Sustainable Retail Development
Jerry Yudelson
Sustainable Retail Development New Success Strategies
123
ISBN 978-...
375 downloads
2769 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Sustainable Retail Development
Jerry Yudelson
Sustainable Retail Development New Success Strategies
123
ISBN 978-90-481-2781-8 e-ISBN 978-90-481-2782-5 DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2009929302 Copyright © 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Foreword
For good reason, sustainability is a word on everyone’s lips these days. Sustainability means meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.1 As such, it is an issue that will not go away, and it has consequences for every area of human endeavor, including the design, construction and operation of shopping centers and retail stores. We now know that human activities of all kinds have had a negative impact on this fragile yet remarkable planet that we call home—an impact that could challenge or even imperil the well-being of future generations. Sustainability is therefore not an issue that any of us involved in the shopping center and retail industries can afford to ignore, even during difficult business conditions. The International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC) has responded to this challenge through a variety of green initiatives and by adding green components to many of our regular meetings and conferences. Our objective is to build awareness of the importance of sustainability among our 70,000 members and to help them to create and implement their own sustainability programs. Some highlights of ICSC’s green efforts include the Sustainable Energy and Environmental Design (SEED) initiative to survey and support green construction practices; ICSC RetailGreen, a conference and trade exposition focusing solely on sustainability; various CentreBuild conferences on the challenge of sustainability; the Green Zone and Green Pavilion, showcasing product and service providers committed to the environment, at RECon, ICSC’s global retail real estate convention in Las Vegas; and publication of The RetailGreen Agenda. Additionally, the ICSC Environmental Sub-Committee, the European Sustainability Working Group and other committees perform sterling service in identifying how green policies and practices impact the shopping center industry. Another very important step in helping our members on their journey to a more sustainable future was the September 2007 appointment of Jerry Yudelson, a highly regarded expert in the field of green buildings and marketing, as Research Scholar 1 Definition coined by the United Nations Brundtland Commission. See Report of the World Com-
mission on Environment and Development (The Brundtland Commission), Our Common Future (London: Oxford University Press, 1987). Definition is also available at http://habitat.igc.org/opengates/ocf-02.htm#I, retrieved February 11, 2009.
v
vi
Foreword
for Retail Real Estate Sustainability. As part of this research scholarship, Jerry has written Sustainable Retail Development, a comprehensive and practical guide for all those involved in conceptualizing and executing an agenda for developing and operating sustainable shopping centers and retail stores. Jerry has provided a wealth of detail about the sustainability programs and current best practices of those shopping center developers and retailers worldwide that are today’s leaders in green retail buildings. Even more importantly, Sustainable Retail Development also provides a ten-point program that any company in these industries—big or small—can follow. This is a book for all professionals involved in retail real estate design, construction and operations, as well as investors in the industry. As you will see as you turn the pages, Jerry has thrown down the gauntlet and is challenging the retail real estate and retail industries to do more to tread lightly on this fair Earth by increasing their commitment to developing and operating green shopping centers and retail stores. I encourage you to take up this challenge. I believe that Jerry’s book provides you with an invaluable reference that will help you to succeed in designing, constructing and operating high-performance, sustainable shopping centers and stores. Michael P. Kercheval President and Chief Executive Officer International Council of Shopping Centers
Preface
Throughout the early part of this decade, as interest in green buildings began to grow dramatically in the United States, Canada, Australia, the United Kingdom and other countries, especially in public buildings and commercial offices, on university campuses and the nonprofit sector, I wondered when the retail sector would catch on to the trend toward sustainable design and development. After all, the retail sector is closest to the consumer, and the consumer in these countries has been environmentally conscious for a long time. The International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC) gave me a two-year appointment in 2007 as its Research Scholar for Real Estate Sustainability. In addition to preparing research reports and speaking at ICSC events, I benefited from introductions to many of the leaders in this very large and important industry. After all, in 2007 retail development was the second-largest commercial building sector in the U.S., behind only office construction. In the U.S., the leading green building and green development rating system is LEED, the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design program introduced in 2000 by the U.S. Green Building Council. In the U.K., the BREEAM system (Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method) has been certifying buildings since the mid-1990s. By the end of 2008, the number of non-residential buildings certified by both systems totaled more than 3,000, yet the number of retail buildings certified was less than 100 and most of those had come from the “volume certification” of a handful of retailers, including one bank and one grocery chain. There were also a few shopping centers certified by the end of 2008, mostly developer-controlled smaller buildings (“in-line shops”) housing multiple retailers. Why has the retail sector been relatively slow to adopt sustainability measures and to embrace the worldwide movement toward green buildings and sustainable development? There are several reasons. First, there is the split in incentives between developers and retailers. In many enclosed shopping centers with a central power supply, the developer pays most of the up-front capital costs, while operating cost savings accrue primarily to the tenants. To date, developers have not been able to recover these investments through higher rents. The same situation prevails in openair or “lifestyle” centers, where the individual large retailer is responsible for most of the design and construction activity.
vii
viii
Preface
There is a third actor in this drama, the consumer. While people have been willing to pay more for “green” products and there are a number of retailers with such offerings, there is little empirical evidence that “green” shopping centers or “green” retailers will attract greater numbers of shoppers. Without some evidence for increased consumer demand, there is little direct incentive for developers and retailers to invest extra money in green measures. Yet, sustainable retail development is happening all over the world. What’s going on? That is precisely what this book seeks to answer. What are the business reasons for retailers and developers going green? What are the difficulties? Which companies are showing the way? What are they learning as they pursue sustainability initiatives? What’s the upshot? What can you learn from some of the early experiments with green design and corporate sustainability? One takeaway lesson is that the retail sector has been late responding to developments in green building design and sustainable development. There is a worldwide tidal wave of concern about global warming and other ecological issues that retailers ignore at the peril of their long-term business interests. In the near future, it is likely that governments worldwide will be pushing everyone in commercial building development and operations to lower the environmental impact of their projects, beginning with reductions in direct and indirect carbon dioxide generation. In this sense, the future will be dramatically different from the present—especially with respect to carbon emissions. Starting with zero-net carbon emissions as the goal will radically change retail building design and construction, as well as product and technology selection, and that is one key lesson to learn from this book. Throughout this book, you’ll see interviews with various leaders in retail sustainability and profiles of successful projects. This group of people and projects was chosen to be representative, not exhaustive, and to cover a wide range of green development and sustainability initiatives. I have tried to avoid being too “U.S.— centric” in my approach and examples, recognizing that my experience has been mostly in the U.S. and Canada. I can only ask for the reader’s tender mercy in this regard. Instead, I hope you will focus instead on the broader message of this book— sustainability matters—and that you will be encouraged to duplicate and extend the many good examples profiled in this book. My goal is to get you started down the path toward sustainable retail development, by helping you learn from those leading the way and by introducing a tenpoint framework that any company can adopt to dramatically reorient its business toward long-term sustainability. At the global level, we’re all in this together. Why not get good at it? I truly hope that this book will help you in that endeavor. Tucson, Arizona June 2009
Jerry Yudelson
Acknowledgments
I want to acknowledge all of the architects, engineers, planners and developers who met with me and who provided information for this book. I’m especially thankful to Michael Kercheval, President and CEO of ICSC, for writing the Foreword and to Michael Niemira, Director of Research for ICSC, for sponsoring this work. Thanks also to Angela Jameson of ICSC for her multifaceted assistance with this book. Thanks are due to Ermine Amies, Managing Director of the ICSC Europe office in the U.K. and operations in India, for assisting with the research effort and for inviting me to speak to the inaugural CentreBuild Europe conference in London in 2008. Thanks to Arco Rehorst of the Netherlands’ Multi Development for arranging a guided tour of Multi’s BREEAM-certified shopping center in Duisburg, Germany (with the company’s CEO for Germany, Alex Funke), to Alexander Otto of ECE for sponsoring my presentation to the ULI Germany in 2008 and to the many developers and retailers in the U.K., Germany, the Netherlands, Portugal and Austria who shared an hour or more of their precious time, along with expertise and insights, in providing interviews and responding to email surveys. Those design and development professionals in the U.S., Australia, Canada, Japan, Europe and the Middle East who agreed to be interviewed for this book also deserve special thanks. A special thanks to Thomas Saunders of the U.K.’s BRE Trust for keeping me up to date on the progress of the BREEAM program. I owe a special recognition to Jaimie Galayda, research director at Yudelson Associates, who prepared the Appendix comparing various international green building rating systems and also provided research and writing for some of the case studies. Thanks to Cyrus KhoshChasm for additional case study research. I would also like to thank the reviewers of the manuscript: Filipa Fernandes, Thomas Saunders and Amber d’Este-Hoare of BRE, Joyce Kelly, Erik Ring, Lauren Yarmuth, and Justin Doak. Thanks also to ICSC for permission to use material that previously appeared in Research Review. Many thanks also to Gretel Hakanson, my editorial associate and chief interviewer. This is our seventh green building book together in the past three years, and her contribution grows with each project. Thanks also to my wife, Jessica, for putting up with all my globetrotting to put this book together.
ix
x
Acknowledgments
Thanks to Heidi Ziegler-Voll of Creative Tornado for providing illustrations for this book and to Professor Ulf Meyer for providing a critical review of the draft manuscript. I owe a final thanks to the many people who participated in interviews, provided expert guidance, helped with arranging project visits and provided photos and renderings for this book, as well as those who served as reviewers and critics. Though this work is sponsored by the ICSC, the opinions in this book are mine alone, but without the help of many thoughtful and sharing colleagues, I wouldn’t have known where to start and, more importantly, how to finish this book.
Contents
List of Figures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xvii
List of Tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xxi
Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxiii 1 Sustainability Matters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1 Multi Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.1 Multi’s Sustainability Principles . . . . . . . 1.1.2 Turning Principles into Development Activity 1.1.3 Getting the Company on Board . . . . . . . . 1.1.4 Getting the Customers on Board . . . . . . . 1.2 Sonae Sierra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.1 Sustainability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2.2 Implementation Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 Marks and Spencer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.1 Beyond Environmentalism . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.2 2008 Plan A Update . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Regency Centers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.1 Branding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.2 Training . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.3 Capital Allocation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.4 Developing a Sustainability Program . . . . . 1.4.5 Taking a Larger Perspective . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.6 Progress . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 4 4 5 6 7 7 8 11 12 13 13 14 15 15 16 16 17 17 18 18
2 Green Buildings Around the World . 2.1 Why Retail Should Go Green . 2.2 North American Case Studies . 2.2.1 Developer Case Studies 2.2.2 Retailer Case Studies . 2.3 United Kingdom (U.K.) . . . . 2.3.1 Cabot Circus . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
21 22 23 23 27 29 29
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
xi
xii
Contents
2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9
Austria . . . . . . . . Japan . . . . . . . . . Australia . . . . . . . Turkey . . . . . . . . Singapore . . . . . . . China . . . . . . . . . 2.9.1 LeSong Mall . 2.9.2 Central Walk 2.10 Summary . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
32 33 34 35 36 37 37 38 39 39
3 What Is a Green Building? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Green Buildings Since 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 High-Performance Building Characteristics . . . . . . 3.3 Green Building Practices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 The LEED Rating Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 LEED for New Construction . . . . . . . . . 3.4.2 LEED for Core and Shell Buildings . . . . . 3.4.3 LEED for Commercial Interiors . . . . . . . 3.4.4 LEED for Existing Buildings: Operations and Maintenance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.5 LEED for Neighborhood Development . . . . 3.5 Typical Green Building Measures . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 To LEED or to Lead? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6.1 Building Commissioning . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6.2 Low-Toxicity Finishes . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7 LEED for Retail . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.8 The Future of High-Performance Buildings in the U.S. 3.9 Non-U.S. Green Building Rating Systems . . . . . . . 3.9.1 BREEAM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.10 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
41 41 43 45 46 49 50 51
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
51 52 53 55 55 56 57 58 59 60 64 64
4 The Business Case for Green Retail . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 Who Benefits and Who Pays? . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 The Developer’s Perspective . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.1 The Entitlement Process . . . . . . . . . 4.2.2 Cost Offsets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.3 Tax and Other Incentives in the U.S. . . . 4.2.4 Renewable Energy Incentives in the U.S. . 4.3 Branding and Marketing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Case Study—First Capital Realty, Toronto, Canada 4.4.1 Business Case Factors . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2 Financial and Nonfinancial Incentives . . 4.4.3 Challenges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
67 67 68 70 70 71 71 71 72 72 72 73
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
Contents
xiii
4.5
The Retailer’s Perspective . . . . . . . . . 4.5.1 Reputation Capital . . . . . . . . 4.5.2 CFOs Going Green . . . . . . . . 4.6 Six Key Areas of Focus for Green Retailing 4.7 Consumer Demand . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8 Challenges for Greening the Retail Sector . 4.8.1 Tenant Guidelines . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
73 74 74 75 75 76 76 77
5 Costs of Greening Buildings and Developments . 5.1 Barriers to Green Building Growth . . . . . . 5.2 Hard and Soft Cost Elements . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Cost Drivers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.1 Design Team Capabilities . . . . . . 5.3.2 Design Process and Scope . . . . . 5.4 The Cost of Learning to Be Green . . . . . . 5.5 Cost of a Developer’s Sustainability Initiative 5.6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
79 80 81 83 83 83 84 85 86 86
6 Solar Power . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1 The Solar Power Movement . . . . . 6.2 Solar Technology . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 The Current Market . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Economics of PV Solar Power . . . . 6.5 Financial Benefits of PV Solar Power 6.6 Noneconomic Benefits of Solar Power 6.7 The Solar Services Model . . . . . . 6.8 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
87 87 90 90 92 93 95 95 96 96
7 Greening Shopping Centers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1 European Green Building Programs . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1 SES SPAR European Shopping Centers, Austria 7.1.2 Forum Duisburg, Germany . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.3 ECE, Germany . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.4 PRUPIM, U.K. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.5 Redevco, U.K. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 North America . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 Uptown Monterey Shopping Center, Monterey, California . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 Green Circle Shopping Center, Springfield, Missouri . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3 Station Park Green, San Mateo, California . . . 7.2.4 Northgate Mall Redevelopment, San Rafael, California . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
99 99 99 101 102 103 105 106
. . . .
107
. . . . . . . .
107 107
. . . .
108
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
xiv
Contents
7.2.5
Tanger Outlet Center at the Arches, Deer Park, New York . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
110 110 111
8 Greening Retail Buildings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1 Wal-Mart Case Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2 LEED Certification for New and Renovated Retail Buildings 8.2.1 Sustainable Site Features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.2 Water Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.3 Energy Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.4 Materials and Resource Conservation . . . . . . . . 8.2.5 Indoor Environmental Quality . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.6 Daylighting and Retail Sales . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.7 LEED Project Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3 Case Study—Target, McKinley Park, Chicago . . . . . . . . 8.4 Case Study—Kohl’s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 Case Study—SUBWAY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.6 Case Study—ASDA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.7 Case Study—The John Lewis Partnership . . . . . . . . . . 8.8 Case Study—Tesco . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.1 Sustainability Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.8.2 Cutting Carbon Dioxide Emissions . . . . . . . . . 8.9 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
113 113 116 116 117 117 119 119 120 121 122 122 123 124 124 125 126 126 127 127
9 Greening Retail Interiors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1 LEED for Commercial Interiors . . . . . . . . 9.1.1 Sustainable Site Features . . . . . . . 9.1.2 Water Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.3 Energy Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.4 Materials and Resource Conservation . 9.1.5 Indoor Environmental Quality . . . . 9.2 Wachovia Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 Grocery Store Remodel . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Operating Green Retail Spaces . . . . . . . . . . 10.1 Sustainable Site Management . . . . . . . . 10.1.1 Exterior and Site Maintenance . . . 10.1.2 Reducing Single-Occupant Auto Use 10.1.3 Open Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.4 Stormwater Management . . . . . . 10.1.5 Urban Heat Island Effect . . . . . . 10.1.6 Light Pollution Reduction . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
129 129 129 130 130 131 132 133 134 135 135
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
137 137 138 138 140 140 140 141
Contents
xv
10.2
11
12
Water Conservation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Indoor Water Conservation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Water Metering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.3 Water-Efficient Landscaping . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.4 Cooling Tower Water Conservation . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Energy Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.1 Reducing Energy Consumption . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.2 Building Commissioning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.3 Renewable Energy Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.4 Emission Reduction Reporting . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Materials and Resources Conservation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.1 Sustainable Purchasing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.2 Purchasing Consumables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.3 Purchasing Durable Goods and Facility Alterations . . 10.4.4 Low-Mercury Lamps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.5 Responsible Waste Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.6 The Waste Stream Audit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.7 Ongoing Consumables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.8 Durable Goods Recycling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4.9 Waste Disposal from Tenant Improvements and Store Remodels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Indoor Environment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5.1 Green Cleaning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5.2 Maintaining Air Quality During Construction . . . . . 10.5.3 Occupant Comfort . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6 Case Study—Stop & Shop . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6.1 The Business Case for Ahold/Stop & Shop . . . . . . . 10.6.2 What Did Stop & Shop Do for LEED-EB Certification? 10.7 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
142 142 142 142 143 143 144 145 145 145 146 146 146 147 147 147 148 148 148
Marketing Sustainable Retail Development . . . . . 11.1 Four Key Marketing Steps for Sustainable Retail 11.1.1 Differentiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.1.2 Become a Low-cost Provider of Green Developments and Green Retail Stores . 11.1.3 Focused Differentiation . . . . . . . . . 11.1.4 Name It and Claim It . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 Build a Brand Image . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.1 Green Power . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3 Sustainability Marketing as an Evolving Strategy References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
157 158 158
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
159 160 161 161 163 164 165
Sustainable Retail Organizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.1 CEO Leadership . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2 Communications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
167 167 167
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
148 149 149 150 150 150 152 152 154 154
xvi
Contents
12.3 Education and Training . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.4 Knowledge Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.5 Corporate Operations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.6 Case Study—SES Spar European Shopping Centers 12.7 The Sustainability Report . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.8 The Long-Term Benefit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.9 Creating a Sustainability Program . . . . . . . . . . 12.10 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
169 170 171 172 173 174 174 176 177
The Ten-Point Program for Retail Sustainability . . . . . . . . . . 13.1 Looking to the Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
179 185 187
Appendix A: Green Building Rating Systems Around the World A.1 Australia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.2 Canada . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.3 France . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.4 Germany . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.5 Hong Kong . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.6 Japan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.7 United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.8 United States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
189 189 191 191 192 192 193 195 196
Author Biography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
207
About the ICSC Research Scholar Program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
208
About SEED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
208
About the International Council of Shopping Centers . . . . . . . . . .
209
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
211
List of Figures
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 2.1 2.2 2.3
2.4 2.5
2.6 2.7 2.8
The U.S. retail sector accounts for 20% of the country’s total site energy use by commercial buildings . . . . . . . . . . . . The triple bottom line concept blends economic, social and ecological criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Forum Duisburg is the first BREEAM Very Good rated center on the European continent . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sonae Sierra’s corporate sustainability program is based on an ISO 14001 Environmental Management System . . . . . . The Rio Sul shopping center is one of Sonae Sierra’s showcase environmental projects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marks & Spencer’s Galashiels store is one of the chain’s many green buildings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Forest City’s Northfield Stapleton development was the first “lifestyle” center to be LEED-Silver certified in the U.S. . . . Abercorn Common in Savannah, Georgia, was the first LEED-certified center in the U.S. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Morningside Crossing, Toronto’s first LEED-compliant shopping center, is one of 30 projects for which the developer, First Capital Realty, plans to pursue LEED certification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cabot Circus in Bristol, U.K., is a green retail project from Hammerson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The £350 million Highcross shopping center in Leicester, U.K., is a significant contribution to a city revitalization project and is rated Very Good by the BREEAM rating system AEON shopping center in Laketown, Japan, received high marks from that country’s CASBEE rating system . . . . . . . Orion Springfield is Australia’s first Green Star rated shopping center . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The 30,000-m2 green roof on Metro Development’s Meydan center in Istanbul, Turkey, not only offers a space to linger but also helps control the building’s internal climate . . . . . .
. . .
3
. . .
3
. . .
5
. . .
8
. . .
10
. . .
14
. . .
24
. . .
25
. . .
27
. . .
30
. . .
31
. . .
33
. . .
34
. . .
36
xvii
xviii
2.9 2.10 3.1 3.2
3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
3.9
4.1 6.1 6.2 7.1 7.2 7.3
7.4
7.5
List of Figures
City Square Mall in Singapore was the first such development to be awarded the government’s platinum Green Mark . Central Walk shopping mall, opened in 2007 in Shenzhen, China . . The growth of new LEED registered projects in the U.S. has consistently grown at more than 50% per annum . . . . . . . . . . LEED for New Construction and Major Renovations distributes its points across six different environmental attributes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An example of a “LEED Scorecard” showing points garnered by this LEED Gold-rated Office Depot project . . . . . . . LEED for Core and Shell can be used for shell retail spaces . . . . LEED for Commercial Interiors rating system can be used for store remodels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LEED-EBOM allows developers and retailers to benchmark performance against established criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Improving indoor air quality leads to major reductions in health symptoms, improving overall employee productivity . . . . . The new BREEAM for Retail system will allow a closer match of green building criteria to specific retailer design and construction practices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BREEAM for Retail Interiors provides retailers with green design criteria for individual store remodels and new construction inside of malls and shell retail spaces . . . . . . . . . The benefits of green retail spaces encompass five major areas of interest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wal-Mart was a pioneer in using extensive rooftop area for solar power generation, as shown by this project in California . . . . This Office Depot store in Austin, Texas, uses solar power to offset a portion of store electricity needs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . EUROPARK in Salzburg, Austria, is an award-winning green retail development from SES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The ATRIO Center in Villach, Austria, connects that country with nearly Slovenia and Italy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ECE shopping centers receive a total of about 155 million kWh per year of hydroelectric power. Ernst-August-Galerie in Hanover is one of 48 ECE shopping centers participating in the company’s green energy initiative . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Redevco plans to assess its retail developments in Europe according to green building rating standards; 40 Princess Street in Edinburgh was the first Redevco building to receive BREEAM certification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The 23,000-ft2 Green Circle Shopping Center in Springfield, Missouri, is the first shopping center in the U.S. pursuing a Platinum-level LEED certification. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
37 39 42
47 48 51 52 53 56
62
63 69 88 91 100 101
102
106
108
List of Figures
7.6
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4
9.1 9.2 9.3
10.1 10.2
10.3
12.1 12.2
13.1 13.2 13.3 A.1
The Tanger Outlet Center at the Arches on New York’s Long Island transformed a former industrial site into a 800,000-ft2 open-air mall . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Energy use in retail stores varies dramatically by end-use and type of activity, as shown by the annual energy use index (EUI) . Falabella’s center in Chile aims to become the first LEED-certified shopping center in South America . . . . . . . . . . Chipotle Mexican Grill shows that even small quick service restaurants can achieve LEED certification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A variety of studies over the past decade strongly suggest that using skylights to increase daylighting in stores can increase retail sales significantly . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marks & Spencer’s Bournemouth store is one of the chain’s many green building projects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Office Depot uses skylights as well as signage to tell customers about their green commitment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wachovia Bank was the first to receive “volume certification” under the U.S. Green Building Council’s LEED for Commercial Interiors program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Alexa center in Berlin, Germany, is another of Sonae Sierra’s green projects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Best Buy, Dick’s Sporting Goods and PetSmart are tenants in the $400 million, 100,000-ft2 Stafford Park shopping center in New Jersey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stop & Shop is the first U.S. grocery chain to use the LEED-EB program to benchmark performance at more than 50 stores . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Corporate sustainability programs typically contain all of these five elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Woolworths made a major commitment to green construction and operations in South Africa with their Midrand distribution center . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The benefits of adopting sustainable retail solutions are multifaceted and long-lasting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Freccia Rossa is a green shopping center in Brescia, Italy . . . . . . Communicating your sustainability progress is an essential part of every successful program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Australia’s Green Star program is a credible rating system used also in New Zealand and South Africa . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xix
110 115 117 118
120 130 132
134 139
144
151 168
169 180 181 184 190
List of Tables
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 4.1 4.2 5.1 5.2 5.3 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 8.1 11.1 12.1 12.2 A.1 A.2 A.3 A.4 A.5 A.6
Growth of All LEED Project Registrations, 2004–2008 . . . . LEED-NC Certifications by Attainment Level, December 2008 LEED-NC 2009 System Categories of Concern . . . . . . . . The Major LEED Rating Systems for Commercial Buildings, December 2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Use of LEED Credits in Gold and Platinum Projects . . . . . BREEAM Certifications, Non-domestic Buildings, 2004–2008 2008 BREEAM Rating Categories and Weightings . . . . . . Potential Business Benefits of Green Retail Centers and Stores . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Who Benefits? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hard Costs for Greening Retail Projects (U.S. Experience) . . Soft Costs for Greening Building Projects (U.S., 2008 Estimates) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Green Building Initiatives—An Example of Estimated Costs ($ millions) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Economics of PV Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Average Cost in Cents/kWh over 20 Years for Solar Power Panels Production (kWh/kw-Peak/Year) . . . . . . . . . . . . Financial Benefits to PV System Owners . . . . . . . . . . . Noneconomic or Intangible PV System Benefits . . . . . . . . Considerations in Purchasing Solar Power from Investment Partnerships . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LEED-NC Points Achieved for Several Retail Stores . . . . . Top Ten Purchasers of Green Power in the U.S., 2008 . . . . . Corporate Departments Engaged in Sustainability Task Force . Key Functional Areas for Sustainability Planning . . . . . . . Australian Green Star Rating Levels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . French HQE Targets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . HK-BEAM Performance Categories and Available Points . . . HK-BEAM Rating Levels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BEE Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CASBEE Grades . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
42 43 46
. . . .
