WORLD SOIL RESOURCES AND FOOD SECURITY
Advances in Soil Science
WORLD SOIL RESOURCES AND FOOD SECURITY
Edited by
Ra...
64 downloads
902 Views
28MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
WORLD SOIL RESOURCES AND FOOD SECURITY
Advances in Soil Science
WORLD SOIL RESOURCES AND FOOD SECURITY
Edited by
Rattan Lal B. A. Stewart
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2012 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Version Date: 20110623 International Standard Book Number-13: 978-1-4398-4451-9 (eBook - PDF) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint. Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright. com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
Contents Preface......................................................................................................................vii Editors........................................................................................................................ix Contributors...............................................................................................................xi Chapter 1 Sustainable Management of Soil Resources and Food Security...........1 Rattan Lal and B. A. Stewart Chapter 2 Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues............. 11 Shahla Shapouri, Stacey Rosen, and Summer Allen Chapter 3 World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges........................ 29 H. Eswaran, P. F. Reich, and E. Padmanabhan Chapter 4 Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Forest and Agricultural Ecosystems in Humid Asia............................................. 53 S. Funakawa, T. Watanabe, A. Kadono, A. Nakao, K. Fujii, and T. Kosaki Chapter 5 Pedogenetic Acidification in Upland Soils under Different Bioclimatic Conditions in Humid Asia............................................. 169 S. Funakawa, T. Watanabe, A. Nakao, K. Fujii, and T. Kosaki Chapter 6 Soil Resources Affecting Food Security and Safety in South Asia.................................................................................................... 271 Tapan J. Purakayastha, Bal Ram Singh, R. P. Narwal, and Promod K. Chhonkar Chapter 7 Formation and Management of Cracking Clay Soils (Vertisols) to Enhance Crop Productivity: Indian Experience........................... 317 D. K. Pal, T. Bhattacharyya, and Suhas P. Wani
v
vi
Contents
Chapter 8 Role of Nuclear and Isotopic Techniques in Sustainable Land Management: Achieving Food Security and Mitigating Impacts of Climate Change............................................................................. 345 Long Nguyen, Felipe Zapata, Rattan Lal, and Gerd Dercon Chapter 9 New Paradigm to Unlock the Potential of Rainfed Agriculture in the Semiarid Tropics..................................................................... 419 Suhas P. Wani, Johan Rockstrom, B. Venkateswarlu, and A. K. Singh Chapter 10 Land Degradation.............................................................................. 471 Freddy O. Nachtergaele, Monica Petri, and Riccardo Biancalani Chapter 11 Where Do We Stand 20 Years after the Assessment of Soil Nutrient Balances in Sub-Saharan Africa?....................................... 499 E. M. A. Smaling, J. P. Lesschen, C. L. van Beek, A. de Jager, J. J. Stoorvogel, N. H. Batjes, and L. O. Fresco Chapter 12 Research Needs for Credible Data on Soil Resources and Degradation....................................................................................... 539 Rattan Lal
Preface World soils, the basis of all terrestrial life, are finite in extent, variable over time and space, and prone to alterations by natural and anthropogenic perturbations. Productive soils of high quality are essential to human well-being, economic and sustainable development, political stability, and ethnic and cultural harmony. Ancient civilizations and cultures (i.e., Mayan, Aztec, Mesopotamian, Indus, Yangtze) arose and thrived on good soils, and survived only as long as soils had the capacity to support them. These and other once thriving civilizations collapsed with declines in the quality of their soils. Even during the twenty-first century, a good soil is the engine of economic development and essential to present and future food security. Yet, the quality of soil resources is threatened by human-induced and natural perturbations. Soil quality is degraded by land misuse and soil mismanagement. Soil resources available for agricultural use are also being diminished for conversion to other uses (e.g., urbanization, industrial, recreational). The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations defines soil degradation as a decline in “the current or potential capability of soils to produce goods and services.” Soil use and management produce several goods including food, feed, fiber, fuel, and industrial raw materials. Under both natural and managed ecosystems, soils also generate numerous ecosystem services including moderation of climate, purification and filtration of water, enhancement of biodiversity, an archive of planetary and earth history, a reservoir of germplasm, etc. Whereas soil degradation may lead to reductions in its ability to produce goods and generate services, its capacity to do so also depends on numerous endogenous and exogenous factors. Endogenous factors are those related to soil-forming factors including climate, vegetation, parent material, terrain, and time. The exogenous factors include anthropogenic perturbations including deforestation, biomass burning, drainage, irrigation, and use of inputs (fertilizer, amendments, tillage methods, residues management, vehicular traffic, cropping and farming systems, etc). Exogenous factors may also be natural perturbations such as volcanic eruption, seismic activity, tsunami, etc. The impacts of exogenous factors on the extent and severity are exacerbated by several endogenous factors (i.e., climate, terrain). There exists a vast amount of literature on soil degradation. However, the data reported in the literature are often confusing, contradictory, erratic, and misleading. The problem is confounded by several factors such as: (i) using interchangeably different terminology such as land vs. soil, degradation vs. desertification; (ii) using different methodologies to assess degradation; (iii) using different categories to assess the severity of a degradation process such as light vs. slight, severe vs. strong; (iv) using proxy methods to indirectly assess the extent and severity of degradation; (v) not validating the estimates by ground truthing; (vi) not relating goods produced (e.g., crop yields) to the severity of degradation under different land uses and management; and (vii) not evaluating the masking effects of improved management practices through partial or complete elimination of some soil-related constraints to vii
viii
Preface
agronomic production. Thus, there is a strong need for creating credible data based on the use of standardized methodology and terminology, ground truthing and validation, assessing impacts on agronomic production under a range of management scenarios, and evaluating social and economic impacts on the community. This volume is specifically dedicated to soil resources of the world in terms of their availability and status in the context of the growing demands of increasing world population and rising expectations of living standards. It comprises invited chapters contributed by renowned scientists in their specific fields of expertise including global food situations by Shahla Shapouri, world soil resources by Hari Eswaran and colleagues, soil resources for humid Asia and their acidification by Funakawa and colleagues, soil resources of South Asia by Tapan Purakayastha and others, properties and management of vertisols by D. Pal and colleagues, use of radio isotopic techniques in soil management by Long Nguyen and his colleagues at IAEA, the potential of rainfed agriculture in the semiarid tropics by S. Wani and group, the status of land degradation by F. Nachtergaele and colleagues, and the nutrient balance in sub-Saharan Africa by E. Smaling and others. The volume is a useful reference source for those interested in the state of the soils of the world in relation to food security and environmental quality. Rattan Lal B. A. Stewart
Editors Rattan Lal is a distinguished professor of soil physics in the School of Environment and Natural Resources and director of the Carbon Management and Sequestration Center, Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences/Ohio Agriculture Research and Development Center, at The Ohio State University. Before joining Ohio State in 1987, he was a soil physicist for 18 years at the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, Ibadan, Nigeria. In Africa, Professor Lal conducted long-term experiments on land use, watershed management, soil erosion processes as influenced by rainfall characteristics, soil properties, methods of deforestation, soil-tillage and crop-residue management, cropping systems including cover crops and agroforestry, and mixed/relay cropping methods. He also assessed the impact of soil erosion on crop yields and related erosion-induced changes in soil properties to crop growth and yields. Since joining Ohio State University in 1987, he has continued research on erosion-induced changes in soil quality and developed a new project on soils and climate change. He has demonstrated that accelerated soil erosion is a major factor affecting emission of carbon from the soil to the atmosphere. Soil-erosion control and adoption of conservation-effective measures can lead to carbon sequestration and mitigation of the greenhouse effect. Other research interests include soil compaction, conservation tillage, mine soil reclamation, water table management, and sustainable use of soil and water resources of the tropics for enhancing food security. Professor Lal is a fellow of the Soil Science Society of America, American Society of Agronomy, Third World Academy of Sciences, American Association for the Advancement of Sciences, Soil and Waste Conservation Society, and Indian Academy of Agricultural Sciences. He is a recipient of the International Soil Science Award of the Soil Science Society of America, the Hugh Hammond Bennett Award of the Soil and Water Conservation Society, the 2005 Borlaug Award, and the 2009 Swaminathan Award. He also received an honorary degree of Doctor of Science from Punjab Agricultural University, India, from the Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Aas, Norway, and the Alecu Russo Balti State University in Moldova. He is a past president of the World Association of the Soil and Water Conservation, the International Soil Tillage Research Organization, and the Soil Science Society of America. He is a member of the United States National Committee on Soil Science of the National Academy of Sciences (1998 to 2002, 2007 to present). He has served on the Panel of Sustainable Agriculture and the Environment in the Humid Tropics of the National Academy of Sciences. He has authored and coauthored around 1500 research papers. He has also written 15 books and edited or coedited another 48. B. A. Stewart is a distinguished professor of soil science at the West Texas A&M University, Canyon, Texas. He is also the director of the Dryland Agriculture Institute, and a former director of the United States Department of Agriculture Conservation and Production Laboratory at Bushland, Texas; past president of the Soil Science Society of America; and member of the 1990–1993 Committee on Long-Range Soil ix
x
Editors
and Water Policy, National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences. He is a fellow of the Soil Science Society of America, the American Society of Agronomy, the Soil and Water Conservation Society, a recipient of the United States Department of Agriculture Superior Service Award, a recipient of the Hugh Hammond Bennett Award of the Soil and Water Conservation Society, and an honorary member of the International Union of Soil Sciences in 2008. Dr. Stewart is very supportive of education and research on dryland agriculture. The B.A. and Jane Anne Stewart Dryland Agriculture Scholarship Fund was established at West Texas A&M University in 1994 to provide scholarships for undergraduate and graduate students with a demonstrated interest in dryland agriculture.
Contributors Summer Allen Economic Research Service United States Department of Agriculture Washington, D.C. N. H. Batjes ISRIC—World Soil Information Wageningen, the Netherlands T. Bhattacharyya Division of Soil Resource Studies National Bureau of Soil Survey and Land Use Planning Nagpur, India Riccardo Biancalani Land and Water Division Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Rome, Italy Promod K. Chhonkar Division of Soil Science and Agricultural Chemistry Indian Agricultural Research Institute New Delhi, India A. de Jager North and West Africa Division International Fertilizer Development Center Accra, Ghana Gerd Dercon International Atomic Energy Agency Vienna, Austria
H. Eswaran Natural Resources Conservation Service United States Department of Agriculture Washington, D.C. L. O. Fresco University of Amsterdam Amsterdam, the Netherlands K. Fujii Graduate School of Agriculture Kyoto University Kyoto, Japan S. Funakawa Graduate School of Agriculture Kyoto University Kyoto, Japan A. Kadono Graduate School of Urban Environmental Sciences Tokyo Metropolitan University Tokyo, Japan T. Kosaki Graduate School of Urban Environmental Sciences Tokyo Metropolitan University Tokyo, Japan Rattan Lal Carbon Management and Sequestration Center The Ohio State University Columbus, Ohio
xi
xii
Contributors
J. P. Lesschen Alterra Wageningen University and Research Centre Wageningen, the Netherlands
Tapan J. Purakayastha Division of Soil Science and Agricultural Chemistry Indian Agricultural Research Institute New Delhi, India
Freddy O. Nachtergaele Land and Water Division Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Rome, Italy
P. F. Reich Natural Resources Conservation Service United States Department of Agriculture Washington, D.C.
A. Nakao Department of Radioecology Institute for Environmental Sciences Aomori-Ken, Japan R. P. Narwal Chaudhary Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University Haryana, India Long Nguyen International Atomic Energy Agency Vienna, Austria E. Padmanabhan Petroleum and Geoscience Department University of Technology Petronas Perak, Malaysia D. K. Pal Division of Soil Resource Studies National Bureau of Soil Survey and Land Use Planning Nagpur, India Monica Petri Land and Water Division Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Rome, Italy
Johan Rockstrom Stockholm Environment Institute Stockholm, Sweden Stacey Rosen Economic Research Service United States Department of Agriculture Washington, D.C. Shahla Shapouri Economic Research Service United States Department of Agriculture Washington, D.C. A. K. Singh Indian Council of Agricultural Research New Delhi, India Bal Ram Singh Department of Plant and Environmental Sciences Norwegian University of Life Sciences Ås, Norway
xiii
Contributors
E. M. A. Smaling Royal Tropical Institute (KIT) Amsterdam, the Netherlands and University of Twente Faculty of Geo-Information Science and Earth Observation (ITC) Enschede, the Netherlands B. A. Stewart Dryland Agriculture Institute West Texas A&M University Canyon, Texas J. J. Stoorvogel Land Dynamics Group Wageningen University and Research Centre Wageningen, the Netherlands C. L. van Beek Alterra Wageningen University and Research Centre Wageningen, the Netherlands
B. Venkateswarlu Central Research Institute for Dryland Agriculture Andhra Pradesh, India Suhas P. Wani International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics Andhra Pradesh, India T. Watanabe Graduate School of Agriculture Kyoto University Kyoto, Japan Felipe Zapata International Atomic Energy Agency Vienna, Austria
Management 1 Sustainable of Soil Resources and Food Security Rattan Lal and B. A. Stewart CONTENTS 1.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Soil and Climatic Effects on Agricultural Production......................................2 1.3 Enhancing Soil Resilience through Sustainable Management.......................... 3 1.4 Per Capita Arable Land Area and Energy Use..................................................5 1.5 Diet Preferences.................................................................................................6 1.6 Carbon Sequestration in Terrestrial Ecosystems............................................... 7 1.7 Soil Degradation................................................................................................8 1.8 Conclusions........................................................................................................8 Acronyms.................................................................................................................... 9 References................................................................................................................... 9
1.1 INTRODUCTION The world population is projected to increase from about 7 billion in 2011 to 9.2 billion in 2050. The current rate of increase is about 6 million/month, with almost all growth occurring in developing countries where natural resources are already under great stress. The Green Revolution technology led to the doubling of food production between 1950 and 2010, with only a 10% increase in the area under production [FAO 2010]. However, meeting the food demand of the growing population, rising standards of living, and changes in diet preferences will necessitate an additional 70% increase in production between 2010 and 2050 [Burney et al. 2010]. Yet yields in the Indo-Gangetic plains and other regions have stagnated or declined over the past two decades and may be jeopardized further by climate change and increases in the frequency and intensity of extreme events [Semonov 2009], especially in sub-Saharan Africa [IIED 2010]. Grain yields of wheat [Semenov 2009] and rice [Wassmann et al. 2009] are sensitive to high temperatures. The problem of food insecurity is also exacerbated by increases in the severity and extent of soil degradation. This is especially true because of declines in the soil structure and hydrological properties in conjunction with reductions in the quantity and quality of soil organic carbon (SOC) content caused by a widespread use of extractive farming practices (i.e., indiscriminate residue removal, excessive grazing, the use of animal dung as household fuel 1
2
World Soil Resources and Food Security
rather than as manure, and a negative nutrient budget). Over and above the biophysical constraints being exacerbated by a changing climate and an increase in the frequency of extreme events, there are also issues related to the human dimensions. To the resource-poor and small-size land holders of the tropics and subtropics, neither the essential inputs are available (e.g., improved seeds and fertilizers and new equipment such as no-till seed drills and soil testing facilities), nor affordable. One, these inputs are prohibitively expensive. Two, farmers are not sure about their effectiveness, especially under conditions of uncertain rains, frequent droughts, and a high incidence of weeds and other pests. This volume is especially focused on the soil resources of the world and the challenge of their management on a sustainable basis. This introductory chapter describes some of the soil-related constraints on enhancing agricultural production on smallholder farms of the tropics and subtropics, and outlines mitigative and adaptive strategies for changing climates and declining qualities of soil and water resources.
1.2 S OIL AND CLIMATIC EFFECTS ON AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION There is a strong interaction between soil degradation and extreme events (e.g., drought, inundation), with positive feedback from reducing the agronomic or net primary productivity (NPP). Declines in productivity are accentuated by reductions in the use-efficiency of nutrients and water, both inherent and applied. These interactive effects lead to declines in both plant- and animal-based outputs (Table 1.1). Specific reductions in plant-based outputs are those related to declines in yields of crops (cereals, grain legumes, roots and tubers, oil seeds, fruits and vegetables), fuel [crop residues, wood, charcoal, biomass from switchgrass (Pennistum vergatum), etc.], feed (forages, crop residues, fodder trees), and fiber [cotton (Gossipium hirsutum)]. Because of close interactions between plants and animals, a decline in soil quality also affects animal health and productivity. Healthy soils produce healthy plants, raise healthy animals, improve human health, and vice versa. Consequently, TABLE 1.1 Agricultural Products Affected by Soil Resource Degradation, Climate Change, and Related Extreme Events Production 1.
Food
2.
Fuel
3.
Feed
4. 5.
Fiber Raw materials
Plant-Based Cereals, grain legumes, roots and tubers, oil seeds, vegetables, fruits Wood, charcoal, biomass, residues, sugarcane, oils Forages, fodder trees and shrubs, rangelands, seed cakes Cotton, hemp, banana, agave Bioeconomy, timber, resins, medicines, pharmaceuticals, oils
Animal-Based Milk, poultry, fish, meat Dung, animal fat, residues Fishmeal, meat and poultry by-products Soil, wool, animal hairs Fish oil, animal products
Sustainable Management of Soil Resources and Food Security
3
a decline in soil quality coupled with an increase in the frequency of extreme events reduce the output of animal-based products such as milk, meat, poultry, wool, etc. (Table 1.1).
1.3 E NHANCING SOIL RESILIENCE THROUGH SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT No technological panacea exists for the global challenges of sustainable use of soil and water resources [The Royal Society 2009]. This is especially true because the constraints on agronomic production differ among climates, soils, and geographical regions. Nonetheless, the strategy is to reverse the degradation trend, restore degraded soils, and enhance resilience to any adverse effects of climate change. Conversion to restorative land use and adoption of recommended management practices (RMPs) would improve soil quality and adaptation to climate change (e.g., onset of rains, changes in soil temperature, moisture regime, and growing season duration). Adoption of RMPs can mitigate climate change [UNFCCC 2008; Lobell and Burney 2010], and is also essential to advancing global food security [Gregory et al. 2005; Lobell et al. 2008]. Furthermore, agricultural RMPs, in addition to enhancing natural processes, are more cost-effective than engineering techniques for carbon capture and storage [McKinsey & Company 2009]. In this context, agricultural intensification in developing countries is an important solution to climate change [World Bank 2009]. Land uses and RMPs that enhance adaptation to climate change also have mitigative effects through (i) sequestering carbon in soils and biota, thereby enhancing the ecosystem carbon pools, and (ii) reducing emissions through conversion of plow-till systems to no-till (NT) or conservation agriculture (CA) systems and enhanced use-efficiency of energy-based inputs (e.g., fertilizers, irrigation). Some RMPs for improving soil quality and enhancing soil resilience are outlined in Figure 1.1. Important among these are (i) integrated nutrient management (INM) for balancing budgets for macronutrients (N, P, K, Ca, Mg) and micronutrients (Zn, Cu, Fe, Se), (ii) improving the chemical properties of soil, such as soil reaction through liming, while also enhancing cation exchange capacity (CEC), (iii) enhancing aggregation and improving soil tilth, (iv) increasing the soil organic carbon (SOC) pool and its quality, along with improvements in the activity and species diversity of soil fauna (microbial biomass carbon, earthworm activity), and (v) moderating soil temperature so that it is within the optimal range (25°C–30°C) in the root zone. Soil-specific RMPs to achieve these goals include CA, cover cropping, manuring, biochar application, and those RMPs that enhance earthworm and other biota activity (Figure 1.1). Similar to soil management, there are also RMPs for improving the use-efficiency of water resources (Figure 1.1). Important among these are (i) conserving water in the root zone by increasing infiltration capacity, decreasing surface runoff, and reducing evaporation, (ii) harvesting and recycling water through supplemental irrigation by using microirrigation, drip subsurface irrigation (DSI), fertigation, and even condensation irrigation (CI), (iii) using genetically modified crops with deep root systems and built-in mechanisms for drought avoidance and tolerance, and (iv) using an aerobic rice culture that saves water and improves water use-efficiency
4
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Soil management Nutrients: macro, micro (INM, slow release, nano-enhanced fertilizers) Reaction: liming, leaching Structure: conservation agriculture Temperature: optimize Biota: macro, micro Precision farming: soil-specific management Amendments: manure, biochar
Water management
Soil water retention Infiltration capacity and storage Runoff control Evaporation reduction Supplemental irrigation (micro, DSI, CI) Water harvesting and recycling Plastic mulch Aerobic rice
Farming systems management
1. Crops: rotations, complex systems, perennial culture, GM crops 2. Trees: species management, GM varieties, super-CO2 adsorbing trees, albedo management 3. Animals: species management, methane management
Ecosystem management Silvo-pastoral systems Agro-silvo-pastoral systems Eco-efficiency approach
FIGURE 1.1 Agricultural intensification to enhance soil and ecosystem resilience for mitigation of and adaptation to climate change and related extreme events. CDSI, drip subirrigation; CI, condensation irrigation; INM, integrated nutrient management.
[Bouman et al. 2007]. There exists a strong interaction between soil temperature and the use-efficiency of soil water. Practiced in conjunction with the retention of crop residue mulch and INM needed for complex rotations, CA can moderate surface soil temperature while reducing losses (by runoff and evaporation) and improving use-efficiency of stored and applied water (Figure 1.1). These strategies and the relevant policy interventions have been described elsewhere [The Royal Society 2009; FAO 2010]. Adoption of improved farming systems is integral to the sustainable management of soil and water resources, and to the mitigation of, and adaptation to, climate change. The goal is to integrate the cultivation of crops with the growth of suitable trees and the raising of livestock. Important options include the perennial culture of wheat (Triticum aestivum) and barley (Hordeum vulgare) [Glover et al. 2010], complex rotations (cereals–legumes–forages/hay), agroforestry, silvopastoral systems, and agrosilvopastoral systems (Figure 1.1). Agroforestry systems enhance, stabilize, and sustain production under small-holder agriculture [Zomer et al. 2009; Sileshi et al. 2008]. These farming systems increase land use intensity and have high NPP per unit area, unit time, and unit consumption of inherent and applied resources (e.g., nutrients, water, energy). While stabilizing productivity and restoring soil quality, complex systems also minimize the incidence of pests. Amudavi et al. [2007] show the effectiveness of a push–pull system of integrated pest management (IPM) for
Sustainable Management of Soil Resources and Food Security
5
maize (Zea mays L) cultivation in East Africa by intercropping maize with desmodium (Desmodium uncinatum), which suppresses striga (Striga hermonthica) and growing Napier grass (Pennisetum purpureum) that is more attractive to moths of the maize stalk borer (Busseola fusca) [Cook et al. 2007; Hassanali et al. 2008]. Complex systems involving intercropping with perennial shrubs can also improve drought tolerance through hydraulic lift [Caldwell and Richards 1989]. Complex farming systems may also enhance the use-efficiency of fertilizers and reduce the rate of application. Future demand for nitrogenous fertilizers may require 2% of the total global energy use by 2050 as the Haber–Bosch process is highly energy-intensive [Glendining et al. 2009]. Complex systems based on reduced cultivation may also promote arbiscular mychorrhizal (AM) associations that enhance plant nutrient uptake and agronomic sustainability [Leigh et al. 2009].
1.4 PER CAPITA ARABLE LAND AREA AND ENERGY USE The increase in population, from 7 billion in 2011 to 9.2 billion in 2050, will occur almost entirely in developing countries. The per capita arable land area—which in most countries of South and East Asia is <0.15 ha (Table 1.2), and as low as 0.04 ha in densely populated countries such as Bangladesh—is declining as the population is increasing. Thus, all basic necessities (food, feed, fiber, fuel, and the raw materials listed in Table 1.1) have to be met from this ever dwindling and fragile resource. Similar to arable land area, fresh renewable water resources are also scarce and in heavy demand for competing uses such as industry and urbanization [Molden 2007]. With arable land and fresh water supplies scarce, resource-poor farmers are unable to invest in or use energy-based inputs. For example, oil consumption per unit of
TABLE 1.2 Arable Land and Oil Consumption in Selected Countries Country USA China Germany Brazil Indonesia India Nigeria Philippines Kenya
Per Capita Arable Land (ha)
Oil Consumption per Hectare of Arable Land (L/ha)
0.568 0.136 0.146 0.343 1.147 1.143 1.220 0.119 0.135
2.73 0.311 2.78 0.231 0.407 0.060 0.256 0.348 0.077
Source: Winslow, M.D., and Ortiz, R., The International Dimensions of the American Society of Agronomy: Past and Future, Madison, WI: ASA, 2010. Note: The oil consumption refers to use in mechanized farm operations and does not include fertilizer equivalent.
6
World Soil Resources and Food Security
TABLE 1.3 Trends of Wheat Yield in India and China Wheat Yield (Mg/ha) Year
China
India
Ratio (China to India)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
3.74 3.81 3.78 3.93 4.25 4.28 4.55 4.64
2.80 2.70 2.80 2.60 2.70 2.60 2.60 2.70
1.34 1.41 1.35 1.51 1.57 1.65 1.75 1.72
Source: Rajaram, S., The International Dimensions of the American Society of Agronomy: Past and Future, Madison, WI: ASA, 2010.
arable land ranges from >2.7 L/ha in Germany to <0.06 L/ha in India (Table 1.2). The low oil consumption is indicative of the lack of, or low intensity of, mechanized farming operations, such as plowing and, harvesting, and the low use of fertilizers and other chemicals. The data in Table 1.3 show trends in the wheat yield in China and India during the 2000s. China’s yield is increasing with time because of the high fertilizer use, up to 600 kg/ha, while India’s yield is stagnating because of soil degradation and nutrient mining. The data in Tables 1.2 and 1.3 raise an important question. Is it possible to increase and sustain production from arable lands managed by resource-poor farmers by reducing external inputs such as fertilizers, amendments, water, and energy? Is recycling a viable option on a national scale where soils are already depleted of their nutrient reserves? Are there viable alternatives to external inputs of fertilizers, pesticides, irrigation, and mechanized farming operations in view of the present and future population? If the answer is yes, where and under what conditions?
1.5 DIET PREFERENCES In addition to a decline in per capita arable land area, reductions in fresh water resources, and rising demands for energy, changes in the dietary preferences of the populations of emerging economies such as China and India must also be considered when seeking to enhance food production. The data in Table 1.4 show gradual increases in meat consumption in developing countries. The ratio of meat consumption in developed vs. developing countries, as computed in terms of kcal/capita/day, is decreasing with time. The ratio was 3.35 in 1990–1992, 2.48 in 1996–1998 and 2.26 in 2003–2005 (Table 1.4). Meat-based diets have a drastically higher footprint for carbon, water, energy, and land area. A shift in the favor of meat-based diets would jeopardize natural resources that are unequally distributed among geographical
7
Sustainable Management of Soil Resources and Food Security
TABLE 1.4 Trends in Meat Consumption in Developed and Developing Countries between 1990 and 2005 Meat Consumption (kcal/capita/day) Produce Beef
Pork
Chicken
Total
Year
Developed Countries (A)
Developing Countries (B)
Ratio A:B
1990–1992 1996–1998 2003–2005 1990–1992 1996–1998 2003–2005 1990–1992 1996–1998 2003–2005 1990–1992 1996–1998 2003–2005
124 102 99 193 178 189 68 73 94 385 357 382
29 32 34 71 89 105 15 23 30 115 144 169
4.27 3.19 2.91 2.72 2.00 1.8 4.53 3.17 3.13 3.35 2.48 2.26
Source: Hawkes, C., and Ruel, M., The International Dimensions of the American Society of Agronomy: Past and Future, Madison, WI: ASA, 2010.
regions, that are dwindling because of conversion to nonagricultural uses such as urbanization, industrial use, and brink-making, and that are prone to degradation because of land misuse, soil mismanagement, and harsh climates.
1.6 CARBON SEQUESTRATION IN TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTEMS In addition to advancing food security, agricultural intensification through adoption of RMPs has potential for carbon sequestration in soils and biota [Burney et al. 2010; Bellasen et al. 2010; FAO 2010]. Furthermore, land-based carbon sinks are highly cost-effective [McKinsey & Company 2009]. There are numerous cobenefits, especially in relation to increases in biodiversity, improvements in water quality, and increases in agronomic productivity. Because agricultural intensification also creates a positive ecosystem carbon budget, sustainable development is being linked to climate change mitigation [World Bank 2009]. Payments to land managers and farmers for ecosystem services rendered are being adopted to promote agricultural intensification through adoption of RMPs. Paying for ecosystem services (PESs) is a better strategy than paying subsidies. In this context, subsidies in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) have proven ineffective, creating dependency, exacerbating corruption, and dampening innovation and initiative. The technical potential of carbon sequestration in terrestrial ecosystems, such as soils, biota, wetlands, and peat soils, is about 4 Gt of carbon/yr [Lal 2010]. With payments of $25/t of carbon, the strategy of PES can generate another income stream for farmers. With agroforestry and other complex farming systems, an
8
World Soil Resources and Food Security
average rate of carbon sequestration of 2 t/ha in soils and biota can generate income of $50/ha. This income is important for resource-poor farmers as an initial step toward poverty alleviation and achievement of the U.N. Millennium Development Goals.
1.7 SOIL DEGRADATION The risks of soil degradation, especially those caused by accelerated erosion and secondary salinization, must be considered when addressing the need to increase food production. While the risks of decline in soil quality due to land misuse and soil mismanagement are serious, the available statistics on the extent and severity are often not credible. Further, the data on the estimates of soil degradation by different processes such as erosion, salinization, and nutrient depletion are not related to agronomic production on national, regional, or global scales. The plot-scale data on the yield decline in relation to specific degradation processes are available for some soil-specific situations. However, these data have not been appropriately scaled up through valid scaling techniques, pedotransfer functions, or geostatistical methods (Bellassen et al. 2010). Therefore, a lack of credible data on the extent of degradation (on national, regional, or global scales) and on the impact of agronomic production under different management scenarios have caused misinterpretations, misunderstandings, confusion, and contradictions. Long-term and soil-based studies are needed under diverse climatic conditions to quantify the impact of degradation processes on agronomic production and the use-efficiency of inputs under a range of farming systems.
