mefi~c Cafip
J. Sire uThe Universe Next Doon Inter-Vanity Press
ISBN: 5-88869-028-7 ICrn~ra n o c s ~ u e ~rwnonornn a ~ a p o ~ o s s p e ~ABTOP ai. AaeT a M npaTKylo xapamepwcTaKy a npocnexnsaeT nx pa3BHTkIe B PCTOPHqeCXOM KOHTeKCTe. TO MOXeT PTOMOPb PHTaTenRM HaPaTb MblCnPTb B KOHTeKCTe M P P O B O ~ ~ PTO ~HP~, eCTb OC03HaBaTb He TOJIbKO CBOBcnoc06 MhILIIJIeHZIR, MO P OKp)'XaIoIL(HXHaC nlonefi, ~ T O ~CHaPaJIa H IIOHRTb, a 3aTeM o 6 p e c ~ anomwHHoe 06ueane B HarueM nnlopmncTaqecXOM 0 6 u e c ~ ~ e .
Originally published by InterVarsity Press as The Universe Next Doo r Updated and Expanded Mition by James W . Sire. Second edition Q 1988 by James W. Sire. Translated and printed by permission of Intervarsity Press, P.O. Box 1400, Downers Grove, IL 60515, USA. Rnr edition Q 1976 by lntervarsity Christian Fellowship of the United States of>America
.................................6 PA3JlMYME..................................... 10
IlPEAMCJlOBME KO BTOPOMY MQ 3H ,lM O t fl7ABA 1 KAPL ,&H l AnbHOE
fl7ABA 2 MMP, 6OXbMM BHIMYMEM ~ I P O H M ~ A H H ~ I ~ ~
(XPMCTMAHCKMfi TEM3M)
........................................ 18
....
BCEJlEHHAR KAK C~ACOBO~ MEXAHM3M: GEM3M 42 fl7ABA 4 6E3MOJlBME OrPAHMClEHHOrO rlPOCTPAHCTBA: HATYPAnM3M ...........................................................55 rl7ABA 3
rl7ABA 5 HYJlEBAR TOClKA: HMrMJlM3M fl7ABA 6
.................... . .........83
no TY CTOPOHY HMTMAM3MA: 3K3MCTEHuMAnM3M
.........................................
109
rl7ABA 7 IlYTEUJECTBME HA BOCTOK:
BOCTOC~HM~~ I~AHTEMCTMC~ECKM~ MOHM3M .........137
................158 3K3AMEH HA XM3Hb ...........................................217
fl7ABA 8 OTAEnbHAR PEAJlbHOCTb: H O B M ~BEK fl7ABA 9
Mapdxopu, K3po~,K ) d x u ~ yM K ~ P O A , Purapdy u Keu' flu, a rnarc..xe ~ H H , rbsc nomioxemwe dpyz Ha dpyza M U ~ M cocrnaemlorn ~ P U ~ M Y H ~dm K I .weruz, HO ItOClttOflHHO UUpflll#WMBCe/leMHYH).
nPmHCJlOBHE KO BTOPOMY H3mHHK)
H e n p e ~ c p a u a m u ~ iH i cm~e ~p e c r a ~ a ~ e n eKi i TO& K H m e , H ~ I I H c ~ H HMHOIO o ~ ~ HeCKOJIbKO JIeT Ha3i3,4, n o - I I p e X H e h i y YAHBm e T H paAyeT M e m . K m & roA o H a n o n m a e T B p m morm CTYAeHTOB, IIOCKOJIbKy ee P e K O M e m y I o T npo&eccopa C T m b HeCXOAHbM AHCLI[HlTJIHH, KaK aIIOJIOreTHKa, HCTOPKH, aHmHfic m n m e p a w a , B s e A e m i e B pemmm, B B e A e m e B &mocoH name ~ y p cn, o c s m e ~ ~ b rr ie In o s e r e c K o M y ~ s ~ e p e m l o H a m . CTOJI~ IIIHp0KHfi HHTepeC nO3BoJureT AYMaTb, !IT0 OAHa H3 mefi, H a KOTOPbIX OCHOBhIBitTLaCb 3 T a KHWra, A ~ ~ ~ C T B H T W I ~ H O OKa3UKaCb BepHofi. A HMelo B B W Y MhICJIb 0 TOM, S T 0 OCHOBOnonaramwae n p o 6 ~ 1 e ~ b 1c, KOTOP~IMH m, KaK S e n o B e r e c m e c Y U J ~ C T I ~BbIHymAeHbI , CYHTaTbCR, H e 3HaIOT K a & e ~ p i t T L b ~ b l X W a H H q . TO TaKOe IIepBkirHaR p e i t T L b ~ O C ~ b ?60r 3 T 0 kiJIH KOCMOC? TO TaKOe Y ~ J I o B ~ K ?TO nPOHCXOAHT B MOMeHT C M ~ P T H ?K ~ HaM K XHTb? ~ T IBOnPOChI I BP ~ B H O M e~p e aIcry&lIbHbl &JDI JMTePaTYPbI H IICIMOJIOIXH, PCJIZ.IIXH H H a m .
n o c n e A H e e AecrrTIzrreTHe x a p a K T e p o T s e T o B H a HHX, no C y l X AeJIa, HHKaK H e H3MeHKnCR. B a p H a m o HeMHOrO, ~ H B HWX BO3MOXCH JIHUb H e 3 H a r H ~ e J I b H b r i I
B
nOA KMeHeM wHo~om Bern*. f l ~ e H a ~ 4 a T JIeT b HX3slq ero OCHOBHW rrpeAcTasHTerreM 6m Kapnoc K a c ~ a ~ eK~mao ,g o r o T e n e p b n e q a T b H e c n m K o M y n o M k i H a e T ; ceronm l?JKa~HbIii 0 6 1 q e c ~ ~ e ~ ~ BbIPEtkiTeJIb arii 3 T O r 0 ABHXeHlUI - U e p J I H M ~ K neiia. YZIUTHB~R 3 ~ k Ti e m e m H k i , R O c H o B a T e r r b H o n e p e c M m pen. B O C ~ M ~ IrOn a B y , 0 3 a r n a ~ k iee ~ u H o s b ~ i iB ~ K * . B~opoec y r r r e c T s e H H o e kicnpaarrei-iwe ~ o c ~ y n o cremepb
TO^ rJIaBbI. O H 0 6bu0 OTBeTOM H a 3 a M e T I a H W p e q e H 3 e m O B n e p B o r o H a a m . E O J X ~ ~ H HaCMTeB pw Or n H c m ~ H T I I K O BH e 06~apyxw1ki ITOYTH HHKaKOTO m e w , OAHaKO HeKOTOpbIe
0603pesa~en~ 3a npeaenaw C o e m ~ e ~ ~ LUT~TOB b r x cnpamkiBLUlki: uA rAe Xe MaPKCK3M, BeAb CerOAHR - 3 T 0 OAHO K 3 CaMbrX 3HaYkiTeJIbHbIX M H P O B O S ~ ~ ~ H H KKOPOTKO ?* R YIIOMXHYJI 0 HCM KaK 06 OAHOP ki3 P ~ ~ H O B ~ H OHaTypam-I3Ma, C T ~ ~ ~ OAHaKO OHM peUMJIki, TITO MaPKCH3M 3aCJfymLJBaeT OTAeJKbHOrO PaCCMOTPeHEZII. C ~ I ' J l a ~ k l B ~ k Ci ~ M b M H , X BKTIH)YLZTI B 3 T 0 H W a H k i e cneqkiLUlbH& pamen. HO nOCKOJIbK)' M O e nOHMMaHHe M a p K c k i 3 ~ aH e AOCTaTOZIHO aAeKBaTH0 3 ~ 0 g UeJ'IH, R 0 6 p a ~ m c xC npocb6oii K M O ~ M YA O ~ ~ O M ~ & CJ T) HTB~~ H Y~ B ~ H C affaH)H.rcrY, npoaeccopy @rnoco@~w K o m e m c a CB. OnaQ>a,w OH nro6esso MeHX 3TOT Pa3AeJI. n o ~ b 3 ~ 5 CJIYI ~ b COrJIaCWICR H a n H C a T b q a e M , sbrpaxam e M y r n y 6 o ~ p 6naroaap~oc~b. Tpene, H e c ~ o n bc y L q e c m e H H o e H ~ M ~ H ~ Hc oKc T~o ,a T B TOM, ZITO R ~ 0 6 a s r npawen, n o c ~ r r u e ~ ~ b Cr ei Ki y m p s o M y ryMaHki3MY. O z i e ~ bMHOrkie 0603pe~a~enki H e 3aMeTKJXki, ZITO, XapaKTepki3yH HaTYpaTIH3M, R OllHCbIBaH) OCHOBHbIe IIOJIOXeHLUI u 3 ~ 0 r oM Z I P O B O ~ ~ Pu ~ T~e ,n e p b R 0 6 0 3 ~ a T I k f ~3TY b CBR3b.
perurn oclpee
ki H a K O H e q , X nPOCTO nOnb1TaJICR Y J I W H T b BCH) KHHIY, wcnonbsy~6onee c o B p e M e H H y m 6 ~ 6 n ~ o r p a @ a m k i ,c n p a m m n e K c H r e c m e l r r e p o x o s a T o c T H w coo6pa3y~KHHV c T ~ M KOHTCKCTOM, K O T O P ~XI a~p~a K T e p e H )WZ K O H 4 a BOCbMWeCHTbIX rOAOB. H a n p k i ~ e p , C p e m CHOCOK K r A a B e 0 HHIWlIki3Me R Y l T O M k i H a ~ZIeTbIpeXTOMHjW KOCMIlYeCKYIo TPKIIOTZIH) Aymaca
& a ~ c ae~ymesodumabno T.'.arcmurcev(e~itchhikerk Guide to the Galaxy*), a T a K m e y r k i T b x s a I o n o m e m e H e K o T o p r a ~ y n b T)"pOAOI'kiYeCIuur a H a J I k i T H r e c m pa6m, O ~ ~ ~ J I H K O B ~ H noH~XX cne 1976 roaa.
T ~ H Me M e H e e ff H e B K T I ~ BS m ~ m y B c e 1 1 3 ~ e ~ eH ~ AOlTOJIHeHlirr, IlpeJIJOXeHHhIe 0603pe~a~ H S~H~ T aw TWMH.
m
~OBOPKTIH, H a n p H M e p . YTO H H e O C B ~ K T I , m m 0~6 p a 3 0 ~ K w o e ~ ~ p 0 ~ 0 3 3 p eCm K e~ ~ ~ I B ~ H ~ aT o6pase C R X ~ ~ H noH , CKOJIbKy, B KOHeUHOM CYeTe, TO, UTO MbI A~I?cTBHTUI~HO AyMaeM H UTO c060ii n p e A c T a m R e M , R B C T B Y ~H e T O ~ ~ K~3 O c @ o ~ M ~ J I H ~ o B ~ H HH ~ aI M X H M W P O B O ~ ~ ~ ~HO H UH~ H, 3 HaZIlllX ~ O C T ~ ~ K O~ B .I P W SO ~s M a ~~ e ~RaR~coxanem, ~ e , STO H e CMOI' H&TW BpeMeHEi H MeCTa XOTR 6b1AJIlI TOI'O, Y T O ~ HKPaTKO o m c a n TO, STO ~ p e 6 y e ~3c ~~ .3wary y R o c T a w m~pyrw~. H a K o H e q , B OAHOM H onamcb B e p e H ce6e. 5I y 6 e m e ~ , 'IT0 AJLR TOI'O, S T O ~ Ho6nwan ~ O J I H O T O CO3HaHlirr ~~ B HHTeJIn e m y a r i a a o M maae, ~ a m q o ws ~ yH a c HWO H e ~ o n b y~Mo e n O l T p e A W T b MUPOB033peHHe Ap)TKX JIIOAefi, HO H OTAaBaTb O R e T B CBOeM C O ~ C T B ~ H H O M :n O S e M y O H 0 H U e H n 0 S e M y CpeAIl MHOI'HX BapHaHTOB MbI B C e - T a m CSHTaeM HCTHHHbIM WMeHHO er0. fl M O W JIMlrrb H w e R T b C R , S T 0 3 T a KHLlra n O M O X e T cnena-ra mar H a nym K P ~ ~ B H TCO~CTB~HHOI'O H ~ C~MOCO~H~H m , a T a K X e H a P H T OTCTaElBaTb CBOe MHPOB033PeHHe. B A o n o n H e m e K w o B a M 6 n a r o ~ a p ~ o c mK,m o p H e R sbrpaxam B C H o c K a x , R 0 ~ 0 6 0 X o T e n 6b1 n o 6 n a r o ~ a p ~ Cn~ m e H a Sopna, I ' e H e p a n b H o r o A k i p e K T o p a w 3 ~ a ~ e n b c ~uHamld sa Shaw Publishem*. M ~ o r noe T H a s w OH n p e m o m M H e HWOm a 3 ~ a r m e n a ~ yrraoc T b 3~01-o M a T e p w a n a B swe n e m f i AJI~I yVaCTHLlKOB XPHCTW~HCKOI'O HCCJIeAOBaTeJIbCKOI'O n p O e K T a , opram30sa~~oM r o~ X ~ H H B ~ P C H T ~ T C KXEp ~HMc n i a H c m M COAp)GKeCTBOM, ~ o ~ o p b rn ipiO X O A K l B C e A a p K a ~ n y B c MmwraHe. OH, a T a w e T o M a c T p e s e T a H , T o x e y ~ a c T B o s a ~ r r r k iBi i3 ~ 0 j i I I p O m a M M e , AaJ'IH M H e ~ ~ ~ B O C X O ACOBeT H ~ I ~OTHOCHTeAbHO H m o x e H m M a T e p H a n a H, I c p o M e T o r o , o K a s a n a cy-rqecTseHHym n O M O u b , KpHTIlSeCKu OUeHHBaR MOH H3bICKaHIlR B 06nacm T w n o n o m I i ~ ~ p 0 ~ 0 3 3 pce M~ O~Mf ~i H Tn~e p ~ o i irry6nw~aqmi TOG KHWTW. C p e ~ aT e x , KTO npogen 3 ~ pyy K o n H c b H n o M o r crnamnb HeKOTOpbIe lUepOXOBaTOCTH, R XOTeA 6b1 H a 3 B a T b C T H B e H a 3 ~ a ~ cOsa a , rwsaecca, Uapnsa X ~ M ~ THOKefi~a H~ H~~ema. MM, a T a m e penamopy ~ 3 ~ a ~ e n b cA>Keii~cy ma Xpepy H
H,
BbTpUCaH) CBOH) WCKPCHHIOH) IIPN3HaTeJIbHOCTb. k3, HaKOHeU, H XClTWI 6h1 n o 6 n a r o ~ a p ~MHOrtrx ~b C T y ~ e H T O B , rIOCel.qaBIlIEM MOW newmi a m a c c H M e 3 a ~ 1 1 K mC T O ~ ~ KBOw e p x a B m m c MOH) KPHTWKY pa3JIWiHbIX B 3 T W O B H a 3TOT MWP.
TO Xe KaCaeTCR HeyAaqHbIX ~bIpa)l(eHHfi kI RBHbIX OWH~ O K TO , OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3 8 H m , YBM, Jle3KWT H a MHe. JxeiiMc B. Caiip, ~ 0 9 6 p b1987 2.
Ho r a c T o H a n e p e n o n H e H H b l x y n M u a x H a w e r o M e W y M e O X ~ C T O W ~ H H6O0 p~b 6 b 1 BO~HM~ K e~ e~ bT~ p a a x~e~n aoHeM e ~ I O C CMblCJl T M ~ H~ B W l~l 0~r p e 6 e ~ ~ 0 XM3HM: h P ~ C TXaWa ~ T PaCTPaTMTb B e C b H a U O r O H b M H e Y e M H Y Q CMJY l
Ha OTblCKaHMe MCTMHHOTO, n0Q, JMl HHOrO nyTM; TOMMTCTpaCTHOe C T p e M J l e H M e nPOHMKHyTb
BT
~ ~ 3 HT O Y r 0 C e P A u a , KOTOPOe ~ ~ ~ T BC HaC F I
T ~ HeMCTOBO, K TaK CMJlbHO, O T K Y AM~b l M K y A a W e M .
- nOCTVIClb,
MMpa
~ ~ o c ~ o &EHO, X ~ HW! KaK BeJIWIeCTBeHHO HMR T B Ono ~ ~ c e Bseme! Cnasa TBOXnpocrHpaeTcH npeshnrre ~e6ec! H3 YCT M.rra,rceweB H r p y A m ~ e ~ eTH f i y c ~ p o mxljany, p a H BparOB TBOKX, Aa6b1 CAenaTb ~ ~ ~ M o J I B H Bpara ~ I M ti MCTKTeNI.
K o r ~ a~ 3 ~ p aH m Ha ~ e 6 e c a TBOH,- Am0 TBOKX IIepCTOB, Ha JrYHY H 3Be3Ab1, KOTOPbIe T ~nOCTaBUn, I TO UTO eCTb UeJIOBeK, UTO T ~ UOMHZllIlb I er0, ti CbIH ~enoseseciafi,UTO T ~nocewaem I ero? He M H O ~ O TM manun ero npen amenam; cnaBom ti UecTtim p e m m ero; nocTasm ero m a b ~ ~ o~ m a , r cAenaMH pylc TBOKX;Bce nOJIOXWI l7OA HOrH WO: OBeq ti BOJIOB BCeX, H Tame llOJIeBbIX 38epefi, nTHU He6ec~bIXH pb16 MOPCKMX, BCe, npexo&nqee MOPC M M H CTe3RMM. ~ O C ~ O A HE0Xe , H ~ I U !K ~ BeJIMUeCTB~HHO K HhUI T B Ono ~ ~ c e i3eme!u i 8).
(nc.
K ~ KKQAtiHaJlbHaH ~R pa3Hllqa MeXJ(y M~OB033PeHWMH, BbIpZiCeHHbIMH B 3THX c T H X O T B O P ~ H ~ no ! CyTH AeJIa, PeUb meT o myx cosepluemo p a s a m
BceneHHaIx, H TeM H e MeHee 06a CTkZXOTBOPeHHH He IIePeCTamT 3BPaTb B yMe H AylUe COBpeMeHHOrO UeJIOBeM. MHOIW~ M3 TeX, KT0 COlXaCeH CO CTHB~HOM Kpeii~oH ~ e, IIpOCTO n 0 M W BeJIHUeCTBeHHOe H npeKpacHoe y-rsepmemie ncamionesqa, UTO EOUH AecHsqa AepmzlT KOCMOC H YTO OH J I ~ ~ I ICT~ o f HapOD. i OHH TOTO, U e r O we He M O W HCKpeHHe nptiH5ITb. EpeI.Ub, n0HBllBI U m C H B pe3YJIbTaTe WaTbI m3HeHHOrO CTePXHH, llOXOlK2i Ha -ry 6e3~1iy,~ o ~ o p apassep3ae~cx rr B cepnqe p e 6 e ~ ~KorAa a , ero OTeq yMtipaeT. kI MK CTPaCTHO XeJIaIOT Te, KT0 we H e BepHT B Eora, U T O ~ ~UTO-TO I 3anOJIHWIO 3TY ~YCTO'TY! OAH~KO MHorkie ti3 Tex, KTO cornaceH c ncmonesqeM a U ~ RBepa B r o c n o ~ aEora He m a m a c ~ o e i icmbr ti He ocKyAena, ~ce-b am spcmyro~ Hanpmeme, c o m b ~ ~ Bo CTHe XOTBOPeHkiM Kpeii~a. fia, kiMeHH0 TaK Ow)%&ieT ce651UelIOBeK,
~ o T ~ ~ x B I . L 50ra. I H ~ fia, kZMeMO 3T0 U Y B C T B P T Te, Y KOrO HeT BepbI B ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y HntiUHOr0 O~O ~OC~ B IC O ~ JA ~ ~~ HH O O' I~Y ~~ : eHkie, OAMHOYeCTBO II
AWe
OTYa5IHHe.
B c n m ~ ~KaK a ~ 6opon~cb , 3a
Bepy H ~ U H n p e ~ e c m e H -
MUKM R QeBXTHaIJaTOM BeKe, MbI BkiqMM, ZPTO M H O r U e T a K H H e ycnexiiz ee o6pecm. Y . ~ H 0 ~B CMepTH T~HHUCOH nIicaJI:
C B o e r o ~ I ' I H ~ K OApJTa, ~O
H ~ BMc e
HeneaoMo, u noToMy MH c v w e M , f i Mary nMlrra B e y K m , YTO o n ~ a x j i ~ AoGpo H a c 06ma~enb1-10 ~aiipie~, M 3:< ~ M M nOp w~ e T ~ e c w b zrepes.
M
l[i1'1'0 KL1CaCTCR CiiMOrO
TCHHMCOH~~, TO B K O H u e
KOHqOB OH
s6pera Bepy, OBHaKO H a 60pb6y flLlAH rOAb1. Ckpz-wreme r n a z c ~ a ~Rb ce6e B e p y , o r r p e A e m T b c B o e ;v.L,pOBcE3peltlkne, CBOM IB3rNLILl liQa PeLTLWOCTb
-
BOT ln6My rri;iBrrrlieHa 3 ~ wiwra. a C @ o p ~ m b ~ 1.on~n.i o G s p e ~ mee , uenb h:OCTCIkIT R TOM, 9 ~ 0 6 ~ 1 : KpaTKO O X a p a k T e p u 3 O B a T b OCtIOBHbIe MkiPOB033pe-
HHX, KOTOPLle OnpeAeJlHEoT, K a K MLI A y M a e M 0 CaMHX
p p y a . ~ xn m n ~ x ,wipe
nplapofiw,
o Eore mli o
ce6e,
a t o ~ e ~ ~ o i i
pcan LHOCTM; ?) IIpOCJIeAHTb B HCTOpHVeCKOAf
KOHTeKCTe, KaK OHH pasHMBWFihklCb M KaK H a CMeHy 'J'eMCTWIeCKOMy MMpOBO33PeHMIO
ITFtHlllflM AeM3M, HaTyJlaJIM3M, HIITKIIHShl, 3K3IICTeHIJHaTJH3M, R O C T O ' J M ~ YMMCTIiUM3M ~~ H HOBOe C 0 3 H a H I l e , XapaICTepHOe AJI5I
4l4ca~;oroR e ~ a * ; 3) F!OCOBeTOBaTb
HCeM FraM MblCJIMl'b B KOHTeKCTe MHPO8033~e133fi,'TO eCTb OC03Hl.iEElX H e TOJIbKO TO, #aK MBICJIHM M U c a m , HO 11 KaK TO A e n a m T A p y r H e , Y T O ~ c~HI a w m a n o m n , a 3 x r e ~o6pec.m n o , q n m e H o e o 6 u e m e B H a m e M m m p a J I H c m e CKOM 061.qec~~e. 3 a ~ a r aH e M a n a r r , w, no C ~ T K A e n a , B c e TO noxoxe H a 3kiJWy BC& X H 3 H H . fl XOTen 6b1, ~ ~ 0 6TaK 6 1O H 0 ki 66~10 AJUI TeX, KFO CIMTXT 3TY KHLI1y II B C e p b e 3 BOCIIpHHHMaeT ee BbIBOAbI. TO,
YTO 3AeCb HiUIHCaHO, - TOlXbKO BBeAeHIIe K T O W , S T 0 BnOJTPIe MOXeT CTaTb HillLIHM 06pa.30~mE13HH. K o r ~ an n H c m 3Ty KHHIY, M H e O C 0 6 e H H o T p Y a H 9 66~10 ~ O H I I T ~YTO , HenpeMeHHo 0 B I U Z ~ Y HB TH ~ ee, a r T o M O ~ O O~~CTHT HO ~ .n O c K o n b K y rr p a c c M a T p E i s m ee n m K ~ BBeAeK H H e , TO, 110 B03MOXHOCTIIY IIbITaTlCX 6 b 1 ~ bHeMHC)TOCJIORHbM: 34qava COCTOrrJIa B TOM, Y T O ~ RbHBWTb ~I CYTb T o r 0 KBH HIIOr(4 MHpOB033PeHLltI, HaMeTHTb er0 C m b P r a I e FI 3 n e nepexoaan ~ K cnenymwew.
cna6b1e CTC)POHbC 1.i
T ~ HMe M e H e e n cren H ~ O ~ X O ~ I I Msncmm~w~r, ~IM B w ~ r -re y TeKCT)Q.JIbFihte Im G I I ~ J I K O ~ ~ ~ @ I I Y ~ C KCHOCKH, M~ KOTOpbIe, x H w e m b , AY i i T a T e m o 6omme, H e x e m cami rnaBLr. E ~ KTO-TO X 0 9 e T IIOCKOpee lI03ZFaKOhiIiTbCFI C TeM, YTO R CUWTaK3 CyI%Kl BOIIpOCa, TO OH M O X e T CIIOKOGHO nJPOlIyCTII'Tb 3TH CHOCKEI, OnHaKO JIJH TeX, KT0 XOYeT ABIIraTbCW CaMOCTORTeXb-
H
HO, OHH M O W OKa3iLTbCR IIOJIe3HbIMZI, AaBaR M a T e p H a n )?JR ~ Z l J ' I b ~ e h L I e r 0YTeHIlrr EI &iJIb~efilUHX BOIIpOCOB, ~pe6ymwrrx
uccnenosamm. qTO TAKOE MHPOBO33PEHME7
Ha C T ~ ~ H M3 ~~0 ~f Ki XP I M ~ HB C K O IIOKBRT" ~ ~ LR MhltHa T;P#?XY @moco@o~, K ~ Kf i a ~ o sA , ~ U C T O TC~aJp~~~pK, a ~ m 1,r Husrue, HO ee ~enbsrr~ a . 3 s z i ~cTporo b @mocoQc~oB.Pasrrbx 06pa30~,HeCMOTpH H a TO YTO B p e M R OT B p e M e H K M M 6 y ~ e ~ y n O M l t H a T b T e K o m e n q H E I , KOTOpbIe 611ara,naprr Anoc=~o,~y namy, Asrycna~y,Q o ~ AKBLIHCKOMY e r n Xaw ~ b b s r i ~ y
wya.
BOIULa B I U E I ~ O K M o ~~H~X O A , - 3TO H e ~ O T O C . ~ I O B C K H ~ ~ .%a K H W a IIOCBHweHa TEIlIOnO~EIkiM E I ~ o B O ~ ~ II~ B~IieKOTOPbM H I ~ ~ ~ , oTHorrreHkirn. o H a n p e a c T a m R e T c R 6onee oc~o~ononarammr,efi~ HeXeJIki @ o p M a ~ b ~ b kiCCJIeAOBaHEIR te B 0 6 i i a c ~@M-~OCO@H~R ~ r w k i ~ O T O C J I O B ~ ~IiI~aye R. r o B o p a , TO mxra o M w p a x , C ~ I O P M M POBaHHbIX TeMH CJIOBaMH ki m e R M H , KOTOpbIe RMeCTe O ~ ~ B S W J T 6onee f i 1 H M e H e e I I O C J I e , 4 O B i 3 T e J I b ~CEICTeMy KOOPAEiHiU B c r o ~ o f iMbICJIM ki 4 e f i ~ ~ B k i3.R fl~.ulIbHeMHOsHe IIMeEoT TO, YTO 1 1 p ~ 6 ~ 1 1 ~ l i m b c6b1 b K RCHO ~blpiUCe~~0fi @H.JIOCO@CKO~~ CHCTeMe, no ~ p a f i ~ eM I ?e p e B TOM B m e , B KaKoM m a H ~ J I ~ ~ ~H ~~ BT~CC TRH ~ I M@moco@am. EI IiI M H e A y M a e T c x , YTO ewe MeHbLue T e x , KTO pacn0narae-r 0 6 ~ ~ 5KTeJIbHO C @ O P M E I P O B ~ H H OT~~~o J I o I u ~ ~ O ~ .A H ~ K yO K m O r O eCTb
0-
MWPOB033peHHe. pa3, KOrAa KTO-TO H 3 HaC HaYWHaeT 0 YeM-TO AYMaTb - 6ynb TO ~ r r y ~ a f i H aMbICJIb H (Tne MOH YacbI?) WIH my6omfi ~ o q o (KTO c R?), - M ~ AI e n a e M TO B M H ~ O B O ~ 3peHYeCKOM KOHTeKCTe. HO C P AeJIa, Mar MOXeM MbICJIWTb TOJIbKO l l p H YCJIOBHH, !IT0 y H a C eCTb MHPOB033PeHHe, KaKUM 6b1 OCHOBaTeJIbHbIM lZTIH llPOCTbIM O H 0 HU 6 ~ 1 0 . Ho vmo x e smo maicoe - ~uposo33pe~ue? lTovwy OHO marc s a x ~ dm o scex H a c ? B e d b a ~urcozdao HeM H e u b t u a / l . Karc a ~ o z e 2 0 u ~ e m b ? M H o r H eT a K W CKiiXyT. B %0fi CBR3W BCAOMWHaeTCH
y
rocnoms X y p n e ~ a3 nbecar Monbepa a M e q a ~ so u ~dsoparrcm60,K O T O P ~H I ~e~o m a H H o sbrrrcm, YTO B T e v e H a e c o p o K a nm rOBOpWI rIp030fi, COBepIIIeHHO H e IIOAO3peBaR 06 %OM. O A H ~ KO ropa3~oBa>KHee onpenenmb c B o e c o 6 c m e ~ ~ o Me H~OBOSspewe. Ho cw nena, TO H ~ O ~ X O & H M ~mar & H a nym K C ~ M O O C O ~ H ~ H Zn Io ~c ,T m c e m m c e 6 ~ caMoro w ocMrxnemK) CBO& JIWYHOCTM. H T ~ K YTO , Xe TaKOe M H p 0 ~ 0 3 3 p e H U e ?K ~ ~ T K O MOXHO CKa3aTb TaK: MIIPOB033peHkIe - 3 T 0 PRA rIpeAllOCbUIOK (HCTHHH~IX IIOJlHOCTbK), OTYaCTH W I K COBePIIIeHHO JIoXHblX), KOTOPbIX MbI n p H A e p w l B a e M C R ( ~ 0 3 H a ~ e J I b Hl 0z n H 6eccos~aTeJIbHO, nOCJIeAOBaTeJIbH0 W H H ~ ~ o C J I ~ A O B ~ T ~ J IpZ3MMI.I~HO), JXXR 06 OCHOBH~IXC n a r a e M m H a m e r o M w p a . Dame ewe H e H a v a B M ~ I C N I T ~ ,B e e M ~ In p a s ~ a e r~T,o HeYTO C m e C T B y e T . HH~IMH CJIOBaMW, BCHKOe MHPOB033PeHHe IIpeAIIOJIaraeT, YTO eCTb HeYTO, H e A0nyCKa.H MbICJIW, !IT0 MOXeT c ~ e c ' k B 0 B a ~HHYTO. b %a npeAnOCbIJIKa HaCTOJIbKO H 3 H a Y U l b H a , YTO ~ O I I ~ L L ~ H H C T B ~3 O H a c name w H e n y M a e T , YTO A o r r y c K a e T ee 4. MH CYWTaeM TO C J I ~ K O MOYeBIZqHbIM W, c n e n o s a T e n b H o , H e AyMaeM, YTO 06 3TOM CTOWT W JTIOMWHaTb. KOH~YHO Xe, YTOTO e ~ ~ Da, b ! 3 T 0 TaK, W B 3TOM BCe AeJIO. Ems M H 3~01-0H e
~m I Y e r o H e AocTkiraeM. K ~ H Km o r H e Apynie 9llPOCTbIe>, QaKTbI, KOTOPbIe AaHbI H a M BO ~ c e f ci B 0 e f i H e l l o CpeACTBeHHOCTW, 3TOT WMeeT O Q O M H ~ CMbICJI. ~ OCO~H~ TOTO, YTO HeYTO A ~ ~ C T B I ~ T ~ J IC~W HeO C T B Y e T , eCTb HaYaJIO c o s ~ a ~ e ~ ~m3m, b ~ o f ia T a m e A B ~ XoTpacnefi @M.JIOCO@E~W: ~ema@usurcu( y r e ~ a eo ~ ~ I T W EwI zHoceofiozuu ) ( ~ e o p mn o s ~ a Hrn). OAH~KO AOBOJIbHO 6b1cTp0 MbI BbMCHRehf, YTO n p w 3 ~ a m e TOrO, YTO HeYTO A ~ ~ ~ C T B M T ~ J I Cy'LIJCCTBYeT, ~HO H e BeneT K OAHOSHBYHOMY nOHZlMaHZlIO 3 T O r 0 GHeYTO*. H C % O r 0 MOMeH-
n p a s a a e ~M ,
HH~
T a MHPOB033PeHWI HaYHHaK)T pa3JIEJaTbCX. O m H C!ikiTaK)T ( ~ e 3 a ~ a c wOT~ oTOTO, W a T I H OHH 06 m O M W I H H ~ T ) ,!IT0 e A w H c T B e m a s o c H o B o n a n a r a m r q a a c y 6 c ~ a q m- TO Mamepwr. ,Qm HHX B c e cywecmymrqee, B K o H e u H o M c u e T e , CBOAHTCR
Apyme T O X e l l p ~ e p X H B a H ) T C RTaKOrO M H ~ H W I ,HO nonaram, u ~ ma o A a H H o c m ecTb Ayx, Aywa KTIH K O A H O ~AaHHOCTH. ~
HeKaR H e M a T e p H U l b H a R ~ y 6 c T a H q m . Ho H e 6 y ~ yrmeKamcff e ~ n p H M e p a M H , u~o6arB HHX H e s a ~ e p m b cB~A. a H H o M c n p a e H a M B ~ X H O onpe~enw~b npwpo~y MHPOB033PeHWII. M ~ p 0 ~ 0 3 3 p COCTOHT e ~ ~ e H 3 pwa OCHOBHbIX
6onee WIH M e H e e C o r n a c o B a m m M e m y co6oii, c 6onbmeZi w z ~~e m m e fci T e n e m m c o 3 ~ a ~ e m ~ moccT ~a aaBaeMbnr H 6onee WIH M e H e e K C T H H H ~ . B 061qe~H q e n o M , HKKTO ~3 H a c B HMX H e C o m e B a e T c x . 0 HIM p e n K O y n o M m a m H U H APY3bX (WLW ~006rqe HLIKOTA~),H M H CaMH BCnOMHHaeM o HHX n m b B TOM cnyuae, e c n H H a r m a e M c n o p w T b c n p e A c T a npeAnocbIJroK,
BHTeAeM VyXAOrO H a M h5iPOB033peHHR.
C m b OCHOBHblX BOflPOCOB TOTO, 9~06b1 JIyYLue nOH.Rm lTpHp0Ay MHPOB033PeHWI, MOXHO PaCCMOTPeTb e T 0 B KOHTeKCTe OTBeTOB H a CIICAYK)uHe CeMb BOnpOCOB. ,$IJI
1. Ymo npedcmasmem co6oC n e p s u r ~ mpeanmocms, mo ecm b peans~ocmscmoC peansHocmu ? B o s ~ o m b r O-rBeTbr: e Eor, ~ O T H ,~aTepWiLJIbHb6i KOCMOC.
2. Karcosa npupoda s~eurrieu"no OmHoureHum rc HaM pean b ~ o cmu, mo ecmb mozo Mupa, rcomopbsu' Hac orcpyxaem? 3 ~ e c b OTBeTbI lTOKiXQT, PaCCMaTpkLBaeM nki MbI 3TOT M H P KaK COTBOp e H H b f i W I H C ~ M O A O C T ~ T O ~ HX~ ~&O, T H Y H H KIM ~~ jTIOPa09eH~ b f i K, ~ K MaTepWm K ~ p H y ~y~r ;B e p w a e M n H H~IJ.IY~ ~ 6 ' b e K T k i ~ -
H F IIHYHYiO CBR3b C M M W l H Xe T O B O P W 0 eTO 0 6 ' b e ~ ~ k i ~ ~ o f i npHpoAe,
~ o ~ o p oAO i iH a c
3. Ym0 mUKOe
H ~ M T K~KO~O Aena. re/l08eK? B a p ~ a ~OTBeTOB: m B Bb1~~11efi
c n ~ ~SOT, i i J I H Y H O C ~ , COTBOpemm no o6pasy I j o x b e ~ y KIM , ~ ~ ~ ~ B O J I O06e3bff~a. C ~ R * 4. Ymo npoucxodum s MoMeHm wepmu? 3 ~ e c bMOXHO c T e n e m CnoxHaR M a m m a ,
TOBOPHTb 0 JIH9HOCTHOM JTaCaHHH, T ~ ~ H C @ O ~B M KaKOe~ ~ H TO 6onee BHCOKOe C O C T O R M e W I H ~ ~ e l U e c T B H kB i q a p C T B 0 TeHefi,
<<noTY CTOPOHY* 3 ~ 0 kM3M.
5. n o q e ~ soo6ye y 6 0 3 M O X H O n o 3 ~ a ~ u e ?OTBeTaX B npO3ByYHT MbICJIb WlH 0 TOM, YTO Mht COTBOPeHhl no 0 6 p ~ BCeBeAyy uero Iiora, m k i YTO c 0 3 ~ a m kie p a s y h i p a 3 s k i s a n a c b B npoqecce
3~onmuww. 6. K a ~ m06pa.30~MU y3tia&, Ymo npa8unb~o u lrmo He6epHO? O ~ M T ~ - T ~ K J IMOXHO OTBeTkiTb, YTO 3TO IIPOkiCXOAkiT n m o h l y , YTO MM, B~PORTHO, c m ~ o p e mno ~ o6pa3y Eora, Ko~opbriio 6 n a ~ a 6 e ~n m X~a p a K T e p o M , ki YTO n p a B K A b H O e ki H e n p a s K n a H o e onpeneme-rcrrno OAHOW n m b r e n o B e r e c K o M y B ~ I ~ O P Y~; p ) T ~OTBeT: fi 3Tki ~ O H I E C T@ ~ O P M ~ ~ P O W ~ n~PCO~c T O 6naroaap~C I I p e m e m m K KYJI~TYPHOM~ki n c m m e c K o M y BH-
mamm. 7 . B l r e ~CMMCII Y ~ J I O B ~ Y ~ Cucmopuu KO~ ? BO~MO)KHIJ~ omeT ~ I : ocwecmw-rb q e n k i , H a M e Y e H H b I e E O ~ O M m k i 60ra~ki; n o c q o w ~ bpaji H a 3ewe; ~ O A ~ O T O B HnTm~~ e jKi x . 1 3 3 B~M~ e c r e Cn m 6 ~ u w ki ~ CBXTbIM E O ~ Oma M Y T O - H H ~ Y Aeue. ~
B KOHTeKCTe
OCHOBHbM MHPOBO!X~PCHH# H e p e n K O BO3HW-
KaIoT ki A p j T k i e BOnpOCbI. H a n p k i ~ e p :KT0 V a B k i T 3THM MkiPOM - E o ~JIIOAki , M k i ~ o o 6 u HWKTO? e C B O ~ O A C HJIki YeJIOBCK, ma B c e H ~ I . L I ~nocTynm npe~onpeaene~ar? TOJI~KO n k i MH OAHH CO3AaeM T e kUIH H H M e ~ ~ H H O C T I I~?e f i c T B k i T e J I b H 0JIM 60r 6nar? JIIiYHOCTb OH EZTIki HeYTO 6 e m ~ 1 ~ 0Cem ?e C T B Y e T n k i OH H a c a M o M ~ e n e Ecnw ? s a ~ a s a 3n ~ kBi o n p o c h I B ~ a ~ onocnenofi BaTeJIbHOcTki, OHH nPOCTO MOryT c 6 a ~ b C TOJIKy. K o r ~ a OTBeTbI Ka>KyrCR HaM BnOJIHe OYeBHAHbIMki, TOrAa H a M HHTepeCHO, nOYeMy KTO-TO ~ ~ C ~ O K O H T ki CR 3 a A a e T KX, KOrAa HeT, TO MbI c a m XOTHM y s ~ a n MOXHO , n k i O T B ~ T H TH~ a 3 ~ k mnpocH i XOT~ c ~ a ~ o j i aoneji - ~ o o n p e A e n e H H o c T k i . ECJWH a M K a m e T c R , YTO OHM CJIIllLZKOM O T l e B m H b I ki, CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, 3AeCb H e 9 e r O PaCCMaTpkiBaTb, 3HaYIIT y HaC eCTb MkiPOB033peHHe, OAHaKO H e T w MbIcnki o TOM, YTO M H O ero ~ ~ H e pa3Aencrm-r. H ~ M H ~ O nOHXTb, YTO MLI m B e M B rIJIH)paTIIICTHYeCKOM 061qecr~e,ki, CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, TO, 9 T O O Y e B m H O AJIH HaC, MOXeT 6b1n a a ~ c ~ onombmp> ii ~ J I RH a u e r o 6~1mcajjllLIero coceaa. E c n k i MbI H e A O ~ ~ C K ~ ~ M ' ~TO T MbI O ~ OYeHb O , HakiBHbI ki H a M H a 0 B H M M ~ T ~ J IlIPWCMOTpeTbC5I ~~~O K XH3HEI B COBpeMeHHOM Mwpe. C ~pyrofi C T O ~ O H ~eI c , m M ~AyMaeM, I YTO HH H a OAHH ki3 3TIlX BOnPOCO~HeJ'Ib3ROTBeTkiTb, H e n p k i 6 e r ~ K y ~M o m e H m e CTBY EZTIH H e COBepllrkiB k i H ~ e J h I e ~ a J I b ~C0 ~ r 0M O ~ ~ H ~ TO, ~ C T B ~ ,
noxoxe,
MH yxe y c ~ o m k ionpenenemoe M W P O B O ~ ~ ~ ~ H W ~ : H e K W @o~M)' CKenTKqK3Ma, K W O p m B CBOeM KpaAHeM BbIpaX e H H K BeAeT K HWlXJlK3M)'. Beno B TOM, TITO B J I I O ~ O McnrJae MM ~ c e - ~ acornmam eMCR C KaKEIMH-TO OTB~TaMK. MM 3aHKMaeM T'j E13IH KHYIO ll03KqKK), H HeXeJIaHEle lTPKHRTb KaKOe-TO MKpOB033peHHe, B CBOK) OTIepeAb, TOXe OKa3bIBaeTCX MKPOB033peHKeM WIH, no K p a i i ~ e i i M e p e , o n p e ~ e n e ~ ~ @moco@c~oii oii YCT~HOBKO~~. OAHHM CJIOBOM, AeBaTbCR HeKyAa. n 0 K a MbI )KZIBeM, MbI 6 y ~ e ~ N l T b IZTM C O ~ H ~ T ~ J I ~ mH kiO~~ ~~ c, c o ~ H ~ T ~ J)KZI3HbK), I ~ H o ~ K amop rroii KHKM n o n a r a e T , YTO n e p B o e n p e A n o s m T e n b H e e . tam^ 06pa30~,n o c n e A y I o u H e r n a s b I ( m m ~3 K W O ~ ~ I X n W B W e H a K~KoM)'-JIH~o M ~ O B O ~ ~ P ~ H WAOJIXHbI K)) lTpOXCH H T ~pawmsble s a p k i a m b x . M ~ paccMo-rpKM, I K ~ K-oe M W P O B O ~ ~ ~O~mH e YKa e~T H a c e M b n e p e Y H c n e H H b r x ~ o r r p o c o ~ , ki B pe3yJIbTaTe IIOJIrJKM B03MOXHOCTb KCCJIeAOBaTb K W O e K 3 HKX, y B w e T b M cxoAcTBa K pammm K n p e A n o n o x m e n b H o OqeHHTb B M C O ~ C T R ~ H H OKOHTeKCTe, M a T a K X e C TOYKEI 3 P e H W I ApFKX MKp0~033pe~~llfi. UTO KacaeTcH M o e r o ~3rnmaH a ~ w p TO , OH B~IIIBHTCII n0YTki Cpa3y, OAHaKO, Y T O ~ WnPe,Q)TIpeAIlTb BCXYeCKEIe normm, CKW, TITO p e Y b 0 HeM noii4e~B cne~yroueiirAaBe. T ~ HMe M e H e e AaHHaR mwra - TO H e npo~03marrre~we M o e r o co6c~BeHHOrO B3~JIXJJaH a MKP, a H3JIOXeHKe H KpKTKYeCKiilE 0 U e H K a p a m m m B a p k i a m o B BbI60pa. E c n ~ B xOAe 3~01-0 KccneAosaH W TIKTaTeAb OC03HaeT CBOe MHPOBOCIIPKl%TKe, KaK-TO K3MeHHT ero ma CAenaeT 6onee X C H ~ I M , TO r n a B H a X qenb KHMM 6yAeT A o c m r H y r a . C ~ ~ C TMHOrO B ~ ~~e p T6 a r r b m mki K0HUenT)'aJIbHbIX MK-
OAHK6bITYIC)T We AaBHO, A p F k i e TOAbKO @OPMHPYIOTCII. K a ~ o i Ki 3 HZ.IX B ~ Z I ~UTO ? BaM ~JJHXC B C ~ T O ?
POB.
MMP, 60XbMM BEnML1MEM ~POHM~AHH~I~ XPMCTMAHCKM~~ TEM3M) MMp, 6 0 ~ b MBeJlMqMeM ~ ~ ~ P O H M ~ ~ CTOPMT, CBePKaR BeCb, KaK aMaJlbraMa, OH BenMqaeTcR, n 0 ~ 0 6 ~ 1xnaMy, cb M
PYUIMTCFI. L(TO X Mbl
He B H e M J l e M
H H ~ I ~ ,
Bb1308~?
