Linguistik AktuelljLinguistics Today (LA) provides a platform for original monograph studies into synchronic and diachr...
58 downloads
1932 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Linguistik AktuelljLinguistics Today (LA) provides a platform for original monograph studies into synchronic and diachronic linguistics. Studies in LA confront empirical and theoretical problems as these are currently discussed in syntax, semantics, morphology, phonology, and systematic pragmatics with the aim to establish robust empirical generalizations within a universalistic perspective.
Series Editor VVernerAlbraham University of California at Berkeley University of Vienna
Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
Advisory Editorial Board Guglielmo Cinque (University of Venice) Gunther Grewendorf (T.W. Goethe-University, Frankfurt) Liliane Haegeman (University of Lille, France) Hubert Haider (University of Salzburg) Christer Platzack (University of Lund) Ian Roberts (University of Stuttgart) Ken Safir (Rutgers University, New Brunswick NJ) Hoskuldur Thrainsson (University of Iceland, Reykjavik) Lisa deMena Travis (McGill University) Sten Vikner (University of Stuttgart) C. Jan-Wouter Zwart (University of Groningen)
Volume 3I Peter Svenonius (ed.)
The Derivation of va and av
E
E
o
VOANDOV
Edited by PETER SVENONIUS
University ofTroms�
JOHN BENJAMINS PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM
/
PHILADELPHIA
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences - Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI
Z39.48-1984-
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The derivation of VO and OV / edited by Peter Svenonius. p.
cm. -- (Linguistik aktuell / Linguistics today, ISSN 0166-0829; v. 31)
Based on a workshop held May 1998, University ofTroms0. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Grammar, Comparative and general--Word order 2. Grammar, Comparative and general- Sentences. 3. Typology (Linguistics). 4. Generative grammar I. Svenonius, Peter. II. Linguistik aktuell ; Bd. 31. P295.D46
2000
415--dc21 ISBN
©
90 272 2752 7
(EUR)
/ 1 55619 915 5
(US) (alk. paper)
99-088392
2000 - John Benjamins B.V.
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfIlm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. . P.O.Box 75577 . 1070 AN AMSTERDAM · The Netherlands John Benjamins North America· P.O.Box 27519 . Philadelphia PA 19118-0519 . U SA
Table of Contents
Introduction
1
Peter Svenonius Word Order, Restructuring and Mirror Theory
27
Michael Brody OV is More Basic than VO
45
Hubert Haider Remnant Movement and OV Order
69
Liliane Haegeman V-movement and VP-movement in Derivations Leading to VO-order
97
Knut Tarald Taraldsen Deriving OV Order in Finnish
1 23
Anders Holmberg Parameter Change in Icelandic
153
Porbjorg Hr6arsd6ttir The Righ,t Periphery in SOV Languages : English and Dutch
181
Sjef Barbiers Nominal Structure: An Extension of the Symmetry Principle
219
Quantifier Movement in Icelandic
255
Naoki Fukui & Yuji Takano
Peter Svenonius Licensing Movement and Stranding in the West Germanic OV Languages
Roland Hinterholzl
293
TABLE OF CONTENTS
vi
Two Types of VO Languages
327
Matthew Pearson Index
365
Peter Svenonius University of Troms¢
This volume grew out of a workshop held at the University of Tromsjj in May of 1 998 (a detailed report on that workshop appears as Svenonius 1 998). The volume contains eleven papers dealing with various aspects of the differences between VO and OV languages, especially with the derivation of one or the other or both from the same or different base structures. Of the eleven, the papers by Fukui & Takano and Haegeman were not presented at the conference; papers by Alison Henry and Susan Pintzuk, which were presented there, could unfortunately not be included in the volume. I would like to take this opportunity to thank all of the participants both in the workshop and the creation of the volume, especially my colleagues Anders Holmberg and Tarald Taraldsen, and also the anonymous reviewers who assisted us in the process of critiquing the various papers for revision. 1 In this introduction I quickly and subjectively tour the history of the work on VO and OV word order which gave rise to the papers at hand. At appropriate points I discuss the current papers, placing them in their respective contexts. A majority of the papers, it will be noted, deal mainly or exclusively with Germanic languages. This bias was inherent in the composition of the workshop, and reflects in part the research programs of the faculty here in Tromsjj, in part a tendency in the recent wave of research that has occurred in the wake of Kayne's influential work, codified in his 1 994 book.
1.
Typology
The broad division of languages of the world into the subclasses VO and OV comes from typological studies. Greenberg ( 1 963), dividing a 30-language sample into classes in which the 'basic' or unmarked main clause order of
2
PETER SVENONIUS
S [ubject] , V [erb] , and O [bject] is VSO, SVO, or SOY, catalogued a litany of word order patterns that corresponded with the basic word orders: he noted, for example, that in languages in which SOY order is basic, an inflected auxiliary follows the main verb; complementarily, VSO correlates with Aux-V order (Universal number 1 6). Exceptions are now known to many of the universals Greenberg proposed, but most of them still survive as significant tendencies. Subsequent work, at least since Lehmann 1 973, has usually collapsed SVO and VSO (along with VOS) into one type, YO, contrasting with the OV type (though see e.g. Hawkins 1983 for arguments against a unified VO type). Many of Greenberg' s universals still hold up even for these more general categories VO and OV when examined against larger samples. For example, Dryer 1 992 shows that the correlation of VO with Aux-V, and of OV and V-Aux holds for about 90% of the languages for which Dryer had the relevant data (64 of 7 1 languages with inflected auxiliaries expressing tense or aspect). Vennemann 1 974 labeled the two types VX and XV, based on the fact that other elements tend to pattern with the object. For example, there is a systematic cross-linguistic tendency for PPs and DP complements to appear on the same side of the verb. The same is true for manner adverbs: they appear on the same side of a verb, in the usual case, as the direct object: the opposite side from the auxiliary verb (cf. Dryer 1 992). Furthermore, the tendencies extend into other categories. VO languages tend to have prepositions, not postpositions, and the opposite is true of OV languages (cf. Greenberg's Universals 3 and 4). Genitive possessors in the noun phrase have a clear predisposition to follow N in VO languages, and to precede N in OV languages (cf. Greenberg's Universal 2; cf. also Hawkins 1 983). The tendencies are unmistakeable, though in almost every case, exceptions can also be found. Subtler distinctions than the unmarked order of major elements may also distinguish VO from OV languages. For example, Greenberg noted some morphological tendencies : there is a correspondence between morphological case and OV order (Universal 4 1 ) . Others have proposed that syntactic mechanisms are sensitive to the VO/OV distinction. For example, Ross 1 967a argued that Gapping, a deletion transformation, operated to the right in VO languages, giving rise to the order SVO and SO, and to the left in OV languages, giving SO and SOV. He also argued that OV languages cannot have rightward movement rules. Similarly, Fukui 1 993 suggests that orderings which do not preserve head-finality in an OV language are more costly, in terms of derivational economy (Chomsky 1 992), than orderings which do. He also suggests that VO languages favor reorderings that preserve head-initiality (cf. also Steele 1 978, who notes that VSO and VOS are frequently alternatives for a single language, as are SOY and OSV).
INTRODUCTION
3
My contribution to this volume explores a particular instantiation of this general tendency; specifically, I take up the contrast in Icelandic between Object Shift, a leftward movement which preserves VO order, and Quantifier Move ment, which gives rise to OV structures. As Icelandic Quantifier Movement has been little studied, I document its characteristics. I argue that Norwegian has a form of Quantifier Movement which does preserve VO order, which bears on the question of whether languages like Dutch and Yiddish might have a version of Object Shift which perturbs VO structure.
2.
Analysis
Various accounts have been offered of the Greenbergian ordering correlations (see for example the various papers in Hawkins 1 988), ranging from strictly formal, grammar-internal accounts to historical accounts to accounts based on processing and other potentially extragrammatical factors (cf. e.g. Frazier 1 979 for an early processing-based account, Hawkins 1 994 for a recent one). Historical and functional accounts necessarily interact with formal syntactic accounts, though linguists differ according to which they take to be of primary concern. In early generative grammar, phrase structure rules were assumed to stipulate word order. Cross-categorial tendencies are potentially captured in an abstract X' theory like that of Chomsky 1 970, and with the advent of the notion of parameters it became common to assume a headedness parameter for deep structures: languages are parametrized according to whether dependents precede or follow the head (Chomsky 1 980: 179, 1 98 1 : 128ff., Stowell 1 9 8 1 : 74f.). On the other hand, it seems that in actual practice it has not been uncommon to assume that, for example, noun phrases in a given language are head-final while other categories are head-initial (e.g. Huang 1 982 for Chinese). On such a view, the headedness parameter describes why no single category varies (e.g. no 2 language has some head-initial verbs and some head-final ones), but does not account for cross-categorial tendencies (but see Jackendoff 1 977: 8 1-85, who suggests that a simplicity metric will favor grammars in which X' rules are cross-categorially general). Even given category-specific headedness parameters, there are many exceptions to the universals. One approach to these exceptions has been to take them to be historical residue, the result of a shift from consistent OV, say, to verb-before-object but retaining other OV characteristics. Another approach has been to eliminate the exceptions through fine-grained analysis. For example, if auxiliaries are taken as dependents of the verb, as in traditional grammar, then
4
PETER SVENONIUS
the fact that they appear on the opposite side of the verb from the object is confusing. Independent evidence, however, suggests that auxiliaries head their own projections (Pullum & Wilson 1 977; Gazdar, Pullum, & Sag 1 982), and that the main verb is in fact the dependent of its auxiliary. Given the analogy Aux:V::V:O, the word order facts fit neatly into place. As another, somewhat more speculative example, take the order of nouns and possessor noun phrases: N[oun]-G[enitive] order correlates with VO and GN with OV (cf. Greenberg's Universal 2). In Hawkins' ( 1 983) survey of 336 languages, about 96% of VI languages (those with basic order VSO or VOS) are NG, and about 88% of SOY languages are GN, showing a strong correlation. However, when SVO languages are examined, about 67% are NG and 33% are GN. This sort of result led Hawkins and others to doubt that VO order is a significant predictor of other features. But careful analysis gives some hope of bringing the SVO languages back into the fold. Generativists have analyzed parallels between sentences and noun phrases in a number of ways (Lees 1959; Chomsky 1970; Abney 1987). Looking at these analyses, it is clear that a possessor NP sometimes corresponds to the subject and sometimes to the object of the corresponding clause (cf. Koptjevskaja-Tamm 1993). In VI and SOY languages, whether a genitive element is objectlike or subjectlike would not make any difference with respect to NG/GN word order. But in an SVO language, it might be expected that subjectlike genitives precede the noun while objectlike ones follow. Thus, in English, the s-genitive is subjectlike (note that it is the natural choice for the subject of action nominal izations) and precedes N, while the of-genitive is objectlike, being a prepositional phrase, and follows N. 3 Such fine-grained analyses raise the prospect of stating exceptionless syntactic principles governing word order. An important subcase of the general strategy of eliminating exceptions through analysis is to argue that observed tendencies are regular at Deep Structure. German, for example, has objects both before and after verbs, depending on whether one looks at finite or non-finite verb forms and at main or embedded clauses. Bach 1 962 proposed that in German, surface VO order is derived from an OV Deep Structure. This kind of approach opened up the possibility of analyzing apparent exceptions to universals in terms of movement: the idea is that languages are consistent at Deep Structure in having head-initial or head-final characteristics, but transformations may give rise to surface inconsistencies. Ross 1 967 a noted that German was a counterexample to some generalizations about OV languages; he proposed that German is in fact a VO language, with OV order being derived. Japanese and Siouan, according to Ross, are 'Deep' OV languages, while German, Hindi, and Turkish are not.
INTRODUCTION
5
This type of analysis is very common in generative work. However, moving the 'true' nature of a language back to Deep Structure runs the risk of losing Greenbergian correlations, which are stated over surface word order. A headed ness parameter affecting Deep Structures can describe the Greenbergian correla tions only if things don't move around very much, or on the assumption that something like Structure Preservation (Emonds 1 976) prevents non-canonical orders from arising, in the usual case. Several specific proposals have been made that ensure that head-initial or head-final structures will in the usual case be preserved (e.g. those of Ross 1 967a; Steele 1 978; Fukui 1993 mentioned above). Another tack has been to parametrize Surface Structure conditions. Kayne 1983 proposed that government (relevant at various levels, including Surface Structure) is directional, and that the direction is parametrized by language. Koopman 1 984: 1 06ff. and Travis 1 984: 32ff. propose the same for Case assign ment (cf. also Li 1 990). They also argue that theta assignment is directional, and that the parameter for theta role directionality is independent of that of Case assignment. Since theta roles are assumed to be assigned at D-Structure, this subsumes some of the Deep Structure directionality parameter (cf. Koopman op. cit. p. 1 20). Though Travis explicitly argues that a language can have differ ent settings for headedness and theta-assignment, the natural conclusion of this line of thinking is nevertheless to do away with the headedness parameter for phrase structure altogether, letting other, independently motivated mechanisms take over. In this vein, Haider 1 992 proposes a general licensing principle, where licensing occurs to the right in VO languages and to the left in OV languages. If all sentence elements are subject to licensing, including for example manner adverbs, then the tendency for all subordinate elements (rather than just those which are Case-marked or theta-marked) to precede or follow their superordinate heads is expected. On the other hand, it is less clear exactly what is subject to the licensing principle. For example, the subject precedes the verb in many VO languages. Possibly, this could be due to some exceptional property of nomina tive case. If nominative case is not subject to more general licensing conditions covering other types of sentence elements, this might provide an explanation for why no ergative languages are SVO (Anderson 1 976; Trask 1 979; Dixon 1 994; Nash 1 996, 1998), since then ergative languages would have to license both arguments in the same direction, unlike accusative languages. 4 At yet another remove from Deep Structure, it is sometimes argued that ordering is strictly a P[honetic] F[orm] phenomenon (e.g. Chomsky 1 994; Uriagereka 1 999). Takano 1 996 and Fukui & Takano 1 998 propose a specific process of linearization of syntactic terminals occurring at PF. They identify two mechanisms operating on syntactic trees to derive pronounceable phonetic
6
PETER SVENONIUS
structures, Demerge and Concatenate. Demerge breaks down syntactic trees, operating top-down and removing maximal projections, defined as non-projecting nodes, and passing them to Concatenate, which linearizes them. A specifier is always a maximal projection, while its sister is not; this leads to specifiers consistently being linearized before their sisters. A complement XP will also be linearized before a head Y, since the head projects Y' and is therefore not maximal. Fukui & Takano assimilate head movement to phrasal movement in taking head movement to attach to phrasal projections; from the derived position, a moved head does not project, while its sister does. Therefore, a moved head will be linearized before other material in the phrase it has attached to. The difference between VO and OV structures, on this view, is due to the fact that in VO structures, the verb has moved to a higher position. Fukui & Takano provide morpho syntactic evidence that this is correct, drawing for example on the connection between OV languages and case noted by Greenberg, as well as various other features. In this volume, Fukui and Takano extend their analysis to noun phrases, arguing that English has N to D raising, resulting in N-initial structures, while Japanese does not. They connect the lack of N to D raising in Japanese to the presence of a classifier system there. They also present a novel analysis of relative clauses and connect the placement of the relative clause (prenominal in Japanese) to the presence or absence of a relative complementizer (absent in Japanese).
3.
Asymmetry
Though most of the typological traits mentioned so far in association with the VO/OV distinction have involved symmetry, neither Haider's theory nor Fukui & Takano's leads to symmetrical structures for VO and OV languages. This is no accident; asymmetrical properties of languages have been apparent from the start. For example, in all of Greenberg's original basic categories, SVO, SOY, and VSO, the subject precedes the object (Universal 1). B ach 1 97 1 noted that wh-movement, when it occurs, is invariably to the left, and that SOY languages don't usually have wh-movement at all (cf. Greenberg's Universal 1 2). It has also been noted that clausal dependents have a tendency to appear to the right of the elements they are dependent on. For example, many OV languages have clausal complements to the right of V (Dryer 1980; Givon 1 984). Such observations often invite explanations in terms of processing (cf. Hawkins 1 994 and references there, e.g. on pp. 5-9). Frequently, processing accounts can fruitfully be seen as interacting with formal syntactic accounts. For
INTRODUCTION
7
example, NRel (relative clause after noun) is vastly more likely than ReIN in va languages, but OV languages are mixed (cf. Hawkins 1983). Two tendencies can thus be seen as interacting: the tendency for clausal elements to be to the right, plausibly due to processing factors, and the headedness parameter, placing depen dents on the same side of their heads, arguably not a function of processing. In this light, consider the fact that the subject almost always precedes the verb in OV languages, but va languages are more mixed; the two tendencies, then, might be for the subject to appear on the same side of the verb as the other dependent elements versus the tendency for the subject to be to the left. In this case as well, the force counteracting the headedness parameter may be amenable to a functional interpretation: subjects may appear to the left because they tend to be topics, and the tendency of topics to be initial may stem from information packaging strategies (Halliday 1 967; Li & Thompson 1 976; Vallduvf 1990). On the other hand, grammar has a tendency to steer the individual language; for example, in many languages, subjects appear in a fixed position, whether they are topics or not, and in others, there is a distinct position for subjects which are not topics (cf. Svenonius in press for some examples from Germanic languages). Thus, the functional explanation for the relative order of the subject and the object interacts with a formalist explanation for the properties of positions of case assignment and other types of formal licensing. In the papers in this volume, the formal constraints are of central interest. Thus, given that Dutch and English are identical in the relative order of indirect object and direct object, or of direct object and PP, as seen in (1) (from Haider 1992), it can be assumed that the licensing positions for the various elements are identical (presumably universally), as in the analyses of Haider 1 992 and Zwart 1 993, without investi gating why exactly the order of the licensing positions is the way it is. Attention focuses then on the position of the verb, which precedes the VP-internal elements in English and follows them in Dutch, in an embedded clause. (1)
a.
b.
. .. omdat ze iedereen een pakje naar hem thuis zullen because they everybody a package to his home should opsturen (Dutch) send . . . because they would send everybody a package to his home address
Haider's proposal, referred to above, is designed to account for the parallel word order. On Haider's account, OV order is basic: VP-internal elements are base generated in the projection of V. The verb starts low and stays there in a strict OV language, but in a va language, it climbs by head movement to a higher
8
PETER SVENONIUS
position. Thus, a clause like the English one in ( 1b) is derived by head move ment, and the VP-intemal arguments are in situ, much as in Larson 1 988. (2)
[AuxP would [yp send1 [yp everybody t1 [yp a package [v' t1 to his house]]]]]
But the structure for the corresponding German clause is not identical; the B asic Branching Conjecture that Haider proposes coupled with the licensing parameter gives the same hierarchical ranking for the sentence elements, but with the verbal heads in substantially different locations, as sketched in (3) (see Haider's paper for details). (3)
[yp ein Paket [v' an seine Privatadresse [ AuxP [yp jedem everyone a package to his private. addres s
schenken]]] werden] send
would
In his contribution to this volume, Haider extends and refines his proposal, showing how it makes better predictions in several arenas than competing analyses (for which see below).
4.
The Universal Base Hypothesis
Bach 1 968 proposed the Universal Base Hypothesis (UBH) , that all languages have identical Deep Structures, which are permuted by language-specific transformations. This completely shifts the weight of cross-linguistic correlations from the Deep Structure to other parts of the grammar. In fact, Peters & Ritchie 1 969 demonstrated that the UBH is vacuous in the absence of meaningful constraints on transformations. However, once transformations are better understood, the UBH invites a different kind of explanation for asymmetries of the type noted in the previous section. For example, consider the fact that in languages in which the auxiliary precedes the main verb, or Aux-V languages (generally VO languages), material can generally appear between the auxiliary and the main verb, whereas in V-Aux languages, this is not the case. Furthermore, in languages in which both orders are possible, Aux-V order tends to allow elements to intervene, while V-Aux order does not. This can be straightforwardly illustrated using German. 5 (4)
a.
Ich habe (schwer) gearbeitet. I have hard worked 'I have worked (hard). '
(German)
9
INTRODUCTION
b.
. . . daj3 ich gearbeitet (*schwer) habe that I worked hard have ' . . . that I have worked'
The obligatory adjacency of V-Aux order, as opposed to Aux-V order, can be seen as a function of the one being derived from the other (various specific implementations of this are discussed below). If the two orders were simply a matter of the auxiliary taking its complement to the left or the right, this systematic difference would be unexpected. The UBH has been revived in a new form by Kayne 1 994, who proposes, among other things, that all branching is binary, all complements are to the right, all adjuncts or specifiers are to the left, and all movement is to the left. On this view, whatever differences there are between Japanese and English must be a function of the derivation of their respective surface structures. Zwart 1 993, 1 997, and Koster 1 994 demonstrated how OV order in Dutch could be derived from a basic VO order by movement of VP-intemal material to the left, into functional specifier positions (making good the promise of Ross 1 967a, which took languages like Dutch not to be 'Deep' OV languages). A Dutch embedded clause is analyzed much as in (5) (cf. Zwart 1993, Ch. IV). (5)
. . . dat [AgrSP Jan 1 [AgrOP het boek2 [PredP op de tajel3 [yp wi! tl that
John
leggen t2 t3 ]]]]
the book
on the table
will
put
In English, on this view, the movements to licensing positions such as SpecAgrOP
occur covertly. However, such accounts raise various questions. For example, if such movements as those in (5) are triggered by strong features, why are the features generally strong (in consistent OV languages) or generally weak (in consistent VO languages)? In mixed cases, what determines what stays behind (e.g. CP) and what moves (e.g. DP)? (For one mixed case, Icelandic, see my contribution to this volume.) If the word order in OV languages is the result of movement, what ensures that the derived order of constituents is identical to the order of those same constituents in a VO language, in cases like those discussed in §3? The same-order cases are handled straightforwardly by Haider's account, as they are actually in essentially the same positions. In addition, the fact that everything shows up on the same side of the verb is handled by Haider's account, based on a general licensing principle. Two different types of solution have been proposed for same-order effects in VO and OV languages. One solution is to assume that the individual elements
10
PETER SVENONIUS
do not move separately, but together. For example, if the Dutch clause begins somewhat as in (6a) (after subject movement to a high functional projection), then if the main verb moves to a low functional head as in (6b), followed by movement of the VP remnant to a specifier position above the auxiliary as in (6c), the correct surface order is established. (6)
a.
dat Jan [AuxP wil hp [vp leggen het boek op de tafel]]]
b.
dat Jan [AuxP wi[ [IF leggen [vp tv het boek op de tafel]]]
c.
that Jan
will
that Jan
will
put
put
the book on the table
the book on the table
dat Jan [AuxP [vp tv het boek op de tafel] wi[ [IF leggen tvp]]
the book on the table will that Jan ' . . . that John will put the book on the table'
put
This type of movement is proposed by Hinterholzl (cf. his 1 997a: 1 98/1 997b: 1 4), though only in conjunction with various other movements. It is also advocated in the contributions to this volume by Pearson and Haegeman. As Haegeman points out, since such an analysis requires the verb to move to a higher functional head, it is consistent with the assumption that verbs in languages with agreement inflection (including German and Dutch) move overtly to a relatively high functional position, bringing the OV languages more into line with facts about VO languages. Haegeman also shows that this type of analysis can preserve the generalizations of Holmberg 1 986 and Diesing 1 992 which are otherwise compromised by the Zwartian analysis. Haegeman furthermore demonstrates in her contribution to this volume that well-motivated assumptions about negation support the claim that the verb in West Flemish occupies a relatively high position overtly (even though West Flemish exhibits OV structures like Dutch). For example, she argues that the two negative markers in West Flemish, en and nie, correspond to the two negative markers in Piedmontese, pa and nen respectively (discussed in Zanuttini 1 997). Piedmontese pa precedes the adverbs pi 'no longer' and sempre 'always' , as shown in (7a) (from Zanuttini 1 997: 70). However, controlling for V2, West Flemish en follows the corresponding adverbs nie meer and atent, as shown in (7b) (cf. Haegeman's (17), from this volume). (7)
a.
Da
'ntlura, a l'ha
since then
invito
pa pi
sempre acetla
i
nost
he he-has not more always accepted the our (Piedmontese)
invitations 'Since then, he hasn't any longer always accepted our invitations.'
INTRODUCTION
b.
11
. .. da Valere nie meer atent no Gent en-goat (West Flemish) that Valere no more always to Gent EN-goes , . . . that Valere doesn't any longer always go to Gent'
In contrast, adverbial negation (West Flemish nie, Piedmontese nen) follows both
adverbs in both languages (and precedes West Flemish en). Haegeman shows that the clause structures for the two languages can be made harmonious if an extended projection of the VP fronts across the negative head en in West Flemish. The moved constituent carries with it the various adverbial elements, preserving their relative order. The second type of UBH approach to identical sequences in VO and OV structures is to assume that the individual elements in a given clause do occupy the same positions but that the verb moves, roughly as in Haider's approach but with a universal base. B arbiers, in this volume, argues for identical base positions in English and Dutch for a number of different sentence elements, arguing that differences in word order are due primarily to the obligatoriness of 'verb intraposition' (see below) in English coupled with the existence of a short verb movement in English. Verb intraposition, on Barbiers' analysis, is optional in Dutch, and Dutch has no short verb movement. An important variation on this type of approach is to assume that the surface positions of sentence elements are derived: the individual elements in a given clause move to distinct specifier positions in OV languages, as on the Kayne and Zwart proposals, but the same also occurs in VO languages, followed by movement of the verb across those elements roughly as in the Haider and B arbiers proposals. In other words, languages like English would have (5) or (6c) above as an intermediate structure, followed by raising of a constituent contain ing the auxiliary and the main verb to a position below the subject. Such proposals have an ancestor in Larson's 1 988 analysis of Heavy NP Shift phenomena as VP-movement to the left of a heavy object (cf. also Kayne 1994). A more direct influence is Hinterh61zl's 1 997a analysis of Verb Raising in German as remnant VP movement, as sketched in (8): first, arguments move out of VP into higher positions, then the functional projection (FP in (8)) containing the verb moves to a specifier to the left of the higher verb (the specifier of PredP in (8), cf. Hinterh6lzl 1 997a). (8)
a. b.
er sie1 nicht [PredP wagte [FP zu kiissen t1]]
he her not
dared
to kiss
er sie1 nicht [PredP [FP ZU kiissen trJ wagte tFPJ
to kiss dared he her not ' . . . (because) he didn't dare to kiss her'
12
PETER SVENONIUS
c. d.
er sie 1 [PredP wagte [pp nicht zu kUssen td]
he her
dared
not to kiss
er sie 1 [PredP [pp nicht zu kUssen td wagte tpp]
he her not to kiss dared , . . . (because) he dared to not kiss her'
On a VP-fronting analysis of VO languages, the remnant moving to the left is larger (it contains the auxiliaries) and moves further (it moves to the left of the licensing position for the object). Thus, Kayne 1 998 argues that in English, there are in fact overt movements in some cases of VP-internal material to the left of the VP, followed by VP-remnant fronting past that material again, resulting in what superficially looks like the original word order. This brings VO languages much closer to Hinterh61zl's vision for the OV ones. For instance, to account for wide scope of negation in a sentence like I will force you to marry noone, Kayne postulates the derivation in (9), where 'W' and 'Neg' are heads in the extended projection of every verb, but shown only for the superordinate clause. For the narrow scope reading, the derivation in (10) is used, and here the functional heads are only shown for the embedded clause. (9)
a. b. c.
(10)
a. b. c.
I will [wp W [NegP Neg [yp force you to marry noone]]] I will [wp W [NegP noone 1 Neg [yp force you to marry td]] I will [wp [yp force you to marry td W [NegP noone 1 Neg typ]]]
I will force you to [wp W [NegP Neg [yp marry noone]]] I will force you to [wp W [NegP noone 1 Neg [yp marry td]] I will force you to [wp [yp marry td W [NegP noone 1 Neg typ]]]
Note that the surface position of noone in each case matches the scope of negation. Kayne notes that Icelandic and archaic Norwegian manifest the order in the (b) examples; this is discussed more fully in my article in this volume. By taking the English VO order to be derived in this way, Kayne proposes to eliminate covert movement from the system of grammar. Note that the claim that objects in VO languages like English leave their base positions overtly has been around for a while; for example, Johnson 1 99 1 , B orer 1 994, and Runner 1995 all take this position. In each of those proposals, however, the verb moves to the left by head movement, as on Haider's account, rather than by VP-remnant movement, as in (9)-(1 0). In this volume, Taraldsen and Hr6arsd6ttir argue for a much expanded role for VP movement in VO languages. Taraldsen reasons that if VO order is derived by VP movement, then in some cases, it should be possible to observe material other than the verb being pied-piped along with the VP. Drawing on
INTRODUCTION
13
evidence from a range of Germanic languages, he argues that prepositional particles provide exactly this kind of evidence for VP movement. For example, Taraldsen proposes that the particle-noun phrase order illustrated in ( l l a) is derived in stages, one stage being similar to theav structure in ( l lb). (11)
a. b.
at han slapp inn katten.
that he let in the. cat . .. dat hij de kat binnenliet. that he the cat in.let , . . .that he let in the cat'
(Norwegian) (Dutch)
Taraldsen argues that the particle originates to the left of the verb, with the object first moving across both verb and particle, leading to the Dutch order. In valanguages, a series of VP movements results in the Norwegian order. Thus, all languages are alike in requiring various VP-internal elements to move overtly to licensing positions, and va languages in addition have the property that there is successive leftward movement of verbal projections to specifier positions. Taraldsen suggests that object shift, too, may profitably be seen as a result of leftward VP movement. Hr6arsd6ttir, drawing on her previous work (see references in her paper), examines historical data from Icelandic, demonstrating that various types ofav structures disappeared simultaneously from Icelandic. In particular, before the nineteenth century, objects frequently appeared to the left of non-finite verbs (finite verbs appeared in second position, as in modern Icelandic). With non finite auxiliaries preceding the main verb, various options are observed: the object might precede both verbs, follow both verbs, or appear between the two verbs. In addition, the auxiliary could precede or follow the main verb. The following word orders are then attested. ( 1 2)
a. Aux Va b. Auxa v c. aAux V d. V Auxa e. a v Aux
(The final logical possibility, VaAux, is unattested; cf. the discussion of V-Aux adjacency above.) Hr6arsd6ttir shows that av orders (including VAux orders) disappeared simultaneously from Icelandic in the nineteenth century, with the result that only the order in ( 12a) is grammatical (with the exception of the examples with quantified objects discussed in my contribution to this volume). Pintzuk 1 997 has also documented the same observation for the history of
14
PETER SVENONIUS
English, showing that various classes of elements ceased to appear to the left of their selecting verbs at the same time. This is puzzling on an approach to OV structures like that in (5) above, because if distinct features move the object to the different positions above and below the auxiliary and cause the reversal, then there is no reason to expect them all to have become weak simultaneously. Hr6arsd6ttir demonstrates how an analysis of VO order based on VP movement yields the right results: if what happened in the history of Icelandic is that VP movement of the type illustrated in the derivations in (9)-(10) went from being optional to being obligatory, then only one change need be postulated, instead of a series of independent but simultaneous ones. Deriving VO order through phrasal movement rather than head movement is one of the main themes running through this volume. Holmberg's and Pearson's papers (discussed below) also take up this issue, as does Brody's, in a way, and HinterhOlzl's, briefly. Aside from this difference, the main distinction between the type of account presented by Taraldsen and Hr6arsd6ttir and Haider's is whether the licensing positions are derived positions or not. Haider argues in this volume that they are not, noting in particular that there are no island effects as might be expected from moved elements; in his paper, Hinter hOlzl argues that they are. HinterhOlzl examines several pieces of evidence from West Germanic languages, including the position of the infinitival marker, word order in complex verbal clusters, and facts about postverbal CPs and PPs. He concludes that there is substantial evidence for an account in which licensing positions are reached through overt movement in OV languages. He provides an analysis of so-called extraposition, such as that exhibited in ( 1 3). ( 1 3)
Hans hat Peters Buch gelesen fiber Chomsky.
