Hilbert space with reproducing kernel 00
00
n=0
n=0
Then
k(u,v) == £e n («)i>) = £/£« n l/ n . l n
Since < f,J2(3W z >= f(z0) for feR(D), kZa = E ( ^ o n ) ^ n . (iii) Assume that f(z) is a function analytic in D with the Taylor expansion / = ^2fnzn, then / = £) J£en£R(D) if and only if X) laH 2 < +°°then «„(«) = £ fkzk
If feR(D),
= f ) £ e f c converge to / in W 22 (£>).
fe=0 fc=0
By Sobolev imbedding theorem, sn(z) converges to f(z) uniformly on D. (iv) Since Mzen = zf3nzn — — — e n + 1 = a n e n + 1 , n = 0,1,2, • • • , Pn+l
MZ*M2 - M 2 M ; = diag(al, a\ - a2,, a2, - a?, • • • ) . Since a2n+1 - a 2 - ^ 0 , M.GC1. (v) For / = £ / „ * " = Zfcen&R(D), ^ Ji/f
^
V^
t
Pn
^
I fm-nTS2-
< Mfen,em
>=< yfk-3 e n + f c ,e m > = < _ ~ Pn+fc [0 Thus M / can be represented as a matrix in (v). Proposition 4.5.4 Let f be analytic in D, then f£R(D)
m>n
^ m
f'eH2,f"eL2(D). Proof If f€R{D) and f(z) = *£fnzn. By Proposition 4.5.3, E 1 ^ < +00. Thus ]>> 2 |/„| 2 < +00 and f'&H2. From the definition of R(D),f"€L2(D). Conversely, if f'eH2,f"eL2(D). A theorem in [Duren, P.L. (1970)](Theorem 3.11) asserts that function / is analytic in D, continuous to C = dD and absolutely continuous on C if and only if f'£Hx. Thus f£C(D) and feR(D). For f&R(D), denote fr := f(rz),z£~D,0
< r
100
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Proposition 4.5.5 (i) fr converge to f in R(D) as i—>1; (ii) fr(Mz)—>Mfasr->l. Proof (i) Since f(z) is uniformly continuous in D, f(rz)—>f(z) formly in D. Thus / \f(rz)-f(z)\2dm-,0
uni-
(r—,1).
JD
Given a positive e, since / ' and f"€L2(D), we can choose ro such that 0 < r 0 < 1 and / \f'(z)\2dm < e and / \f"(z)\2dm < s. D\(2r0-1)D
D\(2r0-1)D
Thus fD\rf'(rz)-f(z)\2dm =
IDVOD
<
WDVOD
k / ' ( « ) - f'(*)\2dm \rf'{rz)\2dm
+ froD \rf'(rz)
-
+ j D V < j D \f'(z)\2dm}
f(z)\2dm
+ JroD \rf'(rz)
f(z)\2dm.
-
Similarly, JD\r2f"(rz)-f"(z)\2dm <
WDVOD
\r2!"{rz)\Hm
+ fD^D
\f"(z)\2dm]
+ JroD \r2f"(rz)
-
f"(z)\2dm.
Since rf'(rz) and r2f"(rz) uniformly converge to f'(z) and f"(z) respectively in any closed subset of D, we can find a r% such that when r > r j , 1. If |2|
- f'(z)\2dm
< 4e + ns2
JD
and
I
' \r2f"(rz)
- f"(z)\2dm
ID
Therefore, fr—>/
(r—>1) in R(D).
< 4e + ne2.
Unitary Invariant
(ii) Given
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
101
g£R(D),
fr(Mz)g=^
f(rm-Mzrlg{z)d£
f
= ^l I /(rOte-*)- 1 ^)^ ICI=J
= f{rz)g{z), Assume that f(z) = ^2fnzn,
zED.
then fr(z) — Y^fnfnzn.
Since
By Proposition 4.5.3, fr&R(D). Thus fr(Mz) = Mfr. Since A'(MZ) strictly cyclic, fr—>f in -R(D) is equivalent to Mfr = fr(Mz)—>Mf. T h e o r e m 4.5.6 Assume that f£R(D), then (i) a(Mf) = f(D); (ii) ae(Mf) = aire(Mf) = f(C). If z0eD and f{z0)
- f(z0))*
is
then
= -»,
where n is the number of zeros of f(z) — f(zo) in D, including multiplicity. Proof (i) Let ZQ^LD, then the value of the functions in the range of Mf — f(zo) is zero at z0 and Mf — f(zo) is not onto. This implies that a(Mf)Df(D). On the other hand, if u>o^f(D), it is easy to see that [f{z)-w0)-^R{D) and [Mf - t«o]M (/ _ 10o) -i = M ( / _ W o ) - i [ M / - w0] = I. Thus a{Mf) = f(D). (ii) By Proposition 4.5.1, ae(Mz) = cr ire (M z ) = C. By [Conway, J.B., Herrero, D.A. and Morrel, B.B. (1989)], ae(Mfr)
= ulre(MfT)
If z 0 e C , f(rz0)eaire(Mfr).
= o-e(fr(Mz))
= fr(C) = {/(*) : |«| = r } .
Since
Mfr-f(rzo)—+Mf-f(z0) f(z0)&aire(Mf)
and
as r —» 1, f(C)Caire{Mf).
102
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
Conversely, if there is a z0GD such that / ( z o ) ^ / ( C ) , then f(z) — f(z0) has only finitely many zeros in D, denoted by {zo,zi,--- , z n }c.D. From the proof of Proposition 4.5.1(i), we know that f(z) - f(z0) = {z- z0)k°(z -
k
Zl)
> • • • (z - zn)k»g(z),
geR(D)
and g(z) ^ 0 for z&D. By Proposition 4.5.1, Mf - f(z0) = (M,_ Zo ) fco • • • ( M 2 _ , J f c " M s n
is a Fredholm operator and ind(Mf — f(z0))
= - ^ ^
= — n. It is easily
i=0
seen that nul(Mf — f(zo)) = 0 and therefore nul(Mf — f(zo))* = n. Proposition 4.5.7 Let feR(D), then (i) IJZQ&D andf(zo) & f{C), thenMj£Bn(Q,), where Q. is a component of pa-p(Mf) containing /(zo) andn is the zeros of f(z) — /(zo) in D; (ii) Mf is an essentially normal operator. Proof (i) It needs only to prove
\J{ker[{Mf - f{zQ)Y]k : k>l} = R(D). In fact, if yeR(D)e\J{ker[(Mf
- /(z 0 ))*] fc : fc>l},
then for each A;, ye[ker[(Mf - / ( z 0 ) ) 1 Y
= ran{Mf - /(z 0 )) f e .
Thus we can find a function h€R(D) such that y=[Mf~
f(z0)]kh
= (z - z0)kok
• • • (z -
zn)k"kgkh.
Note that ZQ is the zero of y of order kko. Since k>l can be any natural number, ZQ is an essentially singular point of y. It is a contradiction. (ii) By Proposition 4.5.3, there is a sequence of polynomials pn converging to / in R(D). Since A'(MZ) = {Mg : g£R(D)} is a strictly cyclic algebra, MPn—>Mf (n—KX>). By Proposition 4.5.3, Mz is essentially normal, and n(Mz) is normal in the Calkin algebra £(R(D))/K{R{D)), where TT is the canonical mapping from
103
Unitary Invariant and Similarity Invariant of Operators
C(R(D)) to C(R{D))/K(R(D)). so is
Therefore 7r(pn) are normal elements and
TT(M/) = lim 7r(M p J, n—>oo
i.e., Mf is an essentially normal operator in C(R(D)). Example 4.5.8 f(z) = z3 + z2, g(z) = ^ £ - £ j £ , M < 1, |/?| < 1. an(
/ ( C ) separates f(D) into three components: fii,^' and i e 0 3 - M;GBi(ni)nB 2 (Q 2 )nS 3 (n3).
^ ^ 3 , l e Q i , —16^2
M;eB2(D).
In the following, we will discuss the commutant of the multiplication operators. Lemma 4.5.9 Let feR(D),
z0eDx := / _ 1 ( f i ) <""*
M}eBn{fl),
/(2) - / ( z 0 ) = (z - zo)'11 (2 -
h
Zl)
h
> •••(z-
Zl)
1+1
where {zi}i=1
are pairwise distinct, ^2 hi = n,gZo(z)
^gZ0{z), — ^ 0,z£D. Then
i=i
there exist n linearly independent vectors is — ru 1.1 . . , uhi-i i. n-za • — \H-zo,^Zot
iKz0
i^u
kh2~l . . . I'WSI
i
hht+1~i\ i^zi
}
such that
kerM}_f{zo) = \jKZo. Proof
Choose kl0,k%0,--- , k ^ _ 1 £R(D) such that M* 1.1 _ u A/f* 1.2 _ JL1 z - z 0 K z o — "201 J W 0 - z o K 2 o — K2o>
Jw
Then for every usR(D)
11/* juhi-l_i.hi-2 ' Mz-z0Kz0 — Kz0
and 0<j
< u, M}_f(zo)kl0 > = < ( / - /(*«,)«, *£, > = < (z - z0)hi-j{z
- Zl)h*
•••(z-
zi)h^gz0u,kZo
>
= 0. Thus k{oekerM*_f(zoy
Similarly, choose k\.,--- ,kz*+1~2eR(D)
M*z_Ziki = ki;\o< Then
keekerM}_f{zo).
i
such that
Structure of Hilbert Space
104
Operators
If there is a sequence of complexes {c^ : 0
— 1} satisfying „ , we get
- 1). Thus kZQ is linearly
= \/^o-
= / _ 1 ( n ) . For z 0 e D i ,
Given feR(D),M*feBn(n),D1
/ ( 2 ) - /(^o) = (z - 2o)(^ - zi) • • • (z - z„_i)5 Z0 (z), # Zo (z) ^ 0 for ze£>. (4.5.1) Let iV~z0 = {zi}2=Q, the numbers in Nzo can repeat. Denote T = Li{NZo :
ZQ£DI,
there is at least one Zi(0
/ ' ( * ) = 0}. Lemma 4.5.10 T is an at most countable subset of D\ and ZQGDI\T and only if the numbers in DZo are pair-wise distinct. Proof If zkGNZo with f(zk) = 0 for some k, 0
= (z - Zi) • • • (z - zn-i)gZ0(z)
if
+ •••
+ (z - z0) • • • (z - Zfc_i)(z - zk+1) • • • (z - zn-i)gZa(z)
-\
+ (z-z0)---(z-zn_i)^0(z). Let z = Zfc, we have (zfc -
Z0) • • • (Zfc -
Zfc_l)(Zfc -
Zfc+l) • • • (Zfc -
Zn_l)g20(Zfc) =
0.
Thus there exists at least an i ^ k with z; = z&. The converse is obvious.
Lemma 4.5.11 Let f€R(D), Mj?eZJ„(fi), then there exist an open subset Acf~1(Q)
and analytic functions ai{z),a2(z),---
,an(z)
and Zi(z),Z2(z),..-,Zn_i(z)
Unitary Invariant
on A such that for each
and Similarity
Invariant
105
of Operators
A&A'(Mf),
(Ag)(z) = a1{z)g(z)+a2(z)g(Z1{z))
+- •
•+an(z)g(Zn-1(z)),z€A,g£R(D).
Proof Denote Dx = / _ 1 ( 0 ) . If the set {z&D^ : f'(z) = 0} is finite, then T is finite. Let A = Di\T. If the set {zeD\ : f'(z) — 0} is a countably many set. Choose an open subset D2CD1, then D2C\T is finite. Let A = D2\T. For zGA, by Lemma 4.5.9 and Lemma 4.5.10, kerMf_f(zj
= y\kz,
kZl, • • •
and the numbers in Nz are pairwise distinct. Since
,kZnlj A&A'(Mf),
A*kz&kerM*f_f(z). Thus there exist n complex numbers cei(z), 02(2), •• • , an(z) such that A*kz = ai{z)kz
+ a2(z)kZl +
\- ^ ( z ) ^ . ; .
Therefore, (Ag)(z) =
>
=
>
= ai(z)g(z)
+ a2(z)g(zi)
+ ••• + an(z)g(zn_i).
(4.5.2)
For Nz = {z, z\, • • • , zn-i}, we choose ui, u2, • • • , un-\&D\ such that (i) the n open balls B(z,e), • • • ,B(zk,£)(l
{uk}nkzln[B(z,e)U(\jB(zk,e))}=
Set fk(Z, Zi, • • • Zn-x) = (uk-Z)(uk-Zi)...
(uk-Zn-.i)gz(uk)-f(uk)+f(Z),
where (k = 1,2, • • • , n — 1) and ZeA.. Computations show that l A l = Me*[|^|(z,2 1 ,...,z n _ 1 )=(*,«i > -,*»-,)]! = I[I1 («i - «i)][Il (* - ^)][ n ff(«i - z)][U gz(ui)]\ ± 0 iytj
ijij
t=l
1=1
106
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
By the implicit holomorphic function theorem [Griffiths, P. (1985)] (Theorem 9.6), there exists a 6 > 0 and analytic functions Zk = Zk(v), (k = 1,2, • • • , n — 1) in B(z, S) such that for v£B(z, S), f(uk)-f(v)
= {uk-v){uk-Z±{v))
• • • {uk-Zn-i{v))gv(uk),
k = l,2,---
,n-l.
Thus for vGB(z,S), V,ZI(V),- •• , Z n _i(v) satisfying (4.5.1) and the analytic functions Z\(v), ••• , Zn-\{v) can be extended analytically to A satisfying f(u) ~ f(z) = (u- z)(u - Zi{z)) • • • (u -
Zn_1(z))gz(u).
From (4.5.2), we get (Ag)(z) = a1(z)g(z)+a2(z)g(Z1(z))+---+an(z)g(Zn-i(z)), Set g = e,z,z2,-
V
g£R(D),z€A. (4.5.3)
• • ,zn~1 respectively and denote h\ = Ae, h2 = Az, • • • , hn = Az7 1 - 1
then cti(z) + zoti(z) +
a2(z) -\ Zi(z)a2(z)
+
H
an(z) = hi(z)
+ Zn-i(z)an(z)
= h2(z) zeA
{ zn-lai{z)
+ Z^-1(z)a2(z)
+ • • • + ZZll(z)an(z)
= hn(z)
Since the coefficient determinant J(z) is a Vandermonde determinant,
J(z) =
1 z Zn-X
1 Zn-\
1 Z\ Zn-l
.. .
^0.
