Устойчивые многочлены. Проблема Рауса-Гурвица. Часть I. Методические указания по курсу ''Теория устойчивости''

            


  
    DZ  

  

        !

   

DZ     ! ! ""# $$  $$  % " &  ' ( ) *

 !"#



   
       

DZ    +"#*  
, - 
. /
0 /


0 /'0    * " *          #   "1  (  !2  $+!   "# $$   3%  "  /$1   (  !2  0 $+!   #  "*  ! "  ""  %  "       $     %  4        %  " 5   (    "1"# 5    # 6 "   %  $+   $   $$!2 (  !2   %  ""#      *   $! /'0 "  "

 $ (  !2   "      $$   DZ 4$ $ "       ("#    "   % !$   "*  $+ "    (!  ! 3   $+!   # (   2  * $*" /0  789/  0%  4 1  !       $*"

*"  !  
 %  "  *  1  ! "  ""   DZ    

   !   "        $*"  (5    $*"% ! $"( ($ !  "1$ *   "# $$   :  !$ "#$ (    !2 $*"2 +     ; + <  ( 1   = DZ   "#  4 $! (! *    $$ <   "  !"










  

       
                              DZ     !          "     
#  $  %  " & "   !$  $  '$  "   ' #    ( $     $        

 

 !  '   )  *   $  %   ! # '   %++ !        
# $      

     )   

          #      , %  

    $      DZ  -       #   $        ++  !     
 -         .#/ !       "     0

 1   2 3 0

 - 4567$ 8 . - 4599$ : / ! - 45;6


) <  $*"$  !   /) %  % > 0 ?   "#  $ ; +  # "#    $ "*(  %   "*  *$   "!$ "#$%  

1!$   !$ "$ "*(!  "  % +%    DZ " 5   @#   

  " "# % $  $$  #  #   *%  4 $ A% $  #   @1! %  $! 

1  (!  "$  * 2  B 5 4 "# (""# %   %      2   DZ(    5* !  (      !2  1 (+  3    !2 $*"   "  $ (+$ < $   2!$ ?  "#!   !!%  2"(% $$    % $   $1 ( % "   "5   ! ("  * $ C 2  42 $"* 2 (1 %  

 "  +"#  "# "1# ! (  %   #   $$   % (! "# 5"   #  

 ?$  $%  %   ! "   $* (!#   #$ *$ $%   "  "#    $"% ! 1""#  #  $ "  ! "1 $ $"# "%  ( 1  "# !2  % ! ""  $2%  2%  2   ?$% " *% (! "# #  $# $ ; +%   # "5  "#   

      

, -    , -     , -  



/0

          ! "#$   %
 $  


   &      $ '(
 ' ) !

  $5 DZ"1 : " $  " # * $ "# "%  $ "% !#  4 "# ' DZ%#&' "() :  $!2  !2%    "!2  (    !2 $* "2 1  "5 $%  !  $$  * 1 D"! /'EF)0G <  

 %       '    - =5#4>=$    - =44= 0                 

 -     

    '              '   ?   @ !     $            

       ' 





 ! "" /"0 * +  ,  $-%% 


   + $-%% '   '$  #$!

H 5  * $*" $$!  "#  5    
DZ #
/ 0 -  /   0  /     0/   .  0

*     /   0<     5  !   5  !  $*"  DZ "# ($!     2"!     . / .  0 $ "1"#! 4 +!%  !$ (  2  
"# $! ''  <   # "*  $!
        $*" $ %     (5 :G .$#!









































 "" /'    )    $-%% 
 !

? (5$ 1 "G

 "# 0+      $-%%     $   $ 

IJK    /)0
$%&'( 

$ / . '0  "$%     """#     / -     0 6 " IJK  "$ $"%  "$  $1 $#   ") 0+ /0 -   .     .    .       /      0   






























 ' $    
1    $   )' +  '
(!