Hans has Peters book read about Chomsky 'Hans has read Peter's book about Chomsky'
(German)
Hinterh6lz1 notes that a rightward movement analysis is incompatible with Antisymmetric principles. What is more, the construction does not bear the usual characteristics of extraction structures: note that the noun phrase is specified, a situation which ordinarily prevents extraction (Ross 1 967b). Hinterh6lz1 presents an analysis in terms of copying with partial deletion which is fully consistent with the Kaynean treatment of OV languages.
15
INTRODUCTION
5.
Mirrors
Several asymmetries were pointed out in the previous section. A particular type of asymmetry not discussed yet is mirror effects, or what is sometimes called 'centripetal' organization (cf. Dik 1 989: 342). For example, Greenberg's Universal 20 states that if any or all of the demonstrative, numeral, and descriptive adjective precede N, then they do so in that order; whereas if they follow N, they appear in the same or the opposite order. As Hawkins 1 983 observes, the mirror-image order is by far the most common, for elements following N. 6 The example in ( 14b) is from Koromfe (Niger-Congo, Burkina Faso; after Rennison 1997: 85-86). (14)
a. b.
those three black cats
lug<mi bfniA tiiii
cats
(Koromfe)
hElJ
black three those
Hetzron 1 978 notes that adjective orders also show a mirror effect; in AN languages like English (those in which the attribute adjective precedes the noun it modifies), adjectives expressing evaluation precede those expressing size, which in turn precede color adjectives, while in NA languages the order is exactly the reverse. (15)
a. b.
a beautiful big red ball
(Indonesian)
bola merah besar jang tjantik
ball red
big
REL beautiful
Koster 1 974 noted a mirror effect for prepositional phrases in Dutch. PPs following the verb have the opposite relative order compared with their sequence preceding the verb (these examples are taken from Barbiers 1 995: 103). ( 1 6)
a.
Hij is door
'n stuuifout
met een knal op het hek
he is through a steering. error with a
gestrand. b.
stranded
Hij is gestrand op het hek
met een knal door
he is stranded on the fence with a
stuuifout.
bang on the fence (Dutch)
een
bang through a
steering.error 'He got stranded on the fence with a bang because of a steering error'
The order in ( 1 6b) is basically the same as in English, while the preverbal order in ( 16a) is the reverse.
16
PETER SVENONIUS
Mirror-image structures are familiar from morphology; Baker's 1985 Mirror Principle observed that the relative closeness of morphemes to a stem reflects the order in which the corresponding syntactic transformations take place; for example, if a benefactive argument is realized as a direct object when an applicative morpheme is attached to the verb, and if passive promotes a direct object to subject position, then in order for a benefactive argument to appear as a subject under passive, the applicative morpheme must be closer to the stem than the passive morpheme. This can be seen in the Chichewa example in (17) (from Baker 1988: 307; SP is subject agreement, ASP is aspect). (17)
Mbewa zi-na-sem-er-edw-a
mitondo.
mice SP-PAST-carve-APPL-PASS-ASP mortars 'The mice were carved mortars' (i.e. somebody carved mortars for the mice)
(Chichewa)
Baker derives the order of morphemes through strictly local head movement (following Travis 1984). In the case of the applicative passive, the applicative suffix is argued to originate as a preposition in a PP complement to the verb, and the passive morpheme is taken to occupy a higher head. The derivation of the applicative passive in (17) proceeds as sketched in ( 1 8), ignoring the prefixes and the aspect suffix. ( 1 8)
a. b. c. d.
PASS [vp carve [pp APPL mice] mortars] PASS [vp carve-APPL 1 [pp tl mice] mortars] [carve-APPLlh-PASS [vp t2 [pp tl mice] mortars] mice3 [carve-APPLlh-PASS [v p t2 [pp tl t3] mortars] In (1 8a), the verb takes two complements, a PP and an NP. In (1 8b), the preposition has incorporated into the verb, appearing as a suffix (cf. Baker op. cit. p. 23 1). In (1 8c), the verb has moved to a higher head, attaching to the left of the passive suffix (op. cit. p. 309). (1 8d) simply shows the NP movement of the derived subject. In subsequent work, however, it has often been assumed that head-movement necessarily leads to adjunction to the left, with the result that suffixes on a stem must reflect successively higher functional heads above that stem (cf. Kayne 1994); predictions about prefixes are less clear; see Julien 2000 for some discussion. Furthermore, it has been common to take these mirroring effects to cover non-grammatical function changing affixes as well; thus, Belletti 1990 could argue that AgrP dominates TenseP, contra Pollock 1989, on the grounds that agreement morphemes occur further from the stem than tense morphemes, cross-linguistical ly. The order of functional elements appears to support this view. For example,
INTRODUCTION
17
the order of suffixes in the Northern Sfuni verb form in (19a), where the potential mood suffix is closer to the stem than the subject agreement suffix, is taken to mirror the order of those heads in the syntactic tree. This view is strongly supported by structures like that in (19b), where the negative and perfective auxiliary verbs take the same suffixes, but where the first auxiliary takes the agreement suffix and the second the mood suffix (cf. Mitchell 1 99 1 ; Holmberg et al. 1993 on Finnish). (19)
a. b.
Veahkeh-earra-n.
help-POT-1 SG 'I could help' J-n
NEG-lsG
(Northern Sami)
l-earra veahkeh-an.
be-pOT help-PERFECT 'I couldn't have helped'
Cinque 1999 develops a strong argument for this extended mirror principle, identifying a number of categories of adverbial meaning and connecting different morphemes with those categories. He demonstrates that cross-linguistically, the ordering of the adverbs mirrors the ordering of the morphemes. The adverbs are taken to occupy specifier positions in phrases projected by functional heads, and the morphemes are taken to be associated with those selfsame heads; morphology then mirrors the syntactic tree in a striking way. Brody 1997 takes these observations as fundamental and proposes the Mirror Theory, by which morphological structure and complement structure are isomorphic: a syntactic complement is realized with its selecting head as a suffix; this yields a result similar to that of a theory in which the head of a complement always raises to its selecting head (cf. Svenonius 1 994), but only if head to head movement happens at the surface: Brody points out, in his contribu tion to this volume, that in his theory there is no room for covert incorporation. He examines the case of Romance restructuring, and demonstrates the advantages of his analysis over one involving covert head movement. He also examines the case of Hungarian verbal clusters, which exhibit an interesting property: certain sequences of Hungarian verbs can appear in either order, e.g. 'begin-swim' or 'swim-begin' , with the same meaning ('begin to swim'). He argues that this reflects an option, either the dependent (main) verb is identified as the specifier or the complement of the superordinate (auxiliary) verb. If the dependent verb is a complement, then by Mirror Theory, the superordinate verb must immediately follow it, as a suffix; if the dependent verb is a specifier, then it is a distinct phrase, and whether it precedes or follows the superordinate verb depends on where that verb is realized (in situ, following the
18
PETER SVENONIUS
subordinate verb, or in a higher functional posltIon preceding it). This is strikingly like the cross-linguistic observation noted above that while Aux-V order does not necessarily require adjacency, V-Aux order does. If V-Aux order is generally derived by head movement or a closely related mechanism, as in Brody's theory, then this cross-linguistic fact may be captured. However, there are other ways in which mirror images may be derived, and head-movement is often reserved for cases in which the elements so combined are clearly wordlike. Kayne (1994: 52ff.; cf, also Julian 2000, Ch. 5) has suggested a derivation for mirror-image ordering based on a phrasal analogue of head movement: if an element Z moves from the right to the left of an element Y, then the order of Z and Y is reversed. If a node dominating both Y and Z then moves leftward across a node X, the order Z-Y-X results, the opposite of the original order. This is illustrated in (20) for the (gloss of the) Indonesian noun phrase in (I5b) above. Brody (1997) refers to structures produced by movement of a node dominating the target of previous movement as 'roll-up' structures. (20)
a. b. c. d.
[xp beautiful [yp big [zp red [NP ball]]]] [xp beautiful [yp big [AP [NP ball] red tNP]]] [xp beautiful [yp [zp [NP ball] red tNPJ big tzp]] [xp [yp [zp [NP ball] red tNP] big tzp] beautiful typ]
If beautiful is the head of XP, big the head of YP, and red the head of ZP, then no functional projections need be assumed. This is consistent with the view of Abney 1987 that adjectives are heads in the extended projection of N. However, if the elements in the reverse order are phrasal, some more complicated structure is necessary. This is how Barbiers 1995 analyzes postverbal PPs in Dutch. According to Barbiers, the various PPs are adjoined to VP, as shown in (21 a) (compare (16», where the different segments of VP are marked with different lower-case letters. The lowest segment of VP moves into the specifier position of the lowest PP, in order to enter into a subject-predicate relation with it, as shown in (21b) (this is the 'intraposition' alluded to above). The next two segments (marked 'b' and 'c' ) move into the next two PP specifiers in (21c-d), resulting in reverse order (cf. Barbiers 1995: 1 15).
(21)
a. b.
[VPd [pp by mistake] [VPc [pp with a bang] [VPb [pp on the fence] [VPa stuck]]]] [VPd [pp by mistake] [VPc [pp with a bang] [VPb [pp [VPa stuck] on the fence] tv pa]]]
INTRODUCTION
c. d.
19
[YPd [pp by mistake] [YPe [pp [YPb [pp [YPa stuck] on the fence] typaJ with a bang] typb]] [YPd [pp [VPe [pp [YPb [pp [YPa stuck] on the fence] tYPaJ with a bang] tYPbJ by mistake] type]
These movements, according to Barbiers, are necessary in order to establish the Spec-Head relation necessary for a PP to predicate over the relevant VP, and must occur covertly in languages in which they do not occur overtly. Holmberg proposes a kind of roll-up structure for Finnish verbal clusters in his contribution to this volume. He notes that in Finnish, V-Aux order requires strict adjacency. He proposes that V-Aux order is derived by movement of VP into the specifier of a functional head which selects the auxiliary. This leads to derivations like that in (22). (22)
a. b. c. d. e.
hp Tense [AuxP have [AspP Aspect [yp write novel]]]] [TP Tense [AuxP have [AspP Aspect [yp novell write t I ]]]] [TP Tense [AuxP have [AspP [yp novel 1 write ttl Aspect typ]]] [TP Tense [AuxP [AspP [yp novel 1 write ttl Aspect typJ have tAspP]] [TP [AuxP [AspP [yp novel 1 write ttl Aspect typ] have tAspP] Tense tAuxP]
In (22a), the base order of heads is shown. In (22b), the object has moved to the left of the verb (here, to SpecVP). In (22c), the VP has moved into the specifier of AspectP, in order for the verb to check its aspectual features against the functional head of that phrase. The same occurs in the next two steps. It can be seen that as long as adjunctions to X' are not allowed, and adjunctions to the right of XP are not allowed, no material will intervene between the verb and its auxiliary in the resulting head-final structure. In the final string, novel write Aspect have Tense, the functional elements Aspect and Tense are suffixal, and are pronounced as a word with the immediately preceding stems, hence some thing like novel writ-ten ha-s in pseudo-English, 'has written a novel' . This affixation is subject to adjacency, according to Holmberg, so that for example the object could not have remained in situ in the first step, leading to an AspP of the form *write novel -Aspect. Pearson, in his paper in this volume, applies the roll-up technology to several additional kinds of mirror-image effects. He notes that although same order patterns of the type discussed above are common, they are not universal. There are languages, such as Malagasy, Palauan, and Zapotec, in which the unmarked order for indirect object and direct object is the reverse of that in
20
PETER SVENONIUS
English. Similarly, some of these languages have the reverse relative order for certain series of adverbs, and show scrambling effects to the right, rather than to the left. But Pearson notes that the mirror effects do not warrant a fully symmetric analysis; each of these languages also shows some same-order effects, for example they are consistently VO, and never OV. Pearson develops an analysis that is consistent with Kayne's LeA, and proposes a novel kind of rationale for why roll-up structures occur; in short, they occur in languages in which verb movement is systematically unavailable. In this way, the proposal bears a relation to Holmberg's, in which V movement and VP movement are alternatives for checking V features; but unlike Holmberg's proposal, in which the two possibili ties are manifested within a single language, Pearson casts the option as a point of cross-linguistic variation.
6.
Conclusion
The analyses in the different contributions to this volume are not completely compatible with each other, though there are several harmonious strands running through most of them. Papers like those of Hinterh61zl, Haegeman, Hr6arsd6ttir, and Taraldsen largely share the same theoretical assumptions and come to highly compatible conclusions. Others of the papers are parts of broader programs initiated by the author or authors; those of Fukui & Takano and Brody stand out in particular in this respect, distinguishing themselves more sharply in their basic theoretical assumptions. Another example is the paper by Haider, which defies what is to some extent the majority view here, deriving from Kayne and earlier work by Hinterh61zl, which envisions leftward movement on a large scale to derive OV order. Hinterh61zl's paper is in part a response to some of the challenges posed by Haider. Another interesting tension is that between the two papers focusing on Icelandic: Hr6arsd6ttir's paper holds that there is general VP movement in modern Icelandic, of the sort proposed by Kayne 1998; but part of Kayne's argument is based on the OV patterns discussed in my paper, which are an intermediate stage in the derivation of a VO language like English, for Kayne. In order for my and Hr6arsd6ttir's analyses to be reconciled, either the landing site of quantified noun phrases in Icelandic must be higher than their landing site in English (i.e. higher than the landing site of the VP), or else the landing site of VP must be lower. Yet another point of tension, noted above, is that between Pearson, who would have head movement versus phrasal movement be a major parameter
INTRODUCTION
21
distinguishing language types, and Holmberg, who makes use of a very similar distinction within Finnish, arguing that both head and phrase movement are options. For these two to be reconciled, either something would have to be said about what makes Finnish unusual in this respect, or else, if Finnish turns out not to be unusual, about what is special about this parameter that allows both settings to be manifested as options in a single language. A third perspective on this issue is held by B arbiers, who uses a combination of head and phrasal movements to derive surface word order in Dutch. The harmonies among the various papers represent a certain kind of forward momentum, while the tensions hint at different possible directions for that movement.
Notes 1.
Thanks to Anders Holmberg, Hubert Haider, and Matthew Pearson for feedback on this introduction.
2.
On the other hand, it seems that some languages have both prepositions and postpositions; e.g. English has the postposition ago, and Finnish has a variety of postpositions and prepositions cf. Holmberg this volume.
3.
Preliminary investigations provide some cross-linguistic support. For example, possessive suffixes in Finnish bear some resemblance to subject agreement suffixes, suggesting that genitives are subjectlike; and Finnish is SVO and GN; possessive pronouns in Moroccan Arabic are identical to object pronouns, meaning that genitives are objectlike, and Moroccan Arabic is SVO and NG. Dryer 1 999 discusses the different motivations for GN versus NG in SVO languages.
4.
Of course, this explanation presupposes that absolutive case is different from nominative.
5.
The generalization, as stated here, holds for very many languages, though perhaps not always for the same reasons. For example, it holds of languages with second-position auxiliaries such as various Slavic, Australian, and Uto-Aztecan languages, but there the obligatory adjacency of V-Aux order may be of a different nature from the obligatory adjacency of V-Aux in for example Japanese or Persian. (i) Aux-V order may be interrupted (ii) V-Aux order may not be interrupted The generalization can be read on two levels: as a claim about unmarked orders and as a claim about any order. As a claim about unmarked orders, counterexamples to (i) are Spanish and Rumanian, and Dutch in embedded clauses. Counterexamples to (ii) include two Bongo-Bagirmi languages, Ngambay and Mbaye. These two languages were the only ones listed in Dryer 1 998 as having base order SVOAux (with verbal auxiliary), while very many languages turned up with base order SAuxOV. As a claim about derived orders, various VP-topicalization structures violate (ii), e.g. in Scandinavian languages.
6.
There are many mixed cases, in particular numbers very frequently precede the noun (cf. Greenberg 1978: 29). In mixed cases, the relative orders of the individual elements remain true
22
PETER SVENONIUS
to the generalization; thus we frequently find for example Num-N-A-Dem (Basque, Indonesian, Vietnamese, Jacaltec, Welsh, and many others) but not Num-N-Dem-A. Greenberg mentions Kikuyu as having N-Dem-Num-A, i.e. the N-final order but with N initial; Hawkins 1983 points out that all such non-mirror image examples seem to come from the Bantu family (though Old Norse allows N-Dem-A, Nygaard 1906, it is not the usual order). See Rijkhoff 1992: 223ff. for discussion.
References Abney, Steven. 1 987. The English Noun Phrase in its Sentential Aspect. Ph.D. disserta tion,
MIT.
Anderson, Stephen. 1976. "On the notion of subject in ergative languages."
In Charles N.
Li (ed.), Subject and Topic. New York: Academic Press. 1-24. B ach, Emmon. 1962. "The order of elements in a transformational grammar of German."
Language 38: 263-269. B ach, Emmon. 1968. "Nouns and noun phrases."
In Emmon Bach and Robert T. Harms
(eds), Universals in Linguistic Theory. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
9 1-124. B ach, Emmon. 197 1 . "Questions." Linguistic Inquiry 2: 153-166. B aker, Mark. 1985. "The Mirror Principle and morphosyntactic explanation." Linguistic
Inquiry 16: 373-416. B aker, Mark C. 1988. Incorporation. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. B arbiers, Sjef. 1995. The Syntax of Interpretation. The Hague: Holland Academic Graphics [HIL dissertations 14] . Belletti, Adriana. 1990. Generalized Verb Movement: Aspects of verb syntax. Turin: Rosenberg and Sellier. Borer, Hagit. 1994. "On the projection of arguments."
In Elena B enedicto and Jeff
Runner (eds), Functional Projections. Amherst: GLSA, University of Massachusetts.
19-47. Brody, MichaeL 1 997. "Mirror theory." London: University College London [DCL Working Papers in Linguistics 9]. Chomsky, Noam. 1970. "Remarks on nominalization."
In Roderick Jacobs and Peter
Rosenbaum (eds), Readings in English Transformational Grammar. Waltham: Ginn and Co. 1 84-221 . Chomsky, Noam. 1980. Rules and Representations. New York: Columbia University Press. Chomsky, Noam. 1 98 1 . Lectures on Government and Binding. Dordrecht: Foris. Chomsky, Noam. 1994. "Bare phrase structure." MIT Occasional Papers in Linguistics 5. Cinque, Guglielmo. 1994. "On the evidence for partial N-movement i n the Romance DP."
In Guglielmo Cinque, Jan Koster, Jean-Yves Pollock, Luigi Rizzi, and Raffaella Zanuttini (eds), Paths Towards Universal Grammar: Studies in honor of Richard S.
Kayne. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press. 85-1 10.
23
INTRODUCTION
Cinque, Guglielmo. 1 999. Adverbs and Functional Heads: A cross-linguistic perspective. Oxford: OUP. Diesing, Molly. 1992. Indefinites. Cambridge,
MA: MIT Press.
Dik, Simon C. 1 989. The Theory of Functional Grammar: Part I: The structure of the
clause. Dordrecht: Foris. Dixon, R.M.W. 1994. Ergativity. Cambridge: CUP. Dryer, Matthew S . 1980. "The positional tendencies of sentential noun phrases in universal grammar." Canadian Journal of Linguistics 25: 123-195. Dryer, Matthew S . 199 1 . "SVO languages and the OV: VO typology." Journal of
Linguistics 27: 443-482. Dryer, Matthew S . 1992. "The Greenbergian word order correlations." Language 68:
8 1-138.
Dryer, Matthew S . 1998. Typological Database. SUNY, Buffalo NY. Dryer, Matthew S . 1 999. Explaining the Order of Genitive and Noun
in SVO Languages.
Ms. SUNY Buffalo. Emonds, Joseph. 1976. A transformational approach to English syntax: Root, structure
preserving, and local transformations. New York: Academic Press. Frazier, Lyn. 1979. "On comprehending sentences: Syntactic parsing strategies." Bloom ington: Indiana University Linguistics Club. Fukui, Naoki, and Takano, Yuji. 1998. "Symmetry in syntax: Merge and demerge."
Journal of East Asian Linguistics 7: 27-86. Fukui, Naoki. 1 993. "Parameters and optionality." Linguistic Inquiry 24.3 : 399-420. Gazdar, Gerald, Pullum, Geoffrey, and Sag, Ivan. 1982. "Auxiliaries and related phenom ena in a restrictive theory of grammar." Language 58: 59 1-638. Givan, Talmy. 1984. Syntax: A functional-typological introduction, Volume 1 . Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Greenberg, Joseph H. 1963. "Some universals of grammar with particular reference to the order of meaningful elements." In Joseph H. Greenberg (ed.), Universals of Lan guage. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 73-1 1 3 . Greenberg, Joseph H. 1978. "Numerals." I n Joseph H. Greenberg (ed.), Universals of Human Language, vol. 3 . Stanford: Stanford University Press. 249-295. Haider, Hubert. 1992. "Branching & discharge." Arbeitspapiere des SFB 340 23, 1-23. Universities of Stuttgart and Tlibingen; revised version to appear in Lexical Specifi cation and Insertion, Peter Coopmans and Jane Grimshaw (eds.), 135-164. The Hague: Holland Academic Graphics. Halliday, M.A.K. 1967. "Notes on transitivity and theme in English, part II." Journal of
Linguistics 3 : 199-244. Hawkins, John A. 1 983. Word Order Universals. New York: Academic Press. Hawkins, John A. 1 988 (ed.). Explaining Language Universals. Oxford: Basil Blackwell. Hawkins, John A. 1994. A Performance Theory of Order and Constituency. Cambridge: CUP.
24
PETER SVENONIUS
Hetzron, Robert. 1978. "On the relative order of adjectives." In Hansjakob Seiler (ed.), Language Universals. Tiibingen: Gunter Narr. 165-1 84. Hinterh61zl, Roland. 1997a. "A VO-based approach to verb raising." In Kiyomi Kusumoto (ed.), Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society 27. Amherst: GLSA. 1 87-202. Hinterh61zl, Roland. 1 997b. An XP-movement account of restructuring. Ms. University of Southern California. Holmberg, Anders. 1986. Word Order and Syntactic Features in the Scandinavian Languages and English. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Stockholm. Holmberg, Anders, Urpo Nikanne, Irmeli Oraviita, Hannu Reime, and Trond Trosterud. 1993 . "The structure of !NFL and the finite clause in Finnish." In Anders Holmberg and Urpo Nikanne (eds), Case and Other Functional Categories in Finnish Syntax. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. 177-206. Huang, C.-T. James. 1982. Logical Relations in Chinese and the Theory of Grammar. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT. Jackendoff, Ray. 1977. X-bar Syntax: A study of phrase structure. Cambridge, MA.: MIT Press. Johnson, Kyle. 199 1 . "Object positions." Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 9: 577-636. Julien, Marit. 2000. Syntactic Heads and Word Formation: A study of verbal inflection. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Tromssz>. Kayne, Richard S. 1 983. "Connectedness." Linguistic Inquiry 14: 223-249. Reprinted in 1984 in Connectedness and Binary Branching, Dordrecht: Foris. Kayne, Richard S. 1994. The Antisymmetry of Syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Kayne, Richard S . 1 998. "Overt vs. covert movement." Syntax 1: 128-19 1 . Koopman, Hilda. 1984. Th e Syntax of Verbs: From verb movement rules in the Kru languages to universal grammar. Dordrecht: Foris. Koptjevskaja-Tamm, Maria. 1993. Nominalizations. London: Routledge. Koster, Jan. 1974. "Het werkwoord als spiegelcentrum." Spektator 3 : 601-6 1 8 . Koster, Jan. 1 994. "Predication incorporation an d the word order o f Dutch." In Guglielmo Cinque, Jan Koster, Jean-Yves Pollock, Luigi Rizzi, and Raffaella Zanuttini (eds) , Paths Toward Universal Grammar: Studies in honor of Richard S. Kayne. Washing ton, D.C.: Georgetown University Press. 255-276. Larson, Richard. 1988. "On the double object construction." Linguistic Inquiry 19: 335-39 1 . Lees, Robert B . 1959. The Grammar o f English Nominalizations. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT Published 1963 in revised form by Indiana University Press, Bloomington, with Mouton, The Hague. Lehmann, W. P. 1 973. "A structural principle of language and its implications." Lan guage 49: 47-66. Li, Charles N., and Thompson, Sandra A. 1976. "Subject and topic: A new typology of language." In Charles N. Li (ed.), Subject and Topic. New York: Academic Press. 457-490. .
INTRODUCTION
25
Li, Yen-Hui Audrey. 1 990. Order and Constituency in Mandarin Chinese. Dordrecht: Reidel. Mitchell, Erika. 199 1 . "Evidence from Finnish for Pollock's theory of IP." Linguistic Inquiry 22: 373-379. Nash, Lea. 1996. "The internal ergative subject hypothesis." Proceedings ofNELS 26. Nash, Lea. 1998. On the absence of SVO ergative languages: The case of Georgian. Ms. University of Paris 8. Nygaard, Marius. 1 906. Norr¢n Syntax. Oslo: H. Aschehoug & Co. Peters, P. Stanley Jr. and Ritchie, RW. 1969. "Context-sensitive immediate constituent analysis: Context-free languages revisited." ACM Symposium on Computing, 1-8, ACM. Reprinted 1 973 in Mathematical Systems Theory 6: 324-333. Pintzuk, Susan. 1997. From OV to VO in the history of English. Ms. University of York. Pollock, Jean-Yves. 1989. "Verb-movement, universal grammar, and the structure of IP." Linguistic Inquiry 20: 365-424. Pullum, Geoffrey and Wilson, Deirdre. 1 977. "Autonomous syntax and the analysis of auxiliaries." Language 53.4: 741-788. Rennison, John R 1 997. Koromfe. London: Routledge. Rijkhoff, Jan. 1992. The Noun Phrase: A typological study of its form and structure. Ph.D. dissertation, Universiteit van Amsterdam. Ross, John Robert. 1967a. "Gapping and the order of constituents" Paper presented at the 10th International Congress of Linguistics. Published 1970 in Progress in Linguis tics, ed. by Manfred Bierwisch and Karl Erich Heidolph. The Hague: Mouton. 249-259. Ross, John Robert. 1967b. Constraints on Variables in Syntax. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT. Published 1986 as Infinite Syntax! Norwood: Ablex. Runner, Jeffrey. 1995. Noun Phrase Licensing and Interpretation. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst. Steele, Susan. 1978. "Word order variation: A typological study." In Joseph H. Greenberg (ed.), Universals ofHuman Language, vol. 4: Syntax. Stanford: Stanford University Press. 585-624. Stowell, Tim 198 1 . Origins of Phrase Structure. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT. Svenonius, Peter. 1994. "C-selection as feature-checking." Studia Linguistica 48: 133-155. Svenonius, Peter. 1 998. "Conference report: Workshop on VO and Ov." Glot International 3.9/10: 25-28. Svenonius, Peter. In press. "Subject positions and the placement of adverbials." To appear in Peter Svenonius (ed.), Subjects, Expletives, and the EPP. Oxford: OUP. Takano, Yuji. 1996. Movement and Parametric Variation in Syntax. Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Irvine. Trask, R L. 1979. "On the origins of ergativity." In Franz Plank (ed.), Ergativity: Towards a theory of grammatical relations. New York: Academic Press. 3 85-404. Travis, Lisa. 1984. Parameters and Effects of Word Order Variation. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
26
PETER SVENONIUS
Uriagereka, Juan. 1999. "Multiple spell-out." In Samuel David Epstein and Norbert Hornstein (eds.), Working Minimalism. Cambridge MA: MIT Press. 251-282. Vallduvf, Enric. 1990. The Informational Component. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Pennsylvania. Vennemann, Theo. 1974. "Topics, subjects, and word order: From S:XV to SVX via TVX." In J.M. Anderson and C. Jones (eds), Historical linguistics 1 . Amsterdam: North Holland. 339-376. Zanuttini, Raffaella. 1 997. Negation and Clausal Structure: A comparative study of Romance languages. Oxford: OUP. Zwart, Jan Wouter. 1993 . Dutch Syntax: A minimalist approach. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Groningen. Groningen: Grodil. Zwart, Jan Wouter. 1997. Morphosyntax of Verb Movement. A minimalist approach to the syntax of Dutch. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Restructuring
Mirror
Michael Brody University College London and Linguistic Institute, HAS
Abstract Sections 1 and 2 briefly outline some central features of mirror theory (Brody 1997) and discuss consequences with respect to 'basic' word order. In Sections 3 and 4 I note that mirror theory is incompatible with covert roll-up head chain type relations and argue that contrary to recent claims the analysis of Romance restructuring need not involve such structures. In Section 5 I note that Kayne's correlation between null subjects and clitic climbing may be better captured under the proposed analysis than it has been in earlier approaches. I argue that both phenomena involve licensing of a Spec by an element of Infl. In Sec tion 6 I discuss some aspects of the behavior of Hungarian restructuring infinitives and their treatment in mirror theory. Section 7 looks at some similarities and differences between the 'climbing' options of Hungarian verbal modifiers and Romance clitics. Finally in Section 8 I argue that to understand Hungarian restructuring constructions it is necessary to distinguish (strictly local) head chain and (successive step) phrasal chain type relations, - a fact that constitutes further evidence for some core assumptions of mirror theory.