Zr
By Cramer's rule, a\(z), • • • , an(z) are analytic in A. Since Ag is analytic, (4.5.3) determines the vector Ag and describes AeA'(Mf). Corollary 4.5.12 J / M ; e B i ( f i ) , then A'(Mf)
= {Mg : gGR(D)}.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
107
Let n>2 and w be the n-th root of 1, i.e., weC, wn = 1. Let A n denote the Vandermonde determinant of order n: 1 1
1
1 w
1 wn-1
w
n-l
w(n-1]
•••
For l
if and only if for each
n i=l n
where cn(z) = £ ^ ( 2 Proof
A»J'57^T)
and {hj}nz=1
are n functions in R(D).
For f{z) = zn,M*neBn(D), A = {zeD : z + 0}. If 1 z, z0eA, zn -Z% = (Z- Z0)(Z - wz0) •••(z-wn zQ),
then Zi{z0) = wl
L
z0
Let AeA'{Mzn), denote hk = Azk~1
(fc = l , 2 , - - - ,n).
Using Theorem 4.5.11, computations indicate that
Anz
2
^=1
A
L n
On the other hand, for arbitrary hi, hi, • • • , hn€.R(D),
^ 3=1
set
••'2J-
108
Structure
of Hilbert
Space
Operators
For gGR(D), formally, set n
i=l
{Claim} A is bounded. For each integer m, let m=m(modn)
and 0 < m < n — 1. Assume that
oo
g{z) = J2
9mZm
'
m=0
then (Ag)(z)=Zai(z)g(wi^z) n
n
n
oo
. .
oo
1 £ iEKE = l j=\ A„M^)( mE = 0 s^^'- ^*")] n
s r E [ E ffn(E Afc-u/"*-1 V n _ J ' + 1 ) ] i=l m=0 oo
j= l n
n
= £ E 4E(E A ^ ^ - D ^ " - ^ ) ] m=0 co
i=l j = l n n
E 5m[E(E A y ^ C - ^ ^ z " - ^ 1 ) ] .
= £
TTI=O
i=i
*=i
It is easy to see that
gAy^^^l i=i
An 0
m=j - 1 m ^ ' - l .
Therefore, (Aff)(z) = E (Qknz^hiz)
+ gkn+1zknh2(z)
k=0 n
oo
= E(E i = 0 fc=0
Qkn+i-lZ^hi).
+ ••• +
gkn+n^zknhn)
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
109
For each i, l
£
gkn+i-iz
hi\\a
k=0 < M\\hi\\2\\
£ fc=0 00
9kn+i-lZ fcn||2
a
fc=0
= Af ||M 2 E |f^±^i| 2 |%±i=i|2 fc=0
Thus ||j4<7||2
(2) ai(z) = ^
+ 1 + E «2fc+i22fc+1 andai(z)ai(-z)
=
a2(z)a2(-z);
= £ bnzn, h2(z) = £ cnzn,
then one of
fc=0
(Hi) If hi,h2&R(D),hi(z)
00
00
n=0
n=0
the following two must be true: (1) zhi(z) = h2(z) and P = I or 0; (2) b0 + ci = \,b2k = -c2k+i (k>l) and hi(z)h2(-z) = hi(-z)h2(z).
110
Structure of Hilbert Space
Proof (i)=>(ii). -z (z ± 0). Since P 2 = P , a\(z)g{z)
Operators
If 0:1(2;) and 0:2(2) correspond to P , then ^1(2:) =
+ ai(z)a2(z)g(~z)
= <xi(z)g(z) + a2(z)g(-z)
+ a2{z)a1(~z)g(-z)
+
a2(z)a2(-z)g(z)
(z ^ 0)
for each g£R(D). When g = e, a\{z) + ax(z)a2{z)
+ a2(z)cti(-z)
+ a2(z)a2(-z)
= ax(z) + a2(z).
- a2(z)ai(-z)
+ a2(z)a2(-z)
= 0:1(2:) -
When g = z, a\(z) - ax(z)a2(z)
a2(z).
Simple computations show that a21(z) + a2(z)a2(-z)
= a1(z)
(4.5.4)
[ai(z) + ai(-z)]a2(z)
= a2(z)
(4.5.5)
Since a i and a2 are analytic functions, a2(z)=0 or 0:1(2:) + a\{—z)=l. If a2(z)=0, then ai(z)=l or 0 and P = I or P = 0. If ai(z) + a i ( - 2 ) = l , if follows from Proposition 4.5.13 that 0:1(2:) is analytic in -D\{0} with a pole of order 1 at z = 0. Therefore, 0:1(2:) can be expressed as 0:1(2:) = ^
+ \ + E a2k+1z2k+K
By (4.5.4),
fc=0
a2(z)a2(-z)
= ai(z)[l - 0:1(2:)] OO
fc=0
= ai(z)«i(-z).
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
111
(ii)=Ki). {P2g){z) = a\(z)g{z)
+ a2{z)a2{-z)g{z)
= a\{z)g(z) + a1(z)a1(-z)g(z) = cti(z)g(z)[ai(z) = ai(z)g(z)
+ a2{z)g(-z)[a1(z) +
+
ax{-z)}
a2(z)g(-z)
+ <*i(-2)] + (*2{z)g{-z)
+ a2(z)g(~z)
= (Pg)(z),
g€R(D).
Similar computation shows that (ii)<£=>(iii). Example 4.5.15
Operator P is defined by
{Pg)(z) = (-+
sinz)g{z) -{-
+ sinz)g(-z),
z ^
0,geR(D).
and P2 = P.
Then PeA'{Mz2)
In the following we will discuss the commutants of the multiplication operators on R(D) with the symbol of the form f(z) — znh(z). Proposition 4.5.16 Let f£R(D),f'(0) ^ 0,T£A'(Mf), then T = Mv for some (psR(D) if and only if T admits a lower triangular matrix representation with respect to the ONB {en}^LoP r o o f If T&A'(Mf) admits a lower triangular matrix representation T = (tijhj^ij
=0(j
>i).
Let f{z) = J2 Uzn with fx ^ 0. Compare the (2.1) entries of T M / =
MfT,
n=0
ft
A> _ f + ^° Pi Pi
Since f\ ^ 0, t n = t22. Compare the (3.2) entries, we get t22 = £3. In general, tu = t22 = • • • = CQ. Compare the (3.1) entries, we get / / P° -r J. JiHz— f t @° —- ]2tt\x— * ^° +_L f Jit +2i—. &1 i\Hi-zPi Pi Pi P2 Since £33 = *n, £32 §7 =t21@±. Thus t32 = cx@±, where cx = jf^*2i- Suppose that £(+1,; = ci^f^
(l
Pfc-2 . t . Pk-2 j. . Pk~2 . t . Pk-1 t . Jl£fc+l,fc"3 r /2tfc+l,fe+l—;5— = 72lfc-l,fc-l—5 1" Jltk,k-1—5—• Pfe-l Pk Pk Pk
112
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
It follows from tk+i,k+i = *fc-i,fc-i that tk+l,k-Z
0k-2 Pk-X
.
Pk-X
Pk-2 Pk-X
- t f c , k - l — 5 — = C\Pk Pk-X
— Pk
and tk+i,k = c i ^ r 1 - By the mathematical deduction, tk+i,k = c i ^ i p 1 f° r all k>l. Similarly, by the same arguments we can prove that if tk x = Ck-x S2—, '
t h e n tk+i,i+i
= Cfc_i-
r, i = 0,l,2,
0
Co Cl^
Since ? = Te0eR(D),
Pk — 1
Therefore,
Co
by Proposition 4.5.3, y> = ]T c„z™ and T = Mv. n=0
Conversely, if T = Mv, by Proposition 4.5.3, T admits a lower triangular matrix representation with respect to the ONB {e n }^L 0 . Lemma 4.5.17[Deddens, J.A. and Wong, T.K. (1973), Lemma 2] Let N be a nil-potent on H, X0 = A + JV,0 ^ AeC. If B,A0,Ai,-••££(?{) satisfying ||,4 fc ||<M and AkX0 = X0Ak-i + B (k = 1,2, • • •), then A0 = Ai = A2 = • • • . L e m m a 4.5.18 Let T£A'(Mz~)nA'{Mf), f&R(D), f = zrg, l
G21 G22
0 and
M,T
=
0 Wx 0
0
0 W20
with respect to the ONB {efc}j?L0, where Gij,Wk are rxr matrices. Wk is invertible and since g(0) 7^ 0, Gu is also invertible (i,j, k = 1, 2, • • •). Since TMZ- = MZ~T,
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
'Tn
of Operators
113
0
T21 T22
with respect to the ONB {ek}kX3=o, where Tij is nxn matrix (i, j = 1,2, • • •). {Case 1 } If r is a divisor of n, n = pr, r > 1 and s = r. Suppose that
nv
'Vft Vi12fc ^ J j 2 - *£
Tkk
Vk Vk • • • Vk L- pi p2 PP
where Vk- is a r x r matrix (k,i,j = 1,2,- • •). Denote m = (k — l)p,k = 1,2, • • • . It follows from TMzrg = MzrgT that TkkFkk = FkkTkk and Fkk equals to 0 0
Wm+l^m+l.m+l Wm+2Gm+2,m+l
0
W/m+2Gm+2,m+2
. *^m+p— l ^ m + p — l , m + l **m+p— l^m+p—
l,m+2 ' * ' "m-l-p—l^m-f-p—l,m-f-p—1 " m
Compare the (1, p — 1) entries of TkkFkk = FkkTkk, we get * / l p ^ m + r - l G m - ) - p _ i i m - ( - p _ l = 0.
Since Wm+r-i and G m + P _ i ) m + P _ i are invertible, V^ = 0. Similarly, Vjj — Oif j > i,k = 1,2, ••• . Thus, Tfcfc admits a block lower triangular matrix representation and Vu
T=
0 ^22
where Vkk is a r x r matrix. By the arguments used in the proof of Proposition 4.5.18, T&A'{MZT). {Case 2 } If r is not a divisor of n. Find positive integers p and q such that qr — pn = s. Since TMzqrgq = MzqrgqT,TM2.+»tJ1 = Mzs+ni,gqT. Because TM zP » = M z P -T,
114
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
TMzsgq = MzsgqT. Note that s is a divisor of n and g9(0) ^ 0. Repeating the proof of Case 1, we get T£A'(Mzs) and complete the proof. Using Lemma 4.5.17 and Lemma 4.5.18, we get the following proposition. Proposition 4.5.19 Let f(z) = znh{z)&R(D),h(z) ^ 0 for z&D and n > l . Then A'(Mf) = A'{Mzn)C\A'{Mh) = A'(MZ*), where s = (n,ni,ri2,Proof
••),/i(.z) = ao + a\znx + a,2Zn2 -\
Assume that f(z) = hnzn + hn+izn+1
H
.Set 0
Pnk — n
fink-
Bk
.
n+1
Pnk-
and hnk hnk+1
Hk
- -
ftnfc-1 hnk
.hnk+n-l
'
fonfc-(n-l)
•• • /lnfc-(n-2)
hnk+n-2
••"
/ijifc
where hi = 0 if i < n. Then 0
Mf =
i=2i
0 0
-?31 -F32 0
where Fk+iik = B^HiB^ Since h(z) ^ 0 for z£D, n/c—1
ker(M})k = \ / {e,}i=l
Suppose that TeA'(Mf).
It follows from T*M}
nk—1
T*( V {ei})cker(Mf)k i=0
=
M*fT* that
nfc—1
-
V {ei} i=0
an
^ hence T* admits a block upper
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
115
triangular matrix representation with respect to the ONB { e j } ^ 0 , i.e. Tn
0
T21 T22
Compare the (2, 1) entries of TMf = MfT, we get F2xTu = T22F2i. It follows from F2\ = B^H^x
and B^lHiBxTx
HiBiTuBi
= TnB^ExBx
= B2T22B2
that
Hi.
Compare the (i,i — 1) entries, we get
i.e.,
TuBi
HiBi-i
= Bi
H\Bi-.\Ti-\,i-\.
Thus HiBi^iTi-iti^iBi_1
= BiTuB~
Bi-iTi-i^-iBi^
= BiTaB~
Hi.
By Lemma 4.5.17, ,
i.e.
Bi
Bi-\Ti-iti-i
= TaBt
-Bj_i.
Thus Ti+1,i+iWi where Wj = B^Bi. that
= WiTH,
Similarly, by mathematical deduction we can prove
Bk+i-iTk+i+i,i+iBi+1
= Bk+iTk+iiiBi
,
i.e.,
Tk+i+iti+iWi
= Wk+iTk+i,i,k
= 0,1,2,-••
This implies that TMZ-=M^T.
,t = 1,2,3, ••
116
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Since TMz~Mh =
Mz~MhT,
MznTMh =
Mz„MhT.
This means that zn(TMhg)(z)
=
zn(MhTg)(z)
for g£R{D) and z&D. Thus TMh = MhT and T&A'(Mzn)nA'{Mh). Conversely, A'(Mzn)nA'(Mh)cA'(Mf)
is obvious. Thus,
A'(Mf)=A'(Mzn)nA'(Mh). II TeA'(Mf)
= A'(Mzn)nA'(Mh). h(z) = a0 + alZni
Suppose that + a2zn2 + ••• ,
where at ^ 0(z = 0,1, 2, • • •). Then h-h(0) = znklhlt where nj = for ki,riGN and n < n and /ix = z r i g i . Since TeA'(Mh),
Since
TMznklMhl
=Mx^lMhlT.
MznklTMhl
=MznklMhlT,
T&A'(Mzn),
i.e.,
for geR(D).
Thus TM fcl =
MhlT.
By Lemma 4.5.18, T e , 4 ' ( M z n ) , where si = (n,ri) = (n,ni). Similarly, if n 2 = n/e2 + r2 for /c2, r 2 e N and r 2 < n, then a 2 z " 2 + a £ 3 + --- = z nfc2 /i 2 ,
nki+ri
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
117
where /12 = ^Qi- By the same argument Te^4'(M z » 2 ) for si = (n, ni,ri2). In general, T€LA'{MZ,), where s = (n,ni,ri2, • • •). Conversely, if r e ^ ' ( M z . ) , then it is obvious that TeA'(Mf). Thus ^ ' ( M / ) = >4'(M z n)a4'(M fc ) = A'(Mz.),a
= (n,n 1 ,n 2 , •• •)•
Corollary 4.5.20 Suppose t/iat feR(D),f(z) = znh(z),h{z) zG-D and for each k > 0, /i(z) is not a function of zk, then A'(Mf)
=£ 0 /or
= A'{MZ) = {M 9 : g&R(D)}.
