Advances in Insect Physiology
Volume 31
ThisPageIntentionallyLeftBlank
Advances in Insect Physiology edited by S. J. Simpson Department of Zoology and University Museum of Natural History, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
Volume 31
Amsterdam Boston Heidelberg London New York Oxford Paris San Diego San Francisco Singapore Sydney Tokyo
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB UK ß 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Ltd, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone ( þ 44) 1865 843830, fax ( þ 44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: ( þ 1) (978) 7508400, fax: ( þ 1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: ( þ 44) 20 7631 5555; fax: ( þ 44) 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier’s Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First edition 2003 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record is available from the British Library. Academic Press An imprint of Elsevier 84 Theobald’s Road London WC1X 8RR, UK http://www.academicpress.com
Academic Press An imprint of Elsevier 525 B Street, Suite 1900 San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA http://www.academicpress.com
ISBN: 0-12-024231-1 ISSN: 0065-2806 The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Printed in Great Britain.
Contents Contributors
vii
Foreword
ix
Obituary
xi
Insect Sterol Nutrition and Physiology: A Global Overview SPENCER T. BEHMER, W. DAVID NES
1
The Nutritional Physiology of Aphids ANGELA E. DOUGLAS
73
The Neurobiology of Taste in Insects STEPHEN M. ROGERS, PHILIP L. NEWLAND
141
Trehalose – The Insect ‘Blood’ Sugar S. NELSON THOMPSON
205
INDEX
287
ThisPageIntentionallyLeftBlank
Contributors S. T. Behmer Department of Zoology, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford, OX1 3PS, UK A. E. Douglas Department of Biology, University of York, PO Box 373, York, YO10 5YW, UK P. L. Newland School of Biological Sciences, University of Southampton, Bassett Crescent East, Southampton, SO16 7PX, UK W. D. Nes Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Texas Tech University, Box 41061, Lubbock, TX 79409-1061, USA S. M. Rogers Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge, Downing St, Cambridge CB2 3EJ, UK S. N. Thompson Analytical Chemistry Instrumentation Facility and Department of Entomology, University of California, Riverside, CA 92521, USA
ThisPageIntentionallyLeftBlank
Foreword This is my first volume as Editor and I must begin by thanking, on all our behalves, Peter Evans for the excellent job he has done over the past 17 years. Peter has overseen the publication of 11 volumes of Advances in Insect Physiology, each one an adventure. I hope to live up to the very high standards he has set. The flavour of a journal will inevitably reflect the tastes of its editor, as well as the prevailing trends and advances in the subject. Recent years have seen a growing interest in physiological mechanisms among ecologists, behavioural scientists and evolutionary biologists. We should nurture this trend, and I aim actively to commission papers in these areas. I am also keen to receive unsolicited proposals, submissions and requests for papers in any area of insect physiology – and I am willing to interpret the field broadly. As the present volume was nearing completion, the sad news came that Reg Chapman had died. Reg’s book The Insects: Structure and Function (editions 1–4) has been the pre-eminent text and reference work on insect physiology for the past 34 years, and will continue to be so for some time yet. Through this seminal book Reg has had a greater role in disseminating the subject than any other insect physiologist. I would like to dedicate Volume 31 to Reg. This is especially fitting, given the direct influence he had through his research on the topics covered by the reviews in this volume. As a result, although it was not planned as such, this volume serves as a Festschrift for Reg.
Reginald Frederick Chapman (1930–2003): An Obituary After taking his undergraduate degree in zoology at Queen Mary College, University of London, in 1951, Reg accepted a scholarship from the AntiLocust Research Centre to work on the factors controlling roosting behaviour in locusts. The ALRC was based at the Natural History Museum in London. Its director was B.P. Uvarov, the father of locust biology. He had brought together a distinguished research team that included John Kennedy and Donald Gunn; two others who, along with Uvarov, had a formative influence on Reg’s scientific development. Reg’s doctoral research was carried out at Birkbeck College in London, to where he would later return and write The Insects. After his Ph.D., Reg joined the International Red Locust Control Service and travelled to East Africa, where he lived and worked for more than three years in the Rukwa Valley, a locust outbreak area in a remote, largely uninhabited, area in East Africa, with no electricity, telephone or radio. Reg built his own house, complete with plumbing, grew his own fruit and vegetables, and became addicted to the idea that laboratory and fieldwork should be combined. At first he extended his study of roosting behaviour in locusts (as well as studying frogs and lizards), then he turned to feeding behaviour – the area in which he went on to make his most important scientific contributions. An indication of Reg’s dedication to taking the laboratory to the field is seen in his experiments testing Peggy Ellis and Graham Hoyle’s hypothesis that haemolymph potassium levels influenced locust behaviour through a direct effect on neuromuscular transmission. This required running a flame photometer under the most unpromising of circumstances. Reg left the locust service in 1957 and took a lectureship at the University of Ghana, where he worked on tsetse flies and grasshoppers, before moving in 1959 to a position at Birkbeck College in London. There he taught invertebrate zoology and developed a masters course in entomology, which he taught single-handedly. Writing and giving the more than 100 lectures and associated practical classes in the course provided Reg with an encyclopaedic knowledge of entomology, and also honed his extraordinary teaching skills. He brought together this knowledge in The Insects – Structure and Function, first published
xii
REGINALD FREDERICK CHAPMAN (1930–2003)
in 1969. While at Birkbeck, Reg was promoted from Lecturer to Reader, then Professor. In addition to his formidable teaching schedule, he established a productive and innovative research group, focusing on feeding behaviour and the chemosensory system. It was during this time that Liz Bernays, who was to become Reg’s wife, joined the group, as did another key figure, Wally Blaney. In 1970, Reg moved to become Director of the Laboratory Research Division of the Anti-Locust Research Centre (later to be renamed the Centre for Overseas Pest Research), which had moved to new premises in Wright’s Lane, Kensington. The incoming Director, Peter Haskell, gave Reg the freedom to develop research projects both in the lab and overseas in the field. Reg and his team took as their themes the basis of varietal resistance in crop plants and the mechanisms of host–plant selection by phytophagous insects. He directed and played an active, practical part in research projects that included a study of movement patterns in the brown rice planthopper, based in the Philippines, a project in India investigating varietal resistance of sorghum to insect pests, one in Botswana on sorghum entomology, another in Nigeria on a pest grasshopper, the impact of soil termites on grasslands, and the impact of pesticide residues on non-target species, and a radar-tracking study in Mali on grasshopper migrations. Meanwhile, in the laboratory, Reg, Liz and their colleagues and students continued to explore feeding behaviour and host–plant selection, making significant progress in elucidating the role of host–plant chemistry. In 1983, Reg and Liz left for Berkeley – Liz to a Faculty position and Reg to an unsalaried situation. In so doing, he had chosen to put Liz’s career ahead of his own, which was a typical example of Reg’s belief in supporting talented others above himself. In 1987, the University of Arizona took advantage of the opportunity to get Chapman and Bernays and, to Berkeley’s loss, offered them both professorships. Reg was appointed Professor in Insect Neurobiology in John Hildebrand’s Division of Neurobiology. Until his retirement in 2001, Reg played an influential role in the academic and teaching life at Tucson, which, thanks in no small part to his efforts, has become one of the world’s most distinguished centres for insect science. One especially notable achievement was Reg’s contribution to the establishment and success of the crossdepartmental Center for Insect Science, for which he served as Interim Director from 1998–1999. Reg also continued his research on feeding and chemosensory physiology, wrote numerous scientific papers, co-wrote the book Host–Plant Selection by Phytophagous Insects (1994) with Liz, co-edited and part-wrote Regulatory Mechanisms in Insect Feeding (1995), and completely rewrote and reillustrated The Insects (1998), as well as writing several key review papers and assuming a demanding graduate and undergraduate teaching load. He did all of this and more under the shadow of advancing leukaemia, which had first been diagnosed in 1990 and to which he finally succumbed on May 2nd 2003.
REGINALD FREDERICK CHAPMAN (1930–2003)
xiii
Reg’s legacy lies at several levels. Through The Insects – Structure and Function and its numerous translations, he has reached and influenced many thousands of biologists worldwide. In his other, more specialist books, book chapters, and review papers, Reg has shaped thinking in the field of insect–plant relationships through his ability to bring together large amounts of scattered literature and build new syntheses. This was especially well demonstrated in his classic review in Advances in Insect Physiology (1982), in which he collated vast amounts of published data on chemoreceptor numbers in insects (itself a huge job) and used them to build functional arguments to explain variation in chemoreceptor numbers between different taxa and lifehistories. At the time such a ‘comparative approach’ was virtually unknown, but has since become a cornerstone of modern biology. Reg also published 110 primary research papers, typified by their scholarship and attention to detail. Many more papers that could have borne his name were published under the authorship of his 37 doctoral students, and the many others to whom he gave his time and encouragement freely. Reg’s philosophy for supervising graduates was to ‘‘try to convey three things: integrity, knowledge and enthusiasm. . . This requires developing a level of mutual trust with each individual that enables us to assess work critically’’. Those of us fortunate enough to have been supervised by Reg have seen his integrity, knowledge and enthusiasm first hand – as well as his passion for getting it right and his ability to grasp the point and effortlessly spot the flaws in apparently water-tight arguments. To this list of attributes, those of us who knew Reg would also wish to add his modesty, kindness, inspiration – and the twinkle in his eye. Reg is survived by two children from his first marriage, Anne and Philip, two grandchildren, and his beloved wife, Liz Bernays. Steve Simpson, June 2003
ThisPageIntentionallyLeftBlank
Insect Sterol Nutrition and Physiology: A Global Overview Spencer T. Behmera and W. David Nesb a
Department of Zoology, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PS, UK; b Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Texas Tech University, Box 41061, Lubbock, TX 79409-1061, USA
1 Introduction 2 2 Sterol structures and dietary sources 4 2.1 Sterol structure and nomenclature 4 2.2 Algal and lichen sterols 4 2.3 Fungal sterols 6 2.4 Plant sterols 7 2.5 Animal sterols 9 3 Insect sterol use and metabolism 9 3.1 Insect sterol use 12 3.2 Insect sterol metabolism 20 3.3 Considerations of patterns of sterol use and metabolism 35 4 Insect sterol physiology 38 4.1 Sterol taste and the regulation of intake 42 4.2 Sterol absorption 44 4.3 Sterol transport and tissue distribution 47 4.4 Sterol reproductive physiology 52 5 Insect sterol ecology 54 6 Applied implications and evolution of sterol metabolic constraints 56 7 Conclusions 57 Acknowledgements 59 References 59
Abstract Unlike most animals, insects lack the capacity to synthesize sterols that are required in lipid biostructures, as precursors to important steroid hormones and as regulators of developmental processes. Therefore insects must acquire sterols from their diet. Hundreds of different sterols have been identified and the review starts by documenting the occurrence of sterols in different insect foods. Next we look at the various nutritional and biochemical studies that have been conducted, and organize them according to insect relatedness, which allows insect sterol use and metabolic capabilities to be viewed from an evolutionary perspective. How sterol structure influences insect feeding behavior is ADVANCES IN INSECT PHYSIOLOGY VOL. 31 ISBN 0-12-024231-1 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-2806(03)31001-X
Copyright # 2003 Elsevier Ltd All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
2
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
examined, and the fate of sterols once they have been ingested, including the processes of absorption and transport, their distribution in different tissues, and their role in reproduction, is detailed. The extent to which sterols may influence ecological outcomes is also considered, especially in phytophagous insects with known sterol metabolic constraints. Finally, mention is made of the potential use of exploiting insect sterol requirements and constraints for pest control, as well as the ability of insects to adapt to the presence of novel sterols in their diet. 1
Introduction
The dietary need for sterols in insects was first established in the blowfly, Lucilia sericata (Hobson, 1935a), and is the only proven nutritional difference between insects and most other animals. However, it was the seminal work by Clark and Bloch (1959a) that demonstrated the inability of insects to synthesize sterols de novo, thereby generating sterol auxotrophy. Since these early studies, the dietary requirement for sterols has been extended to other insect orders, including Orthoptera, Blattaria, Hemiptera, Coleoptera, Diptera, Lepidoptera, and Hymenoptera (Svoboda et al., 1994). Initial studies on insect sterol nutrition focused on cholesterol and its surrogates. For instance, Clayton (1964) reared the hide beetle, Dermestes vulpinus, on a diet that contained different amounts of cholesterol and cholestanol supplemented in the diet and determined that cholesterol played two roles in governing larval growth and development. The two dietary sterols differ in the structure of the nucleus, i.e., the existence of a 5- (double bond at carbon 5–6) or 0- (no double bond), respectively, but this difference has only a minimal effect on the amphipathic properties of the molecules. This means that both can serve equally well as a membrane insert. Clark and Bloch (1959a) surmised that cholestanol, added as a bulk sterol to the food, was serving a structural role, whereas cholesterol added at trace levels acted as a sparing sterol, functioning in a metabolic role. At that time the exact nature of the metabolic role was speculative. Further study demonstrated that ecdysteroids derived from cholesterol were functioning hormonally to control insect growth and maturation (reviewed by Gilbert et al., 2002). The importance of sterol availability and structure to the growth of phytophagous insects was examined in subsequent years by a research group at the U.S. Department of Agriculture (Thompson, 1984). In a beautifully designed set of pioneering experiments, they opened-up the area of structure– activity and enzymatic studies, including the rational design and assay of inhibitors of insect sterol metabolism. For example, certain vertebrate hypocholesterolemic agents such as triparanol were found to inhibit important enzymatic reactions in the sterol biosynthetic pathway that were involved in the conversion of phytosterols to cholesterol in the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta, and other insects (Svoboda and Robbins, 1967). These agents effectively stopped insect growth and development, and thus became important tools for the study
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
3
of phytosterol metabolism in other insects (Svoboda, 1984). Following inhibitor treatment the identification of desmosterol (cholesta-5,24-dienol) as the terminal intermediate to cholesterol in M. sexta provided the first information on intermediate steps involved in the pathway. Subsequently, Ritter and Nes (1981a) composed a sterol-free diet, which was used to culture Helicoverpa zea. The availability of this diet proved instrumental in establishing the exactness of sterol homeostasis (balance in the type and amount of sterol) in controlling insect physiology. At about the same time, Kircher (1982) at the University of Arizona was studying sterol ecology, and Ikekawa et al. (1993) in Japan was studying the stereochemical mechanisms involved in phytosterol side chain dealkylation and reduction. The latter investigators demonstrated the relationship of side chain transformations in insects to more derived animal systems. More recently, the effect of sterols on the Hedgehog (Hb) gene family, which encodes a group of secreted signal molecules that are essential for growth and patterning of many different body parts (Ingham et al., 1991; Alexandra et al., 1999), has been documented. Beachy and coworkers have found that cholesterol can modify covalently the Hedgehog family proteins in animals, thereby affecting morphology (Porter et al., 1996). These observations open up exciting new avenues of research regarding the multiple roles of sterols in insects distinct from studying the role of cholesterol as a membrane insert or as a precursor to ecdysteroids. The role of sterols in insect nutrition and physiology (Clayton, 1964; Dadd, 1977, 1985; Svoboda and Thompson, 1985; Bernays, 1992), including sterol metabolism and ecdysteroid production (Robbins et al., 1971; Thompson et al., 1973; Svoboda et al., 1978; Svoboda and Thompson, 1985; Svoboda and Feldlaufer, 1991; Ikekawa et al., 1993; Svoboda, 1999), has been documented regularly over the past 30 years. Our goal in this chapter is to provide a global overview of this topic, but for practical reasons we have deliberately downplayed the details of sterol metabolism and ecdysteroid production since they have been presented elsewhere on numerous occasions. We have three specific aims. Our first is to look for unifying themes that can explain patterns of sterol use and metabolism among the insects that have been studied to date. We do this by examining sterol use and metabolism within an evolutionary framework, paying particular attention to insect phylogeny. Next, we review different aspects of sterol physiology by following the journey of sterols through the body. Here we discuss a range of topics, including whether insects taste sterols and regulate their intake, the processes related to sterol metabolism, absorption, transport, and tissue distribution, plus the role of sterols in reproduction. Our third aim is to explore the manner in which insect sterol nutrition and physiology can impact ecological and evolutionary processes. Related to this is the potential of targeting insect sterol metabolic limitations for pest management in agricultural systems. Finally, we conclude the chapter by discussing how the unique sterol physiology of insects might be extended to new and developing areas of sterol research.
4
2
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Sterol structures and dietary sources
Insects are incredibly diverse, with approximately one million species so far described. Estimates including undescribed species suggest that the true number could range between 2 and 5 million (Speight et al., 1999), and Erwin (1982) predicts this number is much higher. The unmatched diversity of insects as a group is partly attributed to their ability to use a wide range of substrates as food, including plants, fungi, algae/mosses, animal tissues and decaying organic materials. As detailed in the following sections, sterols exist in numerous forms but there are some underlying features in the types of structures distributed in the food supply of insects. 2.1
STEROL STRUCTURE AND NOMENCLATURE
Sterols normally ingested by insects are characterized by three domains: a 3 hydroxyl group (A), a tetracyclic ring system (B), and a side chain of 8–10 carbon atoms (C), as shown in Fig. 1. The polar and non-polar elements, consisting of domains A versus B and C, give rise to the amphipathic nature of the molecule. This feature, when coupled with the side chain oriented to the ‘‘right’’, provides a suitable fit of the sterol into the lipid leaflet of membranes (Nes et al., 1978; Bitmann, 1997). The sterol may possess methyl groups at C-4 and they are defined accordingly as C-4 dimethyl sterol, C-4 monomethyl sterol and C-4 desmethyl (no methyls) sterols. The degree of C-4 methylation affects the hydrogen bonding ability of the C-3 hydroxyl group as evidenced in the thin-layer chromatography of these compounds (Xu et al., 1988). Alternatively, the sterol may possess a C-24 methyl or ethyl group, which may possess stereochemistry as either - (in front) or - (in back) oriented. It should be noted that the stereochemical nomenclature for the side chain C-24 alkyl groups can be affected by neighbouring substituents when the R/S-nomenclature is used and that the configuration assignments can be different for groups in the side chain relative to the nucleus (Parker and Nes, 1992). The prefix in -sitosterol is dropped in common usage for chemical reasons (Nes and McKean, 1977; Thompson, 1984). The structure assignments for sterol used typically by phytosterol biochemists is different from natural product chemists, who follow the recently revised numbering of sterols by the International Union for Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) and International Union for Biochemistry (IUB), as indicated in Fig. 1. In the current chapter, we continue to use the sterol nomenclature preferred by traditionalists. 2.2
ALGAL AND LICHEN STEROLS
Feeding on algae and lichens (a symbiotic relationship between algae and fungi) is relatively rare among the insects, but it is found among the Plecoptera, Orthoptera and Psocoptera and, to a small degree, in some of the Hemiptera
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
FIG. 1 Sterol numbering systems. A, B and C represent structural domains.
5
6
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
and Endopterygotes. Most aquatic insects include algae in their diets, but few specialize on it. Some insects, including tree-dwelling Collembola and some Plecoptera, feed on a mixture of algae and lichens. In contrast, the lichen grasshopper, Trimerotropis saxatilis (Orthoptera: Acrididae) and the lichen-eating caterpillar, Manulea replana (Lepidoptera: Acrtiidae), are lichen specialists. Perhaps not surprisingly, they have also become highly cryptic on their food. Several hundred species of algae have been examined for sterol content, and the types of sterols found are usually related to taxonomic position (Patterson, 1994). In general, all the algae, except for the dinoflagellates (Pyrrophyta), have predominantly 5-sterols. Among the freshwater algae that might be eaten by insects, the Charophyta (stoneworts) have two dominant sterols, 24ethylcholesterol and isofucosterol, while the major sterols in Chrysophyta (golden algae) and Xanthophyta (yellow-green algae) are 24-ethylcholesta5,22-dienol and 24-ethylcholesterol, respectively. Cryptophyta (cryptomonads) are characterized by the presence of 24-methylcholesta-5,22-dienol, while the Chlorophyta (green algae) contain 24-epi sitosterol (clionosterol) and ergosterol, plus a few other sterols in smaller quantities (Seckbach et al., 1993). Typically, orders with multicellular algae are characterized as having 24-ethylcholesterol and isofucosterol as their primary sterols, while the more primitive, primarily unicellular orders have a range of sterols, including compounds with double bonds at the 5-, 7-, and 5,7-position. Within the algae, ergosterol has so far only been found in unicellular chlorophyte species belonging to the orders Volvocales and Chlorococcales, and in a few members of the Euglenophyta (Patterson, 1994; Volkman, 2003). A variety of sterols have been identified in the Cyanobacteria (blue-green algae), and they frequently have an ethyl group at C-24 and a ring system with 5-, 7-, or 5,7-double bonds (Nes and Nes, 1980; Rzama et al., 1994). 2.3
FUNGAL STEROLS
Fungus eating is primarily found in 6 insect orders (Collembola, Zoraptera, Psocoptera, Thysanoptera, Coleoptera and Diptera), although individuals in 3 additional orders also occupy this feeding guild (Thysanoptera, Lepidoptera and Hymenoptera). Perhaps the best known fungus-feeders are the leaf cutting ants, which maintain fungus gardens within their nests. Leaf-cutting ants (Hymenoptera: Formicidae: Myrmicinae) include a taxonomically compact group of 12 genera that comprise the tribe Attini and contains approximately 190 species (Weber, 1972). Their distribution is confined to the Nearctic and Neotropical biogeographic region, and the fungus-growing Macrotermitinae seem to be their closest ecological equivalent (Wood and Thomas, 1973). Ambrosia beetles are another well-known example of a fungus-eating insect. The fungi are composed of three major groups, the Zygomycota (bread moulds), Ascomycota (sac fungi) and Basidiomycota (club fungi), and well over a hundred species have been examined for sterol composition (Weete, 1973;
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
7
Patterson, 1994). In general, ergosterol is the dominant sterol, although 5and 7-sterols are occasionally found, and C28 sterols are much more frequent than C29 sterols (Weete, 1973). Ergosterol and related 5,7-sterols are the dominant sterols in most of the Zygomycota, but related C28 sterols can also be abundant and some species contain cholesterol and 24-methylcholesterol (Beilby and Kidby, 1980) or 24-ethylcholesterol (Beilby, 1980). Ergosterol is also the principle sterol in most Ascomycota, but some orders, such as Tuberales and Tafrinales, often contain brassicasterol in large proportions (Weete et al., 1985; van Eijk and Roeymans, 1982). Among the Basidiomycota, ergosterol and related C28 sterols tend to be the rule, although sterols with a 7-monoene nucleus have been recorded in this group (Weete and Laseter, 1974). Other fungal sterols include fungisterol, which is found in bracket fungus (Fomes applanatus), and zymosterol, a sterol biosynthesis intermediate is found in some yeast species (Myant, 1981). In the Ascomycota, Gibberella fujikaroi synthesizes as many as 35 sterols (Nes et al., 1988a) and the formation of 24 -methylsterols (ergosterol) and 24 -methylcholesterol is known to occur via different post-lanosterol pathways (Nes and Lee, 1990). 2.4
PLANT STEROLS
Herbivory is found in only 9 of the 29 insect orders (Collembola, Orthoptera, Phasmida, Thysanoptera, Hemiptera, Coleoptera, Lepidoptera, Diptera and Hymenoptera), but almost half of all described insect species occupy this feeding niche (Strong et al., 1984). Phytophagous insects can be found on every plant species and are known to feed on a range of plant tissues and parts, including leaves, stems, wood, roots, buds, flowers, fruit, pollen, nectar, xylem and phloem. At least 100 different sterols have been identified in plants so far (Akihisa et al., 1991), with structural variation occurring mainly in the position and extent of nuclear and side chain unsaturation and in the extent of 24-alkylation in the side chain. With respect to sterol side chain differences, the size of the 24-alkyl group and its direction (- or -oriented) reflect phylogenetic differences in plant evolution, with the ergosterol side chain (6)
SCHEME 1 Hypothetical pathway to plant sterols.