1.
Mirror theory, a brief sketch
In mirror theory (Brody 1997), the morphological structure of words is expressed syntactically as complementation structure. The mirror principle of this theory ensures that if x is the complement of y then x is taken to be the morphological specifier of y. For a large set of morphemes (generally suffixes) it is also typically (though probably not always) true that if x is the morphological specifier of y, then x is the complement of y syntactically. As a simplified example, V is (part of the) the morphological Spec of Infl and V is also typically (part of the) the syntactic complement of Infl.
28
MICHAEL BRODY
In mirror theory, complementation structure is taken to be the default expression of the morphological structure - the mirror hypothesis. According to this hypothesis the syntactic head-complement relation expresses the morpho logical specifier-head relation in inverse topological order: complements follow while specifiers (whether syntactic or morphological) precede the head. Thus no separate :xo-internal representation needs to be assumed that matches and duplicates the complement series. Consider for example the simplified structure in (1) of, say, Mary loves John. Here (Mary) is the trace of the subject in Specv, so Mary and (Mary) form a chain; the object John is taken for the sake of presentation, probably counterfactually, not to form a chain with a position higher than Specv; and Infl, v and V represent, again in a simplified fashion, the morphemes (some null) from which the word loves is composed.
(1)
�
�
Mary
v @ (loves)
�
(Mary)
V
/
John
The complement series in (1), Infl+ v+ V serves as the syntactic representation of the morphological word (MW) V+ v+ Infl. Morphology spells out the syntactic representation of an MW (a) in one of the head positions, here in that of v (as indicated by "@"), from which the MW is composed and (b) in inverse order, due to (the appropriate version of) the mirror hypothesis, an axiom of the system. All this gives the correct morpheme order both word-internally (love+ s) and also word-externally if the Spec (and whatever it dominates) precedes the head, and the complement (and whatever it dominates) follows it. The order of head and complement follows from the order of Spec-Head, given the assumption that specifiers uniformly precede the head both in syntax and in morphology and that syntactic complement relations are inverse order morphological Spec-Head relations - the mirror hypothesis again. Thus in (1) Mary precedes Infl, Infl precedes v where loves is spelt out and v precedes V and whatever V dominates, i.e. in particular John. Under mirror theory the syntactic complementation relation entails morpho logical specifierhood: if x is the complement of y then x is the morphological specifier of y. Thus first of all the arguments of the verb that are morphological ly independent of it, - (non-incorporated, non-clitic) subject or object, or clausal
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
29
complement etc. - must be specifiers. Secondly if the subparts of what in standard systems are extended projections do not form an MW then these parts must also be in the specifier-head rather than in the complement-head relation. For example in "John has come" come cannot be (part of) the complement of has. The auxiliary is an element that is part of the extended word but not of the morphological word of the main verb. It must therefore be a specifier as in (2).
Infl @ (has)
(2)
�
John
Infl
/
come
To ensure the correct word order, it must be assumed that come is the specifier of a head that is lower than the head in which has is spelt out in morphology. The representations in (1) and (2) are simplified in several ways for presentational purposes, but there is a particular simplification that is not presentational, but is meant as a substantive restrictive hypothesis. This has to do with the elimination of phrasal nodes. The structure in (3) for example that (1) replaces is obviously redundant.
(3)
InflP
�
Su
Infl'
�
Infl
vP
�v'
(Su)
�
v
VP
�
Obj
V'
/
V
Call the claim that the set of phrasal and XO-intemal projections of a head can be systematically collapsed the telescope hypothesis. XO-intemal projections are unnecessary given the treatment of MWs as (inverse order) complement lines. As for phrasal projections, the telescope hypothesis embodies the expectation that
30
MICHAEL BRODY
given the accumulating evidence for multiple additional heads of various types in the structure, phrasal projections will invariably be unnecessary. For example the major evidence for the V' level, based on the hierarchical subject-object asymmetry, disappears when the subject is taken to be Specv. This ensures without the intermediate bar level that the subject is higher than the object. Any category can be interpreted as either a phrase or a head in mirror theory - a head by itself and a phrase together with all categories it dominates. (Notice also a terminological point: since categorial projection is eliminated, extended projections are better referred to as extended words.)
2.
Mirror theory and word order
As we have seen, under mirror theory all non-clitic arguments must be specifiers. Does mirror theory therefore entail a strict "underlying" (i.e. chain-root) head final "sov" order? While such a statement would be partly true, it would also be in part incorrect and in part misleading. There are three main reasons. First, a morphologically dependent object, like an incorporated noun for example may be the complement of the verb. Given the mirror hypothesis, it will then be spelt out preverbally as required. Secondly, as noted above, a head like a verb for example, may form an MW with one or more higher heads like v and Infl, each of which is the syntactic complement of the next. The MW may be spelt out in any one of the complement positions that its component members (the morphemes) occupy. Now the notion of MW corresponds to the concept of head chain in standard frameworks, but it is different from this notion in that it provides no natural way of talking about "underlying" or chain root position. The set of heads, each a complement of the previous one, is a decomposed representation of the MW So there is no clear sense in which the lowest head in the series would be an "underlying" or chain root position. Thus mirror theory consistently entails head final structures in the sense that arguments must be specifiers, but there is no sense in which it can be said to entail underlying or chain root SOY, because the positions in which the verb may be spelt out, and which may precede or follow the object and also the subject, form an MW and not a chain. The standard ways of creating non chain-root word orders involve not only V-raising but also VP shift. The third reason why mirror theory cannot be taken to entail chain root SOy is that it provides a treatment for the relevant VP shift operations in which the V-phrase's chain root position corresponds to what is taken to be its shifted, non-root position in other approaches. Recall the discussion .
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
31
preceding (2) above: a V-phrase that does not form an MW with the rest of what in standard terms is its extended projection (in mirror-theoretical terms its extended word, EW), must be in a Spec position. So in general EWs do not necessarily form a series of complements, they can also continue via specifiers. Thus we have a potential solution to the triggering problem of VP shift. When the V-phrase is in a Spec position, this need not be because it forms a chain with a root position where the V-phrase is a complement, part of its extended word. The V-phrase may simply continue its EW via the Spec position, a configuration that must be available in general if the mirror hypothesis is on the right track. Thus at least in some of the cases where non V-final order is achieved in standard terms by VP shift, under mirro r theory the "underlying" chain root V(-phrase)-final order may not exist.
3.
Restructuring and (covert) roll-up
Let us refer to a series of chains as a roll-up structure if it meets the following condition: each chain (except the last) takes the top of the previous chain together with the host of this top member (where this host includes the root of the previous chain) to be the root of the next chain. The term "cascade" has sometimes been used but it I shall avoid it here, since it is often employed also in a different sense. Roberts ( 1 997) has recently suggested analysing Romance type restructuring as (in these terms) a roll-up structure that involves covert head chains. He proposed that restructuring between two verbs V I and V2 involves head movement of V2 up to V I . The V I V2 order in Romance is due to a filter that prevents spelling out V2 in the higher position in its chain. This filter would distinguish between morphemes and words: V can be spelt out on the left of its Inff host since both elements are morphemes, but in restructuring V2 cannot be spelt out on the left of its host VI because both verbs are full words. V2 therefore has to surface lower, and so the VI V2 surface order remains. Roberts assumes (a) that head movement of V2 to V I creates an extended projection that includes both verbs and (b) that the locality/relativized minimality requirement of XP chains makes use of a principle of equidistance (in Chomsky's 1 995 sense), for which positions internal to an extended projection count as equidistant. Following Sportiche 1 995, Roberts assumes that clitic climbing involves XP chains. In the clitic climbing structure in (4), for example, Roberts takes the clitic to move as XP via the lower SpecAgrO and the higher SpecAgrO. That the former position is involved is suggested by the well known participle agreement phenomenon. The involvement of the higher AgrO, as he points out, is suggested by the participial agreement in the matrix in (4).
32
MICHAEL BRODY
(4)
Maria li
ha voluti
prendere.
Maria them (MASC.PL) has wanted (MASC.PL) take
(It)
(This evidence for phrasal chains is strong only on the assumption that the notion of 'checking domain' should be eliminated. Otherwise, as has been noted, agreement of the participle with a nonphrasal element adjoined to the head, i.e. still in its checking domain, is an obvious alternative. See Sportiche 1 992 and Cardinaletti & Starke 1 999 for additional evidence for a phrasal clitic chain.) So for Roberts, invisible movement of the verb prendere to a position hosted by voluti creates an extended projection and thus makes the SpecAgrS of the lower head and the SpecAgrO of the higher one equidistant from the lower AgrO - all three positions are in the same extended projection. In mirror theory, roll-up structures involving heads are analyzed in terms of MWs (as opposed to 'phrases' , i.e. categories taken together with their constitu ents). Elements of MWs are morphemes and the whole MW is a word. Given this restrictive notion, it would make no sense to distinguish component elements of MWs as being either word-level or morpheme-level elements. Another consideration that may be taken to indicate that it may be worth while to look for an alternative treatment of restructuring is the following. Roberts points out that his approach accounts for the possibility of (XP-)move ment across restructuring predicates "without any operation deleting structure in the lower clause" (p. 432). It is not clear however if a solution based on the notion of equidistance is a priori more desirable than one based on structure deletion. The hypothesis that in restructuring contexts intervening position B is deemed not to intervene between positions A and C (whether this is due to A and B being deemed equidistant from C or to some other reason) says nothing about how B will behave under conditions or processes other than movement. On the other hand the hypothesis that in the same contexts B does not intervene because B is not present (either not present at all in the structure or present but in fact occupies a non-intervening position) entails that no principle or operation can make use of B (at all or in the intervening position). These empirical consequences are missing in the weaker equidistance approach. (For the same reason, the layered VP analyses in which AgrO is lower than the chain-root position of the subject in Specv (e.g. Koizumi 1 993; Bobaljik 1 995) would appear to be a priori more desirable than Chomsky' s ( 1995) equidistance solution, where the paths of subject and object cross.)
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
4.
33
Restructuring as 'I in C'
As is well known, there is direct empirical evidence that the complementizer level of the lower infinitive is present in restructuring. (5) is a case with si-passive, (6) clitic climbing and (7) an easy to please construction (cf. Rizzi 1 982; Sportiche 1 995; Kayne 1 987). (5)
? Certe riposte non si
(6)
?Mario, non 10
(7)
sanna mai
come dare.
(It)
certain answers not REFL knows never how give 'One never knows how to give certain answers. '
saprei a chi
affidare.
Mario not him know to whom entrust 'Mario, I would not know to whom to entrust him
? Ce genre d'article est difficile
a
savoir au
(It) .'
classer.
(Fr)
this kind of.article is difficult to know where file 'This kind of article is hard to know where to file. ' Roberts combines Sportiche's phrasal chain analysis of cliticization with the Kaynean approach to restructuring as involving movement of the lower Inil to the higher one. Apart from the suggestion already discussed that this operation creates an extended projection spanning the two clauses, he also suggests that Inil movement is coextensive here with verb movement. Following B elletti ( 1990) he assumes that the infinitival verb in Italian raises to Inil. If this is so, then raising of Inil will involve raising of the verb, resulting in the incorrect word order. Hence the necessity of the * V V filter he proposes, discussed above. The evidence that Roberts quotes from B elletti ( 1990) for the infinitival being in Inil comes from the observation that these must precede elements like mai and piu, naturally associated with negation: (8)
Gianni ha deciso di non tornare mai/piu.
(It)
Gianni has decided to not return ever/more 'Gianni has decided not to come back ever/anymore. ' (9)
* Gianni ha decisio di non mai/piu tornare.
(It)
However even if the polarity elements are in SpecNeg, it does not strictly follow that the verb has raised to the highest Infl. position: it may still be in principle the case that Inil raising in restructuring involves a higher head in the Inil domain than the one to which the verb raises. (Cf. e.g. Cinque 1 999 on multiple Neg positions.) So this evidence in fact does not necessarily prevent a return to Kayne's Inil
34
MICHAEL BRODY
raising analysis. Kayne ( 1 989) assumed that in clitic climbing the clitic raised to the lower Inti, Inti+clitic to C and the whole complex then moved to the higher Inti. It is, however, not clear why the infinitival Infl needs to move to the higher Inti of the restructuring V if clitics form XP-chains. For Kayne, movement to the higher Inti is necessary to carry the clitic up into the higher clause, which is now achieved via the XP-chain. Additionally questions arise concerning the fact that Inti movement to the higher clause appears to cross the higher V position. Let us then dispense with the now apparently unnecessary and problematic part of Kayne' s "I to C to I", namely with "c to I". The residue, "I to C", is motivated by Kayne primarily by the contrast between the restructuring construc tions like in (5)-(7) and those with an overt C as in ( 10) and ( 1 1) (his example is ( 1 1 ) : (10)
*Certe riposte non s i
(11)
*Non li
sanna mai s e dare.
certain answers not REFL knows never if give 'One never knows whether to give certain answers. '
so
(It)
s efare.
not them know if do 'I don't know whether to do them. ' As he notes it is natural to assume that "I to C", hence restructuring, is possible only where C is otherwise empty. (Currently standard assumptions about head movement as head adjunction do indeed provide a basis for expecting some correlation, although they provide no grounds for expecting exactly the observed correlation. If heads do not move through other heads, it remains accidental that only those heads to which Inti cannot adjoin happen to have overt phonological realization. ) Notice however, that the evidence pertains only to the claim that (elements of) Inti are present in C, and not to the assumption that a chain has been formed. Thus we could equally assume that restructuring involves a special type of infinitival C that is in some closer than usual relation with its Inti domain. Suppose Inti can merge with the C selected by restructuring verbs in the sense that Inti (and its Spec, if any) becomes part of the C-domain and thus will not qualify as an A-type intervener. It will thus not interfere with A-chains construct ed across it. The Inti in C analysis automatically covers the case of long si passive in restructuring. Lack of an A-type (Spec-)Inti in the lower clause entails that there will be no (relativized) minimality violation in long si-passives like (5) either. (Like others, I assume that auxiliary selection phenomena in restructuring involves long movement and thus in the relevant respect also falls under the same generalization.)
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
5.
35
Null subjects and ditic climbing
The correlation conjectured by Kayne between the existence of null subjects and the option of clitic climbing is only weakly captured in Kayne 1989. His proposal was that an Infl strong enough to licence null subjects has the ability to void the barrierhood of VP, thereby enabling clitics to escape higher. It is not clear however why these two Infl properties should go together - there is no obvious intrinsic connection between licensing a particular type of Spec and voiding the barrierhood of the complement. Under the phrasal chain analysis of cliticization, the correlation can be captured more directly. Consider Cardinaletti & Starke's ( 1 999) hypothesis that strong and weak pronouns systematically differ from clitics in being XPs, while clitics are heads. In mirror theory terms the only natural way to translate this is to say that non-clitic pronouns are specifiers of the verb's extended word, while clitics are heads, members of the verb's extended word. We can leave it open here whether the clitic starts out as a member of this extended word (essentially as in Sportiche 1 995) or as seems more likely (thanks to Michal Starke for helpful discussion) a head in the Infl domain inherits the features of its (weak) pronominal specifier via Spec-Head agreement. On these approaches syntactic cliticization in the core cases would correspond to a special type of Spec-Head agreement, possible only where the head has the ability or expressive power to carry the referential, anaphoric etc. functions of its designated Spec. Presumably the 'designated' Spec is one whose every feature participates in the Spec-Head agreement relation. With the clitic option taken (the default case where possible, cf. Cardinaletti & Starke's "minimize structure"), the Spec will be typically (apart from clitic doubling) empty or null. The corresponding heads on the other hand are typically non-null, phonologically. The similarity of VP-external, or Infl domain, cliticisation to null subjects is now conspicuous. Null subjects are also licensed by a typically non-null head in the Infl domain that is able to carry the semantic functions of the subject. Thus both VP-external high cliticization and null subjects are licensed in the same way. Both will be possible in a language where clitics exist and Infl domain heads can carry the semantic functions normally carried by Specs as in Italian. In French, as Kayne ( 1 989) points out, even though "easy to please" constructions show restructuring effects, neither null subjects nor VP-external clitics (hence no clitic climbing) are licensed. The analysis outlined in the previous two sections assumes that the clitic's 'phrasal' chain (Spec-to-Spec constituent chain in mirror theory terms) extends to a SpecX position higher than the matrix restructuring verb V*. In mirror
36
MICHAEL BRODY
theory terms this entails that x (which expresses the clitic) and V* cannot form an MW If they did, this would result in the enclitic order: V*-x. To achieve the proclitic order, x must have a complement y with the MW of V* in the Spec of y. (The alternative on which xlclitic and V* in fact form an MW also seems worth exploring, although I will not do so here. If x-V* is an MW then x must originate lower than V*. Hence the Spec-to-Spec constituent chain of the clitic must end lower than V*, which often (as in (5) and (6)) but not always (e.g. (4) above) means lower than the restructuring head, i.e. presumably within the Infl domain of the embedded clause. Such an analysis would be more in the spirit of Kayne's I-to-C-to-I rule, but it would not inherit the problem of I(+C) crossing the matrix V.) .
,
6.
Hungarian verbal dusters
Verbal clusters in Hungarian involving typical restructuring infinitives may appear in two orders: what we might call the straight order as in Romance (and elsewhere) and the inverted roll-up order: ( 1 2)
Utalok [kezdeni jami uszni] .
(Hu)
hate.I begin.INF go.INF swim.INF 'I hate to begin to go swimming (regularly)' ( 1 3)
Utalok [uszni
jami kezdeni] .
(Hu)
hate.I swim.INF go.INF begin.INF - same The infinitives in ( 1 3) are behaving as dependent bound morphemes while those in ( 1 2) behave as words. Adverbials (or other material like the matrix subject for example) may intervene between the infinitivals in ( 1 2) but not between those in ( 1 3) cf. Koopman and Szabolcsi 1 999. Thus, Hungarian restructuring verbs must apparently be intrinsically underspecified (or dually specified) for word hood/morphemehood. The infinitives in ( 1 3) in standard terms appear to form an XO roll-up structure and thus in mirror theory they must be analysed as constitut ing a single MW syntactically a series of complements: -
-
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
( 1 4)
37
-ok@
�
utal-
/
-ni@
�
kezde-
�
-ni
�
jar-
�
-ru
�
usz-
The correct word order results in ( 14) if the MW utalok is spelt out higher than the position of the verb utal, i.e. in some head in the Inil domain represented here by Tns+Agr -ok. Utalok will then precede the (specifier of) its complement the MW uszni jarni kezdeni, a complement series spelt "backwards". In ( 1 2) the morphologically independent infinitives cannot be each other' s complements, they must therefore each b e specifiers: ( 15)
-ok@
�
utal-
/
-ni@
�
kezde-
/
-ni@
�
jar-
/
-ni@
�
usz-
MICHAEL BRODY
38
High spellout of each infinitive ensures the correct word order: each verb in (15) spelt out in the relevant inflectional head position IH will precede the (specifier of the) complement of IH. If we did not have evidence for the infinitives in (13)-(14) constituting a single MW the word order there could also correspond to what in standard terms we could only analyze as a phrasal roll-up structure. While that can be repro duced in mirror theory, this framework appears to provide also an additional possibility. The analysis could be the same as that of ( 1 2)/( 1 5), but with the spellout positions of the infinitives being those of the verbs instead of the higher functional heads. Then each infinitive would be preceded by (the complement of) its specifier resulting in the roll-up order. Low spellout is apparently not an option in Hungarian, a fact perhaps connected to the language allowing null subjects (cf. Roberts 1 997). (Note that in ( 14) and ( 1 5) ' @ ' indicates the spellout position and not that of the strong features. These correspond to the spellout positions in ( 15) and may be the same in ( 14) on the assumption that the spellout position of an MW is its highest strong position.) ,
7.
Verbal modifiers and ditics
As discussed in Koopman & Szabo1csi ( 1998) and also in Brody ( 1997), E. Kiss ( 1 998), Hungarian verbal modifiers (VMs: particles, small clause predicates, bare nouns etc. that can form a single MW with the associated verb, e.g. szet-szed, 'apart-take' ) can apparently also form long-distance chains across a set of restruct uring infinitives (the trace of the VM is indicated by the copy in parentheses): (16)
Szet fogom akami
kezdeni
szedni
(szit) a
radi6t.
(Hu)
apart will.I want.INF begin.INF take.INF apart the radio 'I will want to begin to take apart the radio. '
E. Kiss ( 1998) argues that the VMs i n structures like ( 1 6) relate the verb they semantically belong to and their spell out position via a head chain type relation on the basis of the fact that the string following the VM does not appear to form a constituent and thus cannot be co-ordinated. (17)
*Szet [akarom probalni valogatni a apart will.I
szedni
a
try.INF
radi6t].
sort.INF
babot] es [fogom kezdeni
the beans and will.I begin.INF (Hu)
take.INF the radio 'I will try to sort ( ' apart' ) the beans and will begin to take apart the radio. '
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
39
The co-ordination facts however can pertain only to the question of whether the spellout position of the VM is a head or a Spec position, they do not tell us how the relation between the VM in the matrix and the associated embedded verb is mediated by a head-chain or phrasal chain type relation. Typically the same coordination facts obtain with clitics. ( 1 8)
*Je l 'ai 1
vu
et ai
aime.
(Fr)
him. have seen and have liked
But as we have seen above there is reason to think that clitics can be involved in phrasal chain type relations. Thus Hungarian VMs can be analyzed like clitics: they involve a phrasal chain but at the top position of this phrasal chain a Spec-Head relation is established. The head participating in this Spec-Head relation is of the type that is able to express the content of its VM spec. There is however a real difference between Romance clitics and Hungarian VMs in restructuring. While clitics can cross a filled C-Spec as (6) above shows, reproduced here as ( 1 9), VMs cannot. The infinitival with a +wh SpecC is grammatical in Hungarian as a complement of tud ('know') and van ( 'is' / 'exists' ), but no VM can cross this spec. ( 1 9)
?Mario, non 10
saprei a chi
affidare.
(It)
Mario not him know.I to whom entrust 'Mario, 1 would not know to whom to entrust him. ' (20)
Tudok mit szetszedni.
(Hu)
know.I what apart.take 'I know what to take apart.' (2 1 )
*Szet tudok mit szedni. apart know.I what take.INF - same as (20)
Given the assumption adopted here that the clitic in (19) forms a phrasal chain that spans the matrix and the embedded clause across SpecC, the solution that would attribute the contrast between (19) and (2 1 ) to the difference between the type of interveners to which head chain and phrasal chain type relations are sensitive to is not available. But a different account, still in the spirit of relativized minimality, could be adequate even if both the clitic and the VM form phrasal chains. The VM is an adverbial type element, hence it cannot cross a filled SpecC, - the ungrammaticality of (2 1 ) would then be on a par with that of (22) : (22)
a. b.
*How much did Mary wonder why John weighed? *60 kilos, Mary wondered why John weighed.
40
MICHAEL BRODY
The clitic in (19) on the other hand is an argument. If the top of its phrasal chain is in an A'-position then the structure is like other A'-argument extraction, like e.g. (23). (23)
?Who did Mary wonder why John weighed?
If the clitic is in an A-position, then A'-Specs must be taken to be irrelevant as A-chain interveners, just like A-Specs are irrelevant for A'-chains (cf. Rizzi 1990). As Anna Cardinaletti points out (p.c.), the present approach in terms of an argument-adjunct contrast is supported by the complete lack of idiomatic clitic climbing across filled SpecC:
(24)
a.
Ce
la devo fare.
(It)
there it must.I do 'I have to succeed.' b. *Non ce la so come fare. not there it know.! how do 'I do not know how to succeed. '
8.
Straight and roll-up orders again
There is also Hungarian-internal evidence for the claim that the chain of the VM in straight order restructuring constructions is of the phrasal type (cf. Brody 1 997). This is based on Szabolcsi's ( 1996) observation concerning the interpreta tion of the focussed infinitive in restructuring constructions with more than one layer of clausal embedding. (25)
a. b. c. d. e.
AKARNI fogok kezdeni
(Hu) uszni. want.INF will.I begin.INF swim.INF 'I will indeed want t o begin t o swim.' 'I will WANT to begin to swim. ' (and not, say, TRY to begin to swim) 'I will begin to WANT to swim.' (and not, say, TRY to swim) * 'I will indeed begin to want to swim.'
If the focussed infinitive in (25) has scope over the others, i.e. if it is taken to be associated with the highest infinitival position, then the interpretation of the structure is ambiguous between an emphatic and an 'exhaustive list' reading, as indicated in (25b) and (25c). If however the focussed infinitive has lower scope, i.e. a lower chain-root position, then the emphatic reading (2Se) disappears and only the 'exhaustive list' reading (25d) remains.
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
41
If head-chain and phrasal chain type relations are distinguished, then this state of affairs is straightforward to explain. There are independent reasons to assume that focussing in Hungarian involves a dedicated head, F (cf. Brody 1 990, 1 995) and that the emphatic reading is associated directly with this head rather than with its Spec. Only focussed heads but not focussed phrases can receive the emphatic reading. It is natural to complement this with the assump tion that the exhaustive list reading is associated with the Spec position of F. If head-chain type relations are strictly local but phrasal chains can span larger distances (whether this involves the combination of strictly local links is not relevant here), only the exhaustive list reading (the phrasal chain construction) will be compatible with the lower scope reading. The explanation is contingent on interpreting strictly the standard distinction between head chain and phrasal chain type relations: the former but not the latter are strictly local; head-chains cannot (even apparently, by combining several local steps) cross nonlocal distances. Thus, if the explanation of the correlation between scope and focus interpretation is on the right track, then head chains and phrasal chains must have different locality properties. Whatever way syntax expresses the distinction between these two types of relations, the long-distance chain of the VM in ( 1 6) must belong to the phrasal type. Additional evidence for the existence of the need to distinguish within syntax the head chain and the phrasal chain relations is provided by the fact that the scope of the infinitives in the roll-up structure ( 1 3), reproduced here as (26), is fixed. Thus in (26) kezdeni ( 'begin' ) has scope over jami ('go regularly'), the opposite interpretation is impossible:
(26)
Utalok [uszni
jami kezdeni] .
(Hu)
hate.I swim.INF gO.INF begin.INF 'I hate to begin to go (regularly) swimming.' This is as expected if the roll-up structure involves head chain type relations, that is in mirror theory a series of complements expressing an (inverse order) MW, as in (14) above. Suppose, however that the roll-up structure was created by phrasal chains, by the lowest infinitive (here: uszni) moving to a Spec above the next (here: jami) and then a phrase that includes both this Spec with the lower infinitive in it and the next higher infinitive (i.e. uszni jami) moved in front of the highest infinitive (kezdeni). Clearly there is nothing intrinsic in the concept of phrasal chain that would prevent the lowest infinitive phrase (uszni) from moving in front of the highest one (kezdeni), either in one or in several steps. But this would result in scope relations between the crossed infinitives that correspond to
42
MICHAEL BRODY
their surface order. Under such an analysis uszni would have crossed jami kezdeni and (26) would have the interpretation 'I hate to go (regularly) to begin to swim' which it in fact cannot have. (Admittedly the relevant reading is slightly strange, but this is exactly what (26) would mean if the order of the last two infinitives was reversed, as in Utalok uszni kezdeni jami.) The analyses reviewed in this section make it necessary to take the locality requirement on the relevant head chains to be strict and inviolable. This provides additional evidence for a basic assumption of mirror theory according to which the head chain relation corresponds simply to a local syntactic relation, typically the head-complement relation. Since in this framework no head-chains are formed either in syntax or in morphology and head chains correspond to elements in local relations spelt out in inverse order (MWs), there are no means provided to violate HMC type locality.
Acknowledgments I am grateful to Anna Cardinaletti and Peter Svenonius for helpful correspondence relating to this material.
References Belletti, Adriana. 1990. Generalized verb movement: Aspects of verb syntax. Turin: Rosenberg and Sellier. Bobaljik, Jonathan. 1 995. Morpho syntax: The syntax of verbal inflection. Ph.D. disserta tion, MIT. Brody, Michael. 1990. "Some remarks on the focus field in Hungarian." UCL Working Papers in Linguistics Vo1.2, 201-226. University College London. Brody, Michael. 1 995. "Hungarian focus and bare checking theory." In Arbeitspapiere des Sondeiforschungsbereichs 340, University of Tiibingen. Brody, Michael. 1997. Mirror Theory. ms. University College London. Cardinaletti, Anna and Starke, Michal. 1999. "The typology of structural deficiency: A Case Study of three classes of pronouns." In Henk van Riemsdijk (ed.), Clitics in the Languages of Europe. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. 145-29 1 . Chomsky, Noam. 1 995. The Minimalist Program. Cambridge, MA : MIT Press. Cinque, Guglielmo. 1999. Adverbs and Functional Heads: A cross-linguistic perspective. Oxford: OUP. Kayne, Richard S. 1989. "Null subjects and clitic climbing." In Osvaldo Jaeggli and Ken Safir (eds), The Null Subject Parameter. Dordrecht: Kluwer. 239-261 .