. . . .
49 54 60 61
. . . . . . . . .
68 69 81
. . .
82
. . . . . .
85 92
. . . . . . . . .
92 94 94
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
96 121 164 175 176 190 192 193 194 194 195 xxi
xxii
A.7 A.8 A.9
BREEAM 2008 Sections and Weights . . . . . . . . . . . BREEAM Ratings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Credit Categories and Points for LEED for Retail: New Construction 2009 Rating System . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.10 Comparison of Credit Categories and Points Across LEED Rating Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
List of Tables
. . . . . . . . . .
195 196
. . . . .
198
. . . . .
200
Abbreviations
AIA ASHRAE AuSSI BAS BCA BIM BIPV BRE BREEAM CaGBC CAM CASBEE CBI CDI CDLI CFL CFCs CRS CSO CSR DGNB DOE EMS EPCs EPBD EPI EPP ESCO
American Institute of Architects American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers Australian SAM Sustainability Index Building Automation System Building and Construction Authority (Singapore) Building Information Modeling Building-Integrated Photovoltaics Building Research Establishment (U.K.) Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method (U.K.) Canada Green Building Council Common Area Maintenance Comprehensive Assessment System for Building Environmental Efficiency (Japan) Commercial Building Initiative, U.S. Department of Energy City Developments Limited (Singapore) Climate Disclosure Leadership Index (Carbon Disclosure Project, U.K.) Compact Fluorescent Light Chlorofluorocarbons Center for Resource Solutions (U.S.) Chief Sustainability Officer Corporate Social Responsibility Deutsche Gesellschaft für Nachhaltiges Bauen (German Sustainable Building Council) U.S. Department of Energy Environmental Management System, see also ISO 14001 Energy Performance Certificates (European Union) Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (European Union) Environmental Performance Indicator Environmentally Preferable Purchasing Energy Service Company xxiii
xxiv
ESRD ETS FSC ft2 GBCA GRI GSBC Ha HCFCs HK-BEAM HQE HVAC IAQ ICSC IEQ ISO JaGBC JSBC kW kWh kWp LCC LED R LEED LEED-CI LEED-CS LEED-EBOM LEED-NC LOHAS lm-h m2 m3 MACRS M&S NPV Pg PR PV RECs RMB ROI SRI
Abbreviations
Environmental Standards for Retail Development (Sonae Sierra) Environmental Tobacco Smoke Forest Stewardship Council Square Foot/Feet Green Building Council of Australia Global Reporting Initiative German Sustainable Building Certificate, see also DGNB Hectare Hydrochlorofluorocarbons Hong Kong Building Environmental Assessment Method Haute Qualité Environnementale (French Green Building Rating System) Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning Indoor Air Quality International Council of Shopping Centers Indoor Environmental Quality International Standards Organization, also ISO 14001 Japan Green Building Council Japan Sustainable Building Consortium Kilowatt Kilowatt-Hour Kilowatt (Peak) rated output, used only for photovoltaics (PV) Life-Cycle Costing Light-Emitting Diode R Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED for Commercial Interiors LEED for Core and Shell LEED for Existing Buildings – Operations and Maintenance LEED for New Construction Lifestyles of Health and Sustainability Lumen-hours (used only in calculation of mercury concentration in lamps) Square Meter(s)/Metre(s) Cubic Meter(s)/Metre(s) Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (U.S.) Marks & Spencer Net Present Value Picograms, or “one millionth-millionth” of a gram Public Relations Photovoltaic Renewable Energy Certificates (U.S.) Renminbi (Chinese currency) Return on Investment Solar Reflectance Index
Abbreviations
StEP TOD USGBC VOC
xxv
Solving the E-Waste Problem (United Nations) Transit-Oriented Development U.S. Green Building Council Volatile Organic Compound
Chapter 1
Sustainability Matters
Sustainability, like quality, doesn’t cost; it pays. In all my business experience, I have never seen a more powerful differentiator in the marketplace [1]. —Ray Anderson, Founder and Chairman of Interface, Inc., 2007 sales: $1.1 billion
What is sustainability and why does it matter to the retailer and developer? We’ve heard about corporate social responsibility (CSR) for years. How does this differ from the current discussion about sustainability? One way to think about it is this: Sustainability refers to being responsive to the entire web of living systems inside of which we live and work, whereas CSR primarily pays attention to social obligations (government regulations, worker well-being and consumer demands). One definition of CSR describes it as comprising “two elements: acting as a good corporate citizen, attuned to the evolving social concerns of stakeholders, and mitigating existing or anticipated adverse effects from business activities” [2]. For many business leaders, CSR has become a primary way to secure a long-run competitive advantage. The classic definition of sustainability comes from the U.N.’s Brundtland Commission report of 1987: “Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” [3]. This definition clearly speaks to the long-term, overriding issue of sustainability: we should be living off of income and not stored capital. In other words, our society should be striving to live off of renewable resources and not one-time resources. What’s driving the current push toward corporate sustainability? There are a number of factors. Many companies are responding to customer (demand) pull, supplier push, European regulations (like the Registry of Hazardous Substances, or RoHS) and their own internal stakeholders in creating sustainability offices and hiring or appointing “chief sustainability officers.” There is also a strategic desire to “get ahead of any future legislation” that might regulate such things as carbon emissions. Creating sustainability offices is also the best way to formalize and centralize disparate efforts in various business units and locations [4]. One magazine survey indicated that 25% of Fortune 500 companies expected to appoint chief sustainability officers in 2008 [4]. One pundit, Marc Epstein, reported J. Yudelson, Sustainable Retail Development, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5_1, C 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers Copyright
1
2
1 Sustainability Matters
that “Companies are currently looking to get past the regulatory and compliance aspect of this. The companies that get it are beginning to look at the growth that can come about as a result of sustainability.” In spite of the current economic recession, one leading sustainability consultant, Gil Friend of Natural Logic, cites several reasons why U.S. companies continue to show strong interest in sustainability [5]. • Reduce energy costs for ongoing operations. • Mitigate risk of future regulation of carbon emissions. • Take advantage of opportunities that will arise due to the Obama administration’s commitment to green issues. • Well-designed sustainability initiatives often have a really attractive return on investment. The downturn is prompting many businesses and their customers to reevaluate their value propositions and priorities. This reassessment goes hand in hand with increasing eco-efficiency and creating long-term value through sustainable jobs and renewable energy sources [5]. One important and perhaps overriding issue in sustainability relates to the buildup of human-produced carbon dioxide in the Earth’s atmosphere. The Fourth Assessment Report of the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, issued in 2007, put the probability of human-induced global warming at 90%, up from 67% in the previous Third Report, issued in 2001 [6, 7]. Reducing carbon dioxide emissions in the building sector is critical to our ability to combat global warming. Energy-efficient design and operations of buildings, along with on-site renewable energy production, represent one important response to the challenge to people all over the world to reduce our collective ecological footprint.1 Green buildings are an important component in the effort to bring carbon dioxide emissions back to 1990 levels, as required by the Kyoto Protocol, so that we can begin to stabilize carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere at levels no more than 20% above today’s. Recent studies by the international consulting firm McKinsey indicate that buildings can provide up to 25% of the required carbon emission reductions, requiring costs that can be easily recovered over the life of the building [8, 9]. Retail matters in global warming emissions. Figure 1.1 shows that retail stores and centers account for 20% of site carbon emissions in the U.S., a considerable amount by anyone’s reckoning. To combat global warming, and for other reasons discussed in this book, environmental sustainability is firmly on the global corporate agenda, and is beginning to make a stronger impression in the retail real estate development industry. There are many paths that shopping center developers and owners can take as they create and execute a sustainability program internally and externally. This chapter presents four representative sustainability programs in depth, two undertaken by large shopping 1 See
www.footprintnetwork.org for a fuller explanation of the term ecological footprint.
1
Sustainability Matters
3
Fig. 1.1 The U.S. retail sector accounts for 20% of the country’s total site energy use by commercial buildings. Source: Govt Chart: www.nrel.gov/docs/fy08osti/41956.pdf
center developers based in continental Europe, one by a large U.K.-based retailer and one by a U.S.-based developer. Their varied approaches may give guidance to others launching a sustainability program. Each corporate sustainability program involves considerations of the triple bottom line, concern for economy, environment and ethics (the “three Es”) or people, planet and profit (the “three Ps”), shown in Fig. 1.2. The triple bottom line is a good conceptual way to present the topic of corporate social responsibility within
Fig. 1.2 The triple bottom line concept blends economic, social and ecological criteria
4
1 Sustainability Matters
the larger context of development issues. In this view, each company should pursue activities that create economic benefit, while simultaneously improving (or at least not adversely impacting) the natural environment and providing significant benefits for society. In our research for this book, we found that the European developers are more open in their consideration of the people or ethics aspect of the Triple Bottom Line, viewing business as having an important social mission in their countries, as well as a profit-making one.
1.1 Multi Development Multi Corporation B.V. is headquartered in Gouda, the Netherlands, and is active in 23 countries throughout Europe, extending from the United Kingdom to Turkey [10]. In 2007, Multi was named European Retail Developer of the Year at the MAPIC conference in Cannes [11]. CEO Glenn Aaronson is a firm believer in changing the world via the “2% solution,” making things 2% better every year, instead of trying to make huge leaps all at once. He believes that any corporation can handle 2% change, such as 2% higher costs for green buildings and 2% per year improvement in results. In the space of 10 years, he notes, “you’re then 20% better, and it’s virtually painless.” In his view, the solution to the challenge of achieving sustainability is “getting better” all the time, the well-known approach of continuous improvement. The issue of course is how to audit the changes to make sure that the 2% change is happening each year, without backsliding.
1.1.1 Multi’s Sustainability Principles Aaronson has led the charge at Multi toward incorporating sustainability into every aspect of the company’s operations. The first shopping center to use the company’s sustainability principles was built in Duisburg, Germany, and opened in the fall of 2008 (shown in Fig. 1.3). The project received a Very Good rating from the U.K.’s BREEAM system (see Chapter 3 for a fuller discussion of BREEAM). Multi has formalized its sustainability commitment into five key principles, known as the “5Es for a Sustainable Future” program: 1. Everlasting Design—design should aim at creating flexible and timeless urban spaces that will hold their value far into the future; 2. Ecological Footprint—each project should optimize the use of land and reduce the consumption of resources, by both constructing new buildings more effectively and managing existing buildings more efficiently; 3. Equal Benefits—each project should provide benefits to the local community, through a variety of giveback programs;
1.1
Multi Development
5
Fig. 1.3 Forum Duisburg is the first BREEAM Very Good rated center on the European continent
4. Economic Vitality—each project should aim to create healthy business environments to ensure financial sustainability; 5. Education for All—each project should raise public awareness of the changes required to preserve our planet. Multi’s five principles are its own customized version of the traditional triple bottom line such as the 3 Ps—people, planet and profit—or the “3 Es”—environment, economy and ethics. The five principles also contain operational criteria that reflect Aaronson’s belief that if a company holds strong beliefs internally— in this case about sustainability—it is also important to express these values externally.
1.1.2 Turning Principles into Development Activity With the right focus on customer, shopper, employee and community benefits, appropriate to time and place, it is relatively straightforward to craft a set of operating guidelines for future development and to begin filling in the outline with specific green features. A statement of core values such as the 5 Es begins to suggest synergies to the design team. For example, a focus on light and daylighting immediately integrates with energy efficiency considerations. Studies of daylighting in retail show gains in sales of about 5% but also energy savings of about 10% of initial investment per
6
1 Sustainability Matters
year.2 Appropriate transport connections begin to reduce the carbon footprint of the development by encouraging more public transit and pedestrian access. Aaronson strongly supports the use of BREEAM, the U.K. green building assessment and certification standard for shopping centers in the European Union.3 Aaronson believes that BREEAM is more flexible than other systems such as LEED, that it can be customized to fit many different development situations and that it is focused appropriately on the social dimension of development, in addition to obvious considerations such as water and energy use. One interesting approach adopted by Multi is to use each shopping center as a forum for education about sustainability by creating an educational focus in each center. In the case of the Forum Duisburg project, there is a social program that trains disadvantaged citizens in construction and center operations, in cooperation with the local municipality. Consisting of 59,000 m2 of gross leasable area (GLA), the project cost about C170 million and includes a district heating plant using combined heat and power systems, a green roof and insulation well above standard [12].
1.1.3 Getting the Company on Board Multi has gone through a progression of steps to reach its current level of commitment to sustainable development activities. This sequence may prove to be typical for many retail developers. Under Arco Rehorst’s leadership, a Sustainability Committee was created in 2006, followed in 2007 by a strong CEO commitment to move forward with the committee’s recommendations. Rehorst and the committee started with a long list of possible topics, some 63 in all, narrowing them down to the top 12 to create a focus for future work. From these points of focus came a calendar with a specific focus for each month. In 2008, the firm began regular videoconferencing with its 20 country managers, to bring them up to speed on the commitment and the program. The company is already a big fan of ISO 14001, the international environmental management standard. The goal is to improve sustainability achievements with each succeeding project, and to this end, management believes that it is important to set aspiration levels at the outset of a project and then score performance against these levels. Each new investment proposal submitted to management now becomes an “investment plus sustainability” proposal in that it details the sustainability achieve-
2 See
2003 studies by the Heschong Mahone Group, sponsored by California’s Pacific Gas & Electric Company, available at http://www.h-m-g.com/downloads/Daylighting/A-5_Daylgt_ Retail_2.3.7.pdf, accessed June 13, 2008. 3 This position was adopted in 2008 by the ICSC for all European projects.
1.2
Sonae Sierra
7
ments that it targets. Each new development will carry tenant guidelines, for example, to set green cleaning standards. The purpose of this approach is to transform investment decisions over time, by encouraging development executives to change what they consider to be appropriate considerations. In this case, sustainability has to be considered when money is being allocated, or the project is likely to fall by the wayside.
1.1.4 Getting the Customers on Board Every retail developer such as Multi has two sets of customers: directly, the retail tenants, and, indirectly, the customers it hopes to attract to the shops. There is also a third, very important constituency, namely the investors in the project. Because sustainability measures often involve higher initial costs, certainly at the beginning of the journey, the developer’s dilemma is either how to persuade the retail tenants to pay higher rents (in exchange for continuing savings in energy costs) or to persuade the project’s investors to accept slightly lower returns. This is an important problem, one unlikely to disappear in the next three to five years, even as the world begins moving toward sustainable development and tenants may begin to desire the reputational benefits of locating in green centers. Whether they will be willing to pay higher rents for these benefits is still open to question. (Chapter 5 deals directly with the issues of cost.) The issue of potentially lower returns is also likely to be temporary for two reasons: first, the centers with lower energy, water and waste management costs will be able to demonstrate those reductions in shared operating costs as time goes forward (and therefore have the potential for rent growth); second, developers with green experience are likely to obtain other benefits, such as attracting investment capital and recruiting and keeping key employees (a major emerging issue in most advanced economies at this time).
1.2 Sonae Sierra An innovator in the shopping center business, Sonae Sierra offers an integrated approach to owning, developing and managing shopping centers. Sierra centers integrate leisure with retail and other services, with a focus on green issues. Based in Portugal, the company currently operates fifty centers, with twentyeight under development in Portugal, Spain, Italy, Germany, Romania, Greece and Brazil. For fiscal year 2007, the company reported net operating revenue of C639 million, with net profit of C300 million and net asset value of C1,713 million [13].
8
1 Sustainability Matters
1.2.1 Sustainability Sonae Sierra’s CEO, Álvaro Portela, created a corporate responsibility policy in the past decade [14], based on the firm “belief that no economic activity can take place in a vacuum” [15]. The company was a founding member in 1995 of the World Business Council for Sustainable Development, one of the leading organizations in the field. The ultimate goal is for the business to be “sustainable, in the very longterm meaning of the word.” Sonae Sierra uses an Environmental Management System (EMS) certified under the ISO 14001 standard (see Fig. 1.4). The company’s Environment Manager oversees the application of the EMS to company operations. The key to ISO 14001 is its focus on continuous improvement. Sonae Sierra ensures sustainable buildings by focusing on environmental responsibility in the design, construction and operation phases. Portela believes that the corporate responsibility policy is essential to their
Fig. 1.4 Sonae Sierra’s corporate sustainability program is based on an ISO 14001 Environmental Management System. Courtesy of Sonae Sierra
1.2
Sonae Sierra
9
brand, but “like all brand attributes, you have to deliver what you promise to your stakeholders to be taken seriously.” Hence the importance of each year’s corporate responsibility action plan and the EMS system for monitoring performance. A centralized, online database gathers data for Sonae Sierra’s water use, waste and climate issues. This information generates reports that, for example, call for tighter water use, set annual targets for waste recycling and provide directions for improving Building Management Systems (BMS). Sonae Sierra’s environmental focus covers four major areas. 1. Climate Change The company’s stated short-term goal is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 10%. Sonae Sierra uses its Environmental Standards for Retail Development (ESRD) —an internal internet specification tool—to come up with the best environmental practices in the planning and design of new shopping centers. The tool considers 190 standards that cover issues such as energy, water, waste, transport, health and well-being, site sustainability and materials. The standards are based on Sonae Sierra’s experience, best practices and certification schemes such as LEED and BREEAM. The standards determine the use of technologies such as solar, ventilation, efficient boilers, air-conditioning units, advanced lighting and combined heat and power in design. The company is committed to achieving a high rating under the EU’s Energy Performance of Buildings Directive, which issues grades of A to G, from best to worst in terms of annual energy use per square foot/meter of operating area [16]. Furthermore, the company is part of a three-year project (ending 2009) called the World Business Council for Sustainable Development’s Energy Efficiency in Buildings (EEB) Project which delineates the changes necessary to have all buildings become zero net energy consumers. ESRD have led to transport impact studies at the design stage. These studies result in green travel plans, local transport partnerships and encouraging greater use of public transport, walking and cycling. Furthermore, the company encourages efficient vehicle use through traffic-calming measures, priority lanes, dedicated parking bays for car-poolers, refueling stations and points for alternativefuelled vehicles [17]. In 2004, Sonae Sierra conducted a study to understand the greenhouse emissions of its core activities. In partnership with a Portuguese environmental consulting firm, Sonae Sierra initiated the pilot phase of the project to estimate emissions. This phase was conducted in Portugal in its corporate offices and in the Centro Colombo and Rio Sul shopping centers, shown in Fig. 1.5. In the second phase in 2005, Sonae Sierra applied the Greenhouse Gas Protocol guidelines as a measurement tool to all its offices and centers. 2. Water The company’s goal is to maintain water consumption at or below four liters (one gallon) per visit per year, a target it claims to have achieved in 2007. ESRD standards require water-efficient designs—such as equipment specifications and
10
1 Sustainability Matters
Fig. 1.5 The Rio Sul shopping center is one of Sonae Sierra’s showcase environmental projects. Courtesy of Sonae Sierra
water recycling—and wastewater treatment—such as oil and hydrocarbon separators. Some of the water efficient features are rainwater harvesting and gray water recycling, water-efficient sanitary equipment (such as spray taps and lowflush toilets), efficient irrigation systems and the use of non-water-intensive native or adapted plant species. Furthermore, to prevent pollution from rainwater runoff, filter drains and porous pavements are used. 3. Waste The company’s stated goal is to achieve a minimum 50% recycling rate and a maximum 30% landfill disposal rate. Sonae Sierra conducts site-specific waste management strategy studies to determine the required space for waste separation and recycling. The company calls for construction companies to provide reports of their waste management. Furthermore, it encourages tenants to manage waste responsibly, even though it has little control over tenant activities. 4. Land Use Sonae Sierra’s goal is to use previously developed land for new shopping centers and to protect biodiversity where possible in developing new sites. Where sites have been previously contaminated, the company takes remedial action according to the Canadian Environmental Quality Guidelines or the Dutch
1.2
Sonae Sierra
11
Standards for Soil Quality. ESRD standards specify planting indigenous plant species in landscaped areas and favoring the use of hedgerows and green barriers.
1.2.2 Implementation Issues Introducing a major change toward sustainability at the corporate level is not without its challenges. According to Portela, “the main challenge was the company’s cultural evolution that we had to create in order to place the corporate responsibility management issues at the core of our strategy and mission. All the company, from board-level to the rest of the staff, has to understand and believe that this [policy] is crucial for the growth of the company and it should impact the way we all do business.” This challenge implies the need for a massive and continuing sales job inside the company, as people are continually brought into the organization and those inside the company need constant reminders about the mission. Portela also points out one of the major areas of concern for all developers, saying, “another big issue is how to balance short-term [additional] costs against long-term externalities, since both the environmental and economic benefits are only visible during the operation phase. Only a company [like ours] that holds onto assets, and actively manages them, is able to recoup additional capital costs through reduced running costs.” As for the future two to three years, there is still the challenge “to keep our suppliers and tenants inspired to replicate our own sustainability efforts, and to continuously find innovative and more sustainable ways of developing and managing shopping centers.”
Examples of Sonae Sierra’s Approach to Sustainability El Rosal, Ponferrada, Spain. Built to reflect local character, this shopping center achieved ISO 14001 certification for the construction phase. One of the center’s environmental features is a solar roof with 600 photovoltaic (PV) panels on a 1,500-m2 area that cost C620,300. This results in energy production of 132,447 kWh per year with annual savings of C58,300. At current electricity prices, the company expects to recover the initial system cost after just nine years for equipment with a 25-year life. On average, emissions are reduced by 48 metric tons of carbon dioxide per year and over 25 years by 1,200 metric tons of carbon dioxide. Centro Colombo, Portugal. In this development, Sierra introduced the Green Travel Plan project. It analyzes the transport infrastructure and implements measures to encourage and improve the accessibility of the shopping
12
1 Sustainability Matters
center by public transport, bicycle and foot. Furthermore, in customer surveys, Sierra asks what form of transport its customers use in visiting the centers so that it can monitor indirect greenhouse emissions. Parque D. Pedro, Campinas, Brazil. Water is treated at the center’s treatment plant and reused in bathrooms and for irrigation. In 2007, 48% of water supplied was from reclaimed sources. The reuse and irrigation system cost C83,115, while savings in the first year were C100,000. The center was one of the first buildings in Brazil to receive ISO 14001 certification. Arrabida Shopping Center, Portugal. This center uses a composting system that allows garden managers to use organic waste in the center’s green areas. Zubiarte, Spain. The Bilbao city council and the Zubiarte management team introduced a bicycle loan scheme. People can borrow and return bicycles for free by registering on the internet. Centro Vasco da Gama, Portugal. This project utilizes subterranean water from a nonpotable water supply. The investment for the system consists of a pumping station and treatment equipment. Monthly water consumption has been reduced by 530 m3 (142,000 U.S. gal), corresponding to 11% of total water consumption. According to the company, the initial system investment will be recovered during the first year, with total cost savings equivalent to C11,900 in the following years. Luz del Tajo, Toledo, Spain. An EMS monitors areas such as energy saving, transportation, water treatment, contamination, resource use, selection and use of materials, ecology, and health. A building management system controls energy savings, a pre-treatment system separating residues of fat and hydrocarbons, timers in the public taps and the use of filters in kitchen extraction systems.
1.3 Marks and Spencer The prominent U.K. retailer Marks & Spencer (M&S) embarked in 2007 on a series of wide-ranging sustainability initiatives, widely known as “Plan A,” because as Chairman Sir Stuart Rose said at the time, “there is no Plan B” when it comes to environmental responsibility. Plan A is a five-year, £200-million, 100-point plan for moving the company forward as a leader in corporate sustainability. The plan means that by 2012 M&S aims to accomplish 100 goals relating to five primary areas of concern: • • • • •
become carbon-neutral; send no waste to the landfill; extend sustainable sourcing; set new standards in ethical trading; help customers and employees live a healthier lifestyle.
1.3
Marks and Spencer
13
When announcing the plan in January 2007, M&S Chairman Stuart Rose said [18]: Every business and individual needs to do their bit to tackle the enormous challenges of climate change and waste. While M&S will continue to sell great quality, stylish and innovative products, our customers, employees and shareholders now expect us to take bold steps and do business differently and responsibly. We believe a responsible business can be a profitable business. We are calling this “Plan A” because there is no “plan B.” M&S will change beyond recognition the way it operates over the next five years. We will become carbon neutral, only using offsetting as a last resort; we will ensure that none of our clothing or packaging needs to be thrown away; much of our polyester clothing will be made from recycled plastic bottles instead of oil and every year we will sell over 20 million garments made from Fairtrade cotton.
1.3.1 Beyond Environmentalism M&S’s shift toward greening its operations is a business decision as well as being Rose’s personal philosophy: “No one had announced a big initiative up until then, and we wanted to be the first. . .[w]e were the first out of the pack. I’m not crowing, but it’s important. I’m not going to deny, if you get it right, it does give you a competitive advantage.”
1.3.2 2008 Plan A Update Although the financial benefit is still unclear, Plan A has had some definite business benefits for M&S. For example: • Marketing Week magazine named it as the greenest brand (March 2008). • Over 20% of electricity consumed by the business comes from renewable sources; saving 55,000 tons annually of CO2 produced by stores and offices. • The company opened three eco-stores in the U.K.—Bournemouth, Galashiels and Pollok. The stores were built or remodelled to help the company learn about sustainable construction and many of the lessons are included in a Sustainable Construction manual and have been rolled out across the M&S chain. The Bournemouth store has reduced its energy use by 18% and was refitted to include displacement ventilation and CO2 -based refrigeration, for example. Similar initiatives were included in the stores in Pollok and Galashiels. The Pollok store achieved the highest fitout assessment score that the BRE has issued to date. (The Galashiels store is shown in Fig. 1.6.) • First eco-factory, in Sri Lanka, in partnership with supplier MAS, the eco-factory “is designed to minimize environmental impact.” Green energy is used to power the factory with solar supplementation of around 10%. The factory will use about 40% less energy than an equivalent factory in that place. Rainwater collection and low flow fixtures also reduce normal water use by approximately 50%.