8
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
found in primitive organisms and the stigmasterol side chain found in derivedorganisms (5) (Scheme 1) (Nes and McKean, 1977). Bryophytes are primitive land plants that contain primarily 5-sterols, although some species have been found to contain 5,7-sterols (Nes and Nes, 1980). With respect to the orientation of the alkyl group at C-24, bryophytes contain both and forms, which contrasts with the fungi and algae where the orientation is usually only (Patterson, 1994). Among the pteridophytes, a group of seedless, vascular plants consisting of whisk ferns, horsetails and clubmosses, sitosterol is the dominant sterol but campesterol and stigmasterol are often present (Chiu et al., 1988). These authors also found that in the pteridophytes, sitosterol and stigmasterol have their C-24-ethyl groups in the orientation. With respect to campesterol, they found that in lycopods it tended to follow the orientation, but in the more derived horsetails, whisk ferns and true ferns it followed the orientation. Among the conifers that have been examined, 5-sterols are common, with sitosterol being the most dominant (Svoboda et al., 1995b; Schiff and Feldlaufer, 1996). Flowering plants (Class Angiospermae) are by far the largest group of vascular plants on earth today, with approximately 250 000 identified species representing a relatively small number of families (320–418) (reviewed by Heywood, 1993). The 5-sterols sitosterol (24) and stigmasterol (24 ) are the most common and abundant sterols found in the angiosperms, but many species also contain campesterol (24-methyl) and 24-dihydrobassicaterol (24 -methyl), usually in a 2:1 ratio (Patterson, 1994). Angiosperms, in contrast to the more primitive plants, sometimes contain 7-sterols, such as spinasterol (24) and stigmast-7-enol (24) (Nes and Nes, 1980). The order Caryophyllales is particularly rich in 7-sterols with 7 of the 12 recognized families having major and sometimes dominant quantities, and lesser quantities of 5- and 0sterols (Salt et al., 1991). For example, a survey of the family Curcurbitaceae revealed that it contained almost exclusively 7-sterols (Akihisa et al., 1987). Sterols with a 7 configuration have also been reported in individual members belonging to the Leguminosae, Theaceae and Sapotaceae (Bergmann, 1957). However, sterols with a 5,7 nucleus, such as that found in ergosterol, have yet to be found in large amounts in any angiosperms. In broad terms, most plants contain multiple sterols that vary within some general theme, and there seems to be an underlying phylogenetic pattern determining sterol nucleus structure. An extreme case of structural variation within a species can be found with corn, where 24-alkyl olefin formation is characteristic, but as many as 60 different sterols can be synthesized (Guo et al., 1995). Many insects, especially bees, include pollen in their diets. In general the pollen for most plant species accumulate intermediates such as 24methylenesterols and 9 ,19-cyclopropyl sterols (Nes and Schmidt, 1988; Lusby et al., 1993). Occasionally, however, sitosterol is the principle sterol, as Standifer et al. (1968) found in mule fat (Baccharis viminea), juniper (Juniperus uthaensis), heartsease (Polygonum sp.), waterleaf (Hydrophyllum
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
9
capitatum) Scotch pine (Pinus sylvestris), European alder (Alnus glutinosa) and Lombardy poplar (Populus nigra var. italica). These same authors also found stigmasterol in large amounts in the pollen of heather (Calluna vulgaris) and cholesterol in the pollen of both cottonwood (Populus fremontii) and cat’s ear (Hypochaeris radicata). They found little evidence, however, that taxonomy could be used to predict pollen sterol profile since three species belonging to the family Salicaceae varied widely in the content of C27, C28 and C29 sterols. 2.5
ANIMAL STEROLS
Zoophagous and saprophagous lifestyles are found in all insect orders, with the exceptions of the Phasmida and Zoraptera (Southwood, 1973), and although the range of animals that insects will eat is quite broad, vertebrates and arthropods (including other insects) seem to constitute the bulk of an insect’s diet. In the vertebrates, cholesterol is by far the most abundant sterol, and the majority of it persists in free (unesterified) form in the plasma membranes, the subcellular membranes of cells and in myelin of nervous tissue (Myant, 1981). Additionally, all vertebrates appear capable of synthesizing cholesterol, but in general they do not absorb C-24 alkylated sterols from their diets (Nes and McKean, 1977). The phylum Arthropoda is the largest of the animal kingdom and sterol composition and metabolism have been extensively studied in this group. It is generally accepted that arthropods cannot synthesize sterols and that they acquire sterols from their foods. Cholesterol tends to be the principle sterol in most species, especially in carnivores and scavengers, but there are numerous exceptions, particularly among those that eat plants and/or fungi (Nes and McKean, 1977; see Section 3.2). Among the phytophagous insects, cholesterol tends to be the dominant sterol, although phytosterols are also often present, and sometimes in large quantities (see Section 3.2). 3
Insect sterol use and metabolism
To date slightly more than 100 insects have been investigated with respect to sterol use or metabolism (Table 1). However, no systematic examination has been made with regard to sterol use/metabolism, and of those insects that have been studied, half come from the Coleoptera, Lepidoptera and Hymenoptera. Among the remaining species to have been examined, only 8 orders are represented. An additional bias exists in that many of the species studied are agricultural pests. In spite of these shortcomings, we document what is known about sterol use and metabolism in different insects and look for emerging patterns, paying particular attention to evolutionary relationships among insects (both within and between orders) and to their differing natural histories. Throughout the paper we used the Tree of Life (Maddison et al., 2001), and to a lesser extent Borror et al. (1989), to determine the relatedness
10
TABLE 1 Survey of sterol studies among the different insect orders. Diet composition taken from Southwood (1973). Order
Number of unique species
Utilization studies (no. of species)
Profile studies (no. of species)
Algae/Lichen/Decaying Plant Material Plant Products Algae/Detritus Animal Algae/Lichen/Animal Dead Plant Material/Lichen/Moss Plant Plant/Animal/Mixed
0 1 0 0 0 0 0 9
– – – – – – – 9
– 1 – – – – – 2
Animal Fungus/Mites Mixed/Wood/Animal Decaying Plant Material Moss/Dead Insects Algae/Fungus/Dead Plant Material Animal Plant
0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0
– – 1 – – – – –
– – 2 – – – – –
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Archaeognatha (bristletails) Thysanura (silverfish and firebrats) Ephemeroptera (mayflies) Odonata (dragonflies and damselflies) Plecoptera (stoneflies) Embiidina (web-spinners) Phasmida (stick or leaf insects) Orthoptera (crickets, locusts, grasshoppers and katydids) Mantophasmatodea Zoraptera Dictyoptera (cockroaches, termite and mantids) Dermaptera (earwigs) Grylloblattodea (ice bugs and rock crawlers) Psocoptera (barklice, booklice) Phthiraptera (lice) Thysanoptera (thrips)
Diet
Total
Plant
1
–
1
Plant
1
–
1
Plant/Animal/Mixed Animal Animal Animal Plant/Animal/Mixed Animal
9 0 0 1 21 0
– – – – 18 –
9 – – 1 4 –
Plant/Fungus/Animal Plant/Fungus/Animal Animal Animal Animal/Mixed Plant
2 10 0 1 0 18
2 10 – 1 – 16
– 2 – – – 4
Plant Plant/Animal/Mixed
8 20
– 2
8 18
105
60
53
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
Hemiptera (sucking bugs) Sternorrhyncha (psyllids, whiteflies, aphids and coccids) Auchenorrhyncha (cicadas, leafhoppers, treehoppers and fulgoroids) Heteroptera (true bugs) Megaloptera (dobsonflies and alderflies) Raphidioptera (snakeflies) Neuroptera (lacewings, antlions and owlflies) Coleoptera (beetles) Strepsiptera Diptera (flies) Nematocera (long-horned flies) Brachycera (short-horned flies) Mecoptera (scorpion-flies) Siphonaptera (fleas) Trichoptera (caddisflies) Lepidoptera (moths and butterflies) Hymenoptera (sawflies, wasps, bees and ants) Symphyta (sawflies) Apocrita (bees, wasps and ants)
11
12
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
of different insect families to one another, and have organized the studies according to insect order ! superfamily ! family ! genus ! species. 3.1
INSECT STEROL USE
Traditionally sterol use has been explored by rearing insects on artificial diets that contain different sterols. This approach requires, however, that an artificial diet already exists or is readily formulated, and that the diet does not have a large pool of contaminating sterol. For example, Behmer and Grebenok (1998) have shown that basic ingredients like wheat germ contain sitosterol, while casein and albumin contain small amounts of cholesterol. Likewise, Nes (1987) demonstrated that agar from red algae contains cholesterol, agar from corn contains a mixture of phytosterols and cholesterol and that Tween 80 and some commercial phospholipids contain a mixture of phystosterols. In such instances contaminating sterols need to be removed, via chemical extraction, or it needs to be shown that they have negligible effects. Demonstrating the latter can prove difficult, however, because of the sparing effect associated with cholesterol (e.g. Clark and Bloch, 1959a). For this particular reason, some insect sterol utilization studies should be viewed with caution, especially those in which the purity of sterols and diet ingredients is not reported. Nonetheless, artificial diet studies have revealed some strong trends, the most notable being that cholesterol supports normal growth and development in all predaceous insects, and most herbivorous insects. Sterol use in phytophagous insects can also be studied by manipulating plant sterol profiles via fungicides and transgenic techniques. In general, though, sterol use studies are lacking for most insect orders, and among the Exopterygota, only grasshoppers have been extensively studied. 3.1.1
The Exopterygota
Grasshoppers are one of the few groups of insects in which sterol use has been systematically studied, with the eight selected species coming from two families, the Romaleidae and Acrididae, and within the latter group four different subfamilies being represented. Inspection of the results from these various species indicates a robust pattern in sterol use among grasshoppers. Cholesterol and sitosterol, two 5-sterols, plus cholestanol, a 0-sterol lacking an alkyl side chain, were found to support growth better than the other sterols examined. Additionally, cholesterol, sitosterol and cholestanol were the only sterols that supported growth from hatchling to the adult stage (Dadd, 1960; Behmer and Elias, 1999a, 2000). Most of the grasshoppers that have been studied, with the exception of the grass specialist, Locusta migratoria, are generalist feeders (i.e. they eat mixed plant diets). This means that they may regularly ingest plant material that contains unsuitable sterols (e.g. 5,22, 7 and 7,22). To investigate the consequences of this on growth and development, Behmer and Elias (1999a, 2000) reared Schistocerca americana hatchlings on synthetic diets
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
13
containing different amounts and proportions of suitable and unsuitable sterols. The results were somewhat surprising because grasshoppers failed to complete development on diets when the ratio of suitable to unsuitable sterols in the food fell below 70%. Interestingly development was impaired even when the suitable sterol was present in amounts that alone would have supported growth. Results from these experiments indicate that in grasshoppers the cholesterol sparing mechanism is weak and that their tolerance for the intake of unsuitable sterols is low. Sterol use in grasshoppers has also been examined by using plants with modified sterol profiles. For instance, Charlet et al. (1988) applied the systemic fungicide fenpropimorph to wheat, which caused a change in the sterol profile from mostly 5-sterols, e.g. sitosterol, to a mixture of 8-sterols and 9 ,19cyclopropylsterols (95% of the total). They found that newly hatched L. migratoria nymphs reared on the treated wheat took longer to develop relative to nymphs reared on control wheat, and that nymphs on the treated wheat exhibited wing reversals and reached the adult stage after four instars, rather than the normal five. Chemical analyses revealed that locusts reared on the modified wheat had markedly different tissue sterol profiles, and reduced titre of ecdysteroids, compared to locusts reared on normal wheat. The only other exopterygotes reared on diets containing different sterols are the omnivorous cricket Gryllulus domesticus (Chauvin, 1949) and the cockroach Blattella germanica (Noland, 1954; Gordon, 1959). Like grasshoppers, both grew equally well on diets containing cholesterol and sitosterol. In contrast, however, crickets also grew well on diets containing ergosterol and moderately well on diets containing stigmasterol, while cockroaches grew well on desmosterol and ergostanol, but not zymosterol. 3.1.2
The Endopterygota
Also called the Holometabola because of the dramatic changes that occur between the larval, pupal and adult stages, four of the five largest insect orders (Coleoptera, Diptera, Lepidoptera and Hymenoptera) can be found in this group. Many agricultural pests are endopterygotes and the development of artificial diets for mass rearing purposes has greatly facilitated sterol studies in these insects. A relatively large number of beetles have been examined with respect to sterol use but they all come from one suborder, the Polyphaga. It is, however, the largest suborder within the Coleoptera and contains approximately 300 000 described species, which are split into16 superfamilies. To date, representative species from five of the superfamilies within Polyphaga have been examined for sterol use (Bostrichoidea, Cucujoidea, Tenebrionoidea, Chrysomeloidea, and Curculionoidea). Overall, there seems to be a remarkable flexibility among beetles to use a relatively wide range of sterols, including ones with 5-, 5,22-, and 5,7,22-bonds (Table 2). There is, however, one notable exception. It would
14 TABLE 2 Survey of sterol use among the different insect orders. Insects are organized first by order and then by family. When more than one family occurs within an order, shared roman numerals indicate they come from the same superfamily. No inferences are made about the relatedness of superfamilies to one another. The key to the table is as follows: ( þ þ þ ) ¼ strong growth; ( þ þ ) ¼ moderate growth; ( þ ) ¼ weak growth; (0) ¼ no growth and () ¼ not studied. Numbers in parentheses indicate the cited study. Zoo sterols
Species Cholesterol
Dictyoptera (cockroaches, termites and mantids) Blattellidae Blattella germanica (5, 6) Coleoptera (beetles) Dermestidae (I) Dermestes vulpinus (7, 8, 9, 10, 11) Attagenus piceus (12) Trogoderma granarium (13, 14) Anobiidae (I) Lasioderma serricorne (8) Stegobium paniceum (8)
7-Dehydrocholesterol
Cholestanol
0 0
þþþ þþþ
Sitosterol
Other sterol (1)
Other sterol (2)
Other sterol (3)
Stigmasterol
Ergosterol
Zymosterol
0 0
0 0
þþþ
0
þ þ þ þ þ þ
0 0 0 0 0 0
spinasterol 0 0 0 0 0 0
lathosterol 0 0 0 0
þþþ þþþ
0 0
0 0
0 0
þþþ
þþ
þþþ
0
þþ
þþþ
þþþ
þþþ þþþ þþþ
0 þþ þþþ
0 0 þþþ
0 þþþ
0 þþþ
0 0
0
þþþ þþþ
þþþ þþþ
þþ þþ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ þþþ
þ 0
þ þ þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ þ þ
desmosterol þþþ
lanosterol 0 0
Fungal sterols
ergostanol þþ
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Orthoptera (locusts, grasshoppers, crickets and katydids) Ensifera (short-horned grasshoppers) Acrididae (I) Locusta migratoria (1) þþþ Schistocerca gregaria (1) þþþ Schistocerca americana (2,3) þþþ Trimerotropis pallidipennis (2) þþþ Barytettix humphreysii (2) þþþ Melanoplus differentialis (2) þþþ Romaleidae (I) Romalea guttata (2) þþþ Taeniopoda eques (2) þþþ Caelifera (long-horned grasshoppers) Gryllidae (II) Gryllus domesticus (4) þþþ
Plant sterols
Diptera (flies) Nematocera (long-horned flies) Culicidae Aedes aegypti (29) Culex pipiens (30) Brachycera (short-horned flies) Drosophilidae (I) Drosophila melanogaster (31, 32) Drosophila pachea (33) Calliphoridae (II) Lucilia sericata (34, 35) Phormia regina (36) Calliphora erythrocephala (37) Cochliomyia hominivorax (38)
þþþ
þþþ
þþ
þþ
þþþ
þþþ
þþ
þþþ
campesterol þþþ
desmosterol þþþ
þþþ
þ
þþ
þþ
þþþ þþþ
þ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ
þþ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
þ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
þ þþþ þþþ þþþ
0 þþþ þ
þþþ þ
þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ
þ þþþ
0 þþþ þþþ
þ þþþ
þþþ
0
þþþ
þþþ
lanosterol 0 lanosterol 0
þþþ þþþ
þþþ þþþ
þþ þþ
þþ þ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ þþþ
desmosterol þþþ
campesterol þ
fucosterol þþþ
þþ þþþ
þ
þþ 0
þ þþþ
þ
þþþ 0
þþþ 0
desmosterol 0
schottenol þþþ
lathosterol þþþ
þþþ 0
0
þþ þþþ 0
þ þþ 0
0
þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
Ptinidae (I) Ptinus tectus (8) Silvanidae (II) Oryzaephilus surinamensis (8) Tenebrionidae (III) Tribolium confusum (15, 16) Tenebrio molitor (17) Cerambycidae (IV) Hylotrupes bajulus (18, 19) Bruchidae (IV) Callosobruchus chinensis (20) Acanthoscelides obtectus (21) Curculionidae (V) Hylobius pales (22, 23) Anthonomus grandis (24) Sitophilus granarius (w/o symbionts) (25) Sitophilus oryzae (w/ symbionts) (25) Scolytidae (V) Xyleborus ferrugineus (26, 27) Scolytus multistriatus (28)
(Continued )
15
16
TABLE 2 Continued Zoo sterols
Species Cholesterol
Sarcophagidae (II) Pseudosarcophaga affinis (39) Sarcophaga bullata (40) Muscidae (III) Musca domestica (41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46) Anthomyiidae (III) Delia brassicae (47) Siphonaptera (fleas) Xenopsylla cheopis (48)
Other sterol (1)
Other sterol (2)
Other sterol (3)
Fungal sterols Ergosterol Zymosterol
7-Dehydro- Cholestanol Sitosterol Stigmasterol cholesterol
þ
þ
þþþ
þþþ
þ
þ
þþþ
þ
þþ
þþþ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ þþ
þþþ þþ
þþþ
0 þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
þþþ þ
þþþ
þ
þþþ þþþ þþþ
þ
þþ þþþ
0
0 þþþ
þ
þþþ þþþ
þþþ
0
þ
þþþ
þþ
0
þþþ þþþ
þþþ
þ
þþþ
þ
þþþ
þ
þ
þþ
þ
þ
þþþ
þþ þþþ
þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ
þ þ þ þ
þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
campesterol þ
desmosterol þ
spinasterol þþ
campesterol þþþ
brassicasterol þ
fucosterol þþþþ
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Lepidoptera (moths and butterflies) Plutellidae (I) Plutella xylostella (49) Gelechiidae (II) Pectinophora gossypiella (50) Sitotroga cerealella (51) Tineidae (III) Tineola bisselliella (52) Tortricidae (IV) Homona coffearia (53) Argyrotaenia velutina (54) Pyralidae (V) Ectomyelois ceratoniae (55) Anagasta kuehniella (56) Pyrausta nubilalis (57) Corcyra cephalonica (58) Crambidae (V) Crambus trisecta (52) Diatraea grandiosella (59) Bombycidae (VI) Bombyx mori (60, 61) Sphingidae (VI) Manduca sexta (62)
Plant sterols
Hymenoptera (sawflies, wasps, bees and ants) Apocrita (distinct waist) Chalcididae (I) Brachymeria lasus (65) Pteromalidae (I) Pachycrepoideus vindemiae (65) Apidae (II) Apis mellifera (66)
þþþ
þþþ
0
þþ
þþþ
þþþ
þþþ
þ
þþ
þþ
þþþ
þþ
þþ
þþ
þþþ
þþ
þþ
spinasterol þþ
lathoterol þ
campesterol 24-methylenecholesterol þ þþþ
brassicasterol þ
þ
(1) Dadd, 1960; (2) Behmer and Elias, 1999a; (3) Behmer and Elias, 2000; (4) Chauvin, 1949; (5) Noland, 1954; (6) Gordon, 1959; (7) Fraenkel et al., 1941; (8) Fraenkel and Blewett, 1943; (9) Levinson, 1962; (10) Bergmann and Levinson, 1966; (11) Budowski et al., 1967; (12) McKennis, 1947; (13) Agarwal, 1970; (14) Sehgal and Agarwal, 1973 (15) Fraenkel and Blewett, 1943; (16) Magis, 1954; (17) Leclercq, 1948; (18) Rasmussen, 1956; (19) Rasmussen, 1958; (20) Ishii, 1951; (21) Chiu and McKay, 1939; (22) Clark, 1973; (23) Richmond and Thomas, 1975; (24) Vanderzant, 1963; (25) Baker, 1974; (26) Norris et al., 1969; (27) Chu et al., 1970; (28) Galford, 1972; (29) Goldberg and De Meillon, 1948; (30) Dadd and Kleinjan, 1984; (31) Cooke and Sang, 1970; (32) Cooke and Sang, 1972; (33) Heed and Kircher, 1965; (34) Hobson, 1935a; (35) Hobson, 1935b; (36) Brust and Fraenkel, 1955; (37) Sedee, 1961; (38) Gingrich, 1964; (39) House, 1954; (40) Goodfellow et al., 1971; (41) Monroe et al., 1961; (42) Kaplanis et al., 1965; (43) Dutky et al., 1967; (44) Silverman and Levinson, 1954; (45) Levinson and Bergmann, 1957; (46) Bergmann and Levinson, 1966; (47) Dambre-Raes, 1976; (48) Pausch and Fraenkel, 1966; (49) Behmer and Grebenok, 1998; (50) Vanderzant and Reiser, 1956; (51) Chippendale, 1971; (52) Fraenkel and Blewett, 1946; (53) Sivapalan and Gnanapragasam, 1979; (54) Rock, 1969; (55) Levinson and Gothilf, 1955; (56) Fraenkel and Blewett, 1943; (57) Beck et al., 1949; (58) Sarma and Sreenivasaya, 1941; (59) Chippendale and Reddy, 1972a; (60) Ito, 1961; (61) Ito et al., 1964; (62) Svoboda and Robbins, 1968; (63) Ishii and Urushibara, 1954; (64) Ritter and Nes, 1981; (65) Thompson, 1981; (66) Herbert et al., 1980.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
Arctiidae (VII) Chilo simplex (63) Noctuidae (VII) Helicoverpa zea (64)
17
18
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
appear that dermestid beetles have a limited ability to use fungal sterols, which is in contrast to the two other beetle families, e.g. anobiids and ptinids, within the superfamily Bostrichoidea, which grow quite well on the fungal sterol ergosterol. Perhaps sterol use in the Bostrichoidea is related to feeding ecology. For the zoophagous D. maculatus (Dermestidae) cholesterol is the only sterol that supports growth and development, while in the phytophagous Kharpa beetle, Trogoderma granarium, which is also a dermestid, sitosterol and stigmasterol, in addition to cholesterol, support growth and development. Among the anobiid larvae, the ability to grow and develop on diets containing ergosterol is probably related to the fact that they are often found living in fungi. It would be interesting to know whether these different sterol utilization abilities follow any phylogenetic pattern (cholesterol only ! cholesterol þ phytosterols ! cholesterol þ phytosterols þ fungal sterols). The other interesting finding among the beetles is that lanosterol, a 8,24cholesterol analogue, does not support growth and development in the two species in which it was tested (Norris et al., 1969; Chu et al., 1970; Clark, 1973; Richmond and Thomas, 1975). The Diptera are the second largest insect order and are divided into two suborders, the Nematocera and Brachycera. Within the Nematocera, which generally include small insects with delicate long antennae, 16 superfamilies exist but to date sterol use has only been examined in two species, and both these come from the mosquito family, Culicidae. The larvae of most mosquito species feed on algae and organic debris, but a few are predaceous and feed on other mosquito larvae. Sterol use in Aedes aegypti (Goldberg and De Meillon, 1948) and Culex pipiens (Dadd and Kleinjan, 1984) is broad, although C. pipiens only grows on non-cholesterol diets when lecithin is present. The Brachycera, which include the more compact flies with short antennae, are divided into 20 superfamilies. Sterol use, however, has only been examined in species from four of these superfamilies, and all of these come from the section Calyptra`tae, within the division Schizo´phora. Inspection of the data in Table 2 reveals that sterol use in this group of insects is highly variable. The first notable difference occurs within the Drosophilidae, whose larvae tend to feed on fungi found in decaying fruits and vegetables. Drosophila pachea, which breeds in the stems of senita cactus, is perhaps the most famous example of unique sterol use among the insects. Heed and Kircher (1965) found that 7-stigmasten-3 -ol, isolated from the cactus or synthesized, but not cholesterol, sitosterol, stigmasterol or, surprisingly ergosterol, could replace the cactus in the diet of flies reared non-aseptically or axenically. In contrast, D. melanogaster, which is considered a generalist feeder, grows well on diets containing this latter group of sterols (Cooke and Sang, 1970, 1972). The cabbage root fly, Delia brassicae, is a specialist feeder on plants in the family Brassicaceae. Like other species in the Anthomyiidae, it feeds on plant roots, an environment that favours fungal growth, and perhaps its sensitivity to
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
19
cholesterol (Dambre-Raes, 1976) suggests it has evolved and become a sterol specialist much like D. pachea. Among the muscids only Musca domestica has been examined, and it seems that a range of sterols can be used, although of those tested cholesterol is clearly superior (Table 2). Perhaps this reflects the generalist feeding nature of its larvae, which are found feeding on excrement and various types of decaying material. Flies within the superfamily Oestro`idea, which includes the Calliphoridae and Sarcophagidae, tend to feed on carrion, excrement and similar decaying material, so it is not surprising that cholesterol supports strong growth for flies in this group. It is interesting, however, that the plant sterol sitosterol supports growth and development to high levels in three species (Table 2). This may reflect the remarkable ability of some insects to spare cholesterol while using other sterols for structural purposes (e.g. Clark and Bloch, 1959a). An additional finding of interest for flies from these two families, especially considering the environments in which these insects feed, is that the utilization of fungal sterols seems to be poor or even non-existent. The Lepidoptera are another large order and the majority of the larvae are phytophagous, although a small number are predaceous and some are ectoparasitic. There are five suborders, but all of the species that have so far been studied for sterol use come from the suborder Ditrysia. Of the 17 superfamilies in this suborder, seven are represented in Table 2. The most notable trend is that sitosterol supports strong growth and development in all the species for which it has been tested, which is not surprising considering it is the most common and typically abundant phytosterol. Stigmasterol (5,22) is also widespread in plants, although usually present in smaller quantities than sitosterol, and is also readily used by most lepidopteran species. There are exceptions, however, and specialists that feed on plants where stigmasterol tends to be absent or rare, e.g. Plutella xylostella (crucifers), Pyrausta nubilalis (grasses) and Bombyx mori (mulberry), seem to utilize it less well relative to sitosterol. Performance on diets containing phytosterols with 7- and 7,22-configurations, e.g. lathosterol and spinasterol, has only been examined in two species, the generalist H. zea (Ritter and Nes, 1981b) and the specialist P. xylostella (Behmer and Grebenok, 1998) and neither grew particularly well. This may not be unexpected for the specialist, but H. zea feeds on a wide range of plants. Perhaps the preferred host range of H. zea tends to primarily contain 5-sterols, which regardless of side chain configuration, support growth and development (Nes et al., 1997). The ability of lepidopteran larvae to use fungal sterols such as ergosterol is quite variable, even for species within the same family, e.g. the pyralids. This difference seems to reflect general ecology, rather than phylogeny, since caterpillars that can utilize ergosterol tend to be found in environments that favour fungal growth, e.g. damaged fruits and stored products. Highly mobile generalist Lepidoptera larvae are likely to ingest both suitable and unsuitable sterols when they feed. Nes et al. (1997) investigated the consequences of this by rearing H. zea on a synthetic diet that contained
20
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
different proportions of cholesterol (suitable) and 24-dihydrolanosterol (unsuitable). They found that growth rates began to decrease when the proportion of suitable sterols in the diet dropped below 70%, and that developmental time increased when the proportion dropped below 50%. These results are similar to those found when the grasshopper S. americana was fed diets containing different proportions of usable and non-usable sterols (Behmer and Elias, 1999a, 2000). The only other insects within the Endopterygota to be examined for sterol use are a siphanopteran, Xenopsylla cheopi (Pausch and Fraenkel, 1966) and three hymenopterans. The flea, which feeds primarily on mammals, demonstrated good growth on the phytosterol sitosterol, but did poorly on diets containing stigmasterol and ergosterol. The honeybee, Apis mellifera, in contrast, grew best on diets containing cholesterol and 24-methylenecholesterol, but rather poorly on diets containing other phytosterols (Herbert et al., 1980). The two other Hymenoptera studied were Brachymeria lasus and Pachycerpoideus vindemiae, pupal endoparasites of Lepidoptera and Diptera, respectively (Thompson, 1981). Both larvae grew best on cholesterol, followed by cholestanol, sitosterol and 7-dehydrocholesterol. Cholesterol sparing abilities were also investigated and found to be somewhat limited in both species, but results did suggest that cholestanol worked in this capacity better than did sitosterol or 7-dehydrocholesterol. 3.2
INSECT STEROL METABOLISM
Our understanding of insect sterol use has been greatly enhanced by studies that measure and compare the sterol content of insect tissues to the foods that insects eat. As with sterol use studies there are biases in the existing data, with over half of the species so far examined coming from the Hemiptera and Hymenoptera. Our aim in this section is to describe some of the biosynthetic steps involved in the insect sterol metabolic pathway, and to document how different insect orders metabolize sterols. 3.2.1
Insect sterol metabolic pathways
Insects operate the classic acetate-mevalonate isoprenoid pathway to an unidentified step that forms before synthesis of the 30-carbon olefin, squalene oxide (Fig. 2) (Kircher, 1982; Campbell and Nes, 1983; Silberkang et al., 1983). The post-lanosterol pathway normally operational in other animals is interrupted in insects. For instance, [2-3H]-lanosterol fed to animals is actively converted to cholesterol (Nes et al., 1988b) whereas in the tobacco hornworm, M. sexta, the labelled sterol is absorbed by the gut and metabolized to a sole product, 24,25-dihydrolanosterol, using a reductase-type enzyme (Svoboda et al., 1995a). This enzyme, 24,25-reductase, is also found in the cycloartenolsitosterol pathway of plants (Fig. 3) and has been studied in a cell-free system
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
21
FIG. 2 Isoprenoid–sterol pathway. HMGR, hydroxymethyl gluturayl CoA-reductase; DXS, 1-deoxy-D-xylulose 5-phosphate synthase; SMT, sterol methyl transferase.
FIG. 3 Generalized plant pathway of cycloartenol conversion to stigmasterol.
of the tobacco hornworm (Short et al., 1996). In plants 24,25-reductase normally recognizes 24-methyl and 24-ethyl desmosterol as substrate to generate campesterol and sitosterol, respectively (Yamada et al., 1997) (Fig. 2), whereas the 24,25-reductase of insects recognizes lanosterol or desmosterol as substrates. The 24,25-reductase enzyme is a critical slow step in the insect conversion of phytosterol to ecdysteroid (Short et al., 1996). As a result, the first inhibitors of sterol metabolism were targeted to inhibit the activity of this enzyme (Svoboda, 1994). Insects, in contrast to more derived animals, have many enzymes in the sterol pathway that can be considered as reverse enzymes that are complementary to
22
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
those synthesized by plants. For instance, the normal route for conversion of phytosterols involves nucleus changes as follows: the 9,19-cyclopropane group isomerizes to an 8,9-bond, which is then rearranged to the 7-bond. Next a 5bond is introduced and the 7-bond is reduced to form the final 5-structure characteristic of phytosterol end-products (Fig. 3). In contrast, insects can introduce the 7-bond or remove the 5-bond from the sterol nucleus, so that after feeding on plant leaves, the insect will have a sterol composition of 7- or 0-sterols (Svoboda, 1984). For side chain transformations, plants have an enzyme that adds a 22-bond to the sterol side chain, while insects have an enzyme to remove the 22-bond. Likewise, plants convert the 24(25)-bond to form a 24(28)-exomethylene bond while insects convert the 24(28)-bond to a 24,25-double bond. It appears that the catalysis involved with the reverse reactions operated by insects is not simply that of an equilibrium reaction, but rather unique metabolases evolved to carry out the individual reaction. Key enzymes in the post-lanosterol and post-cycloartenol pathway such as a C-4 demethylase, 8,9-isomerase and 23(24)-reductase (in corn) are also absent from insects (Clark and Bloch, 1959b; Ikekawa et al., 1993; Short et al., 1996; Nes et al., 1997). On the basis of present understanding of metabolic relationships, the aliphatic isooctane side chain of cholesterol occupies a position as a key branch point structure of steroid metabolism since it serves as the precursor to ecdysteroids and provides suitable three-dimensional and amphipathic characteristics for sterol to interdigitate in the membrane. Conversion of phytosterol to cholesterol was hypothesized to proceed through a series of side chain metabolisms as outlined in Scheme 2 (Svoboda, 1984) in which the 24-alkyl group is ultimately removed and the resulting 24,25-double bond is saturated to produce the isooctane structure. Sitosterol (7) and stigmasterol (5), the major 24-ethyl cholesterols found in plants, are converted to cholesterol in insects by essentially the same side chain dealkylation pathway. Cell-free systems, originating from both the tobacco hornworm and the silkworm, B. mori, have been used to study C-24 dealkylase (lyase enzyme) and 24,25-reductase (Ikekawa et al., 1993; Short et al., 1996) but unfortunately no detailed characterization or purification of these enzymes has been reported. Therefore, nothing significant is known regarding kinetics, except for reaction mechanisms. Four steps occur in the 24-dealkylation pathway that converts sitosterol to fucosterol, and the first is catalysed by a single dehydrogenase enzyme that lacks stereospecificity. The next step is the stereospecific conversion of fucosterol to the (24R,28R) epoxide of fucosterol. The penultimate step is catalysed by the fucosterol epoxide lyase involving the elimination of acetaldehyde and migration of H-25 to C-24 to form the 24,25-double bond. Finally, in the conversion of desmosterol to cholesterol, a reductase-type enzyme is involved. In related work it was demonstrated that [2-13C]-mevalonic acid is converted to (25S)-[26-13C]-sitosterol (7) (Nes et al., 1992) and, using a cell-free preparation from corn, [27-13C]-lanosterol was converted to
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
23
SCHEME 2 Pathway of sterol dealkylation by insects and disruption by rationally designed inhibitors targeted for key enzymes in the pathway. The sterol nucleus (SN) in each case is cholesterol based. Structure 7 corresponds to the sitosterol side chain and structure 5 corresponds to the stigmasterol side chain. Structures 10 and 11 correspond to the desmosterol and cholesterol side chains, respectively. Structure 19 is solasodine, a common steroidal alkaloid.
