AD VANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 28
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME
RODNEY J. ARKLEY A.
v. BARKER
JOHN
E. BEGG
J. M. BR...
40 downloads
2423 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
AD VANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 28
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME
RODNEY J. ARKLEY A.
v. BARKER
JOHN
E. BEGG
J. M. BREMNER
C.M. DONALD L. T. EVANS E. A. N. GREENWOOD J. HAMBLIN
R. D . HAUCK D . N . MAYNARD
P. L. MINOTTI N.
H. PECK
G . C.M.SAGE NEILC. TURNER INDRA
K.VASIL
I. F. WARDLAW
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared under the Auspices of the
AMERICANSOCIETY OF AGRONOMY
VOLUME 28 Edited by N. C . BRADY International Rice Research Institute Manila, Philippines
ADVISORY BOARD
w. L COLVILLE, CHAIRMAN G. W. KUNZE D. G. BAKER D. E WEIBEL G. R DUTT H J. GORZ M, STELLY, EX OFFICIO, ASA Headquarters 1976
ACADEMIC PRESS 0 New York
San Francisco
London
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT 0 I 976,w ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART O F THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN A N Y FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC O R MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR A N Y INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WlTHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Piftb Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road,
London N W l
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD
NUMBER:50-5598
ISBN 0-12-000728-2 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CONTENTS
............................ PREFACE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 28
ix xi
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
E . A. N . Greenwood
I . Introduction .......................................... 1 Quantitative Concepts of Nutrient Deficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Nitrogen Stress ........................................ 7 Factors Affecting Nitrogen Stress .......................... 14 Alternative Evaluators of Nitrogen Stress .................... 18 Applications .......................................... 28 Conclusions and Aspirations .............................. 34 References ............................................ 34
I1. 111. IV . V. VI . VII .
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
Rodney J . Arkley
I . Introduction: Objectives and Problems of Soil Classification
.....
I1. Numerical Taxonomy or Cluster Analysis of Soils .............. I11. Ordination of Soils .....................................
IV. Soil as an Anisotropic Entity .............................. V . Statistical Methods for Comparing Classification ............... VI . Conclusions and Evaluation ............................... References ............................................
37 39 54 59 63 64 68
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
D. N . Maynard. A. V. Barker. P . L.Minotti. and N . H .Peck I . Introduction .......................................... 71 I1. Hazards of Nitrate and Nitrite to Human Health ............... 72 I11. Factors Affecting Nitrate Accumulation ..................... 77
IV. Nitrate Concentrations in Vegetables ....................... V . Conclusions ........................................... References ............................................ V
99 113 114
vi
CONTENTS
THE PROGRESS. PROBLEMS. AND PROSPECTS O F PLANT PROTOPLAST RESEARCH
Indra K . Vasil I. I1. 111. IV. V.
Introduction .......................................... Isolation of Protoplasts .................................. Culture of Protoplasts ................................... Protoplasts and the Genetic Modification of Plants ............. TheFuture ........................................... References ............................................
119 120 126 135 152 153
CROP WATER DEFICITS
John E . Begg and Neil C.Turner
.......................................... ..................................... Measurement of Crop Water Status ......................... Effects of Water Deficits on Crop Growth and Development ..... Adaptation to Water Deficits .............................. Effects of Water Deficits on Yield .......................... Water Use Efficiency ....................................
I . Introduction
I1. Evapotranspiration
.
111
161 163 167 170 182 188 195
IV. V. VI . VII . VIII. Difference in Response of Plants Grown Under Controlled Conditions and in the Field ............................... 202 205 IX. Summary and Conclusions ............................... References ............................................ 207
USE OF TRACERS FOR SO1 L AND FERTILIZER NITROGEN RESEARCH
R . D. Hauck and J .M . Bremner I . Introduction .......................................... I1. Assumptions .......................................... 111. Advantages and Disadvantages of Nitrogen Tracer Techniques .... IV . Determination of Nitrogen Isotopes ........................ V. Sources and Cost of Nitrogen Tracer Materials ................ VI . Use of Nitrogen Tracer Materials ........................... VII . Perspective ........................................... References ............................................
219 223 225 226 239 242 260 261
CONTENTS
vii
NUCLEO-CYTOPLASM IC RELATIONSHIPS IN WHEAT
. .
G. C M Sage 1. Introduction
.......................................... I1. Cytoplasmic Variation in Wheat ........................... 111. The Genetics of Fertility Restoration ....................... IV . Cytoplasmic Effects Other than Male Sterility ................ V . The Biological Basis of Nucleo-cytoplasmic Interactions ......... VI . Cytoplasmic Variation in the Absence of Male Sterility ......... VII . Conclusion ........................................... References ............................................
267 268 274 286 290 295 296 297
ASPECTS OF THE COMPARATIVE PHYSIOLOGY OF GRAIN YIELD IN CEREALS
. .
L T Evans and I . F.Wardlaw
I . Introduction .......................................... I1. Origins and Adaptation .................................. 111. Reproductive Development ............................... IV. Root Growth and Nutrient Use ............................ V . Canopy Growth ........................................ VI . Leaf Photosynthesis .................................... VII . Canopy Photosynthesis .................................. VIII . Translocation ......................................... IX . GrainGrowth ......................................... X . Limiting Stages in the Life Cycle ........................... XI . Conclusion ........................................... References ............................................
301 303 305 310 315 317 323 329 335 340 349 350
THE BIOLOGICAL YIELD AND HARVEST INDEX OF CEREALS AS AGRONOMIC AND PLANT BREEDING CRITERIA
C. M . Donald and J . Hamblin
I . Introduction .......................................... 361 I1. The Relationship of Biological Yield. Grain Yield. and Harvest Index to Each Other and to Other Plant Characteristics ......... 364
viii
CONTENTS
111. The Influence of Environmental Factors ..................... IV. Biological Yield and Harvest Index as Criteria in Cereal Breeding . . V . Concluding Comments .................................. References ............................................ SUBJECTINDEX
.......................................
375 390 402 404 407
CONTRIBUTORS Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributionsbegin.
RODNEY J. ARKLEY (37), Department of Soils and Plant Nutrition, College of Natural Resources, University of California,Berkeley, California A. V . BARKER (71), Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts JOHN E. BEGG (161), CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, anbema, A.C.T., Australia J . M. BREMNER (219), Department of Agronomy, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa C. M. DONALD (361), Waite Agricultural Research Institute, University of Adelaide, South Australia, and Department of Applied Biology. University of Cambridge, England L. T. EVANS (301), Division of Plant Industry, CSIRO, Canbema, A.C. T.,Australia E. A. N . GREENWOOD (l), Division of Land Resources Management, CSIRO, Floreat Park, Western Australia J. HAMBLIN* (361), Waite Agricultural Research Institute, University of Adelaide, South Australia, and Department of Applied Biology, University of Cambridge, England R. D. HAUCK (219), Division of Agricultural Development, Tennessee Valley Authority, Muscle Shoals, Alabama D. N. MAYNARD (71), Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts P. L. MINOTTI (7 l), Department of Vegetable Crops, Cornell University,Zthaca, New York N. H. PECK (71), Department of Seed and Vegetable Sciences, New York State Agricultural Experiment Station, Geneva, New York G. C. M. SAGE (2671, Plant Breeding Institute, Cambridge, England NEIL C. TURNER (161), CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, Canbema, A.C.T., Australia INDRA K. VASIL (119), Department of Botany, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida I. F . WARDLAW (301), Division of Plant Industry, CSIRO, Canberra, A.C.T.. Australia
*Present address: Department of Agriculture, Perth, Western Australia.
ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE During 1976, an event occurred which is of great significance to all mankind. At some location, probably in one of the developing countries where population growth is high, a child was born, the world’s four billionth human being. T h ~ s event, which was easily predictable considering national birth and death rates, calls our attention to the ever-present race between population and food supplies. It gives reason for the increased focus of the world’s scientific community on food production and it justifies the attention that has been given by crop and soil scientists to this important human problem. Rising costs of energy are a second area of worldwide human concern, an area that has marked effects on man’s ability to feed himself. Modern agricultural technology, developed over a long period of relatively low energy costs, is generally high in its energy requirements. Sudden increases in energy costs have caused a reexamination of the high energy demanding concepts of modern agriculture and have accelerated attempts to obtain high food production rates using practices with modest energy requirements. This volume contains reviews of the research contributions of crop and soil scientists to the solution of each of these worldwide problems. Attention is given to nitrogen, an element essential for crop production and an element whose supply is markedly affected by energy costs. Nitrogen is supplied either through biological fixation in the field or by commercial fertilizers. In either case, there is need for research findings on this element, its efficiency of utilization and its influence on crop production and crop physiological processes. Three review articles on nitrogen are found in this volume. One deals with nitrogen stress in plants, one with the use of tracers in nitrogen research, and a third with nitrate accumulation in plants. Cereal crops are carrying and will likely continue to carry a major share of the burden of food supply, especially in the developing countries. Three articles in this volume focus on the cereals. Emphasis is given to contributions relating t o their genetic improvement and to their physiology. A review of statistical techniques used in soil classification is very timely and should be useful in studies to integrate soil and crop performance information. Likewise, the article on crop-water relations summarizes work on moisture stress in plants and provides background information for draught-alleviating practices. Lastly, the review article on protoplasts calls attention to an exciting new area of research which will likely be pursued as we attempt to increase the yield potential of crop plants.
xi
xii
PREFACE
Volume 28 continues the tradition of the past in that it calls upon scientists from different national and disciplinary backgrounds and it covers a variety of topics of interest to crop and soil scientists.
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS E.A.N. Greenwood Division of Land Resources Management. CSIRO. Floreat Park. Western Australia
..................................................
I . Introduction I1. Quantitative Concepts of Nutrient Deficiency ......................... A . Classic Approach to Nutrient Response ........................... B . Nutrientstress .............................................. 111. Nitrogen Stress ................................................ A . Definition .................................................. B . Measurement ............................................... IV. Factors Affecting Nitrogen Stress .................................. A Supply .................................................... B . Demand ................................................... V . Alternative Evaluators of Nitrogen Stress ............................. A . LeafNitrogenFractions ....................................... B . LeafElongation ............................................. C. LeafArea .................................................. D. Carbon Dioxide Exchange Rate ................................. E . Conclusions ................................................ VI . Applications ................................................... A . AgronomyandEcology ....................................... B . Stress Physiology ............................................ C. Modeling ................................................... VII . Conclusions and Aspirations ...................................... References ....................................................
.
1 2 3 6 7 7
a
14 14 16 18 18 21 25 27 28 28 29 32 33 34 34
I . Introduction
This article is about the quantitative measurement of nitrogen deficiency in plants . It is not a general review of the extensive field of nitrogen nutrition . It must occur to many agronomists to ask why water stress can appear to be so precisely measurable. whereas for nutrient stress we are limited to such broad terms as clinical. subclinical. severe. and mild Our dependence on these qualitative terms reflects an extraordinary weakness within the discipline of plant nutrition in quantifying nutrient deficit You will say at once that there are valid reasons why water deficit must be easier than nutrient deficit to determine And I will agree My criticism is not directed to the greater challenge. but to the meager evolution within the discipline to deal with it . To some extent the cause may be historical This
.
.
.
.
.
1
2
E. A. N. GREENWOOD
century has seen classic plant nutrition engrossed in the search for essential elements, the physiological role, availability in the soil, the clinical symptoms of deficiency and toxicity, and the response of plants to the quantity and chemical composition of nutrient supply. Plant water research was, of course, not concerned with essentiality and diagnostic critera. Whatever the reason, water deficit is commonly defined in terms of the physical stress of the water, whereas nutrient deficiency has come to be defined in terms of the plant’s response to the added nutrient. Consider the succinct definition proposed by Goodall and Gregory (1947): “a plant is deficient in a certain element if supplying that element to the plant in a suitable form causes an increase in yieM [my italics] , this effect being specific to the element in question.” It follows from this definition that in order to quantify the degree of deficiency one can measure the magnitude of the response of the plant. Hence the universal methods by which agronomists seek an estimate of nutrient deficit are based on plant response. If the increase in yield itself after application of fertilizer is not measured, then the soil or plant tissue might be analyzed in order to predict the response, the predictor having been previously calibrated against a response curve. Although the term nutrient stress has been in limited use for a number of years, I am not aware of any exposition of definitions and philosophy. Thus, an attempt is made in Section I1 to state in agronomic terms some basic considerations that agronomists may well accept as axiomatic in the field of water stress, but which have been ignored in the field of nutrient stress. They are my current, personal viewpoints and all of them are arguable (by author as well as reader). Regardless of whether you agree, your constructive participation will certainly assist the advancement of this aspect of agronomy.
II. Quantitative Concepts of Nutrient Deficiency
The term “stress” as used in plant science needs some clarification. It is a broad term that can be defined from more than one point of view; that is, as the status of the stress factor or as the effect of that status on the growth of the plant. For example, Taylor (1968) considered water stress to be the physiological condition of water in the plant, although a plant is often said to be under water stress whenever the conditions of water are unfavorable to plant growth. Because of this ambivalence of meaning, Taylor considered water stress too broad a term to quantify numerically. Hsiao (1973) confines the meaning of water stress to deficit, which is clearly separate from the plant responses which it induces. Central to the issue of evaluating nutrient stress, then, is to decide whether it is to be defined as deficit or as induced response. My current attitude (I have not always held this view) is that nutrient stress should remain a quantitative concept of nutrient deficiency-like growth, it is not measurable. Our efforts, as with water stress, should be directed toward
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
3
developing measurable parameters of stress which can be used for its evaluation. It would be no departure from convention to call such evaluations “nutrient stress,” for we do not hesitate to invest increments in biomass with the name of “growth rate.” A vital rule must be to indicate which evaluator of nutrient stress is being used. If we allow these first steps to be taken, some difficult problems in estimating nutrient stress can be resolved. But, as these steps are only preliminary, they can be readily retraced should the ground rules be found unacceptable. If the evaluation of nutrient stress is to be analogous to water stress, then we would have to measure such parameters as relative nutrient content and the chemical potential of the nutrient in the plant in some way. Assuming, for the argument, that it is feasible to do this, it would seem that the situation is rather different to what it is for water stress. We take for granted that the upper limit to the water content of a plant cell (full turgor) closely coincides with the water contents at which zero water potential and optimum plant growth occur. But, as is evident from the ability of plants to take upluxury and toxic quantities of nutrients, the upper limit to the nutrient content of a plant cell is well above that required for optimum plant growth. While the lack of a reference point is a major constraint to the concept of relative nutrient content, it is not an objection to the use of chemical potential. It simply implies that the relationship between plant performance and chemical potential would not be so simple, or perhaps as general, as it is in the special case for water stress. The main barrier to the use of chemical potential for estimation of nutrient stress seems to be that it is not yet a feasible proposition to obtain a meaningful measurement of activity of specific ions in plant tissue. And so, for the present, it becomes necessary to fall back to suitable parameters of current plant response. How appropriate to this specific purpose are the classic approaches to the evaluation of nutrient response, viz., nutrient response curves and critical concentrations?
A. CLASSIC APPROACH TO NUTRIENT RESPONSE
This section starts with response curves because the concept dominates the thinking of agronomists about the severity of nutrient deficiency. The only critical criterion of the severity of a deficiency which can be derived from a response curve is the magnitude of the reduction in yield below the maximum, This implies that, for the evaluation of a deficiency, it is unnecessary to know the form of the response curve. The practical significance of this point will be taken up again later in this section. With respect to our present purpose, the main weakness of the nutrient response curve is that it fails to deal with changes in response which inevitably occur in the field with time. The curve is the resultant of all the curves that might have been constructed between sowing and harvesting. Maybe an agron-
4
E. A. N.GREENWOOD
omist does not always want to know more than the final outcome. But sometimes he does need to know what has happened in order to understand how the final response developed-particularly if the results were unexpected. A moment’s consideration shows that responses do vary with time, even to the point of changing sign. These variations in response arise from changes in the supply of the nutrient and the demand for it by the plant. The nutrient supply to the plant may change with time because of uptake by the plant, or as a result of gaseous or leaching losses, chemical reactions, or microbial activity. When fluctuations in nutrient supply are large, the original levels of fertilizer applied inaccurately represent nutrient supply. Further, efficient uptake of fertilizer by the plant implies that the supply of applied fertilizer must approach zero with time, and so response might be expected to decline with this depreciation in treatment strength. The demand by the plant for a given nutrient also changes with time since it is influenced by the changes in all other environmental factors that control plant growth-other nutrients, water, radiation, etc. For example, the amount of nitrogen required by a plant now may be quite large if the environment is favorable for growth, whereas it may be small if, say, the temperature or the supply of available phosphorus is low. In addition to these influences on demand there is the compensating effect of plant size. Plants that response positively to the higher initial levels of the nutrient will, because they are bigger sinks, make larger demands on other nutrients or water. These may in turn become limiting, thereby curtailing the initial response. More certainly, the large plants will intercept so much light that the lower leaves will receive suboptimal illumination. Another important influence on the response of deficient plants is age. The responsivity of plants to a deficient nutrient declines with ontogenetic drift, particuarly in annuals where response approaches zero with maturity. Two conclusions follow from these remarks: nutrient response curves give very little information about the current intensity of deficiency, and in some cases they may also be quite misleading. From the foregoing discussion it is clear there will have to be some integration of supply and demand. A familiar approach has been to determine the concentration of the nutrient in the plant, arguing that the plant itself is the actual integrator of supply and demand. The graphic expression of this approach is to plot yield against nutrient concentration in the tissue (Fig. 1). Refinements are made by selecting the yield of a specific product and the chemical determination may be of some sensitive compound in sensitive tissue. In Fig. la the yield is beet weight, the compound determined is nitrate nitrogen, and the tissue is petiole. A frequent, but not universal, characteristic of the relationship between yield and chemical composition is that, for severe deficiency, yield increases linearly with increase in concentration with a well-defined steep slope, whereas at sufficiency, the curve flattens and becomes poorly defined (Fig. 1). If the change
"Mature" Petioles
A A
A
0
i 20
-
N0.25
I
I
0
I
1
1
16,000
8.000
I
1
1
24,000
Nitrate Nitrogen (ppm) b
100
'
0
128
0
8
8 256
A 80
A 96
0
A
B
0512 88
A
8
0
0
~4 L ~ l l l ~ ~ 1
0
0
2,500
1 .m
5,000
7,500
1
1
1
1
1 0 , ~12,500 15,000 17,500 20,OOO
Nitrate-N In Blade 1 (ppm)
FIG. 1. Relation of yield and nitrate nitrogen in plant tissue. (a) Weight of sugar beet and nitrate in petioles (after Ulrich, 1950). (b) Dry weight of Italian ryegrass and nitrate in leaf blade 1. dy/dx = 1 at approximately 1000 ppm nitrate-N. After Hylton etal. (1964).
6
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
in slope is abrupt, a “critical concentration” is discernible at the discontinuity, above which there is little increase in yield and below which yield is greatly reduced. It is not always easy to locate the critical point because of the variability of the data or because the curve may be broad and continuous. In the latter case, a numerical definition of the critical concentration can be based on the slope of the curve. For example in Fig. l b a slope of dy/dx = 1 has been adopted by Hylton et al. (1964) as critical. It is a step toward numerically quantifying the degree of deficiency, for a continuous change in slope can provide a continuous numerical scale. There are two serious weaknesses in the use of the slope of the yield concentration curve as a continuous indicator of the intensity of deficiency, as distinct from a single critical point. First, as seen in Fig. 1, the deficient arm of the curve shows little change in slope. Second, it is well known that the critical concentration declines with age and that in annuals this decline is precipitous after flowering. As for the response curve, a whole suite of curves like Fig. l a can be obtained for successive ages. Nevertheless it can be a most useful technique for estimating deficiencies in highly standardized crops (e.g., Ulrich, 1950). The critical concentrations of nutrients in plants is the main form of reference to nutrient status to be found in the literature. Extensive use is made of the reference tables compiled by Chapman (1966). For more specific information, agronomists turn to their colleagues in plant nutrition for interpretation of “spot” chemical analyses. The persistent attraction of such information lies in the certainty that below an accepted concentration in the plant a nutrient will be severely limiting, and that usually there is no better information available. It seems paradoxical to make such a claim in face of the vast literature on the use of plant analyses as a tool for assessing the nutritional status of plants. The problem is that although the concepts seem simple, the results must be qualified, as with response curves, by strong interactions with time. This aspect is discussed by Smith (1962) in his comprehensive and lucid review of tissue analysis.
B. NUTRIENT STRESS
It is evident that response curves and tissue analyses will not provide a satisfactory basis for using plant response as an indicator of nutrient status. We ought now to return to the definition of deficiency proposed by Goodall and Gregory (see Section I), and develop a proposition for nutrient stress. For it seems reasonable to argue that if it is acceptable to base a definition of nutrient deficiency on the yield response to a dose of the nutrient, then a quantification of this response should provide an acceptable basis for nutrient stress. Goodall and Gregory used yield (presumably of dry matter) as the criterion of response. But other criteria can be envisaged such as size (e.g., height, leaf area), or a
E. A. N. GREENWOOD
7
process (e.g., carbon dioxide exchange rate), or any other partial expression of plant growth which can be measured readily. The problem with this choice is that each parameter of growth has its own functional relationship with deficiency which would in turn give different estimates of nutrient stress. The use of the full expression of growth itself for these purposes is not possible since growth is not’ measurable, as pointed out by Arnott et al. (1974) in their introduction on the measurements of “growth.” Setting aside the choice of growth parameter until Section V, let me show what can be done with dry weight. The first task will have to be the development of a reference point to represent zero stress. It is implicit in the nutrient response curve and in the tissue concentration curve that the highest yield obtained under the circumstances represents the complete absence of the deficiency. This circumstantial maximum is the standard against which the degree of deficiency at lesser yields is judged. It was pointed out in Section 11, A that one does not need to know the form of the response curve in order to evalute a deficiency. What is required is the relationship of the yield of the deficient plant to the yield of the plant at the circumstantial maximum. It is necessary also to establish that maximum yield has been obtained. In other words, a numerical value for deficiency can be derived from the shortfall in yield relative to the circumstantial maximum yield. This is the crucial point on which the whole of the remainder of this article is based. There is a further point to recall from the criticism of yield response curves in Section 11, A-an inability to indicate current response. This shortcoming can be easily dealt with by measuring current growth rate instead of the accumulated yield of dry matter. If all these considerations are adopted, the current intensity of deficiency of a nutrient-nutrient stress-can be evaluated as the proportion by which the growth rate of the plant or crop is limited by that nutrient under the prevailing conditions. This definition needs to be qualified by the parameter of growth rate used-in this case, dry weight. The transformation of these ideas into a workable technique will be the objective of Section I11 which will be confined to the specific case of nitrogen stress. At this point also there will be a change in emphasis from a critique to a review of the subject. I l l . Nitrogen Stress
A. DEFINITION
Nitrogen stress is a quantitative estimate of the intensity of current nitrogen deficiency in a plant or crop. It can be evaluated as the proportion by which the growth rate of the plant falls short of maximum growth rate attained with a
8
E. A. N.GREENWOOD
nonlimiting supply of nitrogen over the period when stress is being measured. For this representation of nitrogen stress, Greenwood, Goodall, and Titrnanis (1965) used the symbol SN when it was made on a biomass basis. The relative shortfall can be expressed as a percentage, i.e., (prowth rate at maximum N response)-(growth rate at deficiency) SN = 100
growth rate at maximum N response
(1)
For example, if the growth rate of the deficient crop is 7 g/m2/day and 10 g/m2/day when it is given a nonlimiting dose of nitrogen, then nitrogen stress would be 100[(10-7)/10] = 30%. SN has some broad similarities with relative water content, for which the weight of a leaf deficient in water is compared with its weight after it has been brought to a standard, nonlimiting water content. In order to put this expression into practice, it is necessary to decide precisely what is meant by growth rate and how to find the current limitation of it by nitrogen.
B. MEASUREMENT The split-plot technique is basic to all methods so far devised for estimating
SN. At the time SN is to be measured, one subplot is left untreated and the other is given sufficient nitrogen to make nitrogen nonlimiting. Current growth rate is then measured in the untreated subplot, and the maximum growth rate that can be attained by adding nitrogen is measured in the other subplot. 1. Growth Response There are two conventional ways of expressing growth rate on a dry weight basis. Symbol Crop growth rate
C
1 dW Relative growth rate - Wdt
R
Working formula
In W2-ln W 1 t2 - t 1
Units
g/g/day
where W1 and W 2 are the dry weights at time tl and t 2 , respectively. The numerical value of SN obtained may be influenced by which expression is used. Broadly speaking, C is appropriate for crops or swards with a closed canopy and R is appropriate for spaced plants. In order to distinguish which form of growth rate has been used for estimating SN,the appropriate symbol can be used as a
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
9
subscript, i.e., SNC or SNR. The expressions for SN then become: SNC =
100 [(cM-C)/cMl
SNR = 100 [ ( R M - R ) / ~ V I
(2) (3)
where C or R is the growth rate in the control subplot and CM or RM is the growth rate in the subplot to which nitrogen has been added. Equation (3), the one originally proposed by Greenwood et LIZ. (1969, has been used consistently in publications on nitrogen stress. Nevertheless, as indicated above, it is not necessarily the most appropriate equation. Relative growth rates were originally adopted as a compromise in the interests of general application. The problem, briefly, is the exponential character of plant growth in unclosed canopies. Under steady conditions, the daily increment in weight increases with plant size, with the implication that the magnitude of the response to nitrogen is confounded with the weight of the plant. More specifically, when one wishes to compare the responsivity of two plants of different size due to different treatments or age, a bias is introduced. The bigger plant will have the bigger potential response in absolute terms. If the exponent of growth were constant then the bias could be exactly overcome by using relative growth rate. Although R does change less than C over the life of a crop by an order of magnitude, its change is appreciable. Operationally there is no difference between using SNC and SNR,for they both require the same primary data, W 1and W2.The real dilemma is that both C and R are nonideal over the whole life of the crop. And there seems no way of deciding which of them is to be preferred, for young crops behave as a community of spaced plants until the canopy is closed. Even if a working rule is adopted such that R is appropriate for crops with LA1 < 1 and C for crops with LA1 > 1 (LA1 = leaf area index), we would be well aware of a very broad transition zone in which neither R nor C would be fully appropriate. We must conclude that the approach to plant stress through dry weight response cannot be taken without some bias. The importance of the bias can be gauged by comparing SNC and SNR derived from the same dry weight data. This can be seen in Fig. 2c for a situation supposedly favoring SNR. The difference between the two curves is small at the extremes but large in the middle portion. In the case of wheat, the real situation does not seem to be as bad as it sounds from these considerations. In Fig. 3, SNR is plotted against SNC from two sets of data. One is the pot data used for Fig. 2c. The other is a reworking of the field data of Halse etal. (1969) in which SN was estimated at four stages from 4 to 16 weeks (ear emergence) with LAI ranging from about 0.1 to 2.5. The one curve fits both sets of data (R2 = 0.995). Three important points follow: age or LA1 has not affected the relationship between SNR and SNC;SNR is neither more nor less appropriate than SNC ;and it is a simple matter to convert SNRto SNC or vice versa. It can be seen from Fig. 3 that because the intercept is close
u
0
2
4
6
N Supply (mM1
8
1
0
.02 0
2
4
6
N Supply (mM)
8
10
0
2
4
6 N Supply (mM1
8
10
FIG. 2. Four expressions of response by wheat to nitrogen supply between the third and fiith week after emergence. (a) Yield of dry matter; (b) relative growth rate ( R ) and crop growth rate (0;(c) nitrogen stress based on R and on C. Data are from Greenwood (1966).
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
11
80
40
20
0 0
20
60
40
80
100
sNC(%)
FIG. 3. Relationship of nitrogen stress in wheat based on relative growth rate, Sm, to nitrogen stress based on crop growth rate, SNC. Points denoted as are from Fig. 2(c). Other points are derived from Halse et 01. (1969)from a field crop sampled between 4 and 7 weeks (A), 6 and 9 weeks (A), 10 and 13 weeks (+) and 13 and 16 weeks (x) after sowing. ~ derived from all points and accounts for The curve y = 3.55 + 0.25% + 0 . 0 0 6 0 6 ~was 99.5% of the variance.
to zero, and, for subclinical levels of nitrogen deficiency only, the quadratic term can be ignored, the relationship of SNR to SNCcan be simplified to SNR = 0 . 7 5 ~ These ~ . remarks apply to wheat; they may not hold for other species, particularly dicotyledons. A useful reference point is the value of SN at which nitrogen deficiency symptoms begin to develop. In all published work with grasses and cereals this Point Occurs at SNR = 40% (SNC = 60%). This section has dealt with growth response only in terms of dry weight. Other parameters of growth rate are considered in Section V.