1.8 CONCLUSIONS Soil resources of the world are finite, unequally distributed among geographical regions, and prone to degradation by land misuse and soil mismanagement. The per capita agricultural land area is decreasing because of increases in population, conversion to urban and industrial uses, and degradation by a range of human-induced processes. Yet food production must be increased, despite the uncertain climate and risks of drought, weeds, pests, and pathogens. In addition to the required increases in food production, dietary changes in emerging economies, with preference given to more animal-based diets, must also be considered. Thus, the strategy is to: • Improve the data on soil resources including the extent, quality, type, and severity of degradation and the resultant effects on agronomic yield • Indentify recommended management practices that enhance and sustain productivity, strengthen soil resilience against climate change, and improve the use-efficiency of inputs • Implement long-term restoration projects of degraded soils to enhance ecosystem services • Enhance productivity from existing agricultural land, thus minimizing the need to convert new lands from natural ecosystems such as tropical rainforests, savannahs, and steppe to croplands and grazing lands
Sustainable Management of Soil Resources and Food Security
9
ACRONYMS AM CA CEC CI DSI ha INM NPP NT PESs RMP SOC SSA
arbiscular mychorrhizal conservation agriculture cation exchange capacity condensation irrigation drip subsurface irrigation hectare integrated nutrient management net primary productivity no till payments for ecosystem services recommended management practices soil organic carbon sub-Saharan Africa
REFERENCES Amudavi, D., Z. Khan, and J. Pickett. 2007. Enhancing the push–pull strategy. Leisa Magazine 23:8–10. Bellassen, V., R.J. Manlay, J.-P. Chèry, V. Gitz, A. Tourè, M. Bernoux, and J.-L. Chotte. 2010. Multi-criteria spatialzation of soil organic carbon sequestration potential from agricultural intensification in Senegal. Climatic Change 98:213–243. Bouman, B.A.M., R.M. Lampayan, and T.P. Toung. 2007. Water Management in Irrigated Rice: Coping with Water Scarcity. Los Baños, Philippines: IRRI. Burney, J.A., S.J. Davis, and D.B. Lobell. 2010. Greenhouse gas mitigation by agricultural intensification. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107:12052–12057. Caldwell, M.H., and J.H. Richards. 1989. Hydraulic lift: Water efflux from upper roots improves effectiveness of water uptake by deep roots. Oecologia 79:1–5. Cook, S.M., Z.R. Khan, and J.A. Pickett. 2007. The use of push–pull strategies in integrated pest management. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 52:375–400. Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO). 2010. Challenges and opportunities for carbon sequestration in grassland systems. Integrated Crop Management, vol. 9-2010. Rome: FAO. Glendining, M.J., A.G. Dailey, A.G. Williams, F.K. Van Evert, K.W.T. Goulding, and A.P. Whitmore. 2009. Is it possible to increase the sustainability of arable and ruminant agriculture by reducing inputs? Agr. Syst. 99:117–125. Glover, J.D., J.P. Ragnold, L.W. Bell, J. Borevitz, E.C. Brummer, C.M. Cox, T.S. Cox, T.E. Crews, S.W. Culman, L.R. DeHaan, et al. 2010. Increased food and ecosystem security via perennial grains. Science 328:1638–1639. Gregory, P. J., S.I. Ingram, and M. Brklacich. 2005. Climate change and food security. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B 360:2139–2148. Hassanali, A., H. Herren, Z.R. Khan, J.A. Pickett, and C.M. Woodcock. 2007. Integrated pest management: The push–pull approach for controlling insects, pests and weeds of cereals, and its potential for other agricultural systems including animal husbandry. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B 363:611–621. Hawkes, C., and M. Ruel. 2010. Changing global diets: Implications for agriculture. In The International Dimensions of the American Society of Agronomy: Past and Future, B. Payne and J. Ryan, eds., 57–65. Madison, WI: ASA.
10
World Soil Resources and Food Security
International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED). 2010. The Impacts of Climate Change on Food Security in Africa: A Synthesis of Policy Issues for Europe. London: IIED. Lal, R. 2010. Managing soils and ecosystems for mitigating anthropogenic carbon emissions and advancing global food security. Bioscience 60:708–721. Leigh, J., A. Hodge, and A.H. Fitter. 2009. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi can transfer substantial amounts of nitrogen to their host plant from organic material. New Phytol. 181:199–207. Lobell, D., and J. Burney. 2010. Greenhouse gas mitigation by agricultural intensification. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107(26):12052–12057. Lobell, D.B., M.B. Burke, C. Tebaldi, M.D. Mastrandrea, W.P. Falcon, and R.L. Naylor. 2008. Prioritizing climate change adaptation needs for food security in 2030. Science 319:607–610. McKinsey & Company. 2009. Pathways to a low carbon economy. The Global Greenhouse Gas Abatement Cost Curve, version 2. New York: McKinsey & Company. Molden, D., ed. 2007. Water for Food, Water for Life. London: IWMI Earthscan. Rajaram, S. 2010. Challenges in wheat research and development. In The International Dimensions of the American Society of Agronomy: Past and Future, B. Payne and J. Ryan, eds., 39–47. Madison, WI: ASA. The Royal Society. 2009. Reaping the Benefits: Science and the Sustainable Intensification of Global Agriculture. RS Policy Document RD 1608. London: The Royal Society. Semenov, M. 2009. Impacts of climate change on wheat in England and Wales. J. R. Soc. Interface 6:343–350. Sileshi, G., F.K. Akinnifesi, O.C. Ajayi, and F. Place. 2008. Meta-analysis of maize yield response to woody and herbaceous legumes in the sub-Saharan Africa. Plant Soil 307:1–19. United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). 2008. Challenges and Opportunities for Mitigation in the Agricultural Sector. Technical Paper F CC/ TP/2008/8.2008. Wassmann, R.S.,V.K. Jagdish, S. Hauer., A. Ismail, E. Redona, R. Serraj, R.K. Singh, G. Howell, H. Pathak, and K. Sumfleth. 2009. Climate change affecting rice production: The physiological and agronomic basis for possible adaptation. Adv. Agron. 101:59–122. Winslow, M.D., and R. Ortiz. 2010. Biofuels: Risks, opportunities and dilemmas for international agriculture. In The International Dimensions of the American Society of Agronomy: Past and Future, B. Payne and J. Ryan, eds., 99–105. Madison, WI: ASA. World Bank. 2009. World Development Report 2010. Development and Climate Change. Washington, DC: World Bank. Zomer, R.J., A. Trabucco, R. Coe, and F. Place. 2009. Trees on Farm: Analysis of Global Extent and Geographical Patterns of Agroforestry. ICRAF Working Paper 89. Nairobi, Kenya: World Agroforestry Center.
Food Situation 2 Global and Unresolved and Emerging Issues Shahla Shapouri, Stacey Rosen, and Summer Allen CONTENTS 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
Introduction..................................................................................................... 11 Population Growth and Disparity.................................................................... 12 Income Growth and Disparity......................................................................... 12 Production Growth and Disparity................................................................... 13 Food Consumption and Composition.............................................................. 17 Unresolved and Emerging Issues..................................................................... 21 2.6.1 Persistent Food Insecurity................................................................... 21 2.7 Growing Demand for Biofuels......................................................................... 22 2.8 Natural Resources and Climate Change.......................................................... 23 2.9 Access to New Technology to Enhance Production Growth...........................24 2.10 Rising Obesity Rates.......................................................................................25 2.11 Looking Ahead................................................................................................26 References................................................................................................................. 27
2.1 INTRODUCTION The global food situation depends on the interactions between consumption and production that are, in turn, influenced by population and income growth, technological change, geography, environment, and social and cultural factors. The key factors currently driving per capita food consumption are income levels and food prices, while the key factor driving food composition is the geographical setting (e.g., rural vs. urban areas). Therefore, any changes in income, prices, and/or geographical location are normally accompanied by changes in food access, dietary composition, and food security. Growth in food production can result from expanding the agricultural land base and/or intensifying production per unit of land. Given the economic and environmental constraints on cropland expansion, however, the bulk of increased food production will need to come from higher yields on existing cropland. This yield growth depends on the quality and availability of the required inputs, including natural resources such as land and water. Noting the importance of the multiple factors that influence global food security, this chapter will discuss the dynamics of population, income, production, and 11
12
World Soil Resources and Food Security
food consumption and composition, spatially and temporally. These dynamics are affected by the unresolved and emerging issues of chronic food insecurity, rising obesity, increased demand for biofuels, technology adoption, resource scarcity, and climate change. These components will be discussed in more detail.
2.2 POPULATION GROWTH AND DISPARITY During the twentieth century, population grew dramatically compared to historical rates. Between 1800 and 1900, the world population increased from 600 million to 1.6 billion. The rate of growth then accelerated such that by the year 2000, the global population had increased more than 3.5 times, reaching the 6 billion mark. In fact, it took only 12 years for the population to increase from 5 to 6 billion [UNFPA 2008]. This jump took place despite major factors: 1) a decline in the global rate of population growth as fertility rates in 88 countries fell below the level required for long term replacement of their populations; and 2) the AIDS pandemic that spread across Eastern and Southern Africa, resulting in a significant cut in population growth rates in several countries in these regions [UNFPA 2008]. The global population growth rate has averaged about 1% per year since 1990, about half the rate experienced during the 1950s and 1960s [UNFPA 2008]. Despite this slowdown in population growth, total global population increases more than 320 million people—larger than the population of the United States in 2008—every 4 years [FAO 2009]. There was a noticeable difference in the rate of population growth among country groups during the twentieth century. Developing countries, which had been characterized by high birth and death rates, transitioned to low death rates, thereby fueling global population growth. In developed countries, birth rates and death rates generally declined at the same rate; in some countries, mainly European countries and Japan, however, birth rates declined faster than death rates, leading to nearly stagnant population growth rates. This difference in growth paths led to a lasting change in the dynamic of populations during the past century: 80% of the population growth since 1900 has taken place in developing countries, particularly in the world’s poorer countries [UNFPA 2008]. Among developing countries, the population growth paths are clearly associated with income levels. In Asia, the highest income growth region, the decline in the population growth rate was much faster than in other regions. This is followed by Latin America and then Africa. At the subregion level, the smallest change has occurred in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), where historical annual population growth of 3% is projected to decline to 2.2% per year through the next decade, which can to a large degree be attributed to the AIDS pandemic. Despite the HIV/AIDS pandemic, SSA’s population nearly tripled, to an estimated 650 million between 1960 and 2000; in 2008, the region’s population was roughly 760 million or about 11% of the global population [UNFPA 2008].
2.3 INCOME GROWTH AND DISPARITY The most significant factor behind global food consumption patterns is income growth. From 1970 to 2005, global per capita income grew by about 70% on average,
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
13
increasing from about $3700 to $8000 (in 2000 U.S. dollars) [IMF 2007]. If this trend continues, it will result in a doubling of global per capita income by 2040. As expected, this record of overall growth in average world income, however, was not equally distributed among regions. In East Asia and the Pacific, per capita income rose more than 7-fold; in South Asia, income grew more than 2.5-fold, with a 2-fold increase in developed countries with high incomes and Euro areas. Per capita income in the Middle East and North Africa increased by 64% and by 56% in Latin America. SSA experienced the slowest growth at only 3% in 35 years. To put this into a global context, the region has about 11% of the global population, but less than 1.5% of its income. The disparity in growth at the country level was much higher than at the regional level. Per capita income (measured as per capita gross domestic product, GDP, in 2000 U.S. dollars) in 1970 ranged from $122 (in China and Malawi) to $25,000 in Switzerland. In 2005, it ranged from $89 in DR Congo to $40,000 in Norway. In addition to this wide gap between low- and high-income countries, there were also substantial differences among the low-income countries. For example, between 1970 and 2005, China and Malawi took very different growth paths. Malawi’s per capita income increased to $138, while China’s per capita income jumped more than tenfold to $1451. These global income disparities were also witnessed within countries. In the United States, for example, the top 5% of household income was 2.6 times higher than the 50th percentile in 1967; in 2005, it was 3.6 times higher. This scenario is replicated in both developed and developing countries.* In sum, at the start of the twenty-first century, the world was faced with enormous income disparities both across and within countries. The question at hand is, “If recent trends in income disparity continue, what will be the impact on poverty and food security?” During the past century, growth in global food production surpassed population growth, leading to an overall improvement in per capita food consumption at the aggregate level. The main food production surge occurred during the 1950s and 1960s as new, high-yielding crop varieties were adopted [FAO statistics 2009]. Productivity growth allowed for the release of resources—labor in particular—to the rest of the economy and was responsible for a decline in the prices of major agricultural commodities. It is not certain that future productivity increases will be able to outweigh population growth and this could have disastrous effects on food security.
2.4 PRODUCTION GROWTH AND DISPARITY While growth in global food production far outpaced the growth in the world’s population from 1970 to 2007, there was a significant growth disparity among regions. For example, per capita food production growth in South America was more than 60% [Shapouri et al. 2009]. And while growth in North America, Central America, North Africa, and South Asia fell short of that rate, it was still quite strong. SSA had by far the weakest performance. As can be seen in Figure 2.1, West Africa was the only subregion with positive growth, and that was only 1% [Shapouri et al. 2009]. * http://www.frbsf.org/publications/economics/letter/2007/el2007-28.pdf.
14
World Soil Resources and Food Security Percent change 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 –10 –20 –30 –40
E N S W Cent N Cent S S Africa Africa Africa Africa Africa Amer Amer Amer Asia
FIGURE 2.1 Per capita food production from 1970 to 2007.
In addition to changes in food production, returns on agricultural labor (value added per worker), an indicator of prosperity in rural areas, showed an increase of about 40% at the global level from 1980 to 2005 [FAO 2009]. In high-income countries, this return more than tripled from $9000 (in 2000 U.S. dollars) in 1980 to $29,000 by 2005. The second highest return per agricultural worker in 2005 was about $3000 in Latin America and the Caribbean, followed by South Asia at $2300. The lowest return was $348 in SSA. These differences in returns per agricultural worker are mainly due to disparities in agricultural investment and the use of new technology. For example, agricultural machinery use, as measured by tractor use, was by far the lowest in SSA. In high-income countries, 435 tractors were used per 100 square km of arable land in 2003; this was followed by 143 in South Asia and 122 in Latin America and the Caribbean [FAO 2009). In SSA, tractor use was only 12 per 100 square km of arable land [FAO 2009]. Grain yields are also a good proxy for the technological gap among regions. Grains comprise the largest share of the diet of the developing world, and therefore their yield performance directly affects food availability and food security of these countries. Grain yields have outpaced population growth since 1970, and yield growth was comparable for all regions except SSA. In high-income countries as well as Latin America and South Asia, grain yields more than doubled in 35 years [Rosen et al. 2008]. As can be seen in Figure 2.2, even in low-income countries, yields nearly doubled. In SSA, however, yields increased only 30% during the same time period. As a result, in 2005, SSA grain yields were only 20% of those in the highincome countries and about 50% of those in low-income countries in other regions [Rosen et al. 2008]. One major factor affecting yields is technology adoption. Farmers choose between technologies based on land characteristics such as soil quality and access to water, as well as personal characteristics like land tenure, income/wealth, and access to credit and information. The farmer’s choice of practices, such as fertilizer application and residue management, also depends on his/her time horizon. For example, practices
15
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues 6000 5000 kg/ha
4000 3000 2000 1000 0
Sub-Saharan Africa
High-income Latin America & South Asia countries Caribbean 1970
Low-income countries
2005
FIGURE 2.2 Grain yields.
generating high net returns today may not do so indefinitely if they contribute to land degradation. However, practices that reduce land degradation and offer higher net returns in the long run may require initial investments that can preclude adoption. In recent decades, it is estimated that about half of all gains in crop yields have been attributed to genetic improvements in seeds, while the remainder of gains are due to the increased use of conventional inputs, especially fertilizer and irrigation water [Frisvold et al. 1999]. The World Development Report of 2008 notes that an increase in fertilizer use is responsible for 20% of the growth in developing country agriculture for the past 30 years [World Bank 2007]. Growth in fertilizer consumption per hectare of cropland has been slowing, however, from a global average annual increase of 9% in the 1960s to an average annual decline of 0.1% in the 1990s [FAO statistics 2009]. Developed countries are considered a mature fertilizer market, and support measures in the United States and European Union have been reduced. Also, the increasing awareness of potential environmental harm from overuse is hindering growth in fertilizer use. Growth of fertilizer use in developing countries is expected to exceed that of developed countries in the coming years. The fertilizer consumption of developing countries has increased rapidly since 1970. In fact, these countries’ share of global fertilizer use increased from 10% in the 1960s to more than 60% in 2006 [World Bank 2007]. Among developing regions, fertilizer consumption per hectare increased most rapidly in land-scarce Asia and most slowly in Africa. SSA accounts for only 1% of global fertilizer consumption. In many low-income countries, particularly in SSA and Latin America, almost all fertilizer is imported and the insufficient foreign exchange constrains availability. Fertilizer use is most productive in irrigated areas or areas with sufficient moisture. Therefore, in regions suffering from or vulnerable to dry periods (Latin America or SSA), fertilizer use would not experience the results of areas without similar adversities. Investment in irrigation has boosted food production in many developing countries. These higher yields generate higher revenues. For example, gross crop revenue from irrigated plots has shown to be 79% higher than that of nonirrigated plots in
16
World Soil Resources and Food Security
China, due to higher yields, increased cropping intensity, and shifts to higher-valued crops, all made possible by irrigation [Huang et al. 2006]. On average, the global irrigated area increased nearly 1.4% per year between 1980 and 2002, although the growth rate has declined over time [FAO 2009]. Growth in developing countries, in particular, exceeded this rate and currently more than a quarter of arable land area in developing countries is irrigated. The highest growth in irrigated area in the developing world has occurred in Asia, particularly Bangladesh, Nepal, and Vietnam. There are projections that by 2030, irrigated agriculture in many developing countries will be responsible for a large percentage of the increase in grain production [UNESCO 2006]. Currently in South Asia, more than 39% of the cultivated land is irrigated, and more than 29% is irrigated in East Asia, while only 4% is irrigated in SSA [World Bank 2007]. In addition, expansion of irrigated lands in the region is negligible—0.5% per year since 1990 [FAO 2009]. This rate marks a significant slowdown from growth in the prior decade. Irrigation requires access to water as well as investment in equipment and maintenance—elusive factors in most of SSA. Renewable water resources in Africa are less than 9% of the global renewable resources [FAO 2010]. Population growth and the increasing cost of developing new sources of water will place increasing pressure on world water supplies in the coming decades. Even as demand for irrigation water increases, farmers face growing competition for water from urban and industrial users, as well as pressure to support water’s ecological functions. Genetic improvements to seeds that enhance input responsiveness, resistance to pests and diseases, and tolerance to other stresses have driven much of the gains in yields in recent years. Figure 2.3 shows the extent of growth in scientifically bred varieties by the 1990s. 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
Rice
Corn Developing
Wheat Developed
FIGURE 2.3 Percentage of land used for growth of scientifically bred varieties in the 1990s.
17
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
Gains from genetic improvements will continue, but likely at slower rates and increasing costs, particularly because gains in input responsiveness have been almost fully exploited. Moreover, while the use of hybrid seeds has raised yields considerably in some countries, their proliferation may not be possible in many developing countries where conditions are not amenable due to lack of adequate extension services or funding for research.
2.5 FOOD CONSUMPTION AND COMPOSITION The combination of income growth and increasing agricultural production not only resulted in increased food availability, but also changed the composition of diets. Globally, daily per capita calorie availability increased by 17% between 1970 and 2005—from 2134 to 2722 [Rosen et al. 2008]. In 1970, grains accounted for more than half of the calories consumed, as shown in Figure 2.4. Overall, globalization opened markets for products, and many farmers were able to capitalize on these changes by supplying a wide variety of products to growing and evolving markets. Per capita consumption in developing countries exceeded 2722 calories per day in 2005, up from 2134 calories in 1970. The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations recommends a daily per capita intake of roughly 2100 calories. Grains account for more than half of the diets in developing countries, but the almost 11% increase in per capita grain consumption between 1970 and 2005 was much lower than the overall increase in calorie consumption [Rosen et al. 2008]. While per capita consumption of some higher-value food items soared, meat still accounted for only about 9% of the diets in developing countries in 2003, compared with 14% in developed countries [Rosen et al. 2008]. Diet composition changes are illustrated in Figures 2.5 through 2.8. The two most populous countries—China and India—with about one-third of the global population, significantly influence the direction of changes in food consumption in developing countries. In China, the roughly 50% increase in per capita food consumption (measured in calories) between 1970 and 2005 included a tenfold 60 50 40 30 1970
20
2005
10 0
Cereals
Sugar and Veg oils sweeteners
FIGURE 2.4 Global diet composition.
Meat
Milk
18
World Soil Resources and Food Security 3% 6%
4% Cereals
8%
Sugar and sweeteners Veg oils Meat Milk 79%
FIGURE 2.5 Diet composition in developing countries in 1970.
increase in the consumption of fruits and an eightfold increase in the consumption of meat and milk. Other significant increases were in vegetables and vegetables oils. Reflecting the diversification of the diet and increased wealth of the population, the largest decline was seen in cereals, whose share of diets declined from 68% in 1970, to 47% in 2005. In India, the increase in per capita food consumption was relatively modest, 20 percent, during 1970 to 2005. Among the main food categories, per capita consumption of vegetable oils, milk, and eggs more than doubled. Like China, cereals’ share of the diet declined, from 66% in 1970 to 59% in 2005. While per capita calorie consumption rose in the least developed countries (those with per capita incomes below $500 per year), the gain was much smaller than in developing countries as a whole. Their consumption increased from 2000 calories per person in 1970 to 2200 in 2000 [Rosen et al. 2008]. However, consumption of nutritionally beneficial foods, such as pulses, vegetables, and fruits, has declined in the least developed countries. The decline was sharpest for vegetables (32%), followed by fruits (9%) and pulses (5%) [Rosen et al. 2008]. Even with the modest
9%
4% Cereals
12%
Sugar and sweeteners Veg oils
9%
Meat 66%
Milk
FIGURE 2.6 Diet composition in developing countries in 2003.
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
19
12% Cereals
13%
45%
Sugar and sweeteners Veg oils Meat
11%
Milk 19%
FIGURE 2.7 Diet composition in developed countries in 1970.
increases in overall calorie consumptions in these countries, there is a shift in diets toward fats and sugar and away from traditional diets of vegetables and pulses. A major factor influencing the composition of diets is urbanization. In 1975, unlike developed countries, only 25% of developing countries’ populations resided in urban areas. By 2015, that number is expected to reach 50% [UNDP 2002]. In most developing countries, the rate of urbanization was two to three times higher than the population growth rate during the prior three decades [World Bank 2007a]. Since 1970, in 68 out of 114 countries, population in the largest cities more than doubled and most of the increase was in developing countries [World Bank 2007a]. In 18 countries, 16 in SSA, increases in the populations of the largest city were more than fivefold [World Bank 2007a]. Unlike rural agricultural households, urban residents do not rely solely on homeor locally-grown foods and, therefore, have access to a wider selection of foods. Although detailed data for each country are not available, examining diet compositions across countries shows that in countries with the same income level, those with a higher share of urban population tended to have diets with more fat, both
11% Cereals
14%
41%
Sugar and sweeteners Veg oils Meat
17%
Milk 17%
FIGURE 2.8 Diet composition in developed countries in 2003.
20
World Soil Resources and Food Security
vegetable and animal. For example, the urbanization rate is 67% in Mexico vs. 92% in Uruguay, and daily per capita consumption of fat in Mexico was half that of Uruguay, despite similar per capita income levels ($6172 and $6248, respectively, in 2005) [Rosen et al. 2008]. Similarly, fat consumption in Jordan was more than four times that of Namibia. Although their per capita income was almost the same ($2086 in Jordan and $2083 in Namibia in 2005), the 82% urbanization rate in Jordan was much higher than that of Namibia’s at 35% [Rosen et al. 2008]. However, other factors such as cultural and dietary habits might also contribute to differences. All urban environments are not the same; the openness of an economy, access to mass media, particularly television, and marketing systems can also significantly influence consumers’ choices. Regardless of consumer food choices, however, an urban lifestyle usually means a decline in physical activity and the higher participation of women in the workforce. The latter often translates into less time for food preparation, which often leads to increased consumption of processed foods. In addition to income growth and urbanization, the expansion of international trade through world economic integration has influenced global diets. Trade agreements over the past 3 decades, in addition to expanding global trade, have been catalysts for increased investment in transportation and communication systems. The average ocean freight and port charges for U.S. import and export cargo decreased 60% between 1970 and 1990 [Rosen et al. 2008]. New technologies such as refrigeration also facilitated trade in perishable products. The decline in global trade barriers was followed by liberalization in global financing, altering the food systems of most countries. The evolution of global food systems and increases in the number of supermarkets have promoted convenience shopping and wider food varieties in developing countries. Due to efficiencies of scale, supermarkets are often able to offer lower prices than traditional retail stores. Lower prices have boosted the market shares and profits of supermarkets, which have fueled their expansion. The high growth in market share of supermarkets in Latin America highlights the extent of the change: from a 10%–20% market share in the 1980s to 50%–60% in the 1990s, and now rapidly approaching the U.S. share of about 70%–80% [Reardon et al. 2004]. The experiences of East and South Asia also show a similar pattern. In SSA, with the exception of South Africa, the supermarket share in the retail food market is much smaller, but expansion is under way due to growing investment by South African companies. The growing role of supermarkets has both positive and negative implications for consumers. On the positive side, supermarkets are introducing better quality, greater variety, higher standards, and lower prices to the food systems of developing countries. On the negative side, they increase access to low-cost, high-calorie convenience foods for urban consumers with limited physical activity, thereby fueling obesity problems. Furthermore, food imports have become an important component of food supplies in both developed and developing countries because national food self-sufficiency has declined in many countries during the past few decades. Trade in grains, vegetable oils, and meat increased three to five times during the past 3 decades. Developing countries also became more dependent on imports of staple commodities, such as grains and vegetable oils. Rising consumption of wheat, in the processed form of
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
21
bread and pasta, has replaced traditional grains such as millet and sorghum, as well as root crops. Import growth was not limited to staple foods; imports of a variety of commodities, including semiprocessed and processed foods, have also grown. Between 1970 and 2005, global trade volume of highly processed foods (the FAO definition includes food items such as canned meat, breakfast cereals, pastries, and wine) increased more than four times. Import growth for highly processed foods was highest in developing countries—growing more than fivefold between 1970 and 2005 [Rosen et al. 2008].
2.6 UNRESOLVED AND EMERGING ISSUES 2.6.1 Persistent Food Insecurity Despite the growth in food availability, reports (USDA-ERS and FAO) indicate that food insecurity among the poorest countries is intensifying. The global economic crisis, coupled with the financial pressures created by the soaring food and fuel prices during 2006–2008, put food security on the front line of global concerns. The difficult global financial environment may influence food security by limiting commercial imports, which had been growing rapidly in many of these countries, as seen in Figure 2.9. This growing reliance on food imports was spurred by income growth, trade liberalization policies, and improvements in the global transportation system. The global downturn, however, threatened the import capacities of many low-income countries because it led to reduced export earnings as a result of reduced global 120
Million tons
100 80 60 40 20 0 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 Grain food aid
Grain commercial imports
*in 70 lower income developing countries included in the USDA-ERS Food Security Assessment
FIGURE 2.9 Rising commercial imports.
22
World Soil Resources and Food Security
demand, foreign capital inflows, and remittances from relatives working abroad. Regionally, import dependency for grain, the main staple food consumed by the poor, is lowest in Asia, but increases for SSA, Latin America and the Caribbean, and North Africa. Much of Latin America, the Caribbean, and North Africa import nearly half of their grain supplies. Some countries can forgo imports of other commodities and allocate a much larger share of their import budget to food during a crisis period. However, for those that were highly food insecure at the outset, like many in SSA, the decline in economic growth and import capacity can have adverse food security implications. The near- and medium-term food security of developing countries depends on the depth and the length of the current economic downturn. Tighter credit and weaker global growth are likely to cut into government revenues and investment in areas such as human capital and infrastructure that are essential for sustained growth. Even under the assumption of global economic recovery, food insecurity in many lower income countries is expected to remain precarious into the long term. According to the USDA’s Economic Research Service (USDA-ERS), the number of food-insecure people is projected to remain relatively flat through the next decade, reaching 834 million by 2018 [Shapouri et al. 2009]. However, these impacts will not be distributed evenly; while an improvement is projected in Asia, deteriorating food security is projected for SSA. SSA will remain the most vulnerable region in 2018. The region accounts for 25% of the population of the 70 countries included in the USDA-ERS study, but accounts for 57% of the food-insecure people [Shapouri et al. 2009]. Several countries, such as Somalia and the Democratic Republic of Congo, are likely to remain politically unstable as they continue to be plagued by armed conflicts that have caused significant breakdowns of law and order. The resulting social dislocation, food insecurity, and famine diminish optimism for the future. The slow pace or lack of progress in improving food insecurity in low-income countries was evident even before the current global economic downturn. While the full consequences of this crisis are not known, for low-income countries, food security problems are expected to worsen. The short-term concern is that these countries have few or no domestic safety net programs in place. The international safety nets that do exist are inadequate for stabilizing food supplies for the more vulnerable countries. Food aid, the primary safety net, is not sufficient to meet estimated needs around the world. Integrating international and national resources to redesign these safety net programs could help mitigate the effects of shocks and serve as adjuncts to longer term food security strategies. The challenge, however, is to design efficient programs that minimize costs, while working for longer term solutions.
2.7 GROWING DEMAND FOR BIOFUELS Recent oil price hikes have raised serious concerns in low-income countries, both because of the financial burden of the higher energy import bill and because of potential constraints on imports of necessities like food and raw materials. Adding to these worries, the higher oil prices have sparked global energy security concerns that have spurred the demand for biofuel production. The use of food crops for producing
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
23
biofuels, coupled with the increase in food demand spurred by income growth in the most populous countries such as China and India, has reversed the path of declining price trends for several commodities. While rising energy prices have negatively impacted the budget of importing countries, they have also created an opportunity for advances in biofuel technology, which could help fill the growing energy needs of developing countries. Investments in biofuel production by low-income countries could promote rural development, since large shares of their populations depend on agriculture for employment and income. Countries such as Colombia and India have adopted production targets for increasing the share of biofuels in their transportation fuel supplies. Other countries are examining alternative biofuel sources appropriate for their particular environments and resource availabilities. In addition, researchers in several countries of Asia, Latin America, and Africa have pointed toward the potential of several indigenous plants such as Jatropha, which grows wild in these countries, requires little water and few nutrients, and has a relatively high oil yield. The payoff for lowincome countries from investing in research in the area of biofuels can be significant and could help reverse the trend of low national and international investments in agricultural research in low-income countries. Currently, traditional biofuels such as wood fuel account for about one-third of all energy consumed in developing countries. However, these fuel sources provide low yields in terms of heat. For example, a kilogram of wood generates only about onetenth of the heat of a kilogram of liquid petroleum gas. The new sources of biofuels could improve energy efficiency, as well as increase the supply of energy and boost farm incomes and rural employment in poor areas. Success, however, depends on increasing investment in the development of new technology that is consistent with the structure of the agricultural sectors of lowincome countries. Most low-income countries have poor market infrastructures and weak financial systems, which lead to raised costs of production, particularly for newly introduced biofuel commodities that require specific production and distribution facilities. In addition, the financial capacity for investment in low-income countries is limited, and there is concern that increasing investments in biofuel production could compete with food production, thereby intensifying food insecurity.
2.8 NATURAL RESOURCES AND CLIMATE CHANGE Agricultural resource scarcity is an underlying issue that has greatly impacted and will continue to impact any efforts to increase global food supply. Limited water availability, soil degradation (through erosion and nutrient depletion), and deforestation and desertification can have detrimental effects on agricultural production. Water resources, in particular, are considered an integral component of development, especially in rural areas that depend on agriculture. An average of 70% of the water withdrawn from surface or groundwater supplies globally is used for agriculture [FAO 2003]. Of course, there are significant regional variations on how this water is used and the efficiency of those uses. The work Water for Food, Water for Life [Molden 2007] notes that 55% of the value of the world’s food is produced under rainfed conditions. However, given the variability and location of water supplies,
24
World Soil Resources and Food Security
irrigated agriculture plays an increasingly important role, especially for grain production. It is estimated that irrigated agriculture is responsible for 60% of the grain production in the developing world [Huang 2006]. Water resources are subject to multiple demands in addition to agriculture, including energy, industry, domestic, and environmental flows. Presently, around 1.6 billion people live in river basins where water use exceeds recharge rates, and one in three people are already facing water shortages [Molden 2007]. Climate change is projected to result in increased precipitation variability and affect food production through both biophysical and socioeconomic pathways. These impact projections vary greatly among different regions of the world and the magnitude of the changes is unknown. However, temperature increases, changing patterns of precipitation, and more extreme weather will have the most extensive effects on agriculture in the subtropics, where a majority of the least developed countries are located [Molden 2007]. It is estimated that one in six countries will face food shortages each year due to droughts [UNFPA 2009]. A few estimates have been completed regarding the impacts of increased variability and extreme events on agricultural production in these areas. Overall, developing countries are expected to have a 9%–21% reduction in agricultural productivity as a result of global warming by 2080 [Cline 2007]. While the impact projections vary with projections of CO2 levels and assumptions regarding adaptation, the models are robust in the projection of increased aridity in both Mediterranean environments and in the marginal arid and semiarid tropics, especially in SSA [Bates et al. 2008]. Developing economies, in general, are expected to be more affected by climate change due to greater exposure to climate shocks and less adaptive capacity [World Bank 2009]. Despite the unknown climate change impacts on food production in the developing world, there are opportunities to reduce some of the consequences. Productivity gains in low productivity areas (particularly rainfed areas) and more integrated management of water resources could increase food security [Molden 2007]. However, as climate change increases water stress and variability, it is important that water management approaches be integrated into large poverty reduction strategies to help reduce vulnerability to shocks [Molden 2007].