WORD ORDER, RESTRUCTURING AND MIRROR THEORY
43
Kayne, Richard S. 1993. "Toward a modular theory of auxiliary selection." Studia Linguistica 47: 3-3 1 . E. Kiss, Katalin. 1998. The Hungarian verbal complex revisited. ms. Linguistic Institute, HAS. Koizumi, Masatoshi. 1993. "Object agreement phrases and the split VP hypothesis." In Jonathan D. Bobaljik: and Colin Philips (eds.), Papers on Case and Agreement I [MITWPL vol. 18]. Cambridge, MA: ITWPL. 99-149. Koopman, Hilda, and Anna Szabo1csi. 1998. Verbal Complexes. Ms. UCLA. In press, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Koopman, Hilda, and Anna Szabo1csi. 1999. "Hungarian complex verbs and XP-move ment." In Istvan Kenesei (ed.), Crossing Boundaries: Current Issues in Linguistic Theory. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins. 1 1 5-137. Rizzi, Luigi. 1982. Issues in Italian Syntax. Dordrecht: Foris. Rizzi, Luigi. 1990. Relativized Minimality. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Roberts, Ian. 1997. "Restructuring, head movement and locality." Linguistic Inquiry 28: 423--460. Sportiche, Dominique. 1995. "Clitic constructions." In Laurie Zaring and Johan Rooryck (eds), Phrase Structure and the Lexicon. Dordrecht: Kluwer. Szabo1csi, Anna. 1996. Verb and particle movement in Hungarian. Ms. UCLA.
OV is More Basic than VO Hubert Haider University Salzburg
Abstract This paper defends the claim that head-final structures are principally less complex than head-initial structures. The additional complexity of head-initial structures is the result of head movement within the lexical projection. Head movement guarantees the convergence of a head-initial phrase structure, given a universal constraint that admits only a right-branching projection structure. On the theoretical level, this position is in competition with the hypothe sis that OV structures are derived from va structures by evacuation of the VP. In a detailed comparison of the empirical implications, this paper attempts to demonstrate that on the empirical level an evacuation theory is less successful than a head movement theory.
1.
Background
Is OV more basic than VO (or vice versa) is just another way of asking a crucial question in the theory of phrase structure: Is one of the two phrase types head-final-phrases and head-inital ones - a derivative of the other one? In terms of the familiar OV-VO distinction, the question reads: Is the head-initial ( 'VO language') or the head-final structure COV language' ) more basic in terms of the basic X'-structure and its derivational continuation? In Kayne's ( 1994) LCA theory and work building on it, head-initial projections are head-initial underlyingly. This is a consequence of the basic axiom of this theory, the linear correspondence axiom (LCA). 1 It postulates that phrase-structures are built in such a way that the linear order of terminals is a function of asymmetric c-command relations. In the specific implementation of Kayne ( 1994), asymmetric c-command is mapped on precedence. So, in particular,
46
HUBERT HAIDER
the head precedes the complement. Head-final structures are taken to be the result of XP-movement applied to the complements of head-initial projections. So, the OV structure for a VP in particular is the result of evacuating all phrasal elements out of the head-initial VP. The result is a VP that contains nothing but the verb and traces, with everything else situated in functional projections to the left. In a more recent proposal (Kayne 1 998), it is suggested that even in a VO-system like English there are movements of VP-internal phrases in some cases (e.g. negative quantifiers) to the left of VP, followed by fronting the remnant VP past that material again, resulting in what superficially looks like the original word order. This remnant VP-fronting must be ruled out for OV languages. The theory developed in Haider ( 1992) is an alternative to the LCA-based theory of the OVNO-relation. The basic axiom, the branching constraint (BC) postulates a universal right-branching structure for (extended) projections: The projecting node follows the non-projecting sister node. The linear aspect of the head-complement relation is determined by the parametric direction of structural licensing. Licensing to the left triggers the OV structure, licensing to the right the VO structure. In OV languages, with the licensing direction to the left, specifiers and complements precede their respective sister node, that is, the node on the projec tion line of the head of the projection. So, the licensing direction harmonizes with the right-branching structure. Complex head-initial structures, however, cannot meet the directionality of the licensing requirement unless the head is raised (see Section 2 for the details). Thus, head-chains (heads raised to the left) must be formed for the licensing of complements in the (extended) head-initial projections. Head-final structures, on the other hand, will not require head-chains, since the heads follow their complements as well as every left branch (including specifiers) in the (extended) projection. Repercussions of these differences, in particular with respect to the grammar of extraction and the distribution of VP-internal non-arguments, will tum out to be an epiphenomenon of the licensing require ment that forces VO languages, but not OV languages, to apply V chaining. Given this alternative - OV is derived from VO by phrasal movement to the left versus VO is derived from OV by head movement to the left - it should not be too difficult to find decisive empirical evidence. After all, the implica tions of the two accounts are diverse enough. The paper is organized as follows: Section 3 sketches the basics of the head movement account (BC theory) of VO and OV structures. Section 4 presents five areas of data that are of relevance for the evaluation of the competing approach es. It is argued that central implications of the LCA system are in conflict with empirical evidence both on the level of observational as well as on the level of
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN va
47
descriptive adequacy. It is argued that the alternative account provides a more satisfactory modelling of the pertinent facts. Section 5 discusses the trigger problem for each account.
2.
A BC account of VO and OV
The central axiom2 of the approach presented in Haider (1992) and developed further in Haider (1994) is the branching constraint formulated in (1) and illustrated in (2) with a V projection embedded under a functional projection that conforms to (1). It requires that lexical projections and their functional extensions are right-branching: (1)
Branching Constraint (BC): Projection-internal branching nodes on the (extended) projection line follow their sister node. 3
The qualification 'projection-internal' singles out the top node. Without this proviso, the BC would not admit basic head-final structures with a phrasal complement preceding the head, because in this case the top node of the complement phrase would have a right sister, namely the complement-selecting head. What the BC is to capture is the rigid right-branching structure internal to (functionally extended) projections of a lexical head. For the V projection, for instance, this is the V projection proper (as the lexical projection) plus its functional extensions up to CPo (2)
In (2), all non-top branching nodes on the V projection line, that is, all the V' nodes, follow their sister node. On the F-projection line, there is only one
48
HUBERT HAIDER
relevant node, namely F', and it follows its sister node, namely SpecF. The crucial structural difference between a head-inital and a head-final lexical projection will be explained below. (3a) violates the B e, because F' precedes its sister node SpecF. In (3b), V' precedes a VP-intemal node and therefore violates the Be. The Be applies to lexical projections and their functional extensions in general. VP in (2) and (3) is just representative for any complex lexical, head-initial projection. (3)
a. *
FP
�
F'
�O
D
VP
�
V'
� O
V
F
FP
b. *
D
D
The Be forbids a left branch in a binary projection which is a node on the projection line: For any two nodes immediately dominated by different nodes of the (extended) projection line, the node that precedes c-commands the node that follows, and the node that precedes is not a node on the (extended) projection line. This constraint eliminates right-associative projection structures as in (3). As a consequence of (1), precedence and c-command coincide. For all nodes that are immediately dominated by a node on the same (extended) projection line, the preceding nodes c-command the nodes that follow. The Be rules out base generated right-associative structures such as (3) as well as structures derived by movement, that is, as a result of adjunction to the right.4 If a functional projection is a functional extension of the projection of a lexical category, the Be rules out functional heads to the right in general. In this case the projection of the lexical category would be a left sister of the functional head and at the same time a node on the extended projection line as a left branch. This is illustrated in (4): (4)
*
FP
� D
F'
�O
VP
D
F
I
The VP node in (4) is a top node in the V projection, but simultaneously a node on the extended V projection, whose top node is the FP. At this point there is
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN va
49
need for a precise definition of functionally extended lexical projection: A functional projection is a functionally extended lexical projection if and only if the lexical head moves to the functional head position overtly. The BC, for instance, does not rule out clause structures with a clause-final complementizer particle. In this case, the CP is not a functional extension of the complement. It is just a functional projection with a complement selected by a CO-head. Rowev er, the BC would rule out a clause structure if a verb overtly moves to the position of a clause-final functional head that is alternatively realized by a lexical complementizer. In sum, the BC forbids any kind of movement to the right: It forbids head movement to the right, as in (4). It forbids movement into Spec-positions to the right, resulting in structures like (3a). And it forbids adjunction to the right, because this produces structures of the kind (3b). Let us now proceed to head-initial projections. Read-final and head-initial lexical projections have the same kind of branching structure but different head positions. The head position is a function of the licensing directionality.s In (5), the licensing direction is indicated by an arrow. The combination of the BC with the parametric options of licensing (either to the left or to the right) provides the grammatical reason that explains why complex head-initial projections involve shell-structures with a head-chain (cf. Raider 1 993: 28-30). The lexical projection in (2) is a head-final projection. The head and each node on the projection line follows the position to be licensed. So, the structure is simultaneously in harmony with the directionality of licensing and the BC. If, however, the directionality of licensing is progressive, that is, the position to be licensed has to follow, the BC structure provides a single position that meets the licensing requirement. This is the sister of the foot position of the head in (5). The other positions cannot be licensed unless the head is raised. In terms of Chomsky's (1995) framework, the structure (5) is a result of the merge function constrained by the BC: first a Spec-Read-complement configura tion is projected in accordance with the BC. This structure is merged with a head position in order to project another Spec-Read-complement structure. The result is a shell structure of the Larsonian kind (cf. Larson 1 988):
HUBERT HAIDER
50 (5)
The licensing requirement for a phrasal position in a projection is twofold. Licensing combines formal licensing plus identification: The phrase must be assigned to a possible phrase structure position and its dependency relation must be identified. Positions are formally licensed. The parametric direction of formal licensing is the trigger for the shell structure in head-initial lexical projections. Let us now compare the two alternative approaches: In both systems, movement to the right is blocked. The reason is straightforward: The structure presupposed or generated by movement to the right is characterized as ill-formed. In both systems, asymmetric c-command equals precedence. Since movement targets commanding positions, movement is to the left. The differences between the two approaches are easy to trace: In the LCA system, both in the version of Kayne (1994) and ( 1 998), OV is a derivative of a basic VO structure. In the BC system, the OV structure is a potential base structure (cf. structure (2) above). A complex head-initial projection of a lexical head is a shell-structure with a head-chain, as in (5). In order to check the empirical validity of each of these proposals, it is sufficient to derive distinctive, testable implications and check them. (6) lists a selection of areas of grammar in which the two approaches evidently differ. The relevant phenomena will be discussed in the following section.
(6) a. b. c. d. e.
V-head positions per VP VP-internal DP objects VP-internal = postverbal FP topicalization with Vfin universal Aux-V base order
LCA
BC
VO = OV *OV yes yes yes
VO > OV ,/ov
no no no
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN VO
51
(6a) refers to the difference illustrated by (2) and (5). In the LeA system, the V projection of a head-final VP is derived from a head-initial VP structure. Therefore the VP-internal structure is identical for both. In the Be system, however, a head-final V projection is well-formed with a single V position, that is, the verbal head in the foot-position of the projection. In a head-initial VP, the structure is potentially complex, since V chaining is necessary in order to license multiple argument positions. It will be argued below that the distribution of particles in English and Norwegian is a direct reflex of V chaining. (6b): According to the LeA system, the preverbal position of objects in an OV language is always a derived position (i.e. Spec-position of a functional head). In the Be system, the base positions of DP or PP arguments in a head final VP are preverbal. The differentiating prediction is evident: According to the LeA system, any argument is subject to the restrictions on derived positions. In the Be system, preverbal arguments in base positions are expected to behave like arguments in base-positions. In other words: The LeA system predicts that the arguments in an OV clause structure are subject to the kind of restrictions that apply to elements in Spec-positions (e.g. opacity restrictions). The Be system predicts that preverbal arguments in a head-final VP behave just like VP-internal arguments in a head-inital VP. (6c) addresses obligatorily VP-internal elements like selected adverbials or secondary predicates. According to the LeA theory, an obligatorily VP-internal element will surface in a postverbal position in an OV language. Obligatorily VP-internal just means that the element cannot and must not be fronted to a pre VP position. In the Be account, obligatorily VP-internal elements of a head-final VP are necessarily preverbal. (6d) concerns what is traditionally referred to as VP topicalization. In the Be system, it is VP topicalization after all. In the LeA system, the position of a preverbal object is in a higher functional projection. So, traditional VP topicalization must be reanalyzed as the topicalization of a functional projection. If the functional projection contains a link of the head-chain of the finite verb, crossing violations are expected in the LeA system, but not in the Be system. (6e) focusses on the order of auxiliaries. Since the universal base order in the LeA system is head-initial, the auxiliary precedes its complement VP. The VP is head-initial, too. So, the resulting base linearization is: auxiliary before main verb. In German, the linearization is in most cases the mirror image of the English order. In the Be perspective, this is a possible base order.
52 3.
HUBERT HAIDER Data and generalizations: against [OV]
=
[Oi [V ei]]
For ease of reference and for the sake of clarification, the issues listed in (6) will be rephrased as generalizations that ought to be captured by a descriptively adequate model of grammar. Generalization 1 : a. If a result predicate (particles included) may occur in more than one VP-internal position (i.e. adjacent or non-adjacent to the verb), the given language has a head-initial VP. b. In languages with V-final VPs, there is only one particle position for particle verbs, and it is preverbal and V-adjacent. 6 (cf. Haider 1 997 a for details) In English and in Norwegian, verb-particle combinations as well as combinations of a verb plus a resultative predicate occur in one of two serialization patterns: either adjacent or split. In Haider ( 1997a), the non-adjacent pattern is analyzed as the result of optional stranding.
(7)
a. b. c. d.
She cut the tree down carefully. The joggers ran the pavement thin. She cut down the tree carefully. The joggers ran thin the pavement.
(8)
a.
at han kastet matten ut that he threw carpet.the out 'that he threw out the carpet' at de skar kjrjJttet i biter that he cut meat. the to pieces 'that he cut the meat to pieces' at han kastet ut matten at de skar i biter kjrjJtet
b.
c. d.
(Nor)
If the stranding analysis is correct, the particle distribution in English and Norwegian is a direct reflex of verb positions on the V-chain in the V projection. In a stranding language there are as many particle positions as there are links on the VP-internal V-chain. 7
(9)
a. b.
[cu� [the tree [[ei down] carefully]]] [[cut down]i [the tree [ei carefully]]]
In German, which is representative for the Germanic OV languages in this respect, the particle position for verb-particle combinations is preverbal ( IOa-b vs. IOc-d), and adjacent (lOe).
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN va
( 1 0)
a. *daj3 er den Teppich waif weg that he the carpet threw out b. *daj3 er das Fleisch schnitt in (3 gleiche) StUcke that he the meat cut in 3 equal pieces c. daj3 er den Teppich weg waif d. daj3 er das Fleisch in (3 gleiche) StUcke schnitt e. *daj3 er den Teppich weg nichtlachtlos waif that he the carpet out not/carelessly threw
53 (Ger)
It is important to honour two facts: First, this pattern is not confined to particles but applies also to phrasal result predicates, as in ( l Ob, d). Particle incorporation, therefore, would not be an adequate solution. Second, in VO languages, particles and result predicates cannot move to clause internal positions preceding the VP: ( 1 1)
a. *The pavement was thi� [yp run ei] b. *The tree was dow� [yp cut ei]
The problematic aspect for the LCA account is this: If there are elements that do not obligatorily move out of the VP-internal position proper in a VO language, they are - ceteris paribus - expected to do so in an OV language: Given that particles and result predicates are VP-internal elements, they are incorrectly predicted to occur as postverbal elements in OV languages like German, which admit postverbal elements. In the BC account, the facts follow straightforwardly. Since there is only the basic V position in the head-final V projection, there is only one position for particles (cf. ( l Oc)) or result predicates (cf. ( lOd)). Generalization 2: Preverbal argument positions in VO clause structures are VP-external, pre-verbal argument positions in OV languages, however, display VP-internal properties. Phrases in uncontroversial Spec-positions of functional heads are opaque domains for extraction in general. But, as a matter of fact, preverbal positions in OV languages like German, scrambled or unscrambled, are not opaque. 8 So, they cannot be analyzed as Spec-positions of functional heads (without non-standard amendments to the theory, which would need to be independently justified). The contrast in (12), discussed in Kayne ( 1 983: 224), is representative for this generalization. VP-external positions in VO structures are opaque for wh extraction. Preverbal argument clauses in German, however, are not opaque, as (13a) illustrates. (13a) contains a subject clause. ( 1 2)
a. the book that it became difficult [to talk about e] b. *the book that [talking about e] became difficult
HUBERT HAIDER
54 ( 1 3)
Welches Buchi hat [ei zu lesen] dir mehr Spaj3 gemacht? which book has [to read] you more fun.Acc made 'Which book did you enjoy reading?' b. *Welches Buch sagte sie [cp [ei zu lesen] [habe [ihr which book said [she [to read] [has her a.
Spaj3 gemacht]]] ? fun made]]] 'Which book did she say she enjoyed reading?' Although extraction starts from within a subject clause in ( 13a), wh-extraction is possible in this case in German. The contrast between English and German becomes straightforward once it is realized that a German subject stays in its VP-internal position. 9 For a recent survey on this and related issues of German clause structure see Haider ( 1997b), Haider & Rosengren ( 1 998). In ( 1 3b), an embedded V2-clause, the extraction site is contained in a constituent fronted to SpecCP. In this case extraction is ill-formed, as expected. This shows that the standard opacity domains are operative in German. The various movement operations that produce the apparent OV order in the LCA system target functional Spec-positions. Thus, the preverbal XPs in an OV language are predicted to be as opaque for extraction as XPs in uncontroversia1 functional Spec-positions (as for instance the functional subject position in a VO language). These counterfactual implications for VO-to-OV do not arise, of course, if the structure of a head-final projection is identified as an underived, base-generated structure. Generalization 3 : Selected adverbials and secondary predicates are VP-internal in V O languages and preverbal in OV languages. The fact that an element can surface in a VP-internal position in a head-initial VP proves that there is no universal necessity for moving this element to a VP-exter nal position. For OV languages, VP-internal elements would appear postverbally, because VP-internal in OV is, according to the LCA approach (Kayne 1994), identical with VP-internal in a head-initial V projection. Elements that are obligatorily VP-internal in VO languages are particles, result-predicates, object related depictive predicates and selected manner adverbials. All these elements are ungrammatical in preverbal positions in uncontroversial VO structures in English, Romance or Scandinavian languages (cf. ( 14a'-d')). This proves at least that there is no universal trigger for moving these elements out of the VP.
OV IS MORE BASIC
( 14)
a. a'. b. b'. c. , c. d. d'.
THAN
55
VO
They handed it out *They out handed it They drank him under the table *They under the table drank him The meati was served ei raw *The meat was raw served They have lived frugally *They have frugally lived
In the LeA-geared VO-to-OV scenario, the postverbal elements in (15) would have failed to move. In the Be system they could not have been generated in a postverbal position from the beginning. The crucial problem for the LeA approach is that there is no grammatical reason at all for moving these elements: Particles must not move out of the VP (14a). Result predicates do not leave the VP (14b). Depictive predicates are obligatorily VP-internal (14c). Particularly instructive is the distribution of selected manner adverbials. Although a manner adverbial may be placed before the VP, this is not grammatical for selected manner adverbials. All these elements cannot be moved out of the VP in VO languages, so they ought to stay in their VP-internal position in OV languages as well, just like in the regular VO languages. The resulting pattern would be ( 1 5). ( 1 5)
a. *Sie haben es gehiindigt aus ( 14a) they have it handed out b. *Sie haben ihn getrunken unter den Tisch ( they have him drunken under the table c. *Das Fleisch wurde serviert roh ( 14c) the meat was served raw d. *Sie haben gelebt geniigsam ( 14d) they have lived frugally =
=
14b)
=
=
The examples in (15a-d) correspond to (14a-d), respectively. They are ungram matical just because the postverbal elements in ( 1 5) cannot appear postverbally in a head-final projection. The grammatical order is preverbal. To claim that they have to move obligatorily to the left would amount to merely begging the question. There is no OV language known in which these elements appear postverbally, 1O and what is crucial, there is no VO language in which these elements could move to the left, out of the VP. In fact, given the LeA system, one would expect that there are some VO languages in which these elements have to move out of the VP, because the triggers for the evacuation of the VP are in principle independent for each class of items. Why this is trigger obligatorily
HUBERT HAIDER
56
absent in VO languages but obligatorily present in OV languages is a crucial question without an answer at hand. So, we conclude with the insight that there is no straightforward way to derive the OV order from a VO structure for these elements. Generalization 4: Topicalized projections must not contain the trace of the finite verb. In the LCA approach to OV, preverbal elements are assigned to functional Spec positions above VP. What used to be analyzed as VP topicalization must now be analyzed as the topicalization of a VP contained in a functional projection that hosts the preverbal object. In this case, it is important to note that the F-project ion must be lower than the starting point of the head chain that leads to the V2-position of the finite verb. That this is so is easy to demonstrate with the contrast between ( 16a) and ( 16c).
( 1 6)
a.
b. c.
[Einen Fehler nachgewiesen] hat er ihm noch nie.
[a mistake PRT.proven] has he him ever never 'Given him proof of a mistake, he never ever has'
Er wiesj
ihm noch nie
einen Fehler nach-ej .
he prove� him ever never a
mistake PRT-ei
* [Einen Fehler nach-ej ] wiesj er ihm noch nie. [a mistake PRT- ei] prove� he him ever never 'Given him proof of a mistake, he never ever has'
The examples in ( 1 6) feature a particle verb. If the finite verb moves to SpecC, the particle is stranded ( 1 6b). ( 16c) shows that the stranded particle cannot be part of the fronted constituent. In other words, the trace of the finite verb must not be part of the topicalized constituent: ( 16c) demonstrates that the topicalized constituent cannot contain the trace of the finite verb. The particle in ( 16b-c) is an indicator for the position of the trace of the finite verb since the verb is one with a so-called separable particle (cf. ( 1 6b)) that is stranded by V2. Topicalizing the constituent that contains the trace of the verb incurs a crossing violation: The trace of the verb in (16c) fails to be in the c-command domain of the moved verb. With this in mind, let us proceed to the argument: If the topicalized constituent in ( 16a) contained the trace of the finite verb, it would be predicted to be ungrammatical, contrary to the facts. The conclusion must be, therefore, that the topicalized phrase cannot contain the trace of the finite verb. For ( 16a) this means that the topicalized constituent must be a complement of the auxiliary verb. It is only in this case that the finite auxiliary would not have to pass through the functional head of the functional projection that hosts the argument of the main verb (cf. (17)).
OV IS MORE BASIC
THAN
57
va
Unavoidable though this conclusion is, it is an unwanted conclusion, and so is the premise, therefore, which it is derived from: It is unwanted at least for the following reason: This solution is bound to overgenerate. The serialization of the structure (17) is ungrammatical, as the examples ( 1 8a-b) illustrate. The finite auxiliary follows the main verb ( 1 8c). (17)
a. b.
[Aux-VP VAux [FP XPj FO [vp VO . . . ej VP
• • •
]]]
�
VO-aux
FP
�
)Opi
F'
�
FO
VP
�
VO . . . � .
. .
According to this structure, the auxiliary verb in its base position licenses a functional projection as its complement. The Spec of the functional head hosts an element that is moved out of the head-initial VP. If there are more elements, there must be a cascade of functional projections, each of which gives room for one phrase. The result is the surface OV order within the FP. As the examples ( 1 8a-b) illustrate, the order in (17) results in an ungrammatical serialization. ( 1 8)
a. *daj3 er hat (ihm) einen Fehler nachgewiesen that he has him a mistake given.proof.of b. *daj3 er (ihm) einen Fehler hat nachgewiesen that he him a mistake has given.proof.of c. daj3 er (ihm) einen Fehler nachgewiesen hat that he him a mistake given.proof.of has
So, either the structure ( 17) is inadequate or the whole FP must move to a higher position. In the latter case, the FP would tum into an opaque extraction domain. ( 19a) would be predicted to be ungrammatical for the same reason that accounts for the ungrammaticality of extraction out of a fronted constituent in English, as illustrated in (19b): ( 1 9)
WOriiberj [hatj [er [ej gesprochen] ej]] ? what.about has he talked 'What has he talked about?' b. *the book [that [talking about e] he liked] a.
58
HUBERT HAIDER
On the other hand, structure ( 17) could be replaced by a structure in which the auxiliary selects a VP, not an FP (cf. Zwart 1 993), with the surface verb order derived by verb-raising (head-head adjunction). But in this case, the functional projection targeted by VP-intemal elements would be higher than the auxiliary position. So the finite auxiliary would have to pass through the corresponding functional head position. The result would be that (16a) is parallel to ( 16c). In both cases the fronted constituents would contain the trace of the finite verb, and both are predicted to be ungrammatical. There is still another but equally unsuccessful derivational trail that starts with (17) and leads to the word order in ( 1 8c). This is the combination of VP evacuation and the fronting of the remnant VP, as suggested by Kayne ( 1998) for overt quantifier movement in English. The problems remain, however. Since the remnant VP is placed between the evacuated material and the auxiliary, the evacuated material necessarily c-commands the auxiliary, and so do the function al heads that host the material. If the auxiliary moves to the top F-head in the V2-clause, 1 1 it will pass through these head-positions and the ensuing crossing violations cannot be avoided when the minimal constituent that contains the object and the main verb is fronted. Generalization 5: Universal #16 and its extension to auxiliary sequences 12 A final piece of evidence is the order of auxiliaries. The German order, which is representative of OV systems in that respect, is the mirror image of the English sequence. 13 If the OV order is the derivational result of a basic VO order, the base orders of auxiliaries in a VO structure and in an OV structure are predicted to be identical. The evacuation of VP, which produces the OV order, leaves the serialization of verbs unaffected (cf. (20)). If they differ nevertheless, this must be attributed to an additional move in the derivation (20c): (20)
b.
[Vaux [vpVO XP ]] [XPi [Vaux [vpVO ei]]]
Evacuation
c.
XP VO Vaux
Aux-V-reordering (details below)
a.
VO order
In German, the grammatical order (21b) is the mirror image of the English order (21 a). The order parallel to the English one (2Ic) is ungrammatical. In the LCA system, (21b) must be derived from (21 c). In the BC approach, (21b) is a possible base order: Each VP complement is licensed by an auxiliary as the head of a V projection and the VP complement precedes since a verbal head licenses the complement to the left.
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN va
(21)
a.
They [must [have [been [persuaded by him.]]]]
b.
daB [[[[sie von ihm uberredet vp] worden yp] sein vp] that they by him persuaded been have mussen yp] ( 2 1 a) must
59
=
c. *dafi sie miissen sein worden iiberredet von ihm that they must have been persuaded by him The following discussion is meant to highlight the difficulties of integrating this word order property into the LeA system. Of course, there cannot be a demon strative proof that it could not be implemented somehow. The crucial point is just this: In the Be account the German pattern falls out as the expected pattern for head-final languages. This is in accordance with what is known about OV languages. In the LeA account, additional derivational machinery is necessary. Dutch has been claimed to clearly support the LeA approach towards Ov. That this is not so, and that the V-raising phenomenon is a neutral ground at best for a decision between the LeA system and the headedness approach towards OV NO, is what the following paragraphs are meant to indicate. Two possibilities come to mind that could lead to (21b), namely either V-raising or iterative VP movement to the left. Zwart (1993), who primarily analyzed Dutch, advocates a V-raising approach. The auxiliary order is derived by iterative head-to-head adjunction (cf. Zwart 1993 Sect. 2.4). It is possible to derive the order in (21b) from the order in (21 a, c) by means of the devices suggested by Zwart, but the theoretical and empirical soundness remains to be demonstrated. There are several problem areas that undermine this approach as a viable analysis in a Kaynean framework. First, multiple head-to-head adjunction cannot be assumed under the premises of the LeA system, because multiple head-to-head adjunctions are explicitly ruled out by Kayne ( 1994: 8 , 1 9). Secondly, Zwart (1993: 335f.) is forced to admit non-local adjunctions to heads in a derived position in order to capture optional, alternative serializations in the verb cluster in Dutch and German IPP-constructions in which the finite verb is sandwiched by two non finite verbs: (22)
a.
dat Jan verteld zal hebben, dat hij Marie gekust heeft (Dut) that John told
b.
will have
that he Marie kissed has
dafi er sie grufien hiitte mussen that he her greet had must 'that he should have greeted her'
(Ger)
60
HUBERT HAIDER
In terms of the solution proposed by Zwart ( 1 993 : 337), the past participle has moved across the non-finite auxiliary in (22a) and the modal in (22b), respective ly, in order to adjoin to the finite verb in the position of the functional head. But this is in conflict with two standard assumptions: First, head movement is subject to minimality (i.e. the head movement constraint), so the intervening auxiliary should block this movement. Second, if it left-adjoins to the finite verb in the position of an F-head, V-second should transport both verbal elements to SpecC, and not just the finite verb (cf. the movement of finite verbs with adj oined clitics). The result would be ill-formed in Dutch and German, however. If the adjunction approach is hard to maintain, VP movement seems to be the only option left: Starting with the hypothetical base order (2Ic), the order (2 Ib) should be the result of evacuating the VP plus moving every VP out of the VP that contains it to a position preceding the mother VP. The intermediate derivational steps are illustrated in (23). (23a) is the outcome of the evacuation of the proj ec tion of the main verb. The next steps are less straightforward. Let us assume that the finite verb moves to a functional head position (23b), and the remnant VP is fronted (23c). How do we get the inverse order within the fronted VP? (23)
a.