14
1 Sustainability Matters
• Teardrop-shaped eco-trucks with better aerodynamics emit 20% less carbon dioxide. • Carrier bag charging introduced—customers are now encouraged to use a bag for life, and carrier bag use has been reduced by 80%. • Food packaging weight decreased, with a large amount of it now recyclable or compostable. It is important to note that Plan A is an evolving plan and adjustments are made with each lesson learned. For example, because of the threat of loss of habitat through converting agricultural land to biomass crops for ethanol production, M&S put an indefinite hold on the use of biofuels.
Fig. 1.6 Marks & Spencer’s Galashiels store is one of the chain’s many green buildings. Courtesy of the project architect, 3DReid for Marks & Spencer
1.4 Regency Centers Based in the U.S., Regency Centers owns, operates and develops grocery-anchored and community shopping centers. At year end 2008, the company owned 440 retail properties, including those held in co-investment partnerships. Including tenantowned square footage, the portfolio encompassed 58.4 million ft2 located in top markets throughout the U.S., representing an investment at completion of $3.0 billion [19]. The author interviewed Mary Lou Fiala, vice chairman/chief operating officer (COO), and also moderated a presentation by two key players on the Regency
1.4
Regency Centers
15
sustainability team at the 2008 ICSC ReCON conference, Scott Wilson, vice president construction, and Mark Peternell, vice president sustainability.4 In November 2007, Regency’s CEO and chairman Martin E. “Hap” Stein, Jr. announced the company’s sustainability program, including a commitment to move toward basic LEED certification of 60% of all new developments beginning in 2010. According to a recent interview with Stein [20]. The company is pursuing LEED certification at six centers, including the 700,000- ft2 Deer Springs Town Center in Las Vegas, under construction. COO Fiala and CEO Stein emphasize that sustainability has become one of the core values at Regency and is integral to its brand of “quality shopping centers.” While respectful of the economic effects of each decision to go green, key executives at the company are committed to sustainability. Regency realizes that it is big enough to make a difference, and it intends to do so with sustainable construction and operations programs. While many of the company’s anchor tenants have not embraced LEED, the majority of them are aggressively pursuing energy efficiency strategies. A larger issue for greening shopping centers remains the split incentives between landlord and tenant, a subject discussed in more depth later in this book.
1.4.1 Branding As part of its sustainability initiative, Regency adopted a trademarked program that it calls “greengenuityTM ”—green ingenuity—as a way to demonstrate quality and innovation, as well as leadership in the field of sustainability and green building. The greengenuity program encompasses new developments, existing centers and corporate operations. The company expects that tenants with strong LEED certification programs for their own buildings may in the future also want to locate in centers that support that mission. In addition, the company expects that creating and implementing a sustainability program will help it with investors who want green real estate in their portfolios.
1.4.2 Training According to Fiala, Regency is currently training key personnel in green building practices and the LEED certification system, including all construction team members. There is also a condensed training program for all of the company’s investment team members, focusing on the business case for green development. A key 4 Full
disclosure: the author served as a consultant to Regency’s in-house task force for about six months in 2007.
16
1 Sustainability Matters
part of the training is to place good information in people’s hands and to take away the fear factor that going green will significantly harm a project’s expected returns. Training and providing good cost information are critical to changing behavior. Fiala says [21], Training is an extremely important part of implementing a successful sustainability program. As such, this has been an integral part of our initiative since its inception over the past 12 months. We hosted day-and-a-half green building training seminars for our own internal construction teams, as well as some of our top A&E consultants and general contractors. In total, this effort reached over 180 professionals. In addition, we had training for our investment teams that focused more on the business case for sustainability and how to incorporate the cost analysis and yield impact into their initial review of potential development projects. Training will continue to be an important part of our platform in 2009. It takes the commitment and dedication of the entire company to be successful. Additional focus will be given to educating retailers to address the issue of competing incentives.
1.4.3 Capital Allocation Similar to Multi Development, Regency requires that all new investment proposals submitted to the Capital Allocation Committee provide an assessment of the LEED certification potential of all or part of the center, as part of its due diligence process. Naturally, some projects are not amenable to LEED certification. However, Regency expects that requiring all investment decisions to at least consider the sustainability issue will drive its green program forward and also teach its investment officers how to deal with the costs and expected returns of green development. COO Fiala says, Based on the internal analysis performed by our task force, we estimate the cost premium for a LEED certified project to be approximately 2%. These premiums increase with the higher levels of certification (Silver, Gold, and Platinum). However, there is such a broad spectrum of sustainability strategies that it is really difficult to make a blanket statement that it costs “X” to be green. Each investment decision needs to consider any on-going benefits, in addition to first costs, and ultimately make a decision based on a project’s overall return on investment (ROI).
1.4.4 Developing a Sustainability Program Regency began its sustainability initiative with an in-house task force. The group spent nine months looking at three key areas: cost and scope of green construction, as well as operations; LEED and public relations/marketing; and tenant and site assessment issues. One task force undertook detailed cost assessments for LEED certification of specific centers already in the development pipeline.
1.4
Regency Centers
17
1.4.5 Taking a Larger Perspective The business case for green development is discussed at some length in Chapter 4. Regency’s COO Fiala states it in this way: LEED, or other third party green building certifications, are a testament to a building’s quality, and tenants will seek out shopping centers that have these certifications because they are energy efficient, have better indoor air quality, and have shown evidence of higher worker productivity and increased retail sales. As the demand for green buildings increases, our projects will become even more desirable. As a result of this increased demand, green shopping centers should have lower vacancy rates and quicker absorption. Furthermore, because these projects have lower operating expenses, a tenant’s total cost of occupancy will be less, making our shopping centers more competitive. In the end, these trends will result in higher valuations. In addition to these direct economic benefits, there are a number of indirect benefits that make the business case for green real estate compelling. Our commitment to sustainability has been well received by many of our government partners, and we believe this will be advantageous during the entitlement process for new centers. Similarly, the communities in which we develop and operate shopping centers place a high value on environmental stewardship, and we believe this shared value will result in more customer loyalty, translating into more foot traffic and higher retail sales.
1.4.6 Progress Regency Centers hired a corporate sustainability vice president, Mark Peternell, in 2008. Since that time, in spite of the difficult economic environment for center developments, the program has moved ahead with a number of projects. In December 2008, Regency announced a major commitment to water conservation in the western U.S [19]. Regency’s outdoor water conservation initiative will take thirty-six existing shopping centers and install high-efficiency “smart” irrigation controllers aimed at reducing each facility’s outdoor water consumption, expecting to save 42 million gallons of water each year, saving costs both to the company and to its tenants through lower common-area charges. Smart irrigation controllers adjust to changing weather conditions and to reduce over watering, using local weather information to adjust water quantities, timing and duration. Based on results from this pilot study, Regency expects to continue rolling out smart irrigation controllers across its portfolio. In 2008, Regency chose to partner with the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Net Zero Energy Commercial Building Initiative (CBI) as a National Account and was chosen among 21 companies in retail, finance and commercial real estate to team with DOE Laboratories to speed market adoption of current energysaving technologies that will produce buildings with significant, measurable energy savings [20].
18
1 Sustainability Matters
1.5 Summary The four examples in this chapter illustrate a wide-ranging approach to corporate sustainability in the retail sector. Chapter 12 draws some detailed lessons for other companies’ programs that we can glean from these and other examples. Being a leader in retail sustainability, whether as a store operator or as a retail developer, requires a major and ongoing commitment to sustainable design, construction, operations and management, and management focus on a host of important initiatives. Without a strong commitment, most companies tend to revert to status quo ante. Leaders don’t wait for all the data to come in, to prove that a sustainability strategy provides the best direction. Leaders act on incomplete data, backed by sound principles, due diligence and extensive business experience. Throughout this book, there are many examples of interesting and profitable approaches to sustainable retail development, all coming from well-known companies in various segments of the retail industry and in countries large and small around the world. The next chapter highlights some of these projects.
References 1. Sustainability matters. p. 188. Retrieved December 21, 2008, from http://www.gsa.gov/gsa/ cm_attachments/GSA_DOCUMENT/oaspublications_R2-mQC1_0Z5RDZ-i34K-pR.pdf. 2. Porter, Michael E., and Kramer, Mark R. (2006, December) Strategy and society: The link between competitive advantage and corporate social responsibility. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved on June 21, 2009, from harvardbusinessonline.hsbp.harvard.edu/.../Porter_Dec_ 2006.pdf. 3. Report of the world commission on environment and development (1987, December 11). Retrieved on February 8, 2009, from http://www.un.org/documents/ga/res/42/ares42-187.htm. 4. Executive chief sustainability officer appointments on the rise. (2007). ERS Global Newsletter, Fall. 5. Frankel, Carl. (2009, January 23). No downturn for corporate sustainability initiatives. Retrieved on January 23, 2009, from http://featured.matternetwork.com/2009/1/no-downturncorporate-sustainability-initiatives_8068.cfm. 6. Fourth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. pp. 39, 72. (2007). Retrieved on February 9, 2009, http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/ar4-syr.htm, accessed February 9, 2009. 7. Summary of New IPCC Findings on Climate Change. (2007, February 12). Retrieved on February 9, 2009, from http://www.uoregon.edu/˜climlead/publicationspress/ IPCC%20Summary%202.12.pdf. 8. Curbing global energy demand growth (2007, May). Retrieved on February 9, 2009, from http://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/publications/Curbing_Global_Energy/index.asp. 9. The case for investing in energy productivity (2008, February). Retrieved on February 9, 2009, from http://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/publications/Investing_Energy_Productivity/. 10. This section is based on interviews with three key executives in April 2008 at the company’s headquarters: Glenn H. Aaronson, CEO, Multi Corporation B.V.; Arco Rehorst, Technical Director for Multi Asset Management; and Arno G. N. Ruigrok, Adjunct Director of Multi Vastgoed B.V. 11. Multiple awards for Multi Development at MAPIC in Cannes. Retrieved on June 3, 2008, from http://www.multi-development.com/web/nederland.nsf/wwwVwContent/ l2multipleawardsformultidevelopmentatmapicincannes.htm.
References
19
12. Forum Duisburg company web site. Retrieved on June 3, 2008, from www.forumduisburg.de/Aktuelles.php. 13. Sonae Sierra company web site. Retrieved on July 20, 2008, from http://www.sonaesierra. com/Web/en-GB/home/default.aspx. 14. General sources for this section are presentations by Elsa Monterio. Retrieved on July 20, 2008, from youtube.com/watch?v=pVRgKWmgYgU&feature=related (Part 1) and youtube.com/watch?v=5C9VNoanVfg (Part 2). 15. All quotes from an email interview with CEO Álvaro Portela, August 7, 2008. 16. European Commission web site. Retrieved on July 20, 2008, from http://ec.europa. eu/energy/demand/legislation/buildings_en.htm. 17. Presentation by Elsa Monteiro, Head of Institutional Relations, Environment and Communication, Sonae Sierra, at ICSC Centrebuild Europe, London, June 20, 2008. 18. Marks & Spencer: Plan A web site. Retrieved on December 21, 2008, from http://plana. marksandspencer.com/index.php?action=PublicAboutPressDetailDisplay&press_id=2. 19. Field, Catherine. (2008, December 22). Regency Centers goes even greener. Chain Store Age. Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://www.chainstoreage.com/ WebExclusives.aspx?storyId=89093. 20. Shearin, Randall. (2008, May). Regency gaining ground. Shopping Center Business, May 2008. Retrieved on June 4, 2008, from http://www.regencycenters.com/uploads/ Regency%20Gaining%20Ground%20with%20Green%20Initiative.pdf. 21. Interview with Mary Lou Fiala January 2009.
Chapter 2
Green Buildings Around the World
The preceding chapter discussed sustainability programs of some well-known players in the retail real estate and retail industries. This chapter focuses more narrowly on green buildings and provides a survey of retail green building developments around the world. While most of the focus is on projects in North America and Western Europe, where sustainable design has had a larger impact, there are also instructive examples from the Middle East, South America, Asia, Australia and Africa. The overall lesson is that green building is a worldwide phenomenon embraced by many retailers. Green buildings are growing by leaps and bounds. A green building is one that is certified in the U.S. by the U.S. Green Building Council’s LEED system, in the U.K. by the BREEAM system, in Australia and New Zealand by the Green Star system and in various other countries by their own third-party systems. Considering any reasonable metric, the rapid growth in the green building sector since 2005 has been remarkable. BREEAM was introduced in the mid-1990s and LEED was introduced in 2000, originally to cover just new construction projects and major renovations. LEED and BREEAM have since been expanded to cover Core and Shell Buildings, new or remodeled Commercial Interiors and the environmental performance of Existing Buildings. BREEAM and Green Star have similar categories to LEED for certification, which are examined in more detail in the next chapter. Green rating systems typically cover seven major categories of environmental concern, each of which can apply to the retail store and shopping center sector development.1 • • • • •
Sustainable site development Water conservation, both indoors and outdoors Energy conservation and renewable energy use Materials and resource conservation Indoor environmental quality
1 The entire LEED system is available for download and use from the U.S. Green Building Council,
http://www.usgbc.org/leed. BREEAM can be accessed at www.breeam.org and Green Star can be found at http://www.gbca.org.au/green-star/rating-tools/.
J. Yudelson, Sustainable Retail Development, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5_2, C 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers Copyright
21
22
2
Green Buildings Around the World
• Transport energy use • Emissions from site operations In the LEED, BREEAM and Green Star systems and in the green building movement in general, the retail sector has certainly been a laggard, as this sector has faced different challenges and obstacles from the public, nonprofit, and commercial office sectors, which we’ll discuss throughout this book. As of December 2008, approximately 200 retail projects had registered their intent to certify under the LEED-NC or LEED for Core and Shell (LEED-CS) rating system, compared with nearly 15,000 total projects [1]. Green Star and BREEAM just certified their first green projects in 2008. However, the premise of this book is that there are great opportunities for the retail sector to embrace sustainable design, development and operations, for sound business reasons.
2.1 Why Retail Should Go Green The entire world appears to be going green, albeit at different rates and with different approaches. In the commercial office sector, for example, there is a growing appreciation for the business case benefits of green buildings. Many of these benefits apply to the retail sector in one way or another. A fuller discussion of driving forces influencing the business case for green retail buildings and developments is provided in a later chapter. These economic and noneconomic, tangible and intangible benefits include some or all of the following: • • • • • • • • • • •
Reduced energy costs Increased use of utility and tax incentives for energy conservation Increased building value, through higher net operating income (NOI) Improved productivity and reduced health impacts of building operations Improved sales and lease-up (letting) of properties Growing evidence of increased sales from daylighting, averaging 5%2 Marketing benefits Public relations benefits Recruitment and retention of key people Greater funding availability from institutional sources Increased interest by investors (for both public and private companies) in a company’s long-term sustainability programs • Corporate social responsibility exemplified in green buildings, especially with concern over global warming and carbon emissions mounting each year Not all benefits apply in all cases, but this list is indicative of what green retail stores and retail center developers should consider when weighing the costs and 2 See
studies by Heschong Mahone Group for Pacific Gas & Electric, www.h-m-g.com.
2.2
North American Case Studies
23
benefits of greening their operations. In this chapter, we will also explore tenant and consumer demand, local government incentives and mandates and increasing energy costs as driving factors. Chapter 4 presents the business case for green retail in more depth.
2.2 North American Case Studies For this book, the author assessed a number of case studies of LEED-certified and other green retail projects. In small retail operations, an early green adopter in the U.S. was PNC Bank, with more than fifty retail branches certified or registered for LEED certification.3 The giant retailer Wal-Mart completed two “experimental” stores in Colorado and Texas (not LEED-certified, however) and committed in 2005 to more than $500 million in energy conservation upgrades. Owing to its mammoth size, Wal-Mart is a special case discussed in Chapter 8. From other developers, by 2007, two shopping centers were certified at LEED Silver, and the first LEED Gold shopping center was well under way. The first LEED-certified retail project, going back to 2004, was a Giant Eagle supermarket in Ohio. A large grocery chain, Stop & Shop, based in the northeastern U.S., has certified more than fifty stores under the LEED for Existing Buildings program, something we’ll profile in more depth in Chapter 10. These are just a few examples of early adopters among retailers. A more detailed treatment of retail store initiatives will be found later in the book.
2.2.1 Developer Case Studies 2.2.1.1 Northfield Stapleton Forest City’s Northfield development in Denver at Stapleton Field (the former Denver airport site) received the first LEED for Core and Shell Silver certification for a “main street” or “town center” retail development. The Stapleton residential development has received smart growth awards from the Urban Land Institute and the National Association of Homebuilders. The master plan for the entire project required “sustainable development,” a condition that applied also to the retail segment. The LEED certification process involved about sixteen small buildings at the core of this large (1.2 million ft2 ) development, which opened for business in 2006. This open-air project features extensive signage about the green features of the project (created from salvaged signage from the former airport runways), highefficiency plumbing fixtures in public restrooms, low-toxicity paints and carpets, a reflective roof, high-efficiency irrigation and a small solar power system (not visible 3 U.S. and Canadian case studies were based largely on interviews conducted during 2007 and 2008,
by Gretel Hakanson, Yudelson Associates, and Sonja Persram, Sustainable Alternatives Consulting, Toronto.
24
2
Green Buildings Around the World
Fig. 2.1 Forest City’s Northfield Stapleton development was the first “lifestyle” center to be LEED-Silver certified in the U.S. Photography by Steve Crecelius, Wonder Works
from the street level). There are also tenant guidelines that stress both education and incentives for tenants; those who comply get to display a sticker on their window that says, “Sustainability Program Participant” (Fig. 2.1).
2.2.1.2 Abercorn Common Developed by Melaver, Inc., a privately held developer, the 169,000-ft2 Abercorn Common in Savannah (shown in Fig. 2.2), Georgia, also received a LEED-CS Silver certification in 2006. Abercorn Common boasts the nation’s first certified quickservice restaurant in a LEED-certified building, along with a host of green features in the other parts of the center. The project was the first retail LEED for Core and Shell certified project in the country, achieving the Silver level of performance [2]. According to the developer, the second phase of the project, the 16,000-ft2 Shops 600, was certified at the LEED Silver level and built without any discernible cost increase. At Shops 600, the leasable retail space includes solar water heaters and a green roof. Harvested rainwater provides 5.5 million gal a year of irrigation water, the project’s entire consumption. In this warm climate, a highly insulated building envelope and a reflective white roof reduce electricity consumption by more than 30%. Porous pavement in the parking lots reduces stormwater runoff by 30%, and water-efficient plumbing units reduce projected water use by 50%, compared with national code requirements [3]. Green development was an extension of the owner’s vision. A few years ago the company decided that all subsequent development projects would be LEEDcertified. This directive arose out of the company’s core values. In 2002, the
2.2
North American Case Studies
25
Fig. 2.2 Abercorn Common in Savannah, Georgia, was the first LEED-certified center in the U.S. Attic Fire Photography.
executive team met with leading sustainability expert Paul Hawken4 and developer John Knott, who recommended that the company retain its ownership of its buildings, and to insert its values into the development process. At that time, LEED was rising in prominence, and the company was planning the Abercorn Common project. During 2002, Melaver’s planning of an office project was fairly far along (the Whitaker building) when it was halted for four months to allow staff to learn about LEED sufficiently to enable achieving the LEED goals. The knowledge base and goals were then also applied to Abercorn Common, which required a little reworking of the initial planning.
2.2.1.3 First Capital Realty First Capital Realty Inc. is the one of largest owner, operator and developers of retail shopping centers in Canada. Primarily sited within major metropolitan neighborhoods and anchored by supermarkets, the firm’s Canadian centers comprise 161 properties totaling about 18.9 million ft2 of gross leasable area, of which $132.8 million in properties is under development [4]. The company is undertaking an ambitious greening program whereby one-third of all properties will be LEED-certified with the Canada Green Building Council within three to four years, 4 Hawken’s two 1990s books, The Ecology of Commerce and Natural Capitalism (with A. and H. Lovins), are still considered must reading for business executives desiring to understand how to apply sustainability thinking to their enterprises.
26
2
Green Buildings Around the World
and the remaining (existing) buildings will be “as green as possible” over ten to fifteen years.5 2.2.1.3.1 Visionary Leadership This green building program was initiated in 2006 by president Dori Segal, who engaged corporate executives with his vision for the company’s shopping center property holdings to be sustainable going forward—not just from an environmental perspective, but for economic reasons. In 2007, twenty-seven green LEED-NC projects were in progress, and 27 more were at the planning stage. The LEED-certified requirement will relate to all new construction—whether on greenfield sites or on existing properties. As indicated, for existing properties, greening will evolve more slowly, such that, for example, HVAC/re-roofing/landscape upgrades will take place as the existing components approach the end of their useful lives. 2.2.1.3.2 Morningside Crossing Opened in September 2008, the development of Toronto’s Morningside Crossing (Fig. 2.3) testifies to First Capital’s commitment to corporate responsibility and sustainability [5]. As the first large project to benefit from the firm’s May 2006 declaration that all of its new buildings would be green, this property had additional challenges, including a previous legacy of opposition from city hall and residents. For First Capital Realty, the sustainable approach to the redevelopment of this property was unique and appropriate. The plans and detailed design work were mostly complete for Morningside Crossing when the company made the commitment to pursue LEED certification for its new developments. As a large and complicated project that involved the demolition of a three-story mall and the promise of uninterrupted service to several existing tenants, the conversion to LEED standards and principles for all the new buildings further challenged project managers and tenants. Significant changes were introduced to drawings, and new commitments were written into leases to reflect environmentally inspired objectives. Examples include the provision of white reflective roofs; 95% of the concrete from the old mall and parking structure was diverted from landfill and reused on-site; rainwater is now collected on rooftops and redirected for landscape irrigation; and new green technologies ensure greater water and energy efficiency throughout the development. The objective of LEED certification became a central theme that permeated all business decisions for this project and all those to follow. This desire to pursue products and practices that reduce the ecological
5 The
Canada LEED certification is essentially equivalent to the U.S. Green Building Council’s LEED program requirements, with some adaptation for Canadian conditions.
2.2
North American Case Studies
27
Fig. 2.3 Morningside Crossing, Toronto’s first LEED-compliant shopping center, is one of 30 projects for which the developer, First Capital Realty, plans to pursue LEED certification. Photo: © Greg Schmidt 2008
footprint has instilled a new corporate mantra for the people who work for and with First Capital Realty. First Capital Realty has clearly demonstrated that the principles of sustainable development can be integral to a successful business strategy. While the decision to construct green buildings presented some early internal challenges, the company’s commitment helped guide this development from the unwanted status that preceded its arrival to that of a friend and celebrated addition to the community a couple of years later. First Capital’s outreach efforts were extensive and involved local residents and stakeholders from the very onset of this project. The initial plans were altered in response to direct meetings with city officials and other stakeholders. This included the input of about 600 local residents at an open house staged by First Capital staff and senior management to introduce the company and the proposed project.
2.2.2 Retailer Case Studies 2.2.2.1 Giant Eagle Supermarket The first LEED-certified retail project was an 80,000-ft2 Giant Eagle supermarket in the Brunswick Town Center shopping plaza in northeastern Ohio in 2004. When building the Brunswick supermarket, Giant Eagle implemented a range of
28
2
Green Buildings Around the World
environmentally friendly features that are fairly typical of the measures available to large retail stores: • The consumption of 30% less energy than comparable supermarkets, with more than 50% of the location’s electrical energy supplied through off-site-purchased wind power. • More than 50 skylights integrated with electrical lighting sensors, which automatically adjust the amount of electric light supplied depending on the light generated by the skylight. • A fiber-optic lighting system for wine coolers that reduces heat generation. • Natural filtration of parking lot stormwater into the adjacent constructed wetland. • Water-conserving equipment that will save more than 100,000 gal per year. • A construction waste recycling program that diverts 62% of waste from landfills. • All wood used in the building was sustainably harvested certified by the Forest Stewardship Council. • Drought-resistant plants and trees that require no irrigation other than natural rainfall, saving about 400,000 gal of water each year. • A green housekeeping program that uses environmentally responsible cleaning products. • A white reflective roof and increased insulation to allow the building to cool and heat easier [6].
2.2.2.2 Home Depot of Canada Home Depot of Canada Inc. has 155 stores in Canada and has been working to develop an array of ecological choices for home renovations. The North Hill project in Calgary, Alberta, was the company’s first LEED-certified project [7]. Two years ago, when Home Depot of Canada was planning a fifth store in Calgary, the city required that any development within the location preferred by the company—the downtown core—be LEED-certified, and (in the specific instance) utilize an existing building site. Given the desirability of the site, the agreement was struck, and the first LEED-certified Home Depot store was developed. The site was a small, old hotel, which was demolished, with much of this old building reused in the new structure. The size of the site meant underground parking was required. For a variety of green and non-green factors, including the way it was demolished, the requirements for reuse and a labor shortage prompting skyrocketing labor rates (caused by rapid growth in northern Alberta oil sands development), the cost increment for this development was 25%. Lower energy operations and maintenance costs have been noted at the store: energy costs for lighting are 40–50% less than at other stores. Additionally, there have been some water savings due to the installation of water-free urinals and lowflush toilets, as well as timed equipment for plant watering at the garden centers. Many of these higher building standards (such as energy-efficient lighting, temperature sensors allowing energy shedding by regulating lighting with external
2.3
United Kingdom (U.K.)