                              ! "  #$  %    %  & % &'     (    %)    & &   & 

 "*&+
,&(!& DZ # /0 < $*"   

$$  $"  "      L     /0 G 

 /0 








DZ    '   $  %++ !     )  $    #    '   %   (

")  '        )    , '    $        ") +     " +  

>  $    "%    5   $  M     !   +'+ % 2 "  % "   ** $% " $"   2  $*"  DZ"1$%  $*"   $   $$   ? $ " L  2  "#%  +  / 0  NJK   / 0 - OPQRK   / 0 /

0 />0    1  5     :($ $  %  4 + "  #   * "*$*   /
0%     ("# 1   " S T ? "# $  (   # 5 U    ½½

/=0  1 "  !! #" * /0 -    V8  -    U -  WXKYV8 ! .$#! ;* L < 4 *"# $% 2$ Z " [  \   5 $$  #  V8  ?%   $     .     **       *"     

"%  " V8    "   < " V8   
 ! #" /M$0 * +      $    
$























 $     
$      $     

U - /    0 /]0 .$#! 6 "  -       % *  / 0 -    %   - IJK  .  .    .   U - U .    .U DZ "$$ '% U -  /WXKYV8  .    .WXKYV8  0 - /    0
!&' #" 3   $$    %    .  - 78K  ?$ 

/]0 4  "   (  "      !&' ##   $ $"# %    78K % 5 U  $     !2 $*"2 











½
















½


















. :
A   4;B9$    4;BC     '   /( $       +    $       ,  '     %    

  

          "           
ADZ& , + A    0




 $      ¦½     ) "$         

=

 #" .$   + 
    #   


!

 ## DZ
   # $
    $   %     

L

   $ ! 2' 3  ,  +'+ %4    '    $
 $

U

  +  

/ 0G 


  
 

/>0  /=0!    '
(

/)0  %

 ' ) +   5!6!

 #) 7   5!6  #  3   +
4     ½ ¼ $) %
$! /$ #    + 

'   /0  $     ½ /0 

            ++ #8

 #* 9'
 +'+ %  %
$!

/$
( 
(

%
$(  :
( #
 # 3
48

 #+  
   ' # #  +'

/ 0 - ) . ' . = . ' . '= . ] . ' , 
:  #       ! /$  $  / 0     8 ; '   -./01   -
$ 
(   ! DZ 
 #  ' # $-%% / 0    )' + % +  











 +'+ % 8

DZ%  ! &   + %    !          
      ,         % ! !%    %
 !  %!  DZ  %! %)  &DZ% &  % ! !%     !       . /   ' %'  % 0!1    &  . 2  '     %)  &   %% %  &   %!& '   &. /  &  %   %! %  

% !   &. 3   &    &%   %  ! )   4%  5   

  %
 %           1  6   !

) #"' 2 ?" U 2  #$ (5 < "*       L  :!  %  "   U 1 "# #%   $    15   L    " !2    







]

DZ # / 0    .     .    .  /

  0 /E0 ? $ 

$ 5  ! $*"!    / 0  .V8   / 0 -   .    /F0    / 0   OP   / 0 - /  0   .   

    / 0 -  / 0   / 0

78K   78K  /'0 ? $ "% *  4 +! $*" /E0 5  !% $$G  / 0         .        

/''0  / 0           .         ^ #( ( # "1 !5* * (     $ *"    $$   H  # 4  " _ C /'0 %  " 

/ 0 -   / 0 -  / 0 -  :@/  0/ 0 -  /'0 C% 1  "# #  "*$$ 6 "    (5 ("#  ""#   :@/  0 ? ("  $ " $1 # %   - '%   " 4  %    ! #% $ " $*"  5  !  !&' )" C  "#  "*$ 6 "%  !   "#  $%  ""# "    $!   "" #     $  $$% $ %  22 "    1$ " $!  $ 4 

"  '+' ( 4$%  "# 
 + # "      % (!  "   ( #  # _  $%  $*"  $ %     $$  " 

"# *    $$  #  $   5  " !      6 "     5$ $*"$    $# "*$ 6 "%  * $  #
 < (5 ("# ""#  < (   2 (!2 <  *%  (!"   '    !$ ' @ $1 (!#% $#  2 2    )  '
$)  " "*$%  ! (! !( !    ( #_ " $!  $%  4 * " #  !   DZ"1 #%  L  2  "#%  "$%  4      $$  # DZ #          < 4   $ 


























































































































E  %  !2  2    *"  /F0%  <4 5  ! ! /   "%  !0  $*"   :($    WXKY  / 0 / -  '    0 /')0  C * %  - ' / - .'0%  "  21        **          " /    %  0 < $   















1

!! )"

2

3

4

   -  /   .  0 / - '    0 










½

DZ #% " " % $$    $ $  2  /'0    3* "5 $$  $*  5  #  2!  /0 " /)0 ?  $  42 "     .%   $ < "%  *"    1$ "$$! : "#!   