In the following, we will discuss the strong irreducibility of multiplication operator M/ on R(D). Theorem 4.5.21 Given fGR(D), the following are equivalent. (i) M ; e B i ( n ) ; (ii) A'(Mf) = {Mg : g£R(D)}; (Hi) A'(Mf) is commutative; (iv) If M*f € S„(fii), then for each AeA'(Mf), (Az)(z) = zhxiz), {Az2){z) = z^z),
• • • , (Azn'l)(z)
=
z^h^z),
where hi = Ae\; (v) Mf£{SI). Proof (i)=Kii) Corollary 4.5.12. (ii)=^(iii). Obvious. (iii)=>(iv). If there an operator AeA'(Mf) such that (Azk)(z0) =£ Zohi(zo) for some k, 1 < k
= Z^ZQ)
£ (Azk)(z0)
=
(AMzke)(z0).
Thus MzkA ^ AMzk. But A and M 2 t are in A'(Mf). A contradiction. (iv)=^(v). For z€A, since ai(z) + a 2 (z) + • • • + an(z) = h\{z) and
118
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
hk+i = zkh\ for l
- z)an{z)
=0
+ (ZUz) - z*)a3(z) + ••• + {Z*_x{z) - z*)an(z)
=0
(Z?-\z) - z"-i)a2(z) + (Zr\z) zn~l)a3(z) l + ... + (ZZll(z)-z"- )an(z)=0 Computations indicate that the coefficient determinant is still a Vandermonde determinant:
V =
Zx-z Zl - z2 7TI — 1 _
z?~l -
(-1)
Z2-z Z22-z*
n —1
yn—l
1 Z\
1 Z2
Zn-\ — zLi - • ~n—1
••• 1 • •• Zn-\
yn-i
1 z
zl zl ... zu z*
n-1
yn—l l
Z
yn—l 1 "•
L
n-1
_
^0.
yn—l -n—1 n-1 Z
Z
an(z) = 0 and A'{Mf) = {Mg : Therefore a2(z) = a${z) = • • geR(D)}. Since A'(Mf) does not contain nontrivial idempotent, Mf€(SI). (v)=^(i). Suppose that the minimal index of MJ is n and n > 2 . By Theorem 4.5.11, Ag = ot\{z)g{z) H + an(z)g(Zn-i(z)) for A£A'(Mf), geR(D) and zeA. Since M*eA'{M*f),M*ku - uku and M*zkzx{u) = Zi(u)fc21(u) for uGA. By Theorem 4.4.3, the spectrum of M*\ker(M}-f(u))
is connected. Thus u = Z\{u). This contradicts z ^ ^1(2) when zeA. Therefore n = 1 and M;&Bi(fi). Proposition 4.5.22 Mz™e(S7) j / and on/?/ i / n = 1. Proof If n>2, define an operator P by
Pf = \\J{?) + / M + • • • + /K" 1 *)]
/e/W
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
By Proposition 4.5.13, PeA'(Mzn).
Invariant
119
For each i, l
= £[/(w
Pf(w'z)
of Operators
+ ••• +
fi^-^z)}
= £[/(*)+ /("*) + "- + /("n-1*)]Thus p2f
tt"n-lz))\
= £ [ " ( / ( * ) + / ( " * ) + ••• + = ![/(*) + / H
+ • • • + /(a;"" 1 *)] = P / .
It is obvious that P is nontrivial and
Mzn$.{SI).
P r o p o s i t i o n 4.5.23 Let feR(D) with f(z) = znh(zm), h(z) ± 0, zeD and n>\. If for each k > m, h(zm) is not a function of zk, then Mf£(SI) if and only if (n, m) = 1. Proof By proposition 4.5.19 A'(Mf) = A'(Mzs), where s = (m,n). By Proposition 4.5.22, A'{Mzs) contains no nontrivial idempotent if and only if s = 1. Thus Mfe(SI) if and only if s = 1. Proposition 4.5.23 requires n>l. One may asks the question: Is the conclusion of Proposition 4.5.23 true when n = 0? In fact the answer in general is negative unless / is an integral function. oo
E x a m p l e 4.5.24 Let f(z) = 2z - £ ^zn,
then
Mfg(SI).
n=l
Proof It is easy to see that f(z) is analytic in 2D = {zEC : \z\ < 2}. Thus f&R(D). Define an operator P as follows: (Pg)(z) = \g{z) + \g{2 + - A _ ) ,
g£R(D).
Then
Simple computations show that P2 = P and f(z) = / ( 2 + j r j ) . Thus PMfg(z)
= \f{z)g{z)
+ 1/(2 + ^)g(2
= lf(z)g(z)
+
= MfPg(z),
+ ^ )
y(z)g(2+^) for all
geR{D).
120
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
Set g(z) = 10 + f(z), then g satisfies the requirement of Proposition 4.5.23 with n = 0. But Mg£(SI). Proposition 4.5.25 A'{Mz2)/radA'{Mz2) is noncommutative. Proof By Theorem 4.5.21 A'(MZ2) is not commutative. Assume that R is a left ideal of A'(MZ2). Set £1 = {Ae : AeR},R2 = {Az : A&R}. {Claim(i)} Ri,R2 are ideals of R(D), and if hi£Ri,h2€R2, then hl{z) hl{ z)
/n(-*)efli,
~ ' eR1,h2(-z)eR2
and h2{z) -
h2(-z)
eR2.
Let A&R and hi = Ae. Denote h2 = Az£R2. For arbitrary denote B^A'(MZ2) determined by / i , / 2 - For g£R(D),
fi,f2&R(D),
(BA)g(z) =
r/i(z) h l ( 3 ! ) + h ' ( ^l+/ 2 ( z )'' l ( ^-^ ( - )
r
+
/ l ( z )
h2(«Hha(-.) +
h { z )
/.2(»)-h2(-»)
/ 1 ( 2 ) h t ( ^ + " ' ( ^ + / 2 ( Z ) , ' l ( j ) - ^ ( - ^ _ /1(Z)ha(j)+',8(-)+/2(Z)hi»(,>-^(-')1
+ I
22
2
Choose f2 = zfi, i.e., B + M/j, then (BA)g(z) = [ * < f ! ^
+
* ( ^
which means /i/ii€i?i and Ri is an ideal of R(D). Set A = e, / 2 = 0, i.e., (B)(z) = §[g(z) + g(-z)], (BA)»(z) = [M*)+M-») +
then
h2(z)+ ( z)
£ - ]g{z)
_|_ rfei(z) + >ti(-z) _ h2(z)+h2(-z)-i
/ ,N
which means /ii(z) + /ii(—z)Gi?j and /ii(—z)Gi?i. Set A - 0, / 2 = e, i.e., (5ff)(z) = £[(z) - g(-z)],
then
>»i(«)-hi(-»)
(BA)(z) = [
1 hl(«)-hl(-«)
+ [—^
^('l-^C-*)
+
£
]fl(*)
fc2(')-''2(-»)
&—]$(-*),
,
J^V
,
Z
>-
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
121
which means €-Ri- Similarly, we can prove that R2 has the same z properties. {Claim(ii)} For arbitrary z\, z2£D, z\ ^=Q,z2^ 0, Set Ri(zi) = (z2 - zf)R(D), R2(z2) = (z2 -
z2)R(D),
then Ri(zi) is a "maximal" ideal which has the properties: if /ii£i?i(zi) then hi(-z)eR1(z1) and hl(z)~^l(~z)eRi(zi). Similar properties hold for #2(22)- For each hxeR1(z1) and h2GR2(z2), ^ n d -^-A'C^z 2 ) with
(A9)(z) = (*£> + *£>),(*) + (*£> - ^ ) 5 ( - z ) , z ^ 0. Let R(z\, Z2) be the set of all such operator A. Simple computation shows that R(zi,Z2) is an ideal of A'(MZ2). If there is an ideal S of A'(MZ2) such that R(zi,Z2)CS, then Si :— {Ae : AGS}DRI(Z\) is an ideal and by (i) and the "maximality" of Ri(zi), Si = R\{z{). Similarly, S2 := {Az : AGS} = i?2(^2)- Hence S = i?(zi,Z2), i-e-, R{zi,z2) is a maximal ideal of A'(MZ2). {Claim(iii)} radA'(Mz2) = {0}. Let i2 = n{i2(zi, z2) : 21, Z2G£>, ZX ^ 0, z 2 ^ 0}, then .Ri = {Ae : AeR} = n{Ri(zi) = {heR{D)
: h(z) = h(~z) = 0,zeD}
R2 = {Az : AGR} = n{R2(z2) = {heR(D)
: zi&D,zx
^ 0} = {0},
: z2e£>,22 ^ 0}
: h(z) = h(-z) = 0,zeD}
= {0}.
Thus R = {0} and radA'(Mz2) = {0}. Since A'(MZ2) = {0} is noncommutative, A'(Mz2)/radA'(Mz2) is noncommutative. In the last part of this section we will consider in invariant subspace of Mz on R(D). Proposition 4.5.26 Let feR(D). (i) IfBa(z) = f^,a£D, then MfoBa~Mf; (ii) Mf~Mz if and only if f(z) = \fE=£, |A| = 1 and aeD.
122
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Proof (i) It is obvious that foBa€R(D). Define an operator Sa as follows: Saf = foBa, /G-R(D). Computation indicates that there are positive numbers Mi, M2,M$ and M 4 such that / \foBa\2dm<Mi
I \f\2dm,
JD
[ \(foBa)'\2dm<M2
JD
[
JD
\f'\2dm
JD
and f \(foBa)"\2dm<M3 JD
[ |/'| 2 dm + M 4 f JD
\f"\2dm.
JD
Thus | | / o 5 a | | < M | | / | | for some number M and all feR(D), bounded. Note that for each g£R(D), SaMfg
= Sa(fg) =
i.e., Sa is
f(Ba)g(Ba)
and MfoBaSag
= MfoBag(Ba)
=
f(Ba)g(Ba).
Thus SaMf = Mf0BaSa. Since Ba is an invertible analytic function, Sa is one to one and onto. Thus Sa is invertible and Mf0sa = SaMfS*1. (ii) If f(z) = \f5£, then Mf~Mz by (i). On the other hand, if Mf~Mz, by Theorem 3.5.6, f(D) = a(Mf) = a(Mz) = D. Thus f(D)cD. Since / is continuous on D, by maximal module theorem f(D)cD. For arbitrary XeD, since \&a(Mz)\ae(Mz) = f(D)\f(C), Xef(D) and Dcf(D). Therefore / maps D onto D. Note that for each AeD, nul(\ - M}) = nul{\ - Mz*) = 1, this implies that f(z) — A has only one zero. Thus / maps D one to one onto D. It must be a Mobius transformation up to a coefficient of module one. Lemma 4.5.27 Assume that / i , /2, • • • , fn are n functions in R(D) without common zeroes in D. Then there are functions gi,g2, • • • ,gn in R{D) n
such that ]T] fkgk = e. fc=i
Proof Denote J = {gifi + g2f2 + • • • + 9nfn • GR(D)}. It is obvious that J is an ideal of R(D). If J is a nontrivial ideal, it must be contained in a maximal ideal. But this is impossible, because
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
123
the maximal ideal space of R(D) is D and / i , /b, • • • , fn have no common n
zeroes in D. Thus eej
and ^ /£<% = e for some 51,52, • • • ,5nSi?(J5). fc=i
Theorem 4.5.28 (i) Subspace M with finite common zeroes {zi, ^2, • • • , zn} in D, multiplicity included, is an invariant subspace of Mz if and only if M =
(z-z1)---{z-zn)R{D);
(ii) If M is an invariant subspace in (i), then the projection onto M. is PM = Mx{M^Mx)-lM^,
where X=f[
f5^i=l
Proof (i) If M = (z — z\) • • • (z — z„)R(D), it is obvious M is an invariant subspace of Mz with common zeroes {xj}f=1 in D. Conversely, if MeLatMz with common zeroes {z,}" = 1 . Denote N := {geR(D)
: (z -
Zl)
• • • (z -
zn)g£M}.
Then it is not difficult to see that N is an invariant subspace of Mz. For each weD, since {zi}?=1cD, there is a function fw£N such that fw(w) ^ 0. Since fw is continuous in D, choose a neighborhood U(w,e) such that fw does not equal zero in U{w,e). Thus we can find a finite open cover U(wi,ei),--,U(wk,ek) of D and functions fWl,fW2,--,fwk in N such that fWi has no zero in U(iVi,Ei) (l
Y^fwigi
= e.
Note that since polynomials are dense in R(D), each invariant subspace of Mz in fact is an ideal. Thus eeN and N = R(D). Thus {z-z1)---{z-zn)R{D)dM. Since M c ( z - z i ) • • • (z-zn)R(D) is obvious, M = ( z - z i ) • • • (z-2„)i?(D). (ii) Since M* is a Fredholm and kerMx = {0},M*M x is invertible. It is obvious that Mx{MxMx)~lM* is a self-adjoint idempotent. Thus it is an orthogonal projection. By Proposition 4.5.7, M* is a Cowen-Douglas operator of index n, and ranM* = R(D). Thus ran\Mx{MlMx)-x
Mx] = ranMx = xR(D) = M,
124
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
i.e., PM is the projection onto M. It is well-known that in Hardy space H2 Mz similar to the restriction of it on any nontrivial invariant subspace M. The following result indicates that this statement is valid in Sobolev disk algebra if and only if M has only finitely many common zeroes in D. Proposition 4.5.29
Let M&LatMz, then
MZ~MZ\M
if and only if
M=(z-Zl)---(z-zn)R(D), where Proof
{zi}f=1cD. Assume that M = (z — z\) • • • (z — zn)R(D). P=
Denote
{z-zi)---(z-z„).
Define Tp : R(D)—>M by Tpf = pf,feR(D). maps R(D) one to one onto M. Since T;^Mz\MTpf
It is easy to see that Tp
= zf = Mzf,
MZ =
feR(D),
T~1MZ\MTP.
On the other hand, if there is an W : R(D)—>M such that MZ =
W-1MZ\MW,
then WMZ = MZ\MW. Denote h = We. Computations indicate that Wzn — znh. Thus Wp = ph = Mhp for each polynomial p. By Proposition 4.5.2, Wf = Mhf for all feR(D). This implies that W = M/, and Mh has a closed range. By Theorem 4.5.6, O0/i(C). Since Mh is essentially normal, h has finitely many zeroes in D. By Theorem 4.5.28, M = (z — z\) • • • (z — z„)R(D) for
Theorem 4.5.28 and Proposition 4.5.29 describe the structure of invariant subspaces of Mz with finitely many common zeroes in D. The following example is an invariant subspace of infinitely many common zeroes. oo
E x a m p l e 4.5.30 Then
feR{D).
