The Evolutionary Biology of the Bivalvia
Geological Society Specia l Publication s Series Editors A. J . HARTLEY R. E . HOLDSWORT H
A. C . MORTO N M. S.STOKE R
Special Publicatio n reviewin g procedure s The Society makes every effor t t o ensure that the scientifi c and production qualit y of its book s matches tha t o f it s journals. Sinc e 1997 , al l boo k proposal s hav e bee n referee d b y specialis t reviewers a s wel l a s b y th e Society' s Publication s Committee . I f th e referee s identif y weaknesses i n the proposal, thes e mus t be addressed befor e th e proposal i s accepted . Once the book is accepted, the Society has a team of series editor s (liste d above) who ensure that the volume editors follo w strict guidelines on refereeing an d quality control. We insist that individual paper s ca n onl y be accepte d afte r satisfactor y review b y tw o independen t referees . The question s on th e revie w form s ar e simila r to thos e fo r Journal o f th e Geological Society. The referees' form s an d comments must be available to the Society's serie s editor s o n request. Although man y of th e book s resul t fro m meetings , th e editor s ar e expecte d t o commissio n papers tha t wer e no t presente d a t th e meetin g t o ensur e tha t th e boo k provide s a balance d coverage o f th e subject . Bein g accepte d fo r presentatio n a t th e meetin g doe s no t guarante e inclusion i n the book . Geological Societ y Specia l Publication s are include d in th e IS I Scienc e Citatio n Index , bu t they do not have an impact factor, the latter being applicabl e onl y to journals. More informatio n about submittin g a proposal an d producin g a Specia l Publicatio n ca n b e found o n the Society's we b site: www.geolsoc.org.uk.
GEOLOGICAL SO
ETY SPECIA L PUBLICATIO N NO . 17 7
The Evolutionary Biolog y o f the Bivalvi a
EDITED BY
E. M. HARPE R Cambridge University, UK
J. D. TAYLOR
The Natural History Museum, UK
& J. A. CRAM E
British Antarctic Survey, UK
2000
Published b y The Geological Society London
THE GEOLOGICA L SOCIET Y The Geological Societ y o f London wa s founded i n 180 7 an d is the oldest geologica l societ y i n the world. I t receive d its Royal Charter i n 182 5 for the purpose o f 'investigatin g the mineral structur e of the Earth' an d is now Britain' s national society for geology . Both a learned societ y an d a professional body, the Geological Societ y i s recognized b y the Department o f Trade and Industry (DTI) a s the chartering authorit y for geoscience, abl e to award Chartered Geologis t statu s upon appropriately qualifie d Fellows. Th e Society ha s a membership o f 9099, of whom about 150 0 liv e outside th e UK. Fellowship o f the Society i s open to persons holdin g a recognized honour s degree i n geology o r a cognate subject , or not less tha n six years' relevan t experience i n geology o r a cognate subject . A Fellow wit h a minimum of fiv e years' relevan t postgraduate experienc e i n the practice o f geology ma y apply for chartered status . Successful applicants are entitled to use the designatory postnominal CGeo l (Chartered Geologist) . Fellow s o f the Society may use the letters FGS . Othe r grades o f membership ar e available t o members no t yet qualifying fo r Fellowship . The Society ha s its own Publishing House based i n Bath, UK. It produces the Society's internationa l journals, books an d maps, and is the European distributo r for publications of the American Associatio n o f Petroleu m Geologists (AAPG) , the Society fo r Sedimentary Geolog y (SEPM ) an d the Geological Societ y o f America (GSA) . Members o f the Society ca n buy books a t considerable discounts . The Publishing House has a n online booksho p (http://bookshop.geolsoc.org.uk). Further information on Society membershi p may be obtained fro m th e Membership Service s Manager , Th e Geological Society , Burlingto n House, Piccadilly , London W1V OJU (E-mail: enquiries@ geolsoc.org.uk : Tel: +44 (0) 207 434 9944) . The Society's We b Site can be found a t http://www.geolsoc.org.uk/The Society i s a Registered Charity , number 210161. Published by The Geological Societ y from : The Geological Societ y Publishin g House Unit 7, Brassmill Enterprise Centr e Brassmill Lan e Bath BA1 3JN , UK (Orders: Tel . +44 (0)1225 44504 6 Fax+44 (0)1225 442836 ) Online bookshop: http://bookshop.geolsoc.org.u k The publishers mak e no representation, express o r implied, with regard t o the accuracy of the informatio n contained in this book and cannot accept any lega l responsibility fo r any errors o r omissions tha t may b e made. © The Geological Societ y o f London 2000. All right s reserved. No reproduction, cop y or transmission of this publication ma y be made without written permission. N o paragraph o f this publication may be reproduced, copie d or transmitted sav e with the provisions o f the Copyrigh t Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, Londo n W1P 9HE. User s registere d wit h the Copyright Clearance Center, 2 7 Congress Street , Salem , MA 01970, USA: the item-fee cod e for this publication is 0305-8719/00/$15.00. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record fo r this book is available fro m th e British Library . ISBN 1-86239-076- 2 ISSN 0305-8719
Typeset b y E & M Graphics, Bath , UK Printed by Alden Press, Oxford , UK.
Distributors USA AAPG Bookstor e PO Box 979 Tulsa OK 74101-0979 USA Orders: Tel. + 1 918 584-255 5 Fax+1 918560-2652 E-mail bookstore@ aapg.org Australia Australian Mineral Foundation Booksho p 63 Conyngham Stree t Glenside South Australia 506 5 Australia Orders: Tel . +61 8 8 379-044 4 Fax+6188 379-463 4 E-mail bookshop@ amf.com.au India Affiliated East-Wes t Press PV T Ltd G-l/16 Ansari Road , Daryaganj , New Delhi 11000 2 India Orders: Tel . +91 1 1 327-9113 Fax+91 1 1 326-0538 E-mail affiliat @ nda. vsnl. net, in Japan Kanda Book Tradin g Co . Cityhouse Tama 20 4 Tsurumaki 1-3-1 0 Tama-shi Tokyo 206-003 4 Japan Orders: Tel. +81 (0)423 57-7650 Fax+81 (0)42357-7651
Contents Preface vi
i
HARPER, E. M, TAYLOR, J. D. & CRAME, J . A. Unravelling the evolutionary biology of th e Bivalvia: a multidisciplinary approach 1 STEINER, G . A. & HAMMER, S . Molecular phylogeny of the Bivalvia inferre d from 18 S rDNA sequences wit h particular reference to the Pteriomorphia 1
1
CAMPBELL, D . C. Molecular evidence on the evolution of the Bivalvia 3
1
CARTER, J. G., CAMPBELL , D. C . & CAMPBELL, M. R . Cladistic perspectives on early bivalve evolution 4
7
COPE, J. C. W. A new look a t early bivalve phylogeny 8
1
SKELTON, P. W. & SMITH , A . B. A preliminary phylogeny for rudist bivalves: siftin g clade s from grade s 9
7
HARPER, E. M., HIDE, E. A. & MORTON, B . Relationships between the extant Anomalodesmata: a cladistic test 12
9
LYDEARD, C., MINTON , R . L. & WILLIAMS, J . D. Prodigious polyphyl y in imperilled freshwater pearly-mussels (Bivalvia: Unionidae): a phylogenetic tes t of species and generic designation s 14
5
BOGAN, A . E. & HOEH, W . R. On becoming cemented: evolutionary relationships amon g th e genera in the freshwater bivalv e family Etheriida e (Bivalvia: Unionidae) 15
9
HEALY, J. M., KEYS, J. L. & DADDOW, L . Y. M. Comparative sper m ultrastructure i n pteriomorphian bivalves with special referenc e t o phylogenetic an d taxonomic implication s 16
9
KEYS, J . L. & HEALY, J . M. Relevance o f sperm ultrastructure t o the classification o f giant clam s (Mollusca, Cardioidea, Cardiidae , Tridacnidae) 19
1
TAYLOR, J. D. & GLOVER , E . A. Functional anatomy, chemosymbiosis and evolution of th e Lucinidae 20
7
KELLY, S . R. A., BLANC , E. , PRICE , S . P. & WHITHAM, A . G . Early Cretaceous gian t bivalve s from seep-relate d limestone mounds , Wollaston Forland, Northeas t Greenland 22
7
MORTON, B . The function o f pallial eyes within the Pectinidae, wit h a new description o f those present in Patinopecten yessoensis 24
7
LOPES, S. G. B . C. , DOMANESCHI , O. , MORAES , D . T . DE, MORITA, M . & MESERANI , G . D E L. C . Functional anatom y of the digestive syste m of Neoteredo reynei (Bartsch , 1920 ) an d Psiloteredo healdi (Bartsch, 1931 ) (Bivalvia: Teredinidone) 25
7
BENINGER, P. G. & DUFOUR, S . C. Evolutionary trajectories of a redundant feature: lessons fro m bivalve gill abfronta l cili a an d mucocyte distributions 27
3
THOMAS, R . D . K. , MADZAMUSE , A., MANNI, P. K. & WATHEN , A. J . Growth patterns of noetiid ligaments: implication s o f developmental model s fo r the origin o f an evolutionary novelt y amon g arcoid bivalves 27
9
YANCEY, T. E. & HEANEY, III, M . J. Carboniferous praecardioid bivalve s fro m th e exceptiona l Buckhorn Asphalt biota of south-central Oklahoma, USA 29
1
VI CONTENT
S
MALCHUS, N. Evolutionary significanc e o f fossil larval shel l characters: a case stud y from th e Ostreiodea (Bivalvia : Pteriomorphia ) 30
3
SAVAZZI, E. Morphodynamics of Bryopa an d the evolution of the clavagellids 31
3
BYRNE, M. Calcium concretions i n the interstitial tissue s of the Australian freshwater musse l Hyridella depressa (Hyriidae ) 32
9
ROGALLA, N. S . & AMLER, M. R. W. Teranota an d its implications o n anomalodesmatan phylogen y 33 9 CRAME, J. A. The nature and origin of taxonomic diversity gradients in marine bivalves 34
7
JABLONSKI, D., ROY , K . & VALENTINE , J. W. Dissecting the latitudina l diversity gradient i n marine bivalves 36
1
MIKKELSEN, P. M. & BIELER , R . Marine bivalves of the Florid a Keys : discovered biodiversity 36
7
DAGUIN, C . & BORSA , P . Genetic relationships of Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarc k populations worldwide: evidence from nuclear-DN A markers 38
9
CRAMPTON, J. S. & MAXWELL, P. A. Size: al l it's shaped up to be? Evolution of shape through the lifespan o f the Cenozoic bivalve Spissatella (Crassatellidae ) 39
9
JOHNSON, A. L . A., HICKSON , J. A., SWAN , J., BROWN , M. R. , HEATON , T. H. E., CHENERY , S. & BALSON, P. S. The Queen Scallop Aequipecten opercularis: a new sourc e of information on th e late Cenozoic marin e environments in Europe 45
2
PECK, L. S . & CONWAY, L. Z. The myth of metabolic col d adaptation : oxyge n consumptio n i n stenothermal Antarcti c bivalves 44
1
EDELAAR, P . Phenotypic plasticit y o f burrowing depth i n the bivalve Macoma balthica: experimental evidenc e an d general implication s 45
1
CADEE, G. C. Herring gull s feeding on a recent invader in the Wadden Sea, Ensis directus 45
9
SEED, R., RICHARDSON , C . A. & SMITH , K. Marine mussels , their evolutionary success , ecological significanc e an d use as chronometers o f environmental change 46
5
Index 47
9
It is recommended tha t reference to all or part of this book shoul d be made in one of the following ways: HARPER, E. M., TAYLOR , J. D . & CRAME , J. A . (eds ) 2000. Th e Evolutionary Biology o f th e Bivalvia. Geologica l Society , London, Special Publications , 177 . MORTON, B. 2000. Th e functio n o f pallial eyes withi n the Pectinidae, wit h a new descriptio n of thos e present i n Patinopecte n yessoensi s In : HARPER , E. M., TAYLOR , J. D. & CRAME , J. A. (eds) Th e Evolutionary Biology o f th e Bivalvia. Geologica l Society, London , Specia l Publications, 177 , 247-257 .
Preface Bivalves are key components o f Recent marine and freshwater ecosystems , an d have been s o for mos t of th e Phanerozoic . Bivalve s hav e undergon e a n almost relentles s increas e i n diversit y an d hav e exploited a number of varied life habits. Many have abandoned th e primitive burrowin g habit t o attac h to surface s b y flexibl e byssa l threads , o r rigi d attachment b y cementation , o r t o bor e int o rock , shells an d wood, or simply t o rest o n the sedimen t surface. Others swim, at least if danger threatens. In the deep oceans the septibranchs are predatory. The shells o f bivalves - throug h thei r shape , arrange ment o f muscl e scars , hinges , ligaments , growt h lines, microstructur e and chemistry - revea l mor e information abou t the life habits of the animal than for an y other molluscan class. The shell provides a continuous and detailed record of shell growth from the larva l phase t o maturity , a facto r allowin g th e study o f th e bot h chemica l an d structura l signa tures, which may, in turn, be used to interpret both ontogenetic and palaeoenvironmental histories. I t is for thes e reason s tha t palaeontologist s hav e lon g been to the forefront o f evolutionary an d functional studies of bivalves. The lon g histor y o f bot h zoologica l an d palaeontological researc h o n th e bivalve s ha s revealed a startlin g degre e o f convergenc e an d parallel evolutio n whic h ha s hampere d th e inter pretation o f thei r evolutionar y history . However , new discoverie s an d development s mak e i t timel y for a new concerte d effor t to integrat e zoologica l and palaeontologica l technique s t o improv e comprehension o f th e evolutionar y histor y o f th e
class. Molecula r phylogenies , couple d wit h multicharacter morphologica l studies , promis e t o improve th e understandin g o f relationships , alon g with ne w discoverie s o f earl y Palaeozoi c fauna s which illuminat e th e scan t knowledge o f the earl y radiation o f th e class . Th e discover y o f chemo symbiotic relationships, an d the location o f divers e and specialize d bivalve s i n th e dee p sea , hydro thermal vents , cold seep s an d submarine caves , ar e continuously expandin g conception s o f th e morphological range of the class . The Biology and Evolution of the Bivalvia meeting, organized on behalf o f the Malacologica l Society of London, was held in Cambridge (UK) in September 1999 . Attended by nearly 12 0 scientists, it wa s th e firs t internationa l bivalv e meetin g o f zoologists and palaeontologists to be held for over 20 years . Thi s boo k contain s a selectio n o f th e papers presented a t the meeting. We ar e extremely gratefu l t o th e followin g peopl e wh o reviewed papers for the present volume: L. Adamkewicz, M. Amler , E . B . Andrews , M . Angel , A . E . Bogan , J . Buckland-Nicks, C . A . Campbell , J . G . Carter , A . Chartrosse, A . Checa , J . C . W . Cope, J . Davenport , M . Foote, G . Giribet , E . Glover , S . Gofas , E . Gosling , G . Haszprunar, A. Hodgson. J. D. Hudson, J. Hutchinson, D. Jablonski, A . L. A. Johnson, P. A. Johnston, D. S . Jones, H. Jones , M . B . Jones , D . Lees , D . T . J. Littlewood , C . Lydeard, B . Morton , L . S . Peck , H . O . Portner , P . Rainbow, C. A. Richardson, L. R. Saul, J. Schneider, P . W. Skelton, A . B . Smith, G . Steiner , T . Steuber , A . R . H . Swan, J. A. Todd and T. R. Waller.
Liz Harper, John Taylor & Alistair Crame
This page intentionally left blank
Unravelling the evolutionary biology of the Bivalvia: a multidisciplinary approac h E. M. HARPER 1, J. D. TAYLOR2 & J.A. CRAME 3 1 Department of Earth Sciences, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EQ, UK (e-mail: emh21@ cus.cam.ac.uk) 2 Department of Zoology, The Natural History Museum, London SW7 5BD, UK 3 British Antarctic Survey, Madingley Road, Cambridge CBS OET, UK
Bivalves hav e bee n importan t member s o f marin e communities since the early Palaeozoic, i n terms of both their numerical abundance and diversity. They are particularl y prevalen t i n shallo w shel f sediments, bu t the y hav e als o conquere d th e intertidal zone as well a s the dee p sea , where they are successfu l predator s an d ke y component s o f some ven t communities . The y hav e als o invade d freshwater system s a number of times, where today they ar e important (and costly) foulers. I n terms of general communit y structure , bivalve s ar e important a s pre y item s fo r a rang e o f differen t predatory groups , an d a s majo r spac e occupiers , particularly o n hard substrat a where spac e ma y be limited. The abundance and diversity of both Recent and fossil bivalve s hav e mad e the m attractiv e subject s for bot h zoologist s an d palaeontologists , an d bot h disciplines hav e contribute d t o th e presen t syste m of classificatio n an d th e understandin g o f thei r phylogenetic relationships . However , somewha t inevitably, th e focu s o f th e tw o group s ha s bee n rather different , wit h zoologist s concentratin g o n anatomical characters suc h as those associated with the gills and stomach, whils t palaeontologists hav e necessarily dwel t o n hard-par t character s suc h a s dentition an d shel l microstructure . I t i s becomin g increasingly clear , however , tha t convergenc e an d parallelism i s rif e withi n th e clas s an d mor e integrated approache s ar e necessar y t o unrave l these. The las t majo r attemp t t o integrat e th e palaeo ntological an d zoologica l approache s t o bivalv e evolution was more than 20 years ago, at the Royal Society o f London meetin g i n 1977 . Th e resultin g volume o f th e Philosophical Transactions o f th e Royal Society o f London, Volum e 284 , i s stil l a benchmark volume . I n particular, a n earl y attemp t at a cladisti c analysi s o f th e Pteriomorphi a b y Waller (1978 ) an d paper s o n th e origi n an d
taxonomic diversificatio n o f th e bivalve s (Pojet a 1978) an d th e rostroconch s (Runnega r 1978 ) ar e still widel y cited . However , i n 197 7 th e Treatise volumes (Co x e t al 1969 ; Stenze l 1971 ) were stil l very muc h i n vogu e a s a reliabl e dat a source , although even then there was a feeling that it was in need o f a comprehensiv e revisio n (Yong e 1978) . This sentimen t ha s bee n echoe d eve r since , mos t strongly b y Johnsto n & Haggar t (1998 ) i n thei r introduction t o Bivalves: A n Eo n o f Evolution. Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. The Royal Society volume was also written at a tim e whe n cladisti c studie s wer e virtuall y unknown and there was not the wealth of molecular techniques a t han d t o tackl e question s o f phylogeny. Th e enormou s change s whic h hav e taken plac e i n th e wa y i n whic h evolutionar y processes ar e thought about has changed during the last 2 0 years , a s hav e th e numbe r o f taxa , bot h Recent an d fossil, that have been discovere d during this period , bot h o f whic h hav e inspire d thi s volume o f multidisciplinar y paper s fro m bot h palaeontologists an d zoologists.
Bivalve classification an d phylogen y Despite th e long scientifi c interes t i n bivalves, th e relationships betwee n th e highe r tax a ar e perhap s surprisingly unresolved . Certainl y th e Treatise classification i s no w dated , bu t eve n mor e recen t schemes ar e ofte n deepl y conflicting , probabl y because o f their reliance o n singl e or small group s of character s (Starabogato v 1992 ; Morto n 1996 ; Salvini-Plawen & Steine r 1996 ; Walle r 1998 ; Amler 1999) . Th e relativel y recen t boo m i n molecular technique s i s of great potentia l her e and two papers in this volume have used them to try to elucidate th e relationship s betwee n highe r taxa . Steiner & Hammer have use d a n analysi s o f 18 S rDNA sequences in order to tackle the phylogenetic
From: HARPER , E. M., TAYLOR, J. D. & CRAME, J. A. (eds) The Evolutionary Biology of th e Bivalvia. Geological Society , London, Special Publications, 177, 1-9 . 1-86239-076-2/007 $ 15.00 © The Geological Society of London 2000 .
2E
. M . HARPE R ET AL.
relationships o f the pteriomorphs, both i n terms of the majo r pteriomorp h tax a (such as the ostreoids , pinnoids an d pterioids , etc.) , an d betwee n th e Pteriomorphia a s a whol e an d th e othe r majo r bivalve clade s (e.g . protobranchs , heteroconchs , anomalodesmatans). Thei r researche s support s the monophyly o f th e Protobranchia , Heteroconchi a and Pteriomorphia , an d floa t th e ide a tha t th e Heteroconchia an d Pteriomorphi a ma y b e siste r taxa. Withi n th e pteriomorphs , ther e i s stron g support fo r tw o majo r clades , ([Pinnoide a (Ostreoidea + Pterioidea) ] an d [(Anomioide a + Plicatuloidea) + (Limioide a + Pectinoidea)] . Further molecula r studie s ar e presente d b y Campbell, als o usin g th e 18 S gene , wh o investigated th e relationships betwee n a wide range of bivalv e superfamilies , order s an d subclasses . Gratifyingly, h e foun d al l superfamilies , whic h have bee n establishe d o n morphologica l grounds , appeared monophyletic , a s were most orders. Only the Myoid a appea r polyphyletic , thu s confirming the suspicion s o f som e previou s worker s (e.g . Momsetal. 1991) . Palaeontologists face the fascinating but difficul t challenge o f trying to test various models of bivalve phylogeny wit h th e know n fossi l record . A t fac e value th e tas k shoul d b e relativel y simpl e a s th e bivalves have , b y virtu e o f their robus t calcareou s valves, a n excellen t fossi l record , bu t thi s ha s no t proved t o b e th e case . I t i s particularl y difficul t because followin g th e goo d fossi l recor d o f th e earliest widel y accepte d bivalve s (Fordilla an d Pojetaia), whic h ar e relativel y abundan t from th e Tommotian o f Nort h America , Europ e an d Australasia, there is an unfortunate gap in the fossi l record o f th e clas s tha t span s fro m th e middl e Middle Cambrian-Earl y Ordovician , som e 4 % o f the entire evolutionary history of the class (Harpe r 1998). Unhappily , thi s ga p i n th e fossi l recor d appears t o cove r a perio d o f majo r evolutionar y changes withi n the class, for on their reappearanc e the bivalve s ar e large r an d mor e divers e bot h taxonomically and in life habits. None the less, new discoveries i n th e las t decad e hav e improve d current knowledg e o f earl y Palaeozoi c bivalv e faunas. Thes e finding s have inspired tw o papers in this volume which tackle the problem in two rather different ways . Carter e t al. hav e undertake n a n ambitiou s cladistic analysi s of 6 2 bivalv e taxa of Palaeozoi c age, including a number of equivocal forms suc h as Tuarangia, usin g 11 7 character s derive d almos t exclusively fro m th e hard-parts. The larg e number of character s (an d states) an d taxa has limite d this study t o a heuristic analysis , an d th e analysi s has revealed 411 most parsimonious trees. Doubtless an increase i n compute r powe r i n th e nex t fe w year s will allo w mor e exhaustiv e searche s an d furthe r
character refinemen t ma y reduc e th e number s o f possible models . Th e paper i s accompanied b y ful l character description s an d th e dat a matri x whic h will allow such future re-analysis. Despit e the large number o f tree s produced , th e consensu s tree s d o introduce a numbe r o f interestin g conclusions , some o f whic h suppor t th e conclusio n o f previou s studies, such as Waller (1998), on the basal position of th e Mytiloide a amongs t th e pteriomorphs , an d the basa l dichotom y withi n th e palaeotaxodont s between th e Nuculanoide a an d th e Nuculoide a + Solemyoida. The y als o suppor t th e vie w o f share d ancestry o f th e Nuculoide a an d th e palaeoheterodonts. I n othe r areas , however , th e author s come t o rathe r differen t conclusion s t o thos e reached b y others. The most striking o f these is the rejection o f th e popula r notio n tha t th e Bivalvi a were derive d fro m th e rostroconchs , preferrin g instead a stenothecoi d monoplacophora n origin . Elsewhere the y ar e a t odd s wit h Walle r (1998) , rejecting a link betwee n th e Anomalodesmat a an d the Heteroconchs, preferrin g t o place the former as a sister group to the pteriomorphs. Again , there are striking anomalie s betwee n th e result s o f thi s analysis an d thos e o f molecula r studies . Cop e has used a mor e traditiona l approach , base d o n th e culmination of detailed research o f a range of early Ordovician bivalv e faunas. He bases his scheme on dentition, shel l microstructur e an d inferre d gil l grade. Cop e identifie s th e evolutio n o f th e filibranch gill, which he infers from dental changes , as providin g th e initia l impetu s fo r th e diversification o f th e bivalve s i n eithe r th e lates t Cambrian o r earlies t Ordovician . H e recognize s two subclasses ; (1 ) the Protobranchia - includin g the Nuculoidea and chemosymbiotic forms such as the solemyoids ; (2 ) the Autolamellibranchiata from whic h h e derive s thre e principa l stocks , th e Trigonioida, th e Anomalodesmat a an d th e Heteroconchia, whic h he believes the n gav e rise to the Pteriomorphia . Two othe r paper s i n th e volum e dea l wit h th e phylogenetic relationship s o f enigmati c highe r bivalve taxa. In a major new synthesis , Skelton & Smith presen t a firs t attemp t a t a comprehensiv e phylogeny fo r th e rudists , a n extinc t grou p o f sessile, epifauna l bivalves tha t flourishe d i n war m temperate an d tropical sea s fro m th e Lat e Jurassi c to th e Lat e Cretaceous . Thei r cladisti c stud y wa s based o n 3 3 skeleta l character s an d 3 1 species , representing eac h o f the highe r tax a recognized i n previous classificatio n schemes . On e o f th e te n most parsimoniou s tree s obtaine d fro m thei r stud y was selected a s a working hypothesis. This showed many o f th e basi c phylogeneti c relationship s established by early workers, suc h as Douville and MacGillavry, wer e perfectly sound. An oute r shel l layer o f fibrilla r prismati c calcit e i s a diagnosti c
INTRODUCTION 3
synapomorphy for all rudists an d attachment t o the substrate b y on e o r th e othe r valv e provide s a fundamental divisio n int o tw o stocks . Othe r features show n b y th e cladogra m includ e th e monophyletic status of the uncoiled rudists, as well as established families suc h as the Radiolitidae an d Hippuritidae. Important ne w ligh t i s she d o n th e origin o f th e latte r famil y b y it s sister-grou p relationship wit h the polyconitid genu s Tepeyacia, from the Albian of Mexico. There is every prospect that future iteration s o f this stud y will refine rudis t phylogeny even further . Deep-sea carnivor y i s jus t on e o f som e rathe r unusual lifestyle s foun d amongs t member s o f th e bivalve subclas s Anomalodesmata . Thi s grou p comprises 1 4 extan t familie s o f morphologicall y disparate bivalves, many from th e deep sea , whose classification an d phylogeneti c relationship s hav e been highly confused. Harpe r e t al. us e a cladistic analysis of a set of anatomical and shel l character s in a n attemp t t o determin e relationship s amongs t this divers e group . On e conclusio n fro m thi s analysis i s that carnivor y ha s arise n independentl y within tw o separat e clades . Tree s generate d fro m shell characters alon e were incongruent with those derived fro m th e tota l evidenc e o f anatom y an d shell, suggestin g tha t althoug h anomalodesmatan s have a lon g fossi l recor d i t ma y b e difficul t t o integrate fossils int o such an analysis. Bivalves pla y a majo r rol e i n freshwate r communities, wher e the y ar e significan t i n wate r filtering, an d thei r larva l phase s ar e importan t parasites o f fish , whils t thei r propensit y t o sprea d has mad e the m importan t biofouler s (Aldridg e 1999). Because o f the natur e o f freshwater bodies, many tax a ar e endemi c t o specifi c region s an d hence i t i s probabl e tha t they , abov e al l othe r bivalves, ma y sho w extrem e degree s o f morpho logical convergence . Similarly , man y geographi cally restricte d tax a ar e a t grea t dange r fro m extinction. Lydear d e t al . hav e use d th e mitochondrial cytochrom e C oxidase subuni t I and 16S rRN A gen e sequence s t o examin e th e phylogenetic relationship s o f fiv e specie s o f Gul f Coastal unioni d generally accepte d as belonging t o three differen t genera . Thes e ar e particularl y important tax a a s the y ar e al l considere d endangered. Their analyses found tha t the five taxa were all distinct and the 'genera ' in which they had previously bee n disperse d i n wer e polyphyletic . The threa t o f morphologica l convergenc e ham pering classificatio n i s a n issu e wit h th e thre e unionid gener a o f cementin g 'freshwate r oysters ' [Etheria (Africa) , Acostaea (Sout h America ) an d Pseudomulleria (India)] . Despit e th e fac t tha t th e cemented habi t withi n th e Bivalvi a a s a whol e i s well know n t o b e polyphyleti c (Yong e 1979 ) an d that thes e freshwate r cementer s hav e highl y
disjunct geographi c distributions , the y hav e traditionally bee n place d withi n a monophyleti c family, th e Etheriidae . Boga n & Hoe h hav e integrated ne w cytochrom e C oxidas e subuni t I DNA sequences from thes e three taxa with existing data fro m othe r unioni d tax a fro m aroun d th e world. Thei r finding s d o no t suppor t a clos e relationship betwee n th e thre e genera , suggestin g rather tha t th e cemente d habi t ha s arise n a t leas t twice. The y als o pos e th e rathe r interestin g question a s to why the cemented habi t migh t hav e evolved in the firs t place , notin g that ther e are no recorded freshwate r cementer s i n eithe r Nort h America o r China , th e majo r hub s o f unioinoi d diversity. Comparative morpholog y continue s t o b e a n important too l i n ou r effort s t o determin e phylogenetic relationship s amongs t bivalves . A major benefi t fro m th e introductio n o f cladisti c methods in phylogenetic reconstruction has been in the objectiv e definitio n o f character s an d thei r states. Concomitantly , ther e ha s bee n a searc h fo r new types o f characters and two papers sho w ho w detailed morphologica l studie s o f bivalv e sperm , using transmissio n electro n microscopy , ca n generate set s o f phylogeneticall y importan t characters. In the first paper, Healy et al. use sperm characters to explore relationship s within the larg e bivalve subclas s Pteriomorphia , e.g . showin g how the Ostreoide a an d Limoidea ar e probabl y closel y linked, a s ar e th e Pterioidea , Pinnoide a an d Pectinoidea. B y contrast, sperm character s sugges t that the Arcoidea an d Limopsoidea are less closely related than generally supposed. At a more detaile d level, Key s & Heal y us e character s o f sper m ultrastructure t o explor e relationship s amongs t th e living specie s of giant clams - Tridacninae . Sper m data support s a clos e relationshi p betwee n gian t clams an d cardiid bivalves, but perhaps indicate s a separate origin of Hippopus an d the other Tridacna species. Amongs t th e specie s o f Tridacna, T . squamosa share s mor e character s wit h T . gigas than wit h th e othe r specie s i n th e subgenus , Chametrachea, wher e i t i s usuall y placed ; a conclusion supporte d b y some molecular data .
Bivalve form and functio n The great diversity of bivalve life habits is reflected in a wide range of morphological variatio n i n terms of bot h shel l an d anatomy . Th e semina l wor k o f Stanley (1970 ) provide d a firm basis for the use of shell character s t o infe r th e lif e habit s o f extinc t taxa an d fe w hav e approache d th e eleganc e o f th e work of C. M. Yonge in demonstrating the variation in anatomical features across the class. Despite th e established interes t i n bivalv e form an d function , there remain s a surprisin g amoun t t o d o and , i n
4
E. M . HARPE R E T AL.
particular, t o synthesiz e th e information . I t i s important to document the morphological diversit y displayed b y th e clas s an d t o investigat e th e constraints and preadaptations which have favoured some body plans and not others. Taylor & Glove r repor t tha t al l th e specie s o f Lucinidae studie d t o dat e harbou r sulphide oxidizing, chemosymbioti c bacteri a withi n thei r gills. Althoug h chemosymbiosi s i n livin g lucinid s has bee n recognize d fo r som e time , i t seem s tha t little though t ha s gon e int o it s mechanic s - i f sulphide-laden wate r i s draw n int o th e mantl e cavity alongsid e th e inhalan t respirator y current , how i s oxidizatio n prevente d befor e reachin g th e chemosymbionts? Taylo r & Glover's carefu l wor k revealed a number of adaptations by which the two sites o f respiratio n an d chemosynthesi s ar e partitioned, e.g . by the detache d anterio r muscl e which separate s th e oxidize d wate r tha t com e i n anteriorly fro m th e sulphide-ric h water s whic h ar e drawn i n posteriorly. Th e presenc e o f mantl e gill s on the internal surfac e o f the anterio r o f the mantle of many taxa underlines this 'switch' in the location of normal respiratory activity. Mantle gills had been described previously , bu t onl y superficiall y an d their complexit y an d tru e significanc e ha d neve r been realized . Thi s underline s th e continue d importance o f anatomica l studie s o f seemingl y familiar bivalves . Suc h i s th e importanc e o f th e chemosymbiotic relationship , tha t evolutionar y syntheses of the lucinoids should take account of it and i t i s therefor e extremel y usefu l t o no w hav e morphological character s whic h ma y b e use d a s markers for the habit . Man y of thes e feature s are demonstrable in the Silurian Ilionia suggestin g that the chemosymbiosi s withi n th e lucinoid s i s extremely ancient. In recen t year s i t ha s becom e apparen t tha t th e very distinctive chemosymbiotic bivalve communities associate d a t th e presen t da y wit h bot h ho t vents an d col d seep s ca n b e trace d bac k throug h considerable period s o f time. Suc h fauna s see m t o have bee n particularl y widesprea d i n th e Cretaceous an d Kell y e t al. recor d a furthe r occurrence i n th e Earl y Cretaceou s (Lat e Barremian) o f Wollasto n Forland , Northeas t Greenland. Sedimentologica l evidenc e indicate s that thi s i s a methan e cold-see p comple x whic h accumulated i n a mid - t o outer-shel f setting . I t i s characterized b y a larg e numbe r o f limeston e mounds, 1- 3 m in diamete r an d up t o 1. 8 m high , that occu r withi n a n otherwis e monotonous , mudstone-dominated sequence . Th e mounds reveal an interna l structur e o f calcite-cemente d tub e systems, laminate d calcit e crust s an d voi d fills . A large new species of the lucinid genus Cryptolucina is a dominan t elemen t withi n the fauna , an d there are occasiona l specimen s o f th e cryptodon t
Solemya too. However, the most distinctive bivalve within the assemblag e i s a large, ne w taxo n which is referre d t o th e anomalodesmata n famil y Modiomorphidae. Thi s ne w bivalv e reache s c. 300 mm in length b y 12 0 mm i n height, an d has a shel l whic h is , i n places , u p t o 2 8 mm thick . I t seems to be yet anothe r new gian t bivalv e taxo n associated exclusivel y with cold seeps. Members of the Pectinida e posses s th e anatomicall y mos t advanced eye s o f an y bivalv e famil y an d i t woul d seem onl y logica l t o conclud e tha t the y hav e developed thes e to provid e an advance d earl y warning system of vicinal predators. However , i n a wide-ranging review o f the functiona l significanc e of pectinid pallia l eyes , Morton suggests tha t their true purpose i s still largely unknown. He firs t add s to ou r anatomica l knowledg e o f pectini d eye s b y describing those of the boreal specie s Patinopecten yessoensis an d then goes o n to show that in almos t all tax a studie d a n escap e respons e ca n onl y b e elicited b y either tactile or chemical stimuli . Visual clues rarely , i f ever , provok e activ e swimming . I s the pectini d ey e a n exampl e o f evolutionar y overdesign? I f pectini d an d spondyli d eye s ar e indeed homologous , i t woul d sugges t tha t the y evolved befor e th e tw o familie s diverge d i n th e Early Jurassic. Sophisticated pallia l eye s ma y have been retaine d sinc e the n fo r a numbe r o f poorl y understood functions . Few organism s hav e evolve d th e capabilit y o f digesting wood , bu t th e teredini d bivalves , th e shipworms, hav e bee n successfu l i n thi s mod e o f feeding, datin g bac k t o th e earlies t Cretaceous , a time whe n angiospermou s woo d woul d hav e become abundan t i n coasta l habitats . Indeed , i n Recent ecosystem s teredinid s hav e bee n th e scourge o f human-mad e coasta l structure s an d boats mad e o f wood . However , relativel y littl e i s known abou t the evolution of this very specialize d habit. Lope s e t al . hav e describe d an d compare d the functiona l anatom y o f th e digestiv e syste m o f two woo d borin g taxa , Neoteredo reynei (Bartsch , 1920) an d Psiloteredo healdi (Bartsch , 1931) , which ar e commo n i n Brazilia n mangroves . Important difference s between th e two suggest tha t N. reyenei, with its enlarged wood-packed appendi x and ana l canal , i s more dependant o n woo d fo r it s nutrition than is Rhealdi, in which these structure s are smal l an d wher e activ e palp s hav e bee n retained, suggestin g th e importanc e o f suspensio n feeding. Ther e i s evidenc e tha t durin g ontogen y wood ma y increase i n importance i n the diet of the latter. Gill structure in bivalves has long been the focu s of functiona l an d evolutionar y studies , an d Bellinger & Dufour describ e an d discus s th e fin e structure o f th e abfronta l surfac e o f th e gil l filaments. Fro m th e supposed primitive functio n a s
INTRODUCTION 5
a mucociliar y cleanin g surfac e i n protobranc h bivalves, tw o evolutionar y trajectorie s involvin g cilia and mucocytes are proposed. One involves the progressive reductio n i n densit y o f cili a an d mucocytes, and the other involves reduction of cilia but retentio n o r increas e i n aci d mucopoly saccharide-secreting mucocytes. Many arcoi d bivalve s ar e characterize d b y a duplivincular ligament , wherei n th e lamellar laye r is embedde d i n th e fibrou s on e i n a distinctiv e series of chevrons. The one prominent exception to this typ e o f organizatio n occur s i n th e famil y Noetiidae, whic h i s characterize d b y vertical , chevron-shaped strips of lamellar ligament. At firs t sight i t woul d appea r tha t thes e tw o type s o f ligament mus t be the product o f two quite distinc t groups, bu t chanc e observation s o n a serie s o f Limopsis ligaments suggested to Thomas et al. that striking difference s i n th e for m o f th e arcoi d ligament ca n b e produce d b y onl y a ver y modes t change i n th e developmenta l process . T o develo p this idea further the y have hypothesized that , along the mantl e isthmus , alternat e zone s o f activatio n and inhibitio n contro l th e productio n o f lamella r ligament that forms either oblique sheets or vertical layers; only a single, simple change of instructions to a narrow field of cells is required to change from one patter n t o th e other . Test s provide d b y tw o contrasting set s o f mathematica l model s indicat e that thi s ma y indee d b e th e cas e an d i t ma y b e concluded that disparate growth patterns can in fact be produced by only subtle character shifts . With the current revolution in the understanding of whic h taxonomi c group s ma y o r ma y no t b e assigned t o the subclas s Cryptodont a (Johnsto n & Collom 1998) , considerabl e importanc e i s no w attached t o a prope r understandin g o f th e Palaeozoic order Praecardioida. Yancey & Heaney present som e timel y informatio n o n th e Lunulacardiidae, th e younges t praecardioid family in Nort h America . Thei r materia l come s fro m th e Pennsylvanian (Uppe r Carboniferous ) Buckhor n Asphalt biot a o f south-centra l Oklahoma , an d comprises a unique assemblage o f smal l bivalves. Some of these are definitely juveniles but others are adults that can be assigned to an unusual new taxon. Characterized b y a distinct change i n shape from a veneriform juvenile to a sub trigonal adult, this new form possesse s bot h stou t teet h an d a prominent ligament. Indeed , wer e i t no t fo r thes e latte r characters, i t coul d easil y b e confuse d wit h a conocardioid rostroconch ! The morpholog y o f larva l shell s o f bot h livin g and fossi l bivalve s ha s th e potentia l t o suppl y useful phylogeneti c information , particularl y where, as in the case o f the oysters, the post-larval shell i s pron e t o a larg e degre e o f ecophenotypi c variation. Malchu s ha s recognize d an d studie d a
number o f prodissoconch s fro m Middl e Jurassi c oysters. Carefu l examinatio n o f thei r morpholog y revealed that the ancestral larva l hing e most likel y evolved fro m a mytilid-lik e provinculum , t o produce a secondaril y symmetrica l hing e line . H e also suggest s tha t th e smal l siz e o f th e pro dissoconch I , alon g wit h the smal l P I/P I I ratios, confirm tha t th e planktotrophi c developmen t styl e seen in modern oyster s is in fact th e plesiomorphic state for the entire superfamily . The tube-dwelling clavagellid bivalves are some of th e mos t enigmati c o f al l bivalve s an d a s indicated by Harper et al., their position within the subclass Anomalodesmat a i s extremel y equivocal , their extreme morphological adaptation s apparentl y masking usefu l phylogeneti c signals . Savazz i ha s investigated th e little-know n clavagelli d Bryopa. Unlike mos t clavagellids, whic h are thought to be facultative semi-endolithi c tub e dwellers , Bryopa appears t o b e full y an d obligatoril y endolithic . Despite th e fac t tha t th e lef t valv e i s permanentl y attached t o the tube, the bivalve appear s t o migrat e forwards within the substratum throughout growth. Despite th e fac t tha t n o livin g animals , o r indee d soft parts , wer e availabl e fo r study , Savazz i wa s able t o us e morphodynami c principle s t o sugges t how this could occur. He envisages a mechanism by which the shell elongates anteriorly , slidin g the sof t parts forward , whils t th e posterio r portio n o f th e right valv e i s continuall y bein g resorbed . Th e strong inequivalvy which results is seen in none of the othe r clavagellid s and , unfortunately , i t seem s that Bryopa i s to o derive d t o provid e th e muc h needed informatio n a s t o th e affinitie s o f th e superfamily. Although th e mineralizatio n o f th e externa l shells of bivalves has been extensively studied and used as a phylogenetically useful characte r (Taylor et al . 1969 , 1973 ; Carte r 1990) , som e interna l tissues are also mineralized an d freshwater mussel s (Unionoida) ofte n hav e larg e accumulation s o f calcium granule s in their tissues . Byrne describe s the fin e structur e an d chemistr y o f abundan t orange, iron-ric h calciu m granule s i n th e Australian freshwate r musse l Hyridella. Comparison o f granul e distributio n an d com position betwee n differen t unionoid s suggest s th e existence o f phylogeneticall y significan t differ ences. Teranota i s a relativel y newl y describe d taxon , known onl y fro m th e Middl e Devonia n o f Germany. Thes e scimitar-shape d bivalve s ar e interpreted b y Rogall a & Amler a s belongin g t o the enigmatic family Orthonotidae , whose affinitie s are debate d a s belongin g t o eithe r th e modio morphids, anomalodesmatan s o r eve n th e heteroconchs. Rogalla & Amler are persuaded of an anomalodesmatan affinit y bu t suppor t a close lin k
6E
. M. HARPE R E T AL.
with th e modiomorphids . Th e discover y o f specimens i n (apparently ) lif e position , embedde d anterior-end downward s a t angle s o f 60-80 ° t o the sedimen t surface , ha s allowe d the m t o reconstruct thes e a s endobyssat e bivalve s wit h n o true siphons .
quality an d completenes s o f th e sourc e dat a fro m regional levels . A n excellent exampl e o f how thes e data ar e acquire d i s th e analysi s b y Mikkelso n & Bieler o f th e bivalv e faun a o f th e Florid a Keys . Prior t o thei r surve y onl y 16 3 specie s wer e recorded fro m th e area . Usin g a combinatio n o f original collecting , searc h o f museu m collection s and scourin g of literature records thi s list has no w Biodiversity and biogeography been increase d t o 32 5 species . Interestingly , bu t The documentatio n an d analysi s o f pattern s o f rather worrying , primar y literatur e source s biodiversity o n regional an d globa l scales , and , i n recovered onl y 44 % o f th e species , althoug h thi s particular, th e latitudina l diversit y gradient , hav e increased t o 73 % whe n 'grey ' literatur e wa s generated muc h interest , a plethor a o f hypothese s included. Museu m collection s wer e th e mos t and considerabl e controversy . Marin e bivalve s important source of records, pickin g up 77% of the have bee n ofte n use d i n suc h analyse s b y bot h species includin g 6 2 no t foun d b y othe r methods . biologists an d palaeontologists. A new analysi s o f The messag e fro m thi s pape r i s tha t a diversit y regional bivalv e fauna s by Crame shows that bot h database fo r a particula r are a base d solel y o n latitudinal an d longitudina l gradient s ar e no t a s literature record s i s likel y t o b e a sever e regular in form as supposed. There is a distinct step underestimate of th e true diversity. Molecular technique s ar e no w bein g use d i n between 2 0 an d 30° N i n th e latitudina l diversit y gradient fo r th e norther n hemispher e an d i n th e biogeographical analysi s t o tes t hypothese s con southern hemispher e th e bivalve faun a of Australi a cerning th e are a o f origi n an d movement s o f forms a distinct hotspot o f diversity. The cause s of species. Th e smoot h blu e mussel , Mytilus these large-scal e pattern s ar e likel y multipl e an d galloprovincialis, ha s a n unusuall y widesprea d complex, an d Cram e criticall y review s variou s distribution i n temperat e an d subpola r water s o f hypotheses emphasizin g tha t historical processes i n both th e norther n an d souther n hemispheres . the Neogene, suc h as the closure o f Tethys and the Introduction b y human s ma y accoun t fo r som e o f northward movement of Australia into the tropics , the distributio n pattern bu t mussel s ar e presen t i n have bee n importan t i n shapin g th e biodiversit y shell midden s predatin g Europea n arriva l i n southern Australia an d natural dispersal als o seem s patterns of a region. Jablonski et al. have also been investigatin g th e likely. Daguin & Borsa used nuclear DNA marker s latitudinal gradien t i n marin e bivalv e diversity , to determin e th e geneti c relationship s an d teas e paying particula r attentio n t o tha t presen t o n th e apart th e histor y o f Mytilus galloprovincialis eastern Pacifi c continenta l shelf . Here , thei r ver y populations aroun d th e world . The y demonstrat e comprehensive dat a se t als o pick s ou t a shar p the geneti c distinctivenes s o f the Australia n popu (50%) fal l i n the numbe r o f species a t the edg e o f lations an d reject th e hypothesis tha t these mussel s the tropics, followed by a much gentler decline into were recentl y introduce d b y humans . By contrast , Arctic regions. They believe that this gradient may the clos e similarit y o f sample s fro m th e be a positiv e functio n o f availabl e energ y and, Mediterranean, th e Nort h Pacifi c an d Chil e using a residuals analysi s to counte r th e effect s o f supports th e hypothesi s tha t mussel s i n th e latte r spatial autocorrelatio n withi n th e data set , demon- two areas hav e been introduce d recently . strate that mean sea-surface temperature is a highly significant predicto r o f bivalv e diversity . It i s als o Ecological and evolutionary trend s apparent tha t bot h infauna l an d epifauna l tax a increase i n diversity fro m th e pole s t o th e tropics , Bivalves have a crucially importan t rol e t o play in although a t somewha t differen t rates . Alon g th e the stud y o f evolutionar y lineages . Crampto n & Pacific coas t o f North America thei r ratio change s Maxwell argu e tha t outline shap e shoul d be a key significantly wit h latitude an d ther e i s preliminary morphological characte r an d proceed t o develo p a evidence fro m th e Mesozoi c fossi l recor d t o new metho d for studying it based o n Fourier shap e suggest tha t it may also change wit h time. Clearly , analysis. A n outline trac e o f either a growth stag e this is a dynamic gradient drive n by the differentia l or the complete adul t valv e i s digitized, yieldin g a diversification o f th e tw o functiona l groups . D o suite o f Fourie r coefficient s tha t describ e a factors such as the mass extinction event at the K- T spectrum o f harmonicall y relate d trigonometri c boundary and global climatic chang e have a role to curves, o r harmonics . Thes e coefficient s ca n the n play in driving thes e clad e dynamics ? be used to compare syntheti c average morphologie s Analysis o f globa l pattern s o f marin e bio - at a variety of ontogenetic an d evolutionary stages . diversity a s exemplifie d i n th e Cram e an d In a detaile d stud y o f th e shallow-burrowin g Jablonski et a l paper s i s highl y dependen t o n th e crassatellid genus , Spissatella, i t wa s show n tha t
INTRODUCTION 7
growth is strongly allometric . Ontogenetic change s in shap e o f individual s ar e invariabl y fa r greate r than tota l evolutionar y change s withi n th e genu s over c . 2 0 Ma. A n overal l stron g correspondenc e between individua l specie s ontogenie s an d evolu tionary changes in adult form strongl y suggest that heterochrony ha s bee n th e dominan t evolutionar y mechanism throughou t th e lifespa n o f Spissatella. There i s goo d evidenc e t o sugges t tha t paedo morphosis an d peramorphosi s occurre d i n approximately equa l frequencie s fro m th e lates t Oligocene onwards. Johnson et al. have highlighted the potential of the Quee n Scallop , Aequipecten opercularis, a s a tool t o investigat e Lat e Cenozoi c palaeoenviron mental change . Occurrin g a t th e presen t da y fro m Norway t o th e Adriatic , i t ha s rapid , year-roun d growth rates tha t ensure recover y o f well-resolve d records o f seasona l variation , an d a fossi l recor d that stretche s bac k int o th e Miocene . Somewha t surprisingly, an oxygen isotope palaeothermometr y study o n mid-Pliocen e shell s indicate d seasona l temperatures simila r t o thos e o f th e presen t day . This stands in marked contrast to a variety of other isotope an d genera l assemblag e dat a whic h suggests tha t th e mid-Pliocen e wa s globall y warmer than now. Perhaps th e souther n North Sea Basin wa s i n som e wa y exemp t fro m thi s genera l trend, o r mayb e eve n thes e well-preserve d fossil s suffered a degre e o f crypti c diageneti c alteration . More promisin g i n thi s particula r respec t ma y b e the stud y of microgrowth increments, fo r thes e d o show markedl y highe r maxim a an d minim a (i.e . related t o extrem e summe r an d winte r temper atures) i n th e mid-Pliocene . Carbo n isotop e an d various trac e elemen t dat a als o offe r considerabl e potential fo r studyin g variatio n i n seasonalit y patterns. The evolutio n o f physiologica l character s ha s been investigate d experimentall y b y Pec k & Con way. The y wer e particularl y concerne d wit h the concep t o f metaboli c col d adaptio n (MCA) , which i s th e hotl y debate d subjec t o f whethe r th e metabolic rates of polar ectotherms ar e elevated t o compensate fo r th e physiologica l constraint s imposed b y living a t low temperatures. Th e recen t demonstration that the muscles of certain polar fis h contain twic e th e numbe r o f mitochondri a a s temperate specie s i s taken by som e t o be evidenc e for th e operation o f MCA. The approach adopte d i n this stud y wa s t o loo k a t rate s o f oxyge n con sumption in two Antarctic bivalve species an d then to compar e th e result s wit h thos e obtaine d previ ously fro m a rang e o f lowe r latitud e taxa . I n thi s way i t wa s possibl e t o show , quit e conclusively , that rate s o f oxyge n consumptio n declin e wit h increasing latitude. Togethe r wit h a similar stud y of Q10 coefficients , th e dat a indicat e tha t ther e i s n o
significant elevatio n o f whole-organis m metabo lism a t lo w temperatures . Th e restricte d temper ature envelop e an d lo w metaboli c rate s o f pola r ectotherms ar e adaptations tha t hav e evolve d ove r at least the last 1 5 Ma, if not considerably longer . Edelaar ha s bee n investigatin g whethe r th e depth o f burrowin g i n th e deposit-feedin g tellini d Macoma balthica might b e regarded a s a trade-off between safet y fro m predator s an d acces s t o it s food source . Obviously , th e deepe r Macoma burrows th e safe r i t i s fro m surface-dwelling predators, bu t th e mor e remot e i t i s fro m it s food . The ke y questio n o f interes t her e i s whethe r organisms suc h as Macoma ca n adjus t t o optimum values by modifying their phenotype (suc h as depth of burrowing) . To tr y an d answe r this , a serie s o f laboratory experiment s wa s devise d t o investigat e depth o f burrowin g with , firstly , foo d (finel y chopped spinach ) either present or absent, and then a commo n predato r (th e shorecrab , Carcinus maenas) eithe r presen t o r absent . Th e result s showed a significan t decreas e i n burrowin g dept h when foo d wa s adde d bu t the n a significan t increase whe n a predato r wa s introduced . O n average, individua l Macoma burrowed 57 % deeper in the presence o f the shorecrab . Suc h behavioural plasticity ma y hav e a numbe r o f importan t ecological an d evolutionar y implications . Fo r example, pronounce d change s i n th e shap e o r density o f growt h ring s migh t reflec t predatio n intensity as much as a low food supply . Ensis directus, a recen t ballast-wate r invade r along Europea n Nort h Se a coasts , show s periodi c mass mortalitie s tha t ar e stil l poorl y understood . Cadee has noticed how , at certain time s durin g the winter, large numbers o f shells become exposed b y at least half their length above the sediment surface and the n canno t re-burrow . A t suc h time s the y become eas y pre y fo r herrin g gulls , wh o hav e perfected a techniqu e o f alternat e shakin g an d dropping t o brea k ope n th e shell . Thi s invariabl y causes damag e t o just the middle par t of the valv e and th e productio n o f a uniqu e typ e o f shel l fragment. Man y type s o f shel l fragmen t ar e no w known t o b e specifi c t o individua l predator s an d thus hav e considerabl e potentia l fo r palaeoeco logical studies . Presumably, avia n predators exer t a significant predatio n pressure o n intertida l an d shallow subtida l bivalve s and , therefore , th e recognition o f diagnosti c shel l damag e cause d b y these predators , whic h i s demonstrabl y differen t from taphonomi c damage , i s extremel y usefu l i n any futur e attempt s t o document thi s activit y fro m the fossil record . Marine mytili d mussel s ar e probabl y th e mos t familiar and well-studied of all bivalves. They have a hug e biomas s an d ar e majo r space-occupyin g organisms upon rocky intertida l shore s throughou t
8E
. M. HARPE R ET AL.
the world , wher e the y ar e ofte n importan t com ponents of intertidal food webs . Seed e t al. revie w the attributes that contribute towards the ecologica l success o f mytili d mussels . The y the n g o o n t o show ho w musse l bed s themselve s for m majo r habitats fo r man y othe r organisms , wit h th e composition an d structur e o f thes e communitie s remarkably simila r i n widely separate d part s of the world. Becaus e o f thei r abundanc e an d accessi bility, as well a s their importanc e a s food, mussels have bee n widel y use d a s sentine l indicator s o f environmental chang e an d pollution . See d e t al . demonstrate, b y detaile d studie s o f shel l growt h and trac e elemen t analysis , how musse l shell s can be used as chronometers o f environmental change. Their work provides a model fo r the interpretatio n of growth patterns in fossil shells.
Future direction s It would be easy to presume tha t the long traditio n of bivalv e stud y by bot h zoologist s an d palaeont ologists, an d thei r basi c familiarit y with the class , has le d to a comprehensive understandin g o f thei r evolutionary history . However, this i s fa r fro m th e case. Th e star t o f th e twenty-firs t centur y offer s many excitin g challenge s t o th e understandin g o f the evolutionary biology of the Bivalvia. Exciting discoverie s continu e t o b e mad e amongst living bivalves, and two in particular have changed th e concept s o f trophi c adaptation s an d evolution o f th e class . Bivalve s ha d lon g bee n regarded a s having two main feedin g strategie s suspension and deposit feeding - wit h a few species nutritionally dependen t o n havin g photosymbiosi s with unicellular algae. It is only 20 years since th e discovery of predatory behaviour amongst bivalves and thi s i s no w recognize d a s a majo r feedin g strategy amongs t a t leas t thre e group s o f deepe r water bivalve s (Morto n 1981) . Similarly , explor ation o f hydrotherma l vent s an d cold-see p site s over the last 20 years has revealed communitie s of bivalves nutritionall y dependen t o n symbioti c sulphur- an d methane-oxidizin g bacteria . I t i s remarkable that this chemosymbiosis has now been recognized in at least six different clade s and many species o f bivalves, living not onl y in the deep se a but als o i n shallo w wate r an d eve n intertida l habitats (Diste l 1998) . Comparativ e morpholog y suggests tha t thi s chemosymbiosi s i s a n ancien t nutritional strateg y whic h ma y dat e bac k t o th e Ordovician. The biolog y o f thes e humbl e animal s continues to surprise , a s witnesse d b y th e extraordinar y behavioural an d morphologica l adaptation s employed b y freshwater unionid bivalves t o ensure transfer o f thei r larva e t o hos t fis h species . Thes e remarkable adaptation s involv e extension s o f th e
mantle edges t o mimic fish , complet e wit h fin-lik e structures an d 'eyes' , an d als o extrude d structure s containing th e glochidian larva e whic h mimi c fis h and arthropod larvae (Haa g et al. 1995) . A remarkable recen t discover y i s that the wormlike anima l Xenoturbella, a ciliated , virtuall y organless ba g fro m norther n Europe , i s i n fac t a highly modifie d shell-les s protobranc h bivalv e (Israelsson 1999) . Thi s umaskin g o f Xenoturbella extends presen t conception s o f th e morphologica l range of bivalves. Palaeontologists als o continu e t o uneart h wonderful an d extraordinar y animal s whic h trul y extend ou r concept s o f morphologica l disparit y amongst bivalves , e.g . th e discover y o f a ne w family, th e Wallowaconchidae , o f large-vane d an d chambered Triassi c bivalve s (Yance y & Stanle y 1999), whic h ma y hav e harboure d microbia l symbionts. Whils t debat e stil l continue s ove r th e life habit s o f enigmati c extinc t tax a suc h a s th e rudists an d inoceramids , ne w discoverie s ar e gradually extendin g ou r knowledg e o f earl y Palaeozoic bivalv e evolutio n an d continuall y extending, o r otherwis e modifying , th e geologica l ranges of known groups. The most recent published compilation o f familia l range s (Skelto n & Benton 1993) i s strikingl y differen t fro m tha t published i n the Treatise an d even then its authors admit that its quality is rather 'patchy' . One of the most obvious short-term challenges is to produce a comprehensive compilatio n o f al l the available phylogeneti c informatio n an d geologica l ranges an d th e presen t author s ech o th e call s b y Yonge (1978 ) an d Johnsto n & Haggar t (1998 ) fo r an updated versio n o f the Treatise.