(25R)-[2713C]-24(28)-methylenelanosterol (Nes et al., 1996). This suggested a general process, with the biosynthesis of 24-ethyl phytosterols passing through three steps: (i) successive methylation at C-24, (ii) isomerization of the 24(28)-bond to the 24,25-bond, and (iii) reduction of the 24,25-double bond – with net retention in configuration at C-25 in the final chiral product. In the case of the biosynthesis of cholesterol via the 24-dealkylation pathway in insects, there is also a net retention in configuration in the final chiral product (Scheme 2). It can be seen that C-2 of mevalonate incorporated into C-26 (a rotation at C-25 is shown to accommodate nomenclature, cf., Guo et al., 1996) is the pro-S-methyl group whereas in cholesterol generated in animals, the pro-R-methyl is derived from C-2 of mevalonate (Popja´k et al., 1977). In the reduction of the 24(25)-double bond, regardless of the system engaged, both hydrogen atoms were added to the si-face of the double bond equivalent to the cis-addition of the hydride ion to C-25 from a pyridine nucleotide and of a proton to C-24. A more precise understanding of the 24-dealkylation pathway was elucidated by the use of structural analogues targeted to disrupt each step. All the inhibitors shown in Scheme 2 block steps along the 24-dealkylation pathway as shown by the accumulation of substrate for the target enzyme. They are also
24
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
highly effective inhibitors of insect growth (Ikekawa et al., 1993; Short et al., 1996; Svoboda et al., 1994). The mechanism for enzyme inhibition by the ammonium-containing compounds (e.g., 16, 17 and 18) is probably different from the allenes (e.g., 15). It seems that the N-steroids may serve as a highenergy intermediate analogue of the cationic intermediate generated during the catalytic reaction (Short et al., 1996). In contrast, the allenes may serve as a mechanism-based inactivator, much like related compounds prepared and tested with the sterol methyl transferase from yeast (Nes et al., 1998). Natural products, including steroidal alkaloids such as solasodine (19) that contain nitrogen in the side chain, might inhibit the 24,25-reductase as they can inhibit the sterol methyl transferase and inhibit growth of algae by inducing an accumulation of 24-desmethyl sterols with a 24,25-double bond (Mangla and Nes, 2000). However, these N-steroids fail to affect the growth of the tobacco hornworm (Weissenberg et al., 1998), showing important differences between plants and insects in their response to steroidal alkaloids. Prestwich and coworkers (1983, 1984) have studied several side chain modified monofluorinated cholesterols and sitosterols and found that 29-fluorositosterol (20) and 29-fluorostigmasterol were highly toxic to the tobacco hornworm. Abnormal development caused by the 29-fluorosterols is similar to that seen in larvae fed on fluoroacetate. Dealkylation of these fluorosterols produces a lethal product, fluoroacetate, and the inhibitor has no direct effect on phytosterol metabolism. 3.2.2
The Apterygota and Exopterygota
Sterol metabolism has only been examined in four insect orders outside of the Endopterygota. The most primitive is the firebrat, Thermobia domestica, and biochemical studies have shown that it can produce cholesterol from sitosterol (Svoboda and Robbins, 1971). Species in two polyneopteran orders, the Orthoptera and Blattaria, also show the ability to dealkyate. For example, L. migratoria was found to produce radiolabelled cholesterol after it was fed [14C]sitosterol (Rath et al., 1993). Likewise, Costet et al. (1987) and Behmer et al. (1999b) inferred dealkylation of sitosterol in two Schistocerca species reared on diets rich in sitosterol (wheat and artificial diet, respectively) after large quantities of cholesterol were found in the insects’ tissues. However, Behmer et al. (1999b) suggested that S. americana nymphs have a limited ability to dealkylate phytosterols that contain a double bond at the 22-position, e.g. stigmasterol and spinasterol, since these sterols tended to accumulate in the tissues of nymphs reared on diets containing stigmasterol and spinasterol, respectively. Although they also recovered high quantities of cholesterol, it was determined to have originated maternally. Both studies also showed that grasshoppers accumulated 7- and 8-sterols when reared on diets that contained these same sterols, which indicates that grasshoppers also lack the enzymes needed to convert double bonds in the sterol nucleus. Cockroaches,
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
25
like grasshoppers, produce cholesterol from sitosterol (Robbins et al., 1962), but studies using radiolabelled sterols suggest cockroaches have broader sterol metabolic capabilities than grasshoppers. For instance, Clark and Bloch (1959b) found that the German cockroach produces 22-dehydrocholesterol from ergosterol by saturating the 7–8 double bond and demethylating the side chain. However, they also found that cockroaches, like grasshoppers, could not reduce 22–23 double bonds. Among the Hemiptera, sterol metabolism has been examined in at least one species for each of the three major suborders. The Heteroptera, or true bugs, are the largest of the suborders and have both predaceous and herbivorous members. To date, species representing five superfamilies in this suborder have been investigated for sterol metabolism (Table 3). The two other suborders, Sternorrhyncha and Auchenorrhyncha, contain only phytophagous species and are so far only represented by an aphid and a leafhopper, respectively (Table 3). A comparison of food sterol profiles with insect tissue sterol profiles reveals that in this order, cholesterol is found in aphids (Campbell and Nes, 1983) and a leafhopper (Noda and Koizumi, 2003), but not in any of the phytophagous heteropterans (Table 3). By using [14C]-sitosterol, Campbell and Nes (1983) were able to demonstrate that aphids could dealkylate phytosterols. Noda and Koizumi (2003) have proposed that planthoppers use a 7-reductase and produce 24-methylenecholesterol from ergosta-5,7,24(29)-trienol by intracellular yeastlike symbiotes. Cholesterol is then produced by removal of the side chain group. These results, when combined with the absence of cholesterol in phytophagous heteropterans, suggest that the Heteroptera have lost the ability to dealkylate phytosterols. Meeting sterol requirements, both structural and metabolic ones, has never been considered problematic for predaceous hemipterans since their prey items tend to contain large quantities of cholesterol (Nes and McKean, 1977). In contrast, plant phloem and xylem are not particularly nutrient-rich resources, especially with respect to phytosterols, although it has been demonstrated that phytosterols can be translocated through plants via the phloem (Lehrer et al., 2000; Douglas, this issue). Many phytophagous hemipterans harbour endosymbionts which are known to provide valuable nutrients, especially amino acids (Douglas, 1998), and it has been suggested that these endosymbionts might play a role in sterol nutrition. Initially, it was suggested that they provided sterols directly, but since most bacteria lack the ability to biosynthesize sterols or sterol intermediates this seemed unlikely. Indeed, Campbell and Nes (1983) demonstrated that Schizaphis graminum, an aphid that contains bacterial endosymbionts, did not produce radioactively labelled sterols or sterol metabolic intermediates when it was reared on diets containing [2-14C]-melavonate. Nonetheless, Douglas (1988) has shown that aphid endosymbionts might be linked with cholesterol production. After she reared the green peach aphid, Mzyus persicae, on a holidic diet lacking sterols for five
Dietary sterols (% total)
Insect [diet] Orthoptera (locusts, crickets, grasshoppers and katydids) Acrididae Schistocerca americana (1) [synthetic diet w/ mixed sterols]
Locusta migratoria (2) [wheat] [wheat treated with fungicide]
Heteroptera (true bugs) Reduviidae (I) Rhodnius prolixus (5) [young mice] Arilus cristatus (5) [Tenebrio molitor] Pentatomidae (II) Nezara viridula (5) [mixed diet]a
cholesterol (100.0)
(B) sitosterol (60.0), campesterol (27.0), 22-dihydrobrassicasterol (13.0) (C) stigmasterol (99.0) (D) spinasterol (60.0), 22-dihydrospinasterol (40.0)
cholesterol (81.0), sitosterol (9.4), campesterol (9.4) cholesterol (54.0), stigmasterol (46.0) cholesterol (45.7), spinasterol (37.0), lathosterol (10.3), 22-dihydrospinasterol (6.7) cholesterol (70.0), cholestanol (12.0), sitosterol (6.0), lathosterol (3.5), campesterol (3.5), stigmasterol (1.5) cholesterol (41.5), 8-sterols (24.5), 9 ,19-cyclopropylsterols (21.0), sitosterol (3.0), campesterol (2.0), stigmasterol (1.0), others (7.0)
sitosterol (41.0), stigmasterol (34.0), campesterol (17.0), cholesterol (<1.0)
stigmasterol (34.0), sitosterol (31.0), campesterol (17.0), cholesterol (15.0)
sitosterol, stigmasterol, campesterol
24-methylenecholesterol (56.0), cholesterol (23.0), ergosta-5,7,24(28)-trienol (21.0)
not reported, but mostly cholesterol
cholesterol (98.5), campesterol (1.0)
cholesterol (63.3), 7-dehydrocholesterol (18.4), sitosterol (12.2), campesterol (4.6), stigmasterol (1.5)
cholesterol (92.7), sitosterol (3.5), campesterol (1.4)
sitosterol (48.0–65.7), campesterol (6.0–12.8), stigmasterol (8.0–37.4), isofucosterol (7.7–12.2), C-30 sterols (0.0–12.5)
sitosterol (65.3), campesterol (9.9), stigmasterol (9.8), isofucosterol (8.6), stigmast-7-en-3 -ol (2.8)
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Hemiptera (sucking bugs) Sternorrhyncha (psyllids, whiteflies, aphids and coccids) Aphidae Schizaphis graminum (3) [sorghum] Auchenorrhyncha (cicadas, planthoppers and fulgoroids) Delphacidae Laodelphax striatellus (4) [rice]
Insect tissue sterols (% total)
(A) cholesterol (100.0)
sitosterol (54.0), campesterol (24.0), stigmasterol (8.0), isofucosterol (7.0), cycloeucalenol (4.0), obtusifoliol (3.5) 9 ,19-cyclopropylsterols (90.0), 8-sterols (9.0), 5-sterols (1.0)
26
TABLE 3 Sterol profiles from insects and their diets. Insects are organized first by order and then by family. When more than one family occurs within an order, shared roman numerals indicate they come from the same superfamily. No inferences are made about the relatedness of superfamilies to one another.
Acanthosmatidae (II) Cimex lectularius (5) [young mice] Lygaeidae (III) Oncopeltus fasciatus (6) [milkweed] Oncopeltus fasciatus (7) [sunflower] Pyrrhocoridae (IV) Dysdercus fasciatus (8) [rice] Dysdercus cingulatus (6) [cotton seed] Alydidae (V) Megalotomus quinquespinosus (9) [mixed diet]b
Neuroptera (lacewings) Chrysopidae Chrysopa carnea (10) [grain moth eggs] [Schizaphis graminum] Coleoptera (beetles) Dermestidae (I) Trogoderma granarium (11, 12) [synthetic diets]
cholesterol (63.3), 7-dehydrocholesterol (18.4), sitosterol (12.2), campesterol (4.6), stigmasterol (1.5)
cholesterol (88.9), sitosterol (4.1), stigmasterol (4.0), lathosterol (2.4), campesterol (0.6)
not reported, but mostly cholesterol
cholesterol (98.5)
sitosterol (49.1), campesterol (22.3), 24-methylenecholesterol (9.4), isofucosterol (9.1), stigmasterol (8.2) sitosterol (79.5), stigmasterol (10.3), campesterol (10.1)
sitosterol (44.0), campesterol (25.6), 24-methylenecholesterol (11.8), isofucosterol (9.0), stigmasterol (11.8) sitosterol (86.0), campesterol (10.5), stigmasterol (3.2)
sitosterol (97.5), campesterol (2.4), cholesterol (<1.0) sitosterol (91.4), campesterol (4.3), cholesterol (<1.0)
sitosterol (95.1), campesterol (4.8), cholesterol (<1.0) sitosterol (87.6), campesterol (7.0), isofucosterol (3.4), stigmasterol (1.2)
sitosterol (0.0–56.4), spinasterol (0–42.5), 7-stigmastenol (0–39.7), campesterol (0–23.6), stigmasterol (1.2–37.4), isofucosterol (0–9.3), 7-campesterol (0–7.3)
sitosterol (46.6), 7-stigmastenol (13.8), spinasterol (13.4), campesterol (9.0), isofucosterol (5.8), stigmasterol (4.1), 7-campesterol (2.8)
cholesterol (80.2), sitosterol (13.9), campesterol (5.8) sitosterol (54.3), cholesterol (40.3), stigmasterol (5.4)
cholesterol (93.3), campesterol (3.9), sitosterol (2.8) sitosterol (66.8), stigmasterol (19.3), cholesterol (13.8)
(A) sitosterol (69.4), campesterol (25.0), stigmasterol (5.1) (B) [3H]-sitosterol (100.0)
campesterol (59.4), sitosterol (36.7), stigmasterol (2.6), cholesterol (1.3) sitosterol (92.3), campesterol (4.7), cholesterol (<1.0) stigmasterol (85.9), campesterol (5.6), sitosterol (5.4), cholesterol (2.0) desmosterol (93.4), cholesterol (<1.0)
(C) [3H]-stigmasterol (100.0) (D) [3H]-desmosterol (100.0) Coccinellidae (II) Epilachna varivestis (13) [soybean leaves]
sitosterol (55.0), stigmasterol (31.5), campesterol (11.3)
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
Podisus maculiventris (5) [Tenebrio molitor]
cholestanol (50.7), stigmastanol (20.3), lathosterol (11.8), campestanol (6.0), cholesterol (4.5), other sterols (3.7)
27 (Continued )
28
TABLE 3 Continued Dietary sterols (% total)
Insect [diet] Coccinella septempunctata (14) [aphids] Tenebrionidae (III) Tribolium castaneu (15) [mixed diet]c
Tenebrio molitor (15) [mixed diet]d Curculionidae (IV) Diaprepes abbreviatus (16) [synthetic diet] Hypera postica (17) [alfalfa] Anthonomus grandis (18) [synthetic diet]
not reported
cholesterol (46.4), sitosterol (29.5), campesterol (12.2), stigmasterol (5.5), 7-dehydrocholesterol (3.7), stanols (2.7)
sitosterol (90.2), campesterol (6.5), isofucosterol (2.6)
cholesterol (N – 43.7; I – 4.9), 7-dehydrocholesterol ( þ desmosterol) (N – 39.8; I – 52.3), sitosterol (N – 16.0; I – 25.9), 5,7,24-cholestatrienol (N – 0.0; I – 15.1) cholesterol (66.7), 7-dehydrocholesterol (16.8), sitosterol (11.2), campesterol (3.8)
sitosterol (47.3), isofucosterol (36.7), campesterol (11.8), stigmasterol (4.3) cholesterol (83.0), sitosterol (8.9), campesterol (2.7), 22-dehydrocholesterol (1.6), desmosterol (1.4) spinasterol (69.0), 22-dihydrospinasterol (17.3), avenasterol (13.3) sitosterol (92.0), campesterol (8.0)
(A) [14C]-sitosterol (100.0) (B) [ C]-sitosterol (100.0) þ 25-azacholesterol 14
(C) [14C]-desmosterol (100.0) (D) [14C]-campesterol (100.0) Brachycera (short-horned flies) Muscidae (I) Musca domestica (20) [synthetic diets]
Drosophilidae (II) Drosophila melanogaster (21) [synthetic diets]
cholesterol (90.5), sitosterol (7.1), campesterol (1.9) spinasterol (38.0), lathosterol (34.0), 22-dihydrospinasterol (25.5), avenasterol (11.0) cholesterol (58.1), sitosterol (36.9), campesterol (5.0)
cholesterol (66.1), sitosterol (32.7), campesterol (1.2) sitosterol (53.3), cholesterol (27.7), desmosterol (18.4), campesterol (0.6) cholesterol (97.8), desmosterol (2.0) campesterol (63.4), cholesterol (36.6), sitosterol (trace)
(A) cholesterol (100.0)
cholesterol (99.9)
(B) campesterol (100.0) (C) sitosterol (100.0)
campesterol (95.0), cholesterol (3.3), sitosterol (1.6) sitosterol (90.1), cholesterol (8.1)
(A) cholesterol at 0.1% (100.0)
cholesterol (99.9), others (0.1)
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Diptera (flies) Nematocera (long-horned flies) Culicidae Aedes aegypti (19) [synthetic diets]
Insect tissue sterols (% total)
(B) [14C]-desmosterol (100.0) Lepidoptera (moths and butterflies) Pyralidae (I) Plodia interpuntella (23) [mixed diet]e
Galleria mellonella (24) [brood comb] Sphingidae (II) Manduca sexta (25) [synthetic diets]
sitosterol (78.8), isofucosterol (10.4), campesterol (9.3), stigmasterol (1.4)
24-methylenecholesterol (51.9), isofucosterol (21.0), sitosterol (14.2), campesterol (8.0), stigmasterol (4.3) (A) cholesterol (100.0) (B) sitosterol (100.0) (C) stigmasterol (100.0) (D) ergosterol (100.0)
(E) lanosterol (100.0)
(F) obtusifoliol (100.0)
Noctuidae (III) Helicoverpa zea (26, 27) [synthetic diets]
others (97.0), cholesterol (3.0) others (97.3), cholesterol (2.7) others (96.2), cholesterol (3.2) others (95.4), cholesterol (4.6) sitosterol (96.7), campesterol (2.1), cholesterol (1.2) desmosterol (90.3), cholesterol (4.1), sitosterol (2.1), unknowns (3.0)
cholesterol (N – 86.5; I – 14.0), sitosterol (N – 10.8; I – 25.1), desmosterol (N – 1.2; I – 54.2), campesterol (N – 1.2; I – 6.1) cholesterol (85.2), sitosterol (10.7), campesterol (2.5)
cholesterol (87.2), desmosterol (4.4), campesterol (4.3), sitosterol (4.1) cholesterol (77.1), sitosterol (17.4), campesterol (5.5) cholesterol (70.1), stigmasterol (11.2), sitosterol (8.3), campesterol (7.3) cholesterol (49.1), cholest-5,7-dienol (18.2), sitosterol (10.3), campesterol (10.1), ergosterol (7.1), stigmasterol (3.2) dihydrolanosterol (40.1), lanosterol (31.3), cholesterol (18.7), campesterol (3.1), sitosterol (2.9), desmosterol (1.5) obtusifoliol (46.6), cholesterol (35.8), 7-obtusifoliol (6.0), campesterol (3.7), desmosterol (2.8), sitosterol (2.3) cholesterol (100.0)
(B) sitosterol (100.0) (C) stigmasterol (100.0) (D) ergosterol (100.0)
cholesterol (80.0), sitosterol (20.0) cholesterol (84.0), sitosterol (15.0) cholesta-5,7-dienol (41.0), ergosterol (36.0), cholesterol (23.0) clerosterol (80.0), cholesterol (20.0) lathosterol (63.0), spinasterol (34.0), cholesterol (5.0)
29
(A) cholesterol (100.0)
(E) clerosterol (100.0) (F) spinasterol (100.0)
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
Drosophila melanogaster (22) [synthetic diets]
(B) campesterol at 0.1% (100.0) (C) campesterol at 0.2% (100.0) (D) sitosterol at 0.1% (100.0) (E) sitosterol at 0.2% (100.0) (A) [14C]-sitosterol (100.0)
(Continued )
Continued
Insect [diet]
[synthetic diet w/ mixed sterols]
Noctuidae (III) Helicoverpa zea (28) [corn] [alfalfa]
Spodoptera littoralis (29) [synthetic diet] [synthetic diet with inhibitor]
Tenthredinidae (II) Aneugmenus flavipes (31) [bracken fern]
Dietary sterols (% total)
Insect tissue sterols (% total)
(G) lathosterol (A) cholesterol (90.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (10.0) (B) cholesterol (70.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (30.0) (C) cholesterol (50.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (50.0) (D) cholesterol (30.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (70.0)
lathosterol (81.0), cholesterol (19.0) cholesterol (93.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (7.0)
sitosterol (51.0), campesterol þ 22-dihydrobrassicasterol (27.0), isofucosterol (17.0), stigmasterol (6.0) spinasterol (69.0), 22-dihydrospinasterol (17.3), avenasterol (13.3) stigmasterol (100.0)
cholesterol (80.0), campesterol þ 22-dihydrobrassicasterol (11.0), sitosterol (10.0) lathosterol (54.5), 22-dihydrospinasterol (25.5), spinasterol (19.0), avenasterol (0.5)
cholesterol (88.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (12.0) cholesterol (75.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (25.0) cholesterol (50.0), 24-dihydrolanosterol (50.0)
stigmasterol (100.0) þ 20,25-diazacholesterol
cholesterol (59.2), desmosterol (15.0), stigmasterol (10.7), sitosterol þ fucosterol (8.5) sitosterol þ fucosterol (25.8), campesterol (22.4), stigmasterol (21.9), cholesterol (11.6), desmosterol (8.0), others (10.3)
sitosterol (83.5), isofucosterol (7.7), 24-methylcholesterol (4.6), cholesterol (3.1)
cholesterol (75.5), desmosterol (13.6), sitosterol (8.0), 24-methylcholesterol (1.5)
sitosterol (93.0), campesterol (7.0)
cholesterol (73.0), sitosterol (17.0), 7-dehydrocholesterol (6.0), campesterol (4.0) cholesterol (lrv – 55.3, adlt – 72.2)*, sitosterol (lrv – 29.5, adlt – 15.7), 7-dehydrocholesterol (lrv – 11.7, adlt – 0.0), desmosterol (lrv – 0.0; adlt – 10.1), 24-methylcholesterol (lrv – 3.5; adlt – 2.0)
sitosterol (87.8), 24-methylcholesterol (8.2), isofucosterol (2.7)
sitosterol (68.7), isofucosterol (16.6), campesterol (9.0), other (3.7), cholesterol (2.0)
cholesterol (73.0), sitosterol (16.6), desmosterol (6.0), campesterol (3.6)
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Hymenoptera (sawflies, wasps, bees and ants) Symphyta (sawflies) Xyelidae (I) Macroxyela ferruginea (30) [elm] Diprionidae (II) Neodiprion pratti (31) [pine] Neodiprion lecontei (30) [pine]
30
TABLE 3
Argidae (II) Atomocera decepta (30) [Hibiscus] Cephidae (III) Cephus cinctus (30) [wheat] Xiphydriidea (IV) Xiphydria maculata (31) [fungus]
Braconidae (I) Microplitis demolitor (32) [H. zea reared on cholesterol diet] [H. zea reared on ergosterol diet] Apidae (II) Apis mellifera (33) [maple]
Apis mellifera (33) [goldenrod]
Megachilidae (II) Megachile rotundata (34) [alfalfa] Anthophoridae (II) Diadasia rinconis (35) [three Sonoran cacti – average values]
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
Dolerus nitens (31) [fescue grass]
sitosterol (62.0), campesterol (21.3), isofucosterol (4.4), stigmasterol (3.5), other (7.7), cholesterol (1.1)
cholesterol (56.6), sitosterol (17.6), desmosterol (13.6), campesterol (7.6), lathosterol (2.4), other (2.2)
sitosterol (55.3), stigmasterol (31.0), 24-methylcholesterol (10.8), 7-dehydrocholesterol (2.9)
cholesterol (68.5), sitosterol (10.8), trans-22-dehydrocholesterol (10.1), 24-methylcholesterol (6.8)
sitosterol (50.2), 24-methylcholesterol (22.4), stigmasterol (11.4), isofucosterol (10.1), cholesterol (5.9)
cholesterol (72.7), 24-methylcholesterol (14.6), sitosterol (10.3), 7-dehydrocholesterol (1.6)
stigmasterol (32.9), sitosterol (26.8), stigmastanol (12.9), campesterol (7.9), 22-stigmastenol (7.8), 7-stigmastenol (5.8), campesterol (1.9), cholesterol (1.2), 7,22-stigmastadienol (1.1)
7-dehydrocholesterol (74.9), cholestanol (7.9), other (8.8), cholesterol (5.7), ergosterol (2.3)
cholesterol (100.0)
cholesterol (100.0)
7-dehydrocholesterol (56.0), ergosterol (27.0), cholesterol (14.0), 22-dihydroergosterol (3.0)
7-dehydrocholesterol (76.0), cholesterol (24.0)
isofucosterol (55.1), sitosterol (18.3), 24-methylenecholesterol (12.7)
24-methylenecholesterol (pp – 55.8; adlt – 41.7)*, isofucosterol (pp – 19.0; adlt – 22.0), sitosterol (pp – 13.2; adlt – 12.7), cholesterol (pp – 0.6; adlt – 0.7) 24-methylenecholesterol (pp – 52.6; adlt – 34.6)*, 7-stigmasten-3 -ol (pp – 13.2; adlt – 20.4), isofucosterol (pp – 12.6; adlt – 21.8), sitosterol (pp – 9.8; adlt – 12.4), cholesterol (pp – 1.0; adlt – 2.0)
7-stigmasten-3 -ol (66.2), sitosterol (5.7), isofucosterol (5.6), 24-methylenecholesterol (1.5)
not reported
Isofucosterol (40.7), 24-methylenecholesterol (34.1), sitosterol (13.0), campesterol (10.4)
24-methylenecholesterol (84.2), sitosterol (4.3), cycloartenol (3.1), fucosterol (2.8), campesterol (0.5)
24-methylenecholesterol (92.2), sitosterol (1.3), cycloartenol (0.0), fucosterol (2.4), campesterol (1.7)
31
(Continued )
32
TABLE 3 Continued Dietary sterols (% total)
Insect [diet] Vespidae (III) Dolichovespula maculata (34) [omnivorous] Vespula maculifrons (34) [omnivorous] Formicidae (III) Atta cephalotes (36) [fungal garden]f Acromyrmex octospinosus (37) [fungal garden]g
Solenopsis invicta (34) [culture diet]h
Formica exsectoides (34) [not reported]
not reported
not reported
not reported 5,7-4-desmethylsterol (gngyl – 84.6; myclm – 75.4), 5-4-desmethylsterol (gngyl – 1.5; myclm – 3.0), 7-4-desmethylsterol (gngyl – 8.4; myclm – 10.9), unknown sterols (ngyl – 5.5; myclm – 10.7) not reported
not reported
Insect tissue sterols (% total)
cholesterol (86.5), campesterol (3.8), sitosterol (3.7), desmosterol (3.1), 24-methylenecholesterol (0.6) cholesterol (81.5), sitosterol (7.8), desmosterol (5.8), campesterol (2.6), 24-methylenecholesterol (0.6) 7-dehydro-24-methylenecholesterol (70.0), 22-dihydroergosterol (20.0), ergosterol (10.0) 5,7-4-desmethylsterol (pp – 94.1; wrkr – 84.7) þ, 5-4-desmethylsterol (pp – 1.2; wrkr – 8.3), 7-4-desmethylsterol (pp – 1.8; wrkr – 3.2), unknown sterols (pp – 2.9; wrkr – 4.0) cholesterol (pp – 69.5; adlt – 45.4),** campesterol (pp – 23.9; adlt – 26.0), sitosterol (pp – 3.8; adlt – 17.4), isofucosterol (pp – 2.3; adlt – 5.2) cholesterol (69.4), desmosterol (9.4), campesterol (5.5), sitosterol (3.9)
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
(1) Behmer et al., 1999b; (2) Costet et al., 1987; (3) Campbell and Nes, 1983; (4) Noda and Koizumi, 2003; (5) Svoboda et al., 1984; (6) Svoboda et al., 1984; (7) Svoboda et al., 1976; (8) Gibson et al., 1983; (9) Feldlaufer et al., 1986; (10) Keiser and Yazlovetski, 1988; (11) Svoboda et al., 1980a; (12) Svoboda et al., 1980b; (13) Svoboda and Thompson, 1973; (14) Svoboda and Robbins, 1978; (15) Svoboda and Lusby, 1994; (16) Ward et al., 1991; (17) MacDonald et al., 1990; (18) Earle et al., 1967; (19) Svoboda et al., 1982; (20) Feldlaufer and Svoboda, 1991; (21) Feldlaufer et al., 1995; (22) Svoboda et al., 1989a; (23) Svoboda and Lusby, 1994; (24) Feldlaufer et al., 1997; (25) Svoboda et al., 1995a; (26) Nes et al., 1997; (27) Ritter, 1984; (28) MacDonald et al., 1990; (29) Svoboda et al., 1989b; (30) Svoboda et al., 1995b; (31) Schiff and Feldlaufer, 1996; (32) Ritter and Johnson, 1991; (33) Svoboda et al., 1983; (34) Svoboda and Lusby, 1986; (35) Feldlaufer et al., 1993; (36) Ritter et al., 1982; (37) Maurer et al., 1992. a Sunflower seeds, peanuts and green beans. Reported values indicate the range of specific sterols in the available foods. b Soybean, sunflower, and alfalfa seeds, with fresh green beans and water. Reported values indicate the range of specific sterols in the available foods. c White flour/whole wheat flour/extracted brewers yeast (44:44:12) þ 0.1% sitosterol. N ¼ normal diet, I ¼ diet with sterol inhibitor (500 ppm 25-axacoprostane). d Commercial bran meal (no added sterol). e White corn meal/whole wheat flour/glycerol/honey/extracted brewer’s yeast/rolled oats/wheat germ (28:26:17:16:6:4:3), plus 0.05% sitosterol; N ¼ normal diet, I ¼ diet with sterol inhibitor (2 ppm 25-axacoprostane). f From oak leaves and oatmeal bran (values reported for the gongylidia (gngly) and mycelium (myclm)). g From brambles and privet plants. h A mixture of housefly prepupae, boiled eggs and honey/water (1:1). * lrv=larvae; adlt=adult. ** pp=pupae; adlt=adult. þ pp=pupae; wrkr=worker.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
33
generations, she found that the reproductive effort of these aphids was similar to those that had been reared on an identical diet supplemented with cholesterol. However, when she disrupted the endosymbionts using the antibiotic chlortetracycline, her ‘‘aposymbiotic’’ aphids only produced viable offspring when they were reared on the holidic diet that contained cholesterol. She suggested that the bacteria in the aphids might have a sparing effect on the insect’s requirement for sterols, although she did not speculate on how such a mechanism might be operating. 3.2.3
The Endopterygota
Sterol metabolism has been examined in 27 endopterygotes, representing predaceous and phytophagous lifestyles across five different orders. In the one neuropteran studied, the common green lacewing, Chrysopa carnae, insect tissue sterol profiles closely mirrored those found in the food (Keiser and Yazlovetski, 1988). This indicates that little sterol metabolism was occurring, which is not surprising considering that most larval neuropterans are predaceous. Among the Coleoptera that have been examined, which includes phytophagous and predaceous species from the suborder Polyphaga but no representative species from the smaller suborders Archostemata, Myxophaga or Adephaga, no clear pattern of sterol metabolism emerges and in some cases the findings have been quite surprising. For example, the kharpa beetle, Trogoderma granarium, seems to lack the ability to dealkylate phytosterols even though it is a stored-products pest (Svoboda et al., 1980a,b). Coccinella septempuncta also seems to lack the ability to dealkylate sterols (Svoboda and Robbins, 1978), but this is somewhat expected since most coccinelids are predaceous. However, the Mexican bean beetle, Epilachna varivestis, is unique among the coccinelids in that has become secondarily phytophagous and is able, to some degree, to dealkylate sterols (Svoboda and Thompson, 1973). Additionally, this species is unusual because it reduces the 5–6 double bond in the sterol nucleus and has a tissue sterol profile dominated by saturated sterols (Svoboda and Thompson, 1973). The remaining beetle species that have been studied are all phytophagous, and while they all show an ability to dealkylate, other aspects of their sterol metabolic capabilities vary. For instance, both the tenebrionids studied can convert 5-phytosterols to cholesterol, but they also tend to produce and accumulate 7-dehydrocholesterol (Svoboda and Lusby, 1994). Among the curculionids, tissue sterol profiles vary depending on the type of dietary sterols present. For example, the boll weevil, Anthonomus grandis, feeds on cotton and is capable of producing cholesterol from sitosterol, although it also tends to accumulate a large quantity of unmetabolized sitosterol (Earle et al., 1967). In contrast, the alfalfa weevil, Hypera postica, does not produce cholesterol and appears to have a limited capacity to dealkylate the C-24 side chain (MacDonald et al., 1990). Alfalfa plants only
34
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
contain phytosterols with 7,22-configurations, which suggests that a double bond at the 22-position may prevent dealkylation in this insect, and that metabolism of the sterol nucleus is not possible. Whether this is the case for most phytophagous beetles is unclear. Flies from three different superfamilies have now been analysed for sterol metabolism, and the results suggest that dealkylation only occurs in the Nematocera (long-horned flies), which are considered primitive to the Brachycera (short-horned flies). For instance, when larvae of the yellow fever mosquitoes, A. aegypti (Nematocera), were reared on an artificial diet containing [14C]-sitosterol, [14C]-desmosterol or [14C]-campesterol, radiolabelled cholesterol was always recovered (Svoboda et al., 1982). In contrast, when the brachyceran M. domestica was fed radiolabelled [3H]-sitosterol, no radiolabelled cholesterol was identified from the insect tissue (Kaplanis et al., 1963, 1965). Radiolabelled sterols were also used to demonstrate the lack of dealkylation in a second brachyceran, the fruit fly D. melanogaster (Svoboda et al., 1989a). Even Drosophila species that are specialists on cacti lack the ability to dealkylate phytosterols, as demonstrated by Kircher et al. (1984). They analysed the sterol profiles of D. mojavensis and D. nigrospiracula and found that they closely matched the phytosterol profile of their respective hostplants, and contained only minor amounts of cholesterol. Much of the pioneering work into sterol metabolism in insects was conducted on two lepidopteran species, M. sexta (reviewed by Svoboda and Weirich, 1995) and B. mori (reviewed by Ikekawa et al., 1993), and we have reported some of the key details from these studies in the preceding section. In general, lepidopteran insects are capable of producing cholesterol from C28 and C29 5-phytosterols (Table 3). In some species, however, a double bond at the 22-position and/or a methyl group rather than an ethyl group at C-24 seems to reduce the efficiency of this conversion (e.g. Svoboda and Robbins, 1968; Svoboda et al., 1995a). Metabolism of the sterol nucleus has only been studied in two species, M. sexta (Svoboda et al., 1995a) and H. zea (Ritter, 1984, 1986; Nes et al., 1997), and results suggest it does not occur. When these two species were reared on diets containing 0-, 5-, 7- and 8-sterols, the sterol nucleus double bond configuration found in the caterpillars resembled that found in the diet. Cholesterol was also found in all of these caterpillars, but it was probably maternal in origin. Finally, the Hymenoptera seem to show a sterol metabolic pattern similar to the Diptera. That is, dealkylation is present in the primitive members of the order but is lost in the more derived members. For instance, Schaefer et al. (1965) demonstrated that the Virginia sawfly, Neodiprion pratti, could convert [3H]-sitosterol to [3H]-cholesterol. Likewise, cholesterol is the dominate tissue sterol found in most Symphyta even though the plants on which they feed contain primarily 5-phytosterols (Table 3). The one exception to this is Xiphydria maculata, which is thought to feed on fungus and has tissue sterol profiles dominated by 7-dehydrocholesterol (Svoboda et al., 1995b). Among
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
35
the predaceous Apocrita, which primarily includes the wasps and some ants, cholesterol is found in the tissues in large quantities, along with various other phytosterols that are normally associated with the dietary sterols of their prey items (Table 3). This also seems to be the case for the hymenopteran parasitoid, Microplitis demolitor (Braconidae) (Ritter and Johnson, 1991). Interestingly these authors found that the sterol composition of this parasitoid’s host had little effect on its growth. However, growth was effected when they reduced the amount of cholesterol available in the haemolymph of the host. This suggests parasitoids, especially those found in herbivorous insects, have effective cholesterol sparing mechanisms above a minimal cholesterol threshold. Among the ants that tend fungal gardens, the finding that their sterol composition usually mirrors that of the fungus indicates that little sterol metabolism occurs (Maurer et al., 1992). This is an interesting finding because it perhaps suggests that the central nervous system can function in certain organisms without cholesterol. Finally, among the bees that have been examined, 24-methylenecholesterol is the dominant tissue sterol, followed by other phytosterols that are determined by the sterol composition of the bee’s host-plants. Regardless of the dietary sterol available to worker bees, 24-methylenecholesterol is the major tissue sterol found in the brood reared by workers (Svoboda et al., 1983). This is accomplished through a selective transfer of sterols from the endogenous sterol pools of the workers to the developing larvae through the brood food material secreted from the hypopharyngeal and mandibular glands and/or the honey stomach of the workers (Svoboda et al., 1986). 3.3
CONSIDERATIONS OF PATTERNS OF STEROL USE AND METABOLISM
Taken together information about sterol use (Table 2) and metabolism (Table 3) can give useful insights into the evolution of sterol abilities in insects, especially when viewed in a phylogenetic context (Fig. 4). Cholesterol supports growth for most insects, but since it is not always readily available, many insects, especially plant feeders, must dealkylate phytosterols to produce cholesterol. This conversion also provides the necessary precursor to ecdysone, which, along with 20-OH ecdysone, is one of the two most commonly occurring moulting hormones (ecdysteroids) in insects (Svoboda, 1994). That a thysanuran can convert sitosterol to cholesterol suggests the ability to dealkylate the phytosterol side chain had an early evolutionary origin (Fig. 4a). This ability is maintained in some of the Polyneoptera, as demonstrated by the fact that grasshoppers and cockroaches convert sitosterol to cholesterol. The Orthoptera are the best studied exopterygotes, and it is interesting to note that within this group the grasshoppers (acridids), as compared to the crickets (gryllids), have a very limited ability to dealkylate. The Califera (the suborder to which the acridids belong) are derived from the Ensifera
36
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
FIG. 4 A Phylogenetic interpretation of sterol metabolic capabilities in the major insect orders. The phylogeny was adapted from the Tree of Life (Maddison et al., 2001), and represents Kristensen’s (1991) cautious views about the relationships of orders. Dealkylation is considered the primitive state based on the ability of a thysanuran to convert sitosterol to cholesterol (see Section 3.2.2, p. 24). Bars across phylogenetic branches indicate a lost ability to dealkylate. Question marks have been placed next to bars where we hypothesize that dealkylation abilities might be lost, but have yet to be tested. The triple question mark for the Strepsiptera indicates the placement of this branch within the Endopterygota remains uncertain.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
37
(the suborder containing the gryllids) (Rowell and Flook, 1998), which suggests that broad sterol metabolic dealkylation abilities may have been lost. It also perhaps implies that there may be metabolic costs associated with maintaining a broad enzymatic capability. Unfortunately there is little consensus on the phylogenetic relationship within the Polyneoptera (Exopterygota excluding the Apterygota and Paleoptera), and the lack of information on sterol use or metabolism in this group, outside of the acridids, makes it difficult to infer much about the evolution of sterol metabolic capability. Based on our current understanding of the relatedness and feeding habits of the Polyneoptera, we suggest that the loss of dealkylation has occurred independently on multiple occasions. Since the polytomy for this group is soft, clarification of the relationships between the major orders within the Polyneoptera will likely indicate fewer independent losses of sterol dealkylating ability. The hemipteroid assemblage includes the Hemiptera, Thysanoptera, Psocoptera and Phthiraptera, but in this clade only hemipteran species have been examined. The Hemiptera are, however, a large group and inspection of the sterol metabolism data for this group reveals an interesting pattern. The primitive Sternorrhyncha and Auchenorrhyncha can dealkylate phytosterols, but the more derived Heteroptera cannot. Predaceous feeding is the primitive state in the Heteroptera, while plant feeding has arisen secondarily. This result suggests that once dealkylating abilities are lost they may be difficult to regain. An additional unique aspect associated with the loss of dealkylation ability in this group is the use of different moulting hormones by the primitive predaceous hemipterans (C27 ecdysteroids) and their more derived plant-feeding cousins (C28 (Makisterone A) or C29 (Makisterone C) ecdysteroids). Where predaceous feeding has arisen secondarily among the plant feeders, however, Makisterone A is retained as the moulting hormone (Aldrich et al., 1982; Svoboda et al., 1984). This suggests that the mechanisms for ecdysteroid biosynthesis are strongly conserved among the more derived Heteroptera even when cholesterol is abundant (Svoboda, 1994). Based on the feeding lifestyle of the Phthiraptera, we propose that dealkylation abilities may have been lost in this group. Phytophagy appears to be the primitive condition in Coleoptera and it seems that most phytophagous beetles have a broad ability to dealkylate, except perhaps for those, such as T. granarium, which have adopted a plant-feeding lifestyle secondarily. The coccinellid E. varivestis, which has also evolved plant feeding secondarily, is a slight exception. It can dealkylate sitosterol but not other phytosterols, including campesterol. The Neuroptera, Megaloptera and Rhaphidiodea are found in the same clade as the Coleoptera (Fig. 4b), but there is evidence that the ability to dealkylate may have been lost in these members, which would not be surprising considering their predaceous nature. The basal members of the Hymenoptera, Lepidoptera and Diptera are phytophagous, and dealkylation is found in all of the primitive members of
38
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
these orders. So far, it appears that this ability has been maintained throughout the Lepidoptera, but not throughout the Hymenoptera or Diptera. Among the Hymenoptera, dealkylation ability has been lost in the Apocrita, so bees, like the derived hemipterans, use various dietary sterols in unmetabolized form and have Makisterone A as their moulting hormone. Likewise, fungus-eating ants do not metabolize their dietary sterols, e.g. ergosterol, and contain primarily C28 ecdysteroids (Maurer et al., 1991, 1993). Finally, the derived Diptera (Brachycerca) also appear to have lost the ability to dealkylate, and biochemical studies with M. domestica and D. melanogaster revealed that these two derived Diptera produce Makisterone A from campesterol (Feldlaufer and Svoboda, 1991). Nonetheless, these same authors found that C27 ecdysteroids were the major moulting hormones and suggested that they were probably derived from trace amounts of cholesterol in the diet, which were most likely obtained through selective uptake. The predaceous nature of the Mecoptera and Siphonaptera also lead us to suggest that dealkylation abilities may be lost in these two groups, but whether this has occurred independently in each group depends on resolving the relationship of these two Orders to one another.