29
temperatures, central energy management of all stores in Canada and LED signs at both entrances and exits) have been implemented as specifications for all new construction, and some have also been applied in the existing building stock. However, the company is not yet committed to bringing all its buildings to LEED standards, or even to the energy efficiency standards of LEED certification level projects. The driving force for greening future Home Depots in Canada is the business case. If a store is being developed on a greenfield site, it would be more likely to be built to LEED standards. And where a region requires that developments comply with LEED standards, and the expected sales volumes balance out the anticipated cost increases, Home Depot of Canada’s business case requirements may be met. In Bowmanville, a town near Toronto, low land costs allowed development standards targeting a LEED-certified level. While there is a great deal of pride over the LEEDcertified North Hill store, the company did not seek market differentiation on that basis. Home Depot of Canada believes there have been reputation benefits from the project, but these are difficult to measure.
2.3 United Kingdom (U.K.) Paul Edwards is head of sustainability at Hammerson, a major European real estate investment trust. He says: At Hammerson, we find BREEAM useful. We produce our own internal document called a Sustainable Implementation Plan (SIP) with BREEAM plugged into the overarching document. The SIP covers a lot more than just environmental issues, with social issues such as jobs, skills and training included, it is also always evolving as the project develops. For us, BREEAM is just an element of our overall program. I think one of the benefits of BREEAM is that it enables you to label a building as green. It has industry recognition and so tenants, agents and other stakeholders are starting to understand its meaning and that it provides some comfort as to the environmental credentials of the building. BREEAM has limits though and does not cover all environmental aspects [8].
2.3.1 Cabot Circus The first BREEAM Excellent retail project in the U.K. is the Cabot Circus project in Bristol (shown in Fig. 2.4). Cabot Circus provides nearly 1 million ft2 (93,000-m2 ) of new retail space within a 1.5 million ft2 (139,353 m2 ) mixed-use master plan occupying a 36-acre site. It is a leading example of a comprehensively mixed-use scheme with nine different uses: retail, catering, leisure, offices, market housing, affordable housing, student housing, hotel, and car parking. The project represents a £500 million investment by The Bristol Alliance—a partnership between Land Securities and Hammerson, two U.K. Real Estate Investment Trusts. In addition, other entities provided a further £100 million of development within the master plan [9].
30
2
Green Buildings Around the World
Fig. 2.4 Cabot Circus in Bristol, U.K., is a green retail project from Hammerson. Photo: © Bristol Alliance
The scheme is the first retail project of its kind to achieve the highest BREEAM rating of Excellent. Key environmental achievements include: • Eighty-five percent of waste was recycled during construction including store fitout waste • Seventy percent of construction workers lived within 25 miles • “Considerate contractors” average score of 33 (out of 40) • Lighting energy use reduction through intelligent lighting controls • Sustainable tenant fitout guidance and assessment document • Rainwater harvesting system • Roof gardens within residential areas.
2.3.1.1 Sustainability Guidelines The developer provided environmental guidance for all tenants through a number of initiatives, including a store fitout guide, retailer and on-site management training and an education and green issues awareness program. Lighting to streets uses high efficacy LED lighting where appropriate. Motion detectors control back-of-house area lighting to significantly reduce energy use. Car park lighting energy usage costs are reduced 50% through the use of intelligent controls and high-efficiency lamps. An enhanced level of control allows three-stage switching of lighting to all levels, linked to daylight sensors to ensure that lighting is not on during daylight hours. Perimeter lighting is also controlled independently of lighting further into each floor. The architectural design of the scheme took advantage of natural
2.3
United Kingdom (U.K.)
31
Fig. 2.5 The £350 million Highcross shopping center in Leicester, U.K., is a significant contribution to a city revitalization project and is rated Very Good by the BREEAM rating system. Photo: © Hammerson
ventilation to reduce the energy demands associated with heating and cooling via large air handling systems, saving around 5 million kWh annually. Building materials with low environmental impact were used throughout the project. Sustainably harvested timber and mineral wool insulation, along with recyclable materials such as zinc and copper, were used in preference to less recyclable materials. Materials such as natural stone, brick, steel, glass and landscaping were predominantly U.K.-sourced where possible. During construction, the project recycled 90% of steel waste, and 80% of timber waste was chipped and recycled. By design, some 40% of concrete came from recycled sources. Low-water-use fixtures were installed in residential units, landlord and public areas. The rainwater harvesting system captures rainwater from the street canopies for reuse in flushing toilets and irrigation throughout the project. Another Hammerson project is Highcross, shown in Fig. 2.5. Of this project and Hammerson’s overall approach, Edwards says, When I joined Hammerson in 2007, we basically drew a line in the sand on all of our projects in construction and asked: What is the current sustainability status on all of these projects? We called it a sustainability profile. We did this for Cabot Circus and Highcross. We found that they would have achieved a BREEAM Very Good. We reviewed all of the aspects of Very Good and then all of the aspects of how to get to Excellent [the next level], including how much it would cost. It was basically a case of focusing the teams’ minds as much as anything. That initial investigation came back saying it was going to cost us £2 million at Cabot Circus and £2.6 million at Highcross. Following a detailed and thorough review with the design team and main contractor, we found it was just simple things that
32
2
Green Buildings Around the World
were missed or points hadn’t been claimed and the cost at Cabot Circus was reduced to just under £300,000. We invested in modeling the stores and reorganized the way we actually approached BREEAM. Highcross is an extension to an existing asset and so it posed much more difficult questions, and the cost turned out to be prohibitive at that particular time in the project. So at Cabot Circus it turned out not to be a huge cost to take it to Excellent and the Bristol Alliance agreed that the investment was worth it. The main things we’ve done are incorporate high efficiency lighting, daylighting, natural ventilation, high efficiency boilers, rainwater collection and use of sustainable materials. We also completed an exercise with WRAP—Waste Recycling Action Program, a government program. Through that, we found we could change minor things that created a better, more sustainable project, such as increasing the recycled content of blockwork. In summary, it is much easier to achieve a higher rating at a lower cost if you start early. BREEAM does not solve sustainable development, its merely acts as a directional tool.
2.4 Austria In Central Europe, SES SPAR European Shopping Centers (SES) operates a number of shopping centers with a strong focus on sustainability. In 2008, ICSC recognized two of its centers in Austria with ReSOURCE awards: Q19 Einkaufsquartier Döbling in Vienna and ATRIO in Villach, which also received a commendation in the medium-size award category [10, 11]. SES received the award for its efforts to ensure the efficient use of energy, waste disposal and use of locally sourced materials, and also for the strong social- and community-oriented strategies to ensure the integration of the centers within the social and economic infrastructure of existing towns. For example, ATRIO caters to three distinct cultures, Austria, Italy and Slovenia, providing a real heart to the crossborder community and living up to its motto “Sensa Confini”—without borders. The program of the center adopts the motto of the three countries’ cross-border Olympic bid. The traditional Roman idea of the atrium is reborn in both the name of the center and the central plaza idea. The architectural concept arranges the mall and the Interspar hypermarket around this glazed central plaza (50 × 60 m), creating a new urban square for the city of Villach. ATRIO saves energy with a concept that transforms most of its foundation into geothermal “energy piles” making use of geothermal energy assisted by a district heating system from a local power plant. External LED lighting meets all current European regulations. Recycling is aggressive, and the center was subjected to a stringent environmental impact assessment before building permission was granted. R At the Q19 shopping center in Vienna (Wien-Döbling), translucent Teflon roofs are illuminated to create a space that appears to open to the sky and saves energy. Q19 utilizes energy-efficient cooling systems, benefiting from less use of electricity, with higher electrical rates designed during periods of peak demand to reduce daytime usage. Water and energy consumption are monitored constantly. LED lighting of the facade is used to create strong architectural effects. With landscaped, planted roofing and green public green areas, biodiversity and community comfort make Q19 an example of environmental, social and economic sustainability.
2.5
Japan
33
2.5 Japan AEON is a large Japanese retailer that has approached sustainability and retail development in a very systematic way [12]. To understand its approach to green buildings requires an appreciation of the high-level principles and goals it has adopted for corporate sustainability generally. In 2004 and 2005, AEON released an “Agenda for Prevention of Global Warming” and a “Midterm Plan for Prevention of Global Warming.” Its new developments since then have incorporated the company’s philosophy and action agenda. As a retailer, AEON developed three principles to inform its sustainable agenda: first, prevent global warming through improvements in logistics; second, prevent global warming through building and operating the stores; and third, prevent global warming through acting with customers. In March 2008, the company released the “AEON Declaration for Prevention of Global Warming.” In this declaration, AEON set a goal for carbon dioxide emission reduction of 30% by 2012, compared to 2006 emissions levels. This goal represents a reduction in carbon dioxide emissions of 1,850,000 metric tons. To implement the declaration, the company set numeric targets for installing photovoltaic panels on 300 stores and planting 11 million trees worldwide. To further implement the declaration, AEON developed an “Eco-Store” concept to study effective environmental measures for its stores. Based on the studies, AEON opened the first eco-store, AEON Chikusa Shopping Center in Nagoya city, in May 2005. The company has since opened eight eco-stores in Japan; for example, in the shopping centers AEON Kashiwa in Kashiwa city, Chiba prefecture; AEON Dainichi in Moriguchi city in Osakaj; AEON Kagoshima in Kagoshima city; Maxvalu Taki; AEON Laketown (shown in Fig. 2.6) and AEON Hiezu.
Fig. 2.6 AEON shopping center in Laketown, Japan, received high marks from that country’s CASBEE rating system. Courtesy of AEON Retail Ltd.
34
2
Green Buildings Around the World
These stores introduced eco-friendly measures such as utilizing solar energy, planting trees, installing advanced HVAC systems and using recycled materials. Through self-assessment, these stores got “A” ratings from Japan’s CASBEE6 system. CASBEE further certified an even higher “S” ranking for AEON Laketown Shopping Center, which reduced carbon dioxide by more than 20%, compared with a typical center. This shopping center won additional awards, including an Ecobuild Award, Lighting Dissemination Award and Environmental Equipment Design Award in 2006 and an Assessment Case Study award from the World Sustainable Building Conference in 2005.
2.6 Australia Green Star is the Australian green building rating system. In the summer of 2008, the Green Building Council of Australia introduced a new version of Green Star for retail centers. The first three certified projects under this new standard came from the pilot system used to test the applicability of the rating criteria. The Mirvac Group’s Orion Springfield Shopping Center in southeast Queensland, near Ipswich (shown in Fig. 2.7), was rated at 6 Star Green Star (World Leader) in 2008 [13]. The Center houses about 110 shops in 35,000-m2 of space, with a Main Street, Town Square, and connecting malls. Mirvac’s strong commitment to sustainability is found in its broad participation in national and global sustainability programs, including the 2006 and 2007 Climate Disclosure Leadership Index (CDLI) and a listing on the U.K.’s “FTSE4Good” Global Index [14]. The Australian SAM
Fig. 2.7 Orion Springfield is Australia’s first Green Star rated shopping center. Photography courtesy of Christopher Frederick Jones
6 CASBEE
is the Japanese equivalent of LEED and BREEAM.
2.7
Turkey
35
Sustainability Index (AuSSI) recognizes Mirvac as one of the top sustainabilitydriven companies within the entire Australian economy [15]. The cost of the Orion Springfield project is estimated at A$130 million, with an additional A$2.5 million (about 2%) spent on green building initiatives, which the company predicts will offer a payback period of six years. According to Mirvac, this shopping center is already saving money operationally compared to other centers in its portfolio and is future-proofed to meet tenant and consumer demand for sustainable buildings over the coming decade [16]. The Chadstone Shopping Center in Melbourne, Victoria, was rated at 5 Star Green Star (Australian Excellence), also in the Green Star pilot program, while the Westfield Doncaster Shopping Center, an A$600 million redevelopment in Melbourne, was rated at 4 Star Green Star (Best Practice). The 120,000-m2 (1.29-million-ft2 ) Doncaster Center implemented some unique initiatives, including two 50,000-l (13,200-gal) rainwater harvesting tanks to provide water for general cleaning and irrigation purposes, solar hot water panels, light fixtures with energy-saver lamps and sophisticated building management systems that monitor and minimize energy use [17].
2.7 Turkey The Germany-based Metro Group Asset Management company opened its center in Meydan in 2007. The parent Metro Group is one of the largest international retailing companies. In 2007 the Group reached sales of around C64 billion. The company has about 290,000 employees and operates over 2,100 stores in 32 countries [18]. Metro Group has had a sustainability program in place since 2002, with the goal of identifying the relevant social and ecological challenges facing the company, with resulting practical actions and objectives to maximize opportunities and/or minimize risks for the company [19]. Metro Group is particularly focused on using renewable energy systems, including solar and geothermal. Metro Group Asset Management realized high-level green building standards with its Meydan Shopping Square (shown in Fig. 2.8), which opened in Istanbul in October 2007. A sustainable energy concept is the main characteristic of the Shopping Square. One of Europe’s largest geothermal plants is located beneath the center; in summer the plant cools the center and in winter, it heats it. The geothermal plant helps to save 1.3 million kWh of primary energy per year as well as 350 tons of carbon dioxide. The Meydan Shopping Square has about 30,000 m2 (323,000 ft2 ) of green roof space. This project has already received several international awards since it opened, including the Prime Property Award 2008 at the Expo Real conference in Munich, which recognizes properties that combine sustainable management with social requirements, and the Award for Excellence of the Urban Land Institute (ULI) Europe. Following the opening of the Meydan Shopping Square, Metro planned to open another shopping center in Istanbul, Merter, which will open in mid-2009 and feature a sustainable climate control concept: a solar chilling system built on the roof of
36
2
Green Buildings Around the World
Fig. 2.8 The 30,000-m2 green roof on Metro Development’s Meydan center in Istanbul, Turkey, not only offers a space to linger but also helps control the building’s internal climate. Photo © Mr. Murat Pulat
the center. Solar chilling technology is new: Parabolic troughs form a field of collectors and capture the energy from the rays of the sun. The resulting high-temperature water can be utilized in winter in the heating system of the building. In summer the steam from the hot water is transformed into cool air in an absorption refrigeration system and thus used for climate control.
2.8 Singapore The Singapore Building and Construction Authority (BCA) awarded the City Square Mall in Singapore, a project of City Developments Limited (CDL), the Platinum Green Mark in 2007. This is the first time that the government awarded this top-tier Green Mark certification to a private developer for a commercial building [20]. The BCA Platinum Green Mark is awarded to exemplary green projects that demonstrate 30% energy and water savings, as well as environmentally sustainable building practices and innovative green features. Shown in Fig. 2.9, the 700,000-ft2 mall is projected to reduce its energy usage by approximately 39% compared to standard designs. This savings results in an estimated emission reduction of over 5,700 metric tons of carbon dioxide per year. CDL invested approximately 5% of the total construction cost into the development of the center’s numerous green innovations. The City Square Mall’s design features include many Singaporean firsts. It is the first shopping mall project to be integrated with an urban park. It is the first commercial project to boast a pneumatic waste collection system for an odor-free
2.9
China
37
Fig. 2.9 City Square Mall in Singapore was the first such development to be awarded the government’s platinum Green Mark. Artist’s impression courtesy of City Developments Limited
and pest-free environment, built with separate chutes to encourage recycling of food and dry waste. It is also the first shopping mall to have motion sensors fitted into the basement parking garage to control the lighting level for vehicles.
2.9 China An interesting example of an early LEED-certified shopping center in China is the LeSong Mall in the northeastern city of Harbin [21]. The LeSong Mall is a four-story, 642,000-ft2 (60,000-m2 ) building with a retail capacity of 135 shops, including supermarkets and retail stores. Developed by Hadian Real Estate Company, LeSong Mall achieved LEED Silver certification in 2005 under the LEED-CS pilot program.
2.9.1 LeSong Mall LeSong Mall was designed to reduce energy consumption by 29% compared to the prevailing LEED baseline standard. The building also saves water through use of water-efficient plumbing fixtures. Low-VOC (low off-gassing) paints and lowemitting carpeting were used to improve indoor air quality. Construction waste materials were recycled or reused, with over 75% of construction waste diverted from the waste stream. The project also used locally sourced materials for more than 20% of value of all construction materials.
38
2
Green Buildings Around the World
2.9.1.1 Energy Efficiency Measures Energy efficiency measures include high-efficiency lighting, daylighting controls, additional insulation above code, high-efficiency glazing, demand-control ventilation and chillers with heat recovery for domestic hot water production. The lighting power density was reduced by 20%, from the original design of 25 W per m2 to 20 W per m2 (from 2.32 to 1.86 W per ft2 ). Lighting controls are used to automatically dim or turn off lighting in daylight spaces. Daylighting controls act to reduce the overall building peak electrical load in two ways: first by direct reduction of lighting energy use, and second by reducing the cooling load demand resulting from the waste heat of electric lighting. Daylighting controls were used within 15 feet of perimeter window areas, and in the open mall area under the barrel-vault skylight. Ventilation for the building is achieved through a demand-controlled ventilation control scheme employing carbon dioxide sensors to monitor and control ventilation. This approach effectively matches ventilation to actual occupancy of the building, thereby reducing heating and cooling costs. Use of more efficient lighting, along with an improved thermal envelope, allowed for a “downsizing” of installed chiller capacity by nearly 17% over the baseline building, saving a capital cost of RMB 649,440 (US$93,000).7
2.9.2 Central Walk Another interesting Chinese project, designed by the U.S. firm Callison Architecture, is the Central Walk project in Shenzhen, encompassing 135,000 m2 (1.5 million ft2 ) of high-end retail, dining and outdoor public space, shown in Fig. 2.10. Central Walk attempts to balance environmental responsibility and resource efficiency with commercial viability. To achieve this, several factors, including access to public transportation and green space, optimized energy performance and a green roof, were incorporated to make Central Walk a significant green mall in China. The building’s recessed design allows the roof garden to seamlessly connect with the street-level garden walkways and activities. Integrated landscaping and cascading gardens throughout the project foster physical and visual connections to nature. At 26,000 m2 (276,000 ft2 ), the roof garden reduces the heat island effect while restoring open space and natural habitat. The subterranean design and daylighting optimize energy performance. Roof skylights provide daylight to lower levels to reduce dependence on artificial lighting during the day. The vertical design stacks the rooftop public park on top of a four-story retail center with underground parking, while the center’s direct connection to the city’s new subway line and bus system, along with walkways and footbridges, promotes a pedestrian-friendly environment [22].
7 Conversion
rate of approximately 7 RMB = $1 US.
References
39
Fig. 2.10 Central Walk shopping mall, opened in 2007 in Shenzhen, China. Courtesy of Callison/Chris Eden
2.10 Summary In terms of greening the retail sector, there’s little doubt that the retail landscape worldwide will look much different by 2012. In spite of the poor economic climate for retail development and retail in general prevailing in 2008 and 2009, one can still expect that the number of large retailers and developers announcing green building initiatives will accelerate in 2009 and reach a crescendo in the 2010 to 2015 period. The number of shopping center developers building certified green retail centers will increase, so there will be hundreds of new projects registered each year and dozens certified. The engagement of center developers with the public sector, in terms of entitlement (political approval) benefits and green project requirements, will feed this trend.
References 1. USGBC project registration statistics, available at http://www.usgbc.org/leed. These numbers are updated monthly. 2. Melaver project receives 2nd LEED certification. (2007, February 22). Savannah Morning News. Retrieved on March 31, 2007, from http://www.abercorncommon.com/ index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=20. 3. Shops 600 at Abercorn Common receive LEED Silver certification. (2007, February 25). Retrieved on March 31, 2007, from www.prleap.com/pr/67257. 4. First Capital Realty Annual Report. (2006). Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://www.firstcapitalrealty.ca/Files/Annual Report/fin_e_28.pdf
40
2
Green Buildings Around the World
5. Information supplied by First Capital Realty. 6. Giant Eagle becomes first LEED certified supermarket. (2004, December, 27) Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://www.greenbiz.com/news/news_third.cfm?NewsID=27528. 7. Interview with Nick Cowling, Senior Manager, Communications and External Affairs, Home Depot of Canada Inc., June 2007. 8. Interview with Paul Edwards, November 2008. 9. Cabot Circus media information provided by Hammerson PLC. 10. ICSC ReSource Award goes to Sonae Sierra. (26 April 2007). ICSC Press Release. 11. SES Spar European Shopping Centers web site. Retrieved on 28 December 2008, from http://www.ses-european.com/ATRIO.3f2bc4f96c.s33.24.1.html. 12. Interview responses from Jyunji Kinoshita and Kitase Tadashi, Group Environmental and Social Contribution Department, AEON, December 2008. 13. Orion Springfield web site. Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://www. orionspringfield.com.au/sustainability, accessed December 28, 2008. 14. FTSE4Good Global Index. Retrieved March 16, 2009, from http://www.ftse.com/Indices/ FTSE4Good_Index_Series/index.jsp. 15. Mirvac web site. Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://www.mirvac.com/ sustainability-overview. 16. Green Building Council Australia. (2008). p. 32. The Dollars and Sense of Green Buildings. 17. Westfield Doncaster the passion for fashion. (16 October 2008). Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://whatswhat.com.au/fashion/news-and-celebrity/alicias-blog/2008/10/ 16_Westfield_Doncaster_Redevelopment_Unveiled.html. 18. Interview with Arco Rehorst, Metro Group, November 2008. 19. Metro Group web site. Retrieved on December 28, 2008, from http://www.metrogroup.de/ sustainability. 20. Information provided by City Developments Ltd., December 2008. 21. Information supplied by Abhishek Lal and Jason Hainline, EMSI, www.emsi-green.com. 22. Personal communication, Callison Architecture, January 2009.
Chapter 3
What Is a Green Building?
Following a worldwide survey of the green building movement, this chapter takes a closer look at green building design and certification systems, the core of any strategy for greening retail buildings and developments. Since 2000, the green building movement has become increasingly influential in the public and institutional sector and in private-sector office buildings. However, it is just beginning to be noticed in the retail sector, as retailers and developers start to engage in major sustainability initiatives. Greening the retail sector is an important component of the overall green building movement; in the U.S., for example, more than 20,000 retail buildings are built annually, and they comprise the second-largest commercial building sector, after office buildings.
3.1 Green Buildings Since 2000 Green buildings and sustainable design have been major movements in the design, development and construction industry since about 2000, with an accelerating interest since 2006. Figure 3.1 shows the growth of green buildings in the U.S., in terms of cumulative LEED project registrations and certifications, both increasing 75% in 2007 alone, and more than 80% in 2008, versus the prior year. In this respect, the acceptance and practice of green building design, after growing steadily from 2000 to 2005, in fact began accelerating from 2006 to 2008 (equating green commercial buildings in the U.S. with LEED-certified buildings). A similar situation holds true, with less dramatic growth, for the U.K.’s BREEAM system, as shown in Table 3.6. However, a large majority of such projects are still at a basic level of green design, as shown by the number of LEED Certified and Silver projects as a percentage of the total. By the end of 2008, total LEED for New Construction and Major Renovations (LEED-NC) project certifications (U.S. projects only) numbered 1,420 (including the four major systems—LEED for New Construction and Major Renovations, LEED for Core and Shell, LEED for Commercial Interiors, and LEED for Existing Buildings: Operations and Maintenance), total certifications were 2,213. Table 3.1 shows the growth of each of these programs since 2004, through the end J. Yudelson, Sustainable Retail Development, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5_3, C 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers Copyright
41
42
3 What Is a Green Building?
Fig. 3.1 The growth of new LEED registered projects in the U.S. has consistently grown at more than 50% per annum
of 2008, shown by the number of new projects registering their interest in pursuing eventual certification. Table 3.2 shows that the relative percentage of high-performance LEED-NC certifications (Gold and Platinum) represent about 35% of the total, with Platinum representing some 113 U.S. projects, or 5% of the total. Looking at these numbers, it is easy to want to focus on Gold and Platinum projects. However, most retail projects are still at the more basic LEED Silver and Certified levels. Table 3.1 Growth of All LEED Project Registrations, 2004–2008 [1] LEED system LEED-NC LEED-CS LEED-CI LEED-EB Total a
2008 9,555a 2,147 1,757 2,063 15,522
2007
2006
2005
2004
5,800 1,147 852 769
3,895 325 462 244
2,758 142 233 151
1,792 62 106 88
8,568
4,926
3,284
2,048
Numbers are cumulative, beginning in 2004.
3.2
High-Performance Building Characteristics
43
Table 3.2 LEED-NC Certifications by Attainment Level, December 2008a Level Certified Silver Gold Platinum Total a
Number of certified projects 664 711 635 113 2,123
Percentage of total certifications 31.2% 33.5 30.0 5.3 100.0
Numbers are cumulative, beginning in 2004.
3.2 High-Performance Building Characteristics What do the terms “green building” and “high-performance building” actually mean? A green building is one that considers and then reduces its impact on the environment and human health. A green building uses considerably less energy and water than a conventional building and has fewer site impacts and generally higher levels of indoor air quality. It also accounts for some measure of the life-cycle impact of choices between various types of building materials, furniture and furnishings. Green building benefits result from better site development practices; design and construction choices; and the cumulative effects of operation, maintenance, removal and possible reuse of building materials and systems. In the U.S. and Canada, a green building is generally considered to be one certified by the LEED green building rating system of the USGBC or Canada Green Building Council (CaGBC).1 For our purposes, we will use “high-performance” buildings to designate those that achieve a certification from the U.S. or Canadian LEED systems, or from the U.K.’s BREEAM system, or from the Australian Green Star.2 This is not entirely a fair choice, because there are some excellent green buildings that have not sought certification; however, increasingly, one must ask that a high-performance building achieve a reputable third-party certification, since otherwise there would be no standards at all for the definition. This said, the retail industry has criticized LEED for certain requirements that it feels are not realistic for the retail store or development. For example, retail stores tend to use more lighting than the office buildings that are still the core application for the LEED rating system. In response, the USGBC has worked with the retail industry in the U.S. to develop a specific LEED for Retail standard (for individual stores) that will become an official certification program in August 2009, following a 1 This
is the author’s viewpoint and not necessarily that of the ICSC or its members. U.S. ENERGY STAR labeling system deals only with the relative energy performance of a building compared with others of similar use, while in contrast, LEED and BREEAM are absolute, objective standards. It is an important label, but falls short of being a green building certification. The same holds true for the European Union’s energy use labels under the Energy Performance in Buildings Directive, scheduled for full implementation in 2010.