2. Response Interval Ideally, growth rates on the control and the plus-nitrogen subplots should be measured as quickly as possible after the plants have responded to the addition of nitrogen. This is because current response is required and SN may be changing rapidly. In practice there is a lag period between application of the nonlimiting dose of nitrogen and its entry into the roots and leaves even in solution culture
12
E. A. N. GREENWOOD
where immediate uptake of nitrogen is ensured. Bouma (1970a) measuring both leaf area and carbon dioxide exchange rate (CER) on subterranean clover at 2-day intervals could clearly detect a nitrogen response after 2 days. Wolf and Greenwood (unpublished data) used a much shorter time interval and measured the leaf elongation rate (L), and CER of expanding and mature leaves of wheat seedlings in light and in the dark. They found that dark respiration responded to added nitrogen in 2-7 hours but the response was small and insensitive. The CER of mature and expanding leaves responded after 22 hours, and a similar time lag was taken by L for elongating leaves. Full response by AL occurred after 48 hours, whereas CER required more than 72 hours. There was no evidence of any temporary toxicity when the nitrogen supply (as ammonium nitrate) was raised from 1 'to 20 mEq N/liter. An example of one of the several response runs is given in Fig. 4. From the foregoing evidence, it seems that at least 2-3 days should elapse between applying nitrogen and commencing to measure the response. In practice, as agronomists will appreciate, it is difficult to get accurate estimates of dry weight increments in less than a week. This is because field sampling is imprecise and because the variance of the increment W2-W, is about twice the variance of a single dry weight measurement. In addition to this we are measuring differences between increments on one subplot and increments on another. Thus the variance of SN is high. 80
0 0
-8
I
60
f
G e
40
8
2 20
t
i Dark
0
20
Dark I
I
0
40
1
60
1
80
Hours
FIG. 4. Apparent change in nitrogen stress in deficient wheat seedlings immediately after the nonlimiting dose of nitrogen was given to alternate matched plants. Successive values of rates of elongation (L)and carbon dioxide exchange rate Q of the emerging second leaf were substituted into Eqs. (4) and (6) in the text. Developing response is indicateli by rising slopes and the attainment of full response by flat slopes. Replication was X 4 . From unpublished data by Wolf and Greenwood.
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
13
My experience is that a growth interval of at least 10-14 days is required to get meaningful and reliable differences between growth rates on the subplots when these are expressed as dry weights. This is far from being instantaneous. If SN is changing rapidly, only an average value over the time interval can be used. Rapid changes in SN do occur naturally. Power (1971) reported an increase in SNR from 4 to 73% in bromegrass within 3 weeks. On the other hand, there is an advantage in the field in having a fairly long time interval over which SN is being estimated, for it helps to integrate the day-to-day variations in weather which may be of little interest in themselves. Of course, where one wishes to establish relationships between stress and the environment a short-term response would be welcomed. Alternative, short-term, nondestructive methods for estimating stress are described and evaluated in Section V.
3. The Nonlimiting Supply of Nitrogen
SN can be estimated without invoking any assumptions as to the form of the response surface. It requires only the values for the actual growth rate and the growth rate with nitrogen nonlimiting. Since the response curve (i.e., the section of the response surface at prevailing levels of factors other than nitrogen supply) generally has an extensive plateau around the optimum, high precision in the choice of nonlimiting nitrogen levels is not necessary. In cases where there is adequate information available (Power, 1971), one estimate of a nonlimiting nitrogen supply level is sufficient. Otherwise, at least two different levels should be used in order to judge whether the deficiency has been completely removed and whether toxicity has been avoided. The following working rules are useful: when the two “nonlimiting” levels of nitrogen do not produce growth increments that are significantly different from each other, then the increments are averaged to give a best estimate of growth rate with nitrogen nonlimiting; when the difference between them is significant but small, the larger value is taken for nitrogen nonlimiting; when the difference between them is large, then the data are abandoned. Significant growth differences for the two levels of nitrogen selected can be easily avoided provided that some precautions are taken. These precautions can be generalized: very young seedlings and heavily defoliated plants require much lower levels of nitrogen for maximum response than do older and intact plants; for the former, temporary toxicity may occur, particularly if nitrogen is supplied in the ammonium form. 4. Operational Procedures For the estimate of SN by destructive dry weight harvest, a multi-split-plot technique is required. A quartet of matching subplots or quadrat areas is selected. Each of the four subplots is assigned at random to one of the following
14
E. A. N. GREENWOOD
procedures. Dry weight, W1,
is determined at the beginning of the test interval tl and, similarly, W z is obtained at the end of the interval tz . The actual growth increment of the crop is computed from these two values. Meanwhile, at r ,each of the remaining two subplots is given a different “nonlimiting” application of nitrogen and is harvested at tz . From the two dry weights for these subplots the value for W M is obtained. The growth increment of the crop with nitrogen nonlimiting is obtained from W land W M . In the field, if the soil is wet throughout the root zone, the nonlimiting dose of nitrogen can be applied in solution using the equivalent of say only 2 mm of artifical rain in order to avoid disturbing the water regime. A similar amount of nitrogen-free water must also be added to the W z subplot. Where the surface of the soil is dry due to a short and perhaps unimportant absence of rain, then a decision must be made either to wait for rain or to add sufficient water with the nitrogen to simulate rain which could be expected to fall. Again, if water is added it should include Wz.In either case the value for SN would apply to situations where water is not an important limiting factor. In cases where it is realized that water is an important limiting factor, albeit unevaluated, but where rain falls during the growing season, another technique is available. Since it is unlikely that in these circumstances an argonomist would want to know the importance of nitrogen as a limiting factor without similar information for water (though few have sought it), the technique used by Power (1971) can be most effectively employed. This involves the use of supplementary water as well as nitrogen, and it will be discussed in Section VI. IV. Factors Affecting Nitrogen Stress
Nitrogen stress can be considered as a concept that integrates the rate of nitrogen supply with all the other factors essential to growth: genetic, ontogenetic, nutritional, environmental, symbiotic, and other factors. It follows that a change in nitrogen stress may be brought about through variation in either the supply of nitrogen or in any of these other determinants of growth. The following is a review of the limited experimental evidence on factors affecting nitrogen stress. A. SUPPLY
Curves relating SNR and SNC to nitrogen supply for wheat between weeks 3 and 5 are given in Fig. 2c. In this example, both curves lead to a credible
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
15
extrapolation to 100%stress (no net increment in dry weight) at zero introgen supply, and, of course, they both reach zero stress (no response to nitrogen) as the nitrogen supply approaches the nonlimiting level. In nutrient culture work, it is usual to make some attempt to keep the concentration of nitrogen in the solution fairly steady by periodic or by continuous replacement. But where only a single application is given, say at the beginning of a pot experiment, the progressive depletion of the applied nitrogen must result in an increase in SN ,other factors being held unchanged. In the field, marked fluctuations in nitrogen supply in both directions may occur. On the one hand, these may be leaching and gaseous losses and, on the other hand, all those factors such as temperature and wetting and drying which may control the rate of microbial production of available nitrogen in the soil. Some practical perspective is given by the work of Halse et ul. (1969) who grew a wheat crop in a nitrogen-deficient sandy soil (average annual rainfall, 390 mm) and applied nitrogen at three rates at sowing: nil, 56 kg/ha, and 112 kg/ha, the last also receiving two further applications of 112 kg/ha. These treatments gave grain yields of 900, 1800, and 3000 kg/ha, respectively. SNR was determined on the nil and 56 kg/ha treatments. On the nil treatment SNR remained at 48% for several weeks and then fell to 14% at the late boot stage. The application of 56 kg (kglha) almost eliminated stress during the first few weeks, but by floral initiation it had reached 23%before falling to 5% (Table I). These results were obtained in the Mediterranean climatic zone of southern Australia during the growing seasons of autumn, winter, and spring.
TABLE I Effect of Nitrogen Fertilizer and Plant Age on Nitrogen Stress (SNR) in a Wlieat Crop' Nitrogen applied Weeks after sowing
Nil
56 kg/ha %i
4-7 6-9 10-13 13-16
48i1 47il 26i5 14i7
SE
6i2 23i3 11i4 5i8
'Adapted from Hake e l al. (1969).
16
E. A. N. GREENWOOD
B. DEMAND The age and ontogeny of a plant can greatly influence the magnitude of SN. Greenwood and Titmanis (1968) found that for annual ryegrass grown on a constant nitrogen concentration of 1 mM, S N increased ~ from 10% at 2 weeks after emergence to 11% at week 3, to 17% at week 4, and to 32% at week 5. The explanation could be that, as the daily increment in dry weight increases with age, the demand for nitrogen must increase. If the supply is fixed in concentration and inadequate, the shortfall in supply, whence stress, must also increase. At a much later stage, individual axes of the plant produce flowers and become less capable of response to nitrogen in the sense of net increment of dry weight-at least in more determinate species. This implies, particularly for annuals, that SN must approach zero as the plant approaches maturity. These trends are evident in Tables I and 111. Light will increase SN provided that light intensities are below the optimum for plant growth. Table I1 records some unpublished results for wheat seedlings. When the potential growth rate of a plant is limited by other nutrients as well as nitrogen, then an increase in the supply of those nutrients ought to increase SN. A very clear demonstration of this point with respect to sulfur and phosphorus can be inferred from the data of Bouma and Dowling (1967). They showed increasing responses (whence stress) of leaf area to nitrogen in TrifoZium subferraneum. For example, on a very low supply of inorganic nitrogen, values of stress are 25%, SO%, and 70% for sulfur supplies of 0.125,1.0, and 8.0 ppm. In computing these values, I have taken the highest supply of nitrogen as being nonlimiting, which is good enough for this exercise.
TABLE I1 Effect of Shading on Nitrogen Stress (SNC) at lS"/lO"C in Wheat
N fllpply (mM)
Unshaded
Shaded
2 4 6
42 17
31 11 4
13
NOTE: Plants were grown in a naturally lit glasshouse with noon light intensities of 45,000 (unshaded) and 18,000 lx (shaded). Replication was X 7.
17
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
Power (1971) studied the interaction between wafer sfress and nitrogen stress on bromegrass in the northern Great Plains of the United States. He found, over a range of conditions, that the plant stress caused by each of these two limiting factors was roughly additive. To give one instance, the value of nitrogen stress (SNR)as obtained by making nitrogen nonlimiting was 24%.The value of water stress (SWR) as obtained by making water nonlimiting was 32%. But when nitrogen and water were both made nonlimiting, the value of plant stress obtained was 54%. This implies that as water becomes more limiting the value of SN declines. Further results are displayed in Table VI. Defoliation, whether by cutting or by grazing, might be expected to reduce SN at low values of LAI when a reduction in photosynthetic area might be expected to limit potential growth during the recovery period. Greenwood and Titmanis (1968) established this point experimentally with young swards of annual ryegrass in pots with clipping, and in the field with sheep. The particular defoliation regimes used reduced SNR from 32 to 19% in the pot experiment and from 11 to 3%in the grazing experiment. These examples probably underestimate the immediate effect of defoliation on SN since the latter was, of necessity, estimated during the ungrazed recovery period. One of the general, and important, effects of cultivation is to increase the supply of available nitrogen to a crop. This should result in a reduction of stress provided that there is a deficiency of nitrogen and that cultivation does not affect other limiting factors. The situation is likely to vary with soil type and other circumstances. The integration of all these factors by the crop can be expressed, with reference to nitrogen, as SN. Table I11 shows that the effect of cultivating sandy loam was to reduce the subsequent values of SNR in a wheat crop. This will be discussed further in Section VI,A.
TABLE 111 Effect of Age and Cultivation on Nitrogen Stress (SNR) in Wheata Nitrogen stress (%) Cultivation treatment
Wk after emergence: 3-6 13
Nil Conventional
6-9 26,
9-12 13
*
***
ns.
5
17
10
Adapted from Greenwood e?al. (1970).
18
E. A. N. GREENWOOD V. Alternative Evaluators of Nitrogen Stress
The evaluation of nitrogen stress by dry weight increment (SN)as described in Section IV is a simple procedure, but it has three important disadvantages in that it requires destructive sampling, a high replication for precision, and a lengthy period for the response to manifest. Obviously it would be a great advantage if nondestructive or more rapid methods could be found. Alternatives are available and they fall into two classes: parameters of plant nitrogen status which are used as indices of SN, and parameters of plant growth which are used as direct alternatives to dry weight.
A. LEAF NITROGEN FRACTIONS
When attempting to relate leaf nitrogen to nitrogen stress, similar specifications to those which usually apply to the establishment of “critical levels” in tissue analysis must be considered. Decisions must be made as to the choice of nitrogen fraction to determine, organ or tissue to sample, and the time of sampling. Insight into these aspects can be gained first from reference tables such as in Goodall and Gregory (1947) and Chapman (1966) as well as individual research papers. For example, Ulrich (1950) gives critical values of nitrate nitrogen for leaves and for petioles at three physiological ages and at different dates of sampling of Beta vulguns; Hylton et al. (1964) give the value of nitrate nitrogen in several plant parts at which dy/& = 1 for Lolium multijlorum; and Rauschkolb el al. (1974a, b) evaluate the nitrogen status of maize and sorghum in terms of the total nitrogen and nitrate-nitrogen concentrations in the whole leaf, midrib, and basal section of the stem. We have examined the relationship of SN to the concentration of total nitrogen and of ninhydrin (mainly a-amino) nitrogen in the youngest fully expanded leaf of the tillers of annual ryegrass (Lolium rigidum) and in several genotypes of wheat. We used the youngest fully expanded leaf on the tiller at the time of sampling because its physiological age is constant and because it is easy to identify and sample. Total nitrogen was chosen because of its common use. Nitrate nitrogen was rejected, mainly because it does not accumulate in measurable quantities over the whole range of deficiency (e.g., Hylton et al., 1964), but also because it is highly variable in concentration, and it is sensitive to the form of nitrogen supplied and to time of day (Allen et al., 1961). Ninhydrin nitrogen was chosen as being intermediate between nitrate (unmetabolized) nitrogen, and total (mainly protein and therefore historic) nitrogen. Typical curves for total nitrogen and ninhydrin nitrogen in the youngest fully expanded leaves of wheat tillers are given in Fig. 5 .
19
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
K
z
*.
a
b
lJY
i .-
80
:\ 0 60 - \o 40
1
60
Total Nitrogen
\o
40
\
0
b
20
20
0 2
1
I
I
3
4
5
0 6
7
0.3
0.2
0.1
Leaf Nitrogen (%I FIG. 5 . The relation between nitrogen stress (SNR) and the concentration of nitrogen in the youngest expanded leaf of wheat between the third and fgth week after emergence. After Greenwood (1966).
To test the general applicability of leaf nitrogen fractions as estimators of S N , the constancy of the relationship must be investigated under a range of conditions. The results of some investigations are reviewed below. A direct comparison of the relationship of SN to leaf nitrogen was made between four commercial genotypes of wheat between the third and fifth week after emergence. Whereas some genotypes had similar calibration curves others differed (Titmanis and Greenwood, 1969), which leads to the conclusion that, in practice, it would be necessary to calibrate each genotype separately regardless of whether total nitrogen or ninhydrin nitrogen was to be used. Table IV gives the predicted value of SNR for a given value of the estimator in each of the four TABLE IV Comparison of Estimates of Nitrogen Stress (SNR) Given by Set Values of Leaf Nitrogen Fractions in Several Genotypes of Wheat' Nitrogen stress (%) Value of estimator Total N 4% 5% Ninhydrin N 1200 ppm 1500 ppm
Mendos
Gamenya
Emblem
Olympic
Gab0
25 8
25 9
30 -
45 17
21 9
23 10
23 10
20 -
35 11
33 20
'Adapted from Titmanis and Greenwood (1969) and Greenwood (1966).
0.4
20
E. A. N.GREENWOOD
genotypes, and also for Gabo at the same age but from another experiment (Greenwood, 1966). Since the relationship between SNR and leaf nitrogen vanes between close genotypes of the one species, it can also be expected to vary between closely related species. This certainly holds for the two species that have been investigated-annual ryegrass and wheat. At 28 days after seedling emergence the predicted value of SNR at 4% N content is 46% for ryegrass (cf. Fig. 6), which is a much higher value than four out of the five wheat genotypes at the same age just mentioned (Table IV). Work on the effect of age was conducted in two separate experiments by Greenwood and Titmanis (1966); the results have been brought together and reexpressed in Fig. 6. Over the first 5 weeks after emergence, a given concentration of total nitrogen in the youngest fully expanded leaf of the tiller gives a fairly constant estimate of SNR. Thereafter the predicted value of stress falls. For ninhydrin nitrogen, the two experiments gave inconclusive results.
60
0-0-0
50
-
40
-
-ap
3.5%N
-0
Total Nitrogen
\
-
-
6.MN
0-0-0-
10
DO
1
Spring Experiment
0 ,
I
1
0
I
Winter Experiment I
1
I
1
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
21
Insofar as one can generalize from two species, the period over which the concentration of total nitrogen in the youngest fully expanded leaf of the tiller can be used as a stable estimator of SN is short, i.e., 5-6 weeks at the most. No precise work has been recorded on the effects of either the composition of the nitrogen source or the relative supply of other nutrients on the regression of SN on leaf nitrogen. In experiments with young annual ryegrass, we examined the effects of defoliation on the relation of SN to leaf nitrogen (Greenwood and Titmanis, 1968). The various defoliation treatments used had very little effect on the relationship except at high concentrations of plant nitrogen (cf. Fig. 6). Total nitrogen and ninhydrin nitrogen performed simiiarly as estimators of stress. Light exerted a marked effect on the relationship between SNC and the total nitrogen concentration in the youngest fully expanded leaf of wheat tillers in an unpublished experiment by Greenwood. The treatments were full daylight and shading. Average noon light intensities for the unshaded and shaded treatments were 45,000 and 18,000 lx, respectively. Figure 7 and the accompanying statistics show that the estimation of SNC by total leaf nitrogen was good (R2> 0.98) and that the effect of shading was to produce greater slopes and intercepts than the unshaded treatments. If leaf nitrogen is to be used, then which fraction of nitrogen is to be preferred? There is usually little to choose between total nitrogen and ninhydrin nitrogen. The former is easier to deal with in the field and this may be the deciding factor. Nitrate nitrogen is unsatisfactory because it is not present in detectable amounts in severely deficient plants and because it shows diurnal and other variations. My own conclusion now is that any fraction of leaf nitrogen is rather unsatisfactory for general use as a quantitative estimator of SN.
B. LEAF ELONGATION The use of the rate of leaf or tiller elongation as an estimator of current growth rate in Gramineae has been briefly reviewed by Williams and Biddiscombe (1965). This reference also includes an excellent photograph of both continuous-recording and multi-point auxanometers, which are instruments used for the automatic measurement of tiller elongation rate. Leaf elongation has turned out to be the most useful of the estimators of SN so far evaluated for Gramineae. Leaf elongation rate is sensitive to nitrogen stress and, because of the morphology and pattern of leaf development in Gramineae it is simple and cheap to measure. Under steady conditions the daily rate of elongation of a given leaf of a Gramineae is constant from its first appearance until just before its full expansion. Since the latter coincides with the emergence of the next leaf this period approximates the leaf appearnce interval. Leaf elongation is obtained as
22
E. A. N. GREENWOOD 70
X
60
50
--8
40
0
z
v)
R2=0.995)
30
20
Unshaded R2=O!
10
\X I
0 2
I
1
3
I
4
1
1
5
Leaf Nitrogen(%)
FIG. 7. Effect of shading on the estimation of nitrogen stress (SNC) by total nitrogen in the leaf.
the difference between successive measurements of leaf length (in Gramineae this can be from the base of the ligule of the older leaf to the tip of the emerging leaf). Tiller elongation can be measured from a bench mark on the ground to the tip with a rule, or by an awanometer attached to the emerging leaf tip. More elaborate devices may be used for measuring elongation, such as the one used by Hsiao el al. (1970) for maize. The use of leaf elongation rate as an estimator of SN has not been evaluated in dicotyledons. It may well be suitable, for Wadleigh and Gauch (1948), for example, found leaf elongation to be a sensitive estimator of water stress in cotton plants. Leaf elongation rate, L (cm/day), can be used to estimate SN by substituting L for R or Cin the nitrogen stress equation SNL = 100 [(LM-L)/LM]
(4)
The ability of SNL to estimate SN in Lolium is seen in Fig. 8. For subclinical
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
23
100 28-42 Days 0 44-58Days
SNR
A
A
sNC
80
28-42 Days ~-58Dayr
60
-s?z v)
40
20
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
SNL(%)
FIG. 8. Linear regressionsof SNR on SNL and of SNC on SNL in Lolium rigidum. Points derived from Greenwood and Titmanis (1966) for plants between 2 8 4 2 days and 44-56 days after emergence. Values from plants with symptoms are not included in the regression.
levels of nitrogen deficiency, over 97%of variation in either SNR or SNC can be accounted for by SNL.Where deficiency symptoms are present there is a marked increase in slope. This seems to be caused by a rapid recycling of nitrogen from the older leaves to the emerging leaf. Consequently, even when SN approaches 100%(zero growth on a dry weight basis), leaf elongation continues. Unfortunately, annual ryegrass is the only species to have been studied with respect to leaf elongation and nitrogen stress. Some unpublished data of Power show that leaf elongation is sensitive to the effect of nitrogen supply on certain growth rate in a wide range of grasses from May to July in North Dakota (Table V) and therefore might also be useful as an estimator of stress. Power compared leaf elongation rate in swards that received either no nitrogen fertilizer or 220 kg Nlha in early spring. It is tempting to calculate SNL values from this array but to do so would be far from rigorous. This is because at each time of comparison,
24
E. A. N. GREENWOOD TABLE V Rate of Leaf Extension of Various Grass Species Prior to Inflorescence as Affected by Nitrogen Fertilization (Values Are Means of 6 Tiller@ Date
Species
N rate (kdha)
5/27
6/2
6/9
6/17
Average SE (%of mean)
17.8 22.0 7.2 11.3 10.5 25.6 11.3 32.3 6.0 2.7 6.7 12.5 9.0 32.2 9.7 9.5
10 12 17 24 18 19 15 20 26 27 17 18 14 17 14 19
mm/day Reed canary grass Smooth brome Western wheatgrass Russian wild
we Crested wheatgrass Green needle grass Garrison creeping foxtail Intermediate wheatgrass
0 180 0 180 0 180 0 180 0 180 0 180 0 180 0 180
8.7 14.0 10.1 8.2 7.2 8.1 4.8 8.5 7.0 3.8 5.2 4.4 5.5 2.5 10.6 8.5
13.5 18.2 7.8 14.5 9.7 12.5 7.3 18.2 11.0 20.0 9.0 10.0 6.8 21.5 12.3 19.2
14.0 25.3 7.5 18.2 9.3 21.2 10.2 25.0 7.6 10.7 8.4 16.0 6.3 36.2 11.3 18.8
‘Unpublished data of J. F. Power.
the No and Nzzo plots were not at all comparable, the latter having responded extensively to nitrogen applied in early April; consequently a split-plot design that is required for SN did not apply. The data have been presented here because of the rare insight they give into the sensitivity of leaf elongation under a variety of seasonal conditions. For example, soil water measurements showed that the fertilized plots contained 2-8 cm less water in the root zone in late May than did the check plots. This could account for the negative response to nitrogen obtained at that period. The dry matter responses obtained (to be published by Power elsewhere) reflected the variation in leaf elongation rates. The day-to-day change in temperature also produced a noticeable effect on elongation (Power, personal communication), an observation that supports the elegant results with Phalaris tuberosa L., P. arundinacea L., and Festuca arundinacea Schreb. obtained by Williams and Biddiscombe (1965). The standard errors in Table V give some idea of the adequacy of the fourfold replication used by Power. More comprehensive information on the number of
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
25
replicates required for a given level of precision in L is provided by Scott (1961) for tussock grasses. At the present stage of evaluation it appears that leaf elongation is a simply measured and promising estimator of SN, and its use should be encouraged. Accordingly, it would be profitable to investigate its performance early in any program where it might be applicable. Even in the case of annual ryegrass it has been shown that the relation of SNL and SNC does not hold indefinitely. From Fig. 8 it can be seen that a steady relationship holds at least for the first 8 weeks. But Greenwood et al. (1965) have shown that values of SNR begin to rise in relation to SNL shortly after 8 weeks. The application of leaf elongation is taken up again in Section VI, A.
C . LEAFAREA
Since leaf elongation rate is sensitive to nitrogen status, it follows that the rate of increase in leaf area should also reflect accurately the influence of deficiency on growth. Furthermore, lead area is both an expression of size and a partial expression of photosynthetic potential. In this context leaf area is taken to be total leaf area present either per plant or per unit ground area (LAI) as distinct from that of a selected expanding leaf as is used for leaf length. Nutrition can influence photosynthesis (whence growth) through affecting leaf area itself or through changes in photosynthetic rate per unit leaf area (net assimilation rate). These aspects of crop nutrition have been reviewed by Watson (1963) who concluded that, for nitrogen, the main effect on growth is through leaf area rather than through net assimilation rate. More specific evidence of the close relationship between leaf area and the influence of nitrogen on growth can be derived from the data of Bouma and Dowling (1966) and of Halse et al. (1969). Bouma and Dowling measured the dry weight and leaf area response of subterranean clover to nitrogen supply in water culture. I have computed the linear regression of the dry weight data on the leaf area data for each nitrogen level. It shows that 98% of the variation in dry weight is accounted for by the regression on leaf area. Halse measured photosynthetic area (green leaf plus stem area) and SNR in a wheat crop grown at three levels of nitrogen fertilizer: nil, 56 kg N/ha at sowing, and 336 kg N/ha split over three applications. Figure 9 shows my plotting of the change in leaf area against SNR for each period when stress was measured. The exercise shows a close relation between LA1 and nitrogen stress and a strong interaction with time. What is required for the estimation of stress is a set of leaf area data (derived from appropriate plots split for nitrogen) from a range of nitrogen levels and
26
E. A. N. GREENWOOD 2.5
-
2.0
4-7Weeks
-
1.5
0 6-9Weeks
-
A 10-13Weeks
4 C
X
i
-ic?l
1.0
-
0.5
.
0 -
1
1
L
0
10
20
13-16W~ks
I
I
30
40
00,
50
SN R (%I
FIG. 9. Relationship between increase in leaf area index (LAI) and nitrogen stress (Sm) in a crop of wheat over successive 3-weekly intervals. Nitrogen fertilizer treatments were nil, 56 kg N/ha at sowing, and 112 kg N/ha applied at sowing at 5 and at 10 weeks (taken here as producing zero stress). Data are derived from Halse et al. (1969).
which can be substituted into the expression SNA = 100 [(AM-A)/AMI
(5)
where A is the change in leaf area of the deficient plant over a given time interval and A M is the corresponding change in leaf area for a plant given a nonlimiting dose of nitrogen at the beginning of the interval. The adequacy of leaf area as an estimator of SN could then be tested by plotting SNA against SNC which would be derived from the corresponding dry weight values. The author is not aware of any set of data that completely fulfill these requirements other than a fragment from Bouma (1970a). In this instance, subterranean clover was grown in sterile culture solutions containing 4, 16, or 64 ppm N for 27 days. Among other treatments the 16 ppm plants were split into two groups: (1) the nitrogen level remained at 16 ppm; (2) the nitrogen level was raised to 64 ppm (assumed by me to be nonlimiting). Leaf area was estimated frequently. From Bouma’s Fig. 1 , at day 36, leaf area was 34.5 cm for 16 ppm
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
27
and 55.9 cm for 66 ppm. Substituting into Eq. (9,SNA = 38%. This value is very close to that for wheat at the same age and nitrogen supply (Greenwood, 1966) as also is the value of 59% derived by my extensive extrapolation from Bouma’s Fig. 1 for plants on 4 ppm N raised to 64 ppm. The technique for assessing the nutrient status of plants used extensively by Bouma in Canberra over the last decade has all the essentials of the split-plot approach for estimating nutrient stress. It is unfortunate for this review that most of his research has been concerned with nutrients other than nitrogen, for it has led to a more specific understanding of the physiology of nutrient response. Because of the importance of the work to the field of nutrient stress, the essence of the technique and results will be given. Bouma’s procedure is to grow subterranean clover seedlings in a nutrient solution containing all essential elements except the nutrient to be studied. The latter is provided as a pretreatment over a range of deficient levels. At a certain time some of the plants on each pretreatment are transferred to complete solutions, this time containing the previously deficient nutrient at a nonlimiting level. The treatment for the remainder is unchanged. On several occasions the leaf area of each plant is estimated using the photographic standards of Williams et al. (1964), and the carbon dioxide exchange rate (CER) is measured under standard conditions with an infrared gas analyzer. The results demonstrate the speed of response of leaf area and CER, and the relative importance of the contribution of leaf area and net assimilation rate. With these and other measurements, Bouma has studied what might be called the physiology of recovery from nutrient deficiencies such as nitrogen (Bouma, 1970a, b), phosphorus (Bouma, 1967a, b, 1969a, 1971, 1975; Bouma and Dowling, 1969a, b), sulfur (Bouma, 1967a, c, 1970c, 1971; Bouma et al., 1972), potassium and magnesium (Bouma 1970c), and boron (Bouma, 1969b). For most of these references it would be possible to compute nutrient stress in terms of leaf area, CER, and dry weight. With the advent of bench and portable photometric devices the measurement of leaf area has become a rapid operation. If the area of intact leaves is measured, by either photographic standards or, better, electronic scanner, then it is feasible to consider using the expansion rate of selected individual leaves. This would be much quicker than measuring all leaves. In conclusion, leaf area increment must rank as one of the simplest and most meaningful parameters of growth for estimating nitrogen stress of plants.