4
Insect sterol physiology
Why cholesterol accumulates in some but not all insects is puzzling. Moreover, it is unclear why insects have evolved enzymes that transform sitosterol to cholesterol, but not ones that transform cycloartenol and other intermediates of the phytosterol pathway to cholesterol. To examine these enigmas the function of sterols in insects needed to be uncovered. At present sterols are considered to play three roles in insect physiology: (i) as a membrane insert; (ii) as a precursor to the moulting hormones, ecdysteroids; and (iii) as a signalling molecule bound to the hedgehog group of proteins affecting development. Interestingly, the sterol features and amounts involved with each of these functions differ. The bulk of the sterol in insects is localized in microsomes, a combination of membranous systems (Short et al., 1996), which is in agreement with the proposal that the major role for sterols is as an architectural component of membranes (Clark and Bloch, 1959a; Nes and McKean, 1977). Although some insect species have rigid sterol structural requirements, others appear to be able to use a variety of different sterols under different environmental conditions (Behmer and Elias, 1999a, 2000; Mondy and Corio-Costet, 2000). However, when the level of required sterols falls below a critical threshold, for example from 350 g/ml to 55 g/ml in L. migratoria nymphs that have been reared on wheat with a modified sterol profile, insect growth and embryogenesis are impaired (Costet et al., 1987). In an analogous finding, humans that possess inborn errors of cholesterol metabolism accumulate sterol intermediates. This
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
39
accumulation corresponds with a drastic reduction in plasma cholesterol levels – normal, 160 mg/dl, diseased, less than 110 mg/dl – and children that express the error in cholesterol metabolism often exhibit physical malformations (Tint et al., 1997). The total amount of sterol found in an insect is influenced by its size, and generally the larger the insect the more sterol it contains. For example, aphids possess ca. 0.02 g/insect while the tobacco hornworm contains ca. 1800 g/larva (Table 4). The sterol composition of an insect depends on its diet and for phytophagous insects a mixture of cholesterol and 24-alkyl sterols is common (95% of total sterol). The size of the insect in relation to the amount of sterol in the diet is also important. Thus, to grow and complete development the corn earworm requires ca. 200 ppm of added sterol (Nes et al., 1997) whereas the tobacco hornworm requires ca. 320 ppm of added sterol (Svoboda et al., 1995a). In these two studies the total amount of sterol delivered to individual larva was approximately 1–3 mg, which is about the amount of sterol (ca. 1 mg) in a mature sorghum leaf (Nes, 1990). The natural distribution of sterols isolated from insects suggest that they must possess three key features to serve as a membrane insert, including a 3 -hydroxyl group, a flat tetracyclic ring system and an 8–10 carbon side chain positioned in the ‘‘right-handed’’ conformation. The structure of phytosterols juxtaposed as shown in Fig. 5 fit the dimension of the monolayer of the lipid leaflet (Parker and Nes, 1992), but based on the type of sterols accumulated in insects, it seems that some cannot tolerate significant variations in the shape of the cholesterol molecule. Tolerance to variation in sterol structure has been examined in numerous insects by replacing cholesterol with other sterols that either lack a particular feature, e.g., 4,4-dimethyl group, or have some other interesting aspect to them e.g., altered stereochemistry or contained an ‘‘extra’’ methyl group in the sterol side chain (Clark and Bloch, 1959a; Clayton, 1964; Ritter and Nes, 1981a,b; Kircher, 1982; Nes et al., 1982, 1997; Ikekawa et al., 1993; Behmer and Elias, 1999a, 2000). In summary, these structure–activity studies revealed that intermediates in the sitosterol–cholesterol pathways that had methyl groups at C-4, or possessed a 9,19-cyclopropane group or 8-bond could not be utilized by insects. The insect membranes can use sitosterol together with cholesterol, since the methyl group found on sitosterol does not lengthen the side chain beyond functional limits. In addition, the natural stereochemistry at C-20 in phytosterols gives necessary directionality to the overall length of the molecule, thereby contributing to its planar shape, as shown in the conformational perspective illustrated in Fig. 5. In support of this proposal, when cholesterol and either 20-epicholesterol or 17(20)Z-dehydrocholesterol were fed to the silkworm, only cholesterol supported growth (Ikekawa et al., 1993). The stereochemistry of the 24-alkyl group in phytosterols is of less importance to membrane structure, since both sets of compounds are utilized equally well by the insect and undergo metabolism to ecdysteroids.
40
TABLE 4 Total sterol amount for species from different orders. Numbers in parentheses indicate the cited study. Species
Growth form Ametabolous – no metamorphosis Thysanura – primitively wingless, e.g. firebrat Hemimetabolous – incomplete metamorphosis Orthoptera – straight winged, e.g. grasshoppers Homoptera – winged and wingless, e.g. aphids Hemiptera – half-winged, e.g stink bugs Holometabolous – complete metamorphosis Hymenoptera – membrane winged, e.g. ants Coleoptera – forewings thickened, e.g. beetles Lepidoptera – scale-covered wings, e.g. moths
*
NE* NE Schistocerca americana (1) Schizaphis graminum (2) NE Solenopsis invicata (3) Anthonumus grandis (4) Helicoverpa zea (5) Manduca sexta (6) NE
20.00 0.02 2.00 55.00 66.00 1800.00
(1) Behmer et al., 1999b; (2) Campbell and Nes, 1983; (3) Ba et al., 1995; (4) Nes, unpublished; (5) Nes et al., 1997; (6) Svoboda et al., 1995a. NE, not examined.
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Diptera – one pair of wings, e.g. flies
Total sterol (g)
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
41
FIG. 5 Conformational perspective of cholesterol.
The importance of metabolizing the 24-alkyl(alkylidene) group to the cholesterol side chain can be found in the structure of 20-hydroxecdysone (Fig. 6). The moulting hormone requires a 25-hydroxyl group for activity and the 24-alkyl group in the phytosterol side chain will, due to steric factors, interfere with the introduction of the 25-hydroxyl group. The importance of converting phytosterol intermediates to a 5-4-desmethyl sterol is also related to the structure and function of ecdysteroids (Gilbert et al., 2002). The removal of geminal groups at C-3 of cycloartenol is required for a sterol to possess an unhindered 3-hydroxyl group. The elimination of the C-4 methyl groups is necessary for sterol–lipid interactions (Nes et al., 1978) and to covalently bind to protein during Hedgehog signalling (Porter et al., 1996). An insect responds, presumably through the Hedgehog signalling process, to subtle differences in the structure of the side chain, which suggests a greater level of sterol recognition by the insect-signalling mechanisms than is currently recognized in other animal systems. Thus, corn earworm cultured on a synthetic diet treated with non-utilizable sterols, such as ergosta-5,23-dienol, proceed through a very long pupation stage and the adults which emerge are abnormal with malformed wings and legs (Nes et al., 1997). Future efforts to establish the substrate features and quantitative importance of sterol for specific functions during growth and maturation of individual insect species will prove to be a formidable task. However, the use of inhibitors and genetic engineering approaches to assist in providing sufficient protein or enzymes that act on steroids may provide answers. The aim of the remainder of this section is to document the journey of dietary sterols through an insect. We start at the mouth and describe what is known about the ability of insects to taste sterols and regulate their intake via behavioral mechanisms. We next turn our attention to the fate of sterols after they are ingested. The digestive process begins in the mouth and continues as the food is passed through the foregut into the midgut. During this process
42
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
FIG. 6 Roles for cholesterol. Diagrammatic representation of cholesterol functions – (A) membrane insert, (B) precursor to the moulting hormone 20-hydroxyecdysone, and (C) as a component of the hedgehog signalling process. See text for details.
sterols can either be modified, via enzymatic reactions, or remain unchanged. Because we have already discussed many of the details related to sterol metabolism, we focus on the processes involved in their uptake and absorption. We now know that transport of sterols through the haemolymph is facilitated by lipophorin, and we touch on this process before turning our attention to the tissue and intracellular distribution of sterols in an insect. We also examine the central role sterols play in various physiological processes, including development, growth, and reproduction, as well as their influence on parasites and viruses of insects. 4.1
STEROL TASTE AND THE REGULATION OF INTAKE
Whether insects can directly taste sterols has only critically been examined in grasshoppers. In two studies using S. americana nymphs, Champagne and Bernays (1991) and Behmer et al. (1999a) used a series of short-term experiments to explore how different sterols affected feeding behavior, such as
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
43
initial contacts with different test foods and the length and structure of the first meal. Results from these experiments suggested that this grasshopper could not taste sterols, even after they had fed for 24 h on spinach, a plant that is devoid of suitable sterols. Perhaps this finding is not surprising considering the strong lipophilic nature of sterols and the design and manner in which contact chemoreceptors operate. However, until detailed electrophysiological work has been performed, the question of whether insects can directly taste sterols will remain unanswered. Despite the lack of evidence indicating an ability to directly taste sterols, S. americana nymphs still seem capable of adjusting their feeding behavior in response to the sterol profile of their food. For example, when grasshoppers were given spinach, the lengths of successive meals declined until the food was completely rejected (Champagne and Bernays, 1991). This aversion response was eliminated, however, when sitosterol or cholesterol was applied topically to the spinach leaves. Notably the length of the first meal on spinach was identical whether or not a suitable sterol had been added, which indicated there was no immediate effect of sterol profile on feeding behavior. These overall results suggest that grasshoppers were behaving in a fashion that is consistent with food aversion learning mediated through post-ingestive feedbacks (e.g. Lee and Bernays, 1988). That sterols might be responsible for this learned aversion was investigated in a series of experiments by Behmer and Elias (1999b). First, they compared feeding behavior of grasshoppers on artificial diets that contained sitosterol or a spinach lipid extract, and found that the diet containing the extract evoked a deterrent feeding response. Next, they separated the spinach lipid extract into three classes: desmethyl sterols, dimethyl sterols and remaining spinach lipids. These were then added to artificial diets and feeding behavior was again analysed. This experiment showed that only the desmethyl sterol extract, which contains the spinach end-product sterols, deterred feeding. In a separate set of experiments, Behmer et al. (1999a) tested whether the deterrent response to sterols was mediated post-ingestively. In one experiment grasshoppers were given an initial meal on spinach and then injected, through the abdomen, with a small volume of mineral oil that contained ‘soybean’ sitosterol (suitable), ‘spinach’ sterols (unsuitable) or no sterol (the control). Following the injection the grasshoppers were returned to their arenas and given a fresh leaf of spinach and the length of their next meal was recorded. Results showed no difference in feeding time between the ‘soybean’ sitosterol and no sterol treatment (about 75 s each), but showed a significant drop in the meal length of the ‘spinach’ sterol injected grasshoppers (median feed time of only 3 s). It was suggested that the grasshoppers were developing a learned association between the presence of an unsuitable sterol in the blood with the taste of the spinach. This was tested, and verified, by giving grasshoppers artificial foods containing different combinations of sterols and flavors.
44
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
The feeding responses of beetles and caterpillars to sterols have also been examined, although in less detail, and the results are mixed. Among the beetles, for example, cholesterol and sitosterol stimulate biting, but not feeding, in Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Hsiao and Fraenkel, 1968), but neither biting nor feeding in Sericesthis geminata (Wensler and Dudzinski, 1972). Shanks and Doss (1987) examined five weevil species, and found that sitosterol and stigmasterol stimulated feeding in only one of these, the obscure root weevil, Sciphithis obscurus. In the same study a synergistic effect of sterols and sucrose on feeding was observed in S. obscurus as well as in the black vine weevil, Otiorhynchus sulcatus, and the pea leaf weevil, Sitona lineatus. The silkworm, B. mori, is the most thoroughly studied caterpillar with regards to the role of sterols in feeding behavior. Hamamura et al. (1962) reported that sitosterol stimulated feeding, but Nayar and Fraenkel (1962), using commercially obtained preparations of sitosterol of fair purity, found no such effect. Likewise, they reported no effect on feeding by melissyl alcohol, cholesterol, sitosterol, or stigmasterol. However, Ito et al. (1964) showed that silkworm feeding could be stimulated if commercial sitosterol was recrystallized. The functional significance of this is difficult to interpret, however, since they also showed that recrystallizing stigmasterol and campesterol produced a similar effect. Finally, Hamamura (1970) studied biting responses of B. mori towards sterols and measured high levels of activity towards sitosterol but less towards cholesterol and only a few towards ergosterol. Chippendale and Reddy (1972b) showed that in Diatraea grandiosella, cholesterol and sitosterol failed to stimulate biting or feeding. They did show, however, that feeding was negatively effected by three cholesterol esters (three different acid moieties (acetate, myristate, oleate)), which suggests that a substituted 3 hydroxyl group might adversely affect the insect’s sensory mechanisms. We suggest, however, that the interpretations from the beetle and caterpillar be viewed cautiously since the assays used did not look at detailed aspects of individual behavior. 4.2
STEROL ABSORPTION
The midgut appears to be the main site of sterol absorption for many insects, particularly in phytophagous species (Joshi and Agarwal, 1977), as was recently demonstrated by Jouni et al. (2002a). In their study they placed a block of food containing [3H]-cholesterol in the foregut, midgut or hindgut of 5th stadium M. sexta larvae and, after 2 h, measured the radioactivity of the haemolymph. Results showed that when the food was placed in the midgut, radioactivity levels in the haemolymph were 5-fold and 9.5-fold higher compared to when the food was placed in the foregut and hindgut, respectively. In some phytophagous insects, specialized regions of the midgut may be particularly active in sterol absorption. For example, 6 h after Joshi and
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
45
Agarwal (1977) fed cabbage leaves containing [3H]-cholesterol to the grasshoppers, S. gregaria and Hieroglyphus nigrorepleteus, they found that the gastric caeca contained more radioactivity (>50%) than any other region of the gut. In contrast, the same study indicated that in omnivorous species such as the house cricket, Gryllodes sigilatus (Orthoptera: Gryllidae), the carpenter ant, Camponotus compressus (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) and a diving beetle, Dytiscus (Coleoptera: Dytisidae), the foregut, especially the crop, was the primary site of sterol absorption. A similar finding was reported for the cockroaches (Blattaria: Blattidae) Euryocotis floridana (Clayton et al., 1964) and Periplaneta americana (Joshi and Agarwal, 1976), which are also omnivorous. The mechanisms governing the uptake of sterols from the food to gut tissues in insects are poorly understood. In vertebrates, the absorption of sterols into intestinal cells is aided by bile salts. Insects do not have bile salts and current working models suggest that sterols, packaged as mixed micelles with phospholipids, are absorbed passively into the membranes of gut tissue (Turunen and Crailsheim, 1996). In contrast to insects, vertebrates show a strong tendency to absorb cholesterol more easily than phytosterols. In humans for example, cholesterol absorption is 56.2 12.1% in normal subjects during test meals (Ostlund, 2002), but the values for phytosterols are much lower, ranging from 0.04% for sitostanol (Ostlund et al., 2002) up to 16% for campesterol (Lutjohann et al., 1995). This later study also suggests that humans absorb 5-phytosterols more easily than they do 0-sterols (stanols). Sterol uptake mechanisms seem less rigid in insects however, as evidenced by the fact that phytosterols are regularly found in the tissues of both predaceous and phytophagous insects (Table 3). There are some exceptions though, as Robbins (1963) has demonstrated with houseflies, which can selectively absorb and incorporate cholesterol, relative to other dietary sterols, when it is limiting in the diet. Phytosterols reduce cholesterol uptake in humans and for this reason phytosterols are considered beneficial dietary components even though they are non-usable. Phytosterols also reduce cholesterol uptake in the zoophagous D. maculatus, but this negatively effects growth since this species requires a dietary source of cholesterol (Katz et al., 1971). Behmer et al. (1999b) recently explored how usable and non-usable sterols interact to influence sterol absorption and cholesterol production in phytophagous insects. They fed S. americana nymphs artificial diets containing ‘usable’ sitosterol (0.5 g/mg), ‘non-usable’ stigmasterol (0.5 g/mg) or a mixture of these two sterols (equal amounts for a total of 1.0 g/mg) and then compared the tissue sterol profiles. The results showed that the relative amount of stigmasterol in the tissue of ‘mixture’ grasshoppers was significantly lower compared with the ‘stigmasterol’ grasshoppers, even though both treatments contained similar total amounts of stigmasterol. The results also showed that the relative cholesterol level from ‘mixture’ grasshoppers was intermediate between the ‘usable’ sitosterol and
46
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
‘unusable’ stigmasterol treatments. This suggests that phytophagous insects probably do not selectively absorb usable over non-usable sterols, but that non-usable sterols can affect cholesterol production, most likely by reducing the uptake of sterols that serve as precursors to it. In general, it seems that the amounts of sterol absorbed, as well as the amount of cholesterol produced, are directly related to the proportions of usable and non-usable sterols in the food. Other aspects of an insect’s food also influence sterol absorption. For example, Dupnik and Kamm (1970) showed that dietary lipids enhanced the efficiency of sterol uptake in the grass moth Crambus tricestus (Lepidoptera: Crambidae), and Ito and Nakasone (1966) demonstrated that soybean fatty acids increased the utilization of sitosterol in B. mori. Plant secondary metabolites, on the other hand, may reduce sterol utilization, as demonstrated by Weissenberg et al. (1998). They fed M. sexta larvae diets containing the alkaloid spirosolane and glycoalkaloids and found that sterol absorption and metabolism was significantly reduced. However, the negative effect of these alkaloids decreased as the concentration of cholesterol and sitosterol in the food increased, as shown by Weissenberg et al. (1998) with the beetle T. castaneum and Bloem et al. (1989) with the caterpillars H. zea and S. exigua. Sterols can enter and leave midgut mucosal cells rather quickly, as demonstrated by Jouni et al. (2002a). They fed a block of food containing [3H]-cholesterol to 5th instar M. sexta larvae and found that radioactivity levels in the midgut peaked within the first hour of feeding. This peak was then followed by a sharp decrease within 4 h, after which there was a steady decrease until late pupation, at which point the tissue started to disintegrate. Numerous studies have shown that insects can absorb dietary cholesterol both in the free and ester form, but that following absorption a small fraction of the free form is subjected to intracellular esterification (Turunen and Chippendale, 1977; Kuthiala and Ritter, 1988; Komnick and Giesa, 1994; Jouni et al., 2002a). Esterification takes place in intestinal microsomes, fat body and ovaries via acyl coenzyme A: cholesterol acyltransferase (ACAT), but the rate at which exogenous sterols are esterified is affected by various side chain modifications and the number and position of double bonds in the B-ring of the sterol nucleus (Billheimer et al., 1983; Macauley et al., 1986). The significance of esterification is unknown, but it has been suggested that it could serve as a temporary intracellular storage mechanism (Turunen, 1985). Few studies have examined the rates of uptake of radiolabelled phytosterols. Phytophagous insects, compared to zoophagous or omnivorous ones, rarely encounter cholesterol in their diets and in fact most of the sterols they encounter are present as fatty acid esters. We advocate the use of radiolabelled phytosterols and phytosterol esters as a method for more properly investigating sterol absorption in phytophagous insects. It would also lead
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
47
to a more thorough understanding of the manner in which different phytosterols interact with each other, plus other diet constituents, in the insect midgut. 4.3
STEROL TRANSPORT AND TISSUE DISTRIBUTION
Following absorption into the midgut, sterols must be transported through the haemolymph to organs of utilization and storage. However, the hydrophobic nature of sterols requires that they be carried through the cytosol and haemolymph by a specialized carrier system. The specific mechanisms by which cholesterol and other sterols are delivered from the haemoceol through the midgut to different tissues and organs are poorly understood. Recently, however, a putative sterol carrier protein thought to be involved in intracellular transport of cholesterol has been identified in the yellow fever mosquito, A. aegypti (Krebs and Lan, 2003). Likewise, high-density lipophorin (HDLp), a non-covalent mixture of lipid and protein, has been identified as the sole haemolymph carrier of cholesterol in M. sexta (Jouni et al., 2002a). 4.3.1
Intracellular transport
The identification of a putative sterol carrier protein involved in the intracellular transport of cholesterol is significant because it provides a mechanism by which sterols can be delivered to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), the organelle where sterol dealkylation and ecdysteroid production are thought to occur. Krebs and Lan (2003) identified the putative mosquito sterol carrier protein-2 (SCP-2) using cDNA from a fourth instar subtracted cDNA library of A. aegypti and the sterol transfer domain AeSCP-2 was shown to have a high degree of homology in the sterol transfer domain to both rat and human SCP-2 (69%). Transcripts of AeSCP-2 differed between 4th instar larvae and early pupae, being strongly detected in larval midgut tissues, but not in the head and hindgut. This outcome is consistent with the midgut being the primary centre of intracellular cholesterol trafficking in immature insects. In contrast, AeSCP-2 transcripts in the pupae were mainly observed in the thorax, head and body wall of the abdomen, but not in the gut. When interactions between AeSCP-2 and cholesterol were examined, using a radiolabelled cholesterol-binding assay, purified recombinant AeSCP-2 showed a high affinity to cholesterol. They also found that the C-terminal of AeSCP-2 did not have the peroxisome targeting sequence (AKL or SKL) found in vertebrate SCP-2 members. This led them to speculate that AeSCP-2 may be involved in the transfer of sterol between cellular compartments such as lysosomes, ER, plasma membrane and mitochondria. Interestingly they showed that the addition of 60 ng/ml of 20-OH ecdysone to an A. aegypti tissue culture (primarily gut tissue) increased AeSCP-2 expression, which suggests that ecdysteroids may be directly involved in regulating cholesterol uptake in
48
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
the midgut of insects. The only other SCP-2 family member so far described in insects is the Drosophila SCP-X (X97685), but surprisingly the amino acid similarities between AeSCP-2 and SCP-2 domain in Drosophila are low (52%) (Krebs and Lan, 2003). 4.3.2
Haemolymph transport
The discovery that HDLp is the sole carrier of sterols through the haemolymph (Jouni et al., 2002a) is also important because without it cholesterol could not be transferred from sites of absorption or synthesis to sites of storage or utilization. Lipophorin was first identified in the 60s and is best known for its role in the transport of diacylglycerols (DG) between midgut tissues, the fat body and flight muscles, where DG is ultimately used to fuel flight (Ryan and van der Horst, 2000). HDLp is one of three existing forms of lipophorin, each being distinguished from one another based on their densities (Beenakkers et al., 1985). High-density lipophorin (HDLp), which carries sterols, contains relatively little lipid, while low-density lipophorin (LDLp) contains more. A third class, the very-high-density lipophorin (VHDLp) is sometimes produced, and its most common form is vitellogenin. Lipophorin, which tends to be spherical in shape, has a surface composed of phospholipids and proteins and an internal core that is mainly diacyglycerol (DAG) plus smaller amounts of sterols, hydrocarbons, carotenoids and other acylglycerols (Soulages and Wells, 1994). It is produced in the fat body but resides in the haemolymph, where it acts as a reusable shuttle that can easily interface with various tissues to collect and transport cholesterol throughout the body (Chino, 1985). The mechanism by which DG and cholesterol are transported from the midgut to target tissues appears to differ fundamentally. Whereas DG transport is mediated by the HDLp receptor and lipid transfer particle (LTP) in both the midgut (Canavoso and Wells, 2001) and fat body (Canavoso et al., 2003), cholesterol transfer between the midgut and fat body through HDLp seems to operate via aqueous diffusion (Yun et al., 2002). Such a mode of delivery for cholesterol is supported by two findings. First, the transfer of cholesterol from the midgut to HDLp, and from HDLp to fat body shows saturation kinetics. Second, treating the midgut and fat body tissues with suramin, a known inhibitor of fat body HDLp receptor (Tsuchida and Wells, 1990), enocytic inhibitors, anit-LTP antibodies or EDTA, has little or no effect on cholesterol transfer. Based on these results, Yun et al. (2002) proposed that in M. sexta the maintenance of cholesterol homeostasis takes place by a mass action mechanism where cholesterol is freely transferred between lipophorin and tissue depending on the needs of the tissues. Additionally they found that the transfer of cholesterol between fat body and HDLp was bi-directional, but that the transfer between midgut and HDLp was uni-directional (midgut to HDLp). They suggest this might be related to relatively high cholesterol content
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
49
of the midgut basolateral membrane, which would favour the export of cholesterol, but inhibit its import. The fat body is effectively a storage centre for a number of molecules, especially lipids, and in a separate study Jouni et al. (2002b) explored cholesterol efflux from the fat body to HDLp in late instar M. sexta larvae. They demonstrated that lipophorin specifically and significantly induced a transfer of [3H]-cholesterol from the fat body, and then conducted a number of experiments to determine whether cholesterol transfer from fat body to HDLp was receptor-mediated or followed an aqueous diffusion pathway. Several results, including a high Km, high activation energy and the lack of Ca2 þ dependence favoured the aqueous diffusion model. They also examined whether LTP or lipophorin receptor was involved in cholesterol transfer, and found that anti-LTP inhibited cholesterol transfer by 20%, while sumarin, which inhibits lipophorin receptor, reduced cholesterol transfer by 50%. These last two results indicate that LTP-dependent and receptor-mediated pathways may be involved in the transfer process of cholesterol from fat body to HDLp, but Jouni et al. (2002b) argue that if these pathways exist, they likely represent minor routes. Experiments using cholesterol-labelled lipophorin have also been conducted to investigate the fate of lipophorin-cholesterol. Jouni et al. (2002a), using 5th instar M. sexta larvae, found that injected cholesterol was cleared from the haemolymph with a half-life of 10.2 h. After 17 h they found that 30% of the radioactivity remained in the haemolymph but that 38% of it was recovered in the fat body. Only 11% was recovered from the midgut, which agrees with the finding that transfer of cholesterol between the midgut and HDLp is uni-directional towards HDLp (Yun et al., 2002). 4.3.3
Tissue and intracellular distribution
Cholesterol is the dominant tissue sterol for most insects but few detailed studies on the distribution of cholesterol in various insect tissues exist. Lasser et al. (1966) found that total sterol concentration of the tissues from the skunk roach, E. floridana, were similar to, but slightly lower than the concentrations of sterols found in the tissues of vertebrates. Upon inspecting the sterol concentration of individual organs from adults they found that cholesterol concentrations were highest in nerve tissues and salivary glands, intermediate in the gut, Malpighian tubules and fat body, and lowest in muscle and cuticle. Interestingly, increasing the dietary concentration of cholesterol 10-fold, to 1.0%, resulted in a 7-fold increase in the cholesterol content of the fat body. This strongly suggests that the fat body can act as a storage site for excess cholesterol. Other tissues showed significant, but much smaller increases. Tissue sterol profiles can also differ between males and females, and across developmental stages. For instance, Lasser et al. (1966) showed that there was
50
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
a 3-fold higher concentration of cholesterol in the reproductive organs of females compared with males. With respect to development, Ba et al. (1995) detected 26 sterols in the imported red fire ant collected from field stations in Texas and found that an individual ant’s sterol composition was influenced by the stage of development – egg, larva, worker or queen. Eggs contained the least diversity in type of sterol, with cholesterol dominating the total sterol mixture (45% total sterol), whereas the queen possessed the greatest sterol diversity with 24-alkyl sterols detected and 24-ethyl sterols, such as sitosterol, dominating the sterol mixture (54% total sterol). Larvae contained many of the sterols found in the egg, with cholesterol being the most abundant (50% total sterol). Minor amounts of unusual sterols were also isolated, including ergosta-5,23-dienol (3 in Scheme 1) which is produced as a natural phytosterol in corn (Guo et al., 1995). There is strong evidence that tissue, especially nerve tissue, exhibits selective uptake of cholesterol when it is limiting. For example, when Lasser et al. (1966) reared E. floridana on a diet of 0.005% cholesterol and 0.1% cholestanol, they found that brain tissue had a 1:1 ratio of cholesterol:cholestanol, but that the ratio of these two sterols in the other tissues, such as the cuticle (1:4) and the alimentary canal (1:10), were much lower. Likewise, Dwivedy (1993) found that 6-times more cholesterol than sitosterol was recovered from brain tissues of M. domestica larvae reared on a diet containing cholesterol (0.002%) and sitosterol (0.01%). In contrast, all other tissues, e.g. gut, fat body and muscle, from these houseflies had greater proportions of sitosterol than cholesterol. This suggests that nerve tissues might have special quantitative cholesterol requirements compared to other tissues and that the idea of a cholesterol sparing mechanism may extend beyond metabolic, i.e. ecdysteroid, functions to also include specific tissue requirements. It would be interesting to see whether similar selective uptake of cholesterol occur in phytophagous insects with limited dealkylating capabilities when they are reared on foods containing mixtures of sterols that can and cannot be dealkylated. Recently it has been shown that in mammalian membranes, cholesterol is not uniformly miscible, but rather has a tendency to organize the bilayer into cholesterol-rich liquid or cholesterol-poor liquid disorded domains. This leads to the formation of specialized phase domains called rafts, which are known to play an important part in both polarized protein sorting and signal transduction (Simons and Ikonen, 1997; Brown and London, 1997). Rietveld et al. (1999) explored whether these rafts also exist in D. melanogaster, and found that although Drosophila membranes had ergosterol as the predominant membrane sterol (69%), they still contained rafts with similar protein and lipid composition. They also identified a detergent-insoluble fraction in the Drosophila membranes that, like mammalian rafts, was rich in sterol, sphingolipids and glycosylphosphatidlyinostil-linked proteins, and demonstrated that the sterol-linked Hedgehog N-terminal fragment associated specifically with this detergent-insoluble membrane fragment. This, they
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
51
suggest, demonstrates that raft formation is preserved across widely separated phyla in organisms that contain different lipid structures. Lipid rafts have also been found in two caterpillars, H. virescens and M. sexta, but in contrast to Drosophila, cholesterol was the dominant sterol (Zhuang et al., 2002). The proportion of esterified sterols found in different insect tissues can also vary depending on the sterol composition of the diet, as well as the insect’s developmental stage and sex. Lasser et al. (1966) found that the nymphal tissues of E. floridana reared on a low-cholesterol/high-cholestanol diet contained cholesterol primarily in the free form, and that a large proportion of the cholestanol from these same tissues occurred in the ester form. This same study also found that adults had a much higher percentage of esterified sterols in their tissues, even when they were reared on a diet containing only cholesterol. Jouni et al. (2002a) reported a similar finding with M. sexta, but noted a more dramatic shift from the free form to the esterified form in males. In their study male larvae and pupa contained only minor quantities of esterified cholesterol, but in adults the majority of sterols recovered from the fat body were esterified. Female larvae and pupae, in contrast to males, contain sizeable pools of sterol esters, particularly in the fat body. At the adult stage, however, female fat body sterol profiles are quite similar to males. Such results might reflect the fact that in adults the demand for unesterified cholesterol to occupy specific functional spaces is reduced compared to during growth, when a limited availability of cholesterol in the diet might lead to a strict confinement of cholesterol to this space. There is also evidence for sterol turnover in insects (Vroman et al., 1964; Lasser et al., 1966), but the rate at which it occurs depends on the concentrations and types of sterols in the food. In general, the half-life of free cholesterol is significantly longer than that of the free sparing sterol pool, and the greatest turnover of sterol occurs in the alimentary canal. To our knowledge, the subcellular distribution of sterols has only been examined in one insect, the skunk roach E. floridana (Lasser and Clayton, 1966). In this study roaches were reared on a ‘cholesterol-sparing’ diet (0.005% cholesterol þ 0.1% cholestanol) and, after reaching maturity, various samples of muscle, salivary glands and nerve tissue were removed and separated into ‘nuclear’, ‘mitochondrial’, and ‘microsomal’ fractions by differential centrifugation. Sterol concentrations were found to be highest in the microsomal and mitochondria fractions and lowest in the nuclei fraction, but in all three fractions the pool of free sterols was larger than the pool of sterol esters. Three emergent sterol peaks corresponding to cholesterol, cholestanol and 7-cholestanol (a metabolite of cholestanol) were identified and results showed that no single sterol was confined to any particular subcellular fraction. Lastly, they showed that the proportions of these three sterols in each of the fractions within a tissue type were similar, but across the different tissues the proportions varied.