References ALDRIDGE, D . C . 1999 . Th e morphology , growt h an d reproduction o f Unionida e (Bivalvia ) i n a Fenland waterway. Journal ofMolluscan Studies, 65, 47-60. AMLER, M. R. 1999 . Synoptica l classification of fossil an d Recent Bivalvia . Geologica et Palaeontologica, 33, 237-248. CARTER, J. G. 1990 . Skeletal Biomineralization: Patterns, Processes an d Evolutionary Trends. Va n Nostran d Reinhold, New York . Cox, L . R . & 2 4 others . 1969 . In : MOORE , R . C . (ed. ) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca (1-2), Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y o f America, Boulder , CO , an d Universit y o f Kansa s Press, Lawrence, KS . DISTEL, D . L . 1998 . Evolutio n o f chemautotrophi c endosymbioses i n bivalves . Bioscience, 48 , 277-286. HAAG, W . R., BUTLER, R. S . & HARTFIELD, P. D. 1995 . A n extraordinary reproductiv e strateg y i n freshwate r bivalves: pre y mimicry to facilitate larva l dispersal. Freshwater Biology, 34, 471-476 HARPER, E . M . 1998 . Th e fossi l recor d o f bivalv e
INTRODUCTION 9 molluscs. In : DONOVAN , S . K . & PAUL , C . R . C . (eds) Th e Adequacy o f th e Fossil Record. Joh n Wiley and Sons, Chichester, 243-267 . ISRAELSSON, O . 1999 . Ne w ligh t o n th e enigmati c Xenoturbella (phylu m uncertain) : ontogen y an d phylogeny. Proceedings o f th e Royal Society o f London, 266B, 835-841. JOHNSTON, P . A . & COLLOM , C . J . 1998 . Th e bivalv e heresies - inoceramida e ar e Cryptodonta , no t Pteriomorphia. In: JOHNSTON , P . A. & HAGGART , J . W. (eds ) Bivalves: A n Eo n o f Evolution. Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Calgar y Universit y Press , Calgary , 347-360. & HAGGART , J . W . 1998 . In: JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART, J . W . (eds ) Bivalves: A n Eo n o f Evolution. Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D . Newell. Calgar y Universit y Press , Calgary, xi-xii. MORRIS, N. J., DICKINS, J. M . & ASTAFIEVA-URBAITIS , K . 1991. Upper Palaeozoic anomalodesmata n bivalves . Bulletin of the British Museum of Natural History (Geology Series), 47, 51-100. MORTON, B . 1981 . Pre y captur e i n th e carnivorou s septibranch Poromya granulata (Bivalvia : Anomalodesmata: Poromyacea) . Sarsia, 66 , 241-256. 1996. The evolutionar y history of the Bivalvia . In: TAYLOR, J . D . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation of the Mollusca. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 337-356. POJETA, J. 1978 . The origin and taxonomic diversification of pelecypods . Philosophical Transactions o f th e Royal Society of London, Series B, 284, 225-243 . RUNNEGAR, B . 1978 . Origi n an d evolutio n o f th e Clas s Rostroconchia. Philosophical Transactions o f the Royal Society o f London, Series B , 284 , 319-333. SALVINI-PLAWEN, L . v . & STEINER, G . 1996 . Synapomorphies an d plesiomorphie s i n highe r classification o f th e Mollusca . In : TAYLOR , J . D . (ed.) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation o f th e Mollusca. Oxfor d University Press, Oxford, 29-51. SKELTON, P . W . & BENTON , M . J . 1993 . Mollusca :
Rostroconchia, Scaphopod a an d Bivalvia . In : BENTON, M . J. (ed.) Th e Fossil Record 2. Chapma n & Hall, London, 237-263, STAROBOGATOV, Y . I . 1992 . Morphologica l basi s fo r phylogeny and classification of Bivalvia. Ruthenica, 2, 1-25 . STANLEY, S . M. 1970 . Relation o f shell form to life habits of th e Bivalvia . Geological Society o f America Memoir, 125 , 1-296 . STENZEL, H . B . 1971 . Oysters . In : MOORE , R . C . (ed. ) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca (3), Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y o f America Boulder , CO , an d Universit y o f Kansa s Press, Lawrence, KS. TAYLOR, J . D. , KENNEDY , W . J . & HALL , A . 1969 . Th e shell structur e an d mineralog y o f th e Bivalvia . Introduction, Nuculacea-Trigonacea . Bulletin of th e British Museum (Natural History), Zoology Series, Supplement, 3 , 1-125. ,& 1973 . Th e shel l structur e an d mineralogy o f th e Bivalvia . II . Lucinacea Clavagellacea, Conclusions . Bulletin o f th e British Museum (Natural History), Zoology Series, Supplement, 22 , 253-284. WALLER, T . R . 1978 . Morphology , morphocline s an d a new classificatio n o f the Pteriomorphi a (Mollusca : Bivalvia,). Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society o f London, Series B, 284, 345-365 . 1998. Origin of the molluscan Class Bivalvia and a phylogeny of the majo r groups. In: JOHNSTON , P. A. & HAGGART , J . W . (eds ) Bivalves: A n Eo n o f Evolution. Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D . Newell. Calgar y Universit y Press , Calgary, 1-45 . YANCEY, T . E. & STANLEY , G . D . 1999 . Gian t alatofor m bivalves i n th e Uppe r Triassi c o f wester n Nort h America. Palaeontology, 42, 1-23 . YONGE, C . M. 1978 . Introductory remarks. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series 5,284,201. 1979. Cementation i n bivalves. In: VA N DER SPOEL, S., VA N BRUGGEN , A . C . & LEVER , J . (eds ) Pathways i n Malacology. Bohn , Scheltema , Holkema an d Junk, Utrecht, 83-106 .
This page intentionally left blank
Molecular phylogen y o f the Bivalvia inferred fro m 18S rDNA sequences with particular reference t o the Pteriomorphia GERHARD STEINE R & SABIN E HAMME R Institute of Zoology, University of Vienna, Althanstr. 14, A-1090 Vienna, Austria (e-mail: gerhard.steiner@ univie.ac.at) Abstract: Th e classificatio n o f th e Pteriomorphia , a majo r divisio n o f th e Bivalvi a wit h Ordovician origins, is controversial both among palaeontologists and neontologists. To elucidate phylogenetic relationships new near-complet e 18 S rDNA sequences of 26 Pteriomorphia, thre e Protobranchia, thre e Heterodonta, on e Anomalodesmata an d thre e Scaphopod a wer e obtained, aligned wit h 71 other published mollusca n sequences , an d analysed wit h parsimony, maximu m likelihood an d spectra l analysis . Althoug h Bivalvi a appea r diphyleti c du e t o heterogeneit y o f substitution rate s amon g lineages , monophyl y o f Protobranchia , Heteroconchi a an d Pteriomorphia i s supported . Th e heteroconc h Lucinida , Myoid a an d Venerid a ar e no t monophyletic, an d Anomalodesmata aris e fro m withi n Heteroconchia . Th e basa l node s o f Pteriomorphia have little support but two major clades, [Pinnoidea (Ostreoidea + Pterioidea)] and [(Anomioidea + Plicatuloidea) + (Limoidea + Pectinoidea)], ar e resolved wit h more confidence . The strongl y supporte d clad e o f Anomioidea + Plicatuloidea, th e separatio n o f Pinnoidea fro m Pterioidea an d most o f the intrafamiliar relationships ar e not in accordance wit h morphologica l classifications. Combinin g these results with selected morphologica l characters, a phylogenetic hypothesis i s proposed showin g Mytiloidea and Arcoidea a s the basal pteriomorph groups , the latter givin g ris e t o th e clad e unitin g th e pinnoid-ostreoid-pterioi d an d th e anomioid limoid-pectinoid lines.
Molecular character s ar e potentiall y usefu l fo r phylogenetic studies, their usefulness depending on the tim e pas t sinc e th e cladogenese s o r split s i n question. Nucleotid e sequence s characteristicall y provide hig h numbers , usuall y hundred s o r eve n thousands, o f character s o f littl e bu t equa l complexity. They form dat a set s independent fro m morphological dat a an d ar e subjec t t o differen t selective constraints: DNA sequences, especially of ribosomal genes , ar e less selecte d b y lifestyl e an d habitat tha n i s morphology . Thi s i s especiall y important an d neede d whe n man y morphologica l characters and their underlying homology decisions are equivoca l du e t o convergen t and/o r paralle l evolution, a s i s th e cas e i n th e Bivalvia . Thus , i t may b e expecte d tha t molecula r phylogeneti c studies o n bivalves , a group notorious for paralle l evolution, wil l provid e valuabl e insight s into th e branching pattern of its higher taxa. Sequences o f th e nuclear-encode d smal l ribosomal subunit , the 18 S rDNA, are particularly popular for studyin g relationship s amon g and within phyla (e.g. Riutort et al. 1993; Philippe e t al. 1994; Winnepenninck x et al 1994 , 1996 ; Macke y et a l 1996 ; Aguinald o e t a l 1997) . Th e mai n reason fo r thi s popularit y o f thi s gene , a s
summarized b y Winnepenninck x et a l (1994) , i s the alternatio n o f variabl e an d highl y conserve d sequences, facilitatin g amplificatio n an d providing phylogenetic informatio n fo r variou s systemati c levels. The first bivalve 18S rDNA sequences were used for investigations o f relationships o f Mollusc a to other phyla and among molluscan classes (Fiel d et a l 1988 ; Winnepenninck x e t a l 1994 , 1996) . Studies o n bivalv e phylogen y inferre d fro m 18 S rDNA wer e initiate d b y Littlewoo d e t a l (1991) , Rice e t a l (1993 ) an d Kenchingto n e t a l (1994 , 1995), focusin g o n th e familie s Ostreidae , Mactridae, Pectinida e an d Mytilidae . Furthe r complete sequence s were included i n the analyses by Steiner & Mueller (1996), Frischer et al (1998) , Maruyama et al (1998 ) an d Canapa e t al (1999) , whereas Adamkewicz et al (1997 ) and Campbell et al (1998 ) relie d o n partial 18 S rDNA sequences. Monophyly o f th e Bivalvi a wa s unambiguously supported onl y b y th e analysi s o f Frische r e t a l (1998) and , i n a re-analysi s o f Steine r & Muelle r (1996), b y Giribe t & Carranza (1999 ) an d Steine r (1999). Al l othe r analyse s showe d Gastropod a o r Polyplacophora separatin g Pteriomorphi a fro m Heteroconchia. One reason for this unconventional topology wa s attributed to higher substitutio n rate s
From: HARPER, E. M, TAYLOR, J. D. & CRAME, J. A. (eds) The Evolutionary Biology of th e Bivalvia. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 177, 11-29 . 1-86239-076-2/007 $ 15.00 © The Geological Societ y o f London 2000.
12
G. STEINE R & S . HAMME R
in the heterodont and gastropod branches by Steiner & Mueller (1996). However, their study also foun d the phylogenetic signa l fo r a bivalve clad e almos t equally strong as that for competing clades. There ar e considerabl e discrepancie s i n th e molecular studies also in regard to the relationships among th e highe r bivalv e taxa , althoug h protobranchs are generally the first bivalv e branch. Frischer et al. (1998), wit h a limited se t of species , show Pteriomorphi a a s siste r grou p t o th e Heterodonta. Adamkewic z e t al . (1997 ) an d Campbell e t al . (1998 ) presen t paraphyleti c Pteriomorphia wit h respec t t o th e Heterodont a o r Heteroconchia, albei t wit h differen t topologies . A clade of Ostreoidea, Pinnoide a and Pterioidea take s a basa l positio n i n th e tre e o f Adamkewic z e t al . (1997), th e Pectinoidea ar e the siste r grou p to th e Heteroconchia, an d th e anomalodesmata n specie s roots i n the basal polytomy. In contrast, Campbel l et al . (1998) , usin g a differen t specie s set , hav e the Pectinoide a a s th e firs t autobranc h clad e and a polytom y o f Pterioidea , Ostreoide a an d Heterodonta, excludin g th e Pinnoidea . Further more, Adamkewicz et al. (1997) found n o support for th e heteroconc h group s Anomalodesmata , Veneroida and Myoida nor for the Protobranchia . The presen t stud y focuse s o n th e phylogeneti c connection o f th e Pteriomorphi a t o th e othe r bivalve tax a an d o n th e relationship s amon g th e major pteriomorph groups. Pteriomorphia appea r in the fossil recor d no later than the early Ordovician period, wher e mytiloid , arcoi d an d pterioi d forms are als o recognized . Thes e group s experience d periods o f radiatin g diversificatio n i n th e Lat e Devonian and both in the beginning and at the end of th e Mesozoi c (Carte r 1990) . Simila r t o th e molecular studies , phylogeneti c hypothese s base d on morphologica l evidenc e diffe r considerabl y in the statu s o f th e Pteriomorphi a an d i n th e sister group relationships proposed. Figur e 1 summarizes five recentl y published hypotheses . Pteriomorphia appear monophyletic in Cope (1996), Waller (1998) and Morton (1996), althoug h the latter includes the Unionida. Polyphyleti c Pteriomorphi a ar e repre sented in Carter (1990), with separat e origin of the Mytiloidea, an d i n Starobogato v (1992) , wit h Unionida an d Heterodont a separatin g tw o pterio morph groups . Th e ai m o f thi s investigation is t o provide a databas e o f near-complet e 18 S rDN A sequences wit h a t leas t tw o representative s o f al l major pteriomorp h group s an d a t leas t on e o f th e Protobranchia, Heterodont a an d Anomalodesmat a as potential sister-grou p taxa . The tree(s) resultin g from phylogeneti c reconstructio n are expecte d t o elucidate siste r group relationships of the Bivalvi a (by th e inclusio n o f scaphopo d sequences) , th e origin of the Pteriomorphia a s well as relationships within Pteriomorphia . Thes e result s ca n subse -
quently be of aid in evaluating homology decisions of morphological characters .
Materials and Methods Most specimen s sequence d i n thi s stud y wer e collected i n Safag a Ba y (Re d Sea , Egypt) , Rovin j (Northern Adriati c Sea , Croatia ) an d Trondhei m Fjord (Norway), either by scuba diving or dredging. The specie s used for the phylogenetic analyses are listed i n Tabl e 1 wit h thei r EMBL/GenBan k accession number s (sequence s obtaine d herei n ar e in bold).
DNA Extraction Total DN A wa s extracte d fro m adducto r muscle, gills or , in smal l specimens , th e tota l sof t bod y of 30 bivalves (23 pteriomorph, three heterodont, on e anomalodesmatan an d thre e protobranc h species ) and three scaphopods. Minced tissu e samples wer e incubated for 2 h at 65°C in 0.2 mL of sterile water, 5% Chelex® 100 resin (Sigma), 25 uL of proteinase K (2 0 nig mLr 1), 1 0 uL RNAse A (0. 5 m g mL- 1) and 1 0 uL dithiothreito l ( 1 M) o n a shake r an d vortexed severa l time s fo r 5 s durin g incubation. Following centrifugatio n fo r 2 min a t 1 4 000 rpm, the remaining lysate was transferred to a fresh tub e and store d a t 4°C . Dependin g o n th e qualit y an d amount o f genomi c DNA , 1- 5 u L o r appropriat e dilutions o f th e sampl e lysat e wer e use d i n th e amplification procedure .
Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) Near-complete sequence s o f th e 18 S rDN A gen e were obtained by a direct PCR product-sequencing approach. In the first step , the complete 18 S rDNA was amplifie d usin g th e primer s F (5'-CC G AAT TCG TC G AC A AC C TG G TT G AT C CTG-3' ) and R (5'-CC C GG G AT C CAA GC T TG A TC C TTC TG C AG G TT C AC C TAC-3' ) (Steine r & Mueller 1996) . Th e PC R wa s performe d o n a Robocycler 9 6 Gradien t (Stratagene ) i n a 2 5 juL reaction mi x containing 1 mM MgCl2, each dNT P at 200 juM , each primer at 50 pM, 2. 5 units of TAQ polymerase (BioTherm , Genecraft) , an d th e supplied reaction buffe r a t x 1 concentration. Afte r an initia l denaturatio n ste p o f 2 min a t 94°C , fiv e PCR cycle s o f 4 0 s a t a 50° C annealin g temperature, 4 0 s at a 72°C primer extension , an d 40 s a t a 94° C denaturatio n wer e performed , followed b y 3 5 cycle s a t a 61° C annealin g temperature an d a fina l prime r extensio n ste p o f 10 min a t 72°C . In th e secon d step , a nested PC R was performe d t o amplif y tw o overlappin g 18 S rDNA fragment s o f 105 0 an d 90 0 bas e pai r (bp )
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHIA 1
3
Fig. 1 . Comparison of five recently published morphology based phylogenetic hypotheses of pteriomorph relationships with the results obtained in the present study.
length using the tagged primer pairs: pair 1 : F*-T3 pM , primers F*-T3 and R*-T3 at 37.5 pM, 7.5 units (5'-att aa c cc t ca c ta a ag C AA C CT G GT T GA T o f TAQ polymerase (BioTherm, Genecraft), an d the CCT G-3' ) an d R2-STI 2 (5'-cg a tg a ag a ac g ca g supplie d reaction buffe r a t x 1 concentration. Each cgA GAA CTR CGA CGG TAT C-3'); pair 2: F2- o f the 35 PCR cycles consisted of 40 s at 94°C, 40 s STI2 (5'-cga tga aga acg cag cgT CAG AGG YTC a t 52°C and 60 s at 72°C, followed by a final primer GAA GAC G-3') an d R*-T3 (5'-att aac cct cac taa extensio n ste p o f 1 0 min a t 72°C . PC R product s agC CTT CTG CAG GTT CAC CTA C-3'). Lower wer e purified with either Cleanmix purification kit case letter s indicat e th e ta g sequence s (T 3 an d (Talent ) o r QIAquick-spi n PC R purificatio n ki t STI2). Neste d PC R wa s carrie d ou t i n a 7 5 uL (Qiagen) , and sequenced automatically with T3 and reaction mi x containin g 1 mM MgCl 2 eac h dNT P STI 2 sequencing primers on a LI-COR 4000 (VBCat 10 0 uM, primer s R2-STI 2 an d F2-STI 2 a t 7 5 GENOMIC S Bioscience Researc h GmbH) .
14 G
. STEINE R & S. HAMME R
Table 1 . Species used in the phylogenetic analysis Systematic positio n BIVALVIA Pteriomorphia Arcoidea Arcidae
Noetiidae Glycymerididae Mytiloidea Modiolinae Mytilinae
Lithophaginae Pinnoidea Pinnidae Pterioidea Pteriidae
Isognomonidae Malleidae Ostreoidea Gryphaeidae Ostreidae, Ostreina e Ostreidae, Lophina e Ostreidae, Crassostreina e Anomioidea Anomiidae Plicatuloidea Plicatulidae Limoidea Limidae Pectinoidea Spondylidae Pectinidae
Species
EMBL/GENBANK accession numbe r
Area noae Linne, 175 8 Acarplicata (Dillwyn , 1817 ) § Barbatia virescens (Reeve, 1844) Barbatia cancellaria (Lamarck, 1819 ) [p] Anadara ovalis (Bruguiere, 1789) [p] Striarca lactea (Linne, 1758 ) Glycymeris pedunculus (Linne , 1758 ) § Glycymeris sp .
X90960 AJ389630 X9197 AF022470, AF022471 L78852 AF120531 AJ389631 X91978
Modiolus auriculatus Krauss , 184 8 § Brachidontes variabilis (Krauss , 1848 ) § Septifer cf . bilocularis (Linne, 1758 ) § Mytilus galloprovincialis Lamarck, 1819 Mytilus californianus Conrad, 1837 Geukensia demissa (Dillwyn , 1817) Lithophaga lithophaga (Linne, 1758)
AJ389644 AJ389643 AJ389645 L33451 L33449 L33450 AF120530
Pinna muricata Linne , 175 8 § Atrina pectinata (Linne, 1767) Atrina rigida (Lightfoot, 1786 ) [p ]
AJ389636 X90961 L78850
Pteria macroptera (Lamarck , 1819 ) § Pteria hirundo (Linne , 1758 ) Pteria brevialata (Dunker, 1872) [p] Pinctada margaritifera (Linne , 1758 ) § Pinctada imbricata Roding, 1 798 [p] Electroma alacorvi (Dillwyn , 1817 ) § Isognomon legumen (Gmelin , 1791 ) § Isognomon alatus (Gmelin, 1791) [p] Malvifundus regulatus (Forsskal , 1775 ) § Vulsella sp. §
AJ389637 AF120532 L78849 AJ389638 AF022472, AF022473 AJ389641 AJ389639 AF022468, AF022469 AJ389640 AJ389642
Hyotissa cf . hyotis (Linne , 1758 ) § Hyotissa cf . numisma (Lamarck , 1819 ) • Ostrea edulis Linne, 175 8 Ostrea equestris Say , 183 4 [p ] Lopha cristagalli (Linne , 1758) § Crassostrea virginica (Gmelin, 1791 ) Saccostrea cucullata (Born , 1778) §
AJ389632 AJ389633 L49052 AF022466, AF022467 AJ389635 Z29549 AJ389634
Anomia ephippium Linne , 175 8 * Pododesmus caelata (Reeve , 1859) §
AJ389661 AJ389650
Plicatula plicata (Linn e 1767) §
AJ389651
§
Lima lima (Linne , 1758) Limaria hians (Gmelin, 1791 ) Ctenoides annulatus (Lamarck , 1819 ) §
AJ389652 AF120534 AJ389653
Spondylus erassisquamatus Lamarck, 181 9 • Spondylus hystrix Roding, 179 8 § Pecten maximus (Linne , 1758 ) Placopecten magellanicus (Gmelin, 1791 ) Flexopecten glaber (Linne , 1758 ) * Argopecten irradians (Lamarck , 1819 ) Chlamys islandica (Mulle r O.F., 1776 ) Chlamys hastata (Sowerby, 1843 ) Mimachlamys varia (Linne, 1758 )
AJ389646 AJ389647 L49053 X53899 AJ389662 LI 1265 L11232 L49049 L49051
15
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHIA Table 1. Continued Systematic position
Protobranchia Solemyida Solemyidae Nuculida Nuculidae Nuculanidae Heteroconchia Unionida Unionidae Lucinida Lucinidae Ungulinidae Veneroida Veneridae
Tellinidae Arcticidae Corbiculidae Galeommatidae Cardiidae
Mactridae
Solenidae Myoida Myidae Corbulidae Pholadidae Hiatellidae Anomalodesmata Cuspidariidae CAUDOFOVEATA Limifossoridae POLYPLACOPHORA Ischnochitonina Chitonidae Ischnochitonidae Acanthochitonina Acanthochitonidae
Species
EMBL/GENBANK accession numbe r
Crassadoma gigantea (Gray , 1825 ) Exellichlamys spectabilis (Reeve , 1853 ) § Pedum spondyloideum (Gmelin , 1791 ) §
L49050 AJ389648 AJ389649
Solemya togata (Poli , 1795 ) * [p]
AJ389658
Nucula proxima Say , 182 2 [p ] Yoldia limatula (Say, 1831 ) [p ] Yoldiella nana (Sar s M., 1865 ) t Nuculana pella (Linne , 1767 ) *
AF022476, AF022477 L78848 AJ389659 AJ389665
Anodonta imbecilis Say, 182 9 [p ] Elliptio complanata (Lightfoot , 1786 ) [p ]
L78858 L78857
Cardiolucina semperiana (Issel , 1869 ) § Ciena divergens (Philippi , 1850 ) § Diplodonta cf . subrotundata Issel , 186 9 §
AJ389655 AJ389656 AJ389654
Venus verrucosa Linne, 175 8 Callista chione (Linne, 1758 ) Dosinia discus (Reeve, 1850) [p ] Mercenaria mercenaria (Linne, 1758 ) [p ] Donax variabilis Say, 182 2 [p ] Tellina versicolorDe Kay , 1843 [p ] Arctica islandica (Linne, 1767 ) Corbicula leana Prime, 186 4 [p] Divariscintilla yoyo Mikkelsen & Bieler, 198 9 [p ] Galeomma takii Kuroda, 194 5 Tridacna gigas (Linne, 1758 ) Tridacna squamosa Lamarck, 181 9 Hippopus hippopus (Linne , 1758 ) Hippopus porcellanus Rosewater , 198 2 Fragum unedo (Linne, 1758 ) Corculum cardissa (Linne, 1758 ) Vasticardium flavu m (Linne , 1758 ) Fulvia mutica (Reeve, 1844 ) Mactromeris polynyma (Stimpson , 1860 ) Mulinia lateralis (Say, 1822 ) Spisula solida (Linne, 1758 ) Tresus nutalli (Conrad, 1837 ) Ensis directus Conrad, 184 3 [p]
AJ007614 AJ007613 L78863 L78864 L78867 U93556 U93555 L78861 L78869 X91969 D84189 D84190 D84660 D84661 D84664 D88909 D88910 D88911 L11230 L11268 L11266 LI 1269 L78871
My a arenaria Linne, 175 8 [p ] Corbula contracta Say, 182 2 [p ] Cyrtopleura costata (Linne, 1758 ) [p ] Panopea japonica A . Adams, 185 0 [p]
AF022478, M20094, M21541,M21175, J03774 L78860 L78865 L78870
Tropidomya abbreviata (Forbes, 1843 ) ^
AJ389657
Scutopus ventrolineatus Salvini-Plawen, 196 8
X91977
Liolophura japonica (Lischke , 1873 ) Acanthopleura granulata (Gmelin , 1791 ) [p ] Lepidochitona corrugata (Reeve, 1848 ) [p ]
X70210 L78872 X91975
Crytptochiton stelleri (Middendorf, 1847 ) [p ]
L78873 Table 1 continued overleaf
16
G. STEINE R & S . HAMMER
Table 1 . Continued Systematic positio n
Species EMBL/GENBAN
K accession numbe r
GASTROPODA Neritopsina Neritidae Vetigastropoda Trochidae Caenogastropoda Nassariidae Tonnidae Calyptraeidae Gymnomorpha Onchidiidae CEPHALOPODA Coleoidea Loliginidae SCAPHOPODA Dentaliida Dentaliidae
Nerita albicilla Linne , 175 8 X9197
1
Monodonta labio (Linne, 1758 ) X9427
1
Nassarius siquinjorensis (A . Adams) = crematus (Hinds , 1844 ) X9427 Bursa rana (Linne , 1758 ) X9426 Crepidula adunca Sowerby , 182 5 X9427
3 9 7
Onchidella celtica (Cuvier , 1817 ) X7021
1
Loligo pealei Lesueur, 182 1 [p] n
o ace. numbe r
Antalis vulgaris (D a Costa, 1778 ) X9198 0 3 89660 Antalis inaequicostata (Dautzenberg , 1891) * AJ Dentalium bisexangulatum Sowerby , 186 0 § AJ38966 3 Dentalium laqueatum Verrill , 188 5 " AJ38966 4
Sequences obtaine d in this stud y are in bold. Partia l sequence s ar e indicated wit h [p] . * Greece, Mediterranean; t Trondhei m Fjord , Norway ; $ Northern Adriatic ; § Safaga Bay , Re d Sea ; I Charleston, South Carolin a
Sequence alignment, choice oftaxa and phylogenetic analysis The sequences obtaine d wer e aligne d t o publishe d ones usin g CLUSTAL W (Thompso n e t al 1994 ) with subsequen t manual adjustment i n DCS E (D e Rijk & D e Wachte r 1993) , takin g int o accoun t secondary structura l informatio n whe n possible . Nearly al l bivalv e 18 S rDN A sequences wer e included i n th e alignmen t t o achiev e a dens e taxonomic representation o f species, a s advised by Lecointre e t al . (1993) . Som e heteroconc h partia l sequences o f doubtfu l qualit y an d origi n wer e excluded [e.g . th e anomalodesmata n sequence s o f Adamkewicz e t al. (1997 ) tha t ar e clustering with the Gastropoda] . Onl y tw o specie s o f th e gener a Mytilus, Tridacna an d on e representativ e o f Fragum, an d eac h mactri d genu s wer e used . Because sequenc e divergence, branc h lengths an d resolution amon g thes e tax a are minimal , thi s helped reduc e th e numbe r o f tax a i n th e analyse s and computin g tim e withou t losin g valuabl e information. Al l availabl e pteriomorp h sequence s were include d coverin g mos t majo r groups . Unfortunately, n o representativ e o f th e Dimyida e was available for sequencing. Gastropod sequences were selecte d mainl y fro m th e streptoneura n grade. Thus , th e dat a se t include s 9 1 Bivalvi a
(five Protobranchia , 3 3 Heteroconchia , 5 3 Pteriomorphia), si x Gastropoda , fou r Scaphopoda , one Cephalopoda , fou r Polyplacophor a an d on e Caudofoveata, totallin g 10 7 species . O f these , 2 7 are represented b y partial sequences. The alignment and inpu t fil e i s availabl e b y anonymou s FT P from ftp.ebi.ac.uk/pub/databa.ses/embl/Silign as alignment fil e DS40811 . A relativ e rat e tes t fo r th e complet e 18 S rDNA sequences in the data set was made using the output of th e branc h lengt h tes t o f LINTR E (Takezak i e t al. 1995) . Th e mea n o f th e root-to-ti p distance s in a neighbour-joinin g tre e (usin g Scutopus ventrolineatus or Liolophura japonica a s outgroup) was calculated and the distribution of the individual differences fro m th e mean recorded fo r each taxon in question . Thes e value s wer e teste d b y non parametric test s (Kruskal-Walli s an d Mann Whitney-U-Test in SPSS fo r Windows 6.0.1; SPSS Inc.) and a permutation test [softwar e described i n Nemeschkal (1999)] . Parsimony an d maximu m likelihoo d wer e use d for phylogeneti c reconstructio n because the y both allow for the inclusion of partial sequences . Result s of neighbour-joinin g analyse s wit h th e near complete pteriomorp h sequences wer e simila r t o the othe r result s an d ar e no t shown . Unweighted parsimony analyse s wer e performe d wit h PAUP*
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHI A
4.0b2 (Swofford 1998) unde r Windows 95 and with PAUP* 4d65 unde r UNIX . Th e hig h numbe r o f species mad e exhaustiv e an d branch-and-boun d searches unfeasible . Fo r th e heuristi c searche s uninformative characters were excluded, gaps were treated a s missin g an d Scutopus ventrolineatus (Caudofoveata) wa s use d a s outgroup . The searc h strategy consiste d o f a n initia l searc h wit h 5 0 random taxo n additio n sequences , TB R branc h swapping, MULPAR S optio n i n effect, n o steepes t descent, keepin g 10 0 mos t parsimoniou s tree s (MPT) o f each replicate. This search wa s repeated three times with different rando m seed numbers. In the second step , all MPT and trees up to 1 % longe r than th e MP T wer e submitte d t o TB R branc h swapping t o fin d al l MPT . Becaus e th e overal l transition/transversion rati o wa s foun d t o b e onl y slightly > 1 , no weighted parsimony searches were made. Bremer suppor t indice s (Breme r 1988 , 1994 ) were calculate d fo r th e stric t consensu s tre e t o assess robustness of each branch in PAUP* usin g a batch fil e produce d b y Tree-Rot (Sorense n 1996 ) with te n rando m additio n sequence s an d keepin g 100 trees per replicate fo r each search . The Breme r support index (or decay index) gives the number of additional step s neede d t o collaps e a clade . Bootstrap value s wer e calculate d fo r th e pteriomorph subtree . The y ar e derive d fro m 100 0 bootstrap replicate s wit h fiv e rando m taxo n addition sequences , TB R branc h swapping , keeping 5 0 mos t parsimoniou s trees . I t shoul d b e pointed ou t tha t th e hig h proportio n (c . 25% ) o f partial sequence s i n th e alignmen t ma y affec t both measure s o f suppor t fo r th e concerne d nodes. For the maximum-likelihood analyses (ML) both PAUP* andfastDNAml 1.0.6 (Olse n e t al. 1992 ) were used . Th e larg e dat a se t an d a limitatio n i n computer resource s force d eliminatio n o f tre e building b y stepwis e addition . Instead , th e stric t consensus tree wa s used as the startin g tree for the calculation o f M L parameter s an d subsequen t branch swapping . In PAUP*, empirica l nucleotid e frequencies wer e used , an d th e value s fo r th e transition/transversion ratio , proportio n o f invari able site s an d gamm a shap e paramete r wer e estimated unde r th e Hasegawa-Kishino-Yan o (HKY85) mode l wit h rat e heterogeneit y an d fou r categories o f substitutio n rates following a gamma distribution. The resulting values were then se t for the nearest-neighbou r interchang e (NNI ) branc h swapping. Thi s procedur e wa s iterate d a s lon g a s better tree s wer e found . Th e option s se t fo r fastDNAml include d the use of empirical nucleotide frequencies, a transition/transversio n rati o o f 1. 2 (as estimate d i n PAUP*), fou r categorie s o f substitution rate s (0.5 , 1 , 2 an d 4 ) an d tre e
17
rearrangements crossin g fiv e branches . Eac h alignment position wa s assigned t o a rate categor y manually by the following criteria: categor y 1 , site s with n o mor e tha n tw o specie s havin g a substitution; categor y 2 , n o mor e tha n thre e different nucleotide s an d substitutions , mainl y among famil y groups ; categor y 3 , al l nucleotide s present, substitutions also within families; categor y 4, hypervariabl e regions , singl e o r multipl e insertions/deletions. As arbitrar y a s this procedur e is, it reflects the bes t estimat e o f substitutio n rates and yield s tree s wit h bette r M L score s tha n b y using uniform rates. The ML trees obtained by both programmes wer e mutually tested and submitted t o branch swapping in an iterative way until no furthe r improvement wa s achieved . I n additio n t o th e complete dat a set, subset s containin g onl y Arcoidea, Pectinoidea , Pinnoidea , Pterioide a an d Ostreoidea (eac h wit h th e neares t outgrou p species), an d Pteriomorphia + Protobranchi a wer e used in both parsimony and ML analyses (includin g stepwise addition ) t o chec k th e influenc e o f th e number o f outgrou p organism s o n th e topology . Resulting tree s wer e handle d wit h TREEVIEW (Page 1996) . The program s PREPARE an d HADTREE (Hendy & Penn y 1993 ) wer e use d fo r spectra l analysis o f th e Pteriomorphi a usin g th e sam e settings a s in Steiner (1999) , i.e . recodin g th e data to two-state characters and the 'sum of 7' option for calculating th e frequencie s o f splits . Becaus e th e number o f specie s i s limite d t o 2 0 i n thes e programs, onl y tw o specie s wit h complet e sequences o f each famil y grou p wer e include d b y chosing th e leas t an d the mos t derived one s i n the ML tree. The protobranch Yoldiella nana was used as outgroup.
Results The 18 S rDN A sequence s obtaine d i n thi s stud y range i n length fro m 168 7 (Flexopecten glaber) t o 1929 (Ctenoides annulatus) bas e pairs , excep t fo r Solemya togata wher e onl y a 778 bas e pair s lon g fragment o f th e 3 ' en d coul d b e sequenced . Thi s species i s nevertheles s include d i n th e analyse s because it is the onl y solemyi d sequenc e availabl e clustering wit h bivalves . Th e alignmen t wit h th e other mollusca n sequence s submitte d t o th e phylogenetic analyses has 202 6 position s o f which 875 are parsimony informative. The distribution of tree length s of on e millio n rando m trees i s highly skewed wit h a g j inde x o f -0.74 fo r the complet e data se t an d -0.6 0 fo r th e Protobranchi a + Pteriomorphia subset . Thi s indicate s a highl y hierarchical dat a structur e bot h fo r th e complet e data and the subset .
18
G. STEINE R & S . HAMMER
Relative rate test The relativ e rate s ar e expresse d i n Fig . 2 b y th e difference fro m th e averag e branc h lengt h i n a NJ tree. Pteriomorphi a hav e th e lowes t rates i n thi s data set and differ significantl y (p < 0.05) both fro m the Heteroconchia an d all other outgroups . Amon g the Bivalvi a onl y th e tw o protobranc h sequences show simila r rate s t o th e fastes t pteriomorphs , th e Limidae. Althoug h Pteriomorphi a ar e represente d by 46 sequences, their range of rates is very small, especially whe n compared t o the Heteroconchia .
Relationships of higher taxa The parsimon y analysi s returne d 3057 1 MP T o f 4617 step s (C I = 0.376 , RC I = 0.259) . Th e stric t consensus tree (Figs 3 and 4) is one of the MPT and fairly wel l resolved , althoug h th e dee p node s especially have low support indices. Monophyly of the Bivalvia i s not supporte d a s the Heteroconchi a are separate d fro m th e Protobranchi a +
Pteriomorphia clad e b y th e Gastropod a an d th e Polyplacophora. Th e partia l sequenc e o f Loligo clusters wit h th e gastropo d Monodonta. Th e Scaphopoda appea r paraphyleti c a t the bas e o f th e tree wit h Dentalium laqueatum joinin g th e caudofoveat outgroup . Excep t fo r Yoldiella an d Nuculana, th e Protobranchi a for m a n unresolve d polytomy wit h th e pteriomorp h clade . Th e Unionida ar e th e siste r grou p t o th e remainde r o f the Heteroconchi a clade . Th e famil y grou p tax a Galeommatidae, Lucinidae , Tridacnida e an d Mactridae ar e monophyleti c wit h hig h branc h support betwee n 8 an d 60 . Monophyl y o f Veneridae, Donacida e an d Cardioidea i s supporte d with Bremer indices from 2 to 4, whereas the orderlevel tax a Lucinida , Venerid a an d Myoid a ar e polyphyletic. Th e branche s connectin g th e famil y group taxa generally hav e little support ( 1 or 2) and are unstabl e with respec t t o th e M L analysi s (se e below). Only the Cardioide a + Tridacnidae branch and th e sister-grou p relatio n o f Myida e an d Corbulidae are robust.
Fig. 2 . Relative rate test comparing th e differences fro m the mean root-to-ti p distance (ordinate ) in an NJ tree with Liolophura japonica a s outgroup by taxonomic grou p (abscissa ) usin g LINTRE. Pteriomorphi a have significantl y lower value s (p < 0.05) tha n both Heteroconchi a alon e an d all outgroup organism s pooled . The pteriomorp h outlier s (circles) correspon d t o the three specie s o f the Limidae an d Lopha cristagalli (Ostreidae ) wit h the highest substitutio n rates.
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHIA 1
9
Fig. 3 . Strict consensus tree and one of the 30 571 most parsimonious trees (length = 4617, C I = 0.376, RC I = 0.259) found by unweighted parsimony using a heuristic searc h with 50 replicates o f random sequenc e additio n an d TBR branch swapping. The pteriomorph subtre e is shown in detail in Fig. 4. Bremer support indices are indicted abov e the branches.
The branc h o f th e Pteriomorphi a ha s th e sam e Pinnoide a an d Mytiloidea , an d a clad e unitin g support (Breme r inde x 2) as tha t of the Pterioide a and Ostreoidea . As in the heteroconc h Heteroconchia. I t split s u p int o tw o lines : on e clade , th e highes t branc h suppor t value s ar e consists o f th e Arcoide a a s th e basa l branc h detecte d fo r som e o f th e famil y ran k taxa . followed b y a clade of Anomioidea an d Plicatula, Mytiloidea , Anomioidea , Limoidea , Spondylida e being the sister group to Limoidea an d Pectinoidea. an d Pectinida e hav e suppor t indice s o f betwee n 8 The secon d lin e show s a trichotom y o f th e an d 12 , an d bootstra p value s o f > 97; Arcoidea ,
20 G
. STEINE R & S. HAMME R
Fig. 4. Pteriomorph subtre e of the strict consensus tree, continuin g from th e subtree of the outgroup species i n Fig. 3. Bremer support indices are indicted above, and bootstrap values below, the branches.
Ostreioidea an d Pectinoidea ar e intermediate, wit h highes t scor e o f th e entir e pteriomorp h par t o f th e support indice s o f 3- 4 an d bootstra p value s tree . In contrast t o the Heteroconchia, however, all between 78 and 100 . Pinnoidea and Pterioidea have interna l pteriomorp h branche s ar e als o presen t i n branch suppor t indice s o f 2 an d 1 , an d bootstra p th e ML tree . values o f 8 2 an d 74 , respectively . Again , interna l Th e M L tre e (Fig s 5 an d 6 ) ha s lo g likelihoo d branches connectin g thes e famil y group taxa hav e value s o f -26224.8105 5 i n PAUP* an d low suppor t an d bootstra p values , th e exceptio n -2 6 510.05 3 72 in fastDNAml Althoug h its overall being th e clad e o f Plicatula an d th e Anomioide a topolog y is similar to the strict consensus tree, there with a n index o f 1 3 and ful l bootstra p support , the ar e difference s bot h i n th e relationship s o f th e
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHIA 2
1
Fig. 5 . Maximum likelihood (ML ) tree found by PAUP* (lo g L = -26 224.81 0 55 ) and fastDNAml (log L = -2 6 510.053 72). Details on the search strategy are given in the text. For better readability the lengths of the marked branches are reduced by a factor 1. 5 in Dentalium laqueatum and Tropidomya abbreviata, and by factors 2 or 4 in the Tridacnidae an d Cardiidae, respectively . Thi s is the subtree o f the outgroup specie s to the Pteriomorphia. The pteriomorph subtre e is shown in detail in Fig. 6.
major mollusca n group s an d withi n th e Anomalodesmat a an d Myoida . Tropidomya an d Heteroconchia an d Pteriomorphia . Th e analysi s Panopea ar e th e siste r grou p o f th e Galeom yields monophyleti c Scaphopod a an d Gastropod a matidae . Cyrtopleura i s clos e t o th e Myida e + with Loligo her e bein g closes t t o th e outgroup . Corbulida e clad e forming a paraphyletic group to a Protobranchia for m a clad e containin g mono - par t of the Veneroida an d Lucinida . phyletic Nuculanidae . Th e difference s i n th e Th e M L topolog y fo r th e pteriomorp h famil y Heteroconchia clad e concern th e position of Ensis, group s i s th e sam e a s i n th e parsimon y stric t now a t the base of the Heterodonta, a s well a s the consensu s tree, except for resolving the trichotomy
22 G
. STEINE R & S. HAMME R
Fig. 6 . Pteriomorph subtre e of the maximum likelihood tree, continuing from th e subtree of the outgroup species in Fig. 5.
by connectin g the Pinnoidea a s the siste r grou p to complet e pteriomorp h sequence s onl y (result s no t the Pteriodea + Ostroidea clade . Analyses with the shown ) agre e wit h thes e result s i n regar d t o th e subsets Pteriomorphi a + Protobranchi a an d wit h Anomioide a + Plicatuloidea bein g th e siste r grou p each o f th e famil y group s yiel d identica l results , t o Limoidea + Pectinoidea, i n clustering Ostreoide a although th e estimation s o f parameter s fo r th e t o Pterioidea , an d t o ver y shor t branc h length s o f transition/trans version ratio, proportion o f invariant th e basa l clades . Difference s concer n th e sites an d gamm a shap e diffe r fro m th e analysi s of Mytiloide a an d th e Ostreoide a + Pterioide a clad e the complete dat a set. formin g th e basa l branche s o f th e Pteriomorphi a Neighbour-joining analyse s (HKY8 5 model , varyin g in order according to the parameter used in gamma distribute d rat e heterogeneity ) wit h th e th e analysis . Th e positio n o f th e Pinnoide a als o
18S rDNA PHYLOGENY OF PTERIOMORPHIA
varies bu t neve r cluster s wit h th e Ostreoide a + Pterioidea clade. Spectral analysi s fo r selecte d pteriomorp h species (Fig . 7 ) rank s th e signal s (frequenc y o f occurrence o f a spli t minu s normalized frequenc y of conflictin g splits ) fo r th e famil y grou p tax a highest, a s coul d b e expected . Ther e ar e tw o exceptions: th e node of Anomioidea + Plicatula as the mos t robus t nod e unitin g differen t famil y groups take s ran k 4 , thu s bein g bette r supporte d than th e Anomioidea ; th e Pectinoide a (ran k 66) , represented b y Spondylus hystrix, Placopecten magellanicus an d Argopecten irradians, shows the weakest signa l of th e famil y grou p taxa, and eve n of al l node s foun d i n th e stric t consensus and M L trees. However , it als o ha s ver y lo w conflict . The other branches connecting family group s take ranks 11 (Ostreoide a + Pterioidea) , 2 0 (Ostreoide a + Pterioidea + Pinnoidea) , 3 9 (Pectinoide a + Limoidea) an d 5 5 (Pectinoide a + Limoide a + Anomioidea + Plicatula). Th e numerou s node s i n between ar e mostly thos e unitin g single specie s o f either Limoide a o r Ostreoide a t o othe r familie s which ca n b e explaine d b y th e hig h conflic t o r noise fo r thes e tw o groups . Som e o f th e node s i n this are a that are not i n the ML tre e (no t indicated in Fig . 6 ) represen t th e stronges t signa l fo r connecting th e Mytiloide a an d Arcoide a t o othe r family groups . Nod e 2 7 link s Mytiloide a wit h Ostreoidea an d Yoldiella, nod e 3 8 unites Arcoide a
23
and Pterioidea, nod e 42 Arcoidea with Anomioidea and Plicatula, an d nod e 5 0 Arcoide a wit h Mytiloidea an d Pinnoidea. Th e latte r i s o f interes t because it is also present in some of the neighbourjoining trees an d underlines th e separated origi n of the Pinnoidea an d Pterioidea. The clade connectin g these two groups ranks only 87.
Relationships within pteriomorph family groups (Figs 4 and 6) The results for those pteriomorph groups with more than thre e specie s i n th e dat a se t ar e reporte d i n detail. Arcoidea. I n both analyses , Area noae is the basa l offshoot i n the arcoid tree , an d the Arcidae ar e not monophyletic. Th e stric t consensu s tre e show s Arcidae paraphyleti c t o th e siste r group s Striarca lactea (Noetiidae) an d Glycimerididae, wherea s the ML tre e root s thes e familie s withi n th e Arcidae . The basa l positio n o f Area noae ha s th e highes t Bremer support of all arcoid internal branches. Mytiloidea. Th e representative s o f th e Modiolina e and Lithophagina e appea r ancestra l t o th e monophyletic Mytilinae . Althoug h branch suppor t is low, both parsimony and ML analyses return the same topology. Geukensia and Brachidontes are the
Fig. 7 . Spectral analysis o f selected pteriomorph species. Histogram o f support (positiv e values o n ordinate) and corrected conflict (negativ e value s o n ordinate) for splits (abscissa) in the alignment wit h ne t signal > 0, ranked by net signal (signa l minus conflict). Shaded bar s indicat e node s present i n the ML tree. Specie s selected fo r each taxon : Ostreoidea = Hyotissa hyotis + Lopha cristagalli; Pterioidea = Pteria hirundo + Malvifundus regulatus; Mytiloidea = Modioilus auriculatus + Geukensia demissa', Arcoide a = Area noae + Glycymeris pedunculus', Pinnoide a = Atrina pectiniata + Pinna muricata; Pectinidae = Placopecten magellanicus + Argopecten irradians, Pectinoidea = Pectinidae + Spondylus hystrix', al l species of Anomioidea and Limoidea in the data set .
24
G. STEINE R & S . HAMME R
sister group to the clade of Septifer an d Mytilus tha t is characterize d b y exceptionall y hig h suppor t values. Ostreoidea. Th e sister-grou p relationshi p o f Gryphaeidae an d Ostreida e i s supporte d b y hig h bootstrap values, although the Bremer index for the ostreid branc h i s low . Th e resolutio n withi n th e Ostreidae is poor, resulting in a polytomy of all five species i n th e stric t consensu s tree an d ver y shor t internal branc h length s i n th e M L tree . However , the ML tree recover s th e genu s Ostrea a s a clade . The subfamily Crassostreinae appear s polyphyleti c with Crassostrea a t th e bas e o f th e clad e an d Saccostrea clustering with Lopha. Pterioidea. This taxon name is used here in a sense excluding th e Pinnoidea . O f th e thre e pterioi d families treate d i n thi s dat a se t onl y Isognomonidae, represente d b y tw o Isognomon species, appea r monophyletic , wherea s bot h Pteriidae an d Malleida e ar e polyphyletic . Th e genus Plena forms a paraphyletic stem group of the Pterioidea i n th e M L tree . Th e tw o specie s o f Pinctada ar e recovered a s a clade by ML onl y an d not se t in clos e relationshi p t o Pteria. The pterii d Electroma alacorvi cluster s wit h th e mallei d Vulsella a s th e siste r grou p o f Pinctada. Wit h Malvifundus rootin g jus t abov e th e Pteria grade , this render s Malleida e polyphyletic . Branc h support i s lo w withi n th e Pterioidea , th e mos t robust clad e being that of Electroma and Vulsella. However, the topologies of the parsimony and ML analyses are very similar. Pectinoidea. The two Spondylus specie s comprise a well supporte d siste r grou p t o th e Pectinidae . Branch suppor t value s withi n th e Pectinida e ar e low bu t th e topolog y o f parsimon y an d M L tree s are compatible. Crassadoma and Placopecten take the basa l positio n i n th e pectini d subtree . Th e branching patter n o f th e Chlamys specie s an d Pedum a t th e bas e o f th e remainin g pectinid s i s unresolved i n th e stric t consensu s an d marke d b y very shor t branc h length s i n th e M L tree . Whil e Mimachlamys varia is part of this assemblage in the ML tree the suppor t value of 2 connects it more to the to p par t of the tre e b y parsimony criteria. Th e top par t consist s o f a grade d serie s o f Excellichlamys, Pecten, Argopecten an d Flexopecten.
Discussion Potential limits of methods The dat a se t an d phylogeneti c analysi s presented here is one o f the largest of bivalve 18 S sequences
and the largest of pteriomorph species published to date, an d considerabl e significanc e o f th e result s can b e expected . However , a numbe r o f methodological limitation s an d know n potentia l sources o f erro r mus t b e heede d t o evaluat e th e results adequately. The alignment is a difficult ste p in the analysis of the 18 S rDN A gen e du e t o th e variation s i n sequence length in certain loop regions. This results in many alternative alignments of which only a few were tested. Informatio n about secondary structur e can b e o f assistanc e bu t i s i n itsel f ambiguous . If , for example , on e en d o f a ste m ha s a conserve d sequence o n on e stran d an d substitution s o n th e other strand , th e loo p i s elongate d relativ e t o th e stem in the specie s concerned . Alignin g strictl y t o secondary structur e yield s a les s parsimoniou s alignment in this case . Dense taxonomi c samplin g should improv e alignmen t qualit y a s intermediat e forms are expected t o connect the extremes. Thi s is one o f th e reason s wh y th e partia l sequence s ar e included in the data set. The low overall transition/transversion (s/v) ratio of 1. 2 indicate s a certai n saturatio n o f observe d distances, as was already shown with a smaller data set (Steine r & Muelle r 1996) . Th e erosio n o f th e phylogenetic signa l b y multipl e substitution s concerns mostl y ancien t speciatio n events . Th e deep node s ar e consequentl y no t wel l supporte d and nee d t o b e viewe d wit h greate r cautio n tha n nodes higher up in the tree. O n the other hand, the low overall s/v parameter estimated by and for ML analyses coul d lea d t o erroneou s topologie s i n younger clades where the observed parameter value is muc h higher . Severa l analyse s wit h subset s o f pteriomorph families yield the same topology as the entire set . However , th e tre e topolog y o f thes e speciation event s depends less on the s/v parameter and more on the outgroup. Another potential sourc e of error i s the strategy of the tree search in the computationally demanding ML analysis of this large data set. Taking the strict consensus tre e o f th e parsimon y analysi s a s th e starting tree an d allowing rearrangement s crossin g not mor e than five branches , significantl y narrows the tree space covered by the search. That this range of branc h swappin g ca n alte r an d optimiz e a tre e considerably i s demonstrate d b y th e remova l o f Loligo pealei fro m withi n th e gastropod s i n th e strict consensu s t o a positio n betwee n th e caudofoveat outgrou p and th e scaphopods . I n an y case, th e swappin g rang e i s sufficientl y wid e t o check o n al l topologica l variation s o f th e majo r molluscan classes and subclasses represented i n the study. A frequentl y encountere d problem i s th e 'long branch attraction ' effec t causin g parsimon y an d distance algorithm s t o cluste r distantl y relate d
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHI A
species o r clades, either because they share a higher substitution rat e tha n th e remainin g lines , increasing thei r rando m sequence s similarities , o r because th e lon g undivide d branche s bea r a hig h number of unobservable multiple hits (Swoffor d e t al. 1996) . Th e hig h degre e o f similarit y o f th e parsimony an d ML results indicates that the 'long branch attraction ' i s no t a n importan t proble m i n the analysis . Th e tax a wit h th e longes t branche s (Cardiidae an d Tridacnidae , Tropidomya abbreviata, Dentalium laqueatum, Monodonta labio) ar e foun d i n th e outgroups , whil e Pteriomorphia hav e shorte r tha n averag e branc h lengths. The error expected to be introduced by the partial sequences i n th e dat a se t (c . 25 % o f th e species ) seems t o b e o f littl e significanc e judge d b y thei r systematically orthodo x positio n i n th e tree s i n most cases . Congener s o f Glycymeris, Atrina, Ostrea, hognomon and Pinctada, represented b y a complete and partial sequence, are monophyletic, at least in the ML tree. Only the genera Barbatia and Pteria d o no t for m clades , althoug h Pteria i s represented b y tw o complet e sequences . Mor e problematic ar e th e systematicall y questionabl e positions o f Loligo pealei an d Ensis directus, two of th e shortes t sequence s used , varyin g greatl y among th e analyses . Thes e finding s nee d confirmation b y mor e an d mor e complet e sequences of the respective taxa.
Relationships of higher taxa The siste r grou p o f Bivalvi a remain s obscure , partly du e t o thei r apparentl y diphyleti c origin . None o f th e conchifera n group s ar e clos e t o the Protobranchi a + Pteriomorphi a clade , an d Heteroconchia stan d isolated between Scaphopod a and Gastropoda . Thus , a siste r grou p o f Bivalvi a and Scaphopod a (e.g . Salvini-Plawe n & Steine r 1996) is not supported here. Monophyletic Bivalvi a are difficul t t o resolv e wit h th e 18 S rDN A (Kenchington et al 1994 ; Steine r & Mueller 1996 ; Winnepenninckx e t al . 1996 ; Adamkewic z e t al . 1997; Campbel l e t al . 1998) , althoug h Steine r & Mueller (1996 ) foun d th e phylogeneti c signa l fo r Bivalvia to be only slightly weaker than conflicting ones. I t wa s shown , however , b y Frische r e t al . (1998) an d Giribe t & Carranz a (1999 ) tha t alignments yieldin g bivalv e monophyl y d o exist . However, Steine r (1999 ) demonstrate d tha t th e alignment o f Giribe t & Carranz a (1999 ) support s the bivalve clade only by a single non-homoplastic position. A commo n featur e o f th e tree s wit h monophyletic Bivalvi a is the para- or polyphyly of Pteriomorphia wit h Ostreida e joinin g th e heterodont branch . However , i n Frische r e t al . (1998) bot h Pteriomorphi a an d Heterodont a form
25
clades bu t Ostreida e ar e th e firs t pteriomorp h offshoot. Apparen t bivalv e polyphyl y i s caused b y separate origi n o f th e Pteriomorphi a an d Heterodonta and/o r Solemya velum clustering wit h the gastropods (Adamkewic z e t al. 1997 ; Campbel l et al. 1998). In the latter cases, this seems due to an aberrant sequenc e o f thi s Solemya species , a s S . togata i n th e present stud y clusters wit h the othe r Protobranchia. A reason fo r the autobranch group s not t o cluste r ma y b e thei r difference s i n substi tution rate s a s suspecte d b y Steine r & Muelle r (1996). The relative rat e tes t showin g pteriomorp h substitution rate s t o b e significantl y lowe r tha n those of the other molluscan groups, and that of the Heteroconchia i n particular , corroborate s thi s explanation. Th e homogeneit y o f rate s amon g th e Pteriomorphia i s remarkabl e an d lend s additiona l weight to the significance o f these results . All analyse s presente d her e indicat e mono phyletic Pteriomorphi a an d Heteroconchi a (Heterodonta + Anomalodesmata) . Th e Proto branchia clad e i s supporte d i n th e M L tre e only . The result s fo r th e Heteroconchi a confir m th e findings o f Adamkewic z e t al . (1997 ) showin g Unionida a s the basal branch, polyphyly of Myoida and Venerida , an d generall y littl e suppor t fo r internal nodes . No t i n agreement i s the position o f the Anomalodesmata : instea d o f joinin g th e gastropod branch, Tropidomya abbreviata emerges from withi n th e Heterodont a togethe r wit h th e hiatelloid Panopea a s siste r grou p t o th e Galeommatidae. Thus , i f th e probabl y artificia l position o f Ensis is not taken into account, the basal heterodont lineag e consist s o f th e Lucinidae , Galeommatidae, Hiatellida e an d Cuspidariidae . This i s a n extraordinar y taxonomi c mi x bu t corroborates McAleste r (1966 ) an d Morton (1996 ) in regar d t o th e ancien t origi n o f Lucinidae an d Galeommatidae. It also agrees with Morton (1996) , Salvini-Plawen & Steiner (1996 ) and Waller (1998 ) on th e heterodon t root s o f th e Anomalodesmata , although onl y wit h a par t o f th e Myoida . O n th e other hand , th e wid e separatio n o f th e ungulini d Diplodonta fro m th e Lucinida e challenge s al l systematic concepts. From these results , it appear s highly unlikel y tha t an y o f th e Heteroconchi a lines i s a candidat e fo r a siste r grou p o f th e Pteriomorphia.
Pteriomorph relationships The Pteriomorphi a ar e supporte d a s a clad e i n al l analyses i n a simila r wa y t o th e Heteroconchia , both i n term s o f Breme r indice s an d o f branc h length in the ML tree. However, the basal node s of the pteriomorp h tre e ar e no t wel l supporte d an d have to be taken cum grano salts. Two major clade s showing stabilit y i n th e analyses , i n tha t al l
26
G. STEINE R & S . HAMME R
algorithms converge on the same topology, though with low branch support, are the lines of (Pinnoide a [Pterioidea + Ostreoidea) ] an d [(Anomioide a + Plicatuloidea) + (Limoidea + Pectinoidea)]. Among these, th e positio n o f th e Pinnoide a varie s most , suggesting a n origi n a s ancien t a s tha t o f th e Arcoidea an d Mytiloidea , lendin g suppor t t o Starobogatov's (1992 ) concep t o f a n earl y separation o f thi s lin e fro m th e othe r Pteriomorphia. Among the hypotheses shown , only Carter (1990 ) consider s a non-monophyl y o f Pinnoidea an d Pterioidea. Non e o f th e hypothese s depicted i n Fig. 1 are full y supported , instead thi s study corroborate s certai n grouping s i n eac h o f them. The specie s se t used for this study contains only single representative s o f man y pteriomorp h families an d som e ar e no t represente d a t all . Th e results, therefore , permi t onl y restricte d inferenc e of intra family relationships. However , it is striking that the Arcidae an d Pteriidae a s the basal families of thei r respectiv e famil y group s appea r para - o r even polyphyletic. The pterioid family Malleidae is also no t supported , wit h Vulsella an d Malvifindus being clearl y separate d o n th e tree . Th e commo n origin o f Gryphaeida e an d Ostreida e i s strongl y supported, contradictin g th e view s o f Stenze l (1971) an d Carte r (1990) . Resolutio n withi n th e Ostreidae i s no t satisfactor y wit h th e 18 S rDNA, paralleling the finding s wit h 28S rDNA sequences (Littlewood 1994) . Th e branchin g orde r o f subfamilies in the Mytiloidea has Modiolinae a s the basal lin e followe d b y Lithophagina e an d Mytilinae. Withi n th e Mytilinae , Septifer an d th e Mytilus specie s ar e se t of f fro m Geukensia an d Brachidontes specie s b y a strongl y supporte d an d comparatively lon g branch . This i s no t congruent with th e recen t result s o f comparativ e sper m morphology (Kafano v & Drozdo v 1998) , suggesting a close r relationshi p o f Brachidontes and Septifer. Th e pectinid topology recovere d her e differs i n one aspect fro m th e one in Frischer e t al (1998). Th e clade of Crassadoma an d Placopecten is confirmed but instea d of being derive d fro m th e Chlamys + Mimachlamys group s it takes the basal position in the pectinid tree. Instead, the Chlamys + Mimachlamys group s give rise to the Decatopecten - Pecten - Aequipecten groups . Th e difference in branching sequence ma y be attributed to the rather distant outgrou p (Crassostrea o r Geukensia} Frischer e t al. (1998 ) used . This demonstrate s th e importance o f usin g no t to o distantl y relate d outgroups in molecular studies as the resulting long branches connecting it to the ingroup may bear 's o many change s tha t th e sequence s hav e becom e effectively randomized ' (Swoffor d e t al . 1996 , p . 478). Th e presen t topolog y lend s suppor t t o th e systematic schem e o f Walle r (1991) , derivin g th e
pectinoid shell morphology with more or less equal size o f shel l auricle s fro m th e chlamydoi d form with pronounce d unequa l auricle s (Frische r e t al . 1998), althoug h Walle r (1991 ) propose d tha t thi s occurred independentl y i n the Aequipecten group .