*daj3 siei von ihmj [VP l miissen [VP2 sein [VP3 worden [VP4 ei that she by him
must
have
been
iiberredet ej]]]]
persuaded
b. *daj3 sie von ihm miisseni [VP l ei [VP2 sein [VP3 worden [VP4 e iiberredet e]]]] c.
*daj3 sie von ihm [VP l ei [VP2 sein [VP3 worden [VP4 e iiberredet e]]]] miisseni
Since adjunction is banned in the LCA system, the desired order cannot be achieved by VP fronting. More structure is needed. The mirror order can be obtained if each auxiliary projects at least one separate functional projection, whose Spec will then host the fronted complement. (24) illustrates the derivation for the most deeply embedded VP. (24)
a.
[FP Spec [Fo [VP3 worden [VP4 e iiberredet e]]]] been
b.
persuaded
[FP [VP4 e iiberredet e]j [wordeni [VP3 ei ej]]]]
The FP in (24b) will have to move into the Spec of the functional projection whose complement is the VP of the auxiliary sein, as illustrated in (25).
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN VO (25)
a. b.
61
[FP- l Spec [Fo [vp sein [FP-2-]]]] [FP-l [FP-2 -]j [seini [vp ei ej ]]]
The result would be a complex of stacked F-projections in the Spec o f an F-projection. But the complexity of the derivation is not the problem. The real problem is an empirical one. The assumption that the VP and the higher auxiliary-verb projection are each stacked in separate F-Specs overgenerates: (26a) shows that the extraposed object clause can be part of the topicalized phrase that contains only the main verb. But, independent of topicalization (cf. (26b, d)), the extraposed clause cannot intervene. This would be possible, however, if in (26b, d) there were a VP or a higher projection in a SpecF position. In this case, (26b, d) would be expected to pattern parallel to (26a). (26)
a.
[Sagen, [wo
sie wohnt]], wurde er dir nicht konnen
[tell where she lives] would he you not be.able 'To tell you where she lives he would not be able' b. * [ [Sagen, wo sie wohnt] konnen] wurde er dir nicht [tell where she lives be. able] would he you not c.
[Sagen konnen, wo sie wohnt], wurde er dir nicht [tell be.able where she lives] would he you not
d. *Er wurde dir nicht [sagen [wo sie wohnt]] konnen he would you not tell [where she lives] be.able The VP-movement analysis misses an important property. It does not capture the 'verb cluster property' : The clause-final sequence of non-finite verbs in a simple clause in German must not be interrupted by nonverbal material. It would be unfair to withhold that the Be-based account needs a separate condition for capturing the verb-cluster property. But the crucial difference is that the LeA approach has no consistent way of implementing this: In the Be system, the order restrictions for (26a) and (26d) are different, because (26d) must be a possible base order. In the LeA system, however, (26d) and (26a) are instances of orders derived by the same type of movement, that is, movement of V-projec tions into functional Spec-positions. In sum, there are central data areas that bear on the empirical validity of the LeA account and the Be approach. If put to the test, it turns out that central implications of the LeA system with respect to the analysis of OV structures are not compatible with the full range of the empirical evidence.
62
4.
HUBERT HAIDER
Structure and linearization: What triggers what?
The LeA account is too strong and too weak at the same time: It is too strong because it employs more derivational machinery than justified by independent evidence and it is too weak because it does not provide a general enough trigger theory for the OVNO-parametrization. As for the additional machinery, it should be noted that the LeA account and the Be account of complex head-initial projections share one essential device, namely head chaining: In double object constructions, for instance, the verb in the VP-initial position is the head of a head chain. In addition to head chains, the LeA system must invoke phrasal movement in order to derive the OV structure from the VO structure. In the Be system, head movement is the only device. Head movement is sufficient to capture both, the principal differ ence between the OV and VO structures and the concomitant difference in the internal organization. The evidence discussed above points to the conclusion that the more economical approach is at least empirically adequate. The lack of independent empirical evidence for the need of phrasal movement in view of systematic counterevidence is a non-trivial challenge for the LeA strategy. The lack of a trigger theory is a serious deficit. In the absence of a trigger theory, the LeA theory predicts that natural languages are head-initial languages : The O V order i s the result o f evacuating the basic head-initial projection, but this evacuation must be triggered. In the LeA system, the trigger must be a global one because it indiscriminately affects all VP-internal elements, independent of their category and grammatical function: arguments, attributes (including relative clauses), adverbials, particles, (secondary) predicates. Holmberg (this volume) proposes c-selection (i.e. strict subcategorization) as the parametric locus for the global trigger of the respective movement types: The basic difference between OV and VO languages is in his view reducible to a difference in terms of checking c-selection features: In OV languages, c-selec tion features are to be checked by phrasal movement, but in VO languages by head movement. As he acknowledges, this does not account for the serialization of non-subcategorized elements, such as PP adverbials, adverbial clauses, extraposed relative clauses, etc. without some non-standard assumptions. What is more problematic however, is the existence of mixed language types, such as for instance German: N-, P- and functional projections are head-initial, V- and A-projections are head-final. Since the trigger is framed as a computational property of the different implementation of a feature checking mechanism, parametrization according to category subclasses would amount to a parametri zation on the computational level. In addition, this account is open to the issues
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN va
63
raised against an account that takes head-initial structures as a starting point for deriving head-final ones. The trigger for a head movement structure (i.e. a complex head initial lexical projection) in the Be-based approach is the conflicting set of demands for a convergent structure assignment posed by a serialization with an initial head: A convergent structure must be binary branching and it must comply with the Be and the endocentricity requirement, that is, there must be a head position at the bottom of the projection in a right-branching structure. Given these demands, what is the convergent structure for a serialization like (27a)? The solution is (27b): The convergent structure for (27a) is a structure with head movement: This is the only way to simultaneously have a head-position at the foot of the projection and a lexical head element in initial position without violating the Be. Each head position in (27b) is the local directional licenser of its complement, and for each phrase in the projection there is a local head. In a head-final structure (27c), each phrase has a sister that is either the head or a projection of the head in the canonical licensing configuration and, what distinguishes (27c) and (27b), (27c) meets the Be with the head in the base position. (27)
a. b. c.
[HP hO XP YP ZP] [hOi [XP [ei [YP [ei ZP]]]]] [XP [YP [ZP hOH'] H'] HP]
This way of describing the triggering situation may appear strange because it characterizes the problem from a representational point of view: Given an array of terminals, what is the minimal convergent structure? In this perspective, UG is a complex cognitive capacity of symbol processing recruited for representa tional, that is, projective robustness. It enables the learner to assemble the knowledge system called core grammar. The system of representations and principles of core grammar is the recursive solution of the projection problem for a given natural language L, that is, the function from one-dimensional expres sions ( a string of terminals of L) to an at least two dimensional expression ( the grammatical structure of the string). The core grammar determines the projection of a syntactic structure onto a given string of terminals of L. The solution of the projection problem is the criterion of empirical adequacy for grammar theory. The solution is the algorithm that maps strings of L onto well formed structures. From the point of view of the Be hypothesis, the primary question is 'What is the structure for a given serialization?' and not 'What is the serialization for a given structure?' The Be is an attempt to model a principle of structure =
=
64
HUBERT HAIDER
assignment provided by UG that narrowly restricts the construction space for projections, given an array of terminals: Precedence in linear order corresponds to c-command in structure. The LeA perspective is a perspective of structure disambiguation: UG is supposed to provide a principle that organizes the structure in such a way that the terminals of a given phrase structure can be mapped in a unique way on a linear ordering. Kayne ( 1 994) chose to implement this as a function that maps asymmetric c-command relations on precedence relations. This is only one possible implementation out of many possible alternatives, however. Asymmetric c-command could be mapped on succession in linear order rather than on precedence. The result would be a grammar with consistently left branching structures. 14 Moreover, a grammar in which each head is parametrize able for either precedence (i.e. Spec-head-complement) or succession (i.e. complement-head-spec) would also provide a well-formed system of structure-to string mapping. In other words, the branching directionality is not an integral part of Kayne's system. It is first of all an empirical issue, and secondly, a fact about grammars to be modelled in a theory of UG. A final area of difference in a meta-theoretic perspective is the level of applicability of the respective constraints: The Be is a universal local constraint on structure projection or merger. The LeA, however, is a global constraint. It is a prespecified theorem rather than an axiom. What it amounts to is this: The LeA does not constrain structures but first of all gramma rs. The LeA is a criterion of success for grammars. Grammars must be organized such that they obey the LeA. They obey LeA if the structures they admit fulfill the mapping requirements spelled out by the LeA. So, a grammar has to conspire to meet the LeA: The conspiracy combines constraints on structures (Spec before head before complement), distinctions on the projection level (between categories and segments), constraints on merger (at most one adjunct), and constraints on movements (e.g. no adjunction to the right). A local constraint on admissible data structures, as the Be, is necessarily less far-reaching in its theory-internal implications but it is as strong a claim on the level of the cognitively adequate modelling of a UG property as the global benchmarking of grammars is.
Acknowledgments I want to thank Anders Holmberg and Peter Svenonius for many helpful comments. Remaining shortcomings are of course to be blamed on the author.
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN va
65
Notes 1.
Linear correspondence axiom (LCA): d(A) is a linear order of T, for a given phrase marker P, with T the set of terminals and A the maximal set of ordered pairs (�, Yj), such that for each j , � asymmetrically c-commands Yj. (Kayne 1994: 5f.)
2.
The BC is axiomatic in the following sense: If correct, it describes a universal property of data structures of human grammars. The property modelled by the BC is considered to be a primitive element of UG. The axiomatic element of the LCA system is the postulate that asymmetric c-command is mapped on precedence. The system itself does not break the symmetry.
3.
There are at least two areas of facts that are not yet satisfactorily integrated, namely, the order and structure of postverbal adjuncts in VO languages, and the structure of mirror-image VO languages (cf. Pearson, this volume). The order of postverbal adjuncts in English (V-respect > process > space > time [cf. Quirk et al. 1 986: §8.87]) is the inverse of the order of adjuncts in German, which are preverbal. If it turns out that the traditional account of right-adjunction is correct, the scope of the BC would have to be narrowed in to the projection of the A-structure and the functional extension of a lexical projection.
4.
So, scrambling by movement to the right is ruled out. The phenomena discussed under the heading 'Scrambling to the right' are better analyzed as the result of V movement to the left (cf. Haider 1997c; Mahajan 1997). Extraposition by movement to the right is ruled out by the same reason. In Haider (1994, 1997c), extraposition is analyzed in terms of V movement to the left. The type of V movement in these constructions is an instance of the kind of V movement found in head-initial lexical proj ections.
5.
Licensing in this context is to be understood as a structural relation of node-admissibility in the overt projection structure: For a given projection P with the head pO, the sister node of pO and the sister node of each intermediate projection of pO is subject to a directionality requirement. Depending on the parametrization, the head either precedes or follows the nodes to be licensed.
6.
If the verb is finite, this particle is stranded by V-to-C. Adjacent is but a descriptive character ization: The only elements that may intervene between the particle and the verb proper are elements of the inflectional morphology: The ge-prefix of the participial morphology and the zu-prefix of the infinitival morphology (cf. Hinterh61z1, this voL). These prefixes cannot be stranded.
7.
As noted by Den Dikken (1992: 38) and others (e.g. Fraser 1974; Svenonius 1992), particles in the medial or V-adjacent position cannot be modified (cf. b, d). In these positions particles are XO_ elements that combine with the verb. Only in the final position can a particle be treated as phrasal: a. Mike tossed me the wrench (right) up Mike tossed me (*right) up the wrench b. c. He threw the ball rightlstraight up/back/down He threw (*rightlstraight) up/back/down the ball d.
8.
Local scrambling, as in German, is assumed to be a VP-intemal phenomenon, whence the transparency for extraction. A detailed account of this approach in comparison to competing accounts is presented in Haider & Rosengren (1998).
9.
Since subjects remain in their VP-intemal position and since scrambling is confined to VP-intemal positions as well, neither extraction out of scrambled elements nor out of subjects
66
HUBERT HAIDER is affected by an opacity restriction that applies to Spec-positions.
10.
There seem to exist languages in which arguments precede the verb and the rest follows, for instance Bambara (cf. Diallo 1 987). However, this does not contradict the claim just made. These languages are VO languages in which all arguments, not only the subject, are moved to functional Spec-positions overtly. Non-arguments remain in their VP-internal positions.
11.
Movement of an AuxP rather than the auxiliary itself would not help, since the auxiliary would be confined to the moved phrase. If it were allowed to move out, the ungrammatical German patterns discussed above would reappear.
12.
In languages with dominant order VSO, an inflected auxiliary always precedes the main verb. In languages with dominant order SOV, an inflected auxiliary always follows the main verb (Greenberg 1963).
13.
A systematic exception is the so-called IPP construction (infinitive instead of participle) with modals, some perception verbs, and the causative verb lassen (= let, make): (i) daB er es nicht lesen gekonnt hat that he it not read can has 'that he has not been able to read it' (ii) daB er es nicht hat lesen konnen Normally, the finite verb occurs at the left side of the verb cluster or in some cases even further to the left. But it is not ungrammatical if it it just changes place with the modal, i.e. in the order lesen hat konnen (see below in the text; see also Hinterholzl, this volume).
14.
The time-slot hypothesis (Kayne 1994: 37) does not provide the independent empirical motivation that is necessary for the breaking of symmetry in his system. This hypothesis is itself in urgent need of empirical justification.
References Chomsky, Noam. 1995 . The Minimalist Program. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Dikken, Marcel den. 1992. Particles. Leiden: Holland Institute of Generative Linguistics. Diallo, Mohamed L. 1987. Zur Verbalstruktur und Syntax des Bambara. Ph.D. dissertation, Universitat Bayreuth. Fraser, Bruce. 1974. The Verb-Particle Combination in English. Tokyo: Taishukan. Greenberg, Joseph. 1963. "Some universals of grammar with particular reference to the order of meaningful elements." In Joseph Greenberg (ed.), Universals ofLanguage. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 73-1 1 3 Haider, Hubert. 1992. "Branching & discharge." In Working Papers of the Sonderfor schungsbereich 340 (Universities of Stuttgart and Tlibingen) 23, 1-3 1 . (In press in Peter Coopmans & Martin Everaert & Jane Grimshaw (eds), Lexical Specification and Insertion. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins. 1 35-164. Haider, Hubert. 1993. Deutsche Syntax Generativ. Tlibingen: Niemeyer. Haider, Hubert. 1994. "Detachment - the later, the deeper." Working Papers of the Sonderforschungsbereich 340 (Universities of Stuttgart and Tlibingen) # 4 1 . Haider, Hubert. 1997a. "Precedence among predicates." The Journal of Comparative Germanic Linguistics 1, 3-4 1 .
OV IS MORE BASIC THAN VO
67
Haider, Hubert. 1997b. "Projective economy. On the minimal functional structure of the German clause." In Abraham, Werner & EUy van Gelderen (eds), German: Syntactic problems problematic syntax. Tlibingen: Niemeyer. 83-103 . Haider, Hubert. 1997c. "Extraposition." In Beerman, Dorothee, David LeBlanc & Henk van Riemsdijk (eds), RightwardMovement. Amsterdam: John Benjamins [Linguistics Today 17]. l I S-lS I . Haider, Hubert and Rosengren, Inger. 1998. "Scrambling." Sprache & Pragmatic #49. Lund University. Kayne, Richard. 1983. "Connectedness." Linguistic Inquiry 14: 223-249. Kayne, Richard. 1994. The Antisymmetry of Syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Kayne, Richard. 1998. "Overt vs. covert movement." Syntax 1: 219-19I. Larson, Richard. 1988. "On the double object construction." Linguistic Inquiry 19: 335-39 I. Mahajan, Anoop. 1997. "Against a rightward movement analysis of extraposition and rightward scrambling in Hindi." In Tonoike, Shigeo. (ed.), Scrambling. Tokio [Linguistics Workshop Series #5]. 93-124. Quirk, Randolph, Greenbaum, Sidney, Leech, Geoffrey & Svartvik, Jan 1986. A Compre hensive Grammar of the English Language. London: Longman. Svenonius, Peter. 1992. "Movement of pO in the English verb-particle construction." In Black, Andrew & James McCloskey (eds.), Syntax at Santa Cruz, vol. 1 . Santa Cruz: Syntax Research Center, UCSc. 93-1 13. Zwart, Jan-Wouter. 1993 . Dutch Syntax. A minimalist approach. Ph.D. dissertation, Groningen University.
Remnant Movement Liliane Haegeman University of Lille III
Abstract This paper focuses on the derivation of the verb-final pattern in the West Germanic OV languages. The paper concentrates entirely on West Flemish. An antisymmetric approach which assumes short V-movement or no V-movement at all is compared with more recent antisymmetric approaches which postulate both V-to-I movement and remnant XP-movement. I will show that an analysis which postulates absence of V-to-I movement and one-by-one leftward feature driven movement of the V-complements seems to entail a number of funda mental syntactic differences between the West Germanic OV languages on the one hand and the Scandinavian languages, English and the Romance languages on the other hand. These differences have to be stipulated. The analysis elaborated below is in line with Kayne's ( 1994) LeA. I propose that the West Germanic OV order be derived by (i) morphology-driven V-movement to a functional head and (ii) remnant movement of the extended projection of V. This analysis brings the West Germanic OV languages in line with the other languages examined.
1.
Introduction: Antisymmetry and OV order
Embedded clauses in the West Gennanic OV languages such as Dutch, Gennan, and West Flemish (WF), the language focussed on here, have a surface verb-final pattern, as illustrated in WF ( 1 a). (1)
a.
da Valere nen hoek no Gent stiert that Valere a book to Ghent sends 'that Valere sends a book to Ghent'
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
70
In universal base approaches based on Zwart ( 1 993), it is assumed that the com plement-verb order is derived by one-by-one feature-driven leftward movement of the complements of the verb. For instance, in ( 1 a) the indefinite direct object nen boek ('a book' ) moves to SpecAgrOP; the predicate PP no Gent ('to Ghent' ) moves to SpecPredP (Hinterh61zl 1 999; Koster 1 994; Zwart 1 993). Since the finite verb follows the object in SpecAgrOP and the constituent in SpecPredP, the sentence-final position of the verb is taken to be relatively low. Either the verb remains in its base position ( 1 b), or it moves to a low functional head, such as Pred, for instance, in terms of Koster's ( 1 994) analysis ( l c). (1)
b. c.
da [IP Val. [IO] [AgrOP nen boeko [PredP no Gentpp [yp [vo stiert] to tpp]]]] da [IP Val. [IO] [AgrOP nen boeko [PredP no Gentpp [PredO stiert] [vp [vo tv] to tpp]]]]
The consensus is then that the West Germanic OV languages do not display morphology-driven V-to-I movement in the sense of Pollock ( 1 989) and later work. While in Haegeman ( 1 998a, 1 998b) I myself did argue for morphology driven finite V-movement to T and to Neg in WF I continued to assume that the landing site of V was not the 'traditional' high T-head, but rather a second, lower T-head. I will reconsider this analysis below. The present paper re-evaluates the antisymmetric approach illustrated in ( lb-c) in comparative terms. I concentrate on WF but I assume that the analysis carries over to the other West Germanic OV languages. I will show that an analysis which postulates absence of V-to-I movement and one-by-one leftward feature-driven movement of the V-complements implies a number of fundamental syntactic differences between the West Germanic OV languages on the one hand and the Scandinavian languages, English and the Romance languages on the other hand. These differences have to be stipulated. The analysis elaborated below is in line with Kayne's ( 1 994) LeA and parallel to Pearson's analysis (this volume). I propose that the West Germanic OV order be derived by (i) morphol ogy-driven V-movement to a functional head and (ii) remnant movement of the extended projection of V. As we will see, this analysis brings the West Germanic OV languages in line with the other languages examined. The paper is organised as follows. Section 2 summarises a set of problems raised for the analysis outlined above in the light of comparative syntax. These problems have been signalled in the literature. Section 3 introduces a set of additional problems concerning the (comparative) syntax of negation. Section 4 provides an alternative analysis which derives OV orders in terms of double movement. Section 5 shows that the problems raised in Section 2 are solved by ,
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
71
this analysis. Section 6 briefly examines another implementation o f the anti symmetry approach elaborated by Zwart (1 996). The major problem with this analysis concerns the syntax of infinitival clauses. Section 7 is a brief conclusion to the paper.
2.
Problems with the analysis
This section will show that the analysis with short or no V-movement and one by-one fronting of the complements of V gives rise to paradoxes for a compara tive approach to syntax. Two broad areas will be considered: constructions involving argument positions and constructions involving sentential negation. 2. 1
V-morphology and V-to-/
Based mainly on comparative data drawn, among other places, from the German ic VO languages and from the diachronic development of English, it is generally assumed that there is a correlation between V-movement and inflectional morphology (Roberts 1 985; Pollock 1 989; Rohrbacher 1 994; Holmberg & Platzack 1 995; Vikner 1 997; Ackema 1 999; etc.). The West Germanic OV languages Dutch, German and their dialects, have a fair amount of overt inflectional morphology, which would lead one to expect V-to-I movement (see B obaljik & Thrainsson 1 997: 66; Vikner 1 997: 1 92). Based on the agreement morphology of the relevant languages, Kayne ( 1 994) himself suggests that V-to-I movement must be assumed for the West Germanic OV languages: Since German and Dutch show person agreement, it would follow that in those languages, too, V raises to AgrS . . . . this raising must be thought of as leftward, just as for Icelandic, French, and Italian. The specificity of German and Dutch lies in their requiring most of their complements to move leftward past V. Since the finite V in German and Dutch must raise to AgrS, by the preceding argument, I am led to conclude that in those languages the leftward-moved complements must end up to the left of the AgrS position. (Kayne 1994: 52) Concerning the derivation of the embedded OV order Kayne adds: That leftward movement of complements in German and Dutch does not simply take place within the V projection is reinforced by two observations. First, when the verb is infinitival, the complements must precede not only it but also the infinitival marker zulte, which I take to be heading a separate projection, as with English to. Second, the leftward moved complements in
72
LILIANE HAEGEMAN West Flemish precede not only the verb but also the preverbal negative clitic, which is almost certainly as high as NegP. (Kayne 1994: 52)
While Kayne himself advocates V-to-I movement, this is not the position adopted in Zwart (1993) and those following his approach. As mentioned, if V is taken to move overtly at all, it is taken to move to PredO (cf Koster 1 994) and no link is established between the overt movement of the verb and its morphology. In antisymmetric approaches there also seems to be a tacit agreement that sentence final finite verbs occupy the same position as infinitives. The fact that infinitival morphology is poorer than the finite morphology is not taken into consideration. 2.2 Diesing 's generalisation: syntax and interpretation of indefinite objects A second problem for the antisymmetric approaches to the West Germanic OV order concerns DiesiIlg's generalisation, which postulates a correlation between i a.! �10 ���e aIlc! ,VP-inteJ:n.Cl.1 positiQns. In the more traditional OV ap i , , " ,�� �,!�12� proaches, indefinite pre-verbal objects such as nen boek in ( 1 a) were taken to occupy their VP-internal base positiop"s , ,!() t.l1� left of the verb. Such an analysis ' was in line with Diesing; s scope-related analysi� o{ihe distribution of object DPs ( 1992, 1 996, 1 997). On the basis of German data such as those in (2), Diesing proposed that indefinite objects with existential readings relIl,aip withill yg ,' where they are suojecfto e'-xisteiiiliil closure. '
(2)
a.
weil Elly immer Lieder singt
, . ._,.
(Diesing 1 996: 5)
since Elly always songs sings 'since Elly always sings songs' b.
weil Elly Lieder immer singt since Elly songs always sings 'since Elly always sings songs'
In (2a) indefinite Lieder ('songs' ) is VP-internal and receives an existential reading. In (2b), it has moved out of the VP (hence it precedes the adverbial immer ('always'» and it receives a strong reading. 1 See also de Hoop 1992. In Diesing's approach, the distribution of indefinite object DPs in the West Germanic OV languages was analogous to that in Scandinavian. For reasons of space I will not elaborate the data here, and refer the reader to Diesing's own discussions. Diesing's analysis also accounts for the asymmetries in was for extraction illustrated in (3). In a GB approach, extraction from the object DP in the VP-internal base position is grammatical (3a); extraction from the object in a moved position (3b) is interpreted as an ECP-viohitioll.
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER (3)
a.
73
Wasi hat Otto immer [yp [ti flir Bucher] gelesen ?]
what has Otto always for books read 'What kind of books did Otto always read?'
b. *Wasi hat Otto [ti flir Bucher] immer [yp [t] gelesen ?] (Diesing 1 992: 1 1 8-1 20) According to the antisymmetric view the object in OV languages always moves to SpecAgrOP to check its accusative case (den Dikken 1 996; Van den Wyn gaerd 1 989; Zwart 1 993, 1 996). It is hence not possible to make the leftward movement of the object dependent on features such as [±specific] . This means that the distribution of the indefinite object in the West Germanic OV languages would have to differ substantively from the Scandinavian patterns discussed by Diesing, where movement to SpecAgrOP forces a strong reading, as also expressed by the following citation from Hinterh61zl: nominal complements of the verb always have to leave the VP before Spell-out (independently of whether they are definite or indefinite) and are licensed in functional projections (HinterhOlzl 1999: Ch. 4, p. 42; this volume, p. 304).
There is, of course, a solution to this problem but one that is unsatisfactory in that it creates further problems for Germanic comparative syntax. If all nominal complements move leftward in OV languages, we might restate Diesing's generalisation in terms of the degree of leftward movement and propose that existential indefinites move somewhat less than strong indefinites. The asymme try in the was flir extraction data would then also have to be accounted for in terms of the 4egree of movement of the object. This solution is not satisfactory because it leacis to new problems with respect to the syntax of the Germanic VO languages. ()ne w0l..lld have to assllllle that either indefinite object,s.,�!th. existen tial readings" do" not move ln Scandinavian, or else tlieY UIldergo . similar short movement. . In the" former option, the syntax �f S'candi�a�ian indefirrlte objects �wouId'-remain different from its West Germanic counterpart, an unexpected result. In the latter case, the syntax of indefinites in Scandinavian would receive the same analysis as that in West Germanic, but the postverbal position of Scandinavian existential indefinites will imply that the verb itself must now be taken to move leftward. This conclusion again would lead to a number of modifications in our assumptions concerning the grammar of the Scandinavian languages. In particular, the question would arise as to the trigger of V-move ment. (But see Hr6arsd6ttir 1 999, this volume for a different analysis.) The analysis below will allow us to maintain Diesing's generalisation in full and to assume that the syntax of the Scandinavian indefinite object is identical
74
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
to that of its West Germanic counterpart, i.e. the existential indefinite object remains VP-internal. 2.3 Holmberg 's generalisation The syntactic operation responsible for the movement of the object out of the VP in ( 1 a) is generally taken to be object shift (Van den Wyngaerd 1989), which is also at the basis of the leftward object movement in the Scandinavian languages. For the latter, object shift tends to be correlated to V-movement (Holmberg 1986: 176, Chomsky 1 993: 1 8, Zwart 1996: 237-243) . Zwart ( 1996) reformulates the generalisation as in (4): (4)
Holmberg's generalisation Object shift of an element ex from the complement position of a verb 13 to the specifier position of 'Y, the AgrOP associated with 13, is possible only if 13 moves to the head of 'Y (Zwart 1 996: 238)
An approach i� which tll,ere jS )1Q , Qr yepj )J�stricte.d. �Y�to�I movelIlel1t in the , . Germanic OV· langu �ges implie s. that Holmberg's , ��p�<:I,:: �iiii!l�!i�,(1I',�2��_" l1�t apply. Even if 'one ' nllglii 'argi:i�tlha.r'·B15jeCt 'shift' {s licensed by V-to-Ag�O movement, as represented in (5), this would not solve the problem. (5)
da [IP Valere [IO] [AgrOP nen boeko [AgrO kuopt] [yp [vo tv to]]] that
Valere
a
book
buys
First of all, as shown in ( 1b-c) which contain pre-verbal predicates, V-movement cannot have reached AgrO, since this would mean V has to precede the predi cate, contrary to fact. (1)
d. *da [IP Valere [IO] [AgrOP nen boeko [AgrO stiert] [PredP no Gentpp [Pred tv] [yp[vo ly [to tpp]]]]
Moreover, ultimately, the verb would have to move to the left of AgrO, i.e. it should cross the direct object. 2 2.4 Transitive expletive constructions The availability of tr�nsitive expletive cOllstructiol1� (TEC) illust�at�.
��� �,�el1, correlated to" V-to�rm6vemen((Bobaljlk & Jonas 'ig'§'(j;' Jon�s i99'6).