52
4.4
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES STEROL REPRODUCTIVE PHYSIOLOGY
A common observation for many insects is that regardless of the sterol in the diet, cholesterol is the dominate sterol that accumulates in eggs (Dutky et al., 1963; Ichimasa, 1976; Lubzens et al., 1981; Costet et al., 1987; Ba et al., 1995; Behmer et al., 1999b; Jouni et al., 2002a). This suggests that cholesterol might be functionally significant. The three-dimensional structure (length– width–volume) of cholesterol (Fig. 5) shows that it has flatness (a series of parallel planes containing all the atoms), as determined by the transfusions of the ring junctions and the existence of the equatorial attachments of a polar head (3 -hydroxyl group), and a non-polar tail (17 -side chain). Phytosterols share many of the same three-dimensional characteristics, as indicated in the X-ray structures shown in Fig. 7. However, the presence of a bulky 24-alkyl group is assumed to increase the fluidity of the bilayer as a result of altered phase-transitions which causes the side chain to sweep out a modified cone structure compared to the cone structure swept out by the cholesterol side chain (Fig. 7). The significance of cholesterol in eggs may also relate to the fact that it serves as a precursor to numerous ecdysteroids, which regulate a number of critical processes throughout embryonic development (Sall et al., 1983). Almost half of the sterol found in eggs is esterified (Dutky et al., 1963; Ichimasa, 1976; Jouni et al., 2002a), and Ichimasa (1976) found that in the silkworm, the accumulation of sterol esters was higher in ‘diapause’ than in ‘non-diapause’ ovaries. The mechanisms governing the transfer of cholesterol to eggs from the fat body via lipophorin, and the contribution of LTP to this process have recently been investigated using the silkworm, B. mori (Jouni et al., 2003). In this study pupal ovarioles (5-day) were incubated with [3H]-cholesterol-labelled
FIG. 7 X-ray structures showing biosynthetic interrelationships of cycloartenol, sitosterol and cholesterol.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
53
lipophorin under a number of different conditions. Results showed that cholesterol transfer exhibited hyperbolic dependency on lipophorin concentration, with a Km of 0.83 0.17 mg/ml, and that cholesterol transfer was strongly temperature dependent. The role of LTP in cholesterol transfer from lipophorin to ovarioles was studied by treating the ovarioles with anti-LTP IgG and then incubating them with cholesterol-labelled lipophorin. This had no effect on the transfer of cholesterol, indicating that LTP was not involved. Taken together, these findings suggest that cholesterol transfer between lipophorin and ovarioles follows an aqueous diffusion mode of action, which is similar to other studies that have investigated the process of cholesterol transfer between tissues in insects (Jouni et al., 2002a; Yun et al., 2002). The particular importance of cholesterol to developing embryos was demonstrated elegantly by Costet et al. (1987) when they reared newly moulted adult female L. migratoria on wheat seedlings that contained 9 ,19cyclopropylsterols in place of normal 5-sterols (following treatment with fungicide). This caused a shift in the tissue sterol profile of the females, from mostly 5-sterols (81%), to a mixture of 5-sterols (47%), 8-sterols (24.5%) and 9 ,19-cyclopropylsterols (21%). Females on the modified wheat also saw a 90% reduction in cholesterol titres of their haemolymph compared with controls. These differences had no effect on the normal egg-laying cycles, a phenomenon also observed in flies reared on cholesterol-free diets (Monroe, 1959), but they did find that egg production in the locusts reared on the modified wheat was reduced by 10–20% compared with the control group. Not surprisingly, they found that egg sterol profiles reflected the dietary sterol profile, with control eggs containing 95.5% 5- and 0-sterols plus a small fraction of 7-sterols, and experimental eggs containing a mixture of 38% cholesterol, 35.5% 8-sterols, and 24.5% 9 ,19-cyclopropylsterols. Ecdysteroid content of the eggs from the two treatments also varied, with controls, on average, containing 3-fold higher concentrations. They also discovered that the ecdysteroid values of eggs within a pod were similar, so for each pod they destructively sampled 3–4 eggs and then measured percentage hatch for each pod. Their results indicated that when ecdysteroid content fell below 70–80% of the controls, no development occurred, perhaps because no meiotic reinitiation took place. When titres were 50–70% below normal, embryonic development was initiated, but the serosal cuticle was only partially laid down (or not at all) and little normal swelling of the egg occurred. At 40–50% below normal, some eggs hatched normally but many of them had embyros with complex malformations. If, however, ecdysteroid titres were no more than 40% below normal, embryogenesis was normal and viable larvae hatched. Unfortunately, this study cannot completely disentangle the effects of cholesterol from ecdysteroids. Nonetheless, the abnormalities found in the developing embryos would suggest that the lack of cholesterol in adult females, which was needed to produce ecdysteroids for the eggs, was
54
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
probably a greater factor in the low observed viability than was the low cholesterol titre in the eggs. Finally, the effects of dietary sterol, and maternal sterol allocation, on reproduction were examined in the diamondback moth, P. xylostella (Behmer and Grebenok, 1998). In this study caterpillars were reared on diets containing one of three phytosterols, sitosterol, stigmasterol or spinasterol, and two control diets (a ‘wheatgerm’ control, and a trace sterol control). When the females eclosed they were collected and mated with males that came from a culture reared on the ‘wheatgerm’ diet. Fecundity and egg viability were measured and then five second-day neonates from 10 different females were reared on the maternal diet. These were reared and mated with culture males, and once again fecundity and egg viability were measured. Results demonstrated that dietary sterols affected egg viability but not total egg production. This seems to be a recurring phenomenon in insects, and suggests that the mechanisms driving egg production might be independent from those determining egg viability, which is clearly linked to dietary sterols, either directly, or indirectly via ecdysteroid production. There was also a suggestion that the lack of large differences in viability between some of the treatments may have been the result of sterol contributions by males to females during copulation. The males used for mating were reared on diets containing sitosterol, which is readily converted to cholesterol by the diamondback moth. Nuptial gifts have been reported in a number of lepidopteran species (Dussourd et al., 1991; Wiklund et al., 1993; Sculley and Boggs, 1996) but whether sterols are part of this contribution has not been reported.
5
Insect sterol ecology
It seems highly unlikely that sterol requirements would influence the food selection behavior of predaceous insects since cholesterol is probably never a limiting nutrient. Likewise, specialist insect herbivores, by definition, should be specifically adapted to the sterol profiles, concentration and spatial distribution of sterols found in their host-plants, e. g. some of the cactophilic Drosophila species (Fogleman et al., 1986). On the other hand, it has been suggested that constraints on sterol metabolic capacity may be a contributing factor driving food mixing behavior in generalist insect herbivores (Bernays, 1992; Behmer and Elias, 2000). Diverse plant communities provide a rich tapestry of dietary sterols, but little is known about the functional significance of variation in plant sterol profiles. One possibility is that sterol profiles may reflect adaptations to local abiotic conditions. For example, plants in the Chenopodiaceae, which are characterized by high concentrations of 7-desmethylsterols (Xu et al., 1988), are found in alkaline prairies of the United States of America, saline habitats around the Mediterranean, Caspian and Red seas and as weeds in salt-rich soils around human habitations
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
55
(Heywood, 1993). Likewise, 7-desmethylsterols are the major sterols found in the Cucurbitaceae, another family that has members specifically adapted to the dry conditions of the desert (Heywood, 1993). It is, however, also possible that phytosterol profile may function as a unique defence against insect herbivores. Grasshoppers are often found in abundance in dry, saline habitats, and it is interesting to note that chenopods and cucurbs often dominate where large grasshopper communities occur, yet these plants do not suffer great damage (Chambers et al., 1996, personal observations). That phytosterols might function as a defence is strengthened by the finding that grasshoppers have very sensitive behavioral responses, including learning, to food sterol profiles (Champagne and Bernays, 1991; Behmer and Elias, 1999b; Behmer et al., 1999a). Traditionally, the terms specialist and generalist refer to the host range of an insect herbivore, but it could also be used to describe an insect’s sterol utilization abilities. However, host and sterol use range is not always correlated. For instance, D. pachea is a specialist in both senses because it feeds only on senita cactus rots and can only grow on very specific sterols. In contrast, the hornworm, M. sexta, is a specialist on plants in the Solanaceae, but it is a sterol generalist since it is capable of growing on a wide range of sterols (Svoboda and Robbins, 1968). That M. sexta has such a broad metabolic capability despite its restricted diet is probably explained by the fact that solanaceous plants contain a suite of different sterols. In complete contrast to M. sexta are the grasshoppers, which are primarily generalist feeders but sterol specialists since sitosterol is the only phytosterol they can convert to cholesterol (Behmer et al., 1999b). This does not mean that they must have a diet consisting only of sitosterol, but results from experiments where foods contained mixtures of sterols indicate that their capacity to spare cholesterol is much reduced compared to cockroaches (Lasser and Clayton, 1966) and hide beetles (Clark and Bloch, 1959a). Unfortunately the early findings in cockroaches and hide beetles, plus work on flies slightly later (Cooke and Sang, 1970), led most researchers to believe that sterol sparing mechanisms were probably common in insects. While very few studies have explicitly explored this ability in insects, the work on grasshoppers, plus a study using H. zea (Nes et al., 1997), suggest that such an ability may be highly constrained in generalist mandibulate insect herbivores. Perhaps a need to maintain high cholesterol levels partially explains cannibalistic behavior that is observed in some phytophagous insects. There is good evidence in humans that plant sterols can inhibit the process of carcinogenesis and reduce the risk of developing certain cancers (Rao and Korathkar, 1997). Likewise, studies with insects have shown that sterol nutrition can influence an insect’s ability to deal with plant defences and viruses. For example, Bloem et al. (1989) showed that the addition of tomatine to the diet of H. zea significantly reduced growth and food utilization in a linear dose-dependent fashion. However, when they added equimolar
56
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
cholesterol to the same diet, growth and food utilization levels in H. zea returned to normal. Phytophagous insects are often observed eating plant reproductive tissues, such as petals and pollen, that are rich in cholesterol, and it would be interesting to test whether an insect, as a way of self-medicating, might select a diet rich in cholesterol after ingesting tomatine. Dietary sterols can also affect attacking viruses, as demonstrated by MacDonald and Ritter (1988). They found that the sterols in a single-nucleocapsid nuclear polyhedrosis virus (HzSNPV) were similar to those of H. zea, the host insect, and that the HzSNPV isolated from the larvae fed 5-, 0-, or 5,7-sterols contained primarily cholesterol, cholestanol or 7-dehydrocholesterol, respectively. Theirs was the first study to report an insect or animal virus containing sterols other than cholesterol or desmosterol. They also found that dietary sterol influenced virulence, and that the LD50 of viruses originating from insects reared on a lathosterol diet was lower compared with those collected from insects reared on diets containing cholesterol, cholestanol or ergosterol. Ritter (1988) also examined the effects of dietary sterols on an entomogenous nematode. She reared Steinernema feltiae on a diet supplemented with various sterols and found that development was good on 5-, 7- and 0-sterols, but suffered on diets containing 5,7- or 22-sterols. However, when cholesterol was added to the 5,7-sterol diet, growth recovered to normal. Perhaps in some insects, maintaining a specific sterol tissue profile might provide a novel form of resistance against nematodes. Little is known about how dietary sterol of an insect host influences ectoparasitic mites, but the neutral sterol profile of Varroa jacobsoni was found to match that of its honey bee host, Apis mellifera (Feldlaufer and Hartfelder, 1997). Surprisingly, V. jacobsoni is unable to convert dietary sterols to cholesterol, yet it still produces significant amounts of C27 ecdysteroids (Feldlaufer and Hartfelder, 1997).
6
Applied implications and evolution of sterol metabolic constraints
Billions of dollars are spent throughout the world each year trying to reduce the impact of insect herbivores on food crops, yet insect herbivores continue to cause severe problems and at the same time are capable of rapidly evolving resistance to commonly used pesticides. Designing control methods around insect sterol metabolic constraints may, however, provide a unique and powerful approach that specifically targets insects, while leaving non-target organisms, especially vertebrates, unaffected. Recent advances in biochemical and genetic approaches now make it possible to manipulate the sterol compositions of plants to examine how such modifications affect insect growth and development. For example, Costet et al. (1987) used a fungicide to modify the sterol composition of wheat (Costet et al., 1987) while others
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
57
(Corbin et al., 2001; Nes et al., unpublished data) have engineered plants by introducing foreign genes of the sterol pathway. This can generate a modified sterol composition of non-utilizable sterols, such as increased levels of 4-methyl intermediates or side chain olefins such as ergosta-5,23-dienol. The traditional approach of searching for novel dealkylation inhibitors should also lead to the discovery of highly specific insecticides that are non-toxic to plants as well as humans, e.g. targeting an inhibitor for the enzyme catalysing the 24-dealkylation pathway, which would be insect-specific. We feel that by recognizing the natural differences in sterol ecology among insect herbivores, it may be possible to design plants or prepare inhibitors for use against individual species, per se, rather than for broad-spectrum use. The evolution of insect resistance to various insecticides is documented throughout the literature, and it is interesting to speculate about whether insects could evolve rapidly in response to the presence of novel phytosterols that have been bioengineered into their host-plants. At present, no study exists exploring the evolution of sterol metabolic capacities in any insect herbivore, but Behmer and Grebenok (1998) have data that suggest genetic variation for sterol use and metabolism within populations of insect herbivores does exist. Working with P. xylostella, they found lower survival and reduced performance for larvae reared on stigmasterol diets compared with those reared on sitosterol-based diets. Additionally, within the stigmasterol population, variation existed among individuals in larval and pupal development time, mass gain and fecundity. This was a key finding because it indicated that the genetic variation existed upon which selective pressure could act. Somewhat surprisingly, evidence was found suggesting that selection may already be occurring in the second-generation stigmasterol-reared caterpillars. For example, larval and development time was reduced compared with the first generation caterpillars, and there was an increase in both the number of viable eggs produced and in the overall percent viability in the second generation. It would have been interesting with measure various performance measurements over successive generations on the stigmasterol diet to see whether the responses would, after sufficient time, be similar to control reared insects. Additionally, it would be interesting to see, through the application of quantitative genetics methods, whether there were any costs associated with having evolved novel sterol use and metabolic capabilities.
7
Conclusions
It remains a mystery why insects, as well as other arthropods, have lost the ability to synthesize cholesterol, especially considering its fundamental role in many biological processes. Without doubt we have come a long way in our understanding of sterol requirements and metabolism in insects, but a more systematic approach is needed if we are to fully comprehend the relationship
58
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
between insects, particularly phytophagous ones, and their dietary sterols. In this regard we advocate the use of a phylogenetic framework as the guiding principle for selecting groups of insects for future studies on sterol metabolism, and where possible, sterol use. Our hope is that this will lead to the discovery of the type and amount of sterols that are species-specific and host-specific, and that it will shed light on their origins and evolution. In particular we advocate targeting insect groups that show transitions from phytophagy to predaceous lifestyles, followed by phytophagy arising secondarily. This is because such groups provide independent contrasts to study the loss and/or gains of dealkylating ability. We are also starting to gain a greater appreciation for how insects use sterols once they are ingested, and the mechanisms which are employed to regulate their intake, metabolism, transport and distribution within and between different tissues and organelles. However, a stronger foundation in our understanding of the metabolic pathway by which insects generate cholesterol is needed if we are to understand how cholesterol homeostasis in insects is achieved. The role of sterols in cellular signalling processes should also be characterized, and questions of regulation of enzyme activities and gene expression in response to development, and to environment, need to be examined, preferably by way of a comparative approach. Studies exploring how insect sterol physiology interfaces with ecology are in their infancy, but there is evidence to suggest that such interactions could be playing a role in modifying behavior, especially food selection in phytophagous insects. For example, how important are phytosterols in determining patterns of feeding among generalist phytophagous insects? To what extent must generalist insects with sterol metabolic constraints limit their intake of unsuitable phytosterols, and what amounts are tolerable? Are sterols limiting for phytophagous insects, either during development or for reproduction? Perhaps a greater understanding of the relationship between sterols and insects will shed new light on how insect–plant interactions are shaped. Insect sterol metabolic constraints also represent a unique opportunity for bioengineering, and offer a highly target-specific approach to pest management. One of the immediate challenges is to elaborate the specific details, enzymologically and otherwise, of the metabolism of sterols and to identify sites in the pathway, or in absorption/transport, that can be targeted for rational drug design. It is also our hope that generating transgenic plants with modified sterol compositions, such as alterations in the intermediate to endproduct ratios, or specific modifications in the 24-alkyl sterol side chain structures, could be used to study plant–insect interactions, including the evolution of sterol metabolic capabilities. The study of insect sterol nutrition and physiology is a compelling enterprise, and we think that future studies on sterol use in insects will continue to reveal new and fascinating discoveries, with important implications at both the basic and applied level.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
59
Acknowledgements We are most thankful to James Warbrick-Smith, Angela Douglas and Stephen J. Simpson for their feedback on the manuscript. Many thanks also to Naomi Behmer for her help in finding and ordering obscure references from both the Radcliffe Science Library (Oxford University) and the British Library, and for reading various drafts of the manuscript. This research has been supported by grants from the NSF (MCB 0115401), Asgrow seed company and Monsanto to W.D.N.
References Agarwal, H. C. (1970). Sterol requirements of the beetle Trogoderma. J. Insect Physiol. 16, 2023–2026. Akihisa, T., Shimizu, N., Ghosh, P., Thakur, S., Rosenstein, F. U., Tamura, T. and Matsumoto, T. (1987). Sterols of the Cucurbitaceae. Phytochem. 26, 1693–1700. Akihisa, T., Kokke, W. C. M. C. and Tamura, T. (1991). Naturally occurring sterols and related compounds from plants. In: Physiology and Biochemistry of Sterols (eds. Patterson, G. W., and Nes, W. D.), pp. 172–228. Champaign, IL: American Oil Chemists’ Society. Aldrich, J. R., Kelly, T. J. and Woods, C. W. (1982). Larval moulting hormone of trichophoran Hemiptera-Heteroptera: makisterone A, not 20-hydroxyecdysone. J. Insect Physiol. 28, 857–861. Alexandra, C., Lecourtois, M. and Vincent, J-P. (1999). Wingless and Hedgehog pattern Drosophila denticel belts by regulating the production of short-range signals. Development 126, 5689–5698. Ba, A., Guo, D., Norton, R. A., Phillips, S. A. and Nes, W. D. (1995). Developmental differences in the sterol composition of Solenopsis invicta. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 29, 1–9. Baker, J. E. (1974). Differential sterol utilization by larvae of Sitophilus oryzae and Sitophilus granarius. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 67, 591–594. Beck, S. D., Lilly, J. H. and Stauffer, J. F. (1949). Nutrition of European corn borer, Pyrausta nubilalis (Hbn.). I. Development of a satisfactory purified diet for larval growth. Ann. Ent. Soc. Am. 42, 483–496. Beenakkers, A. M. T., van der Horst, D. J. and van Marrewijk, W. J. A. (1985). Insect lipids and their role in physiological processes. Prog. Lipid Res. 24, 19–67. Behmer, S. T. and Elias, D. O. (1999a). The nutritional significance of sterol metabolic constraints in the generalist grasshopper Schistocerca americana. J. Insect Physiol. 45, 339–348. Behmer, S. T. and Elias, D. O. (1999b). Phytosterol structure and its impact on feeding behaviour in the generalist grasshopper Schistocerca americana. Physiol. Entomol. 24, 18–27. Behmer, S. T. and Elias, D. O. (2000). Sterol metabolic constraints as a factor contributing to the maintenance of diet mixing in grasshoppers (Orthoptera: Acrididae). Physiol. and Biochem. Zool. 73, 219–230. Behmer, S. T. and Grebenok, R. J. (1998). Impact of sterols on life-history traits of a caterpillar. Physiol. Entomol. 23, 165–175.
60
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Behmer, S. T., Elias, D. O. and Bernays, E. A. (1999a). Post-ingestive feedbacks and associative learning regulate the intake of unsuitable sterols in a generalist grasshopper. J. Exp. Biol. 202, 739–748. Behmer, S. T., Elias, D. O. and Grebenok, R. J. (1999b). Phytosterol metabolism and absorption in the generalist grasshopper, Schistocerca americana (Orthoptera: Acridiae). Arch Insect Biochem. Physiol. 42, 13–25. Beilby, J. P. (1980). Fatty acid and sterol composition of ungerminated spores of the vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus Acaulospora laevis. Lipids 15, 949–952. Beilby, J. P. and Kidby, D. K. (1980). Sterol composition of ungerminated and germinated spores of the vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus, Glomus caledonius. Lipids 15, 375–378. Bergmann, W. (1957). The plant sterols. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 4, 383–426. Bergmann, E. D. and Levinson, Z. H. (1966). Utilization of steroid derivatives by larvae of Musca vicina (Macq.) and Dermestes maculatus Deg. J. Insect Physiol. 12, 77–81. Bernays, E. A. (1992). Plant sterols and host-plant affliliations of herbivores. In: InsectPlant Interactions (ed. Bernays, E. A.), Vol. 4, pp. 45–57. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Billheimer, J. T., Tavani, D. M. and Ritter, K. S. (1983). Acyl coenzyme A: Cholesterol acyltransferase activity in fat body and intestinal microsomes of Heliothis zea. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 76B, 127–132. Bitmann, R. (1997). Has nature designed the cholesterol side chain for optimal interaction with phospholipids. Subcellular Biochem. 28, 145–171. Bloem, K. A., Kelley, K. C. and Duffey, S. S. (1989). Differential effect of tomatine and its alleviation by cholesterol on larval growth and efficiency of food utilization in Heliothis zea and Spodoptera exigua. J. Chem. Ecol. 15, 387–398. Borror, D. J., Triplehorn, C. A. and Johnson, N. F. (1989). An Introduction to the Study of Insects, 6th edition, p. 875. Orlando, FL: Harcourt Brace & Company. Brown, D. A. and London, E. (1997). Structure of detergent-resistant membrane domains: Does phase separation occur in biological membranes?. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 240, 1–7. Brust, M. and Fraenkel, G. (1955). The nutritional requirements of the larvae of a blowfly, Phormia regina (Meig.). Physiol. Zool. 28, 186–204. Budowski, P., Ishaaya, I. and Katz, M. (1967). Growth inhibition of Dermestes maculatus by phytosterols. J. Nutrition 91, 201–207. Campbell, B. C. and Nes, W. D. (1983). A reappraisal of sterol biosynthesis and metabolism in aphids. J. Insect Physiol. 29, 149–156. Canavoso, L. E. and Wells, M. A. (2001). Role of lipid transport particle in lipid delivery of diacylglycerol from midgut to lipophorin in larval Manduca sexta. Insect Biochem. Molec. Biol. 31, 783–790. Canavoso, L. E., Yun, H. K., Jouni, Z. E. and Wells, M. A. (2003). Lipid transfer particle mediates the delivery of diacylglycerol from HDLp to fat body in larval Manduca sexta. Insect Biochem. Molec. Biol. (in press). Chambers, P., Sword, G., Angel, J., Behmer, S. and Bernays, E. A. (1996). Foraging by generalist grasshoppers: dietary mixing and the role of crypsis. Animal Behaviour 52, 155–165. Champagne, D. and Bernays, E. A. (1991). Phytosterol unsuitability as a factor mediating food aversion learning in the grasshopper Schistocerca americana. Physiol. Entomol. 16, 391–400. Charlet, M., Roussel, J-P., Rinternecht, E., Berchtold, J-P. and Costet, M-F. (1988). Developmental and morphogenetic alterations in larvae of Locusta migratoria reared on plant diet with a selectively modified sterol profile. J. Insect Physiol. 34, 787–796.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
61
Chauvin, R. (1949). Les ste´rols dan le re´gime alimentaire de certains Orthopte`res. C.R. Acad. Sci. 229, 902–903. Chino, H. (1985). Lipid transport: Biochemistry of hemolymph lipophorin. In: Comprehensive Insect Physiology, Biochemistry and Pharmacology (eds. Kerkut, G. A., and Gilbert, L. I.), Vol. 10, pp. 115–135. Oxford: Pergamon Press. Chippendale, G. M. (1971). Lipid requirements of the angoumois grain moth, Sitotroga cerealella. J. Insect Physiol. 17, 2169–2177. Chippendale, G. M. and Reddy, G. P. V. (1972a). Polyunsaturated fatty acid and sterol requirements of the southwestern corn borer, Diatreae grandiosella. J. Insect Physiol. 18, 305–316. Chippendale, G. M. and Reddy, G. P. V. (1972b). Dietary sterols: Role in larval feeding behaviour of the southwestern corn borer, Diatraea grandiosella. Experientia 28, 485–486. Chiu, P-L., Patterson, G. W. and Salt, T. A. (1988). Sterol composition of Pteridophytes. Phytochem. 27, 819–822. Chiu, S. F. and McKay, C. M. (1939). Nutritional studies of the confused flour beetle (Tribolium confusum Duval) and the bean weevil (Acanthoscelides obtectus (Say)). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 32, 164–170. Chu, H., Norris, D. M. and Kok, L. T. (1970). Pupation requirements of the beetle, Xyleborus ferrugineus: Sterols other than cholesterol. J. Insect Physiol. 16, 1379–1387. Clark, A. J. and Bloch, K. (1959a). Function of sterols in Dermetes vulpinus. J. Biol. Chem. 234, 2583–2588. Clark, A. J. and Bloch, K. (1959b). Conversion of ergosterol to 22-dehydrocholesterol in Blatella germanica. J. Biol. Chem. 234, 2589–2594. Clark, E. W. (1973). Hylobius pales: A meridic larval diet using sitosterol. J. Econ. Entomol. 66, 841–843. Clayton, R. B. (1964). The utilization of sterols by insects. J. Lipid Res. 5, 3–19. Clayton, R. B., Hinkle, P. C., Smith, D. A. and Edwards, A. M. (1964). The intestinal absorption of cholesterol, its esters and some related sterols and analogues in the roach, Eurycotis floridana. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 11, 333–350. Cooke, J. and Sang, J. H. (1970). Utilization of sterols by larvae of Drosophila melanogaster. J. Insect Physiol. 16, 801–812. Cooke, J. and Sang, J. H. (1972). Physiological genetics of melanotic tumours in Drosophila melanogaster, Genet. Res. Camb. 20, 317–329. Corbin, D. R., Grebenok, R. J., Ohnmeiss, T. E., Greenplate, J. T. and Purcell, J. P. (2001). Expression and chloroplast targeting of cholesterol oxidase in transgenic tobacco plants. Plant Physiol. 126, 1116–1128. Costet, M. F., Achouri, M. E., Charlet, M., Lanot, R., Benveniste, P. and Hoffmann, J. A. (1987). Ecdysteroid biosynthesis and embryonic development are disturbed in insects (Locusta migratoria) reared on plant diet (Tritcum sativum) with a selectively modified sterol profile. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 84, 643–647. Dadd, R. H. (1960). The nutritional requirements of locusts - II. Utilization of sterols. J. Insect Physiol. 5, 161–168. Dadd, R. H. (1977). Qualitative requirements and utilization of nutrients: Insects. In: Handbook Series in Nutrition and Food. Section D: Nutritional Requirements (ed. Rechcigl, M., Jr.), Vol. 1, pp. 305–346. Cleveland, OH: CRC Press. Dadd, R. H. (1985). Nutrition: organisms. In: Comprehensive Insect Physiology, Biochemistry and Pharmacology (eds. Kerkut, G. A., and Gilber, L. I.), Vol. 4, pp. 313–390. Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press. Dadd, R. H. and Kleinjan, J. E. (1984). Lecithin-dependent phytosterol utilization by larvae of Culex pipiens (Diptera: Culicidae). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 77, 518–525.