$   "*
   ½  !! )#   -     -    ½ .$#! 3  78K   78K  %  9K  /0 -   //00   /   0

 "#!  "    < *"#! DZ"1$ " " %       "    ("1   "1"#$  " 5     3*   "       "1      /0 " /)0  $   ?  $ "   ½   .  %  $   %  *"    1$ "$$! : "#! ! 

$   "*
.$#!




  

¼



½



























¼



!! )) *     $      

U -  / .  .    .  0 








/'0

F .$#! DZ5  G     ½ U -   ½ .   .    .   .  

 $ )'  ) !  /'0 * * % " 5 

$# " % *  - %  * ** (5     $$  # ^ #% 

1  "#   "$$! )% (1$ %  U -  <   " $# $" /'0

"  - 
?"!   2 $$    *2 "12B  $ + "#!   

$$ +"# +  / 0 / 0  /78K   78K  0

/'>0  / 0  ""#  $"#   ("# "   /F0  $* (!# "(!$ 5  !$ $*"$ DZ #          < 5  ! " ! +  * B  2     /0 Z2  \ $$  9'$ +   5  $ $ "   !   "  .'  " /  0    / .0 OY7 /0  '  " /  0    / .0 /'=0 9'$ /: +    " / 0 !   " OY7 /0   OY7 /0 /']0   " /')0   $ ! %    - OY7 /0 *     ! )" DZ
 + /E0     $    
$  ¼





½







¼







½












































  












$     
$      $    ! 7+'

   

- OY7 ½ ½








/F0! .$#! 3$ "  $! '  "$$! ))
!&' )#  " % "    * $*"  "1  + "#* 

$ M$ $!  $ "#! * `  OO

+'   
 '( 

' !&' )) 6 "      + /0   OY7 /0

 ½   /']0  "  OY7 /0 -  /0 - /  0  / .0 /'E0 6 " (! $! $" ! "#  + /0% $ ! "   % $! (! "" (!  ( $ $! )' 

 











 )" <
 '$ /: + % $  #' 

 

aY  - ¼

,+ +  8


$%&'(    "   # )  $*"    " / 0  )# 2     ' '  U  
'  '$



')' $ (      )',  #  # $( , ! .$ -   =        , (!

 ))  
 + %$  %
$    $



    


 


 -
'     '
# $ $


   $
' $   












! > ' 

   $ 3+ %$4  # $
 $    ! /$ +  $   +$     

OY7 ½½/08 

6 7   1 & %    +  3&      & '   % % 8 !  !    &     '      
&  1  '   &     %       8 9 : %)            !

''


" 34& ?   "*(! b>b "*  4"* $ c$ "    " 5  !2  $*" $  " ?   "#  4 $ < "% %  $ < $ ("  (" # $ H! ( $*"        !   $ ?
    " / 0%  "G  /!0 -  /  !  0   /!0 -  /'F0  /!0 -  !
/ 0 /0  /!0 -  /       !  0     /!0  /!0   /'0 C$ + c$% $ +" " + " /
0% "   " $ (  /
0  /
0     /
0 :(" # " 4 + "1  " / 0%  * "! " $*" +B 2 2 " /
0 $1 $# !  *  ?$%   "#  !   " /
0  # $*G !! *" * !
/ 0   $  
 + +     " /! .0 - " /!  0! .$#! 6 "  /!0 - %         /0 DZ # "   B $ "  /'0 "%     /!0   /!0 "!  "  $ !  ^% *$    /!0  /!0  /!0 /  
 !  #0 1    $   $  *%   "  /
0  $"$ $
" ! 6 " 1 ! < ! "# $*"  %   /
0 $  !  "      
 !  #B *"  /'F0% 4       /
0 DZ4$ *$  /
0  /
0    "   $ / " '0   %   "    !
!! *# * !
/ 0  $   
     " /! .0  " /!  0 -  OY7 /0  .$#! 6 "  !   .'%   2
  ! +  $ $  $   " %  *$  /
0  /
0  2   $! %  " /
0 $#   ' ? " +"#*   "  2 (!$ ($

















































































'

 ! *" /c$0


OY7



- " / .0  " /  0 /)0 .$#! "  "# #   !5 "$$!   %  5    +  #

$$ 

 G  S" /! .0  " /!  0T

" /  0  " / .0 * $$      $ $ !  + " <  !$ "$  % 15$  / 0
!&' *" ^$#%   " + c$%  "#

  $! c$ (!"  5    1%       < 4 $*"!B

5    "# " # "# 2 !  #  5 A%  4 + $  (" *  " " 

$$ 1!  ! " $! ' d c$        !   +
 %  " 78K  -    / -  '    0



























 ! *# DZ
 %   : $-%% +  +
  $



?
  