75
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
(6)
dan der drie studenten nen hoek no Gent gestierd een
that there three students a book to Ghent sent 'that three students have sent a book to Ghent'
have
Again, this raises problems for an approach in which very short or no V-move ment is assumed because the availability of TEC has to be dissociated from V-to-I movement. This would create another unexpected contrast between the Scandinavian TEC and that in the West Germanic OV languages. 2.5 The syntax of negation In the Germanic OV languages, as well as in the Scandinavian VO languages, negative quantifiers such as WF niets ( ,nothing'), obligatorily undergo feature driven leftward movement (Haegeman & Zanuttini 1 99 1 , 1 996; Haegeman 1995 ; Watanabe 1 998; Svenonius this volume; for German see Hamann 1 993; Zins meister 1 995; for Norwegian see Christensen 1986; Hoekstra 1 995: 123 ; Zins meister 1 995; Kayne 1 998; for Danish see Zinsmeister 1 995: 39-40; for Icelandic see Jonsson 1 996: 86). WF is illustrated in (7). (7)
a. b. c.
da Valere van niets
(nie) ketent
was
that Valere of nothing not contented was 'that Valere was not pleased with anything'
da Valere (nie) ketent van niets was (*NC , OK with DN reading)
da Valere (nie) ketent was van niets (*NC, OK with DN reading)
WF negative sentences may also contain a negative head, en-, whose distribution is subject to a number of restrictions. One constraint is that the negative head en is compatible with finite verbs and not with infinitives. (7)
d. e.
da Valere van niets
ketent
mee Valere van niets
ketent
en-was
that Valere of nothing contented EN-was
(*en) te (*en) zyn
with Valere of nothing contented (*EN) to (*EN) be 'because Valere was not pleased with anything. '
In Haegeman ( l998a, 1 998b) I interpret this finite/non-finite asymmetry to mean that the negative head en- is cl�p�ndent on or gives rise to V-lllovel11ent. I propose that finite . ver� s IIlOve higller than infinitives, and the neg�tive ' hea� is . . licensed in the-i��dlii.g site of finite verbs', which is inaccessible to Infinitives. _
76
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
The WF IPP construction offers evidence that the negative head en- on the verb triggers overt V-movement. In (8), the finite verb without en- may remain to the right of the IPP complement while that with en- must move leftward (Haegeman 1 998a, 1 998b). (8)
a. b.
da Valere nie willen dienen hoek kuopen (*en)-eet
that Valere not want that book buy EN-has 'that Valere has not wanted to buy that book'
da Valere nie (en)-ee willen dienen hoek kuopen3
If V-movement in (8b) is induced by a checking requirement of the negative affix en-, then it seems plausible that it targets a head carrying the Neg feature. However, in anti symmetric terms, this conclusion leads to a paradox (see Haegeman 1 995 for a first discussion). (i) The leftward Neg movement of the negative constituent van niets in (7a) targets the specifier of a head with the Neg feature. (ii) V-movement in (8b) is also assumed to be triggered by a negative head feature. Yet the negative constituent and the en-affixed verb need not be adjacent, as shown by (9). (9)
da Valere niets
mee no Gent (f!JJ -stiert
that Valere nothing more to Ghent (EN) sends 'that Valere doesn't send anything to Ghent any more'
One solution would be to propose that the Neg feature which checks the negative quantifier is not situated on the functional head which hosts en-. More precisely, a Neg feature on a lower head, Neg2, would be spelt out by the morpheme en-, while leftward Neg movement of negative quantifiers would target a Neg feature on a higher functional head, Neg l . Below we will see that the particular hierarchy would be problematic. In Haegeman ( l998a, 1 998b) I have shown that the distribution of the verb in the IPP pattern is also determined by inflectional properties. This is illustrated in (8c-f). (8)
c.
da Valere willen dienen hoek kuopen eet/*oat
d.
da Valere oaf!ee
e.
that Valere want that book buy has/*had 'that Valere has wanted to buy that book'
willen dienen hoek kuopen
that Valere hadl?has want that book buy 'that Valere hadl?has wanted to buy that book'
Dienen hoek willen kuopen een was en misse.
have was a mistake that book want buy 'It was a mistake to have wanted to buy that book.'
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
f.
77
* Dienen boek een willen kuopen was en misse.
(8c) and (8d) show that in the absence of the negative affix en-, the present tense auxiliary remains preferably to the right of the IPP complement, while the past tense form must move leftward. The infinitival form of the auxiliary cannot 'lnc)'ve-firtlie"left eottn'{tI:Pp-'constrliCtion (8e, f). Since infinitives do not move to the left of the IPP complement, and since the negative affix en- is licensed to the left of the complement (8a-b), en- is incompatible with infinitives: (8)
g.
Dienen boek nie willen kuopen (*en-)een was en misse.
that book not want buy (*EN) have was a mistake. 'It was a mistake not to have wanted to buy that book.'
Based on the data in (8) I assumed in my earlier work (Haegeman 1 998a, 1998b) that the head which hosts en- is dominated by TP, a projection whose head attracts the tensed verb. Following this view, the WF clause would have the following partial hierarchy: (10)
AgrSP > NegPI
niets
>
AgrOP
>
PredP
>
TP2
>
NegP2
en
Though ( 10) derives the non-adjacency of the negative head en- and the moved negative quantifiers, we will see in the next section that this analysis is undesir able because it leads to an unexplained contrast with the hierarchy of negative projections postulated in work on Romance by Zanuttini ( 1 997a, 1 997b).
3.
The syntax of negation
3 . 1 Two domains for negation in Romance Based on an extensive comparative study of a wide range of Romance languages and their dialects, Zanuttini ( 1997a, 1997b) proposes that the expression of sentential negation is not confined to a unique NegP. Rather, she proposes that at least two domains expressing negation should be distinguished: (i) what she calls the preverbal negation, typically associated with the negative morpheme, (ii) the post-verbal domain for negation, associated among others with post-verbal negative adverbs. Zanuttini proposes a partial clausal hierarchy as in ( l I a). (Ub) and ( l I c) illustrate the corresponding fillers for the positions in French and in Piedmontese respectively.
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
78
(11)
a. b. c.
Fr. Pied.
AgrSP TPI NegPl TP2 NegP2 AspP
pas-ne pa
nen
not
not
plus pi nen
AspP
to ujours sempre
no more always
In French, the head of NegP1 is realised by ne, its specifier is realised by pas. In Piedmontese, on the other hand, SpecNegP1 is only realised by pa when the negation is presuppositional (see Zanuttini's discussion for details). Non-presup positional negation is expressed by the negative marker nen, which occupies SpecNegP2. Aspectual negative adverbs such as French plus ('no more') and Piedmontese pi nen ('no more') are associated with a lower AspP. 3.2 WF en- and French ne Zanuttini proposes that French ne is a clitic which undergoes leftward movement to a c-commanding functional head, which I re-label T. For reasons of space I cannot elaborate this point here, and I refer to Haegeman ( 1 999). In finite clauses, the inflected V moves to T. Consequently, ne ends up on the finite V. Infinitival lexical V s do not move to T; they remain in a lower functional head, and ne is stranded in T. Infinitival auxiliaries may move to T, and hence ne may head-adjoin to the infinitival auxiliary. (12)
TP
a.
I
T'
�
T
�
ne-
T (Vfin-T)
NegP
�
Spec
I
Neg'
�
pas Neg b. c. d.
t
Jean ne mange
pas
ne
pas
n 'avoir
pas
Jean NE eats NE
NE have.INF
not
not not
FP
------de chocolat
of chocolate
manger de chocolat eat.INF
of chocolate
mange de chocolat eaten of chocolate
Zanuttini assumes that the relevant TP and NegP occupy a high position in the clausal domain.
79
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
The WF negative element en- shares some of the properties of a negative head like French ne or Italian non (see Haegeman 1995, 1 999 for arguments). On closer inspection, and based on Zanuttini's (1997a, 1997b) criteria, WF en- is more like French ne than like Italian non. (i) Whereas the Italian negative head non can negate a clause alone, French ne and WF en- cannot do so. They need to be accompanied by another negation marker. ( 1 3)
a.
Non l'ho
b.
Je ne l 'ai
c.
K'en-een hem *(nie) gezien.
visto.
NON him.have-l sG seen 'I haven't seen him. ' I NE him.have I EN-have him
*(pas) vu.
not seen
not seen
(ii) Unlike the case in Italian ( 14a), the occurrence ()f .�ren<;h . ne (141:» .aIld WY " en- (14c) is not related to the pre�-oi�post:verbarp��iti �;; -�f" th� n:�g ative indefinite. _
.
..
(14)
.
a.
Nessuno (*non) e venuto.
b.
Personne n ' est venu.
c.
Niemand en-eet er
no one NON is come 'No one has come. '
no one
no one
NE is come
.
*(Non) e venuto nessuno. II n ' est venu personne. It NE is come no one
da gezien.
EN-has there that seen
T-en-eet da niemand gezien.
it-EN-has that no one seen 'No one has seen that.'
I will assume then that WF en- is like French ne in that it heads a negative projection, NegP, which is dominated by TP. Like French ne, WF en- is a clitic and must left-adjoin to a c-commanding head. Unlike French ne, WF en- also need,s to be adjoined to a V-head. On the basis of the distribution oftensecl"verbs In - the WF IPP constructIon (8c-d) and on the basis of the finite/non-finite asymmetry in the distribution of en- (8a-b), I assume that finite verbs in WF may move to T. Past tense verbs move obligatorily (8c), present tense verbs optionally (8cld). Infinitives on the other hand do not move to T but remain in a head position lower than Neg (8e-t) As a result,_'Yf'. �.�- is r��trj�!t3d W finite clauses (8g) (in Haegeman 1 998a, 1 998b I offer a slightly different analysis).
80
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
(15)
TP
a.
I
T'
�
T
�
NegP
�
T Spec Vfin-T
en
Neg'
�
N g b. c.
en
[PAST]
werkte
;
* en
T
werken
[infinitive]
Recall from Section 2.5 that I postulated that the projection TP and NegP in (10) were relatively low in the clausal domain. 3.3 Neg movement and negative adverbials Zanuttini proposes that NegPl , associated with the negative head in Romance, c-commands a lower domain in which are found negative adverbials and negation markers. Such negative markers and adverbials are interspersed among aspectual and temporal adverbs. Piedmontese, for instance, displays the sequence in ( 1 6). ( 1 6)
pa gia
nen pi nen
sempre tut
not already not no more always everything
Recall from the discussion of ( 10), that adopting an antisymmetric analysis like that in Zwart ( 1 993), I assumed that the WF negative head en- was associated with a low TPlNegP2, which is dominated by a higher NegPl . NegPI was the projection associated with the obligatory leftward movement of negative quanti fiers and it was also taken to be the domain in which are found negative adverbials such as nie meer ( 'no more' ) and the negative marker niet. (17)
da Valere a
nie meer atent
no Gent en-goat
NegPI NegP2 that Valere already no more always to Ghent EN-goes
However, the WF negative adverbials and negation markers have the same distri bution with respect to temporal and aspectual adverbials as their Piedmontese
81
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
counterparts. Observe, for instance, the similarity in the relative order of post verbal elements in Piedmontese ( 1 8a) with the negative and other adverbials in WF ( 1 8b). ( 1 8)
a.
A l 'ha
b.
da Valere nie atent
nen dine sempre tut.
he he-has NEN told always everything
alles
(Zanuttini 1 997b: 230)
en-zeidige
that Valere not always everything EN-said
As shown in (19), the ordering in Piedmontese ( 1 6) is parallel to that in WF
.
( 1 9)
a. b.
Piedmontese (pa) gia
WF
a
nen pi nen sempre tut nie nie meer atent alles
(not) already not no more always all
3 .4 The hierarchy of the negative domains The combination of the short V-movement analysis discussed in Section 1 with Zanuttini's ( 1 997 a, 1 997b) proposals for negation in Romance, which assumes two negative projections in the clausal domain (see (10) and (1 1 a)), would lead to the clausal hierarchies summarized schematically in (20). The Romance negative ne-V is associated with the head of the higher NegPI, while the -negative advetbials - associate with the domain of the lower NegP2. ·· The WF negative en-V would ' be ' associated with the head of the lower NegP2, and the negative adverbials associate with the higher NegP l . (20)
a.
ROM.
SU >
TP1 > NegPl > . . . NegP2 AspP Vfin pas ne nen pi nen
b.
WF
SU >
NegPl AspP
nie
nie meer
> TP2 > NegP2 > . . . Vfin en
This hypothesis is not satisfactory, in that it postulates an unexplained difference in the hierarchical organisation of the negative projections. The semantic correlates of the hypothesis are also undesirable: th� _ st:1:l?:f:lQ!iS,JEP99-Q]}$-8t-fu� ne�a,tiye_ ._p:roj�cti()Ils . Negg� .,.:wd NegP2 .become'-reversed. ,;inc,the · two -language �g91lp�. :Zanuttini sh�w-� that' in Romance NegPl is associated with what she calls -----·�' p�e��pp ositional negation, i.e. where the negation in fact reverses the presup posed positive polarity of the clause. As a matter of fact, WF en- in the lower Neg2, also expresses presuppositional negation (see Haegeman 1 999 for discus sion). Typically spelling out en- emphasises the polarity of the clause and contrasts it with a presupposed polarity. In some well-defined contexts, en- may ..
82
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
be even used without an accompanying negative constituent in which case it purely functions as a polarity reversing element. (21)
a. b.
Valere ee nog nie betoald vu zen gezette.
for his newspaper Valere has yet not paid 'Valere has not paid for his newspaper yet.'
J' en-doet.
he EN-does 'He has.'
Semantically then, the low WF NegP2 in (20b) would have to have the function of the high Romance NegPl in (20a). A further drawback of the hypothesis in (20) is that temporal and aspectual adverbs would also have rather different distributions in the two language groups. In Romance, they are c-commanded by the presuppositional negation; in Germanic they c-command the presuppositional NegP. Such oppositions go against current attempts to propose a uniform analysis of adverbial positions related to their semantics (Cinque 1 999). I consider the parametric variation in the hierarchical organisation of projections in (20) to be undesirable. It would be preferable to assume that such specialised projections correlate with some semantic property and have a universal hierarchy. To solve the paradoxes in the syntax of negative sentences, I continue to follow Zanuttini ( l997a, 1 997b) in postulating at least two NegPs in the clausal domain. One NegP is associated with negative markers and adverbials and a second NegP is associated with the negative head and relates to sentential polarity. The latter NegP could plausibly be relabelled PolP (Cormack & Smith 1998). I assume that the hierarchy of projections is that found in Romance (and in English cf. Cormack & Smith 1 998), with the polar NegP, NegP1 , c-com manding the adverbial NegP, NegP2. On the basis of the semantic functions associated with the two projections and following Zanuttini's analysis of the distribution of the temporal and aspectual adverbials, I propose that the WF IP displays the hierarchy in (22). (22)
TPI NegPl FP TP2 NegP2 AspP
polarity
en
adverbial
a
niet
AspP
nie meer atent
N�gP l,-, head�d , PY , gn:: . in , WE, is a, Polarity projectioJ;l. . ,It . is . dominated . . by a .'
fLJn�tjonal projectiQIl" .w,h.ose hea� �ttract� the fiI?te v�rb, let us continue to call r -it TP1': "A�" � fir�t app��ximaf1on� ('assume th"at 'TFf is 'the familiar 'Pollockian' TP. In the next section I will examine the word order in WF in terms of the structure in (22). FP is the projection whose head hosts the infinitival verb.
83
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
4.
Double movement and. OV ord.ers
4. 1 Overt V-to-/ movement I have shown (Haegeman 1 998a, 1 998b) that WF displays morphology-driven V-to-I-movement. The data in (8) above illustrate the patterns. The finiteinon finite asymmetry in the distribution of en- and in IPP constructions reflects the degree of movement. Past tense Vs and verbs with en- move to T l via F (8c-d). A present tense V without en- may remain in F, or it may move to T l (8c-d). An infinitive must remain in F (8e-g). Some degree of infinitival movement would not be unexpected since the WF infinitive is clearly morphologically identified by its -en ending. That the infinitive does not move as high as the pnite v:�r.!?.jrt ,�9-mparal?1�.J2 t1ie sI��Iati61i" �iri' 'prench- (p6116ck" 1989: 1997). A deiaii;d discussion of the s��tureis- f���((ln'Haegeinan (1998a, 1998b, 1999). As a result of the head-to-head movement of the verb, the head position of the VP, and all V-related head positions between VO and FO or TO (as the case may be) contain a trace of the moved V. My analysis is different from the . antisymmetric proposal discussed in Section 1 which assumes either very restricted V-movement or no V-movement at all and is in line with the analysis suggested by Kayne ( 1994) and by Pearson (this volume). 4.2 Deriving the West Germanic OV order Without further modifications, the hierarchy in (22) obviously derives the wrong word order. V moves to Tl ; en-, which heads NegP l , left-adjoins to T l ; negative, temporal and aspectual adverbials and negative quantifiers are associated with NegP2. Without additional movements, we expect to find the surface order in (23). But these examples are ungrammatical. The grammatical counterparts are given in (24). (23)
a. *da Valere en-komt a nie meer atent nor us that Valere EN-comes already no more always to house b. *da Valere en-goat a nie no Gent that Valere EN-goes already not to Ghent c. *mee Valere te kommen nie meer atent nor us with Valere to come no more always to home
(24)
a.
da Valere a
nie meer atent
nor us
en-komt
that Valere already no more always to house EN-comes 'that Valere already doesn't always come home any more.'
84
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
b.
da Valere a
c.
mee Valere nie meer atent
nie no Gent en-goat
that Valere already not to Ghent EN-goes 'that Valere is already not going to Ghent.'
nor us
te kommen
with Valere no more always to home to come 'as Valere does not always come home any more'
In order to derive the grammatical patterns in (24), we need to reorder all the constituents found to the right of the verb in (23) with respect to the verb, while preserving their relative order. Crucially, the reordering is. r�qull:�d, both,for firgte . that 'ill '��h�negative sentences as w�iC'" ye�lJs alJ.d for non-finite verbs:1:tecaii also the � ��piemetits' pre��de-ilie verb, again both in finite and non-finite clauses. (25)
a. b.
da Valere neu atent
nor us
komt
mee Valere neu atent
nor us
te kommen
that Valere now always to house comes 'that Valere now always comes home.'
with Valere now always to home to come 'as Valere now always comes home'
4.3 Remnant movement
In earlier antisymmetric analyses the reordering of the verb and its complements
was achieved by one-by-one movement of individual constituents, such as object DPs and small clause predicates. VP-complements such as the direct object and the small clause predicate which precede the finite verb in the West Germanic OV-Ianguages follow the finite V in Romance. Like Pearson ( 1999), I propose that the West Germanic OV order is not achieved by one-by-one feature-driven leftward movement of the individual constituents. Rather, thLQY�,,,,,Q!der is E�E��,�,g�1Jx,i!l,y;,!g;,.l;lJlQ.;�t, and by (lD",,!':�' ll111�t�Q.x�, m�p.t(cf. Mtille;T996) _QL�,£�1endedpmj ., �ctiQll-q,(""Y".m_�£�£.!!:t Further research into the relative positions of adjuncts and into the mechanisms that derive extraposition effects (see Haegeman 1998c) will be needed to determine precisely which constituent undergoes this remnant movement. I will provisionally label this projection XP. (26) is a schematic representation.
85
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
CP
(26)
�
Spec
C'
�
C
AgrSP
I
�
dat Spec
I
SU
AgrS'
�
AgrS
TP1
�
Spec
I
XP
T1'
�
T1
I
�
en-Vv Spec XP NegP2
niets
ten
�
I
tv
�
I
Neg2'
Neg2
Neg1'
Neg1
�
Spec
NegP1
VP
�
etc.
FP
�
Spec
F'
I
F
�
Tb,e." remnant movem�DCi�.jl1de12el:l,g�Ilt 9f th� m�v�l11ent. ()f V }0 l" 1 alld of the .. . v�i-b p�ese��'-oi�th�'����gative h���i " 'It t���" pi�ce" 'also!'"�h�� ' 'th�"\�fi�ti��(' "-'� ....-"" .-
,
j"�--I.�.:::-t ""'.r�."�h-"""-'";'-";.';::,\.'�h,J ''-��'''t,.t.>'_'''' ,_",,"\:-i';'�� <:�; p.:L-',:'..�...i?m-"-L:
'remains in the lower head F and it takes place in non-negative sentences. V-to-T1 movement is triggered obligatorily by overt past tense and by the presence of the negative head en-, it is triggered optionally with a present tense verb without en-. An obvious question is what triggers the movement of the remnant extended VP in West Germanic OV languages and how these languages differ from, say, Romance, in which no such movement is postulated here (but see Hr6arsd6ttir 1 999, this volume). At this point I can only speculate on this issue. One option would be to propose that the extended projection .Vp has a strong aspectual ,,i��tu.r� \Vhich must be checke(rin'"a"specifierl1ead";�f:ition"'-wltfTf:' The"'p'�·arnet. ric vaIlatlon in the remnant movement could be related to variation in strength of the aspectual features. Alternatively, following Pearson (1999) we may assume
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
86
that3E���,!E£Y�lP:�!lJ:. ofY, Q�!,gf J4�,.prQJ�yti21l:)g), ���()X�,s .tl1� .Y,J�.�WF�§,-9.t,Jh!s projection a� � makes the . fe, atllres of "'��'�"" s1! , lJi��t PP, - �(),P;!�!l�q , .witml�L it, . '-'-accessiole': IfiIiighfoe 'proposed thaf tlie subject DP is attracted by T (for case ---"assTgnmentfand pied-pipes the remnant project1on�'Fotre'asons 'orspace I cannot elaborate this propos��i1 Eere';T refer�-io-'' P��§§!f''(r?99) for discussion. In negative sentences, the negative affix en- clitiCizes to the finite V in T. As before, following Pearson ( 1 999) we may propose that the negative features of constituents contained in the lower NegP2 become accessible for Neg1 as a result of the extraction of V. The lower projection NegP2, which is contained in the moved remnant, attains a specifier head relation with en- as a result of the remnant movement. It is not clear whether the remnant movement should proceed via SpecNegP1 , or whether the specifier head relation can be established with the surface position of en-. 5.
Consequences of the analysis
The double movement analysis of the West Germanic OV orders has conse quences in other areas in Germanic syntax. In particular, it solves the undesirable aspects of the earlier antisymmetric approach developed in Section 2. 5. 1 V-movement My analysis postulates V-to-I movement in the West Germanic OV languages. This is in line with the observed overt verbal morphology as discussed in the literature. There is an asymmetry between finite and non-finite verbs in that the former move to T 1 , while the latter remain in a lower head, F. This asymmetry accounts for the finite/non-finite asymmetry in the realisation of the negative head en-. 5.2 Object shift and specificity, Diesing 's generalisation The implementation of the antisymmetry approach discussed in Sections 1 and 2 implied abandoning Diesing's generalisation. In the double movement analysis of OV orders elaborated here it can be maintained. In (2a), diagrammed here as (27a), singt has moved to T1 and the bracketed remnant projection XP has moved to the left of V. It may well be the case that the indefinite object Lieder has remained VP-intemal. In (2b), analysed as (27b), the distribution of the object w.r.t. the adverbial immer shows it must have moved out of the VP.
87
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
(27)
a. b.
wei! Elly [xp immer [yp 1y Lieder]] singt �p wei! Elly [xp Liedero immer [yp 1y to]] singt �p
5.3 Object shift and V-movement: Holmberg 's generalisation To the extent that V-movement and object shift correlate quite systematically in the Scandinavian languages (cf. 2.3), antisymmetric proposals without V-to-I movement and with generalised object shift in the West Germanic languages were forced to abandon the view that object shift systematically correlates with V-movement. Even if we do not need to postulate generalised object movement to derive the order in (27 a), we have to maintain the view that objects may undergo leftward movement to derive (27b), in which a direct object precedes a duration adjunct. Similarly, the following WF example is taken to illustrate object shift: (28)
da Valere dienen boek nog niet kent that Valere that
book yet not knows
Since we assume generalised V-to-I movement, the object shift data are in line with Holmberg's generalisation. 5.4 TEe
It has also been proposed that transitive expletive constructions illustrated in (6) and repeated here as (29) correlate with V-movement (Bobaljik & Jonas 1 996; Jonas 1 996). (29)
dan der drie studenten nen boek no Gent gestierd een that there three students a book to Ghent sent 'that three students have sent a book to Ghent'
have
In the double movement analysis, the correlation between TEes and V-move ment can be maintained. 4 5.5 Hinterh6lzl$ analysis of VR as remnant movement
In antisymmetric approaches (den Dikken 1 996), Verb Raising structures like that in (30) were derived by leftward extraction of the constituents from the infini tival domain. In (30), both the direct object het boek ('the book') and the adjunct lang move from the domain of lezen (,read' ) into the matrix domain.
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
88 (30)
dat Jan het hoek lang wi!
lezen
that Jan the book long wants read 'that Jan wants to read the book for a long time'
Hinterh61z1 (1 999) rejects the one-by-one movement of the embedded constitu ents and proposes a remnant analysis of VR-patterns. while the infinitive [lezen, lh] may stay in the embedded clause everything else, namely the arguments of the embedded verb and the adverb modifying it, must move into the matrix clause . . .We have argued that this movement cannot be scrambling of the individual constituents . . . . It is thus natural to assume that adverbs end up in the domain of the matrix clause by being pied-piped by the movement of a larger constituent. . . movement of this larger constituent is to a position below all matrix adverbs . . . We thus propose that the embedded FIP, that is essentially the VP plus the potentially empty infinitival marker, is moved into [Spec, CP] of the infinitival after which process the remaining TP of the embedded clause is moved into SpecPredP of the matrix verb (1999, Ch. 4, 57-58).
Hinterholzl's analysis of VR is in line with my own proposal for a remnant movement analysis of OV orders in that the remnant movement which derives VR patterns will be similar to (if not identical to) the remnant movement required for deriving OV orders in general. 5.6 Summary
In Table 1 I list the problems raised for the original antisymmetric approaches to the OV order, which postulated that there is no V-to-I movement and that verbal Table 1. Survey ofproblems (i) Analysis
No V-movement One by one XP movement
Double movement
Problem Morphology and V-movement
Remains
Solved
Finite/non-finite asymmetry in V-movement
Solved ( 'short' V-movement)
Solved
Diesing's generalisation
Remains
Solved
Holmberg's generalisation
Remains
Solved
Transitive expletives
Remains
Solved
PolP > XP
Remains
Solved
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
89
complements move individually to a pre-verbal position. With respect to the problems raised by sentential negation, the non-adjacency of a preposed negative constituent and the negative head as such can be solved if one postulates two NegPs; the remaining problem concerns the hierarchical relation between these NegPIlPolP and NegP2. Various implementations are possible here but for reasons of space I will not develop them. See Haegeman 1999.
6.
An alternative antisymmetric account: Zwart's (1996) F-feature movement analysis
6 . 1 Introduction Zwart's (1996) analysis of the embedded V-final position captures the V-to-I movement effects without postulating overt V-movement to a high inflectional position. Following Minimalist traditions (Chomsky 1995), lexical items are taken to be bundles of features of two types: lexical-categorial features (LC-fea tures) and formal features (F-features). Formal features are involved in feature checking operations (tense, agreement, Case, wh, etc. see Zwart 1 996: 170). To account for the sentence-final position of the verb while attaining the movement effects, Zwart proposes that in both main and embedded finite clauses, the V-features of AgrS are strong and attract the F-features of the verb. The F-features of the verb move successive cyclically via AgrO and T to AgrS. In embedded finite clauses, AgrS, with the F-features of the verb, moves to C. As C is lexically filled, the F-features of the verb can be united with the LC-features of the complementizer and there is no need for movement of the LC-features of the verb to C. As a result the verb is spelled out in V (see Zwart 1996: 244). Zwart's 1996 proposal thus achieves the effects of V-movement without overt reflex. As a result, it overcomes some of the problems encountered by other anti symmetric views. However, the analysis has a number of drawbacks compared to the double movement analysis. The major issue that needs clarifying in this approach is to what extent the movement of F-features proposed for finite verbs extends to infinitivals. Zwart himself does not address the issue, but it is crucial in the light of the discussion here. I will therefore attempt to sketch an analysis in the spirit of Zwart's own proposal and point out its drawbacks. The absence of a root/embedded asymmetry in infinitivals might be taken to mean that there is no F-feature movement. However, infinitival clauses exhibit object shift and TEC. To maintain the correlation between V-movement on the one hand and object shift or TECs on the other, F-feature movement therefore
90
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
has to generalise to infinitives. Let us try to implement this idea. If F-features may move separately from the LC features of the verb as long as they can be spelt out in association with LC-features, we might propose that whenever the infinitival complementiser is overt, the F-features of the infinitival verb can be spelt out by associating with the LC-features of the complementiser while the LC-features of the verb remain stranded. This applies straightforwardly to examples like WF (3 1 a) in which van might be said to realise the embedded C: a.
(3 1 )
Jan ee beloofd
[van dienen boek te lezen] .
Jan has promised [of this book to read] 'Jan has promised to read this book.'
One problem with an F-feature analysis for infinitives is that it is not obvious how to analyse the position of te in such an approach. If te is a functional head of the I-system (cf. Kayne 1 994; Haegeman 1996b, 1 998a, 1 998b) and if the F-features of V always move to C, then F-feature movement will have to be able to skip or strand teo This movement would seem to lead to a violation of the Head Move ment Constraint or its Minimalist equivalent (cf. Zwart 1996: 203, note 1 0). In WF it is not necessary to spell out the complementiser in complement clauses of beloven. This means that no LC-features are available in the embedded C. This in tum might be taken to imply that the conditions for stranding the LC features of the verb are not met and that pied-piping is required, contrary to fact. ,
(3 1 )
b.
Jan ee beloofd
[dienen boek te lezen].
Jan has promised that
book to read
To solve this problem, one might argue5 that the F-features of infinitival lezen move into the matrix domain and associate with the LC-features of the matrix V, giving rise to some form of reanalysis. However, if IPP is an indicator of reanalysis, the absence of the IPP effect in (3 1a-b) suggests there is no reanaly sis (cf. Haegeman 1998b). Further support for the absence of reanalysis is that WF disallows the so-called third construction which involves long distance scrambling of a constituent out of complement clauses as that in (3 1 c) (cf. den Besten and Rutten 1989; Rutten 199 1 on the Dutch third construction). (3 1 )
c. *Jan ee dienen boek beloofd te lezen. Jan has that book promised to read
It is not clear then how the F-features of the complement of beloofd in (3 1b) can be lexicalised without pied-piping the LC-features. A similar question is raised by examples of so-called VP-topicalisation, illustrated in (3 1 d), in which an extended projection of an infinitival V is fronted.
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
91
For arguments that the fronting involves more than VP see Haegeman 1 995. (3 1 )
d.