62
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Dambre-Raes, H. (1976). The effect of dietary cholesterol on the development of Hylemya brassicae. J. Insect Physiol. 22, 1287–1289. Douglas, A. E. (1988). On the source of sterols in the green peach aphid, Myzus persicae, reared on holidic diets. J. Insect Physiol. 34, 403–408. Douglas, A. E. (1998). Nutritional interactions in insect-microbial symbioses: Aphids and their symbiotic bacteria Buchnera. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 43, 17–37. Dupnik, T. D. and Kamm, J. A. (1970). Development of an artificial diet for Crambus trisectus. J. Econ. Entomol. 63, 1578–1581. Dussourd, D. E., Harvis, C. A., Meinwald, J. and Eisner, T. (1991). Pheromonal advertisemet of a nuptial gift by a male moth Utetheisa ornatrix. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. (USA) 20, 9224–9227. Dutky, R. C., Robbins, W. E., Kaplanis, J. N. and Shortino, T. J. (1963). The sterol esters of housefly eggs. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 9, 251–255. Dutky, R. C., Robbins, W. E., Shortino, T. J., Kaplanis, J. N. and Vroman, H. E. (1967). The conversion of cholestanone to cholestanol by the housefly, Musca domestica L. J. Insect Physiol. 13, 1501–1510. Dwivedy, A. K. (1993). A preferential uptake of cholesterol by the brain tissue of the housefly, Musca domestica L. Experientia 39, 272–273. Earle, N. W., Lambremont, N., Burks, M. L., Slatten, B. H. and Bennett, A. F. (1967). Conversion of -sitosterol to cholesterol in the boll weevil and the inhibition of larval development by the two asa sterols. J. Econ. Entomol. 60, 291–293. Erwin, T. L. (1982). Tropical forests: Their richness in Coleoptera and other arthropod species. Coleopterists Bull. 36, 74–75. Feldlaufer, M. F. and Svoboda, J. A. (1991). Sterol utilizaton and ecdysteroid content in the house fly, Musca domestica (L.). Insect Biochem. 21, 53–56. Feldlaufer, M. F., Svoboda, J. A., Aldrich, J. R. and Lusby, W. R. (1986). The neutral sterols of Megalotomus quinquespinosus (Say) (Hemiptera: Alydidae) and identification of makisterone A as the major free ecdysteroid. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 3, 423–430. Feldlaufer, M. F., Buchmann, S. L., Lusby, W. R., Weirich, G. F. and Svoboda, J. A. (1993). Neutral sterols and ecdysteroids of the solitary cactus bee Diadasia rinconis Cockerell (Hymenoptera: Anthophoridae). Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 23, 91–98. Feldlaufer, M. F., Weirich, G. F., Imberski, R. B. and Svoboda, J. A. (1995). Ecdysteroid production in Drosophila melanogaster reared on defined diets. Insect Biochem. Molec. Biol. 25, 709–712. Feldlaufer, M. F., Harrison, D. J. and Wilzer, K. R. (1997). Comparison of the dietary and tissue sterols of the greater wax moth, Galleria mellonella (L). Apidologie 28, 85–90. Fogleman, J. C., Duperret, S. M. and Kircher, H. W. (1986). The role of phytosterols in host plant utilization by cactophillic Drosophila. Lipids 21, 92–96. Fraenkel, G. and Blewett, M. (1943). The sterol requirements of several insects. Biochem. J. 37, 692–695. Fraenkel, G. and Blewett, M. (1946). The dietics of the clothes moth, Tineola bisselliella Hum. J. Expt. Biol. 22, 156–161. Fraenkel, G., Reid, J. A. and Blewett, M. (1941). The sterol requirements of the larva of the beetle, Dermestes vulpinus Fabr. Biochem. J. 35, 712–720. Galford, J. R. (1972). Some basic nutritional requirements of smaller European elm bark beetle larvae. J. Econ. Entomol. 65, 681–684. Gibson, J. M., Majumder, M. S. I., Mendis, A. H. W. and Rees, H. H. (1983). Absence of phytosterol dealkylation and identification of the major ecdysteroid as
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
63
makisterone A in Dysdercus fasciatus (Heteroptera, Phrrhocoridae). Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 1, 105–120. Gilbert, L. I., Rybcznski, R. and Warren, J. T. (2002). Control and biochemical nature of the ecdysteroidogenic pathway. Annu. Rev. Ent. 47, 883–916. Gingrich, R. E. (1964). Nutritional studies on screw-worm larvae with chemically defined media. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 57, 351–360. Goldberg, L. and De Meillon, B. (1948). The nutrition of the larva of Ae¨des aegyptii Linnaeus. Biochem. J. 43, 372–377. Goodfellow, R. D., Barnes, F. J. and Graham, W. J., Jr (1971). Dietary sterol effects on mevalonate kinase activity in axenic and non-axenic Sarcophaga bullata (Diptera). J. Insect Physiol. 17, 1625–1635. Gordon, H. T. (1959). Minimal nutritional requirements of the german roach, Blatella germanica L. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 77, 290–351. Guo, D., Venkatramesh, M. and Nes, W. D. (1995). Developmental regulation of sterol biosynthesis in Zea mays. Lipids 30, 203–219. Guo, D., Jia, Z. and Nes, W. D. (1996). Stereochemistry of hydrogen migration from C-24 to C-25 during phytosterol biomethylation. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 118, 8507–8508. Hamamura, Y. (1970). The substances that control the feeding behavior and the growth of the silkworm Bombyx mori L. In: Control of Insect Behavior by Natural Products (eds. Wood, D. L., Silverstein, R. M., and Nakajima, M.), pp. 55–80. London: Academic Press. Hamamura, Y., Hayashiya, K., Naito, K., Matsuura, K. and Nishida, J. (1962). Food selection by silkworm larvae. Nature 194, 754–755. Heed, W. B. and Kircher, H. W. (1965). Unique sterol in the ecology and nutrition of Drosophila pachea. Science 149, 758–761. Herbert, E. W., Jr, Svoboda, J. A., Thompson, M. J. and Shimanuki, H. (1980). Sterol utilization in honey bees fed a synthetic diet: Effects on brood rearing. J. Insect Physiol. 26, 287–289. Heywood, V. H. (1993). Flowering Plants of the World. pp. 335. New York: Oxford University Press. Hobson, R. P. (1935a). CCXXXVI. On a fat-soluble growth factor required by blow-fly larvae. II. Identity of the growth factor with cholesterol. Biochem. J. 29, 2023–2026. Hobson, R. P. (1935b). CLVI. On fat-soluble growth factor required by blow-fly larvae. I. distribution and properties. Biochem. J. 29, 1292–1296. House, H. L. (1954). Nutritional studies with Pseudocarcophaga affinis (Fall.), a dipterous parasite of the spruce budworm, Choristoneura fumiferana (Clem.). IV. Effects of ribonucleic acid, glutathione, dextrose, a salt mixture, cholesterol, and fats. Can. J. Zool. 32, 358–365. Hsiao, T. H. and Fraenkel, G. (1968). The influence of nutrient chemicals on the feeding behaviour of the Colorado Potato Beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). Ann. Ent. Soc. Am. 61, 44–54. Ichimasa, Y. (1976). Sterol accumulation in developing ovaries of the silkworm Bombyx mori in relation to the diapause hormone. J. Insect Physiol. 22, 1071–1074. Ikekawa, N., Morisaki, M. and Fujimoto, Y. (1993). Sterol metabolism in insects: Dealkylation of phytosterol to cholesterol. Acc. Chem. Res. 26, 139–146. Ingham, P. W., Taylor, A. M. and Nakano, Y. (1991). Role of Drosophila patched gene in positional signalling. Nature 353, 184–190. Ishii, S. (1951). Studies on the host-plants of the cowpea weevil (Callosobruchus chinensis L.) IX. On the relation between chemical constitutions of sterols and the development of larva. Botyu Kagaku 16, 83–90.
64
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Ishii, S. and Urushibara, H. (1954). On fat and water soluble growth factors required by the rice stem borer, Chilo simplex. Bull. Nat. Inst. Agr. Sci. Japan, Ser. C. 4, 109–133. Ito, T. (1961). Sterol requirements of the silkworm, Bombyx mori. Nature 191, 882–883. Ito, T., Kawashima, K., Nakahara, M., Nakanishi, K. and Terahara, A. (1964). Effects of sterols on feeding and nutrition of the silkworm, Bombyx mori L. J. Insect Physiol. 10, 225–238. Ito, T. and Nakasone, S. (1966). Nutrition of the silkworm, Bombyx mori, XIII. Nutritive effects of fatty acids. Bull. Sericult. Exp. Station Tokyo 21, 385–400. Joshi, M. and Agarwal, H. C. (1976). Cholesterol absorption in the roach, Periplaneta americana. Entomon 1, 93–100. Joshi, M. and Agarwal, H. C. (1977). Site of cholesterol absorption in some insects. J. Insect Physiol. 23, 403–404. Jouni, Z. E., Zamora, J. and Wells, M. A. (2002a). Absorption and tissue distribution of cholesterol in Manduca sexta. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 49, 167–175. Jouni, Z. E., Yun, H. K. and Wells, M. A. (2002b). Cholesterol efflux from larval Manduca sexta fat body in vitro: High-density lipophorin as the acceptor. J. Insect Physiol. 48, 609–618. Jouni, Z. E., Takada, N., Gazard, J., Maekawa, H., Wells, M. A. and Tsuchida, K. (2003). Transfer of cholesterol and diacylglycerol from lipophorin to Bombyx mori ovarioles in vitro: Role of the lipid transfer particle. Insect Biochem Mol. Biol. 33, 145–153. Kaplanis, J. N., Monroe, R. E., Robbins, W. E. and Louloudes, S. J. (1963). The fate of dietary H3- -sitosterol in the adult house fly. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 56, 198–201. Kaplanis, J. N., Robbins, W. E., Monroe, R. E., Shortino, T. J. and Thompson, M. J. (1965). The utilization and fate of -sitosterol in the larva of the housefly, Musca domestica L. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 251–258. Katz, M., Budowski, P. and Bondi, A. (1971). The effect of phytosterols on the growth and sterol composition of Dermestes maculatus. J. Insect Physiol. 17, 1295– 1303. Keiser, L. S. and Yazlovetski, I. G. (1988). Comparative study of sterols in the larval lacewing Chrysopa carnea and its food species. J. Evol. Biochem. Physiol. 24, 108–113. Kircher, H. W. (1982). Sterols and insects. In: Cholesterol Systems in Insects and Animals (ed. Dupont, J.), pp. 1–50. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Kircher, H. W., Rosenstein, F. U. and Fogleman, J. C. (1984). Selective uptake and lack of dealkylation of phytosterols by cactophilic species of Drosophila. Lipids 19, 235–238. Komnick, H. and Giesa, U. (1994). Intestinal absorption of cholesterol, transport in the haemolymph, and incorporation into the fat body and malpighian tubules of the larval dragonfly Aeshna cyanea. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 107A, 553–557. Krebs, K. C. and Lan, Q. (2003). Isolation and expression of a sterol carrier protein-2 gene from the yellow fever mosquito, Aedes aegypti. Insect Mol. Biol. 12, 51–60. Kristensen, N. P. (1991). Phylogeny of extant arthropods. In: Insects of Australia: A Textbook for Students and Research Workers, 2nd ed., Vol. 1, (eds. Naumann, I. D., Carne, P. B., Lawrence, J. F., Nielsen, E. S., Spradberry, J. P., Taylor, R. W., Whitten, M. J., and Littlejohn, M. J.), pp. 125–140. Carlton, Victoria: Melbourne University Press. Kuthiala, A. and Ritter, K. S. (1988). Esterification of cholesterol and cholestanol in the whole body, tissue, and frass of Heliothis zea. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 7, 237–247.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
65
Lasser, N. L. and Clayton, R. B. (1966). The intracellular distribution of sterols in Eurycotis floridana and its possible relation to subcellular membrane structure. J. Lipid Res. 7, 413–421. Lasser, N. L., Edwards, A. M. and Clayton, R. B. (1966). Distribution and dynamic state of sterols and steroids in the tissues of an insect, the roach Eurycotis floridana. J. Lipid Res. 7, 403–411. Leclercq, J. (1948). Sur les besoins en ste´rols des larves de Tenebrio molitor L. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 2, 614–617. Lee, J. C. and Bernays, E. A. (1988). Declining acceptability of a food plant for the polyphagous grasshopper Schistocerca americana: The role of food aversion learning. Physiol. Entomol. 13, 291–301. Lehrer, A. T., Dugassa-Gobena, D., Vidal, S. and Seifert, K. (2000). Transport of resistance-inducing sterols in phloem sap of barley, Z. Naturforsch. 55C, 948–952. Levinson, Z. H. (1962). The function of dietary sterols in phytophagous insects. J. Insect Physiol. 8, 191–198. Levinson, Z. H. and Gothilf, S. (1955). A semisynthetic diet for axenic growth of the carob moth Ectomyelois ceratoniae (Zell.). Riv. Parassit. 26, 19–26. Levinson, Z. H. and Bergmann, E. D. (1957). Steroid utilization and fatty acid synthesis by the larva of the housefly Musca vicina Macq. Biochem. J. 65, 254–260. Lubzens, E., Tietz, A., Pines, M. and Applebaum, S. W. (1981). Lipid accumulation in oocytes of Locusta migratoria migratorioides. Insect Biochem. 11, 323–329. Lusby, W. R., Buchmann, S. L. and Feldlaufer, M. F. (1993). Pollen sterols from three species of Sonoran cacti. Lipids 28, 469–470. Lutjohann, D., Bjorkhem, I., Beil, U. F. and von Bergmann, K. (1995). Sterol absorption and sterol balance in phytosterolemia evaluated by deuterium-labeled sterols: Effects of sitostanol treatment. J. Lipid Res. 36, 1763–1773. Macauley, S. K., Billheimer, J. T. and Ritter, K. S. (1986). Sterol substrate specificity of acyl coenzyme A: Cholesterol transferase from the corn earworm, Heliothis zea. J. Lipid Res. 27, 64–71. MacDonald, D. L. and Ritter, K. S. (1988). Effect of host sterols on the sterol composition and virulence of a nuclear polyhedrosis virus of Heliothis Zea. Lipids 23, 1107–1113. MacDonald, D. L., Nham, D. N., Cochran, W. K. and Ritter, K. S. (1990). Differences in the sterol composition of Heliothis zea fed Zea mays versus Medicago satvia. Insect Biochem. 20, 437–442. Maddison, D. R., Maddison, W. P., Schulz, K.-S., Wheeler, T. and Frumkin, J. (2001). The Tree of Life Web Project. Internet address: http://tolweb.org. Magis, N. (1954). Les besions nutritifs des larves de Tribolium confusum Duv. (Coleoptera Tenebrionidae). Bull. Ann. Soc. Entomol. Belg. 90, 49–58. Mangla, A. T. and Nes, W. D. (2000). Sterol C-methyl transferase from Prototheca wickerhamii. Mechanism, sterol specificity and inhibition. Bioorg. Med. Chem. 8, 925–936. Maurer, P., Royer, C., Mauchamp, B., Porcheron, P., Debieu, D. and Riba, G. (1991). Occurrence of 28- and 27-carbon ecdysteroids and sterols in developing worker pupae of the leaf-cutting ant Acromyrmex octospinosus (Reich) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae: Attini). Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 16, 1–9. Maurer, P., Debieu, D., Malosse, C., Leroux, P. and Riba, G. (1992). Sterols and symbiosis in the leaf-cutting ant Acromyrmex octospinosus (Reich) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae: Attini). Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 20, 13–21. Maurer, P., Girault, J.-P., Larcheveque, M. and Lafont, R. (1993). 24-epi-makisteroneA (not makisterone-A) is the major ecdysteroid in the leaf-cutting ant Acromyrmex
66
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
octospinosus (Reich) (Hymenoptera, Formicidae: Attini). Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 23, 29–35. McKennis, H. (1947). The growth-promoting activity of cholesterol and related compounds in black carpet beetle larvae. J. Biol. Chem. 167, 645–654. Mondy, N. and Corio-Costet, M. (2000). The response of the grape berry moth (Lobesia botrana) to a dietary phytopathogenic fungus (Botrytis cinerea): The significance of fungus sterols. J. Insect Physiol. 46, 1557–1564. Monroe, R. E. (1959). Role of cholesterol in house fly reproduction. Nature 184, 1513. Monroe, R. E., Kaplanis, J. N. and Robbins, W. E. (1961). Sterol storage and reproduction in the house fly. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 54, 537–539. Myant, N. B. (1981). The Biology of Cholesterol and Related Steroids. pp. 910. London: William Heinemann Medical Books Ltd. Nayar, J. K. and Fraenkel, G. (1962). The chemical basis of hostplant selection in the silkworm, Bombyx mori (L.). J. Insect Physiol. 8, 505–525. Nes, W. D. (1987). Metabolism and function of sterols in Phytophthora cactorum. J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 64, 634–634. Nes, W. D. (1990). Control of sterol biosynthesis and its importance to developmental regulation and evolution. Rec. Adv. Phytochem. 24, 283–327. Nes, W. D. and Lee, P. H. (1990). Evidence for separate intermediates in the biosynthesis of 24b-methylsterol end products by Gibberella fujikuroi. Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1042, 119–125. Nes, W. D. and Schmidt, J. O. (1988). Isolation of 25(27)-dehydrolanost- -enol from Cerens gigantens and its biosynthetic implications. Phytochem. 27, 1705–1708. Nes, W. D., Xu, S. and Haddon, W. F. (1988a). Evidence for similarities and differences in the biosynthesis of fungal sterols. Steroids 53, 533–558. Nes, W. D., Norton, R. A., Parish, E. J., Meenan, A. and Popja´k, G. (1988b). Concerning the role of 24,25-dihydrolanosterol and lanostanol in sterol biosynthesis by cultured cells. Steroids 53, 461–475. Nes, W. D., Norton, R. A. and Benson, M. (1992). Carbon-13 NMR studies on sitosterol biosynthesized from [13C]mevalonates. Phytochem. 31, 811–811. Nes, W. D., Lopez, M., Zhou, W., Guo, D., Dowd, P. F. and Norton, R. A. (1997). Sterol utilization and metabolism by Heliothis zea. Lipids 32, 1317–1323. Nes, W. D., Marshall, J. A., Zhou, W., Le, H. and Dennis, A. L. (1998). Mechanismbased active site modification of sterol methyl transferase by tritium-labeled 26-homocholesta-8-14-24-trein-26-yn-3 -ol. Tetrahedron Lett. 39, 8575–8578. Nes, W. R. and Nes, W. D. (1980). Lipids in Evolution. pp. 244. New York: Plenum Press. Nes, W. R. and McKean, M. L. (1977). Biochemistry of Steroids and Other Isopentenoids. pp. 690. Baltimore, MD: University Park Press. Nes, W. R., Sekula, B. C., Nes, W. D. and Adler, J. H. (1978). The functional importance of structural features of ergosterol in yeast. J. Biol. Chem. 253, 6218–6225. Nes, W. R., Adler, J. H., Billheimer, J. T., Erickson, K. A., Joseph, J. M., Landrey, J. R., Maraccio-Joseph, R., Ritter, K. S. and Conner, R. L. (1982). A comparison of the biological properties of androst-5-en-3 -ol, a series of (20R)-n-alkylpregn5-en-3 -ols and 21-isopentylcholesterol with those of cholesterol. Lipids 17, 257–262. Noda, H. and Koizumi, Y. (2003). Sterol biosynthesis by symbionts: cytochrome P450 sterol C-22 desaturase genes from yeastlike symbiotes of rice planthoppers and anobiid beetles. Insect Biochem. Mol. Biol. 33, 649–658. Noland, J. L. (1954). Sterol metabolism in insects. I. Utilization of cholesterol derivatives by the cockroach Blattella germanica L. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 48, 370–379.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
67
Norris, D. M., Baker, J. M. and Chu, H. M. (1969). Symbiotic interrelationships between microbes and ambrosia beetles. III. Ergosterol as the source of sterol to the insect. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 62, 413–414. Ostlund, R. E., Jr. (2002). Phytosterols in human nutrition. Annu. Rev. Nutr. 22, 533–549. Ostlund, R. E., Jr, McGill, J., Zeng, C-M, Covey, D. F. and Stearns, J. (2002). Gastrointestinal absorption and plasma kinetics of soy 5-phytosterols and phytostanols in humans. Am. J. Physiol. Endocrinol. Metab. 282, E911–E916. Parker, S. R. and Nes, W. D. (1992). Regulation of sterol biosynthesis and its phylogenetic implications. ACS Symp. Ser. 497, 110–145. Patterson, G. W. (1994). Phylogenetic distribution of sterols. In: Isopentenoids and Other Natural Products: Evolution and Function (ed. Nes, W. D.), pp. 91–107. Washington DC: American Chemical Society. Pausch, R. D. and Fraenkel, G. (1966). The nutrition of the larva of the oriental rat flea Xenopsylla cheopis (Rothschild). Physiol. Zool. 39, 202–222. Popja´k, G., Edmond, J., Anet, F. A. L. and Easton, N. R., Jr (1977). Carbon-13 NMR studies on cholesterol biosynthesized from [13C]mevalonates. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 99, 931–935. Porter, J. A., Young, K. E. and Beachy, P. A. (1996). Cholesterol modification of hedgehog signaling proteins in animal development. Science 274, 255–259. Prestwich, G. D., Shieh, H. M. and Gayen, A. K. (1983). Side chain modified sterols as probes into insect molting hormone metabolism. II. Synthesis of monofluorocholesterols. Steroids 41, 79–94. Prestwich, G. D., Yamaoka, R., Phirwa, S. and Depalma, A. (1984). Isolation of 2fluorocitrate produced by in vivo dealkyation of 29-fluorostigmasterol in an insect. J. Biol. Chem. 259, 1022–1026. Rao, A. V. and Korathkar, R. (1997). Anticarcinogenic effects of saponins and phytosterols. In: ACS Symposium Series 662: Antinurients and Phytochemicals in Food (ed. Shahidi, F.), pp. 313–324. Washington DC: American Chemical Society. Rasmussen, S. (1956). On the significance of cholesterol and yeast extract in the diet of larvae of house longhorn beetle (Hylotrupes bajulus). Oikos 7, 243–250. Rasmussen, S. (1958). On the response of Hylotrupes bajulus larvae to doses of cholesterol and other sterols. Oikos 9, 211–220. Rath, R., Singhal, R., Goel, V. and Agarwal, H. C. (1993). In vivo and in vitro metabolism of sitosterol in Heliothis armigera (Hubner) and Locusta migratoria L. Indian J. Exp. Biol. 31, 699–703. Richmond, J. A. and Thomas, H. A. (1975). Hylobius pales: Effect of dietary sterols on development and on sterol content of somatic tissue. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 68, 329–332. Rietveld, A., Neutz, S., Simons, K. and Eaton, S. (1999). Association of sterol- and glycolphosphatidylinositol-linked proteins with Drosophila raft lipid microdomains. J. Biol. Chem. 274, 12049–12054. Ritter, K. S. (1984). Metabolism of 0-, 5-, and 7-sterols by larvae of Heliothis zea. Arch. Insect Biochem Physiol. 1, 281–296. Ritter, K. S. (1986). Utilization of 5,7- and 8-sterols by larvae of Heliothis zea. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 3, 349–362. Ritter, K. S. (1988). Steinernema feltiae ( ¼ Neoaplectana carpocapsae): effects of sterols and hypolipidemic agents on development. Experimental Parasitology 67, 257–267. Ritter, K. S. and Johnson, J. A. (1991). Effects of host sterols on the development and sterol composition of Microplitis demolitor (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) in Heliothis zea (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 84, 79–86.
68
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Ritter, K. S. and Nes, W. R. (1981a). The effects of cholesterol on the development of Heliothis zea. J. Insect Physiol. 27, 175–182. Ritter, K. S. and Nes, W. R. (1981b). The effects of the structure of sterols on the development of Heliothis zea. J. Insect Physiol. 27, 419–424. Ritter, K. S., Weiss, B. A., Norrbom, A. L. and Nes, W. R. (1982). Identification of 5,7-24-methylene- and methylsterols in the brain and whole body of Atta cephalotes isthmicola. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 71B, 345–349. Robbins, W. E. (1963). Studies on the utilization, metabolism and function of sterols in the housefly, Musca domestica. In: Radiation and Radioisotopes Applied to Insects of Agricultural Importance, pp. 269–280. Proceedings of a Symposium, Athens, 22–26 April 1963. Vienna: International Atomic Energy Agency. Robbins, W. E., Dutky, R. C., Monroe, R. F. and Kaplanis, J. N. (1962). The metabolism of H3- -sitosterol by the German cockroach. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 55, 102–104. Robbins, W. E., Kaplanis, J. N., Svoboda, J. A. and Thompson, M. J. (1971). Steroid metabolism in insects. Ann. Rev. Ent. 16, 53–72. Rock, G. C. (1969). Sterol and water-soluble vitamin requirements for larvae of the red-banded leaf roller, Argyrotaenia velutinana. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 62, 611–613. Rowell, C. H. F. and Flook, P. K. (1998). Phylogeny of the Califera and the Orthoptera as derived from ribosomal gene sequences. J. Orthop. Res. 7, 147–156. Ryan, R. O. and van der Horst, D. J. (2000). Lipid transport biochemistry and its role in energy production. Annu. Rev. Ent. 45, 233–260. Rzama, A., Dufourc, E. J. and Arreguy, B. (1994). Sterols from green and blue-green algae grown on reused waste water. Phytochem. 37, 1625–1628. Sall, C., Tsoupras, G., Kappler, C., Lagueux, M., Zachary, D., Luu, B. and Hoffman, J. A. (1983). Fate of maternal conjugated ecdysteroids during embryonic development in Locusta migratoria. J. Insect Physiol. 29, 491–507. Salt, T. A., Sihua, X., Patterson, G. W. and Adler, J. H. (1991). Diversity of sterol biosynthetic capacity in the Caryophyllidae. Lipids 26, 604–613. Sarma, P. S. and Sreenivasaya, M. (1941). Studies in insect nutrition: The nature of the fat-soluble factor. Current Sci. (India) 10, 525–526. Schaefer, C. H., Kaplanis, J. N. and Robbins, W. E. (1965). The relationship of the sterols of the Virginia pine sawfly, Neodiprion pratti Dyar, to those of two host plants, Pinus virginiana Mill and Pinus rigida Mill. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 1013–1021. Schiff, N. M. and Feldlaufer, M. F. (1996). Neutral sterols of sawflies (Symphyta): Their relationship to other Hymenoptera. Lipids 31, 441–443. Sculley, C. E. and Boggs, C. L. (1996). Mating systems and sexual division of foraging effort affect puddling behaviour by butterflies. Ecol. Entomol. 21, 193–197. Seckbach, J. S., Ikan, R., Ringelberg, D. and White, D. (1993). Sterols and phylogeny of the acidophilic hot springs algae Cyanidium caldarium and Galdieria sulphuraria. Phytochem. 34, 1345–1349. Sedee, P. D. J. W. (1961). Intermediary metabolism in aseptically reared blowfly larvae, Calliphora erythrocephala (Meig.). I. Biosynthesis of squalene and cholesterol. Arch. Intern. Physiol. Biochim. 69, 284–294. Sehgal, S. S. and Agarwal, H. C. (1973). Quantitative dietary requirements of the beetle Trogoderma for cholesterol and choline. J. Insect Phsyiol. 19, 419–425. Shanks, C. H., Jr and Doss, R. P. (1987). Feeding responses by adults of five species of weevils (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) to sucrose and sterols. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 80, 41–46.
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
69
Short, J. A., Guo, D-A., Svoboda, J. A. and Nes, W. D. (1996). Mechanistic and metabolic studies of sterol 24,25-double reduction in Manduca sexta. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 31, 1–22. Silberkang, M., Havel, C. M., Friend, D. S., McCarthy, B. J. and Watson, J. A. (1983). Isoprene synthesis in isolated embryonic Drosophila cells. I. Sterol deficient eukaryotic cells. J. Biol. Chem. 258, 8503–8511. Silverman, P. H. and Levinson, Z. H. (1954). Lipid requirements of the larva of the housefly Musca vicina (Macq.) reared under non-aseptic conditions. Biochem. J. 58, 291–294. Simons, K. and Ikonen, E. (1997). Functional rafts in cell membranes. Nature 387, 569–572. Sivapalan, P. and Gnanapragasam, N. C. (1979). The influence of linoleic acid and linolenic acid on adult moth emergence of Homona coffearia from meridic diets in vitro. J. Insect Physiol. 25, 393–398. Soulages, J. L. and Wells, M. A. (1994). Lipophorin: The structure of an insect lipoprotein and its role in lipid transport in insects. Adv. Protein Chem. 45, 371–415. Southwood, T. R. E. (1973). The insect/plant relationship – an evolutionary perspective. In: Insect/Plant Relationships-R.E.S. Symposium 6 (ed. van Emden, H. F.), pp. 3–30. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications. Speight, M. R., Hunter, M. D. and Watt, A. D. (1999). Ecology of Insects: Concepts and Applications. pp. 350. Oxford: Blackwell Science Ltd. Standifer, L. N., Devys, M. and Barbier, M. (1968). Pollen sterols – a mass spectrographic survey. Phytochem. 7, 1361–1365. Strong, D. R., Lawton, J. H. and Southwood, T. R. E. (1984). Insects on Plants: Community Patterns and Mechanisms. pp. 313. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Svoboda, J. A. (1984). Insect steroids: Metabolism and function. In: Isopentenoids in Plants: Biochemistry and Function (eds. Nes, W. D., Fuller, G., and Tsai, L-S.), pp. 367–388. New York: Dekker. Svoboda, J. A. (1994). Sterol metabolism as a target for insect control. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 22, 635–641. Svoboda, J. A. (1999). Variability of metabolism and function of sterols in insects. Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol. 34, 49–57. Svoboda, J. A. and Feldlaufer, M. F. (1991). Neutral sterol metabolism in insects. Lipids 26, 614–618. Svoboda, J. A. and Lusby, W. R. (1986). Sterols of phytophagous and Omnivorous species of Hymenoptera. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 3, 13–18. Svoboda, J. A. and Lusby, W. R. (1994). Variability of sterol utilization in storedproducts insects. Experientia 50, 72–74. Svoboda, J. A. and Robbins, W. E. (1967). Conversion of -sitosterol to cholesterol blocked in an insect by hypocholesterolemic agents, Science. Wash. 156, 1637–1638. Svoboda, J. A. and Robbins, W. E. (1968). Desmosterol as a common intermediate in the conversion of a number of C28 and C29 plant sterols to cholesterol by the tobacco hornworm. Experientia 24, 1131–1132. Svoboda, J. A. and Robbins, W. E. (1971). The inhibitive effects of azasterols on sterol metabolism and growth and development in insects with special reference to the tobacco hornworm. Lipids 6, 113–119. Svoboda, J. A. and Robbins, W. E. (1978). Comparison of sterols from a phytophagous and predacious species of the family Coccinellidae. Experientia 35, 186–187. Svoboda, J. A. and Thompson, M. J. (1973). Unusual composition of sterols in a phytophagous insect, Mexican bean beetle reared on soybean plants. Lipids 9, 752–755.