D. CARBON DIOXIDE EXCHANGE RATE (CER)
Photosynthesis being the major process for accumulation of dry matter in the plant, its rate is likely to be closely correlated with growth rate as controlled by nutritional deficiencies. The rate of CER may be considered as the most
28
E. A. N. GREENWOOD
comprehensive single measurement that can be taken to indicate instantaneous growth rate of the plant. So it would seem to be an ideal way of obtaining a rapid assessment of nitrogen stress, or any other nutritional stress. In practice it has some limitations. First, the initial cost of the apparatus for determining carbon dioxide concentration (infrared gas analyzer) is great, its use in the field is a little cumbersome, and it has a high maintenance requirement. Second, the rate of CER varies diurnally and between days and seasons. Hence, a near instantaneous determination of CER is not integrated over these variations and will give a biased result. Of course, a more representative result can be obtained by taking several CER readings but this is tedious. If the value of CER of the deficient plant is E , and the corresponding value for a plant given a nonlimiting dose of nitrogen is E M ,then the expression for nitrogen stress becomes
SNE = 100 [(EM-~IEMI
(6) It seems to me that the use of CER in studying nutritional stress has its greatest application in laboratory or controlled environment studies when CER for a large number of treatments can be compared under a standard environment. Bouma (Section V, C) has made great use of this approach. Wolf and Greenwood (unpublished) found that CER measurements in the laboratory gave very satisfactory results in the estimation of nitrogen stress in wheat seedlings. The application of these techniques to physiological studies in the laboratory is taken further in Section VI. E. CONCLUSIONS
Five plant parameters have been proposed for estimating nitrogen stress-leaf nitrogen, dry weight, leaf elongation, leaf area, and CER. What are the criteria for choosing which one of these parameters (or any other which might be proposed) should be used? It has been argued that it is not feasible to measure nitrogen stress in a way similar to water stress, e.g., chemical potential, and that there is no single measurement that can be made which can be called “growth.” Therefore, for the present, practical considerations should be given high priority. The following criteria are helpful: (1) the parameter that has the greatest meaning for the objectives of the project (what measurements are being made irrespective of the measurement of stress); (2) the equipment and expertise that are available; and (3) the measurement that uses the least resources. VI. Applications
It might be said of agronomists in general that they tend to apply treatments, obtain an end result, and then speculate as to how the measured outcome
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
29
occurred. Those who rigorously examine processes and their interactions come to be called crop physiologists! The foregoing remarks are indeed an oversimplification and are not intended as a criticism insofar as there are obvious and compelling reasons why agricultural research does concentrate on yield of products. But it must also be said that there is an aversion to studying the processes underlying yield, which is largely due to the daunting complexities and the lack of practical techniques to resolve them. The previous sections of this article have been directed to developing concepts and techniques that promise some easing of these constraints with respect to nutritional aspects of agronomy. This section deals with their practical application with the aim of suggesting the easiest way of doing the job in a variety of circumstances.
A. AGRONOMY AND ECOLOGY
Consider the basic operation of cultivation. Let us say that in certain situations it has been found to improve crop yield. And let us suppose that appropriate research showed that cultivation controlled weeds, thereby reducing competition for light, water, nitrogen, and other nutrients. On the other hand, the supply of available nitrogen and other nutrients was increased through microbial activity and through greater root exploration, . . ,and so on. In the event, how much of the response to cultivation can be ascribed to the nitrogen status of the plant during successive stages of growth? And from this, what deductions can be made about the mechanism and the timing of the nitrogen effect on final yield? Could we avoid cultivation by substituting an appropriately timed application of nitrogen and weedicide, and, if so, which would be the better solution? A comprehensive way of obtaining answers to such questions would be to have a large number of plots allocated to cultivation treatments and rates and times of application of nitrogen fertilizer. A shortcut to answering some of the questions posed, though certainly not all of them, would be to restrict the experiment to the two cultivation treatments upon which SN would be determined over successive periods. If, in addition to nitrogen stress, one were to determine other stresses such as water and phosphorus, then the agronomist would be in a strong position not only to answer some of the questions about nitrogen but also to comment on the importance of nitrogen vis-A-vis phosphorus and water stress. Cultivation has been chosen as an example because data already presented (Table 111) as a partial illustration can be used. A knowledge of nitrogen stress of a crop at a particular time does not provide a direct and accurate answer to the practical question: How much fertilizer is required to reduce stress to an acceptable level? This is the price to be paid for avoiding the response curve. Naturally it provides a partial answer; that is, whether the amount of fertilizer required is zero, a little, or a lot. In most cases
.
30
E. A. N.GREENWOOD
this may be good enough unless the agronomist has available an integrating model that qualifies the current biological requirement by economic and marketing factors and also accounts for change in requirement with time. A decade ago most agronomists worked exclusively in agricultural ecosystems. They could rely on a strong background of research literature and unpublished knowledge on which to base their future research policies. In the seventies, with increasing emphasis on nonagricultural ecology many agronomists have been assigned to work on ecosystems with which they are unfamiliar and for which little “hard” data exist. When one is confronted with a new ecosystem to be studied, the first questions to be asked are, What are the important limiting factors? How do they interact? The answers provide such penetrating insight into an ecosystem that they are almost a prerequisite for rationalizing research priorities. For example, there seems little point in embarking early, if at all, on a research program of plant nutrition or nutrient cycling in an ecosystem if it can be shown that nutrients are not important limiting factors. Similarly, if nutrition is limiting plant growth then which element is the most limiting? The technique of evaluating nutrient stress is an efficient way of rating nutrients as limiting factors. The techniques described here for estimating nitrogen stress can also be adapted for other nutrients (e.g., Bouma er al., 1969), for temperature (Greenwood er aL, 1976), and for water (Power, 1971). The most elegant example of this approach is the study by Power (1971) on the northern Great Plains of the United States. In these grassland ecosystems both nitrogen and water were known to be limiting plant growth. Since rainfall declined to the west it was considered that water stress would increase in that direction and that nitrogen stress would increase to the east. Further, as soil water declined during the growing season, water stress was expected to increase. At any one location and at any one time, what were the respective limitations to plant growth by the two factors? Power estimated SNR by using nitrogen fertilizer. Concurrently, he estimated water stress, SWR (Sw in his article), by a comparable technique in which water stress was removed by irrigation. An extract of the results is given in Table VI. There was a strong interaction with time, but the two stresses were, in general, additive. It became clear that, for the particular situation studied, nitrogen was more limiting than water. The dry weight approach to stress used by Power is obviously appropriate for the arable grasslands of North Dakota. It would not be satisfactory for arid rangelands where the spatial distribution of plants is exceedingly variable and sparse. Here it would seem better to use a nondestructive method such as SNL , which has the real advantage for remote areas that there is no equipment to break down. M. A. Ross and M. Friedel (personal communication) are currently evaluating leaf elongation rate of grasses in arid rangelands of Central Australia with a view to estimating SN and S, as did Power. Ross is studying the selection of
31
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
TABLE VI Percent Stress on Top Growth of Bromegrass Due to Nitrogen and Water Deficiencies' Sampling interval Stress due to
4/28 to 5/22
5/22 to 6/10
6/10 to 6/30
6/30 to 7/22
56 stress A. Low basal N (0-N) N Water N + Water
73
4 1
57 83
8
61 22 73
104 61 103
B. Medium b a d N (9@N) N Water N + Water
-1 2 4
3 32 49
24 32 54
35 10 58
C. High basal N (270-N)
N
0
Water N + Water LSD (0.5)
4 5
-7 31 23
ns.
18
7 24 33 17
13 32 59 25
'Reproduced from Power (1971).
suitable tillers relating leaf elongation rate to dry weight increments, and developing meaningful ways of applying nutrients and water in remote and a n d locations. He has observed an initial surge in elongation rate for a few days following a subsurface application of water to plants under long-term water stress. A similar study of leaf area increment is envisaged for dicotyledons. If these techniques are successful they will be used to estimate the changes in SN and S, which occur after effective rainfall. A technique for estimating phosphorus status using the dry weight response of detached leaves when placed in solutions with and without the element, has been developed by Bouma and Dowling (1976). It should be adaptable to evaluating nitrogen stress. The approach seems appropriate to those situations where water is nonlimiting and where the standard conditions of response imposed match the cultural conditions of the plant, as in the laboratory. In the field the technique would be most useful where the nutrient in question is the major limiting factor, otherwise some bias in the magnitude of response may develop. Further work on the development of this technique is proceeding (Bouma, personal communication).
32
E. A. N.GREENWOOD B. STRESS PHYSIOLOGY
If functional relationships between nutrient deficiency and specific plant processes are to be established, then two conditions must be met. First, the deficiency must be expressed in terms that arise from the plant itself as distinct from some external supply term. Second, the stress must be expressed numerically. The general failure of nutritional physiologists to meet these two conditions has led to a crippling weakness in research in, and also an avoidance of, this field. It is indicative that the abstracting journal Current Advances in Plant Science cites very few papers dealing with nutrient stress in Section 21 on Stress physiology. It must be admitted that some of the techniques of estimating nitrogen stress, as have been reviewed here, are barely adequate to meet the precision and speed often required by physiologists, particularly in the laboratory. Three suggestions follow. The most suitable technique for physiologists so far discussed is that by Bouma for the determination of CER using the infrared gas analyzer. Either the whole plant or a selected leaf can be used. CER determinations are made in the deficient plant and on a comparable plant for which nitrogen stress has been removed by an adequate addition to the nitrogen supply about 2 days prior to the measurements. The major requirements are a controlled environment chamber, an infrared gas analyzer, and an air-sealed photosynthesis chamber of appropriate geometry (Wolf et aL, 1969). Wolf and Greenwood (unpublished) have designed an extremely simple and sensitive arrangement for determining SNE in grasses and cereals on a relatively large scale. In this system the whole controlled environment chamber becomes the equivalent of the mixing chamber of the above-mentioned air-sealed device in which pots can be placed. The air in the large chamber is homogenized with one or more fans. The leaf is inserted in a glass tube through which the homogenized air is continuously drawn. Reference air is similarly sampled and both streams are led to the external analyzer which determines CER by the difference method. A large battery of plants can be harnessed prior to a run and the tubes may be left on the leaves indefinitely, provided that the leaf does not expand beyond the dimensions of the tube. Speed and precision can be obtained with this arrangement. A manifold of 2-way taps is installed outside the growth chamber so that when the air from a particular leaf is not being analyzed it will still be drawn over the leaf by another pump at the same rate. This reduces equilibration time within the tubing almost to zero and allows successive determinations of CER t o be made at about 2-minute intervals. Some simple precautions must be taken to isolate the air inside the growth chamber from the massive fluctuations in carbon dioxide which may occur outside. The resolution
33
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
and precision of this technique is demonstrated indirectly in Fig. 4,and, of course, it is nondestructive. Wolf and Greenwood used the technique only for one type of situation, but it seems capable of wide adaptation within a controlled environment. A further nondestructive laboratory technique is available for obtaining shortterm weight changes such as would be required by whole-plant physiologists. This is the weighmg technique of Amott et al. (1974), which permits separate live weighings of tops and roots of plants to be made at frequent intervals and with changes in nitrogen supply. Very good estimates of SN on a fresh weight basis can be obtained with this device while the plants themselves are available for other physiological measurements. Two units would be required for each estimate of stress.
C . MODELING
The concepts of nutrient stress can be of direct use to modelers of plant growth in at least two ways. First, a prior knowledge of the stress values for several nutrients allows the modeler to rank the elements in order of importance. He can then filter out the unimportant elements. Second, if the model first generates a potential growth rate which in turn is successively reduced according to the constraints from each important element, then the stress values themselves will be appropriate terms to govern the magnitude of those reductions without necessarily calling on a nutrient supply subroutine. Where the supply of the nutrient, say nitrogen, is also being generated then stress can be estimated through the following steps.
F;-iG J , ,T , , , -( _ty/ {-iziq = supply
controller
increment
CO, ,etc.
I Actual increment
Nitrogen demand is estimated by computing the product of the potential dry matter increment and the nitrogen concentration in the plant. The concentration is derived from a curve of the time course of nitrogen for a plant grown on a nonlimiting supply of nitrogen. This information requires minimal experimentation. The supply of nitrogen is generated by the supply subroutine. The final step is to reduce the potential dry matter increment by a proportion given by the ratio N supply/N demand, which is, of course, a term similar to nitrogen stress.
34
E. A. N. GREENWOOD VII. Conclusions and Aspirations
In this article the opinion has been expressed that the discipline of plant nutrition has badly neglected the quantification of deficiency. It has been suggested that the conventional approaches to deficiency through response curves and tissue analyses are inadequate bases on which to quantify deficiency rigorously except in special circumstances. By analogy with water stress, an attempt has been made to establish the basic requirements for a concept of nutrient stress and a proposal has been offered on how they might be put into practice. But the latter has proved too difficult to accomplish without some compromise and there has been insufficient experimentation to evaluate fully the several techniques available. It is hoped that this article will stimulate the evolution of plant nutrition whether it be through the development of the ideas presented or through more fruitful ideas arising from them.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author is grateful to Dr.J. F. Power, Dr. M. A. Ross, and Dr. D. D. Wolf for supplying unpublished data and to Dr. N. J. Barrow, Dr. D. Bouma, and Mr.G. B. Taylor for their help with the manuscript. The use of leaf elongation was suggested by Dr. R. F. Williams. The work with Dr. Wolf was done while the author was a guest of Virginia Polytechnic Institute. Special thanks go to Dr.R. C. Rossiter for the many enjoyable arguments over the concepts of nutrient stress.
REFERENCES Allen, R. S., Worthington, R. E., Could, N. R., Jacobson, N. L., and Freeman, A. E. 1961. J. Agr. Food G e m . 9,406-408. Amott, R. A., Brockington, N. R., and Spedding, C. R. W. 1974. J. Exp. Bot. 25, 1124-1 136. Bouma, D. 1967a. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 20, 51-66. Bouma, D. 1967b.Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 20,601-612. Bouma, D. 1967c. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 20,613-621. Bouma, D. 1969a. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 20,435-445. Bouma, D. 1969b. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 22,523-533. Bouma, D. 1970a. Ann. Bot. 34,1131-1142. Bouma, D. 1970b. Ann. Bot. 34,1143-1153. Bouma, D. 1970c. Proc. Int. Grassl. Congr., 11th. 1970 pp. 347-350. Bouma, D. 1971. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 22,723-730. Bourn, D. 1975. J. EXP.Bot. 26,42-59. Bouma, D., and Dowling. E J. 1966. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 17,647-655. Bouma, D., and Dowling, E. J. 1967. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 18,223-233. Bouma, D., and Dowling, E. J. 1969a. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 22,505-514. Bouma, D., and Dowling, E. J. 1969b. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 22,515-521.
NITROGEN STRESS IN PLANTS
35
Bouma, D., and Dowling, E. J. 1976.Aust. J. Agric. Res. 27,5342. Bouma, D., Spencer, K., and Dowling, E. J. 1969.Aust. J. Exp. Agric. Anirn. Husb. 9,
329-340. Bouma, D., Greenwood, E. A. N., and Dowling, E. J. 1972. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 25,
1147-1 156. Chapman, H . D., ed. 1966. “Diagnostic Criteria for Plants and Soils.” Div. of Agric. Sci., Univ. of California. Goodall, D. W., and Gregory, F. G. 1947. Cornrn. Bur. Hort. Plant. Crop (G. B.) Tech. Cornmun. 17. Greenwood, E. A. N. 1966.Plant Soil 24,279-288. Greenwood, E. A. N., and Titmanis, Z. V. 1966.Plant Soil 24,379-389. Greenwood, E.A. N., and Titmanis, Z. V. 1968.Aust. J. Agric. Res. 19,9-14. Greenwood, E. A. N., Goodall, D. W.,and Titmanis, Z.V. 1965.Plant Soil 23,97-116. Greenwood, E. A. N., Boyd, W. J. R., Wiitchead, J. A., and Titmanis, Z. V. 1970.Ausf. J. Exp. Agric. Anirn. Husb. 10,763-767. Greenwood, E. A. N., Carbon, B. A., Rossiter, R. C., and Beresford, J. D. 1976.Aust. J. A g r k Res. (in press). Hake, N. J., Greenwood, E. A. N., Lapins, P., and Boundy, C. A. P. 1969. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 20, 987-998. Hsiao, T. C. 1973.Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. 24,519-570. Hsiao, T. C., Acevedo, E.,and Henderson, D. W. 1970.Science 168,590-591. Hylton, L. O., Jr., Williams, D. E., Ulrich, A., and Cornelius, D. R. 1964. Crop Sci. 4,
16-19. Power, J. F. 1971.Crop Sci. 63,726-728. Rauschkolb, R. S., Brown, A. L., Quick, J., Prato, J. D., Pelton, R. E., and Kegel, F. R. 1974a. Calif: Agric. 28, 10-12. Rauschkolb, R. S., Brown, A. L., Sailsbury, R. L., Quick, J., Prato, J. D., and Pelton, R. E. 1974b.Calif:Agrk. 28, 12-13. Scott, D. 1961.N.Z.J. Agric. Res. 4,282-285. Smith, P. F. 1962.Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 13,81-108. Taylor 1968. In “Water Deficits and Plant Growth” (T. T. Kozlowski, ed.), Vol. 1, pp. 49-72. Academic Press, New York. Titmanis, Z. V., and Greenwood, E. A. N. 1969.Field Stn. Rec. 8,9-16. Ulrich, A. 1950.Soil Sci. 69,291-309. Wadleigh, C. H.,and Gauch, H.G. 1948.Plant Pfiysiol. 23,485-495. Watson, D. J. 1963.Proc. Easter Sch. Agric Sci., 10th pp. 233-247. Williams, C. N., and Biddiscombe, E. F. 1965.Aust. J. Agric. Res. 16,14-22. Williams, R. F.,Evans, L.T., and Ludwig, J. 1964.Aust. J. Agric. Res. 15,231-233. Wolf, D. D., Peace, R. B., Carbon, G.E., and Lee, D. R. 1969.Crop Sci. 9,24-27.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
.
Rodney J Arkley Department of Soils and Plant Nutrition. College of Natural Resources. University of California. Berkeley. California
............. ..................... ..............................................
I . Introduction: Objectives and Problems of Soil Classification
11. Numerical Taxonomy or Cluster Analysis of Soils
A. GeneralTheory B. Dataselection .............................................. C. Weighting and Standardization of Variables ........................ D. Measures of Similarity or Difference .............................. E Sorting Strategies ............................................ F . Presentation of Results of Sorting Procedures ...................... 111. Ordination of Soils .............................................. A . Q-TypeOrdination ........................................... B. R-Typeordination ........................................... C. Presentation of Results of Ordination ............................. IV . Soil as an Anisotropic Entity ...................................... A . Soil Profile as an Array of Soil Properties .......................... B Soil Data by Layers or Horizons ................................. C. Soil Profile as an Array of Depth Functions ........................ V . Statistical Methods for Comparing Classifications ...................... A . Cophenetic Correlation ........................................ B Coefficient of Association ..................................... C. Wilk's Criterion .............................................. VI . Conclusions and Evaluation ....................................... A The Choice of Methods ........................................ B. A Suggested Procedure for General Soil Classification ................ References ....................................................
.
.
.
.
37 39 39 40 41 45 47 52 54 55 56 58 59 60 61 63 63 64 64 64 64 65 67 68
I . Introduction: Objectives and Problems of Soil Classification
The purpose of classification is to organize the members of a large population of objects into groups or classes of objects so that the nature of. and relationships between. the objects can be more easily understood . This purpose may be limited to understanding related to a specific purpose such as the irrigability of soils and based upon only those attributes relevant to the purpose; or the purpose may be to develop a more general classification based upon as many 37
38
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
attributes as possible and useful for a wide range of purposes. Most of the research reported herein is of the latter kind with a few exceptions. Prior to 1955 when Hughes and Lindley first used a statistical procedure to reclassify members of six soil series, soil classification was based primarily on subjective judgment. That is not to say that the judgment applied has not been good; some of the best minds in soil science have been focused on soil classification. Nevertheless, both the selection of criterion variables for classification, their effective weighting by application at different categorical levels in a hierarchical classification, and of boundary values for separations have all been made primarily on the basis of fallible human judgment. Although some statistical analysis was carried out on soil data prior to 1955, the amount was limited primarily by the tedium of statistical analysis and the hand sorting of data. However, with the development of the electronic computer this tedium has been removed, and the application of numerical and statistical methods to soil classification has developed rapidly as indicated by the number of references cited in this paper, most of which deal directly with soil classification. To be both comprehensible and most effective, the differentiating characteristics or criterion variables used to form classes should contain the maximum possible information. That is, they should be those which have the most predictive value for the nature and behavior of the soil when subject to external influences. These criterion variables then should be those which are covariant with other properties (accessory characteristics) not used as criterion variables. The number of soil characteristics that might be used for soil classification is very large, and the selection of criterion variables from this list is very likely to be suboptimal by subjective methods. However, the covariance among all variables can readily be examined with the use of the computer by calculating the product-moment correlation coefficient between all pairs of variables and with direct examination or analysis of the resulting correlation matrix. On this basis an optimal set of differentiating characteristics can be chosen. Gibbons (1968) effectively argued the importance of covariance to the usefulness of soil classification. The extent to which soil properties are covariant will be discussed later in this paper. Soil classification in the past has been primarily hierarchical in nature, with one or more criteria used at each categorical level to divide soils into mutually exclusive classes. Such a classification is helpful in the understanding of relationships among soils, but some relationships may be seriously distorted. This occurs when a group of soils which is relatively similar in all other respects, is subdivided into two groups at all lower categorical levels by small differences in a particular differentiating characteristic. This is a general problem of hierarchical classification, in that it is a divisive procedure and the divisions are dichotomous; that is, they either have or have not a certain property or the value of a certain measured property is above or below a specified level. Avery (1968)
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
39
points out that a successful hierarchical classification can be made only if the differentiating criteria can be ordered in accordance with the number of other attributes (accessory characteristics) associated with them. He points out further that soil variation is not of this character, presumably because soil characteristics result from the interaction of several factors. This is the crux of a major problem in soil classification. Are soils to be considered as made up of discrete natural individuals, or do the individual soil profiles represent points in a multivariate continuum, which considered as a whole contains no distinct boundaries for purposes of classification? Experience has shown that soils may occur as discrete, relatively homogeneous bodies when considered only within a local area. But as investigations extend to broader areas more and more soils of intermediate character are encountered which bridge the gaps between the original discrete soil bodies. This leads to problems in soil correlation. The recognition and identification of soil classes, such as soil series in the field, in the face of this kind of soil variation is the bane of the soil surveyor’s existnece. His decisions must be made primarily on the basis of field observations of a number of soil characteristics, and the soils classified on the basis of variations in one or many of these simultaneously. Avery (1968) argues forcefully that a coordinate system of classification is more appropriate for soils than a hierarchical system. The advantage to a coordinate system being that each differentiating criterion is given equal weight, at least a priori. It should be pointed out also that a coordinate system can be used to construct a number of hierarchical systems, by arranging the differentiating criteria in different categorical orders. In the following discussion of the various statistical methods applied to soil classification, it will be observed that much of the work has assumed that soils (mainly soil profiles) fall into natural clusters or groups which can then be ordered into a classification. For the limited sets of soils used, this appears to be a correct assumption. Although little work has been done toward the development of a coordinate classification scheme, it is made clear that some of the statistical methods described can be used effectively for this purpose assuming that soil characteristics vary in such a way as to form a continuum through the whole population of soils. A method is suggested by which soils can be classified using a set of well-separated centroids or conceptual modal soils and classes formed on the basis of the general affinity of real soils to the centroids. II. Numerical Taxonomy or Cluster Analysis of Soils
A. GENERAL THEORY
Numerical taxonomy is defined by Sneath and Sokal (1973) as the grouping by numerical methods of taxonomic units into taxa on the basis of their
40
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
character states. Groupings are formed using the following general procedures: First, data for a number of units, such as soil profiles, are assembled including a sizable number of selected variable properties for each unit. Because this discussion is confined to the classification of soil units, they will be simply referred to as soils. The data are commonly arranged into a matrix consisting of soils by columns and soil properties by rows. Next an over-all estimate of resemblance is obtained between pairs of soils by some mathematical function of all differences between the values for each property of the two soils. After numerical values for the estimate of resemblance (either estimates of similarity or of difference can be used) between all pairs of soils included in the study are obtained, the matrix of n(n-1)/2 values is subjected to a sorting strategy which forms groups of similar soils. The nature of the groups formed and their relationships or taxonomic structure can be presented in various ways; these may include dendrograms, reordered matrices, ordination, or simply tables of coordinates.
B. DATA SELECTION
The choice of soils to be included in the data should be such that the number of soils is large and the general kinds of soils included are well represented. For example if the soils included are mainly well drained and without evidence of wetness, then the inclusion of a very few poorly drained soils may interfere with the analysis because those. soil properties associated with wetness may not be representative of the range of variation in those properties. Tllis is particularly important in cluster analysis as the order of cluster formation is affected by the number of soils in the clusters or groups formed in some clustering techniques. The selection of soil properties is even more important to a successful analysis than the selection of soils. Although all kinds of both field and laboratory data can be used, there are certain kinds that should be excluded or that need special treatment. Some soil properties, such as the field moisture content, are generally irrelevant to soil classification and should be excluded. Logically correlated properties, such as dry and moist colors, are generally so highly covariant that one or the other should be included. Particle size distribution values for sand, silt, and clay always add up to 100% and so one of the three should be eliminated from the data. The inclusion of large numbers of logically related properties should be avoided, as they tend to create an inadvertent extra weight to such a group of properties in the classification. For example, in the initial list of properties used by Sarker et ul. (1966) were 6 particle size ratios, 5 of which were intercorrelated above the 0.90 level. This kind of redundancy among properties should be avoided or dealt with by analysis of variables as discussed later in this paper. Soil data obtained from laboratory analysis are almost always continuous
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
41
variables as are a number of field measurements such as thickness and depths of recognizable characters. Hue, value, and chroma (soil color) are continuous variables even though the color chart commonly used is made up with discrete steps. However, field observations such as soil texture, structure, and consistency are usually discrete or multistate variables and need to be treated with special care. Data of this kind should be coded in such a way as to reflect their proper rank order reflecting their importance to soil behavior or development. For example, soil texture classes might be coded in order of their relative clay content or water retention characteristics. Structure is a particularly difficult soil property to code as a ranked multistate variable. For surface soils an appropriate order of structure type might be single grained, massive, platy, crumb, granular, subangular blocky and angular blocky; for subsoil layers the order might be single grained, massive, platy, granular, subangular blocky , angular blocky, prismatic, and columnar. Structure grade or distinctness such as weak, moderate, and strong coded 1, 2, 3 might well be multiplied by the code for structure type coded 0 to n and a value for size of peds added to give a single value for type-grade-size of structure. The system suggested is only one of many possible ways that soil structure might be treated. Arkley (1971) and Cipra et al. (1970) have used type and grade omitting structure size with some success. Barkham and Norris (1970) treated soil structure type, grade, and size as separate characters. Soil color mottling is troublesome to code. Cipra et al. (1970) used a combination of abundance, size, and contrast of mottles scaled from 0 to 8. Cuanalo and Webster (1970) used abundance percent and position on peds separately. Rayner (1966) used abundance, size, and contrast as separate variables. Dichotomies such as the presence or absence of earthworms, concretions, carbonates, iron pans, manganese stains are sometimes used (Rayner, 1969; Muir et al., 1970). Dichotomies require special treatment which will be discussed in relation to the standardization of variables. The same is true for unranked multistate variables.