Morphological aspects and proposed phylogeny Morphological character s importan t fo r relation ships amon g th e majo r pteriomorp h group s wer e selected fro m Carte r (1990 ) and Waller (1998 ) and projected o n the ML tree topology for these groups (Fig. 8a) . Th e M L tre e i s preferre d t o th e stric t consensus parsimon y tre e becaus e i t resolve s th e mytiloid-pinnoid branchin g sequence . Recodin g the character s give n b y thes e author s t o a dat a matrix fo r a combine d molecula r an d morpho logical analysi s ha s bee n attempte d bu t i s no w postponed. At the time of preparation o f this paper, too man y uncertaintie s i n homolog y an d gap s i n character state s for al l the specie s i n the molecular data set were evident, so that a more comprehensive analysis will be presented elsewhere . Non-homoplastic synapomorphie s (i n bold ) fo r the Pteriomorphia i n Fig. 8a are the discontinuity of larval an d post-larva l ligaments , stomac h morph ology o f typ e II I o f Purchon , rectu m wit h a flattened cross-section , connecte d cardi e auricle s and a branchia l ocellu s i n th e juvenile . Th e tw o latter character s liste d b y Walle r (1998 ) ar e somewhat doubtful ; branchia l eye s ar e no t known from al l pteriomorp h group s (Crag g 1996) . A fusion of auricles was reported b y Atkins (1938) for all pteriomorphs excep t fo r Anomia, expanding on the results of Pelseneer (1911 ) but never confirmed on a broad scale . At least in Area noae, this fusio n must occu r lat e i n ontogen y a s juvenile s hav e clearly separat e auricle s (Steiner , pers . comm.) . Another potentia l synapomorphy , thoug h a homoplastic one , i s th e los s o f th e opisthodeti c ligament. Th e reconstructio n o f thi s characte r involves eithe r a reversa l i n th e Mytiloidea o r a n independent los s in the Ostreioide a + Pterioidea + Pinnoidea lin e an d o n th e branc h leadin g t o th e clade including the Arcoidea. Special attentio n i s draw n t o th e fiv e othe r characters tha t evolv e i n paralle l alon g thes e tw o branches: the calcitic prisms in the outer shell layer, the inequivalv e shell , th e presenc e o f a byssa l notch, th e palp-gill connectio n o f type III an d the dominant right abdominal sense organ (ASO). This collection o f parallelisms , cause d b y th e weakl y supported an d short-branche d basa l node s o f th e 18S trees , promp t u s t o propos e a preliminar y phylogenetic hypothesi s combinin g th e mor e reliable branche s o f th e molecula r tre e an d th e
18S rDNA PHYLOGENY OF PTERIOMORPHIA 2
7
Fig. 8 . (a) Morphological characteristic s of major group s of the Pteriomorphia plotted on the idealized ML tree shown in Fig. 6 . (b) Proposed phylogenetic tre e of the Pteriomorphia combinin g molecular and morphological data . Non-homoplastic synapomorphies (bold) an d homoplastic synapomorphie s are shown. Reversals an d convergences o n terminal branches no t shown; (?), questionable homologies .
morphological dat a (Fig . 8b). The propose d definition , thei r presenc e ma y b e synapomorphi c phylogeny recognize s th e Mytiloide a a s th e firs t fo r th e entir e clad e o r fo r th e Limoide a + pteriomorph branch . It s siste r grou p is define d by Pectinoide a only . Th e presenc e o f mantl e eye s i n the los s o f th e opisthodeti c ligament , micro - th e mantl e margin s diagnose s th e latte r (thoug h laterofrontal cilia and a palp-gill connection of type parallele d i n the Arcoidea); the cementatio n o f the III. Th e siste r grou p t o the Arcoidea no w includes righ t valve is synapomorphic fo r the Anomioidea + the ostreoid-pterioid-pinnoid clad e an d shows th e Plicatuloidea . I t i s agai n emphasize d tha t th e calcitic prism s i n th e oute r shel l laye r a s non - propose d tre e i s stil l preliminar y an d ha s t o b e homoplastic synapomorphy . subjecte d t o rigorou s cladisti c testin g bot h b y The other synapomorphies , inequivalv e shells , a morphologica l an d additional molecula r character s byssal notc h an d th e dominan t righ t AS O suffe r a s well as by th e incorporatio n of palaeontologica l reversals i n th e limoi d branch . A possibl e data . synapomorphy fo r th e ostreoid-pteroid-pinnoi d Briefl y summarizin g th e result s fo r th e clade is the inse t of the posterio r peda l retracto r relationship s on a family level, the following can be insertion, wit h th e posterio r adducto r muscl e pointe d ou t withou t goin g int o th e detai l o f experiencing reversal in the Ostreoidea. Ostreoidea morphologica l characters : th e monophyl y o f and Pteriodea can be defined by their monomyarian Mytilina e and Pectinidae i s supported; Arcidae ar e condition an d th e presence o f a n ana l appendage , paraphyletic ; Pteriida e an d Malleida e ar e although Harr y (1985 ) an d Walle r (1998 ) expres s polyphyletic . certain doubt s abou t it s homology . Monomyar y
is also a synapomorphy
of the clade uniting
The authors are indebted to Werner Piller and Martin Zuschin (Institute of Paleontology, University of Vienna)
Limoidea, Pectinoidea , Anomioide a an d for the posibility to colllect in Safaga, Egypt. Additional Plicatuloidea, togethe r wit h th e comple x cross - tissue samples were provided by David Campbell lamellar inner shell layer and th e typ e IV stomach . (Universit y o f Sout h Carolina ) an d Argyr o Zeneto s The comple x mantl e tentacle s a s classifie d b y (Nationa l Cente r o f Marin e Research , Greece) . Rober t Waller (1978 , 1998 ) unfortunatel y lac k a soun d Felbe r and Manfred Muelle r (VBC Genomics Bioscienc e morphological definition . Dependin g o n th e Researc h GmbH , Vienna ) gav e valuabl e technica l
28
G. STEINE R & S . HAMME R
support. Gonzal o Giribe t permitte d th e us e o f fou r sequences prior t o publication. This stud y was funded b y the Fonds zur Foderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschun g (FWF project no. P11846-GEN).
References ADAMKEWICZ, S . L. , HARASEWYCH , M . G. , BLAKE , J. , SAUDEK, D . & BUL , C. J . 1997 . A molecula r phylogeny o f th e bivalv e mollusks . Molecular Biology an d Evolution, 14 , 619-629. AGUINALDO, A. M. A., TURBEVILLE, J. M., LINFORD, L . S., RIVERA, M . C., GAREY, J . R., RAFF, R. A. & LAKE, J . A. 1997 . Evidenc e fo r a clad e o f nematodes , arthropods and other moulting animals. Nature, 387, 489-493. ATKINS, D . 1938 . O n th e ciliar y mechanism s an d interrelationships o f Lamellibranchia . Par t VII . Latero-frontal cili a o f th e gil l filament s an d thei r phylogenetic value . Quarterly Journal o f Microscopic Science, 80, 345-436. BREMER, K. 1988. The limits of amino acid sequenc e data in angiosper m phylogeneti c reconstruction . Evolution, 42, 795-803. 1994. Branc h suppor t an d tre e stability . Cladistics -The International Journal of the Willi Hennig Society, 10 , 295-304. CAMPBELL, D . C., HOEKSTRA, K . J. & CARTER, J . G. 1998. 18S ribosomal DNA an d evolutionary relationships within th e Bivalvia . In : JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART, J . W. (eds) Bivalves: An eo n o f Evolution - Paleobiological Studies honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 75-85. CANAPA, A., MAROTA, L , ROLLO, F . & OLMO, E . 1999 . The small-subunit rRNA gene sequences of venerids and the phylogen y o f bivalvia . Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 48, 463-468. CARTER, J . G . 1990 . Evolutionary significanc e o f shel l microstructure i n th e Paleotaxodonta , Pteriomorhpia an d Isofilibranchi a (Bivalvia : Mollusca). In : CARTER , J . G . (ed. ) Skeletal Biomineralization: Patterns, Processes and Evolutionary Trends. Vol.umel. Va n Nostran d Reinhold, New York, 135-296. COPE, J. C. W. 1996. The earl y evolution of the Bivalvia. In: TAYLOR , J . D . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation of th e Mollusca. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 361-370 . CRAGG, S . M . 1996 . The phylogeneti c significanc e o f some anatomical feature s of bivalve velige r larvae . In: TAYLOR , J . D . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation of the Mollusca. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 371-380 . DE RIJK , P . & D E WACHTER , R . 1993 . DCSE , a n interactive too l fo r sequenc e alignmen t an d secondary structur e research . CABIOS, 9 , 735-740. FIELD, K . G. , OLSEN , G. , LANE , D. , GIOVANNONI , ST., GHISELIN, M. , RAFF , E., PACE , N . & RAFF , R . 1988. Molecular phylogen y o f th e anima l kingdom . Science, 239, 748-753. FRISCHER, M . E. , WILLIAMS, J . & KENCHINGTON , E. 1998. A molecula r phylogen y o f som e majo r group s o f
Pectinidae inferred from 18 S rDNA gene sequences. In: JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART , J . W . (eds ) Bivalves: An eon of Evolution - Paleobiological Studies honoring Norman D . Newell. Universit y o f Calgary Press, Calgary , 213-221. GIRIBET, G . & CARRANZA , S . 1999 . Point counte r point : What ca n 18 S rDN A d o fo r bivalv e phylogeny ? Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 48 , 256-258 . HARRY, H . W . 1985 . Synopsi s o f th e supraspecifi c classification o f livin g oyster s (Bivalvia : Gryphaeidae an d Ostreidae). Veliger, 28 , 121-158 . HENDY, M . D . & PENNY , D . 1993 . Spectra l analysi s o f phylogenetic data . Journal o f Classification, 10 , 5-24. KAFANOV, A . I . & DROZDOV , A . L . 1998 . Comparative sperm morpholog y and phylogenetic classificatio n of recen t Mytiloide a (Bivalvia). Malacologia, 39 , 129-139. KENCHINGTON, E. , LANDRY , D . & BIRD , C . J . 1995 . Comparison of taxa of the mussel Mytilus (Bivalvia) by analysis of the nuclear small-subunit rRNA gene sequence. Canadian Journal of Fisheries & Aquatic Sciences, 52, 2613-2620. , RODDICK , D . L. , SINGH , K . R . & BIRD , C . J . 1994. Analysis o f small-subuni t rRN A gen e sequence s from si x familie s o f molluscs . Journal o f Marine Biotechnology, 1 , 215-217. LECOINTRE, G. , PHILIPPE, H., LE, L. H. V & LE GUYADER , H. 1993 . Species samplin g ha s a majo r impac t o n phylogenetic inference . Molecular Phylogeny an d Evolution, 2, 205-224. LITTLEWOOD, D . T . J. 1994 . Molecular phylogenetic s o f cupped oyster s base d o n partia l 28 S rRN A gen e sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics an d Evolution, 3, 221-229. , FORD, S . E. & FONG, D . 1991 . Small subuni t rRNA gene sequenc e o f Crassostrea virginica (Gmelin ) and a comparison with similar sequences from othe r bivalve molluscs. Nucleic Acids Research, 19, 6048. MACKEY, L . Y , WINNEPENNINCKX , B. , D E WACHTER , R. , BACKELJAU, T. , EMSCHERMANN , P . & GAREY , J . R . 1996. 18 S rDN A suggest s tha t Entoproct a ar e protostomes, unrelate d t o Entoprocta . Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 42, 552-559. MARUYAMA, T., ISHIKURA , M., YAMAZAKI , S . & KANAI , S . 1998. Molecula r phylogen y o f zooxanthellat e bivalves. Biological Bulletin, 195 , 70-77. MCALESTER, A . L . 1966 . Evolutionar y an d systemati c implications o f a transitional Ordovicia n lucinoi d bivalve. Malacologia, 3 , 433-439. MORTON, B . 1996 . Th e evolutionar y histor y o f th e Bivalvia. In : TAYLOR , J . D . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation o f th e Mollusca. Oxfor d University Press, Oxford , 337-360. NEMESCHKAL, H . L . 1999 . Morphometri c correlatio n patterns o f adult birds (Fringillidae : Passeriformae s and Columbiformes ) mirro r th e expressio n o f developmental contro l genes . Evolution, 53 , 899-918. OLSEN, G . J. , MATSUDA , H. , HAGSTROM , R . & OVERBEEK , R. 1992 . Documentation fo r fastDNAml 1.0. Electronic file distribute d with the program . PAGE, R . D . M . 1996 . TREE VIEW: A n applicatio n t o display phylogeneti c tree s o n persona l computers .
18S rDNA PHYLOGEN Y O F PTERIOMORPHI A Computer Applications i n th e Biosciences, 12 , 357-358. PELSENEER, P . 1911 . Le s lamellibranche s dTexpeditio n du Siboga . Parti e anatomique . Siboga Expeditie Siboga Expedition Monograph, 71 , 1-125 . PHILIPPE, H. , CHENUIL , A . & ADOUTTE , A . 1994 . Can th e Cambrian explosio n b e inferre d throug h molecula r phylogeny? Development, Supplemen t 1994 , 15-25. RICE, E . L . 1990 . Nucleotid e sequenc e o f th e 18 S ribosomal RN A gen e fro m th e Atlantic se a scallop Placopecten magellanicus. Nucleic Acids Research, 18,5551. , RODDICK, D. & SINGH, R. K. 1993 . A comparison of molluscan (Bivalvia ) phylogenie s base d o n palaeontological an d molecula r data . Molecular Marine Biology and Biotechnology, 2 , 137-146. RIUTORT, M. , FIELD , K . G. , RAFF , R . A . & BAGUNA , J . 1993. 18 S rRN A sequence s an d phylogen y o f th e Platyhelminthes. Biochemical Systematics an d Ecology, 21,11-11. SALVINI-PLAWEN, L . & STEINER , G . 1996 . Syn apomorphies an d plesiomorphie s i n highe r classification o f Mollusca . In : TAYLOR , J . D . (ed.) Origin and Evolutionary Radiation of the Mollusca. Oxford Universit y Press, Oxford, 29-52. SORENSON, M. D. 1996 . Tree-Rot. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor . STAROBOGATOV, Y . I . 1992 . Morphological basi s fo r th e phylogeny and classification o f Bivalvia. Ruthenica, 2, 1-26. STEINER, G . 1999 . Point counte r point : Wha t ca n 18 S rDNA do for bivalve phylogeny? Response. Journal of Molecular Evolution, 48, 258-261. & MULLER , M . 1996 . What ca n 18 S rDN A d o fo r bivalve phylogeny ? Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 43, 58-70. STENZEL, H . B . 1971 . Oysters. In : MOORE , R . C . (ed) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part N. Volume 3 , Mollusca 6 , Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y
29
of America , Boulder , CO , an d Kansa s Universit y Press, Lawrence , KS , N953-N1224 . SWOFFORD, D . L . 1998 . PAUP*. Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). Version 4. Sinauer Associates Inc., Sunderland, MA. , OLSEN, G . J., WADDELL, P . J. & HILLIS, D . M. 1996. Phylogenetic inference. In : HILLIS , D . M. , MORITZ , C. & MABLE , B . K . (eds ) Molecular Systematics, 2nd Edition . Sinaue r Associate s Inc. , Sunderland , MA, 407-514. TAKEZAKI, N. , RZHETSKY , A . & NEI , M . 1995 . Phylogenetic tes t o f th e molecula r cloc k an d linearized trees . Molecular Biology an d Evolution, 12, 823-833. THOMPSON, J . D. , HIGGINS , D . G . & GIBSON , T . J . 1994. CLUSTAL W : improvin g th e sensitivit y o f progressive multipl e alignmen t throug h sequenc e weighting, positio n specifi c ga p penaltie s an d weight matri x choice . Nucleic Acid Research, 22 , 4673-4680. WALLER, T . R . 1978 . Morphology, morphocline s an d a new classificatio n o f th e Pteriomorphia . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, London, B284, 345-365 . 1991. Evolutionary relationships among commercia l scallops (Mollusca : Bivalvia : Pectinidae) . In : SHUMWAY, S . E . (ed. ) Scallops: Biology, Ecology and Aquaculture. Volume 21. Elsevier , Ne w York , 1-73. 1998. Origin o f the mollusca n clas s Bivalvi a an d a phylogeny o f majo r groups . In : JOHNSTON , P . A. & HAGGART, J. W. (eds) Bivalves: An Eon o f Evolution - Paleobiological Studies honoring Norman D. Newell. Calgar y Universit y Press, Calgary , 1^7. WlNNEPENNINCKX, B. , BACKELJAU , T . & D E WACHTER, R .
1994. Smal l ribosoma l subuni t RN A an d th e phylogeny o f Mollusca. Nautilus, Suppl . 2, 98-110. ,& 1996 . Investigatio n o f mollusca n phylogeny o n th e basi s o f 18 s rRN A sequences . Molecular Biology and Evolution, 13 , 1306-1317.
This page intentionally left blank
Molecular evidence on the evolution of the Bivalvia D. C. CAMPBELL Department of Geological Sciences, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3315, USA Present address: Biology Department, St Mary's College of Maryland, 18952 E. Fisher Rd, St Mary's City, MD 20686-3001, USA (e-mail: dcampbell@ osprey.smcm.edu) Abstract: Despite widesprea d agreemen t o n the monophyl y o f severa l majo r tax a o f bivalves , others remai n uncertai n an d th e relationship s amon g the m ar e debated . Th e presen t stud y compares new an d published morphological phytogenies with ne w analyses based o n 18 S gene sequences. All but one family an d all superfamilies in the Bivalvia were monophyletic in all the analyses. Several highe r taxa, includin g mos t subclasse s and orders, were also resolved a s monophyletic. Only Myoid a show s stron g evidenc e fo r polyphyly , wit h a t leas t tw o origins fro m Veneroida . Autobranchia was supported as monophyletic in the parsimony analyses. Within Pteriomorphia, Ostreoida i s th e siste r taxo n o f Pterioida , i f no t derive d fro m withi n it , rathe r tha n closes t t o Pectinoida. Th e numerou s point s o f agreemen t wit h morpholog y base d analyse s suggest s tha t both types of evidence are converging on a common phylogeny; however, differences remai n t o be resolved by further study.
The Clas s Bivalvi a ha s bee n recognize d i n essentially its modern for m sinc e Linnaeus (Cox et al. 1969) , bu t th e relationship s o f it s constituen t superfamilies, order s an d subclasse s remai n contested. Mos t familie s an d superfamilie s see m valid, but 'real difficulties arise...whe n attempts are made t o grou p well-define d superfamilie s int o orders an d subclasses' (Newel l i n Cox e t al. 1969 , p. N208) . Th e presen t researc h foun d tha t molecular dat a fro m th e 18 S gen e ca n addres s many of these problems. Most phylogenetic analyses of the Bivalvia so far published ar e based o n what the author considered to b e significan t morphologica l synapomorphie s rather tha n computerize d analyses . Severa l morphological characters are known to have arisen convergently i n differen t bivalv e lineage s (eulamellibranch gil l grade , porcelaneou s micro structure, taxodon t dentition , etc.) , resultin g i n scepticism as to the ability of parsimony analyses to satisfactorily resolv e bivalv e classification . However, Salvini-Plawe n & Steine r (1996 ) attempted a computerized parsimony analysis while noting difficultie s wit h homoplasy . A ne w phylogenetic analysi s (Carter e t al. 2000) wa s als o compared t o th e DN A results . Othe r recen t morphology base d bivalv e phylogenie s includ e Starobogatov (1992) , Morton (1996) , Cop e (1997) and Waller (1998); these summarize much previous work o n th e class . Additiona l phylogeneti c
models fo r specifi c tax a wer e als o considered . The propose d phylogenie s i n thes e paper s were compare d t o th e result s o f th e presen t DNA analyse s an d t o publishe d DNA-base d analyses. The 18 S gene wa s chose n fo r th e presen t stud y because it has been useful i n prior studie s of higher level phylogen y o f th e Bivalvi a an d becaus e th e gene wa s alread y a t leas t partiall y sequence d for severa l tax a (Fiel d e t al . 1988 ; Ric e 1990 ; Holland e t al . 1991 ; Littl e wood e t al . 1991 ; Kenchington et a l 1993 ; Ric e e t al . 1993 ; Kenchington e t a l 1995 ; Steine r & Mlille r 1996 ; Winnepenninckx e t a l 1996 ; Adamkewic z e t a l 1997; Bel l & Grassle 1998 ; Campbel l e t al 1998 ; Frischer et al 1998 ; Maruyama et al 1998 ; Canapa et a l 1999) . Althoug h man y taxonomicall y significant result s wer e obtained , anomalie s an d uncertainties remain . Thus , furthe r stud y o f 18 S gene sequence s promise s importan t dat a fo r resolving the relationships of higher taxa within the Bivalvia. The onl y other gene s fo r which sequence s hav e been obtaine d fo r man y bivalv e superfamilie s ar e the 16 S gene , CO I (bot h mitochondrial ) an d portions of the 28S gene. Mitochondria l gene s ris k reflecting a n organell e phylogen y rathe r tha n th e organismal phylogeny because many bivalves have biparental inheritanc e o f mitochondria , wit h occasional los s an d re-evolutio n o f on e lineag e
From: HARPER, E. M., TAYLOR , J. D. & CRAME, J. A. (eds) Th e Evolutionary Biology o f th e Bivalvia. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 177 , 31-46 . 1-86239-076-2/007 $ 15.0 0 © The Geological Society of London 2000.
Table 1 . Taxa an d sources Taxon
Reference
Accession numbe r
Brachiopoda Lingula anatina Lamarck, 180 1 ['lingua'} Glottidia pyramidata (Stimpson , 1860) Discinisca tenuis (G. B. Sowerby II , 1846 ) 'Neocrania' anomala (Miiller, 1776) Terebratalia transversa (G. B. Sowerby, 1846 ) Thecidellina blochmanni Dall, 1920 [ blochmanif] Neorhynchia sp . D1157 Eohemithiris grayii (Woodward , 1855 ) ['Eohemithyris']
Mackey etal. 1996 Halanych *f a/. 1995 Cohen e t al. unpublishe d Cohen e t al. unpublished Halanych e t al. 1995 Cohen et al. 1998 Cohen e t al. 1998 Cohen e t al. 1998
X81631 U12647 U08327 U08328 U12650 AF025935 AF025937 AF025936
Phoronida Phoronis architecta Andrews, 189 0
Mackey e t al. 1996
U36271
Polyplacophora Cryptochiton stelleri (Middendorff, 1847 ) Liolophura japonica (Lischke , 1873) Lepidochitona corrugata (Reeve , 1848)
Field etal. 1988 Winnepenninckx et al. 1993 Winnepenninckx e t al. 199 6
M20056-58 X70210 X91975
Gastropoda Nerita albicilla Linnaeus, 1758 Monodonta labio (Linnaeus, 1758) Littorina littorea (Linnaeus, 1758) Crepidula adunca G . B. Sowerby I, 182 5 Thais clavigera (Kuster, 1860 ) Anisodoris nobilis (MacFarland , 1905) Onchidella celtica (Cuvier, 1817 ) Limicolaria kambeul (Bruguiere, 1792 )
Winnepenninckx e t al. 199 6 Winnepenninckx e t al. 1 998/7 Winnepenninckx e t al. 1998 0 Winnepenninckx et al. l99Sb Winnepenninckx e t al. 199 6 Field etal. 1988 Winnepenninckx e t al. 1994 Winnepenninckx et al. 199 2
X91971 X94271 Y91970 X94277 X91979 M20097-99 X70211 X66374
Bivalvia: Nuculoide a Nucula proxima Say , 182 2 Acila castrensis (Hinds, 1843)
new new
AF1 20526 AF120527
Nuculanoidea Nuculana minuta (Miiller, 1776) Neilonella subovata (Verril l & Bush, 1897 )
new new
AF120529 AF207645
Mytiloidea Brachidontes exustus (Linnaeus, 1758) Geukensia demissa (Dillwyn , 1817 ) Modiolus americanus (Leach , 1815 ) Musculus lateralis (Say, 1822) Mytilus californianus Conrad , 183 7 Mytilus edulis Linnaeus, 1758 Septifer bilocularis (Linnaeus, 1758 )
new Kenchington et al. 1995 new new Kenchington e t al. 1995 Kenchington et al. 1995 new
AF229623 L33451 AF229624 AF229625 L33449 L24489 AF229622
Arcoidea Area noae (Linnaeus, 1758) Barbatia virescens (Reeve, 1844) Glycymeris glycymeris (Linnaeus , 1758 ) ['sp.']
Steiner & Muller 1996 Winnepenninckx e t al. 1996 Winnepenninckx e t al. 1996
X90960 X91974 X91978
Anomioidea Pododesmus macrochisma (Deshayes, 1839)
new
AF229627, AF229628
Plicatuloidea Plicatula australis (Lamarck , 1819 ) Pectinoidea Chlamys islandica (Muller, 1776) Argopecten irradians (Lamarck, 1819) Pecten maximus (Linnaeus, 1758) Placopecten magellanicus (Gmelin , 1791) Spondylus sinensis Schreibers , 1793
new
AF229626
Kenchington e t al. 199 3 Rice etal. 1993 Frischer ef a/. 1998 Rice 1990 new
LI 1232 LI 1265 L49053 X53899 AF229629
Pinnoidea Atrina pectinata (Linnaeus, 1767 )
Steiner & Muller 199 6
X90961
Pterioidea Pinctada margaritifera (Linnaeus , 1758 ) Isognomon isognomum (Linnaeus, 1758)
new new
AF229620 AF229621
Ostreoidea Ostrea edulis Linnaeus, 1758 Crassostrea virginica (Gmelin, 1791) Hyotissa hyotis (Linnaeus, 1758)
Frischeretal. 1998 Littlewood etal. 1991 new
L49052 Z29549 AF229618, AF229619
Table 1 . Continued Taxon
Reference
Accession numbe r
Unionoidea Elliptio complanata (Lightfoot , 1786 ) Utterbackia imbecilis (Say, 1829 ) ['Anodonta'] Margaritifera margaritifera (Linnaeus , 1758 )
Adamkewicz e t al. 199 7 Adamkewicz e t al. 199 7 new
L78857 L78858 AF229612
Carditoidea Carditamera floridana Conrad , 183 8
new
AF229617
Cyamioidea Basterotia elliptica (Recluz, 1850 )
new
AF229616
Galeommatoidea Galeomma takii (Kuroda, 1945 ) Divariscintilla yoyo Mikkelsen & Bieler, 198 9
Winnepenninckx et al. 199 6 Adamkewicz et al. 199 7
X91969 L78869
Gastrochaenoidea Gastrochaena stimpsonii Try on, 186 1
new
AF229615
Ensiculus cultellus (Linnaeus, 1758 )
Adamkewicz et al. 1997 ; Bell & Grassle 199 8 new
L78871; U93557 AF229614
Tellinoidea TellinaversicolorDeKay, 184 3 Asaphis deflorata (Linnaeus , 1758 ) Donax variabilis Say, 182 2
Bell & Grassle 199 8 Adamkewicz e t al 199 7 Adamkewicz e t al 199 7
U93556 L78868 L78867
Cardioidea Fulvia mutica (Reeve, 1844 ) Vasticardium flavum (Linnaeus , 1758 ) Tridacna gigas (Linnaeus , 1758 ) Tridacna crocea Lamarck, 181 9 Hippopus hippopus (Linnaeus , 1758 ) Fragum fragum (Linnaeus , 1758 ) Corculum cardissa (Linnaeus , 1758 )
Maruyama et al 199 Maruyama et al 199 Maruyama et al 199 Maruyama et al 199 Maruyama et al 199 Maruyama et al 199 Maruyama et al 199
D88911 D88910 D84189 D88908 D84660 D84662 D88909
Veneroidea Venus verrucosa Linnaeus, 175 8 Mercenaria mercenaria (Linnaeus, 1758 ) Callista chione (Linnaeus, 1758 )
Canapa e t al. 199 9 Frischer et al, unpublishe d Canapa et al 199 9
Arcticoidea Arctica islandica (Linnaeus, 1767 )
Bell & Grassle 1998 , unpublishe d U9355 5
Corbiculoidea Corbicula leana Prime, 186 4
Adamkewicz et al. 199 7 L7886
Mactroidea Mactromeris polynyma (Stimpson , 1860 ) Spisula solida (Linnaeus, 1758 ) Mulinia lateralis (Say, 1822 ) Tresus nuttalli (Conrad, 1837 )
Rice e t al 199 3 Rice e t al. 199 3 Rice et al 199 3 Rice et al 199 3
L11230 LI1266 L11268 LI 1269
Field e t al 1988 ; Campbell e t al 199 8
M20094,M21541, M21175; AF022478
Pholadoidea teredinid (pallet s no t preserved )
new
AF229613
Pandoroidea Pandora arenosa Conrad, 183 4 Lyonsia floridana Conrad , 184 9
new new
AF120539 AF120540
Poromyoidea Myonera specie s
new
AF120544
Solenoidea Ensis directus Conrad, 184 3
Myoidea My a arenaria Linnaeus, 175 8
8 8 8 8 8 8 8
AJ007614 AF106073 AJ007613
1
For Bivalvia , th e superfamil y i s given ; fo r othe r Mollusca , th e class ; an d fo r non-molluscs , th e phylum . Taxonomi c change s o r corrections ar e note d i n squar e brackets . Most o f thes e hav e als o been note d b y th e origina l autho r o r othe r reviewers . However , Neocrania i s a n apparently overlooke d junior homonym . Bell & Grassle (1998) in their tex t give corrected, more complete sequences for Tellina versicolor and Ensis directus than the GenBank files, but only use part of the Arctica islandica sequence; the most complete sequences were used in the present analyses.
34
D. C . CAMPBEL L
(Hoeh e t al. 1997) . Also , the y generall y evolv e more rapidl y tha n nuclea r gene s an d s o ar e les s useful fo r earlie r evolutionar y event s (Hilli s & Dixon 1991) . Finally , th e 18 S gene ha s th e mos t available data. Despite it s potential , molecula r phylogenetic s has often yielde d problematical results , conflicting with previou s morphologica l studies . I n som e cases, revie w o f morphologica l dat a has provided support fo r th e ne w classification , wherea s othe r instances see m t o reflec t problem s wit h th e molecular analyses . Althoug h exception s ar e known (Felsenstein 1978) , usually increasing either the numbe r o f tax a o r th e amoun t o f dat a wil l improve accurac y (Po e & Swoffor d 1999) . I n particular, i t i s importan t t o avoi d wid e phylogenetic gap s amon g tax a t o avoi d spuriou s associations ('long-branc h attraction') (Felsenstei n 1978). B y includin g additiona l taxa , th e presen t study sought to address some of these problems.
Materials and Methods Taxa
The present study sought to include as many higher level tax a a s possible . However , variou s highe r level taxa are used differently b y different authors . A consensu s o f recen t systemati c work s suggest s recognizing fiv e extan t subclasses , althoug h othe r classifications hav e bee n advocate d (e.g . Carte r 1990; Cope 1997 ; Carter et al. 2000). The subclass Protobranchia include s th e order s Nuculoid a an d Solemyoida; th e subclas s Pteriomorphi a include s the orders Arcoida, Limoida, Ostreoida, Pectinoida, Pterioida an d Mytiloida; the subclas s Heterodonta includes th e order s Veneroid a an d Myoida ; th e subclass Palaeoheterodont a include s th e order s Unionoida an d Trigonioida ; an d th e subclas s Anomalodesmata include s th e orde r Phola domyoida. The subclasses other than Protobranchia are often groupe d a s the Autobranchia. Within the Autobranchia, tw o majo r group s hav e bee n recognized: th e Pteriomorphi a an d th e Heteroconchia (includin g Palaeoheterodonta , Heterodonta an d Anomalodesmata). Othe r classifications spli t th e Mytiloid a fro m Pteriomorphi a a s the subclas s Isofilibranchia . Suborder s o f Veneroida are herein referre d to as Lucinoidei an d Veneroidei, followin g th e ending s use d b y Starobogatov (1992 ) i n th e ligh t o f variatio n i n ending and assigned rank. The presen t analyse s include d al l publishe d complete bivalve 18 S sequences, except in the case of multipl e sequence s fo r th e sam e genus . Ne w sequences focuse d o n additiona l highe r taxa . Published partia l sequence s wer e include d i f they represented superfamilie s fo r whic h no mor e than
one complet e sequenc e wa s availabl e an d i f their positio n i n analyse s wa s relativel y well constrained. Tabl e 1 list s th e tax a an d sources . Accession number s allo w locatio n o f th e dat a i n GenBank. I n preliminar y analyses , Brachiopoda , Phoronida an d othe r mollusc s wer e th e closes t relatives o f Bivalvia , s o thes e wer e retaine d a s outgroups fo r th e fina l analyses . Onl y a singl e sequence wa s availabl e fo r Scaphopod a an d Chaetodermomorpha, so they were excluded due to the lon g branc h (a t leas t Cambrian-Recent) . Thi s left multipl e sequence s fo r Polyplacophora , Gastropoda an d Brachiopoda , alon g wit h th e phoronid, for outgroups.
Molecular Techniques Molecular procedure s followe d standar d protocol s for cetyltrimethylammoniu m bromid e (CTAB ) extraction, polymeras e chai n reactio n (PCR ) an d dye-labelled cycl e sequencing . PC R an d sequenc ing primers were designed using published primer s (Rice 1990; Winnepenninckx et al. 1994; Giribe t et al. 1996; Whiting et al. 1997) and results of preliminary researc h b y Campbel l e t al . (1998) . PC R primers wer e CAACCTGGTTGATCCT G (forward) an d CTGATCCTTCTGCAGGTT C (reverse). Additiona l sequencin g primer s wer e GTTCGATTCCGGAGAGGGA an d ATGGTTGCAAAGCTGAAAC (forward) , an d AGGCTCCCTCTCCGGAATCGAAC an d TTGGCAAATGCTTTCGC (reverse) . Th e PC R started wit h 4 min at 94°C, followe d by 26 cycle s with 1 mi n 94°C , 1 mi n a t th e annealin g temperature an d 2 mi n a t 72°C . Annealin g temperatures wer e 56 , 54 , an d 52° C fo r th e firs t three cycles , 50° C fo r th e nex t thre e cycle s an d 48°C fo r th e remainder . Thi s wa s followe d b y 10 min a t 72°C. The sequencin g reaction was held at 96° C for 4 min, followed by 2 5 cycles a t 96° C for 3 0 s an d the n a t 49° C fo r 4 mi n 3 0 s. Th e protobranch and anomalodesmatan sequences were obtained b y Gonzal o Giribe t o f th e America n Museum o f Natura l Histor y fro m specimen s obtained b y the present author . New sequences fo r Pteriomorphia were largely obtained while working at th e America n Museum of Natura l History. Th e new complet e sequence s hav e bot h strand s sequenced. A preliminar y partia l sequenc e wa s included for Teredinidae, as no complete sequences are available . I t agree s wel l wit h unpublishe d preliminary dat a fo r Pholadida e i n th e sam e superfamily. Attempt s a t furthe r sequencin g fro m the teredini d wer e unsuccessful . Th e shell s fro m analysed specimen s wer e deposite d i n th e University o f Nort h Carolin a a t Chape l Hil l collections a s vouchers.
MOLECULAR AND MORPHOLOGICAL EVOLUTION
Analytical Methods The DN A sequence s wer e aligne d b y hand , wit h reference t o th e secondar y structur e mode l o f Winnepenninckx e t al (1994) . Alignmen t procedures remai n problematica l (Giribe t & Wheele r 1999) an d variation s i n alignmen t ma y generat e different cladogram s (Winnepenninck x & Backeljau 1996) . Althoug h computerize d align ments are more replicable than manual alignments , there is no guarantee that they are better. Repeate d alignment o f th e sam e sequence s wa s use d t o identify area s o f uncertai n alignment, whic h were revised t o ensur e consistency . Th e presen t alignment wa s submitte d t o EMB L a t http:7www.ebi.ac.uk/ an d i s alignmen t DS41611 . Maximum parsimony , neighbour-joinin g an d bootstrap analyse s wer e performe d usin g PAUP 3.1.1 (Swoffor d 1993 ) and PAUP*4.0 (Swoffor d 1999). Deca y indice s (als o calle d Breme r indices ) were calculate d usin g TreeRot (Sorenso n 1999) , PAUP 3.1.1 and PAUP*4.0. Multipl e outgroup s were use d a s ther e i s disagreemen t o n the closes t relatives o f th e Bivalvi a (e.g . Runnegar 1996; Waller 1998). After preliminary analyses, including several outgroups, Gastropoda, Polyplacophora an d Brachiopoda wer e selecte d becaus e the y consistently place d close t o Bivalvia, if not within it, an d because multipl e complete sequence s wer e available, decreasin g th e ris k o f long-branc h attraction. Th e firs t 2 0 an d las t 2 3 base s wer e excluded becaus e the y represen t prime r sequenc e rather tha n actua l dat a fo r mos t sequences . Multistate characters wer e treated a s uncertain. Maximum-parsimony analyse s wer e use d t o generate phylogeneti c models . Th e heuristi c analyses use d rando m additio n o f taxa , wit h 10 0 replicates. Tre e bisection-rejoinin g wa s use d fo r branch swappin g (Swoffor d & Begl e 1993) . Th e best treatmen t o f gap s i s debate d (Giribe t & Wheeler 1999) . Althoug h ignorin g the m ca n omi t informative data , the presence o f long indels mad e other method s mor e problematical . Th e firs t analysis treated gap s a s missing data. As a test of the effect o f gaps, a second analysis was performed with gap s treate d a s a fift h characte r state . Thi s represents an extreme weighting of gaps, so clades supported by both analyses are probably relatively stable with respect t o gap weighting. The tree s fro m th e heuristi c searche s wer e combined t o generat e stric t consensu s trees . Bootstrap analysi s use d 10 0 replicates , eac h o f which was a heuristic searc h with closest addition , holding te n tree s a t eac h ste p an d usin g tre e bisection-rejoining. Deca y indices were calculated using heuristic searches of 20 random replicates for trees incompatibl e wit h th e constrain t (Sorenso n 1999). Althoug h no absolute criteria ar e known for
35
evaluating deca y indice s (Swoffor d e t al . 1996) , higher indices suggest stronger support. A neighbour-joinin g tre e wa s als o calculate d (Saitou & Nei 1987) . Neighbou r joinin g i s bette r regarded as an algorithm for generating trees to use in further searchin g rather than as a source for fina l trees, a s it has no optimality criterio n (Swoffor d e t al. 1996) . However , i t ha s bee n widel y use d t o generate fina l trees . I t i s include d fo r compariso n and a s a demonstration of nodes that are robust to multiple method s o f analysis . I t use d a oneparameter mode l wit h gaps coded a s missing data. Hillis & Bul l (1993 ) foun d that , fo r unbiase d data sets , bootstra p value s abov e 70 % correlat e with a 95 % probabilit y o f phylogeneti c accuracy . Asymmetry in the present cladograms and variation in evolutionar y rate s woul d ten d t o rais e th e bootstrap valu e necessary fo r 95% confidence, bu t unless th e dat a ar e extremely divergent , bootstra p percentages tend to underestimate the phylogenetic probability. Results Complete sequenc e length s rang e fro m 179 4 to 2192 bases , wit h th e alignmen t lengt h a t 233 0 bases. Th e longes t sequence s wer e th e anomalodesmatans, rangin g fro m 191 9 to 2192. The next longest were the fragines, from the data of Maruyama e t al . (1998) . Othe r ne w sequence s ranged from 179 4 to 182 0 bases, although some of this variatio n reflect s variatio n i n th e numbe r o f bases resolved nea r the primers . With gap s code d a s missing data , 76 4 include d positions ar e parsimon y informative . Th e nin e shortest trees foun d by parsimony wit h gaps code d as missing wer e 374 4 step s an d were foun d b y 97 of th e replicates . Th e g l valu e wa s -0.730 689, based on 100 000 random trees. Other tree statistics include a consistenc y inde x o f 0.458 1 (0.394 5 excluding uninformativ e characters) , a retentio n index of 0.6999 and a rescaled consistency index of 0.3206. Figur e 1 show s th e stric t consensu s tre e with decay index values indicated an d Fig. 2 shows the bootstrap results. Deca y value s range from 1 to 57, suggestin g tha t long-branc h attractio n ma y cause problems . Th e highes t deca y indice s (ove r 20) were confine d t o Cardiidae, Anomalodesmata , Nuculanoidea an d Caenogastropoda . Th e highes t values are within Cardiidae . The neighbour-joining tree was 3780 step s long, evaluated usin g maximu m parsimony . Th e consistency inde x wa s 0.453 7 (0.390 3 excludin g uninformative characters) , the retention inde x was 0.6946 an d th e rescale d consistenc y inde x wa s 0.3151. Figure 3 shows the neighbour-joining tree . Differences wit h the first analysi s ar e noted .
36 D
. C. CAMPBEL L
Fig. 1 . Strict consensus with gaps coded as missing data . Numbers above branches are the decay index or Bremer support values.
MOLECULAR AND MORPHOLOGICAL EVOLUTION 3
7
Fig. 2 . Strict consensus tree with gaps coded a s missing data. Numbers above branches are the bootstrap percentage s for al l clades wit h least 50 % support. Also, the bootstrap suppor t for other ingroup nodes from Fig. 1 is given. Note that conflicting clade s may have higher bootstrap suppor t if support for the clade is under 50%. The two bold clade s had over 50% bootstrap support but conflict wit h the strict consensus tree.
38 D
. C. CAMPBEL L
With gaps coded a s a fifth characte r state, there were 102 4 parsimony informativ e characters . The 122 shortes t tree s foun d b y parsimon y wit h gap s coded a s missing wer e 5672 steps . Thi s represent s
two group s of trees, foun d b y 5 4 an d 2 1 searches . The remaining 25 searches found three longer local minima. Th e gl valu e wa s -0.801 573, base d o n 100 000 random trees. Othe r tre e statistic s includ e
Fig. 3 . Neighbour-joining tree , gap s code d a s missing data . Clade s no t supported i n Fig. 1 are shown wit h thicke r branches, includin g polytomie s in Fig. 1 resolved by neighbour joining .
MOLECULAR AND MORPHOLOGICAL EVOLUTION 3
9
Fig. 4 . Strict consensus wit h gaps coded a s a fifth characte r state . Numbers above branches ar e the decay index or Bremer support values. Clades no t supported in Fig. 1 are shown with thicker branches , includin g polytomies in Fig. 1 resolved i n this second analysis. Polytomies i n this consensus that were resolved in Fig. 1 are also indicated with thicker branches .
40 D
. C. CAMPBELL
Fig. 5 . Strict consensus tree with gaps coded as a fifth characte r state . Numbers above branches are the bootstrap percentages fo r all clades with least 50% support. Also, the bootstrap suppor t for other ingroup nodes from Fig . 4 is given. Note that conflicting clades may have higher bootstrap suppor t if support for the clade is under 50%. The six bold clades were either unresolved in the strict consensus or had over 50% bootstrap suppor t but conflict with the strict consensus. The clade of Hippopus, Fragum and Corculum, supported in the strict consensus, had 49% support. A clade with 50% bootstrap support also conflicted with the strict consensus; it includes Veneroida, excep t Carditamera, Anomalodesmata and Unionidae, as indicated by the lines to the right.
MOLECULAR AND MORPHOLOGICAL EVOLUTIO N
41
other mollusca n classe s represented . Preliminar y analyses in the present study showed that excluding outgroups wit h onl y a singl e availabl e sequenc e and adding additiona l representative s o f remaining outgroup tax a le d t o stronge r suppor t fo r bivalv e monophyly. The results of Hoeh e t al. (1998) ma y also have been affected b y the higher mutation rate of the 16S gene (Hillis & Dixon 1991), which could lead to greater long-branch attraction. In the present study, th e firs t analysi s (gap s code d a s missin g data) supporte d bivalv e monophyly , thoug h wit h weak deca y an d bootstra p support . Th e secon d analysis (gap s coded a s a fifth characte r state ) di d not resolv e bivalv e monophyl y relativ e t o othe r molluscs, ye t bootstra p suppor t fo r bivalv e Discussion monophyly wa s higher (44.3 % wit h no mor e than In general , agreemen t betwee n th e molecula r an d 18.5% against , a s oppose d t o 17.0 % in th e firs t morphological result s i s good , rangin g fro m th e analysis wit h 21.8 % and 15.8 % supporting th e class t o the genu s level. However, ther e ar e som e highest supported clades with bivalve paraphyly or points o f disagreemen t betwee n them , a s wel l a s polyphyly). Non e o f thes e bootstra p value s ar e disagreements amon g models base d o n either dat a high enoug h t o vie w a s stron g support . Th e source. Higher taxa are used in these discussions as neighbour-joining tre e place s Gastropod a nea r th e defined above, although some papers used the same base o f Heteroconchi a an d Polyplacophor a wit h names differentl y [e.g . Cop e (1997 ) exclude d Nuculanoidea a s basal molluscs . A s Nuculanoidea Arcoida fro m Pteriomorphi a an d Campbel l e t al. was a n exceptionall y lon g branch (decay inde x of (1998) placed Myoida in Anomalodesmata]. 50 wit h gap s code d a s missing ) an d Gastropod a Despite th e wide rang e o f deca y indice s an d moderately lon g (deca y inde x o f 8) , thes e ca n b e sequence lengths , tax a wit h hig h value s generall y dismissed a s probabl e errors , i n additio n t o th e grouped into clades compatible with morphological inherent problems o f evaluating neighbour-joining evidence. Onl y th e neighbour-joinin g tree an d th e trees. Monophyl y for Gastropoda , Polyplacophor a internal topolog y o f Cardiida e conflic t wit h and Mollusca had at least 75% bootstrap support in morphological evidenc e i n th e placemen t o f thes e both analyses , an d othe r outgrou p clade s als o probable long branches. received stron g support. Most morpholog y base d analyse s agre e o n th e The parsimon y analyse s supporte d al l fiv e monophyly o f th e Riva l via, apar t fro m uncertain - subclasses o f th e Bivalvi a a s monophyletic , i n ties abou t poorl y know n Cambria n forms . How- agreement with most morphological studies , except ever, molecular suppor t for this has been weak . In for th e positio n o f Carditamera. The neighbour fact, Hoe h e t al . (1998 ) suggested , base d o n joining analysi s ha d Protobranchi a a s diphyletic . molecular data, that the class is diphyletic and other However, th e bootstrap an d deca y suppor t fo r th e molecular analyse s hav e ha d simila r result s (e.g. subclasses wa s ofte n weaker . Previou s molecula r Kenchington e t al . 1994 ; Steiner & Muller 1996; analyses have frequently faile d t o find monophyl y Winnepenninckxefa/. 1996; Campbell ef al. 1998), of th e subclasses , agai n probably becaus e o f poo r usually interprete d a s error . Thi s ma y reflec t a representation o f some subclasse s (bot h in number limited range of taxa, especially with limited repre- of tax a an d completenes s o f sequences) . Another sentation of protobranchs. Suc h wide phylogenetic source o f anomalous results has been the tendency for Crassostrea virginica (on e of th e firs t specie s spacing o f tax a make s long-branch attractio n a likely problem. If, as suggested by the phylogeny of sequenced an d thu s include d i n mos t analyses ) t o Waller (1998) , th e Bivalvia are relatively distantly place outsid e o f Pteriomorphi a o r mak e related to other conchiferans , thi s problem wil l be Pteriomorphia paraphyletic , wit h Crassostrea a s particularly acute , wit h th e divergenc e betwee n the siste r taxo n t o heterodont s (Steine r & Mulle r them an d othe r extan t mollusc s n o late r tha n th e 1996; Winnepenninckx et al. 1996 ; Campbell et al. earliest Cambria n (Runnegar 1996). Modern proto- 1998). This species seems to have a relatively hig h branchs diverge d from othe r bivalves by th e earl y rate o f molecula r evolutio n relativ e t o othe r Ordovician (Cop e 1996 ; Carter e t al 2000) . Thus, pteriomorphians (Steiner & Muller 1996 ; Canapa et limited samplin g o f outgroup s an d protobranch s al. 1999) , makin g i t a likel y candidat e fo r long branch attraction . Th e inclusio n o f other ostreoid s produces ver y lon g branches . Thi s remain s a problem i n th e presen t study , wit h onl y fou r [Ostrea i n Campbel l e t al . (1998) , Frische r e t al . protobranchs, n o solemyoid s an d onl y tw o o f th e (1998) an d Canap a e t al . (1999) , an d Hyotissa a consistenc y inde x o f 0.431 8 (0.383 7 excludin g uninformative characters) , a retentio n inde x o f 0.6642 and a rescaled consistency index of 0.2868. Figure 4 shows the strict consensus tree with decay index value s indicate d an d Fig . 5 show s th e bootstrap results; differences fro m the first analysis are highlighted i n Fig. 4. Decay values range fro m 1 t o 149 , suggesting tha t long-branc h attractio n may cause problems. Decay indices of over 20 were confined t o Cardiidae , Anomalodesmata , Nuculanoidea, Ostreoidea , Pterioide a an d Caenogastropoda. Again , th e highes t value s ar e within Cardiidae .
42
D. C . CAMPBEL L
hyotis, herein ] help s solv e thi s problem . Mos t previous molecula r analyse s onl y includ e Pteriomorphia an d Heterodonta . Som e o f thes e have supporte d monophyl y fo r bot h include d subclasses (Ric e e t al. 1993 ; Frische r e t al 1998 ; Giribet & Carranza 1998) . Also , som e analyse s in Hoeh et al. (1998) supporte d monophyly of all four subclasses include d i n their analyses , althoug h no t supporting monophyl y fo r th e Bivalvia . Adamkewicz e t al. (1997) published the only prior molecular analysi s t o includ e al l fiv e subclasses , though som e o f thei r sequence s wer e ver y short . Pseudogenes, o r error s b y th e sequencin g laboratory, ma y als o hav e cause d problem s wit h some o f thei r sequence s (Adamkewic z pers . comm.). Onl y Heterodont a and Palaeoheterodont a appeared monophyleti c i n thei r analyses . Th e relatively shor t sequences and limited taxonomical coverage (thoug h muc h wide r tha n an y previou s study) probably affecte d thei r resolutio n o f highe r taxa. Although man y morphological analyse s suppor t the monophyl y o f al l include d subclasse s (e.g . Cope 1997 ; Walle r 1998) , other s disagree . Salvini Plawen & Steine r (1996 ) separate d Trigonioid a from Unionoid a an d Myoid a fro m Veneroid a (which the y divide d into Veneroid a sensu stricto and Lucinoidea) , althoug h the y note d th e ris k o f convergent evolution in some supporting characters (compare th e apomorphie s fo r Trigonioid a wit h the synapomorphie s fo r Eulamellibranchia , node s 14 an d 1 6 i n fig . 2.10) . Morto n (1996 ) ha d Pteriomorphia paraphyleti c t o Palaeoheterodont a and Heterodonta paraphyleti c t o Anomalodesmata . Although Neotrigonia i s no t represente d i n th e present analyses , Hoe h e t al . (1998 ) foun d clos e similarity between Neotrigonia and unionids for the 16S gene, an d morphologica l similaritie s ar e als o strong, wit h plausible fossi l transition s (Newell & Boyd 1975) . Likewise , th e similaritie s betwee n Myoida an d Anomalodesmat a ar e pron e t o convergent evolutio n (Salvini-Plawe n & Steine r 1996), an d the similarities betwee n Trigonioida and Pteriomorphia are probably plesiomorphies (Waller 1998). A s discusse d below , molecula r evidenc e strongly support s placin g Myoid a i n Heterodont a rather than in Anomalodesmata . The relationship s amon g thes e subclasse s ar e much mor e contentious. Almost all morphological studies agree that the Protobranchia ar e basal to the remaining Bivalvia. Most see Pteriomorphia a s the next group to diverge (Waller 1998) , possibly along with th e Palaeoheterodont a (Morto n 1996) . However, Cop e (1997 ) groupe d Heterodont a wit h Pteriomorphia (divide d int o Pteriomorphi a sensu stricto an d Neotaxodonta ) an d Anomalodesmat a with Palaeoheterodonta. Previou s molecular studies provide som e resolutio n o f subclass-leve l
relationships, althoug h ofte n no t well-supported . Adamkewicz e t al . (1997 ) ha d protobranch s an d anomalodesmatans basal , an d tendin g t o plac e outside Bivalvia, and Pteriomorphia paraphyletic to a siste r groupin g o f Palaeoheterodont a an d Heterodonta. Similarly , Campbell e t al. (1998) had Protobranchia basal , wit h tendencie s t o plac e outside Bivalvia, and Pteriomorphia paraphyleti c to Heterodonta. Hoe h e t al . (1998 ) agai n ha d protobranchs basal , tendin g t o plac e outsid e o f Bivalvia, an d Palaeoheterodont a nex t mos t basal , with Pteriomorphi a an d Heterodont a a s siste r taxa. I n th e presen t study , Protobranchia , Anomalodesmata an d Palaeoheterodont a ar e eac h represented by , a t most , fou r complet e sequences , making thei r affinitie s les s certain . However , th e association betwee n Anomalodesmat a an d Heterodonta seem s well-supporte d b y th e presen t molecular dat a a s wel l a s morphological evidenc e (Waller 1998) . Monophyl y fo r Heteroconchi a i s supported b y al l th e analyses , althoug h th e neighbour-joining tre e include s Gastropoda . Bootstrap and decay suppor t are lower than for the Heterodonta an d Anomalodesmat a (withou t Carditamera) clade . The relativ e position s of Protobranchia an d Pteriomorphia , a s wel l a s their positio n relativ e t o Heterodont a an d Anomalodesmata, var y fro m analysi s t o analysis . No relationship s amon g subclasse s ha d a deca y index higher tha n two in th e firs t analysi s or three in the second . Relationships simila r t o thos e propose d b y Waller (1998 ) see m mos t likel y fro m al l available evidence . Th e morphological similaritie s between Palaeoheterodonta , Heterodont a an d Anomalodesmata ar e numerous (Salvini-Plawen & Steiner 1996 ; Walle r 1998) , an d molecula r evidence weakl y support s groupin g Palaeoheterodonta wit h th e othe r tw o (Adamkewicz e t al . 1997 ; presen t study) . Cop e (1997) groupe d Heterodont a an d Pteriomorphi a largely o n th e basi s o f crossed-lamella r microstructure; however, this is convergent an d the basal microstructur e in Pteriomorphi a i s nacreou s (Carter 1990 ; Carte r e t al. 2000). Relationships betwee n order s withi n th e subclasses ar e als o debated . Withi n th e Pteriomorphia, Mytiloid a an d Arcoid a ar e generally agree d t o b e basa l [no t universally , though, e.g . Morto n (1996)] . Mytiloid a i s usually considered basal (Walle r 1998 ; Carte r et al. 2000) , but Arcoid a i s viewe d a s basa l i n som e studie s (Cope 1997) . Among the remaining orders, severa l phylogenetic arrangement s hav e bee n proposed . Limoida wa s traditionall y associate d wit h Pectinoida (Co x e t al . 1969) , bu t Walle r (1978 , 1998) moved it to a more basal position an d Morton (1996) grouped it with Ostreoida. The relationships
MOLECULAR AND MORPHOLOGICAL EVOLUTION
between Ostreoida , Pterioida , an d Pectinoid a ar e particularly debated , wit h abou t equa l suppor t fo r closer relationship s betwee n Ostreoid a an d Pectinoida (Morto n 1996 ; Walle r 1998) , an d between Ostreoid a an d Pterioid a (Carte r 1990) . Assignments o f superfamilie s t o thes e order s ha s also varied . Co x e t al. (1969 ) associate d Plicatulidae wit h Pectinoide a an d Pinnoide a wit h Mytiloida, but Waller (1978 ) an d most subsequent work grou p Plicatulida e wit h Ostreoide a an d Pinnoidea wit h Pterioida . Anomioide a i s usuall y associated with Pectinoidea, bu t Waller (1998) put them i n a polytom y relativ e t o Ostreoide a an d Morton (1996) grouped them with Pterioida. Previous molecular studies have supported som e of thes e ideas . Mytiloid a an d Arcoid a wer e generally relativel y basal , althoug h the position of Ostreoida varied (Kenchington et al. 1994 ; Steine r & Miille r 1996 ; Winnepenninckx e t a l 1996 ; Adamkewicz e t a l 1997 ; Campbell e t a l 1998 ; Frischer e t a l 1998 ; Giribet & Carranz a 1998 ; Steiner 1999 ; Canapa e t a l 1999) . Ostreoid a wa s consistently distan t fro m Pectinoida ; whe n Pterioidea wa s represented , i t groupe d wit h Ostreoida. Pinnoide a als o tende d t o appea r basal, but wit h som e tendenc y t o grou p with Pterioide a and Ostreoidea . Th e slo w evolutionar y rat e o f Atrina, a s show n b y lo w percentag e difference s with th e outgroup , probably affecte d it s apparen t affinities (Steine r & Mulle r 1996) . Onl y Adamkewicz e t al . (1997 ) an d Campbel l e t al . (1998) had multipl e familie s for any pterio morphian orde r (Pinnida e and Pteriidae, an d those plus Isognomonidae, respectively) . These produced weak to strong support for monophyly of Pterioida and Pterioidea. With severa l additiona l superfamilie s an d families represente d (Gryphaeidae , Plicatuloidea , Anomioidea, Spondylida e an d Glycymerididae , a s well a s complet e sequence s fo r Pteriida e an d Isognomonidae), an d better representation o f other superfamilies, th e presen t analyse s wer e abl e t o address additiona l morpholog y base d hypotheses . Ostreoida an d Pterioida sho w a close relationship, with Pterioid a paraphyleti c t o Ostreoida . Th e association o f Pterioide a an d Ostreoid a ha s th e highest deca y suppor t ( 4 in the firs t analysis , 5 in the second ) o f an y supraordina l group within th e Bivalvia. Th e presen t analyse s als o strongl y support monophyly for Ostreoidea , includin g both Gryphaeidae an d Ostreidae , i n agreemen t wit h Waller (1998 ) bu t contrastin g wit h the uncertainty expressed i n Carte r (1990) . Plicatuloide a i s strongly supporte d a s th e siste r taxo n o f Anomioidea and they are both generally associated with Pectinoide a (includin g Spondylida e an d Pectinidae). Thi s associatio n o f Plicatuloide a an d Anomioidea i s unexpecte d fro m morphologica l
43
studies. Also, Arcidae appears paraphyletic relative to Glycymerididae ; thi s i s no t entirel y surprisin g because both Area an d Barbatia ha d arise n b y th e Jurassic, wherea s Glycymeridida e extend s bac k only to the Cretaceous (Co x et al 1969) . However, relationships betwee n Pectinoida , Arcoida , Mytiloida an d th e Ostreoida-Pterioid a clad e ar e poorly resolve d i n th e present study . Ancestors of all four were present in the Ordovician (Carter et al 2000), s o th e radiatio n ma y hav e bee n relativel y rapid, an d the basal branche s ar e moderately long , with ver y fe w branche s withi n th e clade s represented before Late Palaeozoic. In contrast to the Pteriomorphia, there ar e many fewer phylogenie s propose d fo r relationship s among superfamilie s i n Heterodonta . Man y examples o f convergenc e ar e known , an d man y authors have proposed that Veneroida, Myoida and Heterodonta ma y b e polyphyleti c (e.g . Newel l 1965). Althoug h Veneroida is sometimes spli t int o lucinid- an d venerid-centre d groups , th e assign ment o f tax a t o thes e tw o division s (order s o r suborders, depending on the reference) is not wellestablished. Fo r example , Newel l (1965 ) place d Tellinoidea with the Lucinoidei, but Morton (1996) put the m close r t o venerid s an d spli t of f som e o f Newell's lucinoideine s basally , relativ e t o th e res t of Heterodonta an d Anomalodesmata. Despite th e uncertaintie s fro m morphology , th e DNA evidenc e provide s resolutio n o f variou s groups withi n th e Heterodont a abov e th e super family level . Al l parsimon y analyse s supporte d a clade includin g Mactroidea , Veneroidea , Corbiculoidea, Arcticoidea, Myoidea , an d Pholadoidea; thi s ha d 94.2 % an d 100 % bootstrap support an d 3 an d 9 fo r deca y inde x values . Previous molecula r studie s have found suppor t for this grouping (Adamkewicz e t al 1997 ; Canap a et al 1999 ) but mos t studie s hav e no t include d enough representatives of both this group and other heterodonts, preventin g assessmen t o f it s monophyly. This group is similar t o the traditional suborder Veneroidei of morphological analyses , but also include s Mactroidea , Myoide a an d Pholadoidea. Sau l (1973 ) propose d evolutio n o f Mactroidea fro m Arcticoidea , whic h would put i t into thi s group . Othe r molecula r studie s sugges t that Dreissenoidea, Chamoidea an d Pisidiidae ma y belong here (Adamkewicz et al 1997 ; Rosenberg et al 1997 ; Hoeh e t a l 1998) . Anothe r veneroi d group, foun d b y al l parsimon y analyse s bu t wit h weaker bootstra p an d deca y value s (55.7 % an d 45.9%, 2 an d 2) , include d Gastrochaenoidea , Galeommatoidea an d Sportellidae . Stron g suppor t (93.6% and 98.3%, 5 and 6 decay index) for a clade of Sportellida e an d Galeommatoide a agree s wit h recent morphological studies (Salas & Gofas 1998) . This clad e resembles Erycinoine i o f Starobogato v
44
D. C . CAMPBELL
(1992), bu t morphologica l studie s sugges t tha t Cyrenoidea is polyphyletic wit h the other familie s probably i n th e suborde r Veneroidei . Splittin g Myoida amon g Vereroid a wa s als o supporte d b y Adamkewicz et al. (1997) and some morphological studies. Althoug h Gastrochaenoide a ha s bee n recognized a s very different fro m Myoide a (Carte r 1978), it s associatio n wit h Galeommatoide a an d Sportellidae i s unexpecte d an d onl y weakl y sup ported b y bootstra p an d deca y (no t supporte d b y neighbour-joining). Th e Gastrochaenoide a doe s consistently plac e within Heterodonta bu t outsid e Veneroidei, whic h contain s Myoide a an d Pholadoidea. Anothe r groupin g supporte d b y th e present parsimon y analyse s i s Tellinoide a plu s Cardioidea, simila r t o th e suborde r Cardioide i o f Starobogatov (1992 ) bu t includin g Donacidae an d excluding Ungulinoidea . However, thi s ma y b e a case o f long-branc h attraction , a s Tellinoide a an d Cardioidea both have high decay indices. Although this clade received 80.6 % bootstra p suppor t in the first analysis , it only received 27.3 % support in the second, les s tha n th e 43.0 % suppor t for grouping Cardioidea, Gastrochaenida e an d Erycinoinei . Solenoidea and the Galeommatoidea-SportellidaeGastrochaenoidea clade seem to be relatively basal, but wit h poo r bootstra p support . Finally , Carditoidea i s basa l no t onl y to al l othe r sample d heterodonts bu t als o t o Anomalodesmata . Thi s i s unexpected; althoug h they appea r t o b e relatively primitive heterodonts , the y ar e morphologicall y similar t o othe r heterodont s exclusiv e o f anom alodesmatans. Mor e molecula r dat a fo r othe r primitive heterodonts are needed to test this result, especially Crassatelloide a an d Lucinoidea. All bivalv e superfamilie s an d familie s appea r monophyletic excep t Arcidae . Suppor t fo r monophyly o f Nuculida e an d Nuculoide a wa s weak. Although the stric t consensus in th e second analysis di d no t resolv e Nuculida e relativ e t o Nuculanoidea, bootstrap support for Nuculidae was slightly higher tha n in th e firs t analysi s (61.0 % v . 59.4%).