2 The
44
3 What Is a Green Building?
two-year “pilot program” or “beta test.” The primary “missing link” still is a rating system for overall shopping centers; USGBC and the industry are working on an equitable rating system for such centers, but this is unlikely to be in place before 2010. The essence of LEED and BREEAM is a point-based rating system that allows vastly different green building practices to be compared, using one resulting aggregate score. This provides an owner, tenant or developer with the ability to label a wide variety of buildings and to rate very dissimilar approaches to sustainable construction and operations with one composite score. Some people may argue with the relative importance of various categories of environmental concern, but both of these rating systems have stood the test of time through continuous improvement and openness to intelligent modification and innovation. Because they are pointbased, LEED and BREEAM also appeal to the competitive spirit in the retail psyche, which values winning very highly and often associates getting “more points” with beating the competition. Interestingly, LEED and BREEAM are seen around the world as good examples of rating systems that are practical to use, but which still signal achievements in sustainable construction and operations far above the norm for most buildings.3 Over the years, LEED and BREEAM have continually adjusted their credit requirements to stay at the leading edge of green building design. In 2009, for example, LEED credits were revised, reflecting a rigorous “life-cycle assessment” approach, giving each credit equal weight for equal environmental benefit. This new system gives owners, along with design and construction teams, far more flexibility in picking which credits to pursue in a given geographic region or for meeting client preferences that might, for example, value energy savings or water savings much more than the current system. In September 2006, the U.S. General Services Administration reported to the U.S. Congress that it would use only the LEED system for assessing the government’s own projects [2]. The U.S. Army adopted LEED in 2008, to replace its own homegrown “Spirit” rating systems. Therefore, in the commercial and institutional arena, if a project is not rated and certified by an independent third party, such as LEED or BREEAM, it can’t really be called a green building, since there’s no other standard definition. Companies are of course free to come up with their own programs, but these still have to meet the test of general public and media acceptance, something that the USGBC and the LEED system have accomplished over the past ten years. If someone states they are “following LEED or BREEAM” but not applying for certification of the final building, one should wonder if the final construction will really achieve the expected results, especially if there is no detailed documentation 3 For
example, a similar approach is being pursued by the German Green Building Council, Deutsche Gesellschaft für nachhaltiges Bauen, which formed in 2007, www.dgnb.de. The Germans began to issue their certificate of sustainable building excellence, “Deutsches Gütesiegel Nachhaltiges Bauen,” early in 2009. See Appendix A.
3.3
Green Building Practices
45
and independent third-party review of results. If they say they are doing “sustainable design,” you have a right to ask, “Against what standard are you measuring your design, and how are you going to prove what you did?” Most retail buildings don’t yet measure up to any accepted standard of a green building. However, that situation is undergoing rapid change for the better, as more retailers and developers are engaging in store and project certification using accepted green building certification programs.
3.3 Green Building Practices A green building uses design and construction practices that significantly reduce or eliminate the negative impact of buildings on the environment and occupants. In the LEED and BREEAM systems, these practices include building location, water and energy use, environmentally preferable purchasing and waste management activities, improved indoor environmental quality and a “continuous improvement” approach to green building innovations. Though owned by the USGBC and BRE, respectively, the LEED and BREEAM rating systems are publicly available documents; they have been kept current and improved over time. The new LEED 2009 system, effective April 27, 2009, has greater flexibility for building teams to consider regional issues, a strong focus on life-cycle assessment and a better way to handle alternative approaches to designing “low-carbon” buildings. In this way it has moved closer to the BREEAM system. Table 3.3 shows the six major categories in the LEED-NC 2009 (for new construction and major renovations) rating system for commercial and institutional buildings and mid-rise and high-rise residential towers above four stories. At first thought, many people think of a green building as one that primarily uses less energy and possibly uses recycled-content materials. Looking at the entire LEED rating system, one can see that the categories of concern are much broader and more comprehensive than just saving energy. Most practitioners in the design, development and construction industry in the United States and Canada have embraced this system over all other competing standards and definitions. One piece of evidence for this viewpoint is the more than 77,000 industry professionals who have already become LEED Accredited Professionals by national exam [3]. From the standpoint of commercial buildings, the LEED rating system is heavily weighted toward saving energy. However, it’s virtually impossible to get LEED Silver or Gold ratings without paying close attention to the sustainable sites criteria, water conservation measures, providing higher levels of indoor environmental quality and engaging in choices that conserve materials and resources. In this sense LEED Silver and Gold projects are fairly balanced across all five main groups of environmental attributes (see Table 8.1). In certified retail projects the main difference between Gold and Silver is a higher level of energy savings in the Gold project.
46
3 What Is a Green Building? Table 3.3 LEED-NC 2009 System Categories of Concern
Category
Total points
Issues evaluated by the LEED-NC 2009 system
1. Sustainable sites
26
2. Water efficiency
10
3. Energy efficiency
35
4. Materials/resources
14
5. Indoor environment
15
6. Innovation
10
Avoiding sensitive sites; promoting urban infill; locating to facilitate use of public transportation; reducing site impacts of construction; creating open space; enhanced stormwater management; lowering the urban heat island effect and controlling light pollution Encouraging water conservation in landscape irrigation and building fixtures; promoting wastewater reuse from on-site sewage treatment Energy conservation; using renewable energy systems; building commissioning; reduced use of ozone-depleting chemicals in HVAC systems; energy monitoring and green power use Use of existing buildings; facilitating construction waste recycling; use of salvaged materials, recycled-content materials, regionally produced materials, agricultural-based materials and certified wood products Improved ventilation and indoor air quality; use of nontoxic finishes and furniture; green housekeeping; daylighting and views to the outdoors; thermal comfort and individual control of lighting and HVAC systems Exemplary performance in exceeding LEED standards; use of innovative approaches to green design and operations; four points for addressing regional issues
3.4 The LEED Rating Systems LEED rates all buildings across five major categories of concern, using key environmental attributes in each category. LEED collects and incorporates a wide variety of best practices across many disciplines including architecture, engineering, interior design, landscape architecture and construction. It is a mixture of performance standards (for example, save 20% of the energy use of a typical building) and prescriptive standards (for example, use paints with less than 50 g per l of volatile organic compounds), but leans more toward the performance approach. In other words, LEED believes that best practices are better shown by measuring results (outcomes) not by prescribing efforts alone (inputs). Until 2009, each LEED rating system had a different number of total points, so that scores could only be compared within each system; however, the method for rewarding achievement is identical, so that a LEED Gold project for New Construction represents in some way the same level of achievement (and degree of difficulty) as a LEED Gold project for Commercial Interiors (tenant improvements).
3.4
The LEED Rating Systems
47
Fig. 3.2 LEED for New Construction and Major Renovations distributes its points across six different environmental attributes
Figure 3.2 shows how the LEED-NC rating system splits points into the five major categories of concern. LEED version 2.2 project attainment levels are rewarded as follows4 : Certified Silver Gold Platinum
>40% of the 64 core points in the system >50% of the core points >60% of the core points >80% of the core points
The LEED rating system is a form of an eco-label that describes the environmental attributes of the project, similar to the nutrition labels on food. Prior to the advent of LEED, there was no labeling of buildings other than for their energy use, R program. While useful in as found in the federal government’s ENERGY STAR presenting a building’s energy use compared with all other buildings of the same type in a given region, ENERGY STAR gives an incomplete picture of a building’s overall environmental impact. The LEED scorecard shows a project’s achievement in each credit category and allows you to quickly assess the sustainable strategies used by the building team (Fig. 3.3) The irony here is that a $20 million building that is not LEED-certified has less labeling than a $2 box of animal crackers, in terms of its “nutritional” benefits
4 LEED
2009 will award certificate levels based on the same percentages of the 100 “core” points in the new system.
48
3 What Is a Green Building?
Fig. 3.3 An example of a “LEED Scorecard” showing points garnered by this LEED Gold-rated Office Depot project. Redrawn with permission from Office Depot
(energy use, water use, waste generation, etc.) and its basic ingredients (materials and systems). Owners of commercial buildings have far less knowledge of what is in the building they just built or bought than one might think, because the construction process is messy: there are usually thousands of design decisions made, along with many product and materials substitutions and changes during construction, and there is seldom money left over to document what really went into the building, so that the construction documents often give an incomplete or even inaccurate picture of what is actually in the building and how all of the building systems are supposed to work together. (The case may be slightly different for retail prototypes, but even so, there are a lot of changes to accommodate site conditions and local codes.) To understand a building’s ingredients and its expected performance (including operating costs for energy and water), an eco-label such as LEED, BREEAM or Green Star is especially valuable both to building owners and to occupants who may naturally be more concerned about how healthy the building is rather than how much water it saves. Figure 3.3 shows the LEED scorecard for an Office Depot certified project.
3.4
The LEED Rating Systems
49
Complicating this rather straightforward percentage method (for determining levels of LEED certification) is the addition of a sixth category with up to 10 “bonus” points for “innovation and design process.” In addition to securing a certain number of points, each rating system has “prerequisites” that each project must meet, no matter what level of attainment it achieves. For example, a LEED 2009-certified building must reduce energy use to at least 10% below that of a comparable building that just meets the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) 90.1-2007 standard for building energy performance.5 Table 3.4 shows the four major systems that account for the vast majority of LEED registered and certified projects as of December 2008 (not including the LEED for Homes and LEED for Neighborhood Development pilot programs). From this table, you can see that the LEED-CS system is the second most popular, followed by LEED-EB (now LEED for Existing Buildings Operations and Maintenance). To best understand LEED, think of it as a self-assessed, third-party-verified rating system. (In that sense, it is like the U.S. income tax system: you decide what you owe, and a third party—the Internal Revenue Service—decides if you are correct!) In the case of a LEED certification, a project team estimates the particular credits for which a project qualifies and submits its documentation to the USGBC, which assigns the review to an independent third party; there is a one-step appeal process for situations in which the project proponent disagrees with the reviewers’ decisions. Table 3.4 The Major LEED Rating Systems for Commercial Buildings, December 2008 Rating system
Percentage of total registrations [4]
Percentage of total certifications
LEED for New Construction (LEED-NC) LEED for Core and Shell (LEED-CS) LEED for Commercial Interiors (LEED-CI) LEED for Existing Buildings (LEED-EB)
61.6 13.8 11.3 13.3
67.1 6.0 18.8 8.1
3.4.1 LEED for New Construction The most widely known and used LEED system is LEED-NC, which is useful for all new buildings (except core and shell developments), major renovations and housing of four stories and above. Table 3.3 captures the essence of the LEED-NC rating system’s major categories of concern. Through the end of 2008, about 62% of LEED projects were registered and 67% were certified using the LEED-NC assessment 5 ASHRAE 90.1-2007 is the accepted U.S. and Canadian standard for measuring expected building
energy performance against a standard or “building code-compliant” similar building designed and constructed without additional energy-efficiency measures.
50
3 What Is a Green Building?
method. LEED-NC has frequently been used as the assessment system for retail stand-alone buildings, along with the pilot version of LEED-NC for Retail. A LEED-NC rating is typically awarded after a building is completed and occupied, since it requires a final checkout process known as “building commissioning” before the award can be made. Under the current LEED version 2.2, certain credits known as “design phase” credits can be assessed at the end of design and prior to construction completion, but no final certification is made until all credits are reviewed after substantial completion of the project.
3.4.2 LEED for Core and Shell Buildings LEED for Core and Shell is a system employed typically by speculative developers who control less than 50% of a building’s tenant improvements at the time of construction. They may build out 40% of the space for a lead tenant, for example, and then rent the rest of the building to several tenants who will take much smaller spaces. LEED-CS is a popular system for developers building retail shell spaces, and it works well as long as the developer also provides the HVAC system and requires certain green building measures as part of the tenant’s lease. LEED-CS allows a developer to precertify a design at a certain level of attainment, then use the LEED rating to attract tenants and, in some cases, financing. LEED-CS also allows a “design phase” review if precertification is not requested. Once the building is finished, the developer submits documentation to secure a final LEED rating. Figure 3.4 shows how the LEED credits in the five main categories are distributed in the LEED-CS system. Except for having eight fewer total points (including two fewer points for energy efficiency), the distribution of credits is quite similar to LEED-NC.6 The benefit of the LEED-CS system for a retail center developer is that marketing cannot wait until a building is finished. By allowing a precertification, using a system very similar to LEED-NC, the LEED-CS rating assists the developer in securing tenants and thereby encourages more green buildings. Not only that, LEED-CS awards a point for creating tenant guidelines that encourage each tenant to use the LEED-CI system to build out their interior spaces. If that happens, the result is similar to a LEED for New Construction building, and everyone is happy! In the commercial office sector, there is growing evidence that a LEED-CS certification helps developers to lease space faster and attract better tenants. There is also evidence that ENERGY STAR-labeled buildings attract higher rents and result in higher resale values [5, 6]. To date, there are no similar studies for the retail sector, as it is at a much earlier stage of market penetration for green buildings.
6 See
the presentation of LEED 2009 in Appendix 2, in which all of the four major rating systems now have the same number of points.
3.4
The LEED Rating Systems
51
Fig. 3.4 LEED for Core and Shell can be used for shell retail spaces
3.4.3 LEED for Commercial Interiors LEED-CI is designed mainly for situations in which the base building systems are not changed and in which a tenant only takes up space in a much larger retail shell building. In this circumstance, the ability to affect total energy and water use, or such issues as open space, landscaping or stormwater management, is either much smaller or nonexistent. Thus, other green building measures are incorporated into the evaluation system. These measures include choices that retail tenants can make about lighting design, energy-using equipment, lighting control systems, submetering, furniture and furnishings, paints, carpet and composite wood products and length of tenancy. (Chapter 9 focuses on retail commercial interiors, showing how any store remodel or store in an existing retail building can adopt green construction and operating principles.) Figure 3.5 shows the distribution of credits in the LEED-CI 2009 rating system.
3.4.4 LEED for Existing Buildings: Operations and Maintenance LEED-EBOM was originally proposed and designed to be a method for assuring ongoing accountability of LEED-NC buildings over time. It has become instead a stand-alone rating system for building owners who want to benchmark their
52
3 What Is a Green Building?
Fig. 3.5 LEED for Commercial Interiors rating system can be used for store remodels
operations against a nationally recognized standard. LEED-EBOM addresses many issues not dealt with in new construction, including upgrades, operations and maintenance practices, environmentally preferable purchasing policies, waste management programs, green housekeeping, continuous monitoring of energy use, retrofitting water fixtures to cut use, relamping and a host of other measures that reduce the environmental footprint of a store or development. All of these issues are important for retailers and center operators, and Chapter 10 devotes considerable attention to them. By late 2008, of the first 110 LEED-EB project certifications, 14 projects had received LEED-EB Platinum ratings, and the system appeared to be gaining momentum, as new LEED-EB project registrations in 2008 increased by 268%. Figure 3.6 shows the distribution of credits in the LEED-EBOM 2009 rating system.
3.4.5 LEED for Neighborhood Development Sometime in 2009, the USGBC will adopt LEED-ND as a rating system, following a two-year pilot program with nearly 240 participating projects in 39 states and 6 countries. LEED for Neighborhood Development is a rating system that integrates the principles of smart growth, new urbanism and green building into the first national standard for neighborhood design. It is being developed by USGBC in partnership with the Congress for the New Urbanism (CNU) and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC). LEED-ND is the urban, mixed-use standard that moves away from certifying individual buildings to certifying large multiple-use developments. It’s beyond the scope of this book to consider LEED-ND, since it’s
3.5
Typical Green Building Measures
53
Fig. 3.6 LEED-EBOM allows developers and retailers to benchmark performance against established criteria
still in the pilot phase, but it may be of some interest to retail developers who do mixed-use projects that might include housing, offices, public buildings and other project types [7].
3.5 Typical Green Building Measures While there is no such thing as a “typical” green building, there are specific design and construction measures that are used in many high-performance buildings. Understanding these measures will help designers work with green builders, building owners, developers, facility managers, government officials, business clients, nonprofit executives or just interested stakeholders in a green building program. Based on the author’s analysis of the first 1,015 LEED-NC certified projects, the following technical measures are those that one might associate with a typical green building project: • Solar photovoltaic systems (44% of Platinum projects had at least 12.5% of total energy use supplied by PV systems, versus only 8% of Gold projects). • Site restoration (used in 88% of Platinum projects and 61% of Gold projects, but only 56% of Silver projects). • Carbon dioxide monitors (used in 96% of Platinum projects, 69% of Gold projects and 59% of Silver projects). • Green or LEED-compliant roofs (used in 84% of Platinum projects and 66% of Gold projects, versus 63% in LEED Silver projects) [8].
54
3 What Is a Green Building?
• Use of certified wood products (in 48% of Platinum projects and 42% of Gold projects, versus about 19% in all LEED-Silver certified projects) [8]. • Rapidly renewable materials such as cork and bamboo flooring (used in 28% of Platinum projects versus used in less than 5% of other projects). • Daylighting design (used in 84% of Platinum projects, 51% of Gold projects and only 41% of Silver projects). Many of these systems and approaches aren’t common because they have fewer opportunities (for example, hard-to-restore sites in dense urban areas), experience supply-chain difficulties or require greater initial cost. The primary reason, of course, for the lack of use of any green building measure is the higher initial cost, followed by the relative inexperience of design teams working with various systems and products. To illustrate the use of these measures, Table 3.5 presents an analysis of 25 LEED-NC Platinum and 105 LEED-NC Gold projects.7 There are more Platinum and Gold projects, of course, but the detailed project data from them is not readily available. Table 3.5 Use of LEED Credits in Gold and Platinum Projects
LEED credit category
Percentage of Platinum projects awarded this credit (n = 25)
Percentage of Gold projects awarded this credit (n = 105)
1. 2. 3.
88 96 84
61 61 66
76 44
44 8
64 84 84 28 48 96 68 84
42 55 90 8 42 69 36 59
60
37
84 88
51 68
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
Site restoration Stormwater control Urban heat island effect (green roof or ENERGY STAR roof) Light pollution reduction Renewable electricity (12.5%/15% of total) Measurement and verification Purchased green power Recycled content materials @ 20% Bio-based materials Certified wood @ 50% Carbon dioxide monitors High-efficiency ventilation @ 30% Improved air quality at occupancy Under-floor air systems for interior thermal comfort Daylighting Views to outdoors
7 Research
by Beth M. Duckles, a Ph.D. candidate at the University of Arizona, for Yudelson Associates, based on the USGBC web site, published data through the end of March 2008, http://www.usgbc.org.
3.6
To LEED or to Lead?
55
3.6 To LEED or to Lead? One reason that LEED has displaced ENERGY STAR as the preferred certification system for larger projects in the U.S. (although both may be used by developers and building owners) is that LEED focuses on a broader range of issues than just energy efficiency. These measures often can lead to reducing operating costs and improved occupant health, productivity and comfort. However, at this time in the U.S., LEED and ENERGY STAR both have marketplace acceptance as brand names that indicate a high level of energy and/or environmental performance against measurable and well-defined criteria. Both LEED and other building evaluation systems encourage an “integrated design” process, in which the building designers (mechanical, electrical, civil/structural and lighting engineers) are brought into the design process with the architectural and interiors team at an early stage, often during programming and conceptual design. Integrated design explores, for example, building orientation, massing and materials choices as critical issues affecting energy use and indoor air quality, and attempts to influence these decisions before the basic architectural design is fully developed.
3.6.1 Building Commissioning LEED also requires all certified buildings to be “commissioned,” through the use of performance testing and verification for all key energy-using and water-using systems. Typically, commissioning involves creating a plan for all systems to be tested, performing functional testing while the mechanical and controls contractors are still on the job, and providing the owner with a written report on the performance of all key systems and components. Green building commissioning involves third-party peer reviews during design to see if the design intent has actually been realized in the detailed construction documents. Finally, most commissioning programs also involve operator training and documentation of that training for future operators. Getting the future store and center maintenance staff involved is also a critical component of effective commissioning practice [9]. Commissioning is analogous to the sea trials a ship undergoes before it is handed over to the eventual owners. No ship would be put into use without such trials, which may expose flaws in design or construction. In the same way, no building should begin operations without a full “shakedown cruise” of all systems that use energy and affect comfort, health and productivity. Often the documentation provided by the commissioning process can be helpful later on in troubleshooting problems with building operations. When likened to sea trials, it seems amazing that any building would be built today without a full commissioning process, so it’s a good thing, absolutely essential for a high-performance building, that LEED requires it for all projects.
56
3 What Is a Green Building?
3.6.2 Low-Toxicity Finishes High-performance buildings achieve higher levels of indoor air quality through a careful choice of less toxic (low-VOC or no-VOC) paints, sealants, adhesives, carpets and coatings for the base building and tenant improvements, often in conjunction with building systems that provide higher levels of filtration and carbon dioxide monitors to regulate ventilation according to occupancy. With so many building occupants today having breathing problems and chemical sensitivities, it just makes good business sense to provide a healthy building. Documentation of these measures can often help provide extra backup when fighting claims of sick building syndrome. This benefit of risk management is an often overlooked aspect of green building guidelines, but can be useful to demonstrate to prospective tenants or occupants the often invisible measures taken by building designers and contractors to provide a safe and healthy indoor environment. Figure 3.7 suggests the potential reduction in health symptoms from better indoor air quality measures, especially in new buildings. Healthy buildings incorporate daylighting and views to the outdoors not only for occupant comfort, health and productivity gains, but also to reduce energy costs. There is a growing body of evidence strongly suggesting that daylighting, operable windows and views to the outdoors can increase productivity from 5 to 15%
Fig. 3.7 Improving indoor air quality leads to major reductions in health symptoms, improving overall employee productivity. Center for Building Performance Diagnostics, Carnegie Mellon University. eBIDSTM : Building Investment Decision Support Tool
3.7
LEED for Retail
57
and reduce illness, absenteeism and employee turnover for many companies [10]. Throw in higher levels of building controls that allow for such things as carbon dioxide monitoring and demand-controlled ventilation adjustments, for example, and one has an effective program addressing the people problem that can be sold to prospective tenants and other stakeholders. For retail stores, these savings alone are often enough to justify the extra costs of such projects. Considering that a large percentage of the non-product operating costs of retailers relate to employee salaries and benefits, it just makes good business sense to pay attention to productivity, comfort and health in building design and operations.
3.7 LEED for Retail Recognizing the importance of greening the retail sector, the USGBC inaugurated its LEED for Retail program, designed to test out changes to the LEED-NC and LEED-CI rating systems that would work better in retail, without compromising the rigor or integrity of the LEED system. About eighty projects signed up to participate in the LEED for Retail pilot program, where the resulting goal is to produce two LEED Retail ratings systems: LEED for Retail Commercial Interiors (intended for use by retail tenants) and LEED for Retail New Construction (for freestanding retail projects). At the time of this book, the LEED for Retail rating systems were being “harmonized” with the LEED 2009 scheme and prepared for USGBC member ballot in anticipation of a market launch as formal rating systems sometime in the summer of 2009. Justin Doak, now a principal of Ecoxera, LLC, a retail sustainability consultancy, was the project manager of the LEED for Retail program at USGBC. He describes some of the challenges of applying LEED to the retail sector [11]: Essentially the LEED for Retail rating systems recognize the unique nature of the retail environment and address the different types of spaces that retailers need for their distinctive project lines. By capturing the feedback of our pilot projects, we were able to develop a LEED program that would push the market forward, but at the same time not be too rigorous and discourage market adoption. When you go into an apparel supply store versus a quick service restaurant versus a supermarket, you’ll see a huge difference in the way that the stores are designed to accommodate their product lines. A grocery store requires a substantial amount of refrigeration because of perishable goods, floral departments and frozen products. An apparel store requires high-intensity lighting to showcase the clothing lines whereas restaurants with their commercial kitchens have both large regulated and unregulated energy demands. The challenge was that the existing LEED rating systems simply did not address these unique settings adequately and they also failed to provide the baselines need to calculate performance. Also in retail, there are more customers than there are employees, which provides for different calculations and strategies from commercial office buildings.