C. WEIGHTING AND STANDARDIZATION OF VARIABLES
I . The Problem of Weighting of Variables Sneath and Sokal (1973) present cogent arguments in favor of weighting all variables equally, especially where a classification is intended t o be a “natural” or basic classification for general use rather than one for a specific objective. These arguments against “a priori” weighting appear to be on sound rational grounds. This is in direct opposition to the methods of orthodox or conventional
42
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
hierarchical classification wherein the differentiating characteristics used at higher categorical levels take precedence over those at lower levels, and therefore have greater effective “weight.” For example, in the Soil Classification of the Soil Survey Staff, U.S. Department of Agriculture (1960), certain diagnostic horizons are considered more important than others; a case in point is the use of the mollic epipedon at the “Order” level to separate the Mollisol soil order from other orders, irrespective of the nature of the subsoil horizons to a large degree, whereas most of the other orders are separated on the basis of the nature of subsoil horizons. Decision such as the one cited are based on intuition or human judgment, both of which are fallible. Sneath and Sokal (1973) also argue in favor of the use of a large number of variables (i.e., soil properties) in numerical taxonomy, on the grounds that the use of variables greatly evens out the effective weight which each one contributes. This argument presupposes that all pertinent groups of covariant properties are about equally represented in the data. In the data used for numerical classification research on soils, this is clearly not true in many cases. Some kinds of measurement on soil properties are more easily obtained than others, or have been of more interest to the investigator, and so are overrepresented and thus unduly weighted. Also the use of a large number of variables involves a great deal of time and expense, especially if the classification is intended to encompass a large number of individuals. However, in the first stages of analysis, the use of a large number of variables standardized so as to give equal weight to each is certainly a sound approach. For the final classification it may be possible to reduce the number of variables to a manageable but still effective size by analysis of the covariance among them.
2. Covariant Soil Variables In the past, covariance among soil variables was rarely analyzed, but with the advent of electronic computers the tedium of the calculation of correlation coefficients has been removed. In several papers involving numerical taxonomy of soils, correlation matrices have been published, revealing how much covariance exist among soil variables. Moore and Russell (1967) analyzed 10 trace elements in 28 soil profiles and found that the correlation matrix of 45 r-values contained 27 which were significant (P < 0.01) and ranging from 0.49 to 0.90; Moore et al. (1972) show 50 of 91 r-values significant (P < 0.01) ranging from 0.18 to 0.80 for 14 variables in 4 layers of 40 soils. Sacker et al. (1966) found that 39 of 61 soil properties were correlated with at least one other at the level of r > 0.50; Russell and Moore (1967) show 57 of 136 r-values significant (P>0.01) ranging from 0.40 to 0.80 for 17 variables and 43 soils. Reexamination of my own data sets used for analysis of variables also revealed similar levels of communality among variables as shown in Table I (Arkley, 1971).
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
43
TABLE I Number of Variables SigniFcantly Correlated with other Variables in Analyses Reported by Arkley (1971) Variables with rvalues significant at P < 0.01
Number of
Soils
Variables
59
621 220 81 87
1+
>2
21 23 34
4 1 7 0 23
8 21
0
34
44
0
53
2
44 51
30 42 46
0
>4 1
20 26 40 38
The extensive covariance among soil variables in the widely differing data sets described in Table I is strong evidence that a long list of soil variables is not necessary to classify soils effectively by either conventional or numerical methods. Also, it is evident that analysis of variables should be among the first steps in the development of a classification system. There should be no objection to weighting variables according to their predictive values as revealed by the analysis of variables as this would not be considered a priori weighting.
3. Standardization of Variables Most procedures for obtaining an estimate of resemblance require that the variables be standardized to a common range of values. It is clearly inappropriate to compare differences in a variable with a range of 0.0 to 1.0 with those in a variable with a range of 100 to 1000. For continuous variables standardization may be by range, i.e.,
x' = (x- Xndn) I x,,
-~ m i 1 n
or by variance, i.e .,
X'=(X-X)/SDx The former gives each variable a range of 0.0 to 1.O, the latter a mean of 0.0 and a standard deviation of k1.0. These methods can also be applied to ranked multistate variables, but with more risk of injecting spurious information. For data containing both continuous and discrete variables, either dichotomous or multistate, Crigal and Arneman (1969) applied a method proposed by Talkington (1967): For a variable that can assume a number of discrete and mutually exclusive states (i.e., soil structure types) which is coded as 1.O for no
44
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
more than one of these states and 0.0 for all others, the maximum possible contribution to the differences or the sum of the square of the differences between two individuals is 2.0 (Table 11). Continuous variables are therefore standardized so that the maximum contribution to the squared difference is also 2.0; such variables are standardized by range and then multiplied by 21'2 or 1.414.
Another method for equalizing the contribution of discrete and continuous variables based upon information theory has been developed by Burr (1 968) but so far has not been applied to soils. Continuous variables are standardized to a mean of 0 and a standard deviation of +21n by the formula
x'=(X-X)/(1.414X SDx) And dichotomous and multistate variables by the formula
M 2= M(t-1) /
[2tp, (s, - I)]
where M' is the standardized variate, M is an unstandardized variate (as coded in Table 11), t is the total number of individuals (soils) with nonmissing data,p, = the proportion of t in state s(sn/t), sn is the number of individuals in state s, and ,S is the number of possible states of variate M. Burr proposes to call this procedure standardizing by reciprocal proportions since the weight of each state is weighted inversely to its frequency of occurrence @,). The formula given above weights a multistate variate M equally with a continuous variable. If one considers that each state s should be weighted equally with a continuous variable, then the parameter S (, - 1) can be omitted from the formula. The problem of highly skewed data should be considered in the standardization of variables. In some cases it would be appropriate to use a logarithmic or square root transform for known skewed distributions as was done by Moore and Russell (1967). Talkington (1967) advocates a slight truncation of the range for extreme values which occur very rarely as was done by Grigal and Arneman TABLE I1 Individuals Variable states (s) $1
Sl s3
84
Difference A
B
(4
0 1 0 0
0 0 0 1
0 1 0 1 2
d' 0 1 0 1
2
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
45
(1969). In this connection it should be pointed out that the use of ratios as data variables may well lead to highly skewed distributions because of the hyperbolic nature of ratios; in general they should be avoided. In any case a careful examination of the data for errors or aberrant data should precede the analysis, simply as a good analytical practice. Where highly skewed variables are suspected, they should be examined in a frequency distribution and perhaps plotted against related variables in a scatter diagram before a decision is made as to their treatment. D. MEASURES OF SIMILARITY OR DIFFERENCE
Various procedures are available for calculating an over-all estimate of resemblance, which can be based upon measures of either similarities or differences. Sneath and Sokal (1973) use the term “similarity coefficient” t o cover coefficients both of similarity and of dissimilarity; the one being the complement of the other. They describe four somewhat fuzzy classes of similarity coefficients as (1) distance Coefficients, (2) association coefficients, (3) correlation coefficients, and (4) probabilistic coefficients, of which the first and third have been used in soil studies most commonly. 1. Distance Coefficients
The simplest practical form of “distance” measure called mean character difference (MCD) is: where Xi . . . n are standardized variates and j and k are two individuals such as soil profiles. However, this coefficient is rarely used and suffers from the fact that a large difference in a single variable is inadequately represented in the coefficient. MCD has been applied by Moore and Russell (1967) and Webster and Burrough (1972). A much more commonly used distance coefficient is the familiar Euclidean distance (d) in the form: d , k = [ a i (X,j-X,)’ i= 1
1
lR
The expression l / n is introduced into the equation in order to equalize differences introduced by missing data, or differing numbers of variates used. The average Euclidean distance coefficient has the advantage of being more readily visualized and can be plotted in two or three dimensiocc although not in n-space where n is greater than 3. It also has other statistical properties which are advantageous. This coefficient has been used in soil studies by Cipra et al. (1970), Crichton (1975), Grigal and Arneman (1969), Moore et al. (1972),
46
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
Lamp (19721, and Webster and Burrough (1972). Cuanalo and Webster (1970) used d2 rather than d. Another distance that has been used several times is referred to as the Canberra metric (dc). It was developed by Lance and Williams (1967b) and has the advantage of needing no prior standardization of variables. It is in the form of n
dc
=z
<&j-X% I)/(&j
+ Xik)
i= 1
However, it has the unfortunate characteristic that a difference in the upper part of the range of a variate (i.e., when the denominator is large) is minimized as compared to an equal absolute difference in the lower part of the range and thus is sensitive to proportional rather than absolute differences between individuals (soils). Another coefficient of similarity [of Bray and Curtis (1958)l was applied to soils by Hole and Hironaka (1960), the first to use numerical taxonomy in soil classification, and later by Bidwell and Hole (1964), Bidwell et al. (1964), Sarkar et ul. (1966), and Moore and Russell (1967). The Similarity Index (SI) mathematically restated is: n
n
i=l
i=1
SIB = z IXi, - X, I / z (Xij + X,)
All variables must be standardized to a common range and positive in sign. It is particularly useful where the data are all in percentages as in species composition of plant communities. Another distance coefficient, Mahlanobis D 2 , is suitable only for use with predetermined groups of individuals. It was applied to soils by Hughes and Lindley (1955) and by Van den Driessche and Maignien (1965). It is based on comparisons of variances within and between groups and is closely allied to discriminant function analysis. However, it is computationally involved and heavily dependent upon multivariate normality. The reader should consult Sneath and Sokal(l973) and Rao (1948) for details of the method.
2. Simple Matching Coefficient For data coded as two state characters (0 and l), a simple matching coefficient (S,) can be used. S, is simply the number of matches 2 vs. 1 or 0 vs. 0) divided by the total number of matches and mismatches. A related coefficient called the coefficient of Jaccard (SJ)omits zero matches from both the numerator and denominator. The coefficient S, was examined by Moore and Russell (1967) but was applied to continuous variables by coding data in rank intervals. This involves considerable loss of information content, and so is not recommended. It was also used for classifying soil bacteria by Brisbane and Rovira (1961). The coefficient of Jaccard was used by Varty and White (1964) to classify montmorillonite clay.
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
47
3. Correlation Coefficients The product moment correlation coefficient (r) has also been used as a similarity coefficient in soil studies (Cipra et al., 1970; Cuanalo and Webster, 1970; Dryden, 1935; Moore and Russell, 1967; Moore et al., 1972; Russell and Moore, 1967). However, the use of r in this way has several disadvantages in soil classification. It is a measure of pattern rather than of magnitude of difference; for example if the values of Xq are 1, 2, and 3, and of X i k are 7, 8, and 9, then r j k = 1.0 indicating the individuals j and k are identical, while they evidently differ in terms of magnitude. Another problem arises in ranked multistate variables, in that the direction of scaling may influence the sign of the correlation coefficient as pointed out by Eades (1965).
4. Comparison of Similarity Coefficients Moore and Russell (1967) compared the results of using five different similarity coefficients, namely, (1) simple matching Coefficient (Sm),(2) mean character difference (MCD), (3) Euclidean distance (4,(4) the Canberra metric &), and (5) correlation coefficient (r). They concluded that the Euclidean distance is probably most appropriate for soils because it is sensitive to magnitude, is metric, and provides a model that can be readily visualized. Webster (1975) criticizes the Euclidean distance measure because of its sensitivity to magnitude, in that a single large difference makes a disproportionate contribution to the calculated dissimilarity between pairs of individuals. This might be true in the case where only a very few soil properties are used; but where a larger number is used, say 15 or more, then the contribution of a single large difference is less and appears to the author to be appropriate for soil classification. Euclidean distance is especially useful for data containing all continuous variables, and can be used effectively for mixed data containing both continuous and multistate variables. For data consisting mainly of 2-state variables, the simple matching coefficient (S,) or the Coefficient of Jaccard (SJ)would be more appropriate.
E. SORTING STRATEGIES
Generally, the matrix of pair-wise similarity coefficients produced from the analysis of the data matrix is very large as the number of pairs is equal to n(n-1)/2, where n is the number of individuals. Thus the similarity matrix usually cannot be adequately interpreted by simple visual inspection. A large and confusing array of sorting strategies have been developed for describing the
48
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
pattern of relationships within the matrix. At least ten different methods have been applied to soil data of which only the more commonly used will be described in any detail. Sneath and Sokal (1973) describe the various methods and combinations of methods for sorting a similarity matrix in “Taxonomic Structure.” The most commonly used procedures in soil studies are included under systems called “sequential, agglomerative, hierarchic, nonoverlapping clustering methods” by Sneath and Sokal. In these procedures, the first step is a search of the matrix for the most similar pair (or pairs) of individuals (maximum similarity or minimum difference) which are joined to form the initial cluster(s). Then the matrix is reexamined for maximum similarity among remaining pairs or individuals or between individuals and prior clusters or between pairs of prior clusters, and the most similar pairs are joined to form new or enlarged clusters. This process is repeated until all individuals are accounted for, and the degree of similarity at each combination recorded. The results are generally presented in the form of a dendrogram or a phenogram, as it is called by Sneath and Sokal. This seems to be a perfectly straightforward method, but there are a variety of algorithms available for the definition of maximum similarity between clusters of individuals and clusters.
1. Single Linkage or Nearest Neighbor Clustering
This method uses the criterion for joining based upon the two most similar individuals between the two clusters. This procedure has the undesirable characteristic of frequently leading to long, wandering clusters; a result that is referred to as “chaining.” Nevertheless, single linkage clustering has been used by a few soil scientists, namely Anderson (1971), Rayner (1966), and Muir et al. (1970), and it has been compared with other methods by Moore et al. (1972). 2. Complete Linkage or Farthest Neighbor Clustering This method forms clusters directly opposite in character to those formed by nearest neighbor sorting. It is based upon the similarity of the least similar pairs of individuals in the two clusters. It forms tight, hyperspherical clusters which join others generally at low levels of similarity and often leave a number of isolated individuals.
3. Average Linkage Clustering This most commonly used clustering methods in soil studies are intermediate between the extremes of the two methods described previously and are forms of arithmetic average linkage methods. The simplest form is the unweighted pair-
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
49
group method using arithmetic averages (UPGMA) and was first used by Rohlf (1963). Individuals or clusters are joined on the basis of the average similarity between all pairs of individuals in one cluster and those in another cluster, after the initial pair or pairs are joined. This method is thus based upon average between-group differences and produces results very similar to the more exact centroid sorting described below. It has been used in soil studies by Anderson (1971), Barkham and Norris (1970), Bidwell and Hole (1964), Bidwell et al. (1964), Cipra et al. (1970), Cuanalo and Webster (1970), and Sarkar et al. (1 966). Unweighted pair-group centroid method (UPGMC) is similar to the WGMA method except that it is based upon the centroid of each cluster, which is calculated from the original data considered as coordinates in n-space for n variables or from the scores of individuals in n-space for n-dimensions derived from analysis of variables. The centroid is defined as the average coordinates of the members of a cluster. For soil studies this is an attractice method because the centroid of a group of soils is conceptually akin to the modal soil concept of the soil series, in which the modal soil is considered to be one near the centroid of the members of that soil series. It also can be represented accurately in two or three dimensions using 2 or 3 standardized variables or factor score dimensions. UPMGA usually gives similar results but it lacks the latter advantage. Unweighted centroid sorting has been examined by Anderson (1971), Campbell et al. (1970), Cuanalo and Webster (1970), and Moore and Russell (1967). Weighting can be applied to the calculation of either the arithmetic average or the centroid method. These are called “weighted pair-group method using arithmetic averages” (WPGMA) and “weighted pair-group centroid method” (WPGMC), respectively, by Sneath and Sokal (1973). In these procedures the individual most recently added to a cluster is weighted equally with all previous members of the cluster. The WPGMA method was used by Grigal and Arneman (1969) but they gave no reason for its selection. There seems to be no rational purpose in using this kind of weighting for soils.
4. Variable Group Clustering Rather than permitting clusters to form by pairs of individuals and/or clusters, it is possible to allow several individuals and/or clusters to join at a single step in the procedure. This requires that an arbitrary criterion level of similarity be specified at each step in the clustering for joining individuals or clusters. The criterion may be based on the change of average within-group similarity introduced by the merger after the first step in which initial clusters are formed by joining individuals above another specified criterion level of similarity. Variable-group centroid sorting is also amenable to an iterative procedure which converges on a stable configuration. As individuals are added to initial
50
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
clusters formed with specified within-group similarity, the centroids are shifted, possibly in the direction of individuals on the outer fringe of other clusters. So after the first clustering, the centroids are established and all individuals are reallocated to the centroid which has the most similar coordinates (closest in n-space). This process is reiterated until the centroids remain stable. Usually, only a few iterations are required, Unweighted variable-group centroid sorting with iteration was used by Arkley (1968, 1971); criteria for joining were based upon change in within-group variance. Cuanalo and Webster (1970) compared a weighted variable-group method with weighted and unweighted pair-group methods and found the results to be very similar for the three sorting strategies. Sokal and Sneath (1963) describe the variable-group methods, but in their later book (Sneath and Sokal, 1973) they indicate that there is little to choose between the methods and so omit the variable-group procedures, mainly because they are more difficult to program for the computer than pair-group methods.
5. Flexible Sort Clustering Lance and Williams (1967a) developed a general formula for S A H N clustering procedures in the form D(i,j),k=aiDi,k+ajDj,k + bDi,j+ cIDi,k-Dj,kI
where D is a measure of difference or dissimilarity, i and j are a joined pair of individuals or groups, and k is a candidate for joining the group, a (alpha) is a parameter that may be set at or a function of the numbers of individuals (t) included in i,j, or k such as = tilt&k
and
aj = tjltj,k
as in UPGMA and UPGMC; c is generally zero except that it is equal to - for nearest neighbor and for farthest neighbor sorting; b is usually zero except in unweighted centroid sorting (UPGMC) where b is equal to n,ai and D is squared Euclidean distance. Lance and Williams (1967a) proposed a method which they called Median sorting in which ai = aj = b = -%, and c = 0. This places the centroid of the combined group midway between the centroids of i and j irrespective of the number of members in i and j rather than nearer the larger of group i or j as in true centroid sorting. Flexible sorting was applied as above with b = - # by Campbell et al. (1970), Crichton (1975), Moore et al. (1972), Russell and Moore (1967, 1968). Moore and Russell (1967) used another form of flexible sorting in which ai = aj, b = 1 (Ui t aj), and c = 0. This procedure was intended to produce especially tight clusters of high within-group similarities. Anderson (1971) also used a “mini-
4
t,
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
51
mum variance clustering” which minimizes the within-group variance in which ai = (ti -k f k ) / ( t i t f j t f k ) ,
aj = ( f j + f k ) / ( f i+ f j
fk),
b = 1 -(Ui t U j )
and c = 0. The clustering algorithm between cluster k and the combined cluster ( i j ) is thus Dk,ij = [ ( t i + f k ) D k i t ( f j t t k ) D k i - t k D i j ] / ( t i t f j t t k )
where t is the number of individuals in clusters i, j , and k. This author points out that the results can be presented as an analysis of variance, because the sum of squares being subdivided is that due to the samples t samples X attributes effects.
6. Information Content Clustering A clustering technique based upon information theory has been used by Norris and Dale (1971) and by Moore et al. (1972) applied to all two-state variables (transition matrix). Clustering is based upon the minimum information gain upon the fusion of two pairs or groups of individuals. The method is explained in detail in Sneath and Sokal(l973); however, they indicate serious reservations with regard to the assumptions on which the method is based. Since most soil data include continuous and ranked multistate variables, the method is not generally applicable in soil classification (see also Section IV,B,3).
7. Sorting Strategies: Divisive Divisive sorting systems have been applied to soil classification in only a few cases. hvisive systems begin with the whole population, and, progressively divide it into smaller and smaller groups using the similarity matrix. Traditional categorical soil classification proceeds in a similar way, generally making separations using a single dichotomous criterion for separation (monothetic) or perhaps two or more criteria simultaneously (polythetic). Norris (1972) used the technique of “Association analysis.” The variables are analyzed for covariance and the first is selected which has highest communality with other variables which can be computed from the maximum sum o f ? for a variable compared to each other variable (ZF1 rtj). Thus this is the variable with the highest predictive value. The population is divided into two classes using this variable as a criterion. Thereafter each subset is further subdivided by the same procedure. The process is terminated when a specified number of classes have been formed or when the maximum sum of r2 falls below a specified level for all remaining variables. Karmeli et al. (1968) devised a procedure for specific design purposes similar to “Association analysis,” which was called “Maximum Uniformity Classifica-
52
RODNEY J.ARKLEY
tion.” The method suggested uses separation on a primary variable with high communality together with minimum variance and t-tests and discriminant functions to increase the separation of groups.
8. Comparison of Sorting Strategies Using the same similarity matrix as Muir et al. (1970), Anderson (1971) compared five sorting strategies: nearest neighbor, farthest neighbor, group average (UPGMA), centroid (UPGMC), and minimum variance clustering. He concluded that the 63 soil profiles sampled from 4 soil series were classified most effectively by farthest neighbor and minimum variance clustering. Campbell et al. (1970) compared centroid, flexible (b = -0.25), and median sorting and concluding that the flexible sort ( b = -0.25) appeared to be the most effective in forming groups, but the appearance of the dendrogram resulting from centroid sorting appeared to be equally effective to this writer. Cuanalo and Webster (1970) compared unweighted pair-group (UPGMA), weighted pair-group (WPGMA), and weighted variable-group methods. They concluded that all gave similar results and printed only the results from UPGMA. Moore and Russell (1967) compared nearest neighbor, farthest neighbor, centroid sort and flexible sort (see above). They found the typical chaining effect of nearest neighbor sorting, but the other three produced dendrograms in which 7 groups could be consistently detected in the 28 soils used. Examination of these comparisons suggests clearly that in soil studes, the single-linkage (nearest neighbor) sorting with its strong tendency to form long chains rather than tight spherical clusters is to be avoided. Unweighted pairgroup or group average clustering (UPGMA), unweighted centroid sorting (UPGMC), and minimum variance clustering are appropriate for soil studies as they produce moderately “tight” initial clusters of reasonable homogeneity and the central “core” of the cluster can be identified. However, as pointed out by Moore and Russell (1967), clustering and its representation in a dendrogram provides a two-dimensional representation of a multidimensional system (nspace) and clearly must contain distortion of the true configuration. They also point out that distortion is least at the lower levels of the hierarchy produced; thus the initial groups formed have the most validity, larger groups formed by merging smaller groups the least. Thus groupings formed at the higher levels should be treated with caution.
F. PRESENTATION OF RESULTS OF SORTING PROCEDURES
A similarity matrix can be shown effectively in a shaded similarity mafrix as in Fig. 1 provided the indiviudals are ordered in such a way that the highest
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
53
similarities are at or near the diagonal. However, if the number of individuals is large, manual sorting to produce the optimum order may be very difficult. In the example shown in Fig. 1, the order was according to the results of a clustering procedure (Fig. 2). By far the most common visual presentation of the results of the similarity matrix sorting procedures is in the form of a dendrogram such as that shown in Fig. 2. In a dendrogram, the individuals are indicated by symbols at the end of each branch, and the length of the branches are proportional to the degree of dissimilarity; the scale of dissimilarity used is often shown, although in this case it was not. Dendrograms have the advantage of being readily interpreted, but it should be remembered that they are two-dimensional representations of a Sornilaroty cwtfeient “!.I
ol.
26
27 25 24 34 33 32 28 35 29 43 36 40
818 90-99 El80-89 70-79
38
site NO
39 41 30 4 31 37 42 19 3 22 1
2 21 20 5
6 23 7 8 10 11
14 12 9 13 18 15 17 16 ~6n24343332283529~364038g41304 313742193 22 1 2 2l20 5 6 2 3 7 8 10 111412 9 1318151716 Slts
No
FIG.1. Shaded similarity matrix for 43 soil bodies. Reprinted from Russell and Moore (1967) by permission of the publisher, Geoderma.
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
54
I
t
1 LL r I
?
1011 14 12 9 13 Y) 15ff 16
433640383941 30 4 3 37 42
GKW
-'
1
n
m
l ! z
FIG. 2. Dendrogam showing relationships between soil bodies using flexible sorting procedure (b = -0.25). Reprinted from Russell and Moore (1967) by permission of the publisher, Geoderma.
multidimensional system and so suffer some distortion. Sometimes some of the distortion can be relieved by changing the order of the initial clusters so as to bring the nearest members of two clusters adjacent to each other. I I I. Ordination of Soils
Another approach to the examination of taxonomic structure is through ordination, which is normally used when the distribution of indiviudals in n-space tends to be continuous rather than in distinct clusters. Thus some form of ordination seems to be appropriate for soils when large numbers of individuals
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
55
are included, if one considers the universe of soil individuals to be represented b y one large hyperspherical swarm of points in n-space with n corresponding to the numbers of independent factors or processes involved. Two kinds of ordination have been used in soil studies. Q-type ordination or analysis of objects operates on a similarity matrix of objects and examines the distribution of objects in object-space to find dimensions along which the objects are distributed. R-type ordination or analysis of variables operates on the covariance matrix variables to find dimensions in variable-/space. These dimensions are formed by clusters of covariant variables. Objects then can be located in varible-space by their coordinates along the axis of these dimensions.
A. Q-TYPE ORDINATION
Ordination of this type was used in one of the first attempts at numerical classification of soils by Hole and Hironaka (1960) and Bidwell and Hole (1964); however, the method is suboptimal as shown by Rayner (1969). The method of principal coordinates analysis (PCO) developed by Gower ( I 966) operates best on a Euclidean distance matrix (dissimilarity coefficients) but may be used with other similarity coefficients. The procedure is discussed in detail by Webster (1975) who points out that PCO gives a good view of the general structure of a population but that distances between indiviudals are imperfectly represented. This is just the opposite of cluster analysis; thus PCO is complementary to cluster analysis in exploring relationships in n-space. A problem of representing the results of PCO comes from the fact that for soils a number of principal axes are often produced, whereas only two, or at the most three, can be shown in a single diagram. Thus it may take a number of diagrams, each showing a pair of principal coordinates to represent the results. The interpretation of such two-dimensional scatter diagrams must be done with care, because two individuals which appear to be closely similar in one diagram, may actually be at an considerable distance along another axis in another diagram. Another problem is that variation along a principal coordinate is not always interpretable as to its source; i.e., variation due t o differences in reaction, clay content, etc. The first use of this approach was by Rayner (1966) who utilized the method of Gower (1 966); and it was again used in a later publication by Rayner (1969). Anderson (1 971) used Rayner’s similarity matrix and applied a Q-type technique called “Nonmetric Multidimensional Scaling,” which uses the rank order of the elements of a similarity matrix rather than the raw matrix. Muir et al. (1970) also used PCO on 63 soil profiles of four soil series in Scotland. They plotted the individual soils on the first two coordinates but found that three of the four soil series could not be well separated. This is not surprising since the first two
56
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
coordinates accounted for only about 28% of the total variance. Norris and Dale (1971) used a slightly modified form of PCO as part of a procedure for comparing the classifications derived from two sets of data (field and laboratory) on the same soils and found a high degree of correlation between the two; canonical correlations between the two sets for the first three principal coorinates were 0.89,O. 62, and 0.58, respectively.
B. R-TYPE ORDINATION
1. Principal Components Analysis The most commonly used R-type procedure is the Principal Components Analysis (PCA) which operates on the matrix of correlation coefficients (r) between all pairs of variables. It extracts orthogonal, independent dimensions from the data which are called principal axes. The coordinates of individuals on these axes are linear combinations of the original variables. Commonly, as few as three principal axes will account for a large portion, as about 75%, of the original total variance of the data matrix. Like Principal Coordinates Analysis (PCO), it provides an accurate representation of the relationships between major groups and clusters, but is less accurate in reproducing differences between closely similar individuals. Also like PCO,it is often difficult to interpret the significance of an axis (dimension) in that it is made up of a combination of all variables. Sometimes an axis may be interpreted rather generally by examination of the so-called factor loadings of the variables on the dimension. However, a threedimensional representation of the individuals plotted in relation to the three axes gives a general picture of the taxonomic structure. More importantly, the coordinates for individuals in each dimension (factor scores) can be used as the data for one of the clustering methods, rather than the raw data matrix. This greatly reduces the number of variables used in clustering. Principal components analysis has been used in a number of soil studies: Anderson (1971) applied this method to the data of Rayner (1966) and then refined the results by examination of the residuals (residual variance) on each individual after extracting the variance represented by two dimensions; he also applied another procedure called “minimization of a quatradic loss function,” which is a procedure for extracting the best minimum number of dimensions from the total number. Barkham and Norris (1970) used principal components analysis on both the vegetation and soils and examined the realtionships between the two by comparing the first two vegetative components with four soil components and various soil variables and by canonical correlations between components of the two
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
57
systems. They considered this procedure to provide a workable strategy to investigate a complex ecosystem. Cipra et al. (1970) used PCA together with cluster analysis to study relationships among 59 world soils. A three-dimensional diagram based on the first three principal components revealed n o very distinct clusters, but a number of remotely related individual soils. The three axes could be interpreted as composites of various soil properties but these did not appear to be very logically related. The first component contained high factor loadings on chroma and clay content. However, ArMey (1971) using factor analysis on these same data found chroma and clay content to fall into separate, independent dimensions. Still, Cipra et al. (1970) considered this a meaningful method of visualizing relationships between soils. Cuanalo and Webster (1970) also used both principal components with projection of individuals on the first two dimensions together with clustering methods. They concluded that soil data be first examined by ordination by principal componenets before attempting a classification of a set of soils. Norris (1971a) applied PCA t o two groups of soils using two sets of date: laboratory and field for each group. From the examination of two-dimensional diagrams, they concluded that the variation of soils can be characterized by the variation of a relatively few properties, and that there is a considerable correspondence between groupings based upon field and laboratory data separately. They suggest that where this is generally the case, soil classification might well be based on a relatively few dimensions defined by a few soil variables, but rarely by one singly. Norris (1972) applied the results derived above (Norris, 1971a) to applied problems in soil mapping and classification and as an aid in understanding the causes for soil variation. Norris (1971b) also used PCA to assist in the solution of a statistical problem which arises in the use of soil data resulting from the fact that many variables are included. This problem is called matrix singularity and may result from a variable being completely determined by one or more other variables (i.e., there is a high degree of correlation among groups of variables) or when the matrix is overdefined (i.e., there are more variables than individuals). Thus the use of PCA reduces the large number of variables to a few components or dimensions, and the overdefinition is relieved with a minimum loss of information.