Conclusions Analysis of 18 S rDNA helps resolve several issues in th e phylogen y o f th e Riva l via. I n particular , conflicts betwee n differen t morpholog y base d interpretations can ofte n b e resolved b y use of this new dat a source . Furthe r stud y promise s t o continue t o improv e ou r understandin g of bivalve evolution. The numerou s area s o f agreemen t betwee n th e present stud y an d previou s morphologica l an d molecular studie s sugges t tha t w e ar e converging on a common phylogeny of the Bivalvia. In particular, th e traditiona l subclasses , orders , super -
families an d familie s generall y see m t o b e monophyletic. However , man y importan t tax a remain poorl y know n an d area s o f disagreemen t remain t o b e resolved, especiall y i n th e relation ships betwee n tax a o f equa l rank . Dat a fro m additional gene s an d furthe r morphologica l analyses should resolve man y of these issues. Relationships amon g th e subclasse s ar e no t ye t clear, apar t from th e grouping of Anomalodesmat a and Heterodonta . Heteroconchi a (Palaeo heterodonta, Heterodont a an d Anomalodesmata ) received weake r support . Monophyl y o f th e subclasses is supported, with the possible exception of Carditoidea placin g basally in the HeterodontaAnomalodesmata clade , a s i s monophyl y o f mos t orders, superfamilie s and families. In addition , thre e clade s no t correspondin g t o named highe r tax a ar e strongl y supported . Th e clade o f advance d veneroid s (Mactroidea , Arcticoidea, Corbiculoidea , Veneroidea , Myoidea, and Pholadoidea) , th e Sportellidae-Galeom matoidea clad e an d th e Plicatuloidea-Anomioide a clade ha d ove r 93 % bootstra p suppor t i n bot h analyses. Als o supporte d b y bot h parsimon y analyses and receiving over 75% bootstrap support in a t least on e analysis were a clade of Tellinoide a and Cardioidea , a clad e o f Arcticoide a an d Veneroidea, a clad e o f Anomalodesmat a an d Heterodonta excludin g Carditoidea, an d a clade of Myoidea an d Pholadoidea . Plicatuloide a an d Anomioidea belon g i n Pectinoid a rathe r tha n Ostreoida or a separate order. Myoida i s polyphyletic , wit h a t leas t tw o separate origins from withi n Veneroida, and should not b e considere d a s a n order . However , tw o 'myoid' superfamilies , Myoidea an d Pholadoidea , form a clade within Veneroida. K. Hoekstra , i n he r master' s thesis , establishe d th e usefulness o f 18 S gen e sequenc e dat a fo r suprafamilia l systematics in the Bivalvia and experimented with various molecular techniques . G . Giribe t an d K . Hoekstr a obtained som e sequenc e dat a use d i n th e presen t stud y and helpe d wit h molecula r techniques . Wor k o n severa l pteriomorph sequence s wa s performe d i n W . Wheeler's laboratory, workin g wit h G . Giribet. The Paleontological Society, Sigma Xi, the Geological Society o f America, the Conchologists o f America , a Royste r Dissertatio n Fellowship and a Martin gran t helpe d fun d thi s research . Several peopl e helpe d obtai n specimens . G . Giribet , E . Harper an d a n anonymou s reviewe r provide d helpfu l comments an d corrections.
References ADAMKEWICZ, S . L. , HARASEWYCH , M . G. , BLAKE , J. , SAUDEK, D . & BULT , C . J . 1997 . A molecula r phylogeny o f th e bivalv e mollusks . Molecular Biology an d Evolution, 14, 619-629. BELL, J . L . & GRASSLE , J . P . 1998 . A DN A prob e fo r
MOLECULAR AND MORPHOLOGICAL EVOLUTION identification o f larvae o f the commercia l surfcla m (Spisula solidissimd). Molecular Marine Biology and Biotechnology, 7, 127-137 . CAMPBELL, D. C, HOEKSTRA, K. T. & CARTER, J. G. 1998. 18S ribosomal DN A and evolutionary relationship s within th e Bivalvia . In : JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART, J. W. (eds) Bivalves: an Eon o f Evolution - Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 75-85. CANAPA, A., MAROTA, I., ROLLO, F. & OLMO, E. 1999 . The small-subunit rRNA gene sequences of venerids and the phylogen y o f Bivalvia . Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 48, 463-468. CARTER, J . G . 1978 . Ecolog y an d evolutio n o f th e Gastrochaenacea, wit h notes on the evolution o f the endolithic habitat . Peabody Museum o f Natural History, Yale University, Bulletin, 41, 1-92 . 1990. Evolutionar y significanc e o f shel l microstructure i n th e Palaeotaxodonta , Pteriomorphia, an d Isofilibranchi a (Bivalvia : Mollusca). In: CARTER , J . G . (ed. ) Skeletal Biomineralization: Patterns, Processes, and Evolutionary Trends, Vol. 1 . Va n Nostran d Reinhold, New York, 135-296. , CAMPBELL , D . C . & CAMPBELL , M . R . 2000 . Cladistic perspective s o n earl y bivalv e evolution . This volume. COHEN, B . L. , GAWTHROP , A. B . & CAVALIER-SMITH, T. 1998. Molecula r phylogen y o f brachiopod s an d phoronids base d o n nuclear-encode d smal l subunit ribosomal RN A gen e sequences . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series 5,353,2039-2061. COPE, J. C. W. 1996 . Early Ordovicia n (Arenig ) bivalve s from th e Llangyno g Inlier , Sout h Wales . Palaeontology, 39, 979-1025. 1997. Th e earl y phylogen y o f th e clas s Bivalvia . Palaeontology, 40, 713-746. Cox, L . R., NEWELL, N . D., BOYD , D . W. ETAL. 1969 . In: MOORE, R . C . (ed. ) Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N, Mollusca 6, Bivalvia. Geological Societ y o f America , Boulder , CO , an d University o f Kansa s Press , Lawrence , KS , N1-N952. FELSENSTEIN, J . 1978 . Case s i n whic h parsimon y o r compatibility measure s wil l b e positivel y misleading. Systematic Zoology, 27, 401-^-10. FIELD, K . G. , OLSEN , G . J. , LANE , D . J . E T AL. 1988. Molecular phylogen y o f th e anima l kingdom . Science, 239, 748-753. FRISCHER, M . E., WILLIAMS, J . & KENCHINGTON , E. L . R . 1998. A molecular phylogen y o f some major groups of Pectinida e inferre d fro m 18 S rRN A gen e sequences. In : JOHNSTON , P . A. & HAGGART , J. W . (eds) Bivalves: a n Eo n o f Evolution Paleobiological Studies honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 213-221. GIRIBET, G . & CARRANZA , S. 1998 . What ca n 18 S rDNA do fo r bivalv e phylogeny ? Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 48, 256-258. & WHEELER , W . 1999 . O n gaps . Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 13, 132-143.
45
, CARRANZA, S., BAGUNA, J., RIUTORT, M. & RIBERA , C. 1996 . First molecular evidenc e for the existenc e of a Tardigrad a + Arthropod a clade . Molecular Biology an d Evolution, 13, 76-84. HALANYCH, K. M., BACHELLER, J. D., AGUINALDO, A. M., LIVA, S . M. , HILLIS , D . M . & LAKE , J . A . 1995 . Evidence fro m 18 S ribosoma l DN A tha t th e lophophorates ar e protostom e animals . Science, 267,1641-1643. HILLIS, D . M . & BULL , J . J . 1993 . An empirica l tes t o f bootstrapping as a method fo r assessing confidence in phylogeneti c analysis . Systematic Biology, 42 , 182-192. & DIXON , M. T . 1991. Ribosomal DNA : molecular evolution an d phylogeneti c inference . Th e Quarterly Review of Biology, 66, 411-453. HOEH, W . R. , STEWART , D . T. , SAAVEDRA , C. , SUTHERLAND, B . W . & ZOUROS , E . 1997 . Phylogenetic evidenc e fo r role-reversa l o f gender associated mitochondrial DN A in Mytilus (Bivalvia : Mytilidae). Molecular Biology an d Evolution, 14 , 959-967. , BLACK, M. B. , GUSTAFSON, R., BOGAN, A. E., LUTZ, R. A. & VRIJENHOEK, R. C. 1998. Testing alternative hypotheses o f Neotrigonia (Bivalvia : Trigonioida ) phylogenetic relationship s usin g cytochrom e c oxidase subuni t 1 DN A sequences . Malacologia, 40, 267-278. HOLLAND, P . W. H. , HACKER , A . M . & WILLIAMS , N . A . 1991. A molecula r analysis o f th e phylogeneti c affinities o f Saccoglossus cambrensis Brambel l & Cole (Hemichordata) . Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society o f London, Series B , 332 , 185-189. KENCHINGTON, E. L . R. , LANDRY , D. & BIRD , C . J . 1995. Comparison o f taxa of the mussel Mytilus (Bivalvia ) by analysis of the nuclear small-subuni t rRNA gene sequence. Canadian Journal o f Fisheries an d Aquatic Sciences, 52, 2613-2620. , RODDICK , D . L. , SINGH , R . K . & BIRD , C . J . 1994. Analysis o f small - subuni t rRN A gen e sequence s from si x familie s o f molluscs . Journal o f Marine Biotechnology, 1 , 215-217. , NAIDU , K . S. , RODDICK , D . L. , COOK , D . I . & ZOUROS, E . 1993 . Us e o f biochemica l geneti c markers t o discriminat e betwee n adducto r muscle s of th e se a scallo p (Placopecten magellanicus) an d the Icelan d scallo p (Chlamys islandicd). Canadian Journal o f Fisheries an d Aquatic Sciences, 50 , 1222-1228. LITTLEWOOD, D . T . J. , FORD , S . E . & FONG , D . 1991 . Complete nucleotid e sequenc e o f the smal l subuni t ribosomal RN A gen e o f th e America n oyste r Crassostrea virginica (Gmelin ) an d a compariso n with similar sequence s fro m othe r bivalve molluscs . Nucleic Acids Research, 19, 6048. MACKEY, L. Y , WINNEPENNINCKX , B., BACKELJAU , T., DE WACHTER, R. , EMSCHERMANN , P . & GAREY , J . R . 1996. 18 S rRN A suggest s tha t Entoproct a ar e protostomes, unrelate d t o Ectoprocta . Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 42, 552-559. MARUYAMA, T., ISHIKURA , M., YAMAZAKI, S. & KANAI , S . 1998. Molecula r phylogen y o f zooxanthellat e bivalves. Biological Bulletin, 195, 70-77.
46
D. C . CAMPBEL L
MORTON, B . 1996 . Th e evolutionar y histor y o f th e Bivalvia. In: TAYLOR , J . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation o f th e Mollusca. Oxfor d University Press , Oxford, 337-359. NEWELL, N . D . 1965 . Classificatio n o f th e Bivalvia . American Museum Novitates, 2206, 1-25 . & BOYD , D . W . 1975 . Parallel evolutio n i n earl y trigoniacean bivalves . Bulletin o f th e American Museum o f Natural History, 154, 53-162. POE, S . & SWOFFORD , D . L . 1999 . Taxo n samplin g revisited. Nature, 398, 299-300. RICE, E . L . 1990 . Nucleotid e sequenc e o f th e 18 S ribosomal RN A gene fro m the Atlanti c se a scallo p Placopecten magellanicus (Gmelin , 1791) . Nucleic Acids Research, 18,5551. , RODDICK, D . & SINGH, R. K. 1993. A comparison o f molluscan (Bivalvia ) phylogenie s base d o n palaeontological an d molecula r data . Molecular Marine Biology and Biotechnology, 2, 137-146. ROSENBERG, G. , TILLIER , S. , TILLIER , A. , KUNCIO , G . S. , HANLON, R . T. , MASSELOT , M . & WILLIAMS , C . J . 1997. Ribosomal RN A phylogeny of selected majo r clades i n th e Mollusca . Journal o f Molluscan Studies, 63, 301-309. RUNNEGAR, B. 1996 . Early evolution of the Mollusca: th e fossil record . In: TAYLOR , J . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation o f th e Mollusca. Oxfor d University Press, Oxford, 77-87. SAITOU, N. & NEI, M. 1987. The neighbor joining method: a new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 4, 406-425. SALAS, C . & GOFAS , S . 1998 . Description o f fou r ne w species of Neolepton Monterosato, 187 5 (Mollusca: Bivalvia: Neoleptonidae) , wit h comment s o n th e genus an d o n it s affinit y wit h th e Veneracea . Ophelia, 48, 35-70. SALVINI-PLAWEN, L . V . & STEINER , G . 1996 . Synapomorphies an d plesiomorphie s i n highe r classification o f Mollusca . In : TAYLOR , J . (ed. ) Origin and Evolutionary Radiation of the Mollusca. Oxford Universit y Press, Oxford , 29-51. SAUL, L. R. 1973. Evidence for the origin of the Mactridae (Bivalvia) i n th e Cretaceous . University o f California Publications i n Geological Sciences, 97, 1-59. SORENSON, M . D . 1999 . TreeRot, versio n 2a . Bosto n University, Boston, MA. STAROBOGATOV, YA . I . 1992 . Morphological basi s fo r phylogeny and classification of Bivalvia. Ruthenica, 2, 1-25. STEINER, G . 1999 . What ca n 18 S rDN A d o fo r bivalv e phylogeny? Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 48 , 258-261. & MULLER , M . 1996 . What ca n 18 S rDNA d o fo r bivalve phylogeny ? Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 43, 58-70.
SWOFFORD, D . L . 1993 . PAUP 3.1.1. Smithsonia n Institution, Washington, DC. 1999. PAUP*. Sinaue r Associates, Sunderland, MA . & BEGLE , D . P . 1993 . User's Manual fo r PAUP: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony. Laboratory o f Molecular Systematics , Smithsonia n Institution, Washington, DC . , OLSEN , G . J., WADDELL, P. J. & HILLIS, D. M. 1996. Phylogenetic inference . In: HILLIS , D. M. & MABLE , B. K . (eds ) Molecular Systematics, 2n d Edition . Sinauer Associates, Sunderland , MA , 407-514. WALLER, T . R . 1978 . Morphology, morphocline s an d a new classificatio n o f th e Pteriomorphi a (Mollusca : Bivalvia). Philosophical Transactions o f th e Royal Society o f London, Series B, 284, 345-365. 1998. Origin o f the molluscan Clas s Bivalvi a an d a phylogeny o f majo r groups . In : JOHNSTON , P . A. & HAGGART, J. W. (eds) Bivalves: a n Eon o f Evolution - Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 1-45. WHITING, M . F. , CARPENTER , J . C. , WHEELER , Q . D . & WHEELER, W . C . 1997 . The Strepsidur a problem : phylogeny o f th e holometabolou s insec t order s inferred fro m 18 S an d 28 S ribosoma l DN A sequences an d morphology. Systematic Biology 46 , 1-68. WlNNEPENNINCKX, B . & BACKELJAU , T. 1996 . 18 S rRN A
alignments derive d fro m differen t secondar y structure model s ca n produc e alternativ e phylogenies. Journal o f Zoological Systematics an d Evolutionary Research, 34, 135-143 . ,& D E WACHTER , R . 1993 . Complete smal l ribosomal subuni t RN A sequenc e o f th e chito n Acanthopleura japonica (Lischke , 1873 ) (Mollusca, Polyplacophora). Nucleic Acids Research, 21 , 1670. ,& 1994 . Small ribosomal subuni t RNA and the phylogeny of the Mollusca. Nautilus, Supp l 2,108,98-110. ,& 1996 . Investigatio n o f mollusca n phylogeny o n th e basi s o f 18 S rRN A sequences . Molecular Biology and Evolution, 13 , 1306-1317. , REID , D . G . & BACKELJAU , T. 19980 . Performance of 18 S rRNA i n littorini d phylogen y (Gastropoda : Caenogastropoda). Journal o f Molecular Evolution, 47, 586-596. , BACKELJAU, T., VAN DE PEER, Y . & D E WACHTER, R . 1992. Structure of the small ribosomal subuni t RNA sequence o f th e pulmonat e snai l Limicolaria kambeul, and phylogenetic analysis of the Mollusca. FEBS Letters, 309, 123-126. , STEINER , G. , BACKELJAU , T . & D E WACHTER , R . 1998&. Detail s o f gastropo d phylogen y inferre d from 18 S rRN A sequences . Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 9, 55-63.
Cladistic perspectives on early bivalve evolution 1
J. G. CARTER1, D. C. CAMPBELL1 & M. R. CAMPBELL 2 Department of Geological Sciences, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill NC 27599-3315, USA (e-mail: clams@ emailunc.edu) 2 Department of Geological Sciences, Indiana University, 1005 East Tenth Street, Bloomington IN 47401, USA Abstract: Parsimony analysi s suggest s derivatio n o f the Bivalvia fro m monoplacophorans rathe r than fro m rostroconchs , an d additionall y indicate s tha t a phylogeneti c classificatio n o f th e Bivalvia ca n b e achieve d b y erectin g th e superorde r Nuculaniformi i nov. an d th e orde r Nuculanoida nov. fo r the superfamil y Nuculanoidea ; relegatin g al l other palaeotaxodonts to the superorder Nuculiformii ; restrictin g th e orde r Nuculoid a t o th e familie s Nuculida e an d Pristiglomidae; expanding th e order Solemyoid a t o include ctenodontid gener a a s basal plesions; restricting the superorde r Heteroconchia to palaeoheterodonts and heterodonts, exclusive of the Modiomorphidae; relegatin g th e ne w famil y Evyanidae , th e Colpomyidae , Matheriida e an d Modiolodontidae to near-basal plesion status withi n th e superorder Pteriomorphia ; restricting the Mytiloida t o th e superfamil y Mytiloidea , inclusiv e o f modiolopsi d gener a a s basa l plesions ; placing Ortonella a s a basal plesion within th e Cyrtodontoida; expanding the order Pectinoida to include th e Myodakryotida e an d th e suborder s Limin a an d Pectinina ; an d expandin g th e superfamily Arcoide a t o includ e th e freji d gener a an d Catamarcaia a s basal plesions , an d th e family Glyptarcidae . Modiomorphid anomalodesmatans appea r t o be more closely related to the Pteriomorphia tha n t o th e Heteroconchia , an d Evyana lie s clos e t o th e commo n ancestr y o f modiomorphids an d colpomyi d pteriomorphians . Arcoid s ma y hav e evolve d fro m left-righ t symmetrical bu t otherwis e rhombopteriid-lik e ancestors , rathe r tha n fro m actinodontoid s o r directly fro m cyrtodontids . The new family Eodonida e is proposed to distinguish the nacreou s genus Eodon fro m the non-nacreous Astartida e within th e superfamily Crassatelloidea .
Bivalves appea r t o hav e evolve d fro m laterall y compressed, stenothecid monoplacophorans similar to earl y Cambria n Anabarella Vostokov a an d Watsonella Graba u (Runnega r & Pojet a 1974) . These two genera are morphologically intermediate between monoplacophorans and both rostroconchs and bivalves . The y diffe r fro m rostroconch s in lacking a tru e pegm a (Runnega r 1996 ) an d the y differ fro m bivalve s in lacking a microstructurally differentiated ligament , althoug h the y d o hav e a ligament precursor (Kouchinsky 1999). Watsonella also resembles bivalves in having a divided larva l shell (Dzi k 1994) . Anabarella, Watsonella an d the Cambrian bivalv e Pojetaia Jel l hav e a columna r prismatic oute r shel l laye r wit h the apice s o f th e prisms mutuall y isolated b y thick , interprismati c organic matrices, together with an inner shell layer consisting o f imbricate d lamina e wit h fibrou s second orde r structura l units . Thes e fibre s constitute matte d an d lamello-fibrilla r structure s ['type-2 nacre' o f Mutvei (1970)] i n stenothecids , but a wide-tablet nacreous structure in Pojetaia an d Fordilla Barrand e (Runnega r & Bentle y 1983 ;
Carter 1990 ; Runnegar & Pojeta 1992; Kouchinsky 1999). Moder n bivalv e nacr e consist s o f smaller , more horizonta l tablets , whic h onl y rarel y sho w traces o f secon d orde r fibre s (Mutve i 1983) . Th e evolutionary transitio n fro m stenotheci d mono placophoran t o tru e bivalv e require d microstructural differentiatio n o f th e ligament , th e evolution o f a t leas t on e adducto r muscle , los s o f permanent shel l gape s an d rearrangemen t o f imbricated, matted/lamello-fibrilla r lamina e int o imbricated nacreou s lamina e a s i n fordilloids , o r imbricated calciti c foliate d lamina e a s i n tuarangioids. The earl y differentiatio n o f th e bivalv e subclasses an d order s i s les s wel l understoo d an d remains controversial. When Fordilla was the only known Cambria n bivalve , Pojet a & Runnega r (1974) suggeste d that i t gave rise t o cycloconchi d palaeoheterodonts, an d palaeoheterodont s the n gave rise to the Pteriomorphia, Isofilibranchi a and Palaeotaxodonta. Pojet a (1975 ) the n offere d a n alternative scenari o i n whic h Fordilla gav e ris e directly t o th e subclas s Isofilibranchia . Babi n
From: HARPER, E. M., TAYLOR, J. D. & CRAME, J. A. (eds) Th e Evolutionary Biology of th e Bivalvia. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 177 , 47-79 . 1-86239-076-2/007 $ 15.00 © The Geological Society of London 2000.
48
J. G . CARTE R E T AL.
(1977) suggested that Fordilla gave rise to Babinka Barrande an d Coxiconcha Babin, an d Coxiconcha then gav e rise t o the Isofilibranchia. Pojeta (1978 ) agreed wit h Babi n (1977 ) tha t Babinka evolve d directly fro m a Fordilla-like ancestor , bu t h e favoured a n independen t ancesto r fo r th e Isofilibranchia. Pojet a (1985 ) presente d a phylogeny i n whic h Pojetaia an d Fordilla ar e ancestral t o palaeotaxodont s an d isofilibranchs , respectively. Runnega r & Bentle y (1983 ) allie d Fordilla wit h Modiolodon Ulrich , an d suggeste d that Fordilla evolve d int o mytiloids , orthonotid s and pholadomyoids, wherea s Pojetaia evolved into praenuculid palaeotaxodont s and , throug h them , actinodonts an d non-mytiloi d pteriomorphians . Runnegar & Pojet a (1992 ) an d Runnega r (1996 ) offered stil l anothe r possibility , tha t Fordilla an d Pojetaia wer e stem-grou p bivalve s predatin g th e last common ancesto r o f th e extan t Bivalvia . Runnegar & Pojet a (1992 ) note d tha t i t i s unlikely tha t th e distinctiv e shel l microstructur e of Pojetaia an d Fordilla wa s los t independentl y in line s leadin g t o palaeotaxodont s an d auto lamellibranchs. MacKinnon (1982 , 1985 ) an d Berg-Madse n (1987) suggeste d tha t th e Pteriomorphi a evolve d directly fro m Cambria n Tuarangia MacKinnon . Runnegar & Bentle y (1983) , Runnega r (1983 , 1985) an d Runnegar & Pojeta (1992) believed tha t Tuarangia i s a laterall y compresse d mono placophoran closel y relate d t o Pseudomyona, noting that these two genera have similarly foliated shells. Accordin g t o thei r interpretation , Pseudomyona has a univalved protoconch an d an adductor muscle positioned differently tha n in early bivalves [see als o Runnega r & Jell (1976)] . Tuarangia and Pseudomyona diffe r fro m undoubted Cambrian and Ordovician bivalve s i n thei r D-shaped , largel y calcitic shells . Specimen s o f Middl e Cambria n Tuarangia gravgaerdensis tenuiumbonata, described by Hinz-Schallreuter (1995), show short, anterior an d posterio r ligamen t insertio n areas ; differentiated lef t an d righ t beaks ; an d possibl e anterior an d posterio r adducto r muscl e scars , suggesting close r affinit y wit h th e Bivalvi a tha n with Pseudomyona. Starobogatov (1992) utilized evolutionary trends in shel l an d sof t anatomica l features , plu s larva l structure an d development , t o divid e th e Bivalvi a (including th e Rostroconchia ) int o thre e super orders, 1 5 orders, 3 0 suborders, 1 5 infraorders an d 119 superfamilies . Starobogato v (1992 , fig . 4 ) indicated tha t th e superfamil y Phaseoloide a gav e rise t o th e superorder s Nuculiformi i Dall , Mytiliformii Ferussa c an d Conocardiformi i Neumayr. Phaseolus Monterosat o i s a Recent , resiliated nuculoid , bu t Starobogato v nevertheles s suggested tha t its pattern o f few, radially disposed ,
lamelliform hing e teet h i s a good ancestra l mode l for nuculoid , nucinelloid an d lyrodesmoi d hinges . The lyrodesmoi d hing e woul d the n hav e bee n transformed int o schizodont , actinodont , an d othe r palaeoheterodont an d heterodon t dentitions . Starobogatov include d in th e Conocardiformi i not only fordilloid s an d variou s anatomicall y derive d anomalodesmatans, but als o rostroconchs, some of which h e claime d ha d a ligamen t an d adductors . Within th e Mytiliformii , th e suborde r Lyro desmatoidei wa s identifie d a s th e ancestra l stoc k for th e order Unioniformes (lyrodesmatids, modiomorphids, gastrochaenids , trigonioids , unionoid s and variou s actinodonts) , th e orde r Phola domyiformes (Pholadomyoidea , Clavagelloidea , Pandoroidea, Thracioide a an d ancien t phola domyoid groups ) an d th e orde r Mytiliforme s (mytiloids, pterioids , cyrtodontoids , arcoid s an d early pectinoids) . Starobogato v separate d th e Ctenodontidae fro m th e Solemyida e a t the ordina l level. H e als o separate d advance d pectinoid s (including limoids ) fro m othe r pteriomorphians , implying that advanced pectinoids are more closely related t o unionoid s an d lucinoids . Starobogato v divided th e remainin g pteriomorphian s int o a n ancestral pterioid-early pectinoid clad e and a more derived cyrtodontoid-arcoid-ostreoid-mytiloi d clade, wit h arcoid s evolvin g fro m cyrtodontoid s through th e additio n o f media l hing e teeth , an d mytiloids, ostreoids an d gryphaeoids evolvin g fro m arcoids throug h replacement o f normal hing e teet h with shell marginal denticles. Waller (1998) maintaine d tha t bivalves ar e more closely relate d t o rostroconchs tha n to stenotheci d monoplacophorans, b y virtu e o f sharin g a strong pallial line and a similar lateral profile, i.e. with the ventral, aperture d par t o f th e shel l exceedin g th e dorsal par t i n height . However , th e Lowe r Cambrian stenotheci d Watsonella crossbyi Grabau, 1900, ha s a profile simila r t o bivalve s an d on e of the oldest rostroconchs, Middle Cambria n Ribeiria junior Runnegar , 1996 , ha s a typica l mono placophoran profile . Walle r (1998 ) regarde d fordilloids as stem-group bivalves evolving from an unnamed proto-bivalv e prio r t o mineralizatio n o f the ligament. He summarized features supporting a basal dichotom y betwee n th e Protobranchi a an d Autobranchia, al l o f whic h ar e non-palaeonto logical excep t fo r th e autobranc h patter n o f 'umburrid-like denta l ontogen y wit h elongate , shallowly incline d primar y teet h an d socket s characterizing early growth stages' [citin g Johnston (1991, p. 315)]. Waller (1998) als o summarized the features, non-palaeontologica l excep t fo r pre dominance o f nacreou s shel l microstructure , indicating a basa l spli t i n th e Protobranchi a between th e Nuculanoide a an d th e Nuculoidea Solemyoidea, th e latte r superfamil y expande d t o
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N
include th e Ctenodontida e an d Nucinellidae . Within th e Autobranchia , a basa l dichotom y allegedly separate s th e Pteriomorphi a fro m th e Heteroconchia (th e latte r inclusiv e o f th e Palaeo heterodonta, Heterodont a an d Anomalodesmata) . The Pteriomorphia were said to be characterized by four sof t anatomica l feature s plu s discontinuou s fibrous ligamen t ontogen y an d anisomyaria n adductors. Th e Heteroconchi a wer e characterize d as having ligament nymphs and a core homology of 3a/2/3b hinge dentition. Salvini-Plawen & Steine r (1996 ) performe d a phylogenetic analysi s of the Bivalvia based largel y on sof t anatomy . The y utilize d 4 2 character s generalized fo r thre e families , thre e superfamilies, three order s an d thre e subclasses . Unfortunately , they incorrectly assumed that amphidetic ligaments and combine d external/interna l ligamen t ar e les s derived than opisthodetic and external ligaments in their polarizations , an d the y incorrectl y indicate d the absenc e o f a n abdomina l sens e orga n i n th e Unionoida (see Herbers 1914) . They concluded that the Palaeotaxodont a i s monophyletic , wit h th e Solemyidae close r t o th e Nucinellida e tha n t o th e Nuculoidea o r Nuculanoidea ; tha t th e Trigoniida e are closel y relate d t o th e Pteriomorphia ; an d tha t the Unionoida , Veneroida , Lucinoide a an d Myoida-Anomalodesmata-Septlbranchia ar e united i n a tetratomy . Ou r analysi s o f thei r data , with correcte d characte r state s an d polarizations , produced 1 8 equall y parsimoniou s trees . Al l 1 8 trees sho w th e Palaeotaxodont a basa l t o th e Autolamellibranchiata, bu t th e Nucinellidae , Solemyidae, Nuculoide a an d Nuculanoide a comprise a paraphyleti c assemblage . Th e Septibranchia ar e show n a s basa l autolamelli branchs; abov e th e Septibranchi a hal f o f th e tree s unite th e Unionoid a wit h a Pteriomorphia Trigoniidae clad e an d th e othe r hal f unit e th e Unionoida wit h the remainin g autolamellibranchs . In th e latte r subclade , th e Veneroida , Lucinoide a and Myoida-Anomalodesmat a differentiat e i n that sequence. Cope (19960 , b, 1997 ) indicate d tha t Fordilla and Pojetaia ar e palaeotaxodonts , an d h e an d Ratter & Cop e (1998 ) favoure d ultimat e palaeotaxodont ancestr y for al l bivalve subclasses . However, Cop e (I996b) acknowledge d tha t th e extremely smal l shell sizes of Pojetaia an d Fordilla (2-4 mm) mak e i t difficul t t o distinguis h between palaeotaxodont an d actinodon t hinges . Cop e (1996/7) followe d Newel l (1969 , p . N393 ) an d Bailey (1983 ) i n unitin g modiomorphoidean s an d actinodontians i n th e Palaeoheterodonta , althoug h he distinguishe d betwee n th e order s Modio morphoida (Modiolopsida e an d Colpomyidae ) and Actinodontoid a (Actinodontoide a an d Glyptarcoidea). Cop e (I996b) assume d tha t
49
modiomorphoids evolve d fro m actinodontoid s through los s o f hinge teet h bu t h e di d no t addres s the distinctio n betwee n th e familie s Modio morphidae an d Modiolopsidae . Cope (1996a , 1997) suggested that the Anomalodesmata evolve d from weakl y dentat e 'modiomorphoids ' suc h a s colpomyids by reducing the hinge dentition. Ratter & Cop e (1998 ) indicate d tha t frejid s an d parallel odontids share common ancestry in a descendant of Catamarcaia, an d tha t Catamarcaia an d th e Cyrtodontoidea (plu s th e ambonychioidea n an d pterioidean descendant s o f cyrtodontids ) shar e common ancestr y i n a hypothetica l descendan t o f Glyptarca Hicks . Glyptarca presumabl y evolve d from th e nuculoi d Cardiolaria Munier-Chalma s (Cope 19960 ; Ratter & Cope 1998) . Cop e (19960 , b, 1997 ) an d Ratter & Cope (1998 ) subdivide d the Pteriomorphia int o th e subclas s Pteriomorphi a sensu stricto [order s Cyrtodontoida , Limoida , Pterioida (Ambonychioide a an d Pterioidea) , Mytiloida, Ostreoid a an d Praecardioida ] an d Neotaxodonta (Catamarcaia, Arcoide a an d Limopsoidea). Cop e (1996a , p . 366 ) believe d tha t the Limoida , Pterioide a an d Ambonychioide a evolved independentl y fro m th e Cyrtodontidae . I n 1997, h e indicate d tha t th e Neotaxodont a i s characterized b y a uniqu e combinatio n o f duplivincular ligaments , a n ancestra l crossed lamellar o r complex crossed lamellar structure , and a tendenc y t o develo p taxodon t dentition . According t o Cope (1997) , neotaxodont s gav e rise to the Heterodonta, wherea s palaeotaxodont s gav e rise t o th e Palaeoheterodonta . Cope' s (1997 ) suggested porcelaneou s neotaxodon t ancestr y fo r the Heterodont a i s incompatibl e wit h th e observation b y Carte r & Lutz (1990 , pi . 104 ) tha t the Devonia n crassatelloidea n Eodon tenuistriata (Hall, 1870 ) is nacreous. Geyer & Stren g (1998 ) regarde d thei r ne w Middle Cambria n taxo n Arhouriella opheodontoides a s a bivalv e o f undetermine d subclas s and order. However , the holotype ha s overhangin g hinge teet h undercu t by th e hing e plate ; a singl e muscle sca r far from th e shell margins; a hinge bar underlying a putativ e anterior , submargina l ligament insertio n area ; an d a lancet-shaped hing e flange (putativ e posterodorsal ligamen t attachment area), al l o f whic h ar e reminiscen t o f ostracode s (see Scot t 1961) . Th e paratype ha s a more typica l bivalve hing e (possibl y edentulous , reportedl y abraded), bu t muc h mor e elevate d beak s an d a possible ligamen t nymph . I t i s no t obviousl y th e same taxon as their holotype. Other hypothese s fo r earl y bivalv e phylogen y have focuse d o n whethe r nuculoid s gav e ris e t o actinodontoids o r vic e vers a (Dechaseau x 1952 ; Babin 1966 ; Newel l 1969 ; Desparme t e t al. 1971 ; Pojeta 1971 , 1978 ; Morris & Fortey 1976 ; Scarlat o
50
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
& Starobogatov 1978 ; Morris 1979 , 1980 ; Babin & Le Penne c 1982 ; Liljedahl 19840 , b\ Waller 1990 , 1998; Johnsto n 1991 , 1995 ; Sanche z 1995 ; Cop e 1996a, b, 1997 ; Johnsto n & Zhang 1998 ; Ratte r & Cope 1998) . Nuculoi d ancestr y i s almos t universally favoure d becaus e nuculoid s ar e common earl y Ordovicia n fossils , the y retai n a plesiomorphic protobranc h ctenidiu m an d the y show certai n earl y ontogeneti c feature s simila r t o other mollusca n classes . However , actinodontoi d ancestry fo r th e Nuculoid a wa s suggeste d b y Morris & Fortey (1976 ) an d Morris (1980 ) o n th e basis o f the existenc e o f early Palaeozoi c bivalve s with transitiona l taxodont/actinodon t hinges . Sanchez & Babin (1998) offered a third alternative, that palaeotaxodont s an d palaeoheterodont s originated independently. The present study is a phylogenetic analysis of a wide diversit y o f Palaeozoi c bivalves , base d o n characters o f shel l morphology , hing e dentition , shell musculature , shell mineralogy , and shel l an d ligament microstructure , togethe r wit h fou r sof t anatomical features inferre d from Recen t taxa. The purpose o f thi s stud y i s t o evaluat e whethe r bivalves ar e mor e closel y relate d t o monoplaco phorans o r rostroconch s an d t o establis h a preliminary phylogeneti c classificatio n fo r thi s class.
Analysed taxa The phylogeneti c analysi s include s 6 2 Palaeozoi c bivalve specie s wit h one specie s Lyrodesma majus (Ulrich 1894) , represente d b y separat e entrie s fo r adult an d juvenil e stage s (Appendi x 1) . W e als o analysed: th e Lowe r Cambrian , laterall y com pressed, stenothecid monoplacophorans Anabarella plana Vostokov a 196 2 an d Watsonella crossbyi Grabau 1900 ; th e problematic , Middl e Cambrian monoplacophoran Pseudomyona queenslandica (Runnegar & Jell 1976) ; and the Middle Cambrian, ribeirioid rostroconc h Ribeiria junior Runnegar , 1996. Shell muscle scars for the latter species were inferred fro m th e Lowe r Ordovicia n ribeirioi d rostroconch Ribeiria lucan (Walcott 1924). The two stenothecids serve d a s th e outgrou p fo r th e analysis. Bot h species hav e been implicate d i n the origin o f both th e Bivalvi a an d th e Rostroconchi a (see Pojet a & Runnega r 198 5 an d ref s cite d therein). I n selectin g bivalve s fo r study , firs t preference wa s given t o the best known species o f each genus ; preference wa s otherwise given t o the type species . Al l o f th e studie d gener a hav e Palaeozoic origins , an d al l bu t Acharax an d Modiolus ar e extinct. The represented familie s are also extinct, except for the Nuculidae, Acharacidae, Malletiidae, Limida e and Parallelodontidae .
Character definitions The characters define d for this study (Appendix 2) are al l palaeontologica l i n natur e excep t fo r inferences o f protobranc h o r non-protobranc h ctenidia, an d the presence o r absence o f abdominal, adoral ('cephalic' ) an d anterio r mantl e sens e organs. I t i s assume d tha t protobranc h ctenidi a characterized al l Cambria n monoplacophorans , rostroconchs, fordilloid s an d undoubte d palaeo taxodonts, wherea s non-protobranc h ctenidi a wer e present i n al l undoubte d pteriomorphians , palaeo heterodonts, heterodont s an d pholadomyoids . Th e ctenidial grad e o f Cambria n Pseudomyona, Cambrian Tuarangia an d al l bivalve s wit h inter mediate palaeotaxodont/actinodon t hinge s (e.g . tironuculids an d cardiolariids ) wer e designate d a s uncertain. It was assume d that an abdominal sense organ wa s presen t i n al l undoubte d Trigonioida , Unionoida an d Pteriomorphia , an d absen t i n al l Monoplacophora, Rostroconchia , Tuarangioida , Fordilloida, Tironuculidae, Nuculoida, Solemyoida and Heterodonta . Lucinoids , actinodontoid s (Cyloconchidae, Redoniidae , Nyassidae , an d Lyrodesmatidae), cardiolariids , modiomorphids , Thoralia Morris , Babinka an d Coxiconcha, wer e scored a s uncertai n fo r thi s feature . Th e reade r i s referred t o Herber s (1914) , Yong e (1977) , Haszprunar (1983 , 1985 ) an d Walle r (1998 ) fo r discussion o f this feature. An adora l sens e orga n is present i n moder n nuculid s an d solemyids , bu t is apparentl y absen t i n th e Nuculanoidea , Nucinellidae, Pristiglomida e an d i n autolamelli branch bivalve s (Waller 1998 , p . 16 , and refs cited therein). It was assumed that an adoral sens e organ is present in nuculids and praenuculids as well as in the solemyi d Acharax Dall , bu t thi s featur e wa s indicated a s uncertai n fo r th e Ctenodontidae , Tironuculidae and Cardiolariidae. The adoral sense organ was scored as absent in the Monoplacophora, Rostroconchia, Tuarangioida , Fordilloid a an d Autolamellibranchiata. A n anterio r mantl e sens e organ i s apparentl y restricted t o th e Nuculanoidea (Yonge 1939 ; Allen 1985 ; Allen & Hanna h 1986 ; Waller 1998) . Thi s featur e i s indicate d a s presen t in th e Nuculanoide a bu t uncertai n i n th e Tironuculidae, Cardiolariidae an d Ctenodontidae. I t was score d a s absen t i n th e Monoplacophora , Rostroconchia an d in all other analysed bivalves . A fe w o f th e character s i n thi s stud y ar e continuous i n nature , e.g . hing e arch , shel l elongation, beak positio n an d beak direction . Mos t of these continuous characters, however, are known to sho w quasi-discontinuou s distributions . Al l unknown character state s wer e coded a s uncertain, and al l intermediat e characte r state s an d intraspecific-variable characters as polymorphisms. Polymorphisms comprise d < 2% o f th e obser -
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N
vations (se e separat e listing s i n Appendi x 3) . Polymorphic characters , whil e no t idea l fo r phylogenetic analyses , ca n nevertheles s increas e phylogenetic accurac y (Wien s & Servedi o 1997) . Although man y o f th e character s hav e missin g observations, i t i s importan t t o not e tha t missin g data pe r s e d o no t distor t phylogeneti c analyses . Rather, the y merel y mimi c th e effect s o f limite d taxon samplin g (Wien s 1998) . Also , highl y significant character s wit h considerabl e missin g data ma y stil l increas e phylogeneti c accurac y (Smith 1994 ; Wiens 1998) . Current terminolog y o f shel l morpholog y an d shell musculatur e follows the definitions in Cox et al (1969-1971) . Us e o f the ter m 'hinge ' implie s the presenc e o f a divide d larva l shell , wherea s 'pseudohinge' implie s a n undivide d larva l shel l (e.g. i n Pseudomyond). N o distinctio n i s mad e between a 'primary ' pallia l line , whic h maintains contact wit h th e posterio r adductor , an d a 'secondary' pallia l lin e (Yong e 1953) , whic h does not . Thes e tw o mode s o f pallia l attachment are intergradational , and th e relationshi p between the pallia l lin e an d th e posterio r adducto r muscle sca r i s deal t wit h in othe r characters . Th e shell microstructur e terminolog y follow s Carte r (1990). Ligament terminolog y i s presentl y modifie d from Walle r (1990 ) an d Carte r (1990 ) t o defin e a number o f ne w varieties . W e distinguish betwee n true ligament s an d pseudoligaments . Ligament s and pseudoligament s ar e bot h morphologicall y specialized t o enhanc e dorsal flexin g o f th e shell , but onl y tru e ligament s diffe r microstructurall y from th e adjacen t shell . Fo r example , the foliated structure comprise s the pseudoligamen t and the adjacent shel l i n Pseudomyona (se e Runnega r 1983, fig . 6B) , wherea s lamella r an d fibrou s structures compris e th e ligament , an d nacreous , porcelaneous and/o r foliate d structure s compris e the adjacen t shel l i n pteriomorphians . Th e terminology o f ancestrall y dorsa l ligament s i s summarized i n Tabl e 1 . Nuculoid an d solemyoi d internal resili a ar e excluded fro m Tabl e 1 because they ar e no t strictl y homologou s wit h dorsa l ligaments. Despit e th e physica l continuit y o f th e dorsal an d resilia l ligament s i n moder n nuculids (Waller 1990), these two ligaments have ancestrally separate fibrou s layers . Thi s i s show n b y th e Triassic malletii d Palaeoneilo elliptica (Goldfus s 1838), which has a well-mineralized dorsal, simple ligament separat e fro m it s laterall y mineralized , internal resilium. It i s tentativel y assume d tha t discontinuou s fibrous ligamen t ontogen y characterize s al l members of the Modiolopsoidea a s defined by Fang & Morri s (1997 ) (i.e . familie s Modiolopsidae , Colpomyidae and Modiolodontidae), as well as all
51
mytilids an d othe r pteriomorphians , includin g frejids an d glyptarcid s [se e discussion s b y Walle r (1990, 1998) , an d Carter & Seed (1998)] . The term 'latera l tooth', fro m th e definitio n b y Cox et al (1969 , p. N106), is restricted t o exclud e pseudolateral teeth . A latera l tooth , a s presentl y defined, i s partly or entirely located som e distance from th e beak and its proximal end does not extend to the beak. A pseudolateral toot h is partly located some distanc e fro m th e bea k bu t extend s al l th e way to the beak. Rather than utilizing inferences of dental homologie s fo r specifi c subumbonal / cardinal teeth , th e pivota l (majo r o r central ) sub umbonal/cardinal toot h has been identified, an d the shape an d orientatio n o f thi s toot h an d th e subumbonal/cardinal teet h immediatel y anterio r and posterior t o it have been described. I n counting the numbe r o f anterior , subumbonal/cardina l an d posterior teeth, only socketed teeth (i.e. as opposed to unsocketed crura) are included. Some cyrtodontid s presen t a proble m fo r classifying teeth as subumbonal or anterior because what i s probabl y a n homologou s cluste r o f relatively anterio r teet h ma y b e positione d subumbonally o r anterio r t o th e umbones . In suc h cases the more posterior an d posteriorly dippin g of any transitiona l subumbonal/anterio r teeth i n cyrtodontids hav e bee n arbitraril y counte d a s subumbonal, and the more horizontal and anteriorly dipping o f these teeth a s anterior. Unfortunately , it is possibl e tha t som e o f thes e 'subumbonal ' teet h are homologou s wit h anterio r frejid , glyptarci d and/or parallelodontid teeth. Edentulous hinge s als o presen t a proble m fo r phylogenetic studie s because edentul y has clearl y evolved severa l times in this class. Many bivalves have apparentl y los t ancestra l dentitio n i n connection wit h lif e habit s and/o r biomechanica l adaptations reducing the need to precisely guide the valves. Therefore , fiv e categorie s o f subumbona l edentuly are recognized o n the basis of association s with particula r lif e habit s o r biomechanica l adaptations: (1 ) wide , thick , pleated , periostraca l margins (e.g. solemyids); (2) wide, flexible, calciti c simple prismati c margin s (e.g . pterineids) ; (3 ) thick, gasket-lik e periostraca l margin s (e.g . som e mytilids); (4) deep burrowing life habit s with very thin, commonl y spiculos e periostraca l extension s of th e shel l margin s (man y pholadomyoids) ; (5 ) subumbonal edentul y apparentl y resultin g fro m a posterior shift i n the umbones rather than from los s of teeth (e.g. possibly falcatodontids) . 'Taxodonty' (Co x 1969 , p . N108 ) i s her e subdivided int o palaeotaxodonty , pretaxodonty , pseudotaxodonty an d heterotaxodonty . Palaeo taxodonty refer s to five o r more laterall y adjacent , regularly shape d taxodon t teet h tha t ar e neithe r strongly ventrall y divergen t no r ventrall y bifid .
52 J
. G . CARTE R ETAL.
Table 1 . Dorsal ligaments an d their evolutionary derivatives 1. Simple narrow (SN): simpl e ligament with narrow insertion area. (a) SNweak : S N ligamen t wit h plesiomorphically weakl y o r non-mineralize d media l portio n o f inne r sublayer, e.g. Pojetaia Jell . (b) SNstrong : S N ligamen t wit h strongl y mineralize d latera l an d media l portion s o f inne r sublayer , e.g . Cycloconcha milled (Meek , 1871) ; als o th e dorsa l ligamen t bu t no t th e resiliu m i n Nuculoidea pinguis (Lindstrom, 1880) . 2. Simple wide (SW) : simpl e ligamen t wit h wide insertion area , e.g . Paracyclas Hall . 3. Parivincula r narrow (PN): parivincula r ligamen t wit h short , narro w nymp h parallelling dorsa l shell margin . (a) PNweak: PN ligament wit h nymphs not strongly projecting abov e dorsa l shel l margin, e.g . Astarte Sowerby . (b) PNstrong: PN ligament wit h nymphs strongly projecting above dorsa l shel l margin , e.g. Lyrodesma Conrad . (c) PNincip: P N ligament wit h incipient nymp h flanked by very weakly differentiate d lamella r ligament groove , e.g. Silurozodus Liljedahl . 4. Parivincular wid e (PW) : shor t t o intermediat e length , barrel-shape d parivincula r ligamen t wit h wide , strongl y dorsally projecting nymph in which anterior nymph margin rises abruptl y above the hinge line. (a) PWext: externa l PW ligament, e.g . Acharax Dall . (b) PWint: internal PW ligament, partially covered b y the prismatic outer shel l layer , e.g. Solemya Lamarck . 5. Parivincular rampe d (PR) : mediu m t o long , barrel-shape d parivincula r ligamen t wit h wide , strongl y dorsall y projecting nymp h in which nymph margin increases graduall y in height toward the posterior . (a) PRthick: P R ligament attache d t o thick, flat t o concave hinge plate, wit h dorsal margi n o f nymph at or below dorsal edg e of dorsal shel l margin . (i) PRthick-shallow : wit h nymp h a t o r shallowl y submerge d belo w dorsa l edg e o f dorsa l shel l margin , e.g . Modiomorpha Hal l & Whitfield . (ii) PRthick-deep: wit h nymph deeply submerge d belo w dorsa l edge of dorsal shel l margin, e.g . Lahillia larseni Sharman & Newton, 1897 . (b) PRthin : P R ligamen t attache d t o thi n hing e plate , wit h dorsoposterio r nymp h margi n projectin g abov e th e dorsal edg e o f dorsa l shel l margi n ('thin ' refer s t o th e hing e plat e thickness , no t necessaril y t o th e ligamen t thickness). (i) PRthin-weak : relatively weak PRthin ligament, e.g. Edmondia gibbosa M'Coy , 1844 . (ii) PRthin-strong: relatively stron g PRthi n ligament , e.g. Goniophora onyx Liljedahl , 1984 . 6. Parivincular submerge d (PS) : relativel y short , parivincula r ligamen t wit h nymp h dippin g distinctl y posteroventrally relative to dorsal edge o f dorsal shel l margin. (a) PSshallow: PS ligament with fibrous layer shallowly submerged below dorsal edge of dorsal shell margin, e.g. Eodon tenuistriata (Hall , 1870) . (b) PSdeep : P S ligament wit h fibrous laye r deeply submerge d below the dorsal edg e o f dorsal shel l margin, e.g. Montanaria Spriestersbach . 7. Duplivincular horizonta l (DH) : duplivincular ligament with adult insertion grooves nearly parallel t o growth lines on hinge; earl y growt h stag e ma y or may not have inclined insertio n grooves . (a) DHopis: opisthodeti c D H ligamen t wit h ventralmost insertion groove extendin g furthe r posteriorl y tha n the dorsalmost insertio n groove. (i) DHopi s 1: DHopis ligamen t wit h only on e adul t fibrou s laye r bu t wit h another ontogeneticall y attenuated , early post-larval, fibrou s layer , e.g. Mytilus Linne . (ii) DHopis2: DHopis ligament with two or more adult fibrous layers at least in some individuals of the species . In som e DHopis 2 ligament s th e insertio n are a i s ver y narro w an d ther e ar e few , widel y separate d ligamen t grooves (e.g . Aleodonta burei Liljedahl, 1994) . I n others, ther e ar e more numerou s ligament groove s an d the early-formed fibrou s layer s ma y b e largel y restricted t o th e anterio r ligamen t insertio n are a (e.g . Cyrtodonta huronensis Billings, 1858) . A third variety shows only growth lines o n the ligament insertio n area , overlain by relatively thick, fibrous ligament ligament layers, each covering several growt h lines [e.g . Gosseletia triquetra Conrad, 1838 ; se e Carter (1990 , p . 198)] . (iii) DHopis 1-2: DHopi s ligamen t wit h normally only one adult fibrous layer but with additional adul t fibrous layers formed i n some individuals a s a consequence o f traumatic withdrawal o f the mantle margin s [e.g . Pinna Linne; see Yonge (1953)]. (b) DHopis/amph: slightly prosodeti c bu t stil l predominantl y opisthodetic D H ligament, e.g . Actinopteria Hall . (c) DHamph: strongl y amphideti c DH ligament, e.g . Leiopecten Khalfin . 8. Duplivincular inclined (DI): duplivincular ligamen t wit h adult insertion groove s distinctl y dippin g relativ e t o the hinge margin . (a) DIopis: entirel y opisthodeti c D I ligament, e.g . Ischyrodonta Ulrich . (b) DIopis/amph : slightl y prosodetic , bu t predominantl y opisthodeti c D I ligament , e.g . Ptychodesma Hal l & Whitfield. (c) DIamph: strongl y amphidetic D I ligament. (i) Dlamph-incl : DIamph ligamen t wit h all ligament groove s distinctl y incline d relativ e t o growth lines , e.g . Pseudaviculopecten Newell . (ii) DIamph-aliv : DIamph ligamen t wit h posterior ligamen t groove s al l distinctly incline d relativ e t o growt h lines, bu t anterio r par t o f ligamen t changin g t o a broad , flat , insertio n are a covere d b y weakl y o r strongl y mineralized fibrous ligament , e.g. Cosmetodon obsoletus (Meek , 1871) .
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTION
53
Table I. Continued 9. Alivincular (ALIV): single, triangular to slightly trapezoidal area of fibrous ligament (resilifer) flanked anteriorly and posteriorly by lamellar ligament . (a) ALIVnar : ALIV ligament with angle of divergence < 20°, e.g . Spondylus Linne . (b) ALIVmod : ALIV ligament with moderate angl e of divergence (20-110°). (i) ALIVmod-trian : ALIVmod ligament with triangular resilifer, e.g. Lentipecten hochstetteri (Zittel, 1864) . (ii) ALIVmod-trap : ALIVmo d ligamen t wit h nearl y trapezoida l resilifer , e.g . Eumorphotis multiformis (Bittner, 1899) . (c) ALIVwide: ALI V ligamen t wit h angl e o f divergenc e > 110° , e.g . Acanthopecten coloradoensis (Newberry , 1861). 10. Multivincular (MULT): serially repeated alivincular ligaments .
Palaeotaxodont teet h ma y b e orthomorphodont , concavodont (distall y concave ) o r convexodon t (distally convex) , o r a combinatio n thereo f [terminology afte r Babi n (1966)] . I n palaeo taxodont hinges , th e toot h numbe r increase s wit h shell growth above c. 1 mm length. Pretaxodonty is presently applie d t o minimall y taxodon t hinge s with only two to four stout, orthomorphodont teeth . Unlike palaeotaxodon t teeth , pretaxodon t teet h d o not increase in number with continued shell growth beyond c . 1 mm length . Fo r example , Pojetaia sarhroensis Geye r & Streng, 1998 , has onl y thre e or fou r pretaxodon t teet h i n shell s 2.2 5 mm i n length, wherea s th e Recen t nuculoi d Microgloma yongei Sander s & Allen , 197 3 has si x t o eigh t palaeotaxodont teet h i n a shel l 1.0m m i n lengt h (Sanders & Alle n 1973 , fig. 10 ) an d Ennucula aegeensis (Forbe s 1843 ) has te n palaeotaxodon t teeth i n a shel l 0.9 8 mm in lengt h (Ockelman n & Waren 1998 , fig. 4C). Pseudotaxodonty (cf . Cox 1969, p . N107 ) presentl y refer s t o fiv e o r mor e closely adjacent , mor e o r les s irregularly shaped , taxodont teeth in one or two rows. Pseudotaxodon t teeth ma y b e strongl y ventrall y divergen t and/o r ventrally bifid , bu t the y ar e no t regularl y concav e or convex . Heterotaxodont y refer s t o hinge s i n which th e anterio r teeth , whic h ma y b e palaeotaxodont o r pseudotaxodont , ar e abruptl y much large r tha n posterio r palaeotaxodon t teet h (e.g. i n Praeleda subtilis, Cop e 1999) . Cope' s (\996a) ter m 'gradidentate ' ha s bee n adopte d fo r taxodont teeth more or less gradually increasing in size anteriorly and posteriorly fro m the subumbonal region. Methods of analysis PAUP* Version 4b2a (Swoffor d 1998 ) was use d with random addition , tre e bisection-reconnectio n (TBR), delaye d transformation , an d on e 42 5 replicate an d tw o 100 0 replicate runs . The deca y index (D.L ) fo r eac h nod e i n th e stric t consensus
tree wa s calculate d usin g a 20-replicat e heuristi c search (rando m addition , TBR , delaye d trans formation) fo r tree s incompatibl e wit h each node . The D.L is the differenc e betwee n the stric t consensus tre e an d th e shortes t tre e incompatibl e with th e node . Wit h referenc e t o Fig . 4 stric t consensus tre e node s wit h D. L othe r tha n zer o include: D.I. = 41 (node 2); D.I. = 6 (node 4); D.L = 5 (node 21); D.L = 4 (nodes 3, 16-20, 31, 55, 64); D.L = 3 (nodes 7, 26, 27, 30, 34); D.L = 2 (nodes 5, 6, 29, 33, 41); and D.L = 1 (nodes 9 22-25, 28, 32, 38-40, 43, 48, 52, 53, 56, 61-63, 65). Appendix 3 shows the database for these analyses. Results The 425 replicate an d two 100 0 replicate heuristi c searches foun d th e sam e 41 1 mos t parsimoniou s trees (lengt h 1103) , suggestin g that all of the mos t parsimonious trees wer e found . Thes e tree s ha d a consistency inde x of 0.5313, a homoplasy inde x of 0.5830, a retention inde x o f 0.6372 and a rescale d consistency inde x o f 0.3385 . Th e strict , Adam s and majorit y rul e consensu s tree s ar e show n i n Figs 1-3 . The stric t consensus tree (Fig . 1) shows that th e Bivalvia (taxa 5-67) resolv e close r t o the laterally compressed monoplacophoran s Watsonella an d Pseudomyona tha n t o th e laterall y compresse d monoplacophoran Anabarella o r th e rostroconc h Ribeiria. Th e stric t consensu s tre e als o indicate s monophyly fo r the subclas s Palaeotaxodont a (tax a 8-19); a clade consistin g o f the Anomalodesmat a (taxon 41 ) togethe r wit h th e Pteriomorphi a (tax a 42-67); a clad e comprisin g th e Tironuculida e (taxon 8) , Praenuculida e (taxo n 9) , Nuculida e (taxon 10 ) and Solemyoida (taxa 17-19); a clade of the Thoraliida e (taxo n 21 ) an d Trigonioid a (tax a 22-25); a clade o f three cycloconchi d gener a (tax a 26-28); a monophyleti c orde r Mytiloid a a s presently define d (tax a 44^4-6) ; a monophyleti c Cyrtodontoida (tax a 50-52) ; monophyleti c
54
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
Pectinoida as presently defined (taxa 55-57); and a monophyletic orde r Arcoid a (tax a 62-67) . Th e Adams consensus tree (Fig. 2) additionally resolves a clad e comprisin g th e Palaeoheterodont a an d
Heterodonta (i.e . severa l actinodont s plu s th e orders Lucinoida, Trigonioida an d Veneroida; taxa 20-40); a clad e withi n th e Pteriomorphi a comprising th e Colpomyidae , Modiolopsidae ,
Fig. 1 . Strict consensus tree for 411 most parsimonious trees from a 425 replicate, heuristic search .
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N 5
Mytilidae, Matheriidae , Modiolodontidae , Cyrto dontidae an d Falcatodontidae , taxa 43-52; an d a second pteriomorphia n clad e represente d b y th e Ambonychioidea, Pectinoida , Pterioida , Ostreoid a and Arcoida. The majority rule consensus tree (Fig.
5
3) adds a weakly supported (53%), poorly resolved association o f th e Palaeotaxodont a togethe r wit h the Palaeoheterodonta an d Heterodonta. From the 411 most parsimonious trees, selecte d for furthe r analysi s were those trees i n whic h th e
Fig. 2 . Adams consensus tree for 411 most parsimonious trees from a 425 replicate, heuristic search.
56 J
. G . CARTER ETAL.
clade o f th e Palaeoheterodont a plu s Heterodont a was resolved a s monophyletic an d exclusive of the Palaeotaxodonta an d Pteriomorphia . Thi s filterin g did no t interfer e with evaluation of th e hypothesi s
of actinodont ancestry to arcoids because all of the most parsimoniou s trees exclude d thi s hypothesis . The filterin g excluded al l but 1 6 trees. I n these 1 6 trees, a palaeoheterodont-heterodon t clad e i s
Fig. 3 . Majority rul e consensu s tre e fo r 411 most parsimoniou s tree s from a 425 replicate, heuristic search . Al l node s are 100 % excep t wher e indicate d otherwise .