2.9 A CCESS TO NEW TECHNOLOGY TO ENHANCE PRODUCTION GROWTH Global agricultural production more than doubled during the second half of the twentieth century, but the rate of growth among countries differed significantly. With demand growth expected to nearly double by the middle of this century as both population and incomes rise in many of the world’s poorest countries, a substantial increase in scientific and technical efforts will be required to achieve a sustainable system of agricultural production. Genetically modified (GM) seeds have been successful in increasing the productivity of several food crops. GM seeds were originally developed to improve crop protection, improve resistance to insect damage or viruses, and increase tolerance to herbicides, but their impact on yield growth has been considerable. The adoption of GM seeds is more widespread in developed countries, but developing countries have
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
25
begun to adopt them as well. In fact, 90% of the farmers growing GM crops in 2007 were smallholders in developing countries, mostly in China, India, South Africa, and the Philippines [PG Economics 2009]. Corn, cotton, canola, and soybeans represent most of the GM crops grown commercially in developing countries and are either herbicide-tolerant, pest-resistant, or both [FAO 2002]. However, countries are performing trials on a much broader range of crops including bananas, cassava, cowpeas, plantains, rice, and sorghum [FAO 2002]. Also, the traits of the crops are expanding to include drought-resistance and quality improvement. Global farm income gains attributed to growing GM crops were estimated at more than $44 billion between 1996 and 2007 [PG Economics 2009]. In 2007 alone, the benefit was valued at more than $10 billion, nearly 60% of which was derived by producers in developing countries [PG Economics 2009]. Included among the many factors that have contributed to these gains are reduced costs from decreased insecticide applications, higher yields from improved weed control and reduced pest damage, and increased production levels resulting from the planting of second-season crops due to the shortening of the production cycle. An additional benefit—for developing countries in particular—is the higher nutritional value of some of the varieties such as golden rice, for example, which can reduce vitamin A deficiency. For all the benefits of GM crops, there are also notable concerns associated with them. Unfortunately, because these are new technologies, the potential effects are simply not known. There is concern—particularly in the developing world—regarding regulating and ensuring the safe use of GM crops. In 2000, for example, a corn variety intended for animal consumption was found in food products [FAO 2002]. Concerns about GM crops, related to human health, revolve around provoking allergies, gene transfer, and outcrossing (moving genes from GM plants to conventional crops in the wild or the mixing of conventional and GM crops) can result in food safety concerns [WHO 2010]. Developing countries will need to weigh the potential benefits of adopting GM crops against the risk factors to determine the appropriate path for them to pursue. For some countries, many in SSA, the technology gap in food production relative to developed countries is huge and any step toward reducing the gap could have significant implications on their farm income and food security.
2.10 RISING OBESITY RATES In contrast to the problem of inadequate food supplies for the poor, the global increase in calorie consumption has led to excess food consumption by some segments of the population in many countries. In developing countries, consumption of high-calorie foods, such as fats and sugar, has risen, and the income elasticity (percentage change in consumption for each 1% change in income) for these products remains positive. While an estimated 800 million to 1 billion people are food insecure, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that there are about 1 billion overweight and obese people worldwide. While this problem is more prevalent in Western countries, it is increasing rapidly in developing countries as well, due to dietary shifts [WHO 2009]. An emerging concern in developing countries is obesity-related diseases such as diabetes and hypertension. For example, the WHO reports that in China hypertension
26
World Soil Resources and Food Security
increased 12% (or the equivalent of 160 million people) between 1991 and 2002 [FAO 2006]. Similarly, an estimated 25%–50% of the population in countries such as Mexico, Thailand, and Tunisia suffer from diabetes [FAO 2006]. The WHO assessment indicates that overweight and obesity represent a rapidly growing threat to health in an increasing number of developed and developing countries. It also indicates that, in some countries, overweight and obesity are now replacing the more traditional public health concerns of undernutrition and infectious diseases. The direct cost of obesity is the increased risk of chronic diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular disease, gallbladder disease, and cancer. If current trends continue, health costs for the developing economies could be substantial. In most developing countries, people are a major resource and public health is a key to economic progress. Research shows that obesity reduces productivity [Thompson et al. 1994]. Moreover, health costs associated with the growing rate of obesity and its related diseases could overwhelm the healthcare systems of developing countries already overburdened with the costs of combating communicable diseases and the effects of malnutrition among lower-income populations. According to the latest World Bank data, average health expenditures, per capita, in developing countries are less than 10% of the health expenditures in developed countries and less than 1% in the least developed countries. Nutritional education is crucial in terms of reaching out to consumers. Because dietary habits are formed at young ages, the nutritional education of children can play a vital role in influencing dietary habits. Other policy interventions can also promote healthy eating. The Scandinavian countries reduced coronary heart disease between 1976 and the 1980s by providing subsidies for the purchase of healthy food items, such as fish [Rosen et al. 2008].
2.11 LOOKING AHEAD An FAO study, How to Feed the World 2050, argues that future demand growth will be influenced by lower population growth rates, higher urbanization rates, and higher incomes that, in turn, will influence the composition of diets. There is consensus that it is possible to produce adequate food in 2050, but achieving that goal requires certain conditions and policy decisions [FAO 2009]. The essential conditions according to the report are investments in productivity and market infrastructures to improve the functioning of markets and implementation of policies to enhance food access of the poor. The question is, “Will the growth in supply be adequate to improve global food security?” An important point to note is that in the past few decades, several large developing countries such as China, India, Brazil, and Mexico have shown significant improvements in their food security situations. On the other hand, food security may remain precarious for low-income countries such as those in SSA. For many low-income countries, growth in agricultural productivity is critical to improving food security for two reasons. First, growth in agricultural productivity translates into increased food supplies and lower food prices for all consumers. This is particularly true in many of the poorest countries that depend heavily on domestic food production for large parts of their food supplies, due in part to financial conditions that constrain imports and the fact that rural economies are not fully integrated
Global Food Situation and Unresolved and Emerging Issues
27
into formal economies. Second, growth in agricultural productivity means higher incomes and, thus, improved abilities to purchase food for the large share of these populations that depend on agriculture for their livelihoods. The World Development Report 2008 emphasized the need to increase investment in agriculture, especially the importance of increasing agricultural productivity in Africa through gains in soil fertility [World Bank 2007]. This would be achieved by increasing fertilizer use in the region, which is currently less than 10% of the level used in other developing regions [World Bank 2007]. Most of the least developed countries are in the early stages of adopting new agricultural technologies, and the potential to increase productivity is enormous, but sustained agricultural growth requires substantial investments in irrigation, rural infrastructure, human capital, and institutions, not just basic inputs. In addition to increasing the productivity of the agricultural sector, support for rural development can provide nonfarm employment and an opportunity for rural communities to diversify their sources of incomes, leading to higher incomes and greater stability. The World Bank has recently devoted much attention to the issue of rural development, especially in the context of increased environmental and economic variability, as seen in the upcoming World Development Report 2010 [World Bank 2009]. In the midst of this variability, developing rural markets can help create lower-risk environments that are essential for sustainable economic growth and improved food security. Unlike the productivity potential that exists in some developing countries in SSA and Latin America, many developed and some developing countries are close to their maximum scientific and technical potential for growing crops. Therefore, maintaining current growth rates may be unlikely in these areas with today’s technologies and practices. These countries must promote investment in agricultural research, technology education, and rural infrastructure. Economic development in developing countries must build upon the lessons learned from previous experience in the region. In some cases, a stronger focus on market integration is necessary, while in other cases, more sustainable use of natural resources is necessary to help compensate for variability and multiple demands.
REFERENCES Bates, B.C., Z.W. Kundzewicz, S. Wu, and J.P. Palutikof, eds. 2008. Climate change and water. Technical paper of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Geneva: IPCC. Cline, W. 2007. Global warming and agriculture: Impact assessments by country. Washington, DC: Peterson Institute for International Economics. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). 2009. How to feed the world in 2050. The prospects for agriculture. FAO Expert Meeting. October, 2009. Rome: FAO. FAO. 2010. AQUASTAT database. http://www.fao.org/nr/water/aquastat/regions/africa/index .stm (accessed January 13, 2010). FAO. 2006. Fighting hunger and obesity. http://www.fao.org/ag/magazine/pdf/0602-1.pdf. Rome: FAO. FAO. FAOSTAT database. Available at http://faostat.fao.org/default.aspx. FAO. 2003. Agriculture, food, and water. Rome: FAO.
28
World Soil Resources and Food Security
FAO. 2002. Biotechnology and food security. Available at http://www.fao.org/worldfoodsummit/ english/fsheets/biotech.pdf (accessed January 11, 2010). Frisvold, G., J. Sullivan, and A. Raneses. 1999. Who gains from genetic improvements in US crops? AgBioForum 2(3&4):237–246 (available at http://www.agbioforum.org). Huang, Q., S. Rozelle, B. Lohmar, J. Huang, and J. Wang. 2006. Irrigation, agricultural performance and poverty reduction in China. Food Policy 31:130–152. International Monetary Fund (IMF). 2007. Finance and development report. International Monetary Fund (IMF) database. Available at http://www.imf.org/external/data.htm. Molden, D., ed. 2007. Water for food, water for life. London: IWMI Earthscan. PG Economics. 2009. Focus on income, well-being, and food security: Biotech crops: Evidence, outcomes, and impacts 1996–2007. Available at http://www.pgeconomics .co.uk/pdf/focusonincomeeffects2009.pdf (accessed January 11, 2010). Reardon, T., P. Timmer, and J. Berdegue. 2004. The rapid rise of supermarkets in developing countries: Induced organizational, institutional, and technological change in agrifood systems. The Electronic Journal of Agricultural and Development Economics 1(2): 168–183 (available at http://www.fao.org/docrep/Article/ejade/ae226e/ae226e00.htm). Rosen, S., S. Shapouri, K. Quanbeck, and B. Meade. 2008. Food security assessment, 2007. Washington, DC: USDA-ERS. Shapouri, S., S. Rosen, B. Meade, and F. Gale. 2009. Food security assessment, 2008–09. Washington, DC: USDA-ERS. Thompson, D., J. Edelsberg, G.A. Colditz, A.P. Bird, and G. Oster. 1994. Lifetime health and economic consequences of obesity. Arch. Intern. Med. 159(18):2177–2183. United Nations Development Program (UNDP). 2002. Human development report 2002: Deepening democracy in a fragmented world. New York: UNDP. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). 2006. Water: A shared responsibility. The United Nations World Water Development Report 2. Paris: UNESCO. United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA). 2009. State of world population, facing a changing world: Women, population, and climate. New York: UNFPA. UNFPA. 2008. State of world population, reaching common ground: Culture, gender and human rights. New York: UNFPA. United States Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service (USDA-ERS). 2009. Outlook Report No. (GFA-20). Available at http://www.ers.usda.gov/Publications/ GFA20/. World Bank. 2009. World development report 2010: Development and climate change. Washington, DC: World Bank. World Bank. 2007a. World development report 2008: Agriculture for development. Washington, DC: World Bank. World Bank. 2007b. World development indicators 2007. Available at http://go.worldbank .org/3JU2HA60D0. World Health Organization (WHO). 2010. 20 questions on genetically modified (GM) foods. Available at http://www.who.int/foodsafety/publications/biotech/20questions/en/ (accessed January 11, 2010). WHO. Obesity and overweight facts. Available at http://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/ publications/facts/obesity/en. World Policy Institute. 2009. Water wars? A talk with Ismail Serageldin. World Policy Journal 26(4):33–40.
Soil Resources 3 World Opportunities and Challenges H. Eswaran, P. F. Reich, and E. Padmanabhan CONTENTS 3.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 29 3.2 Global Distribution of Soils............................................................................. 32 3.2.1 Alfisols................................................................................................. 32 3.2.2 Andisols............................................................................................... 32 3.2.3 Aridisols.............................................................................................. 32 3.2.4 Entisols................................................................................................ 37 3.2.5 Gelisols................................................................................................ 37 3.2.6 Histosols.............................................................................................. 37 3.2.7 Inceptisols............................................................................................ 37 3.2.8 Mollisols.............................................................................................. 43 3.2.9 Oxisols................................................................................................. 43 3.2.10 Spodosols............................................................................................. 43 3.2.11 Ultisols................................................................................................. 43 3.2.12 Vertisols............................................................................................... 47 3.3 Historical Trends............................................................................................. 47 3.4 Current Issues.................................................................................................. 49 3.4.1 Opportunities....................................................................................... 49 3.4.2 Challenges........................................................................................... 49 3.5 Future Perspectives.......................................................................................... 50 3.6 Conclusions...................................................................................................... 51 References................................................................................................................. 51
3.1 INTRODUCTION Soil is a product of the interaction of climate with bedrock; the properties of the soil produced are determined by ancillary factors such as the position of the site on the landscape and the vegetation present. All this, in combination in various proportions, influence the kind of biota that dwells on or in the soil, which also contribute to the soil’s development. The intensity of each of these factors and their interactions 29
30
World Soil Resources and Food Security
determine the nature of the product. Many of the factors are rhythmic with intensities varying with time. The changes may be diurnal and/or seasonal and knowing the climatic endowments of the area may be predictable. The human factor in the development of the soil is intriguing and has been the subject of innumerable studies. Most such studies describe the dramatic or obvious changes or changes that are measurable with available devices. However, land use also induces changes that are generally imperceptible. This includes such features as thickness of surface organic rich horizons. Changes in intensity and direction of processes are seldom evaluated unless they result in recognizable features. Soil management requires fertilization and in some instances copious amounts of fertilizers are added to the soil. This alters the microenvironment of the topsoil having consequences on the biota and processes that operate in the soil. This aspect of soil development has not received the study it deserves; most such studies focus on the fate of the organisms or the response of the soil to management and less on the microenvironmental changes within the soil. In the absence of a better understanding of the changes, soil management will remain ad hoc and contribute less to the sustainability of the system. For most practical purposes, the soil at a point in the landscape is a definable entity. It has measurable properties and studies have established that these properties are the result of factors and processes of soil formation at that point in the landscape. By comparison of soils at different points on the landscape and for different kinds of landscapes, the role of the factors and processes can be elucidated. These observations and, in some instances, assumptions are relevant to understanding the global distribution of soils. Climate is generally the most important variable. Climate can determine the kind of soil or preclude the occurrence of some kinds of soils. The organic and base-rich Mollisols of the temperate regions are rare in the tropics and the Oxisols of the tropics are absent in the higher latitudes. Rock weathering and mineral alteration are also controlled by climate, with intensities and directions being determined by ancillary factors, including the nature of the rock. An appropriate climate map of the world provides a first assessment of different soil regions. In the early classification systems, tropical soils were a unique group of soils and climatic parameters were used to delimit them. During these early days, tropical soils were studied and mapped by persons from European institutions that had a separate section or division dedicated to such soils. However, the study and classification of these soils adhered to the principles used for temperate soils. The contributions of the Belgians [Tavernier and Sys 1965] working in Zaire, the French [Aubert 1958] working in the francophone countries, and the Portuguese [Botelho da Costa 1959] working in Angola provided a different dimension to the knowledge of these soils. This knowledge was synthesized with the advent of soil taxonomy. All classification systems then recognized the unique place of the Oxisols and also that there were equivalents of temperate soils in the tropics. In soil taxonomy [Soil Survey Staff 1999], the distinction between the two groups of soils was considered at the family level. The major concepts and principles of soil classification found a general agreement by the 1970s and subsequent to that, much of the effort was devoted to refining the system. An active soil survey program in the United States enabled a continuous
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
31
testing of the system and the system was formally published in 1975. Although the U.S. Soil Survey was confident of the system for U.S. purposes, its utility around the world was yet to be tested. A project funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development, the Soil Management Support Services (SMSS) enabled this [SMSS Staff 1991]. SMSS not only collected soil samples from around the world, but also trained soil scientists in these countries in the use and application of the system. Knowledge of the soil resources of the world was facilitated by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations in its Soil Map of the World Project [FAO-UNESCO 1976]. This monumental project provided the first understanding of global soil resources. Using an internationally agreed upon terminology and legend, it remains today the best assessment of global soil resources. This effort will not be replicated in the near future and will remain as the basic study of global soil resources for some time to come. Under the auspices of the International Soil Science Society, the World Reference Base for Soil Classification [FAO, ISRIC, and ISSS 1998] was initiated in the 1980s. Although some progress was made, due to lack of funds and general enthusiasm, it remains on the back burner. The unspoken reason may be that it was difficult to improve on the FAO legend or the U.S. soil taxonomy. Consequently, a steady state was reached in the development of classification systems and with only minor changes in the past 2 decades, and with a better appreciation of the systems by the proponents, we now have a reasonably good assessment of global soil resources. Unfortunately, this status was reached when funds for soil resource inventories were dwindling and in the past 2 decades, particularly in developing countries, there is no effort for updating their soil resource inventories. Soil survey organizations are nonexistent or nonfunctional in many developing countries, particularly in Africa. As a result soil information in most of these countries is at least 40 to 50 years old. The purpose of this discourse is to assess the current status of our understanding and knowledge of global soil resources and to evaluate areas of knowledge gaps and consider research priorities. In the past few decades, land use and the demands on land have changed, even in developing countries. However, with modern technology, dependence on forces of nature for production is considerably less, having been circumvented by appropriate management techniques. Technology has aided the economies of water management, pest control, and sustainability in general. Modern agriculture is akin to an automated factory churning out products tailor-made to specifications dictated by consumers. Streamlining and enabling this process to proceed in an unabated manner is the challenge of modern agriculture. Although this is the trend, the whole spectrum from primitive slash-and burn systems to modern plantations occurs in the world. The continuing challenge is to sustainably use the land resources to feed and clothe the current population, without jeopardizing the opportunities for future generations. The challenge is how to maintain the quality of the resource base and even enhance the quality for future generations. Sustainable systems are based on sedentary agriculture and so the challenge is one of making optimal use of the land with a built-in flexibility to make changes as necessity dictates.
32
World Soil Resources and Food Security
3.2 GLOBAL DISTRIBUTION OF SOILS There are tens of thousands of different kinds of soils throughout the world. Soils are classified into groups according to physical, morphological, and chemical properties. In soil taxonomy, soils are grouped into several categories, the highest being soil orders [Soil Survey Staff 1999]. The Global Soil Regions map (Figure 3.1) is a reclassification of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (FAO/UNESCO) Soil Map of the World to soil taxonomy suborders and is aggregated to soil orders. As soil moisture regimes are used to define suborders, a global soil climate map was used with the FAO soil units to determine the best soil taxonomy equivalent. Differences between the FAO system and soil taxonomy are such that direct correlations were not always possible.
3.2.1 Alfisols Most Alfisols were or are forested, with moderate to high base saturation. Typically they have a light-colored surface layer over a horizon of silicate clay accumulation (argillic). The cooler Alfisols tend to form a belt between the grassland Mollisols and the Spodosols of the more humid climates. Where temperatures are warmer, they form a belt between the Aridisols and the older Ultisols and Oxisols. Along with Mollisols, Alfisols account for a major portion of soils that are used to grow crops in the world (Figure 3.2).
3.2.2 Andisols Soils formed on volcanic ash and cinders and having andic properties are distributed along the circum-Pacific belts and occur sporadically elsewhere. The Andisols have mineralogical compositions ranging from volcanic glass, short-range order minerals such as allophane and immogolite, and variable amounts of halloysite. This mineralogical association gives unique properties to such soils including a high phosphate fixing capacity, low cation retention, and a high water holding capacity. Many of these soils are found on volcanic slopes or are developed through the weathering of plateau basalts. These soils support a high human population density due to their general ease of cultivation and also because of the cool environment of the volcanic mountains, which is generally free of pests and diseases (Figure 3.3).
3.2.3 Aridisols Aridisols, as their name implies, are soils that do not have water available to mesophytic plants for long periods. During most of the time when the soil is warm enough for plants to grow, soil water is held at potentials less than the permanent wilting point, or it is salty, or both. There is no period of 90 consecutive days when moisture is continuously available for plant growth. The concept of Aridisols is based on the low availability of soil moisture for sustained plant performance. In areas bordering deserts, the absolute precipitation may be high but, due to runoff, a very low storage capacity, or both, the actual soil moisture regime is aridic (Figure 3.4).
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
Global soil regions
Robinson projection Scale 1:130,000,000
Soil orders Alfisols
Entisols
Inceptisols
Spodosols
Rocky land
Andisols
Gelisols
Mollisols
Ultisols
Shifting sand
Aridisols
Histosols
Oxisols
Vertisols
Ice/glacier
33
FIGURE 3.1 Global distribution of soil orders.
Suborder Aqualfs Cryalfs Ustalfs Xeralfs Udalfs TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent 1,029,202 0.79 2,531,270 1.94 6,024,432 4.61 892,711 0.68 2,678,021 2.05 13,155,636 10.07
Africa Sq km Percent 392,900 1.32 – – 2,647,065 8.89 83,898 0.28 165,063 0.55 3,288,927 11.04
FIGURE 3.2 Global distribution of Alfisol suborders.
Asia Sq km Percent 34,703 0.08 729,218 1.66 1,102,064 2.51 213,922 0.49 271,186 0.62 2,351,093 5.35
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent 126,393 1.58 302 0.00 422,037 5.28 267,277 3.34 227,790 2.85 1,043,800 13.05
Europe Sq km Percent 3.90 373,737 12.11 1,161,705 4.07 389,963 1.35 129,190 5.23 501,670 26.66 2,556,265
South America Sq km Percent 56,410 0.32 1,507 0.01 1,028,205 5.81 28,166 0.16 675,208 3.82 1,789,497 10.12
North America Sq km Percent 45,058 0.21 638,538 2.95 435,098 2.01 170,257 0.79 837,103 3.86 2,126,054 9.81
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
34
Alfisol suborders
Map legend
Suborder Cryands Torrands Xerands Vitrands Ustands Udands Gelands TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent 0.19 250,515 0.00 1,494 0.02 31,763 0.21 280,698 0.05 61,848 0.21 274,747 0.05 61,924 0.74 962,989
Africa Sq km Percent – – 0.00 1,131 – – 0.00 1,087 0.04 11,503 0.11 32,606 – – 0.16 46,326
Asia Sq km Percent 0.13 56,743 0.00 164 – – 0.04 19,552 0.04 18,506 0.25 108,612 0.13 58,959 0.60 262,536
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent 0.00 71 – – – – 0.37 29,429 0.01 1,072 0.40 31,787 – – 0.78 62,360
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
Andisol suborders
Europe Sq km Percent 0.27 25,437 – – 0.13 12,668 0.00 368 0.02 1,897 0.01 618 0.00 10 0.43 40,999
South America Sq km Percent 0.41 71,834 0.00 77 0.01 2,043 0.28 49,183 0.06 11,182 0.46 81,854 0.01 2,216 1.23 218,390
North America Sq km Percent 0.44 96,429 0.00 122 0.08 17,052 0.84 181,079 0.08 17,688 0.09 19,269 0.00 739 1.53 332,378
35
FIGURE 3.3 Global distribution of Andisol suborders.
Suborder Cryids Salids Gypsids Argids Calcids Cambids TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent
1,035,988 1,286,956 679,776 4,677,772 4,886,894 2,919,308 15,486,694
0.79 0.98 0.52 3.58 3.74 2.23 11.85
Africa Sq km Percent 602 162,418 359,577 348,719 1,805,822 847,773 3,524,911
FIGURE 3.4 Global distribution of Aridisol suborders.
0.00 0.55 1.21 1.17 6.06 2.85 11.83
Asia Sq km Percent 399,899 995,337 318,366 1,107,287 2,184,015 1,106,447 6,111,353
0.91 2.27 0.73 2.52 4.97 2.52 13.92
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent – 78,381 – 1,590,658 598,849 336,519 2,604,407
– 0.98 – 19.88 7.49 4.21 32.56
Europe Sq km Percent 105 7,851 1,833 64,119 1,110 29,038 104,055
0.00 0.08 0.02 0.67 0.01 0.30 1.09
South America Sq km Percent 159,648 32,595 – 501,895 102,844 430,966 1,227,947
0.90 0.18 – 2.84 0.58 2.44 6.94
North America Sq km Percent 475,735 10,373 – 1,065,094 194,254 168,565 1,914,021
2.19 0.05 – 4.91 0.90 0.78 8.83
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
36
Aridisol suborders
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
37
3.2.4 Entisols The Entisols show little or no evidence of soil formation. They are most extensive on subrecent alluvial plains and valleys or on steep slopes where erosion is rapid. The rate of soil formation is reduced for several reasons. Generally, time has not elapsed since deposition of the material for soil-forming processes to act. In some of these soils, peraquic conditions prevail, where the soil is saturated with water during the whole year. The soil is permanently reduced, preventing cambic horizon formation. On steep slopes, rapid erosion results in shallow soils where weathered parent materials rest on hard rock (Figure 3.5).
3.2.5 Gelisols In areas where the mean annual soil temperature is less than 0°C, the soils are frozen for long periods of the year and thaw out during the short warmer spells. The freezing and thawing processes promote physical changes in the soil. If there is sufficient water and the warm period is long enough, vegetation establishes and organic matter accumulates on the soil. Organic-rich soils or peat develop. Due to low temperatures, these Arctic soils have unique features such as ice-lenses or a layer of ice underlying the soil (Figure 3.6).
3.2.6 Histosols Most soil classifications, including soil taxonomy, separate mineral soils from organic soils. Histosols are soils that consist dominantly of organic soil materials. They develop where the rates of organic matter accumulation exceed decomposition and removal. Most of these soils formed under saturated conditions where the soil was saturated or nearly saturated with water most of the year. These soils have been referred to as bogs, moors, peat, or mucks. To be farmed, most Histosols must be drained. Management of the water table depth is critical to their use. When drained, Histosols oxidize and subside, requiring further drainage (Figure 3.7).
3.2.7 Inceptisols The Latin word “inceptum” means beginning, and the central concept of Inceptisols is that of soils in the early stages of soil formation. The initial stages of soil formation are exemplified by several attributes that are the result of the presence or absence of certain processes. Soil formation on rocks consists of the weathering of the rock, which is essentially a geochemical process accompanied by soil-forming processes acting on the weathered products. In cool humid climates, the soil-forming process may be the accumulation of organic matter to give rise to a mollic or umbric epipedon. In warmer climates, cambic horizon formation takes place, which is expressed by clay formation or the release of iron to form a color B horizon (Figure 3.8).
Suborder Aquents Psamments Fluvents Orthents TOTAL
Sq km
Global Percent
108,730 4,447,280 3,055,908 15,834,436 23,446,354
0.08 3.40 2.34 12.12 17.94
Africa Sq km Percent
42,596 2,271,000 666,033 7,896,258 10,875,887
FIGURE 3.5 Global distribution of Entisol suborders.
0.14 7.62 2.24 26.50 36.51
Asia Sq km Percent 65,095 121,746 1,284,418 4,634,084 6,105,343
0.15 0.28 2.93 10.55 13.90
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent – 1,251,498 8,945 761,496 2,021,938
– 15.64 0.11 9.52 25.28
Europe Sq km Percent – 21,864 342,825 299,360 664,049
– 0.23 3.57 3.12 6.92
South America Sq km Percent
1,039 781,172 631,074 1,122,408 2,535,694
0.01 4.42 3.57 6.35 14.33
North America Sq km Percent – – 122,613 1,120,830 1,243,443
– – 0.57 5.17 5.74
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
38
Entisol suborders
Map legend
Suborder Histels Turbels Orthels TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent
1,006,321 5,065,473 5,692,048 11,763,841
0.77 3.88 4.36 9.00
Africa Sq km Percent – – – –
– – – –
Sq km
Asia Percent
478,105 1,973,049 4,372,198 6,823,352
1.09 4.49 9.96 15.54
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
Gelisol suborders
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent – – – –
– – – –
Europe Sq km Percent 76,946 53,966 208,194 339,106
0.80 0.56 2.17 3.54
South America Sq km Percent – 23,278 55,256 78,534
– 0.13 0.31 0.44
North America Sq km Percent
451,269 3,015,180 1,056,400 4,522,850
2.08 13.91 4.87 20.87
39
FIGURE 3.6 Global distribution of Gelisol suborders.
Suborder Fibrists Hemists Saprists TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent
195,680 980,686 330,983 1,507,349
0.15 0.75 0.25 1.15
Africa Sq km Percent 17,078 17,078
FIGURE 3.7 Global distribution of Histosol suborders.
0.06 0.06
Asia Sq km Percent 136,211 274,558 249,310 660,079
0.31 0.63 0.57 1.50
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent 1,125 1,125
0.01 0.01
Europe Sq. km Percent 205,451 53 205,504
2.14 0.00 2.14
South America Sq km Percent 10,353 25,204 35,557
0.06 0.14 0.20
North America Sq km Percent 59,468 489,200 39,338 588,006
0.27 2.26 0.18 2.71
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
40
Histosol suborders
Map legend
Suborder Aquepts Anthrepts Cryepts Ustepts Xerepts Udepts Gelepts TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent
3,656,927 450,275 2,598,182 2,230,450 682,562 4,102,039 6,043,091 19,763,526
2.80 0.34 1.99 1.71 0.52 3.14 4.63 15.13
Africa Sq km Percent 369,402 183,883 371 763,561 167,253 218,611 – 1,703,081
1.24 0.62 0.00 2.56 0.56 0.73 – 5.72
Sq km
Asia Percent
1,704,743 29,308 1,495,427 589,305 176,546 1,347,136 4,751,603 10,094,067
3.88 0.07 3.41 1.34 0.40 3.07 10.82 22.99
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
Inceptisol suborders
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent 2,764 – 8,672 14,793 261 252,312 – 278,801
0.03 – 0.11 0.18 0.00 3.15 – 3.49
Europe Sq km Percent 194,747 – 350,803 369,529 320,890 767,872 98,592 2,102,432
2.03 – 3.66 3.85 3.35 8.01 1.03 21.92
South America Sq km Percent 413,983 226,968 260,776 180,570 8,286 933,556 1,901 2,026,040
2.34 1.28 1.47 1.02 0.05 5.28 0.01 11.45
North America Sq km Percent 971,289 10,116 482,133 312,693 9,326 582,553 1,190,995 3,559,105
4.48 0.05 2.22 1.44 0.04 2.69 5.49 16.42
41
FIGURE 3.8 Global distribution of Inceptisol suborders.