B 3anmOM MHpe A0 KOHIJa CeMH&4IJaTOrOBeKa npeo6na~ m TeIlcTmecKoe o ~ a p o ~ o s s p e mM e . H T ~ J ' I J I ~ I ~ I ne~~TI~w~ penmKu ( K O T O ~ L I XTOrAa ~ L I J I OCTOJIbKO Xe, CKOJIbKO H ~ e h a ~ )
AOMHHHK~H~~I
B OCHOBHOM H O C ~ H< < ~ e ~ e f i m xxapanep. jiv MOllTlH H e CO~nalIlaTbCIIC He3yHTaMH, He3yHTbI C CaHTnHKaHaMH, a m a K a H e c n p e c s ~ ~ e p ~ a ~sepKosbm c ~ o i i H TaK Aanee no ~ ~ c K o H ~ ~ H oOAHaKO c T ~ ~ ,BCe HCXOAIZnH H3 OAHMX H TeX Xe OCHOBH~IXnpeAnocmoK. Bce sepkirrki B 6 ~ 6 n e i i c ~ orpweAHro H01'0 JIHSHOCTHOTO Eora, Ko~opbriiRBIiJI Ce6rr HaM B C B O ~ M C b l ~ eBceneHHarr ; - TO Ero TBopeHwe, a renoBeK - TBopeHHe oco6oe. Ecna KaKMe-TO 6aTBb1 H pasropan~cb,OHM BeJIHCb B KOHTeKCTe TeHCTHYeCKOrO MIIPOlIOHHMaHHH. K ~ KHanpaMep, , MH nocTHraeM Eora? r l [ o c p e ~ c pa3y~~o~ Ma, OTKPOBeHHII, BepbI, C03epIJaHWK, !lepe3 K ~ K o ~ - H L ~ ~ Y A ~
AosepeHHoe naqo ma repes HenocpeAcTset-IHoe o 6 ~ e m ec
HHM?B ~ K ~ BeJIHCb M M XapluIe CnOpLI no 3THM BOnpOCaM, H A0
CIlx n O p OHIl COXPaHRHlT CBOH) aKTJ'aTIbHOCTb AJI5I TeX, KT0 ocranc~B narepe ~ e a s ~~ZTIH a . B ~ H Tnpyroji ~ B o n p o c : a3 uero, B n e p B y m o Y e p e A b , COCTOHT ~ c e n e ~ ~ H3mM?a T e p s H , Q O P M ~ I COYeTaHHH T o r 0 H A ~ ) T o ~3o~?e c y b TeHCTOB T O X e H e ~ ~ L T L O eAHHOMbiCJIHH. Q K O B ~ POJIb Y e J I o ~ e Y e c K o f iC B O ~ O A MB M H p e , r A e B e p x o B H a x B n a c T b n p H H w e m k i T E o n ? O m b nepea H a m 0 6 b 1 T l ~ a He c e ~ e f i ~ m nepenama. u C P a H H e r O CpeAHeBeKOBbH H A 0 K O m a C e M H a q a T O r O B e K a OZIeHb H e M H O I X e COMHeBaJIHCb B 6b1m~ Eora, JlllllIb eAkiHHqbI CYHTiUIH, TlTO KOHCYHaH PeaJIbHOCTb ~ ~ ~ J I HW lYH H YTO ~ CMePTb
0 3 ~ a r a enpercpameswe ~ HmHBmyaTIbHoro C ~ ~ ~ C T B O M H ~ . n p H T l H ~ HCHa: a XPHClUaHCTBO HaCTOJIbKO PaCnPOCTPaHllJIOCb B 3 a l l m H O M MMPe, YTO, He3aBHCHMO OT TOrO, BePIZTLU JIH JIIoAH BO X ~ H CHTn~ O C JIH ~TaK, ~KaK n o ~ o 6 a XpHCTHaHaM, e~ IznH HeT, BCe OHH )IUIJIH B KOHTeKCTe mefi, C @ O ~ W ~ O B ~ H H ~ I X x p ~ l c m a ~ c ~~epofi. o i i Aaxe o T s e p r a s u H e ee H e p e A K o xima B cTpaxe nepen ~JJ,CMM o r H e M m~ MyKaMH wcmumqa. IIoporH b I e IIIoAH MOrJIH O T p H q a T b X P H C T H a H C w A O ~ P O A ~ T ~ OAHaJI~, KO OHX 3 H U H , YTO C T O Y M 3PeHHX OCHOBHbIX XPHCTHBHCKIZX HOPM OHH IIOPOYHbI. HeCMOTpH H a TO YTO 3TH HOPMbI, B H e BCHKOrO COMHeHkFR, OCMbICJK5IJIHCb HMM AOBOJIbHO rpy60, OCM b I c n e m e , no C ~ T HA e n a , ~ o c m o x p ~ c r ~ a ~ c xapamep. mfi T e ~ c m r e c m enpennocbmm, n e m B u a e r ~ e - T BOr n y 6 ~ m ~e CHCTeMbI U ~ H H O C T ~O~ ~M, BnHTbIBWIH, YTO Ha3bIBaeTCH, C MOJIOKOM MaTepH. T e n e p b 3 T 0 , KOHCYHO, H e TBK. Ecna MbI H P O A m H C b B
-
3 a n m H O M M H p e , TO CerOAHH 3 T 0 H a M H X Y e r 0 H e r a p a H T H p y e T . M ~ p 0 ~ 0 3 3 p e m fMHOrO. i n p 0 n J I R f i ~ e c bno y m r r ; a M nm6oro 6onbmoro esponefic~oroma c e ~ e ~ o a ~ e ~ ~ Kropona, a ~ c ~H o r o
y n e p B o r o n o n a s m e r o c H renosem M o x e T O K ~ ~ ~ T~ ~a C~HoFOAHO fi 113 M H O ~ ~ C Tp B a m~ H Y m a B ~ ~ W O B
B ~ ~I B ~ H T C YTO ,
H a TO, YTO T a K o e m3m. IIoxoxe, YTO T e n e p b H a c n o ~ m -TO H e YAHBJIHeT, H TeJIeBH3HOHHbIM B e A m M CTaHOBHTCH BCC T p y A H e e ~ 0 6 H p a ~aYAHTOpHH) b 3a CYeT KaKMX-TO 1 L I O K H P Y f O ~ ~ HOBOCT~~~. K ~ CerOAHEI K PaCTeT Y ~ J I o B ~ KI? I ~ ~ A c T~ ~aB~~ -T m ~ 6 y A ~ B o Y K ~ & K ~KOTOpaR, ~~H, mMBR B 3 a n W H O M MMPe B ABa,QqaTOM BeKe, BOClTpHHHMaeT PeaTIbHOCTb B ABYX BeCbMa HeCXOAHbIX BH,lJaX: PeaJIbHOCTb c B 0 e f i M a T e p H H PeaJIbHOCTb O T q a .
Ecn~
~ b
a0
A e n O A O ~ ~ pa3BOfia, T TO BITOnHe B 0 3 M O X H 0 , YTO c y ~ e 6 ~ o e PelLIeHMe BTOprHeTCR B ee CO3HaHHe KaK HeKOe T p e T b e B b I p m e -
M
H a e renoseuec~ofip e m b H o c m . nepen ~ e fBic T a H e T cepbesH a H rrpo6ne~a,KOrAa H m 0 6 y n e ~ PelLIaTb, KaKOBa Xe HcTLlHHaR KapTElHa M H p a .
A T e r z e p b n p e A c T a s a M IF
~ i l i ~ b ~ KOTOP& a m , mZlBeT B C e M H a q a T O M B e K e Pi C ~ o n b r 6 e n k BOCnHTbIBaeTCR i B KJ'JIbTj'P-
owyrrleme C O ~ C T B ~ H H O M ~ Oe m a B m 3 ~ a0.r c p y m a m ~ q I i i iM a p ~ e Z i c m w ~ e n bc y~r rol e c T s y e T , ki OH COTBOpeH E O ~ O M O. C O ~ H ~c B e 6~ ~H EOX~HM HaMeCTHHKOM, HOM O K p y x e m a , A a m w e M
~
AXOH
o ~ b a YYBCTRYeT, YTO e M y A a H a U a C T b H m 3THM M W O M . H e r o ~peGye~crr, Y T O ~ OH ~ I lTOKlIOHILTIC5I 60q,OAHaKO HCHO,
YTO E o B~B b ~ ~ l L I eCf T i e n e H H AOCTOHH IIOKTIOHeHLIH. Heo6xo~aMO 6 b l ~ b ~OCJ'Ij'IUHbIM EM^, OAHBKO TaKOe llOCJIylIIaHKe CYHTaeTCR M C T M H H O ~CBO~OAOG, ~ IIOCKOnbKy ,?IofiH HMeHHO 3TOTO H COTBOpeHLI. M3BeCTH0, YTO E0Xbe H r O - 6naro M YTO
AX OH^
6 p e ~ r Ero r n e r K o . Eonee T o r o , E o x b ~ 3anosen~B o c n p a m M a HlTCR KBK H 3 H a Y U l b H O HPaBCTBeHHbIe. OH 3 H a e T , YTO JIIofiH, C B O ~ O A H L IB~ CBOeM TBOPYeCKOM OTHOlLIeHIlH K 0~pyXi31owefi I.IX B C ~ J I ~ H H O ~MOTJT ~, nOCTI.ITaTb ee T ~ H ~ @I O, P M H P O B ~ TII ~ 0 6 y c T p a ~ B a T bee, KaK 6 0 ~ O M~O n p a~ B H T e l I k f , BO3AeJIbIBaIowae Ero can a n p e n c T a a r r r r m L q H e EMY~IJIOALICBOHX ~ p y n m~ o~ H c m H H o e 6orocnyxeme, - TOMY E o q , K O T O P ~ YWT I ~ ~C B O ~ mopeme, x-imenm Ero c~060nofia AOCTOMHCTBOM. C n e ~ o s a ~ e na ~ M e~e o T c,r r o c H o s a a JIJR o 6 p e ~ e ~ cM mb r c n a X H ~ H H , a A J ~ RO n p e A e n e H H b r x H p a s c T B e H H L r x H a u m , a T a m i c e ,D,.JM B O n p O C a 0 C O ~ C T B ~ H HHAeHTHYHOCTH. O~~ B p e ~ r anOCTOJIOB r a6cyp~aewe H e H a c T y n m o . Aaxe ~ l r e ~ c n ~ p o ~ ~ c ompfoin b n k f p ( 6 b 1 ~ bMOXeT, ~ a M b 1 f i~ M ~ H ~ ~ rep0fi C I I ~*I - ~ T J I H ~ ~ c K o ~ o P e ~ e c c a ~ cHa e) n p m o A a T K n o n H o M y onarrmm. K p o ~ Teo r o , 6onee no3a~wenbecH LUe~cnapaA a m T o c H o s a m e AyMaTb, YTO OH T o x e B n o n H e 6 n a r o n o n y ~ npeononen ~o TOT M o M e H T m a RHWI M, B K O H q e KOHqOB, CyMeJI YCMO'QeTb B 3TOM M H p e CMHCJI
a3~a~eme. tam^ o 6 p a s o ~H, a m e H c c n e n o s a H t i e nywre B c e r o H a v a T b C TeH3Ma. &O @ ) W , & ~ M ~ H T ~ ~ I B3l'nm ~ H ~ I G H a M a p , HMeHHO I13 H e r o 6epy-r c B o e H a v a n o B c e npovae M Z I ~ O B O ~ K~o T ~ o~p HHe ~ , @ O P M H P ~ T C I IB n e p H o A M e m y 1700 a 1900 r o n a M a . M o m 0 ~ L I J I O 6 ~ I1 ~ O ~ewe ~ T AM W l b u l e B my6b BeKOB H 0 6 p a T I . I ~ b c ~K
rPeKO-PHMCKOMy KnaCCHqH3My, OAHaKO H OH, B03POA&iBUZHCb P e ~ e c c a ~ cpea,c c M a ~ p m a n c : xn o Y m H c m m Y H T e n b H o B KOHTeKCTe T e H 3 M a H l I 0 3 T O M y K T e H 3 M y MbI H T'IpHCTYfIaeM. B
',
OCHOBbl XPHCTHAHCKOrO TEH3MA
B K ~ U K & OrJIaBe ~
R lIOlIb1TaH)Cb BbTyEiHTh C p b COOTBeTCT-
B P q e r O MEIPOB033peHHR, HClTOJIb3YR MHHLlMYM KpaTKElX T e 3HCOB. B KOHTeKCTe KaXAOrO MEIPOB033PeHKH 6 y ~ PaCCMOTp pem1 c n e A y m q H e o c H o B H b r e npofine~b~: n p H p o A a H xapalcrep
Eora ma K O H ~ ~ Hp eOa r ~r b H o c m , r r p H p o A a x e s I e ~ ~ oai Yi e n o BeYeCTBa, BOlTPOc 0 TOM, YTO lIPOHCXOAHT C YeJIOBeKOM B M o M e I r r c M e p m , O c H o s a Y e n o s e Y e c K o r o n o s ~ a m o, c H o s a 3TIIKU H CMbICJI HCTOPHH C TOUKH 3 p e H H R T e H 3 M a lIep~b13H ~liX~ekIIfkI3 BOlIpOC KaCaeTCR lTpHpOAb1 60ra. ~ O C K O J I ~ K Y OH
*.
HCWIH)UHTeJIbHO 3HaUHM, H a H e r 0 MbI IlOTpaTHM MeHH, YeM H a BCe OCTaTIbHbIe.
60nbue
Bpe-
1. Eoz 6 e c l c o ~ e v eu~nurHocmeH (mpuedu~),mpaHcyeHdeHmeH u waHeHmeH, ecesedyy, 6naz 1l obnadaem sepxos~ou' snacmbm 3. Pa306be~3 T 0 l I O J I 0 X e H H e H a OTAeJIbHbIe YaCTH. dbz ~ ~ C K O H ~ YTO ~ H .3HaYHT, YTO OH - E H e BCRKOTO lIpeAeJIa H M e p b I , HaCKOJIbKO MbI M O X e M 3 T 0 llOHRTb. HHKTO ~pJT0fiBO BC& B c e n e ~ ~ oHi ei M O X e T 6b1Tb PaBHbTM EM^ no l I p H p O A e . Bce OCTLUIbHOe BTOPHYHO. OH H e H M e e T PaBHbIX, OH - H#ElJIO H K O H e q 61,1m.T O ~ ~OH KO CaMOAOCTdTOYeH B CBOeM C m e C T B O B a H H H 4. EoI' CKa3aTI M o ~ c e mW3 rOpHlI.(erO KyCTa: eCMb Cm&*(Bcx. 3: 114). OH C)'U(eCTByeT TaK, KaK HHKTO ~pJT0fiC m e C T B O B a T b H e MOXeT. * C J ~ Y I kispamb: ~I~~, ~ O C ~ T O 60r D ~ , H a m , ~ ' o c J I o A ~ e A H H eCTb*, - RO3RCCTMJI M o ~ c e 3 ( B ~ o p 614). . X T ~ K60r , C m e C T B y e T H3HaYaTIbH0, OH - nepBHYHaR PeLUbHOCTb H, KaK MbI n O I G W e M IIO3&Hee, HCTOYHUK B C X K O ~N H O ~PeaTIbHOCTH.
dbt? AUYHOC?7ZeH.TO eCTb, 60r H e lIpOCT0 KGKaR-TO C m a , 3~eprru1ma * c ~ ~ c T ~ H L ~ H REor * . - OH; 3 T 0 o s ~ a ~ a YTO e~, Eor - JIHYHOCT~. J I ~ H O Cme T ~npenn0narae-r H a r r a r H e ~ s y x OCHOBHbIX XaPaKTePKCTHK: 1) CaMOOC03HaHHe 11 2) CaMOOlIpeA e n e H H e . HH~IMH CJIOB~MH, Eor XUYHOCT~H, ~ O C K O J I ~ OH K~
3HaeT 0
C B O ~6M b1mki
( O C O ~ H ~C~eT6 ~ki ) lIOCKOJIbKy o 6 ~ 1 m a e ~ ( a , q y ~ a e ~ki *u , q e i i c ~ ~ y e ~ * ) .
C B O ~ ~ C ~ cO aM Mo o n p e A e n e H L l s r
~cxo,JJR kt3 3 T O r 0 , MOXHO CAeJIaTb BbIBOD, YTO OHn o ~ o 6 HaM, 0,JJHaKO 3 T 0 3HaYHJIO 6b1 nOCTaBkiTb T e J I e r y B n e p e A k i noluwLi.
Ha CaMOM Aene MM ~ I O A O ~ HEMY, ~ I OAHaKO
e~
rIOne3HO
6b1 B K p a T q e lTpOKOMMeHTIlPOBaTb II ApyTOe B b r p W e H L i e . OH no,qo6e~HaM. TO 3HaYkiT, YTO eCTb Hercmo B ~ I C L L I H ~ ~ ,
XOTR
n 0 J I a ~ a K ) m k i gOCHOBbI HalLIKM CaMbIM BbICOKZlM yCTpeMJIeH&WM H HUUeMy CaMOMy A p a r O q e H H O M y AOCTORHLIH) - IIIIZIHOCTH. HO
6onee no,qpo6~oMbI apenero ~ e s a c a . Apyroe
IIOrOBOpwM
06
3TOM, KOrDa KOCHeMCR
n o n o m e H H e , K a c a m w e e c r r n k i r ~ o c ~ ~ nopi ki i p o ~ b ~
Eora, P B e p w a e T , YTO Eor - TO H e n p o c T o e e n a H c T B o , H e e,qwmqa. OH a M e e T CBOHa~pw6pb1,CBOHO C O ~ ~ H H O C T HOH . ~ e i i c m a ~ e nnpe,qcTaanrreT t~o Co6oii e m H c T B o , HO e,qwHcTBo CJIOXHOCTLI.
B XPIICTHaHCTm ( ~ B eH Y A ~ M ~ M EOZ ~ )He mOflbK0n ~ 4 ~ 0 c m b , Tpouya. TO eCTb, *BHyTpH ~ , L @ ~ H oCyrrlHOCTki Z~ 60~ecTBa HaM H a 0 PEUIkiYaTb TpW *AHqafi, KOTOPbIe HLI B KOeM CJImae HC H E U I H ~ T C Rapem 60ram, TO a p w M n o c T a c w Eora, w OHH C ~ e C T B j W COpaBHO T COBeYHO E ~ y a Tpowqa - 3 T 0 , KOHeYHO, B e n w K a x ~ a i i ~aa T, e n e p b M ~ Aaxe I H e M O X ~ Tnpwcrnlin # ee TOJIKOBaHkfK). B AaHHOM CJIyYae B-0 OTMeTIITb, YTO T p o ~ q COOTBeTCTByeT a ~ ~ J H H a J oI k ~i Y ~ o f i *l l p l i p O A e BbIClrrerO C Y W ~ C T E0r B ~ . H e TOJIbKO eCTb, HO OH C w e C T B Y e T K a K HO Ld
'.
~ W T I H O C TW ~ ,MbI MOXCM OTHOCLlTbCR K
H~MY K a,K K ~ H Y H O -
IIO~TO 31-ia~b M ~ Eora o s ~ a ~Hae reT o~ Gonbmee, H e x e n w n p O C T 0 n p w 3 H a B a T b Ero CyrrleCTBOBaHHe. TO 3HaYHT, YTO MbI MOXCM 3 H a T b Ero T a K , K a K MbI 3 H a e M 6 p a T a KJIH, W l L I e , CTW.
oTqa.
Eoz m p a ~ c y e ~ d e ~ m C en ~e. ~ o ~ a ~ e OH n ~ B~bom,e H a c li H U I e r O M H p a . OH eCTb He4ntO UHOe. B ~ ~ J I R H IHIaTKaMeI-Ib: ~ 3T0 H e Ijor, Eor n p e s b n u a e T ero. b l o c ~ o - r p k i ~ eH a renosem: TO T o x e H e Ijor, Ijor s L m e renosem. 0 , q ~ a ~ TO o He 03~arae~, YTO OHH e H M e e T HIIKaKOTO OTHOlrreHLlR K H a M H HalLIeMy MHPY. B e p ~ ow TO, YTO dbz mMaHeHmeH w, c n e A o B a T e n b H o , OH c HaMH. B ~ ~ J I R H L IHTa ~KaMeHb: apme H a r e n o B e K a : w B H e M
E0r npLICyTCTByeT B HeM. h l O C ~ 0 Ijor n p w c p c m y e T . E ~ I MTo x~e T ,
B TOM K p o e T c R ~ a ~ o e - n TpOm w ~ o p e r ~ M e ? ~ Bw TOM rrymcre TeH3M n p e A c T a m e T co6oii ~ ~ C C M ~ I C J I H Amam, U~? YTO HeT. K o r ~ a~ o e iAi o r e p w K3pon 6 ~ x m 0 ~b neT, OHa M H O ~ O M ~ M e m HayYwra. O A H ~ om ~ cIM a T e p b m cmenw H a m e , H MaTb CKa3aTIa, YTO 60r IIPWCYTCTBYeT BCWAY. - A B ~ o c T H H o ~60r ~ e c ~ b ?- cnpocma - Aa, - o m e m a M a n .
Kspon.
-ABm e ?
- fla,
-
6bm
OTB~T.
- ~ H ~ Y W Tff , XO)ICY no Eory? @ HeOXH&aHHOCTH MOR X e H a H e HWJJIaCb, YTO OTBeTHTb.
Ho
~ O C M O T ~ W MYTO , noJTyZIaeTcR.
I ~ P W C ~ CnT aB Eor Y 3decb ~
m?
TaK Xe, KaK npHCyTCTByeT KaMeHb, KpeCJIO HJIW H ~ TH,e TaK. E0r WMMaHeHTeH, OHIIPWCYTCTBYeT U e C b W BesAe, OAHaKO
Er0 I I p W C ~ C T B H e nOJIHOCTbH, C o r n a c y e T c R C Ero T p a H C U e H AeHTHOCTbKl. E o H~e MUmepZUl, KaK BbI W R, HO H TeM H e
A~x.
MeHee
OH 3AeCb. B HOB03aBeTHOM TeKCTe n0C2-m-mK Espem
~OBOPWTCR, YTO HWCYC XPHCTOCq e p m B C ~CJIOBOM CHJIM C ~ o e i i o( E B ~1.:3). k ' l ~ aE0r ~ , BCe IIpeBOCXOAKT, HO B TO Xe B p e W OHBO BCeM npwcyrcrByeT w Bce n o m e p m s a e T .
EOEsceeedyy. TO o s ~ a u a e YTO ~ , OH 3 ~ a BeC ~~ . OH - a.IIb@a W O M e r a , W EM^ BeAOMbI HaYiLlTO W KOHeIJ (@K. 22: 13). OH - WCTOYHWK BCRKOrO 3HaHWR H BCRKOrO p a 3 y M e H W R . OH - TO Tom, Kmo stiaem. AB~opa138-1-0 n c a n ~ a~ 3 y n R e T C ~ O C O ~ H O CE0ra T~ IIpWCyTCTBOBaTb B e 3 A e , 3 H a T b eTO A U e TOrAa,
K O r n a O H (POPMHPOB~JICR
BO Y p e B e c B 0 e f i
~ a ~ e .p w EOE - uapb 6~e~letitiOu', OH o 6 ~ 1 a ~Baeep ~ x 0 B H o f i EUIaCTbm. n o cyru A e n a , TO ~am~eZirrree n p o R m e m e Eombefi 6 e c ~ o H e Y H O c m , HO B TOM 60nee n o n H o B b I p a x a e T c f f Ero clpemeHHe llpaBMTb, YfleJIruI BHHMaHMe BCeMy TOMY, YTO COBepLua(3TCR B
Ero B C ~ J I ~ H H O&OT ~.
Tt33HC CBmeTeJIbCTBYeT 0 TOM, YTO HCT
H I l r e r O , YTO ~ P e B O C X O A ~661 O Ero BepXOBHOe BJIWIHMe, BOAWTeJIbCTBO W aBTOPHTeT.
EOE6naz. 3 r o n e p B o e y T s e p y q e H w e o xapamepe Eora. H3 H e r 0 llpOHCTeKaH,T BCe OCTaTIbHbIe. E b 1 ~ ~b J I ~ I X MHJIW , AO~PMM, 0 3 H a W e T A ~ ~ C T B W T ~ J IG~ M HT O ~TaKOBbIM.
E o eCTb ~ 6 n a r o c ~ b TO ,
~
-
ecTa TO, 9eM OHa m e T c s , OH ecm 6naro. Henwa noMarcnkiTa, 9~06b16naroc~b n p e B O C X O ~ aEora, mki ~ a o 6 o p onono6ao ~. TOMY, KaK 6b1~kie- TO C ~ I ~ H O CEro T ~ ~PLIPOAM,6narocn C ~ I U H O C TEro ~ xapamepa. EOBH 6narocm BblpiUCaeTCR A B Y M IlJTIIMki:CBIITOCTbIO a nlo60~bm.
C B H T OlIOffIepKMBaeT C~ Ero a 6 c o m ~ ~ yIIpaBeAHOCTb, m KOTOPaR He TePllkiT H TeHM ma. CnOBaM ~ O C T OHJ oI ~ ~HH~, <(E0reCTb CBeT, ki HeT B H ~ M H E I K ~ K OT~bM ~ bIa (1 HH. 1:5). CBRTOCT~ Eora Ero oTneneHHomb OT Bcero, TITO kiMeeT XOTR 6b1 HaMeK Ha WO. HOE O X ~ I I ~ J I ~ TBblpiUCaeTCR OCT~ ki KaK nm60sb. B O ~ H npmo H r o ~ o p mTITO , < 6 0 r~ C T ~ J I I O ~ O(1 B HH. ~H 4: 16), ki 3TO BeAeT Ero K caMonomepTBoBamm ki K IIOJIHOTe Ero 6 n a r o ~ o n e ~C m B O ~ HapOAy, M~ K O T O P ~ IB ~ B~TXOM 3a~eTe HmbmaeTCR TaK: *Tmeii n m m OBUbIo (k. 78: 13). Amee, 6 0 ) ~ b a6narocm 0 3 ~ a 9 a eBO-nep~brx, ~, TITO cyrrleCTBYeT a 6 c o m ~ ~ HOPMa a x lIpaBeAHOCTki ( K O T O ~ ~O'IlQbIBaeTR CFI B E o x a e xapamepe) ~ a, m-BTOPMX, TITO AJM TIenoBeqemBa eCTb HmeXJT,a ( T ~ KK a K 6E0r eCTb ~ ~ o 6 0 ~ ki b OH o He OCTaBWT C ~ o emopeme). Bnocne~cmki~, KorAa M ~ ~I B ~ Z ~ HKM9eMy , lTPkiBOAkiT OTKa3 OT TeHCTEXeCKOTO B 3 r m a Ha MWP, 3'lM ABa B3akiMOAOnOAHRloULIx H a 6 ~ l o A e H6~ y ~ n p p ~ o 6 p e ~ a Bce m 6onblrry~, 3Ha9kiMOCTb.
no
TO
2. Eoz comsopw B c e n e ~ ~ yus m Hurezo (ex nihilo), rrno6~sce s ~ e u 'deu'cmsosa~os ornicpbirnou' cucrneMe no e c r n e c r n s e ~ ~ ~ ~ 3aKOHaM. Eoz comsopw BceneHHym us Hurezo. Eor - TO TOM,k h o ecrnb, ki, mmo 6brrb, OH - ~ ~ C T O Y H MBcero K O C ~ m b ~ o r HO o. B W O nOHRTb, 9TO 6 0 ~ WCTOTIHUK BceneHHoB He B TOM c ~ b ~ c n TITO e , OH COTBO~WI ee ki3 Ce6a C a ~ o r o .H ~ T Eor , npki3sm ee K 6bm1.110. OH^ Harms 6b1~ano Ero cno~y:<(B c~mm Eor: Aa 6yAeT CBeT. CTaJI CBeT,, (Earn. 1:3). UCXOAR M 3 3~01-0,60rocno~b1~OBOPHT, 51~0Ear 6comopmo ( ~ M T .1:1) B c e n e ~ ~ ex y ~nihilo, o TO emb ~3 mqero, a He ki3 C e 6 C ~ a~oro r? He ki3 K ~ K O ~ O - T O me CyrrIeCTByIoIQero xaoca (ki60 ecnki 6h1 XaOC ~ e i i ~ ~ B H ~ e ni(npeACyIUeCTBOBarrb, bH0 TO 6 b ~ 1 6b1 TaK me sereH, K ~ KsereH Eor).
Aarree, Eor comopm B c e n e ~ ~ Ky ~~ oKedunoobpasue ecmecmsennw npurun s omrcp~moiicucmenre. %a apasa amepecHa TeM, YTO B Hek KaK 6b1 3alLI~~p0BaHb1 ABe KJIIoYeBbIe K0wel-Iuaa 6. Bo-nepsblx, TO o s ~ a ~ aYTO e ~ B, c e n e ~ coTBopeHa ~a~ He KaK XaOC, H 06 3TOM CBHAeTeJIbCTByIOT BenllZIeCTBeHHbIe CTPOKH 113 KHllrll IIPOPOKa H C ~ H H :
uH60 TaK rOBOpHT ~ O C ~ O cm~opaauraii A ~ , ~ e 6 e c aOH , Eor, 0 6 p a 3 0 ~ a s m ~3emm li a c o w a ~ l u a i ee; i OH y T B e p m ee, He HanpacHo comopm ee; OH 06pasosarr ee rn mMTenbcma; Ii - r W r I o ~ b w , HeT HHOrO. He T&HO % rOBOpWI, He B TeMHOM MeCTe 3eUnEI; He r o ~ o p mIi m e M e m H a ~ o ~uHanpacHo a: ameTe Mem*. fl ~
O C ~ O Ei3peKaKlmkifi A ~ , IIpaBAy, oTKpb1BaIOm~lgEICTHHY*
(Hc. 45:18-19). BceneH~arrynopmoreaa; a Eor npeAocTasrzrr ee HaM He B xaoce, a B raphtoaww. T a m ~0 6 p a 3 0 ~ ,npapona Eoxae2i B c e n e ~ ~ oE ii iEro XapaKTep TeCHO B3aHMOCBR3aHbI. TOT M a p e c ~ TO, b YTO OH ecTb, no Kpaii~eiiMepe, omacTH, noToMy YTO Eor e c n TOT,KTO OH e c n . n o w ~ e eMM ~ B ~ I I Mam , 06pa30~ QleXOnilAeHHe nOATBepmaeT 3TO coo6paxe~ae, 3AeCb Xe AOCTaTOYHO OTMeTMTb, YTO B c ~ J I ~ H H ~~ OR p ~ O Y e HE i a o p r a m s o ~ a ~M a . ~ 3I ~ a e YTO ~ , 3 e m BpamaeTca, a nmow Conwe 6 y ~ UeB ~C X O A L I ~ *~ a m ~ b LAem. ii O A H ~ KBO~ ~ H B ~ A ~HHa mH apa3e O ~ COKpbITO erne OAHO s m o e noarrme. C a c ~ e rrarrReTcrr ~a ornlcg~rnou',TO ecTb oHa He s a n p o r p a ~ ~ a p o s aEor ~ a . nocTomHo yracTsyeT B HenpercpaI J & ~ I ~ ~Ae~XT ~eJcIbH ROCTEl B c e n e ~ ~ ono i i Mepe TOrO, KaK OHa pa3BHBaeTCR. H MM, JIloAH, Tome B 3TOM ) ? I ~ C T B Y ~ M ! H E o ~ li, MM MOXeM H3MeHkiTb XOA MElPOBOrO Pa3BHTKR. Mb1 BmIIM, ZIT0 TaKOe ApaMaTHYeCKOe EI3MeHeMe U TOH30lruI0 B MOMeHT rpeXOnaJJeHHR. &ah4 H Esa CAeJIaJIH B M ~ O P , ~ o ~ o p bmien ~ i i OrpoMHoe s ~ a ~ e moAHaKo e, Eor cnenan C ~ o i i B ~ I ~ O PH,CKJTIEIBYeJIOBeYeCTBO XPEICTOM. n0cJIe rpeXOlT~eHH%? Halrra HenpepMBHaR AeXTeJIbHOCTb Tame H ~ M ~ H I XOA I ~ TMwpoBoro ~ ~ ~ B ~ I TJTmGoe H H . Hame g e i i c ~ sue, m 6 o e peluemie nocTynaTb TaK m u maYe m ~ e w r emu, ~,
n w e
c ~ a 3 a ~ b*TBOPII~U , 6 y ~ y u e e .C6pacb1sm OTXOAM B YHCTbIe pem, MH y611~aeMp ~ 6 yw, , cJIeAosaTemH0, B 6 y ~ y u e waM npmeTcrr nHTaTbcrr m a r e . Oumuarr pem, M ~ IcHoBa w s ~ e m Hame e ~ Gy~yuee,u TaK Amee. k n w 6~ B c e n e ~ ~He m
~
6 m a ynopmoYeHa, ~ a u r wpemesm He aMenw 6~ HaKaKux p e s y ~ r b ~ ak~ n o~ a .6~ TeYeHkie c06brmji 6 w 0 npeaonpeneneHO, HamW pememrr OIIHTb-Tam He HMeJIII 6~ W K a K O r O CMbICJIa. ~ O ~ T O M YCO , IYIaCHO TeI13My, CIpYICTYpa B c e n e ~ ~ o f i ynopmoreHa, HO He npeAonpeAeneHa. M ~nym.re I n o f i ~ erTo ~, H1[33TOr0 CAeAyeT, KOrAa 6 y A e ~ paCCMaTpkiBaTb BOIIpOC 0 TOM, KaKOe MeCTO 3aHHMaeT YeJIOBeYeCTBO B KOCMOCe.
3. Ymoserc c o 3 d a ~no o6pa3y 6 o x b e ~ yu, cnedosamenb~o, o6~adaem~ u r ~ o c r n ~npupodori, ori c o 6 c m s e ~ ~ om rip a ~ c y e ~ d e ~ m HOCmbH),JMl3yMOMYHpUt?CmSeHHOCt?lbH), cnoc06~0cm K~ 06qe~um 14 msoprecmsy. Krrloye~a @pas ~ sAecb - o6pa3 60xuz.i~w 3 ~ Kowenqm a HMeeT nepBocTeneHHoe s ~ a u e ~ w XOTX e BM ~ I O T O M ~TO , oHa H HE ~ M
pass ynomHaeTcrr B A B ~ X~e6onb11rmamax w3 K
T~:
uM c m a n Eor: ComopaM YenoBeKa no o6pasy f-famew, no n o ~ o 6 a mHammy; w Aa arra,qrmecTByIoT OHH HW pb16am MOgCKkJMM, ki Hm nTHIJaMH H ~ ~ ~ C H ~ I H MH E Ia, CKOTOM, H Hm BCeH). 3eMAeEO, W H a BCCMH rmaMK, IIpeCMbIKaEo~HMHCff seme. Pi comopm 6or YenoBeKa no o6pa3y C ~ o e ~no y ,o6pa3y 6 0 m m COTBOPKJI Ero; ~ y m r w ~H yxer-nqwHy COT BOP^ IM* (&,IT. 1:26,27; cp. 5:3; 9:6). J~EOAHCoTBopeHbr no o6pasy Eombe~y,K TO o s ~ a r a eYTO ~, O M noAo6~b16 0 ~ M . ~ yxe I omerma, YTO ki 6 0 r~1 0 ~ 0 6 e ~ HaM, OAHaKO B ~ H C ~ H HrOBOpHTCfi H 06 3TOM HHaYe. K o r ~ aMM sOBOpkiM, YTO M M n o d o 6 h ~ ?~ y , TO aIUJeHTAeJIaeTCff Ha TOM, Ha s e M ero H Haao AenaTb: Ha rIepBwYHocTw Eora. MM HmeneHH JIH%-IocTHo~ I I ~ H ~ o A onO ~C ~K , OJIbKy 60r JIHYHOCTeH, TO eCTb, MM s ~ a eYTO ~ ,M ~ CyuecTByeM I (06nmae~ c m o c o s ~ a m i e H~ ) C B O ~ O A H OnpwHwMaeM perueam (TO e a b , K M ~ ~ M . C ~ I O C O ~ H O C T ~ K ~a~00npe~eJIeHkiEO). ~ P I H M HCJIOBaMK, MM MOXeM A ~ ~ C T B O BaTb CaMOCTOHTeJIbHO. MbI He IIPOCTO PearHpyeM Ha HalIIe
o q y x e m e , HO meii npapone.
nocTyllaeM c o r n a c H o HalueMy
xapamepy,
Ha-
~ O B O P H T ,YTO HeT AByX COBePlueHHO OAHHaKOBbM JIIOAeii, I3 3T0 B e p H 0 H e TOJIbKO IIOTOMy, YTO ABa YeJIOBeKa H e M O T a M e T b a6conmmo ~yx e c a M y m H a m e A c T s e m o c n a o q y x e HHe, HO II nOTOhly, YTO ~ a m ~ b lHj3i HaC o6nmae~ YHHKaJIbHbLM x a p a r c r e p o h l , B c o o T B e T c T s a a c ~mopbm M ~ MI ~ I C ~ xMe n, a e M , B3BeUIHBaeM T e k i n a HHbIe IXOCTJTIKLI, AeJIaeM 3 T 0 , IlOTBOPCTBYX ce6e, ma, om% x e , H e AeJIaeM 3~0r0,- KOpOYe roBop(I,
~ ~ 0 sb160pa 6 0 li~ A ~ ~ ~ c T B H X . KamAbrfi Y e n o s e K ( K ~ Ko6pa3) o T p a x a e T T p a H c q e y q e m H W T b E0ra no OTHOUeHHH, K Ero B C ~ J I ~ H H O 60r ~ ~ nOJIHOCTbH) . C B O ~ O A ~OT H C B O ~O~ Q yO X e H H X . M ~ MOrJILl I 6b1 CKa3aTb7 YTO OH o r p a m y e H TOJEKO CBOHM x a p a K T e p o M . 6 y ~ y y w6nar, Eor H e MOXeT JIraTb, H e MOXeT 6b1n O ~ M ~ H Y T ~ L H Me, MOXeT ~ e i i c m o s a nco a n b r H~ a M e p e H a e M a TaK Aanee. HHYTO mewH e e H e MOXeT IIpkIHyAHTb Ero. ECJIH OHP e L u a e T BOCCTaHOBHTb n R m r r y l o 3emm, TO ~ e n a TO e ~no~ohly,YTO C ~ *Mx o r e 3~01-0, ~~ nOTOhly YTO J I ~ ~ H ee.TO A H ~ KOH O C B O ~ O A ~AH~ ~ C T B O BTaK, ~ T ~ KaK n o x e n a e T , s Ero BOM o n p e n e n R e T Ero xapamep (OH TOM, KTOecn). liMeeM
Omacni li ~ a Br~ ~ X O A L 34 ~ Mn p e d a ~ Haruero olcpyxeHm. 3a HCKIIIoYeHueM 3KCTpeMitTIbHbM mEI3HeHHbM C H T Y ~ ~-H 60ne3m ma @asw~ecme n I l l r r e H m (qailmiia ronoA ma, H a n p a M e p , ~ e r r p e p b m ~ onpe6mame e B TeMHme B TeYeHae MHorkiX ~ ~ enonpm) f i - YenoseK H e p e a n i p y e T H a olcpyxeHae C K ~ K o ~ ~ - TOAH03HaYHOCTbH). o B ~HaCTYIlIinH I M H e H a IIitTIeU. TO M H e A ~ J I ~ T P)TaTbcH? ~ ? Moly. IIPOCTHTb B ~ C ? 3 T 0 MOXHO. E ~ I T MOXeT, ~
M
s a q m a ~ b Mory ? a s a ~ p a ~ aA~ ecna b . ~ J I ~ I ~ H ~ TM ~ CoHm? 0 a TaK. Moa nocTyllm O T p a x a m T ~ o fxapamep. i MM~HHOM o e a m XOYeT A ~ ~ ~ c T B o B H ~ T3 ~T 0, ~ e f i c T I 3 l l eH e 3BOH KOJIOKOJIbYWKa, KOrAa IXpOCTO AepHyJIH 3a BepeBKy. M T ~ K JIIoALl , 06rrmam~JIHYHOCTHO~~llpEip0~0fik i M O T B ~ I X O A L ~3a T ~npenem K o c M o c a , B KOTOPOM H a x o m T c R , TO e c T b OHM 9TO-TO 3HaIOT 0 HeM H MOr'J'T kI3MeH5ITb XOA YeJIOBeYeCKHX
H KOCMIIYeCM
~06h1nifi.TO ewe pas,
HO
yxe
rOrBOPHT 0 TOM, YTO KOCMIlYeCKaR CHCTeMa,
no-Ap)TOh.ry, COTBOpeHHaR
~ ~
EOI-OM, ( I ~ C T C F LO T K P ~ I T OLI~ ~I T O ~ T O M YAIOAH
MOW
ee ~ 3 ~ e -
HHTb. ~~H~HOGTHOCT -L 3, T 0 He!lTO IIPKHUMnHlUILHO BSUKHOe H e
TOnbKO
MiI H a c , JIH),Qe3, HO H ULEI E ~ l ' a , ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y HKaK O~O B
T a K li B C B O ~~M H T W .Haua JIkl!lHOCTH%f H~HBH&ytlJItrHOCTL, KOPeHKTCR B Ero JIKYHOCTH, TO eCTb B I j e H ~ B T ~ C H OCBff3H ~ ~ C HHMMbI o 6 p e ~ a e C~ BO~
C ~ 0 e f XH!~HOCTHO~~ i npHpOAe,
I ~ o , & T M H H ~AOM. L ~ ~ a B C e p A q e K m O r O YeJIOBeKa CyLL(eCTByeT IIyCTOTa, COTBOpeHHaR EOTOM*, -- IIKCaTI rk3cKaJXb. a H m e
~ a a IIOKOR, e ~ IIOKa H e JTOKOHTCR B TeGe,, - ?TO ABI'YCTMHB. K ~ K U oM6 p a 3 0 ~E0r YAONfeTBOPReT 3 T 0 BFdCOKOe YCTPeMrresae? OH AeJIaeT 3 T 0 IIO-Pa3HOMY: IIOJIHOCTbH) COOTBeTCTByR CepAUe H e
CJIOBa
C ~ M H O X~L C e ~IIpHpOAe, yA0NfeTBOpRR H W y X a m A y M e X X L n -
HOCTHOrO O ~ L T J ~ H U RBJLIIIICb R, B C B O ~BCeBeAeHllK M KOH~YHO~~ qeniro H a l u e r o c T p e m e m r r K ~ O ~ H ~ H U BH C ) , B O ~6M ec~o~e~ MOM 6b1TMM - I I P H ~ ~ X H L T J ~OT M BCIIKOrO CTpaxa, B C B O e g CBRTOCTH - ClTpaBeJ&JIHBbIM OCHOBaHHeM J&lIHH m e r O C?.peMJIe-
HIltF K CnpaBeAAHBOCTM, B C B 0 e f i ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y AHI O ~~B~HOCHOBaHMeM H a I I I e g H a e X & b I H a C n a C e H H e , B C B O ~6M ec~o-
- KCTOYHHKOM
H W e r O TBOpYeCKOrO BO-
o 6 p a x e m ~H T 0 f i B b 1 ~ I I I e f iQ a C O T H ,
KOTOPYIO MFd CTPeMHMCR
HeYHOM TBOpYeCTBe
OTpa3HTb B H m e M TBOpYeCTBe.