Let f(z)
= ( J ] f$£)(z
- l ) 5 , where an = 1 - 4j-.
Unitary Invariant
Proof
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
125
By a result in [Gardner, B.J. (1989)], f(z) is continuous in D. oo
Let B(z)= n bak, where bak = f ^ . fc=i
{Claim}
B'(z) = £ (^^
ft
bak(z)).
Let G = {z£C : \z\ < r < 1}, choose r so that zeG. Assume that N
oo
an > r when n > N. B(z) = ( fj 6„J( f] 6 0 J. Thus fc=l fc=N+l JV
oo
B'(z) = (Ubak)'( fc=l
N
oo
I] &«*) + ( II *«J( n fc=JV+l
N
fe=l
&«J'
k=N+l
N
= ( I l * . J ' B ^ ) + (ni.JBj»W. fc=l
wher
oo
e BN(z)=
fc=l
ft
bak.
k=N+l
Note that 5jv(z) 7^ 0, z£G. Thus OO
In(Bjv(z))= ]T
M f ^ ) -
k=N+l
But ^ ( 2 )
5
iv(^)
£
K - 2 )( 1 ~ akz)
k£^+l
converges uniformly in G. Thus k=N+l
v
~
akZ
'
n^k,n>N+l
Note that
|S'(z)(z - 1)5| = I £
ia
fe=l
\:ll{k7f
V
n *«„(*)! n^fc
<16E(l-afc)ll^fll2 fe=i
< 64 £ (1 - at) < 00, fc=i 5
thus B'(z)(z — l ) is bounded on Z). It is easy to see that B(z)(z — l ) 4 is bounded on D. Therefore (B(z)(z — l ) 5 ) ' is bounded.
126
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Similarly, (B(z)(z - l ) 5 ) " is bounded on D, these imply f(z)&R(D). Denote M{an} := {g£R(D) : g(an) — 0,n = 1,2,•••}. It is obvious that M{an} is an invariant subspace of Mz with infinitely many common zeroes and f£M{an}. For a given set M, [M] denotes the minimal invariant subspace of Mz containing M. If M ^ {0} is an invariant subspace of Mz on Hardy space H2, Beurlig Theorem asserts that dim(MQzM) = 1 and [MQzM] — M. Comparing to this, the invariant subspaces of Mz on Bergman space L\ are more complicated. [Apostal, C , Bercobici, H., Foias, C. and Pearcy, C. (1985)] proved that if n is any positive integer or +oo, there is an invariant subspace M in L\ such that dim(MQzM)
— n.
For Sobolev disk algebra R(D), we have the following result. Proposition 4.5.31 Let M ^ {0} is an invariant subspace of Mz in R{D), then dim(MQzM) = 1. Proof [Richter, S. (1987)] studied a Banach space B of analytic functions, which satisfies the following conditions: (i) For each XQD, the point evaluation functional is continuous; (ii) If feB, then zfeB; (iii) If f£B and /(A) = 0, then f = (z - X)g for some g&B. S. Richter also proved that if the above Banach space B is an algebra and M is its closed ideal, then dim(MQzM) = 1. It is obvious that Sobolev disk algebra and each nonzero invariant subspace M of Mz satisfy these conditions. Thus dim(MezM) = 1.
4.6
The Operator Weighted Shift
Let {WAJ^LI
De a
sequence of uniformly bounded operator on C". An
oo
operator S in £( 0 C n ) is called a unilateral operator weighted shift with fc=o weighted sequence {Wk}™=1, denoted by 5'~{W/fc}^=1, if S(x0,xi,---
,xk,---)
= (O.WiZo,---
,Wk+1xk,---)
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
+00
for all (xk)eH+
+00
= © C". Similarly, an operator S on H = fc=0
is called
127
of Operators
©
Cn
k~—00
a bilateral operator weighted shift with weighted sequence
W}fcT-oo.
de
™ t e d b y S~{Wb}£T_oo. if
for all (xk)£H In general, unilateral and bilateral operator weighted shifts are both called operator weighted shift, denoted by S~{Wk}, and n is called the multiplicity of S. When n = 1, S is the scalar-valued weighted shift, from which the operator weighted shift is naturally generalized. We must point out here that it is not just a formal generalization. For example, using operator weighted shift, [Pearcy, C. and Petrovic, S. (1994)] proved that an n-normal operator is power bounded if and only if it is similar to a contraction operator. In this section, we will discuss injective operator weighted shift, that is, each Wk is invertible. Given an operator weighted shift S~{Wk}, since S and el9S are unitarily equivalent for each #£[0,27r] [Lambert, A (1971)], cr(S),ae(S) and oy(S) have circular symmetry. It is easily seen that r(S)=
Km k—>oo
n(S)=
(sup\\Wi+k...Wi+1\\)K i
l\m(mf\\Wi+k---Wi+1\\)l, k—>oo 1
where r(S) is the spectral radius of S and ri(S)=
lim
(m(Sk))i,
fc—>00
m(S) := inf{\\Sx\\
: ||z|| = 1}
is the lower bound of S. Since dirnker(S — \)
= {A : |A|
Structure
128
of Hilbert Space
Operators
triangular matrix representation with respect to this ONB. By the basic matrix theory, we have the following proposition. P r o p o s i t i o n 4.6.1 Every operator weighted shift S~{Wk} is unitarily equivalent to an upper triangular operator weighted shift S~{Wk}T h e o r e m 4.6.2 Let S~{Wk}'£L1 be a unilateral operator weighted shift, if cre(S) is disconnected then S^(SI). To prove this theorem we need the following lemmas. Lemma 4.6.3[Herrero, D.A. (1990)] an(AB)
Let A,BG£(H),
= <JI{TAB) = ai{A) -
L e m m a 4.6.4 Let A££(Hi),
then
ar{B).
B&£(H2) and
dirnHi = dimH-zIf oi(A)C\ar{B) = 0, then G := {YGranTAB '• ||V"||<1} is closed in weak operator topology (WOT). Proof Without loss of generality, we assume that H = Hi = Hi. Let {y a } a £ A be a net in G and Y = (WOT) — l i m i ^ . Then there exists a
Xa££(H) such that Ya = TAB{XO). there exists TGC(C(H)), such that
By Lemma 4.6.3, 0 ^ TTAB = I- Therefore,
O-I(JAB)-
Thus
||x a || = ||T(yQ)||<||T||||rQ||<||T|| for each a. Since each bounded closed set in £(H) is compact in weak operator topology [Conway, J.B. (1990)], we can find an operator XG£(H) such that X = WOT — limX a . Therefore, for arbitrary re, y£H, a
lim < (TABXO)X,
y > = lim < AXax, y > — lim < XaBx, = < AXx,
y > - < XBx,
Thus Y = WOT - lim TABXa = TABX.
y>
y >=< (TABX)X,
y > .
Clearly ||F||<1, therefore Y<=G.
L e m m a 4.6.5 Let ^4~{^4fc}j£Li and B~{Bk)V=i ^e unilateral operator weighted shifts with multiplicities n andm respectively. If ai(A)(lo-r(B) = 0
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
129
and if C is an operator of the form 0
0"
cj 0 C2 0
C
0
c3 0
cm cm cm Cm
,
c™ c n c n then CEranTA,BProof Let M = sup{||c fc ||}, k
0 ci 0 c2 0
0 00 0 0
Fk =
and Ek = cfc 0
Cfc 0
0 0
0 0
Then \\Fk\\<M,Fk
= £ Ej and C = WOT - limjFfc. By Lemma 4.6.4 we
need only to prove that each Ek&anTA,B- Set Xk-i Xk-2
= A^ Ck, = (AkAk-i)~1CkBk-i,
X0
(Ak- • •A2)~1ckBk-v (Ak---A1)-1ckBk-V--Bi.
• -B2,
Define X0
X
cr Xk-i
Cr' Cr'
r~in /~m /"m r~*n
A straightforward computation shows that AX — XB = Ek-
130
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Let Hk be the k-th subspace in the orthogonal direct sum H+ = 0
C".
k=0
Then for each unilateral operator weighted shift S~{Wk}kxLi, ^k can be regarded as an invertible operator from Hk-i to Hk- In what follows we will always identify x&Hk with (0, • • • ,0,x,0, • • • )GH+, the k-th of which is x. L e m m a 4.6.6 There exists an ONB {ef'}f = 1 of Hk {k = 0,1,2,---), such that the weighted Wk of S is of the form (fc)
Jfe-i)
wi Wk =
wkk)
(4.6.1)
Sk~i)
„(*) and di>di+i (i = 1, 2, • • • , n — 1), where di=]im(f[\WiU)\)i.
(4.6.2)
3=1
P r o o f For convenience denote Mk = WkWk-i- • -W\ and MQ = / . Choose an ONB {e^0), ef\ ••• , e{°}} of H0- Set dx =max{TInr||M f c ef ) ||* : \
Without loss of generality, we may assume t h a t d i = lim ||M f cM\ ef J ||s. Set k—>-oo
=(°) l|Mfce<°>|| Then (fc-i)
Wke\'
(0),
||M fc el'
„(*) . =
(0)|
\\Mk-A
,mjk)
= u)K 'e
(4.6.3)
and S i := {e[ f c ) }^ 0 is ONB of H+. Let P[k) be the projection from Hk onto the subspace [\j{e{k)}]x and Pj (0) = / . By (4.6.3), P^WkPf-V
= P[k)Wk
(4.6.4)
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
131
Suppose that we have found an orthogonal set Bj of H+,
Bj = {ef] : l<j0} and dj = '^^\\PJt\Mkef)\\i, fc—>oo
J
where P, W (l<j0) is the projection
J
J
from H+ onto (\/{e[k\ ••• , e
d\>d2>
• • • >df,
(h) PJk_\Wke?-V = WJk)ef\ (j = l,2,.--,i). (hi) Pf ]WkPf ~l) = P$k)Wk, 0 = 1,2,-.- ,i). Without loss of generality, we may assume that
(4.6.5) (4.6.6)
d- Hi+1- =l - ^ limll^Mfee^l ^ » ' W
( 0 )
fc—>oo k—*oo
Thus di>di+i. Set (k) _
M
^i
kei+i
f^efi + l l
-eftfc.
By (4.6.6), Fi
Mk&i
^
-
-
WP^M.-^w J "° M f c e ^ 1 1 . c(fc) ||if- 1 , M, k -ieS"'iir + 1
(fc)
(4-6-7)
(fc)
Besides, Si+i = {e^ : l < j < i + l , fc>0} is still an orthogonal set of H+. Let P i + { be the projection from Hk onto the subspace (V{ e i > • • • i ei+i})" 1 a n d i^+i = / . It follows from (4.6.6) and (4.6.7) that P^WkPfc1* = P$\Wk. Repeating the procedure above, we can find {rfi}?=1 and ONB {e[k)}?=1 oiHk such that d i > d 2 > • • • >dn and {e(k) : l0} is an ONB of H+. From the choices of e\ and w\ ', each wk has the form (4.6.1) and fc
~ n 5 " ( i n « W =TS"||i'i(*)iMtei0)||* =di(» = l ) 2,.-- ,n). fc—»oo
-*•-*•
fc—>oo
i=i
By Proposition 4.6.1, the following lemma can be easily proved.
132
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Lemma 4.6.7 Let S~{Wk}kLo
Operators
be an operator weighted shift, then
S\ S\2 • • •
Sin
s2 '••
Hi
!
n2
' *~*n — l , n
'•'rin
o whereH+ = W ^ ' . ^ ^ K ^ l f c l i is an injective unilateral weighted shift and S^ is a scalar-valued weighted shift (not necessarily injective). Without loss of generality, we may assume that Tii = I2. Lemma 4.6.8 Let S~{Wk} be an operator weighted shift of the form given n
in Lemma 4-6.7. Then cre(S) = \J ae(Si). Proof We only prove the lemma when n = 2, and let S =
Si S\2 0 S2
Let n be the canonical map from C{H+) onto C{H+)/K{Ji+).
Then
wi(Si)7ri(5i2) 0 7Ti(5 2 )
n(S)
where TTI : C{Hi)—+C{Hi)/)C{Hi). We need only to show that (T(TT(S)) = O-(-ITI(SI))UO-(ITI(S2)). By Gelfand-Naimark-Segal Theorem, we need only to prove that a(S)=a{S1)Ua(S2). If \€p(S),
then (S - A ) - 1 = (Aij)2x2 S\ — A 0
Sl2 S2-\
satisfying An AX2 A2i A22
Thus (S2 - A)^22 = I- Since dimker(S2 (S2 — X) has a left inverse and \£p(S2). Therefore
- A)<1, by Atkinson Theorem, Since (52 — X)A2i = 0,^21 = 0.
(Si-\)Au=Au(Si-\)=I. This implies that Aep(5i). Thus
\Gp(S1)np(S2).
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
133
of Operators
Conversely, if AGp(5i)np(5 2 ), set X
(51-A)-1-(51-A)-15(52-A)-1 0 (S 2 - A)- 1
Then X{S - A) = (5 - X)X
I. This implies XGp(S) and a(S)
=
Now we are in a position to prove Theorem 4.6.2. n
Proof of Theorem 4.6.2 By Lemma 4.6.8, ae{S) = \J ae(Si). Since ae(S) = an(S)c{\GC
: r!(S)<|A|
there exist e and S, 0<e < <5, such that fl := {A : e < |A| < 5} is a bounded component of PF{S). Therefore, for each Si, at least one of the following holds: (a)
n
Now denote Mi = © Hi and M2 = M^ = i=l
0
Hi. Then
i—io-\-l
s=
AC 0 B
M2'
where A and B are operator weighted shifts with multiplicities io and n — io respectively, and C is of the form given in Lemma 4.6.5. By Lemma 4.6.8, io
\J
By Lemma 4.6.8 and its proof ar(A) = a(B) =
\J
a(Si)cUe.
oe{A)nar(B)=$. By Lemma 4.6.5, there exists an operator X such that AX - XB = C.
Therefore
134
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Set Y =
IX' 0 /
Then YSY'1 and
=
A 0 0 B
Sg(SI).