Issues such as energy use, lighting intensity, daylighting and ventilation rates are certainly critical issues for retailers, but perhaps even more critical is the brand experience retailers are trying to create. Does designing green really help or hinder
58
3 What Is a Green Building?
that experience? Doak believes that the movement toward green buildings creates an opportunity to engage the retail consumer at a new level of meaning. The opportunity is that more and more U.S. adults are showing some type of green motivation. The average consumer knows that running water continuously in the back of a store is not a good thing. Trash that’s co-mingled with recyclables is not a good thing. Those inefficient and wasteful practices translate not only into poor environmental impact, but also into higher costs that are ultimately passed on to the customer. People are cognizant of energy and waste; they care about environmental prosperity—it’s just part of the culture now, an addition to humanity’s ethos. So whenever a customer goes into a store and sees bad practices happening, then it translates into a negative experience and pings against brand loyalty. The opportunity now is that retail brands have a chance to build a new level of loyalty with customers who have eco-values. Patagonia, Timberland, REI and L.L. Bean, for example, have done it for years—that’s why they were some of the first adopters of LEED—the alignment was a natural fit. Environmental initiatives are a core competency for these brands and are a big reason why they’ve maintained such a loyal following. As the customer base grows, we’ll see more and more retailers making sustainability a primary endeavour for their company—and not just on the sales floor, but throughout their entire portfolio—all the way down to the products they sell. The challenge (and the barrier) is how retailers are going to implement green practices successfully into their portfolio. Brand experience is a delicate tool and fine art in retail. How can a retailer now incorporate and communicate green practices effectively into its brand experience and efficiently across their multiple sites, including the warehouse and supply chain? That’s tough. It requires an overhaul; a new way of looking at the way it operates and grows its business. Retailers will regroup, test and implement new processes throughout their operations. The biggest challenge will be getting decision makers within our retail brands to understand how a sustainability program works inside the traditional expectations of the retail business model. Just like the development of any new prototype, be it a product or building, an investment is going to have to be made to evaluate where the cost saving opportunities are for the longer term. You have to spend money to make money, but not necessarily for every project down the road—it’s always the learning curve that requires the real investment. Retailers have practiced efficiencies for years. Without it, the P&L doesn’t look good. What retailers have to realize is that when we talk about green, we are talking about efficiencies and practices that make smart business sense, not investments into green appendages. It’s about saving energy, saving water, reducing waste, reusing whatever you can and providing your employees and customers with a healthy place to work and shop. What does this mean? That innovation yields cost-saving opportunities. There are countless examples emerging in small pockets all over the retail industry, the challenge will be full-scale implementation. Once that happens—the aggregate savings will be astounding and drive sustainability into the retail industry faster than any other sector.
3.8 The Future of High-Performance Buildings in the U.S. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s ENERGY STAR program, the most well-known to American consumers, is likely to be used to promote energy-efficient and zero-net-energy, or carbon-neutral, commercial and retail buildings. By 2010, buildings will likely be designed to cut energy use 50% or more below 2005 levels through integrated design and innovative technological approaches [12]. Zero-net-energy buildings are already coming online in the U.S. and the U.K. in
3.9
Non-U.S. Green Building Rating Systems
59
2009, essentially providing all site electric power needs with renewable power, either generated on-site with solar power or purchased from remote wind projects, for example. In Central Europe, the focus tends to be on considering “primary” energy demand, which includes the energy wasted in producing and distributing the electricity consumed by buildings. There are many definitions of “zero net energy” floating around, so the retailer and developer should try to stay informed about this larger discussion in the years ahead [13]. With the growing awareness of the carbon dioxide/global warming problem and the contribution of buildings and urban settlement patterns to this situation, architects and others in the design and construction industry have begun to propose positive actions. One sign of this is the position statement adopted by the American Institute of Architects (AIA) in December 2005, calling for a minimum 50% reduction in building energy consumption by 2010, compared with 2003 averages [14]. In its statement, the AIA supported “the development and use of rating systems and standards that promote the design and construction” of more resource-efficient communities. This position statement echoes the requirements of the “Architecture 2030 Challenge,” which seeks to reduce building energy use by 50% by 2010 and 90% by 2030.8 Many cities have subscribed to climate change initiatives and will begin to require green buildings from commercial projects, especially large developments with major infrastructure impacts. For example, by the fall of 2008, more than 900 mayors representing cities in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. signed on to the U.S. Conference of Mayors’ climate change initiative [15]. Mayors who sign on to the agreement make a commitment to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in their own cities and communities to a level 7% below 1990 levels by 2012 through a series of actions including increasing energy efficiency, reducing vehicle miles traveled, maintaining healthy urban forests, reducing sprawl and promoting use of clean, renewable energy resources. In 2008, three of the four largest cities in California, Los Angeles, San Jose and San Francisco, passed ordinances requiring private-sector projects above 50,000 ft2 to achieve LEED certification. Developers would be well advised to keep a close watch on more local governments starting to mandate LEED certification for large commercial projects, which will certainly affect most retail projects in the coming years.
3.9 Non-U.S. Green Building Rating Systems Three non-U.S. rating systems have substantial support in their respective markets: the Japanese CASBEE system, the British BREEAM and the Australian Green Star [16]. Appendix A fully explains the CASBEE and Green Star systems. In this section, we’ll focus on BREEAM, because it is the largest and oldest system in use 8 See
www.architecture2030.org for regular updates on this challenge.
60
3 What Is a Green Building?
outside North America and one likely to be of greater interest to both retailers and center developers outside the U.S., particularly in the European Union. The main standard used in the U.K., BREEAM is supported by the nonprofit Building Research Establishment (BRE) and has the longest track record of any rating system.
3.9.1 BREEAM Through the end of 2008, BREEAM had certified 2,049 nonresidential (commercial and institutional) buildings since 2000, a total nearly as great as the LEED system, but in a country one-fifth the size of the U.S. Table 3.6 shows the BREEAM totals for both registered and certified projects through the end of 2008 [17]. BREEAM rates buildings according to nine major categories, with a single score at the end, similar to the LEED system, with the 2008 weightings shown in Table 3.7. At 27% of the total, energy and transport in new buildings are given weightings similar to the LEED-NC version 2.2 system, but less than that in LEED 2009, which weights energy and transportation impacts almost 40%. Along with specific green building measures and weightings, the percentage scores then translate into green points that yield the following rating categories [18]. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Pass (≥30) Good (≥45) Very Good (≥55) Excellent (≥70) Outstanding (≥85)
More than 600 buildings have been rated Excellent by BREEAM. BREEAM can be used to rate all types of buildings, with individual rating systems available for commercial buildings including offices and retail. One critique of BREEAM, similar to that levied against the USGBC’s LEED system, is that: There is no measurement of how the building performs once occupied. It is believed there has been little or no measurement of carbon emissions from the 628 buildings to have been designated Excellent so far. Total emissions are strongly influenced by tenant behavior, from
Table 3.6 BREEAM Certifications, Non-domestic Buildings, 2004–2008 [17] Year 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Total (2000–2008)
Registered projects
Certified projects
449 550 1,353 2,006 5,861
145 192 249 371 728
10,705
2,049
3.9
Non-U.S. Green Building Rating Systems
61
Table 3.7 2008 BREEAM Rating Categories and Weightings Rating category 1. Building management 2. Health and well-being 3. Energy 4. Transport 5. Water 6. Materials and waste 7. Waste 8. Land use and ecology 9. Pollution Total
Weighting—New builds and major refurbishments 12 15 19 8 6 12.5 7.5 10 10 100
Interior fitout only 13 17 21 9 7 14 8 N/A 11 100
the type of fit-out, the number of people in the building and the hours the building is in use each day, to the amount of electrical equipment installed and the occupier’s understanding of how to run the heating and cooling efficiently [19].
In 2008, BREEAM introduced a new and higher rating of Outstanding, to denote the few projects now exceeding the Excellent rating level. Also, in 2008 BREEAM made major changes to the system, including introducing new environmental weightings, mandatory credits and a two-stage certification process, design stage and post-construction. Benchmarks were set for carbon dioxide emissions to align BREEAM with the new Energy Performance Certificates that must be issued for all buildings to comply with the E.U. Energy Performance in Buildings Directive. Finally, BREEAM introduced a Core and Shell rating system for offices and shell retail spaces, similar to one that has been part of the LEED system since 2004. BREEAM is admirably flexible and creates a “bespoke” (or customized) rating system for unusual building types, such as recreation, laboratories, hotels and various higher education structures. In the U.S., LEED has taken the opposite approach by making most of the diverse building types fit into a straitjacket designed originally for office buildings, although this is changing, with rating systems specifically for schools and retail buildings introduced in 2008 and 2009, respectively. In 2008, BREEAM Retail was introduced as a rating tool that can assess new build or major refurbishment, post construction, tenant fitout, existing (occupied) buildings, management and operation [20]. According to BRE staff, BREEAM Retail was developed with a number of partners representing a significant portion of the retail sector. The two-year development process was sponsored by a number of key players in the retail —Marks & Spencer, Tesco, Sainsbury’s Property Services and many more.9 In addition, a number of key BREEAM assessor organizations
9 BREEAM
Retail development sponsors included British Land Company, Chartwell Land Development, Chelsfield, Grosvenor, Hammerson UK Property, Land Securities, Lend Lease Global Investment, Marks & Spencer, Sainsbury’s Property Services and Tesco. The British Retail Consortium also advised during the project’s development.
62
3 What Is a Green Building?
Fig. 3.8 The new BREEAM for Retail system will allow a closer match of green building criteria to specific retailer design and construction practices
were partners in the development of the BREEAM Retail scheme [21]. Figures 3.8 and 3.9 show the BREEAM Retail point distributions. BREEAM Retail can assess the following types of retail developments [22]. • General display and sale of goods: for example, shopping centers, home improvement stores, showrooms and all general retail outlets. • Food retail: for example, supermarkets, general stores with a food retail section and shops that sell food for consumption off the premises. • Customer service retail: For example, bank, post office, dry cleaners, travel agency, etc. Currently BREEAM Retail cannot assess restaurants that do not form part of a wider development. Retail does present challenges to the BREEAM system. BREEAM has successfully overcome many obstacles to develop a methodology suited to assessing the variety of retail environments that exist, particularly since these have very different purposes than office buildings. The issue of daylighting provides an example of how BREEAM requirements can be tailored to the retail environment in individual shopping centers. Daylighting aims to ensure that building users have sufficient access to daylight. In the majority of BREEAM certifications, BRE requires that at least 80% of floor area in each occupied space is adequately daylit to a daylight factor of 2%. BREEAM received feedback from retailers that this target was going to be unachievable and so there was a risk that no one would address the daylighting issue for retail buildings and therefore make no attempt to ensure that building users have sufficient
3.9
Non-U.S. Green Building Rating Systems
63
Fig. 3.9 BREEAM for Retail Interiors provides retailers with green design criteria for individual store remodels and new construction inside of malls and shell retail spaces
access to daylight. To resolve this, BREEAM tailored the requirements of this issue in retail buildings so that at least 35% by floor area of the sales and common spaces have daylight factors of at least 2%. While this still presented a difficult target for retailers to meet, it was no longer unachievable and the design teams could try to incorporate this requirement into a building’s design [21]. There were 43 certified retail projects as of November 2008, according to BRE staff, with nearly 1,300 retail buildings registered for eventual certification (current economic conditions may deter or delay finishing these projects, of course). Retail assessments are currently under way in seven countries outside the U.K.: Germany, Turkey, Sweden, France, Spain, Austria and Iceland. In 2008, ICSC adopted BREEAM as a standard for rating shopping centers throughout Europe, stating at the time [23], After extensive research and comparisons the ICSC Sustainability Working Group, chaired by ICSC European Chair and COO of Redevco Europe, Jaap Gillis, with representatives from other companies such as Sonae Sierra, Multi Development, ING Real Estate and Immochan, launched in 2007 an initiative to develop a pan-European BREEAM framework, in order to establish a common level playing field across the continent. After taking its recommendations to the European Union, which welcomed the selfregulation the retail real estate industry wished to pursue, ICSC is now working with BREEAM to adjust its environmental criteria so it is suitable for adoption by countries across Europe. Using BREEAM, a number of ICSC member-developers aim to implement pilot projects across Europe in 2008. BREEAM could become the blueprint for a pan-European green standard from 2009.
64
3 What Is a Green Building?
3.10 Summary All in all, BREEAM is a worthy competitor to LEED in the U.S. and likely to be a dominant system in many countries. It illustrates green building rating systems that actually work because it’s in tune with the marketplace realities, without giving up a sense of higher purpose. Green building rating schemes have come of age. While there is still some awkwardness in applying office building design and construction criteria to the retail environment, there is much agreement in the industry that retail stores and shopping centers need to be upgraded to meet criteria for green building and highperformance interiors. By 2012, most developers and retailers with strong commitments to corporate social responsibility will most likely find a green building rating and certification scheme that can fit their projects.
References 1. USGBC unpublished data furnished to the author. 2. Report to Congress. General Services Administration. (2006, September). Retrieved on March 6, 2007, from http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID=1916. 3. U.S. Green Building Council web site. Retrieved February 2009, from http://www. usgbc.org/leed. 4. Data for LEED registrations and certifications are from the USGBC, furnished to the author, end of November 2008. 5. Miller, Norman. Does green pay off? Retrieved January 4, 2009, from http://www.sandiego. edu/business/documents/EconofGreenMArch52008.pdf - 2008-04-18. 6. Burr, Andrew. CoStar study finds ENERGY STAR, LEED buildings outperform peers. (2008, March 26). Retrieved January 4, 2009, from http://www.costar.com/News/Article. aspx?id=D968F1E0DCF73712B03A099E0E99C679. 7. U.S. Green Building Council web site. Retrieved February 16, 2009, from http://www.usgbc.org/DisplayPage.aspx?CMSPageID=148. 8. Yudelson, Jerry. (2006) Marketing Green Building Services: Strategies for Success New York: Architectural Press. p. 129. 9. Paul Schwer, PAE Consulting Engineers, May 2008, “Personal communication.” 10. See, for example, studies by the Heschong Mahone Group for Pacific Gas & Electric Company and the California Energy Commission, available at http://www.h-m-g.com, retrieved January 5, 2009. 11. Interview with Justin Doak, USGBC, November 2008. 12. For example, the U.S. Department of Energy began a Commercial Buildings Initiative and a “Net Zero Commercial Building” program in 2008, http://www.energy.gov/ energyefficiency/6454.htm. 13. Yudelson, Jerry. (2009) Green Building Trends: Europe. Washington, D.C.: Island Press (in press). 14. American Institute of Architects press release. Retrieved December 19, 2008, from http://www.aiaarchitect.net/site/news/06/august/sustainability.html. 15. City of Seattle, Mayor’s Office web site. Retrieved April 26, 2007, from http://www.seattle. gov/mayor/climate/PDF/USCM_Faq_1-18-07.pdf. 16. USGBC website. Retrieved January 4, 2009, from http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx? DocumentID=1916. 17. Information supplied by Building Research Establishment to the author, January 5, 2009.
References
65
18. BREEAM web site. Retrieved on January 5, 2009, from http://www.breeam. org/manualpage. jsp?id=28. 19. Jansen, Mark. (2008, August 8). BREEAM’s green credentials are not what they seem. Retrieved August 29, 2008, from http://www.propertyweek.com/story. asp? sectioncode=274&storycode=3119943&c=1. BREEAM In-Use, introduced in 2008, intends to challenge this critique by offering retailers a way to continually update their certification, after a building has been occupied for a year or two. 20. BREEAM web site. Retrieved January 5, 2009, from http://www.breeam.org/ page_1col.jsp? id=54. 21. Email interview with BRE staff, November 2008. 22. BREEAM web site. Retrieved January 5, 2009, from http://www.breeam.org/page.jsp?id=19. 23. Gillis, Jaap. (2008, February 15) Property EU. Retrieved January 5, 2009, from http://www.propertyeu.info/services/expert-views/read/default.asp?id=40
Chapter 4
The Business Case for Green Retail
If green buildings are happening in most segments of the commercial real estate sector, as demonstrated in Chapter 2, it is reasonable to suppose that they will also arrive in the retail segment in the next few years. What would be the benefits to a retail real estate developer to have a larger “green profile?” This chapter sets out the business case for green retail buildings and provides examples of some of the monetary and other benefits that early adopters are gaining. Table 4.1 outlines some of the potential benefits and who would receive them, while Fig. 4.1 shows these benefits graphically. Many of these benefits accrue unequally to various parties. For example, a developer incurs many of the costs of energy efficiency and water efficiency investments, but the tenant secures the benefits, at least initially, through lower common area charges. At this time, the developer is typically unable to secure higher commercial rents from tenants, since the potential future energy and water savings are not recognized in most lease negotiations. This makes a developer reluctant to incur these expenses, since the net result is a higher capital cost and a lower potential return to offer investors. This situation forces a developer to look at a broader picture of costs and benefits. For example, in the commercial office sector in the U.S., LEEDcertified and ENERGY STAR–labeled buildings have been shown predictably to have greater rents (up to 30%), higher occupancy rates (2% to almost 4%) and greater resale value (up to 30%), more than compensating for the 2% or so higher capital cost [1].
4.1 Who Benefits and Who Pays? The irony in green retail is that it is mostly the developer who pays for such items as extra insulation and better glazing, more efficient lighting and higher-efficiency HVAC units, as well as stormwater management, construction waste management recycling, LEED certification and the like, and it is the tenant who benefits, through the center’s green advertising and promotional efforts and through lower common area maintenance (CAM) expenses. While the developer recovers some of these benefits through its non-billable CAM charges (typically 20% or a little more), the J. Yudelson, Sustainable Retail Development, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5_4, C 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers Copyright
67
68
4
The Business Case for Green Retail
Table 4.1 Potential Business Benefits of Green Retail Centers and Stores 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
Utility cost savings for energy and water, typically 30–50%, along with reduced carbon footprint from energy savings Maintenance cost reductions from commissioning, operator training and other measures to assure proper systems integration and ongoing performance monitoring Increased long-term building and center value from higher rents, increased net operating income (NOI) and improved public relations Tax benefits for specific green building investments such as energy conservation and solar power, and local development incentives More competitive real estate holdings for private-sector owners over the long run, including higher resale value Productivity improvements for long-term building owners, typically 3–5% Health benefits, including reduced absenteeism, typically 5% or more. Risk management, including faster lease-up and sales for private developers, and less risk of employee exposure to irritating or toxic chemicals in building materials, furniture and furnishings Marketing benefits, especially for developers, large corporations and consumer products companies Public relations benefits, especially for developers and public agencies Recruitment and retention of key employees and higher morale Increased availability of both debt and equity funding for developers, as both banks and investors such as pension funds make green building projects a priority Third-party financing of solar power systems Political and entitlement benefits of providing sustainable retail stores and shopping centers Demonstration of commitment to sustainability and environmental stewardship; shared values with key stakeholders
tenants enjoy the balance. Over the long run, lower operating costs for energy, water and waste disposal should be reflected in higher rents; at the beginning it’s typically not possible to get rent increases. Restructuring a standard lease to share some of the savings is possible, but is not commonly done. However, one growing movement is for retailers to pay a “gross lease” that would include energy costs. In this situation, developer and tenant interests would be more closely aligned. Table 4.2 shows how benefits might be split between various parties. Table 4.2 shows that the benefits have to be considered as a whole and compared with costs, for each of the parties to a retail transaction. There is no clear-cut answer to the question of “does sustainability pay?” However, there is a clear answer to the obverse: Without a major sustainability program, everything else being equal, a retailer or a developer is likely to surrender a major source of competitive advantage. The more significant question is: Which form of sustainability program offers the greatest benefit to the retail developer and to the retail store operator? To this question, we provide a number of answers in Chapters 12 and 13.
4.2 The Developer’s Perspective Clearly, developers and retailers have common interests—to persuade as many consumers to shop the center as often as possible—however, they also have divergent interests, as the developer functions primarily as a landlord, developing the property,
4.2
The Developer’s Perspective
69
Fig. 4.1 The benefits of green retail spaces encompass five major areas of interest. Courtesy of Palladeo Table 4.2 Who Benefits? Owner type
Energy
Productivity and health
Marketing and PR
Recruitment Financing
Retail store, stand alone: does the retailer benefit? Retail store, interior: does the retailer benefit? Shopping center: does the developer benefit?
Yes
No
Yes
No
N/A
Small savings Small savings
Yes
Yes
Maybe
N/A
No
Yes
Yes
Maybe
maintaining it and collecting rents. At some point, the developer will likely sell the property. The developer aims to collect enough rent to meet investors’ expected return on investment and to keep the center as fully tenanted as possible for as long as possible. The retailer’s goal is to meet or exceed sales targets by satisfying consumer demand for products and services, while paying as little rent as possible. The retailer typically pays directly for utilities, as well as indirectly for other operating expenses through CAM charges, which it would like to keep as low as possible. Because many consumers care about energy use and environmental impact, both developer and retailer have common interests around green certifications.
70
4
The Business Case for Green Retail
4.2.1 The Entitlement Process Getting land use and building permits to build new centers and often to renovate older centers, as well as to construct mixed-use projects, will continue to be a struggle. In many parts of the U.S., cities and counties are beginning to offer preferential treatment to development applications that promise to achieve LEED certification. This treatment can take the form of “top of the pile” priority processing (Chicago and San Francisco are two cities that offer this benefit) and density bonuses or reductions in certain other requirements. As of the end of 2008, more than twenty jurisdictions in the U.S. offered some type of development incentive for green buildings [2]. Many more cities and counties will begin to offer priority processing for commitments to build to green certification standards, if for no other reason than that it is politically attractive to do so and costs the jurisdiction nothing. In some cases, developers may even have to post bonds to back up their commitment. Cities will figure out that they have to grant land use (planning) and building permits long before the developer has gained LEED certification, and they will need some reassurance that the developer will follow through on its commitment. There are also upcoming mandates for the private sector, since more than 900 U.S. mayors have committed their cities to the U.S. Conference of Mayors Climate Change Initiative, committing them to reduce carbon dioxide emissions below 1990 levels by 2012. As cities begin to grapple with the reality of this commitment, there will be a strong temptation to start forcing the private sector to do its part. Developers would be wise to start getting green building experience now, before more of these requirements come into force. As of early 2009, more than twenty cities around the U.S. (including large cities such as Boston, San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Jose, Dallas and Washington, D.C.) had ordinances requiring LEED certification for larger commercial developments. As most cities are run by politicians who value such issues as green building, reducing energy use and promoting more environmentally sensitive land use, developers can expect to face such demands.
4.2.2 Cost Offsets There are opportunities for reducing initial development costs by reconfiguring shopping center layout to recover and reuse rainwater from rooftops for toilet flushing and cooling tower makeup water, and to recover and treat stormwater from parking lots for irrigation and street and sidewalk washing. Recovered stormwater can also be infiltrated (where soils are appropriate for that purpose) and/or used in landscape ponds, drainage swales or even constructed wetlands (for greenfield sites). The goal of all these green measures is to avoid having to send stormwater to a storm sewer and thereby to avoid a lot of impact or development charges. Civil engineers need to be instructed to look at a cost/benefit analysis of such measures before proceeding with the usual storm sewer hookups. Not all jurisdictions will go along with reducing fees, but it is a useful item to have on the table during negotiations.
4.3
Branding and Marketing
71
4.2.3 Tax and Other Incentives in the U.S. At the time of this book, the state of Nevada provided 35% property tax abatements for 10 years to projects that achieve a LEED Silver rating. If the average property tax is 1% of value, then the abatement would be worth up to 3.5% of project costs. Oregon and New York both have large state tax credits for green buildings that achieve at least LEED Silver certification. In Oregon, the incentive is based on square footage (project area), so that an efficient developer can see a very beneficial return. Other states offer similar incentives, so it pays to stay informed at the end of each legislative session about new incentives for green building.
4.2.4 Renewable Energy Incentives in the U.S. More than twenty states and many electric utilities offer some form of incentive for solar power systems [3]. In addition, the 2005 Energy Policy Act (as amended in 2006, 2007 and 2008 by various laws) offers a 30% federal tax credit for solar energy systems placed in service through the end of 2016. Taken together with local utility incentives for solar power, state tax credits and sales tax abatements and accelerated federal depreciation, there is a strong ROI case to be made for putting solar power on every shopping center roof. In April 2007, Kohl’s became the first major retailer to do this, committing to convert more than 75% of its California locations to solar power (see the discussion in Chapter 6) [4]. The benefit of using solar power incentives is simple: Many solar systems can be visible from street level and most of the public does not need a lot of education to recognize them. As a result, a developer or retailer can get a lot of public relations benefit and save money on energy costs. Since 2006, there have been a number of partnerships created to use the state and federal tax and utility incentives for solar power systems, so that it is possible in about seventeen states with such inducements to get the solar system financed by a third party at no initial cost to the developer or retailer, as discussed in Chapter 6.
4.3 Branding and Marketing Green buildings and solar power offer a developer the rare opportunity to do well by doing good. As part of a thoughtful branding and marketing strategy, green and sustainable are beneficial, but they have to be real. The media are pretty well trained by now, or soon will be, to recognize “greenwashing” by the retail sector, so it is best to have a strong corporate commitment to the full extent of sustainable strategies before announcing specific elements. In addition to media scrutiny, greenwashing is an unethical practice that will surely cause consternation and dismay among a company’s employees. For a more extensive discussion of the marketing aspects of sustainable retail development, see Chapter 11.
72
4
The Business Case for Green Retail
Another benefit from green buildings is their positive impact on recruiting. One should also think of the benefits in terms of hiring and retaining good employees. In today’s talent-short world, finding and keeping good people may be a primary benefit realized by greening the retail center and retail store.1
4.4 Case Study—First Capital Realty, Toronto, Canada 4.4.1 Business Case Factors Let’s take another look at First Capital Realty in Canada, where the first driver is location: the company chooses properties surrounded by dense residential communities. The second driver is concern for the tenants. The company anticipates that a demand shift will occur among larger retailers, and that some tenants, especially financial institutions, will consider LEED-CI in their future commercial fitouts. Hence, First Capital plans to be ahead of this market and to stay there. Currently, however, the general experience of First Capital, as with most developers, is that tenants are happy to have the green measures but are unwilling to pay for them. First Capital understands that paybacks will not be in the short term, but will be achieved in the medium and longer term. Although a good deal of effort is now put into educating tenants, the company anticipates that in the future tenants will increasingly demand green leased space, and so the company expects to realize future economic benefits from differentiating itself from the rest of the market in this area. Also, First Capital Realty regards this strategy as part of being a good corporate citizen. While the company anticipates that greener buildings will eventually generate higher rents, it also expects that it will only be able to reliably quantify cost savings for future tenants in this or other properties after one to three years of operation. First Capital anticipates that it will benefit from rent growth only in the medium term—three to five years after a building is fully tenanted.