~ ~ O A ~ I T O ~ L M IOBW~ 0, CKa3aTb, YTO, ~ O A O ~ HEory, O MM o 6 n a a e ~urnocmnou' ~ undusudyall~.rocmwo, co6cmsennou'mpancyenderrmnocmbm, tlOHL&UaHUeM( C ~ I O C O ~ H W T ~ H~ ,~ ~ M ~ I I L U HI I I T ~ I I o ~ H ~ B ~ T Hpa8Cm8eHHMMU ~), ~ a m e Z O ~ ~( cLI I4O C O ~ H O C T ~ H ) pa3JIKYaTb ~ o 6 p o ki 3JI0), YMetfueM obyarnbc~, MnH c o q & i ~ b ~ o f i crlroco6~oc~~m ( x a p a ~ ~ e pwrr ~ o eH a c n p w H q ~ n w a r r b H o xenae HMe, H I T O T P ~ ~ H O C TYeJIOBeYeCKOrO ~, 0 6 ~ u e m- C O O ~ L T J ~ C T Ba
-
O C O ~ C H H O B b I p U e H H O e B aMpKCKOMo H 4XeHCKOMw
arma ax), a TaIoKe msoprecrcum nomenyumoM
(TO
ecn, cr10c06-
HOCTbH) H 3 0 6 p e T a T b HeYTO HOBOe M n l i Ha&3JIHTb C T a p O e HOBbIM
CM~ICJIOM). 0 KOPHXX YeJIOBeYeCKOrO H H T e M e K T a MM IIOrOBOpHM
nome, a 3AeCb II XOTeJI 6~
CKa3aTb HeCKOJIbKO CJIOB 0 TBOPYe-
C K k H C ~ O C O ~ H O C T R YeJIOBeKa, X 0 TOG
ero O C O ~ ~ H H O C T KKOTO,
-
laH B IIOnYJIRPHOM TeW3Me H e p e a K O J'rIyCKaeTCff W3 B W . [eno~e~ec~ TBopYecTBo oe BO~HEIWIOK ~ Ko T p a x e H H e 6 e c ~ o reYH0fi ~03&iAaTeJIbH0fiAeffTeJIbHOCTW CaMOrO 60ra. OAH~UK,~H B m ~ n nC&iA~eii(1554-1586) H a n H c a n o nome, K O T O P ~ I ~ ~ , B O ~ H O C R Ccmom ~ c B o e r o B m m c n a , no cy-w A e n a , nepepom;aeTcrr, TBOPH H e K o T o p b I e B e m H n)nllZIe c a ~ o z ni p H p o A b I WIW 3 T 0 COBePllleHHO WHaYe, TaK, KaK T o r 0 B nPWPOAe
rmorna H e 6 b m a n o... ~ ~ 0 6 naprr 0 ~B ~ npenenax 0 CO~CTB~HHO,opasy~a*.C o r ; ~ a c ~Com ~ e mY, T W TBopYecKEie ~ C~OCO~HO:TEI YeAOBeKa - 3HaYEIT nOYWTaTb Eora, IIOTOMy YTO EOT :He6ecHb1fi C03AaTeJIb 3 T O r 0 TBOpqa* 7 . y XYAOXHMKOB C TeWCTMYeCKMM B3~JIHAOMH a MlriP WMeeTCR I p o Y H o e O c H o B a H u e A J ~HX I TpyAa. Her H H Y e r o 6onee oc~o60xrammero, YeM O C O ~ H ~ H WYTO ~ , TH n o ~ o 6 e Eory ~ w A~~~CTBH'eAbHO MOXelLIb TBOPHTb. X ~ A O X ~ C T B ~ H HH~3 H 06peTaTenbt o c m - TO o T p a x e H w e 6 e s r p a ~ w ~ ~cnoco6~ocm oii Eora K :03maHkUO. B XPWCTWaHCKOM TeK3Me YeAOBeK O q e H e H no ~OCTOHHCTB~.no c n o B a M n c m M o n e s q a , n m w *He M H o r o WaTIeHbr n p e A E o r o ~ > > n o, T o M y YTO Eor C ~ M C O T B O ~HX~ : a w M H , y B e m a B a c n a B o m w YecTWmo (nc. 8:s).B H ~ B ~ C T H O M : M H c n e , Y e n o B e Y e c K o e AOCTOHHCTBO H e ILaTIIIeTcrr COGCTB~HHO IiULIHM. H e n b s r r CO~AaCHTbCH C W3BeCTHbIM )PTBePXCAeHMeM Ipo~oropa,YTO YenoBeK ecm M e p a B c e x semezi. Ero AOCTOHH:TBO 6 e p e ~ HaYaTIO B E0re. OAH~KO, HeCMOTpH H a TO YTO 0 @ 0 3TOpWIH0, AmAW A ~ ~ C T B H T ~ A0~6HnO w a m ~HM, rZyCTb A w e H a l p a B a X A a p a . 0 6 3TOM XOPOUIO CKa3UI X e J I b h t y ~ T r n H ~ e : a B e n ~ ~[ ~~ een o ~ e 3~ma ]e ~ c r rT O A ~ K OH a TOM, YTO Eor B ZB0efi H ~ ~ O C T I . D K M M 6 nO a~ ~r o c ~ AapOBaJIl ~ eMy C ~ o m ~1060~b.
601- A I O ~ H THaC
H e IIOTOMY, YTO MbI npeAcTaBJIrreM KaKJW-TO
JeHHOCm, HO MbI A ~ ~ ~ C T B I ~ T nPeACTaBX(leM ~A~HO JTO H a c J I ~ ~ WEar* T
EIT~K,Y e n o B e Y e c K o e
ee
AOCTOHHCTBO HMeeT A s a
IIOTOhly,
acnema.
M~I, AIoAH,
H a n e A e H b I HM, OAHaKO H a M H e CAeAyeT 3 T W I'OPAIITbCII, nOCKOAbKy OH0 A K U b O T p a x e H W e Toro, &TO o6naIIpeAeAbHbIM AOCTOWHCTBOM. HO 3TO PeiLIIbHOe O l p W e HHe, n 0 3 T O M y TeHCTbI PaCCMaTpHBlUOT YeAOBeKa KaK HeKJW npOMeXyTOYHyH, CTylleHb, KOTOPiLIT B03BbIUlaeTCX H m BCeM DCTaTIbHbIM TBOPeHMeM ( T ~ KKaK E o AapOBUI ~ e M y BJIaCTb H m
HKM
(E~IT.1:28-30 w
nc. 8:6-8),
HO H ~ X O ~ T Cm X
e Eora
(n0~~0JIbKy JIIo)lJi H e 0 6 n a ~ a m CaMOCTORTeJIbHbIM ~ 6 b 1 m e ~W H e MOM m b , oniipaacb Ha c o 6 c ~ ~ e ~ m ~ 31rew b 1 ) . TO HAeaJIbHO c 6 a n a ~ c ~ p o ~ a ~CTaTyC ~ b l iYeJIoBeKa. i Bce HaLlIK 6 e ~ b 1B03HKKAW W3-3a TOTO, YTO MbI He CMOrJ'IH er0 COXPaHKTb, K nOBeCTBOBaHJle 0 TOM, KaK 3T0 IIpOK3OLLUI0, COCTaBJIReT CmeCTBeHHyto YaCTb XpKCTKaHCKOrO TeK3Ma. 04HaKO, npeme YeM O ~ ~ ~ T W T K ~ BOnpOCy C I I 0 TOM, YTO HaPYJIIIinO 3TY TaPMOHJlIo, HaM HaAO rJry6lKe OCMbICJIIITb, YTO Xe 3HaYKT 6b1~bCOTBOPeHHbIM no o6pa3y Eora.
4. Jmdu Mozym nocmuzamb orcpyxaroyuu' w: up u C a ~ o z o Eoza, nOCiCOAbKy 6 0 2 UM t?lUKYfOcnoc06~0cmbU nOCKOAbKy OH de~rnmbnoc HUMU o 6 y a e m c ~ . B ocHoBe YenoBeYecKoro ~ O ~ H ~ HnKe xR m xapamep E o r a - T ~ o p u a .M ~ cOTBOpeHb1 I no Ero o6pasy ( E ~ I T1:27). . Eor BceseAm BcerAa, a M ~ IBpeMtr OT BpeMemi M o x e M n0CTKraTb HeKOTOpbIe BemII. B E s a ~ r e n ~OT wH O ~ H06 H=OM ~ rOBOPWTCII TaK:
HaYme 6bm0 CJIOBO, II C ~ O B6bm0 O y Eora, w CJIOBO 6bm0 Eor. OHO6bm0 B Haqme y Eora. Bce vpes Hero Hararro 6b1~b, w 6e3 Hero HWrTo He H a Y a n O 6bmb, YTO HaYaTIO 6b1~b.B
H ~ 6bua M XK3Hb, K XK3Hb 6bma CBeT YeJIOBeKOB* (HH. l:4). C n o ~ (no-rpe!IecKM o AOZOC, OTKyAa K IIpOK3OLLUIO BCeM HaM K3BeCTHOe CJIOBO A O ~ U K U BeYHO ) W HpeACTaBJIXeT co6oii OAKH W 3 acnemoB caMoro Eora 9. J I o r m ~ o c n ,p m y ~ ,pauwosarrbH O C T ~ , C M ~ I C X- BCe TO npkicyrqe Eory. M w ~ B , cene~~a~ 6bLlI~C03AaHbI no 3aMbICXy 3TOTO pa3YMa K n03TOw KMCIOT ClpyKTypy, IIOpHAOK W CMbICX. Eonee T O ~ O ,C n o ~ oTO , e c n npwcyrqarr Eory P ~ ~ ~ M H O C T ~ , eCTb <
KOH~YHO, C ~ Eor M HacTonbKo s m e H a l u e r o p a 3 y ~ e m YTO M ~ HI e M o m e M n p ~ 6 n a 3 a ~ K b Ero c ~ n o n H o M y nommcemm.
,
Ecna 6b1 OH nomenm, TO H a B c e r A a M O r 6b1 WTaTbCR T~GHOG, OAHaKO E0r XOYeT, Y T O ~ MbI ~ I nOCTHriLlIH Ero, H AeJIaeT nep~adi B 3TOM H a n p a m e m H . Ha ~ O ~ O C J I O B C K O M R3bIKe 3 T a EOUR H m q H a m s a H a 3 b I s a e T c R o n c p o s e m e M . Eor R m e T c l r , ma OTKpbIBaeTCR, H a M A.BJMR OCHOBHbIMH C ~ I W O ~ ~ M I/ H : 06um
2/ O C O ~ ~ IOTKpOBeHMeM. M B 0 6 u e O~T Q O B e H M H E0r 06par.qae~c~ K H a M Y e p e 3 C O T B O ~ ~ H HM~z Il p~O~n O p a O K . Anoc~onI-Ia~enn m e T : uE360, YTO MOXHO 3 ~ a o~Eore, b HBHO ,DJU HLIX, nOTOMy YTO E o ~ R B m HM; E360 HeBLZqHMOe Ero, BeYHarr cma Ero H Eoxecmo, OT c 0 3 ~ a m Mkipa ~ p e psa c c M a T p H B a H H e T B o p e H H f i BLZqEIMbI, TaK YTO OHH 6e3m~m~h1w (Pm. 1:19-20). B ~ K ~ M p a HHe e ncamoneneq nacm 06 TOM TaK: OTKpOBeHHeM;
aHe6eca n p o n o B e A p T cnasy EOXMIO, o A e n a x p y Ero ~ B e u a e T TsepAb. A e m AHH) n e p e A a e T peya, H HOYb HOYH OTKPbIBaeT 3HaHEIeu ( n ~18:2-3). . H
HH~IMH CJIOBaMH, 6bmwe Eora
ki Ero Cyrr[HOCTb KaK T ~ o p q aH Bce~epmerrrrOTKPbIBaIOTCR B Ero n e p B O M UpyKOT m p e m a * , B Ero B c e n e ~ ~ o fCosepqa~ i. ee s e m a e - ee n o p a O K w Q a c o T y - M ~ BO I M H o r o M M O X ~ M I I O H R ~ Eora.
K o r ~ ax e OT p a c c ~ o ~ p eBmc e n e ~ ~ oBGUIHPOKOM C M b I c n e M ~ 0I 6 p w a e ~ c l rK Y e n o s e Y e c T a y , TO BWM H e w 0 60nbuee, nOcKOJIbKy YeJIOBeK rIpHBHOCHT B H e e n ~ H O c T H O H e 3MepeHHe. I I o s ~ o ~50r y A o n m e H 6b1n, no ~ e ~ b u e Mj ei p e , T ~ K JIHYHOCTeH, K a K MbI. T ~ KB ,rnasHarx Y e g r a x , B~ITJIXAHT06r.qee O T K P O B ~ H M ~HO . TO H e B C ~ K . ~ cK ~ a 3 aO ~ 1o ~ AKBWHCKH~~, a 6naroxaprr o614e~y OTKpOBeHHIo MbI MOXeM 3HaTb, YTO E o Cyrr[eCTByeT, ~ OAHaKO 0 TOM, YTO OH - Tpoaqa, MbI MOXeM y 3 H a T b TOnbKO 6 n a r o ~ a p ~ OTKpOBeHHIO O C O ~ O M ~ . Oco6oe o T K p o s e H H e - TO c a M o p a c K p m w e Eora csepxbeCTeCTBeHHbIM cnoco60~. OHRaTIIIeT C e 6 H~ e TOJIbKO B KaKEMTO B n e Y a T m m u m K a g r a H a x , H a n p a M e p , B o6pa3e r o p a e r o KycTa, K O T O ~ HJ e~cropae-r, HO H B 0 6 p a u e ~ w a KJIIOAHM ~a KX R S ~ I K ~06par.qa~cb . K Mo~cem,OH onpexenm C e 6 ~ TaK: a s
xe
E C M ~C ~ E I ~ I TO * , Tame TOT c a ~ b ~Eor, i i Ko~opb~ii w npewe ~ e i i c ~ m s aBOn 6naro espeiic~oroHapona. OH H ~ ~ B ~ J I Ce6E ~ o r oA ~ s p a a ~ akicaam , w k i a ~ o s a(kicx. 3: 1- 17). B TOM pa3roBope Eora C Mowcee~MbI BWWM nOAJIWHHOe ABYCTOPOHHee o6ueme. 3 r o O ~ 11H3 cnoc060~npoHBnem oco6oro OTKpOBeHKR. llo3n~eeEor nan Mowcem flecrr~bsanoseneii w, KpoMe TOM, 0 6 ~ a p ~ h LCBOA j i 3aKOHOB, KOTOPbIM eBpeH AOJMCHbI ~ M W cnenosan B cnoeji m~131-m.flanee Eor o ~ ~ ~ bCe651 ~ s anpopon KaM, ~ ~ ~ M ~ B pasaoe U W M0 6 m e c ~ ~ e m o nonomeawe. e Om ~ m ~ a nEro w crrosy w sanwcb~sarrwero AJIX ~ O T O M K O B .HOBOs a s e ~ ~ b ramop ii n o c n a m K E B ~ ~ pe3mmipym RM TO T a m 06pa30~:&or, MHOrOKPaTHO W ~ ~ o r 0 0 6 p a 3~ ~O 0B O ~ W B U ~ w3~pe~ne mgaM B npoponx* (Esp. 1:I). O r r c p o ~ e mnaHme , Moacem, flasmy w npopoKahi, no I i o x a e ~ ynoseneHwm sanwCbIBaTIWCb K AOJ'KXHbI ~ ~ L T I BHOBb W k i BHOBb YWTaTbCR HaPOW (BTOP. 6:4-6; n c . 118). Co6pa~mreBMecTe, mw sanwcw 06pa3osanw B e m i i 3 a ~ e ~~ o, ~ o p bC~~i iM HHWC~COM M 6m JTBepWeH KaK TOYHOe H aBTOpkiTeTHOe E0Xbe OTKpOBeHHe ll. TOP ~ O C X ~ HKWEBP~RM, I W3JIO)I(EIB C p EOX~CTB~HHOro O T K ~ O He B ~3 a~m,m w ~ a mHa OM w n p o n o m m : a B nocnenHwe n ~ w c m roBopm HaM B C M H ~K,m ~ p o r nocTaBm o HacneAmKoM Bcero. ...Ceii... c m m e cnasb~w o6pa3 wnocracw Em* (EBp. 1:2-3). kiwcyc X ~ H ~ T OBeplIIHHa C oco6oro 5 0 ~ ero m k p o s e m . Ey~yuwE o r o W ~ C ~ H OT ~ 50ra M WC~HHOro, OHropa3~0nonaee, YeM nm6m ~pyrarr@ o p ~oam p o s e m , nOKit3Nf HaM, YTO TaKOe 6 0 ~ HO . IIOCKOJIbKy ~IHCYC TliKXC W I K K O M k i nOnHOCTbI0 6~ YenOBeKOM, OH IUBOpWI HaM ncaee, YeM n1o60e npyroe omposeme. A Tenepb BepHeMcx K HaUUIbHJaIM CnOBaM EB~HRJIWIOT UoaHHa, aIcry2NIbHMM &JM Haurero aaanwsa: aki C n o ~ oC T ~ J I Om o m m w 06w~an0c HaMw, nanHoe 6naronam w wcm~b~w (MH. 4:14). tam^ 06pa30~, C ~ O BO 3T0 ~ ~ W C YXPWCTOC. C aki hfbI BmeJIH CnaBy Ero, n p o n o m m Moam, - cnasy n~emHoponHoro OT Chua*. MHCYCAiUI HaM BO~MOXHOCTEJIlOCTWYb 60ra OYeHb KOHmeTHO w HarwHo. r n a ~ ~ TO, o e YTO,cornacHo T ~ W ~ 50r M YM, O X ~ T o 6 m a ~ b cC ~HaMH, k i AeJIaeT 3TO; WMeHHO n03TOMY MbI MOXCM MHoroe 3 ~ a o~Hb~ Ma ,T a u e o TOM,Yero OHxenam &JM HW. 3 r o sepHo &JM nmneB Bcex speMeH B n1o60~ MecTe, HO
5. Ymoeetc 6 w comeopeti d o 6 p ~ od~atco , zpexonade~ue CCIC~~B U ~H ~O. M o6pa3 Eoxuu',
x o m u tie tiacmoAwco, vmo6u ezo ram 6 ~ 1 0eoccmatioeumb; cnyxetium Ypucma 5 0 2 ucrcynu tmoeevecmeo u tiavaa eoccmatiaeAueamb e iim nepeo3dax~ym 906pmy, x o m ~axdidu'so~etiorneepz~ymbsmo uctcynnetiue.
Uenosevec~ymawc~opum*MOXHO p e 3 m ~ ~ p o B~Yaenm ?ex c n o w : meopetiue, ~ p e X ~ n a d e uctcynnetiue, ~~e, npocnae~eYue.
MM PaCCMOTPeJIM
OCHOBHbIe o c 0 6 e m O C ~YeJIOBeKa, ~ W H ~ O ~ X O ~A M OO ~ ~ B H YTO T ~ , Bce JIIOm k i BCC OCTaJIbHOe
renepb mpowame 6bm0 coTBopeHo 6 n a r a ~ma , xoporrra~.B K ~ a r e E b r m c ~ a 3 a ~ a. o ..w : ysmen Eor Bce, YTO OH C O ~ ~ J a I , BOT xoporrro secbMaw (EMT.1:31). l l o c ~ o n Eor b~~ CBOHM xapamPOM ~ ~ J I O ~ HOPMM W I npaseAHocTa, cnemR KOTOPHM M O ~ O ocTasanca 6 n a m ~TO , YenoBeKy ~ a , q ComBemrBoBan o TpeGosaHmM Eora: xpamn B ce6e o6pa3 E o a a B c~oeii ~ O B C ~ A H ~ B lK HIiO 3H ~H nOCT)TIaTb, HCXOAR W 3 3T0a 6naroii npHpoAM. T p a r e m s a ~ n m ~ a e ~Bc TOM, r r YTO MM nepecTma 6b1~b TCMU, KeM 6bIJIli COTBOpeHM. MH Bmena, YTO YenOBeK GHJI COTBOPeH CO C ~ O C O ~ H O c n m K caMoonpeAenemm. 5or Hapenwx n m ~ e f iC B O ~ O A O ~ ~ , n03TOMy O m M O P COX'aHIITb TeCHYIO CBH3b o6pa3a C nepB006pa3ou, a Moryr a He AeJran rroro. Pis ~ p e ~ b ernasar fi KHEIm 5b1m MM y s ~ a er~ ~, nepsarr o cynpyxecm rma, A q a H~ Esa,
me
p~~
He nOfirHHEITbCH CBOeMy T ~ o p u li y HapJW&iAli3aIIpeT,
~ c T ~ H o B J I ~MM. H H ~3 ITO ~M ~ Cyla rpeXOnaAeHwrr. Aqi3hf W Esa C X C T ~ IIJIOA, K O T O P J ~ Eor 3anpe~wxTporan, w HapjWHJIH CBII3b CO CBOHM TBOPL][OM. TOYHO TaK Xe JIIOAW BCeX Ap)THX 3nOX nbITaTIHCb CaMW sb16apan C B O W ~ ~ b . OHUPerrrWIki ~eficTB0BaTb TaK, KaK ~ Y A T O KX W3Hb He 3aBHCKT OT EOra, HO HMeHHO 3T0 WM H H e YAaBaJIOCb, noTOMy YTO EMy OHM 0 6 r r 3 a ~BCeM: ~ a CBOWM IIPOHCXO~eHWeM,H TeM, YTO A0 CKX nOp OHW lTpOAOJDKaHM.
B
pelrrwnw
cyqecmosan. &TH & a ~ aw EBMWCXO,~OM~ T O ~mOe m o r o nocrIynKa cTana cMeprb, Ko-roparr npHsena Bce nocneAylorqwe noKoneHm
K COCTORHMIO JPHSHOTO, O~UICCTBCHHOTO H IIPHPOAHOrO AHC-
K O M ~ O P T ~M .
O ~c ~Oa s a ~ YTO b , o 6 p Eomii ~ B S e n o s e K e 6m B c e x ero acnercrax. B n u l i ~ o c r n ~matie o~ MU
LICKWCM BO IIOTCPIULW CIIOCO~HOCT~ K CaMOOC03HaBaHHIO H y M e H H e CBO-
6 0 ~ O~n p0e A e m T b H a m H , 4 e f i ~ T B k c006pa3~0 i~ CBOHM yMCTBCHH ~ I Mc n o c o 6 ~ o c ~ 5 1 ~ . H a l r r a co6cmemm T p a H c q e m e m H o c T b oma6na ~ 3 - 3 a O m e H K R , KOTOpOe B03HHKJIO B OTHOlrreHMIIX C ~ O ~ O M , nocrre T o r 0 'G~K h a M H E B O~m e p H y n H c b OT Hero. Y T p a T m TecHoe o 6 r q e ~ ~ c eB e p x o s ~ b rT~p a H c q e H A e m H a r M C y I q e c T BOM, YeJIOBeSeCTBO IIOTeptIllO C ~ O C O ~ H O C nPOTWBOCTO(LTb T~ B c W I ~ H H O ~IIOHHMaTb ~, ee, r i q e K s a T H 0 OqeHHBaTb H n p H H H M a T b nOHCTHHe U C B O ~ O A H U ~ *P e l r r e W . n I 0 A H C T W H CJI)XHTb H e CTOJIbKO bory, CKOJIbKO n p H p O A e , H BMeCTO T o r 0 Y T O ~ Un0 , s a ~ e Eora, ~ y rrpasmb em ( O ~ 1H13 a c n e K T o B o6pasa Eormjero), c a m n o A n a n a n o A ee macn. Ocna6ena H y M c m e e t i t i u e cnoco6~ocmuY e n o B e r n . Tenepb MbI YXe H e MOXeM HMeTb COBeplUeHHO TOuHOrO 3 H a m 06 o K p y x a m w e M H a c m p e H H e cnoco6au M b I c n a T b , H e sna,qaR B n o c T o R H w e 3 a 6 n y m ~ e mY . H a c y h i e m l r r w r a c b tipaecmeetiHas c n o c o 6 ~ o c m bp a a r r m a T b ,406~0H wo, a YTO K a c a e T c R CO4UCUIWiOZO UC?leCCltlU, TO MbI HaYaTIH 3 K C ~ a T H P O B a T bAPJT
B
Apyra. rneopliecrnee, HUO ~ ~ H ~ H ~ T LHCa H u e, B O O ~ ~ ~ X C ~ H H ~ ITOTePtUIO CBH3b C PeWbHOCTbIO, I4 XyAOXHKKSl, T B O P a H e 60r0~ no c o 6 c m e ~ ~ o6pa3y, o ~ y c r a n ~y ~ o ~ m YenOBeYeCTBO b BCC AarJblrre H AUIblrre OT HCTHHHOrO HCTOSHHKa. B A y u I e Y e n o B e K a 06pa.30~arracbnoamme mosewm n y c T o T a , B b I 3 B a H H m 3 m M H lIOCJIeACTBHRhiH. (B EH~JIKH B H ~ H ~ O J I ~ ~
more
~ H O BMm e 3m mea B b r p a x e H u B nep~ofiH B T O P O ~r~n a B a x ~ O C J I ~ H KKR PWMJIRH~M.) Eorocnosb~pe310hmpy10~TO T a m 06pa30~:y H a c H a q a nocb
flue
o m e w e OT bora, OT ~ p y r mJIro,4eB, OT n p ~ p o ~ Ha r OT C a m c e 6 ~ B . 3TOM H COCTOHT C)%@-IOCTb nadzuezo
Y e n o B e y e c T B a 12. OAH~KO r e n o B e Y e c m o M O ~ HO C K ~ ~ H H T OHO ~ , mxyrmeHO. ECJIH noBecTBoBame oTBopeHmi H rpexonaAeHmi s a m ~ a e~ T ~ Hn e p s m rnasrJ W ~EIJTMII, H TO HCTOPHH H c K y n n e H m n o c s m e w B c e o m m b H r J e ITWC~HKR. E H ~ Jpacc~a3mae-r I ~ o TOM, KaK E o ~ JIIO~(L , HBC, C a M HaC m e T , Ha?CO&KT B HalI.IeM
-
3a6n)aure~,O w y x n e H H o M COCTOHHHM M McKynaeT xepmom C ~ o e r oC ~ I kl~cyca H ~ X ~ H C TBTOPOI-0 ~, nMqa T P O H ~IIp0~I. RBJDM K HaM 6JIaI-OBOJI~HM~ M BeJIkiKyIO ~ J I ~ I - O A ~He T ~ 3aCJly, XeHHbIe H a m , 6 0 r AapOBLiJI HaM B03MOXHOCTb HOBO^ W3HK,
s e n ~ e iKi peaTIbHoMy ~ c q e n e ~OT ~ rHaurero n oTYymAeHwrr ki K BOCCTaHOfUIeHHlOo61ue~m C HHM.60r AaTI HaM B03MOXHOCTb BePHyTbCR o6pam0, HO 3T0 BOBCe He 03HaYaeT, YTO OT HaC Hmero He ~ ~ B M C H Th . a ~ Ma E B HMKTO ~ He npaHyx,qm K na,qeHHrn, a Hac HIIKTO He n p H m a e T BepHyracrr K Eory. XapaKTepH3yg TeH3M, MM He c 0 6 ~ p a e 3aHHMaTb ~c~ KaKyIO-TO noswq~mB ~ H ~ M ~ H Ha Tc eO~~e i i ~ o i nepename, i* npwcmeii TO MY ~ ~ p 0 ~ 0 3 3 p e m(npenonpenenemie rn WIH C B O ~ O ~ H ~ H BOJUI), OTMeTliM JEilUb, YTO CpeAH XpHCTKaH HeT eAHHOr0 M H e m OTHOCHT~JEHO TOI-O, ~ a ~ y - ponb 1 0 arpaeT C ~ Eor M w
KaKyKI
OCTaaTLReT HaM. T ~ M He CornackiTcR, YTO B HameM
OH
MeHee
~ O A ~ ~ ~ C T B O ,
HaBepHoe, cnaceHm Eor nenaeT nepsbdi mar. Haura sa,qara - p a c m a c r r B H~J.IIKXrpexoBHm M M C H~ Aenax, npHmm ISOW~HY C J I O B ~H cnen0Eja-n 3a XPHCTOMK L ~ K3a ~ O C ~ O A OHM C n a c u ~ e n e ~ . ~ c ~ y r u e t i ~uenoseuec-rso oe - TO Tame uenoseuecmo, KOTOpOe HaXOAHTC5I Ha l7JTHK BOCCTaHORlIeHLM)HCK.aXeHHOTO o6pasa EoXUS~O,- HHbIMEI CJIOBaMH, Ha ITyTH K peZUIbHOh.ry HCqeAeHHIO B -0a H3 Ha3BaHHbIX 06nac~eii:AKYHOCTHO~ np&ipO,QbI, C O ~ C T B ~ H H TpaHCqemeHTHOCTK, O~~ YMCTB~HHO~~, HP~BCTWHHO~ H C O ~ H W I ~c ~H ~ oO c o~~ ~ H O C T R Xa , Tame cnoco6HOCTH K TBopYecrBy. ~ c v z a ~ ~ e ~ t i u e ~ e n o TO ~ eY~JIO~ec~~
-
BeYecrBo, nonHoc-nm HcqeneHHoe H msyruee B m p e c E o r o ~ , a Ha H H J W B ~ Y ~ T I ~ H OypoBHe M - B Mwpe c A ~ ~ I X M JIIOA~MM H II C CaMHM co6oil. O ~ H ~ BCe K O3T0 COBePUaeTCII TOAbKO IIOCJIe cllrepii H T ~ A ~ C H O I - oBocKpecemm, o B~XHOCTH Kmoporo ~ O C T OnJaI ~ e J IrOBOpHT B 1 ~ o c A ~ H H KH KOPNH@RH~M (r~. 15). ~ K Y H O C TH~aCTOAbKO BaXHa, YTO ee c a ~ o 6 h r r ~ o c TO ~b, eCTb AKYHOe H H~HBlf,Q'aZbHOeCWeCTBOBaHHe, OCTaeTCR H e n p e x o r n m . I I p o c a a m e ~ ~ orenoBeYecTm e - rro TaKoe uenoseYecTBo, Kcrropoe B ame npeo6pame~mo 6 p e ~ a eYHC~ I'YIO J I I I Y H O C T H p IIpHpOAY B o 6 1 u e m ~c EioI-0~H EOXEBHM HapoAoM. tam^ 06pa30~,B ~ e a s Y~e aeo s e K paccMa-rpmaeTca KllK HeYTO OYeHb 3HaYHMOe, nOTOMY YTO OH 60ronono6e~H,
o
6.a/ua ~ a x d o z ~e/106el~a o c-uepmb -smo mu epama 6 X U ~ H c JOZOM u EZO~ a p o d ounu ~ , dopoza K sevrro~yommopxerrum om B C ~ Z Omozo, Ymo o d ~ monblio o u Moxem ocyyecmsumb renosere-
~
C K U e 4CIAHIIH.
0 cMblcxe cMepra H ~ A O6m06b1 ~ O B O P W Tewe ~ B npem,qweM pamene, HO M ~ 0 I 6 p a ~ m c 1K i TO MY mnpocy Tenepb, TIQCKOJibKyB K W O M MlripOBD33peHWII OTHOWeHlle K CMePTH MrpaeT o.rem ~ a m ~ponb. y ~ ,UTO ~ ~ O I I C X O ~KorAa T , renoseK y ~ ~ p aQaBaii~e e ~ ? ~ O B O P H To~ce6e, nocKonaKy TOT ~ w p 0 ~ 0 3 3peHYecKHg aCneKT r n y 6 0 ~ 0 JILnHOCTeH. 5 b I ~ b MOXeT, Ii aC9e3am - H TorAa MOXHO ~ O B O ~ H 06T yracamu ~ n m ~ o c n i ~LTIH ? II BnUaK, B COH 11 3aTeM B03BPaII&aIOCbB K~KOG-TOA P ~ O # Q o p ~ e ,TO ecTb nepe~ormowamcb? npoAomeTcR Moe npeo6pame~~oe cyqecTBoBaHkie: Ha ~ e 6 Ie~ I HB
r~e
w?
Q H C T ~T~ e113~ MH OAH C 03H K aYHE O npHAepXHBaeTC5I ~~~ nocJIenHero 113 nepeYkicneHHbIx BapHamoB. B M o M e m cuepm niGaK npe06paxa~1~~11: O m W Ha9WHaIOTXHTb C E O ~ O11 MEro HapoAoM ( n p w a e f i e ~ ~6om e ~ e )m , ki x e HaBerHo paccTamTcR C HHM,nbITaFICb COXPaHHTb CBOIO ~HIiKanbHOCTbB YXaCHoM OAKHOseCTBe, HaXOAXCb B CTOPOHe KaK pa3 OT TOrO, YTO Morn0 6~ 3EOJIHOCTbIO yAOBJIeTBOP11Tb LIX. B 3TOM CWHOCTb ma. r m 6 e p ~U ~ C T ~ ~ TKaK-TO OH 3a~e-
- TO nammmc ~ e n o ~ e ~ e c cao6o~e, ~oi4 H Mom0 8 0 6 a ~ ~ - YenOBeYeCKOMy ~ b AOCTOHHCTBY. & - 3To Ta JKaHb, KOTOpYIO E0r nJIaTKT C B O ~ O A A ~ , ~ ~ o B ~ KtiX&OMY H H o ~ ~ H3 HaC, u~06bIMar Morn11 sb16kipa~b,KOMY HaM ClIyXHTb; 3TO n p 1 1 3 ~ a Toro, ~ ~ e UTO H ~ L U Hp e m e m HMemT TaKoe s ~ a u e m e , KoTopoe npocrapaeTcH AO ~ e v ~ a npeAenoB nr 13. Te me, KTO npHHmaaeT Eombe crxaceme, H a c e m AonHHM B~YHOCTW K ~ KHcnonHeHHHe cnam Eo=i~bkiT m p e m -
~ m YTO ,
coloepmeHHhIe, o6penrr~enonHoTy 6mm1, OnHaKo He npecbITMBUkieCFI II npHYaCTHbIe K H ~ ~ I P ~ c T ~PH U OHC o TH # o6we~m CBHTbIX. ~ ~ ~ c ~ H H He S KMHOrO X CKa3aHO 0 TaKOM COCTOIMHH, HO Te er0 ~ e 6 e c ~ b 1 npo6necm, e KOTOPbIe BCTPCYaIOTCII, Han p m e p B Kmre O r ~ p o s e ~ w (O r ~ K4-5; . 21), n p o 6 y x ~ a mB ~
B
x p w c m a H a x H a e m , o c y u e c m e H H e K O T O P O ~ ~ ,KaK OHR n a r a m T , npe~3oiiqe~ B c e MX camre - r p e n e T m I e x e n a H m .
no-
7. H ~ ~ @ c ~ & ? H ween1 H o cm~p~a ~ c y e ~ d e ~ m npupoby ~yro u octiosblsaemcx Ha xapalcmepe Eoza - 6nazozo cylyecmsa (csxnzozo u nm6xlyezo). TO nonoxewie BbiTeKaeT 143 n e p B o r o ~eswca.I;or WCTOYHWK HPaBCTBeHHOCTH, P a B H O KaK If @ I ~ ~ H Y ~ c K oM~Hop a . Ijor - rro ~ 0 6 ~K0o T,o p o e H ~ X O W Tc B o e snrpaxemxe B 3 a ~ o ~ a . x If HpaBCTBeHKbDL n p H H U H n a X , KBAeHKbDL UM B ~ H C ~ H H H . C o ~ ~ o p e m bno~ eo6pa3y Ijomaew, MU, no cwec-my, n p e A c T a m e M co6oii H p a B c T s e m b I e cyrrrecma w, c n e A o B a T e n b HO, H e MOXeM H e CBR3bIBaTb HpaBCTBeHHbIe HOPMbI C HillLIWMEI A ~ ~ ~ C T B K R Mr H p e. x o n m e H W e , KOHeYHO, WCKa3WnO HaZlIe H p a B c T s e H H o e Y~BCTBO, w T e n e p b MH H e M o x e M O T P ~ ~ L B I Tce6e ~ HCTUHHYK) A O ~ P O T Y BO B C ~ Gee ~ e J I b H O C T H . OAH~KO, A2lXe 0 l . p W a R TBepAbIe HpaBCTBeHHbIe HOpMbI, MbI H e M O X e M ~ 3 6 a BWTbCH OT O m e H W X , YTO YTO-TO Q ( n P a B W H O * , ELTIW Q(eCTCCTBeHHO*, a YTO-TO HCT. Ha npOTKXeHWW MHOrUX JIeT n 0 Y m BCe 06uecmo CYHTWIO rOMOCeKCyWIW3M aMOpaJIbHbIM. c e r 0 . Q ~ ~ M H O H~ e ~ComiLUlamTcH c m ~OAH~KO, . nocTyrraR T~KMM 06pa30~,OHM WCXOMT H e W3 TOrO, YTO H e CyrrleCTByeT HHKaKWX H p a B c T B e m m HOPM, a 133 TOTO, YTO TO H m e m i e ( r o ~ o c e ~ c y W I W ~ M )AOJIXHO HaXOWTbCH IIO ApyryH, CTOPOHY Y e p H , OTAeJT5IiOuefi HpaBCTseHHOCTb OT ~ ~ ~ H ~ ~ B C T B ~ H H OH C~ TW B~ . CTHO me, H a n p H M e p , YTO O ~ ~ I Y HrOMOCeKCyaTIWCTbI O H e lTpW3HaEOT I ~ ~ o B o c M ~ J . I I ~ H W XB! CBOMX HPaBCTBeHHbIX C m C H l M X nIOAJn o T n w r a m a npyr OT A p y r a , HO MH n o - n p e m e ~ B yn r c m r a i a e M K a m e - T O HpaBCTBeHHbIe OUeHKH, X H B ~ MB COI'JIaCWW C H W W mw H a p y l r r a e M KamAba X K B ~ TB o n p e A e n e m o M H p a B c T B e H H o M m p e , W, n o p a 3 ~ n r c mHW ~ 3 m ~nm60fi , YenoBeK lTpW3HaeT, YTO 3 T 0 A ~ ~ ~ c T B W T ~ J ITaK ~ H OW C 3THM H w Y e r O H e nOAeJIaeJ.IIb. Tews~, OAHaKO, P W T , YTO C w C C T J 3 y e T H e W O C T O KaKaR-TO MOpaTIb, a ~ ~ C O J I I O T H UHOpMa, C ~ o ~ o p oMbI f i COOTHOCHM BCe HpaBCTBeHHbIe CymAeHMH. ?ha H O p M a - C a M E o ~ , Ero 6narofi x a p a K T e p (CBILTOCT~H ~11060~b). Emee T o r o , XpHCTHaHe W HyAeI4 CYWTaIoT, YTO C B OM~e p m O HpaBCTBeHHOCTH 60I' nOKa3aTI H I M B pil3nHYHbM 3aKOHaX W 3anOBeLI(M,
wx.
O-rpaxeHHaas B ~ H ~ J I W A H .e m o r
( n e c ~ m c n o ~ ~He a) ,r o p ~ m
npOnOBeAb, HpaBcTBeHHOe yYeH11e h O C T 0 J I a rklBJIa - C nOM0w b m Bcero ~ T O ~ O a T, a m e M H o r x M H A P ~ ~ H Mcnoc06am H 60r OTKpbIBaeT HaM C ~ o i iXapaKTep. tam^ 06pa30~, MO)I(HO W e p m a T b , YTO C y u e c T B y e T H o p M a , c n o M o m b m ~mopoii MH OrIpeAeXReM, YTO ITpaBKJIbHO, a YTO HeT, H JIlC)m,e C n H 3aXOTRT, M O r F 3TO Y3HaTb. Ho c a M o e n o n H o e B o m o m e H H e ~ 0 6 p o mH 6narocm 3 T 0 HHCYC X~HCTOC. OH - C O B ~ P ~ L I ~ HYeJIOBeK, H ~ I ~ ~ TaK BJIWeK I m H i i Y ~ J I O B ~ Y ~ C npkipo~ofi, KO~~ KaK 3 T 0 MOXeT AWIaTb TOJIbKO
bor. nasen ~ a s m a Ero e ~ BTOP~IMM ~ M O (1 M Kop. 15:45-49). B klwcyce MbI BI.ZIIUM B O I I J I O ~ e H H e6naroZi mEI3HH. M a ~ c k i ~ a r I b H 03TO B b I p a 3 m O C b B Ero CMepTH - aKTe ~CCKOHCYHO# JIIO~BH,1160, K ~ K c~a3anh o c ~ o nHasen, *ems n H KTO p p e T 3a IIpaBeAHXKa.. . HOb0r CBOKI n m 6 0 ~ bK HaM AOKa3bIBaeT TeM, YTO XPHCTOC p e p 3a H a c , K o r A a M ~ 6 Im11 eme r p e m H K a m * (PHM.5:7-8). EM^ BTOPHT ~ O C T O JHoam: I *B T O M J I ~ ~ OYTO B~, H e M ~ ~I o m m 6 m n bora, HO OH ~ 0 3 2 1 m 6 m H a c H ~ O C J I ~ JCI H H ~ C ~ o e r oB p m w m m e H H e 3a rpem H ~ H *(1 MH. 4:lO). tam^ O ~ P ~ ~ OHeCMOlpR M , H a TO, YTO B ~ H ~ Y H T W I ~ H O M#e p e SfTEiKL3 - 3 T 0 c@epaY ~ J I o B ~ Y ~ c K AeHTWIbHOCTH, o~~ B KOHeYHOM cYeTe o H a ~ o c x o p r uK~ Iiory. He MH, HO 60r - M e p H n o HpaBCTBeHHOCTH.
8. Ncmopwr npedcrnasmem co&G /ru~eu'~oe pa3sumue, ucnofitdewiyto cMuc/la no~edosamemdiocmbco6umuu', sedyu(w K ucno/rHeHuto Eoxbezo ~ C L M U oU ~~ m o s e ~ e c m s e . k l c T 0 p W I HMeeT JIllHefiHoe p a 3 B H m e , TO eCTh nOCTyllKH
n m ~ e i (i
~ W H 6b1 ~ ~ C I T O ~ ~ I J O Y H H ~ IXMa H m m H b I M H OHH HH m s a r r ~ c b )n p e n c T a m m T co6oii s s e ~ o B ~ o j nia c n e A o s a T e n h HOCTH, K m o p a x HMeeT CM~ICJI, a T a m e H a u a n o , cepenmy H KOHeU. HCTOPWI H e nOBOpaYHBaeTCR B C M T b , H e nOBTOPHeTCff
no Icpyry; IcpOMe TOrO, OHa H e 6 e c c ~ b 1 c n e ~ ~ a . H c ~ o p m~enecoo6pa3~a, o H a W m e T c H , H a n p a B T u u I c b K mseC T H O ~U~e n H . Iiory K O H ~ UH ~ B ~ C Tc ~c aHM o r o H a u a n a , OH 3 ~ a e ~ H on m 6 oY ~ e n o s e v e c K o M ~ e i i c m ~Kam, o p o e HaxoAHTcrr B Em H H e ABKXeTCH
BJIaCTH.
Iiw6neiicme n H c a T e m oco6oe B m M a m e yaenrrm nowPOTHbIM IIyHKTaM HCTOPHYeCKOrO PaSBHTUII, KOTOPhIC ~ O P M H -
pym~ TeHc-rHYecKoe
npeAcTaaTIeHHe
o Y e n o B e K e BO BpeMeHH.
K
3THM nyHKTaM MOXHO OTHeCTH TBOpeHHe, r p e X O n W e H M e , OTlcpOBeHHe 60ra e B p e f k ~ 0 M H y apony ( K O T O ~ O BKJIIOYaeT ~ Bc e 6 ~ n p ~ 3 s a ~Aspama ~e ~3 Ypa B X a ~ a a ~ c, x o n~3 E m n ~ a , 0 6 p e ~ e m e3aKOHa, CB&i&eTeAbCTBO ~ ~ O ~ O K O BBO) I, I j I O ~ e H H eH - 3 ~ a Bwcyca, pacnrrme H B o c K p e c e H w e , n r r T m e c a n - i H u y , p a c n p o c T p a H e H H e Enaroii seem Q e p ~ o s b m B, T o p o e n p m e c T Bue X p ~ c H ~ ca y ~ 3. r o 6onee n e ~ a r r a a b z i ln e p e r e H a co6maii, n a p a r r n e n b m r i i H C T O ~ H Hs e n o B e r e c m a : mopewe, rpexonaem e , HcKynnewie, npocnaarreHHe. Ta~arrTOYKa 3peHHH lTO3BOJIHeT Y B m e T b , YTO CaMa HCTO-
pm - rro
onpeneneHHaH @ o p ~ O a T K p o B e m , TO e c n H e TOJIbKO 60r OTKpMBaeT C e 6 B~H c T o p H a ( 3 d e ~ b ,m a M , rnozda), HO H CaMa nOCJIeAOBaTeAbHOCTb COG~I?UZ~IIpeACTaBlzIIeT co6oii o n c p o s e H H e . tam^ 06pa30~,M O ~ cO ~ a s a ~ YTO b, HCTOP~ (oco6emo TOT ee n e p H o n , ~ o ~ o p b I CZ Bi I L ~ c~ H)KU~HBH)k i y ~ e i i cKoro ~ a p o ~a )rro s a n w c b T O ~ O , K ~ KE j o r p e a n i p y e T H a co6ama B m3m n m ~ e j Hi K a K o e p a c T k l e OH B HMXn p H H H MaeT. k i c ~ o p m- rro Eoxaii s a ~ b x c e n 0, 6 n e r e m b r i i B KOHlcpeTHyro
@OPW.