Dienen boek an Marie tuogen ee Valere niet gewild.
that book to Marie show has Valere not wanted 'What Valere did not want was to show Marie that book. '
If the F-features of infinitival tuogen move t o the C node of the fronted projec tion, then it is not obvious why the LC-features are not pied-piped, since there are no LC-features available in the embedded C for the moved F-features of the infinitive to associate with. Similarly, in independently used infinitival clauses, the infinitive remains sentence-final, even if there is no lexical host for the F-features: (3 1)
e.
Jenen boek morgen
nie vergeten!
your book tomorrow not forget 'Don't forget your book tomorrow! '
In the next section, I return to the problems discussed above with respect to the earlier anti symmetry approach. 6 For finite clauses, Zwart's (1 996) F-feature movement analysis solves some of the problems, but as shown above, the account does not naturally generalise to infinitives. In contrast, the double movement analysis elaborated in this paper offers an account that extends naturally to infinitival clauses and is therefore superior. 6.2 F-feature movement and the problems discussed above Zwart's (1 996) F-feature movement analysis will not alleviate the problem raised for Diesing's generalisation, since OV orders in his approach continue to be derived by feature-driven one-by-one movement of constituents. The problems raised by absence of morphology-triggered V-to-I movement are solved, if we re-interpret V-to-I movement as F-feature movement. However, on such an account, the observed finite/non-finite asymmetries in WF are hard to capture. Moreover, in Section 6. 1 . I have shown that infinitival F-feature movement is problematic. However, if infinitives are taken not to display F-feature movement, the OV order and TEe remain problematic. It is not clear if the problems raised with respect to the syntax of negation can be solved in the F-feature analysis. On the positive side, the non-adjacency of the negative head en- and the moved negative quantifier finds a natural explanation if we assume that F-feature movement pied-pipes the feature Neg. Assuming successive cyclic movement of the F-features, a fronted negative constituent which occupies the specifier of say AgrO, will be able to check its
92
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
Neg feature with the matching feature which is among the F-features in AgrO. On the negative side, in terms of Zwart's ( 1 996) account, the inflected V with its overt negative head en- remains in a low position. Since the presence of en triggers V-movement to that particular position, the most plausible hypothesis is that the lower projection whose head attracts the verb with the negative head is PolPlNegPl . This hypothesis, though, implies that there is a difference between the hierarchical organisation of Romance (and English, see Cormack & Smith 1 999) and WF. Table 2 summarises the discussion. For the F-feature movement analysis, I consider the variant with infinitival F-feature movement and without such movement separately. Table 2. Survey ofproblems (ii) No V-movement
Double movement
F-feature movement (also in infinitive)
F-feature movement (not in infinitive)
Morphology and V-movement
Remains
Solved
Solved
Solved
Finite/non-finite asymmetry
Solved
Solved
Remains
Solved
Diesing's generalisation
Remains
Solved
Remains
Remains
Holmberg's generalisation Remains
Solved
Solved
Remains
Transitive expletives
Remains
Solved
Solved
Remains
PolP > XP
Remains
Solved
Remains
Remains
Analysis
Problem
7.
Summary
In one type of antisymmetric analyses of the Germanic OV languages, the embedded verb-final order is derived by feature-driven leftward movement of lower constituents. The sentence-final position of the embedded verb is taken as evidence for the absence of V-to-I movement or for short V-movement. Such analyses create a number of problems, concerning the correlation between (i) V-morphology and V-movement, (ii) V-movement and object shift, (iii) V-movement and transitive expletives, (iv) the interpretation and position of indefinite objects. A further paradox arises with respect to the syntax of negation. In the Germanic OV languages, as well as in the Scandinavian VO languages, negative
93
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
quantifiers obligatorily move leftward in order to establish a specifier head relation with a Neg head feature (Haegeman 1 995). On the basis of the WF IPP construction, Haegeman ( 1998a, 1 998b) shows that the presence of the negative head en- on the verb triggers overt V-movement. This suggests that V-movement is induced by Neg. If (i) Neg-movement of XPs targets the specifier of a head with the Neg feature, and if (ii) en-V-movement is triggered by a Neg head feature, the moved negative XP and the en-affixed verb will be expected to be adjacent, contrary to fact. A first analysis proposes that there are two NegPs (cf. Zanuttini 1 997a, 1 997b) and that movement of the negative XP targets the specifier of a higher NegP (NegP1 ) than movement of the en-affixed V (NegP2). Under this hypothe sis a problem is shown to arise w.r.t. the hierarchical relations of the two NegPs. To solve these problems, it is proposed that, like in Romance, the WF higher NegP1 (plausibly PoIP) hosts the negative head en; a Spec feature of the lower Neg2 triggers Neg-movement (32a). (32)
a. b.
SU > TP1 > PolP (en) > . . . FP . . . NegP2 (nie) SU > [TP 1-.lXPk. . . [NegP2 n iel . . . l [Tl en-V] > PoIP > [XP tk .J] .
I propose that Germanic embedded OV orders are derived by double movement: (i) generalised V-to-I movement, and (ii) generalised remnant extended VP movement to SpecTP1 (32b). This derivation applies to both negative and non negative clauses, and to both finite and non-finite structures. The finite/non-finite asymmetries in WF are captured in terms of the degree of V-to-I movement. Essentially based on a set of empirical arguments from WF my analysis is similar to that of Pearson ( 1 999). In the last section of the paper I review Zwart's 1 996 F-feature movement analysis. His analysis fares better in accounting for some of the issues raised, but it can only do so if there is taken to be no finite/non-finite asymmetry in F-feature movement. This is problematic, also in view of the observed finite/non finite asymmetries in WF Moreover, the F-feature movement analysis cannot capture Diesing's generalisation and the problem of the hierarchical relations of the two negative projections remains. ,
.
Notes 1.
Definite DPs may also move leftward: (i) wei! Elly diese Lieder immer singt since EUy these songs always sings 'since EUy always sings these songs'
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
94 2.
Cf. the conditions on domain extension in Chomsky's 1993 analysis of object shift.
3.
For reasons of space I ignore the difference between eet in (8a) and ee in (8b) here. I refer to Haegeman 1998c.
4.
It is not possible to assume that the indefinite subject of the TEC occupies SpecTPl all by itself, given the structure I assume. Following Pearson (1999), we may assume that after the removal of the V-head from the remnant XP, the features of the indefinite subject become accessible for attraction by T and that remnant movement is the result of pied piping. In such a view, the indefinite subject of the TEC would be licensed in SpecTP.
5.
This would be the option assumed by Zwart (p.c.).
6.
It is sometimes claimed that the transparency of extraposed CP complements in the West Germanic OV languages is accounted for in the antisymmetry approach because, it is claimed, under this view so-called extraposed clauses may be said to occupy their base positions. Obviously this would not be compatible with the remnant movement theory espoused here. However, in independent work I have demonstrated that it is not the case that all transparent sentence-final CP complements can be argued to be in their base position. For reasons of space I will not elaborate this point here and refer to HinterhOlzl 1999, this volume, and to Haegeman 1998c, 1999.
References Ackema, Peter. 1999. On the relation between V-to-I and inflectional features. Ms. University of Groningen. Besten, Hans den and Rutten, Jean. 1989. "On verb raising, extraposition and free word order in Dutch." In Danny Jaspers, Wim Klooster, Yvan Putseys, and Pieter Seuren (eds), Sentential Complementation and the Lexicon: Studies in honour of Wim de Geest. Dordrecht: Foris. 4 1-56. Bobaljik, Jonathan, and Jonas, Diane. 1996. "Subject positions and the role of TP." Linguistic Inquiry 27: 1 95-236. Bobaljik, Jonathan, and Hoskuldur Thrainsson. 1997. "Two heads aren't always better than one." Syntax 1 : 37-7 l . Chomsky, Noam. 1993. " A minimalist program for linguistic theory." In Hale, Kenneth and Samuel J. Keyser (eds), The view from Building 20: Essays in linguistics in honor of Sylvain Bromberger. Cambridge, MA: MIT press. 1-52. Chomsky, Noam. 1995. The Minimalist Program. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Christensen, Kristi Koch. 1986. "Norwegian ingen: A case of post-syntactic lexicalization in Scandinavian dialects." In Paola Beninca (ed.), Dialect Variation and the Theory of Grammar. Dordrecht: Foris. 53-83. Cinque, Guglielmo. 1 998. Adverbs and Functional heads. A cross-linguistic perspective. Oxford: OUP. Cormack, Annabel and Smith, Neil. 1998. "Negation, polarity and V positions in English." UCL Working Papers in Linguistics 10, 285-322. Diesing, Molly. 1992. Indefinites. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
REMNANT MOVEMENT AND OV ORDER
95
Diesing, Molly. 1 996. "NP types and conditions on interpretation." In Don, J., B . Schouten and W. Zonneve1d (eds), OTS Yearbook 1995. Utrecht: OTS. 1-12. Diesing, Molly. 1997. "Yiddish VP order and the typology of object movement in Germanic." Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 15: 369-427. Dikken, Marcel den. 1996. "The minimal links of verb (projection) raising." In Werner Abraham, Sam. Epstein, Hosku1dur Thnlinsson, and Jan-Wouter Zwart (eds), Minimal ldeas. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins. 7-96. Haegeman, Li1iane. 1995. The Syntax ofNegation. Cambridge: CUP. Haegeman, Liliane. 1996a. "Object clitics in West Flemish." In Aaron Halpern and Arnold Zwicky (eds), Second Position Clitics and Related phenomena. Stanford: CSLI Press. 135-164. Haegeman, Liliane 1996b. "The typology of syntactic positions: L-relatedness and the AlA' distinction." In Werner Abraham, Samuel Epstein, Hoskuldur Thnlinsson and Jan-Wouter Zwart (eds), Minimal Ideas. New York and Philadelphia: John Benja mins. 141-165. Haegeman, Liliane. 1998a. "V-positions and the middle field in West Flemish." Syntax. 1 : 259-99. Haegeman, Liliane. 1998b. "Verb Movement in embedded clauses in West Flemish." Linguistic Inquiry 29: 63 1-56. Haegeman, Liliane. 1998c. Extraposed clauses in the Germanic SOY languages. Ms. University of Geneva. Chomsky Celebration Website. MIT Press. Haegeman, Liliane. 1999. Embedded verb positions and remnant movement in the West Germanic OV languages. Ms. University of Geneva. Haegeman, Liliane and Zanuttini, Raffaella. 1 99 1 . "Negative heads and the Neg criteri on." The Linguistic Review 8 : 233-25 1 . Haegeman, Liliane and Zanuttini, Raffaella. 1 996. "Negative concord in West Flemish." In Adriana Belletti and Luigi Rizzi (eds), Parameters and Functional Heads: Essays in comparative syntax. Oxford: OUP. 1 17-1 80. Hamann, Cornelia. 1 993. Notes on negation in German. Ms. University of Geneva HinterhOlzl, Roland. 1999. Restructuring Infinitives and the Theory of Complementation. Ph.D. dissertation, USc. Hoekstra, Teun. 1995. "To have to be dative." In Hubert Haider, Susan Olsen, and Sten Vikner (eds), Studies in Comparative Germanic syntax. Kluwer: Dordrecht. 1 1 9-137. Holmberg, Anders. 1986. Word Order and Syntactic Features in the Scandinavian Languages and English. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Stockholm. Holmberg, Anders and Platzack, Christer. 1 995. The Role of Inflection in Scandinavian syntax. Oxford: OUP. Hoop, Helen de. 1 992. Case Configuration and NP Interpretation. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Groningen. Hr6arsd6ttir, porbjorg. 1999. Verb Phrase Syntax in the history of Icelandic. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Troms¢.
96
LILIANE HAEGEMAN
Jonas, Diane. 1996. "Clause structure, expletives and verb movement." In Werner Abraham, Samuel Epstein, Hoskuldur Thrainsson, and Jan-Wouter Zwart (eds), Minimal Ideas. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins. 1 67-1 88. J6nsson, J6hannes Gfsli. 1 996. Clausal Architecture and Case in Icelandic. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst. Kayne, Richard. 1994. The Antisymmetry of Syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Kayne, Richard. 1998. "Overt vs. covert movement." Syntax 1: 128-1 9 1 . Koster, Jan. 1 994. "Predicate incorporation and th e word order o f Dutch." In Guglielmo Cinque, Jan Koster, Jean-Yves Pollock, Luigi Rizzi and Raffaella Zanuttini (eds), Paths towards Universal Grammar. Georgetown: Georgetown University Press. 255-276 Mliller, Gereon. 1 996. Incomplete Category Fronting. Habilitation thesis. Tlibingen. Pearson, Matthew, 1999. "Feature inheritance and remnant movement: Deriving SOY order under the LCA." In Gianluca Storto (ed.), Syntax at Sunset 2, vol. 3. Los Angeles: UCLA Department of Linguistics. 133-173 . Pollock, Jean-Yves. 1989. "Verb-movement, universal grammar, and the structure of !P." Linguistic Inquiry 20: 365-424. Pollock, Jean-Yves. 1 997. "Notes on clause structure." In Liliane Haegeman (ed.), Elements of Grammar. Dordrecht: Kluwer. 237-279. Roberts, Ian. 1 985. "Agreement parameters and the development of English modal auxiliaries." Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 3 : 21-58. Rohrbacher, Bernard. 1994. The Germanic VO Languages and the Full Paradigm: A theory of V-to-I raising. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst. Rutten, Jean. 199 1 . Infinitival Complements and Auxiliaries. Ph.D. dissertation, Universi ty of Amsterdam. Vikner, Sten. 1 997. "V-to-I and inflection for person in all tenses", In Liliane Haegeman (ed.), The New Comparative Syntax. London: Longman. 237-279. Watanabe, Akira. 1 998. Absorption: Interpretability and feature strength. Ms. Department of English, University of Tokyo. Wyngaerd, Guido van den. 1 989. "Object shift as an A-movement rule." MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 1 1 : 256-27 1 . Zanuttini, Raffaella. 1997a. Negation and Clausal Structure: A comparative study of Romance languages. Oxford: OUP. Zanuttini, Raffaella. 1 997b. "Negation and V-movement." In Liliane Haegeman (ed.), The New Comparative Syntax. London: Longman. 214-245. Zinsmeister, Heike. 1995. Die Lizenzierung von kein. Ein Vergleich der syntaktischen Vertaelung von N-Phrasen im Danischen und Deutschen. MA dissertation, Universi ty of Stuttgart. Zwart, Jan-Wouter. 1993. Dutch Syntax: A Minimalist Approach. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Groningen. Zwart, Jan-Wouter. 1996. Morphosyntax of Verh Movement. A Minimalist Approach to the Syntax of Dutch. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
V-movement and VP-movement in Derivations Leading to VO order Knut Tarald Taraldsen University of Troms¢
Abstract In this article, I assume that the Gennanic VO languages are just like the Gennanic OV languages except that a raising operation not found in Gennan, Dutch or Afrikaans has the effect of placing the V to the left of its comple ments in English and Scandinavian. The main purpose of the article is to investigate the nature of this operation: Is it an instance of head-movement (V-raising) or phrasal movement ((remnant) VP-raising)? What is the trigger? Using the distributional properties of verb particles as a diagnostic, I conclude that the VO order of English and Scandinavian must be the result of remnant VP-preposing. The analysis developed below can be seen as an attempt to extend the proposals of Kayne ( 1998), integrating them with certain insights due to Haider ( 1992), (1997).
1.
The options
Assuming the correctness of Kayne's ( 1994) conclusion that all constituents must have Spec-Head complement order, Koster (1994), Zwart ( 1993) and others have analyzed German and Dutch OV order as the result of verbal complements raising out of the VP to check "strong" features in the functional layer above the VP. In the Germanic VO languages, the complements of the verb would remain inside the VP until LF, because the relevant features are "weak". Disregarding criticism that could be directed against the theoretical frame work underlying this analysis, e.g. the absence of any independent motivation for the "strong" vs. "weak" distinction, I tend to consider a simple observation made
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
98
by Haider ( 1 992) as a decisive argument against this approach: The observation is that the complements of the verb are ordered with respect to one another as in ( 1 ) both in the Germanic OV languages and in the Germanic VO languages: 1 (1)
(V) - 10 - DO - PP - (V)
This is illustrated by the following examples from German and English (both from Haider ( 1 992), see also Barbiers (this volume)): (2)
dass sie jedem
ein Paket
that they everybody a
an seine Privatadresse schicken
package to his
home. address send
werden will
(3)
(Ger)
that they will send everybody a package to his home address
If the German sentence has the three verbal complements in SpecFP positions above the VP, while the complements of the verb remain inside the VP in its English counterpart, the system must add stipulations about the ordering of the relevant licensing positions in the functional layer to guarantee that extraction of the complements from the VP must preserve the initial ordering. So, I agree with Haider that deriving the VO order of English and Scandina vian from OV by shifting the V leftward across its complements is preferable to deriving the OV order of German or Dutch by moving complements across the V. Haider ( 1 992) proposes the following initial structure common to all German ic languages: (4)
[10 [DO [PP V]]]
OV languages are characterized as those which allow the V to license its complements from right to left ("regressive licensing"), taking the domain of licensing to be the maximal projection of the head. Hence, in German or Dutch, the V licenses its complements in (4) without leaving its base position. English and Scandinavian, on the other hand, only allow the V to license its complements from left to right ("progressive licensing"). Hence, licensing requires that the V raises (successively) across the structure in (4): 2 (5)
[V [10 tv [DO tv [PP tv]]]
Haider attributes the universality of (4) to his "basic branching condition" (the BBe) requiring the projecting node to follow its (unique) sister. However, (4) obvious ly becomes consistent with Kayne's LCA when viewed as a VP-shell structure as in (6) below, and the BBC would follow from the LCA plus the assumption that all complements of V must be analyzed as specifiers of VP-shells: 3
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER (6)
99
[10 V [DO V [PP V]]J
There is, however, a different way of implementing the idea that VO order results from placing the V to the left of its complement. Suppose that the complements of the V raise overtly to SpecFP positions above the VP in all 4 Germanic languages, giving rise to (intermediate) representations like (7):
(7)
[10 Fio [DO Fdo [PP Fpp [yp V tlO tDO tpp]]]
The fact that the sequence IO-DO-PP shows the same internal order in all Germanic languages will then reflect the universal ordering of the heads Fio' Fdo and Fpp . The VO order characteristic of English and Scandinavian can then be attributed to the remnant VP of (7) raising to a Spec-position above FioP: (8)
[[yp V tro tDO tpp] [IO Fio [DO Fdo [PP Fpp typJ]]
Remnant VP-raising will of course not provide any directly visible clues enabling one to distinguish the two analyses on empirical grounds unless the remnant VP sometimes contains material that cannot be part of the V. In the following sections, however, I will argue that verb particles cannot be part of the V, but may raise across a direct object as part of a remnant VP.
2.
The distribution of particles correlates with VO vs. OV
In the Germanic VO languages, verb particles have two properties not shared by verb particles in the Germanic OV languages: 5 they follow the verb even outside V2-contexts, and whereas some Germanic VO languages (e.g. English) allow a verb particle to precede the direct object, no Germanic OV language has this property. The first of these two contrasts is illustrated in (9)-( 1 0), and the second one in ( 1 1 )-( 14): (9)
that they *outwentlwent out
( 1 0)
dass sie ausgingen/*gingen aus
(11)
They will let the cat in.
(12)
They will let in the cat.
(13) ( 1 4)
that they out.wentl*went
out
(Ger)
Sie werden deine Freunde ein laden.
(Ger)
*Sie werden ein deine Freunde laden.
(Ger)
they will they will
your friends in.invite
in your friends invite
1 00
KNUT
TARALD TARALDSEN
Leaving aside the first contrast, 6 I will briefly show how the second one would be explained on Haider's V-raising account of Germanic VO order. 7 Taking the V and the particle to be one complex V, Haider takes the position of the particle in ( 1 2) as a side-effect of V-raising, as indicated in ( 1 5): (15)
[[vV Prt] [DO tv] ] ]
In the derivation of ( 1 1), the V excorporates from the complex V, stranding the particle in its base position:
( 1 6)
[V [DO [v tv Prt]]]
If particles never move on their own, the ungrammaticality of ( 14) follows straightforwardly from the lack of V-raising in languages with "regressive licensing". In general, no Germanic OV language can have "particle-shift". It is obvious, however, that Haider's V-raising analysis establishes a link between particle-shift and VO order only if a particle is in fact part of a complex V. I will now present a number of reasons to reject that assumption.
3.
The particle is not part of the V
First, we have the familiar problem with V-raising to the V2-position. In no Germanic language does a particle accompany the host V in this situation: 8
Hvoifor slapp hun ut katten ?
(Nor)
( 1 8) *Hvoifor slapp ut hun katten ? why let out she cat. the
(Nor)
( 17)
why
let
she out cat.the
If the particle forms a complex V together with the verb, why must it always be stranded under V2-movement? The problem seems particularly serious, since it is the host of the "incorporated" particle that must excorporate, an option taken not to be available in much recent work (e.g. Kayne 1 994). Notice also that even though one might get around the excorporation problem for Norwegian by saying that the particle may (e.g. in the Norwegian counterparts of ( 1 2)) or may not (e.g. in the Norwegian counterpart of ( 1 1 )) be part of a complex V and assuming that somehow only a simple V is allowed in the V2-position, this would not extend to a language like Swedish, where only the word order in ( 1 2) is gram matical (see Section 5), forcing the conclusion that in Swedish, the particle must be part of a complex V, and yet, the particle is stranded in V2-contexts. 9 Another problem with the assumption that the particle is part of a complex
101
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
V i n sentences like (12) i s that the structure [v V Prt] i s inconsistent with Kayne's ( 1994) LeA and would in any event be the opposite of the [x Y X] structure typical of compound words in Germanic. To circumvent this objection, the V-raising account of particle-shift would have to posit obligatory leftward movement excorporating the V even in the derivation of (12):
( 1 9)
They will let [vin tv] the cat.
This extra movement is not motivated by anything in Haider's analysis, however. Nor is there any obvious reason why it would have to strand the particle. Moreover, it undermines an otherwise promising account of the contrast between (20) and (21): 1 0
(20) She let the cat in and the dog out. (21) *She let i n the cat and out the dog. In (20), we apparently witness a successful conjunction of non-constituents. However, (20) lends itself to an analysis in terms of across-the-board (ATB) V-movement, in the sense of Williams (1 978) out of a conjunction of FPsY
(22)
... X [[the cat in [vp let tDP trrJ] and [the dog out [vp let tDP tPrt]]] I
I
I
ATE
The ATB-derivation of (21) in (23) is illicit, if the V cannot excorporate from complex V containing the particle, since ATB-movement only applies to identical tokens of a constituent:
(23)
... Y [[[let in] [the cat [vp tv tDP tPrt]]] and [[let out] I
I
ATE
I
[the dog [vp tv tDP tPrt]]]]
But if the verb actually always excorporates from the complex V in the deriva tions leading to particle-shift, this account of (20) vs. (21 ) clearly becomes unavailable. That the particle cannot in general be taken as part of a complex V is also shown rather straightforwardly by examples like the Afrikaans sentence in (24) (from Donaldson 1 993): 1 2
(24)
Sy hoe! nie die Zig
af te geskakel het nie.
she need not the light off to turned have not 'She needn' t have turned the light off.'
(Afr)
1 02
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
Here, the particle is separated from the potential host verb by the infinitival marker te, which itself cannot be taken as part of that verb, a past participle. A similar argument can be made on the basis of the distribution of weak pronouns in English and Norwegian. Both of these languages allow the word order seen in ( 1 2). Yet, when the direct object is a weak pronoun, it must precede the particle: (25)
(Nor)
Han har sluppet n ut. he
has let
it out
(26) *Han har sluppet ut n. he has let out it
(Nor)
Thus, the sequence containing the verb and particle shifting over the direct object position in the derivation of particle-shift constructions like ( 1 2) must also contain a weak pronoun, sandwiched in between the verb and the particle. But the weak pronoun cannot easily be analyzed as forming a complex verb either 3 with the verb or the particle, since it separates from both in V2-contexts: 1 (27)
Deifor
slapp han n ikke ut.
therefore let
he it not out
(Nor)
(28) *Deifor slapp n han ikke ut. therefore let it he not out
(Nor)
(29) *Deifor slapp han ikke n ut. therefore let he not it out
(Nor)
Finally, notice that even sequences that are indisputably phrasal may behave like particles, as in the following examples from Norwegian: (30)
Hun sendte pengene
(3 1 )
Hun sendte med lens pengene.
she sent
she sent
med lens.
money. the with Jens
with Jens money.the
(Nor) (Nor)
The contention that the PP behaves like a particle in (30)-(3 1 ) is strengthened by the observation that Danish, which never allows particles preceding the direct object, also does not allow (3 1), while Swedish, which never allows particles following the direct object, rejects (30).
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
4.
103
Particle-shift via remnant VP-raising
If VO order is derived by raising a remnant VP to a Spec-position preceding the complements previously extracted from the VP, as suggested at the end of Section 1 , we can take particle-shift constructions like (12) to have the derivation indicated in (32), where the particle is inside the raised remnant VP: (32)
[[vp V Prt] [DO Fdo tvp]]
The structures with the particle left behind to the right of the direct object, like ( 1 1), must then have the particle extracted from the VP, on a par with the other complements of the V: (33)
[[vp V] [DO Fdo [Prt Fprt tvp]]]
The problems listed in Section 3 do not arise on this analysis. Since the particle is not taken to be part of the V, it is not expected that it will carried along under V-movement to the V2-position. 14 The V-Prt order seen in ( 1 2) is consistent with the LeA, since the particle is analyzed as (the head of) a VP-intemal comple ment rather than a head adjoined to V. The fact that the particle can be separated from the V by an infinitival marker or a weak pronoun is also unproblematic. This analysis of particle-shift generalizes Kayne's ( 1 998) analysis of particle-shift in focus constructions. Kayne argues that a sentence like (34) is to be analyzed as in (35), where the particle shifts as part of a remnant VP raised to a Spec-position immediately above the the focus phrase (FocP): (34)
She will let in only one student.
(35)
she [wp[vp will [let in tDP]] Foc+W [FoeP [DP only one student] tFoe tvp]]
(36), then, must have the particle outside the VP: 1 5 (36) (37)
?She will let only one student in. she [wp[vp will [let tPrt tDP]] Foc+W [FoeP [DP only one student] tFoe [in Fprt tvp]]]
Kayne does not take remnant VP-raising to be the source of particle-shift except in focus constructions like (34). But certain observations concerning the distribu tion of verb particles across the Mainland Scandinavian languages suggest that an analysis of particle-shift as a by-product of remnant VP-raising in (34) cannot co-exist happily with a V-raising analysis of particle-shift in (12). As already mentioned, Norwegian is the only Mainland Scandinavian language allowing both options illustrated by (1 1 )-(12) :
104
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
(38) (39)
Hun slapp katten inn.
(Nor)
Hun slapp inn katten.
(Nor)
�
let
she let
cat.the in
in cat. the
Swedish allows only the word order in (39), while Danish only allows the one in (38) 16 :
(40)
Norwegian Swedish Danish
DP Prt ok *
ok
Prt DP ok ok *
Significantly, this pattern is replicated with focussed direct objects:
(41)
Hun slapp bare en katt inn.
(Nor)
(42)
Hun slapp inn bare en katt.
(Nor)
(43)
she let she let
only one cat in
in only one cat
Norwegian Swedish Danish
only DP Prt ok *
ok
Prt only DP ok ok *
No Mainland Scandinavian dialect has only the DO-Prt order with non-focussed direct objects (like Danish) while allowing the Prt-DO order with focussed direct objects (like Norwegian and Swedish). If particle-shift across non-focussed direct objects is an effect of V-raising, while particle-shift across focussed direct objects reflects remnant VP-raising, we must assume that a particle is necessarily pied-piped under V-raising unless it is outside the VP. But there is no obvious reason why this assumption should hold, unless one takes a VP-internal particle to be necessarily adjoined to the V, an assumption which is inconsistent with the evidence discussed in Section 3 . If all instances of particle-shift are attributed to the raising of a remnant VP containing a particle, however, the identity of the patterns in (40) and (43) follows directly. On the analysis of particle-shift as a side-effect of remnant VP-raising, Swedish must only allow VP-internal particles, 17 Danish must only have particles outside the VP and Norwegian (like English) must have both options. Interesting ly, this view allows us to see a parallelism between the NorwegianiSwedish contrast and a superficially different contrast between Dutch and Afrikaans. In both of the latter two languages, complements of the main verb appear separated
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
1 05
from it, preceding the modal, in sentences like (44)-(45) (Dutch) or (46)-(47) (Mrikaans) : (44)
dat Jan Marie wi! opbellen
(Dut)
(45)
dat Jan Marie op wi! bellen
(Dut)
dat Jan Marie sal opbel
(Afr)
*dat Jan Marie op sal bel
(Afr)
(46) (47)
that Jan Marie will up.call
that Jan Marie up will call that Jan Marie will up.call that Jan Marie up will call
Particles, however, show a different behavior from that of DP complements like the direct object Marie in (44)-(47). In Dutch, a verb particle either immediately precedes the main verb, as in (44), or moves in front of the modal, like the direct object, as in (45). In Mrikaans, the particle must remain next to the main verb, as in (46). Assuming an analysis of "verb raising" constructions along the lines of HinterhOlzl ( 1 997) or Koopman & Szabolcsi ( 1 997), only complements that raise out of the VP, 1 8 to some SpecFP above it, can end up preceding the modal. Hence, we take both structures in (48)-(49) to be available to Dutch, while Afrikaans only has access to (48) : (48) (49)
[DO Fdo [vp Prt V]]] [DO Fdo [Prt Fprt [vP V]]]
Thus, Dutch is just like Norwegian (and English), while Afrikaans is like Swedish, although this underlying parallelism has different reflexes in West Germanic as opposed to Mainland Scandinavian, since only the latter are VO languages, i.e. have remnant VP-raising. 5.