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N
consistently basa l t o a n Anomalodesmata Pteriomorphia clade. The 1 6 trees differ onl y in the position o f Modiomorpha basa l t o Evyana, o r a s a sister grou p t o Evyana, an d i n th e positio n o f th e Matheriidae (Matheria an d Metapadid) a s a siste r group t o Modiolopsis-Whiteavesia-Modiolus, basal to these three genera or basal to Modiolodon. From thes e 1 6 trees th e reconstructio n (Fig . 4 ) i n which Modiomorpha i s basal t o the Pteriomorphi a and i n whic h th e Matheriida e ar e close r t o th e Cyrtodontidae wa s selected . Thi s selectio n wa s justified o n th e basi s tha t Modiomorpha lack s th e multiple ligamen t insertion s characteristi c o f Evyana an d man y othe r basa l o r near-basa l pteriomorphians (includin g som e colpomyid s an d modiolopsids) an d becaus e matheriid s hav e bee n regarded a s closel y relate d t o cyrtodontid s (Desbiens 1994) . Al l characte r stat e change s fo r Fig. 4 ar e give n i n Appendi x 4 an d th e mor e significant of these are reviewed briefly below. This review i s largel y limite d t o unambiguou s apomorphies and non-terminal nodes. The clad e o f Pojetaia-Fordilla-higheii Bivalvi a (node 5 ) i s characterize d b y th e appearanc e o f a subumbonal socke t i n th e righ t valv e an d a corresponding tooth in the left valve, and the loss of radial costae. The clade of Fordilla-highQr Bivalvia (node 6) begins wit h a more anteriorl y situate d bu t non-terminal beak and loss of an ancestral posterior auricle. Th e commo n ancesto r o f th e subclasse s Palaeotaxodonta an d Autolamellibranchiat a (nod e 7) i s characterize d b y separatio n o f th e lef t valv e (LV) pedal retractor sca r from th e adductor muscle scar, a shift i n the position of the posterior adductor muscle sca r close r t o th e hinge , a mor e solidl y inserted pallia l line , smal l table t nacreou s and/o r porcelaneous [crosse d lamella r (CL) , comple x crossed lamella r (CCL), an d fin e CC L and/o r homogeneous (FCCL/HOM) ] structures , an d mor e extensive mineralizatio n o f th e simple , narro w ligament. Th e Palaeotaxodont a (nod e 55 ) the n differentiates b y evolvin g an anterior mantle sens e organ an d palaeotaxodon t hing e teeth , th e latte r anteriorly concavodon t an d posteriorl y ortho morphodont, wit h th e anterio r toot h ro w les s than one third as long as the posterior tooth row and with the posterio r teet h increasin g i n siz e towar d th e posterior. Th e Autolamellibranchiat a (nod e 8 ) differentiates b y changin g from protobranchiat e t o autolamellibranchiate. Withi n th e Autolamelli branchiata, th e Heteroconchi a a s presently define d (node 35 ) the n separate s fro m th e clad e o f th e Anomalodesmata and Pteriomorphia (nod e 9). The Heteroconchia i s characterize d b y a mor e discoidal, les s dorsall y indente d anterio r shel l margin and , possibl y (ambiguous) , b y a chang e from anisomyaria n t o nearl y isomyarian . Th e Anomalodesmata-Pteriomorphia clad e ha s
57
stronger posteroventra l obliquit y an d possibl y (ambiguous) a stronge r inflectio n i n th e pos teroventral shel l margin . Modiomorpha ha s numerous apomorphies , includin g a medioventra l or posteroventra l sinus , proximit y o f th e anterio r pedal retracto r an d anterio r adducto r muscle , placement o f th e anterio r adducto r clos e t o th e hinge, partial overgrowth of the hinge dentition by the advancin g ligamen t insertio n are a an d a shallowly submerged , parivincula r rampe d ligament. Th e suborde r Pteriomorphi a (nod e 10 ) differs fro m th e Anomalodesmat a i n havin g discontinuous fibrou s ligamen t ontogen y an d multiple ligament grooves. Focusing o n the Palaeotaxodonta, ther e is a basal dichotomy betwee n th e superfamil y Nuculanoidea (Nuculites an d Palaeoneilo) an d othe r tax a traditionally place d i n th e order s Nuculoid a o r Solemyoida. Th e Nuculanoide a (nod e 56 ) i s characterized b y a shallo w pallia l sinu s an d possibly als o (ambiguous ) b y a chang e fro m nacreous t o finel y texture d porcelaneou s micro structure. Th e remainin g Palaeotaxodont a (nod e 57) ar e characterize d b y a n increas e i n umbona l elevation and , excep t fo r Eritropis, als o a chang e from anterio r t o media l beak s an d fro m posterio r orthomorphodont t o posterio r concavodon t denti tion (node 58). Except for the basal genus Eritropis, this clad e i s divided int o the famil y Cardiolariida e Cope 1997 , an d a siste r grou p (nod e 61 ) whic h includes Tironucula (famil y Tironuculidae) , Praenucula (famil y Praenuculidae) , Nuculoidea (family Nuculidae ) and the order Solemyoida . Th e Cardiolariidae (nod e 59 ) i s characterize d b y a heterotaxodont hinge . Th e siste r grou p t o th e Cardiolariidae (node 61) corresponds with a change from posteroventral to anteroventral shell obliquity, nuculiform shel l shape , mor e unifor m siz e i n th e posterior palaeotaxodon t hing e teet h an d a n increase i n th e relative length of the anterio r tooth row. Autapomorphies for Tironucula jugata include an increas e i n the hinge arc h an d th e additio n o f a single posterio r lamella r toot h abov e th e posterio r palaeotaxodont teeth . Autapomorphie s fo r Praenuculafaba includ e reduction in the number of dorsal accessor y muscl e scars t o on e o r two an d a change i n th e posterio r hing e teet h fro m con cavodont to orthomorphodont. The latter, however, is no t widesprea d fo r Praenucula, as concavodon t posterior dentition is present in Praenucula infirma Tunnicliff, 1982 , amon g other species . Th e famil y Nuculidae i s presentl y represente d b y Nuculoidea pinguis. Autapomorphies for this species include an internal resilium and increase i n size of the anterio r adductor muscl e scar s relativ e t o th e posterio r ones. The order Solemyoida (node 64) is characterized by: a triangular posteroventral shel l margin; medial
58 J
. G . CARTER ETAL.
or posterior beaks; a greatly elongated shel l anterior with nearly parallel dorsa l an d ventral margins ; at most, only a slight indentation anterio r t o opistho gyrate beaks ; a n externa l parivincula r wid e ligament; an d anterio r palaeotaxodon t teet h wit h
variable shapes . The hinge dentition i s secondaril y reduced in Acharax and other solemyoideans. The subclas s Autolamellibranchiat a (nod e 8 ) i s characterized b y non-protobranc h ctenidi a an d perhaps also (ambiguous) by non-pretaxodont, non-
Fig. 4 . Cladogram selected from 411 most parsimonious trees to base the present phylogenetic classification .
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N
palaeotaxodont hing e teeth . Th e superorde r Heteroconchia (nod e 35 ) i s characterize d b y a change i n th e shap e o f th e anterio r shel l margi n from indente d anterio r t o th e beak s t o discoidal , with a t mos t a ver y sligh t indentation . Thi s nod e may also correspond with a change from unequal to nearly equa l adducto r muscl e scar s (ambiguous) . The Heteroconchi a show s a basa l dichotom y between a n unnamed clad e (nod e 36 ) comprisin g the Lucinoid a (nod e 37) , Thoraliida e an d Trigonioida (node 39), and a second unnamed clade comprising the Cycloconchidae sensu stricto (node 43), Redoniida e (nod e 54) , Nyassida e (nod e 50 ) and basal o r near-basal heterodonts (nod e 46). The lucinoid-thoraliid-trigonioid clad e (nod e 36 ) i s characterized b y a shif t i n the bea k positio n fro m anterior t o medial and , possibly, als o by a slender , non-bifid o r slightl y bifid , righ t pivota l cardina l tooth. Within this clade, the order Lucinoida (node 37) show s a reductio n i n th e shel l length/heigh t ratio t o < 1.25, a mor e nearl y equilatera l shel l shape, an d a wider , simpl e ligament . Th e Thoraliidae show s a n increas e i n umbona l eleva tion, change s fro m posteroventrall y t o antero ventrally oblique , evolve s a mor e robus t righ t pivotal cardina l toot h an d add s a slender , posteroventrally directe d cardina l tooth behind the pivotal cardina l toot h i n th e lef t valve . Th e orde r Trigonioida (nod e 39 ) i s characterize d b y th e change fro m a simpl e t o a n incipien t parivincular narrow ligament . I t ma y b e note d tha t Lyrodesma did not place close to Silurozodus until its juvenile stage was included as a separate taxon. An unname d cycloconchid-redoniid-nyassid heterodont clad e (nod e 42 ) i s characterize d b y posteriorly dippin g pseudotaxodon t hing e teet h located posteriorly t o th e pivotal cardina l toot h in each valve . Withi n this clade , th e Cycloconchida e (as presentl y restricted ; nod e 43 ) show s tw o anterior latera l o r pseudolateral teeth , th e stronge r of these long, slender, lamellar and continuous with the anterio r cardina l tooth . Th e remainin g tax a i n this clad e (nod e 45 ; redoniids , nyassid s an d nea r basal o r basa l heterodonts ) ar e unite d b y sub umbonal pseudotaxodonty an d by posteroventrall y dipping pseudotaxodont teeth anterior to the pivotal cardinal tooth. The nea r basal o r basal heterodon t clad e (nod e 46) is characterized by a shell length/height ratio of < 1.25; thre e o r mor e posterio r latera l o r pseudo lateral teeth , th e stronges t long , slender , an d lamellar; an d a wider posterior hing e plate. Within this clade , Genu s C o f Johnsto n & Goodbod y (1988) shares with Eodon tenuistriata (Hall, 1870 ) (node 48 ) sligh t posterio r rostrateness , a broadl y concave area immediately anterio r to the beaks and reduction o f ancestra l subumbona l pseudo taxodonty to two cardinal teeth.
59
The gener a Redonia an d Noradonta (nod e 54 ) are unite d b y havin g a singl e posterio r latera l o r pseudolateral tooth , a wide r anterio r hing e plat e and, possibly, als o separation o f the posterior pedal retractor sca r from th e posterior adducto r scar (the latter remains uncertain for Noradonta). The family Nyassida e (node 50), represented b y Nyassa, Tanaodon, Montanaria, an d genera A and B of Johnston & Goodbody (1988), is characterize d by th e additio n o f a posteroventral shel l margina l sinus. Possibl e synapomorphie s includ e a slightl y triangular posteroventral margin, a wider posterio r hinge plate and very wide CL and/or CCL structure in the inner shell layer . Within th e superorde r Pteriomorphia , Evyana baltica (Liljedahl, 1989 ) is transitional between the Modiomorphidae an d earl y 'mytiloid ' pterio morphians. Evyana combine s th e deepl y incise d lunule and rather crudely shaped cardinal dentition of Modiomorpha (althoug h mor e distinc t tha n i n Modiomorphd) wit h the opisthodetic, duplivincula r ligament o f other near-basa l pteriomorphian s suc h as colpomyids . Node s 11-1 5 joi n th e variou s 'mytiloid' familie s wit h th e orde r Cyrtodontoida . Node 1 1 correspond s wit h th e appearanc e o f a Fordilla-\ike shel l shap e an d a horizontal , opisthodetic, duplivincula r ligamen t wit h fe w ligament grooves . Nod e 1 2 involves reductio n i n the convexity of the left valve, reduction o f the lef t pivotal subumbonal hinge tooth and closer spacing of th e ligamen t grooves . Nod e 1 3 is supporte d b y only on e ambiguous synapomorph y - a change in the righ t pivota l cardinal/subumbona l toot h fro m bulbous or tuberculiform to more distinctly shaped and slender . Nod e 1 4 coincides wit h shortening of the shel l t o a length/heigh t rati o o f < 1.25 an d reduction of posteroventral shell obliquity. Node 15 is characterize d b y a decreas e i n lef t valv e convexity and partial overgrowth of the hinge plate by the ligament insertion area . Nodes 16-2 0 correspon d with the differentiatio n of th e Ambonychioidea , Pectinoida , Pterioida , Ostreoida an d th e Umburridae-Arcoid a clade . Node 16 is supported by the evolution of a posterior auricle withou t significan t posterio r extension , a byssal sinus , posteroventra l shif t o f th e posterio r adductor muscle scar and calcitic, simple prismati c structure. At node 1 7 the following are observed: a commissural shelf ; a n angula r anterio r auricle ; a n anteriorly dippin g anterio r shel l margin ; an d a straight, proximally restricted gil l wheal , the latter extending fro m th e umbona l cavit y postero ventrally below the posterior adductor . At node 1 8 the left valv e becomes mor e convex than the right one; the duplivincular ligament change s from symmetrical t o asymmetrical; th e subumbonal area has posteriorly dippin g pseudotaxodon t teeth ; th e posterior hinge acquires three or more lateral and/or
60
J. G . CARTE R E T AL.
pseudolateral teeth, wit h the lower ones aligned en echelon closer to the beak, and at least one of these long an d slender ; an d th e toot h closes t t o th e subumbonal area is short and nearly horizontal. The Ostreoida-Arcoid a clad e (nod e 19 ) corresponds wit h a reduce d byssa l sinus ; slightl y more elevate d umbones ; a chang e fro m Pterineaform t o Umburraform shel l shape ; a gil l wheal changin g fro m straigh t an d proximall y restricted, t o distall y posteriorl y curving ; tw o anterior lateral teeth, the stronger of these short and tabular; an d pseudotaxodon t teet h fillin g th e ga p between thes e teet h an d the beak. A t nod e 20 , the duplivincular ligamen t change s fro m opisthodeti c horizontal to amphidetic inclined , and the ligament symmetry change s fro m asymmetrica l t o symmetrical with a wide interfacial angl e between the ligament insertion areas . The clad e o f th e orde r Mytiloid a a s presentl y restricted (nod e 33 ) i s characterize d b y a chang e from Fordillaform t o modiolifor m o r mytilifor m shell shape , an d los s o f subumbona l teet h i n association wit h a thick, gasket-lik e periostracum . Within this clade, the family Mytilidae, represented by Cretaceou s Modiolus, differ s fro m Modiolopsis and Whiteavesia i n reducin g th e convexit y o f it s valves; shifting posteriorly the contact of the pallial line wit h th e posterio r adducto r muscl e scar ; shifting th e posterio r adducto r sca r ventrall y an d posteriorly; an d addin g abundan t irregular simpl e prismatic structur e in the inner shell layer. The superfamil y Cyrtodontoide a (nod e 30 ) i s characterized b y tw o long , lamellar , posterio r lateral teeth, not uniformly aligned en echelon, and separated b y a wide , edentulou s ga p fro m th e subumbonal hing e teeth . Withi n thi s superfamily, Ortonella i s basa l t o th e superfamilie s Cyrtodontoidea an d Falcatodontoidea . Th e Cyrtodontidae, a s represente d b y Cyrtodonta saffordi (Hal l 1859) , ha s a mor e discoida l ventra l shell margin ; more mediall y situate d beaks; mor e equal adducto r muscl e scars ; a gil l whea l proximally dorsoventra l an d distall y posteriorl y curving; a shortene d posterior lateral toot h closest to th e beak ; a thicke r anterio r hing e plate ; an d a deeply bifid , ventrall y o r anteroventrall y ope n subumbonal toot h anterio r t o th e pivota l subumbonal tooth. In contrast, the Falcatodontida e has a posterior auricle ; strong , radial costae ; a less elliptical, mor e triangula r posterio r adducto r muscle scar; two posterior lateral teeth in one valve and thre e i n th e other ; subumbona l edentul y resulting fro m a posterio r shif t i n th e umbones ; and a reductio n i n overgrowt h o f th e hing e dentition. The clade of the Pectinoida (nod e 27) is defined by reduction i n the convexity of the left valve , loss of hinge overgrowt h an d a change in th e ancestral
duplivincular, horizonta l ligamen t fro m opistho detic t o amphidetic . Ambiguou s synapomorphie s include th e adoptio n o f valve-indifferen t pleuro thetic habit s an d a shif t fro m anterio r t o media l beaks. Withi n thi s clade , suborde r Limin a (represented b y Palaeolima) i s characterize d b y a change fro m sligh t posteroventra l t o sligh t anteroventral shel l obliquity ; los s o f th e commissural shelf ; a chang e fro m prosogyrat e t o orthogyrate; closel y t o medium-space d radia l costae; an d th e chang e fro m duplivincular , horizontal, amphideti c ligamen t t o a n alivincula r ligament. Th e suborde r Pectinin a (represente d b y Leiopecten) show s a slight increase in extension of the posterior auricl e beyond the subauricular sinus; a sligh t increas e i n th e shel l length/heigh t ratio ; a more discoidal , anteriorl y incline d anterio r shel l margin; a more convex left valve ; and a hinge with one o r tw o anterio r an d posterior , elongat e teet h that both approximate th e subumbonal area without strong, intervening teeth. Synapomorphies fo r the order Arcoida (nod e 21) include a stronge r inflectio n i n th e posteroventra l shell margin ; posteroventra l inclinatio n o f th e anterior shell margin; reduction of the commissural shelf; secondaril y equivalv e shells ; movemen t o f the posterio r adducto r close r t o th e hinge ; a mor e elliptical anterio r adductor ; increase i n the number of anterior lateral or pseudolateral hinge teeth fro m two t o thre e o r more ; an d a chang e i n th e orientation o f th e pseudotaxodon t subumbona l teeth fro m posteroventrall y incline d t o nearl y vertical or dorsally divergent .
Discussion The present analysi s suggest s tha t the Bivalvia are more closel y relate d t o Watsonella an d Pseudomyona tha n t o Anabarella an d th e Rostroconchia . This analysi s als o suggest s tha t th e commo n ancestor of Tuarangia an d Pojetaia (Fig . 4, node 4) had a non-rostrat e posterior ; a moderatel y t o slightly elongat e ventra l shel l margin ; n o shel l marginal sinuses ; sligh t posteroventra l obliquity ; low, medial beaks with, at most, a slight indentation anterior t o them ; a n angula r posterio r auricle ; n o lunule o r escutcheon ; n o pegm a o r pegma-lik e shelf; thre e o r more subumbonal , dorsal accessor y muscle scars; a non-sinuate pallial line ; a straight , edentulous hinge ; a n aragoniti c shell ; an d a non mineralized o r weakly mineralized, narrow , dorsal, simple ligament. Some of the features indicated for this ancesto r ar e mutuall y inconsistent . Fo r example, presenc e o f a protoconc h (characte r 35 , beak direction) conflicts with medial division of the larval shel l (characte r 98) . Here, PAUP reverted t o a mor e distan t ancestra l stat e fo r characte r 3 5
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTION
because Tuarangia an d Pojetaia diffe r i n thi s character. Fo r a simila r reason , a pseudoligamen t and tru e ligamen t ar e indicate d a s presen t unde r different characters . Contrar y t o thes e indications , the immediate common ancestor of Tuarangia an d Pojetaia probabl y had a divided larval shell and a true ligament , althoug h whethe r i t ha d differentiated anterio r an d posterio r adducto r muscles remains uncertain. The presen t dat a reinforc e th e observatio n b y Waller (1998 , fig . 3 ) tha t th e subclas s Palaeo taxodonta show s a basa l dichotom y betwee n th e superfamily Nuculanoide a an d th e superfamilie s Nuculoidea an d Solemyoidea . Thi s i s significan t because Waller's evidence was largely soft anatomical and the present is principally palaeontological . In recognitio n o f thi s dichotomy , th e subclas s Palaeotaxodonta i s divide d int o th e superorder s Nuculaniformii nov. (containin g th e orde r Nuculanoida nov.) and Nuculiformii (nom. transl Starobogatov, 1992, ex Nuculidae Gray, 1824). The Nuculiformii comprise s al l non-nuculanoidea n palaeotaxodonts. It is als o suggested that Eritropis is exclude d fro m th e Cardiolariida e an d tha t th e 'malletiid' Ekstadia Soot-Ryen , 1964 , i s included in thi s family . Th e Cardiolariida e thu s define d i s uniquely characterize d b y a heterotaxodont hinge . In orde r t o preserv e th e orde r Nuculoid a a s nonpar aphyletic, it should be limited to the superfamily Nuculoidea, families Nuculidae and Pristiglomida e (Sanders & Allen, 1973). The Pristiglomidae share numerous apomorphie s wit h th e Nuculidae , including a sharpl y separate d heel , multipl e loop s in the hindgut and a laterally mineralize d resiliu m (Waller 1998) . Contrary t o Cop e (1996a , 1997) , th e Sole myoidea appea r t o b e closel y relate d t o th e Palaeotaxodonta through the family Ctenodontida e Wohrmann, 1893 . A s constitute d b y McAleste r (1969), th e famil y Ctenodontida e i s presentl y shown t o b e paraphyleti c wit h respec t t o th e Solemyoidea. Pojet a (1988 ) indicate d tha t th e Ctenodontidae i s poorl y conceptualized , s o h e tentatively assigned Ctenodonta an d Tancrediopsis, among othe r genera , t o th e nuculanoidea n famil y Malletiidae. Th e presen t analysi s suggest s tha t Ctenodonta an d Tancrediopsis shoul d b e con sidered near-basa l plesion s withi n th e orde r Solemyoida. The present analysis supports the hypothesi s of Sanchez & Babi n (1998 ) tha t nuculoid s an d palaeoheterodonts merel y shar e commo n ancestry. In this regard, it is important to note that Fordilla was diagnose d a s non-pretaxodont . On e migh t argue tha t Fordilla ha s instea d a reduce d pretaxodont dentition, considering its close affinit y with Pojetaia. I n eithe r case , however , fordilloi d dentition, an d henc e th e dentitio n immediatel y
61
preceding th e differentiatio n o f th e subclasse s Palaeotaxodonta an d Autolamelibranchiata , wa s sparsely dentat e an d neithe r palaeotaxodon t no r actinodont. Actinodont y ha s apparentl y evolve d convergently amon g palaeotaxodonts , palaeo heterodonts and pteriomorphians, just as taxodonty sensu lato ha s evolve d convergentl y amon g palaeotaxodonts, actinodonts , unionoids and pteriomorphians. Th e origi n o f th e subclas s Auto lamellibranchiata ma y correlate with a change from pretaxodont t o non-pretaxodon t an d non-palaeo taxodont dentition, as well as with the change fro m protobranch to non-protobranch ctenidia . The superorde r Heteroconchia , a s presentl y restricted t o palaeoheterodont s an d heterodonts , ancestrally differ s fro m th e Anomalodesmat a an d Pteriomorphia i n having a more discoidal anterio r and mor e equa l adducto r muscl e scars . Thes e changes sugges t a shif t fro m relativel y inactiv e to active burrowing life habits. Within th e Heteroconchia , th e thoraliid trigonioid-lucinoid clad e (nod e 36 ) i s no t sup ported by the strict or Adams consensus trees and it is only supported at 56% by the majority consensus tree. It s significanc e is therefor e questioned . Th e other heteroconc h clade , consistin g o f actinodont s and heterodonts , i s supporte d b y th e Adam s consensus tree and therefore more likely reflect s a natural association . Within th e actinodont-heterodon t clade , Noradonta doe s not place close to Lyrodesma i n the Adams o r majorit y consensu s trees , bu t i t i s resolved clos e t o Redonia i n Fig . 4 . Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson (1977 ) an d Babi n (1982a ) placed Noradonta shergoldi Pojet a & Gilbert Tomlinson, 1977 , i n th e famil y Lyrodesmatidae . However, som e specie s o f Noradonta, suc h a s Noradonta redoniaeformis (Thoral , 1935) , ar e strikingly simila r t o Redonia bohemica Barrande, 1881, differin g i n little mor e tha n th e presenc e o f dental microcrenulations . Redonia an d Noradonta lack ligament nymphs (Pojeta 1978, pi. 4, figs 1 and 2; Babin 1982a , pi. 9, fig. 2), but nymphs are well developed i n Lyrodesma. The presen t stud y i s i n agreement wit h Johnston & Goodbody (1988 ) and Babin & Gutierrez-Marc o (1991 ) i n tha t th e taxonomic significance of dental microcrenulation s has bee n overemphasize d i n th e definitio n o f palaeoheterodont families . Eodon i s on e o f th e earlies t know n repre sentatives o f th e superfamil y Crassatelloidea , an d hence o f th e orde r Veneroid a an d grou p Heterodonta. Chava n (1969 , p . N565 ) place d thi s genus i n th e famil y Astartida e d'Orbigny , bu t i t differs fro m astartids i n retainin g a partiall y nacreous interior [Carte r & Lutz 1990 , pi. 104 ; see Taylor (1973 ) fo r Astartidae ] an d i n havin g a ligament transitiona l betwee n simpl e wide , a s i n
Table 2. Classification Class Bivalvia Linne, 175 8 Order Tuarangioid a Mackinnon , 198 2 Genus Tuarangia Mackinnon , 198 2 Genus Pojetaia Jell, 198 0 Genus Fordilla Barrande, 188 1 Subclass Palaeotaxodont a Korobkov , 195 4 Superorder Nuculaniformi i nov. Order Nuculanoid a nov. Superfamily Nuculanoide a Adam s & Adams, 185 8 Family Malletiidae Adam s & Adams, 185 8 Genus Palaeoneilo Hall & Whitfield, 186 9 Genus Nuculites Conrad, 184 1 Superorder Nuculiformi i Gray , 182 4 Genus Eritropis Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 197 7 Family Cardiolariida e Cope , 199 7 Genus Ekstadia Soot-Ryen, 196 4 Genus Cardiolaria Munier-Chalmas, 187 6 Genus Praeleda Pfab, 193 4 Unnamed clade Family Tironuculida e Babin, 198 2 Genus Tironucula Morris & Fortey, 197 6 Family Praenuculida e McAlester , 196 9 Genus Praenucula Pfab , 193 4 Order Nuculoid a Gray , 182 4 Superfamily Nuculoide a Gray , 182 4 Family Nuculida e Gray, 182 4 Genus Nuculoidea Williams & Breger, 191 6 Order Solemyoid a Gray , 184 0 Genus Tancrediopsis Beushausen , 189 5 Genus Ctenodonta Salter, 185 2 Superfamily Solemyoide a Gray, 184 0 Family Acharacida e Scarlat o & Starobogatov, 197 9 Genus Acharax Dall , 190 8 Subclass Autolamellibranchiat a Grobben , 189 4 Superorder Heteroconchi a Hertwig , 189 5 Unnamed clad e Order Lucinoida Fleming , 182 8 Superfamily Babinkoide a Horny , 196 0 Family Babinkidae Horny, 196 0 Genus Babinka Barrande, 188 1 Superfamily Lucinoide a Fleming , 182 8 Family uncertain Genus Ilionia Billings, 187 5 Unnamed clad e Family Thoraliidae Morris , 198 0 Genus Thoralia Morris , 198 0 Order Trigonioid a Lamarck , 181 9 Family Lyrodesmatidae Ulrich , 189 4 Genus Lyrodesma Conrad, 184 1 Superfamily Trigonioide a Lamarck , 181 9 Family Schizodida e Newel l & Boyd, 197 5 Genus Silurozodus Liljedahl, 199 2 Unnamed clad e Superfamily Cycloconchoidea Ulrich , 189 3 Family Cycloconchida e Ulrich , 189 3 Genus Cycloconcha Miller, 187 4 Genus Fortowensia Cope, 199 6 Genus Actinodonta Phillips , 184 8 Unnamed clad e Unnamed clad e Genus Copidens Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 1977 Genus Ananterodonta Babi n & Gutierrez-Marco, 198 5 Unnamed clad e Genus C Johnston & Goodbody, 198 8 Order Veneroida Rafinesque, 181 5 Superfamily Crassatelloide a Ferussac , 182 2 Family Eodonidae nov. Genus Eodon Hall in Miller, 187 7 Unamed clad e Family Redoniida e Babin , 196 6 Genus Redonia Rouault, 1851 Genus Noradonta Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 197 7
Table 2. Continued Family Nyassidae Hall, 188 5 Unnamed clade Genus Nyassa Hal l & Whitfield, 1869 Genus Tanaodon Kirk , 192 7 Unnamed clade Genus A Johnston & Goodbody, 198 8 Genus B Johnston & Goodbody, 198 8 Genus Montanaria Spriestersbach, 190 9 Superorder Anomalodesmat a Dall, 188 9 Order Modiomorphoida Miller, 187 7 Superfamily Modiomorphoide a Miller, 187 7 Family Modiomorphidae Miller, 187 7 Genus Modiomorpha Hal l & Whitfield, 186 9 Superorder Pteriomorphia Beurlen, 194 4 Family Evyanidae nov. Genus Evyana Liljedahl, 199 0 Family Colpomyidae Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 197 7 Genus Colpomya Ulrich , 189 4 Order Mytiloida Rafinesque, 1815 Superfamily Mytiloide a Rafinesque, 1815 Genus Modiolopsis Hall , 184 7 Genus Whiteavesia Ulrich , 189 3 Family Mytilidae Rafinesque, 1815 Subfamily Modiolina e Keen , 195 8 Genus Modiolus Lamarck, 179 9 Family Matheriidae Scarlato & Starobogatov, 197 9 Genus Matheria Billings , 185 8 Genus Metapadia Desbiens , 199 4 Family Modiolodontidae Fan g & Morris, 199 7 Genus Modiolodon Ulrich , 189 4 Order Cyrtodontoida Ulrich, 189 4 Genus Ortonella Ulrich, 189 4 Superfamily Cyrtodontoide a Ulrich, 189 4 Family Cyrtodontidae Ulrich, 189 4 Genus Cyrtodonta Billings , 185 8 Superfamily Falcatodontoide a Cope , 1996 b Family Falcatodontidae Cope , 1996 b Genus Falcatodonta Cope, 1996 b Superfamily Ambonychioide a Miller, 187 7 Family Ambonychiidae Miller, 187 7 Genus Ambonychia Hall, 184 7 Family Myalinidae Freeh, 189 1 Genus Septimyalina Newell , 194 2 Order Pectinoida Rafinesque, 1815 Family Myodakryotidae Tunnicliff, 198 7 Genus Myodakryotus Tunnicliff , 198 7 Suborder Limina Rafinesque, 1815 Superfamily Limoide a Rafinesque, 1815 Family Limidae Rafinesque, 1815 Genus Palaeolima Hind, 190 3 Suborder Pectinina Rafinesque, 1815 Superfamily Leiopectinoide a Krasilova , 195 9 Family Leiopectinidae Krasilova, 1959 Genus Leiopecten Khalfin, 194 0 Order Pterioida Gray, 1847 Superfamily Pterioide a Gray, 1847 Family Pterineidae Miller, 187 7 Genus Pterinea Goldfuss, 182 6 Genus Tolmaia Williams , 190 8 Order Ostreoida Ferussac, 182 2 Family Rhombopteriidae Korobkov , 196 0 New genus , new species Johnston, 1993 Family Umburridae Johnston, 199 1 Genus Umburra Johnston , 199 1 Order Arcoida Stoliczka, 187 1 Superfamily Arcoide a Stoliczka , 187 1 Genus Alytodonta Cope , 199 7 Genus Freja Liljedahl , 198 4 Genus Trecanolia Ratte r & Cope, 199 8 Genus Catamarcaia Sanchez & Babin, 199 3 Family Glyptarcidae Cope, 1996 b Genus Glyptarca Hicks , 187 3 Family Parallelodontidae Dall , 189 8 Genus Cosmetodon Branson, 194 2
64
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
Genus C o f Johnsto n & Goodbod y (1988) , an d parivincular submerged , a s i n astartids . I n recognition o f these distinctions, Eodon is placed in the new crassatelloidean family Eodonidae . The presen t phylogeneti c reconstructio n con flicts wit h Cope' s (1997 ) hypothesi s tha t palaeo heterodonts gav e ris e t o pteriomorphian s an d heterodonts throug h arcoi d intermediates . Th e Heterodonta, a s represente d b y Eodon, i s a siste r group t o th e Redoniida e an d Nyassidae , wit h al l three taxa most likely evolving from cycloconchid like ancestor s independentl y o f th e Arcoida . I n order t o exclud e paraphyl y wit h th e Crassatel loidea, th e superfamil y Cycloconchoidea an d th e family Cycloconchida e ar e restricte d t o Cycloconcha, Actinodonta and Fortowensia among the genera presently studied . This analysis als o conflicts with Waller's (1990 , 1998) hypothesi s tha t th e Heteroconchi a shoul d include the Anomalodesmata. Waller (1998) cited a 3a/2/3b cor e denta l homolog y an d ligamen t nymphs a s apomorphies , separatin g th e Hetero conchia (inclusiv e o f th e Anomalodesmata ) fro m the Pteriomorphia . However , mos t earl y anomalo desmatans ar e edentulous , including som e modio morphids (e.g . Phorinoplax striata Johnston , 1993). Modiomorpha, regarde d a s an anomalodesmatan b y Walle r (1990) , Morri s e t al. (1991) , Johnston (1993) an d Fang (1998), has only crudely formed subumbona l hing e teet h tha t ar e no t obviously consisten t wit h a 3a/2/3 b denta l homology. Evidenc e i s observe d fo r a clos e relationship between the Anomalodesmata and the Pteriomorphia. Fo r thi s reason , th e superorde r Heteroconchia i s restricte d t o th e Palaeo heterodonta an d Heterodonta , exclusiv e o f th e Modiomorphidae an d probabl y mos t othe r anomalodesmatans. However , th e possibilit y tha t some non-modiomorphid s currentl y classifie d a s anomalodesmatans ar e actuall y heteroconch s cannot presently be excluded. It is also noteworthy that ligamen t nymph s ar e absen t i n man y earl y heteroconchs. Walle r (1998 , p . 34 ) acknowledge d their absenc e i n Copidens an d n o evidenc e i s observed fo r them in Actinodonta cuneata Philips, 1848 an d Cycloconcha milleri (Meek , 1871) . Th e latter specie s ha s a dorsall y open , simple , narro w ligament fossette with, at most, only a very weakly developed latera l groove fo r the lamellar ligament. The redoniids Redonia and Noradonta, the nyassids Nyassa an d Tanaodon, an d th e lucinoid s Babinka and Ilionia als o lac k distinc t nymphs . Thus , ligament nymph s ar e clearl y no t a synapomorph y for th e superorde r Heteroconchia , an d thes e structures hav e probabl y evolve d convergentl y in trigonioids, veneroid s and among later lucinoids. Waller (1998 ) appear s t o b e correc t i n regarding mytiloid s (sensu lato] a s near-basa l
pteriomorphians. I n fact , th e superfamil y Modiolopsoidea Fischer , 1887 , a s defined by Fang & Morri s (1997 ) t o includ e th e Modiolopsida e Fischer, Colpomyida e Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson and Modiolodontidae Fan g & Morris, appears to be paraphyletic wit h respec t t o th e remainin g Pteriomorphia. Also , th e famil y Modiolopsida e i s paraphyletic wit h respec t t o th e superfamil y Mytiloidea. Th e famil y Matheriida e Scarlat o & Starobogatov, 1979 , whic h Desbien s (1994 ) included i n th e superfamil y Cyrtodontoidea , i s apparently mor e closel y relate d t o th e Modiolopsidae an d Modiolodontida e tha n t o th e Cyrtodontidae. Within the order Cyrtodontoida , th e superfamily Cyrtodontoidea i s paraphyletic wit h respect t o the superfamily Falcatodontoidea Cope , and within the superfamily Arcoidea, th e family Frejidae Ratter & Cope (represente d b y Freja, Alytodonta an d Trecanolia) i s paraphyleti c wit h respec t t o Catamarcaia, th e famil y Glyptarcida e Cope , an d the family Parallelodontidae Dall . In orde r t o resolv e paraphyleti c relationship s within th e Pteriomorphia , i t i s recommende d tha t the superfamil y Modiolopsoide a i s abandone d relegating th e modiolopsid gener a t o basal plesio n status withi n th e superfamil y Mytiloidea ; relegating Ortonella to basal plesio n status within the Cyrtodontoida ; relegatin g th e freji d gener a t o basal plesion statu s withi n th e superfamil y Arcoidea; an d includin g th e famil y Glyptarcida e within th e superfamil y Arcoidea . Cop e (1997 ) suggested tha t Catamarcaia belong s i n th e Parallelodontidae. However , thi s placement woul d make th e Parallelodontida e paraphyleti c wit h respect t o th e Glyptarcidae . Th e presen t analysi s supports th e suggestio n b y Sanche z (1995 ) tha t Catamarcaia i s basal t o th e Parallelodontidae, bu t also that Catamarcaia is basal to the Glyptarcidae. Therefore, Catamarcaia i s her e place d i n th e superfamily Arcoidea as an isolated plesion basal to both the Parallelodontidae an d Glyptarcidae . The genu s Myodakryotus Tunniclif f wa s regarded b y Tunniclif f (1987 ) an d Pojet a & Runnegar (1985 ; a s Prolobella) a s a possible lin k between th e familie s Cyrtodontida e an d Limidae . Pojeta & Runnegar (1985) place d thi s genus in the Limidae, bu t Tunniclif f (1987 ) assigne d i t t o th e family Myodakryotidae. The present study suggests a basa l relationshi p wit h bot h th e superfamil y Limoidea an d superfamil y Leiopectinoidea . Therefore, th e Myodakryotidae , th e superfamil y Limoidea, the superfamily Leiopectinoidea an d the various other pectinoid superfamilie s ar e placed i n the orde r Pectinoida . Withi n thi s order , th e suborders Limin a Rafinesqu e an d Pectinin a Rafinesque ar e recognized. The present study confirms that the Ostreoida are
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N
more closel y relate d t o th e Pterioid a tha n t o th e Pectinoida. Thi s relationshi p i s als o compatibl e with dat a o f shel l microstructur e (Carte r 1990 ; McRoberts & Carter 1994) and DNA (Campbell et al. 1998) . Th e majo r anatomica l an d shel l micro structural features reportedly linking ostreoids with pectinoids (Walle r 1998) , suc h a s tentacl e grad e and calciti c foliate d structure , ar e eithe r plesio morphic or convergent. Umburra apparentl y bridges th e morphologica l gap betwee n th e earl y ostreoi d famil y Rhom bopteriidae and the order Arcoida. This placement is compatibl e wit h th e suggestio n b y Johnsto n (1991) tha t Umburra i s closel y relate d t o th e Rhombopteriidae, bu t i t contradict s Johnston' s hypothesis tha t Umburra i s basa l t o th e Rhom bopteriidae, Pterineida e an d Pectinoida . Th e present analysi s suggest s placemen t o f th e famil y Umburridae betwee n th e order s Ostreoid a an d Arcoida. Johnston (1991 ) an d Walle r (1998 ) define d th e Eupteriomorphia o f Bos s (1982 ) t o includ e th e family Umburridae , th e orde r Pterioid a an d th e order Ostreoida , th e latte r containin g both oyster s and scallops. The y also regarded arcoids, ambonychiids an d limids a s basal to the Eupteriomorphia . According t o th e presen t analysis , arcoid s ar e derived, rathe r tha n basal , relativ e t o th e Pectinoida, Pterioid a an d Ostreoid a a s presentl y defined. Consequently , any phylogenetic definition of the Eupteriomorphia that includes the latter three orders must also include the Arcoida. It is therefore recommended tha t th e nam e Eupteriomorphi a b e abandoned. Th e positio n o f th e Arcoid a i n Fig. 4 contradicts mos t current hypotheses fo r the origi n of this group. It suggests that arcoids evolved fro m left-right symmetrica l relative s o f rhombopteriid s rather tha n fro m cyrtodontid s o r actinodonts . Verification o f mineralogica l dat a fo r rhom bopteriids, umburrids , actinodont s an d earl y arcoids, muc h o f whic h i s presentl y tentative , should help resolve this issue. It may be noted, in this regard, that irreversibly polarizin g oute r layer calcite (characte r 90) , a s suggeste d b y Carte r (1980), reduced the proportion of clades supportin g many o f the node s i n th e majorit y rul e consensu s tree, but resulted in no change in the topology of the Pteriomorphia. Thi s polarizatio n adde d two steps , i.e. replacin g th e appearanc e o f calcite a t node 1 6 and it s secondar y los s a t node 2 1 (Arcoida) , wit h the appearanc e o f calcit e a t node s 26 , 28 , 2 9 an d taxon 60. The taxonomic revisions suggested by the present phylogeneti c analysi s ar e summarize d i n Table 2. This researc h wa s supporte d b y th e Natio n Scienc e Foundation (NS F GB36048). Th e Microstructure data for the Nyassidae are based o n a paper in preparation b y the senior author an d Dr P. A. Johnson.
65
Appendix 1 : Species analysed 1. Clas s Monoplacophora , famil y Stenothecidae : Watsonella crossbyi Grabau , 1900 , Lowe r Cambrian , Siberian Platform . 2 . Clas s Monoplacophora , famil y Stenothecidae: Anabarella plana Vostokova, 1962, Lower Cambrian, Siberia n Platform . 3 . Class Monoplacophora , family uncertain: Pseudomyona queenslandica (Runnegar & Jell, 1976) , Middle Cambrian , Queensland , Australia . 4. Clas s Rostroconchia , orde r Ribeirioida , famil y Ribeiriidae: Ribeiria junior Runnegar , 1996 , Middl e Cambrian, Queensland , Australi a [muscl e scar s based on Ribeiria lucan (Walcott , 1924) , Lowe r Ordovician , Canada]. CLAS S BIVALVIA : 5 . Tuarangia gravgaerdensis Berg-Madsen , 1987 , Middl e Cambrian , Denmark. 6 . Pojetaia runnegari Jell , 1980 , Lowe r Cambrian, Sout h Australi a an d Ne w Sout h Wales , Australia. 7 . Fordilla troyensis Barrande , 1881 , Lowe r Cambrian, Greenland . 8 . Tironucula jugata Morri s & Fortey, 1976 , Lowe r Ordovician , Spitsbergen . 9 . Praenucula faba Liljedahl , 1994 , Uppe r Silurian , Gotland. 10 . Nuculoidea pinguis (Lindstrom , 1880) , Upper Silurian , Wenlock , Gotland . 11 . Cardiolaria beirensis (Sharpe , 1853) , Middl e Ordovician , Spain . 12 . Praeleda subtilis Cope, 1999 , Middle Ordovician , Wales. 13. Eritropisperegrinata Cope , 1999, Middle Ordovician, Wales. 14 . Ekstadia tricarinata Soot-Ryen , 1964 , Uppe r Silurian, Gotland. 15 . Nuculites oblongatus Conrad 1841 , Middle Devonian , Ne w York . 16 . Palaeoneilo fecunda (Hall, 1862) , Uppe r Ordovician , Dubuque , Iowa . 17 . Ctenodonta tennesseensis Pojeta , 1988 , Middl e Ordovician, Tennessee . 18 . Tancrediopsis gotlandica (Soot-Ryen, 1964) , Upper Silurian, Gotland. 19 . Acharax (Nacrosolemyd) trapezoides (Meek , 1874) , Uppe r Carboniferous, easter n Kentucky . 20. Redonia bohemica Barrande, 1881 , Middl e Ordovician , Bohemia , Czec h Republic. 21 . Thoralia languedociana (Thoral , 1935) , Lower Ordovician, souther n France. 22. Adult Lyrodesma majus (Ulrich , 1894) , Ordovician , Ohio . 23 . Juvenil e Lyrodesma (Ulrich , 1894) , a s i n adul t Lyrodesma majus except fo r juvenil e hing e an d ligamen t base d o n Lyrodesma sp . from Lowe r Silurian o f Ohio (Harriso n & Harrison, 1975 , pi . 2 , fig s 14-17) . 24 . Lyrodesma sp. , Middle Ordovician , Britis h Columbia , fro m Johnsto n (1996, pi . 3 , fig s 1-5) . 25 . Silurozodus gotlandicus Liljedahl, 1992 , Uppe r Silurian , Gotland . 26 . Cycloconcha mediocardinalis Miller , 1874 , Uppe r Ordovician, Ohio. 27 . Fortowensia grandis Cope, 1996£> , Lower Ordovician, Arenig , Sout h Wales. 28. Actinodonta cuneata Philips , 1848 , Lowe r Silurian , Llandovery , Wales. 29 . Nyassa dorsata (Goldfuss , 1840) , Middl e Devonian, Hamilto n Group , Ne w York . 30 . Tanaodon louderbacki Kirk , 1927 , Middl e Devonian , Sichua n Province, China . 31 . Noradonta shergoldi Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 1977 , Ordovician , Georgin a Basin , Australia. 32 . Ne w genu s A o f Johnsto n & Goodbod y (1988), Middle Devonian, Melville Island, Arctic Canada. 33. Ne w genu s B o f Johnsto n & Goodbod y (1988) , Middle Devonian , Melvill e Island , Arcti c Canada . 34 . Montanaria aff . M. honguedoensis Desbiens , 1994 , Lower Devonian , Emsian , Gaspe , Quebec , Canada . 35 . Copidens browni Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson , 1977 , Ordovician, Australia. 36. Ananterodonta oretanica Babin & Gutierrez-Marco , 1985 , Middl e Ordovician , Llanvirn ,
66
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
Spain. 37 . Babinka prima Barrande , 1881 , Lowe r Ordovician, Europe . 38 . Ilionia prisca (Hisinger , 1837) , Upper Silurian , Ludlow , Gotland . 39 . Ne w genu s C o f Johnston & Goodbod y (1988) , Middl e Devonian , Melville Island , Arcti c Canada . 40 . Eodon tenuistriata (Hall, 1870) , Middl e Devonian , Mosco w Shale , Morrisville, Ne w York . 41 . Modiomorpha concentrica (Conrad, 1838), Middle Devonian, Chanango Valley, New York. 42 . Evyana baltica (Liljedahl , 1989) , Uppe r Silurian, Wenlock , Gotland . 43 . Colpomya hugini Liljedahl, 1994 , Upper Silurian , Wenlock , Gotland . 44 . Modiolopsis modiolaris (Conrad , 1838) , Uppe r Ordovician, Ne w Yor k State . 45 . Whiteavesia cincinnatiensis (Hal l & Whitfield , 1875) , Uppe r Ordovician, Kentucky . 46 . Modiolus meeki (Evan s & Shumard, 1857) , Uppe r Cretaceous , Montana . 47 . Matheria tener Billings , 1858 , Middl e o r Uppe r Ordovician, Quebec, Canada; ligament based on Matheria rugosa Ulrich , 1892 , Middl e o r Uppe r Ordovician , Minnesota. 48. Metapadia matapediensis Desbiens , 1994, Lower Devonian , Canada . 49 . Modiolodon oviformis (Ulrich, 1890) , Middl e o r Uppe r Ordovician , Trenton , Kentucky. 50. Cyrtodonta saffordi (Hall , 1859), Middle or Upper Ordovician , Nashville , Tennessee . 51 . Ortonella hainesi (Miller , 1874) , Uppe r Ordovician , easter n Nort h America. 52 . Falcatodonta costata Cope , 1996 , Lower Ordovician, Arenig , Sout h Wales . 53 . Ambonychia radiata Hall , 1847 , Upper Ordovician , Ne w Yor k an d Kentucky. 54 . Septimyalina perattenuata (Mee k & Hayden, 1858) , Uppe r Carboniferous , Kentucky . 55 . Myodakryotus deigryn Tunnicliff , 1987 , Uppe r Ordovician, Wales . 56 . Palaeolima retifera (Shumard , 1858), Uppe r Carboniferous , Kentucky . 57 . Leiopecten praerectangularis Krasilova , 1959 , Lowe r Devonian , Kazakhstan. 58 . Pterinea laevis Goldfuss , 1826 , Lower Devonian, Germany . 59 . Tolmaia erugisulca Johnston , 1993, Lowe r Devonian , southeas t Australia . 60 . Rhombopteriid new genus and species of Johnston (1993, fig. 16) , Lowe r Devonian , southeas t Australia . 61 . Umburra cinefacta Johnston , 1991 , Uppe r Silurian , Wenlock, New South Wales, Australia. 62. Frejafecunda Liljedahl, 19840 , Upper Silurian, Gotland. 63. Alytodonta gibbosa Cope , 1997 , Lowe r Silurian , Scotland . 64 . Trecanolia acincta Ratter & Cope, 1998 , Upper Silurian , Wenlock, Sout h Wales . 65 . Catamarcaia chaschuilensis (Acenolaza & Toselli , 1977) , Lowe r Ordovician , Argentina. 66 . Cosmetodon obsoletus (Meek , 1871) , Upper Carboniferous , Kentucky. 67 . Glyptarca serrata Cope, 1996& , Lower Ordovician (Arenig) , South Wales.
Appendix 2: Character definition s 1. Arch of LV ventral hinge margin: 1, straight; 2, weak to medium; 4, strong; 5, no hinge or pseudohinge. 2 . LV convexity: 1 , strong; 2, moderate; 3, weak. 3. Extension of LV posterior auricle beyond sinus: 1, no LV posterior auricle; 2 , sligh t wit h angula r termination ; 3 , moderat e with angula r termination; 5, angula r termination but n o posterior extension . 4. LV posterior auricle: 1, absent; 2, present. 5 . L V posterior auricula r sinus : 1 , absent; 2 , present. 6 . Extensio n o f L V anterio r auricl e beyon d sinus: 1, no LV anterior auricle; 3, moderate with angular termination; 5, with angular termination but no extension.