2. Principal Factor Analysis Principal factor analysis (PFA) has been used much less frequently than principal components analysis in soil studies. PFA differs from PCA in that in the latter the diagonals of the correlation matrix of variables are filled with unities, whereas in PFA the unities are replaced by so-called communalities, the percentage of variation due to the common factors. In PCA the axes are
58
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
orthogonal, whereas in factor analysis they can be rotated and can be permitted to become obliquely related, i.e., correlated. This is particularly suited to soil data, which are often highly intercorrelated, as discussed earlier in this paper. Arkley (1968, 1971) used a form of factor analysis described by Tryon and Bailey (1970) which they call Cumulative Communality Cluster Analysis of variables (CC5), wherein each dimension is defined by a minimal number of definer variables which are both intercorrelated and have closely similar patterns of correlations with other variables in the analysis; at the same time the dimensions are held to be as independent of each other as possible. This has the great advantage that the dimensions produced in this way are defined by one a few variables, rather than by factor loadings on all variables, and thus are readily identifiable. Arkley (1971) analyzed the data for 59 soils, used also by Cipra et ul. (1970), by both PCA and PFA and obtained five dimensions which were identical except for the number of definer variables. The exact comparison was made possible by a program by Tryon and Bailey (1970) called cluster summary analysis (CSA2); this program extracted definer variables from PCA which could be compared with those from CC5. The computer program package developed by Tryon and Bailey is a tremendously powerful tool, as it contains a wide variety of options including various methods of principal component and factor analyses which can be applied with great simplicity for purposes of comparison. Also, the output contains a thorough set of statistical parameters for analytic purposes. The package also contains an iterative centroid clustering program for indiviudals, which can be modified at will. Arkley (1971) used the programs described to analyze six different sets of soil data and found that five dimensions accounted for 85% of the squared raw correlations in 220 California soils, 87% in 620 California soils, and 72.1% in 59 world soils; seven dimensions accounted for 75.5% of the squared raw correlations in 148 Ohio soils, and 80.9% in 86 world soils. In every case only about three or four definer variables were required for each dimension. The evidence is clear that relatively few, say 20 to 25, variables are sufficient for soil classification.
C. PRESENTATION OF RESULTS OF ORDINATION
Ordination can be presented as two- or three-dimensional scatter diagrams of the component or factor scores of the individuals along each axis. A typical two-dimensional scatter diagram is shown in Fig. 3 in which the two axes are the first and second components of a principal components analysis (PCA). However, in interpretation of such a diagram it must be kept in mind that individuals that appear to be in close proximity on the diagram, may actually be separated at considerable distance along the axis of a third component.
59
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
I
I
71.
47.
89.
L
-6
-4
-2
I
0 la1 component
2
4
6
FIG. 3. Scatter diagram in which the first principal component is plotted against the second for 85 soil profiles. Reprinted from Cuanalo and Webster (1970), by permission of the publisher, Oxford University Press.
Three-dimensional diagrams are more difficult to prepare than two-dimensional ones, but can be prepared using a computer; and these can represent relationships more completely. The pin and ball diagram, a commonly used type, is shown in Fig. 4 and a rotated view of the same is depicted in Fig. 5. Again it should be kept in mind that a fourth component may well separate individuals which appear in close proximity. Where a number of independent factors or components are needed to represent the taxonomic structure, a number of diagrams may be required to present a complete picture of the structure. IV. Soil as an Anisotropic Entity
Soil descriptions and analytical data have been treated in several different ways in an attempt to solve the problem of homology, i.e., the comparisons of profiles, layers, or horizons. It is sometimes difficult to decide which horizons should be compared between soils with different sets of horizons designated in the conventional way by soil scientists. Comparisons based upon identical depths
60
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
-
~-
I ~
FIG. 4. Front view of a three-dimensional scatter diagram based upon centroid component analysis projections. Reprinted from Cipra et uf. (1970), by permission of the publisher, American Society of Agronomy.
are often inappropriate due both to inherent differences in thickness in the soil or to depths altered by erosion.
A. SOIL PROFILE AS AN ARRAY OF SOIL PROPERTIES One approach that has been used considers the soil profile as an entity, and the conventional designation of master soil horizons A, B, C, and R in the soil description have been used as a basis of comparison. Soil properties such as the color and structure of the A1 and B2 horizons, texture of the Al, B2, and C, and difference between maximum clay in the B and minimum clay in the A horizon have been used. This treatment has been applied by Bidwell and Hole (1964), Bidwell et al. (1964), Cipra et al. (1970), Hole and Hironaka (1960), Moore and Russell (1967), Rozkov (1974), Sarkar etal. (1966), Webster (1973), and Arkley (1 968,197 1). The use of soil “profile” data or soil horizon data has been criticized on the grounds that (a) the designation of horizons by the field scientist is subjective and thus violates one objective of numerical classification which is maximum objectivity, and (b) that it is subject to human error, even when the designation of horizons follows defined rules. This author is inclined to the view that the designation of horizons according to well-established rules such as those published in soil survey guides and handbooks or in “Soil Classification” (Soil
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
61
77
\ /
‘ I
Y+)q \ &
I(+)
FIG. 5. Same as Fig. 4 viewed from the reader’s right.
Survey Staff, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 1960) is sufficiently objective and accurate for the purposes of soil classification when carried out by a trained soil scientist. However, this is a personal view biased by my own long expeirence as a soil surveyor, and I have no wish to dispute the opposite view. The use of selected “profile” data or data by specified pedogenic horizons does have certain advantages, in that the mathematical treatment does not involve the analysis of a three-dimensional data matrix of variables X layers (or horizons) X soil individuals.
B. SOIL DATA BY LAYERS OR HORIZONS
1. Uniform Soil Depth Layers-Direct Comparison Soil samples taken at specified depths and compared directly have been used by Barkham and Norris (1970), Cuanalo and Webster (1970), Hughes and Lindley (1955), Horris (1971a, 1972), Norris and Loveday (1971), and Webster and Burrough (1972). This method is appropriate only over small areas where
62
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
the arbitrary depths chosen can reasonably be expected to sample comparable portions of the soil profiles.
2. Horizon or Layer Matching Methods Rayner (1966) devised a method of calculating similarity between soils by average of maximum similarity between all pairs of horizons; matching first the horizons of soil A with soil B and then soil B with A. There are two difficulties with this procedure. First, the amount of computer time is multipled by twice the number of horizons, and second, maximum simiiarity may well occur between surface horizons and deep horizons as in the C horizons, which seem inappropriate. This method was also used by Lamp (1972), and the similarity matrix of Rayner (1966) was also used by Anderson (1971) and Muir et al. (1970). In order to remedy both objections to Rayner’s method, Grigal and Arneman (1969) devised a similar method except that for a given horizon of soil A, comparisons are limited to three of soil B. The three are the horizons of soil B at the equivalent depth to the horizon of soil A plus the one just above and just below. The horizons of soil B are then compared t o A in the same way, and the average of the maximum similarity between pairs used for comparison of the two profiles.
3. Soil Profilesas a Sequence of Layers Norris and Dale (197 1) developed a method based on a statistical device called a “transition matrix.” In their procedure, all layers or horizons are grouped by one of the clustering methods into classes which are assigned an arbitrary number as a designation. Each profile then is described by a sequence of horizon-type numbers. Thus for a 10-layer profile in which the first 3 layers are of type 2, and the remaining layers type 5, the soil profile is defined as 2,2,2,5,5,5,5,5,5,5. Each soil profile then is redefined as a transition matrix which records the number of times each type-number follows every other type-number down the sequence. In the example given above, the transition matrix of n X n horizons types for that soil would contain all zeros except for matrix position (2,2) would contain a 2, position (2,s) would contain a 1 , and position ( 5 , s ) would contain a 6. Soil profiles defined by transition matrices can be sorted on the basis of minimum information gain statistic of Dale et al. (1970). Norris and Dale (1971) claim several advantages to the method: (1) horizons or layers are conveniently and objectively classified, (2) the transition matrix includes information about relative position, and (3) the number and thickness of layers need not be identical. A major difficulty is the amount of computer time and computer storage space involved. This author agrees that the
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
63
first advantage mentioned is a real one. However, I examined their matrices of profile X horizon types and found that a simple matching coefficient followed by UPGMA gave almost identical soil profile groupings as their much more complicated method. Also it appears to me that there is considerable loss of information in converting the horizon data into a transition matrix. The transition matrix method was also used by Moore et al. (1972). They point out that grouping based upon the transition matrix is dependent entirely on the relation between each layer and the one preceding it.
C. SOIL PROFILE AS AN ARRAY OF DEPTH FUNCTIONS
Colwell (1 970) introduced a procedure applicable to continuous variables such as chemical data. In this method, the depth function for each variable is characterized by fitting the data to an orthogonal polynomial. Colwell found that a polynomial of the fifth degree gives a reasonably accurate fit. The coefficients of the polynomial were used to characterize mean depth trends of four Great Soil Groups for 9 variables, and their confidence intervals at various depths. However, no classification of individual soils was attempted. Campbell et al. (1970) used the coefficients of orthogonal polynomial depth functions as a means of characterizing soil profdes, but concluded that such a smooth depth function will not adequately describe the profile, and did not use the technique further. Moore et al. (1972) used orthogonal polynomial coefficients to represent shape and profile means to represent magnitude as variables for comparing soil profiles. They found wide variation in goodness-of-fit between profiles and between soil properties. However, when the profile mean was weighted equally (5 X) to the 5 polynomial coefficients, they found profile groups similar to those produced by layer by layer comparison weighted by a negative exponential depth function ce-‘” where y is depth in centimeters and c is a constant. They adopted c = 0.02 as most appropriate.
V. Statistical Methods for Comparing Classification
As pointed out by Sneath and Sokal (1973), there is n o general agreement on the optimal classification, except in cladistics where the optimal classification is one best representing the branching pattern of organisms through evolutionary history. For soils there is clearly n o such criterion. However, it is possible to make some statistical comparisons which may be useful.
64
RODNEY J.ARKLEY
A. COPHENETIC CORRELATION
This procedure is described in detail by Sneath and Sokal (1973); it analyzes the level at which the individuals are joined to each other in a dendrogram, and compares that matrix of similarity with the original one by correlation coefficient between the two arrays of values. The higher the correlation coefficient, the more accurately the dendrogram represents the original pattern of similarities. This method was applied by Lamp (1972), and by Grigal and Arneman (1969). The latter compared different sets of data on the same soils and found the cophenetic correlation between field properties alone, and other data sets were 0.817 for comparison with all properties, and greater than 0.74 for three other data sets. Cipra et al. (1970) also applied cophenetic correlation to ordination by three principal components, and to dendrograms based on Euclidean distance and correlation coefficient; the correlations obtained were 0.78, 0.83, and 0.62, respectively.
B. COEFFICIENT OF ASSOCIATION
Grigal and Arneman (1969) used a method of comparing classifications developed by Goodman and Kruskal(l954) to compare numerical classifications with the Seventh Approximation Classification of the U.S.Department of Agriculture and found a low order of correspondence attributed to the differences in criteria used.
C. WILK’S CRITERION
Webster (1971) describes this method based on within group and between group variance extended to multivariate data. He illustrated its use comparing soil map classes at three different map scales and by comparing classes formed according to profile appearnace and by numerical methods. He concluded that the criterion can be used to compare classifications effectively. Webster and Burrough (1972) used Wilk’s criterion to help determine the number of classes most appropriate to use in soil mapping over a small area and to determine the similarity between clusters and previously established soil series. VI. Conclusions and Evaluation
From this welter of different methods employed, including different ways of treating soil profile data, different coefficients of similarity, clustering, and
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
65
divisive methods, is it possible to decide which are the best methods to apply to soils? Although there is no criterion by which a classification can be judged to be the best, it does appear that some methods can be applied more logically to soils than others.
A. THE CHOICE OF METHODS
1. Dhta Selection and Standardization First let us consider the kinds of data that have to be dealt with in soil classification. Field descriptions contain much information that is probably best treated as either ranked or unranked multistate variables. Laboratory data are primarily continuous variables. Thus most soil data sets contain mixed variable types. The data scaling method of Talkington (1967) with standardization of variables by range, and that of Burr (1968) with standardization by variance can accommodate mixed data. If Euclidean distance is used as the similarity coefficient, the results from either method will be about the same. Very rare extreme values on a variable should probably be truncated as advocated by Talkington (1967). Variables with highly skewed distributions should be transformed by logarithmic or square root transformation. The choice of variables to be used will depend, of course, upon the nature of the data available or the purpose of the classification. However, for a general classification my investigations (Arkley, 1968, 1971) suggest that a minimal set of soil properties should include at least one or several measurements representing the following dimensions: 1. Soil reaction such as surface and subsoil pH, carbonate depth, exchangeable Na or S.A.R. 2. Hue and chroma. 3. Texture or contents of clay and sand, or clay and silt, and gravel or stone con tent. 4. Soil color value such as thickness of surface layer with value of 3 or less, or color value per se. 5 . Depth to and degree of mottling and/or other evidence of wetness or poor drainage. 6. Degree of profde differentiation such as difference in clay content between the surface and B-horizon or subsoil, clay films, and structure of the subsoil. 7. Solum thickness. Most of these, as can be seen, are properties measurable in the field. Since the purpose of soil classification is related mainly to land use or plant growth in the field, it is relevant only to soil distributions that are mapped by field methods primarily, supplemented by laboratory analysis only to a limited degree. As indicated in the section (II,C,2) on data selection, soil variables in a data set are
66
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
often highly correlated. Norris (1971a), Grigal and Arneman (1969), Hole and Hironaka (1960), and Norris and Dale (1971) all found a high degree of similarity between the soils classified by numerical methods when the results of laboratory versus field data were compared.
2. Similarity Coefficients Comparisons of two or more similarity coefficients are included in several papers including those of Moore and Russell (1967), Cipra et al. (1970), and Cuanalo and Webster (1970). These comparisons provide no basis for unequivocal recommendations, but it appears that the Euclidean distance is most suitable to soil data on theoretical grounds as well as its ease in conceptual representation. The correlation coefficient and the Canberra metric seem to be less suitable.
3. Sorting Strategies Of the numerous sorting strategies available, nearest neighbor or single linkage sorting seems to be the least useful for soil classification because of its characteristic “chaining.” Furthest neighbor or complete linkage sorting produces the least chaining but is conceptually less satisfactory for soils than centroid sorting (UPGMC) or average linkage (UPGMA). Centroid sorting requires a larger computer storage capacity, but it has the advantages or producing initial clusters of specified degree of within-group homogeneity and also can be applied iteratively to find a stable taxonomic structure. The minimum withingroup variance clustering of Anderson (1971) is also an attractive form of centroid clustering as it can be presented as an analysis of variance.
4. Ordination Methods Ordination per se does not provide a classification but does reveal relationships between individuals and groups when presented in one or several two- or three-dimensional scatter diagrams. Ordination by principal coordinate analysis (PCO), a Q-type analysis of the similarity matrix shows relationships between individuals but the axes are often difficult to interpret. Principal components analysis (PCA), an R-type analysis of the variables is more easily interpretable, but still the components are made up of variable weights on all variables, and further examination or analysis is required to identify the meaning of each component. Factor analysis (PFA), another form of R-analysis, can be used for ordination as well as a means of reducing the number of variables in the analysis, and the axis can be identified as to the nature of the dimensions they represent. In applying either PCO or PFA, the correlation matrix should be examined for
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
redundant variables (i.e., with very high correlation coefficients as one of the pair eliminated before proceeding further.
67
> 0.95) and
B. A SUGGESTED PROCEDURE FOR A GENERAL SOIL CLASSIFICATION The cluster analysis of soils described herein is based on the assumption that soils do indeed fall naturally into discrete clusters or classes. For large numbers of soils, as in an entire nation, a whole continent, or the world, this assumption may not be valid and soils may well form a continuum in multidimensional variable space. For the latter case, a procedure suggests itself which is based upon the idea of arbitrarily defined, well-separated centroids, each centroid thus representing an hypothetical or perhaps an actual modal soil. In order to define the centroids, each variable or dimension is divided into appropriate segments of its total range and the midpoint of each segment established as an arbitrary centroid. For example if we accept the meaningful range of soil clay content to be from 0 to 50, the segments would be 0-10, 10-20, 20-30,3040, 40-50+ and the mid-point centroids would be located at 5, 15, 25, 35, and 45%clay. With this approach, soil individuals would be allocated to the centroid to which it is nearest in n-space on the basis of Euclidean distance. For soils considered as a continuum, this has the greatest advantage over conventional heirarchical classification in that no dichotomous separation is made on the basis of a single variable separated at a single point along its range. For example the soils classified as Mollisols are separated from other soils at a high category on the basis of a specified thickness of a dark, organic rich surface soil. With this kind of dichotomy a small variation in this single property for two soils separates them regardless of the degree of similarity of all other properties. The allocation of soils by over-all similarity to definite centroids avoids this problem entirely, so that each class is distinct from every other in at least one dimension, and individuals within a class are all closely similar to the defined centroid. It is interesting to consider the number of classes formed by this kind of procedure. The number depends upon the number of segments into which each variable is divided raised to the power of the number of variables as follows: Number of dimensions or variables Number of Segments
4
6
5
3 4 5
81 256 625
243 1,024 3,125
7 ~
~~
729 4,096 15,625
2,187 16,384 78,125
8
9
6,561 65,536 390,624
19,683 262,144 1.95 X lo6
~~~
68
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
On the basis of intuition, it appears that seven dimensions divided into five segments each producing 78,125 classes of which perhaps 20% might remain unoccupied would be adequate for a classification of the soils of the world. However, it might be necessary to first stratify the soils such as separating organic soils from mineral soils,and perhaps separating soils of arid regions from those of humid regions as different soil properties might be used as criterion variables for classification of the two major kinds of soils. Soils of subhumid regions then might be classified according to both systems, thus avoiding a dichotomous separation between arid and humid regions. Factor analysis of the kind used by Arkley (1968, 1971) seems to be an effective way of finding a suitable number of independent dimensions for such a classification procedure. This kind of system could be used for setting up a number of hierarchical arrangements depending upon the categorical order in which the dimensions are used, or it could be used as a coordinate system of classification. The latter would be particularly useful to show relationships among soils. For example, if we have five segments labeled VL, L, M, H, VH and seven dimensions, then a sequence of soils varying only in one dimension would be found in classes labeled such as:
VL, H, H, H, H,H,H L, H, H, H, H, H, H M,H, H, H,H,H, H H, H, H, H, H, H, H VH, H, H, H, H, H, H Assuming all classes to be occupied, there would be 15,625 possible such sequences to be examined. These should very well keep the pedologist of the world occupied for some time. Finally, it appears that cluster analysis of soils is a most effective means of classifying soils when the number of distinct soils or soil groups is limited as within a relatively small land area. For large areas including large numbers of soils, clusters of similar soils are likely to be either nonexistent or existing only with diffuse boundaries. In which case a coordinate system based upon predefined centroids is more likely to produce an effective classification system.
REFERENCES Anderson, A. J. B. 1971. J. Int. Assoc. Marh. Geol. 3.1-14. Arkley, R. J. 1968. Trans. Int. Congr.SoilSci.,9rh, 1968 Vol. IV,pp. 187-192. Arkley, R. J. 1971. SoilSci. Soc. Am, Proc. 35,312-315. Avery, B. W. 1968. Trans. Int. Congr. SoilSci., 9th, 1968Vol. IV, pp. 169-176.. Barkham, J. P., and Norris, J. M. 1970. Ecology 51,630-639. Bidwell, 0.W., and Hole, F. D. 1964. Soil Sci. Soc. Am., Roc. 28,263-268.
STATISTICAL METHODS IN SOIL CLASSIFICATION RESEARCH
69
Bidwell, 0. W., Markus, L. F., and Sarkar, P. K. 1964. Trans Int. Congr. Soil Sci., 8th, 1964 Vol. V, pp. 933-941. Bray, J. R., and Curtis, J. T. 1958. Ecol. Monogr. 27,325-349. Brisbane, P. G.,and Rovira, A. D. 19611.J. Cen. Microbiol. 26,379-392. Burr, E. J. 1968. Aust. Comput. J. 1.97-99. Campbell, N. A., Mulcahy, M. J., and McArthur, W. M. 1970. Aust. J. Soil Res. 8,42-58. Cipra, J. E., Bidwell, 0. W., and Rohlf, F. J. 1970. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. R o c . 34,281-287. Colwell, J. D. 1970. Aust. J. SoilRes. 20, 221-238. Critchton, J. E. 1975. Ph.D. Thesis, Dep. Soil Sci., University of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. Cuanalo, H. E. de la C., and Webster R. 1970. J. Soil Sci. 21,340-352. Dale, M. B., McNaughton-Smith, P., Williams, W. T.,and Lance, G.N. 1970. Aust. Comput. J. 2,9-13. Dryden, L. 1935. Am. J. Sci. 29,393-408. Eades, D. C. 1965.Syst. Zool.l4,98-100. Gibbons, F. R. 1968. Trans. Int. Congr. Soil Sci., 9th, 1968 Vol. IV, pp. 159-168. Goodman, L. A., and Kruskal, W. H. 1954.J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 49,123-163. Gower, J. C. 1966. Biometriku 53,325-338. Grigal, D. F., and Arneman, H. F. 1969. Soil Sci. SOC.A m , Proc. 33,433-438. Hole, F. D., and Hironaka, M. 1960. Soil Sci. SOC.Am., Roc. 24,309-312. Hughes, R. E., and Lindley, D. V. 1955. Nature (Lmdon) 175,806-807. Karmeli, D., Pitkovski, G., and Regev, J. 1968. Technion-lsr. Inst., Tech. Fac. Agric. Eng., h b l . 50,l-10. Lamp, J. 1972. D. Agric. Dissertation, Fac. Agric., Christian-Albrechts University, Kiel. Lance, G. N., and Williams, W. T. 1967a. Comput. J. 9,373-380. Lance, G. N., and Williams,W. T. 1967b. Aust. Comput. J. 1,15-20. Moore, A. W.,and Russell, J. S. 1967. Geoderma 1,139-158. Moore, A. W., Russell, J. S., and Ward, W. T. 1972. J. Soil Sci. 23,193-209. Muir, J. W., Hardie, H. G . M., Inkson, R. H. E., and Anderson, A. J. B. 1970. Geoderma 4, 81-90. Norris, J. M. 1971a. J. Soil Sci. 22,69-89. Norris, J. M. 1971b. Pedobiologia 11,410-416. Norris, J. M. 1972. J. Soil Sci. 23,62-75. Norris, J. M., and Dale, M. B. 1971. Soil Sci. Soc. Am., Proc. 35,487-491. Norris, H. M., and Loveday, J. 1971. J. Soil Sci. 22,395-400. Rao, C. R. 1948. J. R. Stat. Soc., Ser. B 10, 159-193. Rayner, J. H. 1966. J. Soil Sci. 17, 79-92. Rayner, J. H. 1969. Sysf. Assoc. 8, 31-39. Rohlf, F. J. 1963. Ann. Entomol. SOC.Am. 56,798-804. Rozhkov, V. A. 1974. Geoderma 12,175-182. Russell, J. S., and Moore, A. W. 1967. Geoderma 1,47-68. Russell, J. S., and Moore, A. W. 1968. Trans Int. Congr. Soil Sci., 9th, 1968 Vol. IV, pp. 205-21 3. Sarkar, P. K., Bidwell, 0. W., and Marcus, L. F. 1966. Soil Sci. SOC. Am., Proc. 30, 269-272. Sneath, P.H.A., and Sokal, R. R. 1973. “Numerical Taxonomy.” Freeman, San Francisco, California. Soil Survey Staff, U.S. Department of Agriculture. 1960. “Soil Classification.” US Govt. Printing Office, Washington, D.C. Sokal, R. R., and Sneath, P.H.A. 1963. “Principles of Numerical Taxonomy.” Freeman, San Francisco, California.
70
RODNEY J. ARKLEY
Talkington, L. 1967. Syst. Zool. 16,149-152. Tryon, R. C., and Bailey, D. E. 1970. “Cluster Analysis.” McCraw-Hill, New York. Van den Driessche, R., and Maignien, R. 1965. Pedologie 3,79-88. Varty, A., and White, D. 1964. Clay Miner. Bull. 5 , 4 6 5 4 7 3 . Webster, R. 1971. J. Soil Sci. 22,254-260. Webster, R. 1973. Math. Geol. 5,27-31. Webster, R. 1975. Soil Sci. 119,394-404. Webster, R., and Burrough, P. A. 1972. J. Soil Sci. 23,210-221.
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES D. N. Maynard,' A. V. Barker,' P.
L. Minotti? and N. H. Peck3
I. Introduction .................................................. 11. Hazards of Nitrate and Nitrite to Human Health . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
A. AcuteToxicity .............................................. B. Other Effects ............................................... C. Relative Dangers of Nitrite Poisoning from Various Nitrate or Nitrite Sources .................................................... D. Nitrosamines ................................................ ... . . .. 111. Factors Affecting Nitrate Accumulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Environmental Factors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Genetic Factors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . .. .. . . C. Nutrient Supply ............................................. IV. Nitrate Concentrations in Vegetables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Distribution in the Plant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . B. Fresh Vegetables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Processed Vegetables . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . .. ... .. . .. . . . . . . . . D. Critical Nitrate Concentrations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Growth and Nitrogen Management of Vegetable Crops . . . . . . . . . . . V. Conclusions ................................................... References ....................................................
.
.
.
.. . .
.
....
.. .
.
.. . . . .. .. . .. .
..... . .
. .. .
. ..
.
.