T ~ KMOAeAb ~R
HCTOPHH, KOHeYHO,
06yc110me~aXPHCTH-
~ H C K T Op~a ,~I W ~ H e i i .Ha n e p ~ ~ 1B3rJIRA fi MOXeT n O ~ a 3 a ~ b c 5 1rITO ,
OHa H e IXPHHIIMaeT BO BHIlMaHIle HEIKOI'O, KPOMe IiyAeeB H XpHCTHaH. OAH~KO M U B W M , YTO B B~TXOM 3aEieTe MHOI'O ~OBOPHTCR o H a p o n a x , )KUBJUHX no cocencmy c kispawre~,a TaKme 0 TeX A I o m , KOTOPbIe H e npHMiWIeXaTIH K HyAeRM, HO yCBOI.LTIH l l y ~ e f i c ~ BepOMHHH ~le H nOTOMy PaCCMaTpHMtoTCR K ~ K vacm Eo>wero 0 6 e ~ o s a m TO . KaCaeTcH H O B O ~S O a~e~ TO B HeM ewe C k U b H e e rIOAYePMBaeTCII BCeOXBaTHOCTb 60%-
a,
ero s a ~ b r c n aH Ero B n a c n . Eioxae o m ~ p o s e ~ uBe nepaym
orepeAb ocmecTanrmoca Y e p e 3 OAHH H a p 0 3 - HyAeeB, H XOTH BMeCTe C Y ~ ~ R M O B B ~ ~ MM O MMOXeM CKa3aTb: a K a CTpaHHO, ~ B CaMOM AeJIe, YTO 60r B ~ I ~ P WHyAeeB*, I - H e CTOMT AYMaTb, YTO TCM CaMbIM E o ~ 3aCBHJleTeJIbCTBOBaTI C ~ o m oco6y1o ~ A ~ ~ W K J I O H H WK TX~O M Y H a p o n y . Anoc~onn e T p O A H W ~ I C K ~ ~ ~ ~J ~I :~ C T H H n H oO3 ~ a m , ZIT0 Eor HeJIHueIIpKRTeH, HO BO BCRXOM HapOAe 6orrru~fica Ero
w a
n o c ~ y n a w r q ~no i i n p a B A e rrpkiaTehi E ~ y (uA ~ R H10:34-35). . BT~K TeHCTbI , O)IKUAaIOT, YTO HCTOPHH 3aBePlUHTCH CYAOM, 3aTeM HaYHeTCH H O B ~ HI ~ C K O H Y ~ ~BeK. M ~O I ~~ ~H ~llpeme KO
M
YeM OH HaCTynHT, Bpehlrr 6 y ~ COXpaHRTb e ~ CBOHI ~ e o 6 p a M O C T ~ ,a H n o p m - CBOHI C o o T H e c e m o c T b c onpeaenemmi
~~-
n p o c T p a r i c m o M . Ha rry m e H I HWO 0 6 p a m ~ bo ~ o 6 o B e mMaHHe, IIOCKOJIbKY OHa p e L U H T ~ b H O OTJIKYaeTCII OT TEUIFIHO BoCTOYHOrO ~ 3 r m Haa np06~1e~y. Ha B o c ~ o M ~ He o r H e crmaHIT, YTO BpeMH - 3 T 0 H.lLlIHI3MII, a HCTOpkirr BeYHO ABIM(eTCII llO ~ ~ M K H ~ T ~pyry. O M ~ E n a r o ~ a np e~p e B o m o u e m m Ayma B H O B ~ H B H O B ~ 0 3 ~ p a u a e ~ c 1B1 ;TOM ny-remecTBmi A B m e H H e B n e p e A AJIHTCII AOJIrO, COBepLUaeTC5I TPYAHO H, 6 b t T b MOXeT, BeYHO. Cornac~ox e X p H c m a H c K o W T ~ H ~ MaYenoBeKaM Y nonoxeHo O A H W b I yMepeTb, a nOTOM CyA* (EBp. 9127).Bb160p, K ~ T O ~ & c0Bepurae-r YenoBeK, ~ H ~ Y HKaK M AJIX H e r o C a M o r o , TaK H AJIX ApJTIIX ki Jl,JlH E0ra. MCTOPWI - 3 T 0 CJIeACTBHe TaKOrO sar6opa; vepes H e r o n o A s e p x o ~ ~ omi ai c T b m Eora B o m o u a e T c x Ero ~ ~ M ~ I C ~ J I . M T ~ K c, a ~ b 1 f BiUKH6Lji i aCrJeKT T ~ H C T W Y ~ C KKOHl.(eIIl.(HH O~~ IICTOPHII CBOAIITCII K T O W , YTO OHa HMeeT CMbICJI, llOCKOJIbKy Eor-Cno~o(noroc) CTOHT 3a BceMH C O ~ ~ I T W I M H ,H e TOJI~KO q e p x a B c e CJIOBOM cmbr C~oeii*(Esp. 4:3), HO H A e n a R TaK, 9 ~ 0 <~JIHI~RU&IIM 6 ~ Eora, n p H 3 B a H H b M no Ero H3BOJIeHHHI, BCe co~e6cmo~ano KO 6nary* (PHM.8:28). tam^ o6pa30~,H a BHelUHIIM XaOCOM ~06bITI.lji B03BbIlrraeTcR Eor, a c n o n ~ e ~ ~ JbI 1I ~6~ BHH ~ e p x a w ~Bic ie B c~oeii macTII.
60XbE BEJlHL(IHE
M T ~ KT, e n e p b
IICHO, !IT0 x ~ I I c T I I ~ H c K HTCH3M ~~ B nepBYI0 OYepeAb 3I.aKneTCX H a KOHIJenL(HH Eora, noCKOJIbKY CYHTaeT, 9TO BCe 6 e p e ~HaYaAO HMeHHO B H ~ MHHYTO . H e MOXeT IlpeAlLIeCTBOBaTb EMYWIH 6 b 1 ~ bPaBHbIM. OH eCTb Tom, Kmo ecmb. tam^ 0 6 p a s o ~~, e 1 1 3 MAaeT OCHOBY AJIII M ~ T ~ @ H ~ H I € K .
K p o ~ Te o r o , Tom, Kmo ecmb, 06~1wae~ A O C T O ~ H xapame~ ~ OHC ~ eCTb M AOCTOIIHCTBO; CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, TeH3M HMeeT OCHOBy II AJIX 3TIIKII. A nOCKOJIbKy Tom, h 0 ecmb, RBJIHeTCR II T ~ MKmo , maem, TO T ~ I I S M p a c n o n a r a e T O C H O B O ~ II JIJ.H r H o c e o n o r m . M H ~ I M HC n o B a m , T ~ I I ~ nMp e A c T a m e T c06oii POM,
3aKOHYeHHOe MIIpOBO33peHEie. M T ~ KE0Xbe , BenIIYIIe - O C H O B H O ~AOrMaT XpHCTHaHCKO-
r0 TeII3Ma. ECJIHMbI n p I I M e M er0 II HaYHeM BOCnpHHHMaTb BCe
OKpJQKaIOmee K & ~ B C T B O B B~ TCOOTseTCTBkiki ~ C I W M , TO %a o c a o B o n o n a r a m m a a ~ o ~ u e n u cw T arH e T K ~ 6b1 K cwoji, TpaHcu e y q e ~ ~ ~ ~o ioi ~ ~ p o mT~O Yo Kj Oi ~ ~ H a c . H a a xm31i5 HaIIOJIHuTCH CMbICJIOM, a P m O C T K K rOpeCTK nOBCeAHeBHOr0
c m e c m o s a w H a rroii n n a H e T e n p e s p a T H T c x B s-e MoMeHTbr ~ o i3ax~a~b1~am1ueZi i ApaMM, B K O T O ~ O ZMM ~ HaAeeMCSI BCerAa IIPKHKMaTb V a C T K e , a C K ~ K O ~ ~ - nTOOP M - BKyIIlaX O A H ~n m b p a ~ o c K ~ bno3a6br~o n e u m . Ho K T e n e p b , K ~ K H e K o r A a H a n a c a n mepapa M3ma X o n m ~ cm , punpo~wsa E O ~ KB M e n m K e M * 14. crEomb~~ H ~ K I ~ I *P H C ~ T C T B ~ IBO M T Kpe
~
<
BCEJlEHHASI KAK L ~ A C O B O ~ MEXAHM3M: AEM3M OT~yaaeeaoM 60r H renoeeK H ~ Ha M seme, rae Haw npoxonm e e ~ ? M ~ K B, W R reJlOBeKa TOnbKO WeCb, Mbl CMeeM PaCCYwaTb, KaKOB OH Be~b? #0rna c e 6 ~RBnReT 60r B MMpaX, f l e n ~ l enH ~ HaM 6ora W ~ W Hnpax? M ~
Te~smCy~eCTBOBiLllAOJllXl, 9 T O Xe BCe-TaKH C ~ T O C O ~ C T B O B ~ no ero p a 3 p y m e ~ L i n ? Ecnw OH a a m y a o m e T B o p a T e r r b m t e OTBeTbI H a BCe OCHOBHbIe BOllPOCbI, 6~ Y ~ ~ H C UOT~ HiUIIHX ~ M c r p a x o B H B c e n w I H a A e w y H a 6yayuee, TO n o v e M y nommocb YTO-TO eIlte? O T B ~ T M H aT 3TU ~ BOlTPOCbI MOXHO n o - p a 3 H O M y . Aeno B TOM, YTO CO B p e M e H e M 0 ce6e 3aRBKTIO MHOrO CKJI, KOTOpble C I T ~ C O ~ C T B O R KpyNIeHMH) ~~~H OCH0BOIIOJIaTaH)~eTO U H T e A J I e K T y m L H O r O eAHHCTBa, X a p a K T e p H O r O AJIX 3aIIa~a.
H ~ K O T O nonaram, ~LI~ r ~ ao e ~ c3@~o p ~ ~ p o ~KaK anc~ I l O n l l T K d 0 6 p e c T ~eALiHOMblCnUe B TOM X a W e @ ~ o c o @ c K M X H
6 o r o c n o ~ c nuc~yccuii, ~~x KOTOPLI~B c e M H a A q a T o M s e K e nepef l u e CaMLiM KX YWlCTHHKaM CTdBULie Ka3aTbCR YeM-TO WkiBMaTlbHbIM H ~36mh1~. MOXeT, MMeHHO 3 T 0 W UMeJl B B m M ~ T O HO, ~ I H C ~ B U L ~ ~ ~ c u e H y , s KOTOPOU n w u e a H r e n u c n o w c T w H e s n w r e c ~ m POcflLi B HeCKOHYaeMLle C n O P b I ,
P;1SM;.LXOM MlVBIClT TeDMUHaMM ~ I M ~ O C O ~Tennnruu' C K ~ ~ ~
...
B CTOpOHe
06~1060saj1~ p+m 6 e c e A h I xom (YM~M - BHTH~~CTBO,~ y 3 b 1 ~-a C e p A q a M OrpmHhI), T a M pa3AYMbRM npeAWIHCb, B~ICOKWM nomcnm o ~POBMA~HKU, n p o ~ I f 4 e m H , 0 Bone H cyAb6e C y A b 6 e ~ T ~ ~ & ~ c T ~ H o BH~B~o H n eH o ~ C~060.4~06, HaKOHeq, - 0 ~ ~ ~ Y C A O B H O M npo~If4em11,myrm H a nyrm K pasrqq~el.
nocne ~ e c ~ n z r r e ~ w y r oi M i HTenbHbrX
c n o p o B nmepaae, W H T a H e H aHIlrrHKaHCK2iH UepKOBb, HaKOHeq-TO, lTOHHJJH, 9 T O m e BePHYTbCR K TOMY, 9 T O HX 0 6 5 e A H 1 u r e ~ .B K ~ K O ~ - TMOe p e AeH3M H 6bUI OTBeTOM H a AaHHYIO CHTyaqHIO, H O BCKOpe A e n O l'lpHHIuI0 T ~ K O O~ O ~ P O T ,9 T O AeH3M C m b H O OTOLLIeJI (YT T p m H UHoHHoro XpHcTHaHcma. @OPMHPOB~HWIO~ e a s C~~ O a C O ~ C T B O B ~ JTI aOK m e meweH H e a a e H T O B B nOHHMaHHH aBTOPWTeTHOr0 MepK7Ia 6orono3HaHLIR. BM~CTO oco6oro OTIcpOBeHIur, COAePXaIL(er0CR B C ~ H H C, T ~ J I Hr o B o p m b o P a s y ~ es, o 6 <
nki-
mo? O A H H~3
IIPHYHH O C O ~ ~ H H BbI3bIBaeT O HPOHHIO. OH^ CBR3aHa C TeWCTHYeCKHM BbIBOAOM, ~ 0 ~ 0 p b L fBnOCJIeACTBMH 3 n p e B p a T m c R B Qop~yny:
>.Ha B c e M n p O T S M e H H H CpeAHKX BeKOB ( 0 ~ s r a c T H6 n a r o ~ a p ~ m H p o e o M y p a c n p o c T p a H e m I o T e o p m i n o 3 ~ a ~rm Zna~o~a) BHLlMaHLle y " i e ~ b I X - ~ O T O C ~ O B O H B HHTeJUIerCryaTIOB 6bU0 R P H KOBaHO K 60rJ'. C ~ H T ~ J - IYTO O CB~HeKOTOPOM , CMbICJIe n 0 3 H a IOwHfi TeM, 9 T O OH n 0 3 H a e T . TO eCTb, eCJDi BbI C?peMHTeCb K T O W , Y T O ~ B~ K~KOG-TO I M e p e CTaTb a 6 n a r ~ ~Hb >
nepen co6oii
He
c ~ o n b~ b r c o ~ yqenb. m Hmo
c K a u a r a , YTO M e p a p x w r e c K o e B o c n p m T s e p e a n b H o c T H m e T -
CX H e TOlIbKO TeMCTENeCKJIM HJM )EPkiCTklaHCKUM, O H 0
6epe~
CBOC H;IYaLTTO UT ~ ~ M T G HH~M . ~HM OTOH e r 0 O H 0 YCBaHBaeT
KOTOPOG M a T e p H R e C T b H e n T O eCJIH I3 H e Woe, M Z H ~ W ~MGe p e , H e p a 3 y M H O e H, Cne&OBaTenbHO, H e ~ 0 6 poe. M a r e p H x - TO TO, TO H ~ J I Onpeononemn, a H e n o c T k i MLiCSIB, COrXaCMO
TO, 1TO i'ZTPI.
O ~ J H ~ Kyh4b1, O B
60mmeii
E K ~ ~ M ~GTarIK Q , yrRepm;laTb, XC&
6e3
CTerieHIi OPHeHTIIPOBaHHbIe H a !IT0 BCe B 0 K P ) T
- Eo-
MHP,
P-i3'b%TMR, M, XOTH 3TO MHP IIWLUM, OH COTBOpeH
OH C T ~ W TTOrO, Y T ~ ~ Le PIO llWTMIYlTL U OCMLICSIRTL. 160jIee TOrO, 160r kiMeeT pa3yhtliy~)r ; p ~ p o ~ w, y , c n e n o B a T e n m o , Ero B c e n e m i a a T o m e pasvr*rHa, y t z o p m o r e l l a w n o c r r i r a e M a . O c ~ i o ~ b r ~ m H ac bTOM It, C n e ~ O R a T e J I b H O , H M e C l L&CHHNTb.
HWXOXfSKMM, f l C H b I e
H a 9 U H MCCfiCnOBaTb CQyKTj"py 3m0u' c ~ r l i l ; l ~ ~ ~ a rKna cp ~m I i a 160-
3cejlew~oti.l l T o c ~ e n e ~H~a rom : a XX10 hiMpki.
MHP C T U
110XOX H a ~ M ~ ~ H T C~JIilXeFfHbIji K I ~ ~ ~
' ~ i t l i d H M J M ,H a O Q O M H H e WlCbI, '4bkJ l l l e C T e P H M I3 P b l U a l 7 I T O r H O l3O&OIHaHhI. T a ~ a s ;KLlpTMHa H e n p O C T 0 BO3IiK#&Ta B XOAe
HayXu-foroH c c ~ 1 e A o B a m I n ,I ~ Ow
C T m i y n I i p o B a n a ero e u e 60nb0 6 c ~ o n ~ e n 1 , ~ o h t yw 3 y r e ~ s m~ c e n e m o i i .
rue, nprrnoarn K 6osree M €lb:MIf CAOFAMLi, POflLLTaCb
H H a 9 U t a A e n a T b yfiImUTe.lIbHbre
YCtleXtlr kLJBeCTH;3R H a M CeI'OfiFIH K3YKa.
B c n e ~3a
~~KOHOM
hO;KHO C ' K a a T b , 9 T O 3KZlHHe C l ' i i l O C U I I O ~ ~C, I I O C O ~ H OW ~~ paB-
J ~ R m T o~p e H & I e M M nce 63,?b1uc n o ~ r ~ ~ero t lr e ~ nbo ~ e u e c ~ o i i Wi3CT&i.3 ~ Xye MLICflb, npama, 6ojree COBpeMeHHLIM R36IKOM
n>K.
WL,IpaXaCT H ~~OKOBCKM <(C . h f 0 e A T O ~ K H3PeHMW, O H , -- I i a y K a - 3 T 0 T B K a OPTaHM3aLIMX 3 H a W , irci3Bo~Me'r R
6 0 n b ~ e fCTelICHhl i
B 11PMPOAe l I O T e H 4 & l W O M * 2 , K'reCTReHHO-Haj"4HbIX
- rIkLLUeT KOTOPLUf
~ O C I I O ~ C T B O B a THb a C O Q b I T b L M
O Z H ~ KeOC n H
,&jTH I T O J I ~ e H H H
3 ~ a ~ k f l /3TOT i M e T O a CTOJIb XOPOLII, TO
60r0r1031iamr~? K o ~ e r ~ Bo XpMCTMaHCKOM , TeM3Me 01% we H I p a J l CBOIO PijJ15, IIOCKOJThKY CqHTUIOCb, S T 0 1601' HB.ilHeT C e 6 B ~ ITpHpOQe. HO I, TO X e R P e M R IlPeflIIOlIa~iLIIOCb, 9'1'0 3 H a H H R 7 l l O x y Y e H H b I e repe3 o6ruee o T r c p o B e m e , H e n o n m i : ropa3~o6onbme o Eiore kll)XHO Y3HaTb U e p e 3 0c060e O T Q O B e H M e . A e m ~ ,OAHaKO, orpuacx', rro Eior n o c T M r a e T c n repes o-rKpoBeHMe, repes oco6bre C a M o m p a x e H M n Eora, n p e A c T a B n e H H a r e . H a n m fIOrehfy
6 ~ He 1
IIPKMeHMTb
er0 14
B
Mep, B ~ M c ~ H M H WIki ~ O ~ O B O I Z I I O L L I ~ H MH M .~
P ~ CCYHTaTb T~B AeM3M y n p a 3 ~ m e ~
Apwc~mema p 6 k l ~ p Bo ~BOnpOCaX Hay=, ~ k i c a ~ w KaK e 60rocno~cmiiaBTOpHTeT, alTeJIJlMpyR TOJIbKO K e r e n o s e v e c K o M y u p a 3 y ~ yITo . cnosaM n a ~ e pM a e ~ a ~ a pewea, ~eo6xodwocmbp a y Ma, M e m e m o ycl-yr~ano Aopory sepe B ero docmamor~ocmb*3. HMe C e M H ~ U a T O r OBeKa, y r B e p m a B l u e e
tam^
O ~ P ~ O MCOrJIaCHO , AeK3My,
60ra
MOXHO YCMOTPeTb
TOJI~KOB anpkipoAe,>, ~ I O AK O T O P O ~n o ~ p a 3 y ~ e m a cck bi c T e M a B C ~ J I ~ H H O ~~ O . C K O J I Xe ~ K 3~T a CMCTeMa PaCCMaTpriBaJIaCb K a K
~ e m rk~ r a ~ ~ c l Uyaco~oii iii ~ e x a m m Eor ,
~ o c n p k a ~ ~ ~ ~ r n c x
KaK YaCOBuHK.
B K ~ K O M - T OC M b I c n e MOXHO c m u a T b , UTO c~eAt%ie 601-0o 6 w e ~ yOTKpOBeHHH, PaBHOCkeTbHO Q k i 3 H a H M l O
IIO3HaHWi K
TOTO, YTO &l&3
H a 3aBTpaK
- B e U b HeWlOXaH K YTO,
Cne&OBa-
TenbHO, MOXHO BCIO CBOlO lKH3Hb (KOTOPaR CerOAHX IIOHeBOne CTaHOBMTCH BCC K O ~ O Y ~ mQflMc0 ) K X M rOTOBHTb K 3 a B T p a K y (a MOXeT 6 b l T b , K n e H Y y k i
o 6 e ~ yT O X ~ ) . T ~ H ~KOMtXHO, M,
TOXe STO-TO y 3 ~ a ~~3b II~IIE)OALI, OAHaKO OH F B e P m a e T , 9TO 3THM 60rono3~ame& W e K O He o z p a ~ u r u s a e m cki~ YTO C y u e c T B y w T ewe M dpyzue nynru.
n p ~ m a e YTO ~, o
E j o r e MOXHO
OCHOBbl AEH3MA
C o r n a c ~ oQpeaepmy K o n n c ~ o ~cy~, c ~ o p ~ r e cTOY ~o wi i ~ M A ~ aMx e H e x m r r e T c w @ ~ O C O ( ~ C Ka1.1~0n0jjl~9. O ~ B
3pem11, A
KOHZI[C C e M H m q a T O r O ki H a Y U e B O C e M H a U a T O r O BeKOB BCer6, JIHLLtb HeCKOnbKO M M C J I M T ~ ~ C ~U T U M MMeHOBaTbCR AeMCTaMH kLTIM CaMM ce6rr CYIITaAM TaKOBbLMM. Y 3TKX ,llO&ea 6bLJ'Ikf 0 6 m ~ e B 3 T W b 1 , OAHaKO 66~11 W PaCXOWeHMR. ~OKKH , WIpli-
BOH
M e p , H e OTBeprZU
meH, OTKPOBeHMR,
HO CYHTWI, YTO
o q e m s a n c nos~uwuY e n o B e r e c K o r o p a s y ~ a4.
er0 klWO
He~oTOpbIe
AekiCTbZ OTHOCMnMCb K XBMCTMaHCTBY 1 3 p ~ e 6 ~ I0i a l, I g M M e p , B o n b ~ e p HO , 6bLJ'IM M T a m e ( K ~ K ,H a n p M M e p , TOT Xe ~ O K K ) KTO ,
3~06 HeIIPMR3HM H e MCnb1TbIBa.X. OAHM B C P W B ~ ~ C C M ~ P T H n y r u ~ , A p y r H e HeT. KTO-TOB e p m , UTO 50q am C ~ o e ~ y TBO%)eHEIlOB03MOXHOCTb pa3BMBaTbCR C ~ M O C T O I I TbHO. ~ J ~ a KTOTO nonarancrr H a n p o B m e m e . OAHM B e p m H B bora K ~ KB ~ M Y H O C TA ~P , y r M e H e npM3HaBaJIH T ~ K B Oe p~b l . 3 0 M , MOXHO CKa3aTb, YTO
no
tam^ o6pa-
OCHOBHbKM BOnpOCaM AekiCTbK
~
UT06b1 JIyYuIe IIOHRTb Aell3M KaK CIICTeh.ry, IIUIOXHd ee B OTHoCllTeJIbHO ICpafiHefi @ O P M ~ . T ~ M KbI ILCHee CMOXeM nom b , noueMy ocna6na no311rr;aa ~ e a s ~ua ~, o c o 6 e ~ ~ npoo ILBWIOCb B BOCeMHaAIJaTOM BeKe. M ~Y IB W M , ST0 HaTYPZUIII3M,
HanpaMep, nomen ewe Aarrbme.
I . Tpa~cyeHdeHmHMLi6 0 2 , lTepsonpuvu~ascezo, comsopus scme~~ym npedocmasun , ee c a ~ o ce6e. ; T a ~ 06pa30~, w f i z He waHeHmeH, He o6~adaema6coflmm~o nuv~ocrn~ou' npupodoG, He m e e m sepxos~oGsflacmu s venosevec~uxdmax u He c n o c d e ~K npedonpedme~um. K ~ wKB ~ e w m eB, A ~ H H OcucTeMe ~ ~ c a ~ b ~~f ai ) ~ ~ T b ~I ~j iI I C ItacaeTcrr LIT^ II xapamepa Iiora. no cmecmy, A ~ I I ~ M. ,T. e. ocna6nrre~II coqawaeT neperem aqw6yTOB 50ra. no MHCHIIK)ACIICTOB, 50r - 3T0 TPaHCIJeHAeHTHaR cma, ma 3 ~ e p r mnepBoABuraTenb , ~ I nepBonpHumia, I Havan0 TOTO, STO 6e3 Hero npeBpaTmocb 6b1 B ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y H O o6pamoe ABMXCHIIC ~ P M Y L I H H O - C ~ ~ A C T B ~ HIJenII. H O ~ ~ HO 0 W ~ M HeJKb3II TOBOPkiTb, YTO 3T0 uOH,>,XOTIE B II3bIKe, KOTOPbIM 60r OITIICbLBaeTCIE, JIIlYHOe MeCTOIlMeHIIe COXPaHReTCII. K p o ~ e T O ~ O ,OH yxe He 3a6omumcn o cBoeM mopewu, He nm6um ero. Y 'Her0 ~ o o 6 w eHeT H I ~ K ~ K
5. PKT
1lHTeJLlIeK~y2lJIbHofiMYAPOCTII, KOTOPYlO MbI MOXeM Ha3BaTb ~ o ~ o M6 . ,O > A H ~ KIior O
cnenyeT
Hemi? p a s y ~~
I
cma, I
tam^
0 6 p a 3 0 ~ WII , AewcTa Ii0r - HeuTO AmeKoe, HHoe H YymAoe. T ~ H Me MeHee paHme AewcTis, no-BUIIMOM~, He YYBCTBOBaTlW Tor0 OAWHOYeCTBa, B KOTOPOM BnOCJKeACTBIlW o ~ a x i ~ ~uenoseuecTBo. ocb
npo~rmonowu ma cTonem, npex6bm OnIrpaH Ha none
Ae ueM TOT B~IBOA, KaK TOBOPHTCIL,
YenoBeYecm
Y~CTB.
2. Kocnioc, c o r n s o p e ~ ~EOZOM, ~ u ' m e e m cmpozo onpedenerrnocrcoflbrcy OH come ope^ rcarc edu~oo6pa3ue npuruH u c~edcmeuu's sarcp~rnou'cucmenie; Hurcarcoe vydo s HeM HYH) cmpyrcmypy, Ht?603M03CHO.
~
B c ~ ~ ~ H s aH~ p~ mRaB c a ~ o j ce6e i B A B ~ Xacnemax. BoIIepBhIX, O H a H e n O ~ e X H T HMMKOMY M3MeHeHMK) CO CTOPOHbI Eora, nmow YTO OH B TOM * H e s a w ~ ~ e p e c o s aOH ~ * .n p O c T o C03AaJI
ee M BCe.
k k B 0 3 ~ 0 X H b 1HMKaKZle Y y A e c a WlM CO~MTKII,
KOTOPhIe TOBOPHJIM
JIm60e
6121O K a m - T O
Oc06bLX E0XCbH.X 3aMbICJIa.X.
BMellIaTeJIbCTBO B MeXaHlf3M
B C ~ J I ~ H H O03HaYaTIO G 6b1,
60r COBePIlIMJI OIIIW~KY, YTO no ce6e y ~ a r w r o6b1 AOCTOMHCTBO B c e s e A y q e r o Eora. Bo-BTOP~M, BCeJIeHHyiO H e M O X e T M 3 M e M T b W YeJIOBeK, n m o M y YTO o H a m e e T 3a~pbr~y10, HenpoHMqaeMyxo ~ Y K T Y P Y YaCOBOrO MeXaHlf3Ma. ,&Dl T o r 0 YT06b1 I I p W a T b eg K ~ K o ~ ~ - T o ~ ~ on oi pim o ~Y, e n o B e K y - B OAMHOYKY KJIM B M e c T e c ~ p y m m nIoAbMM - H m 0 B&TW 38 ee npeAeJIbI, p a 3 0 p B a T b IIPMYMHHOc n e A c T s e m y I o qenb, HO H a M TO H e noA cmy. O A H ~ K HO ~ O 3aMeTMTb, YTO H a 3TOT BbIBOA AeMCTbI H e o6pa1qalo~oco6oro B H u M a w . EO~MLIMHCTBO, B o n p e K u x o ~ yp a c c y m ~ e ~ Mno, YTO B CBOeM M3HaYaTIbHOM IIJIaHe caMo
n p e m e M y n o n a r a e T , YTO M ~ M I o x e M ~ 3 ~ e Hma mbe o K p y x e HMC
.
3. Hec~ompsrHa csom mlruocmuym npupody, lrenose~ocmaemcsr lracmbm vacosozo ~ e x a u u s ~sceneuuoi. a ~ e M c T b 1 , KOHeYHO, H e OTPLIqaHIT, YTO YeJIOBeK - JIMYH O C T ~ .K w b r j i ~3 H a c , no K p a i i a e i i M e p e H a nepsbrii ~3r~m.4, H m e J I e H CaMOC03HaHWeM M C ~ O C O ~ H O C T ~ K I OC a M o o n p e A e n e H W . O A H ~ KBCe O 3 T 0 H W O PaCCMa'TpMBaTb B OAHOM JIKUh q e n o B e Y e c K o M acneme. M ~ InmAw, , H e w M e e M m ~ a ~ oC B j Fi F ~ K
E O ~ O(M K a K y ~ oM O X e T WMeTb o6pa3 no OTHOIMCHMH) K n e p B 0 06pa3y) M, UIeAOBaTeJIbHO, HWKaK H e MQXCM BbLfiTM 3a IIpeAeJIbI C
CMCTeMbI, B K O T O P O ~HaXOAMMCR. ~
KPHTHKYR C O B P e M e H H b I X e M y AeMCTOB, CIILICKOII 4 t ) e ~ e (1651-1715) nMC&JI: <(OHM r O B O P R T , S T 0 IIPM3HaH)T B Sore T ~ o p u a 0, MYApOCTM KOTOPO~O C B W e T e J I b C T B y I O T Ero Aena, o A H a K o y HMX me n o n y c l a e T c c r , STO Ijor H e 6bm 6b1 HH A O ~ P ~ I MHM , MYAPbIM, eC.W 6b1 H m e J I m Y e J I O B e P C B O ~ O A H O ~ ~ ~oneji,TO eCTb C ~ O C O ~ H O Crpemmb, T ~ ~ H e C o r n a l u a T b c H c Ero nOH
K O H ~ ~ HUeJIbIo, O ~ ~ n e p e M H a Y M B a T b M M P O I I O P m O K M 110rM6aTb 6 e 3 ~ 0 3 B p a T H 0 ) >7.
@ e ~ e n Koa ~ caeTcR s ~ e c b O C H O B H O ~npo6ne~br ~ ~ e w s ~Ba : o6nmam~cnoco6-
KOHTeKCTe 3 T O r 0 MWPOR033PeHIIR JIIOAM H e
HOCTLdO COBePLUaTb 3HaYWMbIe A ~ ~ ~ C T B H&JIM X. MbI H e MOXeM c c n e p e ~ ~ aMWPO~OPHAOK*, ~~~b TO M ~ III c a m H m e r o H e 3HBYHM. Mb1 V O C T O MaPHOHeTEM:. EUXH X a X e AOIIyCTIITb, UTO KTO-TO H a A e n e H n m ~ o c ~ ~npwponoii, oii TO II B TarcoM cJryYae OH H e H M e e T C ~ O C O ~ H O C T K U CaMoOnpeAeneHHH). A e H c ~ b 1 ,K O H ~ Y H O , ~ ~ H ~ H ~ UTO I O Tu e, n o B e K H a A e n e H U H meJmeKmoM Cnjenarr a w e m H a Y e n o s e Y e c K o M pasme), ~pascm6eHHOCmMo (OHM OYeHb HHTepeCyIOTCff n p o 6 n e ~ STHEM:), a~~ a T a M e c n o c o 6 ~ o c ~Kb ~ 06 ) 4 e c m 8 e ~ ~ o3KU3HW fi II meOpYeCm6y. OAH~KO, CYHTaH)T OHH, BCe 3 T 0 , XOTH H nPWCYTCTBYeT B HPC KaK B COTBOpeHHbJX C W e C T B a X , H e HMeeT ~ B 0 e f ~i ~ ~ B o ~ ~ E I W H O ~ ~
xapamep Eora. ~ O A O ~ HB cOe M y OCTaTIbHOMy, BO B C ~ J I ~ H H3TW O ~ C~ B O ~ ~ C T B ~ 0 6 n a ~ a m~ ~B T O H O M H O~~~~P H P O A O~~ ~. J I o B eCTb ~ K TO, YTO OH
eCTb: y H e r 0 MUIO H a A e M b I H a TO, UTO OH MOXCT CTaTb KaKEIMTO AP)THM MnW YeM-TO ~ O J I ~ U I W M HeXeJIW , TO, YTO OH IIpeACTaBncreT co6oii ceiinac.
4. K o c ~ o c3mom , MUP,
H ~ X O ~ U 6~CC 6OR eM O ~ M Y H O MCOCmO-
RHUU, a 606Ce He 6 KaKOM-m0 nadrum lUlU HeHOPMMbHOM. M M MOXeM nOCnlUZall3b 6CefleHHyH) U , U3YYaR ee, onpedmmb, Yt?My M O X H O ynodo6umb 6 o z a .
T ~ K KaK B CBO& OCHOBe BCeJIeHHaR TaKOBa, K L ~ K o ~ ~ee COTBOpWI E o ~ a, JIIoAW HaAeJIeHbI H ~ ~ e ~ e 1 c r y a T cnoco6I b ~ 0 ~ HOCTbH) nOHEIMaTb 01~p)%aH)LLl.Hfi KX MWP, TO OHEI M O W IIOCTWr a n Eora B npouecce H c c n e n o s a m x Ero ~ c e n e ~ ~ ok icia. H W , KaK MbI )%e BWeJIM, rOBOPRT, YTO AJIII T ~ K O TOYEM ~ 3 p e H u X A ~ ~ ~ c T B H T ~ J IeCTb ~ H o OCHOBaHHX, nOCKOJIbKy a~e6eca PlpOllOBeAyIOT cJaaBy EoxHH),
H 0 AeJIaX p y K
Ero B e u a e T TBepAb*
(nc. 18:1). T ~ M C T KOHCYHO, ~I, T O X e CYHTaHIT, YTO 60r OTKpbIB a e T Ce6x B nPMP0AHOM M H P O ~ O P ~ K OAHaKO, e, C HX TOYEM: 3 p e P r w r , OH XaTIReT C e 6 ~ H B CJIOBaX - B OTKpOBeHIIII CBOW n p o p o K a M H pa3nHUHbIM 6116neiicm~n W C a T e m M , OTKpOBeHM, K o T o p o e npe8nonarae-r c n o s e c H o e 06ueme. K p o ~ Teo r o , T e k i c n r y T s e p m A a l o T , YTO Eor I L B ~C e 6 ~B C B O ~ Cbme M M~cyce,YTO cccno~oc ~ m onnoTLImv (HH. 1:14). A c TOYEM 3 p e H H R AeMCTOB, y 60ra C '4eJIOBeKOM H e T 0 6 u e ~ mH, e T W ~ e o 6 x o ~ ~ ~B oOcC m O ~ O M OTKPOBeHHH, II, CJIenOBaTeJIbHO, H k i r e r O TaKOrO H e np0HCXOAHT.
<(OS~B~H YTO OM ,
~ aI M e e M
Aeno c ~ o ~ o~ioi a e w a e i i
YeJIOBeM, KOTOPaR COBePlLIeHHO HeCOBMeCTHMa C XPIICTHaHc ~ o isepoii: i Eor-30,qraii7 COTBOPHBIIIM.~a nomepxm~amwii Y Y A ~ C H ~MkiPOIIOPrZqOK I~~ BO B C ~ A ~ H H O OTKPbIBaeTCR ~~, JIHlUb B npapoAe, a, T a m M 0 6 p a 3 0 ~ ,6omue HeT MecTa mx Eora xpacma~ceoiiApaMbI, Eora, HmenaBuero & a ~ a*cnoco6ao-
c n m rpeman a nepeu~a~u6amb muponop~do~u. Eor R ~ T L Z I ~ T Ce6a ~ o n b B~ rrpHpOAe, o HO He B HCTO~WII.OH OTKphLBaeTca B WAeCaX, KOTOPbIe UCCAeAyK)T HaT)'&WIUCTFd U 6 ~ o n o mHO , Ero 6onbme HeT B r e n o ~ e r e c ~ ocosecm fi c I I P I I C ~ E I M E Iefi Y~BCTBaMH rpexa, 6ecrec~m IzrrH 6naro~a~11, KOTOpbIe 6bmki TorAa, KorAa owyrumocb Eoxbe npacyrcTBae; OHnpeAomaBm YenoBeKy B03MOXHOCTb CaMOMY PelLIaTb CBOH) C Y A ~ ~ Y *
Eor AeacToB - TO C O ~ A ~ THO~ He J I nm6m4Mii ~, Oreq, He C y ~ b II a ~o061qe H e JIHYHOCT~. OHH e A ~ ~ C T B YB HCTOPIIK. ~T OH npeA0CTaBWX 3TOT MQY CaMOMY ce6e. OAH~KO, HeCMOTPR Ha TO, YTO, B H3BCCTHOM CMbICJIe, 'leJIOBe'leCTB0 MOXeT PelLIaTb CBOH) c y ~ b 6 y OHO, , TeM He MeHee, npe6b1sae~B 3 a ~ p b 1 ~ 0CIICTeMe. fi Ceo6oda om Eora
He craHosaTca csohdozi C J T H AeJIa, 3T0 II He C B O ~ O ABOBCe. ~
d m rero-na6o: no
OAHOa 3 n p o ~ m o p e ~ aAeasMa, ii B Hasane cBoero scce a 0 ~ e ~ l o e e ~(1773 e u r o ~ onacbmaeT ) A n e ~ c a w pH o p : Oncy~aBeAoM Eor a renoseK H ~ Ha M seurre, rAe ~ a u npoxoAKT r B~K? K ~ KB, W R YeJIOBeKa TOJIbKO WeCb, M ~ CIM e e M PaCCY)KAaTb, KaKOB OH B e ~ b ? K o r ~ ace6a ffarraeT Eor B mpax, ~ ~ B N JIH I ~ HaM T 60ra 3 ~ e l l 1 H ~l lf pi a ~ ?
C O ~ A ~ C3mM H O WeCTIl CTPOYMM, MbI MOXeM HOCTliraTb Eora TOJI~KO vepes accneAosaHae oIcpyxaIowero Hac Mapa. Beam TRrOTeeT K 3MZIUPH3MY. M3 OnpeAeJIeHHbIX AaHHarx MbI nomaeM ~ ~ u e - cseAeHLiR TO a s a ~ OTe YacTHoro ~ nepexonm
Bcrr HaLUa I ~ H @ o ~ M n~p uk fIX~O Im T K H a M TOJIbKO 113 o n m a . noyn r r p o A o n m a e T : K 06ueMy.
KTOB m H T C K B 0 3 b H e B m I 1 ~ b l gIIOKPOB CJIOX~W B C~~ J I ~ H H H O 3~ MIIPOB, ~ A p y r ~ ec o n H U a ,
KOHM c q e T y H e T ,
B I c p y r O B p a u e H M I 1 ApYrkfX
lWBHeT, ,@yrHX ~ 0 3 ~ a ~ II11Af ip ~ I l 3x n O X , TOT C K a m e T HBM, KLiK COTBOPMJI H a C 60r. Ho pa3se c o s e p l i i e ~ ~ e i i u rKapKLic, ~ii 9
b C~ oueHeHbrr H e
rn H a m m rna3,
T ~ o e iAyLUe i HCCJIeAOBaTb A a H O M B qacw qenoe ~ ~ K J I I O Y ~ H lo. O? 3Aecb
Il0yn rOBOPHT 0 TaKOM n 0 3 H a H H H 60ra H
nPIIPOAbI,
OH C a M n p m ~ a 3e ~~ 0cnpaurmacr , r m a T e n c r , M o x e T nw TOT 0603pen BCIO B c e n e H H y m 11 y ~ ~ e K~ a K bp a, 6 o ~ a eee ~ raco~oiiM e x a KOTOPOe HCRO3MOXHO IIOJIYqkITb OIIbITHbIM IIYTeM.
HM3M.
O A H ~ KeCXM O
3 T O r O H e M O X e T YMTdTeJIb, TO, HaAO
n o n a r a T b , H e M o x e T M CBM noyn. Ho B T a K o M c n y z I a e n o q e M y O H rOROPMT 06 O l ~ O M H L L X ,XOPOLUO C X U e H H b L X W C ~ X ?
OAHOI13 ABYX: MnU
BCHKOe 3 H a H l I e I I P k i X O m T H 3 OIIbITa, H
T0rAi-i MbI, C y u e C T B B KOHCYHbIe, H e M O X e M nOCTIl!Ib BCH) BCeneFXHYK, B UeJXOM, KlIH KaKOe-TO 3 H a H M e M O X H O IIOJIyzILITb H 3 A p y r O r O MCTOYHMKa, H a n p H M e p , I13 n P I 1 C w H X H a M B p O m e H HbIX ~ e f MnH i HOJIy'YeHHOrO OTKpOBCHIuI. OAH~KO, IIOAO~HO
now
~ O X L I ~ I I ~ H C T BACHCTOB, Y H e I I p I 1 3 H a e T OTKPOBeHUII K, K p o M e T O ~ O ,(no ~ p a i i ~ eMi ei p e , B c B o e M a 3 c c e u ) HH c n o B a H e I'OBOPIIT 0 B y O w e H H b l X m e R X .
T ~ K M06pa30~, M R r H o c e o n o r m noyna BIIAHM onpeneJ I e H H b I e HeCOOTBeTCTBMR. M M ~ H H O T a K O r 0 P O A a IIpOTHBOpe!IUII H C a e J I U I H ASM3M AOBOJIbHO IlIaTKI-IM MMPOB033PeHMeM.
5. S m u ~ aonpede/wemcn mehi, limo datio 6 o 6 4 e o~ m ~ p o e e HUU; IIOCKOAM~
6ceAeHHm t i o p a m i a , otia cahia n o ~ a 3 m ~ a e r n ,
VmO flpat3UAbti0.
E c n ~50ra
MOXHO YCMOTPeTb TOJIbKO B eCTeCTBeHHOM
MMpe, K O T O P ~ IK~TOMY Xe BOCnpMHMMaeTC5I K a K H ~ I I ~ ~ J J J L I TO M~~, MOXHO CAenaTr,
e u e OAMH BL~BOA,a
M M ~ H H O :Ear, KaK B C ~ M O -
m a k T~opeu,OTBeTcTBeHeH 3a X C b C Y U J ~ C T B ~ ~MEIPO~ ~ & n 0 p r i q O K . TOT MUP AOJlXeH OTpXKaTb Ezrrki TO, Y e r O 50r XOYeT, HilH TO, H a YTO OH lIOXOX.
B 3THYeCKOM CMbICJIe TaKaH ~03liJJIIII
BeAeT K C A e A y l o U e M y
TesHCy, U3nOXeHHOMY ~ ~ K C ~ H A~ o~J TOI oM :
3 a m ~ e B~npqo,qe o MacTepcTBo, X o ~ b~ e c n o c o 6 eT ~~ ~I O C T H Yero. ~ B pamme nm, H e x m e ~ ~ b l j j 3ewe; [ B c e ~ a p ~~ o oe 6 p oB YaCTIirHOM me, T ~ nOKOpHCb, K ~ 0 3 ~ aTBOPeHbIo fi YeCTb: ~ O M C T I ~BCE H ~ XOPOLUO, UTO ECTb ll.
no C>.Iu AeJIa, T a K U YCTaHOBKa IlpHBOAUT K p a 3 p y l r r e H H l O 3TKKM. ECAHnpaBEzrrbH0 ~ ~ C O J I K > T H OBCe, TO B TaKOM C n y Y a e H e T H H M K O r O 3Aa. A06p0 & I 3AO CTaHOBHTCH Hepa3JIUYUMbIMH, a, KaK CM3aJ'I 50pJIep: AH 5 0 T eCTb, TO 3 T 0 AbHBOA>>. H ~ T CMbICna rOBOPUTb O ~ o 6 p e~ , 6 0e ,c n U H e T cnoco6~ocmpamaUaTb, TO H e T H U TOTO, HM ApjTOTO: H U do6pa, HM 3na. & H K ~ HCY e 3 a e ~ . T ~ HM e M e H e e , KaK M ~ yme I o - r M e u m a , nIoAU n o - n p e x ~ e ~ y n p o B o A m o n p e A e n e H H b r e p a m u a x B H ~ ~ B C T B ~ Hcaepe. H O ~ ~B
MKOM-TO c M b r c n e ~ax,qbIji a3 H a c o T n u Y a e T x o p o l r r e e OT IIJIOXOrO, IIpaBEzrrbHOe OT H e n p a B I m b H O T O . B ~ 0 f ip e a J ' I b ~ 0 f i Y ~ J I o B ~ Y ~ c KCoH~T~ ~ ~ U H HB, K O T O P O ~ ~ MbI HaXOAWMCH, 3TEIKa AeUCTOB H a M H e rO,L@iTCH. A e w s ~ n p e B p a I 4 a e T C H B MUpOBO33peHHe, KOTOPOMY HeJLb3R CJIeAOBaTb, ll0TOMy YTO HHKTO H e MOXeT m b no ero n p a w a n a M . K O H ~ Y H O ,H e B c e AeKcTbr B m e n a (H BWT
ceji~ac),YTO m
npeAnOCbIJIKu BeAyT K TeM BbKBOAaM, K KOTOPbIhi lTpHlIIeA n0)TI. H ~ K O T OU~3 ~HHX I MKXKeTCH, YTO 3TWYeCKOe y r e H a e M ~ l c y c a- X O , l70 C).ru AeAa, ~ C T ~ C T B ~ H 3aKOH, H ~ I ~BbIpCiXeH~
~ b r i CAOBaMU. i HOB Harop~ofil7pOnOBeAU,
KOHeYHO
me,
HeT
HE.NeTO TaKOTO, YTO HaIlOMLlHaTIO 6 6 1 Te3KC, COrJIaCHO KOTOPOM y BCe, YTO eCTb, - n p a B H i l b H 0 . M H AyMaeTcH, ~ TO ecna ~ b r 6onee OCHOBaTeAbHO PaCCMOTpKM MLIPOB033PeHMe AeUCTOB, TO Y B m H M , UTO O W lTPOCTO HenOCneAOBaTeJIbHbI U H e n p U 3 H a I o T 3TOr0.
A n e ~ c a ~JIoyn, ~ p n m o M y ZITO, O ~ ' ~ R B T I XBCe, H ZITO e C n , IlpaBWIbHLLM, OH B TO x e Bpeh4.H p y r a e T n m ~ e i 3a i HX ropaocn (B K O T O P O ~ ~e, c n H c n e A o s a T b ero T o r K e 3 p e H H H , B O O ~ ~ ~ ~H-e TA O O M H O 6b1~bHHZIerO WIOXOTO!): H€X-IOCJI~AOB~T~JI~H c a M
M ~ rOPAOCTbH) I ~
~ C C ~ A O Z ~QHe l Or r I~l M
ki K COBePlrreHCTBY rOPHeMY CIIelrrHM. X o ~ e n a6b1 M ~ aI m e n a m c T a T b , ki B GOTH M e m T ar-renbcKaR p a n . Ho a H r e n b l M m e m b r e B wy, A venosem ~ ~ ~ c T B ~B I6Op eT ~ y ; KTOH 3 B p a U a T b B C ~ M M P H L IC~T~P O ~Aep3HyJI, ~ TOTH a ~ ~ P B o I I P H Y H H YIIOCHrHyJI 12.