Suborder Albolls Aquolls Rendolls Xerolls Cryolls Ustolls Udolls Gelolls TOTAL
Sq km
Global Percent
6,651 117,867 261,035 923,418 2,464,068 3,937,001 1,262,703 155,544 9,128,288
0.01 0.09 0.20 0.71 1.89 3.01 0.97 0.12 6.99
Africa Sq km Percent – – 396 74,795 – 4,423 – – 79,613
FIGURE 3.9 Global distribution of Mollisol suborders.
– – 0.00 0.25 – 0.01 – – 0.27
Asia Sq km Percent 6,651 34,861 62,635 256,378 1,593,058 948,629 131,230 150,766 3,184,208
0.02 0.08 0.14 0.58 3.63 2.16 0.30 0.34 7.25
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent – – 11,831 58,158 – 21,622 25,465 – 117.076
– – 0.15 0.73 – 0.27 0.32 – 1.46
Europe Sq km Percent – 14,930 127,100 371,806 152,896 898,549 78,211 30 1,643,522
– 0.16 1.33 3.88 1.59 9.37 0.82 0.00 17.14
South America Sq km Percent – – – 719 51,060 408,051 527,354 1,470 988,654
– – – 0.00 0.29 2.31 2.98 0.01 5.59
North America Sq km Percent – 68,076 59,074 161,562 667,055 1,655,728 500,444 3,278 3,115,215
– 0.31 0.27 0.75 3.08 7.64 2.31 0.02 14.37
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
42
Mo l l i s o l s u b o r d e r s
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
43
3.2.8 Mollisols To a large extent Mollisols are the breadbasket of the world—the prairies of the United States, the steppes of Russia, and the pampas of Argentina. Most Mollisols are cultivated; in fact, there are only limited areas in the world where they have not been cultivated. Mollisols may initially be farmed with no addition of fertilizers. However, to sustain the high yields of corn, soybeans, sorghum, and small grains of today, fertilizers must be used. Soil temperature and moisture are principally used to separate all but two (Albolls and Rendolls) of the seven suborders of Mollisols (Figure 3.9).
3.2.9 Oxisols Oxisols are reddish, yellowish, or grayish soils. They are most common on the gentle undulating surfaces of geologically old surfaces in tropical and subtropical regions. The most extensive areas of Oxisols are on the interior plateaus of South America, the lower portions of the Amazon Basin, significant portions of the Central African Basin, and important areas in Asia, northern Australia, and several tropical islands of the Pacific. Their profiles are distinctive because of the lack of obvious horizons. Their surface horizons are usually somewhat darker in color than the subsoil, but the transition of subsoil features is gradual (Figure 3.10).
3.2.10 Spodosols A black or reddish brown to strong brown subsoil (spodic) horizon is the primary identifying characteristic of a Spodosol. It is often overlain by a gray to light gray eluvial horizon. These distinctive and contrasting colors make Spodosols easy to identify, although there are always exceptions. The simple explanation for this horizon sequence holds that under cool, humid, or perhumid climates, organic acids from a litter layer leach amorphous mixtures of organic matter and aluminum with or without iron from the eluvial horizon and deposit them in the illuvial spodic horizon. Most Spodosols have formed under such conditions and thus are common in the northern latitudes where most of these soils are to be found (Figure 3.11).
3.2.11 Ultisols Ultisols are similar to Alfisols in that they have a subhorizon of clay accumulation but have few bases, especially at depth. Most Ultisols are acid, although some may have a high pH in the surface horizons due to vegetation recycling or aerosolic additions. From a process point of view, the ideal Ultisol has a subsurface horizon of clay enrichment due to clay translocation from the surface horizons. If the surface horizons are more than 40% clay, these soils—with textural changes with depth— are considered as Ultisols for practical purposes. If there is less than 40% clay in the surface horizons, then they are classified as Oxisols (Figure 3.12).
Suborder Aquox Torrox Ustox Perox Udox TOTAL
Sq km
Global Percent
321,973 31,179 3,114,685 1,166,678 5,233,036 9,867,552
0.25 0.02 2.38 0.89 4.01 7.55
Africa Sq km Percent 321,128 9,140 1,711,581 89,224 1,743,805 3,874,878
FIGURE 3.10 Global distribution of Oxisol suborders.
1.08 0.03 5.75 0.30 5.85 13.01
Asia Sq km Percent
– – 19,391 54,539 77,193 151,124
– – 0.04 0.12 0.18 0.34
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent 845 4,134 53,604 9,129 24,668 92,379
0.01 0.05 0.67 0.11 0.31 1
Europe Sq km Percent – – – – – –
– – – – – –
South America Sq km Percent – 16,366 1,328,943 1,013,198 3,382,965 5,741,472
– 0.09 7.51 5.73 19.12 32.46
North America Sq km Percent – 1,539 1,166 589 4,405 7,699
– 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.02 0.04
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
44
Oxisol suborders
Map legend
Suborder Aquods Cryods Humods Orthods Gelods TOTAL
Sq km
Global Percent
167,311 2,574,197 57,145 648,889 1,110,554 4,558,096
0.13 1.97 0.04 0.50 0.85 3.49
Africa Sq km Percent – – – – – –
– – – – – –
Asia Sq km Percent 13,250 64,555 19,236 13,343 107,020 217,404
0.03 0.15 0.04 0.03 0.24 0.50
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
Spodosol suborders
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent – 14 32,708 28,502 – 61,224
– 0.00 0.41 0.36 – 0.77
Europe Sq km Percent
99,330 1,012,855 4,471 265,137 402,126 1,783,920
1.04 10.56 0.05 2.76 4.19 18.60
South America Sq km Percent – 14,648 652 413 – 15,713
– 0.08 0.00 0.00 – 0.09
North America Sq km Percent 54,731 1,482,126 78 341,494 601,408 2,479,836
0.25 6.84 0.00 1.58 2.77 11.44
45
FIGURE 3.11 Global distribution of Spodosol suborders.
Suborder Aquults Humults Udults Ustults Xerults TOTAL
Global Sq km Percent 1,284,545 380,494 5,539,787 3,339,721 18,664 10,563,211
0.98 0.29 4.24 2.56 0.01 8.08
Africa Sq km Percent 55,637 35,699 602,503 1,355,657 900 2,050,396
FIGURE 3.12 Global distribution of Ultisol suborders.
0.19 0.12 2.02 4.55 0.00 6.88
Asia Sq km Percent 256,980 177,677 3,065,910 717,548 2,632 4,220,748
0.59 0.40 6.98 1.63 0.01 9.61
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent 75,833 25,339 87,712 70,823 – 259,707
0.95 0.32 1.10 0.89 – 3.25
Europe Sq km Percent – – 4,275 – – 4,275
– – 0.04 – – 0.04
South America Sq km Percent 691,509 – 858,411 1,058,014 13 2,607,947
3.91 – 4.85 5.98 0.00 14.74
North America Sq km Percent 204,586 141,780 920,975 137,679 15,120 1,420,139
0.94 0.65 4.25 0.64 0.07 6.55
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
46
Ultisol suborders
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
47
3.2.12 Vertisols Vertisols are clay soils with deep, wide cracks on some occasions during the year and slickensides within 100 cm of the soil surface. They shrink when dry and swell when moistened. Vertisols make up a relatively homogeneous order of soils because of the amount and kind of clay that is common to them. In many countries where Vertisols are common, they are known by their local names; for example, gilgai soils (Australia), adobe (Philippines), sha chiang (China), black cotton soils (India), smolnitza (Bulgaria), tirs (Morocco), makande (Malawi), vleigrond (South Africa), and sonsosuite (Nicaragua) (Figure 3.13).
3.3 HISTORICAL TRENDS Soil science evolved from geology, chemistry, physics, and biology. This field of science has been considered to be an independent area with a strong focus on agriculture for the past century or so [Arnold 1983; Sumner 2000]. Research in agriculture is instrumental in the rapid development of soil science [Sposito and Reginato 1992]. Over the past 2 decades, food insecurity has become a major concern in developing countries. A compounded effect of this insecurity is seen in the decline in soil productivity leading to accelerated land degradation. In contrast, intensive development of the agricultural sector in developed countries has culminated in the advent of several environmental issues. Enhanced techniques in modern agriculture include monocropping, high input and nonlabor intensive agriculture, precision agriculture, and zero-tillage. Concomitant with increasing demands for food and declining soil productivity, the need to implement sustainable agricultural systems worldwide was well recognized about 3 decades ago. The concept of sustainable development was enlarged to include wise use of natural resources in 1992 in Rio de Janeiro [UNCED 1992]. It is interesting to note that many methods that are currently in use (e.g., soil erosion and conservation assessment) were developed after the World War II. Despite some improvements in these methods over the years, there appears to be little progress in terms of their use and adaptability to the current context. In modern times, the soil scientist plays an important ethical role in linking the farmers’ interests with those of the land quality in defining the productivity of the agroecosystem. In the 1980s, the focus of soil science research took a different turn. It was widely recognized at this time that technology used in temperate regions could not be directly transferred to tropical areas. Some of the challenges to soil scientists at that time were summarized by Khanwar [1982]: • Assessing the potential of soil resources for alternative uses • Optimizing agricultural productivity of the land under cultivation • Improving the efficiency of agricultural inputs such as water and fertilizer in combination with high yielding seeds to maximize yield • Curbing the acceleration of soil degradation due to poor management of resources • Rehabilitating degraded lands • Developing a monitoring system for early detection of declines in soil quality
Suborder Aquerts Cryerts Xererts Torrerts Usterts Uderts TOTAL
Sq km
Global Percent
5,441 17,148 98,024 893,583 1,769,861 382,611 3,166,668
0.00 0.01 0.08 0.68 1.35 0.29 2.42
Africa Sq km Percent 688 – 12,317 194,140 715,765 66,074 988,985
FIGURE 3.13 Global distribution of Vertisol suborders.
0.00 – 0.04 0.65 2.40 0.22 3.32
Asia Sq km Percent 3,322 – 46,569 64,698 599,270 110,332 824,190
0.01 – 0.11 0.15 1.36 0.25 1.88
Australia/Oceania Sq km Percent – – 19,905 586,074 242,591 14,360 862,929
– – 0.25 7.33 3.03 0.18 10.79
Europe Sq km Percent – 16,995 17,284 – 28,191 19,768 82,237
– 0.18 0.18 – 0.29 0.21 0.86
South America Sq km Percent 1,430 46 1,026 6,365 38,702 105,618 153,188
0.01 0.00 0.01 0.04 0.22 0.60 0.87
North America Sq km Percent – 107 923 42,306 145,342 66,460 255,138
– 0.00 0.00 0.20 0.67 0.31 1.18
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Map legend
48
Ver t i s o l s u b o r d e r s
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
49
Khanwar [1982] pointed out that in industrialized countries, the focus was on maintaining high soil productivity while minimizing degradation. However, in developing countries, the focus was on improving productivity per unit of land per unit of time by enhancing the efficiency of water use and implementing high-input agricultural systems. Interestingly, Khanwar [1982] stressed the lack of interest in the management of forest lands, range lands, and grasslands and that, although priorities may vary, the challenges remain the same and, although the practices may differ, the principles of soil science remain be the same. Since the 1980s, there has been a steady shift in emphasis from soil science to the environment and ecology [Wild 1989; Yaalon 1993; Miller 1993; Gardner 1993; Bouma 1994; Warkentin 1994; Wilding 1994; Mermut and Eswaran 1997, 2001; Sparks 2000]. The Soil Science Society of America joined the American Geological Institute (AGI) in 1993 to further enhance the society’s role in geoscience [Landa 2004]. Understandably, there were some changes in priorities at the different time intervals.
3.4 CURRENT ISSUES 3.4.1 Opportunities Spatial and temporal analysis of soils presents an opportunity to strengthen the discipline of soil science by integrating several branches such as soil genesis, classification, mineralogy, physics, chemistry, biology, biochemistry, and micromorphology. Currently, there is also a need to establish good links between the various disciplines within earth science. This would undoubtedly create an avenue for more research in the areas of ethnopedology [Winkler-Prins and Sandor 2003], hydrogeophysics [Hubbard and Rubin 2002; Muller 2003], hydropedology [Lin 2003], and nanoscience [NSF 2002]. In addition, a holistic approach to soil science would improve the understanding of landscape evolution and increase awareness of the impacts of global climate change or economic globalization on social and ecological environment. Recently, Effland et al. [2009] have indicated that increased demands for effective communication of global soil resource inventories requires continued development of correlation matrices for cross-referencing international and national soil classification systems. A direct impact of this would be enhanced agrotechnology transfer and greater scopes of scientific research. The geoscience division and soil science in the twenty-first century have been noted to share a common agenda. An aspect, among others, of this agenda is to encourage a fundamental knowledge of earth systems that is more systematic, interdisciplinary, dynamic, and process-oriented and to identify early warning systems of natural hazards and resource degradations. Despite identifying this aspect as an opportunity, the very fact that a more holistic approach needs to be undertaken in understanding earth systems renders the process a modern day challenge.
3.4.2 Challenges The widening gap between geologists and soil scientists has been left unmonitored for over 4 decades. Problems associated with this can be seen in a steady decrease of
50
World Soil Resources and Food Security
the number of students enrolling in soil science programs at universities worldwide. This is further evidenced by the closure and renaming of soil science departments, purportedly to stay abreast of the latest developments and requirements of the general public. This lack of focus and leadership in steering the soil science community to greater heights has culminated in the profession earning a poor reputation among the public. Undoubtedly, funds for basic soil science research are shrinking fast and this is directly lined to drastic reduction in the number of scientific papers in highimpact journals. These issues indicate that, in the absence of proper and proactive strategies to revitalize the entire discipline, the long-term sustainability of this program remains very doubtful. On a slightly different note, it is worthwhile to reexamine the criteria for securing research grants, evaluation of research projects, and scientific recognition of the work done. There appears to be a tendency to recognize highly specialized works. This has a negative impact on young researchers who will be quietly discouraged from taking part in interdisciplinary groups. Changes in evaluation criteria will undoubtedly allow soil science to adapt better to current challenges.
3.5 FUTURE PERSPECTIVES Soil science has an important role in enhancing food security and addressing major issues of the twenty-first century such as climate change, water management (Figure 3.14), desertification, and biofuels. Holistic approaches have been advocated on countless occasions to foster stronger ties with all the disciplines. Such paradigm shifts are not restricted to research trends only, but also apply to undergraduate and graduate programs. A direct consequence of this is the strong need to raise the profile of the soil scientist and the profession. The future of soil science looks extremely bright, taking into account the need to increase the profile to meet current and future expectations.
FIGURE 3.14 Improper water management causes flooding, as well as degradation of soil resources.
World Soil Resources: Opportunities and Challenges
51
3.6 CONCLUSIONS This treatise shows very clearly that priorities have changed over the past 4 decades or so and continue to change as our expectations for the land and science change with time. The basic tenets of agrotechnology transfer appear to have been partially successful. The main reason for this partial success is the fact that technology developed in temperate countries was not really adaptable in tropical situations. In many cases, this mismatch in technology and, to a large extent, knowledge, still exists. To encompass a holistic approach to soil science, local conditions will have to be considered. Priorities will tend to vary depending on geographical locations as a result of influence by natural limitations apart from other challenges such as local politics. Administrative restrictions will set the precedence in determining the challenges in soil science for the future. Clearly this is an extremely challenging task, but not an unachievable one. Past successes show that a concerted effort to conduct research in a holistic manner has paid off very well. This, therefore, should be the norm in future research programs.
REFERENCES Arnold, R.W. 1983. Concepts of soils and pedology. In Pedogenesis and soil taxonomy: I. Concepts and interactions, 1st ed., L.P. Wilding, N.E. Smeck, and G.F. Hall, eds., 1–21. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Aubert, G. 1958. Classification des sols. Compte Rendu Reunion Sous-comite. Congo Brazzaville. Botelho da Costa, J.V. 1959. Ferralitic, tropical fersiallitic and tropical semi-arid soils: Definitions adopted in the classification of the soils of Angola. Third Inter-African Soils Conference, Dalaba. I:317–319. Bouma, J. 1994. Proposed activities to seize opportunities for soil science and its applications in the 21st century. Bull. Int. Soc. Soil Sci. 86:13–14. Effland, W.R., Eswaran, H., and Reich, P. 2009. Toward development of a global soil classification correlation matrix (GSCCM). 2009 International Annual Meeting ASA-CSSASSSA. Nov. 1–5, 2009. Pittsburgh, PA. FAO, ISRIC, and ISSS, 1998. World reference base for soil resources. Rome: FAO. FAO-UNESCO. 1971–1976. Soil map of the world. Rome: FAO. Gardner, W.R. 1993. A call to action. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 57:1403–1405. Hubbard, S., and Rubin, Y. 2002. Study institute assesses the state of hydrogeophysics. Eos, Transactions American Geophysical Union 83(51):02–606. Khanwar, J.S. 1982. Managing soil resources to meet the challenges to mankind: Presidential address. 12th International Congress of Soil Science. New Delhi, India. February 8–12, 1982. New Delhi: Rekha Printers Pvt Ltd. Landa, E.R. 2004. Soil science and geology: Connects, disconnects and new opportunities in geoscience education. J. Geosci. Educ. 52:191–196. Lin, H. 2003. Hydropedology—Bridging disciplines, scales and data. Vadose Zone Journal 2:1–11. Mermut, A.R., and Eswaran, H. 1997. Opportunities for soil science in a milieu of reduced funds. Can. J. Soil Sci. 77:1–7. Mermut, A.R., and Eswaran, H. 2001. Some major developments in soil science since the mid1960’s. Geoderma 100:403–426. Miller, F.P. 1993. Soil science: A scope broader than its identity. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 57(299):564.
52
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Muller, M. 2003. Opening doors for geophysics in soil science. American Geophysical Union 84(26):243. National Science Foundation (NSF). 2002. Report of the nanoscience workshop. Berkeley, CA, June 14–16, 2002. Soil Management Support Services (SMSS) Staff. 1991. Soil Management Support Services Final Report 1980–1990. Washington, DC: USDA-SCS. Soil Survey Staff. 1999. Soil Taxonomy: A basic system of soil classification for making and interpreting soil surveys. Ag. Handbook No. 436. Washington, DC: USDA-NRCS. Sparks, D.L. 2000. Soils. Geotimes 45:39. Sposito, G., and Reginato, R.J., eds. 1992. Opportunities in basic soil science research. Madison, WI: Soil Science Society of America, Inc. Sumner, M.E., ed. 2000. Handbook of soil science. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Tavernier, R., and Sys, C. 1965. Classification of the soils of Congo. Pedologie (Ghent, Belgium) Special Issue No. 5:91–136. UNCED. 1992. United Nations Conference on Environment and Development. Rio de Janeiro: UN. Warkentin, B.P. 1994. The discipline of soil science: How should it be organized? Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 58:267–269. Wild, A. 1989. Soil scientists as members of the scientific community. J. Soil Sci. 40: 209–221. Wilding, L.P. 1994. Surficial studies: Soil science. Geotimes 39:13–14. Winkler-Prins, A.M.G.A., and Sandor, J.A., eds. 2003. Ethnopedology (Special Issue). Geoderma 111(3–4). Yaalon, D. 1993. Soil science in the eyes of the beholder: Better understanding of soil processes and pedology urged. Bull. Int. Soc. Soil Sci. 84:13–14.
Resources and 4 Soil Human Adaptation in Forest and Agricultural Ecosystems in Humid Asia S. Funakawa, T. Watanabe, A. Kadono, A. Nakao, K. Fujii, and T. Kosaki CONTENTS 4.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 55 4.2 Clay Mineralogy and Its Relationship to Soil Solution Composition in Soils from Different Weathering Environments.............................................. 56 4.2.1 Soil Samples Used for the Analysis..................................................... 57 4.2.2 Mineralogy of the Silt and Clay Fractions........................................... 58 4.2.3 Chemical Composition of Soil Water Extracts....................................60 4.2.4 pH and Activities of Al–OH Species in the Soil Water Extracts........ 63 4.2.5 Transformation of 2:1 Type Clay Minerals..........................................64 4.3 Pedogenetic Alterations of Illitic Minerals Represented by Radiocesium Interception Potential in Soils with Different Soil Moisture Regimes............ 65 4.3.1 Study Soils...........................................................................................66 4.3.2 Quantitative Mineralogical Properties, Cs-Fixed Capacity, and RIP Values...........................................................................................66 4.3.3 Statistical Relationship between RIP and Mineralogical Properties............................................................................................. 67 4.3.4 Nature of Illitic Minerals in the Three Regions in Terms of the Frayed Edge Site.................................................................................. 68 4.3.5 Illite Vermiculitization and Soil Weathering...................................... 70 4.3.6 Weathering Sequence in Upland Soils of Humid Asia........................ 71 4.4 Regional Trends in the Chemical and Mineralogical Properties of Upland Soils in Humid Asia with Special Reference to the WRB Classification Scheme...................................................................................... 72 4.4.1 Soils Studied........................................................................................ 73
53
54
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.8
World Soil Resources and Food Security
4.4.2 Regional Trend in the General Physicochemical and Mineralogical Properties of the Soils.................................................. 73 4.4.3 Relationship between Clay Mineral Composition and Cation Exchange Capacity in the Soils........................................................... 77 4.4.4 Relationship between Clay Mineral Composition and Soil pH........... 77 4.4.5 Classification of the Soils Examined According to WRB and Its Relationship to Mineral Weathering Conditions................................. 79 Factors Controlling Potentially Mineralizable and Recalcitrant Soil Organic Matter in Humid Asia........................................................................ 81 4.5.1 Soils Studied........................................................................................ 82 4.5.2 Soil Properties and a Comparison of Land Use.................................. 83 4.5.3 Amounts of PMC and PMN and the Rate Constants for the Different Land-Use Systems................................................................84 4.5.4 Estimation of PMC and PMN by Stepwise Linear Regression Using the Five Identified Factors by Principal Component Analysis.... 84 4.5.5 Estimation of PMC and PMN by Stepwise Linear Regression Using Soil Properties Representing the Five Identified Factors.......... 86 4.5.6 Factors Controlling ROC and RON..................................................... 87 Comparative Study on Soil Fertility Status under Shifting Cultivation in East Kalimantan, Northern Thailand, and Japan in Relation to Dynamics of Readily Mineralizable SOM and Soil Acidity........................... 89 4.6.1 Description of Study Sites................................................................... 89 4.6.2 General Physicochemical Properties of the Soils Studied..................92 4.6.3 Factors Controlling the Amounts of C0 and N0...................................94 4.6.4 Relationships between Respective Factors and Topography or Land-Use Status in East Kalimantan..................................................97 4.6.5 Dynamics of Soil Fertility Status throughout a Land Rotation System of Shifting Cultivation in Northern Thailand......................... 98 4.6.6 General Consideration on Land Uses in Upland Soils in Respective Regions in Relation to Soil Fertility Status..................... 101 Comparative Study on Proton Budgets in Soils of Cropland and Adjacent Forest in Thailand and Indonesia................................................... 103 4.7.1 Study Plots......................................................................................... 104 4.7.2 Physicochemical Properties of Soils.................................................. 104 4.7.3 Carbon Stock and Flow..................................................................... 104 4.7.4 Soil Solution Composition................................................................. 109 4.7.5 Net Proton Generation and Consumption.......................................... 111 4.7.6 Comparison of Soil Acidification Processes in Forests and Croplands........................................................................................... 115 4.7.7 Evaluation of Cultivation-Induced Soil Acidification in Relation to Organic Matter Dynamics............................................................. 116 Quantitative Analysis of Organic Matter Dynamics under Shifting Cultivation Systems in Northern Thailand with Special Reference to Functions of the Soil Microbial Community................................................. 117 4.8.1 Description of Study Sites................................................................. 117
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
55
4.8.2 Field Measurements of SOM Budgets in Different Stages of Land Use under Shifting Cultivation................................................. 118 4.8.3 In Situ Soil Solution Composition under Shifting Cultivation.......... 127 4.8.4 Fluctuation of Microbial Biomass and Metabolic Quotient, qCO2.................................................................................................. 127 4.8.5 Substrate-Induced Microbial Activities (Respiration and N Assimilation/Nitrification) by Short-Term Laboratory Incubation .. 129 4.8.6 Dynamics of Microbial Activities during Different Stages of Shifting Cultivation and the Function of the Fallow Phase............... 131 4.8.7 Main Functions of the Fallow Phase in Shifting Cultivation by Karen People in Northern Thailand.................................................. 133 4.9 Factors Controlling Soil Organic Matter Decomposition in Small Home Gardens in Different Regions of Indonesia................................................... 134 4.9.1 Description of Study Sites................................................................. 134 4.9.2 Field Measurement of Soil Respiration............................................. 137 4.9.3 Laboratory Incubation to Determine Soil Respiration Rate with Microbial Origin................................................................................ 140 4.9.4 Extensive Survey to Determine Distribution Patterns of SOM- Related Properties of Soils in Java and East Kalimantan........ 143 4.9.5 SOM Dynamics in Soils Situated in Different Climatic and/or Geological Conditions....................................................................... 147 4.9.6 Possible Land Management Systems in Different Regions of Java and East Kalimantan.................................................................. 150 4.10 General Discussion and Conclusion.............................................................. 150 References............................................................................................................... 152 Appendix—Analytical Methods............................................................................. 161 4.A1 Composition of Soil Water Extract for Thermodynamic Analysis............... 161 4.A2 Quantification of the Frayed Edge Site Using Radiocesium Interception Potential (RIP) Methodology......................................................................... 162 4.A3 Theoretical Calculation of Water Fluxes, Soil Acidification Rates, and Net Proton Generation................................................................................... 163 4.A3.1 Water Fluxes................................................................................... 163 4.A3.2 Soil Acidification Rate and Net Proton Generation........................ 164 4.A4 Determination of Potentially Mineralizable Carbon (PMC) and Nitrogen (PMN)............................................................................................. 166
4.1 INTRODUCTION Soils in humid Asia exhibit relatively incipient mineralogical characteristics because of the dominant steep slopes, crust movement, and volcanic activity on young alpine fold belts [FAO 2001] compared with soils developed on stable plains associated with the Precambrian shield in eastern South America or equatorial Africa. Among these continents, geological components are also different; distribution of mafic (or basic) parent materials is limited and sedimentary rocks as well as igneous felsic rocks
56
World Soil Resources and Food Security
are major parent rocks in humid Asia [Geological Survey of Japan 2004], whereas some metamorphic or basic rocks are dominated in the tropics of other continents [FAO/Unesco 1971, 1977]. Because of these essential differences in topographical and geological conditions, dominant upland soils in humid Asia are Ultisols, which is quite contrasting with the humid tropics in other continents where Oxisols are predominant [Soil Survey Staff 1999]. Since much of the information relating to the soils and agriculture in humid tropics has been derived from the achievements in Africa and Latin America [e.g., Mohr et al. 1972; Sanchez 1976], we believe that the actual situation of soil distribution and ecological processes both in natural and agricultural ecosystems in humid Asia are worthwhile to be introduced as integrated information when considering possible solutions as well as countermeasures against land degradation presently observed in the area. The present work comprises two parts. The first part (Sections 4.2 to 4.4) highlights unique clay transforming processes in the upland soil of humid Asia (Indonesia, Thailand, and Japan), which are considered to be affected strongly by both geological and climatic conditions. The pedogenetic alterations of illitic minerals under different soil moisture regimes (ustic or udic) are the main topics discussed in these sections. In the studied regions, sedimentary and felsic igneous rocks are predominantly distributed and fates of dioctahedral mica (illite) are essential to determine soil physicochemical properties such as soil acidity and cation exchange capacity (CEC). In the second part (Sections 4.5 to 4.9), on the basis of information of the previous part, conventional shifting cultivation and upland farming in different regions of Thailand and Indonesia are comparatively analyzed with special reference to the dynamics of soil organic matter (SOM) and soil acidity. There are several differences between shifting cultivation systems on Alisols under rainforest climates and those on Acrisols under monsoon climates, which can closely be linked with the ecosystem and pedogenetic processes and resulting soil properties in the regions. The main conclusion is given that, under low-input managements, subsistence agriculture must be strongly regulated by the respective soil-ecological conditions and, in turn, it could be represented as human adaptation to respective ecological conditions.
4.2 C LAY MINERALOGY AND ITS RELATIONSHIP TO SOIL SOLUTION COMPOSITION IN SOILS FROM DIFFERENT WEATHERING ENVIRONMENTS To assess inherent soil fertility for appropriate large-scale land management, it is important to understand how clay mineralogy relates to geological and weathering conditions and how physicochemical properties are affected by the clay mineralogy of soils. The neoformation of gibbsite, kaolin minerals, and smectite, and the transformation of mica are important processes in the formation of clay minerals. Neoformation is mainly controlled by H 4SiO 04 activity. Gibbsite forms under conditions of strong desilication where H 4SiO 04 activity is low [Huang et al. 2002]. Kaolin minerals form under moderate H 4SiO 04 activity conditions and smectite under high activity [Reid-Soukup and Ulery 2002]. Mica, which is commonly present in felsic
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
57
and sedimentary rocks, weathers to vermiculite and smectite, with a decrease in the layer charge and release of alkaline metals. The increased resistance to weathering of dioctahedral mica means that dioctahedral vermiculite is more common in soils than trioctahedral vermiculite [Malla 2002]. Among the processes, the intensity of vermiculitization of dioctahedral mica (or illitic minerals) is one of the key processes when considering the influence of mineralogy on soil physicochemical properties since the presence of expandable 2:1 minerals strongly affects soil properties such as CEC. In this section, therefore, unique clay transforming processes in upland soils of humid Asia (Indonesia, Thailand, and Japan) are comparatively analyzed relating to climatic conditions and resulting soil moisture regimes. The distribution of clay minerals in the upland soils of humid Asia, namely Japan, Thailand, and Indonesia, has been described previously. In general, hydroxy-Al interlayered vermiculite (HIV), mica, and kaolin minerals dominate in Japan [Matsue and Wada 1989; Araki et al. 1990], while kaolinite, mica, and smectite are dominant in Thailand [Yoshinaga et al. 1995; Yoothong et al. 1997; Kanket et al. 2002], and kaolinite, vermiculite, and smectite are the primary clay minerals found in Indonesia [Goenadi and Tan 1988; Koch et al. 1992; Supriyo et al. 1992a; Prasetyo et al. 2001]. However, each of the above regional reports fails to compare the formation of local clay minerals with formative processes in other regions. In addition, thermodynamic data on soil solution is lacking for humid Asia, and little emphasis has been placed on thermodynamic analysis of soil–water relationships. Soil solution data have been used successfully in the past to quantitatively predict and explain the distribution of clay minerals in soil and explain weathering trends [Kittrick 1973; van Breemen and Brinkman 1976; Karathanasis et al. 1983; Rai and Kittrick 1989; Norfleet et al. 1993; Karathanasis 2002]. Such an approach may help to understand the distribution of different clay minerals throughout humid Asia. The objective of the present section is, therefore, to explain the distribution of clay minerals in humid Asia based on the composition of soil water extracts, as affected by climate, parent material of the soil, and soil age.