An excursus on Kayne (1998)
According to Kayne ( 1 998), scope cannot be assigned via covert movement. 1 9 Thus, the wide scope reading of bare en student "only one student" in Norwegian example (50) comes from a structure in which this DP has raised to a position above the matrix VP, with subsequent remnant VP-raising to a still higher Spec position masking the effect of the first movement (and stranding the second object previously extracted from the VP, as will be discussed below):
106
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN (50)
I de siste arene har hun ¢nsket a matte gi
bare en
in the last years has she wished to have.to give only one
student en A. (5 1)
student an A
(Nor)
. . Foc+W [PocP only one student tFoc [an A [vp has wished ... .
I
I
Kayne proposes that the FocP must be the complement of a head W which attracts a VP to its Spec, as indicated in (5 1) . He makes no commitment as to how the raising of the remnant VP to SpecWP is to be related to the processes determining the position of the V in general. Yet, there seem to be good reasons to believe that if the analysis of (50) in (5 1) is correct, VP-raising to the pre FocP SpecWP should be assimilated to the process inducing VO order. First of all, the property of attracting a VP to its Spec cannot be a property of W in general. Even in (52), where the subject is focussed by only, the focussed DP must be preceded by W, taken to attract only from the head position of the FocP: (52)
Only John chose the marinated salmon.
But this W does not attract the VP to its Spec. In general, W attracts a VP to its Spec just in case the following focussed constituent is such that it is generally postverbal, e.g. a direct object rather than a subject. This fact seems to force one to view the VP-raising to SpecWP in (5 1) as a special case of whatever process makes complements of the verb postverbal in VO languages. Assuming the correctness of Kayne's analysis of (50), this process should therefore involve VP-raising, although not to the Spec of a head (W) appearing only in front of a FocP, but rather to the Spec of some FP always projected in between the subject position and the various complements extracted from the VP (according to the analysis sketched at the end of Section 1) . 20,21 Another straightforward observation supporting this view is that not even focussed direct objects have the VP shifting to their left in languages which, like German and Dutch, are not VO languages, even though the fact that the focus particle (e.g. German nur "only") precedes the focussed phrase would require the presence of a W even here. Finally, notice that the focussed indirect object in (50) is followed by a non focussed direct object. On the wide scope reading of the focussed DP, this direct object must also be in a position outside the matrix VP, as indicated in (5 1), i.e. it shows the distribution characteristic of DP complements in the West Germanic "verb raising" construction. The unavailability of the wide scope reading in (53),
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
107
then, would be correlated with the fact that hate is not a trigger for "verb raising" in West Gennanic either:
(53)
I de siste arene har hun hatet a matte gi
bare en student
in the last years has she hated to have.to give only one student (Nor) en A. an A
But if the direct object of the infinitive can raise across the matrix V (provided the matrix V is a "verb raiser"), and VO order is derived by V-raising, (54) would be derived by applying V-raising to the intennediate structure in (55):
(54) *Hun har en A ¢nsket a fa.
she has an A wished to get
(55)
(Nor)
. . . [an A [vp has wished . . .
If VO order is the result of remnant VP-preposing, on the other hand, only the grammatical (56) can be derived from (55) : 22
(56)
Hun har ¢nsket a fa en A. she has wished to get an A
(Nor)
I conclude that if Kayne's ( 1998) account of the wide scope reading of (50) is correct, Gennanic VO order should be derived by remnant VP-preposing, a conclusion which obviously dovetails with the analysis of particle-shift argued for in preceding sections. 6.
Two problems
At this point, it seems that the weight of the evidence favors analyzing Gennanic VO order as the result of remnant VP-raising. But particle constructions raise two important problems that remain to be dealt with. First, we must return to a question raised in Section 1 : Why do we always find the order Prt-V in the Gennanic OV languages (modulo V2), but always V-Prt in the VO languages? In the analysis developed so far, the particle is VP-internal in particle-shift constructions like (12) (repeated below), and it is likewise VP-internal in Dutch and Afrikaans sentences like (44)1(46) (also repeated below): (12)
(44)
They will let in the cat.
dat Jan Marie wil opbellen
that Jan Marie will up.call
(Dut)
KNUT
108 (46)
TARALD TARALDSEN
dat Jan Marie sal opbel
that Jan Marie will up.call
(Afr)
Yet, we have the order V-Prt in (12), but Prt-V in (44)/(46). In view of the previous discussion of the contrast (20) vs. (21) (repeated below), we do not want to derive ( 1 2) by having V-raising applying to the output of VP-raising (assuming the VP-internal order to be always Prt-V, perhaps with Prt(P) in the Spec-position of a VP-shell):
(20) She let the cat in and the dog out. (21) *She let in the cat and out the dog. But the only available alternative would seem to be postulating VP-internal V-Prt order for the VO languages and VP-internal Prt-V order for the OV languages, a devastating conclusion in the context of an attempt to reduce the word order differences between the Germanic VO languages and their OV cousins to the effects of remnant VP-raising. The second problem concerns the claim that the particle is never part of a complex V. Although we have seen good evidence supporting this conclusion, there is also a well-known fact which at first sight seems inconsistent with it. A particle modified by an element like right doesn't shift, as illustrated by the following examples from English and Norwegian:
(57) They will let the dog right in. (58) *They will let right in the dog. (59) Hun sendte katten rett ut.
(Nor)
(60) *Hun sendte rett ut katten.
(Nor)
she sent she sent
cat.the right out
right out cat.the
Strikingly, even Swedish, which allows simple particles only to the left of the direct object, can only have a modified particle after the direct object:
Dam sliippte hunden ratt in.
(Swe)
(62) *Dam sliippte ratt in hunden. right in dog.the they let
(Swe)
(61)
they let
dog.the right in
This fact would find a straightforward explanation if the theory only allowed a particle to shift as part of the V, since presumably only a head can incorporate into the V. Thus, we seem to be led towards a paradox: A shifted particle both must and must not be part of the V.
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
1 09
The same paradox may also arise in a somewhat different guise in Mri kaans. According to Donaldson ( 1993), bare nouns optionally behave like particles, in the sense that they may stay next to the infinitives in "verb raising contexts", while modified nouns must shift across the matrix V:23 (63 )
dat die olifante
kom water drink
(Afr)
dat die olifante
water kom drink
(Afr)
(65) *dat die olifante
kom vars water drink
(Afr)
dat die olifante
vars water kom drink
(Afr)
(64)
that the elephants come water drink
that the elephants water come drink
that the elephants come fresh water drink
(66)
that the elephants fresh water come drink
This strongly suggests that in Mrikaans, nouns (and particles) may remain next to the selecting V just in case they are incorporated into the V. But, as pointed out in Section 3, the construction exemplified in (24) (repeated below) shows that particles are not incorporated into the V, and (67) leads to the same conclusion for bare nouns:
(24)
(67)
Sy hoe! nie die Zig
af te geskakel het
nie.
she need not the light off to turned have not 'She needn't have turned the light off. '
Die olifante
hoe! water te gedrink het.
the elephants need water to drunk have 'The elephants need to have drunk water.'
(Afr)
(Afr)
In the next section, I present an implementation of the basic idea underlying the VP-raising account of VO order which seems capable of resolving this paradox and of eliminating the VP-internal Prt-V vS. V-Prt problem as well. 7.
Generalized VP-to-SpecWP raising
The fact that modified particles don't shift means that a shifted particle must be incorporated into the head of the constituent that raises across the direct object: We can then prevent modified particles from shifting by saying that all comple ments of that head, including a PrtP containing a modified particle, are extracted out of its maximal projection:
1 10
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN (68)
... FeompI ... Feompn (x:p Spec Prt+X compI ... compn]
I'
I
I
'
I
XP should contain the V, since particle-shift only occurs in languages where the V as well ends up preceding the direct object. But this does not entail that X is the V, since we can take the V to be contained in a remnant VP in SpecXP, i.e. the VP originates as the complement of the particle and subsequently raises to SpecXP above it. By making that assumption, we avoid the undesirable conclu sion that a shifted particle must be part of the V. In other words, the paradox that the facts about modified particles apparently led to is not a real one: It dissolves under the scenario depicted in (68). Likewise, the problem raised by Prt-V order in the OV languages vs. V-Prt in VO languages is sidestepped: According to (68), the particle is outside the VP, and V-Prt order is the result of placing a remnant VP in SpecXP, preceding the head X to which the particle is adjoined. We may take it that the VO languages always place the VP in SpecXP, 24 while the OV languages never do, leaving it instead in its base-position below X. The analysis embodied in (63) bears an obvious resemblance to Kayne's ( 1 998) analysis of focus constructions. As we saw in Section 4, Kayne analyzes a sentence like (34) (repeated below) as in (35): (34)
She will let in only one student.
(35)
she [wp[yp will [let in tDP]] Foc+W [FoeP [Dpon1y one student] tFoe typ]]
The focussed DP is raised to SpecFocP, the head Foc adjoins to the immediately higher head W which also attracts the VP to its Spec. The parallelism between this analysis and the analysis of particle constructions in (68) is brought out more clearly if we adopt the more elaborated version of (68) in (69), which is the analysis I propose for the Norwegian particle-shift sentence in (39) (repeated below):
(39)
Hun slapp inn katten.
(69)
. . . [wp [yp slapp ts d [Prt inn]] +W [PrtP [s c katten P] tPrt typ]]
she let
in cat.the
(Nor)
According to this analysis, a shifted particle originates as the head of a particle phrase (PrtP) whose Spec is filled by a small clause (SC) with a null predicate identified under Spec-Read-agreement by the Prt head. 25 The Prt head incorpo rates into the immediately higher W (corresponding to the X of (68)), and the remnant VP is raised to SpecWP. The "stationary" particles of Dutch and Afrikaans will be analyzed like the shifted particle of (39), except that the VP doesn't raise to SpecWP:
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
(44) (46) (70)
111
dat Jan Marie wi! opbellen
(Dut)
dat Jan Marie sal opbel
(Afr)
that Jan Marie will up.call
that Jan Marie will up.call . . . [wp [Prt op] ]+W [PrtP [s c Marie P] tPrt [yp bel(len) ts cJ]]
Before we consider the details of the derivation of (39) from (69), the derivation of (44)/(46) from (70) and the treatment of non-shifting particles, it is appropri ate to clarify certain aspects of the general analysis of the "extended VP" which my analysis of particles must fit into. Here, I will outline the approach which seems most appealing to me for general conceptual reasons. In the final section, however, I will discuss an empirical problem that may force one to adopt an alternative formulation. The approach I shall pursue takes it that the analysis in (69)-(70) is a special instance of the general structure (7 1), which replicates itself at all levels of the extended VP above the VP itself up to and including the F hosting the indirect object DP in its Spec:
(7 1)
. . . Fxp+W [FXPP XP tFxp [
. . •
[yp V . . .
W attracts the VP to its Spec in some languages, which for that reason come out as VO languages. The OV languages are those where W does not attract VP.
Thus, this extension of Kayne's analysis of focus constructions is motivated by the empirical observations made in Section 5: The VP-raising to SpecWP in focus constructions in English and Scandinavian must be identified with the process creating VO order in general. But how does the theory enforce the presence of the W heads interspersed between the functional projections of the extended VP? The functional heads instantiating the Fxp of (7 1) select a phrase and are themselves selected by the lexical head in whose extended projection they appear. Adapting a proposal by Fukui & Speas ( 1986), we may say that a functional head only establishes a selection relation with a phrase in its Spec, while a lexical head only establishes the required selection relationship with a projection whose head is incorporated into it, hence only with its complement. The second half of this assumption entails that each functional projection above the VP in the extended projection of the V must be the complement of a copy of the V, i.e. it must be the complement of W now taken to be essentially an abstract V: 26
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
1 12
We can now say that the remnant VP raises to SpecWP in the Gennanic VO languages in order to identify the +V feature of W via Spec-Head-agreement, arriving at an analysis which in certain respects is rather close to Haider's ( 1992) proposal: The W heads correspond to the V-positions filled by successive V-raising in Haider's (5) (repeated below):
(5)
[V [10 tv [DO tv [PP tv]]]
They indirectly license complements of the verb by licensing (under selection) the functional heads that license them. There are two important differences, however. In (72), V-raising to the W-positions is not an option because of the intervening functional heads. Hence, the identification requirement on the +V feature can only be satisfied by VP-raising to SpecVP. Moreover, the general assumption that selection by a lexical head only can be established via incorpora tion into it forces the presence of [w +V] heads even in the OV languages, raising the question why VP-raising is not forced. However, we might adapt Haider's assumption about a basic asymmetry between OV and VO languages with respect to the relationship between a V and its complement, by taking this asymmetry to be relevant to the identification of +V features on the W heads: In an OV lan guage, the overt V may identify the Ws in its extended projection from right to left, but in the VO languages, identification must proceed from left to right. The idea that W heads are V s also implies that a WP is really itself a VP. This will become important when we examine the subsequent steps in the derivation of (39) from (69).
8.
The derivation of Prt-DO order
The next steps in the derivation from (69) are driven by the need for the DP subject of the SC to be licensed: 27
(73) (74)
. . . Fdp +W I [PdpP katten tpdp [WP2 [vp slapp ts cJ [Prt inn]]+W2 [PrtP [SC tDP P] tPrt tvp]]] . . . [WP I [WP2 [vp slapp ts cJ [Prt inn]+W2 [PrtP [s c tDP P] tPrt tvp]]Fdp +W I [PdpP katten tpdp twp2]]
In (73), the DP subject of the SC has been raised to the appropriate SpecFP above the WP having the remnant VP in its Spec. The head Fdp is selected by V, and so there is an occurrence of W immediately above FdpP to which F dp adjoins. (74) is fonned by raising the lower WP (WP2) into the Spec of the higher WP (WP I ) ·
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
1 13
The raising of WP2 to SpecWP 1 must be motivated by the need for the +V feature of W2 to be identified. Obviously, the latter requirement would have been satisfied by raising the VP from SpecWP I stranding the particle adjoined to W2. However, the VP and WP2 both have the +V feature attracted by W I . 28 Assum ing a version of the A-over-A principle, it follows that SpecWP I must be filled by WP2' and we get the effect of particle-shift. The analysis correctly predicts that particle-shift won't occur in the German ic OV languages, since particles shift only as part of a WP and the W above FdpP does not attract VPIWP to its Spec in these languages. The only relevant further step in the derivation of (44)/(46) from (70) is the one driven by the licensing requirements of the small clause subject, corresponding to (73) above: (75)
9.
. . . Fdp +W l [FdpP Marie tFdp [WP2 [Prt oP]] +W2 [PrtP [sc tDP P] tPrt [yp
bel(len) tsd JJ
A resolution of two problems for the V-raising account of particle shift
The analysis also provides an account of the particle-like behavior of full PPs seen in (30)-(3 1) (repeated below): (30)
Hun sendte pengene
(Nor)
(3 1)
Hun sendte med lens pengene.
(Nor)
she sent she sent
med lens. money.the with Jens
with Jens money. the
Assuming that the SC-predicate can contain the complement of a null head, we can give the particle-shifted version in (3 1 ) a representation like (76): 29 (76)
. . . [WPI [WP2 [yp sendte tsd [Prt med] +W2 [PrtP [s c tDP P lens] tPrt typ]] Fdp +WI [FdpP pengene tFdp twp2]]
Pairs like (30)-(3 1) are problematic for the V-raising account of particle shift, since that account must analyze a shifting particle as part of the V undergoing raising, and therefore seems to predict that full PPs shouldn't shift. For similar reasons, the fact that a weak pronoun always interrupts the V Prt sequence in English and Norwegian is also unexpected on the V-raising approach, since, as we saw in Section 3, the weak pronoun does not incorporate either into the verb or into the particle: (25)
Han har sluppet n ut.
he has let
it out
(Nor)
1 14
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
(26) *Han har sluppet ut n. he has let out it
(Nor)
The analysis we are now exploring has an account of (25)-(26), provided weak pronouns must be inside the VP moving to the Spec of the W to which the particle adjoins, as suggested by the analogy with the partially homophonous definiteness markers in DPs, which seem to originate in a position immediately above the NP: (77)
den svarte katten i nabohuset
the black cat.n in the.neighbors .house r
In particular, we might take weak pronouns to originate as functional heads in the extended V-projection immediately above the VP, perhaps with a null DP raising to its Spec, as in Sportiche (1992):
(78)
. . . W [FelP DP [Fc1 n ] [vp V tDP]] When (78) is embedded under a particle head, we end up getting (79): (79)
. . . [WP I [WP2 [vp sluppet tsd [Fc1 n ] +W2 [FelP DP tFc1] ] [Prt inn]] +W 1 [PrtP [sc tDP P] tPrt twp]]
At first sight, this account of weak pronouns seems desperately at odds with the well-known fact that Scandinavian weak pronouns sometimes clearly occur in positions higher than those occupied by other DPs. This is the case in V2 contexts: (80) (81)
Vi sa
n
ikke (*n).
Vi sa
(* katten) ikke katten.
we saw him not we saw
him
cat.the not catthe
(Nor) (Nor)
But in fact, the analysis under consideration suggests an analysis that has certain advantages over the traditional "object shift" analysis of (80). Suppose V2 has remnant VP-raising across negation and adverbials as a necessary subcompo nent. 3D Assuming, as before, that VP-raising applies to WPs as well (since these are essentially VPs), we can then take both of (80)-(81) to have a WP corre sponding to (78) (with the VP shifted to SpecWP) raised across the negation. This correctly only allows for the pre-negation position of the weak pronoun in (80): (82)
. . . [wp [vp sa tDP] [Fc1 n ] +W [FelP DP tFc1]] [NegP ikke . . . twp In (8 1), Fc1 is null, and the object DP is extracted from the relevant WP to a licensing SpecFdpP, so that it necessarily follows the negation:
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
(83)
1 15
. . , [wp [vp sa tDP] [Fcl 0]+W [FelP DP tFcl]] [NegP ikke . , . [FdpP katten Fdp . . . twp]]
so, this approach would take object shift to be a side-effect of remnant VP-rais ing, made possible precisely by the property that weak pronouns themselves remain very low in the tree. 3 1 Its main appeal comes from the fact that Holm berg's generalization is now automatically accounted for: A weak pronoun may appear in a position preceding negation or sentence adverbials only when the governing V moves. 32 Unfortunately, there are serious problems as well. One of them is a special case of a more general problem discussed in the next section. In structures containing both a weak pronoun and a particle, successive application of VP-rais ing applying to VP and WP will assemble WPs like (79) (repeated below): (79)
. . , [WP I [WP2 [VP sluppet tsd [Fcl n] +W2 [FelP DP tFcl] ] [Prt inn]] +WI [PrtP Esc tDP P] tPrt twp] ]
Since (27)-(29) show that the particle and the weak pronoun must eventually end up on opposite sides of the negation, we must ensure that remnant VP-movement in this case can only apply to the smallest WP, i.e. WP2 in (79): ' (Nor) (27) Derfor slapp han n ikke ut. therefore let he it not out (Nor) (28) *Derfor slapp n han ikke ut. therefore let it he not out (Nor) (29) *Derfor slapp han ikke n uf. therefore let he not it out And apart from the consequences with respect to object shift, the analysis based on (78) raises a question concerning the distribution of the contrast (25) vs. (26) across the Scandinavian languages. In fact, the contrast is reversed in Swedish, i.e. (26) is grammatical, and (25) isn't. The fact that even weak pronouns follow particles only in the one Scandinavian language which also only has ordinary DP objects following particles, is unexpected on the analysis suggested above, as Anders Holmberg (p.c.) points out. But even if this observation should lead one to reject the analysis of weak pronouns in (78), we still have the more fundamen tal conclusion that while the pattern in (25)-(26) is inconsistent with attributing particle shift to V-movement, it is in principle compatible with seeing particle shift as a reflex of remnant VP-movement. 33
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
116
10. The derivation of DO-Pri order
On the analysis developed above, a particle that fails to shift in a VO language cannot be the head of PrtP. Thus, I will take it that particles, in English or Norwegian, either are functional heads, occurring in the Prt-positions, or else are part of the SC in SpecPrtP. 34 A sentence like (38) will have a representation like (84) at an early stage of its derivation (with Prt an empty functional head): (38) (84)
Hun slapp katten inn.
she let cat.the in . . . [wp [yp slapp tpp] Prt+W [[pp katten [pp inn]] tPrt typ]]
(Nor)
Unlike an SC with an empty head (licensed by a "functional" particle), the SC in (84) must raise to a designated licensing position outside the WP, just like the small clause subject: (85)
. . . [WPI [WP2 [yp slapp tpp] Prt+W2 [PrtP tpp tPrt typ]] Fdp +W I [FdpP katten tFdp [FscP [pp tDP [pp inn] Fsc twp2]]]]
I also hold movement to SpecFscP responsible for the appearance of the particle to the left of the modal in Dutch "verb raising" sentences like (45): 35 (44) (45)
dat Jan Marie wil opbellen
(Dut)
dat Jan Marie op wil bellen
(Dut)
that Jan Marie will up.call
Taking the "verb raising" effect to be automatic, as is indeed the case for DPs in (Standard) Dutch, we conclude, as before, that Dutch, like English and Norwe gian, allows a particle to be analyzed either as a functional head outside the corresponding small clause, or as the lexical head of the small clause itself. In the latter case, (45), but not (44), is derived. The derivation of (38) as reflected in (85) has two instances of VP-raising to SpecWP, neither of which has a counterpart in Dutch, an OV language. (Also, Norwegian shows no "verb raising" effects. 36) First, the VP raises (string vacuously) to the SpecWP immediately above PrtP, and then, that WP raises to the SpecWP immediately above FdpP, crossing over both the lexical particle and the object DP. According to the scenario described in Section 7, however, one should also expect an intermediate step at which the lowest WP (WP2 in (85)) raises to a SpecWP immediately above FscP, yielding (86): (86)
. . . [FdpP katten Fdp [WPI [WP2 [yp slapp tpp] Prt+W2 [PrtP tpp tPrt typ]]
Fsc+W 1 [FscP [pp tDP [pp inn] tFsc twp2]]]]
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
1 17
This is because every functional projection in the extended projection of the VP should be immediately dominated by an occurrence of W attracting VP to its Spec. But if (86) is a stage in the derivation of (38), VP-raising to SpecWP above FdpP must target WP 1 rather than the larger WP2 including it. Otherwise, the particle would incorrectly end up preceding the object DP. But we have previously seen that when VP-raising reapplies to the output of VP-raising to the SpecWP immediately above the functional particle projection (PrtP), the larger VP (WP) must be targeted. Thus, the pied-piping effect for VP-raising must somehow be made to take force selectively. 37 It seems impossible to achieve this in a way entirely consistent with the general ideas about the extended VP-projection put forth in Section 7. In particular, it now seems impossible to maintain that all functional projections are governed by Ws each of which is a replica of the lexical head V. Rather, one must introduce some formal distinction between the Ws cooccurring with the PrtP (and FelP, if the analysis of (25) in Section 9 is correct) on the one hand, and all higher occurrences of W on the other, in a way reminiscent of Hinter holzl's distinction between his PredP level and the higher functional projections. The least costly implementation of this with respect to the proposals of Section 7 might be to say that the + V feature of a higher W is erased once a licensing VP has been raised to its Spec, while the + V feature of the W associat ed with PrtP (or FelP) remains visible. This move might be justified, if it can be shown that the latter plays a role at LF, while the + V features of the higher Ws do not. Alternatively, one must fall back on a different scheme according to which there is a W attracting VP just above the PrtP and a different W' just above FdpP attracting WP, but no Ws in between, leaving the nature of these two heads un determined for now. Unlike the analysis adopted above, this alternative analysis would also seem to predict that there could be languages where VP doesn't raise above a functional particle, but WP (i.e. Prt VP) raises above the object DP, or vice versa. Although I know of no Germanic language verifying the second expectation, Yiddish appears to have VO order (resulting from WP raising above the direct object), but Prt V order (indicating failure of the VP to raise past the functional particle), judging from Diesing ( 1997) ((87) Diesing's (23)): =
(87)
Maks vet avekshikn a briv.
Max will away. send a letter
(Yid)
118
KNUT
TARALD TARALDSEN
11. Conclusion
The principal claim made in this article is that VO order in Germanic (outside V2 contexts) arises as the result of remnant VP-raising across a functional layer inside which various complements of the V have previously been placed. From this point of view, the complements of the V behave the same way in all the Germanic languages, but the VP is forced to raise only in the Germanic VO lan guages. The arguments in favor of this view have largely centered on the syntax of verb particles. In particular, I have argued that the particle shift phenomenon characteristic of the Germanic VO languages cannot be successfully analyzed as a by-product of V-raising, while it can be understood as a side-effect of remnant VP-raising. On the other hand, the special behavior of modified particles (and of modified nouns vs. bare nouns in Afrikaans) turns out to be reconcilable with this view only if certain assumptions are made about the nature of the extended V-projection. In Section 7, I presented a set of assumptions generalizing recent ideas of Kayne's about focus constructions and suggested a partial integration of these with the basic ideas of Haider (1992). Whether this interpretation can be maintained, will depend in part on whether it allows for a satisfactory solution of the problem discussed in Section 10. If not, alternative conceptualizations compatible with the basic idea that Germanic VO order reflects remnant VP-rai sing remain to be explored. Notes 1.
Even disregarding the effects of Scrambling, the text statement must perhaps be somewhat modified. The basic (e.g. non-scrambled) order of double objects has been claimed to be DO-IO in German; cf. den Dikken (1995). The relative ordering of postverbal PPs in Dutch may not correspond to the one found in English or Scandinavian; cf. Barbiers (1995), Nilsen (1998).
2.
Actually, Haider has the lowest complement to the right of the V in VO languages. Given the assumption that heads license their complements from left to right in VO languages, this allows the lowest complement of the V to be licensed without V-raising.
3.
See Brody (1997) for discussion.
4.
The idea that direct objects raise out of the VP in overt syntax even in English and Scandina vian was already argued for by Johnson (1991).
5.
Yiddish has Prt-V order. Swedish and some dialects of Norwegian have Prt-V order where the V is a past participle not combining with auxiliary ha 'have' . Danish never allows a particle to the left of the direct object. See Taraldsen ( 1983), Vikner (1987), Svenonius (1994), Haider (1997).
6.
Haider actually attributes the V-Prt order of English and Scandinavian to the V having to precede its lowest complement in the VO languages (cf. footnote 2).
DERIVATIONS LEADING TO VO-ORDER
1 19
7.
If *(14) is explained as a result of further DP-movement across a (shifted) particle, (i) still calls for further assumptions (about Q-stranding): (i) * . . . deine Freunde ein aUe laden
8.
Except, perhaps, in Yiddish, in which case Prt+V in Yiddish should probably always be analyzed as a lexical compound similar to lexical Prt+V compounds in Scandinavian and the suggestion made about Yiddish at the end of Section 10 is incorrect.
9.
In the following paradigm from Afrikaans, a particle associated with the second V in what appears to be a conjunction of Vs moving to the V2 position, is stranded exactly as in the cases where a single V moves: dat sy hom sit en aanstaar (i) that she him sits and at.stares (ii) *dat sy hom aan sit en staar that she him at sits and stares (iii) *Sy sit en aanstaar hom. she sits and at.stares him (iv) Sy sit en staar hom aan. she sits and stares him at It is not immediately obvious how this is to be integrated into the standard analysis of the effect of V2 on verbs.
10.
The basic observation is due to Svenonius (1 994), and is also discussed by den Dikken (1995).
11.
However, this predicts that there should be no OV counterpart of (20), if the V never raises in (Germanic) OV languages except in V2 contexts. The prediction may be wrong. Wilma ter Haar (p.c.) finds a Dutch embedded sentence modeled on (20) relatively acceptable.
12.
See also Hinterh6lzl (1 997, this volume), who constructs a similar argument on the basis of West Flemish.
13.
Notice that a weak pronoun precedes a particle even in contexts where the weak pronoun does not undergo "object shift", i.e. in contexts where the governing verb has not moved, as in (25)-(26).
14.
V2 as V-raising incorrectly predicts (i) to be grammatical as an instance of ATE V-raising to C, unless the complement of C for some reason cannot be a conjoined structure: (i) *Han slapp inn hunden og ut katten. he let in dog.the and out cat.the Anders Holmberg (p.c.) suggests that the ungrammaticality of (i) in Norwegian may be due to the particle being unable to bear contrastive focus when it precedes the object. If focused constituents must be phrases (licensed in SpecFocP), this approach fits in with the analysis in Sections 7-8 where a particle that precedes the object must be a bare head. However, Holmberg also notes that (i) is marginally acceptable in Swedish.
15.
The fact that (37) is less than perfect, in contrast to ( 1 1), raises a problem for the generalization of the remnant VP-raising approach proposed here.
16.
See Taraldsen (1 983), Vtkner (1987), Svenonius (1994), Haider (1997).
17.
Except in the special case discussed in Section 6: When modified by (the Swedish equivalent of) right, the particle must follow the direct object even in Swedish.
18.
Actually, a particle will raise across the modal just in case it is outside the PredP, a constituent that properly contains the VP, on Hinterh6lzl's analysis. This distinction can be overlooked here, but will be important in Section 7.
120
KNUT TARALD TARALDSEN
19.
This conclusion is virtually forced by HinterhOlzl's (1997) observations about scope in German.
20.
The assumption of a fixed target for VP-raising may not be necessary. The central claim is rather that the SpecWP appearing in conjunction with a FocP cannot be the (only) target.
21.
A reason for dissociating VP-raising to SpecWP from the process leading to VO order in general might come from the fact that in the Scandinavian languages, all of them VO languages, the VP is not raised to a position preceding an internal complement raised to SpecNegP.
22.
Sentences with the word order of (54) remain derivable to the extent that the embedded VP can also be extracted from the matrix vP, an option which I take (modem) Scandinavian languages and English not to have, but which may have been available to Middle Icelandic; cf. Hr6arsd6ttir (1999, this volume).
23 .