AYM~T~,
co6oii HeZlTO 6 o n b l r r e e , a rOpAOCTb - 3 T 0 H W T O H e B e p H O e , A w e 2pm. O A H ~ KoO6 p a ~ BHHMaHHe: ~~e QeX H e npOTHB Eora KaK JIHZIHOCTU, a IIPOTHB < < B e Z I ~ o IIpHZIHHbI*, fi TO eCTb IIPOTMB K ~ K O ~ - T @ O M ~ O C O @ C K O a6c-rpa~1.1~~. ~~ B TaKOM KOHTeKCTe Arne CaMO M O B 0 Zpm n p u o 6 p e ~ a e HHJW ~ OKpaCKy. B-ee, o A H a K o , TO, ZITO c a M o n o w T H e rpexa AOJIXHO H C Z I ~ ~ H Y T ~ e, c n H MH c v m a e M , ZITO B c e , 'ITO ecm, - n p a B m b H o . ZlTO TM npeACTaBjTHelUb YeM eCTb H a CaMOM AeJIe, - rOpAOCTb,
A~H~TLI
CTpeMWIMCb COXPaKZlTb HpaBCTBeHHOe C0AepX.aH H e XpHCTHaHCTBa, HO H e MOrJIH H&TH JIJMH e r 0 I I O , D , X O A ~ e r O OCHOBaHkiR.
no 3~0fiIIpHYMHe
H H3-3a ~ B 0 e f iHenOCJIeAOBa-
TeXLHOCTH AeM3M KaK C e p L e 3 H O e MZIpOBO33peHZIe l T p O C ~ e C T BOBWI OTHOCHTeJIbHO HeaOJIrO, XOTH ZI CerOAHR eCTb JXKIAZI, CvwTamrrlHe
ce6~ AekiCTaMZI.
6. N c m o p u m e e m flutieu'tioe pa3sumue, noctcoflbtcy caMo passumue scenetitiou' 6 ~ onpeduetio 0 s MoMetim msopeHu. OXO OX^, ZITO CaMH AeHCTbI H e CJIllluKOM HHTepeCJWTCR H c T o p H e f i , IIOTOMy ZITO, KaK IIOAZlepKuBWI Epefie, 3 H a K l z e 0 Eore o m o T ~ 1 c m B a m - rB n e p B y m oyepenb B n p H p o A e . JIo HX M H e r u i m , ZICTOPZIR e ~ p e i i c ~ o rHoa p o A a , n p e A c T a a r r e H H a r r B EZI~JIZIZI, BeCbMa
IIOJIe3Ha H e KaK nOBeCTBOBaHkie 0 50XbH.X
A e t I m m B m3m ZIenoBeYecTBa,
G O X ~ C T B ~ H H O ~3aKOHa, O
a
KaK m m c ~ p a u k i r rT o r o
H 3 KOTOPOrO M O M 0 BbIBeCTH COOTBeT-
CTByIOLQIle HpaBCTBeHHbIe IIpHHUHnbI.
CO~JI~CHO, HaIIpZIMep,
T o p a ~ ~(1670y 1722), CaMO XpKCTHaHCTBO T a K Xe mopeme; E ~ a ~ r e n - ~TO e c B o e r o pons arrepeK3AaHHeB P e J I K I X K IIpKpOAbI. C T ~ K TOYKU O ~ 3 p e W Kamen ~ 6 KOHKPeTHbIe 0 KCTOPKYeCKHe A e R W H e T a K JCX K EWfWhl, awem A e n a e T c r r H a 0 6 I I i e 3 ~ a Y M ~ b rnpmqunax. x K ~ cK rtasarr noyr~,a n e p B o r r p m K H a B TOM, YTO c y ~ b~ ~ K O H 0M6 u k i e B &KOH)'
cTapo, K ~ K
Eory C O B e p l u e H H O H e K H T e p e C H b I HM 0 T ~ e J I b H b d K p o ~ Te o r o , B c e n e H H a R s a ~ p b r ~ ce6e, O ~ 3 T 0 H e OTlCpbITaR CKCTeMa, B K O T O ~ O KOH MOT 6b1
IIPOCTOMB 13.
Y e a o B e K , HK u e n b I e H a p o m . BC ~ M
YTO-JIKGO
1
I
nepeKHaYmb.
CO B p e M e H e M
C T W O RCHO, YTO AeK3M HeJIb3R H a 3 B a T b
XOpOluO O ~ O C H O B ~ H H M M MHpOBO33peHMeM.
B HHTeJIJIexiy2UIb-
HOM MMPe ~ ~ ~ H L I K[ K A ~Kr n k i uO H TOClIOACTBOBU HeAOJITO: C KOwa
17-io K a0 IIep~ofiI I O J I O B M b I l8-r0 ~ e K ~a
~ H M X ~BC T O
TeM3Ma, C a M O H YCTyrIKTI A O p O v HaTYPaTIH3MY. ~ b
f:
a
n o r e ~ y3 T 0 M K P O B 0 3 3 P e K M e OKll3aTTOCb CTOJTb MLIMOJICT~ h iO? C H O B HlIpMYMHbI ~I~ MbI JCXe O T M e T l m K : B H y r p e H H 5 U I
A O T H Y C C W HeIIOCJIeAOBaTeJILHOCTb K H e O C m e C T B K M O C T b H a l l p a K T K K e H e K O T O p b M e T 0 I I p M H W l I O B . BOTOCHOBHLIe MOMOHT b I HelIOCJIeAOBaTeAbHOcTM, AOBOZbHO CKOPO 3 a S U i M ~ L U e f i 0
ce6e: 1) B
?+
' F
O ~ A ~ C T3TklKII H AeH3M KCXOAHJI I13 ITPCAlTOJIOXeHIIFI, YTO H a w MNP H e napmati, YTO OH n p e A c r a m n e T co608 HOP~ a r r b ~ yBr co e n e H V , M B p e s y n b ~ a ~( Ke ~ KB cnyrae c h e ~ c a A p O M n0yrI0~) n O A C n y A H 0 npOBOAKTIaCb MLICAb 0 I I p a B W I b H O CTH B e e r 0 C m e T O . tam^ 06pa30~, )Vpa.1MB2UIOCb K O H K p e T H O e
conepxame ~ T K K I ( . O A H ~ KAeKCTbI O GLLIIM
B e C b M a 3 a K H T e p e C O B a H b I B ee coxpa-
H e M M , llOCKOJIbKy H 3 BCeX pa3AeJIOB XpKCTMaHCKOrO YYeHWI
o ~ a s m a c brn HZW ~ a ~ 6 0 n ne ep ~ e ~ ~ ~ e ~ o f i . T LOT I Y a c T H o r o K 064eMY r r o T e p n e n o H e y A a y y , ~IOCKOJIMCY ~ I ~ K I ~KT TOYHOMY M 0606oHa
2) B raoceonorm cTpeMneme ~
1
U e H M H ) MOXHO, JIEllLIb PaCnOJIaTaff ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y HPa3YMOM, ~LM C ~ I O C O ~ H ~OTCJ'IeXl-fBaTb IM BCe H ~ O ~ X O A H M ,?ljIff ~ I 3~T O r 0 AeTWlM.
~ -
W H e JItoAH IIpHlUJIII K w e e 0THOCHTeJIbHOCTI-i BCRKOTO l l 0 3 H a H M , XOTb WM 6 b ~ HeJIerKO 0 3 T 0 nPWH5ITb 14. 3) TO K a c a e T c R ~ e n o ~ e ~ e c~ P~HoPjOi A ~TO I, n e p e ~ n ~ 3 a ~ p b I T 0 f i W IIOTOMY ~ e ~ 0 I I y c K a I oHHKaKOrO ~ e ~ W3MeHeHW
uo~
B C ~ ~ ~ HH eH n bO 3 R ~6bmo W rOBOpWTb 0 3HaYIIMOCTkI YeJIOBeKa
w ero H H A H B ~ ~ ~ T ~ ~ H O3C T~ H~a.H ~ Y H M O CwT~~e x a w q e c m i t A e T e P M I I W 3 M IIPOCTO H e yXHB&JIWCb Ap)T C Ap)TOM. cel?0,4HR MOXHO H a 3 B a T b ewe HeCKOJIbKO aCneKTOB AeW3M a , KOTOPbIe BbI3bLBaH)T COMHeHZle. Y Y e ~ b 1 e B OCHOBHOM n e p e c T a T J H p a c c M a r p H s a T b B c e n e H H y m K ~ Kr k i r a m c m e Y a c u . ~ $ ~ B ~ c T HYTO o , 3JIeKTpOHbI ( ~ rOBOPR e )'X 0 APYlTiX C ~ ~ ~ T O M H L X YaCTHqaX, KOTOPbIe BBepTaH)T HaC B ewe 6onbmee HeAOy h i e ~ a e )B e A y r c e 6 ~c o B c e M H e K ~ K=me-TOM e n m e Y a c m ~ e x a ~ a sA ~w a e. e c n H B c e n e H H a H H n p e A c T a m e T co6oii
T ~ K O GMeXaHHsM, OH r O p a 3 A O CJIOXHee, YeM 6bu0 IIpWHIITO AyhiaTb, a 60r COBeplUeHHO H e IIOXOK H a KaKOrO-TO <<30AYerO*
-
I Z ~ K< w a c o B u m a u . Eonee T o r o , Y e n o s e u e c K a R n H Y H o c T b TO T o m e ~ ( ~ I ~ K~TcHe n e ~ ~ oH i ecm i, 60r COTBOPWI ee m e m o T ~ K O G TO , H e H a 0 n k i H 0 H ~ I'OBOPHTb M KaK 0 . ~ Y H o c T H ?
T~MM 0 6 p a 3 0 ~C, H C T O ~ W Y ~ C KT O Y~ ~K I ~ ~ ~ ~ H AeH3M .H~I, TO H e K o e n p o M e x y r o w o e M H P O B O ~ ~ ~II~ THe M Z ~H ~e M e H e e ena as^ C K ~ ~ ~ TZITO L , ceiiuac OH M e p m . f l e a s ~n p o A o r r m a e T K M T b A MMPOB033PeHIIH HeKOTOPbIX )"XHbIX, pa60~am1qmB a K a e M M u e c K k i x u e ~ ~ p no a x B c e M y m p y . fi n k i u H o 3 ~ a mT e x ,
K T 0 CUHTaeT ce6a AeHCTOM, II nOAO3peBaH), YTO M H O W e 6ecc03H a T e n b H O HBJIRH)TCR TaKOBbIMH. E c n ~T ~ K Ow e~~ b I f i , K i K , HanpwMep, fbb6ep~ 3 j l m ~ e f ia~y c, M a r p m i a e n BO B c e n e ~ ~ o f i WIEI B H e ee KBKJW-TO BL1CIlI)QO CWIY W, KPOMe TOrO, OTCTaMBaeT HiLnkiuHe p u y M a B c o T s o p e H H o M M a p e , ero, no cym A e n a , MOXHO C'iMTaTb AeMCTOM, XOTR, B H e BCRKOrO COhfHeHHX, MHOr H e n p O C T 0 H e XOTeJlH 661 J T R e P m a T b HeYTO TaKOe, YTO C J I W K O M ~ L nOXOAIlJI0 I H a @WIOCO@HH) W 3 H U IS.
H ~ O X M ~ ~IlepeA H H O ,&IB~OM IlpeflCTaIla TOrHaR KapTMHa CMePTM: m H H H a R H o p a B 3 e ~ n eH , e uupe T B o e r o Tena, B KOTOPYIO ~ e 6 ~ T a U a T , B TO BpeMR KaK 6 n e ~ ~ bnML@ l e OTXOMT KyAa-TO H a 3 a . T b l x o r e u r b AO HMX A O T F I H ~ ~ ~ CHO R , PYKM n p n x a T M . C n o n a T H a nu40 CblflneTCR TPR3b.
cnenoA
Tbl
OCTaHeLllbCR T a M HaBCerAa, BblTRHYBUMCb,
~ e 6 eHHKTO H e BCflOMHHT H HMKorAa H e ~ O ~ O B n~ aTn .b u u Y ~ H H R I O T C R ,a 3 y 6 nesyr ~ Ha CTOPOHM B o r p o ~ ~ opacnon3ao~eAc~ il rpmace, c o e c e M noxomen H a nonocy M e n a . M s e ~ PYUIMTCR, n ~ M conwe r a c H e T , H TaM, H ~ ~ ~ M O ~ B HMM CO~ BI p, e M e H e M 0
rAe
KOrAa-TO 6 b l n ~ 3Be3,Qbl1 UapCTByeT HeM3MeHHaR TbMa.
-
Ae~sm TO CBoerO pOAa nepeukeK M e w ~ ( ~ y KOHTWh a ~ Hemam: T ~ H ~ M OwMH ~ T Y ~ ~ I I H ~ M 3To O M . e c ~ e c m e ~ wn iyi~ b , s e ~ r n i or i nepBoro KO BTOPOM~, H XOTR, BO~MOXHO, 6e3 AeH3Ma HaTypaJIH3M TaK JIeIXO He IIOlIBWCR 6161,Aew3M TeM He MeHee Bcero xurub n p o ~ e x y r o ~s ~ a~ninoxom2i ,i Ha HeKym HHTWIJIeKTyaJIbHyIo AOCTOllpHMeYaTeJ'IbHoCTb. YTOXe KaCaeTCR
~ a ~ y p m w sTO ~ arro , yxe Hewo cepbe3~0e. B HHTeJUIeIcryaIIbHOM CMbICJIe 3TOT l7j'Tb BbITWeJI CJIeAymwaM 0 6 p a 3 0 ~ :B ~ e a s Eor ~ e npeAcTaeT K ~ K ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y H ~ R JIHYHOCT~, T ~ o p e uw O c ~ o s a~ c e ~ ~ e B~ ~~ eowi is ;OH ~ eapeAyqHpyeTCR*, HaqHHaeT )IpaYHBaTb C ~ o m JIWIHOCTHYIO npHpOJQ', XmlI ki OCTaeTCR TBOPUOM L.i T0fi ~ W o f i KOTOpaR , IIOmep-
m a e T KOCMOC; B H ~ T ~ ~ ~ T Eor I E Iewe ~ M 6om11re ~ epemwpyeTcm ki ~ P O C T OyTpaYwBaeT caMoe C ~ o cyiqecmosame. e
H M ~ Ho, 3 ~ a ~ e ~ o s a co6oii ~ 1 . u ~ nepexon ~ OT ~ e w s ~ Ka HaTYPWIki3MY, 6 e c ~ k i c n e ~ M ~H oO eXCCTBO, oco6e~1-10B IIePkiOA M e w 1600 ki 1650 roaaMw. Cpem HHX M O ~ ~O a 3 ~ Pa e~~ be AeKap~a(1596- 1650). OHBnOJXHe C03HaTenbHO Bb16paJX Teki3M, OAHaKO, BOCnpkiHHMl3H BCeJIeHHj'IO KaK I X ~ ~ H T CMeXaHki3M KU~~ uMaTepwwu, ~mopyro YenoseK nocmrae-r ~ P ~ ~ ~ M OnoAroToM H , BKTI ~ O Y B Y~IJLH 6yayiqero nepexona. no cym aena, Ae~apT PaCwenIvr PeaJIbHOCTb Ha ABa B a a 6brrm ki C T0fi nOPhI 3ana)JHba MHP C TPYAOM M O r PaCCMaTPkiBaTb c e 6 KaK ~ eAkiHOe senoe. Halyparrkic~br, peIIrkiBlukie ~ a i i n irqm K emHcTsy, cnenanki p a s y ~onpeAeneHmIM nopgaoM Ma-repkiki, oc~arcJM~lueii~H Ha MeXaHMCTkiYeCKOM YpOBHe. ~ O K K (1632- 1714), B OCHOBHOM Tekicr, Bepm B Eora KaK ~ V H O C T ~RB , kiBlUYIO C e 6 HaM, ~ OAHaKO CVkiTaJX, VTO Mepy
DOH
WCTknHHOCTki 6w6neiic~oroOTIcpOBeHuR AOJJXeH OnpeAemTb HauI 6 0 r 0 ~ a H ~ b Ipa3yM. fi Y 6 p a ~ki3 3T0G KoHqenqHki CJIOBO e 6 0 r o ~ a ~ ~ b I HalypaTIEIcTH ji*, npeBpamki p a 3 y ~ B emHcrseH~ b I j i~ p k i ~ e p aW i iC ~ H M . O ~ ~ oki3 i icaMHx kiH-repecHhIx Qaryp B TOM npoqecce CMeweHkiR aKJJeHTOB, 6 b XlOJIbeH ~ OQpe Ae ~ M ~ T P H (1709- 1751). B cBoe s p e m ero Aaxe C V H T ~ J I M aTekicToM, OAHaKO C a M O H rOBOPWI TaK: aTenepb, K O r a a H CTaB.ilK, nOA coMHeHkie cyiqecTBosaHkie sllcruero Cyiqecma, MHe KameTcR, YTO BeCbMa 3HaYkiTeJIbHl3H CTeneHb BePOIITHOCni rOBOPkiT B nonbsy 3 ~ 0 i sepbr*. i O A H ~ KAanee O OH noacme-r: USTO TeopeT m e c m kicmHa, He kiMemwaR n o ~ m H W K ~ K npamkivec~oji O~~ qeHHOCTH* l. n p w u ~ ~Ha a , ocHosaHww ~ o ~ o p oJ iI ia ~ e ~ p npmomT ki K B~IBOAY, VTO 6brrkie Eora He kiMeeT IIOVTH H W K ~ K n O p~ a~m u e C K O ~~ H ~ V I I M O C T H3, a ~ n m ~ a B e TOM, ~ c ~ VTO Eor ,DJM Hero rnoflbicoT ~ o p e sq c e n e ~ ~ oHiHe i 6onee. C ~ Eor M He npkiHkiMaeT
Ehfy BCe PaBHO, IIOKTIOHEInki EMYKTO-TO B 3 ~ 0 j i~ c e n e ~ ~m ok jii H ~ T . T a m 0 6 p a 3 0 ~ 6brrkie , Eora, no CYTM Aena, M O ~ HOe npkimMaTb BO BmMaHkie K ~ K H e memwee ~ k i ~ a ~~ o H ~fViI I M O C T W 2. HM~HH TaKOe O M k i P O O m e H k i e ki T ~ K B OhIB ~OA 3HaMeHOsmki nepexon K H ~ T V D U H ~ M VB . T e o D m J l a ~ e m u- neutrr. R HkiKaKOrO JIIlvHOrO yYaCTkiH B Hea, ki
eTcrr
1. Mamepwr cy~qecmsyemu3sev~ou npedcmasmem co6oti me, Ymo Y o x e m cy~qecmsosamb.Eoza Hem. K ~ KB ~ e ~ EI3 ~~e ae s ~ nepsbfi e, TWHC 3 ~ e c bT o x e K a c a e T c R npHpOAhI 6b1~m. B n e p B b I X AByX MHpOBO33peHkMX p e v b m a o Eore. B ~ a - r y p m ~ H s a~ M e e m o Eora masmca KOCMOC, K 0 ~ 0 p b f iH3HaYaTIeH, TaK KaK T e n e p b , KOrAa B e Y H b f i
6 0 r - T B O P6onee ~ ~ H e n p H H H M a e T C a BO BHHMaHHe, KOCMOC CaM CTaHOBHTCR BeYHbIM, XOTH H H e BCerAa B ~ ~ 0 e~fb iI H ~ U l H e f i Q o p ~ H, e no cy~wA e n a , ~aseprurrcaH e B ~ e f4.i JIyvure B c e r o YI-Y MbICJIb BbIpa3Izrr aCTPo@H3HK H n O ~ J L I l p H 3 a T O pH a m QpJI C a r a ~c~asa~rrrafi, , YTO <
B K ~ K O ~ ~ -@ T Oo p ~BCH e MaTepkur B c e n e ~ ~ o f i cyuecmosma B c e r A a . C ~ MCJIOBO O YUmepW7 HaAO nOHElMaTb B AOBOnbHO U H P O KOM c M H c n e , n o c K o n b r c y H a u m m c 18-1-0 BeKa H a y K a B c e 6onee pacrrrwma n p e A c T a m e H u e o ~ e f i Y;le~bm . ewe n p e A c T o m o O q b r r b , YTO MaTepKH H e TOJIbKO 0 6 n a ~ a c.JIoXHO~~ e~ ClpyKTYpofi, HO YTO OHa TeCHO CBR3aHa C 3 H e p I X e f i . OHMOCMbICJIRJIH ee K ~ COBOK~IIHOCT~ K HH K Y e w 6onee H e C B O ~ M ~ uI eXa m w u u , c a M o r o KocMoca.
CmeCTsyIoIIJHX B ~ O C T ~ ~ H C T B ~ H H O - M ~ X ~CBH3EI HEIY ApJT ~CKO~~,
c~ p y r o ~ TOG , CBH~HK , OTOP~
s y ~H ap a ceI c~p b I s a e T m ~ k u r H @113HKa H KOTOPaH HaXOAHT CBOe BbIptlXeHKe b H e y ~ 0 J I k i M b I X e3aKOHaXu. U O ~ ABbIIICHKTIOCb, H~~ YTO IIPHpOAa H e CTOJIb RCHa HJIH, no ~ e ~ b r r r eMf ei p e , H e c ~ o n b npoc-ra. Ho-BLZ~IIM H eOC~ m,e C T B y e T HEIKaKkM HeCB0,QMMbIX 4e,4Ha @ ~ s a u e c mse a ~ o H~ Mbe m ~ TOJI~KOM a T e M a m Y e c K o e
~m*,
BbQX3XeHWe. Tenepb me HeJIb3ff 6m0 C YBePeHHOCTbK) CKa3 a ~ b Y, T c060ii ~ n p e A c r a m e T npapona IHLTIEIYTO o H a , npennon o m T e n b H o , A o m a co6oii npeac-ramn. T ~ HMe M e H e e HaTYPaTIElCTOB 0 6 ~ , e ~ . ~ i Te3HC, me~ ~0~0pbIfi MbI npHBeJIE1 BbIUIe. no Elx MHCHHM, HeJSb3R CKa3aTb, YTO KOCMOC COCTOHT E13 ABYX HaYaTI - MaTepHH E1 pa3yhia KnE1 MaTepHH H AyXa. no CJIOBaM .bMeT&lW, U B O B ~ e f BceJIeKHofi i C m e C T B y e T TOJIbKO OAHa cfic~a~qkiff, pa3JIHYHbIM 06pa30~ BHAOE13MeHlilQ~2UICrr*6. B KOHeYHOM CYeTe, KOCMOC - 3 T 0 H W T O OAHO, H e E1MeK)aee H H K ~ K OCBff3H ~ C f f ~ 0 6 b I HaXOWWHMCff H a HUM C ~ ~ C T B O M HeT ; HWKaKOrO ~60ra*, HMKaKOrO
<
HyEO MOXHO OCMbICJIffTb KaK MeXaHH3M, IHLTIEI YaCbI, a MOXHO E1 H e Aena-rb 3~01-0.C o ~ p e ~ e ~ p ~ ebma r ee 0 6 ~ a p y x c m ~ YTO , CBff3b M e m y Pa3nHYHbIMII 3JIeMeHTaMEI PeaTIbHOCTH rOpa3AO c n o x H e e , a M o x e T 6 b r r b , ti s a r a o ~ ~ e uee,M B n p k i M e p e c YaCOBbIM MeXaHW3MOM. T ~ M H e M e H e e B c e n e H H a R o c T a e T c R 3arcpmmou' cwc~e~ofi. h 3 HeJIb3ff H3MeHCiTb BHelUHWM B O ~ A ~ ~ ~ C T HH B WCO ~M CTOPOHbI V a H c q e y n e H m o r o Cy-uecma ( n o c ~ o n b i c yEro n p o c T o H ~ T,) MM - K n o 3 ~ ~ e Me~ I06 TOM nOrOBOpwM n o ~ p o 6 ~ e-e co CTOPOHbI aBTOHOMHOr0 YWIOBeYeCKOI'O C W e C T B a ( ~ T o c K o J I ~ K ~ OH YaCTb 3 T 0 3 a K p b I ~ 0 f i C W C T ~ M M ) . X a p a ~ ~ e p a Aar-tHym sy~ T O Y K ~3 p e m 3 ~ m Epeiie b miweT: ~ I o P ~ ~ a~ 6 ~ 1o ~ )K A a e, M b rBi i npwpone, n p e A c T a m e T ~060fi J I ~ l l r r b~ e o 6 x o A . L i ~ y JTIOPq4OYeHHOCTb m ee ~acrefi,OCHOBaHHyno H a c a ~ o icyrw i seueii; H a n p u M e p , n p e K p a c H o e repeAOBaHHe BpeMeH rOAa - 3 T 0 H e CJIeACTBHe 6 0 x e c r ~ e ~ ~ o r o s a ~ b r c n a ,a p e 3 y n b ~ ra p~a s I i T a s m i * 7.
BO BTOPOMWaHWCTHYeCKOM XalQUeM
M ~ H H @ ~ c (1973), T~ BbIpaB3~JIRAbI TCX, KT0 ~ a 3 b I B a e Tce611 UCeKYJIffPHbIMEl
"Y
ryMaHHCTaMHB, CKa3aHO TaK: HaC HeT AOCTaTOYHhtX OCHOBaHW#, Y T O ~ MBePWTb B CY'IL(eCTB0BaHIle CBePfieCTeCTBeHHOrOH *.
k n w HW Eora, HH C B e p l C b e c r e c T R e m o m HeT, TO, KoHeYHo, B C ~ ,
YTO IIPOWCXOAWT, nPOWCXOA&iT B W W AaHHOrO M E i p O n O p ~ K a . POAO e i i p 6 p ~ npp~R~M 0 TOBOPWT: <4Mb1H e n p W 3 H a e M r y A e C H 0 -
ro* (&TheColumbia History of the Worldu, 1972) 9. Hwo c ~ a s a ~ b , YTO T a K o e y - r B e p x q e m e npo@eccopareonorm Kony~6wiic~or0 YHWBePCWTeTa H e HBJIIIeTCR YeM-TO HeOXMAaHHbIM. YAWBHT~JI~HO YTO , IlOYTW TO Xe CaMOe rOBOPWT W I I p e n O AaBaTeJIb C e M W H a p m J J ~ B ~ T&KoGnmr: A a M b ~(TO eCTb COBpeMeHHbIe JIIOAW) BOCnpWHliMaeM BCeJIeHHylO K a K LKeJIOCTHOe eAWHCTB0 n p O C l p a H C T B a , B p e M e H l i H MaTepWW, 06pasyl01uee 3TY UeJIOCTHOCTb K a K 6b1 W3H)TpW. ...H e n b s ~ CKasaTb, YTO 60r HaXOAHTCR rAe-TO B H e B p e M e H l i W IIpOClpaHCTBa, PaBHbIM o 6 p a s o ~OH H e RBXIIeTCR YCM-TO BHelLIHWM W n0 OTHOllIeHliH) K MaTePWW, TO eCTb WMeH)IuWM CBR3b C ~ A ~ X O B H O GYaCTbIO * Y e n o s e m . ...H ~ M K ~ K - T O H ~ nOp ~ 3 ~ a m YTO , UWCYC Xpm-
TOC - n o p o m e H w e T o r o x e ~ B O J I I ~ ~ W O H H O npoqecca, ~O =KOBbIM RBTLIFeMCR W BCe MbI* 10. UT~K, nbITaeTCH OCMbICJIWTb XPWCTWaHCTBO B KOHTeKCTe HaTypWIWCluYeCKOrO MWPOB033peHIltI. KOH~YHO, nOCJIe T o r 0 KaK 60ra 4llOMeCTIIJIW* BIi)TQW CWCTeMbI - eAWH006pa3~oii3 a K p b 1 ~ 0 g CWCTeMbI nPWYWH H c J I ~ A C T B W ~ ,- OH )IpaTIm H e TOJIbKO CBOH) BePXOBHJW BnaCTb, HO W MHOrOe A p y r o e , YTO x p H n W a H e no I p a A ~ m Kc ~ m m WCTWHH~IMno OTHOlIIeHWH) K H e ~ yJJeno . B TOM, YTO H a T y p m W 3 M - BeCbMa p a c n p o c l p a H e H H o e M E I ~ O B O ~ ~ ~K ~o THo M p o ~e M , O ~ oO6 ~ a p y xmbB caMm H e o m a H m x Meam. K ~ K O BOCHOBHbIe ~I npW3HaKH 3 ~ 0 k~ U K P ~ ~ C MHOC ~T ~ M ~ I ? H a ~ y p a J I l l c ~ by IT B e p ~ a H ) T ,YTO BCeJIeHHaR IIpeACTWJIReT CO6oii aqenocmoe eA&iHcTBo n p o C T p a H c T B a , B p e M e H l i W M a T e p m , 06pasyrowee 3 T y UeJIOCTHOCTb KaK 6b1 W3HyT'W*. ~ o A Y ~ ~ K M ~ m YTO , s a ~ p b ~ ~c wac Ta e M a eAWHa 3a c r e T ~ e n p e n o m o i iw H ~ P ) " J U H M O ~~~P I I Y H H H O - C A ~ A C T B ~ H HCBR3W, O~ HaTypaTIWCTbI npeACTaH)T KaK C l p O r W e AeTepMWHHCTbI. ~ O J I ~ ~ U W H C T W BO 3 HIM A ~ ~ ~ c T B W T ~ J TaKOBbI, I~HO XOTR MHOrWe Y I ' B e p ~ a I o T , YTO TaKaR YCTaHOBKa H e JTIpa3AHReT ~ a l L I e f C i B O ~ O A H OBOJIW ~ ~ W OTBeTCTB e H H o c l u 3a CBOW noclynm. Ho c o r n a c y e ~ AH c ~ c ~ o 6 0 ~c a ~01.n1enqWeii 3 a ~ p b 1 ~ 0CkL I C T ~ M ~ I&lIH ? TOrO, Y T O ~ H OTBeTkfTb H a TOT B o n p o c , H a M H ~ 6onee O n o ~ p o 6 ~p aoc c M o l p e m HaTypaJIWCTWYeCKyIo KOHqenUWH) reJIOBelca.
&KO~JIWHI.
3. Ymoserc -smo cnoxrran mauuttau; nuwiocmb npedcmasm e m co6ow' s3amocsx3b q3u3urec~wc u xwturecKwc csou'cms, xomopue e y e tie n o w m u do Kotiya. a e ~ a cril-rm, p ~ YTO . r e n o s e K - o w a c T w M a m m a , owacTM - p a 3 y ~K a K oco6an C ~ ~ C T ~ H HO U I ~OJI~LLM[HCTBO ~ ~ . HaTyPibnUCTOB BOCT[PIIHkiMaK)T pa3YM W1K CO3HaHHe KaK @YHKJJWH) ~ ~ O M H H ~MUJlMHGI. T O ~ ~ n a ~ e ~ pOAHH k i ki3 n e p B b I X BbIpa3KJI 3TO M H e H H e C rpy6osa.roii I ~ ~ H M O<<MT~K, T O ~ - l-IkULleT OH, - MbI AOJUKHbI CAeJIaTb C M ~ J I BLIROA, ~ G YTO YeAOBeK RaTIIFeTCII MaIIIkl~ o i iK YTO BO ~ c e l i~ c e n e ~ ~coy ria ie c T B y e T TOJI~KO oma C Y ~ C T ~ W U I I , P W k i V H L I M 0 6 p m 0 ~B m O k i 3 M e H H I o w U C I I * ll. Eonee p e s ~ o06 TOM r o B o p m n b e p X ~ Xopx H Ka6a~wc
s T a m o6pa30~,B c n p a e c n a ~ e ~ p~ wb wMeeM... l npwYywwBOe OnwcaHwe YenoseYecKoro Tena K ~ K CwcTeMbl ~oo6pax a e M b I x I r r e c T e p e H , sy6qo~ w x p a n o s w K o B . E y ~ p wM L I K ~ O K O CMOM, Y e n o B e K n p o c T o n p e A c T a a n c r e T co6oii ewe OWH M e x a HH3M B TOG K O C M Z ~ ~ ~ CMaZLIZIHe, KO~~ KOTOpaR IIaTIIFeTCII KOCMOCOM. H a ~ T I nI p w Y y m m L I e w rpy60~ameo n w c a m , MU H e MOXeM C A e p X i T b Y J I ~ I ~ K L . OAHaKO I, T ~ ~ K OJIeAeeM M MaICJlb, YTO BCe OKH B KOHUe K O U O B IlpaBIIJIbHbI, XOTII II HeMHOrO n p e ~ e s p e ~ e m bCr .n p m e c m w e M K o M n b I o T e p a c o 6 n a 3 ~ Ma-
rwrr
IrrHHki3aqHH CTaHOBIlTCR ewe 6onee HenpeOAOJIkiMbIM, noCKOnbKY B AaHHOM CJIySIae MLI HMeeM AeAO YXe H e C KaIUfM-TO YCTapeJIbIM MeXaHki3MOM, COCTOBwHM I13 KOJIeC II ~ A O K O B , a C TeM, KOTOP~&, n o - B m I I M O M Y , M O X e T BOCllPOW3BO&kiTb np0qeccbr, cosepmamwaecrr B YenOBeYecKOM c 0 3 ~ a m w M . OX~T JIM M a l u l l H a MLICAHT~? B H W e BpeMII 3TOT BOnPOC HaYIJHaeT AOMIIHHPOBaTb* 13.
KOTOPbIe K ~ e ilTPWIOXHMb1, i nPkiMeIUIMb1 H K HaM. ki HeJIb3R C K m a n , YTO B K ~ K O M - T OC M ~ I C J M ? ~ ~ MI o x e M B~XGTH 3a npenenb~ BC~JI~HHO~~. MM, KOHeYHO, npenCTaBAHeM
co6oii AOBOJIbHO
CJIoXHbIfi
n o m n ~ i no i K o H u a , H ~ O ~ T OY eMn o~B e K IIpOAOJDKaeT H3JWJIXTb H a C a 0 6 ~ a ~ b l B HalI.IIl a ~ b OWaHkicr, OQHaKO m6aa 3arwKi3 - 3 T 0 H e pe3yJIbTaT K ~ K O ~ - THCTHHO ~ o i~i a i i m ra, cnencmue ~ e x a m r e c ~ oCJIOXHOCTH ii 14. Orcmna H e n a n e K o no B ~ I B O A YTO ~ , Y e n o B e Y e c m o HLiYeM H e OTJIklYaeTCR OT IIPenMeTHOrO M H p a B C ~ J I ~ H H O YTO ~ , 3 T 0 ITPOCTO M~X~HII~M e u, e H e
O m H H 3 O G ' ~ ~ K T O BOAHaKO , HalypaJ'IHCTbI Y T B e p W a m T , YTO 3 T 0 H e TaK. ~ J I H X~ ~ KHC J I H ,H a n p H M e p , rOBOpHT, YTO MbI OTJIHYaeMCII OT XKBOTHbM, IIOCKOJIbKy TOnbKO MbI cnoc06m1 K o T a r r e r e H H o M y r.tbnrvremm, H a K o m e m m a nepeaave q e H H o c ~ e i i( K y n b l y p a ) , a TaIoKe o 6 n a ~ a epevbm ~ H c~oeo6pa3~e~ 3BOJIIOLI[HOHHOrO Pa3BHTkW 15. K 3TOMy IIOYTH BCe Ha'IYpaTMCTbI M o r n H 6b1 A O ~ ~ B HH THazlIY ~ C ~ O C O ~ H O C6 T b I~T b C y q e C T B a M H HPaBCTBeHHbIMH (TeMa, KOTOPYIO MbI PaCCMOTPkiM O T A ~ J I ~ H O ) . Bce 31-3 O C O ~ ~ H H O C TH3BeCTHbI H H c a ~ O O ~ e ~ w Ha~ypanwm 1 . C T ~ Ic w T a m T , YTO HM OAHO 113 HHX H e n p e n n o n a r a e T ~ a ~ o i i - ~ o T ~ ~ H c L I [ ~ ~ ~ H T CWIhI H o ~ ~H H e q e 6 y e KaKOrO-TO ~ HeMaTepHmbHOrO OCHOBaHHR.
~ P H C TH 3 W e n n o n r e p m s a e T , YTO xapa~~epa3yrr NuenoCTHOCT~*YenOBeKa, H e CneAyeT 06paua~bcrrK B H e u e n o s e u e c KMM ~ J I ~ M ~ H ~T a~zM l ~ eCi ~i ~ I C I Y P ~OH I . n m r e T : *He oqwarr, YTO aame c a ~ b ~ xapamepHbre e yenosevecme O C O ~ ~ H H O C T H ~ ~ B H C HOT T T o r o , YTO H ~ J I ~m~HRe c m K ero renoserec~oii npapoae, spenbrii ~ a l y p a ~ C1- r~p e3M~m c R o u e m B a n n p ~ p ~ p , y
Y e n o s e m B c B e T e ezo neiicm~iiH A O C T K ~ K ~ K Uezo ~ ~ y, c T p e M n e HC~OCO~HOCT ezo ~ ~n ~p e, n e n o B H qarrirecmx H e y n a y , a T a m eTex 6 n e c ~ m m c s e p u e ~ ~ Ki io,T o p M e FIBIIRIOTCR ~ O A O M
~m
ero k i 3 0 6 p e T a ~ e J I b ~ O C ~Hk i ~ 0 0 6 p a ~ e ~ l l r16.r * ~ o A Y ~ ~ m re~oserrrocmb y (TO e c T b ~ a u Hy e n o x o m e c x b H a B c e ,
~ w B ~ R YTO
eCTb B KOCMOC~), Ha'IYpaJIMCTbI B w H T B 3TOM OCHOBY YeJIOBeY ~ c K o3HaYHMOCTH. ~ ~ OHWCYEITaWT, YTO Y M C T B ~ H H Mcnoc06~ HOCTH, KyJIb'IYpHaH YTOHYeHHOCTb, OC03HaHHe TOTO, YTO npaBWIbHO H YTO HeBepHO, ITpeQCTaBJLHIoT co6oii H e TOnbKO ~ a M 0 6 b I T H b I eY e n o B e Y e c m e Yep-ru, HO H IIBJIHIOTCR TeM, YTO
AenaeT Hac ~ H ~ Z I H M ~ I M %a H . M ~ I C J I6onee ~ n o ~ p o 6 ~H aor r a r a eTcR B m e c r o M ~e311ce. k3, H a K O H e q , HeCMOTPR H a TO, ZIT0 HeKOTOPbIe HaTypWKHC T ~ Ip a c c M a q I i s a m T B c e n p o H c x o A m e e BO ~ c e n e ~ ~ (HoBiTOM i
r m n e renoserecme ~ e j i c ~ c~nmo 3) ~ ~ 1cqororo ;m AeTepMHHH3Ma B TeM CaMbIM 0TPHLI;aIOT BCHKOe OWJ"U&HHC C B O ~ O A M B o n a , M H O l X e Y T M p X A a l o T , YTO MM CBO~OAHH,n0 Icpame6 M e p e o n a c m , sepmmb C B O COGCTB~HHY~O ~ cy~bGy.H~KOTOpHe n o A r e p m s a m , r T o XOTH werr 3aIcpmoil ~cenemoilH npewonaraez ~ e ~ e p ~ m ~ c - r~ cOm~ i Ol ATO, T ~ M H e MeHee H e n p o m B o p e w T w e e renoaerec~oiiC B O ~ O A m ~ I ~no , ~pameil M e p e , AOrIyCKaeT B03MOXHOCTb O m a T b ee. M b I MOXeM A e n a T b M H o r o e ~3 T o r o , ZITO XOTW Denam, H H a M H e B c e r A a n p I i x o m T c r r n 0 c T y n a - m B o n p e K u H a l r r a M x e n a a m . JI, H a n p H M e p , MOW n e p e c T a m rmcam 31-y K H I I I ~ , e c n H saxow, HO M H e IIPOCTO 3 T O r 0 H e XOSeTCR. C T O r K u 3peHMH MHOr'KX HaTYPilTIIICTOB, 3 T 0 OCTaaTIReT B03MOXHOCTb &I'M 3 H a S H M O r 0 '4eJIOBe'4eCKOrO A ~ ~ C T B WW, CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, 3aKJIa&hKBaeT OCHOBY M O p W . B e ~ be C n H MM H e CBO~OAHMnOCT)TIHTb H H a r e , MbI H e MOXeM HeCTW OTMTCTB e H H o c n 3a TO, STO A e n a e M . B cne~ymweiima= MM ~ B W M , S T 0 TaKaR H e COBCeM nOCJIeAOBaTeJIbHaH TOYKa 3 p e H H H O m 0
-
H3
cna6m '
4.
MeCT B H a T Y P ~ H C T W J e C K O MM H P O B O C ~ P ~ W L I .
C ~ e p m b- smo yrrurmoxerrue
nurrrocmu u u r r d u e u d y a n b -
HOCmU. T ~ ~ H q yCA H e e B c e r o n p ~ m bHO , OH c aGConmHOG H ~ O ~ X O A H M O C T ~BbITeKaeT IO H 3 H ~ T ~ ~ W I H C T ~ N KOH~CKO~~ qenL(HW B C ~ J I ~ H H OEcnw ~ ~ . r e n O B e K COCTOHT W3 O A H O ~TOnbKO ~ M a T e p a w , TO B M o M e H T C M ~ P T H ,K o r A a @ o p ~ ~ p o s a ~ r n ero arr M a T e p a R y-rparwBaeT n p e m m m clpylcrypy, n w r H o c T b k i c r e -
,Qam&i
3ae~. * H a c ~ o n a ~H aoM
H3BeCTH0, - rOBOPHTCH BO BTOPOM ry~ m H c m r e c K o MM ~ H W @ ~ C T~ ,BCH ~ ~ H O BCq eTn o ~M npeac T a m e T co6oil @ y ~ w 6m~ o n o ~ r e c ~ooprro a m 3 ~ aKOTO, par6 m a a ~ o ~ e i l c r ~co ym cpe~oiiB C O L I ; H ~ ~ H OHM~ y n b - r y p ~ o ~ KOHTeKCTe. Mbl H e P a C n O J I a r a e M AOCTOBepHbIMH CB&iAeTeJIbcTBarn, AOKa3hIBaH)I4iMHy rITO H 3 H b COXPaHReTCH IIOCJIe CMepTH ma,''. *Hra
F
...~ a ~ y p a n u s ~
63
I
O C Q O T a MbICJIW W YyBCTBa He MOXeT COXPaHIiTb 11H)JHBUAyaTlb~ y i om 3 ~ bno ly cropowy M O I ~ I J I ~ I B ,- n m m B e p r p a ~ Paccen la. BTOPWT h b a p e Aiiep: ~ M e HR... @am,YTO cwecmosame renoseKa npeIcpaqaeTcrr B M0MeH-rcMeprw* 19. 6mee o614e~CMbICne YeJIOBeYecTBO PaCCMaTpHBaeTCH KaK HerTo n p e x o m e e . uCynb6a Yenosem, - nonaram ~ P H C T H 3 w e n , - TO 3 n ~ 3 0 nM e w ~ y w 3i a 6 ~ e m 20. ~ ~ b
Ew
urn
B
Tame y r s e p w e m a c w w HeWycMbzcneHw. Bce mo ~ o x mn p o 6 y m ~ bMHOxeCTBO nCKxonOrmeCKEM n p o 6 n e ~ ,
/
OAHaKO C ~ M K OO~ HqeIIqWW HeJIb3R OTKa3aTb B IIOCJIenOBaTeJlbHWTH W TOYHOCTLI. C O ~ J I ~ CB H~ Oo p o ~ r')WaHLiCTLiYeCKOM)' y ~mw@ecly, emHcTseHHoe u6ecc~epnieo- mo B O ~ M O ~ K H O C T ~ ullpOAOx>KaTbCweCTBOBaTb B H m HOTOMKiOX TaKWM o6pa30M, q~06bI HLU.Ia XH3Hb OKa3bzBa.JlaamuIHHe Ha ApyMx nroneii B ~ ; 1 ~ l ei(yJIblype* fl 21. B He60JIbUI0hi PaCCKa3e nOn Ha3BaHWeM aronybun~en e p m -OH mag^ TpOraTeJIbHO 06bn-pb1~am3T-y MbICnb, OnWCbIBaR, KaK MmbYWK A3BH)l p a 3 ~ w m H a cnoBami cBoero nac-ropa, c~a3asmer0, TO ~ e 6 0u n 0 ~ 0 6 ~ 0 ~o6pmk e b p a a ~ a~ Z I H K O ~ XCHByI4efi ~ H ~ , nocne Herob 22. K ~ K II ynowmy-rb~il paHee npoaeccop ceMaHapm, nacTop A3sma IIepeCTaTl 6 ~ TeWCTOM ~ b 11 IIPOCTO nblTaeTCR AaTb ~A)%oBH~&* cose-r, H e sarxoap 3a paMw ~ a ~ y p m s ~ a .