4.2.1 Soil Samples Used for the Analysis The regions considered in this study are Japan, Thailand, and the Java, Sumatra, and East Kalimantan regions of Indonesia. Japan is part of a volcanic belt, and contains widely distributed felsic igneous and sedimentary rocks and tephra. In northern and northeast Thailand, sedimentary and felsic igneous rocks are most common. Java and Sumatra are part of a volcanic belt and consist mostly of tephra, andesite, and sedimentary rocks; felsic rocks are only found locally. Most of East Kalimantan is covered with sedimentary rocks where there are no active volcanoes; soils are more weathered on stable rolling landscapes. All the above regions have a humid climate, although Thailand has a distinct dry season with lower annual precipitation. Temperatures in Indonesia and Thailand are higher than those in Japan; this strongly favors weathering. Soil temperature and moisture regime are therefore described as mesic/thermic-udic in Japan, hyperthermic-udic in Indonesia, and hyperthermicustic in Thailand (Figure 4.1). Among these, a moisture deficiency during the dry
58
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Interfrost 40ºN
Ustic Aridic or permafrost
JPN
JPS Udic or perudic
THH Ustic
20ºN
THL
Udic or perudic
IDH
0º
IDL
100ºE
120ºE
FIGURE 4.1 Study area with soil moisture regimes.
season is only expected in Thailand (Figure 4.2). Considering the geology of each region, we collected upland soils from subsurface horizons at 204 sites (37 in Japan, 90 in Northern Thailand, one in Northeastern Thailand, 28 in Java, nine in Sumatra, and 39 in East Kalimantan) for identification of clay minerals. We also selected 53 soils from 38 of the 204 sites with the representative clay mineral composition and various parent materials for each region, for the analysis of the composition of soil water extracts. Soil samples were divided into four groups: Japan (JP1-JP13), Thailand (TH1-TH14), sedimentary rock areas of Indonesia (ID-S1-ID-S10), and volcanic areas of Indonesia (ID-V1-ID-V7). Indonesian samples were subdivided on the basis of parent material, as the volcanic rocks are usually andesitic or mafic and therefore quite different from the typically felsic sedimentary rocks. We use the following abbreviations for samples from Indonesian sites: JV, Java; SM, Sumatra; and EK, East Kalimantan. For JP and TH, parent rocks were mostly felsic igneous and sedimentary rocks.
4.2.2 Mineralogy of the Silt and Clay Fractions X-ray diffractograms of the silt fraction indicate that mica is usually absent in soils with parent materials of andesitic or mafic volcanic ejecta or andesite that are characteristic of ID-V, gabbro or limestone, while mica is present in soils with parent materials of sedimentary or felsic igneous rock (granite and rhyolite), characteristic
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia 300
250
250
200
200
150
150
100
100
50
50
0
0
300
Chiang Mai (Thailand)
Ja n Fe b M a Apr Mr ay Ju n J Auul g Se p O c N t ov D ec
Kyoto (Japan)
Ja n Fe b M a Apr Mr ay Ju n J Auul g Se p O c N t o Dv ec
Monthly average (mm)
300
59
Balikpapan (Indonesia)
200 150 100 50 0
Rainfall Potential evapotranspiration Ja n Fe b M a Apr Mr ay Ju n J Auul g Se p O c N t o Dv ec
Monthly average (mm)
250
FIGURE 4.2 Monthly distribution of rainfall and potential evapotranspiration for the three regions: southwestern Japan (Kyoto), northern Thailand (Chiang Mai), and East Kalimantan of Indonesia (Balikpapan). The precipitation data were derived from the Global Historical Climatology Network, version 1 (GHCN 1), and the potential evapotranspiration was estimated with the Thornthwaite method [Thornthwaite and Mather 1957].
of JP, TH, and ID-S (Figure 4.3). In some of soils from Java, smectite is dominant in the silt fraction; this may be inherited from the parent rocks. For the clay fraction from all regions, mica and vermiculite are absent when a mica peak at 1.0 nm was not detected in the silt fraction (ID-V6(SM) in Figure 4.3). In contrast, when mica was present in the silt fraction, mica, vermiculite, and HIV were common in the clay fraction. Mica was most abundant in 2:1 clay minerals in TH, with vermiculite most common in ID-S, and HIV in JP (Figure 4.4). Interlayered materials between the 2:1 layers were generally more common in JP than in ID-S, as the peak tended to remain with the heat treatment. In JP and ID-S, the relative peak intensity of 1.4–1.0 nm was larger in the clay than in the silt fraction, suggesting that 1.4 nm clay minerals
60
World Soil Resources and Food Security
ID-V6(SM) Bw (Andesitic-basaltic volcanic breccia)
TH1 Bt (Granite)
Clay, Mg
Clay, Mg Silt, Mg
Silt, Mg 1.42 1.0 0.72 d-space (nm)
0.485
JP1 BC (Granite)
1.42 1.0 0.72 d-space (nm)
0.485
ID-S7(EK) Bt (Sandstone-mudstone) Clay, K-550ºC
Clay, K-550ºC
Clay, K-25ºC
Clay, K-25ºC
Clay, Mg Clay, Mg Silt, Mg Silt, Mg 1.42 1.0 0.72 d-space (nm)
0.485
1.42 1.0 0.72 d-space (nm)
0.485
FIGURE 4.3 X-ray (Cu–Kα) diffractograms from oriented specimens of silt and clay fractions. Parent materials are shown in parentheses.
formed from mica (Figure 4.3). A broader peak at 0.7 nm among the JP and ID-V samples indicates the lower crystallinity of kaolin minerals compared to ID-S and TH samples. Our clay mineral composition results are generally consistent with previous reports for each region [Goenadi and Tan 1988; Matsue and Wada 1989; Araki et al. 1990; Koch et al. 1992; Supriyo et al. 1992a; Yoshinaga et al. 1995; Yoothong et al. 1997; Prasetyo et al. 2001; Kanket et al. 2002].
4.2.3 Chemical Composition of Soil Water Extracts The pH of soil water extracts from JP and ID-S samples is low, mostly within the range 4.3 to 5.5; however, the pH is relatively high in TH and ID-V soils (pH 5.4– 6.5). The pH of the soil water extracts was generally higher than that determined for soil suspensions, presumably due to the gradual dissolution of minerals that occurs during the 1-week preparation of the soil water extracts. The activities of Al–OH species (Al3+, Al(OH)2+, Al(OH)+2 , Al(OH)30 , and Al(OH) –) are higher in JP than in
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
61
Kaolin minerals 0 10
100 80
30
70
40
(%)
JP TH ID-S ID-V
90
20
60
50
50
60
40
70
30
80
20
90
10
100 Mica
0
(%)
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90 100
(%)
0 1.4 nm minerals
FIGURE 4.4 Clay mineralogical composition of the soils determined based on relative peak areas of kaolin minerals, mica, and 1.4-nm minerals in x-ray diffractograms.
ID-S samples, although the pH of extracts from both regions is low (Figure 4.5). The activities of Al–OH species in TH and ID-V samples are low; in some extracts, the Al concentration is below the detection limit, due to higher pH. The H 4SiO 04 activity of the soil water extracts was highest in JP (approximately 10−3.1−10−3.8 mol L−1) and ID-V (approximately 10−3.2−10−3.9 mol L−1) samples, followed by ID-S (approximately
JP TH ID-S ID-V Gibbsite Amorphous Al(OH)3
log(Al total)
–2
–4
–6 ID-S2(JV)
–8
3
4
5
pH
6
7
ID-S1(JV)
8
FIGURE 4.5 Sum of activities of Al–OH species (Al3+, A1(OH)2+, Al(OH)+2 , Al(OH)30 , Al(OH)−4 ) in soil water extracts with gibbsite and amorphous Al hydroxide solubility lines.
62
World Soil Resources and Food Security JP
ID-S
4
Muscovite
2 0
–4.0
–2.5
–2 –4.5
–4.0
–3.5
–3.0
ID-V 6
pH + log(K+)
Muscovite
–2 –4.5
–4.0
TH Microcline
Gibbsite
Kaolinite
log (H4SiO4)
2 0
Gibbsite
log (H4SiO4)
6 4
–3.0
ID-S1(JV)
2
Kaolinite –3.5
Microcline
Muscovite
4 ID-S2(JV)
0
Gibbsite
–2 –4.5
pH + log(K+)
6
Microcline
pH + log(K+)
pH + log(K+)
6
–3.5
log (H4SiO4)
–3.0
–2.5
Microcline
4
Muscovite
2 0
Kaolinite
–2.5
Gibbsite
–2 –4.5
–4.0
Kaolinite –3.5
log (H4SiO4)
–3.0
–2.5
FIGURE 4.6 Composition of soil water extract from JP, TH, ID-S, and ID-V plotted on a stability diagram.
10 −3.5−10 −4.0 mol L−1) and lowest in TH (approximately 10 −3.6 −10 −4.3 mol L−1) [detailed data were given by Watanabe et al. 2006]. In the stability diagram (Figure 4.6), the compositions of TH extracts plot close to the line where both kaolinite and muscovite are stable, while JP and ID-S samples mostly plot within the field where kaolinite is stable and muscovite unstable; exceptions to this trend are ID-S1(JV), which is derived from limestone, and ID-S2(JV), which contains significant montmorillonite. In the solubility diagram (Figure 4.7), the compositions of JP and TH extracts mostly plot between the solubility lines of amorphous Al hydroxide and gibbsite, which indicates that gibbsite can precipitate. The ID-S samples and a few TH and ID-V samples plot under the kaolinite solubility line, indicating the dissolution of gibbsite and kaolinite.
63
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
Gibbsite
7 6 –4.5
Muscovite
Kaolinite
–3.5
ID-S2(JV) Smectite ID-S1(JV) Gibbsite
Muscovite
7
JP6 –4.0
Amrp. Al(OH)3
9 8
–3.0
Kaolinite
6 –4.5
–2.5
–4.0
log (H4SiO4) Amrp. SiO2 Amrp. Al(OH)3
9
Smectite
8 Muscovite 7 6 –4.5
Gibbsite
–3.5
ID-V
11 10 9 8
Amrp. Al(OH)3
–2.5
–3.0
–2.5
Smectite
Gibbsite Muscovite Kaolinite
7
Kaolinite
–4.0
–3.0
Quartz
TH
log(Al3+) + 3pH
log(Al3+) + 3pH
10
–3.5
log (H4SiO4)
Quartz
11
Amrp. SiO2
10
Amrp. SiO2
8
Smectite
Quartz
Quartz Amrp. Al(OH)3
ID-S
11
log(Al3+) + 3pH
log(Al3+) + 3pH
10 9
Amrp. SiO2
JP
11
6 –4.5
–4.0
log (H4SiO4)
–3.5
–3.0
–2.5
log (H4SiO4)
FIGURE 4.7 Composition of soil water extract from JP, TH, ID-S, and ID-V plotted on a solubility diagram.
4.2.4
pH and Activities of Al–OH Species in the
Soil Water Extracts
The pH and activities of Al–OH species such as Al3+ are very important when considering mineral behavior such as stability or the possibility of neoformation in soils. Extract pH appears to reflect precipitation, evapotranspiration, and geology. The difference between precipitation and potential evapotranspiration in each region was 808 mm in Japan, –390 mm in Thailand, and 457–2709 mm in Indonesia; these trends may explain the lower pH in JP and ID-S samples and the higher pH in TH samples. ID-V samples have a high pH despite intense leaching. This probably occurs because ID-V soils contain easily weathered minerals such as mafic minerals that can neutralize acidity when weathered rapidly; this will be apparent at high H 4SiO 04 activity in high pH extracts (Figures 4.6 and 4.7).
64
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Solubility diagrams (Figures 4.5 and 4.7) for JP and TH samples indicate that the activity of Al–OH species is controlled by the dissolution and precipitation of Al hydroxide, which has a crystallinity intermediate between gibbsite and amorphous Al hydroxide. In ID-S samples, the dissolution of kaolinite controlled lower activities. Al–OH species record a higher activity in JP samples than ID-S. As both regions are characterized by low pH, the difference in activity may reflect the freshness of JP soils.
4.2.5 Transformation of 2:1 Type Clay Minerals In the case of TH samples, both mineralogical and thermodynamic analyses indicate that mica is relatively stable and did not transform easily into 1.4 nm minerals (Figures 4.4 and 4.6). Araki et al. [1998] investigated the weathering of Tanzanian soils, which experience a distinct dry season similar to that in Thailand, and reported the weathering of mica without the formation of 1.4 nm minerals. The authors assumed that it takes a long time, perhaps several million years, for mica to weather to kaolinite or gibbsite. According to the stability diagram, both pH and K+ activity in solution are important for the weathering of mica. Mica is more stable than kaolinite with increasing pH or K+ activity (Figure 4.6). For example, Rausell-Colom et al. [1965] demonstrated that the removal of K from micas is strongly dependent on the K concentration of the solution. In our experiment, however, K+ activity in TH extracts is almost the same as that in JP and ID-S extracts, ranging from 10 –3.8 to 10 –4.8 mol L−1 (Figures 4.6 and 4.7). This indicates that pH plays an important role in the in situ weathering of mica. The apparent limits of pH(H2O) and pH of the soil water extract in terms of mica weathering to 1.4 nm minerals are 5.0–5.5 and 5.5–6.5, respectively, above which mica is stable. In contrast, mineralogical analysis of JP and ID-S samples show the formation of 1.4-nm clay minerals such as HIV and vermiculite from mica (Figure 4.3). The stability and solubility diagrams indicate the dissolution of mica, which is interpreted in this dissolution process as 2:1 opened layers forming 1.4 nm minerals such as HIV and vermiculite as transitional products (Figures 4.6 and 4.7). In JP samples, low crystalline clay minerals and easily weathered primary minerals dissolve and release Al to the soil solution; the released Al may precipitate as Al hydroxide contaminants between 2:1 layers as well as gibbsite. The 2:1 layers of HIV are thought to be stable, probably because the buffering capacity of interlayered materials is such that it can react with acid more easily than the 2:1 layers. Such a preferential dissolution of interlayered materials in 2:1 layers is widely observed in the surface horizons of acidic forest soils [Ross and Mortland 1966; Bouma et al. 1969; Gjems 1970; Hirai et al. 1989; Funakawa et al. 1993a]. In ID-S samples, small to negligible amounts of easily weathered minerals are present in soils from a tropical rainforest climate and relatively stable landscape conditions; this indicates limited potential for acid neutralization via mineral dissolution. Accordingly, interlayered materials and gibbsite may already have dissolved preferentially to 2:1 layers and vermiculite formed. Dissolution of 2:1 layers or a reduction in layer charge may result in the formation of smectite from vermiculite [Borchardt 1989].
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
65
4.3 P EDOGENETIC ALTERATIONS OF ILLITIC MINERALS REPRESENTED BY RADIOCESIUM INTERCEPTION POTENTIAL IN SOILS WITH DIFFERENT SOIL MOISTURE REGIMES X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis normally is used to identify illitic minerals in a complex soil matrix. In some aspects, the nature of the minerals may differ from the pure illite formed in geological environments, but the XRD patterns at least indicate the presence of a K-bearing 2:1 phyllosilicate layer (i.e., an illitic layer). Computational disintegration analysis of the XRD patterns can yield a quantitative estimation of a soil’s illitic layer [Lanson 1997]; the total K content in soil clay also affords a reasonable estimate of their content, provided that K-feldspars are not present [Thompson and Ukrainczyk 2002]. Thus, we can determine the mass of illitic layers from the XRD pattern and total amount of K in clay. However, these conventional methods barely reveal the details of the nature of the illitic minerals, such as their degree of partial vermiculitization. In this section, we focused on the amount of frayed edge site as an indicator of changes in illitic minerals in soil. The weathering front in the interlayers of illitic minerals expands into a wedge shape, referred to as the frayed edge site [Sawhney 1972] (Figure 4.8). Illitic minerals reportedly enlarge the site by transformation to vermiculite [Le Roux and Rich 1969]; on the other hand, hydroxy-Al interlayering in the vermiculitic layers can reduce it at the site [Maes et al. 1999a]. The frayed edge site is characterized as having very high selectivity of Cs against hydrated cations [Brouwer et al. 1983]. Based on its selective-charge characteristics, Radiocesium interception potential (RIP) methodology was established to quantify the frayed edge site in soil [Cremers et al. 1988; Wauters et al. 1996]. The detailed methodology as well as experimental method for RIP measurement is given in the Appendix and Nakao et al. [2008].
1.0 nm
1.4 nm
K+ Hydrated cation Dehydrated cation Frayed edge site (FES) (RIP/KcFES(Cs-K)) FES + Vermiculitic expanded layer (Cs-fixed capacity)
FIGURE 4.8 Schematic illustration of the layer expansion of micaceous minerals.
66
World Soil Resources and Food Security
4.3.1 Study Soils Soils were collected from southwestern Japan (JP), northern Thailand (TH), and East Kalimantan in Indonesia (ID), representing, respectively, temperate, subtropical, and tropical climates. We used subsurface soils with B-horizon properties. Soils strongly affected by volcanic ashes, basaltic rocks, or ultramafic rocks were excluded because dioctahedral-type micas usually are uncommon in these types of parent materials. Figure 4.2 shows the monthly distributions of both rainfall and potential evapotranspiration. In total, 63 soils were sampled from 35 profiles in the three regions described above (JP, n = 21; TH, n = 19; ID, n = 23) and used for the RIP experiment as well as several soil characteristics including the acid-oxalate-extractable Fe (Feo) [McKeague and Day 1966], dithionite-citrate-bicarbonate (DCB) extracted-Fe (Fed) [Mehra and Jackson 1960], and total Fe (Fet) of the soils (for <2 mm fraction) and hot sodium citrate extracted-Al and Si (Alcit and Sicit, respectively) [Tamura 1958], total K content (TKclay), and Cs-fixed capacity of the clay fraction as indicators of interlayered materials of 2:1 minerals, clay mica content, and the vermiculitic layer [Komarneni and Roy 1980], respectively.
4.3.2 Q uantitative Mineralogical Properties, Cs-Fixed Capacity, and RIP Values Although JP soil clays usually showed a trace level 1.0 nm XRD peak after the Mg-25°C treatment compared to TH soils, as already shown in Figure 4.3, there was no significant difference in mean TKclay values between JP (27 g kg−1) and TH soil clays (33 g kg−1) and between those of JP and ID (20 g kg−1) clays (p < 0.05). This contradictive result suggests that the dominating 1.4 nm peak may overlap the 1.0 nm peak, or that the hydroxy-interlayered minerals in JP soils may occlude the illitic layers [Harris et al. 1992]. The mean kaolinite content of JP soil clays (119 g kg−1) was significantly smaller than that in the TH (409 g kg−1) and ID (482 g kg−1) soil clays, corresponding closely to the differences in the relative abundances of the 0.72 nm XRD peaks. This trend in kaolinite contents in temperate- and tropical-regions confirms common understanding [Velde 2001; Thiry 2000]. The mean Alcit in JP was significantly larger than that in TH and ID, suggesting that the HIV is more common in JP. However, unexpectedly, TH soil clays had a mean Alcit of 5.6 g kg−1, approximately half that of JP soil clays (11 g kg−1), despite the trace level of the 1.4 nm XRD peak. At the same time, the amounts of Sicit for both TH and ID were significantly larger than that for JP (p < 0.05). This might reflect the dissolution of some aluminosilicate during this extraction [Ndayiragije and Delvaux 2003]. For TH and ID, kaolinite is assumed to dissolve in the extraction. To avoid overestimating hydroxy-Al interlayering in the TH and ID samples, in the following statistical analysis we adopted the molar subtraction of Sicit from Alcit (i.e., Alcit – Sicit) in place of Alcit as the variable indicating the amount of hydroxy-Al polymers in the vermiculitic layers. The mean calculated Alcit – Sicit values for JP, TH, and ID, respectively, were 0.27, 0.04, and 0.01 mol kg–1. We note that this subtraction might underestimate the amount of hydroxy-interlayered minerals, as the interlayer spaces also might fix hydroxy-aluminosilicate in addition to hydroxy-aluminum [Sterte and Shabtai 1987].
67
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
The mean Cs-fixed capacity was highest for JP (7.5 cmolc kg–1) followed by ID (3.4 cmolc kg–1) and TH (1.3 cmolc kg–1) (p < 0.05), i.e., consistent with the relative abundances of the 1.4 nm XRD peaks. Therefore, it can be regarded as a representative value indicating the amount of vermiculitic layer charge. Thus, the Cs-fixed capacity and mineralogical properties described above agree with the mineralogical characteristics represented by XRD patterns of soil clays in each sampling region. We compared them with the RIP values in the following discussions. On the other hand, there was no significant difference in the mean values of RIP between JP (12.0 mol kg−1), TH (8.1 mol kg−1), and ID (13.4 mol kg−1). Even the minimum RIP values were larger than that of standard kaolinite (0.01 mol kg−1) and montmorillonite (0.1 mol kg−1) [Nakao et al. 2008], and those of organic soils (<0.02 mol kg−1) [Rigol et al. 2002]. Many soil clays in the present study have larger RIP values than standard illite [Montana illite, 12.6 mol kg−1; Delvaux et al. 2001].
4.3.3 Statistical Relationship between RIP and Mineralogical Properties Table 4.1 represents the Pearson correlation matrices for the mineralogical and Cs-adsorption (Cs-fixed capacity, RIP) indices. Because of the skewed distribution of RIP in each regional group, and TKclay and Cs-fixed capacity in JP, the variables TABLE 4.1 Pearson Correlation Coefficients for the Mineralogical Properties of JP, TH, and ID Soil Clays (JP)
log RIP
Kaolinite
1/TKclaya
Kaolinite 1/TKclaya Alcit − Sicit log(Cs-fixed)a DCB-oxides
−0.41 −0.59** −0.74*** 0.73*** −0.34
0.44* 0.46* −0.23 −0.40
0.55** −0.32 0.36
(TH)
log RIP
Kaolinite
Kaolinite TKclay Alcit − Sicit Cs-fixed DCB-oxides
−0.83*** 0.95*** −0.28 0.17 −0.38
Alcit – Sicit
log(Cs-Fixed)a
−0.85*** 0.50*
–0.49*
TKclay
Alcit − Sicit
Cs-Fixed
−0.77*** −0.06 −0.46* 0.01
−0.48* 0.06 −0.47*
0.42 0.57*
0.20
TKclay
Alcit − Sicit
Cs-Fixed
−0.26 −0.20
−0.02
(ID)
log RIP
Kaolinite
Kaolinite TKclay Alcit − Sicit Cs-fixed DCB-oxides
−0.59** 0.46 0.24 0.34 0.21
−0.87*** −0.21 0.16 −0.49
0.19 –0.19 0.40
Note: Significant at the *p = 0.05, **p = 0.01, and ***p = 0.001 level. a TK clay was reciprocated and Cs-fixed was transformed in the logarithm to normalize the data (JP).
68
World Soil Resources and Food Security
were normalized by either logarithmic- or reciprocating-transformation for the correlation analysis. In JP soil clays, the logarithm of RIP significantly correlated with Alcit − Sicit (r = −0.74), the logarithm of Cs-fixed capacity (r = −0.73), and 1/TKclay (r = −0.59). In TH soil clays, strong correlations existed between the logarithm of RIP and TKclay (r = 0.95) and the amount of kaolinite (r = –0.83). The two independent variables also were negatively correlated (r = −0.77). Similar to TH group, ID soil clays showed correlations between the logarithm of RIP and TKclay (r = 0.46) and the amount of kaolinite (r = −0.59), and negative correlations between the two independent variables (r = −0.87). There were three types of statistical relationships between the logarithm of RIP and the other variables: positive (TKclay and Cs-fixed capacity), negative (amount of kaolinite and Alcit − Sicit), and no correlation (amount of DCB-oxides). The negative correlations of the amount of kaolinite with the logarithm of RIP found for TH and ID reflect the enrichment of kaolinite in tropical–subtropical soils that directly decreases the proportion of illitic minerals in soil clays. The lack of a significant correlation between the logarithm of RIP and the amount of DCB-oxides in all sampling regions agrees with the findings of Dumat et al. [1997] showing that free oxides may not affect 137Cs selective adsorption on soil clays. Therefore, we do not take these two variables into account in the following discussion on alterations in illitic mineral in clays.
4.3.4 Nature of Illitic Minerals in the Three Regions in Terms of the Frayed Edge Site The absence of vermiculitic layers in TH soil clays was confirmed by the trace 1.4 nm XRD peak and the very small Cs-fixed capacity. The ustic soil moisture regime with a distinct dry season causes a higher soil pH and more K+ to be held in the solid phase than does the udic soil moisture regime [Mizota et al. 1988; Malavolta 1985], which may reduce the alteration of illitic minerals into vermiculite, as supposed in the previous section [Watanabe et al. 2006]. The strong positive correlation between the logarithm of RIP and TKclay observed for the TH soil clays indicates that the amount of the frayed edge site is related directly to the amount of illitic minerals. Therefore, it is reasonable to define the correlation line between the logarithm of RIP and TKclay in TH soil clays as being a no vermiculitization line, as depicted in Figure 4.9. The general understanding on Belgian and northwest European soils, belonging to the udic soil moisture regime [Boucneau et al. 1996], is that the amount of the frayed edge site is correlated with that of the vermiculitic layers [Delvaux et al. 2001]. Maes et al. [1999b] suggested the 137Cs-selective sites are not illitic sensu stricto, but vermiculitic layers associated with illitic interlayers in Belgian forest soils. We expect that the amount of the frayed edge site in highly vermiculitized illitic minerals might be related to the amount of the vermiculitic layers, rather than that of the illitic layers. The same may be true for the udic soils in humid Asia (i.e., JP and ID). They showed a weaker correlation between the logarithm of RIP and TKclay and a stronger one between the logarithm of RIP and Cs-fixed capacity than did the TH soil clays (Table 4.1). For ID soil clays, all logarithms of RIP values were
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
69
log (RIP) (mol kg clay–1)
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
JP TH ID 0
10
20
30
40
TKclay (g kg clay–1)
50
60
FIGURE 4.9 Scatter diagram of log RIP and TKclay. The solid line through the data for TH soil clays is a correlation line between log RIP and TKclay (r = 0.95, p < 0.001).
above the no vermiculitization line (Figure 4.9), and the mean Cs-fixed capacity was significantly larger than that for TH soil clays, although the simple correlation between the logarithm of RIP and Cs-fixed capacity was weak. Thus, apparently, in ID soils the formation of the frayed edge site through the vermiculitization of illitic minerals proceeds. As the low Alcit – Sicit and weak correlation between the logarithm of RIP and Alcit – Sicit indicate, the ID soil clays are not affected greatly by hydroxy-Al interlayering. The effect of hydroxy-Al interlayering on both illitic- and vermiculitic-layers is more important in JP than in ID soil clays. In the former, the logarithm of RIP correlated best and negatively with Alcit – Sicit, indicating that the frayed edge site is reduced with an increasing degree of hydroxy-Al interlayering. The hydroxy-Al polymers may well directly reduce the frayed edge site since some JP soil clays with a large Alcit – Sicit value were below the no vermiculitization line shown in Figure 4.9, despite there being a larger mass of vermiculitic layers in JP soil clays, represented by the Cs-fixed capacity, than in TH soil clays. Maes et al. [1999a] described such a process after investigating the decrease in magnitude of 137Cs fixation in vermiculitized biotite after artificially intercalating hydroxy-Al polymers. On the other hand, they reported the in situ transformation of illitic minerals through the release of hydroxy-Al polymers from the vermiculitic layer, as assessed in relation to 137Cs fixation in the weathering sequence from Dystric Cambisol to Haplic Podzol [Maes et al. 1999b]. The release of hydroxy-Al polymers through monomerization and complexation with organic acids can occur in highly acidic soils in southwestern Japan, as one of the representative mineralogical transformation processes occurring with podzolization [Funakawa et al. 1993a; Hirai 1995]. Pedogenetic alteration of illitic
70
World Soil Resources and Food Security
minerals in JP soils, associated with the frayed edge site, might be similar to that in soils from Belgium or northwest Europe.
4.3.5 Illite Vermiculitization and Soil Weathering The weak vermiculitization of illitic minerals in TH soil clays does not indicate that the soils are in a juvenile stage. The degree of their weathering can be assessed from the soil’s Fe status, that is, the activity ratio (Feo/Fed) and the crystallinity ratio (Fed – Feo)/Fet [Nagatsuka 1972; Arduino et al. 1986; Tsai et al. 2007]. Soil with lower Feo/Fed and higher (Fed – Feo)/Fet ratios is assumed to have been weathered more intensively. The TH soils showed relatively small Feo/Fed and large (Fed – Feo)/ Fet ratios mostly within the region of Feo/Fed < 0.4 and (Fed – Feo)/Fet > 0.5, namely the red soil region in Japan [Nagatsuka 1972]. In contrast, most JP and approximately one half the ID soils (with an elevation above 600 m) are within the region of Feo/Fed > 0.4 and (Fed – Feo)/Fet < 0.5 (the brown forest soil region), indicating that the TH soils are highly weathered relative to the latter soils. Therefore, the weak vermiculitization in TH soil clays is considered as the accumulative effect of soil development. Belgian forest soils, under well-drained conditions with an udic soil moisture regime, show prominent 1.4 nm XRD peaks [Brahy et al. 2000] that could be ascribed to the partial vermiculitization of illitic minerals. On the other hand, they have large Feo/Fed and small (Fed – Feo)/Fet ratios compared with the soils that we studied, suggesting, in terms of Fe status, that the Belgian soils are less weathered. ID soils from an elevation below 100 m have Feo/Fed and (Fed – Feo)/Fet ratios similar to those of TH soils, whereas the soils collected from around 600 m are within the region of brown forest soils, indicating that altitude largely affects the degree of soil weathering. However, it seems that the ID soil clays at both higher and lower altitudes exhibited more intense vermiculitization than that of TH soil clays. Thus, the pedogenetic alteration of illitic minerals may not correspond to the weathering stage of soils, but be strongly determined by whether the soil moisture regime is ustic or udic. The lack of relationship between soil weathering and pedogenetic alterations of illitic minerals may rest partly on the difference in the response to wet-dry repetitions. These periodic repetitions in the ustic soils enhanced weathering of primary silicates to secondary minerals (e.g., feldspar–kaolinite) [Inskeep et al. 1993]. On the other hand, wet-dry repetitions may enhance K fixation to the expanded 2:1 layers, rather than its release from illitic minerals, as shown in some laboratory experiments [Šucha and Širáńová 1991; Olk et al. 1995]. Since laboratory experiments cannot properly reproduce the in situ effect of wet-dry cycles on the pedogenetic alteration of illitic minerals, direct evidence is required, such as transformations of test illite inserted in soil in the respective regions, to clarify the effect of climate on illitic mineral alterations. Another factor might cause the RIP values in the ID soil clays and some of JP ones to be larger than expected from the amount of TKclay. Thus, chloriteto-vermiculite transformation may increase the proportion of the latter in the soil clays [Barnhisel and Bertsch 1989] and so contribute to the RIP value. However, there has been no attempt to determine whether chlorite, or vermiculite derived from it, has 137Cs selective sites like a frayed edge site. To attribute the regional
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
71
characteristics of the RIP values to pedogenetic alteration of illitic minerals, further investigations are required.
4.3.6 Weathering Sequence in Upland Soils of Humid Asia Based on the discussions so far, the mineral weathering sequence for each region is shown in Figure 4.10. In Thailand, under higher pH conditions associated with the ustic moisture regime, mica is relatively stable whereas other primary minerals such as feldspars are unstable and dissolve to form kaolinite and gibbsite. Under lower pH conditions of the udic moisture regime in Japan and Indonesia, mica weathers to form 1.4 nm minerals. Japanese soils are young and have much Al–OH species in soil solution, resulting in Al hydroxide between the 2:1 layers and gibbsite, while Al hydroxides and gibbsite have not formed or were already removed from the more highly weathered Indonesian soils. In soils derived from mica-free parent material, which for clay mineral compositions are kaolin minerals and smectite, the clay mineral composition changes to the kaolin apex along the mineral axis of the 1.4 nm minerals–kaolin. Based on the analysis of the frayed edge site as an indicator of the alteration of illitic minerals in the soil using RIP methodology, the details of vermiculitization of illitic minerals were traced for each of the regions studied, as illustrated in Figure 4.11. In TH soils, a small degree of vermiculitization was demonstrated by the direct correlation between the frayed edge site and the amount of illitic minerals, and the very small Cs-fixed capacity. Under an udic soil moisture regime, illitic minerals weather to form vermiculite, while in ID, such vermiculitization is directly reflected in the enlarging of the frayed edge site. In the case of JP, however, hydroxy-Al interlayering reduces the frayed edge site that forms through vermiculitization. The release of hydroxy-Al polymers from vermiculitic layers can induce the progressive reexposition of the frayed edge site under podzolization.