Next we will discuss when the adjoint of a unilateral operator weighted shift is a Cowen-Douglas operator. Proposition 4.6.9 Let <S~{Wfc}j£Li be a unilateral operator weighted shift. IfO€ae(S), then S* can not be a Cowen-Douglas operator. Proof If ae(S) = a(S), then S* is not a Cowen-Douglas operator. Thus we may assume that ae(S) ^
=
A 0 Mi = D. 0 B M2
A* 0 M 1 . Since a(B*) = a{B)c{\ : \\\<e} 0 B* M (see the proof of Theorem 4.6.2), B* — X is invertible for all Asft. Thus
So D* = (Y*)~1S*Y*
A;er(Zr-A)oMi. This implies that \J{ker(S* - A) : Aeft} ^ H+. Theorem 4.6.10 Let S^{Wk}^=1 Then the following are equivalent: (i) M := sup ||Wfc-1|| < oo;
be a unilateral operator weighted shift.
(ii) n ( 5 ) > 0 ; (Hi) 0£pF{S); (iv) There exists a connected open set ft containing 0 such that S*eBn{n). Proof (i)=»(ii) and (ii)=^(iii) are obvious from the definitions.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
135
(iii)=4-(iv). It is easy to see that there exists a connected open set fi containing 0 and riCpF(S). Since ap(S) = 0,5* — A is surjective and dimker(S* - A) = ind(S* - A) = indS* = n for all Aeft. Note that \/{ker(S*)k : fc>l} = H+, thus S*eBn(Q). (iv)=>(i). Since 5* is surjective, it has a right inverse T = (Tk,i)%l=0eC{H+). Thus W^Tk>k-i = / and H ^ H = Wn^W^TW for each k. By Proposition 4.6.9 and Theorem 4.6.10, the following corollary is obtained. Corollary 4.6.11 Let S~{Wk}kLi be a unilateral operator weighted shift. Then B* is a Cowen-Douglas operator if and only if sup || VK^-1 j| < +oo. fc
In what follows we consider the backward operator weighted shift S~{Wk} with the form OWi
0
0 W2 0
C" Cn
'•.
on H = 0 C n , n=l
0 and denote Ao(S) =
A'(S)\kers-
Theorem 4.6.12 Let S~{Wk} be a backward operator weighted shift, then the following are equivalent: (i) There exists AoGAo(S) such that card(a(Ao)) = m, (m
multiplicity n-i and ^2 rii = n; i=l
(Hi) S has a spectral family. Proof (i)=>(ii). For convenience, we assume that m — 2. Since A0eAo(S), there is A£A'(S) such that A\kers = A0. Let Aa = diag(A0,Ai,- • • ,Ak,---) be the diagonal part of A and let p(z) be the characteristic polynomial of AQ. Since Ak — Ek~1AoEk,p(Aa) — 0, where Ek = Wv • Wk (fc>l). Thus p(a(Aa)) = {0}. This implies that a(Ao) = {Ai,A2}. Thus there are Jordan domains S7i and 0,2 such that Aiefii,A 2 en 2 and 0[r^h = 0- Denote T* = dtli (i = 1,2). Clearly,
136
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Ad&A'(S). Thus the Riesz idempotents Pi =
2^ /
(A
" Ad)~ldX£-A'{S)
(i = 1,2).
Note that (A - Ad)'1 Thus Pi = diag(P£\
Pk] = Ek1^
= diag((X - A0)-\-
• • , E^(X
- A0)-lEk,
•••).
• • • ,P{ki] ,• • •), where
I
(A - A0)-1d\)Ek
= E^P^Ek,
(i = 1,2)
and
P f ' p f =0, P^ + P™ =/c»,(* = 0,l,2,...). Denote Mk = P ^ C " , Nk = P?)Cn, Hi = PJi, (* = 1,2). Then OO
W = ®(Mk+Afk) = H1+H2, fc=0
and 5 = S1+S2, where 5i = S\Hl, 5 2 = S| W a . Since
= ni
dimAik = dimMk-i and
dimMk = dimAfk-i — ^2 (&>!•)• Therefore Wk = W ^ - i - W ^ , where ^ e A . M f c . M f c - i ) , ^ 2 ^ / : ^ , ^ - ! ) . 00
Define the unitary operator Ui£C(Hi,
® Alt) as follows fc=0
^1 = ((j/o,0),(yi,0),--- , (yfc)0),---)i-> (y0,2/i,---
,Vk,---)-
Then U\S\Ul = Si is an operator weighted shift with weight sequence {Wjfc }£ii a n ( i multiplicity n i . Similarly, we can define a unitary operator
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
137
U2£C(H2, 0 A4) such that U2S2U2 = S2 satisfying the requirements of fc=o the theorem. (ii)=>(iii). Obvious. (iii)=>(i). We still assume that m = 2. Since {Qi,Q2} is a spectral family of 5, Qi,Q2eA'(S). Let
Qf=diag{Q(i\..-,Qf,...) be the diagonal of Qi{i a spectral family of 5.
= 1,2). Clearly, {Qd ,Qd } is also Set Si = S\ „(i) (i = 1,2). Then
5 = S\+S2- Repeating the argument of (i)=>(ii), we can prove that Wk = W^+WP, where W^]eC(Mk,Mk-i), W™eC(NkMk-i) and dimMk = dimMk-i,dimAfk = dimNk-i for all k>l. Choose i±\,ii2&C such that \ni\ < |/n2|Set AQ = HIIMO+MI/SO and Afe = E^xA0Ek = fiilMk+^I^, k>l. Then
||Afc||<|H(IIQi|| + IIQ2||). Thus A:=diag(A0,Ai,---
,Ak,---)eA'{S)
and A0 = ^| fcer s,cr( J 4o) = { / i i , ^ } , i.e., card(a(Ao)) = 2. Theorem 4.6.13 Let S~{Wk}
be a backward operator weighted shift and r
let r = ma,x{card(a(A0))
: A0&Ao{S)}.
Then S~S
= 0 Si, where each r
Si^(SI)
is an operator weighted shift with multiplicity rii and £^ n» = n. i=l
Corollary 4.6.14 Let S~{Wk} be a backward operator weighted shift and A0eAo{S), then a(A0) = aAo{s)(A0). Proof Clearly, a(A0)CaAo(S)(Ao). Assume that Ad = diag(Ao,Ai,---,Ak,---), where Ak = Ek~1AoEk (k>l). By the preceding discussion, cr(Ao) = o-(Ad) and AdeA'(S). If A £ a(A0), AdB = BAd = I for some Be£(H) and BGA'(S). This implies that B0 = B\kers€Ao(S) and A0B0 = B0A0 = J o - Therefore <MO(S)(4>)C
138
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Theorem 4.6.15 Let S~{Wt-} be an operator weighted shift, then the following are equivalent: (i) Se(SI); (ii) cr(Ao) contains only one point for each AoGAo(S); (Hi) Ao(S)/radA0(S)^C; (iv) There is no nontrivial idempotent in Ao(S), Proof (i)=>(ii). It is a straightforward conclusion of Theorem 4.6.12. (ii)=Kiii). Let J = {A0eAo(S) •
where
XAoea(A0).
Note that a{Ao) consists of one point and for each Bo£[-<4o], Ao — B0€radAo(S). Thus a(A0 - B0) = {0}. Assume that a(A0) = {A}, a(B0) = {/j,}, then 0 = tr(Ao — B0) = trAo — trBo = nX — nfi and A = v. This implies that
+ XAB-XAXB]
= [A- XA\[B\ +
XA[B-XB],
it follows from a((A - XA)B) = a{XA{B - XB)) = {0} that
for all Po£Ao{S), where Ao = 0 or Ao = 1. Since ip([PQ - AJc-]) = 0,
= trPo—nX. This implies that P0 = 0 or Po =
Ic-
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
139
(iv)=>(i). Assume that PeA'(S) is an idempotent, then Po = P\kers£Ao(S) is also an idempotent. Thus Po = 0 or Po = i o - Without loss of generality, we assume that PQ = 0. From PS = SP,
c nn c
OPoi * 0 Pl2 P =
Since P 2 = P, P = 0. Thus
C"'
0 '••
Se{SI).
Theorem 4.6.16 Let S~{Wfc} be an operator weighted shift, then SG(SI) if and only if J := {A£A'(S) : c(A\kers) = {0}} is a maximal two sided ideal of A'(S) and A'(S)/J is abelian. Proof Suppose that Se(SI). {Claim a } J is a linear space. For A, B&J, (A + B)\kerS = A\kerS + B\kerS = A0 + Bo.
By Theorem 4.6.15, a{A0 + B0) = {A}. Thus nX = tr(A0 + Bo) = trA0 + trB0 = 0. This implies that A = 0 and A + B e J. {Claim b } J is a closed two-sided ideal. Note that for A£j and BeA'(S), AB\kers = (A\kers)(B\kers)&MS)Thus a(AB\kers) = {0} and Claim b holds. {Claim c} J is a maximal ideal. Suppose that J' is a two-sided ideal of A'(S) satisfying J' D J and J' ± J. Choose AeJ'\J, then Ad, oo
the diagonal of A with respect to H = 0 C n , is in A'(S).
Since
A^J,
fc=0
o-(Aa) = o-{A\kers) = {A}, A 7^ 0. This means that Ad is invertible. Denote Ar = A- Ad. Then AreJ. Thus Ad = A - ArSj'. This implies that J' = A'(S). Therefore J is maximal. {Claim d } A'{S)/J is commutative. For A, BeA'(S), Set C = AB - BA. Then Co = C\kerS = (AB — BA)\kerS
= A0B0
— Po^O-
By Theorem 4.6.15, a(C0) = {fi}. Thus n/i = trC0 = tr(A0B0
- B0A0) = tr{A0B0)
- tr(B0A0)
=0
140
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
and fi = 0. Therefore C£j and A'(S)/J is commutative. Conversely, suppose that J is a maximal two-sided ideal of A'(S) and A'{S)/J is abelian. If P is a nontrivial idempotent in A'(S). Set J' = A'(S)PA'(S) + J. It is not difficult to see that J' is a twosided ideal of A'(S) and J'DJ. Since P 0 = P\kerS ¥= 0 , P £ J and J ' ^ J ' . We assert that the identity 7 ^ J ' . Otherwise I = APB + C, where A,B<=A'{S) and C e J . Thus 7 C " = liters = A0P0B0 + C 0 , here ^4o = A\kerS,B0 = B\kerS and C 0 = C|fcers. Since C0Sk7|fcerS,o'(Co) = {0}. This means that J c „ - C 0 = A)P 0 So is invertible. But the determinant detPo of P 0 is zero (P 0 7^ 0). Thus deL4 0 P 0 B 0 = (detA0)(detP0)(detB0)
= 0.
A contradiction. Therefore J'Z)J (but J' ^ J7) is also a maximal proper ideal. This contradicts the assumption that J is a maximal two-sided ideal. Corollary 4.6.17 Let S~{Wk} be an operator weighted shift satisfying that Wk = W for all fc>l. Then SG(SI) if and only if We(SI). Proof By Jordan Theorem, there is an invertible matrix XGMn(C) such that Jnj(^l) l
J = XWX~
0
= Jnt(h)
and ^2 rii = n. i=l
_
Set Y = diag(X, X, • • •), then Y is invertible, and S = YSY^^Wk} is an operator weighted shift, where Wk = J. By Theorem 4.6.15, S£(SI) if and only if I = 1 or if and only if W£(SI). The following example indicates that the condition Wk = W (k>l) can not be omitted. Example 4.6.18
Let W2k+i
11 01
, w2k =
1 -1 0 1
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
141
then Wk-
11 01
e(Sl).
Let S be the operator weighted shift with weighted {Wk}. Set 2k+l
=
10 00
11 p2fc
00
and P — diag(Pi,P2, P3, • • •). A simple computation shows that PS = SP andP2 = P, i.e., S#(SI). Now we will discuss the similarity of two operator weighted shifts. Proposition 4.6.19 Let S~{Wk} andT~{Vk\ be two operator weighted shifts. Then 5 ~ T if and only if there is a sequence of invertihle matrices {Xt} such that sup{\\Xi\\, ||Xf i } < 00 and Wt = X i K i X i + 1 1 , (*>1). i
Proof
on C n such that
If there are invertihle operators {Xi}^
supdl^llJX - l l
<
00
and Wi =
XiViX-+\,(i>l).
Set X = diag(Xi,X2, •••). Then X is invertihle and SX = XT, i.e., S~T. On the other hand, if 5 ~ T or SX = XT and X^S = TX~l for some operator X. Note that X can be expressed as Xi X\i
X\z
X2
-^23
X =
where WiXi+i
x3
= XiVi and sup{||Xj||} < 00. Since X ^ 1 ^12 ^13 X2
X~l
=
Y23
x
has the form
142
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
where Y,Wi = ViYi+\ and sup{||Yj||} < oo. Since i
xx-1 = x~1x = i, XiYi = YiXi = ICn, Corollary 4.6.20 Proof
(i = l , 2 , - - - ) .
Let S^{Wk}f=1,T^{Wk}^=2
By Corollary 4.6.11, SeBn(tt)
and S€Bn(Sl),
then
implies that
sup{||W i ||,||W i - 1 ||}
Set Xi = Wi, then Wi = XiWi+iXr^v
By Proposition 4.6.19, S~T.
Proposition 4.6.21 Let S~{Wk} and S~{Vk} be two operator weighted shifts, then S~S if and only if S~q.sS, where "~ q . s " means quasisimilar. Proof We need only to verify that S~q.sS implies S~S. By the quasisimilarity, we can assume that S and S have the same multiplicity n and there exist X, Ye£(H) with trivial kernels and dense ranges such that SX = XS and YS = ~SY. Then X and Y have the form Xx
*
x2
X
Y2
0 Since kerXxckerX
0
= {0},Xi is invertible. If follows from SXY
XYS that XYeA'(S)
= XSY +
and XiYx
* X2Y2
XY = 0
Thus d%ag{XxYi,X2Y2, • • • )£A'(A). From SX = XS, we have X2 = W^XM,.•
• ,Xk+1 = W^XkVk, (fc>l).
This implies that Xk (k>l) is invertible. Similarly, Yk (k>l) is invertible. Thus XkYk (k>l) and diag(X\Yi,X2Y2, • • •) are invertible, and [diagiX^XiYi,
• • • J]" 1 = diag{Y^ X^\Y2~l
X^\
•••).