5. NcmopuR - smo nuneu'noe melrenue cobumuu', cemannb~: no npunyuny npurunu u c/ledcmeuR, no be3 rcarcou'-nu60 eceobaemrou(eu' ymu. B AaHHoM ~e311cenon C ~ O B O Mucmopuu n o n p a 3 y ~ e ~ a m c ~ KaK eCTeCTBeHHU WCTOpuR MWPO3AaHKH, TaK W WCTOPuR 9mOBeYecTsa, n o c ~ m b i ( y w TO, w npyroe h~TypaJIMc~bI paccMaTpwsamT K ~ KHerTo qenocmoe. UenoBerec~mGepm cBoe Havano B npwpoAe: M ~ ~ I 0 3 m ~ 1a 13 eHee ~ II, cKopee Bcero, B Hee li BO3BpaTkiMCH (He Ha K~kiBH)lYaJIbHOM Y'OBHe, a KaK OnpeAe-
n e ~ w i BW). i EcT~cTB~HHU? WCTOPKII HaYWHaeTCR C IIPOWCXOmeHKII BC~JI~HH KOTOPaR O ~ , (H~CMOTPH Ha PaCXOmeHKe HaTypaJIliCTOB no TOM^ noso~y)p a c c ~ a ~ p w ~ aKm~ cKBesHarr. ~ EonsUIWHCTBO yYeHm nonaram, YTO ~ a ~ o e - ~ T ~OC C Y ~ TKmmeH O ~ CTBO nm HW B KocMoce HaYancff npoqecc, n p ~ s e ~ w fBi
K O w e K O W O B , K @OPMIIPOB~HIIIO B C ~ J I ~ H B HKOO~T~O, ~ OMM ~
,
HbIHe )ILZIBeM H HalIWYWe K O T O P O ~ OC03HaeM. ~ O A H ~ KIIOZITH O HMKTO He rOBOPWT, KiiK WMeHHO 3TO l-QOW3011LTIO.TOYKY 3peHEIR MHOrkiX BbIptiX3eT npo@eccop~ O A ~ B W KBom~bep,aCTPOHOM Karryhi6wiic~oroyHmepcwTeTa, K O T O ~ H ~B ~YacrHocm, , roBo-
PHT: d I p o w c x o ~ e ~ w Bcero, e YTO ecTb, - ZIenoBeKa, ~ ~ M J I W , BC~JI~HH OKYTaHO O ~ ~ , ~ a f i ~ ~Bf PaCKPbITHH i, K O T O P O ~ ~MH HLlCKOJIbKO H e YAaJIKnHCb OT JIeTOnkiCIJa KHkirki EbX~kie*23. Anrr 0 6 . a r r c ~ e ~3~01-o ~ 1 1 npoqecca 6 ~ x npemoxeHo 0 MHoro ~eopwfi,OAHaKO HH OAHa ki3 HHX He OAepXaJIa no6e~b1.T ~ M He MeHee cpena HaTypwwcToB pacnpocTpaHeHo MHeHkie, ZIT0 OH 6b~nCaMOpa3BHBaH)wWMCII,TO eCTb, H e 6~ npkiBeAeH B A B W e H W e K~KOG-TOXlep~~IIpki~~kiH~fi - E O ~ O Wki M
r e ~ - n w 6 oewe. O~HZIH CZIWTaeTCH, O ZITO OG'~IICHEJT~ npOHCX0)ICqemeY m O BeKa MOXHO C 60nbmeG YBepeHHOCTbH), HeXeJIki npOHCXOX&eHHe B C ~ J I ~ HAonroe H O ~ . BpeM HaTYpZiJMCTbI, YTO Ha3bIBaeTCII, 3a6a~~xmwcb ~e0pWefi 3BOJIIoqHH, KoTOpM, llOCne O ~ ~ R C H ~ H I I R &~PBWHOM ee U M ~ X ~ H E J ~ Mnonwma ~*, mHpoKoe pacnpoclpaHeme. ~ O Y T WBCe XIIKOJIbHbIe we6mm rOBOPIIT 0 Hefi KaK 0 p~~bHOM @aICI'e. O A H ~ KHOM O KMeTb B B W , ZITO TeOpW s~onmqww- TO He cqoro HaTypalIwmmecmx Teopm. MHOMe TeHCTbI - TOXe 3BOJIIO~HOHWCTH24.C TOZIKH 3PeHH.H TeWcra, ~ ~ c K o H ~ Z I H ~J II ~~ ~H O C T H ~ 60r C ~ ~ CTOWT HM Bcem ecTecTseHHarMH npoqeccmw B TOM Mwpe. Ewmomecniil huiponopsqoK nocme p a 3 ~ m BeCOOTB~TCTBWWc ~ B K M ~ ~ M M C J I O Mno ;
cmea cyrrr OH ~ e n e a n o m e ~TO ' , rno6p-e~ K qm, ~ o ~ o xenama p a ~ C a ~ o ~hry. y no MHeHMo x e HaTyparmcra, TOT npoqecc pa3sMBaeTcR caMocTomemHo. C W M ~ CrOBOPWT OH 06 3TOM TaK XOPOlLIO, ZITO MH He npeMHHeM npHBeCTH IIpOCTpaHHym qHTaTy H3 er0 BHCKa3bIBaHHII:
AX.
uIIo cmeMy npowcxomeHwm w x a p a ~ ~ e np eyf i m ~ mopraH m e c m ~ B O J I ~ InpeAcTaarureT JJUI ~ 0 6 Bceqeno 0 ~ MaTepkiankim3M
Teneonom [rpen. telos (teleos) - uena+nozun] - mane - @HJIOCO@KUKOHUelDWt, COI'nBCHO KOTOPO~~BCt B MHPC
@maYCTPO-
eH0 ue~1ecoo6pa3~0 H BCHKOe Pa3BHTHC IlWIReTCIl OC~eCTBnCHHCM3apaHee npeAonpeAeneHHhar b r o H~ ~ nHp ~ p o ~ ouenefi. fi ~ C o ~ p e ~ c cno~~arg aaps m o c ~ p i w ~ a rcno~v, x M., 1993 r. - n p w . p e ~ .
.
C l ' W i e C ~ ~ i fIIPOUeCC. i . . E y ~ y r wM ~ T ~ P M ~ T I H C T I ~ Yn0 H O~~ ~ 0 e f i n p H p O A e , X H 3 H b , TCM H e M e H e e , MMeeT HeKOTOPhIe C ~ M O ~ ~ I T HbIe csoiicma, x a p a m e p H b r e H e AJW ee M a T e p l r a n a , HJIH M e x a HKW, a ee o ~ ~ ~ H H ~ ~ u U He -n H o. s e ~ n o r r s m c H B pesyxb~a~e
m
o p r a m e c ~ o i i~ B O J I ~ U Ha~ ,ero 6 ~ m eH n e j i c r ~ mT o x e MaTepHaJIHC'lINHbI, O W a K O CpeAH BCeX @ O ~ Mm 3 H M 9eJTOBerecmfi BWI o 6 ~ 1 a ~ ~a eH~H K ~ T I ~ C~BM O ~H~ C T B ~ MAHO, ~ Q ~ H I I I O W M W Te C ~ M O ~ ~ I TO C HO~~ I~ H ~ HOCTW KOTOpbIe , OTJIIlYaHYTXM3Hb OT BCeX IIPOWiX @ O ~ MMaTepMH H ~ e f i C T B m M . HT~J'IA~K.I~~A~H a S , COUHaJIbHaS H AyXOBHaS I I p H p O A a r e J I O B e K a no CBOeMy n 0 B H I O SBJISeTCS H c W I I O Y H T ~ J I ~ H O C ~p e~A H XHBOTHOTO MHpa,
OXHaKO O H a T O X e B O 3 H H W I a B Be3yJTbTaTe X H B O T H O ~ ~ 3BOJIIOUHHH 25.
B TOM o T p M B K e H e TOJI~KORCHO p e p x , q a e T c s e m H c m o r e n o B e n co B c e M KOCMOCOM, HO H n o m e p m B a e T c s ero cmo6 m o m b . OAH~KO, 9 ~ 0 MbI 6 ~H e npLllLUM K BMBOAY, ~ Y A T O H a u r a C ~ M O ~ ~ ~ ~ H HOa m C eT nonoxeme ~ , B n p H p o A e KaK ee BbI~oW3ib.LIero TBoPeHEirr 6 b l ~ 13i3,QYMaHbI ~ HCKMM T e J I e O J I O m e C m M l l p H ~ H n O M ,~ e f i c T B y ~ o w H BO M B C e J I e ~ I i o f i , CHM~COH BCRKOrO COMHel-iKH, H e RBJIHeTCR UeJIbIO 3BOJIIOIJHH, KOTOpaS, 0 9 C B W H 0 , H e H M e e T ~ K a K 0 f i L J m u 26. B KaKOM-TO CMbICJIe T e O P W l 3BOJIlOLJJiH H e TOJIbKO pa3pem a e T BOnpOCM, HO H CTaBHT HX. OH^ 06.arrcme~,UmO n p O H C XOXHJIO H a n p o T m c e H H u M H O r e ~ o n o r m e c w 3p, HO H e A a e T meTa, nolrmy npoacxonmo l r M e H H o TO. uem H e n p H -
x o 6 a m e ~ :~ U W I O B ~ BKH, e
MA~R
e u r r e M a ~+H I
-
HaqpmicToB.
no c n o s p
XaKa
MOHO,reno-
BeK 3TO *HOMep, B h I n a ~ l I I k ni ~P H H r p e B PyJIeTKy*, TO eCTb B TO~I arpe, r A e U a p c m y e T OAHH nEilLlb C J I 27.~ BCSU ~ ~03MOXHOCTb K ~ K O ~ ~ - J I HlIpeAHaMepeHHOCTH ~O HCWlIO!IaeTCS C caMoro Harana. H a - r y p m ~ c IIOJIaraItX, ~b~ 9TO C MOMeHTa ~ O R B l l qeJIOe ~ serecrsa 3~onoqmH e o m a m o n p k i m m HOB& ~OBOPOT, T ~ KaK K renoseic H a e n e H c a ~ o c o s ~ a m H, e6~ k M o x e T , BO B c e f i B C ~ J T ~ H H TOJIbKO O~ OH o6nwae~TaKKM CBO~~CTBOM 28. K p o ~ TOrO, e MbI, JM),QH, C ~ O C O ~ H K H OC03HaHHOM)' BOC~IPHHTWH) C H T ~ ~ U H H K, pemeawm H ~ e f i c m ~ m .
T ~ K H M0 6 p a 3 0 ~ ,H a q O r 0
6 u o n o r t i s e c ~ oYpOBHe ~
3BO-
J I m q H H n o - I l p e X H e M Y OCTaeTCR H ~ O C O ~ H ~ HKHcO~ ~I Y ~ W~HO~~, HO
renosesecaie ~ e f i c ~-~H m e TaKoBbr. Hem311c ~ a s a nYTO ,
B
O m TOJIbKO W C T b U ~ C T ~ C T B ~ HCpeAbI. H O ~ ~ ~ HEnr MbI HMeeM
.nexosesecKym k i c T o p a r o . HWMH CJIOBaMK, BMeCTe
C lTOILBneHLieM YeJIOBeKa HaYHHXTCR K O c M b r c n e r n m HCTOPL~~I- L I C T O P ~ Y e n o B e q e m B a , TO eCTb C O ~ ~ J T L WCOBeplLIaeMbIe , JIK)AbMK, KOTOPbIe 06~1aqam~ CaMOC03HaHHeM K C R O C O ~ H O C T ~ KK) CaMOOIIPeAejIeHHK). O A H ~ KO,
no,q06~0TOMY KSLK 3BOJIIOhI;KII H e K M e e T BH)TpeHHe
iIpLICY-
q e i i eii qens, acTopLirr T o m e H e m e e T H L I K S L K Ou~e~n k i , KOTOP~R
6gma ~
L eii I H 3 H ~ W l J I b H OC B O ~ ~ C T E E H HH~ c . ~ o p m- 3 T 0 TO, YTO
C O ~ ~B ! iIe JTI ~ ~~e ! i e ~ K OHCTOPHK fi HMeIoT TOJIbKO c a m n p m a m T aM, cosepluaR m HJIK OrJX5IAbtBasICb H a HIW. no IIpOlUeCTsHH BpeMeHH. HCTOPHH p a 3 s m a e ~ cno~ n p ~ ~ on fa Hi a a , KSLKK B ~ e a s ~ e (a H e ~ K ~ K T I H OKaK , B BOCTOUHOM n a ~ ~ e m ~o e AH ) a,K o H e meeT H K ~ K s Oa ~ p a~~ e ey ~ a ~ o m e r n ouem. ii BM~CTO Toro u r o 6 ~AOCTMUb c B O ~ GKyJIbMKHaIJHK BO BTOPOM IIPEILUeCTBkiH M l r AeJIaeM.
TOT CMMCJI, K O T O ~ L InmALi ~~
~ o ~ o ~ ~ J I o B ~ KOSHLa ,n p O C T 0 lLTJKTCR POBHO CTOJIbKO, CKOJIbKO c y r y e c m y e T c o 3 ~ a m r y ~ci e i 6~ u e n o s e K . K o r ~ a~ a arc n e s s e ~ , HC9e3HeT K Ye.AOBe!ieCKaR HCTOPKR, MMpa ~ Y A IlpOAOJwcaTbCR ~ T
6. ~ PIpa
~
U
a HCTOPKII
eCTeCTBeHHOr0
6e3 HaC.
m K eQ e m omtiouetiue momco
K
renose~y.
BOSKMKHOB~HMK H ~ T Y ~ ~ J I m H ~e M cm ~
w
e coo6paxe-
H e ~ r p a r r uO C H O B H O ~~~O J I L I . C ~ o p e eBcero, ~ B O ~ H MKSLK ~ C n o r m e c K o e pacwipeme H e w r o p b x x ~ e
a ~ y p m 3 ~ ~aQ~3rne-
cmx nommii o npiipone B H e u r H e r o m p a . HOYTK Bce p a H m e H a T Y p a H C T h I OTCTaHBaJIH 3TKYeCKlie B 3 T m b I ,
CXOAHbIe C
TeMK, YTO ~ M T O B ~ J I IBI 0 ~ p y X a ~ l ~ HX e fKYJIbTYPe i H KOTOPbIe B
qenora
Hena3R
6m0 OTJIKYKT~OT
pacnpocTpaHeHHoro Toraa
XpKCTKPHCTBa. ~ O A ' - ~ ~ ~ K ~ BYBtiXCeHHe ~ T I O C ~K AOCTOMHCTBy O T A ~ J X ~ H JIIMHOCTK, O~~ yTBepXCAaJIaCb IJeHHOCTb J I ~ ~ B H ripe, AaWIOCTb KCTHHe H OCHOBaM YeCTHbIX B ~ ~ K M o o T H o ~ L z ~ H H ~ ~ . %.PHCYC~ CYKTaJIK V K T e J I e M BbICOKux HPaBCTBeHHbIX m e a J I O B .
HecwoTp~H a TO, YTO ceroam T a K m y c T a H o s K a ocna6e~aea, B ~ a ~ o i i M- e~p oe K a p r w H a o c T a e T c r r n p L i M e p H o TO^ x e . 3a BbHeTOM HeKOTOpbtX n e p e r ~ 6 0 IlOCJIeAHerO ~ B p e M e H H (CHHC-
XOAHTeJIbHOe O T H o l u e H K e K ~ 0 6 p a ~ ~ bEZTIH I M B H ~ ~ ~ ~ s H ~ I M IIOJIOBbIM CBR3RM, a 6 0 p r o ~ H n p a B a YeJIOBeKa H a c ~ M o J ~ H ~ ~ c T BO) M O ~ cO~ a 3 a nYTO , 3 m e c m e H O P M ~ I ,rrpo~o3maure~me BO B T O ~ OIYMaHEICTWIeCKOM M M ~ H K ~ ~ IIOXOXH C T ~ , Ha TpmHL I ; H O H W Mop-. H e p e ~ TeHCTbI ~o H HaTYpaTIHCTbI =BJT 6 0 ~ 0 ~ O KH , e C n O p R no BOnpOCaM HpaBCTBeHHOCTH. M e w HHMEf B c e r A a 6 b m pacxo)ISqeHm, ~ H m e AyMaeTcH, r T o no M e p e T o r o KaK rYMaHH3M 6 y ~ BCe e ~AWIblue OTXOjQfTb OT x ~ H C T H ~ H C K O ~ ~ 3mm, O m craHyr YBeJIWIHBaTbCR 29. HOK a m M H 6b1 HEI 6 b m ~ 3TH paCX0)ISqeHH.H (H KaKOBbIM 6b1 H H 6 b ~ 0 ~AHHOM~ICJIW~), OCHWU lUur n0CTpOeHIlsr HPaBCTBeHHbIX HOPM P m W b H O HHaR. ,@MTeKCTa O C H O B O ~HpaBCTBeHHaDs U ~ H H O C T OCTaeTCR ~~~ Eor, JIJUI HaTYpiUTHCTa 3 T H 4eHHOCTH - IIJIOA YeJIOBeYeCKOTO T B o p s e c m a , M TO n o m ~ e c m B m e K a e T ~3 n p e A m m emCOB. E c n ~no renosem H e 6br1.10 m K a K o r o C O ~ H ~ H H . H TO, , CJIenOBaTeJIbHO, H e 6 b ~ H 0 OLIJweHHSI TOrO, YTO lIPaBEZTIbHO, a 'IT0 HeBepHO. 60JIee TOrO, e c n M 6b1 H e 6bmo cnoco6~ocm n o c T y n a T b maye, YeM M ~ nI o c l y n a e M , TO m K a K o e o w e m e n p a s m b H o m HJIH J I O ~ O C T H H e m e n o 6b1 n p a ~ ~ m e c ~ o f i UeHHOCTH. tam^ 06pa30~, YCnOBHe CyI4ecTBOBaHHH 3THKEI TO c 0 3 ~ a m eH c a M o o n p e A e n e m e . C n e ~ o ~ a ~ e pew m ~ oH,e ~ 3 6 e m 0AOJDKHa HATH 0 JIKYHOCTH. H ~ T Y ~ ~ T I M cr oT B~ oI p m , r ~ coo 3 ~ a m H e caMoonpeAeneme
IIORBEZTIHCb BMeCTe C B03HEIKHOBeHEIeM YeJIOBeKa H, TaIUiM 06pa30~,BMeCTe C HHM C @ O P M E ~ P O B ~ T LH~ C3THKa. ~ HHK~K~H 3TI.neCKaR CHCTeMa H e MOXeT 6 b I T b BbIBeAeHa TOnbKO 113 ~ I I P H P O A ~ Beaefi* I 663 y Y a c m Y e n o B e g e c K o r o C O ~ H ~ H ~ . MH~IMLICnOBaMH, B KOCMOCe H e H a Y e p T a H O HHKaKOrO CCTCCTBeHHOrO 3aKOHa. Aaxe J I ~ M ~ T ~~ H o ~, o p a HeMHOrO rB n0aaHTa~ K ~ O B ~ HJ aI n, a c a B , YTO c r n p H p o A a comopma B c e x H a c [nmnefi H X K B O T H ~ I X ] lUur OAHOrO J I W b CYaCTbR*, H TCM CaMbIM 06~apym~n. CBOH A e H c T m e c m e KOPHU, - &axe OH B 6~ J 6 e ) I S q e H m ~ HaTypWIHCTOM. OHIIHCiUT: 4Bb1 B m m e , YTO ~CT~CTB~H 3aKOH H ~ I ~-~H e l l M O UHOC, XQX COKPOBeHHOe W C T BO, KOTOPOe, 1 1 0 ~ 0 6 ~ BCeM 0 rIpOWih4 YyBCTBaM, a T a K Xe H
c a ~ o i iM~ICJIH, OTHOCHTCR K c@epe ~ o o 6 p a x a e ~ o r 3O. o u %o 4~006pa~ae~0J e uI ~ M ~ T K~OH H ~, Y H O , B O C ~ P H H H M ~ JYHCTO I
Mexamcmrecmi. 3 m ~ AASI a Hero - TO npoc~onoseAeHIie n m ~ e i ic, n e A y I o w TOMY o6pa3rly, ~ o ~ o p b3 ~a nf ie r a ~ n Be ~ HHX KaK B npkipOAHbM CmeCTBaX. tam^ O ~ P ~ ~ OnoJIyYaeTcII, M , ST0 B B0npOca.X HPaBCTBeHHoCTH He CmeCTBYeT HEiYerO TPWIC-
qememHoro. B~opoiip a ~ ~ c m e c m~ fair n a e ccnon~oii ~ HCHOCT~H) TOBOPkiT, OTKyAa 6 e p e ~Harmo 3 m ~ aHaTypaJIH3Ma: a M b ~ y-mepmaeM, ZITO HpaBcTBemMe q e m o c T H 6epyr cBoe Harmo B renoBerecKoM onme. 3Twm ~ S ~ O H O MHHcumyayuorrrra, ~ oHa H e HywAaeTCII HH B KaK0fi ~ O ~ O C J I O B WIH C K~ O~~ ~O A O ~ ~ C 6 e p e ~Harmo B uenoBerecm I I O T ~ ~ ~ H O C T I I ~ caHWww. 11 mrrepece. Orpmame 3~01-o 0 3 ~ a r a ewcKameHwe ~ BCIIKO~~ X H ~ H ~ H HO OCH ~O ~BbI. Y ~ J I o B ~ Y ~ c K W3Hb ~II HMeeT CMbICJI, noroMy ST0 MbI CaMH TBOpkiM H5LUle 6 y ~ m e 31. e~ 60JIhur&i~CT~0 ~OCJIeAOBaTeJIbHbIXHaTypaJIkiCTOB, HaBepHoe, CO~AaClzrrOcb6b1 C 3mh4 WepmeHHeM. OAH~KO BOIIpOC 0 TOM, KaK IIOHUMaHWe TOG WIH HHOG UeHHOCTH B03HIIKaeT H3 KOHKP~THO~ !~ I ~ A O B ~ Y CHTYaIJWH, ~ C K O ~ ~OCTaeTCII TaKIiM Xe ~ e p a s p e r r r w ~Kb ~ ~ ~ K w,Bonpoc o npoKcxoxaeHwH Bcenemoi3. n p e m e Bcero H ~ A OB ~ L F I C H H Tcneaymuee: ~ K ~ K H M o6paOM do~xrroe M O ~ BO~ I B O A W T24~ 3 cmecmymuero? T p w u w O H H 3 ~ m ~ aTO , ecn XpmmaHcKoro ~ e w ~ymepxa , AaeT TpaHcqeH,qeHmocn mmecKoro Harma, COOTHOCII KPWTep~ii~ o 6 p ac ~ ~ C K O H ~ S H n~ 1I 1Mr ~ O c m b 1~ ~O ~ O M Ao6p0 . 3T0 60r, YTO 6bm0 IIBTIeHO M H O ~ O O ~ ~ ~ ~ CH~~OI CMOI~I ~ MaWc , Haki60~1b~eii noJLH0~0ii- B XM3HH, peHIlI1 I1 CMepTki k;lwcyca
xpkic~a.
Y HaTypaIIkfCTOB HeT BO3MOXHOCTH TaKOrO o 6 p a u e ~ ~K~ 1 1
Am
60I"y, Aa o ~ w He HymAaIoTcII B H ~ M . HKX 3Twm - 3TO Hew0 YHCTO renoBerecKoe. B O ~ H I I Kcepbe3wii ~~T Bonpoc: K ~ K M M0 6 p a s o ~ 113 @arc-raC ~ M O C O ~ H ~ H IHI RCaMoonpeAenem, TO eCTb 113 c@epbIToro, r ~ ecmb o 11 u ~ Moxern o 6umb, M O ~ O nepeiiTI1 B c@epy TOrO, YTO ~ O A X H O 6b1~bWIH AOJLXHO 6 m b
c~ena~o? HaTypanwc~b~ yTBepx&amT,YTO Bce nm~11 cnoco6~h1 pa3AIlYaTb HpaBCTBeHHbIe IJeHHOCTII. C O ~ A ~ C mH e ~OO M H H J V O M y
C H M ~ C O3H Tki~ ,IJeHHOCTH 6epyr HaYUIO B kiHTyklWK (*oxqmem~ npaBmmocTw, KoTopoe He npeAnonaraeT 06%-
&K.
eKTI1BHOrO IICCJIeAOBa~ O ~ O C H O B ~ H H O C T3TOr0 W WCTBB,
K
O
~
~
p a B H 0 KaK H llPOBePKH HCTHHHOCTH WIH IIOXHOCTH CAWIaHHbM r r p e w o c h u r o a o ) , B a B T o p a T e T e a B o6mae. Bce MM no M e p e Haurero @ o p m p o ~ a m B o c n p m a M a e M T e uemocm, KOTOpHe HaM n p e A o c T a a r u r e T H a u r e o K p y x e H a e . k3[ A a x e ema YenoBeK m B e p r a e T HX, s a p a ~ e ecornmmcb c BO~MOXHW OCTPaKH3MOM H MyWHIIYeCTBOM, TO IIOSTH HHKOrAa H e ~ 3 0 6 p e T a e T T a m uemoc~eii,KOTOpHe H e H M e m 6b1 H E ~ K ~ K O ~ CBR3H C eM) K y J I b ~ ~ p o f i . K o ~ e r ~ Bo ,p a 3 H b M KyIIbTypaX - pa3I-KbIe UeHHOCTH, H HHVTO H e BbIrJfH&HT i36c0JIIOTH0 YHWBePCaJIbHbIM. & ~ x o A R 8 3 3TOr0, CHM~COH OTCTaHBaeT 3TIIKY,KOTOPiM OCHOBbIBaRaCb 6121 H a ~ ~ ' ~ ~ K T H B H HCCJIeAOBaHHH, OM H B W H T ee B rapMOHElH nro~eRM e w co6oR, a T a a e c HX o K p y x e H H e M 32. Bce, STO cnoco6cmye-r3 ~ o iria p M o m a , - xoporrro, B c e , r T o H e cnoco6CTByeT, - lUIOX0. C ~ p e M 5 i C bIIOCTPOH7la 3TIIXy B CO~JIaCHHC ~ I M ~ B H O P H ~ M O* M 6. C m e p a , -OH I h a n B o ~ ~ o~3f CBOKX i c r a ~ e frimer i
a.
uCracne
- TO C o r n a c o B a H W e KpancoBpeMei-nim
ycmd
C TeMH, KOTOPbIe P a C C S H T a W H a 6onee ~ 0 I I m f iWi&i BeCbMa ~ A O J D K M T ~ J I ~ H ICpOK, & a MyApOCTb - 3TO 3 H a H H e TOrO, KaK 3TOM) AOCTHT[b. h e ~ IIOBeAeHwe ~ ~ BO3IUiKaeT e TOrAa, KOI'Aa KpaTKOBpeMeHI-KbIe YCWIWZ HHAHBHAa COBIIaAL3lOT C AOJII'OBpeMeHHarMw Y C ~ W I M H TOR m~ HHOR rpynnht. B p e s y n b ~ a ~ e CTaHOBHTCff n e r K o 46XOPOLUHM* W, rOBOpH 60nee TOSHO, uxoporrro c e 6 ~ B e a m 33.
* EHX~BHOPH (OT ~ Mmrn. b e h a v i o u r - nose~enae)- omo a3 nan p a r u r e ~ uB I I C H X O J I O ~ 20 B. (rn. 06p. ~ M ~ P H W C K O ~ ~ )CmTamwee , npenMeToM ncHxononiH H e C O ~ H S U I H ~a, noBeneHae, KOTO~OCnoHaMaemg w a ~c o ~ o ~ y m l o c@ ~b a s a o n o m c c w pea@ Ha Bnerrrmie cmMynu. .COB~~M~H UlOBapb H ~ & H H O C ~ b I XCJIOa*, M.,1993 r. - ITpHM. pen.
CHMITCOH N llharr - mo yyeaHe, K o T o p H e ~ O H H M ~ , 9TO B CBOUX H3bICKaHHXX HM H a 0 OCTaBaTbCR H a BCeqeJIO r y M a H H c n n e c K E a r n 0 3 H q m f X , H n03TOMY OHH 0 6 ' b e J ~ i m B ~ e n a H o e qenoe CBOH H a y u m r e n o 3 ~ a ~Hm H p a B c m e H m r e YCTaHOBKII. OT I'yhtaHHCTmeC#EIX m'Ieii OlTUIKHBaeTCR H YonT e p J a n n ~ a a . c ~ o e ipa6o~e i ai7pedumoaue rc h i o p a n u v (1929) OH 3 a m ~ a Hea ~ y - p a T I H m m e c K y mno3~qmo no O m o u r e H H i o K ~ c e n e ~ ~ onmeaaoii, ii, no ero M H ~ H W H ) , q e n H . OH x o Y e T nOc-rpOHTb 3 W K Y H a OCHOBe TOrO, YTO, KaK e M y KXKeTCR, ~ H J X O
B
AYXOBH~IXywi~eneii*.JQUI I ~ n n ~ a no6po - TO TO, YTO n o K a n p ~ s ~ a e ~TOJI~KO c r r ~ n w ~ o iaic,B o 60nH0ii a p ~ c ~ o K p a ~ z iAyXa* e f i 34. OH cwnae-r, YTO e c n z i AIOAH neiicmzi~enb~ XOTIIT o n e p e m b x a p a m p ~ DJIH d AsmaToro CTOJIeTM KpH3HC, TO 3 T a 3JIHTapHaII 3 m K a AOJI)KHa CTaTb J&JIH HkiX 06113a~enbH0fi. C ~ Mno6po O - 3TO 6 e c ~ o p b 1 c m e ,c n o c o 6 ~ o c ~ CWIIYaTb b 6ecnopmm H paoraposamirr 3 ~ o r om p a . k 3 ~ e m oT e n e p b p X a B 9 M H a COBpeMeHHOCW pa3'beAaeT ' I p a H U H O H H y I O OCHOBY H p a B c T B e m o r o n o B e n e m . T p y ~ B~psyx o cnosax ~ b 1 p a 3 ~TOm conepmamie, K o T o p o e J H ~ B~ m WM b m a~ e T BH CJIOBO 6ecrcop~crnrr~c.B ~ p e ~ b e Yi ia c m c ~ o e i K i m r H OH nbrTaeTcR c A e n a T b 3 T 0 , OaHaKO H a 0 OTMeTHTb, YTO B KOHeYHOM CYeTe er0 3THKa CTPOMTCR H a ~ H O pMe u r e m H mamma, K O T O P ~ Ix~o~T e n 6b1 ~ E , I THPaBCTBeHHbIM, ~ H YTO OHa H e HMeeT H H K ~ K oCBII3H ~ C Q~KTOB, TO ecm c np~ponoii~euteiiB q e n o M :
0614~ y ~u B e n m c m
MW~OM
~P~JIM~H OCHOBaHHaR H, H a KOHKPeTHbM BbIBOAaX H 3 a q 0 HOMMH, ~ W O J I O ~ MHWHCTOPHH, MOXeT n O C T p a a T b , AsuKe pap)'UWTbCII n P H OTKPbITHM KaKUX-TO HOBbM HCTHH, OaHaKO peJIH-
rUFI AyXa H e 3aBMCMT OT CMMBOJIOB B e p b I M K O C M O J I O ~ My~ ,H e e HeT 3aMHTepeCOBaHHOCTH B K~KOG-TOK O H K P ~ T H OHCTHHe. ~~ Ee M m e p e c y e T H e TO, K~-M o6pao~ o p r a ~ a 3 0 s a ~Maa T e p m , a KaYecTBo ~ e n o ~ e ~ e c ~x o e nr a-Hom w 35.
H a 0 XOpOUO
n 0 H H M a T b TOT H3bIK, K O T O P M ~HCnOJIWyeT o p am bw H p a a c T B e H ~ b 6 MMnYJIbC, i nOA *XOM - H p a B C T B e H H p C ~ O C O ~ H OYeC ~ n o B e K a , TO, YTO B O ~ B W ~ ~ero T HW XHBOTH~IMH, a T a w e ~ a , q
J a n n ~ a aITonpe/luzueu' . OH n o H m a e T ~
TeMM,
y
KOrO ~ P e J I M r W I * - IIPOCTO HeYTO
06mepacnpoc~pa-
~ a
H ~ H H O TO ~ . e c n , acnonmye-rcrr R ~ H K~ e m ~OaA H, ~ K OconepXMWC OCTaeTCR YHCTO HaTYPaTLHCTCKHM. OTm a m 3 ~ e c boc-rae-rcrr T ~ J ~ ~yrBepWeme K O BbICOKOrO B ~ ~ J L S IHa A ~mem cnpaBeAnaBoma nepen rraqoM s c e n e ~ ~ o i l , ~ o ~ o p anpomo rr npacynm3ye-r a He meeT B ce6e m m ~ o i l
UeHHOCTH.
tam^
O ~ P U O M , 3THKa HMeeT
CMO JIKTIHOCTHOe
m ~ e p e m ae 3asacaT OT su6opa Yenosem. H ~ C K O J Irr~sK~Oa m , ~ H ~ I I I M O ~~ ~ IH Y~ H He O CBR3hlBaKIT C 3K3HCTeHqHaTLHCTaMH, O A H ~ K OB L U ~ C T Ornme ~~ MM ~BHAHM, YTO ero sepcHaqpaJIKCTCKO~ 3THKH B BbI~lIIefiCTeIIeHU CXOAHa C 3TkiK0fi 3K3HC-
T ~ ~ H ~ J I H ~ M ~ . Ha~yparrac~ nbITaIoTCR u nOClpOHTb clp0fiHbIe 3 m e c ~ ~ e cameMu, acnorrmyrr caMbIe pa3~b1enornonu, H A a x e xpac-raaHCKHe TeHCTbl BbIHmeHbI npH3HaTb, YTO MHOrHe 3TI.IJIeCKHe coo6paxe~kur:HaTy"WCT0B WeIoT OnpeAeJIeHHyIo 3HaYkiMOCTb. T e a c ~ H ae~CTOElT YAEI&TIIITbCTOMY, II YTO HPaBCTBeHHbIe HCTHHM MM nocmraeM, ~ a 6 r r m ~3a a an p ~ p o ~ oYenoBem ii a ero noseAeHaeM, TaK m~ renoseK CoTBopeH no o6pa3y Eora H B YenoseKe AOJDKHO olpamanca - n y c n CMYTHO - Hew0 OT 60Xbefi 6narocm eCJIH, KOHeYHO, 3TOT o6pa3 H e OKOHYaTeJIbHO
paspyurea rpexona,qeHaeM. C ~ ~ C T B ) ' IAOBT@~ O P M ~ IHaTypaTLki3Ma, KOTOPbIe 3aClIyXIiBamT oco6oro BHEIMaHHH. K IIepB0fi OTHOCEITCR TaK Ha3bIBaeM& c e x y m p ~ ~ ~CY M ~ H U 3To ~ M .HaaMeHosaHEie a c n a ~ r m y e ~ c ~ K ~ KC T O ~ O H H K K ~ M I I ,TaK a KPMTMK~MHAamoro TeYeHEur, a nopoii -re K ApyrLle w~ anoyr1o~pe6m1o~. H e o 6 x o ~ a ~cnenan o ~oe-~am ~ OeI I C H ~ H E I R . B o - n e p ~ b ~cs~, K Y J I H P HVBHH3M ~~ - 3TO @0pMaIIpORBn e a m r y ~ a m 3 B~ qenoM, a oAHaKo He emHmseHHarr. T p a HKSM m~ T ~ K O B Ox~a~p a ~ ~ e p a 3 y e ~~ c rcr e o 6 ~ m m ~ymaeii H O B K O ~ ~CornacHo , K O T O P O ~YenoBeK ~ 06nmae~oco6oii q e H H o c n m , a ero yclpemeam, MbIcnw a YUHHH ayem nepBocTenemoe s ~ a ~ eK~p o~~e~e o. r oAenae-rcrr , a w e m Ha ~ H ~ Y M M O CTH HmMBMAa. +
W ~ ~ H HC 3nom ~ U B O ~ P O ~ ~ HMMCJIWTeJIH KIZ CaMbIX pa3y 6 e m e ~ w GH ~ ~ ~ I B ~ce611 J I H W a H u c m a M u ; cpenw HKX 6 ~ 1 0HeMLUI0 XPHCTWaH. ~ ~ M ~ H M C T W WIH, , KaK CerOAHH morAa ~OBOPRT, x p u c m u a H c ~ m u E ~ M H U C ~ ~ M U 6bl~11l , X~H 3Karrbsm-i(1509- P566), AesmepIiii 3 p a 3 (1456?~ 1536), 3 m Cne~cep(1552?- 1599), YWIMMU e ~ c m p(1564-1616), ,@KOH ~ ~ ~ B T(1O608?H 1674), nwcamuue B K o m e K c r e x p a c m m c K o r o T e H C l u Y E K O m MII[BOB033PeHHR. HX CTiLIIEI TaK Ha3bIBaTb 3a cTpememe noasepmxin A O C T O ~ C T B Os e J I o B e K a , H e npcnx~on0cTam.m em hory, a wcxom ~3 o6pa3a b x b e r o B ~ax,qoii m o c r u .Cero~m monie C B O ~ O A H xpacmase ~I~ mom C-HO X e n a H ) T OTCTORTb CJIOBO t?JMOHIWM, YTO, llIbITaffCb OTAeJIIlTb er0 HMX
OT CeKyJIHPHbIX @OPM 3 T O r 0 ABMXeHklR, IIO,I(nIlCLUIIl T a K Ha3hI-
sae~blEiX p a c m a ~ c w - i i i r y ~ a ~ ~ c m u e c~mai m i @ e(1982), c~ B KOTOPOM ~ I ~ O B O ~ ~ J I ~YTO ~ ~x pT ~Cc R m ,a H c m B o cerna WepxAaTIO 3HaYHMOGTb Y ~ J I o B ~ ~ ~ c K JIH9HOCTl-i oG 36. C e K y q m t l ~ ~ M B H H~ MTO A p y r a R @ o p ~ray ~ a ~ w 3 ~ a . Ero n p ~ ~ ~ anny ubl L rI e B c e r o B b r p a x e H a r BO BTOPOMr y M a H w c TLneCKOM M ~ H H @ ~ C T COCTaELJIeHHOM ~, n a y J I e M K y p m e ~np0, @eccopo~~ K T I O C O ~ H IHI ~ H ) - ~ O ~ K C K Or ~o cOy A a p m B e H H o r o y m m e p c m e T a B Ey@@ano37. C e K y m p ~ b L j ir y ~ a m 3 - ~TO TaKaH @ 0 p M a r y M a H H 3 M a , KOTOPaff IJeJILIKOM pa3BHBaeTCff B PaMKaX H a T ~ a r u I C T H s e C K O r O1WIpOB033peH&i!4. M H IGiXeTCff, ~ 9TO R H e nOIJ?elHy KIPOTkIB IICTHHbI, e C J M CKa)Ky, ZIT0 G O J I ~ W H CTBO ki3 TeX, KT0 XOPOllIO c e 6 YyBCTByeT, ~ HOCH 3BaHkle CeKyJTXp~ o r or y M a H H c T a , ~ a i i q eX a~p a K T e p H c m K y cnom B ~ ~ J X J Q O BB n e p B M X lLIeCTki Te3HCaX, OllHCaHHbLX BbIllle. HH~IMH CJIOBaMIl, CeKyJIHpHbIe ryMaHHCTbI - 3 T 0 npOCTO HaTypaJIHCTbI, X m f f B TO Xe RpeMH HeJIb3H CKa3aTb, YTO BCe HaTYPaJIHCTbI - CeKyJIQHbIe WaHHCTbI.
T p y ~ B~AByX o CJIOBaX A a T b 0IIpeAe.JIeHIle MaPKCI13My WII1 er0 lIpOaHUM3HPOBl3Tb, T a K KaK C m e C T B y e T MHOrO p a a r r l n m BWOB u M a p K c H c T o m 38. I I p ~ l e m e B~abp H~a ~m o M OCMbICJIt2HWII MaPKCI13Ma MOXHO CUIlTaTb BOCl'IpHHTIle el% KaK O A H O ~I13 @ O ~ MI'yMaHEI3Ma. H ~ K O T C Oe K~y J~I RIp H~b I e m a HIlCTbI REJXHWTCH MaPKCIICTaMII, IlJII1 IIO ~ p a f i ~ e M f ie p e BIcpaTI&2
COUyBCTBeHHO OTHOCHTCH K MaPKCI13MY, H O ~ O J I ~ ~ L I I I H C T B O I13 H I M TaKOBbIMIl H a 3 B a T b HeJIb3R. 4 M b 1 I I P I l B e P X e H b I OTQbITOMY AeMOKPaTIlUeCKOMY O ~ ~ C C T B Y *, rOBOpI1TCH BO BTOPOM QWaHIlCTIlUeCKOM M ~ H K @ ~ C TIIOACIIYAHO ~, OTBepraltow e M MaPKCI13M 39. XOTRM ~ P K C K C T CI'yMaHII3M ~ I1 O T J I l n a e T CR CBOIlMH OCO~CHHOCTRMH,HO KaK IIpORBJIeHEIe HaTypaAI13Ma OH I1 H ~ T ~ ~ ~ T I H C T ~ FI'yMaHI13M Z I ~ C & HMCIOT MHOrO 0 6 1 4 . ~ ~ IIpeAIIOCdlIOK. BOBceX CBOIM @OPMBX MaPKCI13M BOCXO,4&iT
K COUHH~HWRM
Kapna M a p ~ c a(18 18-1883), ~ o ~ o p om r o e Bcero p a c c M a T K ~ K o n p e ~ e n e ~ ~ b~m r i iI y m m c T a . B OAHOM 113 CBOIM CaMbIX PaHHKX 3CCe OH RCHO rOBOPHT, UTO UUeJIOBeK - 3TO sr,Icrrree cwecmo ~ n rure n o s e K a a Ej[3 3~61-o I'yMaHHcmecKOrO Te3kiCa M a p ~ cBbIBOAkiT C B O ~p e ~ o n m ~ o ~JI03YHr, ~b~ji
pman
COrnaCHO KoTOpOMY HaAO ylIpa3AHIITb BCe T e CHCTeMnr, r A e uenoseK ~HM)K~H nopa6oue~, , no11 rpe311pae~41.
CBOW I'yMaHI1CTI.TYeCKMe IIpHHLT,HIIbI M a p ~ c B ~ I ~ ~ ~ BO T ~ J I IIOJIeMkiKe C AByMH I13BeCTHbIMII @IZTIOCO@~~MII 19-r0 BeKa: I'eopro~B k u r b r e J I b ~ bQPLZ~PIMOM ~ I ' e r e n e ~(1770- 1830) 11 J I m A . E k i r o ~ Qeiiep6axo~(1804- 1872). Cbi.rxoco@~lrr I'erem TO o n p e A e n e H H a R @ o p ~W a ~ ~ J I H ~ cMo r ~n a, c H o ~mopofiEor wJrH <(a6conm~~nrii AD* - H e KaKOe-TO C M e C T B O , OTJIMYHOC OT
3~01-om p a ,
HO T a p e a n b H o c n , K o T o p a R n m T e n e H H o
ocwe-
Xe KOHKpeTHOM Mkipe. )$IR I ' ~ I W I HAaHHb& npoqecc no c ~ o e inpwpone i dua~elcmuve~, TO e c n npennonaraClWMeTCR B 3TOM
e T o n p e A e n e i i H o e II~OTZIBO~OPCTBO,B KOTOPOM m o e c a M o o c w e c T m e m e ~yxa QMBOAHT K n o p o m e H k i m ero ~POTZIBO-
nonomoro H a u a n a , m11K a o T p k i q a m m * . IB pe3ynb~q~e CTO~KHOBeHIlR ~ I ~ o T Z I B O I I O J I O ~ O A C TD~ BbIXOAHT ~ H a ewe 6onee sbrco~ymCTWHIO c a ~ o p e m 3 a u m ,UTO, B C B O ~ouepenb, O m T b QkiBOAkiT K er0 OTPkiLT,aHLM), I1 T a K AaJIee. C TOUKH 3 p e w I'erem, s a r c o u a i j n r r k i ~C p e A c m o M C a M o B b I p a x e m AYxa RNIReTCR u e J I o B e u e c K o e o 6 u e c ~ ~ I1 o OCOGCHHO er0 COBpe-
MeHHI.de @ O ~ M H , CJIOXHBlUlleC5I B KanWTaTIHCTlCneCKWX rOCy-
fiapmsax 3 m a ~ ~ oEi si p o n ~19-1-0 BeKa. tam^ 06pa30~,M O ~ Oc ~ a s a ~ bYTO , y Ikrex~~ 6wa BeCbMa yromemasi @wnoco@m wc~opaw.OH nonaran, YTO H m e B p e M e H H O e npe6mame H a TO# 3 e M n e O~IACHFI~TCH T ~ M YTO , MH o c m e c m e M ~ ~ M H CEora, ~ H K m o p o r o @mo-
m*.