4.4.2 Financial and Nonfinancial Incentives Permitting and awarding additional building capacity are significant factors impacting costs differentially across the nation: in British Columbia, municipalities are so familiar with, and supportive of, greening that permits are fast-tracked (saving a 1 Many
of the corporate audiences addressed by the author emphatically agree with this idea. Despite the current global recession, there is a considerable shortage of people in the 30–40 yearold age category in most of the world’s advanced economies. Without good people, how are you going to grow your business and/or profit in the future?
4.5
The Retailer’s Perspective
73
great deal of time and money), or the municipality may offer another pad to build on as a developer incentive, given a project’s green goals. Further east, however— from Alberta through Central and Eastern Canada—while municipal policies were intended to encourage building greening, their staffs were unfamiliar with the measures, and in fact the building permitting process was slowed down. First Capital had to spend time with municipal staff in these regions in order to bring them on board.
4.4.3 Challenges There have been three major challenges experienced to date: Tenant education: Much time is spent in educating the tenants regarding potential implications of their space changes arising from the greening. Delays also are incurred due to the leasing department’s education gaps. Municipal staff limitations: As indicated, while municipalities have the political will to green buildings, at the moment, east of British Columbia, municipal staffs are not sufficiently knowledgeable to effectively support green building permitting. Managing costs: Cost challenges were significant at the beginning. The anticipated cost increment for greening was 5–7%; however, for some green components the cost increase was as high as 15–20%. One green project, the Morningside Crossing property, was an existing shopping center with parking. A major portion of the center was vacated and demolished, with an occupied portion still standing while the new center was built. This particular property presented some challenges. First, deals with tenants were done prior to the decision to add green features, which required additional time to educate tenants as to the benefits of the greener building. Second, leases were triple net, with tenants responsible for energy costs; however, some anchor tenants have “clawbacks” and caps on costs, limiting what they are prepared to pay the developer to reduce those costs. Third, the decision to go green took place after consulting and design drawings were done, requiring many changes to the contract that added considerably to the expenses. Costly green components have included higher efficiency rooftop units and low-e, triple-paned, argon-filled windows (with 30% higher costs than conventional windows).
4.5 The Retailer’s Perspective As seen in earlier chapters, a number of retail chains are increasingly committing to ambitious sustainability goals, including tracking and reducing their carbon footprints, greening the supply chain and operating green stores. What might be some of the less obvious reasons for doing this? The first that comes to mind is building or burnishing the company’s own reputation as a forward-looking corporation.
74
4
The Business Case for Green Retail
4.5.1 Reputation Capital Joseph Feldman is managing director and a retail stock analyst at Telsey Advisory Group.2 He says [5]: The green movement has definitely started to take hold within retail. It’s no longer just a fad, it’s a trend that’s here to stay. It may be tough to justify the expense in the current market in terms of the recessionary environment. That being said, a lot of retailers are starting to play with it. When a company like Wal-Mart is putting some significant effort behind the green movement, I think that says a lot. . . Obviously, using less energy is good for the environment but using less energy is also good for Wal-Mart. I think it’s both a company savings and a global savings. A big part of the green initiative from retailers goes beyond the profitability aspect. A lot of it is reputation capital. More and more consumers are concerned with green—being healthy, eating organics, breathing clean air, and consuming less energy. If Wal-Mart is in the forefront of that, it makes sense to me that others will follow its lead. Look at Whole Foods. In reality, the entire concept is based on the green movement. It’s the poster child for the green movement. It’s all about organic and natural products. The concept has built its brand and reputation on healthy, green living, and has gained loyal customers in the process.
4.5.2 CFOs Going Green This point was emphasized in a 2007 survey by a major consulting firm. In this survey, two-thirds of chief financial officers at leading U.S. retailers say their company is actively involved with green or environmentally friendly practices, and 44% of those indicate they have increased their investments in these practices during the past two years [6]. Among the top 100 largest retailers, 83% are involved in green practices, and a majority of those (62%) have increased their green investments since 2005. Among those retailers involved with green practices, 34% are pursuing internal activities (environmentally modifying operations and buildings) exclusively, while 9% are focused solely on external practices (selling green products). Of the retailers surveyed, 57% are pursuing a combination of both external and internal green practices. When asked to identify the greatest motivator for their company to pursue environmentally friendly practices, two-thirds of the CFOs cited the company’s corporate image (54% cited “image among consumers” and 13% cited “image among shareholders”). Surprisingly, a tax break or tax incentive was the greatest green motivator among only 15% of the CFOs, followed by 10% who cited city/state or zoning regulations.
2 Telsey Advisory Group is the leading independent equity research and consulting firm focused on
the consumer sector. www.telseygroup.com.
4.7
Consumer Demand
75
4.6 Six Key Areas of Focus for Green Retailing These points were reinforced by a 2008 review of the sustainability programs of 100 U.S. retailers by another consulting and research firm, which found that green retailers had six key focus areas [7]. • • • • • •
Green sourcing/procurement (59%) Waste management (54%) Eco-friendly mandates in packaging (49%) Redesign the retail supply chain (41%) Eco-friendly “end-of-life” programs, such as product takeback (41%) Redesign store facilities and infrastructure (35%) According to the study’s authors: The top actions on the green retail agenda align with the strategic decision to take a holistic approach to all aspects of brand management and total cost of operations. For 59% of retail respondents, implementing a responsible and green-oriented sourcing and procurement plan is a crucial element of success. The focus on the very beginning of the retail supply chain complements the strategy of adopting eco-friendly standards for waste management (54%) and product end-of-life, recycle and reuse programs (41%). This end-to-end approach underscores an intensive vision of the retail value chain and indicates that retailers are becoming more involved in the entire life cycle of their products and operational activities, according to the report.
The study concluded that the six top actions of green retail initiatives demonstrate that practically no aspect of the retail enterprise will go untouched by the sustainability agenda. Even more importantly, the study demonstrated that the best-in-class retailers achieve not only dramatic cost savings (20% decrease in energy costs) especially when compared to industry laggards (39% increase in energy costs), but also dramatically improved customer loyalty. This ought to be reason enough for all retailers to dramatically accelerate their green building and retrofitting programs.
4.7 Consumer Demand One can foresee that as more large retailers (such as Home Depot, Office Depot, Tesco, Marks & Spencer and others) begin to build green stores, consumers will come to expect that the entire shopping center will have green and sustainable features. If one does and another does not, is it possible that consumers will prefer to shop at one and not another? What is clear from a number of studies of the LOHAS consumer (representing Lifestyles of Health and Sustainability) is that a certain core group of such consumers prizes “authenticity” in their lives and selectively patronizes retailers who demonstrate those values. One meaning of authenticity might simply be, we do what we say; for a retailer to sell green products, authenticity requires a very strong sustainability program. What is not clear at this time is how much
76
4
The Business Case for Green Retail
typical consumers are going to change their shopping habits to patronize centers that have such tenants. From the retailer’s perspective, anything that helps attract consumers to a given center, any successful point of differentiation, is a good thing. More traffic should mean more sales, everything else being equal. We can foresee centers offering their own “green seals,” much as Forest City Stapleton did at Denver’s Northfield center, to cooperating retailers who meet LEED guidelines for store fitout. We also expect to see larger retailers and anchor tenants such as Kohl’s, Best Buy, Office Depot, Marks & Spencer and similar enterprises aim at the green consumer with certifications of upcoming stores. What many are of course discovering is that the green certification is a result and not a cause of good store design, as they find operating costs coming down and employee satisfaction rising. The advent of skylights throughout the large retail store environment, pioneered by Wal-Mart, is a good example of doing well by doing good. Not only do sales increase, as shown by research, but cost recovery happens within five to ten years, depending on local prices for electricity. There is also some evidence that there is less eyestrain on retail clerks working under skylights than under artificial lights, leading to greater job satisfaction and longer job tenure.
4.8 Challenges for Greening the Retail Sector The first and foremost challenge to greening the retail sector is cost, a subject that is tackled in the next chapter. Other challenges include the capabilities of the design and construction teams to provide green features on conventional budgets, the disparity between which parties incur costs for green features and which parties get the benefits, and writing green tenant guidelines.
4.8.1 Tenant Guidelines Some developers certify to the LEED for New Construction, BREEAM or the new LEED or BREEAM for Retail standards, while others creating only shell retail space prefer to use the LEED for Core and Shell rating system, with its precertification benefit. In either case, having gone to the effort to green the retail center, a developer often wants to write tenant guidelines that will ask or require tenants to use sustainable design and construction measures in their own spaces. In the LEED rating system, a strong set of tenant guidelines also qualifies for one credit point toward certification of a center. These guidelines could cover such items as using low-toxicity paints, adhesives, sealants and carpets in tenant buildout, using more efficient lighting systems and a wide variety of measures that are covered in the LEED for Commercial Interiors (Retail) rating system. If the guidelines are not required, then developers need to engage in a strong tenant education program, starting with the lease negotiations. This may provoke discomfort among the leasing
References
77
brokers or letting agents working for both developer and tenant; therefore, a clear set of guidelines, with attention to how they’re written and promoted, is a key part of the process. There is a strong business case for green retail stores and green shopping center development, but it is not just in terms of the typical return on investment, wherein one tries to recover extra initial costs through utility savings on energy and water. The real business case comes from corporate social responsibility initiatives, supplemented by real but intangible benefits in terms of development approvals, marketing, public relations and stakeholder engagement.
References 1. Burr, Andrew. (2009). CoStar study finds ENERGY STAR, LEED buildings outperform peers. (2008, March 26). Retrieved January 4, 2009, from http://www.costar.com/News/Article. aspx?id=D968F1E0DCF73712B03A099E0E99C679. This study was updated through the second quarter of 2009, with similar results to the earlier data. Personal communication, Andrew Burr, July 2009. 2. Yudelson, Jerry. (2007). Green building incentives that work: A look at how local governments are incentivising green development. Retrieved on February 15, 2009, from http://www.naiop.org/foundation/ greenincentives.pdf. accessed February 15, 2009. 3. The best source for these incentives is the Database of State Incentives for Renewables and Efficiency, maintained by the North Carolina Solar Center, http://www.dsireusa.org. 4. Hajewski, Doris. (2007, April 26). Kohl s to go solar in California. Journal Sentinel. Retrieved on June 14, 2007, from http://www.jsonline.com/business/29452254.html. 5. Interview with Joseph Feldman, November 2008. 6. U.S. retailers embrace “green” practices according to BDO Seidman, LLP survey of CFOs. (2007, October 1). http://www.businesswire.com/portal/site/google/index.jsp? ndmViewId=news_view&newsId=20071001005301&newsLang=en. 7. Getting from green to gold: Retail success factors and outcomes. (2008, August 18). Retrieved on August 18, 2008 from http://www.environmentalleader.com/2008/08/18/green-retailers-sixkey-focus-areas.
Chapter 5
Costs of Greening Buildings and Developments
The key issue in building green retail centers and stores is extra cost versus added benefit. Design and construction teams who work in retail have become good at cost-cutting and cost management. To ask them to add cost for green features goes against the grain. Nevertheless, it is necessary, certainly at the beginning, to add cost to achieve green building certification. The testimony is fairly solid from many developers and retailers that a LEED certification is initially going to add about 2% to the capital cost of a shopping center and perhaps a similar amount to a retail store. From the experience with many LEED project studies, the cost for basic certification should decrease to nearly zero once the basic lessons of green design and green building have been mastered. In one sense, cost is the only issue, since benefits are apparent. It is a truism that “costs are real and present-tense, but benefits are speculative and future-tense.” This means that a developer makes an investment in green building features and certification by paying more in initial costs, but with the hope of getting some significant return over time. This is not an unreasonable thing to do, but right now it is an exercise in leadership in the industry to commit to a strong green building program. One developer told the author in 2007 that the cost impact was about “5 to 15 basis points” (hundredths of a percent, nominally) in the rate of return, certainly a subject for concern but not a deal breaker. There’s no doubt that achieving a LEED or BREEAM certification for a retail development is initially going to cost more, and it is not clear that a developer can recoup these extra costs in higher rents or faster lease-up of the retail spaces, at least not right now. It is possible that the developer may realize some marketing and public relations benefits, but that is speculative in many cases. Perhaps the greatest benefit may lie in a faster entitlement process and perhaps some reduced development fees—for example, a lower storm sewer connection fee, if the development keeps all rainwater on-site, either for recharge, landscaping or beneficial reuse in the buildings. There is also a not-insignificant benefit in achieving or maintaining a leadership position in this fast-changing green retail landscape—many of a company’s employee-associates care intensely about this issue. In one case, a Lowe’s store in south Austin, Texas, completed in 2005, reportedly benefited from its commitment to building a LEED Silver building by receiving all of its permits in three months instead of the expected fifteen months. The resulting J. Yudelson, Sustainable Retail Development, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5_5, C 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers Copyright
79
80
5 Costs of Greening Buildings and Developments
early opening yielded enough profits in 12 months to pay for the entire building! [1] While this story is an unusual example, it does illustrate the sometimes hidden benefits that may offset higher costs.
5.1 Barriers to Green Building Growth Barriers to the widespread adoption of green building techniques, technologies and systems are related to real-life experience and to a lingering perception in the building industry that green buildings add extra costs. Senior executives representing architectural and engineering firms, consultants, developers, building owners, corporate owner-occupants and educational institutions have positive attitudes about the benefits and costs of green construction, according to the 2005 Green Building Market Barometer, a survey conducted by Turner Construction Company, the largest commercial builder in the U.S. [2]. For example, at that time, 57% of the 665 executives surveyed said their companies were involved with green buildings; 83% said their green building workload had increased since 2002; and 87% said they expected green building activity to continue. However, despite an overwhelming sense that green buildings provided considerable benefits, these same executives thought that green buildings cost 13–18% more than standard buildings! In a 2007 survey by Building Design & Construction, 41% of construction industry participants surveyed said that green buildings added 10% or more to cost of buildings, even while the clear evidence then was that cost increases were less than 10%! [3] This just shows that all building decisions are fundamentally economic ones and that the added costs of high-performance retail buildings and developments will continue to be an issue until project teams figure out how to design such projects consistently without any cost increases. An updated Market Barometer survey performed by Turner Construction in 2008 involving 754 respondents reported the following as presenting an extremely or very significant obstacle to green construction: the costs of LEED documentation (61%), higher construction costs (61%), the length of the payback period (57%) and the difficulty of quantifying the benefits of green building (43%) [4]. Although 54% of executives noted that the cost of LEED documentation is an “extremely” or “very significant” obstacle to green construction, 83% of executives said they would be “extremely” or “very likely” to seek LEED certification if they were planning to build within the next three years. For those seeking LEED certification, 40% expected to pursue Silver, 26% would seek the Certified level, 24% would pursue Gold and 10% Platinum. Among executives who think the first cost of green buildings to be higher, roughly three-quarters believed green buildings can pay back their higher initial costs, with this figure rising to 84% among those who would seek a Gold or Platinum certification. The median estimated payback period cited by executives for sustainable features was seven years.
5.2
Hard and Soft Cost Elements
81
5.2 Hard and Soft Cost Elements It is easy to make the distinction between hard costs and soft costs—those for construction and those for design and certification services. (In reality, all costs are hard for the company that has to write the check!) Nonetheless, the hard costs of green, based on experience in other commercial projects, are shown in Table 5.1. These cost premiums are only indicative. As with automobile fuel efficiency claims, “your mileage may vary.” According to research, larger LEED Platinum projects were completed in 2007 and 2008 for less than a 2% construction cost premium (compared with a conventional building), but these results typically come first to experienced developers or large institutions with sophisticated project management teams [5]. It is important to point out that most developers have found that these cost premiums come down over time, as they gain more experience with green projects. These costs do NOT include the costs of including solar technologies, but might include such things as innovative stormwater management, water conservation measures, energy efficiency investments, green materials, construction waste recycling and other sustainability features. In addition to hard costs, there is a range of soft costs, such as requests for additional architectural and engineering fees, holding “eco-charrettes”1 for considering green alternatives and the LEED system documentation and certification activities. Table 5.2 shows some of these cost premiums. Note that the two most expensive elements are things you probably want to do anyway, such as modeling the energy use characteristics of your building(s) and commissioning the HVAC equipment to make sure that it’s working according to design intent. David Green is an architect and principal at Altoon + Porter in Los Angeles, California. His experience says that the soft costs can be quite large, at least for the first few projects a developer undertakes [6]. We have only one project where the cost of green, or specifically LEED-CS certification was evaluated, The Collection at RiverPark, a 600,000-ft2 retail entertainment center in Oxnard, California. In this case the “LEED Premium” was calculated to be $761,500, or less than 1% of the $80 million total construction budget. The bulk of this additional cost ($643,000) is in “soft” or administrative costs paid to USGBC and the consultant team, whereas only
Table 5.1 Hard Costs for Greening Retail Projects (U.S. Experience)
1 An
LEED certification level
Construction cost premium
Certified (Basic level) Silver Gold Platinum
0–2% 1–3% 3–5% Above 5%
eco-charrette is an intensive design exercise focused typically around issues specified by a particular green building rating system.
82
5 Costs of Greening Buildings and Developments Table 5.2 Soft Costs for Greening Building Projects (U.S., 2008 Estimates)
Cost category
Estimated cost
Design services Building energy modeling or prescriptive design analysis Building commissioning LEED consultant/certification effort LEED certification fees
0–10% extra (depending on experience with green) $15,000–$30,000 $0.40–$0.70 per ft2 , $20,000 minimum $25,000 to $50,000 (varies by project size) $0.035 per ft2 , with certain minimum and maximum fees
$118,500 has been identified as increased cost to the construction, or only 0.015% of the total construction cost.
Hard costs can be a different story, according to Green: Most of our pre-design explorations show that achieving the minimum level of certification under LEED-NC or LEED-CS can be cost neutral to even cost-reductive compared to standard design and construction methods. Whether projects have been third-party certified or not, we have incorporated many of the green building and green site development strategies into our projects, which were completed on their original construction budgets. So, there were no identified premiums. Third-party certification does have direct and indirect costs to the project and the design team, as the example described above demonstrates. The direct cost paid to USGBC was only about $20,000 of the soft cost total. Even considering the total of hard and soft costs, the figure of $761,500 is only 0.38% of the total $200 million development costs of this particular project.
Modeling energy use is an essential element for any building project, particularly for retailers. How will developers know what the carbon footprint should be without some estimate of expected energy use? How will they know they are meeting expectations without a predictive model of anticipated energy use? How will construction teams be able to meet the European Union’s building labeling requirements of the Energy Performance in Buildings Directive without a model of expected energy use? Finally, how will they be able to design a less energy-intensive building without a baseline against which to measure design improvements? Commissioning is a high-payoff activity for most projects, but is often not done in the retail sector; its main goal is to make sure that all energy-using equipment is working according to design intent. It is amazing but true that equipment tends to get installed without anyone fully checking to make sure it is delivering designed performance. That is the benefit provided by building commissioning. For smaller retail projects, the costs of green building certification can definitely be a perceived barrier, unless a company has a specific plan for realizing some of the benefits of green project recognition. For volume builders, including both retailers with small buildings such as bank branches and companies such as Home Depot, Lowe’s and Wal-Mart with very large stores, the USGBC developed a “portfolio” program that will allow a company to certify the basic green elements of its prototype or typical store, with documentation needed only for specific “site credits”
5.3
Cost Drivers
83
for each individual location. The portfolio program aims to drive down the cost of green project certification to levels that a retailer can more easily handle.
5.3 Cost Drivers Costs are real and immediate, but what drives costs? What are the key controllable parameters on which retail real estate executives can focus, to keep the costs of going green under control? Key drivers of design costs include the following: • • • • • •
Design team experience with green/high-performance projects Level of green building certification desired Team structure Design process and scope Green certification required documentation Additional design fees
These two issues are discussed below in more detail, so that the retailer and developer will understand how to address them in the future.
5.3.1 Design Team Capabilities While there are more than 14,000 LEED projects under way in the U.S., fewer than 2,200 were certified at the end of 2008. Part of this is owing to the time lag between project registration (typically early in schematic design) and the completion and certification of a project (which can take two to three years after the start of design). As a result of this gap between interest and certification, most design (and construction) teams engaged heavily with retail work have not yet completed a LEED project. As a result, many design teams are asking for premiums for adding the LEED component to their scope of services, and they are not always very comfortable with what it takes to make a project green. In addition, their ability to deliver green features on conventional budgets is suspect, and unnecessary cost increases on early projects may result. In this situation, a retail developer would be wise to insist that the architect add an experienced green consultant to the project team, to guide the entire team through the design, product and system specification and LEED certification process.
5.3.2 Design Process and Scope Fundamentally, it is critical to bring the entire design and construction team together for enough early-stage meetings to arrive at a unified scope and series of measures to achieve green results [5]. However, one can expect that a serious commitment to
84
5 Costs of Greening Buildings and Developments
integrated design will add to design costs, because of additional meetings, design charrettes and further studies and analyses during the design period. A typical allday meeting is going to cost $20,000 if it involves many consultants, each billing $1,200 to $2,000 for the day. The least costly approach is to get everyone together just once, but not to leave the meeting until most key design decisions or directions are made. This approach is especially important when consultants are brought in from out of town or even out of country. In some cases, multi-day charrettes are useful; it is also possible that shorter meetings can work, in cases where the developer’s team is really well informed about LEED and already experienced in delivering high-performance projects. However, some leading experts in integrated design maintain that integrated design requires a series of facilitated charrettes, until all reasonable options and opportunities are fully explored. It is also important to do most of the key thinking at the initial meeting and to use energy models in particular to get better and earlier design decisions. Some of the new developments in Building Information Modeling (BIM) promise to allow energy outcomes to be modeled for alternative design approaches very early in schematic design. At the U.S. Green Building Council’s 2007 Greenbuild conference, one leading BIM vendor showed a promising approach that would eventually allow modeling of approximate energy outcomes even from rough sketches [7].
5.4 The Cost of Learning to Be Green One early adopter of green practices was developer Melaver, Inc., of Savannah, Georgia. In a study of the company’s costs for adopting LEED practices, Melaver considered both soft and hard costs. First of all, the cost of training twenty-seven staff members (including a calculation of the staff time involved, bonuses paid for passing the LEED AP exam, etc.) was about $50,000, or about $2,000 each. However, the more significant cost was $1.5 million of extra costs and deferred rents (from longer time to market) for the first four retail projects [8]. The CFO wrote, “As a values-centric company, Melaver, Inc., is comfortable paying a 50 basis point premium for being a green developer” [8]. Lessons learned included the following: 1. Set green objectives as early in the project as possible. 2. Stick to those objectives throughout the project; this is harder than it sounds, as anyone experienced in design and construction will attest. 3. Make sure all members of the development team are strongly in alignment with these objectives and are not just paying lip service to them. 4. Use an experienced LEED (green building) consultant, at least for the first few projects. 5. Do your learning on smaller projects, if you can, before tackling the “project of a lifetime.” 6. Stay on top of the construction process, to ensure that green objectives are being met by the team in the field.
5.5
Cost of a Developer’s Sustainability Initiative
85
7. Only do as much green in the first few projects as your organization can handle. (For example, it may be too much to expect the leasing team to get “green leases” from all tenants.) 8. Expect mistakes and put enough money into the budget to cover them. Having said all this, the company still concludes that short-term and longer-term tangible and intangible cost reductions and value creation provide overriding benefits to the green strategy. Even after a net investment estimated at $5 million, most of which comes from employees’ time, CEO Martin Melaver considers the return on investment to be positive. As he wrote, “Investments in a green bottom line can (and should) be amortized over the long term, comprising part of a company’s overall institutional expertise—an expertise that simply becomes more refined (and profitable) over time.” [8]
5.5 Cost of a Developer’s Sustainability Initiative Sometimes it is helpful to take a more comprehensive look at what a major commitment to sustainability might look like. Table 5.3 shows an example program that aims to LEED-certify $100 million in new projects in year one, followed by $200 million in year two and $300 million in year three, and bring a similar amount of existing buildings up to LEED standards, for a hypothetical development company. Improving the sustainability profile of corporate operations might cost nearly $1 million over a three-year period (of course there is likely to be some financial return as well from this activity). Some of the cost elements might be surprising, such as a major cost of corporate communications and donations to environmental nonprofits, but a developer needs to consider the full financial consequences of this commitment, especially since the benefits might be slower in coming than imagined. The total program cost is 2.75% of all development costs. Table 5.3 Green Building Initiatives—An Example of Estimated Costs ($ millions) Program element
2009
2010
2011
Total
LEED-certify new centersa LEED-certify existing centersb Corporate communicationsc Corporate sustainability operationsd Charitable contributions (to green groups) Total
$2.00 $0.75 $0.30 $0.35 $0.10 $3.50
$4.00 $0.75 $0.30 $0.35 $0.10 $5.50
$6.00 $0.75 $0.30 $0.35 $0.10 $7.50
$12.00 $2.25 $0.90 $1.05 $0.30 $16.50
a Based
on $100 million projects in 2009 at 2% cost increase, $200 million of new projects in 2010 and $300 million of new projects in 2011. b Three centers per year, $250,000 per center, for 2009, 2010 and 2011. c Estimated $25,000 per month. d Assumes one CSO and one sustainability manager, total budget of $300,000 per year, plus education and training expenses of at least $50,000 per year.
86
5 Costs of Greening Buildings and Developments
5.6 Summary Green development and green retail buildings are not free, in the sense that they may require higher initial costs, certainly until an organization learns the ropes. However, there are considerable data and experience in greening other building types. As discussed here and in the following chapters, many retailers and some developers have begun to accumulate the experience with sustainable design, construction and operations that will allow them to keep incremental cost increases within reasonable bounds in the future.