Kaolin minerals
Higher pH (Ustic)
TH
ID-S Mica-free Lower pH (Udic)
Mica
JP
1.4 nm minerals
FIGURE 4.10 Assumed mineral weathering sequence in upland soils in humid Asia.
72
World Soil Resources and Food Security Under ustic soil moisture regime
Thailand
Indonesia
Japan
Few expandable minerals are formed. Mica slowly weathers to kaolin or other secondary minerals. Under udic soil moisture regime Vermiculitization (i.e., formation of expandable 2:1 minerals) occurs due to intensive acid load to interlayered K+ Secondary Al hydrixides fill up the interlayer space along with vermiculitization and then 2:12:1:1 intergrades are formed.
FIGURE 4.11 Vermiculitization of illitic minerals under different moisture conditions.
4.4 R EGIONAL TRENDS IN THE CHEMICAL AND MINERALOGICAL PROPERTIES OF UPLAND SOILS IN HUMID ASIA WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE WRB CLASSIFICATION SCHEME Recently a new classification scheme of the world’s soils was proposed, the World Reference Base for Soil Resources (WRB) [ISSS-ISRIC-FAO 1998a, 2006]. One of the new ideas in the WRB is the introduction of clay activity (or cation exchange capacity [CEC]/clay) to classify soils in the highest category level (i.e., reference soil groups [RSG]), which is used to discriminate soils that have an argic horizon into Lixisols and Luvisols (high base saturation [>50%] soils) or Acrisols and Alisols (low base saturation [<50%] soils). Upland soils in humid Asia are predominantly acidic because of excessive precipitation and, hence, Acrisols and Alisols are in the major RSGs if argic horizons are recognized [ISSS-ISRIC-FAO 1998b]. The regional distribution patterns of these two soils remain, however, controversial in this region, and there is very little data on which to base any discussion. Although both Acrisols and Alisols are acidic and agricultural production is strongly restricted on these soils [FAO 2001], higher CEC/clay values in Alisols indicate that the levels of exchangeable and soluble Al achieve toxic quantities and cause more serious constraints for agricultural use in Alisols than in Acrisols. It is necessary to understand the regional distribution patterns of the two soils with reference to pedogenetic factors, such as geology and climate. As discussed in the preceding sections, different pathways of weathering of illitic minerals were postulated in our study. Since it is generally known that the presence of expandable 2:1 minerals strongly affects soil properties such as cation exchange capacity (CEC), regional distribution patterns of Acrisols and Alisols are possibly regulated by soil moisture regimes through difference in the mineral weathering sequences.
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
73
4.4.1 Soils Studied A total of 186 B-horizon soils from upland soil profiles with minimum disturbance (i.e., under forest or cropland with low-input management), a majority of which is overlapped with the samples used in Section 4.2, were used for the analysis in this section. These soils are grouped into seven categories based on pedogenetic conditions (Table 4.2). According to Figure 4.1, a large part of East Asia is situated under either ustic, udic or perudic soil moisture regimes and, hence, the present study was considered to cover major soils in terms of soil moisture conditions. As soils derived from intermediate to mafic volcanic rocks and limestone are considered to exhibit different properties, judging from the results presented in a previous section, they are separated from the other soils and grouped as mafic. These soils were derived mainly from volcanic rocks in the Java and Sumatra Islands of Indonesia (ID-V soils in Section 4.2), and partly from limestone in northern Thailand and mafic intrusive rocks in Japan. The sample groups of IDL and IDH comprise soils derived from sedimentary rocks (mostly sandstone and mudstone) or felsic materials in low (<600 m) and high (>600 m) elevation areas of Indonesia, respectively, and equivalent to the ID-S soils in Section 4.2. Although both elevation areas would be classified as having a hyperthermic soil temperature regime according to the U.S. Taxonomy [Soil Survey Staff 2006], they are divided into two groups in the present study because the percolation of organic matter into the B-horizon soils is apparently more extensive at elevations above 600 m according to soil survey results, presumably because of the extremely humid conditions (i.e., perudic soil moisture regime) there. The THL and THH soils, equivalent to the TH soils in Section 4.2, were collected from Thailand, mostly from the northern mountainous region, which has a monsoon climate. The border of the two groups is approximately 800 m above sea level, above which there is predominately evergreen forest, presumably because of decreasing water stress during the dry season. The soil temperature regimes of THL and THH are hyperthermic and thermic, respectively. A wide variety of sedimentary rocks and granite make up most of the parent materials of these soils. The JPS and JPN soils, equivalent to the JP soils in Section 4.2, were collected from warm and cool temperate forests in Japan and, therefore, the soil temperature regimes of these soils were thermic and mesic. The parent materials are predominantly sedimentary rocks (predominantly mudstone with minor occurrences of sandstone and shale) and partly felsic igneous rocks. Soils strongly affected by volcanic ejecta were not included in the samples. General physicochemical properties of the soils collected were analyzed. The CEC derived solely from mineral components (CECmin) was calculated by eliminating the contribution of organic C [see details in Funakawa et al. 2008].
4.4.2 Regional Trend in the General Physicochemical and Mineralogical Properties of the Soils The average values of selected chemical and mineralogical properties of the B-horizon soils from different regions, with ANOVA results, are summarized in
74
TABLE 4.2 Average Values of Selected Chemical and Mineralogical Properties of the Soils from Different Regions Clay Mineral Composition pH(H2O) Sample Group
Number of Samples
AVE
Clay
SE
AVE
Total C
CECmin/Clay
a
SE
AVE
(%)
SE
AVE
(g kg−1)
Fed
SE
AVE
(cmolc kg−1)
1.4 nm
a
SE
AVE
(g kg−1)
1.0 nm
SE
AVE
(%)
0.7 nm
SE
AVE
(%)
SE
(%)
Sorted by regions and parent materials 39
4.58
0.07
a
38.6
2.1
ab
5.4
0.5
a
32.4
1.5
bc
20.7
1.5
a
37
3
b
7
1
ab
56
3
cd
IDH
10
4.52
0.06
a
34.0
2.3
ab
6.5
1.0
ab
45.2
2.9
d
22.1
3.1
abc
37
5
b
18
4
abc
45
4
bc
THL
40
5.44
0.07
c
53.0
2.3
c
9.6
0.5
bc
22.2
1.3
a
37.3
2.6
cd
4
1
a
31
3
c
66
3
de
THH
24
5.50
0.09
c
47.2
3.2
bc
14.6
2.0
c
25.7
1.4
ab
40.8
5.0
bcd
12
2
a
17
4
b
71
4
ef
JPS
30
4.71
0.04
ab
35.1
2.4
a
12.9
2.6
bc
40.0
2.1
d
23.6
2.6
ab
58
4
c
11
2
ab
31
3
b
JPN
20
4.59
0.05
a
47.1
1.9
bc
33.4
3.0
d
39.9
2.2
cd
34.0
1.9
bcd
80
3
d
9
2
ab
11
2
a
mafic
23
5.02
0.16
b
66.5
2.3
d
11.2
0.9
bc
31.4
2.9
bc
65.4
6.7
d
14
5
a
4
3
a
81
5
f
Sorted by reference soil groups Andosols
4
4.66
0.06
ab
50.9
1.7
ab
46.0
5.8
c
31.2
4.8
ab
30.4
2.2
a
83
3
c
9
3
ab
8
1
a
Podzols
6
4.38
0.09
a
43.7
2.1
ab
33.3
3.6
c
43.4
2.5
b
42.0
1.6
a
75
5
c
15
5
ab
10
1
a
Acrisols
32
5.28
0.09
b
56.4
2.6
b
9.4
0.7
ab
18.1
0.8
a
39.1
4.1
a
6
1
a
25
3
b
70
4
c
Alisols
64
4.76
0.06
a
45.7
1.8
a
6.8
0.5
a
33.2
1.1
b
31.6
2.5
a
33
3
b
9
1
a
57
3
bc
Luvisols and Lixisols
9
5.81
0.20
c
56.3
7.0
ab
9.9
1.3
ab
30.9
4.0
b
47.8
7.5
a
6
3
ab
15
7
ab
79
7
bc
Cambisols
71
4.95
0.07
ab
41.0
1.9
a
15.7
1.5
b
36.2
1.6
b
32.6
3.0
a
39
4
b
15
2
a
46
4
b
All
186
4.96
0.04
46.3
1.2
12.5
0.8
31.9
0.9
34.4
1.7
32
2
14
1
54
2
Note: The values with the same letters are not significantly different by Tukey test (p < 0.05). AVE, average; SE, standard error. a ANOVA was applied after logarithmic transformation for normalizing dataset.
World Soil Resources and Food Security
IDL
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
75
Table 4.2. Although clay mica was always the dominant component in the 1.0-nm minerals, judging from virtually no expansion of the 1.0-nm diffraction peak after glycerol solvation as well as a clear diffraction peak remaining after 550°C heating in our samples, there is a possibility that halloysite is a minor component. As shown in Table 4.2 and Figure 4.12, the majority of soils were acidic. Base saturation (by CEC at pH 7) is usually below 50%. Among the B-horizon soils, soils from the ustic soil moisture regime in Thailand show significantly higher pH(H2O) values. Some soils from mafic parent materials also exhibit higher base saturation above 50% (Figure 4.12). According to Table 4.2, Alisols and Podzols are strongly acidic, followed by Andosols, Cambisols, and Acrisols. As for clay content, the soils from Indonesia are less clayey than those from Thailand or from mafic parent materials. Total C content clearly increases as soil temperature decreases in the following order: IDL, IDH, THL (hyperthermic) < THH, JPS (thermic) < JPN (mesic). The values of CECmin/clay are plotted together with ECEC/clay (effective CEC [sum of exchangeable bases and Al] divided by clay content) or exchangeable Al/clay in Figure 4.13. The CECmin/clay of the soils derived from sedimentary rocks (excluding limestone) or felsic materials showed a clear regional trend; that is, it was usually higher than 24 cmolc kg−1 (corresponding to Alisols if the argic horizon is recognized) under the udic or perudic soil moisture regimes in Indonesia (IDL and IDH) and Japan (JPS and JPN), whereas it was predominantly lower than 24 cmolc kg−1 (corresponding to Acrisols) under the ustic soil moisture regime in Thailand (THL). The values of THH soils are occasionally higher than 24 cmolc kg−1, presumably because the more percolating soil moisture conditions in high mountains result in similar conditions to the udic soil moisture conditions. Most of the cation exchange sites represented by ECEC seem to be occupied by exchangeable Al (Figure 4.13b) and, therefore, the level of Al toxicity should be higher in the soils from the udic or perudic soil moisture regimes of Indonesia and Japan compared with those from the ustic soil moisture regime of Thailand. Similarly high CEC/clay values were reported for soils with an udic soil moisture regime, for example, 34.0 and 26.3 cmolc kg−1 in
Base saturation (%)
100
r = 0.70 (n = 186, p < 0.01)
80 60 40
IDL IDH THL THH JPS JPN mafic
Base saturation = 50%
20 0
4
5
pH(H2O)
6
7
FIGURE 4.12 Acidity and base saturation of the soils studied.
76
World Soil Resources and Food Security
ECEC/clay (cmolc kg–1)
(a)
CECmin/clay = 24 cmolc kg–1
60
IDL IDH THL THH JPS JPN mafic
40 20 0
0
20
40
CECmin/clay (cmolc (b) Exch. Al/clay (cmolc kg–1)
1:1
60
CECmin/clay = 24 cmolc kg–1
60
80
kg–1) 1:1 For Acrisols and Alisols y = 0.52x – 3.57 r2 = 0.48, n = 96
40 20 0
0
20
40
60
CECmin/clay (cmolc kg–1)
80
IDL IDH THL THH JPS JPN mafic
FIGURE 4.13 Characteristics of the cation exchange capacity (CEC) of the soils. CECmin/ clay, CEC value per unit clay content; ECEC/clay, effective CEC (sum of exchangeable bases and Al), divided by clay content.
subsoil layers of upland soils in northern Sarawak, Malaysia [Tanaka et al. 2005], or average values of 34.7 and 41.2 cmolc kg−1 for 25 and 17 upland soils, respectively, in southern Sarawak, Malaysia [Tanaka et al. 2007]. In contrast, for soils with an ustic soil moisture regime, lower values of CEC/clay were often reported. Toriyama et al. [2007] reported the CEC/clay values for subsoils of well-drained Acrisols in central Cambodia (60–100 m above sea level) to be approximately 10 cmolc kg−1. According to Watanabe et al. [2004], the clay mineralogy and CEC/clay values in upland soils in northern Laos (600–1100 m above sea level) were essentially similar to our results in that illite and kaolinite were dominant in the clay fraction, and the values of CEC/ clay of the B-horizon soils were almost equal to or lower than the threshold value (i.e., 24 cmolc kg−1). All these reports indicate that our results obtained in some limited regions in humid Asia can be applied to different countries with similar geological or climatic conditions. The relationship obtained between CECmin/clay and exchangeable Al/clay for Acrisols and Alisols (i.e., exchangeable Al/clay = −3.57 + 0.52 CECmin/clay) is close to that reported in FAO [2001] for soils in Indonesia, the Caribbean region, Rwanda,
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
77
Cameroon, Peru, and Colombia; that is, Al/clay = −1.28 + 0.64 CEC/clay. Thus, the overall properties of Al retention and perhaps of the proportion of permanent and variable negative charges of the soils in the present study are considered to be similar to those in Acrisols and Alisols from other regions. There is a unique characteristic of the soils derived from mafic parent materials compared to the soils from sedimentary rocks (excluding limestone) or felsic volcanic materials; these soils are more variable in pH (Figure 4.12) or CECmin/clay (Figure 4.13a). According to Figure 4.13b, the majority of the soils do not retain appreciable amounts of exchangeable Al, even when the value of CECmin/clay is high. One reason for this must be the relatively higher pH and base saturation for some soils (Figure 4.12). Another possible explanation is that variable negative charges derived from free oxide surfaces can contribute to the apparent increase of CEC at higher pH ranges (i.e., 7), and the actual CEC at the lower pH range at which Al can dominate is small. Variation in the chemical properties of soils derived from mafic materials (including limestone) in Java Island was also reported by Supriyo et al. [1992b].
4.4.3 Relationship between Clay Mineral Composition and Cation Exchange Capacity in the Soils It is widely known that clay mineralogical properties of soils strongly affect soil physicochemical properties. In fact, the CECmin/clay in the present study is influenced by the relative abundance of 1.4 nm minerals in the clay fraction (Figure 4.14a). The following equation is obtained:
CECmin/clay (cmolc kg−1) = 0.201 × (1.4 nm minerals in %) + 25.5
(r 2 = 0.24, p < 0.01).
(4.1)
This equation suggests that the 1.4 nm minerals contribute to a CEC increase of 20.1 cmolc kg–1. As most of the 2:1 minerals in the Japanese soils are modified by hydroxy-interlayered materials [Hirai 1995; Kitagawa 2005], the CEC values of these soils could be estimated to be lower than the possible negative charge derived from the 2:1 lattice structure [Funakawa et al. 2003]. On the contrary, among soils with the lowest amounts of expandable 2:1 minerals (e.g., Thai soils), the relative contribution of other mineral components increases, and the CECmin attributable to the 1.4 nm minerals should be appreciably lower than the value of the intercept of the equation, that is, 25.5 cmolc kg−1. As a result, the actual contribution of expandable 2:1 minerals to CEC may be considerably higher than 20.1 cmolc kg−1 clay. Thus, the CEC of the upland soils in humid Asia is primarily determined by the relative abundance of expandable 2:1 minerals, in which exchangeable Al is dominant as represented by the equation: Exch. Al/clay = –3.57 + 0.52 CECmin/clay.
4.4.4 Relationship between Clay Mineral Composition and Soil pH Soil pH is an important index that affects a wide range of agronomical and environmental functions of soils [Robson 1989]. In our present study, a negative correlation
78
World Soil Resources and Food Security (a)
80
CECmin/clay (cmolc kg–1)
r = 0.49 (n = 186, p < 0.01) 60 y = 0.201x + 25.5 r2 = 0.24
40
20 CECmin/clay = 24 cmolc kg–1 0
20
40
60
80
100
Relative abundance of 1.4 nm minerals (%)
(b) Relative abundance of 1.4 nm minerals (%)
0
IDL IDH THL THH JPS JPN mafic
100 80
r = –0.46 (n = 186, p < 0.01) IDL IDH THL THH JPS JPN mafic
60 40 20 0
4
5
6
7
pH(H2O)
FIGURE 4.14 Relationship between mineralogical composition and chemical properties of the soils. Relationships between relative abundances of expandable 1.4-nm minerals in clay fraction and (a) CECmin/clay and (b) pH(H2O) of soils.
is observed between the relative abundance of 1.4 nm minerals and soil pH (Figure 4.14b), and the following equation is obtained:
pH(H2O) = 5.06 – 0.00803 × (1.4 nm minerals [%]) + 0.00451 × (Fed [g kg–1])
(r 2 = 0.23, p < 0.01).
(4.2)
As most of the soils studied are acidic and base saturation is lower than 50%, the dominant cation retained on the cation exchange sites of soils is Al3+. The equation above indicates that the presence of expandable 2:1 minerals contributes to pH reduction by 0.008 units per clay percentage. In solution, the Al3+ ion behaves as a weak acid through a hydrolytic reaction: that is, Al3+ + OH− = Al(OH)2+ (pKa = 5.0), and soils rich in exchangeable Al show a distinct buffer zone against OH− addition during
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
79
titration [Funakawa et al. 1993b]. The strong acidity far below pH 5.0 of some soils must be affected by the presence of a stronger acid(s), that is, H+, although quantitative analysis of exchangeable H+ is difficult, and the selectivity coefficient between Al3+ and H+ ions on the permanent negative sites of soils is rarely determined. In contrast, the oxide surfaces represented by the Fed fraction are considered to increase soil pH by 0.00451 units per g Fed kg−1 soil. As is well known, the oxide surfaces act as weak acids that have a zero point of charge (ZPC) of approximately 6–9 [McBride 1989]. In lower pH regions, it might mitigate H+ in solution through the protonation reaction: M–OH + H+ = M − OH +2 , where M represents the metal ions (Fe, Al) at the surface of the soil particles, and thereby contributes to increased soil pH. Soils derived from mafic volcanic materials are often rich in the Fed fraction, which was originally inherent in the parent materials, and soil pH was relatively high (Table 4.2). In humid Asia, the major distribution of the mafic parent materials is generally limited to specific regions, such as the volcanic belts of Java and Sumatra Islands. In the humid tropics of other continents, for example, eastern Latin America or equatorial Africa, however, mafic materials cover wider regions. It can be said that acid mitigation by oxide surfaces is relatively limited in humid Asia, unlike in other continents. The general results obtained in the present study are considered to be specific for some regions of humid Asia, in which sedimentary rocks or felsic volcanic materials are the dominant parent materials of the soils.
4.4.5 Classification of the Soils Examined According to WRB and Its Relationship to Mineral Weathering Conditions Table 4.3 summarizes the classification of the soils examined according to WRB [ISSS-ISRIC-FAO 2006]. The RSGs to which mafic soils are classified as diverse, including Alisols, Acrisols, Luvisols, and Cambisols. More detailed surveys focusing on the relationship between parent materials or primary minerals and properties of the soils that developed there are necessary. Most of the members of IDL and IDH belong to Alisols according to WRB, except for those on relatively steep slopes in high mountains that are classified as Cambisols (dystric) because of a lack of a clear argic horizon. Higher soluble Al3+ in Alisols may be a more serious constraint for agricultural production compared with Acrisols. In contrast, Acrisols are dominant in THL, whereas the proportion of Alisols and Cambisols (dystric) increased in THH. In Japan, the majority of the soils are Cambisols (dystric) and some from JPS are Alisols. In JPN, some soils are classified into Andosols or Podzols because of the relatively high influence of amorphous materials under cool temperate climates and/or the presence of nearby active volcanoes. It should be noted that no extremely weathered soils such as Ferralsols or Plinthosols were found in the present study, although it is necessary to extend future surveys to whole regions of humid Asia, especially to the relatively stable plains of Northeast Thailand, and to central Cambodia. Thus, of the 186 soil samples, only nine and eight soils are classified into Luvisols (or Lixisols) and Cambisols (eutric), respectively, indicating that the upland soils in humid Asia are predominantly acidic. In the preceding sections, dioctahedral mica inherent to sedimentary rocks or felsic igneous rocks was thought to weather to form
80
TABLE 4.3 Summary of the Classification of the Soils According to the World Reference Base Number of Soils Classified into Different RSG Cambisols Sample Group
Number of Samples 39 10 40 24 30 20 23 186
Andosols
Podzols
Alisols
Acrisols
Luvisols (or Lixisols)
(Dystric)
(Eutric)
0 0 0 0 0 4 0 4
0 0 0 0 0 6 0 6
34 5 5 6 7 0 7 64
2 0 20 6 0 0 4 32
0 0 3 (1) 1 0 0 4 9
2 5 9 9 23 10 5 63
1 0 2 2 0 0 3 8
World Soil Resources and Food Security
IDL IDH THL THH JPS JPN mafic Total
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
81
expandable 2:1 minerals, that is, vermiculitization, under the lower pH conditions associated with the udic or perudic soil moisture regime. In contrast, mica is relatively stable under the higher pH conditions associated with the ustic soil moisture regime, whereas other primary minerals, such as feldspars, are unstable and dissolve to form kaolin minerals and gibbsite. These processes should be critically analyzed further considering the possibility of selective dissolution of interlayered K+ ion of mica under acidic conditions from a clay mineralogical viewpoint [see Fanning et al. 1989]. Our finding in the present study suggests that the regional distribution patterns of Acrisols and Alisols in humid Asia are strongly related to pedogenetic conditions through clay mineral formation. In turn, such a close relationship suggests that the soils in humid Asia are predominantly on the course of pedogenesis under the present bio-climatic conditions, probably unlike tropical soils on plains in other continents. Thus, it was observed that chemical and mineralogical properties of soils and associated ecosystem processes in humid Asia were largely different depending on geological and climatic conditions. In the following sections, soil fertility status is first analyzed in terms of soil acidity and SOM-related properties and then conventional cropping systems in different regions (e.g., shifting cultivation and home garden management), are comparatively evaluated from the viewpoint of human adaptation to respective soil environments under low-input conditions.
4.5 F ACTORS CONTROLLING POTENTIALLY MINERALIZABLE AND RECALCITRANT SOIL ORGANIC MATTER IN HUMID ASIA SOM has been traditionally regarded as one of the key components for maintaining the soil fertility of agricultural land. However, in relation to the problem of global warming, considerable attention has recently been focused on SOM dynamics as both a possible source and sink of carbon dioxide. In this context, very many attempts have been made to quantitatively simulate SOM dynamics using models such as CENTURY [Parton et al. 1987] and RothC [Jenkinson 1990], which have proved successful under certain environmental conditions. Generally these models were developed under mild climatic conditions such as a temperate climate with rather dry conditions, where steppe vegetation or rain-fed cereal cropping provides relatively stable C fluxes. It is, therefore, still questionable whether such simulations can directly apply to SOM dynamics under highly fluctuating conditions, which are very common in the humid tropics due to conversion of land use from forest to cropland or vice versa. Recently, models with conceptual SOM fractions have been improved by using functional SOM pools determined by physical and chemical fractionation methods [e.g., Shirato et al. 2004; Zimmermann et al. 2006]. These methods, however, do not yield homogeneous SOM pools with respect to the turnover rates [von Lützow et al. 2007]. One of the methods used to determine the turnover rate of the SOM pool is decomposition. Soils are incubated for several months under constant and favorable conditions for microbes. The released CO2 and/or mineral N are measured and fitted to first-order kinetics to calculate the rate constant and potentially mineralizable carbon (PMC) or nitrogen (PMN) [e.g., Stanford and Smith 1972]. To investigate the relationship between the potentially mineralizable OM and other soil properties,
82
World Soil Resources and Food Security
including SOM fractions and climatic conditions, Kadono et al. [2008] tested 41 surface soils in the Eurasian steppe and concluded that PMC and PMN could be determined by light fraction-organic matter (LF-OM), clay content and soil pH. On the other hand, recalcitrant organic C (ROC) and N (RON), equivalent to the difference between the total organic C (OC) or nitrogen (ON) content and the PMC content (or PMN content), comprise most of the slowly decomposing SOM group. To understand the mechanism of C sequestration in soil, the factors controlling ROC and RON need to be determined. In humid Asia, including Thailand, Indonesia, and Japan, however, there is a wide variety of soils under different climatic conditions and with different parent materials. In general, humid regions are characterized by a mean annual precipitation (MAP) to potential evapotranspiration ratio greater than 0.65 [Middleton and Thomas 1992] and covered by forest ecosystems (i.e., natural vegetation). Although these regions are important in terrestrial C and N cycles, owing to the vast stock in vegetation and rapid C turnover between the vegetation, atmosphere, and SOM, the factors controlling potentially mineralizable and recalcitrant OM in this region have not been studied in detail. In addition, this area is also characterized by the presence of volcanos and is covered by volcanic parent materials. Although the relatively higher soil organic carbon (SOC) stock in the volcanic soils results from a higher amount of active metals (e.g., Al and Fe) in the amorphous clay minerals [Hiradate et al. 2004], the contribution to potentially mineralizable OM and recalcitrant OM has not been clearly determined. In the present study, we tested soil samples from humid regions in Asia to reveal the relationships between potentially mineralizable OM, recalcitrant OM, and soil and meteorological properties.
4.5.1 Soils Studied A total of 89 surface soil samples (0–10 cm) were collected from Japan (n = 26), northern Thailand (n = 9), and Indonesia (n = 54), covering a range of climatic conditions and parent materials. In Japan, forest sites (n = 14) were selected in the west with varying vegetation and management (seminatural evergreen broadleaved forest, and mixed and fallow forests), and cropland sites (n = 12) were selected to cover a range of climates (from cool temperate to subtropical) and agricultural uses (paddy fields and upland cultivation). Parent materials in the forest sites included tephra, rhyolite, and sedimentary rocks, whereas in the cropland sites the parent materials included peat, tephra, sedimentary rocks, and alluvial materials. Detailed information about the Japanese cropland sites was given in Sano et al. [2004]. In northern Thailand, soils were sampled from forest fallow sites under shifting cultivation at various altitudes. The parent material of the lowland (<180 m) sites was sedimentary rock, whereas the parent material of the highland (>1000 m) sites was granite. All nine sampling sites in Thailand were classified as forest sites in the present study. In Indonesia, soil sampling was conducted on Java, Sumatra, and Borneo Islands in areas with varying parent materials (e.g., sedimentary rocks, volcanic rocks, limestone, and tephra) and land uses (e.g., natural tropical rainforest, secondary, or fallow forest and cultivated land). Thirty-seven sites were classified as forest sites and 17 sites were cropland sites.
83
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
The sampling sites were categorized into two land uses, namely cropland (n = 29) and forest (n = 60). The forest sites included tropical rainforests, deciduous forests, mixed forests, secondary forests, and fallow forests under shifting cultivation. Fresh soil samples were used to determine PMC and PMN (see details in Appendix) in addition to conventional determination of general physicochemical properties of the soils using air-dried samples. The contents of the light fraction (LF) and the heavy fraction (HF) were also determined with density fractionation using sodium iodide solution (1.60 g cm−3) and centrifugation at 2600 g [modified from Spycher et al. 1983].
4.5.2 Soil Properties and a Comparison of Land Use The average soil properties for all the land uses are shown in Table 4.4. Higher coefficients of variation (CV) were observed for variables of SOM and were well explained
TABLE 4.4 Averages and Coefficients of Variation for Soil Properties in Different Land-Use Systems Total (n = 89) TC TN TC/TN pH Sand Silt Clay LFW LFC LFN LF C/N HFC HFN HF C/N LFC/TC LFN/TN Sio Feo Alo
(g C kg soil) (g N kg−1 soil) −1
(%) (%) (%) (%) (g C kg−1 soil) (g N kg−1 soil) (g C kg−1 soil) (g N kg−1 soil) (%) (%) (g kg−1) (g kg−1) (g kg−1)
Cropland (n = 29)
Forest (n = 60)
AVE
CV (%)
AVE
AVE
49.5 3.4 14.7 5.2 42 25 33 2.1 5.8 0.26 24.7 43.7 3.1 14 11.9 7.6 1.9 8.1 7.9
69 62 28 17 48 39 49 89 93 99 30 70 62 30 76 89 279 98 141
30.8b 2.2b 14.6a 5.7a 46a 23a 31a 0.9b 1.9b 0.09b 25.5a 28.9b 2.1b 14.2a 7.3b 4.6b 3.4a 8.1a 9.0a
58.5a 3.9a 14.8a 5.0b 41a 25a 34a 2.6a 7.6a 0.34a 24.3a 50.8a 3.6a 14.0a 14.1a 9.1a 1.1a 8.2a 7.4a
Note: For each variable for land use, a different letter in the same row indicates a significant difference (p < 0.05). AVE, average; CV, coefficient of variation; TC, total organic carbon; TN, total nitrogen; LFW, LF content of the soil weight; LFC and LFN, carbon and nitrogen contents in LF, respectively; HFC and HFN, carbon and nitrogen contents in HF, respectively; Sio, Feo, Alo, acid oxalate soluble Si, Fe and Al, respectively.
84
World Soil Resources and Food Security
by differences in the land use. Significantly higher amounts of SOM accumulated in forest sites than in cropland sites. Total C and TN in the forest sites (58.5 g C kg−1 and 3.9 g N kg−1, respectively) were 1.9-fold and 1.8-fold the TC and TN in the cropland sites (30.8 g C kg−1 and 2.2 g N kg−1, respectively), whereas the TC/TN ratio did not differ with land use. Although the total variation in the pH values was relatively low, variation in the pH values for different land uses was observed in the present study. Soil texture did not differ with land use. The LF-OM was only 2.1% of the whole soil by weight, and LFC and LFN accounted for 11.9% of TC and 7.6% of TN, respectively. The LF-OM in the forest sites was approximately 4-fold larger than that in the cropland sites, and LFC/TC in the forest sites (14.1%) was higher than LFC/TC in the cropland sites (7.3%). Light-fraction C/N and HF C/N did not differ with land use. Properties relating to amorphous oxides (Sio, Feo, and Alo) had the highest CV, owing to the presence of samples with extremely high values; the maximum values recorded for Sio, Feo, and Alo content were 31 g kg−1, 53 g kg−1, and 57 g kg−1, respectively. There were 14 samples with Alo + 1/2Feo contents greater than 20 g kg−1, 10 of which were classified as Andisols. The higher pH in the cropland sites (5.7) than in the forest sites (5.0) results from liming in crop production.