71 72 72 73 74 76 77 71 88 94 98 98 99 101 104 108 112 114
I. Introduction
Nitrate accumulation in plants is a natural phenomenon resulting from uptake of the nitrate ion in excess of its reduction and subsequent assimilation. As discussed in the following pages, accumulation of nitrate is dependent on and related to the genetic makeup of the plant, the nitrate supplying-power of the soil, and the environmental conditions under which the plant is grown. In addition, nitrate concentrations differ in plant parts and with age of the plant. Much recent interest and investigation has focused on nitrate in the environment, in drinking water, and in foods and feeds for man and his livestock. The
' Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts. 'Department of Vegetable Crops, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York. Department of Seed and Vegetable Sciences, New York State Agricultural Experiment Station, Geneva, New York. 71
72
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
potential for nitrate reduction to nitrite and its adverse effect on human and animal health is in large measure responsible for this concern. Several recent reviews on the general importance of nitrate have been prepared (Committee on Nitrate Accumulation , 1972; Deeb and Sloan, 1975; Viets and Hageman, 1971; Wright and Davison, 1964), and the reader is referred to them for a general consideration of the scope and magnitude of the “nitrate problem.” Among the food products consumed by man, fresh and processed vegetables have most often been cited as the major source of dietary nitrate intake. For this reason, much research has been conducted in the United States and elsewhere in the past few years to study nitrate accumulation in vegetables and the factors influencing its occurrence. This review is based largely on the authors’ own work with vegetable crops and is generously supplemented with supporting data from the recent literature. I I. Hazards of Nitrate and Nitrite to Human Health
Man is continuously exposed to nitrate and nitrite through drugs, water, and foods. Usually the amounts of nitrate and nitrite are small, and no harm results, but nitrate or nitrite in high concentrations or under special circumstances may cause great economic losses through illness or death. Nitrate toxicity is relatively low and varies widely, the fatal adult dose in humans being in the order of 15 to 70 mg of nitrate-N per kilogram of body weight (Burden, 1961; Lee, 1970). Nitrite, formed from the reduction of nitrate or present as a food additive, is the factor that presents health hazards. A lethal dose of nitrite also varies widely but appears to be about 20 mg nitrite-N per kilogram of adult body weight (Burden, 1961; Lee, 1970). Before ingestion, the reduction of nitrate to nitrite may occur through the action of microorganisms present in water, plants, or food during storage or by bacterial contamination of sterile food in opened containers. Natural plant enzymes may contribute to some nitrite accumulation in stored foods. Nitrite may also be formed from nitrate after ingestion. In humans with healthy alimentary canals, nitrate is absorbed rapidly without reduction in the upper intestines, but gastrointestinal disturbances may delay absorption and increase the chances for reduction. Reduction is more likely in infants than in adults, on one hand, because of the lesser acidity in the gastrointestinal tract which allows nitrate-reducing coliform and clostridial bacteria to survive and, on the other hand, because of higher frequency of digestive disturbances which might bring the nitrate-reducing bacteria into the upper intestinal tract. A. ACUTE TOXICITY
If the nitrite ion is absorbed into the blood, the ferrous iron of hemoglobin may be oxidized to the ferric form producing methemoglobin which cannot
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
73
transport oxygen. Methemoglobin may compose naturally about 1 % of the hemoglobin in healthy adults, 4%in newborn infants, and 6%or greater in babies with respiratory illness or diarrhea (Kubler, 1958; Lee, 1970. Luhrs, 1973). The small amount of methemoglobin normally produced can be converted enzymatically back to hemoglobin (Lee, 1970. Stolk and Smith, 1966); however, if the capacity for reconversion is exceeded, methemoglobin will build up to abnormal concentrations. Babies are much more susceptible to methemoglobin accumulation than older children or adults. Fetal hemoglobin, which may be 80% of the total hemoglobin in the newborn, is much more easily converted to methemoglobin than the regular hemoglobin of older children and adults. Infants, also, may have a temporary deficiency of the enzyme of red blood cells which converts methemoglobin to hemoglobin (Finch, 1948; Lee, 1970; Luhrs, 1973). Acute nitrite toxicity is shown by cyanosis, a bluish-purple discoloration of the skin and lips, and occurs when about 15% of the hemoglobin is oxidized to methemoglobin. A proportion of methemoglobin of 70%or more of the total hemoglobin may be fatal (Lee, 1970; Luhrs, 1973) unless relief from intravenous injection of methylene blue or thionine is provided (Lee, 1970; Stecher, 1968). Methemoglobin accumulation may be caused by chemicals other than nitrite, such as carbon monoxide, sulfa drugs, phenacetin, and aniline dyes of furniture polish, laundry-marking inks, and crayons (Luhrs, 1973). Genetic defects may cause high levels of methemoglobin to be inherited (Finch, 1948). Although generally it is the infants who are most liable for nitrite poisoning, adults who are exposed to conditions which increase methemoglobin accumulation, who have genetically high methemoglobin levels in their bloods, or who are anemic must be cautious against ingestion of nitrate or nitrite.
B. OTHER EFFECTS Acute cases of nitrate or nitrite toxicity are shown by cyanosis or methemoglobinemia as described above, but other effects more chronic in nature also result. Nitrate or nitrite in animal diets has been linked to vitamin A deficiency due to degradation of carotene by nitrite in the alimentary canal (Phillips, 1966). Also, in animals nitrate may increase the need for iodine due to abnormalities being produced in the thyroid gland (Bloomfield er al., 1961). Nitrite may also produce rapid heartbeat, peripheral vasodilatation, vomiting, and diarrhea (Luhrs, 1973). High levels of dietary nitrite have been shown to give abnormal electroencephalograms in rats (Shuval and Gruener, 1972), and although most patients with hereditary methemoglobinemia do not have mental or neurological disorders, mental retardation has been reported in patients with hereditary methemoglobinemia (Joffe and Heller, 1964). In cattle, sheep, and other livestock, abortions m a y result from their consumption of feeds
74
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
high in nitrate (Wright and Davison, 1964), but the methemoglobin content of the blood apparently must exceed 4050% for pregnancies to be terminated (Winter, 1964). Cancer, mutations, and birth defects are caused by nitrosamines, compounds formed by the reaction of nitrite and certain organic amines. More is said on this subject in the review below (Section 11, D).
C. RELATIVE DANGERS OF NITRITE POISONING FROM VARIOUS NITRATE OR NITRITE SOURCES
1. Drugs
Methemoglobinemia associated with the therapeutic use of cardiac nitrites (nitroglycerine, amyl nitrite, sodium nitrite), antidiarrheal agents (bismuth subnitrate), diuretics (ammonium nitrate), or burn treatments (silver nitrate) are rare complications from drugs (Goodman and Gilman, 1965; Greenberg er al., 1945; Marcus and Joffe, 1949; Strauch er al., 1969).
2. Water A report by Comly (1945) is responsible for our present concern over the possibility of nitrate or nitrite poisoning of infants, for the most common cause of methemoglobinemia is from the drinking of water with high nitrate concentrations, resulting in nearly 2000 cases in the United States and Europe. Numerous infants, but no adults, have died from this cause (Luhrs, 1973). Babies are naturally more susceptible to nitrite methemoglobinemia and additionally they take in proportionally more water and hence more nitrates than adults. Sterilization of water by boiling for infant formula may tend to increase the nitrate concentration in the water. In the United States all cases but one have been associated with private, usually rural, well-water supplies (Vigil et al., 1965). A survey by Walton (1951) led the United States Public Health Service in 1962 to establish a standard limiting nitrate to 10 ppm nitrate-N in drinking water (U. S. Public Health Service, 1962), since no case of infant methemoglobinemia in the United States has been reported from ingestion of water with nitrate concentrations below this standard (Walton, 1951). This standard can be met easily by municipal water supplies. The adequacy of this standard is being reevaluated, however (cf. Luhrs, 1973).
3. Foods
a. Cured Meats and Fish. Nitrate or nitrite is used in the United States for curing of meat and fish products. Cured meat or fish is permitted to have either nitrate or nitrite added at 200 ppm (U. S. Public Health Service, 1962). The
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
75
purposes of these additives are to fix a reddish pink color (nitrosylmyoglobin) in the products, to add flavor, and to protect against bacterial growth, notably Clostridium botulinum. In Europe, nitrate and nitrite are added to cheese and flour as well. Cases of methemoglobinemia have occurred with children and adults as the result of accidental use of excessive amounts of these additives in meat (Bakshi et ul., 1967; Singley, 1962), but no cases have occurred at the permitted levels of addition. b. Vegetables. Richardson (1907) reported on a survey of nitrate concentrations of fresh vegetables obtained in retail markets in the Chicago area. He concluded that the nitrate concentrations of fresh vegetables, including beets (Beta vulguris L.), radish (Raphanus sutivus L.), spinach (Spinach oleruceu L.), eggplant (Solanum melongenu L,), lettuce, (Luctucu sutivu L.), celery (Apium gruveolens L.), turnips (Brussicu rupu L.), parsley (Petroselinum crispum Nym.), summer squash (Cucurbitu pep0 L.), cabbage (Brussicuoleruceu var. cupituta L.), cauliflower (Brussica oleruceu var. botrytis L.), and carrots (Dmnts curota L.), in most cases were higher than those of cured meats. He also concluded that the average person would take in more nitrate from vegetables than from meat foods. Based on the available data in subsequent surveys (Brown and Smith, 1966, 1967; Jackson et ul., 1967; Maynard and Barker, 1972; Wilson, 1943, 1949) since Richardson’s time, it is suggested that the nitrate concentrations in fresh vegetables have not changes appreciably in the past 65 years. Nitrate is a natural constituent in plants, and concentrations within plants vary with a number of environmental and genetic factors. Plant parts eaten as the vegetable and the amount of nitrate available in the soil appear to be major factors determining whether or not a vegetable will behigh in nitrate. Any N fertilizer added as nitrate or capable of being oxidized to nitrate by soil microorganisms and applied in generous quantities to a crop will usually lead to nitrate accumulation. These and other factors are discussed in more detail in other parts of this article (Sections 111, A and 111, C). Although the nitrate content of vegetables can be rather high, the nitrite content of vegetables is relatively low (Committee on Nitrate Accumulation, 1972). Nitrate may be converted to nitrite during storage of plant products as the result of bacterial action or plant nitrate reductase activity (Kubler, 1958; Luhrs, 1973). About 50 cases of methemoglobinemia from eating vegetables have been reported, and very few of these occurred in the United States (Luhrs, 1973). All of the reported cases occurred with infants under one year of age, and all but one case, which occurred from strained beets, have involved fresh spinach or carrots which had been prepared into baby food (Committee on Nitrate Accumulation, 1972; Keating et ul., 1973; Luhrs, 1973). Many of the cases of methemoglobinemia occurred with these baby foods prepared from fresh vegetables and stored without refrigeration for a day or more (Luhrs, 1973; Phillips, 1968). No federal standards are established for nitrate concentrations in canned or
76
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
fresh vegetables, but Simon (1966) recommended that no spinach should be given to children under 3 months of age, that spinach used for infant feeding contain no more than 0.07% nitrate-N on a dry weight basis, and that prepared spinach be kept refrigerated. Knauer (1970) estimated the maximum safe level of nitrate-N to be 0.1% of the dry matter. Most baby foods (Lee, 1970) appear to equal or exceed the standard suggested by Simon, but millions of jars of canned spinach, beets, and carrots are sold annually in the United States without medical reports of infant methemoglobinemia although it is conceivable that many cases go unreported. Simon’s value seems to be rather low considering the facts that only when spinach is grown in unfertilized plots or solely on ammonium-N nutrition will this proposed standard be met (Barker et al., 1971; Mills, 1975). Lorenz and Weir (1974) and Maynard and Barker (1974) indicated that it would be very difficult for an adult to get a toxic dose of nitrate from even excessively fertilized vegetables, assuming the estimates of toxic doses are valid.
D. NITROSAMINES The presence of nitrite and secondary amines together may lead to the formation of nitrosamines, which are carcinogenic, teratogenic, and mutagenic compounds (Committee on Nitrate Accumulation, 1972). Nitrite may be formed from the nitrate in foods or may be added to foods as a preservative. Information on the occurrence of secondary amines in the environment is scanty, but they are potentially present from a number of sources including foods, tobacco smoke, and flavorings (Lijinsky and Epstein, 1970). Evidence for nitrosation in foods is limited, and some of the reports of nitrosamine occurrence in foods may have been based on inadequate analytical procedures (Wolff and Wasserman, 1972). Most analytical procedures are subject to criticism because of the wide range of physical properties of nitrosamines and the difficulty of detecting nitrosamines at low concentrations. It must be questioned, therefore, as to whether or not nitrosamines exist in the environment (Walters, 1973). Some cases of occurrence of nitrosamines in feeds and foods are apparent. An outbreak of liver disease in sheep in Norway was attributed to a diet of herring preserved with nitrite (Sakshaug et al., 1965). Sen et al. (1969) reported that fish preserved with nitrite formed nitrosamines upon cooking. Cooking apparently increases the presence of secondary amines (Lijinsky and Epstein, 1970). Sen (1972) found some nitrosamines in a few samples of processed meats. Few reports of nitrosamines in vegetable foods are known. A close association was found between the occurrence of esophageal cancer in Bantu tribespeople and Mo deficiency in pumpkins (Cucurbira pep0 L.), Phaseolus, and corn (Zeu mays L.) (Burrell er al., 1966). Nitrosamines have been detected in the fruit juice of
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
77
Solanurn incanum, which is used by the Bantu people to curdle milk (Du Plessis et al., 1969). Hedler and Marquardt (1968) found nitrite and nitrosamines in wheat and flour. Keybets et al. (1970) could not detect nitrosamines in nitratecontaining spinach under normal processing conditions. 111.
Factors Affecting Nitrate Accumulation
A. ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS
All things being equal, nitrate concentrations of plant tissues can be expected to bear some relationship to the availability of nitrate in the root zone and, in many cases, to the amount of fertilizer-N applied. Environmental variables may exert a marked effect on nitrate accumulation, but they are difficult if not impossible to manipulate under production conditions and are equal from one crop growing situation to another only by rare coincidence. Thus, it would be risky to generally equate high nitrate concentrations in tissues with high or excessive applications of fertilizer-N. Without attempting to determine cause, the role of environment will be illustrated with a few examples. 1. Magnirude and Significance
The data in Table I show a straightforward relationship between the nitrate concentration of outer leaves of head lettuce and the amounts of fertilizer-N applied within a given planting date and N source. However, environmental effects were so pronounced as to completely mask, in some cases, the effects of fertilizer rates. A summer crop to which no fertilizer was applied contained as much or more nitrate when mature than the spring crop receiving 112 kg N/ha. Similarly, summer lettuce receiving 112 kg N/ha as NaNOJ had higher nitrate concentrations than spring lettuce receiving 224 kg N/ha; summer lettuce receiving 56 kg N/ha as (NI-L,)2S04 accumulated more nitrate than the spring crop fertilized at 4 times that rate. In other unpublished work on organic soils, Minotti sampled onions (Allium cepa L.) in mid-July for 4 consecutive years from plots receiving the same yearly N applications. Nitrate concentrations varied considerably from year to year within N treatment, and in some cases the year-to-year variations were as large as differences caused by 1 12 kg N/ha. The previous examples demonstrate the effects of relatively long-term climatic variables; however, environmental variables can exert an appreciable effect on nitrate concentration in a matter of hours as illustrated in Fig. 1 (Minotti and Stankey, 1973). Nitrate concentrations in whole beet plants changed as much as twofold in periods as short as 8-12 hours. Minimum concentrations were found
TABLE I Effect of Rate and Source of Nitrogen and Planting Time on the Nitrate Concentration and Yield of Minetto Head Lettuce Grown on Organic Soil in Oswego, New York' Nitrogen applied Source
Rate (kg/ha)
spring cropb
23May
17 June ~
Summer crop 5 July
27 June
15 July
b
Fresh wt/carton'
6Aug.
Spring
Summer
~~
NO, -N, % dry wt
NO,-N, % dry W t
kg
NaNO,, NaNO, NaNO,
Zero 56 112 224
0.12 0.40 0.46 0.6 1
0.13 0.58 0.76 0.96
0.10 0.20 0.32 1.12
0.31 0.50 0.76 0.87
0.73 1.08 1.19 1.28
0.41 0.78 1.09 1.59
14.1 20.8 23.6 23.5
19.2 19.8 20.8 20.8
(NH,),SO, (NH,),SO, (NH,),So,
56 112 224
0.14 0.15 0.1 1
0.29 0.37 0.35
0.23 0.41 0.49
0.48 0.52 0.65
1.00 1.01 1.13
0.67 0.79 1.16
21.0 21.9 21.3
20.2 21.7 21.2
'P. L. Minotti, unpublished data. bSpring crop planted in April and harvested at maturity on 5 July; summer crop planted in June and harvested on 6 August in adjacent plot. 'Carton of 24 heads.
79
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
c 35 -
&
30-
W w
22
20-
Ly
e
15-
10 -
8
1
2
4
8
1
1
4
8
1
2
4
8
1
2
4
8
1
2
HOUR
FIG. 1. Diurnal fluctuations in air temperature, soil temperature and nitrate-N concentration of beet plants over a 52-hour period (Minotti and Stankey, 1973).
at 4 p.m. after which nitrate increased, reaching maximum levels at 4 a.m. and 8 a.m. Most vegetables are grown in outdoor environments where rapid changes in climatic factors are expected. However, even environmental differences existing between two types of greenhouses were found t o appreciably modify nitrate concentrations. Lettuce was grown to maturity during the period August to October in (I) a conventional pad-cooled, completely enclosed glasshouse and (11) a double-layered, plastic-topped house with open sides and ends in which temperatures and humidities more closely paralleled the outdoor environment. Although identically grown and fertilized in both cases the plants in system I1 invariably contained lower concentrations of nitrate; yet, their total N concentration excluding nitrate was generally higher (Table 11). Plants in system I1 were higher in dry matter and required more frequent watering.
80
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL. TABLE I1 Effect of Different Greenhouse Environments, Closed PadCooled Glass (CG) and Open-Sided, PlastioTopped (OP), on N Constituents and Growth of Several Lettuce Cultivars‘
N (excl.
Variety
mb
Minetto Oswego (H) ParrisIsland (R) SummerBibb (B) Buttercrunch (B) GrandRapids Q SaladBowl(L.)
NO,-N (7%dry wt)
NO,)
Dry matter
(% dry wt)
(%I
CG
OP
CG
OP
CG
op
CG
op
1.69 1.38 1.41 1.21 1.24 1.41 1.43
0.87 0.96 0.77 0.64 0.58 0.63 0.69
3.4 3.6 3.1 3.9 3.2 3.5 3.6
3.4 4.6 4.4 4.9 4.9 3.9 4.2
3.4 3.8 5.1 4.6 4.1 4.2 5.0
4.8 5.0 5.3 4.3 4.4 5.4 5.1
1.21 1.66 0.67 0.42 0.80 1.10 0.63
1.24 1.71 1.30 0.72
Fresh wt (kg/head)
1.05 1.05 0.97
‘P. L. Minotti, unpublished data. bH= crisp head, R = romaine, B = butter head, L = leaf.
It is of interest in this example that climatic factors acted in such a way as to decrease nitrate without decreasing the nonnitrate fraction, much of which consists of useful protein and amino-N. In situations where changes in nitrate are mediated by changes in applied N, one usually finds that increments of fertilizer simultaneously increase nonnitrate N, and this parallel effect extends beyond the “critical concentration” ranges (Section IV,D). The above experiments were obviously not designed to separate the effects of individual climatic factors on nitrate concentrations, but they do illustrate the significance of environment. Applications of N fertilizers are probably too often blamed in instances of high nitrate accumulation. Retail produce sampled for nitrate fluctuates widely (Section IV,B), whereas fertilizer-N programs for any specified crop do not diverge to the same extent. This also suggests, although indirectly, that factors other than fertilizer are heavily involved. Schuphan et al. (1967) showed the involvement of other factors, environmental and genetic. Spinach harvested at optimum maturity from several fields over a period of years varied in nitrate concentration by a factor of 5 or more with the same amount of fertilizer.
2. General Mechanism The concentration of nitrate in plant tissues is always in a dynamic state since it represents the difference between rates of absorption and rates of assimilation within the plant. For a particular plant part, translocation of absorbed nitrate to or from the part is also involved. Thus, a factor may modify tissue nitrate by
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
81
affecting any one or all of the processes of absorption, assimilation, and translocation. If absorption is limited due to low availability of nitrate; then, the effect of assimilation and translocation rates will be minimized since tissue accumulation will tend to be low regardless of these factors. Similarly at greatly excessive soil nitrate levels, tissue nitrate may tend to be high regardless of assimilation and translocation rates. Most vegetable crops would be fertilized between such extremes since it is self-defeating to nutritionally starve a crop and senseless to overuse N, considering its cost, availability, and environmental repercussions (Minotti, 1975). Thus, factors affecting assimilation or translocation could play a significant role in regulating nitrate concentrations under most production situations.
3. Specific Factors
a . Light. It is well documented that reductions in light intensity are often associated with increased nitrate concentrations in plants (Schuphan et al., 1967; Viets and Hageman, 1971; Wright and Davison, 1964). The first step in nitrate assimilation is the reduction of nitrate to nitrite mediated by the enzyme nitrate reductase (NR), a metallo-flavoprotein (Beevers and Hageman, 1969). It is considered a rate-limiting step because nitrate may accumulate while other intermediates in the process normally do not, at least prior to the amino-N stage (Kessler, 1964). The enzyme in leaf tissue loses activity rapidly in the dark (Candella et al., 1957; Hageman and Flesher, 1960), and provided other factors are not limiting, maximum activity has been associated with maximum solar radiation incident to the leaf surface (Hageman et al., 1961). Further, these same workers have shown the enzyme to exhibit a diurnal variation such that peaks in leaf NR activity corresponded to depletion of leaf nitrate concentrations. Accordingly, light is presumed to modify tissue nitrate concentrations primarily by regulating NR activity, although the mechanism by which light modifies NR is still uncertain (Viets and Hageman, 1971). Certainly a large part of the diurnal variation in nitrate in beets, as depicted by Fig. 1, might be explained by the above reasoning. Attempts to assess the magnitude of the light effect independent of other variables, such as temperature and humidity, are fraught with difficulties; therefore, completely enclosed growth chambers with fluorescent tubes supplemented by incandescent bulbs are usually employed. In this manner Cantliffe (1972a) demonstrated dramatic differences in the nitrate concentration of spinach grown for 35 days at 2400 ft-c and then for an additional 2 weeks at intensities of 600, 1600, 2400, and 3500 ft-c. Average values for the percentage nitrate-N of leaves were 1.26,0.49,0.34, and 0.34, respectively. In greenhouse experiments using shade cloth and supplementary light to vary intensities, Cantliffe (1973a) obtained equally dramatic reductions in nitrate concentrations with increases in the intensity of light over beets and spinach
82
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
growing in pots of Ontario fine sandy loam differentially fertilized with N (Table 111). As predicted from the scheme describing the processes of nitrate absorption, translocation, and assimilation (Section 111, A, 2), light factors were particularly significant at moderate N levels since at low N levels, nitrate concentrations were relatively low, and at high N levels, concentrations were high. Light still exerted a marked effect at high N levels. Moreover, total N content over the experimental period was much greater at higher light levels suggesting that the reduced nitrate concentrations are indeed resulting from increased nitrate assimilation rates. Although growth was greatly accelerated at higher light intensity, the concentrations of nonnitrate N were not reduced, indicating that the lower nitrate concentrations are not resulting from simple dilution effects. Working under field conditions, Schuphan et al. (1967) found considerable variation in the nitrate concentrations of spinach harvested at different dates, and concentrations found were negatively correlated with the hours of sunshine the plants received in the week immediately prior to harvest. He subsequently protected spinach plots from direct sunlight by using various types of shading materials. Both light and strong shading accentuated nitrate accumulation. Also working in the field, Knipmeyer et al. (1962) found that shading markedly affected nitrate concentrations in leaves of several varieties of corn without commensurate changes in total N concentrations. They obtained similar results whether the shading was caused by shading screens or by adjacent corn plants. Increases in the nitrate concentrations of beet leaves (Fig. 2) were obtained by 1.2 LENGTH OF THE LIGHT PERIOD
R
I 0
0 0
8 HOURS 12 HOURS 16 HOURS
0 20 HOURS
I
I
I
100
200
300
400
NITROGEN ADDED (pounds per acre)
FIG. 2. The effect of photoperiod on the nitrate-N concentration of beet leaves grown at different fertilizer rates (Cantliffe, 1972b).
TABLE 111 Effect of N and Light Intensity on N Constituents and Dry Weight of Spinach Leaves and Beet Leaves and Rootsa
NO,-N (% dry wt) Crop
N (excl. NO,) (% dry wt)
Growth @ dry Wt/POt)
N Content (dry wt X % total Ny High
Low
Nitrogen applied (mg/kg soil)
Highb
Low
High
Low
High
Low
0 100 200
0.09 0.35 0.72
0.14 1.09 1.61
2.69 3.61 3.76
3.19 3.25 2.84
0.22 1.27 1.25
0.22 0.57 0.42
0.61 5.02 5.60
0.73 2.47 1.86
0
100
0.06 0.18 1.12
0.15 0.50 1.26
1.46 1.73 1.61
1.54 1.70 1.72
2.04 2.87 3.49
0.99 1.41 1.80
3.10 5.19 9.52
1.67 3.10 5.36
0 50 100
0.02 0.04 0.35
0.04 0.13 0.44
1.33 1.40 1.72
1.38 1.51 1.77
1.28 2.67 2.99
0.68
1.72 3.84 6.18
0.96 1.80 2.98
(glpotx 102)
~~~
Spinach leaves
Beet leaves
50
Beet roots
'Adapted from Cantliffe (1973a). 'High = 3.23 X lo4 Ix (3000 ftc); low = 1.08 '%TOM N = % NO,-N + % N.
X
1.10 1.35
lo4 lx (1000 ft-c).
00
w
84
D.N.MAYNARD ET AL.
shortening the photoperiod at a constant light intensity of 2500 ft-c, and similar results were shown for the beet roots (Cantliffe, 1972b). Extended photoperiods reduced total N concentrations, but since data on plant growth were not presented it is not certain whether or not these were dilution effects. In another growth chamber experiment at 2500 ft-c and a constant 12-hour photoperiod, Cantliffe harvested radish leaves and roots, spinach leaves, and snap bean pods (phuseolus vulgaris L.) at the end of the dark period and 6 and 12 hours after initiating light. Each additional 6 hours of light decreased the concentration of nitrate-N by approximately 0.18% in radish leaves, and although little nitrate accumulated in snap bean pods there was an approximately one-third reduction in their nitrate concentration when harvested at the middle or end of the light period. Nitrate concentrations in spinach leaves did not change with response to the additional light period under these conditions. Harper and Paulsen (1968) attempted to assess the effects of light quality on nitrate assimilation in wheat (Triticum uestiuum L.). After 28 days, leaf nitrate concentrations were consistently lower under blue light (380-470 nm), and NR activity was markedly higher than in red light (680-740 nm). However, neither the radiant energy nor growth data were reported under each regime; so, interpretation remains tenuous. b. Temperature. It is difficult to make a general statement about the effects of temperature on nitrate accumulation because the processes of absorption, translocation, and assimilation are all affected. The relative degree to which each process is affected depends on other factors such as light, moisture, and N availability which can be markedly affected by temperature. It is not surprising then to find nitrate accumulation associated with both temperature increases (Kretschmer, 1958; Younis et ul., 1965), temperature decreases (Nightingale et ul., 1930) or not appreciably affected by temperature. For field-grown plants, temperature may diverge widely in a short time span (Fig. 1). Moreover, root and shoot temperatures differ with the result that shoots can be considerably warmer at midday; yet, the roots are warmer at night. In addition, roots are exposed to a gradient of temperature with soil depth. These root-shoot temperature relationships should not be ignored in considering diurnal nitrate fluctuations in shoots. Considering that all biological processes are temperature moderate, a low night temperature would seem to have a lesser effect on root absorption than shoot assimilation of nitrate; thus, the temperature drop favors accumulation in accordance with observed diurnal patterns. In organic soils, temperature exerts a pronounced effect on rate of mineralization and subsequent nitrification, and such effects are undoubtedly involved in the high accumulation found in the summer-grown lettuce crop as compared to the spring crop (Table I). Similarly, soil nitrification rates and nitrate availability are likely involved in Kretchmer’s (1958) finding that nitrate accumulation in everglades forages was positively correlated with d d y low temperature-the higher the daily low, the greater the nitrate concentration.