70
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
Svoboda, J. A. and Thompson, M. J. (1985). Steroids. In: Comprehensive Insect Physiology, Biochemistry and Pharmacology (eds. Kerkut, G. A., and Gilbert, L. I.), Vol. 10, pp. 137–175. Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press. Svoboda, J. A. and Weirich, G. F. (1995). Sterol metabolism in the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta – a review. Lipids 30, 263–267. Svoboda, J. A., Dutky, S. R., Robbins, W. E. and Kaplanis, J. N. (1976). Sterol composition and phytosterol utilization and metabolism in the milkweed bug. Lipids 12, 318–321. Svoboda, J. A., Thompson, M. J., Robbins, W. E. and Kaplanis, J. N. (1978). Insect steroid metabolism. Lipids 13, 742–753. Svoboda, J. A., Nair, A. M. G., Agarwal, N., Agarwal, H. C. and Robbins, W. E. (1980a). The sterols of the kharpa beetle, Trogoderma granarium Everts. Experientia 35, 1454–1455. Svoboda, J. A., Nair, A. M. G., Agarwal, N. and Robbins, W. E. (1980b). Lack of conversion of C29-phytosterols to cholesterol in the kharpa beetle, Trogoderma granarium Everts. Experientia 36, 1029–1030. Svoboda, J. A., Thompson, M. J., Herbert, E. W., Shortino, T. J. and Szczepanik-van Eeuwin, P. A. (1982). Utilization and metabolism of dietary sterols in the honey bee and yellow fever mosquito. Lipids 17, 220–225. Svoboda, J. A., Herbert, E. W., Jr, Lusby, W. R. and Thompson, M. J. (1983). Comparison of sterols of pollens, honeybee workers, and prepupae from field sites. Arch. Insect Biochem Physiol. 1, 25–31. Svoboda, J. A., Lusby, W. R. and Aldrich, J. R. (1984). Neutral sterols of representatives of two groups of Hemiptera and their correlation to ecdysteroid content. Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 1, 139–145. Svoboda, J. A., Herbert, E. W., Jr, Thompson, M. J. and Feldlaufer, M. F. (1986). Selective sterol transfer in the honey bee: its significance and relationship to other hymenoptera. Lipids 21, 97–101. Svoboda, J. A., Imberski, R. B. and Lusby, W. R. (1989a). Drosophila melanogaster does not dealkylate [14C]sitosterol. Experientia 45, 983–985. Svoboda, J. A., Rees, H. H., Thompson, M. J. and Hoggard, N. (1989b). Intermediates of stigmasterol metabolism in Spodoptera littoralis. Steroids 53, 329–343. Svoboda, J. A., Feldhaufer, M. F. and Weirich, G. F. (1994). Evolutionary aspects of steroid utilization in insects. ACS Symp. Ser. 562, 126–139. Svoboda, J. A., Ross, S. A. and Nes, W. D. (1995a). Comparative studies of metabolism of 4-desmethyl, 4-monomethyl and 4,4-dimethyl sterols in Manduca sexta. Lipids 30, 91–94. Svoboda, J. A., Schiff, N. M. and Feldlaufer, M. F. (1995b). Sterol composition of three species of sawflies (Hymenoptera: Symphyta) and their dietary plant material. Experientia 51, 150–152. Thompson, M. J. (1984). Contributions of USDA scientists to the chemistry and biochemistry of steroids and other isopentenoids. In: Isopentenoids in Plants: Biochemistry and Function (eds. Nes, W. D., Fuller, G., and Tsai, L-S.), pp. 1–27. New York: Dekker. Thompson, M. J., Kaplanis, J. N., Robbins, W. E. and Svoboda, J. A. (1973). Metabolism of steroids in Insects. Adv. Lipid Res. 11, 219–265. Thompson, S. N. (1981). Brachymeria lasus and Pachycrepoideus vindemiae: sterol requirements during larval growth of two hymenopterous insect parasites reared in vitro on chemically defined media. Expt. Para. 51, 220–235. Tint, G. S., Batta, A. K., Xu, G., Shefer, S., Honda, A., Irons, M., Elias, R. and Salen, G. (1997). The Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome: A potentially fatal birth defect
INSECT STEROL NUTRITION AND PHYSIOLOGY
71
caused by a block in the last enzymatic step in cholesterol biosynthesis. Subcellular Biochem. 28, 117–144. Tsuchida, K. and Wells, M. A. (1990). Isolation and characterization of a lipoprotein receptor from the fat body of an insect. J. Biol. Chem. 265, 5761–5767. Turunen, S. (1985). Absorption. In: Comprehensive Insect Physiology, Biochemistry and Pharmacology (eds. Kerkut, G. A., and Gilber, L. I.), Vol. 4, pp. 241–277. Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press. Turunen, S. and Chippendale, G. M. (1977). Lipid absorption and transport: sectional analysis of the larval midgut of the corn borer, Diatraea grandiosella. Insect Biochem. 7, 203–208. Turunen, S. and Crailsheim, K. (1996). Lipid in sugar absorption. In: Biology of the Insect Midgut (eds. Lehane, M. J., and Billingsley, P. F.), pp. 291–320. London: Chapman and Hall. van Eijk, G. W. and Roeymans, H. J. (1982). Distribution of carotenoids and sterols in relation to the taxonomy of Taphrina and Protomyces. A. van Leeuw. J. Microbiol. 48, 257–264. Vanderzant, E. S. (1963). Nutrition of the boll weevil larva. J. Econ. Entomol. 56, 357–362. Vanderzant, E. S. and Reiser, R. (1956). Studies of the nutrition of the pink bollworm using purified casein media. J. Econ. Entomol. 49, 454–458. Volkman, J. K. (2003). Sterols in microorganisms. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 60, 495–506. Vroman, H. E., Kaplanis, J. N. and Robbins, W. E. (1964). Cholesterol turnover in the American cockroach, Periplaneta americana (L.). J. Lipid Res. 5, 418–421. Ward, G. W., Mayer, R. T., Feldlaufer, M. F. and Svoboda, J. A. (1991). Gut chitin synthase and sterols from larvae of Diaprepes abbreviatus (Coleoptera: Curculionidae). Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 18, 105–117. Weber, N. A. (1972). Gardening ants: The Attines. Mem. Am. Philos. Soc. 92, 1–146. Weete, J. D. (1973). Sterols of the fungi: Distribution and biosynthesis. Phytochem. 12, 1843–1864. Weete, J. D. and Laseter, J. L. (1974). Distribution of sterols in the fungi 1. Fungal spores. Lipids 9, 575–581. Weete, J. D., Kulifaj, M., Montant, C., Nes, W. R. and Sancholle, M. (1985). Distribution of sterols in fungi. 2. Brassicasterol in tuber and Terfezia species. Can. J. Microbiol. 31, 1127–1130. Weissenberg, M., Levy, A., Svoboda, J. A. and Ishaaya, I. (1998). The effect of some Solanum steroidal alkaloids and glycoalkaloids on larvae of the red flour beetle, Tribolium castaneum, and the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta. Phytochem. 47, 203–209. Wensler, R. J. and Dudzinski, A. E. (1972). Gustation of sugars, amino acids and lipids by larvae of the Scarabeid, Sericesthis geminata (Coleoptera). Ent. Exp. Appl. 15, 155–165. Wiklund, C., Kaitala, A., Lindorfs, V. and Abenius, J. (1993). Polyandry and its effect on female reproduction in the green-veined white butterfly Pieris napi (L.). Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 33, 25–33. Wood, T. G. and Thomas, R. J. (1973). The mutalistic association between Macrotermitinae and Termitomyces. In: Insect-Fungus Interactions (eds. Wilding, N., Collins, N. M., Hammond, P. M., and Weber, J. F.), pp. 69–92. San Diego: Academic Press. Xu, S., Norton, R. A., Crumley, F. G. and Nes, W. D. (1988). Comparison of the chromatographic properties of sterols, select additional steroids and triterpenoids: Gravity flow liquid chromatography, thin layer chromatography, gas-liquid
72
S. T. BEHMER AND W. D. NES
chromatography and high-performance liquid chromatography. J. Chromatogr. 452, 377–389. Yamada, J., Morisaki, M., Iwai, K., Hamada, H., Sato, N. and Fujimoto, Y. (1997). 24-Methyl and 24-Ethyl-24(25)-cholesterols as immediate biosynthetic precursors of 24-alkyl sterols in higher plants. Tetrahedron 53, 877–884. Yun, H. K., Jouni, Z. E. and Wells, M. A. (2002). Characterization of cholesterol transport from midgut to fat body in Manduca sexta larvae. Insect Biochem. Molec. Biol. 32, 1151–1158. Zhuang, M., Oltean, D. I., Go´mez, I., Pullikuth, A. K., Sobero´n, M., Bravo, A. and Gill, S. S. (2002). Heliothis virescens and Manduca sexta lipid rafts are involved in Cry1A toxin binding to the midgut epithelium and subsequent pore formation. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 13863–13872.
The Nutritional Physiology of Aphids Angela E. Douglas Department of Biology, University of York, PO Box 373, York, YO10 5YW, UK
1 Introduction 74 2 The diet of aphids: phloem sap 76 2.1 Phloem sap transport 76 2.2 The composition of phloem sap 79 2.3 Aphid-induced changes to phloem sap 85 3 Acquisition of phloem sap by aphids 87 3.1 Ingestion of phloem sap 87 3.2 Stylet penetration to the sieve elements 90 3.3 Aphid saliva 91 4 Processing of food in the aphid alimentary tract 92 4.1 Approaches to study food processing 93 4.2 Structural organization of the alimentary tract 94 4.3 Processing of ingested sugars 97 4.4 Processing of ingested nitrogenous compounds 102 4.5 The fate of ingested allelochemicals 104 5 Acquisition of nutrients from symbiotic micro-organisms 107 5.1 The microbiology of aphids 107 5.2 The nutritional contribution of Buchnera to aphids 109 6 Fate of nutrients acquired by aphids 112 6.1 Metabolic fate of acquired nutrients 112 6.2 Physiological fate of acquired nutrients 117 6.3 Determinants of nutrient allocation patterns 120 7 Future directions 121 7.1 Regulation of nutrient utilization 122 7.2 Comparative physiology of phloem sap feeders 125 8 Concluding comments: why study the nutritional physiology of phloem sap feeding insects 128 References 130
Abstract Plant phloem sap, the principal food of aphids, is a grossly unbalanced diet for animals, with high ratios of sugars:amino acids, non-essential:essential amino acids and K þ :Na þ and exceptionally low lipid levels. The chief digestive ADVANCES IN INSECT PHYSIOLOGY VOL. 31 ISBN 0-12-024231-1 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-2806(03)31002-1
Copyright # 2003 Elsevier Ltd All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
74
A. E. DOUGLAS
function of the alimentary tract is hydrolysis of phloem sugars, usually sucrose to glucose and fructose. Additionally, multiple complex sugars, including oligosaccharides of 20 hexose units are synthesized in the gut and these transformations contribute to the reduction in osmotic pressure of ingested phloem sap, such that the voided honeydew is isosmotic with the haemolymph. Sugars assimilated into aphid tissues are allocated principally to respiration and lipid synthesis. Aphids derive their nitrogen requirement from the phloem amino acids and symbiotic bacteria, Buchnera, which provide essential amino acids. Buchnera may also contribute to aphid nitrogen nutrition by recycling aphid waste nitrogen. Recent advances in analytical techniques and molecular biology/genomics provide the basis to explore the processes by which nutrient provisioning by Buchnera is integrated into the wider nutritional physiology of aphids and to identify the physiological traits of Hemiptera which contribute to the predisposition of these insects to evolve the phloem sap feeding habit.
1
Introduction
Insect nutritional physiology addresses the processing of ingested food and pattern of nutrient allocation in an insect. This subject seeks mechanistic explanations of physiological patterns in terms of the activity of specific digestive enzymes or gut transporters and the metabolic characteristics of specific cells or organs; and it offers mechanistic explanations for wholeorganism traits of ecological or evolutionary importance, such as food preferences, habitat requirements or life history traits of the insect. The entomological focus of this review is aphids, interpreted here as the family Aphididae (Blackman and Eastop, 1984). These insects feed principally or exclusively on the phloem sap of plants, and the nutritional physiology of phloem sap feeding insects is predicted to have unusual, possibly unique, characteristics for two linked reasons. The exceptional features of their diet The phloem sap passing more-or-less continuously through the gut of an aphid is a liquid of high osmotic pressure containing readily assimilated nutrients of a composition that is nutritionally grossly unbalanced for animals. It is only by a remarkable array of anatomical, physiological and biochemical adaptations that aphids neither shrivel, through osmotic collapse, as they feed nor die prematurely through malnutrition. The intimate symbiosis with micro-organisms All insect groups using plant sap as the principal or sole source of food have symbiotic micro-organisms, and most aphids bear bacteria of the genus Buchnera, from which they derive nutrients in short supply in phloem sap. When aphids are experimentally
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
75
deprived of their bacteria, for example by antibiotic treatment, they grow poorly and produce no viable offspring. Understanding the physiological characteristics that mediate the successful utilization of phloem sap by the aphid–bacterial symbiosis is not only of academic interest. Aphids include a number of pests of agricultural importance, especially in temperate and glasshouse crops, by both transmission of plant viruses and direct damage. Unusual or unique features of these insects are potential targets for novel approaches to control aphid pests. Although aphids are just one of several hemipteran groups which subsist principally on phloem sap (Fig. 1), they have been the focus of most physiological research on phloem-feeders. Why aphids? The principal reason is that some aphid species can be cultured very easily under laboratory conditions. The cultured aphids are parthenogenetic, viviparous females, which, although small, have a remarkable reproductive capacity. For example, an adult weighing 1 mg can generate 1 g of aphid biomass in 23 days and 1 kg in 46 days, under standard culture conditions, as a consequence of their short
FIG. 1 Aphids and other phloem-feeding insects. Aphids, i.e. members of the family Aphididae sensu (Blackman and Eastop, 1984), are one of three families in the superfamily Aphidoidea, within the suborder Sternorrhyncha. All Sternorrhyncha are small (1–10 mm in length) obligate parasites of plants and most (including the Aphididae) feed predominantly or exclusively on plant phloem sap. The Sternorrhyncha are members of the order Hemiptera, which have specialized mouthparts suitable only for liquid diets. The sister group of the Sternorrhyncha comprises the Auchenorrhyncha and Heteroptera, both of which include species that feed on phloem sap or on the cell contents of other plant cells (e.g. mesophyll cells). Other auchenorrhynchans are xylem-feeders and some heteropterans are predacious, using vertebrate blood or other animal fluids. The traditional taxonomy of the Hemiptera treats the Sternorrhyncha and Auchenorrhyncha as sister groups within the suborder Homoptera, but extensive morphological and molecular evidence favours a closer relationship of the Auchenorrhyncha with the Heteroptera than with the Sternorrhyncha (e.g. Goodchild, 1966; Campbell et al., 1995; Von Dohlen and Moran, 1995), as illustrated here.
76
A. E. DOUGLAS
larval development time (ca. 1 week) and high reproductive output (ca. 100 live offspring produced over ca. 3-week reproductive period). The parthenogenetic aphids occur naturally in the spring/summer; in temperate conditions, there is a single sexual generation in the autumn, followed by overwintering as coldhardy sexual eggs. This advantage of aphids over other phloem-feeding insects as experimental material has been compounded by the availability of, first, valuable techniques, especially chemically defined diets for nutritional studies (e.g. Dadd, 1985) and electrical recording of feeding behaviour (Tjallingii, 1995) and, second, large datasets, particularly the complete genome sequence of Buchnera in two aphid species, Acyrthosiphon pisum (Shigenobu et al., 2000) and Schizaphis graminum (Tamas et al., 2002). [Genomic data are lacking for aphids, although QTL markers are available for A. pisum (Hawthorne and Via, 2001) and the sequencing of the genome of this aphid species is under consideration.] There is a long tradition of research on the nutritional physiology of aphids (Auclair, 1963; Raven, 1983) but, to the author’s knowledge, Srivastava (1987) is the most recent review. The purpose of this article is to provide an up-to-date overview of the subject, not neglecting the pre-1981 literature that is becoming forgotten through a lack of computerized literature retrieval facilities. However, this article will not consider one important aspect of nutritional physiology, the contribution of physiological approaches to the understanding of aphid ecology, especially plant utilization patterns and life history traits, because this topic has been addressed by Dixon (1998). The opening sections of this article are structured to follow the fate of aphid food, from an overview of plant phloem sap as a diet (Section 2) to aphid acquisition of phloem sap (Section 3) and the processing of ingested sap in the aphid gut (Section 4). Section 5 explores the contribution of symbiotic micro-organisms to aphid nutrition, and the fate of nutrients acquired from both food and symbiotic micro-organisms is reviewed in Section 6. The article concludes on a speculative note by considering likely avenues of future research, including opportunities afforded by recent developments in both analytical methods and molecular biology/genomics (Section 7).
2 2.1
The diet of Aphids: phloem sap PHLOEM SAP TRANSPORT
Phloem sap mediates the bulk flow of photosynthetically fixed organic carbon compounds from ‘source tissues’ (predominantly the leaves) to ‘sink tissues’ (e.g. roots, fruits), at rates of 0.5–3 m per h (Ko¨ckenberger et al., 1997). The transport vessels are highly specialized cylindrical living cells called sieve elements, 20–30 m in diameter, 100–500 m long and aligned end-to-end.
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
77
Adjacent sieve elements are connected by a sieve plate, the pores of which are dilated plasmodesmata (i.e. between-cell connections bounded by plasma membrane). Resistance to sap flow is reduced by large-scale simplification of the cell contents (Van Bel and Knoblauch, 2000). Internal to the cell wall of mature sieve elements are the plasma membrane and a thin parietal cytoplasm containing an endomembrane system, plastids and a few mitochondria all anchored to the plasma membrane, presumably so that they maintain their position. The phloem plastids are not photosynthetically active (they may contribute to sieve plate sealing) and the mitochondria may be non-functional. The nucleus, cytoskeleton, ribosomes and other organelles are absent, and sieve elements are therefore unable to synthesize protein. Each sieve element is metabolically and genetically dependent on its sister cell, called the companion cell, to which it is connected by specialized cytoplasmic pores, known as the pore-plasmodesmal units, through which small proteins can pass (the molecular exclusion limit is 10–40 kDa) (Kempers and van Bel, 1997). Apart from this cytoplasmic link to companion cells, transport sieve elements are almost completely isolated, i.e., they approximate to leakfree pipes. The osmotic pressure in the sieve elements is 0.6–3 MPa, and the flow of phloem sap is widely accepted to be under positive pressure and driven by a greater osmotic pressure in the source tissues than the sink tissues. The implications are, first, that the concentration of phloem sap solutes in one sieve tube declines progressively with distance from the source tissue; and, second, that the rate and direction of phloem sap movement varies both with position in the plant and over time, according to the relative strength of sources and sinks. As a consequence, the nutrients available to insects feeding at different locations along one sieve tube or from different sieve tubes of one plant are not identical. Generally, the photoassimilates are loaded into the sieve element/companion cell complex in the minor veins and at the vein endings of the source tissue. However, sieve elements are absent from the tips of the veins. For example, in leaves of the potato, sieve elements extend to the seventh-order veins of the abaxial surface and sixth order veins of the adaxial surface (McCauley and Evert, 1989). According to the mass flow hypothesis of phloem translocation as originally envisaged by Mu¨nch (see Fisher, 2000), all plant cells from the site of photosynthetic fixation in the source tissues to the sieve elements and thence to the sink tissues are hydraulically connected. Many plants, including an estimated 80% of all woody species, approximate to this condition. They are called ‘symplasmic loaders’, and the photoassimilates are transferred to the sieve elements in minor veins of the source tissues via numerous plasmodesmal connections between the cells (Fig. 2). Many plants, however, have very few plasmodesmal connections between the sieve-element/companion cell complex and adjacent cells in the source tissue, and the solutes are loaded into the sieve element by uptake from the apoplast (extracellular space) across the plasma
78
A. E. DOUGLAS
FIG. 2 Long-distance transport of photoassimilates via the sieve elements of vascular plants. Sieve elements are in symplasmic connection with each other, companion cells and the sink tissue via plasmodesmata. Phloem loading at the source tissue is mediated by two alternative processes: (a) symplasmic loading: sucrose is transported symplasmically from the site of synthesis to the sieve element. In the companion cell, some of the sucrose is transformed to raffinose and other sugars of the raffinose series, which are loaded into the sieve element via the plasmodesmatal pore, but are too large for the transport via standard plasmodesmata in the reverse direction. The proposed accumulation of raffinose series oligosaccharides in the sieve element is known as polymer trapping (see Section 2.2.1 for details); and (b) apoplastic loading: sucrose is released into the apoplast in minor veins and taken up by the H þ /sucrase transporter (shown as a closed circle) located on the cell membrane of the companion cell (e.g. Arabidopsis thaliana) or sieve element (e.g. potato).
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
79
membrane. Apoplastic loading is evolutionarily more derived than symplasmic loading (Turgeon et al., 2001), and is restricted largely to herbaceous angiosperms, especially species in cold and dry climatic zones (Van Bel and Gamalei, 1992); temperate crops are generally apoplastic loaders. Some taxa display structural, and probably functional, variation in the sieve elements. Notably, the Graminae have both thick-walled sieve elements, which function principally to retrieve minerals and solutes from xylem, and thinwalled sieve elements, which mediate long-distance transport (Fritz et al., 1983). The aphid Sitobion yakini preferentially feeds from the latter (Matsiliza and Botha, 2002). 2.2
THE COMPOSITION OF PHLOEM SAP
Phloem sap is sampled by three methods: exudation from shallow incisions into the stem, exudation from cut surfaces into EDTA solution (which inhibits sieve element sealing) and from the severed stylets of aphids (Kennedy and Mittler, 1953; King and Zeevart, 1974; Peel, 1975). The last method is strongly preferred because the sap composition is not contaminated by the contents of other cell types or confounded by the plant response to wounding. Its one major drawback is that, by definition, it cannot control for possible aphidinduced changes in phloem sap content (see Section 2.3), but this is more of a problem for plant physiologists than for insect physiologists interested in phloem sap feeders. The limitations of the EDTA exudation technique are well defined (Weibull et al., 1990). The EDTA exudates provide an excellent measure of the amino acid composition and amino acid:sugar ratio, but not of either total amino acid content or sugar composition (because phloem sugars are hydrolysed by contaminating enzymes in the exudates). 2.2.1
Carbohydrates
The dominant compounds in phloem sap are carbohydrates, especially sugars. Sucrose is a major transport sugar in most plants, probably linked to its chemical stability (it is a non-reducing sugar) and low viscosity in concentrated solutions (Lucas and Madore, 1988). It accounts for 95% or more of the phloem sugars in species with apoplastic phloem loading (see Section 2.1), reaching concentrations of 0.5 M–1.5 M. This is an order of magnitude higher than in the cytoplasm of other plant cells (Winter et al., 1992), and is a consequence of the active transport of sucrose into the sieve element– companion cell complex (Ward et al., 1998) (Fig. 2). In symplasmic loading plants with sucrose as the dominant phloem sugar (e.g. Populus, Salix), the sucrose concentration is not elevated in the sieve elements relative to mesophyll cells (Turgeon and Medville, 1998). Over the diurnal cycle, the phloem sucrose
80
A. E. DOUGLAS
concentration generally varies by less than two-fold because the phloem sucrose is derived from both recently assimilated carbon and, especially at night, from starch accumulated during the day in the source tissues (Winter et al., 1992; Genger and Servaites, 1994; Kehr et al., 1998). Sucrose is not the sole phloem sugar in many plants. In particular, some taxa, notably members of the Lamiaceae and Cucurbitaceae, also transport sugars of the raffinose family, including raffinose, stachyose and higher order oligosaccharides, synthesized by the stepwise transfer of one, two or more galactose units, respectively, to the glucose moiety of sucrose. Although plants with phloem sugars of the raffinose series are generally symplasmic loaders, the raffinose sugars are loaded against a concentration gradient and, therefore, can attain high concentrations in the phloem sap. This apparent paradox has been accounted for by the polymer trapping model of Turgeon (1991), as illustrated in Fig. 2a. Polyols (sugar alcohols) are also quantitatively important phloem compounds in several families of dicots: sorbitol in Rosaceae and Plantaginaceae, galactitol ( ¼ dulcitol) in the Celestraceae and Scrophulariaceae, and mannitol in many species including members of Oleaceae and Apiaceae (Noiraud et al., 2001). As examples, the principal carbohydrates in the phloem sap of apple trees are sorbitol (65–75%) and sucrose (25–35%) (Klages et al., 2001); the concentration of mannitol in celery phloem sap is 150–300 mM, accounting for up to 60% of the total phloem carbohydrate (Hu et al., 1997); and the dominant phloem carbohydrates in Primula are an unusual seven-carbon polyol, volemitol (D-glycero-D-manno-heptitol) and sucrose (Ha¨flinger et al., 1999). The contribution of polyols to phloem carbohydrates may be particularly important during the night (Klages et al., 2001) and their absolute concentrations are elevated under drought stress and at elevated temperature in some plant species (Noiraud et al., 2001). 2.2.2
Lipids and sterols
It is widely assumed that lipids and sterols are not quantitatively important components of phloem sap. However, this is based on rather little experimental data; the comment of Ziegler (1975) ‘there are very few analyses, none of which are systematic, of the lipid content of the sieve tubes’ provides a fair description of the current literature on phloem lipids. Exceptionally, Mady et al. (2002) detected free fatty acids and, at lower concentrations, triacylglycerols, phospholipids and steryl and wax esters in EDTA exudates from oil-seed rape (Brassica napus). The dominant fatty acid was palmitic acid (16:0), appreciable amounts of lauric acid (12:0), myristic acid (14:0) and pentadecanoic acid (15:0) were also present, and the ratio of saturated:unsaturated fatty acids was about five-fold higher than in the shoot cytosol fractions. Absolute concentrations cannot be obtained by this method. Although the authors present evidence that the exudates were not
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
81
contaminated by non-phloem material and that unsaturated fatty acids were not oxidized to saturated forms during exudation, these results should be verified with stylet exudate data and a range of plant taxa. Plant sterols are chemically distinctive in that they are alkylated with either C1 or C2 substituents at C-24 of the parent molecule. Common plant sterols, including sitosterol (C29), stigmasterol (C29) and campesterol (C28), are phloem-mobile, as revealed by their recovery in the honeydew of phloemfeeding insects reared on plants (Forrest and Knight, 1972; Campbell and Nes, 1983). The impact of environmental conditions and plant developmental age on the concentration and composition of lipids and sterols in phloem sap is not wellknown. O. Biddulph and R. Cory are reported in Ziegler (1975) to have found detectable phloem sterols in young, but not old, leaves of soy bean Glycine max; and Mady et al. (2002) describe substantial increased fatty acid levels in EDTA exudates of B. napus after exposure to UV-irradiation. 2.2.3
Nitrogenous nutrients
The principal nitrogenous compounds in the phloem sap of most plants are free amino acids, with a total concentration between 50 and 800 mM; the concentration of inorganic nitrogenous compounds, ammonium and nitrate, are very low and undetectable, respectively. Many, often all, of the 20 amino acids which contribute to protein are detectable (i.e. at concentration >1 nM), and the dominant amino acids are usually one-to-all of aspartate, glutamate, asparagine and glutamine. The concentration of ‘essential’ amino acids, i.e. amino acids which animals cannot synthesize de novo, is low, accounting for 10–30% of the total protein amino acids. (The essential amino acids are: histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan and valine.) Within these bounds, the total concentration and composition of phloem amino acids are very variable. It is commonplace to obtain three-to-five-fold variation in amino acid concentration among replicate samples of exudates from severed stylets using plants raised under tightly controlled conditions (Girousse et al., 1996; Telang et al., 1999) and variation over the diurnal cycle is also reported (Winter et al., 1992; Corbesier et al., 2001). The composition varies considerably with plant developmental age (Corbesier et al., 2001; Karley et al., 2002), environmental conditions, especially drought stress (Girousse et al., 1996), season (Douglas, 1993; Sandstro¨m, 2000) and between plant species (Ziegler, 1975; Wilkinson and Douglas, 2003). In barley, which has been studied intensively, the total concentration of amino acids in the cytoplasm of leaf mesophyll cells and phloem sap are equivalent, suggesting that amino acid transfer to the sieve elements is passive, even though phloem loading is apoplastic in this species (Winter et al., 1992). However, the composition of amino acids in the two locations is not
82
A. E. DOUGLAS
FIG. 3 A comparison of two indices of leaf nitrogen content in potato plants: total leaf carbon-to-nitrogen ratio (C:N, closed circles) and molar ratio of sucrose to amino acids (sucrose:amino acid, open circles) in leaf phloem exudates. (Reproduced from Fig. 1b of Karley et al. (2002).)