7. LV anterior auricle : 1 , absent; 2, present. 8. Shape of RV anterio r auricle : A , n o R V anterio r auricle ; no t secondarily absent ; B , dorsa l margi n dip s towar d th e anterior; C, anterior margin nearly straight and vertical; D, anterior margi n nearl y straigh t bu t dippin g towar d th e posterior; E , anterio r margi n i s nearl y straigh t antero ventrally an d < 45 ° t o hinge axis ; dippin g towar d th e posterior; wit h an angular to slightly rounded shoulder . 9. Shape of LV posterior auricle: 1 , primitively absen t or none o f th e following ; 2 , straight , horizontal ; 3 , slope s upward posteriorly ; 4 , straight ; slope s downwar d posteriorly; 5 . curves downward posteriorly. 10 . Relative length o f L V anterior an d posterio r auricles : 1 , bot h primitively absent ; 2 , equal ; 3 , anterio r longer , posterio r shorter o r absent ; 4, posterio r longer , anterio r shorte r o r absent. 11. RV byssal sinus: 1 , absent; 2, present. 12 . LV umbonal elevation : 1 , absent o r slight ; 3 , moderate ; 4 , strong. 13. LV posterior rostrateness : 1 , absent; 2, slight to moderate ; 3 , strong . 14 . L V elongatio n (L/H) : 1 , intermediate (1.25-2.00) ; 3 , lon g ( > 2.00); 5 , shor t (< 1.25) . 15 . L V posteroventra l shel l margin : 1 , rounded, ova l o r slightl y truncat e withou t stron g inflection; 2 , like 1 but with strong inflectio n but neithe r triangular no r rectangular; 3, triangular posteroventrally; 4, triangula r medioposteriorly ; 5 . rectangular . 16 . L V obliquity (predominan t growt h gradien t relativ e t o beak an d hing e axis) : 1 , equilateral ; 2 , slightl y posteroventral; 3 , slightl y anteroventral ; 4 , strongl y anterior; 5 , strongly posterior; 6 , strongly posteroventral . 17. Shap e o f anterio r shel l margin : Beak terminal anterior, n o anterior auricle: G , bea k anterio r t o anteroventral aperture, the latter oriented a t high angle to length axi s o f aperture . 2 , anterio r obsolescen t an d anterior margi n belo w th e byssa l sinus , i f th e latte r i s present, i s strongl y incline d towar d th e posterior ; E , anterior obsolescent, anterior margin below byssal sinus, if the latter i s present, i s broadly ovat e to nearly straigh t and nearly perpendicular t o hinge axis; B, anterior margin slopes posteriorl y an d is broadl y ovate , withou t anterior auricle. Beak anterior bu t no t terminal, n o anterior auricle: 1 , entire anterior is discoidal with, at most, a very slight indentation anterior to beaks; 4, shallow but distinct indentation o r n o indentatio n anterio r t o th e beaks , anterior shel l margi n i s convex wit h a tight curvatur e in comparison wit h th e maximu m posterio r heigh t o f th e shell an d th e anteroventra l margi n i s broadl y ovat e t o straight; 5 , dorsa l anterio r margi n broadl y concav e immediately anterior to beaks and convex anteroventrally; 6, dorsoanterior margi n i s distinctl y indente d anterio r t o beaks, not broadly concave; anterior margin is discoidal to moderately ovate to slightl y triangular, with a convexity that i s nearl y a s wid e a s th e maximu m posterio r shel l height; anterio r margi n is not greatly extende d anteriorl y nor i s i t triangular ; anterio r passe s int o moderatel y t o broadly ovat e margi n anter o ventrally; 7 , presenc e o r absence of indentation immediately anterio r to beak, with shell anterior elongated an d with nearly horizontal dorsal and ventra l areas, an d with discoida l t o moderately ova l anteriormost termination ; A , n o indentatio n anterio r t o beaks, anterio r margi n ver y broadl y ovat e an d nearl y vertical; C, anterior margin slopes dorsally , not forming a straight-edged auricle , an d the n swing s sharpl y downwards to make a broadly ovate to discoidal anterior ; H, shallow, distinct indentation or no indentation anterio r
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N
to beaks, anterio r margi n smoothl y an d broadly conve x anterodorsally bu t slightl y straigh t anteroventrally , an d shell i s no t elongat e enoug h t o b e modioliform . Beak anterior bu t no t terminal, with anterior auricle: 3 , anterior margi n ventral to the byssal sinus (if the latter i s present) i s broadl y ovat e t o nearl y straigh t an d posteroventrally inclined ; D , anterio r margi n belo w auricle an d auricula r sinu s (i f th e latte r i s present ) i s broadly ovat e o r straigh t an d nearl y perpendicula r o r anteriorly slightl y incline d t o hing e axis ; F , anterio r margin below auricl e an d auricula r sinus (if the latte r i s present) i s moderatel y ovat e t o discoida l an d anteriorl y inclined. Beak medial o r posterior: 8 , a t mos t a sligh t indentation anterio r t o beak s an d anterio r margi n i s narrowly ovat e to smoothl y triangular but not extremel y elongated, with no anterior auricle; 0, as in option 8, but with distinc t indentatio n anterio r t o beaks ; K , anterio r slightly truncate ; L , sligh t bu t distinc t indentatio n immediately anterio r t o beaks , anterio r margi n nearl y discoidal; P, at most a slight indentation anterior to beaks; anterior greatly elongated wit h nearly parallel dorsa l and ventral margins . 18 . Slop e o f L V sharpl y angula r dorsoanterior shell margin relative to hinge axis (usin g line draw n fro m th e anteriormos t hing e tangen t t o anteroventral shel l margin) : 0 , n o sharpl y angula r dorsoanterior shel l margin ; 1 , nearl y righ t angle ; 2 , slightly < 90° between ligament axis and tangent, angled posteriorly; 5 , > 90° between ligamen t axi s and tangent, angled anteriorly ; 6 , hinge , pseudohinge , ligamen t an d pseudoligament al l absent . 19 . L V adul t ventra l shel l shape: 1, nearly discoidal without posteroventral sinus; 2, moderately t o broadl y ovat e o r straight , moderatel y t o slightly elongate , withou t a media l ventra l o r posteroventral sinus ; 4 , no t elongate , anteroventrall y broadly ovate , nearl y straight , o r straight , wit h posteroventral sinus ; 6 , anteroventrall y concav e an d posteroventrally spatulate ; 7, anteriorly nearly straight or convex, moderatel y elongat e t o elongate , wit h media l ventral or posteroventral sinus ; 8, very elongate, virtually straight o r onl y slightl y convex , withou t media l o r posteroventral sinus. 20. Permanent anterior shell gape: 1, absent; 2 , anter o ventral gap e obliqu e t o hinge axi s in bivalved shell ; 4 , fa r anterio r gap e i n bivalve d shell ; 6 , anterior t o anteroventra l gap e i n univalve d shell ; 7 , anterior gap e closabl e b y flexin g th e shel l margin s an d periostracum. 21 . Permanen t posterio r shel l gape : 1 , absent; 6, present. 22. Posteroventral sinus: 1, absent; 2, present. 23 . L V lunule : 1 , absen t bu t hing e o r pseudohinge present ; 2 , wea k an d shallow ; 5 , sharpl y defined, ver y deep; 6 , no hinge or pseudohinge (Ribeiria lucan). 24 . L V escutcheon : 1 , absen t bu t hing e o r pseudohinge present; 2, weakly developed; 4, no hinge or pseudohinge. 25 . Topograph y o f L V lunule: 1 , lunul e absent bu t hing e o r pseudohing e present . 2 , prominen t growth line s anterio r t o ligamen t are a o n nearl y commarginal, deeply inset lunular surface or on the hinge margin immediatel y ventra l t o beaks ; 4 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge; 5 , smooth . 26 . L V commissural shelf : 1 , absent; 2 , present. 27 . Shel l morphologi c evidenc e fo r branchitellum: 1 , no ; 2 , yes . 28 : Valv e dow n i n pleurothetic taxa : 1 , non-pleurothetic; 2 , L V down ; 4 , either valve down indifferently. 29 . LV beak position: 2, posterior; 3 , medial ; 4 , anterio r bu t no t terminal ; 5 , terminal anterior. 30. Beaks are posteriorly situated : 1 ,
67
no; 2 , yes. 31. Shel l valv e equality : 1 , equivalve; 2 , RV slightly large r o r mor e convex ; 4 , L V slightly large r o r more convex; 5, LV much larger o r more convex ; 6 , n o hinge o r pseudohinge. 32 . Genera l tren d of shell valv e equality: 1 , equivalve; 2 , LV larger o r mor e convex ; 3 , RV larger or more convex; 4, no hinge and pseudohinge. 33. Media l subumbona l septu m or buttress: 1 , absent but a hinge or pseudohinge present; 3, prominent septum deep in umbonal cavity; 4, no hinge or pseudohinge; bu t septum o r pegm a possibl y present . 34 . Umbonal anteroventral buttres s o r umbonal-anteroventra l deck: 1 , absent but hinge or pseudohinge present; 2, nonauricular, ridge-lik e buttress , passin g jus t posterio r t o anterior adducto r scar , possibly continuou s with anterior hinge; 3, buttress passing from hinge line to anteroventra l margin on proximal margin of auricle; 5, anterior pegmalike structur e bu t n o tru e pegma ; 6 , tru e pegma . 35 . Predominant adult beak direction : 1 , prosogyrate with prodissoconch; 2 , orthogyrat e wit h prodissoconch ; 3 , opisthogyrate with prodissoconch; 4 , protoconch present . 36. Distinctive shel l shapes: 0, none of the following; A, mytiliform o r modioliform ; B , Ambonychiaform-, C , Pterineaform; D , Silurozodus-gotlandicusform; E , Arcaform; F , Falcatodontaform', G , Cyrtodontaform', H , Fordillaform', I , Umburraform', J , Nyassaform', K , Eodoniform', L , Solemyaform o r nearly Solemyaform', M , Palaeoneiloform; N , Pinnaform; P , Crassatellaform', Q , Redoniaform', R , Leiopecteniform, Leiopectinellaform, o r Pecteniform; S , Pholadomyaform; T , Orthonotaform', U , Nuculoideaform', 1 , Pojetaiaform', 2 , Anabarellaform', 3 , Nuculaform-, 4 , Permophoriform ; 5 , Matheriaform; 1, Cycloconchaform; 8 , Limaform; 9 , GryphaeaformLophaform. 37 . Distinctiv e prosopon : 1 , neither o f th e following; 2 , edmondii d typ e sharpl y reflecte d commarginal flanges ; 3 , lat e ontogeneti c chang e fro m regular commargina l rib s t o irregula r growt h lines . 38 . Adult L V antimargina l prosopon : 1 , absent ; 2 , fine , regular, closel y space d costa e o r costellae ; 3 , strong , regular, closel y t o medium-space d costa e o r plicae ; 5 , very fine, regular, closely spaced lineations not associated with margina l macrocrenulations ; 9 , largel y smoot h bu t with some radial costellae anteriorly and/o r posteriorly; B, very fine , irregula r radial striae . 39 . Adul t L V ranks o f antimarginal prosopon : 1 , absent; 2 , on e siz e rank ; 3 , more tha n on e siz e rank . 40 . Adul t R V antimargina l prosopon: 1 , absent ; 2 , fine , regular , closel y space d costae o r costellae ; 3 , strong , regular , clos e t o mediu m spaced costa e o r plicae ; 5 , ver y fine , regular , closel y spaced lineation s no t associate d wit h margina l macrocrenulations; 6 , fine, regular , widel y spaced costa e or costellae ; 9 , radia l costella e onl y anteriorl y and/o r posteriorly; B , ver y fine , irregula r radia l striae . 41 . Anterior L V peda l retractor/levato r muscl e sca r position: 1 , separat e fro m adductor ; 2 , jus t touchin g adductor dorsall y o r dorsoposteriorly ; 3 , overlappin g adductor; 6 , just touchin g adducto r posteroventrally ; 7 , primitively no anterior adductor but anterior lef t an d right pedal retractors present. 42. Special support for anterior pedal retractor : 1 , absent; 4 , pegma-lik e shelf ; 5 , tru e pegma. 43. Posterior LV pedal peda l retractor/levato r position: 1 , separat e fro m adducto r an d dorsa l o r dorsoanterior t o it; 2, just touching adductor and dorsal or dorsoanterior t o it ; 3 , overlappin g adducto r an d dorsomedial o r dorsoanterio r t o it ; 4 , confluen t wit h
68
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
adductor sca r an d dorsomedia l o r dorsoanterio r t o it , o r secondarily absent ; 8 , n o adducto r bu t posterio r peda l retractors present ; 9 , n o adducto r bu t media n posterio r pedal retracto r present . 44 . Junctio n o f L V pallial lin e and posterio r adducto r muscl e scar : 1 , midventral t o anteroventral edg e o f adductor; 2 , posteroventral edg e o f adductor; 3 , posterio r edg e o f adductor ; 4 , adducto r i s entirely interio r t o trend of the pallial lin e but close t o it; 7, primitivel y n o posterio r adductor ; 8 , primitively onl y one adductor. 45. Position o f LV posterior adductor : 1 , just belo w hinge ; 2 , moderatel y ventra l an d posterior t o hinge; 6, primitively no posterior adductor; 7, primitively only one adductor. 46. Buttress or deck for LV posterior adductor: 1 , absen t o r adducto r secondaril y reduced ; 2 , distinct ridg e o r non-auricula r deck ; 3 , primitivel y n o adductors; 4 , primitivel y onl y on e adductor ; 5 , radial , platform-like thickenin g of shel l alon g muscle migration pathway. 47 . Shap e o f L V posterior adducto r scar : 1 , round t o subcircular ; 2 , elliptica l t o subtrapezoida l with length axi s nearl y paralle l o r onl y slightl y obliqu e t o nearest shel l margin ; 3 , subtriangular ; 5 , primitivel y n o adductors; 6, primitively onl y one adductor. 48. Positio n of LV anterior adducto r (inferre d ancestra l position if secondarily reduced) : 1 , o n hing e plat e o r cuttin g int o hinge plat e o r adducto r deck ; 2 , of f hing e plate ; 4 , primitively n o adductors ; 5 , primitivel y onl y on e adductor. 49. LV anterior adductor buttress: 1 , adductor present bu t no t buttressed , o r sligh t buttres s lack s a posterior slop e break ; 3 , buttres s wit h distinc t posterio r slope break ; 4 , adducto r supporte d b y hing e plate ; 5 , adductor secondaril y reduce d an d ther e i s n o trac e o f a former supportin g buttres s o r deck ; 7 , primitivel y n o anterior adductor ; 8 , primitivel y onl y on e adductor . 50 . Shape o f LV anterior adductor : 2 , point o f attachment; 3, round to subcircular ; 4 , elliptica l t o subtrapezoidal ; 5 , subtriangular; 6 , elongate ; 7 , primitivel y n o anterio r adductor; 8 , primitively onl y on e adductor . 51 . Relativ e size o f adducto r scars : 1 , anterio r on e secondaril y reduced; 2, posterior one larger by at least 100% ; 3, nearly isomyarian; 4 , anterio r muc h larger ; 5 , primitivel y n o adductors; 6 , primitivel y onl y on e adductor . 52 : Gil l retractor, suspenso r and mantle bloo d vesse l scars : 1 , none apparent ; 2 , lin e o f scar s proximall y restricted , straight, extending from umbona l cavity posteroventrally , below posterior adductor ; Quenstedt scar may or may not be differentiated ; ma y b e expresse d a s a ridg e o r a s a distinct brea k i n th e slop e o f th e shel l interior ; 3 , proximally dorsoventra l and distall y posteriorl y curvin g scar, usually represented b y a groove on the shell interior ; Quenstedt sca r ma y o r ma y no t b e differentiated ; rarel y expressed a s th e extensio n o f a n umbona l septu m extending dorsoventrall y fro m th e media l o r anterio r umbonal cavity , the n curvin g slightl y towar d th e posterior; no t a n anterio r adducto r buttress ; 4 , anterior-posterior, nearl y horizonta l lin e o f scar s o n flanks o f umbona l shel l interior . 53 . Umbona l t o posteroventral gill wheal: 1 , absent; 2, present ( 2 or 3 in preceding category) . 54. Anterior pallial , protracto r o r other muscle scar not dorsa l t o anterior adductor: 1, none evident; 3, single or multiple scars medioposterior or posteroventral t o anterio r adductor ; adjacen t t o anterio r adductor an d no t extendin g posteriorl y fro m th e pallia l line; 4 , single , discret e sca r a t junctio n o f anterio r adductor with anteroventral pallia l line ; 5 , primitively n o
anterior adducto r scar s an d n o anterio r pallia l line ; 6 , primitively n o anterio r adductor s bu t anterio r pallia l o r cephalic feedin g orga n retractor s present . 55 . Dorsa l accessory muscl e scar s (excludin g on e anterio r an d one posterio r peda l retracto r o r peda l levato r sca r closest t o eac h adducto r an d excludin g scar s o n ventral margi n o f a posterio r interna l ridge , score d elsewhere): 1 , absent; 2, only one or two closely spaced , medial subumbonal , insertin g o n surfac e othe r tha n posteroventral margin of hinge plate an d othe r than apex of umbona l cavity ; 3 , thre e o r more , subumbonal , inserting on concave interior surface , no t on ventral edge of a posterio r interna l ridg e an d no t onl y nea r anterio r adductor muscl e scar , o r betwee n umbona l cavit y an d posterior adductor ; or one or more scars between umbona l apex an d anterior peda l retractor , no t present posteriorl y except possibl y o n ventra l margi n o f posterio r interna l ridge or on ventral margin of posterior hing e plate; 5 , one or tw o closel y spaced , small , isolate d muscl e scar s just ventral to the hinge, between beak and posterior adductor , distinct fro m th e posterio r peda l retractor ; 6 , severa l small, closel y space d muscl e scar s jus t ventra l t o th e hinge, betwee n umbona l cavit y an d posterio r adductor , distinct fro m th e posterior peda l retractor ; 7, onl y one or two closely spaced scars at the far apex of umbonal cavity, excluding anterio r peda l retractor ; 8 , onl y on e o r tw o closely space d scar s o n ventra l edg e o r umbona l cavit y side of hinge plate, not at far apex of umbonal cavity. 56. Depth o f posterior pallia l sinus : 1 , absent; 2, shallow; 3, deep. 57 . Pallia l lin e structure : 1 , solid o r wit h small , closely space d scar s excep t possibl y discontinuou s a t anterodorsal an d posterodorsa l extremities ; 3 , entirel y broken; 4, entirely o f long, radial scars , no t a solid pallia l line wit h proxima l radia l extensions ; 5 , soli d anteriorly , broken posteriorly. 58 . Pallial lin e continuity: 1 , solid or consisting o f closel y spaced , smal l scar s (1 above) ; 2 , at least partiall y discontinuou s (3- 5 above) . 59 . Non-shel l marginal posterio r lateral o r pseudolateral teeth in LV or RV (excluding palaeotaxodon t teeth): 1 , absen t and none of the following; 2, only one suc h tooth i n either o r both valves , not mor e tha n one ; 3, two suc h teeth in on e or both valves , not more tha n two; 4, three o r more suc h teeth in either or both valves; 5, no hinge or pseudohinge . 60. Shap e o f non-palaeotaxodon t posterio r latera l o r pseudolateral toot h closes t t o subumbona l area : 1 , absent; non e o f th e following ; 3 , long , lamella r latera l tooth; 4 , lamella r toot h immediatel y posterio r t o a palaeotaxodont subumbona l tooth , derive d ontogenetically fro m palaeotaxodon t teeth ; 6 , no hinge or pseudohinge; 7 , short , nearl y horizontal , lamella r o r tabular tooth either separated from th e cardinal area by an edentulous gap , separate d fro m th e anterio r are a b y a n edentulous gap , o r adjacen t t o cardina l pseudotaxodont teeth wit h a distinctl y differen t orientatio n tha n th e lamellar/tabular tooth ; 8 , short , distinctl y posteriorl y dipping, lamella r o r tabula r toot h adjacen t t o similarl y posteriorly dippin g cardina l pseudotaxodon t teeth . 61. At least one posterior toot h no t reaching bea k in either or both valves , excludin g palaeotaxodon t an d pseudolateral teeth : 1 , no hinge or pseudohinge present; 2, on e an d onl y on e soli d lamella r o r tuberculifor m posterior latera l i n eithe r o r bot h valves ; no t mor e tha n one i n eithe r valve ; 4 , mor e tha n on e i n eithe r o r bot h valves, uppers en echelon close r t o beak; 5, more than one
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTION in either or both valves, not uniformly aligned en echelon, with wide edentulous gap from beak; 7, more than one in either o r both valves , lower s e n echelo n close r t o beak , and n o cardinolatera l no r transitiona l palaeotaxodont / lamellar tooth ; 8 , more than one in either o r both valves, lowers e n echelon close r t o beak; cardinolatera l present; A, n o hing e o r pseudohinge . 62 . Shap e o f stronges t posterior lateral, non-palaeotaxodont tooth: 1, does not apply; 3, strong, long, slender, lamellar; 4, strong but short and tabular or tuberculiform; 7, no hinge or pseudohinge. 63. More than one posterior latera l with lower teeth en echelon close r t o beak: 1 , no, but hinge or pseudohinge present; 2, yes; 3, no hinge or pseudohinge. 64. Posterior palaeotaxodont teeth , no t transitiona l t o lamellar : 1 , no, bu t hing e o r pseudohinge present; 2, yes, wit h littl e increase i n toot h siz e posteriorly ; 3 , yes , wit h grea t increase i n toot h siz e posteriorly ; 4 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge. 65. Distinctive posterio r hing e dentitions : 1, hinge or pseudohinge present but none of the following apply; 2 , lateral , pseudolatera l o r pseudotaxodon t teet h above separat e posterio r palaeotaxodon t o r pseudo taxodont teeth ; 3 , numerou s posterio r teet h dippin g towards posterior , increasin g i n numbe r ontogeneticall y by branchin g and/o r intercalation ; 5 , posterio r lamella r tooth wit h pseudotaxodon t branches , withou t accom panying separate pseudotaxodont or palaeotaxodont teeth; 6, n o hinge o r pseudohinge ; 8 , tw o lon g posterio r pseudolateral teeth , on e abov e th e other , immediatel y posterior t o subumbona l palaeotaxodon t teeth . 66 . Glyptarcid-type hing e (subumbona l pseudotaxodon t teeth represent subdivision s of posterior pseudolatera l tooth, dorsa l an d posterio r t o othe r subumbona l pseudotaxodont teeth) : 1 , neithe r o f th e following ; 5 , primitively n o hing e o r pseudohinge ; 7 , present . 67 . Hinge o r pseudohing e subumbonall y edentulous : ? , yes, bu t associate d lif e habi t an d biomechanica l factor s unknown; 1 , no; 2, yes an d associated with a gasket-like, periostracal margin ; 3, hinge or pseudohinge present and ancestral edentulou s conditio n i s retaine d (Watsonella, Pseudomyona); 5 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge ; 6 , yes , associated wit h wide , flexible , periostraca l margins ; 7 , yes, associate d wit h rigi d shel l margin s an d shallo w burrowing o r semi-infauna l lif e habits , with subumbonal edentuly apparentl y a n artifac t o f posterio r shif t i n th e umbones rathe r tha n actua l toot h reduction ; 8 , yes , associated wit h deep burrowin g habits an d extensio n of rigid shel l margin s by a thin periostracu m studde d with aragonitic spike s o r granules . 68 . Subumbona l pseudotaxodonty, palaeotaxodont y o r pretaxodonty: 1 , hinge o r pseudohing e present but non e of th e followin g apply; 2 , pseudotaxodon t i n on e row , teet h paralle l o r ventrally divergent , possibl y ventrall y bifid ; 3 , pseudotaxodont i n tw o rows , on e ove r th e other ; 4 , palaeotaxodont; 5 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge ; 6 , pseudotaxodont i n on e row , teeth dorsall y divergent ; 7, pretaxodont. 69 . Subumbona l o r anterio r toot h ro w relationship wit h posterio r palaeotaxodon t o r pseudotaxodont toot h row : 1 , hing e o r pseudohing e present bu t no t exclusivel y palaeotaxodon t no r exclusively pseudotaxodont ; 2 , toot h row s i n line ; 3 , posterior ro w overlap s anterio r row ; 4 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge. 70 . Subumbona l dentitio n bulbou s o r tuberculiform, excludin g indistinc t teet h a s i n Modiomorpha an d Ambonychia: 1 , no , bu t hing e o r
69
pseudohinge present ; 2 , yes ; 3 , primitivel y n o hing e o r pseudohinge. 71 . An y non-palaeotaxodont , non pretaxodont subumbona l teeth , includin g indistinc t teeth a s i n Fordilla, Modiomorpha, an d Ambonychia, but excludin g crura l teeth : 1 , absen t bu t hing e o r pseudohinge present ; 2 , present ; 3 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge. 72 . Distinctiv e cardinal-subumbona l dentitions: 0 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge ; 1 , hing e o r pseudohinge presen t bu t non e of the followin g apply ; 2, no anterio r hing e teeth , bu t a t leas t thre e non-bulbous , short subumbonal teeth, and anteriormost dips towards the posterior o r is orthocline; 3, strongly posteriorly concave , distinct, non-taxodont , anterio r subumbona l toot h i n either valve ; 5 , no anterio r hing e teet h bu t a t least thre e non-bulbous, shor t subumbona l teeth , deepl y grooved , and tightl y fan-like , wit h anterio r toot h dippin g toward s the anterior ; A, dorsall y divergen t teeth, subumbona l or anterior an d posterior t o subumbona l area, possibly wit h an edentulous ga p below the beak; C, overlap of anterior palaeotaxodont o r pseudotaxodon t dentitio n b y media l and posterior palaeotaxodont dentition; D, pretaxodont; E, overlap o f media l pseudotaxodon t o r transitiona l pseudotaxodont/lamellar dentitio n b y posterio r pseudo taxodont o r transitiona l pseudotaxodont/lamella r dentition. 73 . Anterior , non-palaeotaxodont , pseudo lateral bu t not anterior latera l teet h i n either o r bot h valves (excludin g crura) . 1 , hing e o r pseudohing e present bu t doe s no t apply ; 2 , on e an d onl y on e solid , long, pseudolateral anterio r tooth in either or both valves; not more than one; 4, more than one solid, long , anterio r pseudolateral tooth in either or both valves; 6, no hinge or pseudohinge. 74 . A t leas t on e adul t anterio r non palaeotaxodont, non-pseudotaxodont , latera l toot h (i.e. no t reachin g beak ) i n eithe r o r bot h valves , excluding crura , bu t includin g small , tuberculifor m teeth: 1 , no, but hinge or pseudohinge is present; 5, more than on e suc h tooth i n a t least on e valve , not uniformly aligned en echelon, wit h wide edentulous ga p to beak; 6 , more tha n on e suc h toot h i n a t leas t on e valve , no t necessarily aligned en echelon, with pseudotaxodont teeth filling ga p to beak; 7, more than one such tooth in at least one valve , lower s e n echelo n close r t o beak ; 8 , on e o r more transitional palaeotaxodont-pseudotaxodont teet h in either o r bot h valves , wit h palaeotaxodon t o r pseudotaxodont teet h fillin g ga p to beak; 0 , n o hinge o r pseudohinge. 75 . Anterio r latera l o r pseudolateral , non-pseudotaxodont, non-palaeotaxodont tooth in LV or RV (minute, tuberculiform teeth are scored as 1 and 2) (this excludes mytili d anterior shell marginal teeth) : 1, absent o r doe s no t appl y but hing e o r pseudohing e i s present; 2 , only on e suc h anterior toot h i n either o r both valves; not more than one; 3 , two suc h teeth i n either o r both valves ; not mor e tha n two ; 4 , thre e o r mor e suc h teeth in either or both valves; 5, no hinge or pseudohinge. 76. Relationship o f strongest non-shel l marginal , non palaeotaxodont, non-pseudotaxodont, anterior latera l or pseudolatera l toot h wit h anterio r cardinal subumbonal tooth: 1, no such anterior tooth, but hinge or pseudohinge present ; 2 , continuou s wit h cardinal subumbonal tooth; 3 , separate fro m cardinal-subumbona l tooth; 4 , separate d fro m cardinal-subumbona l tooth b y palaeotaxodont teeth ; 5 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge . 77 . Strongest non-shel l marginal , anterio r latera l o r pseudolateral, non-palaeotaxodon t tooth: 1, none of the
70
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
following; 2, very small, short, possibly tuberculiform and impersistent; 3 , strong , long , slende r lamellar ; 4 , stron g but short and tabular; 5, no hinge or pseudohinge; 6, short, derived ontogeneticall y fro m ar m o f anterior , concavodont tooth. 78. Distinctive hinges : 0 , none of the following; 1 , evyanid-type ; 2 , cyrtodont-type ; 3 , rhombopteriid-umburrid-type; 4 , modiomorphid-type ; 5 , thoraliid-type; 6 , gryphaeid-ostreid-type; 7 , right pivotal cardinal-subumbonal toot h nearl y paralle l wit h dorsoanterior shel l margin ; 8 , colpomyid-type ; 9 , subumbonal teet h pseudotaxodon t an d nearl y vertica l o r dorsally divergent in at least one valve; A, only one or two anterior and posterior elongat e hinge teeth approximating the subumbona l area without strong, intervening teeth in adult o r earl y juvenil e shell ; B , montanariid-type ; C , babinkid-type; D , redoniid-type ; F , nyassid-type ; G , cycloconchid-type; H , secondaril y edentulou s fro m immediate palaeotaxodont ancestors; I, subumbonal teeth pseudotaxodont an d onl y posteroventrall y inclined , no t ventrally divergent ; J , tironuculid-type ; K , astartid-crassatellid-type; L , a t leas t partiall y palaeotaxodont wit h anterior toot h row a t least one-thir d as long a s posterior toot h row ; M, lyrodesmatid-type; O, matheriid-type; P , at leas t partiall y palaeotaxodon t wit h anterior tooth row less than one-third as long as posterior tooth ro w an d no t tironuculid-typ e hinge ; R , schizodia n type; T , pretaxodont-type . 79 . R V pivota l cardinal subumbonal tooth : 0 , differentiate d cardinal subumbonal teeth absent in RV but hinge or pseudohinge present, o r otherwis e non e o f th e following ; 1 , amorphous, crudely wedge-shaped, typically with growth lines on articulating surface; 2, bulbous or tuberculiform, rounded t o elliptical , horizontall y elongat e o r oblique , generally non-bifid ; 3 , distinctl y shaped , heavy , subtrigonal, wit h onl y a fain t indicatio n o f bifidness , although the tooth may be smooth or irregularly grooved ; 4, distinctly shaped, heavy, subtrigonal, only superficiall y bifid; 5 , distinctly and regularly shaped , full y bifid , wit h bisectrix oriente d towar d posteroventral , ventra l o r anteroventral direction; 6, distinctly shaped, slender, nonbifid o r slightl y bifi d onl y a t th e fa r dista l end , possibly slightly lobate distally; 7, palaeotaxodont; A, no hinge or pseudohinge; B, pseudotaxodont; G, pretaxodont. 80 . LV cardinal-subumbonal toot h immediatel y anterio r t o LV pivota l cardinal-subumbona l tooth : 0 , hing e o r pseudohinge presen t bu t cardinal-subumbona l teet h absent; 1 , n o toot h i n thi s position ; 2 , slender , no t pseudotaxodont; directe d anteroventrally ; no t paralle l with dorsoanterio r shel l margin ; 3 , slender , no t pseudo taxodont; paralle l o r nearl y paralle l wit h dorsoanterio r shell margin ; 4 , slender , no t pseudotaxodont , no t palaeotaxodont, directed posteroventrally ; 6 , palaeo taxodont; 8 , pseudotaxodon t an d nearl y vertica l o r dipping toward s th e anterior ; A , pseudotaxodon t an d dipping towar d th e posteroventral ; B , n o hing e o r pseudohinge; D , pretaxodont (Pojetaia); E , strongl y an d deeply bifid, opening ventrally or antero ventrally. 81. LV cardinal-subumbonal toot h immediatel y posterio r t o LV pivota l cardinal-subumbona l tooth : 0 , hing e o r pseudohinge presen t bu t cardinal-subumbona l teet h absent i n LV ; 1 , n o cardinal-subumbona l tooth i n thi s position; 2 , slender , no t pseudotaxodont ; directe d posteroventrally; 3 , slender , no t pseudotaxodont ; nearly parallel wit h dorsoposterio r shel l margi n an d bas e o f
ligament nymph ; 4 , slender , nearl y vertica l t o slightl y anteroventrally directed , no t palaeotaxodon t o r pseudotaxodont; 5 , palaeotaxodont ; 6 , pseudotaxodon t and nearl y vertical ; A , pseudotaxodon t an d dippin g towards th e posterior ; D , pseudotaxodon t an d dippin g towards th e anterior ; C , n o hing e o r pseudohinge ; E , pretaxodont. 82 . Pivota l R V cardinal-subumbona l socket: 1 , hinge or pseudohinge present but no socket; 2, proximally floored; 3, unfloored; 4, completely floored; 5, no hinge o r pseudohinge . 83 . Presenc e o r absenc e o f dental striations (not longitudinal grooves). 1 , absent or hinge is edentulous, but hinge or pseudohinge present; 2, present; 3 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge . 84 . Heterotaxodonty: 1 , absen t bu t hing e o r pseudohing e present; 2 , present ; 3 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge . 85 . Predominant anterio r palaeotaxodon t toot h shape . 1 , non-palaeotaxodont but hinge o r pseudohinge present ; 2 , orthomorphodont; 3 , concavodont ; 6 , concavoconvex , convexoconcave or diconvex; 7, no hinge or pseudohinge. 86. Predominan t posterio r palaeotaxodon t toot h shape: 1 , non-palaeotaxodon t bu t hing e o r pseudohing e present; 2 , orthomorphodont ; 3 , concavodont ; 6 , concavoconvex, convexoconcav e o r diconvex ; 7 , n o hinge o r pseudohinge . 87 . Pseudohing e o r hing e overgrowth: 1 , non e o f th e following ; 2 , partia l overgrowth o f hing e dentitio n b y advancin g ligamen t insertion are a o r deepl y incise d lunule ; 4, n o hing e o r pseudohinge; 5 , pseudohing e presen t bu t n o tru e hinge . 88. Widt h o f L V posterio r hing e o r pseudohing e excluding ligamen t insertio n are a an d auricle : 1 , narrow t o medium, obsolescent o r absent; 3, wide ; 4, n o hinge o r pseudohinge. 89 . Widt h o f LV anterior hinge or pseudohing e excludin g ligamen t insertio n area , auricle an d deepl y impresse d lunule : 1 , narro w t o medium, obsolescen t o r absent ; 3 , wide ; 4 , n o hing e o r pseudohinge. 90 . Mineralog y L V outer shel l layer : 1 , aragonite o r predominantl y aragonit e wit h isolate d calcite; 2 , al l calcit e o r al l calcit e i n a continuou s outer sublayer. 91. Mineralogy L V adult inner shell layer : 1, aragonite; 3, calcite. 92. General microstructura l grade of middle/inne r shel l layers : 1 , exclusivel y matte d t o lamello-fibrillar, o r larg e table t nacre , o r Cambria n and entirely regularly foliated , the latter convergen t o n som e post-Ordovician pteriomorphians ; 2 , smal l table t nacreous; CL , CC L and/o r FCCL/HOM . 93 . Predominant lef t outer layer microstructure: 1 , regular simple prismatic ; 2 , mixe d regula r simpl e prismatic , irregular simple prismatic, HOM, or just ISP and HOM; 6, porcelaneous; 7 , non-denticula r composit e prismati c and/or aragoniti c regula r simpl e prismatic ; th e NDC P may grad e laterall y int o irregula r spheruliti c prismatic , regular spherulitic prismatic and/or homogeneous; 8, RSP to ISP to HOM (aragonite) overlyin g a fibrous prismati c sublayer; 9 , aragoniti c F P o r denticula r composit e prismatic, possibl y wit h minor ICCL , FCCL o r irregula r spherulitic an d irregula r simpl e prisms . 94 . Calciti c regular simpl e prism s presen t nea r adul t shel l margins: 1 , no; 2, yes. 95. Calcitic foliated structur e in LV: 1, absent; 2, present. 96: Predominant porcelaneou s structure in inner shell layer: 1 , absent; 2, fine comple x crossed-lamellar and/o r HO M (undifferentiated) ; 5 , irregular comple x crossed-lamella r possibl y als o wit h cone CCL , mediu m and/or coars e textured ; 6, matte d to complex crossed lamellar ; 7 , very wide CL and CCL. 97.
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N Aragonitic prism s i n middle and/o r inner shel l layer , excluding adductor myostraca: 1 , minor ISP sublayers; 2, abundan t IS P sublayers ; 3 . vertica l IS P pillars ; 6 , fibrous prism s and matted structure comprise most of the shell interior . 98 . Media l divisio n o f larva l shell : 1 , absent; 2, present. 99. Hinge o r pseudohinge: 1 , absent; 2, present . 100 . Discontinuou s fibrou s ligamen t ontogeny, or derived from such ancestors: 1 , no; 2, yes. 101. Nuculoid/solemyoi d interna l ligament : 1 , absent; 2, presen t a s a resilium (nuculoids) , a s a RV ligamental chondrophore (Palaeozoi c solemyoids ) o r a s a possibl e internal lamellar ligament homolog (modern solemyoids). 102. Spacin g o f elongated ligamenta l grooves : 1 , only one present ; 2 , multipl e groove s closel y spaced ; 3 , multiple grooves moderately spaced ; 4, multiple groove s very widely spaced, including pteriomorphian alivincular and multivincula r ligaments ; 5 , n o ligamen t o r pseudoligament; 6 , pseudoligamen t present . 103 . Mineralization o f ancestrall y elongate d dorsa l ligament (includin g lamella r remnan t o f dorsa l ligament i n resiliated nuculoids) : 1 , non-mineralized or weakly mineralize d withou t accompanyin g resilium ; 2 , mineralization extend s from valv e to valve , whether the ligament i s stil l externa l o r no w submerged ; 6 , n o ligament o r pseudoligament ; 7 , onl y pseudoligamen t present. 104. General ligament grade: 1 , no ligament, or only pseudoligament , or primitivel y weakly mineralized or unmineralized dorsal ligament; 2, well mineralized true ligament o r derive d fro m suc h ancestors . 105 . Genera l categories o f ancestrall y dorsa l ligament s (excludin g nuculoid an d solemyoid interna l ligaments): 0 , neither ligament nor pseudoligament present; 1, pseudoligament; A, D H (duplivincula r horizontal); B, D I (duplivincular inclined); D, SN (simple narrow); E, SW (simple wide); F, PN (parivincular narrow); G, PW (parivincular wide); H, PR (parivincula r ramped) ; J , P S (parivincula r submerged); K, ALIV (alivincular). 106. Major varietie s of ancestrall y dorsa l ligament s (excludin g nuculoi d and solemyoids interna l ligaments): 1 , ligament present but non e o f th e following ; 2 , neithe r ligamen t no r pseudoligament i s present ; 3 , pseudoligament ; A , DHopis; B , DHopis/amph ; C , DHamph ; D , DIopis ; E , DIopis/amph; F , DIamph ; G , DIpros ; K , SNweak ; L , SNstrong; M , PNincip ; N , PNweak ; O , PNstrong , P , PWext; Q, PWint; R, PRthick; S, PRthin; T, PSshallow; 4, PSreduced; 5 , PSdeep ; 7 , ALIVnar ; 8 , ALIVmod ; 9 , ALIVwide; 0 , ALIVsplit . 107 . Detaile d ligamen t varieties (excludin g nuculoi d an d solemyoi d interna l ligaments): 0 , neithe r ligamen t no r pseudoligament ; 1 , pseudoligament; 2 , tru e ligamen t bu t non e o f th e following; A , DHopis2 ; B , DHopis 1; C, DHopi s 1-2; D , Dlamph-incl; 3 , DIamph-aliv ; I , PRthick-shallow ; J , PRthick-deep; K , PRthin-weak ; L , PRthin-strong ; M , PSdeep-sub; N , PSdeep-sub/resil ; O , PSdeep-resil ; P , ALIVmod-trian; Q , ALIVmod-trap ; R , SNweak-opis ; S,
71
SNweak-amph. 108 . Alternativ e grouping s o f simila r dorsal ligament , excludin g palaeotaxodon t interna l ligaments: 0, pseudoligament or no ligament; 1, ligament present bu t non e o f th e followin g apply ; 2 , DHopi s o r DIopis (opisthodeti c duplivincular , regardles s o f inclinations); 3 , DHopis/amp h o r DIopis/amp h (slightl y amphidetic duplivincula r regardles s o f inclinations) ; 4 , DHamph o r DIamp h (strongl y amphideti c duplivincular regardless o f inclinations) ; 5 , S N o r S W (al l simpl e ligaments); 6 , PN , PW , P R o r P S (al l parivincula r ligaments excep t P F an d PW , whic h clearl y evolve d separately). 109 . Additiona l dorsa l ligamen t varieties : 0, ligamen t presen t bu t non e o f th e following ; 5 , pseudoligament or no ligament; 7, DHopis2 ligament with several ligamen t groove s an d wit h early forme d fibrous layers largel y restricte d t o th e anterio r o f th e ligamen t insertion area; 8, DHopis2 ligament with very few, widely spaced ligamen t grooves . 110 . Dorsa l shel l plat e kinetics: 1 , flexibl e b y virtu e o f microstructura l differentiation; 3 , crackin g o f media l dorsa l shel l plat e during growt h t o kee p valve s apar t ventrally ; 4 , pseudoligament; 5 , non e o f th e abov e (mos t Monoplacophora). 111 . Combine d interfacia l angl e o f L-R ligamen t insertio n area s fo r duplivincula r ligaments an d thei r alivincular , multivincula r an d planivincular derivatives , measure d nea r th e adul t hinge margi n (thi s exclude s nuculoi d an d solemyoi d internal ligaments) : 1 , symmetrica l an d < 70°, o r ligament i s no t duplivincula r nor derive d therefrom ; 2 , L-R asymmetrical ; 3, alivincula r and submerge d below shell margins ; 4 , symmetrica l an d >70° ; 5 , pseudo ligament o r n o ligament ; 6 , adul t portio n o f elongate , simple ligament inserts on ventromedial surface o f dorsal hinge margi n wit h n o tru e nymp h bu t possibl y wit h a pseudonymph. 112 . Suppor t fo r palaeotaxodon t internal ligament: 0, no ligament or only pseudoligament present; 1 , ligamen t presen t bu t n o palaeotaxodon t internal ligament; 2, resilifer in one valve opposes a tooth or tooth-lik e structur e i n othe r valve ; 3 , opposin g resilifers, not strongly projecting beneath hinge rotationa l axis; may be symmetrical o r asymmetrical; 5 , ligamenta l chondrophore attaching below beak in RV, with ligament arching upwards without a chondrophore in LV. 113. L- R asymmetrical palaeotaxodon t resilife r (excludin g solemyoid ligamenta l chondrophore) : 0 , neithe r ligament no r pseudoligamen t present ; 1 , absent , bu t a ligament i s present; 2 , present. 114 . Ctenidia l grade : ?, uncertain; 1 , protobranchiate ; 2 , autolamellibranchiate . 115. Abdominal sens e organ: 1 , absent; 2, present. 116 . Adoral an d anterio r mantl e sens e organs : 1 , bot h absent; 2 , adora l sens e organ present; 3, anterio r mantle sense orga n present . 117 . Shel l heigh t abov e dorsa l limits o f apertur e exceed s shel l heigh t belo w dorsa l limits of aperture: 1 , yes; 2, no.
Appendix 3: Database for phylogenetic analysi s Vertical, species number; horizontal, character number. * Polymorphisms, indicated separately as follows. Note that 6-15[l,2] signifies specie s 6, character 15 , character states 1 and 2, etc. Polymorphisms, 5-5[l,2], 6-15[l,2], 6-18[0-5], 6-41[2,3], 6-50[4,6], 6-55[2-7], 7-79[l,2], 8-64[l,2], 8-78[J,L] , 8-86[l-3], 9-14[l,5], 10-38[1,5] , 10-40[l-5], ll-15[l-2] , 1129[3,4], 13-2[l-2] , 13-85[2,3] , 14-29[3,4] , 16-69[2,3] , 16-72[1,C] , 16-86[2,3] , 18-22[1,2] , 21-17[7,8] , 22-35[2,3], 23-35[2,3] , 24-35[2,3] , 25-15[3,5] , 26-29[3,4] , 26-50[4,5] , 26 59[2,3], 26-60[l-3], 26-61[l,2], 26-62[l,3], 26-68[l,2] , 27-15[2,4] , 27-29[3,4], 27-60[l,3], 27-61[l,2] , 27-62[l,3] , 27-79[0,B] , 28-15[l,4] , 28-59[3,4] , 28-60[l,3], 28-61[l,8] , 28 62[1,3], 28-68[l,2], 28-88[l,3] , 29-17[l,6] , 30-60[1,8] , 32-78[B,F] , 34-15[2,3] , 34-19[2,4] , 36-15[l,2] , 36-17[l,4] , 36-34[l,2] , 36-61[4,5] , 37-16[l,3] , 37-17[l,6] , 37-29[2,3] , 3730[1,2], 37-50[4-6], 37-80[l,2], 37-81[l,4], 39-17[5,6], 40-15[2,5], 40-17[5,6], 40-55[4,5], 40-78[B,K], 41-11[1,2], 41-13[1,2], 41-17[6,9], 41-36[A,4], 41-37[1,3], 41-49[1,4], 4315[2,5], 43-43[l,3], 43-93[2,9] , 44-12[l,3], 44-13[l,2] , 44-43[l,2] , 44-56[l,2] , 45-12[l,3] , 45-13[l,2] , 45-16[5,6], 45-36[4,A] , 46-12[l,3], 46-13[l,2] , 48-36[A,H] , 48-48[l,2], 4950[3,4], 50-17[4,H] , 50-49[1,4] , 51-23[1,2] , 51-25[1,5] , 51-49[3,4] , 51-61[5,7] , 51-63[1,2] , 51-109[7,8] , 52-50[3,4] , 52-63[l,2] , 53-3[l,5] , 53-4[l,2] , 53-18[0,l] , 54-18[0,3] , 54 36[A,C], 55-l[l,2], 55-5[l,2], 55-9[2,4] , 55-10[2,4] , 55-16[l,2] , 55-18[l,5] , 56-10[2,3], 56-93[l,2] , 57-16[2,5] , 57-36[R,C] , 58-17[3,D], 58-48[l,2] , 58-59[3,4] , 58-106[A,B] , 58108[2,3], 59-17[2,E], 59-34[l,3], 59-48[l,2], 59-61[5,7] , 60-78[3,I], 61-59[3,4], 61-65[1,3], 61-78[3,I], 62-16[l,2], 62-19[l,2] , 62-88[l,3], 63-74[6,7] , 63-88[l,3], 65-29[3,4] , 6560[1,7], 65-75[3,4], 66-14[l,3] , 66-60[l,7] , 67-60[l,7], 67-78[9,G] . 1234567890123 45678 901234567890 1234567890 1234567890 1234567890 1234567890 1234567890 1234567890 1234567890 1234567890 123456 67
15311111A11111136G626616441115164454215157487635477511531??56A73465554330605550ABC533774441117111611115610200555001111 22211111A11111142602661111111411115101?1?7487635477511531??11111111311111111110000111115111117111622116711310545001112
31352152C24142113D121111111111311111 401?1??1 ?8746588611 ??1?? 23231111 311111153 1200001111 1511231 ??2111211 671131054 500?112
45211111A11111136G62661644111516446421???7597635477511631??56A73465554330605550ABC5337744411??111111115610200535001111111 51252*11A34112152852111111111311111201515?1??21?21?311??!??!111131111211111111000011122111231??2112211111DKS5011117112 62252111A441111*18*2111111111311111111111*11121221*2111*1321111111117111D11111TGDE41111111111711112211111DKR5011111112
7221111 1A1111111126021111111111411111 1H1111 313121 221 4222 131521111111111111211111110*114111111111111?111122111111DKR5011111112
84211111A11131513602111111111311111131111111?1122143111?1??24111*2114211118146*7654113*113112?11??22111?2DL2501111?1?22
9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122 9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122
12211111A111315*2602111111111*11111101111111?112214311131111111131114311C11111P76541213111112?11??22111?2DL2501111?1?2 22252111A541325228021111111113 11111101111111P112214311131111111131114211111111P76541212111112?11??22111?2DL2501111?1? 2
9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122 9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122 9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122
62211111A11111112602111111111411111171111111?1122143111?2111111121114*11*11111P7654112*111112211212211122DL25011111132 72211111A111321338081111111113111113L1111?1??11?2143111?!??1111121114211111111L00011166111112?11??2211122GP21011111172
9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122 9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122
02111111A111311126021111111114111121Q1111?1121111433111?!112123111111122311111D21141111113112?11??22111?2DL25011112?12 12211111A11132143*02111111111311111301111111?112214311131??1111111111112111111533242111111112?11??22111?2DL2501111??12 22211111A111121551021111111114 11112*P19291111112143311182 111111111112112511111MB8A42111133112?11??2211122FO26011112?12 32211111A11112155102111111111411111*P19291111112234311182 111111111111112111111R63332111111112?11??2211122FM26011112?1 2 42211111A11112155102111111111411112*P192911111??14331118???2811111112112511111MB8A42111133112?11??2211122F026011112?12
9221111A1A111131 * 1300 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 122111111 311111111? 111 22 14 3 1 1 121? ?1 1 1 1 2 1 11421111111111 L76 54 11 3211111112911112221111112DL250111 1 11 122
62211111A11111112102111215111*11111171111???111721*311?3111****11111*112141323GB8A41111111112?11??22111?2DL25011112712 72211111A111311*5602111111111*1111110?????1711132132 111?1113***1111111121413236*3341111111112?11??22111?2DL25011112?12
82211111A111111*5102111??Ill141111110111121311122133 111?Ill****11111*112117424GB8A411111*1112?11??22111?2DL25011112?12 92211111A11111136*04112111111411112Ul111???1112234311??1114873211112112211111FBAA41111231112611212211122DL25011112?12 02211111A11111136B04112111111511112Ullll?!??11?144?111?1114*732111121122 11111FBA342111131112611712211172DL25011112?1 2 12211111A111111366021111111114111121J1111?11?1121443111????2111111112112211111MBAA42111113112?11??22111?2DL25011112?12 22211111A111111325041121111114111111J111111??11?146?11??!??1111111112112511111*B8A41111131112611712211122E125011112?12 32211111A111121326041121111114111111J111111??11?143??????1111111111111122 11111B54342111111112?11712211122E125011112?1 2 423 1111 1A11 11 21* 25 0* 111 215 111 411 111 1J 1111 113 311214331118111111111111111111122111111B543411111131111291171221111122J5M60111112? 1 2
52211111A11111522102111111111411111101111???11122143111?11148732 11112112111111FBAA41111133112?11??22111?2DL25011112?1 2 62311111A111115*2*0111121511141111*IK?11111?11122143 111?11143*3111112112111111FBAA41111131112?11??22111?2DL25011112?1 2 72211111A1113151**02111111111**!111101111214111121*341131111111111111122111111C4**32111111112?11??22111?2E125011112?12
423 1111 1A11 11 21* 25 0* 111 215 111 411 111 1J 1111 113 311214331118111111111111111111122111111B543411111131111291171221111122J5M60111112? 1 2
92211111A11112522*021112151114111111K311111411122143 111?1112323111111112111131B6???2111131112?11112211122E12501111211 2 02311111A111121*2*021112151114111121K311111311121343221*1112323111111112121223*22141111131112911512211122JT26011112112 12211111A11*1*126*071115121114 111111**11121311121*4211131111111111111112111111411141111211112 9 11112211122HRI6011112?1 2 22211111A111111266021115121114111111011111?41112214232331111111111111122111111121111111111112911112221322BD22011112212 32211111A111321*6H021111111114123111H111111*?112214?2213 1111111111111122111111821121111111112*11112221322AAA281111221 2 42311111A111**1264071111111114111111A111111*111221321113*111111111121111111111000011111111112?11112221122AAB2116112212 52311111A111**32*4021111111114111111*3111???11122143 111??111111111121111111111000011111111112?11112221222AAA281111221 2 62211111A111**1264071111111114111111A1111?1332122142????1111111111121111111111000011111111112911122221122AAB2116112212
423 1111 1A11 11 21* 25 0* 111 215 111 411 111 1J 1111 113 311214331118111111111111111111122111111B543411111131111291171221111122J5M60111112? 1 2
82311111A111111164021112151114111111*1111????11?*142111????Ill1111111112111111060041111111112??1??22212?2AAA2?11112212 92311111A111115124021111111114111121H1111?12211213*21?131111111111111112111111065141111111112?!1112221222AAA2811112212 02211111A11131512*011111111113111111G1111?1321121*4332??111375411111111211433426E141111213112?11??22212?2AAA2?11112212 12211111A11112552402111*1*1114111121H111121??11?1*4?????11133*3*11111112111111251241111231112?11??22212?2AAA2*11112212 22255111A111315524021111111114111111F1323?!??11321*2 111?1114373*11171111114334200011111111112?11??22212?2AAA2?1111221 2 312**111A24211516E*14115121115111111B132311332122511??15132475411111111221111126424111121121212?1122212?2AAA2?11112212
423 1111 1A11 11 21* 25 0* 111 215 111 411 111 1J 1111 113 311214331118111111111111111111122111111B543411111131111291171221111122J5M60111112? 1 2
5*322*52C**21151*0*111111121431111118162631?32121152221?1111111111111112111111051241111111??2?????2221??2AC2401?112212 6135215262*211513052111111114311111281323?!???!?????????!??1111111101111111111000011111111212*213122214?2K8P1011112212 71332232E2221111*F5211111121?3142111*1111?1???1?2???????1??1111111101111111111A00011111111212?2???22212?2AC24011112212 82232232B24211512*222111112124152111C1111?!?1211*132??1?111*873211112112211111IBAA4111121121222?1122212?2A*A*?1?112212 92332252024211526*1211111121241421*1013361112211*122221311147*3213112112211111IBAA41111233212?????22212?2AB23012112212 02252152B24131512D51111111222315211111331?1?3212213232171113764211112112116334*B8A41111213212?2???22212?2AAA2?12112212 12252152C24131512D11111111212314212111111112121221323233111*76321*112112116334*B8A41111233?12??1??22212?2BFD4014112212 2215215262413152*35*1111111113111112G111131311122142113?11147631111121121164349B86411112*1112?11??22213?2BFD4014112212 32252152B2413252230111111?1113111111F1222?13?1122142??1????477321111211211*4329B86411112*3112?11??22212?2BFD4014112212 41252152B441315123511111111113111112G?????1??11?2142 111?1113793115116112A163349BAD42111211112?11??22212?2BFD401411221 2 52252152B441?2??635?Ill111111*111121E1111?!??1122342??13???4*93215116112A16*339B8641111231?12?11??22212?2BD22014112212 61122252024233*263271111111214111112E0222?1??11?2143????1??4*43211116112A164349BAD42111211112911512221222BF34014112212 712521520241323563521111111114111111E1111?1??1112?33111??112*11111713112E16434*B8642111111112?11??22212?2?????11112212
74
J. G. CARTE R ET AL.
Appendix 4: Character state changes for nodes in Fig. 4 Key: 34(5-6) indicates character 34 changing from stat e 5 to state 6; 34(5-6,7) indicates character 34 changing fro m state 5 to state 6 or state 7 (indeterminate). *, State change of uncertai n hierarchica l positio n du e t o uncertaint y o f character state in one or more adjacent siste r groups. Node l-Anabarella: 2(2-3) , *97(l-6) , *110(3-5) . Node 1-2: 16(6-2) , 18(6-0) , 23(6-1) , 24(4-1) , 25(4-1) , 31(6-1), 32(4-1) , 33(4-1) , 36(2-0) , 59(5-1) , 60(6-1) , 61(A-1), 62(7-1) , 63(3-1) , 64(4-1) , 65(6-1) , 66(5-1) , 67(5-3), 68(5-1) , 69(4-1) , 70(3-1) , 71(3-1) , 72(0-1) , 73(6-1), 74(0-1) , 75(5-1) , 76(5-1) , 77(5-1) , 79(A-0) , 80(B-0), 81(C-0) , 82(5-1) , 83(3-1) , 84(3-1) , 85(7-1), 86(7-1), 87(4-5) , 88(4-1) , 89(4-1) , 99(1-2) , 102(5-6) , 103(6-7), 105(0-1) , 106(2-3) , 107(0-1) , *110(3-4) , 117(1-2). Nod e 2-Watsonella: * 1(5-2), * 15(3-4), *17(G-6), *29(5-4), *35(4-l), *97(l-6), *98(l-2). Node 2-3: *1(5-1) , 3(1-5), 4(1-2), 10(1-4), *15(3-1), 20(6-1), 21(6-1), *29(5-3) , 34(5-1) , 42(4-1) . Nod e 3 Pseudomyona: 2(2-3) , 6(1-5) , 7(1-2) , 8(A-C) , 9(1-2), 12(1-4), *13(l-2) , 16(2-3) , *17(G-D) , 18(0-1) , *44(7-8), *45(6-7) , *46(3-4) , *47(5-6) , *48(4-5) , *49(7-8), *50(7-8), *51(5-6), 59(1-2), 60(1-3), 61(1-2), 62(1-3), 74(1-5), 75(1-3), 77(1-2), *90(l-2), *91(l-3) , *95(l-2). Nod e 3-4 : *17(G-8) , *45(6-2) , *46(3-l) , *48(4-2), *49(7-l) , 67(3-1) , 87(5-1) , *98(l-2) , 102(6-1), 103(7-1) , 105(1-D) , 106(3-K) , 108(0-5) , 109(5-0), 110(4-1) , 111(5-1), 112(0-1) , 113(0-1). Node 4-Tuarangia: 9(1-3) , *13(l-2) , 15(1-5) , 18(0-5) , *35(4-2), *51(5-3), 64(1-3), 69(1-2), 85(1-2), 86(1-2) , *90(l-2), *91(l-3) , *95(l-2) , *107(1-S) . Nod e 4-5 : *l(l-2), *35(4-l), 38(5-1), 40(5-1), *41(7-3), *44(7-l), *47(5-2), *50(7-4) , *51(5-2) , *54(5-l) , 82(1-4) , *107(1-R). Nod e 5-Pojetaia: 9(1-4), 16(2-1) , 36(0-1) , *43(8-l), 55(3-2,7) , *57(l-3) , 68(1-7) , 72(1-D) , 78(0-T), *79(0-G) , *80(0-D) , *81(0-E) . Nod e 5-6 : 3(5-1), 4(2-1) , 10(4-1) , * 17(8-6), 29(3-4) , *43(8-3) , *79(0-1), *80(0-1) , *81(0-1) . Nod e 6-Fordilla. 36(0-H), 52(1-2) , 53(1-2) , *57(l-5) , *71(l-2) . Nod e 6-7: 41(3-1) , 45(2-1) , 58(2-1) , 92(1-2) , *93(7-9) , 103(1-2), 104(1-2) , 106(K-L) , 107(R-2) . Nod e 7-55 : *43(3-l), *51(2-3) , 64(1-3), 68(1-4), 69(1-2), 78(0-P), 79(1-7), 80(1-6) , 81(1-5) , 85(1-3) , 86(1-2) , 116(1-3). Node 55-57 : 12(1-3) . Nod e 57-58 : 29(4-3) , 86(2-3) . Node 58-61: 16(2-3) , 36(0-3), 64(3-2) , 78(P-L). Node 61-Tironucula: 1(2-4) , *14(l-5) , 59(1-2) , 60(1-4) , 65(1-2), 74(1-8) , 76(1-4) , 77(1-6) , 89(1-3) . Nod e 61-62: 17(6-0) , 29(3-2) , 30(1-2) , * 116(3-2). Node 62 Praenucula. 55(3-2) , 86(3-2) . Nod e 62-63 : 16(3-4) . Node 63-Nuculoidea: *36(3-U) , 51(3-4) , 101(1-2) , 112(1-3). Nod e 63-64 : 15(1-3) , 17(0-P) , 19(2-8) , 35(1-3), *36(3-L) , 85(3-6) , 105(D-G) , 106(L-P) , 108(5-1). Nod e 64-65 : 79(7-0) , 80(6-0) , 81(5-0) , 82(4-1). Nod e 65-Ctenodonta: *13(l-2) , 16(4-3) , 17(P-8), 29(2-3), 30(2-1), *86(3-6) . Node 65-Acharax: *12(3-1), 14(1-3) , 20(1-7), 34(1-2) , 38(1-B) , 40(1-B), 51(3-4), 54(1-4), *57(l-4) , *58(l-2) , 64(2-1), 67(1-6), 68(4-1), 69(2-1), 78(L-H), 85(6-1), *86(3-l), *93(9-2), 101(1-2), 112(1-5) . Nod e 64-Tancrediopsis: *12(3-1) , *13(l-2), 23(1-2) , 24(1-2) , 25(1-5) , 46(1-2) , 64(2-3) . Node 58-59 : *14(l-5) , 84(1-2) . Nod e 59-60 : 85(3-1) .
Node 6Q-Cardiolaria: 69(2-3) , 72(1-C) . Nod e 60 Praeleda: 3(1-5) , 4(1-2) , 9(1-5) , 10(1-4) , 13(1-2) , *15(l-2), 17(6-8) , 86(3-2). Node 59-Ekstadia. 17(6-H) , 34(1-2), 41(1-2) , 43(1-2) , *44(l-2) , 49(1-3) , 52(1-4) , 56(1-3), *96(l-2). Node 57-Eritropis: 13(1-3) , 15(1-5), 16(2-6), 17(6-4) , 19(2-4) , 36(0-J) . Nod e 55-56 : 56(1-2), *96(l-2). Node 56-Nuculites: 14(1-3) , 16(2-5) , 17(6-1), 24(1-2) , 34(1-2), *36(0-M) , 49(1-3), 54(1-3) , *55(3-6), *93(9-6) , 103(2-1) . Nod e 56-Palaeoneilo: *36(0-7), 64(3-2) , 85(3-2) , *93(9-2) . Nod e 7-8 : *71(l-2), 114(1-2). Node 8-35: 17(6-1), *51(2-3). Node 35-42: *79(1-B) , 81(1-A) . Nod e 42-45 : 68(1-2) , *78(0-F), *80(1-A) . Nod e 45-49 : 36(0-J) , 48(2-1) , 49(1-4), 72(1-2) . Nod e 49-54 : *17(l-6) , *34(l-2) , 43(3-1), 59(1-2) , 89(1-3) . Nod e 54-Redonia: 2(2-1) , 12(1-3), 36(J-Q) , *44(l-2) , 47(2-1) , 50(4-3) , 61(1-2) , *62(l-3), 68(2-1), 70(1-2), 72(2-3), *78(F-D), 79(B-2), 80(A-1), 81(A-1) . Nod e 54-Noradonta. *15(l-3) , 16(2-6), *78(F-M) , 83(1-2) . Nod e 49-50 : *15(l-3) , 19(2-4), 22(1-2) , *88(l-3) , *96(l-7) . Nod e 50-53 : 16(2-6), *34(l-2), *59(l-4), 61(1-7), *62(l-3), 63(1-2), *93(9-6). Node 53-Nyassa: 48(1-2) , 49(4-3), *60(l-8) , 87(1-2), 96(7-2). Node 53-Tanaodon: 17(1-B) , 29(4-5), 81(A-3), 83(1-2) . Nod e 50-51 : *17(l-5) , 105(D-E) , 106(L-1). Nod e 51-Genu s A Johnsto n & Goodbod y 1988: *50(4-6) , 72(2-5) , *80(A-8) , *93(9-6) . Nod e 51-52: 13(1-2) , *50(4-3) , 68(2-1), *78(F-B) , 79(B-F), *80(A-4), 81(A-3) . Nod e 52-Genu s B Johnsto n & Goodbody 1988 : * 17(5-6), 83(1-2), 88(3-1) . Nod e 52Montanaria. 2(2-3) , 22(2-1) , 23(1-2) , 25(1-5) , *44(l-3), *55(3-8) , 105(E-J) , 106(1-5) , 107(2-M) , 108(5-6). Nod e 45-46 : 14(1-5) , * 15(1-2), *59(l-4) , *62(l-3), *88(l-3) . Nod e 46-Copidens: *60(l-8) , *61(l-7), 63(1-2) , 89(1-3) . Nod e 46-47 : 23(1-2) , 25(1-5), 36(0-K) , *60(l-3) . Nod e 41-Ananterodonta. *2(2-3), 19(2-1) , *61(l-4,5) . Nod e 47-48 : 13(1-2) , 17(1-5), *37(l-3), 59(4-2), *61(l-2), 68(2-1), 78(F-B). Node 48-Genu s C Johnsto n & Goodbod y 1988 : 43(3-4), *76(l-3) , *79(B-6) , 83(1-2) , *105(D-E) , *106(L-1). Node 48-Eodon: *2(2-3) , 14(5-1) , 34(1-2) , 48(2-1), 49(1-3), 52(1-2), 53(1-2), *55(3-4,5), 73(1-2), 75(1-2), *76(l-2) , 77(1-3) , *79(B-2) , *80(A-2) , *81(A-1), 96(1-5) , *105(D-J) , *106(L-T) , 108(5-6) . Node 42-43 : *59(l-3) , 75(1-3) , 76(1-2) , 77(1-3) , *78(0-G), *80(l-8) . Nod e 43-Cycloconcha: 23(1-2) , 25(1-5), 36(0-7) , *73(l-4) . Nod e 43-44 : 16(2-5) , 50(4-3). Nod e 44-Fortowensia: 12(1-3) , *15(l-2,4) , 17(1-6), 47(2-3), 51(3-2) , *73(l-4) , 80(8-3) , 81(A-3) . Node 44-Actinodonta. *41(1-2) , 74(1-7) , 75(3-4) , 77(3-4). Nod e 35-36 : 29(4-3) , *79(l-6) . Nod e 36-38: 13(1-2), 35(1-3) , 43(3-1), 80(1-3). Nod e 38-Thoralia: 12(1-3), *15(l-4) , 16(2-3) , 17(1-7,8) , *78(0-5) , 79(6-3), 81(1-2) , *83(l-2) . Nod e 38-39 : *15(l-5) , *78(0-R), 105(D-F) , 106(L-M) , 108(5-6). Node 39-40: 16(2-5), 29(3-4) , *36(0-P) , 38(1-9) , 39(1-2) , 40(1-9) , *55(3-8), 56(1-2) , *83(l-2) . Nod e 40-41 : 34(1-2) , 48(2-1), *49(l-4), 50(4-3), 68(1-2), 72(1-5), 78(R-M), 79(6-B), 80(3-8) , *81(1-A) , 88(1-3) , 89(1-3) , 106(M-O). Nod e 4\-Lyrodesma majus adult : n o autapomorphies. Nod e 4\-Lyrodesma sp . Johnsto n 1996: 59(1-2) , 60(1-8) . Nod e 4Q-Lyrodesma majus juvenile: *49(l-3) , *81(l-3) , *82(4-3) . Nod e 39 Silurozodus: 14(1-5) , *36(0-D) , 41(1-3) , 43(1-2) , 52(1-2), 53(1-2), *55(3-7) , *82(4-3) , *115(l-2) . Nod e
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTIO N 36-37: 14(1-5), 16(2-1) , 105(D-E) , 106(L-1). Node 37Babinka. 12(1-3), *41(l-2), 43(3-4), 47(2-1), *52(l^t), 70(1-2), 78(0-C), 79(6-4), 82(4-3), *83(l-2). Nod e 37Ilionia: *15(l-2) , 17(1-C) , 19(2-4) , 22(1-2) , 24(1-2), 25(1-5), 37(1-4), *41(l-3) , 44(1-4), *50(4-6) , 51(3-4), *52(l-2), 53(1-2) , 57(1^) , 58(1-2) , 80(1-0) , 81(1-0) . Node 8-9 : * 15(1-2), 16(2-6) . Nod e 9-Modiomorpha: 19(2-7), *23(l-5) , *25(l-2) , 36(0-4,A) , 41(1-2) , 48(2-1), 78(0-4) , 87(1-2) , *105(D-H) , *106(L-R) , 107(2-1), *108(5-6) , *79(l-2) . Nod e 9-10 : *79(l-2) , 100(1-2), 102(1-3) , *108(5-2) , *115(l-2) . Nod e 10 Evyana. *23(l-5), *25(l-2), 43(3-4), 52(1-3), *53(l-2), 54(1-3), *70(l-2) , 78(0-1) , *82(4-l) , *105(D-B) , *106(L-D). Nod e 10-11 : 36(0-H) , *105(D-A) , *106(L-A), 107(2-A) , 109(0-8) . Nod e ll-Colpomya: 12(1-3), 13(1-2) , *17(6-H) , 31(1-2), 32(1-3) , 52(1-2) , *53(l-2), *70(l-2) , 78(0-8) , 82(4-2) . Nod e 11-12 : 2(2-3), *17(6-4) , 80(1-0) , 81(1-0) , 102(3-2) . Nod e 12-33: 36(H-A) , 67(1-2), 71(2-1), *79(2-0) , *82(4-l) . Node 33-34 : 19(2-7) , 102(2-1) , 107(A-B) , 109(8-1) , 111(1-6). Nod e 34-Modiolopsis: 43(3-1,2) , 50(4-3) . Node 34-Modiolus: 2(3-2) , 44(1-3) , 45(1-2) , 97(1-2) . Node 33-Whiteavesia: 14(1-3) , 37(1-3) , 51(2-3). Node 12-13: *79(2-6) . Nod e 13-32 : 23(1-2) , 25(1-5) , 78(0-O). Node 32-Matheria: 36(H-5) , 80(0-1), 81(0-3) . Node 32-Metapadia: *15(2-1) . Nod e 13-14 : 14(1-5) , *15(2-1), 16(6-2) , *44(l-2) . Nod e \4-Modiolodon: 34(1-2), 43(3-2) , *48(2-l) , 49(1-3) , 80(0-5) , 81(0-1) . Node 14-15 : 2(3-2) , 87(1-2) . Nod e 15-30 : 59(1-3) , 60(1-3), 61(1-5) , 62(1-3) , 78(0-2) . Nod e 30-31 : 12(1-3), 74(1^) , 75(1-3) , 76(1-3) , 77(1-4) . Nod e 31Cyrtodonta: 19(2-1) , 29(4-3) , *36(H-G) , *48(2-l) , 51(2-3), 52(1-3) , 53(1-2) , 60(3-7) , 62(3-4) , 80(0-E) , 81(0-1), 89(1-3). Node 3l-Falcatodonta: 3(1-5) , 4(1-5), * 15(1-5), *36(H-F), 38(1-3), 39(1-2), 40(1-3), 47(2-3), 59(3-4), *61(5-7) , 67(1-7) , 71(2-1) , 79(6-0) , 82(4-1) , 87(2-1). Node W-Ortonella. 13(1-2) , *15(l-5), 34(1-2), *41(l-2), *48(2-l) , 49(1-3,4) , 79(6-5) , 80(0-1) , 81(0-2), 88(1-3) . Nod e 15-16 : 3(1-5) , 4(1-2) , 9(1-2) , 10(1-4), 11(1-2) , 36(H-C) , 45(1-2), 90(1-2), *93(9-2) , 94(1-2). Nod e 16-29 : *1(2-1) , 16(2-6) , 23(1-5) , 25(1-2), *29(4-5), *50(4-1), 51(2-1), 55(3-5). Node 29Ambonychia: *17(4-E) , * 19(2-1), 20(1^) , 36(C-B) , 38(1-3), 39(1-2), 40(1-3), *44(2-3) , *49(l-5) , 57(1-3), 58(1-2), 59(1-4) , 60(1-7) , 61(1-5) , 62(1-4) , 72(1-2) , 78(0-2), 80(0-4) , 81(0-2) , 93(2-1) . Nod e 29 Septimyalina: 2(2-1) , * 17(4-2), * 19(2-6), *28(l-2) , 31(1-4), 32(1-2), 34(1-4), 47(2-1), *48(2-l), *49(l-6) , 79(6-1). Node 16-17: 6(1-5), 7(1-2), 8(A-B), *17(4-D), 18(0-5), 26(1-2) , 52(1-2) , 53(1-2) , * 109(8-0). Nod e 17-27: 2(2-3) , *28(l-4) , *29(4-3) , 87(2-1) , 106(A-C), 107(A-2), * 108(2-4). Nod e 27-Myodakryotus: 3(5-2) , 8(B-C), *19(2-1), *36(C-8), 38(1-6), *39(l-2), 40(1-6), *41(l-3), *44(2-3) , *48(2-l) , *50(4-5) , *79(6-5) , 80(0-1), 81(0-2) . Nod e 27-28 : *1(2-1) , * 10(4-2), 67(1-0), 71(2-1) , *79(6-0) , 82(4-1) . Nod e 28 Palaeolima: 16(2-3) , 26(2-1) , 35(1-2) , *36(C-8) , 38(1-3), *39(l-2) , 40(1-3) , *96(l-3) , 102(2-4) , 105(A-K), 106(C-8) , 107(2-P) , 108(4-1) . Nod e 28 Leiopecten: 3(5-3) , 5(1-2) , 6(5-3) , 8(B-E) , 14(5-1) , 17(D-F), 31(1-4) , 32(1-2) , 78(0-A) . Nod e 17-18 : *28(l-2), 32(1-2) , *50(4-3) , 59(1-4), 60(1-7), 62(1-3) , 63(1-2), 68(1-2), 78(0-1), *79(6-B), 81(0-A), 111(1-2) . Node 18-26: 3(5-3), 5(1-2), 47(2-1), *61(l-7), 72(1-2),
75
*80(0-A). Node 26-Pterinea: 6(5-3) , *18(5-2), 20(1-2), *31(l-5), *44(2-l) , 60(7-8) . Nod e 26-Tolmaia: 2(2-3) , 8(B-C), 15(1-2) , 16(2-6) , 17(D-2,E) , * 18(5-1), *31(l-4), 38(1-3), 39(1-3) , 40(1-6), *43(3-l) , 50(3-2), 65(1-3), 88(1-3) , *89(l-3) , *106(A-B) , 107(A-2) , *108(2-3). Nod e 18-19 : 11(2-1) , 12(1-3) , *19(2-1) , *29(4-3), 36(C-I), 52(2-3), *61(l-6), 74(1-6) , 75(1-3), 76(1-3), 77(1-4) , *80(0-8) , *89(l-3) . Nod e 19 Rhombopteriid ne w Genu s Johnsto n 1993 : 27(1-2), *31(l-5), 38(1-3) , 39(1-3) , *44(2-3) , 59(4-3), 62(3-4). Node 19-20: *44(2-l), 105(A-B) , 106(A-F), 107(A-D), - 108(2-4), 111(2-4) . Nod e 2to-Umburra. 8(B-C) , 18(5-1), *31(l-4) , 34(1-2) , 43(3-2) , 54(1-3) , 88(1-3) . Node 20-21 : 15(1-2) , 17(D-3) , 26(2-1) , 28(2-1) , 32(2-1), 45(2-1) , 50(3-4) , 75(3-4) , 78(1-9) , 81(A-6) , *90(2-1), *94(2-l) . Nod e 21-22 : *36(I-G) , *52(3-l) , *53(2-l), 89(3-1) . Nod e 22-Freja: 2(2-1) , *35(l-2) , *41(l-3), 54(1-3) , *63(2-l) , 102(2-3) . Nod e 22-23 : 61(6-9), 68(2-6) , 72(1-A) . Nod e 23-Trecanolia: *1(2-1), *9(2-4) , 15(2-1) , *35(l-2) , 59(4-3) , *63(2-l) , *65(l-5), 75(4-3) , 80(8-A) , 81(6-D) , *83(l-2) . Nod e 23-24: 13(1-2) , 16(2-6) , 36(G-E) . Nod e 24 Catamarcaia. *9(2-4) , 34(1-2) , 49(1-3) , *65(l-5) , 77(4-3), 88(1-3), 106(F-D) , *107(D-2), 108(4-2). Node 24-25: *1(2-1) , 8(B-D) , *14(5-3) , *29(3-4) , 51(2-3) , *83(l-2). Node 25-Cosmetodon: 2(2-1) , 3(5-2), 5(1-2), 11(1-2), 13(2-3) , 18(5-2) , *19(l-7) , 27(1-2), *35(l-2) , 37(1-0), 38(1-2) , 39(1-2) , 40(1-2) , *61(9-4) , 80(8-A), 81(6-D), *93(2-9) , *96(l-5) , *107(D-3) . Nod e 25 Glyptarca: 15(2-5) , *19(l-2) , *47(2-l) , 50(4-3) , 59(4-2), *61(9-1) , 62(3-1), *63(2-l) , 66(1-7), 68(6-3) , 72(A-E), 87(2-1) , 111(4-1) . Nod e 21-Alytodonta: 13(1-2), 18(5-0) , *36(I-F) , 38(1-2) , 39(1-2) , 40(1-2) , 61(6-7), 77(4-2) . Nod e 1-Ribeiria: 34(5-6) , 42(4-5) , 43(8-9), 54(5-6).