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
143
Therefore, there exists M > 0 such that suP{||yfc-%-1||}<M. k
Since diag(X\,X2,
• • • )£kerrs•§, there exists N > 0 such that sup{||Xfc||} < k
N. Furthermore,
supdin-^D^supdin-^fc-^i.HXfciD^supdiy^Xfc-^D-supfHXfciD^Miv. This implies that diag(Yi,Y2,- ••) diag(Yi,Y2, • • • )€kerTgS. Thus S ~ 5 . Proposition 4.6.22 Let S~{Wk} shifts with multiplicity n. S,S£(SI) Then Ao(T)/radA0(T)^C ® C. Proof Note that
-4'(T) = J
For arbitrary Xi2&kerrSg 'Xx
invertible
and
and S~{Vk} be two operators weighted and S is not similar to S. T = S®S.
XS<=A'{S) Xi2£kerrSg
-^21 -X"s
is
Xg£A'(S) X2i€herrg
s
1 J '
and X21 £kerTg s, we have * '
x2
'Yx
*•
Y2
, X21 =
.0
. 0 Computations indicate that X12X2i&A'(S),X2iX12€A'(S) and -^12-^2l|fcerS = XlYi,
Since S,'Se(SI),
•^21-^12|fc e r 5 =
YiX\.
it follows from Theorem 4.6.15 that
= {A}.
{Claim} A = 0. We assume that Xi and X2 are invertible. Set X' = diag(X\,X2, •••), then kerX' = {0} and ranX' = H. Similarly, if Y' denotes Y' = diag(Yi,Y2,- ••) then kerY' = {0} and ranY' = H. Since X'ekerrs^ and Y'£kerTg s, S~S. A contradiction.
Structure of Hilbert Space
144
Operators
For each En E12 E21 E22 and XGkerTs-g,
eMT)
\&
D =
En E12 0
E21 E22
=
0
By the claim above, cr(E2iX\kerg) that
.0
E2lX\kerg_
= {0}. Thus a(D) = {0}. This implies
0X1\kerS 0
'0EnX\kers
GradA0(T).
0
Repeating the argument above, if YGkerr-g s , then 0 y\kerS
0 0
GradA0(T).
Thus Ao{T)/radA
o(T) = {
Xs + radAo{S) 0
By Theorem 4.6.15, Ao(T)/radAo(T)^C
0 Xg+radAo(S)
XS&A Xs€A' '(S)j-
© C.
Proposition 4.6.23 Let S and S be two operator weighted shifts, S,Se(SI) and S~S. T = S®S, then MT)/radA0(T)^M2(C). Proof
Without loss of generality, we assume that S = S. Then
IfcerS X\2\kerS XijeA'(S),i,j = l,2.|. !\Xn \kerS X22I kerS U*21 Since S£(SI), by Theorem 4.6.15, A0(T)/radAo(T)^C. Thus we have Ao(T)/radA0{T)^M2{C).
MT)
=
Proposition 4.6.24 Let S~{Wk} and 5~{Vfc} be two operators weighted shifts. S,SG(SI) and S is not similar to S. T = S(BS. Then Ao{T)/radA0{T)^C
© C.
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
145
Proof Assume that S and S have multiplicities m and n respectively. By Theorem 4.6.15, we need only to prove the proposition in the case of m
since E12E21 GAQ(S) Denote
is not invertible, by Theorem 4.6.15, a(Ei2E2i)
radA'(S) E21
J =
= {0}.
EuEkerTgg 1 E2iGkerT-gS J '
Ei2_ radA'(S)
By the arguments used in the proof of Proposition 4.6.21 we have J radAo{T). Thus Ao(T)/radAo{T)^C 0 C.
=
Summarizing the discussion above, we have the following theorem. Theorem 4.6.25 Let S and S be two operator weighted shifts. S, S€(SI) and T = S®S. Then 1. S~S if and only if Ao(T)/radAo(T)^M2(C)] 2. S is not similar to 5 if and only if Ao(T)/radAo(T)=C © C. As a matter of fact, we have a more general result by Proposition 4.6.21, Proposition 4.6.22 and Proposition 4.6.23. Theorem 4.6.26 m
S~@Sj
Let S and S be two operator weighted shifts and
, where Si£(SI)
is an operator weighted shift and S^Sj
i=i
_
i ^ j (Corollary 4.6.13).
Let T = S®S,
then S~S
if and only if
m
Ao(T)/radA0(T)^
0 M 2fci (C). i=i
Proposition 4.6.27 Let S~{Wk}
k
be an operator weighted shift and
~ |_0 1 J ' fc
then A'(S) is commutative if and only i/sup | ^ Aj| = +00. fc
for
_
i=i
146
Structure of Hilbert Space
Proof
If
Operators
then T is of the form
TGA'(S),
T i i T\i T13 • • • 2~22 ? 2 3 • • '
0
and Tk+1>k+1 = Elk1TnE1,k+i-i
T33'--
(A;>1, Z>1), where k
Elk=WlWl+v--Wk
lEAi
=
i=l
0
1
Set Tu =
*21 *22
then = Hi Hi
Tk+i,k+i — Elk T\iE^k+i^i
i'
t'
'21 r 2 2
where k
t'n = hi — ( E Ai)*2i i=l
k+l-1
k+l-1
t'12=t12 + ( E
Wn
- (Z W22 - (Z \i)( E
i=i
t=l
fc
i=l
i-1
= *i2 + (EAi)(tn-*22) + ( - E A i + i=l
i=l
AOfei
i=i
fc+i-1
E
fc
k+l-1
A0*n-(EAi)( E
i=fc+l
i=l
Ai)t2i
i=l
k+l-1 t
t'22= 22 + ( E
A<)*21.
i=l
If sup | E Ai| = +oo, since t'n are uniformly bounded, £21 = 0. Since fc
»=i
sup{||Wfc||}<+oo,|Ai|<M fc
Unitary Invariant
and Similarity
Invariant
of Operators
147
l-\ fc+J-1 Thus | - E A* + E A»| < 21M. Since t'l2 are
for some number M.
i=i
uniformly bounded, tu = t\i.
»=fc+i
Thus
Tk+l,k+l = -Effc T'll-Bi.fc+i-l = *ll-f + *12«^2(0). Therefore, .4' (5) is commutative. * If s u p | ^ Aj| = N < + o o , set A k
diag(B\,B2,
= diag(A\,A2,---)
and B
=
»=i
•••), where fc fe
•EAi(EAi)2 -4fc+i
fc
EAi i=l
Bi =
4.7
01 00
. Then A,
BGA'(S),
but AB - BA ^ 0.
Open Problem
1. Is every operator in JC(H) is a direct integral of strongly irreducible operators? 2. What is the necessary and sufficient conditions for an operator T€£(H) to have only finitely many Banach reducing subspaces? 3. If Te£(H)fl(SI), is A'(T)/radA'(T) commutative? 4. Does the following statement holds for arbitrary Ti,T2&£(J~t)C\(SI)l T!~Ta if and only if Ko(A'(T1®T2))=Ko(A'(T1))^Ko(A'(T2)). 5. Let T&£(H)r\(SI), then for each natural number n, does T^ have a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity? 6. If TG£(H) is a direct sum of finitely many (SI) operators, does T have a unique (SI) decomposition up to similarity? 7. What is the "Beurling" Theorem for Mz in Sobolev disk algebra? 8. Given a necessary and sufficient condition for an injective unilateral operator weighted shift S~{Wk} to be strongly irreducible. 4.8
Remark
Theorems 4.1.3-4.1.20 are given by [Fang, J.S., Jiang, C.L. and Wu, P.Y. (2003)]. Theorem 4.2.1, Proposition 4.2.13 and Theorem 4.2.14 are due
148
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
to [Cao, Y., Fang, J.S. and Jiang, C.L.(2002)]. Theorem 4.3.1 belongs to [Fang, J.S. and Jiang, C.L. (1999)]. Proposition 4.3.5, Theorem 4.3.9, Proposition 4.3.11 and Proposition 4.3.12 are proved by [Ji, Y.Q. and Yang, Y.H. (2003)]. Example 4.3.8 is due to [Fang, J.S. and Jiang, C.L. (1999)]. Theorem 4.3.6 is given by [Jiang, C.L. (2004)]. Theorem 4.3.13 and Corollary 4.3.14 are proved by [Wang, Z.Y. and Xue, Y.F. (2000)]. Example 4.4.1 and Proposition 4.4.2 belong to [Jiang, C.L. and Li, J.X. (2000)]. C.L. Jiang also proved Theorem 4.4.3 [Jiang, C.L. (2004)]. The all results in Section 4.5 are proved by [Wang, Z.Y. (1993)], [Wang, Z.Y. and Liu, Y.Q. ], [Liu, Y.Q. and Wang, Z.Y. (2004)], [Liu, Y.Q. and Wang, Z.Y. ], [Jin, Y.F. and Wang, Z.Y.(l)]]. Theorem 4.6.2, Proposition 4.6.9 and Theorem 4.6.10 are given by [Ji, Y.Q., Li, J.X. and Sun, S.L. (2003)]. Theorem 4.6.12-Theorem 4.6.26 are proved by [Jiang, C.L. and Li, J.X. (2000)]. Example 4.6.18, Proposition 4.6.19-Proposition 4.6.27 are given by jia-jin-wan. The reader can refer to [Davidson, K.R. and Herrero, D.A. (1990)] about the (SI) decomposition of some special operator classes and [Behncke, H.], [Yan, C.Q. (1993)] about to the unique (SI) decomposition up to unitary equivalence.
Chapter 5
The Similarity Invariant of Cowen-Douglas Operators 5.1
The Cowen-Douglas Operators with Index 1
The backward unilateral shift is a typical Cowen-Douglas operator with index 1. Denote H = I2 — {(xi,x2,- • •) : X) W 2 < °°}- F ° r («o,ai,- ••)&2, define T*(ao, a\, • • •) = (ai, «2, • • • )• For I'M < 1> w e have r 2 *(l,A,A 2 ,-..) = A(l,A,A 2 ,..-).
This implies that Dcap(T*). Clearly, T*eBi(D) and A'(TZ)^H°°. Note that Tz, the adjoint of Tj*, is an analytic Teolitz operator and also a pure isometry operator. oo
An operator
SGC(H)
is called a pure isometry operator if f] SnH = n=l
{0}.
von-Neumann-Wold Theorem Let S£C(Ti) be a pure isometry operai
tor. Then S^ ® Tz, where I =
dimkerS*.
fc=i
It is easily seen that Tz is also a pure isometry operator for each natural number n. The following is a well-known result. Lemma 5.1.1 Let SGJC(H) be a pure isometry operator, then (i) 5 S T i ° and S*eBt(D), where I = dimkerS*; (ii) S€(SI)ifandonlyifS*eB1(D). Lemma 5.1.2 Let P be an idempotent in A'(Tz), let S = TJ"^ |PW
150
Structure of Hilbert Space
(i) U(PH^)=H^®0^m\
Operators
i.e.,
UPU* =
0
0
(ii) LetV = U\ Pfi(rv), then VSV* = Tzm , i.e., S is unitarily equivalent
toZ
(m)
Proof It is obvious that S is a pure isometry. By von-Neumann-Wold Theorem, S is unitarily equivalent to TJ . Thus there is a unitary operator V : PH{n)
—• H{n)
such that VSV* = T ( m ) . Note that if m < n, W ( n ) ©PW ( m ) is infinite dimensional. Therefore, there exists a unitary operator W : H(n)ePH(n)
—> Hin~m).
Set U = V®W, then U satisfies the requirements of the lemma. Lemma 5.1.3 Let P be an idempotent in A' ((T*)^) and let S = (T*)(n^\p-H(n). If m = dimkerS, then there exists a unitary operator U such that: (i)
U(Pn^)
=
ft(m)©0(n-m\
i.e., UPU* =
(ii) Let V = C/| PH (n), then VSV* = (T*)^m\ alent to (r*)( m >. Proof Let Q = (IHM - P)*, then QGA'((T2)^) (Q(Tzr>Q)*
0
y{n-m)
0
i.e., S is unitarily equivis an idempotent and
(n)/( / „ , - P ) . = (/„(„, - P ) ( T ; ) W H(
Thus
{{T*T%H^Y Since
=
Wl {T;T\i H{n)-P)H^
PeA'((T*)^), dimker((Tz)^\QnMr
=
•
dimker{{T*z)M)\(jH{n)_P)nM
= n- dimker((T*)^)
=n-m.
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
Operators
151
By Lemma 5.1.2, there exists a unitary operator XJ\ such that
0
0
and rp(n-m)
U^QT^QUt
=
0
^
ft(n-m)
0
U(m).
Thus UxPU* =
0
0 H(m)
and UiPiT^PU?
0
<^(n-m)
0
* (T*)( m )
W(m)
•
Define U2 : H{n) = H{n-m)®H{m) - ^ H{m)®H(m) by U2{x®y) = y®x onto, {n m) {m) for x€H ~ and y£H . Then t/2 is a unitary operator. Let U = U2UU then U satisfies the requirements of the lemma. For T e # n ( Q ) and zeQ, S(T - zl) = (T - zI)S for all SeA'(T). Sker(T - zI)cker{T
-
Thus
zl).
Define (TTS)(Z) = S\ker(T-zi)- In general, we substitute S(z) for (FyS 1 )^) (see Chapter 3). Clearly, TT is an injective contraction. But for T — (T*)(n^GBn(D), we can easily obtain the following lemma. Lemma 5.1.4 Let T = {T*)^n\ A'{T) onto Mn(H°°).
then TT is an isometry isomorphism from
Lemma 5.1.5 Let H = H2, .4e6i(fi)n£(W) and T = A<-nK For each idempotentPeA'(T), denoted =T\PnM. //Ti<=£ m (ft), thenT^A^l Proof Without loss of generality, we can assume that DcQ. Then we can find W-valued holomorphic functions v(z) and e(z) on D such that (A-z)v(z)
= 0, (T; - z)e(z) = 0,
and v(z) and e(z) can be chosen to be the holomorphic frames of ker(A — z)
152
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
and ker(T* — z) respectively. Set «fc(z) = ( 0 , " - , 0 ) v ( z ) , 0 , - . - , 0 ) ) k = 1,2, • • • ,n,z&D. efc(z) = ( 0 , - - - , 0 , e ( z ) , 0 , . . . , 0 ) , Let P{z) = (TTP)(z), zeD, then P{z) = ( P ^ z ^ ^ e M ^ t f 0 0 ) is an idempotent. By Lemma 5.1.4, P(z) is an idempotent in A'((T*)'")). Set
g = P(z) and
s = (r;)(nW>. Since Ti£Bm(fl),
dimkerS = ranP(0) = dimkerTi
= m.