   
! 7+'

OY7 ½ ½

- /

0


  & % %
   %


 +' & % %
   %
  #$       % %
   %
!

/

/0

0 .$#! DZ ("#2 
   /
0    $ * * " %
   DZ4$ " /. 0 - & /% %    % 0

" / 0 - & /% %      /'0 % 0 -   & /% %    % 0 /  " < 4  " #$% "5    "  $ ( %    % 0
:   ( #     + c$  ! Z  !2\ $*"    ? " 78K   78K  /!$ $!  $$ 0 " 4*  "#  $ + ! "*$ 6 "  + "  $%   1$ * $    G    -     78K   78K  />0 














 















































A    )   +   -     B4 ?   45    ) &  $            
$     

D  $  3        

   E %   "     $     


') M  $  "#* $! " "*$ <   "$ * *  "  :@/  0 <  (   !"   *  "  /'0 `     "  /'F0  /0%    $   +   "#! /1 40 !&' *# M     $1!  (   + c $ !&' *) Z ( c$% 2     2%   % *    "# !  %  (  *$  "!2 4 +  "!2 2
 + c$\ /DZe`(! 0  *" /$   $
?
  78K   78K  8 









 *# 2#
 #
 #' @!6   ' +  '

/ 0

  # ) $  +      ! DZ   - +  ' '  # ) $  +     !

;& 1  % <%=%    %   &'     :& !            &   )   !1    %'    

 &!     >&     

   % 

)          )  %)        % 4&'5      >  8 %)   

> ,4& && DZ # $*"!    "! /''0 6 "  - %       />0 $ G   / 0 - !  !

/=0   / 0 - /  !  0     /  !  0    .    /]0

! $%  !2%      1%     %   " *  4 + "  %      $1 $#  1 + ? !2%4 +!  "     $*"# $+!      /E0      "  " 4"$   $ ;

 @ 4$   !   ! ""# )  
 ? (    "  2$    !   (! $%   (" " * 




























































'

   $ *$$  $$ ""  !    "   2 "*$  ? "#$  !$ DZ "$ DZ # 4 +! $*" /E0 $5! $

 
     DZ2        %  $ /=0/]0%      $"#! 2  $*"   $*"     ./  ! 0    .     ./  ! 0    .   

 " * +

"1    "      "    52 4 +  ! "*$ " +   %   5 "*      $    4$ " $5 $

    4 +! % %    % $*" + c$ "  "5* $ $!  












































     

   

    

   !  "  # " 

!$ %  & !'% %(   #

 "  "   !  "  

DZ " * * Z2  \   $

   "  5$  4 + $ $*"   %  Z*" \  !%    Z"* $ \%

2   4 +! % !52 $*" + D" "*$ $ *  6 "   )%  $! A$ "#%  ! $*" 1 *" +%      "1 *     !!$ DZ"1  ( !2%    "#! $ c$ ((!   4  ""#! + !  ($  #  "%   ("  $ "  "  (  ("*"G 






'>

 ! +" .
 +  )'   '     %  %
    %
   
    '$  #$!

*" $$)''% "   * $*" " / 0 " /. 0 -  3 % * !% " / 0    " /. 0  %  $! $$ "

4 $"#!$ "$G " / 0 -   " /. 0 -  DZ      ! %  " + $ $"#     . 'B  + *" C  *     "%   % < *  M$  (2$ #%    # "  $   )'
3#  $  "*$  DZ     " *" #%  $*"  $   $$    1 *" +  / 0 - %    .    /% -   -  '    0 :     #' '  ' ') $-%% %  %   %  4 4 +!% "   "#!2% $* $#  " !  3$ ($% (" # $$    % $ "*" # " M  ( # "*$ !   "  " $%   " !$    $  $! /'0       1  4 $% 2 !2      (% !$ (  !  $+!   "  ""  #  `5 * "     2  G    5   (    2   ""   #%   $$  #  B    !2  5  !2 (  !2    $$  # 2  / - 0 D"*$    ( "# 4   G .$#!

