References ADAMS, H . & ADAMS , A . 1854-1858 . Th e Genera o f Recent Mollusca Arranged According to their Organization. J. van Voorst, London, 2, 1-661. ALLEN, J . A . 1985 . The Recen t Bivalvia , thei r for m an d evolution. In : TRUEMAN , E . R . & CLARKE , M . R . (eds) Th e Mollusca, Volume 10 , Evolution. Academic Press, New York, 337-403. & HANNAH , F . J . 1986 . A reclassificatio n o f th e Recent gener a o f th e subclas s Protobranchi a (Mollusca, Bivalvia) . Journal o f Conchology, 32 , 225-249. BABIN, C . 1966 . Mollusques bivalves et cephalopodes d u Paleozoique Armoricain. Imprimerie Commercial e et Administrative, Brest. 1977. Etude comparee des genres Babinka Barrande et Coxiconcha Babi n (Mollusque s bivalve s d e FOrdovicien). Interet phylogenetique. Geobios, 10, 51-79. 19820. Mollusque s bivalve s e t rostroconches . In : BABIN, C. , COURTESSOLE , R. , MELO U M., PILLET, J., VIZCAINO, D. & YOCHELSON , E. (eds) Brachiopodes (articules) e t Mollusque s (bivalves , rostroconches , monoplacophores, gastropodes ) d e 1'Ordovicie n inferieur (Tremadocien-Arenigien ) de la Montagne Noire (Franc e meridionale) . Memoire d e l a Societe des Etudes Scientifiques d e I'Aude, 37-49.
76
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
1982/7. Tromelinodonta nov. gen., bivalv e lyrodesmatide (Mollusca ) d e 1'Arenigie n (Ordovicien Inferieur) . Geobios, 15, 423-427. & GUTIERREZ-MARCO , J . 1991 . Middl e Ordovicia n bivalves fro m Spai n an d thei r phyleti c an d palaeogeographic significance . Palaeontology, 34 , 109-147. & LE PENNEC, M. 1982 . Ontogenese et phylogenese, a propo s d e quelque s caractere s dentaire s de s mollusques bivalves. Malacologia, 22, 709-720 . BAILEY, J . B . 1983 . Middl e Devonia n Bivalvi a fro m th e Solsville Membe r (Marcellu s Formation) , centra l New Yor k State. Bulletin o f th e American Museum of Natural History, 174(3), 193-326. BERG-MADSEN, V . 1987 . Tuarangia fro m Bornhol m (Denmark) an d similaritie s i n Baltoscandia n an d Australasian lat e Middl e Cambria n faunas . Alcheringa, 11, 245-259. BEURLEN, K . 194 4 [1947] . Beitrag e zu r Stammes geschichte de r Muscheln . Sitzungsberichte de r Mathematisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen Abteilung der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften m Munchen, 1944 , 133-145 . Boss, K . J . 1982 . Mollusca . In: PARKER , S . P . (ed. ) Synopsis and Classification of Living Organisms. Volume 1 . McGraw-Hill, Ne w York, 945-1166. CAMPBELL, D. C, HOEKSTRA, K. J. & CARTER, J. G. 1998 . 18S ribosomal DN A and evolutionary relationship s within th e Bivalvia . In : JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART, J. W. (eds) Bivalves, an Eon o f Evolution — Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 75-85. CARTER, J . G . 1980 . Environmenta l an d biologica l controls o f bivalv e shel l mineralog y an d micro structure. In : LUTZ , R . A . & RHOADS , D . C . (eds ) Skeletal Growth o f Aquatic Organisms. Plenum , New York , 69-113. 1990. Evolutionar y significanc e o f shel l microstructure i n th e Palaeotaxodonta , Pterio morphia and Isofilibranchia. In , CARTER , J. G. (ed. ) Skeletal Biomineralization, Patterns, Processes, and Evolutionary Trends, Volume I . Va n Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 135-296. & LUTZ, R . A. 1990 . Bivalvia (Mollusca), Plates. In: CARTER, J . G . (ed. ) Skeletal Biomineralization, Patterns, Processes, and Evolutionary Trends, Volume II . Va n Nostran d Reinhold , Ne w York , 5-28, pi s 1-121. & SEED , R . 1998 . Therma l potentiatio n an d mineralogical evolutio n i n Mytilus (Mollusca ; Bivalvia). In : JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART , J . W. (eds ) Bivalves, a n Eo n o f Evolution — Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 87-117. CHAVAN, A. 1969. Superfamil y Crassatellacea. In : Cox, L . R. & 2 4 other s (eds ) 1969-197 1 Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca 6. Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y o f America , Boulder, CO, and University o f Kansas Press, Lawrence, KS, N562-N580. COPE, J. C. W. 19960. The early evolution of the Bivalvia. In: TAYLOR , J . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary
Radiation of the Mollusca. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 361-370 . 19966. Early Ordovician (Arenig ) bivalves fro m th e Llangynog inlier , Sout h Wales . Palaeontology, 39 , 979-1025. 1997. Th e earl y phylogen y o f th e clas s Bivalvia . Palaeontology, 40, 713-746. 1999. Middle Ordovicia n bivalve s fro m mid-Wale s and th e Wels h Borderland . Palaeontology, 42 , 467^99. Cox, L . R . & 2 4 OTHERS . 1969-1971 . In: MOORE , R . C . (ed.) Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca 6 . Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y o f America, Boulder , CO , an d Universit y o f Kansa s Press, Lawrence, KS, 1, 1969, xxxvii , N1-N489; 2, 1969, ii , N491-N952; 3, 1971 , iv , N953-N1124. DALL, W . H. 1889 . O n th e hing e o f pelecypod s an d it s development, wit h a n attemp t towar d a bette r subdivision o f th e group . American Journal o f Science, 38, 445-462. 1898. Contributions to the Tertiary fauna of Florida. Transactions of the Wagner Free Institute of Science of Philadelphia, 3(4) , 571-948 . DECHASEAUX, C . 1952 . Class e de s Lamellibranches . In : PIVETEAUX, J . (ed. ) Traite d e Paleontologie, Tom e II. Masson et Cie, Paris, 220-364. DESBIENS, S . 1994 . Le s bivalve s Cyrtodontace a Ulric h 1894 d e l a Formatio n d e Yor k River , Emsie n d e Gaspesie, Quebec. Geobios, 27, 449-458. DESPARMET, R., TERMIER, G. & TERMIER, H. 1971 . Su r u n bivalve protobranche ante-Arenigien trouve au nord de Wardak (Afghanistan). Geobios, 4, 143-150. DZIK, J . 1994 . Evolutio n o f 'smal l shell y fossils ' assemblages. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica, 39 , 247-313. FANG, Z . 1998 . Revisio n an d taxonomi c positio n o f th e aberrant Devonian bivalve Beichuania. In: MORTON , B. (ed.) Th e Bivalvia - Proceedings of a Memorial Symposium in Honour of Sir Charles Maurice Yonge, Edinburgh, 1986. Hon g Kon g Universit y Press, Hong Kong, 185-191 . & MORRIS , N . J . 1997 . Th e genu s Pseudosanguinolites an d som e modiolifor m bivalves (mainly Palaeozoic). Palaeoworld, Press of University o f Science an d Technolog y o f China, 7, 49-69. FERUSSAC, A . E . D E 1822. Tableaux Systematiques de s Animaux Mollusques classes en families naturelles, dans lesquels on a etablis la concordance de tous les sysfemes. A . Bertrand, London. FISCHER, P . H. 1880-1887 . Manuel d e Conchyliologie e t de Paleontologie Conchyliologique. F. Savy, Paris. FLEMING, J. 1828. A History of British Animals, Exhibiting the Descriptive Characters and Systematical Arrangement of the Genera and Species of Quadrupeds, Birds, Reptiles, Fishes, Mollusca, and Radiata o f th e United Kingdom. Bel l & Bradfute , Edinburgh. FRECH, F . 1891 . Di e devonische n Aviculide n Deutschlands, ei n Beitra g zu r Systemati k un d Stammesgeschichte der Zweischaler. Abhandlungen z. Geolologischen Specialkarte von Preussen und den Thuringischen Staaten, 9(3) . GEYER, G . & STRENG , M . 1998 . Middl e Cambria n
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTION pelecypods fro m th e Anti-Atlas , Morocco . Revista Espanola de Paleontologia, num. extr. Homenaje al Prof. Gonzalo Vidal, 83-96 . GRAY, J . E . 1824 . A natura l arrangemen t o f Mollusc a according t o interna l structure . Repository, 15 , 229-239. 1840. Synopsis o f th e contents o f th e British Museum, 42n d Edition. Britis h Museum , London . 1847. A list of the genera of Recent Mollusca, thei r synonyms and types. Proceedings of th e Zoological Society o f London, 15, 129-219. GROBBEN, K . 1894 . Zur Kenntnis s der Morphologic , de r Verwandschaftsverhaltnisse un d de s System s de r Mollusken. Sitzungsberichte de r MathematischNaturwissenschaftlichen Classe der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien, 103 , 61-86. HALL, J . 1885 . Lamellibranchiata II, Text an d Plates. Containing Descriptions and Figures of the Dimyaria of the Upper Helderberg, Hamilton, Portage, and Chemung Groups. Geological Survey of the State of New York, Paleontology, Vol. 5, Pt. 1. Van Benthuyse n & Sons , Albany , Ne w York , 269-562, pis 34-80, 93-96. HARRISON, W . B . Il l & HARRISON , L . K . 1975 . A Maquoketa-like mollusca n communit y i n th e Brassfield Formatio n (earl y Silurian ) o f Adam s County, Ohio . Bulletins o f American Paleontology, 67, 193-234. HASZPRUNAR, G . 1983 . Comparativ e analysi s o f th e abdominal sens e organ s o f Pteriomorphi a (Bivalvia). Journal o f Molluscan Studies, Supplement, 12A , 47-50. 1985. Th e fin e structur e o f th e abdomina l sens e organs o f Pteriomorphi a (Mollusca , Bivalvia) . Journal o f Molluscan Studies, 51, 315-319. HERBERS, K . 1914 . Entwicklungesgeschicht e vo n Anodonta cellensis Schroter . Zeitschrift fu r Wissenschaftliche Zoologie, 108, 1-174. HERTWIG, R . 1895 . Lehrbuch de r Zoologie, 3r d Edition . Jena. HINZ-SCHALLREUTER, I. 1995 . Muscheln (Pelecypoda) au s dem Mittelkambriu m vo n Bornholm . Geschiebekunde Aktuel, 11 , 71-84. HORNY, R . 1960 . O n th e phylogen y o f th e earlies t pelecypods (Mollusca) . Vestnik Ustfedniho Ustavu Geologickeho, 35, 479-482, pi. 1 . JOHNSTON, P. A. 1991 . Systematics an d ontogeny of a new bivalve, Umburra cinefacta, fro m th e Siluria n o f Australia, implication s fo r pteriomorphia n evolution. Alcheringa, 15 , 293-319. 1993. Lowe r Devonia n pelecypod s fro m southeastern Australia . Association o f Australasian Palaeontologists, Memoir, 14, 1-134. 1995. Evolutionary pathways in the bivalve subclass Pteriomorphia. In : JOHNSTON , P. A. (ed. ) Canadian Paleontology Conference Program and Abstracts, 5, 16-17 . 1996. Middl e Ordovicia n (Caradoc ) pelecypod s from th e Advanc e Formation , Britis h Columbia . Geological Survey o f Canada Bulletin, 491 , 113-129. & GOODBODY , Q . H . 1988 . Middl e Devonia n bivalves fro m Melvill e Island , Arcti c Canada . In : MCMILLAN, N. J., EMBRY, A. F. & GLASS, D . J . (eds)
77
Devonian of the World, Volume III: Paleontology, Paleoecology an d Biostatigraphy. Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists , Calgary , Alberta, Canada, 337-346. & ZHANG , R . 1998 . Re-interpretation o f Sinodora Pojeta an d Zhang , 1984 , a n unusua l bivalv e (Trigonoida) fro m th e Devonia n o f China . In : JOHNSTON, P . A. & HAGGART , J . W . (eds) Bivalves, An Eon of Evolution — Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. University of Calgary Press, Calgary, 361-375. KEEN, A . M . 1958 . Marine Shells o f Tropical West America. Stanfor d University Press, Stanford, CA. KOROBKOV, I. A. 1954 . Handbook an d Methodical Guide to the Tertiary Mollusca, Lamellibranchiata. Gosud. Nauchno-tecno'i Isledov. Nefti . Gorno-toplivnoi litry, Leningradskoi Otdeleni e [in Russian], 1960. Rhombopteriidae/am. nov. In: EBERZIN, A . G. (ed.) Osnovui Paleontologhii. Spravochnik dlya paleontologov i geologov SSSR. 3, Mollyuski, Pantsirnye. Dvustvorchatye, Lopatonogie. Moskva, Izdatel'stvo Akademi i Nau k SSSR, 81 . KOUCHINSKY, A . V . 1999 . Shell microstructure s o f th e Early Cambria n Anabarella an d Watsonella a s new evidence o n th e origi n o f th e Rostroconchia . Lethaia,32, 173-180. KRASILOVA, I. N. 1959. A new family Leiopectinidae from the Uppe r Siluria n an d Lowe r Devonia n o f th e northeastern par t o f th e Balkhas h region . Paleontologicheskiai Zhurnal, 1959(2) , 41-4 6 [i n Russian]. LAMARCK, J . B . P . A . D E M. D E 1815-1822. Histoire Naturelle des Animaux sans Vertebres, Volumes 1-7. Verdiere & Deterville, Pari s [se e Volume 6, Part 1 , 1819] LILJEDAHL, L . 19840 . Siluria n silicifie d bivalve s fro m Gotland. Sveriges Geologiska Undersokning, Avhandlingar oc h Uppsater, Seri e C , Nr . 804, 78, 1-82. 1984/7. Silicifie d Siluria n bivalve s fro m Gotland . Lund Publications in Geology, 24, 1-28 . 1994. Silurian nuculoid and modiomorphid bivalves from Sweden . Fossils and Strata, 33, 1-89 . LINNE, K . 1758 . Systerna Naturae pe r Tria Regna Naturae. Edit, decima, L Laurenti i Salvii , Stockholm. MACKINNON, D . I . 1982 . Tuarangia paparua n . gen. and n. sp., a late Middle Cambria n pelecypo d fro m New Zealand. Journal o f Paleontology, 56 , 589-598. 1985. New Zealand lat e Middle Cambria n mollusc s and th e origi n o f Rostroconchi a an d Bivalvia . Alcheringa, 9, 65-81. McALESTER, A. L. 1969 . Family Praenuculidae . In : Cox, L. R . & 2 4 other s (eds ) 1969-1971. Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca 6, Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y o f America , Boulder , CO, and University of Kansas Press, Lawrence, KS, N229-N230. MCROBERTS, C . A . & CARTER , J . G . 1994 . Nacre i n a n early gryphaei d bivalv e (Mollusca) . Journal o f Paleontology, 68, 1405-1408 . MILLER, S . A. 1877 . Th e American Palaeozoic Fossils, a Catalogue of the Genera and Species, with Names of Authors, Dates, Places of Publication, Groups of
78
J. G . CARTE R ETAL.
Rocks in Which Found, and the Etymology and Significance of the Words, and an Introduction Devoted to the Strati graphical Geology of the Palaeozoic Rocks. Publishe d b y th e author , Cincinnati Time s Co . Boo k an d Jo b Rooms , Cincinnati, Ohio. MORRIS, N . J . 1979 . On th e origi n o f th e Bivalvia . In: HOUSE, M . R . (ed. ) Th e Origin o f Major Invertebrate Groups. Systematic s Associatio n Special Volum e No. 12 , Academic Press , London , 381-413. 1980. A new Lower Ordovicia n bivalv e family , the Thoraliidae (?Nuculoida), interprete d a s actinodon t deposit feeders . Bulletin o f th e British Museum o f Natural History (Geology), 34 , 265-272. & FORTEY , R . A . 1976 . Th e significanc e o f Tironucula gen. nov. t o th e stud y o f bivalv e evolution. Journal o f Paleontology, 50, 701-709. , DICKINS , J . M . & ASTAFIEVA-URBAITIS , K . 1991 . Upper Palaeozoi c anomalodesmata n Bivalvia . Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History), Geology, 47 , 51-100. MUTVEI, H . 1970 . Ultrastructur e o f th e minera l an d organic component s o f mollusca n nacreou s layer . Biomineralization Research Reports, 2, 48-61. 1983. Ultrastructural evolution of molluscan nacre. In: WESTBROEK , P . & D E JONG , E . W . (eds ) Biomineralization and Biological Metal Accumulation. D. Reidel Co. , Boston, 261-21 \. NEWELL, N . D . 1942 . Lat e Paleozoi c pelecypods , Mytilacea. State Geological Survey o f Kansas, 10 , 1-115. 1969. Classificatio n o f Bivalvia , an d Superfamil y Modiomorphacea. In: Cox, L. R. & 24 others (eds) 1969-1971. Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca 6, Bivalvia. Geological Societ y of America, Boulder , CO , an d Universit y o f Kansa s Press, Lawrence , KS , N205-N224 , an d N393-N399. & BOYD , D . W . 1975 . Parallel evolutio n i n earl y Trigoniacean bivalves . Bulletin o f th e American Museum o f Natural History, 154(2), 53-162. OCKELMANN, K . & WAREN , A . 1998 . Taxonom y an d biological note s o n the bivalve genus Microgloma, with comment s o n protobranc h nomenclature . Ophelia, 48, 1-24 . ORBIGNY, A . D' , 184 4 [1843] . Paleontologie Frangais terrains cretaces, Volume 3 , Mollusques. G . Masson, Paris . POJETA, J. JR 1971. Review of Ordovician pelecypods . U S Geological Survey Professional Paper, 695 , 1-46 , pis 1-20 . 1975. Fordilla troyensis Barrand e an d earl y pelecypod phylogeny . Bulletins o f American Paleontology, 67, 363-384. 1978. Th e origi n an d earl y taxonomi c diversification o f pelecypods . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, 284, 225-246. 1980. Mollusca n phylogeny . Tulane Studies i n Geology an d Paleontology, 16, 55-80. 1985. Earl y evolutionar y histor y o f diasom e mollusks. In : BROADHEAD , T . W . (ed. ) Mollusks, Notes for a Short Course. University of Tennessee
Department o f Geologica l Sciences , Studie s i n Geology, 13 , 102-130 . 1988. Th e origi n an d Paleozoi c diversificatio n o f solemyoid pelecypods . Ne w Mexico Bureau o f Mines an d Mineral Resources Memoir, 44 , 201-271. & GILBERT-TOMLINSON , J . 1977 . Australia n Ordovician pelecypo d molluscs . Bulletin o f th e Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics, 174, 1-64, pis 1-29 . & RUNNEGAR , B . 1974 . Fordilla troyensis an d th e early histor y o f pelecypo d mollusks . American Scientist, 62, 706-711. & 1985 . Th e earl y evolutio n o f diasom e molluscs. In : WILBUR , K . M . (ed. ) The Mollusca, Volume 10 , Evolution. Academi c Press , London , 295-336. RAFINESQUE, C. S. 1815 . Analyse d e la Nature ou Tableau de L'Univers et des Corps Organises. Published by the author, Palerme, 1-214 . RATTER, V. A. & COPE , J. C . W . 1998 . New neotaxodon t bivalves from th e Silurian o f South Wales an d their phylogenetic significance . Palaeontology, 41 , 975-991. RUNNEGAR, B . N . 1983 . Molluscan phylogen y revisited . Memoirs of the Association of Australasian Palaeontologists, 1 , 121-144. 1985. Shel l microstructure s o f Cambria n molluscs replicate d b y phosphate . Alcheringa, 9 , 245-257. 1996. Earl y evolutio n o f th e Mollusca , th e fossi l record. In: TAYLOR, J. (ed.) Origin and Evolutionary Radiation of th e Mollusca. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 77-87 . & BENTLEY , C . 1983 . Anatomy , ecolog y an d affinities o f the Australia n earl y Cambria n bivalv e Pojetaia runnegari Jell . Journal o f Paleontology, 57, 73-92. & JELL , P . A . 1976 . Australian Middl e Cambria n molluscs an d thei r bearin g o n earl y mollusca n evolution. Alcheringa, 1 , 109-138. & POJETA , J . J R 1974 . Fordilla troyensis an d th e early histor y o f pelecypo d mollusks . American Scientist, 62, 706-711. & 1992 . Th e earlies t bivalve s an d thei r Ordovician descendants . American Malacological Bulletin, 9, 117-122. SALVINI-PLAWEN, L . V . & STEINER , G . 1996 . Synapomorphies an d plesiomorphie s i n highe r classification o f Mollusca . In : TAYLOR , J . (ed. ) Origin and Evolutionary Radiation of the Mollusca. Oxford Universit y Press , Oxford, 29-51. SANCHEZ, T . M . 1995 . Comment s o n th e genu s Catamarcaia Sanche z an d Babi n an d th e origi n o f the Arcoida. Geobios, 28, 343-346. & BABIN , C . 1998 . The origi n o f actinodon t fro m taxodont dentitio n o r vic e versa , a n unnecessar y controversy? In: JOHNSTON , P. A. & HAGGART, J. W (eds) Bivalves, A n Eo n o f Evolution — Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 409-^12. SANDERS, H. L. & ALLEN, J. A. 1973 . Studies on deep-se a Protobranchia (Bivalvia) ; prologu e an d th e
EARLY BIVALV E EVOLUTION Pristiglomidae. Bulletin o f th e Museum o f Comparative Zoology, 145 , 237-362 . SCARLATO, O . A . & STARABOGATOV , Y . I . 1978 . Phylogenetic relation s an d the early evolution o f the class Bivalvia . Philosophical Transactions o f th e Royal Society o f London, Series B , 284 , 217-224. & 1979 . General evolutionary patterns and the system o f th e clas s Bivalvia . Trudy Zoologicheskogo Instituta, Akademiya Nauk, SSSR, 80,5-38 [in Russian]. SCOTT, H . W . 1961 . Shel l morpholog y o f Ostracoda . In : BENSON, R . H . & 1 6 others. In : MOORE , R. C . (ed. ) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part Q, Arthropoda 3 , Crustacea, Ostracoda. Geologica l Society of America, Boulder, CO, and University of Kansas Press, Lawrence, KS, Q21-Q37. SMITH, A . B . 1994 . Systematics an d th e Fossil Record, Documenting Evolutionary Patterns. Blackwel l Scientific Publications , Oxford . STAROBOGATOV, Y . I . 1992 . Morphologica l basi s fo r phylogeny and classification of Bivalvia. Ruthenica, 2, 1-25 . STOLICZKA, F . 1870-1871 . Cretaceou s faun a o f souther n India. 3 . Th e Pelecypoda , wit h a revie w o f al l known gener a o f thi s class , fossi l an d Recent . Geological Survey of India, Palaeontologica Indica, Series 6, 3, 1-537. SWOFFORD, D . L . 1998 . PAUP*. Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). Version 4b2a. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland , MA. TAYLOR, J . D . 1973 . Th e structura l evolutio n o f th e bivalve shell . Palaeontology, 16 , 519-534. TUNNICLIFF, S . P. 1987. Caradocia n bivalv e molluscs fro m Wales. Palaeontology, 30, 677-690, pis 76-77. ULRICH, E . O . 1893 . Ne w an d littl e know n Lamellibranchiata fro m th e Lower Siluria n rocks of Ohio an d adjacen t states. Report o f th e Geological Survey o f Ohio, 1, 627-693, pis 45-56.
79
1894. Th e Lowe r Siluria n Lamellibranchiat a o f Minnesota. In : Final Report o f th e Geological an d Natural History Survey of Minnesota, Volume 3, 475-628 [publishe d separatel y i n 189 4 prio r t o the entire Volume 3 in 1897]. WALLER, T . 1990 . Th e evolutio n o f ligamen t system s i n the Bivalvia . In , MORTON , B . (ed.) Th e Bivalvia Proceedings of a Memorial Symposium in Honour of Sir Charles Maurice Yonge, Edinburgh, 1986. Hong Kon g University Press , Hong Kong , 47-91. 1998. Origin o f the molluscan clas s Bivalvia an d a phylogeny o f majo r groups . In : JOHNSTON , P . A. & HAGGART, J . W. (eds) Bivalves, An Eo n o f Evolution — Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 1-45. WIENS, J . J . 1998 . Doe s addin g character s wit h missin g data increas e o r decreas e phylogeneti c accuracy ? Systematic Biology, 47, 625-640. & SERVEDIO , M . R. 1997 . Accurac y o f phylogeneti c analysis includin g an d excludin g polymorphi c characters. Systematic Biology, 46, 332-345. WOHRMANN, S . F . VO N 1893. Uebe r di e systematisch e Stellung de r Trigonide n un d di e Abstammun g de r Nayaden. Jahrbuch de r Kaiserlich-Koniglichen Geologischen Reichsanstalt, Wien, 43, 1-28 . YONGE, C . M . 1939 . Th e protobranchiat e Mollusca ; a functional interpretatio n o f thei r structur e an d evolution. Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society o f London, Series B, 230, 79-147 . 1953. For m an d habi t i n Pinna carnea Gmelin . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, 237, 335-374 . 1977. For m an d evolutio n i n th e Anomiace a (Mollusca, Bivalvia ) - Pododesmus, Anomia, Patro, Enigmonia (Anomiidae) , Placunanomia, Placuna (Placunidae fam. nov.}. Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society o f London, Series B , 276 , 453-523.
This page intentionally left blank
A new look at early bivalve phylogeny JOHN C. W. COPE Department of Earth Sciences, Cardiff University, PO Box 914, Cardiff CF10 3YE, UK (e-mail:
[email protected]) Abstract: I n th e 3 0 years sinc e publication o f th e bivalv e Treatise, (Moore , R . C . (ed.) 1969. Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N . Mollusca 6 , Bivalvia, Geologica l Societ y o f America and University of Kansas) important new faunas have been described fro m the early and mid Cambria n an d fro m th e earl y an d mi d Ordovician . Thes e contai n significan t ne w forms , including som e long-rangin g intermediat e groups , tha t indicat e th e relationship s betwee n th e principal bivalv e clades , bu t lack o f fossils fro m th e late Cambria n an d earliest Ordovician i s a major hindrance . Th e principal phas e o f bivalve diversificatio n followe d o n from th e evolutio n of th e filibranch gill in the latest Cambria n or earliest Ordovician . Th e fundamenta l division of the class is into two subclasses, Protobranchia an d Autolamelli branchiata; links between the two can be demonstrated in the early Ordovician. Major division s of each subclas s are recognized a s superorders. Within th e Protobranchia , th e Nuculoid a develope d specialis t food-gatherin g palp s an d a n enlarged foot . Divergin g earl y fro m th e protobranc h stoc k wer e othe r bivalve s tha t live d symbiotically wit h sulphur-oxidizin g chemoautotrophi c bacteria ; thi s allowe d colonizatio n o f anaerobic substrate s an d produce d tw o distinc t stocks : th e deepl y infauna l anteriorl y elongat e Solemyoida an d the shallower infaunal Nucinelloida . The Autolamellibranchiata, initially identified by strongly asymmetrical hinges, diversified in three directions, each characterized by distinctive hinges. The Trigonioida were characterized by ligamental nymph s and frequently denticulat e teeth , an d rapidly regaine d greate r symmetry ; the Anomalodesmata als o develope d a stron g ligamenta l insertio n withi n nymph s an d largel y los t their dentition , whils t th e Heteroconchia, principall y wit h a shell includin g a complex crossed lamellar structure , ha d variou s combination s o f cardina l an d latera l teeth . Heteroconc h diversifications wer e mainl y i n th e Mesozoi c an d Cenozoic , bu t on e Ordovicia n group , th e Glyptarcoidea, i s a good ancestor for the Pteriomorphia. The followin g ne w tax a ar e proposed: Cardiolarioide a superfam . nov., Eritropidae fam . nov. and Catamarcaidae fam. nov.
The phylogen y o f th e bivalve s ha s becom e muc h Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinso n 1977 ; Babi n 1982a ; better understoo d ove r th e past 3 0 years an d credit Babi n & Gutierrez-Marco 1991 ; Cop e 1996 , 1999) , for thi s i s du e t o th e renewa l o f interes t i n earl y whic h hav e extende d th e know n range s o f man y Palaeozoic bivalve s followin g a perio d o f man y bivalv e group s an d yielde d intermediat e fossil s years during which interest i n these fossils appear s crucia l t o the understanding o f bivalve evolution , to hav e bee n minimal . I n turn , thi s followe d o n from th e frenzy o f naming new species and genera The earliest bivalves in th e middl e year s o f th e las t century . Th e latel y renewed interes t wa s initiate d b y tw o importan t Knowledg e o f Cambria n bivalve s ha s als o publications: Babin' s (1966 ) descriptio n o f th e increase d dramaticall y ove r pas t 3 0 years . Pojet a Ordovician fauna s o f Brittan y an d Pojeta's (1971 ) (1971 ) examine d th e variou s putativ e Cambria n now classic review of Ordovician bivalves. Both of bivalve s then recorded an d conclude d tha t none of these works demonstrated the unexpected diversity the m could be unequivocally regarded a s a bivalve, of Ordovicia n bivalves , bu t a t tha t tim e link s Pojeta' s (1971 ) suspicion s abou t Lamellodonta between variou s group s o f Ordovicia n bivalve s wer e confirme d whe n Havlice k & Kri z (1978 ) were largely unknown and several major group s of demonstrate d tha t th e mid-Cambria n genus , bivalves wer e the n unknow n befor e th e mi d though t a t th e tim e o f publicatio n o f th e bivalv e Ordovician. Since then important faunas hav e been Treatise (Co x et al 1969 ) to be the earliest bivalve, described fro m th e earl y an d mid-Ordovician (e.g . wa s in fact a distorted obolelli d brachiopod. Pojet a From: HARPER , E. M., TAYLOR , J. D. & CRAME, J. A. (eds) The Evolutionary Biology of th e Bivalvia. Geological Society , London, Specia l Publications, 177 , 81-95. 1-86239-076-2/007 $ 15.00 © The Geological Society o f London 2000 .
82
J. C . W . COPE
(1973, 1975 ) undertoo k a stud y o f th e earl y Cambrian genu s Fordilla an d establishe d tha t i t was indee d a bivalve . Jel l (1980 ) describe d th e early Cambria n genu s Pojetaia tha t is no w known to be widely distributed in early and mid-Cambrian rocks, an d subsequentl y ne w form s hav e bee n described fro m th e early and mid-Cambrian (Berg Madsen 1987 ; Hinz-Schallreute r 1995 ; Geye r & Streng 1998) . I n additio n t o Pojetaia, th e middl e Cambrian bivalve s includ e th e gener a Tuarangia and Camya, which ar e both o f unknown affinities . The genus Arhouriella, describe d fro m th e Middl e Cambrian o f Morocc o (Geye r & Stren g 1998) , i s clearly differen t fro m othe r Cambria n bivalve taxa described hithert o an d th e author s o f th e genu s were unable to suggest a suitable higher level taxon for it. Arhouriella is based on two right valves (only one, th e holotype , show s man y features ) bu t thi s identification depend s upo n th e state d orientation . It bears two peg-like teeth and also seems to have a long posterio r latera l tooth , no t note d i n th e description bu t visibl e i n Geye r & Streng' s illustration (1998 , pi . 7 , fig . A ; se e als o Fig . la) . Geyer & Stren g (1998 , pp . 93 , 94 ) suggeste d tha t Arhouriella ha d a n amphideti c ligament ; th e authors sugges t tw o ligamenta l sites , on e anterio r and one posterior t o the umbones (Geyer & Streng 1998, fig . 8) . I f th e sit e identifie d a s a posterio r ligamental sit e i s such , then this valve is correctl y identified a s a righ t valve . If , however , th e othe r site (Geye r & Streng 1998 , fig . 8, af) wa s th e sol e ligamental site , the n th e specime n shoul d b e interpreted a s a lef t valve . On e peculiar featur e o f Arhouriella i s tha t i t apparentl y doe s no t hav e properly differentiate d denta l sockets ; th e author s believed that this was due to the teeth growing later over the mid part of a juvenile elongate amphidetic ligament Althoug h ther e ar e som e superficia l resemblances t o nucinelloid s (particularl y i f th e holotype wer e i n realit y a lef t valve ) to o littl e i s known abou t Arhouriella t o dra w an y fir m conclusion of its affinities . There stil l remain s onl y a singl e bivalv e speci men known worldwide from rocks of late Cambrian age (Berg-Madsen 1987 ) an d this persistent ga p in the bivalve record i s particularly unfortunate sinc e it is now apparen t tha t this fairly clearl y coincide s with th e appearanc e o f th e filibranc h gil l (Cop e 1995, 1991 b). It is also very apparent that many of the problem s tha t stil l remai n i n earl y bivalv e evolution wil l onl y b e resolve d b y th e discover y and descriptio n o f fauna s fro m thi s late Cambria n lacuna. Cambrian bivalve s ar e certainl y ver y smal l an d these earl y form s nee d no t hav e bee n shallo w infaunal form s tha t comparison s wit h moder n nuculoids have suggested. Tevesz & McCall (1976) suggested tha t bivalve s o f < 1 cm i n lengt h coul d
have functioned equall y wel l as epifaunal crawler s (as thei r tergomya n ancestor s almos t certainl y were). Morto n (1995 ) als o viewe d thes e earl y forms a s surface dwellers that used thei r foo t bot h for feeding and locomotion. Cope (1995) noted that very smal l bivalve s coul d onl y hav e survive d infaunally i n ver y fin e sediment . Thus , th e lif e habits of these early forms are not well-established , but th e adven t o f large r size s i n th e earlies t Ordovician woul d hav e mad e a greate r variet y o f habitats possible . Knowledge o f th e earlies t Ordovicia n bivalv e faunas is also scant. From the early Tremadoc there are onl y a handfu l o f poorl y preserve d mould s described b y Harringto n (1938) , whils t th e lat e Tremadoc fauna s describe d b y Harringto n (1938) , Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinso n (1977 ) an d Babi n (1982a), totallin g perhap s te n specie s fro m th e whole o f th e Tremado c Series , merel y hin t a t th e variety o f form s tha t ar e certai n t o b e discovered . The discoverie s o f th e pas t 2 5 year s hav e take n back the origins of many groups to far earlier in the geological pas t tha n wa s conceive d whe n th e Treatise (Co x et al 1969 ) wa s published, but ther e remains this major ga p in knowledge . By th e earl y Ordovician , bivalve s wer e apparently restricte d t o th e peri-Gondwana n sea s (Cope & Babi n 1999) , wherea s i n th e earl y Cambrian the y appea r t o hav e a cosmopolita n distribution. I n th e mi d Cambria n the y ar e known from Baltic a an d Gondwana , an d th e singl e lat e Cambrian specime n i s also Baltican (Berg-Madse n 1987). Earl y bivalve s wer e largel y restricte d t o inshore silt y mud s (Cop e 1996 ) bu t th e lat e Cambrian margin s o f bot h Gondwan a an d Baltic a were largel y rifted , thu s suc h clos e inshor e facie s are consequently rare and this may well explain the, so far, disjunct early bivalve fossil recor d (Cop e & Babin 1999) .
Bivalve taxonomy In trying to produce a satisfactory classification for the bivalves, a large number of schemes have been, and continu e to be, proposed. Th e principal divid e in thes e scheme s ha s bee n betwee n th e zoologist s who naturally rely on soft-part anatomy in drawing distinctions and the palaeontological approac h tha t has largel y relie d upo n feature s suc h a s dentitio n and musculature , togethe r wit h th e fossi l record . More recently , studie s o f shel l microstructur e (Taylor et al 1969 , 1973 ; Carter 1990 ) have added further informatio n t o hel p elucidat e phylogeny , whilst molecula r phylogenie s ar e no w als o bein g reconstructed, base d o n 18 S ribosoma l DN A (rDNA) (e.g . Adamkewic z e t al . 1997) . However , with th e discover y o f ne w fauna s fro m th e Cambrian an d Ordovicia n rock s ove r th e pas t 2 5
BIVALVE PHYLOGEN Y 8
3
Fig. 1 . (a) Arhouriella opheodontoides Geye r & Streng, 1998, Middle Cambrian, Morocco. Holotype: right valve; x 44. Reproduced by permission o f the Societa Espanola di Paleontologia. (b ) Nucinella sohli Pojeta, 1988 , paratype , Upper Cretaceous, Georgia , USA . Photograph kindl y supplie d by J. Pojeta Jr. Holotype: left valve ; x 35. Reproduce d by permission o f the New Mexico Burea u of Mines and Mineral Resources, (c) and (d) Ovatoconcha fragilis Cope , 1996. Moridunian Stage, Arenig, Lower Ordovician, South Wales, (c) Holotype: right valve view of conjoined valves of a silicified composite mould, showing muscle scars; x 3 . (d) External impression of the posterior portio n of a lef t valve, to which the outer part of the silicified shel l adheres , showin g umbonal region and possible periostraca l fring e beyond the mineralized shel l margin , (e) Noradonta redoniaeformis (Thoral) , Lowe r Arenig , Lowe r Ordovician , Montagne Noire. Holotype: left valv e showing cardinal teeth (?two missing) lying beneath lin e of hinge along crenulate posterior tooth, posterior par t of which appears to be of discrete teeth of palaeotaxodontid type. This specie s appears to be a link between N. shergoldi Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson and the cardiolarioids; x 4, Negative kindly loaned by C. Babin. (f) Eritropis peregrinata Cope, Lower Llanvirn, Middl e Ordovician , Mid-Wales . Holotype: lef t valve internal moul d prepared t o show cardiolarioid dentition; x 3.
84
J. C . W . COPE
years, the possibility of a taxonomic scheme based on phylogen y derive d fro m th e fossi l recor d ha s become much more of a realizable objective. One of the ways in which it has been possible t o advance th e understandin g o f th e method(s ) b y which bivalve s evolve d i s th e recognition tha t th e evolution o f the filibranch gil l from a protobranc h gill wa s a singl e evolutionar y ste p (Cop e 1995) . Too ofte n i n th e past , palaeontologist s hav e believed that it would not be possible to determine the gill grade of extinct bivalves and because of this there develope d th e feelin g tha t al l Ordovicia n bivalve group s mus t hav e bee n protobranc h an d that th e filibranc h gil l evolve d separatel y i n different bivalv e groups i n the early Silurian . Suc h a view has also been expressed a s recently as 1997: 'the gills [of most bivalve groups] probably crossed a functiona l threshold during the late Ordovician early Silurian, operating as nutrient filters as well as respiratory organs ' (Bento n & Harpe r 1997 , p . 177). Recognizing that the hinges of some bivalves of palaeotaxodont grad e wer e strongl y asymmetrical , so tha t th e hing e la y alon g th e lin e o f posterio r taxodont teet h whils t th e large r anterio r teet h la y below the hinge, Cope (1995 ) suggeste d tha t these hinges were designed for wider valve opening; the larger anterio r teet h ensurin g tha t ful l denta l articulation wa s preserve d eve n wit h a wid e shel l opening. Cop e (1995 ) correlate d thi s wit h th e evolution of the filibranch gill and the concomitan t need t o voi d pseudofaeces ; later , Cop e (1997Z? ) erected th e famil y Cardiolariida e t o accommodat e such forms. The Cardiolaridae were assigned to the subclass Palaeotaxodont a although , a s argue d b y Cope (1997Z?) , the y wer e likel y t o hav e ha d filibranch gills . Contemporary nuculoids (members of th e famil y Praenuculidae) , o n th e othe r hand , show no such modifications an d early, mid and late Ordovician praenuculi d gener a hav e hing e teet h that, with a wide valve opening, would readily have lost denta l articulatio n a s th e valve s wer e pro gressively opened . B y th e Silurian , however , nuculoid genera such as Nuculoidea sho w enlarged teeth at the anterior and posterior extremities of the hinge plate . Thes e to o ar e clearl y designe d t o accommodate greate r openin g o f the valves, but in this cas e th e hing e i s approximatel y symmetrical , there i s a n interna l resiliu m an d th e augmente d valve openin g the n possible seem s mor e likel y t o be associated with a greatly enlarged foot, a feature characteristic of the Recent Nucula, and which can therefore be assumed to date back to no earlier than the Siluria n whe n th e earlies t nuculoid s wit h a n internal resilium occu r (Pojet a 1971) . It no w seem s clea r tha t th e positio n ha s bee n reached wher e th e tw o subclasse s recognize d b y neontologists ca n b e separate d wit h confidence ,
and thu s th e tim e i s rip e t o produc e a unifie d taxonomic schem e tha t ma y b e use d b y bot h zoologists an d palaeontologists. I n Cope's (1991 b, p. 715) review of bivalve phylogeny, it is noted that 'it may be .. . that a taxonomically mor e defensibl e position woul d b e t o regar d .. . major division s o f the clas s a s superorder s rathe r tha n subclasses' . Therefore, i n thi s accoun t o f bivalv e phylogeny , only tw o subclasse s ar e recognized , th e Proto branchia an d th e Autolamellibranchiata . Withi n each o f thes e subclasse s man y o f th e highes t category subdivisions are ordinal, but in some cases a superordina l categor y i s als o use d for categorie s which had previously bee n regarde d a s subclasse s by palaeontologists . Thi s classificatio n base d o n two subclasse s wa s firs t employe d b y Grobbe n
Fig. 2 . Proposed phylogenetic relationships within the class Bivalvia. The separat e derivation of the Trigonioida, Heteroconchia an d Pteriomorphia from a cardiolarioid ancestor i s supported b y bivalves showin g intermediate character s a s follows: (1 ) cardiolarioid dentition links directly to the early Ordovician Noradonta redoniaeformis (Thoral ) - se e Fig. le ; in turn, this can be linked to N. shergoldi (Pojeta & GilbertTomlinson), Tromelinodonta and thence t o Lyrodesma (see Babin 1982/7 , fig. 1) ; (2) Waller (1998, fig . 5) has shown how the dentition of a 'malletiid ' o r a cardiolarioid (Waller 1998, p. 36) links to other cardiolarioids lik e Inaequidens, thence via Ekaterodonta to a cycloconchid suc h as Copidens (or indeed t o an earlier for m suc h as Carminodonta); (3 ) Cope (1995 , fig. 30.1) showed how the dentition of Cardiolaria linked it to Glyptarca, whils t Ratter & Cope (1998, fig . 7) showed how Glyptarca coul d have given rise to a form that was ancestral t o both arcoids an d cyrtodonts a t the base of the pteriomorphian stocks.
BIVALVE PHYLOGEN Y
(1894) bu t ha s subsequentl y bee n use d b y man y other workers, including Allen (1985), Cox (1959), Waller (1978, 1990 , 1998 ) and Yonge (1959).
Subclass Protobranchi a Pelseneer , 188 9 This grou p i s unifie d b y th e protobranc h gil l tha t typifies the modern nuculoids and solemyoids. The protobranch ctenidium is also simila r t o the gill of primitive archaeogastropods , bu t differ s i n possessing latero-frontal cilia (Walle r 1998 ) an d is widely accepte d a s bein g clos e t o th e primitiv e molluscan gill . Th e earlies t Cambria n bivalves , Fordilla an d Pojetaia, hav e both been assigne d t o the palaeotaxodont s (Runnega r & Pojet a 1992) . These authors recorded that the shell microstructure of these two genera was similar an d resembled tha t of th e oute r shel l laye r o f a Devonia n nuculoi d described b y Carter (1990) , which clearly played a major rol e in making that assignment. Runnegar & Pojeta (1992), however, also left open the possibilty that thes e tw o gener a wer e stem-grou p bivalves . The Palaeotaxodont a mus t no w b e regarde d a s a paraphyletic unit, since the demonstration by Cop e (1995, 1997/? ) that at least one grou p of them was likely t o hav e ha d filibranc h gills , wherea s th e majority o f the palaeotaxodonts ca n be assigned t o the subclas s Protobranchia . Thus , palaeotaxodont s are here regarded a s an informal grade.
Nuculoids Many author s hav e considere d tha t th e genu s Nucula i s th e mos t primitiv e livin g bivalv e an d have modelle d th e anatom y o f earl y Palaeozoi c palaeotaxodont bivalve s o n it . Mor e recently , however, has come the realization tha t some of the features o f Nucula, suc h a s th e enlarge d foo t an d the larg e food-gatherin g palps , ar e specialization s that nee d no t hav e bee n presen t i n th e primitiv e bivalve (Morton 1995 ; Walle r 1998) . Alle n (1978) , in a stud y o f deep-se a protobranchs , argue d tha t both protobranch s an d autolamellibranch s coul d have evolved fro m a n ancestor lik e Nucinella (se e below). H e late r (Alle n 1985 ) conclude d tha t nucinellids were more primitive than nuculoids. It is at least possible tha t som e of the Cambria n bivalves may be nuculoids. The strongest candidat e here i s Pojetaia, whic h ha s palaeotaxodon t dentition an d a shel l structur e havin g element s i n common wit h a Devonia n nuculoi d (Runnega r & Pojeta 1992) . Most o f th e earl y Ordovicia n form s ca n b e included i n the family Praenuculidae, bu t man y of these ar e s o poorl y know n (o r ill-preserved ) tha t they tel l u s little . Th e thre e specie s figure d b y
85
Harrington (1938) , fro m th e Tremado c o f Argentina, a s specie s o f Ctenodonta ar e probabl y praenuculids, a s i s a t leas t on e specime n o f th e types o f th e specie s figure d b y hi m a s Cosmogoniophorina tenuicostata, a s note d b y Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson (1977, p. 11). The only other possibl e Tremado c praenuculi d wa s a for m figured by Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson (1977 , pi. 3, fig. 8 ) a s Deceptrixl sp . A . Althoug h almos t certainly no t a Deceptrix [se e discussio n b y Cop e (1997ft, pp . 736-738) ] thi s specimen , tha t ha s n o preserved dentition , is o f praenuculid shape . Cop e (1996) figured tw o genera of praenuculids from th e early Areni g o f Sout h Wale s (Paulinea an d Pensarnia) i n whic h detail s o f musculatur e an d dentition wer e wel l preserve d an d thes e remai n probably th e bes t know n earl y Ordovicia n nuculoids. I t appear s likel y tha t th e earlies t praenuculids gav e ris e t o th e asymmetricall y hinged cardiolariids ; tha t group may well show the connection betwee n th e protobranc h an d autolamellibranch bivalves (Cope 1995 , 1997ft) . I n the mi d Ordovician , praenuculid s becam e mor e diverse an d includ e form s lik e Similodonta an d Arcodonta (se e Cop e 1999) ; th e famil y continue d on into the Devonian. During th e earl y Ordovicia n nuculoid s diversi fied. Th e ctenodontids , whic h ma y hav e bee n derived fro m a praenuculi d ancesto r (se e below) , became anteriorl y enlarge d an d thei r umbone s migrated rearwards . Th e nuculanid s ar e repre sented, probably from the mid Ordovician onwards, by th e famil y Malletiidae , whos e shel l wa s posteriorly elongate. The majo r innovatio n i n th e nuculoi d stock s appeared i n th e earl y Siluria n whe n th e nuculid s developed a n internal ligament housed in a central resilifer o n th e hing e plate . Som e o f thes e form s developed large r teet h a t eac h en d o f th e hing e plate, suggestin g tha t they had already evolve d th e larger foo t tha t characterize s man y moder n nuculids.
Solemyoids Solemyoids ar e a long-ranging conservative group of protobranc h bivalve s tha t appea r t o hav e changed littl e sinc e th e earl y Ordovician ; the y ar e always dimyarian , alway s edentulou s an d the y often have a periostracum whic h is unusually thick. Harper (1997 , p . 7 6 ) recorde d periostraca l thick nesses o f 10- > 10 0 um, whils t Beedha m & Owen (1965) recorde d u p t o 14 0 (im. Th e periostracu m frequently project s beyond the calcifie d portio n of the valves ; th e valve s gap e anteriorl y an d posteriorly (Pojet a 1988 ; Cop e 1997ft) . Th e valves frequently hav e parallel dorsa l and ventral margins
86
J. C . W . COPE
and ther e ar e well-develope d radia l mantl e muscles. I n addition , Taylo r e t al (1969 ) reporte d that the calcareous shell microstructure o f Solemya was unique . It consist s o f a n oute r prismatic laye r with a unique prism form and an inner layer (that is irregular i n thicknes s an d distribution ) o f finel y laminated homogenou s aragonite . Sinc e then , Carter (1990 ) has examine d furthe r solemyid s an d found, fo r instance , tha t th e Uppe r Carboniferou s species Acharax (Nacrosolemya) trapezoides wa s partially nacreous . The reduce d gu t o f solemyoid s wa s a caus e o f much speculatio n o n their feedin g habit s tha t wa s resolved whe n Cavanaugh (1983) was able to show that the y live d symbioticall y wit h sulphur oxidizing chemoautotrophi c bacteria . I t i s no w known tha t bot h solemyoid s an d nucinelloid s ar e chemoautotrophic, a s note d b y Walle r (1998) ; h e therefore suggeste d tha t chemoautotrophi c symbiotic bacteri a wer e present 'a t the base of the Solemyoidea' (i n whic h h e include d th e nucinelloids) an d suggeste d tha t thi s wa s i n th e earlier par t o f th e Ordovician . Cop e (1996 ) described the solemyoid Ovatoconcha that alread y had anterio r an d posterio r shel l gapes , smal l posteriorly place d umbones , paralle l ventra l an d dorsal shel l margins , strongl y anisomyaria n musculature (with the anterior adducto r the larger ) and radial mantle muscles. In addition, Cope (1996) presented evidenc e t o sho w tha t th e shel l o f Ovatoconcha could have had a thick periostracum . The recen t discover y o f a specime n o f thi s genu s showing wha t appear s t o b e a periostraca l fring e extending beyond the calcified margin s of the shel l (but a t a n angl e t o them ) furthe r confirm s th e solemyoid natur e o f Ovatoconcha, an d tha t earl y Arenig solemyoid s ha d man y o f th e character s o f Recent forms. Figure I d show s this new specime n (NMW 78 . 17G . 1270b ) [compar e to o wit h th e Solemya parkinsoni figure d by Pojeta (1988 , pi . 1, fig. 9) , in which the angle between the periostraca l fringe an d the calcified portion of the shell is more acute]. The origin of the solemyoid s mus t thus go back further tha n the early Arenig. In many respects, th e fact tha t Ovatoconcha is s o like Recen t solemyid s reinforces Waller' s (1998 ) opinio n o n th e earl y origin o f th e chemoautotrophism, suggestin g tha t the divergenc e int o th e praenuculoi d typ e o f nuculoid an d th e chemoautotrophi c grou p o f bivalves mus t have occurred ver y early i n bivalve history. The Solemyida e ar e thu s a grou p tha t i s edentulous through its known stratigraphical range and the present autho r has no problem in including the edentulou s mid-lat e Ordovicia n genu s Psiloconcha in the Solemyoidea, a s was suggested by Pojeta (1988).
Nucinelloids One bivalv e grou p clearl y relate d zoologicall y t o the solemyid s i s th e Nucinelloidea . Th e shel l morphology o f nucinelloid s contrast s markedl y with tha t o f th e solemyoids . Nucinelloid s appear : always t o be smal l (1- 5 mm in length); alway s to be rar e organism s (eithe r a s fossil s o r a s extan t bivalves); t o b e dentate ; strongl y anisomyarian o r monomyarian; and their shell has no gapes. Allen & Sanders (1969 ) describe d a Recen t specie s o f th e Jurassic-Recent genus Nucinella, suggesting that it was a livin g actinodont . I t i s no w clea r tha t an y such similarit y betwee n tha t dentitio n an d tha t o f the Lowe r Palaeozoi c heteroconc h actinodont s i s merely convergence, an d they are in no way related [see also discussion by Cope (1996, pp. 990-991)]. Nucinellid shel l microstructur e wa s investigate d by Taylo r e t al (1973 , p. 287) , wh o reported tha t Nucinella had a homogenous shell simila r to that of Nuculana bu t unlik e tha t o f the solemyoid s o r the nuculoids. Carte r (1990 , pp . 175-176) , however , showed that the shell microstructure of nucinelloids is no t alway s entirel y homogenous ; fo r th e Cretaceous species N. sohli he recorded an irregular simple prismati c t o fibrou s prismati c oute r layer , and a crossed acicula r to homogenous middle shel l layer, whils t Recen t N . walvis ha s a n irregula r simple prismatic to homogemous oute r shel l layer , a fin e comple x crossed-lamella r t o homogenou s middle layer and an homogenous inner layer. Nucinella has a range of Jurassic-Recent and can be related t o the Permian famil y Manzanellidae , a s was suggeste d b y Kee n & Newel l (i n Co x e t al . 1969) wh o place d th e tw o group s i n th e Limopsoidea; the y noted that there was uncertainty with th e orientatio n o f thes e form s an d suggeste d the possibilit y tha t the y migh t b e prosodetic . Following anatomica l wor k b y (amongs t others ) Allen & Sander s (1969) , i t wa s foun d tha t Nucinella wa s o f solemyoi d affinities . Pojet a (1988) suggeste d tha t th e superfamil y Nucinelloidea shoul d contai n th e tw o familie s Nucinellidae an d Manzanellidae; thi s arrangemen t was followe d by Cop e (1991 b). Pojet a (1988 , fig . 3) als o suggeste d tha t the Uppe r Palaeozoi c genu s Clinopistha an d th e middl e Ordovicia n genu s Dystactella wer e directl y ancestra l t o th e Nucinelloidea, and Waller (1990, p. 61) gave assent to this interpretation. However, there must be major reservations abou t includin g i n a lineag e o f smal l dentate bivalve s tha t i s unknow n befor e th e Permian, a grou p o f bivalve s tha t are , a s fa r a s i s known, totall y edentulou s (an d muc h larger) ; th e only rea l poin t o f similarit y betwee n Clinopistha and Nucinella i s that they have similar shell shape s (Pojeta 1988 , fig s 2 an d 4) . Th e presen t autho r would prefe r t o regar d bot h Dystactella an d
BIVALVE PHYLOGEN Y
Clinopistha a s earl y offshoot s o f th e solemyoi d stock. The presen t autho r believe s tha t logi c dictate s that a dentate bivalve, lacking shel l gape s and with the calcifie d margi n o f th e valv e coinciden t wit h the periostracal margin, is likely t o be derived fro m an ancestor sharing these characters. Therefore, i t is believed tha t i t is likely tha t the nucinelloids wer e derived fro m a n earl y dentat e stoc k an d ar e consequently likel y t o b e mor e primitiv e tha n th e solemyoids. Carte r (1990 , p . 178 ) conclude d tha t the common ancesto r o f nucinellids and solemyids had shell s tha t wer e a t leas t partiall y nacreous . Allen's (1985) zoological investigations recognized Nucinella a s a solemyoi d mor e primitiv e tha n th e nuculoids an d suggeste d it s simpl e peg-lik e teet h were mor e primitiv e tha n nuculoi d teeth . Thes e dentate form s constitut e th e superfamil y Nucinelloidea, whils t th e edentulou s anteriorl y elongate form s (presumably ) develope d fro m th e same ancestor , ofte n wit h th e periostracu m extending beyon d th e calcifie d margin s o f th e valves an d wit h well-develope d radia l mantl e muscles, an d anterio r an d posterio r shel l gapes . These constitut e the superfamil y Solemyoidea; th e earliest membe r o f this famil y know n s o far is th e early Arenig genu s Ovatoconcha Cope , 1996 , als o including th e late r Ordovicia n genu s Psiloconcha as well as more recent genera .