equivalent, indicative of some selectivity in amino acid loading. Synthesis of glutamine from glutamate via glutamine synthetase activity in the companion cell/sieve element complex may additionally contribute to the high glutamine levels in the phloem sap of certain species (Pereira et al., 1992). Linked to the active accumulation of sucrose but not amino acids in the sieve elements of apoplastic loading plant species, the sucrose:amino acid ratio (mol/mol) in phloem sap, at 3:1–20:1 is considerably higher than in the cytoplasm of other plant cells, where the ratio is ca. 1:1. As a result, there is little justification for the widespread use of total plant tissue C:N as an index of the nutritional value of plants for phloem sap-feeding insects. For example, the total leaf C:N and phloem sucrose:amino acid ratio of the potato Solanum tuberosum are not well correlated and vary in different ways with plant developmental age (Fig. 3). Non-protein amino acids, peptides and various other nitrogenous compounds have been reported in plant phloem sap. In particular, the sulphur amino acids methionine and cysteine are transported principally as the nonprotein amino acid S-methylmethionine and the tripeptide glutathione (glutamate–cysteine–glycine), respectively, which together can account for 3.5% of the total phloem amino acids and represent the principal route for phloem transport of sulphur (Rennenberg, 1982; Bourgis et al., 1999). Other nitrogenous compounds, including polyamines and ureides, have been identified in the phloem sap of various plants (Ziegler, 1975), and some limited data are available on the variation in their concentration with environmental conditions and plant developmental age (Antognoni et al., 1998). The phloem proteins encountered by phloem-feeding insects are known as the sieve tube exudate proteins (STEPs), which comprise at least
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
83
150–200 different proteins, mostly of molecular weight 10–40 kDa and at a very low total concentration, 0.1–2 g l1. Exceptionally, the Cucurbitaceae have protein-rich phloem sap at 10–40 g l1. Most STEPs are synthesized in companion cells and translocated into the sieve elements, and they may be cycled back to the companion cells for degradation or transported to sink tissues (Thompson and Schulz, 1999). Hayashi et al. (2000) suggest that phloem proteins have roles in: (a) intermediary metabolism, e.g. all enzymes in glycolysis are detectable in phloem sap, suggesting that sieve elements may contribute to ATP production; (b) redox regulation, as mediated by thioredoxin h, glutaredoxin and glutathione reductase, all of which have been detected in phloem sap; and (c) defence against insect and microbial attack (see Section 2.2.5). In cucurbits (which have high phloem protein concentrations), they may also contribute to the long-distance transport of nitrogen. The sieve elements of many species also bear structural proteins, known as P-proteins, in the parietal cytoplasm. These proteins do not generally occur in the sap stream, although some, which form crystalline or amorphous accumulations (called P-protein bodies) in the cytoplasm, may be in equilibrium with the soluble monomeric form in the STEP fraction. The P-proteins have been implicated in the wound response of sieve elements, especially in legumes. There is some evidence to support the notion that the sieve elements respond to loss of turgor pressure by increased cytoplasmic concentration of Ca2 þ ions (released from the endoplasmic reticulum or taken up from the apoplast), resulting in the dispersal of the cytoplasmic P-proteins and their plugging of the pore plates (Van Bel et al., 2002). This response may be complemented by (and in taxa apparently lacking P-proteins, replaced by) the deposition of callose at the pore plates, but there is some evidence that callose deposition may be an artefact of preparation methods for microscopical analysis (Radford and Overall, 2001). 2.2.4
Inorganic substances
The total concentration of inorganic substances in phloem sap is 1–5 g l1, and the dominant components are potassium, K þ , at 50–150 mM, and phosphate, at 10–50 mM. K þ ions are crucial to the phloem transport of photoassimilates, as indicated by the depressed solute loading and phloem flow, and linked sucrose accumulation in source leaves of K þ -deficient plants (Kochian, 2000). Phosphate and other anions, including bicarbonate and organic acids (e.g. malate), maintain the charge balance and play a large role in determining the pH of the phloem sap, at 7.3–8.0 units (Ziegler, 1975; Marschner et al., 1996; Fisher, 2000). The other principal phloem-mobile inorganic ions are Mg2 þ , at ca. 5 mM, and Cl, at ca. 10 mM (but see below). The concentrations of inorganic nitrogen (as nitrate and ammonium) and sulphur (as sulphate) are low, often undetectable, in phloem sap, and the
84
A. E. DOUGLAS
elements nitrogen and sulphur are transported principally as organic compounds (see Section 2.2.2). The calcium concentration in phloem sap is also low, at 10 M–3 mM, of which 10–30 M is free and the remainder is chelated (Fisher, 2000; Volk and Franceschi, 2000). Phloem sap also contains detectable amounts of the micronutrients, including iron, manganese, zinc, copper and molybdenum. Boron is generally considered to be phloemimmobile, but its phloem mobility is reported to be enhanced by the presence of polyols in the phloem sap (Noiraud et al., 2001). The Na þ :K þ ratio of phloem sap is generally low, at 1:5–1:10 (Fisher, 2000). Plant biologists dispute whether sodium is an essential nutrient for plants, and high sodium levels are undoubtedly toxic to many plant species. Na þ is, however, phloem-mobile and the concentration of Na þ in phloem sap is elevated when plants are grown under saline conditions. For example, when Lohaus et al. (2000) watered maize plants with 0.1 M NaCl, the phloem Na þ concentration was >10 mM, an order of magnitude higher than that in plants watered with distilled water; the high salt treatment increased the phloem Cl concentration ca. three-fold, from 8 to 30 mM, but had little effect on the concentration of sucrose, amino acids and other inorganic ions. 2.2.5
Defences against insects
Plant chemical defences against herbivory principally comprise toxins and compounds which interfere with digestion (e.g. tannins). They are located in the apoplast and cell vacuole, where they have no deleterious effects on plant metabolism, and are excluded from sieve elements, which are a cytoplasmic compartment bounded by the plasma membrane. As a consequence, phloem sap poses fewer toxicological hazards for animals than most other plant tissues. However, the phloem sap of some plant species is not entirely without chemical protection. Analysis of both phloem sap and the tissues and honeydew of feeding aphids offer unambiguous evidence for phloem-mediated transport of various secondary compounds. These include: glucosinolates, found mainly in crucifers and other Capparales (Merritt, 1996; Brudenell et al., 1999; Chen et al., 2001); cardenolides, particularly in the Asclepiadaceae (Botha et al., 1977); alkaloids, e.g. ricinine (Waller and Skursky, 1972), quinolizidines (Wink and Witte, 1991) and pyrrolizidines (Hartmann, 1999), in various plant groups; and the glucoside of hydroxamic acid in wheat (Givovich et al., 1994). The concentration of secondary compounds in the phloem sap varies with developmental age of the plant and, at least for the quinolizidine alkaloids, with time of day (Wink and Witte, 1991). The sieve elements of all plants are well-defended against mechanical damage. When a sieve element is damaged, the sieve pores are plugged, preventing any further phloem flow through the affected sieve tube. The plugging material may include phloem P-proteins, sieve element plastids (which
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
85
‘explode’ on wounding) and callose, but the relative importance of these different components is disputed and may vary between plant species. Calcium may be a crucial signal in the sieve element wounding response, when the free Ca2 þ concentration is probably transiently elevated (by release from stores in the endoplasmic reticulum of the sieve elements or uptake from the apoplast), resulting in sealing of plasmodesmata and sieve plates (Van Bel et al., 2002). When aphids imbibe phloem sap from susceptible plants, the structural organization of the sieve elements is not usually altered detectably, at either the light- or electron-microscopical levels, suggesting that feeding may depend on circumventing or suppressing the sieve plate sealing response. Consistent with this interpretation, sieve element sealing has been implicated as a possible resistance factor in certain plant/aphid combinations (Van Helden and Tjallingii, 1993; Caillaud and Niemeyer, 1996). 2.3
APHID-INDUCED CHANGES TO PHLOEM SAP
Insects feeding on phloem sap are hydraulically equivalent to plant sinks, such as fruits or roots. There is, however, evidence that the relationship between an aphid and a susceptible plant is more complex than the relationship between the source tissues and sink tissues of a plant. Various studies indicate, first, that aphid feeding induces specific plant responses and, second, that these responses can include changes in phloem sap that are advantageous to the insect. Aphid feeding induces changes in the patterns of plant transcription and protein synthesis that overlap with inducible plant responses to microbial pathogens and are distinct from plant responses to mechanical wounding as evoked by chewing insects (Walling, 2000; Gatehouse, 2002). For example, Arabidopsis thaliana plants infested with the green peach aphid Myzus persicae display a strong response in the salicylic acid-pathway, including an order of magnitude increase in the levels of the pathogenesis-related gene PR-1 and the -1,3,-glucanase gene BGL2 (Moran and Thompson, 2001). These responses are traditionally considered as defensive. However, they are largely localized to the plant apoplast, not the contents of the sieve elements, and they do not translate into resistance to the aphid. Indeed, some aphid-induced changes in the plant tissues may promote phloem suitability for the insect. For example, Moran and Thompson (2001) suggest, first, that the elevated activity of glucanase (the product of BGL2) near phloem sieve elements may counteract callose deposition, a putative sieve element wound response (see Section 2.2.5) and, second, that the increased transcription of the gene STP4, coding a sugar-H þ transporter, may promote the insect-sink. The possibility that aphids may modify the nutrient composition of plant phloem sap has been discussed extensively in the literature (Klingauf, 1987; Dixon, 1998). If an aphid induced changes in the sieve element from which it
86
A. E. DOUGLAS
was feeding, one would anticipate systematic differences between the composition of phloem exudates from severed aphid stylets and from EDTA exudates, which sample all the sieve elements of the plant tissue being tested. No such differences have been identified (Weibull et al., 1990), suggesting that, contrary to suggestions in the literature, aphids generally do not manipulate phloem sap composition at the level of the single sieve element. Exceptionally, aphids which induce chlorotic lesions or galls on their food plants may modify plant sap composition. Considering aphid-induced chlorosis first, Sandstro¨m et al. (2000) compared the amino acid profiles of exudates from severed stylets of three aphid species feeding on wheat: Rhopalosiphum padi, which causes no visible macroscopic changes to the plant, and S. graminum and Diuraphis noxia, which cause leaf necrosis and chlorosis. Both the total concentration and the composition of phloem amino acids varied significantly among the three species, with elevated concentrations of amino acids, especially essential amino acids, in the exudates from S. graminum and D. noxia stylets, relative to R. padi (Fig. 4). Further experiments revealed that the amino acid composition of EDTA exudates from leaves uninfested with aphids were closely similar to those of leaves bearing R. padi and different from those with S. graminum (Sandstro¨m et al., 2000), and that D. noxia reared on a resistant cultivar of wheat induces neither lesions nor a change in phloem composition (Telang et al., 1999). Several conclusions can be drawn: that feeding by S. graminum and D. noxia enhances the nutritional quality of wheat phloem sap; that aphidinduced changes in phloem sap are systemic, at least to the level of the infested
FIG. 4 Amino acid content of phloem sap exudates from severed stylets of aphids feeding from wheat seedlings (closed bar, essential amino acids; open bar, non-essential amino acids): the mean % essential amino acids in exudates from Rhopalosiphum padi is 29%, Diuraphis noxia is 33% and Schizaphis graminum is 42% (essential amino acids are defined as the nine amino acids that cannot be synthesized de novo by animals). (Figure drawn from data in Sandstro¨m et al. (2000).)
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
87
leaf; and that these changes are correlated with aphid-mediated induction of lesions. The impact of lesion-inducing aphids on plant phloem sap bears parallels to the indirect interactions between plant pathogenic fungi and aphids. In particular, improved leaf nutritional quality, arising from leaf chlorosis and premature leaf senescence induced by fungal infection, has been shown to result in improved performance of the alder aphid Pterocallis alni on leaves of alder Alnus pubescens (Gange, 1995) and of the birch aphid Euceraphis betulae on leaves of birch Betula pendula (Johnson et al., 2003). The phloem sap of senescencing leaves is enriched in amino acids derived from hydrolysis of leaf proteins prior to abscission. However, aphids are believed to induce chlorotic lesions by salivary toxins or enzymes (Miles, 1999) and the extent to which the processes underlying the resultant induced shifts in phloem composition match those underlying fungal-promoted or ‘natural’ senescence remains to be established. Various aphids induce plant galls. It is widely accepted that the phloem sap is nutritionally superior in galled tissue than ungalled tissue (Forrest, 1987; Dixon, 1998), although this difference has not been quantified directly. The underlying plant physiological processes are also obscure and probably different from chlorosis-linked shifts in plant sap composition because galls are persistent structures and not subject to premature senescence.
3 3.1
Acquisition of phloem sap by aphids INGESTION OF PHLOEM SAP
As in other hemipteran insects, the mandibles and maxillae of aphids are transformed into needle-like stylets, the mandibular stylets surrounding the inner maxillary stylets. Two canals, a salivary canal (0.2–0.4 m diameter) and larger food canal (1–2 m diameter), lie between the tightly apposed maxillary stylets; and each mandibular stylet contains one canal bearing two nerve axons (Fig. 5a). When the insect is not feeding, the stylets are enclosed within the labium (also known as the rostrum or proboscis). Aphids lack maxillary and labial palps, and chemoreception is mediated by sensilla in two locations: at the tip of the labium and in the epipharyngeal gustatory organ (Fig. 5b). Plant phloem sap in the sieve tubes is under positive pressure (see Section 2.1), sufficient for it to be forced up the food canal of the stylets into the pharyngeal duct of the aphid. The empirical evidence for passive ingestion is that phloem sap continues to exude from severed stylets at a rate comparable to the rate of honeydew production by the feeding insect (Auclair, 1963). However, the insect does have some control over the rate of phloem sap ingestion (Ponsen 1987). The food passes into the alimentary tract only if the pharyngeal valve, which lies just distal to the epipharyngeal gustatory organ, is
88
A. E. DOUGLAS
FIG. 5 The mouthparts and foregut of an aphid. (a) Diagrammatic transverse section through the stylets; (b) longitudinal section through head to show cibarial pump and head musculature (shaded), with the detail of the pharyngeal valve (abbreviated to ‘valve’ on figure) displayed as the inset: the salivary canal of the stylets and the salivary glands are not shown for clarity. (Redrawn from Fig. 2.3 and Fig. 2.7 of Dixon (1998).)
open, a condition that requires the contraction of dilator muscles in the aphid head. An aphid can, presumably, halt ingestion very rapidly in response to noxious or deterrent compounds detected by the epipharyngeal gustatory organ. Distal to the pharyngeal valve is the cibarial pump (also known as the pharyngeal pump), which, as the name suggests, has the opposite capability: it can ‘suck’. The dorsal wall of the cibarial pump is flexible and, when dilator muscles attached to the dorsal wall contract, the volume of the pump is
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
89
increased, drawing fluid in. When the muscles relax, the liquid in the pump is either forced distally down the alimentary tract (when the pharyngeal valve is closed) or ejected back down the stylets (when the pharyngeal valve is open). An indication of the capability of the cibarial pump comes from the capacity of aphids to suck liquid from artificial diets at atmospheric pressure for days-to-weeks and from plant xylem vessels at pressure of 0.02–0.2 MPa for at least several hours (Spiller et al., 1985). For most animals, the amount of food ingested is determined by the duration of feeding bouts and the ingestion rate during each feeding bout. On susceptible plants, aphids often feed continuously from single sieve elements for extended periods. The evidence comes principally from two complementary sources. The first is ‘honeydew clock’ experiments, where each honeydew droplet is collected on paper on a slowly moving rotating table placed below a feeding insect; aphids produce honeydew droplets of uniform size at regular intervals of once per 15–40 min, varying with aphid and plant species. The second is electrical monitoring of aphid feeding, in which an aphid is part of an electric circuit and the position of its stylet tips and stylet activity can be determined from the associated changes in resistance, recorded as changes in potential on an electrical penetration graph (EPG) (Tjallingii, 1995). EPG traces of aphids feeding from susceptible plants generally include many uninterrupted hours of the wave pattern associated with ingestion of phloem sap from sieve elements. These data have led to the consensus view that aphids do not have well-defined feeding bouts, dictated by temporal changes in appetite and satiation (Tjallingii, 1995); but for a different perspective, see Montllor (1991). Aphid feeding rates increase with body size, both over larval development (Febvay et al., 1999) and among aphid species (Dixon, 1998). Generally, aphids feed faster on the phloem sap of susceptible plants than on artificial diets. Peel (1975) estimated that severed stylets may exude ca. 1 l of phloem sap h1, which is equivalent to emptying 235 sieve elements per minute, and Pollard (1973) calculated that M. persicae ingests 10% of its body weight h1. Aphid feeding rates also vary with the nutrient content of the ingested food. Early studies with diet-reared aphids demonstrated that sustained feeding depended on the presence of sucrose at concentrations >0.1 M in the diet and was promoted by at least one amino acid, methionine. Sucrose and methionine are, therefore, widely regarded as phagostimulants. In addition, aphids exhibit compensatory feeding responses, i.e. elevated feeding rates on dilute diets, resulting in increased nutrient uptake. Compensatory feeding on diets containing low sucrose concentrations has been described for both M. persicae and A. pisum (Mittler and Meikle, 1991; Abisgold et al., 1994). In A. pisum, increased feeding rates only partly compensates for low dietary concentrations, such that the total amount of sucrose ingested declines with decreasing sucrose concentration (Fig. 6). Aphids also display compensatory feeding response to dietary amino acid levels at concentrations in the range 75–250 mM, but not at higher concentrations (Prosser et al., 1992; Abisgold
90
A. E. DOUGLAS
FIG. 6 Feeding response of pea aphids Acyrthosiphon pisum to variation in concentration of dietary sucrose. Eight replicate final-instar apterous larvae were caged individually for 48 h to diets containing 0.2–1.0 M sucrose. (a) Volume of diet ingested. (b) Amount of sucrose ingested (circle) and recovered from aphid tissues (square) and honeydew (triangle). (Previously unpublished data of W.A. Smith and A.E. Douglas; methodology as in Ashford et al. (2000).)
et al., 1994), and their feeding responses to other dietary constituents, notably inorganic ions, have not been investigated. 3.2
STYLET PENETRATION TO THE SIEVE ELEMENTS
Stylet penetration to the sieve elements is predominantly intercellular. The stylets pass directly through the plant cell walls, a route that is known as the intramural pathway, and not along the middle lamella between the walls of adjacent cells. From the time when the aphid stylets penetrate the plant surface, it takes between 20 min and more than an hour for them to reach a sieve element and the aphid to initiate feeding; this period of stylet penetration through the plant tissues is commonly called ‘the pathway phase’. Complementary microscopical analysis and EPG studies indicate that the stylets puncture plant cells briefly (usually for <10 s) during the pathway phase (Tjallingii, 1995). The significance of these penetrations into the cytoplasm of plant cells is uncertain. Perhaps, they reflect the difficulties in maintaining the
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
91
intramural pathway (i.e. the aphid stylets are ‘clumsy’), and perhaps they provide the opportunity for aphids to sample cell contents, as a check on the suitability of the plant or in search for a sieve element. Consistent with the latter perspective, plant cytoplasmic contents are imbibed during the brief puncture, at a rate of ca. 0.1 pl s1 (Martin et al., 1997). The punctures do not cause damage to the plant cell evident at the microscopical level, but they may trigger plant changes, for example in gene expression or at the biochemical level (see Section 2.3). The factors determining the direction of stylet progression through the plant tissue are not understood. Microscopical analyses indicate that the stylet pathway is irregular, often with multiple changes in direction, and does not take the shortest route to the plant vascular tissue (Tjallingii and Esch, 1993). These data suggest that the plant sieve elements are located by trial-and-error. Furthermore, an aphid does not necessarily initiate sustained feeding from the first sieve element penetrated. This raises two linked questions: do sieve elements in one plant vary in their suitability for aphids, and what cues does an aphid use to initiate sustained feeding from a sieve element? Perhaps, stylet movement is arrested principally by the high osmotic pressure and sugar concentration in sieve elements. Other phloem constituents may also influence sieve element suitability. For example the possible significance of phloem amino acid levels is suggested by the finding of Ponder et al. (2000) that the stylets of R. padi feeding on barley penetrate to the sieve elements more times for every incidence of sustained feeding on nitrogen-deficient plants, with 110 14 mM phloem amino acids, than on nitrogen-sufficient plants, with 180 23 mM phloem amino acids. Aphid saliva is central to the progression of aphid stylets through plant tissues to the sieve elements, and initiation of sustained feeding, and this issue is considered in the next section. 3.3
APHID SALIVA
The production and composition of saliva has been studied over many years in aphids, and Miles (1999) provides a comprehensive review. Aphid saliva is produced in paired salivary glands and secreted via the salivary canal. (As considered in Section 3.1 and Fig. 5a, the salivary canal is one of two canals between the tightly apposed maxillary stylets; the other canal is the food canal, along which the liquid food is passed in the opposite direction.) The food canal, but not the salivary canal, extends to the distal tips of the maxillary stylets and, therefore, saliva is predicted to exit the stylets into the plant tissues only when food is not being ingested (Prado and Tjallingii, 1994). Two types of aphid saliva are recognized: the gelling saliva produced as the stylets penetrate through plant tissues but not once the stylet tip accesses a sieve element, and the watery saliva produced during both penetration and the sieve element phase. The gelling saliva is a lipoprotein of unknown
92
A. E. DOUGLAS
biochemical composition, which solidifies on extrusion from the stylets, principally because sulphydryl groups are oxidized to form disulphide bonds that promote hydrogen bonding. The watery saliva, which has pH 8–9, contains free amino acids, various proteins, and reducing activity of unknown chemical basis. The gelling saliva is crucial to stylet penetration through the plant tissues. It forms a continuous tube, or sheath, around the stylets as they extend through the plant tissues, and it may both support the stylets mechanically and protect them from plant defence responses. When the aphid retracts its stylets from a plant, the stylet sheath remains undisturbed in the plant tissue, leaving a track of the movement of stylets through the plant tissue. The watery saliva contains various enzymes, including polyphenol oxidase ( ¼ catechol oxidase) which may detoxify phloem-mobile allelochemicals, and pectinesterase, polygalacturonase and cellulase which have been suggested to promote stylet penetration through plant cell walls and to degrade plant oligosaccharides produced by aphid wounding to inert monomers (Miles, 1999). It is, however, widely accepted that aphid stylet penetration has a predominantly mechanical basis, with little or no contribution from enzymatic degradation of the plant cell wall material. The watery saliva has also been suggested to ‘condition’ the sieve elements, perhaps linked to preventing plant processes that halt phloem flow in damaged sieve elements (e.g. callose formation, P-protein precipitation). The basis of this putative conditioning is chemically undefined and it is believed to occur in the first 30 seconds-to-few minutes after sieve element puncture by the stylets, when the aphids are salivating but not ingesting phloem sap (represented by E1 waveform in EPG analyses). Consistent with a possible role of salivation in phloem conditioning, some aphids feeding from plants on which they perform relatively poorly salivate into the sieve element for extended periods (>5 min) before initiating sustained feeding, and also make multiple transitions between phloem ingestion and salivation during the subsequent hours when the stylets are tapped into the sieve element (Van Helden and Tjallingii, 1993). Aphid-mediated ‘conditioning’ of plants is considered further in Section 7.1.1. There are several early reports of -glucosidase and -fructosidase activities in aphid saliva (reviewed in Srivastava, 1987). In principle, such enzymes could initiate digestion of phloem sugars before the sap reaches the gut. However, the purity of the saliva extracts and specificity of the enzymatic assays in these studies are uncertain (Miles, 1999), and further research is required to validate the results and demonstrate their quantitative importance.
4
Processing of food in the aphid alimentary tract
Feeding aphids ingest a continuous stream of phloem sap, a liquid food of high osmotic pressure comprising nutrients of low molecular weight and of
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
93
unbalanced composition (e.g. high sucrose:amino acid ratio and high ratios of K þ :Na þ and Mg2 þ :Ca2 þ ). This diet generates three predictions about the function of the aphid alimentary tract: (1) It mediates the efficient assimilation of limiting organic nutrients and inorganic ions, such as amino acids and Ca2 þ ions; (2) it has a restricted digestive capacity, largely related to the hydrolysis of di- and oligo-saccharides to monosaccharide sugars; and (3) it contributes to the maintenance of osmotic balance and regulation of the water content of the insect. Our understanding of all three issues is only fragmentary, however, because physiological analysis of the aphid alimentary tract is technically challenging. The gut is small and delicate, largely precluding physiological studies of isolated gut preparations, and limiting the material available for purification and biochemical analysis of gut enzymes. Most research on gut function has, to date, been conducted on intact insects, which are amenable to two approaches: quantification of assimilation efficiency and analysis of chemical transformations in ingested food in the gut. These methodologies are considered further in Section 4.1, followed by a review of our current understanding of the structural organization of the aphid alimentary tract (Section 4.2), the processing of sugars and nitrogenous compounds (Section 4.3 and Section 4.4) and the fate of ingested allelochemicals (Section 4.5). The gut-mediated processing of ingested sugars is linked to osmoregulation, and these two topics are therefore addressed together (see Section 4.3). The translocation of inorganic ions across the gut epithelium and the significance of the gut, especially the rectum, in ionic regulation have not been studied in aphids. 4.1 4.1.1
APPROACHES TO STUDY FOOD PROCESSING
Assimilation efficiency
The assimilation efficiency of a nutrient refers to the proportion of an ingested nutrient that is assimilated across the gut wall into the insect tissues. The amount ingested per unit time is determined from the product of feeding rate and dietary concentration of the nutrient, and the amount assimilated is the difference between the amount ingested and recovered in the egesta (i.e. in the honeydew released from the aphid). The assimilation efficiency of aphids reared on chemically defined diets can be determined readily because the dietary concentration is known and feeding rate can be obtained from the quantitative recovery in the honeydew of a non-metabolizable compound included in the diet at a defined concentration (radioactively labelled inulin is widely used as the non-metabolizable compound (Wright et al., 1985)). The values of assimilation efficiency obtained for diet-reared aphids should be extrapolated to aphids on their natural food of plant phloem sap with the greatest caution. Aphid feeding rate is generally lower on diets than on plants,
94
A. E. DOUGLAS
and it has been suggested that the assimilation of nutrients from phloem sap may be limited by its short transit time in the gut (Dixon, 1998). This issue has not, to my knowledge, been investigated experimentally. It is technically demanding to obtain accurate values of aphid feeding rates on plants and nutrient concentrations of phloem sap in the sieve tubes from which an aphid is feeding, and few studies have included estimates of the assimilation efficiency of aphids feeding from plants. More generally, the limitations of assimilation efficiency as an index of the food processing capability of an animal have been identified (Raubenheimer and Simpson, 1994). In particular, because this index is a proportion, it can provide an incomplete and potentially misleading measure of the amount of a nutrient available to insect tissues. Information on the absolute rates of nutrient assimilation, as well as the assimilation efficiency, is increasingly being provided in nutritional physiology studies of insects, including aphids. 4.1.2
Chemical transformations of ingested food in the gut
Aphids reared on chemically defined diets have also been a vital tool in the analysis of digestion and other gut-mediated chemical changes to ingested compounds. A productive approach is to compare the composition of honeydew produced by aphids feeding on diets containing the compound(s) of interest at different concentrations. The dietary compound(s) may be labelled, for example with radioactivity, to define more precisely the details of the chemical changes. The chief caveat with this whole-organism approach is that the site of chemical transformation is not defined. Aphid honeydew is not simply the residue of the ingesta after digestion and assimilation in the gut, but also contains waste products of aphid metabolism voided via the gut. For example, aphids excrete ammonia in the honeydew and, when reared on diets with individual amino acids deletions, their honeydew commonly contains the amino acid absent from the diet, varying among both amino acids and aphid species (Douglas and Prosser, 1992). One approach to investigate whether the chemical transformation is gut-mediated is to conduct parallel experiments with dissected guts in insect saline (Douglas, 1990) or with crude homogenates of guts (Ashford et al., 2000). Such experiments, however, need careful interpretation because the isolation procedure may destroy the structural organization of the alimentary tract or result in the degradation of key enzymes. 4.2
STRUCTURAL ORGANIZATION OF THE ALIMENTARY TRACT
The alimentary tract of aphids is simple anatomically (Fig. 7). Formally, the ‘mouth’ of the aphid is at the junction of the cibarial pump and the oesophagus, which is a thin-walled tube opening, via the oesophageal valve,
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
95
FIG. 7 The alimentary tract of the green peach aphid Myzus persicae. (a) anatomical features; (b) organization in intact animal. (Redrawn from Fig. 5 of Ponsen (1979) and Fig. 2.1.6F of Ponsen (1987).)
into the midgut (this valve prevents the back flow of food from the midgut when the pharyngeal pump dilates (see Section 3.1)). The midgut comprises a proximal ‘stomach’, which is dilated or tubular, and a distal ‘intestine’, and it lacks any caeca or other diverticula. The transition from midgut to proximal hindgut is not marked by Malpighian tubules, which are absent from aphids, or any other anatomical feature. The distal portion of the hindgut is the rectum, a thin-walled, distensible sac in which egesta accumulate prior to expulsion as a single drop of honeydew, every 15–45 min. The aphid gut is 2–4 times longer than the body, varying between aphid species. The intestine (i.e. distal midgut) contributes much of the length of the aphid gut and it is looped several times within the body cavity. The oesophagus and hindgut include no loops or coils. In many aphids, including most members of the Aphidinae, the stomach is closely apposed to more distal regions of the gut. In some aphids, notably members of the subfamilies Callaphidinae, Lachninae and Drepanosiphinae, this anatomical association is elaborated, such that a portion of the midgut is encircled by a more distal region of the alimentary tract, an arrangement described as a filter system.
96
A. E. DOUGLAS
(Contrary to early suggestions in the literature, the proximal region is not completely enclosed within the distal region, and the two regions are separated by a narrow haemolymph-filled space (Ponsen, 1981).) For example, in Eulachnus brevipilosis and other lachnines, the most proximal region of the midgut is enclosed within the proximal hindgut; and the callaphidine Subsaltusaphis ornata has two filter systems, a first in which the stomach is encircled by the proximal hindgut and a second involving very close apposition between the proximal and distal intestine (Ponsen, 1979, 1981). The close apposition between proximal and distal regions of the alimentary tract and particularly the filter systems in certain species is reasonably interpreted as facilitating the transfer of compounds between different regions of the gut, as is discussed in Section 4.3.3. The gut wall in aphids comprises a single layer of epithelial cells bounded externally by the basal lamina and musculature. The latter is limited to scattered circular muscle cells for the foregut and midgut, and a well-developed circular muscle plus scattered longitudinal muscle fibres for the hindgut (Ponsen, 1987). The poorly developed gut musculature is consistent with the food being forced through the gut principally by proximal pressure exerted by the plant sieve elements or aphid cibarial pump, with the possible assistance of peristaltic movements of the hindgut. The gut epithelial cells are separated from the gut lumen by a chitinous cuticle for the foregut and hindgut, as in other insects. At each moult of the insect, the cuticle is shed; the oesophageal cuticle is passed back into the stomach, where it remains through the life of the insect. The midgut of aphids and other hemipteran insects lacks a peritrophic matrix and the apical surface of the midgut cells is bounded by a continuous sheet of lipoprotein that Terra (1990) call the perimicrovillar membrane. The perimicrovillar membrane of aphids has not been studied in detail, but is probably similar in origin and general organization to that in other hemipteran insects, e.g. Silva et al. (1995). The structure of the epithelial cells of the aphid midgut has been investigated in detail, especially by M.B. Ponsen (reviewed in Ponsen, 1987). Consistent with the role of the midgut as the site of enzyme production and nutrient assimilation, the apical cell membrane of midgut cells is elaborated into microvilli or, especially in the stomach, more complex structures that Ponsen terms ‘microlabyrinths’. The basolateral membranes of many cells are also highly folded, indicative of a role in transport. The early literature (summarized in Ponsen, 1987) concluded that digestive enzymes are secreted into the aphid gut lumen by apocrine secretion, i.e. the shedding of portions of cytoplasm by cellular constriction or budding. Profiles of cells with the predicted apical extensions are evident in the stomach of sectioned aphids prepared by traditional histological methods. However, the contribution of fixation artefacts to these observations cannot be excluded definitively (Brunings and DePriester, 1971) and the significance of apocrine secretion to aphid gut function deserves re-examination with modern microscopical techniques.
THE NUTRITIONAL PHYSIOLOGY OF APHIDS
97
Recent studies implicate the perimicrovillar membrane as an important site of enzyme activity, as is considered in detail for sucrase in Section 4.3.1.
4.3
PROCESSING OF