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
85
The effect of temperature can vary with species (Bathurst and Mitchell, 1958). When nitrate concentrations were compared at temperatures regulated upward from 7°C in approximately 5" intervals, nitrate was lowest in Dallisgrass (Paspalum dilatatum Poir.) at 18" but lowest in ryegrass (Lolium sp., L.) at 7". Particularly high temperatures (30°C and above) have decreased NR activity in corn (Younis et al., 1965) and in barley (Hordeum uulgare L.) (Onwueme et al., 1971) especially when coupled with mild water stress (Huffaker et al., 1970). Investigations with lettuce grown under field conditions in the Imperial Valley of California (Mayberry and Rauschkolb, 1975) have shown close correlations between the mean weekly temperature (MWT) of the ambient air and N uptake. When the MWT was below 12.7"C, applications of N did not result in increased uptake or in midrib nitrate levels high enough to maintain growth or correct deficiency. It was recommended that applications be given before the cooler weather began, since at warmer temperatures uptake was sufficient to raise midrib-nitrate levels high enough to sustain plant needs through the subsequent cold period. Cantliffe ( 1 9 7 2 ~ )regulated growth chambers at 5 , 10, 15,20,25, or 30°C for 28 days starting with 1-month-old spinach plants growing in pots of Ontario fine sandy loam. Light intensity was maintained at 1500 ft-c and photoperiod at 12 hours, conditions conducive to nitrate accumulation. In general, nitrate concentrations increased with increasing temperature at 3 levels of applied N (0,50,or 200 mg/kg of soil). There was a temperature X N interaction such that at 0 N, nitrate did not begin to accumulate until the temperature was raised above 15", but at 50 and 200 N, nitrate accumulation began at 10" and So, respectively. The effects were interpreted to be caused primarily by increased uptake from the media since total N concentration also increased. This of course does not mean that assimilation rates were unaffected by temperature but simply that effects on uptake were relatively greater. It would be of interest to repeat this same kind of experiment under conditions of lighting and photoperiod that would not limit assimilation. c. Temperature X Light Interactions. A beautiful example of a temperature X light interaction is provided by the data of Hoff and Wilcox (1970) (Table IV) who showed that temperature exerted its greatest effect on tomatoes (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) at high N and low light and that light exerted its greatest effect at high temperature and high N. In these experiments in growth chambers, light intensities were maintained at 3000 or 600 ft-c for an unstated photoperiod. The high temperature regime was 27°C day-21" night, and the low regime was 21" day-15" night. High N consisted of supplemental fertilization with NH4N03. d . Carbon Dioxide Concentration. Gradients in C 0 2 concentration around plant canopies can occur, particularly in full greenhouses where supplementary COz is often successfully used to increase vegetable and flower yields. Further, plant-mediated depletion of atmospheric C 0 2 beyond ambient levels is not
86
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL. TABLE IV Effect of Temperature, Nitrogen, and Light Levels on Accumulation of NitrateN in Tomato Leaves and Fruit Before Harvest'
Environmental Factors
Treatment levels
Nitrogen: Light: Temperature:
High High High
Low Low
Low
High
High Low
High
Low Low
High
Low
ppm NO, -N, fresh wt
Leaf 1st exp. 2nd exp. Fruit Unripe Ripe
420 500
475 568
1100 1510
230 228
420 448
250 26
475 228
330 106
10 11
6 12
50 46
24 11
22 9
20 11
13 15
12 14
'From Hoff and Wilcox, 1970.
uncommon in full growth chambers (Raper et ul., 1973). Partial depletion of C 0 2 in growth cambers was shown to elevate nitrate concentrations in tobacco (Nicotianu tabucum L.) leaves (Raper et al., 1973), and C 0 2 enrichment was shown to lower nitrate concentrations in the leaves (W. W. Weeks, P. L. Minotti, C. D. Raper, and R. C. Long, unpublished data, North Carolina State University, Raleigh). Nitrate reduction appears dependent on photosynthetically produced substrate for the generation of reducing equivalents (NADH) in chlorophyllous tissue (Klepper er ul., 1971). Further, synthesis and maintenance of NR in leaves could be linked to active photosynthesis since the NR in leaves of Perilla decayed in an illuminated, C02-free atmosphere at levels similar to that which occurred when the leaves were placed in the dark (Kannangara and Woolhouse, 1967). Obviously, photosynthetic rates fluctuate diurnally in the same manner as NR activity and nitrate concentrations. Even in roots nitrate reduction is dependent on respiratory substrate from shoots (Minotti and Jackson, 1970). e. Water Relations. The review of Wright and Davison (1964) cites several studies reporting excessive nitrate accumulation in forages subject to drought, some leading to poisoned cattle (Davidson er ul., 1941; Gamer, 1958; Mayo, 1895). Such accumulations probably result because water stress decreases both NR activity (Huffaker et al., 1970) and photosynthesis; and, therefore, nitrate assimilation prior to the time absorption from the soil is depressed. Accordingly,
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
87
tissues remain high in nitrate throughout the stress period or until conditions are once again favorable for assimilation and growth. Moreover, dry periods have been shown to result in upward movement and a buildup of nitrate in the topsoil as it dries out (Robinson and Gacoka, 1962). Since growing vegetables without irrigation is such a risky proposition, nitrate accumulation caused by extended drought would be less common than with forages. However, temporary restrictions in assimilaton caused by combined effects of high temperature and mild water stress without commensurate restriction in nitrate uptake appear more likely. The effects of humidity and, thus, transpiration on nitrate accumulation have not been studied; yet, these are uncontrolled variables in all the work discussed thus far in Section 111, A. In the field, clear skies and high light intensities are accompanied by lower humidities and higher transpiration rates. These rates would be subject to the same diurnal pattern previously discussed for nitrate accumulation, NR activity, and photosynthesis. Artificial or mutual competitive shading can also alter the humidity and possibIy the temperature of the leaf microenvironment. In a l l probability, higher light intensities were compounded with differential humidity and water relations in the growth chamber studies cited below. The environment of the closed glass greenhouse (Table I) was more humid than that in the open plastic house, where a higher frequency of watering was required. Light intensity was about 10% lower in the open plastic house; yet, the lettuce accumulated much less nitrate and had a greater dry matter percentage. This was true at three stages of growth and regardless of whether mean temperatures in the plastic house the week before harvest were lower or higher than those in the glass greenhouse for the corresponding period. Thus, it appears that something other than light intensity, temperature, or nutrient supply is responsible for the differential nitrate accumulation observed. The association between nitrate accumulation and high humidity is of interest in view of the fact that the exact manner in which light affects NR and assimilation is still uncertain (Viets and Hageman, 1971). Nitrate reductase is a substrate inducible enzyme, and the light effect could well be indirect, possibly facilitating nitrate movement to induction sites (Beevers ef al., 1965). Also NR in roots has the same characteristics and requirements as that in shoots. Further, when extraction media contain compounds to remove inhibitors (Dirr ef al., 1973), the specific activity (per unit protein) of root NR activity in many species approaches that of shoots. Moreover, Beevers et al. (1965) found induction of NR to occur in the dark in corn seedlings and radish cotyledons, although higher amounts were induced in the light. They postulated that light was acting indirectly, possibly by increasing the permeability of tissue (Warburg and Negelein, 1920) to the inducer. Possibly, reduced humidities and increased transpiration rates are involved in
88
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
maintaining a continuous movement of nitrate to induction sites, thereby helping to maintain NR and keeping accumulated nitrate low. Enzyme activity and nitrate assimilation are associated with the lamina whereas most of the accumulation occurs in vascular tissue. Previously accumulated nitrate reportedly does not maintain activity as NR decays in the dark or when plants are placed in a nitrate-free solution even though tissue nitrate remains high (Jackson ef al., 1973). Thus, it is necessary to keep new nitrate moving to induction sites or from vascular to laminar tissues, and the role of water relations in this process seems worthy of further investigation.
B. GENETIC FACTORS
1. Evidence a. Spinach. Schuphan ef al. (1967) analyzed 19 varieties of field-grown spinach sown at the same date, fertilized with 120 kg N/ha, and harvested at “optimum time” for each variety. He concluded that only small differences, if any, exist among the 19 varieties tested in this trial; yet, his data show an approximately twofold difference in the nitrate concentration between the highest and lowest values for the 10 varieties harvested simultaneously. He presumably minimized the varietal effect because it was less dramatic than that associated with sampling time and solar radiation, and possibly because at reduced solar insulation all the varieties tended to be high in nitrate. Subsequent workers, however, have amply documented significant varietal differences in spinach nitrate concentrations over a spectrum of screening conditions (Barker ef al., 1971, 1974; Cantliffe, 1972a,b, 1973b; Maynard and Barker, 1974; Sistrunk and Cash, 1974). Using spinach potted in Ontario fine sandy loam and grown at rates of 0 or 250 mg N/kg soil in the greenhouse under a 9 hour photoperiod and a minimum light intensity of 1800 ft-c, Cantliffe (1973b), screened 31 plant introductions and commercial cultivars. None of the cultivars accumulated appreciable nitrate without added N but ranged from 0.62 to 1.21% nitrate-N at the 250 mg/kg rate of N. Barker et al. (1974) separated 18 spinach cultivars into 3 groups of 6 according to whether they possessed smooth, heavily savoyed, or semisavoyed leaves. As a group, smooth-leafed cultivars were considerably lower in nitrate than heavily savoyed cultivars when grown in the greenhouse (Table V). Similar results were obtained when these cultivars were grown simultaneously in the field on Hadley fine sandy loam at 3 rates of N except that all nitrate concentrations were considerably lower. Some intermediate or semisavoyed cultivars were low nitrate accumulators while others were high accumulators. In an extension of this work
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
89
TABLE V Nitrate Concentration in Different Types of Spinach Leaves from Greenhouse Studies' Leaf part and nitrate treatment (mEq/liter) Blades LeafType
7.5
Savoyed Semisavoyed Smooth
0.30
15.0
Petioles
7.5
15.0
NO, -N %, dry wt 0.18 0.08
0.56 0.50 0.45
1.15 0.84 0.42
2.95 2.48
2.56
'From Barker etal. (1964).
Maynard and Barker (1 974) determined that the critical nitrate-N concentration (Section IV, D) under greenhouse conditions for Hybrid 424, a typical smoothleaf variety was about one-third of that for America, a typical savoyed leaf cultivar. Similarly, unpublished work of N. H. Peck, R. W.Robinson, and C. Y. Lee of the Geneva, New York Experiment Station has shown marked differences in nitrate concentrations between the smooth-leafed Tuftegard and the heavily savoyed Bloomsdale spinach cultivars. Although the case presented by Barker et al. (1974) relating nitrate concentrations to leaf type is convincing, the relationship is not infallible, and they found one of the smooth leaf cultivars, High Pack, to be a high accumulator. Moreover, Cantliffe (1973b) reported that leaf type was not related to nitrate concentration in his experiment with 31 varieties where leaf types were categorized on a scale of 1 to 9 depending on degree of Savoy. Likewise, Sistrunk and Cash (1974) working with seven lots of canned spinach found that nitrate and nitrite were not necessarily related to leaf type. Both the highest and lowest nitrate accumulators were smooth-leafed. They generally concluded that differences resulting from cultural practices may not be as important as processing techniques and length of storage periods as far as canned spinach was concerned (Sistrunk and Cash, 1975). b. Lettuce. Table I1 shows differing nitrate concentrations in different lettuce types with highest concentrations found in the crisphead cultivars. However, the crisphead cultivars can vary tremendously; thus, P. L. Minotti (unpublished) found differences as great as fivefold when 14 cultivars were screened under various field situations. The magnitude of the differences depended on environmental conditions. From one field situation to another, some shifting in the
90
D.N. MAYNARD ET AL.
relative position of cultivars ranking intermediate in nitrate occurred, but high accumulators always remained high and low accumulators remained low in relative ranking order. Continued comparison of two particular varieties, Minetto and Val Rio, under nine growing situations showed that nitrate vaned considerably with the environment, plant age, and plant part, but Minetto was without exception higher in nitrate concentration and lower in dry matter percentage (Table VI). Total N did not show a consistent pattern. It appears that genetic influences on nitrate accumulation can be of enough significance so as not to be masked by environmental effects, as great as the latter are. c. Other Oops. Differential capacity for nitrate accumulation has also been noted in radishes and snap bean pods (Cantliffe, 1972a). Consistent, although relatively small, varietal differences have been documented for other crops such as oats ( h e m sutiva L.), corn, sugar beets, perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.), timothy (Phleum pretense L.), and cotton (Gossypium sp., L.) (Wright and Davison, 1964). 2. Mechanism Differences in nitrate accumulation may be related to differences in uptake, assimilation, or translocation. In attempting to explain the basis for the differences in smooth-leaf versus savoyed-leaf cultivars, Olday (1973) found the NR activity of the smooth-leaf Hybrid 424 was 2.1 to 3.3 times greater than that in the heavily savoyed America depending on the plant organ being studied. Although uptake was not measured, it is unlikely that uptake rates would vary by this order of magnitude; hence, it appears that differential assimilation is indeed the primary cause of differences in this particular case. When total N determinations represent the average N concentration of the whole plant and the Kjeldahl or other total N analysis has been executed so as to prevent loss of nitrate during digestion, total uptake from growth until harvest can be calculated by multiplying percentage N X total dry weight. Applying this method to total plant harvests and analyses of Val Rio and Minetto lettuce (Table VI) indicates a primary role for differential assimilation capacity since total N uptake was often greatest in Val Rio, the cultivar lowest in nitrate. Possibly the ratio of nitrate-N concentration to total-N concentration can be taken as an indirect measure of assimilatory capacity since it indicates the units of reduced-N present for every unit of nitrate-N in tissue at a given time. Such ratios again suggest a major role for assimilation rates in both the spinach screened by Cantliffe (1973b) and the unpublished lettuce work of Minotti since lower nitrates often occur with relatively high total-N concentrations as one compares cultivars. Since nitrate concentrations can markedly fluctuate in a few hours such ratios are used with caution in suggesting mechanism, particularly if only plant parts are analyzed or total weights are not given.
TABLE VI: Nitrate and Total-N Concentrations and Dry Matter in Two Crisphead Lettuce Varietiee NO,-N (% dry wt)
Growth situation
Plant age
Composited plant part
Minetto
Val Rio
Total N (% dry wt)
Minetto
Val Rio
Dry matter (%)
Minetto ~~
Greenhouse 1972 flats, peatlite mix Field 1972 mineral soil 1970 mineral soil 1970 organic soil 1970 organic soil 1972 mineral soil 1972 mineral
Young seedlings
Whole plants
Young seedlings Mature
Whole plants Outer leaves Outer leaves Outer leaves Quartered heads Stems Roots
12- to 14Leaf stage Mature Mature Mature
soil 1972 mineral soil
Mature
1972 organic soil
12-Leaf stage
Leavesb 1-8 9-1 6 17-24 25-32+ Stems Whole plants Roots
Val Rio ~
~~
2.84
1.86
4.50
4.49
4.02
4.48
0.25
0.18
4.10
4.26
8.99
9.50
1.43
0.43
3.56
3.61
ND
ND
0.79
0.39
ND
ND
ND
ND
1.27
0.22
ND
ND
ND
ND
0.95 1.11 0.62
0.39 0.44 0.20
3.36 2.96 1.88
3.13 2.98 1.58
3.83 6.44 9.72
4.54 8.10 12.67
0.94 1.23 0.7 1 0.56 1.19 0.97 0.69
0.61 0.6 1 0.52 0.45 0.64 0.6 1 0.58
3.63 3.14 2.89 3.44 3.09 4.37 3.27
3.13 2.89 2.73 3.5 1 3.20 4.63 3.42
5.09 3.14 3.42 4.64 5.80 4.48 5.67
5.64 4.28 3.97 5.17 7.02 4.7 1 6.24
‘P. L. Minotti, unpublished data. ND = no data. bouterrnost leaf samples designated No. 1. Numbers increase as newest growth is approached inside the head.
92
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
Perhaps there is merit in seeking to elucidate a common or primary mechanism by which varieties differ in nitrate, particularly from a plant improvement point of view. It may well be, however, that varieties vary for a number of reasons; thus, one is low because of high NR in leaves, another is high because of rapid uptake from the media and a low shoot-root ratio, and another may be low because of relatively high capacity for the root system to reduce nitrate, thus transporting a smaller proportion of the N to shoots as nitrate. Simple structural characteristics may be involved as well and should not be overlooked. For example, petioles and vascular tissue (veins) are sites of accumulation but have low NR (Peck et ul., 1974) whereas the lamina, by contrast, is high in NR and low in nitrate. Thus, the size and number of petioles and veins or the ratio of vascular to laminar tissue could account for observed differences in leaf nitrate. Thus, leaves with relatively large midribs and numerous veins might, also, misleadingly appear to be lower in NR unless specific activity is expressed in terms of protein which resides mostly in laminar portions. Although correlation by no means establishes cause, the invariably higher percentage moisture of Minetto lettuce which parallels its invariably higher nitrate content when compared to Val Rio is provocative (Table VI). In general, those situations that caused the greatest divergence in dry matter contents between the two varieties also resulted in the greatest divergence in nitrate concentrations. Moreover, when percentage dry matter is calculated for the data of Maynard and Barker (1974), it turns out that at the N concentrations in the media where the cultivars America and Hybrid 424 widely differ in nitrate they also differ in dry matter in the same manner as the lettuce, that is, the low accumulator is higher in percentage dry matter. Whether such associations are coincidental or result from involvement of water relations in nitrate accumulation requires further investigation. a. Environmental Interaction. The plant breeder who decides that developing strains with lower nitrate concentrations is a worthy objective is beset with many problems, not the least of which concerns previously discussed environmental effects, particularly N supply and light. Ideally, selections should be made under several environments, and at least two would seem a prudent minimum. (For example, a moderate but not excessive supply of N with temperature adequate for good growth coupled with light intensities and photoperiods that, on the one hand, would favor accumulation and, on the other, permit maximum assimilation.) Especially low or deficient levels of N can be omitted since all cultivars may concentrate negligible nitrate under these conditions (Cantliffe, 1973b; Maynard and Barker, 1974). Likewise, excessive N levels might be omitted since all cultivars tend to be high, particularly if high N levels are coupled with conditions not conducive to rapid nitrate assimilation. N. H. Peck and R. W. Robinson (unpublished) screened inbred spinach lines growing in an outdoor sand-nutrient solution containing 1 mEq/liter
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
93
ammonium-N and 14 mEq/liter nitrate-N at an equidistant spacing of 10 X 1 0 cm. They found all lines to be high in nitrate under these conditions, averaging 1.1% in the blades and 3.7% NOJ-N dry weight in the petioles. They concluded that breeding alone would not solve the problem of high nitrate concentrations in spinach. b. Quality. Some consideration needs to be given to factors such as vitamin and mineral content, reduced N content, oxalate content, color, and texture since it would be somewhat self-defeating to develop a low nitrate cultivar at the expense of one or more other quality features. There is an assumption in all this that a lower nitrate variety will further reduce the risk from nitrite poisoning, even if slight to begin with. However, postharvest physiologists are just beginning to thoroughly investigate nitrate to nitrite conversions after harvest and during storage (Sistrunk and Cash, 1975). It seems to be a matter of bacterial contamination and when the proper organisms are present at sufficient populations, the conversion and subsequent nitrite buildup can occur under refrigeration as well as at room temperatures (Hicks et al., 1975; Lee et al., 1971a). Lee and associates (1971b) regulated the nitrate content of fresh table beets and spinach by differential fertilization and found that conversions to nitrite were not necessarily related to fertilizer applied or initial nitrate levels. Nothing is known about the influence of variety on these conversions. Since nitrite and not nitrate is the toxic principle, it is a bit disconcerting to realize that efforts to develop a low nitrate accumulator could be to n o avail if the cultivar turned out t o be more likely to form nitrite after harvest and during storage for reasons other than initial nitrate content. Such considerations certainly indicate the desirability of involving post harvest physiologists and food scientists in efforts to develop lower nitrate cultivars. c. Selection cziteria. The simplicity of the smooth vs. the savoyed spinach leaf has appeal but should be used with caution since Cantliffe (1973b) did not obtain good correlation between leaf type and nitrate concentration, and Barker et al. (1974) had one smooth leaf variety in their group of six that behaved as a high accumulator. Certainly, selection for high NR activity in both shoots and roots warrants consideration since high NR activity is a heritable characteristic (Hageman et al., 1967; Schrader er al., 1966; Warner er al., 1969). Moreover, NR activities were higher in the smooth-leaved Hybrid 424 spinach than the savoyed America (Olday , 1973). Because NR is substrate inducible, cultivar differences could result from differences in nitrate absorption capacity; thus, higher NR activities are not necessarily correlated with lower nitrate concentrations. In fact, Purvis (1972) reported that genotypic differences in NR levels of corn were independent of tissue nitrate content. Also working with corn, Deckard (1970) found correlations between NR activity and leaf nitrate concentrations only in the
94
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
grain development phase when leaf nitrate was extremely low. Possibly, the varietal differences in nitrate assimilation may result from differences in factors other than NR, such as differences in photosynthetic capacity, differences in ability to generate and translocate respiratory substrate and reducing equivalents, or differences in capacity to translocate absorbed nitrate to reduction sites. Another consideration is that it is unlikely that breeding lines would reach the same degree of maturity at precisely the same time. Nitrate concentrations may be declining rapidly as crops are reaching maturity, particularly when fertilized at planting time, and the N supply is being depleted (Peck et al., 1974). Comparing selections at more than one sampling time as well as under more than one environment would reduce chances for error but this increases the work involved manyfold.
C. NUTRIENT SUPPLY
High nitrate concentrations accumulate in plants only if the nitrate supply in the nutrient medium is high or if something interferes with normal nitrate metabolism within the plants. The relationship between nutrient supply and nitrate accumulation has received much attention throughout the world (Commoner, 1970). Most of this attention has been directed toward field and forage crops; however, nutritional factors that affect nitrate accumulation by these crops apply in principle to vegetable crops. This section will deal primarily with aspects of mineral nutrition which affect nitrate accumulation in vegetables but will include occasional reference to other crops when appropriate. I . Nitrogen a. Supply, Source, and Application. Nitrate in vegetables is derived primarily from nitrate added or formed in the nutrient medium; therefore, the N supply is the most important nutritional factor governing nitrate accumulation in vegetables (Barker and Maynard, 1971 ; Brown and Smith, 1966, 1967; Lorenz and Weir, 1974). The amount and source applied and the time and method of application govem the effects of N fertilizers on nitrate accumulation in vegetables. The usual effect is that increasing the level of N nutrition increases the nitrate concentrations of vegetables (Arora and Luthra, 1971; Barker and Maynard, 1971; Barker et al., 1971; Brown and Smith, 1966, 1967; Gately, 1971; Hanway and Englehorn, 1958; Peck et al., 1971; Regan e t al., 1968; Schmidt et al., 1971; Trevino and Murray, 1975). Most commercial fertilizers contain N as nitrate, ammonia (ammonium), or urea, and a few contain organic N forms other than urea. Due to mineralization and nitrification, nitrate is the primary soil-
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
95
derived N form regardless of the source of N applied; therefore, within limits as much nitrate may be accumulate from organic or ammoniacal fertilizers as from nitrate carriers (Barker, 1975; Peck et al., 1971) if sufficient time is allowed for mineralization to occur. Crops that follow a leguminous green manure crop will accumulate nitrate from mineralization of the crop which is plowed-under (Hanway and Englehom, 1958). Materials that mineralize slowly, such as dried cow manure, lead to lesser nitrate accumulation in vegetables than materials that mineralize more rapidly (Barker, 1975). The rates of application of slowly mineralizable materials may have to be markedly increased to maintain crop yields equivalent to those produced with chemical and easily mineralized organic fertilizers (Atanasiu and Hamdi, 1964). Clearly, if crops are fertilized for maximum yields, nitrate accumulation by them is a natural and unavoidable process. Barker er al. (1971) showed that urea, ammonium nitrate, and potassium nitrate sidedressed to a rapidly growing spinach crop increased the nitrate concentrations in its leaves but that urea gave the least increase and potassium nitrate the greatest. Peck et al. (1971) noted that urea sidedressed to table beets resulted in lesser nitrate levels in the beet roots and shoots than did potassium nitrate. The differences were larger at higher levels of N fertilization. Lorenz and Weir (1974) also showed that nitrate sources led to higher nitrate accumulation in vegetables than did ammoniacal sources of N. Barker et al. (1971) further noted that sidedressing N fertilizer to a growing spinach crop resulted in lower nitrate concentrations in its leaves than did broadcasting the N before planting. Peck et al. (1971) observed that nitrate accumulation from sidedressed urea or potassium nitrate tended to increase in the plant with time after application. Thus, the longer that a plant is in contact with a nitrate-rich medium the greater will be its tendency to accumulate nitrate. The accompanying cation has an influence on the absorption of nitrate and hence its accumulation by plants. Minotti et al. (1969) found that ammonium ions suppressed nitrate absorption relative to the effects of Ca, K, Na, or Mg ions. Wallace and Mueller (1957) with lemon (Cifnrs limon Bum. f.) cuttings and Lycklama (1963) with ryegrass also found that ammonium ions restricted absorption. Ammonium ions appear to be the nutritional repressor (Losada ef ul., 1970; Shen, 1969) and nitrate the nutritional inducer (Beevers et al., 1965) of NR in plants. No evidence is available to indicate that the presence of nitrate and ammonium ions simultaneously in the nutrient medium leads to enhanced accumulation of nitrates in plants, but, in fact, the evidence indicates that the nitrate concentrations will be lowered if part of the N supply is ammoniacal. The effects of other cations on nitrate absorption will be covered in following sections. b. Nitrification Inhibitors. The use of ammoniacal fertilizers and an inhibitor of nitrification may be used to control nitrate accumulation in vegetables.
96
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
Mills (1975)and Mills et ul. (1976)found that the use of ammonium sulfate and the nitrification inhibitor, 2-chloro-6-(trichloromethyl)pyridine,virtually eliminated nitrate accumulation in spinach and radish. Ammonium toxicity, especially with high rates of N application, tended to decrease yields relative to treatments in which the major portion of the N was from a nitrate source, and at extremely high levels the inhibitor has some phytotoxicity (Mills et ul., 1973). Others (Bengtsson, 1968;Spratt and Gasser, 1970)with field studies found that yields of spinach, ryegrass, wheat, and kale (Brussicu oleruceu var. ucephulu DC) were often higher with the inhibitor and an ammoniacal N source because of N conservation against leaching losses.
2. Other Nutrients a. Phosphoms and Sulfur. Phosphorus supply does not have a marked effect on nitrate accumulation by vegetables. Barker and Maynard (1971)and Brown and Smith (1966, 1967) found no effect of moderate P deficiency on nitrate accumulation by vegetables. Arora and Luthra (1971) found that P fertilization decreases nitrate concentrations in mung bean (Phuseolus uureus L.) leaves, but on the other hand, Hills et ul. (1970) found that P-deficient sugar beets did not absorb nitrate as well as those adequately supplied with P. Arora and Luthra (1971) found that S deficiency was associated with nitrate accumulation in mung bean leaves. Evans and Nason (1953)established that NR extracted from higher plants had a sulfhydryl requirement. Schrader et ul. (1968) indicated that the sulfhydryl group is essential for NR activity with NADH as the cofactor. Sulfur deficiency may therefore interfere with NR activity in vivo and lead to nitrate accumulation. b. Potassium. Studies in the field (Brown and Smith, 1966,1967)and with nutrient solutions (Barker and Maynard, 1971) have shown little effect of moderate K deficiency on nitrate accumulation by vegetables. An abundant supply of K is said to stimulate nitrate absorption. Both of these ions undergo luxury consumption by plants, and one may be absorbed after the accumulation of the other to preserve electrical neutrality in the plant (Wright and Davison, 1964). Regan et ul. (1968) found that K fertilization in the field increased nitrate accumulation in spinach and that the effect was greater on limed soils than on unlimed soils. Other studies with solution culture have shown that K generally stimulates nitrate absorption with respect to the effects of other cations (Minotti et ul., 1968;Tottingham et ul., 1934)and that increasing the K supply increases nitrate accumulation, especially at high levels of nitrate nutrition (Barker, 1962). Nightingale et ul. (1930), on the other hand, showed that tomato plants devoid of K nutrition accumulated high levels of nitrate but appeared N-deficient. c. Calcium and Mugnesium. No definite effect of Ca supply on nitrate
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
97
accumulation by vegetables is apparent (Barker and Maynard, 1971; Brown and Smith, 1966, 1967). Calcium has an effect on nitrate uptake (Nightingale et al., 1931) and possibly an effect on its reduction by plants (Minotti et al., 1968). Calcium deficiency restricts root development markedly and thus may have an indirect effect on nitrate absorption. No evidence is available to indicate that Mg supply has an effect on nitrate accumulation other than its effects on general plant metabolism and chloroplast development and subsequently on NR activity (Kessler, 1964). d. Minor Elements. Molybdenum is a component of NR and thus is a requirement for the enzymatic reduction of nitrate to nitrite (Afridi and Hewitt, 1964; Evans and Hall, 1955; Hewitt and Gundry, 1970; Merkel et al., 1975; Randall, 1969). In Mo-deficient plants, nitrate may accumulate to very high levels in the leaves, sometimes exceeding 3% on a dry weight basis (Hewitt and Smith, 1975). Plants grown on ammonium nutrition apparently d o not have a Mo requirement (Hewitt and Gundry, 1970). In lower organisms, Fe in addition to Mo is an essential constituent of NR in that the system contains a b-type cytochrome (Garret and Nason, 1967). In higher plants Fe has a role in NR in that reduced ferredoxin formed by illuminated chloroplasts participates in the reduction. Chloride in the soil is antagonistic to nitrate uptake. The expression of the antagonism is related to the background concentrations of nitrate and chloride in the soil (James et al., ,1970). Deficiency of Mn has been associated with nitrate accumulation in oats and canary grass (Phaluris sp., L.) (Leeper, 1941). Burstrom (1939) with wheat seedlings confirmed that nitrate assimilation required Mn. A specific role of Mn in nitrate assimilation is unknown.
3. Nonessential Elements Bains and Fireman (1964) found that increasing the exchangeable Na in the soil increased the absorption of nitrate from ammonium sulfate applied to nonsterile soil and increased the nitrate concentrations in corn, sorghum (Sorghum vulgare Pen.) and ryegrass, had little effect on nitrate in tomato, and decreased nitrate concentrations in safflower (Gzrthanus tinctorius L.) plants. Minotti et al. (1969) showed that Na was essentially as effective as Ca, K, or Mg in maintaining nitrate absorption over a 24-hour period by N-starved wheat plants. Increasing the potential pressure or salt concentration in the soil increased the percentage of nitrate in bean plants (Wadleigh and Ayres, 1945). Tungsten has been used as a competitive inhibitor of Mo function in plants, and its use leads to nitrate accumulation in plants (Heimer et al., 1969). Afridi and Hewitt (1964), however, found no effect of W or V on nitrate reductase in cauliflower. Nickel (Maranville, 1970) was shown to stimulate nitrate reductase in extracts of sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L.) and sundangrass (Sorghum vulgare
98
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
var. sundanense Hitchc.) but reduced the activities in wheat, corn, and soybean (Glycine max Merr.). The effect was thought to be in the protection against cyanide inhibition, and no metabolic effect of the Ni was assumed. Vanadyl sulfate sprayed on sugar beet leaves increased the nitrate concentration in the plant (Singh and Wort, 1970). The effects of Al ions on nitrate uptake appear to be somewhat stimulatory in barley (Bassioni, 1971; Nagata, 1954).