4.5.3 Amounts of PMC and PMN and the Rate Constants for the Different Land-Use Systems As eight samples had kC values of <0.003, the total number of samples fitted to the equations was 81. The PMC amounts of 69 samples were fitted to the first-order equation, six samples were fitted to the double first-order equation, and six samples were fitted to the Gompertz equation. The PMN of 37 samples were fitted to the firstorder equation, 24 samples were fitted to the Gompertz equation, and 23 samples were fitted to the logistic equation. Five samples did not converge for any of the three equations. The average amounts of PMC and PMN and the proportions of total organic C and N for all the soils and for each land use are shown in Table 4.5. The PMC and PMN had high CV (92% and 85%, respectively), which is partly explained by land use. In the present study, both PMC and LFC in the forest sites were approximately 4-fold higher than in the cropland sites, whereas the difference in PMN with land use (2.4-fold) was not so conspicuous as LFN (4-fold). As the PMC/PMN in the forest sites (26.0) was similar to the LF C/N (24.7, n = 89), whereas PMC/PMN in the cropland sites (12.6) was much closer to the HF C/N (14.0, n = 89), the major source of potentially mineralizable OM might differ with land use, that is, LF-OM in the forest sites and HF-OM in the cropland sites.
4.5.4 Estimation of PMC and PMN by Stepwise Linear Regression Using the Five Identified Factors by Principal Component Analysis The soil pH, sand, silt and clay content, LFC, LFN, HFC, HFN, C/N ratio of the LF and HF, Sio, Feo, Alo, MAT, and MAP were summarized as five factors by principal component analysis. Based on a correlation between the factors and variables, these factors were named LF, amorphous, clay, humid and warm, and C/N (Table 4.6).
85
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
TABLE 4.5 Average Amounts for Potentially Mineralizable Organic Carbon and Potentially Mineralizable Organic Nitrogen, Their Proportions in Total C and Total N, and Their Rate Constants for Different Land-Use Systems Total PMC kC (Fi) PMC/ TC PMN kN (Fi) PMN/TN PMC/PMN
(mg C kg−1) (d−1) (%) (mg N kg−1) (d−1) (%)
Cropland
Forest
n
AVE
CV (%)
n
AVE
n
AVE
81 69 81 84 37 84 77
3878 0.010 8.1 200 0.012 7.1 21.8
92 56 59 85 58 87 89
27 24 27 26 12 26 24
1261b 0.012a 5.1b 100b 0.009a 7.3a 12.6b
54 45 54 58 25 58 53
5186a 0.009a 9.6a 244a 0.013a 7.1a 26.0a
Note: For each variable for land use, a different letter indicates a significant difference (p < 0.05). AVE, average; CV, coefficient of variation; TC, total organic carbon; TN, total nitrogen; PMC and PMN, potentially mineralizable C and N, respectively; kC (Fi) and kN (Fi), rate constants for PMC and PMN that were fitted with the first-order equation, respectively.
TABLE 4.6 Correlation Matrix between the Factors and Soil Properties Variable pH Sand Silt Clay LFC LFN LF C/N HFC HFN HF C/N Sio Feo Alo MAT MAP Proportion (%)
PC1 −0.55** −0.04 0.14 −0.03 0.93** 0.93** −0.26* 0.71** 0.70** 0.15 −0.03 0.09 0.19 −0.27* 0.20 22 LF
PC2
PC3
PC4
PC5
−0.08 0.07 0.13 −0.16 −0.06 0.00 −0.23* 0.43** 0.44** 0.03 0.87** 0.86** 0.94** −0.24* 0.08 20 Amorphous
0.02 −0.98** 0.66** 0.84** −0.01 −0.07 0.28** 0.34** 0.36** −0.14 −0.21* 0.16 −0.14 −0.14 0.07 17 Clay
−0.17 0.01 −0.34** 0.19 −0.01 −0.09 0.34** −0.23* −0.16 −0.19 −0.03 −0.03 −0.09 0.75** 0.84** 11 Humid and warm
−0.20 0.02 0.13 −0.10 0.00 −0.15 0.60** 0.11 −0.12 0.83** −0.16 0.15 −0.07 −0.07 0.01 8 C/N
Note: Significant correlation coefficients at **p < 0.01 and *p < 0.05. LFC and LFN, C and N contents in the light fraction, HFC and HFN, C and N contents in the heavy fraction; Sio, Feo and Alo, acid oxalate soluble Si, Fe and Al, respectively, MAP, mean annual precipitation, MAT, mean annual temperature.
86
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Using linear regression analysis with the stepwise method, PMC and PMN were estimated by the five identified factors as follows:
PMC (mg C kg−1) = 4044 + 2629 × (LF factor) + 1072 × (clay factor) + 751 × (humid and warm factor)
(n = 81, r 2 = 0.63**)
PMN (mg N kg−1) = 201 + 67 × (LF factor) + 53 × (clay factor)
(n = 84, r 2 = 0.26**).
(4.3)
(4.4)
As the factor scores are standardized values, the coefficient for each factor indicates the relative contribution of the factor in each equation. Compared with the clay factor, the LF factor showed a larger contribution to PMC than to PMN; the coefficient of the LF factor was 2.5-fold larger than that of the clay factor in PMC and 1.3-fold larger in PMN. Similar to the Eurasian steppe soils [Kadono et al. 2008], the LF factor had a larger contribution to PMC and PMN than the clay factor in the present study. This results from the labile nature of LF-OM compared with the clay-associating OM. There are several reports stating that the LF is enriched in carbohydrates relative to both the whole soil and the HF [Dalal and Henry 1988; Murayama et al. 1979; Oades 1972; Whitehead et al. 1975]. Von Lützow [2007] reviewed articles on the turnover times of different SOM fractions separated by physical fractionation schemes and showed that the stability of OM increased from the free LF (or free particulate OM [POM]) to the occluded LF (or POM) and further to mineral-associating SOM. The humid and warm factor contributed positively to PMC in the present study. This results from the higher NPP in the higher MAT and MAP sites. A strong correlation between NPP and MAP has been reported for sites with less than approximately 3000 mm year−1 precipitation [Gower 2002].
4.5.5 Estimation of PMC and PMN by Stepwise Linear Regression Using Soil Properties Representing the Five Identified Factors Using linear regression analysis with the stepwise method, PMC was estimated by LFC (mg C kg−1), Alo (g kg−1), clay (%), MAP (mm), and HF C/N as representative variables of the five factors. The following equation was obtained:
PMC (mg C kg−1) = −2942 + 0.46 × LFC (mg C kg−1) + 41.5 × clay (%) + 1.2 × MAP (mm)
(n = 81, r 2 = 0.58**).
(4.5)
Similarly, a regression analysis was conducted for PMN. The equation obtained by this method was as follows:
PMN (mg N kg−1) = 10.0 + 0.24 × LFN (mg N kg−1) + 3.9 × clay (%)
(n = 84, r 2 = 0.25**).
(4.6)
87
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
According to these equations, scatter plots between the measured and estimated PMC and PMN values are shown in Figure 4.15. As shown in the equations, PMC and PMN could be estimated by LFC, LFN, clay content, and MAP. Amorphous oxide (Alo) did not contribute to PMC and PMN. The coefficients of clay content in Equations 4.5 and 4.6 indicated that 1% of clay contributed to 41.5 mg C kg−1 of PMC and 3.9 mg N kg−1 of PMN, respectively. This might suggest that clay-associated OM was partially decomposable and/or clay-occluded LF-OM was mineralizable. As von Lützow et al. [2007] reported that the 14C mean residence time of the clay fraction ranged from 75 to 4409 years, clay-associated OM shows a wide range of decomposability and might be a mixture of labile and recalcitrant OM. As the clay content did not differ with land use, the difference in the amount of PMC and PMN between the forest and cropland sites is attributed to the LF-OM. Therefore, the lower content of LF-OM in the cropland sites results from the relatively higher contribution of clayassociating OM to PMC and PMN.
4.5.6 Factors Controlling ROC and RON Using linear regression analysis with the stepwise method, ROC and RON were estimated by the five identified factors as follows: ROC (g C kg−1) = 45.3 + 24.5 × (LF factor) + 12.6 × (amorphous factor) + 8.8 × (clay factor) − 7.2 × (humid and warm factor) + 3.4 × (C/N factor) (n = 81, r 2 = 0.91**)
Estimated PMC (mg C kg–1)
20000
R2 = 0.58**
1000
1:1
15000 10000 5000 0
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
Estimated PMN (mg N kg–1)
Measured PMC (mg C kg–1)
1:1
R2 = 0.25**
750
500
250
0
–5000
(4.7)
0
500
1000
Measured PMN (mg N kg–1)
1500
FIGURE 4.15 Scatter plots showing the measured potentially mineralizable organic C (PMC) and the estimated PMC (n = 81), and the measured potentially mineralizable organic N (PMN) and estimated PMN (n = 84). Black circles indicate samples from cropland sites and triangles indicate samples from forest sites.
88
World Soil Resources and Food Security
RON (g N kg−1) = 3.11 + 1.52 × (LF factor) + 0.84 × (amorphous factor) + 0.61 × (clay factor) − 0.29 × (humid and warm factor) − 0.26 × (C/N factor)
(n = 84, r 2 = 0.89**).
(4.8)
According to the regression equations obtained, ROC and RON were explained by all five factors; the amorphous factor had a higher contribution than the clay factor, the contribution of the humid and warm factor was negative, and the C/N factor had the opposite affect effect on PMC and PMN. Using original variables closely related to the respective factors, ROC was estimated as follows:
ROC (g C kg−1) = −23.3 + 0.48 × clay (%) + 3.67 × LFC (g C kg−1) + 1.26 × Alo (g kg−1) + 1.51 × HF C/N
(n = 81, r 2 = 0.71**).
(4.9)
Similarly, RON was estimated as follows:
RON (g N kg−1) = −0.42 + 0.034 × clay (%) + 4.65 × LFN (g N kg−1) + 0.076 × Alo (g kg−1) + 0.00022 × MAP (mm)
(n = 84, r 2 = 0.67**).
(4.10)
According to the coefficient of LFC and LFN in Equations 4.9 and 4.10, respectively, the amount of ROC proportional to LFC was 3.67-fold larger than the amount of LFC itself, whereas the RON controlled by LFN was 4.65-fold as much as LFN. As the LF-OM partly represents the amount of NPP in each site, it would suggest that the higher amount of recalcitrant OM was partly attributed to the higher intensity of OM input by the vegetation. The contribution of the clay content is attributed to the SSA as the capacity to sorb dissolved OM [Kaiser et al. 1996; Nambu and Yonebayashi 2000]. In the present study, 0.48 g C kg−1 of ROC and 0.034 g N kg−1 of RON was accumulated at an increment of 1% clay content. In humid Asia, amorphous minerals played a significant role in both ROC and RON, whereas they did not contribute to PMC and PMN. According to the coefficient of Alo in Equations 4.9 and 4.10, 1 g kg−1 of Alo contributed to 1.26 g C kg−1 of ROC and 0.076 g N kg−1 of RON (i.e., mol ratio of C to Alo and N to Alo was 2.8 and 0.15, respectively). In general, soils from volcanic ash are characterized by a high accumulation of OC because of the ligand exchange of carboxyl groups to aluminum surface groups or complexes of reactive Al to humic and fulvic acids [Boudot 1992; Parfitt et al. 1977]. Kaiser and Guggenberger [2003] found that the specific surface area (SSA) of amorphous Al hydroxide (285 m2 g−1) was 3.7-fold and 18-fold that of illite (77 m2 g−1) and kaolinite (16 m2 g−1), respectively. Both the higher affinity of amorphous mineral surfaces to OM and the larger SSA contribute to the higher ROC and RON in the volcanic soils.
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
89
4.6 C OMPARATIVE STUDY ON SOIL FERTILITY STATUS UNDER SHIFTING CULTIVATION IN EAST KALIMANTAN, NORTHERN THAILAND, AND JAPAN IN RELATION TO DYNAMICS OF READILY MINERALIZABLE SOM AND SOIL ACIDITY Shifting cultivation, which has often been referred to as slash-and-burn or swidden agriculture, is an extensive farming system that incorporates both cropping and fallow periods in its land rotation [Kunstadter and Chapman 1978; Nye and Greenland 1960]. Recently population increases in the mountainous areas of Southeast Asia has lead to an expansion of cropland, widespread forest degradation, and a shortening of the fallow period in traditional farming systems. This has resulted in an irreversible degradation of soil fertility. To alleviate forest degradation while maintaining or improving the living conditions of the hill people, it is essential to introduce improved and/or alternative land-use systems that allow continuous cultivation. It is widely believed that tropical soils are generally infertile and shifting cultivation is an adaptation to such poor soil conditions. However, as discussed so far, ecological conditions in the tropics are surprisingly diverse, and systems of shifting cultivation are consequently also quite variable. The main objective of this study is to compare soil fertility status under shifting cultivation systems in different bioclimatic conditions with special reference to the dynamics of labile organic matter in soils. This fraction of organic matter is expected to be a good indicator for evaluating the overall sustainability of the fallow-cropping system, and may give an insight into how to achieve more efficient management of organic matter resources in forest-soil ecosystems.
4.6.1 Description of Study Sites This study was carried out in three areas under different bioclimatic conditions: East Kalimantan, Indonesia (EK), northern Thailand (NT), and Japan (JP) (Figure 4.16). In EK, two broadly separated regions were selected: the lower part of the R. Mahakam watershed with an elevation of less than 100 m (EKL), and the mountainous area known as Apokayan on the Malaysian Sarawak border with an elevation of between 600 and 800 m (EKH). Both areas belong to Köppen’s Af climate type and do not have a distinct dry season [Kottek et al. 2006], hence the soils have an udic soil moisture regime. The mean annual temperature is above 25°C and annual precipitation exceeds 2000 mm in EKL. The EKH region is very humid and the annual precipitation exceeds 6000 mm. Although both regions have an equally hyperthermic soil temperature regime (>22°C), accumulation of organic matter in soil profiles is apparently higher in EKH soils according to field observation, presumably due to the extremely humid conditions there. Parent materials are mainly tertiary sandstone and/or mudstone, except for a limited number of plots in EKH, in which andesitic volcanic rocks are distributed. Among the EKL soils, however, limestone sometimes influences the soil, and in this case the soils were expected to be less acidic than other soils in the region. Most soils in the two regions were classified as Alisols [World Reference Base for Soil Resources, ISSS-ISRIC-FAO 2006], corresponding
90
World Soil Resources and Food Security
DP
20°N
RP(RPc) NT
EKH SM EKL BS(BSc)
0°
BG LB 100°E
PC 120°E
FIGURE 4.16 Locations of the experimental plots in Thailand and Indonesia.
to Udults in U.S. soil taxonomy [Soil Survey Staff 2006] (Figure 4.17a). In EK, farmers usually plant upland rice for 1 year only after clearing and burning the forest cover, and then leave the land for more than 20 years as fallow (Figure 4.17b). On relatively fertile soils near the river however, cultivation of crops with a shorter fallow of around eight years is practiced. In NT, activities of shifting farmers were observed mainly in a mountainous area with an elevation of between 600 and 1300 m. The climate type falls between Köppen’s Aw and Cw classifications, with a distinct dry season. Mean annual temperature is in the range of 20°C to 25°C and annual precipitation is between 1200 and 2000 mm. Parent materials are mainly granite, shale, mudstone, and limestone. The soils are mostly classified as Acrisols in WRB and Typic Haplustults or Ustic Dystropepts in U.S. Soil Taxonomy (Figure 4.17c). Although the traditional land use by the Karen people is 1 year of cropping and more than 10 years of fallow, the fallow period has recently decreased to as little as 3 years as a result of increasing population pressure (Figure 4.17d). Our survey was mainly carried out at a particular Karen village (DP village), at which the fallow period is still eight years. Upland rice is the main crop. In JP, traditional shifting cultivation is difficult to find. Our study site, located in Ishikawa Prefecture, may be one of the last examples of shifting cultivation in JP. This area belongs to Köppen’s Cf climate type, with an annual precipitation of 2600 mm and a mean annual temperature of 12°C. Parent material is mudstone with some influence from volcanic ejecta. Soils are classified as Cambisols (WRB) or Andic Dystrudepts (U.S. Soil Taxonomy) (Figure 4.17e). Traditionally, farmers plant cereals for about five years, followed by a long period of fallow (Figure 4.17f).
(c)
(b)
(e)
(d)
(f )
91
FIGURE 4.17 Representative soil profiles and landscape at the experimental plots in Indonesia, Thailand, and Japan with East Kalimantan, Indonesia (a) and (b); northern Thailand (c) and (d); and Japan (e) and (f).
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
(a)
92
World Soil Resources and Food Security
At the end of each dry season from 1997 to 2001, a total of 115 composite samples were collected from the surface 5-cm layer of soil in fields under different land-use stages of shifting cultivation. Then mineralization patterns of readily mineralizable organic C and N were analyzed using the same methodology as in the previous section (Section 4.5).
4.6.2 General Physicochemical Properties of the Soils Studied Table 4.7 shows the general physicochemical properties of the soils studied. The soils from EK were generally more acidic than those from NT, with higher Al, lower bases, and lower pH values. Among the EKH soils, however, those from riverside were higher in exchangeable Mg and Ca as well as in base saturation than those from upper slopes, suggesting relatively high fertility in the former. The soils from JP were somewhat intermediate between those of EK and NT in terms of exchangeable cation composition, since they had higher amounts of bases than EK or NT, but at the same time had high Al. This trend is similar to the results obtained for B-horizon soils in these regions (Section 4.4). Under the udic soil moisture regime in EK or JP, both subsoils and surface soils are subjected to more intensive acidification. The main difference between EKL and EKH was observed for the properties relating to SOM; that is, total C and N were significantly higher in EKH than in EKL. In addition, the EKL soils had a relatively coarse texture. This was presumably because of progressive clay translocation in the soil profiles due to a relatively gentle topography in the coastal or Mahakam lowland areas, compared with the mountainous region at the inland site of the island. The C mineralization pattern of the soils was fitted either by the Fi or Fi + Fi model and the value of C0 was determined in most cases. Only three EKL values and five EKH values were eliminated from further discussion because of low reliability with extremely low k values (i.e., <0.003). The average values of C0 are also given in Table 4.7. In EKH, the C0 values and the percentage of C0/TC were significantly higher, and fewer C0 values were able to be calculated than in the others. Thus it is assumed that the amount of readily mineralizable C is especially high in EKH, presumably because of the extremely high precipitation in that region and the resulting high net primary production and the slightly lower temperatures that may decrease the rate of SOM decomposition. As regards N mineralization, it was remarkable that NH +4 often accumulated during the incubation experiment, especially in the EK soils. The NH +4 accumulation over NO3− formation was commonly observed in the soils from the upper slopes of EKL or EKH (Figure 4.18a), indicating a delay in nitrification relative to N mineralization (or ammonification). Accumulation of NH +4 may lead to enhanced immobilization, and this may be why N0 is quite low relative to C0, compared with the other soils (Figure 4.18b). However, this figure for N mineralization was often missing among the soils from lower slopes or riverside areas of EKH. In these cases, little NH +4 remained at the end of the incubation experiment, and the pattern of nitrification appeared to be smooth, as was the case in the NT soils. Enhanced nitrification in a downslope was also detected using aerobic incubation [Kutsuna et al. 1988] or the 15N dilution technique [Tokuchi et al. 2000] in a Japanese conifer plantation forest in which the soils were similarly acidic.
Exchangeable K Area
n
pH(H2O)
EKL
36
4.7
EKH
34
NT
27
JP
5
Mg
pH(KCl)
a
3.9
4.9
a
5.6
b
4.8
a
NH4
Sum of Exch. Bases
Al
Base Saturation
(cmolc kg–1)
a
0.45
a
1.22
3.9
a
0.51
ab
4.8
b
0.95
b
4.3
a
1.00
ab C0
Area
Ca
(%)
a
1.80
a
0.41
1.66
a
2.38
ab
2.86
b
4.36
b
2.60
ab
9.10
c
N0
Total C
Total N
(% as TC)
(% as TN)
(g kg )
(g kg )
(g kg )
(g kg )
b
3.13
b
3.90
a
43.5
0.72
c
4.35
b
5.28
ab
52.5
a
0.25
ab
0.92
a
8.21
bc
85.4
b
0.04
a
3.19
ab
12.89
c
76.0
ab
Available Phosphate
a
Particle Size Distribution Sand
Silt
Clay
CN Ratio
(mg kg )
EKL
30.5
a
2.2
a
3.98 (13)a
a(b)
0.15 (7.0)
a(b)
14.2
a
39.4
a
56.9
b
20.7
a
22.4
a
EKH
63.4
b
4.4
bc
12.03 (18)b
b(c)
0.28 (6.2)
b(b)
14.3
a
57.8
a
36.8
a
26.2
a
37.0
c
NT
54.0
b
3.7
b
5.21 (9.3)
a(ab)
0.22 (5.9)
ab(b)
14.5
a
45.0
a
43.8
a
26.8
a
32.5
bc
JP
68.3
b
5.2
c
1.87 (2.9)
a(a)
0.09 (1.7)
a(a)
13.1
a
321.9
b
53.3
ab
23.6
a
23.1
ab
–1
–1
–1
–1
(%)
–1
Note: Soils were collected from cropland or fallow forest under shifting cultivation in Ishikawa Prefecture, Japan. The values with the same letters are not significantly different (p < 0.05). a n = 33. b n = 29.
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
TABLE 4.7 General Physicochemical Properties of the Soils Studied
93
94
World Soil Resources and Food Security
NH4-N accumulation at 133 d (g kg–1)
(a) 200
100
0
–100
N0 (g kg–1)
(b)
1:1
0
100
200
300
400
500
–100 Net NO3-N formation at 133 d (mg kg–1) EKL/upper slope EKH/upper slope EKH/riverside NT JP
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
0
10
C0 (g kg–1)
20
30
FIGURE 4.18 Scattergrams among the mineralization indices of soil organic matter determined by incubation experiments. C0 and N0 are the amounts of readily mineralizable organic C and N.
4.6.3 Factors Controlling the Amounts of C0 and N0 To analyze the effects of physicochemical properties on the amounts of C0 and N0, or N mineralization properties, principal component analysis followed by stepwise multiple linear regression was conducted separately for the soils from EK and NT, since physicochemical properties of soils were largely different between the two regions. Variables employed included pH(H2O), pH(KCl), exchangeable K, Mg, Ca, and Al, available phosphate, total C and N, CN ratio, and contents of sand, silt, and clay fractions. Tables 4.8 and 4.9 show the factor patterns for the first four principal components determined for the EK and NT soils, which accounted for 86% and 82% of their total variances, respectively. The factor patterns in both soils were rather similar, with factors relating to the quantity of organic matter, soil acidity, and NC ratio commonly determined. In the next step, stepwise multiple regression analysis was conducted to examine the contribution of each factor (determined above) to C0, N0, and NH +4 accumulation by the 133rd day (NH4 (133d)), and net nitrification by the 133rd day (NO3 (133d)),
95
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
TABLE 4.8 Factor Pattern for the First Four Principal Components Determined for the Surface Soil Samples from East Kalimantan (n = 70) Variable pH(H2O) pH(KCl) Exch. K Exch. Mg Exch. Ca Exch. Al Avail. P Total C Total N CN ratio Sand Silt Clay Proportion (%)
PC1
PC2
PC3
PC4
0.13 0.13 0.09 0.16 0.20 0.50** 0.29 0.93** 0.94** 0.01 –0.84** 0.58** 0.91** 31 SOM and texture
–0.89** –0.93** –0.18 –0.83** –0.91** 0.80** 0.04 –0.03 –0.11 0.25 0.18 –0.25 –0.09 31 Acidity
0.05 0.01 0.84** 0.16 –0.01 –0.12 0.82** 0.18 0.18 –0.02 –0.18 0.26 0.09 12 P and K
–0.16 –0.18 –0.07 –0.19 –0.12 –0.10 –0.02 0.26 0.11 0.87** 0.44 –0.54** –0.28 12 CN ratio
Note: Significant correlation coefficients at **p < 0.01 and *p < 0.05.
TABLE 4.9 Factor Pattern for the First Four Principal Components Determined for the Surface Soil Samples from Northern Thailand (n = 27) Variable pH(H2O) pH(KCl) Exch. K Exch. Mg Exch. Ca Exch. Al Avail. P Total C Total N CN ratio Sand Silt Clay Proportion (%)
PC1
PC2
PC3
PC4
−0.78** −0.90** −0.68** −0.91** −0.94** 0.83** −0.18 0.14 0.04 0.32 0.26 −0.16 0.18 35 Acidity
−0.48 −0.27 0.25 0.22 0.07 0.38 −0.05 0.94** 0.98** −0.41 −0.37 −0.13 0.01 21 SOM
0.17 0.20 0.38 0.03 0.02 0.12 0.80** −0.13 0.07 −0.70* 0.70* 0.13 −0.19 15 P and NC ratio
−0.08 0.15 −0.07 −0.14 0.10 0.04 −0.01 −0.10 −0.09 −0.02 −0.08 0.82** 0.82** 11 Texture
Note: Significant correlation coefficients at **p < 0.01 and *p < 0.05.
96
World Soil Resources and Food Security
using the dataset of 62 samples from EK, for which all the variables were determined. The latter two variables are used because it is difficult to determine convergent values for mineralized NH4 and NO3. The following equations were obtained for the EK samples:
C0 (mg kg−1) = 7630 + 4925 × (SOM and texture factor) + 1139 × (acidity factor) + 1384 × (CN ratio factor)
(r 2 = 0.59**)
(4.11)
N0 (mg kg−1) = 212.5 + 76.2 × (SOM and texture factor) − 38.1 × (acidity factor) + 24.8 × (P and K factor) + 23.3 × (CN ratio factor)
(r 2 = 0.40**)
(4.12)
NH4 (133d) (mg kg−1) = 37.9 + 24.7 × (SOM and texture factor) + 48.8 × (acidity factor) − 8.41 × (P and K factor) + 10.4 × (CN ratio factor)
(r 2 = 0.68**)
(4.13)
NO3 (133d) (mg kg−1) = 103.2 + 19.0 × (SOM and texture factor) − 64.7 × (acidity factor) + 27.3 × (P and K factor)
(r 2 = 0.53**).
(4.14)
Since all the scores were already standardized, each coefficient directly gave the relative contribution of the factors. If we introduce standardized C0 value (C0-std) into the regression to take account of the effect of mineralizable C on N mineralization, Equations 4.12 and 4.14 can be improved with relatively high coefficients for C0-std as follows: N0 (mg kg−1) = 211.4 + 128 × (SOM and texture factor) − 26.0 × (acidity factor) + 20.3 × (P and K factor) + 38.0 × (CN ratio factor) − 69.8 × (C0-std)
(r 2 = 0.49**)
(4.15)
NO3 (133d) (mg kg−1) = 102.6 + 55.0 × (SOM and texture factor) − 56.3 × (acidity factor) + 24.2 × (P and K factor) + 14.3 × (CN ratio factor) − 48.3 × (C0-std)
(r 2 = 0.61**).
(4.16)
On the other hand, for NT soils, the following equations were obtained:
C0 (mg kg−1) = 5215 + 2249 × (SOM factor) − 851 × (texture factor)
(r 2 = 0.44**)
(4.17)
97
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
N0 (mg kg−1) = 220.3 − 30.7 × (acidity factor) + 60.3 × (SOM factor)
(r 2 = 0.74**)
(4.18)
Since NH +4 accumulation was scarcely observed for the NT soils, NH4 (133d) could not be explained by the regression analysis. NO3 (133d) showed a similar trend to N 0. These equations indicate that:
1. Becaues the OM factor positively contributes to C0, N0, NH4 (133d), and NO3 (133d), the quantity of readily mineralizable organic matter reflects the overall organic matter accumulation in the soils. 2. Equations 4.12, 4.13, 4.14, and 4.18 indicate that the factors relating to the acidic and/or oligotrophic nature of the soils, such as high acidity and P depletion, suppress nitrification and hence accelerate NH +4 accumulation, resulting in a reduction in net N mineralization. 3. C0 contributes negatively to nitrification and net N mineralization, implying that accumulation of readily mineralizable C accelerates microbial activity and N immobilization during the incubation experiment (Equations 4.15 and 4.16).
It is noteworthy that suppression of nitrification, which was often observed for the EK soils, during the long-term incubation experiment was usually not observed in the NT soils. The NT soils showed lower soil acidity than the EK soils, except for some cases where soil was collected under forests with long-term fallow phases. Thus, the more acidic and/or oligotrophic conditions of EK soils may suppress nitrification. In turn, this retards further loss of bases and slows soil acidification. Furthermore, the accumulation of C0 under the highly productive rainforest in EK may enhance the immobilization of NH +4 through the activity of soil microbes. Hence the ecology of EK is not so beneficial for shifting farmers in terms of N supply for agricultural production. It is thus indispensable to retain a long fallow phase, so that N can be released through the intensive soil burning effect that only occurs when a large amount of plant biomass is burned [Tanaka et al. 2001].
4.6.4 Relationships between Respective Factors and Topography or Land-Use Status in East K alimantan Based on Table 4.8 and Figure 4.19, the EKH soils showed high scores for the first component (i.e., the SOM and texture factor) compared to the EKL soils, indicating a relatively high accumulation of organic matter-related resources in high elevation regions, as was observed for the C0 values in Table 4.7. Regarding the quality of the organic matter, the scores of the CN ratio factor in the EKL soils were more variable than in the EKH soils (Figure 4.19b), suggesting that extremely low N status relative to C can often affect agricultural production on some EKL soils, in spite of similar values of average CN ratios in both soils (Tables 4.7 and 4.10). Among the EKH soils, those from riverside areas showed lower acidity (Table 4.10). At the same time, the
98
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Acidity factor
(a)
2 1 –2
0
–1
0
1
2
3
–1 –2 –3
SOM and texture factor (b)
4
CN ratio factor
2
–2
–1
0
–2
0
P and K factor
1
2
6
7
EKL/upper slope EKH/upper slope EKH/riverside
FIGURE 4.19 Distribution of factor scores determined by the principal component analysis in relation to elevation and topography in soils from East Kalimantan.
riverside soils of EKH often exhibited higher scores for P and K factors (Table 4.10 and Figure 4.19b), suggesting that the soil nutritional conditions relating to bases and P are all more favorable in soils from riverside areas. In EKH soils, where the influence of limestone is negligible, the scores of the acidity factor showed relatively clear trends in terms of the length of the fallow period (Table 4.10). That is, they tended to be low in the early stage of fallow (from the first to the third year), presumably due to the effect of ash input on slash-and-burn of forest before cultivation, and then later increased along with the growth of fallow forest. This high acidity in the middle to later stages of fallow may lead to a poor N nutrient status through suppressing nitrification and enhancing immobilization, as shown in the regression analysis discussed earlier.