By Lemma 5.1.3, there exists a unitary operator U such that U(PH{n))
= W(m)©0("_m),
i.e.,
UPU* =
0
0
(5.1.1)
and if V = *7|PW(n), then KSK* = (Tz*)(m>. Since l/*(V^ m )©0("- m )) = l/*(ft( m )eO( n ~ m )) = QH™ and VSV* = {T*)(m\ U*ei(z)£ker(S-z)cker((T*)(n'>-z),l
-\
h Xin(z)en(z),
l
>= <% < e(z),e(z) >, l
h A in (z)Aj n (z) = <5y, l
From (5.1.1), UP(z)U*ei(z)
= IH(m)ei(z)
= e^z), l
P{z)U*ei{z) =
(5.1.2) Therefore,
U*ei(z),
i.e., (Pij(z)) n x „(Aii(z),- • • ,\in(z)) where Ki<m
and z e D .
= (\n(z),---
,Aj„(z)),
(5.1.3)
The Similarity
Invariant
Set Wi{z) = Xn(z)vi(z)
of Cowen-Douglas
Operators
+ • • • + \in(z)vn(z),l
< v(z),v(z)
>,l
153
Since j
(5.1.4)
by (5.1.2), < Wi(z),Wj(z) > = Sij < v(z),v(z) >,l
- z) — ker(T\ - z),
thus Wi(z)£ker(Ti — z), lker(T1 - z) as follows U(z)vi(z) = Wi(z),
l
It follows from (5.1.4) and (5.1.5) that < U(z)vi(z),U(z)vj(z)
>=< Vi(z),Vj(z) > = S^ < v(z),v(z)
>,l
Since U(z) is a holomorphic isometric bundle map, using Rigidity Theorem wehaveTi^^™). Theorem 5.1.6 Let A&Bi{Q)nC{K), then V ( * 4 ' ( ^ ) ) - N and K0(A'(A))^Z. Proof By Theorem 4.2.1, for every natural number n and idempotent Pe(A'{A^)), if Ax = A(")|p W („), then A^A. This is a straightforward corollary of Lemma 5.1.5. Proposition 5.1.7 Let A,BGBI(£1), then the following are equivalent. (i) A~B; (ii) K0{A'(A®B))^Z. Proof (i)=^(ii). It is a straightforward conclusion of Theorem 5.1.6. (ii)=Ki). We need only to show that if A^B, then K0(A'(A®B))^Z. Otherwise, we assume that K0{A' {A®B)=Z. Since A^B, there exists a maximal ideal J in A'(A®B) such that A'(A@B)/J^C, where I" J' [kerTBtA
kerrAiB A'(B) _
and J' is a maximal ideal of .4'(.A) (see Section 5.2) following separating exact sequence: 0—>J -i-»
n A'{A®B)^A'{A@B)/J A
Thus we have the
Structure of Hilbert Space
154
Operators
and the semi-exact sequence:
Ko(J) - ^
K0(A'(A®B))^K0(A/J). A*
Observing the six-term exact sequence:
K0(J) KX(A\A®B)IJ)
- ^ K0(A'{A®B))
-^
*— K^A'iAQB))
—
K0(A'(A(BB)/J) K^J)
It is easy to see that 3 = 0. Thus we get the exact sequence: 0^Ko(J)
- ^ K0(A'(A®B))
Note that K0{A'(A@B))^K0(A/J)=Z, tradicts that K0 (J) ^ 0. 5.2
-^
tf0(„4/J)^o.
therefore K0{J)
= 0. This con-
Cowen-Douglas Operators with Index n
L e m m a 5.2.1 Let AeBn{fl)n(SI), T = A{l)e£{H{l)) and let P be an idempotent in A'(T) satisfying T|pW(i)€(S'-r). Then A\ := T\PH(i) is similar to A. Proof Without loss of generality, we may assume that D. = D an n is the minimal index of A. For convenience we will prove the lemma only in the case of n = 2. Then T = A® A. Note that P is an idempotent in A'(T), by Theorem 4.4.3 we can find an idempotent P\€A'{T) and B£radA'(T) such that P(z) = P\(z) + B(z), where fn(z) fn(z)
fn(z) /22O)
ker(A — z) ker(A — z)
and B{z) =
Bn(z)B12(z) B2i(z)B22(z)
ker(A — z) ker(A — z)'
fijGH00 and Bij£radA'{A). Set G = -Inm + (2Pi + B). Since B€radA'(T), G is invertible in A'(T) and PG = GP^ This implies that G-1PG = P1eA'(T).
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
Operators
155
Without loss of generality, we may assume that P — P\, i.e.,
fn(z) h2{z) ker(A — z)
P{z)
hl{z)
ker(A — z)'
fn(z)
fi2(z)
./2l(z)
f22(z)
ker(Tz* — z) ker(Tz* — z)'
f2l(z)
Set P'(z) =
Since T\Pnm&{SI), tr(P'(z)) = 1 for all z£D. By the arguments similar to that used in the proof of Lemma 5.1.5, there exists an invertible element X(z) in M2(H°°) such that IcO 0 0
X(z)P'(z)X-\z) and
0 0 0/c
X(z)(I-P'(z))X-\z)
Furthermore, X(z)\ranp>^ and X{z)\ran(j-pi(z)) are isomorphic bundle maps from ranP'(z) and ran(I — P'(z)) respectively onto ker(Tz* — z). Set X(z) =
un(z)
ui2(z)
U2l(z)
U22(z)
and X{z) =
Ull(z)Iker(A-z) U2l{z)Iker(A-z)
Ul2(z)her(A-z) U22(z)Iker(A_z)
Then X(z)P(z)X(z)
=
her(A-z) 0
0 0
Note that X(z)ker(T - z) = ker(T - z). {Claim} G(z) = X(z)\ranp^ is an isomorphic bundle map from ranP(z) onto ker(A — z). Note that G(z) = X(z)\ranpi^z-) is an isomorphic bundle map from ranP'(z) onto ker{Tz> — z). Let e{z) be a holomorphic frame of ker{Tz* — z) and ti(z) = e(z)®0,
t2(z) = 0®e(z).
156
Structure
of Hilbert Space
Operators
Then (£i(z), ^(z)) is a holomorphic frame of ker(T^,' — z). Set Ai = Tz. |p/(z)W(2) and Z(z) is a holomorphic frame of fcer(.Ai — z), then i(z) = a(2)t 1 (z) + / 8(z)t 2 (z), where a(z),(3(z) are analytic functions in D. Since G(z) is a holomorphic isomorphic map, we can find a function c(z) holomorphic in D such that G(z)l(z) = c(z)e(z) and |K(z)||2 = (|a(z)| 2 + |/3(z)| 2 )||e(z)|| = |c(z)| 2 ||e(z)|| for zeD. Let (Si(z), • • • , Sn(z)) be a holomorphic frame of ker(A — z). Set Vj(z)
= Sj(z)eO, Uj{z) = OeSj(z), (j = 1, 2, • • • , n).
Then (fi(z), • • • ,vn(z),ui(z), • • • ,un(z)) is a holomorphic frame of ker(T— z). Let fj(z) = a(z)vj(z) + /3(Z)UJ(Z), (j — 1,2,- • • ,n). Then (fx(z), • • • , fn(z)) is a holomorphic frame of ker(A\ — z). Set V{z)fi(z)
=
c(z)Vj(z).
Let K\(z), • • • , Kn(z) be analytic functions in D and g(z) = /fi(z)/i(z) + • • • +
Kn(z)fn(z)
= #i(z)(a(z)vi(z) + )8(z)ui(z)) + • • • + tfn(z)(a(z)t>n(z) + j 8(z)u n (z)). Then G(z)(z) = c(z)(iT 1 (z) Vl (z) + • • • + tfn(z)un(z)) := g\z). Since < UJ(Z),WJ(Z) > = < Ui(z),Uj(z) >=< Si(z),Sj(z) > for z£D, < g(z),g(z)
| ^ ( z ) | 2 ( | a ( z ) | 2 + |/?(z)| 2 )||Si(z)|| 2
>=t t=i
+ t
Ki{z)Kj{z){\a{z)\'>
+
\(3{z)\'>)<Si{z),Sj(z)>.
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
157
Operators
Furthermore,
> = E |#,-(z)| 2 | C (z)| 2 ||Si(s)|| a
+ E
Ki(z)^-W|c(z)|2 < ^ ( z ) ^ ) > .
This implies that ||G(.z)<7(.z)|| = ||ff(-z)|| and it verifies our claim. Similarly, we can prove that -^(z)|ran(/-P(z)) is also a holomorphic isomorphism from ran{I — P(z)) onto ker(A — z). By Rigidity Theorem, we can find two isomorphisms and U2££({I - P)tt ( 2 ) ,0©ft)
UitCiPH™,H®0)
such that X = Ui + U2<=A'(T) and XPX This indicates that Ai~A
-l
0 0
and ends the proof of the lemma.
By Theorem 4.2.1 and Lemma 5.2.1, we get the following theorem. Theorem K0(A'(A))^Z.
5.2.2 Let
AeBn{n)r)(SI),
then
\J(A'{A))^N
<™d
Similar to the proof of Proposition 5.1.7, we have the following result. Proposition 5.2.3 Let A,BeBn(fi)D(SI), ments are equivalent: (i) A~B; (ii) K0(A'{A®B))^Z. 5.3
then the following two state-
The Commutant of Cowen-Douglas Operators n
In this section, we always assume that T = 0 Tk, where TfcSBnfc (0fc)n(S7) fc=i
and
\/ ker(Tk — z) = Tik- By the basic operator theory, we have the
following properties: (5.3.1) A'(T) = {(Sij)nxn\Sij£kerTT algebra.
T .,
l
Structure of Hilbert Space
158
Operators
(5.3.2) kerrT, is a linear space and kerrT, T = A'iTi) is a unital Banach algebra. (5.3.3) Denote eA,(T) the identity in A'(T). Then e
A'(T)
e
A'{T1)i
">t'(T„)-
(5.3.4) If Sij£kerrT. T . and Sjk&kerTT. (5.3.5) If (Sij^neA'iT), then o... 5(«,j)
, then SijSjk£kerrT.
.
T
o ••• o
0 • • • Sij
o...
T
•••
0
£A'(T).
o ••• o
By (5.3.5), we can define a canonical map $ y : A'(T)—>kerrT. follows:
T.
as
(5.3.6) $„• is a linear map and $ i i (5)G^ / (T i ) for all S G ,4'(T). In this section, J denotes a proper two-sided ideal. (5.3.7) Let J be an ideal of A'(T). Define o... Uij — i*~^j • >Jij^.rCGTTrp_ rp_ clIlCl
o ••• o
0 • • • Sij
•••
0
0
•••
0
eJ}
Then (5.3.7.1) Ju is an ideal of A'(Ti) or Ju = A'(Ti); (5.3.7.2) Jij is a subspace of kerrT. T.; (5.3.7.3)
S(i,j)&J
for S = ( S y ) n x n G J .
By (5.3.7), we can define a canonical map from kerrT kerrT, T./$ij{J) as follows: 5jj— > [S'ij] l 7, where kerrT, T./$ij(J) quotient of kerrT T. modulo Qij(J'). If i7 is closed, then • A ' C n / J - {([Sii]j)nxn •
SijGkerr^.}
T.
onto is the
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
159
Operators
is a unital Banach algebra. Thus we have a canonical map $j : A'(T) —>
A'(T)/J
as follows: ®j((Sij)nxn)
= ([Sij]j)nxn-
(5.3.8) Let J be a closed ideal of A'(T). ([Sii]j)nxn
=
If
*j(S)€A'(T)/J,
then •Q...
••• 0_
0
0 • • • [Sii\j • • • 0 $j(S(i,mA'(T)/J.
o...
o ••• o
Lemma 5.3.1(Lifting Lemma)
Let T = © Tk and J\ he an ideal fc=i
of A'(Ti), then there exists an ideal J of A'{T) such that §i\(J) = J\. Furthermore, if there is another ideal J1 of A'{T) such that $n(»7') = J\, then JQ-J', where <J?n is given in (5.3.5). Proof Set X={
Rl R^D I A21K3 B21H4B12]
:
Ri£Ji,i
= 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ; B « , A i j € k e r T ,3i "
and J = {xi + X2 H
h xn : \
{Claim} J is an ideal of A'{T). Clearly, J is an additive group. Set W =
Wn W12 W21 W22
&A'{T) and X =
Ri R2A12 A21R3 B21R4B12
ex-
Then WnRi
{WllR2)Al2
W21R1 W21R2A 12
+
(W12A2i)R3 (W22A2i)R3
(W12B21R4)B12 (W22B21)R4B12
= 1,2},
160
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Since WuRi
(W12A21)R3 (W22A2l)R3
(WuR2)A12
W21R1
W21R2A 12
(W12B21R4)B12 (W22B21)R4B12 ex,
WXeJ. Similarly, XWeJ. Thus J is an ideal of A'(T). Since $n(X)€j1 for all XGJ, eA, $ J. Therefore J" is a proper ideal of A'{T) and $ n ( J ) = J i . If $n(J') = J i for another ideal J' of A'(T), by (5.3.4) and (5.3.7), JcJ'. Corollary 5.3.2
Let T = 0 Tk and J i be an ideal J of A'{Ti),
then
fc=i
there exists an ideal J of A'{T) such that $ n ( J " ) = J\. Furthermore, if $11 (J') = J i for another ideal J' of A'(T), then JcJ'. Corollary 5.3.3 Let T = 0 Tk and J<=M(A'{T)), .4'(Tfc) or $kk{J)£M{A'{Tk))7k
then $kk(J)
= 1,2, • • • ,n.
Lemma 5.3.4 Let T = 0 Tk and S = (Sij)nxneA'(T).
If for each
fc=i
Rji£kerrT, T ., RjiSij = 0, £/ien S(i, j)£radA' Proof For each
Rn
(T).
Rln
R tlnl
' ' ' *Mi
0 ••• RuSij RS(i,j)
=
Corollary 5.3.5 LetT= §kk{radA'{T))
••• 0
0 • • • RjiSij • • • 0 0 • • • Knibij
Since i^SV,- = 0, (RS(i,j))n
=
••• 0
= 0. This implies that 5(z,
j)£radA'(T).