IV. Nitrate Concentrations in Vegetables
A. DISTRIBUTION IN THE PLANT
Nitrate tends not to be uniformly distributed throughout the plant but rather tends to accumulate in certain plant parts. Although this observation was first made by Berthelot (1884a,b,c), few reports since have provided complete analysis of plant parts for nitrate in a single experiment. Therefore, the generalities concerning nitrate accumulation in plant parts are drawn from many sources and may be subject to the limitations of the internal and environmental effects on nitrate uptake and reduction as discussed elsewhere in this paper (Section 111). Nonetheless, it generally appears (Hanway et al., 1963; Viets and Hageman, 1971; Wright and Davison, 1964) that nitrate concentrations are lowest in floral parts, and increasing concentrations are found in fruit or grain, leaves, roots, and petioles or stems in that order. Within a plant part, nitrate concentrations are higher in older tissue (cf. Table VIII). Bodiphala and Ormrod (1971) have confirmed this pattern of nitrate accumulation for the aerial parts of the spinach plant. In the garden pea (Pisum sativum L.), nitrate accumulates in the vegetative aerial part of the plant while the seed has a relatively very low concentration of nitrate (Trevino and Murray, 1975). Lorenz and Weir (1974), working with table beets, found the highest nitrate concentrations in petioles with lesser concentrations in roots and leaf blades in that order. In tomato plants (Gomez-Lepe and Ulrich, 1974), highest nitrate concentrations were also found in petioles with lesser concentrations in leaf blades, stems, and roots in that order. Thus, it appears from the available data on nitrate distribution in vegetable crops that the generalities cited above are applicable to most plants. However, certain plants are typically nitrate accumulators while others are not. Thus considerable variation in nitrate-N concentrations may occur among the same organs of different plants, e.g., roots of beet and radish generally have high nitrate-N concentrations while carrot and sweet potato (Ipomea batatas L.) roots generally have very low concentrations (cf. Table VII).
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
99
B. FRESH VEGETABLES
The tendency for nitrate to accumulate in certain species was first noted by Berthelot (1 884a) and has been the topic of numerous investigations since that time. As pointed out elsewhere, accumulation represents the difference between uptake and reduction of nitrate. Certain vegetables, because of a very efficient uptake system, an inefficient reductive system, or an unfavorable combination of both, tend to accumulate more nitrate than others. Beets, spinach, and radishes are noted by Lee (1972) as being nitrate accumulators. The Committee on Nitrate Accumulation (1972) adds broccoli (Brussicu oleruceu var. itulicu Plenck.), celery, lettuce, kale, mustard greens (Brussicu junceu Coss.) and collards (Brussicu oleruceu var. ucephulu DC) to the list of nitrate accumulators. We have complied (Table VII) comparable data from the literature which supports the contention that spinach, celery, beets, and radishes are nitrate accumulators. The data in Table VII are not sufficient, however, to justify classifying lettuce and broccoli as nitrate accumulators. Other data in this review (cf. Tables I, 11, IV) indicate that lettuce is a nitrate accumulator while data not shown in Table VII support the inclusion of collards, mustard greens, and kale as nitrate accumulators. Splittstoesser and associates (1 974) have shown that mustard greens and collards accumulate high nitrate concentrations. With applications of 112 kg/ha N as ammonium nitrate, mustard green leaves had 780 ppm nitrate-N and collard leaves 1160 ppm on a fresh weight basis. Comparable data for kale are not available, but the nitrate concentrations obtained using the data of Brown and Smith (1967) and assuming 10% dry weight appear to justify including kale as a nitrate accumulator. Because of the great time span over which nitrate concentration data are available for vegetable crops, it is possible to compare nitrate-N concentrations at a time when most of the fertilizer applied was organic (Richardson, 1907) with a later period when most fertilizers are inorganic. Comparisons between organic and inorganic sources of N can be made for twelve vegetables. Nitrate-N concentrations in the more recent data appear t o be considerably higher in cabbage and cauliflower, slightly higher in celery, carrot and potato (Solunum tuberosum L.), unchanged in spinach, beet, sweet potato, and radish, somewhat less in snap bean and onion, and considerably less in lettuce. It is obviously difficult to make any meaningful generalizations relative to the effects of organic vs. inorganic N sources on nitrate accumulation in vegetables. In addition to the comparison between organic and inorganic N sources discussed above, one may also compare nitrate-N concentrations in vegetable crops over a period of years when the use of inorganic N fertilizers increased. In 1945, total N fertilizer consumption was 595,313 tons (Hargett, 1970). By 1970 consumption of fertilizer N had increased to 7,459,004 tons in the United States (Hargett, 1974). Total harvested crop acreage remained constant from 1945 to
c
0 0
TABLE VII Nitrate-N Concentrations in Fresh Vegetables Plant part
Richardson (1907)
Wilsona
Jackson et d.
Lee
Maynard and Barker
Vegetable
(1949)
(1967)
(1972)
(1972)
Cabbage Lettuce Spinach Celery Rhubarb Beet Carrot Sweet potato Radish
46 378 434 340 587 15 15 413
-
43-276 92 69-541 743 230-1045’ 307’ 75 70-270 -
100 12 52 17 34
230-1254’ 12 14 181-885‘ 460’
ppm NO,-N, fresh wt Leaves Petiole Roots
Fruit
Stem Bulb Tuber Flower parts
Peas Snap bean Tomato Asparagus Onion Potato Broccoli Cauliflower
-
‘NO,-N concentration of expressed sap. ’Field samples. ‘D. N. Maynard and A. V. Barker, unpublished data.
72 153 121 64 1 275 23 10 343 11 53 17 40 24 12
207 63 468 226
-
548 76 45 6 -
-
-
214 238
165 170 524 535 91’ 600 32 0 402 26‘ 35 20 25‘ 14 42
-
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
101
1970; thus, one can conclude that each harvested acre received about twelve times more fertilizer N in 1970 than it did in 1945. It would be improper to apply this increase to vegetable crop acreage since vegetables have been traditionally liberally fertilized. Nonetheless, it would seem realistic to assume a two- to threefold increase in N fertilizer applicaton for vegetable crops during this 25-year span (Lorenz and Bartz, 1967). The data of Wilson (1949) can be compared with data of Jackson et al. (1967), Lee (1972), and Maynard and Barker (1972) for thirteen vegetable crops. This comparison shows two vegetables with greatly increased nitrate-N concentrations, four with slightly increased concentrations, three with slightly lower concentrations, three with much lower concentrations and one with a similar concentration during the period of increased fertilizer N consumption. Thus, it is impossible to generalize with respect to the relationship between increased fertilizer usage and nitrate-N concentrations in vegetable crops. Although considerable information concerning the nitrate concentrations in vegetables has been amassed, the data are based on sporadic and limited sampling. Consequently, the data do not reflect the great variations that can occur in nitrate concentrations in fresh vegetables resulting from genetic, environmental, or nutritional factors (Section 111). These variations are shown in Table VIII for celery, lettuce, and spinach. P. L. Minotti (unpublished) determined the nitrate concentration in these vegetables by sampling for several months and found as much as an eightfold difference in nitrate concentrations for a given vegetable between sampling dates. Certainly some of the difference in nitrate concentration between sampling dates can be attributed to genetic factors, although the cultivars were not known. A part of the difference can be accounted for by nutritional factors since fertilizer applications vary somewhat with geographical location and season of growth. Probably most of the difference in nitrate concentration between sampling dates, however, can be related to environmental conditions before and at harvest (Section 111,A). Nitrate in plants is in a dynamic state constantly responding to changes in environment; thus, extreme variation in nitrate concentrations in plants is normal and to be expected. Nonetheless, the average values obtained with repeated sampling are similar to the average of values shown in Table VII. Presumably, average values based on a sufficient number of samples will largely circumvent the problem of variability.
C. PROCESSED VEGETABLES
The concentration of nitrate in a processed vegetable is usually much less than that in the comparable fresh vegetable. The earliest reported data for processed vegetables showed that nitrate concentrations in canned spinach averaged only 60% of that in fresh spinach (Richardson, 1907). This finding has been generally
102
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL. TABLE VIII Nitrate Concentrations in Fresh Vegetables Purchased in Ithaca, New York Supermarkets' Celery Date sampled
Outer petioles
Lettuce
Inner petioles
Outer leaves
3 April 10 April 17 April 24 April 1 May 7 May 15 May 22 May 5 June 12 June 18 June 15 October 21 October 28 October 5 NovembeI
577 181 337 425 975 277 625 243 575 752 787 465 1000 930 472
187 42 322 106 300 175 137 90 218 156 122 262 387 335 262
ppm NO,-N, 356 450 500 212 231 437 287 168 187 468 487 600 287 237 262
Average:
5 75
207
346
Spinach
Inner leaves fresh wt 143 125 143 112 100 156 117 107 113 162 193 100 156 118 137 132
Petioles only
Petioles and lamina
1850 1050 1175 750 2250 1250 750 950 1275 1250 2250 900 1475 1312 1037
685 355 5 25 3 15 985 511 289 455 500 475 1050 7 25 412 536 5 19
1228
556
'P. L. Minotti, unpublished data.
confirmed by Bodiphala and Ormrod (1971) for spinach and snap beans and by Lee et al. (1971b) for spinach and beets. The loss in nitrate during processing is attributed to leaching during the blanching process (Lee et al., 1971b), and most of the loss occurs within the first minute of blanching (Bodiphala and Ormrod, 1971). 1. Nitrate and Internal Can Corrosion
In addition to the potential health hazards (Section It), the preservation of canned vegetables may be adversely affected by high nitrate concentrations. Sweet potatoes (Smittle and Scott, 1969), snap beans, carrots, spinach (Farrow et al., 1969), and especially tomatoes (Farrow et al., 1971; Hoff and Wilcox, 1970; Myazaka, 1975) act in storage on the tin coating of the can to reduce the shelf-life of the product. Nitrate, acting as an oxidizing agent, has been determined to be the principal detinning agent in these products.
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
103
In many cases, however, other constituents or properties of the product may act in concert with nitrate or independently to cause can detinning. Thus, can corrosion by sweet potatoes (Smittle and Scott, 1969) was related to both phenolase activity and high nitrate concentrations. Oxalic acid and product pH, as well as nitrate, were associated with can corrosion by spinach. Detinning by snap beans was related to pH and nitrate concentrations while low product phosphate concentrations along with high nitrate concentrations caused detinning by carrots (Farrow et at!, 1969). It appears that even vegetables typically quite low in nitrate (Section IV, B), like sweet potatoes, snap beans, and sometimes carrots, may cause internal can corrosion in association with other product constituents.
2. Nitrate and Processed Product Quality The confounding of external and internal factors affecting absorption of nitrate and NR activity may affect other metabolic processes within plants, and the degree of effect may depend on the stage of growth, development, and maturation of the plants. Therefore, the concentration of nitrate in plant tissue at harvest is only a part of the effect of nitrate during the growing season, leading to the end result of total N in the plant tissue. A relation of concentration of nitrate to total N or other N compounds obtained only at harvest may be misleading as to the overall perspective of relationships of nitrate to total N in plants. Nitrogen fertilization and the accumulation of nitrate in vegetable crops may have marked effects on quality components of certain processed products. This is well illustrated in sugar beets (Ulrich et al., 1959; Ulrich and Hills, 1973) and is applicable to table beets where sugar and glutamine (Bourne and Robinson, 1967; Lee, 1974; Lee et al., 1971a; Peck et al., 1974; Shallenberger and Sayre, 1960; Shallenberger et al., 1959; Shannon et al., 1967) contents are related to N fertilization. Both glutamine and sugar have organoleptic significance on the quality of table beets. The effects of time and rate of N fertilizer on nitrate-N and glutamine in the roots of table beet plants are shown in Figs. 3 and 4 and Table IX. Without N fertilizer the beet roots had low concentrations of nitrate and glutamine and a low final yield at harvest. Nitrogen fertilizer applied before planting resulted in beet roots with a high concentration of nitrate in the seedling stage which gradually decreased with time to a low of only 0.01% nitrate-N dry weight at harvest, yet produced a high yield of roots with 1.79% total N and 2.93% glutamine (Table IX). Nitrogen fertilizer, sidedressed only, increased the concentrations of total N, nitrate-N, and glutamine in the roots, but yields were not as high as from N fertilizer applied before planting. However, N fertilizer applied before planting or sidedressed had about the same effects when expressed as
104
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
NJTRATE - N IN ROOTS
2
6 a
0.2
0.1 No ffllll2fM N
0 30
7
I5
JUNE
JULY
JULY
22 JULY
29 JULY
5 12 AUGUST AUGUST
FIG. 3. Effects of N fertilizer (112 kglha) applied before planting and/or sidedressed during the growing season on the concentration of nitrate-N in table beet roots (adapted from Peck ef al., 1974).
content of total N, nitrate-N and glutamine in the roots at harvest (Table IX). Nitrogen fertilizer applied before planting plus sidedressed had an additive effect on total N, nitrate-N, and glutamine but not on yield. Due to the accumulation of glutamine with increased N-fertilization of table beets, the formation of 2-pyrrolidone-5-carboxylicacid (F'CA) from the heatlabile glutamine during processing is also enhanced. PCA causes a distinctive off-flavor in canned beets. Lee and associates (1971b) have shown that glutamine accumulation in beets is directly related to N fertilization and that the concentration of PCA in the processed product was directly related to the glutamine content of the fresh beets. The concentration of PCA in processed beets can be controlled to some extent by the processing time.
D. CRITICAL NITRATE CONCENTRATIONS
The prediction of fertilizer requirements from plant analysis is based on the critical concentration of a nutrient within the plant. This concept as developed by Ulrich (1952) and expanded by Ulrich and Hills (1967) defines critical concentration as the nutrient concentration of a plant when the nutrient is just
105
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
I
"O
/
t
01
30 JUNE
I
7 JULY
15 JULY
22 JULY
29 JULY
5 AUGUST
12 AUGUST
FIG. 4. Effects of N fertilizer (112 kg/ha) applied before planting and/or sidedressed during the growing season on concentrations of glutamine in roots of table beet plants (adapted from Peck el ul., 1974).
deficient for maximum growth. As a matter of convenience and practice, the critical concentration usually has been determined at a 10%restriction in growth resulting from a deficiency of the nutrient under study. Plant variables such as tissue, tissue age, nutrient fraction, or cultivar may affect critical concentration values. In like manner environmental and soil variable such as light, temperature, or moisture supply influence the critical concentration. These and other relationships have been reviewed by Bates (1971). Precise critical nitrate-N concentrations have been extracted from the literature and are presented in Table X. Due to the number of variables affecting critical concentrations, it might be more appropriate and meaningful to use a narrow range of concentrations around the determined values. Despite these limitations, the determination of critical nitrate-N concentrations for vegetable crops offers an effective procedure for predicting nitrate requirements. Thus, N fertilization can be equated with crop requirements, and excessive nitrate-N accumulation can be avoided. It is unfortunate that critical nitrate-N concentrations are documented in the literature for only eight vegetable crop species. The paucity of such data perhaps can be explained by the high cost of conducting these experiments, the large number of different vegetable
TABLE IX Effect of Ammonium Nitrate Fertilizer on Growth and NCompounds in Table Beet Roots at Harvest'
P
Ammonium nitrate (kg N/ha) Before planting
Sidedressed
Total N
0 0 112 112
0 112 0 112
1.20 2.42 1.79 2.77
'From Peck etal. (1974).
NitrateN
Fresh
Glutamine
Sugar
0.01 0.11 0.04 0.18
1.37 4.53 2.93 5.36
56.9 48.9 53.9 48.8
wt
Dry wt
Total N
NitrateN
Glutamine
Sugar
17,000 21,100 29,900 28,100
3360 3250 5490 4930
40 79 98 137
0.3 3.6 2.2 8.9
46 147 161 264
1910 1590 2960 2410
z
5 3
*
r
TABLE X: Critical Nitrate-N Concentrations at a 10% Growth Restriction for Various Vegetable Crops Critical Conc. crop Cucumber
Species Cucumis sativus L.
Lettuce
Lactuca sativa L.
Potato
Solanum tuberosum L.
Radish
Raphanus sativus L.
Spinach
Spinach oleracea L.
Cultivar Cubit Blackseeded Simpson White Rose Cherry Belle America Heavy Pack
Squash
sweet melon
Tomato
Cucurbitapep0 L.
Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.
Plant tissue
42 days from seeding Market Maturity
Mature petioles
18 days vegetative growth Market Maturity Market Maturity Market Maturity
Hybrid 424
Market Maturity
Black Zucchini
42 days from seeding 42 days from seeding 46 days from seeding
Cucumis melo var. du&im Naud.
Sampling time
Ginza 4
4 VF145-21
Entire aerial portion Petiole 2 from terminal Root
% NO,-N Dry wt
0.200
El-Sheikh et al. (1970) Maynard and Barker (1971)
0.200
Ulrich and Fong (1973) 0.200 0.500
Entire aerial portion Entire aerial portion Entire aerial portion Mature petiole
Reference
Maynard and Barker (1971) Maynard and Barker (1974)
0.170 Maynard and Barker (1974)
c
0.150 Maynard and Barker (1974)
bl
0.045 El-Sheikh ef at! (1970)
0.100 Mature petiole Petiole 2 from terminal
0.300
El-Sheikh et al. (1970)
0.050
Gomez-Lepe and Ulrich (1974)
c)
s
108
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
crops grown commercially, the demonstrated (Maynard and Barker, 1974) cultivar differences in critical concentrations, and the need to define the environmental conditions preceding the sampling period (Section 111, A). Excess nitrate accumulation in plants may be defined as the amount of nitrate found in the tissue above the concentration required for maximum growth. The data compiled in Table XI indicate that excess accumulation varies considerably among species and probably depends upon the tissue being sampled, tissue age, and environmental conditions. Specifically, excess nitrate-N accumulation relative to that required for maximum growth varies from 103% for leaf lettuce to 384% for squash. Data such as these confirm that plants have a great capacity to accumulate nitrate beyond the concentrations required for maximum growth. At present the best available basis for assessing and predicting nutritional requirements is through the critical concentration concept. The use of critical concentrations should be expanded and encouraged as critical nitrate-N values are obtained, recognizing that nitrate concentrations in plants fluctuate and, therefore, that some caution should be applied to its use.
E. GROWTH AND NITROGEN MANAGEMENT OF VEGETABLE CROPS
A N fertilization program for vegetable crops should be managed to provide adequate, but not excessive available N for reliable production of yield and quality, while avoiding or minimizing losses of N to the environment. Yield and quality of produce per unit of N available from all sources during the growing season should be used to evaluate N-use efficiency, rather than units of N per area of land. Improvement in cultural practices other than N management may increase N-use efficiency. For instance, plant selection can be used as a means of increasing production per unit of N (O’Sullivan ef al., 1974). The concentration of nitrate in various portions of plants may be considered as a measure to evaluate the balance between adequate and excessive available N for optimum growth and development during the growing season. Typically, however, this balance assumes two greatly different modes depending on the particular vegetable crop under consideration. Flants that develop fruit or storage organs, such as tomatoes or potatoes, usually show a decline in nitrate-N concentrations in the petioles as the crop approaches harvest (Ceraldson ef al., 1973). The decline in petiole nitrate concentrations is associated with translocation of soluble-N to the developing storage organ, as well as a gradual decrease in available soil-N (Allaway, 1975). A greatly different pattern of nitrate accumulation occurs in vegetables that do not develop storage organs as the food product in that nitrate generally continues to accumulate with age in celery (Zink, 1963), Iettuce (Zink and Yamaguchi, 1962), and spinach (Barker ef al., 1971).
109
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES TABLE XI Nitrate-N Culture Levels Resulting in Maximum Yields and Maximum Nitrate-N Accumulation for Various Vegetable Crops Maximum yield
Maximum NO, -N accumulation
NO,-N level (mEq/liter)
NO,-N accumulation (% dry wt)
NO,-N Level (mEq/liter)
NO, -N accumulation (%dry wt)
NO,-N Excess (% dry wt)
6
0.57
48
1.74
1.17
Lettuce
12
1.41
24
1.45
0.04
Potato
16
3.15
64
3.96
0.81
Radish
12
1.04
48
1.42
0.38
Squash
6
0.44
48
I .69
1.25
Sweet melon
6
0.72
48
1.75
1.03
16
2.67
64
3.29
0.62
Crop Cucumber
Tomato
Reference El-Sheikh er al. (1970) Maynard and Barker (1971) Ulrich and Fong (1973) Maynard and Barker (1971) ElSheikh er al. (1970) El-Sheikh et al. (1970) Gomez-Lepe and (Ulrich (1974)
NOTE: Refer to Table X for species, cultivar, sampling time, and plant tissue.
The stage of growth, development, and maturation of plants must be considered, when relating optimum concentration of nitrate in any plant part to the N status of the plant (Chamberland and Doiron, 1973; Geraldson et al., 1973; Maynard and Barker 1972; Peck er al., 1974; Smith and Salmon, 19.47). Vegetable crops have the characteristic sigmoid growth curve of plants consisting of three interrelated stages of growth during their relatively short life from planting to harvest: (1) seedling and early growth, (2) frame, and (3) maturation (Peck, 1975). 1. Seedling and Early Growth Stage A high concentration of nitrate in seedlings indicates that adequate N is available in the limited rooting zone to promote early, vigorous, uniform growth. Uniform emergence and growth of a crop is essential for the production of a high-yielding, quality crop (Peck and Clark, 1973). Therefore, factors affecting nitrate availability at planting may have a continuing effect on the plants from planting until harvest. Generally, because of nitrification, N is absorbed from soils in the nitrate form by plants, and nitrate produces better growth than the ammonium form (Hewitt, 1970; Ingested, 1972; Polizotto er al., 1975), especially for seedlings (Barker er al., 1970; Patnaik et al., 1972). The rate of nitrification of ammonium to nitrate is dependent upon soil environmental conditions (Alexander, 1965; McLaren, 1969).
110
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
The capacity of soils to supply available N over the growing season may be estimated from the N mineralization potential of soils (Giles et al., 1975, Stanford and Smith, 1972). Nitrogen mineralization rates indicate the amount of soil N available to the plants over a period of time; thus, one can calculate the rate and amount of N fertilizer needed during the growing season for adequate available N for plant growth based on potential or expected yield (Stanford, 1973). Requirements for fertilizer-N can also be estimated by plant analysis, particularly when these determinations are made early in the growth cycle (Geraldson et al., 1973). With potatoes, for example, maximum yields occur when nitrate-N concentrations are at least 1.20% on a dry weight basis in the most recently matured petioles during the early (before blossoming) plant growth stage (Tyler et al., 1961). Nitrate sufficiency values have been established for a number of other vegetable crops during the early plant growth or seedling stage (Geraldson et al., 1973), but in sweet corn, a rather poor relationship was found between nitrate concentration at the 8-leaf stage and yield. 2. Frame Stage A medium concentration of nitrate in plant tissues during the frame or midgrowth stage indicates sufficient available N in the rooting zone to maintain growth and development in the plants. Carter et al. (1971) interpreted the time-dependent decrease in concentration of nitrate in petioles of sugar beet plants during the growing season to predict the need for supplemental N fertilizer for the remainder of the season. Halvorson et al. (1975) found that fresh juice can be used to determine nitrate-N in petioles of beet plants. However, a petiole test, preferably together with a soil test, early in the growing season is more useful for determining the requirements for optimal N fertilizer applications. Nitrate concentrations in roots, petioles, and blades of table beet plants grown with different rates and time of application of N fertilizer were determined during the growing season (Peck et aL, 1974). Within the range of about 0.04 to 0.60% nitrate-N on a dry weight basis, the linear correlation ( r 2 ) between percentage nitrate-N in the roots and blades was 0.76 (Fig. 5). Within the range of nitrate of about 0.04 to 0.60% nitrate-N in the roots and 0.07 to 2.0% in the petioles, the linear correlation between percentage nitrate-N in the petioles and roots was 0.82. Thus, with the close correlation between percentages of nitrate in petioles and roots and the wider range of nitrate in the petioles than in blades, petioles are a more sensitive sampling tissue than blades to indicate the nitrate status of the roots. In potato petioles, at least 0.90% nitrate-N on a dry weight basis at midseason is required to insure maximum yields (Tyler et al., 1961). Geraldson et al. (1973) reported the following nitrate-N concentrations at midgrowth as being
NITRATE ACCUMULATION IN VEGETABLES
111
sufficient: carrot petioles, 1 .OO%; celery petioles, 0.90%; spinach petioles, 0.80%;and sweet potato petioles, 0.35%, on a dry weight basis.
3. Maturation Although N fertilizer applications generally increase the concentration of nitrate in plants, the concentration of nitrate in plants at harvest time has not been consistently related to N fertilization (Wright and Davison, 1964). When
?
0.6 -
ILu
petio\ec
z
2
$
0.2
Lu
z* o V
PER C E N T NITRATE-N BLADES A N D PETIOLES
FIG. 5. Correlations of concentrations of nitrate in roots, petioles and blades of table beet plants (adapted from Peck etal., 1974).
potassium chloride fertilizer is applied to soil, plants absorb and accumulate the K and C1 ions, which remain in the plant tissues in amounts nearly proportional to the rate applied (Peck and MacDonald, 1972). In contrast, when ammonium nitrate fertilizer is applied to soil, plants absorb most of the N in the nitrate form, and with adequate growing conditions, most of the nitrate is assimilated and metabolized to other N compounds within the plants (Peck et al., 1974). Long-term effects of N fertilizer applied before or at planting may have less influence on the concentration of nitrate in plant tissues at harvest time than short-term effects (Section 111, A) such as soil and air temperature, solar radiation, awilable soil water and evapotranspiration stress on the plants at or near harvest (Hanway ef al., 1963). Brown and Smith (1966) reported that table beet roots, grown with 0 to 448 kg N/ha from ammonium nitrate applied at planting, had very low concentrations of nitrate in response to N fertilization. However, as they explained the higher rates of N fertilizer may have increased early vegetative growth which was followed by a reduced supply of available nitrate in the soil; thus, accumulation of nitrate did not occur as evidenced by sampling only at harvest. In a later study, Brown and Smith (1967) reported that N increased the concentration of nitrate in the roots harvested on 26 June when table beet plants were grown in 1964 with 0 to 224 kg N/ha. Roots harvested on 19 July, however, had a higher
112
D. N. MAYNARD ET AL.
nitrate concentration than those harvested on 26 June, probably due to a cool and wet spring followed by warmer soil temperatures which increased available nitrate in the soil. In 1965, N fertilizer increased the concentration of nitrate-N in the tops of the beet plants from 0.19 to 0.78% dry weight but did not affect nitrate in the roots. The inconsistent effect of N fertilizer on concentration of nitrate in the beet roots at harvest justifies the necessity of monitoring nitrate in the plants during the growing season. In addition, environmental factors that affect nitrate availability in the root zone, uptake by the plants, and metabolism of nitrate within the plants must be considered in order to evaluate the cause of different concentrations of nitrate in the roots at harvest. Their conclusion (Brown and Smith, 1966, 1967) that in general, the use of fertilizer N in excess of 56 kg/ha causes nitrate accumulation in most vegetables is obviously a misleading guide to efficient use of N fertilizer for table beets. In order to evaluate the economic response of table beets to N fertilizer, information is needed on plant population per unit area, especially in rows close enough for commerical production. Thus, returns per unit of N fertilizer can be expressed per unit of production rather than unit area of soil. The concentration of available N in the rooting zone must be adjusted to the response or requirements of the plants at various stages of growth, development, and maturity in order to supply adequate but not excessive available N for optimum N efficiency. Using the definitions of concentration and contents as proposed by Farhoomand and Peterson (1968), the concentration of nitrate, expressed as percentage nitrate-N on a dry weight basis, generally decreases during the growing season for crops producing fruit or storage organs. A high concentration of nitrate in the early growing season may increase the growth of plants so that at harvest, plants may have a low concentration of nitrate/unit of dry weight but a high content of nitratelha in the total dry weight of plants. For vegetative crops, concentration and content of nitrate may increase with maturity. V. Conclusions
The threat of nitrate toxicity to man from ingestion of vegetables has stimulated widespread interest and research in nitrate accumulation by vegetable crops. Findings summarized herein tend to minimize the hazard associated with consumption of nitrate-containing vegetables by adults and by infants over 3 months of age when the food is given sanitary preparation, proper refrigeration, and timely consumption. Nonetheless, it appears important to incorporate low nitrate-accumulating cultivars, fertility and management practices resulting in restricted nitrate concentrations, and ma