Origin of the Solemyoida Pojeta (1988 ) derive d th e solemyoid s fro m th e palaeotaxodont Ctenodonta. Th e presen t autho r does not agree that this genus is related i n any way to the origin of the solemyoids a s was suggested by Pojeta (1988 ) an d followe d b y Walle r (1990 , 1998) - Ctenodonta i s a perfectl y norma l 'mainstream' palaeotaxodon t grad e for m tha t i s anteriorly enlarge d (lik e severa l othe r nuculoi d taxa). Th e suppose d radia l mantl e muscle s show n by Pojeta (1988, e.g. pi. 13 , fig. 10) are interpreted here as no more than a discontinuous pallial line, as noted b y Pojet a whe n h e previousl y figure d th e same specimen (1971 , pi. 4, fig. 10). The lectotype of the type species of Ctenodonta, C. nasuta (Hall) , 1847 , wa s designate d b y McAlester (1968 , p . 22 , an d refigured 1968 , pi . 1, fig. 1) . Th e lectotyp e show s n o featur e o f th e dentition, bu t Pojet a (1971 , pi . 4 ) refigure d it , together with the paratype (recte paralectotype) and specimens o f th e sam e specie s showin g a well developed palaeotaxodon t dentition . Th e nam e Ctenodonta has been much misused throughou t th e history o f Lower Palaeozoi c bivalv e palaeontolog y and, a s pointe d ou t b y Pojet a (1971 , p . 15) , 'Ctenodonta .. . ha s bee n use d s o widel y fo r s o many differen t nuculoid s that the only informatio n
87
it no w convey s i s tha t a nuculoi d i s bein g described'. Thi s i s certainl y th e cas e fo r th e nuculoids described b y Harrington (1938 ) from th e Tremadoc o f Argentin a a s thre e ne w specie s o f Ctenodonta (C . famatinensis, C . laevigata an d C . miniscularia)', non e o f thes e remotel y approache s the ctenodonti d for m an d the y al l resembl e praenuculid shape . O n th e othe r hand , Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson (1977 , p . 9) placed Palaeoneilo iruyensis Harrington , 193 8 tentativel y in Ctenodonta. Thi s specie s i s represente d b y thre e specimens o f whic h Harringto n figure d on e (presumably th e bes t preserved) . Eve n thi s specimen (Harringto n 1938 , pi . 3 , fig . 6 ) i s ver y indifferently preserved , wit h n o dentitio n an d a n outline that has been restored on the photograph. Its umbo i s one-thir d o f th e lengt h fro m th e anterio r margin (Harringto n 1938 , p . 132 ) and , althoug h valve heigh t i s greate r anteriorl y tha n posteriorly , the presen t autho r woul d b e loath e t o giv e thi s specimen an y generi c identity . Thi s appear s t o b e the sole basis for Pojeta's clai m (1988 , p . 211) tha t Ctenodonta occur s in the early Ordovicia n an d the reported mi d Ordovicia n Nort h America n occur rences of Ctenodonta would now all be regarded as from th e lat e Ordovician . Th e presen t autho r dis agrees wit h Pojeta' s (1988 ) placin g o f th e lat e Ordovician specie s Ctenodonta logani Salter, 185 9 within tha t genus , believin g tha t tha t specie s belongs fa r more readily t o Tancrediopsis, althoug h the hinge-angl e i s a little mor e obtus e tha n i n the type specie s T . contracta (Salter) . Middl e Ordovician Ctenodonta specie s ar e typifie d b y those figure d fro m Australi a b y Pojet a & Gilbert Tomlinson (1977) ; thes e (C . macalesteri an d C . youngi), togethe r wit h C . jonesii, previousl y described b y Johnsto n (1888) , al l hav e thei r umbones well into the anterior end of the shell. This is importan t i n vie w o f Pojeta' s (1988 ) claime d derivation o f the solemyid s fro m th e ctenodontids; Pojeta's conclusion s wer e accepte d b y Walle r (1990, 1998) . However , analysi s o f th e recor d o f ctenodontids show s tha t th e earlie r specie s hav e their umbone s wel l t o th e anterio r o f th e shell , which i s contrar y t o wha t woul d b e expecte d i f ctenodontids wer e closel y relate d t o solemyoid s (which hav e their umbones a t the posterio r en d of the shell) . Waller (1990 , 1998 ) believe d tha t th e principa l apomorphy linkin g ctenodontid s an d solemyoid s was tha t the y bot h ha d ligamenta l nymphs . However, th e onl y ctenodontid s t o sho w suc h structures ar e a fe w o f th e lat e Ordovicia n form s figured b y Pojet a (1988) . N o ligamenta l nymph s are know n fro m th e Gondwana n mid-Ordovicia n material (althoug h i t include s well-preserve d silicified replicas) . Accordin g t o Morri s (1979 , p . 392), hi s advanced parinvincula r ligamen t typ e (in
88
J. C . W . COP E
which th e ligamen t i s inserte d i n nymphae ) i s present, amongs t others, i n the Ctenodontacea [sic] and, i n a modifie d version , i n th e Solemyidae . Thus, i n his opinio n there ar e differences betwee n the ligamenta l insertion s i n th e ctenodontid s an d solemyoids. Because Waller (1990, 1998 ) believed these ligamenta l nymph s linke d ctenodontid s an d solemyoids he was forced to conclude (1990, p. 61) that 'th e anatomical features characteristic of the ... Nucinellidae + Ctenodontida e + Solemyida e originated before [hi s italics] the nymphae that are present i n th e Ctenodontida e an d Solemyidae' . Now i t ca n b e show n tha t th e solemyoid s almos t certainly predat e th e ctenodontids an d that pre-late Ordovician ctenodontid s apparentl y did not possess ligamental nymphs . I t ma y b e tha t nymph s wer e perforce develope d i n th e ctenodontid s a s th e rearward migratio n o f th e umbone s shortene d th e effective lengt h o f th e ligament , thu s makin g stronger insertion essential. Thus, it follows that the nymphae are not apomorphic to the two groups but evolved independently. The origin of the ctenodontids does not appear to have bee n previousl y considered , bu t i t seem s probable tha t the y wer e derive d fro m earl y Ordovician praenuculids ; a relativel y equilatera l praenuculid genu s perhap s simila r t o Paulinea (Cope 1996 ) coul d for m a suitabl e ancestor . Ctenodontids coul d hav e evolve d fro m suc h a n ancestor b y anterio r enlargemen t an d gradua l rearward movement of the umbones. However, the origin o f th e solemyid s wa s probabl y a n earlie r event of which, at present, there is no knowledge. The ver y clea r difference s betwee n th e nucinelloids an d th e solemyoid s fro m thei r firs t appearances i n the Permia n an d early Ordovician , respectively, sugges t a lon g separat e history . Pending furthe r informatio n they are both retaine d in the order Solemyoida Dall , 1889. This comprise s two superfamilies : th e Solemyoide a Adam s & Adams, 1857 , whic h contain s th e singl e famil y Solemyidae Adam s & Adam s 1857 ; an d th e Nucinelloidea Yokes , 1956 , i n whic h two familie s are recognized , th e Nucinellida e Yoke s 1956 , an d the Manzanellidae Chronic, 1952 .
Subclass Autolamellibranchiat a Grobben , 1894 Grobben (1894 , p . 73 ) introduced thi s subclas s t o include al l bivalve s wit h gill s othe r tha n o f protobranch grade . Th e subclas s ha s bee n largel y neglected by palaeontologists, but was reintroduced by Nevesskaya et al (1971 ) and followed by other workers, including Starobogatov (1992) and Waller (1978, 1998) . However , al l o f thes e author s have altered th e origina l ter m Autolamellibranchiat a of Grobben (1894 ) t o Autobranchia . Althoug h th e
International Cod e o f Zoologica l Nomenclatur e (ICZN) rules , strictl y speakin g d o no t appl y a t subclass level, the present author feels that as all of these authors have credited Grobben (1894) with its authorship, it should be used in the original spelling and no t th e shortene d ter m no w use d merel y a s a convenience. The subclas s i s characterize d b y filibranch , eulamellibranch o r septibranch gills; later gill types were independentl y derive d fro m filibranc h ancestors i n separat e bivalv e group s a s firs t demonstrated b y Ridewoo d (1903) . Cop e (1995 ) suggested tha t th e evolutio n o f th e filibranc h gil l was a single morphological chang e that occurred i n one group of palaeotaxodont bivalves , late r name d the famil y Cardiolariida e (Cop e 1991 b). Th e characters of this group are a fairly straigh t line of posterior teeth along which the hinge line lay (Cope 1995, fig . 30.1.b ) an d a grou p o f large r anterio r teeth that lie beneath the hinge, constituting a hinge designed to allow full valv e articulation with wider opening o f th e valves , suc h a s woul d hav e bee n needed to void pseudofaeces concomitan t wit h the evolution o f th e filibranc h gill . Cop e (1995 ) correlated thi s wit h th e sudde n increas e i n size , abundance and morphological diversit y o f bivalve s in th e earlies t Ordovician . A s mor e bivalve s wit h the cardiolariid hing e are recognized a s such, it has become clea r tha t thei r morphologica l diversit y is greater than can be comfortably included in a single family. Thus , propose d her e i s th e superfamil y Cardiolarioidea superfam . nov. , t o includ e th e family Cardiolariida e Cope , 1991 b,and the family Eritropidae fam . nov. , t o includ e suc h gener a a s Eritropis Pojeta & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 1977 , whic h have a derived cardiolarioi d dentitio n i n which the posterior teet h have become elongate a t right angle s to the hinge and partially fused [se e Cope (1999, pi. 2, fig s 1 1 an d 12 ; Fig . If)] . A s note d b y Cop e (1999, p. 480) , ther e i s evidenc e tha t th e juvenil e dentition of Eritropis had a dentition which lacke d a subumbona l lacuna. The dental elongation o f the posterior teeth , tha t characterize s Eritropis, ca n also b e see n i n Inaequidens Pojet a & Gilbert Tomlinson, 1977 , which Cope (I991b) ha d already transferred t o the Cariolariidae. The primitiv e cardiolarioi d ca n no w b e envisaged a s havin g a ro w o f subequa l posterio r teeth an d a group o f large r teet h lyin g belo w thi s hinge line . Suc h fossils ma y be expected fro m th e late Cambria n o r earlies t Ordovician . I t i s note worthy tha t amongs t th e gener a o f praenuculoid s known thu s fa r fro m th e earl y Ordovician , som e show a degree of this type of asymmetry, including Pensarnia Cope, 1996 , but the posterior teet h tend to b e o n a n arche d plat e rathe r tha n th e straigh t posterior hing e plat e o f th e cardiolarioids . Th e cardiolarioid asymmetr y provide s a basi c hing e
BIVALVE PHYLOGEN Y
plan from whic h it is possible to readily deriv e the various autolamellibranchiat e bivalv e groups . Waller (1998, fig. 5) depicted a series of dentitions of early-mid-Ordovicia n bivalve s showin g ho w cycloconchid type s coul d b e derive d fro m a 'malletiid' o r cardiolariid type (Waller 1998, p. 33). The Cardiolarioidea are not assigned to an order for the present but form the rootstock of the superorder Heteroconchia Hertwig, 1895 . Whether the cardiolarioids wil l be confirmed in this fundamenta l positio n i n autolamellibranc h evolution depend s upo n th e discover y o f lat e Cambrian t o earl y Ordovicia n representative s o f that group . Thei r morpholog y strongl y suggest s such a positio n bu t th e possibilit y tha t the y represent a nuculoid evolutionar y lin e convergen t on the heteroconchs cannot be excluded at present. One featur e that occur s i n man y groups o f th e Autolamellibranchia is their retention of the byssus. This post-larva l structur e mad e possibl e th e development o f th e epifauna l mode o f lif e tha t i s characteristic o f man y autolamellibranchiat e bivalves. Order Trigonioida Dall, 1889 Many authors treat the trigonioids as being derived from a cycloconchi d ancestor . On e o f th e criteri a usually liste d a s occurrin g commonl y i n th e trigonioids, and one that for many workers was the cause o f th e linkag e o f th e Lowe r Palaeozoi c lyrodesmatids to the Mesozoic trigonioids, was the presence i n both o f denticulat e teeth . Johnsto n (in Johnston & Goodbody 1988 , p . 340 ) showe d that many familie s o f Lower Palaeozoic bivalve s have crenulations o f the teeth and that in som e families only a singl e specie s i s crenulate . I n fact , th e present author believes that the position is yet more variable tha n that , e.g . i n hi s descriptio n o f Glyptarca serrata Cope (1996 , p . 994 ) note d tha t out of a tota l of 484 specimen s two had crenulations o n a singl e toot h ( a differen t on e i n each specimen) . Thus , a s pointed ou t by Johnston (in Johnsto n & Goodbody 1988) , there seems little reason t o accep t crenulatio n o f th e teet h a s a reliable characte r i n familia l diagnoses . Johnston (in Johnsto n & Goodbody 1988 , p . 341) , however, then goe s o n t o poin t ou t tha t Lyrodesma majus (Ulrich) appears to possess ligamental nymphs and later (Johnston 1996 ) confirme d that the genus did indeed possess a short parinvincular ligament with well-developed nympha e resembling the schizodid ligament. H e thu s transferre d th e famil y Lyrodesmatidae t o th e orde r Trigonioida , con firming th e classificatio n o f Newel l & LaRocqu e (in Co x et al 1969) . The Trigonioid a ar e represente d toda y b y th e single genus Neotrigonia, bu t thei r origin s ca n be
89
plausibly trace d bac k t o th e early-middl e Ordovician genu s Noradonta, first describe d fro m the middl e Ordovicia n o f Australi a b y Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson (1977 ) bu t subsequentl y foun d in the early Areni g o f the Montagne Noire (Babin 19820). The dentition of Noradonta redoniaeformis (Thoral) i s very lik e that of a cardiolarioid i n that there is a straightish posterior dentition lying along the hing e line , togethe r wit h a grou p o f large r subumbonal teeth lyin g below th e hinge (Fig . le) . The dentitio n o f Noradonta redoniaeformis differ s from tha t o f a cardiolarioi d suc h a s Deceptrix i n that th e cardina l teet h ar e subparalle l an d th e posterior teeth have become fused t o form a single denticulate posterior tooth. The hinge of Noradonta also differ s fundamentall y fro m th e hinge s o f cycloconchid gener a suc h a s Copidens Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson o r Carminodonta Cope i n tha t the opisthodeti c ligamen t in Noradonta i s paralle l to the posterior toot h (a s it is als o i n Cardiolaria) whilst in the cycloconchids, wit h a sheaf o f teeth, the teet h ar e terminate d b y th e ligamen t an d th e teeth had to be resorbed to allow ligamental growth, as noted by Johnston & Zhang (1998, p. 372). From Noradonta redoniaeformis i t is readily possibl e t o derive th e genu s Tromelinodonta, fro m th e uppe r Arenig of the Massif Armoricain of France (Babin 1982£>), and in turn from Tromelinodonta t o derive the genu s Lyrodesma, whic h i s widel y reporte d from the Ordovician of Europe and North America, and is also known from the Lower Silurian of North America (Harrison & Harrison 1975) . Th e earlies t Lyrodesma recorde d s o fa r i s fro m th e earl y Llanvirn o f Wale s (Cop e 1999 ) an d th e lates t i s from th e Wenloc k Serie s o f Wale s (Ratter , pers . comm.). One featur e tha t ma y b e note d i n thi s evolutionary sequenc e fro m th e cardiolarioi d ancestor through to the lyrodesmatids is the gradual diminution and loss of the strong asymmetry of the hinge tha t characterize d earl y member s o f th e lineage. The relationship between the lyrodesmatids and the late r trigonioid s ha s bee n th e subjec t o f considerable debate , bu t th e basi c proble m i s a distinct stratigraphica l ga p betwee n th e lates t lyrodesmatids an d the earliest trigoniids . Thi s ga p is fille d b y th e schizodids , whic h hav e a ver y similar ligamenta l insertio n t o th e lyrodesmatids , but they lack the denticulate teeth o f the other two groups. I n vie w o f th e argument s of Johnsto n (i n Johnston & Goodbody 1988 , p . 340 ) this does not appear t o b e a significan t phylogeneti c obstacle . Newell & Boy d (1975 ) note d tha t whil e lat e Palaeozoic trigonioid s lac k the denticulate teeth of lyrodesmatids, the y share d th e sam e musculatur e with bot h the m an d th e Mesozoi c trigonioids . A s suggested b y Harriso n (i n Pojeta e t a l 1986) , th e
90
J. C . W . COP E
schizodid denta l arrangemen t o f th e famil y Schizodidae probably aros e throug h paedomorphic retention o f th e juvenil e lyrodesmati d dentition . Pojeta (1978 ) dre w attentio n to th e similaritie s o f the ventrall y flare d denticulat e teeth , th e dorsa l placement o f all the musculature and the positions of th e peda l retractor s a t th e extremitie s o f th e hinge plate in both lyrodesmatids and trigonioids. The Treatise (Co x e t al 1969 ) include d th e Trigonioida i n th e subclas s Palaeoheterodont a Newell, 1965 , whils t Pojet a (1971 ) include d th e trigonioids withi n the order Actinodontoida of that subclass. However , it s ligament , born e withi n strong nymphae , i s unlik e tha t o f th e othe r actinodontoids, a s note d b y Johnsto n (1996 ) an d Johnston & Zhan g (1998) ; th e latte r author s recommended th e retentio n o f th e orde r Trigonioida. Here , th e orde r Trigonioid a i s considered as being an entirely separate division of the subclas s Autolamellibranchiat a fro m th e heteroconchs, wit h whic h the y hav e frequentl y been place d hithert o (e.g . Co x e t al. 1969 ; Pojet a 1971, 1978 ; Babin 19826 ; Cope 19976 , 1999) . Th e group i s characterize d throughou t b y a prismato nacreous shell ; i t share s it s columna r aragonit e prismatic shel l microstructur e wit h tha t o f th e Unionioida, but this was probably derived from th e simpler prismato-nacreous shell of its ancestors. Anomalodesmata The superorder Anomalodesmata constitute a group of essentiall y edentulou s burrowin g bivalve s tha t are characterize d b y a prismato-nacreou s shel l similar t o tha t o f nuculoid s (Taylo r e t al . 1973) . Most moder n forms hav e eulamellibranch-grad e gills bu t som e ar e septibranch . Another characteristic feature of anomalodesmatan shell s is that they frequently displa y a fine-scal e tuberculation . Th e earliest anomalodesmata n hithert o recorde d i s Arenigomya fro m th e early Arenig o f South Wales (Cope 1996) , fo r which , lik e late r Ordovicia n anomalodesmatans, there is as yet no evidence of a strongly parinvincular ligament, although such may have been present. Indeed, as these bivalves largely lacked dentition , th e presenc e o f a well-locate d ligament coul d wel l hav e bee n necessar y fo r accurate valv e articulation . Arenigomya i s on e o f several anomalodesmatan s tha t posses s interna l calcareous structures that may have been concerned with valve articulation (Cope 1996 , fig. 7). There has hitherto been much confusion ove r the affinities o f th e famil y Modiomorphoide a a s defined i n th e Treatise (Co x e t al . 1969) . Suc h confusion i s typifie d b y Pojet a (1971 , p . 20) , 'Pelecypods whic h rang e i n ag e fro m earl y Ordovician to late Permian have been placed in the Modiomorphidae, bu t th e concep t summe d u p b y
the nam e i s vagu e an d uncertain , an d probabl y more than one family-level taxon is included in the Modiomorphidae a s presently recognized' . I t wa s many year s late r befor e thi s taxonomi c proble m was resolved. Fan g & Morris (1997 ) demonstrate d that ther e wa s a rea l differenc e i n th e hing e structures of Ordovician Modiolopsis an d Devonian Modiomorpha. I n modiomorphoids the hinge itself lies alon g th e lin e o f a n elongat e opisthideti c ligament house d withi n usuall y well-develope d nymphae; th e modiolopsoid s lac k th e ligamenta l nymphs tha t th e forme r possess . Fan g & Morri s (1997) als o showed that the family Permophoridae was a junio r subjectiv e synony m o f Modio morphidae an d that the Treatise (Co x e t al. 1969 ) superfamily Modiomorphoide a shoul d b e replace d by th e Modiolopsoidea Fischer , 188 7 (nom. trans. Fang & Morris 1997 ) i n whic h the y include d th e families Modiolopsidae, Colpomyida e an d the new family Modiolodontidae . The y als o suggeste d abandonment o f th e orde r Modiomorphoid a Newell, 196 9 (i n Cox et al. 1969) . Carter & Alle r (1975 ) showe d tha t th e perio stracum o f certai n bivalve s wa s embedde d wit h calcified spicules . The y recognize d tw o type s o f spicules; th e on e i n whic h th e periostraca l calcification too k th e form o f spicules o r granule s cemented within the outer prismatic shell layer they reported i n th e Anomalodesmata , Permophorida e [= Modiomorphidae ] an d mos t o f th e Carboniferous-Recent orde r Myoida . Th e latte r order has been included in the Anomalodesmata b y some authors (e.g. Purchon 1987 ; Waller 1990) . Fang & Morri s (1997 ) conclude d tha t th e Modiomorphidae shoul d b e assigne d t o th e Anomalodesmata becaus e o f th e character s tha t they shared . Cop e (19976 ) suggeste d tha t th e similarities betwee n mytilids and modiomorphoid s were mos t likel y du e t o convergenc e an d cite d evidence produced by Carter (1990) showing a lack of intermediat e forms , despit e a n excellen t fossi l record o f Lat e Palaeozoi c modiomorphoid s an d mytilids. Johnston (1993) followe d Waller's (1990 ) suggestion tha t th e modiomorphoid s belonge d t o the Anomalodesmata 'withou t prejudice'. The origin s o f th e anomalodesmatan s ar e unknown. They differ fro m most possible ancestor s in lackin g teeth . However , th e anomalodesmatan s have a well-located ligamen t which clearly acted as an efficien t substitut e for th e posterio r teeth . Thi s change ma y hav e bee n effecte d i n on e o r mor e stages - eithe r b y the simpl e substitutio n o f the ligament fo r th e teeth , o r b y a n initia l fusio n o r reduction o f th e posterio r teeth , followe d b y thei r loss. A s th e ligamen t i s house d withi n well developed nymphae , thi s clearl y provide d sufficient protectio n agains t an y shearin g motio n along the hinge.
BIVALVE PHYLOGEN Y
Modiolopsoids ar e essentiall y edentulou s (Modiolopsidae), hav e a variabl e numbe r o f anterior teet h (Modiolodontidae ) situate d beneat h the hing e line , o r ma y hav e a blun t subumbona l articulating device (Colpomyidae). The former two are clearly not related to the anomalodesmatans and although th e latte r wer e include d i n th e Isofilibranchia b y Pojet a & Runnegar (1985) they noted tha t som e post-Ordovicia n pholadomyoid s had amorphou s bulbou s teet h comparabl e wit h those o f colpomyids . Fan g & Morris' s (1997 ) placement i s followe d here , pendin g furthe r information. I t had previously bee n suspecte d that modiolopsoids wer e relate d t o th e heteroconchs , being derived from the m by reduction in dentition . However, Carter & Seed (1998 ) demonstrate d that some modiolopsids had multiple insertions of nonparinvincular ligaments , suggestin g tha t the y ha d affinities wit h the Pteriomorphia.
Superorder Heteroconchia This term is used here to link the palaeoheterodont s (from whic h the trigonioids ar e excluded) an d th e heterodonts followin g Pojet a (1971, 1978) . Waller (1998) use d th e ter m i n th e wide r sense , a s employed b y Co x (1960) , i n whic h th e paleo heterodonts, heterodont s an d anomalodesmatan s are included. Waller (1998) claimed that a 3a/2/3b dental arrangemen t wa s a cor e homolog y linkin g these groups. There has been a great deal of debate about th e variou s bivalv e group s possessin g th e heterodont type of hinges that display combinations of cardina l an d lateral teeth . Th e Treatise (Co x e t al. 1969 ) divide d these forms int o two subclasses : the Palaeoheterodont a Newell , 196 5 an d th e Heterodonta Neumayr , 1884 . Thi s schem e ha s subsequently been adopte d by many workers (e.g . Carter 1971 ; Baile y 1983 ; Cop e 1996 , \991a, b) . Others have suggested that the two groups are best combined i n th e superorde r Heteroconchi a Hertwig, 189 5 as they share similar dentitions an d have othe r feature s i n commo n (e.g. Pojet a 1971 , 1978; Babin & Gutierrez-Marco 1991 ) Hitherto, the present author has subscribed to the view that it was possible to separate the two groups and i t wa s suggeste d (Cop e \991b) tha t shel l micro structural difference s coul d distinguis h between prismato-nacreous Palaeoheterodont a an d a crossed-lamellar/comple x crossed-lamella r shel l of the Heterodonta. This view was based very much from a n Ordovicia n perspectiv e an d pre-suppose s that th e shel l microstructure s o f th e man y Lowe r Palaeozoic forms tha t are hitherto unknown would fit int o thi s pattern . Thes e view s hav e change d largely as a result of examining large collections of Silurian bivalve s mad e b y D r V . A . Ratte r i n
91
Cardiff. Hi s collection s includ e topotyp e materia l of Actinodonta cuneata from the Llandovery Serie s of Pembrokeshire an d a new genus and species that occurs i n slightl y younge r rocks. Actinodonta has what ca n b e regarde d a s typica l palaeoheterodont ventrally divergen t multidentat e dentition , simila r to tha t show n b y Ordovicia n gener a suc h a s Carminodonta Cope , 199 6 o r Copidens Pojet a & Gilbert-Tomlinson, 1977 , whilst the new genus has a dentitio n clos e t o tha t o f a crassatelloi d heterodont. Othe r detail s o f th e shel l diffe r i n n o marked wa y an d th e similarit y o f th e tw o ha s allowed them to be incorporated in the same family. Thus, separatio n a t a highe r taxonomi c leve l i s untenable an d s o th e palaeoheterodont s an d heterodonts ar e unite d i n th e superorde r Heteroconchia. Interestingly, b y separatin g ou t fro m thi s grou p the modiomorphoid s [no w include d i n th e Anomalodesmata following Fang & Morris (1997)] and th e trigonioids , th e tw o principa l group s o f bivalves characterize d throughou t b y prismato nacreous shells have been removed. However, it is probable tha t som e o f th e earl y heteroconch s retained thi s basi c prismato-nacreou s shel l micro structure. However, for later heteroconchs the outer shell laye r i s normall y o f prismati c calcite , th e middle laye r is of a crossed-lamellar structur e and there is an inner complex crossed-lamellar layer . It may b e tha t sinc e bivalv e group s quit e clearl y descended fro m th e glyptarcoid s ar e al l charac terized b y a crossed-lamellar shel l microstructure , then the superfamil y Glyptarcoide a also possessed that type of shell microstructure . The Glyptarcoidea hav e a dentition tha t radiate s dorsally from a point within the centre of the valves (see Babi n & Gutierrez-Marco 1991 , fig . 7; Cop e 1996, fig . 5) rather than the subumbona l ventrally divergent dentition of the majority of heteroconchs. The anterio r dentitio n o f Glyptarca, originall y figured from the Arenig of Ramsey Island by Hicks (1873) an d redescribed b y Carte r (1971) , wit h it s strongly curve d anterio r teeth , le d man y author s (e.g. Pojet a 1971 ; Babi n 1966 ; Morri s 1978 ) t o suggest tha t Glyptarca wa s th e idea l ancesto r fo r the cyrtodontids . However , whe n thes e author s made thi s suggestion , th e dentitio n o f Glyptarca was ver y imperfectl y know n a s th e genu s wa s based o n inadequat e typ e material . I n orde r t o stabilize th e nomenclature , Cop e (1996 ) figure d material with well-preserved dentition that showed that Glyptarca lacke d th e subumbona l denta l lacuna tha t i s characteristi c o f th e cyrtodont s an d indeed ha d a comple x subumbona l dentition . Glyptarca coul d b e quit e readil y derive d fro m a cardiolariid ancestor , a s demonstrate d b y Cop e (1995), as could the actinodonts (Walle r 1998 , fig. 5 and text pp. 33-34).
92
J. C . W . COP E
It wa s th e Mesozoi c an d Cenozoi c evolutio n of the heteroconchs tha t wa s responsible fo r th e pre eminent positio n thi s superorde r ha s i n Recen t bivalve faunas. It therefore lies outside of the scope of this review of early bivalve phylogeny.
cardinal teeth , together wit h a half chevron-shape d ligament. There ar e stil l majo r gap s i n ou r knowledg e o f the earl y arcoids , particularl y sinc e ther e ar e n o records betwee n Catamarcaia i n th e Areni g an d Alytodonta i n the early Llandovery . Ratter & Cope (1998) note d tha t Lowe r Palaeozoi c arcoid s ar e particularly characteristi c o f ver y close-inshor e Pteriomorphia facies an d this may explain thei r extreme rarity . The earlies t pteriomorphian s ar e recorde d fro m Sanchez & Babin (1993 ) erecte d th e ne w bivalv e genus Catamarcaia fo r a bivalv e fro m th e mid - the lat e Tremado c o f Australi a (Pojet a & Gilbert Arenig o f Argentina , whic h remain s th e earlies t Tomlinson 1977) . Bot h o f the recorded gener a ar e bivalve ye t know n wit h a duplivincula r ligament . cyrtodontids, bu t sinc e the y ar e preserve d a s As show n b y Cop e (1997a ) an d Ratte r & Cop e sandstone mould s ther e i s n o knowledg e o f thei r (1998), th e dentitio n o f Catamarcaia coul d b e ligament. However , becaus e the y ar e lik e late r derived quit e readil y fro m a n ancesto r lik e th e cyrtodontids tha t hav e multipl e ligamenta l inser heteroconch Glyptarca (se e Ratte r & Cop e 1998 , tions, i t i s probabl y saf e t o assum e tha t the y als o fig. 7) . Wit h th e latte r genu s i t share s stron g had thi s ligamen t type . A s the y predat e anterior teeth and a complex subumbonal dentition, Catamarcaia i t i s possibl e tha t the y an d and differs i n the posterior dentitio n and the lack of Catamarcaia evolve d fro m a commo n ancestor , a duplivincula r ligament . Th e superfamil y such as that proposed b y Cope (1991 a). In turn, from th e cyrtodonts, ambonychiids could Glyptarcoidea, however , is see n a s the most likely origin fo r thi s stock . Thus , i t seem s tha t th e be readil y derive d b y reductio n o f th e anterio r o f Arcoidea coul d hav e bee n derive d directl y fro m the shell ; th e earliest ambonychii d know n hitherto early glyptarcoi d heteroconchs . Cop e (1995 , is the Cleionychia recorded fro m the middle Arenig 1997a, b ) separated th e order Arcoida (fro m whic h of Sout h Wale s b y Cop e (1996) . I n addition , th e he exclude d th e cyrtodontids ) from th e remainde r derivation o f pterioids implie s th e developmen t of of th e pteriomorphs o n the grounds that they wer e asymmetry betwee n th e valve s an d th e earlies t the only group with a chevron-shaped duplivincular pterioid recorde d hithert o wa s fro m th e earl y ligament an d tha t the y lacke d th e calciti c oute r Arenig of South Wales (Cope 1996) . Thus, all these layer that characterizes mos t pteriomorphian shells. early pteriomorphian group s had evolved within the He suggeste d tha t Korobkov' s (1954 ) ter m early Ordovician . The presenc e o f a multipl e non-parinvincula r Neotaxodonta wa s th e most appropriat e availabl e name for this group. It is now clear that this was an ligament i n the modiolopsoids , note d b y Carte r & oversimplistic vie w an d tha t ther e ar e man y Seed (1998) , suggest s tha t the y belong withi n th e synapomorphies uniting the Arcoida wit h the other Pteriomorphia. Th e earlies t for m tha t ca n b e pteriomorphs (Walle r 1998) , s o tha t the y ma y b e included i n thi s superfamil y i s a colpomyi d fro m the Tremado c o f Australi a (Pojet a & Gilbert recombined in the superorder Pteriomorphia. Following th e discover y o f Catamarcaia, othe r Tomlinson 1977) , but , a s pointe d ou t above , th e early arcoid s hav e bee n discovered , includin g colpomyids ma y be anomalodesmatans . Insofa r a s Alytodonta (Cop e 1991 b), Trecanolia an d is known , no multipl e ligamenta l insertion s hav e Uskardita (Ratte r & Cop e 1998) , whic h lin k th e been see n i n a colpomyid . Th e earlies t modio lopsids an d modiolodontid s appea r t o b e fro m th e group t o th e mid-Siluria n genu s Freja. Ratte r & Cope (1998 ) assigne d th e las t fou r gener a t o th e early Areni g o f Sout h Wale s (Cop e 1996) . Th e new family Frejidae , leavin g Catamarcaia without Tremadoc Cosmogoniophorina describe d b y Harrington (1938) is probably a nuculoid (Pojeta & familial assignment . I t i s clea r tha t Catamarcaia has dentitio n tha t differ s fro m tha t of th e Frejida e Gilbert-Tomlinson 1977) . Modiolopsoid s coul d and also from that of the Parallelodontidae, a s noted have bee n derive d fro m cyrtodonts , o r the y coul d by Sanche z (1995) , bu t th e ligamen t o f th e have share d a commo n ancesto r wit h reduce d Parallelodontidae i s simila r t o that of the Frejidae , pteriomorphian dentition . leading Ratter & Cope (1998, fig. 7) to suggest that The othe r principa l pteriomorphia n grou p t o both familie s wer e derive d fro m a commo n post - evolve durin g th e Ordovicia n wa s th e limids . Catamarcaia ancestor . I t is proposed her e tha t th e Tunnicliff (1987 ) describe d th e ne w genu s monotypic famil y Catamarcaida e accommodate s Myodakyrotus fro m th e Upper Ordovician o f North the genu s Catamarcaia. The characteristics o f this Wales. This grou p is dimyarian , a s opposed t o the family includ e a n asymmetri c dentition , whic h normal monomyarian musculature in most limoids , includes lamellar anterior and posterior lateral teeth and i n man y respects i s intermediat e betwee n th e combined wit h a serie s o f largel y chevron-shape d cyrtodontids an d the limids.
BIVALVE PHYLOGEN Y
Conclusions Bivalves first diversifie d i n the Cambrian, perhaps from initia l surfac e dwellers , to produce a limited variety o f form s tha t include d shallo w infauna l burrowers that, like the majorit y o f bivalves, were able t o capitaliz e o n th e substrate s o f th e Lowe r Palaeozoic seas . Probabl y stil l withi n th e Cambrian, som e o f thes e form s migrate d int o partially anaerobi c substrate s wher e the y live d symbiotically wit h chemoautotrophi c sulphur oxidizing bacteria , producin g a rapi d diversifi cation amongst the protobranch bivalves. Towards the end of the Cambrian, or within the very earliest Ordovician, on e grou p o f palaeotaxodont bivalves developed the filibranch gill; this produced a major evolutionary burs t i n th e autolamellibranch s tha t allowed bivalves to take advantage of the increased nutrient supplie s i n th e Ordovicia n sea s (Cop e & Babin 1999) . Fro m th e rootstoc k o f th e newl y evolved heteroconch s a plethor a o f ne w bivalv e groups diversifie d rapidl y an d colonize d semi infaunal an d epifauna l habitats . B y th e en d o f th e early Ordovicia n al l mai n group s o f bivalve s ha d evolved an d link s betwee n man y o f thes e group s can b e establishe d wit h varyin g degree s o f confidence as the fossil record of the Cambrian and Ordovician bivalves becomes better known. I am grateful fo r the assistance of Mrs D. G. Evans, of the Geology Department , Nationa l Museum of Wales, in th e drafting o f Fig. 2.
References ADAMKEWICZ, S . L. , HARASEWYCH , M . G. , BLAKE , J. , SAUDEK, D . & BULT , C . J . 1987 . A molecula r phylogeny o f th e bivalv e mollusks . Molecular Biology an d Evolution, 14, 619-629. ADAMS, H . & ADAMS , A . 1854-1858 . Th e Genera o f Recent Mollusca Arranged According to their Organisation, Vol. 2 . J. van Voorst, London. ALLEN, J. A. 1978 . Evolution of the deep-sea protobranch bivalves. Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society o f London, Series B, 284, 387-401. 1985. Th e Recen t Bivalvia : thei r for m an d evolution. In : TRUEMAN , E . R . & CLARKE , M . R . (eds) Th e Mollusca. Vol. 10, Evolution. Academi c Press, New York, 337-403. & SANDERS , H . L . 1969 . Nucinella serrei Lam y (Bivalvia: Protobranchia) , a monomyaria n solemyoid an d possibl e livin g actinodont . Malacologia, 7, 381-396. BABIN, C. 1966 . Mollusques bivalves et cephalopodes d u Paleozoique armoricain. Imprimerie Commercial e et Administrative, Brest . 19820. Mollusqe s bivalve s e t rostroconches . In : BABIN, C., COURTESSOLE, R., MELOU, M. , FILLET, J., VIZCAINO, D . & YOCHELSON , E . L . Brachiopodes (articules) et mollusques (bivalves, rostroconches,
93
monoplacophores, gastropodes) de VOrdovicien inferieur (Tremadocien-Arenigien) de la Montagne Noire (France meridionale). Memoir e d e la Societe des Etude s Scientifique s d e 1'Aude , Sival , Carcassonne, 37-49, pis 8-12 . 1982b. Tromelinodonta nov . gen. , Bivalv e lyrodesmatide (Mollusca ) d e 1 ' Arenigie n (Ordovicien inferieur). Geobios, 15, 423-427. & GUTTIERREZ-MARCO , J . C . 1991 . Middl e Ordovician bivalve s fro m Spai n an d thei r phyleti c and palaeogeographi c significance . Palaeontology, 34, 109-147 . BAILEY, J . B . 1983 . Middle Devonia n Bivalvia fro m th e Solsville Membe r (Marcellu s Formation) , centra l New Yor k State. Bulletin of th e American Museum of Natural History, 174 , 193-326. BEEDHAM, G. E. & OWEN , G . 1965 . The mantl e an d shel l of Solemya parkinsoni (Protobranchia : Bivalvia) . Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London, 145, 405-430. BENTON. M . J . & HARPER , D . A . T . 1997 . Basic Palaeontology. Addiso n Wesley Longman, Harlow. BERG-MADSEN, V . 1987 . Tuarangia fro m Bornhol m (Denmark) an d similaritie s i n Baltoscandia n an d Australasian lat e Middl e Cambria n faunas . Alcheringa, 11, 245-259. CARTER, J . G . (ed. ) 1990 . Skeletal Biomineralization: Patterns, Processes and Evolutionary Trends. Vol s 1. and 2. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York. & ALLER , R . C . 1975 . Calcification i n th e bivalv e periostracum. Lethaia, 8, 315-320. & SEED , R . 1998 . Therma l potentiatio n an d mineralogical evolutio n i n Mytilus (Mollusca ;
Bivalvia). In: JOHNSTON , P . A . & HAGGART , J . W .
(eds) Bivalves: An Eon of Evolution — Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary , 87-117. CARTER, R . M . 1971 . Revision o f Areni g Bivalvi a fro m Ramsey Island , Pembrokeshire . Palaeontology, 14, 250-261, pis 38-39. CAVANAUGH, C . M . 1983 . Symbiotic chemoautotrophi c bacteria i n marin e invertebrates fro m sulphide-ric h habitat. Nature, 302, 58-61. CHRONIC, H . 1952 . Molluscan fauna s fro m th e Permia n Kaibab Formation , Walnu t Canyon , Arizona . Bulletin o f th e Geological Society o f America, 63 , 95-166, pis 1-11 . COPE, J . C. W. 1995. The earl y evolution o f the Bivalvia . In: TAYLOR , J . D . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation of th e Mollusca. Oxford University Press , Oxford, 361-37 0 1996. Early Ordovicia n (Arenig ) bivalves fro m th e Llangynog Inlier , Sout h Wales . Palaeontology, 39, 979-1025. 19970. Affinitie s o f th e earl y Ordovicia n bivalv e Catamarcaia Sanche z an d Babin, 199 3 and its rol e in bivalve evolution. Geobios Memoire Special, 20 , 126-131. 1997b. The earl y phylogen y o f th e clas s Bivalvia. Palaeontology, 40, 713-746. 1999. Middle Ordovicia n bivalve s fro m mid-Wale s and th e Wels h Borderland . Palaeontology, 42 , 467-499 .
94
J. C . W . COPE
& BABIN, C. 1999. Diversification of bivalves in the Ordovician. Geobios, 32, 175-185. Cox, L . R . 1959 . Th e geologica l histor y o f th e Protobranchia an d th e dua l origi n o f th e taxodon t Lamellibranchia. Proceedings of th e Malacological Society, London, 33, 200-209. 1960. Thoughts on the classification of the Bivalvia. Proceedings o f th e Malacological Society, 34 , 60-88. & 2 4 other s 1969-1971 . In : MOORE , R . C . (ed.) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Part N. Mollusca 6 , Bivalvia. Geologica l Societ y o f America, Boulder , CO , an d Universit y o f Kansa s Press, Lawrence, KS. DALL, W . H. 1889 . On th e hing e o f pelecypod s an d it s development, wit h a n attemp t towar d a bette r subdivision o f th e group . American Journal o f Science, 38, 445-462. FANG, ZONG-ZI E & MORRIS , N . J . 1997 . Th e genu s Pseudosanguinolites an d som e modiolifor m bivalves (mainl y Palaeozoic) . Palaeoworld, 7 , 50-74. GEYER, G . & STRENG , M . 1998 . Middl e Cambria n pelecypods fro m th e Anti-Atlas , Morocco . Revista Espanola d i Paleontologia, no . extr a Homenaja e al Prof. Gonzal o Vidal , 83-96. GROBBEN, K . 1894 . Zur Kenntnis s der Morphologic , de r Verwandschaftsverhaltnisse un d de s System s de r Mollusken. Sitzungsberichte de r Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften, MathematischNaturwissenschaftlichen Classe, 103, 61-86. HARPER, E . M . 1997 . The mollusca n periostracum : a n important constrain t i n bivalv e evolution . Palaeontology, 40, 71-97. HARRINGTON, H . J . 1938 . Sobr e la s fauna s de l Ordoviciano inferio r de l Nort e Argentine . Revista del Museo de La Plata, Nueva Serie, 1, 109-289. HARRISON, W. B. & HARRISON, L. K. 1975. A Maquoketalike mollusca n communit y i n th e Brassfiel d Formation (Earl y Silurian ) o f Adam s County , Ohio. Bulletins o f American Paleontology, 67 , 197-231. HAVLICEK, V . & KRIZ , J . 1978 . Middl e Cambria n Lamellodonta simplex Vogel : 'bivalve ' turne d brachiopod Trematobolus simplex (Vogel) . Journal of Paleontology, 52, 972-975. HERTWIG, C . W . T . R . 1895 . Lehrbuch de r Zoologie. Gustav Fischer, Jena . HICKS, H . 1873 . O n th e Tremado c rock s i n th e neighbourhood o f St . David's , Sout h Wale s an d their fossi l contents . Quarterly Journal o f th e Geological Society of London, 29, 39-52, pis 3-5 . HINZ-SCHALLREUTER, I. 1995. Muscheln (Pelecypoda) au s dem Mittelkambriu m vo n Bornholm . Geschiebekunde aktuell, 11, 71-84. IREDALE, T . 1939 . Grea t Barrie r Ree f expeditio n 1928-1929. Scientific Reports, British Museum (Natural History), 5, [Mollusca, Par t 1] , 209-425. JELL, P . A. 1980 . Earliest know n pelecypod o n Earth . A new Earl y Cambria n genu s fro m Sout h Australia . Alcheringa, 4, 233-239. JOHNSTON, P. A. 1993 . Lower Devonian Pelecypoda fro m south-eastern Australia . Memoirs of th e Association of Australasian Palaeontologists, 14, 1-134 .
1996. Middl e Ordovicia n (Caradoc ) pelecypod s from th e Advanc e Formation , Britis h Columbia . Bulletin o f th e Geological Survey o f Canada, 491, 113-129. & GOODBODY , Q . H . 1988 . Middl e Devonia n bivalves fro m Melvill e Island , Arcti c Canada . In : MCMILLAN, N. J., EMBRY, A. F. & GLASS, D. J. (eds) Devonian of the World. 3. Paleontology, Paleoecology an d Bi o stratigraphy. Canadia n Society o f Petroleu m Geologists , Memoi r 14 , 337-346. & ZHAN G R . 1998 . Re-interpretation o f Sinodora Pojeta an d Zhang , 1984 , a n unusua l bivalv e (Trigonioida) fro m th e Devonia n o f China . In : JOHNSTON, P . A. & HAGGART , J . W . (eds) Bivalves: An Eon of Evolution - Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D. Newell. University of Calgary Press, Calgary , 361-375 . JOHNSTON, R . M . 1888 . Systematic Account o f th e Geology o f Tasmania. J. Walch & Sons, Hobart. KOROBKOV, I . A . 1954 . Sprvochnik i metodicheskoe rukovodstro po tretichnum Mollyuskam Plastinchatozhabernye. Nauchno-tecnoi ' Isledov . Leningradskoi Otdeleni e [i n Russian]. MCALESTER, A . L . 1968 . Typ e specie s o f Paleozoi c nuculoid bivalve genera. Memoir of the Geological Society o f America, 105. MORRIS, N . J . 1978 . The infauna l descendant s o f th e Cycloconchidae: a n outlin e o f th e evolutionar y history o f th e Heteroconchia, Superfamilie s Cycloconchacea t o Chamacea . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, 284, 259-275. 1979. On the origi n o f the Bivalvia . In: HOUSE , M . R. (ed. ) The Origin of Major Invertebrate Groups. Systematics Associatio n Specia l Volum e No . 12 . Academic Press , London , 381^-13. MORTON, B . 1995 . Th e evolutionar y histor y o f th e Bivalvia. In : TAYLOR , J . D . (ed. ) Origin an d Evolutionary Radiation o f th e Mollusca. Oxfor d University Press, Oxford , 337-359. NEUMAYR, M . 1884 . Zu r Morphologi c de r Bivalve nschlosses. Kaiserlich-Koniglichen Akademie de r Wissenschaften, Wien. Mathematische, Naturwissenschaftliche Klasse, Sitzungberichte, Abteilung 1 , 88, 385-418. NEVESSKAYA, L. A., SCARLATO, O. A., STAROBOGATOV, YA. L. & EBERZIN , A . G . 1971 . Ne w idea s o n bivalv e systematics. Paleontological Journal, 2 , 3-20 . [English translatio n b y America n Geologica l Institute, published 1972] . NEWELL, N . D . 1965 . Classificatio n o f th e Bivalvia . American Museum Novitates, 2206, 1-25 . & BOYD , D . W . 1975 . Parallel evolutio n i n earl y trigoniacean bivalves . Bulletin o f th e American Museum o f Natural History, 154, 53-162. PELSENEER, P . 1889. Sur l a classificatio n phylogenetique des pelecypodes. Bulletin Scientifique d e l a France et de la Belgique, 20, 27-52. POJETA, J . 1971 . Revie w o f Ordovicia n pelecypods . Professional Paper of the United States Geological Survey , 695. 1973. Fordilla troyensis Barrande: the oldest known pelecypod. Science, 180, 866-868.
BIVALVE PHYLOGENY 1975. Fordilla troyensis Barrand e an d earl y pelecypod phylogeny . Bulletins o f American Paleontology, 67 (287), 363-384 . 1978. The origin and early taxonomic diversificatio n of pelecypods . Philosophical Transactions o f th e Royal Society o f London, Series B, 284 , 225-246, pis 1-15 . 1988. Th e origi n an d Paleozoi c diversificatio n o f solemyoid bivalves . Memoir o f th e Ne w Mexico Bureau o f Mines an d Mineral Resources, 44 , 201-271, pis 1-24 . & GiLBERT-ToMLiNSON , J . 1977 . Australia n Ordovician pelecypo d molluscs . Bulletin o f th e Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics, 174 , 1-64, pis 1-29 . & RUNNEGA R , B . 1976 . Th e paleontolog y o f rostroconch mollusk s an d th e earl y histor y o f th e Phylum Mollusca. Professional Paper of th e United States Geological Survey, 968. & 1985 . Th e earl y evolutio n o f diasom e molluscs. In : TRUEMAN , E . R . & CLARKE , M . R . (eds) The Mollusca, 10, Evolution. Academic Press , Orlando, 295-336. , ZHANG , R . & YANG , Z . 1986 . Systemati c paleontology o f Devonia n pelecypods o f Guangxi and Michigan . Professional Paper o f th e United States Geological Survey, 1394, 57-108. PURCHON, R . D. 1987 . Classification an d evolution o f the Bivalvia: a n analytica l study . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B, 316, 277-302. RATTER, V . A. & COPE , J . C . W . 1998 . New neotaxodon t bivalves from th e Siluria n o f South Wales and their phylogenetic significance . Palaeontology, 41 , 975-991. RIDEWOOD, W . G . 1903 . On th e structur e o f th e gill s o f lamellibranchs. Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society of London, Series B, 194, 147-284. RUNNEGAR, B . & POJETA , J . 1992 . The earlies t bivalve s and thei r Ordovicia n descendants . American Malacological Bulletin, 9, 117-122 . SANCHEZ, T . M . 1995 . Comment s o n th e genu s Catamarcaia Sanche z an d Babi n an d th e origi n o f the Arcoida. Geobios, 28, 343-346.
95
& BABIN, C. 1993. Un insolite bivalve, Catamarcaia n.g., d e 1'Areni g (Ordovicie n inferieur ) d'Argentine. Comptes rendus d e V Academie de s Sciences, Paris, Serie II, 316, 265-271. STAROBOGATOV, YA . L . 1992 . Morphologica l basi s fo r phylogeny an d classificatio n o f th e Bivalvia . Ruthenica, 2, 1-25 . TAYLOR, J . D. , KENNEDY , W . J . & HALL , A . 1969 . Th e shell structur e an d mineralog y o f th e Bivalvia . Introduction. Nuculacea-Trigonacea. Bulletin of th e British Museum (Natural History), Zoology Series, Supplement 3. ,& 1973 . Th e shel l structur e an d mineralogy o f th e Bivalvia . II . Lucinacea Clavagellacea, Conclusions . Bulletin o f th e British Museum (Natural History), Zoology Series, 22 , 256-294, pis 1-15 . TEVESZ, M . J . S . & McCALL , P . L. 1976 . Primitive lif e habits an d adaptiv e significanc e o f th e pelecypo d form. Paleobiology, 2, 183-190. TUNNICLIFF, S . P. 1987. Caradocian bivalve molluscs from Wales. Palaeontology, 30, 677-690, pis 76 and 77. YOKES, H . E . 1956 . Note s o n th e Nucinellida e (Pelecypoda) wit h a descriptio n o f a ne w specie s from th e Eocen e o f Oregon . Journal o f Paleontology, 30, 652-671. WALLER, T . R . 1978 . Morphology, morphocline s an d a new classificatio n o f the Pteriomorphia (Mollusca : Bivalvia). Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society o f London, Series B, 284, 345-365. 1990. Th e evolutio n o f ligamen t system s i n th e Bivalvia. In : MORTON , B . (ed. ) Th e Bivalvia Proceedings of a Symposium in Honour of Sir Charles Maurice Yonge. Hon g Kon g Universit y Press, Hon g Kong, 49-71. 1998. Origin o f the mollusca n clas s Bivalvi a and a phylogeny o f majo r groups. In: JOHNSTON , P . A. & HAGGART, J . W . (eds ) Bivalves: A n Eo n o f Evolution - Paleobiological Studies Honoring Norman D . Newell. Universit y o f Calgar y Press , Calgary, 1-45. YONGE, C . M. 1959. The status of the Protobranchia i n the bivalve Mollusca. Proceedings of the Malacological Society, London, 33, 210-214.
This page intentionally left blank
A preliminary phylogeny for rudist bivalves: sifting clades from grades PETER W. SKELTON1 & ANDREW B. SMITH 2 1 Department of Earth Sciences, Open University, Milton Keynes MK7 6AA, UK (e-mail: P.W.Skelton@ open.ac.uk) 2 Department of Palaeontology, Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London SW7 5BD, UK Abstract: Th e taxonomi c history o f th e lat e Jurassic-Cretaceou s rudis t bivalves (Superfamily Hippuritoidea) i s reviewe d an d a ne w phylogen y base d o n cladisti c analysi s o f 3 2 skeleta l characters i s proposed . Informativ e characters include : relativ e thicknes s an d structure s o f th e outer (calcitic) shel l layer; valve asymmetry and attachment to the substrate by either th e left o r right valve ; for m o f th e ligament ; and , i n th e aragoniti c inne r shell , th e dentitio n an d shell y supports (myophores ) for th e adducto r muscles, as well a s accessor y cavities an d blind-ending (pallial) canals . Th e myocardina l comple x (teet h an d myophores ) i s especiall y importan t fo r discriminating clade s previousl y lumpe d i n paraphyleti c o r eve n polyphyleti c tax a (e.g . Caprinidae, sensu lato, in the bivalve Treatise (Moore , R . C. (ed.) 1969 . Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology, Part N. Mollusca 6 , Bivalvia, Geological Societ y o f Americ a an d Universit y of Kansas). As outgroup , a megalodontid bivalv e wa s used , a s thi s share s thre e derive d trait s (massiv e dentition, modified parivincular ligament and posterior myophores) in common with rudists. The clade o f al l rudists i s unite d by possessio n o f a n oute r shel l laye r o f fibrilla r prismati c calcit e (albeit greatl y reduce d i n a fe w taxa). Tw o subclade s ar e distinguishe d accordin g t o th e attachment of the shell - eithe r by the left valve (all 'diceratids', except Diceras and Valletta, plus the monophyleti c requieniids) , o r b y th e righ t valv e (Diceras, Valletta an d al l othe r rudists) . Monophyly o f some previously established familie s i s substantiated. Thes e includ e Caprinidae , sensu stricto (Skelton, P . W. 1978 . Philosophical Transactions of th e Royal Society of London, Series B, 284, 305-318) , Radiolitidae (with Agriopleura as sister taxon) and Hippuritidae (with Tepeyacia emergin g a s a possible siste r taxon) , whil e other s ar e resolve d int o distinc t clades . There i s som e evidenc e fo r th e Polyconitida e Ma c Gillavr y (1937) , thoug h wit h negligibl e bootstrap support .
The rudists are an extinct group of sessile epifaunal radioliti d interna l mould , togethe r wit h tw o bivalves that flourished in low-latitude shallow seas inarticulat e brachiopods (Crania and Discina) and from lat e Jurassi c t o Cretaceou s times . A n a lidded solitar y rugos e coral (Calceola). Lamarc k expansive adaptive radiation spread them across the place d th e grou p alongsid e th e oyster s i n hi s broad carbonat e platform s tha t develope d i n th e 'Conchiferes monomyaires'. Othe r tax a no w equatorial Tethy s Ocea n an d o n scattere d regarde d as rudists were put elsewhere by Lamarck seamounts i n th e Pacifi c (Mass e & Phili p 1986 ; (1819 ) - Diceras amon g chamacea n bivalve s and Ross & Skelto n 1993 ; Phili p e t al 1995 ; Phili p Hippurites wit h the cephalopods. Deshaye s (1825 ) 1998). Th e shell s an d resultin g debri s fro m vas t late r unite d th e hippuritid s wit h th e radiolitid s t o 'meadows' o f rudist s indee d contribute d compris e a more restricte d groupin g o f 'rudistes', substantially t o th e growt h o f th e platforms , whic h he placed in the bivalves, especially i n the late Cretaceou s (Gil i et al. 1995 ; Man y ne w description s followed , wit h muc h Carannante et al. 1999) . speculativ e phylogeneti c pigeon-holing . Th e tax a The nam e (originall y 'les rudistes') wa s firs t no w recognized as rudists were variously classified given b y Lamarc k (1819 ) t o a n assortmen t o f a s brachiopods , corals , cirripedes , anneli d tubes , inequivalve fossi l shell s wit h prominen t beaks , o r members o f a n independent grou p of molluscs , comprising onl y tw o currentl y recognize d rudis t a s wel l a s bivalves , unti l the y wer e finall y genera (Radiolites an d Sphaerulites) plu s a assemble d - togethe r wit h Chama and a few other From: HARPER, E. M., TAYLOR , J. D. & CRAME, J. A. (eds) The Evolutionary Biology of th e Bivalvia. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 177 , 97-127 . 1-86239-076-2/007 $ 15.00 © The Geological Societ y of London 2000.
98
P. W. SKELTO N & A. B . SMITH
bivalve gener a - within th e Bivalvi a ('Familie Chamaceen'), by Quenstedt (1852) [see Woodward (1855) fo r historica l details] . Munie r Chalma s (1873) was the first to extend the name 'rudistes' t o cover the expanded groupin g of taxa from Diceras onwards. Newel l (1965 ) rename d th e grou p a s 'Superfamily Hippuritace a Gray 1848' , in keeping with moder n nomenclatura l rules , henc e thei r coverage unde r tha t nam e i n th e Treatise o n Invertebrate Paleontology (Dechaseau x e t al. 1969). Following Ride et al. (1999) this should now be corrected t o Hippuritoidea. The divers e an d elaborat e (som e woul d say, 'baroque') morphologie s o f th e rudist s presen t a good arra y o f character s fo r cladisti c analysis . Informative character s include : th e relativ e thickness an d mesostructura l modification s o f th e outer (calcitic ) shel l layer ; valv e asymmetr y an d attachment to the substrat e by either th e lef t valv e (LV) o r th e righ t valv e (RV); the conditio n of th e ligament; th e configuratio n o f th e massiv e (pachyodont) dentition; and the arrangement of the internal shell y support s (myophores ) fo r th e adductor muscles , a s wel l a s variou s associate d accessory cavitie s an d othe r structure s withi n th e aragonitic inner shell. So far, however, this character-rich group has not been extensively subjected to phylogenetic analysis using cladistics . Hand-draw n cladogram s hav e been proposed for caprinids by Skelton (1991) and, more rigorously , b y Skelto n & Mass e (1998 ) fo r those o f th e Lowe r Cretaceous . Smit h (1994 ) an d Steuber (1999a) presented hand-drawn cladograms for a wide r selectio n o f rudists , thoug h base d o n limited data derived from the literature, while Stone & Telfor d (1999 ) constructe d a computer-derive d cladogram, thoug h agai n base d o n rathe r fe w characters and taxa. The most rigorous and detailed analyses t o dat e ar e computer-base d cladogram s constructed fo r variou s caprini d rudists , wit h selected outgrou p taxa, by Chartrousse (I998a). History of ideas on rudist systematics and phylogeny Following th e consensu s o n rudist s a s bivalves , authors a t firs t tende d t o all y the m wit h chamaceans, followin g Quensted t (1852 ) (e.g . Bayle 1855 ; Woodward 1855; Zittel 1885 ; Fischer 1887). Althoug h Douvill e (1886 , 1887 ) als o initially favoure d suc h a link , h e subsequentl y (Douville 1935) preferred a direct derivation from a byssate ancestor, suc h as Pterocardia. The chamid hypothesis wa s finall y rejecte d b y Kenned y et a l (1970), who convincingly showed chamids to be a later, independen t offshoo t fro m th e carditids . However, Pterocardia (probabl y a specialize d
Jurassic cockle ) i s als o a n unlikel y candidat e fo r ancestry, possessin g som e derive d feature s no t shared wit h rudists , suc h a s pronounce d latera l teeth ( a character typica l o f cardiids). Instead , th e hypothesis mos t widel y favoure d toda y i s fo r th e derivation o f th e rudist s fro m megalodontid s [following Boeh m (1882) , an d Dechaseau x (1952)]. Megalodontid s shar e wit h th e earlies t rudists projectin g spirogyrat e umbone s associate d with a modifie d parivincula r ligament , massiv e pachyodont dentitio n an d ledge-lik e myophore s supporting the posterior adductor s (Fig. la; Skelto n 1978). The golden age for the systematic subdivisio n of rudists wa s i n th e lat e nineteent h an d earl y twentieth centuries. The foundations for the current higher leve l classificatio n o f th e grou p wer e lai d down largely by Douville (1886, 1887, 1888, 1889 , and man y subsequen t works , culminatin g i n hi s remarkable synthesi s o f 193 5 - publishe d i n his 89th year). The most important subsequent revision was tha t o f Ma c Gillavr y (1937) , whos e investigations o f Caribbea n rudist s le d t o severa l major conclusion s concernin g rudis t phylogeny in general. Following Munie r Chalma s (1882) , Douvill e (1887) recognize d a fundamenta l distinctio n between a 'serie normale' o f shells wit h one main tooth in the LV and two in the RV (Fig. Ib and c), and a 'serie inverse' showin g two teet h i n the LV (Fig. Id ) and one in the RV. To the 'serie normale' he assigned only the primitive Tribu de Diceratines together with a minor offshoot, th e Bayleines (late r included i n th e Famil y Requieniida e Douville , 1915), whil e si x other tribus were include d i n th e 'serie inverse'. Douvill e furthe r note d tha t attachment to the substratum was by the LV in the 'normal' group , wit h th e exceptio n o f Diceras itself, i n whic h eithe r valv e migh t b e attached , while the 'inverse' forms invariably attached by the RV. Douvill e (1887 ) initiall y accepte d Munie r Chalmas' [Munie r Chalmas (1882)] explanation of dental inversion for the difference between his two series, by analogy with Chama. However, he later argued (Douville 1896 ) that the change in dentition was due , instead, t o suppressio n o f th e anterio r tooth i n th e R V an d enlargemen t o f a n incipien t posterior toot h i n the LV (e.g. Fig. Ib) i n the firs t 'inverse' form , Valletta. From specimen s prepare d b y Bayl e (1873) , Douville (1935) further rec