0 Tk, then = radA'(Tk), k = 1,2, • • • , n.
The Similarity
Corollary 5.3.6 ®ij{J)- IfSijrji
Invariant
Let T =
of Cowen-Douglas
® Tk,
161
Operators
and Si:i€kerTT,
JGM(A'(T))
T./
= 0 for all r^eker-r^ T . / $ , j ( J ) , then Si:j = 0. n
Theorem 5.3.7 Let T = © Tk, then for each JeM(A'(T)),
there is a
fc=i
positive integer I j
By Corollary 5.3.3, $kk(J)
= A'(Tk)
or $kk(J)eM(A'(Tk)),k
= 1,2,-••
,n.
By Theorem 4.4.3, A'(Tk)/radA'(Tk) is commutative for k = 1,2, • • • ,n. Thus A'(Tk)/$kk(J)^C or A'(Tk)/$kk{J) = {0},fc = l , 2 , - - - ,n. Without loss of generality, we may assume that there exists an integer lj
= 1,2,-••
,lj,
and A\Tk)/$kk{J)
= {0}, k = lj +
l,---,n.
Thus, A'(T)/J
= {([Sy]j)nx„ :
S^ekerr^.
and [Skk]
=0,h
By (5.3.4), 0 = [S^R^j = [S^jSA'^/^iJ), where SijekerTT. T,, Rji£kerrT. Ti and / j - < i
A'(T)/J={
({Sij])ljxlj
0
°
0
I
OijKzK&TTrp.
rp_
Structure of Hilbert Space
162
{Claim 1}
For l
Operators
if
feerrTiiTi/$«(J)^{0} and kerTTjTJ$jk(J)^{0}, then kerTTiTk/$ik(J)
^ {0}.
Note that > l ' ( T i ) / $ « ( J ) S C and ^ ' ( ^ / ^ - ( J ^ C , l
If
fcerTTi>Ti/*o-(J)^{0}, by Corollary 5.3.6, there exist Sij&kerTTiTJ$ij(J) Sji€kerTT. Ti/$ji{J) such that SySji = [e^>(Ti)]j = 1Similarly, there exist Sjk£kerrT. T /$jk(J) and Skj&kerrT such that SjkSkj = [e^'(Tfc)]>7 = 1- Thus, SijSjk ^
and iT./$kj(J)
0 and
{Claim 2 } $U(J) ± kerrTiT, for l
^ {0},
l
and / c e r r T i | T i / * „ ( J ) = {0}, jo < j < / ^ . By Claim 1, we have kerT
Tj,Tj$ji(J)
= {0}- l<«<7'o,jo < j < / j - .
By Corollary 5.3.6, kerT^^./^jiiJ)
= {°}» 1<*<J0, Jo < J < / j .
Thus
•A'CH/J-j
^og(([5y]j) J0 xjo> ([sij}jhj-3oKh-Jo)) 0
This contradicts
° 0
'•
Sij€'ier"rTi,Tj
JGX(^'(T)).
{Claim 3 } M{T)/J^Mls{C). For l
163
The Similarity Invariant of Cowen-Douglas Operators
eij-eji = en,l
Since A'{Ti)/$u(J)=C,eiieu
&ij&ji ~ ei\BxjCj^e\i
= en. Assume that
— C^2'
and ji ij — ej\C\i€-i\&\j — Gjj.
Since for each Sij£kerTT, that
T./$ij(J)
ij
(l
==
there exists A^GC such
^ij^ij
and since
— X^ij&ji
— \ ij
"ij^iij^ij
^ij J^ii^ij
=
*-M
Sij = Xijeij. Thus the first part of the proof of Theorem 5.3.7 is now complete. lfTk~Tuk = 1,2, • • • ,n, then A'(Tk)/$kk(J)^C for all J e X CA'(T)). This completes the proof of the theorem. Theorem 5.3.7 implies the following properties. (5.3.9) If A'{TM$ii(J) JeM(A'(T)), then
?
{0} and A'^/^^J)
kerTTiiT. l*ijtf)^kerTTiiTi (5.3.10) lfA'(Ti)/$ii(J) then kerTT.iTJ$ik(J) Theorem 5.3.8
± {0} for
/^i(J)=C
= {0} for some i: l
= {0},fc= 1,2, • • • ,n.
LetT = ® Tfc, t/ien /or eoc/i Ji£M(A'(Ti)),
there is a
fc=i
unique JeM{A'{T)) such that $ U ( J ) = Jx. Proof We only prove the theorem when n = 2 and T = Ti®T%The general case can be proved similarly. By Lemma 5.3.1, there is an ideal J0 of A'(T) such that $u(J0) = Ji. Set J' = J0 + radA'{T).
164
Structure of Hilbert Space Operators
Then J' is still an ideal of A'(T) and $n(J') = Jx. By Corollary 5.3.6, radA' (T2)C.§22{J'')- Therefore we may assume that Jo = J ' , ^ ' ( T i ) / $ i 1 ( J 0 ) = C and A'{T2) / $22{JQ) is semisimple. By Theorem 4.4.3, A'{Tk)/radA'{Tk) is commutative, k = 1,2. Note that A'(T)/J0
={
Sll
S\2
Sij£kerTT,TJ
S'21 'S'22
l
Denote ekk = [eA,{Th)]j,k = 1,2. Since A'^/^uiJo^C, {Case 1 } Assume that there are ei2€kerTTiiT2/$i2(J0),
e n = 1.
e2i€kerTT2iTJ$2i{Jo)
such that ei 2 e 2 i = 1. Set Qi = e 2 iei2 and Q2 = e22 — Qi, then Qi and Q2 are idempotents in A'(T2)/$22(J0) and Q1Q2 = Q2Q1 = 0. Let
A' = { [ | ;
2 Q^ 22
: Syekerr^/S^Jo),
l
and
.4" = {
0
0
:
0 Q2S22
S22£A'(T2)/$22(Jo)}-
{Claim 1} A'(T)/J0 = A'®A". It is obvious that for each S = 5*ii
(Sij)2x2&A'{T)/J0,
S'12
+
S21 Q1S22
0
0
0 Q2S22
where S n S12 S21 Q1S22
GA'
and 0
0
0 g2s22
eA".
For Sn
S12
S'21 Q1S22
eA'
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
Operators
165
and 0
0
o g 2 5 22
eA",
we have that tr =
0
0
S12Q2S22
0
rt =
0 Q2S22S12
0 0
To verify Claim 1, we need only to show that S12Q2 — Q2S21 — 0. For arbitrary S^e/cerr^ T 2 / $ i 2 ( J o ) and S2iekerTT2 Tl/$2i(Jo), we can find a A € C such that S ^ f ^ e n = Aei2e2i. By (5.3.4), we have (S12Q2 - Aei2)ei2 = 0 and
= e12e2i(5'i2<52) = ei 2 (e 2 i5 12 (52) = 0.
Similarly, we can show that Q2S12 = 0. Thus rt = tr = 0 and this proves Claim 1. {Claim 2} A'^M2(C). Let
A, = {Sn :
SneA'inyQuiJo)}
and A = {Ql5 2 2 : 5 2 2 e>4'(r2)/*22(Jo)}. Note that *4i=C. We define a map 0 : ^ 2 — y A i as follows: 0(6) = ei 2 6e 2 i
for all 6e.4 2 -
Clearly, 0 is a homomorphism. Since
166
Structure of Hilbert Space
Then n is a homomorphism. Since A'=M2(C),
Operators
J = kern <E M{A'{T))
and
* n ( J ) = Ji. {Case 2 } If there is no ei2£kerrTi T2/$i2(Jo) and e2i£kerTT2Ti/$2i(J0) such that e 12 e 2 i = e n = 1. Since A'(Ti)/
errTir2/$12(Jo)
= {0}
and *erT^ i T l /*2i(Jo) = {0}. Thus A\T)/J0^A\Tl)/§u{JQ)®A'{T2)/<5>22{J0)^C@A'{T2)/<5>22{Jo). Similar to the proof in Case 1, we can find a JeM(A'(T))
such that
Now we prove the uniqueness. Suppose that there are J J'£M(A'(T)) such that $n(J) = $ n ( J ' ) = J i . Let J
= J + J'
Then J is an ideal of A'(T). Theorem 5.3.9
= {S + S' : SeJ,
and
S'GJ'}.
Since $ n (~J) = Jlt J = J' = ~J•
LetT = 0 Tk, then for each
SGA'(T),
fc=i
a(S)=
(J
^(S)),
jeM(T)
u//iere $ j - is a canonical map: A'(T)—>A'(T)/J,a($j(S)) is the spectrum of$j(S)inA'(T)/J. Proof We only prove the theorem when n = 2 and T = T\®T2. The general case can be proved similarly. If ^ ' ( T 1 ) / $ l x ( l 7 ) S C and A'(T2)/$22(J) = {0} for every JeM(A'(T)), then *J(S)
=
Aen 0 , 0 0
AeC
(see Theorem 5.3.8)
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
If Al{T1)/$n(J)^A'(T2)/*22(J)2iC,
Operators
167
then A l i e n Ai2ei2 A21C21 A22C22
where ei2e2i = en,e2iei2 = e22- This means that
|J
o-($j(S))ca(S).
J£M(T) If Xea(S), consider the maximal two-sided ideal J generated by - S) in A'(T), clearly \£a($j(S)) and this completes the proof of the theorem. (MH®H
2
Lemma 5.3.10 Let T = 0 Tfc, then the following are equivalent: fc=i
(i)
There exist a positive integer n and Xi€kerrT
T
, yi£kerrT
n
where i = 1,2, • • • , n , such that J2 Xit/i =
IA'(T)>
i=l
(ii) There exists an idempotent e£M„(A'(T2)) -f^'(r 1 )©°~a0®e
in
*
such that
Mn(A'(T2))\
Proof (i)=»(ii). Let 'y\
yixi [xi
••• xn]
•••
y„xi
&Mn{A'{T2)).
= _Vn^l
Vn
' ' ' yn%n _
By (i), 2/1
2/1 [xi
•••
[xi
xn]
.Vn
%n — e.
Vn.
Now set 0
0 [zi ••• xn] 0 0
0"
~yi'
0
(n+l)x(n+l) .Vn.
(n+l)x(n+l)
T
,
168
Structure of Hilbert Space
Operators
Then uv
*
Mn(A'(T2))
JU'(r,)©0 =
vu.
and
This implies that 7^ 1 ©0~ a 0©e in
(ii)=>(i). If
•4'(Zi)
*
*
M„M'(T2))
IAli
3e in '^'(Ti)
*
*
M„(^'(r2))
then by the basic properties of if-theory, we find u,v€
A'(T!) *
* M2(A'(T2))
such that /^'(T!)©0 = uv and 0©e = vu, and « = (^'(roMOQeJ.t; =
{0®e)v(IA.(Tl)).
n
Since
/A-(TI)©0
= uv, J2 xiVi = ^Aii=i
Proposition 5.3.11 Lei T = A^ and {Pi,--- , P m } be an (SI) decomposition, then m — l and Ai = A^\p-^(i)&Bn(fl). Proof We first show that m
(
Pk = (Plkj)ixi,k = 1,2,
•••,m.
Then
1>(Pk)(J) =
MP&iJVixi-
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
Operators
169
I
Denote tr{ip{Pk){J))
:= £
nk>l. Note that £
m
p
k = / a n d PkPk> = Skk,Pk, thus £ tr(iP(Pk)(J))
=I
fc=i fc=i m
m
or £ tr(*l,(Pk){J))
= £ nfc = /. Therefore m
fc=i fc=i
Now we prove that yliGi?n(^)- Otherwise, assume that AiGBk(Q,), and k < n. Let 5 = ASAi. Since k < n, a simple calculation indicates that 0
kerr.
A2,Al
°
71
keTT
.
1*
GA'(S).
By the arguments similar to that used in the proof of Theorem 5.3.7, we can find Ji€M(A'(S)) such that A'(S)/J1^C. Set T1=A®T
=
AV+1).
By Theorem 5.3.7 A'(T)/j£*Ml+1(C) for all JeM(A'(Ti)). Note that Ti=A®Ai®---®Am and m
5.4
The Commutant of a Classes of Operators
FIR algebra. Let A be a Banach algebra, n is a representation of A on a Banach space X, dimX>l, if 7r is a nontrivial continuous homomorphism from A onto C{7i). If a linear subspace y of X satisfies ir(a)ycy for all a£A, y is said to be an invariant subspace of ir{A). A representation ir is said to be irreducible if a subspace y of X satisfying n(a)ycy for all a^A is either y = {0} or y = X. An ideal J'cA is called a Primitive ideal of A if J = kern, when 7r is an irreducible representation of A. Definition 5.4.1 A Banach algebra A is called an FIR algebra if for every irreducible representation ir : A—>£(X),TT(A) is finite dimensional, i.e., dimX < oo. A Banach algebra A is said to be n-homogeneous if there
170
Structure
of Hilbert Space
is a natural number n such that representation of A.
Operators
where n is a irreducible
TX(A)=M„(C),
Definition 5.4.2 Let A be a unital Banach algebra, A is said to be essentially commutative if A/radA is commutative. P r o p o s i t i o n 5.4.3 The com/mutant of every strongly irreducible CowenDouglas operator is essentially commutative. Definition 5.4.4 Let AC(7i). A is called typical strongly irreducible operator AG(SI) and A is essentially commutative. A is called a type1 operator if A has a finite (SI) decomposition (Pi,P2,--- ,Pn) and each A\PiH *s a typical (SI) operator. P r o p o s i t i o n 5.4.5
Every Cowen-Douglas operator is a type-1 operator.
By Gelfand Theorem, we know that an essentially commutative Banach algebra is 1-homogeneous. On the other hand, every 1-homogeneous algebra is essentially commutative. In fact, we have the following stronger result. P r o p o s i t i o n 5.4.6 Let A be a unital Banach algebra and let x(-4) be the set of all nonzero multiplicative linear functionals. For x£A, r(x) denotes the spectral radius of x. Then the following are equivalent: (i) A is essentially commutative; (ii) A is 1-homogeneous; (iii) a(x) = {
p£x(A)}
'•
cr(xy) = a(yx).
o(xzy).
The Similarity
Invariant
of Cowen-Douglas
171
Operators
Note that for each n > l and 0
= a((xy)n~k~1
xyxkyk)
= a(yk{xy)n-k-1xk+1y)
a{(xy)n-k-1xk+lyk+1).
=
This implies that cr((xy)n) = a(xnyn). r(x,y) = (r((xy)n))i
a{yk{xy)n~k~lxyxk)
=
Thus
= (r(xnyn))±
= ||* n ||*||y||*.
Let n—>oo, we have r(xy)
{xi, • • • , xn}eX.
Let SeC(X),
then 5 = (Sjj)„ x „), where
Sij£C(Xi,Xj).