CO@ I I O H W M ~KaK u ~ ~ C Q ~ I O T H ~ I ~ ~
aeiiep6ax me 6~u1 M a T e p a a r r a c T o M , OH npocnasmca BHCE(a3bIBaHHeM, COTJIaCHO KOTOPOMY J'XIOM - 3TO -0, YTO OHM eART*, k i YTO peJIHI.EuI - lLTIOA YeJIOBeYeCKOrO BbIMHCJIa. no M H e m m @eiiep6axa, Eor - s o npoemm n o T e m w a n b H m BO~MOXHOCT~ YenOBeKa ~~[ H B b I p U e H H e er0 HeOCmeCTBWMbIX W e W O B . PeJ'IkiI.EuI BpeAHa, IIOCKOnbKJ', IIp-aB 60ra, MbI HaYWIH JTOXAaTb 3T0fi ~ a I l I e f iBhZqyMKe, BMeCTO T o r 0 9 ~ 0
6 ~
n p e o A o n e m T a H e A o c T a T m i , K o T o p H e n p w B e n w K ee BO~HKKHOs e H a w . CBOH) K~HTLIK p e~ n H m a Q P e i i e p 6 a x pacnpocTpam a H a @moco@cmfi mearxa3~ rerem. OHy c M a T p a B a n B r e r e n e B C K O ~# o~H q e n I u i H aAyxa* ewe o n ~ npoemam y YenoRerecm ~os~orn~ocK ~ oeTioip,a n n p e n c T a e T K ~ Kc n e m C ~ K ~ J I F I P H ~ O s a H H a r r sepcm x p a c T a a H c K o r o Eora. M a p ~ cUenHKOM k i n0AHOCTbH) BOCnpkiHWI Q H T H K y
nofiazuern I'I~OTHBO~OPCTBO,B K ~ O P O Mc o n e p H m a w m e CTOpOHb1 C03AaH)T CBOMX C O ~ C T B ~ H Ha~HM T a r O W C T O B , B pe3yJIbTaT e qer0 @ O P M L I P ~ ~ T CPW, R "KyAa-TO HallpaBAHK)~HXCH* HCTOpurecmx KOH@~HKTOB.qenb HCTOPHH - @ o p ~ a p o ~ a COme
0
I
: i fi
t 1
...n a r y p a n ~ s ~
75
B e p m e m o r o , m~ W e a n b H o r o , v e n o s e v e c K o r o 0 6 ~ . q e c ~ s a*on, HaKO HeBepHO Ha3bIBaTb TaKOe 0 6 w e c ~ ~ *AyXOM*. o hhp0~033pemeM a p ~ c aMOXHO oxapamepa30~a~b K ~ K ~ u ~ U ~ K ~MU a m~e ~ p mCu m K WJIH U ~ucmopuvec~uii ' Mamepmm.
J(~anemmecmiiinmohly, YTO B c e n e H H a r r p a c c M a ~ p m i a e T crr K ~ Konpenene~wiinpoqecc, n o c ~ y n a ~ e n b ~ axapamep rji ~moporoO ~ ~ C J I O B TKOH@IMKTOM I~H ~ ~ ~ O T M B ~ ~ O P C T B ~ I O cm. USIM B TO Xe Bpeh4.H 3 T 0 H H C T O P I ~ Y ~ C KMaTepHaJIH3M, E~~ n0CKOJIbKy M a p ~ ca w e H T H p y e T BHHMaHHC H e H a MaTepHH KaK ~ e K 0 e f i ~ e n o n ~ m o@ i tm m e c ~ o ipie a n b H o c T H , a H a HCTOPHH Y e n o B e u e a a . H a ~ y p a n mM ~a p ~ c a- 3 T 0 T ~ K OHaTYpaJIH3M, ~ B KOTOPOM n p H p o n a B o c n p k i m M a e T c r r KaK ~ ~ a ~ k ~ ~ enpoc r n f i
qecc c npacy-uaw ehly ~ e p e a r r ~ s o B~Oa~ M ~ O~= KwH~O C T H ~ . C T o r m 3 p e m M a p ~ c a ,npIipony nyYlue B c e r o OCM~ICXIITL~ KaK HCTOPHIO.
C ~M M a p ~ HMeHyeT c ce6rr aMaTepHLUHCTOM*,
H B =OMTO CMbICJIe 3 T 0 , A ~ ~ ~ c T B H T ~ J I TBK, ~ H o ,nOCKOJIbKy OH B P m J I H 6b1 BOCIIPHHNI W C H ) 0 TOM, YTO 'IeJIOBeK H BCeJIeHHaR HMeKlT KaKOe-TO CBepXT&CTeCTBeHHOe Ha'IaJIO. O ~ H ~ M K aOp ~ nOYTw c HKYerO H e rOBOpHT 0 UMaTepHH*, IIOCKOJIbKy JlJIR H e r 0 MaTepH~IIH~M TO npeme B c e r o p e m e 06 HCTOPHH Y e n o B e q e m B a . c o r n a c H o 3 ~ 0 h l yp e m m , YenoBeYecKyIO HCTOPHK) onpenem m npeme B c e r o @ a m o p ~~ K O H O M ~ ~ C KI HI o~c.~ o n b K y v e n o s e K no c ~ o e i ni p H p o n e MaTepkianeH, TO ero m 3 ~ Hb~ A O
M
OCMbICJMTb B KOHTeKCTe H C O ~ X O ~ H M O C TTHP y n a , HanpaBJIeHHOH a ynORlIeTBOpeHHe MaTeyHUIbHbIx n o ~ p e 6 ~ 0 c ~ eMCTOfi. p m - TO 6opa6a renosem 3a n p o m T a H H e , KJIOB, onemy, a TaIoKe 3a TO, Y T O ~ C~ H I ~ ~ A Ece6x I T ~ H ~ O ~ X O A E I M ~ LOMPHY W M H ,
r0
~ O ~ B O J I I I ~ I ~ HAMe M n a n B c e TO
6onee ~ @ @ ~ ~ H B H o .
O 6 ~ . q ~B3UIR4 ii M a p ~ c aH a HCTOPHIO B b I T m H T HPHMePHO TaK: HCTOpIlrr 6 e p e ~Ha'IUIO B C ~ e C T B O B a H E I HOTHOCkiTfXbHO ~ e 6 0 J I b l r r H XYenOBeYeCKtix O ~ ~ H OPraHEI30BaHHbM H , B IIJICMeH a no P0,QOBOhly IIpH3HaKy; Y ~ C T H OC O ~ ~ C T B ~ H H O C T ewe H HeT, 3TO n e p ~ o 6 b m ~ b r i W i , H e C T e c ~ b H H b & , KOMMYHU3M, B KOTOPOM 0 ~ ~ ~ b H YeJIOBeK a r g 0TO)ICAeCTBTIReTCII C OGWHOG KaK enHHblM U ~ J I ~ I MPamae . KOMMyHEICTmeCKEle c0061qec~~a neiiCTBHTeJIbHO HMeIOT n e p B 0 6 b I ~ k i b I f i XapaKTep, IIOCKOJIbKy H e pacnonaram H H K a m M H T e x H o n o m Y e c m M H C p e n c m a M H , KOT o p b I e 06nersran~6b1 HX 6opb6y 38 B b r m f B a m e K ynommope-
Hae HacmHbrx n o ~ p e 6 ~ o c ~ eCo i i . speMeHeM B 061qecme pammaeTcx onpenenemax Ternonom a HaMevaeTcx paneneHae Tpyna. KTO-TOHaYaHaeT o c y w e c m n K O H T ~ O J I HaA ~ OPYAMRMki lTPOki3BOJJCTBaki peC)'pCaMH, OT KOTOphIX 3aBkiCkiT 6naronorry~aeO ~ I ~ ~ C Tw Bx ~o, naeT eMy B O ~ M O X H O C T ~ KCfIJIyaTkipOBaTbApYI7UX. tam^ O ~ P Z ~ O BM pe3YJIbTaTe , paxeJIeHWI Tpyna a nocnenymuero ~ o ~ ~ p o r3ar rcpencmam r rrpom-
Boncma pomaeTcx wraccoBoe 06uecmo. C TOY= 3 p e ~ mM a p ~ c a couaarrbHare , wraccar - TO Te mmeKTmecme, npom~o60pmsyrouaec m ~KoTopare , rerenb HeBepHO OTOX&eCTBJUIJI C )QXOBHbIMki PeaTLHIIMH. ,!$Dl Puiag~cakiCTOpILFI CBOWTCII K HCTOPWW wracco~ofi6 0 p b 6 ~ . bPocne Toro W K n e p ~ o 6 coo6qecma ~ ~ e nepemarra c n e C T B O B ~ T ~rnaBeHmBo , BcerAa c o x p w o c b 3a ~ a w l ~ -wracn, COM KTIH maccaMa, TO ecTb OrrpenenembrMa rpynnaMa, KOHT ~ O J I E I ~ ~ ~ E Icpencma MEI npow3~onmsa.IIpouecc cowaHm
MaTepI.imbHm 6nar, ~ e o 6 x o n ~ ~JIJH b m061qemsa, 5r.w'~mcrr ~ H ) Y O MK noHmamH) ero npaponu. M a p ~ c~asbmamem e6a3wco~u o61qecma. KoH~peTHrn CWCTeMa nPOki3BOACTBa MaTepuarrbHm 6nar (~anpuuep,@ e o ~ m m o3emenemuece Koe X O ~ I P ~ ~ C T Bma O co~peuemb1i4H H A ~ C T ~ H ~ KanmaJI~~R nwm) co3nae~KoHICpeTrqm wraccoBym c - r p y ~ ~ QT ~ ~KOTOy, poii, B CBOIO ouepenb, 3aswca~TO, u ~ oM a p ~ cHwmaeT
w ~ a n q o i i ~ o i i uw: c ~ y c c ~ ~p eo n, a m , @moco@m,~oparrb a - YTO m e e Bcero - nomTEnecKEae WHCTWI~TN. C o u w m b ~ b ~nepeMeHH e npoacxow TorAa, Korna oma CMCTeMa lTPOkl3BOACTBa BbI3LIBaeT IIOREJIeHMe Apyrofi. HOB~ K O H O M W ~ C K ~*~~~ x J [~ w@OPMHPY~TCR c* B HeApaX cTap0fi UHWc~pojimw.Onmaxcb Ha rocyAapcTBemHe crpyrcryp~,mcnoacmyrouue couaarraHHe wraccH cTapom yKTIa,qa CTpewTcg lKaK MOXHO AOJIblrre COXPaWiTb BnaCTb. HO B KOHeYHOM CYeTe HOBaEf 3KOHOMEIYeCKaR CMCTeMa EI ~0BbIfi@ O P M E I P ~ ~ H ~ ~ C H KlIaCC CTaHOBIITCR nOCTaTOYHO MOIyJJ&CTBeHHhIMH, YTO ITPEIBO-
AHT K peBomwa, B K O T O P O ~cTaprn ~ ~ a ~ c ~ p os fa i~~e am m c HOBHM C O ~ H ~ J I ~ H I~I O IM P ~ K O M , 6onee a,qemaTrio o ~ p a x a m WMM J I e ~ a u ~Bf er0 i OCHOBe ~ K O H O M K Y ~ C I M yKTIW. ~ C O ~ J I ~ CMapKcy, HO kiCT0pH.H KaIIHTaH3Ma XOpOluO IIOKa3mae~ acmmomb ~ T W X T ~ ~ I I C O BC . pejl~ese~o~ aeonarrboe Hoe O ~ ~ ~ C TCO3&iJIO B O COBpeMeHHOe HH&yCTpHWIbHOe, TO
~
~anemecqw npomBononoxwxm. B TeYeHae Aonroro BpeMem @eonanb~arr apacToKpa-rm mTanacb ynepXHl3aTb BTIaCTb, OAHaKO, C TOYKX4 3PeHIIR M a p ~ c a , pa^qysc~arrpewnmsm cTana TopxecmoM H O B O ~ OcpeAHero wracecTb, CBOIO
Ca, K O T O P M ~KOHTpOJIkipYeT CpeACTBa npOki3BOACTBa B KanHTaTe x e AaaneKmecme C ~ M , KOTOPhIe IIpLlBeJIll K @OPMLIPOB~HHIO KanHTUIB3Ma, H YHlNTO-
nacmuecKoM o 6 u e c ~ ~ eHo .
ero. K a n a ~ a n a snpeAnonaraeT ~ 3 ~ c m y a ~ a q ~s1~0a u a ~ e n b ~ ovacm fi H e a m w x ~ p y ~ w w x c r&mi r , nponeTapaaTa. C TOYKX4 3PeHM.R M a p ~ c a ,3KOHOMEneCKaSf AHHaMHKa ~anmanas~ ~e a a 3 6 e m oIIpllBeAeT K @ o P M ~ ~ & ~ o B ~ H 06ueHIO
xaT
Cma, B KOTOPOM nPOJIeTaPKaT 6 y ~ ne OC ~TOHHH0 YEeJIkWHBaTbcrr, a ero 3 ~ c n r r y a ~ a qm nocTorrmo wspac~ala.B KanmaJIliCTwYeCKOM o 6 u e c ~ 0 ~ 6e % ~llpOAJKIJHHnOCTOriHH0 PaCTeT, OaHaKO PaCnpeAeJIeHHe MaTepHUbHaIX U ~ H H O C CTaHOBkiTCR T~~~ BCe 6onee Y3KX4M. B K O w e K O W O B IM KOWeHTpauwi nPLlBOAHT K @OPMWPOB~HHK)T ~ K O GCTpJKTypbI 06uecma, KOrAa npoas-
~o~cm npeBbnrraeT o n o ~ p e 6 n e ~ anee; p e n p o a 3 ~ o ~ cseAm ~m K 6e3pa6mase a e u e 60~1blue~y y c m e w m cTpa,qamfi. B a ~ o r e , npOJIeTapHaT BbIHYXAeH ~ Y H T o B ~ T ~ . Cornac~oMap~cy,npoTecr nponeTapaaTa 6 y ~ mOTJIHvancrr OT Bcex npeAmywm pe~onmqafi.Pmbure O ~ cosaH anb~arfiwracc, yHuYToxaR cBoero p m a T e m , caM, B CBOK) OYepeAb, CTaHOBkLnCR TaKOBUM. np0Jle~apkiaTXe C @ O ~ M H ~ ~ ~ T ~OJI~JUHHCTBO,y Kmoporo H e 6 y ~ wmepeca e ~ B coxpaHems cTaporo MaponopmKa a ~ O ~ T OOHM~ H ~ ~ T O ) I L UBCIO T cacTeMy wraccoBoro p e T e m B senoM. Bnep~hIeB acTopaa uenoseYeCTBa 3T0 CTaHeT B03MOXHbIM 6naro~aprrTOMy, YTO COBpeMeHHaR T e X H O J I O W CO3,QaeT Ma~e~kanbHoe aso6mwe, no-
Hero A ~ X6opb6h1, conepmvecrsa a yi-HeTeHm ~ e a s 6 e m osamm 6ar o ce6e B HOB^ @ o p ~ a x . C@OPMKPY~TCR HOBOe 6ecwracco~oe06uecm0, B KOTOPOM OCmeCTBHTCII TO, YTO M a p ~ c06br-1~0Ha3hIBU * H O B W c~onb~ 6e3 y
COUKaTlbHhIMYeJIOBeKOM*, 0 KOTOPOM CerOAHR, ClpeMCb a36e-
x a n mcKpamHauaa no npawsrry nona, roBopm KaK o *HOBOM ~ ~ U & ? C T B ~ H H OIIWLIBHAe* M *. O C J I ~ ~AyX H ~H U TB H A Y me
* CJIOBO aYeJIOBeK* (man) B &HI'JT&CKOM a ~ y x a m y w ~ I ~ H Mn e. p e B .
-
kI HeMeIIKOM 0 3 H a P a e T TBK-
c o n e p H w Z r e c m a , n w w B 6onbweii c T e n e H k i c ~ 0 I - p n o n y r a T b y n o a n e T s o p e H w e , ?pywcb H a 6naro ~ p y ~ u E x y. n e ~ n p e o n o n e H o
m a 3 ~ aw
B ~ I C O@~o p ~ a ~ e n o ~ e r e c ~XoHi ~i H H . T a m K a p m H a BO MHOrOM CXOnHa C XPMCTHaHCKLIM IIpefiCTaaTIeHkieM 0 H a C T y n n e HMLI Eombero Uapmsa, w ~ O ~ T O MB Y n o n H e ~ O H H T H O ,n o z I e M y MaPKCM3M I I o ~ oHa3bIBaJIH ~ X ~ W C T H ~ H C KepeCbH). O~~ C a ~ k Xe i MaPKCMCTbI 3aRBIIIIH)T, SIT0 IIX Q'MaHLlCTW~eCKEleW C O W a T I b H b I e mew - TO H e n p a 3 n H a c r M e r T a , T a K K ~ KOHM 6epyr H a r m 0 B pembso cyqecmyroum I i c T o p M r e c m cmax. M a p ~ ymepxc A m , 9TO eTO COIJWWIM3M MMeeT ~ a f l ~ b X ~a fp aiK T e p , 3 T 0 H e KaKM-TO j ' T O n w I . K a p T k f ~ aK , O T O P W OH PkfCyeT, BO MHOrOM QMTRraTenbHa. ~ ~ P m K fCl 0 ~ 0 nOHllrMWI ~ O T ~ ~ ~ H YeJIOBeKa O C T ~B IIOAJIUHHOM c o o 6 ~ e c ~ saeTaroKe , ero c r p e m e w e n 0 n y Y a - m y n o B n e T B o p e H H e OT C O ~ C T B ~ H H OTPYna. ~O OH OCTPO n e p e X M B a J I H e TOJIbKO n p o 6 n e ~ y~ ~ ~ H O C HO T HH, YTpaTy S I e n o B e Y e c K o r o AOCTOtMCTBa, KorAa r e n o s e K paccMaTpwsaeTcH n p o c T o K ~ K BHHTHK B OQOMHOG W H J I ~ C T ~ W ~ J I ~MalrrwHe. HO~~ OH M e w a T I 06 ~Gntec-me,B KOTOPOM p a 6 o ~ aCTaHeT AJIR SIeJlOBeKa TBOPqeCTBOM, a CaM 9eJIOBeK 6 y ~ e TP a C C M a l p M B a T b ee KaK B03MOXHOCTb n O M O r b
n p y r w ~w ce6e.
O ~ H ~eCTb K OHeCKOJIbKO C e p b e 3 H h M BOnpOCOB, H a KOTOPbIe M a p ~ cH e M o x e T n a T b y6enw~em~oro m s e T a . npex,qe B c e r o , perb W e T o ero sepe B TO, SITO MCTOPHH r e n o B e r e c - m a A B m c e T c R lI0 H a n p a ~ e H M H JK HeKOeMY W e a J I b H O M Y O ~ U ~ C T B YO . CT~BI~B ~ c q m sepy B n p o B m e H w e , a T a w e p a c n p o c m s l r r w c b c MblCJlbK) r e r e J I H 06 ~ ~ C O J I I ~ T H O M AyXe, J I e X a W e M B OCHOBe HCTOpMreCKOrO IlpOIJeCCa, M a p ~ c H e MMeeT P e m b H O r O OCHOBaHHH JlJR TaKOrO POAa H;39e>yq. CBOH YTIOBaHksrr OH OCHOBMB a e T H a 3MIIWPIISIeCKOM IiCCJIeAOBaKMIi IiCTOPIlki ki O C O ~ ~ H HHOa aHWIW3e 3KOHOMIIYeCKM CZZTI. O ~ ~ HMHOrHe ~ K O ki3 er0 IIpefiCKa3 a ~ ~(w,i iB S I a c m w m , yrBep>yqeHMe, r ~ BoP ~ ~ B M TK ~a nMm a n w c m r e c m c T p a H a x 6 e n ~ o c ~pa6orm b 6 y n e ~noc-rommo B O ~ P ~ C T BeCbMa ~ T ~ ) fiaJleKM OT HCTMHbI, ki MOXHO YCOMHHTbCII, c n o c o 6 e ~n H ~ a ~ o j i - r n 6 y ncowonor b TOSIHO npenc~a3an
6ynmee.
B~oparrnpo6ne~aKacaeTcrr Hmero m e n a m p a 6 0 ~ a ~BOb IJMR nocqoeHm more 6y~y-qero o61qecma, o c o 6 e ~ ~ Korna o MU 3 ~ a e YTO ~ , OHO m m ~ He b rapamwposaHo. Uero pa,qw H nOx>KeH er0 C'QOllTb II 3aYeM MHe GOPOT~CX 38 YlIpa3nHeHHe coquarrb~ofi3 ~ c r m y a ~ a q u uM ? a p ~ co ~ p u q a e~a1aie-rn60 ~ HPaBCTBeHHbIe QeHHOCTH B KaYeCTBe OCHOBbI ~aK0fiMOTHBaqkiLI. Ki3K HaTYPilIIkiCT, OH PaCCMaTpwBaeT MOpWIb nPOCT0 KaK
npO,QXT Y ~ J I o B ~ Y ~ cKyJIbTYPbI. Ko~~ H ~ HLlKaKEiX T TpaHCIJeHAeHTHbIx I J ~ H H o c T Ha~KOTOpbIe ~~, MOXHO 6 b ~ 6b1 0 CCWaTbCX
OAH~KO BneraTneHwe, rTo, mwparr Ha ~ 3 n e p x rn ~ a n w ~ a r r ~caM s ~M a ,a p ~ wcnonHeH c HpaBcTseHHoro HeroAOBaHm. HO Ha YeM Xe OH OCHOBbIBaeT CBOe OCJ%C,QeHHe KanmanwcTmecKoro 061qecma, ecaa Tame HpaBcTseHmIe KaK Ha OCHOBY AJUI K ~ L I T L I S ~ C KOIJeHKU O~~ KyJIbTYPbI.
HepenKO cKnwHsaeTcrr
llOHRTHIT, KaK UCrlpaBe~LIBOCTb* H UYeCTHOCTb*,
- BCerO JIKUIb
meonomsecKarr B ~ U ~ M K ~ ? Ase nocnenme c e p b e s ~ b ~ne p o 6 ~ 1 e~~p o~ m ~ c rBr ero BoCnpllrrTwH q e n o ~ e ~ e c ~ npwponb~, ofi a T a m e B aHanwse oc~o~ononaramIqefi m renosem ckflyaqww. Cornac~omap^cy, senoseK TBOPHT c e 6 ~caM; MLI c o 3 n a e ~ce6a vepes am VYn. Korna H m a XCH3HeAe5ITeJlbHOCTb npOTeKaeT B aTM0cQepe o n W e H m , OnWaeMcrr M ~ Ic a m , a Korna Ham ~ p y n npwo6pe~ae~ nollTIkjHHo YenoBeqecme repnr, MH c a m c-raHoBWMCIT JIH)AbMki-I3 llO&JIHHHOM CMbICJIe 3TOr0 CJIOBa. -0CTb,
conepHmecmo H s a s ~ c 0n 6 y c n o m e ~~C~H H O C T ~ H GeneHw) e M 061qec~sa Ha KnaccbI; B meZlJIbHOM o 6 1 4 e c ~ ~ 3TIM e 30JI He 6yne~. Bonpoc B TOM, HaCKOJIbKO mfi0K B3TJIH,4 h f a p ~ c aHa renoserecqw npwpoxy, a T a m e ero a ~ m w 3TOG cwyaqww, B K O T O P O ~HaxonwTcrr ~ YenoBeK. l l p a ~ n a nu, u ~ 31-OH~M o w xqqHOCTb - 3T0 BCWO JIIllLlb CJIeHCTBHe HenOCTaTKa MaTepHilIIbHbIx 6nar H KnaccoBoro nenewrr 061qec~sa?MOXHOnw, coqqaB
~ o ~ p YenoBeKa yr Hamxexauym cpeny, cnenan ero HCTMHHO ~ O ~ P ~ IHa M ?OCHOBaHLlH OnbITa TeX 0614ec~'B,KOTOpbIe He CKPbIBaIOT cB0efi C O U H ~ M C T L ecK0fi ~Y OpHeHTaqHH, BHnHO , YTO JIH)AH nOCTaTOSH0 ~ 3 0 6 p e ~ a ~ e J I bB~ b CTpeMJIeHHH I HCnOJIb30BaTb nm6ym CUCTeMy AJrR C B O e r O JIHSHOrO 6nara. H a s e p ~ o ep, a s r w ~ sa e n o ~ e u e c ~ onpwponb1 fi KpoeTcrr my6-
xe,
H e x e n e A y M m M a p ~ c H, , 6 b 1 ~ bMOXeT, 3 T a n p o 6 n e ~ a P a C K p b I B a e T ApyTJW: A ~ ~ C T B H T ~ J IJIH ~ HMbI O CyI.l.(eCTBa YHCTO ~a~epHaJIbHbIe? n o n ~ e p 1 u r B a 5 I n p H H I J H n H U I b H ) W 3HaYHMOCTb TpyAa H 3KOHOMH'leCKUX @ ~ K T O P O BB @OPMHPOB~HWHYeJXOBeYeCKOro 06wec~sa,M a p ~ c6bUI 6 e s y c n o ~ ~nop a B , OAHaKO H e c K n a A h m a e T c x nki r e n o s e r e c K a r r X H ~ H ~3~rero-TO60nbme-
r0,
!ieM lTpOCT0 ~ K O H O M L I K ~ Henbsrr ? OTpHIJaTb, YTO B ~ o J I ~ J I I H H c T B3KOHOMH9eCKU ~ pa3BHTbIX C T p a H H e M U I O MOnoAexH 6 b e ~ B ~ nRo k i c K a x c M M c n a H u e n H X H ~ H H .I T o ~ o 6 ~ o BCeM OCTiUTbHbIM @ O ~ M ~HM a T y p U I H 3 M a , MapKCH3M nepex H s a e T H e n p a r a e B p e h i e a a , C T p e M R c b A a T b r e n o s e K y TOT c M m n a uena.
XYISHECTBRKOCT~ HATYPAnH3MA B o T n B r k i e OT ~ e a s ~~aa,~ y p a n w H esy~? p a r a a a e T
cBoero BJIHRHMB, KOTOPOe H B HaLUH AHM OCTaeTCR 3HaZIHTeJIbHbIM. Poaw~lrrwcB b BOCeMHaUaTOM CTOJIemII, OH AOCTHr COBePLLIeHHOJIeTHH B AeBHTHWUaTOM H B03MY)IKan B A B a U a T O M . H e c ~ o T ~ H H a TO TO T e n e p b n o H s I t r r H c b n p m ~ a m c r a p e a k i r r , OH ewe AOCTaTOsHO X M B F . HaTyparrkis~rOClTOACTByeT B yHHBePCHTeTaX, K O J I J I e H~ B~ICLUHXm K o n a x , 3 a a e TOH ~ norm BO B c e x H a p H b r x accneaoBaHEuur. OH CO3AaeT TOT C M ~ I C J I O B O@OH, ~~ H a KOTOPOM YWIOBereCTBO npOflOJDKaeT OTbICKElBaTb BbICLUHe I J e H H O C m CBOerO 6 ~ m ~,O C K O J I ~ KB~ , 0 6 w e ~H Q e n o M , n a c a T e n a , nomu, XyA03KHHKH B ap'THCTM H e M O W ITPeOAOneTb er0 C K O B b I B a l o ~ e r0 BJTMHHlfH. CHX lTOp C HMM H e MOXeT COBJIWaTb HHKaKOe Ap)TOe MHPOB033peKUe, XOTH B ABWUaTOM BeKe eCTb 113 9er0 sbr6apa~b11, K p o M e T o r o , B nocnemee s p e w BO B c e x cnom o6uecma H ~ ~ J I K ) A ~ ~ T~c oH s p o x ~ ~e e~a ~s e~ a . ~ O ehty Y X>nreHaTypaJIH3M TaK X H ~ H ~ C T Ha O ~3TOT K ? BOnPOC MOXHO AaTb ma OCHOBHbIX OTBeTa. B o - n e p ~ b m , C m ~ b r B a e T c r r B n e Y a T n e m e , UTO TO r e - H o e H 06'bemki~~oe ~~p0~033pe-
A0
HHe. Bac lTp113bIBalOT lTpH3HaTb TOJIbKO TO, YTO H K O ~ OCHOBM~ I BaeTCH H a @amax H H a BbIBepeHHbIX pe3yJ'IbTaTaX H a p H o r 0 HccJreAosaHHrr. Bo-BTOP~RL, A O B O ~ ~ HM O H O ~ MOH Ka.xeTcrr IIOCJIeAOBaTeJ'IbHbIM. B~IBOAEJ I13 er0 IIpeAnOCbLnOK IGUQTCII OCHOBaTeJIbHbIMIl H IIOTOMy IlpHeMJIeMbl?dH. CO~JI~CHO HaTypa-
JIki3V, 3M3Hki.
no .Iy CTOpOHY MOlXUlbI
TOJI~KO YenOBeK
HeT HkiKIIKOTO
6ora, AyXa
wIH
CO3AaeT CkiCTeMy u ~ H H O C T ~ He ~.
n p ~ s ~ a s aYTO a , B cmy K ~ K O ~ O - T ~O ~ M M C MU J I ~npeAcTaBiuIeM COGOR CpeAOTOYHe B C ~ J I ~ H H O ~HaT)"plUIH3M ~, nOJIaraeT, YTO MbI c a h f u O n p e A e m e M c B o e M e c T o B TOM ~ ~ J T H HCaMB , ce6rr c o 3 ~ a kie co3maeh4 ~ ce6a H e w 0 uemoe. a ~ e n o ~ 3e ~ ~ 0 C N O e BbICOKOPa3BBTOe )I(UBOTHOe, - lIKI.UeT CHM~COH. - TOT @am,YTO T O ~ ~ KOHO c n 0 ~ 0 6 Be ~~I H O C H TT~a K o e c m e m e , c a M no ce6e B M K O ~ - T O M e p e CBki,4eTeJIbCTByeT, YTO 3 T 0 ACRCTBHTeJIbHO TaK* 42. C J I ~ A O B ~ T ~HaM JI~H H aO4 ,0 CAenaTb OnpeAeJIeHHbIe BbIBOAbI, YYkiTbIBaff, YTO MbI 3aKMMaeM 0~06oeMeCTO B IIplIpOAe H B TO Xe BPeMR ( H ~ C K O J I ~ K 3OT 0 ~ 0 3 ~ 0K0)ITPO~ 0 ) JIkipyeM ki ki3MeHReM XOA ~ i ~ ~3BOJIH)LI;kiB ~ e f i 43. Bce 3TO BbIlYIH&MT AOBOJIbHO npHRJIeKaTeJIbH0, H e c n k i 6~ HaTypWlki3M ~ e f i C T B k i ~ e J I bnpeACTaaruuI ~0 co6oii TO, YTO 0 HeM r o B o p a T , TO, H a s e p H o e , ero cJIenoBarro 6b1 assa an H e ~ o n b ~ o npHBJIeKaTeJIbHbIM WIki ~ M ~ H ~ C T O ~ ~ KHO E IkiMHCTkiMblM. , M ~ I paCl7kiClUIki6U er0 AOCTOkiHCTBa ki ki3nOXeHHhIe 3AeCb AOBOAbI pacummu 6 b 1 AO uenoro TpaK-raTa, p a c c s k i T a H H o r o H a cospeMeHHOrO YkiTaTeAR. OAH~KO 3 a O J I r O 80 HaYaJIa ml3A4aTOrO B e M B 3AaHkiK HaTy'"WlK3Ma HaYNlK nOHBJI5ITbCH TpeLIJMHbI. TO KaCaeTCff KpWTkiKOB-TeMCTOB, TO OHW BCerAa CYkiTWIki, YTO 3AeCb STO-TO H e TaK. O m H e M o r n H O T K ~ ~ ~ TOT ~M C R ~ I C ~ STO H , 3a npeaenam 3 ~ 0 f Bi C ~ J I ~ H H O0~6~k i ~ a e~~~ C K O H ~ YE Ho ~ ~ -I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Y HMX ocT~ K p k i T m e c m e AOBOAM MOXHO 6bLJX0 6131PaCueHkiTb M K npOffBJIeHkie KOHCePBaTki3Mi3, 3aRBKB, YTO O m ~ O I I T C R~ P O C H T ~ C B R HeBenOMbIe BOAbI HOBO^ HCTkiHbI, OAHaKO H a CaMOM Aerie P e Y b
rn
m a o ~ p y r oB~cne~yoxqeii . rnase M ~ nI o ~ p o 6 ~ peaec c K a m e M , MK B narepe c a m H a - r y p w k i m o B H a v a n p a 3 n a s a ~ b c ap o n o T HeAOBOJIbCTBa. T e s k i c b ~ ,H a KOTOPblX OCHOBbIBaTIOCb 3 T 0 MHPO-
~033peme( n p w o ~ a~ ~ e l u ~no e f oi T H o u e m m K v e n o s e K y BC~JI~HHOG ee, 3aMKHYTaR ki Hepa3pbIBHaff npHYHHH0-CneACTBeHHaH C B R ~ COMHeHkiH) ~) H e nO&BeprilJlWCb. n p o 6 n e ~ a MCan a C b o6nacm AOM3aTeJIbCTB. E C TJIM ~ Y H a m W I k i 3 M a AOcTaTOYHbIe AOBOAhI TOTO, Y T O ~ ~ MbI I M0rJJ.H p a c c M a l p m a T b ce611 M K HeYTO 3 ~ a Y k i M 0 e ?Aa, B03MOXH0, MbI YHkiKaTLbHbI, HO TaKOBbI ki l;OPWLILbI, ki n1060ii A p y ~ 0 f B i W. ~ H ~ Y H M O C Y eTn~o BeKa - BOT YTO C T ~ nep~oii O npo6ne~oii,s c e m x o x q e f i 6ecno-
.
K O ~ ~ C T B OM. o r n e T
nki C w e C T B O ,
KOTOpOe BO3HMKJIO c J Q F I ~ ~ ~ H o ,
6 b 1 n 3HaYH~hth4? B o - ~ ~ o p b l r xM, o x e T
nIi
cyuec-rBo,
n p o I i c x o x q e H H e KOTO-
poro c T o n b H e n o m m o , A O B ~ P R Tc~ ~ o e ici n o c o 6 ~ o c nr ~o s ~ a HM? C w e npocro: ~ ecm BO~MOXHOCTH M o e r o p a y h i a O ~ i 3 H M Y e H b MOHM I M03rOM, eCJlki Uff* MiUIIHHa, TO K I K Xe B TaKOM CJQFIae ~ r ~ c n H E ?c
PO-)
JXeXaQaff
- 3 T 0 IIPOCTO M
b ff M o l y AOBepffTb
I
C
n ~c o 3 ~ a ~ 3~T e0 3 n l l I $ e H o ~ e H (T. e. n 0 6 0 ~ ~ h I j i
MaTepHH, TO, 6 h l ~ bMOXeT, ZIenOBeYeCKaR CBO~OAI, B OCHOBe MOPaTIH,
-
IIPOCTO ~ ~ H I $ ~ H o M CJQFIiW ~ H
W I H K ~ K O ~ O - H M ~HYeA r I ~p e n o X H o r o 3aKOHa. B o ~ M o X H O , CIIY-
uafi r n o~n p e ~ e n e ~ ~M~H rp oi ni o p q n o K n m b
n o p o m a m T BO
M H e *Ol.4WeHI.le* TOrO, YTO ff C B O ~ O H ~ H XOTff , H a CaMOM A w I e 3 T 0 BOBCe H e TaK.
H a 0 CKa3aTb,
YTO 3TH H
n o ~ o 6 ~ lBOnpOCbI re
BO3HLlKaIoT
we 3a rrpenenam H a T y p a n H c m u e c K o r o ~ ~ p 0 ~ 0 3 3 p eo w m: n p H c y u w e M y . Orrace~wr,r I p 0 6 y r n A a e ~ b 1 e HM B H e K o T o p m
)%fa, B e A y r n p f f M 0 K HKI'KTIH3MY, K O T O P ~ IM~ H ~ e T O X e XOYeTCR H a 3 B a T b MHPOB033peHMeM, XOTff H a CaMOM AeJle OH npeACTaBJlHeT
co6oii
~
OTpHUaHMe BCeX ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 3 3 p e H H f i .
~
E c n ~sl CKMHY 310 psatioe 06~1aretibe, M C B O ~ O ~ HB~fiay O B OrPOMHMe ~ e 6 e c a , M ecnM sl tiMrero TaM He ~ a a y , K p o ~ e6e36pextioh T O ~ Y ~ H ~ H ~ I , 683 eAMtioro OTronocKa, HMrero tie 31iaa~qei4 TO ~ o r ~ a ?
-
HHm3m TO He C T O ~ K O &HTIOCO&IUI, CKOJILKO ~ C T B O , H, c T p o r O rOBOpH, n o ~006we H e @KIIOCO@~. HW~WJM -~ M TO o q m a H W e @IZIIOCO@HEI, O T p w a m e C ~ O C O ~ H O C TKH no3 ~ a m 1 0a, T a m e ~ e n p a s ~ a m T oer o , r T o H e r T o M o x e T m i e n KaKYIO-TO 3HaSWMOCTb. Ecnw A M 0 AOXOAkiT A 0 ~ ~ C O J I I O T H O TOO' I p H I 4 a H m Y e r O 6b1 TO Hki 6 ~ 1 0TO , OTpWLl[aeTCR A r n e PeiUIbHOCTb CaMOrO C m e C T BOBaHXH. &'~-~MMII CJXOBaMki, M r W I M 3 M - 3 T 0 ~ I o J I HHeTaTNBH3M: ~I~~ o T p w a m i e n o 3 ~ a m3mm, , K p a c m b r , c a ~ o jpie a n b H o c T H . B H e M HElKaKOe yTBep.>KAeHHe H e HMCeT 3HaYWMOCTH, BCC JXWlIleHO CMbICJIa. TOT,K o r o H e K o c H y n o c b o n a x m e , T p e B o r a K c K y K a , l I p 0 6 y X A a e ~ b I eHI.IIXiJIW3MOM, H a B e p H O e , C TPYGOM A O T C K a e T , YTO er0 B C e p b e 3 MOXHO CYWTaTb 4MWPOB033PeHHeMa. O A H ~ K O 3 T 0 TaK, H AJIH K w O r 0 , KT0 XOTeJI 6b1 ZIOHII'Il, YTO lIPOHCXOAHT B ABaHUaTOM BeKe, 661~10 661 HelXlOXO - XOTH, KOHeqHO, JIkiUrb
yCnOBH0 - OlUyTHTb B ce6e Y T O - H E I ~ Y AOT ~ HEITUSIH3Ma KaK o r r p e ~ e n e ~ r i oycTaHosKw ii Ha renoBeYecKoe cmecTBosmse. Cospe~emb~ xyAoxecTseHHaIe e ranepea nonHH mmsCTEPICCKHX npoEi3~e~eHKfi, eCJIki, KOHeYHO, M o m 0 rOBOPZiTb 0
( n p o a s s e ~ e ~sc~ycmsa), m B O ~ ~ K L Us~3 Mm e r o ( x y ~ oHe~nps3~a10uuie ~ , B cBoeM CmecmoBaHss m ~ a ~ o i si ~ c l u e i UeHHocm, i curs Tame xy~omsm~ a a y r c r r ) . Y~M-TO
n 0 3 ~ H e eMbI YBWLIM, YTO hMKaKOe HCKYCCTBO He MOXeT 6b1~b
jqo atoms H L I ~ ~ L I C T U Y H M MOAHaKo , HeKmopbre ero HanpameH m CTpemCII BOWIOTIlTb B ce6e M H O I u e HHTUSIllCTH5IeCKHe OCO~~HHOCTII.Memo B C ~ O M H H TKapmHy ~ Mapcem AmmaHa: OHa n0AnHCaHa llCeBAOHMMOM ki s306pamae~~ ~ ~ I K H o B ~ H HE,& nsccyap, ~yrmemmHa pbxwe. K a p s ~ a~ a s m a e ~ c r r ~ ~ @ o H T ~B HApaMaT)'pIull *. CpeAH o 6 p a 3 u o ~HHTUSIHCTWeCKOro m a q a HWO npeme Bcero ~ a s s a ~ b Ca~b103na
Eewce~a,w o 6 e ~ dorrey ~o wpbw s crB oxudarruu roam. Ero H ~ ~ H C T ~ e C KElCKYCCTBO O e AOcTMraeT BeplUHHbI B llbece
~fluarrueu,~moparr~ H T C I ~I p m u a ~~ Ib I
ceKyHA T ~
s B KOTO-
H ~ T HM O A H O ~~~e n o ~ e ~ e cpons. ~ofi Hepea H a m KyYa Mycopa, ocsemeHHarr T ~ C K J I ~ ICMB ~ T O M , K Q T O P ~ ICTaHOBElTCII ~~ HeMHOrO RpYe, OAHaKO, TaK k i He ~ a 6 p a ~ c~oefn i o n ~ o i iCIZTI~I,o m ~ TycmeeT. b H ~ HMK~KHX T CIIOB. B Harane nbecbx p a 3 ~ a e ~ c rsra r m c a ~ ~ b rHa ii M ~ ~ H T O @ O H H
poii
neHTy KPMK, 3 a ~ BAOX, e ~ B~IJKOXH onmb KPIIK, KOTOP~IMnbeca A sasepaarae~c~. Eemce~aTaatoe qbrxaHse* - TO ~EZ~HI,.
Hma B
O ~ ~ M zIeTbIpe ~ I M paccmsa Ayrnaca h a ~ c aatmopb~fi , ~ W H O @aHTacTsKH. ~ ~ B HKX OH IIOBeCTByeT 0 TOM, KaK C nOMOI4bIO KOMlIbIOTCPOB JIIOAH nbITaIOTCH H~fil'H cmwbxcn cBoero cywecTBosam. B pacc~asax *lIyrnesodumeJlbno
p a 6 o ~ a Be WHpe ~ H
fierttolrry Baymrw, *Pecmopari s Korrye sceneririoiiu, emurib, sceJleHttaa M eeqttocmw, ceudattwi u cnacu60 3a ace, pbl6w [sHitchhikerQsGuide to the Galaxy*; aThe Restaurant at the End of the Universe*;* Life, the Universe and Everything*; wSo Long and Thanks for ALl the Fish*] A q a ~ conscmaeT HCTOPEIIO scenew~oiiirc aoum s p e ~ w ueTbrpex r r e - g o ~ eKOTopbIe, ~, npeoAoneBm ruemaxamrecKoe s p e m H npocTpaHcmo, rryremeCTB)WT no ~ e f C i MOMeHTa ee B03HLIKHOBeHKII B I j m b l u o ~ B3pb1~e H no nonMoro ymYToxeHm l . M ~yIs ~ a eYTO ~ , KameTO c s e p x p i l 3 y ~ ~ mcyuecma e ( O K ~ ~ ~ I BYTO ~ ~ TTO C M~ILUZIT), R,
~ ~
3waBIIIHCb qeJIbH) HafiTH OTBeT Ha *llOCJIeIlHHfi BOnPOC )KU3HH, BC~JI~H HH BCerO O ~ Ha ~ C X T e w , IIOCTpOHJIH 0 ~ 0 ~ H WKOMnbIOfi Tep ( * ~ n w r k i ~ oci i He60JIb~0iiropon*). *Deep Thought* (urny60mmcnbw) - TaK OHH ero ~ a 3 s a . x-~noTpan3.n H a
Bwnicneme
ceMb
c nono~moitM
~ H O H O B neT 2.
* ~ P o B ~ J & RB IIOnCYeTaX II BbIYHCJIeHKRX CeMb C ~ O J I O B H H O ~ ~
MKTLnHOHOB JET, d(rJIY60Ka5I hbICJIb* B KOHLle K O W O B B03BeCTKTI, YTO crrBeT 0 3 ~ a y a eCOPOK ~ ma, w Torna npllaunocb llOCTpOHTb npyrofi, ewe 6onbmaii KOMnbIOTep, Y T O ~ ~Bb IMC~ m bB, YeM x e 3amm~a~1cn Bonpoc. TOT, ~ 0 ~ 0 p b IHjai3BmW *3e~ncr*,6m c ~ o n bBenm, YTO ero racTo no oura6~enpwmMmw 3a maHe.ry - oco6emo Te CTpaHHbIe, 06e3bn~onono6~b1e cwecTBa, KoTophIe ~POJWTH no ero nosepmocm, cosepmeHHo He C O ~ H ~ B ~YTO H , OW Bcero ~~ YaCTb ~ & W ~ H T C K O M~ ~T I ~ I O T ~ P HnpOrpaMMbI. O~~ Bce 6 b ~ O 0YeHb CTPaHHO, IIOTOMy qT0 6e3 3 ~ 0 g npocrofi W O Y ~ B I Z ~ H AOnH O ~ ~ n o 3 ~ a mHEnTO W 3 BCerO, K O ~ A ~ - m 6 0 npoacxonmurero Ha 3 e ~ n e n, o - B I W L I M O He~ aMeno , 6b1 m KpOXK CMbIUIa. OAH~KO, K HeCYaCTbH),COBCeM He3mOnTIrO A0 Tor0 MOMeHTa, K O r n a H m O 613~10nOJIYSI4ITbpe3yJIbTaT, 3eMnm H e o ~ a m o y ~ u u ~ o ; ~ uBorowb~., rra perrrwsrrrae - KaK o m c a m roBopWJIH - npOBeCTll 3neCb H O B W CBePXKOCMEneCKYIO O ~ X O A H ~ ~ O AOpOI'y, &iBCHKElH H w e a a OTbICKaT'b CMbICJI m3HW 6bIJIa
-
HaBcerAa ncrrepma. no ICpafi~efiMepe, TaK Morno
~ O K ~ ~ ~ T F 3. SH*
KK O BToporo ~ pacc~asanyTerrrecmeHmm y s s a m ~YTO , ucaM Bonpocw (nocnenmii Bonpoc w 3 m , ~ c e n e ~ ~Hoscero ii Ha c ~ e ~rrracm: e) ~ C K O J I ~6 y KnOe ~mecTbro n e ~ n n ? u4. OHM nOWMaIOT, YTO BOnPOC LI OTBeT ~ ~ c c M ~ I c J I ~Aeno HH~I. B TOM, YTO Ha YeJIOBeYeCKOM YPOBHe (TO eCTb Ha WOBHe VeJIH
H C M ~ I C J~I ~~ C ) C M ~ I C JHe I~H TOJXKO CaM OTBeT (COPOK nBa*: nepen HaMw npocTo nnoxan MaTeMaTuKa. nnorryrae~cn, YTO cauan paVwoHarJmarr n ~ c r r ; ~ m BO l i ~~ ac e i~i c e n e m o iCBenacb i
K a6cypny.