 ! +# DZ
  ! 7+'A

0  %   -  % -   +    $        - & /%    % 0   -   & /%    % 0 /F0 (0  %   -  % -   +       '   $   $    - & /%    %   0   -   '  & /%    %   0 /)0 







































F        G DZ   #      F        ,  G
,  ")       '        
 0       



'=

0  %   -  %   %    +    $        - & /%    %   0.'   -   & /%    %   0  ' /)'0 *0  %   -  %   %    +       '   ) $   $)   -     - & /%    %   0   -     & /%    %   0 /)0 0  %   -  % -   +       ' '
$   $   $    - & /%    %   0   -     & /%    %   0 /))0 .$#! DZ "  $*" + $ G    /
0 - %  
 %    /
0 - %  
 /
0 - % ? " /0 "  *" + ?  "#!2 "2  " ( $*"    %  1   (5  "# ? $$%  $! $$ "

"*$$ 6 "B +

   "1 (!#   "%  "# />0   " (  %  *  " "  $*"   "  <  #   " * $1" < (5$ ("#$ ""$  - :@/  0 Z  !2\ $*"  f  G '    /0 -  " /(0

/ 0 %  '    /0 -   % "2 / 0% /*0% /0 / 0 %  %  f 1 $!  "     "1  /0  $$    "  /'0 :    # /F0/))0 ? Z( $\ " / 0  " $*"     (5  "#   5   $ %  $           "  + c$%  1 $  $!   "# # $ ' " /(0% /*0  /0 (    2* $*" /0 6*

" "#   /0% * ' - 78K %  $ $!$ "#   $$!  DZ 4$    "    (5 ("# ""#  C2  4 +! %  %  $ %   $! ("* $ $ "  ? 2 />0    5   DZ4$ "   "* $*" *  ! #  1%  " "#  #%  # * " #%   #  "# #  $ 

















































































































































.     "      

'] !&' +" 5   + $1 %  %     $%   "  4"$ $

    *    "  (( <      !$ ($ "  $*"  @ %   "$ 4"$ $    ("# "    $ 2 + 









 +" DZ $
   

( ' +  @  B  '  )'   ' 

 -) +!

 +# ; %
$(

  *)+     $        $-%% ,+ +   #  ,   + 
  )    
! ; $ %
$( *)++ "  $    *)+   

+  '  
   #$ ;' ! C #  $
 : *)+8

 +) DZ '   )'  $   # $ DZ5  ! D65D A

 ,

-*)* . /001  ( .  .(  $23*4 .  ( ( (    !. .(      .  /001 23*4 ,  .(#

.



2)'    .  -   % 

/E0! /$ +  #


%
$ -*)*8 /$  
 :8 .  
( $
DZ$ 

DZ5 $$ +  $) # $!


 &   ! &   %%1&$       %  )       ( '  1!  &' % & & & %!           3 -  

    &' %      =%  %& /      % % - & %&  

1  & 8   1  &  

'E

= 4& !6& DZ  $     $*" /E0 5  !$ 4 +$    $+ "5  !G 

           

   

           
           
    






/)0

/4 +       2  " " %  $! "*$   -    - 0 +  !     
 $*"  :( $  ) *" ! $ 4 $+!%  !    !2  2 

"(+2 e*  #%   "$ "(+  "#  " < * "#! < 4"$ "  " :     DZ4$ ) -)    /)>0




























!! ," 2 +
  


- ) % - ))    % - ))  /)=0 .$#! :$$ "%  $+    "  ("  /E0% !  #    4 + $*"     ^ $$   $ $+!   2*"#$ % $ $ ;



   !$ !($  "$!2 4"$  ?     /=0/]0  "  " 4"$    %      $ 1  4  +!  < "5* $*" + DZ !   "(+ #  1!B $   2% $! "$ /  '0  /  '0$+  1 Z* +  \ !%     4 +$ $*"     DZ   1 +% $! $ +  *"# $+ %



































%    %         




    %      




   

  