4.6.5 Dynamics of Soil Fertility Status throughout a Land Rotation System of Shifting Cultivation in Northern Thailand The dynamics of soil fertility status were more clearly observed in the shifting cultivation system by Karen people in northern Thailand. Figure 4.20 shows the
99
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
TABLE 4.10 Average Factor Scores in Different Areas of East Kalimantan or Under Different Land-Use Stages of Shifting Cultivation in EKH Area For all EK soils EKL/slope EKH/slope EKH/riverside For EKH soils Early stage of fallow (1st to 3rd year) Middle stage of fallow (4th to 8th year) Later stage of fallow (after 9th year)
n
SOM and Texture Factor
Acidity Factor
P and K Factor
CN Ratio Factor
36 21 13
−0.660 0.860 0.439
a b b
0.071 0.331 −0.732
b b a
−0.018 −0.288 0.514
ab a b
0.135 −0.124 −0.174
a a a
9
0.970
a
−0.849
a
0.352
a
−0.174
a
18
0.518
a
0.128
b
−0.082
a
−0.075
a
7
0.816
a
0.395
b
−0.152
a
−0.278
a
Note: The values with the same letters are not significantly different (p < 0.05).
dynamics of the first, second, and third factors (Table 4.9) throughout different landuse stages of shifting cultivation. In the initial stage of fallow, the scores of the acidity factor were kept low, presumably reflecting the ash input at the beginning of cultivation (Figure 4.20a). It then sharply increased in the middle stage of fallow (3–6 years), and then decreased again in the late stage of fallow. As a similar but more prolonged acidification was reported for subsoils under fallow in the area [Tanaka et al. 1997], soil acidification may commonly occur as a result of cation uptake by fallow vegetation. The values of SOM factor were low throughout the cropping year and the initial stage of fallow (0–6 years), and then increased along with the establishment of secondary forest and an increasing supply of forest litter (7–8 years) (Figure 4.20b). Similarly, the values of C0 and N0 were also low through the cropping year and the initial stage of fallow (0 to 4 years), and then increased along with the establishment of secondary forest and an increasing supply of forest litter (5 to 8 years) (Figure 4.21). As the acidity factor showed a decreasing trend at the same time in the late stage (Figure 4.20a), this litter may be supplying bases (obtained by tree roots from further down the soil profile) to the surface soil. This simultaneous change in acidity and SOM factors in the surface soil through forest-litter deposition in a late stage of fallow has an increasing effect on nutritional elements, and can be considered essential to the maintenance of this forest-fallow system. Agricultural production can thus be maintained with a relatively short fallow period of around ten years. Conversely, fallow periods of less than five years can be considered to be less sustainable. However, since in the long fallow the acidity factor scores were often high, cumulative cation uptake by forest vegetation may cause soil acidification. It is necessary to investigate in more detail whether prolonged fallow can accumulate bases
100
World Soil Resources and Food Security (a)
Factor 1
Scores of acidity factor
2
Long fallow (>15 y)
1 0
0
2
4
6
8
10
–1 –2
Fallow period (y)
–3
(b)
Factor 2
Scores of SOM factor
3
Long fallow (>15 y)
2 1 0
0
2
4
6
8
10
–1 –2
Scores of P and NC ratio factor
(c)
Fallow period (y) Factor 3
3
Long fallow (>15 y)
2 1 0
–1
0
2
4
6
8
10
–2 –3
Fallow period (y)
FIGURE 4.20 Distribution of factor scores in relation to land-use stages of shifting cultivation in northern Thailand.
in surface soil layers. In the long fallow, the values of “SOM” factor scores were usually high due to cumulative litter input. The P and NC ratio factor was occasionally high, but only at the cropping phase and the initial stage of fallow, presumably after higher ash input at the burning; it was then low throughout the fallow stages, including long fallow. The fallow practice does not seem to improve the soil properties relating to this factor. The slashand-burn practice was, therefore, considered to be indispensable for improving the soil properties relating to this factor for the next cropping. This is in contrast to the
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
C0 (mg kg–1)
(a)
N0 (mg kg–1)
Long fallow (>15 y)
10000
5000
0
(b)
C0
15000
101
0
2
4
6
8
10
Fallow period (y)
N0
800
Long fallow (>15 y)
600 400 200 0
0
2
4
6
8
10
Fallow period (y)
FIGURE 4.21 Distribution of C0 and N0 in relation to land-use stages of shifting cultivation in northern Thailand.
acidity and/or SOM-related properties of the soils, which already showed improvements in the late stage of fallow. Figure 4.22 shows the fluctuations of C0 and N0 in the shifting cultivation system in JP. Unlike EK or NT, neither C0 nor N0 fluctuate appreciably during the cropping and fallow phases, presumably because the northern temperate climate produces lower amounts of forest litter during the fallow period. Such a mild climate also prevents SOM from actively decomposing, allowing continuous cultivation for several years, as introduced earlier.
4.6.6 General Consideration on Land Uses in Upland Soils in Respective Regions in Relation to Soil Fertility Status As shown in Table 4.10 for EK, the prolonged fallow does not improve the low fertility status of the soils relating to the P and K factor, indicating that a high ash input, probably after long period of fallow, is indispensable for achieving sufficient yields
102
World Soil Resources and Food Security (a)
Long fallow (>15 y)
C0
4000
C0 (mg kg–1)
3000 2000 1000 0
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Fallow period (y) (b)
Long fallow (>15 y)
N0
250
N0 (mg kg–1)
200 150 100 50 0
0
2
4
6
8
Fallow period (y)
10
FIGURE 4.22 Distribution of C0 and N0 in relation to land-use stages of shifting cultivation in Japan.
in the next cropping phase in the traditional shifting cultivation system. As far as P supply, the situation of NT was not very much different, i.e., the factor scores in the P and NC ratio factor were not improved even in the late stage of the fallow phase in NT (Figure 4.20c). In EK, the high ash input after a long period of fallow may also contribute to amelioration of soil acidity problems, resulting in an increased N utilization by crops. This is not the case for the relatively fertile soils in terms of N supply under shifting cultivation in NT. This may be a key factor in explaining why it has been difficult to establish cropping systems without long fallow periods in the traditional shifting cultivation in highly acidic upland soils in EK. Smithson and Giller [2002] also concluded that additions of P and N fertilizer should be seen as necessary in low-nutrient soils of the tropics. From these results, we can conclude that it will be difficult to establish intensive cropping systems in most of the upland areas unless very high amounts of fertilizer as well as liming are applied in EK. Topographic factors should be taken into consideration for developing alternative, more intensive agriculture; that is, the riverside soils should be the first priority for more intensive
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
103
uses. As discussed earlier, the riverside soils showed higher net nitrification relative to NH4 formation, and higher N0/C0 ratios than the other EK soils from upper slopes. Soil fertility status relating to acidity as well as P and K factors was also apparently favorable in the riverside soils. Thus the riverside soils were exceptionally fertile in terms of soil acidity, P and K status, and N supply potential, promising a better agricultural response at this location. On the other hand, in the shifting cultivation system by Karen people in NT, some soil properties relating to soil acidity improve at the same time as the SOM-related properties increase the late stage of fallow. The litter input may be supplying bases (obtained by tree roots from further down the soil profile) to the surface soil. This simultaneous increase in SOM and bases in the surface soil, through forest-litter deposition in the late stage of fallow, has an increasing effect on nutritional elements. These functions of the fallow phase can be considered essential to the maintenance of this forest-fallow system. Agricultural production can therefore be maintained with a fallow period of around 10 years in NT, which is somewhat shorter than widely believed. Traditional shifting cultivation in EK, NT, and JP can be seen to be well adapted to their respective soil-ecological conditions. Socioeconomic conditions are, however, drastically changing, making it difficult to sustain these systems. Even so, these systems provide an insight into basic soil processes—an understanding of which is essential to the better management of organic matter in all agroecosystems.
4.7 C OMPARATIVE STUDY ON PROTON BUDGETS IN SOILS OF CROPLAND AND ADJACENT FOREST IN THAILAND AND INDONESIA Soil acidification is a natural process, accelerated by agriculture, in humid regions under a climate where precipitation exceeds evapotranspiration [Helyar and Porter 1989; Juo et al. 1996]. In the croplands, proton generation associated with nitrification was reported to accelerate soil acidification owing to the enhanced mineralization of soil organic nitrogen [Tanaka et al. 1997; see Section 4.8 in this volume], limited vegetation uptake at the beginning of the cropping season [Poss et al. 1995], and nitrogen fertilization [Bouman et al. 1995]. However, soil acidification is also contributed to by proton sources other than nitrification, i.e., acidic deposition, dissociation of organic anions and carbonic acid and excess uptake of cations over anions by vegetation. Since most of proton-generating processes are associated with the organic matter cycles, they are influenced by the cultivation-induced changes in organic matter cycles, typically the loss of SOM owing to the increased organic matter decomposition and product removal. However, the effects of cultivation on individual processes are various and thus, their influence on soil acidification is still unclear. As discussed in the previous section (Section 4.6), soil acidity fluctuated considerably in different stages of land uses in shifting cultivation systems that incorporated both cropping and fallow phases in their land rotations. The objective of the present section was to evaluate the influence of cultivation on soil acidification by
104
World Soil Resources and Food Security
quantifying proton budget in a soil-vegetation system including solute leaching, vegetation uptake, and organic matter decomposition in croplands and adjacent forests in northern Thailand and East Kalimantan, Indonesia.
4.7.1 Study Plots Experimental plots consisted of one forest and one cropland plot in both Thailand and Indonesia. The forest and cropland plots in Thailand (RP and RPc, respectively) were located in Ban Rakpaendin, Chiang Rai Province (Figure 4.16). The corn (Zea mays L.) had been cultivated during the wet season without fertilization in RPc for 3 years since the conversion of forest to cropland. Soils were derived from sedimentary rocks (RP) and sedimentary rocks associated with granite intrusion (RPc) and classified as Typic Haplustults [Soil Survey Staff 2006]. On the other hand, the forest and cropland plots in Indonesia (BS and BSc, respectively) were located in the experimental forest of the Tropical Rainforest Research Center, Mulawarman University, Bukit Soeharto, East Kalimantan Province (Figure 4.16). The chili (Capsicum sp.) had been cultivated for 2 years after deforestation in BSc. Soils were derived from sedimentary rocks and classified as Typic Paleudults [Soil Survey Staff 2006]. 0.71 Mg DW ha−1 yr−1 of poultry manure was applied at the beginning of cropping season (October 2004–October 2005). Soil solution and precipitation (for the cropland plots) or throughfall (for the forested plots) were collected and the proton budget was calculated (see Appendix for detailed methodology).
4.7.2 Physicochemical Properties of Soils The physicochemical properties of soils are presented in Table 4.11. Soil pH was low throughout the soil profiles in BS (3.8–4.3) and BSc (4.2–4.3) than in RP (4.6–5.0) and RPc (5.4–5.5). Clay contents in soils were higher in RP (70%–75%) and RPc (40%–51%) than in BS (23%–31%) and BSc (19%–33%), although the differences in clay contents between RP and RPc might be due to the influence of granite in RPc. Total carbon contents in the A horizons in the cropland plots were lower (27 and 14 g kg−1 in RPc and BSc, respectively) than in the adjacent forest plots (63 and 23 g kg−1 in RP and BS, respectively).
4.7.3 Carbon Stock and Flow Carbon stock is presented in Table 4.12. In the forest plots, organic carbon was stored as the aboveground biomass (169.1 and 292.6 Mg C ha−1 in RP and BS, respectively) as well as SOM (65.2 and 26.6 Mg C ha−1 in RP and BS, respectively) in the upper 30-cm layers of soil. The higher aboveground biomass and the lower stock of organic matter in the mineral soil in the present study, as compared to temperate forests, were consistent with a previous report [Nakane 1980]. In the cropland plots, C stock in the mineral soil was lower than in the adjacent forest plots. C stock in the mineral soil in RPc and BSc (55.8 and 24.6 Mg C ha−1, respectively) was 9.4 and 2.0 Mg C ha−1 less than in RP and BS, respectively (Table 4.12).
Depth
pH
Exchangeable Total C
Horizon
(cm)
(H2O)
(KCl)
Total N
Bases
(g kg−1)
Al
Particle Size Distribution CEC
Sand
(cmolc kg−1)
Silt
Clay
(%)
Thailand RP
RPc
A
0–7
5.0
4.1
62.6
3.8
5.8
1.9
27.6
5
25
70
BA
7–20
4.9
3.9
19.8
1.5
2.0
3.5
19.9
4
23
73
Bt
20–45+
4.6
4.0
8.9
1.0
1.4
3.2
20.1
6
19
75
Ap
0–7
5.4
4.7
26.8
2.0
8.0
0.2
11.5
42
18
40
BA
7−20
5.5
4.8
15.0
1.3
5.9
0.2
14.4
32
13
55
Bt
20−45+
5.5
4.8
10.8
1.0
4.3
0.4
14.4
39
10
51
Indonesia BS
BSc
0−5
4.0
3.9
22.9
1.6
2.2
3.0
8.5
52
25
23
BA
A
5−25
3.8
3.8
4.2
0.5
0.8
3.9
6.2
49
27
24
B1
25−40
4.0
3.8
3.5
0.5
0.8
4.8
5.0
43
30
27
Bt
40+
4.3
3.8
2.5
0.4
1.0
7.0
5.0
34
35
31
Ap1
0−5
4.3
3.9
14.3
1.6
2.1
1.9
6.8
64
16
19
Ap2
5−20
4.2
3.8
4.8
0.5
1.8
3.3
8.7
54
19
28
B1
20−40
4.2
3.8
3.7
0.5
1.2
4.6
10.3
46
21
33
Bt
40−60+
4.3
3.8
3.2
0.4
0.9
5.9
11.3
54
19
26
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
TABLE 4.11 Physicochemical Properties of Soils in Thai and Indonesian Plots
105
106
TABLE 4.12 Stock and Annual Flow of Carbon in the Thai and Indonesian Plots RP 169.1
RPc
BS
(−)
5.8
(0.8)
292.6
2.4 2.2 1.7
(0.3) (0.2) (0.1)
0.1 0.1 –
(0.0) (0.0)
2.6 65.2
(0.1) (5.0)
– 55.8
(a)
5.5
(0.3)
(b) (c) (d)
5.2 4.0 1.2 – 5.8 −0.2
(0.2) (0.2) (0.1)
(e)
(−) (0.4)
BSc (−)
1.2
(0.2)
1.0 1.2 2.1
(0.4) (0.3) (0.4)
0.2 0.1
(0.1) (0.0)
(2.3)
3.5 26.6
(0.3) (0.8)
24.6
(0.3)
8.2
(0.3)
5.4
(0.5)
3.6
(0.3)
4.3 4.1 0.2 1.7 – −3.9
(0.7) (0.7) (0.1) (0.3)
5.0 4.1 0.9 – 10.6 −0.4
(0.5) (0.5) (0.1)
1.4 1.1 0.3 0.2 – −2.2
(0.1) (0.1) (0.1) (0.0)
(0.8)
(–) (0.8)
Note: The figures in parentheses represent standard errors. a Organic carbon in soil at 0–30-cm depths was counted. b The C input was calculated as the sum of litterfall and root litter (b = c + d). c The annual rates of root litter production were assumed to be 20% of the fine root biomass in the forest [Nakane 1980]. d The C budget in soil was calculated as the difference between organic matter decomposition and C input (e = b − a).
(0.3)
World Soil Resources and Food Security
C stock (Mg C ha−1) Aboveground biomass Fine root biomass O, A horizon BA horizon B1 horizon Soil organic matter O horizon Mineral soil horizonsa C flow (Mg C ha−1 yr−1) Organic matter decomposition Organic matter production C input to soilb Litterfall Root litterc Product removal Wood increment C budget in soild
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
107
Seasonal fluctuations of soil temperature and volumetric water content in the soil and the rates of organic matter decomposition are shown in Figures 4.23 and 4.24, respectively. In RP and RPc, the rates of organic matter decomposition were positively correlated with volumetric water content in the soils (RP: r = 0.91, n = 9, p < 0.01; RPc: r = 0.63, n = 9, p < 0.10), while, in BS and BSc, they were independent of volumetric water content in the soils. Therefore, the annual rates of organic matter decomposition in RP and RPc were calculated as totals of the simulated emission rates using the regression equations and monitored volumetric water content in the soil, whereas, in BS and BSc, the rates were calculated using the average rates of CO2 emission measured. Volumetric water content in soil (L L–1)
Soil temperature (ºC) 35
Thailand RP
30 25
0.5 0.4
20
0.3
15
0.2
10
0.1
5 0 Apr-04
0.6
Jun-04
Aug-04
Oct-04
Dec-04
Feb-05
0.0
Date Volumetric water content in soil (L L–1)
Soil temperature (ºC) 35
Indonesia BS
30 25
0.3
15
5 0 Sep-04
0.5 0.4
20
10
0.6
0.2 Soil temperature at 5-cm depth (Cropland) Soil temperature at 5-cm depth (Forest) 0.1 Volumetric water content in soil at 5-cm depth (Cropland) Volumetric water content in soil at 5-cm depth (Forest) 0.0 Nov-04 Jan-05 Mar-05 May-05 Jul-05 Sep-05
Date
FIGURE 4.23 The seasonal fluctuations of soil temperature and volumetric soil water content.
108
World Soil Resources and Food Security C flux (µ gC m2 s–1) 60
Thailand RP
40
20
0 Feb-04 Apr-04 Jun-04 Aug-04 Oct-04 Dec-04 Feb-05 Apr-05
Date
C flux (µ gC m2 s–1) 60
Indonesia BS Forest Cropland
40
20
0 Nov-04
Jan-05
Mar-05
May-05
Jul-05
Sep-05
Nov-05
Date
FIGURE 4.24 Seasonal fluctuations of the rates of organic matter decomposition in the forest and cropland plots. Bars indicate standard errors (n = 5).
The annual flow of carbon is presented in Table 4.12. In the forest plots, the annual rates of organic matter decomposition thus determined were 5.5 and 5.4 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 in RP and BS, respectively. These values were consistent with those reported in tropical seasonal forests (4.1 Mg C ha−1 yr−1) (Section 4.8) and tropical rain forests (4.8–8.9 Mg C ha−1 yr−1) [Bond-Lamberty et al. 2004], respectively. Assuming that annual root litter rates were 20% of the fine root biomass [Nakane 1980], the annual rates of organic matter decomposition were almost balanced with C inputs as the sum of litterfall and root litter (5.2 and 5.0 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 in RP and BS, respectively) in the forest plots. Organic matter was accumulated in the ecosystems as wood increment in the growth stage of forests in RP and BS.
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
109
In the cropland plots, the annual rates of organic matter decomposition were higher in RPc and BSc (8.2 and 3.6 Mg C ha−1 yr−1, respectively) than C inputs (4.3 and 1.4 Mg ha−1 yr−1, respectively). These values suggest a loss of SOM (3.9 and 2.2 Mg C ha−1 yr−1 in RPc and BSc, respectively) in the cropland plots. The SOM loss caused by cultivation can account for the lower SOM stock in the cropland plots, although the lower clay content in the soil of RPc might also contribute to the lower SOM stock than in RP.
4.7.4 Soil Solution Composition The annual volume-weighted mean concentrations of ions in precipitation, throughfall, and soil solution are presented in Table 4.13. The soil solution pH was relatively high in RP and RPc (6.1–6.2 and 5.7–5.8, respectively). The soil solution pH was moderately low (5.2–5.6) in BSc, while the soil solution pH was very low (4.2–4.4) in BS. The concentrations of bicarbonate in soil solution were significant (0.03–0.05 mmolc L−1) in all plots except for BS, where they were negligible owing to the low pH of soil solution. The concentrations of organic anions in soil solution were higher in the O and A horizons in BS (0.20–0.26 mmolc L−1) and in the Ap1 and Ap2 horizons in BSc (0.09–0.13 mmolc L−1), as compared to RP and RPc (0.01–0.02 mmolc L−1) (Table 4.13). The concentrations of organic anions in soil solution were correlated with those of DOC in BS and BSc, and these relationships were expressed by the following regression:
(Orgn–) = 0.087 × (DOC) + 0.042 (r = 0.77***, n = 111, p < 0.01)
(4.19)
(Orgn–) = 0.100 × (DOC) + 0.008 (r = 0.66***, n = 77, p < 0.01)
(4.20)
where (Orgn–) represents the concentration of organic anions in soil solution (mmolc L−1) and DOC represents the concentration of DOC in soil solution (mmol L−1). The higher concentrations of DOC in soil solution in the surface soil horizons in BS and BSc (17.2–34.7 and 9.3–9.7 mg C L−1, respectively), as compared to RP and RPc (3.1–3.9 and 2.2–4.5 mg C L−1, respectively), contributed to proton generation associated with dissociation of one acidic functional group for 11.5 and 10.0 C atoms of DOC, respectively. In the cropland plots, the concentrations of nitrate in soil solution were higher both in RPc (0.34–0.38 mmolc L−1) and BSc (0.06–0.14 mmolc L−1), as compared to the respective adjacent forest plots. The concentrations of nitrate in the Ap horizons were highest especially at the beginning of the cropping season in RPc (April 2004– June 2004) and BSc (October 2004–January 2005) owing to the enhanced decomposition of SOM and the small amount of biomass (Figure 4.25). Although nitrification is generally suppressed in the acidic soils [Kemmitt et al. 2006], the concentrations of nitrate in soil solution were still higher in BSc than in BS. This was consistent with the report by Killham [1990], in which nitrate could be produced by autotrophic bacteria even in the highly acidic soils in croplands. The concentrations of nitrate in soil solution were correlated with the concentrations of Ca (r = 0.99, n = 83, p < 0.01)
110
TABLE 4.13 Water Flux and Annual Volume-Weighed Mean Concentrations of Ions in Throughfall and Soil Solution
Thailand RP
RPc
BSc
a b
Horizon
pH
DOC (mg C L−1)
TF a A BA Bt
2083 1602 1162 825
6.09 6.21 6.13 6.05
2.7 3.9 3.1 3.1
0.029 0.034 0.029 0.029
0.015 0.020 0.012 0.012
0.017 0.021 0.025 0.018
0.058 0.072 0.060 0.069
0.001 0.001 0.001 0.001
0.012 0.007 0.007 0.007
0.104 0.123 0.103 0.108
0.000 0.007 0.006 0.008
0.001 0.009 0.008 0.004
0.003 0.061 0.054 0.060
P a Ap BA B1
2223 1414 1064 1064
6.22 5.80 5.66 5.83
2.9 4.5 2.2 1.9
0.030 0.034 0.048 0.047
0.008 0.017 0.009 0.012
0.014 0.371 0.380 0.338
0.052 0.117 0.076 0.095
0.001 0.002 0.002 0.001
0.009 0.007 0.008 0.008
0.088 0.508 0.486 0.439
0.000 0.004 0.001 0.002
0.001 0.004 0.005 0.006
0.003 0.149 0.120 0.101
TF a O A B1
2031 1619 1196 545
5.23 4.44 4.22 4.39
9.0 34.7 17.2 9.9
0.009 0.001 0.000 0.003
0.101 0.257 0.196 0.119
0.036 0.038 0.044 0.032
0.104 0.136 0.100 0.116
0.006 0.037 0.061 0.041
0.038 0.088 0.035 0.018
0.197 0.256 0.197 0.176
0.003 0.019 0.009 0.005
0.007 0.040 0.038 0.027
0.017 0.070 0.068 0.051
P a Ap1 Ap2 B1
2187 1144 824 824
6.09 5.62 5.57 5.21
4.2 9.7 9.3 5.9
0.024 0.042 0.051 0.038
0.016 0.126 0.087 0.038
0.009 0.143 0.137 0.061
0.022 0.084 0.097 0.083
0.001 0.002 0.003 0.006
0.014 0.020 0.018 0.023
0.045 0.311 0.298 0.187
0.000 0.010 0.008 0.006
0.001 0.046 0.034 0.019
0.001 0.061 0.083 0.067
HCO3–
Orgn− b
NO3–
CI– + SO24–
H+
NH+4
(mmolc L–1)
P and TF represent precipitation and throughfall, respectively. Orgn− represents anion deficit, the negative charge of organic acids.
Fe2+
Aln+ b
(mmolc L–1)
Si (mmol L−1)
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Indonesia BS
Na+ + K+ + Mg2+ + Ca2+
Water Flux (mm)
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia Nitrate concentration (mmolc L–1) RP
Nitrate concentration (mmolc L–1) BS
0.5
0.5
A horizon
0.4
B1 horizon
0.2 0.1
0.1 0 Apr-04
B horizon
0.3
Bt horizon
0.2
O horizon
0.4
BA horizon
0.3
Jun-04
Aug-04
Date
Oct-04
Dec-04
Nitrate concentration (mmolc L–1)
0.0 Nov-04
Feb-05
May-05 Aug-05 Nov-05
Date
Nitrate concentration (mmolc L–1)
RPc
3.0
BSc
3.0
2.5
Ap horizon
2.5
Ap1 horizon
2.0
BA horizon
2.0
Ap2 horizon
1.5
B horizon
1.5
B1 horizon
1.0
1.0
0.5
0.5
0.0 Apr-04
111
Jun-04
Aug-04
Date
Oct-04
Dec-04
0.0 Nov-04
Feb-05
May-05 Aug-05 Nov-05
Date
FIGURE 4.25 Seasonal fluctuations of concentrations of nitrate in soil solution. Bars indicate standard errors (n = 5).
and Mg (r = 0.99, n = 83, p < 0.01) in soil solution in RPc. The basic cations, mainly Ca and Mg, were leached out with nitrate (Figure 4.26).
4.7.5 Net Proton Generation and Consumption NPGNtr, NPGCar, and NPGOrg (where NPG stands for net proton generation) were calculated from the fluxes of solutes (Figure 4.26). Since cation contents exceed anion contents in plant materials in all plots (Table 4.14), excess cation charge is compensated for by net proton release from root to soil as NPGBio. Within NPGBio, since litterfall was the circulating fraction, NPGBio attributable to litter can be neutralized by cations released from fallen litter. NPGBio (wood increment or product removal) in each of the soil horizons was calculated by distributing it based on the distribution of the fine root biomass in the soil profiles (Table 4.12), according to Shibata et al. [1998]. Using NPGNtr, NPGCar, NPGOrg, and NPGBio, proton budget was calculated in each of the soil horizons (Figure 4.27). In RP, the concentrations of organic anions and nitrate in soil solution were low (0.01–0.03 mmolc L−1) owing to the rapid mineralization of organic anions and nitrate uptake by vegetation, respectively, and thus, NPGOrg and NPGNtr in each of the soil horizons were negligible (Figure 4.27). Although bicarbonate was a dominant anion in soil solution in RP, contribution of NPGCar to soil acidification was minor. In RP,
112
World Soil Resources and Food Security
Horizon RP
TF
Horizon SO42– NO
HCO3–
3
+
NH4 Na+ NH2+ Ca2+ Fe
A
Orgn–
Cl–
TF
3+
HCO3– NO3–
Ca2+
Na+
Fe3+
Aln+
O
Aln+
K+
BS
Orgn–
SO42–
Cl– H+
–2
0
NH4+
K+
Mg2–
A
BA Bt
B1
H+
–8
–6
–4
–2
0
2 4 6 8 (kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
–8
Fluxes of cations (+) and anions (–) Horizon
Orgn–
2 4 6 8 (kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
Fluxes of cations (+) and anions (–)
BSc
HCO3– Na+ NH + 4
SO42–
Ap
–4
Horizon
RPc P
–6
P
Fe3+ NO3–
Cl–
Mg2+
BA
Cl–
SO42–
Ap1
Ca2+
K+
HCO3–
Orgn–
NH4+ Na+ Fe3+ K+ Mg2+Ca2+
NO3–
Aln+
n+
Al
Ap2
Bt
B1
H+
–8
–6
–4
–2
0
2 4 6 8 (kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
Fluxes of cations (+) and anions (–)
–8
–6
–4
–2
0
H+
2 4 6 8 (kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
Fluxes of cations (+) and anions (–)
FIGURE 4.26 Fluxes of solutes at each horizon. P and TF represent precipitation and throughfall, respectively. O, A, Ap1, Ap2, BA, B, B1, and Bt represent soil horizons.
NPGBio (wood increment) distributed in the mineral soil horizons (0.6–0.8 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) and it contributed to soil acidification in each soil horizon (Figure 4.27). Since protons were consumed in the same horizon, proton leaching was negligible in RP (Figure 4.27). In BS, although protons were produced by the dissociation of organic anions in the O horizon (NPGOrg: 2.10 kmolc ha−1 yr−1), they were consumed owing to the mineralization and adsorption of organic anions in the A and B horizons (NPGOrg: −1.8 and −1.7 kmolc ha−1 yr−1, respectively) (Figure 4.27). An increase in the flux of NH +4 leaching from the O horizon (0.6 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) (Figure 4.26) suggested that protons were mainly consumed in the mineralization of organic nitrogen to NH +4 in the O horizon (NPGNtr: −0.78 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) (R–NH2 + H2O + H+ = NH +4 + R–OH) (Figure 4.27). A decrease in the fluxes of NH +4 leaching from the A horizon (1.0 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) (Figure 4.26) suggested that protons were released associated with the excess uptake of NH +4 over NO3− by biomass or adsorption of NH +4 on clays in the A horizon (NPGNtr: 0.9 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) (Figure 4.27). NPGBio (wood increment) distributed in the A and B horizons (0.7 and 2.1 kmolc ha−1 yr−1, respectively), while it also distributed in the O horizon (1.0 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) (Figure 4.27). NPGOrg
OMa production
Na
K
Ca
(Mg ha−1 yr−1) Thailand RP Wood increment Litterfall RPc
Product removal Litterfall Indonesia BS Wood increment Litterfall BSc
a b
Product removal Litterfall Fertilizerb
Mg
Fe
Al
Cl
S
P
(Cation)bio
(kg ha−1 yr−1)
(Anion)bio
NPGBio
(kmolc ha−1 yr−1)
NPGBio/OM Production (molc mol−1 C)
5.8
9.2
20.9
8.7
2.7
4.4
4.0
0.8
0.4
0.7
2.13
0.07
2.06
0.004
3.4
2.8
23.2
40.7
18.8
0.9
1.3
0.6
2.3
2.4
3.90
0.41
3.49
0.012
1.7
2.5
12.6
0.4
2.2
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.3
1.7
0.66
0.08
0.58
0.004
4.1
4.1
42.6
5.9
8.8
0.9
2.0
0.1
3.5
2.4
2.47
0.30
2.17
0.006
10.6
14.7
33.0
29.3
15.8
10.0
0.5
1.0
8.6
2.2
4.39
0.64
3.75
0.004
4.1
3.6
45.2
35.7
18.5
1.7
3.3
0.7
5.0
2.5
4.57
0.41
4.15
0.012
0.2
0.5
11.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.7
0.6
0.0
0.31
0.05
0.26
0.020
1.0 –
1.7 0.4
19.6 2.2
12.9 2.7
3.5 0.8
0.6 0.1
1.1 0.1
4.4 0.1
3.3 0.2
1.2 1.0
1.48 0.25
0.37 0.05
1.11 0.20
0.013 –
Soil Resources and Human Adaptation in Ecosystems in Humid Asia
TABLE 4.14 Uptake of Cations and Anions by Vegetation
OM represents organic matter. Poultry manure was applied at the rate of 0.71 Mg DW ha−1 at the beginning of rainy season.
113
114
World Soil Resources and Food Security Horizon
Horizon
RP
A BA
A
Bt
B1
Total
Total
–10
–5
0
5
10
(kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
Net proton generation (+) or consumption (–)
–10
–5
0
5
10
(kmolc ha–1 yr– 1)
Net proton generation (+) or consumption (–)
Horizon
Horizon
Ap BA
BS
O
Ap1
RPc
Ap2
Bt
B1
Total
Total
(H+)in – (H+)out
BSc
ΔANC NPGNtr
NPGOrg NPGBio
–10
–5
0
5
10
(kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
Net proton generation (+) or consumption (–)
–10
NPGCar
–5
0
5
10
(kmolc ha–1 yr–1)
Net proton generation (+) or consumption (–)
FIGURE 4.27 Net proton generation and consumption in the soil profiles. TF represents throughfall. O, A, Ap1, Ap2, BA, B, B1, and Bt represent soil horizons.
and NPGBio (wood increment) contributed to acidification of the O horizon (1.8 kmolc ha−1 yr−1) (Figure 4.27). Although most of the protons produced in the O horizon were consumed in the same horizon, 0.6 and 0.7 kmolc ha−1 yr−1 of protons