B Kome TpeTbero pacc~asaB ~ I ~ C H R ~ Tn Co y~ e, w Bonpoc EI OTBeT He KMeHIT H H K ~ K OA ~O~~ H Y ~ C K C OB~R3 ~Ei. Om11 kf3
n p a ~ ~, O T o p b L f lI F K O ~ M3 H a e T KOHe9HYIO w c m ~~OBOPIIT: ~, ~EOIUC YTO ~ ,Bonpoc H he^ wcmmqam apyr npyra. l l o s ~ a w l eomoro nonirecai M e m a e T n o s ~ a m m npyroro. H ~ B O ~ M 9O ~~ O 0 B,6 npenenax ~ o ~ ~ owi ~i o i xi e R C ~ J I ~ H H O~0raa-~11160 G MO=KHO 6 y n e ~ n o m T b H TO k i A p v O e * ( @ ' Q ' A ~ H T ~ I - @ H ~ w K wY B W T , YTO 3AeCb 0 6 b n p ~ ~ a e ~IIpHHcrr Ukin H e o n p e A e n e H H o c r w r e h e ~ 6 e p r a ,c o r n a c H o ~ m o p o ~ y ~ o m oon p e ~ e n ~~ O~~bH L M H~i)CKOPOCT~3nercrpo~a,o n H a K o repoeB,
no
MMeHH
'.
H e n b 3 H 3TO CAenaTb CO B C e m ToYHOCT~H).)
H T ~ Ky ,HaC
eCTb w I H OTBeTbI, I I O X O W e H a JTI0hMH)TbIG
6e3 BOnPOCOB, HnIi BonpocbI, KoTopbIe ~ K ~ ~ ~ I B H a~n H p aI mT e m e H a m e r o noucrca, HO H e B O ~ P O CM m B e T BhaeCTe. T a m h a o 6 p a 3 0 ~ c, ? p e m e H m K *CopOK
Am*, KOTOPbIe
HH9eI-0 H e 3 H a Y a T
06peTeHHlO OKOHSaTeJSbHO~OCMbICna H a M H e ~ O B J I e T B O P I I T ' b .
qmarr Ca~bm3naE ~ K K w~ @pama T~ K a @ ~ y ,3 x e ~ a uo~ec~ Ho mose@aXemepa, Kyp-ra B o H H e r y r a ~ I M6onee c o B p e M e H H o r o a B T o p a Ayrnaca & a ~ c a , H a r I i H a e m o w m a n ( ~ C J I H KOHeYHO, , PaHbuIe H e MCnblTUi = O r 0 B H W T I I ~ o c T H ~ L ~ ~ B ~ K )TY 60nb, KOTOP~SI nopowae-rcsr n y c ~ o ~ or ei in o B e r e c K o r o CyU&CTBOBaHHH M )W13HbW), M ~ ~ ~ H H B CO I I K~O ~ ~UeHHOCTH, qena M cMblrcna. O ~ H ~ BO3MOXeH KO JIM IIepeXOA OT HaTYPUikI3Ma K HMlX-q83Pdy? P a 3 B e H a T y p U K 3 M H e y6e~HTeJIb~brii BbIBOA, nOAflt3H~ b & H a OCHOBe BbIBepeHHLlX HaJW-bIX AaHHbM. Ii OTKPbtTOrO HHTeJJJIeKTyUibHOrO H c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H H ?Passe 3 T 0 MKPOB033PeHWe H e O ~ ~ H C H I I ~YTO T , T a K o e Y e n o B e K w B Yeha ero C ~ M O ~ ~ I T H O C T ~ B KOCMWIeCKOM MHPO~TOP~SAK~? Passe O H 0 H I i u e r O H e POBOPHT
0 YeAOBeYeCKOM JJOCTOMHCTBe W ~ H ~ Y H M O C T I I ? U ~ ~ O B ~ CyrrIeCTBO B b I C l u e r O IIOpHAKa, OH ~ A K H C T B ~ H HBO ~ IB~ C ~~G B C ~ J I ~ H HHOa A ~ e~J I e H C a M O C O 3 H a H H e M H C ~ O C O ~ H O C T ~ K H, CaMOOnpeAeJIeHHW), O H n p a B H T BCeM OCTaJKbHbIM, C B O ~ O A H O BbICTpaHBaH CBOW) CHCTeMY Q ~ H H O C T ~IiGC T O n b Xe C B O ~ O A H O onpeaencrx 6ynyrrlee c ~ o e i tC O ~ C T B ~ H H3O~~o~n m ~ w wUero .
ewe x e n a ~ b ? ~ O J I ~ U M H C T BHaTypaJKIlCTOB O 3 a B e p U a e T CBOe HCCJXeAOB a H H e H M e H H O 3 n e C b , H ,4ilR HMX H e T H W K ~ K OA O ~ pOrH K
~arrn113~y. OAH~KO n o ~ a r r r r e - r c R B c e 60nblue n m ~ e i i ,KOTOP~IM H a p H b E BbIBOAbI H e K.XKjVCff CTOJIb BbIBePeHHbIMW;
3aKpMmari
K
IIpHpOAa ~ c e J I e H H 0 f iBOCllpHHElMaeTCR KaK HeYTO C K O B b I B m mee; W e R c M e p r w K ~ Ky r a c a H I u r B c e m e T ncmonomecqio TpeBOry, a IIOJIOXCeHMe BbIClUerO C m e C T B a B KOCMOCe BOCnpHH W a e T C R MJIH KaK O a i y l y q e H M e OT H e r o , MJIH KaK TaKOe C HHM
enmeme, B KOTOPOM KX q e H H 0 c - m H e n p e B b m a e T qeaaocm np~6pemoi3 ranbm. B e ~ Tba me r m K a UXKB~T* Aaxe ~onblrre! YTO CBR3blBaeT HaTYpaTIH3M, ) T ~ e p X A a ~ o m H fqeHHOCTb i reno~ e u e c ~ oXiKi ~ H Hc ~ o i@i I O P M O ~~~ a ~ y p a r r w sK~Oa ,T O ~ ~3~01-o H H e A ~ J I ~ ~OAHHM T ? CIIOBOM, Ki3K B03HHK H W ~ W J I H ~ M ? H e ~ 6 mCKa3aTb, YTO OH B03HHK nOTOMy, YTO TeHCTbI H AeHCTbI PaClLIaTWIH HaTypUlH3M H3BHe. HLITMJIH~M - er0 POAHoe AmR.
I l E P B M CBS13b: HE06XOJlMMOCTk
CQ
CIIYW~~HOCT~
n e p ~ a R H OCHOBHaR IIpHYHHa BO3HElKHOBCHIIR HHlWJIH3Ma KpOeTCR B JIOrJlYeCKElX BbIBOAaX, KOTOPbIe BhlTeKaIOT H 3 OCHOB o n o n a r a m m m T ~ ~ M C O~Ba ~ y p a n a sB ~ sa r. w H a uenoseuecK)W IIPMPOW C m e C T B e H H O H3MeHIITCR, eCJIH MbI B C e p b e 3 OTHeCeMCR K TOMY, YTO (1) BO B C ~ J I ~ H H C)%L(CCTBYeT O~~ TOJIbKO MaTepIur, KOTOpaH BeYHa; (2) KOCMOC Pa3BHBaeTCR B e ~ w ~ o o 6 pasww npwum H c n e n c r ~ ~ lBi i3axpwmoli CHcTeMe. TO 0 3 ~ a ~ a eYTO ~ , YenoBeK - Y a c n T ~ K OCHCT~MH. ~I kiaTypanac~bI,KOHCYHO, COIXalLIaIOTCR C 3 T m , YTO RBCTBYeT K 3 KX T p e T b e r o ~ e s ~ cvenosevecrcue a: cyyecmsa - 3mo cnoxuwe
Maruuuu, a nuvuocmu& npupda venoserca - ecezo nurub @ y u ~ ywr c n o x u u xuMuvecKux u @u3uvec~ux csolicms, e y e ue nommW do KOU4a. T ~ H Me M e H e e MHOrJle H 3 HawaTLHCTOB IIOn p e m e M y H a c r a m a m , YTO BHqPrpa 3a~pb1~0fi cHcTer+m YenoBeK OCTaeTCR C B O ~ O A H ~ I M . n 0 r J l K a TaKOBa: BCRKOe c 0 6 ~ m BO e B C ~ J ' K ~ H H OO~ ~n p e A e m ~ T C Xn p e x m M c o c T o R m e Aen, BKnIovaR r e H e m e c q i o npeAp a c n o n o x e m o c T b , cwryaqam, B ~ o ~ o p oHiaix o m T c R YenoBeK, H A a x e TO, rero OH x o v e T K K r e M y CTP~MEITCR.B TO x e B p e m K 3 HaC MOXeT ~ ~ 0 6 BbIpiIXi3Tb 0 ~ ~ 0CBOH XWIaHHII H CBOH CTpeMneHHH. ECJIH, HalTPHMeP, MHe 3aXOTeJIOCb CbeCTb 6yrep6po~,a raCTpOHOM HaXOAHTCR npRMO 3a YIXOM, R MOW TO cAenaTb. Ecna R saxouy y K p a c T b ero, nonoxqm, K o r A a npoaaseu s a i i ~ e ~ cCBOKMH rr A e n a M a , R MOW c A e n a T b H TaK.
HHYTO H e CKOBblBaeT C B O ~ O A MOerO ~I ~b16opa,H MOH A ~ ~ X B ~ I R C ~ M Hce611 o n p e A e m m T . tam^ 06pa30~,YeJIOXK, K O T O P M ~ ~B, H e BCIIKOrO COMHe~ m06na,qae~ , C ~ M O C O ~ H ~ H a, H ~no-BWMOM~, M c a M onpeneJIReT CBOH IIOCTYIIKLI, M O X e T COBePlYaTb 3HaYKMbIe A~GCTBZZR H H e c m 3a H U OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb. 3a K p W 6 y ~ e p 6 p o ~ Mae m M O W apeCTOBaTb H BllOJIHe O ~ O C H O B ~ H HnOo ~ p e 6 0 s a ~ Y b T, O ~ E J II 3 a m a ~ m u~pa@. OAH~KO T a K AH BCe II~OCTO? E C T JIIoAH, ~ H HX HeMaJIO, KOTOPbIM H e K Z e T C I I , YTO AeAO o 6 c ~ o m m e m o TaK. ]IIpo6~1eMa ~enoserec~o C iBiO ~ O A Hrny6xe, H e x e m x o n p e A c T m e T CII HaTypUIHCTaM. fi, KOHeYHO, M O W AeJIaTb BCe, YTO X O W , OAHaKO TO, Y e r O II XOYy, 06ycnome~oMOHM IIPOLZUIbIM, HaJJ KOTOPbIM II, B KOHeYHOM CYeTe, H e HMeJI KOHTPOJLII. fi H e 6~ C B O ~ O A ~BHsb160pe M O ~ G r e ~ e m ~ e c ~CTp-hl oii ItTIH T o r 0 c e ~ e f i ~ oor oq y x e m , B KOTOPOM POC. fi sa,qamcb B o r r p o c o M , C B O ~ O A ~JIM H II B CBOHX A ~ G C T B ~ Ma~ ~MXe, m y T e M IIpHpOAa H BOCnHTaHHe c @ o ~ M H ~ o B ~ . J I H MeHII T a U M 06pa30~,YTO B 0 3 HHKHOBeHZ3e CaMOrO 3 T O r 0 BOIIpOCa 6bmo 06ycnome~oH, CneAOBaTeJIbHO, MOe 4IIu OnpeAeJIeHO BHelLIH3iME.I CItTIaMH. fi, K o H e Y H o , MOW 3 m a ~ a ~ Tb a m e B O ~ P O C H , MOW ~ e j i c m o ~ a m COrJIaCHO MOHM x ~ J I ~ H H ~ M CTPeMJIeHKRM H, 3HaYHT, M O W ~ a 3 a ~ b cce6e a C B O ~ O A H ~ I MXOTH , H a CaMOM A e A e 3TO TOJIbKO BMAVMOCTb. Bce AeAO B TOM, YTO eCAH BCeJIeHHaR ~ e f i ~ T B k i T e J I b ~ 0 saqbrrarr c w c T e M a , TO B c e , YTO B ~ e j ~i P O H C X O ~ TM, o x e T ynpammbcrr T O A ~ K O H ~ H Y T ~ HJ. I m 6 a ~cma, H a K ~ K O M6h1 y p o B H e o H a m C ~ O C O ~ C T B O B ~n eJ pI ~e M e H a M B K o c M o c e (MHKPOKOCMklSIeCKOM, YeJIOBeYeCKOM W I H M~KPOKOCWY~CKOM), eCTb
ero H e o T a e M n e M a R Y a c n . C r r e ~ o s a ~ e n b ~~oT, Hn e p e M e H b 1 MOXHO O ~ S H C H E I TntOfl6KO ~ OAHKM: H a C T O I I U e e IIOJIOXeHHe AeJI 0 6 y c n o m ~ s a e6ypyrqee. ~ HH~IMH CnOBaMH, H a c T O m e e ILBXIIe T c x npwm~oi3 6y~yuer0,K o T o p o e , B c ~ o m orepenb, 06yc.110~JIHBaeT 6onee OTAaTIeHHOe Gy~yuee,H TaK A m e e . B o s p a x e ~ ~CeO, ~ J I a C H OKOTOPOMY BO B C ~ J I ~ H H O(GK ~ OKH a OlTMCaHa B TeOPHH OTHOCHTeJIbHOCTH ~ ~ H l U ~ e fHeB03MOXi~a) HO OIIpeAeJIHTb OAHOBPeMeHHOCTb I I p O H C X O m e r O H, CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, HeB03MOXHO AOKa3aTb HaJIKYHe IIpHYHHHO-CJIeACTBeHHaIX cBII3efi, 6 b e T MHMO VeJIK. B AaKHOM CJQTae Mhl
rOBOpKM H e 0 TOM, KaKKM o 6 p a s o ~ co6brrm CBH3aIIIJ M e w ~060fi,a TOnbKO 0 TOM, YTO O W CBH3aHH. OAHEIc06b1~m IIpOKCXOAHT IIOTOMy, YTO nPOK3011IJIK ApyT'I3e, K BCR AeHTeJIbHoCTb BO B C ~ J I ~ H npeACTaBlIIzeT HO~~ ~060fi TaKYIO B3aKMOCBH3b. tam^ 06pa30~,MbI M O X e M K H e 3HaTb, KaKOBa n P K P O A a B3aKMOCBH3K, OAHaKO lTpeAnOCbIJIKa, COrJIaCHO K O T O P O ~K ~ en e H H a r r s a ~ c p b ~sac~aarrrre~ ~a, H a c npm%~w K B~IBOAY, YTO 3 ~ a B3aKMoCBH3b C m e C T B y e T . Eonee TOTO, HaTIkiYKe T a m B ~ ~ I I M O C B IMOXHO I ~ ~ ~ ~AOKas a ~ b .Onpe~enemareco6brrm n o A q a m T c r r o c m c n e H K m H a YPOBHe M o ~ W I e f i K, , CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, HeKOTOpbIe K 3 HWX MOXHO n p e ~ c ~ a 3 a(c n TOYKM 3 p e ~ mH a m e r o ~ ~ M H OB~~O~ M ~ H K ) n 0 Y T K C A O C T O B ~ P H O TOYHOCTbIO: ~~ H a n P K M e P , I'Ae K KOI'Aa n p o ~ s o Z i q oe r~e p e A H o e s a ~ ~ e mHa e .6n~xa-e mHaAqaTb BeKOB M O W 0 nPeACKa3aTb, KOI'Aa K r A e H a 3eMJIe nO5IBKTCH T e H b OT BCeX ~ Y A ~ E 3I aX~ M e H K f i . KOH~YHO, ~OJI~~LIKHCTBO ~ 0 6 b ~ KHeJIb3R f i n p e A C K a 3 a T b C T a ~ 0 f TOYHOCTbIO, i OAHaKO BCe Aeno, BEILIE.IMO,B TOM, YTO M ~ nIp o c T o H e s ~ a Bec e x~n e p e M e a HbIX BeJIKYKH, a T a E K e EIX B ~ ~ K M O C B HOAHK ~ ~ ~ ~C.O ~ ~ I T K R 6onee n p e ~ c ~ a s y e ~Hber x, e m Apyrwe, HO HK OAHO 113 HKX H e OCTaeTCH H a Y p O B H e ~ O ~ J U O X H O C ~KU a. ~ q o eAOJEiCHO ~ p 0 ~ 3 0 f i ~ K . EGnw B c e n e H H a r r n p e A c r a a r r r r e T co6oii 3 a ~ p b csmehiy, v TO TO H e o s ~ a ~ a YTO e ~ , K a w e - ~ o c 0 6 ~ mMOW K H e n p 0 K 3 0 h K , a K ~ K M ~ - T TOJIbKO o B03MOXHhI. ~ ~ M ~ H ~ nHP O W- I E KCXOAHT TOJI~KO noA B O ~ A ~ ~ ~ C T Bonpe~enemofi K~M cmar, a c a M a 3 ~ cma a norrarrrreTcrr T o n b K o 6naro~apx~ o ~ e f i c ~ ~ ~pyrofi,K T a K A 0 ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y H O C TMKo.X H O CKa3aTb, YTO B 3~0fi q e n K H e T HKKaKOrO p a 3 p b I B a OT n p 0 l u n 0 ~BeYHOCTU A 0 ~ Y A Y BeKK BeKOB, aMKH6. O ~ ~ I Y H OYeJIOBeKy MY AeTepMKHK3M H e npeACTaBlIIzeTCH YeM-TO KCTUHIIIJM. M h I n P K B b W I K CYKTaTb, YTO ~ e f i ~ T B y e ~ M ~ 0 6 0 OAHaKO ~ ~ 0 3, T 0 BCerO JIkiWb E Z I L T I I O~~O~ ,C K O J I ~MK ~ nIp o c T o H e s ~ a er T ~o ,s a c ~ a ~ m H aoc n p K m n TO m~ K H o e pememe. UTO-TO,K o H e Y H o , 3 a c ~ a ~ m 0 , OAHaKO H a M KameTCH, YTO 3 T 0 6 ~ H 1a m C B O ~ O A I IBIHJ ~~O~P . Ta~arrC B O ~ O A( ~ c J I K , KOHeYHO, H e CJIEllIlKOM AYMaTb 0 ee ~H~Y~HK BbI~rrrrAKT K) BnOJIHe yAOBJIeTBOPKTeJIbH0,nO Icpahefi M e p e , c TOYKK 3 p e m H e K m o p b m 6.
~ e f i BO ,
x o
k k b I M ( r ~CJIOBaMH, B 3 a K P b I T o f i B C ~ J I ~ H H cso6oda O~~ - 3TO c~oel-op o A a ~ e n p u 3 ~ ad ~e m~em p ~ u ~ u p o s a ~ ~ o ca mTeM, b , KTO A e n a e T o T c m A a c o o T s e T c T s y I o m a e B ~ I B O A ~ I TO , He K ~ ~ T C R AOCTaTOYHhLM OCHOBaHHeM B03MOXHOCTH CaMOOIIpeAeJIe-
mII
H W I KJLH H P ~ B C T B ~ H H O OTBeTCTBeHHOCTki. ~ B e A b eCAH R O w a -
6m 6 a m , 3T0, B KOHeYMOM CYeTe,
IIPOH30LLLnO B CHJI)' H e n p e JIOXHbIX, XOTR H HeOC03HaBaeMbM M H O m @~KTOPOB, KOTOPbIe npasena K TOMY, YTO c B o e pemeaae R 6onbme H e M o r p a c c M a T p H B a T b K a K CBOe. Ho ecna MOW p e l u e m H a c a M o M A e n e H e MOH, TO R H e M o r y 3a HkM OTBeYaTb, ki 3TO B e p H 0 no OTHOWeHkiK) K m 6 0 ~ y
~eiicmamm6oro rejrosem. tam^ 06pa30~,Y e n o s e K - TO n p o c T o Y a c n K~KOTO-TO examm ma, ==-TO ~ r p y m ~(cnomm, a H A a x e BecbMa cnomax, HO TeM H e M e H e e ~rpymm) 6emm~m KocMEiYecmx cm. C a ~ o c o s ~ a ~Ywe neo s e m - 3 ~ oT O A ~ K O~ ~ E I ~ ~ H O T O A ~ K On 0 6 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 ee6 c m a 3 e ~oro ~ e x a ~ a sHo ~ aecna . cos~aH H e - BCerO JLULUb YaCTb MeXaHM3Ma, TO B H e er0 H e C m e C T B y e T HIlKaKOrO UR*. H ~ HHKaKOrO T *3rO*, KOTOPOe M o r n 0 6~ u n p o TKBOCTOHT~*c a m e M e w y n p m n em no c B o e M y y c M o T p e m m . u B o m o 3TOr0 u ~ o 3TO B O KOCMOCa, ~ a mecb 6m0 6b1 p e c m o n p a s e c T a A O B O ~ ~ Hxopomee O onacame Y e n o s e m , A a H H O e 6. a.CKZIHH~POM. OH rOBOPWT, YTO m II TOrO, - 0 6 ~ k i 3 M e m T b JIK),I(~~, H ~ O ~ X O A L I MI O 1 3 M e m T b KX O K p y x e H a e ,
M ~ H ,
06-
CTORTeJIbCTBa, B KOTOPbIX O m A ~ ~ ~ c T B Y I O Ta, T a m e C U M , KOTOpbIe B03,I(efiCTBYIOT H3 HIIX. % I O B ~ K PeaIXpyeT C O O ~ P ~ ~ H O BO~A~~~CTBW ~O I OC, K O J L ~ c K TOYKH ~, 3 p e ~ kCl ~m ~ ~ e p~am;q& a, ki3 H a c - TO TOJL~KOW B e T H a R p e a u r n , a H e 6onee T o r o . ~ ~ ~ A O H e B~ 0~3 ~Ke f i c T B yH ea ~MWP, HO MJlP ~ 0 3 ~ e f i ~ T B yH ea T Y e n o B e K a * 7. H a m a c m CJIeayIOT 3TOMy MHeHklH), KOTOPOe B I c p a T y e MOXHO a m o m n TaK: Y e n o B e K - TO H w e n e H H a R c o 3 ~ a m e M U H H a , l M l r r e H H a R c n o c o 6 ~ o c ~Oan p e A e m n CBOK) ~ y , I ( b 6 ~ U H GOBepllIaTb YTO - ~ 1 1 6 y ~3HaYEITeAbHOe; b n03TOMY OH ( K ~ K Hewo
q e ~ ~ oMee)p m . Ero m
3 ~ b 30c g q u x a m e w
Eemce~a,
M o x e 6mb, ~ MbI CJILlllIKOM YCKOPHAEI XOA H U K X paccyx, I ( e ~ u f i H YTO-TO ) T I Y ~ ~ k l n k iK ? a~oji-m6y~ HaTYpaTIWCT b CKa3m
~
6b1, YTO 3 T 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c T B H TTaK, ~ J IYTO ~ H MbI o O W H ~ ~ ~ M CO~%RCHIFR R, K3MeHeHHH 0 ~ ~ JIHUb 0 6 H ~ P ~ ~ P ~ InPMYHHHO-CJIeACTBeHB H O ~ ~ H O CBR3bH). ~ C T0YKE.I 3PCHI.ZII x a ~ MOHO, a HalTpHMep, BC5fKOe c e p b e s ~ o eH ~ M ~ H ~(TO H eHc T~b n o m e H M e ~ e r o - T O A~~~CTBHTeJIbHO HOBOTO) C J I Y T I ~ ~ H OH . a~ypar~~m CYHTaIOT, bI 9TO 3TO HOBOe B03HKKaeT B ~ ~ ~ M ~ PKOJIKYeCTBe: H O M TaKOB I C a ) ~ ~ q b LUar ~fi H a ~BOJIIOUIIOHHO~~ JIeCTHKUe, HaYHHaR OT BOAOPOAa K )TJIepO-
&a, KIlCJIOpOAa K a 3 0 T a , KOTOPbIe B CBO~OAHOMCOC,L(HHeHMK o6pasyro~c n o x m I e a m H o m c n ' o T b I K ApyI-Ke O C H o B o n o n a r a I O W K e X K 3 H e H H b I e KOMnOHeHTbI. K ~ b ~~ 0i ~ i0 ~ 0 T H hMOMeHT Ifi (a kilt MHOX~CTBO) npeAn0n a r a e T cnysrafi~oe B O ~ H M K H O B ~ H M ~ero-TO ~ HOBO~O. 3 a ~ e HaYKHaeT ~ e f i C T ~ 0 ~ H aT ~O b ~ X O A H M O CLmK, T ~ COrJIaCHO MOHO, UMeXaHM3M HeK3MeHHOCTK*, K O T O P ~ IYABaKBaeT ~ MOAeJIb, CO-
~
3AaHHYH) CJIyYaeM. M e m e ~ ~Hoa ,~ p O T I D K e H W BeKOB, i 6naroA a p R COYeTaHHIO CJIyYaH K H~O~XO,L(HMOCTK, CHaYiUIa BO3HHKaeT KTIeTOYHaR =3Hb, IIOTOM MHOrOKTIeTOYHaH, 3 a T e M PaCTkITeJIbH o e K XHBOTHOe UapCTBO K, HaKOHeU, YeJIOBeK TWM 06pa30~,c m a i i n p e n o A H o c K T c r r K ~ Kn e p B o a a Y a r I b ~ h I f i BMlTyJIbC, K O T O H ~ ~IIpKBeJI ~ K B03HMKHOBeHEIIO YenoBeYecTBa. Cornac~o C ~ m c o wc,r m a H , uenb, ycTpeMJreHHOCTb, TO eCTb BCe, YTO A 0 3 T O r 0 MOMeHTa OTCYTCTBOBarIO B ~BOJIIOUKK, n o m m e T c R c npIiLLlemBKeM Y e n o B e K a K CTaHoBKTCH HeOTbehUIeMbIhi CBO~CTBOM HOBO^^ 3BOJIIOUKK, K O T O P m
'.
'.
CBOAKTCR K H ~ M YCaMOMy* H0 YTO TaKOe cJI)W~G? TO WIK H e H 3 M e H H a R C ~ O C O ~ H O C T ~ PeiUIbHOCTK Ka3aTbCR ~ J r y z l a f i H O f (i ~ I o c K o J I ~ KM6I ~ H e 3 H a e M , no ~ a ~ olTpKYHHe fi O H a K2UCeTCR T ~ K o @ o ~K~ ,H a 3 b I B a e M CJ'IYYaeM H a . ~ e c n o c o 6 ~ o nc o~ 3b ~ a o~n pb e n e r r r r m u K e Q~KTOPH), WIK HeYTO ~ ~ C O ~ I O T K HpOp a U K O H U I b H O e . B n e p B O M BapKiiHTe CJryY a f i - 3 T 0 nPOCTO H e n 0 3 ~ a H H b I f iAeTePMKHH3M, a H e C B O ~ O A ~ . Bo BTOPOM - r o B o p R o cnysrae, M ~ m I e r o H e O~MICHII~M. c o B e p u a e T c H ~ a ~ o e - T COO ~ ~ I T KK~m, o p o e HenC B R ~ m ~ T c~ ~ a ~ or xj pi m ~ ~ o f3To i . crryuafi~peC O ~ ~ I T KOHO ~. H e TOJIbKO MOrJIO H e l I p 0 ~ 3 0 f i T H ,HO H e 6 ~ 1 HHKaKEM 0 OCHO~ a H K f iO-aTb, YTO O H 0 ~ o r ~ a - r n 6Cn[YYKTCR. 0 ~O~TOMY, CO3AaBaR B m K M O C T b C B O ~ O A ~ ~n[YYafi, I, n0 CYTK AeJIa, n p K B 0 AHT K a6cypny. &0 HeYTO 6 e c n p m ~ ~ ~ 6ecuenb~oe oe, K J I m e H H o e ~ a ~ o6b1 i TO i HM ~ ~ I J IHOa n p a m e H H o c T K . ?ho n p o c T o
AO~I~CTKM,
B H e 3 a n H a R AaHHOCTb, BOIIJlOTWBWaHCR BO BpeMeHLl W KIpCXT-
paacme. Q A H ~ K O , COrJIaCHO m a ~ yMOHO,C W ~ G IIPWBHOCHT B I l p O C v a H C T B O Ii BpeM5I WMrryJIbC HOBOrO HaIIpaBJIeHElrr. C~ryZ l a k i ~ o eC O ~ ~ I THH e Wh4eeT ~ nPHYHHb1, HO, GYAYULI I ~ P ~ C ~ Y W H O ~ ~ CaMO ll0 ce6e, O H 0 OTHbIHe CTaHQBLlTCR H ~ o T ~ ~ M J I YaCTbIo ~ M o ~ ~ 3aK33161~02 B C ~ J I ~ H H O G ~ .J I ) ' W ~ ~ H OcC 0T0 ~6 u a e ~B C ~ X ~ H HHOe ~ ~ p 1 9 3 y ~ ,C M ~ I C1 ~ ~4UeJIb, HO a 6 c y p ~ H . e o ~ a w MH o HaYIiHaeM IlOHWMaTb, YTO H e 3 H a e M , r A e HaXOAkIMCR: T e n e p b MhI He 4 B e T O K H a ~ ~ J I O C T HTKaHW O~ KOCMOCB, a K a W - T O ~ w a f i ~ U
me
rnm~oiiK o x e ~ ~ ~ T L M T I H O ~ O . T ~ K E OJ M ~ P ~ O M HAeR , cJIJW&HOCTH H e A a e T HaTypaAkiCTy TOTO, YTO PPCO~XOAIIMOJIJHCaMOC03HaHHH Ii C B O ~ O A ~ I OH^ . 6 0 p O ~ a B i ~ 1H1a
JILIIIL1b lT03BOJLReT, O C 0 3 H a B U
c e 6 ~3aBHCeTb , OT CO~CTB~HHOI+O
KalTpWsa. H0 OCHOBaHHOe H a K a n p W 3 e A ~ ~ ~ C TB 3TO H ~ BOBCe H e C B O ~ O A H Oc a~M o B h t p a w e H k z e Y e n o s e m i , 06na~a1ouero onpeAeJIeHHblM XapaKTepOM. TO l l p O C T 0 HeZlTO CBOeBOJIbHOe W
6ecnpmwmoe. a e i i c ~ ~ woec ,H o s a H H o e H a ~anpwse,H e l i M e e r H m e r o o6uero c c a M o o r r p e A e n e H w e M , w, T a m M O ~ P ~ O M y H, ~ C no-npemew H e T m ~ a ~ oO Ci Hi O B ~ rn I n o c q o e H m MOP=. Moxmo c ~ a s a nYTO , T a K o e ~ e j i c m npocro ~e cmecrByeTw He 6onee T O ~ O . ~ O A B ~ AWTOrW. ~ M O C H O B H ~ RIIpWYWHa, no K O T O P O ~H~ a w p a n w s ~n e p e x o A I i T B H W ~ W ~ COCTOWT M , B TOM, Z~TOH a T y p a n I i s M H e A a e T s e n o s e K y OCHOBH rn ~ H ~ Y W M M~eiicrswii. X OH, C K O p e e BCerO, OvWI&XT B 0 3 M O m O C T b C m e C T B O B a H K R CaMOo l 7 p e A e m I o I 4 e r o c R WH&kiBHAa, K O T O P ~ I MOT ~ ~ 6h1 Bb16WpaTb, O C H O B ~ I B ~HCa ~CO~CTBCHHOMC ~ M O C O ~ H ~ H H ki W n p H c m e h i OT poxaeHm
xapamepe. M u
Bcero m
M H p O B a H H h I e KJIW K a n p I i 3 H h I e .
cnoco6~ocmK
Y
CaMoonpeAeJIemIo.
b
~ a r r r w ~ a3anporpa~r,
HaC HeT C a M O C 0 3 H a W W
nam, m m 3 m ma a c m H a BCC TO,
YTO m m e T c B e h l y s ~ a m e ~ A a s a f i T e llOCMOTpHM, IIOYeMY 3TO TaK. Cornac~o~ a ~ y p a r r a 3 B~ yo c, n p m a e a n o 3 ~ a m e- mo HeYTO T O w e C T s e H H O e HalUeMy M 0 3 m KTIW e r O n060~~lbdi
npoAyicr. OHMB O ~ H H K ~ I O T6 n a r o ~ a p&ymaaowrposamm ~ M a T e p s a , a H a v e H e 6m0 6b1 m ~ a ~ oMMCJIH. j i OAH~KO M~TCPHII CyLI@?CTByeT no CBOHM c o 6 c ~ ~ e m 3aKOHaM w W~ 0 3 ' I ' O
.
~ H ~ THBK~KKXO C H O B ~ H Wnonaran, ~~ YTO o H a XOTB K ~ K - T O 3UIHTepeCOBaHa B TOM, YT06b1 IIpHBeCTH H a e n e H H O e CO3HaHHe M cyxuecmo K HCTHHHOMY B O C ~ P ~ T N Ima O J I O ~ ~ C K Z(TO ~ M eCTb I I p a B ~ ~ r b H h I hBhIBOAaM, f) OCHOBaHHbIM H a TOYHOM ~ a 6 m Aema a B e p H m i n p e m o c m K a x . JImw - e A m c m e H H b x e cyuecma BO ~ c e f~i c e n e ~ ~ K~TOPMX ofi, 3a60mm awe B O ~ P O C M . K p o ~ eTOrO, YeJ'KOBeK n p H a R 3 a H K CBOeMy TWIy k i er0 C03HaHWe B03HHKaeT K3 c J I o X H O ~ B3aNMOCaR3H Pa3nUZZHbIX KOMnOHeHTOB ~ B ~ I C O K O O ~ ~ ~ H M ~ OMaTepHN. B ~ H H O ~n ~ 0 Y*e M y x e B TaicoM cJIyYae B c e TO, YTO 3 ~ Ma a T e p m O C O ~ H ~ ~ ~To , m o KaK-TO CBR3bIBaTbCR C TeM, YTO A ~ ~ C T B H T ~ J I eCTb? ~HO C ~ ~ C T ByeT JIM ~ a ~ o f i - n a 6~cpkiTep&ifi, 0 C n0MOw;bIo KOTOpOrO M0)IMIO 6 m o 6121 OTJIWIHTb WNII03HH) OT p e a T l b ~ ~ C T l iH? a ~ y p w c T M rOBOpRT 0 MeTOAilX Haj'YHOrO NCCJIeAOB~HEIR, I I p ~ ~ ~ e C K w x T ~ C T ~aXTaK Aarree, HO o c y x u e c m e H a e B c e m mom qoacxoW T 38 CYeT BCIIOJKb30BaHWII T o r 0 CaMOrO M 0 3 r a , K O T O ~ OHH I ~ H npOBepRIOT H a Zl,QeKBaTHOCTb B O C l T P l i K I ' ~ . JIm6ill1 TaKaR nposepw nemo n p e B p q a e T c R B 6ecnone3~oe,xmff a nocneAOBaTeJIbHOe lUIeTeHHe lWJII03~fi. &m ~ a - r y p u a sB~Hae ca~cific a c T e M H muero H e cyxuecrye^. H ~ T H a K a K o r o Eora, 0 6 ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ a m ma u e rYoe c r H o r o , c o B e p r u e H H o r o ma H e c o s e p r u e m i o r o , n m H o r o ma 6e3~1mHOM. C ~ ~ C T TOJIbKO B ~ KOCMOC, ~ T B KOTOPOM J I I O m - e m H c m e H m e cyxuecma, Ha,aenemiMe C O ~ H ~ H H ~ M HO , C~OBHO
~yna-mo n o ~ ~ a ~ l u a e . Aa, OHH A ~ ~ ~ c T B N T U I ~ aB03HKKJlH*, HO HO KaK WBHO? Moryr m OHH A o a e p m b c B o e M y pmyh.ry, cnoefi cnoco6~ocm cmem? C ~ M Yapns A a p ~ ao ~ n ~ a x ~ ac~a3a~1: r uBcamiik pa3 B O ~ H N K ~y x~ aTc H o e c o M H e x u i e B TOM, YTO y6ex,qesarr uenoBeYeCKOrO YMa, pa3BNBUIerOCR N 3 C~TOCO~HOCTC#HH3LL[W XNBOTHMX,
06nagam~KaK0fi-JIki60
3HaYHMOCTbH) N AOCTO-
BepHOCTbIO. A o B ~ ~ H J I c R JIH 6b1 KTO-HH6ynb K ~ K O M Y - H H 6 y n b y 6 e w e ~ w 1 0 B03HHKILIeMy , B y h f e 0 6 e 3 b R H h t , eCJIH 6~ B H e M TaKOBOe ~ ~ L T I O lo.? k~l H b I ~ k CJIOBIMII, i eCJIH ~ 0 f M i 03r - He YTO HHOe, KPK M 0 3 r B ~ I C O K O O ~ ~ ~ H H ~ O 06e3bRHh1, B ~ H H O ~ ~R H e MOIY AOBePRTb C O ~ C T B ~ H H OTeOPHH # IIpOHCXOXAeHKII. flm6onhrr~arrAeTWb: Arne eCJIH HaTypWH3M A a p ~ k i H a HCTHH~H,H ~ H T H K ~ K OBO~MOXHOCTH ~~ o n p e A e n k i T b ero DOCTOBePHOCTb H TCM 6onee 3TO AOKa3aTb. A o ~ e p k i e K JIOlXKe H c m m Y a e T c R . tam^ o6pa3o~, caMy Teopkim A a p ~ k i o ~ anpo-
i
H C X O w e H H H B m O B H m 0 BOCnPHHHMaTb H a Bepy. ~ P W X O ~ T C R JfkIlUb rOJIOUIOBH0 y I . s e p w a T b , YTO M 0 3 r MeXaHK3M, ~ 0 3 ~ m a m i6i ni a r o ~ a pe c~T e c T B e m o M y 0 ~ 6 0 p yH C J I Y Y ~ ~ ~ H ~ ~ M H ~ M ~ H ~ H W R MOXeT M) A ~ ~ c T B z ~ T ~ J I3HUltlb, ~Ho YTO KaKaR-TO IIpeAIIOCbLNKa HeCOMHeHHO HCTHHHa. KlIafi~f l b ~ > H rOBOPHT c 06 3TOM TaK:
TOT
wknw B c e cyuecrsyrouee - rro TOJI~KOT I p ~ o n aTOJI~KO , ~ a ~ o e - Tsenwoe, O ~ ~ C C M ~ ~ C J I ~H HqH e nOo c~T H o e C O ~ M T H ~ , ecnw HUH c a M M e rny6omie y6eme~m- n p o c T o no60y~hdt npO,QWT HppaI@IOHWbHOTO llpOqeCCa, TOrAa, KOHeYHO, HeT HH ~aneihueroOCHOB~HKHnonaran, YTO H a q e o M e H H e COOTBeTCTBKII H BbITeKiUOuaR OTcmAa B e p a B e m ~ o o 6 p a YTO~e JIM60 rOBOPRT 0 PeWbHOCTH, ~ H e l I I H e f no i OTHOUeHHIO K HaM. Harrrki y 6 e w e m - mo npocro TO, YTO Kacae-rcR H a c caMwc, KaK, H a n P H M e P , D e T BOJIOC. k J I H HaTypaTIH3M npm, TO B TaKOM CJIYYae y HaC HeT HKKaKMs O C H O B ~ H H~ O ~ ~B C P H T bHalJ.lefi MbIcJIa 0 TOM, YTO npapona eAHH006pa3Ha*
".
T O m , Y T O ~ U6B 3TOM YBePeHHbIMH, ~ ~ 0 6 x 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 6UBHe 6 1 HaC H nPHPOnbI* C ~ e C T B O B WH e m i f i PaLJHOHaJXb~ h dAYX, t OT KoTOpOrO M o r n a 6h1 H C X O H~a u a C O ~ C T B ~ H H ~ R c n o c o 6 ~ o cK ~ PaUHOHaT116HOMy b OCMbICJIeHKIO. T C H ~npemoM JIaraeT, YTO TaKOe OCHOBaHHC A ~ ~ ~ c T B H T ~ JCCTb, I ~ H oHaTYpaSIH3M x e moro H e n p w 3 ~ a e ~ . M u H e TOJI~KO o r p a m e w ~ a r r r wn ~p o m M , TO ecm H ~ H M n p o H c x o w e m i e M ~3 ~eonyrrrewxemofi,nmxremofi C 0 3 H l U - i ~ MaTepHH, HO KaK MJdCJIHT(:JIH MbI 3aMKH)VH H B
~ a u r e f~i
b z ~ e m eCHTYWHH. f i
A O ~ ~ C T HR M paccylutAam , o TOM,
~ ~ 0 ,
I
YTO BCe JXlOAIl CMepTHbI. A P H C T O T ~OA H~a c w c - Y e n o B e K , CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO, O H C M e P e H . O 6 o c ~ o s a ~ ~ aBbIBOA, oit He npaB-
na AH? Jonycmw, rmo ~ Q K ,HO n o r m y s u peurunu, rmo smo npa6u/lbHO? O Y e H b IJPOCTQ: R CneAOBaTI 3 a K O H a M JIOWKH. K ~ K ~ A I saico~am? C rezo su BWU, rmo OHU U C ~ U H HTO ~ CaMooYeBliq-
!
HO, II, B K O H U ~K O H ~ O B passe , 6e3 HHX 6 m a 6b1B O ~ M O X H X~ O T ~ KaKaZE-TO M b I C n b WIH c006~qeme?Hem, KOHCYHO, Hem. HO T o r A a OHM WCTIIHH~I? Hem, smo sosce He 06mame/lt~o. JI1o6ofi npwm~marfiH a M a apryhiem npeanonarae-rH ~ J I W w e wxaccmecm ~ ~ K O H OTBo m e c m a , H e n p o m B o p e u m w WCKJIlOYeHHOn> TpeTljerO. OAH~KO 3TQT @BKT BOBCe H e r a p a H THPYeT *AOCTOBePHOCTW* APHHJdX 3aKOHOB B TOM CMhICne, YTO nm6arr H a m a m c n b mw B ~ I C K ~ ~ ~ I BH ~e nHp W o T ~m ,o p e Y a A q w e WM, AOIDKHI~I H e n p e M e H H o C O ~ T H O C H T ~ C Rm e m o c T a m n o n o x e m i e M A e n B O ~ ~ ~ K T Z I BcH y Or u e c ~ ~ y z o ~w e~j i~ e m ~noe j i O T H O ~ e H W l OK H a M B C W I ~ H H O ~ sonee . TOrCl, BCKKOe CTpehUIeHWe n p O B e p W T b O ~ O C H O B ~ H H O C TOrO T~ U k I WHOrO apryhieHTa c a M o n p e A c T a m e T co6oB apryhiem, ~ o ~ o p a rM f io x e T 6 ~ ~ H e l l p a B H J B H O nOHHT. H ~ Y HAYMaTb H ~ B TaKOM KJIIoYe, MbI PIICKyeM A 0 ~ ~ C K O H ~ ~ H O ABIIraTbCR CTH B O ~ ~ ~ T HHaQaBTTeO M HHH; M ~ I ,YTO H ~ ~ ~ I B ~ ~nTm Ca eRM, c R cxm-rmb c e 6 ~ 3a XBOCT, )43WrZlXCb no ~ ~ C K O H ~YAJIWHHlOAqeMYCR ~ H O KOPliqOPY T a K O r O pons p a c c y w ~ e H W f mw, i rompa waaue, T e p r r e M HW KOOPAMHaTbI B M o p e ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y H O C T I I . OAH~KO H e s a 6 x y w a c b JIM MhI, OTpLIqZlX B03MOXHOCTb ~ O ~ H ~ W EBIeR~?b ,no B c e f i BepOHTHOCTH, MM A ~ ~ ~ c T B H T W I ~ H O M o x e M 6onee m w M e H e e y A o m m m p m e ~ b H on p o ~ e p ~ ero ~b AOCTOBepHOCTb. H ~ M H3BeCTH0, YTO e C T b BCWW, KOTOPhIe MOXHO ~a3~a1-b JIOXHMMW KTIW B ~ b ~ c m ecfTie n e H W H e a e p o m H m a , H a r r p w M e p , p e p m e H H e o TOM, ~ ~ A H T eOo p r a m e c K o e BeAqeCTBO M O X e T CaMOnpOII3BOJIbHO I I O p O ~ a T bM H K ~ O ~ O I ~ . Bce s ~ a l o m IIOYeMy , KHnWT BOAa, B03HWKaeT YeCOTKa, m a d t
3 ~ a CBOKX e ~ ~ 1 p y 3 e Bw y31-1ae.r KX B T o n n e . no C ~ T KA e n a , ~ ~ K O H Y ~ H H E moceonormecm JX mnim-
w3 H a c
6 h 1 ~ a eW~T, e M H e M e H e e HaTYpLUIW3M H e A a e T u e n o B e K y C K O ~ ~ - H W ~ BYCAC~K O ~~~P K Y I I H H ,H a OCHOBaHWH K O T O P O ~O H M O r 61x1AOBePRTb CBOeMy p a 3 W . B K O H q e K O W O B C - W mcsi n a p q q o K c a n a H a R , H e n m e m a x wpoma cw-ryaqm:sawCTOB H e
b