   %    1 4 +! $*"  %   * % % 5*  *" H1 4"$ ( % $   $%  " !   ' '
,  /$1  25  "0 3 ( 






'F

2  "# ""#   - ) %    *" ! $! )  DZ4$ ) - % % % / - '     0

/)]0   " /)=0
 ! ," /; +0 0+ / 0 -   .     .    .  /     

B   0 /)E0 







































 +'  $ +' $+'  ' 
+   +

  


  A

 / - '     0 /)F0 .$#! f 1 $!     !  !5 "$$!  $ >'  >
!&' ," DZ"1$%  $*"  !      * "  "#2 $  "     C "$$! ='  $! > "%      # 2   2 %  ""#   - )  (  "#  DZ 4$% " /)0   1 $! >% $   / )   - 0     2   ""  #  * 5  *  DZ$ 1  )   /  - % )   - 0   2   ""  # ! $"  1!2  !2   !&' ,# " ! (" 1  "!$G " *% (! Z $#\$$% *!  $5  $*"     #%   " # "#   "* $ )  :  ( ("#5#   #  B  $! >' "%   $*" 2     #% ""#   4$ * ! "#    $ $  2$! $ ;

%   4$  *" ! $! )    "   (!  ! "  ?(5 $ ; + (

$! " $ #  " !2  2 < " 4* "  "# # 2$   !&' ,) ?'F'* De#A cA"1" *        $*" :   "%  "      $*" /)E0     $-%%    (2$    !"    )   )      )    

 "  

/0 )   )      )      $  ) 





















































D $     $    / !   

 f "  e#c /0 !*" 5% $  "  ; + /)F0% $   1   $# $!2     g ! ""#    4   15  / $ 1 (1$%    $ =0% " " 2 !"  "  /0 $* (!# (%  "  #   $    "#  /)F0  /0

 ," .$    )
   )
  
  $





 
 +      
$  $
#$

   #$    

) )  )
   
)
)
 




 ,# DZ
  )   ! ;'
  ('   $     # $
  
$8


$%&'( %  " DZ   $  ,) .$ 
 '   
    

/)0  - $-%% + / 0   .   .   .    /    

B   0 /'0
$%&'(  " /0 - %  $*"! /0  */0   /  0 / - 78K 0     ! "    !  $  ,* * /0  - $ %
$  '   ' /'0  %  '     $
(  


 
    
























       ' ) + )  ! DZ      $# (,     
  '
$  ' +   ,  $ %
$! DZ -
'
 ! D&ED D5D!

DZ &    %&   !     1  :   %%  &  &  

& % &'     ? %!  &     ! !    '     !  &

'

5&&

' ;$2 h% 7    [ G @% 'F=]  DZ   % >  +  [ G @% 'FE' ) H  ;% @ $ D% 0' 

 $)  -  ) %    ' $  + $)
 [ g# G ;:@3C @H3DZ% 'F)=  $  DZ% $   $  
 [ G @% 'F=] > H D;% /
  : +  [ iG ; 2% 'F>= = D2 @% H  % " $ )  )     [ g# G ;:@3C @H3DZ% 'F)E ]  $ @@% `( @;% DZ    

 '      ) %
$ [ 3! CD@%  =% 'FF E DZ  % /$ : #'
 [ G f*% 'F>F F DZ  % 0 $   ''   
' [ G @% 'F]> ' DZ  % 0 $ $  [ G @% 'F]= '' DZ" ;% * ;% F'    # [ G @% 'F]= ' ;"$ e%  D% /
 GDZA '+  ')' [ iG % 'F]F /

 ! H* b')b 1   " "1 $B  (" 4"$  ( "#   bb *  b'b      "2 $ *   $+ @("#  (j$ * b)b 1  ! 5 ( "

 2 (%  52     !2 $*"  M *  "  (("*    #B  *"      !" 1" kQXY8IJ IY7 ila9XaXY8IJ NaK8mJIk ? ( bb "*   $ ; +  Z 2 " \%     5 * ! 4 +"$ 2 *  !%  $ *"%  # %  "  "# # bb ? $* 2 b=]b #   ("$  ; + " +"!2 +  H* DZ  bE''b% $!  ? %  $ $*   $    !2 $*" %  2  " 1$ 5$ $ $ H* b'b $"#  "    " Z" $2\ :  (!! ! ! DZ5% $! H$ D  $    ! "  * *$$ %   + "   $$ 2 " *$ %  $1    # $$