References 1. Personal communication, S. Richard Fedrizzi, CEO, U.S. Green Building Council, February 2007. 2. 2005 survey of green building plus green building K-12 and higher education. Retrieved on March 6, 2007, from http://www.turnerconstruction.com/greensurvey05.pdf. 3. Green buildings research white paper: Where building owners, end users, and AEC professionals stand on sustainability and green building (2007, November). Building Design & Construction. Retrieved on December 23, 2008, from http://www.loginandlearn.com/ media/whitepapers.php. 4. Credit market condition not likely to affect plans to build green buildings, say 75% of commercial real estate executives surveyed by Turner Construction Company. (2008, November 18). Retrieved on December 23, 2008 from http://www.turnerconstruction.com/ corporate/content.asp?d=6504. 5. Yudelson, Jerry. (2008). Green Building through Integrated Design. (New York: McGraw-Hill). 6. Interview with David Green, November 2008. 7. Plenary presentation by Phil Bernstein, Autodesk, at the USGBC’s Greenbuild conference, Chicago, November 2007. 8. Melaver, Martin, et al. (2008). The Green Building Bottom Line, p. 113. (New York: McGraw-Hill).
Chapter 6
Solar Power
More retailers are getting aboard the solar power train. With the advent of third-party financing partnerships, putting solar power on the roof allows a retailer to buy renewable electricity without incurring the upfront capital costs. This chapter explores what some retailers are doing today and presents the current economics of solar power [1]. This chapter is particularly focused on the U.S., but the information can be useful for international situations. For example, in Germany, the government kick-started the solar power industry in 2004 by mandating “feed-in tariffs” that required electric utilities to buy solar-generated electricity at about three times the going rate for conventional energy (more than $0.50 per kWh of electricity), on a twenty-year purchase contract [2].
6.1 The Solar Power Movement A powerful change in energy usage among retailers is shining through with each new company announcement. Collectively, solar power implementation is getting significant traction throughout the retail sector, although the number of stores today with those systems is relatively small as the industry experiments with the technology. In late 2007, Wal-Mart announced a solar power pilot project in California and Hawaii to outfit twenty-two facilities with solar energy systems, with a projected output of 20 million kWh per year [3]. The company signed ten-year agreements with three companies: SunEdison LLC, BP Solar and SunPower Corporation. WalMart will maintain ownership of the Renewable Energy Credits (RECs) that the solar systems produce. According to Charles Zimmerman, Wal-Mart’s vice president, prototype and new format development, once it has evaluated the results of the pilot projects, the company may move forward with additional solar power systems for other stores [4]. In late 2008, Wal-Mart announced the installation of its fifteenth system at a store in Hanford, California, a 554-kW array, estimated to provide about 15% of the store’s annual electricity consumption [5]. Figure 6.1 shows a Wal-Mart store in Southern California with an extensive rooftop solar array. J. Yudelson, Sustainable Retail Development, DOI 10.1007/978-90-481-2782-5_6, C 2009 by the International Council of Shopping Centers Copyright
87
88
6
Solar Power
Fig. 6.1 Wal-Mart was a pioneer in using extensive rooftop area for solar power generation, as shown by this project in California. Courtesy of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
In January 2009, Wal-Mart Mexico announced plans to install a 174-kW solar system on top of its Bodega Aurrera Aguascalientes store, which at this time is the largest solar array in Latin America. “This is the first large-scale project to generate energy using photovoltaic panels, not only for Wal-Mart Mexico, but for Wal-Mart International. This puts Mexico at the head of the energy field. The project reinforces our commitment to obtain all the energy the company requires from renewable sources by 2025,” said Raul Arguelles, senior vice president for corporate affairs and people division at Wal-Mart Mexico [6]. In 2008, Safeway Stores installed solar systems on its Placerville, California [7] store and two of its Pavilions stores in California [8]. The grocer has plans to “solarize” twenty-three stores, mainly in California, with systems averaging about 300 kW each. Collectively, these systems are expected to produce 7.5 million kWh per year [9]. According to Joe Pettus, senior vice president of Safeway, “Safeway, one of California’s largest renewable energy purchasers, has embarked upon a major solar initiative with Solar Power Partners to augment our comprehensive Greenhouse Gas Reduction Initiative. There are many items that must come together to make solar economics work, with no two projects being exactly the same” [10]. As of September 2008, Kohl’s department stores installed sixty solar systems on stores in California, New Jersey, Wisconsin and Connecticut, with another twenty in various stages of construction. At the end of 2008, it appeared that Kohl’s was the largest U.S. retail host of solar power [11]. Kohl’s program is expected to generate 35 million kWh annually [12]. Ken Bonning, executive vice president for Kohl’s, said, “Kohl’s is committed to being environmentally responsible. We are actively
6.1
The Solar Power Movement
89
seeking ways to make a difference as an organization. Our continued commitment to green power is an important way Kohl’s can make an immediate and long-term impact” [13]. Other retailers with solar power announcements include: • On Earth Day 2008, Macy’s announced a plan to install solar power systems on twenty-eight stores [14]. For fifteen of the stores, Macy’s will purchase solargenerated electricity from a third-party financier. At the end of 10 years, Macy’s can renew the agreement, transfer the equipment to a new site or buy the system. Macy’s plans to purchase outright solar power systems for the other forty stores [15]. • Target installed solar panels on the roofs of eighteen of its California stores in 2007 supplying 20% of their electricity needs [16]. • In August 2008, JCPenney announced plans for solar and wind power projects to supply electricity to ten stores in California and New Jersey and one distribution center in Nevada. “These projects further our commitment to incorporate sustainability into all aspects of our operations. We will closely monitor the results to determine how we can best leverage these innovative methods to increase our participation in renewable energy projects while also benefiting our business,” said Jim Thomas, vice president and director of corporate social responsibility for JCPenney [17]. • In 2007, Costco installed its second solar system at one of its California warehouse facilities [18]. • In January 2009, the Kona Commons shopping center in Kailua-Kona, Hawaii completed a 803-kW project consisting of seventeen distinct rooftop PV systems. Each system is net-metered, and tenants enter into separate agreements with the developer to purchase power from the system [19]. • By late 2008, REI, the outdoor gear and apparel consumer coop, installed solar systems on three San Francisco Bay Area stores, bringing the retailer 50% closer to its goal of installing solar on 10% of its stores [20]. • The largest U.S. solar power system installed in a shopping mall was inaugurated in February 2009, when The Shops at Mission Viejo in Mission Viejo, California added a 20,000-ft2 , 173-kW rooftop system costing more than $1 million. To fund this project, Simon Property Group entered into a power purchase agreement with Houston, Texas–based Element Markets. The system will supply an estimated 5% of the mall’s total annual electricity consumption [21]. Third parties finance most of these projects, with various end-of-lease arrangements. (See the section entitled “The Solar Services Model” in this chapter for a more extensive description of how third-party equipment leasing partnerships work.) Typically, the retailer agrees to take all energy generated by the system (which is typically no more than 30% of its daytime needs) and to pay prevailing or slightly reduced retail electrical energy rates. Ownership of the renewable energy credits created by the solar power output is negotiable between the retailer and the solar system provider. Since the systems provide less power than the typical
90
6
Solar Power
daytime demand of a retailer, except on those rare holidays when a store is closed, there is no need to sell power back to the electrical grid, effectively displacing the marginal price of electricity that would otherwise be purchased during those hours. According to one source [22]. SunEdison, the largest commercial solar power provider in the U.S., sells commercial solar power at or below the going rate for electricity, by leveraging capital from Goldman Sachs and other investors to cover the initial capital cost of installing PV panels on customers’ roofs. By mid-2007, SunEdison already had built 127 of its distributed generation systems nationwide for many customers, including retailers Staples and Whole Foods.
6.2 Solar Technology PVs come in two basic forms: stand-alone PVs, which are typically installed on rooftops (but could be used as shading devices for surface parking lots); and building-integrated photovoltaics (BIPVs), which are usually placed on sunshades, skylights or spandrel panels, or integrated with roofing tiles. For most retailers, the roof-mounted stand-alone solar arrays are probably the system of choice, provided there is enough roof area to make for an economical installation. In general, a free roof area of at least 50,000 ft2 will provide this required area and generate up to 500 kW (peak) system power output, given the efficiencies of today’s PV technology.1 With today’s technology, it is probably better to use single-crystal or polycrystalline solar modules, since they produce about twice as much power per unit area as the “amorphous” silicon panels; hence, they require only half the roof area. In turn, this means that a given area of roof can generate twice as much power. However, solar thin-film technology is advancing rapidly, and retailers should consider new advances from major manufacturers when examining the costs and viability of solar power for their facilities. Some estimates are that the cost of solar power may decrease to about the level of that of conventional power by 2014 (a phenomenon known as “grid parity”), as solar cell production costs continue to fall and retail electricity prices continue to grow. One research firm estimated that venture capital firms pumped $264 million into solar companies in 2006, which is one indicator that expected cost reductions are likely to be achieved [23].
6.3 The Current Market The current U.S. market for photovoltaics for retailers is dominated by investment partnerships, or by large vendors with financing to complete the transaction and take all the tax and utility benefits. In this context, the market is vastly changed from the 1 10–12
W (AC) of peak power per ft2 (100–120 W/m2 ) is typically the output of today’s solar technology.
6.3
The Current Market
91
PV market during the 1980s and 1990s, when energy was a lot cheaper and PV systems were much more expensive. Consider these points about solar energy in the U.S.: • For commercial systems, costs have come down, from about $10 per W (peak) a few years ago to less than $6 per W (peak) in 2008. • For systems placed in service before the end of 2016, the federal tax credit for PVs is 30%. • Accelerated depreciation tax deduction adds about 25% (net) to the tax benefits of PV systems. • Many state, city, and utility programs are offering additional incentives, in the form of tax credits, subsidies based on system size or payments for power generated.2
Fig. 6.2 This Office Depot store in Austin, Texas, uses solar power to offset a portion of store electricity needs. Photo courtesy of SBLM
2 For
a updated directory of state incentives for renewable energy and energy efficiency, visit www.dsireusa.org, accessed December 21, 2008.
92
6
Solar Power
• Most experts expect the price of electricity to rise considerably in the future, probably faster than the rate of inflation, making the output of PV systems more valuable over time. • Globally, the solar power industry is projected to grow fourfold by 2010, from $20 billion in 2006 to $90 billion in 2010 [24]. Figure 6.2 shows a typical retail solar power system, in this case on top of an Office Depot store.
6.4 Economics of PV Solar Power Without access to third-party financing, of course, a company must make its own investment in solar PV systems. Without tax incentives, feed-in tariffs or other financial supports, the economics of solar power are not very favorable. Take a look at the basic economics of PVs as an add-on power source for buildings (this is a rough order-of-magnitude approach, but not far off), shown Tables 6.1 and 6.2. Table 6.1 Basic Economics of PV Systemsa System cost (50 kW—peak output) $300,000 (assuming $6/W-peak installed) Annual energy output: 75,000 kWh (assuming 1,500 kWh/kW-peak/year) Value of output: $9,000 (at 12 cents/kWh) Annual return on investment: 3.0%, assuming no maintenance costs Payback: 33 years (at 0% discount rate); never (at 5% discount) a
Examples calculated by the author.
An easy way to estimate the cost of PV-generated power is to first collect the following information: 1. Cost of installation, excluding the value of all incentives, expressed as dollars per kW (typically given at peak power output). 2. Annual energy generated (the typical U.S. range is 1,200–1,800 kWh per year, per kW-peak power rating) 3. Value of power generated: typically the retail rate, 8–12 cents per kWh (although some places may have slightly higher average rates) Table 6.2 Average Cost in Cents/kWh over 20 Years for Solar Power Panelsa Production (kWh/kw-Peak/Year) Net Cost
$2,400
2,200
2,000
1,800
1,600
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
3000 $/kWp 4200 $/kWp 4600 $/kWp 5000 $/kWp
12.5 17.5 19.2 20.8
13.6 19.1 20.9 22.7
15.0 21.0 23.0 25.0
16.7 23.3 25.6 27.8
18.8 26.3 28.8 31.3
21.4 30.0 32.9 35.7
25.0 35.0 38.3 41.7
30.0 42.0 46.0 50.0
37.5 52.5 57.5 62.5
a
Examples calculated by the author. Production is actual kWh (AC power) output.
6.5
Financial Benefits of PV Solar Power
93
4. System lifetime: assume 20 years 5. Net Present Value (NPV) factor: Determine the best way to discount the value of future electricity—typically, figure a 5% discount rate (like a twenty-year government bond); over twenty years, the value of getting $1 each year at 5% is worth $12.46 today. Remember, this is pretty risk-free, and typically generates a fairly reliable return. Then apply this easy formula: Value of PV electricity = (Annual kilowatt-hours produced) × (retail electric rate) × NPV factor. (For example = 1,500 kWh × $0.12 × 12.46 = $2,243.) This sample result says that the system cost could be $2,243 (per kW-peak) and it would generate a 5%, 20-year return, at 12 cents per kWh. If the retail rate is 15 cents, then one could pay up to $2,803 for the same return. If power costs increase faster than the rate of inflation, then even more could be spent on the system, after taking all incentives into account. The fundamental economic problem is: if the system costs $6,000 per kW, there will never be a return on investment, without considering tax and other benefits. From Table 6.1 and the sample calculation, it is easy to see that without tax incentives and utility payments, there is little direct economic justification for photovoltaics as an add-on energy supply system for private projects (in areas with no utility credits or low peak period power rates). Table 6.2 shows how to calculate the cost of solar-generated electricity, given the amount of sunshine available and the installed (net) cost of solar power systems. Readers can apply their own economic variables to come up with a similar table. The calculated values in the table reflect the total cost in cents per kWh produced. They assume a 10% total capital cost (for instance 4% interest rate, 1% operating and maintenance cost, and depreciation of the capital outlay over twenty years). The table can be modified based on the unique variables of the country in which the business is operating.
6.5 Financial Benefits of PV Solar Power But now, the potential financial benefits to PV system owners are shown in the list in Table 6.3. These can change the economic outlook dramatically for most users. Despite the unfavorable “raw” economics of implementing PV systems, Table 6.4 indicates that in some cases, at least, it may pay to look at a full range of economic and financial benefits, particularly those that will reduce initial costs or secure a rapid payback. For example, some states, such as Oregon, offer a 50% solar tax credit and allow projects to “pass through” state tax credits to other private entities, making this benefit realizable to private investment partnerships. In such situations, a PV project may command a return on investment (or internal rate of return) of up to 10–12%.
94
6
Solar Power
Table 6.3 Financial Benefits to PV System Owners • • • • • • •
Federal and state accelerated depreciation (for stand-alone systems) might be worth 25% net Federal tax credits (30% for commercial PV systems put in place by the end of 2016) State tax credits (e.g., Oregon tax credit is valued at about 25% of initial cost) State and local subsidies ($2,000–$3,000 per kW in some places like California and Arizona) Utility credits and payments for power produced (15–30 cents per kWh or more) Peak period power savings, in areas where power demand is monitored “real time” Greenhouse gas emission reduction credits (Renewable Energy Credits)
The financial benefits of solar power have been significant enough to generate tens of millions of dollars for investment partnerships dedicated to investing in solar power on buildings, including retail stores. Many of the larger retailers have one very under-utilized asset: the large expanse of roof area that serves now mainly to keep the rain out. Typically retailers do not have to worry about shading of rooftop solar panels, either, since they are surrounded by parking lots. The rooftops are also largely vandal-proof, since they are generally out of sight and/or hard to reach, with 24/7 security the norm in large retail environments. Table 6.4 Noneconomic or Intangible PV System Benefits PV feature
Benefit to user or owner
PV systems on buildings are visible from the street PV output can be measured and displayed easilya PVs are a visible commitment to renewable energy
It is immediately recognizable to the public that you have a green building that uses solar energy PV can be incorporated into public education about green buildings They may generate support for retail projects and result in faster entitlements for development projects Because they are visible and do not pollute, PV systems may be perceived as attractive and thus gain media attention to publicize the project PVs can be part of a “micro-utility” that can be owned and operated by a private company, even for public projects, qualifying them for full tax benefits. As physical property, PV systems may qualify for accelerated depreciation
Larger PV systems are still newsworthy in most locations Rooftop PV systems can be physically separated from the underlying building and owned by different entities and taxed as physical property instead of real estate, which is beneficial under U.S. tax law To the public, PV systems represent a commitment to using renewable energy PVs can help get additional LEED project credits for energy efficiency and renewable energy
a
PVs can be part of the branding of a retail company
The value of moving from a basic LEED-certified project to a LEED Silver level may be significant where there are tax credits, or where there is an owner or public policy requirement for attaining LEED Silver (or higher) certification
For one example, see http://www.qualityattributes.com/greentouchscreen
6.7
The Solar Services Model
95
6.6 Noneconomic Benefits of Solar Power Consider, too, the noneconomic benefits (some tangible, others intangible) that may come with installing PV systems, as shown in Table 6.4, which describes how PV systems may translate into user or owner benefits. The major point of this discussion is that PV has a prime benefit for retailers, because it is a visible commitment to renewable energy, or because “The six o’clock news will have something to film.” Based on the list of benefits in Table 6.4, it is clear that the decision whether to go with PVs should not be made just by the electrical or energy engineer, but the senior corporate leaders. Proponents of photovoltaics have to be creative in presenting the economics and financing of solar energy systems, as well as the nonquantifiable benefits, to upper management. Architects, engineers and contractors who are PV proponents should also incorporate these benefits in presentations to owners and design review committees.
6.7 The Solar Services Model Installation of PV systems accelerated from 2006 to 2008 because investors, store operators and developers figured out how to separate ownership of the PV system from that of the underlying building. This micro-utility model was first used in the 1980s to install solar water-heating systems in apartment buildings in California; at the time, there was a 55% state solar tax credit, a 25% federal solar tax credit, and generous depreciation schedules. However, as energy prices decreased in the early 1980s, the psychological preference for renewable energy waned, and when those tax benefits disappeared in 1986, so did these programs.3 In the more recent solar services model, a company agrees to buy all the solar electricity generated by a rooftop PV system for a period of at least ten years, at then-prevailing commercial electrical rates. (In essence, the company is running its meter backward.) According to a 2007 report, General Motors, Alcoa, Staples and Whole Foods were installing such units on the roofs of their warehouses and bigbox retail stores. These facilities typically had more than 80,000 ft2 of rooftop area, as well as unimpeded access to sunlight and plenty of electrical demand [25]. In the solar services model, investors build, own and operate the PV systems, while leasing the rooftop for a nominal amount. Typically, the units are larger than 100 kW ($600,000 installed cost), which helps pay for the cost of installation and all the sales and marketing expenses. For a $1,000,000 system, for example, the current U.S. federal tax credit would be $300,000, and accelerated depreciation could add another $250,000 in net benefits. In the state of Oregon, a solar tax credit would net another $250,000 in state tax benefits, as well as electricity payments of $0.15 per
3 Personal
experience of the author, at one time director of solar industry commercialization programs for the state of California.
96
6
Solar Power
Table 6.5 Considerations in Purchasing Solar Power from Investment Partnerships 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Length of contract? Anything over 15 years may tie you up for too long Options to renew after 10 years or purchase the system Provisions for default or lack of production, including system removal Level of experience of vendor and reliability of its financing source Can the investment partnerships get access to product, so that the installation will finish before December 31, 2016? Will the installation have any effect on the roof warranty? What if the investment firm goes out of business? Will you have the right to take over the system? What is the price for electricity in the contract? Is it pegged to prevailing utility rates (e.g., 10% off the going rate), or is it level for the term of the contract? Who will own the renewable energy credits? You may want to own these for offsetting other corporate carbon generation
kWh. Table 6.5 presents some of the considerations to explore when an investment group approaches a company or vendors representing them. Tax benefits and utility payments can meet 80–100% of total system cost. Thus, investors would not have to rely on the rather small 2–3% of capital cost generated each year by the electricity from the PV system. For example, at $0.10 per kWh payment and 1,500 kWh/kW per year net power output, a 1 kW system costing $6,000 would generate perhaps $150 a year in income—a 40-year payback, without tax and/or utility incentives. Retailers thinking about investing directly in solar power should be sure to consult a knowledgeable tax advisor, to ensure they can use all the tax credits and other benefits in a reasonable period of time.
6.8 Summary Solar power is a visible signal to consumers that a retail operator or a shopping center operator has a commitment to renewable energy. Depending on the particular tax, utility and incentive programs of a given country or region, a retailer might choose a direct purchase or a third-party supplier. Of all the energy technologies today, solar power offers the best indirect benefits in terms of marketing, political issues and consumer preference; it is also the technology with the greatest potential for future cost reductions. As a result, 2009 and 2010 might be opportune years for retail organizations to get some experience with solar power systems and to figure out how to incorporate them into future planning for stores and centers.
References 1. Yudelson, Jerry. (2007, December). Letting the sun shine on the retail sector. ICSC Research Review, 14 (3), p. 3. 2. Weng, Rainer. (2007, April 23). Photovoltaic investments outside Germany? Looking into the southern EU states. Retrieved on December 21, 2008, from http://www.solarserver.de/ solarmagazin/solar-report_0407_e.html.
References
97
3. Wal-Mart launches solar power pilot project. Retrieved December 1, 2007, from http://www. walmartfacts.com/FactSheets/Solar_Power_Pilot_Project.pdf. 4. Charles, Zimmerman, December 2007, personal communication. 5. Wal-Mart and SunPower complete work on solar power system in Hanford store. (2008, December 12). Retrieved on February 15, 2009, from http://www.walmartstores.com/ FactsNews/NewsRoom/8885.aspx. 6. Grover, Sami. (2009, January 22). Wal-Mart Mexico launches largest solar array in Latin America. Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.treehugger. com/files/2009/01/wal-mart-mexico-solar.php?daylife=1&dcitc=daylife-article. 7. Safeway Celebrates Earth Day with Two New California Solar-Powered Stores. (2008, April 21). Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.foxbusiness.com/story/markets/ industries/retail/safeway-celebrates-earth-day-new-california-solar-powered-stores/. 8. Bruce, Allison. (2008, October 21). Pavilions store unveils alternative power source. Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.venturacountystar.com/news/2008/oct/21/ going-solar-in-simi-pavilions-store-unveils/. 9. Safeway to install solar power panels on 23 stores. (2007, September 14). Retrieved on December 13, 2007, from http://www.environmentalleader.com/2007/09/14/ safeway-to-install-solar-power-panels-on-23-stores/. 10. Solar power partners completes flagship Safeway solar project.(2007, September 18). Retrieved on December 18, 2008, fromhttp://www.energyrecommerce.com/ index.php?fuseaction=public.news_article&id=13. 11. Kohl’s web site. Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.kohlsgreenscene.com/ KohlsInitiatives/EnergyManagementPrograms.html. 12. Hajewski, Doris. (2007, April 26). Kohl s to go solar in California. Journal Sentinel. Retrieved on December 15, 2007, from http://www.jsonline.com/story/index.aspx?id=596541. 13. Kohl’s readies its California rooftops for solar power. (2007, April 26). Retrieved on December 18, 2007, from http://www.kohlscorporation.com/2007PressReleases/ News0426Release.htm. 14. Macy’s hails Earth Day with SunPower solar dedication in San Jose. (2008, April 21). Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.foxbusiness.com/story/markets/ industries/energy/macys-hails-earth-day-sunpower-solar-dedication-san-jose/. 15. Macy’s installs solar power in 26 stores. (2007, June 6). Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.environmentalleader.com/2007/06/06/macys-installs-solar-power-in-26-stores/. 16. Target web site. Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://sites.target.com/site/en/company/ page.jsp?contentId=WCMP04-031814. 17. JCPenney launches solar and wind power projects. (2008, August 13). Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.csrwire.com/News/12855.html. 18. Costco expands solar energy system. (2007, February 6). Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.environmentalleader.com/2007/02/06/costco-expands-solar-system/. 19. Sunetric completes largest rooftop solar project in Hawaii. (2009, January 30). Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.solarindustrymag.com/e107_plugins/content/ content.php?content.2457 20. Guevarra, Leslie. (2008, November 14). REI forges ahead with solar plan. Retrieved on February 12, 2009, from http://www.greenerbuildings.com/news/2008/11/14/rei-solar-plan. 21. Simon completes solar panel installation at The Shops at Mission Viejo. (2009, February 4). Retrieved on February 15, 2009, from http://www.csrwire.com/News/14498. 22. Park, Andrew. (2007) The 6th annual Fast 50. Fast Company. Retrieved on December 18, 2007, from http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/113/open_14-sunedison.html. 23. Davidson, Paul. (2007, August 28). Forecast for solar power: Sunny. USA Today. Retrieved on December 18, 2007, from http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/environment/ 2007-08-26-solar_N.htm 24. Marsh, Peter. (2007, April 4) Solar energy demand soars. Financial Times Retrieved on December 18, 2007, from http://www.ft.com/cms/s/edfdbbf0-e248-11db-af9e-000b5df10621,
98
6
Solar Power
Authorised=false.html?_i_location=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ft.com%2Fcms%2Fs%2F0% 2Fedfdbbf0-e248-11db-af9e-000b5df10621.html%3Fnclick_check%3D1&_i_referer= &nclick_check=1. 25. Deutsch, Claudia H. (2006, October 21). New York Times. Retrieved on December 18, 2007, from, http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/21/business/21solar.html.
Chapter 7
Greening Shopping Centers
At the first European green shopping center conference, Centrebuild, hosted by the ICSC in 2008, it was obvious to the author that elements of the European retail real estate development community were doing a lot to incorporate low-energy design and sustainability concerns into their new projects, perhaps even more so than North American developers. At this time, beyond new development, few developers are tackling the refurbishment of existing centers to secure greater energy savings, except at normal—8to 15-year—intervals when the retail environment itself requires major alternations. Let’s look at some European shopping center developers and their sustainability programs.
7.1 European Green Building Programs Jerry Percy, head of sustainability for the Gleeds management/construction consulting firm in the U.